id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13228v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13228v2 | Smaug: Fixing Failure Modes of Preference Optimisation with DPO-Positive | 2024-02-20T18:42:34 | 2024-07-03T13:46:33 | Arka Pal, Deep Karkhanis, Samuel Dooley, Manley Roberts, Siddartha Naidu, Colin White | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Direct Preference Optimisation (DPO) is effective at significantly improving
the performance of large language models (LLMs) on downstream tasks such as
reasoning, summarisation, and alignment. Using pairs of preferred and
dispreferred data, DPO models the relative probability of picking one response
over another. In this work, first we show theoretically that the standard DPO
loss can lead to a reduction of the model's likelihood of the preferred
examples, as long as the relative probability between the preferred and
dispreferred classes increases. We then show empirically that this phenomenon
occurs when fine-tuning LLMs on common datasets, especially datasets in which
the edit distance between pairs of completions is low. Using these insights, we
design DPO-Positive (DPOP), a new loss function and training procedure which
avoids this failure mode. Surprisingly, we find that DPOP outperforms DPO and
other fine-tuning procedures across a wide variety of datasets and downstream
tasks, including datasets with high edit distances between completions.
Furthermore, we find that the DPOP-tuned model outperforms the DPO-tuned model
(all else equal) on benchmarks independent of the fine-tuning data, such as
MT-Bench. Finally, using DPOP, we create and open-source Smaug-34B and
Smaug-72B, with the latter becoming the first open-source LLM to surpass an
average accuracy of 80% on the HuggingFace Open LLM Leaderboard. | [
-0.49764472246170044,
-0.5629137754440308,
0.671865701675415,
0.1389869600534439,
-0.2961953580379486,
-0.06201571598649025,
-0.2521008551120758,
-0.08954263478517532,
-0.030897626653313637,
0.5472803711891174,
-0.6841371655464172,
-0.18088088929653168,
-0.7184652090072632,
0.25820937752723694,
-0.16629722714424133,
0.7560316324234009,
-0.1071561947464943,
-0.13514330983161926,
-0.3769805431365967,
-0.07299967855215073,
-0.3765854835510254,
-0.6052250266075134,
-0.6703429818153381,
-0.32792505621910095,
0.45351290702819824,
0.73061203956604,
0.8403944373130798,
0.6737456917762756,
0.6192352771759033,
0.25089263916015625,
-0.20712603628635406,
0.48669949173927307,
-0.7266308069229126,
0.03640641272068024,
0.1048189178109169,
-0.7666435837745667,
-0.7770134806632996,
0.23515070974826813,
0.5635167956352234,
0.69194495677948,
-0.20292575657367706,
-0.12557198107242584,
0.2695964276790619,
1.280187964439392,
-0.4098326563835144,
0.07290499657392502,
-0.9383751153945923,
0.04736271873116493,
-0.26840949058532715,
-0.3732371926307678,
-0.4568493664264679,
-0.3789176642894745,
0.0567544586956501,
-0.4076898396015167,
-0.007569284178316593,
0.10818998515605927,
0.6552191376686096,
0.636079728603363,
-0.4258083403110504,
-0.18892259895801544,
-0.6774905323982239,
0.9288842678070068,
-0.7739161849021912,
0.3636390268802643,
0.42031222581863403,
0.018322737887501717,
-0.5413972735404968,
0.041900984942913055,
-0.5051100850105286,
-0.30514317750930786,
-0.01001704391092062,
0.04030901566147804,
0.04662095010280609,
0.2585570514202118,
0.20838388800621033,
0.7871752977371216,
-0.22861537337303162,
0.10381998866796494,
-0.0780281350016594,
-0.07225832343101501,
0.6223955154418945,
-0.00009702220995677635,
-0.09415831416845322,
-0.2473168969154358,
-0.2315787523984909,
0.1238468736410141,
-0.8922834396362305,
-0.07293586432933807,
0.6027432680130005,
0.3901870548725128,
0.2184700220823288,
0.4892730116844177,
-0.2510121166706085,
0.9443008303642273,
0.6199360489845276,
-0.4366694986820221,
0.3662886917591095,
0.010897315107285976,
-0.22535696625709534,
0.01984524354338646,
0.5747119784355164,
0.5274796485900879,
0.32013094425201416,
0.05670751631259918,
-0.15345922112464905,
0.024568138644099236,
0.05615744739770889,
-0.40970465540885925,
-0.15484704077243805,
0.4210059344768524,
-0.38918352127075195,
-0.6064732670783997,
-0.25515061616897583,
-0.23506218194961548,
-0.3765900433063507,
-0.5595858693122864,
0.3939230740070343,
-0.4288902282714844,
-0.2722485363483429,
0.40620389580726624,
0.08590181171894073,
0.018854860216379166,
0.29245442152023315,
-0.9490340352058411,
0.17495693266391754,
0.788322925567627,
0.9488816857337952,
-0.3265922963619232,
-0.28206056356430054,
-0.878399670124054,
0.019273294135928154,
-0.38969185948371887,
0.6969881057739258,
-0.24391092360019684,
-0.47437718510627747,
-0.25823912024497986,
-0.03193579986691475,
-0.21056073904037476,
-0.7242276072502136,
0.7818969488143921,
-0.20964756608009338,
0.18553732335567474,
-0.46910420060157776,
-0.734775185585022,
-0.12808062136173248,
0.2407764047384262,
-0.5693272352218628,
0.9445607662200928,
0.11991723626852036,
-0.8878360390663147,
0.5713182091712952,
-0.5004503130912781,
-0.4264107942581177,
-0.2185170203447342,
0.007486001122742891,
-0.5901858806610107,
0.33823782205581665,
-0.04493510350584984,
0.582589328289032,
-0.018304284662008286,
0.24938327074050903,
-0.7955273985862732,
-0.47944286465644836,
0.014592784456908703,
-0.1393633484840393,
0.8116663098335266,
-0.08611072599887848,
-0.2643646001815796,
0.16634587943553925,
-0.7535416483879089,
-0.3261084258556366,
0.12337864190340042,
-0.2414817065000534,
-0.557557225227356,
0.2973615527153015,
-0.37201258540153503,
0.39499199390411377,
0.10940491408109665,
-0.612738311290741,
0.453358918428421,
-0.3689751923084259,
0.5590747594833374,
1.0641816854476929,
-0.2514186501502991,
0.40890949964523315,
-0.47874826192855835,
0.33288171887397766,
0.04556921869516373,
0.4031723439693451,
0.2615005671977997,
-0.33678197860717773,
-0.8175612092018127,
-0.22474582493305206,
0.21067601442337036,
0.6398234963417053,
-0.5404502153396606,
0.5159859657287598,
0.08877973258495331,
-0.26905274391174316,
-0.5510738492012024,
0.38689371943473816,
-0.001156550133600831,
1.029043197631836,
0.009668941609561443,
-0.175588920712471,
-0.44676101207733154,
-0.9607925415039062,
0.10106360167264938,
-0.3115733861923218,
0.12156963348388672,
0.5504726767539978,
-0.0285831019282341,
-0.38131025433540344,
0.6962226629257202,
-0.646710991859436,
-0.3671265244483948,
-0.23528988659381866,
-0.3203170895576477,
0.3368864953517914,
0.18559888005256653,
0.823413074016571,
-0.795887291431427,
-0.598343551158905,
-0.12379195541143417,
-0.30343854427337646,
-0.18020844459533691,
0.19381743669509888,
-0.2166859656572342,
0.44636762142181396,
0.11989068239927292,
-0.4642895460128784,
0.07978855818510056,
0.7111341953277588,
-0.2315954715013504,
0.6526245474815369,
-0.17596599459648132,
0.45600923895835876,
-0.8791790008544922,
-0.10262919217348099,
0.03907378017902374,
-0.3655068576335907,
-0.4522649049758911,
-0.27206066250801086,
0.07276908308267593,
0.01281480211764574,
-0.5300900340080261,
0.31672757863998413,
-0.02439836598932743,
0.17055641114711761,
-0.32314375042915344,
0.11591529101133347,
-0.24188198149204254,
0.35168692469596863,
-0.032001230865716934,
0.6882075071334839,
0.6692538261413574,
-0.7173553109169006,
0.2515508830547333,
0.4078267812728882,
0.005931163672357798,
0.6022062301635742,
-0.541921854019165,
0.1094873696565628,
-0.2054031938314438,
0.08661153167486191,
-1.1142466068267822,
-0.3204730749130249,
0.20806652307510376,
-0.10977303981781006,
0.3971279561519623,
-0.3684716522693634,
-0.47078680992126465,
-0.44899576902389526,
-0.4788729250431061,
0.09854183346033096,
0.4366001486778259,
-0.6171395778656006,
0.18638628721237183,
0.4252353608608246,
-0.2553492784500122,
-0.5182448625564575,
-0.4315350353717804,
-0.11248888075351715,
-0.4881576895713806,
-0.785773754119873,
0.37251174449920654,
-0.4102516174316406,
-0.21277815103530884,
-0.3505196273326874,
-0.28672319650650024,
0.07077307254076004,
0.2905329465866089,
0.2675342559814453,
0.38840577006340027,
0.12463343888521194,
0.08803495019674301,
0.10929133743047714,
-0.323225736618042,
-0.27848416566848755,
0.05739022046327591,
0.4489949941635132,
-0.354189932346344,
-0.20053578913211823,
-0.24196746945381165,
0.2855313718318939,
0.7313408255577087,
-0.08382966369390488,
0.6735714673995972,
0.26924020051956177,
-0.18772786855697632,
-0.23402181267738342,
-0.48283177614212036,
-0.17840063571929932,
-0.541282594203949,
0.044211823493242264,
-0.43594369292259216,
-0.955365002155304,
0.275134801864624,
0.036927804350852966,
0.1995539665222168,
0.44603124260902405,
0.30559465289115906,
-0.17495055496692657,
1.123326301574707,
0.9809073805809021,
-0.23109617829322815,
0.5537092089653015,
-0.0016372805694118142,
0.17233824729919434,
-0.5790203809738159,
0.23212990164756775,
-0.31216537952423096,
-0.23163394629955292,
-0.6643531322479248,
-0.07258295267820358,
0.425680547952652,
0.3131033480167389,
0.006248404737561941,
0.2115841656923294,
-0.42739835381507874,
0.32937929034233093,
0.608755350112915,
0.16414113342761993,
0.5252861976623535,
-0.0012471399968490005,
0.007274609059095383,
-0.16091477870941162,
-0.781331479549408,
-0.46138784289360046,
1.1148393154144287,
0.33419883251190186,
0.7281992435455322,
-0.10534718632698059,
1.0013035535812378,
0.24153847992420197,
0.2488798350095749,
-1.0139358043670654,
0.4619201719760895,
-0.5813401937484741,
-0.3550373613834381,
-0.17335140705108643,
-0.564809262752533,
-0.560935378074646,
-0.07082145661115646,
-0.04404949024319649,
-0.33178311586380005,
0.17252953350543976,
0.7627884149551392,
-0.3965907394886017,
0.32394060492515564,
-0.7453529238700867,
0.8219015598297119,
-0.32495221495628357,
-0.34343910217285156,
-0.20238752663135529,
-0.32162463665008545,
0.54026198387146,
-0.020011821761727333,
0.03884616866707802,
-0.3554002344608307,
0.05958975851535797,
0.4435572326183319,
-0.20529967546463013,
0.4492432773113251,
-0.13490571081638336,
-0.2085808962583542,
0.14504481852054596,
0.1774231642484665,
0.3322400152683258,
0.09848077595233917,
-0.42883291840553284,
0.14101548492908478,
-0.02099805325269699,
-0.39395514130592346,
-0.44361528754234314,
0.9802646636962891,
-0.6357327699661255,
-0.6479358077049255,
-0.42380276322364807,
-0.29964742064476013,
-0.46508246660232544,
0.16612133383750916,
0.1279856115579605,
0.5346404314041138,
0.2135951966047287,
0.19372375309467316,
0.7887709140777588,
-0.008564679883420467,
0.264386922121048,
0.5855323672294617,
-0.09278666228055954,
-0.3739560544490814,
0.7740499973297119,
0.0644025057554245,
0.49839478731155396,
0.1676269918680191,
0.3305617570877075,
-0.30490556359291077,
-0.6449093222618103,
-0.45281004905700684,
0.3665607273578644,
-0.4591711461544037,
-0.24562574923038483,
-0.393586665391922,
-0.14090481400489807,
-0.18844419717788696,
-0.12680010497570038,
-0.5749980211257935,
-0.5325849652290344,
-0.18856492638587952,
-0.14851970970630646,
0.44623222947120667,
0.4773605763912201,
-0.22697380185127258,
0.03230423107743263,
-0.5342397093772888,
0.3386903405189514,
0.21926142275333405,
0.8586592674255371,
-0.22170153260231018,
-0.4669956564903259,
0.032461509108543396,
0.10593120008707047,
-0.40379759669303894,
-0.8072977662086487,
0.18911044299602509,
0.27165448665618896,
0.5207757949829102,
0.24689187109470367,
0.1251063346862793,
0.5463525652885437,
-0.5044613480567932,
0.4210573136806488,
-0.006832666229456663,
-0.6359477043151855,
0.816669762134552,
-0.6632092595100403,
0.14701808989048004,
0.8331495523452759,
0.5800080299377441,
-0.4700925946235657,
-0.19787366688251495,
-0.4566982388496399,
-0.6627441048622131,
0.6185950040817261,
0.0066350121051073074,
-0.29700568318367004,
-0.21433916687965393,
0.7152355909347534,
0.5002602338790894,
0.3999467194080353,
-0.5723845958709717,
-0.5487942695617676,
0.014602633193135262,
-0.08366730809211731,
-0.3356578052043915,
-0.3966046869754791,
-0.13179023563861847,
-0.2395431101322174,
1.0868452787399292,
-0.2189122587442398,
-0.05623192712664604,
0.32223251461982727,
-0.021627889946103096,
-0.3744438588619232,
0.33469828963279724,
0.49890878796577454,
0.5930261611938477,
-0.7202169299125671,
-0.14703278243541718,
-0.22836889326572418,
-0.23824471235275269,
0.19864226877689362,
0.1760592758655548,
-0.34387242794036865,
-0.21157535910606384,
-0.11216557770967484,
0.7633137106895447,
0.019969608634710312,
-0.5425859689712524,
0.3041205108165741,
-0.18937267363071442,
-0.3027561604976654,
0.029944857582449913,
0.11558625847101212,
-0.1929035633802414,
-0.2402048259973526,
0.30268600583076477,
0.32095620036125183,
0.2581597864627838,
-0.5703442692756653,
0.386260449886322,
0.4495018720626831,
-0.5245571136474609,
-0.18381346762180328,
0.4929439127445221,
0.4619634747505188,
-0.22796735167503357,
0.37020143866539,
-0.35638388991355896,
-0.5492186546325684,
0.26005521416664124,
0.35909050703048706,
0.8623821139335632,
-0.06725745648145676,
0.4341244101524353,
0.25129544734954834,
0.25625479221343994,
-0.3339102566242218,
0.3017302453517914,
0.07081355899572372,
-0.6021926403045654,
-0.5633016228675842,
-0.7374510169029236,
-0.6573737263679504,
0.3268108367919922,
-0.49606865644454956,
0.3923821747303009,
-0.3777264356613159,
-0.1636711210012436,
-0.1947639286518097,
0.243662029504776,
-0.5884659290313721,
0.16710159182548523,
0.14729785919189453,
0.7315181493759155,
-0.8812987804412842,
0.5260056257247925,
0.7201772332191467,
-0.010042507201433182,
-0.4978175461292267,
0.043426696211099625,
0.21813054382801056,
-0.579008936882019,
0.09688898921012878,
0.0879523977637291,
-0.09406962245702744,
-0.12273038178682327,
-0.1541646122932434,
-0.9697517156600952,
0.7475730180740356,
0.6716128587722778,
-0.9672775268554688,
0.1417638212442398,
-0.05774393305182457,
0.3585183024406433,
-0.25376197695732117,
-0.09682120382785797,
0.7610116600990295,
0.28597792983055115,
-0.1355394721031189,
-1.3670461177825928,
-0.12143684923648834,
0.11277148127555847,
-0.4605870544910431,
0.5189926028251648,
-1.0962618589401245,
0.6371732950210571,
-0.15630733966827393,
0.17328861355781555,
-0.07609396427869797,
0.11425122618675232,
0.31019625067710876,
0.1477687656879425,
0.9014030694961548,
0.6182085871696472,
0.6740501523017883,
-0.19532853364944458,
1.0907096862792969,
-0.30159011483192444,
0.33854374289512634,
0.9446534514427185,
-0.2463531196117401,
0.9720406532287598,
0.5984654426574707,
-0.21186025440692902,
0.2823832333087921,
0.76896733045578,
0.4411749243736267,
0.6519488096237183,
-0.0678887665271759,
-0.057807762175798416,
-0.3651084005832672,
0.17050541937351227,
-0.3543838858604431,
0.478156715631485,
0.1215304285287857,
-0.16620874404907227,
0.09770949929952621,
0.0017813504673540592,
-0.17787106335163116,
0.10897727310657501,
-0.4321351945400238,
0.6500045657157898,
0.1624736487865448,
-0.6897990703582764,
0.7397159337997437,
-0.19933293759822845,
0.7970512509346008,
-0.5512909293174744,
0.2212643027305603,
-0.4435041844844818,
0.4455064833164215,
-0.3280709683895111,
-0.6564376950263977,
0.5018866658210754,
-0.3754562735557556,
-0.43777593970298767,
-0.2895314395427704,
0.8368675112724304,
-0.3798190653324127,
-0.5323458313941956,
0.275860995054245,
0.29367512464523315,
-0.32188981771469116,
-0.18661721050739288,
-0.7787396907806396,
0.2595166265964508,
0.2614406943321228,
-0.1583683043718338,
0.28910794854164124,
0.14274364709854126,
0.26002976298332214,
0.7762995362281799,
0.3011942207813263,
0.13966241478919983,
-0.23100332915782928,
0.035840533673763275,
0.6729068160057068,
-0.47620198130607605,
-0.5425103902816772,
-0.8332710862159729,
0.5343303084373474,
-0.1492101401090622,
-0.22489240765571594,
0.8249261975288391,
0.43198642134666443,
0.8666093945503235,
-0.07855145633220673,
0.8010203242301941,
0.05607277899980545,
0.7461268901824951,
-0.3301459550857544,
0.5242489576339722,
-0.7724783420562744,
0.22208844125270844,
-0.48697197437286377,
-1.0489284992218018,
-0.17471258342266083,
0.5491399168968201,
-0.5375898480415344,
-0.3696940243244171,
0.27692916989326477,
0.6135560274124146,
-0.3068438470363617,
-0.22251498699188232,
0.29013776779174805,
0.2077948898077011,
0.30761945247650146,
0.5537651181221008,
0.5520453453063965,
-0.4319562613964081,
0.5434530377388,
-0.614410400390625,
-0.6643300652503967,
-0.3721560537815094,
-1.0544873476028442,
-0.9159788489341736,
-0.5315867066383362,
-0.5693825483322144,
-0.19260206818580627,
0.1787903606891632,
0.7416704893112183,
0.7888336777687073,
-0.6954866647720337,
-0.10788063704967499,
-0.09667941927909851,
0.2399229109287262,
-0.1898002326488495,
-0.26821479201316833,
0.09451902657747269,
-0.24423691630363464,
-0.5675991177558899,
0.3606628477573395,
0.6678311228752136,
0.07459947466850281,
-0.10024172067642212,
-0.19899357855319977,
-0.02393173612654209,
0.14177559316158295,
0.7493695020675659,
0.16474097967147827,
-0.7325167059898376,
-0.41774317622184753,
0.14428366720676422,
0.16661275923252106,
0.23327799141407013,
0.5998074412345886,
-0.5163895487785339,
0.45787152647972107,
0.39242294430732727,
0.5122729539871216,
0.3140052855014801,
-0.015077689662575722,
0.8141765594482422,
-0.5615888833999634,
0.13574327528476715,
0.12417364865541458,
0.49252599477767944,
0.5597163438796997,
-0.42897653579711914,
0.45948484539985657,
0.2647014260292053,
-0.807765781879425,
-1.0095205307006836,
0.4224604070186615,
-1.1577061414718628,
0.10000893473625183,
1.101521611213684,
0.20303811132907867,
-0.11636748909950256,
0.24136628210544586,
-0.6349725723266602,
-0.10725370794534683,
-0.4770743250846863,
1.135973334312439,
0.8500270247459412,
-0.47636184096336365,
-0.007270116824656725,
-0.35435763001441956,
0.9978548884391785,
0.4606620669364929,
-0.5341866612434387,
0.14184890687465668,
0.5710903406143188,
0.5822885036468506,
-0.06504488736391068,
0.7728335857391357,
0.03989866003394127,
0.3690268099308014,
-0.2308342307806015,
-0.5097428560256958,
-0.151248961687088,
-0.2786056697368622,
-0.19625510275363922,
0.07037131488323212,
0.3606415390968323,
-0.1254856139421463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13225v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13225v1 | AgentMD: Empowering Language Agents for Risk Prediction with Large-Scale Clinical Tool Learning | 2024-02-20T18:37:19 | 2024-02-20T18:37:19 | Qiao Jin, Zhizheng Wang, Yifan Yang, Qingqing Zhu, Donald Wright, Thomas Huang, W John Wilbur, Zhe He, Andrew Taylor, Qingyu Chen, Zhiyong Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Clinical calculators play a vital role in healthcare by offering accurate
evidence-based predictions for various purposes such as prognosis.
Nevertheless, their widespread utilization is frequently hindered by usability
challenges, poor dissemination, and restricted functionality. Augmenting large
language models with extensive collections of clinical calculators presents an
opportunity to overcome these obstacles and improve workflow efficiency, but
the scalability of the manual curation process poses a significant challenge.
In response, we introduce AgentMD, a novel language agent capable of curating
and applying clinical calculators across various clinical contexts. Using the
published literature, AgentMD has automatically curated a collection of 2,164
diverse clinical calculators with executable functions and structured
documentation, collectively named RiskCalcs. Manual evaluations show that
RiskCalcs tools achieve an accuracy of over 80% on three quality metrics. At
inference time, AgentMD can automatically select and apply the relevant
RiskCalcs tools given any patient description. On the newly established RiskQA
benchmark, AgentMD significantly outperforms chain-of-thought prompting with
GPT-4 (87.7% vs. 40.9% in accuracy). Additionally, we also applied AgentMD to
real-world clinical notes for analyzing both population-level and risk-level
patient characteristics. In summary, our study illustrates the utility of
language agents augmented with clinical calculators for healthcare analytics
and patient care. | [
0.03153912350535393,
-0.6923076510429382,
0.7691816091537476,
-0.04146266356110573,
-0.1291074901819229,
0.37835726141929626,
-0.1284433901309967,
-0.26700201630592346,
0.14940793812274933,
0.5715401768684387,
-0.2703920006752014,
-0.7878185510635376,
-0.7688974738121033,
-0.22632774710655212,
0.20300796627998352,
0.6704259514808655,
-0.05229112505912781,
0.5254006385803223,
-0.5320062041282654,
-0.1384190171957016,
-0.3099654018878937,
-0.3529019057750702,
-0.7657660841941833,
-0.4527544677257538,
0.6073781847953796,
0.47508955001831055,
1.2632137537002563,
0.6306056976318359,
0.6321051716804504,
0.3013934791088104,
0.488642156124115,
0.1887899786233902,
-0.16146181523799896,
0.38110896944999695,
-0.050556495785713196,
-0.5279850959777832,
-0.8849129676818848,
-0.045118119567632675,
0.3173817992210388,
0.8315442204475403,
-0.31015703082084656,
-0.012566601857542992,
-0.4037599265575409,
0.20441225171089172,
-0.6152189373970032,
0.5323580503463745,
-0.3302232027053833,
0.026453278958797455,
0.07757476717233658,
-0.6396027207374573,
-0.5136623978614807,
-0.5533478856086731,
0.2679878771305084,
-0.47608938813209534,
0.04172390326857567,
-0.3734149634838104,
0.12500424683094025,
0.305921733379364,
-0.6402936577796936,
-0.42981404066085815,
-0.589051365852356,
0.4669719338417053,
-0.3155449628829956,
0.16339462995529175,
0.7195537686347961,
0.8524706959724426,
-0.29973798990249634,
-0.5877483487129211,
-0.1641594022512436,
-0.30328020453453064,
0.34887802600860596,
0.010797767899930477,
-0.13194848597049713,
0.29513025283813477,
0.1043798103928566,
-0.012171593494713306,
-0.5399713516235352,
0.25768786668777466,
-0.1409597545862198,
-0.6804775595664978,
0.7942034006118774,
0.36863985657691956,
0.5471473932266235,
0.2819446623325348,
-0.15395978093147278,
-0.5270977020263672,
-0.8774225115776062,
-0.20773783326148987,
-0.051445577293634415,
0.19037684798240662,
-0.00504051661118865,
0.375418484210968,
0.3343946635723114,
0.21109548211097717,
-0.4328763782978058,
-0.4002554714679718,
0.4574774205684662,
0.13566775619983673,
-0.14407004415988922,
0.5320748090744019,
0.7816438674926758,
0.32464635372161865,
0.027366671711206436,
-0.16809508204460144,
0.10456574708223343,
0.022120539098978043,
0.5475896000862122,
-0.89997798204422,
-0.2433708757162094,
0.46237650513648987,
-0.017459049820899963,
-0.5210979580879211,
-0.25223222374916077,
-0.5693303942680359,
-0.8420006632804871,
0.0036624977365136147,
0.4446597993373871,
-0.42938852310180664,
-0.28627854585647583,
0.10837359726428986,
-0.02058647759258747,
-0.11905889213085175,
0.6039925813674927,
-0.23967288434505463,
0.34487587213516235,
0.5774557590484619,
0.6455792784690857,
-0.18849849700927734,
-0.12791427969932556,
-0.9205063581466675,
0.025596635416150093,
-0.6137419939041138,
0.7732288241386414,
-0.5187591910362244,
-0.8293361663818359,
0.21371987462043762,
0.09150529652833939,
0.07049839198589325,
-0.45170170068740845,
0.5375325679779053,
-0.1794952154159546,
-0.20664779841899872,
-0.02056131511926651,
-0.3678169846534729,
-0.0039648995734751225,
0.1496381163597107,
-0.8228731155395508,
0.7192248106002808,
0.5745338201522827,
-0.23726755380630493,
0.5550990700721741,
-0.3956817388534546,
-0.5750519633293152,
0.36862698197364807,
-0.2570630609989166,
-0.617039680480957,
-0.14456366002559662,
0.010876773856580257,
0.5217349529266357,
-0.5497255325317383,
0.32053589820861816,
-0.5272613763809204,
0.09539273381233215,
0.4445438086986542,
-0.575604259967804,
0.45419812202453613,
0.4863009750843048,
-0.18478424847126007,
0.2913806140422821,
-0.584709644317627,
0.1815631091594696,
0.030570127069950104,
-0.018296364694833755,
-0.31964150071144104,
-0.11630077660083771,
0.06820055097341537,
0.34900686144828796,
-0.08894843608140945,
-0.3629923164844513,
-0.09884151816368103,
-0.2794091999530792,
0.2512636184692383,
0.560279130935669,
0.12782837450504303,
0.43313369154930115,
-0.4530612826347351,
1.2697994709014893,
-0.00029799758340232074,
0.16489633917808533,
-0.10573969036340714,
-0.4458290636539459,
0.05018247291445732,
-0.3918861746788025,
0.049450457096099854,
0.511130690574646,
-0.8903644680976868,
0.09459065645933151,
-0.3152213394641876,
-1.0053396224975586,
-0.5019161701202393,
-0.053505390882492065,
0.4357546269893646,
0.32476484775543213,
0.16853870451450348,
-0.3351077437400818,
-0.25865116715431213,
-0.2912915349006653,
-0.20505806803703308,
-0.25724589824676514,
0.00449853902682662,
0.4824211299419403,
0.08048243075609207,
-0.6803994178771973,
0.6574328541755676,
-0.6949824690818787,
-0.30016782879829407,
-0.5136274695396423,
0.03299775347113609,
-0.11960378289222717,
0.32525044679641724,
0.45689207315444946,
-0.5168130397796631,
-0.3998302221298218,
0.2686081826686859,
-0.576316773891449,
-0.11628203839063644,
-0.014695316553115845,
-0.10329245775938034,
0.06268259882926941,
0.4069055914878845,
-0.6402437686920166,
0.5805312991142273,
0.3412171006202698,
-0.2970055639743805,
0.567455530166626,
-0.7565535306930542,
-0.03033911995589733,
-1.1903293132781982,
-0.23601025342941284,
-0.0110032819211483,
-0.4540848731994629,
-0.6085167527198792,
0.0130925877019763,
0.2282152771949768,
-0.1535412073135376,
-0.5471137762069702,
0.7231591939926147,
-0.37677979469299316,
0.179849773645401,
-0.24577271938323975,
0.045867014676332474,
-0.2135457843542099,
-0.12428445369005203,
-0.041826214641332626,
0.7557855844497681,
0.647497296333313,
-0.4667668044567108,
0.36584311723709106,
0.10710743069648743,
-0.09000634402036667,
0.33385106921195984,
-0.44483092427253723,
-0.028991198167204857,
-0.03164249286055565,
0.32613980770111084,
-0.637395977973938,
-0.25589433312416077,
-0.028305022045969963,
-0.46305692195892334,
0.3649677038192749,
-0.0011969141196459532,
-0.30772674083709717,
-0.4833392798900604,
-0.33881598711013794,
0.3173581659793854,
0.37966492772102356,
-0.023724621161818504,
0.7440847754478455,
0.9250646233558655,
-0.4237794280052185,
-0.48999449610710144,
-0.5523781776428223,
0.24014003574848175,
0.06444091349840164,
-0.29452282190322876,
-0.12890861928462982,
-0.05345010757446289,
-0.31154200434684753,
-0.27989551424980164,
-0.045562852174043655,
-0.09539853036403656,
0.0195394828915596,
0.6630061268806458,
0.4063940644264221,
-0.013925673440098763,
0.6086637377738953,
0.22424231469631195,
-0.23631694912910461,
0.49306097626686096,
-0.25100117921829224,
0.4522266089916229,
0.004295408725738525,
-0.6264643669128418,
-0.030516158789396286,
0.08265671133995056,
0.7774716019630432,
-0.23094631731510162,
0.5995383262634277,
0.6279535889625549,
-0.54841148853302,
-0.38793671131134033,
-0.42513522505760193,
-0.16908660531044006,
-0.4333193004131317,
0.5691699385643005,
-0.27502018213272095,
-0.5853517055511475,
0.4824449419975281,
-0.21404500305652618,
-0.12347467988729477,
0.4439355731010437,
0.9969597458839417,
0.5013555288314819,
1.3958264589309692,
0.23009271919727325,
0.1253526210784912,
0.07602408528327942,
-0.33806678652763367,
-0.08375857770442963,
-0.43276748061180115,
-0.32653936743736267,
-0.40457016229629517,
0.1523553878068924,
-0.6853040456771851,
-1.0569626092910767,
0.7067045569419861,
-0.7632975578308105,
-0.13137097656726837,
0.28591883182525635,
-0.32079172134399414,
0.1801147162914276,
0.2534578740596771,
0.3555404841899872,
0.06129239872097969,
-0.22043074667453766,
-0.38871991634368896,
0.1721581518650055,
-0.6573586463928223,
-0.5406786203384399,
1.6489033699035645,
0.556470513343811,
1.102126121520996,
0.12676537036895752,
0.6679742932319641,
0.6481001377105713,
0.5335367321968079,
-0.9199022650718689,
0.4081614315509796,
0.20083847641944885,
-0.5235241651535034,
-0.3787439465522766,
-0.5714530348777771,
-1.0404609441757202,
0.10800030827522278,
-0.06756492704153061,
-0.37024351954460144,
0.09742757678031921,
0.011798552237451077,
-0.5170645713806152,
0.007998136803507805,
-0.8060290813446045,
0.8715175986289978,
-0.27371641993522644,
-0.4836878180503845,
-0.2792830765247345,
-0.6156112551689148,
-0.15387140214443207,
-0.18754340708255768,
0.47160571813583374,
-0.19112654030323029,
-0.21683870255947113,
0.22104284167289734,
-0.8847059011459351,
0.6984028220176697,
-0.020057635381817818,
-0.34635788202285767,
0.3335081934928894,
0.5279195308685303,
0.4823061525821686,
0.3793102502822876,
-0.1580822467803955,
-0.1848386973142624,
0.427203506231308,
-0.2646193504333496,
-0.501441478729248,
0.7648200392723083,
-0.7014877796173096,
-0.4559634327888489,
-0.7667478322982788,
-0.7193835377693176,
-0.4576670527458191,
0.2925170063972473,
-0.09036058187484741,
0.947263240814209,
-0.5896612405776978,
-0.11337146162986755,
0.3394024670124054,
-0.31670621037483215,
0.0786965861916542,
0.6316960453987122,
0.021434016525745392,
-0.4428393840789795,
1.0110172033309937,
-0.15023569762706757,
0.5361027717590332,
0.38229987025260925,
0.3502683639526367,
-0.5135931372642517,
-0.3109283447265625,
-0.2580951154232025,
0.029009362682700157,
-0.9140484929084778,
-0.33145642280578613,
-0.7967106103897095,
-0.15596948564052582,
-0.5308462977409363,
-0.28816425800323486,
-0.1928817480802536,
-0.42537397146224976,
-0.05474751442670822,
-0.38724324107170105,
0.38374200463294983,
0.4118027091026306,
-0.0713326632976532,
0.17512790858745575,
-0.7072882056236267,
0.13111649453639984,
0.19689230620861053,
0.25563833117485046,
-0.2458266168832779,
-0.07020977884531021,
-0.1940012127161026,
0.18732666969299316,
-0.3039778172969818,
-0.7786064743995667,
0.9268934726715088,
0.3517542779445648,
0.5050974488258362,
0.7514383792877197,
0.2529948949813843,
0.3790220618247986,
-0.5290095806121826,
0.22114354372024536,
0.29333803057670593,
-0.4938087463378906,
0.5008817315101624,
-0.14389565587043762,
0.2564307451248169,
0.6558914184570312,
0.49358105659484863,
-0.451070636510849,
-0.5661606788635254,
-0.7161186337471008,
-0.39022085070610046,
0.6447818875312805,
-0.03750040754675865,
-0.08582198619842529,
-0.16737133264541626,
-0.13063141703605652,
0.3559877574443817,
0.1273430436849594,
0.14715789258480072,
-0.11064540594816208,
-0.012383776716887951,
-0.5156682133674622,
-0.5910390019416809,
0.03794180974364281,
-0.3397977650165558,
-0.18908093869686127,
0.47721052169799805,
-0.45781654119491577,
0.19822369515895844,
0.30080941319465637,
-0.4309011995792389,
-0.3990269899368286,
0.2137175351381302,
0.41050341725349426,
0.8962351679801941,
-0.3842357099056244,
0.5377464890480042,
0.11469101160764694,
-1.1764867305755615,
0.07687587291002274,
0.3978283703327179,
0.3605775237083435,
0.10138237476348877,
0.4137597978115082,
0.5801501274108887,
0.30269449949264526,
-1.3011410236358643,
0.5726985335350037,
-0.24232691526412964,
-0.12602753937244415,
-0.49429699778556824,
0.24130937457084656,
-0.12220443785190582,
-0.12408201396465302,
0.1179153248667717,
0.1379835456609726,
0.32517239451408386,
-0.7159413695335388,
0.45273199677467346,
0.41566070914268494,
-0.9885377883911133,
-0.11738787591457367,
0.8810378313064575,
0.16317962110042572,
-0.4478665888309479,
0.14978736639022827,
-0.12697751820087433,
-0.4484567642211914,
0.9848805665969849,
0.4250011742115021,
0.9108532667160034,
-0.41191205382347107,
0.7257871627807617,
0.14966218173503876,
0.14934134483337402,
-0.0019720757845789194,
0.17369845509529114,
0.18927155435085297,
-0.47516849637031555,
-0.2961595356464386,
-0.27195823192596436,
-0.905375599861145,
-0.3267712891101837,
-0.40593835711479187,
0.25983181595802307,
-0.5080804228782654,
-0.464506059885025,
0.24931901693344116,
0.20416218042373657,
-0.7025312781333923,
0.151539608836174,
0.06330259144306183,
0.9218075275421143,
-0.37739554047584534,
0.8690066337585449,
0.8967108130455017,
-0.35542526841163635,
-0.8955618143081665,
-0.44229671359062195,
0.4062615931034088,
-1.0260623693466187,
0.10532128065824509,
0.18253056704998016,
-0.006036899983882904,
-0.11775674670934677,
-0.05297195538878441,
-0.36074432730674744,
1.3178430795669556,
0.41034993529319763,
-0.07026845216751099,
0.08555616438388824,
0.5775521993637085,
0.6946339011192322,
-0.5759194493293762,
0.8330554366111755,
0.5080036520957947,
0.16652534902095795,
0.40019145607948303,
-0.9719561338424683,
0.3407469689846039,
-0.2791265547275543,
-0.34607812762260437,
0.2237575352191925,
-0.11656946688890457,
0.5504770874977112,
-0.751203715801239,
0.055900584906339645,
-0.22273018956184387,
-0.031243501231074333,
0.029803238809108734,
0.6936159133911133,
0.24921131134033203,
0.3231119215488434,
0.7524871230125427,
-0.012621600180864334,
1.2330421209335327,
-0.29848819971084595,
0.18435871601104736,
0.9272435307502747,
-0.5059916973114014,
0.4444458782672882,
-0.03889322653412819,
-0.36504000425338745,
0.37148934602737427,
0.42467162013053894,
0.3380264639854431,
0.10676474124193192,
0.05130258947610855,
-0.5393022894859314,
-0.5046096444129944,
-0.16573169827461243,
-0.3206140100955963,
0.3046213388442993,
0.6049883365631104,
-0.4535343050956726,
-0.2109035849571228,
0.2061835527420044,
0.13988995552062988,
0.02324274554848671,
-0.3077470660209656,
0.6670308709144592,
0.29901283979415894,
-0.6458423137664795,
0.41309604048728943,
-0.3561466634273529,
-0.15769636631011963,
-0.7820467352867126,
-0.198710098862648,
0.07287068665027618,
0.597703754901886,
0.08335113525390625,
-0.7699472904205322,
-0.14766277372837067,
-0.4005869925022125,
0.28195494413375854,
-0.1607362926006317,
0.8541277647018433,
-0.5203622579574585,
-0.6185135841369629,
0.09607678651809692,
0.6166280508041382,
0.13304056227207184,
-0.31508690118789673,
-0.4237563908100128,
-0.1279929280281067,
-0.5358798503875732,
0.23976393043994904,
0.4029660224914551,
0.6189106702804565,
-0.21726566553115845,
1.286299467086792,
0.6805135607719421,
0.40291285514831543,
-0.3623006045818329,
0.3101763427257538,
0.7717934250831604,
-0.3717515170574188,
-0.468780517578125,
-0.7012531757354736,
0.02523280307650566,
0.05248558893799782,
-0.19057799875736237,
0.5688528418540955,
0.47824767231941223,
0.24043720960617065,
-0.07560160011053085,
0.6718996167182922,
0.3152276575565338,
0.39520153403282166,
-0.006201691459864378,
1.0239112377166748,
-0.4601384401321411,
0.21069055795669556,
-0.32461661100387573,
-0.3921665847301483,
-0.3829156458377838,
0.04543540999293327,
-0.35932600498199463,
-0.11512190848588943,
0.7240360975265503,
0.7093195915222168,
0.41797417402267456,
-0.18935136497020721,
0.49446991086006165,
0.1783367097377777,
0.601427435874939,
0.5672765374183655,
0.2734827399253845,
-0.26900336146354675,
0.4945550858974457,
-0.22573085129261017,
-0.43967777490615845,
-0.5225543975830078,
-0.6215484142303467,
-0.9492844343185425,
-0.36453384160995483,
-0.41557303071022034,
-0.3946625292301178,
0.06913012266159058,
1.3643836975097656,
0.5182933211326599,
-0.6411131024360657,
0.00823486689478159,
-0.00344371167011559,
0.3457496762275696,
-0.31656309962272644,
-0.1315823197364807,
0.5875370502471924,
-0.14103183150291443,
-0.48486706614494324,
0.1586529016494751,
0.40399447083473206,
-0.017071573063731194,
-0.342563658952713,
-0.3540489971637726,
0.2543400526046753,
0.09638649970293045,
0.7005531787872314,
0.29048284888267517,
-0.31712666153907776,
0.09316977858543396,
0.000844349677208811,
-0.4614900052547455,
-0.16814732551574707,
0.6335555911064148,
-0.8000804781913757,
1.002647042274475,
0.1863662153482437,
0.6728854179382324,
0.10532533377408981,
-0.19253064692020416,
0.8378446102142334,
-0.19217146933078766,
0.1815105527639389,
0.6129801273345947,
0.19759336113929749,
0.001088032848201692,
-0.5455293655395508,
0.46402817964553833,
0.012920811772346497,
-0.4586487412452698,
-0.8298122882843018,
-0.10493449121713638,
-1.086184024810791,
-0.072783924639225,
1.2218337059020996,
0.028398489579558372,
-0.3715379536151886,
-0.2578134834766388,
-0.5330530405044556,
0.22542835772037506,
-0.5384971499443054,
0.5931184887886047,
0.2646956443786621,
0.1746518611907959,
0.02179543301463127,
-0.8419694304466248,
0.6701692938804626,
0.015216268599033356,
-0.9012866616249084,
-0.0716555118560791,
0.49261564016342163,
0.17527176439762115,
-0.03475550562143326,
0.7003116011619568,
-0.30046674609184265,
0.7654868364334106,
0.029320459812879562,
0.22149698436260223,
-0.199336439371109,
-0.0726807564496994,
-0.03073243424296379,
-0.0007847178494557738,
0.1867196410894394,
0.04403649643063545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13222v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13222v1 | RoCode: A Dataset for Measuring Code Intelligence from Problem Definitions in Romanian | 2024-02-20T18:32:47 | 2024-02-20T18:32:47 | Adrian Cosma, Bogdan Iordache, Paolo Rosso | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, large language models (LLMs) have become increasingly powerful and
have become capable of solving a plethora of tasks through proper instructions
in natural language. However, the vast majority of testing suites assume that
the instructions are written in English, the de facto prompting language. Code
intelligence and problem solving still remain a difficult task, even for the
most advanced LLMs. Currently, there are no datasets to measure the
generalization power for code-generation models in a language other than
English. In this work, we present RoCode, a competitive programming dataset,
consisting of 2,642 problems written in Romanian, 11k solutions in C, C++ and
Python and comprehensive testing suites for each problem. The purpose of RoCode
is to provide a benchmark for evaluating the code intelligence of language
models trained on Romanian / multilingual text as well as a fine-tuning set for
pretrained Romanian models. Through our results and review of related works, we
argue for the need to develop code models for languages other than English. | [
-0.11967510730028152,
-0.6040492653846741,
0.13783422112464905,
0.07149104028940201,
-0.12689076364040375,
-0.03813449293375015,
-0.7432262897491455,
-0.20964528620243073,
-0.014481984078884125,
0.2877162992954254,
-0.5531253814697266,
-0.8003306984901428,
-0.43153467774391174,
0.3197721540927887,
-0.2613568902015686,
1.1364189386367798,
-0.26428747177124023,
0.4684235751628876,
-0.3460858464241028,
-0.3288438022136688,
-0.6759642958641052,
-0.4036760628223419,
0.08771532028913498,
-0.1515573263168335,
0.30316004157066345,
0.9201446175575256,
0.39621028304100037,
0.14226582646369934,
0.9559598565101624,
0.24727818369865417,
0.4245053231716156,
0.056898605078458786,
-0.5380244255065918,
0.06948342174291611,
-0.14475691318511963,
-0.6936442255973816,
-0.40868693590164185,
-0.013786395080387592,
0.4643789827823639,
0.5151808261871338,
-0.07631146907806396,
0.4455442428588867,
-0.009910336695611477,
0.5421677231788635,
-0.39262470602989197,
0.20490509271621704,
-0.840317964553833,
-0.009223777800798416,
0.002703077858313918,
-0.39174380898475647,
-0.4466395378112793,
-0.597986102104187,
-0.3365650773048401,
-0.37986865639686584,
0.44593125581741333,
0.01456269808113575,
0.858684778213501,
0.3837641775608063,
-0.025060594081878662,
-0.7184883952140808,
-0.7828307151794434,
1.025018572807312,
-0.361632376909256,
0.2752905786037445,
0.05202381685376167,
0.21319369971752167,
-0.1911572813987732,
-0.36230701208114624,
-0.35747870802879333,
-0.4324444830417633,
0.1271219551563263,
-0.07853531092405319,
-0.341828852891922,
-0.26326021552085876,
0.20946292579174042,
0.12103063613176346,
-0.8707886934280396,
0.15039275586605072,
-0.6301179528236389,
-0.04981602355837822,
0.6966174840927124,
0.21106061339378357,
0.4978899657726288,
0.033552709966897964,
-0.18579114973545074,
-0.06702364236116409,
-1.0268902778625488,
0.1137194037437439,
0.4142425060272217,
0.2278112918138504,
-0.11908894032239914,
0.6071649789810181,
-0.04096949100494385,
0.6205021739006042,
-0.4615052044391632,
0.13283787667751312,
0.18715254962444305,
-0.28998643159866333,
-0.12473855167627335,
0.048008836805820465,
0.6054396033287048,
0.1755201369524002,
0.5958187580108643,
-0.2415638118982315,
-0.20119866728782654,
0.41118526458740234,
0.2781142294406891,
-0.8321288824081421,
-0.36824971437454224,
0.17528323829174042,
-0.32006630301475525,
-0.3738960027694702,
0.06729642301797867,
-0.6474194526672363,
-0.09733626246452332,
-0.04539266973733902,
-0.01928585208952427,
-0.3268607258796692,
-0.20855356752872467,
0.24053137004375458,
0.09871981292963028,
0.6473367214202881,
-0.21112443506717682,
-0.6169668436050415,
0.1718292087316513,
0.8909449577331543,
0.4954209327697754,
-0.044390950351953506,
-0.24687348306179047,
-0.5934669971466064,
-0.5410817861557007,
-0.770280659198761,
0.9095823168754578,
-0.7966325879096985,
-0.3840881288051605,
-0.04272937402129173,
0.06337137520313263,
0.05589791387319565,
-0.4580024182796478,
0.6935344934463501,
-0.4472252428531647,
-0.12020106613636017,
-0.07798323780298233,
-0.4389302134513855,
-0.02356106974184513,
0.16476067900657654,
-0.3433968126773834,
1.0883036851882935,
0.13844133913516998,
-0.6989153623580933,
0.32457593083381653,
-0.3620856702327728,
-0.3567899763584137,
0.41241925954818726,
-0.7139414548873901,
-0.43982255458831787,
0.2269190102815628,
0.04967425763607025,
0.4522532522678375,
-0.6047152280807495,
0.5069872140884399,
-0.10079558938741684,
-0.3662078082561493,
0.15711244940757751,
-0.07910974323749542,
0.9620314836502075,
0.20965726673603058,
-0.49284297227859497,
0.049399908632040024,
-0.5514018535614014,
0.3007666766643524,
0.14382342994213104,
-0.2644187808036804,
-0.20939941704273224,
0.25002530217170715,
-0.10123971104621887,
-0.06340177357196808,
0.19687491655349731,
-0.7043905854225159,
0.2065085470676422,
-0.054023321717977524,
0.3002358675003052,
0.5760033130645752,
-0.2812836170196533,
0.17414119839668274,
-0.3722705841064453,
0.9278319478034973,
-0.33823826909065247,
-0.045671213418245316,
0.09286012500524521,
-0.7516854405403137,
-0.7536184787750244,
-0.04706895723938942,
0.4393278956413269,
0.7559952139854431,
-0.4688340127468109,
0.2556764483451843,
-0.625957727432251,
-0.6770904660224915,
-0.5689067840576172,
0.543537974357605,
0.5397321581840515,
0.3020569384098053,
0.1535884588956833,
-0.026228537783026695,
-0.47593191266059875,
-0.9366666674613953,
-0.06805116683244705,
0.10707015544176102,
-0.02077850140631199,
0.5152713656425476,
0.6859248280525208,
-0.32076889276504517,
0.7099266648292542,
-0.3921492099761963,
-0.4497600793838501,
-0.8012020587921143,
0.07322943210601807,
0.2265014946460724,
0.4526010751724243,
0.5774527192115784,
-0.704940140247345,
-0.36120855808258057,
0.1559508740901947,
-0.8254269957542419,
-0.11056136339902878,
0.1040525734424591,
-0.05367971956729889,
0.0898396298289299,
0.600532591342926,
0.05977322533726692,
0.16719172894954681,
0.9615877270698547,
-0.13058772683143616,
0.6794037818908691,
-0.5829473733901978,
0.14616622030735016,
-0.9431747794151306,
0.22678415477275848,
0.09710728377103806,
0.22485357522964478,
-0.4741896688938141,
0.5582568049430847,
0.3113015592098236,
-0.44389402866363525,
-0.23208284378051758,
0.3197457492351532,
-0.6815664172172546,
-0.11111471056938171,
0.14301566779613495,
0.28585413098335266,
-0.1843584179878235,
0.4350690245628357,
0.2609798014163971,
0.9083731174468994,
0.5615774393081665,
-0.5398554801940918,
0.7930365800857544,
0.25571170449256897,
-0.789177417755127,
0.44286292791366577,
-0.9232072234153748,
0.1282123476266861,
-0.02355826273560524,
0.08765368163585663,
-0.804867148399353,
-0.07249618321657181,
-0.2852190136909485,
-0.7722316384315491,
0.06136101484298706,
-0.19816453754901886,
-0.25948289036750793,
-0.33850982785224915,
-0.14651384949684143,
0.7474977374076843,
0.6241398453712463,
-0.2773978114128113,
0.19856372475624084,
0.30795571208000183,
-0.35530659556388855,
-0.6540650725364685,
-0.7536163926124573,
0.1270056962966919,
-0.15521372854709625,
-0.8192746639251709,
0.07484222948551178,
-0.28300926089286804,
-0.5263279676437378,
-0.07574798911809921,
0.3512391746044159,
-0.39540931582450867,
0.03792857006192207,
0.0993787869811058,
0.41687241196632385,
-0.5200864672660828,
0.28539836406707764,
-0.2337530106306076,
-0.295369416475296,
0.1624976396560669,
-0.05165223032236099,
0.4736991822719574,
-0.2799254059791565,
-0.12333770096302032,
-0.13364510238170624,
0.31016165018081665,
0.23534440994262695,
-0.8318541646003723,
0.40693700313568115,
0.2815435230731964,
-0.19918061792850494,
-0.782193124294281,
-0.219734326004982,
0.2012261003255844,
-0.409985214471817,
0.5345127582550049,
-0.515211820602417,
-0.5318624973297119,
0.4355752468109131,
0.14950361847877502,
0.19608108699321747,
0.12929603457450867,
0.7115919589996338,
0.06695329397916794,
0.8303714394569397,
0.8619223237037659,
-0.2149748057126999,
0.219655379652977,
-0.507670521736145,
0.4245130121707916,
-0.5303345918655396,
-0.11809971928596497,
-1.0669560432434082,
-0.28198158740997314,
-0.7950758337974548,
-0.6255261898040771,
0.26257088780403137,
-0.20457753539085388,
0.13572129607200623,
0.6195346713066101,
-0.6208882331848145,
0.6316125392913818,
0.404549777507782,
0.0811353325843811,
0.3042970299720764,
-0.03212970495223999,
-0.1701408177614212,
-0.1830640435218811,
-0.9030573964118958,
-0.542153537273407,
1.3856276273727417,
0.028989277780056,
0.9947260618209839,
-0.05598635971546173,
0.7648432850837708,
0.32573026418685913,
0.20235906541347504,
-0.6895883679389954,
0.36289867758750916,
-0.17165175080299377,
-0.6036840677261353,
-0.07664117962121964,
-0.6046255230903625,
-1.032537579536438,
-0.2836166024208069,
-0.0771450623869896,
-0.24571238458156586,
0.1254628300666809,
-0.030054308474063873,
-0.38431212306022644,
0.25138700008392334,
-0.47826701402664185,
1.0398131608963013,
-0.43511873483657837,
-0.20228949189186096,
-0.5494722127914429,
-0.008680004626512527,
0.34571555256843567,
0.06972579658031464,
0.5358158349990845,
-0.17476022243499756,
0.10519988089799881,
0.7384419441223145,
-0.2747730016708374,
0.36929959058761597,
0.12427925318479538,
-0.2364421784877777,
0.39935335516929626,
0.3132117986679077,
0.36611121892929077,
0.13113461434841156,
-0.2128239870071411,
0.18744972348213196,
-0.13091523945331573,
-0.5262265801429749,
-0.31152087450027466,
0.84317547082901,
-0.6009082794189453,
-0.31108707189559937,
-0.3037809133529663,
-0.6078553199768066,
-0.013826912268996239,
0.052245885133743286,
0.5942257046699524,
1.1030749082565308,
-0.4726579189300537,
0.40405789017677307,
0.9061189293861389,
-0.6183963418006897,
0.18818910419940948,
0.5128534436225891,
0.13791625201702118,
0.016448503360152245,
1.1452769041061401,
-0.14162667095661163,
0.09007488191127777,
0.2459322065114975,
-0.04704428091645241,
0.07003506273031235,
-0.6323297619819641,
-0.4489639401435852,
0.044177837669849396,
-0.5027425289154053,
-0.31421566009521484,
-0.2536960542201996,
-0.08025309443473816,
-0.20498187839984894,
-0.4621008336544037,
-0.23441718518733978,
-0.033958662301301956,
0.09803318232297897,
-0.008531174622476101,
0.21748755872249603,
1.0901060104370117,
-0.16181087493896484,
-0.39552855491638184,
-0.6150104999542236,
0.5059295892715454,
0.1925850212574005,
0.47088533639907837,
-0.31633222103118896,
-0.387209951877594,
-0.39629146456718445,
0.21531906723976135,
-0.04693969711661339,
-0.7777450084686279,
0.3546668589115143,
0.26510486006736755,
0.709339439868927,
0.10263550281524658,
0.25518476963043213,
0.2613300085067749,
-0.4217682182788849,
0.5571063160896301,
-0.15293346345424652,
-0.6853299140930176,
0.745908796787262,
-0.19698791205883026,
-0.02897927165031433,
0.5695454478263855,
0.4329133927822113,
-0.547989547252655,
-0.48314061760902405,
-0.506852924823761,
-0.37027254700660706,
0.5067821741104126,
0.11956406384706497,
0.2960323095321655,
-0.12432708591222763,
-0.005343282129615545,
-0.017571663483977318,
-0.09682656824588776,
-0.6398043632507324,
-0.06828480213880539,
0.2591657340526581,
-0.27600806951522827,
-0.17840537428855896,
-0.21186389029026031,
0.052624717354774475,
-0.16682139039039612,
0.5877342224121094,
0.0521160364151001,
0.25801882147789,
0.02259998396039009,
-0.6020412445068359,
-0.10897496342658997,
0.41896533966064453,
0.7026457786560059,
0.9172496795654297,
-0.10153903067111969,
-0.14712783694267273,
0.023700950667262077,
-0.49492907524108887,
0.09853903949260712,
-0.20707476139068604,
-0.12525661289691925,
0.11039521545171738,
0.5097361207008362,
0.24448351562023163,
0.341257780790329,
-0.9914807081222534,
0.6389105916023254,
-0.3539790213108063,
-0.2453809231519699,
-0.2200167030096054,
0.3705289661884308,
-0.1530635803937912,
-0.10678328573703766,
0.27290868759155273,
-0.16642342507839203,
-0.10990998148918152,
-0.5427194833755493,
0.3452840745449066,
0.5356544852256775,
-0.5417440533638,
-0.17842140793800354,
0.5044830441474915,
0.6268210411071777,
-0.5280497074127197,
0.8961251378059387,
-0.37468814849853516,
-0.6782714128494263,
1.1264398097991943,
0.15900841355323792,
0.7692826986312866,
-0.09890549629926682,
0.36062055826187134,
0.6537495851516724,
0.5379579067230225,
0.27332571148872375,
0.4340294599533081,
-0.04254388436675072,
-0.8468626141548157,
-0.26844799518585205,
-0.5756469368934631,
-0.2800901532173157,
-0.04782688617706299,
-0.8258536458015442,
0.5099548101425171,
-0.3785998225212097,
0.277073472738266,
-0.22512052953243256,
0.33544284105300903,
-0.7786831259727478,
0.040424514561891556,
0.05787557736039162,
1.1316248178482056,
-0.8048123717308044,
0.8962031006813049,
0.7171819806098938,
-0.2983566224575043,
-0.5732996463775635,
-0.43544328212738037,
-0.29522454738616943,
-0.9462872743606567,
0.7891557812690735,
0.07056999206542969,
-0.1553560346364975,
0.014876098372042179,
-0.7317764163017273,
-0.49869298934936523,
0.8051481246948242,
0.17007596790790558,
-0.530929684638977,
0.09232636541128159,
0.17212539911270142,
0.43621858954429626,
-0.6078191995620728,
0.22892293334007263,
0.6871901750564575,
0.25860005617141724,
-0.3858921527862549,
-0.7448906302452087,
-0.33949053287506104,
-0.5252282619476318,
-0.08657568693161011,
0.2421569675207138,
-0.4998255670070648,
0.7795959711074829,
-0.680133581161499,
-0.28004854917526245,
0.14493469893932343,
0.405751496553421,
0.09838999807834625,
-0.19793465733528137,
-0.010407770983874798,
0.42423930764198303,
0.5914484262466431,
-0.1309349238872528,
0.9065034985542297,
-0.7934293746948242,
0.40301141142845154,
1.078635811805725,
-0.22114898264408112,
0.8963325619697571,
-0.09291258454322815,
-0.030788954347372055,
0.8056731820106506,
0.39585351943969727,
-0.14435240626335144,
0.17516668140888214,
0.3503739833831787,
-0.00833936221897602,
-0.41622722148895264,
0.015747355297207832,
-0.5392276048660278,
0.5911633372306824,
0.3658951222896576,
-0.12125826627016068,
-0.4470549523830414,
-0.04889022558927536,
0.07243724167346954,
0.42567646503448486,
-0.20165422558784485,
0.5393304228782654,
-0.10867304354906082,
-0.7203633785247803,
0.7551409006118774,
0.10486653447151184,
0.6147367358207703,
-0.6176745295524597,
-0.19506430625915527,
-0.5896061658859253,
0.42998379468917847,
-0.14193300902843475,
-0.7275075316429138,
0.0999111458659172,
0.6026731133460999,
-0.0030039208941161633,
-0.21113619208335876,
0.10867393016815186,
-0.41068175435066223,
-1.037392020225525,
0.3332632780075073,
0.31751978397369385,
0.3299132287502289,
0.24118664860725403,
-0.7267513871192932,
0.18762902915477753,
0.11158104240894318,
0.1838623434305191,
0.04618972912430763,
0.5415685772895813,
0.1158173456788063,
0.7207008004188538,
0.2843327224254608,
0.3694160282611847,
0.22828908264636993,
-0.15164828300476074,
0.6824752688407898,
-0.5231581330299377,
-0.33091670274734497,
-0.4656384587287903,
0.28419414162635803,
0.3322441279888153,
-0.6346827745437622,
0.7031229138374329,
0.718948483467102,
0.9647945165634155,
0.14318183064460754,
0.8760564923286438,
-0.3083294630050659,
0.32167288661003113,
-0.3555416166782379,
0.5119853615760803,
-0.41215381026268005,
0.12761402130126953,
-0.24941696226596832,
-0.9461657404899597,
-0.16573038697242737,
0.6836729645729065,
-0.3981613218784332,
-0.06087939813733101,
0.6993692517280579,
1.10395348072052,
-0.008769311010837555,
-0.26542583107948303,
0.3637988269329071,
0.25730985403060913,
0.20501793920993805,
0.9784208536148071,
0.5817497372627258,
-0.4768214523792267,
0.919419527053833,
-0.1967923492193222,
-0.5625391006469727,
-0.20627087354660034,
-0.7915062308311462,
-0.9073660969734192,
-0.5205492973327637,
-0.1427532583475113,
-0.16272349655628204,
0.037977878004312515,
0.7911777496337891,
0.41044485569000244,
-1.161868691444397,
-0.6363632082939148,
-0.16395734250545502,
0.2842200696468353,
-0.1444292664527893,
-0.13150449097156525,
0.15187504887580872,
-0.8013449311256409,
-0.5283902883529663,
0.256062775850296,
0.016716523095965385,
-0.4037564992904663,
-0.47130024433135986,
-0.3581213355064392,
0.08407320082187653,
0.040826909244060516,
0.19032369554042816,
0.26626527309417725,
-0.30518364906311035,
-0.045652929693460464,
0.3052721321582794,
-0.17148800194263458,
0.2366599589586258,
1.1522806882858276,
-0.6624797582626343,
0.5475248694419861,
0.4874518811702728,
0.39116010069847107,
-0.12126590311527252,
-0.04236462339758873,
0.8131899833679199,
-0.46879637241363525,
0.3005119562149048,
0.2785925269126892,
0.5089616775512695,
0.22185368835926056,
-0.17854268848896027,
0.4689188599586487,
-0.02319147065281868,
-0.6731407046318054,
-0.7483397126197815,
0.2590424716472626,
-0.40959081053733826,
-0.2939784526824951,
1.2302367687225342,
-0.1868358701467514,
-0.327970027923584,
-0.1473272293806076,
0.05777986720204353,
-0.12760956585407257,
-0.1630774736404419,
0.7140388488769531,
0.6257036328315735,
-0.025298966094851494,
0.03114519827067852,
-0.7231127023696899,
0.6955249309539795,
0.25870460271835327,
-0.7087709903717041,
0.33332857489585876,
0.5210288166999817,
0.2633947432041168,
0.0045812069438397884,
0.5563852787017822,
-0.04585891216993332,
0.6933058500289917,
0.19569815695285797,
0.4688621163368225,
0.04698306322097778,
-0.7516574263572693,
-0.3950746953487396,
-0.18188872933387756,
0.13180020451545715,
-0.009567774832248688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13220v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13220v1 | How Easy is It to Fool Your Multimodal LLMs? An Empirical Analysis on Deceptive Prompts | 2024-02-20T18:31:27 | 2024-02-20T18:31:27 | Yusu Qian, Haotian Zhang, Yinfei Yang, Zhe Gan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | The remarkable advancements in Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have
not rendered them immune to challenges, particularly in the context of handling
deceptive information in prompts, thus producing hallucinated responses under
such conditions. To quantitatively assess this vulnerability, we present
MAD-Bench, a carefully curated benchmark that contains 850 test samples divided
into 6 categories, such as non-existent objects, count of objects, spatial
relationship, and visual confusion. We provide a comprehensive analysis of
popular MLLMs, ranging from GPT-4V, Gemini-Pro, to open-sourced models, such as
LLaVA-1.5 and CogVLM. Empirically, we observe significant performance gaps
between GPT-4V and other models; and previous robust instruction-tuned models,
such as LRV-Instruction and LLaVA-RLHF, are not effective on this new
benchmark. While GPT-4V achieves 75.02% accuracy on MAD-Bench, the accuracy of
any other model in our experiments ranges from 5% to 35%. We further propose a
remedy that adds an additional paragraph to the deceptive prompts to encourage
models to think twice before answering the question. Surprisingly, this simple
method can even double the accuracy; however, the absolute numbers are still
too low to be satisfactory. We hope MAD-Bench can serve as a valuable benchmark
to stimulate further research to enhance models' resilience against deceptive
prompts. | [
-0.2831524610519409,
-0.8621737360954285,
0.875404953956604,
0.23644298315048218,
0.04268193617463112,
0.015443161129951477,
0.05524751916527748,
-0.2805832624435425,
-0.3656805753707886,
0.375828355550766,
-0.8581674098968506,
-0.41135793924331665,
-0.6076939105987549,
0.27867767214775085,
-0.4662935137748718,
0.6466529369354248,
0.10975279659032822,
0.24396178126335144,
-0.3711091876029968,
-0.23371222615242004,
-0.7649380564689636,
-0.7078709602355957,
-0.2832551598548889,
-0.02420177310705185,
0.5914985537528992,
0.06166769936680794,
0.45415809750556946,
0.18989619612693787,
0.5133113861083984,
0.2713330090045929,
0.2306612879037857,
0.40764155983924866,
-0.5201204419136047,
0.38135066628456116,
-0.053833942860364914,
-0.6999662518501282,
-0.10390176624059677,
0.13720963895320892,
0.28425726294517517,
0.4045248329639435,
-0.17373207211494446,
0.10600873082876205,
-0.03009754978120327,
0.6751182079315186,
-0.7281515002250671,
0.08142790198326111,
-0.9106932282447815,
-0.07701001316308975,
-0.100672647356987,
-0.11678258329629898,
-0.8127754926681519,
-0.24953430891036987,
-0.2085035890340805,
-0.3854494094848633,
0.24001279473304749,
0.29573407769203186,
0.7851356267929077,
0.49634042382240295,
-0.4214768707752228,
-0.1890156865119934,
-0.5516433119773865,
0.7807289361953735,
-0.5840067863464355,
0.3790110647678375,
0.4494835436344147,
0.6513823866844177,
-0.3065546154975891,
-0.5897619724273682,
-0.43307143449783325,
-0.8005803823471069,
0.17774032056331635,
0.0418715663254261,
-0.443159282207489,
-0.13117563724517822,
0.5354081988334656,
0.0025464098434895277,
-0.6077040433883667,
-0.0322873480618,
-0.06560332328081131,
-0.439270943403244,
0.39444372057914734,
0.5247734189033508,
0.22771528363227844,
-0.07037006318569183,
-0.5157872438430786,
-0.33893340826034546,
-0.7162346243858337,
-0.04644099622964859,
0.4717119038105011,
0.34015050530433655,
-0.07786109298467636,
0.7845667004585266,
0.07333903759717941,
0.7616667747497559,
0.12279430776834488,
-0.40850335359573364,
0.17648546397686005,
-0.4085201919078827,
-0.11223258078098297,
-0.025630079209804535,
0.69964599609375,
0.3940858840942383,
0.49544477462768555,
-0.07487889379262924,
-0.4967108368873596,
0.3859780430793762,
0.38754963874816895,
-0.7042730450630188,
-0.24536724388599396,
0.30077117681503296,
-0.2828230559825897,
-0.17175497114658356,
-0.20851771533489227,
-0.6835228204727173,
-1.04475736618042,
-0.2200010120868683,
0.6923303604125977,
-0.7456824779510498,
-0.14506790041923523,
0.04688122123479843,
-0.1253359019756317,
0.15912342071533203,
0.5102708339691162,
-0.5242708921432495,
0.1428055465221405,
0.5259858965873718,
0.8857985138893127,
-0.324745237827301,
-0.41909533739089966,
-0.48516929149627686,
-0.059737756848335266,
-0.2539210021495819,
0.9272188544273376,
-0.5890020132064819,
-0.44068217277526855,
-0.2071901261806488,
0.020782064646482468,
-0.30699580907821655,
-0.5186379551887512,
0.5142534971237183,
-0.2771605849266052,
0.08316338807344437,
-0.520291268825531,
-0.20349448919296265,
-0.19646163284778595,
0.707169771194458,
-0.6365339756011963,
0.8770197629928589,
0.03003004565834999,
-0.8175042271614075,
0.11694025993347168,
-0.22463595867156982,
0.01550973393023014,
-0.45533648133277893,
-0.39050963521003723,
-0.20187726616859436,
0.22773751616477966,
0.382699579000473,
0.2728005051612854,
-0.18341520428657532,
0.3256484866142273,
-0.5172326564788818,
-0.38676801323890686,
0.7544463276863098,
-1.240234136581421,
0.6961169242858887,
0.1593543142080307,
-0.2898362874984741,
0.1376553177833557,
-0.7983700037002563,
-0.22027716040611267,
0.2608342170715332,
-0.040577877312898636,
-0.2903709411621094,
-0.3157435953617096,
-0.24512600898742676,
0.2802093029022217,
0.18631801009178162,
-0.34651684761047363,
0.2424178123474121,
-0.13488522171974182,
-0.041875675320625305,
0.9846805334091187,
-0.028279637917876244,
-0.10559543967247009,
-0.5656489133834839,
0.5710420608520508,
0.2923981845378876,
0.21512176096439362,
-0.3217315375804901,
-0.5997578501701355,
-0.4700120687484741,
-0.5460037589073181,
0.23490917682647705,
0.6002551317214966,
-0.7495471239089966,
-0.23639309406280518,
-0.07892286032438278,
-0.5754807591438293,
-0.7236512303352356,
0.03668234497308731,
0.4231383800506592,
0.43783363699913025,
0.2249375283718109,
-0.09221301972866058,
-0.36748170852661133,
-1.111480951309204,
-0.5435527563095093,
-0.12027789652347565,
-0.06536521762609482,
0.3327510952949524,
0.5646723508834839,
-0.16934971511363983,
0.5949280261993408,
-0.23471654951572418,
-0.02374875545501709,
-0.002779316157102585,
0.2844199240207672,
0.20747153460979462,
0.1450701355934143,
0.5363022089004517,
-0.6040762662887573,
-0.31682389974594116,
-0.32687535881996155,
-0.6590793132781982,
-0.22277511656284332,
-0.2665077745914459,
0.09630550444126129,
0.3733676075935364,
0.22890202701091766,
-0.9566954374313354,
0.294709175825119,
0.5865137577056885,
-0.4575975239276886,
1.013571858406067,
-0.2225140929222107,
0.3321313261985779,
-0.706162691116333,
0.0032275966368615627,
-0.07190466672182083,
-0.131983682513237,
-0.51715087890625,
0.031974758952856064,
0.2582169473171234,
0.09193209558725357,
-0.4736214876174927,
0.39307713508605957,
-0.540626585483551,
0.022441215813159943,
-0.18164797127246857,
0.13378018140792847,
0.04597115144133568,
0.5631377100944519,
-0.5589647889137268,
0.9899042248725891,
0.5810582637786865,
-0.640514075756073,
0.44588273763656616,
-0.07548236101865768,
-0.5390626192092896,
0.795885443687439,
-0.5458029508590698,
0.1352091133594513,
-0.37974870204925537,
0.15126697719097137,
-1.2272483110427856,
-0.32168087363243103,
0.4930459260940552,
-0.3462202250957489,
0.4174479842185974,
0.09150291979312897,
-0.5957415103912354,
-0.346583753824234,
-0.4353051781654358,
0.24780236184597015,
0.3467087149620056,
-0.5087193250656128,
0.6879982948303223,
-0.008774288929998875,
0.050500962883234024,
-0.7217772603034973,
-0.7206023931503296,
0.15669776499271393,
-0.29821228981018066,
-0.5069769024848938,
-0.04494664818048477,
-0.4354727268218994,
-0.5206860303878784,
-0.3308245837688446,
-0.27797797322273254,
0.21729470789432526,
0.09131471067667007,
0.4366742968559265,
0.25819066166877747,
-0.21031443774700165,
0.0458003431558609,
-0.29834622144699097,
0.08504640311002731,
0.3749152421951294,
0.22467410564422607,
0.6408069133758545,
-0.23184466361999512,
-0.9937494993209839,
-0.44726142287254333,
0.20059417188167572,
1.0423176288604736,
0.011549083516001701,
0.603868842124939,
0.6045936346054077,
-0.1844925731420517,
-0.0004842895723413676,
-0.7455419301986694,
-0.239619642496109,
-0.4669681787490845,
0.2542264461517334,
-0.6861100196838379,
-0.4278576076030731,
0.529721200466156,
0.04161369055509567,
0.04092492163181305,
0.13218185305595398,
0.7458337545394897,
0.21299287676811218,
1.490333080291748,
0.2801196873188019,
0.2291373461484909,
0.20815661549568176,
0.18410927057266235,
0.008866057731211185,
-0.5653624534606934,
-0.5579302906990051,
-0.42167729139328003,
-0.3152105510234833,
-0.44036757946014404,
-0.5432776808738708,
0.4383311867713928,
-0.2240208387374878,
-0.3008071482181549,
-0.015902535989880562,
-0.38887083530426025,
0.2549017369747162,
0.6178280711174011,
0.13930124044418335,
0.33143889904022217,
-0.03315899148583412,
-0.2545979619026184,
-0.2450185865163803,
-0.5033753514289856,
-0.3374570310115814,
1.1446291208267212,
0.3696516454219818,
1.0793174505233765,
0.3991573750972748,
0.26221445202827454,
0.225930318236351,
0.3022618591785431,
-0.6610163450241089,
0.5270274877548218,
0.3236677944660187,
-0.7955097556114197,
0.01940711960196495,
-0.2885432839393616,
-0.7530614733695984,
0.5380726456642151,
-0.11548446863889694,
-0.7059129476547241,
0.15252235531806946,
0.010217219591140747,
-0.4344140589237213,
0.1609308123588562,
-0.9766774773597717,
0.7110623717308044,
-0.5317659378051758,
-0.5203195810317993,
0.0717417299747467,
-0.5115908980369568,
0.8404501676559448,
-0.3193124830722809,
0.25192633271217346,
-0.36873504519462585,
-0.1506422460079193,
0.4390546977519989,
-0.0672561302781105,
1.1472349166870117,
-0.19103989005088806,
-0.31654587388038635,
0.1349155753850937,
0.3689558804035187,
0.8780686259269714,
-0.03257023170590401,
0.03364420309662819,
-0.005581258796155453,
0.05680865794420242,
-0.3509661555290222,
-0.7531409859657288,
0.7984138131141663,
-0.676112174987793,
-0.9684353470802307,
-0.4995494484901428,
-0.873324990272522,
-0.6466687917709351,
0.03262977674603462,
0.07366771250963211,
0.5259668827056885,
0.008256151340901852,
0.021494923159480095,
0.854793906211853,
-0.22742560505867004,
0.3520621657371521,
0.6239088773727417,
-0.2162230759859085,
-0.31137675046920776,
0.812592089176178,
-0.01195960957556963,
0.294119656085968,
0.1384950578212738,
0.2263627052307129,
-0.538386344909668,
-0.5329636931419373,
-0.4847383201122284,
0.2376091182231903,
-0.7578178644180298,
-0.19146455824375153,
-0.7609776854515076,
0.08016049116849899,
-0.42037832736968994,
0.3168078362941742,
-0.336564302444458,
-0.22727437317371368,
-0.20127201080322266,
-0.029576433822512627,
0.32750675082206726,
0.6669074296951294,
0.06086016446352005,
-0.028105244040489197,
-0.7484630942344666,
0.3826766014099121,
0.35321685671806335,
0.1081569567322731,
-0.015607216395437717,
-0.7612439393997192,
0.24306602776050568,
0.2667762041091919,
-0.33658722043037415,
-1.135023832321167,
0.40249913930892944,
-0.19029167294502258,
0.811235785484314,
0.5121675133705139,
0.28755879402160645,
0.8336009383201599,
-0.5265465974807739,
0.8438791036605835,
0.27741292119026184,
-0.5437239408493042,
0.29179292917251587,
-0.2983429431915283,
0.3390958309173584,
0.5633457899093628,
0.43844643235206604,
-0.24201993644237518,
-0.5141068696975708,
-0.44957610964775085,
-0.48576027154922485,
0.463683158159256,
0.012986531481146812,
0.22105780243873596,
0.10109163075685501,
-0.04658164829015732,
0.48613810539245605,
0.3078952729701996,
-0.8609009981155396,
-0.4576621949672699,
-0.3351977467536926,
-0.24567310512065887,
0.01753394864499569,
-0.30231982469558716,
-0.3552771508693695,
-0.159188374876976,
0.31550735235214233,
-0.05879852548241615,
0.22481167316436768,
0.09998293220996857,
-0.1503744274377823,
0.1573026180267334,
0.31525033712387085,
1.0051860809326172,
0.7185721397399902,
-0.3515261709690094,
0.5732073783874512,
0.27377933263778687,
-0.47962936758995056,
0.2347436249256134,
0.004773195367306471,
0.0727468878030777,
0.10122600197792053,
0.3844081461429596,
0.9344615340232849,
0.16253966093063354,
-0.9543859362602234,
0.6114106178283691,
-0.16362705826759338,
-0.1847473680973053,
-0.11494738608598709,
0.009866866283118725,
-0.08621235191822052,
0.35734567046165466,
0.19462135434150696,
0.3516654074192047,
0.005993017461150885,
-0.6054324507713318,
0.0412970706820488,
0.6286850571632385,
-0.3186395466327667,
-0.27998384833335876,
0.6376182436943054,
-0.12375146895647049,
-0.203819140791893,
0.46263712644577026,
-0.22080902755260468,
-0.383642315864563,
0.4012933671474457,
0.8100624084472656,
0.672247052192688,
-0.23301482200622559,
0.24288280308246613,
0.2434445172548294,
0.6212464570999146,
-0.2566464841365814,
0.1612740010023117,
0.14408738911151886,
-0.555371880531311,
-0.19997167587280273,
-0.4806508719921112,
-0.4207572638988495,
0.37491121888160706,
-0.4522773027420044,
0.05070430040359497,
-0.2958196699619293,
-0.19573478400707245,
-0.2468787580728531,
-0.22032968699932098,
-0.5699732303619385,
-0.1392996907234192,
0.3166438341140747,
1.0713375806808472,
-0.765507161617279,
0.6908812522888184,
0.39551815390586853,
-0.3366669714450836,
-0.5077899098396301,
-0.05219980329275131,
0.3478245735168457,
-1.0806959867477417,
0.4549032151699066,
0.3828637897968292,
-0.21303357183933258,
-0.16907243430614471,
-0.7315318584442139,
-0.7112288475036621,
0.9347806572914124,
0.5308871269226074,
-0.6969218254089355,
-0.08375005424022675,
0.17291519045829773,
0.3044207692146301,
-0.21481092274188995,
0.40594810247421265,
0.6291356682777405,
0.8472183346748352,
0.22024096548557281,
-0.6413033604621887,
0.31382668018341064,
-0.15522992610931396,
-0.15727724134922028,
-0.09116068482398987,
-0.4053184986114502,
1.0665080547332764,
-0.48885592818260193,
-0.3313896358013153,
0.12605351209640503,
0.34392237663269043,
0.7525525689125061,
0.5134790539741516,
0.5488877296447754,
0.34182772040367126,
0.9941284656524658,
-0.08293211460113525,
1.1753180027008057,
-0.22943417727947235,
0.013020135462284088,
0.9294641613960266,
-0.27144041657447815,
0.6542760729789734,
0.7180034518241882,
-0.145978182554245,
0.4642259180545807,
0.6488559246063232,
-0.2938636839389801,
0.6805130839347839,
0.3003779351711273,
-0.20847932994365692,
-0.559032142162323,
-0.047136787325143814,
-0.4716854393482208,
0.2572228014469147,
0.4990777373313904,
-0.15003177523612976,
-0.3196885883808136,
0.14369304478168488,
-0.016575895249843597,
-0.06458833068609238,
-0.2144051343202591,
0.4086970090866089,
0.20898011326789856,
-0.6990881562232971,
0.839850664138794,
-0.1953604370355606,
0.7463818788528442,
-0.642478883266449,
0.0659288540482521,
-0.3200922906398773,
0.1775387078523636,
0.07232604920864105,
-0.49837133288383484,
-0.03823735937476158,
0.009428603574633598,
-0.07738453894853592,
-0.04873165488243103,
0.6338986754417419,
-0.2403436154127121,
-0.5000157952308655,
-0.053779181092977524,
0.8141663074493408,
0.243325874209404,
-0.41231203079223633,
-0.9157924652099609,
0.36333784461021423,
-0.031247718259692192,
-0.3647536039352417,
0.44421082735061646,
0.6074833869934082,
-0.06883955001831055,
1.0217896699905396,
0.6720157265663147,
-0.21668194234371185,
0.2277994155883789,
0.20592273771762848,
0.7302733063697815,
-0.7862086296081543,
-0.052373774349689484,
-1.084139347076416,
0.4264692962169647,
-0.01855805516242981,
-0.2668391168117523,
1.1566880941390991,
0.23276051878929138,
0.4139282703399658,
-0.18050166964530945,
0.5777263045310974,
0.3140830397605896,
0.24827657639980316,
-0.5507382750511169,
0.6696293354034424,
-0.660988450050354,
0.4866155683994293,
-0.07908573746681213,
-0.6844703555107117,
-0.18539901077747345,
0.19073311984539032,
-0.3314779996871948,
0.14951376616954803,
0.8497312664985657,
1.2640920877456665,
-0.001387890544719994,
-0.09957440197467804,
0.6848468780517578,
0.5206842422485352,
0.17745418846607208,
0.6055822372436523,
1.2766011953353882,
-0.17580768465995789,
0.7444628477096558,
-0.1847618669271469,
-0.11074328422546387,
-0.36276641488075256,
-0.6701367497444153,
-1.114328145980835,
-0.37366166710853577,
-0.14521874487400055,
-0.5880739092826843,
0.06931918114423752,
0.6488490104675293,
0.2917741537094116,
-0.7835380434989929,
0.17510898411273956,
0.09946326911449432,
0.11550497263669968,
-0.34437501430511475,
-0.18878673017024994,
0.2360120415687561,
-0.2502477169036865,
-0.6466458439826965,
0.625350296497345,
0.12153701484203339,
0.2916937470436096,
-0.5618889927864075,
0.045073509216308594,
-0.09522183984518051,
0.38427188992500305,
0.6200290322303772,
-0.058307040482759476,
-1.064681053161621,
-0.29375380277633667,
0.27067112922668457,
-0.44318169355392456,
-0.055225107818841934,
0.655304491519928,
-0.9227242469787598,
0.3943078815937042,
0.30020251870155334,
0.5189358592033386,
0.09998920559883118,
0.06945289671421051,
0.40442273020744324,
-0.6633394956588745,
-0.018866965547204018,
0.09400136023759842,
0.31754574179649353,
0.5028361678123474,
-0.20606942474842072,
0.2025090754032135,
0.43043091893196106,
-0.2596278190612793,
-1.2237277030944824,
0.3707078695297241,
-1.0947659015655518,
-0.5897611379623413,
1.4279426336288452,
0.09655161201953888,
-0.4507494568824768,
-0.2597871720790863,
-0.5382237434387207,
-0.05060099810361862,
-0.2593170702457428,
1.018526554107666,
0.8922787308692932,
-0.22729353606700897,
-0.22414875030517578,
-0.8497717976570129,
0.3559495508670807,
0.36611777544021606,
-0.5877930521965027,
0.3185180127620697,
0.6715813279151917,
0.21825216710567474,
0.25147852301597595,
0.2642725706100464,
-0.1393922120332718,
0.28680092096328735,
0.5218033790588379,
-0.1762813925743103,
-0.48581990599632263,
-0.343736857175827,
-0.4195375442504883,
0.37332186102867126,
0.07868092507123947,
-0.26285839080810547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13213v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13213v1 | Softmax Probabilities (Mostly) Predict Large Language Model Correctness on Multiple-Choice Q&A | 2024-02-20T18:24:47 | 2024-02-20T18:24:47 | Benjamin Plaut, Khanh Nguyen, Tu Trinh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Although large language models (LLMs) perform impressively on many tasks,
overconfidence remains a problem. We hypothesized that on multiple-choice Q&A
tasks, wrong answers would be associated with smaller maximum softmax
probabilities (MSPs) compared to correct answers. We comprehensively evaluate
this hypothesis on ten open-source LLMs and five datasets, and find strong
evidence for our hypothesis among models which perform well on the original Q&A
task. For the six LLMs with the best Q&A performance, the AUROC derived from
the MSP was better than random chance with p < 10^{-4} in 59/60 instances.
Among those six LLMs, the average AUROC ranged from 60% to 69%. Leveraging
these findings, we propose a multiple-choice Q&A task with an option to abstain
and show that performance can be improved by selectively abstaining based on
the MSP of the initial model response. We also run the same experiments with
pre-softmax logits instead of softmax probabilities and find similar (but not
identical) results. | [
-0.23387059569358826,
-0.9090892672538757,
0.75835782289505,
-0.044009730219841,
0.06799571216106415,
-0.02968742698431015,
-0.377908319234848,
-0.48378702998161316,
-0.08578640222549438,
0.4867950677871704,
-0.435282438993454,
-0.14495405554771423,
-0.65641850233078,
0.12046486884355545,
-0.28160953521728516,
0.8693088293075562,
0.03389112651348114,
0.04384560137987137,
-0.2937946319580078,
-0.3744233548641205,
-0.6115610599517822,
-0.44463542103767395,
-0.6282064318656921,
-0.15127812325954437,
0.5621383786201477,
0.5194648504257202,
1.057091236114502,
0.4152565002441406,
0.2712341845035553,
0.27455002069473267,
-0.04634307324886322,
0.1950482875108719,
-0.3889399766921997,
0.2529037296772003,
-0.14790374040603638,
-0.6314331889152527,
-0.5399646162986755,
0.17452378571033478,
0.41068097949028015,
0.4503713846206665,
-0.3482803404331207,
0.05594518408179283,
0.21830464899539948,
0.4498293995857239,
-0.8364897966384888,
-0.26575466990470886,
-0.7881953716278076,
-0.020672595128417015,
-0.10883177816867828,
0.044780388474464417,
-0.5960134863853455,
-0.2523824870586395,
0.008481000550091267,
-0.4232659935951233,
0.08707522600889206,
-0.030092459172010422,
0.5072463750839233,
0.245957612991333,
-0.588425874710083,
-0.1447361558675766,
-0.9202806949615479,
0.9465195536613464,
-0.8938511610031128,
0.4903823435306549,
0.5560478568077087,
0.027116641402244568,
0.04438655078411102,
-0.13752228021621704,
-0.611089825630188,
-0.41550198197364807,
0.20762500166893005,
0.1294865608215332,
-0.18906259536743164,
0.07050330936908722,
0.3589232563972473,
0.20097732543945312,
-0.7606626749038696,
0.3008846640586853,
-0.21481861174106598,
-0.21387867629528046,
0.6352596282958984,
0.1509149670600891,
-0.047570325434207916,
0.14067697525024414,
-0.18557819724082947,
0.269446462392807,
-0.8274273872375488,
0.00596124492585659,
0.29747819900512695,
0.3390359878540039,
0.3750327229499817,
1.0284175872802734,
-0.04209401085972786,
0.5220952033996582,
0.03091663494706154,
-0.15662188827991486,
0.44324934482574463,
-0.3813684582710266,
-0.23473384976387024,
-0.1895868182182312,
0.6212605834007263,
0.046714942902326584,
0.7479820847511292,
-0.06989899277687073,
-0.40669333934783936,
0.0013347301864996552,
0.20033341646194458,
-0.5785703063011169,
0.22070373594760895,
0.6748335361480713,
-0.24695807695388794,
0.10523096472024918,
-0.18468362092971802,
-0.19722211360931396,
-0.38491639494895935,
-0.13962996006011963,
0.5833330750465393,
-0.27515050768852234,
-0.4723270833492279,
0.15109167993068695,
-0.021277016028761864,
-0.1502966284751892,
0.25382566452026367,
-0.42294058203697205,
0.24350795149803162,
0.6191896796226501,
0.6498285531997681,
-0.18978795409202576,
-0.41067957878112793,
-0.762202799320221,
-0.025843648239970207,
-0.4889675974845886,
0.7464128136634827,
-0.48364391922950745,
-0.3265444338321686,
0.06297063082456589,
-0.05456610023975372,
-0.2941887676715851,
-0.6774707436561584,
0.6482348442077637,
-0.4330500364303589,
0.15773461759090424,
-0.3512265086174011,
-0.6798514723777771,
0.03329593688249588,
0.3384611904621124,
-0.6463951468467712,
0.7456376552581787,
-0.06973361223936081,
-0.6740156412124634,
0.49535611271858215,
-0.22489681839942932,
-0.3979114294052124,
-0.09230435639619827,
-0.01648385263979435,
-0.3029165267944336,
0.12408944964408875,
0.06187785044312477,
0.3424435257911682,
0.07455700635910034,
0.15340164303779602,
-0.6266823410987854,
-0.2770810127258301,
0.8384784460067749,
-0.6813850402832031,
0.762238085269928,
0.28531599044799805,
-0.376464307308197,
0.016416503116488457,
-0.36991387605667114,
0.22403737902641296,
-0.03742880001664162,
-0.47450482845306396,
-0.2648584544658661,
0.05169392004609108,
-0.2477450668811798,
0.7333691716194153,
-0.11695744842290878,
-0.7461027503013611,
0.17651332914829254,
-0.5148192048072815,
0.3296439051628113,
0.8595500588417053,
-0.18358896672725677,
0.3112778663635254,
-0.5304439663887024,
0.7498669028282166,
0.03000548668205738,
0.3748125731945038,
0.4005977511405945,
-0.6966635584831238,
-0.5976665616035461,
-0.1794339120388031,
0.35576239228248596,
0.9454553127288818,
-0.6364426612854004,
0.03376713767647743,
0.07047634571790695,
-0.3096808195114136,
-0.5113027095794678,
0.5904982686042786,
0.526945948600769,
0.2618434429168701,
0.2913566827774048,
-0.39416974782943726,
-0.3083168566226959,
-0.9973092675209045,
-0.3707737624645233,
-0.23563994467258453,
-0.0718827098608017,
0.5132318139076233,
0.5257636904716492,
-0.09981255233287811,
0.9198324084281921,
-0.517412006855011,
-0.28875333070755005,
-0.41384562849998474,
-0.01072374451905489,
0.37828004360198975,
0.3817633092403412,
0.4089689552783966,
-0.8284627795219421,
-0.3574504554271698,
-0.558038055896759,
-0.1759069710969925,
0.0693778395652771,
0.094569131731987,
-0.04330926761031151,
0.6501104235649109,
0.25358954071998596,
-0.9503281712532043,
0.1599067896604538,
0.494438111782074,
-0.37627941370010376,
0.8895292282104492,
-0.17357371747493744,
0.11756930500268936,
-0.9267594218254089,
0.13271702826023102,
0.18234571814537048,
-0.2484348565340042,
-0.47047507762908936,
-0.04168272390961647,
0.0367184616625309,
0.3264952301979065,
-0.5006397366523743,
0.46546387672424316,
-0.28744935989379883,
0.0421837754547596,
-0.21034137904644012,
0.08357803523540497,
-0.11613000184297562,
0.3312332332134247,
0.05332159623503685,
0.7895259857177734,
0.37858450412750244,
-0.490425169467926,
0.12794198095798492,
0.20953422784805298,
-0.23597948253154755,
0.17844058573246002,
-0.7252165079116821,
0.07861955463886261,
-0.18696783483028412,
0.21403402090072632,
-1.2506111860275269,
-0.06364165246486664,
-0.1701718419790268,
-0.6161442995071411,
0.2415282279253006,
-0.16654664278030396,
-0.4449303448200226,
-0.5003489851951599,
-0.2455766499042511,
0.29743844270706177,
0.430597186088562,
-0.06869161874055862,
0.3709823787212372,
0.3526003956794739,
-0.5016632080078125,
-1.1226563453674316,
-0.814899206161499,
-0.0699712485074997,
0.11523250490427017,
-0.45733198523521423,
-0.07598970085382462,
-0.4874956011772156,
-0.43600955605506897,
0.03036447986960411,
-0.15133465826511383,
-0.12483250349760056,
0.1468515396118164,
0.35607823729515076,
0.3662794232368469,
-0.3682958781719208,
0.28464916348457336,
-0.401824951171875,
-0.14931951463222504,
-0.14532554149627686,
-0.13144099712371826,
0.41419094800949097,
-0.2530072331428528,
-0.47659191489219666,
0.11676976084709167,
0.33824121952056885,
0.6731634140014648,
-0.2577107846736908,
0.8961637020111084,
0.3481905460357666,
-0.3294018805027008,
-0.14805567264556885,
-0.7758310437202454,
-0.12593702971935272,
-0.4587787389755249,
0.23086056113243103,
-0.1832066774368286,
-0.9481004476547241,
0.504427433013916,
0.40048977732658386,
0.44286662340164185,
0.5712806582450867,
0.4552540183067322,
0.01111777313053608,
1.658290982246399,
0.5656640529632568,
-0.06678908318281174,
0.27961260080337524,
-0.16611187160015106,
0.07561663538217545,
-0.46216967701911926,
-0.04475327581167221,
-0.7225275039672852,
-0.15325923264026642,
-0.6407045125961304,
-0.3853520154953003,
0.24739277362823486,
-0.09204801917076111,
-0.2858019173145294,
0.14646033942699432,
-0.18877923488616943,
0.4401973783969879,
0.5504475831985474,
0.036347925662994385,
0.24579668045043945,
-0.30981817841529846,
-0.18183213472366333,
0.1196010559797287,
-0.9021591544151306,
-0.1946571171283722,
1.2852363586425781,
0.3129473626613617,
0.558632493019104,
0.29082736372947693,
0.4813946485519409,
0.1860193908214569,
0.4829530119895935,
-0.7544882893562317,
0.4222186803817749,
-0.21366649866104126,
-1.1952427625656128,
-0.46816685795783997,
-0.6147290468215942,
-0.8419334888458252,
0.15344750881195068,
-0.5076161623001099,
-0.5710097551345825,
0.20999793708324432,
0.2909097671508789,
-0.6961909532546997,
0.11244543641805649,
-0.6947572827339172,
0.8197510838508606,
-0.2489319145679474,
-0.541050136089325,
-0.182437926530838,
-0.5750255584716797,
0.41030633449554443,
-0.02427167259156704,
0.5067501664161682,
-0.08636210858821869,
-0.173739954829216,
0.5978400111198425,
-0.1529059261083603,
0.6250554919242859,
-0.0368255078792572,
-0.20395800471305847,
0.584870457649231,
0.2860068380832672,
0.6453234553337097,
0.0962800458073616,
-0.3586644232273102,
-0.1973111778497696,
-0.14647407829761505,
-0.464948445558548,
-0.33918341994285583,
0.6410964727401733,
-0.6747857332229614,
-0.6958871483802795,
-0.41190212965011597,
-0.2876623868942261,
-0.5025607943534851,
0.1091703549027443,
0.30654215812683105,
0.6999751925468445,
-0.018822338432073593,
0.2495461404323578,
0.8425346612930298,
-0.1571887880563736,
0.3726305365562439,
0.646067202091217,
0.028675928711891174,
-0.3345148265361786,
0.6840000152587891,
0.5266380906105042,
0.5141466856002808,
0.1095191016793251,
0.2566741704940796,
-0.5968402028083801,
-0.8026800155639648,
-0.47282636165618896,
0.21761804819107056,
-0.6405901312828064,
-0.29638904333114624,
-0.7143471837043762,
-0.284416526556015,
-0.5168092846870422,
-0.21457885205745697,
-0.441830575466156,
-0.5798457860946655,
-0.08109498769044876,
-0.3242909610271454,
0.07144488394260406,
0.5917271375656128,
-0.2413923293352127,
-0.27220985293388367,
-0.9074341058731079,
0.2419767677783966,
0.5299274921417236,
0.4085695445537567,
-0.17261150479316711,
-0.7302231192588806,
-0.09096966683864594,
0.25706151127815247,
-0.2189558893442154,
-0.8783370852470398,
0.32822754979133606,
0.47541481256484985,
0.8746637105941772,
0.4992761015892029,
0.21084803342819214,
0.2643454968929291,
-0.3453833758831024,
0.7372588515281677,
0.06543990969657898,
-0.6288862824440002,
0.2663687467575073,
-0.26455870270729065,
0.34438538551330566,
0.7442725896835327,
0.5617772936820984,
-0.5469318628311157,
-0.9031848907470703,
-0.7509014010429382,
-0.8701686859130859,
0.29851722717285156,
0.0839507207274437,
0.2194540798664093,
-0.1000116765499115,
0.29799365997314453,
0.3452548384666443,
0.36266040802001953,
-0.8518186211585999,
-0.2344798445701599,
0.06815266609191895,
-0.031175561249256134,
-0.5730783939361572,
-0.44916754961013794,
-0.09640376269817352,
0.04924016445875168,
0.8908811211585999,
-0.17484426498413086,
0.10528985410928726,
0.12900380790233612,
-0.16505393385887146,
-0.4727306365966797,
0.6125105023384094,
0.7080451846122742,
1.0169050693511963,
-0.26574641466140747,
0.31010863184928894,
0.4060550332069397,
-0.41970446705818176,
0.13202224671840668,
-0.07563840597867966,
-0.19467690587043762,
-0.13104529678821564,
0.3643057942390442,
0.40741226077079773,
-0.09741207957267761,
-0.9509212374687195,
0.6525688767433167,
-0.009322501718997955,
-0.22395485639572144,
-0.3260791003704071,
0.22944341599941254,
0.05535731464624405,
0.21012017130851746,
0.5035490989685059,
0.227353036403656,
0.14513938128948212,
-0.6749350428581238,
0.26895368099212646,
0.6366270780563354,
-0.2976011633872986,
-0.07217516750097275,
0.5947263240814209,
0.07964235544204712,
-0.16969917714595795,
0.5895512104034424,
-0.16524699330329895,
-0.7602705955505371,
0.6740472316741943,
0.41279715299606323,
0.6944466829299927,
-0.297579824924469,
0.3791815936565399,
0.5036529898643494,
0.49867865443229675,
-0.3223519027233124,
0.4192202389240265,
0.3681544065475464,
-0.8604930639266968,
-0.8698492050170898,
-0.5269524455070496,
-0.451523095369339,
0.2939963638782501,
-0.31804633140563965,
-0.04863628000020981,
-0.22375521063804626,
-0.4462699294090271,
-0.11233916878700256,
0.22982431948184967,
-0.5841029286384583,
0.3385794460773468,
0.2775179147720337,
0.9916124939918518,
-0.9956603050231934,
0.6185694932937622,
0.4734094738960266,
-0.282296746969223,
-0.8621093034744263,
-0.17380796372890472,
0.1371777206659317,
-0.6009514331817627,
0.24766132235527039,
0.12473982572555542,
-0.13147218525409698,
-0.28161701560020447,
-0.7451395392417908,
-1.0550727844238281,
0.6000577211380005,
0.29978474974632263,
-0.6028440594673157,
0.3193107545375824,
0.14676526188850403,
0.371791273355484,
-0.07148687541484833,
0.3621828556060791,
0.33143481612205505,
0.3890848457813263,
0.0961940661072731,
-1.177676796913147,
0.04127343371510506,
-0.1497269719839096,
-0.33748018741607666,
0.12065411359071732,
-0.4387422204017639,
0.937741219997406,
-0.8003889322280884,
-0.16175410151481628,
0.042260028421878815,
0.392844557762146,
0.3769163191318512,
0.4448937773704529,
0.8540248274803162,
0.4156198799610138,
0.5197394490242004,
0.15422432124614716,
0.9031049013137817,
-0.10403351485729218,
0.20675180852413177,
1.0327837467193604,
-0.4222732186317444,
1.2230195999145508,
0.43099120259284973,
-0.10438574105501175,
0.15276461839675903,
0.528266191482544,
0.43061909079551697,
0.35689777135849,
0.07028977572917938,
-0.14291375875473022,
-0.7953540682792664,
0.023489177227020264,
-0.19645053148269653,
0.512549877166748,
0.3378170430660248,
-0.1807827651500702,
0.1092958077788353,
0.048456087708473206,
0.01956263743340969,
-0.03311986103653908,
-0.3585508465766907,
0.569419264793396,
0.062359463423490524,
-1.0274828672409058,
0.6223652958869934,
0.018047353252768517,
0.7875287532806396,
-0.5774140954017639,
0.17670345306396484,
-0.2724001407623291,
0.296150267124176,
-0.22586823999881744,
-1.1163560152053833,
0.18888194859027863,
-0.06745467334985733,
-0.08564828336238861,
-0.2546151578426361,
0.9593165516853333,
-0.5646508932113647,
-0.37586939334869385,
0.054789941757917404,
0.9882208108901978,
0.03461025655269623,
-0.22623346745967865,
-0.789400041103363,
-0.3960421085357666,
-0.1879173070192337,
-0.5395302772521973,
0.3581133782863617,
0.20287606120109558,
0.11229220777750015,
0.9673366546630859,
0.6237859129905701,
0.08658121526241302,
-0.043241407722234726,
-0.15292133390903473,
0.6290112137794495,
-0.2941408157348633,
-0.3117710053920746,
-0.8225530982017517,
0.4355661869049072,
0.05611276626586914,
-0.5150519609451294,
0.7848742604255676,
0.6230988502502441,
0.7196798920631409,
0.09753792732954025,
0.8061698079109192,
0.1055568978190422,
0.6450769305229187,
-0.48060980439186096,
0.4791831374168396,
-0.721977949142456,
0.022701485082507133,
-0.2896917164325714,
-0.8208174109458923,
-0.09203626960515976,
0.42967331409454346,
-0.39105120301246643,
0.1474403738975525,
0.5612996816635132,
0.8489659428596497,
0.07882852107286453,
-0.08383896946907043,
0.38920530676841736,
0.3189948797225952,
-0.0035855418536812067,
0.7957044243812561,
0.8877974152565002,
0.023408710956573486,
0.7622591853141785,
-0.1625347137451172,
-0.13986125588417053,
-0.503763735294342,
-0.8408532738685608,
-0.5213664174079895,
-0.4990675151348114,
-0.3250531554222107,
-0.7681453824043274,
0.0056557804346084595,
0.9569706320762634,
0.4307287037372589,
-0.8823625445365906,
-0.07786926627159119,
0.147588312625885,
0.3246398866176605,
-0.48465409874916077,
-0.1218426302075386,
0.05114320293068886,
-0.16469718515872955,
-0.3895084261894226,
0.32065168023109436,
-0.07317323237657547,
0.07432647049427032,
-0.060684934258461,
-0.16934816539287567,
-0.2884547710418701,
0.4706592857837677,
0.5756303071975708,
0.5059250593185425,
-0.45104897022247314,
-0.5074700117111206,
0.3828169107437134,
-0.36579519510269165,
-0.05336359515786171,
0.7792674899101257,
-0.4578879475593567,
-0.014259124174714088,
0.5323279500007629,
0.2646995484828949,
0.2383159101009369,
0.016327327117323875,
0.5753211975097656,
-0.7002753615379333,
-0.0837930217385292,
0.5490511059761047,
0.44568243622779846,
0.1827811598777771,
-0.24148106575012207,
0.32401734590530396,
0.09716986119747162,
-0.7094550728797913,
-0.9249215722084045,
0.3062361180782318,
-0.8275009989738464,
-0.6660858392715454,
1.6338419914245605,
-0.08100508898496628,
-0.06070210039615631,
-0.40431755781173706,
-0.13157546520233154,
0.01745399832725525,
-0.3273923993110657,
0.5450500845909119,
0.6847108006477356,
-0.11933832615613937,
-0.0315701998770237,
-0.9472395777702332,
0.3761569857597351,
0.6742027401924133,
-0.4760816693305969,
0.3254753649234772,
0.7321387529373169,
0.5475780963897705,
0.2227872908115387,
0.8005427718162537,
0.2689277231693268,
0.5051518678665161,
-0.06136059761047363,
-0.1773323267698288,
-0.08089649677276611,
-0.4926431477069855,
-0.17514553666114807,
0.5296283960342407,
0.45512712001800537,
0.03239418938755989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13212v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13212v2 | Soft Self-Consistency Improves Language Model Agents | 2024-02-20T18:22:38 | 2024-06-05T19:50:19 | Han Wang, Archiki Prasad, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Generations from large language models (LLMs) can be improved by sampling and
scoring multiple solutions to select a final answer. Current "sample and
select" methods such as self-consistency (SC) rely on majority voting to score
answers. However, when tasks have many distinct and valid answers, selection by
voting requires a large number of samples. This makes SC prohibitively
expensive for interactive tasks that involve generating multiple actions
(answers) sequentially. After establishing that majority voting fails to
provide consistent gains on such tasks, we demonstrate how to increase success
rates by softening the scoring criterion. We introduce Soft Self-Consistency
(SOFT-SC), which replaces SC's discontinuous scoring with a continuous score
computed from model likelihoods, allowing for selection even when actions are
sparsely distributed. SOFT-SC improves both performance and efficiency on
long-horizon interactive tasks, requiring half as many samples as SC for
comparable or better performance. For a fixed number of samples, SOFT-SC leads
to a 1.3% increase over SC in absolute success rate on writing bash programs, a
6.6% increase on online shopping (WebShop), and a 4.7% increase for an
interactive household game (ALFWorld). Finally, we show that SOFT-SC can be
applied to both open-source and black-box models. | [
-0.02789568528532982,
-0.6082168221473694,
0.699070155620575,
0.3511466085910797,
0.18460918962955475,
0.17321783304214478,
-0.6057950854301453,
-0.14540281891822815,
0.14343471825122833,
0.6245425343513489,
-0.4059545695781708,
-0.49100157618522644,
-0.34011468291282654,
0.18683107197284698,
-0.11977876722812653,
0.916582465171814,
0.04158659651875496,
-0.35030120611190796,
-0.22267866134643555,
-0.35558050870895386,
-0.2027333378791809,
-0.2549932599067688,
-0.4735754728317261,
-0.4102983772754669,
0.46186402440071106,
0.6239900588989258,
0.9558159112930298,
0.7303863167762756,
0.40422117710113525,
0.47404763102531433,
0.310242623090744,
0.27458128333091736,
-0.553313136100769,
0.8589298129081726,
-0.253856360912323,
-0.23288941383361816,
-0.583257257938385,
0.2019565999507904,
0.6236041188240051,
0.6226202845573425,
-0.5314610004425049,
-0.010216767899692059,
0.503840446472168,
0.8187880516052246,
-0.6147825121879578,
0.1344917118549347,
-0.5299584269523621,
-0.28936904668807983,
0.004830014891922474,
0.1160140186548233,
-0.36666160821914673,
-0.3260192275047302,
-0.23831623792648315,
-0.44943156838417053,
0.28869739174842834,
-0.3907611668109894,
0.4777282178401947,
0.07230262458324432,
-0.4377026855945587,
-0.18564245104789734,
-0.9406123757362366,
0.8359449505805969,
-0.8917388916015625,
0.449409157037735,
0.18778300285339355,
0.05267448350787163,
-0.4682447612285614,
-0.46731463074684143,
-0.548930823802948,
-0.5424051284790039,
0.26844722032546997,
0.13812988996505737,
0.15632455050945282,
0.21928687393665314,
0.16694985330104828,
0.09997387230396271,
-0.2706672251224518,
0.04989512637257576,
-0.18659758567810059,
-0.24989184737205505,
0.9258221387863159,
0.18418653309345245,
-0.06605163216590881,
0.041500743478536606,
-0.1134764701128006,
-0.20688606798648834,
-0.6021865010261536,
0.1535147726535797,
0.4109475910663605,
0.5801469683647156,
0.1140751838684082,
0.6147801876068115,
-0.37329739332199097,
0.48625630140304565,
0.3292156457901001,
-0.5706903338432312,
0.3891141712665558,
-0.36850136518478394,
-0.07198859751224518,
-0.4518539309501648,
0.8012431263923645,
0.011382977478206158,
0.3058711588382721,
-0.0718192309141159,
-0.5402281284332275,
-0.14599695801734924,
0.11225680261850357,
-0.5613853335380554,
-0.13557255268096924,
0.4426150619983673,
-0.5211949348449707,
-0.008630002848803997,
0.137077197432518,
-0.5601900219917297,
-0.2916523516178131,
-0.47304725646972656,
0.4070943295955658,
-0.2803558111190796,
-0.5215334892272949,
0.058654118329286575,
-0.06360971927642822,
0.18252569437026978,
0.5650030970573425,
-0.9307031631469727,
0.6525971293449402,
0.7144555449485779,
0.810389518737793,
-0.35341835021972656,
-0.5071990489959717,
-0.6835466027259827,
0.1452319473028183,
-0.5865355730056763,
0.9183313846588135,
-0.37561115622520447,
-0.2602887451648712,
-0.023294493556022644,
-0.14550797641277313,
-0.021233225241303444,
-0.8237037658691406,
-0.0375404916703701,
-0.00006439557910198346,
0.10577300935983658,
-0.273627370595932,
-0.5873050093650818,
0.23593714833259583,
0.37334954738616943,
-0.6248897314071655,
1.1916449069976807,
0.12960100173950195,
0.08281591534614563,
0.5070142149925232,
-0.32884955406188965,
-0.42110851407051086,
0.05534018948674202,
-0.2253609448671341,
-0.4041660726070404,
0.36337462067604065,
-0.22864015400409698,
0.4991571605205536,
0.3121969997882843,
0.06098705530166626,
-0.7593252062797546,
-0.5110121369361877,
0.22750906646251678,
-0.5747509002685547,
0.4089428782463074,
0.26521313190460205,
-0.6193652153015137,
0.09412645548582077,
-0.38491126894950867,
0.37487226724624634,
-0.0013826523208990693,
-0.5497105121612549,
-0.13933885097503662,
0.0839766263961792,
-0.07755421102046967,
0.32960620522499084,
0.3171466886997223,
-0.5312538146972656,
0.5893509984016418,
-0.22068430483341217,
0.021055180579423904,
0.9832428097724915,
-0.3190512955188751,
0.46327105164527893,
-0.5480557084083557,
0.4319457411766052,
-0.07931088656187057,
0.2581690549850464,
-0.1307453215122223,
-0.3917529582977295,
-0.770585834980011,
-0.3180415630340576,
0.4907621741294861,
0.3751713037490845,
-0.4647354781627655,
0.5076189637184143,
-0.1536271870136261,
-0.47759905457496643,
-0.6667684316635132,
0.8313952088356018,
0.16194097697734833,
0.03563910350203514,
0.16060175001621246,
-0.5010063648223877,
-0.12018469721078873,
-0.6997162103652954,
-0.14280033111572266,
-0.23236408829689026,
0.06396734714508057,
0.418246328830719,
0.2587173879146576,
-0.035330358892679214,
1.056419014930725,
-0.2915569841861725,
-0.43153685331344604,
-0.45346879959106445,
0.19100509583950043,
0.32712751626968384,
0.5480860471725464,
0.24512113630771637,
-0.532042384147644,
-0.6080313324928284,
-0.2944479286670685,
-0.5935883522033691,
-0.09283413738012314,
0.0013255646917968988,
0.09515156596899033,
0.5366463661193848,
0.3950991928577423,
-0.45136451721191406,
0.23546268045902252,
0.7533268928527832,
-0.28284263610839844,
0.4574469327926636,
-0.5738906860351562,
0.39627885818481445,
-0.7437285780906677,
-0.13001899421215057,
0.056858595460653305,
-0.5562621355056763,
-0.5308746099472046,
0.0795661136507988,
0.07336628437042236,
0.26601362228393555,
-0.49225708842277527,
0.5005017518997192,
-0.5426373481750488,
-0.002934479620307684,
-0.49536943435668945,
0.10081472247838974,
0.029550869017839432,
0.404939740896225,
-0.08039789646863937,
0.8731362819671631,
0.26903799176216125,
-0.637385368347168,
0.17800505459308624,
-0.19393575191497803,
0.13036571443080902,
0.42473748326301575,
-0.7713376879692078,
0.5854419469833374,
-0.17588917911052704,
0.15559197962284088,
-1.1261539459228516,
0.032186251133680344,
-0.031154172495007515,
-0.09488328546285629,
0.3253330588340759,
-0.22685949504375458,
-0.49221283197402954,
-0.1426202803850174,
-0.4550619423389435,
0.14554810523986816,
0.5747116804122925,
-0.27934756875038147,
0.9668631553649902,
0.24961651861667633,
-0.14191299676895142,
-0.6082389950752258,
-0.3888188302516937,
-0.03569026663899422,
0.1893197000026703,
-0.45363545417785645,
0.04710124433040619,
-0.45481714606285095,
-0.4060932993888855,
-0.01171179674565792,
-0.2229277342557907,
0.116056889295578,
0.11215463280677795,
0.12646476924419403,
0.1635725498199463,
-0.27902108430862427,
0.22020286321640015,
-0.04461076483130455,
-0.133292093873024,
-0.4055525064468384,
-0.3048512637615204,
0.34984907507896423,
-0.334536612033844,
-0.5861384272575378,
-0.11977406591176987,
0.550736665725708,
0.5793952345848083,
-0.019116953015327454,
0.5900282263755798,
0.13407135009765625,
-0.130513995885849,
-0.35892632603645325,
-1.0049822330474854,
-0.3469371795654297,
-0.5571510791778564,
-0.02038300409913063,
-0.5582571029663086,
-0.9447405934333801,
0.4049760401248932,
-0.10967465490102768,
0.40699276328086853,
0.3608435392379761,
0.4575383961200714,
-0.27525532245635986,
1.2947160005569458,
0.6980103850364685,
0.04728315770626068,
0.43121272325515747,
0.044514913111925125,
-0.11453109234571457,
-0.3463115096092224,
-0.12507392466068268,
-0.5531354546546936,
-0.2584807574748993,
-0.7113425731658936,
-0.3143062889575958,
0.33988744020462036,
-0.08957609534263611,
-0.2388072907924652,
0.0280875563621521,
-0.4427300691604614,
0.5590453147888184,
0.7277842164039612,
0.2309851497411728,
0.42751964926719666,
-0.06325668841600418,
-0.07699143141508102,
-0.08132507652044296,
-0.6433671116828918,
-0.5129746198654175,
1.0861245393753052,
0.24700197577476501,
0.9616345167160034,
0.2939658463001251,
1.1686960458755493,
0.4968445897102356,
0.43580907583236694,
-0.5357663035392761,
0.6731106638908386,
-0.38453230261802673,
-0.6599894165992737,
-0.5814346075057983,
-0.4710709750652313,
-1.2317390441894531,
0.23279228806495667,
-0.25449514389038086,
-0.3831774890422821,
0.07527197152376175,
0.3690444827079773,
-0.378549724817276,
-0.00947978999465704,
-0.6914033889770508,
0.7573018074035645,
-0.2569958567619324,
-0.7354143857955933,
-0.23270435631275177,
-0.2431338131427765,
0.05277850106358528,
0.18762147426605225,
0.07347305864095688,
-0.5357763171195984,
-0.25427043437957764,
0.6007223129272461,
-0.37275269627571106,
0.9774361848831177,
-0.16359664499759674,
-0.1139301285147667,
0.470797061920166,
0.3776693344116211,
0.6244038343429565,
-0.22523462772369385,
-0.20131337642669678,
0.1230950877070427,
-0.053962789475917816,
-0.5743794441223145,
-1.0508116483688354,
0.7532150149345398,
-0.6776127219200134,
-0.9997678399085999,
-0.6458339095115662,
-0.43093588948249817,
-0.11616142839193344,
0.1278035193681717,
-0.310775488615036,
0.3825001120567322,
0.03871353715658188,
0.45452868938446045,
0.7458568811416626,
0.4012928605079651,
0.5412715077400208,
0.8750646710395813,
-0.1003987267613411,
-0.351237952709198,
0.6361602544784546,
0.34806984663009644,
0.5036135911941528,
-0.24145066738128662,
0.3208397924900055,
-0.49752727150917053,
-0.4450068473815918,
-0.40433773398399353,
0.3477657735347748,
-0.5524622201919556,
-0.3137127459049225,
-0.544799268245697,
-0.1482410579919815,
-0.7729464173316956,
-0.09163781255483627,
-0.58131343126297,
-0.2971917390823364,
-0.05807684361934662,
0.0427352599799633,
0.20502495765686035,
1.0140091180801392,
-0.4169377088546753,
-0.06122482195496559,
-0.6692099571228027,
0.3500610888004303,
0.44543081521987915,
0.7027020454406738,
-0.28879642486572266,
-0.5219973921775818,
0.1212906464934349,
-0.05196188762784004,
-0.2612174451351166,
-1.061156988143921,
-0.035554349422454834,
0.4092484414577484,
0.7479079961776733,
0.2453850656747818,
0.03591369464993477,
0.6543833017349243,
-0.481179803609848,
0.5710626840591431,
0.06064752861857414,
-0.9004649519920349,
0.5310993790626526,
-0.36712023615837097,
0.4959107041358948,
1.0151498317718506,
0.0737249106168747,
-0.4829756021499634,
-0.7618576288223267,
-0.75252366065979,
-0.7792947292327881,
0.4255158007144928,
0.08120260387659073,
0.44638553261756897,
-0.03685082122683525,
0.3646281063556671,
0.29009759426116943,
0.18339651823043823,
-0.7717605829238892,
-0.28899624943733215,
-0.16327232122421265,
-0.6315484642982483,
-0.18576794862747192,
-0.21571138501167297,
0.05809636041522026,
-0.00543838320299983,
0.8005989193916321,
-0.5718291997909546,
-0.19838117063045502,
0.27036231756210327,
0.21342794597148895,
-0.2388775646686554,
0.4252011775970459,
0.33405324816703796,
0.5821118354797363,
-0.023427598178386688,
0.3003954589366913,
0.08490130305290222,
-0.4498114585876465,
0.4289711117744446,
0.039563797414302826,
-0.38276517391204834,
-0.20777519047260284,
0.22688354551792145,
0.08523610979318619,
0.17966945469379425,
-0.6740687489509583,
0.5823267102241516,
0.1340930014848709,
-0.13691531121730804,
-0.26674172282218933,
0.5470226407051086,
-0.1796456128358841,
0.3550979197025299,
0.49721744656562805,
0.01605852320790291,
0.23993290960788727,
-0.8325372934341431,
0.4299124479293823,
0.557107150554657,
-0.3668200373649597,
0.0803561881184578,
0.33760592341423035,
0.09647724777460098,
-0.4549858868122101,
0.8450113534927368,
-0.33603692054748535,
-0.2680986821651459,
0.5599209666252136,
0.6708196997642517,
0.7148688435554504,
-0.5590365529060364,
0.46710139513015747,
0.16134390234947205,
0.2625381648540497,
-0.6469647884368896,
0.557086706161499,
-0.03292445093393326,
-0.7138977646827698,
-0.449449360370636,
-0.3522082567214966,
-0.6444724202156067,
-0.02795732580125332,
-0.3283700942993164,
0.2618979513645172,
-0.44250383973121643,
-0.21362756192684174,
-0.4317379295825958,
0.38847365975379944,
-0.6076953411102295,
0.2731117010116577,
0.1636108011007309,
0.7270577549934387,
-0.913888692855835,
0.7693142890930176,
0.3976499140262604,
-0.42451512813568115,
-1.0584948062896729,
-0.13048531115055084,
-0.03568102791905403,
-0.40900304913520813,
-0.05264591798186302,
0.18227146565914154,
-0.18578609824180603,
-0.06961695849895477,
-0.6793513894081116,
-1.2352911233901978,
0.941513180732727,
0.4040831923484802,
-0.7582469582557678,
0.300577312707901,
-0.006624381989240646,
0.5709904432296753,
-0.4201994240283966,
0.47973430156707764,
0.5057249665260315,
0.36920055747032166,
0.1358809471130371,
-0.9023662805557251,
0.1770525723695755,
-0.17376360297203064,
-0.24308907985687256,
0.10833323001861572,
-0.7680274248123169,
0.5236097574234009,
-0.38645273447036743,
-0.019642110913991928,
0.0258482713252306,
1.2270773649215698,
0.9055845737457275,
0.43769901990890503,
0.9652277231216431,
0.1350473314523697,
0.9215143322944641,
-0.05491846799850464,
0.7653958201408386,
-0.20391492545604706,
0.27365797758102417,
1.2025797367095947,
-0.7018855214118958,
1.0300703048706055,
0.2164757251739502,
-0.1507103443145752,
0.8349524736404419,
0.2332901805639267,
-0.15808764100074768,
0.28855350613594055,
0.005387615412473679,
-0.22138941287994385,
-0.6438723802566528,
-0.01161198504269123,
0.007734157145023346,
0.5931317210197449,
0.0556052066385746,
0.0626053437590599,
-0.04798434302210808,
-0.030017223209142685,
0.045472972095012665,
0.38092026114463806,
-0.09008996188640594,
0.772505521774292,
0.08333770185709,
-1.0306464433670044,
0.15104924142360687,
-0.17596161365509033,
0.6412728428840637,
-0.8388739228248596,
-0.2839137315750122,
-0.3976536691188812,
0.2943929433822632,
-0.047003015875816345,
-0.9754913449287415,
0.01554994285106659,
-0.27066731452941895,
-0.17608210444450378,
-0.3525850772857666,
0.9418867826461792,
-0.6295779347419739,
-0.5205277800559998,
0.2458619773387909,
0.9464008808135986,
0.17605507373809814,
0.01019527018070221,
-0.8148037791252136,
0.10388808697462082,
-0.3229362964630127,
-0.5002560615539551,
0.33459070324897766,
0.3840947449207306,
0.11926156282424927,
0.7826468348503113,
0.6465571522712708,
0.0854727253317833,
-0.11413288861513138,
0.15560269355773926,
0.6681398749351501,
-0.6360989212989807,
-0.378446102142334,
-0.7994241118431091,
0.39023202657699585,
-0.23512353003025055,
-0.27413642406463623,
0.8825649619102478,
0.6359574198722839,
0.47956958413124084,
0.27179035544395447,
0.7916245460510254,
-0.05051059275865555,
0.4384821653366089,
-0.26108992099761963,
0.3480469882488251,
-0.5678421258926392,
0.09314090013504028,
-0.12754249572753906,
-0.9743748307228088,
-0.1433422863483429,
0.36874762177467346,
-0.21708689630031586,
0.5371584296226501,
0.4973008930683136,
0.7434351444244385,
-0.08682204782962799,
-0.36943644285202026,
0.5646609663963318,
0.17335298657417297,
0.17944081127643585,
0.24855215847492218,
0.6145378947257996,
-0.10444840788841248,
0.6372345089912415,
-0.31396764516830444,
-0.35865768790245056,
-0.06610698252916336,
-0.9713373184204102,
-0.6292698979377747,
-0.4785057604312897,
-0.5565532445907593,
-0.856891930103302,
0.25905460119247437,
1.2466990947723389,
0.9727742671966553,
-0.8779277801513672,
-0.3863292634487152,
0.2240085005760193,
0.12663713097572327,
-0.6637083888053894,
-0.199763685464859,
0.0642722100019455,
-0.7744169235229492,
-0.6753721833229065,
0.46814700961112976,
0.35065293312072754,
0.0406653955578804,
-0.4630931317806244,
-0.11939122527837753,
0.0665668398141861,
0.4378303587436676,
0.23758716881275177,
0.43614569306373596,
-0.7141082286834717,
-0.3724796772003174,
0.37711888551712036,
-0.42936861515045166,
0.28536638617515564,
0.8691731691360474,
-0.9081486463546753,
0.23346519470214844,
0.3910822570323944,
0.19161367416381836,
0.4062838554382324,
0.26659631729125977,
0.6325451731681824,
-0.4655740559101105,
-0.17545168101787567,
0.2925136387348175,
0.3375413417816162,
0.5062223076820374,
-0.4432699978351593,
0.48079681396484375,
0.15801352262496948,
-0.7425089478492737,
-0.377625435590744,
0.16773517429828644,
-0.9932279586791992,
-0.3833242952823639,
1.4324404001235962,
-0.23191317915916443,
-0.4157699644565582,
-0.488152414560318,
-0.04561110958456993,
-0.1079787015914917,
-0.7003048658370972,
0.9263519048690796,
0.4977504312992096,
-0.1906171590089798,
-0.06741394847631454,
-0.26325950026512146,
0.3040927052497864,
0.5501173138618469,
-0.5693785548210144,
0.08210481703281403,
0.609099268913269,
0.6566363573074341,
0.10393621027469635,
1.2316889762878418,
0.12668471038341522,
0.2620922327041626,
-0.07010718435049057,
0.010002709925174713,
0.022353649139404297,
-0.5629925727844238,
-0.4123300015926361,
0.5440572500228882,
0.2404470145702362,
0.18577440083026886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13211v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13211v2 | Can Large Language Models be Good Emotional Supporter? Mitigating Preference Bias on Emotional Support Conversation | 2024-02-20T18:21:32 | 2024-06-05T13:39:59 | Dongjin Kang, Sunghwan Kim, Taeyoon Kwon, Seungjun Moon, Hyunsouk Cho, Youngjae Yu, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotional Support Conversation (ESC) is a task aimed at alleviating
individuals' emotional distress through daily conversation. Given its inherent
complexity and non-intuitive nature, ESConv dataset incorporates support
strategies to facilitate the generation of appropriate responses. Recently,
despite the remarkable conversational ability of large language models (LLMs),
previous studies have suggested that they often struggle with providing useful
emotional support. Hence, this work initially analyzes the results of LLMs on
ESConv, revealing challenges in selecting the correct strategy and a notable
preference for a specific strategy. Motivated by these, we explore the impact
of the inherent preference in LLMs on providing emotional support, and
consequently, we observe that exhibiting high preference for specific
strategies hinders effective emotional support, aggravating its robustness in
predicting the appropriate strategy. Moreover, we conduct a methodological
study to offer insights into the necessary approaches for LLMs to serve as
proficient emotional supporters. Our findings emphasize that (1) low preference
for specific strategies hinders the progress of emotional support, (2) external
assistance helps reduce preference bias, and (3) existing LLMs alone cannot
become good emotional supporters. These insights suggest promising avenues for
future research to enhance the emotional intelligence of LLMs. | [
-0.7011618614196777,
-0.5589351058006287,
0.7171425819396973,
0.22745835781097412,
-0.29184940457344055,
0.014184287749230862,
-0.6629447937011719,
-0.46286365389823914,
0.5025386214256287,
0.5040483474731445,
-0.7292629480361938,
-0.1554497629404068,
-0.6787370443344116,
0.27319765090942383,
0.03804262354969978,
1.2407904863357544,
0.024112636223435402,
0.1776983141899109,
-0.466903954744339,
-0.2456541508436203,
-0.5066126585006714,
-0.6058333516120911,
-0.9026791453361511,
-0.46002355217933655,
0.6984378695487976,
0.7713048458099365,
0.4428679347038269,
0.20667660236358643,
0.26562613248825073,
0.2806922495365143,
-0.24975444376468658,
0.06589734554290771,
-0.5098935961723328,
0.6452586054801941,
0.15905320644378662,
-0.5844460725784302,
-0.4937826693058014,
-0.413030743598938,
0.21671999990940094,
0.47320735454559326,
-0.4805152118206024,
-0.03709663823246956,
0.2881515920162201,
0.8923583030700684,
-0.5104821920394897,
-0.09951730072498322,
-0.9230329394340515,
0.04932752624154091,
-0.22942312061786652,
0.08500859141349792,
-0.5350475311279297,
-0.12484993785619736,
0.18338048458099365,
-0.3652324676513672,
-0.1364637315273285,
0.07165514677762985,
0.4645801782608032,
0.15723757445812225,
-0.5669150948524475,
-0.402340292930603,
-0.7421543002128601,
0.8630051016807556,
-0.711653470993042,
0.18107110261917114,
0.5876047611236572,
0.22272491455078125,
-0.026967167854309082,
0.07838180661201477,
-0.2651682496070862,
-0.42500004172325134,
0.22505109012126923,
0.14884482324123383,
-0.31613075733184814,
0.37349721789360046,
0.4887661337852478,
-0.04669282212853432,
-0.19661164283752441,
0.4275771677494049,
0.04715467244386673,
-0.09344768524169922,
0.4711925983428955,
0.13902634382247925,
0.11320135742425919,
0.011765604838728905,
-0.005893789231777191,
0.1802416741847992,
-0.6801964640617371,
0.26341816782951355,
0.5269078016281128,
0.19904468953609467,
-0.05371033772826195,
0.6886617541313171,
-0.3071916997432709,
0.18943896889686584,
0.18584755063056946,
0.3652389943599701,
-0.03106599673628807,
0.23376496136188507,
-0.03814622759819031,
0.23112526535987854,
0.5063493847846985,
0.4929489195346832,
0.6796016693115234,
0.10074050724506378,
-0.2550104260444641,
0.2123488038778305,
0.1569075733423233,
-0.9078324437141418,
0.3332299292087555,
0.352843701839447,
-0.6612012982368469,
0.048388443887233734,
-0.10171260684728622,
-0.7167229056358337,
-0.8544957637786865,
-0.37060555815696716,
-0.20672054588794708,
-0.09205833822488785,
-0.4884498417377472,
0.06407181173563004,
0.11054293066263199,
0.23521679639816284,
0.44824880361557007,
-1.1038031578063965,
0.4276992976665497,
0.704288899898529,
0.7820162773132324,
-0.13286474347114563,
0.21267056465148926,
-0.5931268334388733,
-0.04774349182844162,
-0.23933707177639008,
0.9011314511299133,
-0.7270613312721252,
-0.7363437414169312,
0.2282174974679947,
0.04009625315666199,
0.23826034367084503,
-0.4786919355392456,
0.9972602128982544,
-0.10456528514623642,
-0.13502851128578186,
-0.7204574346542358,
-0.4924967586994171,
0.2399410456418991,
0.33535370230674744,
-0.5361870527267456,
0.5881715416908264,
-0.34911200404167175,
-0.7181053161621094,
0.17699649930000305,
-0.4149561822414398,
-0.45163726806640625,
-0.16821829974651337,
-0.22474448382854462,
-0.3449811339378357,
0.39843690395355225,
0.19983485341072083,
0.6882919669151306,
-0.3160424530506134,
0.008626226335763931,
-0.8687913417816162,
-0.07743561267852783,
0.44992029666900635,
-0.28516489267349243,
0.25710755586624146,
0.1654871553182602,
-0.42461296916007996,
-0.08116360008716583,
-0.4732932150363922,
-0.3223879039287567,
0.13975811004638672,
-0.1210920438170433,
-0.4961288869380951,
0.43956050276756287,
-0.08130396902561188,
0.26729312539100647,
-0.01893007941544056,
-0.6624692678451538,
0.1684969663619995,
-0.39200663566589355,
0.35917016863822937,
1.1121766567230225,
-0.060920603573322296,
0.4435785710811615,
-0.1744808852672577,
0.7899491786956787,
-0.14914798736572266,
0.04910944029688835,
-0.029689399525523186,
-0.4687475562095642,
-0.9376911520957947,
-0.03353675454854965,
-0.2417731136083603,
0.0922282338142395,
-0.6016587615013123,
-0.08248177915811539,
0.08878102153539658,
-0.38145333528518677,
-0.4573350250720978,
0.08898062258958817,
0.27150243520736694,
0.417555570602417,
0.1719736009836197,
0.030060401186347008,
-0.7915407419204712,
-1.2420682907104492,
-0.13562612235546112,
-0.28879356384277344,
0.16284357011318207,
0.655785858631134,
0.18114455044269562,
0.01792394183576107,
0.5680752992630005,
-0.3718051314353943,
-0.14543627202510834,
-0.34424829483032227,
-0.30175113677978516,
0.06177731975913048,
0.049064524471759796,
0.6299425959587097,
-0.7713358998298645,
-0.6685125231742859,
0.032281294465065,
-0.26633697748184204,
-0.3444862365722656,
0.18283654749393463,
-0.220786452293396,
0.533701479434967,
0.4055818021297455,
-0.4818415939807892,
0.13763009011745453,
0.8192199468612671,
-0.4012836813926697,
0.3298483192920685,
0.06304900348186493,
0.2323075234889984,
-0.9696617722511292,
-0.17305347323417664,
0.3059445917606354,
-0.18492627143859863,
-0.6059896349906921,
-0.57524174451828,
-0.06526463478803635,
0.30280110239982605,
-0.43137097358703613,
0.370268315076828,
-0.334522545337677,
0.17555317282676697,
-0.44726797938346863,
0.10875266790390015,
-0.20697446167469025,
0.17195448279380798,
0.44135043025016785,
0.22920477390289307,
0.7425290942192078,
-0.42275628447532654,
0.34493497014045715,
0.16517499089241028,
0.11654332280158997,
1.0227453708648682,
-0.8597703576087952,
0.16238746047019958,
-0.32834383845329285,
0.44118770956993103,
-1.0648804903030396,
0.04106013476848602,
0.05678220093250275,
-0.36833739280700684,
0.298618346452713,
-0.2665620446205139,
-0.1312897503376007,
-0.4333193004131317,
-0.20982860028743744,
-0.12447412312030792,
0.3836888372898102,
-0.2532881200313568,
0.8514237403869629,
0.46577611565589905,
-0.42551571130752563,
-0.585482656955719,
-0.6498206853866577,
0.08050363510847092,
-0.45423609018325806,
-0.5312405824661255,
0.11750109493732452,
-0.45805421471595764,
-0.49347037076950073,
-0.18757201731204987,
-0.10764559358358383,
0.43537765741348267,
0.20328868925571442,
0.5498799681663513,
0.31906992197036743,
-0.1652192920446396,
0.32011276483535767,
-0.2670569121837616,
-0.10601085424423218,
0.152542844414711,
-0.04861481115221977,
0.5880411863327026,
-0.2948797941207886,
-0.5388093590736389,
-0.12108736485242844,
0.6965206861495972,
0.772218644618988,
-0.3164059519767761,
0.904221773147583,
0.24955900013446808,
-0.40362605452537537,
-0.3742738366127014,
-0.9517886638641357,
-0.3956819474697113,
-0.45532065629959106,
0.5233988165855408,
-0.18087884783744812,
-0.8325788378715515,
0.5032737255096436,
0.3425266146659851,
0.040877897292375565,
0.11862951517105103,
0.7446439266204834,
-0.1627058982849121,
1.5575348138809204,
0.38942256569862366,
-0.36529701948165894,
0.6291402578353882,
0.04692751541733742,
0.08639983087778091,
-0.8668963313102722,
-0.22175510227680206,
-0.8362860083580017,
-0.3748927414417267,
-0.4457065463066101,
0.26426470279693604,
-0.043814919888973236,
-0.5399363040924072,
-0.2047949880361557,
0.01625603623688221,
-0.31072068214416504,
0.12563806772232056,
-0.08037087321281433,
0.12639561295509338,
-0.00818516407161951,
-0.0059563168324530125,
0.1708105057477951,
-0.33226242661476135,
-0.5128070712089539,
-0.41360828280448914,
0.7442306876182556,
0.7470425367355347,
0.9360812902450562,
0.2092176377773285,
0.4465966522693634,
0.09450595080852509,
0.29566308856010437,
-1.0340546369552612,
0.6436304450035095,
-0.12851548194885254,
-0.4561842978000641,
0.08756522089242935,
-0.3638037443161011,
-0.7889602780342102,
0.11232361197471619,
-0.5645913481712341,
-0.7345314621925354,
0.007514545693993568,
0.17779111862182617,
-0.2618519961833954,
0.2060970515012741,
-0.8081420063972473,
0.4738338887691498,
-0.29362884163856506,
-0.48852860927581787,
-0.23094645142555237,
-0.41775766015052795,
-0.12487351894378662,
0.0714435800909996,
0.17686772346496582,
-0.2211221307516098,
-0.05851510912179947,
0.8095822334289551,
-0.2787819504737854,
0.8301501870155334,
-0.21934621036052704,
-0.06825176626443863,
0.17395085096359253,
0.09880354255437851,
0.8893532156944275,
-0.0253884457051754,
-0.45124515891075134,
-0.28680118918418884,
-0.3343135416507721,
-0.42300906777381897,
-0.5877596735954285,
0.9572438597679138,
-0.7584677338600159,
-0.9865686297416687,
-0.20870640873908997,
-0.1649923324584961,
-0.6723222136497498,
-0.12425881624221802,
0.010137537494301796,
0.19348016381263733,
-0.2300702929496765,
0.713703989982605,
0.919792890548706,
-0.0012192002031952143,
0.6544036269187927,
0.5718101263046265,
0.056391648948192596,
-0.17166708409786224,
0.36963844299316406,
0.1885615736246109,
0.5259638428688049,
0.039234135299921036,
0.4115210175514221,
-0.3593316376209259,
-0.39960506558418274,
-0.19400091469287872,
0.3398802578449249,
-0.6799538731575012,
-0.14998522400856018,
-0.8819673657417297,
0.14060524106025696,
-0.3466183841228485,
-0.20144882798194885,
-0.5919532775878906,
-0.1363552063703537,
-0.3471733033657074,
-0.5163329243659973,
0.5072777271270752,
0.7189187407493591,
0.3704647719860077,
0.02241826243698597,
-0.5616026520729065,
-0.16480375826358795,
0.22023561596870422,
0.2070000022649765,
0.2674085795879364,
-0.35906949639320374,
-0.3821323812007904,
0.009993353858590126,
-0.24443045258522034,
-1.0120471715927124,
0.214166522026062,
0.035645995289087296,
0.7772542834281921,
0.7010515928268433,
0.2618829011917114,
0.5440770983695984,
-0.3806280493736267,
0.8714393377304077,
0.15392045676708221,
-0.8407056927680969,
0.551604688167572,
-0.5663530826568604,
-0.035496316850185394,
0.40876898169517517,
0.3990947902202606,
-0.6730082035064697,
-0.3729865849018097,
-0.6055560111999512,
-0.8587282299995422,
0.6089929938316345,
0.11080337315797806,
0.3365359306335449,
-0.09017083048820496,
0.12560804188251495,
-0.2606394290924072,
0.38915055990219116,
-0.7647644877433777,
-0.34391123056411743,
0.0742482915520668,
-0.08265870809555054,
0.12837716937065125,
-0.4260072708129883,
-0.18532580137252808,
0.30086639523506165,
0.8356533050537109,
-0.3335915207862854,
0.10607593506574631,
0.2352614402770996,
0.43403947353363037,
-0.5171714425086975,
0.45017555356025696,
0.4786278009414673,
0.16178300976753235,
0.06338683515787125,
0.08308660238981247,
0.4326746165752411,
-0.21494479477405548,
-0.031281616538763046,
-0.058953315019607544,
0.17501066625118256,
-0.3762516975402832,
0.0861029252409935,
0.9260333180427551,
0.01650565303862095,
-0.5933567881584167,
0.5798428058624268,
-0.20440058410167694,
-0.06292913854122162,
-0.1743287742137909,
-0.09930399060249329,
0.45337140560150146,
0.17342780530452728,
0.2675628364086151,
-0.03687358275055885,
-0.05750503018498421,
-0.5795926451683044,
-0.1461372673511505,
0.848663866519928,
-0.5755043029785156,
-0.2188807725906372,
0.3798477053642273,
0.43015995621681213,
-0.3978395164012909,
0.3060000538825989,
0.11652680486440659,
-0.6855534911155701,
0.8493175506591797,
0.6547924280166626,
0.7081010341644287,
-0.34265637397766113,
0.2078520953655243,
0.0899394154548645,
-0.07886960357427597,
-0.26086437702178955,
0.018941106274724007,
0.1686987429857254,
-0.8885127305984497,
-0.1842307150363922,
-0.2720179557800293,
-0.5495109558105469,
-0.07820301502943039,
-0.6875981092453003,
0.5344581007957458,
-0.2186770886182785,
-0.34433668851852417,
-0.36117473244667053,
-0.015941908583045006,
-0.7023292779922485,
-0.06980862468481064,
0.630568265914917,
0.7859640121459961,
-0.9057755470275879,
0.6364260315895081,
0.8829229474067688,
-0.27174389362335205,
-0.8965337872505188,
-0.12744463980197906,
0.21979691088199615,
-0.7445867657661438,
0.34381282329559326,
0.06238324195146561,
-0.12533113360404968,
-0.28790733218193054,
-0.40897297859191895,
-0.4569771885871887,
0.8485706448554993,
0.35350504517555237,
-0.7804654836654663,
0.1358460783958435,
-0.05882519483566284,
0.7615441083908081,
-0.7165416479110718,
0.7055231928825378,
0.20401710271835327,
0.5029310584068298,
0.18757979571819305,
-0.7304815649986267,
0.0557420440018177,
-0.22666873037815094,
0.0005235058488324285,
0.09590417891740799,
-1.1023703813552856,
0.4452168643474579,
-0.16019479930400848,
0.10815317928791046,
0.11939233541488647,
0.5079985857009888,
0.3503631353378296,
0.24531246721744537,
0.9514821171760559,
0.22827447950839996,
0.6410613059997559,
0.035086244344711304,
1.021652102470398,
-0.19903390109539032,
0.21818873286247253,
0.726402997970581,
-0.5392095446586609,
0.9565457105636597,
0.8738641142845154,
0.12245483696460724,
0.4874543845653534,
0.6490346789360046,
0.1870415061712265,
0.14835748076438904,
0.31269171833992004,
-0.3646085262298584,
-0.4797126054763794,
-0.6627304553985596,
-0.1791461855173111,
0.10981856286525726,
0.39664962887763977,
-0.405803918838501,
0.1397058516740799,
0.24219603836536407,
0.27410730719566345,
0.24701309204101562,
-0.5150892734527588,
0.6183561086654663,
0.3657250702381134,
-0.8280789852142334,
0.0954541563987732,
-0.30340656638145447,
0.718788206577301,
-0.8107101917266846,
0.10013438016176224,
-0.24337522685527802,
0.06019703298807144,
-0.5786519646644592,
-0.7215407490730286,
0.029407614842057228,
0.21890459954738617,
-0.0583638958632946,
-0.22307851910591125,
0.8199829459190369,
-0.3651857376098633,
-0.10453598201274872,
0.6044713258743286,
0.5427014827728271,
-0.3601171672344208,
-0.12936528027057648,
-0.6140260696411133,
0.1777878999710083,
0.08686069399118423,
-0.7431496381759644,
0.49248820543289185,
0.5485407710075378,
0.1691180020570755,
0.8561809062957764,
0.580517590045929,
0.3562774360179901,
-0.48205000162124634,
0.2792488634586334,
0.9501907825469971,
-0.3737550377845764,
-0.5195163488388062,
-1.092218279838562,
0.7498272657394409,
-0.03595559298992157,
-0.08760247379541397,
0.960593581199646,
0.09748291969299316,
0.4338826835155487,
0.14099451899528503,
0.7995653748512268,
0.04660571366548538,
0.1966312676668167,
-0.5089209675788879,
0.5165720582008362,
-0.5904725193977356,
0.46859654784202576,
-0.3312835991382599,
-0.8905348181724548,
-0.00021501646551769227,
0.4746229350566864,
-0.4468538761138916,
0.17997726798057556,
0.4505784511566162,
0.9592825174331665,
0.330510675907135,
0.24857620894908905,
0.4004102647304535,
0.34684181213378906,
0.5937733054161072,
0.7144757509231567,
1.231775164604187,
0.426310658454895,
0.5826138854026794,
-0.052808187901973724,
-0.19178131222724915,
-0.2532143294811249,
-1.053897738456726,
-1.0606039762496948,
-0.4890710413455963,
-0.20881684124469757,
-0.6821079254150391,
0.08094219863414764,
1.6019008159637451,
0.7443707585334778,
-0.6144735813140869,
-0.16622892022132874,
-0.015916289761662483,
0.08934798836708069,
0.10912198573350906,
-0.18421976268291473,
-0.052191756665706635,
0.00034555551246739924,
-0.858397364616394,
0.12900777161121368,
0.06195920333266258,
0.02561156451702118,
-0.3126504123210907,
-0.3159187138080597,
0.12476558238267899,
0.24214576184749603,
0.4678381383419037,
0.2532390356063843,
-0.49839866161346436,
-0.3335481286048889,
0.527299165725708,
-0.14365702867507935,
0.16488036513328552,
0.9666016697883606,
-0.41446658968925476,
0.47086378931999207,
0.45525696873664856,
0.7953251600265503,
0.11222852766513824,
-0.1420489102602005,
0.6278343796730042,
-0.35293877124786377,
-0.044920407235622406,
0.35381248593330383,
0.7933803796768188,
0.5357432961463928,
-0.6427154541015625,
0.23363906145095825,
0.02478170208632946,
-0.8657901287078857,
-0.7432449460029602,
0.3611639440059662,
-0.8321755528450012,
0.0098040122538805,
1.787780523300171,
-0.0466029979288578,
-0.14386245608329773,
0.06817643344402313,
-0.7226102948188782,
0.05945999547839165,
-1.0696055889129639,
0.44741085171699524,
1.0717289447784424,
-0.4239446222782135,
-0.2692640721797943,
-0.5711045861244202,
0.4115951955318451,
0.6490382552146912,
-0.5374671816825867,
0.2437158077955246,
0.3342483639717102,
0.05670452117919922,
-0.08987253159284592,
0.5770785212516785,
0.21925359964370728,
-0.12390992790460587,
-0.5899438261985779,
-0.11893190443515778,
-0.04165859520435333,
-0.11336644738912582,
-0.5428760647773743,
-0.044566765427589417,
0.5257380604743958,
0.2152436077594757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13208v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13208v1 | How do Hyenas deal with Human Speech? Speech Recognition and Translation with ConfHyena | 2024-02-20T18:19:08 | 2024-02-20T18:19:08 | Marco Gaido, Sara Papi, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The attention mechanism, a cornerstone of state-of-the-art neural models,
faces computational hurdles in processing long sequences due to its quadratic
complexity. Consequently, research efforts in the last few years focused on
finding more efficient alternatives. Among them, Hyena (Poli et al., 2023)
stands out for achieving competitive results in both language modeling and
image classification, while offering sub-quadratic memory and computational
complexity. Building on these promising results, we propose ConfHyena, a
Conformer whose encoder self-attentions are replaced with an adaptation of
Hyena for speech processing, where the long input sequences cause high
computational costs. Through experiments in automatic speech recognition (for
English) and translation (from English into 8 target languages), we show that
our best ConfHyena model significantly reduces the training time by 27%, at the
cost of minimal quality degradation (~1%), which, in most cases, is not
statistically significant. | [
-0.45048007369041443,
-0.24819159507751465,
0.23493321239948273,
0.3990916609764099,
-0.36904430389404297,
-0.15622588992118835,
-0.2959321439266205,
-0.7971702218055725,
0.18202519416809082,
0.29848572611808777,
-0.3193463087081909,
0.09069303423166275,
-0.6859208345413208,
0.11922656744718552,
-0.4278663396835327,
0.6147529482841492,
0.18874455988407135,
-0.25279372930526733,
0.11373165994882584,
-0.5529515147209167,
-0.5117436051368713,
-0.609618067741394,
-0.6513569355010986,
-0.5414286255836487,
0.7511999607086182,
0.5008808970451355,
0.8295418620109558,
1.0341088771820068,
0.3390742838382721,
0.2616344690322876,
-0.033621907234191895,
-0.16140764951705933,
-0.46052902936935425,
0.1654500812292099,
-0.23566275835037231,
-0.26071393489837646,
-0.10222466289997101,
0.055575259029865265,
0.56490159034729,
0.5361031293869019,
-0.31067004799842834,
0.5638113021850586,
0.0960632860660553,
0.7361897230148315,
-0.7641318440437317,
0.18569964170455933,
-0.3517434895038605,
-0.0663013607263565,
-0.3785909116268158,
0.16269451379776,
-0.013225805945694447,
-0.3280934989452362,
0.4472057819366455,
-0.6513845920562744,
0.23048534989356995,
-0.02458670549094677,
0.5757150650024414,
0.8492709994316101,
0.029361747205257416,
-0.24540573358535767,
-0.8195298910140991,
0.5994331240653992,
-0.44790181517601013,
0.7342779636383057,
0.2968149483203888,
0.3460325300693512,
-0.4305313527584076,
-0.7916507124900818,
-0.7011385560035706,
-0.20230402052402496,
0.2904094457626343,
-0.3006264269351959,
-0.6079177856445312,
0.08420230448246002,
0.3299187421798706,
0.23961244523525238,
-0.4911612570285797,
0.07287950813770294,
-0.601341962814331,
-0.3213171064853668,
0.5292243361473083,
-0.32716643810272217,
0.16465356945991516,
0.011293811723589897,
0.010105861350893974,
-0.10438444465398788,
-0.4903966784477234,
0.4235208332538605,
0.1570800393819809,
-0.08374831080436707,
-0.029080579057335854,
0.3977918326854706,
-0.2573128640651703,
0.8880938291549683,
0.3454861044883728,
0.019615482538938522,
-0.09197130054235458,
0.36385658383369446,
-0.6000567078590393,
0.44946902990341187,
0.8298697471618652,
0.0013104478130117059,
0.6106407046318054,
-0.23415538668632507,
0.10438600182533264,
0.4874207675457001,
0.2838013470172882,
-0.8651124238967896,
-0.442681223154068,
0.33162882924079895,
-0.3655450940132141,
-0.011089387349784374,
-0.5585528016090393,
-0.8318655490875244,
-0.2837790846824646,
-0.31638118624687195,
0.37981072068214417,
-0.10339055955410004,
-0.12784714996814728,
0.40428727865219116,
-0.018213093280792236,
0.21852122247219086,
0.2634078562259674,
-0.9750098586082458,
0.5883587598800659,
0.5334081649780273,
0.8770703673362732,
-0.27614688873291016,
-0.1933785378932953,
-0.9329159259796143,
-0.07583499699831009,
-0.2294934242963791,
0.6903077960014343,
-0.4068778455257416,
-0.11964885890483856,
-0.18814444541931152,
0.017738256603479385,
-0.12179050594568253,
-0.6915333271026611,
0.6259057521820068,
-0.3668517768383026,
-0.18531332910060883,
-0.1329948902130127,
-0.32608091831207275,
-0.509220540523529,
-0.1519627720117569,
-0.8693967461585999,
0.572857677936554,
0.09429127722978592,
-0.5394017696380615,
-0.18674033880233765,
-0.5475754737854004,
-0.6165726780891418,
0.03639013320207596,
-0.028840143233537674,
-0.39129072427749634,
0.023038217797875404,
0.09677977114915848,
0.4414013922214508,
-0.6819645762443542,
0.03734540566802025,
-0.1601439267396927,
-0.4093310236930847,
0.26920443773269653,
0.10786668211221695,
0.6405187845230103,
0.5165830254554749,
-0.4837643504142761,
0.19718307256698608,
-0.7802428007125854,
-0.320416122674942,
0.08785737305879593,
-0.46242743730545044,
-0.37702640891075134,
-0.11490833759307861,
0.042184460908174515,
0.5273462533950806,
0.10206782072782516,
-0.6808465719223022,
-0.16265587508678436,
-0.35616809129714966,
0.8898762464523315,
0.3783305883407593,
-0.07814829051494598,
0.6510229110717773,
-0.25624334812164307,
0.5846256613731384,
-0.06281778961420059,
0.284006804227829,
0.03733949363231659,
-0.5050133466720581,
-0.9629335403442383,
-0.24911408126354218,
0.24546928703784943,
0.3797796666622162,
-0.3509368598461151,
-0.15412481129169464,
-0.08192680776119232,
-0.687248170375824,
-0.9658916592597961,
0.1823066920042038,
0.38115379214286804,
0.7352936863899231,
0.4079563617706299,
-0.15764497220516205,
-0.6013008952140808,
-0.8452371954917908,
-0.04646681994199753,
-0.15132689476013184,
0.11277791857719421,
-0.19454321265220642,
0.2111772894859314,
-0.19994106888771057,
0.5119296312332153,
-0.14028503000736237,
-0.4187828302383423,
0.06968659907579422,
-0.11148115992546082,
0.252529501914978,
0.6152618527412415,
0.5626475214958191,
-0.6939243674278259,
-0.26924994587898254,
0.008184718899428844,
-0.4224781394004822,
0.11799264699220657,
-0.13671815395355225,
-0.10023803263902664,
-0.020119503140449524,
0.4551808834075928,
-0.7264059782028198,
0.44748178124427795,
0.755608081817627,
0.022379618138074875,
0.3211669325828552,
-0.0429636612534523,
-0.013590329326689243,
-0.7758249640464783,
0.027387909591197968,
0.3334904611110687,
-0.36228981614112854,
-0.7359353303909302,
-0.17270761728286743,
0.14243267476558685,
-0.33393949270248413,
-0.6117189526557922,
0.4436231851577759,
-0.43993982672691345,
0.08990871161222458,
-0.37144365906715393,
-0.1669912040233612,
-0.2206638902425766,
0.8795438408851624,
0.04811304435133934,
0.9114550948143005,
0.5218452215194702,
-1.0079492330551147,
0.5492432117462158,
0.500464916229248,
-0.31443366408348083,
0.4705173969268799,
-1.0251269340515137,
0.44249770045280457,
-0.05960962921380997,
0.00750730698928237,
-0.858900249004364,
-0.23980467021465302,
0.4843795597553253,
-0.4426453411579132,
0.32348671555519104,
-0.11799205839633942,
0.036762528121471405,
-0.38700151443481445,
-0.18326090276241302,
0.6810227036476135,
0.7448128461837769,
-0.6991065144538879,
0.4384987950325012,
0.7387611865997314,
-0.15392571687698364,
-0.3563312292098999,
-0.5617259740829468,
0.19196775555610657,
-0.1431441456079483,
-0.5879787802696228,
0.45600786805152893,
-0.03510246053338051,
-0.2528831958770752,
-0.1784009486436844,
-0.28024300932884216,
-0.0222808625549078,
-0.07445026934146881,
0.24703384935855865,
-0.419650673866272,
-0.2976643741130829,
0.18607814610004425,
-0.2647092044353485,
0.08808372169733047,
0.01724676787853241,
-0.5422032475471497,
0.4751153588294983,
-0.026205921545624733,
0.22234699130058289,
-1.0066086053848267,
0.4193344712257385,
1.1423852443695068,
-0.6334148049354553,
0.11638757586479187,
0.421134889125824,
-0.6541008353233337,
0.10808062553405762,
-0.557727038860321,
0.04893871396780014,
-0.4395848214626312,
0.30042460560798645,
-0.40259185433387756,
-0.5234692096710205,
0.38874056935310364,
-0.005068276543170214,
-0.09193883836269379,
0.3493960201740265,
0.50469571352005,
-0.268388032913208,
0.7221345901489258,
0.794685423374176,
-0.42081332206726074,
0.7294600009918213,
-0.19325700402259827,
-0.014058660715818405,
-1.057753086090088,
-0.27835944294929504,
-0.7833340167999268,
-0.3100895583629608,
-0.7103099226951599,
-0.19411487877368927,
0.2950046956539154,
-0.3018525242805481,
-0.17940053343772888,
0.6712690591812134,
-0.5975642800331116,
0.1330086588859558,
0.604328989982605,
0.10126987099647522,
-0.0668938159942627,
-0.04116136208176613,
0.4965151846408844,
0.02703631855547428,
-0.7400307655334473,
-0.2263897955417633,
0.6962918639183044,
0.4926735460758209,
1.0457183122634888,
0.059831518679857254,
0.5126720070838928,
0.39549437165260315,
0.15485244989395142,
-1.0512089729309082,
0.2575344145298004,
-0.22243259847164154,
-0.18468700349330902,
-0.5894238352775574,
-0.043335847556591034,
-1.0080803632736206,
0.41517549753189087,
-0.08204801380634308,
-0.5526398420333862,
0.7561965584754944,
0.29260188341140747,
-0.5866052508354187,
-0.041155532002449036,
-0.46972769498825073,
0.8840977549552917,
0.013468216173350811,
-0.48363161087036133,
-0.36998873949050903,
-0.548015296459198,
0.3149215877056122,
-0.1959918737411499,
0.043133605271577835,
-0.29222923517227173,
0.0678880587220192,
0.9950279593467712,
-0.22967858612537384,
0.5680291056632996,
-0.1209285780787468,
-0.2482210248708725,
0.23105494678020477,
0.1824834793806076,
0.4968244433403015,
-0.11259181797504425,
-0.2721770405769348,
0.14464730024337769,
0.16456130146980286,
-0.4179714024066925,
-0.45143046975135803,
0.41804614663124084,
-0.7469025254249573,
-0.6503976583480835,
-0.6512576341629028,
-0.5290365219116211,
-0.07980053871870041,
0.06219470128417015,
0.24730445444583893,
0.30977946519851685,
-0.284752756357193,
0.08468341082334518,
0.7268548011779785,
0.09651742875576019,
0.54290372133255,
0.3307284414768219,
0.145234152674675,
-0.4921911060810089,
0.6622809171676636,
0.171391099691391,
-0.007049631327390671,
0.05413566157221794,
0.3023136258125305,
-0.3640477657318115,
-0.45321252942085266,
-0.5456407070159912,
0.4934794008731842,
-0.6251148581504822,
-0.10394608229398727,
-0.7656252980232239,
-0.057170409709215164,
-0.5836240649223328,
0.22754047811031342,
-0.3761599659919739,
-0.36262819170951843,
-0.6177592277526855,
0.29635053873062134,
0.22329622507095337,
0.5155839323997498,
0.012932667508721352,
0.6008915305137634,
-0.5671307444572449,
0.7612007856369019,
0.779184103012085,
-0.007393489126116037,
0.039390917867422104,
-0.8391121029853821,
-0.3377689719200134,
0.10860247910022736,
-0.17087344825267792,
-0.9191678166389465,
0.5005260705947876,
0.6019515991210938,
0.5251696705818176,
-0.013760564848780632,
0.06004464253783226,
0.7340852618217468,
-0.551832914352417,
0.24876707792282104,
0.1890774965286255,
-0.9430299997329712,
0.369988352060318,
-0.08414225280284882,
0.6116515398025513,
0.21762004494667053,
0.15914811193943024,
-0.9772670865058899,
-0.23930154740810394,
-0.2565375566482544,
-0.242096945643425,
0.5334944128990173,
0.3728512227535248,
0.1501295566558838,
0.2329636663198471,
0.5796311497688293,
-0.09340627491474152,
0.08485817909240723,
-0.07823040336370468,
-0.061913203448057175,
-0.41585469245910645,
-0.21438248455524445,
-0.20704519748687744,
-0.25475171208381653,
0.06128028407692909,
-0.6826621890068054,
0.5749191641807556,
-0.11951708048582077,
-0.0003175525926053524,
0.48000669479370117,
-0.31181859970092773,
-0.306327760219574,
0.16470195353031158,
0.8007395267486572,
0.4217403829097748,
-0.14109228551387787,
0.027431638911366463,
0.01584712415933609,
-0.740687906742096,
0.5321179032325745,
0.13903911411762238,
-0.16209089756011963,
0.08355190604925156,
0.1223631501197815,
0.7514609098434448,
0.23237544298171997,
-0.29710397124290466,
0.1755361258983612,
-0.3619611859321594,
-0.017173267900943756,
-0.24855279922485352,
0.1259893774986267,
0.09745533764362335,
0.2547542154788971,
0.2897067666053772,
0.25751060247421265,
0.33287885785102844,
-0.5505412817001343,
0.23825441300868988,
-0.13491813838481903,
-0.4874376952648163,
-0.4574459195137024,
0.9127925634384155,
0.39015480875968933,
-0.5706908702850342,
0.4219624996185303,
0.2730441689491272,
-0.47284120321273804,
0.7652193903923035,
0.582880973815918,
1.1261472702026367,
-0.8279374837875366,
0.07029560208320618,
0.2560989260673523,
0.3166348338127136,
-0.23936937749385834,
0.3604690730571747,
-0.25133877992630005,
-0.34838560223579407,
-0.1180339828133583,
-0.8243269920349121,
-0.46839532256126404,
0.1945783644914627,
-0.7139274477958679,
0.1220698282122612,
-0.3334563374519348,
-0.2205589860677719,
0.5458579063415527,
-0.3164195120334625,
-0.693740963935852,
0.13774946331977844,
0.18554092943668365,
1.0287690162658691,
-0.5030055642127991,
1.215599775314331,
0.5644819736480713,
-0.3108825087547302,
-0.35676702857017517,
-0.004390517715364695,
-0.42537808418273926,
-0.3485044836997986,
0.2863580882549286,
0.2177896797657013,
-0.6186698079109192,
0.3207555115222931,
-0.5507254004478455,
-0.8722988367080688,
0.5253510475158691,
0.9879006743431091,
-0.9954574704170227,
0.1092541515827179,
0.043119877576828,
0.5248162746429443,
-0.17244888842105865,
-0.774215579032898,
1.0666532516479492,
0.47669506072998047,
-0.0603187195956707,
-1.1064367294311523,
0.035842444747686386,
-0.1329001933336258,
-0.12082920968532562,
-0.16580627858638763,
-0.8316728472709656,
0.7911821603775024,
-0.5060109496116638,
-0.32742172479629517,
0.004077115561813116,
1.0117870569229126,
-0.18827737867832184,
0.03615435212850571,
0.46449345350265503,
0.26267287135124207,
0.9499824047088623,
0.21245740354061127,
0.7916179895401001,
-0.05329803377389908,
-0.06624220311641693,
1.0372138023376465,
-0.24828919768333435,
0.7637211084365845,
0.6391026973724365,
-0.03637690097093582,
0.21596798300743103,
0.7612253427505493,
0.27776119112968445,
0.6824614405632019,
0.44504547119140625,
-0.1318560689687729,
-0.3413572609424591,
-0.295723021030426,
-0.10207804292440414,
0.7112757563591003,
0.3453778028488159,
0.06509353220462799,
0.02474546991288662,
0.42457473278045654,
-0.07455892860889435,
0.2254858762025833,
-0.5021289587020874,
0.7869990468025208,
0.45411956310272217,
-0.8983794450759888,
1.1317139863967896,
-0.15892702341079712,
0.5867422223091125,
-0.349842369556427,
-0.036553703248500824,
-0.10107767581939697,
0.4062612056732178,
-0.06404373794794083,
-0.38145574927330017,
0.2883378565311432,
-0.11045902967453003,
-0.357066810131073,
0.2560388743877411,
0.455658882856369,
-0.6708348393440247,
-0.28877490758895874,
0.27176234126091003,
-0.16476598381996155,
0.0492539219558239,
-0.582190752029419,
-0.5479710102081299,
0.1885378360748291,
-0.3265403211116791,
0.04046611115336418,
-0.06542719155550003,
0.07577025890350342,
-0.39640694856643677,
0.8650507926940918,
0.6493495106697083,
-0.07256323844194412,
0.3548227846622467,
-0.04104866459965706,
0.7460155487060547,
-0.6102133393287659,
-0.7623199820518494,
-0.833315372467041,
-0.19554559886455536,
0.2834300398826599,
-0.2157920002937317,
0.23826277256011963,
0.33905699849128723,
0.5961129665374756,
-0.1821267306804657,
0.758342981338501,
0.35822805762290955,
0.0578983835875988,
-0.3828302323818207,
0.8902589678764343,
-0.28906604647636414,
-0.44863733649253845,
0.06716504693031311,
-0.6456241011619568,
-0.19805017113685608,
0.4957607388496399,
0.22261439263820648,
-0.5453320145606995,
0.6029047966003418,
0.38815194368362427,
-0.16251641511917114,
-0.015457778237760067,
0.4819129407405853,
0.10240761935710907,
0.535417377948761,
0.8776257038116455,
0.6187009215354919,
-0.6032686829566956,
0.6691663861274719,
-0.4119134545326233,
-0.18979990482330322,
-0.26961007714271545,
-0.5599803328514099,
-0.8725274801254272,
-0.7925350666046143,
-0.36456888914108276,
-0.2228168249130249,
0.29647138714790344,
1.01870858669281,
1.0193250179290771,
-0.8806895613670349,
-0.415346622467041,
0.26440557837486267,
0.07741398364305496,
-0.4354977309703827,
-0.005229485686868429,
0.5301381945610046,
-0.23913098871707916,
-0.8095923066139221,
0.42383912205696106,
0.3699933886528015,
0.36529940366744995,
-0.40138497948646545,
-0.15651188790798187,
-0.1870453655719757,
0.22121590375900269,
0.44502031803131104,
0.9329363703727722,
-0.6850594878196716,
-0.2094360888004303,
0.07518051564693451,
-0.4147059917449951,
0.20715130865573883,
0.7076605558395386,
-0.6449911594390869,
0.5327132940292358,
0.5823301076889038,
0.7299185395240784,
0.818161129951477,
-0.1948137879371643,
0.7846157550811768,
-0.1679646372795105,
0.6049356460571289,
0.23013001680374146,
0.47142285108566284,
0.5479585528373718,
-0.5749494433403015,
0.3950689435005188,
0.04187491163611412,
-0.5487818121910095,
-0.6070407629013062,
0.12769815325737,
-1.055824637413025,
0.2164323478937149,
1.0513091087341309,
-0.046622276306152344,
-1.0209236145019531,
-0.4083048105239868,
-0.47640538215637207,
0.6338528394699097,
-0.4534211754798889,
0.9373843669891357,
0.5515362024307251,
-0.06287343055009842,
-0.21475990116596222,
-0.5474920272827148,
1.0128175020217896,
0.148002490401268,
-0.5575516223907471,
0.20208853483200073,
0.2507176697254181,
0.4315241277217865,
0.1014939621090889,
0.6749978065490723,
0.07372744381427765,
0.8478541374206543,
-0.5196106433868408,
0.2666270136833191,
-0.103148452937603,
-0.553053617477417,
-0.6718961596488953,
-0.002533909399062395,
-0.020660677924752235,
-0.9422357678413391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13188v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13188v1 | Question Calibration and Multi-Hop Modeling for Temporal Question Answering | 2024-02-20T17:56:24 | 2024-02-20T17:56:24 | Chao Xue, Di Liang, Pengfei Wang, Jing Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many models that leverage knowledge graphs (KGs) have recently demonstrated
remarkable success in question answering (QA) tasks. In the real world, many
facts contained in KGs are time-constrained thus temporal KGQA has received
increasing attention. Despite the fruitful efforts of previous models in
temporal KGQA, they still have several limitations. (I) They adopt pre-trained
language models (PLMs) to obtain question representations, while PLMs tend to
focus on entity information and ignore entity transfer caused by temporal
constraints, and finally fail to learn specific temporal representations of
entities. (II) They neither emphasize the graph structure between entities nor
explicitly model the multi-hop relationship in the graph, which will make it
difficult to solve complex multi-hop question answering. To alleviate this
problem, we propose a novel Question Calibration and Multi-Hop Modeling
(QC-MHM) approach. Specifically, We first calibrate the question representation
by fusing the question and the time-constrained concepts in KG. Then, we
construct the GNN layer to complete multi-hop message passing. Finally, the
question representation is combined with the embedding output by the GNN to
generate the final prediction. Empirical results verify that the proposed model
achieves better performance than the state-of-the-art models in the benchmark
dataset. Notably, the Hits@1 and Hits@10 results of QC-MHM on the CronQuestions
dataset's complex questions are absolutely improved by 5.1% and 1.2% compared
to the best-performing baseline. Moreover, QC-MHM can generate interpretable
and trustworthy predictions. | [
-0.30223381519317627,
-1.028913140296936,
0.7451635599136353,
0.011066668666899204,
-0.07310111820697784,
0.2552753984928131,
0.3769855201244354,
-0.43809768557548523,
-0.06641382724046707,
0.5075327754020691,
-0.8333412408828735,
-0.10591866821050644,
-0.334129273891449,
0.07168225198984146,
0.04447653889656067,
0.7905015349388123,
-0.11964356154203415,
0.09567155689001083,
-0.28657078742980957,
-0.2556794583797455,
-0.5333486199378967,
-0.5053620338439941,
-0.5675989985466003,
-0.5124579668045044,
0.5877451300621033,
0.028842540457844734,
0.6584230661392212,
0.36981040239334106,
0.007555811200290918,
0.1825517863035202,
-0.15713216364383698,
0.34419652819633484,
-0.21801219880580902,
0.1102188229560852,
0.18266189098358154,
-0.5159193277359009,
-0.35907480120658875,
0.07612959295511246,
0.6172851324081421,
0.9018041491508484,
-0.037676066160202026,
0.4674924314022064,
-0.1720903515815735,
0.5124403834342957,
-0.6081581711769104,
0.27238649129867554,
-0.5904004573822021,
0.046862147748470306,
0.21102194488048553,
-0.6394306421279907,
-0.42814213037490845,
-0.663313090801239,
0.21733368933200836,
-0.6549078226089478,
-0.16445103287696838,
0.06659919768571854,
0.6728830337524414,
0.2975802719593048,
-1.1008820533752441,
-0.16156917810440063,
-0.8175998330116272,
0.654288113117218,
-0.708967387676239,
0.6194961071014404,
0.3546561300754547,
0.7574148774147034,
0.011056615971028805,
-0.6442012190818787,
-0.5730835795402527,
-0.10687767714262009,
-0.006558573804795742,
0.1938907653093338,
0.16833902895450592,
-0.14859753847122192,
0.42381855845451355,
-0.01949157752096653,
-0.7038050889968872,
-0.3650307059288025,
-0.2679392397403717,
-0.3624196946620941,
0.1460295021533966,
0.4253776967525482,
0.1282770037651062,
-0.27723681926727295,
-0.3134806156158447,
-0.14813509583473206,
-0.3524515628814697,
0.5478911995887756,
0.4817548990249634,
0.1483861207962036,
0.20388194918632507,
0.5582888722419739,
-0.43356671929359436,
0.8038174510002136,
-0.09049540013074875,
-0.2649005651473999,
0.08005768805742264,
-0.4322337508201599,
-0.020632248371839523,
-0.244743213057518,
0.34013378620147705,
0.3087750971317291,
0.3228662610054016,
-0.26603972911834717,
0.3896278440952301,
-0.26184889674186707,
0.14056359231472015,
-1.0914884805679321,
-0.26822882890701294,
0.5461156964302063,
-0.07506144046783447,
-0.16137292981147766,
-0.1421319544315338,
-0.602788507938385,
-0.15053792297840118,
-0.3505934476852417,
0.611933708190918,
-0.4351663291454315,
-0.1570032835006714,
0.11940013617277145,
-0.13543479144573212,
0.33461013436317444,
0.4540097415447235,
-0.22427205741405487,
0.005716605111956596,
0.3241470754146576,
0.46751704812049866,
0.6118012070655823,
-0.33119022846221924,
-0.8017900586128235,
0.4189516007900238,
-0.37494879961013794,
0.46976304054260254,
-0.6299054622650146,
-0.21911968290805817,
-0.3543548583984375,
0.02997792698442936,
-0.4331406354904175,
-0.1962125301361084,
0.06201452389359474,
-1.3054457902908325,
0.32298216223716736,
-0.2953321039676666,
-0.5813375115394592,
-0.34886839985847473,
0.8238527178764343,
-0.6046531200408936,
0.7245690822601318,
0.2425549328327179,
-0.89476478099823,
0.06389784812927246,
-0.379099577665329,
-0.15656450390815735,
-0.13475301861763,
0.08876054733991623,
-0.2857052683830261,
-0.5504655838012695,
0.6244992613792419,
0.22043122351169586,
-0.3072804808616638,
0.38628867268562317,
-0.38722696900367737,
-0.17256894707679749,
0.3946622908115387,
-0.3584637939929962,
0.9358094930648804,
0.340558260679245,
0.24551527202129364,
-0.24041233956813812,
-0.6034566760063171,
0.596169114112854,
0.01252967119216919,
-0.6076771020889282,
-0.13115283846855164,
-0.03243514522910118,
-0.48752766847610474,
0.2970978617668152,
0.1672338992357254,
-0.7178719639778137,
0.2719516158103943,
-0.19976016879081726,
0.5542449355125427,
0.5079423785209656,
0.3794141113758087,
0.35317668318748474,
-0.6770768165588379,
0.8053010106086731,
0.18976853787899017,
0.3593941628932953,
-0.36101365089416504,
-0.5156902074813843,
-0.23558206856250763,
0.16553397476673126,
0.3473738729953766,
0.8318584561347961,
-1.0464402437210083,
-0.06747012585401535,
-0.4938785135746002,
-0.6319519281387329,
-0.49760350584983826,
-0.19438804686069489,
0.24941366910934448,
0.8635187745094299,
0.5338799953460693,
0.05225089192390442,
-0.18249033391475677,
-0.4619160592556,
-0.2682496905326843,
-0.5614173412322998,
-0.1342296451330185,
0.6623217463493347,
0.38784727454185486,
0.043167535215616226,
1.1162173748016357,
-0.7366904020309448,
0.2143629491329193,
0.003627947997301817,
0.42725276947021484,
0.2688003480434418,
0.3363345265388489,
0.3886386454105377,
-0.9954965114593506,
-0.2524872124195099,
-0.40031591057777405,
-0.5043210983276367,
-0.028355006128549576,
-0.17144761979579926,
-0.018058929592370987,
-0.2828875780105591,
0.32836878299713135,
-0.4889140725135803,
0.2640339732170105,
0.6358107328414917,
-0.29435691237449646,
0.8885905742645264,
0.033154137432575226,
0.5831116437911987,
-1.2105281352996826,
0.06871895492076874,
-0.4169895648956299,
-0.352171391248703,
-0.6787503957748413,
-0.014846859499812126,
0.3456881046295166,
-0.29340851306915283,
-0.6075990200042725,
0.7269245386123657,
-0.16156001389026642,
0.2030210942029953,
0.0599401630461216,
-0.07897809892892838,
0.5114991068840027,
0.6963649988174438,
-0.3449912667274475,
0.608384907245636,
0.1496935337781906,
-0.8477228879928589,
0.37333256006240845,
0.3705061376094818,
-0.13392038643360138,
0.3571593761444092,
-0.8079253435134888,
0.44293203949928284,
-0.3040764331817627,
0.6094643473625183,
-1.035984992980957,
-0.03464672714471817,
0.27496060729026794,
-0.7164385914802551,
0.24183817207813263,
-0.6856111288070679,
-0.5189063549041748,
-0.5301711559295654,
-0.11876394599676132,
1.0635675191879272,
0.22740408778190613,
-0.35155951976776123,
1.0156967639923096,
-0.042716048657894135,
-0.045842431485652924,
-0.6130059361457825,
-0.509728193283081,
-0.3922499418258667,
0.002934360643848777,
-0.8221098184585571,
0.2571219801902771,
-0.3696655333042145,
0.2332773655653,
0.05035800486803055,
-0.19097863137722015,
-0.19966007769107819,
0.04871000722050667,
0.07040495425462723,
0.21861670911312103,
-0.1906449943780899,
0.26654812693595886,
-0.017235590144991875,
-0.03816421329975128,
0.03405691683292389,
-0.3888914883136749,
0.7255657315254211,
0.026275910437107086,
-0.5669126510620117,
-0.32519838213920593,
0.2273164838552475,
0.7692559957504272,
-0.4324589967727661,
0.8030620813369751,
0.5799921154975891,
-0.3274083733558655,
0.2336277961730957,
-0.5417854189872742,
-0.387678861618042,
-0.4046970009803772,
0.22710615396499634,
-0.5544752478599548,
-1.0049850940704346,
0.6303295493125916,
-0.11957196146249771,
-0.015218592248857021,
0.19307857751846313,
0.1348291039466858,
-0.15657441318035126,
1.1101884841918945,
0.1616545021533966,
-0.011393235996365547,
0.2945694327354431,
-0.26713141798973083,
0.23628711700439453,
-1.0518426895141602,
-0.24844753742218018,
-0.5805356502532959,
-0.16830363869667053,
-0.5508699417114258,
-0.4679572284221649,
0.8171920776367188,
0.4164753556251526,
-0.5955333709716797,
0.05272756516933441,
0.02795969322323799,
0.12159955501556396,
0.6504635810852051,
0.276287704706192,
0.2549465000629425,
-0.3750532567501068,
-0.42427876591682434,
0.14897096157073975,
-0.8351725339889526,
-0.383876234292984,
1.1163328886032104,
0.2467813640832901,
0.6945191621780396,
-0.047090400010347366,
0.22254185378551483,
-0.047271423041820526,
-0.007613851688802242,
-0.4175914227962494,
0.4250832498073578,
0.23145809769630432,
-0.8938241004943848,
-0.5089576840400696,
-0.9409328103065491,
-0.7617723345756531,
0.174753800034523,
-0.054965853691101074,
-0.7353456020355225,
-0.11188533157110214,
0.17974628508090973,
-0.6916019320487976,
0.6571177244186401,
-0.7091177105903625,
0.9200486540794373,
-0.07685386389493942,
-0.06084456294775009,
0.17955397069454193,
-0.8310074806213379,
0.20871485769748688,
0.011750691570341587,
0.19188357889652252,
-0.3933759033679962,
0.28196990489959717,
0.6775055527687073,
-0.3321860730648041,
0.6548085808753967,
-0.30577534437179565,
0.3236212134361267,
0.5406724810600281,
0.31994494795799255,
0.5906980037689209,
0.1858019083738327,
-0.11580657958984375,
-0.2358054369688034,
0.6877570748329163,
-0.5763599276542664,
-0.7559439539909363,
0.22806188464164734,
-0.8097848296165466,
-0.5048641562461853,
-0.2133212834596634,
-0.9461864233016968,
-0.6640960574150085,
0.157330721616745,
-0.09070554375648499,
0.8674418926239014,
0.16717280447483063,
0.04048527404665947,
0.36447829008102417,
-0.38107386231422424,
0.248893603682518,
0.5535751581192017,
-0.3097289204597473,
-0.4484228491783142,
0.5196729898452759,
0.1922558844089508,
0.4250637888908386,
0.7607701420783997,
0.3960743248462677,
-0.6278141736984253,
-0.15024936199188232,
-0.5442267060279846,
0.3474123179912567,
-0.725964367389679,
-0.2637450098991394,
-1.0861014127731323,
-0.4000972509384155,
-0.6968608498573303,
0.2568710744380951,
-0.21289721131324768,
-0.5968276262283325,
-0.1744307577610016,
0.1345212161540985,
0.3696650564670563,
0.16094355285167694,
0.3734748065471649,
0.3561440706253052,
-1.173482060432434,
0.5092552304267883,
0.8249697089195251,
0.24969619512557983,
0.11750651150941849,
-0.5044477581977844,
0.033788759261369705,
0.33599281311035156,
-0.4562218487262726,
-1.1356345415115356,
0.0644821748137474,
0.06667803227901459,
0.3535200357437134,
0.07903740555047989,
0.4053763449192047,
0.8864045739173889,
-0.42300575971603394,
0.6574567556381226,
-0.08238467574119568,
-0.6385881900787354,
0.5701278448104858,
-0.2950775623321533,
0.6592916250228882,
0.4690053462982178,
0.4444858729839325,
-0.8020341396331787,
-0.36330679059028625,
-0.4112626612186432,
-0.702000617980957,
0.5131984353065491,
0.065629743039608,
0.08984319120645523,
0.12679074704647064,
0.5056707859039307,
-0.10296487808227539,
0.4364599585533142,
-0.5502530336380005,
-0.30672702193260193,
-0.14713338017463684,
0.07622227817773819,
0.11438402533531189,
-0.32040828466415405,
0.08781290799379349,
-0.12515033781528473,
0.6046040058135986,
-0.3012533187866211,
0.32050925493240356,
0.21354393661022186,
-0.061974991112947464,
-0.21554692089557648,
0.5082487463951111,
0.061495039612054825,
0.8345702290534973,
-0.4457791745662689,
0.10267988592386246,
0.273253858089447,
-0.24208448827266693,
0.30601727962493896,
0.2576576769351959,
-0.3696185350418091,
-0.2894822657108307,
0.3448091149330139,
0.4679577648639679,
-0.09573432803153992,
-0.32635411620140076,
0.3483918011188507,
-0.02175610139966011,
-0.040638476610183716,
-0.07802685350179672,
-0.0806073322892189,
0.18925049901008606,
0.5146056413650513,
0.40575507283210754,
-0.004405469633638859,
-0.14980457723140717,
-0.4923827648162842,
0.15364305675029755,
0.2972411513328552,
-0.28531476855278015,
-0.2310151308774948,
0.9652809500694275,
-0.17409434914588928,
0.006059729959815741,
0.8884952664375305,
-0.18563951551914215,
-0.8912762999534607,
0.8633998036384583,
0.36138206720352173,
0.45454296469688416,
-0.33503830432891846,
0.4237140119075775,
0.5504165887832642,
0.27738553285598755,
0.32486844062805176,
0.6490361094474792,
-0.020468806847929955,
-0.8285292387008667,
-0.611650288105011,
-0.6500818729400635,
-0.515268862247467,
0.054451704025268555,
-0.6363232731819153,
-0.11204265058040619,
-0.1389377862215042,
-0.292268842458725,
-0.20259568095207214,
0.23367755115032196,
-0.8444123864173889,
0.3864910900592804,
-0.20726004242897034,
0.8872509002685547,
-0.7291529774665833,
0.7572173476219177,
0.6426711678504944,
-0.3024017810821533,
-1.1165838241577148,
0.05386904999613762,
-0.244430810213089,
-0.7139142751693726,
0.3812756836414337,
0.19043971598148346,
-0.06848487257957458,
0.30748629570007324,
-0.30641841888427734,
-0.7752323746681213,
1.508249044418335,
0.2628471255302429,
-0.15262827277183533,
-0.35025790333747864,
0.4026024043560028,
0.3025580048561096,
-0.17357270419597626,
0.40468722581863403,
0.2547037601470947,
0.4815292954444885,
0.44499868154525757,
-0.7452449202537537,
-0.0404055155813694,
-0.18204808235168457,
-0.25094419717788696,
0.3115990459918976,
-0.6476261615753174,
0.9882538914680481,
-0.4098128080368042,
-0.13444559276103973,
0.05353190377354622,
0.3771430552005768,
0.550902783870697,
0.6379424929618835,
0.7267102599143982,
0.5095013380050659,
0.7720544934272766,
-0.15891329944133759,
1.1346253156661987,
-0.45870739221572876,
0.360851526260376,
1.2185654640197754,
-0.16336168348789215,
0.5218750238418579,
0.46324214339256287,
-0.3218664824962616,
0.2765214443206787,
0.7374228239059448,
0.33960258960723877,
0.45404621958732605,
0.09010312706232071,
0.01745726354420185,
-0.4927218556404114,
-0.18042728304862976,
-0.5575355887413025,
0.25667107105255127,
-0.014958287589251995,
0.12216886132955551,
-0.3020106852054596,
-0.08046528697013855,
-0.08845894783735275,
-0.36374062299728394,
-0.268376886844635,
0.383975088596344,
-0.1853814274072647,
-0.6925303936004639,
0.23684534430503845,
-0.08007817715406418,
0.008922767825424671,
-0.7845955491065979,
0.017111532390117645,
-0.19967769086360931,
-0.13176128268241882,
0.22890940308570862,
-0.6123058199882507,
0.06104668229818344,
-0.250291109085083,
-0.14318422973155975,
-0.1330619752407074,
0.4356118142604828,
-0.5018434524536133,
-0.5576751232147217,
0.24952863156795502,
1.0171633958816528,
-0.11883123964071274,
-0.3315874934196472,
-0.6080319881439209,
-0.48397257924079895,
-0.18616962432861328,
-0.29559192061424255,
-0.035597868263721466,
0.5387029647827148,
0.0800512358546257,
1.039353847503662,
0.5371116399765015,
0.0015935105038806796,
0.5117757320404053,
0.19572249054908752,
0.8732653260231018,
-0.5873394012451172,
-0.7192242741584778,
-0.48317018151283264,
0.4160706400871277,
0.39529818296432495,
-0.06213759258389473,
0.3845967650413513,
0.477293998003006,
0.7732295393943787,
0.15903271734714508,
0.4824039936065674,
0.05115680769085884,
0.7033718824386597,
-0.6755045652389526,
0.4236718714237213,
-0.7882375717163086,
0.18772020936012268,
-0.3001236021518707,
-0.7178143858909607,
-0.07121739536523819,
-0.0009914509719237685,
-0.4180790185928345,
0.3535214960575104,
0.7047141790390015,
0.7584655284881592,
0.0503021739423275,
0.19938205182552338,
0.28312578797340393,
0.011244670487940311,
0.5698858499526978,
0.9797552824020386,
1.0910032987594604,
-0.5585969090461731,
1.0042545795440674,
-0.5736081600189209,
0.03732970729470253,
-0.05684111639857292,
-0.8610062599182129,
-0.650343656539917,
-0.6050874590873718,
-0.3175964653491974,
-0.395450621843338,
-0.15925709903240204,
0.6709690093994141,
0.7665032148361206,
-0.7848436236381531,
0.14193445444107056,
0.39804890751838684,
0.20425453782081604,
-0.36408475041389465,
-0.23629166185855865,
0.469611257314682,
-0.1561989188194275,
-0.4335944354534149,
0.1366729736328125,
0.04193273186683655,
0.294075071811676,
0.0677691325545311,
-0.0004605126450769603,
-0.39898398518562317,
0.0492495633661747,
0.5036342740058899,
0.09344316273927689,
-0.4213661551475525,
-0.5196064114570618,
0.4220079481601715,
0.04758172482252121,
0.0349956713616848,
0.798481822013855,
-0.7661857008934021,
0.7035546898841858,
0.48943331837654114,
0.8277782201766968,
0.6198460459709167,
0.28208959102630615,
0.23862966895103455,
-0.8612438440322876,
-0.3040274679660797,
0.4782794415950775,
0.22235777974128723,
0.11265149712562561,
-0.22176428139209747,
0.35134270787239075,
0.1374523639678955,
-0.6684601902961731,
-0.4756629765033722,
0.505943775177002,
-0.8703182339668274,
-0.31869420409202576,
0.9974590539932251,
-0.09208987653255463,
-0.1856810748577118,
-0.29575642943382263,
-0.04950738698244095,
0.6345758438110352,
-0.10755091160535812,
0.6991466283798218,
0.7042962312698364,
-0.13475050032138824,
-0.13840916752815247,
-0.8449680805206299,
0.0167984701693058,
0.3011077046394348,
-0.5954151153564453,
-0.11035089939832687,
0.5154392123222351,
0.38264885544776917,
0.10264930874109268,
0.7813470363616943,
-0.17225787043571472,
0.3532356917858124,
-0.2592858374118805,
-0.4529717266559601,
-0.5233616828918457,
-0.5055410265922546,
0.1937643438577652,
0.5129713416099548,
-0.03227538987994194,
-0.3691745102405548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13184v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13184v2 | What if LLMs Have Different World Views: Simulating Alien Civilizations with LLM-based Agents | 2024-02-20T17:49:46 | 2024-02-21T04:54:22 | Mingyu Jin, Beichen Wang, Zhaoqian Xue, Suiyuan Zhu, Wenyue Hua, Hua Tang, Kai Mei, Mengnan Du, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, we introduce "CosmoAgent," an innovative artificial
intelligence framework utilizing Large Language Models (LLMs) to simulate
complex interactions between human and extraterrestrial civilizations, with a
special emphasis on Stephen Hawking's cautionary advice about not sending radio
signals haphazardly into the universe. The goal is to assess the feasibility of
peaceful coexistence while considering potential risks that could threaten
well-intentioned civilizations. Employing mathematical models and state
transition matrices, our approach quantitatively evaluates the development
trajectories of civilizations, offering insights into future decision-making at
critical points of growth and saturation. Furthermore, the paper acknowledges
the vast diversity in potential living conditions across the universe, which
could foster unique cosmologies, ethical codes, and worldviews among various
civilizations. Recognizing the Earth-centric bias inherent in current LLM
designs, we propose the novel concept of using LLMs with diverse ethical
paradigms and simulating interactions between entities with distinct moral
principles. This innovative research provides a new way to understand complex
inter-civilizational dynamics, expanding our perspective while pioneering novel
strategies for conflict resolution, crucial for preventing interstellar
conflicts. We have also released the code and datasets to enable further
academic investigation into this interesting area of research. The code is
available at https://github.com/agiresearch/AlienAgent. | [
-0.4743576645851135,
-0.9298824667930603,
0.549972414970398,
0.2437790483236313,
-0.015456724911928177,
0.43001511693000793,
-0.27643048763275146,
-0.7481408715248108,
0.3150930106639862,
0.4198874235153198,
-0.7967246174812317,
-0.3752889633178711,
-0.33160415291786194,
-0.03753683343529701,
-0.18504220247268677,
0.6891599297523499,
0.3842203617095947,
0.0028218538500368595,
-0.5648282766342163,
0.0316283293068409,
-0.17884273827075958,
-0.5589454770088196,
-0.6478318572044373,
-0.4066072702407837,
0.2861119508743286,
0.26477622985839844,
1.0119973421096802,
0.394135981798172,
0.8832269906997681,
0.36354926228523254,
-0.2971043884754181,
0.24408817291259766,
-0.6170199513435364,
-0.18183693289756775,
-0.3663904070854187,
-0.4524221420288086,
-0.2068960964679718,
0.3227846920490265,
0.07285192608833313,
0.620708703994751,
-0.08299195766448975,
0.2252563089132309,
0.0019236826337873936,
0.05961575731635094,
-0.12346401065587997,
0.1014629527926445,
-0.4036328196525574,
0.3581893742084503,
0.3262372314929962,
-0.295923113822937,
-0.08011636137962341,
-0.5404955148696899,
0.1962161511182785,
-0.8223962783813477,
-0.1044277772307396,
0.5707465410232544,
0.5680831074714661,
0.6087427139282227,
-0.14438073337078094,
-0.47280752658843994,
-0.9580598473548889,
0.8188589215278625,
-0.4608798027038574,
0.30614644289016724,
0.049494028091430664,
-0.0035496389027684927,
-0.4810619354248047,
-0.43508613109588623,
-0.8656333088874817,
-0.6839223504066467,
0.1343492865562439,
0.44778287410736084,
-0.1376115083694458,
-0.19509094953536987,
0.08237550407648087,
0.11517133563756943,
-0.44918617606163025,
0.21534085273742676,
-0.512058436870575,
-0.03104967251420021,
0.5505053997039795,
0.29902827739715576,
0.33085328340530396,
-0.006638102233409882,
-0.5297920107841492,
-0.06997663527727127,
-0.6564136743545532,
0.4420728385448456,
0.510045051574707,
0.05857592448592186,
-0.47179916501045227,
0.5409224629402161,
0.31788790225982666,
0.13948436081409454,
0.1434648633003235,
0.16344739496707916,
-0.3305512070655823,
-0.03162557631731033,
-0.1848200559616089,
-0.018853364512324333,
0.5633955597877502,
0.6911988854408264,
-0.16794076561927795,
-0.20271608233451843,
0.3335706889629364,
0.22229647636413574,
0.35266032814979553,
-0.7502341270446777,
-0.028358126059174538,
0.43020880222320557,
-0.5907037258148193,
-0.45745745301246643,
0.119800865650177,
-0.7979730367660522,
-0.6580033898353577,
-0.40556561946868896,
0.19955788552761078,
-0.29872646927833557,
-0.31160232424736023,
0.07799632102251053,
-0.013720202259719372,
0.36067497730255127,
0.30616679787635803,
-0.33148902654647827,
0.42709434032440186,
0.8882244825363159,
0.4892183244228363,
-0.16041916608810425,
-0.42740970849990845,
-0.2729492485523224,
0.06279237568378448,
-0.36103081703186035,
0.565664529800415,
-0.6247026324272156,
-1.1303030252456665,
-0.3508003056049347,
-0.27141571044921875,
0.29033610224723816,
-0.3390282094478607,
0.5307632088661194,
-0.650542140007019,
0.10034124553203583,
-0.4433373212814331,
-0.5744224786758423,
-0.4286721348762512,
0.5315148830413818,
-0.6613286733627319,
0.4662758409976959,
-0.20208622515201569,
-0.4438266158103943,
0.1521942913532257,
-0.8822957873344421,
-0.08964040875434875,
0.46835407614707947,
-0.6140839457511902,
-0.4906621277332306,
-0.1943412721157074,
-0.29290011525154114,
0.14499478042125702,
-0.40927574038505554,
0.3543106019496918,
-0.5866187810897827,
-0.45193153619766235,
0.4929756820201874,
-0.2166120707988739,
0.7871835231781006,
0.40772679448127747,
-0.2573012709617615,
0.0407354012131691,
-0.5617948174476624,
0.010733027942478657,
0.19898037612438202,
-0.37885063886642456,
-0.40933480858802795,
0.4510987102985382,
-0.11704442650079727,
0.1857353150844574,
0.4444485306739807,
-0.7266319394111633,
0.08064229786396027,
-0.13553909957408905,
0.12910987436771393,
0.7096845507621765,
0.09104537963867188,
0.6028170585632324,
-0.646191418170929,
0.5041084885597229,
-0.11383356899023056,
0.41824081540107727,
0.14041905105113983,
-0.43601635098457336,
-0.7994508743286133,
-0.06120742857456207,
-0.5199980139732361,
0.837086021900177,
-0.1966211348772049,
0.45938315987586975,
-0.07465074211359024,
-0.5996251106262207,
-0.2605820596218109,
-0.18546459078788757,
0.3359845280647278,
0.10858689993619919,
0.2635713815689087,
0.07929358631372452,
-0.7717406749725342,
-0.49568718671798706,
-0.4939037561416626,
-0.3963688910007477,
0.38984569907188416,
0.4146150052547455,
0.49631834030151367,
-0.561728835105896,
1.0931346416473389,
-0.16854839026927948,
0.13351576030254364,
-0.030804235488176346,
-0.34038448333740234,
0.13857261836528778,
0.6035658121109009,
0.26272690296173096,
-1.0642434358596802,
-0.07282373309135437,
0.2920968234539032,
-1.0205795764923096,
0.3942079544067383,
-0.05136163905262947,
-0.07579688727855682,
-0.26122966408729553,
0.8149915933609009,
-0.31813010573387146,
0.4431152939796448,
0.7367112040519714,
-0.3732692301273346,
0.3175826668739319,
-0.370565265417099,
0.3628307282924652,
-1.2199572324752808,
-0.06738806515932083,
-0.0006496984278783202,
0.10398673266172409,
-0.44713538885116577,
0.3303406834602356,
-0.23929743468761444,
-0.15070654451847076,
-0.6146233081817627,
0.4641359746456146,
-0.1510390192270279,
0.07030200958251953,
-0.16702862083911896,
-0.05724030360579491,
-0.09181217104196548,
0.19175942242145538,
-0.15656031668186188,
0.7600346803665161,
0.1387391835451126,
-0.6651656031608582,
0.4196654260158539,
0.447924941778183,
-0.2881886959075928,
0.7828174829483032,
-0.529967725276947,
0.31335049867630005,
-0.23104976117610931,
0.31969088315963745,
-0.42780059576034546,
-0.06781972944736481,
0.28583869338035583,
-0.42185166478157043,
-0.5487650036811829,
-0.02616192400455475,
-0.3050999641418457,
-0.3498671352863312,
-0.08148675411939621,
0.26125410199165344,
0.5940712690353394,
-0.5160746574401855,
0.8370181918144226,
0.3592173159122467,
-0.2515932321548462,
-0.5257766246795654,
-0.46686020493507385,
0.34902143478393555,
-0.4796192944049835,
-0.7442185878753662,
0.3651324510574341,
-0.5250421762466431,
-1.0186570882797241,
0.15209347009658813,
0.19943134486675262,
0.16025590896606445,
0.2654757499694824,
0.757224977016449,
0.5305992364883423,
0.09540636092424393,
-0.44231629371643066,
0.1379261463880539,
-0.0015097645809873939,
0.26447954773902893,
-0.6038087606430054,
0.38346824049949646,
-0.5029942393302917,
-0.47607237100601196,
-0.40123799443244934,
0.6410056948661804,
0.46689465641975403,
-0.08547868579626083,
0.5247963070869446,
0.4566080570220947,
-0.42723792791366577,
-0.010349905118346214,
-0.4338333010673523,
0.012484444305300713,
-0.5496137738227844,
0.5712860226631165,
-0.2798914313316345,
-1.0306235551834106,
0.7966156005859375,
-0.3602783977985382,
0.2542731463909149,
0.10520429164171219,
0.9104180335998535,
-0.16132524609565735,
0.43049800395965576,
1.0378001928329468,
0.14574375748634338,
0.15213796496391296,
-0.3724425435066223,
0.34225571155548096,
-0.5666753053665161,
-0.7275733947753906,
-0.24918991327285767,
-0.13773849606513977,
-0.8004029989242554,
-0.8247865438461304,
0.6075076460838318,
-0.24299506843090057,
-0.10934183746576309,
0.05393450707197189,
-0.4102047085762024,
0.9408330917358398,
0.37796223163604736,
-0.3660244047641754,
0.36556267738342285,
-0.08304053544998169,
-0.3027011454105377,
0.37572577595710754,
-0.31442317366600037,
-0.7698829770088196,
0.6452337503433228,
0.10246457904577255,
1.0457756519317627,
0.4539080858230591,
0.694972038269043,
0.5447426438331604,
0.48535510897636414,
-0.6112303733825684,
0.6480469703674316,
-0.12201710790395737,
-0.6042393445968628,
0.013416998088359833,
-0.37371134757995605,
-0.9583557844161987,
0.3169194757938385,
-0.41000714898109436,
-0.5742908716201782,
0.32204875349998474,
-0.07924512028694153,
-0.7659419178962708,
0.42002585530281067,
-0.5927830934524536,
0.3068581521511078,
-0.20470543205738068,
-0.4607952833175659,
-0.607694149017334,
-0.6302125453948975,
0.16454589366912842,
0.06689010560512543,
0.5751916170120239,
-0.2689186632633209,
-0.10905101150274277,
0.3513590395450592,
-0.11375173926353455,
0.8440505862236023,
0.09825512021780014,
-0.34720736742019653,
0.6053677797317505,
0.22803577780723572,
0.27250057458877563,
0.5044353008270264,
-0.32518309354782104,
0.40636956691741943,
0.11687567085027695,
-0.18272541463375092,
-0.09326347708702087,
0.9785981774330139,
-1.3662065267562866,
-0.6625977158546448,
-0.33563682436943054,
-0.8903599381446838,
0.1600218117237091,
0.03804794326424599,
0.1601002812385559,
-0.01655587926506996,
-0.967680811882019,
-0.13076114654541016,
0.4692116677761078,
-0.4952634871006012,
0.47755926847457886,
0.592595100402832,
-0.23690244555473328,
-0.320021390914917,
0.761845052242279,
-0.17902642488479614,
0.07468551397323608,
0.3371807038784027,
0.2172565907239914,
-0.2071092575788498,
-0.15079471468925476,
-0.33308035135269165,
-0.10562814772129059,
-0.625709056854248,
0.1533113420009613,
-0.5591757893562317,
-0.17723971605300903,
0.05127892643213272,
-0.496120423078537,
-0.21432866156101227,
0.014071554876863956,
-0.1971266120672226,
0.15971679985523224,
0.23012927174568176,
0.9828894138336182,
-0.168777197599411,
0.183069109916687,
-0.642969012260437,
0.00788590032607317,
0.23482151329517365,
0.10777093470096588,
-0.1735273152589798,
-0.16250814497470856,
-0.29997143149375916,
0.0971250906586647,
-0.35661736130714417,
-0.2902813255786896,
0.21987371146678925,
-0.18780864775180817,
0.35328957438468933,
0.1765371859073639,
-0.014849088154733181,
0.6282252073287964,
-0.5816118717193604,
0.7414165139198303,
0.08971327543258667,
-0.8000138998031616,
-0.023560069501399994,
-0.4190620481967926,
0.037695322185754776,
0.3454793691635132,
0.12002870440483093,
-0.7196034789085388,
-0.5584465861320496,
-0.6219203472137451,
-0.5185380578041077,
0.3173436224460602,
0.1869608610868454,
0.2548225224018097,
0.09846944361925125,
0.5951468348503113,
0.3419587016105652,
-0.061985764652490616,
-0.632957398891449,
-0.2057742327451706,
-0.01948186755180359,
-0.143182635307312,
-0.08817161619663239,
0.37517622113227844,
-0.4281251132488251,
0.15791822969913483,
0.28594496846199036,
0.05730708688497543,
0.33817604184150696,
0.3639044463634491,
-0.08068691939115524,
-0.33777347207069397,
0.31400763988494873,
0.47980430722236633,
0.5373173952102661,
-0.0817812830209732,
0.14656437933444977,
0.23356997966766357,
-0.6034863591194153,
0.44599249958992004,
0.2907654941082001,
-0.13466738164424896,
-0.6111949682235718,
-0.039481449872255325,
0.3479141294956207,
-0.43826189637184143,
-0.6876537799835205,
0.34790587425231934,
-0.587142288684845,
-0.17100711166858673,
-0.9439882636070251,
0.18361632525920868,
0.20738115906715393,
0.8748719692230225,
0.37122565507888794,
0.5159049034118652,
-0.07089337706565857,
-0.45826631784439087,
0.11800871789455414,
0.4012061357498169,
-0.23554286360740662,
-0.5170722007751465,
0.8934942483901978,
0.46232107281684875,
-0.6763535141944885,
0.1828252524137497,
-0.5849521160125732,
-0.3462221026420593,
0.9952738881111145,
0.38831716775894165,
0.4784584939479828,
-0.09547916054725647,
-0.08457052707672119,
-0.027369892224669456,
0.535132110118866,
0.2224748432636261,
0.2190818339586258,
0.2267807126045227,
-0.8066132068634033,
-0.5477105975151062,
-0.5343586802482605,
-0.891791045665741,
0.05132318660616875,
-0.28502026200294495,
0.2386787235736847,
-0.7765913605690002,
-0.048220664262771606,
-0.22067153453826904,
0.2461852729320526,
-0.7415081858634949,
0.11428597569465637,
0.5042074918746948,
0.6565483808517456,
-0.41533973813056946,
0.4975382387638092,
0.8310659527778625,
-0.10804150253534317,
-0.591324508190155,
0.30468055605888367,
0.3708001375198364,
-0.7157246470451355,
0.40821823477745056,
0.12405116111040115,
-0.616065263748169,
0.04629340022802353,
-0.7123392224311829,
-0.8931275606155396,
1.0604320764541626,
0.34715721011161804,
-0.549735963344574,
0.2941857576370239,
0.17540696263313293,
0.4696861803531647,
-0.4197099506855011,
-0.03183203563094139,
0.5300495624542236,
0.32181841135025024,
-0.03013557568192482,
-0.5518273115158081,
-0.01901024393737316,
-0.5340492129325867,
-0.09546372294425964,
-0.06564527750015259,
-1.2033982276916504,
0.7508600950241089,
-0.7078564763069153,
0.028971677646040916,
0.490348756313324,
0.9255436062812805,
0.37606391310691833,
0.5839097499847412,
0.6185442209243774,
0.41766485571861267,
0.7013721466064453,
0.27000778913497925,
0.8592917323112488,
-0.4817800223827362,
0.3895495533943176,
0.6545658111572266,
-0.46074751019477844,
0.33343246579170227,
0.42794227600097656,
-0.2673185467720032,
0.5583436489105225,
0.5776309370994568,
-0.16480229794979095,
0.18950682878494263,
0.2144252061843872,
-0.46211880445480347,
0.0004169114981777966,
-0.27440258860588074,
-0.16852442920207977,
0.6910679340362549,
0.4835984408855438,
0.20997172594070435,
0.09952232986688614,
-0.19278472661972046,
0.19095590710639954,
0.15019358694553375,
-0.07618557661771774,
0.5593864321708679,
0.21088939905166626,
-0.7650708556175232,
0.07696320861577988,
0.0849694013595581,
0.8267420530319214,
-0.39068803191185,
-0.007952217943966389,
-0.03554530069231987,
0.3402959406375885,
-0.3054565489292145,
-0.48881131410598755,
0.21283729374408722,
0.06155841052532196,
-0.055706530809402466,
0.030685439705848694,
0.24550312757492065,
-0.29009711742401123,
-0.5302711725234985,
0.5168566107749939,
0.6318930983543396,
0.02445143274962902,
0.5969700217247009,
-0.6905203461647034,
0.3168584406375885,
-0.030347228050231934,
0.10495982319116592,
0.10186085104942322,
0.16077379882335663,
-0.07189521938562393,
0.6915298104286194,
0.9916058778762817,
-0.028389407321810722,
-0.003930758219212294,
-0.0923345759510994,
0.861673891544342,
-0.7624984979629517,
-0.7531461119651794,
-1.0581399202346802,
0.1811964511871338,
-0.12004683911800385,
-0.10932589322328568,
0.6631012558937073,
0.5452401638031006,
0.7387068271636963,
0.16911298036575317,
1.0910800695419312,
-0.3107062876224518,
0.14494727551937103,
-0.11187021434307098,
0.7070377469062805,
-0.3757206201553345,
0.3993730843067169,
-0.07373932749032974,
-0.7061106562614441,
-0.20018568634986877,
0.44865432381629944,
-0.26725080609321594,
-0.06007387861609459,
0.43517112731933594,
0.7796431183815002,
0.1337297409772873,
0.3649715781211853,
0.3866216242313385,
0.16815043985843658,
0.749703586101532,
0.4710760712623596,
1.393818736076355,
0.11308645457029343,
0.6671513319015503,
0.013163719326257706,
-0.297275573015213,
-0.23626826703548431,
-0.6702519655227661,
-0.8449284434318542,
-0.3022928237915039,
-0.0009000153513625264,
-0.3695005178451538,
0.04893006384372711,
1.524038314819336,
0.5519471764564514,
-0.2533295750617981,
-0.558027446269989,
0.013775850646197796,
-0.006774350069463253,
0.050676167011260986,
-0.1955122947692871,
0.11747033894062042,
0.1913612186908722,
-0.9092592000961304,
0.39680254459381104,
0.48734718561172485,
0.26388493180274963,
-0.6295952796936035,
-0.2857535779476166,
0.28370124101638794,
0.5861951112747192,
0.5600571632385254,
0.22289402782917023,
-0.7728603482246399,
-0.3741159737110138,
0.20574110746383667,
-0.005179849453270435,
-0.06753091514110565,
0.7138521075248718,
-0.6656590104103088,
0.24214954674243927,
-0.26450979709625244,
0.5480828285217285,
0.015540421940386295,
-0.1052093505859375,
0.32567235827445984,
-0.33613717555999756,
0.6514793634414673,
0.4031745493412018,
0.113861083984375,
0.3070448338985443,
-0.7116416096687317,
0.20618122816085815,
0.06066986173391342,
-0.8057548403739929,
-0.39478692412376404,
0.4476351737976074,
-0.9692227244377136,
-0.09783343225717545,
1.14747154712677,
-0.15883375704288483,
-0.3575807511806488,
-0.16398616135120392,
-0.23800010979175568,
0.0570652037858963,
-0.5002460479736328,
1.0866738557815552,
0.33422067761421204,
-0.3741298317909241,
0.3277045786380768,
-0.2740705609321594,
0.2602922022342682,
0.36721381545066833,
-1.0419790744781494,
-0.24510033428668976,
0.39142969250679016,
0.2951997220516205,
0.38804468512535095,
0.4583706259727478,
-0.012450081296265125,
0.15980328619480133,
0.03196468949317932,
0.1553764045238495,
-0.08210629969835281,
0.04553786665201187,
-0.03591169789433479,
-0.006943053100258112,
-0.07242481410503387,
0.12841381132602692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13178v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13178v2 | Benchmarking Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Medicine | 2024-02-20T17:44:06 | 2024-02-23T16:46:58 | Guangzhi Xiong, Qiao Jin, Zhiyong Lu, Aidong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While large language models (LLMs) have achieved state-of-the-art performance
on a wide range of medical question answering (QA) tasks, they still face
challenges with hallucinations and outdated knowledge. Retrieval-augmented
generation (RAG) is a promising solution and has been widely adopted. However,
a RAG system can involve multiple flexible components, and there is a lack of
best practices regarding the optimal RAG setting for various medical purposes.
To systematically evaluate such systems, we propose the Medical Information
Retrieval-Augmented Generation Evaluation (MIRAGE), a first-of-its-kind
benchmark including 7,663 questions from five medical QA datasets. Using
MIRAGE, we conducted large-scale experiments with over 1.8 trillion prompt
tokens on 41 combinations of different corpora, retrievers, and backbone LLMs
through the MedRAG toolkit introduced in this work. Overall, MedRAG improves
the accuracy of six different LLMs by up to 18% over chain-of-thought
prompting, elevating the performance of GPT-3.5 and Mixtral to GPT-4-level. Our
results show that the combination of various medical corpora and retrievers
achieves the best performance. In addition, we discovered a log-linear scaling
property and the "lost-in-the-middle" effects in medical RAG. We believe our
comprehensive evaluations can serve as practical guidelines for implementing
RAG systems for medicine. | [
-0.510898768901825,
-0.6202591061592102,
0.5738852620124817,
0.16252003610134125,
-0.25645726919174194,
0.23861382901668549,
-0.018177052959799767,
-0.3993908166885376,
0.27026960253715515,
0.35014355182647705,
-0.26858845353126526,
-0.3841184377670288,
-0.5081075429916382,
0.36691173911094666,
-0.35980263352394104,
1.246992588043213,
0.039453111588954926,
0.37636902928352356,
-0.27774548530578613,
-0.35814762115478516,
-0.4782043695449829,
-0.47766369581222534,
-0.796905517578125,
-0.15815889835357666,
0.6218875050544739,
0.024753088131546974,
0.7432878613471985,
0.4380147457122803,
0.7335951924324036,
0.1663830429315567,
-0.12582044303417206,
0.4790595769882202,
-0.6202332377433777,
0.35914114117622375,
-0.21027055382728577,
-0.3116689622402191,
-0.36481696367263794,
-0.24970915913581848,
0.5749061703681946,
0.5263774394989014,
-0.36735090613365173,
0.48897412419319153,
-0.17031551897525787,
0.8805427551269531,
-0.8196051120758057,
-0.40617790818214417,
-0.6194568276405334,
0.0017662550089880824,
-0.2246655374765396,
-0.4677375853061676,
-0.16954267024993896,
-0.5905190110206604,
0.011672570370137691,
-0.6267288327217102,
0.20936810970306396,
0.29937922954559326,
0.9384147524833679,
0.5076034665107727,
-0.17341260612010956,
-0.2527576684951782,
-0.45174914598464966,
0.44921544194221497,
-0.5630180239677429,
0.4834071695804596,
0.24196591973304749,
0.6609190702438354,
-0.3491719961166382,
-0.9201410412788391,
-0.4053005278110504,
-0.16268141567707062,
0.1631718873977661,
0.18184180557727814,
-0.11610491573810577,
-0.21257628500461578,
0.2753280699253082,
0.6027815937995911,
-0.6551359295845032,
-0.12219741195440292,
-0.34793099761009216,
0.04485039785504341,
0.3743997812271118,
0.28527459502220154,
0.275901734828949,
-0.1563514620065689,
-0.49468621611595154,
-0.17850849032402039,
-0.8952476978302002,
-0.2668861448764801,
-0.2979905903339386,
-0.08935156464576721,
0.30031898617744446,
0.67686927318573,
-0.22044096887111664,
0.606682538986206,
0.09208669513463974,
-0.3730010986328125,
0.42895758152008057,
-0.34016498923301697,
-0.2827523946762085,
-0.37921953201293945,
0.7392950057983398,
0.4713444411754608,
-0.16120903193950653,
-0.27154016494750977,
-0.4099619686603546,
-0.1087162122130394,
0.5080786347389221,
-0.8267452120780945,
-0.22599788010120392,
0.2273520678281784,
-0.4109240174293518,
-0.307582288980484,
-0.38059309124946594,
-0.9182820320129395,
-0.771827220916748,
-0.10589367151260376,
0.7337396740913391,
-0.4635876715183258,
-0.17850138247013092,
0.03486334905028343,
-0.14931371808052063,
0.22704081237316132,
0.1189509853720665,
-0.5042473077774048,
0.6199806332588196,
0.8163992762565613,
0.6111473441123962,
-0.3992997407913208,
0.049030426889657974,
-0.8087490200996399,
-0.2175273597240448,
-0.5996674299240112,
1.0347650051116943,
-0.29834070801734924,
-0.4427182972431183,
-0.13733303546905518,
-0.4855629801750183,
-0.0955311730504036,
-1.3232330083847046,
0.6935716867446899,
-0.5439072251319885,
0.3410283029079437,
-0.3383871614933014,
-0.5302436947822571,
0.11088693886995316,
0.4591309428215027,
-0.48700758814811707,
1.300649642944336,
0.2570633590221405,
-0.7398049235343933,
0.6314778923988342,
-0.349784791469574,
-0.12433330714702606,
0.25703883171081543,
-0.48574867844581604,
-0.48523837327957153,
0.1974705308675766,
0.4508647322654724,
0.21657060086727142,
-0.7851893901824951,
0.26161959767341614,
0.044137440621852875,
-0.4611190855503082,
0.3771381974220276,
-0.40302276611328125,
0.36744260787963867,
0.34375306963920593,
-0.29392752051353455,
-0.14649125933647156,
-0.8221615552902222,
0.27383843064308167,
0.02781657502055168,
-0.4659261107444763,
-0.3039786219596863,
-0.1197705790400505,
-0.03406354784965515,
0.2617059648036957,
0.1690489798784256,
-0.40615975856781006,
0.03629942238330841,
-0.47529336810112,
-0.28263363242149353,
0.3962293267250061,
0.4227898120880127,
-0.0857086181640625,
-0.738559901714325,
0.6883771419525146,
-0.10292548686265945,
0.21558736264705658,
0.09531711041927338,
-0.4700007736682892,
-0.5989943742752075,
-0.41537705063819885,
0.48109206557273865,
0.5189119577407837,
-1.085371732711792,
0.022510454058647156,
-0.14559005200862885,
-0.48227521777153015,
-0.9246252775192261,
0.00748410914093256,
0.7006552815437317,
0.7159090638160706,
0.5502300262451172,
-0.2441614270210266,
-0.35379862785339355,
-0.9208579659461975,
-0.5210232138633728,
-0.1220955103635788,
-0.1637023240327835,
0.6890637874603271,
0.205142542719841,
-0.2816099524497986,
0.5011894702911377,
-0.3564067780971527,
0.08171962201595306,
0.10199665278196335,
-0.02083927020430565,
0.3582894206047058,
0.11710623651742935,
0.363834023475647,
-0.8077548742294312,
-0.3185472786426544,
-0.01591288298368454,
-0.5685514211654663,
-0.38296785950660706,
0.1612485647201538,
-0.23051537573337555,
0.050472792237997055,
0.14740636944770813,
-0.27408692240715027,
0.3176143765449524,
0.6548076272010803,
-0.26530352234840393,
0.7219188809394836,
-0.413259893655777,
0.5620815753936768,
-1.1038187742233276,
0.48015981912612915,
-0.24805791676044464,
-0.13191497325897217,
-0.5432608723640442,
0.17869649827480316,
0.11237622797489166,
-0.004778632894158363,
-0.2744896113872528,
0.7323740124702454,
-0.35210955142974854,
-0.21644200384616852,
-0.27528348565101624,
0.18075470626354218,
0.06210876628756523,
0.07113949954509735,
-0.3751411437988281,
1.139216423034668,
0.22249893844127655,
-0.5810768008232117,
0.1066412702202797,
0.06459023803472519,
-0.3577817976474762,
0.8242141008377075,
-0.6181051731109619,
0.11714212596416473,
-0.11192916333675385,
0.10991200804710388,
-0.8490192294120789,
-0.09144580364227295,
-0.025476878508925438,
-0.4034031927585602,
0.33606231212615967,
0.19926710426807404,
-0.6624355316162109,
-0.43991872668266296,
-0.20697319507598877,
0.546164333820343,
0.6877851486206055,
-0.5738265514373779,
0.42342305183410645,
0.47939521074295044,
-0.1472901701927185,
-0.7541470527648926,
0.02993692271411419,
0.24134404957294464,
-0.20451194047927856,
-0.29712149500846863,
0.13774700462818146,
0.0073435865342617035,
-0.302339106798172,
-0.19101759791374207,
-0.30731716752052307,
0.01940634660422802,
-0.042442090809345245,
0.14715872704982758,
0.39019885659217834,
-0.22777512669563293,
0.28625839948654175,
0.18103714287281036,
-0.15609650313854218,
-0.04934471473097801,
-0.03227609395980835,
0.5482481122016907,
-0.007211104966700077,
-0.2778589427471161,
0.06365670263767242,
0.11878543347120285,
0.544194757938385,
-0.3646903336048126,
0.41788119077682495,
0.42066389322280884,
-0.34358450770378113,
-0.11739655584096909,
-0.9036140441894531,
-0.0061479960568249226,
-0.42913350462913513,
0.35385072231292725,
-0.3802722990512848,
-0.5646725296974182,
0.28191012144088745,
-0.3576207160949707,
0.1753423660993576,
0.6552143096923828,
0.7357199192047119,
-0.02294398844242096,
0.9227209687232971,
0.1339593380689621,
0.1906016319990158,
-0.09218723326921463,
-0.04920240491628647,
-0.09099027514457703,
-1.1005737781524658,
-0.40798211097717285,
-0.5156107544898987,
-0.27729055285453796,
-0.5279867053031921,
-0.7576722502708435,
1.1688976287841797,
0.20462463796138763,
-0.11749682575464249,
-0.10566111654043198,
-0.678280770778656,
0.3069089949131012,
0.37743499875068665,
0.2900865375995636,
0.4126046299934387,
-0.08913642913103104,
-0.46859970688819885,
0.09966351091861725,
-0.7577846646308899,
-0.4442107081413269,
1.3624578714370728,
0.22440774738788605,
0.6751206517219543,
-0.06662806868553162,
0.8137148022651672,
0.03225109353661537,
0.7230837941169739,
-0.4197748005390167,
0.5359386801719666,
-0.3147965967655182,
-0.7341472506523132,
-0.0073400987312197685,
-0.5643183588981628,
-1.067455768585205,
0.4935636520385742,
-0.5920001864433289,
-0.3566381335258484,
-0.022272083908319473,
0.008690780028700829,
-0.4724121689796448,
0.19733624160289764,
-0.3700931966304779,
0.41713273525238037,
-0.14947299659252167,
-0.31701990962028503,
-0.03904913738369942,
-0.5529893636703491,
0.31973978877067566,
-0.3300520181655884,
0.21831746399402618,
-0.0942339301109314,
-0.4581564962863922,
0.6885151863098145,
-0.3253425061702728,
0.1800442337989807,
-0.12885068356990814,
0.04282054305076599,
0.08519574999809265,
0.06793460994958878,
0.21397261321544647,
-0.04365627467632294,
-0.12802161276340485,
-0.08912793546915054,
0.3406201899051666,
-0.24250346422195435,
-0.6216380000114441,
0.662346363067627,
-0.5126561522483826,
-0.42402371764183044,
-0.32008811831474304,
-0.5890701413154602,
-0.576757550239563,
0.22360560297966003,
0.37726178765296936,
0.5932354927062988,
-0.3792225122451782,
0.07626909017562866,
0.7739806175231934,
-0.5347711443901062,
-0.18739156424999237,
0.45730090141296387,
-0.6153911352157593,
-0.7719793915748596,
0.8665379881858826,
0.09395170956850052,
0.15830393135547638,
0.31269145011901855,
0.29698315262794495,
-0.2920241057872772,
-0.6253454089164734,
-0.816231906414032,
0.3905492126941681,
-0.4336117208003998,
-0.3981311321258545,
-0.7263181209564209,
-0.1821364313364029,
-0.0709882378578186,
0.1879713088274002,
-0.24349774420261383,
-0.24797961115837097,
-0.02319941110908985,
0.33889856934547424,
0.2493470311164856,
0.8544961214065552,
0.12645666301250458,
-0.22474095225334167,
-0.7726274132728577,
0.707831859588623,
0.1504095196723938,
0.5369531512260437,
-0.20458433032035828,
-0.4293040335178375,
-0.1278175562620163,
-0.15825936198234558,
-0.35074639320373535,
-0.7620482444763184,
0.25570148229599,
0.10190555453300476,
0.6227240562438965,
0.21753792464733124,
-0.1214962750673294,
0.6801581382751465,
-0.7723593711853027,
0.6984363198280334,
0.06396427005529404,
-0.35303476452827454,
0.34213757514953613,
-0.27691251039505005,
0.27928707003593445,
0.7966991662979126,
0.25812995433807373,
-0.3928680419921875,
-0.48835423588752747,
-0.7168671488761902,
-0.8120409846305847,
-0.01661050319671631,
0.1132386103272438,
-0.26439279317855835,
-0.29401102662086487,
0.5475541949272156,
0.19789987802505493,
0.24602852761745453,
-0.014852147549390793,
-0.34041374921798706,
0.4014713168144226,
-0.22526369988918304,
0.008857827633619308,
-0.22125472128391266,
-0.31987693905830383,
-0.004861301276832819,
0.5417131781578064,
0.11754762381315231,
0.1314936727285385,
0.3323788642883301,
0.26400527358055115,
-0.14787855744361877,
0.2695106565952301,
0.5759122371673584,
0.8421679139137268,
-0.04191059619188309,
-0.004970767069607973,
0.37824124097824097,
-0.6714656949043274,
0.1290939301252365,
0.24447117745876312,
-0.1444576382637024,
0.1321437805891037,
0.01361528504639864,
0.3539467751979828,
0.1923617124557495,
-0.9942378997802734,
0.4052053987979889,
-0.07180982828140259,
-0.11993513256311417,
0.05826253816485405,
0.1335250735282898,
-0.181057408452034,
0.2593052387237549,
0.5554174780845642,
0.008518354035913944,
0.512430727481842,
-0.302816778421402,
0.40668538212776184,
0.449925035238266,
-0.0016040425980463624,
0.11089129000902176,
0.729892909526825,
-0.09970539063215256,
-0.2458149790763855,
0.3364860713481903,
0.038481976836919785,
-0.33249369263648987,
0.40406593680381775,
0.5425815582275391,
0.6484041810035706,
-0.16507771611213684,
0.020020397379994392,
0.44040539860725403,
0.11045952886343002,
-0.17342253029346466,
0.4700583517551422,
0.10092248767614365,
-0.21955733001232147,
-0.39034926891326904,
-0.7382408380508423,
-0.6003751158714294,
-0.015840834006667137,
-0.7287955284118652,
0.07569189369678497,
-0.29851752519607544,
-0.43408656120300293,
-0.03733953833580017,
0.1556481570005417,
-0.7354649305343628,
0.36340534687042236,
-0.14960838854312897,
1.0409103631973267,
-0.38427647948265076,
0.3544996678829193,
0.730474591255188,
-0.15475061535835266,
-0.778496265411377,
-0.06177973747253418,
-0.10141754150390625,
-0.8845630288124084,
0.4436972141265869,
-0.20784054696559906,
-0.13439294695854187,
-0.2549757659435272,
-0.313774436712265,
-0.803830623626709,
1.0360196828842163,
0.11492465436458588,
-0.4534439742565155,
0.012124058790504932,
-0.1756879836320877,
0.9061595797538757,
-0.23946385085582733,
0.21009927988052368,
0.623956024646759,
0.12840119004249573,
0.11508525162935257,
-1.2908143997192383,
-0.003150566713884473,
-0.4292684495449066,
0.036690641194581985,
0.41526806354522705,
-0.49056464433670044,
0.7899666428565979,
-0.251935750246048,
-0.2925945222377777,
0.4392753541469574,
0.24413123726844788,
0.8580394387245178,
0.6294476389884949,
0.34245696663856506,
0.7379571795463562,
0.9208751320838928,
-0.1069430336356163,
1.4114389419555664,
-0.4564031660556793,
0.04079132154583931,
0.8992941975593567,
-0.21477273106575012,
1.119742751121521,
0.4518648386001587,
-0.26071736216545105,
0.4440824091434479,
0.3198322653770447,
0.26982226967811584,
0.40378156304359436,
0.5099218487739563,
-0.490998774766922,
0.15250571072101593,
-0.10294041782617569,
-0.6984138488769531,
0.05372023582458496,
0.44735124707221985,
-0.5432885885238647,
-0.13910900056362152,
0.09672215580940247,
0.03552141785621643,
0.011231564916670322,
-0.2796798050403595,
1.1164430379867554,
-0.09235802292823792,
-0.8602677583694458,
1.025262475013733,
-0.32611528038978577,
0.4024282693862915,
-0.2949216961860657,
-0.18873070180416107,
-0.33578720688819885,
0.10004960745573044,
-0.1344485729932785,
-0.5700905919075012,
-0.10135463625192642,
0.16642966866493225,
0.031928785145282745,
0.22313527762889862,
0.6652553677558899,
-0.31446149945259094,
-0.5170235633850098,
-0.10631649196147919,
0.7085192799568176,
0.40742334723472595,
0.14303022623062134,
-0.6387565732002258,
0.06521424651145935,
-0.27381789684295654,
-0.1471126824617386,
0.3961649537086487,
0.5792527198791504,
0.10211540758609772,
0.714470386505127,
0.5782199501991272,
0.5472689867019653,
0.16467547416687012,
0.024660689756274223,
1.166874885559082,
-0.44819384813308716,
-0.0014919065870344639,
-0.4112847149372101,
0.2643742561340332,
-0.12571777403354645,
-0.5131532549858093,
0.6509538888931274,
0.8408939838409424,
0.41049790382385254,
0.24658609926700592,
0.4880291223526001,
0.11197976022958755,
1.077202320098877,
-0.37026286125183105,
0.8024017810821533,
-0.7839536070823669,
0.31565117835998535,
-0.261270135641098,
-0.9471561312675476,
-0.3081391155719757,
0.2807878255844116,
-0.14664185047149658,
0.15513287484645844,
0.5961406230926514,
0.7257393598556519,
0.2419801503419876,
-0.23680627346038818,
0.422109454870224,
0.11797799915075302,
0.23772753775119781,
0.5275492668151855,
0.7019832134246826,
-0.615898609161377,
0.43050655722618103,
-0.10666784644126892,
-0.4204944670200348,
-0.10461817681789398,
-0.4287584125995636,
-0.5493987202644348,
-0.43474137783050537,
0.0408577024936676,
-0.7530760169029236,
0.3855469524860382,
0.8978121876716614,
0.44405898451805115,
-0.5452716946601868,
-0.011340219527482986,
0.32274818420410156,
-0.23514893651008606,
-0.30322083830833435,
-0.14859317243099213,
0.4694637954235077,
-0.5372735261917114,
-0.449086993932724,
0.4186302125453949,
0.42345568537712097,
-0.25068768858909607,
-0.2983086109161377,
0.0641215518116951,
-0.07054053992033005,
0.1119692325592041,
0.5580727458000183,
0.3513307273387909,
-0.6217653751373291,
-0.05605509504675865,
0.2545873522758484,
-0.40191423892974854,
0.07870405912399292,
0.728144109249115,
-1.1082338094711304,
0.7024374008178711,
0.3279154896736145,
0.9464849233627319,
0.3938235342502594,
0.32025817036628723,
0.42988166213035583,
-0.4635975956916809,
-0.4349338710308075,
0.6054480671882629,
0.14298659563064575,
0.2626068592071533,
-0.142017662525177,
0.6756584644317627,
-0.08917918056249619,
-0.8932123780250549,
-0.9541128277778625,
-0.2565957307815552,
-0.6180050373077393,
-0.13089187443256378,
1.144834280014038,
0.22234579920768738,
-0.00467249471694231,
-0.13771894574165344,
-0.5427263975143433,
0.12269924581050873,
-0.03553809970617294,
0.9397152066230774,
0.30815500020980835,
-0.3009713888168335,
0.006195649039000273,
-0.7865176796913147,
0.676792562007904,
0.6268531680107117,
-1.012425184249878,
-0.17839962244033813,
0.5495434999465942,
0.36904504895210266,
0.12843057513237,
0.9184463024139404,
-0.45901718735694885,
0.5876927375793457,
-0.02958611771464348,
-0.08966928720474243,
0.16657322645187378,
-0.2301216572523117,
-0.28766608238220215,
0.23705916106700897,
0.10123460739850998,
-0.13959620893001556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14857v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14857v2 | Is the System Message Really Important to Jailbreaks in Large Language Models? | 2024-02-20T17:39:40 | 2024-06-18T19:22:19 | Xiaotian Zou, Yongkang Chen, Ke Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR | The rapid evolution of Large Language Models (LLMs) has rendered them
indispensable in modern society. While security measures are typically to align
LLMs with human values prior to release, recent studies have unveiled a
concerning phenomenon named "Jailbreak". This term refers to the unexpected and
potentially harmful responses generated by LLMs when prompted with malicious
questions. Most existing research focus on generating jailbreak prompts but
system message configurations vary significantly in experiments. In this paper,
we aim to answer a question: Is the system message really important for
jailbreaks in LLMs? We conduct experiments in mainstream LLMs to generate
jailbreak prompts with varying system messages: short, long, and none. We
discover that different system messages have distinct resistances to
jailbreaks. Therefore, we explore the transferability of jailbreaks across LLMs
with different system messages. Furthermore, we propose the System Messages
Evolutionary Algorithm (SMEA) to generate system messages that are more
resistant to jailbreak prompts, even with minor changes. Through SMEA, we get a
robust system messages population with little change in the length of system
messages. Our research not only bolsters LLMs security but also raises the bar
for jailbreaks, fostering advancements in this field of study. | [
-0.3144073486328125,
-0.5841434597969055,
0.5770174860954285,
0.23850350081920624,
-0.3756134510040283,
0.11636634171009064,
-0.0719427540898323,
-0.6806640625,
0.4574916362762451,
0.6328315138816833,
-0.45265352725982666,
-0.024058464914560318,
-0.6676278114318848,
0.043475229293107986,
-0.4954914450645447,
1.127800464630127,
0.015691706910729408,
-0.0841837078332901,
0.10659144818782806,
-0.04949181154370308,
-0.8173884749412537,
-0.7458834648132324,
-0.32561755180358887,
-0.07739675790071487,
0.45353397727012634,
0.37002554535865784,
0.33373159170150757,
0.6018521189689636,
0.6021263599395752,
0.25862228870391846,
-0.4210004210472107,
-0.04934993386268616,
-0.5390581488609314,
0.6384570002555847,
-0.21516269445419312,
-0.5851250290870667,
-0.26572999358177185,
-0.3721790611743927,
0.4192639887332916,
0.5058276057243347,
0.13649871945381165,
0.1406092643737793,
-0.011170828714966774,
0.8543686270713806,
-0.623910129070282,
-0.27214470505714417,
-0.673849880695343,
-0.13669617474079132,
-0.3804374039173126,
-0.09451218694448471,
-0.436567485332489,
-0.20708392560482025,
-0.10153783857822418,
-0.1386149525642395,
-0.27872681617736816,
0.13092805445194244,
0.4974396824836731,
-0.06807468831539154,
-0.20266632735729218,
-0.48888498544692993,
-0.7401753664016724,
0.6577674150466919,
-0.8246302604675293,
0.15620960295200348,
-0.0788048729300499,
0.30342984199523926,
-0.6075286269187927,
-0.19556672871112823,
-0.255321204662323,
-0.5359153747558594,
0.14627715945243835,
-0.38454699516296387,
-0.16578267514705658,
-0.04954855144023895,
0.13104914128780365,
-0.007775157690048218,
-0.19341740012168884,
0.4420909881591797,
-0.6930434703826904,
-0.25869396328926086,
0.5509286522865295,
0.43793317675590515,
0.6874083876609802,
-0.20134098827838898,
-0.2942611575126648,
-0.04173982888460159,
-1.164238452911377,
-0.10238511860370636,
0.3990802466869354,
0.24373742938041687,
-0.28108084201812744,
0.22658227384090424,
0.18818239867687225,
0.5360597372055054,
-0.15175433456897736,
-0.18878501653671265,
-0.030790381133556366,
-0.11396116018295288,
-0.07894928008317947,
0.28428611159324646,
0.8801063895225525,
0.28273335099220276,
0.1834925264120102,
-0.15129952132701874,
-0.1858096420764923,
-0.07498429715633392,
0.11051009595394135,
-0.7827708721160889,
0.19911712408065796,
0.2590450048446655,
-0.3281863331794739,
-0.5692951083183289,
0.4065698981285095,
-0.8335286378860474,
-0.7020002603530884,
0.336001992225647,
0.13154128193855286,
-0.2711898684501648,
-0.12295408546924591,
0.08645503968000412,
-0.1758614033460617,
0.002607135334983468,
0.44379284977912903,
-1.2008559703826904,
0.17101261019706726,
0.807794451713562,
0.7820357084274292,
-0.0396413616836071,
-0.27797988057136536,
-0.6151790022850037,
0.24041542410850525,
-0.3729449510574341,
0.5769389271736145,
-0.3485570251941681,
-0.5451923608779907,
-0.2883695662021637,
0.18141809105873108,
-0.0012584807118400931,
-0.5127137303352356,
0.2577225863933563,
-0.5345622897148132,
-0.23227645456790924,
-0.0889086201786995,
-0.5159283876419067,
0.23990678787231445,
-0.0430937185883522,
-0.4898660480976105,
0.36859697103500366,
-0.3726281523704529,
-0.5904127359390259,
0.09466596692800522,
-0.54549640417099,
-0.6527019143104553,
0.0929628387093544,
0.08745993673801422,
-0.3410857319831848,
0.40259265899658203,
0.032254330813884735,
0.5243234038352966,
-0.16238750517368317,
0.36311033368110657,
-0.6212497353553772,
-0.49082842469215393,
0.5558798909187317,
-0.30370908975601196,
0.6092175245285034,
0.6507580280303955,
-0.6565048694610596,
-0.22373300790786743,
-0.43165847659111023,
-0.10705043375492096,
0.31053730845451355,
-0.4949672222137451,
-0.4597286283969879,
0.2340019941329956,
-0.19086778163909912,
-0.10422659665346146,
0.4288995563983917,
-0.6900486350059509,
0.38637661933898926,
-0.42125070095062256,
0.8654537796974182,
1.0389823913574219,
0.14392009377479553,
0.4474900960922241,
-0.014853022992610931,
0.4317459464073181,
-0.12167554348707199,
0.26055312156677246,
-0.46918046474456787,
-0.4290899634361267,
-0.17938333749771118,
-0.14447945356369019,
-0.07766164094209671,
0.7454634308815002,
0.022975338622927666,
0.2993970215320587,
0.05502161383628845,
-0.5895494818687439,
-0.10918596386909485,
0.16899673640727997,
0.43906089663505554,
-0.08162889629602432,
-0.1134839579463005,
-0.12150987237691879,
-0.639312744140625,
-0.8544210195541382,
-0.4228931665420532,
-0.5229325890541077,
0.34165382385253906,
0.2736646234989166,
0.33696815371513367,
-0.3709403872489929,
0.46724647283554077,
-0.43998023867607117,
0.36962059140205383,
-0.6850054860115051,
-0.3312927782535553,
0.1815495789051056,
0.3395288288593292,
0.7730647921562195,
-0.3029831051826477,
-0.10570427030324936,
-0.19691035151481628,
-0.8061704039573669,
-0.4251296818256378,
-0.31022584438323975,
0.09318730980157852,
-0.13472017645835876,
0.7312480807304382,
-0.6333554983139038,
0.24519503116607666,
0.6792341470718384,
-0.5915384888648987,
0.7365105152130127,
-0.33157938718795776,
0.0836775153875351,
-0.9826832413673401,
-0.20165683329105377,
-0.10063133388757706,
-0.18977439403533936,
-0.817992091178894,
0.47488847374916077,
0.06017071008682251,
-0.05225590988993645,
-0.5255222320556641,
0.6021685004234314,
-0.37573423981666565,
-0.2424592524766922,
-0.4163059890270233,
0.2178213894367218,
-0.26384326815605164,
-0.3185197412967682,
-0.6065881848335266,
0.7901339530944824,
0.5230767130851746,
-0.5561327934265137,
0.42866969108581543,
0.04840845242142677,
-0.4025660455226898,
0.2807149291038513,
-0.4794744849205017,
0.2678379714488983,
-0.019267087802290916,
0.11882255226373672,
-0.8618825078010559,
-0.1624101996421814,
0.17438443005084991,
-0.21469268202781677,
0.04876327887177467,
0.09277665615081787,
-0.40917500853538513,
-0.43432602286338806,
-0.15883894264698029,
-0.128090500831604,
0.39774197340011597,
-0.5686143636703491,
-0.03719218447804451,
0.4506024718284607,
-0.1293228715658188,
-0.25282207131385803,
-0.6766454577445984,
0.5421829223632812,
-0.4824056625366211,
-0.7893736958503723,
-0.17559592425823212,
-0.20516417920589447,
-0.5909834504127502,
-0.5293810963630676,
-0.2157798856496811,
0.30221807956695557,
0.8420912027359009,
0.5485162138938904,
0.41930851340293884,
-0.2012004554271698,
0.11308956891298294,
0.2213362753391266,
0.06101246923208237,
0.3313847780227661,
-0.2742116153240204,
0.5285496115684509,
-0.3976484537124634,
-0.11301222443580627,
-0.342069536447525,
0.3254605829715729,
0.9138662219047546,
0.008733308874070644,
1.0740007162094116,
-0.0184449665248394,
0.01826273836195469,
-0.27568259835243225,
-0.311439573764801,
-0.39711543917655945,
-0.47749173641204834,
0.3535933494567871,
-0.30015844106674194,
-1.2030670642852783,
0.4567773938179016,
-0.1539127379655838,
-0.041677460074424744,
-0.0015941091114655137,
0.4155845642089844,
-0.2039678990840912,
0.9449217915534973,
0.6722869873046875,
-0.5098108649253845,
0.6537372469902039,
0.28070199489593506,
0.3400466740131378,
-0.6111283898353577,
0.012042387388646603,
-0.7036535739898682,
-0.2823337912559509,
-0.6269698739051819,
0.2422967553138733,
0.061088595539331436,
0.34180963039398193,
-0.36032453179359436,
0.5229789018630981,
-0.5450239777565002,
0.4693259596824646,
0.10565990209579468,
0.022078605368733406,
0.34469664096832275,
-0.09416601806879044,
-0.024259384721517563,
0.1449384093284607,
-0.36418867111206055,
-0.7596848607063293,
1.1424890756607056,
0.4947581887245178,
1.0272899866104126,
0.1719457060098648,
1.1130515336990356,
0.3894444704055786,
0.4364934265613556,
-0.31995776295661926,
0.8520198464393616,
-0.030819008126854897,
-0.7055820822715759,
-0.15805524587631226,
-0.4603736102581024,
-0.9710894227027893,
0.18839803338050842,
-0.08688903599977493,
-1.2958884239196777,
-0.005816331133246422,
0.028821034356951714,
-0.43478110432624817,
0.43211519718170166,
-0.7435628175735474,
0.6153215765953064,
-0.36640307307243347,
0.1792217195034027,
-0.10666976124048233,
-0.8550398945808411,
0.5076751112937927,
-0.18699584901332855,
0.7539098858833313,
-0.2709093689918518,
0.13623137772083282,
0.7617854475975037,
-0.7134581208229065,
0.783569872379303,
-0.20192497968673706,
-0.20251134037971497,
0.24205219745635986,
0.390006422996521,
0.7097868919372559,
0.22080017626285553,
0.08432335406541824,
-0.18072625994682312,
0.1746540069580078,
-0.1657344251871109,
-0.3789916932582855,
0.8738769292831421,
-0.8826332092285156,
-1.0956590175628662,
-0.2552359700202942,
-0.4217088222503662,
0.03756024315953255,
0.12326094508171082,
0.18635202944278717,
0.20643176138401031,
0.1586097627878189,
0.1345936506986618,
0.7404062151908875,
-0.2883535623550415,
0.37941619753837585,
0.2607783079147339,
-0.5951129794120789,
-0.24872170388698578,
0.7253642082214355,
-0.13730460405349731,
0.6573870778083801,
-0.08822736889123917,
0.3722573518753052,
0.49088045954704285,
-0.8228179812431335,
-0.601938009262085,
0.3151182532310486,
-0.5532722473144531,
-0.14231975376605988,
-0.6278797388076782,
-0.14306411147117615,
-0.14373265206813812,
-0.3714119493961334,
-0.19966483116149902,
-0.3066771924495697,
-0.3705022633075714,
-0.30714941024780273,
0.411159873008728,
0.907034695148468,
-0.1863860934972763,
0.4132036566734314,
-1.167710781097412,
0.28109076619148254,
0.1447405219078064,
0.061665259301662445,
-0.11645681411027908,
-0.6225507259368896,
-0.2096119225025177,
0.024419840425252914,
-0.049470994621515274,
-1.3644702434539795,
0.14029374718666077,
0.10165298730134964,
0.5262284874916077,
0.34208056330680847,
-0.1037331074476242,
0.42190757393836975,
-0.3443458080291748,
0.74774569272995,
0.23412922024726868,
-0.8814674615859985,
0.7583462595939636,
-0.43131884932518005,
0.1527978628873825,
0.40718862414360046,
-0.2408967763185501,
-0.7956569194793701,
-0.9076642394065857,
-0.33382296562194824,
-0.7825279235839844,
0.6163643002510071,
-0.16706335544586182,
0.7282422780990601,
-0.18556147813796997,
0.5734516978263855,
0.11207298934459686,
0.1877930462360382,
-0.673812747001648,
-0.2383781224489212,
0.19497455656528473,
0.010847283527255058,
0.22884514927864075,
-0.26114702224731445,
0.08608679473400116,
0.04878271743655205,
0.3456341624259949,
0.2969650328159332,
0.1162542924284935,
-0.052202388644218445,
-0.08437404781579971,
-0.21408091485500336,
0.7705533504486084,
0.6184366941452026,
0.25643694400787354,
-0.17538303136825562,
-0.02793031930923462,
0.16679741442203522,
-0.8471017479896545,
0.5560122132301331,
-0.386201947927475,
-0.3110089898109436,
-0.30593055486679077,
0.22757107019424438,
1.015108346939087,
-0.07807115465402603,
-1.003380298614502,
0.44384875893592834,
0.06801629811525345,
-0.17018114030361176,
0.06659792363643646,
0.39446157217025757,
0.09225177764892578,
0.29590967297554016,
0.4426715672016144,
0.2459273487329483,
-0.13119657337665558,
-0.9880867004394531,
0.034577637910842896,
0.4041750729084015,
-0.3413224518299103,
-0.3848516345024109,
0.6268731951713562,
0.08365043997764587,
-0.4104996621608734,
0.5222997665405273,
-0.1867426186800003,
-0.44239872694015503,
0.7265408039093018,
0.9773362874984741,
0.7950707077980042,
-0.4163346588611603,
0.31378239393234253,
-0.0748848244547844,
0.7764350771903992,
-0.44240424036979675,
0.067398801445961,
0.21940775215625763,
-0.6233044266700745,
-0.37657108902931213,
-0.7065244317054749,
-0.4263085126876831,
0.11821746826171875,
-0.3402137756347656,
0.2960667610168457,
-0.7839253544807434,
-0.08434287458658218,
-0.252096563577652,
-0.6798689961433411,
-0.03203730657696724,
0.13723818957805634,
0.4955478310585022,
1.035240650177002,
-0.9124618172645569,
0.5798344016075134,
0.6319241523742676,
0.22831575572490692,
-0.8536980748176575,
-0.2024306356906891,
0.08790408074855804,
-0.47411084175109863,
0.7915456891059875,
0.36867162585258484,
-0.04002078250050545,
-0.2867705821990967,
-0.8807359337806702,
-0.9918758869171143,
0.6893026828765869,
0.5952680110931396,
-0.8796231150627136,
0.052908722311258316,
0.019583286717534065,
0.5061265826225281,
-0.5820877552032471,
-0.09712428599596024,
0.7188471555709839,
0.49101290106773376,
-0.07452955842018127,
-0.8019927740097046,
0.2773554027080536,
-0.12549813091754913,
-0.019834265112876892,
0.7100973129272461,
-0.6187461614608765,
0.626915454864502,
-0.735907793045044,
-0.18067209422588348,
0.32554641366004944,
0.36947911977767944,
0.7114028930664062,
0.21679061651229858,
0.3593723773956299,
0.43186527490615845,
0.5072429776191711,
-0.12257512658834457,
0.9682281017303467,
-0.24457211792469025,
0.08215188980102539,
0.8357605338096619,
-0.4121314585208893,
0.767953097820282,
0.7268738150596619,
-0.1343395859003067,
0.5990942120552063,
0.4533867835998535,
0.020023144781589508,
0.4332440495491028,
0.6396129727363586,
-0.11786171793937683,
-0.2435993254184723,
0.4376278221607208,
-0.3667081892490387,
0.24678993225097656,
0.5187666416168213,
-0.37324559688568115,
-0.20058222115039825,
0.5535678863525391,
0.4303916394710541,
-0.02801823616027832,
-0.3628149926662445,
0.7995594143867493,
0.38313746452331543,
-0.4370969533920288,
0.5047306418418884,
0.1725885570049286,
0.5721070170402527,
-0.3470236361026764,
0.40206378698349,
-0.40133652091026306,
0.0686701163649559,
-0.27978870272636414,
-0.6004754304885864,
0.17800362408161163,
0.2730639576911926,
0.05607427656650543,
-0.08530480414628983,
0.9628616571426392,
0.2442394196987152,
-0.09128987044095993,
0.43565940856933594,
0.31746646761894226,
0.3704826235771179,
-0.05931580439209938,
-0.4977814257144928,
0.3906606435775757,
0.10325195640325546,
-0.4824572205543518,
0.588024914264679,
0.1625891625881195,
-0.1883953958749771,
0.9000951051712036,
0.7568632960319519,
0.4808427393436432,
0.4155842065811157,
-0.12741701304912567,
1.0804548263549805,
-0.7919716835021973,
-0.6723224520683289,
-1.3008779287338257,
0.3947586715221405,
0.032828062772750854,
0.006967988330870867,
0.8329907059669495,
0.17020882666110992,
0.31004348397254944,
0.08742827922105789,
1.137851357460022,
-0.13806825876235962,
0.2104460895061493,
-0.4200018644332886,
0.6766710877418518,
-0.2737693786621094,
0.9644583463668823,
-0.38138347864151,
-1.0219019651412964,
-0.04339846596121788,
0.09874414652585983,
-0.5836023688316345,
-0.19582952558994293,
0.5886421799659729,
0.44778740406036377,
0.33079907298088074,
0.2877809703350067,
0.12606288492679596,
0.1329992711544037,
0.4781600534915924,
0.6251452565193176,
0.9471726417541504,
-0.41180315613746643,
0.7025488018989563,
0.32874637842178345,
-0.37023141980171204,
-0.38107702136039734,
-0.5993276238441467,
-0.8158894777297974,
-0.15563753247261047,
-0.12309276312589645,
-0.5488600730895996,
0.6013568043708801,
0.8088383674621582,
0.2869696319103241,
-0.7766982913017273,
-0.5071679949760437,
-0.26999640464782715,
0.1732722818851471,
-0.021670760586857796,
-0.18543925881385803,
-0.2570303678512573,
-0.3311447501182556,
-0.038908205926418304,
0.5242573022842407,
0.8327782154083252,
0.19663314521312714,
-0.3752273619174957,
-0.0765705481171608,
0.10567585378885269,
0.26395630836486816,
0.41736021637916565,
0.46214303374290466,
-0.40146777033805847,
-0.5076432824134827,
0.15376783907413483,
-0.4046816825866699,
0.0367722250521183,
0.7437162399291992,
-0.418422669172287,
0.18775507807731628,
0.4295523464679718,
0.5348652601242065,
0.28530552983283997,
-0.4088055491447449,
0.5741313099861145,
-0.47282031178474426,
0.17983375489711761,
-0.09745293110609055,
0.5686964988708496,
0.3174859285354614,
-0.4851544201374054,
0.043969132006168365,
0.30061566829681396,
-0.729892373085022,
-1.1068124771118164,
0.5883830189704895,
-0.40159788727760315,
-0.5014359951019287,
1.3342844247817993,
-0.09444524347782135,
-0.6682177782058716,
-0.18964579701423645,
-0.33443009853363037,
-0.3644462823867798,
-0.5005670189857483,
0.708195686340332,
0.7475401759147644,
0.19805289804935455,
-0.35406550765037537,
-0.5331605672836304,
0.16278724372386932,
0.28787142038345337,
-1.041640281677246,
0.20415587723255157,
0.25900712609291077,
0.356004536151886,
0.27188336849212646,
0.366472452878952,
-0.23475347459316254,
0.3121386170387268,
-0.21452631056308746,
-0.11685216426849365,
0.02839662693440914,
-0.2605884373188019,
-0.19628731906414032,
0.29538625478744507,
0.2571600675582886,
0.16167347133159637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13152v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13152v1 | AnnoTheia: A Semi-Automatic Annotation Toolkit for Audio-Visual Speech Technologies | 2024-02-20T17:07:08 | 2024-02-20T17:07:08 | José-M. Acosta-Triana, David Gimeno-Gómez, Carlos-D. Martínez-Hinarejos | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | More than 7,000 known languages are spoken around the world. However, due to
the lack of annotated resources, only a small fraction of them are currently
covered by speech technologies. Albeit self-supervised speech representations,
recent massive speech corpora collections, as well as the organization of
challenges, have alleviated this inequality, most studies are mainly
benchmarked on English. This situation is aggravated when tasks involving both
acoustic and visual speech modalities are addressed. In order to promote
research on low-resource languages for audio-visual speech technologies, we
present AnnoTheia, a semi-automatic annotation toolkit that detects when a
person speaks on the scene and the corresponding transcription. In addition, to
show the complete process of preparing AnnoTheia for a language of interest, we
also describe the adaptation of a pre-trained model for active speaker
detection to Spanish, using a database not initially conceived for this type of
task. The AnnoTheia toolkit, tutorials, and pre-trained models are available on
GitHub. | [
-0.6595731377601624,
-0.8882795572280884,
0.26164063811302185,
0.23342680931091309,
-0.30371159315109253,
-0.14199428260326385,
-0.38496699929237366,
-0.8817930221557617,
0.5575281381607056,
0.44286608695983887,
-0.4353782832622528,
-0.4625789523124695,
-0.2295316606760025,
0.24647359549999237,
-0.51157146692276,
0.4762466847896576,
0.1294730305671692,
-0.0949767604470253,
0.030307218432426453,
-0.1069805696606636,
-0.26246771216392517,
-0.06841319799423218,
-0.4872516691684723,
-0.0034568095579743385,
0.2349267452955246,
0.6189742684364319,
0.4997158348560333,
0.6070759892463684,
0.1775592714548111,
0.43549877405166626,
0.15322257578372955,
0.2623383104801178,
0.04603428766131401,
0.17232312262058258,
0.006272961851209402,
-0.3095768690109253,
-0.23429638147354126,
-0.020073698833584785,
0.6453010439872742,
0.4765394926071167,
-0.007567054126411676,
0.5898118615150452,
-0.2446320354938507,
-0.0654977560043335,
-0.48812249302864075,
0.2676355540752411,
-0.39665356278419495,
0.14421208202838898,
-0.5621755719184875,
-0.45476245880126953,
-0.10275144129991531,
-0.1911996603012085,
0.41075292229652405,
-0.8249853253364563,
0.045757606625556946,
0.14504124224185944,
0.5765617489814758,
0.7446079850196838,
-0.04364508390426636,
-0.2212921380996704,
-0.7625213265419006,
0.5661011934280396,
-0.354995459318161,
0.4347732365131378,
0.6819091439247131,
0.5007402300834656,
0.024159278720617294,
-0.6723080277442932,
-0.7755433320999146,
-0.3699352741241455,
0.1670600026845932,
-0.15107373893260956,
-0.5493538975715637,
-0.03668070584535599,
0.23539991676807404,
0.2995326519012451,
-0.4238547086715698,
0.3778104782104492,
-0.4519059658050537,
-0.6479010581970215,
0.3264588713645935,
-0.5008084774017334,
0.5346186757087708,
-0.33143436908721924,
-0.10831017047166824,
-0.0962926372885704,
-0.3126225471496582,
-0.2038525938987732,
0.45832687616348267,
0.3742227554321289,
-0.29856032133102417,
0.5493740439414978,
-0.016210701316595078,
1.0684186220169067,
-0.3592666685581207,
-0.3042945861816406,
0.6026408672332764,
-0.017983250319957733,
-0.22706198692321777,
0.4245639145374298,
0.7653506398200989,
0.012394651770591736,
0.42433488368988037,
0.022849058732390404,
-0.11076986789703369,
0.375212162733078,
0.02249985560774803,
-0.47070103883743286,
-0.4232344925403595,
0.07883448153734207,
-0.0671577975153923,
-0.18746857345104218,
-0.14765526354312897,
-0.5168014168739319,
-0.3200763463973999,
-0.3624139130115509,
0.5650278925895691,
-0.14327819645404816,
-0.32290443778038025,
-0.11404567211866379,
-0.13229447603225708,
-0.22260840237140656,
0.35423368215560913,
-0.6404013633728027,
0.2493935227394104,
0.11900076270103455,
0.8705479502677917,
0.10849656164646149,
-0.3870314955711365,
-0.8506297469139099,
-0.06337739527225494,
-0.21320019662380219,
0.992378830909729,
-0.4254293739795685,
-0.3049103319644928,
0.10248150676488876,
0.17678290605545044,
0.18652713298797607,
-0.5435258150100708,
0.6300331354141235,
-0.006930943112820387,
0.43589410185813904,
-0.09469592571258545,
-0.32000574469566345,
-0.22270312905311584,
-0.03420660272240639,
-0.6976673603057861,
1.1652086973190308,
-0.04971284046769142,
-0.7459157109260559,
0.20947356522083282,
-0.5974521040916443,
-0.4560253620147705,
0.32858866453170776,
-0.37516579031944275,
-0.28042998909950256,
-0.008104624226689339,
0.2797008752822876,
0.3589944839477539,
-0.21772310137748718,
-0.06924011558294296,
-0.1475793570280075,
-0.22860874235630035,
0.1512579768896103,
-0.21063382923603058,
0.705737292766571,
0.29133298993110657,
-0.48944801092147827,
0.1729135811328888,
-0.9932727813720703,
-0.18694756925106049,
-0.017053959891200066,
-0.006761349271982908,
-0.5553337335586548,
-0.161863312125206,
0.4646720588207245,
0.33351197838783264,
0.41320616006851196,
-0.8956915140151978,
-0.08609874546527863,
-0.4121689200401306,
0.5182766914367676,
0.42677217721939087,
-0.025744466111063957,
0.2514515817165375,
0.10233865678310394,
0.4735073745250702,
-0.26563024520874023,
0.20575101673603058,
-0.361524760723114,
-0.522616446018219,
-0.8032701015472412,
-0.6796715259552002,
0.18979662656784058,
0.7417961359024048,
-0.8580797910690308,
0.2650652825832367,
0.07942207902669907,
-0.5529420375823975,
-0.9409653544425964,
0.23399658501148224,
0.433034747838974,
0.6846699714660645,
0.3562872111797333,
-0.17738443613052368,
-0.7866732478141785,
-1.1464134454727173,
0.11857786029577255,
-0.4138154685497284,
-0.20083709061145782,
0.1469467431306839,
0.428423136472702,
-0.05385022237896919,
0.7926579713821411,
-0.05853217840194702,
-0.7784934043884277,
0.12854599952697754,
0.28128254413604736,
-0.0010320739820599556,
0.26929932832717896,
0.7075279951095581,
-0.8711938858032227,
-0.15212424099445343,
0.24138054251670837,
-0.7391024827957153,
-0.5984053611755371,
0.1724124252796173,
0.12815701961517334,
0.048638489097356796,
0.4811839461326599,
-0.08576048165559769,
0.30257540941238403,
0.7787559032440186,
-0.19987855851650238,
-0.0732874944806099,
-0.3988366425037384,
0.17994755506515503,
-0.9332127571105957,
0.17628934979438782,
0.35542502999305725,
-0.48658010363578796,
-0.5656678676605225,
-0.4996771514415741,
0.03075561113655567,
-0.23208311200141907,
-0.7095854878425598,
0.7805327773094177,
-0.5038216710090637,
-0.47097504138946533,
-0.36594483256340027,
0.35330867767333984,
-0.40586599707603455,
0.45860403776168823,
0.44767382740974426,
0.9016566872596741,
0.8235913515090942,
-0.5009783506393433,
0.48751601576805115,
0.3312617838382721,
-0.35977864265441895,
0.6367083787918091,
-0.5698111653327942,
-0.07057918608188629,
0.1182485893368721,
-0.13069625198841095,
-0.8277552723884583,
-0.2946920692920685,
0.11667341738939285,
-0.38254645466804504,
0.18548603355884552,
-0.2813386917114258,
-0.5617032051086426,
-0.3410070836544037,
-0.0906948670744896,
0.37590017914772034,
0.4422280192375183,
-0.7064006328582764,
0.4757422208786011,
1.0312986373901367,
-0.15505650639533997,
-0.3104022443294525,
-0.7208743691444397,
0.17866769433021545,
-0.22264504432678223,
-0.6317936778068542,
0.3375948965549469,
0.31638991832733154,
-0.28992581367492676,
-0.006930461619049311,
0.17988426983356476,
0.0066807870753109455,
-0.04271438717842102,
0.3634701073169708,
0.09111712872982025,
0.11489702016115189,
0.12982717156410217,
-0.2018936723470688,
-0.27030420303344727,
-0.2129397988319397,
-0.5585103034973145,
0.30700892210006714,
-0.12094634771347046,
-0.4185473918914795,
-0.9376227259635925,
0.10136282444000244,
0.534312903881073,
-0.553736686706543,
0.14298617839813232,
0.7104036211967468,
-0.6578588485717773,
-0.2714443504810333,
-0.8435488343238831,
-0.04030723497271538,
-0.425393283367157,
0.36077815294265747,
-0.19358289241790771,
-0.6268270015716553,
0.7551922798156738,
0.08158629387617111,
0.152739018201828,
0.31581684947013855,
0.6949925422668457,
-0.1335272490978241,
0.708674967288971,
0.7356992363929749,
0.09529010951519012,
0.926763653755188,
-0.16062551736831665,
-0.08142083138227463,
-0.5576813817024231,
-0.2869625687599182,
-0.6851301193237305,
-0.18939176201820374,
-0.6208099126815796,
-0.6047216653823853,
0.4385231137275696,
-0.5902906656265259,
0.09755635261535645,
0.5197734236717224,
-0.6179593801498413,
0.32076025009155273,
0.8529858589172363,
-0.09062747657299042,
0.24543586373329163,
0.019597020000219345,
0.17467214167118073,
-0.12706783413887024,
-0.46349963545799255,
-0.6631631255149841,
0.7300872802734375,
0.4400671422481537,
0.590671718120575,
0.019243665039539337,
0.7117774486541748,
0.5764737129211426,
0.12375926226377487,
-0.7614491581916809,
0.47960931062698364,
0.022844938561320305,
-0.6296219229698181,
-0.4673839509487152,
-0.25938597321510315,
-0.6468384861946106,
0.15131372213363647,
-0.18312062323093414,
-0.8215242028236389,
0.5084584355354309,
0.5527645945549011,
-0.36083388328552246,
0.10941394418478012,
-0.7995648384094238,
1.1896142959594727,
-0.39431697130203247,
-0.32060059905052185,
0.050873249769210815,
-0.4396704435348511,
-0.028059957548975945,
-0.13420626521110535,
0.4306837320327759,
-0.1394534409046173,
-0.052164774388074875,
1.057521939277649,
-0.29254642128944397,
0.8449483513832092,
-0.44620147347450256,
0.039099015295505524,
0.42421093583106995,
0.05079124495387077,
0.3463325798511505,
-0.15527138113975525,
0.14260414242744446,
0.10694047808647156,
0.0722046047449112,
-0.33773675560951233,
-0.06651312112808228,
0.6568041443824768,
-0.6248957514762878,
-0.11662989854812622,
-0.3578338325023651,
-0.18052972853183746,
-0.09217582643032074,
0.28703370690345764,
0.19233225286006927,
0.4135432243347168,
-0.4737216830253601,
-0.17338746786117554,
0.5620031356811523,
-0.24946917593479156,
0.4086898863315582,
0.4722652733325958,
-0.4144149422645569,
-0.36162054538726807,
0.9706876873970032,
0.26271212100982666,
-0.06983410567045212,
0.16027358174324036,
-0.008505902253091335,
-0.3729027509689331,
-0.4734017848968506,
-0.6138326525688171,
0.36660829186439514,
-0.7535962462425232,
0.17172253131866455,
-0.6037604808807373,
0.42443495988845825,
-0.22753657400608063,
-0.009128008969128132,
-0.6211847066879272,
-0.6685271263122559,
-0.3438658118247986,
-0.11759363114833832,
0.3494236171245575,
0.4645210802555084,
-0.10828835517168045,
0.2592674791812897,
-0.2506673336029053,
0.5138635635375977,
0.48121464252471924,
-0.07419049739837646,
-0.40927305817604065,
-0.6112824082374573,
-0.18642620742321014,
-0.20507919788360596,
0.09640582650899887,
-1.0436311960220337,
0.574948251247406,
0.48395204544067383,
0.6451083421707153,
0.4244050979614258,
0.02780301868915558,
0.7039992213249207,
-0.4315791130065918,
0.3984854817390442,
0.0033715118188410997,
-0.8804001212120056,
0.9629389047622681,
-0.216604083776474,
0.2116728276014328,
0.6457239389419556,
0.11771787703037262,
-0.4754433333873749,
-0.6387307047843933,
-0.5966935157775879,
-0.5653806328773499,
0.6715512871742249,
0.23575660586357117,
-0.0656440332531929,
-0.10374902933835983,
-0.19209502637386322,
-0.10031954944133759,
0.22068576514720917,
-0.5907754898071289,
-0.11931103467941284,
-0.4005204141139984,
-0.2382960468530655,
-0.11522191762924194,
0.05976385250687599,
-0.22766907513141632,
-0.20847080647945404,
0.8250478506088257,
-0.1440393328666687,
0.12107893079519272,
0.30437755584716797,
-0.4156253933906555,
-0.3456188440322876,
0.07876811921596527,
0.4681072533130646,
0.49453121423721313,
-0.240536630153656,
0.2308807373046875,
0.09815648198127747,
-0.48426687717437744,
-0.1171623095870018,
0.6232966780662537,
-0.10468707233667374,
0.3574884235858917,
0.5181525945663452,
0.8881837725639343,
0.5498676300048828,
-0.8795990943908691,
0.4966769218444824,
-0.10689350217580795,
0.09035558253526688,
-0.7988227009773254,
-0.18787822127342224,
-0.12841621041297913,
0.2858745753765106,
0.44278860092163086,
0.006582684814929962,
0.2424210011959076,
-0.7163938283920288,
0.13675689697265625,
0.19202905893325806,
-0.39129766821861267,
-0.44764721393585205,
0.7414053082466125,
0.5935493111610413,
-0.5760445594787598,
0.23324373364448547,
-0.15259705483913422,
-0.45629578828811646,
0.38660958409309387,
0.27307265996932983,
0.6716873049736023,
-0.511021614074707,
0.2393883317708969,
0.1704312562942505,
0.4170636236667633,
-0.008783088997006416,
0.5297107100486755,
-0.4158848822116852,
-0.41294893622398376,
-0.2150575816631317,
-0.6899238228797913,
-0.4593645930290222,
-0.24260203540325165,
-0.44305136799812317,
0.5809956192970276,
-0.17944365739822388,
-0.378978967666626,
0.42712366580963135,
-0.0385889858007431,
-0.7434885501861572,
-0.01649266667664051,
0.593819260597229,
0.7888292670249939,
-1.3708746433258057,
0.8516626358032227,
0.9406923651695251,
-0.3562709093093872,
-0.4371114671230316,
-0.5388069748878479,
0.17995594441890717,
-0.8096718192100525,
0.43615633249282837,
0.06638965755701065,
-0.22400625050067902,
0.10284493863582611,
-0.06271076947450638,
-0.5150564908981323,
0.7816211581230164,
0.7015423774719238,
-0.5132812261581421,
0.07363618910312653,
-0.01924939453601837,
0.7128008604049683,
-0.25398361682891846,
0.19608326256275177,
0.4167805314064026,
0.6925691366195679,
0.0816769003868103,
-1.5080350637435913,
-0.4500751197338104,
-0.38408342003822327,
-0.3415941298007965,
0.21886493265628815,
-0.1922179013490677,
0.553153932094574,
-0.017830489203333855,
-0.23681005835533142,
-0.13492754101753235,
0.7462096214294434,
-0.040725044906139374,
0.48967647552490234,
0.5747230648994446,
0.4580325186252594,
0.8800089359283447,
-0.11388841271400452,
0.7715978622436523,
-0.23297449946403503,
-0.032625991851091385,
0.9832454323768616,
-0.03758092597126961,
0.8062857985496521,
0.6363369822502136,
0.061177484691143036,
0.019733844324946404,
0.7926309108734131,
0.02151617966592312,
0.4301411211490631,
-0.030717257410287857,
-0.3114878535270691,
-0.45883649587631226,
-0.47641369700431824,
-0.2720107436180115,
0.7023874521255493,
0.3535216152667999,
-0.3611707389354706,
-0.04708394408226013,
0.4840262234210968,
-0.09431836009025574,
0.22543461620807648,
-0.23606182634830475,
0.6693623065948486,
0.026097211986780167,
-0.5613114237785339,
0.521778404712677,
-0.3022822439670563,
0.46437934041023254,
-0.4573262929916382,
-0.05054545775055885,
0.08225630223751068,
-0.0511980839073658,
-0.3362942337989807,
-0.577519953250885,
-0.020818345248699188,
0.34788280725479126,
0.2314004749059677,
-0.13471408188343048,
0.5007694959640503,
-0.5243958234786987,
-0.6200382709503174,
0.26775282621383667,
0.5399279594421387,
0.3748434782028198,
0.1731051206588745,
-0.4622463881969452,
0.2389238029718399,
0.046150438487529755,
-0.1328340768814087,
-0.14898858964443207,
0.5256473422050476,
-0.26781129837036133,
0.6254477500915527,
0.544722855091095,
0.3202255368232727,
0.2039828598499298,
0.36467060446739197,
0.6320744156837463,
-0.2376059740781784,
-0.7585863471031189,
-0.509319007396698,
0.3422471284866333,
-0.24338878691196442,
-0.47758644819259644,
0.8915705680847168,
0.4856688678264618,
0.9089585542678833,
0.13885921239852905,
0.6128296256065369,
0.03877510875463486,
0.6014798879623413,
-0.36704638600349426,
0.3289899528026581,
-0.5035452842712402,
0.322393536567688,
-0.6210185885429382,
-1.1612136363983154,
-0.486594557762146,
0.8963741064071655,
-0.4005507528781891,
-0.25303125381469727,
0.2664788067340851,
0.7024587392807007,
-0.2710241675376892,
0.005655347835272551,
0.4075399339199066,
0.17935389280319214,
0.25922301411628723,
0.07549445331096649,
0.8338220119476318,
-0.17362158000469208,
0.32749420404434204,
-0.47284695506095886,
-0.4805493950843811,
-0.22346711158752441,
-0.8108144402503967,
-0.8822153210639954,
-0.7911466956138611,
-0.5467038154602051,
0.22435833513736725,
0.12370661646127701,
1.0436692237854004,
0.8475764989852905,
-0.5940989851951599,
-0.28565505146980286,
0.25223276019096375,
-0.2654142677783966,
-0.0028200740925967693,
-0.028482098132371902,
0.3967059254646301,
0.1587967872619629,
-0.9840218424797058,
0.6416701674461365,
0.4258640706539154,
0.1859794706106186,
-0.6136787533760071,
0.060554880648851395,
-0.20847389101982117,
-0.21579618752002716,
0.19848015904426575,
0.9590243101119995,
-0.570375382900238,
-0.14844395220279694,
-0.2655898332595825,
0.306605726480484,
-0.121591717004776,
0.45642808079719543,
-0.9331420063972473,
0.955443263053894,
0.43581750988960266,
0.3063989579677582,
0.6713784337043762,
-0.16007336974143982,
0.32511985301971436,
-0.7781705260276794,
0.9196513891220093,
0.43532469868659973,
0.6337801218032837,
0.6388535499572754,
0.08080250769853592,
0.4167318046092987,
0.08319701254367828,
-0.41002413630485535,
-1.230754017829895,
0.012834439054131508,
-1.0782989263534546,
0.0455574132502079,
0.9023256897926331,
0.09185468405485153,
-0.3823966979980469,
-0.28919416666030884,
-0.47680312395095825,
0.3887072503566742,
-0.41609475016593933,
0.6033353805541992,
0.33106645941734314,
-0.07164878398180008,
-0.2242847979068756,
-0.946560800075531,
0.5813592672348022,
0.17364968359470367,
-0.7846692204475403,
0.03131113946437836,
0.7140252590179443,
-0.0496535561978817,
0.475555419921875,
0.7128466963768005,
0.07897787541151047,
0.5518381595611572,
-0.21993014216423035,
0.3704427182674408,
-0.44168809056282043,
-0.5337891578674316,
-0.15046368539333344,
-0.05057721957564354,
0.2131538838148117,
-0.5597167611122131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13145v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13145v2 | CMDAG: A Chinese Metaphor Dataset with Annotated Grounds as CoT for Boosting Metaphor Generation | 2024-02-20T17:00:41 | 2024-02-21T03:18:04 | Yujie Shao, Xinrong Yao, Xingwei Qu, Chenghua Lin, Shi Wang, Stephen W. Huang, Ge Zhang, Jie Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Metaphor is a prominent linguistic device in human language and literature,
as they add color, imagery, and emphasis to enhance effective communication.
This paper introduces a large-scale high quality annotated Chinese Metaphor
Corpus, which comprises around 28K sentences drawn from a diverse range of
Chinese literary sources, such as poems, prose, song lyrics, etc. To ensure the
accuracy and consistency of our annotations, we introduce a comprehensive set
of guidelines. These guidelines address the facets of metaphor annotation,
including identifying tenors, vehicles, and grounds to handling the
complexities of similes, personifications, juxtapositions, and hyperboles.
Breaking tradition, our approach to metaphor generation emphasizes grounds and
their distinct features rather than the conventional combination of tenors and
vehicles. By integrating "ground" as a CoT (Chain of Thoughts) input, we are
able to generate metaphors that resonate more with real-world intuition. We
test generative models such as Belle, Baichuan, and Chinese-alpaca-33B using
our annotated corpus. These models are able to generate creative and fluent
metaphor sentences more frequently induced by selected samples from our
dataset, demonstrating the value of our corpus for Chinese metaphor research.
The code is available in
https://github.com/JasonShao55/Chinese_Metaphor_Explanation. | [
-0.68929123878479,
-0.5976874828338623,
0.4244421124458313,
0.4866640269756317,
-0.8586494326591492,
-0.34118103981018066,
-0.44514375925064087,
-0.2979724705219269,
0.29842302203178406,
0.46384552121162415,
-0.4794667959213257,
-0.4493366777896881,
-0.49794745445251465,
0.10016205161809921,
-0.3491542935371399,
0.8229677081108093,
0.23948803544044495,
0.005034893751144409,
-0.1292961835861206,
-0.07617129385471344,
-0.8688874244689941,
-0.5153026580810547,
-0.5853149890899658,
-0.08953802287578583,
0.741423487663269,
-0.04428830370306969,
0.8435925841331482,
1.046149492263794,
0.22960823774337769,
0.1547602117061615,
0.05963359400629997,
0.4044179618358612,
-0.23676514625549316,
0.07638117671012878,
-0.10835574567317963,
-0.32997098565101624,
-0.2129751294851303,
0.44206881523132324,
0.37144678831100464,
0.5646138191223145,
-0.08350344747304916,
-0.042804062366485596,
0.05020369961857796,
0.11121626198291779,
-0.6628205180168152,
0.25958970189094543,
-1.103424072265625,
0.26206621527671814,
-0.28749802708625793,
-0.5608680844306946,
-0.2606047987937927,
-0.32387399673461914,
-0.1353062093257904,
-0.9450825452804565,
0.0648333728313446,
0.26583176851272583,
0.9871191382408142,
0.257607638835907,
-0.4472983479499817,
-0.06946626305580139,
-0.10610128194093704,
0.7184080481529236,
-0.42335066199302673,
-0.1141105368733406,
0.18575190007686615,
0.7091854214668274,
-0.059861280024051666,
-0.8890751600265503,
-0.7029975056648254,
-0.3618779182434082,
-0.018242942169308662,
0.20965120196342468,
0.48255929350852966,
-0.036726903170347214,
0.41752442717552185,
0.37202349305152893,
-0.20209535956382751,
-0.09957260638475418,
-0.3166273832321167,
-0.23422296345233917,
0.35339492559432983,
0.21147948503494263,
0.6602638959884644,
-0.141047865152359,
-0.9231314659118652,
-0.2266790121793747,
-1.0371347665786743,
-0.23218974471092224,
0.19989585876464844,
0.5036748051643372,
-0.20411652326583862,
0.3860086500644684,
0.16480664908885956,
0.8394059538841248,
-0.1957157552242279,
-0.07555121183395386,
0.22173228859901428,
-0.2552028000354767,
-0.20358404517173767,
0.32392728328704834,
0.716143012046814,
0.7501322627067566,
0.546054482460022,
-0.32190608978271484,
-0.19306600093841553,
0.4879896342754364,
0.35743847489356995,
-0.7302508354187012,
-0.3009189963340759,
0.04681684449315071,
-0.45883479714393616,
-0.6143626570701599,
0.48448196053504944,
-0.7946341037750244,
-0.5645284056663513,
-0.6468737721443176,
0.10315962135791779,
-0.5850287675857544,
-0.19799061119556427,
-0.17411381006240845,
-0.41659656167030334,
0.44362491369247437,
0.16285589337348938,
-0.8919976949691772,
-0.16082656383514404,
0.7257370352745056,
0.7018905878067017,
-0.18791866302490234,
-0.5834790468215942,
-0.48342275619506836,
0.2737503945827484,
-0.7743727564811707,
0.762579083442688,
-0.47760993242263794,
-0.09304305911064148,
0.137549489736557,
-0.053024016320705414,
-0.05444428324699402,
-0.38616201281547546,
1.140831470489502,
-0.03731808438897133,
0.16067664325237274,
-0.7032713890075684,
-0.3553066551685333,
-0.061060793697834015,
0.4400455057621002,
-0.6701866388320923,
0.7458033561706543,
0.06724636256694794,
-1.030678629875183,
0.43001216650009155,
-0.4579772353172302,
-0.09998741745948792,
0.1855059266090393,
-0.8793882727622986,
0.19504007697105408,
0.026625242084264755,
0.4098185896873474,
0.4409259855747223,
-0.8590103983879089,
0.4698951542377472,
-0.0003938265726901591,
-0.6328368186950684,
0.32490843534469604,
-0.30749452114105225,
1.0957285165786743,
0.4980026185512543,
-0.29984182119369507,
0.0708252564072609,
-0.6795545816421509,
0.15816514194011688,
0.20528852939605713,
0.03709631413221359,
-0.3932711184024811,
-0.22455108165740967,
0.6394327878952026,
0.5615456104278564,
0.03418724238872528,
-0.3588690757751465,
-0.09725087881088257,
-0.2845914363861084,
0.5174754858016968,
0.6131359338760376,
0.024201499298214912,
-0.07742191851139069,
-0.5952896475791931,
0.5706284642219543,
0.413206547498703,
-0.21252860128879547,
-0.7403425574302673,
-0.27706435322761536,
-0.39357390999794006,
-0.29888322949409485,
0.5461958050727844,
0.1303996741771698,
-0.9967794418334961,
0.8478771448135376,
-0.2113703340291977,
-0.5506622791290283,
-0.6128173470497131,
-0.26675471663475037,
0.17857983708381653,
0.6684003472328186,
0.2915307581424713,
-0.07123903930187225,
-0.4638966917991638,
-0.843610942363739,
0.08804786205291748,
-0.08107197284698486,
-0.295584112405777,
0.20330949127674103,
0.08422715961933136,
-0.044268690049648285,
0.8850589990615845,
-0.3923057019710541,
-0.3117489218711853,
0.008772040717303753,
0.20705771446228027,
-0.2369222342967987,
0.46474212408065796,
1.1222516298294067,
-1.0769085884094238,
-0.06201754882931709,
-0.16884568333625793,
-0.9302394390106201,
-0.4114895164966583,
-0.6184874176979065,
-0.6593213081359863,
-0.2279352843761444,
0.3421190679073334,
-0.6502465009689331,
-0.02939773164689541,
0.45943182706832886,
-0.3428986072540283,
0.8521233201026917,
0.1385020911693573,
0.3181714713573456,
-1.2414097785949707,
0.12384773790836334,
-0.12978991866111755,
0.26328834891319275,
-0.19259534776210785,
0.48692262172698975,
0.10230062156915665,
0.08826052397489548,
-0.5455765128135681,
0.5091150403022766,
-0.29280155897140503,
0.26660165190696716,
-0.4374372065067291,
0.6793866157531738,
0.1543443202972412,
0.3599605858325958,
0.1457974761724472,
0.8513224124908447,
0.9728330969810486,
-0.6536722779273987,
0.707763671875,
0.14255699515342712,
-0.1833394169807434,
0.5546977519989014,
-0.4272673428058624,
-0.01527318824082613,
-0.15835776925086975,
0.41657426953315735,
-0.8441469073295593,
-0.15533319115638733,
0.296737939119339,
-0.25374481081962585,
-0.26788294315338135,
0.33168333768844604,
-0.7342590093612671,
-0.11082235723733902,
-0.43224796652793884,
0.5269846320152283,
0.48235005140304565,
-0.9491095542907715,
0.2639574110507965,
0.24563664197921753,
0.41102761030197144,
-0.6122347712516785,
-0.6958152055740356,
0.3856891095638275,
-0.7155199646949768,
-0.3905305862426758,
0.4402622580528259,
-0.05067174509167671,
-0.1707899570465088,
-0.26686471700668335,
0.11689825356006622,
0.049417972564697266,
0.045190609991550446,
0.28331172466278076,
0.2850951552391052,
-0.2553809881210327,
0.1616571545600891,
0.11052882671356201,
-0.07216925919055939,
0.5365309715270996,
-0.366576224565506,
0.6602036356925964,
0.19440293312072754,
0.022039897739887238,
-0.03074498660862446,
0.04102545604109764,
0.5567541718482971,
-0.18122786283493042,
0.7117960453033447,
0.7773451805114746,
-0.7007148265838623,
-0.3370256721973419,
-0.19311566650867462,
-0.004643899854272604,
-0.41694405674934387,
-0.1166924461722374,
-0.4022488594055176,
-0.2275603711605072,
0.442889928817749,
-0.04593750834465027,
0.1594592183828354,
0.6464728116989136,
0.6356763243675232,
0.19873520731925964,
0.35434114933013916,
0.37482643127441406,
-0.162023663520813,
-0.029932761564850807,
0.047898415476083755,
0.03336426615715027,
-0.8533399701118469,
0.07200562953948975,
-0.4164496064186096,
-0.1153494343161583,
-0.5208206176757812,
-0.5875784754753113,
-0.07757887244224548,
0.035082414746284485,
-0.10346656292676926,
0.4252505600452423,
-0.6485876441001892,
0.3890005946159363,
0.3272528350353241,
-0.15413962304592133,
0.10940872877836227,
-0.05197712779045105,
-0.6053783893585205,
-0.29705607891082764,
-0.5730705261230469,
-0.8047080039978027,
0.7361429333686829,
0.15902365744113922,
0.3416273295879364,
-0.3825455605983734,
0.3849600851535797,
0.1310332715511322,
0.31508636474609375,
-0.5808058977127075,
0.6316973567008972,
-0.02803322859108448,
-0.41871291399002075,
0.11325542628765106,
-0.317646324634552,
-0.7800602912902832,
0.3906109631061554,
-0.3843449056148529,
-0.5536329746246338,
-0.07637133449316025,
0.1070253849029541,
-0.27369990944862366,
0.14508257806301117,
-0.21935130655765533,
0.8271899223327637,
-0.3165811598300934,
-0.02546103298664093,
0.16094914078712463,
-0.6124451160430908,
0.7597110271453857,
-0.2839322090148926,
0.024050261825323105,
0.014596751891076565,
-0.09719241410493851,
0.5863227248191833,
-0.11895531415939331,
0.44308581948280334,
-0.052727360278367996,
-0.2863505780696869,
0.7399499416351318,
-0.09135623276233673,
0.13613609969615936,
-0.1687128245830536,
-0.07832960784435272,
0.25586190819740295,
0.07735266536474228,
-0.2928277552127838,
-0.4910850524902344,
0.7138255834579468,
-0.4007246494293213,
-0.3331700563430786,
-0.41356223821640015,
-0.660760223865509,
-0.0537569485604763,
0.05271783843636513,
0.5675233006477356,
0.05826454609632492,
-0.19711507856845856,
0.3431524932384491,
0.12460435181856155,
-0.5266022086143494,
0.1748047173023224,
-0.45577237010002136,
-0.1274375021457672,
-0.4663625657558441,
0.6419645547866821,
0.023138275370001793,
0.12596842646598816,
0.1670006960630417,
0.1241733580827713,
-0.2235221266746521,
-0.21251386404037476,
-0.5162064433097839,
0.014608584344387054,
-0.8717480897903442,
-0.19160430133342743,
-0.44081124663352966,
-0.5288403034210205,
-0.19450066983699799,
-0.35379093885421753,
0.02362234704196453,
-0.34123513102531433,
0.021086089313030243,
-0.333515465259552,
0.2895231246948242,
0.0015693387249484658,
0.29570382833480835,
0.40239545702934265,
-0.3087756335735321,
0.4736526608467102,
-0.06294664740562439,
0.07038311660289764,
0.09160225838422775,
-0.20712049305438995,
-0.16884073615074158,
0.2749924659729004,
-0.4255860447883606,
-0.8292428851127625,
0.3663763403892517,
-0.17526957392692566,
0.408719927072525,
0.839817225933075,
0.29766273498535156,
0.7769467830657959,
-0.5113416910171509,
1.091026782989502,
0.44122257828712463,
-0.7300532460212708,
0.3543216288089752,
-0.6688457131385803,
-0.13741663098335266,
0.2852303385734558,
-0.07343554496765137,
-0.6127340793609619,
-0.5352736115455627,
-0.6523050665855408,
-0.8831941485404968,
0.2729908525943756,
0.4856409728527069,
0.38653483986854553,
-0.408782422542572,
0.541418194770813,
0.12958405911922455,
0.35722342133522034,
-0.7523558735847473,
-0.4275974631309509,
-0.48107340931892395,
-0.2304919958114624,
-0.09222588688135147,
-0.030208250507712364,
-0.35298675298690796,
0.01868002489209175,
0.2867465913295746,
-0.2630194425582886,
0.2076692283153534,
0.012520447373390198,
0.23106832802295685,
-0.12619014084339142,
0.011312602087855339,
0.30348342657089233,
0.6562461853027344,
0.11777085810899734,
0.40879181027412415,
0.08249428868293762,
-0.34610581398010254,
-0.11213558167219162,
-0.07624781131744385,
-0.24325193464756012,
0.09048723429441452,
0.16356804966926575,
0.49543511867523193,
-0.08472494035959244,
-0.9498717188835144,
0.24741829931735992,
-0.003716320963576436,
-0.049114327877759933,
-0.6209841966629028,
0.3477667570114136,
0.24492798745632172,
-0.05276496335864067,
0.2977193295955658,
-0.2303636223077774,
0.044457387179136276,
-0.47794950008392334,
0.1704522669315338,
0.33326178789138794,
-0.12123666703701019,
-0.0055100517347455025,
1.1234369277954102,
0.09646566957235336,
0.05197305977344513,
0.333198219537735,
-0.15409602224826813,
-0.29799288511276245,
1.0099766254425049,
0.7341930866241455,
1.0154474973678589,
0.2597866356372833,
0.10277224332094193,
0.4883105456829071,
0.3591982424259186,
-0.20353934168815613,
-0.15163710713386536,
0.013068806380033493,
-0.7943418025970459,
0.06326007843017578,
-0.647898256778717,
-0.16679514944553375,
0.4058309495449066,
-0.4490404427051544,
0.6886718273162842,
-0.5277169346809387,
0.07264690846204758,
-0.03464793786406517,
-0.1153571605682373,
-0.561626672744751,
0.6780531406402588,
0.5733193755149841,
1.097489356994629,
-0.9056488871574402,
0.9875115752220154,
0.7750851511955261,
-0.6344008445739746,
-0.8682515025138855,
0.4903242290019989,
-0.23784156143665314,
-0.3342016339302063,
0.5043185353279114,
0.5955405235290527,
-0.07987938076257706,
-0.1336905062198639,
-0.7048065066337585,
-0.2962994873523712,
1.4904383420944214,
0.43225571513175964,
-0.2512064576148987,
0.04014298692345619,
0.05538100749254227,
0.7009019255638123,
-1.0427861213684082,
0.12701265513896942,
0.4687645435333252,
0.4681444764137268,
0.19723032414913177,
-0.5059046149253845,
0.4063969850540161,
-0.29671189188957214,
0.30717718601226807,
-0.391183465719223,
-0.6975412964820862,
1.1308921575546265,
0.08170551806688309,
-0.24955961108207703,
0.38982483744621277,
0.7600540518760681,
0.9855351448059082,
0.36008980870246887,
0.669945240020752,
0.3207950294017792,
0.6181859374046326,
-0.24479776620864868,
0.8134356737136841,
-0.594178318977356,
0.05296451598405838,
0.9063997864723206,
-0.10766630619764328,
0.3747272193431854,
0.45765891671180725,
0.3569677770137787,
0.2839646637439728,
0.866226851940155,
-0.2572677433490753,
0.340920627117157,
0.42550748586654663,
-0.12702986598014832,
-0.19734907150268555,
-0.3741074204444885,
-0.5036125779151917,
0.3398951590061188,
0.2659793794155121,
-0.799588143825531,
-0.27800583839416504,
-0.1545763909816742,
0.07457514107227325,
0.4923856258392334,
-0.18091647326946259,
0.19464780390262604,
0.19214534759521484,
-0.7676774263381958,
0.7360828518867493,
0.2392692118883133,
0.6037105321884155,
-0.3139934837818146,
-0.35372838377952576,
0.0010838201269507408,
-0.2085060179233551,
0.018196744844317436,
-0.4504181146621704,
0.033408068120479584,
-0.011906865984201431,
0.29554492235183716,
-0.0064283329993486404,
0.47929316759109497,
-0.49868205189704895,
-0.40955138206481934,
0.3782474398612976,
0.43731406331062317,
0.3203412592411041,
-0.12102042883634567,
-0.6023656725883484,
0.0013711791252717376,
-0.2029777318239212,
-0.09041494876146317,
0.19146862626075745,
1.0716856718063354,
-0.3001987934112549,
0.35281693935394287,
0.4660387337207794,
0.2954387366771698,
-0.09976327419281006,
0.1859423965215683,
0.9608727097511292,
-0.8563112616539001,
-0.7303475737571716,
-0.8058385252952576,
0.3410095274448395,
-0.047227807343006134,
-0.5013984441757202,
0.49335482716560364,
0.40190643072128296,
0.6400948166847229,
-0.21829526126384735,
0.9576975107192993,
-0.27907058596611023,
-0.05433227866888046,
-0.7006411552429199,
1.0270720720291138,
-0.3008343279361725,
0.28680220246315,
-0.3667960464954376,
-1.108656883239746,
-0.34995490312576294,
0.8411015272140503,
0.168535977602005,
0.23935039341449738,
0.826370894908905,
0.6605864763259888,
-0.1659618616104126,
0.04151894897222519,
0.4290558099746704,
0.15828146040439606,
0.288652628660202,
0.5041589140892029,
0.8623934388160706,
-0.5146719813346863,
0.34340912103652954,
-0.23784981667995453,
0.018225111067295074,
0.19030798971652985,
-1.0969339609146118,
-0.9957607984542847,
-0.7066671252250671,
-0.26432672142982483,
-0.3306661546230316,
-0.010243849828839302,
1.231155514717102,
0.5285330414772034,
-0.5359923243522644,
-0.096035897731781,
-0.3133965730667114,
-0.21953578293323517,
-0.46404293179512024,
-0.2859627604484558,
0.5168696045875549,
-0.6666579842567444,
-0.8372481465339661,
-0.0691118985414505,
-0.07215873897075653,
-0.08073195815086365,
-0.3261984586715698,
-0.005967285484075546,
0.014660583809018135,
0.3383660614490509,
0.48798897862434387,
-0.16354501247406006,
-1.0025819540023804,
-0.38162368535995483,
-0.3580983877182007,
-0.4012950360774994,
0.03519519418478012,
0.8383346199989319,
-0.9910575151443481,
0.2699883282184601,
-0.0005697039305232465,
0.673594057559967,
-0.26365935802459717,
0.5324327349662781,
0.6469581723213196,
-0.8904663920402527,
0.3946141302585602,
0.07396578043699265,
0.5650854706764221,
0.4112302362918854,
-0.4023473858833313,
0.566660463809967,
0.3156549334526062,
-0.19675669074058533,
-0.8689849972724915,
0.09829426556825638,
-1.296288013458252,
-0.30786827206611633,
1.3065769672393799,
-0.3116242289543152,
-0.09227243810892105,
0.2942827045917511,
-0.7559768557548523,
0.4462110996246338,
-0.07625127583742142,
1.309645652770996,
1.0452053546905518,
0.31816381216049194,
-0.2913627624511719,
-0.5702001452445984,
0.665104329586029,
0.15536290407180786,
-0.938262939453125,
0.47035011649131775,
0.6794498562812805,
-0.02887408621609211,
0.24581380188465118,
0.2378876656293869,
-0.33579596877098083,
0.3428236246109009,
0.2653791308403015,
0.23270656168460846,
-0.019497543573379517,
-0.37027567625045776,
-0.03434668481349945,
0.2128235399723053,
0.007826358079910278,
-0.4381924271583557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13137v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13137v2 | The Hidden Space of Transformer Language Adapters | 2024-02-20T16:53:26 | 2024-06-10T06:53:58 | Jesujoba O. Alabi, Marius Mosbach, Matan Eyal, Dietrich Klakow, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL | We analyze the operation of transformer language adapters, which are small
modules trained on top of a frozen language model to adapt its predictions to
new target languages. We show that adapted predictions mostly evolve in the
source language the model was trained on, while the target language becomes
pronounced only in the very last layers of the model. Moreover, the adaptation
process is gradual and distributed across layers, where it is possible to skip
small groups of adapters without decreasing adaptation performance. Last, we
show that adapters operate on top of the model's frozen representation space
while largely preserving its structure, rather than on an 'isolated' subspace.
Our findings provide a deeper view into the adaptation process of language
models to new languages, showcasing the constraints imposed on it by the
underlying model and introduces practical implications to enhance its
efficiency. | [
-0.21596167981624603,
-0.05572846531867981,
0.5735067129135132,
0.010733610019087791,
0.0681668147444725,
0.2546127140522003,
-0.23707735538482666,
-0.28790482878685,
-0.09936384856700897,
0.5377728939056396,
-0.4792771339416504,
-0.06177971512079239,
-0.6056811809539795,
-0.22728905081748962,
-0.04586545750498772,
0.7703394293785095,
-0.030454566702246666,
-0.21557645499706268,
0.027352333068847656,
-0.07815126329660416,
-0.7524513602256775,
-0.10529454052448273,
-0.358037531375885,
-0.4640645980834961,
0.06823901832103729,
0.6691762804985046,
1.0239039659500122,
0.847963273525238,
0.118995800614357,
0.33589407801628113,
-0.16421693563461304,
-0.5996863842010498,
-0.48822781443595886,
0.029142951592803,
-0.22681096196174622,
-0.9843122959136963,
-0.1366698145866394,
-0.23240119218826294,
0.8549213409423828,
0.6809666156768799,
-0.20045188069343567,
-0.1432337462902069,
-0.06844893097877502,
0.4542427361011505,
-0.4223722219467163,
0.24951429665088654,
-0.8958545923233032,
0.2912222445011139,
0.041050393134355545,
0.3332793414592743,
-0.7019941806793213,
-0.14808620512485504,
0.27581658959388733,
-0.49048423767089844,
0.38979896903038025,
-0.12270950525999069,
0.5449953079223633,
0.2650531530380249,
-0.17910663783550262,
0.0370485782623291,
-1.186618447303772,
0.7198469042778015,
-0.3767399787902832,
0.49975234270095825,
-0.0038531331811100245,
0.7543894052505493,
-0.19500082731246948,
-0.6082434058189392,
-0.5427406430244446,
-0.13480612635612488,
-0.1798037588596344,
0.2031600922346115,
-0.8612031936645508,
-0.33518117666244507,
0.163819819688797,
0.30175599455833435,
-0.18049460649490356,
0.28510183095932007,
-0.46856027841567993,
-0.09021931886672974,
0.3410433828830719,
-0.21808764338493347,
0.34978461265563965,
0.04363510012626648,
-0.10021814703941345,
-0.400501012802124,
-0.5355622172355652,
-0.10294298082590103,
0.16163095831871033,
0.23153096437454224,
-0.3875391185283661,
0.2578391432762146,
0.20752692222595215,
0.3555630147457123,
0.12080340832471848,
0.20737795531749725,
0.2493046522140503,
0.40760862827301025,
-0.16226826608181,
-0.14390869438648224,
0.43181687593460083,
-0.003848643973469734,
0.23465219140052795,
-0.2979187071323395,
-0.1735696643590927,
-0.07454043626785278,
0.3873286545276642,
-0.4522528052330017,
-0.6200716495513916,
-0.3302900195121765,
-0.31318220496177673,
-0.04378725215792656,
-0.3075694143772125,
-0.3953302502632141,
-0.3388989567756653,
0.3704938292503357,
0.23144131898880005,
-0.4067339599132538,
-0.5440106391906738,
0.03814273700118065,
-0.28804177045822144,
0.21099112927913666,
0.31664690375328064,
-1.0048284530639648,
0.878595232963562,
0.5003131628036499,
0.6424593925476074,
-0.11453687399625778,
-0.3685869574546814,
-0.17890538275241852,
0.14744651317596436,
-0.4670659899711609,
0.9094634056091309,
-0.8258760571479797,
-0.1916416883468628,
0.012864469550549984,
0.4053093194961548,
-0.3596818149089813,
-0.684985339641571,
0.45474499464035034,
-0.7161297798156738,
0.3164018988609314,
0.031811438500881195,
-0.27777963876724243,
-0.30924203991889954,
-0.3133395314216614,
-0.9749123454093933,
0.7807888388633728,
0.3658920228481293,
-0.18739564716815948,
0.42758697271347046,
-0.8665227293968201,
-0.1681966483592987,
0.2070208042860031,
0.13579489290714264,
-0.3038681745529175,
0.7558852434158325,
0.21646858751773834,
0.36776986718177795,
-0.11136303842067719,
-0.3285461962223053,
0.0367942750453949,
-0.23459221422672272,
0.5118035674095154,
-0.2856161594390869,
0.413947194814682,
0.18301165103912354,
-0.22001972794532776,
-0.007969346828758717,
-0.6256924867630005,
-0.24222861230373383,
0.21532680094242096,
-0.4585675001144409,
-0.37569117546081543,
0.056754253804683685,
0.0688236802816391,
0.2910623252391815,
-0.14779147505760193,
-0.5572870969772339,
0.3801766037940979,
-0.42557355761528015,
0.40525001287460327,
0.6255277991294861,
-0.34133127331733704,
1.0899848937988281,
0.13246281445026398,
0.7958254814147949,
0.2677062451839447,
0.1026482954621315,
-0.2870796024799347,
-0.5720625519752502,
-1.0195362567901611,
0.23106275498867035,
0.28648990392684937,
0.32921433448791504,
-0.7876659035682678,
0.11573915928602219,
-0.5104014873504639,
-0.5696573853492737,
-0.663411557674408,
-0.08627030998468399,
0.011679127812385559,
-0.009148742072284222,
0.08543185144662857,
-0.06290749460458755,
-0.21365147829055786,
-1.0689880847930908,
-0.38056090474128723,
-0.14927998185157776,
-0.10538818687200546,
0.16425563395023346,
0.4537907540798187,
-0.2911345660686493,
0.6763913631439209,
-0.704279363155365,
-0.06882670521736145,
-0.476215660572052,
-0.32315635681152344,
0.5730436444282532,
0.5734557509422302,
0.7499216198921204,
-0.7559612989425659,
-0.6539236307144165,
0.35375285148620605,
-0.33016395568847656,
0.13645683228969574,
-0.13321653008460999,
0.024329708889126778,
-0.12732884287834167,
0.5637364387512207,
-0.4994056522846222,
0.16887137293815613,
1.036925196647644,
-0.3160078525543213,
0.05003819987177849,
-0.25344496965408325,
-0.466776043176651,
-1.0350842475891113,
-0.20060928165912628,
-0.4528372287750244,
-0.24945123493671417,
-1.052432656288147,
0.04764297977089882,
0.2340506613254547,
-0.3103434443473816,
-0.29071950912475586,
0.5459717512130737,
-0.7715883851051331,
-0.07832475751638412,
-0.5537688136100769,
0.19163571298122406,
-0.2799946665763855,
0.44977691769599915,
0.14708822965621948,
0.5815596580505371,
0.8982083797454834,
-0.3138675093650818,
-0.1655896157026291,
0.14792054891586304,
-0.30046841502189636,
-0.19146007299423218,
-0.40538957715034485,
0.4253847301006317,
-0.06960400193929672,
-0.01657801866531372,
-0.9762667417526245,
-0.1316702961921692,
0.1311972588300705,
-0.126925528049469,
0.3977251350879669,
-0.5374107360839844,
-0.018480772152543068,
-0.3468848466873169,
0.019890710711479187,
0.4790736138820648,
0.8688943982124329,
-0.38946446776390076,
0.7681112885475159,
0.6403598189353943,
0.06782277673482895,
-0.4644576907157898,
-0.8086205124855042,
0.06605100631713867,
-0.025836290791630745,
-0.4214160740375519,
0.15739604830741882,
-0.17320366203784943,
-0.03558621183037758,
0.3138943910598755,
-0.11883264780044556,
-0.2401459664106369,
0.15590369701385498,
0.39101850986480713,
-0.035964567214250565,
-0.5731437802314758,
-0.12450464814901352,
0.2928012013435364,
-0.1790253072977066,
-0.10171493887901306,
-0.5614098310470581,
0.6102885603904724,
-0.2740762233734131,
-0.23744308948516846,
-0.0029003252275288105,
0.10361694544553757,
0.7908828258514404,
0.32118839025497437,
1.0905030965805054,
0.41678184270858765,
-0.6414623856544495,
-0.26898065209388733,
-0.44982409477233887,
0.06168406456708908,
-0.5696898698806763,
0.47753483057022095,
-0.638422966003418,
-0.8452707529067993,
0.8195844292640686,
-0.23889222741127014,
-0.03645654767751694,
0.727635383605957,
0.3203655183315277,
0.2751120626926422,
0.8289186358451843,
1.4100890159606934,
-0.09606780111789703,
0.5975990295410156,
-0.15186935663223267,
0.24847322702407837,
-0.9037132859230042,
-0.1967199295759201,
-0.5136989951133728,
-0.31883591413497925,
-0.8509747385978699,
-0.8313112258911133,
0.14308424293994904,
0.28225868940353394,
0.32609838247299194,
0.8255579471588135,
-0.3925599455833435,
0.7647958993911743,
0.1482863575220108,
-0.21649914979934692,
-0.11244190484285355,
0.1393628567457199,
-0.3089848458766937,
-0.305305153131485,
-1.2042546272277832,
-0.12419062852859497,
0.5495930910110474,
0.781386137008667,
0.6401461958885193,
0.25706198811531067,
0.3515264689922333,
0.026898259297013283,
0.3689797520637512,
-0.7760733366012573,
0.26595181226730347,
-0.35140565037727356,
-0.49116969108581543,
-0.22042639553546906,
-0.05896243453025818,
-0.9621391296386719,
0.28714168071746826,
-0.061324745416641235,
-0.8548868298530579,
0.508159339427948,
0.02297813445329666,
-0.09408412128686905,
0.4634319245815277,
-0.8809751868247986,
0.652746856212616,
0.20467858016490936,
-0.07759504020214081,
-0.2950957119464874,
-0.4421120285987854,
0.05354061722755432,
-0.2564477324485779,
0.3402808606624603,
0.04137622192502022,
0.2872195541858673,
0.9077185988426208,
0.03875941038131714,
0.7790330052375793,
-0.30080246925354004,
0.028189094737172127,
0.018768368288874626,
0.5018078088760376,
0.40699437260627747,
-0.2666444182395935,
-0.11650662869215012,
0.18437731266021729,
-0.30735787749290466,
-0.48600760102272034,
-0.6639237403869629,
0.5019814968109131,
-0.9297325015068054,
-0.7923350930213928,
-0.21393947303295135,
-0.7837674617767334,
-0.06330900639295578,
0.4134446978569031,
0.02587270550429821,
0.07405125349760056,
-0.26305118203163147,
0.17647898197174072,
0.5453904271125793,
-0.603370726108551,
0.5812233686447144,
0.7092924118041992,
-0.29986000061035156,
0.016982650384306908,
0.5690966248512268,
-0.09725891053676605,
0.34445908665657043,
0.7597715258598328,
0.5990360975265503,
-0.05752306431531906,
-0.7063766121864319,
-0.5102658867835999,
0.3837164342403412,
-0.9396443367004395,
-0.004403516184538603,
-0.6030484437942505,
-0.4930814504623413,
-0.2610730230808258,
-0.2681576609611511,
-0.6224880814552307,
-0.6843484044075012,
-0.03215162083506584,
-0.1604914367198944,
0.27406010031700134,
1.0809425115585327,
-0.13037505745887756,
0.8345555663108826,
-0.8718608617782593,
-0.006688706576824188,
0.31986457109451294,
0.43033042550086975,
-0.07644441723823547,
-0.8687804937362671,
-0.676657497882843,
-0.23560404777526855,
0.11776717007160187,
-0.6901901960372925,
0.47605642676353455,
0.38095468282699585,
0.7724220752716064,
0.28370916843414307,
-0.33966735005378723,
0.6306735277175903,
-0.9710773825645447,
0.7127500772476196,
0.1593097746372223,
-1.069351077079773,
0.38066381216049194,
-0.10710104554891586,
0.8395583033561707,
0.09712301194667816,
0.10250993072986603,
-0.5649223923683167,
-0.4328022599220276,
-0.6469604969024658,
-0.3997997045516968,
1.0402300357818604,
0.15073233842849731,
0.7548542022705078,
0.3239973783493042,
0.4975360929965973,
0.33807796239852905,
0.05845584347844124,
-0.9372327327728271,
-0.231795996427536,
-0.18064264953136444,
0.14174285531044006,
-0.16518598794937134,
-0.45373788475990295,
-0.060196489095687866,
-0.1334289014339447,
0.1646272987127304,
-0.2863243520259857,
0.8460904955863953,
-0.4193779230117798,
-0.25536537170410156,
-0.6067264080047607,
0.25539958477020264,
0.5397190451622009,
0.4512716233730316,
0.1498170644044876,
0.2260013073682785,
0.4909322261810303,
-0.7111249566078186,
-0.029596569016575813,
-0.24758093059062958,
0.012627460062503815,
0.08077144622802734,
0.5819185376167297,
1.2392327785491943,
0.4054010808467865,
-0.1922604739665985,
0.3857174217700958,
-0.3246060609817505,
0.17176030576229095,
-0.547200083732605,
0.383332222700119,
0.178191676735878,
0.5244994759559631,
0.4281781315803528,
0.8253889679908752,
-0.07112327218055725,
-0.6027083396911621,
0.2769021689891815,
0.2231399118900299,
-0.6956487894058228,
-0.9073882102966309,
0.700153648853302,
-0.28792572021484375,
-0.5953330397605896,
0.36382076144218445,
0.27362799644470215,
-0.751215398311615,
0.2546445429325104,
1.0538913011550903,
1.2340245246887207,
-0.7752405405044556,
0.3842104971408844,
0.00416431063786149,
0.6523401141166687,
0.052028682082891464,
-0.09253619611263275,
0.05271298438310623,
-1.131978154182434,
-0.2824869751930237,
-0.6383259892463684,
-0.09265444427728653,
0.005898772738873959,
-0.6126089692115784,
0.24737921357154846,
-0.33076977729797363,
0.16585732996463776,
-0.08616805821657181,
-0.5670986771583557,
-0.7550808191299438,
0.04321083426475525,
0.24979747831821442,
1.3288156986236572,
-1.1916006803512573,
1.246442437171936,
0.5873215794563293,
0.2860601246356964,
-0.7676418423652649,
0.2130221575498581,
-0.4443926513195038,
-1.2587697505950928,
0.5242538452148438,
-0.2258259654045105,
-0.25415685772895813,
-0.17973190546035767,
-0.36686110496520996,
-1.1276123523712158,
0.8536927103996277,
0.6917868256568909,
-0.5426490306854248,
0.02867564931511879,
0.22477439045906067,
0.9148175716400146,
-0.538430392742157,
0.23352743685245514,
0.5973374843597412,
0.30599409341812134,
0.03278917446732521,
-0.7403308153152466,
0.24708522856235504,
-0.4882429242134094,
0.1518828421831131,
0.07390382885932922,
-0.5477331280708313,
0.8835915923118591,
-0.11805981397628784,
-0.35746920108795166,
-0.12323612719774246,
0.5527222156524658,
-0.3845771551132202,
-0.28414952754974365,
0.695503830909729,
0.09819956868886948,
0.4627566933631897,
-0.09963014721870422,
1.0753811597824097,
-0.11880651116371155,
0.23469412326812744,
0.8249061703681946,
-0.1363275647163391,
0.9471733570098877,
0.38431569933891296,
0.04885203391313553,
0.8785417675971985,
0.11306963115930557,
-0.1287916898727417,
0.8359977602958679,
-0.04921870678663254,
0.10259180516004562,
-0.0424668975174427,
0.020811550319194794,
-0.08741135895252228,
0.41009390354156494,
0.611798107624054,
-0.32663998007774353,
-0.03133412450551987,
0.1923331320285797,
0.07491570711135864,
-0.06710010021924973,
-0.010201898403465748,
0.7217228412628174,
0.15373730659484863,
-0.5298944115638733,
0.6174860000610352,
0.017103279009461403,
0.09065031260251999,
-0.40189245343208313,
0.011789696291089058,
-0.2179354429244995,
0.2786504030227661,
-0.09081011265516281,
-0.8168218731880188,
0.35331016778945923,
-0.3353627324104309,
-0.3114160895347595,
-0.2841973602771759,
0.8574934601783752,
-0.36849793791770935,
-0.5326516032218933,
0.6630588173866272,
0.5053459405899048,
0.1496715247631073,
0.3072124719619751,
-0.4828713536262512,
0.19431182742118835,
0.035753294825553894,
-0.194797083735466,
0.31850218772888184,
0.5666239857673645,
-0.07965140789747238,
0.6476324200630188,
0.34220877289772034,
0.24657267332077026,
0.4273328185081482,
0.05002644285559654,
1.1151585578918457,
-0.4779757261276245,
-0.5947895050048828,
-0.6971810460090637,
0.6419398784637451,
0.13686694204807281,
-0.08168847113847733,
0.7469264268875122,
0.36247751116752625,
0.8588999509811401,
-0.4500836730003357,
0.7070356011390686,
0.08449964970350266,
0.13396558165550232,
-0.5600953698158264,
0.8185097575187683,
-0.2613731920719147,
0.46085724234580994,
-0.4018540680408478,
-1.090194821357727,
-0.3590046763420105,
0.43267104029655457,
-0.3230486512184143,
-0.13345874845981598,
0.8081310987472534,
0.5440881848335266,
-0.38331639766693115,
-0.24262750148773193,
0.7754407525062561,
0.5534862279891968,
0.24430499970912933,
0.45515331625938416,
1.0451557636260986,
-0.7213068604469299,
0.32694125175476074,
-0.32064032554626465,
-0.2249433398246765,
-0.0938720628619194,
-0.666975200176239,
-0.8980369567871094,
-0.7632576823234558,
-0.24331630766391754,
-0.04965631663799286,
-0.2094324231147766,
0.39886343479156494,
0.9158324599266052,
-1.0353871583938599,
-0.5857568383216858,
-0.09225969761610031,
0.17848041653633118,
-0.33110061287879944,
-0.24729272723197937,
0.22185494005680084,
0.13221411406993866,
-0.8077101111412048,
0.8354867100715637,
0.3057747483253479,
-0.020827766507864,
-0.06981982290744781,
-0.015141120180487633,
0.22322258353233337,
0.00015851941134314984,
0.3502795398235321,
0.15695707499980927,
-0.5248581171035767,
-0.6635152101516724,
0.35793232917785645,
0.34466955065727234,
0.3050489127635956,
1.1095404624938965,
-0.8315819501876831,
0.529619574546814,
0.2624439001083374,
0.49193477630615234,
0.7964927554130554,
-0.6353816986083984,
0.8706715703010559,
-0.8131164312362671,
0.46924376487731934,
0.05115332454442978,
0.3913143575191498,
0.2700415849685669,
-0.3395080268383026,
0.015578638762235641,
0.009484890848398209,
-0.25504380464553833,
-0.8533964157104492,
0.27673467993736267,
-0.6869955658912659,
-0.3915966749191284,
0.8891751766204834,
-0.16349557042121887,
-0.2996814548969269,
-0.19738411903381348,
-0.020322471857070923,
0.39962297677993774,
-0.3138130307197571,
0.8133400082588196,
0.5008093118667603,
-0.13479748368263245,
-0.6022710204124451,
-0.6076546311378479,
0.6135265827178955,
0.19125699996948242,
-0.45417729020118713,
0.2175064980983734,
-0.06374343484640121,
0.42311668395996094,
0.6158055663108826,
0.2555716931819916,
0.030510755255818367,
0.010542312636971474,
0.2289750874042511,
-0.10027167201042175,
0.30570051074028015,
-0.5657270550727844,
-0.933251142501831,
0.2814062833786011,
0.3857496380805969,
-0.14803551137447357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13130v1 | Are ELECTRA's Sentence Embeddings Beyond Repair? The Case of Semantic Textual Similarity | 2024-02-20T16:43:20 | 2024-02-20T16:43:20 | Ivan Rep, David Dukić, Jan Šnajder | cs.CL | cs.CL | While BERT produces high-quality sentence embeddings, its pre-training
computational cost is a significant drawback. In contrast, ELECTRA delivers a
cost-effective pre-training objective and downstream task performance
improvements, but not as performant sentence embeddings. The community tacitly
stopped utilizing ELECTRA's sentence embeddings for semantic textual similarity
(STS). We notice a significant drop in performance when using the ELECTRA
discriminator's last layer in comparison to earlier layers. We explore this
drop and devise a way to repair ELECTRA's embeddings, proposing a novel
truncated model fine-tuning (TMFT) method. TMFT improves the Spearman
correlation coefficient by over 8 points while increasing parameter efficiency
on the STS benchmark dataset. We extend our analysis to various model sizes and
languages. Further, we discover the surprising efficacy of ELECTRA's generator
model, which performs on par with BERT, using significantly fewer parameters
and a substantially smaller embedding size. Finally, we observe further boosts
by combining TMFT with a word similarity task or domain adaptive pre-training. | [
-0.1304234266281128,
-0.7606050968170166,
0.7999659776687622,
-0.36563315987586975,
-0.3437272012233734,
0.25803178548812866,
-0.2935691475868225,
-0.41623008251190186,
0.26373469829559326,
0.6869441866874695,
-0.46125122904777527,
-0.20437490940093994,
-0.44616907835006714,
0.1633361279964447,
-0.5443199276924133,
0.8676193356513977,
-0.00207835016772151,
-0.37881988286972046,
-0.2600111961364746,
-0.09796827286481857,
-0.46250689029693604,
-0.22935892641544342,
-0.3327399492263794,
-0.38595500588417053,
0.585780680179596,
0.7157161235809326,
0.6754061579704285,
0.46993711590766907,
0.42002955079078674,
0.312383234500885,
0.002630375325679779,
0.5033106207847595,
-0.7722216248512268,
0.06333468109369278,
-0.13755284249782562,
-0.5525935292243958,
-0.1471743881702423,
-0.17797279357910156,
0.3873090147972107,
0.6118043065071106,
-0.19484655559062958,
-0.015902744606137276,
0.20977972447872162,
0.7616531848907471,
-0.5738042593002319,
-0.2757159471511841,
-1.1857255697250366,
-0.14573746919631958,
-0.13636241853237152,
-0.17622514069080353,
-0.579828143119812,
-0.46369844675064087,
0.28668954968452454,
-0.5351485013961792,
0.4653007686138153,
0.3267829120159149,
1.3727855682373047,
0.4316808581352234,
-0.17842520773410797,
-0.043643880635499954,
-0.6730926632881165,
0.8960643410682678,
-0.5158805847167969,
0.14336413145065308,
0.28518855571746826,
-0.1690702736377716,
-0.0009118916932493448,
-0.7126480937004089,
-0.5032471418380737,
-0.25685274600982666,
0.16508668661117554,
-0.04196983575820923,
-0.5990455746650696,
0.0925072431564331,
0.17886681854724884,
0.01899663731455803,
-0.39430415630340576,
0.28998565673828125,
-0.47733792662620544,
-0.030295170843601227,
0.3276903033256531,
0.17247053980827332,
0.2609637975692749,
-0.24569585919380188,
-0.3832297921180725,
-0.25146225094795227,
-1.0463007688522339,
-0.409713476896286,
0.544516384601593,
0.4209235608577728,
0.32620519399642944,
0.5689528584480286,
0.22938962280750275,
0.5292736291885376,
-0.16361889243125916,
0.46390336751937866,
0.40908417105674744,
0.1177697703242302,
-0.38919609785079956,
0.24904237687587738,
0.41745656728744507,
0.5243072509765625,
0.5384270548820496,
-0.3928525745868683,
-0.015583028085529804,
0.23983047902584076,
0.6327001452445984,
-0.6234615445137024,
-0.42916715145111084,
0.134391188621521,
-0.47213926911354065,
-0.09973829984664917,
0.021168947219848633,
-0.2906702160835266,
-0.1908816397190094,
-0.3228576183319092,
0.6644548177719116,
-0.9386173486709595,
-0.1824161410331726,
0.23481646180152893,
-0.20217251777648926,
0.06488028168678284,
0.1128501296043396,
-0.7316020131111145,
0.30373135209083557,
0.7267540693283081,
0.9453546404838562,
0.24380111694335938,
-0.32442206144332886,
-0.335448682308197,
0.1301942616701126,
-0.19098742306232452,
1.067873477935791,
-0.5820074081420898,
-0.08073285967111588,
0.1472378820180893,
-0.1036200001835823,
-0.4060056507587433,
-0.7172156572341919,
0.614867627620697,
-0.4063703417778015,
-0.16099479794502258,
-0.37223947048187256,
-1.0663504600524902,
0.05397241562604904,
-0.0033166101202368736,
-0.7719177007675171,
0.926396906375885,
0.09186789393424988,
-0.8894533514976501,
0.4881887435913086,
-0.30377209186553955,
-0.35389211773872375,
0.03230281546711922,
0.29991501569747925,
-0.8938547968864441,
0.4457683563232422,
0.026037631556391716,
0.4971911609172821,
-0.05186884105205536,
-0.06781760603189468,
-0.5105448961257935,
-0.5687236189842224,
0.1382148563861847,
0.0334337092936039,
0.2545797526836395,
0.08712919801473618,
-0.11635148525238037,
-0.1926870048046112,
-0.858357846736908,
0.07861529290676117,
-0.07609722018241882,
0.27751126885414124,
-0.836498498916626,
0.2842617630958557,
0.20323291420936584,
0.0764692947268486,
0.17603541910648346,
-0.823867917060852,
-0.047473542392253876,
-0.7982054948806763,
0.991985559463501,
0.8281611800193787,
-0.23638366162776947,
0.29759377241134644,
-0.6490931510925293,
0.20782683789730072,
-0.06261277198791504,
-0.19062577188014984,
-0.022935613989830017,
-0.1702815741300583,
-1.0572155714035034,
-0.1856730878353119,
0.4412769079208374,
0.23471592366695404,
-0.6933975219726562,
0.5641312599182129,
-0.6163714528083801,
-0.6983633637428284,
-0.7357890605926514,
-0.07329398393630981,
0.25324463844299316,
0.329519659280777,
0.5575993657112122,
-0.20794983208179474,
-0.7332354784011841,
-1.0452523231506348,
-0.6797519326210022,
-0.23604872822761536,
-0.022834274917840958,
0.11400996893644333,
0.5457494258880615,
-0.0017956714145839214,
1.008584976196289,
-0.5382170081138611,
-0.41980069875717163,
-0.27283456921577454,
0.06425532698631287,
0.13818149268627167,
0.35173913836479187,
0.5230259895324707,
-0.3100416958332062,
-0.36672383546829224,
-0.15185394883155823,
-0.13883300125598907,
-0.05317433923482895,
-0.08173571527004242,
-0.004895576275885105,
0.13874870538711548,
0.4377194046974182,
-0.6199585199356079,
0.2539665102958679,
0.33884745836257935,
-0.5330662131309509,
0.29587268829345703,
-0.5713865756988525,
0.08861079812049866,
-1.0557550191879272,
-0.10226757824420929,
-0.0772026926279068,
-0.34115809202194214,
-0.47995758056640625,
-0.023633025586605072,
0.213431254029274,
0.1651139259338379,
-0.3123599886894226,
0.029938358813524246,
-0.19716982543468475,
0.07354343682527542,
-0.32036247849464417,
0.2054009735584259,
-0.0013232235796749592,
0.17797860503196716,
-0.29521146416664124,
0.7000302076339722,
0.14536753296852112,
-0.453016459941864,
-0.1219554990530014,
0.38835448026657104,
-0.5692859292030334,
0.47959980368614197,
-1.0390923023223877,
0.2847626805305481,
-0.16589026153087616,
-0.15066559612751007,
-0.8785645365715027,
0.08623020350933075,
-0.3632781505584717,
-0.0672232061624527,
0.13044600188732147,
0.15542112290859222,
-0.6026114225387573,
-0.20492152869701385,
-0.6737312078475952,
0.02707074023783207,
0.7667251229286194,
-0.5595900416374207,
0.4339272379875183,
0.15971167385578156,
-0.1184336394071579,
-0.2609330117702484,
-0.6866869926452637,
0.1110144853591919,
-0.3822125196456909,
-0.7017936706542969,
0.8014549612998962,
0.337072491645813,
-0.10302388668060303,
0.13749909400939941,
0.18298077583312988,
0.037776850163936615,
0.12783728539943695,
0.13657191395759583,
0.11378425359725952,
-0.015227328054606915,
0.5968329906463623,
0.407572478055954,
0.05439825356006622,
-0.21967138350009918,
-0.15302449464797974,
0.6440929174423218,
-0.19255034625530243,
-0.10715404152870178,
-0.003403056412935257,
0.21843920648097992,
0.23824046552181244,
-0.16974486410617828,
1.0337600708007812,
0.38933902978897095,
-0.26145806908607483,
-0.29189878702163696,
-0.7340790033340454,
-0.05213634669780731,
-0.48860231041908264,
0.4045037627220154,
-0.31052088737487793,
-1.145566701889038,
0.3640733063220978,
-0.09807062149047852,
0.005565624218434095,
0.6810299158096313,
0.3139340281486511,
-0.46354180574417114,
0.6476556062698364,
0.9151519536972046,
0.1753864735364914,
0.5713782906532288,
-0.15491808950901031,
0.23808960616588593,
-0.6849379539489746,
-0.20082080364227295,
-0.7745682001113892,
-0.2954889237880707,
-0.5301398634910583,
-0.16774186491966248,
0.2754717767238617,
-0.019003983587026596,
-0.5560734868049622,
0.7428158521652222,
-0.5864279866218567,
0.45754697918891907,
0.47606468200683594,
0.637514054775238,
0.15328054130077362,
0.1454278975725174,
0.03821743279695511,
-0.33185651898384094,
-0.6710063219070435,
-0.7526090741157532,
0.9315110445022583,
0.16765013337135315,
0.761813223361969,
-0.057801179587841034,
0.8027834296226501,
0.3635161817073822,
-0.1549641191959381,
-0.4192787706851959,
0.3553799092769623,
-0.49258989095687866,
-0.0329613983631134,
-0.20284061133861542,
-0.2468329817056656,
-1.2658408880233765,
0.04930531978607178,
-0.15060415863990784,
-0.649877667427063,
0.0673823282122612,
0.1355687975883484,
-0.3234689235687256,
0.47495585680007935,
-0.8543940782546997,
0.6758708953857422,
0.345672070980072,
-0.1390046328306198,
-0.6646544337272644,
-0.5292128920555115,
-0.16332672536373138,
-0.047038380056619644,
-0.011610183864831924,
-0.2602519989013672,
-0.05755167454481125,
0.8091724514961243,
-0.8357619643211365,
0.67144775390625,
0.14111657440662384,
-0.04791954532265663,
-0.04713823273777962,
-0.0979103073477745,
0.3296641707420349,
-0.38626646995544434,
-0.026125773787498474,
-0.05922326818108559,
-0.021309364587068558,
-0.47647449374198914,
-0.337537944316864,
0.7857427597045898,
-0.8404068350791931,
-0.2622911334037781,
-0.1258476972579956,
-0.21571633219718933,
-0.20288574695587158,
-0.020877698436379433,
0.32337069511413574,
0.4896409809589386,
-0.369777649641037,
0.1972319632768631,
0.8056923747062683,
-0.16377855837345123,
0.5702850222587585,
0.24121196568012238,
0.47643929719924927,
-0.10561339557170868,
0.8444864153862,
0.16098171472549438,
0.15243755280971527,
0.49224159121513367,
-0.08203231543302536,
-0.08620625734329224,
-0.26331326365470886,
-0.06933988630771637,
0.2172081172466278,
-0.3376869559288025,
-0.505682110786438,
-0.8176798224449158,
0.036003269255161285,
-0.02548225224018097,
-0.3045918345451355,
-0.46877825260162354,
-0.5972099304199219,
-0.4407462179660797,
-0.29989689588546753,
0.810841977596283,
0.6863712668418884,
0.21706442534923553,
0.1710873693227768,
-0.8763466477394104,
0.059760931879282,
0.12587083876132965,
0.3139534890651703,
0.11825518310070038,
-0.5288768410682678,
-0.33033090829849243,
-0.15354321897029877,
-0.383876770734787,
-0.7531725764274597,
0.3569152355194092,
0.6810719966888428,
0.046889688819646835,
-0.0340433195233345,
0.20011791586875916,
0.7431507110595703,
-1.080850601196289,
0.8598784804344177,
0.08853456377983093,
-1.182725191116333,
0.5963472127914429,
0.020541785284876823,
0.21241721510887146,
0.5702032446861267,
0.010761205106973648,
-0.12640345096588135,
-0.6798869371414185,
-0.7649849057197571,
-1.019736886024475,
0.3017926514148712,
0.31203198432922363,
0.5851051807403564,
-0.18988777697086334,
0.30399370193481445,
0.3400973379611969,
-0.05721966549754143,
-0.2948456108570099,
-0.15319359302520752,
-0.23276402056217194,
-0.36626553535461426,
-0.10789132118225098,
-0.4421134889125824,
0.22464781999588013,
-0.2567104995250702,
0.7117176055908203,
0.024743419140577316,
0.37897008657455444,
0.28565120697021484,
-0.4675975739955902,
-0.16313037276268005,
0.5321866273880005,
0.3011768162250519,
0.6010634899139404,
-0.1125553548336029,
0.01434437744319439,
0.3024899661540985,
-0.38876867294311523,
-0.049068912863731384,
0.29473015666007996,
-0.15769991278648376,
0.1340426802635193,
0.5103988647460938,
0.90179443359375,
0.565632700920105,
-0.8227719068527222,
0.4171299338340759,
0.09685372561216354,
-0.23414941132068634,
-0.3498425781726837,
0.010462179780006409,
-0.17488759756088257,
0.2515874207019806,
0.3998981714248657,
0.11061764508485794,
0.17988930642604828,
-0.4461682140827179,
0.27554935216903687,
0.29046162962913513,
-0.48722296953201294,
-0.22282996773719788,
0.7322792410850525,
0.07088187336921692,
-0.1806061863899231,
0.700395941734314,
0.34048980474472046,
-0.7140235304832458,
0.5254179239273071,
0.3660323917865753,
0.8092660307884216,
0.05163969472050667,
0.48093146085739136,
0.22074371576309204,
0.47984763979911804,
-0.0914839431643486,
0.4080035984516144,
0.24300575256347656,
-0.724109411239624,
-0.45568275451660156,
-0.4166314899921417,
-0.3282647728919983,
-0.43067696690559387,
-0.6733822226524353,
0.25491809844970703,
-0.14981931447982788,
-0.1138605996966362,
-0.04515489563345909,
0.07257890701293945,
-0.8899258971214294,
0.15362662076950073,
-0.1276467740535736,
0.868533194065094,
-0.9035147428512573,
0.6882880926132202,
0.6332453489303589,
-0.41264092922210693,
-0.9732411503791809,
-0.09294654428958893,
-0.7540932297706604,
-0.5143207311630249,
0.351965069770813,
0.3210582435131073,
-0.08927898108959198,
0.15397879481315613,
-0.5194669961929321,
-0.6300954818725586,
1.0614278316497803,
0.7801878452301025,
-0.8019615411758423,
-0.14871203899383545,
0.08676522970199585,
0.729110062122345,
-0.03285868465900421,
0.3965609669685364,
0.6795221567153931,
0.09710463136434555,
-0.27478736639022827,
-1.0949314832687378,
0.1778196394443512,
0.007306176703423262,
0.21425597369670868,
0.5661829710006714,
-0.6899345517158508,
0.8130329251289368,
-0.21161943674087524,
-0.07027255743741989,
0.4719955027103424,
0.6593055129051208,
0.03264728933572769,
0.03368052840232849,
0.57137131690979,
1.0332666635513306,
0.8538261651992798,
-0.19140852987766266,
0.9781421422958374,
-0.15623582899570465,
0.8546867966651917,
0.790861189365387,
-0.4096513092517853,
1.1618729829788208,
0.4815557599067688,
-0.2852315604686737,
1.0051542520523071,
0.37704089283943176,
-0.09770692884922028,
0.7512499094009399,
0.19009630382061005,
0.06255417317152023,
-0.44813525676727295,
-0.0788387879729271,
-0.4548971951007843,
0.33064019680023193,
0.23611408472061157,
-0.6226913332939148,
-0.20559783279895782,
0.19515658915042877,
-0.06862673163414001,
0.44025957584381104,
-0.34257641434669495,
0.5928811430931091,
0.2196425497531891,
-0.3246292173862457,
0.48957398533821106,
-0.10250556468963623,
0.6709475517272949,
-0.3643578290939331,
-0.049813125282526016,
0.032561033964157104,
0.42769181728363037,
-0.11518491059541702,
-0.4894075393676758,
0.34402376413345337,
-0.10567353665828705,
-0.021754316985607147,
-0.165595144033432,
0.9379210472106934,
-0.4408019781112671,
-0.40557190775871277,
0.2210904359817505,
0.42114898562431335,
-0.0892435759305954,
-0.07091126590967178,
-0.4423266351222992,
0.11262992024421692,
-0.2919371724128723,
0.026565421372652054,
0.07260355353355408,
0.2903602719306946,
0.3479135036468506,
0.6291391253471375,
0.27180713415145874,
-0.0325997918844223,
-0.036878492683172226,
0.3540278971195221,
1.0287680625915527,
-0.5851651430130005,
-0.5016323924064636,
-1.0211619138717651,
0.2948824465274811,
-0.3116629719734192,
-0.40472254157066345,
0.6650063395500183,
0.4811655580997467,
0.8833857178688049,
-0.10181785374879837,
0.5550296306610107,
-0.11220408231019974,
0.7115588784217834,
-0.8025948405265808,
0.6579585075378418,
-0.6102755665779114,
0.2069452702999115,
-0.6514541506767273,
-1.08348548412323,
-0.19606226682662964,
0.5308287143707275,
-0.16991911828517914,
-0.10070671886205673,
0.8865782618522644,
0.6613313555717468,
-0.08424697071313858,
0.12257757782936096,
0.4090293049812317,
0.4183972179889679,
0.056556690484285355,
0.8644249439239502,
0.9344833493232727,
-0.658699095249176,
0.6037946939468384,
-0.05567491799592972,
0.08106561005115509,
-0.07383757829666138,
-0.7827118635177612,
-1.073407530784607,
-0.602162778377533,
-0.43085259199142456,
-0.34934234619140625,
0.3339857757091522,
1.009192705154419,
0.4034976661205292,
-0.7069024443626404,
0.38057905435562134,
-0.23543894290924072,
-0.0226582083851099,
-0.19839881360530853,
-0.20260095596313477,
0.5749456286430359,
-0.33724477887153625,
-0.5291928052902222,
0.08679304271936417,
0.19979840517044067,
-0.39243870973587036,
0.08426147699356079,
0.20055784285068512,
-0.03837902843952179,
0.15512016415596008,
0.6326723694801331,
0.02195126935839653,
-0.7210607528686523,
-0.8645370006561279,
-0.03459417074918747,
0.028459496796131134,
-0.0020105107687413692,
0.7952794432640076,
-0.882301390171051,
0.2024325579404831,
0.3501700758934021,
0.7625311017036438,
0.47764262557029724,
-0.19694358110427856,
0.6525375247001648,
-0.7300963997840881,
-0.11072497814893723,
0.268104612827301,
0.6324207782745361,
0.43428337574005127,
-0.19105374813079834,
0.35910239815711975,
-0.0861002504825592,
-0.6858624815940857,
-0.7714040875434875,
0.1802045851945877,
-0.903400719165802,
-0.2529100477695465,
0.849414587020874,
-0.12587520480155945,
-0.061114367097616196,
-0.20044749975204468,
-0.19168934226036072,
0.21960803866386414,
-0.34822824597358704,
0.8999360799789429,
0.7068856358528137,
0.1377912312746048,
-0.20295590162277222,
0.04382132366299629,
0.2635471224784851,
0.7619450688362122,
-0.4856092929840088,
-0.15350522100925446,
0.342358261346817,
0.3687967360019684,
0.03741251677274704,
0.21861672401428223,
0.1426783800125122,
0.165035218000412,
-0.19450339674949646,
-0.1386878490447998,
0.06035258248448372,
-0.13749253749847412,
-0.19636693596839905,
0.21654920279979706,
0.1304439902305603,
-0.0821893960237503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13125v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13125v1 | TreeEval: Benchmark-Free Evaluation of Large Language Models through Tree Planning | 2024-02-20T16:38:33 | 2024-02-20T16:38:33 | Xiang Li, Yunshi Lan, Chao Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, numerous new benchmarks have been established to evaluate the
performance of large language models (LLMs) via either computing a holistic
score or employing another LLM as a judge. However, these approaches suffer
from data leakage due to the open access of the benchmark and inflexible
evaluation process. To address this issue, we introduce $\textbf{TreeEval}$, a
benchmark-free evaluation method for LLMs that let a high-performance LLM host
an irreproducible evaluation session and essentially avoids the data leakage.
Moreover, this LLM performs as an examiner to raise up a series of questions
under a topic with a tree planing strategy, which considers the current
evaluation status to decide the next question generation and ensures the
completeness and efficiency of the evaluation process. We evaluate $6$ models
of different parameter sizes, including $7$B, $13$B, and $33$B, and ultimately
achieved the highest correlation coefficient with AlpacaEval2.0 using only
around $45$ questions. We also conduct more analysis to show the robustness and
reliability of TreeEval. Our code can be accessed via the provided
https://github.com/Ashura5/TreeEval. | [
-0.07156220078468323,
-0.7961165308952332,
0.36456605792045593,
0.3644741475582123,
-0.379611998796463,
0.1352430284023285,
-0.43254005908966064,
-0.504861056804657,
-0.08296134322881699,
0.466423362493515,
-0.28278809785842896,
-0.7468124628067017,
-0.42976459860801697,
-0.3967572748661041,
-0.5314346551895142,
0.8459812998771667,
-0.12146884202957153,
-0.11583071947097778,
-0.31379738450050354,
-0.49771520495414734,
-0.2630416750907898,
-0.320318341255188,
-0.52509605884552,
0.0024792365729808807,
0.19875288009643555,
0.5023444294929504,
0.7062883377075195,
0.8580113649368286,
0.5721330046653748,
0.21460223197937012,
-0.2911726236343384,
-0.13308735191822052,
-0.5336971879005432,
0.45858561992645264,
-0.17424367368221283,
-0.37179702520370483,
-0.580836832523346,
-0.24881836771965027,
0.7979704737663269,
0.5041755437850952,
-0.4046885073184967,
0.6135615110397339,
0.2920767366886139,
0.7191236019134521,
-0.8373202681541443,
0.428455114364624,
-1.0034915208816528,
-0.22534236311912537,
-0.48734185099601746,
-0.11225665360689163,
-0.541438102722168,
-0.6124286651611328,
-0.08085925132036209,
-0.2470148652791977,
-0.11164199560880661,
0.061948955059051514,
0.5179091095924377,
0.3014003336429596,
-0.09010693430900574,
-0.12393578141927719,
-0.6094071269035339,
0.685600221157074,
-0.5782728791236877,
0.35024598240852356,
0.4947635233402252,
0.6771504282951355,
0.016802307218313217,
-0.611513614654541,
-0.07798302173614502,
-0.4127962589263916,
0.31167495250701904,
0.001317306887358427,
-0.36395514011383057,
-0.08043672144412994,
0.23206160962581635,
0.2768917679786682,
-0.5866930484771729,
0.05677565187215805,
0.14279280602931976,
0.09764103591442108,
0.6453292965888977,
0.06985369324684143,
-0.08468468487262726,
-0.12836462259292603,
-0.26077499985694885,
-0.3468512296676636,
-0.8756928443908691,
0.010285180062055588,
0.07622635364532471,
0.35599786043167114,
0.02200552076101303,
0.4768306314945221,
-0.21009676158428192,
0.3581240773200989,
-0.23779945075511932,
0.06324894726276398,
0.2594113349914551,
-0.2979801297187805,
-0.3214600086212158,
0.015781491994857788,
0.6924815773963928,
0.25197529792785645,
0.2542352080345154,
-0.15558889508247375,
-0.227944016456604,
-0.1297261267900467,
-0.026185721158981323,
-1.1818305253982544,
-0.06407444924116135,
0.3295086920261383,
-0.5306917428970337,
-0.4124651253223419,
-0.20979604125022888,
-0.97517329454422,
-0.2403828203678131,
0.1686633676290512,
0.17949874699115753,
-0.39555278420448303,
-0.3934730589389801,
-0.10485260933637619,
0.456477552652359,
0.06607930362224579,
0.2596970498561859,
-0.7269263863563538,
0.47868603467941284,
0.8892024755477905,
0.7192138433456421,
-0.08280016481876373,
-0.26849454641342163,
-0.9159818291664124,
0.1183810904622078,
-0.5177624225616455,
0.6769728660583496,
-0.6602194905281067,
-0.5026596188545227,
0.11904129385948181,
-0.09215658158063889,
0.06728488206863403,
-0.5652135610580444,
0.7552525401115417,
-0.6209757924079895,
-0.09984580427408218,
-0.0042546954937279224,
-0.3654320240020752,
-0.0497332327067852,
0.2529253363609314,
-0.686068594455719,
1.0778518915176392,
0.08512450009584427,
-0.7409542798995972,
0.3152688145637512,
-0.6526697278022766,
-0.16906656324863434,
0.37384021282196045,
-0.18573397397994995,
-0.5032941699028015,
-0.043960023671388626,
0.3897649049758911,
0.08308472484350204,
-0.45806318521499634,
0.5359585285186768,
-0.41598451137542725,
-0.243100106716156,
-0.0728122815489769,
-0.7213354110717773,
0.8935509324073792,
0.22515659034252167,
-0.39376920461654663,
0.3976154923439026,
-0.6447280049324036,
0.5118730664253235,
0.07682517915964127,
-0.3285031318664551,
-0.26866328716278076,
0.2465278059244156,
-0.026606516912579536,
-0.12916623055934906,
0.19488516449928284,
-0.4884604811668396,
0.18621183931827545,
-0.3313594162464142,
0.09337683767080307,
0.6800883412361145,
-0.11942168325185776,
-0.031249914318323135,
-0.30060532689094543,
0.6970001459121704,
-0.1972196102142334,
0.23987777531147003,
-0.13326162099838257,
-0.27125421166419983,
-0.6440774202346802,
-0.06909030675888062,
0.5735939145088196,
0.43426552414894104,
-0.3158998489379883,
0.407146155834198,
-0.42571887373924255,
-0.8538526892662048,
-0.6070547699928284,
0.063936248421669,
0.6215986609458923,
0.174479678273201,
0.40759795904159546,
-0.18634648621082306,
-0.42289549112319946,
-0.7578743100166321,
-0.358762264251709,
-0.4846501052379608,
0.019298601895570755,
0.25933098793029785,
0.3645595908164978,
0.10779841989278793,
0.6930747032165527,
-0.34058359265327454,
-0.21216632425785065,
-0.2250344455242157,
0.09549602121114731,
0.2214375138282776,
0.39436331391334534,
0.3579234778881073,
-0.14119702577590942,
-0.6284092664718628,
-0.030605411157011986,
-0.5078321695327759,
-0.293673038482666,
0.10762658715248108,
-0.011559044942259789,
0.2935579717159271,
0.6112538576126099,
-0.5540522933006287,
0.29453179240226746,
0.7635428309440613,
-0.185228630900383,
0.5915670394897461,
-0.11539268493652344,
-0.1656050831079483,
-1.0270143747329712,
0.3146955668926239,
-0.25529709458351135,
-0.3161235451698303,
-0.18978767096996307,
0.4223114848136902,
0.268216609954834,
0.0030441987328231335,
-0.35491833090782166,
0.4777365028858185,
-0.555962860584259,
-0.19787144660949707,
-0.050307340919971466,
0.0593465194106102,
-0.20804190635681152,
0.25994059443473816,
-0.17191840708255768,
0.7493087649345398,
0.6656434535980225,
-0.1014970913529396,
0.06315170973539352,
0.19741001725196838,
-0.7161577939987183,
0.31280961632728577,
-0.44108831882476807,
0.2046467512845993,
0.05283894017338753,
0.24892297387123108,
-0.7614749073982239,
0.10984376817941666,
-0.0675729438662529,
-0.2537331283092499,
0.226954385638237,
-0.3408689796924591,
-0.46602702140808105,
-0.13233938813209534,
-0.5083388090133667,
0.44890713691711426,
0.3497328758239746,
-0.7906675338745117,
0.2135048657655716,
0.43282264471054077,
-0.2233262062072754,
-0.5427827835083008,
-0.5138837695121765,
0.18963932991027832,
-0.2858012020587921,
-0.5183223485946655,
0.22022919356822968,
-0.19264768064022064,
-0.3888651728630066,
0.1686643660068512,
-0.10403800755739212,
0.03650885075330734,
0.13817079365253448,
0.31491708755493164,
0.22541318833827972,
-0.4573304355144501,
0.26612916588783264,
-0.11059574037790298,
-0.15295420587062836,
0.163019061088562,
0.004553023260086775,
0.5146075487136841,
-0.509954035282135,
-0.6265093088150024,
-0.22907648980617523,
0.23149926960468292,
0.7720045447349548,
-0.5519527196884155,
0.3960002660751343,
-0.1892867237329483,
-0.43147706985473633,
-0.28104183077812195,
-0.5307217240333557,
0.3079591691493988,
-0.43808335065841675,
0.5374520421028137,
-0.520158588886261,
-0.6606994271278381,
0.22559720277786255,
-0.14959566295146942,
0.2397397756576538,
0.42657536268234253,
0.5417545437812805,
0.362382173538208,
1.1282119750976562,
0.4952027499675751,
-0.19433605670928955,
0.3028874099254608,
-0.16046132147312164,
-0.08087792992591858,
-0.7583498358726501,
-0.13523653149604797,
-0.7602313756942749,
-0.10266312956809998,
-0.6073629856109619,
-0.6419845223426819,
0.2633190155029297,
0.3404309153556824,
-0.15395928919315338,
0.3454114496707916,
-0.3319849371910095,
0.8033379912376404,
0.3749356269836426,
-0.4570276141166687,
0.6572256088256836,
-0.029877308756113052,
-0.371642529964447,
0.15192218124866486,
-0.4522230923175812,
-0.7123022675514221,
1.2599806785583496,
0.5209651589393616,
0.6703349351882935,
0.18976570665836334,
0.6559061408042908,
-0.12415426969528198,
0.602246880531311,
-0.7198119163513184,
0.701875627040863,
-0.017169663682579994,
-0.431508868932724,
-0.47421330213546753,
-0.3126724660396576,
-1.1000984907150269,
0.44854339957237244,
0.009671577252447605,
-1.0455870628356934,
0.02563110552728176,
-0.11329340934753418,
-0.1226596012711525,
0.509691059589386,
-0.49832671880722046,
0.8166373372077942,
-0.47091004252433777,
-0.5210536122322083,
-0.49499064683914185,
-0.40284401178359985,
0.43353989720344543,
-0.302715927362442,
0.16270312666893005,
-0.19643911719322205,
0.014487944543361664,
0.8010958433151245,
-0.5152196884155273,
0.39023905992507935,
-0.23952126502990723,
0.17838118970394135,
0.33888906240463257,
0.45948541164398193,
0.5919502973556519,
0.13898205757141113,
-0.4120664894580841,
0.1438254565000534,
0.34920015931129456,
-0.17484307289123535,
-0.37571948766708374,
0.8903484344482422,
-0.634013831615448,
-0.5861671566963196,
-0.5237985253334045,
-0.5756118297576904,
-0.5792360901832581,
0.15477457642555237,
-0.25086864829063416,
0.29044216871261597,
-0.49281659722328186,
0.5568515062332153,
0.09511959552764893,
-0.057912424206733704,
0.7339950203895569,
0.6728417873382568,
-0.6960670948028564,
-0.3758096396923065,
0.5478895902633667,
0.006400190759450197,
0.3581872880458832,
0.31970110535621643,
0.48072269558906555,
-0.38501280546188354,
-0.7870283126831055,
-0.41130226850509644,
0.08324575424194336,
-0.45887717604637146,
-0.376472532749176,
-0.287311315536499,
-0.4803118109703064,
-0.004585006274282932,
0.3034988045692444,
-0.5106196403503418,
-0.5267489552497864,
0.28370723128318787,
-0.22339412569999695,
0.3135145604610443,
0.5258066654205322,
0.09364842623472214,
0.18947705626487732,
-0.7036848664283752,
-0.10861599445343018,
0.1195249855518341,
0.5950800180435181,
0.33079466223716736,
-0.14640946686267853,
-0.12137046456336975,
-0.0622989796102047,
-0.5113902688026428,
-0.5641475319862366,
0.2719721496105194,
0.1300039440393448,
0.4791240096092224,
0.5752415657043457,
0.10684531182050705,
0.8879752159118652,
-0.4385751783847809,
0.3516739308834076,
-0.05022275820374489,
-0.9555584788322449,
0.5789957046508789,
-0.13954736292362213,
0.4141256511211395,
1.0785613059997559,
0.18263587355613708,
-0.4747484028339386,
-0.5462440848350525,
-0.7133049964904785,
-0.8197267651557922,
0.5816916823387146,
0.06226811930537224,
-0.11400830000638962,
0.05454850569367409,
-0.10598554462194443,
0.09137441962957382,
0.0748281329870224,
-0.5977672338485718,
0.18201419711112976,
-0.06900795549154282,
0.07430076599121094,
0.019679397344589233,
-0.3314896821975708,
-0.13965468108654022,
-0.27275004982948303,
0.610697865486145,
-0.1412343680858612,
-0.28248438239097595,
-0.043442558497190475,
-0.17158599197864532,
-0.4156651794910431,
0.434464693069458,
0.05260523781180382,
0.8806188702583313,
-0.5218145251274109,
0.3640434145927429,
0.31810930371284485,
-0.2935817837715149,
-0.07627499103546143,
0.17360487580299377,
-0.16080570220947266,
-0.05464501678943634,
0.595264732837677,
0.49084368348121643,
0.04098958149552345,
-0.7157210111618042,
0.6444396376609802,
-0.06298855692148209,
-0.1726638227701187,
-0.013148377649486065,
-0.22178570926189423,
0.31654831767082214,
0.2241649329662323,
0.12504258751869202,
-0.17690332233905792,
-0.255436509847641,
-0.581341564655304,
0.336478054523468,
0.628382682800293,
-0.5001234412193298,
-0.13972122967243195,
0.6211097240447998,
0.04325249418616295,
-0.4247407019138336,
0.579129695892334,
-0.08559955656528473,
-0.27389955520629883,
0.3710319399833679,
0.6034116148948669,
1.0884487628936768,
-0.5859211683273315,
0.18485091626644135,
0.4172579348087311,
0.31827324628829956,
0.1508101522922516,
0.25848516821861267,
-0.11952280253171921,
-0.30678221583366394,
-0.42260801792144775,
-0.7849907875061035,
-0.5287919044494629,
0.43691492080688477,
-0.44864171743392944,
0.28237372636795044,
-0.402817040681839,
0.23277735710144043,
-0.29603996872901917,
0.15515387058258057,
-0.2872406840324402,
-0.06442555785179138,
-0.2205522507429123,
1.4073795080184937,
-0.5518856644630432,
1.1100047826766968,
0.11762576550245285,
-0.1888512820005417,
-0.7594443559646606,
0.3166511356830597,
-0.06989210844039917,
-0.9682022333145142,
0.5031184554100037,
0.24853216111660004,
-0.16752342879772186,
-0.2414042353630066,
-0.1747943013906479,
-0.9801305532455444,
0.9868303537368774,
0.40189459919929504,
-0.8068327903747559,
0.04488608241081238,
0.28350386023521423,
0.5924437046051025,
-0.2453104555606842,
0.592524528503418,
0.5937927961349487,
0.48388567566871643,
0.2745126187801361,
-0.9642436504364014,
0.19284145534038544,
-0.3318040370941162,
-0.03290660306811333,
0.37787607312202454,
-0.5700050592422485,
0.5337234735488892,
-0.07567696273326874,
-0.42302751541137695,
0.19918975234031677,
0.305162638425827,
0.33302223682403564,
0.08479543775320053,
0.7795446515083313,
0.5978037714958191,
0.8783429265022278,
0.09997125715017319,
0.9550556540489197,
-0.7205344438552856,
0.3447890877723694,
1.3734554052352905,
-0.4887221157550812,
1.472267746925354,
0.3348871171474457,
-0.25961682200431824,
0.35152849555015564,
0.48075953125953674,
0.10030367970466614,
0.5274156928062439,
0.511070728302002,
-0.3323121964931488,
-0.09692995250225067,
-0.1553550511598587,
-0.4793943166732788,
0.563649594783783,
0.12683279812335968,
-0.15225057303905487,
-0.6925902366638184,
-0.5859479308128357,
0.11407183855772018,
0.0310636255890131,
-0.17600233852863312,
0.591511607170105,
0.05362553521990776,
-0.8721592426300049,
0.6573891639709473,
-0.10537520796060562,
0.09273787587881088,
-0.698685348033905,
0.07817155867815018,
-0.16002747416496277,
0.4282083809375763,
-0.1763206571340561,
-0.7917330265045166,
0.5170432925224304,
0.1483948677778244,
0.32772332429885864,
-0.32537296414375305,
0.48745793104171753,
-0.3576420843601227,
-0.6624434590339661,
0.608027458190918,
0.6980759501457214,
0.27713242173194885,
-0.1986568123102188,
-0.5810450911521912,
0.09731423854827881,
-0.2264196276664734,
-0.26599112153053284,
0.37759634852409363,
0.13672061264514923,
-0.6464144587516785,
0.7793017029762268,
0.6751019358634949,
0.43680012226104736,
-0.20053057372570038,
0.24930819869041443,
0.7896156907081604,
-0.5051913857460022,
-0.3077745735645294,
-1.0082499980926514,
0.25946179032325745,
0.018409617245197296,
-0.23330040276050568,
0.7187527418136597,
1.1635854244232178,
0.5727157592773438,
0.3467361629009247,
0.5436475276947021,
0.2520279884338379,
0.6319678425788879,
-0.42614129185676575,
0.8335688710212708,
-0.28134921193122864,
0.5070910453796387,
-0.3216927647590637,
-1.216395616531372,
-0.3660569489002228,
0.32701006531715393,
-0.28621992468833923,
-0.1516708880662918,
0.9918044805526733,
0.7999505996704102,
-0.09712284803390503,
0.22719992697238922,
0.20047935843467712,
0.3160138726234436,
0.5260440111160278,
0.8264166712760925,
0.8904328346252441,
-0.075661301612854,
0.8844459652900696,
-0.09224878996610641,
-0.5570446848869324,
-0.13301658630371094,
-1.0642558336257935,
-0.6178652048110962,
-0.3457218408584595,
-0.30846330523490906,
-0.2240757942199707,
0.1606600135564804,
0.6803017258644104,
0.7385497093200684,
-0.7964778542518616,
-0.8005573749542236,
-0.2834359109401703,
0.18103183805942535,
-0.18859614431858063,
-0.19200025498867035,
0.7395168542861938,
-0.21124379336833954,
-0.4838395118713379,
0.6210826635360718,
0.2623222768306732,
-0.2220911830663681,
-0.39228513836860657,
0.02153833769261837,
-0.06158319115638733,
-0.025086287409067154,
0.4555678367614746,
0.10042010992765427,
-0.6246214509010315,
-0.4072474241256714,
-0.3064696192741394,
0.09457390755414963,
0.29422569274902344,
0.5221643447875977,
-0.8581360578536987,
0.3972608149051666,
0.4192560315132141,
0.7808077931404114,
0.9804741144180298,
0.15555024147033691,
0.25120338797569275,
-0.6342083811759949,
-0.14159998297691345,
0.33243533968925476,
0.33620989322662354,
0.2198631465435028,
0.1061495840549469,
0.6689485311508179,
-0.31210675835609436,
-0.6193088293075562,
-0.9060415625572205,
0.19779865443706512,
-0.9404309988021851,
-0.1746675670146942,
1.0418872833251953,
-0.07250408828258514,
-0.23752468824386597,
0.2748755216598511,
-0.17810972034931183,
0.0270101185888052,
-0.26292046904563904,
0.6805998086929321,
0.7921507954597473,
-0.08748633414506912,
-0.14684098958969116,
-0.5766549110412598,
0.35376718640327454,
0.44546952843666077,
-1.164070963859558,
0.695193350315094,
0.31691688299179077,
0.24909046292304993,
0.08455318957567215,
0.6406604647636414,
-0.3582767844200134,
0.020793678238987923,
-0.0763801783323288,
-0.16593101620674133,
-0.02274082414805889,
-0.31931376457214355,
-0.40921494364738464,
0.45162245631217957,
0.5610418319702148,
-0.38180041313171387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13116v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13116v3 | A Survey on Knowledge Distillation of Large Language Models | 2024-02-20T16:17:37 | 2024-03-08T13:29:03 | Xiaohan Xu, Ming Li, Chongyang Tao, Tao Shen, Reynold Cheng, Jinyang Li, Can Xu, Dacheng Tao, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the era of Large Language Models (LLMs), Knowledge Distillation (KD)
emerges as a pivotal methodology for transferring advanced capabilities from
leading proprietary LLMs, such as GPT-4, to their open-source counterparts like
LLaMA and Mistral. Additionally, as open-source LLMs flourish, KD plays a
crucial role in both compressing these models, and facilitating their
self-improvement by employing themselves as teachers. This paper presents a
comprehensive survey of KD's role within the realm of LLM, highlighting its
critical function in imparting advanced knowledge to smaller models and its
utility in model compression and self-improvement. Our survey is meticulously
structured around three foundational pillars: \textit{algorithm},
\textit{skill}, and \textit{verticalization} -- providing a comprehensive
examination of KD mechanisms, the enhancement of specific cognitive abilities,
and their practical implications across diverse fields. Crucially, the survey
navigates the intricate interplay between data augmentation (DA) and KD,
illustrating how DA emerges as a powerful paradigm within the KD framework to
bolster LLMs' performance. By leveraging DA to generate context-rich,
skill-specific training data, KD transcends traditional boundaries, enabling
open-source models to approximate the contextual adeptness, ethical alignment,
and deep semantic insights characteristic of their proprietary counterparts.
This work aims to provide an insightful guide for researchers and
practitioners, offering a detailed overview of current methodologies in KD and
proposing future research directions. Importantly, we firmly advocate for
compliance with the legal terms that regulate the use of LLMs, ensuring ethical
and lawful application of KD of LLMs. An associated Github repository is
available at https://github.com/Tebmer/Awesome-Knowledge-Distillation-of-LLMs. | [
-0.41283756494522095,
-0.7614111304283142,
0.8253431916236877,
-0.20567020773887634,
-0.12429772317409515,
0.34393852949142456,
-0.42656636238098145,
-0.20860835909843445,
-0.1448134481906891,
0.43406975269317627,
-0.34571701288223267,
-0.5027391910552979,
-0.9292578101158142,
-0.18213315308094025,
-0.321829229593277,
1.0448784828186035,
0.014867055229842663,
0.16595369577407837,
-0.5144042372703552,
-0.06739327311515808,
-0.48120489716529846,
-0.740742564201355,
-0.26317498087882996,
-0.5870441198348999,
0.5185064077377319,
0.3911179304122925,
0.4269125461578369,
0.5842562317848206,
0.33921584486961365,
0.28378909826278687,
-0.3132670223712921,
-0.016124777495861053,
-0.8179002404212952,
0.3469778895378113,
-0.13862323760986328,
-0.5460862517356873,
-0.43079978227615356,
0.10350638628005981,
0.4560348093509674,
0.7525514364242554,
-0.37102723121643066,
0.19520387053489685,
0.3318588137626648,
0.9897419214248657,
-0.7177847027778625,
0.22197000682353973,
-0.6486415863037109,
-0.045375000685453415,
-0.2452985942363739,
0.12008790671825409,
-0.07282768934965134,
-0.5749991536140442,
0.2761942744255066,
-0.4849233627319336,
-0.0074738371185958385,
-0.33599743247032166,
0.41714394092559814,
0.6446123719215393,
-0.6180387139320374,
-0.46183645725250244,
-0.9829608201980591,
0.7043901681900024,
-0.7899825572967529,
0.48882752656936646,
0.3986143171787262,
0.5211620926856995,
-0.1652868688106537,
-0.8963088989257812,
-0.5691429376602173,
-0.1499508023262024,
0.11893899738788605,
-0.047088995575904846,
-0.059711944311857224,
0.08988671004772186,
0.2762300968170166,
0.8476299047470093,
-0.03581222891807556,
0.2912239134311676,
-0.6443392038345337,
-0.061671409755945206,
0.46058714389801025,
-0.09063846617937088,
0.1697668880224228,
0.20487529039382935,
-0.04573819041252136,
-0.21706677973270416,
-0.8333064317703247,
-0.2042972892522812,
0.36641064286231995,
-0.09832616150379181,
0.09297889471054077,
0.6503587365150452,
-0.3348524868488312,
0.5158284902572632,
0.1623382419347763,
-0.5425326824188232,
0.2087896764278412,
-0.3202705383300781,
-0.1694139987230301,
0.14964616298675537,
0.6632981300354004,
0.3112991750240326,
0.26756227016448975,
-0.12453161925077438,
-0.09701596200466156,
-0.18299061059951782,
-0.008230190724134445,
-0.748093843460083,
-0.5789983868598938,
0.027243103832006454,
-0.25133973360061646,
-0.38002997636795044,
-0.2998583912849426,
-0.6986067891120911,
-0.7386276721954346,
-0.5890186429023743,
0.1641298085451126,
-0.3227601647377014,
-0.5382679104804993,
0.16913951933383942,
-0.33291351795196533,
-0.1016777902841568,
0.1370616853237152,
-0.9243078827857971,
0.11614840477705002,
0.6100406050682068,
0.678742527961731,
-0.0715988352894783,
-0.20356643199920654,
-0.1096235066652298,
0.2029668092727661,
-0.3617057502269745,
0.3781872093677521,
-0.36337634921073914,
-0.4799112379550934,
-0.1128862276673317,
-0.21794235706329346,
0.3920101821422577,
-0.7062886953353882,
0.6334044933319092,
-0.7337892651557922,
-0.08936174213886261,
-0.4492987096309662,
-0.7547195553779602,
-0.2706398367881775,
0.24572251737117767,
-0.6804447770118713,
0.989511251449585,
0.060768116265535355,
-0.6848609447479248,
0.6430261731147766,
-0.6122867465019226,
-0.04147068038582802,
0.0923728346824646,
-0.330600380897522,
-0.15546815097332,
0.26252642273902893,
0.28539860248565674,
0.553698718547821,
-0.4542008936405182,
0.4513593316078186,
-0.5539975166320801,
0.27125418186187744,
0.08408520370721817,
-0.480021595954895,
0.7850137948989868,
0.3641589283943176,
0.012127633206546307,
-0.19535139203071594,
-0.7580732703208923,
-0.029085077345371246,
0.15026958286762238,
-0.38085052371025085,
-0.7738822102546692,
-0.11805040389299393,
-0.331628680229187,
0.23780259490013123,
0.41076043248176575,
-0.43213310837745667,
0.38229548931121826,
-0.17772652208805084,
0.6196043491363525,
0.8518602252006531,
0.107811339199543,
0.6746426224708557,
-0.10019942373037338,
0.5497945547103882,
0.031372711062431335,
0.1261528879404068,
-0.10655368864536285,
-0.2570851147174835,
-0.4530549645423889,
-0.4198065996170044,
0.49453434348106384,
0.10327032953500748,
-0.9016444683074951,
0.38303688168525696,
-0.36888188123703003,
-0.9308792352676392,
-0.7710393667221069,
0.4591183066368103,
0.15821513533592224,
0.5473216772079468,
0.24353660643100739,
0.21476276218891144,
-0.32418566942214966,
-0.871940553188324,
-0.01774858869612217,
-0.15557153522968292,
0.08117972314357758,
0.22258812189102173,
0.32189080119132996,
-0.07333149015903473,
1.0503206253051758,
-0.7375183701515198,
-0.4250658452510834,
-0.16137456893920898,
-0.030113354325294495,
0.19671766459941864,
0.3637044429779053,
0.6765514612197876,
-0.6066151261329651,
-0.6425529718399048,
0.11674884706735611,
-0.8260402083396912,
-0.29485419392585754,
0.33017244935035706,
-0.07924012094736099,
0.016782933846116066,
0.604508638381958,
-0.5856335163116455,
0.044241271913051605,
0.6320133805274963,
-0.10675223171710968,
0.5579227209091187,
-0.4656582176685333,
0.19410569965839386,
-1.1674895286560059,
0.04876445233821869,
-0.16161233186721802,
-0.033992670476436615,
-0.6455072164535522,
0.14910876750946045,
0.04825558513402939,
0.2625294029712677,
-0.22691640257835388,
0.2897579073905945,
-0.6337133049964905,
-0.015283755958080292,
-0.4355596899986267,
0.17170867323875427,
-0.13457494974136353,
0.10528705269098282,
-0.13268022239208221,
0.4934646189212799,
0.6270501017570496,
-0.5885106921195984,
0.6234030723571777,
0.014436922036111355,
-0.7073336243629456,
0.49264267086982727,
-0.5358142256736755,
0.15774734318256378,
-0.21860158443450928,
0.2516661286354065,
-0.8865290284156799,
-0.2057635337114334,
0.036657799035310745,
-0.23527008295059204,
0.23071438074111938,
-0.41636374592781067,
-0.7331663370132446,
-0.3252049684524536,
-0.05990630015730858,
0.5372952818870544,
0.8428999185562134,
-0.5687271356582642,
0.41789788007736206,
0.6098965406417847,
-0.3304976224899292,
-0.6295694708824158,
-0.6760738492012024,
-0.0033580351155251265,
-0.38837340474128723,
-0.5367951393127441,
0.1328313946723938,
-0.23812557756900787,
-0.4177185893058777,
0.133876234292984,
-0.22143813967704773,
-0.16398723423480988,
0.14820460975170135,
0.09989489614963531,
0.2952870726585388,
-0.08712755888700485,
0.12366392463445663,
0.28657227754592896,
0.1994047909975052,
0.1451219618320465,
-0.3471972942352295,
0.5615503191947937,
0.307291716337204,
-0.5543961524963379,
-0.2014903426170349,
-0.09952718019485474,
0.8032006621360779,
0.04220148175954819,
0.6449134349822998,
0.4650384485721588,
-0.13969933986663818,
-0.3057486414909363,
-0.820798933506012,
-0.21920974552631378,
-0.4642733335494995,
0.2964647114276886,
-0.31697195768356323,
-1.219918966293335,
0.4047643542289734,
-0.26898306608200073,
-0.017647113651037216,
0.4208218455314636,
0.7814398407936096,
0.15552788972854614,
0.7164775729179382,
0.7239258289337158,
-0.4254283010959625,
0.29709315299987793,
-0.25573039054870605,
0.2948763966560364,
-0.6990755200386047,
-0.26288020610809326,
-0.4376528859138489,
-0.44795987010002136,
-0.37274497747421265,
-0.4595789313316345,
0.5508020520210266,
0.4398569166660309,
0.03857468441128731,
-0.1517581343650818,
-0.533679187297821,
0.656014084815979,
0.46254414319992065,
-0.2529544532299042,
0.6538108587265015,
-0.1387639194726944,
-0.07469622045755386,
-0.07918321341276169,
-0.6132941842079163,
-0.32566216588020325,
1.471204400062561,
0.5411309599876404,
0.934255063533783,
-0.03694891557097435,
0.7962793111801147,
0.39032265543937683,
-0.012570488266646862,
-0.8602728247642517,
0.3696287274360657,
0.1463756561279297,
-0.6081894040107727,
-0.32447683811187744,
-0.41615036129951477,
-0.5610403418540955,
0.1664174646139145,
0.09373929351568222,
-0.48209330439567566,
0.2618563175201416,
0.2778615951538086,
-0.2619556188583374,
0.32032620906829834,
-0.8840180039405823,
0.6815479397773743,
-0.12022241950035095,
-0.04902870953083038,
-0.4336361587047577,
-0.37025994062423706,
0.8708212971687317,
-0.45631492137908936,
0.18375687301158905,
-0.15897320210933685,
-0.008368398994207382,
0.5417587161064148,
-0.4883907735347748,
0.7676756381988525,
-0.5380661487579346,
-0.7224524617195129,
0.23041583597660065,
0.05553567036986351,
0.5174496173858643,
-0.1511775106191635,
0.1720404475927353,
0.3419829308986664,
0.32025688886642456,
-0.06746478378772736,
-0.6846501231193542,
0.926743745803833,
-0.8222734332084656,
-0.6670035719871521,
-0.12286340445280075,
-0.5944152474403381,
-0.1806103140115738,
0.1683611273765564,
-0.045780934393405914,
0.12780748307704926,
-0.037446655333042145,
0.4456408619880676,
0.7640023231506348,
-0.007837790995836258,
0.3109167516231537,
0.5401542782783508,
-0.46963417530059814,
-0.3795224726200104,
0.8447358012199402,
0.4492672085762024,
0.49738845229148865,
0.09255336970090866,
0.201555535197258,
-0.59163898229599,
-0.7402703762054443,
-0.26864880323410034,
0.10489878058433533,
-0.9970869421958923,
-0.10964872688055038,
-0.6112056970596313,
-0.30061522126197815,
-0.6162546873092651,
0.10022196918725967,
-0.502052903175354,
-0.5527288913726807,
-0.13729844987392426,
-0.3443831205368042,
0.5149019360542297,
0.9207875728607178,
-0.13637404143810272,
0.14647218585014343,
-0.6776083111763,
0.314060777425766,
0.438456654548645,
0.22914789617061615,
0.2185918688774109,
-0.3892967104911804,
-0.2276557981967926,
0.23018038272857666,
-0.2172536998987198,
-0.5000695586204529,
0.2588229775428772,
0.13154813647270203,
0.656398594379425,
0.3980792760848999,
0.3435884714126587,
0.659791886806488,
-0.510141909122467,
0.8650367856025696,
0.18517078459262848,
-0.6743183135986328,
0.39504945278167725,
-0.1488986313343048,
0.270302414894104,
0.5754850506782532,
0.6025018692016602,
-0.6855395436286926,
-0.3802582621574402,
-0.33253926038742065,
-0.8052042126655579,
0.765033483505249,
-0.043262310326099396,
0.029696064069867134,
0.2186107188463211,
0.40088698267936707,
0.3526507318019867,
0.3073708713054657,
-0.530849277973175,
-0.38470810651779175,
0.06664646416902542,
-0.21404628455638885,
-0.04732327163219452,
-0.32686495780944824,
-0.17863357067108154,
-0.3420780897140503,
0.8434074521064758,
0.01891779527068138,
-0.3182850182056427,
0.05605786666274071,
-0.22499991953372955,
0.18781982362270355,
0.2659386098384857,
0.19955860078334808,
0.7205914258956909,
0.1365826278924942,
0.26508352160453796,
0.04067977890372276,
-0.6105983257293701,
0.27742913365364075,
-0.011348938569426537,
-0.04584779590368271,
-0.42727765440940857,
-0.004295943770557642,
0.5528589487075806,
-0.1419111043214798,
-0.6344241499900818,
0.4073319137096405,
0.16174359619617462,
-0.3710864782333374,
-0.1969580501317978,
0.15005652606487274,
0.23865284025669098,
0.5253646373748779,
0.3904156982898712,
-0.23314933478832245,
0.2206815779209137,
-0.4410274624824524,
-0.069512739777565,
0.29363012313842773,
-0.12061910331249237,
-0.26204612851142883,
0.5995851755142212,
0.029343103989958763,
0.2729682922363281,
0.49568548798561096,
-0.1847824901342392,
-0.17826950550079346,
0.2673884630203247,
0.2225564420223236,
0.8492077589035034,
-0.264202356338501,
0.07018616050481796,
0.1655469387769699,
0.0593239888548851,
-0.19701656699180603,
0.016170725226402283,
-0.3415273427963257,
-0.7932664752006531,
-0.6347280740737915,
-0.7680931091308594,
-0.018366266041994095,
0.38381466269493103,
-0.5147831439971924,
0.17367908358573914,
-0.2786394953727722,
-0.10582872480154037,
0.03777531534433365,
-0.142701655626297,
-0.34318894147872925,
-0.2586551904678345,
0.18831028044223785,
0.7777595520019531,
-0.7088156938552856,
1.0949714183807373,
0.5601048469543457,
-0.3511025905609131,
-0.623421847820282,
0.012709040194749832,
0.2053896188735962,
-0.7627322673797607,
0.937497615814209,
-0.4195514917373657,
-0.013438588008284569,
0.3023231625556946,
-0.518379271030426,
-0.7406045794487,
1.4358116388320923,
0.5533406734466553,
-0.7194864153862,
-0.09139884263277054,
0.3577820658683777,
0.5837376117706299,
-0.05683914199471474,
0.013415229506790638,
0.8953628540039062,
0.4512365758419037,
0.3077584207057953,
-1.066232442855835,
-0.02812913805246353,
-0.0779280886054039,
0.1574627161026001,
0.123810775578022,
-0.41372260451316833,
0.5387892127037048,
0.03842105716466904,
-0.12603522837162018,
-0.1255330890417099,
0.4207231104373932,
0.22999723255634308,
0.09196934103965759,
0.3729000389575958,
0.7675535082817078,
0.8043591380119324,
-0.04930763319134712,
0.6767013669013977,
-0.5399308204650879,
0.22338944673538208,
1.1719567775726318,
-0.3264957368373871,
0.5331481695175171,
0.650919497013092,
-0.23613891005516052,
0.2179480344057083,
0.3445169925689697,
-0.006731903646141291,
0.750862181186676,
0.23093768954277039,
-0.35069194436073303,
0.044925011694431305,
-0.139240562915802,
-0.46833688020706177,
0.32542574405670166,
0.31713294982910156,
-0.40367329120635986,
-0.4052780866622925,
0.16414637863636017,
0.0007540559745393693,
0.1443301886320114,
-0.34922096133232117,
1.1317682266235352,
0.11714497208595276,
-0.6424401998519897,
0.5462030172348022,
-0.1826888918876648,
0.6997331380844116,
-0.5906257629394531,
-0.05031260848045349,
-0.08876535296440125,
0.2873741090297699,
-0.13199447095394135,
-0.9062545895576477,
0.19233813881874084,
0.015652485191822052,
-0.40053215622901917,
-0.3841887414455414,
0.895419180393219,
-0.6583154201507568,
-0.14751918613910675,
0.3148806095123291,
0.7668886780738831,
0.15171529352664948,
-0.17506004869937897,
-0.44132399559020996,
0.14783723652362823,
-0.02044673264026642,
-0.011272864416241646,
0.5147753953933716,
0.8819817900657654,
0.173001229763031,
0.7259602546691895,
0.5526316165924072,
0.35619255900382996,
0.1968056559562683,
0.14824385941028595,
1.1319499015808105,
-0.3269822299480438,
-0.3146721124649048,
-1.1010891199111938,
0.4743797183036804,
-0.13343478739261627,
-0.05916338786482811,
0.9208658337593079,
0.5645034313201904,
1.0457758903503418,
-0.1638079583644867,
1.0763654708862305,
-0.2920697331428528,
0.4632831811904907,
-0.5691108107566833,
1.1175904273986816,
-0.33373862504959106,
0.37465330958366394,
-0.17363710701465607,
-1.051160454750061,
0.16840238869190216,
0.04687400907278061,
-0.48963111639022827,
0.011750884354114532,
0.47044292092323303,
0.6904051899909973,
-0.07131484150886536,
-0.069784015417099,
0.46463847160339355,
0.38314855098724365,
0.43270599842071533,
0.16631294786930084,
1.0627833604812622,
-0.08345064520835876,
0.5473952293395996,
-0.41825157403945923,
-0.20245124399662018,
-0.012019539251923561,
-0.9063363075256348,
-0.8143932819366455,
-0.8617992997169495,
-0.34414780139923096,
-0.0283427145332098,
-0.20757927000522614,
0.9256138801574707,
0.5783151388168335,
-0.40549591183662415,
-0.12679271399974823,
-0.20260150730609894,
0.10187686234712601,
0.07522643357515335,
-0.2305571436882019,
0.1935562938451767,
-0.5201323628425598,
-0.9072569012641907,
0.3915371000766754,
0.0929073840379715,
0.09409893304109573,
-0.6453660726547241,
-0.1270453929901123,
-0.004370992071926594,
-0.2972099184989929,
0.7213448882102966,
0.08734580874443054,
-0.7119819521903992,
0.057925768196582794,
-0.23761509358882904,
0.04976065456867218,
-0.1948205977678299,
0.8201732039451599,
-0.8094931244850159,
0.5449227094650269,
0.5274699926376343,
0.8167147636413574,
0.4385877847671509,
-0.2366470843553543,
0.6739001274108887,
-0.7437278032302856,
-0.10626185685396194,
0.15135647356510162,
0.1974823772907257,
0.16259384155273438,
-0.3067339062690735,
0.47215861082077026,
0.2904888093471527,
-0.8255404829978943,
-0.9643964171409607,
0.11062917858362198,
-0.5800950527191162,
-0.36698654294013977,
1.215373158454895,
-0.23195874691009521,
-0.08737411350011826,
-0.12432199716567993,
-0.4152212142944336,
0.13932669162750244,
-0.4311196804046631,
0.876659631729126,
1.140263557434082,
0.1886332631111145,
-0.14891251921653748,
-0.7049375772476196,
0.7571969032287598,
-0.1179797351360321,
-0.6305398941040039,
0.42644378542900085,
0.9506217837333679,
0.3980773091316223,
0.05875207111239433,
0.6587562561035156,
-0.29096129536628723,
-0.1498415470123291,
-0.15041522681713104,
0.2330399453639984,
-0.26465651392936707,
-0.20701156556606293,
-0.44568687677383423,
0.13498525321483612,
0.44575026631355286,
0.07601037621498108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13113v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13113v2 | When Only Time Will Tell: Interpreting How Transformers Process Local Ambiguities Through the Lens of Restart-Incrementality | 2024-02-20T16:09:49 | 2024-06-02T14:48:13 | Brielen Madureira, Patrick Kahardipraja, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Incremental models that process sentences one token at a time will sometimes
encounter points where more than one interpretation is possible. Causal models
are forced to output one interpretation and continue, whereas models that can
revise may edit their previous output as the ambiguity is resolved. In this
work, we look at how restart-incremental Transformers build and update internal
states, in an effort to shed light on what processes cause revisions not viable
in autoregressive models. We propose an interpretable way to analyse the
incremental states, showing that their sequential structure encodes information
on the garden path effect and its resolution. Our method brings insights on
various bidirectional encoders for contextualised meaning representation and
dependency parsing, contributing to show their advantage over causal models
when it comes to revisions. | [
-0.10747580975294113,
-0.5231684446334839,
0.7647420763969421,
0.4929981827735901,
0.05648167431354523,
0.02983517199754715,
-0.05535363405942917,
-0.567136287689209,
0.19678810238838196,
0.5258340239524841,
-1.1129693984985352,
0.13923658430576324,
-0.72088623046875,
0.4711354970932007,
-0.5974274277687073,
0.7453970909118652,
-0.4257594048976898,
-0.169697567820549,
0.013003713451325893,
-0.2445390373468399,
-0.7716324925422668,
-0.2023165225982666,
-0.7852421998977661,
-0.7163759469985962,
0.3310077488422394,
0.35617464780807495,
0.8580716252326965,
0.8302155137062073,
0.2822318375110626,
0.3239487111568451,
-0.2945573031902313,
-0.40505510568618774,
-0.24387507140636444,
0.6273097395896912,
-0.16383357346057892,
-0.7225584387779236,
0.13965854048728943,
-0.05112073943018913,
0.8624858856201172,
0.7917109131813049,
-0.07136755436658859,
0.2375565767288208,
0.0059233433566987514,
0.5031924247741699,
-0.33367177844047546,
0.3096569776535034,
-0.8015240430831909,
0.36773407459259033,
-0.1065986230969429,
-0.6405518651008606,
-0.6247754693031311,
-0.06399211287498474,
-0.057468563318252563,
-0.30915379524230957,
0.45973390340805054,
-0.2331906259059906,
0.9797186851501465,
0.7944005131721497,
-0.5918576717376709,
-0.04030361771583557,
-1.073014497756958,
0.687764585018158,
-0.5891894102096558,
0.3661719262599945,
-0.29052895307540894,
0.5911716818809509,
-0.29747289419174194,
-0.8887901902198792,
-0.7042213082313538,
-0.1440495103597641,
-0.46981340646743774,
0.2357049584388733,
-0.11453411728143692,
-0.3810519576072693,
0.43640339374542236,
0.3108186721801758,
-0.2375732958316803,
-0.07894644886255264,
-0.08191715180873871,
0.04099484533071518,
0.1215890422463417,
0.43006041646003723,
0.11988933384418488,
-0.6517603397369385,
-0.8086735010147095,
-0.24940279126167297,
-0.5073601603507996,
0.2913077771663666,
0.2663136422634125,
0.08323889225721359,
-0.13184331357479095,
0.5118851661682129,
0.043936096131801605,
0.5239064693450928,
0.4063827693462372,
0.17462223768234253,
-0.05639208108186722,
-0.20432217419147491,
-0.26527249813079834,
0.26537057757377625,
0.6688962578773499,
0.13484211266040802,
0.005284457933157682,
-0.23682233691215515,
-0.11454207450151443,
0.29728710651397705,
0.432684063911438,
-0.5487683415412903,
-0.02167397364974022,
0.29866328835487366,
-0.35332345962524414,
-0.3040279746055603,
0.22615906596183777,
-0.7269816994667053,
-0.40437692403793335,
-0.5181774497032166,
0.4087176024913788,
-0.2516229748725891,
-0.18920135498046875,
0.25567471981048584,
-0.3525885045528412,
0.24840497970581055,
0.42485740780830383,
-0.5255342125892639,
-0.052931491285562515,
0.48803648352622986,
0.8322337865829468,
0.16597262024879456,
-0.5050622224807739,
-0.17379848659038544,
0.2556036412715912,
-0.36702975630760193,
0.8673423528671265,
-0.28638574481010437,
-0.43897750973701477,
-0.25939473509788513,
0.7986407279968262,
-0.006013582460582256,
-0.2273404598236084,
0.12819784879684448,
-0.5609105825424194,
-0.06154371798038483,
-0.39108577370643616,
0.054310113191604614,
0.02055949531495571,
0.13602758944034576,
-0.661971390247345,
0.589526355266571,
0.1752166748046875,
-0.8192811608314514,
0.6553142070770264,
-0.49100714921951294,
-0.49710556864738464,
-0.3371294140815735,
-0.15141640603542328,
-0.2819620370864868,
0.006625857204198837,
0.07102356106042862,
-0.04873036593198776,
0.03372323513031006,
0.3973632752895355,
-0.11509858071804047,
-0.05578996241092682,
0.27213168144226074,
-0.9142271280288696,
0.9398564100265503,
0.07210838049650192,
-0.5351212024688721,
0.35263803601264954,
-0.49864619970321655,
-0.4162418246269226,
0.16498056054115295,
0.04600024223327637,
0.2397107481956482,
0.2638327479362488,
-0.39988094568252563,
0.2863006293773651,
0.17325054109096527,
-0.7721229791641235,
0.33490967750549316,
-0.22577327489852905,
0.4750969409942627,
1.1266837120056152,
0.5581199526786804,
0.5149400234222412,
-0.45366889238357544,
0.5330674052238464,
0.6458978056907654,
0.4992498457431793,
-0.7578561305999756,
-0.6601938605308533,
-1.0563349723815918,
0.29790282249450684,
-0.14061981439590454,
0.5100459456443787,
-0.7277783155441284,
-0.07162373512983322,
-0.42627549171447754,
-0.47372421622276306,
-0.5608806610107422,
-0.2999248802661896,
-0.05225512757897377,
0.5720993876457214,
0.4030236005783081,
-0.5070511698722839,
-0.5893637537956238,
-1.048115849494934,
-0.5966149568557739,
-0.1175534799695015,
-0.014085698872804642,
0.1336689442396164,
0.5465478301048279,
-0.42501991987228394,
1.0815706253051758,
-0.48796918988227844,
-0.10603764653205872,
0.21894033253192902,
0.5319615006446838,
0.5031967759132385,
0.36136430501937866,
0.18580415844917297,
-0.5722842812538147,
-0.4477863311767578,
-0.06974467635154724,
-0.9282266497612,
-0.01032082736492157,
-0.8046613931655884,
-0.009440160356462002,
-0.05062413960695267,
0.5204641222953796,
-0.6910483241081238,
0.5718642473220825,
0.1785905510187149,
-0.8717426657676697,
0.43811050057411194,
-0.3392297625541687,
0.5666471719741821,
-0.5962203741073608,
-0.3083430826663971,
-0.2159028947353363,
-0.27355316281318665,
-0.13293367624282837,
-0.20538997650146484,
-0.02467360720038414,
-0.09287180006504059,
-0.1730952262878418,
0.4382178783416748,
-0.49970272183418274,
-0.28004536032676697,
-0.091319739818573,
0.012698071077466011,
0.11417520046234131,
0.27384698390960693,
-0.1809646040201187,
0.6967714428901672,
0.09870835393667221,
-0.5459867715835571,
0.12438738346099854,
0.35209691524505615,
-0.26277995109558105,
0.3978480398654938,
-0.4384838044643402,
0.06647942960262299,
-0.547471821308136,
0.3940601348876953,
-1.0744097232818604,
-0.12674401700496674,
0.234180748462677,
-0.5517239570617676,
0.39893126487731934,
-0.2524121403694153,
-0.6197956800460815,
-0.2788587212562561,
0.0582144632935524,
0.29034972190856934,
0.2919972836971283,
-0.8807240724563599,
0.7094628214836121,
0.1513519138097763,
0.28582969307899475,
-0.35949257016181946,
-0.713980495929718,
0.14141325652599335,
-0.13611607253551483,
-0.7655134797096252,
0.27298733592033386,
0.16156160831451416,
-0.5070372819900513,
0.20567090809345245,
-0.16395670175552368,
0.17440269887447357,
0.23602189123630524,
0.5156275629997253,
-0.04542084038257599,
0.05132557824254036,
0.10275164991617203,
0.04398210719227791,
-0.5071007609367371,
0.29230260848999023,
-0.2584483027458191,
0.3647444546222687,
0.032320547848939896,
-0.5123052597045898,
-0.365823358297348,
0.4608670771121979,
0.8632054328918457,
-0.07718297094106674,
0.8834827542304993,
0.4415578246116638,
-0.28447678685188293,
-0.058749374002218246,
-0.3375299274921417,
-0.25098371505737305,
-0.48445630073547363,
-0.1431300789117813,
-0.4706249237060547,
-0.4391070008277893,
0.5266249775886536,
0.0709812194108963,
0.18291305005550385,
0.7322990894317627,
0.3927377164363861,
-0.12237563729286194,
0.9990948438644409,
0.6924210786819458,
0.07856002449989319,
0.3679998517036438,
-0.2615947127342224,
0.33713459968566895,
-0.7102906107902527,
-0.3659537732601166,
-0.44450223445892334,
-0.29449406266212463,
-0.6031161546707153,
-0.39339739084243774,
0.5150388479232788,
0.058219533413648605,
-0.49457424879074097,
0.5340588688850403,
-0.668285071849823,
0.26297104358673096,
0.36963051557540894,
0.07125993072986603,
0.5418246984481812,
-0.26251381635665894,
0.14277958869934082,
-0.23597528040409088,
-0.5777494311332703,
-0.46886032819747925,
0.6077921986579895,
0.24006964266300201,
0.5801889300346375,
0.21856865286827087,
0.13829296827316284,
0.37613704800605774,
0.6328598856925964,
-0.731530487537384,
0.29189595580101013,
0.14783164858818054,
-0.5502575039863586,
-0.09858004748821259,
-0.18995262682437897,
-1.0900880098342896,
0.2957022190093994,
-0.06802751868963242,
-0.7607067227363586,
0.5105757713317871,
0.02675003558397293,
-0.09741193056106567,
0.6710119843482971,
-0.6262019276618958,
0.9950267672538757,
-0.1008075624704361,
-0.2543995976448059,
-0.2670449912548065,
-0.5504088997840881,
0.261005163192749,
0.04448617249727249,
0.15298503637313843,
0.130344420671463,
0.18362264335155487,
0.43511173129081726,
-0.2667703926563263,
0.7981693744659424,
-0.212792307138443,
0.03665322810411453,
0.3391472399234772,
0.38844382762908936,
0.6626354455947876,
0.06777331233024597,
0.12317916750907898,
0.3095868229866028,
0.2772921025753021,
-0.21226026117801666,
-0.7210460305213928,
0.7288581132888794,
-0.5926566123962402,
-0.7764190435409546,
-0.6543363928794861,
-0.3995589017868042,
-0.0498613640666008,
-0.16332578659057617,
0.41605085134506226,
0.4273318648338318,
0.33058592677116394,
-0.15834009647369385,
0.38370323181152344,
-0.2623712122440338,
0.800622820854187,
0.4256115257740021,
-0.27083083987236023,
0.06150517240166664,
0.15420281887054443,
0.11890300363302231,
0.2525261640548706,
0.21252954006195068,
-0.05308639630675316,
-0.08362185209989548,
0.21628586947917938,
-0.4473170042037964,
0.22518081963062286,
-1.1349401473999023,
-0.06988571584224701,
-0.6233823895454407,
-0.10574343055486679,
-0.29006463289260864,
-0.36184853315353394,
-0.39780858159065247,
-0.23797757923603058,
-0.12899544835090637,
-0.022064244374632835,
0.46827125549316406,
1.1167325973510742,
-0.26704666018486023,
0.27953651547431946,
-0.7989491820335388,
0.30955812335014343,
0.2206231951713562,
0.13859622180461884,
0.21099841594696045,
-0.5448631048202515,
-0.15016333758831024,
-0.08673810958862305,
-0.44374096393585205,
-1.1711119413375854,
0.2693004012107849,
-0.17473965883255005,
0.09945205599069595,
0.34134095907211304,
-0.20497025549411774,
0.9637003540992737,
-0.8730480670928955,
0.8575876951217651,
0.14761362969875336,
-0.9489603638648987,
0.6751857399940491,
-0.18772301077842712,
0.8388896584510803,
0.18003569543361664,
0.23709289729595184,
-0.9771119952201843,
-0.5448146462440491,
-0.8602303862571716,
-1.024126410484314,
0.32094135880470276,
0.11159618943929672,
0.05596494302153587,
-0.1677040308713913,
0.5128727555274963,
0.27691394090652466,
0.06017163023352623,
-0.6616474390029907,
-0.4728552997112274,
-0.3523804545402527,
0.1650623232126236,
-0.09295064955949783,
-0.37867653369903564,
-0.05783030018210411,
-0.2461348921060562,
0.4585963487625122,
0.3034713864326477,
0.618320882320404,
0.44641584157943726,
-0.11802682280540466,
-0.6583133339881897,
0.46142518520355225,
0.07678613811731339,
0.737424910068512,
-0.08478528261184692,
0.04943518713116646,
0.1003984808921814,
-0.08691873401403427,
0.41446125507354736,
-0.10437272489070892,
-0.39632993936538696,
0.3733905553817749,
0.7852799892425537,
0.7933118939399719,
0.5201674699783325,
-0.22926388680934906,
0.28539079427719116,
-0.12673504650592804,
0.31994950771331787,
-0.8215630650520325,
-0.0932057797908783,
-0.3649168908596039,
0.6272623538970947,
0.3680109977722168,
0.5099695324897766,
0.028495127335190773,
-0.7233774662017822,
0.49999627470970154,
0.23538300395011902,
-0.7428641319274902,
-0.5170800685882568,
0.9193885326385498,
-0.4091480076313019,
-0.39076852798461914,
0.6704927682876587,
-0.011915044859051704,
-0.47483986616134644,
0.647185742855072,
0.40081343054771423,
1.0776578187942505,
-0.1710047721862793,
0.07239968329668045,
0.7122119665145874,
0.4465581178665161,
0.16512924432754517,
0.06509869545698166,
-0.14528803527355194,
-0.739290177822113,
-0.6824172139167786,
-0.6682443618774414,
-0.3249739110469818,
-0.08076794445514679,
-0.8852806091308594,
0.025054041296243668,
-0.34226351976394653,
-0.3132602870464325,
-0.15839475393295288,
-0.642905592918396,
-0.7219043970108032,
0.2434527426958084,
-0.2312987893819809,
0.7800954580307007,
-0.9541410207748413,
0.5917104482650757,
0.42312881350517273,
-0.40597429871559143,
-0.6620839834213257,
0.31645074486732483,
0.031675830483436584,
-0.4835430681705475,
0.8128220438957214,
0.20545156300067902,
-0.20333778858184814,
-0.020688239485025406,
-0.4904104173183441,
-0.9979916214942932,
1.0932512283325195,
0.039274923503398895,
-0.4094771444797516,
-0.0262189619243145,
-0.03194000571966171,
0.44490745663642883,
0.01133762951940298,
0.1839040368795395,
0.7476588487625122,
0.6970606446266174,
0.13019698858261108,
-0.8302891850471497,
0.10489476472139359,
0.016849204897880554,
-0.07943671941757202,
0.574474573135376,
-0.42843979597091675,
1.1158452033996582,
-0.2661983370780945,
-0.7653459310531616,
-0.017716754227876663,
0.6109073758125305,
-0.2419208437204361,
-0.10971811413764954,
0.7008733153343201,
0.7838535904884338,
0.3774421513080597,
-0.4422975182533264,
1.361476182937622,
-0.4310038685798645,
0.4558582901954651,
1.3687057495117188,
0.15068504214286804,
0.5739538073539734,
0.6082099080085754,
-0.34698641300201416,
0.8405535817146301,
0.6662084460258484,
0.01545786764472723,
0.5384373068809509,
-0.09000549465417862,
-0.3801339566707611,
-0.12438280135393143,
-0.03375253453850746,
-0.20114025473594666,
0.3240656554698944,
-0.025006890296936035,
-0.2006942331790924,
-0.5403105020523071,
0.07321340590715408,
0.15622840821743011,
-0.07899123430252075,
-0.1834707409143448,
0.42535093426704407,
0.17440830171108246,
-0.9506815671920776,
0.0598079077899456,
-0.07545846700668335,
0.18686693906784058,
-0.5055335760116577,
-0.24699772894382477,
-0.1895780712366104,
0.5141439437866211,
-0.15479284524917603,
-1.0295398235321045,
0.5782867074012756,
-0.16983167827129364,
-0.3566398024559021,
-0.7922905683517456,
0.3178192973136902,
-0.1936698853969574,
-0.2613958716392517,
0.5981086492538452,
-0.005569057539105415,
-0.2979591190814972,
-0.014165570959448814,
-0.5658401846885681,
-0.16855880618095398,
-0.0005198698490858078,
-0.23994150757789612,
-0.06252836436033249,
0.7233010530471802,
0.1742619425058365,
0.8597263693809509,
0.39074480533599854,
0.22268901765346527,
0.18318475782871246,
0.05809587240219116,
0.4468981623649597,
-0.949764609336853,
-0.26604512333869934,
-0.8660669922828674,
1.036309838294983,
0.15603342652320862,
-0.20226231217384338,
0.9644973278045654,
0.08796641230583191,
0.9091536402702332,
0.02357064187526703,
0.4884454309940338,
0.1157078966498375,
0.2443534880876541,
-0.5680924654006958,
0.48492875695228577,
-0.4059838354587555,
0.33847859501838684,
0.07113809138536453,
-0.5043695569038391,
0.09503203630447388,
0.5508702993392944,
-0.45256832242012024,
-0.3748567998409271,
0.9496209621429443,
0.49156075716018677,
0.09379014372825623,
0.22416479885578156,
-0.0503883920609951,
0.8886861801147461,
0.4034597873687744,
0.3570152521133423,
1.050514817237854,
-0.5711475610733032,
0.14619150757789612,
-0.3974611759185791,
-0.10660546272993088,
0.24686802923679352,
-0.7810234427452087,
-0.18376827239990234,
-0.8356658816337585,
-0.18347831070423126,
-0.7767700552940369,
-0.39725542068481445,
0.4770558178424835,
0.1972372680902481,
-0.7022576332092285,
-0.19436447322368622,
-0.2656104862689972,
0.12116202712059021,
-0.2615506649017334,
-0.35446351766586304,
0.180439293384552,
-0.5426850318908691,
-0.2909596562385559,
0.5481990575790405,
0.6365172863006592,
0.006264010444283485,
-0.44589370489120483,
0.33067652583122253,
-0.14178504049777985,
0.07874343544244766,
0.5001282691955566,
0.16044269502162933,
-0.6868613958358765,
-0.5895819067955017,
-0.37420469522476196,
0.24208885431289673,
0.5031355619430542,
0.9869168996810913,
-1.1030287742614746,
0.8436197638511658,
0.1945035457611084,
0.1307443082332611,
0.8050743341445923,
-0.17280113697052002,
0.7251675724983215,
-0.2916608452796936,
0.29396817088127136,
0.14246366918087006,
0.7545081973075867,
0.383267879486084,
-0.5460349917411804,
0.511437714099884,
0.3893052637577057,
-0.6089604496955872,
-0.6132457256317139,
0.6564088463783264,
-0.4303862154483795,
-0.4618789553642273,
0.9476390480995178,
-0.04495234414935112,
-0.32562708854675293,
-0.11782349646091461,
0.16139718890190125,
0.5150407552719116,
0.15606707334518433,
0.7960168123245239,
0.6199323534965515,
-0.2793654501438141,
-0.010030620731413364,
-0.5533757209777832,
0.32532522082328796,
0.06020214781165123,
-0.5131022930145264,
-0.09587372094392776,
0.35235804319381714,
0.3085319697856903,
0.2799147963523865,
0.5973353385925293,
-0.19391953945159912,
-0.09505116939544678,
0.24531254172325134,
-0.4218915104866028,
0.20926766097545624,
-0.6282467842102051,
-0.4522571265697479,
0.06489837169647217,
0.04169594496488571,
-0.03683838993310928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13109v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13109v2 | CIF-Bench: A Chinese Instruction-Following Benchmark for Evaluating the Generalizability of Large Language Models | 2024-02-20T16:02:12 | 2024-06-04T14:26:30 | Yizhi LI, Ge Zhang, Xingwei Qu, Jiali Li, Zhaoqun Li, Zekun Wang, Hao Li, Ruibin Yuan, Yinghao Ma, Kai Zhang, Wangchunshu Zhou, Yiming Liang, Lei Zhang, Lei Ma, Jiajun Zhang, Zuowen Li, Stephen W. Huang, Chenghua Lin, Jie Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advancement of large language models (LLMs) has enhanced the ability to
generalize across a wide range of unseen natural language processing (NLP)
tasks through instruction-following. Yet, their effectiveness often diminishes
in low-resource languages like Chinese, exacerbated by biased evaluations from
data leakage, casting doubt on their true generalizability to new linguistic
territories. In response, we introduce the Chinese Instruction-Following
Benchmark (CIF-Bench), designed to evaluate the zero-shot generalizability of
LLMs to the Chinese language. CIF-Bench comprises 150 tasks and 15,000
input-output pairs, developed by native speakers to test complex reasoning and
Chinese cultural nuances across 20 categories. To mitigate data contamination,
we release only half of the dataset publicly, with the remainder kept private,
and introduce diversified instructions to minimize score variance, totaling
45,000 data instances. Our evaluation of 28 selected LLMs reveals a noticeable
performance gap, with the best model scoring only 52.9%, highlighting the
limitations of LLMs in less familiar language and task contexts. This work not
only uncovers the current limitations of LLMs in handling Chinese language
tasks but also sets a new standard for future LLM generalizability research,
pushing towards the development of more adaptable, culturally informed, and
linguistically diverse models. | [
-0.15433290600776672,
-0.4960111975669861,
0.4637867212295532,
0.5148792266845703,
-0.0744204968214035,
-0.14295901358127594,
-0.6022156476974487,
-0.3388558328151703,
-0.3303782641887665,
0.41272634267807007,
-0.36203429102897644,
-0.8045929670333862,
-0.43803656101226807,
-0.1536920815706253,
-0.5198615789413452,
0.7664896249771118,
-0.15566790103912354,
0.16935090720653534,
-0.21211236715316772,
-0.21391810476779938,
-0.17220690846443176,
-0.5659996867179871,
-0.4033001661300659,
-0.3772524297237396,
0.4166581332683563,
0.463496595621109,
0.5231058597564697,
1.0167263746261597,
0.5211811065673828,
0.11558179557323456,
0.13490435481071472,
-0.023565417155623436,
-0.46935170888900757,
-0.20662498474121094,
-0.1549634486436844,
-0.49815288186073303,
-0.3641928434371948,
-0.19367966055870056,
0.8222125172615051,
0.8966241478919983,
-0.19911345839500427,
0.27615419030189514,
0.23821784555912018,
0.7397082448005676,
-0.9050168991088867,
0.34012937545776367,
-0.45967498421669006,
0.09563876688480377,
-0.4062957763671875,
0.12547826766967773,
-0.47734859585762024,
-0.3261473476886749,
-0.043470680713653564,
-0.4531283974647522,
0.33437448740005493,
-0.266053706407547,
0.6666150689125061,
0.14876475930213928,
-0.16812404990196228,
0.0654434785246849,
-0.7653535008430481,
0.7289167046546936,
-0.7888922095298767,
0.2905786633491516,
0.45778554677963257,
0.4797900915145874,
-0.13271424174308777,
-0.6633137464523315,
-0.31922367215156555,
-0.41996970772743225,
0.14054551720619202,
-0.033787764608860016,
0.1750941425561905,
0.14725953340530396,
0.2437552660703659,
0.45632848143577576,
-0.8047179579734802,
0.24894008040428162,
-0.00705579062923789,
0.12708315253257751,
0.7545866966247559,
0.1701626181602478,
0.4445202648639679,
0.139948770403862,
-0.4100930392742157,
-0.30202168226242065,
-0.9017782807350159,
0.20716753602027893,
0.0880250483751297,
0.3936508297920227,
-0.3546822667121887,
0.2365826666355133,
-0.6091170310974121,
0.6998249888420105,
-0.10567785799503326,
0.13029912114143372,
0.14975197613239288,
-0.3511510193347931,
-0.37756773829460144,
-0.20099695026874542,
0.8802027106285095,
0.3481779396533966,
0.3284444212913513,
-0.39201459288597107,
-0.14754444360733032,
-0.2849673926830292,
-0.21251362562179565,
-0.7755305171012878,
-0.22863662242889404,
0.10566055029630661,
-0.30653828382492065,
0.09329594671726227,
0.19929370284080505,
-0.5743858814239502,
-0.3752421438694,
-0.08183777332305908,
-0.07428204268217087,
-0.4154573976993561,
-0.21891850233078003,
-0.051331013441085815,
0.1262384057044983,
0.6929160356521606,
0.11587121337652206,
-1.1591960191726685,
0.4014662504196167,
0.9433321356773376,
0.6912784576416016,
-0.34031742811203003,
-0.3377249538898468,
-0.7015146017074585,
0.3013259768486023,
-0.5700071454048157,
0.6466034650802612,
-0.7539498805999756,
-0.4730287790298462,
0.15880122780799866,
0.10912983119487762,
-0.15552879869937897,
-0.7574329376220703,
0.7156291604042053,
-0.12321945279836655,
-0.12602204084396362,
-0.6146478056907654,
-0.5034762620925903,
-0.1047617569565773,
0.3242841362953186,
-0.6047521233558655,
0.9655228853225708,
0.027793947607278824,
-0.27760764956474304,
0.172915518283844,
-0.536485493183136,
-0.3821221888065338,
0.19591647386550903,
-0.4252873659133911,
0.04321499541401863,
0.08222611993551254,
0.22062790393829346,
0.44309523701667786,
-0.6289141774177551,
0.2997608780860901,
-0.6630241870880127,
-0.905674159526825,
0.01097014918923378,
-0.5616764426231384,
0.7153507471084595,
0.01289142295718193,
-0.5734052062034607,
-0.13806867599487305,
-0.6762714385986328,
0.24216407537460327,
0.0873386487364769,
-0.29029178619384766,
-0.2670750319957733,
0.12265081703662872,
-0.11721695214509964,
0.1271941214799881,
0.2641367018222809,
-0.468565434217453,
0.12362174689769745,
-0.3000962436199188,
0.11680145561695099,
0.7177457213401794,
-0.25994211435317993,
0.3526277542114258,
-0.2865228056907654,
0.37173938751220703,
-0.13498908281326294,
0.18729670345783234,
-0.2869161069393158,
-0.10497500747442245,
-0.9345635771751404,
-0.08381564915180206,
0.42006659507751465,
0.6154712438583374,
-0.6416563987731934,
0.13564062118530273,
-0.2784506678581238,
-0.6635127067565918,
-0.36749961972236633,
0.4090067744255066,
0.5471370220184326,
0.24414962530136108,
0.1744023710489273,
-0.2439473271369934,
-0.12160035222768784,
-0.9894322752952576,
-0.32861581444740295,
-0.1673668920993805,
-0.29731476306915283,
0.24103917181491852,
0.2143181562423706,
-0.030461667105555534,
0.39434540271759033,
-0.27718526124954224,
-0.0675501748919487,
-0.21045880019664764,
0.045561179518699646,
0.2627382278442383,
0.5122888088226318,
0.6293874382972717,
-0.49908819794654846,
-0.7875127196311951,
0.1602574735879898,
-0.7697488069534302,
-0.18494324386119843,
-0.1917281299829483,
-0.2889598309993744,
0.14880743622779846,
0.5068035125732422,
-0.3732280135154724,
0.2560707628726959,
0.6779537796974182,
0.04302568361163139,
0.5671715140342712,
-0.12695299088954926,
0.111718088388443,
-0.5441478490829468,
0.2563346028327942,
0.13332344591617584,
0.11303257197141647,
-0.6552906036376953,
0.39838752150535583,
0.393722265958786,
0.13877789676189423,
-0.4645122289657593,
0.5054998993873596,
-0.6217747926712036,
-0.1148095354437828,
-0.2780795693397522,
0.1345347911119461,
-0.19458305835723877,
0.7719493508338928,
0.04088689386844635,
0.614862859249115,
0.43550536036491394,
-0.7484632134437561,
0.2481313794851303,
-0.27441221475601196,
-0.4098762273788452,
0.3810720443725586,
-0.7141917943954468,
0.2327442616224289,
0.06314775347709656,
0.11795297265052795,
-0.8884448409080505,
-0.23548197746276855,
0.27874869108200073,
-0.16260729730129242,
0.38491031527519226,
0.08771343529224396,
-0.667331337928772,
-0.1962813287973404,
-0.38734742999076843,
0.38424360752105713,
0.28842514753341675,
-0.6500354409217834,
0.2932358682155609,
0.025136379525065422,
0.03588965907692909,
-0.7505465149879456,
-0.8814918994903564,
0.006330547388643026,
0.15485545992851257,
-0.4948175549507141,
0.40451690554618835,
-0.3281228244304657,
-0.2534322440624237,
-0.15729059278964996,
-0.09599675983190536,
-0.2812211215496063,
0.2028931826353073,
0.19930219650268555,
0.33816802501678467,
-0.37644141912460327,
0.18953903019428253,
-0.1131618395447731,
0.15585505962371826,
0.27297860383987427,
-0.038076043128967285,
0.5313602089881897,
-0.12766756117343903,
-0.792199969291687,
-0.3125080168247223,
0.13472925126552582,
0.25666511058807373,
-0.28866493701934814,
0.6395036578178406,
0.5345152616500854,
-0.47835099697113037,
-0.35589948296546936,
-0.446738064289093,
0.2748916745185852,
-0.45340463519096375,
0.5304750800132751,
-0.24365438520908356,
-0.5896851420402527,
0.3637755215167999,
-0.012926103547215462,
0.450068861246109,
0.4237361252307892,
0.4766530394554138,
0.07547374069690704,
0.8784195184707642,
0.7256953716278076,
-0.3857147991657257,
0.4248320460319519,
-0.04105009511113167,
-0.03132785111665726,
-0.7584779262542725,
-0.008932746015489101,
-0.47365128993988037,
-0.31725406646728516,
-0.6775597929954529,
-0.5893545150756836,
0.06631215661764145,
0.06226525455713272,
-0.28966936469078064,
0.11429373174905777,
-0.40569061040878296,
0.6963827013969421,
0.4851300120353699,
-0.05679788067936897,
0.2552211880683899,
-0.28067782521247864,
-0.20104561746120453,
0.11418630182743073,
-0.4993349611759186,
-0.34013915061950684,
1.1926666498184204,
0.18390871584415436,
0.6101928949356079,
0.04181595519185066,
0.6851807236671448,
0.2541932761669159,
0.49954158067703247,
-0.4283503592014313,
0.5484691262245178,
-0.6720215082168579,
-0.4918466806411743,
-0.25392332673072815,
-0.2939450144767761,
-0.5694386959075928,
0.3271036744117737,
0.10187055170536041,
-0.7943217754364014,
0.05161503329873085,
-0.040342651307582855,
-0.28674235939979553,
0.37482380867004395,
-0.7205653786659241,
0.8451781868934631,
-0.5075010061264038,
-0.4308503270149231,
0.020184259861707687,
-0.3503505289554596,
0.8679095506668091,
-0.08260703086853027,
0.15379764139652252,
-0.26959919929504395,
-0.17343571782112122,
0.4721393287181854,
-0.14378796517848969,
0.8429726362228394,
-0.19652891159057617,
0.032174002379179,
0.18926525115966797,
-0.1436687707901001,
0.3614928126335144,
-0.19969354569911957,
-0.22338701784610748,
0.14712409675121307,
0.11850240081548691,
-0.5957733392715454,
-0.5852043628692627,
0.8543269634246826,
-0.7825464606285095,
-0.8021726608276367,
-0.4107065200805664,
-0.5260229706764221,
-0.36844155192375183,
0.15726229548454285,
0.14079783856868744,
0.13418899476528168,
-0.6377381086349487,
0.4078713357448578,
0.7059947848320007,
-0.38261738419532776,
0.5772349238395691,
0.778607189655304,
-0.19694480299949646,
-0.054237429052591324,
0.9215669631958008,
0.2110937535762787,
0.368821918964386,
0.666637659072876,
-0.1139313131570816,
-0.08928687870502472,
-0.5385609269142151,
-0.47680211067199707,
0.21085180342197418,
-0.5800943970680237,
0.06812823563814163,
-0.2351357787847519,
-0.5584110617637634,
-0.3225148618221283,
0.05155114457011223,
-0.39190739393234253,
-0.20209276676177979,
-0.13514874875545502,
-0.0022036214359104633,
-0.3194234073162079,
0.5726038813591003,
-0.02487189695239067,
0.14940816164016724,
-0.8000245094299316,
0.26376867294311523,
0.20120760798454285,
0.6498005390167236,
0.17078934609889984,
-0.4999517798423767,
-0.4327639639377594,
0.18186362087726593,
-0.2625713646411896,
-0.5733112096786499,
0.14736980199813843,
0.2076120674610138,
0.8895201683044434,
0.5711034536361694,
0.356020450592041,
0.6641345024108887,
-0.31608498096466064,
0.8050187230110168,
0.12637072801589966,
-0.851466715335846,
0.2813970446586609,
-0.33676832914352417,
0.7281707525253296,
0.473535418510437,
0.17305490374565125,
-0.7724084258079529,
-0.4040330648422241,
-0.3794584572315216,
-0.6480632424354553,
0.7315921783447266,
-0.199012890458107,
0.15940947830677032,
0.07791896909475327,
0.2806624472141266,
0.07520648092031479,
-0.08781396597623825,
-0.6270793080329895,
-0.37067344784736633,
-0.06919806450605392,
-0.10152094811201096,
-0.132716566324234,
-0.2422584593296051,
-0.02793930284678936,
-0.09629630297422409,
0.4320145547389984,
-0.2892391085624695,
0.06060191988945007,
-0.07833771407604218,
-0.17848657071590424,
-0.08833278715610504,
0.3803239166736603,
0.4480402171611786,
0.618354082107544,
-0.2233385443687439,
-0.042251937091350555,
0.4166249930858612,
-0.4194955825805664,
-0.04565506428480148,
0.24764618277549744,
-0.2687870264053345,
-0.025526555255055428,
0.3971523940563202,
0.5290167331695557,
0.24862225353717804,
-0.9424973726272583,
0.48545700311660767,
-0.20629678666591644,
-0.22269800305366516,
-0.48240163922309875,
0.5196816325187683,
0.3945617973804474,
0.17962244153022766,
0.3832826614379883,
-0.3058123290538788,
0.11087124049663544,
-0.5230046510696411,
0.16024595499038696,
0.3763904869556427,
-0.47402557730674744,
-0.31426435708999634,
0.627280056476593,
0.1454930156469345,
-0.02864665724337101,
0.6214245557785034,
-0.10769863426685333,
-0.15563133358955383,
0.7369508147239685,
0.28038010001182556,
1.0402616262435913,
-0.34175074100494385,
0.31779563426971436,
0.4646601378917694,
0.4472115635871887,
-0.20823542773723602,
0.026872243732213974,
-0.19419628381729126,
-0.5010255575180054,
-0.3204202353954315,
-0.35513338446617126,
-0.6969802975654602,
0.3104771077632904,
-0.8874027729034424,
0.20891515910625458,
-0.8769106864929199,
0.14387986063957214,
-0.23036092519760132,
0.1377556324005127,
-0.7404455542564392,
0.188320592045784,
0.5159465670585632,
1.1842703819274902,
-0.5394166707992554,
1.1331839561462402,
0.3674256503582001,
-0.2996459901332855,
-0.7074447870254517,
0.1957334280014038,
0.03656812757253647,
-0.8906124830245972,
0.46569645404815674,
0.3039088547229767,
0.17962318658828735,
-0.5959755778312683,
-0.7359461188316345,
-0.8113678693771362,
1.2463479042053223,
0.6534271240234375,
-0.8374666571617126,
-0.045283764600753784,
0.49614450335502625,
0.6330432891845703,
-0.3647572696208954,
0.42183026671409607,
0.8891292214393616,
0.48387935757637024,
0.008312424644827843,
-0.6772582530975342,
0.10913580656051636,
-0.4651745557785034,
0.11556098610162735,
-0.12646982073783875,
-1.0223993062973022,
0.8887585401535034,
-0.06643422693014145,
-0.4482342004776001,
0.2943047881126404,
0.6916710138320923,
0.3123610019683838,
0.2937861680984497,
0.39163652062416077,
0.21965907514095306,
0.8048104643821716,
-0.21167993545532227,
1.0698878765106201,
-0.4351394772529602,
-0.13744886219501495,
1.3671413660049438,
-0.4431613087654114,
1.09794282913208,
0.09906895458698273,
-0.12984012067317963,
0.5263996720314026,
0.5832743048667908,
-0.1666737198829651,
0.36664536595344543,
0.37506020069122314,
-0.2805771231651306,
-0.1944129914045334,
-0.3546893894672394,
-0.4172225296497345,
0.44113653898239136,
0.269539475440979,
-0.40633296966552734,
-0.25732481479644775,
-0.524672269821167,
0.04726206883788109,
0.2222348004579544,
-0.19501017034053802,
0.4861106872558594,
0.06100084260106087,
-0.7824674248695374,
0.7897418141365051,
0.06377150863409042,
0.5570032000541687,
-0.7855048775672913,
-0.12892985343933105,
-0.5005059242248535,
0.27614688873291016,
-0.1709698736667633,
-0.6754221320152283,
0.07648525387048721,
0.24361638724803925,
-0.20089592039585114,
0.01831699348986149,
0.41999250650405884,
-0.5708135366439819,
-0.3544626832008362,
0.5854723453521729,
0.44643309712409973,
0.06899107247591019,
-0.09430166333913803,
-0.6240308284759521,
0.16922032833099365,
0.23414461314678192,
-0.09795327484607697,
0.7350761890411377,
0.38007688522338867,
-0.13580921292304993,
0.658748984336853,
0.4809723496437073,
0.06166214123368263,
0.033244539052248,
0.2145242542028427,
0.7501132488250732,
-0.8779534697532654,
-0.2008671760559082,
-0.7629439234733582,
0.2225172370672226,
-0.07449091225862503,
-0.33592164516448975,
0.5731468200683594,
0.44762492179870605,
1.0997058153152466,
0.18385210633277893,
1.0094337463378906,
0.20084218680858612,
0.38244640827178955,
-0.3061177432537079,
0.7771936655044556,
-0.4781615138053894,
0.4492666721343994,
-0.05368799343705177,
-0.897601306438446,
-0.20120900869369507,
0.09714764356613159,
-0.4095607101917267,
0.0193388182669878,
0.5726022720336914,
0.7422548532485962,
0.1228591799736023,
0.11104990541934967,
0.4761928915977478,
0.13235025107860565,
0.36049243807792664,
1.113627314567566,
0.5790961980819702,
-0.27734747529029846,
0.8647390604019165,
-0.48839741945266724,
-0.32973870635032654,
-0.0813535824418068,
-0.6093149781227112,
-0.8779059648513794,
-0.3105323016643524,
-0.11264824867248535,
0.25629279017448425,
0.12602518498897552,
0.7118154764175415,
0.5353197455406189,
-1.0376347303390503,
-0.6821742653846741,
0.10074523091316223,
0.10497332364320755,
-0.545731782913208,
-0.20737934112548828,
0.4740164577960968,
-0.4230392575263977,
-0.9341349005699158,
0.2467299848794937,
0.20307382941246033,
-0.22929158806800842,
-0.32965585589408875,
-0.25006839632987976,
-0.2489047795534134,
-0.018645016476511955,
0.3595552444458008,
0.6732206344604492,
-0.6967735290527344,
-0.2798435091972351,
0.2643328607082367,
-0.39851680397987366,
-0.09421107172966003,
0.5139453411102295,
-0.4333747923374176,
0.5071426630020142,
0.4614531397819519,
0.9003572463989258,
0.4102114140987396,
-0.14756692945957184,
0.9295276999473572,
-0.5403357744216919,
-0.09630220383405685,
-0.0021289228461682796,
0.3917880654335022,
0.4385402500629425,
-0.1399931013584137,
0.7720664739608765,
0.026969801634550095,
-0.35444048047065735,
-0.7638240456581116,
-0.1423475444316864,
-0.7247963547706604,
-0.25542715191841125,
1.081038236618042,
-0.538608729839325,
-0.36488077044487,
0.26641911268234253,
0.2550581991672516,
0.2583589553833008,
-0.2729954421520233,
0.6928813457489014,
0.9588889479637146,
-0.053739629685878754,
-0.36371201276779175,
-0.6281480193138123,
0.2870936691761017,
0.46075761318206787,
-0.7595565915107727,
0.3725740909576416,
0.28068599104881287,
0.24633489549160004,
-0.1125175952911377,
0.6790227293968201,
-0.07115016877651215,
0.5977157354354858,
0.0981142520904541,
0.03987546265125275,
0.006298847030848265,
-0.05266112834215164,
-0.24211472272872925,
0.18435253202915192,
0.13889801502227783,
-0.3411531150341034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13098v1 | ELAD: Explanation-Guided Large Language Models Active Distillation | 2024-02-20T15:47:59 | 2024-02-20T15:47:59 | Yifei Zhang, Bo Pan, Chen Ling, Yuntong Hu, Liang Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The deployment and application of Large Language Models (LLMs) is hindered by
their memory inefficiency, computational demands, and the high costs of API
inferences. Traditional distillation methods, which transfer the capabilities
of LLMs to smaller models, often fail to determine whether the knowledge has
been sufficiently transferred, potentially resulting in high costs or
incomplete distillation. In this paper, we propose an Explanation-Guided LLMs
Active Distillation (ELAD) framework that employs an active learning strategy
to optimize the balance between annotation costs and model performance. To
improve efficient sample selection, we introduce an explanation-guided sample
selection method that identifies samples challenging its reasoning by
exploiting uncertainties in explanation steps. Additionally, we present a
customized LLM-annotated explanation revision technique where the teacher model
detects and corrects flaws in the student model's reasoning. Our experiments
across various reasoning datasets demonstrate that our framework significantly
enhances the efficiency of LLM knowledge distillation. | [
-0.13083039224147797,
-1.1929597854614258,
0.8998301029205322,
0.03828142210841179,
-0.3358660638332367,
-0.06839996576309204,
-0.4823150634765625,
-0.18886619806289673,
-0.2027016580104828,
0.43859434127807617,
-0.5529418587684631,
-0.4717709422111511,
-0.5084799528121948,
0.16870518028736115,
-0.42817747592926025,
0.8986910581588745,
-0.4930966794490814,
-0.11040374636650085,
-0.1159873753786087,
0.14893220365047455,
-0.29257339239120483,
-0.058096978813409805,
-0.9411824941635132,
-0.5863816738128662,
0.5367242693901062,
0.4635992646217346,
0.47167474031448364,
0.9360114932060242,
0.2896338701248169,
0.2556881904602051,
-0.561586320400238,
0.36585524678230286,
-0.2993227243423462,
0.577721118927002,
-0.07739630341529846,
-0.7149026989936829,
-0.3643324077129364,
-0.1366381198167801,
0.2687774896621704,
0.9115248322486877,
-0.3300417959690094,
0.11874967068433762,
-0.1900634467601776,
0.6357103586196899,
-0.776952862739563,
0.08441650867462158,
-0.7513523697853088,
-0.13826896250247955,
0.03111749142408371,
0.06872467696666718,
-0.41999149322509766,
-0.23328404128551483,
0.4459749460220337,
-0.6652774214744568,
0.2771867513656616,
0.05491809919476509,
0.5852515697479248,
0.6765846610069275,
-0.4475613832473755,
-0.6316509246826172,
-0.953353762626648,
0.7509148120880127,
-0.6677247285842896,
0.014712843112647533,
0.5406357645988464,
0.5963456034660339,
-0.15534895658493042,
-0.8097590804100037,
-0.6426399350166321,
0.16298358142375946,
0.0011786484392359853,
-0.07745121419429779,
-0.05699395760893822,
0.272749125957489,
0.1832333207130432,
0.47011420130729675,
-0.35251128673553467,
0.11191718280315399,
-0.3666929006576538,
0.019194019958376884,
0.5791018605232239,
-0.2472490668296814,
-0.0221190694719553,
0.17561756074428558,
-0.3557741343975067,
0.1937882900238037,
-0.7926724553108215,
-0.26848283410072327,
0.4556307792663574,
0.17058147490024567,
0.03527052700519562,
0.48025304079055786,
-0.012338919565081596,
0.9078649282455444,
0.18048904836177826,
-0.2388201355934143,
0.08777603507041931,
-0.05171593278646469,
-0.3490540087223053,
0.4038955271244049,
0.29730457067489624,
0.01877204328775406,
0.08689971268177032,
0.11970160156488419,
-0.5219421982765198,
-0.06002739444375038,
-0.07107952237129211,
-0.878109335899353,
-0.4415595829486847,
0.6084541082382202,
-0.4119284749031067,
-0.3834060728549957,
-0.33742648363113403,
-0.8117955923080444,
-0.47547075152397156,
-0.32776615023612976,
0.4380885660648346,
-0.15492326021194458,
-0.320921391248703,
0.2076503187417984,
-0.16133683919906616,
-0.3096712529659271,
0.6804897785186768,
-1.0441182851791382,
0.04794488474726677,
0.38305482268333435,
0.7227237820625305,
-0.2398287057876587,
0.10982222855091095,
-0.3761803209781647,
0.3897380232810974,
-0.1887487918138504,
0.6778699159622192,
-0.4993724226951599,
-0.25054675340652466,
-0.0574706569314003,
-0.14182984828948975,
0.13469141721725464,
-0.6743021011352539,
0.5947368741035461,
-0.4671347439289093,
0.13603447377681732,
-0.2049318552017212,
-0.634442150592804,
-0.5583034753799438,
0.13402490317821503,
-0.7451254725456238,
0.9648247361183167,
-0.2281561940908432,
-0.5027195811271667,
0.3802275061607361,
-0.6969197392463684,
-0.4309655725955963,
0.01514189038425684,
0.00047257152618840337,
-0.5443506240844727,
0.1859646737575531,
0.5057331919670105,
0.45098933577537537,
-0.1936826854944229,
0.42247313261032104,
-0.14940422773361206,
-0.3511982262134552,
0.1408681720495224,
-0.6241180896759033,
0.8516665101051331,
0.5675142407417297,
-0.38526222109794617,
0.0009978368179872632,
-0.8805822730064392,
-0.29267796874046326,
0.25551658868789673,
-0.5039125680923462,
-0.5289621949195862,
0.18097205460071564,
-0.39070647954940796,
-0.17097310721874237,
0.4158685505390167,
-0.29389554262161255,
0.16042236983776093,
-0.10055826604366302,
0.4261065125465393,
0.8666598200798035,
0.13937455415725708,
0.4678564667701721,
-0.09579723328351974,
0.6698065996170044,
0.050709422677755356,
0.10366808623075485,
-0.6390407681465149,
-0.32379698753356934,
-0.7773861885070801,
-0.5308094024658203,
0.2695420980453491,
0.33139264583587646,
-0.6346102356910706,
0.2623285949230194,
0.14387433230876923,
-0.2824689745903015,
-0.7131423354148865,
0.43670016527175903,
0.22054290771484375,
0.6141099333763123,
0.38788852095603943,
0.3956291675567627,
-0.48856237530708313,
-0.8290902972221375,
-0.0583571195602417,
-0.4262726306915283,
0.07466525584459305,
0.060294508934020996,
0.44184860587120056,
-0.0328838936984539,
0.7828137874603271,
-0.4790414869785309,
0.02037028968334198,
-0.4218822121620178,
0.30719128251075745,
0.23911850154399872,
-0.023003684356808662,
0.5605230331420898,
-0.9984637498855591,
-0.47123852372169495,
-0.08326608687639236,
-0.5532326698303223,
-0.8167787194252014,
-0.29975199699401855,
0.031821008771657944,
0.009976191446185112,
0.516539454460144,
-0.43725594878196716,
0.28013232350349426,
0.6806238293647766,
-0.2870652675628662,
0.3572777509689331,
-0.34270891547203064,
-0.1392860859632492,
-0.7707139253616333,
-0.11420346796512604,
0.006165493279695511,
-0.055800411850214005,
-0.3867836594581604,
-0.008804738521575928,
0.06182350218296051,
0.16540978848934174,
-0.30951693654060364,
0.533204972743988,
-0.8893947005271912,
0.3022904694080353,
-0.6370872855186462,
0.3834882378578186,
0.35640308260917664,
0.3461182117462158,
-0.11276112496852875,
0.5225851535797119,
0.6140201091766357,
-0.5944567918777466,
0.6449316143989563,
-0.058211129158735275,
-0.28305959701538086,
0.3391615152359009,
-0.7275121808052063,
-0.09145812690258026,
-0.38525688648223877,
0.3421930968761444,
-1.199384331703186,
-0.095140241086483,
-0.24328576028347015,
-0.06293006241321564,
0.31695613265037537,
-0.37704533338546753,
-0.25729385018348694,
-0.29705554246902466,
-0.047963451594114304,
0.17213399708271027,
0.5188903212547302,
-0.9507979154586792,
0.8136561512947083,
0.040310949087142944,
-0.11214549094438553,
-0.5465677976608276,
-0.830215573310852,
-0.20199324190616608,
-0.5119554400444031,
-0.3790968954563141,
0.29209423065185547,
-0.002903588814660907,
-0.7149709463119507,
0.2544870972633362,
-0.405752956867218,
0.011560061015188694,
0.4943106770515442,
0.0663168877363205,
0.16654857993125916,
-0.1169983372092247,
0.2969626784324646,
0.37146881222724915,
0.09729187935590744,
0.18366220593452454,
-0.08311843127012253,
0.09301896393299103,
0.32759085297584534,
-0.5956268310546875,
-0.4241043031215668,
0.010311692021787167,
0.5427635312080383,
-0.17374062538146973,
0.8492341637611389,
0.20875883102416992,
-0.3396305441856384,
-0.8397308588027954,
-0.5684089660644531,
-0.2435932755470276,
-0.4892117381095886,
0.39257943630218506,
-0.36885955929756165,
-0.43009230494499207,
0.6996639370918274,
-0.4460431933403015,
0.4957607090473175,
0.37247857451438904,
0.6479975581169128,
0.07448922097682953,
1.0392248630523682,
0.1921025961637497,
0.3389798104763031,
0.4993065297603607,
-0.06772396713495255,
0.5116848349571228,
-0.4426487982273102,
-0.3106454014778137,
-0.6148495078086853,
-0.5253766179084778,
0.005338758695870638,
-0.49708619713783264,
0.16704413294792175,
0.3944915533065796,
-0.1339293122291565,
-0.2044028788805008,
-0.5593125820159912,
0.6480084657669067,
0.3566865921020508,
-0.19598901271820068,
0.5614417791366577,
0.03467438369989395,
-0.18747000396251678,
0.21773624420166016,
-0.5497424006462097,
-0.7563213109970093,
1.0495011806488037,
0.5005607604980469,
1.0422148704528809,
0.4017944931983948,
0.6652507781982422,
0.13679474592208862,
0.2524726092815399,
-0.7858702540397644,
0.40376853942871094,
0.0023029320873320103,
-0.8962525725364685,
-0.3250570595264435,
-0.40091705322265625,
-0.6144967079162598,
0.48020899295806885,
-0.1498774141073227,
-0.3752201199531555,
0.00017485413991380483,
0.34758999943733215,
-0.32897964119911194,
0.3827545940876007,
-1.1046143770217896,
0.5399860143661499,
-0.5224741101264954,
-0.3306768536567688,
-0.11840523779392242,
-0.295740008354187,
0.3870502710342407,
-0.44550350308418274,
0.5268999338150024,
-0.10238442569971085,
-0.01295927632600069,
0.5961737036705017,
-0.5557039976119995,
0.7842062711715698,
-0.5358772873878479,
-0.2986826002597809,
0.5941292643547058,
0.049323469400405884,
0.7573266625404358,
-0.0653391033411026,
-0.4624086320400238,
-0.22431986033916473,
-0.35856521129608154,
-0.21126502752304077,
-0.9060336947441101,
0.703650712966919,
-0.5501708388328552,
-0.8638826012611389,
-0.019291847944259644,
-0.5136417150497437,
0.10824904590845108,
0.024899989366531372,
-0.1295657455921173,
0.05303944647312164,
0.13917624950408936,
0.21728812158107758,
1.027929425239563,
-0.28046199679374695,
0.5071340203285217,
0.6179847717285156,
-0.39558568596839905,
-0.07069287449121475,
0.30902042984962463,
0.1444290280342102,
0.42985692620277405,
0.18125465512275696,
0.32526248693466187,
-0.34559497237205505,
-1.037313461303711,
-0.6061952114105225,
0.14602713286876678,
-0.8938769102096558,
-0.1051860824227333,
-0.5138971209526062,
0.09554870426654816,
-0.06253953278064728,
-0.27644655108451843,
-0.33720821142196655,
-0.5707428455352783,
-0.29893195629119873,
-0.5803775787353516,
0.679387629032135,
0.6797114610671997,
0.15105348825454712,
0.5280912518501282,
-0.34587857127189636,
0.34979701042175293,
0.40279170870780945,
0.040916383266448975,
0.32407698035240173,
-0.8258045315742493,
-0.29627299308776855,
0.2959095239639282,
-0.3257666528224945,
-0.9828200936317444,
0.22081850469112396,
0.41326257586479187,
0.8233492970466614,
0.8003506064414978,
0.23776932060718536,
0.7364426851272583,
-0.3607475459575653,
0.7305826544761658,
0.013946733437478542,
-0.914665937423706,
0.877475380897522,
-0.0845903679728508,
0.20035138726234436,
0.4343421459197998,
0.3248743712902069,
-0.15196460485458374,
-0.5245999097824097,
-0.38748741149902344,
-1.2339361906051636,
0.540742039680481,
0.03160223737359047,
0.0034727014135569334,
-0.03742271661758423,
0.7370553612709045,
0.20577524602413177,
0.003253792179748416,
-0.7001953125,
-0.5510663390159607,
0.26439040899276733,
-0.5278882384300232,
0.20833422243595123,
-0.2718886733055115,
-0.20542384684085846,
-0.19780081510543823,
1.153720736503601,
0.01821148954331875,
-0.29663655161857605,
0.043852970004081726,
-0.21365021169185638,
-0.3395903706550598,
0.23170220851898193,
0.3967854380607605,
0.7794246673583984,
-0.19727379083633423,
0.5606849193572998,
0.24785621464252472,
-0.48705145716667175,
0.12998437881469727,
0.22017540037631989,
-0.25690585374832153,
0.24827182292938232,
0.4123916029930115,
1.0829311609268188,
-0.1910889744758606,
-0.8327463269233704,
0.481875479221344,
-0.04166325181722641,
-0.3226565420627594,
-0.24502301216125488,
0.255793958902359,
0.35814476013183594,
0.42795437574386597,
0.863487184047699,
-0.41410452127456665,
-0.12529969215393066,
-0.4908874034881592,
-0.0933113694190979,
0.1137595996260643,
-0.14858394861221313,
-0.27181586623191833,
0.8360719084739685,
0.2539519965648651,
-0.1326923370361328,
0.385534405708313,
-0.06002146005630493,
-0.4927302896976471,
0.6874778866767883,
0.4365867078304291,
0.7358736991882324,
-0.42680686712265015,
0.11085201799869537,
0.17208610475063324,
0.23511193692684174,
-0.37908831238746643,
0.2407613843679428,
0.00527040334418416,
-0.5872625708580017,
-0.7366058826446533,
-0.7221143841743469,
-0.4511888921260834,
0.1894216239452362,
-0.5501435995101929,
0.4467812776565552,
-0.30966126918792725,
0.07960374653339386,
0.27460765838623047,
-0.13987265527248383,
-0.22106897830963135,
0.11164151132106781,
0.15317437052726746,
0.7920241951942444,
-1.1397619247436523,
0.7477681636810303,
0.8447060585021973,
-0.30437958240509033,
-0.8320704698562622,
-0.18638543784618378,
0.05588991567492485,
-0.6240649819374084,
0.752999484539032,
-0.11335188150405884,
0.0664011761546135,
-0.19181206822395325,
-0.5418052673339844,
-0.6072050333023071,
1.1995421648025513,
0.4133172631263733,
-0.8555499911308289,
0.13334979116916656,
-0.3384591042995453,
0.5890505909919739,
-0.31524327397346497,
0.1904544234275818,
0.5183055996894836,
0.6401705741882324,
0.4811621606349945,
-0.7612484693527222,
0.07344872504472733,
-0.023526344448328018,
-0.3471744954586029,
0.30299612879753113,
-0.2372821569442749,
0.8242265582084656,
-0.4970560073852539,
0.05404625087976456,
-0.3524460196495056,
0.5944468379020691,
0.4533582031726837,
0.4138180911540985,
0.6432474851608276,
0.6302673816680908,
1.0085563659667969,
-0.15558475255966187,
0.5552866458892822,
-0.0031126560643315315,
0.30706313252449036,
1.1712411642074585,
-0.4279201626777649,
0.6312982439994812,
0.8804149627685547,
-0.15503427386283875,
0.4768650531768799,
0.7727687358856201,
-0.02084684930741787,
0.7662106156349182,
0.43164393305778503,
-0.6004161834716797,
-0.19277068972587585,
0.08866584300994873,
0.0004885487724095583,
0.3468935787677765,
0.4487719237804413,
-0.7626467347145081,
-0.32437095046043396,
0.13239216804504395,
0.09777174890041351,
0.19483205676078796,
-0.3433433175086975,
0.7575511932373047,
0.06456007808446884,
-0.7876747846603394,
0.7401261925697327,
0.11869461834430695,
0.44890186190605164,
-0.41210728883743286,
-0.23148396611213684,
-0.1752406656742096,
0.3305763006210327,
-0.2831457853317261,
-0.4679237902164459,
0.22731710970401764,
0.2530139982700348,
-0.2614342272281647,
-0.5492591261863708,
0.46996980905532837,
-0.742190957069397,
-0.37368205189704895,
0.15029850602149963,
0.5219192504882812,
0.28037601709365845,
0.11488502472639084,
-0.6242222785949707,
0.08151516318321228,
0.3343037962913513,
-0.562821626663208,
-0.06471934914588928,
0.9328234791755676,
-0.18240639567375183,
0.6561408638954163,
0.49659350514411926,
0.38311606645584106,
0.05597969889640808,
0.14569872617721558,
0.8884708881378174,
-0.15485891699790955,
-0.3008890151977539,
-1.0866154432296753,
0.4920482635498047,
-0.023257091641426086,
0.02551419287919998,
0.6453481912612915,
0.4104136824607849,
0.5483692288398743,
0.263840913772583,
0.9654041528701782,
0.03894514963030815,
0.5972529053688049,
-0.6102746725082397,
0.5670762062072754,
-0.5659629106521606,
0.95952308177948,
0.04300021752715111,
-1.06541109085083,
-0.15175767242908478,
0.9726725220680237,
-0.38492169976234436,
0.024747278541326523,
0.7601884007453918,
0.5596063137054443,
-0.1285625547170639,
0.16822762787342072,
0.057634223252534866,
0.5130923390388489,
0.4363008439540863,
0.30958470702171326,
0.7111505270004272,
-0.18555104732513428,
0.45716047286987305,
-0.28048765659332275,
-0.3032163679599762,
-0.17336340248584747,
-1.1112685203552246,
-0.9981201887130737,
-0.35197126865386963,
-0.6742292642593384,
-0.19703496992588043,
0.13993732631206512,
0.8470468521118164,
0.4907244145870209,
-0.6043395400047302,
0.10981146991252899,
-0.1880846917629242,
0.34298470616340637,
-0.2012234926223755,
-0.17018435895442963,
0.5560543537139893,
-0.2124217450618744,
-0.9464003443717957,
0.4255271255970001,
-0.026774050667881966,
0.21022389829158783,
-0.4765909016132355,
0.038696397095918655,
-0.3223204016685486,
0.1959618777036667,
0.38459718227386475,
-0.08794363588094711,
-0.7227926254272461,
0.017202334478497505,
-0.21769586205482483,
0.22810795903205872,
-0.3321485221385956,
0.6160278916358948,
-0.520088791847229,
0.6390100121498108,
0.4266555905342102,
0.6286801695823669,
0.7806300520896912,
0.04186622425913811,
0.587037980556488,
-0.7416550517082214,
0.2819099426269531,
0.20178267359733582,
0.4221894145011902,
0.3475117087364197,
-0.3288622796535492,
0.4464471936225891,
-0.01734401099383831,
-0.5355005860328674,
-1.0805864334106445,
0.07111237943172455,
-0.7382614612579346,
-0.713149905204773,
1.462172508239746,
-0.633018434047699,
-0.36609190702438354,
-0.3945172429084778,
-0.18540486693382263,
0.3246918022632599,
-0.34013235569000244,
0.9229674339294434,
0.9341530799865723,
0.06378037482500076,
-0.1951054483652115,
-0.7003105282783508,
0.42369532585144043,
0.3177432715892792,
-0.568693995475769,
0.41641131043434143,
0.6790276169776917,
0.26258406043052673,
-0.11851371079683304,
0.17626209557056427,
-0.013581220991909504,
-0.008889509364962578,
-0.219053253531456,
0.1404137760400772,
-0.4234227240085602,
-0.236081063747406,
-0.40777820348739624,
0.05966287851333618,
0.32552918791770935,
-0.0975349023938179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13094v1 | Digital Comprehensibility Assessment of Simplified Texts among Persons with Intellectual Disabilities | 2024-02-20T15:37:08 | 2024-02-20T15:37:08 | Andreas Säuberli, Franz Holzknecht, Patrick Haller, Silvana Deilen, Laura Schiffl, Silvia Hansen-Schirra, Sarah Ebling | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Text simplification refers to the process of increasing the comprehensibility
of texts. Automatic text simplification models are most commonly evaluated by
experts or crowdworkers instead of the primary target groups of simplified
texts, such as persons with intellectual disabilities. We conducted an
evaluation study of text comprehensibility including participants with and
without intellectual disabilities reading unsimplified, automatically and
manually simplified German texts on a tablet computer. We explored four
different approaches to measuring comprehensibility: multiple-choice
comprehension questions, perceived difficulty ratings, response time, and
reading speed. The results revealed significant variations in these
measurements, depending on the reader group and whether the text had undergone
automatic or manual simplification. For the target group of persons with
intellectual disabilities, comprehension questions emerged as the most reliable
measure, while analyzing reading speed provided valuable insights into
participants' reading behavior. | [
-0.7366161346435547,
-0.5933088660240173,
0.6042232513427734,
0.4089612662792206,
-0.5021187663078308,
-0.15958639979362488,
-0.24544161558151245,
-0.48296022415161133,
-0.024009287357330322,
0.04036666080355644,
-0.7191147208213806,
-0.15582510828971863,
-0.7870400547981262,
0.8223543763160706,
-0.44424763321876526,
0.8454723954200745,
-0.5465245246887207,
0.08810338377952576,
-0.29368165135383606,
-0.13179762661457062,
-0.5118832588195801,
-0.19902878999710083,
-0.4785709083080292,
-0.4670088589191437,
0.3942925035953522,
0.4599332809448242,
0.611443281173706,
0.625201940536499,
0.7540577054023743,
0.376770943403244,
-0.22872938215732574,
-0.10840342193841934,
-0.0039156898856163025,
0.15139059722423553,
-0.006150014698505402,
-0.25049319863319397,
-0.5289697647094727,
-0.07414300739765167,
0.5324400067329407,
0.9924659132957458,
0.07416652888059616,
0.32980218529701233,
0.4489581286907196,
1.0645967721939087,
-0.7039114832878113,
-0.012756151147186756,
0.20554761588573456,
0.10158007591962814,
-0.06165216863155365,
-0.427808552980423,
-0.36725127696990967,
-0.5606772303581238,
0.22637593746185303,
-0.7621769905090332,
0.4117431938648224,
0.08023443818092346,
0.31937775015830994,
0.42612406611442566,
-0.934115469455719,
-0.6321461796760559,
-0.9082251191139221,
0.6132270693778992,
-0.32405975461006165,
0.6039831042289734,
0.506076991558075,
0.10601850599050522,
0.12204895168542862,
-0.8271272778511047,
-0.9823794960975647,
-0.16482795774936676,
-0.3029804527759552,
0.01929435133934021,
-0.10545290261507034,
0.23190821707248688,
0.6382983922958374,
0.1843029111623764,
-0.6108263731002808,
-0.4361881911754608,
-0.5960776805877686,
-0.029379600659012794,
0.8643369674682617,
0.13660983741283417,
0.6087053418159485,
-0.2661074101924896,
-0.16069413721561432,
-0.1022736206650734,
-0.1022411584854126,
0.09709980338811874,
0.4758438169956207,
-0.24607853591442108,
0.07834795117378235,
0.7639725804328918,
-0.4292738437652588,
0.8224723935127258,
-0.043113160878419876,
-0.21267180144786835,
0.28995653986930847,
-0.6739618182182312,
-0.2002125233411789,
0.030218137428164482,
0.33006957173347473,
0.4372808635234833,
0.6510338187217712,
-0.1220267117023468,
-0.22179007530212402,
-0.22907499969005585,
0.1369004249572754,
-0.4925249516963959,
-0.2298606038093567,
0.2533324658870697,
-0.5906813740730286,
0.17189352214336395,
0.14280249178409576,
-0.5791507363319397,
-0.47267648577690125,
-0.5247491598129272,
0.4443080425262451,
-0.3811424672603607,
-0.02828134037554264,
0.31735920906066895,
-0.4924347698688507,
-0.11252035945653915,
0.6658065915107727,
-0.861138105392456,
0.47417938709259033,
0.27759823203086853,
0.7186290621757507,
-0.4097926616668701,
-0.3377029001712799,
-0.0925910696387291,
0.28475338220596313,
-0.0046770633198320866,
1.0953878164291382,
-0.026023974642157555,
-0.5229459404945374,
-0.46059951186180115,
-0.0026294745039194822,
-0.4763209819793701,
-0.12664198875427246,
0.9609642028808594,
-0.5156852602958679,
0.0903162956237793,
-0.24906466901302338,
-0.66777104139328,
-0.41472598910331726,
0.13295507431030273,
-0.9003229737281799,
0.5962299108505249,
-0.04536990448832512,
-1.0134109258651733,
0.7180001139640808,
-0.6632878184318542,
-0.6189444661140442,
0.01277417317032814,
0.210780069231987,
-0.1554592102766037,
0.17175297439098358,
0.10380097478628159,
0.16943039000034332,
-0.03861787170171738,
-0.014875154010951519,
-0.04953066632151604,
-0.7571951746940613,
0.2583802342414856,
-0.7535669803619385,
0.9840831756591797,
-0.10182426124811172,
-0.5431901216506958,
-0.10473818331956863,
-0.7584031224250793,
0.3367833197116852,
-0.18574917316436768,
-0.7784520983695984,
-0.6046053767204285,
0.12528109550476074,
0.21370768547058105,
0.14450298249721527,
0.07812175899744034,
-0.5135834217071533,
0.06267963349819183,
-0.29682397842407227,
0.06082470715045929,
0.5807992815971375,
0.11465039104223251,
0.23078812658786774,
-0.5619878768920898,
0.3125010132789612,
-0.27553853392601013,
0.20103590190410614,
-0.07145517319440842,
-0.41263699531555176,
-0.842629611492157,
-0.4075521230697632,
0.5790143013000488,
0.7623395323753357,
-0.5974739193916321,
0.3941003382205963,
-0.4282185137271881,
-0.3393394649028778,
-0.27001145482063293,
0.2989915907382965,
0.25390002131462097,
0.29609933495521545,
0.2617667615413666,
-0.2193061262369156,
0.029658963903784752,
-0.5505466461181641,
-0.5377828478813171,
-0.3151009678840637,
-0.2880445718765259,
0.27200403809547424,
0.5991843342781067,
-0.22552569210529327,
0.42612019181251526,
-0.50057452917099,
-0.14748434722423553,
-0.20387358963489532,
0.52876216173172,
-0.2910466194152832,
0.4900954067707062,
-0.10018181055784225,
-1.1276402473449707,
-0.7983333468437195,
-0.2540450096130371,
-0.647300660610199,
-0.3281997740268707,
-0.08597476035356522,
0.583012044429779,
0.5439032912254333,
0.7303876876831055,
-0.43548405170440674,
0.7297456860542297,
0.2995634377002716,
-0.6249070763587952,
0.4499656856060028,
-0.7280435562133789,
0.5898436307907104,
-0.4874846935272217,
0.14277607202529907,
0.05152444168925285,
-0.17223107814788818,
-0.6758303046226501,
0.035773735493421555,
0.25235414505004883,
0.23270153999328613,
-0.4033338725566864,
0.5436938405036926,
-0.6735401749610901,
-0.13420827686786652,
-0.00034073367714881897,
0.355550080537796,
0.22170253098011017,
0.10123160481452942,
-0.27042636275291443,
0.7750530242919922,
-0.01712111569941044,
-0.6856639385223389,
0.4371793270111084,
0.1296158879995346,
-0.36028966307640076,
0.8412070870399475,
-0.9025342464447021,
0.18173189461231232,
-0.514362633228302,
0.20290304720401764,
-1.520650029182434,
-0.3170192241668701,
0.12937046587467194,
-0.2747260332107544,
0.10623423010110855,
0.6286502480506897,
-0.6319242119789124,
-0.3383859395980835,
-0.3621799647808075,
0.5974189639091492,
-0.03557751327753067,
-0.15252110362052917,
0.7485068440437317,
0.05790000036358833,
-0.40509381890296936,
-0.21500129997730255,
-0.7854813933372498,
-0.07336362451314926,
-0.12530775368213654,
-0.9121454358100891,
0.29440510272979736,
-0.5424875617027283,
-0.6253036260604858,
-0.16547837853431702,
-0.07587283104658127,
-0.35601043701171875,
0.21411246061325073,
0.19870276749134064,
0.05976982042193413,
0.22451472282409668,
0.31095197796821594,
0.23652328550815582,
-0.1531013548374176,
-0.1821378469467163,
0.41915011405944824,
0.293878972530365,
0.10773668438196182,
-0.4919053018093109,
-0.7442795634269714,
0.640344500541687,
0.23445628583431244,
0.05494053289294243,
0.3400743007659912,
0.1983802169561386,
-0.25725817680358887,
0.0795946791768074,
-0.44092193245887756,
-0.23401206731796265,
-0.4736059606075287,
-0.1379082351922989,
-0.5538570284843445,
-0.5996526479721069,
0.3628098964691162,
-0.26615968346595764,
-0.1517159789800644,
0.47035422921180725,
0.2572588622570038,
-0.4544678032398224,
1.1527763605117798,
0.8351547122001648,
0.688166618347168,
0.18584327399730682,
0.37823590636253357,
0.09535536170005798,
-0.43389973044395447,
-0.332682728767395,
-0.8015603423118591,
-0.33308038115501404,
-0.5777140259742737,
-0.10475530475378036,
0.2829732894897461,
0.21048162877559662,
-0.08869697898626328,
0.16799701750278473,
-0.46723973751068115,
0.45168444514274597,
0.520991325378418,
0.30286943912506104,
1.0277016162872314,
-0.10028994828462601,
-0.14826460182666779,
-0.27526354789733887,
-0.19990764558315277,
-0.6926781535148621,
0.9825602173805237,
0.10306296497583389,
0.5350049138069153,
0.28311049938201904,
0.6336003541946411,
0.7069661617279053,
0.26445987820625305,
-1.0210915803909302,
0.5156010389328003,
-0.14475519955158234,
-0.6727597713470459,
-0.6832568645477295,
-0.39657655358314514,
-0.8640811443328857,
-0.11298686265945435,
-0.14140920341014862,
-0.6846919655799866,
0.3846803605556488,
-0.007259160280227661,
-0.2172575145959854,
-0.1172378733754158,
-1.0216343402862549,
0.7297400832176208,
-0.1109205111861229,
0.28531596064567566,
-0.24652455747127533,
-0.48230111598968506,
0.23910368978977203,
-0.6828010082244873,
0.10369118303060532,
0.07060232013463974,
-0.4663684666156769,
0.8007120490074158,
-0.09536144137382507,
0.5142905116081238,
0.11386275291442871,
0.29179444909095764,
0.15445362031459808,
-0.016997484490275383,
0.43592071533203125,
-0.35714682936668396,
-0.2762981355190277,
0.0013653002679347992,
0.38740459084510803,
-0.4012039601802826,
-0.6900542378425598,
0.4095545709133148,
-0.7388501167297363,
-0.7611956000328064,
-0.6202887892723083,
-0.46111586689949036,
-0.1332693099975586,
0.6157258152961731,
0.2498307079076767,
0.14104808866977692,
-0.3718215525150299,
0.0666196346282959,
0.7136621475219727,
-0.07517000287771225,
0.683239758014679,
0.5996590852737427,
0.3089427649974823,
-0.209678515791893,
0.4326411783695221,
0.6252537369728088,
0.2579317092895508,
-0.023907244205474854,
-0.08264616876840591,
-0.4868493974208832,
-0.5921021699905396,
-0.522632896900177,
0.17904408276081085,
-0.9458383917808533,
0.4019481837749481,
-0.6738812923431396,
-0.03374853357672691,
-0.35666725039482117,
-0.23364032804965973,
0.4696841537952423,
-0.694263219833374,
-0.3711088001728058,
-0.08729663491249084,
-0.044155657291412354,
0.7947500348091125,
0.016905970871448517,
0.47738730907440186,
-0.6081212759017944,
0.5362311005592346,
0.5562896132469177,
0.4085109531879425,
-0.263053297996521,
-0.39758217334747314,
0.13046565651893616,
-0.2847228944301605,
-0.3730255663394928,
-1.0082374811172485,
0.13438138365745544,
0.1565931737422943,
0.4495268762111664,
0.02865755371749401,
0.5178257822990417,
0.41978514194488525,
-0.30233779549598694,
0.46197569370269775,
0.21130956709384918,
-1.167888879776001,
0.271035760641098,
-0.119316466152668,
0.37749266624450684,
0.9051523208618164,
0.5819324851036072,
-0.5986304879188538,
-0.010852833278477192,
-0.4780658185482025,
-0.8490011096000671,
0.45689091086387634,
0.13713249564170837,
0.18539296090602875,
0.3194652795791626,
0.2718328833580017,
0.06981386989355087,
0.10175314545631409,
-0.6201211214065552,
-0.4381215274333954,
0.000838523090351373,
-0.2981146275997162,
-0.04080302640795708,
-0.3937050998210907,
-0.170001819729805,
-0.3125659227371216,
0.3378593623638153,
-0.07532753795385361,
0.0975382998585701,
0.42828595638275146,
-0.22705437242984772,
-0.24781231582164764,
0.3477475941181183,
0.6994637846946716,
0.9090280532836914,
-0.15234850347042084,
0.15552230179309845,
0.1726953238248825,
-0.7149372696876526,
0.5455151796340942,
0.3440278470516205,
-0.45287057757377625,
0.13389025628566742,
0.4184547960758209,
0.4886050522327423,
-0.29243016242980957,
-0.5992793440818787,
0.644475519657135,
-0.6002271771430969,
-0.2809624671936035,
-0.3342989683151245,
0.1306449919939041,
-0.047426920384168625,
0.10594049841165543,
0.4597111642360687,
0.12866908311843872,
0.5339340567588806,
-0.1903090476989746,
0.40391120314598083,
-0.04836397245526314,
-0.42151734232902527,
-0.03952192887663841,
0.29598870873451233,
0.3234887421131134,
-0.46962782740592957,
0.4870518445968628,
-0.08169620484113693,
0.09127400070428848,
0.6031234860420227,
0.3752306401729584,
0.8706145286560059,
-0.2354223132133484,
0.413276344537735,
0.09231444448232651,
0.6203107833862305,
-0.2642248272895813,
0.5023671984672546,
-0.21745546162128448,
-0.4401637017726898,
-0.2470189332962036,
-0.2064943164587021,
-0.45095518231391907,
-0.3880995512008667,
-0.5404641032218933,
0.3107968270778656,
-0.39713001251220703,
-0.5051634311676025,
0.32878538966178894,
0.23026619851589203,
-0.5377117991447449,
0.6783496737480164,
-0.3124209940433502,
1.2147380113601685,
-0.8364153504371643,
0.4878453314304352,
0.893393337726593,
-0.33284446597099304,
-0.6815255284309387,
0.7439336180686951,
0.12750642001628876,
-0.20246464014053345,
0.7133228182792664,
0.07614649832248688,
-0.10167118161916733,
0.1681709885597229,
-0.06022061035037041,
-0.6309061646461487,
1.0716451406478882,
0.39115068316459656,
-0.2770751714706421,
-0.053683098405599594,
0.38934075832366943,
0.6385202407836914,
0.08568475395441055,
0.45541760325431824,
0.6218950152397156,
0.7936437726020813,
-0.18324853479862213,
-1.0359041690826416,
0.19900135695934296,
-0.13094137609004974,
0.04424269497394562,
0.08722548931837082,
-0.4969829320907593,
0.5908209681510925,
-0.16485446691513062,
-0.38905298709869385,
-0.18192636966705322,
0.4444698989391327,
0.18069064617156982,
0.7019138932228088,
0.6505370736122131,
0.36012163758277893,
0.9352974891662598,
-0.09204543381929398,
1.0518077611923218,
-0.23632873594760895,
0.1501684933900833,
0.6032703518867493,
0.11707586795091629,
0.7542828917503357,
0.6590177416801453,
-0.0035485122352838516,
0.37167230248451233,
0.5415678024291992,
0.3624468743801117,
0.32362064719200134,
0.19955359399318695,
-0.6433756351470947,
-0.06693439930677414,
-0.07595059275627136,
-0.010599724017083645,
0.23881055414676666,
0.05219190940260887,
-0.3452922999858856,
-0.2054651826620102,
0.24902592599391937,
-0.07602507621049881,
0.29525697231292725,
-0.3773534297943115,
0.8398073315620422,
0.06651275604963303,
-0.8343274593353271,
0.5460354685783386,
0.3116456866264343,
0.4306347370147705,
-0.24630631506443024,
0.2400895357131958,
-0.2517901360988617,
0.21522913873195648,
-0.3573838174343109,
-1.1495085954666138,
0.6232852935791016,
0.13112154603004456,
-0.4332100450992584,
-0.26248568296432495,
0.7792568206787109,
0.04872797429561615,
-0.7225248217582703,
0.33511683344841003,
0.5356062650680542,
0.30538907647132874,
-0.00408140430226922,
-0.7520152926445007,
0.15700247883796692,
0.0181119404733181,
-0.6773452162742615,
0.04246172308921814,
0.6326107382774353,
-0.1800304800271988,
0.9199776649475098,
0.3887545168399811,
0.03747473657131195,
0.0312035009264946,
-0.14148177206516266,
0.6919793486595154,
-0.6392143368721008,
-0.2589983344078064,
-0.8103081583976746,
0.5324041247367859,
-0.032272305339574814,
-0.43204256892204285,
0.9535829424858093,
0.2507840096950531,
0.8125997185707092,
0.09522920846939087,
0.8233588337898254,
-0.10994750261306763,
0.38818255066871643,
-0.1340138465166092,
0.6909812092781067,
-0.6650087237358093,
0.027800627052783966,
-0.45062771439552307,
-0.8967487215995789,
-0.5018510222434998,
0.4614752233028412,
-0.453677773475647,
0.2596222162246704,
0.8454268574714661,
0.41379401087760925,
-0.11110508441925049,
0.17977310717105865,
0.23513399064540863,
-0.3316302001476288,
-0.11631262302398682,
0.20786774158477783,
0.2410726100206375,
-0.46576181054115295,
0.7637045383453369,
-0.2617094814777374,
-0.516463577747345,
-0.1315598040819168,
-0.889214277267456,
-0.7203111052513123,
-0.5297711491584778,
-0.43834957480430603,
-0.26798778772354126,
0.11639130860567093,
0.7218692898750305,
0.15667735040187836,
-0.5945196747779846,
-0.15325592458248138,
-0.0596538670361042,
0.30709850788116455,
-0.22770698368549347,
-0.22347168624401093,
0.40636202692985535,
0.09121260792016983,
-0.8153891563415527,
-0.1547650694847107,
0.17819474637508392,
0.4049551486968994,
-0.2777179777622223,
0.07383869588375092,
-0.007483368273824453,
0.44915732741355896,
0.33043989539146423,
0.20161008834838867,
-0.15999187529087067,
-0.05630658194422722,
0.06793900579214096,
-0.6010259389877319,
-0.09180542081594467,
0.6034842133522034,
-0.25381383299827576,
0.7748989462852478,
1.1248375177383423,
0.21148867905139923,
0.383940726518631,
0.2883686125278473,
0.4370404779911041,
-0.3001325726509094,
0.0752907320857048,
0.0988815650343895,
0.13604797422885895,
0.43128296732902527,
-0.3995603322982788,
0.2731262743473053,
0.4407477080821991,
-0.584936797618866,
-0.6311603784561157,
0.03016451559960842,
-0.8220157623291016,
-0.3401530683040619,
0.9755893349647522,
-0.3227367699146271,
-0.272192120552063,
-0.6352523565292358,
-0.32023492455482483,
0.24842236936092377,
-0.11223715543746948,
0.8615930676460266,
0.8904970288276672,
-0.25292888283729553,
-0.29674676060676575,
-0.6662558913230896,
0.6412709355354309,
0.1350218802690506,
-0.8975696563720703,
-0.05084416642785072,
0.6192945837974548,
0.2645183503627777,
0.1749461144208908,
0.8881573677062988,
0.15865172445774078,
0.4366435110569,
0.021358566358685493,
-0.09015390276908875,
0.048220787197351456,
-0.23547481000423431,
-0.42352959513664246,
0.22818730771541595,
0.028115054592490196,
0.2931823432445526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13093v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13093v2 | Event-level Knowledge Editing | 2024-02-20T15:36:41 | 2024-04-21T06:13:45 | Hao Peng, Xiaozhi Wang, Chunyang Li, Kaisheng Zeng, Jiangshan Duo, Yixin Cao, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge editing aims at updating knowledge of large language models (LLMs)
to prevent them from becoming outdated. Existing work edits LLMs at the level
of factual knowledge triplets. However, natural knowledge updates in the real
world come from the occurrences of new events rather than direct changes in
factual triplets. In this paper, we propose a new task setting: event-level
knowledge editing, which directly edits new events into LLMs and improves over
conventional triplet-level editing on (1) Efficiency. A single event edit leads
to updates in multiple entailed knowledge triplets. (2) Completeness. Beyond
updating factual knowledge, event-level editing also requires considering the
event influences and updating LLMs' knowledge about future trends. We construct
a high-quality event-level editing benchmark ELKEN, consisting of 1,515 event
edits, 6,449 questions about factual knowledge, and 10,150 questions about
future tendencies. We systematically evaluate the performance of various
knowledge editing methods and LLMs on this benchmark. We find that ELKEN poses
significant challenges to existing knowledge editing approaches. Our codes and
dataset are publicly released to facilitate further research. | [
-0.07205580919981003,
-0.6576685905456543,
0.6046409606933594,
0.02229013666510582,
-0.011350860819220543,
0.17533224821090698,
-0.20244134962558746,
-0.7903446555137634,
-0.08325633406639099,
0.5374410152435303,
-0.3226402997970581,
-0.9403818249702454,
-0.5746058225631714,
0.26458799839019775,
-0.3856177031993866,
0.8956830501556396,
-0.3503243029117584,
-0.33542683720588684,
-0.2739450931549072,
-0.1759074628353119,
-0.3317120373249054,
-0.5572007298469543,
-0.9705166816711426,
-0.01828025095164776,
0.5921961665153503,
0.3881247341632843,
0.5434446930885315,
0.8145543932914734,
0.48251521587371826,
0.23399485647678375,
-0.681327223777771,
0.17474982142448425,
-0.48701003193855286,
0.2281537503004074,
-0.2244567573070526,
-0.5999029278755188,
-0.8406663537025452,
-0.1864187866449356,
0.7817034721374512,
0.5247055888175964,
0.0620095394551754,
0.2976400554180145,
0.0050611961632966995,
0.5847954154014587,
-0.7054802179336548,
0.09390410035848618,
-0.8190703392028809,
-0.012521778233349323,
-0.3037383556365967,
-0.07884705811738968,
-0.19846123456954956,
-0.2252747118473053,
0.011668040417134762,
-0.8406046628952026,
0.27799874544143677,
0.04233841970562935,
0.5276958346366882,
0.2592306435108185,
-0.19261518120765686,
0.03397960588335991,
-0.5737959742546082,
0.5348294377326965,
-0.7541802525520325,
0.46073269844055176,
0.22798432409763336,
-0.19413985311985016,
-0.21685464680194855,
-0.5038348436355591,
-0.6341269016265869,
0.23041009902954102,
0.1821848750114441,
-0.17668142914772034,
-0.29770979285240173,
0.16720879077911377,
0.6243443489074707,
0.02325044944882393,
-0.27417540550231934,
0.0789741724729538,
-0.1654738485813141,
0.2539686858654022,
0.7137237787246704,
0.3222983479499817,
0.2793264091014862,
-0.29634684324264526,
0.16679425537586212,
0.10377313196659088,
-0.9533436298370361,
-0.0744018703699112,
0.27315226197242737,
-0.16673192381858826,
0.34839579463005066,
0.731716513633728,
-0.5089653730392456,
0.7655434608459473,
0.06392356753349304,
-0.3807753622531891,
0.025035707280039787,
-0.5405613780021667,
-0.12461081147193909,
0.24176794290542603,
0.40693289041519165,
0.6042273044586182,
-0.07313556224107742,
-0.17791783809661865,
-0.23225142061710358,
-0.46058425307273865,
-0.12807613611221313,
-0.5718066096305847,
0.15442155301570892,
0.3189476430416107,
-0.34240561723709106,
-0.4512621760368347,
-0.2817806303501129,
-0.5478447675704956,
-0.7235782146453857,
-0.2757762372493744,
0.4287485182285309,
-0.44735246896743774,
0.09717011451721191,
0.26976272463798523,
-0.21053573489189148,
-0.03518570587038994,
0.7845578789710999,
-0.5297252535820007,
0.018512437120079994,
0.7936883568763733,
0.5997123122215271,
-0.026450376957654953,
-0.5532125234603882,
-0.5707894563674927,
0.5504943132400513,
-0.43785086274147034,
0.7568851113319397,
-0.752382218837738,
-0.15867699682712555,
-0.020032713189721107,
-0.22784104943275452,
0.1767009049654007,
-0.45950087904930115,
0.3104049861431122,
-0.9467123746871948,
-0.0165643859654665,
-0.5177561044692993,
-0.8487305045127869,
0.07383193075656891,
0.2797725200653076,
-0.47534385323524475,
1.1393009424209595,
-0.2855990529060364,
-0.7714590430259705,
0.7491474151611328,
-0.6294525861740112,
-0.5873841643333435,
0.006478793453425169,
0.2620756924152374,
-0.06444365531206131,
-0.013112113811075687,
0.4928218126296997,
0.2949460744857788,
0.1604670286178589,
0.23999589681625366,
-0.0824131965637207,
-0.11433102935552597,
0.08756016194820404,
0.051326580345630646,
0.3602089583873749,
-0.18551935255527496,
-0.26467251777648926,
0.19041341543197632,
-1.210915446281433,
-0.3941136300563812,
-0.22730325162410736,
-0.5713858604431152,
-0.4586046636104584,
0.24347849190235138,
-0.42147570848464966,
0.2500016987323761,
0.5408318638801575,
-0.7735192775726318,
0.5756585597991943,
-0.1664389818906784,
-0.010301940143108368,
0.8361015319824219,
0.47863855957984924,
0.37195974588394165,
-0.41203320026397705,
0.42748016119003296,
-0.09560070186853409,
0.328490674495697,
-0.004412158392369747,
-0.7290253043174744,
-0.7450851798057556,
0.08494646847248077,
0.38411712646484375,
0.6552556157112122,
-0.8508303165435791,
0.35517922043800354,
-0.22065596282482147,
-0.2808234989643097,
-0.6668802499771118,
0.33544132113456726,
0.13311658799648285,
0.3487424850463867,
0.33815762400627136,
0.13001583516597748,
-0.7058663368225098,
-0.4737076163291931,
-0.8156458735466003,
-0.19388219714164734,
0.10784833878278732,
-0.21407775580883026,
0.37229567766189575,
0.027551669627428055,
0.7951153516769409,
-0.3496161997318268,
-0.1700342446565628,
-0.11924257129430771,
0.429040789604187,
0.007219838444143534,
0.21354572474956512,
0.2276744246482849,
-0.29824602603912354,
-0.39005252718925476,
0.28320401906967163,
-0.6485854387283325,
-0.15688292682170868,
-0.08365033566951752,
-0.08362708985805511,
0.523361086845398,
0.5602834224700928,
-0.37075841426849365,
0.5189165472984314,
0.4028673470020294,
-0.41657376289367676,
0.43103691935539246,
-0.21867355704307556,
0.5869447588920593,
-0.9511909484863281,
-0.26994821429252625,
-0.18664702773094177,
-0.1754685789346695,
-0.7271714210510254,
-0.06291812658309937,
0.2010752558708191,
-0.019987521693110466,
-0.478647381067276,
0.7406545877456665,
-0.3284147083759308,
-0.015529518947005272,
-0.1337171345949173,
0.2765285074710846,
-0.08217336237430573,
0.37656429409980774,
-0.1419861763715744,
0.5097924470901489,
0.4549090266227722,
-0.39187729358673096,
0.48108887672424316,
0.48286837339401245,
-0.8541998863220215,
0.48743516206741333,
-0.3546312153339386,
0.1992940753698349,
-0.3061622381210327,
0.14480754733085632,
-0.4473085403442383,
-0.023366253823041916,
-0.12855708599090576,
-0.21411582827568054,
0.10750464349985123,
-0.20663206279277802,
-0.8083471655845642,
-0.014714756049215794,
-0.38509881496429443,
0.23155948519706726,
0.3526254892349243,
-0.6414840221405029,
0.501237690448761,
0.2959889769554138,
-0.46955958008766174,
-0.6584311127662659,
-0.5227663516998291,
0.4937455952167511,
0.13011108338832855,
-0.8623935580253601,
0.17521683871746063,
0.12957878410816193,
-0.5314839482307434,
0.37263381481170654,
-0.18788103759288788,
0.1885947585105896,
-0.3005579710006714,
-0.2226603627204895,
0.18712693452835083,
-0.08214487135410309,
0.12942539155483246,
0.1747642606496811,
0.021396102383732796,
-0.15897992253303528,
-0.36189860105514526,
-0.12973834574222565,
0.21067076921463013,
-0.3160998821258545,
-0.807426929473877,
0.20444418489933014,
0.5245460867881775,
-0.34917765855789185,
0.808217465877533,
0.40142789483070374,
-0.633114218711853,
0.15718334913253784,
-1.0486242771148682,
0.1427856981754303,
-0.37794220447540283,
0.6130490303039551,
-0.5069482922554016,
-1.1657171249389648,
0.6289922595024109,
0.20438185334205627,
0.4676359295845032,
0.5514574646949768,
0.29409298300743103,
-0.05843046307563782,
1.1749584674835205,
0.31392422318458557,
0.08422277867794037,
0.5486096739768982,
-0.03595319762825966,
0.16770365834236145,
-1.0888432264328003,
-0.19551438093185425,
-0.5004218816757202,
-0.4012490212917328,
-0.34704482555389404,
-0.6612377166748047,
0.47230008244514465,
0.2007995992898941,
-0.046438299119472504,
0.29353126883506775,
-0.11885278671979904,
0.6633321046829224,
0.41555893421173096,
0.027453746646642685,
0.8251855373382568,
-0.35543206334114075,
0.3447956144809723,
0.04613041132688522,
-0.8931068778038025,
-0.4934524893760681,
1.1120750904083252,
0.11334864795207977,
0.7165780067443848,
0.13883690536022186,
0.7319164276123047,
0.2663891315460205,
0.24795503914356232,
-0.13451315462589264,
0.5064665675163269,
-0.0016264233272522688,
-0.7710728049278259,
-0.8117754459381104,
-0.4048994183540344,
-0.560746967792511,
0.14266078174114227,
-0.3797967731952667,
-0.8642339110374451,
0.6204606294631958,
0.2704061269760132,
-0.2558640241622925,
0.8526897430419922,
-0.45948484539985657,
0.8024701476097107,
0.16776412725448608,
-0.2504015564918518,
-0.4469154179096222,
-0.3431951701641083,
0.1640399694442749,
-0.12263348698616028,
0.6659796237945557,
-0.3229241669178009,
-0.20211128890514374,
1.0261166095733643,
-0.2500685751438141,
0.7015442252159119,
-0.13379350304603577,
-0.1664755642414093,
0.171912282705307,
0.2416853904724121,
1.1990083456039429,
0.3429549038410187,
-0.42441532015800476,
-0.13419142365455627,
0.2705147862434387,
-0.38169825077056885,
-0.7132936716079712,
0.6247835755348206,
-0.7039147615432739,
-0.6127404570579529,
-0.13205745816230774,
-0.49120137095451355,
-0.352458655834198,
-0.008367780596017838,
0.06773162633180618,
0.8533754944801331,
-0.33057528734207153,
0.03220311924815178,
0.7595543265342712,
-0.3846558630466461,
0.197469100356102,
0.4901137948036194,
-0.2156030684709549,
-0.3360899090766907,
0.7438533306121826,
0.24480441212654114,
0.3432498276233673,
0.6243100762367249,
-0.04285644739866257,
0.005216763820499182,
-0.7871989607810974,
-0.5326225757598877,
0.04669215902686119,
-0.9447310566902161,
-0.1486373096704483,
-1.0602760314941406,
0.01758561283349991,
-0.5915950536727905,
-0.4586339294910431,
-0.28409379720687866,
-0.7192455530166626,
-0.09673333913087845,
-0.15230394899845123,
0.6191721558570862,
1.1220656633377075,
-0.42722296714782715,
0.0939086452126503,
-0.7579110264778137,
0.4762004613876343,
0.507462203502655,
0.4681558609008789,
-0.0919669046998024,
-0.4173872768878937,
-0.3321663439273834,
-0.20086491107940674,
-0.04113546013832092,
-0.7406084537506104,
-0.11135081946849823,
0.13997289538383484,
0.3706723153591156,
0.02312428317964077,
-0.04236132279038429,
0.635988712310791,
-0.4897307753562927,
0.8916646242141724,
0.039381109178066254,
-1.162918210029602,
0.7475953102111816,
-0.40828320384025574,
0.4888085424900055,
0.5411625504493713,
0.0329008512198925,
-1.0627647638320923,
-0.8886593580245972,
-0.7336413264274597,
-0.5759316086769104,
0.9679017663002014,
0.062435608357191086,
-0.18248870968818665,
0.02470504119992256,
0.5642296075820923,
0.08728695660829544,
0.2217690348625183,
-0.34056034684181213,
-0.11809750646352768,
0.2047017216682434,
0.07382871210575104,
0.06504534929990768,
-0.6381617188453674,
-0.03397778794169426,
-0.6067965030670166,
1.0673606395721436,
0.23728685081005096,
-0.24303361773490906,
0.18912817537784576,
-0.17118582129478455,
-0.34658148884773254,
0.5287858247756958,
0.5673307180404663,
1.1281044483184814,
-0.3566990792751312,
-0.0005580196739174426,
0.9862627387046814,
-0.14659838378429413,
-0.06918542832136154,
-0.07266131043434143,
-0.23364360630512238,
-0.04568564146757126,
0.7002473473548889,
1.0508426427841187,
0.4859197735786438,
-0.40853774547576904,
0.3358704149723053,
-0.10743299871683121,
-0.4466341733932495,
0.2115660458803177,
0.14439226686954498,
0.060527972877025604,
0.2235628217458725,
0.21147212386131287,
0.01855306886136532,
-0.11694202572107315,
-0.5376808047294617,
0.005178612191230059,
-0.09158150106668472,
-0.19599054753780365,
-0.15213268995285034,
0.6651567816734314,
0.2895420491695404,
-0.25592687726020813,
0.2911626100540161,
-0.3586764931678772,
-0.4045169949531555,
0.21966572105884552,
0.16654448211193085,
0.5367394685745239,
-0.17786791920661926,
-0.032460086047649384,
0.552771806716919,
0.525922954082489,
0.021771462634205818,
0.31168487668037415,
0.27421602606773376,
-0.795479953289032,
-0.9494509100914001,
-0.6735345721244812,
-0.5826321244239807,
0.2024216502904892,
-0.36323511600494385,
0.32934361696243286,
-0.23071274161338806,
0.1543264240026474,
0.05030294135212898,
-0.06918260455131531,
-0.7550839185714722,
0.06177269294857979,
-0.056865938007831573,
1.0266581773757935,
-0.39250093698501587,
0.642052173614502,
0.8875207304954529,
0.01171435508877039,
-0.30296334624290466,
-0.162567138671875,
0.06911802291870117,
-0.5356987118721008,
0.24848727881908417,
-0.5201130509376526,
0.20920740067958832,
0.13472424447536469,
-0.41267484426498413,
-1.0623383522033691,
0.9014331698417664,
0.16624444723129272,
-0.6580582857131958,
-0.31137552857398987,
0.11576677858829498,
0.35265931487083435,
-0.023305874317884445,
-0.21646901965141296,
0.8500329256057739,
0.8628088235855103,
0.16028912365436554,
-0.8201452493667603,
-0.12373531609773636,
-0.04343589022755623,
0.052246447652578354,
0.38962215185165405,
-0.1781064122915268,
0.4254786968231201,
-0.09174676239490509,
-0.006821198854595423,
-0.09634397178888321,
0.7743993997573853,
-0.09069393575191498,
-0.06385500729084015,
0.38325202465057373,
0.8149504661560059,
0.817140519618988,
-0.1457010805606842,
0.8382323980331421,
-0.4412841200828552,
0.12453679740428925,
1.1453396081924438,
-0.3453841805458069,
0.6568214297294617,
0.18249252438545227,
-0.16623453795909882,
0.36686262488365173,
0.5094337463378906,
0.21804292500019073,
0.21788933873176575,
0.06323693692684174,
-0.6985333561897278,
-0.3054749369621277,
0.11262629181146622,
-0.44748833775520325,
0.2640978693962097,
0.15085719525814056,
0.2848254442214966,
-0.22982341051101685,
0.2643463909626007,
0.2245803326368332,
-0.2536284625530243,
-0.35488447546958923,
1.0559715032577515,
-0.25334498286247253,
-0.5757715702056885,
0.13659018278121948,
0.2731446921825409,
0.3870774507522583,
-0.3561680018901825,
-0.07759099453687668,
-0.04540275037288666,
-0.023426193743944168,
-0.21958297491073608,
-1.0369765758514404,
0.31948378682136536,
0.41298219561576843,
-0.19415394961833954,
-0.2038550227880478,
0.7214962244033813,
-0.46024617552757263,
-0.5290163159370422,
0.12758874893188477,
0.35932958126068115,
-0.056701116263866425,
-0.27969855070114136,
-0.36801403760910034,
0.4464873671531677,
-0.1493634730577469,
-0.41682446002960205,
0.2540871202945709,
0.9086229205131531,
0.1370721161365509,
0.3734700679779053,
0.5485804677009583,
0.3296509385108948,
0.2678261995315552,
0.15227238833904266,
0.5180418491363525,
-0.8008464574813843,
-0.4301716685295105,
-0.5422825813293457,
0.5037180185317993,
-0.24752674996852875,
-0.42601025104522705,
0.3928443193435669,
0.596173107624054,
1.0550520420074463,
0.2050199806690216,
1.0676192045211792,
-0.1230388954281807,
0.46866682171821594,
-0.574959933757782,
0.5262123942375183,
-0.5299414396286011,
0.04896952584385872,
-0.31553900241851807,
-0.8162864446640015,
-0.4118092954158783,
0.10859265178442001,
-0.542506992816925,
-0.40096378326416016,
0.8042654991149902,
0.730883002281189,
0.2669439911842346,
0.4472135305404663,
0.47452637553215027,
0.42033031582832336,
0.32260817289352417,
0.3616030514240265,
1.0424838066101074,
-0.33778655529022217,
0.3431433141231537,
-0.4921516180038452,
-0.35794004797935486,
-0.1418837159872055,
-0.8813479542732239,
-0.9037501811981201,
-0.6965513825416565,
-0.547878086566925,
-0.033805567771196365,
0.6594951152801514,
1.0056582689285278,
0.4500785768032074,
-0.7574409246444702,
-0.15371744334697723,
0.14801259338855743,
0.4314618408679962,
-0.2475447952747345,
-0.14153899252414703,
0.3978520929813385,
-0.5206014513969421,
-0.6101763844490051,
0.4843562841415405,
0.40260595083236694,
-0.29637783765792847,
0.34357649087905884,
0.2496369630098343,
-0.39133667945861816,
0.007409269921481609,
0.8622124791145325,
0.17429925501346588,
-0.532896876335144,
-0.6674414277076721,
-0.258108526468277,
0.0003633792221080512,
0.04518710449337959,
0.6844937205314636,
-0.39791256189346313,
0.4054114818572998,
0.5690063238143921,
0.6979028582572937,
0.6351326704025269,
-0.33696964383125305,
0.4765331745147705,
-0.6713002324104309,
-0.15501880645751953,
-0.04051412269473076,
0.3710961937904358,
0.25001558661460876,
-0.4044544994831085,
0.3509584069252014,
0.28758591413497925,
-0.6703505516052246,
-0.6023830771446228,
-0.07525172084569931,
-0.7044996023178101,
-0.05961357429623604,
1.34516179561615,
0.23922543227672577,
-0.3206450641155243,
-0.2812850773334503,
-0.2543075680732727,
0.4198125898838043,
-0.09618328511714935,
0.6400396227836609,
1.0395665168762207,
-0.35179704427719116,
-0.06192607432603836,
-0.6533982157707214,
0.7387341260910034,
0.17900843918323517,
-0.8851646780967712,
0.3824557662010193,
0.4283868670463562,
0.12448901683092117,
-0.25155192613601685,
0.5749344825744629,
-0.16123418509960175,
0.453852117061615,
-0.19583076238632202,
0.6059683561325073,
-0.0893094390630722,
-0.45983850955963135,
-0.18526382744312286,
0.08519548922777176,
0.2774033844470978,
0.15086206793785095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13089v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13089v1 | Towards an empirical understanding of MoE design choices | 2024-02-20T15:31:44 | 2024-02-20T15:31:44 | Dongyang Fan, Bettina Messmer, Martin Jaggi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this study, we systematically evaluate the impact of common design choices
in Mixture of Experts (MoEs) on validation performance, uncovering distinct
influences at token and sequence levels. We also present empirical evidence
showing comparable performance between a learned router and a frozen, randomly
initialized router, suggesting that learned routing may not be essential. Our
study further reveals that Sequence-level routing can result in topic-specific
weak expert specialization, in contrast to syntax specialization observed with
Token-level routing. | [
-0.6653394103050232,
-0.683578610420227,
0.43853330612182617,
0.05306616798043251,
-0.2688853144645691,
-0.03974774852395058,
0.12177572399377823,
-0.47122588753700256,
0.05672404170036316,
0.1830538660287857,
-0.25630807876586914,
-0.16642653942108154,
-0.29281947016716003,
0.17537438869476318,
-0.18984781205654144,
0.7641664147377014,
0.013939814642071724,
0.20897437632083893,
-0.313730925321579,
0.008400342427194118,
-0.9165953993797302,
-0.30230987071990967,
-0.6350502371788025,
-0.44633948802948,
0.5828686356544495,
0.4695236384868622,
0.48971620202064514,
0.4096337854862213,
0.3713107705116272,
0.27405399084091187,
-0.3387918472290039,
0.1681489795446396,
-0.26060158014297485,
0.14593960344791412,
-0.51404869556427,
-0.6853727698326111,
-0.5040047764778137,
-0.3002112805843353,
0.4874221086502075,
0.8004612326622009,
-0.3404236435890198,
0.005301918368786573,
0.18683090806007385,
0.701833188533783,
-0.7109427452087402,
-0.08707480132579803,
-0.7452943325042725,
0.2748633325099945,
-0.3333219587802887,
-0.12010585516691208,
-0.6735286116600037,
0.10917095094919205,
0.4224925637245178,
-0.5721396803855896,
0.3513539731502533,
0.6215358972549438,
0.6984272003173828,
0.24033968150615692,
-0.6650322079658508,
-0.26353979110717773,
-0.7862396836280823,
0.8926708698272705,
-0.4983995854854584,
0.5675504207611084,
0.14689168334007263,
0.20805345475673676,
-0.33132773637771606,
-0.5486409664154053,
-0.1827441155910492,
0.3537116050720215,
-0.08162140846252441,
0.2660004198551178,
0.043523043394088745,
0.3239167332649231,
0.31539061665534973,
0.635857105255127,
-0.4434683620929718,
0.3984742760658264,
-0.8220757842063904,
-0.06544914096593857,
0.8688961863517761,
0.36214813590049744,
0.23423725366592407,
-0.19986702501773834,
-0.36849814653396606,
0.11146900057792664,
-0.5892541408538818,
0.3821128010749817,
0.42343416810035706,
-0.0683770626783371,
-0.03962366282939911,
0.3836739659309387,
-0.5825270414352417,
0.9446631073951721,
0.20960499346256256,
-0.12433791905641556,
0.3949396312236786,
0.06997692584991455,
-0.22876837849617004,
0.03141022101044655,
0.63631671667099,
0.3288957476615906,
0.2083158940076828,
-0.4264865815639496,
-0.43186500668525696,
-0.4584996998310089,
0.6164160370826721,
-0.4192262589931488,
-0.4110157787799835,
0.21892881393432617,
-0.6658312082290649,
-0.16827167570590973,
0.3909139335155487,
-0.9165019989013672,
-0.1897737681865692,
-0.5080665946006775,
0.513694703578949,
-0.30738550424575806,
-0.46161267161369324,
0.2854369580745697,
-0.8140483498573303,
0.21683569252490997,
0.5229416489601135,
-0.9038485884666443,
0.18852446973323822,
1.0262258052825928,
0.6098378300666809,
-0.2364097237586975,
-0.42044132947921753,
-0.008959918282926083,
-0.03658626973628998,
-0.4643785059452057,
0.742913007736206,
-0.6160155534744263,
-0.8245384693145752,
-0.2192547470331192,
-0.631318986415863,
-0.3184921443462372,
-0.739189624786377,
0.5000077486038208,
-0.9749857783317566,
-0.021517490968108177,
-0.4937695562839508,
-0.5904585719108582,
-0.37747901678085327,
-0.10388434678316116,
-0.6368893980979919,
0.7255992293357849,
-0.1056397408246994,
-0.839860200881958,
0.982839047908783,
-0.5466626286506653,
-0.7260857224464417,
-0.17181725800037384,
-0.4319038689136505,
-0.09391740709543228,
0.6199418306350708,
0.025692760944366455,
0.33368176221847534,
-0.001807555090636015,
0.28477972745895386,
-0.36089256405830383,
-0.47553858160972595,
0.3676786720752716,
-0.5339903235435486,
0.7080737948417664,
0.5286665558815002,
-0.3942565619945526,
-0.03921341523528099,
-1.2928547859191895,
-0.04146186262369156,
-0.22766540944576263,
-0.5262974500656128,
-0.4603521227836609,
0.30125442147254944,
-0.45140698552131653,
0.18407398462295532,
-0.19146975874900818,
-0.4525761306285858,
-0.03716759383678436,
-0.13635356724262238,
0.35372596979141235,
1.1824100017547607,
0.4206893742084503,
0.5972532033920288,
-0.5979358553886414,
0.3392631709575653,
0.28558847308158875,
0.20862546563148499,
-0.11627320945262909,
-1.093656301498413,
-1.0801563262939453,
-0.3041112422943115,
0.5600731372833252,
0.26722580194473267,
-0.5095792412757874,
0.3045235872268677,
-0.15894149243831635,
-0.43640294671058655,
-0.5079853534698486,
0.14606882631778717,
0.461334764957428,
0.5680361986160278,
0.32570379972457886,
-0.5546092391014099,
-0.31955865025520325,
-1.1365333795547485,
-0.4596168100833893,
-0.15674139559268951,
-0.1001102551817894,
0.5092884302139282,
0.3495106101036072,
-0.06761635094881058,
1.4589612483978271,
-0.48835739493370056,
0.26006680727005005,
-0.08624458312988281,
0.399885892868042,
0.09350696206092834,
0.7286650538444519,
0.7577484846115112,
-0.623894989490509,
-0.42099729180336,
-0.02179616130888462,
-0.685429573059082,
-0.03152298927307129,
0.02413673885166645,
-0.3113502860069275,
-0.35119450092315674,
0.23299163579940796,
-0.5820644497871399,
0.6318440437316895,
0.20557361841201782,
-0.16359999775886536,
0.3620222508907318,
0.1650654375553131,
0.13727736473083496,
-0.7565311193466187,
-0.3130047619342804,
-0.052986543625593185,
0.377761572599411,
-0.507342517375946,
0.1537790447473526,
-0.14857980608940125,
0.03780103474855423,
-0.411678284406662,
0.5869555473327637,
-0.2832578718662262,
-0.11149415373802185,
0.13957317173480988,
-0.5381733775138855,
0.28572380542755127,
0.5493729114532471,
-0.06531870365142822,
0.9263995289802551,
0.5608870387077332,
-0.9371819496154785,
-0.07024982571601868,
-0.04200797528028488,
-0.47490084171295166,
0.7265323996543884,
-0.961986780166626,
0.33352839946746826,
-0.1338527947664261,
-0.044194746762514114,
-1.0598937273025513,
-0.35167789459228516,
0.20787520706653595,
-0.27013665437698364,
0.2577848434448242,
-0.223072350025177,
-0.4666896164417267,
-0.28113746643066406,
0.09746050089597702,
0.5732312798500061,
0.7043274641036987,
-0.2936830520629883,
0.8056561946868896,
-0.0007612464833073318,
0.08797862380743027,
-0.24575132131576538,
-0.777688205242157,
-0.24253998696804047,
-0.3054066300392151,
-0.7712383270263672,
0.15476661920547485,
-0.20490968227386475,
-0.6297318935394287,
-0.2791039049625397,
-0.18398292362689972,
-0.2172669619321823,
0.5101140141487122,
0.44199836254119873,
-0.18098348379135132,
-0.5379363298416138,
-0.02729310840368271,
0.3982858955860138,
-0.014805487357079983,
0.2885378897190094,
-0.14953581988811493,
0.41635337471961975,
-0.005819214973598719,
-0.9509791731834412,
-0.6499913930892944,
0.5409988164901733,
0.6622646450996399,
-0.34324946999549866,
0.7578091621398926,
0.11350656300783157,
-0.08929149061441422,
-0.31747815012931824,
-0.857576847076416,
0.04976160451769829,
-0.5291544795036316,
0.03126540035009384,
-0.6309329867362976,
-0.6007669568061829,
0.759980320930481,
0.030801137909293175,
0.2695033848285675,
0.6383649706840515,
0.1969919055700302,
-0.23683218657970428,
0.951565146446228,
0.3230161964893341,
0.10805356502532959,
0.4297725558280945,
0.03124382346868515,
0.09369509667158127,
-0.9640640020370483,
-0.42096802592277527,
-0.443579763174057,
-0.5918120741844177,
-0.4084305763244629,
-0.22320958971977234,
0.2944500148296356,
0.28901398181915283,
-0.34983929991722107,
-0.30457940697669983,
-0.17283791303634644,
0.42778563499450684,
0.9250805974006653,
0.36036333441734314,
0.2329876720905304,
0.1765040159225464,
-0.5893495678901672,
0.3328896760940552,
-1.1070141792297363,
-0.4221552908420563,
1.3148480653762817,
0.3887772262096405,
0.7062099575996399,
0.02416239306330681,
0.8921107053756714,
0.20033489167690277,
0.13189147412776947,
-0.4795776903629303,
0.4625795781612396,
0.2920577824115753,
-0.9118068814277649,
-0.13186895847320557,
-0.2407398819923401,
-0.9082662463188171,
0.3006127178668976,
-0.03724915534257889,
-0.5178343057632446,
0.6592496633529663,
0.2615256905555725,
-0.5920775532722473,
0.3194093704223633,
-0.8609330058097839,
0.3824487328529358,
-0.2932429611682892,
-0.2920666038990021,
-0.30125290155410767,
-0.4681224524974823,
0.27259165048599243,
-0.14299970865249634,
0.18676213920116425,
0.28130432963371277,
0.1776525229215622,
0.8936474919319153,
-0.36891087889671326,
0.8791192173957825,
0.055893320590257645,
0.06150813400745392,
0.5079236030578613,
-0.05654828995466232,
0.1735427975654602,
0.18492889404296875,
-0.5693482756614685,
0.3741779029369354,
-0.9013614654541016,
-0.505465030670166,
-0.5235736966133118,
0.48143982887268066,
-1.072842001914978,
-0.8061948418617249,
-0.06462515890598297,
-0.16822606325149536,
-0.44518908858299255,
0.26720425486564636,
0.5830115079879761,
0.6377688646316528,
-0.17186199128627777,
0.35787132382392883,
0.9966360926628113,
0.014487375505268574,
0.2573712468147278,
0.30483588576316833,
0.10457481443881989,
-0.48507288098335266,
0.5830073952674866,
0.2633420526981354,
0.27608439326286316,
0.34666159749031067,
0.2126123309135437,
0.2850339114665985,
-0.9501038789749146,
-0.7246800065040588,
-0.39456361532211304,
-0.7613385319709778,
0.034108392894268036,
-0.5891043543815613,
-0.21031296253204346,
-0.03685300797224045,
-0.4428911507129669,
-0.4951426386833191,
-0.33250802755355835,
-0.5670944452285767,
-0.3611135184764862,
0.2343222200870514,
1.1498706340789795,
0.05633988976478577,
0.4283273220062256,
-0.6548341512680054,
0.0243686530739069,
0.636411190032959,
0.5720490217208862,
0.5919021964073181,
-0.45656266808509827,
-0.24829603731632233,
0.05007517337799072,
-0.5339195728302002,
-0.588298499584198,
-0.36653023958206177,
-0.018239133059978485,
1.171221137046814,
1.1244356632232666,
0.06997530162334442,
0.6774808764457703,
-0.7579807639122009,
1.0281202793121338,
0.12371165305376053,
-0.7398238778114319,
0.6643962264060974,
-0.29875805974006653,
-0.10633296519517899,
0.6701219081878662,
0.21294310688972473,
0.10750710219144821,
-0.20240861177444458,
-0.9214187860488892,
-0.7354394793510437,
0.3084898889064789,
0.2390795201063156,
0.12635350227355957,
-0.14998626708984375,
0.3524547815322876,
0.4970996379852295,
0.39701318740844727,
-0.19542092084884644,
-0.44313061237335205,
-0.05458950251340866,
0.28983795642852783,
0.1460605412721634,
-0.5004399418830872,
-0.2518232762813568,
-0.24227693676948547,
0.1434580534696579,
0.5282086730003357,
0.2851894497871399,
0.11980520188808441,
0.05856327712535858,
-0.06488113850355148,
0.2672761082649231,
0.8286616206169128,
1.1039965152740479,
-0.1798049509525299,
-0.03718581050634384,
0.1769028753042221,
-0.02832379937171936,
-0.013071887195110321,
-0.4435417056083679,
-0.37469926476478577,
0.2280644029378891,
0.6657925248146057,
0.9555325508117676,
0.48470667004585266,
-0.13966535031795502,
0.18170155584812164,
0.13192959129810333,
-0.33169111609458923,
0.1742432564496994,
0.6258457899093628,
-0.4332979619503021,
0.11983565241098404,
0.5635370016098022,
0.69467693567276,
0.42075568437576294,
-0.2832583487033844,
0.29447951912879944,
0.23523816466331482,
-0.049969594925642014,
-0.5429962277412415,
0.6227825284004211,
0.8184146881103516,
-0.6313268542289734,
0.7357733249664307,
-0.0461980476975441,
-0.44146785140037537,
0.6872316598892212,
0.14470785856246948,
0.9033232927322388,
-0.15385015308856964,
-0.14196637272834778,
0.18782994151115417,
0.08528310805559158,
0.02700972557067871,
0.12796169519424438,
-0.18983279168605804,
-0.5953415632247925,
-0.060238778591156006,
-0.42511406540870667,
-0.3470064103603363,
-0.4326646327972412,
-1.1394991874694824,
0.2576442062854767,
-0.6223407983779907,
-0.369071900844574,
-0.41675934195518494,
-0.5576572418212891,
-1.1236546039581299,
0.5044769048690796,
-0.08509576320648193,
1.0934619903564453,
-0.8390424251556396,
0.17725595831871033,
0.9645232558250427,
-0.1420130431652069,
-0.8530107140541077,
-0.012056462466716766,
0.0030393474735319614,
-0.8860846757888794,
0.9095082879066467,
-0.16708925366401672,
0.025934001430869102,
-0.16508497297763824,
-0.12030322104692459,
-0.7700579762458801,
1.1000324487686157,
-0.3494722843170166,
-0.5141879916191101,
0.025409523397684097,
0.08785738795995712,
0.4199460446834564,
-0.2258284091949463,
0.4374305307865143,
-0.046535689383745193,
0.10102800279855728,
0.13737504184246063,
-1.1889089345932007,
-0.4691215753555298,
-0.3271881639957428,
0.11955446749925613,
-0.011139093898236752,
-1.0920687913894653,
1.1673181056976318,
0.02310134284198284,
0.07088639587163925,
-0.17326663434505463,
0.8211783170700073,
0.49019524455070496,
0.7073326706886292,
0.5101460814476013,
0.7641385197639465,
0.9039334058761597,
0.1888447403907776,
0.8784963488578796,
-0.323224276304245,
0.1414669305086136,
0.7558750510215759,
-0.09804163128137589,
0.8420627117156982,
0.5005110502243042,
-0.1960940808057785,
0.8485082983970642,
0.8968691229820251,
0.4065225124359131,
0.8052285313606262,
0.2002398520708084,
-0.03463345766067505,
-0.29648736119270325,
0.26435646414756775,
-0.9068571329116821,
0.3745245337486267,
0.3441467583179474,
-0.4491090774536133,
-0.07591383904218674,
-0.09415119141340256,
-0.09975767880678177,
-0.47307348251342773,
-0.5859697461128235,
0.8154116272926331,
0.03358195722103119,
-0.7573727965354919,
0.08950219303369522,
-0.03172359988093376,
0.6552907824516296,
-0.22442536056041718,
0.05287400633096695,
-0.3690057098865509,
-0.050876449793577194,
-0.2918587327003479,
-0.7769559621810913,
-0.03237370774149895,
-0.2642739713191986,
-0.4697882831096649,
-0.2340499460697174,
0.5669881701469421,
0.3961647152900696,
-0.45399218797683716,
-0.10380642861127853,
0.6067808866500854,
-0.10728850960731506,
0.1516125500202179,
-0.36390024423599243,
0.06325331330299377,
-0.19341140985488892,
-0.5187933444976807,
0.49227771162986755,
1.016762614250183,
0.11695092171430588,
0.7545550465583801,
0.5140590667724609,
-0.08867605030536652,
0.4713498055934906,
-0.11929156631231308,
0.9772981405258179,
-0.4315468966960907,
-0.744292140007019,
-0.7088531851768494,
0.9023404121398926,
-0.22425206005573273,
-0.6700758337974548,
0.8807557225227356,
0.7008895874023438,
1.177113652229309,
-0.261869341135025,
0.8620038032531738,
0.31913912296295166,
0.2593246102333069,
-0.972501277923584,
0.5748825669288635,
-0.6056522130966187,
0.6394584774971008,
-0.37960556149482727,
-0.6438326835632324,
0.08155227452516556,
0.6616713404655457,
-0.5150490403175354,
0.29000064730644226,
0.34708601236343384,
0.3900505304336548,
-0.3539643883705139,
0.1982933133840561,
0.10740561783313751,
-0.1851213276386261,
0.30397316813468933,
0.36098599433898926,
1.1541495323181152,
-0.10071887075901031,
-0.004492360632866621,
-0.35428938269615173,
-0.24444931745529175,
-0.6272955536842346,
-0.7837823033332825,
-1.1383240222930908,
-0.25392061471939087,
-0.32867249846458435,
-0.10449912399053574,
-0.017964379861950874,
0.657012403011322,
0.8887110948562622,
-0.7095054984092712,
-0.1036960557103157,
-0.20565994083881378,
0.512633740901947,
-0.1920788288116455,
-0.2542077302932739,
0.05386684834957123,
-0.3509419858455658,
-0.37704187631607056,
0.15414588153362274,
0.22190213203430176,
-0.1294887810945511,
-0.09228049963712692,
-0.14197702705860138,
0.24111318588256836,
0.27305012941360474,
0.5738250017166138,
0.012348872609436512,
-1.018027663230896,
-0.15334956347942352,
-0.04173484817147255,
0.12945707142353058,
0.2712065875530243,
1.177058458328247,
-0.6600376963615417,
0.5390302538871765,
0.8702141046524048,
0.612544059753418,
-0.18310678005218506,
0.27561134099960327,
0.8139744400978088,
-0.4925307631492615,
-0.04387110099196434,
0.009685993194580078,
0.6936876773834229,
-0.33812493085861206,
-0.38031062483787537,
0.31311866641044617,
0.4604707658290863,
-0.6586685180664062,
-0.8700588941574097,
0.2809630334377289,
-0.8140438199043274,
-0.19524969160556793,
1.2821520566940308,
-0.10283955931663513,
0.13433563709259033,
-0.4530434310436249,
-0.19901713728904724,
-0.36509138345718384,
-0.4839033782482147,
0.7516912221908569,
1.0423853397369385,
-0.4301753044128418,
-0.035138171166181564,
-0.6821535229682922,
0.17622502148151398,
0.4221876561641693,
-0.08010072261095047,
-0.5475448369979858,
0.20362481474876404,
0.506362795829773,
0.32178404927253723,
0.4785865545272827,
0.40154120326042175,
0.3276953399181366,
0.1804271787405014,
-0.3122921884059906,
-0.21384458243846893,
-0.5012460947036743,
-0.06741905957460403,
0.26761314272880554,
0.41971173882484436,
-0.27975520491600037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13064v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13064v1 | Synthetic Data (Almost) from Scratch: Generalized Instruction Tuning for Language Models | 2024-02-20T15:00:35 | 2024-02-20T15:00:35 | Haoran Li, Qingxiu Dong, Zhengyang Tang, Chaojun Wang, Xingxing Zhang, Haoyang Huang, Shaohan Huang, Xiaolong Huang, Zeqiang Huang, Dongdong Zhang, Yuxian Gu, Xin Cheng, Xun Wang, Si-Qing Chen, Li Dong, Wei Lu, Zhifang Sui, Benyou Wang, Wai Lam, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce Generalized Instruction Tuning (called GLAN), a general and
scalable method for instruction tuning of Large Language Models (LLMs). Unlike
prior work that relies on seed examples or existing datasets to construct
instruction tuning data, GLAN exclusively utilizes a pre-curated taxonomy of
human knowledge and capabilities as input and generates large-scale synthetic
instruction data across all disciplines. Specifically, inspired by the
systematic structure in human education system, we build the taxonomy by
decomposing human knowledge and capabilities to various fields, sub-fields and
ultimately, distinct disciplines semi-automatically, facilitated by LLMs.
Subsequently, we generate a comprehensive list of subjects for every discipline
and proceed to design a syllabus tailored to each subject, again utilizing
LLMs. With the fine-grained key concepts detailed in every class session of the
syllabus, we are able to generate diverse instructions with a broad coverage
across the entire spectrum of human knowledge and skills. Extensive experiments
on large language models (e.g., Mistral) demonstrate that GLAN excels in
multiple dimensions from mathematical reasoning, coding, academic exams,
logical reasoning to general instruction following without using task-specific
training data of these tasks. In addition, GLAN allows for easy customization
and new fields or skills can be added by simply incorporating a new node into
our taxonomy. | [
-0.21088291704654694,
-1.0970873832702637,
0.450953871011734,
-0.15929533541202545,
0.09458962827920914,
0.5328928232192993,
-0.3114374279975891,
-0.3843398988246918,
0.3124580979347229,
0.5637261271476746,
-0.5846483707427979,
-0.7571946978569031,
-0.07537557929754257,
-0.3184182941913605,
-0.4942413568496704,
1.1642394065856934,
0.18042892217636108,
-0.0011997956316918135,
-0.21510432660579681,
0.20297351479530334,
-0.2510543167591095,
-0.42916223406791687,
-0.6934293508529663,
-0.2423107773065567,
0.40430259704589844,
0.6785955429077148,
0.5682065486907959,
1.101845622062683,
0.22349298000335693,
0.3573441803455353,
0.11973927915096283,
0.6810030341148376,
-0.5019346475601196,
-0.24878470599651337,
-0.5271576642990112,
-0.3293461203575134,
-0.9376969933509827,
0.08909478783607483,
0.8336914777755737,
0.8834078311920166,
-0.3006552457809448,
0.5465810298919678,
0.07634236663579941,
0.6248332262039185,
-0.552742600440979,
-0.05881388857960701,
-0.8008043169975281,
-0.14165645837783813,
-0.26160189509391785,
-0.3567001521587372,
-0.5443046689033508,
-0.6578980088233948,
-0.07408783584833145,
-0.8461235761642456,
0.7782256603240967,
0.2835734486579895,
0.8255018591880798,
0.04141005873680115,
-0.35226675868034363,
-0.539436399936676,
-0.8951712846755981,
1.0132856369018555,
-0.3008550703525543,
0.2723918855190277,
0.4321623146533966,
0.40236279368400574,
-0.30882957577705383,
-0.9022651314735413,
-0.5513496994972229,
-0.39912834763526917,
-0.035829316824674606,
-0.0453513003885746,
-0.014245446771383286,
0.5608795881271362,
0.29996293783187866,
0.6962689757347107,
-0.5582317113876343,
0.12248232960700989,
-0.7985167503356934,
-0.25871697068214417,
0.7466521263122559,
0.425088107585907,
0.46144142746925354,
0.30106303095817566,
-0.16822689771652222,
-0.22389771044254303,
-0.7842313051223755,
-0.01642591506242752,
0.6481348872184753,
0.18293461203575134,
-0.1885087937116623,
0.46686851978302,
-0.33005210757255554,
1.2532066106796265,
0.0910307765007019,
-0.14600849151611328,
0.2155032902956009,
-0.387887179851532,
-0.42233148217201233,
-0.09319190680980682,
0.5838406682014465,
0.16062301397323608,
0.3716224730014801,
-0.2661115229129791,
-0.088734932243824,
0.12804435193538666,
0.6118327379226685,
-0.5044535994529724,
-0.48153746128082275,
0.044929105788469315,
-0.17766447365283966,
-0.27069345116615295,
0.06477242708206177,
-0.8533658385276794,
-0.055460888892412186,
-0.8982257843017578,
0.4351027309894562,
-0.3378746509552002,
0.18338553607463837,
0.035060860216617584,
0.16360405087471008,
0.41545921564102173,
0.15368543565273285,
-1.428767204284668,
0.5388860106468201,
0.7781638503074646,
0.8157489895820618,
-0.22771331667900085,
-0.29336726665496826,
-0.43872955441474915,
0.2590695917606354,
-0.6541046500205994,
0.6667270064353943,
-0.7745133638381958,
-0.4697656035423279,
0.07655509561300278,
0.10139034688472748,
-0.2234925925731659,
-0.5688703060150146,
0.3113246560096741,
-0.5241547226905823,
0.37653297185897827,
-0.047479916363954544,
-0.8749094605445862,
-0.1290879100561142,
0.12958355247974396,
-0.629602313041687,
1.0039668083190918,
0.30545854568481445,
-0.19298505783081055,
0.1108565479516983,
-0.9071362614631653,
-0.5871076583862305,
-0.1628299355506897,
-0.2279888540506363,
-0.2167760580778122,
0.26833975315093994,
-0.01178889162838459,
0.1671571135520935,
-0.4908123314380646,
0.1856774240732193,
-0.04915311560034752,
-0.5290829539299011,
-0.1793515980243683,
-0.09450807422399521,
0.6833271384239197,
0.1802823841571808,
-0.033152058720588684,
0.29004529118537903,
-0.9850866198539734,
0.7090756893157959,
-0.3540894389152527,
-0.3368443548679352,
-0.2345498949289322,
-0.05326719954609871,
-0.24348759651184082,
-0.14076365530490875,
0.2826083302497864,
-0.4131062626838684,
0.6041345000267029,
-0.4860045313835144,
0.47435545921325684,
0.8018869161605835,
-0.1479862779378891,
0.7135050296783447,
-0.35227611660957336,
0.6833385825157166,
-0.3704085052013397,
0.13614636659622192,
-0.11314282566308975,
-0.4366544485092163,
-0.7815998792648315,
-0.27076709270477295,
0.31438809633255005,
0.7388656735420227,
-0.6533838510513306,
0.43183663487434387,
-0.10331732034683228,
-0.44546177983283997,
-0.7861811518669128,
0.5102441906929016,
0.48174718022346497,
0.567772388458252,
0.5739076733589172,
0.0016342576127499342,
-0.7087017297744751,
-0.9311505556106567,
0.009627520106732845,
-0.047431573271751404,
-0.17129036784172058,
0.03546377271413803,
0.38640540838241577,
-0.2756316661834717,
1.0759834051132202,
-0.8459413051605225,
-0.2748367190361023,
-0.3200175166130066,
0.12266591191291809,
0.2877860963344574,
0.5015823245048523,
0.5075703263282776,
-0.4116803705692291,
-0.521662175655365,
0.30007293820381165,
-0.6269210577011108,
-0.26117801666259766,
-0.1713106632232666,
-0.43702226877212524,
0.19781996309757233,
0.7834128141403198,
-0.358428955078125,
0.14489881694316864,
0.6116300821304321,
-0.15571430325508118,
0.8340893387794495,
-0.6436423063278198,
-0.004188111051917076,
-1.2378500699996948,
0.05617692694067955,
-0.2875213027000427,
0.15733809769153595,
-0.8492605686187744,
0.12248574197292328,
0.337523877620697,
0.07815087586641312,
-0.21199677884578705,
0.7680094242095947,
-0.5484402775764465,
0.10824688524007797,
-0.3377572000026703,
-0.3222162127494812,
0.05069243162870407,
0.4245234727859497,
-0.12692300975322723,
1.0258718729019165,
0.48840391635894775,
-0.7601214051246643,
0.6045589447021484,
-0.04520237073302269,
-0.5246769785881042,
0.40945425629615784,
-0.9163073301315308,
0.31579163670539856,
-0.06533008068799973,
0.041226521134376526,
-0.6246349215507507,
-0.6127451658248901,
0.2511539161205292,
-0.08524658530950546,
0.5427237749099731,
-0.14056943356990814,
-0.12155364453792572,
-0.33989012241363525,
-0.31817978620529175,
0.37610772252082825,
0.5047562122344971,
-0.5325403213500977,
0.6070162653923035,
0.28224244713783264,
-0.010097271762788296,
-0.49018973112106323,
-0.42366379499435425,
0.04686376079916954,
-0.17623743414878845,
-0.4101094901561737,
0.6602024435997009,
-0.19700591266155243,
-0.1590059995651245,
0.18184518814086914,
0.12720228731632233,
-0.18331584334373474,
-0.04726182669401169,
0.07368414849042892,
0.4617178738117218,
-0.32599470019340515,
0.31118255853652954,
0.3726222515106201,
0.04512009397149086,
0.004908396862447262,
-0.6256358623504639,
0.4887843728065491,
0.043481480330228806,
-0.3632257282733917,
-0.2297506332397461,
0.2664768099784851,
0.30443862080574036,
-0.12336605787277222,
0.710729718208313,
0.5712257027626038,
-0.15719160437583923,
-0.8991067409515381,
-0.3831477761268616,
0.09095986932516098,
-0.564643919467926,
0.6306813955307007,
-0.07785315811634064,
-1.0166212320327759,
0.4033815860748291,
0.0016415085410699248,
0.12237724661827087,
0.08350024372339249,
0.6125630736351013,
-0.1461201310157776,
0.7401831746101379,
0.9518559575080872,
-0.34789904952049255,
0.570402979850769,
-0.5313736200332642,
0.123761385679245,
-0.7819113731384277,
-0.3117368221282959,
-0.3481003940105438,
-0.4648602306842804,
-0.6816693544387817,
-0.6639528870582581,
0.3849608898162842,
0.0311263594776392,
-0.3061414062976837,
0.06754839420318604,
-0.5948931574821472,
1.0995054244995117,
0.7493157982826233,
-0.05635186657309532,
0.09559876471757889,
0.18353679776191711,
0.016665766015648842,
0.28758275508880615,
-0.5608422160148621,
-0.43490973114967346,
1.436432957649231,
-0.003947752993553877,
0.9355649948120117,
-0.09668528288602829,
0.7972062826156616,
0.5039067268371582,
0.2952674627304077,
-0.8376324772834778,
0.596681535243988,
-0.32794660329818726,
-0.6323310136795044,
-0.21705928444862366,
-0.5416706800460815,
-0.9556416273117065,
-0.028950801119208336,
0.020205151289701462,
-0.7854936122894287,
-0.2515031397342682,
0.6396754384040833,
-0.5332373976707458,
0.424204558134079,
-1.0763319730758667,
0.7144818305969238,
-0.23105210065841675,
-0.32585352659225464,
-0.2951009273529053,
-0.3919135630130768,
0.6476873755455017,
-0.09897118806838989,
0.19191545248031616,
0.28296464681625366,
-0.06397991627454758,
0.7044007182121277,
-0.3757413327693939,
0.9726799130439758,
-0.05864741653203964,
-0.21132606267929077,
0.45873403549194336,
-0.06865520030260086,
0.15811626613140106,
-0.08782435208559036,
-0.003498068545013666,
-0.14632189273834229,
-0.09959573298692703,
-0.5024789571762085,
-0.8017731308937073,
0.8436136245727539,
-0.9861055612564087,
-0.7019883394241333,
-0.21220514178276062,
-0.8732468485832214,
-0.39156481623649597,
0.09748504310846329,
0.13491496443748474,
0.494663268327713,
-0.38650110363960266,
-0.0911741554737091,
0.8504494428634644,
-0.3954232931137085,
0.21973760426044464,
0.4023042917251587,
-0.24881376326084137,
-0.6276471614837646,
1.3818440437316895,
0.16265936195850372,
0.5766061544418335,
0.41180604696273804,
0.028066448867321014,
-0.2683156430721283,
-0.39662468433380127,
-0.5591107606887817,
0.21340598165988922,
-0.4984625577926636,
-0.22673965990543365,
-0.10792797803878784,
-0.4402278661727905,
-0.27843162417411804,
-0.22933658957481384,
-0.19388237595558167,
-0.400023877620697,
-0.23316486179828644,
-0.11858440190553665,
0.29547178745269775,
1.0605796575546265,
-0.13036859035491943,
0.5115388631820679,
-0.7346494197845459,
0.6322094202041626,
0.514435887336731,
0.3588562309741974,
-0.06850248575210571,
-0.7593992352485657,
-0.5448651313781738,
0.3481287956237793,
-0.42088115215301514,
-0.5124205350875854,
0.19770067930221558,
0.9146826863288879,
0.5632809996604919,
0.377315878868103,
-0.25981593132019043,
0.7567278146743774,
-0.789822518825531,
0.6371299624443054,
-0.16385243833065033,
-1.0018160343170166,
0.5662466287612915,
-0.2786402106285095,
0.21872478723526,
0.1960594654083252,
0.38616320490837097,
-0.33220523595809937,
-0.2449939101934433,
-0.43769571185112,
-0.8655213117599487,
0.83094722032547,
-0.34561723470687866,
0.5010268092155457,
0.10424840450286865,
0.40067607164382935,
0.10508721321821213,
0.2308395504951477,
-0.1152789369225502,
-0.26618215441703796,
0.004796445835381746,
-0.3978562653064728,
-0.2865137755870819,
-0.23047135770320892,
-0.26092568039894104,
-0.688414454460144,
0.6342586278915405,
-0.26930227875709534,
0.12970179319381714,
-0.23281972110271454,
-0.03178903087973595,
-0.13327550888061523,
0.24679724872112274,
0.8711152076721191,
0.8034005761146545,
-0.09626390039920807,
0.05105360969901085,
0.25808006525039673,
-0.8474308848381042,
0.3415047824382782,
-0.3135855495929718,
-0.2652360498905182,
-0.22674888372421265,
0.5486344695091248,
0.7761932611465454,
0.15250608325004578,
-0.38176873326301575,
-0.22383873164653778,
0.32778072357177734,
-0.3812004029750824,
-0.12839791178703308,
0.6306768655776978,
0.09016859531402588,
-0.057491134852170944,
0.330258846282959,
-0.19182564318180084,
-0.15167079865932465,
-0.7455523014068604,
0.27234336733818054,
0.3759143352508545,
0.20383912324905396,
-0.6579566597938538,
0.5173615217208862,
0.0013690287014469504,
-0.23529794812202454,
0.5748401880264282,
-0.3761482536792755,
-0.21817442774772644,
0.6475239992141724,
0.8984851837158203,
0.7821435928344727,
-0.36616501212120056,
0.7544307112693787,
0.3835655152797699,
0.327379435300827,
-0.09537378698587418,
0.33498984575271606,
-0.010810586623847485,
-0.761731743812561,
-0.6521489024162292,
-0.981611967086792,
-0.7135528326034546,
0.3397101163864136,
-0.7414410710334778,
0.032078810036182404,
-0.8636712431907654,
0.09155852347612381,
0.007004902232438326,
0.08243869245052338,
-0.47775834798812866,
0.3878297805786133,
0.03727809712290764,
0.8153846859931946,
-0.9122017621994019,
1.2938777208328247,
1.0847634077072144,
-0.08927891403436661,
-0.8617811799049377,
-0.15758390724658966,
0.031440529972314835,
-0.9117109179496765,
0.45966070890426636,
-0.20611830055713654,
-0.1380319595336914,
0.19400690495967865,
-0.6413023471832275,
-0.8211137652397156,
0.9846246838569641,
0.6590010523796082,
-0.5503214001655579,
-0.2809741497039795,
0.5303665995597839,
0.7760782241821289,
-0.35411739349365234,
0.01517458725720644,
0.8781805634498596,
0.13211148977279663,
0.18199050426483154,
-0.724591851234436,
-0.3643352687358856,
-0.34269195795059204,
0.05037097632884979,
0.24380114674568176,
-0.5428455471992493,
0.915153980255127,
-0.24673469364643097,
-0.047363732010126114,
0.06771200150251389,
0.7676114439964294,
0.1665150374174118,
0.2851482033729553,
0.0930410698056221,
0.6650860905647278,
1.1733249425888062,
-0.03187805041670799,
0.9293906688690186,
-0.35433438420295715,
0.19254238903522491,
1.1672979593276978,
0.0014969147741794586,
0.443845272064209,
0.27859753370285034,
-0.18669746816158295,
0.5832602977752686,
0.41352176666259766,
0.0035828568506985903,
0.4169032871723175,
0.41345328092575073,
-0.2532658874988556,
-0.25432106852531433,
0.030448516830801964,
-0.5347673296928406,
0.4358770549297333,
0.5012227892875671,
-0.26842358708381653,
-0.15679587423801422,
-0.1834753006696701,
-0.13526281714439392,
0.18672746419906616,
-0.6479836702346802,
0.5175976157188416,
0.009780298918485641,
-0.527205228805542,
0.8501623272895813,
0.06355282664299011,
0.43557974696159363,
-0.8771504163742065,
-0.19652025401592255,
-0.38568878173828125,
0.24678263068199158,
-0.34160181879997253,
-0.6628651022911072,
0.3675297498703003,
0.10384488105773926,
-0.38519930839538574,
-0.25890904664993286,
0.49465206265449524,
-0.7095116972923279,
-0.8467317223548889,
-0.009022022597491741,
0.3752119541168213,
-0.09430225938558578,
0.45336732268333435,
-0.38562726974487305,
0.10682547837495804,
0.12678028643131256,
-0.20158472657203674,
0.4860203266143799,
0.4953289031982422,
-0.29221948981285095,
0.7733973264694214,
0.7178288102149963,
0.3864940404891968,
0.24837733805179596,
0.12515050172805786,
0.9824058413505554,
-0.7593461871147156,
-0.3480496108531952,
-0.7307724356651306,
0.4246106445789337,
-0.09982794523239136,
-0.4544598162174225,
0.6611798405647278,
0.5840044617652893,
1.2849501371383667,
-0.3743813931941986,
0.8798546195030212,
-0.11690396070480347,
0.4207662343978882,
-0.8194434642791748,
0.7373983860015869,
-0.4491565525531769,
0.20006024837493896,
-0.14610692858695984,
-1.0597928762435913,
-0.17513816058635712,
0.4422909915447235,
-0.3338611423969269,
0.07300814241170883,
0.49790340662002563,
1.079992413520813,
-0.31599724292755127,
-0.08486031740903854,
0.3032963275909424,
-0.052706360816955566,
0.187009796500206,
0.4289115071296692,
0.7754389643669128,
-0.06516484916210175,
0.187233105301857,
-0.1777503341436386,
-0.31069353222846985,
0.13776461780071259,
-0.5796291828155518,
-0.9752842783927917,
-0.5065158009529114,
-0.17185920476913452,
0.0971941277384758,
0.2883943021297455,
0.9452236294746399,
0.49531662464141846,
-1.2226734161376953,
-0.5403264760971069,
0.029795372858643532,
0.1716385781764984,
-0.14260463416576385,
-0.2403726577758789,
0.4709935188293457,
-0.8126654624938965,
-0.8064640164375305,
0.7071866393089294,
-0.023327292874455452,
-0.20183077454566956,
-0.09777543693780899,
-0.12897688150405884,
0.0713939294219017,
0.07463818043470383,
0.5137285590171814,
0.5590238571166992,
-0.43805885314941406,
-0.4522668719291687,
0.16353699564933777,
-0.08597694337368011,
-0.32282155752182007,
0.7909038066864014,
-0.6630856394767761,
0.43989190459251404,
0.3055208623409271,
0.6237673163414001,
0.04914580285549164,
0.2042425125837326,
0.6557067036628723,
-1.0041245222091675,
0.1801144927740097,
-0.02349301241338253,
-0.06013309210538864,
0.030267788097262383,
-0.11505378037691116,
0.47310498356819153,
0.17627570033073425,
-0.5449557304382324,
-0.8442854881286621,
0.27499961853027344,
-0.843982994556427,
0.019867846742272377,
0.9510563015937805,
-0.004225569777190685,
-0.3328348398208618,
0.11848971247673035,
-0.26971733570098877,
0.20123882591724396,
-0.031380683183670044,
1.1695923805236816,
0.4439700245857239,
-0.09900590032339096,
0.24613818526268005,
-0.6257016658782959,
0.7388899326324463,
0.2897711396217346,
-0.8954031467437744,
-0.04717523604631424,
0.5255259275436401,
0.20052121579647064,
-0.007129585836082697,
0.3673580288887024,
0.21825845539569855,
0.2751185894012451,
-0.14294098317623138,
0.1654725968837738,
-0.379815012216568,
-0.7097268104553223,
-0.010739205405116081,
0.20210106670856476,
-0.0646689236164093,
-0.47511303424835205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13055v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13055v1 | Identifying Semantic Induction Heads to Understand In-Context Learning | 2024-02-20T14:43:39 | 2024-02-20T14:43:39 | Jie Ren, Qipeng Guo, Hang Yan, Dongrui Liu, Xipeng Qiu, Dahua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
performance, the lack of transparency in their inference logic raises concerns
about their trustworthiness. To gain a better understanding of LLMs, we conduct
a detailed analysis of the operations of attention heads and aim to better
understand the in-context learning of LLMs. Specifically, we investigate
whether attention heads encode two types of relationships between tokens
present in natural languages: the syntactic dependency parsed from sentences
and the relation within knowledge graphs. We find that certain attention heads
exhibit a pattern where, when attending to head tokens, they recall tail tokens
and increase the output logits of those tail tokens. More crucially, the
formulation of such semantic induction heads has a close correlation with the
emergence of the in-context learning ability of language models. The study of
semantic attention heads advances our understanding of the intricate operations
of attention heads in transformers, and further provides new insights into the
in-context learning of LLMs. | [
-0.2309826910495758,
-0.6465803980827332,
0.7751931548118591,
0.07905612885951996,
-0.06685197353363037,
-0.29210492968559265,
-0.4037453532218933,
-0.6115778088569641,
0.0429392009973526,
0.7953192591667175,
-0.9228888750076294,
-0.32504045963287354,
-0.8320345282554626,
0.29413923621177673,
-0.5688413381576538,
0.7487339973449707,
0.1253875344991684,
0.024582674726843834,
-0.4644051194190979,
-0.09521522372961044,
-0.5046425461769104,
-0.4515964388847351,
-0.6990875601768494,
-0.47852474451065063,
0.5904359221458435,
0.17238111793994904,
0.48619532585144043,
0.8533018827438354,
0.6688171029090881,
0.30954647064208984,
-0.21438844501972198,
0.06738008558750153,
-0.507041335105896,
0.13039883971214294,
-0.47834452986717224,
-0.5238274335861206,
-0.14468428492546082,
-0.07561178505420685,
0.7491983771324158,
1.0816285610198975,
0.3819968104362488,
0.21644869446754456,
0.2715146541595459,
0.654749870300293,
-0.6655669808387756,
0.6805068254470825,
-0.9638628363609314,
0.04470349848270416,
-0.1710623949766159,
-0.4621651768684387,
-0.6672074198722839,
0.069826640188694,
0.41372138261795044,
-0.5017948746681213,
0.0885167345404625,
0.03245749697089195,
0.7394377589225769,
0.5284652709960938,
-0.43751898407936096,
-0.3633870482444763,
-0.4670146107673645,
0.8595432043075562,
-0.4053889513015747,
0.5789076685905457,
0.18971243500709534,
0.23021858930587769,
-0.56246018409729,
-0.9911409616470337,
-0.642051100730896,
0.19949619472026825,
-0.5100833773612976,
-0.16340644657611847,
0.05539289861917496,
0.20550493896007538,
0.357969731092453,
0.29241108894348145,
-0.2176707684993744,
-0.08982580900192261,
-0.11669030785560608,
-0.14203155040740967,
0.13476207852363586,
0.27222147583961487,
0.30951058864593506,
-0.043490517884492874,
-0.43582749366760254,
-0.03447076305747032,
-0.858101487159729,
-0.08259253203868866,
-0.04685516655445099,
0.4464177191257477,
-0.27755770087242126,
0.661435067653656,
-0.2967125177383423,
1.1174110174179077,
0.2741999328136444,
-0.4397805333137512,
0.16756920516490936,
-0.3123950660228729,
-0.2767675518989563,
0.19738394021987915,
0.5581592321395874,
0.2692908048629761,
0.6179404854774475,
-0.5891668796539307,
-0.034026850014925,
0.12016114592552185,
0.12403815239667892,
-0.6754900813102722,
0.28583383560180664,
0.0553414411842823,
-0.38549619913101196,
-0.14709486067295074,
0.0496077798306942,
-0.14033038914203644,
-0.20375214517116547,
-0.6574703454971313,
0.45007020235061646,
-0.29135555028915405,
-0.17228837311267853,
0.11344039440155029,
-0.3136460781097412,
0.6938022375106812,
0.07659874856472015,
-0.9958181977272034,
0.28992557525634766,
0.9736568927764893,
0.6456272602081299,
-0.3656754791736603,
-0.5262402892112732,
-0.5520024299621582,
0.4810207188129425,
-0.12490954250097275,
0.7217386364936829,
-0.7499107718467712,
0.12395516037940979,
0.24125275015830994,
0.2837987542152405,
-0.28953540325164795,
-0.6152445077896118,
0.17958427965641022,
-0.8400618433952332,
0.03083719313144684,
-0.4633485972881317,
-0.8689554929733276,
-0.28707069158554077,
0.06785650551319122,
-0.5817136168479919,
0.6480728983879089,
0.4659331142902374,
-1.1259642839431763,
0.3993970453739166,
-0.6353343725204468,
-0.4389064610004425,
0.0727943554520607,
-0.3905913829803467,
0.1016751229763031,
0.09525410830974579,
0.02804565615952015,
0.7314665913581848,
-0.19407247006893158,
0.03535967320203781,
-0.1093800961971283,
-0.3192104995250702,
0.29947665333747864,
0.2318592667579651,
1.0971540212631226,
-0.17550942301750183,
-0.3180929720401764,
0.2258448302745819,
-0.6156833171844482,
-0.36367854475975037,
0.12333656847476959,
0.10607627034187317,
-0.4535796642303467,
-0.09522183239459991,
-0.3966084420681,
0.34832561016082764,
0.18698392808437347,
-0.39318662881851196,
-0.17817571759223938,
-0.6202095150947571,
0.6369317173957825,
0.6223341822624207,
0.2949413061141968,
0.49879759550094604,
0.09271231293678284,
0.14427374303340912,
0.3446005582809448,
-0.14162883162498474,
-0.40939533710479736,
-0.46926364302635193,
-0.8817725777626038,
-0.0939255878329277,
0.18795014917850494,
0.12072329223155975,
-0.5487604737281799,
0.6829749941825867,
-0.24495790898799896,
0.04556337371468544,
-0.24287624657154083,
0.18146906793117523,
0.3948354423046112,
0.9760531187057495,
0.032495126128196716,
-0.4484952688217163,
-0.4592028558254242,
-0.8895690441131592,
-0.5034176707267761,
0.01828545145690441,
0.004914456512778997,
0.21925225853919983,
0.44130825996398926,
-0.3565109074115753,
1.3658473491668701,
-0.2947790026664734,
-0.3146769404411316,
-0.438664972782135,
-0.23159773647785187,
0.018953416496515274,
0.25786325335502625,
0.584879457950592,
-0.5247285962104797,
-0.3236393928527832,
-0.012231901288032532,
-0.9887887835502625,
0.012017911300063133,
-0.027996813878417015,
-0.48524969816207886,
-0.016428522765636444,
0.7279134392738342,
-0.7706693410873413,
0.25463369488716125,
0.34570690989494324,
-0.496094286441803,
0.3010866343975067,
0.2695050835609436,
-0.4034164547920227,
-0.7656328082084656,
-0.08159395307302475,
-0.04873872548341751,
-0.3052082657814026,
-0.5908929705619812,
0.27558276057243347,
0.2145637720823288,
0.1992681473493576,
-0.6082325577735901,
0.5587491989135742,
-0.3901938796043396,
-0.5789733529090881,
-0.1719987988471985,
0.40094929933547974,
0.03597164526581764,
0.7791035771369934,
0.26223987340927124,
0.658410906791687,
0.6993801593780518,
-0.8918595314025879,
0.1326770931482315,
0.40715378522872925,
-0.3310251235961914,
0.4550287425518036,
-0.4940355122089386,
0.18142566084861755,
-0.3406411409378052,
0.20643699169158936,
-0.9079568982124329,
-0.5142672657966614,
0.24146768450737,
-0.4681292772293091,
0.426148921251297,
0.006736731622368097,
-0.5756887793540955,
0.020537806674838066,
-0.03509629890322685,
0.34469863772392273,
0.1760822832584381,
-0.6627111434936523,
0.580647885799408,
0.6584134101867676,
0.1029665619134903,
-0.591916024684906,
-0.6264510750770569,
-0.19690953195095062,
-0.3369760811328888,
-0.5577153563499451,
0.32141581177711487,
0.40926414728164673,
-0.5494959950447083,
0.09936344623565674,
-0.057971056550741196,
0.025840694084763527,
0.13884200155735016,
0.13978362083435059,
0.06353382021188736,
-0.16145895421504974,
0.09764261543750763,
-0.10519789159297943,
-0.2522493600845337,
0.5997102856636047,
-0.4640093743801117,
0.5629907846450806,
0.10126961767673492,
-0.08143895119428635,
-0.6090715527534485,
0.08757025003433228,
0.7417471408843994,
-0.26251518726348877,
0.9688311219215393,
0.41163209080696106,
-0.6177340745925903,
-0.17226353287696838,
-0.4010830223560333,
-0.5518686771392822,
-0.4761527180671692,
0.4878883957862854,
-0.354006826877594,
-0.8293601870536804,
0.6054546236991882,
0.11132871359586716,
-0.039075180888175964,
0.6713787913322449,
0.739452064037323,
0.16399317979812622,
0.6131331324577332,
0.7274789214134216,
0.08565784245729446,
0.5116897225379944,
-0.19240212440490723,
0.14220066368579865,
-1.0814495086669922,
-0.4169682264328003,
-0.33206242322921753,
-0.08048810809850693,
-0.5549578070640564,
-0.2225600928068161,
0.27203309535980225,
-0.16062988340854645,
-0.27775144577026367,
0.4627456068992615,
-0.2787627875804901,
0.5854020714759827,
0.39717066287994385,
0.09962684661149979,
0.28372690081596375,
-0.09130305051803589,
-0.07456667721271515,
-0.013744276948273182,
-0.5662110447883606,
-0.34868961572647095,
1.0731573104858398,
0.48946723341941833,
0.5005782246589661,
-0.1991860568523407,
0.46915382146835327,
-0.051304008811712265,
0.012915490195155144,
-1.0192159414291382,
0.48291072249412537,
0.1649327576160431,
-0.34930387139320374,
-0.29142630100250244,
-0.2146874964237213,
-0.9061876535415649,
0.21402853727340698,
0.09294764697551727,
-0.7576954364776611,
0.0352734811604023,
-0.08886320143938065,
-0.23590655624866486,
-0.00014713760174345225,
-0.7660565376281738,
1.1728477478027344,
0.06604533642530441,
-0.345886766910553,
-0.22574302554130554,
-0.936933696269989,
0.41447556018829346,
0.10525426268577576,
-0.08297345042228699,
0.02496793307363987,
-0.045317042618989944,
0.8933889269828796,
-0.2035982459783554,
0.9117584824562073,
0.006924997083842754,
-0.30313917994499207,
0.3977678418159485,
-0.07579955458641052,
0.5772385597229004,
-0.12456576526165009,
0.33758601546287537,
0.19748806953430176,
-0.3481970429420471,
-0.18392741680145264,
-0.5733829736709595,
0.7287824749946594,
-0.7080807089805603,
-0.5430757999420166,
-0.1907540261745453,
-0.7824457287788391,
-0.5280911922454834,
0.2934778034687042,
0.10954058915376663,
0.47020700573921204,
0.2350223809480667,
0.13813473284244537,
0.8496799468994141,
-0.029432453215122223,
0.46022671461105347,
0.1568484902381897,
-0.1490536332130432,
0.19109460711479187,
0.578620195388794,
0.04058854654431343,
0.44953057169914246,
0.604584813117981,
0.08979906886816025,
-0.3641795217990875,
-0.3722468614578247,
-0.2116517722606659,
0.4780793786048889,
-1.0019772052764893,
-0.02496415376663208,
-0.9279524087905884,
-0.3570214509963989,
-0.27827656269073486,
0.11758588254451752,
-0.20986153185367584,
-0.43720850348472595,
-0.1662556678056717,
-0.08357095718383789,
0.42024487257003784,
0.8463841080665588,
0.47841504216194153,
0.4928751289844513,
-0.430964857339859,
0.3005637228488922,
0.442838191986084,
0.35988783836364746,
0.2891828417778015,
-0.5864554047584534,
-0.364884614944458,
-0.289430171251297,
-0.20746363699436188,
-0.828405499458313,
0.24767711758613586,
0.14386244118213654,
0.560494065284729,
0.7373548150062561,
-0.057248059660196304,
0.654123842716217,
-0.6010091304779053,
0.6129845380783081,
-0.0019725572783499956,
-0.8749972581863403,
0.2589617669582367,
-0.36254727840423584,
0.33511579036712646,
0.21342533826828003,
0.2787138521671295,
-0.46782636642456055,
-0.7564741969108582,
-0.6145034432411194,
-0.6952844858169556,
0.9001308679580688,
0.12798519432544708,
0.0008798195631243289,
-0.2865948975086212,
0.5203699469566345,
0.2751297056674957,
0.314944863319397,
-0.509416401386261,
-0.4005422294139862,
0.07646813988685608,
-0.16443583369255066,
0.159758061170578,
-0.42303699254989624,
-0.029651060700416565,
-0.19331347942352295,
0.23979619145393372,
-0.1481189727783203,
0.49413615465164185,
0.0003701517707668245,
-0.48342424631118774,
-0.10569234192371368,
-0.13010148704051971,
0.5071725249290466,
1.0198450088500977,
-0.23235946893692017,
0.3638516068458557,
0.07900899648666382,
-0.40101319551467896,
-0.43093398213386536,
-0.46675410866737366,
0.04379495605826378,
0.1119726300239563,
0.6132553815841675,
0.8372989296913147,
0.4585206210613251,
-0.5173957943916321,
0.5031619668006897,
0.047241002321243286,
0.18664035201072693,
-0.6124088168144226,
0.09210199117660522,
0.299083948135376,
0.13473071157932281,
0.32913023233413696,
-0.10290402919054031,
0.1970260590314865,
-0.7046570777893066,
0.3802160918712616,
0.6716223359107971,
-0.45737460255622864,
-0.3866429626941681,
0.48031291365623474,
0.1583225131034851,
-0.19066591560840607,
0.47904303669929504,
-0.026775088161230087,
-0.5868667960166931,
0.5543842911720276,
0.7035043239593506,
1.123116135597229,
0.12611337006092072,
-0.3161766529083252,
0.35639187693595886,
0.09828292578458786,
0.24259017407894135,
-0.09332507103681564,
-0.23112159967422485,
-0.8747453689575195,
-0.7423455119132996,
-0.6624190211296082,
-0.465495765209198,
0.2170444130897522,
-0.852258026599884,
0.3040803372859955,
-0.2958512604236603,
0.06911926716566086,
0.11298245936632156,
-0.36075732111930847,
-0.8769316673278809,
0.07178192585706711,
0.3291712999343872,
0.7627959251403809,
-0.7186456322669983,
0.9008262157440186,
0.43724167346954346,
-0.12306741625070572,
-0.5428916811943054,
0.2115359604358673,
-0.18207202851772308,
-1.015919804573059,
1.023175835609436,
0.5482292771339417,
-0.38028475642204285,
0.16888545453548431,
-0.4134455621242523,
-0.938692569732666,
0.8454907536506653,
0.4839264452457428,
-0.35356688499450684,
-0.2315441220998764,
0.23125296831130981,
0.2776557505130768,
-0.7781419157981873,
0.284959077835083,
0.9595009088516235,
0.2740713059902191,
-0.10244746506214142,
-0.7840541005134583,
0.08022022992372513,
0.3634927272796631,
0.022471442818641663,
0.16445544362068176,
-0.5344546437263489,
0.7240107655525208,
-0.07520969957113266,
-0.3573637008666992,
-0.37445512413978577,
0.8017979264259338,
0.03279481083154678,
-0.03605257347226143,
0.384928435087204,
0.36763447523117065,
0.43598824739456177,
-0.11286286264657974,
1.0832610130310059,
-0.6972638964653015,
0.3362237513065338,
0.9583187103271484,
-0.22419914603233337,
0.7076895236968994,
0.9374868869781494,
-0.1009431779384613,
0.7184910774230957,
0.5144988894462585,
0.5096655488014221,
0.6337108612060547,
0.014267788268625736,
0.04860500991344452,
-0.223184734582901,
-0.2557410001754761,
-0.12346140295267105,
0.5476439595222473,
0.6489065289497375,
-0.4623856842517853,
-0.3098430037498474,
-0.09109057486057281,
-0.006672960706055164,
-0.05617443099617958,
-0.5259403586387634,
0.9836639165878296,
0.12954840064048767,
-0.64615398645401,
0.5343311429023743,
-0.13843178749084473,
0.45478567481040955,
-0.5363191962242126,
-0.06659627705812454,
0.013605938293039799,
0.3452576994895935,
-0.2417425513267517,
-0.6830610632896423,
0.5384190678596497,
-0.23471257090568542,
-0.20459845662117004,
-0.04298869147896767,
0.5621128082275391,
-0.4227668046951294,
-0.2107502520084381,
0.4965532720088959,
0.2998828589916229,
0.10009515285491943,
-0.0910758450627327,
-0.2689647972583771,
0.12308051437139511,
-0.26055875420570374,
-0.32356587052345276,
0.5000662207603455,
0.6536526083946228,
-0.08452513068914413,
0.5103939175605774,
0.33457401394844055,
-0.08218886703252792,
0.1806957721710205,
0.01942809857428074,
0.7207868695259094,
-0.7336151599884033,
-0.4841955900192261,
-0.9654173851013184,
0.361715167760849,
0.002752892440184951,
-0.19780583679676056,
0.8327440619468689,
0.30425262451171875,
1.1961007118225098,
-0.28420963883399963,
0.6632550358772278,
0.1498771458864212,
0.4570383131504059,
-0.6148502826690674,
0.5264276266098022,
-0.29433754086494446,
0.0028716896194964647,
-0.14453954994678497,
-0.9725664854049683,
-0.3484812378883362,
0.6892036199569702,
-0.27159714698791504,
-0.225675567984581,
1.0496306419372559,
0.6706733107566833,
0.0589485839009285,
-0.1360297054052353,
0.23566587269306183,
0.2189636528491974,
-0.14050914347171783,
0.6386939287185669,
0.7515415549278259,
-0.3242705762386322,
0.23865874111652374,
-0.3678502142429352,
-0.0825943872332573,
-0.2158370167016983,
-0.8262578845024109,
-1.2107219696044922,
-0.5444063544273376,
-0.300533652305603,
-0.34501585364341736,
-0.11445029824972153,
1.0733742713928223,
0.3823378086090088,
-0.9004359841346741,
-0.346871942281723,
-0.33785706758499146,
0.30225852131843567,
-0.4140458405017853,
-0.27416130900382996,
0.5335043668746948,
-0.9916826486587524,
-0.894387423992157,
0.11542702466249466,
0.45786190032958984,
-0.26033610105514526,
-0.46018341183662415,
-0.09523655474185944,
0.04090801626443863,
-0.04340851679444313,
0.7946954369544983,
-0.013368502259254456,
-1.0249494314193726,
-0.4332424998283386,
0.012811068445444107,
-0.17934732139110565,
0.11951436847448349,
0.9096687436103821,
-0.9635353088378906,
0.2972394824028015,
0.43520641326904297,
0.838166356086731,
0.2700980305671692,
-0.20417556166648865,
0.592322826385498,
-0.7745137214660645,
0.5771034359931946,
-0.0042732697911560535,
0.5216373801231384,
0.3632768988609314,
-0.31990301609039307,
0.4709746837615967,
0.32148587703704834,
-0.29877567291259766,
-0.8637292385101318,
0.38580644130706787,
-1.0236457586288452,
0.0591200515627861,
1.3524094820022583,
-0.10288508981466293,
-0.6406423449516296,
-0.20545026659965515,
0.0721566304564476,
0.42602577805519104,
0.002763379830867052,
0.5048486590385437,
0.7362938523292542,
-0.2004818469285965,
-0.08541958034038544,
-0.5043542981147766,
0.6812821626663208,
0.22692632675170898,
-0.32031652331352234,
0.3357270359992981,
0.09536726027727127,
0.2532978355884552,
0.14708565175533295,
0.07669471204280853,
-0.26408490538597107,
0.23426614701747894,
-0.13817858695983887,
-0.09471247345209122,
0.1419357806444168,
-0.40847525000572205,
-0.16404475271701813,
0.0801125019788742,
0.2396145612001419,
-0.33183929324150085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13048v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13048v1 | Stable Knowledge Editing in Large Language Models | 2024-02-20T14:36:23 | 2024-02-20T14:36:23 | Zihao Wei, Liang Pang, Hanxing Ding, Jingcheng Deng, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Efficient knowledge editing of large language models is crucial for replacing
obsolete information or incorporating specialized knowledge on a large scale.
However, previous methods implicitly assume that knowledge is localized and
isolated within the model, an assumption that oversimplifies the interconnected
nature of model knowledge. The premise of localization results in an incomplete
knowledge editing, whereas an isolated assumption may impair both other
knowledge and general abilities. It introduces instability to the performance
of the knowledge editing method. To transcend these assumptions, we introduce
StableKE, a method adopts a novel perspective based on knowledge augmentation
rather than knowledge localization. To overcome the expense of human labeling,
StableKE integrates two automated knowledge augmentation strategies: Semantic
Paraphrase Enhancement strategy, which diversifies knowledge descriptions to
facilitate the teaching of new information to the model, and Contextual
Description Enrichment strategy, expanding the surrounding knowledge to prevent
the forgetting of related information. StableKE surpasses other knowledge
editing methods, demonstrating stability both edited knowledge and multi-hop
knowledge, while also preserving unrelated knowledge and general abilities.
Moreover, StableKE can edit knowledge on ChatGPT. | [
-0.0902646854519844,
-1.0558241605758667,
0.5365557074546814,
-0.02086224965751171,
-0.005662221927195787,
0.1681012064218521,
-0.6102510690689087,
-0.49284428358078003,
0.23288805782794952,
0.5610933899879456,
-0.11250310391187668,
-0.6150797009468079,
-0.6044270396232605,
-0.10180796682834625,
-0.25527283549308777,
0.9171647429466248,
-0.09081889688968658,
-0.0452524796128273,
-0.3324144780635834,
-0.3603258430957794,
-0.5134474635124207,
-0.3701189458370209,
-0.686212420463562,
-0.09393217414617538,
0.3616800904273987,
0.4583432376384735,
1.3979012966156006,
0.8873026967048645,
0.3289639353752136,
0.3974546790122986,
-0.5430611968040466,
0.16856525838375092,
-0.5487732887268066,
0.518025279045105,
-0.36688143014907837,
-0.4168452322483063,
-0.754730761051178,
-0.376496285200119,
1.0395077466964722,
0.9016321301460266,
-0.11061481386423111,
-0.24616265296936035,
-0.03640759363770485,
0.5001960396766663,
-0.7396074533462524,
0.14029143750667572,
-0.7150534987449646,
-0.3543156087398529,
-0.18389339745044708,
0.3538207411766052,
-0.33661749958992004,
-0.3124554455280304,
0.22058168053627014,
-0.7867634296417236,
-0.03924978896975517,
-0.4319811761379242,
0.7568098902702332,
0.17676164209842682,
-0.3497387170791626,
0.1087045669555664,
-0.6749621033668518,
0.566561758518219,
-0.9608191847801208,
0.4641304016113281,
0.4582012891769409,
0.08547915518283844,
-0.289117693901062,
-0.6294460892677307,
-0.4310988783836365,
-0.177732914686203,
0.013936353847384453,
0.0051641869358718395,
0.195188969373703,
0.3170336186885834,
0.26014941930770874,
0.20239520072937012,
-0.052677229046821594,
0.06076053902506828,
-0.29962602257728577,
-0.2062825858592987,
0.3488820195198059,
-0.14982688426971436,
0.5717499852180481,
-0.11604386568069458,
-0.07433024793863297,
-0.057035718113183975,
-0.6827302575111389,
0.010047515854239464,
0.2780952751636505,
0.12822824716567993,
0.2728164494037628,
0.6852948069572449,
-0.5191401839256287,
0.8355600833892822,
0.12556453049182892,
-0.23133768141269684,
0.11245892196893692,
-0.13833686709403992,
-0.028380373492836952,
0.15629997849464417,
0.6390342116355896,
0.3357420563697815,
-0.15452556312084198,
-0.3788076937198639,
-0.19965951144695282,
-0.1707015186548233,
0.011881855316460133,
-0.480130672454834,
-0.22601713240146637,
0.014914223924279213,
-0.2374090552330017,
-0.45308876037597656,
0.0742802619934082,
-0.6792572736740112,
-0.5012326836585999,
-0.14437304437160492,
0.5583885908126831,
-0.43804603815078735,
-0.5066993832588196,
0.18264992535114288,
-0.09615110605955124,
-0.1509631723165512,
0.5781850218772888,
-0.8923841714859009,
0.148267924785614,
0.699314534664154,
0.618140459060669,
0.03726305440068245,
-0.47004321217536926,
-0.3864414095878601,
0.6125088930130005,
-0.6012343764305115,
0.5581958293914795,
-0.7792899012565613,
-0.18760059773921967,
-0.1379999816417694,
0.083293117582798,
0.21438917517662048,
-0.26686081290245056,
0.4117310345172882,
-0.8679938912391663,
0.14553724229335785,
-0.38770559430122375,
-0.7390875816345215,
-0.19036129117012024,
0.16838595271110535,
-0.7435599565505981,
1.000433087348938,
0.15415515005588531,
-0.8928806781768799,
0.3873361051082611,
-0.5657673478126526,
-0.5450766682624817,
-0.09367454797029495,
0.3391280770301819,
-0.2778647840023041,
0.06990056484937668,
0.2235029935836792,
0.3648114502429962,
0.16890637576580048,
0.5693413019180298,
-0.5022673606872559,
0.006223124917596579,
-0.006329239346086979,
-0.15405385196208954,
0.5485783219337463,
-0.018050655722618103,
-0.18213321268558502,
0.26526781916618347,
-0.6832566857337952,
-0.11118076741695404,
-0.12797917425632477,
-0.48786574602127075,
-0.7052145004272461,
0.08650834858417511,
-0.31349289417266846,
0.05293271318078041,
0.3985918462276459,
-0.4517860412597656,
0.6175788044929504,
-0.5076673626899719,
0.42390599846839905,
0.5972375273704529,
0.3138425350189209,
0.8719576001167297,
-0.08353639394044876,
0.4264160990715027,
-0.10287754237651825,
0.1554899960756302,
-0.12602965533733368,
-0.5652409791946411,
-0.7020846009254456,
-0.0049361251294612885,
0.6129869818687439,
0.5269001722335815,
-0.8460325598716736,
0.20975685119628906,
-0.42775532603263855,
-0.4102782607078552,
-0.37288516759872437,
0.3862146735191345,
0.11821695417165756,
0.7762054204940796,
0.39896926283836365,
0.06269801408052444,
-0.34028637409210205,
-0.9238433837890625,
-0.3548209071159363,
-0.10163407772779465,
0.13797050714492798,
-0.5154255628585815,
0.09018004685640335,
-0.4381865859031677,
0.8524972200393677,
-0.3450619876384735,
0.08311082422733307,
-0.26443660259246826,
0.05555710941553116,
0.04841014742851257,
0.6276949644088745,
0.35605818033218384,
-0.6565501689910889,
-0.4383693337440491,
0.30623626708984375,
-0.7523069977760315,
0.04595975950360298,
-0.20252442359924316,
-0.35224449634552,
0.11266173422336578,
0.5679290890693665,
-0.8857492804527283,
0.16133303940296173,
0.4321952760219574,
-0.32292839884757996,
0.25759851932525635,
-0.2664664685726166,
0.37500444054603577,
-1.265628695487976,
-0.1478937417268753,
-0.2960263192653656,
-0.502758264541626,
-0.6814538836479187,
0.16134025156497955,
0.40761715173721313,
-0.10241636633872986,
-0.19955699145793915,
0.5002357363700867,
-0.5761262774467468,
0.36413246393203735,
-0.20123973488807678,
0.4815537631511688,
0.040083181113004684,
0.05941271409392357,
0.1530713587999344,
0.39051589369773865,
0.6364064812660217,
-0.15480388700962067,
0.19886547327041626,
0.4059963822364807,
-0.39603906869888306,
0.004004471469670534,
-0.39325615763664246,
0.15175066888332367,
-0.2576715052127838,
0.10692153871059418,
-0.7311698794364929,
-0.49706265330314636,
0.048393331468105316,
-0.34442418813705444,
0.4804084300994873,
-0.3087429106235504,
-0.44178375601768494,
0.15809756517410278,
-0.31613343954086304,
0.2818801999092102,
0.430421382188797,
-0.2626826763153076,
0.5633333921432495,
0.6537620425224304,
-0.47777771949768066,
-0.7306793332099915,
-0.5135065913200378,
0.41672283411026,
-0.15974058210849762,
-0.917400062084198,
0.17100271582603455,
0.17746633291244507,
-0.47817137837409973,
0.22332367300987244,
-0.17997854948043823,
-0.30549225211143494,
0.1166611760854721,
-0.21090805530548096,
0.26354268193244934,
-0.2026444673538208,
0.3815349042415619,
0.588275671005249,
-0.18526893854141235,
-0.27542778849601746,
-0.3012421429157257,
-0.007271583657711744,
-0.13694338500499725,
-0.0021627130918204784,
-0.35461723804473877,
0.36568427085876465,
0.9364507794380188,
-0.38172096014022827,
1.047743320465088,
0.368149995803833,
-0.6306495666503906,
0.018634093925356865,
-0.7490355968475342,
-0.1170223280787468,
-0.4394051432609558,
0.5544372797012329,
-0.35149121284484863,
-0.9282096028327942,
0.6846761703491211,
-0.16266171634197235,
0.3321308195590973,
0.6990247368812561,
0.2978421747684479,
0.14183731377124786,
1.0424604415893555,
0.6249266862869263,
-0.0884578749537468,
0.424217164516449,
0.032662343233823776,
0.21808142960071564,
-0.6263521909713745,
0.02887585572898388,
-0.27873802185058594,
-0.18812648952007294,
-0.2883826196193695,
-0.2537163197994232,
0.23706012964248657,
0.8354395627975464,
-0.05712530016899109,
0.3118281066417694,
-0.36696019768714905,
0.6682437062263489,
0.27945825457572937,
0.30628302693367004,
0.4326518476009369,
-0.299306720495224,
-0.09310894459486008,
-0.2108357548713684,
-0.9772334694862366,
-0.4484417736530304,
0.9894700050354004,
0.30025002360343933,
0.6928914189338684,
0.25932177901268005,
0.5081564784049988,
0.1662447601556778,
0.274831086397171,
-0.5198454856872559,
0.4538264870643616,
-0.021833421662449837,
-0.540471076965332,
-0.6525168418884277,
-0.37635672092437744,
-0.5767818093299866,
0.04433364048600197,
-0.5470766425132751,
-0.6140331625938416,
0.20270352065563202,
0.4717811048030853,
-0.2952476143836975,
0.4766835868358612,
-0.8673921823501587,
1.121394157409668,
-0.1353973150253296,
-0.5005092024803162,
-0.307515025138855,
-0.8194905519485474,
0.3735359311103821,
-0.2366279512643814,
0.4724266827106476,
0.004386701621115208,
-0.15931035578250885,
0.6535782814025879,
-0.591791033744812,
0.7089391350746155,
-0.2500792145729065,
-0.02102324739098549,
0.22604870796203613,
0.44764700531959534,
0.8948747515678406,
0.27679210901260376,
-0.37163856625556946,
-0.0377715565264225,
0.10817515850067139,
-0.45426395535469055,
-0.8964486122131348,
0.7305971384048462,
-0.7061042785644531,
-0.7239952683448792,
0.03635374829173088,
-0.6435795426368713,
-0.45080485939979553,
0.37503665685653687,
-0.017241744324564934,
0.39242368936538696,
0.181850403547287,
0.45627906918525696,
0.6824979782104492,
-0.21151621639728546,
0.022022884339094162,
0.13590778410434723,
-0.2534959316253662,
-0.6349272727966309,
0.6583008766174316,
0.3335561156272888,
0.6679434776306152,
0.4120957851409912,
0.4227137267589569,
-0.14454859495162964,
-0.5777615308761597,
-0.310362309217453,
0.037762075662612915,
-1.220115065574646,
-0.0588831789791584,
-0.7785593867301941,
-0.038315847516059875,
-0.4411153197288513,
-0.46183907985687256,
-0.6468053460121155,
-0.8514022827148438,
0.17704583704471588,
-0.2660317122936249,
0.5848573446273804,
0.6443931460380554,
-0.2458658665418625,
0.29562610387802124,
-0.9915457367897034,
0.39252063632011414,
0.29323309659957886,
0.2201095074415207,
-0.1901460587978363,
-0.32379212975502014,
-0.5601075887680054,
0.1395847052335739,
0.16449826955795288,
-1.052980661392212,
-0.03855520859360695,
0.2298118770122528,
0.6739421486854553,
0.42621082067489624,
0.228192538022995,
0.8597500324249268,
-0.244746595621109,
0.7027850151062012,
0.03968193754553795,
-1.1083476543426514,
0.6660403609275818,
-0.7253721952438354,
0.5106092691421509,
0.8025245666503906,
-0.00827260036021471,
-0.6300883889198303,
-0.8244361877441406,
-0.577379047870636,
-1.0695692300796509,
0.5109584331512451,
-0.09290605783462524,
0.2569481134414673,
-0.13129937648773193,
0.7243926525115967,
0.19904159009456635,
0.2873329520225525,
-0.769183337688446,
0.16279293596744537,
-0.17079216241836548,
-0.24077370762825012,
0.25968214869499207,
-0.385879248380661,
-0.016049757599830627,
-0.5613760948181152,
0.9450441598892212,
0.12067025154829025,
-0.16717001795768738,
0.08880636841058731,
-0.38039442896842957,
-0.21589896082878113,
0.2545646131038666,
0.576123058795929,
1.000091552734375,
-0.03910970687866211,
0.2904883623123169,
0.4849211871623993,
-0.3635859489440918,
-0.05236992985010147,
-0.17649056017398834,
-0.5152983069419861,
-0.08888811618089676,
0.4949379563331604,
0.7179815769195557,
0.6092275977134705,
-0.38312721252441406,
0.2902374565601349,
0.15758579969406128,
-0.08501921594142914,
0.18873365223407745,
0.12239217013120651,
0.247407928109169,
0.20204073190689087,
-0.07056570798158646,
0.5400726199150085,
-0.18559804558753967,
-0.3010224997997284,
0.18806684017181396,
0.07970502972602844,
-0.13196754455566406,
-0.18801477551460266,
0.869234561920166,
0.07760998606681824,
-0.10988327860832214,
0.5527616739273071,
0.11288931965827942,
-0.4659261405467987,
0.10580676048994064,
0.3851831257343292,
0.8558447360992432,
-0.44353222846984863,
0.12116096168756485,
0.4002271294593811,
0.41276147961616516,
-0.4525580406188965,
-0.1288272589445114,
-0.05158397927880287,
-0.8066199421882629,
-0.7407706379890442,
-0.3937923312187195,
-0.42763379216194153,
0.04461505636572838,
-0.4023263156414032,
0.38950851559638977,
-0.5595482587814331,
-0.13772590458393097,
-0.22347767651081085,
-0.5000683665275574,
-0.07316190004348755,
-0.02044103667140007,
-0.26845377683639526,
0.7439182996749878,
-0.692162275314331,
1.0235519409179688,
0.9775329232215881,
-0.22846901416778564,
-0.7414166331291199,
0.10856492072343826,
-0.1766945719718933,
-0.29251226782798767,
0.32903313636779785,
-0.14398826658725739,
-0.070710688829422,
-0.011329109780490398,
-0.3944648802280426,
-1.075918436050415,
0.7601160407066345,
0.6881222724914551,
-0.5359867215156555,
-0.0033581447787582874,
-0.31532374024391174,
0.42774006724357605,
0.08353669196367264,
-0.17186519503593445,
0.32748866081237793,
0.688748300075531,
0.07200394570827484,
-0.8402488231658936,
-0.04358576983213425,
-0.19353832304477692,
-0.06867460161447525,
0.34242966771125793,
-0.5061957240104675,
0.6385732889175415,
0.02681855484843254,
0.03434700518846512,
-0.07949581742286682,
0.6153639554977417,
-0.1899653673171997,
-0.33775171637535095,
0.5165461897850037,
0.7095184326171875,
0.7497906684875488,
0.005444721318781376,
0.7506950497627258,
-0.5304709076881409,
0.4342317283153534,
1.1734869480133057,
-0.08062069118022919,
0.9002703428268433,
0.22557656466960907,
0.14546655118465424,
0.31951209902763367,
0.6790733933448792,
0.2489626556634903,
0.4692245125770569,
-0.4089854955673218,
-0.5090330839157104,
-0.5899292230606079,
0.4212683439254761,
-0.24205288290977478,
0.33107230067253113,
0.1957220882177353,
-0.05814862996339798,
-0.26665690541267395,
0.1514376401901245,
0.4958564043045044,
0.15589706599712372,
-0.35216227173805237,
0.8012802004814148,
-0.27199962735176086,
-0.7988036274909973,
0.5455382466316223,
0.33140653371810913,
0.16400833427906036,
-0.7717028260231018,
-0.08621440827846527,
0.11749761551618576,
0.259755402803421,
-0.23899729549884796,
-0.7711918354034424,
0.5959081649780273,
-0.23352737724781036,
-0.27484822273254395,
-0.27927881479263306,
1.0803442001342773,
-0.6518774628639221,
-0.5637888312339783,
0.23566564917564392,
0.3185994327068329,
-0.17235352098941803,
-0.046605926007032394,
-0.5501213073730469,
0.06696967035531998,
-0.026365965604782104,
-0.41293981671333313,
0.16267380118370056,
0.6309586763381958,
-0.33327022194862366,
0.5114848613739014,
0.5348244309425354,
0.26896676421165466,
0.20668210089206696,
-0.12587372958660126,
0.9060260057449341,
-0.39978888630867004,
-0.570767879486084,
-0.8452064990997314,
0.9519468545913696,
-0.27414822578430176,
-0.10299541801214218,
0.845647394657135,
0.41039833426475525,
0.6614155769348145,
-0.0875086858868599,
0.9998109340667725,
-0.0987539291381836,
0.27663758397102356,
-0.5905806422233582,
0.9806592464447021,
-0.36068403720855713,
0.25780609250068665,
-0.5169923901557922,
-1.1465184688568115,
-0.6396142244338989,
0.7395246624946594,
-0.6452111601829529,
-0.19288361072540283,
0.5484175682067871,
0.5686955451965332,
-0.009993539191782475,
-0.13247714936733246,
0.40757253766059875,
0.6022422313690186,
0.004595722071826458,
0.04833577573299408,
0.7795791625976562,
-0.24351727962493896,
0.38312697410583496,
-0.33933135867118835,
-0.3603689968585968,
0.19507215917110443,
-0.7508822083473206,
-0.7237063646316528,
-0.44173261523246765,
-0.4873892068862915,
-0.29882028698921204,
0.23531267046928406,
0.7631276249885559,
0.6804933547973633,
-0.6912035346031189,
0.03351550176739693,
-0.15163639187812805,
0.37311601638793945,
-0.13685500621795654,
-0.2148638814687729,
0.4316348731517792,
-0.5636995434761047,
-0.6421886086463928,
0.5715256333351135,
0.45051825046539307,
-0.16107310354709625,
-0.0873812884092331,
-0.01797015406191349,
-0.29843080043792725,
-0.2448035031557083,
0.571918249130249,
0.1699233502149582,
-0.4743068516254425,
-0.4616854190826416,
-0.1384635865688324,
0.22245894372463226,
0.05966927111148834,
0.42849430441856384,
-0.5188384056091309,
1.0035394430160522,
0.6222440004348755,
0.8757163286209106,
0.34533989429473877,
0.12072456628084183,
0.8347654342651367,
-0.5130388736724854,
0.36188805103302,
0.06521926820278168,
0.40628090500831604,
0.35330551862716675,
-0.45098939538002014,
0.12350129336118698,
0.32419395446777344,
-0.6414439678192139,
-0.6196196675300598,
0.16708628833293915,
-0.827650785446167,
-0.22971399128437042,
1.1364374160766602,
-0.31528812646865845,
-0.17573414742946625,
-0.1338093876838684,
-0.3343459963798523,
0.36345601081848145,
-0.20448079705238342,
0.7204464673995972,
1.0109219551086426,
0.15617585182189941,
-0.2896081507205963,
-0.8022404313087463,
0.45258772373199463,
0.2578376829624176,
-0.7438663840293884,
0.16994069516658783,
0.6758131980895996,
0.390656054019928,
-0.006624266039580107,
0.37674596905708313,
-0.25830551981925964,
0.22654591500759125,
-0.008858732879161835,
0.16023463010787964,
-0.04037981480360031,
-0.15413342416286469,
-0.05202023312449455,
0.28175702691078186,
0.36374369263648987,
0.10656774044036865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13043v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13043v3 | Effective and Efficient Conversation Retrieval for Dialogue State Tracking with Implicit Text Summaries | 2024-02-20T14:31:17 | 2024-04-02T20:06:52 | Seanie Lee, Jianpeng Cheng, Joris Driesen, Alexandru Coca, Anders Johannsen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Few-shot dialogue state tracking (DST) with Large Language Models (LLM)
relies on an effective and efficient conversation retriever to find similar
in-context examples for prompt learning. Previous works use raw dialogue
context as search keys and queries, and a retriever is fine-tuned with
annotated dialogues to achieve superior performance. However, the approach is
less suited for scaling to new domains or new annotation languages, where
fine-tuning data is unavailable. To address this problem, we handle the task of
conversation retrieval based on text summaries of the conversations. A
LLM-based conversation summarizer is adopted for query and key generation,
which enables effective maximum inner product search. To avoid the extra
inference cost brought by LLM-based conversation summarization, we further
distill a light-weight conversation encoder which produces query embeddings
without decoding summaries for test conversations. We validate our retrieval
approach on MultiWOZ datasets with GPT-Neo-2.7B and LLaMA-7B/30B. The
experimental results show a significant improvement over relevant baselines in
real few-shot DST settings. | [
-0.24437540769577026,
-0.8485228419303894,
0.67537921667099,
-0.0870194286108017,
-0.6310180425643921,
0.20828689634799957,
-0.13264934718608856,
-0.32164281606674194,
0.285857230424881,
0.5189472436904907,
-0.6988270282745361,
-0.7049735188484192,
-0.4627246558666229,
0.1395624428987503,
-0.3061254322528839,
1.1275169849395752,
0.2763187289237976,
-0.1279422789812088,
-0.02866276167333126,
-0.267556756734848,
-0.08543282747268677,
-0.5490854382514954,
-0.5807499289512634,
-0.3038215935230255,
0.34745481610298157,
0.2686939537525177,
0.30226829648017883,
0.1596706658601761,
0.3937053382396698,
0.2274477630853653,
-0.6031410098075867,
0.437137246131897,
-0.8906540274620056,
0.49113568663597107,
0.34089258313179016,
-0.3594209551811218,
-0.2915388345718384,
-0.30707085132598877,
0.5155227780342102,
0.4513992369174957,
-0.19825507700443268,
-0.08316193521022797,
0.052585531026124954,
0.46618205308914185,
-0.6167038083076477,
0.46364825963974,
-0.882537305355072,
0.034922078251838684,
-0.004453093744814396,
-0.41926059126853943,
-0.346171498298645,
-0.5204855799674988,
0.4077734053134918,
-0.3549722135066986,
0.14887776970863342,
-0.04274255409836769,
0.4155149459838867,
0.1781856268644333,
-0.7351511716842651,
-0.3875263035297394,
-0.6111069917678833,
0.6598156690597534,
-0.8444388508796692,
0.21935850381851196,
0.3713739216327667,
0.2661714255809784,
-0.30872786045074463,
-0.6653465032577515,
-0.46077463030815125,
-0.15997770428657532,
-0.21902574598789215,
0.3016107976436615,
-0.222096249461174,
0.4143795967102051,
0.35274600982666016,
0.4144045114517212,
-0.36099115014076233,
-0.1398320347070694,
-0.20125381648540497,
-0.2735311985015869,
0.4640258550643921,
0.5715383291244507,
-0.01782383769750595,
-0.26643162965774536,
-0.14323848485946655,
0.07053457200527191,
-0.8141805529594421,
-0.06218501552939415,
0.20015236735343933,
0.4909211993217468,
-0.024791229516267776,
0.6156045794487,
-0.6770424246788025,
0.6155750155448914,
-0.09438807517290115,
-0.42473092675209045,
-0.039526309818029404,
-0.83182293176651,
0.054374828934669495,
0.05036156252026558,
0.7458412051200867,
0.4854721128940582,
-0.08091971278190613,
-0.09966710954904556,
-0.15696562826633453,
-0.24127838015556335,
-0.0762488842010498,
-1.139963150024414,
-0.07983114570379257,
-0.08366190642118454,
-0.20262111723423004,
0.06675732135772705,
-0.14262408018112183,
-0.5857725143432617,
-0.20622748136520386,
-0.060365229845047,
0.15121948719024658,
-0.22759109735488892,
-0.028238916769623756,
-0.15814979374408722,
-0.18648189306259155,
0.4419473707675934,
0.5147107243537903,
-0.9387373328208923,
0.37817317247390747,
0.7036895155906677,
0.9790366291999817,
-0.09001042693853378,
0.40858736634254456,
-0.4544600546360016,
0.00025433074915781617,
-0.4038641154766083,
0.7085587382316589,
-0.45792829990386963,
-0.6531310677528381,
0.05359313637018204,
-0.1102135181427002,
-0.018728476017713547,
-0.3190996050834656,
0.40440428256988525,
-0.580374002456665,
0.2160097360610962,
-0.31727710366249084,
-0.7308517694473267,
-0.1504991203546524,
0.530798077583313,
-0.30069756507873535,
0.8636655211448669,
-0.25049301981925964,
-0.5765561461448669,
0.11105939000844955,
-0.4529878497123718,
-0.404044508934021,
0.04687751084566116,
-0.44693344831466675,
-0.29877832531929016,
0.15787367522716522,
0.3727104961872101,
0.34124812483787537,
-0.1913316547870636,
-0.044793952256441116,
-0.10770626366138458,
-0.7614224553108215,
-0.03556361794471741,
-0.62020343542099,
0.46293511986732483,
-0.030100185424089432,
-0.12246529757976532,
-0.17718897759914398,
-0.4751589298248291,
-0.041617680341005325,
0.13399912416934967,
-0.24539567530155182,
-0.36976805329322815,
0.1390831619501114,
-0.20978878438472748,
0.03874959424138069,
0.1355389803647995,
-0.7210955619812012,
0.314256876707077,
-0.4852464199066162,
0.21525835990905762,
0.4094547927379608,
0.46722322702407837,
0.32099053263664246,
-0.02452748641371727,
0.403947651386261,
-0.03864283859729767,
-0.02045425772666931,
-0.6737533807754517,
-0.5107494592666626,
-0.6885403990745544,
-0.2801080346107483,
-0.17916393280029297,
0.4547443091869354,
-0.7040150165557861,
0.19855833053588867,
-0.3494376540184021,
-0.3781152367591858,
-0.47463130950927734,
0.09916746616363525,
0.5625324249267578,
0.6109177470207214,
0.29518061876296997,
-0.17375688254833221,
-0.22505512833595276,
-0.8402685523033142,
-0.17723923921585083,
-0.21629689633846283,
-0.1015140563249588,
0.6715043783187866,
0.45414862036705017,
0.02054772898554802,
1.045867681503296,
-0.9581449627876282,
-0.3538810908794403,
-0.5757901072502136,
0.22695805132389069,
0.23280906677246094,
0.13892917335033417,
0.35141658782958984,
-0.7145736813545227,
-0.566376805305481,
-0.24988968670368195,
-0.5704797506332397,
0.07716037333011627,
0.026366736739873886,
-0.011401792988181114,
0.19298557937145233,
0.4081283211708069,
-0.7581180930137634,
0.5183846950531006,
0.19639979302883148,
-0.08494564145803452,
0.1234053373336792,
0.05739631876349449,
0.307733952999115,
-1.2397888898849487,
-0.10025054216384888,
-0.12292609363794327,
-0.43982046842575073,
-0.6264460682868958,
-0.3779677152633667,
0.034092143177986145,
-0.029381586238741875,
-0.47562968730926514,
0.473871111869812,
-0.3423335552215576,
-0.13825877010822296,
-0.3090207278728485,
0.5228481292724609,
-0.008467826060950756,
0.7134567499160767,
0.03738589584827423,
1.0561034679412842,
0.16155001521110535,
-0.6641266345977783,
0.20115025341510773,
0.697658896446228,
-0.32337769865989685,
0.6164491176605225,
-0.6984283924102783,
0.6346727609634399,
-0.2810676693916321,
0.6974613666534424,
-1.0604342222213745,
0.07999128848314285,
0.15691053867340088,
-0.29447096586227417,
0.19014082849025726,
-0.716058075428009,
-0.5511981844902039,
0.042818695306777954,
-0.4579058885574341,
0.08041511476039886,
0.45405179262161255,
-0.5594721436500549,
0.3857322335243225,
0.3338634669780731,
-0.3694058358669281,
-0.5121338963508606,
-0.4199375808238983,
0.15059232711791992,
-0.13990330696105957,
-0.32601287961006165,
0.26822906732559204,
-0.12387169897556305,
-0.02007765881717205,
-0.3695908188819885,
-0.6408950090408325,
-0.07553315162658691,
0.0816572979092598,
-0.06579452753067017,
0.237064391374588,
-0.17742139101028442,
-0.01169888861477375,
0.09084749966859818,
-0.18878386914730072,
-0.08163311332464218,
-0.03995763882994652,
0.534778356552124,
-0.07028663903474808,
-0.332629531621933,
-0.39395901560783386,
0.42811310291290283,
0.35150060057640076,
-0.04468342289328575,
0.598567008972168,
0.45298588275909424,
-0.21403159201145172,
-0.007920440286397934,
-0.5386670231819153,
-0.5211555361747742,
-0.4298899471759796,
0.4732898473739624,
-0.4398155212402344,
-1.1240696907043457,
0.47869226336479187,
-0.10436394065618515,
0.27710476517677307,
0.17266643047332764,
0.24998608231544495,
-0.29139694571495056,
1.2926360368728638,
0.5055661797523499,
-0.18181557953357697,
0.6458300948143005,
-0.2292906641960144,
0.21909599006175995,
-1.1031131744384766,
-0.3002980053424835,
-0.5055935382843018,
-0.05360189080238342,
-0.5466280579566956,
-0.07639599591493607,
0.6674026250839233,
-0.08161194622516632,
0.07017170637845993,
0.39161261916160583,
-0.03985893353819847,
0.6756571531295776,
0.4361208379268646,
0.19488202035427094,
0.7473186254501343,
-0.12851771712303162,
0.13870728015899658,
-0.21329614520072937,
-0.5378457903862,
-0.4145643413066864,
1.0065239667892456,
-0.11091223359107971,
0.9653870463371277,
0.319265753030777,
0.740066409111023,
-0.02526867389678955,
-0.010764194652438164,
-0.8627589344978333,
0.6218359470367432,
-0.11735473573207855,
-0.4494580328464508,
-0.11681909114122391,
-0.7419853210449219,
-0.8139154314994812,
0.658782422542572,
-0.16473355889320374,
-1.0162841081619263,
-0.229092538356781,
0.08622980862855911,
-0.3976912796497345,
0.024665270000696182,
-0.5168002247810364,
0.7326887845993042,
-0.06558365374803543,
-0.1023186519742012,
-0.4374240040779114,
-0.6457555890083313,
0.433857262134552,
0.11118536442518234,
-0.4473070502281189,
-0.4110442101955414,
0.05256939306855202,
0.5600585341453552,
-0.2789194881916046,
0.864176332950592,
-0.08033500611782074,
-0.08394435793161392,
0.26426899433135986,
-0.0044228509068489075,
0.6604511141777039,
0.11226700246334076,
0.1995421051979065,
-0.06856825947761536,
0.010836653411388397,
-0.16408176720142365,
-0.8807805180549622,
0.5580928325653076,
-0.3766261339187622,
-0.6103090047836304,
-0.2930408716201782,
-0.323369562625885,
-0.33020228147506714,
0.06337718665599823,
0.2749900817871094,
0.7228082418441772,
-0.39738568663597107,
0.49670034646987915,
0.8259652256965637,
-0.13395917415618896,
0.5024240016937256,
0.795782208442688,
0.023166876286268234,
-0.22567592561244965,
0.5600301027297974,
-0.024970488622784615,
0.3828262984752655,
0.5327396392822266,
0.060834549367427826,
-0.5233711004257202,
-0.49256277084350586,
-0.3930386006832123,
0.04152102395892143,
-0.6743904948234558,
-0.5133018493652344,
-0.9271791577339172,
-0.15036901831626892,
-0.3935706615447998,
0.2109311819076538,
-0.4251851439476013,
-0.4051632881164551,
-0.23954975605010986,
-0.18514136970043182,
0.5494933128356934,
0.6112130880355835,
0.5359218120574951,
0.5186823606491089,
-0.7547560930252075,
0.4735606014728546,
0.3211652934551239,
0.22855742275714874,
-0.30012333393096924,
-0.5683541297912598,
-0.2172163426876068,
0.13141155242919922,
-0.42552030086517334,
-0.827783465385437,
0.26173877716064453,
0.43399444222450256,
0.5560530424118042,
0.2138020545244217,
0.3787726163864136,
0.8581691384315491,
-0.2752886116504669,
0.8426735401153564,
0.016666650772094727,
-0.7865458726882935,
0.8058913946151733,
-0.22804057598114014,
0.5711190104484558,
0.6895900964736938,
0.20888517796993256,
-0.6588219404220581,
-0.4709646701812744,
-0.42641356587409973,
-1.0244722366333008,
0.9973182082176208,
0.37203896045684814,
0.44890719652175903,
-0.07378630340099335,
0.21532578766345978,
-0.05081895738840103,
0.34548789262771606,
-0.21819698810577393,
-0.3072560131549835,
0.12107942253351212,
-0.30395033955574036,
-0.1019318699836731,
-0.27871617674827576,
-0.13680271804332733,
0.028917096555233,
0.5981038212776184,
-0.4579158425331116,
0.23893225193023682,
0.24641838669776917,
-0.3662619888782501,
0.25795814394950867,
0.46052640676498413,
0.4149647057056427,
0.355705589056015,
-0.39921441674232483,
-0.001353533356450498,
0.3809087574481964,
-0.37028804421424866,
-0.08970216661691666,
0.2665707767009735,
-0.3777603209018707,
0.13977424800395966,
0.1487048864364624,
0.8402071595191956,
0.5009917616844177,
-0.6918289661407471,
0.6595683097839355,
-0.33505821228027344,
0.12748974561691284,
-0.2172187715768814,
0.14429694414138794,
-0.08959903568029404,
0.4062916040420532,
0.4765753746032715,
-0.3417856991291046,
0.4984544813632965,
-0.4687720835208893,
0.14980840682983398,
0.591465413570404,
-0.3334343135356903,
-0.20241379737854004,
0.4115973114967346,
0.3598734736442566,
-0.02823573164641857,
0.9055454134941101,
-0.12937697768211365,
-0.5027880668640137,
0.3910213112831116,
0.6084485054016113,
0.950937807559967,
0.20561136305332184,
0.13438163697719574,
0.3372243642807007,
0.14983101189136505,
-0.13252165913581848,
0.09414367377758026,
-0.6251424551010132,
-0.6155917644500732,
-0.4638679027557373,
-0.2104347050189972,
-0.8318799734115601,
-0.07378188520669937,
-0.5844546556472778,
-0.016888301819562912,
-0.13335281610488892,
-0.18947412073612213,
-0.3816536068916321,
0.23729966580867767,
-0.45446711778640747,
-0.2476169615983963,
0.2427307516336441,
0.6795417070388794,
-0.557154655456543,
0.5937570333480835,
0.2252083122730255,
-0.39164942502975464,
-0.2967146337032318,
0.06324519217014313,
0.34062278270721436,
-0.6206042766571045,
0.25253307819366455,
0.23572371900081635,
-0.4592284560203552,
0.11489011347293854,
-0.5445998311042786,
-0.7497204542160034,
1.2361420392990112,
0.4598894715309143,
-0.5802125930786133,
0.03667385131120682,
-0.058715853840112686,
0.5991854667663574,
-0.19668234884738922,
0.7070483565330505,
0.6480535864830017,
-0.07369215786457062,
0.38611721992492676,
-0.8288933038711548,
-0.15797683596611023,
-0.040183231234550476,
-0.031831178814172745,
0.3239538371562958,
-0.802207887172699,
0.29866015911102295,
-0.09719488769769669,
-0.35582995414733887,
0.15382832288742065,
0.6574072241783142,
0.29929864406585693,
0.35339051485061646,
0.24441742897033691,
0.2895280420780182,
0.5623687505722046,
-0.3256237506866455,
0.977519154548645,
-0.16950219869613647,
0.3106381595134735,
1.3382686376571655,
-0.1548270732164383,
0.7941209077835083,
0.3218591511249542,
0.02832654118537903,
0.16253212094306946,
0.4755752980709076,
0.39222750067710876,
0.6536051630973816,
0.0024886270985007286,
-0.46291354298591614,
-0.15287038683891296,
-0.23476725816726685,
-0.147372305393219,
0.5020045042037964,
0.4351648688316345,
-0.14251598715782166,
-0.30301785469055176,
-0.3034399747848511,
0.23534168303012848,
-0.1712382286787033,
0.0010948756244033575,
1.4352744817733765,
0.2607536315917969,
-0.5629356503486633,
0.25873667001724243,
-0.3157406747341156,
0.7808560729026794,
-0.8155487179756165,
-0.2230193018913269,
-0.8355374932289124,
0.06939505785703659,
-0.043899230659008026,
-0.5133745074272156,
0.11858372390270233,
0.2135513424873352,
0.23915249109268188,
-0.23204638063907623,
0.5433350801467896,
-0.7563014626502991,
-0.1724880337715149,
0.10646643489599228,
0.5836688876152039,
0.28612980246543884,
-0.18634118139743805,
-0.447598934173584,
0.01382417418062687,
-0.006298310589045286,
-0.44729694724082947,
0.225104421377182,
0.34448927640914917,
0.11432833224534988,
0.6121799349784851,
0.5161791443824768,
-0.16150039434432983,
-0.04716653376817703,
0.2771013081073761,
0.9647921919822693,
-0.8058452010154724,
-0.4742155075073242,
-0.7436664700508118,
0.2707887887954712,
-0.17476880550384521,
-0.3960482180118561,
0.6560635566711426,
0.7667155265808105,
0.610561728477478,
0.3647959530353546,
0.640251636505127,
0.16684575378894806,
0.4791383147239685,
-0.6820729970932007,
0.39590418338775635,
-0.3425339460372925,
0.4987773597240448,
-0.37867650389671326,
-1.0669220685958862,
-0.043616678565740585,
0.6676995158195496,
0.0258625615388155,
-0.13255919516086578,
0.4377407729625702,
0.8856254816055298,
-0.029391901567578316,
0.28432583808898926,
0.21430836617946625,
0.18726156651973724,
0.5731973648071289,
0.5005316138267517,
0.9657872915267944,
-0.49977317452430725,
0.8541334271430969,
-0.08122219890356064,
0.034694332629442215,
-0.25395292043685913,
-0.6591880321502686,
-0.8128923773765564,
-0.40880265831947327,
-0.33834466338157654,
-0.12222262471914291,
0.154927596449852,
1.0960578918457031,
0.7284665107727051,
-0.5236108303070068,
-0.085658960044384,
0.1251186579465866,
0.09901633113622665,
-0.023831455036997795,
-0.17244713008403778,
0.20727233588695526,
-0.5034720301628113,
-0.9532745480537415,
0.8262032866477966,
0.31280943751335144,
0.21122153103351593,
-0.03768157958984375,
-0.06285391747951508,
0.0026896081399172544,
-0.027930650860071182,
0.7571229934692383,
0.20193317532539368,
-0.5944313406944275,
-0.18825659155845642,
0.07785903662443161,
-0.22995062172412872,
0.10786871612071991,
0.9092124700546265,
-0.7152202129364014,
0.49380749464035034,
0.4590446949005127,
0.6804381608963013,
1.1719197034835815,
0.12590552866458893,
0.6068136096000671,
-1.066249966621399,
0.13389666378498077,
0.3818443715572357,
0.22327566146850586,
0.4299626350402832,
-0.24188469350337982,
0.5285328030586243,
0.10452007502317429,
-0.34969618916511536,
-0.5511268377304077,
0.17793568968772888,
-0.9508194923400879,
0.06418101489543915,
1.082636833190918,
-0.2052803933620453,
0.19640196859836578,
-0.17679037153720856,
-0.35060349106788635,
0.2001350075006485,
-0.7848860621452332,
0.676966667175293,
0.3986087441444397,
-0.40124452114105225,
-0.3609951436519623,
-0.44684791564941406,
0.51554936170578,
0.24263979494571686,
-0.7676546573638916,
0.1534731537103653,
0.6326663494110107,
-0.0003862412995658815,
-0.13626320660114288,
1.0486973524093628,
-0.06263776868581772,
-0.16393087804317474,
-0.08001811057329178,
-0.4526267647743225,
0.10184936225414276,
-0.09699220955371857,
-0.27634406089782715,
-0.10521737486124039,
-0.19227294623851776,
-0.2792103886604309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13040v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13040v1 | Text-Guided Molecule Generation with Diffusion Language Model | 2024-02-20T14:29:02 | 2024-02-20T14:29:02 | Haisong Gong, Qiang Liu, Shu Wu, Liang Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, q-bio.BM | Text-guided molecule generation is a task where molecules are generated to
match specific textual descriptions. Recently, most existing SMILES-based
molecule generation methods rely on an autoregressive architecture. In this
work, we propose the Text-Guided Molecule Generation with Diffusion Language
Model (TGM-DLM), a novel approach that leverages diffusion models to address
the limitations of autoregressive methods. TGM-DLM updates token embeddings
within the SMILES string collectively and iteratively, using a two-phase
diffusion generation process. The first phase optimizes embeddings from random
noise, guided by the text description, while the second phase corrects invalid
SMILES strings to form valid molecular representations. We demonstrate that
TGM-DLM outperforms MolT5-Base, an autoregressive model, without the need for
additional data resources. Our findings underscore the remarkable effectiveness
of TGM-DLM in generating coherent and precise molecules with specific
properties, opening new avenues in drug discovery and related scientific
domains. Code will be released at: https://github.com/Deno-V/tgm-dlm. | [
-0.02026633359491825,
-0.9124055504798889,
0.7215725779533386,
0.03955862671136856,
-0.4382265508174896,
0.20847195386886597,
-0.11829115450382233,
-0.10335229337215424,
0.00600125826895237,
0.49120351672172546,
-0.5174906849861145,
-0.9836905002593994,
-0.76580810546875,
0.05446571484208107,
-0.47622719407081604,
0.9309061765670776,
-0.07112239301204681,
0.13840708136558533,
-0.21208608150482178,
0.12658092379570007,
0.04269925877451897,
-0.020361073315143585,
-0.621858537197113,
-0.43669795989990234,
0.5195189118385315,
0.07909686863422394,
0.3179202079772949,
0.7852033972740173,
0.2997533082962036,
0.1507587879896164,
-0.3100588321685791,
0.09019643813371658,
-0.2974357008934021,
0.2807462811470032,
-0.0003407747717574239,
-0.250201016664505,
-0.6860501766204834,
-0.1825612336397171,
0.5699199438095093,
0.5640447735786438,
-0.5363272428512573,
-0.10670990496873856,
-0.08444135636091232,
0.727124035358429,
-0.2762885093688965,
0.0975208729505539,
-0.45779141783714294,
0.25330784916877747,
-0.2758398652076721,
-0.07479154318571091,
-0.30601900815963745,
-0.5489467978477478,
0.4163222312927246,
-0.38319188356399536,
0.4268842041492462,
-0.1252962350845337,
0.5947442054748535,
0.1540631353855133,
-0.8209391832351685,
-0.6419656872749329,
-0.5924649238586426,
0.6867396235466003,
-0.9735919237136841,
0.14527882635593414,
-0.02995643950998783,
0.18610574305057526,
-0.4567555785179138,
-0.6927029490470886,
-0.34088125824928284,
-0.4015302360057831,
0.3252677619457245,
0.1277109980583191,
-0.001959514804184437,
0.1759469211101532,
-0.1835683137178421,
0.2794938385486603,
-0.7679557204246521,
-0.282141774892807,
-0.19143512845039368,
-0.04120700806379318,
0.4718093276023865,
0.03335532546043396,
0.21583028137683868,
-0.24027875065803528,
-0.5221959948539734,
-0.012476213276386261,
-0.5541760325431824,
-0.5816430449485779,
0.07633720338344574,
0.3544674217700958,
0.10479633510112762,
0.6954089999198914,
0.24646806716918945,
0.7604559063911438,
0.3014134466648102,
-0.28465476632118225,
0.23402039706707,
-0.40894433856010437,
-0.2208293080329895,
0.24170343577861786,
0.8961197137832642,
0.1945292353630066,
0.1519056111574173,
0.013554301112890244,
-0.2722128927707672,
-0.291843980550766,
0.17698797583580017,
-1.1282963752746582,
-0.3445647358894348,
0.3668685853481293,
-0.5331055521965027,
-0.6522393822669983,
-0.22682002186775208,
-1.0769151449203491,
-0.2944822907447815,
0.30733081698417664,
0.7060724496841431,
-0.6264073252677917,
-0.4151553213596344,
0.0014738609315827489,
-0.4448492228984833,
-0.3341611921787262,
0.2638838589191437,
-0.7623738646507263,
0.030006563290953636,
0.2501526176929474,
1.0855518579483032,
-0.46739402413368225,
0.13294045627117157,
-0.3880014419555664,
0.6046662330627441,
-0.24538066983222961,
0.712036669254303,
-0.5177438259124756,
-0.859707236289978,
-0.03582119196653366,
-0.4730226695537567,
0.037735242396593094,
-0.6487935781478882,
-0.23105677962303162,
-0.3479156792163849,
0.4761236906051636,
-0.026736414059996605,
-0.9206098914146423,
-0.10929740965366364,
-0.057978104799985886,
-0.4099273383617401,
0.7377216815948486,
0.3460598886013031,
-0.3537044823169708,
0.46375492215156555,
-0.782116711139679,
-0.5830071568489075,
-0.007311998400837183,
-0.16538825631141663,
-0.6774260997772217,
0.1584528386592865,
-0.03270029276609421,
0.318111389875412,
-0.0575411431491375,
0.5432021021842957,
-0.18304653465747833,
0.18342918157577515,
0.11600540578365326,
-0.2996315062046051,
0.6916629076004028,
0.3217477798461914,
-0.48041701316833496,
-0.09509330242872238,
-0.9777746796607971,
-0.20301933586597443,
0.1175006553530693,
-0.637256920337677,
0.007205758709460497,
0.003210377413779497,
-0.0952705666422844,
0.17451371252536774,
0.47442254424095154,
-0.4911881387233734,
0.31606370210647583,
-0.3013780415058136,
0.4332455098628998,
0.6956655979156494,
0.4737866520881653,
0.7002049684524536,
0.007501200307160616,
0.5700141787528992,
0.5624527335166931,
-0.10888370126485825,
-0.3591104745864868,
-0.7208245396614075,
-0.5541389584541321,
-0.16264791786670685,
0.27156418561935425,
0.3607307970523834,
-0.4533146023750305,
0.3667951226234436,
0.16613668203353882,
-0.32246077060699463,
-0.0581895187497139,
0.23954273760318756,
0.2676084637641907,
0.7623450756072998,
0.5038582682609558,
-0.31477949023246765,
-0.2450740486383438,
-0.5413591861724854,
-0.1084522008895874,
-0.33434879779815674,
0.09845851361751556,
0.446717232465744,
0.38473236560821533,
-0.6063839197158813,
0.8789118528366089,
-0.7740657329559326,
-0.26365309953689575,
-0.05608835443854332,
0.4463101029396057,
-0.31119439005851746,
0.4995596706867218,
0.4925268590450287,
-0.6132986545562744,
-0.4007760286331177,
-0.18206621706485748,
-0.5330547094345093,
-0.3020349442958832,
-0.042248692363500595,
-0.3358723223209381,
0.4484196603298187,
0.30619749426841736,
-0.5542401671409607,
0.20478126406669617,
0.43797212839126587,
-0.4560770094394684,
0.1136590912938118,
-0.34029996395111084,
-0.044215381145477295,
-1.4894647598266602,
0.012104899622499943,
0.3368239104747772,
-0.5140345692634583,
-0.6798496842384338,
-0.30268391966819763,
-0.09059438109397888,
-0.17099301517009735,
-0.41830363869667053,
0.6625436544418335,
-0.46028101444244385,
0.20018593966960907,
-0.47544410824775696,
0.2513573467731476,
0.09073368459939957,
0.3254254460334778,
0.022582590579986572,
0.5142520666122437,
0.4884887635707855,
-0.7767843008041382,
0.1104157343506813,
0.16754646599292755,
0.12825551629066467,
0.3608047366142273,
-0.5215803384780884,
-0.14589212834835052,
-0.13730040192604065,
0.36222073435783386,
-1.0130518674850464,
-0.26654666662216187,
0.351235955953598,
-0.35281485319137573,
0.5204094052314758,
-0.05001852661371231,
-0.41057488322257996,
-0.2781316041946411,
0.04604106396436691,
0.33080652356147766,
0.8741124868392944,
-0.428089439868927,
0.7391854524612427,
0.41079020500183105,
-0.05638528987765312,
-0.09651833772659302,
-0.9900192022323608,
0.06955106556415558,
-0.3113711178302765,
-0.7002349495887756,
0.43064084649086,
-0.20924407243728638,
-0.0050071789883077145,
-0.12529779970645905,
-0.13008412718772888,
-0.13689492642879486,
-0.10035689175128937,
0.024058431386947632,
-0.014694596640765667,
-0.17635732889175415,
0.19019359350204468,
0.380638986825943,
0.03224769979715347,
0.07844068855047226,
-0.8814569711685181,
0.3386226296424866,
0.22326435148715973,
-0.030255381017923355,
-0.17596684396266937,
0.40809381008148193,
0.3207050859928131,
0.00972108356654644,
0.5794841647148132,
0.682816207408905,
-0.047616347670555115,
-0.4500505328178406,
0.02912626415491104,
-0.13973836600780487,
-0.5201539993286133,
0.19471357762813568,
-0.006251972634345293,
-0.756142258644104,
0.3255545496940613,
-0.29185840487480164,
-0.05938723683357239,
0.3904708921909332,
0.7261331081390381,
-0.017451226711273193,
1.126609206199646,
0.630896270275116,
0.5821282267570496,
0.6592395305633545,
-0.03501315414905548,
0.14498917758464813,
-0.4617040455341339,
-0.4671430289745331,
-0.12449109554290771,
0.004589706193655729,
-0.4963216483592987,
-0.615687906742096,
0.4270423352718353,
0.04196223244071007,
-0.10050111263990402,
0.2634274661540985,
-0.6132409572601318,
-0.07238134741783142,
0.6264880895614624,
0.14853347837924957,
0.2198694497346878,
0.2132922261953354,
-0.45620080828666687,
0.1869225949048996,
-0.7226682901382446,
-0.6100773811340332,
1.0145487785339355,
0.1577252894639969,
0.7401894330978394,
0.28380894660949707,
1.0919594764709473,
0.3644140064716339,
0.011456276290118694,
-0.47609037160873413,
0.788195013999939,
-0.36597371101379395,
-0.33840325474739075,
0.05607878416776657,
-0.6596580147743225,
-0.8992250561714172,
-0.09861727803945541,
0.03763764351606369,
-0.4631706178188324,
0.15956062078475952,
0.5201759934425354,
-0.14308291673660278,
0.26781120896339417,
-0.7522956132888794,
0.6735494136810303,
0.003025643527507782,
-0.009319581091403961,
-0.0971224382519722,
-0.5938839316368103,
0.24525998532772064,
-0.11908619105815887,
-0.07997377216815948,
-0.13248346745967865,
-0.3075203001499176,
0.6262915134429932,
-0.583029568195343,
0.5950677990913391,
-0.4328146278858185,
-0.7504307627677917,
0.4355528652667999,
0.21393537521362305,
0.4867492616176605,
-0.014054736122488976,
0.0328853577375412,
0.039010919630527496,
-0.4173508882522583,
-0.4431162476539612,
-0.33263230323791504,
0.7730488777160645,
-0.14725953340530396,
-0.5717321038246155,
-0.26596978306770325,
-0.31497445702552795,
-0.10464157909154892,
0.5260089039802551,
0.49565938115119934,
0.4135293662548065,
-0.23518747091293335,
-0.43467408418655396,
0.9464719295501709,
-0.2799144685268402,
0.6214605569839478,
0.47856441140174866,
-0.4957352876663208,
-0.5863621830940247,
1.264050006866455,
0.0477009043097496,
0.6179720163345337,
0.39550507068634033,
0.21739362180233002,
-0.2575055956840515,
-0.7497285008430481,
-0.5415078401565552,
0.14475680887699127,
-0.5196399688720703,
-0.02260788343846798,
-0.7898147106170654,
0.022417865693569183,
-0.45340633392333984,
-0.05003069341182709,
-0.4297046959400177,
-0.6799497008323669,
-0.6990852952003479,
0.06115003675222397,
0.4333844482898712,
0.8572296500205994,
-0.24577048420906067,
0.21404129266738892,
-0.8791224360466003,
0.5113798379898071,
0.31396159529685974,
0.1908315271139145,
-0.06824079155921936,
-0.21226269006729126,
-0.3768714368343353,
0.3712085485458374,
-0.46679046750068665,
-0.9912872910499573,
0.42527392506599426,
0.2996269166469574,
0.32652539014816284,
0.3024038076400757,
-0.3148515820503235,
0.3606586158275604,
-0.6936599612236023,
1.0655113458633423,
0.20364393293857574,
-0.7876390218734741,
0.9973190426826477,
-0.6274368166923523,
0.544434666633606,
0.03425692021846771,
-0.07790307700634003,
-0.08441039174795151,
-1.0292810201644897,
-0.7523533701896667,
-0.9160577654838562,
0.32581526041030884,
0.49471336603164673,
-0.055082403123378754,
-0.3553136885166168,
0.3964899480342865,
0.11005450040102005,
0.5162438750267029,
-0.4325628876686096,
-0.43836715817451477,
-0.4199029803276062,
-0.6018238067626953,
0.23634839057922363,
-0.1770496964454651,
-0.14433708786964417,
0.32324036955833435,
0.7473074197769165,
-0.03518420457839966,
0.6010228395462036,
0.3314390480518341,
-0.13253088295459747,
-0.2849529981613159,
0.077847920358181,
0.8670146465301514,
0.3260878026485443,
-0.3642822206020355,
0.05244654044508934,
-0.34797343611717224,
-0.6676620841026306,
0.21185031533241272,
0.23762725293636322,
-0.4478559195995331,
0.3467043936252594,
-0.13127242028713226,
0.5560595989227295,
-0.37186112999916077,
-0.5722684860229492,
0.3659438192844391,
0.005640173796564341,
-0.3463677167892456,
0.09369415044784546,
0.5220310091972351,
0.19608712196350098,
0.2975890636444092,
0.6260136365890503,
0.332283616065979,
0.2891351282596588,
-0.2799456715583801,
0.32200491428375244,
0.40068763494491577,
-0.2930987477302551,
-0.20507748425006866,
0.9365499019622803,
0.28845664858818054,
-0.2733471989631653,
0.15386472642421722,
-0.2272794544696808,
-0.20569418370723724,
0.6752267479896545,
0.6411371827125549,
1.1146661043167114,
-0.32565784454345703,
0.4979657828807831,
0.32051706314086914,
-0.1527038961648941,
-0.1982557624578476,
0.24507303535938263,
-0.2340312898159027,
-0.3114359676837921,
0.14748413860797882,
-0.6233503818511963,
-0.12844540178775787,
-0.40941715240478516,
-0.4251869022846222,
0.08937593549489975,
-0.4440353214740753,
-0.3544613718986511,
0.016403678804636,
-0.0888545885682106,
-0.032842040061950684,
0.506973147392273,
0.3662370443344116,
0.7436866164207458,
-0.397969126701355,
0.8238023519515991,
0.4771929681301117,
-0.16397137939929962,
-0.24196486175060272,
0.46676239371299744,
0.2069804072380066,
-0.4798504114151001,
0.4297791123390198,
-0.04808075726032257,
-0.31223389506340027,
0.2012503445148468,
-0.5952644944190979,
-0.9274471998214722,
1.3351467847824097,
0.2205858826637268,
-0.582939088344574,
-0.06100749224424362,
0.022513670846819878,
0.6972512006759644,
-0.6502048373222351,
-0.20783685147762299,
0.27632084488868713,
0.41129952669143677,
0.4030573070049286,
-0.4511469006538391,
0.11173682659864426,
0.0003323113778606057,
0.4667622745037079,
0.22397688031196594,
-0.738332986831665,
0.6936424970626831,
-0.4333370625972748,
-0.3079525828361511,
0.282259464263916,
0.8280296921730042,
0.5259218215942383,
0.24781379103660583,
0.21088853478431702,
0.46432560682296753,
0.9469807147979736,
-0.005041833966970444,
0.765891432762146,
-0.33483994007110596,
0.41949382424354553,
0.9084298014640808,
-0.2828189432621002,
0.4797450602054596,
0.4816880226135254,
0.0022774278186261654,
0.694215714931488,
0.5751610994338989,
-0.29857325553894043,
0.8032478094100952,
0.2562064230442047,
-0.549010694026947,
0.060224127024412155,
0.026682507246732712,
-0.24043697118759155,
-0.13562238216400146,
0.4552226960659027,
-0.6519779562950134,
-0.29779505729675293,
0.4075245261192322,
0.0459330789744854,
-0.2271704077720642,
-0.2141743004322052,
0.7828966975212097,
0.19526587426662445,
-0.5982902646064758,
0.30070093274116516,
0.07090751826763153,
0.5676354169845581,
-0.5168277621269226,
-0.12836067378520966,
-0.19430221617221832,
0.1043759286403656,
0.004767246078699827,
-0.9284712672233582,
0.14551599323749542,
0.09093732386827469,
-0.2745459973812103,
-0.4203313887119293,
0.6799817085266113,
-0.9464722275733948,
-0.4757139980792999,
0.20586973428726196,
0.31495630741119385,
0.06202381104230881,
0.4188046157360077,
-0.8064122796058655,
-0.4395848512649536,
0.37360256910324097,
-0.4999127984046936,
0.25083714723587036,
0.58204185962677,
0.3627585172653198,
0.7198757529258728,
0.20244759321212769,
-0.05136080086231232,
0.2501359283924103,
0.08176134526729584,
0.5532350540161133,
-0.8277751803398132,
-0.21259073913097382,
-0.9147545695304871,
0.4771319329738617,
0.18751390278339386,
-0.25475478172302246,
0.7542924284934998,
0.6331497430801392,
0.304669588804245,
-0.033361829817295074,
0.8101134300231934,
-0.08466465026140213,
0.3054767847061157,
-0.6911404132843018,
0.6810785531997681,
-0.7952350378036499,
0.31424200534820557,
-0.2029370218515396,
-0.7579798698425293,
-0.3316907286643982,
0.5460472702980042,
0.30297771096229553,
0.38091573119163513,
0.6219266057014465,
0.8446211814880371,
0.10706865787506104,
-0.07456938922405243,
0.005473610013723373,
0.5263504385948181,
0.6551284193992615,
0.5545167326927185,
0.23031210899353027,
-0.550146758556366,
0.671320915222168,
-0.03239404782652855,
0.0888354480266571,
-0.2698321044445038,
-0.8472996950149536,
-1.0031037330627441,
-0.34744730591773987,
-0.6648472547531128,
-0.8257055878639221,
0.0630340725183487,
0.6729872226715088,
0.6378097534179688,
-0.6018884778022766,
-0.11627458035945892,
-0.8654828667640686,
0.007857940159738064,
0.2573266923427582,
-0.2447681874036789,
0.20977307856082916,
-0.2311984747648239,
-0.8497338891029358,
0.39836034178733826,
0.5379698872566223,
0.8555521965026855,
-0.591072142124176,
-0.12905822694301605,
-0.15378858149051666,
0.21898333728313446,
0.3515450060367584,
0.12024593353271484,
-0.5491764545440674,
0.2670498788356781,
-0.024266010150313377,
-0.5793648958206177,
0.3243664503097534,
0.6186584234237671,
-0.676313042640686,
0.5517009496688843,
0.508461058139801,
-0.008985662832856178,
0.7704184055328369,
-0.04100807383656502,
1.1686373949050903,
-0.81818026304245,
-0.09471631795167923,
0.2626226544380188,
0.09753420948982239,
0.3757309913635254,
-0.4903443157672882,
0.1907637119293213,
0.3043883442878723,
-0.5792001485824585,
-0.6827633380889893,
0.3239462077617645,
-1.1710988283157349,
-0.6037604212760925,
1.3756366968154907,
-0.04062587395310402,
-0.5138607621192932,
0.22278112173080444,
-0.10683021694421768,
0.40937477350234985,
-0.8310936093330383,
0.7348524928092957,
0.5367752313613892,
-0.2550854980945587,
-0.05997516214847565,
-0.11949114501476288,
0.7378055453300476,
0.3418404161930084,
-0.595137357711792,
-0.024505527690052986,
0.6209263801574707,
0.3137608766555786,
0.16096250712871552,
0.7473286390304565,
-0.1632026880979538,
0.2292080521583557,
0.06894788146018982,
-0.21073365211486816,
-0.03600730374455452,
-0.1305517852306366,
-0.35004401206970215,
0.21707499027252197,
-0.2107408046722412,
-0.041436851024627686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13036v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13036v1 | SiLLM: Large Language Models for Simultaneous Machine Translation | 2024-02-20T14:23:34 | 2024-02-20T14:23:34 | Shoutao Guo, Shaolei Zhang, Zhengrui Ma, Min Zhang, Yang Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Simultaneous Machine Translation (SiMT) generates translations while reading
the source sentence, necessitating a policy to determine the optimal timing for
reading and generating words. Despite the remarkable performance achieved by
Large Language Models (LLM) across various NLP tasks, existing SiMT methods
predominantly focus on conventional transformers, employing a single model to
concurrently determine the policy and generate the translations. However, given
the complexity of SiMT, it is challenging to effectively address both tasks
with a single model. Therefore, there is a need to decouple the SiMT task into
policy-decision and translation sub-tasks. We propose SiLLM, which delegates
the two sub-tasks to separate agents, thereby incorporating LLM into SiMT. The
policy-decision agent is managed by a conventional SiMT model, responsible for
determining the translation policy. The translation agent, leveraging the
capabilities of LLM, generates translation using the partial source sentence.
The two agents collaborate to accomplish SiMT. To facilitate the application of
token-level policies determined by conventional SiMT models to LLM, we propose
a word-level policy adapted for LLM. Experiments on two datasets demonstrate
that, with a small amount of data for fine-tuning LLM, SiLLM attains
state-of-the-art performance. | [
-0.28255495429039,
-0.6736255884170532,
0.5803550481796265,
0.6697635650634766,
-0.3998136520385742,
0.07742995023727417,
-0.4573027193546295,
-0.19137924909591675,
0.0369524247944355,
0.7361984848976135,
-0.6460704803466797,
-0.2966810166835785,
-0.6811513304710388,
0.2767186760902405,
-0.2267439067363739,
1.0038402080535889,
-0.23092764616012573,
0.1626969277858734,
-0.28371700644493103,
-0.04434626176953316,
-0.7318480014801025,
-0.2520323097705841,
-0.7139285802841187,
-0.5438877940177917,
0.46554023027420044,
0.18953758478164673,
1.086120843887329,
0.6366289854049683,
0.6252513527870178,
0.2723771333694458,
-0.13788047432899475,
0.516257107257843,
-0.3932555317878723,
0.07477044314146042,
-0.3364671766757965,
-0.3562510013580322,
-0.5614662766456604,
-0.15692129731178284,
0.9828321933746338,
0.4530923366546631,
0.07638061791658401,
0.04634936526417732,
0.15511879324913025,
0.3527640104293823,
-0.19649070501327515,
0.3349587917327881,
-0.7455423474311829,
0.06162717938423157,
-0.007279917597770691,
-0.3907814025878906,
-0.513943612575531,
-0.19402021169662476,
-0.14430417120456696,
-0.34465497732162476,
-0.2336539924144745,
0.23374395072460175,
0.5624697804450989,
0.5939655900001526,
-0.6703610420227051,
-0.2554965019226074,
-0.8948342800140381,
0.896407961845398,
-0.7458449602127075,
0.23762305080890656,
0.06292309612035751,
-0.07532190531492233,
-0.23955640196800232,
-0.46460387110710144,
-0.4339623749256134,
-0.5006177425384521,
-0.18879327178001404,
0.22566145658493042,
0.06330600380897522,
0.07262220233678818,
0.3131217062473297,
0.14721649885177612,
-0.6755092740058899,
0.13339972496032715,
-0.28274884819984436,
0.011960344389081001,
0.6077238917350769,
0.3406537175178528,
0.44932684302330017,
0.09656188637018204,
-0.7724382877349854,
0.2425757199525833,
-0.6610265374183655,
-0.43679800629615784,
0.089405357837677,
0.3635115325450897,
0.07284122705459595,
0.7776219844818115,
0.011016693897545338,
0.2293766289949417,
-0.345863401889801,
-0.41872867941856384,
0.2047971934080124,
-0.5260115265846252,
-0.19638502597808838,
0.1676173210144043,
0.9019025564193726,
0.15446974337100983,
0.2587006986141205,
-0.3244331181049347,
-0.47579360008239746,
-0.1307622492313385,
0.16090139746665955,
-0.7604237198829651,
0.5322229266166687,
0.11400240659713745,
-0.16210414469242096,
-0.13484984636306763,
-0.021707752719521523,
-0.3504594564437866,
-0.1891966611146927,
-0.5774409770965576,
0.5693264007568359,
-0.3451140820980072,
-0.3170351982116699,
0.23289000988006592,
0.170938178896904,
0.24158331751823425,
0.26668643951416016,
-0.5394273996353149,
0.5004070401191711,
0.8138291239738464,
1.0864089727401733,
-0.6834906339645386,
-0.7185097336769104,
-0.5320223569869995,
0.4303569495677948,
-0.2857062816619873,
0.34849825501441956,
-0.2008286416530609,
-0.39206206798553467,
-0.185071662068367,
-0.00030301447259262204,
-0.5849899053573608,
-0.48789989948272705,
0.22963416576385498,
-0.36050882935523987,
-0.16181525588035583,
0.03458620235323906,
-0.4828264117240906,
0.06917650252580643,
0.28662312030792236,
-0.6821916699409485,
1.0066184997558594,
-0.04756179824471474,
-0.7146985530853271,
0.1716795116662979,
-0.8761981129646301,
-0.6828347444534302,
0.09211115539073944,
-0.15293031930923462,
-0.2750091254711151,
0.2526845633983612,
0.23022021353244781,
0.4618930518627167,
-0.5606126189231873,
0.5310923457145691,
-0.11410556733608246,
-0.3461416959762573,
0.20274357497692108,
-0.5914406180381775,
0.7291127443313599,
0.3417750298976898,
-0.23476257920265198,
0.20279395580291748,
-0.09082254767417908,
-0.19423498213291168,
0.12638473510742188,
-0.5285273194313049,
-0.06187194958329201,
-0.05679525434970856,
0.09088780730962753,
0.37131091952323914,
0.551425576210022,
-0.43324562907218933,
0.5166246891021729,
-0.21464888751506805,
0.35329383611679077,
0.5085711479187012,
-0.0769052505493164,
0.5612766742706299,
-0.33628371357917786,
0.6364189982414246,
-0.04450655356049538,
0.12137605249881744,
-0.10319855064153671,
-0.2742113769054413,
-0.7806779742240906,
-0.40247684717178345,
0.30853283405303955,
0.8556680679321289,
-0.6708418726921082,
0.09693832695484161,
-0.32410529255867004,
-0.220317542552948,
-0.647650420665741,
0.26162123680114746,
0.2442370355129242,
-0.15381307899951935,
0.436527281999588,
-0.05602851137518883,
-0.19544847309589386,
-0.8394550681114197,
-0.3486216962337494,
0.015863249078392982,
0.34661486744880676,
0.1927238404750824,
0.4141892194747925,
-0.3330085575580597,
0.7730135917663574,
-0.4361434578895569,
-0.47899678349494934,
-0.6127291321754456,
0.3244931995868683,
0.09887193143367767,
0.46238505840301514,
0.3615971803665161,
-0.8679116368293762,
-0.5509267449378967,
0.2583739757537842,
-0.8071569800376892,
-0.3418201506137848,
-0.4881914258003235,
-0.14690637588500977,
0.24416926503181458,
0.8934841156005859,
-0.7203182578086853,
0.29030340909957886,
0.4817662537097931,
0.03328938037157059,
0.5244026184082031,
-0.46454858779907227,
0.01667070761322975,
-1.3403689861297607,
-0.2082964926958084,
-0.4007255733013153,
-0.6166873574256897,
-0.3813905715942383,
0.25932782888412476,
0.006860760506242514,
-0.050738729536533356,
-0.6409199833869934,
0.528420627117157,
-0.6058252453804016,
-0.3015511631965637,
-0.3902016580104828,
-0.08972900360822678,
-0.25417858362197876,
0.33792591094970703,
0.061262357980012894,
1.0164498090744019,
0.3296402096748352,
-0.3480149507522583,
0.18576617538928986,
-0.05472252145409584,
-0.08239739388227463,
0.2514287829399109,
-0.6010637879371643,
-0.041182998567819595,
-0.06347750127315521,
0.300289511680603,
-0.6275283694267273,
-0.15591180324554443,
-0.012921187095344067,
0.01626097783446312,
0.3248281478881836,
-0.006343999411910772,
-0.7905874252319336,
-0.32081282138824463,
0.049520377069711685,
0.4089747965335846,
0.5354093909263611,
-0.264526903629303,
0.7496488690376282,
0.37634173035621643,
-0.3577917218208313,
-0.42622891068458557,
-0.6136714816093445,
0.1083076223731041,
-0.20872266590595245,
-0.5424653887748718,
0.3163798153400421,
-0.03968612104654312,
-0.15091094374656677,
0.11512359976768494,
-0.11103637516498566,
0.09743791073560715,
0.09993453323841095,
0.3794347643852234,
0.18473918735980988,
-0.37306690216064453,
0.003954153973609209,
0.24650314450263977,
-0.32930800318717957,
-0.20193421840667725,
-0.3835158050060272,
0.7054996490478516,
-0.1760098934173584,
-0.5123999118804932,
-0.4222584664821625,
0.5216139554977417,
0.9907529354095459,
-0.3961820602416992,
0.9838352203369141,
0.8110026121139526,
-0.16214361786842346,
-0.45663243532180786,
-0.37859097123146057,
-0.03921440243721008,
-0.36809515953063965,
0.35488802194595337,
-0.688997745513916,
-0.8838224411010742,
0.2514791190624237,
-0.6030775904655457,
0.21718794107437134,
0.36711910367012024,
0.9191141128540039,
0.12194731831550598,
1.2448679208755493,
0.6510047316551208,
-0.04796404391527176,
0.4459657669067383,
-0.07872096449136734,
0.22816666960716248,
-0.652198076248169,
0.0000904833068489097,
-0.26063013076782227,
-0.13356637954711914,
-0.36307191848754883,
-0.5699329376220703,
0.4707666039466858,
0.24769504368305206,
0.0787525400519371,
0.5040404200553894,
-0.08770718425512314,
0.6561741828918457,
0.5880165100097656,
-0.1268722414970398,
0.49234843254089355,
-0.0062295482493937016,
-0.49800905585289,
0.1750190109014511,
-0.6805338263511658,
-0.6219127178192139,
0.6428945660591125,
0.24190278351306915,
0.8569545745849609,
-0.01732095703482628,
0.8124027252197266,
0.22115181386470795,
0.08512038737535477,
-0.7754222750663757,
0.7918746471405029,
-0.3489258289337158,
-0.3075144588947296,
-0.26132649183273315,
-0.5572565197944641,
-0.7825164198875427,
0.5984131097793579,
-0.12927159667015076,
-0.5003593564033508,
-0.3692283630371094,
0.02616203762590885,
0.010394214652478695,
0.28243714570999146,
-0.5569264888763428,
0.9442340731620789,
-0.41819119453430176,
-0.12896279990673065,
-0.3636821508407593,
-0.5665366649627686,
0.4783878028392792,
-0.4779455065727234,
0.09243393689393997,
-0.4519976079463959,
-0.1676592081785202,
0.2655852735042572,
-0.39228203892707825,
0.5932797193527222,
0.1477571725845337,
-0.03461563587188721,
0.10991021245718002,
0.24953396618366241,
0.5796512365341187,
0.045524708926677704,
-0.1903878152370453,
0.17898645997047424,
0.18363262712955475,
-0.2204677164554596,
-0.28910350799560547,
0.6746286749839783,
-0.7037922739982605,
-0.5603809356689453,
-0.5493600964546204,
-1.125679612159729,
-0.02740851230919361,
0.36753836274147034,
0.10910973697900772,
0.1181822270154953,
-0.3210389018058777,
0.3112058639526367,
0.3898732364177704,
-0.27442771196365356,
0.31841790676116943,
0.6186878085136414,
-0.5295447111129761,
-0.07152923941612244,
0.9390177130699158,
0.20714768767356873,
0.6099207997322083,
0.3930828273296356,
0.20904530584812164,
-0.3157044053077698,
-0.5857542753219604,
-0.4401779770851135,
0.35365188121795654,
-0.26275449991226196,
-0.08350289613008499,
-0.7194939255714417,
-0.519347608089447,
-0.5034909248352051,
-0.03577224537730217,
-0.39241737127304077,
-0.24163275957107544,
-0.12312908470630646,
0.31557774543762207,
0.0817316323518753,
0.7641979455947876,
-0.13565391302108765,
0.4701901972293854,
-0.7159262299537659,
0.5656450390815735,
0.08385537564754486,
-0.1327228993177414,
-0.3813527822494507,
-0.3591473400592804,
-0.19465455412864685,
0.064602330327034,
-0.13050299882888794,
-0.6720088720321655,
0.4225625991821289,
0.05628926306962967,
0.40158313512802124,
-0.06803934276103973,
0.011110392399132252,
0.6305986046791077,
-0.7880939841270447,
0.5137911438941956,
0.10393024981021881,
-0.8441083431243896,
0.33599233627319336,
-0.18069259822368622,
0.6147378087043762,
0.32105401158332825,
0.2848756015300751,
-0.6459305286407471,
-0.6799922585487366,
-0.16665716469287872,
-1.02449631690979,
1.0750398635864258,
0.26146799325942993,
0.14794132113456726,
0.014182636514306068,
-0.129540354013443,
0.08770430088043213,
0.23243215680122375,
-0.6043940186500549,
0.10753102600574493,
0.4069176912307739,
-0.3076677620410919,
0.005505898501724005,
-0.13693800568580627,
0.14439469575881958,
-0.016206396743655205,
0.9455808401107788,
-0.24234434962272644,
-0.04226081818342209,
-0.11205458641052246,
-0.511076807975769,
0.030786724761128426,
0.4913789629936218,
0.5013498663902283,
0.6154613494873047,
-0.11698617786169052,
0.2482878714799881,
0.36256128549575806,
-0.4209337532520294,
0.07889649271965027,
0.04306218400597572,
-0.6209440231323242,
0.034714408218860626,
0.2776217758655548,
0.866215169429779,
0.20286230742931366,
-0.561152458190918,
0.5772260427474976,
-0.028165537863969803,
-0.2072947472333908,
-0.14539816975593567,
0.13109007477760315,
0.313092976808548,
0.4681572914123535,
0.09015993028879166,
0.09133660793304443,
-0.28201526403427124,
-0.3572606146335602,
0.2925296723842621,
0.3953571319580078,
-0.16674648225307465,
-0.04594169929623604,
0.6811935901641846,
-0.020281745120882988,
-0.36611372232437134,
0.3260025382041931,
-0.19336150586605072,
-0.5567012429237366,
0.641447901725769,
0.9169243574142456,
0.9039490222930908,
-0.14979083836078644,
0.362846314907074,
0.04735549911856651,
0.6701623201370239,
-0.5412247776985168,
0.23112377524375916,
0.21098050475120544,
-0.5475218296051025,
-0.554620623588562,
-0.9164034128189087,
-0.18740715086460114,
0.08885020762681961,
-0.5022212862968445,
0.3070846199989319,
-0.17470981180667877,
-0.12678508460521698,
-0.1421574056148529,
-0.15848243236541748,
-0.7074384689331055,
-0.1858273446559906,
0.14115676283836365,
0.7478721141815186,
-0.8603211641311646,
1.0224804878234863,
0.6226968169212341,
-0.5252484083175659,
-0.7798623442649841,
0.1801789253950119,
0.035458892583847046,
-0.7620792388916016,
0.5101528167724609,
0.05783452093601227,
-0.2652207016944885,
0.2184910923242569,
-0.3189942240715027,
-0.7327518463134766,
1.0544794797897339,
0.6931582689285278,
-0.6280578970909119,
-0.18137015402317047,
0.59999018907547,
0.25988590717315674,
-0.4092191755771637,
-0.07743573188781738,
0.6773520112037659,
0.4957973062992096,
0.1090034767985344,
-1.2361441850662231,
0.02557448484003544,
0.3725892901420593,
0.1734616458415985,
0.35963764786720276,
-0.6541247963905334,
0.9099459648132324,
-0.07163999229669571,
-0.25909703969955444,
0.17047469317913055,
0.5852910280227661,
0.14968998730182648,
0.2096216231584549,
0.5820863842964172,
0.35870659351348877,
0.49896904826164246,
-0.057901471853256226,
1.054440975189209,
-0.23549529910087585,
0.4474527835845947,
1.3720369338989258,
-0.5687007904052734,
0.7939967513084412,
0.5850543975830078,
0.05602245777845383,
-0.28360626101493835,
0.3645361065864563,
0.13978362083435059,
0.26574525237083435,
0.10532651841640472,
-0.38700440526008606,
-0.42477360367774963,
-0.6006697416305542,
-0.2603631615638733,
0.39027687907218933,
0.3364654779434204,
-0.46800515055656433,
-0.3619667589664459,
0.24721911549568176,
0.22134944796562195,
-0.1037340834736824,
-0.36173298954963684,
0.9381703734397888,
0.36943724751472473,
-0.7852445840835571,
0.22309164702892303,
0.24718274176120758,
0.36022815108299255,
-0.6199166178703308,
0.07656092941761017,
-0.1973882019519806,
0.3937114179134369,
0.00009323634731117636,
-0.7064523696899414,
0.26116034388542175,
-0.012962820008397102,
-0.15525902807712555,
-0.6203435659408569,
0.7114139795303345,
-1.0055770874023438,
-0.6330496668815613,
0.3858342170715332,
0.7782796621322632,
0.457689106464386,
0.04835262894630432,
-0.9452419281005859,
0.27339839935302734,
-0.12763774394989014,
-0.29177120327949524,
0.2280881404876709,
0.5777530074119568,
-0.3734181225299835,
0.4859835207462311,
0.5729045867919922,
0.42942050099372864,
0.3711462616920471,
0.2081904411315918,
0.5694465041160583,
-0.43289288878440857,
-0.39802873134613037,
-0.9699516892433167,
0.10867452621459961,
0.034574300050735474,
0.00765204755589366,
0.6406093835830688,
0.6238718032836914,
0.7531958222389221,
-0.12033221870660782,
0.748909056186676,
0.027364738285541534,
0.18613815307617188,
-0.7308749556541443,
0.5734820365905762,
-0.8338033556938171,
0.2558914124965668,
-0.030969340354204178,
-1.2357665300369263,
-0.2998529374599457,
0.3245358467102051,
-0.2944144308567047,
-0.20926029980182648,
0.9467472434043884,
1.0011183023452759,
-0.35777199268341064,
-0.1543847769498825,
0.47791263461112976,
0.22222104668617249,
0.16972234845161438,
0.528784990310669,
0.7685250639915466,
-0.11709368228912354,
0.6463030576705933,
0.1337677538394928,
0.025726445019245148,
-0.2622559368610382,
-0.8579038977622986,
-0.8833905458450317,
-0.37124690413475037,
-0.2436896115541458,
-0.0933530330657959,
0.018717220053076744,
1.2824634313583374,
0.6745395660400391,
-0.6073154211044312,
-0.2719826102256775,
-0.06608593463897705,
0.26574283838272095,
-0.34706684947013855,
-0.18219298124313354,
0.196975439786911,
-0.6178157925605774,
-0.9428792595863342,
0.5041549205780029,
0.655886709690094,
0.00940108671784401,
-0.3378753066062927,
-0.24970920383930206,
-0.31309249997138977,
0.34999528527259827,
0.6462163925170898,
-0.022712774574756622,
-0.8244290351867676,
0.17639844119548798,
-0.22101621329784393,
-0.5078926086425781,
-0.1734495311975479,
1.0378414392471313,
-0.2707807421684265,
0.21254470944404602,
0.632562518119812,
0.9574224352836609,
0.7678933143615723,
-0.03266178444027901,
0.6365619897842407,
-0.6957088708877563,
0.13302680850028992,
0.15502354502677917,
0.3398832678794861,
0.06058835983276367,
-0.24261833727359772,
0.7106753587722778,
0.08385452628135681,
-0.4937751889228821,
-0.8750991225242615,
0.3580828309059143,
-0.8892096877098083,
-0.37297773361206055,
1.3780405521392822,
-0.16160164773464203,
-0.3340800106525421,
0.06320182234048843,
-0.5701624155044556,
0.3029012680053711,
-0.2413480132818222,
0.03986189514398575,
0.6250776052474976,
0.11703556030988693,
-0.09981460124254227,
-0.8138606548309326,
0.22159931063652039,
0.5029156804084778,
-0.8711744546890259,
0.02795979380607605,
0.25552719831466675,
0.06758560240268707,
-0.07441078871488571,
0.8036949038505554,
-0.1655603051185608,
-0.062221650034189224,
-0.06176326423883438,
-0.2061491161584854,
-0.19557900726795197,
-0.7497261762619019,
-0.18473638594150543,
0.15571220219135284,
0.05803878605365753,
-0.12003529816865921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13035v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13035v3 | Learning to Check: Unleashing Potentials for Self-Correction in Large Language Models | 2024-02-20T14:23:23 | 2024-06-17T15:24:29 | Che Zhang, Zhenyang Xiao, Chengcheng Han, Yixin Lian, Yuejian Fang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Self-correction has achieved impressive results in enhancing the style and
security of the generated output from large language models (LLMs). However,
recent studies suggest that self-correction might be limited or even
counterproductive in reasoning tasks due to LLMs' difficulties in identifying
logical mistakes.
In this paper, we aim to enhance the self-checking capabilities of LLMs by
constructing training data for checking tasks. Specifically, we apply the Chain
of Thought (CoT) methodology to self-checking tasks, utilizing fine-grained
step-level analyses and explanations to assess the correctness of reasoning
paths. We propose a specialized checking format called "Step CoT Check".
Following this format, we construct a checking-correction dataset that includes
detailed step-by-step analysis and checking. Then we fine-tune LLMs to enhance
their error detection and correction abilities.
Our experiments demonstrate that fine-tuning with the "Step CoT Check" format
significantly improves the self-checking and self-correction abilities of LLMs
across multiple benchmarks. This approach outperforms other formats, especially
in locating the incorrect position, with greater benefits observed in larger
models.
For reproducibility, all the datasets and code are provided in
https://github.com/bammt/Learn-to-check. | [
-0.061445094645023346,
-0.7220923900604248,
0.7668911814689636,
0.06911864131689072,
-0.11804446578025818,
0.21179719269275665,
-0.24074006080627441,
-0.3510487377643585,
-0.10629861801862717,
0.8940785527229309,
-0.6222754716873169,
-0.48532700538635254,
-0.5554256439208984,
0.3077380061149597,
-0.611264169216156,
0.975566565990448,
-0.46328529715538025,
-0.09496017545461655,
-0.11648489534854889,
0.15404166281223297,
-0.5395974516868591,
-0.5122389793395996,
-0.7901543378829956,
-0.45904502272605896,
0.5796166658401489,
0.47935259342193604,
0.429671972990036,
0.6666646003723145,
0.3483351171016693,
0.39915239810943604,
0.08848819881677628,
0.661643922328949,
-0.5357775092124939,
-0.015559433028101921,
-0.6400049328804016,
-0.5799435377120972,
-0.6195354461669922,
-0.008116409182548523,
0.47447678446769714,
0.19500188529491425,
0.010885111056268215,
0.22217895090579987,
-0.039003923535346985,
0.972686231136322,
-0.6690860986709595,
0.182763934135437,
-0.6293613314628601,
-0.009235505945980549,
-0.14877118170261383,
-0.29446443915367126,
-0.509905219078064,
-0.2543254494667053,
-0.4605730473995209,
-0.017240365967154503,
0.31158217787742615,
0.14665932953357697,
0.5824286937713623,
0.5034720301628113,
-0.5063095688819885,
-0.4049258828163147,
-0.7022587656974792,
0.4340595602989197,
-0.7630630135536194,
0.46153882145881653,
0.7260205745697021,
0.10318265855312347,
-0.3678399324417114,
-0.45834967494010925,
-0.7404147386550903,
-0.05015379190444946,
-0.08703149110078812,
-0.17563727498054504,
0.02864805795252323,
0.09410975873470306,
0.44235196709632874,
0.45773497223854065,
-0.4869917631149292,
0.04344840720295906,
-0.3014701008796692,
-0.32019034028053284,
0.6667822003364563,
0.053816694766283035,
0.3209571838378906,
0.0010590906022116542,
-0.1408926248550415,
-0.33527833223342896,
-0.7128756642341614,
-0.005631384905427694,
0.4200056493282318,
0.22178412973880768,
-0.02218790538609028,
0.5872796177864075,
-0.4908885061740875,
0.7697011232376099,
0.31700024008750916,
-0.30283623933792114,
0.009893951006233692,
-0.4615230858325958,
-0.473112553358078,
0.07194845378398895,
0.4897776246070862,
0.08840508759021759,
0.19016563892364502,
-0.020966144278645515,
-0.6728022694587708,
0.030328111723065376,
0.3187485337257385,
-0.435809850692749,
-0.5193920731544495,
0.4025459289550781,
-0.08089793473482132,
-0.3586103916168213,
-0.15820728242397308,
-0.3159133493900299,
-0.47482386231422424,
-0.5861168503761292,
0.5910934805870056,
-0.4359413981437683,
0.07838763296604156,
0.5371965169906616,
0.4349578022956848,
-0.06758453696966171,
0.4982244074344635,
-0.7444556951522827,
0.12483079731464386,
0.6554812788963318,
0.4879140853881836,
0.04300795868039131,
-0.5535403490066528,
-0.7687780857086182,
0.035392530262470245,
-0.8638646006584167,
0.9198877215385437,
-0.17533524334430695,
0.17128334939479828,
-0.022432532161474228,
0.03844129666686058,
-0.003516262164339423,
-0.4678806662559509,
0.3153867721557617,
-0.44419845938682556,
-0.17813774943351746,
-0.4451182782649994,
-0.5930061936378479,
0.041879475116729736,
0.5768643021583557,
-0.4796147346496582,
1.13728928565979,
0.015123158693313599,
-0.5722579956054688,
0.2772034704685211,
-0.4266689419746399,
-0.568734347820282,
-0.2718989849090576,
-0.20086069405078888,
-0.4586365520954132,
-0.04724281653761864,
0.4095170199871063,
0.44417884945869446,
-0.07833603024482727,
0.17926755547523499,
-0.14600570499897003,
-0.11939992755651474,
0.2786659002304077,
-0.11056745797395706,
0.7295404076576233,
0.1254742592573166,
-0.6352719068527222,
0.32409238815307617,
-0.8465725779533386,
0.23031210899353027,
0.05581288784742355,
-0.35504868626594543,
-0.18981875479221344,
-0.07136893272399902,
-0.607875645160675,
0.42941081523895264,
0.1277489811182022,
-0.43572574853897095,
0.30473777651786804,
-0.17170831561088562,
0.2948666512966156,
0.8418805599212646,
-0.16047465801239014,
0.02140689641237259,
-0.24695757031440735,
0.3978349566459656,
0.23681007325649261,
0.2013130635023117,
-0.2366466224193573,
0.013778982684016228,
-1.2282593250274658,
-0.08700905740261078,
0.54541015625,
0.4319765865802765,
-0.8561496734619141,
0.8159329891204834,
0.3099677264690399,
-0.4250197410583496,
-0.386897474527359,
0.4492473006248474,
0.5369713306427002,
0.4526340365409851,
0.4607316553592682,
-0.3403073847293854,
-0.6110519170761108,
-0.3787875175476074,
-0.28755393624305725,
-0.2521802484989166,
0.34368228912353516,
-0.12269995361566544,
0.6575380563735962,
-0.5178689360618591,
0.7449043989181519,
-0.3449345529079437,
-0.25520819425582886,
-0.12542369961738586,
0.11457459628582001,
-0.01971682347357273,
0.511115312576294,
0.0754542127251625,
-0.1442580223083496,
-0.2183769792318344,
-0.04424178972840309,
-0.5174086689949036,
-0.17379024624824524,
-0.5092045664787292,
-0.36645272374153137,
0.14816483855247498,
0.8579592704772949,
-0.28815019130706787,
0.4632827341556549,
0.5797500014305115,
-0.6610563397407532,
0.6141698956489563,
-0.5738632082939148,
0.14628474414348602,
-0.6053279638290405,
-0.1749456226825714,
-0.23660917580127716,
-0.6699768900871277,
-0.3573172688484192,
0.0584859661757946,
0.5050520300865173,
0.19913886487483978,
-0.10285009443759918,
0.32914915680885315,
-0.5131974220275879,
-0.16624566912651062,
-0.4813356101512909,
0.12819747626781464,
-0.011782080866396427,
0.41928422451019287,
-0.304282009601593,
0.8117400407791138,
0.6398850083351135,
-0.7120257019996643,
0.18464656174182892,
0.21844106912612915,
-0.4807949960231781,
0.4418766498565674,
-0.38717037439346313,
0.5469579100608826,
-0.10438574850559235,
0.44197914004325867,
-0.933285117149353,
-0.085870161652565,
0.07503611594438553,
-0.13627955317497253,
0.38809120655059814,
-0.08096896857023239,
-0.6816381812095642,
-0.47001367807388306,
-0.09672287851572037,
0.332869291305542,
0.12986062467098236,
-1.0052275657653809,
0.43025466799736023,
0.1529131978750229,
0.23337581753730774,
-0.714846670627594,
-0.42807814478874207,
0.03389084339141846,
0.2801894545555115,
-0.37216717004776,
-0.006050219759345055,
-0.05605494976043701,
-0.08095518499612808,
-0.4047999083995819,
-0.47833940386772156,
0.1177498996257782,
-0.058912839740514755,
-0.01046338677406311,
0.15306788682937622,
0.15713095664978027,
0.4355102777481079,
-0.051756784319877625,
-0.10579483956098557,
0.14334575831890106,
-0.46398216485977173,
0.6353675127029419,
-0.30596068501472473,
-0.522663414478302,
-0.19107365608215332,
-0.19218143820762634,
0.5390266180038452,
-0.5611024498939514,
0.37031930685043335,
0.43738406896591187,
-0.3347463309764862,
-0.6151887774467468,
-0.8446224927902222,
-0.21337543427944183,
-0.5028043985366821,
0.17518837749958038,
-0.3619072735309601,
-0.8459767699241638,
0.3440934717655182,
-0.1615709364414215,
-0.07891983538866043,
0.45196017622947693,
0.5837496519088745,
-0.21237188577651978,
0.8730602860450745,
0.7265174984931946,
-0.05454694479703903,
0.2119656801223755,
-0.2943061888217926,
0.6299771070480347,
-0.8859696984291077,
-0.24866603314876556,
-0.547768235206604,
-0.12885817885398865,
-0.6217370629310608,
-0.9094788432121277,
0.03389611840248108,
0.11071141064167023,
-0.5229399800300598,
0.36632606387138367,
-0.30297067761421204,
0.8341224789619446,
0.3064175546169281,
0.36209747195243835,
0.4888099431991577,
-0.27791112661361694,
-0.36252138018608093,
0.2402186095714569,
-0.5200421214103699,
-0.5089771747589111,
0.9179595112800598,
0.449817419052124,
1.212882399559021,
-0.24817246198654175,
0.9575278162956238,
0.33157795667648315,
0.07495087385177612,
-0.6215921640396118,
0.5636789202690125,
-0.15993347764015198,
-0.4337700605392456,
-0.4205198585987091,
-0.37281304597854614,
-0.6987382173538208,
-0.07625787705183029,
-0.1745908558368683,
-0.5237776637077332,
0.21152694523334503,
0.5450372695922852,
-0.24056166410446167,
0.6194815039634705,
-0.3614034950733185,
0.6393023133277893,
-0.6877834796905518,
-0.2993425726890564,
-0.37568551301956177,
-0.3612923324108124,
0.43588608503341675,
-0.25938305258750916,
0.11224407702684402,
-0.13211949169635773,
0.3068297505378723,
0.40215176343917847,
-0.5073270201683044,
1.0930339097976685,
0.3565077781677246,
-0.6152311563491821,
0.4551495909690857,
0.4563947319984436,
0.8779838681221008,
-0.045866549015045166,
0.20356808602809906,
0.11979574710130692,
0.007747489959001541,
-0.328165203332901,
-0.6163898706436157,
0.5979066491127014,
-0.7016981840133667,
-0.6432557702064514,
-0.49739503860473633,
-0.45427557826042175,
-0.4577307403087616,
0.3494037985801697,
-0.03682877868413925,
0.3308406472206116,
0.2512005865573883,
0.02499024011194706,
0.8381620645523071,
-0.05207325518131256,
0.13872669637203217,
0.5359439849853516,
-0.5026089549064636,
-0.21177653968334198,
0.7711777091026306,
-0.05309367552399635,
0.3596346080303192,
0.3692021071910858,
0.2749194800853729,
-0.41043537855148315,
-0.3992761969566345,
-0.4269249141216278,
0.35275939106941223,
-0.9044786095619202,
-0.29994937777519226,
-0.5219534635543823,
-0.13708807528018951,
-0.3902629017829895,
0.03722997009754181,
-0.705834686756134,
-0.22347329556941986,
0.08544166386127472,
-0.1307016760110855,
0.2218043953180313,
1.0317881107330322,
-0.2459927648305893,
-0.006206130143254995,
-0.47765302658081055,
0.2671082317829132,
0.49502134323120117,
0.7266004085540771,
0.11863653361797333,
-0.3668987452983856,
-0.27920109033584595,
-0.04440442472696304,
-0.4042031168937683,
-0.5418272614479065,
0.12427625805139542,
-0.2075275033712387,
0.2757003605365753,
0.23295539617538452,
-0.06759187579154968,
0.8787801861763,
-0.4802950322628021,
0.445144385099411,
0.22734735906124115,
-1.273834466934204,
0.8415175080299377,
-0.06467846781015396,
0.2810248136520386,
0.5111541748046875,
0.09010671079158783,
-0.5166394114494324,
-0.3892021179199219,
-0.5637359023094177,
-0.5650254487991333,
0.48557108640670776,
0.19827380776405334,
-0.2937770485877991,
-0.07443774491548538,
0.5642430782318115,
-0.09648910164833069,
0.03065229207277298,
-0.6712853908538818,
-0.07233082503080368,
-0.08243795484304428,
-0.0394040010869503,
-0.23448288440704346,
-0.17272058129310608,
-0.20159786939620972,
-0.27557820081710815,
0.7840335369110107,
-0.5306262373924255,
0.07580046355724335,
0.5956075191497803,
-0.16315405070781708,
-0.4928247630596161,
0.2877190411090851,
0.5506029725074768,
0.883338451385498,
0.07830967754125595,
0.4901057481765747,
0.44262468814849854,
-0.15665581822395325,
0.20075784623622894,
-0.5132207274436951,
0.029663223773241043,
-0.2466404289007187,
0.2887158691883087,
0.7303589582443237,
0.07739784568548203,
-0.6397653222084045,
0.14319521188735962,
-0.019122067838907242,
-0.02474880777299404,
-0.010769487358629704,
0.3387526273727417,
-0.03503933921456337,
0.334547221660614,
-0.2745363414287567,
0.11440275609493256,
0.03247915953397751,
-0.8786661028862,
0.21893717348575592,
0.28353187441825867,
-0.21861565113067627,
-0.049517616629600525,
0.3251211643218994,
0.04462800174951553,
-0.4327313303947449,
0.6238540410995483,
-0.20996452867984772,
-0.663469672203064,
0.5269913673400879,
0.8290078043937683,
0.8209203481674194,
-0.24950578808784485,
0.14263653755187988,
0.5184719562530518,
0.6101381778717041,
-0.41378670930862427,
0.4637572467327118,
-0.1322643905878067,
-0.7515451908111572,
-0.5893984436988831,
-0.45493951439857483,
-0.640823245048523,
0.35776016116142273,
-0.4811745882034302,
0.32085564732551575,
-0.6120414137840271,
0.013778483495116234,
-0.22934116423130035,
-0.05506707727909088,
-0.7755003571510315,
0.7130817174911499,
0.1675976812839508,
0.7414283752441406,
-0.5957199335098267,
0.9367437362670898,
0.5044770836830139,
-0.2088014781475067,
-1.118261456489563,
0.21132835745811462,
-0.20648667216300964,
-0.9025751948356628,
0.47177359461784363,
0.10476764291524887,
-0.505731463432312,
-0.2876885235309601,
-0.7330923080444336,
-1.0369987487792969,
0.8657370805740356,
0.3109143078327179,
-1.1500660181045532,
0.1271854192018509,
0.07797639816999435,
0.7235127091407776,
-0.3285331130027771,
0.06277503073215485,
0.8573946952819824,
0.2397012561559677,
0.051344726234674454,
-0.9072279334068298,
0.1688171774148941,
0.14265920221805573,
-0.15716449916362762,
0.3860515058040619,
-0.6086323857307434,
0.8175692558288574,
-0.5828165411949158,
0.13826824724674225,
-0.27978748083114624,
0.5040289163589478,
0.31386277079582214,
0.04661453887820244,
0.728566586971283,
0.5929265022277832,
1.1353760957717896,
0.06202716380357742,
1.006975531578064,
-0.3128056526184082,
0.5728586316108704,
1.4392775297164917,
-0.25389182567596436,
0.8241550922393799,
0.3524855375289917,
-0.08867484331130981,
0.7221180200576782,
0.5434259176254272,
-0.0036164496559649706,
0.14234235882759094,
0.3427143692970276,
0.14488577842712402,
-0.6894441843032837,
0.3815743029117584,
0.03235740214586258,
0.4502151906490326,
0.2865268290042877,
-0.26775169372558594,
-0.1546560376882553,
-0.29875653982162476,
-0.07725073397159576,
0.09208907186985016,
-0.39896589517593384,
0.6245498657226562,
-0.04162681847810745,
-0.802959144115448,
0.6222019195556641,
-0.012721715494990349,
0.33566781878471375,
-0.3893011510372162,
-0.042674023658037186,
-0.1605978161096573,
0.4762915074825287,
-0.3144860565662384,
-0.8922970294952393,
0.17023009061813354,
0.1426198035478592,
-0.012034604325890541,
-0.25793638825416565,
0.9435580372810364,
-0.5610426068305969,
-0.42920583486557007,
0.4099511206150055,
0.4747665822505951,
0.03176628053188324,
-0.03749259188771248,
-0.6616578698158264,
0.06993291527032852,
0.15730707347393036,
0.05048653483390808,
0.22983132302761078,
0.5108527541160583,
-0.18102382123470306,
0.8980776071548462,
0.6359182596206665,
0.11707339435815811,
-0.15009845793247223,
0.2533351480960846,
0.6743541359901428,
-0.8329881429672241,
-0.5439592599868774,
-0.8121336698532104,
0.3924371600151062,
-0.017163632437586784,
-0.5058160424232483,
0.5438493490219116,
0.45055899024009705,
1.2342814207077026,
-0.225437730550766,
0.6415424346923828,
0.20656251907348633,
0.36373424530029297,
-0.6627783179283142,
0.5430529117584229,
-0.42675065994262695,
0.23464085161685944,
-0.15178777277469635,
-0.5679881572723389,
-0.17004650831222534,
0.8515239953994751,
-0.36792007088661194,
0.07121223211288452,
1.053796648979187,
0.9033598303794861,
0.08089017122983932,
-0.1063520759344101,
0.5281261205673218,
0.4273669719696045,
0.37634727358818054,
0.4157886803150177,
0.7596808671951294,
-0.552940309047699,
0.23617634177207947,
-0.514506995677948,
-0.18681445717811584,
0.02331678941845894,
-1.0150262117385864,
-1.3195806741714478,
-0.4106723666191101,
-0.6174328327178955,
-0.6664102673530579,
0.13833799958229065,
1.0849381685256958,
0.604093074798584,
-1.0202335119247437,
-0.26961857080459595,
-0.2954091727733612,
0.31865161657333374,
-0.3563380241394043,
-0.05716771259903908,
0.346262663602829,
-0.8627346754074097,
-0.3888145089149475,
0.5039059519767761,
0.5644677877426147,
-0.029217001050710678,
-0.4178846776485443,
-0.03213883936405182,
-0.1456093192100525,
0.3931909501552582,
0.7243430018424988,
0.10957296192646027,
-0.7779892086982727,
-0.45140430331230164,
-0.03663838654756546,
-0.19985635578632355,
0.059622906148433685,
1.1605037450790405,
-0.605305552482605,
0.8221265077590942,
0.3889234960079193,
0.6430000066757202,
0.4761887192726135,
-0.24846477806568146,
0.43119123578071594,
-0.5431713461875916,
-0.4658675491809845,
-0.020022543147206306,
0.7074962854385376,
0.37102946639060974,
-0.6414361000061035,
0.6547180414199829,
-0.12181662023067474,
-0.7889079451560974,
-0.6891387701034546,
0.1692054122686386,
-0.847059428691864,
-0.07595285028219223,
1.0761477947235107,
-0.18960236012935638,
-0.29448115825653076,
-0.09202230721712112,
-0.5315255522727966,
0.4155299961566925,
0.07109767943620682,
1.3184361457824707,
0.7661645412445068,
-0.1976182907819748,
0.05884328857064247,
-0.13290806114673615,
0.6864404678344727,
0.5574811100959778,
-1.1424763202667236,
0.44944605231285095,
0.1652115285396576,
0.5802546739578247,
0.037120476365089417,
0.45599353313446045,
-0.17714858055114746,
0.35715600848197937,
-0.27472636103630066,
0.0942603275179863,
0.1690840721130371,
-0.5403172373771667,
-0.38533905148506165,
-0.3472043573856354,
0.10731971263885498,
0.0487063005566597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13028v1 | Heterogeneous Graph Reasoning for Fact Checking over Texts and Tables | 2024-02-20T14:10:40 | 2024-02-20T14:10:40 | Haisong Gong, Weizhi Xu, Shu wu, Qiang Liu, Liang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Fact checking aims to predict claim veracity by reasoning over multiple
evidence pieces. It usually involves evidence retrieval and veracity reasoning.
In this paper, we focus on the latter, reasoning over unstructured text and
structured table information. Previous works have primarily relied on
fine-tuning pretrained language models or training homogeneous-graph-based
models. Despite their effectiveness, we argue that they fail to explore the
rich semantic information underlying the evidence with different structures. To
address this, we propose a novel word-level Heterogeneous-graph-based model for
Fact Checking over unstructured and structured information, namely HeterFC. Our
approach leverages a heterogeneous evidence graph, with words as nodes and
thoughtfully designed edges representing different evidence properties. We
perform information propagation via a relational graph neural network,
facilitating interactions between claims and evidence. An attention-based
method is utilized to integrate information, combined with a language model for
generating predictions. We introduce a multitask loss function to account for
potential inaccuracies in evidence retrieval. Comprehensive experiments on the
large fact checking dataset FEVEROUS demonstrate the effectiveness of HeterFC.
Code will be released at: https://github.com/Deno-V/HeterFC. | [
-0.007257496472448111,
-1.2973833084106445,
0.8897549510002136,
0.08323989808559418,
-0.14911213517189026,
0.06551308184862137,
-0.08522576093673706,
-0.33424338698387146,
0.0028922203928232193,
0.46490731835365295,
-0.2733681797981262,
-0.8915296196937561,
-0.6053889393806458,
0.08506904542446136,
-0.3034282326698303,
1.0242822170257568,
-0.21437855064868927,
-0.2979108393192291,
-0.43431907892227173,
-0.19103282690048218,
-0.1444057822227478,
-0.4194001853466034,
0.0014440121594816446,
-0.8778930306434631,
0.5473980903625488,
0.5814520716667175,
0.7777175307273865,
0.8913523554801941,
0.108855240046978,
0.3758181035518646,
0.025847183540463448,
0.5379488468170166,
-0.4116927683353424,
-0.2113039344549179,
-0.17902427911758423,
-0.15289703011512756,
-0.28588515520095825,
0.22442293167114258,
0.6739474534988403,
0.7121300101280212,
-0.062497783452272415,
-0.0815247967839241,
-0.1236109584569931,
0.11924543231725693,
-0.6749253869056702,
0.5842163562774658,
-0.8101305961608887,
0.21213680505752563,
-0.11039989441633224,
-0.184919536113739,
-0.6057584881782532,
-0.5697950720787048,
0.08814946562051773,
-0.5212123394012451,
0.2508842647075653,
0.18142633140087128,
1.1008714437484741,
0.1288105994462967,
-0.5083961486816406,
-0.001288565923459828,
-0.524703860282898,
0.19452765583992004,
-0.5748210549354553,
0.5385773181915283,
0.6957877278327942,
-0.037125419825315475,
-0.1267320066690445,
-1.127546787261963,
-0.7440800070762634,
-0.26163941621780396,
-0.3780994117259979,
0.11753225326538086,
-0.05690675601363182,
0.051912423223257065,
0.2974299490451813,
0.2566682994365692,
-0.3974000811576843,
-0.14765025675296783,
0.14563825726509094,
-0.6670728325843811,
0.26304012537002563,
-0.06341204792261124,
0.18907129764556885,
-0.4057042598724365,
-0.4507005512714386,
0.10678113996982574,
-0.6192781925201416,
-0.08324725180864334,
0.5427663922309875,
0.46012359857559204,
-0.06051415205001831,
0.811141848564148,
-0.3925209939479828,
0.7341228127479553,
-0.0950077697634697,
-0.20139941573143005,
0.24947726726531982,
-0.47741711139678955,
-0.21228055655956268,
0.5174304246902466,
0.6854656934738159,
0.22286637127399445,
-0.19741283357143402,
-0.4800499379634857,
-0.06887772679328918,
0.39015769958496094,
-0.040334802120923996,
-0.9223125576972961,
-0.25944364070892334,
0.2764705717563629,
-0.41541242599487305,
-0.28541725873947144,
0.0773862972855568,
-0.6517363786697388,
-0.3029506504535675,
-0.05902698636054993,
0.3269244432449341,
-0.5822311043739319,
0.02743227779865265,
0.17468872666358948,
-0.2315240502357483,
-0.5233516693115234,
0.49421533942222595,
-0.40106400847435,
-0.034254271537065506,
0.6170082092285156,
0.7911361455917358,
0.23016174137592316,
-0.45321476459503174,
-0.881797194480896,
0.2086181789636612,
-0.14234919846057892,
1.2179546356201172,
-0.7062780261039734,
-0.07233954221010208,
0.3149731159210205,
0.06664229184389114,
-0.06573183834552765,
-0.01191510446369648,
0.8484171628952026,
-0.5623850226402283,
0.48484790325164795,
-0.3578645884990692,
-0.6649982929229736,
-0.2053861767053604,
0.6615335941314697,
-0.6641781330108643,
0.8799883127212524,
0.08217178285121918,
-1.3366199731826782,
0.44666123390197754,
-0.49786806106567383,
-0.7706145644187927,
0.13087497651576996,
-0.29809442162513733,
-0.5963268280029297,
-0.5834514498710632,
0.08283943682909012,
0.27993154525756836,
-0.19782212376594543,
0.3857102394104004,
-0.625366747379303,
-0.1138453483581543,
0.04011743143200874,
-0.17517513036727905,
0.5079056620597839,
0.23065145313739777,
-0.3037533760070801,
0.2341691106557846,
-0.7964094877243042,
0.12236945331096649,
-0.010789715684950352,
-0.8450169563293457,
-0.19620655477046967,
0.3274802267551422,
-0.006213096436113119,
0.03912293538451195,
-0.00002119944110745564,
-1.0070936679840088,
0.06643636524677277,
-0.1431720107793808,
0.4187220633029938,
0.3206501007080078,
-0.005651529412716627,
0.12890276312828064,
-0.18467232584953308,
-0.2178322821855545,
-0.001164159970358014,
-0.06435336917638779,
-0.018322914838790894,
-0.5285298228263855,
-0.23754289746284485,
-0.09031684696674347,
0.45079556107521057,
0.5648487210273743,
-1.0126820802688599,
0.42989179491996765,
-0.2420589029788971,
-0.07520997524261475,
0.020959438756108284,
-0.23486778140068054,
0.3407990038394928,
1.1013377904891968,
0.531926691532135,
0.05043879151344299,
-0.4725727140903473,
-0.5888828039169312,
-0.30564695596694946,
-0.385762482881546,
0.18985265493392944,
0.30708014965057373,
0.4825964570045471,
-0.5231294631958008,
0.9535537362098694,
-0.6307181715965271,
-0.1941058188676834,
-0.08483143895864487,
0.4989953935146332,
0.11178916692733765,
0.25032544136047363,
0.3337668776512146,
-0.7347788214683533,
-0.27214866876602173,
0.26627010107040405,
-0.8246596455574036,
0.05023694038391113,
0.10593987256288528,
0.041583266109228134,
0.10682173073291779,
0.532558023929596,
-0.6018319725990295,
0.7163457870483398,
0.22139722108840942,
-0.796495795249939,
0.32943081855773926,
-0.2669186294078827,
0.2191828042268753,
-0.641950249671936,
0.10697533190250397,
0.16165265440940857,
-0.4700859487056732,
-0.5512747168540955,
-0.26911190152168274,
0.10175260156393051,
0.07771389931440353,
0.010450792498886585,
0.11489924788475037,
-0.35946011543273926,
-0.00023088102170731872,
-0.34924760460853577,
0.04523193836212158,
0.14009016752243042,
0.4449531137943268,
0.022740574553608894,
0.28396210074424744,
0.24630825221538544,
-0.3259912133216858,
0.5229011178016663,
0.5077695250511169,
-0.4317072629928589,
0.42764148116111755,
-0.6031884551048279,
0.06861954182386398,
-0.1979772001504898,
0.37163200974464417,
-0.8632417917251587,
-0.3523242175579071,
0.22040630877017975,
-0.339457631111145,
0.22319796681404114,
-0.28397127985954285,
-0.6879065632820129,
-0.48003092408180237,
0.006808989215642214,
-0.0749746635556221,
-0.0669328048825264,
-0.6952105760574341,
0.9500635266304016,
0.45596054196357727,
0.1767074167728424,
-0.765716552734375,
-0.4448549151420593,
0.016119806095957756,
0.23856180906295776,
-0.7099837064743042,
0.49747058749198914,
0.23069584369659424,
-0.45304057002067566,
0.44197818636894226,
-0.4597698748111725,
-0.1818360984325409,
-0.042976073920726776,
0.4401281476020813,
0.401742547750473,
-0.3308040201663971,
0.2518918812274933,
-0.07700313627719879,
0.12313937395811081,
0.0444335862994194,
-0.457448810338974,
0.363101065158844,
-0.4009796380996704,
-0.4209289848804474,
-0.08090289682149887,
0.18122223019599915,
0.3945367932319641,
-0.16655680537223816,
0.840675950050354,
0.5729785561561584,
-0.5223429799079895,
-0.11816264688968658,
-0.5889889001846313,
-0.1493251770734787,
-0.3566112816333771,
0.3753354251384735,
-0.3226411044597626,
-0.8731347918510437,
0.6059225797653198,
-0.2979518473148346,
0.0273091159760952,
0.6854120492935181,
0.6485925912857056,
0.07668869942426682,
0.7893498539924622,
0.498737633228302,
0.074463851749897,
0.2133355736732483,
-0.14844173192977905,
0.17431113123893738,
-0.19914545118808746,
-0.5679721236228943,
-0.7327245473861694,
0.07413247227668762,
-0.35179370641708374,
-0.4096686542034149,
0.3831682503223419,
-0.3092879056930542,
-0.26951494812965393,
0.045379433780908585,
-0.34574073553085327,
0.5958982110023499,
0.18269090354442596,
0.283886194229126,
0.6138855814933777,
0.1302555501461029,
-0.4228914678096771,
0.5386815667152405,
-0.8855336308479309,
-0.3374291956424713,
0.7106373310089111,
0.39910149574279785,
0.7583507895469666,
-0.10622680932283401,
0.23919188976287842,
0.39779239892959595,
0.5005990862846375,
-0.4148402512073517,
0.2699422836303711,
-0.1145058423280716,
-0.7244170904159546,
-0.5632627606391907,
-0.8484427332878113,
-0.7205718159675598,
0.35041719675064087,
-0.5599901676177979,
-0.8058033585548401,
0.2451009452342987,
0.13544373214244843,
-0.2632928788661957,
0.5960052013397217,
-0.632091224193573,
0.9044173359870911,
0.1439809799194336,
-0.6842958331108093,
-0.23038223385810852,
-0.7895967364311218,
0.41878584027290344,
0.21917662024497986,
0.29024699330329895,
-0.2200329750776291,
0.5729626417160034,
0.4344581365585327,
-0.6024035215377808,
0.7016322016716003,
-0.10943174362182617,
-0.06432099640369415,
0.46899673342704773,
-0.009786593727767467,
0.7489926815032959,
0.46891671419143677,
-0.26082152128219604,
0.05717388540506363,
0.00808450672775507,
-0.24640636146068573,
-0.2798471748828888,
0.6850643754005432,
-0.6846479773521423,
-0.3931402266025543,
-0.41185930371284485,
-0.8406578302383423,
-0.30714109539985657,
0.4715639352798462,
0.5739302635192871,
0.6103293299674988,
-0.37730473279953003,
0.231979101896286,
0.6949553489685059,
0.17800219357013702,
0.16978614032268524,
0.4391244947910309,
-0.05029071867465973,
-0.0939587876200676,
0.7421912550926208,
0.10390820354223251,
-0.1143481582403183,
0.48948991298675537,
0.46553829312324524,
-0.5546819567680359,
-0.35851290822029114,
-0.4654710590839386,
0.042933836579322815,
-0.898945152759552,
-0.3141651153564453,
-1.0558351278305054,
-0.07291682064533234,
-0.45020079612731934,
0.40819305181503296,
-0.33147168159484863,
-0.32471510767936707,
0.09226527810096741,
-0.09631496667861938,
0.42935851216316223,
0.7163281440734863,
-0.022955263033509254,
0.0026303441263735294,
-0.6225892305374146,
0.6142694354057312,
0.39246881008148193,
0.8110455274581909,
-0.3943750262260437,
-0.2768726348876953,
-0.22292259335517883,
0.1415775567293167,
0.046447090804576874,
-0.9965773820877075,
-0.2157335728406906,
0.06146863475441933,
0.6201993823051453,
0.3211964964866638,
0.1979355365037918,
0.13223931193351746,
-0.5024157166481018,
0.23843474686145782,
0.16606873273849487,
-0.7963305711746216,
0.28608423471450806,
-0.282509446144104,
-0.08805648237466812,
0.5367670059204102,
0.38408488035202026,
-0.4236263930797577,
-0.1296166330575943,
-0.7266929149627686,
-0.5255742073059082,
0.7554929256439209,
0.10397068411111832,
-0.3706393241882324,
0.21979525685310364,
0.23841671645641327,
-0.045251160860061646,
0.22511030733585358,
-0.6749529838562012,
-0.162758007645607,
-0.8432031869888306,
-0.1197042241692543,
0.20965835452079773,
-0.12876969575881958,
-0.6180995106697083,
-0.2656726539134979,
0.5862645506858826,
-0.6162751913070679,
0.1944710910320282,
0.32915300130844116,
-0.0019152597524225712,
-0.2632793188095093,
0.34229251742362976,
0.2749408483505249,
0.4452168345451355,
-0.4144960045814514,
0.7457433342933655,
0.1739635467529297,
-0.5961647033691406,
0.0009064771584235132,
0.6636683344841003,
-0.15228188037872314,
0.20024564862251282,
0.5140408873558044,
0.7620298862457275,
-0.061280447989702225,
-0.19443145394325256,
0.4124167561531067,
-0.1608290672302246,
-0.48726949095726013,
0.3888428807258606,
-0.11021678894758224,
0.1937970519065857,
0.09386125206947327,
0.04852099344134331,
0.01470533013343811,
0.09687778353691101,
-0.974429190158844,
0.2608359158039093,
0.27168548107147217,
-0.1720309853553772,
-0.061244264245033264,
0.5152472257614136,
0.03626291826367378,
0.09611952304840088,
0.7714446783065796,
-0.3072773516178131,
-0.7563449144363403,
0.5691191554069519,
0.5354859232902527,
0.372309148311615,
0.06601113080978394,
0.39912518858909607,
0.3294837772846222,
0.27679258584976196,
-0.14049741625785828,
0.16378284990787506,
-0.024833938106894493,
-1.0953881740570068,
-0.4450446665287018,
-0.3618384301662445,
-0.41670772433280945,
0.16127941012382507,
0.025007599964737892,
-0.2809353470802307,
-0.5521122217178345,
-0.18206371366977692,
0.6317867040634155,
0.013178098946809769,
-0.38701122999191284,
0.31162190437316895,
-0.07394879311323166,
0.6577045917510986,
-0.992439866065979,
0.8353813290596008,
0.6327018141746521,
-0.43886515498161316,
-1.0501009225845337,
0.08873401582241058,
0.049533482640981674,
-0.6221590638160706,
0.5334378480911255,
-0.07642385363578796,
-0.2065179944038391,
-0.29605787992477417,
-0.7577555179595947,
-0.6405524015426636,
0.6672617793083191,
0.38402682542800903,
-0.19570663571357727,
0.029258297756314278,
0.0773744136095047,
0.3422646224498749,
-0.36982181668281555,
0.12438470125198364,
0.5259615182876587,
0.8350465297698975,
0.4071390926837921,
-0.4814700782299042,
0.22427019476890564,
-0.2627834975719452,
-0.35515305399894714,
-0.07324541360139847,
-0.28168243169784546,
1.1521235704421997,
-0.4186556339263916,
-0.3925632834434509,
-0.44279009103775024,
0.8096283674240112,
0.032193493098020554,
0.7077969908714294,
0.6971362233161926,
0.6738322973251343,
0.9994350671768188,
-0.29695001244544983,
1.1365711688995361,
-0.2509947121143341,
0.5522279143333435,
1.2936592102050781,
-0.7133259773254395,
0.16922400891780853,
0.20317156612873077,
-0.033096980303525925,
0.9841752648353577,
0.5343102812767029,
-0.17276014387607574,
0.32563453912734985,
0.004136302508413792,
-0.131394624710083,
-0.36665305495262146,
-0.5483431816101074,
-0.30583885312080383,
0.3842446208000183,
0.15704777836799622,
-0.042404890060424805,
-0.6270267367362976,
-0.2767808735370636,
0.13886873424053192,
0.2995930016040802,
-0.025261549279093742,
0.44482195377349854,
-0.3629084527492523,
-0.7830202579498291,
0.4056178331375122,
0.36950790882110596,
0.1870093196630478,
-0.4615478813648224,
-0.18882808089256287,
0.04085060581564903,
0.13707132637500763,
-0.6047150492668152,
-1.066308617591858,
0.22477498650550842,
0.030221575871109962,
-0.250532865524292,
0.03060269169509411,
1.2377803325653076,
-0.4917405843734741,
-0.061645593494176865,
0.07931314408779144,
0.6212781071662903,
-0.2992808520793915,
-0.2243167757987976,
-0.45231515169143677,
-0.08679512143135071,
-0.01628853939473629,
-0.14017842710018158,
-0.015870606526732445,
0.7407540082931519,
-0.07493636757135391,
0.4168059229850769,
0.8284537196159363,
-0.1828213930130005,
-0.42367950081825256,
0.3302266299724579,
1.0143070220947266,
-0.20893476903438568,
-0.8566601276397705,
-0.7295743227005005,
0.06271281838417053,
-0.2823772728443146,
-0.037070173770189285,
0.8852887749671936,
0.6421085596084595,
0.45555779337882996,
0.21903494000434875,
0.7366032004356384,
-0.1691047102212906,
0.27373066544532776,
-0.5315552353858948,
0.711982250213623,
-0.24597972631454468,
-0.10084529221057892,
-0.35495293140411377,
-0.5193040370941162,
-0.15693704783916473,
0.6269910931587219,
-0.442569762468338,
-0.07987656444311142,
0.881412148475647,
0.469330370426178,
-0.21324634552001953,
0.5318155884742737,
0.018133901059627533,
0.42752352356910706,
0.07945254445075989,
0.36081039905548096,
0.9181016087532043,
-0.07201776653528214,
0.32844802737236023,
-0.12196176499128342,
-0.06267305463552475,
-0.29725146293640137,
-0.9931148886680603,
-0.9752430319786072,
-0.4031218886375427,
-0.47536519169807434,
-1.011060118675232,
-0.08794478327035904,
0.664047360420227,
0.750060498714447,
-0.5950117111206055,
0.24003323912620544,
-0.2160552740097046,
0.716489315032959,
0.09909939765930176,
-0.17817433178424835,
0.583246648311615,
-0.037793099880218506,
-0.02479405142366886,
0.30103540420532227,
0.3123767077922821,
-0.06160851940512657,
0.22992412745952606,
0.03682458773255348,
-0.7397700548171997,
0.12235432118177414,
0.4596257507801056,
0.31498557329177856,
-0.40956512093544006,
-0.5812830328941345,
-0.23594024777412415,
-0.42874541878700256,
0.2878914773464203,
0.9739724397659302,
-0.6923355460166931,
0.2296934425830841,
0.7394878268241882,
0.5593456625938416,
0.75223708152771,
0.06469156593084335,
0.1129528135061264,
-0.7267647385597229,
0.15681537985801697,
0.22108234465122223,
0.607799768447876,
0.3821139633655548,
-0.7093386650085449,
0.47269415855407715,
0.6999211311340332,
-0.3317095637321472,
-0.7918999791145325,
0.22830045223236084,
-0.8008914589881897,
-0.6335378289222717,
0.9496497511863708,
-0.22083598375320435,
-0.4134868383407593,
-0.45019033551216125,
0.17611515522003174,
0.7121083736419678,
-0.23714599013328552,
0.7997332811355591,
0.6883990168571472,
-0.05366545543074608,
0.25454089045524597,
-0.1884070187807083,
0.541146993637085,
0.17752677202224731,
-1.2423365116119385,
0.3134397566318512,
0.71934974193573,
0.3460734486579895,
0.48916512727737427,
0.5370137691497803,
-0.0978129655122757,
0.29079097509384155,
0.39662688970565796,
-0.03806420788168907,
-0.4222819209098816,
-0.5395916104316711,
0.27025893330574036,
0.4873449206352234,
-0.3830815553665161,
0.10390177369117737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13025v1 | CFEVER: A Chinese Fact Extraction and VERification Dataset | 2024-02-20T14:08:24 | 2024-02-20T14:08:24 | Ying-Jia Lin, Chun-Yi Lin, Chia-Jen Yeh, Yi-Ting Li, Yun-Yu Hu, Chih-Hao Hsu, Mei-Feng Lee, Hung-Yu Kao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present CFEVER, a Chinese dataset designed for Fact Extraction and
VERification. CFEVER comprises 30,012 manually created claims based on content
in Chinese Wikipedia. Each claim in CFEVER is labeled as "Supports", "Refutes",
or "Not Enough Info" to depict its degree of factualness. Similar to the FEVER
dataset, claims in the "Supports" and "Refutes" categories are also annotated
with corresponding evidence sentences sourced from single or multiple pages in
Chinese Wikipedia. Our labeled dataset holds a Fleiss' kappa value of 0.7934
for five-way inter-annotator agreement. In addition, through the experiments
with the state-of-the-art approaches developed on the FEVER dataset and a
simple baseline for CFEVER, we demonstrate that our dataset is a new rigorous
benchmark for factual extraction and verification, which can be further used
for developing automated systems to alleviate human fact-checking efforts.
CFEVER is available at https://ikmlab.github.io/CFEVER. | [
-0.4859158396720886,
-0.49820032715797424,
0.29415276646614075,
0.3312487304210663,
-0.2213112860918045,
-0.42268872261047363,
-0.29349952936172485,
-0.5167300701141357,
0.060099080204963684,
0.2738644480705261,
-0.2590954005718231,
-0.35585519671440125,
-0.3283062279224396,
0.4691268801689148,
-0.6066024899482727,
1.118276596069336,
0.23941966891288757,
-0.10089731216430664,
-0.09126254171133041,
0.02796008810400963,
0.022047003731131554,
-0.2084205597639084,
-0.3730318248271942,
-0.2178405076265335,
0.6622821092605591,
0.7811347246170044,
0.7186470627784729,
0.6418030858039856,
0.5051800608634949,
0.27805572748184204,
0.5161446332931519,
0.38519537448883057,
-0.4637661278247833,
-0.28796035051345825,
-0.13080808520317078,
-0.06756336241960526,
-0.12085480988025665,
0.1529081165790558,
0.5369823575019836,
0.24536144733428955,
-0.1743498593568802,
0.38542085886001587,
-0.15812407433986664,
0.25811341404914856,
-0.5465809106826782,
0.05167689919471741,
-0.5759351849555969,
0.09286913275718689,
-0.478815495967865,
0.05100663751363754,
-0.2763305604457855,
-0.4847356975078583,
0.3563273549079895,
-0.7770179510116577,
0.6239975690841675,
0.15431417524814606,
1.1816210746765137,
0.05737391486763954,
-0.37203308939933777,
-0.12062331289052963,
-0.39370954036712646,
0.28565919399261475,
-0.716885507106781,
0.5800673365592957,
0.20546799898147583,
0.3276022970676422,
-0.08846619725227356,
-1.054693341255188,
-0.9181768298149109,
-0.2503604590892792,
-0.362714022397995,
0.03087291307747364,
0.04129056632518768,
-0.20388366281986237,
0.29287484288215637,
0.5819735527038574,
-0.4672800600528717,
-0.26359426975250244,
-0.5795261859893799,
-0.6498673558235168,
0.9771360754966736,
-0.18820667266845703,
0.542423665523529,
-0.4909999668598175,
-0.5979048609733582,
0.026596739888191223,
-0.6780648231506348,
0.05794049799442291,
-0.12026876211166382,
0.2554301917552948,
-0.02958877943456173,
0.5084390640258789,
-0.3349587023258209,
0.4373970925807953,
0.2727520763874054,
-0.20309557020664215,
0.3251362144947052,
-0.3463013470172882,
-0.4812508821487427,
0.5426782369613647,
0.9606149792671204,
0.2709653973579407,
0.04549628868699074,
-0.3019004166126251,
-0.2330089956521988,
-0.6264945864677429,
0.05472211912274361,
-0.817050039768219,
-0.6279036998748779,
0.2847743332386017,
-0.6058730483055115,
-0.4064079523086548,
0.7840956449508667,
-0.8381999135017395,
-0.7882548570632935,
-0.15331092476844788,
0.2610231041908264,
-0.5265557169914246,
-0.7393449544906616,
-0.10647957772016525,
-0.39406993985176086,
0.525898277759552,
0.19902554154396057,
-0.5747456550598145,
-0.031894005835056305,
0.8063285946846008,
0.767515242099762,
-0.006486466620117426,
-0.4185137450695038,
-0.3945600986480713,
-0.19175276160240173,
-0.5866600275039673,
1.0760176181793213,
-0.24948929250240326,
-0.22868138551712036,
-0.05060378462076187,
0.16606974601745605,
0.19956479966640472,
-0.5077497363090515,
1.0291153192520142,
-0.38635826110839844,
0.2471313178539276,
-0.9014533162117004,
-0.5866350531578064,
-0.2825913727283478,
0.37746021151542664,
-0.9267114996910095,
1.1536637544631958,
-0.035284366458654404,
-1.074494481086731,
0.4196690618991852,
-0.5329349040985107,
-0.5393487811088562,
0.1563342809677124,
-0.27654948830604553,
-0.12540209293365479,
-0.03283064439892769,
0.024155598133802414,
0.3900316059589386,
-0.40412166714668274,
0.4437428414821625,
-0.396644651889801,
-0.2401595115661621,
0.40297767519950867,
-0.47224369645118713,
1.0097544193267822,
0.4298422634601593,
-0.4118186831474304,
-0.19463616609573364,
-1.0175889730453491,
-0.3162466287612915,
0.2412368804216385,
-0.44050830602645874,
-0.27091506123542786,
0.05048428848385811,
0.08585206419229507,
0.3245302736759186,
0.3704289495944977,
-0.9634225368499756,
0.09351048618555069,
-0.18735279142856598,
-0.04811037704348564,
0.6316251158714294,
-0.02546376734972,
-0.09465218335390091,
-0.24165083467960358,
-0.04650912806391716,
0.0995735228061676,
0.14010511338710785,
-0.15622460842132568,
-0.23236270248889923,
-0.9296680092811584,
-0.16608259081840515,
0.453651487827301,
0.6427653431892395,
-0.8498527407646179,
0.35828787088394165,
-0.287018358707428,
-0.7469902038574219,
-0.2888529598712921,
0.1307944655418396,
0.011882512830197811,
1.0054423809051514,
0.390216201543808,
0.2798905074596405,
-0.6621321439743042,
-0.9366328716278076,
0.01226838119328022,
-0.4475301504135132,
-0.23824913799762726,
-0.1469753384590149,
0.3303126394748688,
0.017897162586450577,
1.207564115524292,
-0.4513421356678009,
-0.19441458582878113,
0.05419118329882622,
0.04478636384010315,
0.2561759352684021,
0.2964666187763214,
0.806242823600769,
-1.1549508571624756,
-0.29835253953933716,
0.2729737162590027,
-1.0466196537017822,
-0.06514202058315277,
-0.2645821273326874,
-0.32007452845573425,
0.23235298693180084,
0.32013750076293945,
-0.37819358706474304,
0.3030413091182709,
0.20868098735809326,
-0.370109885931015,
0.7921253442764282,
0.06935511529445648,
0.3289031982421875,
-0.7778347730636597,
0.4418792128562927,
0.2662324905395508,
-0.16588012874126434,
-0.625111997127533,
-0.0940089300274849,
0.17470966279506683,
0.21845179796218872,
-0.4994274079799652,
0.3577791452407837,
-0.17812855541706085,
0.32163965702056885,
-0.2374216765165329,
0.09167944639921188,
0.005103150848299265,
0.30601733922958374,
0.21269114315509796,
0.4967614710330963,
0.5447679162025452,
-0.6511609554290771,
0.8901087045669556,
0.10401113331317902,
-0.3626323640346527,
0.7357190251350403,
-0.4752466082572937,
-0.2308914065361023,
0.087284155189991,
0.32359978556632996,
-0.8760784864425659,
-0.44462865591049194,
0.7077839374542236,
-0.36491671204566956,
-0.07211565971374512,
0.1289537101984024,
-0.6679019331932068,
-0.4273711144924164,
-0.4038460850715637,
-0.05399587005376816,
0.050075072795152664,
-0.9340667128562927,
0.4767744839191437,
0.32931286096572876,
0.044904906302690506,
-0.7920948266983032,
-0.5227007269859314,
0.11958394199609756,
-0.2469179928302765,
-0.5223419666290283,
0.18815456330776215,
-0.029803214594721794,
-0.33138319849967957,
0.0771404430270195,
-0.3372710943222046,
-0.3372511565685272,
0.07999765872955322,
0.15968388319015503,
0.3888832926750183,
-0.6274412870407104,
0.2037937194108963,
-0.1418057382106781,
0.046934518963098526,
0.3730548620223999,
-0.4508899450302124,
-0.0889328122138977,
-0.12887299060821533,
-0.21059352159500122,
-0.33957910537719727,
0.06977938115596771,
0.12022942304611206,
-0.05139513686299324,
0.44786596298217773,
0.865034818649292,
-0.9153633713722229,
0.14231353998184204,
-0.6774238348007202,
0.008939760737121105,
-0.494399756193161,
0.06919603794813156,
-0.1909443587064743,
-0.4115524888038635,
0.32651400566101074,
0.17104800045490265,
0.7615603804588318,
1.0308488607406616,
0.20038644969463348,
-0.07258196920156479,
0.5869268178939819,
0.369963675737381,
-0.2648042142391205,
0.06424478441476822,
0.07083187252283096,
-0.054547570645809174,
-0.11566142737865448,
-0.46592238545417786,
-0.6022509336471558,
-0.10232160985469818,
-0.42030662298202515,
-0.24488790333271027,
0.015444737859070301,
-0.15880082547664642,
-0.340603232383728,
0.12519019842147827,
-0.38797590136528015,
0.4522135853767395,
0.41097354888916016,
0.2012363225221634,
0.2915199398994446,
-0.05507320538163185,
0.01381105650216341,
0.025662237778306007,
-0.7491348385810852,
-0.3279184401035309,
0.7573836445808411,
0.10626601427793503,
0.25540366768836975,
0.1884889453649521,
0.5080652236938477,
0.6667121648788452,
0.8272541165351868,
-0.3695226311683655,
0.4279530644416809,
-0.18119928240776062,
-1.0304454565048218,
-0.34341832995414734,
-0.5118352770805359,
-0.6442022919654846,
0.2049575299024582,
-0.4960596561431885,
-0.4618363678455353,
0.2814878821372986,
0.0021079860161989927,
-0.4344864785671234,
0.37813499569892883,
-0.508836567401886,
0.7626164555549622,
-0.48010820150375366,
-0.23266474902629852,
0.006705558393150568,
-0.5091676115989685,
0.7961869835853577,
-0.13927337527275085,
0.3237934708595276,
-0.24638058245182037,
0.10697221755981445,
0.7784523963928223,
-0.6502984166145325,
0.6917951703071594,
-0.40058258175849915,
-0.5191952586174011,
0.5378100275993347,
-0.11827370524406433,
0.043843433260917664,
0.5473617911338806,
-0.4034188389778137,
0.3958347737789154,
0.2344503551721573,
-0.3478069305419922,
-0.27586761116981506,
0.6876305341720581,
-0.6070011854171753,
-0.5793564915657043,
-0.7421077489852905,
0.089711993932724,
0.11067429184913635,
0.6430965065956116,
0.3918780982494354,
0.45997199416160583,
-0.5900206565856934,
0.15241122245788574,
0.8576015830039978,
-0.36488887667655945,
0.2208823412656784,
0.4985904395580292,
-0.27090898156166077,
-0.49117571115493774,
1.331526517868042,
0.18665267527103424,
-0.3408066928386688,
0.3873346149921417,
0.38450995087623596,
-0.367323637008667,
-0.13080817461013794,
-0.3926849961280823,
0.1970262974500656,
-0.9268381595611572,
-0.394970566034317,
-0.3133077025413513,
-0.48328498005867004,
-0.5758329033851624,
0.07935848087072372,
-0.31903406977653503,
-0.37255194783210754,
-0.12451883405447006,
-0.40800848603248596,
0.4363957643508911,
0.6811398863792419,
-0.4853612184524536,
-0.04842390492558479,
-0.8763758540153503,
0.6755138635635376,
0.11968432366847992,
0.41848012804985046,
-0.1868458092212677,
-0.27510035037994385,
-0.44130703806877136,
0.13738012313842773,
-0.2579367458820343,
-0.8645713925361633,
-0.1154041439294815,
0.24433261156082153,
0.7726811170578003,
1.1447902917861938,
0.5232256650924683,
0.7779121398925781,
-0.24016046524047852,
0.9853699207305908,
0.169624924659729,
-0.8479153513908386,
0.3856663107872009,
-0.10780633240938187,
-0.21001215279102325,
0.527441680431366,
0.416141152381897,
-0.7216440439224243,
-0.16722814738750458,
-0.8628002405166626,
-0.43541479110717773,
0.6965008974075317,
0.12014049291610718,
-0.13814273476600647,
-0.027529876679182053,
0.6042804718017578,
0.38371118903160095,
-0.15135900676250458,
-0.3953286409378052,
-0.581432044506073,
-0.6592280268669128,
-0.25719550251960754,
0.06899814307689667,
-0.20331761240959167,
-0.11629641056060791,
-0.22551511228084564,
0.783764660358429,
-0.07721872627735138,
0.1019958034157753,
0.6647377610206604,
-0.19707973301410675,
0.07794901728630066,
-0.16166351735591888,
0.5255725383758545,
0.7069719433784485,
-0.1641249805688858,
0.3371292054653168,
0.2977284789085388,
-0.4631747901439667,
-0.18033382296562195,
0.5293406844139099,
-0.19533652067184448,
0.39801809191703796,
0.4713498651981354,
0.20549221336841583,
0.26513832807540894,
-0.6276645064353943,
0.4189707338809967,
-0.35309067368507385,
-0.26287612318992615,
-0.4276900589466095,
0.16924411058425903,
-0.18680411577224731,
0.08477792888879776,
0.66399747133255,
-0.06864326447248459,
0.4056476652622223,
-0.04473021626472473,
0.704479992389679,
-0.04621734097599983,
-0.16588474810123444,
-0.4522148072719574,
0.7160805463790894,
0.42636528611183167,
0.2221127450466156,
0.8028082847595215,
0.05212778225541115,
-0.370682954788208,
0.6418741941452026,
0.09649660438299179,
0.45371052622795105,
-0.06049201264977455,
0.5204901695251465,
0.7486191391944885,
0.40282419323921204,
-0.26597970724105835,
0.04106447845697403,
-0.11522232741117477,
-0.7217943072319031,
0.06436793506145477,
-0.28090593218803406,
-0.3547564744949341,
0.17307879030704498,
-0.4990250766277313,
0.6309636831283569,
-0.4745250344276428,
0.05011087656021118,
0.27525490522384644,
0.33156782388687134,
-0.5644850730895996,
0.4118135869503021,
0.5961249470710754,
1.5240187644958496,
-0.6738568544387817,
0.801188051700592,
0.42515578866004944,
-0.5527809858322144,
-0.7264537811279297,
0.1491110771894455,
0.35259249806404114,
-0.47849518060684204,
0.28642529249191284,
0.33280354738235474,
0.055602628737688065,
-0.2934773862361908,
-0.866201639175415,
-0.6899520754814148,
1.087263584136963,
0.5016074180603027,
-0.1853068619966507,
0.15338049829006195,
0.140175461769104,
0.2475411742925644,
-0.19273777306079865,
-0.12462776899337769,
0.6130226850509644,
0.8081252574920654,
0.08935797214508057,
-0.5985627770423889,
0.30985838174819946,
-0.3729592263698578,
-0.6036149263381958,
-0.297471284866333,
-0.8899039626121521,
0.5446648597717285,
-0.29800719022750854,
-0.40558111667633057,
-0.08168403804302216,
1.2618672847747803,
0.39691174030303955,
0.6269779205322266,
0.800121545791626,
0.03147453814744949,
1.2529126405715942,
-0.14387676119804382,
0.7752963304519653,
-0.1599624752998352,
0.3330061137676239,
0.8366786241531372,
-0.23029448091983795,
0.5613212585449219,
0.12743264436721802,
0.04174713045358658,
0.514781653881073,
1.0038846731185913,
-0.27329346537590027,
0.1617925465106964,
-0.07163290679454803,
-0.06616518646478653,
-0.34144020080566406,
-0.05908159911632538,
-0.5561034679412842,
0.3690539300441742,
0.4402928352355957,
-0.18012414872646332,
-0.26772403717041016,
-0.2460363507270813,
0.4012347459793091,
-0.3000332713127136,
-0.09989960491657257,
0.6135779023170471,
-0.12355384975671768,
-0.8763986229896545,
0.4806804060935974,
0.10242235660552979,
0.48779091238975525,
-0.5880045890808105,
-0.11286181956529617,
-0.4181743562221527,
-0.1427759975194931,
-0.6656660437583923,
-0.777579128742218,
0.12603943049907684,
0.2992086112499237,
-0.07495293766260147,
0.3353517949581146,
0.9469138383865356,
-0.3945416808128357,
-0.7252125144004822,
-0.28730711340904236,
0.10063312202692032,
0.1869714856147766,
0.017065294086933136,
-0.6435638070106506,
-0.2420179396867752,
0.1643674522638321,
-0.22551625967025757,
-0.13710792362689972,
0.9308100342750549,
0.07297583669424057,
0.3764093220233917,
0.8185713887214661,
0.05488135293126106,
0.0674709603190422,
-0.28019028902053833,
0.7139764428138733,
-0.7123035788536072,
-0.3110640347003937,
-0.9028198719024658,
0.3478172719478607,
-0.5168954730033875,
-0.24284794926643372,
0.8950697183609009,
0.8508408665657043,
0.6593706607818604,
0.20592185854911804,
1.1701432466506958,
-0.6658298373222351,
0.171936497092247,
-0.3016316294670105,
0.8684354424476624,
-0.4913029074668884,
-0.037999771535396576,
-0.15211625397205353,
-0.34957411885261536,
-0.3493157923221588,
0.4782353639602661,
0.2745295763015747,
-0.36777034401893616,
0.4725601375102997,
0.5662490129470825,
-0.17867374420166016,
0.48359382152557373,
-0.005546641070395708,
0.21216672658920288,
0.5059158802032471,
0.3103187382221222,
0.6814211010932922,
-0.36470040678977966,
0.7630776762962341,
-0.614833652973175,
-0.23811914026737213,
-0.28878891468048096,
-1.011171579360962,
-0.6583868861198425,
-0.6946565508842468,
-0.474247545003891,
-0.5392636656761169,
-0.27899688482284546,
1.00664484500885,
0.6310276985168457,
-1.0103505849838257,
-0.0437886044383049,
0.418129563331604,
0.3852077126502991,
-0.4469826817512512,
-0.22140584886074066,
0.507842481136322,
-0.22466161847114563,
-0.4318206012248993,
0.15771247446537018,
-0.08517685532569885,
-0.1324882209300995,
-0.2475568950176239,
-0.24720053374767303,
-0.2815101444721222,
0.24992813169956207,
0.3398756682872772,
0.7708444595336914,
-0.5418351888656616,
-0.4692823588848114,
0.016159769147634506,
-0.18952497839927673,
0.08896683156490326,
0.9163451194763184,
-0.5533398389816284,
0.33388423919677734,
0.5531561970710754,
0.7490053176879883,
-0.16911596059799194,
0.07432016730308533,
0.4654158651828766,
-0.7740458250045776,
-0.1085226833820343,
-0.4770794212818146,
0.46622079610824585,
0.3885698914527893,
-0.5320897698402405,
0.5271329879760742,
0.5122250914573669,
-0.29132744669914246,
-0.8166753053665161,
-0.32567286491394043,
-0.8928754925727844,
-0.17918770015239716,
0.9689072966575623,
-0.24395127594470978,
-0.19667989015579224,
-0.17785154283046722,
-0.2535209655761719,
0.4720984101295471,
-0.3613207936286926,
1.0251578092575073,
0.9582222104072571,
-0.03284705430269241,
0.007562264800071716,
-0.23452945053577423,
0.6596233248710632,
-0.2874894440174103,
-0.8466988801956177,
0.4149860143661499,
0.6564074754714966,
0.5488964319229126,
0.2161867469549179,
0.558002769947052,
0.086033895611763,
0.6504396796226501,
-0.034380655735731125,
-0.01996440626680851,
-0.11269242316484451,
-0.24288375675678253,
0.10361582785844803,
0.2498665153980255,
-0.22534947097301483,
-0.18468190729618073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13022v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13022v1 | SoMeLVLM: A Large Vision Language Model for Social Media Processing | 2024-02-20T14:02:45 | 2024-02-20T14:02:45 | Xinnong Zhang, Haoyu Kuang, Xinyi Mou, Hanjia Lyu, Kun Wu, Siming Chen, Jiebo Luo, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM | The growth of social media, characterized by its multimodal nature, has led
to the emergence of diverse phenomena and challenges, which calls for an
effective approach to uniformly solve automated tasks. The powerful Large
Vision Language Models make it possible to handle a variety of tasks
simultaneously, but even with carefully designed prompting methods, the general
domain models often fall short in aligning with the unique speaking style and
context of social media tasks. In this paper, we introduce a Large Vision
Language Model for Social Media Processing (SoMeLVLM), which is a cognitive
framework equipped with five key capabilities including knowledge &
comprehension, application, analysis, evaluation, and creation. SoMeLVLM is
designed to understand and generate realistic social media behavior. We have
developed a 654k multimodal social media instruction-tuning dataset to support
our cognitive framework and fine-tune our model. Our experiments demonstrate
that SoMeLVLM achieves state-of-the-art performance in multiple social media
tasks. Further analysis shows its significant advantages over baselines in
terms of cognitive abilities. | [
-0.3891313970088959,
-1.24300217628479,
0.5835049152374268,
0.22403950989246368,
-0.27592596411705017,
0.08129839599132538,
-0.4246892035007477,
-0.3518432080745697,
0.15477050840854645,
0.3332841396331787,
-0.818191647529602,
-0.42063218355178833,
-0.7139711976051331,
-0.3915528655052185,
-0.4750371277332306,
0.6746960878372192,
0.37877601385116577,
0.18399189412593842,
0.03760693967342377,
-0.11093726754188538,
-0.4757654666900635,
-0.2964962422847748,
-0.7981469631195068,
0.03483007848262787,
0.6894709467887878,
0.31706979870796204,
0.5926835536956787,
0.5070964694023132,
0.5857383012771606,
0.3435659110546112,
0.1436285376548767,
0.4640258848667145,
-0.9796432256698608,
-0.063143789768219,
-0.3025156855583191,
-0.17645639181137085,
-0.45975956320762634,
-0.2393728792667389,
0.752234160900116,
0.2724345028400421,
-0.09897612035274506,
0.49127277731895447,
-0.051047299057245255,
0.7338563203811646,
-0.5960181951522827,
0.11268935352563858,
-0.8166309595108032,
-0.27132365107536316,
-0.10346391052007675,
-0.14815230667591095,
-0.2841247022151947,
-0.1789969503879547,
0.03478211537003517,
-0.6197410821914673,
-0.041961368173360825,
0.14859150350093842,
0.5146946907043457,
0.29781508445739746,
-0.10266423970460892,
-0.05277586355805397,
-0.7572807669639587,
0.9498641490936279,
-0.4822784662246704,
0.6035913228988647,
0.41589364409446716,
0.8003500699996948,
0.3426997661590576,
-0.8459192514419556,
-0.7983493208885193,
0.0947522297501564,
0.33136218786239624,
-0.08855953812599182,
-0.10839003324508667,
-0.06055060774087906,
0.1340251863002777,
-0.18025530874729156,
-0.5336188077926636,
-0.10150270164012909,
-0.6295923590660095,
-0.004456286784261465,
0.5967279672622681,
0.2768111824989319,
0.17697541415691376,
-0.28173962235450745,
-0.25867924094200134,
0.18043874204158783,
-0.1376933455467224,
0.18969354033470154,
-0.22571273148059845,
0.21341943740844727,
-0.12289067357778549,
0.628905713558197,
-0.48743611574172974,
0.8650919795036316,
-0.27102094888687134,
-0.2096889764070511,
0.06463408470153809,
-0.2687234878540039,
-0.4573691785335541,
-0.25286656618118286,
0.4842737019062042,
0.9015270471572876,
0.6585479974746704,
0.16274376213550568,
-0.10630857199430466,
0.3234648108482361,
0.519996166229248,
-0.5804238319396973,
-0.04579111933708191,
0.21973565220832825,
-0.8253219127655029,
-0.14568501710891724,
-0.1711081564426422,
-0.3608872890472412,
-0.43142032623291016,
-0.5094090700149536,
0.3224664032459259,
-0.6650447845458984,
-0.2461424171924591,
0.06283369660377502,
-0.0867580771446228,
0.19631870090961456,
0.5784612894058228,
-0.6738902926445007,
-0.10505001246929169,
0.6756126284599304,
0.764988899230957,
-0.3112903833389282,
-0.3661302924156189,
-0.5554446578025818,
0.12539909780025482,
-0.26638832688331604,
0.6504456400871277,
-0.8069235682487488,
-0.05775263532996178,
0.39232760667800903,
0.027349980548024178,
-0.14298386871814728,
0.028065737336874008,
0.17480380833148956,
-0.8554700613021851,
-0.3531557619571686,
-0.4029080271720886,
-0.6583036184310913,
-0.29830896854400635,
0.6003153920173645,
-0.4967365860939026,
0.7223929166793823,
-0.03262893110513687,
-0.5237066745758057,
0.3554687201976776,
-0.550853967666626,
-0.37071070075035095,
0.5267335176467896,
-0.1642107218503952,
-0.04150886461138725,
-0.058020930737257004,
0.0792936235666275,
0.9036229252815247,
-0.3262920081615448,
0.059509988874197006,
-0.5713983178138733,
-0.30304932594299316,
0.45713213086128235,
-0.37676239013671875,
0.7566229104995728,
0.32791849970817566,
0.05981499329209328,
0.3482101857662201,
-0.7852186560630798,
0.17601807415485382,
0.07461390644311905,
-0.3522413372993469,
-0.4050373435020447,
0.04958673194050789,
0.4031357765197754,
0.47667697072029114,
0.4044402837753296,
-0.4654677212238312,
0.08414730429649353,
0.1043601855635643,
0.6474025845527649,
0.6559343338012695,
0.053417470306158066,
0.46579626202583313,
-0.27914583683013916,
0.22041645646095276,
-0.1690160483121872,
0.6603601574897766,
-0.15125127136707306,
-0.5817027688026428,
-0.5984266996383667,
-0.3291720151901245,
-0.2274685800075531,
0.4027385413646698,
-1.2528047561645508,
-0.15982601046562195,
-0.35921573638916016,
-0.511215090751648,
-0.8367247581481934,
0.6688264012336731,
0.28595635294914246,
0.1043727844953537,
0.2886495888233185,
0.013921447098255157,
-0.5574496984481812,
-0.7733379006385803,
0.05338352173566818,
0.06960096210241318,
0.10600236803293228,
0.36917757987976074,
0.2290467917919159,
-0.36750108003616333,
0.8495015501976013,
-0.369682639837265,
-0.5909810662269592,
-0.4182429313659668,
-0.11879784613847733,
-0.12932229042053223,
0.08585841208696365,
0.5669278502464294,
-1.2215460538864136,
-0.4483180642127991,
-0.038283150643110275,
-1.042614221572876,
0.1962459832429886,
-0.06334003806114197,
-0.2778637409210205,
0.18628530204296112,
0.5914017558097839,
-0.5205394625663757,
0.15294191241264343,
0.6666898131370544,
-0.10410113632678986,
0.15452466905117035,
-0.05183548852801323,
0.21312184631824493,
-0.9571685791015625,
-0.26326924562454224,
0.35305193066596985,
-0.27889683842658997,
-0.7220034599304199,
0.034643206745386124,
0.21686211228370667,
0.020620698109269142,
-1.1392927169799805,
0.4654480218887329,
-0.27860382199287415,
0.0008919881656765938,
-0.3218144178390503,
0.2099081426858902,
-0.21779374778270721,
0.443645179271698,
-0.06738324463367462,
0.08061017841100693,
0.8982080817222595,
-0.7415176630020142,
0.795458197593689,
-0.0662233754992485,
-0.3511715233325958,
0.7188209891319275,
-0.4714536666870117,
0.005693844519555569,
-0.4038447439670563,
-0.09529532492160797,
-1.2434138059616089,
-0.34825509786605835,
-0.06724487245082855,
-0.3872767686843872,
0.09913720935583115,
0.07107514888048172,
-0.58783358335495,
-0.4908837378025055,
-0.3050594627857208,
0.3188213109970093,
0.4661591351032257,
-0.32659125328063965,
0.7200027704238892,
0.4680105149745941,
0.18714535236358643,
-0.2660805284976959,
-0.5791223049163818,
0.047536980360746384,
-0.03327326476573944,
-0.8566755056381226,
0.16504907608032227,
-0.12971869111061096,
-0.18091677129268646,
0.2395082414150238,
0.447162389755249,
0.09113936871290207,
-0.25090938806533813,
0.18098244071006775,
0.3463914692401886,
-0.2160796970129013,
0.1661864072084427,
-0.22336971759796143,
0.10412649810314178,
-0.2949589192867279,
-0.22405144572257996,
0.6067737340927124,
-0.10874676704406738,
-0.2994857430458069,
-0.38726964592933655,
0.24772153794765472,
0.7519949674606323,
-0.40045982599258423,
0.6945289969444275,
0.8444172143936157,
-0.4194839596748352,
-0.4387160539627075,
-0.7304543256759644,
-0.12384508550167084,
-0.5053439736366272,
0.4342363476753235,
-0.19141711294651031,
-1.0741832256317139,
0.37415921688079834,
0.13405106961727142,
0.22986534237861633,
0.027723224833607674,
0.8413103818893433,
-0.3215785026550293,
1.2354967594146729,
0.7848978638648987,
0.014318669214844704,
0.895418107509613,
-0.14856591820716858,
0.015431233681738377,
-0.529190719127655,
-0.03839976713061333,
0.16525939106941223,
-0.29237622022628784,
-0.4494588077068329,
-0.6249008774757385,
0.230127215385437,
-0.276950865983963,
-0.10891413688659668,
0.23710310459136963,
-0.42521390318870544,
0.4447142779827118,
0.5472358465194702,
0.15895849466323853,
0.1633000522851944,
0.06065266206860542,
0.2269095778465271,
-0.07888559252023697,
-0.7245824933052063,
-0.42327287793159485,
0.7195400595664978,
0.3400645852088928,
0.8877155184745789,
0.1524716317653656,
0.20077218115329742,
0.6830839514732361,
0.3026629686355591,
-0.7516822218894958,
0.8149345517158508,
-0.5807276964187622,
-0.776389479637146,
-0.5020103454589844,
-0.030541587620973587,
-0.592049241065979,
0.32222020626068115,
-0.5468268990516663,
-0.8618037104606628,
-0.08047068864107132,
0.340136855840683,
-0.3076455593109131,
0.06310328096151352,
-0.6550782322883606,
0.8210210204124451,
-0.2699296474456787,
-0.5721055865287781,
-0.4301599860191345,
-0.6208446621894836,
0.5944284796714783,
-0.0917711928486824,
0.3685470223426819,
-0.18615929782390594,
0.29839372634887695,
0.4845949113368988,
0.1484634429216385,
1.2744728326797485,
-0.15684950351715088,
0.11697322130203247,
0.40252792835235596,
-0.07403172552585602,
0.4061545431613922,
-0.12892630696296692,
0.05055805295705795,
0.025612907484173775,
0.18302318453788757,
-0.32613641023635864,
-0.5558523535728455,
0.7744031548500061,
-0.5297925472259521,
-0.3474762737751007,
0.07759623974561691,
-0.5612302422523499,
-0.0905880406498909,
0.22669591009616852,
0.18815559148788452,
0.24554473161697388,
-0.34619179368019104,
0.4886475205421448,
0.4542085528373718,
-0.236863374710083,
0.651481032371521,
0.5632806420326233,
-0.39043915271759033,
-0.020760560408234596,
1.2887202501296997,
0.39540499448776245,
0.17046236991882324,
0.23202423751354218,
-0.16944095492362976,
-0.29553335905075073,
-0.24351732432842255,
-0.4451236426830292,
0.11314886808395386,
-1.1061677932739258,
0.05377882719039917,
-0.654190719127655,
-0.31822437047958374,
-0.4946379065513611,
-0.26043766736984253,
-0.3197808265686035,
-0.1642993688583374,
-0.0351458340883255,
0.09038668125867844,
0.2677023112773895,
0.5877320766448975,
0.38453802466392517,
0.43659552931785583,
-0.8712414503097534,
0.6744800209999084,
0.47769176959991455,
0.3060365617275238,
0.2606196701526642,
-0.32538437843322754,
-0.3421022593975067,
0.04804656654596329,
-0.13715599477291107,
-0.8585997223854065,
0.3546535074710846,
0.332609087228775,
0.7003688216209412,
0.567499577999115,
0.0016548584681004286,
0.6024191975593567,
-0.6995612382888794,
0.6438175439834595,
0.18549589812755585,
-0.6390272974967957,
0.44760164618492126,
-0.34086838364601135,
0.34772706031799316,
0.28398504853248596,
0.36018890142440796,
-0.6374475359916687,
-0.46024084091186523,
-0.43373629450798035,
-0.5962634682655334,
0.5828956961631775,
0.21865496039390564,
0.3735682964324951,
-0.15487952530384064,
0.14628568291664124,
-0.4321146309375763,
0.2578805088996887,
-0.7015178799629211,
-0.12164708971977234,
-0.45398473739624023,
-0.21969826519489288,
0.036254823207855225,
-0.28897592425346375,
-0.07334273308515549,
-0.35253971815109253,
0.40684452652931213,
-0.14977821707725525,
-0.008736967109143734,
-0.23877184092998505,
-0.4601762890815735,
-0.22699415683746338,
0.1103917583823204,
0.6015881896018982,
0.906607449054718,
0.006632201373577118,
0.18922807276248932,
0.18418782949447632,
-0.21160149574279785,
-0.293026328086853,
-0.12473560869693756,
-0.26347166299819946,
-0.25201892852783203,
0.4169001579284668,
0.8571723103523254,
0.16673123836517334,
-0.719519317150116,
0.4320787787437439,
-0.15321014821529388,
-0.27508068084716797,
-0.20288746058940887,
0.28801003098487854,
0.37752509117126465,
0.6461051106452942,
0.6667860746383667,
-0.08268064260482788,
0.11375286430120468,
-0.7102954983711243,
0.20460836589336395,
0.4926629066467285,
-0.4402160346508026,
-0.11209199577569962,
0.7334033250808716,
0.08768362551927567,
-0.5142661929130554,
0.2320568710565567,
-0.24459154903888702,
-0.4758554995059967,
0.4214114844799042,
0.4143396317958832,
0.5309886932373047,
-0.1332743912935257,
0.40634867548942566,
0.07583703100681305,
0.37254980206489563,
-0.08437293767929077,
0.4901808500289917,
-0.011259185150265694,
-0.9448658227920532,
-0.5407228469848633,
-0.9728716015815735,
-0.063164621591568,
0.10753884166479111,
-0.45362260937690735,
0.18922662734985352,
-0.5429105162620544,
-0.32694634795188904,
0.6354618668556213,
-0.47963374853134155,
-0.8442202210426331,
0.5036866664886475,
0.28043657541275024,
0.4087188243865967,
-0.8610339760780334,
1.130394458770752,
0.8634442090988159,
-0.23202455043792725,
-0.47953522205352783,
-0.2797471284866333,
0.31613221764564514,
-1.016470193862915,
0.8518811464309692,
0.15211911499500275,
-0.0694224089384079,
0.1845056563615799,
-0.6542420387268066,
-0.6828791499137878,
0.8194870948791504,
0.13157236576080322,
-0.7960235476493835,
0.08322478085756302,
0.1084974855184555,
0.7375353574752808,
-0.590176522731781,
-0.34626004099845886,
0.3929623067378998,
0.392024964094162,
0.28525158762931824,
-0.6262399554252625,
0.13945867121219635,
-0.31449443101882935,
0.48128366470336914,
-0.28558844327926636,
-0.7171306014060974,
0.7363829016685486,
-0.1224270910024643,
-0.1151522696018219,
-0.48560798168182373,
0.5399617552757263,
0.27354907989501953,
0.44586074352264404,
0.609147310256958,
-0.05948423594236374,
0.5134285688400269,
0.15209470689296722,
1.0134996175765991,
-0.3071328103542328,
0.23165109753608704,
0.8335073590278625,
-0.22739596664905548,
1.0432878732681274,
0.4419299066066742,
0.13263148069381714,
-0.07371488958597183,
0.5197615027427673,
-0.13422642648220062,
0.5881066918373108,
-0.10135149955749512,
-0.16146636009216309,
-0.6606510877609253,
-0.2724989652633667,
0.03347582370042801,
0.5658937692642212,
0.5648256540298462,
-0.48050010204315186,
-0.03791595622897148,
0.4447467625141144,
-0.582615315914154,
0.0513470396399498,
-0.520961344242096,
0.7441044449806213,
0.2923335134983063,
-0.6370319128036499,
0.5938882827758789,
0.009892186149954796,
0.7177107930183411,
-0.5182785987854004,
-0.05189233273267746,
0.2527253329753876,
0.28385868668556213,
-0.2555524408817291,
-0.8952677845954895,
0.3891085982322693,
0.034867383539676666,
-0.30494919419288635,
-0.22674302756786346,
1.0379585027694702,
-0.4452339708805084,
-0.763005256652832,
0.527916431427002,
0.5014715790748596,
-0.022010304033756256,
-0.05930953100323677,
-0.8432127833366394,
0.28090953826904297,
-0.0656445175409317,
-0.378608763217926,
0.22045613825321198,
0.555934488773346,
-0.4387427568435669,
0.7987551689147949,
0.8608060479164124,
0.10457503795623779,
0.32151246070861816,
0.54755699634552,
0.8475251793861389,
-0.4967140853404999,
-0.5771129727363586,
-1.0977860689163208,
0.4243175685405731,
-0.23783718049526215,
-0.20154684782028198,
0.7385208606719971,
0.10137002170085907,
0.7381522059440613,
0.006542798597365618,
0.9332088232040405,
-0.253574013710022,
0.323866605758667,
-0.5485462546348572,
0.7941232919692993,
-0.8554556369781494,
0.1438351720571518,
-0.36905649304389954,
-0.9057089686393738,
-0.3306603729724884,
0.6830414533615112,
-0.23797856271266937,
0.057391129434108734,
0.3913672864437103,
0.7433436512947083,
-0.18871045112609863,
-0.09875232726335526,
0.8491948843002319,
0.22783561050891876,
0.1758992224931717,
0.2195063829421997,
0.7695885896682739,
0.13277246057987213,
0.6077835559844971,
-0.132785826921463,
-0.13708528876304626,
-0.5166125297546387,
-0.6766177415847778,
-1.179874300956726,
-0.8220065832138062,
-0.002198704518377781,
-0.3098538815975189,
0.2339354008436203,
0.8562565445899963,
0.8911038041114807,
-0.42425939440727234,
0.000041364844946656376,
0.27567291259765625,
-0.0368584580719471,
-0.29675373435020447,
-0.1971099078655243,
0.1794668436050415,
-0.306650847196579,
-0.6335507035255432,
0.11389461904764175,
0.3454205393791199,
-0.18088331818580627,
-0.36828428506851196,
-0.22566309571266174,
-0.3733660876750946,
0.09720230102539062,
1.1258693933486938,
0.1333540827035904,
-0.7521322965621948,
-0.2912876307964325,
0.34670230746269226,
-0.26228517293930054,
-0.18240471184253693,
0.4539862871170044,
-0.07382518798112869,
0.6568861603736877,
0.5879157781600952,
0.6632859706878662,
0.8613681197166443,
0.12080267816781998,
0.33602818846702576,
-0.9512856006622314,
0.05742209032177925,
-0.10079547017812729,
0.4402596056461334,
0.5002548098564148,
-0.24617521464824677,
0.22700685262680054,
0.14052805304527283,
-0.302701473236084,
-0.5701773762702942,
0.14197780191898346,
-1.1471991539001465,
-0.7105221748352051,
1.4482693672180176,
0.2249239981174469,
-0.46985214948654175,
-0.14438822865486145,
-0.4317215085029602,
0.49190613627433777,
-0.47902461886405945,
0.8621417880058289,
0.7865408062934875,
0.15471211075782776,
-0.7324873805046082,
-0.9614288806915283,
0.4067777693271637,
0.2442104071378708,
-0.49834364652633667,
-0.008006390184164047,
0.48186904191970825,
0.23903915286064148,
0.19993431866168976,
0.9288182854652405,
0.34488511085510254,
0.4824897050857544,
-0.34471097588539124,
-0.04374634847044945,
-0.03754134848713875,
-0.3059317171573639,
-0.022122718393802643,
0.296285480260849,
-0.15624094009399414,
-0.2859720289707184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13016v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13016v1 | Understanding the effects of language-specific class imbalance in multilingual fine-tuning | 2024-02-20T13:59:12 | 2024-02-20T13:59:12 | Vincent Jung, Lonneke van der Plas | cs.CL | cs.CL | We study the effect of one type of imbalance often present in real-life
multilingual classification datasets: an uneven distribution of labels across
languages. We show evidence that fine-tuning a transformer-based Large Language
Model (LLM) on a dataset with this imbalance leads to worse performance, a more
pronounced separation of languages in the latent space, and the promotion of
uninformative features. We modify the traditional class weighing approach to
imbalance by calculating class weights separately for each language and show
that this helps mitigate those detrimental effects. These results create
awareness of the negative effects of language-specific class imbalance in
multilingual fine-tuning and the way in which the model learns to rely on the
separation of languages to perform the task. | [
-0.5719131827354431,
-0.6059905886650085,
-0.1411508470773697,
0.12075354903936386,
-0.08267737179994583,
0.18134795129299164,
-0.3409202992916107,
-0.7047308087348938,
0.047131553292274475,
0.4943024516105652,
-0.2964824438095093,
-0.01425767783075571,
-0.6153801679611206,
-0.0026733367703855038,
-0.17468613386154175,
1.1635260581970215,
0.18057885766029358,
0.424002468585968,
-0.16746802628040314,
-0.4940202236175537,
-0.6708602905273438,
-0.6531364917755127,
-0.5135037899017334,
-0.8852313160896301,
0.6980214715003967,
0.709321141242981,
0.8249840140342712,
0.5878777503967285,
0.5491716861724854,
0.29149919748306274,
-0.14254404604434967,
-0.11894887685775757,
-0.6831825971603394,
-0.11047293245792389,
-0.18213070929050446,
-0.873586893081665,
-0.47064852714538574,
0.036703456193208694,
0.8619348406791687,
0.7591461539268494,
-0.12211150676012039,
0.2906609773635864,
0.24918553233146667,
0.432834267616272,
-0.7433512210845947,
0.15412206947803497,
-0.5178455710411072,
0.12006086111068726,
-0.4572325348854065,
-0.28166621923446655,
-0.4037100672721863,
0.08019137382507324,
0.037834249436855316,
-0.3496786653995514,
0.2713109850883484,
0.008436448872089386,
0.7954078316688538,
0.4402664601802826,
-0.3627491295337677,
0.09462083876132965,
-0.7268895506858826,
0.9229224920272827,
-0.5538483262062073,
0.35244065523147583,
0.3074416220188141,
0.1658293604850769,
0.353145569562912,
-0.18762873113155365,
-0.34701934456825256,
0.14920400083065033,
-0.2269955426454544,
0.036508236080408096,
0.121648408472538,
0.05021006241440773,
0.28512224555015564,
0.660862386226654,
-0.47744470834732056,
0.6495417952537537,
-0.42163628339767456,
-0.03537597134709358,
0.536543607711792,
0.17574875056743622,
0.5001380443572998,
0.305746465921402,
0.12252119928598404,
-0.18397469818592072,
-0.8160737752914429,
0.017804613336920738,
0.7625628709793091,
0.6703744530677795,
-0.14029337465763092,
0.564383864402771,
0.043196577578783035,
0.8277137875556946,
-0.034801460802555084,
-0.32863855361938477,
0.40026766061782837,
0.007924983277916908,
-0.18322011828422546,
0.21855109930038452,
0.3520165681838989,
0.5342472791671753,
0.5121129155158997,
-0.20511379837989807,
-0.13826052844524384,
0.29338496923446655,
0.1040918156504631,
-0.869893491268158,
-0.15949274599552155,
-0.18738555908203125,
-0.2959234416484833,
-0.44971826672554016,
-0.23817196488380432,
-0.5770142078399658,
-0.37278661131858826,
-0.5533849596977234,
0.428609162569046,
0.056425828486680984,
-0.24399663507938385,
0.052854347974061966,
-0.011614316143095493,
0.15229099988937378,
0.029094615951180458,
-1.1382801532745361,
0.2665318250656128,
0.42620566487312317,
0.386549711227417,
-0.23529602587223053,
-0.47478726506233215,
-0.4090951979160309,
0.11728445440530777,
0.023274069651961327,
0.7462944984436035,
-0.8290758728981018,
-0.06900930404663086,
0.006408984307199717,
0.26975905895233154,
-0.17309558391571045,
-0.8703672885894775,
0.43855607509613037,
-0.35909736156463623,
0.28724363446235657,
-0.17440886795520782,
-0.5466594099998474,
-0.13395988941192627,
0.15363691747188568,
-0.5456168055534363,
0.8304250836372375,
-0.13750970363616943,
-0.7869111895561218,
0.6587755680084229,
-0.2618602514266968,
-0.6327157616615295,
0.08296407759189606,
-0.08392992615699768,
-0.5878087282180786,
0.10766512900590897,
0.06034625321626663,
0.4620710611343384,
-0.24174678325653076,
0.20638421177864075,
-0.3298759460449219,
-0.6336712837219238,
0.049422383308410645,
-0.5535306930541992,
0.6542866826057434,
0.21517562866210938,
-0.1405303180217743,
-0.06918046623468399,
-0.7813088893890381,
0.05044444650411606,
0.02890559285879135,
-0.48078230023384094,
-0.6211197972297668,
0.15196067094802856,
0.24621109664440155,
0.31589770317077637,
0.13262483477592468,
-0.3291303515434265,
0.2673788070678711,
-0.4639248251914978,
0.13482354581356049,
0.5691612958908081,
-0.1251630038022995,
0.571104109287262,
-0.3998658061027527,
0.4928360879421234,
0.2018922120332718,
0.15376821160316467,
-0.07821675390005112,
-0.32654401659965515,
-0.8230946063995361,
-0.11646785587072372,
0.37993788719177246,
0.776567816734314,
-0.3997453451156616,
0.11258377134799957,
-0.14553667604923248,
-0.3730789124965668,
-0.8972687721252441,
0.2816479206085205,
0.6392682790756226,
0.35084494948387146,
0.39568397402763367,
-0.3316454589366913,
-0.1648186892271042,
-1.085728645324707,
-0.45269787311553955,
0.2842857837677002,
0.15553127229213715,
-0.01713371090590954,
0.1914365291595459,
-0.376731276512146,
0.48210281133651733,
-0.5292145609855652,
-0.37344807386398315,
-0.34687942266464233,
0.018305210396647453,
-0.10099543631076813,
0.5478212833404541,
0.6895908117294312,
-0.8372335433959961,
-0.4493017792701721,
0.09679559618234634,
-0.4598270654678345,
-0.3323327302932739,
-0.030061831697821617,
0.08685917407274246,
0.3954574167728424,
0.5101610422134399,
0.04068303108215332,
0.14451482892036438,
0.6114252805709839,
-0.38532230257987976,
0.3141527473926544,
-0.2923114001750946,
0.13004958629608154,
-0.7786725759506226,
-0.12577727437019348,
0.12510758638381958,
0.0711529403924942,
-0.6637974381446838,
0.20820055902004242,
0.23427340388298035,
0.06514285504817963,
-0.4662502706050873,
0.49282383918762207,
-0.11196412146091461,
0.1369197815656662,
-0.3096752166748047,
0.16143031418323517,
-0.029297707602381706,
0.4161638915538788,
-0.12824110686779022,
0.6053553223609924,
0.3744121491909027,
-0.6818503737449646,
-0.06562710553407669,
0.0001731016527628526,
-0.3895294666290283,
0.6566911935806274,
-0.42079269886016846,
-0.4141404628753662,
-0.4224247336387634,
-0.2342732548713684,
-0.8221893906593323,
-0.12012256681919098,
-0.08414895087480545,
-0.06619031727313995,
0.9603943824768066,
-0.2287883162498474,
-0.4984271824359894,
-0.28747692704200745,
-0.018277136608958244,
0.4951951205730438,
0.12693099677562714,
-0.6559235453605652,
0.22795982658863068,
0.5616294145584106,
0.028866278007626534,
-0.7953987717628479,
-0.8878104090690613,
-0.17520762979984283,
-0.47972095012664795,
-0.4671357274055481,
0.23484671115875244,
-0.18700610101222992,
-0.4938414692878723,
-0.23476910591125488,
-0.1982399821281433,
-0.03956616297364235,
0.34850651025772095,
0.18736261129379272,
-0.0898943766951561,
-0.06004071608185768,
0.2770736813545227,
0.16500090062618256,
-0.2255692332983017,
-0.2027105838060379,
-0.001979466527700424,
0.6645671725273132,
-0.3052530884742737,
-0.4056428372859955,
-0.17081449925899506,
0.09024765342473984,
0.7076054215431213,
-0.26035189628601074,
0.9896566867828369,
0.5162495970726013,
-0.09655850380659103,
-0.1897844672203064,
-0.6189249157905579,
-0.14951065182685852,
-0.477254182100296,
0.43184351921081543,
-0.4524993598461151,
-0.7738556861877441,
0.7913385629653931,
0.07156062126159668,
0.12119242548942566,
0.5928317308425903,
0.5781461000442505,
0.038479361683130264,
1.1763936281204224,
0.8634587526321411,
-0.35443970561027527,
0.7011118531227112,
-0.10390283912420273,
0.19287443161010742,
-0.481172114610672,
-0.2632487416267395,
-0.6481614112854004,
-0.630479097366333,
-0.960489809513092,
-0.10908826440572739,
0.13091494143009186,
0.0991813987493515,
-0.3080005347728729,
0.0710897371172905,
-0.4835107624530792,
0.8474429845809937,
0.5185251832008362,
-0.03440898284316063,
0.39200952649116516,
0.1284339874982834,
-0.09274379163980484,
-0.28191590309143066,
-0.6867936849594116,
-0.42427554726600647,
0.8112444877624512,
0.2129925936460495,
0.9138846397399902,
0.07618091255426407,
0.2972603142261505,
0.1712770015001297,
0.3306915760040283,
-0.618066668510437,
0.07081171125173569,
-0.5883777141571045,
-0.5641692876815796,
-0.29712703824043274,
-0.4269702732563019,
-0.7938373684883118,
0.5925695300102234,
-0.3242656886577606,
-0.46812498569488525,
0.03551211208105087,
0.2722285985946655,
0.20320357382297516,
0.4716455638408661,
-0.9909080266952515,
1.0586379766464233,
-0.47844770550727844,
-0.450124591588974,
-0.33250555396080017,
-0.6064121127128601,
0.27556338906288147,
-0.363279789686203,
0.5132112503051758,
-0.18786171078681946,
0.4237707853317261,
0.5219981074333191,
-0.21931061148643494,
1.0353126525878906,
-0.2829618752002716,
-0.49693840742111206,
-0.08120585232973099,
-0.07020052522420883,
0.3032964766025543,
-0.09183349460363388,
-0.17268013954162598,
0.2357620894908905,
-0.03184652328491211,
-0.5327362418174744,
-0.34321263432502747,
0.7852004766464233,
-1.135215401649475,
-0.3580631613731384,
-0.0535033717751503,
-0.5843973159790039,
-0.27136343717575073,
0.1600770503282547,
0.6192819476127625,
0.3070942163467407,
-0.05449908226728439,
-0.012694294564425945,
0.6742976307868958,
-0.4436402916908264,
0.37128928303718567,
0.890772819519043,
-0.27395299077033997,
-0.04348624125123024,
1.2154545783996582,
0.5818412899971008,
0.49002599716186523,
0.6051134467124939,
0.2544713318347931,
-0.02236647717654705,
-0.21797475218772888,
-0.436526358127594,
0.15952269732952118,
-0.6604143381118774,
-0.12467021495103836,
-0.4552483856678009,
0.05519057810306549,
-0.15297375619411469,
-0.2708262503147125,
-0.38848593831062317,
-0.6832894682884216,
-0.2232801616191864,
-0.07121015340089798,
0.0688190683722496,
0.5963786244392395,
0.181266650557518,
0.7070626020431519,
-0.5333130359649658,
0.08397846668958664,
0.23739145696163177,
0.8155030608177185,
-0.03465593606233597,
-0.8464263081550598,
-0.5563833117485046,
0.028147373348474503,
-0.4208433926105499,
-0.24040748178958893,
0.20803292095661163,
0.3483768105506897,
0.7232416272163391,
0.6086945533752441,
-0.18284182250499725,
0.7885981202125549,
-0.6184769868850708,
0.5996875762939453,
0.22874683141708374,
-0.8685926795005798,
0.2485252022743225,
-0.24846157431602478,
0.5338677167892456,
0.45939356088638306,
0.03590020537376404,
-0.8861196041107178,
-0.8985596299171448,
-0.3742782175540924,
-1.0297303199768066,
0.897210955619812,
-0.12747083604335785,
0.17898818850517273,
0.038302697241306305,
0.3655657470226288,
0.18355493247509003,
0.10776959359645844,
-1.0854554176330566,
-0.7929179668426514,
-0.17744141817092896,
-0.08744357526302338,
-0.5704660415649414,
-0.41815951466560364,
0.0694303959608078,
-0.3614228367805481,
0.750268280506134,
-0.05769210681319237,
-0.14671894907951355,
-0.5569469928741455,
-0.40667277574539185,
-0.5289177894592285,
0.4139500558376312,
0.8039966225624084,
0.4122145473957062,
-0.04314311221241951,
0.40424126386642456,
0.45416203141212463,
-0.37673407793045044,
0.17004968225955963,
-0.0854729488492012,
-0.11407048255205154,
-0.33431604504585266,
0.3201464116573334,
0.8494892120361328,
0.3813505470752716,
-0.5824360847473145,
0.21945291757583618,
0.00781895499676466,
-0.03842443972826004,
0.07355056703090668,
0.31922370195388794,
0.05852557718753815,
0.10849358141422272,
0.19849269092082977,
0.1724991798400879,
-0.03965027257800102,
-0.32082873582839966,
0.146731898188591,
0.38290542364120483,
-0.3790467381477356,
-0.28483420610427856,
0.5196347236633301,
0.0873364508152008,
-0.08127608150243759,
0.48332494497299194,
0.21888531744480133,
-0.3595123589038849,
0.7607688307762146,
0.7302464246749878,
0.48036447167396545,
-0.665215015411377,
-0.046346914023160934,
0.15454523265361786,
0.6028628349304199,
-0.2776966094970703,
0.035390738397836685,
0.22543944418430328,
-0.7751318216323853,
-0.5923406481742859,
-0.7721925973892212,
-0.3592389225959778,
0.12265300005674362,
-0.686749279499054,
0.38340237736701965,
-0.030499130487442017,
0.0005321730859577656,
0.08293699473142624,
-0.10610110312700272,
-0.6055066585540771,
0.20749403536319733,
0.34934255480766296,
0.5345667600631714,
-1.1807119846343994,
0.8047099709510803,
0.8329824805259705,
-0.18554526567459106,
-0.7221529483795166,
-0.05840518698096275,
0.0011426906567066908,
-0.7911337018013,
0.6633417010307312,
0.29585137963294983,
-0.14685726165771484,
-0.18756330013275146,
-0.2305314838886261,
-0.9094355702400208,
0.5407521724700928,
0.5743041038513184,
-0.8326265215873718,
0.21439652144908905,
0.6790465712547302,
0.7728937268257141,
-0.09571527689695358,
0.16930513083934784,
0.4275738596916199,
0.6241860389709473,
-0.1975906491279602,
-1.0635977983474731,
-0.35448145866394043,
-0.18557396531105042,
-0.19592830538749695,
0.6254614591598511,
-0.8286764621734619,
0.7576513886451721,
0.030327143147587776,
0.03301200643181801,
-0.44948217272758484,
0.08952206373214722,
-0.42681825160980225,
0.17224542796611786,
0.2546311020851135,
0.7382649779319763,
0.9206944704055786,
-0.13398000597953796,
0.8090713620185852,
-0.5180494785308838,
0.34549447894096375,
1.2776585817337036,
-0.09628049284219742,
0.5590219497680664,
0.3985580503940582,
-0.029190026223659515,
0.15337316691875458,
0.5191591382026672,
-0.22527602314949036,
0.4659750163555145,
0.4071427285671234,
-0.19149404764175415,
-0.2737327218055725,
-0.0020651917438954115,
-0.42206329107284546,
0.6881132125854492,
0.43034428358078003,
-0.2600099742412567,
-0.34282001852989197,
0.3905382752418518,
-0.036375630646944046,
-0.11922768503427505,
-0.6157597899436951,
0.6501897573471069,
-0.043358270078897476,
-0.6155866384506226,
0.676602840423584,
0.1646609604358673,
0.8727719783782959,
-0.1920386254787445,
0.24608741700649261,
-0.3227023482322693,
0.6387537717819214,
-0.4261852502822876,
-0.6737241744995117,
0.45508354902267456,
-0.13770174980163574,
-0.4720316231250763,
-0.33582979440689087,
0.407246470451355,
-0.7553561925888062,
-0.4715208113193512,
0.41797927021980286,
0.5402637124061584,
0.059652332216501236,
0.07793821394443512,
-0.528691291809082,
-0.027849148958921432,
-0.009133187122642994,
-0.1851048618555069,
0.5975238084793091,
0.5282480716705322,
-0.2209899127483368,
0.7093092203140259,
0.13349328935146332,
-0.13951613008975983,
0.03281904011964798,
0.49847447872161865,
0.5695421695709229,
-0.4250342547893524,
-0.2488953322172165,
-0.9613936543464661,
0.3163132071495056,
0.3194342851638794,
-0.20063477754592896,
0.8051550984382629,
0.7889961004257202,
1.217908263206482,
-0.12544994056224823,
0.6045364737510681,
0.21647116541862488,
0.4282015860080719,
-0.1873716115951538,
0.8903298377990723,
-0.9559049606323242,
0.48465895652770996,
-0.42107224464416504,
-0.8360433578491211,
-0.7886520624160767,
0.4232625961303711,
-0.22356656193733215,
-0.0520588681101799,
0.3129720389842987,
0.5760497450828552,
-0.11850468069314957,
-0.13528116047382355,
0.5335147380828857,
0.229642853140831,
0.24914047122001648,
0.0654611587524414,
0.7431084513664246,
-0.1662934571504593,
0.49388790130615234,
-0.3477512001991272,
0.03782452270388603,
-0.2651679813861847,
-0.5516300797462463,
-1.1064364910125732,
-0.34738412499427795,
-0.404795378446579,
-0.09269686043262482,
-0.1128416433930397,
0.6782808303833008,
0.3474934995174408,
-0.8808116316795349,
-0.38534244894981384,
0.1652808040380478,
0.3778415322303772,
-0.1623716801404953,
-0.27272164821624756,
0.12591993808746338,
-0.6808284521102905,
-0.8673368692398071,
-0.08899106830358505,
0.16667932271957397,
0.21249157190322876,
0.06433010846376419,
0.06586319953203201,
0.038539960980415344,
-0.23555706441402435,
0.7205939292907715,
0.19666768610477448,
-0.5487964749336243,
-0.1611117273569107,
-0.14248842000961304,
-0.13739797472953796,
0.2624988257884979,
0.8106191158294678,
-0.5411117672920227,
0.44659000635147095,
0.13327725231647491,
0.23658888041973114,
0.4415777027606964,
-0.32886070013046265,
0.5091223120689392,
-1.0691050291061401,
0.46881306171417236,
-0.03839081525802612,
0.34085845947265625,
0.2130819857120514,
-0.31503772735595703,
0.4156399369239807,
0.14683301746845245,
-0.55860435962677,
-0.7915829420089722,
0.11866535991430283,
-0.5845052003860474,
-0.5704969167709351,
0.9360634088516235,
0.24986103177070618,
0.2134053111076355,
-0.15380001068115234,
-0.18041318655014038,
0.3975437879562378,
-0.17179188132286072,
0.9216156005859375,
0.8389085531234741,
-0.003787937806919217,
-0.12510795891284943,
-0.3831591308116913,
0.4766828119754791,
0.5482838749885559,
-0.5880131125450134,
0.3143693506717682,
0.43643954396247864,
0.3155049979686737,
0.18963928520679474,
0.06670047342777252,
-0.04670438542962074,
-0.19309422373771667,
-0.3297036588191986,
0.27656877040863037,
0.2440716177225113,
-0.4194504916667938,
-0.50880366563797,
0.2623995542526245,
0.23028425872325897,
0.21620550751686096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13013v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13013v1 | Code Needs Comments: Enhancing Code LLMs with Comment Augmentation | 2024-02-20T13:56:38 | 2024-02-20T13:56:38 | Demin Song, Honglin Guo, Yunhua Zhou, Shuhao Xing, Yudong Wang, Zifan Song, Wenwei Zhang, Qipeng Guo, Hang Yan, Xipeng Qiu, Dahua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | The programming skill is one crucial ability for Large Language Models
(LLMs), necessitating a deep understanding of programming languages (PLs) and
their correlation with natural languages (NLs). We examine the impact of
pre-training data on code-focused LLMs' performance by assessing the comment
density as a measure of PL-NL alignment. Given the scarcity of code-comment
aligned data in pre-training corpora, we introduce a novel data augmentation
method that generates comments for existing code, coupled with a data filtering
strategy that filters out code data poorly correlated with natural language. We
conducted experiments on three code-focused LLMs and observed consistent
improvements in performance on two widely-used programming skill benchmarks.
Notably, the model trained on the augmented data outperformed both the model
used for generating comments and the model further trained on the data without
augmentation. | [
-0.5746598839759827,
-0.3250286877155304,
0.37145641446113586,
0.270492285490036,
-0.3813658356666565,
0.323273241519928,
-0.40267473459243774,
-0.6707434058189392,
0.1969025582075119,
0.746489942073822,
-0.4406564235687256,
-0.5199262499809265,
-0.43654972314834595,
0.3633861839771271,
-0.42700716853141785,
1.3186755180358887,
0.14073055982589722,
0.23930466175079346,
-0.6794003248214722,
0.20222072303295135,
-0.28005051612854004,
-0.6515313386917114,
0.009059995412826538,
-0.11870202422142029,
0.3751050531864166,
0.40991464257240295,
0.7644975185394287,
0.5653819441795349,
0.7844125032424927,
0.2422361969947815,
0.17895852029323578,
0.22009031474590302,
-0.42551732063293457,
-0.16314446926116943,
0.21060723066329956,
-0.6069198846817017,
-0.5684711933135986,
-0.173623189330101,
0.4037833511829376,
0.8249651193618774,
0.16117124259471893,
0.07943886518478394,
0.18078157305717468,
0.6489307284355164,
-0.5160675048828125,
0.16095022857189178,
-0.35064083337783813,
0.07737581431865692,
0.014599939808249474,
-0.4365417957305908,
-0.23973171412944794,
-0.704166054725647,
0.050374120473861694,
-0.5471753478050232,
0.16884487867355347,
-0.3660402297973633,
0.5851731300354004,
0.7145670056343079,
-0.0389026440680027,
-0.3770233690738678,
-0.5861179232597351,
0.5524866580963135,
-0.9403696656227112,
0.24192723631858826,
0.420261949300766,
-0.4142276346683502,
-0.011462880298495293,
-0.4415262043476105,
-0.39618995785713196,
-0.43308642506599426,
-0.18429554998874664,
-0.11009229719638824,
0.4993416368961334,
0.21329690515995026,
0.6738133430480957,
0.5595071911811829,
-0.36677315831184387,
-0.12675605714321136,
-0.459016889333725,
-0.011824993416666985,
0.7590178847312927,
-0.10927684605121613,
0.2219802886247635,
-0.04962925240397453,
-0.10863503813743591,
0.18095755577087402,
-0.6249992847442627,
0.03686397150158882,
0.5229292511940002,
0.20730648934841156,
-0.13153232634067535,
0.5848130583763123,
-0.16269060969352722,
0.9907364249229431,
-0.2817804515361786,
-0.1174202561378479,
0.4744637906551361,
-0.43733569979667664,
-0.05121227726340294,
-0.2849869430065155,
0.35486549139022827,
0.2302432358264923,
0.6470056176185608,
-0.25202980637550354,
-0.221798837184906,
0.26012083888053894,
0.5096353888511658,
-0.6535515189170837,
-0.5690068602561951,
-0.1298440843820572,
-0.32632285356521606,
-0.4600273668766022,
0.3287712633609772,
-0.595090925693512,
-0.6669758558273315,
-0.6891279816627502,
-0.0034280049148947,
-0.13074584305286407,
-0.3370853066444397,
-0.05945646017789841,
-0.02303427644073963,
0.1945028305053711,
0.27243614196777344,
-0.7794162631034851,
0.25625911355018616,
0.7313038110733032,
0.5272794961929321,
-0.12425554543733597,
-0.15254457294940948,
-0.5490739941596985,
-0.06320886313915253,
-0.6258718371391296,
0.8459499478340149,
-1.012370228767395,
-0.3301352560520172,
0.10862074792385101,
-0.19774366915225983,
0.2244916409254074,
-0.6433390378952026,
0.35684606432914734,
-0.6842350959777832,
-0.13084827363491058,
-0.2179563045501709,
-0.5900843739509583,
0.08070626854896545,
0.0961340069770813,
-0.44660472869873047,
1.2334330081939697,
0.42170724272727966,
-0.814356803894043,
0.4422283470630646,
-0.630522608757019,
-0.6942062973976135,
0.24366065859794617,
-0.3997909128665924,
-0.10687614977359772,
0.3607231676578522,
0.17956741154193878,
0.2694672644138336,
0.02442696876823902,
0.1553085446357727,
-0.6023496389389038,
-0.6220178604125977,
0.46586334705352783,
-0.02882067672908306,
0.29538366198539734,
0.14950548112392426,
-0.1469646841287613,
0.0071264454163610935,
-0.9806391000747681,
0.36801013350486755,
-0.3725939691066742,
-0.5880516171455383,
-0.09493336081504822,
0.12450863420963287,
-0.24475815892219543,
0.27655917406082153,
0.49030813574790955,
-0.324015349149704,
0.344735324382782,
-0.5813591480255127,
0.1648331731557846,
0.4933202564716339,
-0.056356385350227356,
0.46697771549224854,
-0.05882168933749199,
0.5538457036018372,
-0.1058218702673912,
0.16222073137760162,
-0.18656612932682037,
-0.1379334032535553,
-0.8812308311462402,
-0.15632863342761993,
0.2126208394765854,
0.49129486083984375,
-0.7586032748222351,
0.28527048230171204,
-0.21015624701976776,
-0.1605616956949234,
-0.6659218668937683,
0.821357011795044,
0.5133805274963379,
0.2447824776172638,
0.31650158762931824,
-0.7041858434677124,
-1.1074825525283813,
-0.7401260137557983,
-0.15006867051124573,
0.006497805006802082,
-0.012103155255317688,
0.2341310977935791,
0.1300020068883896,
-0.3784193694591522,
0.9787037968635559,
-0.668892502784729,
0.12918789684772491,
-0.1620137095451355,
-0.05623960867524147,
0.19639073312282562,
0.4754648208618164,
0.11782446503639221,
-0.43124479055404663,
-0.5782648324966431,
-0.1474272459745407,
-0.6717616319656372,
-0.4027007520198822,
0.08993163704872131,
0.07866230607032776,
0.1346852332353592,
0.7496988773345947,
-0.29228129982948303,
0.49980229139328003,
0.6370338201522827,
0.18313181400299072,
0.37172970175743103,
-0.268060564994812,
0.0738958865404129,
-0.6941062211990356,
0.1560937762260437,
0.02857442945241928,
-0.22922703623771667,
-0.6438943147659302,
0.04183816537261009,
0.20721741020679474,
-0.19101566076278687,
-0.07942096889019012,
-0.06888505816459656,
-0.5898770093917847,
-0.2997846007347107,
-0.6797856092453003,
0.09224085509777069,
0.04704445227980614,
0.43359851837158203,
0.29507920145988464,
1.0437464714050293,
0.4319170117378235,
-0.7112353444099426,
0.12102843821048737,
0.09136583656072617,
-0.5206565856933594,
0.193730890750885,
-0.5373246669769287,
0.6205577254295349,
0.07202892750501633,
-0.018536971881985664,
-1.038700819015503,
-0.23835612833499908,
-0.18074215948581696,
-0.5010294318199158,
0.43376848101615906,
-0.39454197883605957,
-0.39802566170692444,
-0.46373146772384644,
-0.33842769265174866,
0.18149524927139282,
0.30485185980796814,
-0.2590741813182831,
0.1677354872226715,
0.45800676941871643,
-0.20100992918014526,
-0.7333746552467346,
-0.7952084541320801,
0.2446267008781433,
0.14454853534698486,
-0.5362059473991394,
0.0943790152668953,
-0.22327791154384613,
-0.09047482162714005,
-0.020153028890490532,
-0.015654580667614937,
-0.22760239243507385,
0.2156013548374176,
0.2918761670589447,
0.47760987281799316,
-0.17383813858032227,
0.09644787013530731,
-0.4722113311290741,
-0.09940528869628906,
0.321018785238266,
-0.09214992821216583,
0.5440027713775635,
-0.09490695595741272,
-0.21651417016983032,
-0.11597970873117447,
0.18863123655319214,
0.39640581607818604,
-0.23660029470920563,
0.659492552280426,
0.25478267669677734,
-0.05520785227417946,
-0.19892750680446625,
-0.7344983220100403,
-0.12014943361282349,
-0.4634658694267273,
0.5530903339385986,
-0.1019560918211937,
-0.958124577999115,
0.3122286796569824,
0.16674193739891052,
-0.06972914189100266,
0.0772106796503067,
0.22613327205181122,
-0.17791199684143066,
1.1244621276855469,
0.9563853740692139,
-0.3589038848876953,
0.6937983632087708,
-0.11588955670595169,
0.5078912377357483,
-0.8856109380722046,
-0.08407015353441238,
-0.5095744132995605,
0.05388038977980614,
-0.5470472574234009,
-0.5569197535514832,
0.009943814016878605,
0.1018868014216423,
-0.11633520573377609,
0.27719858288764954,
-0.6246019601821899,
0.6567311882972717,
0.3303326368331909,
0.23059290647506714,
0.1810101866722107,
0.011326023377478123,
0.27943864464759827,
-0.09529291838407516,
-0.48476436734199524,
-0.44246023893356323,
1.343274712562561,
0.2204362154006958,
0.8631342053413391,
-0.19517803192138672,
0.6521974802017212,
0.30519139766693115,
0.5250148177146912,
-0.34907597303390503,
0.48203298449516296,
-0.17855261266231537,
-0.33002135157585144,
0.037233173847198486,
-0.5491422414779663,
-0.31001052260398865,
-0.16746391355991364,
-0.11042263358831406,
-0.3166239559650421,
-0.004097870551049709,
0.3317967355251312,
-0.4926184117794037,
-0.05227594077587128,
-1.0147430896759033,
0.6408039927482605,
-0.3536028265953064,
-0.596728503704071,
-0.21229204535484314,
-0.6088396310806274,
0.2870904505252838,
-0.05085163563489914,
0.24811704456806183,
0.13574139773845673,
-0.18188278377056122,
0.5197634696960449,
-0.6286076307296753,
0.959006667137146,
-0.38703981041908264,
-0.18722859025001526,
0.3403024673461914,
-0.19735530018806458,
0.5164803266525269,
0.08592764288187027,
-0.05430924892425537,
-0.0558164156973362,
-0.230177104473114,
-0.37417805194854736,
-0.5719130635261536,
0.7095837593078613,
-0.8339473605155945,
-0.7519243955612183,
-0.16482451558113098,
-0.6780495643615723,
-0.5124396085739136,
0.023478830233216286,
0.013078507035970688,
0.3474980294704437,
0.22452512383460999,
0.17483201622962952,
0.7486345171928406,
-0.09618497639894485,
0.31557366251945496,
0.40809231996536255,
-0.15555386245250702,
-0.5755293369293213,
0.7726905941963196,
0.03358513116836548,
0.382015198469162,
0.14774468541145325,
-0.33145350217819214,
-0.13062478601932526,
-0.6973088383674622,
-0.046354297548532486,
0.2345685064792633,
-0.8355878591537476,
-0.28711822628974915,
-0.6658743023872375,
-0.37547600269317627,
-0.49088674783706665,
-0.21002180874347687,
-0.1721005141735077,
-0.23618283867835999,
-0.3091621398925781,
-0.13139832019805908,
0.5221612453460693,
0.9153475761413574,
0.06057630851864815,
0.11818473786115646,
-0.884276807308197,
0.15497972071170807,
0.11281605064868927,
0.8941866159439087,
-0.027294576168060303,
-0.5747812986373901,
-0.7888268232345581,
0.02890903316438198,
0.07255597412586212,
-0.7437758445739746,
0.284981369972229,
0.04234970360994339,
0.4377242624759674,
0.2662825286388397,
-0.15697713196277618,
0.9554488658905029,
-0.0695648267865181,
0.7570497989654541,
-0.03648078441619873,
-0.8866291642189026,
0.591023862361908,
-0.058535683900117874,
0.27577924728393555,
0.9185851812362671,
-0.013895235024392605,
-0.29805055260658264,
-0.4225054979324341,
-0.2974415421485901,
-0.6814303398132324,
0.7492716312408447,
-0.1192852109670639,
0.3825960159301758,
-0.1707414835691452,
0.5165789723396301,
-0.13994573056697845,
0.5960245728492737,
-0.9923178553581238,
0.05604064092040062,
-0.13237078487873077,
-0.21921253204345703,
-0.09967288374900818,
-0.467239648103714,
0.11219293624162674,
-0.47076553106307983,
0.5234919786453247,
-0.1792682558298111,
0.12456423789262772,
0.20291419327259064,
-0.3356110155582428,
-0.15436530113220215,
0.1247267872095108,
0.7217358946800232,
0.5935347080230713,
-0.08890561014413834,
0.232438325881958,
0.22912801802158356,
-0.4800776541233063,
-0.08820286393165588,
-0.09157323837280273,
0.05040772259235382,
-0.3006224036216736,
0.3028191328048706,
0.5156533718109131,
0.4216897487640381,
-0.6636326909065247,
0.48161014914512634,
0.19124096632003784,
-0.04385479539632797,
-0.2042638212442398,
0.4783080518245697,
0.16452503204345703,
-0.1990547925233841,
0.1928025335073471,
0.4500877857208252,
0.029769545421004295,
-0.4767705202102661,
0.34550711512565613,
0.31005576252937317,
-0.5295058488845825,
-0.20606642961502075,
0.18980734050273895,
0.26839679479599,
-0.11326554417610168,
0.44186899065971375,
-0.13472917675971985,
-0.695284903049469,
0.6260182857513428,
0.49787840247154236,
0.6486603021621704,
-0.11453340202569962,
0.037051890045404434,
0.3290998339653015,
0.35800260305404663,
0.04987293481826782,
0.47589486837387085,
-0.3172585070133209,
-0.44681233167648315,
-0.9529042840003967,
-0.39593154191970825,
-0.23097479343414307,
0.021458037197589874,
-0.49874526262283325,
0.45510804653167725,
-0.7442021369934082,
-0.045846130698919296,
-0.40509822964668274,
0.33800479769706726,
-0.7187395095825195,
0.24862785637378693,
0.36812663078308105,
0.798690140247345,
-0.7689250707626343,
0.9684667587280273,
0.7234882712364197,
-0.5625479221343994,
-0.8768213391304016,
0.01558289397507906,
-0.49084609746932983,
-0.716492235660553,
0.6068845987319946,
0.22537796199321747,
-0.10522060841321945,
-0.023291438817977905,
-0.6939603090286255,
-1.1456900835037231,
0.3519662022590637,
0.4481388330459595,
-0.46027064323425293,
0.2558528482913971,
0.4857325553894043,
0.910505473613739,
-0.48504865169525146,
0.4484013617038727,
0.5693309307098389,
0.2594824433326721,
-0.16129861772060394,
-0.6206727623939514,
-0.25744810700416565,
-0.7148365378379822,
0.14672668278217316,
0.23301798105239868,
-0.5005295872688293,
0.5402178764343262,
-0.24363815784454346,
0.12158910930156708,
-0.1397686004638672,
0.5938305854797363,
0.07855255901813507,
0.11778520792722702,
0.4097341001033783,
0.6046551465988159,
0.7060429453849792,
0.11050321906805038,
1.1411902904510498,
-0.7349105477333069,
0.08785489201545715,
1.2554196119308472,
-0.6501628160476685,
0.7792806029319763,
0.47684699296951294,
-0.29263797402381897,
0.7793328166007996,
0.44643449783325195,
-0.10138852894306183,
0.46842342615127563,
0.36308279633522034,
-0.15875308215618134,
-0.1736825853586197,
-0.10546630620956421,
-0.5839241147041321,
-0.019687961786985397,
0.3525259494781494,
-0.33186569809913635,
0.21494416892528534,
-0.16645383834838867,
-0.10813818871974945,
0.29997387528419495,
-0.1836184561252594,
0.9846699833869934,
0.0282121654599905,
-1.0319592952728271,
0.5491332411766052,
-0.2953578531742096,
0.6771261096000671,
-0.6210812926292419,
-0.06024475768208504,
-0.31927290558815,
0.16211111843585968,
-0.8576281666755676,
-0.7076588273048401,
0.4298379421234131,
0.4559799134731293,
-0.41513198614120483,
0.024200977757573128,
0.5670068264007568,
-0.5136070251464844,
-0.44424423575401306,
0.39396268129348755,
0.10185141116380692,
-0.04505894333124161,
0.08946075290441513,
-0.4254504144191742,
0.1381402462720871,
0.22018565237522125,
-0.056013837456703186,
0.3769531548023224,
0.2838567793369293,
0.29371434450149536,
0.4241778254508972,
0.7990972995758057,
0.19355280697345734,
0.2898953855037689,
0.38013654947280884,
1.1998271942138672,
-0.4602982997894287,
-0.37860023975372314,
-0.6516404747962952,
0.43655961751937866,
-0.4621647000312805,
-0.18399503827095032,
0.8474507927894592,
0.8053049445152283,
0.9325422048568726,
-0.17158456146717072,
0.9884231686592102,
0.011683724820613861,
0.6058191657066345,
-0.37758833169937134,
0.23244330286979675,
-0.22250764071941376,
0.6872127652168274,
-0.5239388346672058,
-1.0134057998657227,
-0.41155365109443665,
0.7269014120101929,
-0.7582021951675415,
0.24376280605793,
0.588054895401001,
1.1341917514801025,
0.13072368502616882,
0.14512236416339874,
0.2115088850259781,
-0.03474070131778717,
0.0826645940542221,
0.5698082447052002,
0.9843520522117615,
-0.24427206814289093,
0.5844743251800537,
-0.4402070939540863,
-0.09442903846502304,
-0.22564154863357544,
-0.8243364095687866,
-0.8039866089820862,
-0.16397042572498322,
-0.5405715703964233,
-0.34182077646255493,
-0.224153533577919,
0.9596091508865356,
0.7917060256004333,
-0.8833432197570801,
-0.2649818956851959,
-0.4463934600353241,
0.046008676290512085,
0.09664510190486908,
-0.23514950275421143,
0.08879214525222778,
-0.9110941290855408,
-0.4344634711742401,
0.41387805342674255,
0.3483937084674835,
-0.14338991045951843,
-0.30370911955833435,
-0.24365702271461487,
0.006632363889366388,
0.01409115456044674,
0.37224820256233215,
0.2236209511756897,
-0.3712017238140106,
-0.2722252607345581,
0.13002856075763702,
-0.31532835960388184,
0.3506820797920227,
1.1913580894470215,
-0.7972413897514343,
0.543201744556427,
0.4553178548812866,
0.7471516132354736,
0.34262794256210327,
0.18426689505577087,
0.5577259659767151,
-1.015038013458252,
0.3328782618045807,
0.20353010296821594,
0.23527422547340393,
0.5083487629890442,
-0.6379783153533936,
0.5650382041931152,
0.07366921007633209,
-0.5864547491073608,
-0.9937165975570679,
-0.004550488665699959,
-0.5787289142608643,
-0.08696084469556808,
1.0513038635253906,
-0.1331072747707367,
0.013693302869796753,
-0.3349849283695221,
-0.19971978664398193,
0.12273188680410385,
-0.2203999012708664,
0.7018930912017822,
0.7034409046173096,
-0.0678531751036644,
-0.2640860974788666,
-0.606011152267456,
0.8122342824935913,
0.5854989290237427,
-0.8655272722244263,
0.20039993524551392,
0.5163370966911316,
0.13514791429042816,
0.1311073750257492,
0.7650702595710754,
-0.20594169199466705,
0.4318629205226898,
-0.091779924929142,
0.27645477652549744,
-0.07803070545196533,
-0.3723495602607727,
-0.43702971935272217,
0.34031179547309875,
0.47666576504707336,
0.21875344216823578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13302v1 | Enhancing Modern Supervised Word Sense Disambiguation Models by Semantic Lexical Resources | 2024-02-20T13:47:51 | 2024-02-20T13:47:51 | Stefano Melacci, Achille Globo, Leonardo Rigutini | cs.CL | cs.CL | Supervised models for Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD) currently yield to
state-of-the-art results in the most popular benchmarks. Despite the recent
introduction of Word Embeddings and Recurrent Neural Networks to design
powerful context-related features, the interest in improving WSD models using
Semantic Lexical Resources (SLRs) is mostly restricted to knowledge-based
approaches. In this paper, we enhance "modern" supervised WSD models exploiting
two popular SLRs: WordNet and WordNet Domains. We propose an effective way to
introduce semantic features into the classifiers, and we consider using the SLR
structure to augment the training data. We study the effect of different types
of semantic features, investigating their interaction with local contexts
encoded by means of mixtures of Word Embeddings or Recurrent Neural Networks,
and we extend the proposed model into a novel multi-layer architecture for WSD.
A detailed experimental comparison in the recent Unified Evaluation Framework
(Raganato et al., 2017) shows that the proposed approach leads to supervised
models that compare favourably with the state-of-the art. | [
-0.5449154376983643,
-0.37738969922065735,
0.6081070899963379,
-0.3007180690765381,
-0.2222713679075241,
-0.13524585962295532,
-0.16155089437961578,
-0.7296527028083801,
0.13371680676937103,
0.33868101239204407,
-0.3919723331928253,
-0.495613157749176,
-0.7091932892799377,
-0.02508634328842163,
-0.41000863909721375,
0.8373305201530457,
0.010994313284754753,
0.11223676800727844,
-0.3912041187286377,
-0.6075182557106018,
-0.5775274634361267,
-0.643281877040863,
-0.16718757152557373,
-0.43883752822875977,
0.619184672832489,
-0.20104803144931793,
0.7112124562263489,
0.3155915141105652,
0.3956533968448639,
0.3386014401912689,
-0.6074188351631165,
0.4999403953552246,
-0.02250187285244465,
0.02189161628484726,
-0.39227235317230225,
-0.06578726321458817,
-0.4664994478225708,
-0.09627220034599304,
0.2253277599811554,
1.1391280889511108,
-0.24423018097877502,
-0.14211975038051605,
0.17804911732673645,
0.5275631546974182,
-0.9631051421165466,
0.05505239963531494,
-0.7661254405975342,
0.032921869307756424,
0.04050905257463455,
-0.018323278054594994,
-0.16184616088867188,
0.03781907632946968,
0.550819993019104,
-0.8126375079154968,
0.25098180770874023,
-0.025530340149998665,
0.6460965871810913,
0.11888749897480011,
-0.3794763684272766,
-0.33444324135780334,
-0.31634601950645447,
0.8866337537765503,
-0.6339613795280457,
0.7048780918121338,
0.29149195551872253,
0.16223296523094177,
-0.21240290999412537,
-0.7816068530082703,
-0.5930257439613342,
-0.29148098826408386,
-0.264323353767395,
0.15535132586956024,
-0.024712257087230682,
0.1844407171010971,
0.14192278683185577,
0.3208940923213959,
-0.1611032634973526,
-0.09776415675878525,
-0.24677959084510803,
-0.3699374496936798,
0.4322963058948517,
0.12174065411090851,
-0.03874931111931801,
-0.05326027423143387,
-0.6322852969169617,
-0.23720192909240723,
-0.1612614393234253,
-0.0857967883348465,
0.061939455568790436,
0.5451762080192566,
0.23639461398124695,
0.579001784324646,
-0.4063929617404938,
1.2423889636993408,
-0.20406483113765717,
-0.4397544264793396,
0.3766254186630249,
-0.5294511318206787,
-0.02455282397568226,
0.15697361528873444,
0.13187001645565033,
0.4163435995578766,
0.19160465896129608,
-0.3603709936141968,
-0.395065575838089,
0.4628860056400299,
0.27059635519981384,
-0.56144118309021,
-0.22042959928512573,
-0.061950430274009705,
-0.25211301445961,
-0.23215045034885406,
0.28527525067329407,
-0.31109094619750977,
-0.5822943449020386,
-0.7575306296348572,
0.5701521039009094,
-0.653583824634552,
-0.3767147362232208,
0.4584883451461792,
-0.7007713913917542,
0.07064349204301834,
0.2874685227870941,
-0.5135288834571838,
0.3367559015750885,
0.6599012613296509,
0.7777319550514221,
-0.2725791335105896,
-0.4379885494709015,
-0.21806499361991882,
0.20777712762355804,
-0.06931321322917938,
0.6813809871673584,
-0.7767326831817627,
-0.2509693503379822,
0.0643601268529892,
0.04473442584276199,
0.039786048233509064,
-0.5910149216651917,
0.19819375872612,
-0.579608678817749,
0.18043547868728638,
-0.3806720972061157,
-0.6908358335494995,
-0.23515157401561737,
0.2587045729160309,
-0.40928372740745544,
0.9568091034889221,
0.49864575266838074,
-0.944168746471405,
0.6609576344490051,
-0.8990855813026428,
-0.4938057065010071,
-0.022996021434664726,
0.11831280589103699,
0.14828594028949738,
0.40047481656074524,
0.16051869094371796,
0.3075004518032074,
0.1417577564716339,
0.4072989225387573,
-0.44455304741859436,
-0.26602697372436523,
0.3361490070819855,
-0.2273579239845276,
0.5869442820549011,
0.3413635194301605,
0.11002565920352936,
0.13316087424755096,
-0.9736154079437256,
0.048951804637908936,
0.021310867741703987,
0.004947441164404154,
-1.1509960889816284,
-0.15144416689872742,
0.07314464449882507,
0.1282690167427063,
0.3734907805919647,
-0.5856256484985352,
-0.13057823479175568,
-0.42101216316223145,
0.6590844392776489,
0.3556184470653534,
-0.12337057292461395,
0.6096546053886414,
-0.15214425325393677,
0.13822241127490997,
0.5882972478866577,
0.129288449883461,
-0.09447869658470154,
-0.2897926867008209,
-0.45184606313705444,
-0.26265451312065125,
0.2350487858057022,
0.31339147686958313,
-0.7723877429962158,
0.4923904538154602,
-0.16096779704093933,
-0.3979811668395996,
-0.4558202624320984,
0.07462858408689499,
0.27276137471199036,
0.7314746379852295,
0.5776169300079346,
-0.5270912051200867,
-0.3392656445503235,
-0.5778483748435974,
-0.151597261428833,
0.05374348536133766,
-0.32599860429763794,
0.2378334403038025,
0.32081735134124756,
-0.2007024586200714,
1.4257429838180542,
-0.5096253752708435,
-0.4557536840438843,
-0.20479260385036469,
-0.3035306930541992,
-0.14489023387432098,
0.2238112986087799,
0.3666885793209076,
-1.0137226581573486,
0.29166901111602783,
-0.175569549202919,
-0.5968315005302429,
0.10608962178230286,
0.3649355173110962,
-0.07255910336971283,
-0.05703390762209892,
0.3214738368988037,
-0.36686092615127563,
0.46779680252075195,
0.28390398621559143,
-0.5239335894584656,
0.3521888554096222,
-0.2724308967590332,
-0.2163657248020172,
-1.1923854351043701,
-0.17687593400478363,
0.20586951076984406,
-0.06349875777959824,
-0.6712604761123657,
0.3708231747150421,
0.2590111196041107,
-0.13311956822872162,
-0.6091976761817932,
0.7226663827896118,
-0.4097510576248169,
-0.27968040108680725,
-0.3301323354244232,
0.6069405674934387,
0.5685630440711975,
0.192549467086792,
0.17902228236198425,
0.5186882615089417,
0.5496708750724792,
-0.7549780607223511,
0.3247954845428467,
0.2358415424823761,
-0.4952582120895386,
0.711664617061615,
-0.6346963047981262,
-0.2938147783279419,
-0.3420907258987427,
0.09946118295192719,
-0.6972513198852539,
-0.10578110069036484,
-0.205548495054245,
-0.2976006269454956,
0.14749421179294586,
0.060620617121458054,
-0.40289902687072754,
-0.34892505407333374,
-0.22594347596168518,
0.26999980211257935,
0.12918345630168915,
-0.7743657827377319,
0.46837118268013,
0.44298428297042847,
0.36784985661506653,
-0.4267677366733551,
-0.7254950404167175,
0.09290251135826111,
-0.382646381855011,
-0.5676242709159851,
0.7119978666305542,
0.32767027616500854,
-0.31605225801467896,
0.22827963531017303,
-0.26139745116233826,
-0.12015477567911148,
0.3153458833694458,
0.0665006935596466,
0.29591867327690125,
-0.052691999822854996,
0.4008864760398865,
0.027353139594197273,
-0.12438717484474182,
-0.2764255702495575,
-0.6683769822120667,
0.4498017132282257,
-0.19566772878170013,
-0.4260985553264618,
-0.0271404217928648,
0.3387300670146942,
0.48174455761909485,
-0.6852325201034546,
0.7885632514953613,
0.751089334487915,
-0.5882384181022644,
-0.20076115429401398,
-0.4771292805671692,
-0.5373107194900513,
-0.48198822140693665,
0.5842796564102173,
-0.5152270197868347,
-1.213826298713684,
0.3813943564891815,
-0.29345038533210754,
-0.08427106589078903,
0.05579100176692009,
0.002509248908609152,
-0.047058816999197006,
0.9141638278961182,
0.6651536822319031,
-0.06663508713245392,
0.4553963840007782,
-0.050107743591070175,
0.3448035717010498,
-1.1836321353912354,
-0.17561830580234528,
-0.2441125512123108,
-0.24944362044334412,
-0.44790852069854736,
-0.3182414770126343,
0.35460877418518066,
0.3170009255409241,
-0.10712892562150955,
0.3768497109413147,
-0.6634259223937988,
0.08747457712888718,
0.3762347400188446,
0.1859312802553177,
0.22830769419670105,
0.16144020855426788,
-0.4526352882385254,
0.02509365603327751,
-0.862543523311615,
-0.35006749629974365,
0.5729966163635254,
0.3071051239967346,
0.7998641133308411,
0.08978958427906036,
0.5333420634269714,
0.21356281638145447,
-0.006678971461951733,
-0.8753067255020142,
0.511833906173706,
-0.22193852066993713,
-0.2395062893629074,
-0.22337716817855835,
-0.14280642569065094,
-0.9021663069725037,
0.48194822669029236,
-0.14402183890342712,
-0.6027335524559021,
0.2681478261947632,
-0.13214488327503204,
-0.3082064986228943,
0.20664598047733307,
-0.778546929359436,
0.7984171509742737,
-0.011487643234431744,
-0.22360281646251678,
0.04840587452054024,
-0.3509909510612488,
0.24406062066555023,
0.18230290710926056,
0.14532393217086792,
0.013752191327512264,
-0.227392315864563,
0.45565861463546753,
-0.6612438559532166,
0.836224377155304,
-0.6455109119415283,
-0.39044082164764404,
0.29514238238334656,
-0.22887022793293,
0.27078697085380554,
-0.19884631037712097,
-0.10509756952524185,
0.3013245463371277,
0.1850297451019287,
-0.2970462143421173,
-0.6258920431137085,
0.6463718414306641,
-0.34341004490852356,
-0.4200018346309662,
-0.35143589973449707,
-0.7616769075393677,
-0.5314635634422302,
0.039709512144327164,
-0.04124796390533447,
0.8293504118919373,
0.1288089007139206,
-0.012123674154281616,
0.546404242515564,
-0.05524948984384537,
0.3602308928966522,
0.3066837191581726,
-0.006561291869729757,
-0.19525547325611115,
0.7470163702964783,
0.20475031435489655,
0.2634943127632141,
-0.007519603706896305,
0.25769293308258057,
-0.6009036302566528,
-0.5202975273132324,
-0.3004038631916046,
-0.16997243463993073,
-0.6087480783462524,
-0.3065657317638397,
-0.5959234833717346,
-0.2940128743648529,
-0.49135062098503113,
-0.08227322995662689,
-0.10320529341697693,
-0.2505347728729248,
-0.016077877953648567,
-0.14418862760066986,
0.8353316187858582,
0.4201180040836334,
0.2773350477218628,
0.34693047404289246,
-0.7344444394111633,
0.1554722636938095,
0.22332067787647247,
0.5675637722015381,
0.25918686389923096,
-0.6002451181411743,
-0.13024915754795074,
0.04395207390189171,
-0.04660608619451523,
-0.6572946310043335,
0.25986766815185547,
0.29902148246765137,
0.48127281665802,
0.522589385509491,
0.17843866348266602,
1.0733933448791504,
-0.5056411623954773,
0.6754592061042786,
0.24960802495479584,
-0.7521381974220276,
0.640963077545166,
-0.08231403678655624,
0.423213392496109,
0.44876527786254883,
0.13777226209640503,
-0.5218493342399597,
-0.4209892153739929,
-0.44273799657821655,
-0.7538652420043945,
0.30007269978523254,
-0.2529072165489197,
0.3272017240524292,
-0.2775554060935974,
0.45836248993873596,
0.17662104964256287,
0.22863949835300446,
-0.2472802847623825,
-0.024893276393413544,
-0.3329910635948181,
-0.43022334575653076,
0.15421761572360992,
-0.2594883441925049,
-0.017385128885507584,
-0.10339156538248062,
0.34804457426071167,
-0.3145028054714203,
-0.20697630941867828,
0.4056890606880188,
-0.3758005201816559,
0.6042308807373047,
0.27357274293899536,
0.33622053265571594,
0.7671395540237427,
0.05966808274388313,
0.34775882959365845,
0.408561110496521,
-0.5072649121284485,
0.06587868183851242,
0.07844878733158112,
-0.3740620017051697,
0.08751358091831207,
0.25005456805229187,
0.9086430668830872,
0.5090769529342651,
-0.5619733929634094,
0.4632726013660431,
0.14137724041938782,
-0.12225047498941422,
-0.3420253098011017,
0.3061886727809906,
0.1511293351650238,
0.2944723069667816,
0.3179182708263397,
0.18265701830387115,
0.2554318606853485,
-0.4245172441005707,
0.34494641423225403,
0.5294522047042847,
-0.5466651320457458,
-0.036035895347595215,
0.33848583698272705,
-0.130838543176651,
0.1018519252538681,
0.09673520922660828,
-0.45962581038475037,
-0.5107260942459106,
0.21293072402477264,
0.8031189441680908,
0.34593087434768677,
0.05785057321190834,
-0.047570668160915375,
0.3776680529117584,
0.09109427034854889,
-0.13501819968223572,
0.2986232042312622,
-0.28000128269195557,
-1.0429143905639648,
-0.1899811178445816,
-0.9230849742889404,
-0.22990696132183075,
-0.03902100399136543,
-0.9468288421630859,
0.1380005031824112,
-0.1537833958864212,
-0.3277231454849243,
-0.13292624056339264,
-0.025670189410448074,
-0.6390743851661682,
0.2521491050720215,
0.18589504063129425,
1.0909912586212158,
-0.6440950632095337,
0.9605206251144409,
0.964055061340332,
-0.14129848778247833,
-0.5574241876602173,
-0.14470550417900085,
-0.10886965692043304,
-0.5494130849838257,
0.39947831630706787,
0.23118343949317932,
-0.15526755154132843,
-0.02259220741689205,
-0.15082404017448425,
-0.8014152646064758,
1.259531855583191,
-0.07346267998218536,
-0.6192206740379333,
0.05510087311267853,
0.07833044230937958,
0.465667724609375,
-0.3449471592903137,
-0.006523745134472847,
0.5250920653343201,
0.42151862382888794,
0.13677595555782318,
-0.5191495418548584,
0.0003628599224612117,
-0.0777653232216835,
0.5790791511535645,
0.17532339692115784,
-0.15376876294612885,
0.5391898155212402,
-0.2762598693370819,
-0.23832552134990692,
0.005830027628690004,
0.9594202041625977,
0.5353631973266602,
0.5411361455917358,
0.8801125884056091,
0.9861083030700684,
0.9239795207977295,
-0.08921331912279129,
0.828944742679596,
-0.2870332598686218,
0.10068861395120621,
1.313944697380066,
-0.6097646355628967,
0.8690564036369324,
0.7002230286598206,
-0.23127630352973938,
0.4038730263710022,
0.5915557146072388,
-0.06806575506925583,
0.74866783618927,
0.4488743245601654,
-0.4585207402706146,
0.033483829349279404,
-0.6009916663169861,
-0.2709518373012543,
0.577512264251709,
0.5462632179260254,
-0.04107372835278511,
-0.3673544228076935,
0.43526965379714966,
-0.14535196125507355,
0.29973942041397095,
-0.4457121789455414,
0.8469072580337524,
0.04822305962443352,
-0.3964596390724182,
0.2511548697948456,
0.17492185533046722,
1.2136858701705933,
-0.6343525052070618,
0.08449963480234146,
-0.24635709822177887,
0.21222947537899017,
-0.18560680747032166,
-0.518607497215271,
0.34633296728134155,
0.05664721876382828,
-0.1488078385591507,
0.11515607684850693,
1.1741520166397095,
-0.5255416035652161,
-0.5905662775039673,
0.581004798412323,
0.5784499049186707,
-0.04020005837082863,
-0.1959177851676941,
-0.43252599239349365,
-0.03104408085346222,
-0.5103694200515747,
0.07114119827747345,
0.6346808671951294,
0.6304718255996704,
-0.2600996494293213,
0.38737645745277405,
0.762592613697052,
0.23131218552589417,
0.11668555438518524,
0.6394468545913696,
0.8265519142150879,
-0.6591954231262207,
-0.3509816527366638,
-0.6510752439498901,
0.27294260263442993,
-0.20906731486320496,
-0.3625293970108032,
0.5611636638641357,
0.20031307637691498,
1.2145700454711914,
0.0976896733045578,
0.6243332624435425,
-0.11552620679140091,
0.25637373328208923,
-0.4451659321784973,
0.770907461643219,
-0.7628875970840454,
-0.022115305066108704,
-0.2398541420698166,
-0.8417229652404785,
-0.21184517443180084,
0.7221521139144897,
0.08336944133043289,
0.19833986461162567,
0.3662334680557251,
0.9903850555419922,
-0.23841717839241028,
0.11862292140722275,
0.4313383400440216,
-0.17723794281482697,
-0.04286275431513786,
0.32056865096092224,
0.8541865944862366,
-0.260814905166626,
0.08481915295124054,
-0.5421953797340393,
-0.256690114736557,
0.109190933406353,
-0.9691411852836609,
-0.6421379446983337,
-0.86661696434021,
-0.24943794310092926,
-0.22654208540916443,
-0.05264259874820709,
0.7805699706077576,
0.6886450052261353,
-0.670030415058136,
0.31922265887260437,
-0.13976791501045227,
-0.0691639855504036,
-0.33808785676956177,
-0.2547103464603424,
0.30372154712677,
-0.6675316095352173,
-0.5572223663330078,
0.5321406722068787,
0.20743222534656525,
-0.07645249366760254,
-0.47027161717414856,
-0.0853416919708252,
0.09638232737779617,
-0.14870132505893707,
1.0763208866119385,
-0.3256005048751831,
-0.956250786781311,
-0.5423644185066223,
0.10621599853038788,
-0.08950412273406982,
-0.37841567397117615,
0.5209344029426575,
-1.0125999450683594,
0.2771008014678955,
0.2798456847667694,
0.7803029417991638,
-0.001944337273016572,
-0.09211709350347519,
0.1730778068304062,
-0.6980597376823425,
0.33950087428092957,
-0.03804466873407364,
0.6945722103118896,
0.4345300495624542,
-0.016809791326522827,
0.4939103126525879,
0.3298760652542114,
0.20982663333415985,
-0.7779349684715271,
0.1561359316110611,
-0.9108904600143433,
-0.4102404713630676,
1.0450973510742188,
-0.18816623091697693,
-0.2913612127304077,
-0.12117503583431244,
-0.029813449829816818,
0.21827632188796997,
-0.0344470776617527,
0.825736939907074,
0.6934030652046204,
0.1757822036743164,
0.06834345310926437,
-0.48534876108169556,
0.22478941082954407,
0.4372628629207611,
-0.4545409083366394,
0.047639816999435425,
0.5558152198791504,
0.24755392968654633,
0.21722117066383362,
0.003526192856952548,
-0.4789679944515228,
0.08930595964193344,
-0.0808836817741394,
0.02028943970799446,
-0.4513855278491974,
-0.3796229660511017,
-0.39845699071884155,
0.11799964308738708,
0.03407400846481323,
-0.2580164074897766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13006v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13006v2 | Investigating the Impact of Model Instability on Explanations and Uncertainty | 2024-02-20T13:41:21 | 2024-06-04T11:18:03 | Sara Vera Marjanović, Isabelle Augenstein, Christina Lioma | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Explainable AI methods facilitate the understanding of model behaviour, yet,
small, imperceptible perturbations to inputs can vastly distort explanations.
As these explanations are typically evaluated holistically, before model
deployment, it is difficult to assess when a particular explanation is
trustworthy. Some studies have tried to create confidence estimators for
explanations, but none have investigated an existing link between uncertainty
and explanation quality. We artificially simulate epistemic uncertainty in text
input by introducing noise at inference time. In this large-scale empirical
study, we insert different levels of noise perturbations and measure the effect
on the output of pre-trained language models and different uncertainty metrics.
Realistic perturbations have minimal effect on performance and explanations,
yet masking has a drastic effect. We find that high uncertainty doesn't
necessarily imply low explanation plausibility; the correlation between the two
metrics can be moderately positive when noise is exposed during the training
process. This suggests that noise-augmented models may be better at identifying
salient tokens when uncertain. Furthermore, when predictive and epistemic
uncertainty measures are over-confident, the robustness of a saliency map to
perturbation can indicate model stability issues. Integrated Gradients shows
the overall greatest robustness to perturbation, while still showing
model-specific patterns in performance; however, this phenomenon is limited to
smaller Transformer-based language models. | [
-0.3582099974155426,
-1.142869234085083,
0.6315972208976746,
0.11123250424861908,
-0.058145660907030106,
-0.25553083419799805,
-0.2691517472267151,
-0.4974631369113922,
-0.3840666115283966,
0.022150272503495216,
-0.47360119223594666,
-0.06275150924921036,
-0.8709000945091248,
-0.06053227558732033,
-0.5023990869522095,
0.8111403584480286,
-0.034885477274656296,
0.07311604917049408,
-0.23403799533843994,
0.2981058955192566,
-0.24928192794322968,
-0.516739010810852,
-0.6801721453666687,
-0.16378670930862427,
0.6102726459503174,
0.17232592403888702,
1.1848353147506714,
0.6885972023010254,
0.47665655612945557,
0.3500187397003174,
-0.38430285453796387,
-0.11137978732585907,
-0.41913777589797974,
0.3359387516975403,
-0.040267109870910645,
-0.6547303199768066,
-0.29839348793029785,
0.03239111602306366,
0.7386232018470764,
0.7695176005363464,
-0.13903690874576569,
-0.022867193445563316,
0.1772608757019043,
0.026049355044960976,
-0.6631698608398438,
0.028253605589270592,
-0.6187450885772705,
-0.22395431995391846,
0.00944566447287798,
-0.028880799189209938,
-0.3591337203979492,
0.0947401151061058,
0.48986655473709106,
-0.7588931918144226,
0.1568874716758728,
0.10387154668569565,
1.3562564849853516,
0.7467989325523376,
0.15673959255218506,
-0.2875285744667053,
-1.263668417930603,
0.8229559659957886,
-0.7855518460273743,
0.3275948464870453,
0.5147649049758911,
0.1833222508430481,
-0.10982975363731384,
-0.6191576719284058,
-0.560447633266449,
-0.015779033303260803,
-0.13592001795768738,
0.16120405495166779,
-0.17763333022594452,
0.2640909254550934,
0.2830410897731781,
0.27805495262145996,
-0.044411201030015945,
0.3515898585319519,
-0.09160788357257843,
-0.3028795123100281,
0.44889339804649353,
-0.01141406036913395,
0.09602624922990799,
0.1773117482662201,
-0.021891562268137932,
-0.24764375388622284,
-0.47879770398139954,
0.33197855949401855,
0.6535415649414062,
0.10722131282091141,
-0.20785580575466156,
0.32534685730934143,
0.12863561511039734,
0.5493482947349548,
0.3435949981212616,
-0.15762357413768768,
-0.21125954389572144,
-0.3150344789028168,
-0.19295035302639008,
0.04842009022831917,
0.8084799647331238,
0.1011241003870964,
-0.04827101156115532,
-0.013797910884022713,
-0.17061637341976166,
0.03903117775917053,
0.3300073444843292,
-0.6631579399108887,
-0.21374332904815674,
0.3709908425807953,
-0.39023011922836304,
-0.46262192726135254,
0.16770361363887787,
-0.8616344332695007,
-0.34610846638679504,
-0.07806859165430069,
0.5943502187728882,
-0.3508473038673401,
-0.30252766609191895,
0.26294761896133423,
0.0805533155798912,
-0.0009726348798722029,
0.6031133532524109,
-0.9098007678985596,
0.09852815419435501,
0.4403366148471832,
0.40192949771881104,
0.04611605405807495,
-0.46406805515289307,
-0.2106378972530365,
0.03941759467124939,
-0.3938649594783783,
0.6265724301338196,
-0.5781753659248352,
-0.21007414162158966,
0.053328048437833786,
-0.07374276220798492,
-0.030794259160757065,
-0.24070684611797333,
0.5933293700218201,
-0.3214544951915741,
0.41308459639549255,
-0.03358438238501549,
-0.3298206925392151,
-0.25910454988479614,
-0.0007114096661098301,
-0.6301334500312805,
0.9515843391418457,
-0.040140099823474884,
-0.8940043449401855,
0.4157739281654358,
-0.7074421644210815,
-0.2957321107387543,
-0.4565040171146393,
-0.1951136589050293,
-0.7403706908226013,
0.30894842743873596,
0.36985644698143005,
0.2811892032623291,
-0.1354442685842514,
0.22193311154842377,
-0.15841718018054962,
-0.5214022994041443,
0.7104853391647339,
-0.9555093050003052,
0.5599426627159119,
-0.01054952759295702,
-0.4793337881565094,
0.08639027923345566,
-0.6478117108345032,
-0.28218919038772583,
-0.0012655203463509679,
-0.0695958137512207,
-0.16834145784378052,
0.2825809419155121,
-0.37273967266082764,
0.12848161160945892,
0.004709927830845118,
-0.15082769095897675,
-0.28715431690216064,
-0.48222315311431885,
0.5085574984550476,
0.6927542090415955,
0.08327130228281021,
0.36187800765037537,
-0.22486180067062378,
0.6715686917304993,
0.35474005341529846,
0.37228521704673767,
-0.44326552748680115,
-0.5850964188575745,
-0.6855570077896118,
-0.09474805742502213,
0.4744247496128082,
0.24830135703086853,
-0.2516357898712158,
-0.24906909465789795,
-0.14485180377960205,
-0.2736295759677887,
-0.8309541940689087,
-0.23034711182117462,
0.38061633706092834,
0.5822027921676636,
0.18580444157123566,
-0.029903095215559006,
-0.39642712473869324,
-0.7482187151908875,
-0.34002968668937683,
-0.6411985158920288,
-0.03978494554758072,
0.11297750473022461,
0.30021578073501587,
-0.2079058140516281,
0.7792962789535522,
-0.03402093052864075,
0.3997701108455658,
0.0902714654803276,
0.41400250792503357,
-0.08167116343975067,
0.4221864938735962,
0.36997705698013306,
-0.8694221377372742,
-0.02372479997575283,
-0.231308713555336,
-0.4224202632904053,
0.1210688129067421,
-0.2588697373867035,
-0.009358137845993042,
0.3959640562534332,
0.36177951097488403,
-0.7204394340515137,
0.7071387767791748,
0.5648658275604248,
-0.11022839695215225,
0.8359494209289551,
-0.14881323277950287,
0.13709789514541626,
-0.7671957612037659,
-0.13252197206020355,
0.02278951369225979,
0.049442216753959656,
-0.5319814085960388,
-0.05801623687148094,
-0.3501834273338318,
0.0771620124578476,
-0.15764379501342773,
0.0760134607553482,
-0.4072727560997009,
0.11064165830612183,
0.0001763983746059239,
0.24711892008781433,
0.12086798995733261,
0.0770205706357956,
-0.1221725195646286,
0.5765851736068726,
0.7088010907173157,
-0.5705263018608093,
-0.18432068824768066,
-0.030628975480794907,
-0.24152283370494843,
0.13004949688911438,
-0.8332346677780151,
-0.06917643547058105,
-0.2199830710887909,
-0.0810142233967781,
-1.0978113412857056,
-0.6392867565155029,
0.19035208225250244,
-0.7854319214820862,
0.5198697447776794,
-0.11888577789068222,
-0.29225119948387146,
-0.15716344118118286,
-0.014830727130174637,
0.19501212239265442,
0.3725357949733734,
-0.46330395340919495,
0.6206914782524109,
0.18229451775550842,
-0.043708719313144684,
-0.7376435995101929,
-0.8430508971214294,
-0.15140751004219055,
-0.3950948715209961,
-0.6006792187690735,
0.19082091748714447,
-0.04707220941781998,
-0.6718378663063049,
-0.0716543197631836,
-0.3883802890777588,
-0.19660082459449768,
0.6897901296615601,
0.7021745443344116,
0.2343539148569107,
-0.41803160309791565,
0.2757572531700134,
0.11379959434270859,
0.013918056152760983,
0.3972337543964386,
-0.05465459078550339,
0.16571466624736786,
-0.29919394850730896,
-0.3224746286869049,
-0.833574116230011,
0.04327200725674629,
0.7472730875015259,
-0.018485719338059425,
1.0477361679077148,
0.5298068523406982,
-0.35646161437034607,
-0.15699124336242676,
-0.33759960532188416,
-0.3622807264328003,
-0.48982611298561096,
0.4965970814228058,
-0.5242012143135071,
-0.7949920296669006,
0.6668612360954285,
-0.1107630580663681,
0.02528645470738411,
0.6267732381820679,
0.4860917031764984,
-0.3996144235134125,
1.192469596862793,
0.571408748626709,
0.2100025713443756,
0.4094843864440918,
0.06019618734717369,
0.38043880462646484,
-0.31364867091178894,
-0.14848604798316956,
-0.7012094259262085,
-0.07730662822723389,
-0.5988355875015259,
-0.40087082982063293,
0.008355057798326015,
0.4459312856197357,
-0.3055325448513031,
-0.30720192193984985,
-0.44715967774391174,
0.3105018436908722,
0.3755568861961365,
-0.0458022765815258,
0.2630898952484131,
0.13364943861961365,
0.23068761825561523,
-0.12415647506713867,
-0.9178087115287781,
-0.6757130026817322,
0.7236542701721191,
0.709735631942749,
0.9402759671211243,
0.03293521702289581,
0.2360256314277649,
-0.10962548851966858,
0.13648630678653717,
-0.5787141919136047,
0.043542489409446716,
0.11151594668626785,
-0.6063733696937561,
-0.6553834676742554,
-0.1788010597229004,
-0.7811063528060913,
0.018594149500131607,
-0.45151418447494507,
-0.9425800442695618,
0.3635125458240509,
0.5707777142524719,
-0.7068938612937927,
0.1203298568725586,
-0.6293250918388367,
0.6513496041297913,
-0.19843527674674988,
-0.4008622169494629,
-0.01664489135146141,
-0.8156970143318176,
0.29448309540748596,
-0.09321156144142151,
0.4850676655769348,
0.257102370262146,
0.0846954807639122,
0.454856812953949,
-0.37514740228652954,
0.9056164622306824,
0.04874938353896141,
-0.22843925654888153,
0.2376537024974823,
0.26830029487609863,
0.5250137448310852,
0.18707318603992462,
-0.3739650547504425,
0.38760367035865784,
-0.05327019467949867,
-0.3247688114643097,
-0.8741522431373596,
0.39131247997283936,
-1.000596046447754,
-0.8805499076843262,
-0.06594553589820862,
-0.6063278317451477,
-0.0597093366086483,
-0.14964962005615234,
0.6928606629371643,
0.32910269498825073,
0.15350185334682465,
0.08022713661193848,
0.8725343942642212,
-0.24673087894916534,
0.438457190990448,
0.25287824869155884,
-0.27733954787254333,
-0.0030476106330752373,
0.6407956480979919,
0.24020616710186005,
0.5234591960906982,
0.15841226279735565,
0.3275384306907654,
0.036010950803756714,
-0.8577505350112915,
-0.27740544080734253,
-0.0885835811495781,
-0.5150424838066101,
0.20089051127433777,
-0.4038219451904297,
-0.2531906068325043,
-0.08251582831144333,
-0.17153982818126678,
-0.5411014556884766,
-0.5061023831367493,
-0.42627862095832825,
-0.3051997125148773,
0.29441460967063904,
0.871253490447998,
-0.03809849172830582,
0.6709693670272827,
-0.2935272455215454,
-0.07922019809484482,
0.04882437735795975,
0.5036666989326477,
0.007805284578353167,
-0.869083821773529,
-0.5951714515686035,
0.39398062229156494,
0.02084651030600071,
-0.9367402791976929,
0.04664844274520874,
0.30275630950927734,
0.5201102495193481,
0.8989267945289612,
0.027233397588133812,
0.7993897795677185,
-0.13224242627620697,
1.080163598060608,
-0.08189333230257034,
-1.0789821147918701,
0.7080156803131104,
-0.44012701511383057,
0.23320655524730682,
0.30288973450660706,
0.34008294343948364,
0.1358577013015747,
-0.7958288788795471,
-0.7990996837615967,
-0.7681167721748352,
0.7791264057159424,
0.2604566514492035,
-0.010402332060039043,
0.2278517186641693,
0.8551327586174011,
0.18190397322177887,
0.04730278626084328,
-0.5127670168876648,
-0.3743075728416443,
-0.3328125476837158,
0.03088495321571827,
0.05259209871292114,
-0.5819305777549744,
-0.22091194987297058,
-0.14647161960601807,
0.6346592307090759,
0.07162037491798401,
0.4043930172920227,
0.2932750880718231,
0.014684071764349937,
-0.45891961455345154,
-0.003636909183114767,
0.81600421667099,
0.7279578447341919,
-0.12220736593008041,
0.25176218152046204,
-0.12623918056488037,
-0.44596171379089355,
-0.11679048091173172,
0.12144812941551208,
-0.27239418029785156,
0.23613302409648895,
0.6050106883049011,
1.0571461915969849,
0.20189468562602997,
-0.5374199748039246,
0.3236134648323059,
-0.3149469792842865,
-0.19702517986297607,
-0.2038249373435974,
0.01598983444273472,
-0.11546444892883301,
0.14819402992725372,
0.22696776688098907,
0.3578314781188965,
-0.08585355430841446,
-0.4449451267719269,
-0.08128997683525085,
0.2478109449148178,
-0.4420127272605896,
-0.642329216003418,
0.9945572018623352,
-0.1714521199464798,
-0.3943365216255188,
0.41439202427864075,
0.051558248698711395,
-0.5064552426338196,
0.6557429432868958,
0.5243854522705078,
0.5207775235176086,
-0.5180158019065857,
0.3087448179721832,
0.22503970563411713,
0.6882035136222839,
-0.2547476887702942,
0.03719577193260193,
0.25688162446022034,
-0.8175903558731079,
-0.6430122256278992,
-0.5319006443023682,
-0.5419541001319885,
0.07323991507291794,
-0.8003671765327454,
-0.041817739605903625,
-0.4270821511745453,
-0.33936959505081177,
0.1398591548204422,
-0.4274357259273529,
-0.4619665741920471,
0.37141427397727966,
0.03656439855694771,
0.3663053810596466,
-0.8246508836746216,
0.47450417280197144,
0.7779932022094727,
-0.5044296979904175,
-1.1348236799240112,
0.5493276119232178,
-0.008553755469620228,
-0.46682095527648926,
0.3637087941169739,
0.005766929127275944,
-0.2062705010175705,
-0.21504853665828705,
-0.7764515280723572,
-1.148119330406189,
0.7895711660385132,
0.8710194826126099,
-0.5467255711555481,
-0.01889108307659626,
0.06390219181776047,
0.7289339303970337,
-0.1689264327287674,
0.3618983030319214,
0.5527647137641907,
0.6109533905982971,
0.013840370811522007,
-0.9100344777107239,
-0.036997921764850616,
-0.031212424859404564,
-0.00950186513364315,
-0.003937250468879938,
-0.6551792621612549,
0.8869487643241882,
-0.33012261986732483,
-0.3577042520046234,
0.05083103105425835,
0.5323228240013123,
-0.11363537609577179,
0.19995534420013428,
0.34198155999183655,
0.46973147988319397,
0.9727396965026855,
-0.41275450587272644,
1.2437957525253296,
-0.48026466369628906,
0.25966015458106995,
1.2591148614883423,
0.22968751192092896,
0.7828790545463562,
0.6542665362358093,
-0.2092750519514084,
0.687565267086029,
0.9372389912605286,
0.16076155006885529,
0.22529752552509308,
0.11413511633872986,
0.028734639286994934,
-0.3175739645957947,
-0.07821834832429886,
-0.12339311093091965,
0.4524023234844208,
0.6253688931465149,
-0.5596670508384705,
0.23809851706027985,
0.04300583153963089,
-0.06193408742547035,
-0.09639362245798111,
-0.2644534111022949,
0.44209912419319153,
-0.030102767050266266,
-0.5967054963111877,
0.5182583332061768,
-0.15593306720256805,
0.2728196084499359,
-0.24988575279712677,
0.12531372904777527,
-0.02264048531651497,
0.15143917500972748,
-0.26073744893074036,
-0.5497180223464966,
0.30055075883865356,
-0.31160837411880493,
-0.41880959272384644,
-0.11372938007116318,
0.5654503107070923,
-0.31913235783576965,
-0.4362199306488037,
0.1758134812116623,
0.42487630248069763,
0.2853972315788269,
0.046249087899923325,
-0.39557528495788574,
0.42898106575012207,
-0.1344578117132187,
-0.46974092721939087,
0.18747198581695557,
0.7697438597679138,
0.03990303352475166,
0.6367166638374329,
0.17710138857364655,
0.00023715982388239354,
0.3063218593597412,
-0.05116865038871765,
0.661246120929718,
-0.043605949729681015,
-0.08808334171772003,
-1.0061413049697876,
0.8904614448547363,
0.09411674737930298,
-0.38240113854408264,
0.8210398554801941,
0.04959135875105858,
0.6316549777984619,
0.0881679579615593,
0.7517132759094238,
0.2633572220802307,
0.19838972389698029,
-0.48003387451171875,
0.8428774476051331,
-0.5666568279266357,
0.5803602337837219,
-0.25852829217910767,
-0.6542248129844666,
-0.3436058461666107,
0.6000761985778809,
-0.22809314727783203,
0.021966462954878807,
0.6132715940475464,
0.8249529004096985,
0.19048890471458435,
0.17683659493923187,
0.4215252101421356,
0.9136192798614502,
-0.0010170810855925083,
-0.19845516979694366,
0.9257203340530396,
-0.4516781270503998,
0.5567135810852051,
-0.3661275804042816,
-0.04533945769071579,
-0.19757968187332153,
-0.7659093737602234,
-0.6282499432563782,
-0.544303297996521,
-0.5509324669837952,
-0.555648148059845,
0.308694064617157,
0.3194746971130371,
0.7818111777305603,
-0.8550316691398621,
0.17262038588523865,
-0.21284595131874084,
0.3135705888271332,
-0.28895625472068787,
-0.22581467032432556,
0.39859405159950256,
-0.2691604793071747,
-0.7502928376197815,
0.26176655292510986,
0.16821350157260895,
0.22263555228710175,
-0.38912633061408997,
-0.0822969451546669,
0.054221104830503464,
0.4166192412376404,
0.3212471902370453,
0.10595732182264328,
-1.015403151512146,
-0.364548921585083,
-0.12736330926418304,
0.180614173412323,
0.05753786489367485,
0.3765554428100586,
-0.5110871195793152,
0.7741014361381531,
0.018237315118312836,
0.6626290678977966,
0.3238210380077362,
0.19705791771411896,
0.8989579081535339,
-0.6163990497589111,
0.17669329047203064,
0.11675304919481277,
0.2472267597913742,
0.18226505815982819,
-0.6377986073493958,
0.22375309467315674,
-0.038325171917676926,
-0.6353392601013184,
-1.074903130531311,
0.0814424529671669,
-0.49927735328674316,
-0.25551289319992065,
1.0186127424240112,
-0.4121250510215759,
-0.21453161537647247,
-0.10629947483539581,
-0.03258750960230827,
0.3739178478717804,
-0.47280803322792053,
1.1125458478927612,
1.1795881986618042,
-0.22946999967098236,
-0.44234737753868103,
-0.5610089302062988,
0.5788916945457458,
0.5911884307861328,
-0.4727588891983032,
-0.01772332191467285,
0.3903653621673584,
-0.02235947735607624,
0.39339396357536316,
-0.1408139020204544,
-0.08394615352153778,
0.36770835518836975,
0.3974382281303406,
-0.2880133092403412,
0.08647593855857849,
-0.33155813813209534,
-0.6711653470993042,
0.1801619976758957,
0.4023020267486572,
-0.011309852823615074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12998v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12998v1 | Phonotactic Complexity across Dialects | 2024-02-20T13:25:39 | 2024-02-20T13:25:39 | Ryan Soh-Eun Shim, Kalvin Chang, David R. Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Received wisdom in linguistic typology holds that if the structure of a
language becomes more complex in one dimension, it will simplify in another,
building on the assumption that all languages are equally complex (Joseph and
Newmeyer, 2012). We study this claim on a micro-level, using a
tightly-controlled sample of Dutch dialects (across 366 collection sites) and
Min dialects (across 60 sites), which enables a more fair comparison across
varieties. Even at the dialect level, we find empirical evidence for a tradeoff
between word length and a computational measure of phonotactic complexity from
a LSTM-based phone-level language model-a result previously documented only at
the language level. A generalized additive model (GAM) shows that dialects with
low phonotactic complexity concentrate around the capital regions, which we
hypothesize to correspond to prior hypotheses that language varieties of
greater or more diverse populations show reduced phonotactic complexity. We
also experiment with incorporating the auxiliary task of predicting syllable
constituency, but do not find an increase in the negative correlation observed. | [
-0.6554014682769775,
-0.795686662197113,
0.8347621560096741,
0.2065424621105194,
-0.18777815997600555,
-0.05036598816514015,
-0.4819178879261017,
-0.6365892291069031,
0.4039578139781952,
0.4480030834674835,
-0.25002551078796387,
-0.443258672952652,
-0.6324247717857361,
0.18709509074687958,
-0.02328440546989441,
0.37453028559684753,
0.3318409323692322,
-0.11378519982099533,
-0.06553386151790619,
-0.2418343722820282,
-0.18098072707653046,
-0.7439523935317993,
-0.45414918661117554,
-0.6748631000518799,
0.36428800225257874,
0.48450136184692383,
0.6629995107650757,
0.5780004262924194,
0.38371288776397705,
0.31746330857276917,
-0.648872435092926,
0.1896289736032486,
-0.13007032871246338,
0.10787953436374664,
0.07023908197879791,
-0.5640630722045898,
-0.47008568048477173,
-0.3363083302974701,
0.4865209460258484,
1.3886613845825195,
-0.317963182926178,
-0.0019077241886407137,
-0.08288921415805817,
0.7335591316223145,
-0.43714505434036255,
0.27464234828948975,
-0.5473299622535706,
-0.018890095874667168,
-0.3564938008785248,
-0.13543382287025452,
-0.25149133801460266,
-0.31449463963508606,
0.576550304889679,
-0.3553330600261688,
0.09325631707906723,
-0.06203484535217285,
0.8076471090316772,
-0.13553744554519653,
-0.40919071435928345,
-0.297542005777359,
-0.9621322154998779,
0.7015416026115417,
-0.6882258653640747,
0.17100869119167328,
0.5861747860908508,
0.13968679308891296,
0.044452354311943054,
-0.22377921640872955,
-0.5163012742996216,
-0.4350302517414093,
-0.05531855300068855,
0.046783480793237686,
-0.21690955758094788,
0.47701776027679443,
0.2180723249912262,
0.6395294070243835,
-0.5744922161102295,
0.16600796580314636,
-0.45318371057510376,
-0.15064063668251038,
0.27800360321998596,
0.23947569727897644,
0.31716927886009216,
-0.5084227323532104,
0.11844952404499054,
0.05956243351101875,
-0.3999388813972473,
0.3171249330043793,
0.5700690150260925,
0.5428900122642517,
-0.15450412034988403,
0.7071216702461243,
-0.26700547337532043,
0.7304549217224121,
-0.1251298040151596,
-0.3557675778865814,
0.24030952155590057,
-0.4051660895347595,
-0.15435977280139923,
0.06546452641487122,
0.5463725924491882,
0.11496967822313309,
0.5318751931190491,
0.09593680500984192,
-0.10133247077465057,
-0.21035143733024597,
-0.13664191961288452,
-0.4374947249889374,
-0.3850126266479492,
0.3460749685764313,
-0.387698233127594,
0.038977496325969696,
0.13199160993099213,
-0.4461875855922699,
-0.35243579745292664,
-0.2562669515609741,
0.35151442885398865,
-0.6640927791595459,
-0.6008488535881042,
0.5026031136512756,
-0.1386229246854782,
0.05916636437177658,
0.3116249740123749,
-0.9029626250267029,
0.4492604732513428,
0.818409264087677,
1.1262530088424683,
-0.13120180368423462,
-0.30831480026245117,
-0.006726932246237993,
-0.1320417821407318,
-0.4806368947029114,
0.5385414361953735,
-0.49207833409309387,
-0.5260462760925293,
0.057689640671014786,
-0.24471700191497803,
-0.12113163620233536,
-0.790482223033905,
0.2503197491168976,
-0.19341257214546204,
0.048371028155088425,
-0.39395177364349365,
-0.46174293756484985,
-0.40014326572418213,
0.11365623772144318,
-0.868867814540863,
0.8912325501441956,
0.4347532093524933,
-0.4843534231185913,
0.5817015767097473,
-0.01635243184864521,
-0.6302686333656311,
-0.14939886331558228,
0.03814154490828514,
-0.5258726477622986,
0.6289544105529785,
-0.10728174448013306,
0.19162656366825104,
-0.1948530673980713,
0.014464703388512135,
-0.333172082901001,
-0.2561977803707123,
0.12042444944381714,
-0.12400118261575699,
0.8724452257156372,
0.09016535431146622,
-0.19281286001205444,
-0.0762631967663765,
-1.0026204586029053,
0.019909562543034554,
-0.059692807495594025,
-0.5231772065162659,
-0.6317138671875,
-0.25634390115737915,
-0.24780550599098206,
0.09043522924184799,
0.08297022432088852,
-0.4555651843547821,
0.40472280979156494,
-0.537094235420227,
0.34329551458358765,
0.37882930040359497,
0.08546324074268341,
0.8313196301460266,
-0.4697255492210388,
0.6233265995979309,
0.13192632794380188,
0.010435640811920166,
0.08088704198598862,
-0.6462299823760986,
-0.9899742007255554,
-0.19913926720619202,
0.33433306217193604,
0.5563666820526123,
-0.31620386242866516,
0.49468234181404114,
-0.4663253128528595,
-0.43107497692108154,
-0.31169530749320984,
-0.06425648182630539,
0.3373528718948364,
0.13117536902427673,
0.3284473419189453,
-0.649626612663269,
-0.43643975257873535,
-1.058456540107727,
0.04249678924679756,
-0.4499579071998596,
-0.04768337309360504,
0.2656905949115753,
0.2117253541946411,
0.12331464141607285,
0.7818164825439453,
-0.06491688638925552,
-0.11980652809143066,
-0.5234933495521545,
0.22143450379371643,
0.3428182899951935,
0.27236229181289673,
0.5458200573921204,
-0.3496740162372589,
-0.30034181475639343,
0.30266010761260986,
-0.2400987297296524,
-0.3383696675300598,
0.17716355621814728,
0.38761115074157715,
0.26737165451049805,
0.20557864010334015,
-0.7428407073020935,
0.37796342372894287,
0.4314057528972626,
-0.03836190700531006,
0.647433876991272,
-0.29624128341674805,
0.007361321710050106,
-0.6439375877380371,
-0.2638710141181946,
-0.1576424390077591,
0.011220774613320827,
-0.8347769975662231,
-0.2378503978252411,
-0.32142484188079834,
0.004053452052175999,
-0.06794148683547974,
0.22115886211395264,
-0.5795201063156128,
-0.40286141633987427,
-0.07343018800020218,
-0.14349131286144257,
-0.08900150656700134,
0.599224328994751,
0.048816584050655365,
0.509348452091217,
0.3567555248737335,
-0.6700481176376343,
0.15340188145637512,
-0.17134985327720642,
-0.7924266457557678,
0.12667325139045715,
-0.5926892757415771,
-0.22014547884464264,
0.038138847798109055,
-0.04201939329504967,
-1.0953338146209717,
-0.24884527921676636,
-0.12620995938777924,
-0.2175930142402649,
0.16441266238689423,
-0.25806736946105957,
-0.2831452190876007,
-0.2300734966993332,
0.08236339688301086,
0.5350919365882874,
0.4340352714061737,
0.10290952771902084,
0.7647445201873779,
0.39482176303863525,
-0.3615261912345886,
-0.1483570635318756,
-1.020451307296753,
-0.10582663863897324,
-0.2120172083377838,
-0.7564385533332825,
0.030229004099965096,
0.11608586460351944,
-0.8967922925949097,
-0.18484652042388916,
-0.32919639348983765,
-0.24384157359600067,
0.0026386019308120012,
0.050146281719207764,
-0.43970832228660583,
-0.3483307361602783,
0.29487931728363037,
-0.15805846452713013,
0.08272740244865417,
-0.05941353365778923,
-0.4782020151615143,
0.915930986404419,
-0.2272932380437851,
-0.39127853512763977,
-0.26995372772216797,
0.4535781443119049,
0.63941890001297,
-0.17202964425086975,
0.4513135254383087,
0.1278681606054306,
-0.19543342292308807,
-0.3949649930000305,
-0.5274515748023987,
0.06565476208925247,
-0.4020961821079254,
0.2950085997581482,
-0.7655051946640015,
-0.9850606918334961,
1.1094471216201782,
0.11713943630456924,
-0.3810245990753174,
0.3470796048641205,
0.7507882714271545,
0.18854263424873352,
0.5503230094909668,
0.6131694316864014,
-0.026039613410830498,
0.38961637020111084,
-0.19001609086990356,
0.12180957943201065,
-0.16497591137886047,
-0.2634606957435608,
-0.591745913028717,
-0.11015891283750534,
-0.8821213245391846,
-0.3595319390296936,
0.41919586062431335,
0.04832586273550987,
-0.19361183047294617,
0.38201406598091125,
-0.21652492880821228,
0.4436531662940979,
0.7202291488647461,
0.13194933533668518,
0.40809252858161926,
0.14954853057861328,
-0.2495909333229065,
-0.04407681152224541,
-0.8170167803764343,
-0.18133001029491425,
0.7319952845573425,
0.19471679627895355,
0.35199931263923645,
0.3803204596042633,
0.862348198890686,
0.24497389793395996,
-0.40676257014274597,
-0.973296582698822,
0.4277910888195038,
-0.25853434205055237,
-0.34406113624572754,
-0.5850778818130493,
-0.5261777639389038,
-0.8110219836235046,
0.27375951409339905,
0.06968733668327332,
-0.6486400961875916,
0.6106448173522949,
-0.030762046575546265,
-0.38504594564437866,
0.343842089176178,
-0.663341760635376,
0.40122395753860474,
0.05992012098431587,
-0.047861646860837936,
-0.23200282454490662,
-0.6911998391151428,
0.3600638806819916,
0.06889104098081589,
0.3843943476676941,
-0.14662200212478638,
0.16652251780033112,
0.37200430035591125,
-0.8920456767082214,
0.5712445974349976,
0.0361945703625679,
-0.4275035560131073,
0.49276429414749146,
0.5614957809448242,
0.12424445897340775,
-0.23914718627929688,
-0.2692553997039795,
0.258816659450531,
-0.19148483872413635,
-0.48574450612068176,
-0.4330250024795532,
0.3668132722377777,
-0.8129894137382507,
-0.6071895360946655,
-0.29163432121276855,
-0.5414238572120667,
-0.2320365458726883,
0.12362270057201385,
0.542600154876709,
0.49783387780189514,
0.05871913209557533,
0.2923699915409088,
0.6078614592552185,
-0.1986222118139267,
0.21638184785842896,
0.2703961431980133,
-0.11861670762300491,
-0.23554033041000366,
0.7117030620574951,
0.6129065752029419,
0.6538597345352173,
0.6268014907836914,
0.4669307470321655,
0.1267802119255066,
-0.8542433977127075,
0.00809641182422638,
-0.04546041786670685,
-0.7251567840576172,
0.31314989924430847,
-0.5541788935661316,
0.00914931483566761,
-0.2373313456773758,
0.09272002428770065,
-0.33830201625823975,
-0.9510470628738403,
0.2316129505634308,
-0.274291068315506,
0.31305816769599915,
0.7596606016159058,
-0.34928274154663086,
0.4238159954547882,
-0.556806743144989,
0.1428004950284958,
0.4920596480369568,
0.17093555629253387,
0.10865676403045654,
-0.5490572452545166,
-0.21228088438510895,
-0.08040482550859451,
0.24146829545497894,
-0.7626515626907349,
0.17892055213451385,
0.3528759479522705,
0.2420656532049179,
0.24165913462638855,
-0.24106819927692413,
0.5879045128822327,
-0.4442899227142334,
0.9315674304962158,
0.1545870006084442,
-1.0793030261993408,
0.12223666906356812,
-0.6249164342880249,
0.43825021386146545,
0.4814765453338623,
-0.05700736120343208,
-0.513888955116272,
-0.6181054711341858,
-0.6246006488800049,
-1.1158006191253662,
0.34269118309020996,
0.13293945789337158,
-0.07021203637123108,
0.05318179726600647,
0.3523445725440979,
0.10876960307359695,
0.15009832382202148,
-0.6658803820610046,
-0.32903429865837097,
-0.153423473238945,
0.17122967541217804,
0.04548131301999092,
-0.5062362551689148,
0.08039310574531555,
-0.3965819478034973,
0.28027719259262085,
0.17729218304157257,
0.2040308713912964,
0.152721107006073,
-0.1065324917435646,
-0.18460416793823242,
0.49682122468948364,
0.9003366231918335,
0.9359078407287598,
-0.2933277487754822,
0.39622926712036133,
0.23786957561969757,
-0.5073313117027283,
0.2632598578929901,
-0.20916318893432617,
-0.015412446111440659,
0.2886658310890198,
0.9308772683143616,
0.7684586644172668,
0.08046864718198776,
-0.260330468416214,
0.3797273635864258,
0.364913672208786,
-0.4870228171348572,
-0.35866594314575195,
0.07748609781265259,
0.12769730389118195,
0.07513229548931122,
0.35591229796409607,
-0.04330325871706009,
0.17368477582931519,
-0.6368085741996765,
0.24170733988285065,
0.118473581969738,
-0.16870911419391632,
-0.33459386229515076,
0.18426719307899475,
0.10086223483085632,
-0.2248656153678894,
0.3822377026081085,
-0.27935484051704407,
-0.7070270776748657,
1.0032062530517578,
0.016049865633249283,
0.8755831122398376,
-0.1751498579978943,
-0.07815205305814743,
0.33218181133270264,
0.6018874049186707,
-0.11532565951347351,
0.3525499403476715,
-0.08376523107290268,
-0.6271494030952454,
-0.5155242085456848,
-0.7663230895996094,
-0.624732494354248,
0.3007453680038452,
-0.6625943779945374,
0.041327036917209625,
-0.40915340185165405,
-0.14030908048152924,
0.14678840339183807,
0.165203258395195,
-0.35851430892944336,
0.06537467241287231,
0.14271093904972076,
0.7381478548049927,
-0.7603108882904053,
0.7962296605110168,
0.32962608337402344,
-0.4399937391281128,
-0.895436704158783,
0.19659613072872162,
0.062375228852033615,
-0.7211408019065857,
0.6429217457771301,
0.05992117151618004,
-0.41031986474990845,
-0.2866319715976715,
-0.21849916875362396,
-0.5659016370773315,
0.6112883687019348,
0.1710975617170334,
-0.7144410014152527,
0.013936609961092472,
0.5758108496665955,
0.8034011721611023,
-0.11691763252019882,
0.10267160832881927,
0.6803710460662842,
0.6175104975700378,
-0.031132180243730545,
-1.3519803285598755,
-0.31601735949516296,
-0.09687064588069916,
0.13028648495674133,
0.3100616931915283,
-0.49291735887527466,
1.451084017753601,
-0.16984957456588745,
-0.2458227276802063,
0.19562819600105286,
0.5835757851600647,
-0.010717962868511677,
0.14734892547130585,
0.6586006879806519,
0.7044634222984314,
0.6927454471588135,
-0.25940749049186707,
0.971389889717102,
-0.44071125984191895,
0.3101552724838257,
0.8089215755462646,
-0.13833600282669067,
0.373193621635437,
0.2477116733789444,
-0.4067382216453552,
0.6047038435935974,
0.65755695104599,
0.2570180892944336,
0.28185757994651794,
0.49159717559814453,
-0.3150918185710907,
-0.5590683221817017,
-0.10593391209840775,
-0.31732308864593506,
0.7616710066795349,
0.40986132621765137,
-0.023648642003536224,
-0.11163996160030365,
-0.12194924056529999,
0.14796237647533417,
0.2251761555671692,
-0.41834959387779236,
0.7772341370582581,
0.2466541975736618,
-0.607310950756073,
0.7202807068824768,
-0.10718071460723877,
0.5321416854858398,
-0.7859593629837036,
0.19336386024951935,
-0.37852227687835693,
0.17366546392440796,
-0.15737518668174744,
-0.8434964418411255,
0.2556806206703186,
-0.5124697089195251,
-0.4204719662666321,
0.07091566920280457,
0.6011837720870972,
-0.728074848651886,
-0.10238274931907654,
0.5053444504737854,
0.8869575262069702,
0.0014415825717151165,
-0.004075663164258003,
-0.18984298408031464,
-0.04398525878787041,
-0.18739959597587585,
-0.4579206109046936,
0.13285434246063232,
0.9733766913414001,
-0.09049805253744125,
0.6991406083106995,
0.4398030638694763,
0.583925187587738,
0.1977284997701645,
0.3443343937397003,
0.4971805214881897,
-0.48720476031303406,
-0.7701939940452576,
-0.8004780411720276,
0.12230269610881805,
-0.03452857583761215,
-0.29674896597862244,
0.8237116932868958,
0.3956340551376343,
0.9655177593231201,
-0.13206198811531067,
0.9072380661964417,
-0.04586230590939522,
0.45272961258888245,
-0.5977148413658142,
0.30161556601524353,
-0.6290622353553772,
0.210617795586586,
-0.2346753627061844,
-0.733178436756134,
-0.4423965513706207,
0.6309671401977539,
-0.33163073658943176,
0.20680616796016693,
0.6608245372772217,
0.5761678218841553,
-0.09431485831737518,
-0.2252715677022934,
0.4252091348171234,
0.2726982831954956,
0.028190627694129944,
0.4857432246208191,
0.5964540839195251,
0.15528681874275208,
0.5557481050491333,
-0.6106177568435669,
-0.030038492754101753,
-0.29406043887138367,
-0.6515676379203796,
-0.6486837267875671,
-0.6336827278137207,
0.0888075903058052,
-0.48020175099372864,
-0.03725823014974594,
0.87591153383255,
0.4922254979610443,
-0.9575850367546082,
-0.6741313934326172,
-0.22606545686721802,
0.17267145216464996,
-0.5083044171333313,
-0.24797320365905762,
0.38254019618034363,
-0.05101251229643822,
-0.8089520335197449,
0.16344432532787323,
0.4396081566810608,
0.032145559787750244,
-0.19170315563678741,
0.094406858086586,
-0.01955178938806057,
0.17823940515518188,
0.7116574645042419,
0.33798009157180786,
-0.7649087905883789,
-0.49764156341552734,
0.10076215118169785,
-0.3449283838272095,
0.12430009990930557,
1.134704828262329,
-0.10334650427103043,
0.6256216764450073,
0.8574128746986389,
0.26372042298316956,
0.24204404652118683,
-0.1566549837589264,
0.627017617225647,
-0.9321840405464172,
0.4040445387363434,
0.22115932404994965,
0.5892770886421204,
0.1971169114112854,
0.028581872582435608,
0.42980992794036865,
0.36459076404571533,
-0.3536600172519684,
-0.4908316433429718,
0.633429229259491,
-1.2128093242645264,
-0.46953290700912476,
1.3114625215530396,
0.10874997824430466,
-0.02531990222632885,
-0.5305750966072083,
-0.024274395778775215,
0.05427348613739014,
-0.3236704170703888,
0.8112220764160156,
1.1736401319503784,
-0.08150674402713776,
-0.2860024869441986,
-0.42735210061073303,
0.733604907989502,
0.4118378162384033,
-0.41936057806015015,
0.17383591830730438,
0.48653846979141235,
0.03802991285920143,
0.6130754351615906,
0.6983290910720825,
0.11623810231685638,
0.15685690939426422,
0.10072257369756699,
0.09119110554456711,
-0.10475614666938782,
-0.3889135718345642,
-0.4464482069015503,
0.4007200598716736,
0.20629481971263885,
0.2206667959690094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12997v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12997v4 | Towards Trustworthy Reranking: A Simple yet Effective Abstention Mechanism | 2024-02-20T13:25:16 | 2024-04-02T12:56:53 | Hippolyte Gisserot-Boukhlef, Manuel Faysse, Emmanuel Malherbe, Céline Hudelot, Pierre Colombo | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Neural Information Retrieval (NIR) has significantly improved upon
heuristic-based IR systems. Yet, failures remain frequent, the models used
often being unable to retrieve documents relevant to the user's query. We
address this challenge by proposing a lightweight abstention mechanism tailored
for real-world constraints, with particular emphasis placed on the reranking
phase. We introduce a protocol for evaluating abstention strategies in a
black-box scenario, demonstrating their efficacy, and propose a simple yet
effective data-driven mechanism. We provide open-source code for experiment
replication and abstention implementation, fostering wider adoption and
application in diverse contexts. | [
-0.13381648063659668,
-0.4795766770839691,
0.5107203722000122,
0.01670035719871521,
-0.20082205533981323,
0.30062228441238403,
-0.16067513823509216,
-0.40854233503341675,
0.3329722583293915,
-0.1012340635061264,
-0.3132869005203247,
-0.252046674489975,
-0.4073719382286072,
-0.01343623735010624,
-0.7175896167755127,
1.0277873277664185,
0.026356657966971397,
-0.13970890641212463,
-0.4665302634239197,
-0.20288708806037903,
-0.3137904405593872,
-0.34260860085487366,
-0.6050721406936646,
-0.8980871438980103,
0.8941500782966614,
0.6675652265548706,
0.6269542574882507,
0.7180507779121399,
0.990533709526062,
0.20609410107135773,
-0.13508078455924988,
-0.057428088039159775,
-0.7618758082389832,
0.3513015806674957,
-0.3354569375514984,
-0.7749089598655701,
-0.014355586841702461,
0.019433515146374702,
0.5102552175521851,
0.573905885219574,
-0.43125736713409424,
-0.005807419307529926,
0.1474490761756897,
0.5760674476623535,
-1.0543113946914673,
-0.21624068915843964,
-0.8480919599533081,
0.12306185811758041,
-0.1046777293086052,
-0.3378414511680603,
-0.6551888585090637,
-0.6727867126464844,
0.22463683784008026,
-0.5143018960952759,
0.19667696952819824,
0.1935630440711975,
1.0118026733398438,
0.24405018985271454,
-0.06554663181304932,
-0.020250441506505013,
-0.6614593267440796,
0.6257246136665344,
-0.4258137047290802,
0.2892388701438904,
0.47808006405830383,
0.47449544072151184,
0.19552363455295563,
-0.9158846139907837,
-0.4335494339466095,
-0.31153589487075806,
-0.11982794851064682,
-0.01632644794881344,
-0.20865683257579803,
-0.20771290361881256,
-0.12680931389331818,
0.2825891077518463,
-0.2264886200428009,
-0.04475277662277222,
-0.36826616525650024,
-0.17353598773479462,
0.13386143743991852,
0.017623314633965492,
0.013328777626156807,
-0.14987783133983612,
-0.3663862645626068,
-0.18174855411052704,
-0.825839638710022,
-0.44531670212745667,
0.4736654460430145,
0.26005011796951294,
0.015523837879300117,
0.6418888568878174,
-0.40042033791542053,
0.34114187955856323,
0.08572761714458466,
0.30522891879081726,
0.17905592918395996,
-0.2881908118724823,
0.14769361913204193,
0.13200727105140686,
0.3645734190940857,
0.4798716902732849,
0.14179939031600952,
-0.7088534832000732,
-0.7151488661766052,
-0.016488006338477135,
0.7191441059112549,
-0.8450834155082703,
-0.14853116869926453,
-0.010023427195847034,
-0.5630601644515991,
-0.6975916624069214,
0.2524583339691162,
-0.42549729347229004,
-0.05292609706521034,
0.002800145884975791,
0.9509279131889343,
-0.5871492624282837,
-0.1472274512052536,
-0.23827029764652252,
-0.32109013199806213,
0.35561639070510864,
0.23944047093391418,
-0.6493235230445862,
0.46557748317718506,
1.0948225259780884,
1.210026741027832,
-0.10013946145772934,
-0.1848202496767044,
-0.3825645446777344,
0.0700012594461441,
-0.1991373896598816,
0.432893306016922,
-0.36969006061553955,
-0.28118786215782166,
-0.2938956618309021,
-0.22606505453586578,
0.14826709032058716,
-0.620598316192627,
0.46556356549263,
-0.6344735026359558,
-0.2876970171928406,
-0.093410924077034,
-0.47935694456100464,
-0.09107627719640732,
0.5707694888114929,
-0.6419193744659424,
0.464906245470047,
-0.043531011790037155,
-0.779183030128479,
0.3230162262916565,
-0.5120295882225037,
-0.3188270628452301,
0.0256634633988142,
0.08640647679567337,
-0.7059765458106995,
0.3250172734260559,
-0.20717677474021912,
0.058966051787137985,
-0.21180853247642517,
0.10194210708141327,
-0.38674601912498474,
-0.7771036028862,
0.14374962449073792,
-0.5228098034858704,
0.5134550333023071,
0.39400774240493774,
-0.45806100964546204,
-0.042958103120326996,
-0.28226152062416077,
0.3261900544166565,
0.22208082675933838,
0.012039212509989738,
-0.7042789459228516,
0.03250063583254814,
-0.017879031598567963,
-0.39702123403549194,
0.001525886240415275,
-0.6782962083816528,
0.2102355808019638,
-0.44819632172584534,
0.5445756912231445,
0.7213037610054016,
0.07164005190134048,
0.4058057963848114,
-0.6104906797409058,
0.15504153072834015,
-0.44288817048072815,
0.3874203562736511,
0.14790445566177368,
-0.24488729238510132,
-0.5473405718803406,
-0.06153354421257973,
0.7215205430984497,
0.5555528402328491,
-0.8792046904563904,
0.15765447914600372,
-0.4457818269729614,
-0.6468554139137268,
-0.6818118095397949,
0.004095235373824835,
1.0122294425964355,
0.5084638595581055,
0.3560583293437958,
-0.4037131369113922,
-0.16317757964134216,
-1.1956897974014282,
-0.13407683372497559,
-0.2384125292301178,
-0.06691888719797134,
0.16916531324386597,
0.8096411228179932,
-0.08253645896911621,
0.8590807914733887,
-0.6511418223381042,
-0.44170814752578735,
-0.030346380546689034,
0.5551167130470276,
-0.22478848695755005,
0.8112921714782715,
0.3617429733276367,
-1.159376621246338,
-0.1363385170698166,
-0.23431900143623352,
-0.8913189172744751,
0.27380046248435974,
0.1744993031024933,
-0.1927877813577652,
-0.06645265221595764,
0.6156995296478271,
-0.30780133605003357,
0.8478909730911255,
0.19634927809238434,
-0.10059958696365356,
0.4804656505584717,
-0.09538731724023819,
0.21315698325634003,
-0.7604588866233826,
0.4122922122478485,
-0.09386689215898514,
-0.37011954188346863,
-0.33215445280075073,
0.5259243249893188,
0.2573291063308716,
-0.040472257882356644,
-0.3602100908756256,
0.32951435446739197,
-0.26757827401161194,
0.08196045458316803,
-0.15631447732448578,
0.05724770575761795,
0.0315016470849514,
0.11237405240535736,
0.01776360161602497,
0.639410138130188,
0.09464333951473236,
-0.49068018794059753,
-0.07384714484214783,
0.3345932960510254,
-0.5558397173881531,
0.8002626895904541,
-1.0097547769546509,
0.07284793257713318,
-0.2457355111837387,
0.030091190710663795,
-0.882869303226471,
-0.1276210993528366,
0.3103067874908447,
-0.6415027976036072,
0.29630178213119507,
-0.5472747087478638,
-0.33401837944984436,
-0.02074553072452545,
-0.4550520181655884,
0.6851938366889954,
0.229477658867836,
-0.7418179512023926,
0.14331459999084473,
0.02749158814549446,
-0.16018378734588623,
-0.8084794878959656,
-0.7672792673110962,
0.31881582736968994,
-0.008853415958583355,
-0.3797832429409027,
0.668753981590271,
-0.12492682039737701,
-0.4888244569301605,
0.4647881090641022,
-0.3760240375995636,
-0.14596444368362427,
0.3717269003391266,
0.25045737624168396,
0.021397234871983528,
0.11109625548124313,
0.010975189507007599,
-0.14142024517059326,
-0.32981476187705994,
-0.08547083288431168,
-0.11841670423746109,
0.2123355269432068,
-0.12652793526649475,
-0.7357243895530701,
-0.4070225656032562,
0.34267279505729675,
0.6250162124633789,
-0.18777300417423248,
0.8781391382217407,
0.28224119544029236,
-0.48647966980934143,
-0.3135315179824829,
-0.524132251739502,
-0.8593646883964539,
-0.5253326296806335,
0.04658911004662514,
-0.3113882541656494,
-0.6189736127853394,
0.4906768798828125,
-0.005230366718024015,
0.15945705771446228,
-0.14752309024333954,
0.09626457095146179,
-0.08040202409029007,
0.7203605771064758,
0.6835770606994629,
0.0326559841632843,
0.582466721534729,
-0.2565723955631256,
0.31276363134384155,
-0.8495609760284424,
-0.43290263414382935,
-0.7187406420707703,
-0.6630772948265076,
-0.253074586391449,
-0.16496403515338898,
0.42272746562957764,
-0.01041983999311924,
0.17897580564022064,
0.12876571714878082,
-0.7775136232376099,
0.7268000245094299,
0.8375115990638733,
0.4546642303466797,
0.15976010262966156,
0.006675464101135731,
-0.27071523666381836,
-0.17188717424869537,
-0.5529047846794128,
-0.12337009608745575,
0.854878306388855,
0.1018231064081192,
1.1397697925567627,
0.4666988253593445,
1.007683515548706,
0.4086157977581024,
0.7598680853843689,
-0.7884494662284851,
0.3140123784542084,
0.03154108300805092,
-0.7638197541236877,
-0.33183807134628296,
-0.7744632959365845,
-0.8591330051422119,
0.19178955256938934,
-0.3378898501396179,
-0.676692008972168,
0.4212566912174225,
0.07445576786994934,
-0.2633396089076996,
0.3577498495578766,
-0.7991679310798645,
0.4903472661972046,
-0.20474471151828766,
-0.7474098205566406,
-0.16461336612701416,
-0.6227574348449707,
0.2986619770526886,
-0.025169745087623596,
-0.18276455998420715,
0.16873225569725037,
-0.005490729585289955,
0.6944786906242371,
-0.5257455706596375,
0.5928377509117126,
-0.38927799463272095,
0.40348517894744873,
0.024131160229444504,
0.4990755021572113,
0.579373836517334,
0.23990921676158905,
-0.4169442355632782,
0.03568287938833237,
-0.30150988698005676,
-0.24736404418945312,
-0.8130824565887451,
0.7751528024673462,
-0.4944283068180084,
-0.5244784951210022,
-0.4416964650154114,
-0.40320342779159546,
0.08722241967916489,
0.500288724899292,
0.22905635833740234,
0.37568628787994385,
-0.1946031004190445,
0.9051152467727661,
0.7546484470367432,
0.16167853772640228,
0.2914044260978699,
0.6328854560852051,
0.030345654115080833,
-0.6167669892311096,
1.1196203231811523,
0.23227530717849731,
0.3323504328727722,
0.4810113310813904,
0.24505549669265747,
-0.19307704269886017,
-0.9422208666801453,
0.09438113123178482,
-0.001831183792091906,
-0.4734805226325989,
-0.5249234437942505,
-0.2563409209251404,
-0.18052543699741364,
-0.2696576416492462,
-0.4541681110858917,
-0.5395376086235046,
-0.5846868753433228,
0.24196450412273407,
-0.4582115709781647,
0.3681473433971405,
0.6569188237190247,
-0.3210446834564209,
0.2667538523674011,
-0.2084425687789917,
0.41699132323265076,
0.23769424855709076,
0.7854310870170593,
0.18133313953876495,
-0.386841356754303,
-0.15425819158554077,
-0.16081774234771729,
-0.12834353744983673,
-0.5385061502456665,
0.4815949499607086,
0.0805128812789917,
0.8379337191581726,
0.3149148225784302,
0.43755388259887695,
0.5626487135887146,
-0.36260759830474854,
0.12178095430135727,
0.041405629366636276,
-0.8522463440895081,
0.4581061601638794,
-0.1426284909248352,
0.09088633209466934,
1.2068872451782227,
0.3444361090660095,
-0.4648204445838928,
-0.46472859382629395,
-0.4126761853694916,
-1.3895981311798096,
0.5156926512718201,
0.5463124513626099,
-0.044270120561122894,
0.0941741093993187,
0.7785735130310059,
-0.01184789463877678,
0.3170323371887207,
-0.6680753231048584,
-0.4103836417198181,
-0.2504619359970093,
-0.2417190968990326,
0.0017271531978622079,
-0.3216692805290222,
-0.2798108756542206,
-0.04879932478070259,
0.7179427146911621,
-0.0976514220237732,
0.2435089647769928,
0.5635387897491455,
-0.3240765631198883,
0.001277274452149868,
0.10900700837373734,
0.391360878944397,
0.5506671667098999,
-0.7678256630897522,
0.25373733043670654,
-0.38243815302848816,
-0.4901235103607178,
0.3620571494102478,
-0.06949332356452942,
-1.021417260169983,
-0.2662828266620636,
0.1190909817814827,
0.20863234996795654,
0.5665205121040344,
-0.1930544525384903,
0.4190484881401062,
-0.521000325679779,
-0.580579400062561,
-0.19709667563438416,
-0.10303296148777008,
0.0007233033538796008,
-0.13588306307792664,
0.5881006121635437,
0.0615977980196476,
0.24540163576602936,
-0.34947311878204346,
0.9853704571723938,
0.5060268044471741,
-0.7420729398727417,
0.06757813692092896,
0.7872079610824585,
0.3648605942726135,
-0.5457544326782227,
0.9088400602340698,
-0.3392235040664673,
-0.37603774666786194,
0.5741885900497437,
0.5785064101219177,
0.7030486464500427,
-0.03180437907576561,
0.30718550086021423,
0.21052186191082,
0.7067283391952515,
-0.42603594064712524,
0.12216184288263321,
0.020686255767941475,
-0.6726874709129333,
-0.1595001369714737,
-0.27543067932128906,
-0.7975650429725647,
-0.29743146896362305,
-1.1457853317260742,
-0.24233902990818024,
-0.7143520712852478,
-0.2256641536951065,
0.0918380618095398,
0.005130848381668329,
-0.2558664381504059,
-0.11699242144823074,
-0.1545301079750061,
1.186598300933838,
-0.48953378200531006,
0.538795530796051,
0.48302242159843445,
-0.5617908835411072,
-0.36552953720092773,
0.1747276335954666,
0.3126448392868042,
-0.5742265582084656,
0.5744062066078186,
0.17696015536785126,
-0.264057457447052,
-0.014501873403787613,
-0.839451253414154,
-0.7740305066108704,
1.1086533069610596,
0.45231395959854126,
-0.45164018869400024,
0.22326886653900146,
-0.4393482804298401,
0.2030002921819687,
0.05134990066289902,
0.26227423548698425,
0.02783334255218506,
0.7572000026702881,
-0.045296330004930496,
-0.6917487382888794,
0.2078237682580948,
-0.44010716676712036,
-0.4270441234111786,
0.20884303748607635,
-0.8708073496818542,
0.7101914286613464,
-0.26271140575408936,
-0.12639836966991425,
0.3050122559070587,
0.5972833633422852,
0.15880940854549408,
0.6387228965759277,
0.6953012943267822,
0.7882915139198303,
0.7374595999717712,
-0.19355857372283936,
1.0177861452102661,
-0.1713096797466278,
0.14855548739433289,
1.1373051404953003,
-0.5080778002738953,
0.9169459939002991,
0.6994761824607849,
0.3923104405403137,
0.4690670669078827,
0.07353802770376205,
0.07450711727142334,
0.88665771484375,
0.4229820668697357,
-0.3084632456302643,
-0.24033726751804352,
-0.4186069071292877,
-0.028191812336444855,
0.4960843622684479,
0.28183913230895996,
-0.06660010665655136,
-0.3472026288509369,
-0.13217341899871826,
0.01252739131450653,
0.31472471356391907,
-0.1484365463256836,
0.6541751623153687,
0.20118214190006256,
-0.6910868287086487,
0.36087027192115784,
0.13332977890968323,
0.8369420170783997,
-0.762148380279541,
-0.33774781227111816,
-0.2970680594444275,
0.43584996461868286,
-0.16529622673988342,
-0.4920658469200134,
0.39710474014282227,
-0.10760190337896347,
-0.31820347905158997,
-0.3818310499191284,
0.7872481942176819,
-0.10824321210384369,
-0.29505568742752075,
0.412387877702713,
0.5998383164405823,
-0.0008063674904406071,
0.047066282480955124,
-0.705334484577179,
0.15697556734085083,
-0.0924505740404129,
-0.199847012758255,
0.601418137550354,
0.24739602208137512,
-0.0924689918756485,
1.246654748916626,
0.6958851218223572,
-0.009511260315775871,
-0.4186251759529114,
0.036208465695381165,
0.6769304275512695,
-0.5893162488937378,
-0.4931850731372833,
-0.5508683919906616,
0.14726673066616058,
-0.1210719645023346,
0.13785159587860107,
0.8879468441009521,
0.512579083442688,
0.7296565771102905,
0.4166555106639862,
0.7664368748664856,
-0.11924295872449875,
0.36570197343826294,
-0.12039709836244583,
1.2205872535705566,
-0.7133098840713501,
0.3245071470737457,
-0.12150155752897263,
-0.5070415139198303,
-0.5928868651390076,
0.7368270754814148,
-0.15349723398685455,
-0.12094919383525848,
0.3769385814666748,
1.020641565322876,
-0.1077493354678154,
-0.3228023946285248,
0.2633307874202728,
0.03262564167380333,
0.3140272796154022,
0.2320280224084854,
0.6753371357917786,
-0.29514095187187195,
0.9410833120346069,
-0.6324554085731506,
-0.17224498093128204,
-0.5528470277786255,
-0.864496111869812,
-0.4824908375740051,
-0.16232967376708984,
-0.26492467522621155,
-0.37899652123451233,
0.7744368314743042,
0.5891286730766296,
1.0740119218826294,
-0.6078820824623108,
0.10044252127408981,
0.08690702170133591,
0.7746664881706238,
-0.6170259714126587,
-0.24727000296115875,
0.03993922472000122,
0.0018921628361567855,
-0.34617775678634644,
0.5281299948692322,
0.04194822907447815,
-0.11555831134319305,
-0.07594621181488037,
-0.09239103645086288,
-0.23921962082386017,
0.009587096981704235,
0.16962648928165436,
0.5394712686538696,
-0.2200225293636322,
-0.6522253751754761,
0.015952739864587784,
-0.10198966413736343,
-0.20872023701667786,
0.9002302289009094,
-0.8333054780960083,
0.27816614508628845,
0.5156408548355103,
0.6032978892326355,
0.19868239760398865,
0.5061850547790527,
0.7277582287788391,
-1.0295815467834473,
-0.0726977288722992,
0.4994673430919647,
0.1192234605550766,
0.2628602981567383,
-0.3269354999065399,
0.8937278389930725,
0.23079806566238403,
-0.48616495728492737,
-1.3832015991210938,
-0.052061956375837326,
-0.7701252698898315,
-0.3687646687030792,
0.7452081441879272,
-0.0941074937582016,
-0.45118048787117004,
-0.2974238991737366,
0.2687986493110657,
-0.04840892180800438,
-0.7085680365562439,
1.0511019229888916,
0.4007342457771301,
0.23646549880504608,
-0.16067247092723846,
-0.23080311715602875,
0.03444312885403633,
0.6109057068824768,
-0.42618995904922485,
0.11245890706777573,
0.23450465500354767,
0.42562153935432434,
0.43107911944389343,
0.5805661678314209,
-0.21568895876407623,
0.24734704196453094,
0.30739668011665344,
0.20464761555194855,
-0.4263579249382019,
-0.6532152891159058,
-0.21837055683135986,
0.463532954454422,
0.2210051417350769,
-0.08115895092487335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12991v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12991v2 | TRAP: Targeted Random Adversarial Prompt Honeypot for Black-Box Identification | 2024-02-20T13:20:39 | 2024-06-06T17:46:48 | Martin Gubri, Dennis Ulmer, Hwaran Lee, Sangdoo Yun, Seong Joon Oh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | Large Language Model (LLM) services and models often come with legal rules on
who can use them and how they must use them. Assessing the compliance of the
released LLMs is crucial, as these rules protect the interests of the LLM
contributor and prevent misuse. In this context, we describe the novel
fingerprinting problem of Black-box Identity Verification (BBIV). The goal is
to determine whether a third-party application uses a certain LLM through its
chat function. We propose a method called Targeted Random Adversarial Prompt
(TRAP) that identifies the specific LLM in use. We repurpose adversarial
suffixes, originally proposed for jailbreaking, to get a pre-defined answer
from the target LLM, while other models give random answers. TRAP detects the
target LLMs with over 95% true positive rate at under 0.2% false positive rate
even after a single interaction. TRAP remains effective even if the LLM has
minor changes that do not significantly alter the original function. | [
-0.18375341594219208,
-1.1706219911575317,
0.4722919166088104,
0.07771029323339462,
-0.22628523409366608,
0.30817198753356934,
-0.0662548691034317,
-0.4420464038848877,
0.13729321956634521,
0.7931814193725586,
-0.660844624042511,
-0.48070085048675537,
-0.611962616443634,
0.08648408204317093,
-0.6512282490730286,
0.8987992405891418,
0.3986697196960449,
-0.16203483939170837,
0.07419010996818542,
0.1843898743391037,
-0.8672665953636169,
-0.5586044788360596,
-0.6250340938568115,
-0.025711780413985252,
0.5683295726776123,
0.1905815452337265,
0.5159260034561157,
0.46814557909965515,
0.2446162849664688,
0.3047289252281189,
-0.0909491702914238,
0.135225310921669,
-0.39900442957878113,
-0.07246819883584976,
0.050897158682346344,
-0.9576236009597778,
-0.01622607558965683,
0.042672041803598404,
0.28357571363449097,
0.24937433004379272,
-0.06668293476104736,
0.3765842914581299,
-0.050853487104177475,
0.07260982692241669,
-0.6992027759552002,
-0.2280919998884201,
-0.8333775997161865,
-0.14434511959552765,
-0.653672993183136,
-0.254643052816391,
-0.7690266370773315,
-0.4010990262031555,
-0.2818542420864105,
-0.14016421139240265,
0.3927059769630432,
0.29352596402168274,
0.8742471933364868,
0.3572227656841278,
-0.28775331377983093,
-0.17728778719902039,
-0.8998740315437317,
0.44308120012283325,
-0.6956505179405212,
-0.13959453999996185,
0.13761018216609955,
0.4740655720233917,
-0.6540291905403137,
-0.15884970128536224,
-0.5732267498970032,
-0.4640733003616333,
0.016042346134781837,
-0.38501495122909546,
-0.45676642656326294,
-0.24792025983333588,
0.33649352192878723,
0.15279093384742737,
-0.6785978078842163,
0.19904446601867676,
-0.5789614915847778,
-0.5740281343460083,
0.49685391783714294,
0.14837270975112915,
0.45665088295936584,
0.0030694385059177876,
-0.5888950824737549,
0.21005995571613312,
-0.9195470809936523,
0.26338449120521545,
0.7293369770050049,
0.5271312594413757,
-0.1197640597820282,
0.7364351749420166,
0.15601569414138794,
0.7495241761207581,
0.23264318704605103,
-0.11303658783435822,
0.07991158962249756,
0.018641313537955284,
-0.10269445925951004,
0.1430893838405609,
0.8093644976615906,
0.0651690810918808,
0.3526631295681,
-0.30088114738464355,
-0.11132968962192535,
0.15211758017539978,
0.3311464190483093,
-0.7452748417854309,
-0.15568625926971436,
0.3560127913951874,
-0.2260192334651947,
-0.5394529700279236,
0.20901630818843842,
-0.7535722851753235,
-0.9297323226928711,
0.18860752880573273,
0.3508112132549286,
-0.2120903730392456,
-0.23931936919689178,
-0.24124443531036377,
-0.2963832914829254,
0.44624361395835876,
0.10506829619407654,
-0.6221563220024109,
0.10201670229434967,
0.8809380531311035,
0.7564270496368408,
-0.07274067401885986,
-0.08093298226594925,
-0.9890584349632263,
0.017952701076865196,
-0.43876922130584717,
0.6457372307777405,
-0.4742806553840637,
-0.28637176752090454,
0.0848725438117981,
0.1506023108959198,
0.09733933210372925,
-0.6557339429855347,
0.02904118224978447,
-0.9316461086273193,
-0.003385958494618535,
-0.004372857976704836,
-0.4402359127998352,
0.039846085011959076,
0.32094699144363403,
-0.627032995223999,
0.7643623948097229,
0.08309216052293777,
-0.49337339401245117,
0.34811460971832275,
-0.3701690137386322,
-0.3562633693218231,
0.71611088514328,
-0.1786266267299652,
-0.5583006143569946,
0.0975961983203888,
0.011901029385626316,
0.47488832473754883,
-0.06991775333881378,
0.15709403157234192,
-0.7715874910354614,
-0.6539266109466553,
0.62063068151474,
-0.41460245847702026,
1.277237892150879,
0.21670697629451752,
-0.3830464482307434,
0.01593707874417305,
-0.8087151646614075,
-0.2602038085460663,
0.3127000331878662,
-0.10000798106193542,
-0.502129316329956,
-0.24370220303535461,
-0.182674378156662,
-0.09591884911060333,
0.477133184671402,
-0.8539210557937622,
0.24810494482517242,
-0.33572691679000854,
0.06455571949481964,
0.7451175451278687,
0.16261765360832214,
0.11096679419279099,
-0.07619240134954453,
0.8691044449806213,
-0.02602124586701393,
0.1682439148426056,
-0.24297592043876648,
-0.8040193915367126,
-0.20009084045886993,
-0.7188470959663391,
0.34974405169487,
1.0401755571365356,
-0.6188998222351074,
0.5263392329216003,
0.146742582321167,
-0.5214259028434753,
-0.5784050822257996,
0.427954763174057,
0.5879003405570984,
0.09370182454586029,
-0.022733166813850403,
0.04358639568090439,
-0.2720678746700287,
-0.9463375210762024,
-0.2405957728624344,
-0.04070523381233215,
-0.19003967940807343,
0.5937367677688599,
0.43805405497550964,
-0.3150801956653595,
0.9449533224105835,
-0.41849982738494873,
-0.29203125834465027,
-0.1746254861354828,
0.0985548347234726,
0.4443759024143219,
0.13998104631900787,
0.7613773941993713,
-0.7004548907279968,
-0.43873515725135803,
-0.17183318734169006,
-0.5052019357681274,
-0.4077502191066742,
-0.15539711713790894,
-0.0016319089336320758,
0.10663536190986633,
0.5225934982299805,
-0.6553460955619812,
0.45527413487434387,
0.6368783712387085,
-0.5527305006980896,
0.6277416348457336,
0.055328868329524994,
0.1379328817129135,
-1.1433221101760864,
0.22521966695785522,
0.1269816756248474,
-0.13365525007247925,
-0.6247131824493408,
0.27474331855773926,
0.23936207592487335,
-0.4089277386665344,
-0.6077707409858704,
0.8303842544555664,
-0.4238024652004242,
0.12284589558839798,
-0.35779452323913574,
0.09474614262580872,
-0.5103281140327454,
0.3264860510826111,
-0.5444982051849365,
1.1153476238250732,
0.3703254759311676,
-0.4618092477321625,
0.8450087904930115,
0.10908427089452744,
-0.2579896152019501,
0.6820317506790161,
-0.6315498948097229,
0.21533870697021484,
-0.06911289691925049,
0.12982983887195587,
-1.2072159051895142,
-0.21503041684627533,
0.6754249334335327,
-0.7829358577728271,
0.29575175046920776,
-0.5235646963119507,
-0.4892828166484833,
-0.5994954705238342,
-0.18106752634048462,
0.11187298595905304,
0.5121800303459167,
-0.6608688831329346,
0.7059509754180908,
0.26720309257507324,
0.17237359285354614,
-1.035843014717102,
-0.5708068609237671,
0.2425394356250763,
-0.4351479709148407,
-0.4279825687408447,
0.09513489156961441,
-0.05570397153496742,
-0.18556638062000275,
0.04737706109881401,
0.10871962457895279,
0.02371770702302456,
0.5868881344795227,
0.4424602687358856,
0.5009083151817322,
-0.16403630375862122,
-0.4066349267959595,
-0.4585229754447937,
-0.04519607126712799,
0.4083257019519806,
0.03063846193253994,
0.5492559671401978,
0.17443059384822845,
-0.15414682030677795,
-0.36916494369506836,
0.5484265685081482,
0.5506128668785095,
-0.2507427930831909,
0.7782058715820312,
0.6181895732879639,
-0.4077434837818146,
-0.5770838260650635,
-0.5495368838310242,
-0.23852704465389252,
-0.5513913631439209,
0.06079939380288124,
-0.5253445506095886,
-0.7916679978370667,
0.8044536709785461,
0.20659604668617249,
-0.10284838825464249,
-0.09533699601888657,
0.5704236626625061,
0.19766098260879517,
0.8535154461860657,
0.8445903062820435,
-0.3268393278121948,
0.45951905846595764,
0.17594845592975616,
0.42890509963035583,
-0.6724662780761719,
-0.15256714820861816,
-0.527336061000824,
-0.10100274533033371,
-0.5452460646629333,
-0.13678820431232452,
0.18062777817249298,
-0.0206774789839983,
0.18876153230667114,
0.6068052053451538,
-0.41738200187683105,
0.5849270820617676,
0.8736957907676697,
0.3307480812072754,
-0.05527356639504433,
-0.3235997259616852,
-0.2806152105331421,
0.3086269795894623,
-0.21465875208377838,
-0.4858403205871582,
1.2760281562805176,
0.27403661608695984,
0.7792152762413025,
0.29392969608306885,
0.7796345949172974,
0.49479246139526367,
0.692680299282074,
-0.5465854406356812,
0.8881052732467651,
-0.010780902579426765,
-1.0776779651641846,
-0.1880219578742981,
-0.419475793838501,
-1.224636197090149,
-0.15104347467422485,
-0.12180143594741821,
-1.203825831413269,
-0.16231168806552887,
0.40268489718437195,
-0.575212299823761,
0.288910835981369,
-0.7643641233444214,
0.9619929194450378,
-0.0681624710559845,
-0.15456122159957886,
0.16355149447917938,
-0.432180792093277,
0.7670174241065979,
-0.23359473049640656,
0.01858578994870186,
-0.39001548290252686,
0.1950170248746872,
0.3547649383544922,
-0.32177042961120605,
1.127130150794983,
-0.49745824933052063,
-0.08400459587574005,
0.26161906123161316,
0.236057311296463,
0.7290603518486023,
0.08276500552892685,
0.2688085436820984,
0.06746108829975128,
-0.01626531593501568,
-0.3444405496120453,
-0.6990312933921814,
0.6309066414833069,
-0.6248683333396912,
-1.0527198314666748,
-0.3736880123615265,
-0.1384248435497284,
0.001420500106178224,
0.22759705781936646,
0.23219753801822662,
0.35169872641563416,
-0.12526673078536987,
0.20151779055595398,
0.7953806519508362,
-0.3244974911212921,
0.19842994213104248,
0.849136233329773,
-0.16293294727802277,
-0.142839714884758,
0.8470339179039001,
-0.2875038981437683,
-0.003740315092727542,
0.46083781123161316,
0.18386529386043549,
-0.21732060611248016,
-0.7028982043266296,
-0.6767105460166931,
0.3669412136077881,
-0.45469537377357483,
-0.34286972880363464,
-0.3833562135696411,
-0.32630741596221924,
-0.19535815715789795,
-0.0456758588552475,
-0.11489341408014297,
0.26088738441467285,
-0.2969832420349121,
0.23693303763866425,
0.4616832435131073,
0.45573723316192627,
0.22298456728458405,
0.28962796926498413,
-0.6772025227546692,
0.42057597637176514,
0.4698188304901123,
0.304833322763443,
-0.2811942398548126,
-0.5720654129981995,
0.016342677175998688,
-0.06436413526535034,
-0.008181974291801453,
-1.4609043598175049,
0.19283440709114075,
-0.2864210307598114,
0.7414577007293701,
0.35555872321128845,
0.18491919338703156,
0.2993994355201721,
-0.5665524005889893,
0.8162671327590942,
-0.043922875076532364,
-0.6610913872718811,
0.6377691030502319,
-0.37929508090019226,
0.20641979575157166,
0.2636887729167938,
0.2557792365550995,
-0.3602393567562103,
-0.9830968379974365,
-0.4774211347103119,
-0.6640568971633911,
0.3849402964115143,
-0.042242277413606644,
0.4059022068977356,
0.006818417925387621,
0.38000959157943726,
-0.16723868250846863,
0.31069502234458923,
-0.8344152569770813,
-0.6513835787773132,
0.2579742670059204,
-0.23179277777671814,
-0.14258651435375214,
-0.39079806208610535,
-0.24580784142017365,
0.42252326011657715,
0.5490778088569641,
0.08010011911392212,
0.3267717957496643,
-0.21823039650917053,
-0.051104914397001266,
-0.000663739803712815,
0.3066936433315277,
0.5927973985671997,
0.264911025762558,
-0.27331358194351196,
0.09538138657808304,
-0.018027599900960922,
-0.5659620761871338,
0.37172073125839233,
0.2856272757053375,
-0.45326194167137146,
-0.028185592964291573,
0.1673242300748825,
0.3197031319141388,
-0.06583406776189804,
-0.6831344962120056,
0.9078754782676697,
-0.27878275513648987,
0.011340769939124584,
-0.5100364089012146,
0.41062331199645996,
-0.2043938785791397,
0.41898879408836365,
0.8199080228805542,
0.031174421310424805,
0.16692619025707245,
-0.33360469341278076,
0.2724882960319519,
1.093160629272461,
-0.16050809621810913,
-0.1593218892812729,
0.6963949203491211,
0.2900392413139343,
-0.8363573551177979,
0.41870200634002686,
-0.43647658824920654,
-0.6434767246246338,
0.8307613134384155,
0.6794582009315491,
1.0106984376907349,
-0.5872912406921387,
0.11746318638324738,
0.21353377401828766,
0.6292216777801514,
0.3547467291355133,
0.14680056273937225,
0.042674098163843155,
-0.8635203838348389,
-0.3360048234462738,
-0.29734715819358826,
-0.4540795385837555,
0.5646103024482727,
-0.5581275820732117,
0.6028855443000793,
-0.5928228497505188,
-0.1709638386964798,
0.23920738697052002,
0.01699441485106945,
-0.5862471461296082,
-0.11776629835367203,
0.602556586265564,
0.7721161246299744,
-1.107697606086731,
0.5937296152114868,
0.3642924427986145,
0.048197757452726364,
-0.6513742208480835,
-0.08517968654632568,
0.5284130573272705,
-0.947632372379303,
0.26033082604408264,
0.4361274540424347,
-0.1989838182926178,
0.04003911837935448,
-0.7878656983375549,
-0.8097054958343506,
0.7903162837028503,
0.3585549592971802,
-0.5713456869125366,
0.33577683568000793,
-0.14554986357688904,
0.2571803629398346,
-0.21193479001522064,
0.05001875385642052,
0.5861445665359497,
0.37513017654418945,
-0.007940971292555332,
-0.6710230708122253,
0.4280690550804138,
-0.43565478920936584,
0.01475061010569334,
0.42539939284324646,
-0.45323818922042847,
0.40587687492370605,
-0.4518662393093109,
-0.3815193474292755,
0.2388564497232437,
0.5320038199424744,
0.6557316780090332,
0.27556928992271423,
0.46194180846214294,
0.2596460282802582,
0.6998457908630371,
-0.0690104067325592,
0.8789180517196655,
-0.4278046190738678,
0.05868178978562355,
0.8638280630111694,
-0.33634650707244873,
0.741184413433075,
0.443488746881485,
-0.20080998539924622,
0.2918056547641754,
0.5090158581733704,
-0.7458745241165161,
0.4094269275665283,
0.5568038821220398,
-0.3265700042247772,
0.059557925909757614,
0.1138358861207962,
-0.1675984263420105,
0.34400230646133423,
0.39863321185112,
-0.16789837181568146,
0.02005792036652565,
0.3128146231174469,
0.27889227867126465,
0.16903111338615417,
-0.2140463888645172,
0.6175919771194458,
-0.2521168887615204,
-0.7410181164741516,
0.5829378962516785,
0.11434746533632278,
0.7712265253067017,
-0.59951251745224,
0.10289401561021805,
-0.1367080956697464,
0.28450754284858704,
-0.004007495939731598,
-0.5303743481636047,
-0.003821772523224354,
0.051533542573451996,
-0.1310817301273346,
0.10112565755844116,
0.5583245754241943,
-0.4756118059158325,
-0.3155970871448517,
0.2632615864276886,
0.14470219612121582,
0.13056716322898865,
-0.02133917808532715,
-0.6827737092971802,
0.22729016840457916,
0.03327040374279022,
-0.15337465703487396,
0.06308529525995255,
0.2741971015930176,
0.148049458861351,
0.9565876722335815,
0.857185959815979,
0.28462713956832886,
0.21439829468727112,
-0.09137638658285141,
0.6139031648635864,
-0.6177088022232056,
-0.5875465273857117,
-1.0982459783554077,
0.2919427752494812,
-0.2188064008951187,
-0.2724170982837677,
0.9935454726219177,
0.4996391236782074,
0.6150920987129211,
-0.17861485481262207,
0.7883154153823853,
-0.062357354909181595,
0.604708194732666,
-0.3940525949001312,
0.47321322560310364,
-0.2327609658241272,
0.5773288011550903,
-0.1483723670244217,
-0.6614994406700134,
-0.23722238838672638,
0.08582437038421631,
-0.263097882270813,
-0.01688242144882679,
0.5878027677536011,
1.2590644359588623,
-0.004701545462012291,
-0.3836345970630646,
0.411833792924881,
-0.010448625311255455,
0.4529407322406769,
0.7920989990234375,
0.9609860181808472,
-0.3515792191028595,
0.8812260031700134,
-0.04148603230714798,
-0.5861092209815979,
-0.716200053691864,
-0.8537057042121887,
-1.3433736562728882,
-0.2599315643310547,
-0.542908251285553,
-0.646086573600769,
0.15737980604171753,
0.7010790109634399,
0.7594903707504272,
-0.7706407904624939,
0.03561935946345329,
0.2890753149986267,
0.2570810616016388,
-0.3433041572570801,
-0.2802756726741791,
-0.08867750316858292,
0.02520553022623062,
-0.5546435117721558,
0.453225314617157,
0.19492504000663757,
0.32969042658805847,
-0.48540449142456055,
0.39541271328926086,
0.09516965597867966,
0.3231154680252075,
-0.008132992312312126,
0.6858177781105042,
-0.9903998970985413,
-0.352024644613266,
0.01810026355087757,
-0.4034215211868286,
-0.24803301692008972,
0.7969502806663513,
-0.5335977077484131,
0.26795586943626404,
-0.04554864391684532,
0.8154412508010864,
0.28393983840942383,
0.15998965501785278,
0.6272685527801514,
-0.9569258689880371,
0.31430935859680176,
0.16327406466007233,
0.19401389360427856,
0.17441900074481964,
-0.8853927254676819,
-0.06152220815420151,
0.24254189431667328,
-0.37053754925727844,
-1.027518391609192,
0.3770449459552765,
-0.9880499839782715,
-0.4168739318847656,
1.3237372636795044,
-0.2775667905807495,
-0.5657230019569397,
-0.35743844509124756,
-0.13455606997013092,
-0.19162331521511078,
-0.35297825932502747,
0.843347430229187,
0.6275104284286499,
0.3864598274230957,
-0.4482940435409546,
-0.3844435214996338,
0.5307285189628601,
-0.046923838555812836,
-0.5442858338356018,
0.03115151636302471,
0.28460633754730225,
0.4838774502277374,
0.24872905015945435,
0.5496312975883484,
-0.006724765989929438,
0.5248687863349915,
-0.08762059360742569,
-0.0715864822268486,
-0.3318781554698944,
-0.41797998547554016,
-0.4148022532463074,
0.33363646268844604,
-0.17064760625362396,
-0.6131947636604309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12984v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12984v1 | Can GNN be Good Adapter for LLMs? | 2024-02-20T13:13:13 | 2024-02-20T13:13:13 | Xuanwen Huang, Kaiqiao Han, Yang Yang, Dezheng Bao, Quanjin Tao, Ziwei Chai, Qi Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior
capabilities in understanding and zero-shot learning on textual data, promising
significant advances for many text-related domains. In the graph domain,
various real-world scenarios also involve textual data, where tasks and node
features can be described by text. These text-attributed graphs (TAGs) have
broad applications in social media, recommendation systems, etc. Thus, this
paper explores how to utilize LLMs to model TAGs. Previous methods for TAG
modeling are based on million-scale LMs. When scaled up to billion-scale LLMs,
they face huge challenges in computational costs. Additionally, they also
ignore the zero-shot inference capabilities of LLMs. Therefore, we propose
GraphAdapter, which uses a graph neural network (GNN) as an efficient adapter
in collaboration with LLMs to tackle TAGs. In terms of efficiency, the GNN
adapter introduces only a few trainable parameters and can be trained with low
computation costs. The entire framework is trained using auto-regression on
node text (next token prediction). Once trained, GraphAdapter can be seamlessly
fine-tuned with task-specific prompts for various downstream tasks. Through
extensive experiments across multiple real-world TAGs, GraphAdapter based on
Llama 2 gains an average improvement of approximately 5\% in terms of node
classification. Furthermore, GraphAdapter can also adapt to other language
models, including RoBERTa, GPT-2. The promising results demonstrate that GNNs
can serve as effective adapters for LLMs in TAG modeling. | [
-0.010007726959884167,
-0.6195036172866821,
0.4812465012073517,
-0.0946594774723053,
-0.4431990683078766,
0.11282031238079071,
-0.11003076285123825,
-0.6403180956840515,
0.25355973839759827,
0.261779248714447,
-0.3506234884262085,
-0.4838067293167114,
-0.5797055959701538,
-0.1368003636598587,
-0.2678970396518707,
0.9541476368904114,
-0.12302809953689575,
-0.24035491049289703,
-0.04622881859540939,
-0.09491060674190521,
-0.5881433486938477,
-0.2125898152589798,
-0.9556224942207336,
-0.5409993529319763,
0.7863340377807617,
0.13635845482349396,
0.4224085509777069,
0.8223275542259216,
0.40898868441581726,
0.3371821343898773,
0.044285546988248825,
0.27429336309432983,
-0.5827699303627014,
0.08191869407892227,
-0.2720801830291748,
-0.307886004447937,
-0.7191599607467651,
-0.09366092830896378,
0.5511019229888916,
0.4174532890319824,
0.06278713792562485,
0.2842097580432892,
0.047003958374261856,
0.4361386001110077,
-0.165542870759964,
0.23758311569690704,
-1.0619916915893555,
-0.2759034335613251,
0.15915697813034058,
-0.09320838749408722,
-0.3673347532749176,
-0.22062644362449646,
-0.06108768284320831,
-0.7637140154838562,
-0.02334694191813469,
0.2471899688243866,
0.9243224263191223,
0.3125682473182678,
-0.41279035806655884,
-0.32822906970977783,
-0.5728062391281128,
0.5499029755592346,
-0.664766788482666,
0.08762288093566895,
0.1254555881023407,
0.349529892206192,
-0.3617240786552429,
-1.0472755432128906,
-0.5244641304016113,
0.032589223235845566,
0.026112813502550125,
0.10034389793872833,
-0.36523404717445374,
0.04353434965014458,
-0.11164911091327667,
0.009178705513477325,
-0.5686725974082947,
0.4967334270477295,
0.2711027264595032,
-0.14346802234649658,
0.36222952604293823,
0.10622455179691315,
0.5696054697036743,
-0.3902489244937897,
-0.4280409812927246,
0.21203239262104034,
-0.5317783355712891,
-0.29017695784568787,
0.35178589820861816,
0.5836902260780334,
0.09168154001235962,
0.3699866831302643,
-0.010788521729409695,
1.105198621749878,
-0.30182963609695435,
-0.14644382894039154,
0.11876185238361359,
-0.4977955222129822,
-0.26229265332221985,
-0.19373780488967896,
0.8226954340934753,
0.6652541756629944,
0.7005001306533813,
-0.36721140146255493,
0.032017771154642105,
0.15941987931728363,
0.14179329574108124,
-0.945836067199707,
-0.4755782186985016,
-0.05991663783788681,
-0.29904818534851074,
-0.1951802670955658,
-0.39213648438453674,
-0.4700488746166229,
-0.47498998045921326,
-0.10824251174926758,
0.2719970643520355,
-0.27703842520713806,
-0.2571818232536316,
0.04489773139357567,
-0.28477510809898376,
0.05681382864713669,
0.5709854364395142,
-0.7434688806533813,
0.241005539894104,
0.6317679286003113,
1.284253478050232,
-0.10239524394273758,
-0.20078766345977783,
-0.36925217509269714,
0.3083050549030304,
-0.12850666046142578,
0.887790322303772,
-0.4057406187057495,
-0.26929575204849243,
-0.17952214181423187,
0.17290367186069489,
-0.42774468660354614,
-0.25645071268081665,
0.4219439923763275,
-0.628079354763031,
-0.2831030488014221,
0.08573555201292038,
-0.6470811367034912,
-0.22919334471225739,
0.4412197768688202,
-0.6397021412849426,
0.8014046549797058,
0.16214868426322937,
-0.8009679317474365,
0.2595284879207611,
-0.5008135437965393,
-0.43779122829437256,
0.33283472061157227,
0.07369878888130188,
-0.40593305230140686,
-0.16267794370651245,
0.23005834221839905,
0.6322088241577148,
-0.2501189410686493,
0.21424686908721924,
-0.4060775339603424,
-0.5466219782829285,
0.1997712403535843,
-0.357312947511673,
0.5017651915550232,
-0.0420510359108448,
0.08365551382303238,
0.15683278441429138,
-0.77886962890625,
-0.009515308775007725,
0.3235831558704376,
-0.4636664390563965,
-0.5110121965408325,
0.2968747317790985,
0.112221859395504,
0.25369125604629517,
-0.03150898218154907,
-0.5807185173034668,
0.3074268698692322,
-0.35619330406188965,
0.7370524406433105,
0.8846162557601929,
0.10065527260303497,
0.45371389389038086,
-0.23841415345668793,
0.4185370206832886,
-0.3903414309024811,
-0.34346890449523926,
-0.10093172639608383,
-0.6038696765899658,
-0.5520749092102051,
-0.44525042176246643,
0.4823656678199768,
0.5694164633750916,
-1.0830239057540894,
0.39073076844215393,
-0.6077299118041992,
-0.5799441337585449,
-0.3510796129703522,
0.24967065453529358,
0.10411149263381958,
0.7974757552146912,
0.15827195346355438,
-0.1720302551984787,
-0.48218560218811035,
-0.36705008149147034,
-0.4609634578227997,
-0.4079078733921051,
-0.07689124345779419,
0.6407252550125122,
0.33647599816322327,
-0.23265419900417328,
0.8763367533683777,
-0.38525769114494324,
-0.49940618872642517,
-0.483407199382782,
-0.22944816946983337,
0.47263774275779724,
0.21563026309013367,
0.7172387838363647,
-0.44993463158607483,
-0.6004101634025574,
0.22116804122924805,
-0.6766206622123718,
-0.07515659928321838,
0.012511148117482662,
-0.08568967878818512,
0.09940404444932938,
0.43369024991989136,
-0.3328436613082886,
0.24099110066890717,
0.8302406668663025,
-0.24063071608543396,
0.2696567475795746,
-0.13894376158714294,
-0.5558932423591614,
-1.3018040657043457,
-0.08050624281167984,
0.419181227684021,
-0.7378697395324707,
-0.7438361644744873,
-0.2728421688079834,
-0.06260959804058075,
0.1993979960680008,
-0.26554349064826965,
0.7543696165084839,
-0.3631995916366577,
-0.19258002936840057,
-0.5329515933990479,
0.38466790318489075,
0.03900004178285599,
0.2667466700077057,
-0.21479594707489014,
0.807805597782135,
0.37963107228279114,
-0.49748820066452026,
0.45877158641815186,
0.10399100184440613,
-0.43768516182899475,
0.42440056800842285,
-0.7539578080177307,
0.2005072683095932,
-0.15414059162139893,
0.5345794558525085,
-1.4779804944992065,
-0.0724288821220398,
0.36762312054634094,
-0.44385847449302673,
0.29539754986763,
-0.6267865896224976,
-0.5761365294456482,
-0.5244507193565369,
-0.28446656465530396,
0.12831240892410278,
0.2563669681549072,
-0.7877976894378662,
0.898018479347229,
0.3256351351737976,
-0.043033670634031296,
-0.3701556324958801,
-0.7125822305679321,
0.28728288412094116,
-0.11235172301530838,
-0.36491405963897705,
0.1851494163274765,
-0.12642838060855865,
0.3316613435745239,
0.19911494851112366,
0.03276539966464043,
0.23267953097820282,
0.39034706354141235,
0.4617651402950287,
0.5152996182441711,
-0.13185542821884155,
0.30422455072402954,
-0.29214686155319214,
-0.35768923163414,
-0.12350022047758102,
-0.7291200160980225,
0.7500119209289551,
0.023653248324990273,
0.01074854377657175,
-0.3683694303035736,
-0.22606852650642395,
0.13374096155166626,
0.10318364202976227,
0.5253416299819946,
0.5474421381950378,
-0.27981656789779663,
-0.28280237317085266,
-0.15361849963665009,
0.31052693724632263,
-0.5296680927276611,
0.7693929076194763,
-0.24612262845039368,
-0.9167574644088745,
0.5317896604537964,
-0.4872662127017975,
-0.2904900908470154,
0.38162949681282043,
0.5593949556350708,
-0.19096103310585022,
0.7645109295845032,
0.5092737674713135,
-0.6430457830429077,
0.7835291624069214,
-0.28660985827445984,
0.16472075879573822,
-1.1751248836517334,
0.23806853592395782,
-0.3967205584049225,
-0.5745214819908142,
-0.7433475255966187,
-0.38722658157348633,
0.008075702004134655,
-0.03827081620693207,
-0.27626895904541016,
0.3892204165458679,
-0.551525354385376,
0.6085508465766907,
0.29704517126083374,
0.08768724650144577,
0.3058949112892151,
0.14733313024044037,
0.007743567228317261,
0.24056792259216309,
-0.7783055901527405,
-0.3902781903743744,
1.0420606136322021,
0.4176592230796814,
0.9984511137008667,
-0.005360780283808708,
0.4581970274448395,
0.08923155814409256,
0.5923458933830261,
-1.0716038942337036,
0.5066938400268555,
-0.3994455933570862,
-0.3783862590789795,
-0.23121875524520874,
-0.4787999093532562,
-0.818316638469696,
0.2870326042175293,
0.004456982482224703,
-1.0654760599136353,
0.03091585636138916,
0.2564944326877594,
0.10474749654531479,
0.5513984560966492,
-0.7186738848686218,
0.6658633947372437,
-0.16975001990795135,
-0.13854704797267914,
0.4418449103832245,
-0.5379976034164429,
0.03836480528116226,
-0.08008232712745667,
0.32295867800712585,
-0.47356295585632324,
-0.22843089699745178,
0.7881361246109009,
-0.17109358310699463,
1.1288175582885742,
-0.2564118802547455,
-0.0008272382547147572,
0.33190497756004333,
0.06287628412246704,
0.7730080485343933,
0.07500555366277695,
-0.24823898077011108,
0.0490630641579628,
-0.5232139825820923,
-0.08510889112949371,
-0.6178613305091858,
0.9948922395706177,
-0.952125608921051,
-0.2728331685066223,
-0.25937506556510925,
-0.8587320446968079,
-0.11724843084812164,
0.4455002248287201,
-0.015715045854449272,
0.33048325777053833,
-0.060919277369976044,
-0.18569941818714142,
0.15292170643806458,
0.1307809054851532,
0.8832642436027527,
0.2615799605846405,
-0.4439588487148285,
-0.5701661109924316,
1.2805380821228027,
0.35246628522872925,
0.4546470046043396,
0.23373660445213318,
0.20644918084144592,
-0.07734199613332748,
-0.7315083742141724,
-0.7616490125656128,
0.42174434661865234,
-0.8572329878807068,
-0.6115944981575012,
-0.6677563786506653,
-0.25911757349967957,
-0.08660142868757248,
-0.19604960083961487,
0.05805765837430954,
-0.47234052419662476,
-0.6965700387954712,
-0.23435673117637634,
0.7001181840896606,
0.6779050230979919,
0.3006570637226105,
0.7193931937217712,
-0.2800792455673218,
0.301085501909256,
0.2847641706466675,
0.5121957659721375,
0.28327256441116333,
-0.6224411725997925,
-0.15426945686340332,
-0.11407029628753662,
0.05703921616077423,
-0.5944058895111084,
0.31373125314712524,
0.5353507995605469,
0.3962955176830292,
0.009687254205346107,
-0.23319505155086517,
0.5341598391532898,
-0.6700051426887512,
0.6000192761421204,
0.12567682564258575,
-0.7311517596244812,
0.2452966868877411,
-0.4884176254272461,
0.3392828702926636,
0.3931600749492645,
0.42069485783576965,
-0.5792826414108276,
-0.03285697475075722,
-0.1869553029537201,
-0.947418212890625,
0.6259118914604187,
-0.11157795041799545,
0.39381784200668335,
0.028198156505823135,
0.7699711322784424,
-0.2572488486766815,
0.09675028175115585,
-0.849186360836029,
-0.2682632505893707,
-0.32061126828193665,
-0.48511257767677307,
-0.34977206587791443,
-0.08937658369541168,
0.18617242574691772,
-0.2913266122341156,
0.6832793354988098,
-0.7113858461380005,
0.2777653634548187,
-0.026639139279723167,
-0.2218572348356247,
-0.0638350248336792,
-0.006989127025008202,
0.1716078370809555,
0.47662216424942017,
-0.20041827857494354,
0.2608817219734192,
0.26420146226882935,
-0.5528971552848816,
0.22293230891227722,
0.20537610352039337,
-0.20640859007835388,
0.027294395491480827,
0.41030153632164,
0.8904783725738525,
0.014648069627583027,
-0.12953007221221924,
0.44290074706077576,
-0.12716799974441528,
-0.15251146256923676,
0.1069950982928276,
0.08906015753746033,
0.6124727129936218,
0.15371713042259216,
0.10617032647132874,
-0.08775673806667328,
-0.016933666542172432,
-0.4200884997844696,
0.01289563812315464,
0.6092149019241333,
-0.5814911127090454,
-0.26211512088775635,
0.6318718194961548,
0.042056210339069366,
-0.4868083596229553,
0.4187585115432739,
-0.1006268709897995,
-0.622822642326355,
0.6296889185905457,
1.16001558303833,
0.6836169362068176,
-0.2613162696361542,
0.2290719598531723,
0.09430244565010071,
0.24800466001033783,
0.22284065186977386,
0.1568659245967865,
0.23052416741847992,
-1.0346882343292236,
-0.6068850755691528,
-0.6053216457366943,
-0.23088932037353516,
-0.2910688817501068,
-0.18970948457717896,
0.14836205542087555,
-0.6244379878044128,
-0.3277711272239685,
0.34419646859169006,
-0.07414187490940094,
-0.6545422077178955,
0.19061030447483063,
0.023319968953728676,
0.8980071544647217,
-0.831207811832428,
1.046033263206482,
0.7532069683074951,
-0.1807454228401184,
-0.85260009765625,
-0.23651908338069916,
-0.07986282557249069,
-1.29294753074646,
0.5065463185310364,
0.17809446156024933,
-0.22297081351280212,
0.5416324734687805,
-0.5488900542259216,
-0.8194289803504944,
1.2934744358062744,
0.21447299420833588,
-0.5215322375297546,
-0.13786715269088745,
0.12546582520008087,
0.5913196206092834,
-0.5670433640480042,
0.3682854473590851,
0.3160105347633362,
0.2904895544052124,
0.45281919836997986,
-0.621259331703186,
0.22996018826961517,
-0.14609557390213013,
0.44617241621017456,
0.23454095423221588,
-0.6288601756095886,
0.7878309488296509,
0.02468143403530121,
0.030014580115675926,
0.12644650042057037,
0.4444611668586731,
0.03610021620988846,
0.18084338307380676,
0.5337662100791931,
0.4637599289417267,
0.7621989250183105,
-0.0175469983369112,
1.1747808456420898,
-0.14501164853572845,
0.5193734765052795,
1.2933826446533203,
-0.557235598564148,
0.7887229919433594,
0.24614624679088593,
-0.02172645926475525,
0.695321798324585,
0.5168800354003906,
-0.0901452824473381,
0.36474499106407166,
0.4711029529571533,
-0.016927188262343407,
-0.19226859509944916,
-0.4898664653301239,
-0.08569490909576416,
0.25581249594688416,
0.4775974452495575,
-0.3824516832828522,
-0.3786093294620514,
-0.16563089191913605,
0.23771773278713226,
-0.19191668927669525,
-0.4397108852863312,
1.0102014541625977,
0.22555798292160034,
-0.02849668450653553,
0.31081077456474304,
-0.047642603516578674,
0.6520392298698425,
-0.5468934178352356,
0.028927335515618324,
0.09111788123846054,
0.3166753351688385,
-0.23647424578666687,
-0.7322527766227722,
-0.010882954113185406,
-0.14853723347187042,
-0.1735060065984726,
-0.054546892642974854,
1.457501769065857,
-0.14073733985424042,
-0.7325441241264343,
0.6174921989440918,
0.4141212999820709,
-0.037101805210113525,
0.00423398707062006,
-0.5067968368530273,
0.11743541061878204,
-0.27017420530319214,
-0.16611023247241974,
0.3946351408958435,
0.32587820291519165,
0.057577185332775116,
0.7007980942726135,
0.7092207670211792,
0.21835541725158691,
-0.05370764061808586,
0.21845121681690216,
1.2763100862503052,
-0.4959010183811188,
-0.34624531865119934,
-0.9531872272491455,
0.32506051659584045,
-0.060504648834466934,
0.0170054342597723,
0.8126681447029114,
0.36376312375068665,
0.5380924344062805,
0.3116292357444763,
0.9582934379577637,
0.2196100950241089,
0.4326653480529785,
-0.3788797855377197,
0.7655616402626038,
-0.40951812267303467,
0.059724774211645126,
-0.45403891801834106,
-0.9593517780303955,
-0.5962142944335938,
0.5358797311782837,
-0.3234286606311798,
0.14846457540988922,
0.33760127425193787,
0.46143004298210144,
0.028979016467928886,
-0.10899759829044342,
0.19681312143802643,
0.14463412761688232,
0.6409648656845093,
0.5656659007072449,
0.6454682946205139,
-0.6384758949279785,
0.46951234340667725,
0.33273056149482727,
-0.13196346163749695,
-0.24473533034324646,
-1.255547046661377,
-1.160598874092102,
-0.16214609146118164,
-0.1734212189912796,
-0.43009719252586365,
0.1631786823272705,
0.6693292260169983,
0.5564281940460205,
-0.427083283662796,
-0.18260209262371063,
-0.2127767950296402,
0.36698731780052185,
0.06525490432977676,
-0.1488548368215561,
0.29754194617271423,
-0.11120577156543732,
-0.485401451587677,
0.2325860857963562,
0.31034645438194275,
0.24138136208057404,
0.03984621912240982,
0.05397885665297508,
-0.4946235716342926,
0.00677097775042057,
0.466726690530777,
0.08885421603918076,
-0.5126218199729919,
-0.7030523419380188,
-0.05413985624909401,
0.10194917768239975,
0.1619144231081009,
0.5725117921829224,
-0.8439346551895142,
0.5355383157730103,
0.3728032112121582,
0.8514893054962158,
0.6242918372154236,
0.12108143419027328,
0.30390551686286926,
-0.8213975429534912,
0.006840717513114214,
-0.123438760638237,
0.45915958285331726,
0.4382418394088745,
-0.25580114126205444,
0.5498471856117249,
0.2474006861448288,
-0.7339494228363037,
-0.6213200092315674,
0.2499711662530899,
-1.078703761100769,
-0.15059572458267212,
1.3491802215576172,
-0.21973474323749542,
-0.473370224237442,
-0.08589175343513489,
-0.22637493908405304,
0.358297199010849,
-0.2634868025779724,
0.195405974984169,
0.5222589373588562,
0.07168693095445633,
-0.18888220191001892,
-0.6368284821510315,
0.06178027763962746,
-0.09707534313201904,
-0.7545488476753235,
0.0022510425187647343,
0.1849406510591507,
0.531100332736969,
0.04301059618592262,
0.7851167917251587,
0.41181159019470215,
-0.16772985458374023,
-0.20001284778118134,
-0.010133625939488411,
-0.33813902735710144,
-0.19500204920768738,
-0.37039777636528015,
-0.04751283675432205,
0.32010695338249207,
-0.2788534462451935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14856v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14856v2 | Comparing Inferential Strategies of Humans and Large Language Models in Deductive Reasoning | 2024-02-20T12:58:14 | 2024-06-03T13:53:01 | Philipp Mondorf, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Deductive reasoning plays a pivotal role in the formulation of sound and
cohesive arguments. It allows individuals to draw conclusions that logically
follow, given the truth value of the information provided. Recent progress in
the domain of large language models (LLMs) has showcased their capability in
executing deductive reasoning tasks. Nonetheless, a significant portion of
research primarily assesses the accuracy of LLMs in solving such tasks, often
overlooking a deeper analysis of their reasoning behavior. In this study, we
draw upon principles from cognitive psychology to examine inferential
strategies employed by LLMs, through a detailed evaluation of their responses
to propositional logic problems. Our findings indicate that LLMs display
reasoning patterns akin to those observed in humans, including strategies like
$\textit{supposition following}$ or $\textit{chain construction}$. Moreover,
our research demonstrates that the architecture and scale of the model
significantly affect its preferred method of reasoning, with more advanced
models tending to adopt strategies more frequently than less sophisticated
ones. Importantly, we assert that a model's accuracy, that is the correctness
of its final conclusion, does not necessarily reflect the validity of its
reasoning process. This distinction underscores the necessity for more nuanced
evaluation procedures in the field. | [
-0.14056020975112915,
-0.9600804448127747,
1.0407097339630127,
0.2500966787338257,
-0.15510110557079315,
0.17646247148513794,
-0.43643277883529663,
-0.3632819354534149,
-0.22449375689029694,
0.4393960237503052,
-0.33084651827812195,
-0.24690471589565277,
-0.4710448384284973,
0.35960114002227783,
-0.12328536063432693,
0.3825817406177521,
0.1303265392780304,
0.3335528075695038,
-0.596423327922821,
0.1359253227710724,
-0.5016031265258789,
-0.883358359336853,
-0.5840815305709839,
-0.8406442403793335,
0.20775824785232544,
0.38758692145347595,
0.8389847874641418,
0.42784950137138367,
0.6305939555168152,
0.30774006247520447,
-0.4016121029853821,
0.16577759385108948,
-0.18438884615898132,
0.19832225143909454,
-0.45707234740257263,
-0.573275625705719,
-0.22770747542381287,
0.05925486981868744,
0.36576735973358154,
0.9391005635261536,
-0.21703366935253143,
0.10328400135040283,
0.07562042027711868,
0.596312403678894,
-0.6428215503692627,
-0.07297902554273605,
-0.6734752058982849,
-0.14476734399795532,
-0.20071227848529816,
-0.1534416526556015,
-0.6391573548316956,
-0.43579965829849243,
0.4185459315776825,
-0.23583553731441498,
-0.024458106607198715,
-0.11627963930368423,
0.5094057321548462,
0.1725948452949524,
-0.39867350459098816,
-0.651411771774292,
-0.7006560564041138,
0.7504826784133911,
-1.0436450242996216,
0.17769646644592285,
0.4604007601737976,
-0.027641624212265015,
-0.5056805610656738,
-0.39726877212524414,
-0.4952605366706848,
-0.6644334197044373,
-0.12773571908473969,
-0.16306692361831665,
-0.14595654606819153,
0.01103720348328352,
0.7464040517807007,
0.041176263242959976,
-0.48368051648139954,
0.38489100337028503,
-0.03916002810001373,
0.07728759944438934,
0.7095994353294373,
0.1540956050157547,
-0.08528927713632584,
-0.2329956442117691,
-0.3214256465435028,
-0.1749986708164215,
-0.7109459638595581,
0.09950780123472214,
0.232746422290802,
0.11888895183801651,
0.08341135084629059,
0.5325790643692017,
-0.36754488945007324,
0.9205002784729004,
0.2855522334575653,
-0.216316357254982,
-0.015092444606125355,
-0.08324230462312698,
-0.35630521178245544,
0.12544293701648712,
0.5537333488464355,
0.4463109076023102,
0.45498281717300415,
-0.07675483822822571,
-0.3751871585845947,
0.44500482082366943,
0.17617002129554749,
-0.5303046703338623,
-0.04520881921052933,
0.07534249871969223,
-0.5705529451370239,
-0.20392701029777527,
-0.18989627063274384,
-0.539625346660614,
-0.7158869504928589,
-0.3875811696052551,
0.4262903332710266,
-0.33478549122810364,
-0.0788806900382042,
0.5628611445426941,
-0.2050679326057434,
0.42607638239860535,
0.3338434398174286,
-0.7919455170631409,
0.48894003033638,
0.7944654822349548,
0.5630946159362793,
-0.1439952850341797,
0.014585785567760468,
-0.4258931875228882,
0.10023925453424454,
-0.610561192035675,
0.9237869381904602,
-0.7963523268699646,
-0.4409430921077728,
-0.0800623819231987,
-0.34103506803512573,
-0.04502515867352486,
-0.9248273968696594,
0.9535113573074341,
-0.5300741195678711,
0.056298788636922836,
-0.5548282265663147,
-0.8181554079055786,
-0.37966808676719666,
0.3546435832977295,
-0.4195575714111328,
0.6205678582191467,
-0.19973288476467133,
-0.5729894042015076,
0.4229790270328522,
-0.7022703289985657,
-0.5118677020072937,
0.0033411504700779915,
-0.333909809589386,
0.05188428610563278,
0.3545732796192169,
0.15772856771945953,
0.6783250570297241,
-0.740526020526886,
0.1747753620147705,
-0.5257583856582642,
-0.35506898164749146,
0.8635757565498352,
-0.4875999093055725,
0.8680238723754883,
0.17297564446926117,
-0.5558342933654785,
-0.209480881690979,
-0.640311062335968,
-0.03468438982963562,
0.4038604497909546,
-0.2788105607032776,
-0.5682036876678467,
0.33691489696502686,
-0.7511895895004272,
0.241970956325531,
0.03946404159069061,
-0.414002001285553,
0.2028013914823532,
-0.45491501688957214,
0.7351598739624023,
0.6622798442840576,
-0.00846812967211008,
0.43619251251220703,
-0.26548394560813904,
0.3221639394760132,
-0.24742081761360168,
0.13931795954704285,
0.16094523668289185,
-0.2672348618507385,
-0.5494619607925415,
-0.20761995017528534,
0.10430076718330383,
0.49107468128204346,
-0.27419865131378174,
0.18083424866199493,
-0.23211711645126343,
-0.5502127408981323,
0.004462714772671461,
0.11866588890552521,
0.42547738552093506,
0.45900559425354004,
0.16200245916843414,
-0.0884760171175003,
-0.3720207214355469,
-0.8309995532035828,
-0.33765533566474915,
-0.20311443507671356,
0.035719797015190125,
0.08987468481063843,
0.6008732914924622,
-0.019686974585056305,
0.7231618165969849,
-0.46446725726127625,
0.2582109570503235,
-0.29692378640174866,
0.028346169739961624,
0.35340699553489685,
0.2422434389591217,
0.4641941785812378,
-0.6549313068389893,
-0.13323894143104553,
-0.1408538520336151,
-1.01341712474823,
-0.018687931820750237,
-0.07730337232351303,
-0.08868005126714706,
0.35620546340942383,
0.5666022896766663,
-0.7516761422157288,
0.35750603675842285,
0.21451136469841003,
-0.5138166546821594,
0.5016941428184509,
-0.1979113519191742,
-0.0185089074075222,
-0.35586169362068176,
-0.35167166590690613,
0.12705089151859283,
0.025543002411723137,
-0.41427403688430786,
0.04722774401307106,
-0.12554152309894562,
0.41127288341522217,
-0.17356310784816742,
0.373539000749588,
-0.41250091791152954,
-0.008231325075030327,
-0.13246628642082214,
0.16808238625526428,
0.1845037043094635,
0.277113676071167,
0.18438473343849182,
0.4706384241580963,
0.37875795364379883,
-0.7317144870758057,
0.5254858732223511,
0.05847754701972008,
-0.6034825444221497,
0.6702070236206055,
-0.8936530351638794,
0.30158698558807373,
-0.12210928648710251,
0.33568093180656433,
-1.1896218061447144,
-0.04563799500465393,
0.1467302143573761,
-0.30503925681114197,
0.07308735698461533,
0.11628410965204239,
-0.7386592626571655,
-0.4963076412677765,
-0.24858039617538452,
0.23927250504493713,
0.5047089457511902,
-0.5130771994590759,
0.4401739537715912,
0.04037056490778923,
0.07837269455194473,
-0.3555377721786499,
-0.7809646129608154,
0.09574896842241287,
-0.6178886294364929,
-0.6345595717430115,
0.2515889108181,
-0.06642884016036987,
-1.0657358169555664,
-0.35626381635665894,
-0.17033551633358002,
0.11402011662721634,
0.2892916202545166,
0.016670934855937958,
0.25918903946876526,
-0.07927007973194122,
0.20503364503383636,
-0.39208048582077026,
0.08305057138204575,
0.4422703981399536,
-0.08962908387184143,
0.5120688080787659,
-0.05988981947302818,
-0.4741489589214325,
-0.16347447037696838,
0.17260269820690155,
0.6446870565414429,
-0.2455223947763443,
0.6898226141929626,
-0.1431771069765091,
-0.2838771343231201,
-0.11624187976121902,
-0.8446416258811951,
-0.42074882984161377,
-0.4120063781738281,
0.09532514959573746,
-0.5048301815986633,
-0.5264711380004883,
0.3444584012031555,
-0.20120997726917267,
-0.23376569151878357,
0.3199167847633362,
0.5928517580032349,
-0.2569347321987152,
1.0451141595840454,
0.12794001400470734,
0.2382999211549759,
0.08521310240030289,
-0.31822535395622253,
0.20087800920009613,
-0.842144250869751,
-0.3262978494167328,
-0.5701767802238464,
-0.220319002866745,
-0.34243524074554443,
-0.4008479416370392,
0.11283399909734726,
0.20104925334453583,
-0.542146623134613,
0.18502072989940643,
-0.47559574246406555,
0.40107834339141846,
0.4153086543083191,
0.16783082485198975,
0.5096681118011475,
-0.005677194334566593,
-0.20789511501789093,
-0.048082493245601654,
-0.6953507661819458,
-0.9339767694473267,
0.9336262345314026,
0.38756823539733887,
0.8731933236122131,
0.33596888184547424,
0.4045359492301941,
0.3153602182865143,
0.08840680867433548,
-0.7584121227264404,
0.8093231320381165,
-0.06717685610055923,
-0.5076517462730408,
-0.24016070365905762,
-0.32047200202941895,
-0.8926488161087036,
0.4227549731731415,
-0.28425323963165283,
-0.8087766766548157,
0.2703073024749756,
-0.04762931168079376,
-0.3520939350128174,
0.19898302853107452,
-0.6422634720802307,
0.8086481690406799,
-0.6411277055740356,
-0.4040418267250061,
-0.47391045093536377,
-0.6121279001235962,
0.17795735597610474,
0.0831466019153595,
0.12478533387184143,
-0.08105460554361343,
0.043277595192193985,
0.6660578846931458,
-0.21224422752857208,
0.8804702758789062,
-0.03380651772022247,
-0.4373093843460083,
0.4579009413719177,
0.261656790971756,
0.5439940094947815,
-0.14963571727275848,
-0.36149874329566956,
0.01754930429160595,
0.006702876184135675,
-0.2056252807378769,
-0.8054876923561096,
0.4821866452693939,
-0.49810469150543213,
-0.8982889652252197,
-0.3443233370780945,
-0.36772802472114563,
-0.21036075055599213,
-0.27329638600349426,
0.29035767912864685,
0.6322612166404724,
-0.3079773485660553,
0.1485697329044342,
0.7886002063751221,
-0.10965348035097122,
0.4742196798324585,
0.5415341854095459,
-0.0058479905128479,
-0.10784398764371872,
0.398375928401947,
0.13495253026485443,
0.5815265774726868,
0.6018742918968201,
0.4819398522377014,
-0.5852301120758057,
-0.494806170463562,
-0.2881010174751282,
0.38646242022514343,
-0.9206793904304504,
-0.11543069779872894,
-0.29654791951179504,
0.18455544114112854,
-0.296275794506073,
-0.13552874326705933,
-0.12840121984481812,
-0.261177122592926,
0.05335197225213051,
-0.09046760201454163,
0.3079371750354767,
0.8154430985450745,
0.17555660009384155,
-0.010288720950484276,
-0.4221963882446289,
0.12123114615678787,
0.4768124520778656,
-0.012579711154103279,
0.3291165232658386,
-0.6311076879501343,
0.06514087319374084,
0.20939354598522186,
-0.4479794204235077,
-0.9239451885223389,
-0.03191874921321869,
-0.2417982816696167,
0.7811304926872253,
0.401583194732666,
0.05768724903464317,
0.6092749834060669,
-0.28160879015922546,
0.605467677116394,
-0.021097330376505852,
-0.931122362613678,
0.5439351201057434,
-0.2376141995191574,
0.12923495471477509,
0.25577062368392944,
0.36959293484687805,
-0.23587428033351898,
-0.07392037659883499,
-0.5714564919471741,
-0.43118026852607727,
0.24962002038955688,
0.06038707122206688,
-0.05510939285159111,
-0.37450751662254333,
0.4237793982028961,
-0.030470285564661026,
0.1234295517206192,
-0.5471131205558777,
0.11189085990190506,
0.21954065561294556,
0.14173901081085205,
0.04338903725147247,
-0.3723123371601105,
-0.09943564981222153,
-0.3338412344455719,
0.3168789744377136,
-0.07676884531974792,
0.06391322612762451,
0.40059569478034973,
-0.11234394460916519,
0.05322694778442383,
0.3515898585319519,
0.7245261669158936,
1.04076087474823,
-0.22862014174461365,
0.23964355885982513,
0.36333855986595154,
-0.014187043532729149,
0.277326762676239,
-0.1669250726699829,
-0.08147362619638443,
-0.1523626148700714,
0.7162787914276123,
0.5003284811973572,
0.07822214066982269,
-0.9389344453811646,
0.5071437358856201,
0.13900117576122284,
-0.25745531916618347,
-0.34109604358673096,
-0.0022498073522001505,
0.12425810843706131,
0.6197065114974976,
0.2028174102306366,
0.01938248984515667,
0.17511987686157227,
-0.7939043045043945,
-0.32407280802726746,
0.6729505658149719,
-0.02801194228231907,
-0.14340060949325562,
0.39799168705940247,
0.00996327679604292,
-0.38973909616470337,
0.8129739761352539,
-0.18581229448318481,
-0.570572018623352,
0.533923864364624,
0.7106598615646362,
0.7406457662582397,
0.001747454283758998,
0.15847206115722656,
0.22204963862895966,
0.1973082423210144,
-0.3634927272796631,
0.1579476147890091,
0.009559527970850468,
-0.9404878616333008,
-0.7087108492851257,
-0.4453738331794739,
-0.28721392154693604,
0.07474939525127411,
-0.44781920313835144,
0.09152807295322418,
-0.4440315067768097,
-0.23245073854923248,
0.021241677924990654,
0.007224283646792173,
-0.5795271992683411,
0.18319836258888245,
0.35474279522895813,
0.9962302446365356,
-0.5539947748184204,
0.548241913318634,
1.0275044441223145,
-0.4113331437110901,
-0.6732378005981445,
0.052411068230867386,
-0.09060191363096237,
-0.6185105443000793,
0.9539557099342346,
0.037896912544965744,
-0.5051681399345398,
-0.45425283908843994,
-0.6784660816192627,
-0.7804769277572632,
0.7804343700408936,
0.5932431817054749,
-0.44279220700263977,
0.07536708563566208,
0.02503686398267746,
0.6059957146644592,
-0.5357387661933899,
0.2782324254512787,
0.7137025594711304,
0.5282573103904724,
0.27688661217689514,
-0.8539314866065979,
0.29234030842781067,
0.16876626014709473,
0.07072603702545166,
-0.058350879698991776,
-0.5422869920730591,
0.8244740962982178,
-0.5075831413269043,
-0.04417687654495239,
0.08161970973014832,
0.45808467268943787,
0.49250027537345886,
0.24516622722148895,
0.6463661193847656,
0.5222175717353821,
0.8256019353866577,
0.17751426994800568,
1.0724478960037231,
0.10871011018753052,
0.0128618273884058,
1.0673491954803467,
-0.5953798890113831,
0.9513381123542786,
0.4108389616012573,
-0.24972717463970184,
0.8357167840003967,
0.5378261804580688,
0.07305566221475601,
0.4369087815284729,
0.6638123989105225,
0.036440491676330566,
-0.5779492259025574,
-0.09766495227813721,
-0.06319650262594223,
0.7858291268348694,
0.5290955305099487,
-0.30315038561820984,
-0.0014443036634474993,
-0.17713215947151184,
0.22825992107391357,
0.5709199905395508,
-0.37185847759246826,
0.7632957696914673,
0.07917343080043793,
-0.8750192523002625,
0.7610583901405334,
-0.02302107773721218,
0.6279315948486328,
-0.3343863785266876,
-0.1511322557926178,
-0.10176555067300797,
0.4799824357032776,
-0.24157120287418365,
-0.8510558605194092,
0.15891633927822113,
-0.015568990260362625,
-0.24704799056053162,
-0.02184387855231762,
0.6681014895439148,
0.08759936690330505,
-0.3583091199398041,
0.4274190664291382,
0.5370810031890869,
0.1545834243297577,
-0.2634381651878357,
-0.5634806752204895,
0.12982434034347534,
-0.09136796742677689,
-0.11997729539871216,
0.1027747243642807,
0.5863752961158752,
-0.38918381929397583,
0.8257644772529602,
0.48048534989356995,
0.0193391814827919,
-0.23277121782302856,
0.25496309995651245,
0.6134345531463623,
-0.7587201595306396,
-0.050227090716362,
-1.4677808284759521,
0.239604651927948,
-0.17620378732681274,
-0.18111221492290497,
0.9065525531768799,
0.3172997832298279,
0.8421221375465393,
-0.08076804131269455,
0.5730994343757629,
0.1360546499490738,
0.45915448665618896,
-0.564157247543335,
-0.05507549270987511,
-0.3625319302082062,
0.4670912027359009,
-0.4201798439025879,
-0.8836807608604431,
-0.19130124151706696,
1.0034645795822144,
-0.638049840927124,
0.033384934067726135,
0.6644790172576904,
0.6069005727767944,
0.19280657172203064,
0.11659739166498184,
0.21783913671970367,
0.373031347990036,
0.23932938277721405,
0.6876908540725708,
1.3957539796829224,
0.0328032560646534,
0.2398577183485031,
-0.12366965413093567,
-0.26029446721076965,
-0.1440351903438568,
-1.0910049676895142,
-1.1133077144622803,
-0.2399110645055771,
-0.3045341372489929,
-0.3292553424835205,
-0.17068850994110107,
1.1410735845565796,
0.45855069160461426,
-0.4305538535118103,
-0.5682834386825562,
-0.07011254876852036,
0.2658003866672516,
-0.4760320484638214,
-0.17189645767211914,
0.20527900755405426,
-0.20935675501823425,
-0.33671045303344727,
0.3924957811832428,
0.24327780306339264,
-0.11389505118131638,
-0.2841326594352722,
-0.10848620533943176,
-0.30840855836868286,
0.3429129123687744,
0.8529083728790283,
-0.1213475912809372,
-1.045270562171936,
-0.27084439992904663,
0.08387944847345352,
-0.1731298416852951,
0.008729865774512291,
0.7323018312454224,
-0.8704219460487366,
0.25494056940078735,
0.5660431981086731,
0.37581074237823486,
0.17504779994487762,
-0.07329151034355164,
0.6432387828826904,
-0.06520666927099228,
-0.006064167711883783,
0.244749516248703,
0.40232330560684204,
0.5434430837631226,
-0.33160829544067383,
0.6756139993667603,
0.13261325657367706,
-0.6931332945823669,
-0.6312181949615479,
0.35175782442092896,
-0.7656204104423523,
-0.5084198713302612,
1.1822518110275269,
0.06190784275531769,
-0.08252421021461487,
0.007160082925111055,
-0.31424611806869507,
-0.06532662361860275,
-0.2709847688674927,
0.677634596824646,
0.9053730368614197,
-0.37115684151649475,
0.206496000289917,
-0.4740722179412842,
0.4225752651691437,
0.4425217807292938,
-0.42336633801460266,
0.08985661715269089,
0.4063701629638672,
0.15857289731502533,
0.25352954864501953,
0.5162628293037415,
0.03856561705470085,
0.07556241750717163,
-0.1487247496843338,
-0.3078826069831848,
0.29219380021095276,
-0.09032372385263443,
-0.3199462294578552,
0.006656593643128872,
0.37354615330696106,
-0.10632726550102234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12976v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12976v2 | The Impact of Demonstrations on Multilingual In-Context Learning: A Multidimensional Analysis | 2024-02-20T12:53:31 | 2024-06-07T13:44:07 | Miaoran Zhang, Vagrant Gautam, Mingyang Wang, Jesujoba O. Alabi, Xiaoyu Shen, Dietrich Klakow, Marius Mosbach | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-context learning is a popular inference strategy where large language
models solve a task using only a few labeled demonstrations without needing any
parameter updates. Although there have been extensive studies on English
in-context learning, multilingual in-context learning remains under-explored,
and we lack an in-depth understanding of the role of demonstrations in this
context. To address this gap, we conduct a multidimensional analysis of
multilingual in-context learning, experimenting with 5 models from different
model families, 9 datasets covering classification and generation tasks, and 56
typologically diverse languages. Our results reveal that the effectiveness of
demonstrations varies significantly across models, tasks, and languages. We
also find that strong instruction-following models including Llama 2-Chat,
GPT-3.5, and GPT-4 are largely insensitive to the quality of demonstrations.
Instead, a carefully crafted template often eliminates the benefits of
demonstrations for some tasks and languages altogether. These findings show
that the importance of demonstrations might be overestimated. Our work
highlights the need for granular evaluation across multiple axes towards a
better understanding of in-context learning. | [
-0.40468597412109375,
-0.6687504649162292,
0.2894588112831116,
0.5384877324104309,
-0.08656724542379379,
-0.11158447712659836,
-0.20826105773448944,
-0.21900629997253418,
-0.24148783087730408,
-0.12006494402885437,
-0.24063485860824585,
-0.36751633882522583,
-0.5479574799537659,
0.0009183500078506768,
-0.37057623267173767,
0.981023371219635,
-0.14888177812099457,
0.215753436088562,
-0.6991643905639648,
-0.18071727454662323,
-0.4803820252418518,
-0.6113119125366211,
-0.5830703973770142,
-0.5274018049240112,
0.468451589345932,
0.7024739980697632,
0.15306708216667175,
0.1876809298992157,
-0.22933873534202576,
0.2800421416759491,
0.04315468296408653,
0.21873986721038818,
-0.40535157918930054,
-0.03777499869465828,
-0.08640719205141068,
-0.35142800211906433,
-0.09369777143001556,
0.11431672424077988,
0.8448718190193176,
0.8806455135345459,
0.05566224828362465,
-0.00179872231092304,
0.43017464876174927,
0.3143385052680969,
-0.5554057955741882,
0.2523784041404724,
-0.15704786777496338,
0.12808862328529358,
-0.05676424503326416,
-0.046740978956222534,
-0.5432145595550537,
-0.11119316518306732,
0.287148118019104,
-0.4828680753707886,
-0.1357627958059311,
-0.3029320538043976,
0.45434871315956116,
-0.12388220429420471,
-0.989045262336731,
-0.3867103159427643,
-0.6812083721160889,
0.9209983944892883,
-0.4879780411720276,
0.3343556821346283,
0.26521754264831543,
0.3808654546737671,
-0.11795655637979507,
-0.7792046070098877,
-0.4176708161830902,
-0.32541581988334656,
-0.1687164008617401,
0.4261291027069092,
-0.16533347964286804,
-0.16048002243041992,
0.37831005454063416,
-0.051785726100206375,
-0.2646539509296417,
0.411614328622818,
-0.25959494709968567,
-0.09652722626924515,
0.22668838500976562,
0.030803171917796135,
0.27824169397354126,
-0.28720441460609436,
-0.5534998178482056,
-0.3169620633125305,
-0.8052382469177246,
0.47468990087509155,
0.5627301931381226,
0.2449096441268921,
-0.46760424971580505,
0.2720031142234802,
-0.04109691455960274,
0.5473994016647339,
-0.035870421677827835,
-0.44311845302581787,
0.17568424344062805,
-0.32242774963378906,
-0.13065312802791595,
-0.23745866119861603,
0.6646695137023926,
0.19571997225284576,
-0.07663106173276901,
-0.11374060064554214,
-0.09398126602172852,
-0.2694171071052551,
0.024341247975826263,
-0.9807319045066833,
0.13286763429641724,
0.1019594743847847,
-0.5214738249778748,
0.06502442061901093,
0.11400466412305832,
-0.9965969920158386,
-0.23142066597938538,
-0.28128671646118164,
0.8640388250350952,
-0.3708648085594177,
-0.4095545709133148,
0.0022650156170129776,
-0.3132963478565216,
0.040225863456726074,
0.37130337953567505,
-0.6999610066413879,
0.28522974252700806,
0.5546878576278687,
0.5888700485229492,
-0.09258132427930832,
-0.9375501275062561,
-0.5506328344345093,
0.15798766911029816,
-0.271648108959198,
0.7842261791229248,
-0.4782413840293884,
-0.503099262714386,
0.20274962484836578,
0.11989035457372665,
-0.4683075249195099,
-0.41903671622276306,
0.0802396759390831,
0.020647099241614342,
0.4854164719581604,
-0.49654123187065125,
-0.6852306127548218,
-0.449270635843277,
0.25847429037094116,
-0.47226062417030334,
0.6250356435775757,
-0.11712654680013657,
-0.5317727327346802,
0.7125118374824524,
-0.7238758206367493,
-0.6595937609672546,
-0.13355277478694916,
-0.37747272849082947,
-0.34599339962005615,
0.01135119516402483,
0.2571236789226532,
0.6599576473236084,
0.1465975046157837,
0.1095263808965683,
0.05741719901561737,
-0.4899810552597046,
0.1889827698469162,
-0.7418822646141052,
0.4728637933731079,
-0.1506595015525818,
-0.8046337366104126,
0.06759531795978546,
-0.5494904518127441,
-0.3027966022491455,
0.02404612861573696,
-0.3983263671398163,
-0.33718204498291016,
0.16790872812271118,
-0.16303293406963348,
0.396769642829895,
-0.11168184131383896,
-0.35187608003616333,
0.17395737767219543,
-0.3136647641658783,
0.1813240349292755,
0.4338277578353882,
0.1734033077955246,
0.4207572638988495,
-0.24985861778259277,
0.7484998106956482,
0.14257538318634033,
0.19379985332489014,
-0.5527653694152832,
-0.5054977536201477,
-0.3613519072532654,
-0.30048516392707825,
0.06299563497304916,
0.11458209902048111,
-0.7962667942047119,
-0.6135719418525696,
-0.15278948843479156,
-0.42178040742874146,
-0.11128537356853485,
0.13034319877624512,
0.7753021121025085,
0.4191254675388336,
0.10760895907878876,
-0.09667474776506424,
-0.1225210577249527,
-0.9264009594917297,
-0.08610182255506516,
-0.014196990989148617,
0.20056457817554474,
0.26031097769737244,
0.6542027592658997,
-0.040983330458402634,
0.3493894040584564,
0.24429167807102203,
-0.044429317116737366,
-0.5750733613967896,
0.2788872718811035,
-0.13529597222805023,
0.3058255612850189,
0.8981966972351074,
-0.7414279580116272,
-0.6606437563896179,
0.33342865109443665,
-0.5795722603797913,
0.0944674089550972,
-0.4399225413799286,
0.1242750808596611,
0.13539081811904907,
0.5028789043426514,
-0.39345407485961914,
0.4251061677932739,
0.5501681566238403,
0.06535771489143372,
0.620279848575592,
-0.5084226727485657,
0.3806311786174774,
-0.883905291557312,
-0.4042622745037079,
0.07423495501279831,
0.04234463721513748,
-0.8439269661903381,
0.24074819684028625,
0.4535450339317322,
0.026988010853528976,
-0.7807528376579285,
0.671898603439331,
-0.28755319118499756,
-0.14931930601596832,
-0.18733495473861694,
0.16937188804149628,
0.29741403460502625,
0.5242301821708679,
0.06394229084253311,
0.9371598958969116,
0.6615279316902161,
-0.6274453997612,
-0.1636497527360916,
0.044926226139068604,
-0.44904807209968567,
0.6231710314750671,
-0.3659333884716034,
-0.03030376322567463,
-0.0555681474506855,
0.3166697919368744,
-1.0724101066589355,
-0.3736632168292999,
-0.010668974369764328,
-0.03174589201807976,
0.43875986337661743,
-0.14129605889320374,
-0.5295059680938721,
-0.03642481192946434,
-0.44341805577278137,
0.19182024896144867,
0.10237333178520203,
-0.9875849485397339,
0.5249065160751343,
0.14963451027870178,
0.1781710535287857,
-0.6425948143005371,
-0.3944302499294281,
-0.14830449223518372,
-0.6864691376686096,
-0.281984806060791,
0.2503178119659424,
0.0757359117269516,
-0.42726367712020874,
-0.6979281902313232,
0.03706901893019676,
0.18130788207054138,
0.17090022563934326,
0.31081902980804443,
-0.35039547085762024,
0.020069316029548645,
0.3927389979362488,
0.38635146617889404,
0.2067974954843521,
0.12235530465841293,
0.04069402441382408,
0.44200417399406433,
-0.23366715013980865,
-0.8236579298973083,
-0.5347059965133667,
0.6171239614486694,
0.6148298978805542,
-0.15173882246017456,
0.6678284406661987,
0.5680506825447083,
-0.21828143298625946,
-0.11194748431444168,
-0.19136059284210205,
0.026189526543021202,
-0.4027967154979706,
0.5353108048439026,
-0.43781644105911255,
-0.3287704586982727,
0.4996982514858246,
-0.28754156827926636,
0.16010983288288116,
0.20429769158363342,
0.47569674253463745,
-0.1181977167725563,
1.2333104610443115,
0.444623202085495,
0.21809323132038116,
0.5094660520553589,
-0.4310835301876068,
0.06759049743413925,
-0.6745406985282898,
-0.5205545425415039,
-0.4244841933250427,
-0.18365894258022308,
-0.33879244327545166,
-0.1823457032442093,
0.528479814529419,
-0.010447420179843903,
-0.14233340322971344,
0.16605040431022644,
0.11150527745485306,
0.353359580039978,
0.5623953342437744,
0.182095006108284,
0.00580925727263093,
0.048850107938051224,
-0.2768848240375519,
-0.1302713304758072,
-0.7773445248603821,
-0.5279688835144043,
0.9525706171989441,
0.23453928530216217,
0.5274794101715088,
0.41135528683662415,
0.6322253346443176,
-0.12483850866556168,
0.3716347813606262,
-0.6844786405563354,
0.19604338705539703,
-0.1748301386833191,
-0.05667657405138016,
-0.1358664631843567,
-0.11521784216165543,
-1.0642703771591187,
0.5075268149375916,
0.07298325002193451,
-0.6261535286903381,
0.2265719771385193,
0.16682231426239014,
-0.12186982482671738,
0.22942231595516205,
-1.2581878900527954,
1.134518027305603,
-0.3144739866256714,
-0.4726787805557251,
-0.345210999250412,
-0.47254815697669983,
0.1978733092546463,
0.014923026785254478,
0.6341728568077087,
0.5926093459129333,
0.21250082552433014,
0.6029373407363892,
-0.04878593981266022,
1.290794849395752,
-0.42704829573631287,
-0.4194003939628601,
0.012091054581105709,
0.10502998530864716,
0.42246583104133606,
-0.018125245347619057,
0.1635444164276123,
-0.07433341443538666,
-0.03378704562783241,
-0.4129832684993744,
-0.6648069024085999,
0.7356688380241394,
-0.6124826073646545,
-0.5717943906784058,
0.12269645929336548,
-0.5264478325843811,
-0.25296297669410706,
-0.30966779589653015,
0.26845070719718933,
0.9937666058540344,
-0.09825371950864792,
0.14558513462543488,
0.5206530094146729,
-0.5224453806877136,
0.5746016502380371,
0.2940724194049835,
-0.18167828023433685,
0.02592744119465351,
1.0907576084136963,
0.24272318184375763,
0.7847504019737244,
0.3860364258289337,
0.41651520133018494,
-0.33117762207984924,
-0.4341091513633728,
-0.5671873688697815,
0.08898243308067322,
-1.2033088207244873,
0.19468872249126434,
-0.6499812602996826,
0.3597200810909271,
-0.21611501276493073,
-0.09291504323482513,
-0.0861460492014885,
-0.30311551690101624,
-0.23372243344783783,
-0.14904995262622833,
-0.07693617790937424,
1.1302186250686646,
-0.0036384984850883484,
0.5726532340049744,
-0.3057369589805603,
-0.032502878457307816,
0.7727762460708618,
0.009201380424201488,
0.45844408869743347,
-0.34632062911987305,
-0.3373732268810272,
0.06426443159580231,
-0.5985851883888245,
-0.8519131541252136,
0.21273748576641083,
0.548964262008667,
1.006201982498169,
0.7843378782272339,
-0.42743122577667236,
0.9893750548362732,
-0.5467865467071533,
1.049093246459961,
-0.0868636891245842,
-0.972169041633606,
0.4139760136604309,
-0.21330250799655914,
0.2976088523864746,
-0.04495636001229286,
0.507925808429718,
-0.5619608759880066,
-0.541495680809021,
-0.5090424418449402,
-0.7373459339141846,
0.5540106892585754,
-0.2125004380941391,
0.4671972990036011,
-0.2636164724826813,
0.03849482163786888,
0.5890609622001648,
0.25826698541641235,
-0.8328180909156799,
-0.16969190537929535,
-0.5357034206390381,
0.2807319164276123,
-0.09986459463834763,
-0.18698784708976746,
-0.19251689314842224,
-0.30610355734825134,
0.4132941663265228,
-0.27879753708839417,
0.14049546420574188,
-0.16216492652893066,
-0.43412846326828003,
0.24080003798007965,
0.27038469910621643,
1.0582181215286255,
0.8638310432434082,
0.19300788640975952,
0.12253133952617645,
0.2858465611934662,
-0.20155727863311768,
-0.04939235746860504,
-0.056257184594869614,
0.1954977661371231,
-0.05740414932370186,
0.691625714302063,
1.0344806909561157,
0.7092224955558777,
-0.6220458745956421,
0.7823023796081543,
0.028243206441402435,
-0.22816774249076843,
-0.17081935703754425,
-0.19310356676578522,
-0.04198450595140457,
0.4591153860092163,
0.3319936990737915,
-0.044212110340595245,
0.15731759369373322,
-0.6179269552230835,
0.08619431406259537,
0.47139066457748413,
-0.3017008304595947,
-0.4712218940258026,
0.5373339056968689,
-0.19401629269123077,
-0.2836434841156006,
0.15138894319534302,
-0.27617329359054565,
-0.5243155360221863,
0.8027402758598328,
0.6706182956695557,
0.3593685030937195,
-0.20465488731861115,
0.44484052062034607,
0.2852245271205902,
0.12992160022258759,
-0.059873033314943314,
-0.03462455794215202,
-0.29740190505981445,
-0.4667360782623291,
-0.6123020052909851,
-0.05688406527042389,
-0.6126057505607605,
0.0919274091720581,
-0.7203665971755981,
0.17855311930179596,
0.10669336467981339,
0.25870680809020996,
0.027168333530426025,
-0.2154371589422226,
-0.6517120003700256,
-0.16881904006004333,
0.09712379425764084,
0.7925314903259277,
-1.1524070501327515,
0.6473222970962524,
0.7414434552192688,
-0.2897142767906189,
-0.5967000126838684,
0.17651714384555817,
0.033311910927295685,
-0.4005768299102783,
0.8545763492584229,
0.4761843681335449,
-0.04246976599097252,
-0.14397987723350525,
-0.31403979659080505,
-0.44814160466194153,
0.8348458409309387,
0.46047788858413696,
0.025912785902619362,
0.29539260268211365,
-0.017282461747527122,
0.5482738614082336,
-0.6272994875907898,
0.5183270573616028,
0.15317317843437195,
0.41366246342658997,
-0.2312059998512268,
-0.8935666084289551,
-0.429823100566864,
-0.004092122428119183,
-0.07998557388782501,
-0.20758092403411865,
-0.6634092926979065,
0.7976712584495544,
-0.14355428516864777,
-0.22103965282440186,
-0.030672214925289154,
0.4711819589138031,
0.18115627765655518,
0.4052262306213379,
0.5040866732597351,
-0.0223437137901783,
0.504743754863739,
-0.0725778266787529,
1.412297248840332,
0.2305525243282318,
0.12895144522190094,
0.9042985439300537,
-0.29245394468307495,
0.8282357454299927,
0.7463834881782532,
-0.14620403945446014,
0.706963300704956,
0.6037858128547668,
0.44817161560058594,
0.5285196900367737,
-0.06824259459972382,
-0.22044207155704498,
-0.25858891010284424,
0.014894891530275345,
-0.1809665709733963,
0.5653966069221497,
0.5764575600624084,
-0.04341419041156769,
-0.5422255992889404,
0.7526543736457825,
0.029246671125292778,
0.2618406414985657,
-0.24704255163669586,
0.6897238492965698,
-0.32545506954193115,
-0.5618199706077576,
0.5105971097946167,
-0.4268118739128113,
0.5082834362983704,
-0.49019721150398254,
-0.39577189087867737,
-0.28879308700561523,
0.06069858372211456,
-0.05433070287108421,
-0.501040518283844,
-0.03808752819895744,
-0.26172035932540894,
0.044407542794942856,
-0.5153502225875854,
0.11151156574487686,
-0.4936821758747101,
-0.16547690331935883,
0.5543150901794434,
0.6808668971061707,
0.3837943375110626,
0.04934012144804001,
-0.26627689599990845,
-0.33179935812950134,
-0.10614153742790222,
-0.34138989448547363,
0.8328786492347717,
0.5639071464538574,
-0.32335376739501953,
0.5550928711891174,
0.2312450110912323,
-0.3786402642726898,
0.193990558385849,
0.558494508266449,
0.6608657240867615,
0.048430848866701126,
-0.1816868931055069,
-0.7759125828742981,
0.690599262714386,
0.02810627967119217,
-0.19609449803829193,
1.0556256771087646,
0.45687177777290344,
1.1331148147583008,
-0.3119562864303589,
0.6358112096786499,
0.21891462802886963,
0.3101184666156769,
-0.5535457134246826,
0.4969162940979004,
-0.9192200899124146,
0.16159580647945404,
-0.3895665109157562,
-0.37925514578819275,
-0.031165404245257378,
0.3659074902534485,
-0.23480942845344543,
0.011329766362905502,
0.7432992458343506,
0.48259371519088745,
-0.3055420219898224,
-0.03104024939239025,
0.5698871612548828,
0.028973501175642014,
0.45685797929763794,
0.204510897397995,
1.1005570888519287,
-0.2982602119445801,
0.4278580844402313,
-0.6001278162002563,
-0.25384321808815,
0.06621239334344864,
-0.9862112998962402,
-1.0747015476226807,
-0.8304926753044128,
-0.2379075586795807,
0.05832436680793762,
-0.16642235219478607,
0.9100387096405029,
0.6813898086547852,
-0.5484088659286499,
-0.5929992198944092,
0.3421395421028137,
0.17080672085285187,
-0.891194760799408,
-0.19667263329029083,
0.5132884383201599,
-0.5592648983001709,
-1.1065541505813599,
0.6965466737747192,
0.08191218972206116,
0.1380327045917511,
-0.242816761136055,
-0.028999699279665947,
-0.24725328385829926,
-0.330705463886261,
0.9547533392906189,
0.18910537660121918,
-0.7654814124107361,
-0.2624456286430359,
-0.0557887963950634,
0.2755354642868042,
0.018857132643461227,
0.6939332485198975,
-0.7275516390800476,
0.5619906783103943,
0.08824709057807922,
0.47102704644203186,
0.4938366413116455,
-0.3247840702533722,
0.5787246227264404,
-1.1730425357818604,
0.4879434108734131,
-0.31604334712028503,
0.6551260948181152,
0.4216834008693695,
-0.07007919251918793,
-0.014751219190657139,
0.049525439739227295,
-0.4182690680027008,
-0.7231248021125793,
0.29303640127182007,
-0.43608665466308594,
-0.33226218819618225,
1.2916256189346313,
-0.3565739393234253,
-0.02512899972498417,
-0.13071246445178986,
-0.2563287615776062,
0.06872085481882095,
-0.09799659252166748,
0.7901239395141602,
0.7491047382354736,
-0.12188611924648285,
-0.3137207627296448,
-1.0274991989135742,
0.3048675060272217,
0.2796704173088074,
-0.7464147210121155,
0.017879460006952286,
0.2653602361679077,
0.06028049439191818,
0.10590998083353043,
0.12782205641269684,
0.027376526966691017,
0.39007142186164856,
-0.27111443877220154,
-0.04029487818479538,
0.05155975744128227,
-0.5478881001472473,
-0.7321706414222717,
0.2999197542667389,
-0.023193733766674995,
-0.15680725872516632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12969v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12969v1 | GlórIA -- A Generative and Open Large Language Model for Portuguese | 2024-02-20T12:36:40 | 2024-02-20T12:36:40 | Ricardo Lopes, João Magalhães, David Semedo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Significant strides have been made in natural language tasks, largely
attributed to the emergence of powerful large language models (LLMs). These
models, pre-trained on extensive and diverse corpora, have become increasingly
capable of comprehending the intricacies of language. Despite the abundance of
LLMs for many high-resource languages, the availability of such models remains
limited for European Portuguese. We introduce Gl\'orIA, a robust European
Portuguese decoder LLM. To pre-train Gl\'orIA, we assembled a comprehensive
PT-PT text corpus comprising 35 billion tokens from various sources. We present
our pre-training methodology, followed by an assessment of the model's
effectiveness on multiple downstream tasks. Additionally, to evaluate our
models' language modeling capabilities, we introduce CALAME-PT (Context-Aware
LAnguage Modeling Evaluation for Portuguese), the first Portuguese zero-shot
language-modeling benchmark. Evaluation shows that Gl\'orIA significantly
outperforms existing open PT decoder models in language modeling and that it
can generate sound, knowledge-rich, and coherent PT-PT text. The model also
exhibits strong potential for various downstream tasks. | [
0.13250771164894104,
-0.6529309749603271,
0.24661491811275482,
0.19235926866531372,
-0.4307554364204407,
-0.23031361401081085,
-0.34859001636505127,
-0.6323367357254028,
0.002882313681766391,
0.7262795567512512,
-0.2553401291370392,
-0.7495248913764954,
-0.6463619470596313,
0.21460705995559692,
-0.6763618588447571,
0.8859757781028748,
-0.0005204683402553201,
0.401792049407959,
0.400255024433136,
-0.06529943645000458,
-0.2418196201324463,
-0.6113433837890625,
-0.9162285327911377,
-0.12191545218229294,
0.350094735622406,
0.055802274495363235,
0.540106475353241,
0.8344526290893555,
0.2844071090221405,
0.3205472528934479,
-0.08884722739458084,
-0.035623837262392044,
-0.9036983847618103,
0.0855914056301117,
-0.21695880591869354,
-0.6933659911155701,
-0.6304724812507629,
-0.13535599410533905,
0.7752722501754761,
0.7478341460227966,
0.03175002709031105,
-0.018138322979211807,
0.14817631244659424,
0.2857794165611267,
-0.5080987811088562,
0.45898157358169556,
-0.7271836996078491,
-0.04352330043911934,
-0.22367486357688904,
-0.17754632234573364,
-0.39656373858451843,
-0.39440253376960754,
0.2291468232870102,
-0.6226966977119446,
0.04060398042201996,
-0.1966475248336792,
0.8266547918319702,
0.2591342031955719,
-0.3498486578464508,
-0.5488021373748779,
-1.008273959159851,
0.8621102571487427,
-0.30736780166625977,
0.6105769276618958,
0.015611646696925163,
0.2463667392730713,
-0.12632018327713013,
-0.43262121081352234,
-0.3471732437610626,
-0.6055125594139099,
0.36505070328712463,
0.12118306756019592,
-0.2520618140697479,
-0.005899842828512192,
-0.04794441908597946,
0.3952557146549225,
-0.511540412902832,
0.22333954274654388,
-0.48353439569473267,
-0.04918768256902695,
0.11756288260221481,
-0.07171493768692017,
0.21799449622631073,
0.08884802460670471,
-0.4261241853237152,
-0.011378571391105652,
-1.264133095741272,
-0.21287234127521515,
0.6765626668930054,
0.6068596243858337,
-0.19060520827770233,
0.6395971179008484,
0.08870405703783035,
0.9233109354972839,
-0.38464897871017456,
-0.5553788542747498,
0.03755656257271767,
-0.21731802821159363,
-0.46143248677253723,
0.14160777628421783,
0.7547199130058289,
-0.250703364610672,
0.5014764070510864,
-0.2221139818429947,
-0.14554938673973083,
0.35393404960632324,
0.16593672335147858,
-0.8481266498565674,
0.18067720532417297,
0.12648706138134003,
-0.3949580192565918,
-0.2386462539434433,
-0.017849314957857132,
-0.37056615948677063,
-0.23007334768772125,
-0.42392924427986145,
0.23508000373840332,
-0.6971500515937805,
-0.1291717290878296,
0.5278136730194092,
0.2579312324523926,
0.303775429725647,
0.36792054772377014,
-0.7492529153823853,
0.09153018146753311,
0.7527374029159546,
0.48918646574020386,
-0.07622610032558441,
-0.2896884083747864,
-0.5781534314155579,
0.033497557044029236,
-0.5335463881492615,
0.5744745135307312,
-0.5287426710128784,
-0.6145273447036743,
0.46088144183158875,
0.06430202722549438,
-0.03975469991564751,
-0.4352050721645355,
1.010866403579712,
-0.5144789814949036,
0.47151780128479004,
-0.11818446964025497,
-0.2967066168785095,
-0.1904725730419159,
0.26416513323783875,
-0.4900660216808319,
0.7857059240341187,
0.27103766798973083,
-0.7841183543205261,
0.42197683453559875,
-0.5066633224487305,
-0.2206568419933319,
0.11770837754011154,
-0.16478630900382996,
-0.010508257895708084,
0.20425570011138916,
0.049561627209186554,
0.2578504979610443,
-0.4930192530155182,
0.23446443676948547,
-0.21153274178504944,
-0.3886494040489197,
0.10704412311315536,
-0.6438747644424438,
0.818519115447998,
0.4346596300601959,
0.031725965440273285,
0.05341446027159691,
-0.814064621925354,
-0.5207617282867432,
0.04648023843765259,
-0.7202826738357544,
-0.38921141624450684,
-0.03132070600986481,
0.09061175584793091,
0.04152565822005272,
0.4736728072166443,
-0.6124210357666016,
0.35080528259277344,
-0.7830614447593689,
0.5410493016242981,
0.3445742726325989,
-0.4799259603023529,
0.5194531083106995,
0.027358675375580788,
0.7152309417724609,
-0.002374609000980854,
0.13145746290683746,
-0.34130534529685974,
-0.40950724482536316,
-0.9397872686386108,
-0.3342316746711731,
0.440941721200943,
0.6608333587646484,
-0.8943870663642883,
0.31145691871643066,
-0.4695233404636383,
-0.4798649549484253,
-0.747078537940979,
0.11469190567731857,
0.6495353579521179,
0.5005731582641602,
0.11056952178478241,
-0.6154686212539673,
-0.5170431733131409,
-0.6830836534500122,
0.2148798108100891,
-0.30435872077941895,
-0.2655447721481323,
0.1685371696949005,
0.46410882472991943,
-0.1773710995912552,
0.8510376811027527,
-0.09200228005647659,
-0.46367746591567993,
-0.536483883857727,
0.12056861072778702,
0.411208838224411,
0.18892011046409607,
0.6872239112854004,
-0.5318361520767212,
-0.250047892332077,
0.03186362609267235,
-0.753250241279602,
-0.31469017267227173,
0.2567649185657501,
0.05243714898824692,
0.4625280201435089,
0.4213844835758209,
-0.25867149233818054,
0.08200269937515259,
0.8703758716583252,
-0.15218672156333923,
0.6138158440589905,
-0.7052701115608215,
0.057236019521951675,
-1.13185453414917,
0.23999370634555817,
-0.06060471758246422,
-0.2320452779531479,
-0.6054670810699463,
0.07190855592489243,
-0.04647361487150192,
-0.2845931947231293,
-0.8602701425552368,
0.4381699562072754,
-0.4160631597042084,
-0.3012160360813141,
-0.3245704174041748,
0.07546912133693695,
-0.14913293719291687,
0.18135981261730194,
0.4957024157047272,
0.7511533498764038,
0.8941873908042908,
-0.4633692800998688,
0.22586306929588318,
0.10866481065750122,
-0.3180573582649231,
0.6812281608581543,
-0.826906681060791,
-0.07885118573904037,
-0.40235447883605957,
0.2492692917585373,
-0.8466712832450867,
-0.1712983101606369,
0.27736896276474,
-0.27247029542922974,
0.4903945326805115,
-0.5449365973472595,
-0.46308067440986633,
-0.35346898436546326,
-0.1048428937792778,
0.40908652544021606,
0.18369126319885254,
-0.5313711762428284,
0.6210925579071045,
0.4366825819015503,
-0.2705473005771637,
-0.5021557211875916,
-0.45957496762275696,
0.3083159923553467,
-0.37770339846611023,
-0.6785718202590942,
0.35465240478515625,
0.062169477343559265,
-0.022343486547470093,
-0.16923081874847412,
0.42673787474632263,
-0.19800741970539093,
-0.02893667295575142,
0.19732874631881714,
0.41346240043640137,
-0.5370526313781738,
0.14230899512767792,
-0.18759393692016602,
-0.40522459149360657,
-0.055291417986154556,
-0.6812832355499268,
0.7676568627357483,
-0.2828843593597412,
-0.26528066396713257,
-0.18222199380397797,
0.25793755054473877,
0.6645685434341431,
-0.448777437210083,
0.6811844110488892,
0.4309319853782654,
-0.16994452476501465,
-0.05173468217253685,
-0.3541370928287506,
0.26128658652305603,
-0.39396581053733826,
0.3873133957386017,
-0.32837238907814026,
-1.1763263940811157,
0.4243704080581665,
0.09356909245252609,
0.06945934146642685,
0.2802307903766632,
0.7916253805160522,
0.3212616741657257,
0.8805524706840515,
1.1460016965866089,
-0.5154885649681091,
0.5470237135887146,
-0.17688371241092682,
0.06118423864245415,
-0.29378896951675415,
0.10125057399272919,
-0.9603530168533325,
0.2616446614265442,
-0.5919144153594971,
-0.5526126623153687,
0.5093920230865479,
0.10592280328273773,
-0.20514927804470062,
0.5844253897666931,
-0.3774634301662445,
0.4015403687953949,
0.5945921540260315,
-0.3845698833465576,
0.5464500188827515,
0.014994792640209198,
-0.0377407968044281,
0.24752859771251678,
-0.6324003338813782,
-0.8123936653137207,
1.2002103328704834,
0.4450876712799072,
1.0200129747390747,
-0.07481426000595093,
0.6222665905952454,
-0.1037849634885788,
0.3980523347854614,
-0.602837324142456,
0.3430529534816742,
-0.3845893442630768,
-0.575717568397522,
-0.047698698937892914,
-0.3803684711456299,
-1.2625370025634766,
0.26363998651504517,
-0.16116781532764435,
-0.8336970806121826,
-0.09914706647396088,
0.16035692393779755,
-0.4974154531955719,
0.0888434499502182,
-0.661840558052063,
0.9943988919258118,
-0.22465498745441437,
-0.08623006194829941,
0.034665029495954514,
-0.47021758556365967,
0.44719940423965454,
-0.06709346920251846,
0.2000899314880371,
0.11457368731498718,
-0.2124810516834259,
0.4733727276325226,
-0.16751383244991302,
0.7644432783126831,
0.1236734613776207,
-0.5908519625663757,
0.49376747012138367,
0.10062316805124283,
0.2676118016242981,
-0.0790281668305397,
-0.032674554735422134,
0.23457476496696472,
0.07510089129209518,
-0.2113238275051117,
-0.05291847512125969,
0.6085631251335144,
-0.9219668507575989,
-0.022503769025206566,
-0.3804517090320587,
-0.4163309335708618,
-0.009886539541184902,
0.09586255252361298,
0.39575716853141785,
0.5638192892074585,
-0.5625410079956055,
-0.008708005771040916,
0.6946173310279846,
-0.5821176171302795,
0.2800487279891968,
0.8877738118171692,
-0.41444286704063416,
-0.38169175386428833,
0.9681500792503357,
-0.08448611199855804,
0.11999254673719406,
0.6071799397468567,
0.019795328378677368,
-0.4246234893798828,
-0.590608537197113,
-0.5737659931182861,
0.4101269841194153,
-0.3569651246070862,
0.062458038330078125,
-0.5372320413589478,
-0.058734867721796036,
-0.4768766164779663,
-0.08467403799295425,
-0.551811158657074,
-0.06232143193483353,
-0.38983815908432007,
0.08872516453266144,
-0.05866203084588051,
0.9891604781150818,
-0.11699984222650528,
0.3975309431552887,
-0.9099791646003723,
0.18229573965072632,
0.20906563103199005,
0.10222716629505157,
-0.2873579263687134,
-0.47586870193481445,
-0.06081309914588928,
-0.024140050634741783,
-0.18549183011054993,
-0.9908557534217834,
0.8420717716217041,
0.025999242439866066,
0.3124178349971771,
0.8164976239204407,
-0.3607264459133148,
0.15507134795188904,
-0.4558700621128082,
0.6919087767601013,
0.04106635972857475,
-0.7335488200187683,
0.47576355934143066,
-0.8540602326393127,
0.19730782508850098,
0.33121925592422485,
0.44813019037246704,
-0.35470977425575256,
-0.46090275049209595,
-0.48938482999801636,
-0.7689749002456665,
0.642516553401947,
0.13345548510551453,
0.1693551242351532,
-0.19502535462379456,
0.035110365599393845,
0.18209302425384521,
0.3918081820011139,
-0.8860616683959961,
0.19522398710250854,
-0.07782275229692459,
0.08530954271554947,
-0.18118949234485626,
-0.39002811908721924,
0.24712474644184113,
0.08465763926506042,
0.761979877948761,
-0.14339374005794525,
0.27367064356803894,
-0.1187133714556694,
-0.1273295134305954,
-0.13584114611148834,
0.4477793574333191,
0.5949287414550781,
0.5663512945175171,
-0.26268336176872253,
-0.00994526781141758,
0.22009609639644623,
-0.41244643926620483,
-0.21435441076755524,
0.35754334926605225,
-0.3389894664287567,
0.039373598992824554,
0.26292693614959717,
0.46819648146629333,
0.35679465532302856,
-0.7088831663131714,
0.39511311054229736,
-0.1842513531446457,
0.09703642129898071,
-0.32561495900154114,
-0.06001181900501251,
0.17433278262615204,
0.014720724895596504,
0.06652664393186569,
-0.36682501435279846,
-0.043632037937641144,
-0.7785550951957703,
-0.3040110170841217,
0.3460773229598999,
-0.7293534278869629,
-0.36428552865982056,
0.7281332015991211,
0.2621949315071106,
-0.1839984655380249,
0.4376855492591858,
-0.22797755897045135,
-0.6283908486366272,
0.30308061838150024,
0.40849268436431885,
0.7448934316635132,
-0.35355424880981445,
0.19481773674488068,
0.239670068025589,
0.29926034808158875,
-0.06924482434988022,
0.5507439970970154,
0.14378955960273743,
-0.7138639092445374,
-0.5873783826828003,
-1.163822889328003,
-0.3450703024864197,
0.27860358357429504,
-0.3605353534221649,
0.281202107667923,
0.0545860156416893,
-0.01413167268037796,
-0.28541427850723267,
-0.03163648769259453,
-0.6590572595596313,
0.1713346540927887,
0.4110555946826935,
1.091387152671814,
-0.8899135589599609,
1.2985783815383911,
0.4041617810726166,
-0.40319353342056274,
-0.6160603165626526,
-0.5209061503410339,
-0.23493076860904694,
-0.9268139004707336,
0.6442232131958008,
0.17823681235313416,
-0.14755038917064667,
-0.15975525975227356,
-0.5471068620681763,
-0.74386066198349,
0.6920706033706665,
0.8719493746757507,
-0.3599703907966614,
-0.16234974563121796,
0.5453795194625854,
0.7741519212722778,
-0.7114803791046143,
0.35594311356544495,
0.8129332065582275,
0.24985535442829132,
0.31908944249153137,
-0.9978857636451721,
-0.5323427319526672,
-0.06806571781635284,
0.152201309800148,
0.1615464985370636,
-0.28755587339401245,
0.9242757558822632,
-0.013788950629532337,
-0.18564972281455994,
0.6069477200508118,
0.8163952231407166,
0.1485804319381714,
-0.23026153445243835,
0.3858758211135864,
0.6228967308998108,
0.47150540351867676,
-0.26109951734542847,
1.2377419471740723,
-0.5698884725570679,
0.09750323742628098,
1.0486392974853516,
-0.30656698346138,
0.9089698791503906,
0.059316251426935196,
-0.06518486887216568,
0.2715745270252228,
0.3717575669288635,
0.21805529296398163,
0.2785157263278961,
0.3230646252632141,
-0.402499794960022,
-0.30722224712371826,
-0.5227137804031372,
-0.5430876612663269,
0.8654714822769165,
0.44072818756103516,
-0.6085001826286316,
-0.667192816734314,
-0.0872054249048233,
0.32954978942871094,
-0.05681252107024193,
-0.40998324751853943,
0.44490277767181396,
0.09506040811538696,
-0.9199204444885254,
0.4100026488304138,
0.27366071939468384,
0.6068292856216431,
-0.9146738648414612,
-0.015568285249173641,
-0.191554456949234,
0.4075874984264374,
0.31013068556785583,
-0.3832443058490753,
0.18170149624347687,
0.39022040367126465,
0.1826566457748413,
-0.6055200695991516,
0.7257454991340637,
-0.660558819770813,
-0.6542682647705078,
0.34368637204170227,
0.5551018118858337,
0.4744540750980377,
-0.19790160655975342,
-0.5716699957847595,
0.36860397458076477,
-0.22007852792739868,
0.0255583468824625,
0.38009893894195557,
0.5913209319114685,
0.1400550901889801,
0.4834582805633545,
0.551385760307312,
0.2752022445201874,
0.012382682412862778,
0.2518714666366577,
0.8711577653884888,
-0.24624848365783691,
-0.5563924312591553,
-0.5786049962043762,
0.1986571103334427,
0.25516217947006226,
-0.5407890677452087,
0.6906552314758301,
0.6631397008895874,
0.8582094311714172,
-0.1429620385169983,
0.6823993921279907,
0.15368545055389404,
0.5340189933776855,
-0.4030783176422119,
0.8060854077339172,
-0.3167337477207184,
0.05787662789225578,
-0.18123291432857513,
-1.1374659538269043,
-0.10258377343416214,
0.6560530662536621,
-0.43648478388786316,
-0.0031790430657565594,
0.36912474036216736,
0.9394214153289795,
-0.023054247722029686,
0.05952160060405731,
0.49809399247169495,
0.5338394045829773,
0.3654053509235382,
1.0080703496932983,
0.8116030693054199,
-0.20569352805614471,
0.8927236199378967,
0.16671684384346008,
-0.4469785988330841,
-0.08624383062124252,
-1.1992573738098145,
-0.8351303935050964,
-0.2991902232170105,
-0.057923298329114914,
-0.3615480661392212,
0.2636547386646271,
0.647691011428833,
0.6621091961860657,
-0.8166869282722473,
-0.5523752570152283,
-0.13918136060237885,
-0.013157927431166172,
0.14150618016719818,
-0.09947443008422852,
0.279166042804718,
-0.4062678813934326,
-1.135581135749817,
0.6456588506698608,
0.5401051044464111,
0.18187685310840607,
-0.7258284091949463,
-0.01146137248724699,
0.2967047393321991,
0.1210121139883995,
0.6294184923171997,
0.5040785074234009,
-0.41743770241737366,
-0.160699263215065,
-0.08671317994594574,
-0.2684466540813446,
-0.0645507350564003,
0.585864782333374,
-1.0459283590316772,
0.5009876489639282,
0.5223433971405029,
0.21441750228405,
0.2861352860927582,
-0.287529855966568,
0.8416986465454102,
-0.4815392792224884,
0.3082461953163147,
0.20021657645702362,
0.8286869525909424,
0.370171457529068,
0.24890100955963135,
0.5303717851638794,
0.06461352109909058,
-0.3604241609573364,
-0.45459094643592834,
0.2723543345928192,
-1.1911284923553467,
-0.10737650841474533,
1.329975962638855,
-0.3901374638080597,
-0.4463249742984772,
-0.11133768409490585,
-0.46125924587249756,
0.21568092703819275,
-0.33566710352897644,
0.7716705799102783,
0.4130929112434387,
0.5356295108795166,
0.43267935514450073,
-0.47450771927833557,
0.21200264990329742,
0.0338987372815609,
-0.7065222859382629,
-0.0773531049489975,
0.5912887454032898,
0.12256938964128494,
0.2711513638496399,
0.6566604971885681,
-0.25431132316589355,
0.13287492096424103,
-0.06877445429563522,
-0.06614240258932114,
-0.08911451697349548,
-0.7358613610267639,
-0.3068894147872925,
0.5439289808273315,
0.14478717744350433,
0.011865254491567612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12959v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12959v1 | Prompt Stealing Attacks Against Large Language Models | 2024-02-20T12:25:26 | 2024-02-20T12:25:26 | Zeyang Sha, Yang Zhang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | The increasing reliance on large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT in
various fields emphasizes the importance of ``prompt engineering,'' a
technology to improve the quality of model outputs. With companies investing
significantly in expert prompt engineers and educational resources rising to
meet market demand, designing high-quality prompts has become an intriguing
challenge. In this paper, we propose a novel attack against LLMs, named prompt
stealing attacks. Our proposed prompt stealing attack aims to steal these
well-designed prompts based on the generated answers. The prompt stealing
attack contains two primary modules: the parameter extractor and the prompt
reconstruction. The goal of the parameter extractor is to figure out the
properties of the original prompts. We first observe that most prompts fall
into one of three categories: direct prompt, role-based prompt, and in-context
prompt. Our parameter extractor first tries to distinguish the type of prompts
based on the generated answers. Then, it can further predict which role or how
many contexts are used based on the types of prompts. Following the parameter
extractor, the prompt reconstructor can be used to reconstruct the original
prompts based on the generated answers and the extracted features. The final
goal of the prompt reconstructor is to generate the reversed prompts, which are
similar to the original prompts. Our experimental results show the remarkable
performance of our proposed attacks. Our proposed attacks add a new dimension
to the study of prompt engineering and call for more attention to the security
issues on LLMs. | [
-0.3057748079299927,
-1.1091639995574951,
0.4250953793525696,
0.12420777976512909,
-0.24851635098457336,
0.1770276427268982,
0.3262951970100403,
-0.33503293991088867,
0.05702603980898857,
0.9842424988746643,
-0.7574310898780823,
0.16019749641418457,
-0.6177518367767334,
0.23121866583824158,
-0.42976731061935425,
0.7364698052406311,
0.22266602516174316,
0.0963449701666832,
0.14939062297344208,
0.2756158113479614,
-0.8244065046310425,
-0.5870406031608582,
-1.0839415788650513,
0.24868491291999817,
0.7219936847686768,
0.14715763926506042,
0.48517414927482605,
0.25153473019599915,
0.17492139339447021,
0.35949066281318665,
-0.17774848639965057,
-0.23372414708137512,
-0.41435304284095764,
0.41192397475242615,
0.06945041567087173,
-0.3364008665084839,
-0.3633383512496948,
0.08950478583574295,
0.40867453813552856,
0.12381429225206375,
0.2195359170436859,
0.013816144317388535,
0.19672265648841858,
0.37235593795776367,
-0.45442405343055725,
0.1253644824028015,
-0.7847818732261658,
-0.13921265304088593,
-0.2763480246067047,
-0.6529565453529358,
-0.7248920202255249,
-0.37367457151412964,
-0.3010801374912262,
-0.20486846566200256,
0.1627243310213089,
0.24483054876327515,
0.7205540537834167,
-0.009135798551142216,
-0.19472484290599823,
-0.46743568778038025,
-0.311771035194397,
0.6936059594154358,
-0.6984735131263733,
0.026126371696591377,
0.26706066727638245,
0.589918851852417,
-0.5550216436386108,
-0.4755028486251831,
-0.42699578404426575,
-0.310134619474411,
-0.08879702538251877,
-0.15510910749435425,
-0.4015606939792633,
-0.12035519629716873,
0.5483887195587158,
0.09922448545694351,
-0.5895617604255676,
0.4628966152667999,
-0.4702953100204468,
-0.38660192489624023,
0.49165138602256775,
0.1520824283361435,
0.7962860465049744,
-0.4761310815811157,
-0.8241869807243347,
0.07843802124261856,
-1.0067362785339355,
0.2519819438457489,
0.3528122007846832,
0.35249438881874084,
0.11488499492406845,
0.49568039178848267,
0.06561153382062912,
0.6359477043151855,
0.001746283145621419,
-0.2872714102268219,
-0.21148422360420227,
-0.05808832123875618,
-0.17497369647026062,
0.16550731658935547,
0.779338538646698,
0.11955680698156357,
0.3562873303890228,
-0.14049150049686432,
-0.4690725803375244,
-0.40067240595817566,
0.0836801826953888,
-0.8129087090492249,
-0.035680290311574936,
0.15236054360866547,
-0.4158520996570587,
-0.4849812686443329,
-0.13322468101978302,
-1.0726906061172485,
-0.7977746725082397,
-0.03589467331767082,
0.2139064073562622,
-0.36189547181129456,
-0.048360425978899,
-0.13022953271865845,
-0.12165217846632004,
0.7022560834884644,
0.2294936627149582,
-0.903648853302002,
-0.059519924223423004,
1.0396021604537964,
0.7896111607551575,
-0.13995057344436646,
-0.33804306387901306,
-0.9372648000717163,
0.024516798555850983,
-0.04547031223773956,
0.7202227711677551,
-0.5128483772277832,
-0.7375245690345764,
-0.10434550791978836,
0.08250156790018082,
0.042357660830020905,
-0.3734287619590759,
0.47449320554733276,
-1.1909977197647095,
0.3180239498615265,
-0.4176883399486542,
-0.5188056826591492,
0.022074580192565918,
0.3949905037879944,
-0.9811420440673828,
0.5521329641342163,
-0.2873344421386719,
-0.8018608689308167,
0.03915238752961159,
-0.29779258370399475,
-0.16210637986660004,
0.15572498738765717,
-0.17934678494930267,
-0.09231583029031754,
0.0404345840215683,
0.4620039463043213,
0.46265870332717896,
-0.30248454213142395,
0.014570358209311962,
-0.3143761157989502,
-0.18959428369998932,
0.652032732963562,
-0.8209418654441833,
1.3009713888168335,
0.32358071208000183,
0.09329655766487122,
0.06871800124645233,
-0.7263392210006714,
-0.22967058420181274,
0.28676488995552063,
-0.07064932584762573,
-0.312569260597229,
-0.14524681866168976,
-0.17656444013118744,
0.2026761919260025,
0.44015878438949585,
-0.6844323873519897,
0.31185832619667053,
-0.3773602247238159,
0.46663472056388855,
1.062526822090149,
0.5675698518753052,
0.3899135887622833,
-0.34970059990882874,
0.9290437698364258,
-0.31980812549591064,
0.11299976706504822,
-0.4211146831512451,
-0.4631924629211426,
-0.036899808794260025,
-0.7735138535499573,
-0.07159010320901871,
0.6850146055221558,
-0.8409696817398071,
0.14551904797554016,
0.10120607167482376,
-0.4561961889266968,
-0.26737678050994873,
-0.049663692712783813,
0.2124089002609253,
0.47789135575294495,
0.24246563017368317,
0.23446670174598694,
-0.38056713342666626,
-0.6784458160400391,
-0.6584157347679138,
-0.04441731423139572,
-0.18082642555236816,
0.08608119934797287,
0.18955644965171814,
-0.1136639192700386,
1.109584093093872,
-0.5413405299186707,
-0.13102653622627258,
-0.46263840794563293,
-0.2393033802509308,
0.3370303511619568,
0.5977725386619568,
0.7841293811798096,
-0.5628405213356018,
-0.3472338318824768,
-0.4001772403717041,
-0.5098438858985901,
-0.4032304286956787,
-0.49774089455604553,
-0.08462240546941757,
0.10667124390602112,
0.7787847518920898,
-1.070271611213684,
0.13180005550384521,
0.11593741923570633,
-0.4928721487522125,
0.8693506121635437,
0.17978744208812714,
0.005777920596301556,
-1.2591623067855835,
0.030750440433621407,
-0.29295700788497925,
-0.04426505044102669,
-0.5579659342765808,
0.35084518790245056,
-0.10076442360877991,
-0.545863687992096,
-0.6195284724235535,
0.8248690366744995,
-0.6272927522659302,
0.14562126994132996,
-0.2677844166755676,
-0.03789224475622177,
-0.12638047337532043,
0.41412848234176636,
-0.49624767899513245,
0.8885022401809692,
0.59520024061203,
-0.3190583884716034,
0.5970090627670288,
0.2271236777305603,
-0.23799489438533783,
0.5335521697998047,
-0.8080752491950989,
0.36637529730796814,
-0.12083078175783157,
0.1785050332546234,
-1.2736635208129883,
-0.15491138398647308,
0.4521704912185669,
-0.6950453519821167,
0.4904126226902008,
-0.3261246383190155,
-0.557284414768219,
0.025451824069023132,
-0.4084364175796509,
-0.021724676713347435,
0.48593753576278687,
-0.6895481944084167,
0.6522950530052185,
0.2715962529182434,
-0.6984606981277466,
-0.7642886638641357,
-0.4217498302459717,
0.24663494527339935,
-0.41155683994293213,
-0.5604361891746521,
-0.06638503074645996,
-0.014804969541728497,
-0.34560224413871765,
-0.3149852752685547,
-0.15868426859378815,
0.023724999278783798,
0.5255908370018005,
0.06825672090053558,
0.5165382027626038,
-0.0870441272854805,
-0.3917943239212036,
-0.035021599382162094,
-0.20413336157798767,
0.5776365995407104,
0.1828005015850067,
0.8219521641731262,
0.4470897316932678,
-0.38627007603645325,
-0.6198551058769226,
0.6847094297409058,
0.8645869493484497,
-0.32377344369888306,
0.4283469021320343,
0.251842737197876,
-0.25409477949142456,
-0.26616859436035156,
-0.5079552531242371,
-0.34164848923683167,
-0.6012093424797058,
0.472273588180542,
-0.4683009684085846,
-0.8542706966400146,
0.5433980226516724,
0.03209266439080238,
0.5226882696151733,
0.06042183190584183,
0.1671483814716339,
0.04970917850732803,
1.074152946472168,
0.24893608689308167,
-0.3664771318435669,
0.5491634607315063,
0.2264227718114853,
0.04009513184428215,
-0.5605831742286682,
-0.1201867088675499,
-0.642827570438385,
-0.18089905381202698,
-0.3045808672904968,
-0.10995305329561234,
0.027754344046115875,
0.12622129917144775,
-0.2490404099225998,
0.3224581480026245,
-0.03621750324964523,
0.6837290525436401,
0.5063653588294983,
-0.1460421234369278,
0.07095007598400116,
0.18948929011821747,
0.07061545550823212,
0.15422184765338898,
-0.3091680705547333,
-0.7429949045181274,
0.698204517364502,
0.3114188015460968,
0.8045700192451477,
0.09122388064861298,
0.8094891905784607,
0.3897576332092285,
-0.26052770018577576,
-0.6198253035545349,
1.001922845840454,
0.3210194408893585,
-0.39149701595306396,
-0.15546800196170807,
-0.49414607882499695,
-1.090510368347168,
0.4783898591995239,
0.020150156691670418,
-0.936809241771698,
-0.006704297848045826,
-0.15926818549633026,
-0.38925236463546753,
0.5375697016716003,
-0.6992611885070801,
0.5890759825706482,
-0.07825231552124023,
-0.08096130937337875,
-0.0263937097042799,
-0.501592218875885,
0.3605886995792389,
-0.11072921752929688,
0.18780262768268585,
-0.03804412856698036,
0.14857052266597748,
0.6590865850448608,
-0.34834185242652893,
1.1421531438827515,
-0.3961673974990845,
-0.2844083607196808,
0.3062710762023926,
0.6545950174331665,
0.8091748952865601,
0.3124313950538635,
0.00396069698035717,
-0.13642264902591705,
0.08519309014081955,
-0.526870608329773,
-0.701362133026123,
0.7449780702590942,
-0.6667502522468567,
-1.0655913352966309,
-0.37243813276290894,
-0.19603478908538818,
-0.04156391695141792,
0.12747099995613098,
0.2905270457267761,
0.612369179725647,
-0.2974044978618622,
-0.1906248778104782,
0.38163480162620544,
-0.43211203813552856,
0.8606990575790405,
0.3946835398674011,
-0.0995117798447609,
-0.46530580520629883,
0.9445177316665649,
-0.10382325947284698,
0.44027453660964966,
0.3169296681880951,
0.10328534990549088,
0.038366515189409256,
-0.4259647727012634,
-0.4495912492275238,
0.2760719954967499,
-0.5099001526832581,
-0.2413274049758911,
-0.6412540674209595,
-0.3298529386520386,
-0.3153507709503174,
-0.2568601071834564,
-0.015115732327103615,
-0.4403139054775238,
-0.555298924446106,
0.01381960790604353,
0.20468610525131226,
0.36122167110443115,
0.36619970202445984,
0.4155987501144409,
-1.0674571990966797,
0.16824501752853394,
0.6382793188095093,
-0.24606190621852875,
0.31630221009254456,
-0.5416042804718018,
0.3636796772480011,
-0.24186092615127563,
-0.2745699882507324,
-1.207153558731079,
0.6600524187088013,
-0.3211294710636139,
0.6005942821502686,
0.45617491006851196,
0.1687069833278656,
0.15337979793548584,
-0.6946503520011902,
0.9173283576965332,
0.11886197328567505,
-0.8007790446281433,
0.35568854212760925,
-0.14699290692806244,
0.313708633184433,
0.27418798208236694,
0.237929567694664,
-0.5562303066253662,
-0.35444217920303345,
-0.5951594710350037,
-0.755283534526825,
0.7837676405906677,
-0.019629664719104767,
0.30148276686668396,
-0.033789150416851044,
0.3273457884788513,
0.2838853895664215,
-0.09095615893602371,
-0.5402990579605103,
-0.1565709412097931,
0.07668094336986542,
0.030828017741441727,
0.21815091371536255,
-0.7188333868980408,
0.12035437673330307,
0.34543919563293457,
0.5493234395980835,
0.21461695432662964,
0.1493855118751526,
-0.044445235282182693,
-0.22884048521518707,
0.3386324644088745,
0.485262393951416,
0.3812731206417084,
0.36292019486427307,
0.2570870518684387,
0.1472032517194748,
0.23674850165843964,
-0.5840345621109009,
0.04788577929139137,
0.09603076428174973,
-0.2682381272315979,
-0.18938730657100677,
0.6016106605529785,
0.6710688471794128,
-0.012235665693879128,
-0.5790059566497803,
0.5179165005683899,
-0.0840379148721695,
0.3698681890964508,
-0.45763447880744934,
0.05290602520108223,
-0.1274694800376892,
0.40407270193099976,
0.3947512209415436,
0.22613093256950378,
0.00008849563164403662,
-0.2806340157985687,
0.20327666401863098,
0.5781081318855286,
-0.44276726245880127,
-0.6286592483520508,
0.4324590265750885,
0.1715906262397766,
-0.7307416796684265,
0.5839089155197144,
0.028556520119309425,
-0.5449608564376831,
0.69012051820755,
0.8393633365631104,
0.9259128570556641,
-0.4986097812652588,
0.07023884356021881,
0.1985100656747818,
0.3445417881011963,
0.1517469882965088,
0.2736804187297821,
0.03528541326522827,
-0.4554140567779541,
-0.31696027517318726,
-0.3952264189720154,
-0.3147638738155365,
0.2445605993270874,
-0.39960163831710815,
0.45822110772132874,
-0.6875979900360107,
0.18651989102363586,
-0.2937600314617157,
-0.4184621572494507,
-0.26820847392082214,
-0.28485196828842163,
0.16139717400074005,
0.6484799385070801,
-0.3596058189868927,
0.5725804567337036,
0.3171326220035553,
-0.2341885268688202,
-0.631022572517395,
0.036486778408288956,
0.2402767539024353,
-0.885536253452301,
0.7646474838256836,
0.2651814818382263,
0.013960083946585655,
-0.005915061105042696,
-0.795667827129364,
-0.8918426632881165,
0.7608270645141602,
0.3795606195926666,
-0.4707110524177551,
-0.34134817123413086,
-0.003327292390167713,
-0.0244736410677433,
-0.04570704698562622,
0.12433011084794998,
0.5244993567466736,
0.15100611746311188,
0.056673649698495865,
-0.6136231422424316,
0.47858163714408875,
-0.13519559800624847,
-0.29579541087150574,
0.20675039291381836,
-0.4548710286617279,
1.0392123460769653,
-0.16050991415977478,
-0.6385040879249573,
0.2913161814212799,
0.5219689607620239,
0.6542554497718811,
-0.021465694531798363,
0.4752688705921173,
0.048899926245212555,
0.6499440670013428,
0.29135140776634216,
0.8435741066932678,
-0.10705333203077316,
0.11948071420192719,
1.0696383714675903,
-0.3742865324020386,
0.6947058439254761,
0.5631173849105835,
0.17878665030002594,
0.14074857532978058,
0.337686687707901,
-0.12441571801900864,
0.46117252111434937,
0.2511346936225891,
-0.25690335035324097,
0.023450084030628204,
0.22844605147838593,
-0.2766706645488739,
0.3610747456550598,
0.3298618495464325,
-0.2731076776981354,
-0.3262127935886383,
0.2006542831659317,
0.5121038556098938,
-0.23030035197734833,
-0.2640836834907532,
0.8271403312683105,
0.24810071289539337,
-0.4999859631061554,
0.5505766868591309,
-0.07408297806978226,
0.5573269128799438,
-0.6908972859382629,
0.02325538359582424,
-0.18241770565509796,
0.0027910007629543543,
0.09281759709119797,
-0.46384042501449585,
-0.014616352505981922,
0.17774584889411926,
0.0788993090391159,
-0.3593815863132477,
0.8325374126434326,
-0.08399250358343124,
-0.16005919873714447,
0.207986518740654,
0.39976003766059875,
-0.06325817108154297,
-0.298985093832016,
-0.5353994965553284,
-0.05978790298104286,
0.16954883933067322,
-0.5119444727897644,
0.38843822479248047,
0.4853149950504303,
0.0730333998799324,
0.667375385761261,
0.6935065388679504,
0.2570667564868927,
0.16869570314884186,
-0.24307389557361603,
0.9156239628791809,
-0.8479741811752319,
-0.6719174981117249,
-1.4380831718444824,
0.12010200321674347,
-0.24205875396728516,
-0.20303405821323395,
0.9572243094444275,
0.4110238254070282,
0.4654790163040161,
-0.2258419394493103,
0.7234817743301392,
0.1287250965833664,
0.576669454574585,
-0.782935380935669,
0.9624605178833008,
-0.09329043328762054,
0.7167291045188904,
-0.5101395845413208,
-0.9348793029785156,
-0.14619219303131104,
-0.04380015283823013,
-0.27074170112609863,
-0.11689962446689606,
0.5210843086242676,
0.955660879611969,
0.10772127658128738,
0.3131123185157776,
0.12982460856437683,
0.28389447927474976,
0.9466553926467896,
0.4229893088340759,
1.3643254041671753,
-0.06019735336303711,
0.6099039912223816,
0.2300826907157898,
-0.3947627544403076,
-0.03436978906393051,
-0.5671465396881104,
-1.1746294498443604,
-0.36965101957321167,
-0.05643494799733162,
-0.28265586495399475,
-0.1266021430492401,
1.0703299045562744,
0.18020430207252502,
-0.6639898419380188,
-0.09652817249298096,
0.11200502514839172,
0.15965935587882996,
-0.0489664301276207,
-0.2914125919342041,
0.5600838661193848,
-0.44658711552619934,
-0.5613831877708435,
0.68946772813797,
0.037047721445560455,
0.07526341825723648,
-0.32253265380859375,
0.4510546624660492,
-0.01323674526065588,
0.31171077489852905,
0.5320215225219727,
0.47771361470222473,
-0.8270344734191895,
-0.2638750970363617,
0.08562021702528,
-0.165919691324234,
-0.19186091423034668,
0.940802812576294,
-0.7264008522033691,
0.07083819806575775,
0.8454985618591309,
0.882895290851593,
-0.06579377502202988,
-0.046845417469739914,
0.4744943380355835,
-0.7626615166664124,
-0.0037252428010106087,
0.2736787796020508,
0.6043307781219482,
0.26637372374534607,
-0.5177093148231506,
-0.06427805125713348,
0.31138452887535095,
-0.4983479082584381,
-0.9540767669677734,
0.6032915711402893,
-1.0437864065170288,
-0.6640160083770752,
1.3892884254455566,
-0.19381514191627502,
-0.35429486632347107,
-0.15254689753055573,
-0.9145785570144653,
-0.11312975734472275,
-0.537146270275116,
0.6986005902290344,
0.5057300925254822,
0.14796558022499084,
-0.06364846974611282,
-0.5695311427116394,
0.46756020188331604,
0.14585550129413605,
-0.5839927196502686,
0.34577587246894836,
0.5169892907142639,
0.39035293459892273,
0.09288963675498962,
0.23559805750846863,
-0.4854142963886261,
0.1385202556848526,
-0.10969359427690506,
-0.19115467369556427,
-0.2677561938762665,
-0.1365346759557724,
-0.4466440975666046,
0.6955384612083435,
0.04873831197619438,
-0.2854655683040619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12948v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12948v3 | GumbelSoft: Diversified Language Model Watermarking via the GumbelMax-trick | 2024-02-20T12:05:47 | 2024-05-28T04:58:41 | Jiayi Fu, Xuandong Zhao, Ruihan Yang, Yuansen Zhang, Jiangjie Chen, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) excellently generate human-like text, but also
raise concerns about misuse in fake news and academic dishonesty.
Decoding-based watermark, particularly the GumbelMax-trick-based watermark(GM
watermark), is a standout solution for safeguarding machine-generated texts due
to its notable detectability. However, GM watermark encounters a major
challenge with generation diversity, always yielding identical outputs for the
same prompt, negatively impacting generation diversity and user experience. To
overcome this limitation, we propose a new type of GM watermark, the
Logits-Addition watermark, and its three variants, specifically designed to
enhance diversity. Among these, the GumbelSoft watermark (a softmax variant of
the Logits-Addition watermark) demonstrates superior performance in high
diversity settings, with its AUROC score outperforming those of the two
alternative variants by 0.1 to 0.3 and surpassing other decoding-based
watermarking methods by a minimum of 0.1. | [
-0.49698886275291443,
-0.5855132937431335,
0.061361923813819885,
0.45471489429473877,
-0.6223295331001282,
0.6447994112968445,
0.02120300382375717,
-0.6182126998901367,
0.2922605872154236,
0.5491684079170227,
-0.46178728342056274,
-0.4745332896709442,
-0.8178441524505615,
0.12852312624454498,
-0.5681113004684448,
1.0539673566818237,
0.11621439456939697,
-0.06080010533332825,
0.13700535893440247,
-0.5309275388717651,
-0.36240315437316895,
-0.709423840045929,
-0.5631265044212341,
-0.2797667384147644,
0.408611923456192,
0.14495879411697388,
0.9095675349235535,
0.5598930716514587,
0.14007826149463654,
0.2640720307826996,
-0.42203330993652344,
0.18979142606258392,
-0.6344233751296997,
0.27800217270851135,
-0.06718719750642776,
-0.42549097537994385,
-0.4373195469379425,
-0.19894711673259735,
0.5781294107437134,
0.4929850399494171,
-0.13996703922748566,
-0.02256702445447445,
0.17655135691165924,
0.6620955467224121,
-0.6539915204048157,
0.09796460717916489,
-0.7734128832817078,
0.13802142441272736,
-0.19035176932811737,
-0.06151136755943298,
-0.3440263271331787,
-0.4778296947479248,
-0.25877273082733154,
-0.4056580364704132,
0.3052043616771698,
0.13644571602344513,
1.0333149433135986,
-0.2203686535358429,
-0.5603079795837402,
-0.2492118775844574,
-0.7223849296569824,
0.9476637244224548,
-0.8556765913963318,
0.13379797339439392,
0.06583652645349503,
0.3426707088947296,
-0.08141681551933289,
-0.546856164932251,
-0.2751224637031555,
0.24347354471683502,
0.09741237759590149,
0.17315948009490967,
-0.5285236239433289,
-0.18796658515930176,
0.2109680324792862,
0.5353645086288452,
-0.5386909246444702,
-0.13924247026443481,
-0.1289871633052826,
-0.36696383357048035,
0.752704918384552,
0.19327110052108765,
0.13053323328495026,
0.12241081148386002,
-0.23186814785003662,
-0.24674320220947266,
-0.8356534242630005,
0.05592005327343941,
0.4866507947444916,
0.35006073117256165,
0.2856180667877197,
0.3746337890625,
-0.16932550072669983,
0.7274141311645508,
-0.22832812368869781,
-0.32765623927116394,
0.397748738527298,
-0.07915870100259781,
-0.17481572926044464,
0.18114449083805084,
0.4841742515563965,
0.21479809284210205,
0.433147668838501,
-0.12432496249675751,
-0.5205726027488708,
0.08291187137365341,
-0.25346946716308594,
-0.9722040891647339,
0.07260079681873322,
-0.10020563006401062,
-0.3551185429096222,
-0.3472854495048523,
0.3085017204284668,
-0.6368858218193054,
-0.4746714234352112,
0.05173567682504654,
0.31989622116088867,
-0.4582916796207428,
-0.3899790644645691,
0.391952246427536,
-0.38115158677101135,
0.1317123919725418,
0.24477063119411469,
-0.8248533606529236,
0.3503700792789459,
0.784312903881073,
0.7605878710746765,
-0.2750092148780823,
0.02905537188053131,
-0.7321308255195618,
0.4723486602306366,
-0.18901199102401733,
1.046072244644165,
-0.7758641839027405,
-0.8052402138710022,
-0.05566185340285301,
0.024921312928199768,
0.2118918001651764,
-0.778389036655426,
0.37081488966941833,
-0.6142046451568604,
0.23670652508735657,
-0.11277086287736893,
-0.8396614789962769,
-0.26373887062072754,
0.03774789348244667,
-0.9234849810600281,
0.8957534432411194,
0.36164408922195435,
-0.6103097200393677,
0.40862640738487244,
-0.47362926602363586,
-0.597795844078064,
0.5175856351852417,
-0.17007805407047272,
-0.6111705899238586,
0.1211891695857048,
0.16785138845443726,
0.130116268992424,
-0.13548901677131653,
0.4174085259437561,
-0.31105661392211914,
-0.2601112723350525,
0.46120262145996094,
-0.7037336826324463,
0.9097921848297119,
0.11324942111968994,
-0.45688870549201965,
0.04332379624247551,
-0.8493335247039795,
0.18566761910915375,
0.29745805263519287,
-0.6319215297698975,
-0.35710999369621277,
-0.34036582708358765,
0.07963603734970093,
-0.05155414342880249,
0.15713104605674744,
-0.34596964716911316,
0.03417843580245972,
-0.027350714430212975,
0.09694433212280273,
0.8163456320762634,
-0.029446784406900406,
0.18570533394813538,
-0.552312970161438,
0.9739959239959717,
0.10466572642326355,
0.24160334467887878,
-0.2814711034297943,
-1.072056531906128,
-0.3418738543987274,
-0.6717826724052429,
0.6162572503089905,
0.645470142364502,
-0.5485877990722656,
0.39217081665992737,
-0.3493899703025818,
-0.43040767312049866,
-0.5224708914756775,
0.5185657143592834,
0.24456140398979187,
0.2837415933609009,
0.30234065651893616,
-0.5398643612861633,
-0.36097487807273865,
-0.8983266353607178,
-0.8027394413948059,
-0.09988104552030563,
-0.2191985696554184,
0.5266335606575012,
0.20868772268295288,
-0.4256318211555481,
1.1912938356399536,
-0.4264739155769348,
-0.05452261120080948,
-0.35599270462989807,
0.17769280076026917,
0.164646714925766,
0.2903001606464386,
0.8482182025909424,
-0.8028560280799866,
-0.6833316683769226,
-0.2276587337255478,
-0.3296563923358917,
-0.39323222637176514,
0.03504980728030205,
0.03724076226353645,
0.23523370921611786,
0.15749472379684448,
-0.45666399598121643,
0.3813377320766449,
1.0692452192306519,
-0.7282001972198486,
0.6399966478347778,
0.11298239231109619,
0.08715809136629105,
-0.8521671295166016,
-0.04945136606693268,
-0.3152788281440735,
-0.4646175503730774,
-0.5679394006729126,
-0.10589177906513214,
0.14139211177825928,
0.0016583086689934134,
-0.24888326227664948,
0.6441782712936401,
-0.4281424880027771,
0.08229047805070877,
-0.4932011365890503,
-0.05569145828485489,
0.30102670192718506,
0.026987161487340927,
-0.3321346640586853,
0.6604844331741333,
0.687731146812439,
-0.21907910704612732,
0.5527851581573486,
-0.015123242512345314,
-0.3082561790943146,
0.36858922243118286,
-0.5958849787712097,
-0.031424105167388916,
-0.3221825063228607,
0.3207867741584778,
-0.7400309443473816,
0.014104404486715794,
0.11069133132696152,
-0.20364516973495483,
0.4007609188556671,
-0.13841888308525085,
-0.556701123714447,
-0.04151191562414169,
-0.49081969261169434,
0.3923678696155548,
0.802467405796051,
-0.6446130275726318,
0.7394777536392212,
0.1680399477481842,
-0.3347606956958771,
-0.6024051308631897,
-0.8633687496185303,
0.40663331747055054,
-0.3918970227241516,
-0.8113676309585571,
0.4314174950122833,
-0.26360753178596497,
-0.12347915023565292,
0.25960031151771545,
-0.23898376524448395,
0.04746093973517418,
0.2336387038230896,
0.20689813792705536,
0.25258922576904297,
-0.40812429785728455,
-0.2901073098182678,
0.39208096265792847,
-0.20427067577838898,
-0.3899354636669159,
-0.34159284830093384,
0.3976098299026489,
-0.3679301142692566,
-0.3719234764575958,
0.17653310298919678,
0.77390056848526,
0.2075699120759964,
-0.17648763954639435,
0.793470025062561,
0.5803803205490112,
-0.3623369038105011,
-0.3276037871837616,
-0.5255880951881409,
-0.10969001054763794,
-0.5682264566421509,
0.1505976766347885,
-0.09928504377603531,
-1.39286470413208,
0.39877110719680786,
-0.087248794734478,
0.38919389247894287,
0.2523432970046997,
0.17795062065124512,
0.2600027620792389,
1.0565412044525146,
0.645612359046936,
-0.15801148116588593,
0.5483092069625854,
0.10682480782270432,
0.24575449526309967,
-0.44193920493125916,
-0.08120886981487274,
-0.35001593828201294,
-0.22688862681388855,
-0.4820912778377533,
-0.2825486660003662,
-0.09836320579051971,
0.48939067125320435,
0.05480385944247246,
0.4255257844924927,
-0.4520155191421509,
0.44455578923225403,
0.4996602237224579,
-0.27079856395721436,
0.6840939521789551,
0.5141819715499878,
-0.09944742172956467,
-0.016850383952260017,
-0.8635666370391846,
-0.6823258996009827,
0.9045345187187195,
0.17341865599155426,
0.8737192749977112,
0.20901820063591003,
0.954545259475708,
0.2639077603816986,
0.9466531872749329,
-0.4757741689682007,
0.6253359913825989,
-0.15778279304504395,
-0.9389609098434448,
-0.2723187208175659,
-0.6015676259994507,
-1.208640217781067,
0.48351699113845825,
-0.10114006698131561,
-0.6138476729393005,
0.09017603099346161,
0.2037835717201233,
-0.17372390627861023,
0.34394609928131104,
-0.667813241481781,
0.615677535533905,
-0.33985450863838196,
-0.1977343112230301,
-0.23936986923217773,
-0.24715754389762878,
0.1915583610534668,
-0.19210121035575867,
0.6370028257369995,
-0.4540804922580719,
-0.2397449016571045,
0.6136113405227661,
-0.11983443796634674,
0.6746007800102234,
-0.18368563055992126,
-0.37894538044929504,
0.39056411385536194,
0.33081960678100586,
0.5831084847450256,
0.26355409622192383,
-0.08000966906547546,
0.17802083492279053,
-0.39109644293785095,
-0.5320919752120972,
-0.42820262908935547,
0.6222491264343262,
-0.30454221367836,
-0.8438715934753418,
-0.39917710423469543,
-0.42481228709220886,
-0.21283109486103058,
0.28109270334243774,
0.15072175860404968,
0.4254004955291748,
-0.15026506781578064,
0.2902209162712097,
0.6800520420074463,
-0.34772318601608276,
0.6092669367790222,
0.5598856210708618,
-0.5329111814498901,
-0.5697861313819885,
1.085353136062622,
-0.12268565595149994,
0.2712479531764984,
0.05797016620635986,
0.3150481581687927,
-0.09873181581497192,
-0.5649319291114807,
-0.32035306096076965,
0.2709302306175232,
-0.9975666403770447,
-0.29493528604507446,
-0.5817123651504517,
-0.3636297583580017,
-0.26939985156059265,
-0.26189711689949036,
-0.25059279799461365,
-0.556107223033905,
-0.33513525128364563,
-0.11071247607469559,
0.49234411120414734,
0.5598214268684387,
-0.16962656378746033,
0.24112461507320404,
-1.0292690992355347,
0.44630518555641174,
0.760975182056427,
0.5405628085136414,
-0.4096003770828247,
-0.682296097278595,
0.0030542383901774883,
-0.023942377418279648,
-0.3868056535720825,
-0.8585793375968933,
0.4220835864543915,
0.3523920774459839,
0.6543636918067932,
0.5772467255592346,
-0.26095423102378845,
0.4287951588630676,
-0.39311468601226807,
0.6415782570838928,
0.522519588470459,
-0.911748468875885,
0.1646188497543335,
-0.19977672398090363,
0.49920621514320374,
0.3364885449409485,
0.008607160300016403,
-0.5133438110351562,
-0.6528480648994446,
-0.7821059823036194,
-1.0301759243011475,
0.41394487023353577,
0.4491707682609558,
0.3521876633167267,
0.19131781160831451,
-0.05245829373598099,
0.48110127449035645,
0.3961722254753113,
-0.996491014957428,
-0.41963186860084534,
-0.6629210114479065,
-0.2033836841583252,
-0.06689552962779999,
-0.4582994282245636,
-0.17889541387557983,
-0.016827767714858055,
0.7877340316772461,
-0.20749737322330475,
-0.09776052087545395,
-0.14782172441482544,
-0.16811981797218323,
-0.09187088161706924,
0.5711128115653992,
0.5526232123374939,
0.48525309562683105,
0.07953120768070221,
0.18267883360385895,
0.10087446123361588,
-0.4597282111644745,
0.13470089435577393,
0.14103493094444275,
-0.34896543622016907,
0.5186069011688232,
0.3917941749095917,
0.963908314704895,
-0.10493888705968857,
-0.8208097815513611,
0.31758347153663635,
-0.1971246898174286,
-0.20955392718315125,
0.14000757038593292,
0.47500523924827576,
0.4918377995491028,
0.149206280708313,
0.7045651078224182,
0.06568165123462677,
0.055931124836206436,
-0.38240253925323486,
0.12105721980333328,
0.5653860569000244,
-0.08092281222343445,
-0.22488418221473694,
0.4677659273147583,
0.27615970373153687,
-0.5126067996025085,
0.13988834619522095,
-0.3106110692024231,
-0.6400485038757324,
0.5795536041259766,
0.6750060319900513,
0.9474465250968933,
-0.47208747267723083,
0.21598902344703674,
0.22436796128749847,
0.4663148820400238,
-0.1415012627840042,
0.4912426471710205,
0.07265680283308029,
-0.6845079660415649,
-0.20553000271320343,
-0.6278696656227112,
-0.34318652749061584,
0.04200921207666397,
-0.5211668610572815,
0.1200467050075531,
-0.533797562122345,
-0.37638789415359497,
-0.18462854623794556,
-0.3580532670021057,
-0.5166120529174805,
0.22123663127422333,
0.4906526505947113,
0.7944250106811523,
-0.6255218982696533,
0.8044834136962891,
0.5420401096343994,
0.35897722840309143,
-0.386194109916687,
-0.07123417407274246,
-0.16045041382312775,
-0.746424674987793,
0.09115318953990936,
0.3776114583015442,
-0.2995016574859619,
0.011530270799994469,
-0.6722243428230286,
-0.9538522958755493,
1.0797828435897827,
0.7088658213615417,
-0.8048011660575867,
0.2773430049419403,
0.37971481680870056,
0.2877216339111328,
-0.49450069665908813,
-0.21285898983478546,
0.5282604694366455,
0.6069974899291992,
-0.2384478747844696,
-0.5199419856071472,
0.35160329937934875,
-0.41130495071411133,
0.2941242754459381,
-0.012844875454902649,
-0.6457086205482483,
0.5833418965339661,
0.12609319388866425,
-0.516792356967926,
-0.16523554921150208,
0.4917120635509491,
0.6168360710144043,
-0.013475651852786541,
0.7718914747238159,
0.24943599104881287,
0.7091803550720215,
-0.1197674572467804,
1.0101087093353271,
-0.34955835342407227,
0.32075604796409607,
0.8758167028427124,
-0.3220154643058777,
0.3159310817718506,
0.5283012390136719,
-0.0761450007557869,
0.7104440927505493,
0.3260469138622284,
-0.3426956236362457,
0.47843044996261597,
0.2172042727470398,
-0.5493960380554199,
-0.37213364243507385,
-0.09660306572914124,
-0.48565396666526794,
-0.06518642604351044,
0.5323163866996765,
-0.1712302565574646,
-0.1741410344839096,
-0.15561214089393616,
-0.10486017912626266,
-0.12300603836774826,
-0.030865898355841637,
0.5587486624717712,
0.42033496499061584,
-0.48273858428001404,
0.5546765327453613,
0.3481648564338684,
0.9577605724334717,
-0.8431919813156128,
0.2345062643289566,
-0.5248973369598389,
-0.018982643261551857,
-0.25208932161331177,
-0.7786388993263245,
0.12444336712360382,
0.08493950217962265,
0.04300576448440552,
-0.324775367975235,
0.805523157119751,
-0.47472846508026123,
-0.6621661186218262,
0.5917481780052185,
0.30146318674087524,
-0.19475170969963074,
0.032152507454156876,
-0.8690075874328613,
0.15146785974502563,
0.10045739263296127,
-0.5495156645774841,
0.15852633118629456,
0.36859941482543945,
-0.08652376383543015,
0.7462241053581238,
0.523558497428894,
0.058393463492393494,
0.43523839116096497,
0.37433329224586487,
0.7905147671699524,
-0.7051622271537781,
-0.7625636458396912,
-0.985859215259552,
0.41611698269844055,
-0.3385061025619507,
-0.2747078239917755,
0.8709249496459961,
0.6825152635574341,
0.6352000832557678,
-0.09835077077150345,
1.1462551355361938,
0.17878372967243195,
0.16826963424682617,
-0.21365143358707428,
0.4866427481174469,
-0.5880370736122131,
0.2516961991786957,
-0.45648112893104553,
-1.0419889688491821,
-0.43002817034721375,
0.2884458899497986,
0.3142479956150055,
0.2263961285352707,
0.6217623949050903,
0.8522883653640747,
-0.16837352514266968,
0.2711435854434967,
0.4072684645652771,
-0.15582275390625,
0.4755643606185913,
0.5397651791572571,
0.9123337268829346,
-0.22010007500648499,
1.0657373666763306,
0.04497596248984337,
-0.4049331247806549,
-0.42084166407585144,
-1.0164039134979248,
-0.8742857575416565,
-0.08007120341062546,
-0.5602846741676331,
-0.3196096420288086,
-0.0721227377653122,
0.4500088095664978,
0.5321569442749023,
-1.1899125576019287,
-0.3020734488964081,
-0.0613209530711174,
0.10589183121919632,
-0.312690794467926,
-0.18604116141796112,
-0.05772259458899498,
0.04658783972263336,
-0.47669368982315063,
0.3997001349925995,
0.5619391202926636,
0.6543614864349365,
-0.14466971158981323,
-0.3477254807949066,
0.2241990566253662,
0.5400882959365845,
0.46574586629867554,
0.2086237519979477,
-0.43861469626426697,
0.0471152700483799,
-0.08892425149679184,
-0.17604652047157288,
0.26255783438682556,
1.1663391590118408,
-0.5872576832771301,
0.16399510204792023,
0.37807711958885193,
0.6240792274475098,
0.6954729557037354,
0.013416402041912079,
0.4486008882522583,
-0.7181747555732727,
0.318984717130661,
0.40549880266189575,
0.5447172522544861,
0.7298632264137268,
-0.17194421589374542,
0.18910694122314453,
0.5837575197219849,
0.02731606923043728,
-0.8647304177284241,
0.3877987563610077,
-0.6618649363517761,
-0.6570028066635132,
1.333621621131897,
-0.2200564444065094,
-0.0780225321650505,
-0.21881629526615143,
-0.18402621150016785,
-0.004773428197950125,
-0.48057419061660767,
0.8111432790756226,
0.7607119679450989,
0.24983692169189453,
0.05289975553750992,
-0.24313756823539734,
0.40324705839157104,
0.8067681789398193,
-0.778634250164032,
0.05528435856103897,
0.3764429986476898,
0.574553906917572,
-0.015049106441438198,
0.3712107837200165,
-0.30949434638023376,
0.22019897401332855,
0.10932131856679916,
-0.01849842071533203,
-0.13684669137001038,
-0.14116738736629486,
-0.44366055727005005,
0.3917015492916107,
0.052137590944767,
0.20700494945049286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12940v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12940v2 | Normalized Orthography for Tunisian Arabic | 2024-02-20T11:52:29 | 2024-06-11T20:28:35 | Houcemeddine Turki, Kawthar Ellouze, Hager Ben Ammar, Mohamed Ali Hadj Taieb, Imed Adel, Mohamed Ben Aouicha, Pier Luigi Farri, Abderrezak Bennour | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tunisian Arabic (ISO 693-3: aeb) isa distinct variety native to Tunisia,
derived from Arabic and enriched by various historical influences. This
research introduces the "Normalized Orthography for Tunisian Arabic" (NOTA), an
adaptation of CODA* guidelines for transcribing Tunisian Arabic using Arabic
script. The aim is to enhance language resource development by ensuring
user-friendliness and consistency. The updated standard addresses challenges in
accurately representing Tunisian phonology and morphology, correcting issues
from transcriptions based on Modern Standard Arabic. | [
-0.305413156747818,
-0.5681317448616028,
0.25301745533943176,
0.2734687328338623,
-0.4016309380531311,
-0.15040713548660278,
-0.04271765798330307,
-0.6007863879203796,
0.582208514213562,
0.5380619764328003,
-0.21549637615680695,
-0.9818618297576904,
-0.5320591926574707,
0.30586984753608704,
-0.1643405556678772,
0.8657023310661316,
-0.0816739872097969,
0.2728561758995056,
0.5934489369392395,
-0.6308723092079163,
-0.4629184603691101,
-0.36752331256866455,
-0.5032552480697632,
0.07492515444755554,
0.47407597303390503,
0.6343702673912048,
1.0602068901062012,
0.5345377922058105,
0.44950902462005615,
0.1992967128753662,
0.12801708281040192,
0.03932134062051773,
-0.18990042805671692,
0.18961653113365173,
0.040378350764513016,
-0.4510515034198761,
-0.6056973338127136,
-0.4291883409023285,
0.6172923445701599,
0.8106284737586975,
0.00435662642121315,
0.2489701807498932,
-0.5408767461776733,
0.9837840795516968,
-0.9144391417503357,
0.06321091204881668,
-0.1742909550666809,
-0.4602911174297333,
-0.7355945706367493,
-0.10510987788438797,
0.03644603490829468,
-1.076131820678711,
0.05379766598343849,
-0.03347529098391533,
0.13191145658493042,
-0.30824318528175354,
0.6904416084289551,
-0.2694273293018341,
-0.5398675203323364,
-0.4487277567386627,
-0.6137678027153015,
0.6600791811943054,
-0.6268288493156433,
0.46019694209098816,
0.20971189439296722,
0.42552149295806885,
-0.3429911732673645,
-0.5531449317932129,
-0.3199847340583801,
-0.007810276001691818,
0.2579691410064697,
-0.04016955941915512,
-0.04086530953645706,
0.14515595138072968,
0.1911403089761734,
0.5938829779624939,
-0.6296624541282654,
-0.09807925671339035,
-0.5491273999214172,
-0.1904512345790863,
0.9375846982002258,
-0.27511608600616455,
0.93989098072052,
0.024023858830332756,
-0.09037305414676666,
0.036602891981601715,
-1.0154690742492676,
0.1816471815109253,
0.5647369027137756,
0.2860642373561859,
-0.5215045809745789,
0.33186832070350647,
-0.11961246281862259,
0.9948384165763855,
-0.34850266575813293,
-0.40203768014907837,
0.669313371181488,
-0.014468907378613949,
-0.19151011109352112,
0.23152734339237213,
0.26296132802963257,
0.4165566861629486,
0.4260287880897522,
-0.23742318153381348,
-0.5387864708900452,
-0.27325189113616943,
-0.026194417849183083,
-0.6344013214111328,
-0.12906351685523987,
0.016644738614559174,
-0.6460351347923279,
0.2714252173900604,
0.35732802748680115,
-0.6310910582542419,
-0.2517181634902954,
-0.027469679713249207,
0.2549067735671997,
-0.4954999089241028,
-0.18010737001895905,
0.1914520263671875,
-0.3548808693885803,
0.3242862820625305,
0.4581383466720581,
-1.0239191055297852,
0.10026342421770096,
-0.06543174386024475,
0.8703428506851196,
-0.1810390204191208,
0.32766193151474,
0.20047526061534882,
0.2283565104007721,
-0.6360943913459778,
0.79541015625,
-0.5433539152145386,
-0.7262934446334839,
0.42678138613700867,
-0.22312688827514648,
-0.09588614851236343,
-0.5633072257041931,
0.8518227934837341,
-0.7846980690956116,
-0.14439938962459564,
0.052668239921331406,
-0.1864921599626541,
-0.9455508589744568,
0.009728219360113144,
-1.051389217376709,
0.7857829928398132,
0.6198684573173523,
-0.16190552711486816,
0.20706340670585632,
-0.8123888969421387,
-0.6227738857269287,
0.14578089118003845,
-0.40349099040031433,
0.04572797939181328,
0.4964295029640198,
0.29063743352890015,
-0.1397123634815216,
-0.42171594500541687,
0.046018101274967194,
-0.03130326047539711,
-0.3462471067905426,
0.08991021662950516,
-0.26965945959091187,
1.185546636581421,
0.5970138311386108,
-0.27697062492370605,
-0.03862825781106949,
-1.3072830438613892,
0.3011458218097687,
-0.30426204204559326,
-0.21805116534233093,
-0.3219425678253174,
-0.2151273936033249,
0.5736045241355896,
0.1734524965286255,
0.4568626880645752,
-0.6685217618942261,
0.2016090452671051,
-0.3761977255344391,
0.48113152384757996,
0.48983296751976013,
0.35127004981040955,
0.32085415720939636,
-0.7841126918792725,
0.6344538927078247,
-0.2462647557258606,
0.021166816353797913,
0.07701538503170013,
-0.6842237114906311,
-0.7570995688438416,
-0.8395280241966248,
0.4800824224948883,
0.19179855287075043,
-0.30863600969314575,
0.3988473415374756,
-0.1440298855304718,
-0.7948545217514038,
-0.6766213178634644,
0.07563807815313339,
-0.07331051677465439,
0.07585392892360687,
0.33777672052383423,
-0.5856208205223083,
-0.7264207601547241,
-1.1400814056396484,
-0.23409026861190796,
-0.10074896365404129,
-0.008351366966962814,
-0.017748313024640083,
0.17392049729824066,
-0.4154514968395233,
0.7971853613853455,
-0.07099785655736923,
-0.7384471893310547,
-0.3026058077812195,
0.3686070740222931,
0.6783146858215332,
0.5326875448226929,
1.007157325744629,
-0.5869039297103882,
-0.83711177110672,
-0.15703938901424408,
-0.3046744465827942,
-0.41273194551467896,
-0.183881938457489,
-0.11126738041639328,
0.4422679543495178,
0.3321918547153473,
0.032744161784648895,
0.9324989914894104,
0.7282154560089111,
-0.19270874559879303,
-0.14766399562358856,
-0.05970929190516472,
0.2997681796550751,
-0.9421097040176392,
0.04330490902066231,
-0.3114929795265198,
-0.3564109206199646,
-0.668319582939148,
0.03180535137653351,
0.225534588098526,
0.18745292723178864,
-0.43028751015663147,
0.3198912739753723,
-0.7547082901000977,
0.04283296689391136,
-0.22513343393802643,
-0.3647724390029907,
0.033477600663900375,
0.02463364414870739,
0.27355605363845825,
1.166671872138977,
0.3929106295108795,
-0.4573609232902527,
0.08806383609771729,
0.18329553306102753,
-0.464275985956192,
0.4374275505542755,
-0.5577489137649536,
0.3570445477962494,
-0.06102854385972023,
0.07569845020771027,
-0.9286363124847412,
-0.05596058443188667,
-0.2009531408548355,
-0.4784514904022217,
0.11804582178592682,
0.11630343645811081,
-0.4581742584705353,
0.3614269495010376,
-0.4800993800163269,
0.7832551002502441,
0.7684813737869263,
-0.2870037853717804,
0.8307279944419861,
0.3750159740447998,
-0.2699313759803772,
-0.03145606815814972,
-0.6953824162483215,
-0.1030380055308342,
0.232320636510849,
-0.8845676779747009,
0.5340937376022339,
0.2471441626548767,
-0.3199005126953125,
-0.4450376331806183,
-0.3055295944213867,
-0.3476705253124237,
-0.0063744476065039635,
0.2766511142253876,
0.24205917119979858,
-0.39203396439552307,
-0.1492813527584076,
0.12548670172691345,
0.22591881453990936,
0.03673878684639931,
0.04223764315247536,
0.552495002746582,
0.11106691509485245,
-0.223627969622612,
-0.8147570490837097,
0.509426474571228,
0.5375445485115051,
-0.0689588412642479,
0.8004693984985352,
0.325068861246109,
-0.49511662125587463,
0.2674679458141327,
-0.8460726737976074,
-0.13157549500465393,
-0.45153841376304626,
-0.011406222358345985,
-0.5802894234657288,
-0.5075592994689941,
0.6657078862190247,
0.1685149073600769,
0.21488215029239655,
0.5913913249969482,
0.7389090061187744,
-0.23048852384090424,
0.8663678169250488,
0.7823976874351501,
0.040974557399749756,
0.4085741639137268,
0.10005919635295868,
0.14566586911678314,
-0.6397830843925476,
-0.5122007727622986,
-0.9356240630149841,
-0.7284718155860901,
-0.743477463722229,
-0.2778165936470032,
0.33435380458831787,
-0.02656598389148712,
-0.19728034734725952,
0.17931586503982544,
0.04276164248585701,
0.3289920687675476,
0.6458229422569275,
-0.11610186845064163,
0.33270975947380066,
0.23915694653987885,
0.1853666454553604,
-0.07863963395357132,
-0.3157571852207184,
-0.8627868890762329,
1.504721760749817,
0.1454669088125229,
0.9389373660087585,
0.7842357158660889,
1.0266083478927612,
0.6217487454414368,
0.23131796717643738,
-0.43114495277404785,
-0.08538445830345154,
0.21749350428581238,
-0.9483842253684998,
-0.0497688427567482,
0.1023675873875618,
-0.9262773394584656,
-0.10352540016174316,
-0.13483919203281403,
-1.0364305973052979,
0.7407317757606506,
-0.03915439918637276,
-0.3751431405544281,
-0.039636753499507904,
-0.7284583449363708,
0.4935692548751831,
0.06513407826423645,
0.2500881850719452,
0.06599161773920059,
-0.68618243932724,
-0.11934187263250351,
0.16960039734840393,
0.31480228900909424,
-0.014588532038033009,
-0.2109822779893875,
0.9603030681610107,
-0.2925927937030792,
0.5880374908447266,
0.05680587515234947,
0.0057057770900428295,
0.4185255765914917,
0.38086169958114624,
0.3723616302013397,
0.25154373049736023,
-0.21448606252670288,
0.424683541059494,
0.26573866605758667,
-0.7783188223838806,
-0.4261462986469269,
0.6129876375198364,
-1.2455077171325684,
-0.5425874590873718,
-0.8236755728721619,
-0.6928663849830627,
-0.27252525091171265,
0.40616458654403687,
0.24208997189998627,
0.27376946806907654,
-0.399323433637619,
0.4806981086730957,
0.4215153753757477,
0.039392344653606415,
0.19057273864746094,
0.6485095024108887,
-0.08219706267118454,
-0.5036172270774841,
0.7824034690856934,
0.4691602289676666,
0.06956323236227036,
0.37079817056655884,
-0.37015169858932495,
-0.5290120244026184,
-0.9652373790740967,
-0.4203891158103943,
0.14799755811691284,
-0.7399235367774963,
-0.1464489996433258,
-0.34714025259017944,
-0.42293187975883484,
-0.8748593926429749,
-0.35286176204681396,
-0.039747197180986404,
-0.6567601561546326,
-0.43077585101127625,
-0.23046381771564484,
0.4239116311073303,
0.7659723162651062,
-0.34946584701538086,
0.24730971455574036,
-1.0208501815795898,
0.47661489248275757,
0.02777530625462532,
-0.05942275747656822,
-0.5210780501365662,
-0.8569265604019165,
0.07931585609912872,
-0.07244767248630524,
-0.24815553426742554,
-1.4488744735717773,
0.3248424828052521,
0.3859063982963562,
0.3944816291332245,
0.716546893119812,
-0.035463593900203705,
0.5839689373970032,
-0.2734474539756775,
0.7614673972129822,
0.18373322486877441,
-1.015102505683899,
0.2691218852996826,
-0.38471126556396484,
0.3769691288471222,
0.8175777792930603,
0.3653576374053955,
-0.6744728684425354,
-0.22280575335025787,
-0.6383922100067139,
-0.9723777174949646,
0.6120507121086121,
0.5813868641853333,
0.35637399554252625,
-0.09028350561857224,
0.167439803481102,
0.4501881003379822,
0.16367194056510925,
-0.2658436596393585,
-0.4688442647457123,
-0.2657489478588104,
-0.38023966550827026,
-0.0036072260700166225,
-0.6917402148246765,
-0.21318399906158447,
-0.058697719126939774,
0.5502029657363892,
0.13900890946388245,
0.34960806369781494,
0.18689391016960144,
-0.6709285378456116,
-0.0035622376017272472,
0.4018714427947998,
0.8003547191619873,
1.1168363094329834,
-0.6962651610374451,
0.022296451032161713,
-0.17948666214942932,
-0.8044521808624268,
0.32388776540756226,
-0.12438042461872101,
-0.6635674238204956,
0.3617258071899414,
0.6047161221504211,
0.40534719824790955,
-0.508022665977478,
-0.5347917079925537,
0.2923562824726105,
0.19700537621974945,
-0.2528720796108246,
-0.5772944688796997,
0.06242595985531807,
-0.12421141564846039,
-0.019855914637446404,
0.47426074743270874,
-0.04459405317902565,
0.4822606146335602,
-0.6123861074447632,
-0.1268126368522644,
0.17775723338127136,
-0.4837961196899414,
-0.37449339032173157,
0.06695520132780075,
0.513382613658905,
-0.4405377209186554,
0.722122073173523,
0.21059615910053253,
-0.048741694539785385,
0.783248782157898,
0.7270979285240173,
0.7115604877471924,
-0.08198216557502747,
0.17476265132427216,
0.25626465678215027,
0.6316006183624268,
0.5161371827125549,
1.2917160987854004,
0.24082893133163452,
-0.7361530661582947,
0.17427416145801544,
-0.42505013942718506,
-0.09133069217205048,
0.13980881869792938,
-1.020423412322998,
0.1912703961133957,
-0.9816064238548279,
-0.23716838657855988,
-0.11075103282928467,
-0.43946507573127747,
-0.7804734706878662,
0.5347931981086731,
0.14301997423171997,
1.3513933420181274,
-0.9638553261756897,
1.0387448072433472,
1.0247347354888916,
-0.6830217838287354,
-0.8193740844726562,
-0.08489132672548294,
0.02067333273589611,
-1.0717276334762573,
0.7328857183456421,
0.14841072261333466,
-0.24889685213565826,
-0.01687023416161537,
-0.19310055673122406,
-1.0404690504074097,
1.0032364130020142,
0.3452209532260895,
-0.4301724135875702,
0.3475066125392914,
-0.024050381034612656,
0.42925554513931274,
-0.42005252838134766,
0.6746232509613037,
0.8268641233444214,
0.6055314540863037,
-0.14842218160629272,
-0.496830552816391,
0.06631532311439514,
-0.18814601004123688,
0.6625313758850098,
0.17438234388828278,
-0.48104140162467957,
0.9374614953994751,
0.08401258289813995,
-0.3081301748752594,
0.37865036725997925,
1.0567169189453125,
-0.052065715193748474,
-0.23006951808929443,
0.13710901141166687,
0.23918463289737701,
0.5707928538322449,
-0.1287255436182022,
0.6960451006889343,
-0.4696263372898102,
-0.1792725920677185,
0.6618818044662476,
-0.27296730875968933,
0.4603550136089325,
1.0493824481964111,
-0.11735552549362183,
1.0095851421356201,
0.8189685344696045,
0.4224473834037781,
0.6291958689689636,
0.07930728793144226,
-0.3485157787799835,
-0.09327808767557144,
-0.12366120517253876,
-0.8668051362037659,
0.47109538316726685,
0.30667945742607117,
-0.44346725940704346,
-0.39439985156059265,
-0.40041792392730713,
0.03150356933474541,
0.38932111859321594,
-0.3369908630847931,
0.721518874168396,
-0.0726027637720108,
-0.46479713916778564,
0.8601909875869751,
0.4665345847606659,
0.21958039700984955,
-0.6809232234954834,
-0.24565421044826508,
-0.44415464997291565,
-0.11641436815261841,
-0.41639241576194763,
-0.2587033212184906,
0.3728354871273041,
-0.07349994778633118,
-0.305109441280365,
0.09093458205461502,
0.18511387705802917,
-0.2684544324874878,
-0.3790377378463745,
0.16456985473632812,
0.390770822763443,
0.1653967946767807,
0.03228257969021797,
-0.5118425488471985,
-0.013220071792602539,
0.3024597764015198,
0.04431048408150673,
0.19991031289100647,
0.17536894977092743,
-0.44452327489852905,
0.1650611013174057,
0.5795748233795166,
0.26775139570236206,
0.16716741025447845,
0.31958237290382385,
0.6538109183311462,
-0.7551929354667664,
-0.5093905925750732,
-0.6370340585708618,
0.2493298202753067,
0.18341584503650665,
-0.4124334454536438,
0.7381271123886108,
0.40127843618392944,
0.7443636655807495,
-0.3897832930088043,
0.8746631145477295,
-0.2857150435447693,
0.24465389549732208,
-0.734315037727356,
0.745194673538208,
-0.4343015253543854,
-0.13310985267162323,
0.10481216758489609,
-1.3763740062713623,
-0.6627217531204224,
1.0584121942520142,
-0.162896528840065,
0.12509439885616302,
1.1226121187210083,
0.8238125443458557,
0.11392015963792801,
0.14573493599891663,
0.353522926568985,
-0.0928206667304039,
0.1424930989742279,
0.567211925983429,
0.3315243721008301,
-0.377498984336853,
0.1656457930803299,
-0.05430132523179054,
-0.49581941962242126,
-0.47255581617355347,
-0.7660932540893555,
-0.9239034056663513,
-0.137624591588974,
-0.2007920891046524,
-0.45424914360046387,
0.37708017230033875,
1.401610016822815,
0.32484349608421326,
-1.3720569610595703,
-0.622239887714386,
-0.007928741164505482,
0.09102530032396317,
-0.3485831916332245,
-0.10630194842815399,
0.3937196135520935,
-0.14716723561286926,
-0.7961548566818237,
0.2782858908176422,
0.4236321747303009,
0.3217393159866333,
-0.056029461324214935,
0.024205585941672325,
-0.5448030829429626,
0.36745908856391907,
-0.1270352452993393,
0.6006619930267334,
-0.43456095457077026,
-0.41375109553337097,
-0.3353342115879059,
-0.5594910979270935,
0.3303678035736084,
0.7384660243988037,
-0.21964284777641296,
0.7365434169769287,
0.9224724769592285,
0.45575863122940063,
0.22486574947834015,
-0.2594066560268402,
1.0157102346420288,
-0.6389119625091553,
0.686886727809906,
0.327078640460968,
0.3844771087169647,
0.13726972043514252,
-0.11740723997354507,
0.3839627206325531,
0.10687118768692017,
-0.028525372967123985,
-0.4131319224834442,
0.4915179908275604,
-0.841225266456604,
0.20862241089344025,
1.0829813480377197,
-0.4951459467411041,
-0.3278505504131317,
-0.43395107984542847,
-0.42603176832199097,
0.11790887266397476,
-0.925944447517395,
0.9302433133125305,
0.7252587080001831,
0.17626924812793732,
-0.021070217713713646,
-0.17279848456382751,
0.7402454018592834,
0.311200350522995,
-0.5439507365226746,
-0.8709816336631775,
0.3762246072292328,
0.1584542840719223,
0.19249415397644043,
0.843325674533844,
-0.4554278254508972,
0.8024712800979614,
-0.3384600579738617,
0.5310060977935791,
0.06943520158529282,
-0.31178709864616394,
-0.37547099590301514,
0.18466700613498688,
0.6906229257583618,
-0.43707966804504395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12914v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12914v1 | Large Language Model-based Human-Agent Collaboration for Complex Task Solving | 2024-02-20T11:03:36 | 2024-02-20T11:03:36 | Xueyang Feng, Zhi-Yuan Chen, Yujia Qin, Yankai Lin, Xu Chen, Zhiyuan Liu, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | In recent developments within the research community, the integration of
Large Language Models (LLMs) in creating fully autonomous agents has garnered
significant interest. Despite this, LLM-based agents frequently demonstrate
notable shortcomings in adjusting to dynamic environments and fully grasping
human needs. In this work, we introduce the problem of LLM-based human-agent
collaboration for complex task-solving, exploring their synergistic potential.
In addition, we propose a Reinforcement Learning-based Human-Agent
Collaboration method, ReHAC. This approach includes a policy model designed to
determine the most opportune stages for human intervention within the
task-solving process. We construct a human-agent collaboration dataset to train
this policy model in an offline reinforcement learning environment. Our
validation tests confirm the model's effectiveness. The results demonstrate
that the synergistic efforts of humans and LLM-based agents significantly
improve performance in complex tasks, primarily through well-planned, limited
human intervention. Datasets and code are available at:
https://github.com/XueyangFeng/ReHAC. | [
-0.392535537481308,
-0.9595353603363037,
0.7703819870948792,
0.1892024725675583,
0.1667778342962265,
0.6367893815040588,
-0.5290762186050415,
-0.7537840008735657,
0.3276515603065491,
0.33897215127944946,
-0.7525876760482788,
-0.33761653304100037,
-0.39382708072662354,
0.1210218146443367,
0.19259266555309296,
0.665298342704773,
-0.3174656629562378,
0.009712978266179562,
-0.4727640450000763,
-0.057931337505578995,
-0.5303161144256592,
-0.5725001692771912,
-0.7179262638092041,
-0.7920042872428894,
0.7075415849685669,
0.6347249746322632,
0.7361570000648499,
0.3364253640174866,
0.5165378451347351,
0.44589388370513916,
0.048262156546115875,
0.43076297640800476,
-0.4526594877243042,
0.48296377062797546,
-0.43276241421699524,
-0.43861934542655945,
-0.6363328099250793,
-0.13072821497917175,
0.4505907893180847,
0.7420464754104614,
-0.559138834476471,
-0.2510955035686493,
0.0950893685221672,
0.2841278612613678,
-0.6002591848373413,
0.5217444896697998,
-0.28470972180366516,
-0.015211071819067001,
0.0224717129021883,
0.05287853628396988,
-0.21621473133563995,
0.08459557592868805,
0.27130380272865295,
-0.7689165472984314,
0.009967747144401073,
0.17001748085021973,
0.3692954480648041,
0.426206111907959,
-0.375733345746994,
-0.051963601261377335,
-1.0596325397491455,
0.9012510776519775,
-0.7100529074668884,
0.1445532888174057,
0.5031030178070068,
0.24017368257045746,
-0.9257112145423889,
-0.45826441049575806,
-0.6660746932029724,
-0.41237449645996094,
0.2737538516521454,
0.06193513795733452,
0.03057856298983097,
0.3924387991428375,
0.2090015411376953,
-0.06500841677188873,
-0.36265459656715393,
0.30979183316230774,
-0.03462407365441322,
-0.04971756041049957,
0.6938113570213318,
0.49556800723075867,
0.30189618468284607,
0.18966172635555267,
-0.2442479133605957,
-0.05394810065627098,
-0.424600750207901,
0.17776186764240265,
0.06443473696708679,
0.3869176506996155,
-0.129267156124115,
0.4555051922798157,
-0.33728891611099243,
0.5702372789382935,
-0.18362490832805634,
-0.23303423821926117,
0.19101126492023468,
-0.3271751403808594,
-0.04586762562394142,
-0.24942104518413544,
0.5361244678497314,
-0.035697679966688156,
0.11620970070362091,
-0.3421231508255005,
-0.49323907494544983,
-0.03692852333188057,
0.39017391204833984,
-0.3410240709781647,
0.07590167969465256,
0.22764526307582855,
-0.21479660272598267,
-0.29737964272499084,
0.020502222701907158,
-0.22970323264598846,
-0.3811950087547302,
-0.4744926393032074,
0.5272027254104614,
0.11005954444408417,
-0.37759923934936523,
-0.043263692408800125,
0.1528654396533966,
0.09999395906925201,
0.4960484504699707,
-0.5696157217025757,
0.41813966631889343,
0.7561286687850952,
0.5857394933700562,
-0.17734776437282562,
-0.8705961108207703,
-0.8046395778656006,
0.22739861905574799,
-0.24053525924682617,
0.699771523475647,
-0.4161682724952698,
-0.27615001797676086,
0.10897915810346603,
0.18716640770435333,
0.060871466994285583,
-0.652843177318573,
0.43056145310401917,
-0.3643868565559387,
-0.13175354897975922,
-0.30647990107536316,
-0.43024131655693054,
-0.004151518456637859,
0.5551149845123291,
-0.943267822265625,
0.7920733094215393,
0.13157743215560913,
-0.46114522218704224,
-0.02272079326212406,
-0.8287279605865479,
-0.5974514484405518,
0.08295606821775436,
-0.19372142851352692,
-0.6149343848228455,
-0.2869611084461212,
-0.12971770763397217,
0.369086891412735,
-0.6693936586380005,
0.5108233094215393,
-0.43805065751075745,
-0.3340519368648529,
0.3822149932384491,
0.02928844653069973,
0.36076366901397705,
0.12338916212320328,
-0.43614882230758667,
0.5739331841468811,
-0.29678428173065186,
0.05997847393155098,
0.306237131357193,
-0.489101767539978,
-0.00924447737634182,
0.047961995005607605,
0.09085039794445038,
0.44149309396743774,
0.5444471836090088,
-0.5057169198989868,
0.17886702716350555,
-0.21286843717098236,
0.41415390372276306,
0.5032045245170593,
-0.11773211508989334,
0.41544100642204285,
-0.6787548661231995,
0.781414270401001,
-0.32360008358955383,
0.08756793290376663,
0.27361324429512024,
-0.36409106850624084,
-0.4096135199069977,
-0.19575949013233185,
0.13861887156963348,
0.5367313027381897,
-1.1205775737762451,
0.4679778218269348,
-0.02187638357281685,
-0.36604395508766174,
-0.11294758319854736,
0.12495670467615128,
0.6796919107437134,
0.12753278017044067,
0.17839281260967255,
-0.34745174646377563,
-0.511746346950531,
-0.7346299886703491,
-0.13006147742271423,
-0.18806840479373932,
0.09788712859153748,
0.36963754892349243,
0.5938995480537415,
-0.35719236731529236,
1.0227501392364502,
-0.49417728185653687,
-0.4957156777381897,
-0.6005602478981018,
0.4181241989135742,
-0.2192714959383011,
0.44145843386650085,
-0.02174154296517372,
-0.7978746891021729,
-0.5728864669799805,
-0.09971848875284195,
-0.7130814790725708,
-0.067517951130867,
0.11270944029092789,
-0.1027354747056961,
0.3696744740009308,
0.49796006083488464,
-0.5903952717781067,
0.3505111634731293,
0.6379588842391968,
-0.23398426175117493,
0.6496593952178955,
-0.6399511694908142,
0.03692867234349251,
-0.9841111898422241,
0.2006233185529709,
0.0007353330729529262,
-0.5179590582847595,
-0.7786906361579895,
-0.040352921932935715,
-0.42265740036964417,
-0.24801915884017944,
-0.46600425243377686,
0.4467998445034027,
-0.5061701536178589,
-0.12119869887828827,
-0.6028362512588501,
0.21050849556922913,
-0.29727333784103394,
0.8862226009368896,
0.24254554510116577,
0.4022180140018463,
0.2846978008747101,
-0.04555772244930267,
0.6564704775810242,
0.17887882888317108,
-0.08743251115083694,
0.47848284244537354,
-0.6769961714744568,
0.2617354989051819,
0.23124636709690094,
0.5225645303726196,
-0.4875374138355255,
-0.42045265436172485,
0.26019954681396484,
-0.07804568111896515,
0.15240436792373657,
0.20290373265743256,
-0.8582088947296143,
-0.16596272587776184,
-0.2196589857339859,
0.653343915939331,
0.09136145561933517,
-0.27958983182907104,
0.8646342158317566,
0.6624283194541931,
-0.13588732481002808,
-0.42381635308265686,
-0.43402430415153503,
0.27608823776245117,
0.15008187294006348,
-0.713779628276825,
0.6905105113983154,
0.03443120792508125,
-0.27998918294906616,
0.05877833813428879,
0.026387689635157585,
-0.2797905504703522,
0.05813165009021759,
0.4772788882255554,
0.33396056294441223,
0.3666406273841858,
-0.04363042488694191,
-0.3079549968242645,
-0.1850086748600006,
0.072906993329525,
-0.038506679236888885,
0.42895814776420593,
-0.1859799474477768,
-0.42217665910720825,
-0.32140809297561646,
0.5071060061454773,
0.6347900629043579,
-0.3786737322807312,
0.9210937023162842,
0.4369408190250397,
-0.4908069670200348,
-0.29202374815940857,
-0.4796077013015747,
-0.25692254304885864,
-0.4336763024330139,
0.5670229196548462,
-0.19663666188716888,
-1.0277488231658936,
0.5863572955131531,
-0.378274530172348,
0.009596160613000393,
-0.23517610132694244,
0.7568206787109375,
-0.17352184653282166,
0.8559682369232178,
0.7802336812019348,
-0.15415358543395996,
0.5901750326156616,
-0.228579580783844,
0.1436930000782013,
-0.5229077935218811,
-0.4984731674194336,
-0.2518339157104492,
-0.29987961053848267,
-0.42458561062812805,
-0.6830870509147644,
0.4466582238674164,
-0.2293206751346588,
-0.19091813266277313,
0.33124101161956787,
-0.17099399864673615,
0.34427696466445923,
0.5308703184127808,
0.14682139456272125,
0.32351815700531006,
-0.30552905797958374,
0.1587029993534088,
0.1971151977777481,
-0.7741209864616394,
-0.17207980155944824,
0.7364127039909363,
0.3226083219051361,
0.7578929662704468,
0.2348957657814026,
0.655360758304596,
0.4011468291282654,
-0.045779962092638016,
-0.5651572346687317,
0.6693788170814514,
0.14411276578903198,
-0.42933887243270874,
-0.6907851099967957,
-0.5221221446990967,
-1.4029585123062134,
0.16044951975345612,
-0.6142657399177551,
-0.46336281299591064,
-0.06939080357551575,
0.07062635570764542,
-0.2504211664199829,
0.2627298831939697,
-0.40470966696739197,
0.9525542855262756,
-0.3091210126876831,
-0.4604993164539337,
-0.8071324229240417,
-0.751694917678833,
-0.0780164897441864,
-0.09328510612249374,
0.2012607902288437,
-0.08117499202489853,
-0.10803893208503723,
0.7938131093978882,
-0.5323401689529419,
0.9475278854370117,
-0.1473143845796585,
-0.2734437584877014,
0.28041940927505493,
0.044522110372781754,
1.1029576063156128,
-0.3611626923084259,
0.27297553420066833,
-0.07242871075868607,
-0.4264731705188751,
-0.531835675239563,
-0.6255090236663818,
0.6716390252113342,
-0.8348466157913208,
-0.5641300678253174,
-0.32805049419403076,
-0.934067964553833,
-0.42071276903152466,
0.1561194360256195,
-0.3092648684978485,
0.30910012125968933,
-0.43187251687049866,
0.08894096314907074,
0.3066039979457855,
-0.0100325932726264,
0.29016396403312683,
0.621692955493927,
-0.21311239898204803,
-0.2306639850139618,
0.9236003756523132,
0.04890155792236328,
0.3572779595851898,
0.3408188819885254,
0.0180311668664217,
-0.11240359395742416,
-0.37032002210617065,
0.04824068769812584,
0.24941955506801605,
-0.5260366201400757,
0.04344957694411278,
-0.2599089443683624,
-0.08542035520076752,
-0.07367736846208572,
-0.2629874348640442,
-0.3515344560146332,
-0.021554118022322655,
-0.13638228178024292,
0.38460788130760193,
0.019539181143045425,
0.8861960172653198,
-0.04222773388028145,
0.0076476591639220715,
-0.7117575407028198,
0.24413932859897614,
0.36951693892478943,
0.16381850838661194,
0.2215963751077652,
-0.07482636719942093,
-0.6731323599815369,
0.10835134983062744,
-0.29408395290374756,
-0.63290935754776,
0.311935156583786,
-0.1704408824443817,
0.7174689173698425,
-0.04378657042980194,
0.25301340222358704,
0.25032079219818115,
-0.11743974685668945,
0.33547350764274597,
0.12156900018453598,
-0.8008974194526672,
0.1580663025379181,
-0.514856219291687,
0.2269173115491867,
0.2534369230270386,
0.12257836759090424,
-0.5557681322097778,
-0.5528127551078796,
-0.48617395758628845,
-0.8658013939857483,
0.9130033850669861,
0.41734081506729126,
-0.755107581615448,
0.4296107888221741,
0.03251873701810837,
-0.28850027918815613,
0.19500039517879486,
-0.3671385943889618,
-0.10949744284152985,
0.28689709305763245,
-0.07410784065723419,
-0.05141862854361534,
0.0513424426317215,
-0.17335891723632812,
0.04409313201904297,
0.5216177701950073,
-0.09983249008655548,
0.08881804347038269,
0.08077723532915115,
-0.17877960205078125,
-0.40474316477775574,
0.29221880435943604,
0.6048287153244019,
0.5406318306922913,
0.06313049048185349,
0.03422538563609123,
0.39778855443000793,
-0.16977497935295105,
0.33882245421409607,
0.10188698023557663,
0.34050530195236206,
-0.5890001654624939,
0.5780690908432007,
0.47066643834114075,
0.43158799409866333,
-1.1085829734802246,
0.40226030349731445,
-0.04937783256173134,
-0.27303987741470337,
-0.48948484659194946,
0.1555553525686264,
0.3890106976032257,
0.7557108998298645,
0.2715727984905243,
-0.0673229992389679,
-0.192310631275177,
-0.620602011680603,
-0.022022495046257973,
0.520715594291687,
-0.11485467851161957,
-0.2615857720375061,
0.323270320892334,
0.6286100745201111,
-0.7204994559288025,
0.6022949814796448,
-0.46889787912368774,
-0.855232298374176,
0.9037310481071472,
0.4307819604873657,
0.7831870913505554,
-0.05871814861893654,
0.2028237283229828,
-0.05079081282019615,
-0.024106422439217567,
-0.2786600887775421,
0.307932049036026,
-0.1406540721654892,
-0.7086420059204102,
-0.7966315746307373,
-0.030610036104917526,
-0.8038679957389832,
-0.15722054243087769,
-0.31035009026527405,
0.08778070658445358,
-0.18181708455085754,
-0.2323058694601059,
-0.2789291441440582,
0.4662087559700012,
-0.5295951962471008,
-0.13289569318294525,
0.16734793782234192,
0.26232993602752686,
-0.8179650902748108,
1.1133819818496704,
0.9284626245498657,
-0.3264389932155609,
-0.9593347311019897,
0.14914663136005402,
0.028087785467505455,
-0.3256693482398987,
0.7070052027702332,
-0.16525141894817352,
-0.40474385023117065,
-0.014689479023218155,
-0.437524676322937,
-0.7178694009780884,
1.3070467710494995,
0.37361860275268555,
-0.6772987246513367,
-0.17622773349285126,
0.3499617576599121,
0.6796175837516785,
-0.4455838203430176,
-0.011479292996227741,
0.37535375356674194,
0.5689572095870972,
0.034351930022239685,
-1.4198507070541382,
0.3001200556755066,
-0.09409602731466293,
-0.03802870959043503,
0.3373155891895294,
-0.7180512547492981,
0.7831825017929077,
-0.3388495445251465,
-0.05339261516928673,
0.04499075189232826,
0.6886506676673889,
0.39751240611076355,
0.27005940675735474,
0.9712415933609009,
0.43316301703453064,
0.6601923108100891,
0.3321026563644409,
0.63338303565979,
-0.1453939974308014,
0.558837354183197,
1.0942494869232178,
-0.5808570981025696,
0.7842198014259338,
0.4813925325870514,
-0.22309701144695282,
0.4903327524662018,
0.24119088053703308,
0.10485454648733139,
0.32469937205314636,
0.27834323048591614,
-0.5065814256668091,
-0.6159906983375549,
-0.49986451864242554,
0.16748753190040588,
0.3076353073120117,
0.00032983472920022905,
0.25773507356643677,
-0.23554082214832306,
0.19665692746639252,
-0.04906267300248146,
0.16709688305854797,
-0.2182985246181488,
0.8075281381607056,
0.16857406497001648,
-0.9772634506225586,
0.31423166394233704,
0.14458106458187103,
0.6647180914878845,
-0.3701864778995514,
-0.2568298876285553,
0.369506299495697,
0.31178781390190125,
-0.30489906668663025,
-0.8381483554840088,
0.1456296741962433,
-0.2984078526496887,
-0.3852163553237915,
0.08767484873533249,
0.7513096332550049,
-0.8842925429344177,
0.06795831024646759,
0.6475126147270203,
0.6997301578521729,
-0.04540698975324631,
-0.171004056930542,
-0.7211628556251526,
0.04748023301362991,
-0.12817755341529846,
0.007813320495188236,
0.657569169998169,
0.17164042592048645,
-0.3454535901546478,
1.0125434398651123,
0.7425281405448914,
0.06622353196144104,
-0.43642330169677734,
-0.029062774032354355,
0.7870033383369446,
-0.6549023389816284,
-0.5558927655220032,
-0.5079775452613831,
0.2158621996641159,
0.12013544887304306,
0.21613021194934845,
0.3404526114463806,
0.19748660922050476,
0.6969695687294006,
0.10681678354740143,
0.7556518912315369,
-0.11666527390480042,
0.34125271439552307,
-0.12060025334358215,
0.5032797455787659,
-0.5374273061752319,
0.15777425467967987,
-0.10289409756660461,
-0.78919917345047,
-0.10416097939014435,
0.4483449161052704,
-0.18424025177955627,
0.1396871954202652,
0.7201455235481262,
0.8970283269882202,
0.21242402493953705,
-0.19027847051620483,
0.44071468710899353,
0.1010281890630722,
0.5797008275985718,
0.8574057221412659,
0.8854367733001709,
0.23741422593593597,
0.6616732478141785,
-0.37674084305763245,
-0.23780295252799988,
-0.4551835358142853,
-0.713858962059021,
-0.92696613073349,
-0.8313552737236023,
-0.2107577621936798,
-0.393198698759079,
0.1959814876317978,
1.6068814992904663,
0.5860865116119385,
-0.36014148592948914,
-0.4625203311443329,
-0.19414351880550385,
0.14764846861362457,
-0.2787478566169739,
-0.12028773874044418,
0.17155148088932037,
-0.18344929814338684,
-0.6473817825317383,
0.4827546179294586,
0.045749228447675705,
-0.11649692058563232,
-0.7128297686576843,
-0.6388425230979919,
-0.2999366819858551,
-0.06654904037714005,
0.382131963968277,
0.5779469609260559,
-0.7821288704872131,
-0.058293890208005905,
-0.10255298018455505,
-0.2973538935184479,
-0.09518905729055405,
1.1654447317123413,
-0.6440368294715881,
0.24970601499080658,
0.5208165049552917,
0.6595997214317322,
0.4668535888195038,
0.09466814994812012,
0.7905594110488892,
-0.5514867901802063,
0.11137105524539948,
0.3097386658191681,
0.36835581064224243,
0.18662132322788239,
-0.21589677035808563,
0.38782721757888794,
0.18057295680046082,
-1.0022082328796387,
-0.7066020965576172,
0.15549898147583008,
-0.9652706980705261,
-0.3754434287548065,
0.9320506453514099,
-0.39024046063423157,
-0.3172602951526642,
-0.6254681348800659,
-0.28542783856391907,
0.4784802496433258,
-0.6566712856292725,
0.8344919681549072,
0.4661046862602234,
-0.18693074584007263,
0.13488097488880157,
-0.22983400523662567,
0.2759040892124176,
0.6400395035743713,
-1.087703824043274,
0.19910146296024323,
0.2549714744091034,
0.002292684745043516,
0.1682841032743454,
0.5871111750602722,
0.48244383931159973,
0.4050183892250061,
-0.14532023668289185,
0.5153011083602905,
-0.4183379113674164,
-0.5559971928596497,
-0.14145852625370026,
-0.04341398552060127,
0.3749333918094635,
-0.02410375513136387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12913v1 | OPDAI at SemEval-2024 Task 6: Small LLMs can Accelerate Hallucination Detection with Weakly Supervised Data | 2024-02-20T11:01:39 | 2024-02-20T11:01:39 | Chengcheng Wei, Ze Chen, Songtan Fang, Jiarong He, Max Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper mainly describes a unified system for hallucination detection of
LLMs, which wins the second prize in the model-agnostic track of the
SemEval-2024 Task 6, and also achieves considerable results in the model-aware
track. This task aims to detect hallucination with LLMs for three different
text-generation tasks without labeled training data. We utilize prompt
engineering and few-shot learning to verify the performance of different LLMs
on the validation data. Then we select the LLMs with better performance to
generate high-quality weakly supervised training data, which not only satisfies
the consistency of different LLMs, but also satisfies the consistency of the
optimal LLM with different sampling parameters. Furthermore, we finetune
different LLMs by using the constructed training data, and finding that a
relatively small LLM can achieve a competitive level of performance in
hallucination detection, when compared to the large LLMs and the prompt-based
approaches using GPT-4. | [
-0.49097028374671936,
-0.8504102826118469,
0.9968395829200745,
0.012780326418578625,
-0.4180598258972168,
-0.5023279786109924,
-0.2126520723104477,
-0.4900756776332855,
0.3337196111679077,
0.4114826023578644,
-0.6423400640487671,
-0.733540952205658,
-0.5124949216842651,
0.6166295409202576,
-0.23136328160762787,
0.6409114599227905,
0.010778945870697498,
0.16820716857910156,
-0.39857426285743713,
-0.011083516292273998,
-0.41845691204071045,
-0.3209744095802307,
-0.4846382737159729,
-0.44885751605033875,
0.49259504675865173,
0.5709238052368164,
0.2680417001247406,
0.3970932960510254,
0.463355153799057,
0.2769749164581299,
-0.15015394985675812,
0.4991728663444519,
-0.31849879026412964,
0.09823641926050186,
0.07509443163871765,
-0.34045669436454773,
-0.6420114040374756,
-0.18792928755283356,
0.3289420008659363,
0.5511869788169861,
0.211859330534935,
0.029311129823327065,
0.32316887378692627,
0.27203571796417236,
-0.5141639113426208,
-0.07707858830690384,
-0.7235039472579956,
0.3154545724391937,
-0.26781901717185974,
-0.37073639035224915,
-0.5351431369781494,
-0.24555839598178864,
-0.32458698749542236,
-0.16139036417007446,
0.39695265889167786,
0.2059057205915451,
0.6950095295906067,
0.7240192294120789,
-0.19504095613956451,
-0.37132057547569275,
-0.28749173879623413,
0.7442517876625061,
-0.7129684686660767,
0.248246431350708,
0.4267386794090271,
-0.00028884722269140184,
-0.26884394884109497,
-0.6565474271774292,
-0.45424947142601013,
0.006069440394639969,
-0.18078653514385223,
0.040256816893815994,
0.07084525376558304,
0.10037781298160553,
0.4023825228214264,
0.24024395644664764,
-0.6266811490058899,
0.4988687336444855,
-0.3489910066127777,
-0.45281878113746643,
0.42967307567596436,
0.347732275724411,
0.026253098621964455,
-0.42162153124809265,
-0.2967747151851654,
0.27933159470558167,
-0.7155143022537231,
-0.3206508755683899,
0.34226909279823303,
0.4390113949775696,
-0.05443223565816879,
0.6250123977661133,
-0.26179805397987366,
0.39693769812583923,
-0.05366058275103569,
-0.18831007182598114,
0.517490029335022,
-0.40641316771507263,
-0.1786053627729416,
0.2361638844013214,
0.8822799921035767,
-0.06174113601446152,
-0.2089006006717682,
-0.17842566967010498,
-0.46879321336746216,
0.3243335783481598,
0.09147223085165024,
-0.8934915661811829,
-0.2517947554588318,
0.07069756090641022,
-0.6624079346656799,
-0.5416507720947266,
-0.16316181421279907,
-0.826934814453125,
-0.5837908387184143,
-0.4837362766265869,
0.7434614300727844,
-0.21066494286060333,
0.046322051435709,
0.057688239961862564,
0.16880352795124054,
0.2870503067970276,
0.479776531457901,
-0.9054663181304932,
0.23590217530727386,
0.5106900334358215,
0.8560196757316589,
-0.6809282898902893,
-0.3350471258163452,
-0.9769948124885559,
-0.23311559855937958,
-0.27805009484291077,
1.0031335353851318,
-0.16325588524341583,
-0.24856260418891907,
-0.16358992457389832,
0.2322310358285904,
0.11249915510416031,
-0.7015590667724609,
0.9792056083679199,
0.08069901168346405,
0.05060926452279091,
-0.31503182649612427,
-0.4718683362007141,
-0.038681138306856155,
0.10242551565170288,
-0.5039849281311035,
1.0216065645217896,
-0.21866340935230255,
-0.5980852246284485,
0.35707443952560425,
-0.1716127097606659,
-0.42743775248527527,
0.12228870391845703,
-0.7092764377593994,
-0.7668473720550537,
0.358396053314209,
0.34101778268814087,
0.7356482744216919,
-0.19684134423732758,
0.14135242998600006,
-0.2947085499763489,
-0.8532978296279907,
-0.07454822957515717,
-0.44158512353897095,
0.33364632725715637,
0.05187268555164337,
-0.7322450280189514,
0.14280639588832855,
-0.8601250052452087,
-0.21631334722042084,
0.08907466381788254,
-0.110340915620327,
-0.03709610924124718,
-0.06645872443914413,
-0.2144647091627121,
0.06722712516784668,
0.323617160320282,
-0.3873409032821655,
0.30263596773147583,
-0.32492494583129883,
0.051739078015089035,
0.8555724620819092,
0.12251386046409607,
0.4410099387168884,
-0.23154638707637787,
0.3581218123435974,
0.08121166378259659,
-0.02049862965941429,
0.03867645934224129,
-0.6091175675392151,
-1.0348596572875977,
-0.31399625539779663,
0.16858214139938354,
0.20564554631710052,
-0.7274550199508667,
0.5618061423301697,
0.08866660296916962,
-0.14939533174037933,
-0.3766261637210846,
0.3430481255054474,
0.11167167127132416,
0.5300675630569458,
0.5044236183166504,
0.07721861451864243,
-0.750633955001831,
-0.9027260541915894,
-0.022020382806658745,
0.008669705130159855,
-0.015091263689100742,
0.2147974967956543,
0.7728096842765808,
-0.5580549836158752,
0.4462723433971405,
-0.377514511346817,
-0.8231054544448853,
-0.11757896840572357,
0.4674113690853119,
0.34689366817474365,
0.27293965220451355,
0.2878947854042053,
-0.48281556367874146,
-0.07334873825311661,
-0.17922723293304443,
-1.1572363376617432,
-0.45180314779281616,
0.06382427364587784,
0.06713523715734482,
0.5161439180374146,
0.7431586980819702,
-0.21484489738941193,
0.5172160863876343,
0.2437117099761963,
-0.1589491069316864,
0.3154671788215637,
-0.1072966605424881,
0.16593526303768158,
-0.854752779006958,
-0.37740617990493774,
-0.35636278986930847,
-0.28997108340263367,
-0.4833393394947052,
-0.4420168101787567,
-0.021641438826918602,
0.13452264666557312,
-0.5103791356086731,
0.2766122817993164,
-0.5464470386505127,
-0.30638667941093445,
-0.5755848288536072,
0.18217982351779938,
-0.3882175385951996,
0.5595272779464722,
0.29867368936538696,
0.46516525745391846,
0.5419806838035583,
-0.5413317680358887,
0.09814279526472092,
0.1490248441696167,
-0.17169693112373352,
0.3908975124359131,
-0.5217267870903015,
0.39902377128601074,
-0.08514418452978134,
-0.20944108068943024,
-0.9641297459602356,
-0.510873556137085,
0.28629159927368164,
-0.45755571126937866,
-0.005102584604173899,
0.18234527111053467,
-0.6494095921516418,
-0.28612998127937317,
-0.4314020872116089,
0.2178788036108017,
0.6925570368766785,
-0.8877685070037842,
0.5145288705825806,
0.08567054569721222,
0.02243267558515072,
-0.18680045008659363,
-0.7270352840423584,
-0.1766403168439865,
-0.3311951756477356,
-0.5959785580635071,
0.2557337284088135,
-0.03401591628789902,
-0.03674839809536934,
-0.180214986205101,
-0.13919568061828613,
0.33924445509910583,
0.13437911868095398,
0.48019665479660034,
0.10353056341409683,
-0.16314350068569183,
0.22562584280967712,
0.18371911346912384,
-0.28129515051841736,
0.07361230254173279,
-0.004388800822198391,
0.46505221724510193,
-0.33832848072052,
-0.5503798127174377,
-0.5240564942359924,
0.017737144604325294,
0.12578420341014862,
0.49563220143318176,
0.387144535779953,
0.8028899431228638,
-0.7756732702255249,
-0.5248745083808899,
-0.4235078990459442,
-0.6647002100944519,
-0.45640385150909424,
0.009057946503162384,
-0.5781236290931702,
-0.9374078512191772,
0.39317700266838074,
-0.14892230927944183,
-0.342057466506958,
0.43613749742507935,
0.7313753962516785,
-0.039817046374082565,
1.2003443241119385,
0.3858785331249237,
0.03968210890889168,
-0.14729534089565277,
-0.03639993816614151,
0.10495845973491669,
-0.6432752013206482,
-0.30326852202415466,
-0.544825553894043,
-0.4577457010746002,
-0.46565940976142883,
-0.3148801326751709,
0.44898858666419983,
0.08449982106685638,
0.016699690371751785,
0.13677571713924408,
-0.8320018649101257,
0.331452339887619,
0.349313884973526,
0.17284680902957916,
0.5274294018745422,
-0.001148883136920631,
-0.13643454015254974,
-0.2929951548576355,
-0.45717814564704895,
-0.6662693619728088,
0.9176859855651855,
0.19878603518009186,
0.9616393446922302,
-0.038279999047517776,
1.1816805601119995,
0.4183947443962097,
-0.029032479971647263,
-0.8453058004379272,
0.8118012547492981,
0.02711598016321659,
-0.0914972797036171,
-0.3629012107849121,
-0.2602054178714752,
-0.7961617708206177,
0.3128848969936371,
-0.10871390253305435,
-0.818544864654541,
0.25609931349754333,
-0.05696862190961838,
-0.33889225125312805,
-0.003004780039191246,
-0.37566396594047546,
0.6930718421936035,
-0.2091943919658661,
-0.5026963949203491,
0.24395878612995148,
-0.3872793912887573,
0.5733208060264587,
-0.2629660964012146,
-0.006784815341234207,
-0.12470781803131104,
-0.1637723445892334,
0.7632990479469299,
-0.5113040208816528,
0.8206959366798401,
-0.1976933479309082,
-0.15106408298015594,
0.21875935792922974,
-0.23850388824939728,
0.7885403037071228,
0.23424336314201355,
0.08741738647222519,
-0.04110687971115112,
-0.44544875621795654,
-0.025002844631671906,
-0.2971067428588867,
0.8644076585769653,
-0.5300170183181763,
-0.4864179491996765,
-0.5325470566749573,
-0.18819941580295563,
-0.13651292026042938,
0.16840218007564545,
0.8276906609535217,
0.12583208084106445,
0.028818467631936073,
0.3818337023258209,
0.8263570666313171,
-0.007724856957793236,
0.36751869320869446,
0.06265974789857864,
-0.21826289594173431,
-0.2404651641845703,
0.9469400644302368,
-0.04643445089459419,
-0.186062291264534,
0.1253649890422821,
0.12776604294776917,
-0.3619682192802429,
-0.9376782774925232,
-0.1556626707315445,
0.32356664538383484,
-0.8030107617378235,
-0.3783054053783417,
-0.8105026483535767,
-0.24670015275478363,
-0.42018923163414,
-0.25589966773986816,
-0.41184675693511963,
-0.053583841770887375,
-0.7340477108955383,
-0.0893806591629982,
0.1783357411623001,
0.6817378997802734,
-0.1444280445575714,
0.18018698692321777,
-0.3444010615348816,
0.6968778967857361,
0.344883531332016,
-0.156156525015831,
-0.4142524003982544,
-0.6926345825195312,
0.05788807198405266,
-0.24266327917575836,
-0.33248576521873474,
-0.5448510646820068,
0.3837758004665375,
-0.02774004638195038,
0.5502562522888184,
0.5202259421348572,
0.13232584297657013,
0.6385704874992371,
-0.3381853997707367,
0.8125103116035461,
0.1447516232728958,
-0.8211909532546997,
0.8503172993659973,
-0.18192139267921448,
0.19584596157073975,
0.8281562328338623,
0.20204408466815948,
0.1828627735376358,
-0.45203879475593567,
-0.6319814920425415,
-0.5600852370262146,
0.8036916851997375,
0.4055473208427429,
-0.23228144645690918,
0.10298249870538712,
0.26377007365226746,
0.3942575752735138,
0.14017392694950104,
-0.9140150547027588,
-0.1061311587691307,
0.15335431694984436,
-0.31292808055877686,
0.12132775038480759,
-0.33456340432167053,
0.14236608147621155,
-0.1571834236383438,
0.8023279309272766,
-0.4299410581588745,
0.4441710412502289,
0.2125128209590912,
-0.2106361836194992,
-0.016262628138065338,
0.18355950713157654,
0.6884141564369202,
0.2284144014120102,
-0.3063949644565582,
0.4282095730304718,
0.5393514633178711,
-0.3747445046901703,
0.32157960534095764,
-0.07567749917507172,
-0.3973037004470825,
0.27487120032310486,
0.4161236882209778,
0.8544305562973022,
0.2733297646045685,
-0.3858894109725952,
0.6488738059997559,
-0.1059085950255394,
-0.567847728729248,
-0.44597840309143066,
0.22673553228378296,
-0.01366959698498249,
0.39255762100219727,
0.22158275544643402,
-0.00001039932612911798,
0.377400279045105,
-0.25598180294036865,
0.27510517835617065,
0.26005780696868896,
-0.3075469434261322,
-0.45076459646224976,
0.9203704595565796,
0.043141815811395645,
-0.1948045939207077,
0.26414480805397034,
-0.6108183860778809,
-0.3031677305698395,
0.46025702357292175,
0.40509602427482605,
0.9428380131721497,
-0.03747163340449333,
-0.030647611245512962,
0.3741432726383209,
0.33814847469329834,
-0.3425125777721405,
0.6682336330413818,
-0.17287908494472504,
-0.6250826120376587,
-0.013557600788772106,
-0.7302647233009338,
-0.23747625946998596,
0.6764754056930542,
-0.4672795236110687,
0.8668798208236694,
-0.17903487384319305,
-0.06970646977424622,
-0.0913233533501625,
-0.07933162152767181,
-0.6926733255386353,
0.05269724503159523,
0.2520388662815094,
0.39230963587760925,
-0.8274636268615723,
0.6444131731987,
0.47444260120391846,
-0.26114967465400696,
-0.5640419125556946,
-0.00010980730439769104,
0.3694252073764801,
-0.5162854194641113,
0.7092074155807495,
0.40447109937667847,
-0.3610081970691681,
-0.023936059325933456,
-0.6110920906066895,
-0.304200679063797,
1.3541858196258545,
0.17915625870227814,
-0.5644391179084778,
-0.16783128678798676,
0.06854356080293655,
0.35250213742256165,
-0.3478812575340271,
-0.03036222793161869,
0.5858915448188782,
0.40183278918266296,
0.22276714444160461,
-0.5339215397834778,
0.04595021530985832,
0.03625946864485741,
-0.12674473226070404,
0.07780374586582184,
-0.46935924887657166,
0.6803029179573059,
-0.0747743546962738,
-0.17456117272377014,
0.5366886258125305,
0.9202128648757935,
0.630903959274292,
0.6370149850845337,
0.42270779609680176,
0.6827452182769775,
0.9160664677619934,
-0.33673518896102905,
0.6088175177574158,
0.13716858625411987,
0.29603344202041626,
1.182948112487793,
-0.3455169200897217,
0.6693145036697388,
0.6488776803016663,
0.05649704858660698,
-0.01748894527554512,
0.7851575016975403,
-0.10012724250555038,
0.6362978219985962,
0.13082240521907806,
-0.24212461709976196,
-0.4298696219921112,
-0.22642071545124054,
-0.4668843150138855,
0.5490750670433044,
0.262426495552063,
-0.38778388500213623,
-0.17187514901161194,
0.4990071952342987,
-0.19704222679138184,
-0.07593856006860733,
-0.3407628536224365,
0.783592164516449,
0.38277849555015564,
-0.5929095149040222,
0.7159318923950195,
-0.22290630638599396,
1.0737377405166626,
-0.17755088210105896,
-0.009798869490623474,
-0.3845716118812561,
0.25938495993614197,
-0.34898310899734497,
-0.2726207673549652,
0.07844974845647812,
0.08246589452028275,
0.0242224782705307,
-0.16738387942314148,
1.2580703496932983,
-0.19812257587909698,
-0.400000661611557,
0.34533587098121643,
0.651138186454773,
0.607531726360321,
-0.020952150225639343,
-0.10896632820367813,
0.3001022934913635,
-0.03205650672316551,
-0.21495194733142853,
0.23651546239852905,
0.7023201584815979,
0.05035294219851494,
0.20544467866420746,
0.22948193550109863,
0.12826575338840485,
-0.009265481494367123,
0.39873552322387695,
0.5708153247833252,
-0.5998196005821228,
-0.24756206572055817,
-0.8929570317268372,
0.11808169633150101,
-0.08047674596309662,
-0.2256518453359604,
0.917011022567749,
0.612114667892456,
0.7141079306602478,
-0.25283294916152954,
0.6317262053489685,
0.22575245797634125,
0.47112008929252625,
-0.9195104241371155,
0.4510537385940552,
-0.7617254257202148,
0.41746070981025696,
-0.32871395349502563,
-0.9772330522537231,
-0.1850992739200592,
0.7215247750282288,
-0.1960563063621521,
0.0221645999699831,
0.8926884531974792,
0.96075838804245,
-0.011582077480852604,
0.29098597168922424,
0.6251738667488098,
0.18967628479003906,
0.004752232693135738,
0.6367581486701965,
1.1432619094848633,
-0.5567464232444763,
0.4186023771762848,
-0.18784332275390625,
0.02749483287334442,
-0.4043205678462982,
-0.7941305041313171,
-1.1804965734481812,
-0.5449913144111633,
-0.40146759152412415,
-0.0951596200466156,
-0.21303974092006683,
0.6884085536003113,
0.5375040173530579,
-0.8567050695419312,
0.13194110989570618,
-0.48548704385757446,
0.17488691210746765,
0.04375921189785004,
-0.23882701992988586,
0.3833843469619751,
-0.6429281234741211,
-0.9555867910385132,
0.6987859606742859,
0.4335511028766632,
0.26916417479515076,
-0.1363392174243927,
-0.31020572781562805,
0.0012601847993209958,
-0.25727251172065735,
0.5620810985565186,
-0.15865427255630493,
-0.7282419800758362,
-0.358124315738678,
0.03475010022521019,
-0.23263338208198547,
0.05068550631403923,
0.5590842962265015,
-0.7292723059654236,
0.10630212724208832,
0.7644214034080505,
0.7162940502166748,
0.5364611148834229,
-0.13487160205841064,
-0.030009634792804718,
-0.6757659912109375,
0.28354015946388245,
0.43919676542282104,
0.5606201887130737,
0.1334863305091858,
-0.5279275178909302,
0.9083069562911987,
0.5171393752098083,
-0.850957453250885,
-1.054944396018982,
-0.10740821063518524,
-0.9650489091873169,
-0.2643549144268036,
1.260265588760376,
0.3617958128452301,
-0.2281772792339325,
-0.11331064999103546,
-0.20254652202129364,
0.015584665350615978,
-0.24507904052734375,
0.6397407054901123,
0.7613085508346558,
-0.6005808711051941,
-0.2303164303302765,
-0.6379402875900269,
0.7485895752906799,
0.5563333630561829,
-1.1859736442565918,
-0.4800017178058624,
0.6232934594154358,
-0.18995647132396698,
0.2167387455701828,
0.8153347373008728,
-0.02130177989602089,
0.36334678530693054,
0.0029380840715020895,
-0.09814106673002243,
-0.046057116240262985,
-0.5885193347930908,
-0.5189868807792664,
0.22941939532756805,
0.02803628146648407,
-0.30634254217147827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12890v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12890v1 | More Discriminative Sentence Embeddings via Semantic Graph Smoothing | 2024-02-20T10:34:19 | 2024-02-20T10:34:19 | Chakib Fettal, Lazhar Labiod, Mohamed Nadif | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper explores an empirical approach to learn more discriminantive
sentence representations in an unsupervised fashion. Leveraging semantic graph
smoothing, we enhance sentence embeddings obtained from pretrained models to
improve results for the text clustering and classification tasks. Our method,
validated on eight benchmarks, demonstrates consistent improvements, showcasing
the potential of semantic graph smoothing in improving sentence embeddings for
the supervised and unsupervised document categorization tasks. | [
-0.2679596543312073,
-0.9898731112480164,
0.8934008479118347,
-0.07014333456754684,
-0.39557722210884094,
0.22148673236370087,
-0.3790816068649292,
-0.24825963377952576,
0.2868366539478302,
0.6860954165458679,
-0.46961724758148193,
-1.1259891986846924,
-0.9657625555992126,
-0.027017906308174133,
-0.5817917585372925,
0.8047357201576233,
-0.028989505022764206,
0.09371186792850494,
-0.5517852306365967,
0.06780625134706497,
-0.4953807294368744,
-0.47821754217147827,
-0.3345235586166382,
-0.46726980805397034,
0.40038901567459106,
0.3650341331958771,
0.5893916487693787,
0.5328242778778076,
0.34452271461486816,
0.3108699917793274,
0.19037339091300964,
0.3778896927833557,
-0.5988305807113647,
0.06757622957229614,
0.2646259069442749,
-0.48937904834747314,
-0.131840318441391,
0.23518642783164978,
0.5643213391304016,
1.0811583995819092,
-0.26783493161201477,
-0.2111417055130005,
0.015784727409482002,
0.4147375226020813,
-0.36307454109191895,
0.49727335572242737,
-0.5262728929519653,
0.10260521620512009,
-0.2595401108264923,
-0.2466287761926651,
-0.72016441822052,
-0.47187525033950806,
0.04100373014807701,
-0.9502329230308533,
0.4511048495769501,
0.23140233755111694,
0.7973816394805908,
0.26257309317588806,
-0.9205392003059387,
0.03803890198469162,
-0.46712982654571533,
0.55721116065979,
-0.5503247976303101,
0.5598202347755432,
0.40495818853378296,
-0.01994265802204609,
-0.5129812955856323,
-1.2176018953323364,
-0.31706929206848145,
-0.19079264998435974,
-0.1273213028907776,
0.185155987739563,
-0.10987567901611328,
0.26949477195739746,
0.17050610482692719,
0.17423251271247864,
-0.46926066279411316,
0.5219703912734985,
-0.06191423907876015,
-0.2251567542552948,
0.6405892968177795,
-0.02036106213927269,
0.31273558735847473,
-0.01597738265991211,
-0.1712329238653183,
-0.48572036623954773,
-0.31291794776916504,
0.005864391569048166,
0.547877848148346,
0.38770827651023865,
0.26589760184288025,
0.5999679565429688,
-0.3007543385028839,
0.753275990486145,
-0.079169861972332,
0.12187987565994263,
0.7664023637771606,
-0.01849224604666233,
0.03797673434019089,
0.3230848014354706,
0.5071064829826355,
0.6483585834503174,
0.42402344942092896,
-0.3510749936103821,
0.10017016530036926,
0.6421123743057251,
0.3737461268901825,
-0.7626475691795349,
-0.44666966795921326,
0.019324172288179398,
-0.5719386339187622,
-0.03891517221927643,
0.42761602997779846,
-0.8355986475944519,
-0.31419023871421814,
-0.19560600817203522,
-0.148598313331604,
-0.5084872245788574,
0.008558386005461216,
0.44773298501968384,
-0.6639683246612549,
-0.2506770193576813,
0.30132269859313965,
-0.6625446677207947,
0.4066516160964966,
0.8033098578453064,
0.6186656951904297,
0.0031398413702845573,
-0.21271011233329773,
-0.49802106618881226,
0.12464939802885056,
-0.417337030172348,
1.1283801794052124,
-0.9465718865394592,
-0.4604596793651581,
0.34195476770401,
0.226724311709404,
-0.2722630798816681,
-0.1732771098613739,
0.890075147151947,
-0.35424017906188965,
0.22925777733325958,
-0.06951501220464706,
-1.0145841836929321,
-0.45697543025016785,
0.10559543967247009,
-0.49946504831314087,
1.2952473163604736,
0.2649921774864197,
-0.7898274064064026,
0.8606249094009399,
-0.46968531608581543,
-0.5308821797370911,
0.004280388355255127,
-0.0554363876581192,
-0.5418153405189514,
0.1744084656238556,
0.499153196811676,
0.6801283359527588,
0.24665327370166779,
0.34202563762664795,
-0.573580801486969,
-0.37481242418289185,
0.041642509400844574,
-0.20142552256584167,
0.4235583245754242,
-0.01805037260055542,
-0.04007923975586891,
0.3109525144100189,
-0.8251413106918335,
0.031222976744174957,
-0.021298415958881378,
0.023346221074461937,
-0.7549223899841309,
-0.03867008909583092,
0.26823690533638,
0.001312070875428617,
-0.06050455942749977,
-0.9603542685508728,
0.04557306319475174,
-0.5847328901290894,
0.409927636384964,
0.6110662221908569,
0.1425953358411789,
0.5132154822349548,
-0.061787594109773636,
0.2644321024417877,
0.16562002897262573,
-0.18135634064674377,
-0.058814361691474915,
-0.6377326846122742,
-0.6494476795196533,
-0.26180508732795715,
0.4099348187446594,
0.3312554955482483,
-0.6436750888824463,
0.7159520387649536,
-0.36428967118263245,
-0.36769917607307434,
-0.6125912070274353,
0.16040872037410736,
0.32710447907447815,
0.306933730840683,
0.36801233887672424,
-0.43833088874816895,
-0.39928629994392395,
-0.5649567246437073,
-0.19069579243659973,
0.10581853985786438,
0.030081486329436302,
-0.07146541029214859,
0.4407258629798889,
-0.18090733885765076,
0.8075332641601562,
-0.9955216646194458,
-0.4885474145412445,
-0.1552497297525406,
0.4297514855861664,
-0.19294992089271545,
0.39733707904815674,
0.4356187582015991,
-0.707628071308136,
-0.4405289590358734,
-0.021056875586509705,
-0.5648004412651062,
0.08452491462230682,
0.22147372364997864,
-0.17922118306159973,
0.12171424180269241,
1.0038903951644897,
-0.6283974647521973,
0.6826089024543762,
0.1294318288564682,
-0.6305112242698669,
-0.09193335473537445,
-0.6682576537132263,
-0.0015164228389039636,
-0.8557152152061462,
-0.4143398404121399,
0.12308575212955475,
-0.7566482424736023,
-0.40853846073150635,
0.030626334249973297,
-0.08014135807752609,
-0.060622438788414,
-0.16046923398971558,
0.08645453304052353,
-0.6593189835548401,
-0.15654052793979645,
-0.25694891810417175,
0.7289162874221802,
0.15832597017288208,
0.42881929874420166,
-0.026755578815937042,
0.3079892098903656,
0.5041248798370361,
-0.37707486748695374,
0.1915523111820221,
0.5694375038146973,
-0.3994344174861908,
0.2748469114303589,
-0.6123589873313904,
0.04569831117987633,
-0.5407422184944153,
0.6510447263717651,
-1.0844390392303467,
0.0723608210682869,
-0.1903783529996872,
-0.24380625784397125,
0.28194886445999146,
0.20155948400497437,
-0.8051270246505737,
-0.6011801362037659,
-0.37283819913864136,
-0.2072259485721588,
0.6645476222038269,
-0.5273285508155823,
0.36100462079048157,
0.4637056291103363,
0.11466340720653534,
-0.07950504869222641,
-0.5520895719528198,
-0.12305597960948944,
-0.327203631401062,
-0.4958759844303131,
0.6764966249465942,
0.42639467120170593,
-0.015644589439034462,
0.13523556292057037,
0.190178781747818,
0.0902753695845604,
0.14878056943416595,
0.38262221217155457,
0.08363707363605499,
-0.07413613051176071,
0.3498157262802124,
0.3609029948711395,
-0.5282191038131714,
-0.11788516491651535,
-0.5271817445755005,
0.739595890045166,
0.2711758315563202,
-0.25369560718536377,
-0.399505615234375,
0.5304251313209534,
-0.13926933705806732,
-0.29771673679351807,
0.6054542064666748,
1.1331478357315063,
-0.2055995762348175,
-0.22475387156009674,
-0.28033447265625,
-0.24453991651535034,
-0.42032644152641296,
0.5031217932701111,
-0.14327949285507202,
-1.4560792446136475,
0.3135305643081665,
-0.5138238668441772,
-0.19794246554374695,
0.4604954421520233,
0.2507157027721405,
0.014087365008890629,
1.3156661987304688,
0.9307667016983032,
0.270411878824234,
0.4609319865703583,
-0.13221463561058044,
0.3316771388053894,
-0.6616625785827637,
-0.2661803960800171,
-0.6773313283920288,
-0.03514936566352844,
-0.9786381721496582,
-0.3159754276275635,
0.0390223003923893,
0.008109391666948795,
-0.22959330677986145,
0.1895420104265213,
-0.6629427075386047,
0.26362669467926025,
0.61786949634552,
0.3622160255908966,
0.14665740728378296,
0.11975710839033127,
-0.31518232822418213,
-0.0706620141863823,
-0.5305122137069702,
-0.3876146376132965,
0.9040459990501404,
0.23496036231517792,
0.5009317994117737,
-0.20214538276195526,
0.6345709562301636,
0.31333479285240173,
-0.25405609607696533,
-0.40315619111061096,
0.4230925142765045,
-0.7084302306175232,
-0.08527327328920364,
-0.21600770950317383,
-0.23107150197029114,
-1.1451643705368042,
0.1586335301399231,
-0.40041816234588623,
-1.1234209537506104,
0.36304938793182373,
-0.175413116812706,
0.019282780587673187,
0.012627150863409042,
-0.840584933757782,
1.0175355672836304,
0.2798865735530853,
0.2597581446170807,
-0.22144250571727753,
-0.573890209197998,
-0.17272436618804932,
0.05346704646945,
0.055803511291742325,
-0.1959797739982605,
0.10407005250453949,
0.9274258017539978,
-0.6170936822891235,
1.106786847114563,
-0.32405903935432434,
0.18447203934192657,
0.16110558807849884,
-0.3593716025352478,
0.6204169988632202,
-0.08037668466567993,
0.07756075263023376,
-0.1033199355006218,
-0.17774274945259094,
-0.6174169778823853,
-0.7415554523468018,
0.6979997754096985,
-0.7178221940994263,
-0.5186598300933838,
-0.31938159465789795,
-0.5818554162979126,
-0.47603854537010193,
0.32683902978897095,
0.3200448751449585,
0.5441864132881165,
-0.32214388251304626,
0.053515031933784485,
0.5744068026542664,
-0.034078970551490784,
0.6262761950492859,
0.1981145143508911,
-0.3879312574863434,
-0.0026335171423852444,
0.5744780898094177,
0.05082913488149643,
-0.07273886352777481,
0.5622169971466064,
0.11490340530872345,
-0.647737443447113,
-0.7580246925354004,
0.08933456242084503,
0.08239690214395523,
-0.8711978197097778,
0.022675402462482452,
-1.1566441059112549,
-0.0014408971183001995,
-0.9361430406570435,
-0.2736329138278961,
0.034559525549411774,
-0.6099415421485901,
-0.3721047043800354,
-0.809562087059021,
0.9446350336074829,
0.8133602142333984,
0.1688975989818573,
0.8466625213623047,
-0.4998455047607422,
0.12472173571586609,
-0.09564986079931259,
0.15285298228263855,
-0.16523674130439758,
-0.36090031266212463,
-0.0552968755364418,
-0.11040317267179489,
-0.09341294318437576,
-0.4786642789840698,
0.4562780261039734,
0.3029717206954956,
0.6898055076599121,
0.39687278866767883,
0.26243171095848083,
0.7904241681098938,
-0.6759598255157471,
0.645126461982727,
0.2484511137008667,
-0.7103816270828247,
0.6120451092720032,
-0.20423993468284607,
0.10766860842704773,
0.6666497588157654,
0.4503602087497711,
-0.12749186158180237,
-0.5998561978340149,
-0.6398532390594482,
-1.0289921760559082,
0.29306915402412415,
-0.03985486179590225,
0.3769143521785736,
-0.2596608102321625,
0.502970814704895,
0.15174250304698944,
0.1536889374256134,
-0.2725677192211151,
-0.11766776442527771,
-0.47727328538894653,
-0.45284324884414673,
-0.6684245467185974,
-0.32750511169433594,
0.18940378725528717,
-0.30890050530433655,
0.5078882575035095,
-0.12244375795125961,
0.31641167402267456,
0.21059761941432953,
-0.24557848274707794,
0.3675038814544678,
0.045663513243198395,
0.09579282999038696,
0.34114912152290344,
-0.16753968596458435,
0.24986422061920166,
-0.06728830933570862,
-0.5952842235565186,
0.0005287014064379036,
0.5477422475814819,
-0.22556956112384796,
0.2250211089849472,
0.5596993565559387,
1.0456645488739014,
0.29565900564193726,
-0.40116116404533386,
0.6278376579284668,
-0.17655779421329498,
-0.12357941269874573,
-0.21822060644626617,
-0.022387471050024033,
0.024772949516773224,
0.042820043861866,
0.0007439347100444138,
-0.23042698204517365,
0.40379151701927185,
-0.45897814631462097,
0.5548055768013,
0.2362372726202011,
-0.8363131284713745,
0.20725339651107788,
0.5417152047157288,
0.11964461207389832,
-0.12464514374732971,
0.8333271145820618,
-0.1683974415063858,
-0.6015661954879761,
0.4226168990135193,
0.8426598310470581,
0.6045931577682495,
-0.05699232965707779,
0.7519142031669617,
0.032424695789813995,
0.05014325678348541,
-0.16462796926498413,
-0.0536249540746212,
0.14907057583332062,
-0.7472197413444519,
-0.4624737501144409,
-0.4515441358089447,
0.028953559696674347,
-0.703813374042511,
-0.788946270942688,
0.15830010175704956,
-0.17656417191028595,
-0.3307860493659973,
0.31144243478775024,
0.19989077746868134,
-0.50340735912323,
0.19750218093395233,
-0.28688591718673706,
0.6380422115325928,
-0.9818382263183594,
0.9144895672798157,
0.6696760058403015,
-0.46366778016090393,
-0.6361015439033508,
-0.17344073951244354,
-0.26691335439682007,
-0.9202229976654053,
0.6404742002487183,
0.43058276176452637,
0.051349394023418427,
0.2856351137161255,
-0.3237823247909546,
-0.5645297765731812,
1.0418859720230103,
0.3748272657394409,
-0.4328591525554657,
-0.1089659258723259,
0.2029094398021698,
0.696596622467041,
-0.6760096549987793,
0.2667851746082306,
0.5055370926856995,
0.33898699283599854,
0.129609152674675,
-0.5201984643936157,
0.23159021139144897,
-0.32055342197418213,
0.383780837059021,
0.292070597410202,
-0.31006017327308655,
0.7241563200950623,
0.062403880059719086,
-0.28291627764701843,
-0.13867880403995514,
0.7553848028182983,
-0.17686815559864044,
0.3900074064731598,
0.4330911636352539,
0.8846718072891235,
1.2760337591171265,
-0.3448309004306793,
1.41904616355896,
-0.17623205482959747,
0.24980224668979645,
1.2200102806091309,
-0.4496994912624359,
0.7717106938362122,
0.16099046170711517,
-0.0014886095887050033,
1.0629135370254517,
0.9771166443824768,
-0.05391303449869156,
0.5554382801055908,
0.20138949155807495,
-0.09499117732048035,
-0.42433494329452515,
-0.5372480750083923,
-0.16250717639923096,
0.4616071879863739,
0.19105270504951477,
-0.2870073616504669,
-0.30976083874702454,
0.5764274001121521,
0.3994002938270569,
0.7410506010055542,
-0.24849829077720642,
0.7638221979141235,
0.12787528336048126,
-0.42356428503990173,
-0.04883036017417908,
0.09965047240257263,
0.5868973135948181,
-0.4731940031051636,
-0.20664720237255096,
0.11263176798820496,
0.3671242296695709,
-0.22357845306396484,
-0.7339178323745728,
0.08175069093704224,
-0.3552117943763733,
-0.047364700585603714,
-0.35733217000961304,
0.9764049649238586,
-0.4713185429573059,
-0.6639364361763,
0.6617452502250671,
0.21760571002960205,
0.023140205070376396,
-0.024576855823397636,
-0.4296228885650635,
-0.03445136919617653,
-0.1642419695854187,
0.05244932323694229,
0.3827596604824066,
0.6426015496253967,
-0.1482529193162918,
0.5026589632034302,
0.8476168513298035,
-0.2782227098941803,
0.1519327461719513,
0.5305343866348267,
0.9840297102928162,
-0.5302490592002869,
-0.9426800012588501,
-0.5961867570877075,
0.26331284642219543,
-0.41927987337112427,
-0.22635334730148315,
1.137184500694275,
0.529754102230072,
0.9330537915229797,
0.16975924372673035,
0.3912091553211212,
0.2621716558933258,
0.4818890392780304,
-0.8613590598106384,
0.4660396873950958,
-0.16381384432315826,
-0.12362153083086014,
-0.4695352613925934,
-0.7916647791862488,
-0.5320064425468445,
0.682409942150116,
-0.4754003882408142,
0.11833787709474564,
1.0883151292800903,
0.5225552320480347,
0.23777399957180023,
0.15957342088222504,
0.2975211441516876,
0.07456804811954498,
0.18984374403953552,
0.2554038465023041,
0.6049620509147644,
-0.3438047766685486,
0.11269859969615936,
-0.18334351480007172,
-0.05149407684803009,
0.050040002912282944,
-0.9210487008094788,
-1.097267508506775,
-0.6876316070556641,
-0.5930593609809875,
-0.341307669878006,
0.2766587734222412,
0.4582999050617218,
0.6049554347991943,
-0.44324588775634766,
0.1959482580423355,
-0.4108557403087616,
0.14557044208049774,
-0.20515123009681702,
-0.26617759466171265,
0.7147074937820435,
-0.48704400658607483,
-0.7219997048377991,
0.09070145338773727,
0.10865810513496399,
0.10122742503881454,
0.069381944835186,
0.18450991809368134,
-0.39133477210998535,
-0.10500653088092804,
0.7056189775466919,
-0.3476771414279938,
-0.27588438987731934,
-0.5385617017745972,
-0.20304757356643677,
0.08847389370203018,
0.092646025121212,
0.9537926912307739,
-0.7980737090110779,
0.3649819493293762,
0.3461730480194092,
0.45868760347366333,
0.935286283493042,
0.09058594703674316,
0.4309861660003662,
-0.8357110619544983,
0.5805971622467041,
-0.1712600588798523,
0.4736819863319397,
0.41254740953445435,
-0.6485863924026489,
0.36849620938301086,
0.18606510758399963,
-0.4053508937358856,
-0.6052840948104858,
0.017695680260658264,
-1.1375716924667358,
-0.45426273345947266,
0.8427251577377319,
-0.5727435946464539,
-0.32016903162002563,
-0.39734789729118347,
0.027038026601076126,
0.4548138976097107,
-0.5669147968292236,
0.30452337861061096,
0.5254618525505066,
-0.20875005424022675,
-0.1723545342683792,
-0.3294868767261505,
0.3367576599121094,
0.009551015682518482,
-0.8659725785255432,
-0.1014624759554863,
0.5984731316566467,
0.003350339364260435,
0.20018725097179413,
0.7638822197914124,
-0.2984336018562317,
-0.13246950507164001,
0.38971370458602905,
-0.1400027871131897,
-0.162519171833992,
-0.30029648542404175,
-0.06835267692804337,
0.23436233401298523,
-0.02273038774728775,
-0.09561464190483093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12881v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12881v1 | GRAFFORD: A Benchmark Dataset for Testing the Knowledge of Object Affordances of Language and Vision Models | 2024-02-20T10:23:00 | 2024-02-20T10:23:00 | Sayantan Adak, Daivik Agrawal, Animesh Mukherjee, Somak Aditya | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate the knowledge of object affordances in pre-trained language
models (LMs) and pre-trained Vision-Language models (VLMs). Transformers-based
large pre-trained language models (PTLM) learn contextual representation from
massive amounts of unlabeled text and are shown to perform impressively in
downstream NLU tasks. In parallel, a growing body of literature shows that
PTLMs fail inconsistently and non-intuitively, showing a lack of reasoning and
grounding. To take a first step toward quantifying the effect of grounding (or
lack thereof), we curate a novel and comprehensive dataset of object
affordances -- GrAFFORD, characterized by 15 affordance classes. Unlike
affordance datasets collected in vision and language domains, we annotate
in-the-wild sentences with objects and affordances. Experimental results reveal
that PTLMs exhibit limited reasoning abilities when it comes to uncommon object
affordances. We also observe that pre-trained VLMs do not necessarily capture
object affordances effectively. Through few-shot fine-tuning, we demonstrate
improvement in affordance knowledge in PTLMs and VLMs. Our research contributes
a novel dataset for language grounding tasks, and presents insights into LM
capabilities, advancing the understanding of object affordances. Codes and data
are available at https://github.com/sayantan11995/Affordance | [
-0.13454391062259674,
-0.3986809551715851,
0.5133652091026306,
-0.07664134353399277,
-0.11109206825494766,
-0.24882134795188904,
-0.18578048050403595,
-0.3055879771709442,
-0.36900651454925537,
0.48604750633239746,
-0.35862037539482117,
-0.5576130151748657,
-0.5196743607521057,
-0.10634427517652512,
-0.5730166435241699,
0.523360013961792,
-0.16707727313041687,
0.0427803136408329,
-0.6957105994224548,
-0.6175305247306824,
-0.40171268582344055,
-0.6098012924194336,
-0.13655593991279602,
0.09055498242378235,
0.23598627746105194,
0.5113058686256409,
0.7966340184211731,
0.8328730463981628,
0.6641995906829834,
0.2112901359796524,
-0.025774452835321426,
-0.19492262601852417,
-0.6070017218589783,
-0.3416229784488678,
-0.3049364387989044,
-0.39366233348846436,
-0.10825920850038528,
0.10032375901937485,
0.39632508158683777,
0.7554689049720764,
-0.02401651255786419,
0.21062108874320984,
0.07056628167629242,
0.5838041305541992,
-0.8341522812843323,
0.1469956338405609,
-0.9721283912658691,
-0.15407469868659973,
-0.10893100500106812,
-0.00869075208902359,
-0.4449489414691925,
0.11471199989318848,
0.19721446931362152,
-0.9551839232444763,
0.37118688225746155,
0.3794381618499756,
1.221838355064392,
0.6012086868286133,
-0.1296164095401764,
-0.15440766513347626,
-0.34726113080978394,
0.9996649622917175,
-0.3548482656478882,
0.7014757990837097,
0.6520107388496399,
0.19864718616008759,
0.3486552834510803,
-0.8710793852806091,
-0.29312068223953247,
-0.40784990787506104,
-0.6184040904045105,
0.19754038751125336,
-0.02809913270175457,
0.015502306632697582,
0.4736839830875397,
0.2624538540840149,
-0.45388177037239075,
-0.3426310122013092,
-0.4759965240955353,
-0.06484443694353104,
0.1556384116411209,
0.035410284996032715,
0.26370376348495483,
-0.47156232595443726,
-0.5355966091156006,
-0.3353150188922882,
-0.7673670053482056,
0.23502202332019806,
0.13607913255691528,
0.18287312984466553,
0.024942560121417046,
0.8255372643470764,
-0.3078361451625824,
1.0168676376342773,
-0.31842851638793945,
0.04986412078142166,
0.23459124565124512,
-0.3241772949695587,
-0.21431250870227814,
-0.24007990956306458,
0.4205648601055145,
0.4828432500362396,
0.4626317024230957,
-0.2846396267414093,
-0.10487359762191772,
0.08082982897758484,
0.5680012702941895,
-0.6793419718742371,
-0.31032219529151917,
0.048953428864479065,
-0.5720352530479431,
-0.5252782106399536,
0.19707989692687988,
-0.21577188372612,
-0.20136332511901855,
-0.5848760008811951,
0.5003092885017395,
-0.6667284369468689,
0.010993672534823418,
0.2531331777572632,
-0.35795605182647705,
0.8010542988777161,
0.22623048722743988,
-0.6291952133178711,
0.11558739840984344,
0.7569306492805481,
0.7519471645355225,
-0.21939027309417725,
-0.8436872363090515,
-0.4041142463684082,
0.24887312948703766,
-0.3189222514629364,
0.8161513209342957,
-0.41610825061798096,
-0.2909960150718689,
-0.20308341085910797,
0.29129260778427124,
0.09037544578313828,
-0.7204135656356812,
0.765396237373352,
-0.0478472076356411,
-0.12500418722629547,
-0.4953506886959076,
-0.29368582367897034,
-0.24452926218509674,
0.4251127541065216,
-0.5478371977806091,
0.9936591982841492,
0.5327125787734985,
-0.867359459400177,
0.7755217552185059,
-0.4357162117958069,
-0.631607174873352,
0.021810509264469147,
-0.12559236586093903,
-0.29134511947631836,
0.38768112659454346,
0.17408008873462677,
0.4927361011505127,
0.003800348611548543,
0.470865398645401,
-0.6050681471824646,
-0.36186453700065613,
0.12213686108589172,
-0.2755878269672394,
0.8164476752281189,
-0.0449981763958931,
-0.14757591485977173,
0.23396719992160797,
-0.86199951171875,
-0.21263521909713745,
0.16689155995845795,
-0.021077835932374,
-0.399391233921051,
0.37770646810531616,
0.17923444509506226,
0.23635520040988922,
0.07099008560180664,
-0.3281916081905365,
-0.14515002071857452,
-0.4516918659210205,
0.374953031539917,
0.877962052822113,
-0.5767936706542969,
0.5338625907897949,
-0.49486058950424194,
0.17887724936008453,
0.11658366769552231,
0.3470629155635834,
-0.31348565220832825,
0.15432390570640564,
-1.037903070449829,
-0.15598106384277344,
-0.19422724843025208,
0.6234910488128662,
-0.6771643161773682,
0.16999658942222595,
-0.22232340276241302,
-0.0748753771185875,
-0.490196168422699,
0.1576015204191208,
0.3329380452632904,
0.8499261140823364,
0.3701747953891754,
-0.0028521630447357893,
-0.6354377865791321,
-1.097363829612732,
-0.4202890992164612,
-0.02954518236219883,
-0.10592586547136307,
0.7099658250808716,
0.3734931945800781,
-0.21155747771263123,
1.2642179727554321,
-0.5274869799613953,
-0.4357241094112396,
-0.01992933452129364,
-0.297646701335907,
-0.046021413058042526,
0.3699287474155426,
0.8068687319755554,
-0.778908371925354,
-0.11517304182052612,
-0.06921206414699554,
-1.1039291620254517,
0.08657635003328323,
0.23303735256195068,
-0.22697828710079193,
0.03165268898010254,
0.6143972873687744,
-0.4513656198978424,
0.592714250087738,
0.318042516708374,
-0.21411629021167755,
0.46599137783050537,
-0.19137310981750488,
-0.10575984418392181,
-0.8085223436355591,
0.2921011447906494,
-0.25698602199554443,
-0.517071008682251,
-0.4172147214412689,
0.19539345800876617,
0.11588343977928162,
-0.2776649594306946,
-0.7912907004356384,
0.5676887631416321,
-0.6492834091186523,
-0.34020403027534485,
-0.28448978066444397,
0.21456076204776764,
0.17795278131961823,
0.45718085765838623,
0.31539496779441833,
0.8580599427223206,
0.8330419063568115,
-0.3769862651824951,
0.07669438421726227,
0.37730172276496887,
-0.5666486620903015,
0.7195295691490173,
-0.9434260129928589,
0.10437209904193878,
-0.4049712121486664,
-0.07044284790754318,
-0.7356853485107422,
-0.24014157056808472,
0.1521165668964386,
-0.13786686956882477,
-0.14482825994491577,
-0.2395700216293335,
-0.3848453164100647,
-0.3080127239227295,
-0.12487894296646118,
0.43047764897346497,
0.5666453242301941,
-0.7772602438926697,
0.8108595609664917,
0.31400537490844727,
0.25093376636505127,
-0.599588930606842,
-0.5027159452438354,
-0.19562658667564392,
-0.23251882195472717,
-0.4102989137172699,
-0.1654825657606125,
-0.12126212567090988,
-0.39804044365882874,
0.07408339530229568,
-0.17754679918289185,
-0.07184740155935287,
0.4591205418109894,
0.6068540811538696,
0.34936684370040894,
-0.14072537422180176,
0.06760211288928986,
-0.4182175099849701,
-0.3990105986595154,
0.1765117198228836,
-0.48165711760520935,
0.32275503873825073,
-0.43888863921165466,
-0.42633354663848877,
-0.021830672398209572,
-0.06924257427453995,
0.37267524003982544,
-0.21525318920612335,
0.6334825158119202,
0.3827269673347473,
-0.3091159164905548,
-0.10791369527578354,
-0.3679038882255554,
-0.13103850185871124,
-0.5071719884872437,
0.3345026969909668,
-0.5513013601303101,
-0.7041717171669006,
0.20309515297412872,
-0.02815360389649868,
0.094724640250206,
0.3178587853908539,
0.16420480608940125,
-0.3210378587245941,
0.5489128828048706,
0.4866727590560913,
-0.027498546987771988,
0.4215001165866852,
-0.4450030028820038,
-0.10962328314781189,
-0.7095975279808044,
0.03218632936477661,
-0.4751720726490021,
-0.31884750723838806,
0.06894441694021225,
-0.6883398294448853,
-0.05065908282995224,
0.4129023849964142,
0.010899404995143414,
0.4955785572528839,
-0.3647722899913788,
0.8062543272972107,
0.5924323797225952,
0.29227644205093384,
0.4281286895275116,
-0.12770183384418488,
0.14486539363861084,
-0.02105412818491459,
-0.4989752173423767,
-0.5387821793556213,
1.2754197120666504,
-0.085001140832901,
0.684907078742981,
-0.25077661871910095,
0.249650776386261,
0.12254519015550613,
0.49960702657699585,
-1.0408815145492554,
0.3735376298427582,
-0.43590715527534485,
-0.48524951934814453,
-0.07431842386722565,
-0.40600913763046265,
-0.6147212386131287,
0.17456172406673431,
0.09892459213733673,
-0.5913708806037903,
0.05857274681329727,
0.5263928174972534,
-0.06881408393383026,
0.2485331892967224,
-0.6775973439216614,
1.1204506158828735,
-0.5122848153114319,
-0.35024043917655945,
-0.0764954537153244,
-0.7395126819610596,
0.3190782368183136,
-0.059857893735170364,
0.22765126824378967,
-0.3178085684776306,
0.14720720052719116,
0.44235190749168396,
-0.23706451058387756,
0.6395807266235352,
-0.0987069308757782,
0.0746607705950737,
0.20318834483623505,
0.15831546485424042,
0.5074196457862854,
0.10593850165605545,
0.03515037149190903,
0.2980296313762665,
0.003495276439934969,
-0.5896105170249939,
-0.5298752784729004,
0.5075569748878479,
-0.6325721144676208,
-0.485577255487442,
-0.21485325694084167,
-0.7043460607528687,
-0.40176352858543396,
0.3729003667831421,
0.2864404320716858,
0.6683856844902039,
-0.5138255953788757,
0.5124932527542114,
0.5310720205307007,
-0.1834821105003357,
0.37846866250038147,
0.46650171279907227,
-0.3437056243419647,
-0.24950380623340607,
1.1331536769866943,
-0.10908243805170059,
0.38029980659484863,
0.5319604277610779,
0.3449609577655792,
-0.13149957358837128,
-0.48312801122665405,
-0.3056451678276062,
0.0271100252866745,
-0.7437800765037537,
-0.09039629250764847,
-0.6973676681518555,
0.04583994671702385,
-0.19202232360839844,
-0.5565854907035828,
-0.3353762924671173,
-0.29770904779434204,
-0.2854863703250885,
-0.5030544996261597,
0.33306971192359924,
0.7361347079277039,
0.036678314208984375,
0.42060884833335876,
-0.5387011766433716,
0.6353381276130676,
0.47649362683296204,
0.5151127576828003,
-0.23094098269939423,
-0.5897857546806335,
-0.08556357771158218,
0.21305279433727264,
0.05776064097881317,
-0.35651469230651855,
0.09656191617250443,
0.1181936264038086,
0.5745474696159363,
0.5110249519348145,
0.1739390343427658,
0.70114666223526,
-0.5093887448310852,
0.5579195022583008,
-0.11559626460075378,
-1.0786467790603638,
0.6741041541099548,
-0.4858556389808655,
0.09834424406290054,
0.8117229342460632,
0.14592187106609344,
-0.33662962913513184,
-0.17800387740135193,
-0.8244600296020508,
-0.6392918825149536,
1.092684030532837,
0.1949714869260788,
-0.008302217349410057,
0.24779260158538818,
0.12285757064819336,
0.14366017282009125,
0.2759619355201721,
-0.7372389435768127,
-0.16656503081321716,
-0.5900489091873169,
-0.37187474966049194,
-0.4043600857257843,
-0.16692706942558289,
-0.19206519424915314,
-0.5660595297813416,
0.412487655878067,
-0.2552405595779419,
-0.08852166682481766,
-0.017046615481376648,
-0.6690295338630676,
0.27351048588752747,
-0.04481973126530647,
0.7370739579200745,
0.8015684485435486,
-0.46112531423568726,
0.20279935002326965,
0.3513867259025574,
-0.3960120379924774,
0.049808401614427567,
-0.15498383343219757,
-0.2685411274433136,
-0.005739176645874977,
0.37838736176490784,
1.0287190675735474,
0.4169769287109375,
-1.0282337665557861,
0.7866189479827881,
0.03076796978712082,
-0.3114663064479828,
-0.418911337852478,
-0.10108833760023117,
-0.04239073768258095,
-0.20786307752132416,
-0.009526362642645836,
0.4328448176383972,
-0.03792181611061096,
-0.356628954410553,
0.45159029960632324,
0.46419286727905273,
-0.7562324404716492,
-0.32367202639579773,
0.5817074179649353,
0.17082282900810242,
-0.19360536336898804,
0.5415035486221313,
0.022180045023560524,
-0.2586703896522522,
0.5414825081825256,
0.27452942728996277,
0.826033353805542,
0.2462393343448639,
0.18123260140419006,
0.26141634583473206,
0.6125761270523071,
-0.24781395494937897,
0.09252779185771942,
-0.1961895078420639,
-0.9984288811683655,
0.016634449362754822,
-0.5719195604324341,
-0.3287045359611511,
-0.016289440914988518,
-0.7024473547935486,
0.37848401069641113,
-0.5174039602279663,
0.34728264808654785,
-0.5148739218711853,
-0.519311785697937,
-0.8785702586174011,
0.1256428062915802,
-0.37385278940200806,
0.8807302713394165,
-0.801413893699646,
0.7178739309310913,
0.6659371852874756,
-0.2643626630306244,
-0.9805546998977661,
0.04174555093050003,
-0.06324408948421478,
-1.1611995697021484,
0.8620008826255798,
0.5132668614387512,
-0.2631397545337677,
0.21330101788043976,
-0.6408966779708862,
-0.8205952644348145,
0.9664948582649231,
0.576997697353363,
-0.424329549074173,
-0.03817278519272804,
0.12518294155597687,
0.1838904768228531,
-0.03131856396794319,
0.1235935166478157,
0.6021134257316589,
0.4579316973686218,
0.04302232339978218,
-0.47020140290260315,
-0.30362042784690857,
-0.0801558867096901,
-0.1453598290681839,
0.1503903567790985,
-0.6664886474609375,
0.5554383397102356,
-0.09671209752559662,
-0.25759267807006836,
0.11327731609344482,
0.45286083221435547,
0.2940613627433777,
0.35032692551612854,
0.7597129940986633,
1.0867161750793457,
0.3417002260684967,
-0.28897273540496826,
1.1183193922042847,
-0.2917025089263916,
0.5770538449287415,
1.2044049501419067,
-0.44798707962036133,
1.0041053295135498,
0.5010349750518799,
-0.22141104936599731,
0.15360775589942932,
-0.012057584710419178,
0.13455334305763245,
0.43483462929725647,
0.3807520270347595,
0.07332917302846909,
-0.4343717694282532,
-0.15551507472991943,
-0.142905592918396,
0.7076467275619507,
0.14927351474761963,
-0.36462685465812683,
-0.22725273668766022,
0.5101907253265381,
-0.11171970516443253,
-0.030773265287280083,
-0.022605175152420998,
0.8359171152114868,
0.1267334669828415,
-0.38657617568969727,
0.5513535737991333,
-0.39322879910469055,
0.46496111154556274,
-0.5997684001922607,
0.06125043332576752,
-0.22854448854923248,
0.3555586040019989,
-0.0482172928750515,
-0.7008723020553589,
0.5034313201904297,
-0.0941988006234169,
-0.3660854995250702,
-0.6851577758789062,
0.9729959964752197,
-0.1266304850578308,
-0.8111024498939514,
0.4220227301120758,
0.43205440044403076,
0.21812473237514496,
-0.2604064643383026,
-0.5220040678977966,
0.10024631768465042,
-0.13512200117111206,
-0.09408368170261383,
0.16098333895206451,
0.33412009477615356,
0.2648566961288452,
0.7751096487045288,
0.7287198305130005,
-0.044482890516519547,
0.042610052973032,
0.2294987291097641,
0.8147999048233032,
-0.6808504462242126,
-0.18206481635570526,
-0.6593384146690369,
0.5212198495864868,
-0.0657154768705368,
-0.36509981751441956,
0.7015987038612366,
0.7793707251548767,
1.166714072227478,
-0.3633987605571747,
0.7060033679008484,
-0.1395110785961151,
0.5378358960151672,
-0.5415335297584534,
0.6968353986740112,
-0.7118203639984131,
-0.05779815837740898,
-0.3163546919822693,
-0.7632644772529602,
-0.12067918479442596,
0.7899189591407776,
-0.2784327566623688,
-0.12160051614046097,
0.7011672258377075,
0.870369017124176,
-0.45462489128112793,
-0.2169911414384842,
0.5570047497749329,
0.15651452541351318,
-0.06718655675649643,
0.5385327339172363,
1.1745245456695557,
-0.5092570185661316,
0.815741777420044,
-0.568024754524231,
-0.08926919102668762,
-0.09297122061252594,
-0.834585964679718,
-1.0778558254241943,
-0.5892077088356018,
-0.028775164857506752,
-0.16735199093818665,
0.15251004695892334,
0.48832741379737854,
0.9304754734039307,
-0.7683039903640747,
-0.27972838282585144,
-0.4627518951892853,
0.03867727145552635,
-0.2936563193798065,
-0.2411998212337494,
0.33053675293922424,
-0.2697162926197052,
-0.5221710801124573,
0.3850632309913635,
0.3116971552371979,
0.08493730425834656,
-0.028598971664905548,
-0.08045660704374313,
0.040329910814762115,
-0.33981192111968994,
0.6935481429100037,
0.14758986234664917,
-0.9191809892654419,
-0.4910754859447479,
0.35485878586769104,
-0.005392065737396479,
0.1949135661125183,
1.1994870901107788,
-1.0798287391662598,
0.25380319356918335,
0.4580899178981781,
0.6263149380683899,
0.05044296756386757,
0.44129738211631775,
0.5000760555267334,
-0.8305764198303223,
0.5521337389945984,
0.08321903645992279,
0.6154738664627075,
0.33957284688949585,
-0.17181305587291718,
0.4856134057044983,
0.6197476983070374,
-0.2859223186969757,
-0.8230109214782715,
0.4195508360862732,
-1.2014646530151367,
-0.41056492924690247,
0.9593241214752197,
-0.06728880852460861,
-0.27215775847435,
-0.06819365173578262,
-0.6117982864379883,
-0.14380614459514618,
-0.035837311297655106,
0.5280726552009583,
0.7384627461433411,
0.3949891924858093,
-0.5768392086029053,
-0.3733536899089813,
0.5316401720046997,
0.6497204303741455,
-1.097331166267395,
0.4047088623046875,
0.5033252835273743,
0.341579794883728,
-0.027352014556527138,
0.37563827633857727,
0.1381341516971588,
0.1739654392004013,
-0.03733065351843834,
-0.16057533025741577,
-0.33458465337753296,
-0.532799482345581,
-0.17478801310062408,
0.17936719954013824,
0.12545186281204224,
-0.2529660761356354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12880v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12880v1 | Autism Detection in Speech -- A Survey | 2024-02-20T10:18:18 | 2024-02-20T10:18:18 | Nadine Probol, Margot Mieskes | cs.CL | cs.CL | There has been a range of studies of how autism is displayed in voice,
speech, and language. We analyse studies from the biomedical, as well as the
psychological domain, but also from the NLP domain in order to find linguistic,
prosodic and acoustic cues that could indicate autism. Our survey looks at all
three domains. We define autism and which comorbidities might influence the
correct detection of the disorder. We especially look at observations such as
verbal and semantic fluency, prosodic features, but also disfluencies and
speaking rate. We also show word-based approaches and describe machine learning
and transformer-based approaches both on the audio data as well as the
transcripts. Lastly, we conclude, while there already is a lot of research,
female patients seem to be severely under-researched. Also, most NLP research
focuses on traditional machine learning methods instead of transformers which
could be beneficial in this context. Additionally, we were unable to find
research combining both features from audio and transcripts. | [
-0.45563486218452454,
-0.9337724447250366,
0.15234704315662384,
0.15199777483940125,
0.22861060500144958,
0.1887950301170349,
0.07258766889572144,
-0.8547699451446533,
0.6045500040054321,
0.4691602885723114,
-0.6134752631187439,
-0.31735217571258545,
-0.904671311378479,
0.2939457297325134,
-0.7543004751205444,
0.6644546985626221,
0.3730233609676361,
0.3682742416858673,
0.03693055734038353,
-0.09841854870319366,
-0.3865489363670349,
-0.5981359481811523,
-1.3854504823684692,
-0.29696640372276306,
0.2469319850206375,
0.4163641929626465,
0.4776725172996521,
0.05080810561776161,
0.368325799703598,
0.19344675540924072,
-0.577333927154541,
0.1014133021235466,
0.0679980143904686,
0.14061807096004486,
-0.11812306940555573,
-0.2711329758167267,
-0.9202520847320557,
0.1369207203388214,
0.46787533164024353,
1.0044153928756714,
0.012951099313795567,
0.09521782398223877,
0.10106589645147324,
0.43037497997283936,
-0.19263266026973724,
0.08043009042739868,
0.055214717984199524,
0.4646371304988861,
-0.5415176153182983,
0.08482315391302109,
-0.11575145274400711,
0.16487005352973938,
0.07772572338581085,
-0.403051495552063,
0.3114287257194519,
0.30701401829719543,
0.3509245812892914,
0.11886439472436905,
-0.8356657028198242,
-0.5713328123092651,
-0.7909731268882751,
0.6560443639755249,
-0.7672637104988098,
0.5415773391723633,
0.9027997851371765,
0.08060331642627716,
0.09906072914600372,
-0.5504351854324341,
-0.5818942189216614,
-0.42635872960090637,
-0.08015865832567215,
-0.0559534877538681,
-0.857147753238678,
-0.16416645050048828,
0.23084816336631775,
0.22090043127536774,
-0.8754207491874695,
0.27146151661872864,
-0.21356011927127838,
-0.46332278847694397,
0.6774163246154785,
0.0810210257768631,
0.7836166620254517,
-0.07588112354278564,
0.2556562125682831,
0.17031660676002502,
-0.28526270389556885,
0.10677038133144379,
0.451727032661438,
0.33595627546310425,
-0.09381339699029922,
0.4829675257205963,
-0.019656384363770485,
0.36453282833099365,
0.1338682770729065,
0.15836800634860992,
0.41191214323043823,
-0.3823109567165375,
0.30762675404548645,
0.19064128398895264,
0.5997263789176941,
0.09829827398061752,
0.11156679689884186,
-0.09287148714065552,
-0.06470367312431335,
0.2441496104001999,
0.3229748010635376,
-0.29056331515312195,
-0.04413559287786484,
0.09754731506109238,
-0.5248137712478638,
-0.07328591495752335,
-0.2695066034793854,
-0.5239225029945374,
-0.1715925931930542,
-0.06736066192388535,
-0.2446344494819641,
-0.512734055519104,
-0.6708657145500183,
-0.032835423946380615,
-0.2838969826698303,
0.13860392570495605,
-0.09415051341056824,
-1.2359530925750732,
0.7987502217292786,
0.6535031795501709,
0.7828052639961243,
-0.17328554391860962,
-0.029125088825821877,
-0.45028966665267944,
-0.26425427198410034,
-0.3894510865211487,
0.8787095546722412,
-0.5738818049430847,
-0.5335831046104431,
-0.17859125137329102,
0.09219291061162949,
-0.13219556212425232,
-0.805450975894928,
0.8273212909698486,
-0.05192576348781586,
0.2591412365436554,
-0.33315107226371765,
-0.5167037844657898,
-0.17817245423793793,
-0.07068032026290894,
-0.8556384444236755,
0.6594640612602234,
0.41573408246040344,
-0.7814863324165344,
0.16582556068897247,
-0.8534493446350098,
-0.5552234649658203,
0.12028255313634872,
-0.28883862495422363,
-0.5524064898490906,
-0.14061300456523895,
0.1713392436504364,
0.06451825797557831,
-0.03794148936867714,
0.1817442923784256,
-0.004437149967998266,
-0.11556609719991684,
0.35286882519721985,
-0.42056575417518616,
0.9547614455223083,
0.2827073633670807,
-0.39056554436683655,
0.015042951330542564,
-0.5931658148765564,
-0.3479718267917633,
0.09095226973295212,
0.16594421863555908,
-0.27037176489830017,
0.2254825085401535,
0.34766700863838196,
-0.1780770868062973,
-0.24313317239284515,
-0.6231586337089539,
-0.0866752490401268,
-0.7091975808143616,
0.3452554941177368,
0.017234699800610542,
0.1170462965965271,
0.1929238736629486,
-0.3792537450790405,
0.8959128260612488,
0.350410521030426,
0.21551628410816193,
0.2033422589302063,
-1.0987731218338013,
-0.14863163232803345,
-0.21032454073429108,
0.5842791199684143,
0.5183102488517761,
-0.2600947320461273,
0.6171882152557373,
0.29603853821754456,
0.062348172068595886,
-0.5620945692062378,
-0.1424456685781479,
0.4786927103996277,
0.7912189364433289,
0.39751768112182617,
-0.7543210387229919,
-0.5403695106506348,
-0.8190813064575195,
-0.1336062252521515,
-0.0657401904463768,
0.048452794551849365,
0.24925048649311066,
0.5418103337287903,
-0.2063179314136505,
0.7102006673812866,
-0.3064025938510895,
-0.5361238121986389,
-0.2601796090602875,
0.38186758756637573,
-0.13625718653202057,
0.34571367502212524,
0.8902385234832764,
-0.8782442212104797,
-0.2255064845085144,
-0.1259913295507431,
-0.43740537762641907,
-0.22477369010448456,
0.5866675972938538,
0.41784438490867615,
0.0270546842366457,
0.6101256608963013,
-0.5383803248405457,
0.5124576687812805,
0.48749035596847534,
-0.6383888721466064,
0.35473981499671936,
0.2937116026878357,
0.23243387043476105,
-0.7058085203170776,
-0.002290124073624611,
-0.030156901106238365,
-0.30411896109580994,
-0.8356768488883972,
-0.4280066192150116,
-0.33095434308052063,
-0.1679304987192154,
-0.2166288197040558,
0.45691028237342834,
-0.1693132072687149,
-0.3129555881023407,
-0.4136013984680176,
0.2702128291130066,
-0.07685443013906479,
-0.08081001788377762,
-0.10241004824638367,
0.5831632018089294,
0.8595284819602966,
-0.5440153479576111,
0.3809570372104645,
0.504483699798584,
-0.2037048041820526,
0.7702437043190002,
-0.47313573956489563,
-0.06447172909975052,
0.056383587419986725,
0.32799553871154785,
-1.1609835624694824,
-0.25490665435791016,
0.6940553784370422,
-0.9305621981620789,
0.32084980607032776,
0.2940720319747925,
-0.03478136286139488,
-0.46819713711738586,
0.04773341119289398,
0.7290442585945129,
0.2554408013820648,
-0.024199441075325012,
0.4234391450881958,
0.7974692583084106,
-0.4298228919506073,
-0.6839361786842346,
-0.83782958984375,
0.03337305411696434,
-0.2377835214138031,
-0.25084829330444336,
0.34021440148353577,
0.02603962831199169,
-0.3978153467178345,
0.16488152742385864,
-0.20405313372612,
-0.2516319453716278,
0.41575002670288086,
0.009165446273982525,
-0.2868168354034424,
-0.44811955094337463,
0.03627661615610123,
0.07952571660280228,
-0.1652476191520691,
0.22773148119449615,
0.33039340376853943,
0.5785500407218933,
0.049433790147304535,
-0.4801945090293884,
-0.5497840642929077,
0.877651572227478,
0.16235516965389252,
-0.27077582478523254,
0.28903234004974365,
0.6779856085777283,
-0.5411630272865295,
-0.1809794008731842,
0.06329627335071564,
-0.3614722788333893,
-0.3163074254989624,
0.3944617807865143,
-0.016546770930290222,
-0.7870185375213623,
0.6895710229873657,
-0.15575242042541504,
-0.507085382938385,
0.5555655360221863,
0.3773186206817627,
-0.4554003179073334,
1.3792778253555298,
0.6801308989524841,
-0.32071414589881897,
0.4519272446632385,
-0.22981591522693634,
0.40660130977630615,
-0.8190840482711792,
0.1301284283399582,
-0.9446333646774292,
-0.26113054156303406,
-0.507000207901001,
0.20398882031440735,
0.2944907546043396,
-0.2832426130771637,
-0.040046609938144684,
0.0408465601503849,
-0.5111936926841736,
0.18885286152362823,
0.42756909132003784,
0.0075380331836640835,
0.1569737046957016,
-0.4023340046405792,
0.20172087848186493,
0.06574764102697372,
-0.7199788689613342,
-0.3622535765171051,
1.1847550868988037,
0.27905192971229553,
0.03727037459611893,
0.41141271591186523,
0.4113039970397949,
0.7831261157989502,
0.16636419296264648,
-0.7980130910873413,
0.26715171337127686,
-0.3077428936958313,
-0.8364726305007935,
-0.2920932471752167,
-0.2715548276901245,
-1.3932527303695679,
0.019794771447777748,
-0.1623321920633316,
-0.8554429411888123,
0.319724440574646,
0.019293880090117455,
-0.45992007851600647,
0.018716976046562195,
-0.455966055393219,
0.8384740948677063,
-0.235176220536232,
0.4480670392513275,
-0.018334729596972466,
-0.605326771736145,
0.573796272277832,
-0.14224500954151154,
0.5802565217018127,
-0.2549706995487213,
0.2033415287733078,
1.0891776084899902,
-0.08559580147266388,
0.7802664041519165,
-0.16169002652168274,
-0.11142771691083908,
0.2058415561914444,
-0.36476749181747437,
-0.33115720748901367,
-0.08784878998994827,
0.0627293735742569,
0.26547130942344666,
0.13669370114803314,
-0.13645319640636444,
-0.3638549745082855,
0.3336794674396515,
-0.6658740639686584,
-0.379258394241333,
-0.7853590250015259,
-0.4645196497440338,
-0.557991623878479,
-0.041605059057474136,
0.16998617351055145,
0.5244272351264954,
-0.5085523128509521,
-0.07317530363798141,
0.50069659948349,
-0.12189849466085434,
0.42228639125823975,
0.43013885617256165,
-0.43247830867767334,
0.05383061617612839,
0.6218571066856384,
0.025067869573831558,
-0.04776829108595848,
0.1168079525232315,
0.2461879700422287,
-0.3589652180671692,
-0.6448638439178467,
-0.10446494072675705,
0.37224477529525757,
-0.4354126751422882,
0.06969965994358063,
-0.2774028480052948,
-0.4363485872745514,
-0.769890308380127,
0.2971864938735962,
-0.2770181894302368,
-0.5150620937347412,
-0.550581157207489,
-0.09784750640392303,
0.4253068268299103,
0.6441084146499634,
-0.21740537881851196,
0.49511048197746277,
-0.4033347964286804,
0.8669862747192383,
0.12386786937713623,
0.22243131697177887,
-0.09190715849399567,
-0.6430778503417969,
-0.10113807022571564,
0.17354820668697357,
-0.4596821367740631,
-0.9854673147201538,
0.6779107451438904,
0.40269315242767334,
0.5969604849815369,
0.42455142736434937,
-0.14606492221355438,
0.1012415960431099,
-0.2447657585144043,
1.1022484302520752,
-0.024714644998311996,
-0.9114207625389099,
0.6455303430557251,
-0.04341485723853111,
-0.10030143707990646,
0.15401847660541534,
0.8185617327690125,
-0.6507763862609863,
-0.5580934286117554,
-0.9598314762115479,
-0.6642909646034241,
0.7201865315437317,
0.30974969267845154,
-0.14589589834213257,
-0.09259562939405441,
0.19417451322078705,
-0.1006053015589714,
0.009717521257698536,
-0.23989860713481903,
-0.6303657293319702,
-0.0901692658662796,
-0.19030442833900452,
-0.3507467806339264,
-0.16677795350551605,
-0.5430303812026978,
-0.43797463178634644,
0.42258477210998535,
0.026313070207834244,
0.47980326414108276,
0.09432289749383926,
0.2574833929538727,
-0.14194969832897186,
0.2996681034564972,
0.6120217442512512,
0.648447573184967,
-0.11706862598657608,
0.11009535938501358,
-0.045957811176776886,
-0.763216495513916,
0.107813261449337,
0.19275076687335968,
-0.121247299015522,
0.4063633382320404,
0.710322916507721,
0.6100761890411377,
0.0677357017993927,
-0.7282148003578186,
0.7776782512664795,
-0.2890986502170563,
-0.47167909145355225,
-0.3024286925792694,
0.05043887719511986,
0.2281280755996704,
0.4754143953323364,
0.2955871522426605,
0.22103597223758698,
0.6772612929344177,
-0.6997222304344177,
0.35343411564826965,
0.7021804451942444,
-0.26899588108062744,
-0.48172852396965027,
0.6403772234916687,
0.09734409302473068,
-0.9034131765365601,
0.5423033833503723,
-0.07141728699207306,
-0.3821614980697632,
0.7996944189071655,
0.6181126832962036,
0.7711272239685059,
-0.6387724876403809,
0.2996976971626282,
-0.17622245848178864,
0.05957268178462982,
0.1869460791349411,
0.5136027336120605,
-0.08707477152347565,
-0.8796886801719666,
0.016960373148322105,
-0.32033610343933105,
-0.7123669981956482,
0.2287084013223648,
-0.8131445050239563,
-0.0828796923160553,
-0.10115426778793335,
-0.7676165103912354,
0.6716553568840027,
-0.09930924326181412,
-0.33649495244026184,
0.3319164514541626,
0.427582710981369,
0.5521253347396851,
-1.0030241012573242,
0.7149332761764526,
0.45078352093696594,
-0.37567761540412903,
-0.451718807220459,
0.004371436312794685,
0.41986003518104553,
-0.44153469800949097,
0.4991953372955322,
-0.21062062680721283,
-0.4576864242553711,
0.030876846984028816,
-0.5703571438789368,
-0.7825296521186829,
0.6075257062911987,
0.2092158943414688,
-0.43126872181892395,
0.04453989863395691,
0.22980253398418427,
0.7127783298492432,
-0.48269039392471313,
0.4279153645038605,
0.7508646845817566,
0.42485129833221436,
-0.162523552775383,
-1.311860203742981,
-0.48346826434135437,
-0.32293835282325745,
-0.3918490409851074,
-0.14083799719810486,
-0.28484195470809937,
0.6614944338798523,
0.2183181643486023,
-0.1894194781780243,
-0.09792304784059525,
0.5817928314208984,
0.2390090525150299,
0.8706779479980469,
0.36960333585739136,
0.31535688042640686,
0.9359152913093567,
-0.039687588810920715,
0.8877609372138977,
-0.12012416869401932,
-0.002956873271614313,
0.678204357624054,
-0.2982548773288727,
0.7975197434425354,
0.20365025103092194,
-0.26030001044273376,
0.2441854327917099,
0.5811400413513184,
0.4533275365829468,
0.31109818816185,
0.038375601172447205,
-0.2380247712135315,
0.29995259642601013,
-0.38659223914146423,
-0.603916585445404,
0.7551226019859314,
0.8577026724815369,
-0.1901666522026062,
-0.0180084016174078,
0.37427300214767456,
-0.07613195478916168,
0.127081036567688,
-0.2762046754360199,
0.6627970933914185,
0.3260030448436737,
-0.2665662467479706,
0.4640360176563263,
0.017313813790678978,
0.5663437247276306,
-0.5793231129646301,
-0.018507452681660652,
-0.22523291409015656,
-0.023798486217856407,
-0.25111210346221924,
-0.6022882461547852,
0.923425555229187,
0.049140896648168564,
-0.06749274581670761,
-0.2952733635902405,
0.6130638122558594,
-0.34633830189704895,
-0.32495012879371643,
0.2676607370376587,
0.6866409182548523,
0.3529263436794281,
0.03641954064369202,
-0.699606716632843,
-0.003310345346108079,
-0.3334493637084961,
-0.18037818372249603,
0.34206876158714294,
0.23097030818462372,
-0.3075033128261566,
0.6670615077018738,
0.30565211176872253,
0.2836854159832001,
-0.011963768862187862,
0.37260180711746216,
0.4122847318649292,
-0.6419345140457153,
-0.3347928524017334,
-0.49490636587142944,
0.10093067586421967,
0.09111925959587097,
-0.34028181433677673,
0.6795644164085388,
0.4526320695877075,
0.629987895488739,
0.0900920182466507,
0.5408744215965271,
0.10081443190574646,
0.9250410795211792,
-0.34198763966560364,
0.6853495240211487,
-0.5544002056121826,
0.005650409497320652,
-0.42017948627471924,
-0.4597392678260803,
-0.5020934343338013,
0.6950962543487549,
-0.15166756510734558,
0.09878994524478912,
0.8485103845596313,
0.5378904342651367,
-0.22728896141052246,
0.5958804488182068,
0.10478484630584717,
0.11982102692127228,
0.07350226491689682,
0.2812005579471588,
0.861692488193512,
-0.31047648191452026,
-0.19188882410526276,
0.04466407373547554,
-0.30340906977653503,
-0.061962541192770004,
-0.40798696875572205,
-0.37915927171707153,
-0.887252926826477,
-0.5926105976104736,
0.062295522540807724,
0.1504458785057068,
0.49236100912094116,
0.7236990928649902,
-0.8756979703903198,
-0.2207048237323761,
0.07422091066837311,
0.3207562267780304,
-0.8454346060752869,
-0.17133408784866333,
0.2887435555458069,
0.05125771462917328,
-0.6353031396865845,
0.8423736095428467,
-0.13376642763614655,
-0.12032108008861542,
-0.07326652109622955,
0.1563607007265091,
-0.26371490955352783,
0.017921283841133118,
0.4981168806552887,
0.5102624297142029,
-0.6974813342094421,
-0.227512389421463,
-0.1300475299358368,
0.14726391434669495,
0.15038229525089264,
0.6997808218002319,
-0.5758451223373413,
0.0599161796271801,
0.24398809671401978,
0.413860946893692,
0.35549822449684143,
0.18333327770233154,
0.2974511682987213,
-0.6918396949768066,
-0.10106822103261948,
0.769736111164093,
0.35708990693092346,
0.179560124874115,
-0.3862355649471283,
0.2602261006832123,
0.4002988636493683,
-0.6156439781188965,
-0.7703853845596313,
0.316947340965271,
-1.3187552690505981,
-0.2941431403160095,
0.887738049030304,
0.22935335338115692,
-0.20289826393127441,
-0.6725134253501892,
-0.3427134156227112,
0.3187286853790283,
-0.3138643503189087,
0.45858776569366455,
0.6448144316673279,
-1.0040559768676758,
-0.27733856439590454,
-0.6371921300888062,
0.7553653120994568,
0.34554293751716614,
-0.5376863479614258,
-0.16667911410331726,
0.4095878005027771,
0.12625862658023834,
0.28750374913215637,
0.9045393466949463,
0.0427720732986927,
0.3195239305496216,
0.1242493987083435,
-0.046661000698804855,
0.18205778300762177,
-0.3404633104801178,
-0.7203125357627869,
0.18631283938884735,
0.025119969621300697,
-0.14566156268119812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12869v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12869v2 | Exploring the Impact of Table-to-Text Methods on Augmenting LLM-based Question Answering with Domain Hybrid Data | 2024-02-20T10:00:58 | 2024-04-09T09:00:57 | Dehai Min, Nan Hu, Rihui Jin, Nuo Lin, Jiaoyan Chen, Yongrui Chen, Yu Li, Guilin Qi, Yun Li, Nijun Li, Qianren Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Augmenting Large Language Models (LLMs) for Question Answering (QA) with
domain specific data has attracted wide attention. However, domain data often
exists in a hybrid format, including text and semi-structured tables, posing
challenges for the seamless integration of information. Table-to-Text
Generation is a promising solution by facilitating the transformation of hybrid
data into a uniformly text-formatted corpus. Although this technique has been
widely studied by the NLP community, there is currently no comparative analysis
on how corpora generated by different table-to-text methods affect the
performance of QA systems. In this paper, we address this research gap in two
steps. First, we innovatively integrate table-to-text generation into the
framework of enhancing LLM-based QA systems with domain hybrid data. Then, we
utilize this framework in real-world industrial data to conduct extensive
experiments on two types of QA systems (DSFT and RAG frameworks) with four
representative methods: Markdown format, Template serialization, TPLM-based
method, and LLM-based method. Based on the experimental results, we draw some
empirical findings and explore the underlying reasons behind the success of
some methods. We hope the findings of this work will provide a valuable
reference for the academic and industrial communities in developing robust QA
systems. | [
-0.4419609308242798,
-0.9168148636817932,
0.7243226170539856,
-0.061574917286634445,
-0.2962440848350525,
0.4388331472873688,
0.15986360609531403,
-0.6639447808265686,
0.013294074684381485,
0.4258904457092285,
-0.419260174036026,
-0.6124319434165955,
-0.002599228173494339,
0.3853886127471924,
-0.5401350855827332,
1.0126903057098389,
-0.129938542842865,
-0.04163694381713867,
-0.6776357889175415,
0.015104403719305992,
-0.5621519088745117,
-0.9124813675880432,
-0.24077920615673065,
-0.10384666919708252,
0.32605189085006714,
0.3714618682861328,
0.8109272718429565,
0.4892864227294922,
0.3455313742160797,
0.1589267998933792,
-0.01398791465908289,
0.38310790061950684,
-0.36905279755592346,
0.03761615604162216,
-0.03054845705628395,
-0.5664159059524536,
-0.39013996720314026,
-0.27474772930145264,
0.5183259844779968,
0.6588520407676697,
-0.12988711893558502,
0.26538974046707153,
-0.0028123469091951847,
0.64863121509552,
-0.49447694420814514,
0.021039657294750214,
-0.5855805277824402,
0.15382370352745056,
-0.13802874088287354,
-0.5561398267745972,
-0.5230429172515869,
-0.39515554904937744,
0.007428842596709728,
-0.4636216461658478,
0.0961408019065857,
0.2875968813896179,
0.5812315940856934,
0.03322627767920494,
-0.5508439540863037,
-0.22815199196338654,
-1.1953532695770264,
0.5641040205955505,
-1.0233275890350342,
0.383741170167923,
-0.04471535608172417,
0.23689940571784973,
-0.2559254765510559,
-0.7910978198051453,
-0.8519929647445679,
-0.06494688242673874,
-0.29297935962677,
0.24076953530311584,
0.0767550989985466,
-0.07503209263086319,
0.3877340853214264,
0.4896549582481384,
-0.827195942401886,
0.17252324521541595,
-0.23058128356933594,
0.10192754119634628,
0.5345220565795898,
0.28480616211891174,
0.5369820594787598,
-0.057793229818344116,
-0.4499945640563965,
-0.17912620306015015,
-0.6050941944122314,
0.010617752559483051,
0.08848783373832703,
0.16724839806556702,
0.13150295615196228,
0.7951240539550781,
-0.21082626283168793,
0.7741448283195496,
-0.19745996594429016,
-0.18183620274066925,
0.0417223796248436,
-0.49325817823410034,
-0.2152276486158371,
-0.23709797859191895,
0.6236429810523987,
0.29337599873542786,
-0.09668038040399551,
-0.6422610878944397,
-0.369991660118103,
0.12742295861244202,
0.2006959468126297,
-0.411452978849411,
0.20326879620552063,
0.39542752504348755,
-0.2325223982334137,
-0.20515744388103485,
0.05385233834385872,
-0.9294370412826538,
-0.23389272391796112,
-0.2484029233455658,
0.634335994720459,
-0.1476561278104782,
-0.2549269199371338,
-0.009985039010643959,
-0.2809304893016815,
0.7137706279754639,
0.2302095890045166,
-0.582766056060791,
0.46241888403892517,
0.7903473377227783,
0.5491304993629456,
-0.6742493510246277,
0.06779694557189941,
-0.4787072241306305,
0.3520544767379761,
-0.46284809708595276,
0.9805395007133484,
-0.3329099714756012,
-0.5470836162567139,
0.36219510436058044,
-0.29250386357307434,
-0.09444872289896011,
-1.0680822134017944,
0.45569369196891785,
-0.9805625677108765,
0.36832427978515625,
-0.31466108560562134,
-0.5096548199653625,
0.07750391215085983,
0.2925909161567688,
-0.6297754049301147,
1.2559230327606201,
0.146928608417511,
-0.698455810546875,
0.3472960293292999,
-0.6419782638549805,
-0.6121678352355957,
0.09431859850883484,
-0.3808053135871887,
-0.529330313205719,
-0.002730002161115408,
0.11015589535236359,
0.42789533734321594,
-0.501895010471344,
0.2167130559682846,
-0.19096410274505615,
-0.2836659848690033,
0.6610822081565857,
-0.16933487355709076,
0.2668182849884033,
-0.03238562121987343,
-0.36945053935050964,
-0.015469254925847054,
-0.7872257232666016,
0.17130565643310547,
0.20869678258895874,
-0.40189313888549805,
-0.21296124160289764,
0.05230576917529106,
0.16858512163162231,
0.48697611689567566,
0.009685887023806572,
-0.49217548966407776,
-0.23552608489990234,
-0.24613896012306213,
0.2464277446269989,
0.2975407540798187,
0.37839004397392273,
0.17813020944595337,
-0.6831720471382141,
0.6988926529884338,
-0.04612766206264496,
-0.07297391444444656,
0.18410205841064453,
-0.33550214767456055,
-0.5453711152076721,
0.021307503804564476,
0.5119441151618958,
0.6497682929039001,
-1.0542018413543701,
0.20215992629528046,
-0.2104385644197464,
-0.3408476710319519,
-0.36776435375213623,
-0.24360327422618866,
0.26322874426841736,
0.7655723690986633,
0.48588553071022034,
-0.2484743595123291,
-0.33820563554763794,
-0.9891866445541382,
-0.09349042177200317,
-0.19706791639328003,
-0.20192965865135193,
0.2693800926208496,
0.26363006234169006,
-0.042289670556783676,
1.135263442993164,
-0.453261137008667,
0.09457305818796158,
-0.4116210341453552,
-0.12444891780614853,
-0.013120651245117188,
0.37837424874305725,
0.3200676739215851,
-0.7185923457145691,
-0.5745720267295837,
-0.022962652146816254,
-0.6222817897796631,
-0.02845918759703636,
-0.076662577688694,
-0.3588404357433319,
0.37462425231933594,
0.32992857694625854,
-0.38413605093955994,
0.4424391984939575,
0.3870714604854584,
-0.19543562829494476,
0.7767466902732849,
0.09997431933879852,
0.2973138391971588,
-1.1411327123641968,
0.24577002227306366,
0.07139454782009125,
-0.14373737573623657,
-1.0491279363632202,
0.06041412800550461,
0.15093018114566803,
-0.2710527181625366,
-0.557921826839447,
0.239893838763237,
-0.39423850178718567,
-0.4560497999191284,
-0.11301084607839584,
0.24078881740570068,
0.30291908979415894,
0.5783160924911499,
0.1569433957338333,
1.35417902469635,
-0.06470648944377899,
-0.593876838684082,
-0.06770139187574387,
0.6482009887695312,
-0.2139204740524292,
0.3867509663105011,
-0.6885195374488831,
0.2916199564933777,
0.026965759694576263,
0.157297283411026,
-1.1207480430603027,
0.1163722351193428,
0.09257958084344864,
-0.32445383071899414,
0.32964199781417847,
0.2032121866941452,
-0.8485670685768127,
-0.2752164900302887,
-0.4250301122665405,
0.22411371767520905,
0.47774893045425415,
-0.5137406587600708,
0.5420896410942078,
0.41955116391181946,
-0.2231622189283371,
-0.406393826007843,
-0.7278113961219788,
0.17888566851615906,
-0.3219001293182373,
-0.7777259349822998,
0.6022368669509888,
-0.0952473133802414,
-0.29456397891044617,
-0.30037423968315125,
-0.4161113500595093,
-0.09714190661907196,
0.06582657247781754,
-0.19123604893684387,
0.6468443870544434,
-0.27045243978500366,
0.14299333095550537,
0.2704102098941803,
0.0410015694797039,
0.30509382486343384,
-0.09195271134376526,
0.6710302233695984,
0.16811063885688782,
-0.10213987529277802,
-0.4966586232185364,
0.5707255601882935,
0.39562517404556274,
-0.4304739534854889,
0.9375330805778503,
0.20713409781455994,
-0.1392008662223816,
-0.5701002478599548,
-0.555937647819519,
-0.25555911660194397,
-0.4730222523212433,
0.30428868532180786,
-0.2037908285856247,
-0.7947469353675842,
0.6360927224159241,
-0.1612040102481842,
0.23806904256343842,
0.4657112956047058,
0.47532984614372253,
-0.37190061807632446,
0.6019740104675293,
0.4868110418319702,
0.3631610572338104,
0.21031919121742249,
-0.14620117843151093,
0.27307575941085815,
-0.8552026748657227,
-0.38477441668510437,
-0.7583433985710144,
-0.19533434510231018,
-0.5297389030456543,
-0.5494669675827026,
0.6995511651039124,
-0.16279849410057068,
0.20974525809288025,
0.07753998786211014,
-0.2584683299064636,
0.08323993533849716,
0.30290207266807556,
0.1618313491344452,
0.7392840385437012,
0.05665251985192299,
0.046545349061489105,
0.07948482781648636,
-0.9301425814628601,
-0.6383233666419983,
1.0468653440475464,
0.27746933698654175,
0.5013216137886047,
0.04114244505763054,
0.4979374408721924,
0.37972554564476013,
0.30798083543777466,
-0.48489910364151,
0.6691662669181824,
-0.06629249453544617,
-0.4338513910770416,
-0.3588801324367523,
-0.43847161531448364,
-0.7286796569824219,
0.17958514392375946,
-0.398810476064682,
-0.26263394951820374,
0.18414399027824402,
0.026726191863417625,
-0.3185886740684509,
0.21031928062438965,
-0.7210155725479126,
0.7933436036109924,
-0.20867012441158295,
-0.43912971019744873,
0.07902929186820984,
-0.49988096952438354,
0.2953868806362152,
-0.26999256014823914,
0.20481179654598236,
0.1796804964542389,
-0.26761627197265625,
0.942496657371521,
-0.49547550082206726,
0.6607457995414734,
0.041066162288188934,
-0.4309311509132385,
0.33510223031044006,
-0.003704506903886795,
0.6832504272460938,
0.17360787093639374,
-0.13734540343284607,
-0.03211655095219612,
0.2733401656150818,
-0.30264097452163696,
-0.7503008842468262,
0.4295303523540497,
-0.6392718553543091,
-0.6094204783439636,
-0.32964688539505005,
-0.7686665654182434,
-0.9978931546211243,
-0.17332331836223602,
-0.06230016052722931,
0.5010089874267578,
0.02103000320494175,
0.06548411399126053,
0.8716669678688049,
-0.5395001769065857,
0.2827652096748352,
0.585228681564331,
-0.14728912711143494,
-0.24656394124031067,
0.7386707067489624,
0.260449081659317,
0.5235488414764404,
0.6819273233413696,
-0.1484455168247223,
-0.5179798603057861,
-0.8077702522277832,
-0.532892107963562,
0.35914021730422974,
-0.4612809121608734,
-0.26607397198677063,
-0.7951955199241638,
-0.25083664059638977,
-0.332343190908432,
-0.06585980951786041,
0.0769362673163414,
-0.5585762858390808,
-0.27765971422195435,
-0.18095393478870392,
0.4290506839752197,
0.3867630958557129,
0.41049012541770935,
0.17444708943367004,
-0.8776838183403015,
0.429071843624115,
0.35932108759880066,
0.42814454436302185,
0.1332315355539322,
-0.33193808794021606,
-0.10052800923585892,
-0.16335374116897583,
-0.032136499881744385,
-1.037530779838562,
0.21585389971733093,
-0.0361507385969162,
0.4587334394454956,
-0.19118088483810425,
0.30377259850502014,
0.5241482853889465,
-0.354947566986084,
0.7772157788276672,
-0.1521548479795456,
-0.7090187668800354,
0.21885477006435394,
-0.49188289046287537,
0.16326266527175903,
0.5175806879997253,
0.31076329946517944,
-0.6448680758476257,
-0.3907865285873413,
-0.35550457239151,
-0.9761872291564941,
0.4611968398094177,
0.24459782242774963,
-0.08568871021270752,
0.26727986335754395,
0.525505542755127,
0.5106667280197144,
0.4009234309196472,
-0.5930411219596863,
-0.33287152647972107,
0.34403011202812195,
-0.03974951431155205,
0.10627109557390213,
-0.2411738485097885,
-0.08913328498601913,
0.17313994467258453,
0.5886399745941162,
0.03511136770248413,
0.36571910977363586,
0.2246275693178177,
-0.13923130929470062,
-0.08198890089988708,
0.6100687384605408,
0.5243093371391296,
0.8831788301467896,
-0.10693900287151337,
-0.14793246984481812,
0.25382962822914124,
-0.20171670615673065,
0.03846316784620285,
0.14716824889183044,
-0.48347318172454834,
0.07096569985151291,
0.10405508428812027,
0.5075170397758484,
-0.2660069763660431,
-0.8076680302619934,
0.04494454339146614,
0.0686374232172966,
-0.3150971829891205,
-0.11612138152122498,
-0.002935869852080941,
0.06812581419944763,
0.07718928903341293,
0.6515371799468994,
-0.403481125831604,
0.3254625201225281,
-0.6544598340988159,
0.38388776779174805,
0.48491236567497253,
-0.058985915035009384,
-0.09372596442699432,
0.5219334363937378,
0.1818626970052719,
-0.272532194852829,
0.24998971819877625,
0.090288907289505,
-0.3954867422580719,
0.5711923837661743,
0.8012217879295349,
0.5327135324478149,
0.0981471836566925,
0.5298067331314087,
-0.06857336312532425,
0.18391582369804382,
0.22141852974891663,
0.45484238862991333,
-0.0020510570611804724,
-0.458873450756073,
-0.6284085512161255,
-0.4558066427707672,
-0.6160002946853638,
0.2885855734348297,
-0.5884413719177246,
-0.11294414103031158,
-0.23719649016857147,
-0.10694315284490585,
-0.09945235401391983,
0.15870441496372223,
-0.4301057457923889,
0.20253519713878632,
-0.09034736454486847,
0.8809923529624939,
-0.8251601457595825,
0.4165589213371277,
0.7424490451812744,
-0.2746380865573883,
-0.9261922836303711,
0.223222553730011,
-0.36441943049430847,
-0.5951086282730103,
0.06513294577598572,
-0.2060074359178543,
0.1520020067691803,
0.05929351970553398,
-0.14196814596652985,
-0.7263782620429993,
1.0777584314346313,
-0.009566267021000385,
-0.4819377064704895,
-0.15173688530921936,
0.8955690264701843,
0.8101094365119934,
-0.1601419746875763,
-0.056446172297000885,
0.7662012577056885,
0.3588096499443054,
-0.05083760991692543,
-0.8466073274612427,
0.22043129801750183,
-0.2107607126235962,
0.2608756124973297,
0.4263728857040405,
-0.5414314866065979,
0.15045247972011566,
0.23887322843074799,
-0.3280211091041565,
-0.20754499733448029,
0.8552908301353455,
0.40063294768333435,
0.5758664608001709,
0.3635593056678772,
0.3105297088623047,
0.41707369685173035,
-0.026581786572933197,
0.9349154829978943,
-0.15755169093608856,
-0.04904565215110779,
0.8864763379096985,
-0.6246079206466675,
0.9530553221702576,
0.7261472344398499,
-0.46175873279571533,
0.47739627957344055,
0.5684555768966675,
0.05887719616293907,
0.26220789551734924,
0.2241164594888687,
-0.18812580406665802,
0.13890475034713745,
-0.2617858350276947,
-0.5084813833236694,
-0.015610316768288612,
0.2925500273704529,
-0.07464683800935745,
-0.17781871557235718,
0.033549122512340546,
-0.09990067034959793,
0.31227418780326843,
-0.10784610360860825,
0.9409022927284241,
-0.05175746604800224,
-0.5378015637397766,
0.48811256885528564,
-0.029880767688155174,
0.5991889238357544,
-0.3946685791015625,
-0.020785842090845108,
-0.32969576120376587,
-0.37406855821609497,
-0.2900390625,
-0.7654803395271301,
0.43409910798072815,
0.07114996761083603,
-0.08564089983701706,
-0.20227524638175964,
0.6069551706314087,
-0.4643099904060364,
-0.1744222193956375,
0.07793477922677994,
1.0297608375549316,
-0.19617533683776855,
0.18470364809036255,
-0.36444246768951416,
0.05848054587841034,
-0.03627527877688408,
-0.08397779613733292,
0.5408464074134827,
0.3327364921569824,
-0.11252108216285706,
0.3352683186531067,
0.6720386743545532,
-0.11716283112764359,
0.14981940388679504,
-0.15201377868652344,
0.946694552898407,
-0.4798634648323059,
-0.3830019235610962,
-0.41134804487228394,
0.6891100406646729,
0.03259781375527382,
-0.08823330700397491,
0.689007043838501,
0.8158158659934998,
0.7700994610786438,
-0.21988964080810547,
0.8005314469337463,
-0.06402519345283508,
0.8394206166267395,
-0.5645195245742798,
0.5397391319274902,
-0.530046820640564,
0.4765894114971161,
-0.29225048422813416,
-0.9760294556617737,
-0.25620630383491516,
-0.16905248165130615,
-0.34041014313697815,
0.05888219177722931,
0.7308235168457031,
0.8070719838142395,
0.23721927404403687,
-0.0732773095369339,
0.32094720005989075,
0.003839528188109398,
0.3001909852027893,
0.20413175225257874,
0.8922231793403625,
-0.39862489700317383,
0.7546402812004089,
-0.30485543608665466,
-0.09685385972261429,
-0.043937478214502335,
-0.45716455578804016,
-0.5753757357597351,
-0.5861476063728333,
-0.39072808623313904,
-0.561044454574585,
0.12638022005558014,
0.6452613472938538,
0.19476142525672913,
-0.7730797529220581,
-0.3672909736633301,
0.1616399735212326,
-0.1521722674369812,
-0.23664933443069458,
-0.2824905812740326,
0.5466798543930054,
-0.2001447230577469,
-0.5925612449645996,
0.22740377485752106,
0.3001802861690521,
0.06936895102262497,
-0.07683203369379044,
0.2389187216758728,
-0.2348834127187729,
0.2298671156167984,
0.7157875299453735,
0.36323845386505127,
-0.27347204089164734,
0.048781268298625946,
0.45783594250679016,
-0.07895079255104065,
0.32514095306396484,
0.7943906784057617,
-0.8044660687446594,
-0.020113490521907806,
0.5848352909088135,
0.9858702421188354,
0.5128791332244873,
0.3496266007423401,
0.9095980525016785,
-0.5329153537750244,
-0.3229212462902069,
0.4792235493659973,
-0.1336592733860016,
0.20830096304416656,
-0.5045843124389648,
0.5273656845092773,
0.06943225860595703,
-0.5290602445602417,
-1.0712783336639404,
0.04135972633957863,
-1.0575828552246094,
-0.24260297417640686,
1.1550450325012207,
0.29346662759780884,
-0.14776001870632172,
-0.34543877840042114,
-0.08358684927225113,
0.26473116874694824,
-0.3349812924861908,
1.0542384386062622,
0.30250176787376404,
-0.3406853973865509,
-0.056504230946302414,
-0.6683886647224426,
0.573081910610199,
0.626229465007782,
-1.4482327699661255,
-0.01885390281677246,
0.44943690299987793,
0.05744962394237518,
0.07386601716279984,
0.34901589155197144,
-0.3306190073490143,
0.48563581705093384,
-0.3210867643356323,
-0.04999518394470215,
0.02300090715289116,
-0.05828527361154556,
-0.26496705412864685,
0.39842039346694946,
0.12747697532176971,
0.026629861444234848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12865v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12865v1 | Backward Lens: Projecting Language Model Gradients into the Vocabulary Space | 2024-02-20T09:57:08 | 2024-02-20T09:57:08 | Shahar Katz, Yonatan Belinkov, Mor Geva, Lior Wolf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Understanding how Transformer-based Language Models (LMs) learn and recall
information is a key goal of the deep learning community. Recent
interpretability methods project weights and hidden states obtained from the
forward pass to the models' vocabularies, helping to uncover how information
flows within LMs. In this work, we extend this methodology to LMs' backward
pass and gradients. We first prove that a gradient matrix can be cast as a
low-rank linear combination of its forward and backward passes' inputs. We then
develop methods to project these gradients into vocabulary items and explore
the mechanics of how new information is stored in the LMs' neurons. | [
-0.24249882996082306,
-0.4106736183166504,
0.36947593092918396,
0.03342944383621216,
0.18707109987735748,
0.12839464843273163,
-0.17524293065071106,
-0.14625303447246552,
0.19641739130020142,
0.699869692325592,
-0.5640730261802673,
-0.5550751686096191,
-0.7203994393348694,
-0.36902040243148804,
-0.7434744238853455,
0.9253368973731995,
0.020197216421365738,
0.2923314571380615,
0.18513335287570953,
-0.07235508412122726,
-0.5073032975196838,
-0.27784642577171326,
-0.5950515866279602,
-0.6589292883872986,
0.7220019102096558,
0.24816901981830597,
0.9032991528511047,
0.5125248432159424,
0.3736068904399872,
0.2206326425075531,
-0.16178582608699799,
-0.29376789927482605,
-0.5500333905220032,
0.12068900465965271,
-0.5022159218788147,
-1.0170040130615234,
-0.20824381709098816,
0.11132483929395676,
0.9812157154083252,
1.0047011375427246,
-0.38261061906814575,
0.1231428012251854,
0.1985887587070465,
0.5578655004501343,
-0.5880517959594727,
0.11335442960262299,
-0.6673166751861572,
0.28268927335739136,
-0.07933502644300461,
-0.28166618943214417,
-0.47227463126182556,
-0.2395961582660675,
0.05999651551246643,
-0.5346569418907166,
0.29480668902397156,
-0.1551726907491684,
0.8436273336410522,
-0.04427263140678406,
-0.09467504173517227,
-0.4063161313533783,
-0.8460355401039124,
0.8670346736907959,
-0.4669916033744812,
0.7601010799407959,
0.21775050461292267,
0.33107465505599976,
0.0668010488152504,
-0.944603443145752,
-0.6447428464889526,
-0.06833607703447342,
-0.19975467026233673,
0.11331594735383987,
-0.3558274507522583,
-0.06730668991804123,
0.015863023698329926,
0.5288476943969727,
-0.36652886867523193,
0.2892036736011505,
-0.5668079257011414,
-0.13593879342079163,
0.35471946001052856,
0.2519727051258087,
0.14359796047210693,
-0.07812836766242981,
-0.321710467338562,
-0.2749719023704529,
-0.8349831104278564,
-0.05328235775232315,
0.1514165699481964,
0.47412529587745667,
0.042735546827316284,
0.6020516157150269,
0.10183924436569214,
0.5717408061027527,
0.05751684308052063,
0.1649540215730667,
0.23099146783351898,
-0.2747916877269745,
-0.34029337763786316,
-0.33091965317726135,
0.1748236119747162,
0.22694259881973267,
0.2581367492675781,
-0.37054210901260376,
-0.3450574576854706,
-0.036910153925418854,
0.5707389712333679,
-0.6088210344314575,
-0.2575052082538605,
-0.05774809420108795,
-0.7492141723632812,
-0.3172580301761627,
-0.07876075804233551,
-0.8483480215072632,
-0.5516431331634521,
-0.32047292590141296,
0.6803224682807922,
-0.22449059784412384,
-0.34693995118141174,
0.06828823685646057,
-0.10175532847642899,
0.48319679498672485,
0.39337512850761414,
-0.8664849996566772,
0.6508232951164246,
0.6904845237731934,
0.8966836929321289,
-0.17378678917884827,
-0.3688221573829651,
-0.4921998977661133,
-0.1435714066028595,
-0.4187425374984741,
0.42275696992874146,
-0.6084808111190796,
-0.5665497183799744,
0.44843780994415283,
0.21255937218666077,
-0.26000139117240906,
-0.6541213989257812,
0.29689496755599976,
-0.8377286195755005,
0.2447204887866974,
-0.005807037465274334,
-0.5473774671554565,
-0.32723602652549744,
0.17608125507831573,
-0.6729894280433655,
0.8503149747848511,
0.029676804319024086,
-0.3909507989883423,
0.10661355406045914,
-0.5449038743972778,
-0.34727808833122253,
0.05405999347567558,
-0.19024145603179932,
-0.06398220360279083,
0.4308141767978668,
-0.07656203210353851,
0.570398211479187,
-0.06646702438592911,
0.15041881799697876,
0.0747373104095459,
-0.35403889417648315,
0.19045232236385345,
-0.44537991285324097,
0.5044499635696411,
0.16476821899414062,
-0.05792970210313797,
0.05189363285899162,
-0.7467243671417236,
-0.34766125679016113,
0.06496541202068329,
-0.5695646405220032,
-0.259676456451416,
0.28780192136764526,
-0.022383779287338257,
0.24124999344348907,
0.046836718916893005,
-0.39110949635505676,
0.25029146671295166,
-0.4267185628414154,
0.2985561490058899,
0.733880877494812,
-0.39207860827445984,
1.0081340074539185,
0.04104785993695259,
0.5921871066093445,
0.3290517330169678,
0.09544830769300461,
-0.23122252523899078,
-0.5071722865104675,
-1.0428502559661865,
0.22564230859279633,
0.029146477580070496,
0.6546908617019653,
-0.7779906988143921,
0.12744462490081787,
-0.2650589644908905,
-0.49114611744880676,
-0.5647422075271606,
0.23308397829532623,
0.14330212771892548,
0.7632946372032166,
0.4877781867980957,
-0.36332783102989197,
-0.24417781829833984,
-0.8835684657096863,
-0.39905452728271484,
-0.054495811462402344,
0.010394827462732792,
0.2279840111732483,
0.5371714234352112,
-0.23321369290351868,
0.6380888223648071,
-0.6924301981925964,
-0.38850823044776917,
-0.27145540714263916,
0.11514133960008621,
0.48563680052757263,
0.5639345049858093,
0.2776472568511963,
-0.8037407994270325,
0.15495024621486664,
-0.4027893841266632,
-0.4459556043148041,
0.12079773098230362,
0.004419276956468821,
-0.1715661585330963,
-0.0947883352637291,
0.7254827618598938,
-0.6179003715515137,
0.6206479072570801,
0.6634842157363892,
-0.43479880690574646,
0.08571022003889084,
-0.08886872231960297,
-0.45818936824798584,
-0.9384661912918091,
0.1446172446012497,
0.06755072623491287,
-0.11992646753787994,
-0.8213465809822083,
0.04449813812971115,
-0.0401705801486969,
0.017091210931539536,
-0.36804646253585815,
0.7772714495658875,
-0.48549652099609375,
-0.2753572165966034,
-0.21357093751430511,
0.33226585388183594,
0.08974611014127731,
0.42824849486351013,
0.0913359597325325,
0.40764912962913513,
0.7382867932319641,
-0.6155197024345398,
0.2119436413049698,
-0.012305567041039467,
-0.3060184121131897,
0.5582919716835022,
-0.436587393283844,
-0.09594079852104187,
-0.5609833598136902,
0.24042454361915588,
-1.138663411140442,
0.3653509020805359,
0.32617372274398804,
-0.44928649067878723,
0.6921709179878235,
-0.2091267704963684,
-0.17873331904411316,
-0.10121597349643707,
-0.15935111045837402,
0.28657156229019165,
0.6583475470542908,
-0.5878778696060181,
0.8969104886054993,
0.4607947766780853,
-0.06180214881896973,
-0.9734652638435364,
-1.1040793657302856,
0.002329115057364106,
0.009971508756279945,
-0.18281224370002747,
0.4202796518802643,
0.15161137282848358,
-0.2577357292175293,
0.10627031326293945,
0.24385333061218262,
-0.008311020210385323,
0.1807602047920227,
0.2496594786643982,
0.21208356320858002,
-0.5174623131752014,
0.37323451042175293,
-0.11425454169511795,
0.05754825845360756,
0.09369249641895294,
-0.6233717203140259,
0.652209460735321,
-0.18121473491191864,
-0.13015463948249817,
-0.301716148853302,
0.264524906873703,
0.20550550520420074,
-0.09158052504062653,
1.0327943563461304,
0.7509427070617676,
-0.47674477100372314,
-0.3466697633266449,
-0.3179561495780945,
-0.3993726074695587,
-0.4498555660247803,
0.606452465057373,
-0.3810090720653534,
-0.6724459528923035,
0.6346588730812073,
-0.1101604774594307,
0.12414920330047607,
0.5441534519195557,
0.6908984184265137,
-0.09771821647882462,
0.7234122157096863,
0.8150227069854736,
-0.08216792345046997,
0.6371003985404968,
-0.5857064127922058,
0.03729039058089256,
-0.7765507698059082,
-0.5295087695121765,
-0.3952663838863373,
-0.6334676146507263,
-0.40753674507141113,
-0.6983806490898132,
-0.09618889540433884,
0.5458886027336121,
-0.07949412614107132,
0.1140337586402893,
-0.2510288655757904,
0.346525102853775,
0.6235176920890808,
0.04691796749830246,
0.3607853055000305,
-0.04048255458474159,
-0.23743614554405212,
-0.010928853414952755,
-0.7086870670318604,
-0.339013934135437,
0.8011960983276367,
0.801552414894104,
1.1254326105117798,
0.1262083351612091,
0.5757091045379639,
-0.006606757175177336,
0.7215583920478821,
-1.0492808818817139,
0.5391377806663513,
-0.3305720388889313,
-0.556623637676239,
-0.18078447878360748,
-0.022275865077972412,
-0.9262535572052002,
0.3194553852081299,
-0.029645387083292007,
-0.8748888373374939,
0.5534782409667969,
0.31323957443237305,
-0.06325964629650116,
0.4063619375228882,
-0.44193869829177856,
0.5629263520240784,
0.08169739693403244,
-0.24801726639270782,
-0.44166234135627747,
-0.708084225654602,
0.08964502066373825,
0.18666526675224304,
0.20534451305866241,
0.2290552407503128,
-0.23957295715808868,
0.7985227108001709,
-0.25203922390937805,
1.2063281536102295,
-0.4924999475479126,
-0.37763604521751404,
0.04251331090927124,
0.36163708567619324,
0.29168832302093506,
-0.06708860397338867,
0.11776863038539886,
0.4179331064224243,
-0.34103184938430786,
-0.22511781752109528,
-0.7707836627960205,
0.6009929180145264,
-0.501530647277832,
-0.5357108116149902,
-0.1051982194185257,
-0.5469037294387817,
-0.10133298486471176,
0.1650093048810959,
0.24942463636398315,
0.522336483001709,
-0.07472893595695496,
-0.04462449625134468,
0.5594289898872375,
-0.30602923035621643,
0.4588650166988373,
0.5524019002914429,
-0.6855216026306152,
0.11729294806718826,
0.9178934693336487,
0.18625491857528687,
0.2005070596933365,
0.7495543956756592,
0.11025897413492203,
-0.3162527084350586,
-0.6569564938545227,
-0.35541632771492004,
0.2156105786561966,
-1.1139658689498901,
-0.016248369589447975,
-0.25508153438568115,
-0.44294270873069763,
-0.01752544194459915,
0.04287333786487579,
-0.5257673263549805,
-0.5494288206100464,
-0.4313714802265167,
-0.15016213059425354,
-0.05043217912316322,
1.0179672241210938,
-0.20833423733711243,
0.3878788352012634,
-0.5636730790138245,
0.006645817309617996,
0.15433070063591003,
0.39218780398368835,
0.26112428307533264,
-0.6078087687492371,
-0.44835370779037476,
-0.06953456252813339,
-0.2562717795372009,
-0.7726418972015381,
0.5068333148956299,
0.2624303996562958,
0.5534354448318481,
0.24036285281181335,
-0.6738449931144714,
0.3383242189884186,
-0.7719783782958984,
0.9704941511154175,
0.12079218029975891,
-1.0337722301483154,
0.5654796957969666,
0.03332341089844704,
0.09996987134218216,
0.2166319489479065,
0.3446933329105377,
-0.6462753415107727,
-0.21566535532474518,
-0.35868364572525024,
-0.7247342467308044,
0.5499582886695862,
-0.015378960408270359,
0.44342756271362305,
0.1924208104610443,
0.501100480556488,
0.17535285651683807,
0.21491074562072754,
-0.6654990315437317,
-0.47619524598121643,
-0.3024832308292389,
-0.33069878816604614,
-0.5869435667991638,
-0.1631011664867401,
-0.12332496792078018,
-0.10070182383060455,
0.2499491423368454,
-0.17079129815101624,
0.5175876617431641,
0.0732618048787117,
-0.24641142785549164,
0.10132749378681183,
0.14858166873455048,
0.7390913963317871,
0.574842631816864,
-0.06217674911022186,
0.3917076587677002,
0.098353810608387,
-0.7257563471794128,
-0.14392328262329102,
0.01348829548805952,
-0.0843387246131897,
0.17205898463726044,
0.35177746415138245,
0.9134181141853333,
0.12047692388296127,
-0.3181074261665344,
0.6211314797401428,
0.06255324929952621,
0.03966866061091423,
-0.3247568607330322,
-0.007397708483040333,
0.1510155349969864,
0.541991651058197,
0.4999546408653259,
0.29178348183631897,
0.18716305494308472,
-0.621527910232544,
0.08583984524011612,
0.3722589612007141,
-0.7350947260856628,
-0.6113516092300415,
0.39573150873184204,
-0.06164443865418434,
-0.3624168634414673,
0.6821317672729492,
0.38158175349235535,
-0.49304792284965515,
0.30353495478630066,
0.5646119713783264,
0.7106394171714783,
-0.36420002579689026,
0.194474458694458,
0.04208044707775116,
0.2145502120256424,
-0.16888144612312317,
0.505189836025238,
-0.09236621111631393,
-1.150080919265747,
-0.37596139311790466,
-0.6019209027290344,
-0.22767794132232666,
0.0222924891859293,
-0.9268431663513184,
0.057569049298763275,
-0.22905661165714264,
-0.14632704854011536,
0.06074931472539902,
-0.42201635241508484,
-0.7884925007820129,
0.46660223603248596,
0.3393973708152771,
1.2482987642288208,
-0.7728758454322815,
1.0025231838226318,
0.4531669318675995,
-0.491973876953125,
-0.763626217842102,
0.07366349548101425,
-0.2668558359146118,
-1.547845721244812,
1.4756711721420288,
-0.12965452671051025,
-0.3713933825492859,
0.05921095237135887,
-0.489728182554245,
-0.7832057476043701,
1.0746450424194336,
0.2762167453765869,
-0.47045567631721497,
-0.5608667135238647,
0.043522171676158905,
0.5051122903823853,
-0.3214586675167084,
0.18137148022651672,
0.3307285010814667,
0.2740660011768341,
0.07261247932910919,
-0.6450695395469666,
-0.04193107783794403,
-0.22738245129585266,
0.0963011384010315,
0.2007044404745102,
-0.3056889772415161,
1.0879018306732178,
-0.20135295391082764,
-0.29819101095199585,
0.06614671647548676,
0.6577114462852478,
-0.1782582402229309,
0.14553231000900269,
0.32594430446624756,
0.5153284668922424,
0.7437416315078735,
-0.08540399372577667,
1.2052336931228638,
-0.17176339030265808,
0.5273749828338623,
0.904556155204773,
0.11048098653554916,
1.2484756708145142,
0.7524383664131165,
0.052965980023145676,
0.8611423969268799,
0.13426470756530762,
-0.05307042971253395,
0.7197220921516418,
0.5448585152626038,
0.11353503167629242,
0.1255136877298355,
-0.21939584612846375,
-0.1686374545097351,
0.4428105652332306,
0.6572511792182922,
-0.8721583485603333,
0.04427731782197952,
0.14376597106456757,
0.016336841508746147,
-0.09310634434223175,
-0.7396981120109558,
0.4380035400390625,
0.4324573576450348,
-0.6158734560012817,
0.47109654545783997,
0.05295011028647423,
0.7094322443008423,
-0.3968804180622101,
-0.09836139529943466,
-0.30085983872413635,
0.5966715812683105,
-0.28902381658554077,
-1.0929045677185059,
0.4119756519794464,
-0.4570305645465851,
-0.20399591326713562,
-0.2329835742712021,
0.79128497838974,
-0.6138088703155518,
-0.4970967769622803,
0.49545982480049133,
0.6083099246025085,
0.06802897900342941,
0.22157302498817444,
-0.546221911907196,
-0.11801119893789291,
-0.37173447012901306,
-0.40592896938323975,
0.09276065975427628,
-0.12464490532875061,
0.1995481252670288,
0.7258648872375488,
0.044710200279951096,
0.5043236613273621,
0.2829963266849518,
0.3126774728298187,
0.7303266525268555,
-0.7418980002403259,
-0.38699841499328613,
-0.9376517534255981,
0.4841043949127197,
0.04082440957427025,
-0.3096468150615692,
0.7163748145103455,
0.25246304273605347,
0.9014123678207397,
-0.1615791767835617,
0.4007214903831482,
0.4704408049583435,
0.5433163642883301,
-0.8667391538619995,
0.7609097361564636,
-0.6126155853271484,
0.2699822783470154,
-0.191216841340065,
-0.7541303038597107,
-0.46259739995002747,
0.6685776710510254,
-0.27175167202949524,
0.07625561952590942,
0.49912095069885254,
0.8692673444747925,
-0.010468443855643272,
0.05415666103363037,
0.20884288847446442,
0.3030147850513458,
0.09229984879493713,
0.7021865844726562,
1.289579153060913,
-0.5149892568588257,
0.3104773163795471,
-0.1007823646068573,
0.09677718579769135,
0.006103022489696741,
-0.6387900710105896,
-0.7544779181480408,
-0.7149928212165833,
-0.2324761152267456,
-0.5448605418205261,
-0.013862933963537216,
0.29248830676078796,
0.939752459526062,
-0.7467010617256165,
-0.4265601634979248,
-0.3042531907558441,
0.11821487545967102,
-0.00196192623116076,
-0.2863939106464386,
0.35222047567367554,
-0.146978959441185,
-0.6697699427604675,
0.3443620502948761,
0.2325933873653412,
-0.039460521191358566,
-0.76065593957901,
-0.2321525663137436,
-0.023988988250494003,
0.1088327094912529,
0.5880756974220276,
0.15906226634979248,
-0.7025198340415955,
-0.12256532907485962,
0.023819923400878906,
-0.032081473618745804,
0.15513533353805542,
1.0068973302841187,
-1.058956265449524,
0.2573041021823883,
0.4408879578113556,
0.7089914083480835,
0.5176235437393188,
-0.3730849623680115,
0.8734169006347656,
-0.7878217101097107,
0.060488857328891754,
0.29490208625793457,
0.3680408000946045,
0.33966511487960815,
-0.17328815162181854,
0.3256489634513855,
0.19242241978645325,
-0.18745961785316467,
-0.6997878551483154,
0.4514698386192322,
-0.7551711797714233,
-0.42254897952079773,
0.9986348152160645,
-0.16389454901218414,
-0.09211929142475128,
0.08740746229887009,
0.06019660457968712,
0.1998547911643982,
-0.009670434519648552,
0.1912471503019333,
0.5331653356552124,
-0.04264318197965622,
-0.38516420125961304,
-0.43353116512298584,
0.46134647727012634,
0.337753564119339,
-0.3653215169906616,
-0.22770725190639496,
0.1483134627342224,
0.23713167011737823,
0.4460039734840393,
0.3252476155757904,
-0.1963479071855545,
-0.14721177518367767,
0.038648612797260284,
-0.25908443331718445,
0.3454117178916931,
-0.3300301432609558,
-0.8910797238349915,
0.2811083197593689,
0.046808671206235886,
-0.32374370098114014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12862v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12862v1 | Handling Ambiguity in Emotion: From Out-of-Domain Detection to Distribution Estimation | 2024-02-20T09:53:38 | 2024-02-20T09:53:38 | Wen Wu, Bo Li, Chao Zhang, Chung-Cheng Chiu, Qiujia Li, Junwen Bai, Tara N. Sainath, Philip C. Woodland | cs.CL | cs.CL | The subjective perception of emotion leads to inconsistent labels from human
annotators. Typically, utterances lacking majority-agreed labels are excluded
when training an emotion classifier, which cause problems when encountering
ambiguous emotional expressions during testing. This paper investigates three
methods to handle ambiguous emotion. First, we show that incorporating
utterances without majority-agreed labels as an additional class in the
classifier reduces the classification performance of the other emotion classes.
Then, we propose detecting utterances with ambiguous emotions as out-of-domain
samples by quantifying the uncertainty in emotion classification using
evidential deep learning. This approach retains the classification accuracy
while effectively detects ambiguous emotion expressions. Furthermore, to obtain
fine-grained distinctions among ambiguous emotions, we propose representing
emotion as a distribution instead of a single class label. The task is thus
re-framed from classification to distribution estimation where every individual
annotation is taken into account, not just the majority opinion. The evidential
uncertainty measure is extended to quantify the uncertainty in emotion
distribution estimation. Experimental results on the IEMOCAP and CREMA-D
datasets demonstrate the superior capability of the proposed method in terms of
majority class prediction, emotion distribution estimation, and uncertainty
estimation. | [
-0.7133288383483887,
-0.461264431476593,
0.4699942171573639,
0.12850713729858398,
-0.37795910239219666,
0.10117977112531662,
-0.39489084482192993,
-0.7123236060142517,
-0.03776325657963753,
-0.028302574530243874,
-0.5298747420310974,
-0.2499413639307022,
-1.045629858970642,
0.031148113310337067,
0.02298148348927498,
0.7254317998886108,
-0.3501058518886566,
-0.06145700812339783,
-0.046140868216753006,
-0.5252524614334106,
-0.2468879669904709,
-0.7658566832542419,
-0.2861078381538391,
-0.5036648511886597,
0.4021757245063782,
0.4856937527656555,
0.6992167830467224,
-0.07336683571338654,
0.3610801696777344,
0.32892942428588867,
-0.08492251485586166,
0.2859955132007599,
-0.3024153411388397,
0.28142452239990234,
0.0632750540971756,
-0.4709596037864685,
-0.31797805428504944,
0.038612332195043564,
0.11531378328800201,
0.5826810002326965,
-0.2716195583343506,
-0.035253409296274185,
-0.33900806307792664,
0.7646579146385193,
-1.1617590188980103,
0.10286451131105423,
-0.3412668704986572,
0.6341767907142639,
-0.07457859814167023,
-0.07530952244997025,
-0.47198817133903503,
-0.1215476393699646,
0.33914363384246826,
-0.4381200075149536,
0.043997909873723984,
0.047146834433078766,
0.7032866477966309,
0.4427367150783539,
-0.6635617017745972,
-0.5067728757858276,
-0.7097786068916321,
0.9277983903884888,
-0.5032089352607727,
0.5406712293624878,
0.5248189568519592,
0.3292018175125122,
0.07605648040771484,
-0.45228442549705505,
-0.7900527715682983,
0.24345684051513672,
0.084629587829113,
0.45224133133888245,
-0.4868318438529968,
0.36527884006500244,
0.014965220354497433,
0.3252847194671631,
-0.23446649312973022,
0.2813560366630554,
0.1523495465517044,
0.04506342485547066,
0.820085346698761,
-0.0025524739176034927,
0.11647579073905945,
0.045868877321481705,
-0.36277154088020325,
-0.19082926213741302,
-0.342117577791214,
0.1831786334514618,
0.5997525453567505,
0.09941788017749786,
0.09368333220481873,
0.4085410237312317,
-0.11036897450685501,
0.24828888475894928,
0.3235432803630829,
0.2709386348724365,
0.5493127107620239,
0.5746082067489624,
-0.7580040693283081,
0.18915492296218872,
0.686234176158905,
0.29534706473350525,
0.10323455929756165,
0.10478251427412033,
-0.31470826268196106,
0.13095149397850037,
0.2307450771331787,
-0.5759088397026062,
-0.058713413774967194,
0.5707041025161743,
-0.36808812618255615,
-0.05775397643446922,
-0.10356427729129791,
-1.1910299062728882,
-0.8393866419792175,
-0.25518131256103516,
0.42800426483154297,
-0.14238779246807098,
-0.46579355001449585,
0.2888146936893463,
-0.05964343249797821,
-0.2636029124259949,
0.4242793321609497,
-0.9556832313537598,
0.2714056968688965,
0.3775789141654968,
0.27006033062934875,
-0.08528679609298706,
0.287418395280838,
-0.08479481935501099,
-0.18228277564048767,
-0.3088338375091553,
0.4956037700176239,
-0.741504967212677,
-0.13206547498703003,
0.13354574143886566,
-0.1101364716887474,
-0.051886677742004395,
-0.6319067478179932,
0.8450729250907898,
-0.5669631958007812,
0.22499988973140717,
-0.05964973196387291,
-0.947690486907959,
-0.5236749053001404,
0.12692800164222717,
-0.3854562044143677,
0.8992396593093872,
0.3900463581085205,
-0.7158215045928955,
0.49431636929512024,
-0.5863812565803528,
-0.11774527281522751,
0.03366263583302498,
0.00991953257471323,
-0.5740310549736023,
0.36121314764022827,
0.22674717009067535,
0.6004581451416016,
-0.02044549025595188,
0.24458199739456177,
-0.552828311920166,
-0.34316286444664,
0.40480679273605347,
-0.4421221911907196,
0.3301888406276703,
0.43279188871383667,
-0.4947659373283386,
-0.18427276611328125,
-0.4551498293876648,
0.07245256006717682,
-0.21512937545776367,
0.046267569065093994,
-0.36666202545166016,
-0.03297806158661842,
-0.011539502069354057,
0.11238287389278412,
0.021482769399881363,
-0.46970754861831665,
0.031473781913518906,
-0.1814190298318863,
0.1790921539068222,
0.8610209226608276,
-0.023360280320048332,
0.5725301504135132,
0.22420458495616913,
0.6278011798858643,
0.4966658651828766,
0.35874176025390625,
0.248489111661911,
-0.46500450372695923,
-1.0175503492355347,
-0.17818626761436462,
0.16766472160816193,
0.5763296484947205,
-0.34718868136405945,
0.6682407259941101,
0.17990335822105408,
-0.38721755146980286,
-0.6160010099411011,
-0.3275071382522583,
0.16397537291049957,
0.5197328329086304,
0.4715823829174042,
-0.01592601090669632,
-0.590387761592865,
-0.585741400718689,
-0.20850569009780884,
-0.41955068707466125,
0.1750054955482483,
0.3481374680995941,
0.4194144308567047,
-0.5007734298706055,
0.8148378133773804,
-0.5251541137695312,
-0.040763456374406815,
0.20492370426654816,
0.8090677261352539,
-0.2657676339149475,
0.4623393714427948,
0.3430521488189697,
-1.1873215436935425,
-0.3350389897823334,
0.13731636106967926,
-0.6317911744117737,
0.030771099030971527,
-0.21127881109714508,
0.07914409786462784,
0.2969103753566742,
-0.21273083984851837,
-0.5195648670196533,
0.6959096789360046,
0.2867644727230072,
0.05548641085624695,
0.20905065536499023,
0.050335485488176346,
0.33746978640556335,
-0.4999346435070038,
-0.5320032238960266,
0.18595768511295319,
-0.03182031959295273,
-0.853360116481781,
-0.12950457632541656,
0.2594602704048157,
0.198214590549469,
-0.5938528776168823,
0.3861158490180969,
-0.45547670125961304,
0.16853351891040802,
-0.23393873870372772,
0.03628907725214958,
0.1875596046447754,
0.445178747177124,
0.39139050245285034,
0.3151347041130066,
0.7871250510215759,
-0.41194429993629456,
0.4569971561431885,
0.3005591034889221,
-0.4061518907546997,
0.8087692260742188,
-0.11215366423130035,
0.1864030659198761,
-0.6380252838134766,
0.213505357503891,
-0.9680814146995544,
-0.26840248703956604,
0.7236553430557251,
-0.3396361470222473,
0.5769718885421753,
-0.18806859850883484,
-0.09726259857416153,
-0.4128403961658478,
0.1700485497713089,
0.465960294008255,
0.6735016703605652,
-0.5391323566436768,
0.7294015884399414,
0.2037140130996704,
-0.03672211989760399,
-0.9251126050949097,
-0.8367241024971008,
-0.0030989903025329113,
-0.6696615815162659,
-0.41144490242004395,
-0.049002520740032196,
-0.1639101505279541,
-0.3266616463661194,
-0.12484817206859589,
-0.37012979388237,
-0.6376100778579712,
0.07890630513429642,
0.6234379410743713,
-0.24057836830615997,
0.02377944253385067,
0.6037718057632446,
0.339229017496109,
0.09300488978624344,
0.10816442966461182,
0.03014964982867241,
-0.00960899330675602,
-0.23585206270217896,
-0.5380477905273438,
-0.43509453535079956,
0.7731730341911316,
0.21309491991996765,
-0.005011121276766062,
0.283535897731781,
0.8295925259590149,
-0.6412582993507385,
-0.1775769293308258,
-0.48499688506126404,
0.0040458678267896175,
-0.497033953666687,
0.1956253945827484,
-0.2962127923965454,
-0.7420991659164429,
0.6101601719856262,
-0.3476312458515167,
-0.4080263376235962,
0.26199954748153687,
0.42454588413238525,
-0.4693652093410492,
1.148717999458313,
0.5955963134765625,
0.016021978110074997,
0.42398741841316223,
-0.04883060231804848,
0.5819457173347473,
-0.7869657278060913,
-0.08743146061897278,
-0.2988445460796356,
-0.5543642640113831,
-0.35961535573005676,
-0.249953955411911,
0.2049715369939804,
0.23715978860855103,
-0.13893355429172516,
-0.015234087593853474,
-0.4919571578502655,
0.23240530490875244,
0.2629622519016266,
0.34856778383255005,
-0.14314009249210358,
-0.07219277322292328,
0.3761977255344391,
-0.24519279599189758,
-0.22367548942565918,
-0.22585169970989227,
0.6412431001663208,
0.4295613765716553,
0.7280395030975342,
0.24169215559959412,
0.9153369665145874,
0.46584582328796387,
0.674394965171814,
-0.9523373246192932,
0.027624910697340965,
0.0579216331243515,
-0.6303309202194214,
-0.23865346610546112,
-0.41007354855537415,
-0.8918824195861816,
0.38148584961891174,
-0.1777801662683487,
-0.958594560623169,
0.9492702484130859,
0.015211757272481918,
-0.46475687623023987,
0.28733181953430176,
-1.0437564849853516,
0.8540313243865967,
-0.16218014061450958,
0.14874061942100525,
0.0996086597442627,
-0.8436294794082642,
0.3820972442626953,
-0.17502763867378235,
0.14432641863822937,
-0.4240212142467499,
-0.00906435027718544,
0.46016737818717957,
-0.4297926723957062,
0.9871766567230225,
-0.35023173689842224,
-0.06804974377155304,
0.525715708732605,
0.02701076678931713,
0.5727065801620483,
-0.04404696077108383,
-0.4487400949001312,
0.19568930566310883,
-0.32666799426078796,
-0.28614771366119385,
-0.9693583846092224,
-0.00860508345067501,
-0.8955362439155579,
-0.5121219158172607,
-0.48205631971359253,
-0.5827342867851257,
-0.3506127893924713,
-0.15911395847797394,
0.5481658577919006,
0.08786381781101227,
0.06744521856307983,
-0.21240122616291046,
0.8485473394393921,
-0.08841723203659058,
0.4830029606819153,
0.25774434208869934,
0.5596770644187927,
-0.2344519942998886,
0.658467173576355,
-0.03318912908434868,
0.23053234815597534,
0.41476985812187195,
0.3221806287765503,
-0.5629615783691406,
-0.4996262490749359,
-0.4250129759311676,
-0.42843231558799744,
-1.0224982500076294,
-0.30244526267051697,
-0.7735354900360107,
0.23722855746746063,
-0.4542773962020874,
-0.26157984137535095,
-0.11242511868476868,
-0.06658631563186646,
-0.551923930644989,
-0.40658172965049744,
0.49652034044265747,
0.5587928891181946,
-0.24214577674865723,
0.5761663317680359,
-0.5994674563407898,
0.19900169968605042,
0.21370604634284973,
0.2244100421667099,
-0.16242095828056335,
-0.681835949420929,
0.10257010906934738,
0.26159390807151794,
-0.09029146283864975,
-1.1769458055496216,
0.6766682267189026,
0.4267352223396301,
0.346788227558136,
0.6607743501663208,
0.7173460721969604,
0.8550692200660706,
-0.08789042383432388,
0.6996042132377625,
0.359366238117218,
-1.2270394563674927,
0.402200847864151,
0.09474547207355499,
-0.2844216823577881,
0.4559241533279419,
0.7000880241394043,
-0.6563905477523804,
-0.3350546061992645,
-0.5974687933921814,
-1.023961067199707,
0.5395694971084595,
0.18371433019638062,
0.1385248452425003,
-0.0615348219871521,
0.2962932586669922,
0.18737812340259552,
0.4690363109111786,
-0.42631807923316956,
-0.5614404082298279,
-0.25964388251304626,
-0.4743659496307373,
0.02688751555979252,
-0.1524408608675003,
-0.2764138877391815,
-0.11467187106609344,
0.32281455397605896,
-0.06174865737557411,
0.30384591221809387,
0.30731087923049927,
-0.20384319126605988,
-0.345932275056839,
0.3813265562057495,
0.5967134237289429,
0.24414531886577606,
-0.4600561559200287,
0.3735353946685791,
0.1625126302242279,
-0.27452754974365234,
0.5498027205467224,
0.16720378398895264,
0.2776627838611603,
0.022123200818896294,
0.061807114630937576,
0.9644185900688171,
-0.14925827085971832,
-0.7352604866027832,
0.7707897424697876,
-0.07172293215990067,
-0.05726523697376251,
-0.2716670334339142,
-0.32107821106910706,
-0.18823981285095215,
0.3674875795841217,
0.21679724752902985,
0.5295694470405579,
0.5885037183761597,
-0.36657580733299255,
0.29237064719200134,
0.02412855625152588,
-0.8296763300895691,
-0.02934923768043518,
0.32445430755615234,
0.21222320199012756,
0.08675611764192581,
0.5797541737556458,
-0.44005170464515686,
-0.740626335144043,
0.7237688899040222,
0.17401659488677979,
1.0863384008407593,
-0.3126145601272583,
0.35075047612190247,
-0.25445955991744995,
0.1406981199979782,
-0.016411608085036278,
0.45496976375579834,
-0.10231917351484299,
-0.9707235097885132,
-0.19992682337760925,
-0.07023022323846817,
-0.7508784532546997,
-0.4323115050792694,
-0.9816445708274841,
-0.23700833320617676,
-0.17877580225467682,
-0.38034966588020325,
0.009009263478219509,
-0.03277737647294998,
-0.8478654026985168,
0.6911824941635132,
0.6422248482704163,
0.6580822467803955,
-1.1282933950424194,
0.4901791512966156,
0.6386019587516785,
-0.2186541110277176,
-0.6153419613838196,
-0.23060303926467896,
0.156119704246521,
-0.6508134007453918,
0.6949762105941772,
0.18142905831336975,
0.030138125643134117,
-0.45249760150909424,
-0.5151590704917908,
-0.41770386695861816,
0.5844076871871948,
0.15449880063533783,
-0.4435829520225525,
0.7992698550224304,
0.22439587116241455,
0.6409323215484619,
-0.3016105890274048,
0.6301851272583008,
0.43835023045539856,
0.755706787109375,
0.17551524937152863,
-0.29043900966644287,
-0.11613786965608597,
-0.1474359631538391,
-0.4011777937412262,
0.4470052421092987,
-0.6601428985595703,
0.8029220104217529,
-0.1759343445301056,
-0.3933694362640381,
-0.061116039752960205,
0.8476361036300659,
-0.007929193787276745,
0.6720767617225647,
0.7286773920059204,
0.5470861196517944,
1.3717023134231567,
-0.3685261309146881,
0.7572312951087952,
0.28528380393981934,
0.5266964435577393,
1.0805951356887817,
-0.5587104558944702,
0.7642768025398254,
0.3249029517173767,
-0.20163774490356445,
0.349961519241333,
1.4268356561660767,
0.036539699882268906,
0.31281980872154236,
0.38145220279693604,
-0.8507699966430664,
-0.4379517734050751,
-0.21340544521808624,
-0.42023664712905884,
0.1766733080148697,
0.7086927890777588,
-0.0138831352815032,
-0.13346056640148163,
0.14014792442321777,
-0.1413203626871109,
-0.23751556873321533,
-0.23488371074199677,
0.43716898560523987,
0.14682820439338684,
-0.3135901689529419,
0.37562641501426697,
-0.17379195988178253,
0.6436164975166321,
-0.19276981055736542,
0.10279964655637741,
-0.4183623790740967,
-0.024737698957324028,
-0.36791348457336426,
-0.9759950041770935,
0.013688228093087673,
-0.14558373391628265,
-0.1462283432483673,
-0.275089830160141,
0.6263643503189087,
-0.6596230864524841,
-0.2473946064710617,
0.16678939759731293,
0.2139347493648529,
0.4524462819099426,
-0.41667652130126953,
-0.6810901761054993,
0.13568755984306335,
-0.2671149671077728,
-0.45081356167793274,
0.12304061651229858,
0.9714834094047546,
0.043496422469615936,
0.6147666573524475,
0.08397644758224487,
-0.35680797696113586,
0.21636997163295746,
0.1582683026790619,
0.5553175210952759,
-0.44033733010292053,
-0.18915358185768127,
-0.6499419212341309,
0.56196129322052,
0.12781284749507904,
-0.6144153475761414,
0.18779857456684113,
-0.0866238996386528,
0.6087641716003418,
-0.143439382314682,
0.8158825635910034,
-0.15212887525558472,
-0.03707490488886833,
-0.02063421905040741,
0.147968590259552,
-0.6723381876945496,
-0.34057310223579407,
-0.35912683606147766,
-0.5287578701972961,
-0.44726723432540894,
0.6465937495231628,
-0.18072840571403503,
0.08515613526105881,
0.42346620559692383,
0.182390496134758,
0.11891824752092361,
0.5000714659690857,
0.3268283009529114,
0.058655086904764175,
0.1893007606267929,
0.8998911380767822,
1.0569803714752197,
-0.6151630878448486,
0.1759524941444397,
-0.6082512736320496,
-0.2018095701932907,
-0.2865186035633087,
-1.018776535987854,
-0.5186676383018494,
-0.291553795337677,
-0.6774533987045288,
-0.14476880431175232,
-0.06333900988101959,
0.9170383214950562,
1.0876052379608154,
-0.9149368405342102,
0.20071884989738464,
0.17509940266609192,
0.39802849292755127,
-0.5115001201629639,
-0.27257272601127625,
0.29159343242645264,
-0.2262481153011322,
-1.1317414045333862,
0.22232213616371155,
0.18401940166950226,
0.34176430106163025,
0.1592857837677002,
-0.13739843666553497,
0.20617982745170593,
0.044533200562000275,
0.5524173974990845,
0.30828896164894104,
-0.6779394745826721,
-0.5819743275642395,
-0.2363889068365097,
0.010041902773082256,
0.2291148155927658,
0.5292432308197021,
-0.3387755751609802,
0.6987589597702026,
0.4366704821586609,
0.7507975697517395,
0.33967047929763794,
0.1785212904214859,
0.3945564329624176,
-0.992186427116394,
0.27247142791748047,
0.4181230366230011,
0.39313939213752747,
0.1494891196489334,
-0.8578007817268372,
0.546986997127533,
0.09317027777433395,
-0.6412907242774963,
-0.6993608474731445,
0.5371894836425781,
-1.162885069847107,
-0.13114412128925323,
0.7192066311836243,
-0.5852673649787903,
-0.019792713224887848,
-0.11346030235290527,
0.038640182465314865,
0.3502941131591797,
-0.5646335482597351,
0.8752807378768921,
0.7926160097122192,
-0.5513333678245544,
-0.3983090817928314,
-0.31154122948646545,
0.37655285000801086,
0.5413134694099426,
-0.7274307608604431,
0.16468451917171478,
0.3835877478122711,
-0.16915275156497955,
0.13701781630516052,
0.19527821242809296,
0.2719516456127167,
-0.037283726036548615,
-0.12258698046207428,
0.4150376617908478,
0.4009474813938141,
-0.20625807344913483,
-0.4705655872821808,
0.08472754806280136,
-0.4071444272994995,
-0.32752761244773865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12851v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12851v1 | MoELoRA: Contrastive Learning Guided Mixture of Experts on Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for Large Language Models | 2024-02-20T09:30:48 | 2024-02-20T09:30:48 | Tongxu Luo, Jiahe Lei, Fangyu Lei, Weihao Liu, Shizhu He, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fine-tuning is often necessary to enhance the adaptability of Large Language
Models (LLM) to downstream tasks. Nonetheless, the process of updating billions
of parameters demands significant computational resources and training time,
which poses a substantial obstacle to the widespread application of large-scale
models in various scenarios. To address this issue, Parameter-Efficient
Fine-Tuning (PEFT) has emerged as a prominent paradigm in recent research.
However, current PEFT approaches that employ a limited set of global parameters
(such as LoRA, which adds low-rank approximation matrices to all weights) face
challenges in flexibly combining different computational modules in downstream
tasks. In this work, we introduce a novel PEFT method: MoELoRA. We consider
LoRA as Mixture of Experts (MoE), and to mitigate the random routing phenomenon
observed in MoE, we propose the utilization of contrastive learning to
encourage experts to learn distinct features. We conducted experiments on 11
tasks in math reasoning and common-sense reasoning benchmarks. With the same
number of parameters, our approach outperforms LoRA significantly. In math
reasoning, MoELoRA achieved an average performance that was 4.2% higher than
LoRA, and demonstrated competitive performance compared to the 175B GPT-3.5 on
several benchmarks. | [
-0.6365270018577576,
-0.9062368869781494,
0.40155062079429626,
0.16571608185768127,
-0.5215429067611694,
-0.01454966701567173,
-0.5362056493759155,
-0.31807228922843933,
-0.007541540544480085,
0.49406132102012634,
-0.45166435837745667,
-0.4591069221496582,
-0.4904399812221527,
-0.19852958619594574,
-0.1583307683467865,
0.8961194753646851,
0.15482863783836365,
0.04114344343543053,
0.25784993171691895,
-0.3186561167240143,
-0.45422637462615967,
-0.23974432051181793,
-0.9290756583213806,
-0.522359311580658,
0.8230332732200623,
0.43513023853302,
0.625558078289032,
0.47161197662353516,
0.2840973436832428,
0.3373696208000183,
-0.12935616075992584,
0.6042450666427612,
-0.672846794128418,
0.2529229521751404,
-0.626204252243042,
-0.49729445576667786,
-0.41050106287002563,
-0.20246551930904388,
0.5138257741928101,
0.8842092156410217,
-0.2809675633907318,
-0.08045104146003723,
0.3335312604904175,
0.7703332901000977,
-0.8567835092544556,
0.0783890038728714,
-1.0532243251800537,
-0.08964361995458603,
-0.301370769739151,
-0.28508201241493225,
-0.253972589969635,
-0.13896465301513672,
0.13133025169372559,
-0.7129408717155457,
0.22566470503807068,
-0.07380596548318863,
0.7429171800613403,
0.4499565660953522,
-0.2846667468547821,
-0.0095383170992136,
-0.5717809796333313,
1.0854781866073608,
-0.7129849791526794,
0.20648311078548431,
0.26945123076438904,
0.36905860900878906,
-0.13473516702651978,
-0.2820413410663605,
-0.3370194733142853,
0.12497880309820175,
0.18593284487724304,
0.08171255886554718,
-0.09846622496843338,
-0.0812380313873291,
-0.1649249643087387,
0.28200870752334595,
-0.3965686559677124,
0.36852940917015076,
-0.28003692626953125,
0.03625251725316048,
0.6509996652603149,
0.07795645296573639,
-0.09487932175397873,
0.46271446347236633,
-0.11899914592504501,
-0.07640714198350906,
-0.7050759792327881,
-0.26069605350494385,
0.48241037130355835,
0.5296425819396973,
-0.08814539015293121,
0.08211684972047806,
-0.42192840576171875,
0.754339337348938,
0.3111816942691803,
0.046314455568790436,
0.15069714188575745,
0.08346116542816162,
-0.2690749764442444,
-0.052003808319568634,
0.5821653604507446,
0.10899438709020615,
0.4250609278678894,
-0.05859699472784996,
-0.20277541875839233,
-0.19134756922721863,
-0.005686166230589151,
-0.7015767693519592,
-0.767501950263977,
-0.010523373261094093,
-0.23840202391147614,
-0.24761755764484406,
-0.04971965029835701,
-0.8830018043518066,
-0.4129911959171295,
-0.48465386033058167,
0.4232752025127411,
-0.5600141882896423,
-0.25262802839279175,
0.03035997971892357,
0.23177464306354523,
0.14018966257572174,
0.7942557334899902,
-0.9480106234550476,
0.2721337378025055,
0.7746869921684265,
0.4894406497478485,
-0.24752402305603027,
-0.3141348958015442,
-0.8436729907989502,
0.1075821965932846,
-0.23496697843074799,
0.9163904190063477,
-0.7171525359153748,
-0.3802817463874817,
-0.2993180751800537,
-0.5595105290412903,
-0.31915637850761414,
-0.8989975452423096,
0.43065345287323,
-0.6453645825386047,
0.1667192280292511,
-0.18851764500141144,
-0.31355568766593933,
-0.5403621196746826,
0.20420695841312408,
-0.4661324620246887,
0.972001850605011,
0.1912718564271927,
-0.6152958273887634,
0.21951444447040558,
-0.4171786308288574,
-0.3085925281047821,
-0.06513802707195282,
-0.3238431513309479,
-0.3671385943889618,
0.19728340208530426,
0.4546326696872711,
0.5085632801055908,
-0.2758544087409973,
0.24991978704929352,
-0.39321911334991455,
-0.527798056602478,
0.11237892508506775,
-0.7022410035133362,
0.5540839433670044,
0.4360042214393616,
-0.3539622128009796,
0.1489337533712387,
-0.8890833854675293,
0.00947495549917221,
0.033746153116226196,
-0.5867002010345459,
-0.4636666774749756,
-0.0023523473646491766,
0.047835174947977066,
0.059448014944791794,
0.2617237865924835,
-0.07397328317165375,
0.12298908829689026,
-0.43750396370887756,
0.21398082375526428,
1.0718765258789062,
-0.04748382046818733,
0.3081802725791931,
-0.2450280785560608,
0.2266647219657898,
0.2587263584136963,
-0.0335683636367321,
0.04718775302171707,
-0.652120053768158,
-0.987166702747345,
-0.42842939496040344,
0.5106148719787598,
0.5025306940078735,
-0.7563979625701904,
0.5068883299827576,
-0.07660218328237534,
-0.5676491260528564,
-0.44186195731163025,
0.7416988015174866,
0.5128655433654785,
0.5876682996749878,
0.5433547496795654,
-0.08743112534284592,
-0.18701039254665375,
-0.9525896310806274,
-0.4421585500240326,
0.125655859708786,
-0.1599060446023941,
0.3108837604522705,
0.1628970354795456,
-0.13663551211357117,
0.8203878402709961,
-0.7615331411361694,
-0.2377091497182846,
-0.06496227532625198,
0.24415625631809235,
0.44379693269729614,
0.6694577932357788,
0.5935266017913818,
-0.8135491609573364,
-0.8253688812255859,
0.3793655335903168,
-0.28264686465263367,
-0.32033056020736694,
0.08709917217493057,
-0.24031735956668854,
-0.014481841586530209,
0.42282238602638245,
-0.17226533591747284,
-0.09695391356945038,
0.6612768769264221,
-0.2832866907119751,
0.22220729291439056,
-0.37959933280944824,
-0.07162460684776306,
-0.9641506671905518,
-0.045522406697273254,
0.13649818301200867,
-0.2250877320766449,
-0.37811511754989624,
0.2853388786315918,
-0.042542919516563416,
0.13295352458953857,
-0.38451892137527466,
0.6084744334220886,
-0.22400686144828796,
0.4103362262248993,
-0.30073705315589905,
0.06894516944885254,
-0.20421366393566132,
0.8294844031333923,
-0.12702776491641998,
0.7562132477760315,
0.7084859609603882,
-0.6831820607185364,
0.15699344873428345,
-0.22871120274066925,
-0.07434875518083572,
0.8340691328048706,
-0.482408344745636,
0.17227840423583984,
0.1466260403394699,
-0.11886540055274963,
-0.8102850317955017,
-0.194125697016716,
0.3339894711971283,
-0.07650841027498245,
0.23206877708435059,
-0.015262342058122158,
-0.5090809464454651,
0.2764872610569,
-0.1992276906967163,
0.5342521071434021,
0.7215254306793213,
-0.6579489707946777,
0.9134442806243896,
0.06585193425416946,
-0.39911937713623047,
-0.27280741930007935,
-0.45849642157554626,
-0.25829756259918213,
-0.42037054896354675,
-0.38833311200141907,
0.4091585576534271,
-0.13025696575641632,
-0.34289830923080444,
-0.17597070336341858,
-0.02105114422738552,
-0.30072805285453796,
0.35655155777931213,
-0.039985381066799164,
-0.11258438229560852,
-0.316080778837204,
0.04577747359871864,
0.5074788331985474,
-0.2240295112133026,
-0.2634516656398773,
-0.05766505375504494,
0.6531078219413757,
-0.16700218617916107,
-0.4831356108188629,
-0.31661736965179443,
0.42385947704315186,
0.2884420156478882,
-0.2933075428009033,
0.6994808316230774,
0.8303055167198181,
-0.11232829838991165,
-0.530532717704773,
-0.7337678670883179,
-0.12470245361328125,
-0.5478081703186035,
0.40342003107070923,
-0.36585426330566406,
-0.7200189828872681,
0.6913084387779236,
-0.2757110893726349,
-0.022076649591326714,
0.5017249584197998,
0.5038716793060303,
0.036607690155506134,
0.9345253109931946,
0.4978905916213989,
-0.18923373520374298,
0.6984876990318298,
-0.06834077090024948,
-0.005262020509690046,
-0.5726311206817627,
-0.06542264670133591,
-0.5176036953926086,
-0.4994317293167114,
-0.5094877481460571,
-0.6182669401168823,
0.5040915012359619,
0.39021214842796326,
-0.38594669103622437,
-0.10262525081634521,
-0.304555207490921,
0.6759831309318542,
0.8087233901023865,
0.4854716956615448,
0.45259255170822144,
0.16203832626342773,
-0.27794691920280457,
0.20173515379428864,
-0.7987191677093506,
-0.1314934343099594,
1.054228663444519,
0.0664525181055069,
0.778482973575592,
0.0932600200176239,
0.782444953918457,
0.03126297518610954,
0.24257971346378326,
-0.48281633853912354,
0.6845901012420654,
-0.45134010910987854,
-0.2190527617931366,
-0.17466598749160767,
-0.5060607194900513,
-0.8009474873542786,
0.5562663674354553,
-0.2003547102212906,
-0.5788507461547852,
0.3178558945655823,
0.46568968892097473,
-0.4182000458240509,
0.3664582073688507,
-0.77830970287323,
0.37735605239868164,
-0.07329817116260529,
-0.5330988764762878,
-0.5577473640441895,
-0.5094773769378662,
0.16112832725048065,
-0.40263763070106506,
0.05727982893586159,
-0.09011461585760117,
-0.12440181523561478,
0.5694451928138733,
-0.3367094099521637,
0.9727151393890381,
-0.14364808797836304,
-0.38151317834854126,
-0.0013408031081780791,
0.07576759159564972,
0.4687401056289673,
-0.01201364304870367,
-0.27464836835861206,
0.2037743777036667,
-0.38227319717407227,
-0.6987453699111938,
-0.6580038070678711,
0.9927462935447693,
-0.7929501533508301,
-0.5322770476341248,
-0.10180598497390747,
-0.6160200834274292,
-0.5579087138175964,
0.2842682898044586,
0.20295467972755432,
0.2515600323677063,
0.10875356942415237,
0.3566901683807373,
1.037642240524292,
-0.06685703992843628,
0.29821884632110596,
0.4631800055503845,
-0.01004741620272398,
-0.47510388493537903,
1.111976981163025,
0.11031896620988846,
0.08371546119451523,
0.592457115650177,
0.3957306146621704,
0.1563270390033722,
-0.8767691254615784,
-0.11959569156169891,
0.2476649433374405,
-0.652435302734375,
-0.10562293976545334,
-0.34148579835891724,
-0.04918528348207474,
0.0052504148334264755,
-0.3395690321922302,
-0.5991364121437073,
-0.22714708745479584,
-0.4956073462963104,
0.32390862703323364,
0.27944421768188477,
0.38795238733291626,
0.11176156252622604,
0.45874446630477905,
-0.7056425213813782,
0.24972330033779144,
0.6541095972061157,
0.42487457394599915,
0.26429271697998047,
-0.39127063751220703,
-0.32210808992385864,
-0.06572461128234863,
-0.5140852332115173,
-0.5412511229515076,
0.2543063163757324,
0.35782089829444885,
0.7741158604621887,
0.8810738921165466,
0.06177109107375145,
0.7455388903617859,
-0.426513135433197,
0.5606275796890259,
0.04963431879878044,
-0.9130927920341492,
0.45626959204673767,
-0.6125848889350891,
0.29866307973861694,
0.644022524356842,
0.13811638951301575,
0.07725290209054947,
-0.32758453488349915,
-0.4504040479660034,
-0.9325292706489563,
0.3424074351787567,
0.26458173990249634,
0.13098041713237762,
0.24387654662132263,
0.1545259654521942,
0.4198552072048187,
0.19842171669006348,
-0.33419349789619446,
-0.17251171171665192,
0.13432973623275757,
-0.3703407943248749,
-0.2616227865219116,
-0.14243286848068237,
-0.2676272988319397,
-0.39026278257369995,
0.663084089756012,
-0.28856340050697327,
-0.1072220727801323,
-0.15179921686649323,
-0.013012760318815708,
0.08556506782770157,
0.34353014826774597,
0.6184393763542175,
0.7727138996124268,
-0.23928113281726837,
0.19858314096927643,
0.33762404322624207,
-0.27106618881225586,
-0.280547171831131,
0.297986775636673,
0.0012893062084913254,
-0.08989090472459793,
0.3084469735622406,
0.5089492201805115,
0.54563307762146,
-0.6965752243995667,
0.06568142026662827,
0.33596280217170715,
-0.2796075940132141,
0.06356555968523026,
0.6137569546699524,
0.0796801820397377,
0.5076624751091003,
0.5400600433349609,
0.26362550258636475,
-0.0036334958858788013,
-0.28413841128349304,
-0.11807642132043839,
0.2983093857765198,
-0.13945335149765015,
-0.23719967901706696,
0.4440467953681946,
0.5054657459259033,
-0.14577163755893707,
0.49179607629776,
0.0009337596711702645,
-0.3687606155872345,
0.4229467213153839,
0.20813466608524323,
0.7444904446601868,
-0.4061200022697449,
-0.19125477969646454,
-0.027681246399879456,
-0.10071874409914017,
-0.042954664677381516,
0.32942336797714233,
-0.20693622529506683,
-0.736039400100708,
-0.17624180018901825,
-0.48095381259918213,
-0.5136159658432007,
0.005083809606730938,
-0.60770183801651,
0.10863913595676422,
-0.4875645637512207,
0.06056996434926987,
-0.18257346749305725,
-0.0017883845139294863,
-0.6169189214706421,
0.12959595024585724,
0.028712179511785507,
0.8529532551765442,
-0.8006141185760498,
0.981168270111084,
0.6262423992156982,
-0.11326196044683456,
-0.7987627387046814,
0.13312529027462006,
-0.24593403935432434,
-0.712704598903656,
0.624583899974823,
-0.10008995234966278,
-0.22369766235351562,
-0.02615419588983059,
-0.452674925327301,
-0.521003246307373,
0.9921497702598572,
0.6956257820129395,
-0.7165843844413757,
0.021146519109606743,
-0.12071653455495834,
0.5510709285736084,
-0.22688524425029755,
0.017975913360714912,
0.4049507677555084,
0.3769778311252594,
0.07005956023931503,
-0.9152389168739319,
-0.12641069293022156,
-0.29084017872810364,
-0.03163691982626915,
0.07415767759084702,
-0.8625885248184204,
1.224326252937317,
0.13091614842414856,
0.2631807327270508,
0.08085799217224121,
0.6422677636146545,
0.6040472984313965,
0.3092905282974243,
0.6052306294441223,
0.5064495801925659,
0.9436222910881042,
0.06343452632427216,
0.7544692158699036,
-0.2826625406742096,
0.41061505675315857,
1.299820065498352,
-0.22056183218955994,
1.1119650602340698,
0.6812588572502136,
-0.24965785443782806,
0.5525729060173035,
0.5810755491256714,
0.06390129774808884,
0.6836701035499573,
0.08299455046653748,
-0.32755371928215027,
-0.6595325469970703,
0.18316282331943512,
-0.5167455673217773,
0.32656189799308777,
0.3601146936416626,
-0.4584940969944,
-0.5661280155181885,
-0.04142413288354874,
0.041043031960725784,
0.32065579295158386,
-0.6660981774330139,
0.5632716417312622,
0.1512380987405777,
-0.6318703889846802,
0.6088560223579407,
0.047681767493486404,
0.8947576880455017,
-0.6110467314720154,
-0.22662074863910675,
-0.459333598613739,
0.5510123372077942,
-0.0690896138548851,
-0.46450328826904297,
-0.11391247808933258,
-0.16994524002075195,
-0.16894935071468353,
-0.018665647134184837,
0.41405606269836426,
-0.523689329624176,
-0.5461833477020264,
0.1866483837366104,
0.46467825770378113,
-0.12046398967504501,
-0.4357096254825592,
-0.751640260219574,
-0.10529842972755432,
-0.14417743682861328,
-0.21980375051498413,
0.5699911117553711,
0.49814993143081665,
0.005388725083321333,
0.8874110579490662,
0.567638099193573,
0.11802184581756592,
0.002539909677579999,
0.017920225858688354,
1.2616424560546875,
-0.3609931170940399,
-0.7987736463546753,
-0.7901800274848938,
0.26419734954833984,
-0.02075151912868023,
-0.3374784290790558,
0.7066535353660583,
0.4169093668460846,
0.9750098586082458,
-0.19513116776943207,
0.548512876033783,
0.48355403542518616,
0.5008811354637146,
-0.9358236789703369,
0.6427375674247742,
-0.6141322255134583,
0.43747806549072266,
-0.27910366654396057,
-0.977840781211853,
-0.3071328401565552,
0.563567578792572,
-0.46858134865760803,
0.3135148882865906,
0.5416838526725769,
0.6968671679496765,
-0.5428683757781982,
-0.14951913058757782,
0.34317269921302795,
0.19709010422229767,
0.3290320038795471,
0.8080816268920898,
0.4676348865032196,
-0.07261865586042404,
0.4395025670528412,
-0.3139652609825134,
-0.0833396390080452,
-0.5441809892654419,
-0.8826596140861511,
-1.0314298868179321,
-0.2642990052700043,
-0.4863152801990509,
0.05142708122730255,
0.13774162530899048,
1.0389848947525024,
0.9247090220451355,
-1.1020632982254028,
-0.055453889071941376,
-0.15436246991157532,
0.1861172765493393,
-0.47308221459388733,
-0.1939842849969864,
0.5385270714759827,
-0.30983492732048035,
-0.9818440675735474,
0.339251309633255,
0.18668772280216217,
-0.2404344528913498,
-0.26219967007637024,
-0.16187989711761475,
-0.12038759142160416,
0.18791092932224274,
0.3703314960002899,
0.183589369058609,
-0.7074214220046997,
-0.020640980452299118,
-0.552802324295044,
0.13402706384658813,
0.07743076235055923,
0.6494206190109253,
-0.7927719950675964,
0.2979031205177307,
0.5578711032867432,
0.6930032968521118,
0.2029515653848648,
0.10231626778841019,
0.6950664520263672,
-0.6007302403450012,
0.19163283705711365,
0.16316069662570953,
0.43495017290115356,
0.15633413195610046,
-0.33310574293136597,
0.441000759601593,
0.23573453724384308,
-0.34111183881759644,
-0.6527347564697266,
0.14751844108104706,
-1.2413756847381592,
-0.5355907678604126,
0.9983446598052979,
-0.2161083072423935,
-0.023934531956911087,
-0.06952676922082901,
-0.4705051779747009,
-0.012346699833869934,
-0.6492837071418762,
0.8729668259620667,
0.4683709442615509,
-0.1383727490901947,
-0.25227540731430054,
-0.24642719328403473,
0.18074142932891846,
0.6627316474914551,
-0.7148536443710327,
-0.2305183708667755,
0.20767803490161896,
0.4648406207561493,
-0.0006061616004444659,
0.32753512263298035,
0.1799468994140625,
0.19397656619548798,
-0.11391991376876831,
-0.47604262828826904,
-0.3431357741355896,
-0.3169441521167755,
-0.3724597990512848,
0.5215927362442017,
0.19850800931453705,
-0.050075713545084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12847v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12847v2 | Instruction-tuned Language Models are Better Knowledge Learners | 2024-02-20T09:20:32 | 2024-05-26T03:19:48 | Zhengbao Jiang, Zhiqing Sun, Weijia Shi, Pedro Rodriguez, Chunting Zhou, Graham Neubig, Xi Victoria Lin, Wen-tau Yih, Srinivasan Iyer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In order for large language model (LLM)-based assistants to effectively adapt
to evolving information needs, it must be possible to update their factual
knowledge through continued training on new data. The standard recipe for doing
so involves continued pre-training on new documents followed by
instruction-tuning on question-answer (QA) pairs. However, we find that LLMs
trained with this recipe struggle to answer questions, even though the
perplexity of documents is minimized. We found that QA pairs are generally
straightforward, while documents are more complex, weaving many factual
statements together in an intricate manner. Therefore, we hypothesize that it
is beneficial to expose LLMs to QA pairs before continued pre-training on
documents so that the process of encoding knowledge from complex documents
takes into account how this knowledge is accessed through questions. Based on
this, we propose pre-instruction-tuning (PIT), a method that instruction-tunes
on questions prior to training on documents. This contrasts with standard
instruction-tuning, which learns how to extract knowledge after training on
documents. Extensive experiments and ablation studies demonstrate that
pre-instruction-tuning significantly enhances the ability of LLMs to absorb
knowledge from new documents, outperforming standard instruction-tuning by
17.8%. | [
-0.3680342733860016,
-0.8339540362358093,
0.7616888284683228,
-0.333866149187088,
-0.2749182879924774,
0.12703683972358704,
-0.37582817673683167,
-0.21749629080295563,
0.021381724625825882,
0.5579876899719238,
-0.520342230796814,
-0.38976696133613586,
-0.6860204339027405,
0.0302912425249815,
-0.3377626836299896,
0.9133332967758179,
0.14666491746902466,
0.04537646472454071,
-0.411952406167984,
0.26745086908340454,
-0.4476338326931,
-0.3568292558193207,
-0.6845609545707703,
-0.22544045746326447,
0.4552561342716217,
0.4766473174095154,
0.5488227009773254,
0.8827782869338989,
0.3907525837421417,
0.3920087516307831,
0.04370133578777313,
0.4002264738082886,
-0.442704975605011,
0.09243221580982208,
-0.04711875692009926,
-1.0397427082061768,
-0.46846985816955566,
0.23012013733386993,
0.525545597076416,
0.6792532205581665,
-0.20430997014045715,
0.04968101903796196,
-0.09724549949169159,
0.6554507613182068,
-0.6936125159263611,
0.013442080467939377,
-0.8799992203712463,
-0.2809560000896454,
-0.028860749676823616,
-0.7412740588188171,
-0.4125652611255646,
-0.4451248049736023,
0.09681367874145508,
-0.8991732001304626,
0.33555033802986145,
0.16546262800693512,
0.998563289642334,
0.4769253134727478,
-0.2918170988559723,
-0.5424097180366516,
-0.5622923970222473,
0.5525001883506775,
-0.684945285320282,
0.6132112145423889,
0.6672574877738953,
0.09854873269796371,
-0.2154747098684311,
-0.4858902096748352,
-0.6659499406814575,
-0.13298198580741882,
-0.13809233903884888,
0.1581699401140213,
0.16813234984874725,
0.14733873307704926,
0.4404118061065674,
0.4136061668395996,
-0.3167879581451416,
0.09661680459976196,
-0.3789326846599579,
0.029926413670182228,
0.4492827355861664,
-0.09266600012779236,
0.34217962622642517,
0.24539272487163544,
-0.011197490617632866,
-0.2854726016521454,
-0.8686714768409729,
0.04087325930595398,
0.33737969398498535,
0.037507642060518265,
-0.02255581133067608,
0.2647054195404053,
-0.16688957810401917,
0.9568639397621155,
0.43628400564193726,
-0.2937184274196625,
0.21532171964645386,
-0.037608254700899124,
-0.31289878487586975,
0.03805601969361305,
0.36605721712112427,
0.032357893884181976,
0.3966389000415802,
-0.37455156445503235,
-0.14042417705059052,
-0.21606765687465668,
0.451953649520874,
-0.6251206398010254,
-0.26609307527542114,
-0.12059184908866882,
-0.006607292219996452,
-0.025035088881850243,
0.09345459192991257,
-0.46381130814552307,
-0.31593918800354004,
-0.7492901086807251,
0.6627563834190369,
-0.4460758864879608,
-0.025249449536204338,
0.251548707485199,
-0.06836587190628052,
0.6777240037918091,
0.48621606826782227,
-1.158352017402649,
0.16989320516586304,
0.8270540833473206,
0.4266805648803711,
0.09715641289949417,
-0.2836427688598633,
-0.819635272026062,
0.19954264163970947,
-0.5885183811187744,
0.9349589347839355,
-0.6772909760475159,
-0.3914239704608917,
-0.013215629383921623,
0.11416774988174438,
-0.3500603139400482,
-0.6094646453857422,
0.30723243951797485,
-0.9453248381614685,
0.3974415957927704,
-0.5454800128936768,
-0.7713450193405151,
0.03636184707283974,
0.3113676905632019,
-0.4473145306110382,
0.6765732169151306,
0.21109166741371155,
-0.5338994264602661,
0.34014567732810974,
-0.4731467664241791,
-0.5180797576904297,
-0.14681804180145264,
-0.18499793112277985,
-0.23094859719276428,
0.19650638103485107,
0.378761351108551,
0.3697715103626251,
-0.2868722379207611,
0.04111574590206146,
-0.04589793458580971,
-0.4659559428691864,
0.16635026037693024,
-0.28696680068969727,
0.4068559408187866,
0.019338509067893028,
-0.16761665046215057,
0.013328080996870995,
-0.6481218934059143,
0.05545896664261818,
-0.11812646687030792,
-0.7796668410301208,
-0.4406624138355255,
-0.06499002128839493,
-0.7978540658950806,
-0.049861203879117966,
0.3250851333141327,
-0.3317881226539612,
0.2119196355342865,
-0.6350165009498596,
0.045039523392915726,
0.9756584763526917,
-0.15116475522518158,
0.5118050575256348,
-0.546364426612854,
0.7003018260002136,
-0.10792909562587738,
0.032096996903419495,
-0.3878767490386963,
-0.10044696182012558,
-1.2512586116790771,
0.22258980572223663,
0.2366253286600113,
0.5287673473358154,
-0.7818454504013062,
0.4628196358680725,
-0.18758262693881989,
-0.29656755924224854,
-0.9177544713020325,
0.46553024649620056,
0.6500075459480286,
0.8790605664253235,
0.47552043199539185,
-0.14471152424812317,
-0.3240860402584076,
-0.6061073541641235,
-0.25325730443000793,
-0.09906705468893051,
-0.018924720585346222,
0.4684393107891083,
0.1007714718580246,
0.051195789128541946,
0.617477536201477,
-0.5653592944145203,
0.13079403340816498,
-0.006384853273630142,
0.14441369473934174,
0.07875708490610123,
0.4033730924129486,
0.163090318441391,
-0.6965779066085815,
-0.610694169998169,
0.03525891527533531,
-0.729945719242096,
-0.10407719761133194,
-0.12991546094417572,
-0.40796971321105957,
0.21388663351535797,
0.788841962814331,
-0.5075265765190125,
-0.045126691460609436,
0.3345358371734619,
-0.26078006625175476,
0.4711425304412842,
-0.39770543575286865,
0.2201954573392868,
-1.1223773956298828,
-0.10213492810726166,
-0.3286862373352051,
-0.16569127142429352,
-0.626478910446167,
0.027483893558382988,
0.237945556640625,
0.06434892863035202,
-0.30130186676979065,
0.5097711682319641,
-0.6961807608604431,
-0.07600241154432297,
-0.33815664052963257,
0.2878047227859497,
0.22100502252578735,
0.5525819659233093,
0.1259344071149826,
1.0597212314605713,
0.5104330778121948,
-0.7199025750160217,
0.24862487614154816,
0.30163538455963135,
-0.5689867734909058,
0.42239072918891907,
-0.572681725025177,
0.5859846472740173,
-0.2762746512889862,
-0.14981338381767273,
-0.49549248814582825,
-0.12894843518733978,
-0.15031881630420685,
-0.38578248023986816,
0.8259742856025696,
-0.015288932248950005,
-0.2526651620864868,
-0.12165949493646622,
-0.12303510308265686,
0.07967200130224228,
0.5097815990447998,
-0.6271998882293701,
0.6797074675559998,
0.33704185485839844,
-0.2076258659362793,
-0.5665498375892639,
-0.24212132394313812,
-0.3188612163066864,
-0.04189428314566612,
-0.5318012237548828,
0.2559000551700592,
-0.1774706095457077,
-0.07208049297332764,
0.01021136436611414,
-0.37940725684165955,
-0.054415132850408554,
0.2399497926235199,
-0.08454129099845886,
0.28740739822387695,
-0.46207180619239807,
0.4049728512763977,
0.24043668806552887,
-0.1639968305826187,
0.0907016471028328,
-0.16163760423660278,
0.6057962775230408,
-0.13377903401851654,
-0.4462559223175049,
-0.35448676347732544,
0.21451297402381897,
0.3969272971153259,
-0.4772789180278778,
0.8888811469078064,
0.4393196702003479,
0.0734882652759552,
-0.12948213517665863,
-0.9157986044883728,
-0.35131075978279114,
-0.5288829207420349,
0.3425014615058899,
-0.4935759902000427,
-0.987938642501831,
0.09653929620981216,
-0.25972118973731995,
0.10694858431816101,
0.1852526217699051,
0.4100545048713684,
-0.5462340712547302,
0.868802011013031,
0.8149899244308472,
-0.027427539229393005,
0.6555244326591492,
-0.22266723215579987,
0.016323111951351166,
-1.0392712354660034,
-0.27498114109039307,
-0.6481649279594421,
-0.13910767436027527,
-0.2638973891735077,
-0.3845066726207733,
0.4811071455478668,
0.4001113176345825,
-0.2029716521501541,
-0.023753948509693146,
-0.2104426771402359,
0.7779256701469421,
0.8328494429588318,
0.19552190601825714,
0.18957477807998657,
-0.15331844985485077,
0.09232590347528458,
0.3720785677433014,
-0.8341889381408691,
-0.471951425075531,
1.3113001585006714,
0.06375753879547119,
0.8362982869148254,
-0.07301521301269531,
0.7869725823402405,
-0.1429676115512848,
0.2553116977214813,
-0.56766277551651,
0.34299424290657043,
-0.23575380444526672,
-0.42034804821014404,
-0.4030444622039795,
-0.35359784960746765,
-0.9627883434295654,
0.05191166698932648,
-0.40832382440567017,
-0.4110000729560852,
0.0023296037688851357,
0.51954185962677,
-0.47758030891418457,
0.09940072149038315,
-1.0091097354888916,
0.7845295667648315,
-0.5152261853218079,
-0.32110750675201416,
-0.15366888046264648,
-0.5964733958244324,
0.18197600543498993,
-0.140362948179245,
0.20232650637626648,
0.20910924673080444,
0.09489928930997849,
0.7480505108833313,
-0.37498950958251953,
0.6343609690666199,
-0.09367174655199051,
-0.21712107956409454,
0.15004441142082214,
-0.19083644449710846,
0.5940775275230408,
-0.0298758652061224,
-0.069693922996521,
-0.3907996118068695,
-0.022279242053627968,
-0.3934420049190521,
-1.0410388708114624,
0.5234919190406799,
-1.0706862211227417,
-1.286661148071289,
-0.08278898149728775,
-0.518845796585083,
-0.49605831503868103,
0.23445717990398407,
0.16782142221927643,
0.40577489137649536,
0.12076037377119064,
0.29280027747154236,
1.2741296291351318,
-0.2806457579135895,
0.0340408980846405,
0.9632096886634827,
0.06936610490083694,
0.05435164272785187,
0.8452932834625244,
-0.04087620601058006,
0.42306020855903625,
0.7560185790061951,
0.2405541092157364,
-0.3060919940471649,
-0.570029616355896,
-0.31669390201568604,
0.39592885971069336,
-0.6204618811607361,
-0.12036498636007309,
-0.6795646548271179,
-0.2805185914039612,
-0.4985717236995697,
-0.23078224062919617,
-0.18543317914009094,
-0.12566177546977997,
-0.5022170543670654,
-0.08979904651641846,
0.26209500432014465,
0.421701043844223,
0.12637634575366974,
0.4970182180404663,
-0.8854799270629883,
0.47196996212005615,
0.7879846096038818,
0.3616270422935486,
-0.31045424938201904,
-0.8370541930198669,
-0.42758625745773315,
0.09052946418523788,
-0.17838355898857117,
-0.8978260159492493,
0.0699782446026802,
0.3471181094646454,
0.6278727650642395,
0.3336259424686432,
-0.08261946588754654,
0.7318341135978699,
-0.5009320974349976,
0.3248421549797058,
-0.19531819224357605,
-0.7666618227958679,
0.8111982345581055,
-0.2132665514945984,
0.3889574706554413,
0.6831495761871338,
0.5192612409591675,
-0.31536415219306946,
-0.2821696102619171,
-0.38614699244499207,
-0.5791885256767273,
0.9642961025238037,
-0.35437503457069397,
0.3385462760925293,
0.0034357388503849506,
0.5645596981048584,
0.06946470588445663,
0.35455358028411865,
-0.4073479175567627,
0.009466469287872314,
-0.13235148787498474,
-0.18307723104953766,
-0.19773249328136444,
-0.3034452497959137,
-0.17035646736621857,
-0.1956622302532196,
0.9102033376693726,
-0.14919981360435486,
0.12047558277845383,
-0.10403749346733093,
-0.3089565336704254,
-0.16835351288318634,
0.41790613532066345,
0.48242419958114624,
0.6399437785148621,
-0.27486342191696167,
0.13348574936389923,
0.1738339513540268,
-0.42285439372062683,
0.003100566565990448,
0.02264300361275673,
-0.3210102319717407,
-0.3945079743862152,
0.5878610610961914,
1.167220950126648,
0.18184031546115875,
-0.6105877161026001,
0.39179134368896484,
-0.12351417541503906,
-0.1969781517982483,
-0.1432681828737259,
0.7552461624145508,
0.20743314921855927,
0.19534367322921753,
-0.05701906606554985,
-0.15295608341693878,
-0.27110642194747925,
-0.7164150476455688,
0.01916494220495224,
0.4548376202583313,
-0.09314507991075516,
-0.11618974804878235,
0.3295682668685913,
0.32234424352645874,
-0.5395923852920532,
0.7713544964790344,
-0.0770411342382431,
-0.429546594619751,
0.5497270822525024,
0.6883568167686462,
0.5711871981620789,
-0.3848438560962677,
0.08412077277898788,
0.25757086277008057,
0.27161678671836853,
-0.04699080437421799,
0.32886675000190735,
-0.37262651324272156,
-0.831060528755188,
-0.3699045777320862,
-0.8957101702690125,
-0.297648549079895,
0.1997932642698288,
-0.7081727385520935,
0.27538833022117615,
-0.40437600016593933,
0.26554110646247864,
-0.23363688588142395,
0.023641854524612427,
-0.7723740935325623,
0.38558483123779297,
-0.2002427875995636,
0.8941593766212463,
-0.7403252124786377,
1.1330379247665405,
0.7117477059364319,
-0.29693901538848877,
-1.2318540811538696,
0.07138081640005112,
-0.3615502119064331,
-0.9737756848335266,
0.38474878668785095,
-0.046176183968782425,
-0.07014815509319305,
0.29889562726020813,
-0.29028990864753723,
-0.9947178363800049,
1.1100307703018188,
0.7001195549964905,
-0.9280872941017151,
-0.31208866834640503,
-0.055792950093746185,
0.4823545217514038,
-0.14440104365348816,
0.274203360080719,
0.7673928737640381,
0.39024102687835693,
0.09724371135234833,
-0.6323269605636597,
-0.21396848559379578,
-0.3957085907459259,
-0.3552986681461334,
0.24701756238937378,
-0.6108129620552063,
0.7538864016532898,
-0.21612548828125,
-0.1982133835554123,
-0.23174330592155457,
0.510242223739624,
0.05192059278488159,
0.15337640047073364,
0.49250295758247375,
0.6268852949142456,
1.0343807935714722,
-0.10244695842266083,
1.0556939840316772,
-0.4129643738269806,
-0.21677915751934052,
1.4689605236053467,
0.047296199947595596,
0.803540825843811,
0.42986419796943665,
-0.1282183974981308,
0.5949979424476624,
0.4309881627559662,
0.17126896977424622,
0.44520363211631775,
0.06748563051223755,
-0.15189483761787415,
-0.5597597360610962,
0.1081540584564209,
-0.5237782597541809,
0.4757855534553528,
0.38142651319503784,
-0.2899233400821686,
0.06945811957120895,
-0.13726942241191864,
0.005175219848752022,
0.3421786427497864,
-0.3722992539405823,
1.1736000776290894,
-0.009270468726754189,
-1.1046253442764282,
0.7472936511039734,
-0.104985810816288,
0.5150853395462036,
-0.7103498578071594,
0.02905740961432457,
-0.4685102105140686,
-0.16511566936969757,
-0.08114046603441238,
-0.40375712513923645,
0.16838900744915009,
0.11203140765428543,
-0.36369219422340393,
-0.04814229533076286,
0.5535709857940674,
-0.6002959609031677,
-0.39191991090774536,
0.00234021432697773,
0.4946322441101074,
0.10805447399616241,
0.08799716085195541,
-0.5015435218811035,
-0.11146943271160126,
-0.10387326031923294,
-0.2567456066608429,
0.465703547000885,
0.4301813542842865,
0.1817348152399063,
0.5594678521156311,
0.6789941191673279,
0.1591741442680359,
0.43851515650749207,
0.13786379992961884,
1.0470120906829834,
-0.4348978102207184,
-0.38456082344055176,
-0.6175477504730225,
0.4029361307621002,
-0.04392332211136818,
-0.21720314025878906,
0.5306406021118164,
0.38344746828079224,
0.9827172160148621,
-0.03422316163778305,
0.6654810309410095,
0.2184591144323349,
0.6557315587997437,
-1.143401026725769,
0.6594372987747192,
-0.7252469658851624,
0.5070828795433044,
0.04302532225847244,
-0.8238928914070129,
0.12126477807760239,
0.6329014301300049,
-0.5129184722900391,
0.1341569423675537,
0.6914533972740173,
1.0454063415527344,
-0.08411732316017151,
0.007765659596771002,
0.3425828516483307,
0.22089217603206635,
0.2064526379108429,
0.7350121140480042,
0.703567385673523,
-0.19973480701446533,
0.45718300342559814,
-0.21574713289737701,
-0.28704577684402466,
-0.001005397061817348,
-0.5998630523681641,
-1.090749979019165,
-0.49736711382865906,
-0.07129613310098648,
0.010813196189701557,
0.32386723160743713,
0.7731310129165649,
0.7224609851837158,
-0.6700274348258972,
-0.03597339987754822,
-0.16430392861366272,
0.2787204682826996,
0.06970032304525375,
-0.11669516563415527,
0.601646363735199,
-0.8984891772270203,
-0.7178627848625183,
0.649408757686615,
0.13670866191387177,
-0.0016822011675685644,
-0.04354134574532509,
-0.2985101342201233,
-0.29053786396980286,
0.2629616856575012,
0.3865523040294647,
0.3542989194393158,
-0.43971219658851624,
-0.20632484555244446,
0.21262408792972565,
-0.05389077216386795,
0.028461050242185593,
0.8412104845046997,
-0.7570868730545044,
0.7286826968193054,
0.33990606665611267,
1.101913571357727,
0.5652022957801819,
0.151539608836174,
0.6909291744232178,
-0.7384191155433655,
-0.005320452153682709,
0.08631154149770737,
0.15981799364089966,
0.3207920789718628,
-0.4374511241912842,
0.23597466945648193,
-0.041400957852602005,
-0.5323339700698853,
-0.6219210624694824,
0.22353000938892365,
-0.6544898152351379,
-0.25768399238586426,
0.98206627368927,
-0.3668319582939148,
-0.2693510353565216,
-0.02665320225059986,
-0.1163858026266098,
0.5370751619338989,
-0.18094706535339355,
1.2272310256958008,
0.5976948142051697,
-0.052389468997716904,
-0.3890265226364136,
-0.29952529072761536,
0.7097794413566589,
0.6624668836593628,
-1.166927456855774,
-0.09112312644720078,
0.3253616690635681,
0.20243783295154572,
0.006913983728736639,
0.8402748107910156,
0.050481125712394714,
0.5217976570129395,
-0.15958967804908752,
-0.2997962236404419,
-0.42368483543395996,
-0.5448353886604309,
-0.15608341991901398,
0.040792323648929596,
0.5157302021980286,
-0.1271299421787262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12844v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12844v1 | ICON: Improving Inter-Report Consistency of Radiology Report Generation via Lesion-aware Mix-up Augmentation | 2024-02-20T09:13:15 | 2024-02-20T09:13:15 | Wenjun Hou, Yi Cheng, Kaishuai Xu, Yan Hu, Wenjie Li, Jiang Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Previous research on radiology report generation has made significant
progress in terms of increasing the clinical accuracy of generated reports. In
this paper, we emphasize another crucial quality that it should possess, i.e.,
inter-report consistency, which refers to the capability of generating
consistent reports for semantically equivalent radiographs. This quality is
even of greater significance than the overall report accuracy in terms of
ensuring the system's credibility, as a system prone to providing conflicting
results would severely erode users' trust. Regrettably, existing approaches
struggle to maintain inter-report consistency, exhibiting biases towards common
patterns and susceptibility to lesion variants. To address this issue, we
propose ICON, which improves the inter-report consistency of radiology report
generation. Aiming at enhancing the system's ability to capture the
similarities in semantically equivalent lesions, our approach involves first
extracting lesions from input images and examining their characteristics. Then,
we introduce a lesion-aware mix-up augmentation technique to ensure that the
representations of the semantically equivalent lesions align with the same
attributes, by linearly interpolating them during the training phase. Extensive
experiments on three publicly available chest X-ray datasets verify the
effectiveness of our approach, both in terms of improving the consistency and
accuracy of the generated reports. | [
-0.34430158138275146,
-0.008004521019756794,
0.5496944785118103,
0.641247570514679,
-0.5047318339347839,
0.45487260818481445,
0.39774030447006226,
-1.0401017665863037,
0.7024069428443909,
0.46194857358932495,
-0.11110933125019073,
-0.26907697319984436,
-0.992598831653595,
0.08351387828588486,
-0.32541510462760925,
0.6986117362976074,
-0.11357637494802475,
0.28465986251831055,
-0.2731423079967499,
-0.7250846028327942,
-0.9358343482017517,
-0.1247154101729393,
-0.5917947888374329,
-0.4468369483947754,
0.4026006758213043,
0.3205198049545288,
1.3121917247772217,
0.8841009736061096,
0.6847395300865173,
0.10940103232860565,
0.48729395866394043,
0.5926346182823181,
-0.14925053715705872,
0.1984974890947342,
-0.09394987672567368,
0.17604413628578186,
-0.6567363739013672,
-0.19384263455867767,
0.498312383890152,
0.4665777385234833,
0.10260897874832153,
-0.43957459926605225,
-0.1062590554356575,
0.5526609420776367,
-0.6012330055236816,
-0.02516407147049904,
-0.48549941182136536,
-0.21174529194831848,
0.03561902791261673,
-0.8289422392845154,
-0.22216349840164185,
-0.39454707503318787,
-0.056055568158626556,
-0.8080487847328186,
-0.05413046106696129,
-0.2178013175725937,
1.0591808557510376,
-0.055623482912778854,
-0.24793577194213867,
-0.328874796628952,
-0.5212788581848145,
0.2648450434207916,
-0.6304318308830261,
0.4065738022327423,
0.372280091047287,
0.44070884585380554,
0.048685427755117416,
-0.9989408254623413,
-0.23878733813762665,
-0.2771552503108978,
-0.6307207942008972,
0.4061196446418762,
-0.24769598245620728,
0.1131448969244957,
0.0018547502113506198,
0.28329402208328247,
-0.4028452932834625,
0.021311789751052856,
-0.010061227716505527,
-0.32841792702674866,
0.6912001967430115,
0.2754490077495575,
0.5502245426177979,
0.1559114009141922,
-0.6365770101547241,
-0.32683536410331726,
-1.1280686855316162,
-0.3518175184726715,
-0.04595278576016426,
0.2261524796485901,
0.12731008231639862,
0.44802576303482056,
-0.21122793853282928,
0.4935990571975708,
0.21762679517269135,
-0.16460400819778442,
0.5429663062095642,
-0.4217202365398407,
-0.04541594535112381,
0.48887577652931213,
0.4699905812740326,
0.6797654032707214,
-0.4564419984817505,
-0.1325167864561081,
-0.26709601283073425,
0.07462012022733688,
0.42350128293037415,
-0.8717400431632996,
-0.25147709250450134,
0.2832486927509308,
-0.32961487770080566,
-0.4395713210105896,
0.0613936111330986,
-0.0734863132238388,
-0.6560621857643127,
-0.18568028509616852,
0.988997757434845,
-0.7611372470855713,
-0.20847870409488678,
0.10694766789674759,
-0.055947113782167435,
-0.12592196464538574,
0.6111013293266296,
-0.5078073143959045,
0.1791897416114807,
0.39643585681915283,
0.5461190938949585,
0.3392238914966583,
-0.1523066610097885,
-1.0038586854934692,
0.6109166741371155,
-0.3857179880142212,
0.9256877899169922,
-0.6601728200912476,
-0.5117265582084656,
-0.0889001116156578,
-0.22890882194042206,
0.11636127531528473,
-0.9719383716583252,
0.05257013440132141,
-0.31521016359329224,
0.009014108218252659,
-0.56751549243927,
-0.3522108495235443,
-0.0760018602013588,
0.43868038058280945,
-0.5349617004394531,
1.3043971061706543,
0.4880606234073639,
-0.5791135430335999,
0.817206859588623,
-0.3719382882118225,
-0.35372769832611084,
0.32953307032585144,
-0.6880068182945251,
-0.5329672694206238,
0.002605119254440069,
0.594383180141449,
0.35723018646240234,
-0.17178970575332642,
0.1111215129494667,
0.08824634552001953,
-0.3270924389362335,
0.10712211579084396,
0.032555341720581055,
0.3585037589073181,
-0.07854722440242767,
-0.23720712959766388,
0.15009309351444244,
-0.6044114828109741,
0.1746055781841278,
-0.0035204393789172173,
0.023925617337226868,
-0.4481310546398163,
-0.27087101340293884,
-0.25812482833862305,
0.30620333552360535,
0.3252069354057312,
-0.7847152352333069,
0.3772628903388977,
-0.01679289899766445,
-0.19396358728408813,
0.5176743865013123,
0.17969737946987152,
-0.08401910215616226,
-1.061877727508545,
0.3152051568031311,
0.518264889717102,
0.2937258183956146,
-0.23902614414691925,
-0.5696747303009033,
-0.5443681478500366,
-0.6746619343757629,
0.2789105772972107,
0.2618257999420166,
-0.644412100315094,
0.2361464947462082,
-0.3694320023059845,
-0.5623341798782349,
-0.6566310524940491,
-0.2556159198284149,
0.5431484580039978,
0.6625323295593262,
0.5010400414466858,
-0.9522398710250854,
-0.7894157767295837,
-0.9352039098739624,
-0.28932905197143555,
-0.10748722404241562,
0.10209456086158752,
0.41847869753837585,
-0.13537342846393585,
-0.3989315927028656,
0.7292370200157166,
-0.3406085968017578,
-0.5178497433662415,
0.029068199917674065,
0.316518098115921,
-0.1371506303548813,
0.5668569803237915,
0.7048835158348083,
-0.6236525177955627,
-0.7722334265708923,
0.30470430850982666,
-0.8035883903503418,
-0.24226026237010956,
-0.30106931924819946,
-0.14820346236228943,
-0.15073594450950623,
0.9426056146621704,
-0.110988549888134,
0.6896694302558899,
0.3767196834087372,
-0.1518646478652954,
0.263872355222702,
-0.6737521290779114,
0.6890804171562195,
-0.8641768097877502,
0.09124547988176346,
-0.29178157448768616,
-0.6556252837181091,
-0.5006864070892334,
-0.08885964006185532,
0.16634482145309448,
0.10628128051757812,
-0.26066428422927856,
0.3995921313762665,
-0.4583502411842346,
-0.1302250623703003,
-0.062301307916641235,
-0.2761813998222351,
0.4073067903518677,
-0.1772375851869583,
-0.043003566563129425,
0.6932870745658875,
0.6134587526321411,
-0.3432374596595764,
-0.22533321380615234,
0.22002549469470978,
-0.21535097062587738,
0.7667296528816223,
-0.46356165409088135,
0.19723962247371674,
-0.15569423139095306,
0.0932418555021286,
-0.9331287145614624,
-0.2669297754764557,
0.31679078936576843,
-0.29124128818511963,
0.6824516654014587,
-0.16714313626289368,
-0.46346378326416016,
0.09688945859670639,
-0.2677972912788391,
0.557732105255127,
0.4845449924468994,
-0.47738057374954224,
0.8204087018966675,
0.28887489438056946,
-0.09791223704814911,
-0.7850573062896729,
-0.5110769271850586,
0.20582616329193115,
0.15410052239894867,
-0.5292065143585205,
0.5112633109092712,
-0.33437684178352356,
0.00706833228468895,
0.12002658098936081,
-0.13172785937786102,
-0.1915065497159958,
-0.4239965081214905,
0.3933015465736389,
0.25422507524490356,
-0.16813701391220093,
-0.02585756778717041,
0.10177284479141235,
-0.01781095750629902,
-0.28788527846336365,
0.0127408467233181,
0.3912675380706787,
0.1309530884027481,
-0.7617293000221252,
-0.3330422341823578,
0.4699348211288452,
0.7394942045211792,
0.1167256161570549,
0.2886728346347809,
0.2972792983055115,
-0.42143014073371887,
0.3824475109577179,
-0.6272773146629333,
-0.20224639773368835,
-0.39537203311920166,
0.3203924000263214,
-0.3712763786315918,
-0.44301462173461914,
0.8029241561889648,
-0.1980825513601303,
0.24730908870697021,
0.25810182094573975,
0.3349469006061554,
-0.3118855357170105,
1.2507939338684082,
0.4292163848876953,
0.23545542359352112,
0.27069365978240967,
0.09132840484380722,
0.0801965594291687,
-0.8980659246444702,
-0.48090389370918274,
-0.2599591016769409,
-0.19996418058872223,
-0.06967214494943619,
-0.31103336811065674,
0.7060117721557617,
0.02160315029323101,
0.09536006301641464,
-0.004800801165401936,
-0.7091280817985535,
0.5344037413597107,
0.009247357957065105,
0.39711862802505493,
0.5325560569763184,
0.3529936969280243,
0.14553478360176086,
-0.3260459899902344,
-0.887901782989502,
-0.20083388686180115,
0.9136726260185242,
0.07780415564775467,
0.5244223475456238,
0.016588900238275528,
0.9612522721290588,
0.6480078101158142,
0.6861376166343689,
-0.41221073269844055,
0.2791334092617035,
-0.32892218232154846,
-0.40125784277915955,
-0.0608220212161541,
-0.05779898911714554,
-1.2064348459243774,
0.3018605411052704,
-0.3458736538887024,
-0.3543533682823181,
0.29750680923461914,
0.49795326590538025,
-0.13487282395362854,
0.18820929527282715,
-0.2635859251022339,
0.46234914660453796,
0.04668673872947693,
0.05126279592514038,
-0.2310667335987091,
-0.6623609662055969,
0.010488432832062244,
0.00916426070034504,
0.287933886051178,
-0.19881540536880493,
0.017953649163246155,
0.45479536056518555,
-0.9411268830299377,
0.6596105694770813,
0.07472552359104156,
-0.029966091737151146,
0.22927337884902954,
0.3077547550201416,
0.5905254483222961,
0.12059716880321503,
0.2998024523258209,
0.29622703790664673,
-0.15828819572925568,
-0.4726884961128235,
-0.7038718461990356,
0.6208130717277527,
-0.8611897230148315,
-0.22050701081752777,
-0.3952735662460327,
-0.9428683519363403,
-0.34501051902770996,
0.24925829470157623,
0.5101365447044373,
0.97523432970047,
-0.21535836160182953,
-0.38048675656318665,
0.613411009311676,
0.15273725986480713,
-0.17835021018981934,
0.5094904899597168,
-0.2095010131597519,
-0.7183576226234436,
1.2097421884536743,
0.2721785306930542,
0.37270739674568176,
0.5167146325111389,
0.02475690469145775,
-0.07075423002243042,
-0.714771032333374,
-0.6161948442459106,
0.35319462418556213,
-0.8932398557662964,
-0.4512445330619812,
-0.6197400689125061,
-0.3321969509124756,
-0.3391765058040619,
-0.6364492774009705,
-0.6039361953735352,
-0.2818598449230194,
0.1101081445813179,
0.444608598947525,
0.4590800702571869,
0.8956290483474731,
-0.5229722857475281,
0.32427337765693665,
-0.8463797569274902,
0.17443886399269104,
0.12706705927848816,
0.257941871881485,
-0.2579509913921356,
-0.6045846343040466,
-0.31273841857910156,
-0.020509080961346626,
-0.0626276358962059,
-0.6370295286178589,
0.1329268366098404,
0.004214993678033352,
0.40855732560157776,
0.1934293508529663,
-0.0011971555650234222,
0.8330390453338623,
-0.014281680807471275,
0.257683128118515,
0.652171790599823,
-0.7937495708465576,
0.48493656516075134,
-0.3574056923389435,
0.2041657418012619,
0.6914253234863281,
0.12422885000705719,
-0.462251752614975,
-0.7919541597366333,
-0.9704295992851257,
-0.9499676823616028,
0.5755533576011658,
0.2900901734828949,
-0.33573222160339355,
-0.012152904644608498,
0.07224974781274796,
0.4818447232246399,
0.05197998136281967,
-0.36122918128967285,
-0.1790807694196701,
-0.32326540350914,
-0.15514202415943146,
0.19209377467632294,
-0.15044939517974854,
-0.6624603867530823,
-0.24759042263031006,
0.7496659755706787,
-0.0911424458026886,
0.09942920506000519,
0.43512290716171265,
-0.20838558673858643,
-0.24360932409763336,
0.004336127080023289,
0.6536548733711243,
1.063655138015747,
-0.500460684299469,
0.39524874091148376,
-0.06636108458042145,
-0.9467206001281738,
0.20077474415302277,
-0.12596234679222107,
-0.017399800941348076,
0.362362802028656,
0.34322014451026917,
0.39676254987716675,
0.08745028078556061,
-0.5189590454101562,
0.7262904644012451,
-0.026248767971992493,
-0.29993391036987305,
-0.011899936012923717,
-0.023070307448506355,
-0.14394767582416534,
0.16023476421833038,
0.2666786313056946,
0.5909358859062195,
0.03252372890710831,
-0.4024744927883148,
0.39566344022750854,
0.24443137645721436,
-0.941191554069519,
0.049510981887578964,
0.30891555547714233,
0.14073576033115387,
0.2128562033176422,
0.5777276158332825,
-0.05632217600941658,
-0.01316121593117714,
0.6104984879493713,
0.5699964165687561,
0.5742490291595459,
-0.26500824093818665,
0.22842004895210266,
0.19818951189517975,
0.48789945244789124,
0.0514439158141613,
0.5029988884925842,
0.4693683385848999,
-0.6470649838447571,
-0.39306560158729553,
0.06675779074430466,
-0.4369511604309082,
0.2554682791233063,
-0.8345891237258911,
0.29496681690216064,
-0.6246473789215088,
-0.003956962376832962,
0.12484826892614365,
-0.46261802315711975,
-0.31586602330207825,
0.5196969509124756,
-0.13273797929286957,
0.7574362754821777,
-0.851889431476593,
0.6950902342796326,
0.9808063507080078,
-0.570809543132782,
-0.9857850074768066,
-0.12305876612663269,
-0.3520558476448059,
-1.200849175453186,
0.4748307764530182,
0.10467375069856644,
-0.07272130995988846,
-0.25449779629707336,
-0.10913251340389252,
-0.7076818943023682,
1.1546872854232788,
0.43379417061805725,
-0.2512780427932739,
0.48617079854011536,
0.3538931608200073,
0.30922895669937134,
-0.8109046816825867,
0.43299952149391174,
0.32418227195739746,
0.3592495322227478,
0.3427659273147583,
-0.9851981401443481,
0.6460853219032288,
-0.01645585335791111,
-0.0913001298904419,
0.3634697198867798,
-0.3185511827468872,
0.6016095876693726,
-0.34282779693603516,
-0.06996782124042511,
0.03780549764633179,
0.5691736340522766,
0.3311172425746918,
0.6220711469650269,
0.5728710889816284,
0.8135647773742676,
0.5898906588554382,
0.03925691545009613,
1.0460739135742188,
-0.29007503390312195,
-0.09556296467781067,
0.9722542762756348,
-0.25127917528152466,
0.24702179431915283,
0.31277772784233093,
0.1682555228471756,
0.6072474122047424,
0.3487679958343506,
0.08984781801700592,
0.572754979133606,
-0.48156312108039856,
-0.3675866723060608,
-0.3868864178657532,
-0.322846919298172,
-0.7904877662658691,
0.30773040652275085,
0.29548487067222595,
-0.4018276333808899,
-0.4179345369338989,
-0.15252164006233215,
0.062036916613578796,
-0.21440672874450684,
-0.3120257258415222,
0.7821369767189026,
-0.3157353401184082,
-0.4176884889602661,
0.7535936832427979,
-0.486724853515625,
0.17767441272735596,
-0.8393032550811768,
-0.41967955231666565,
-0.1910562515258789,
0.014791232533752918,
-0.5415405035018921,
-0.9054343104362488,
0.293025940656662,
-0.6442703604698181,
-0.3911762535572052,
0.12465450912714005,
0.7465282082557678,
-0.5118422508239746,
-0.13484497368335724,
0.08890320360660553,
0.33435678482055664,
0.2491905242204666,
0.028149401769042015,
-0.5577937960624695,
0.534358561038971,
0.04665025323629379,
0.5204229950904846,
0.7801439762115479,
0.23303452134132385,
-0.10867664963006973,
0.18809258937835693,
0.30906614661216736,
0.21261265873908997,
-0.2056465744972229,
0.2335902750492096,
1.0583804845809937,
-0.03910629078745842,
-0.5685000419616699,
-0.22791866958141327,
0.5941384434700012,
-0.4382913112640381,
-0.40279313921928406,
0.5359989404678345,
0.7141425013542175,
0.6137953996658325,
0.1465511918067932,
0.7961171865463257,
0.08715902268886566,
0.24554333090782166,
-0.3561152219772339,
0.6623367071151733,
-0.6185385584831238,
0.3787865936756134,
-0.25482967495918274,
-0.6748508810997009,
-0.3986901044845581,
0.21509867906570435,
0.11275108903646469,
0.04281649738550186,
0.6295837163925171,
1.072106957435608,
-0.442950963973999,
-0.2914794385433197,
0.456644743680954,
0.24953986704349518,
0.3210147023200989,
0.15387506783008575,
0.7239862680435181,
-0.7020445466041565,
0.4911077618598938,
-0.17295120656490326,
-0.4801425337791443,
-0.6932216286659241,
-0.8349238038063049,
-0.35824573040008545,
-0.46852532029151917,
-0.8181232213973999,
-0.8441606163978577,
0.28358832001686096,
0.38409051299095154,
0.8977245688438416,
-0.4369344711303711,
0.01203183550387621,
0.03875153511762619,
-0.23564200103282928,
-0.42186570167541504,
-0.14794425666332245,
0.5147265195846558,
-0.2359909862279892,
-0.21903444826602936,
0.3794305920600891,
0.9399613738059998,
0.1432521641254425,
0.15343354642391205,
-0.21733537316322327,
0.07160767912864685,
0.30548447370529175,
0.48401305079460144,
0.5964939594268799,
-0.4335600733757019,
-0.5726174712181091,
-0.4085131287574768,
-0.45028018951416016,
0.6515788435935974,
1.0100001096725464,
-0.9350776672363281,
1.0299001932144165,
0.2663120627403259,
0.510041356086731,
0.3734065592288971,
-0.21823884546756744,
0.23431438207626343,
-1.0278576612472534,
0.10272622853517532,
0.3059788644313812,
0.17899642884731293,
0.5242612361907959,
-0.5472457408905029,
0.39839446544647217,
0.06759181618690491,
-0.3862614631652832,
-0.8381211161613464,
0.34848955273628235,
-1.337009072303772,
-0.24162174761295319,
0.5805265307426453,
-0.161256805062294,
0.4394943118095398,
-0.40566474199295044,
-0.28011810779571533,
0.1750730723142624,
-0.3189043700695038,
0.8590187430381775,
-0.008382724598050117,
-0.7214993238449097,
0.14545176923274994,
0.06567326188087463,
0.5890631675720215,
0.602002739906311,
-0.7802708148956299,
-0.232185497879982,
0.3578141927719116,
0.43314871191978455,
0.2028842270374298,
1.2117109298706055,
-0.4692120850086212,
0.7508707046508789,
0.2124093621969223,
0.08173944056034088,
-0.323650985956192,
-0.22289907932281494,
0.08512353897094727,
0.016302775591611862,
0.1928069293498993,
-0.16493508219718933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12842v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12842v2 | PromptKD: Distilling Student-Friendly Knowledge for Generative Language Models via Prompt Tuning | 2024-02-20T09:10:08 | 2024-06-24T05:40:38 | Gyeongman Kim, Doohyuk Jang, Eunho Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have raised concerns
about inference costs, increasing the need for research into model compression.
While knowledge distillation (KD) is a prominent method for this, research on
KD for generative language models like LLMs is relatively sparse, and the
approach of distilling student-friendly knowledge, which has shown promising
performance in KD for classification models, remains unexplored in generative
language models. To explore this approach, we propose PromptKD, a simple yet
effective method that utilizes prompt tuning - for the first time in KD - to
enable generative language models to transfer student-friendly knowledge.
Unlike previous works in classification that require fine-tuning the entire
teacher model for extracting student-friendly knowledge, PromptKD achieves
similar effects by adding a small number of prompt tokens and tuning only the
prompt with student guidance. Extensive experiments on instruction-following
datasets show that PromptKD achieves state-of-the-art performance while adding
only 0.0007% of the teacher's parameters as prompts. Further analysis suggests
that distilling student-friendly knowledge alleviates exposure bias effectively
throughout the entire training process, leading to performance enhancements. | [
-0.34889790415763855,
-0.740168571472168,
0.5224629640579224,
0.2257125973701477,
-0.4544428288936615,
0.10607226938009262,
-0.4022139310836792,
0.23992933332920074,
-0.3465197682380676,
0.3504748046398163,
-0.6209738850593567,
-0.5860075354576111,
-0.38229140639305115,
0.0816594809293747,
-0.1765470951795578,
1.0388498306274414,
0.3996738791465759,
0.21660423278808594,
-0.4381057322025299,
0.1549675166606903,
-0.6908112168312073,
-0.2491617649793625,
-0.9384102821350098,
-0.25511080026626587,
0.6641263961791992,
0.7628808617591858,
0.4235047698020935,
0.8281310200691223,
-0.03865167498588562,
0.2247145175933838,
-0.3579382002353668,
-0.08103348314762115,
-0.2795470952987671,
0.5120886564254761,
-0.06361948698759079,
-0.6294152736663818,
-0.06096596643328667,
0.11937829107046127,
0.39447811245918274,
0.8903967142105103,
-0.25180909037590027,
0.016008857637643814,
0.4243308901786804,
0.6528306007385254,
-0.47450435161590576,
0.25095313787460327,
-0.5870265960693359,
-0.11106716841459274,
-0.2790951430797577,
-0.197113499045372,
-0.6352435946464539,
-0.6450239419937134,
0.10320432484149933,
-0.7921113967895508,
0.5387505292892456,
-0.03747573867440224,
0.38410577178001404,
0.5693880319595337,
-0.4102743864059448,
-0.37171468138694763,
-0.39844465255737305,
0.602287769317627,
-0.5667576193809509,
0.37212854623794556,
0.4456709623336792,
0.5240142941474915,
-0.19047676026821136,
-0.6320175528526306,
-0.7086957693099976,
-0.08811617642641068,
0.0020385761745274067,
0.017348449677228928,
0.10100242495536804,
0.3184937834739685,
0.5864776968955994,
0.31075066328048706,
-0.32565218210220337,
0.2558186948299408,
-0.08663060516119003,
-0.16133683919906616,
0.2570670247077942,
0.07977902144193649,
0.308332622051239,
-0.38298121094703674,
-0.32158175110816956,
-0.31416797637939453,
-0.589616596698761,
0.31576967239379883,
0.3890109360218048,
0.6291635036468506,
-0.039521973580121994,
0.32861945033073425,
-0.4585093855857849,
0.8666555881500244,
0.22756345570087433,
-0.30739566683769226,
-0.12431064993143082,
-0.2975749373435974,
0.08488123118877411,
0.14201620221138,
0.5415259003639221,
0.41329672932624817,
0.2969908118247986,
-0.1492873579263687,
-0.08574461191892624,
0.17882639169692993,
-0.02289128489792347,
-1.0245766639709473,
-0.7650846838951111,
-0.31456321477890015,
-0.23682275414466858,
-0.5159313082695007,
-0.4228575825691223,
-0.9690669178962708,
-0.5540328025817871,
-0.5733579397201538,
0.30473753809928894,
-0.4351733326911926,
-0.2281675487756729,
-0.03148597106337547,
-0.19419877231121063,
0.12679508328437805,
0.4453856647014618,
-1.082049012184143,
-0.08046046644449234,
0.5523463487625122,
0.8035871386528015,
-0.06080295890569687,
-0.12780305743217468,
-0.6214728355407715,
-0.14910922944545746,
-0.25460192561149597,
0.674638032913208,
-0.6144906282424927,
-0.680494487285614,
-0.10633508861064911,
-0.07400937378406525,
0.14275403320789337,
-0.5485949516296387,
0.6649771928787231,
-0.6365971565246582,
0.13810542225837708,
-0.5150436758995056,
-0.7352002263069153,
0.05229184404015541,
-0.07319174706935883,
-0.49641457200050354,
1.167414903640747,
0.37841883301734924,
-0.6319063901901245,
0.7286725044250488,
-0.3331771492958069,
-0.5521063804626465,
0.3286805748939514,
0.0056198518723249435,
-0.21396608650684357,
0.14992251992225647,
0.3200368583202362,
0.49321040511131287,
-0.13806191086769104,
0.3702966570854187,
-0.25992411375045776,
0.049721527844667435,
-0.014386843889951706,
-0.49710166454315186,
0.8937653303146362,
0.5617701411247253,
0.1955174207687378,
0.04061161354184151,
-0.9037395119667053,
-0.03384077176451683,
-0.17771942913532257,
-0.4092941880226135,
-0.805610179901123,
-0.4100191593170166,
-0.14634056389331818,
0.1302272230386734,
0.14612029492855072,
-0.39197084307670593,
0.6664772033691406,
-0.2831076979637146,
0.15347419679164886,
1.038887619972229,
0.07343066483736038,
0.6990917325019836,
-0.044597186148166656,
0.7593128085136414,
0.0012937909923493862,
0.07712872326374054,
-0.5152729749679565,
-0.46947619318962097,
-0.7814350128173828,
-0.29715588688850403,
0.3817465901374817,
0.19796553254127502,
-1.2123292684555054,
0.29489749670028687,
0.0011006883578374982,
-0.4566041827201843,
-0.8078866004943848,
0.36257967352867126,
0.09428352117538452,
1.1259772777557373,
0.23618607223033905,
0.15945838391780853,
-0.28940480947494507,
-0.5258983969688416,
-0.23379799723625183,
-0.2082359343767166,
-0.15937165915966034,
0.22472766041755676,
-0.19099338352680206,
0.2644382417201996,
1.196730136871338,
-0.8012710809707642,
0.004124682862311602,
-0.27623632550239563,
0.25132158398628235,
0.19411854445934296,
0.5619451403617859,
0.6111327409744263,
-0.5116251111030579,
-0.9373703002929688,
-0.20488789677619934,
-0.4567311108112335,
-0.5283552408218384,
-0.07340365648269653,
-0.284915030002594,
-0.0555461123585701,
0.6328752636909485,
-0.5785889625549316,
0.04060015082359314,
0.111744225025177,
-0.6186309456825256,
0.5129320025444031,
-0.22423969209194183,
0.13641594350337982,
-1.2335119247436523,
-0.10570017993450165,
-0.10132144391536713,
-0.31554707884788513,
-0.6172246932983398,
-0.05669254809617996,
0.2213073968887329,
-0.21146564185619354,
-0.2267615646123886,
0.6157151460647583,
-0.23876157402992249,
0.39378613233566284,
-0.49526557326316833,
0.0021541265305131674,
0.06123252958059311,
0.3911759555339813,
-0.024821331724524498,
0.8803130388259888,
0.9118221998214722,
-0.9309471249580383,
0.5090205669403076,
0.32427579164505005,
-0.5772896409034729,
0.794808030128479,
-0.5439453125,
0.18479815125465393,
-0.24581468105316162,
-0.05623720958828926,
-0.9569728970527649,
-0.09765446931123734,
0.1524752974510193,
-0.3753443658351898,
0.47905027866363525,
-0.6036356687545776,
-0.33257707953453064,
-0.22738224267959595,
0.01190327387303114,
0.4256157875061035,
0.8724998831748962,
-0.9761613607406616,
0.33431506156921387,
-0.09483599662780762,
-0.4683803617954254,
-0.2211625576019287,
-0.06359593570232391,
-0.08379807323217392,
-0.4456457495689392,
-0.43439623713493347,
0.1122511476278305,
-0.3351118862628937,
0.053064726293087006,
-0.03320971503853798,
-0.12179882824420929,
0.1008913666009903,
0.47358009219169617,
0.0032123990822583437,
0.36689430475234985,
-0.09119239449501038,
0.3534698486328125,
0.36790981888771057,
-0.29391321539878845,
0.030240831896662712,
-0.3098064064979553,
0.524290919303894,
0.44369009137153625,
-0.11613942682743073,
-0.44229379296302795,
0.07716439664363861,
0.4376347064971924,
0.07655996084213257,
0.6531757116317749,
0.4235372543334961,
-0.12984980642795563,
-0.6610031127929688,
-0.4287906885147095,
-0.5925698280334473,
-0.5425390005111694,
0.2722019851207733,
-0.5031716227531433,
-0.8859750628471375,
0.25013238191604614,
-0.481863796710968,
-0.1419350504875183,
0.2242388278245926,
0.3040747046470642,
-0.17793549597263336,
1.098509669303894,
0.8497448563575745,
-0.10807706415653229,
0.7013955116271973,
0.13080710172653198,
0.007597074378281832,
-0.6209885478019714,
-0.40519288182258606,
-0.9151526689529419,
-0.14944854378700256,
-0.413149893283844,
-0.19602139294147491,
0.35189875960350037,
0.6201983690261841,
-0.038991205394268036,
0.06267374008893967,
-0.3760979175567627,
0.7543659210205078,
0.6902748346328735,
-0.02167471870779991,
0.32637229561805725,
-0.012779499404132366,
-0.1598082184791565,
-0.09921972453594208,
-0.8465172648429871,
-0.3800274133682251,
1.0187451839447021,
0.014218805357813835,
0.8940035104751587,
-0.1355239301919937,
0.6199904680252075,
0.2145465761423111,
0.22049929201602936,
-0.7875516414642334,
0.5674670934677124,
-0.15998098254203796,
-0.19327865540981293,
-0.3180152475833893,
-0.6972426772117615,
-0.6855573058128357,
-0.052941713482141495,
-0.027138711884617805,
-0.33370333909988403,
0.05854697525501251,
0.3908402621746063,
-0.48294883966445923,
0.0023497026413679123,
-0.9822364449501038,
0.9278767704963684,
0.03750545531511307,
-0.1464230716228485,
-0.03827977180480957,
-0.5411209464073181,
0.2726224958896637,
-0.03797317296266556,
0.011568865738809109,
-0.10797451436519623,
0.2627633512020111,
0.7692795395851135,
-0.549371063709259,
0.7967298626899719,
-0.6511590480804443,
-0.28443947434425354,
0.20759060978889465,
0.16202567517757416,
0.6593332290649414,
0.24143138527870178,
0.07845029979944229,
-0.32023000717163086,
-0.0007276847027242184,
-0.37135493755340576,
-0.9839939475059509,
0.8118725419044495,
-0.688452959060669,
-0.7347010374069214,
-0.07812260091304779,
-0.5006785988807678,
-0.32047250866889954,
0.2076488435268402,
0.2703530490398407,
0.30490902066230774,
0.08586046099662781,
0.03120698407292366,
1.0319887399673462,
-0.21118636429309845,
0.4551137387752533,
0.7456648349761963,
-0.3753008544445038,
-0.14124281704425812,
1.0988829135894775,
-0.02199103869497776,
0.36994197964668274,
0.031082237139344215,
0.4600359797477722,
-0.6484712362289429,
-0.32984602451324463,
-0.6552908420562744,
-0.10077913105487823,
-0.7908613085746765,
-0.3582919239997864,
-0.5989900231361389,
0.08758942782878876,
-0.613540768623352,
-0.16859157383441925,
-0.33906984329223633,
-0.5310727953910828,
-0.6690874099731445,
-0.2300008088350296,
0.7474544644355774,
0.42314258217811584,
0.08402296900749207,
0.5459845066070557,
-0.5287179350852966,
0.3536359965801239,
0.5816712379455566,
0.5310676097869873,
0.04981953278183937,
-0.7653092741966248,
-0.11478637158870697,
-0.10049378126859665,
-0.16610179841518402,
-0.706305742263794,
0.23533649742603302,
0.46573132276535034,
0.4159265458583832,
0.6631386876106262,
0.6326945424079895,
0.503376305103302,
-0.33118143677711487,
0.7736518383026123,
0.274406373500824,
-0.7640842795372009,
0.824336051940918,
-0.09382116049528122,
0.48670172691345215,
0.6713088750839233,
0.34711387753486633,
-0.8828461766242981,
-0.31095775961875916,
-0.2555525004863739,
-0.7674315571784973,
1.0316009521484375,
-0.31921425461769104,
0.27609142661094666,
-0.09975530207157135,
0.5413560271263123,
0.5089099407196045,
0.11194825172424316,
-0.3526862859725952,
-0.4210553467273712,
-0.35509437322616577,
-0.5632326006889343,
-0.2352638989686966,
-0.3107437193393707,
0.16858981549739838,
-0.3682810366153717,
0.7880070209503174,
-0.2484806478023529,
-0.4093177020549774,
-0.1943550556898117,
-0.09021156281232834,
0.08960938453674316,
0.4165450632572174,
0.1816989779472351,
0.15136541426181793,
0.1053936779499054,
0.48976829648017883,
0.006418326869606972,
-0.4509223699569702,
0.42923668026924133,
0.01970010995864868,
-0.6477569937705994,
-0.07827802002429962,
-0.015381771139800549,
0.9114099740982056,
0.19335992634296417,
-0.3480203151702881,
0.3289863169193268,
-0.18325988948345184,
0.13086749613285065,
0.24998518824577332,
0.4591628313064575,
0.06415579468011856,
0.21276354789733887,
0.23102860152721405,
0.12464827299118042,
0.04706898704171181,
-0.09658638387918472,
0.13209861516952515,
0.26619860529899597,
-0.21938017010688782,
-0.469154953956604,
0.6940772533416748,
0.4091698229312897,
-0.19969730079174042,
0.8760908842086792,
-0.29682162404060364,
-0.4290665090084076,
0.41000670194625854,
0.5868875980377197,
0.9205043911933899,
-0.4511435925960541,
0.45105084776878357,
0.6084846258163452,
-0.07744867354631424,
-0.14149436354637146,
0.15317489206790924,
-0.45191773772239685,
-0.6495352983474731,
-0.3598480820655823,
-0.91934734582901,
-0.016464442014694214,
0.02525462955236435,
-0.8426651358604431,
0.38384929299354553,
-0.32313838601112366,
-0.005255499389022589,
-0.0071993558667600155,
-0.10740138590335846,
-0.6431297659873962,
-0.022891046479344368,
-0.130619615316391,
1.0218675136566162,
-0.9759431481361389,
1.0095727443695068,
0.545203685760498,
-0.16469237208366394,
-0.9046231508255005,
-0.21417632699012756,
-0.24632208049297333,
-0.5591580867767334,
0.6645737886428833,
-0.02497180923819542,
0.24099045991897583,
0.5667891502380371,
-0.6438383460044861,
-0.3598175048828125,
0.8797816038131714,
0.6235938668251038,
-0.8087253570556641,
0.05432523041963577,
0.16519422829151154,
0.24141442775726318,
0.040528424084186554,
0.06002485007047653,
0.6236417889595032,
0.3301168978214264,
0.447432279586792,
-0.44726091623306274,
0.029077179729938507,
-0.20075426995754242,
0.11889150738716125,
0.040430426597595215,
-0.4436570703983307,
0.6847525835037231,
-0.32608482241630554,
-0.5124215483665466,
0.025947878137230873,
0.705346941947937,
-0.006470625288784504,
0.42855557799339294,
0.590351402759552,
0.6778749227523804,
1.0430948734283447,
-0.2606515884399414,
0.7617079615592957,
-0.521629810333252,
0.2651998996734619,
0.9950619339942932,
-0.08283921331167221,
0.27826347947120667,
0.5875881910324097,
-0.31513673067092896,
0.10025510936975479,
0.6578196287155151,
0.10085812956094742,
0.9003638625144958,
0.08736345171928406,
-0.7296032905578613,
-0.5672861337661743,
-0.4326878488063812,
-0.43921026587486267,
0.07142015546560287,
-0.051062554121017456,
-0.03715778514742851,
-0.34704840183258057,
0.4022434949874878,
-0.14861737191677094,
0.20867106318473816,
-0.42471590638160706,
1.131897211074829,
0.006874758284538984,
-0.8221619725227356,
0.42178621888160706,
-0.10093791037797928,
0.718135416507721,
-0.5344167351722717,
-0.07981149107217789,
-0.6111630201339722,
-0.12035685032606125,
0.07600901275873184,
-0.5163350105285645,
-0.08384697884321213,
0.1879129707813263,
-0.4532325267791748,
-0.47886401414871216,
0.6747732162475586,
-0.8448741436004639,
-0.4476393759250641,
-0.1835285723209381,
0.3149947226047516,
-0.061494600027799606,
0.019411569461226463,
-0.1746639758348465,
-0.2087196260690689,
0.13102898001670837,
-0.042409684509038925,
0.40846553444862366,
0.7971281409263611,
0.3180449903011322,
0.7809591293334961,
0.7010030746459961,
0.1522269994020462,
0.198203444480896,
0.2715166509151459,
1.076164960861206,
-0.5114693641662598,
-0.6476171016693115,
-0.886754035949707,
0.36039072275161743,
0.134739488363266,
-0.3658853769302368,
0.9239859580993652,
0.3687933087348938,
0.9295585751533508,
-0.2680281400680542,
0.9133046269416809,
0.047551874071359634,
0.5705125331878662,
-0.7387397885322571,
0.8892430663108826,
-0.2411518394947052,
0.3372863233089447,
-0.17577175796031952,
-0.7828978300094604,
0.15848276019096375,
0.42179080843925476,
-0.0014180755242705345,
-0.03879589959979057,
0.16903679072856903,
0.7688851952552795,
0.15005585551261902,
0.16246554255485535,
0.42178231477737427,
0.184528648853302,
0.40480804443359375,
0.2954656183719635,
1.0571699142456055,
0.06928884238004684,
0.39268365502357483,
-0.5824804306030273,
-0.29101526737213135,
-0.06963778287172318,
-0.8874800205230713,
-0.8597313761711121,
-0.66410893201828,
-0.5849349498748779,
-0.07080714404582977,
-0.061602186411619186,
0.8663146495819092,
0.5165862441062927,
-0.6577192544937134,
0.2921788990497589,
-0.3508864939212799,
0.31366994976997375,
-0.0945197194814682,
-0.2833437919616699,
0.3980282247066498,
-0.8806867003440857,
-0.81343013048172,
0.411227822303772,
-0.30170491337776184,
0.21822209656238556,
-0.14068302512168884,
-0.21362988650798798,
0.3372111916542053,
-0.23692968487739563,
0.49621832370758057,
0.09925192594528198,
-0.4669080078601837,
-0.1915265917778015,
0.11470135301351547,
-0.029151011258363724,
-0.2525050640106201,
0.9108809232711792,
-1.021767020225525,
0.8349041938781738,
0.3629720211029053,
0.6173092126846313,
0.21097253262996674,
0.10794922709465027,
0.4841245412826538,
-1.1800774335861206,
0.06380722671747208,
0.10311641544103622,
-0.02671600878238678,
0.26463618874549866,
-0.4033103883266449,
0.09152273088693619,
0.37551385164260864,
-0.5069394111633301,
-0.9056980609893799,
0.1710391789674759,
-0.8265030980110168,
-0.24109189212322235,
1.030808448791504,
-0.2456376552581787,
0.16909503936767578,
-0.08748886734247208,
-0.44462719559669495,
0.5873435735702515,
-0.5435256958007812,
0.9592693448066711,
0.7295195460319519,
0.3066162168979645,
-0.3615850806236267,
-0.3744153082370758,
1.014650583267212,
0.31445130705833435,
-0.5847231149673462,
0.40013474225997925,
0.6169372797012329,
0.3580521047115326,
-0.33400100469589233,
0.36939048767089844,
0.3717814087867737,
0.17489022016525269,
-0.05876621603965759,
0.0538945347070694,
-0.34186848998069763,
-0.4695817530155182,
-0.4505622386932373,
0.13971947133541107,
0.37490227818489075,
-0.1679973602294922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12840v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12840v1 | ArabicMMLU: Assessing Massive Multitask Language Understanding in Arabic | 2024-02-20T09:07:41 | 2024-02-20T09:07:41 | Fajri Koto, Haonan Li, Sara Shatnawi, Jad Doughman, Abdelrahman Boda Sadallah, Aisha Alraeesi, Khalid Almubarak, Zaid Alyafeai, Neha Sengupta, Shady Shehata, Nizar Habash, Preslav Nakov, Timothy Baldwin | cs.CL | cs.CL | The focus of language model evaluation has transitioned towards reasoning and
knowledge-intensive tasks, driven by advancements in pretraining large models.
While state-of-the-art models are partially trained on large Arabic texts,
evaluating their performance in Arabic remains challenging due to the limited
availability of relevant datasets. To bridge this gap, we present ArabicMMLU,
the first multi-task language understanding benchmark for Arabic language,
sourced from school exams across diverse educational levels in different
countries spanning North Africa, the Levant, and the Gulf regions. Our data
comprises 40 tasks and 14,575 multiple-choice questions in Modern Standard
Arabic (MSA), and is carefully constructed by collaborating with native
speakers in the region. Our comprehensive evaluations of 35 models reveal
substantial room for improvement, particularly among the best open-source
models. Notably, BLOOMZ, mT0, LLama2, and Falcon struggle to achieve a score of
50%, while even the top-performing Arabic-centric model only achieves a score
of 62.3%. | [
-0.4875730872154236,
-0.648808479309082,
0.5194094777107239,
0.24471579492092133,
-0.1872984617948532,
0.20570892095565796,
-0.2074824869632721,
-0.3321368992328644,
-0.27942773699760437,
0.23034028708934784,
-0.6072672009468079,
-0.6855964660644531,
-1.027451992034912,
0.06745442748069763,
-0.30658578872680664,
1.0445815324783325,
-0.38795310258865356,
-0.00411642761901021,
-0.1393684297800064,
-0.6341348886489868,
-0.3570123612880707,
-0.44187647104263306,
-0.5052562952041626,
-0.38072115182876587,
0.5929763317108154,
0.550392746925354,
0.7429982423782349,
0.31220743060112,
0.21529819071292877,
0.20564788579940796,
0.012105760164558887,
0.28079184889793396,
-0.3659636080265045,
-0.11246486008167267,
0.020851870998740196,
-0.18080095946788788,
-0.3528428077697754,
0.035793501883745193,
0.5742061138153076,
0.7490164041519165,
-0.16210326552391052,
0.570203423500061,
-0.027742881327867508,
0.9026515483856201,
-1.076965093612671,
0.2869936525821686,
-0.477407842874527,
-0.050810277462005615,
-0.36003735661506653,
0.28692418336868286,
-0.2906918525695801,
-0.05122631415724754,
-0.03157752752304077,
-0.3783126771450043,
-0.23659077286720276,
-0.2862338721752167,
0.5926823616027832,
0.0882837250828743,
-0.8088411688804626,
-0.38483965396881104,
-0.43497583270072937,
0.8669400215148926,
-0.5192069411277771,
0.5629909634590149,
0.686126172542572,
0.5367522835731506,
0.0003915173001587391,
-0.40454092621803284,
-0.43415775895118713,
-0.3516450524330139,
0.16599203646183014,
0.1883220672607422,
-0.09845040738582611,
-0.06809430569410324,
0.0013754242099821568,
0.3145267367362976,
-0.8231607675552368,
-0.18593662977218628,
-0.10412545502185822,
-0.18167990446090698,
0.4703574478626251,
0.11633700132369995,
0.2550356984138489,
0.20445647835731506,
-0.15399549901485443,
-0.0224591176956892,
-0.695077657699585,
0.2695242762565613,
0.39722582697868347,
0.11626515537500381,
-0.2202141284942627,
0.5082043409347534,
-0.2657559812068939,
0.8647661209106445,
-0.5500625371932983,
-0.25856029987335205,
0.2654716372489929,
-0.5680201053619385,
-0.25461649894714355,
-0.15295644104480743,
0.5551210641860962,
0.12022754549980164,
0.29246076941490173,
-0.052609607577323914,
-0.2348669469356537,
0.16435006260871887,
0.24825437366962433,
-0.9302969574928284,
-0.20068612694740295,
0.3660470247268677,
-0.22412405908107758,
0.2523822486400604,
-0.22755229473114014,
-0.314085453748703,
-0.3103436231613159,
-0.24895773828029633,
0.36402565240859985,
-0.35559791326522827,
-0.3596126139163971,
0.20578429102897644,
0.28082871437072754,
-0.015836074948310852,
0.3937722444534302,
-0.6120519042015076,
0.15407881140708923,
0.5878828167915344,
0.9342235922813416,
-0.00030342215904965997,
-0.6124991774559021,
-0.40558522939682007,
-0.10832645744085312,
-0.2946915924549103,
0.6096012592315674,
-0.7311713695526123,
-0.28528669476509094,
0.06544424593448639,
-0.3186587691307068,
-0.4405020773410797,
-0.5612778067588806,
0.766241729259491,
-0.6019359827041626,
-0.29126864671707153,
-0.2703278064727783,
-0.3488755524158478,
-0.6498730182647705,
0.42345595359802246,
-0.6094322204589844,
0.99689120054245,
0.2981087863445282,
-0.5322357416152954,
0.282591313123703,
-0.794052004814148,
-0.3596367835998535,
-0.10173641890287399,
0.025243820622563362,
-0.14207249879837036,
-0.03722555562853813,
0.3869878053665161,
0.2809448540210724,
-0.29837915301322937,
0.257254421710968,
-0.13257074356079102,
-0.27929356694221497,
0.2285042107105255,
-0.4292134642601013,
0.5933871865272522,
0.49224188923835754,
-0.24717429280281067,
0.3246903121471405,
-0.5906699299812317,
0.1784292757511139,
0.006042348220944405,
-0.2838968336582184,
-0.285861074924469,
-0.2440645694732666,
0.4805919826030731,
0.6135596036911011,
0.3140583336353302,
-0.46546652913093567,
0.10273554176092148,
-0.22987544536590576,
0.2089604288339615,
0.3988671898841858,
-0.5130227208137512,
0.09502949565649033,
-0.40377146005630493,
0.6757947206497192,
0.2071639597415924,
0.03350553661584854,
-0.26517778635025024,
-0.6083590388298035,
-0.6722728610038757,
-0.3028368353843689,
0.2902267277240753,
0.3373054563999176,
-0.4633055329322815,
0.03786072880029678,
-0.0930163711309433,
-0.9099348187446594,
-0.8764584064483643,
0.458779901266098,
0.5244390368461609,
0.07316407561302185,
0.2765796184539795,
-0.3019256293773651,
-0.15895390510559082,
-0.9167969822883606,
-0.34950610995292664,
0.07787670195102692,
0.15003539621829987,
0.41420602798461914,
0.7807572484016418,
-0.3703497052192688,
0.3759002685546875,
-0.31742948293685913,
-0.36300036311149597,
-0.438681036233902,
0.4587528705596924,
0.3210265636444092,
0.2744070887565613,
0.6630256175994873,
-0.5593129992485046,
-0.5577379465103149,
0.12315544486045837,
-0.5224171280860901,
0.06275444477796555,
0.08538362383842468,
-0.1301397681236267,
0.07672348618507385,
0.15691375732421875,
-0.7401947379112244,
0.315356969833374,
0.9502543210983276,
-0.5236898064613342,
0.8558337688446045,
-0.10456918179988861,
0.36426109075546265,
-0.7425386905670166,
0.41426751017570496,
-0.09448493272066116,
-0.18750964105129242,
-0.8028942346572876,
0.47305670380592346,
0.3189939558506012,
-0.09174831211566925,
-0.5495417714118958,
0.7012324929237366,
-0.4281858801841736,
-0.09150326997041702,
-0.41818666458129883,
0.160112664103508,
-0.14676672220230103,
0.43950194120407104,
-0.34033939242362976,
1.1623185873031616,
0.5124251246452332,
-0.4423888325691223,
0.04149310663342476,
0.05550342798233032,
-0.9553470015525818,
0.2091337889432907,
-0.4722500145435333,
0.41147732734680176,
-0.17769555747509003,
0.16899417340755463,
-1.143671989440918,
0.04286576434969902,
0.036171719431877136,
-0.18377533555030823,
-0.030487651005387306,
-0.03410737216472626,
-0.5150083899497986,
-0.17301565408706665,
0.06785232573747635,
0.7948434948921204,
-0.011197902262210846,
-0.3875598907470703,
0.7711995840072632,
0.3927655816078186,
-0.22184213995933533,
-1.0834404230117798,
-0.14708569645881653,
0.11098645627498627,
0.10969667881727219,
-0.5806938409805298,
0.005245243199169636,
-0.21911203861236572,
-0.3914337158203125,
-0.24162548780441284,
-0.2924821078777313,
-0.2841302752494812,
0.47003671526908875,
0.40015578269958496,
-0.032321762293577194,
-0.3280520737171173,
0.032034553587436676,
0.0818222388625145,
0.0639776736497879,
0.12309709936380386,
-0.03784364461898804,
0.740222156047821,
-0.23870128393173218,
-0.5310201644897461,
-0.30185598134994507,
0.2753811478614807,
1.0639207363128662,
-0.7035367488861084,
0.9761159420013428,
0.7023230195045471,
-0.4112204909324646,
-0.0071035949513316154,
-0.34062090516090393,
0.11638334393501282,
-0.3782691955566406,
0.7276991605758667,
-0.7863118648529053,
-0.7193281054496765,
0.4760177433490753,
0.0334722101688385,
0.5236253142356873,
0.48295772075653076,
0.7137624025344849,
0.16626319289207458,
1.2071969509124756,
0.4418594241142273,
-0.4412706196308136,
-0.08364377170801163,
-0.06847947835922241,
0.007731263991445303,
-0.5285864472389221,
-0.12599757313728333,
-0.5472891330718994,
-0.3101606070995331,
0.05517556518316269,
-0.5172420740127563,
0.34364956617355347,
0.053248628973960876,
-0.13596612215042114,
0.1711883246898651,
0.2584836781024933,
0.4447677433490753,
0.23230788111686707,
-0.09578211605548859,
0.3028979003429413,
-0.21918389201164246,
-0.3038662374019623,
0.17654895782470703,
-0.49693113565444946,
-0.5804564952850342,
1.2776837348937988,
0.2630198299884796,
0.33291298151016235,
0.510606050491333,
0.3451676070690155,
0.26552319526672363,
0.6062527894973755,
-0.8393614888191223,
0.2633042633533478,
-0.04474421963095665,
-0.7206293344497681,
-0.2118113934993744,
-0.35622143745422363,
-1.0065869092941284,
0.6964926719665527,
0.06697211414575577,
-0.6315112113952637,
-0.5306879878044128,
-0.08630326390266418,
-0.33804407715797424,
0.09422197192907333,
-0.6703755855560303,
1.221445083618164,
-0.10919491201639175,
-0.0938185453414917,
-0.7170051336288452,
-0.29310551285743713,
0.6837167739868164,
-0.3467325270175934,
0.6009413599967957,
-0.48721686005592346,
-0.008070923388004303,
0.9269483685493469,
-0.24789197742938995,
0.3087211549282074,
-0.21650710701942444,
-0.16391119360923767,
0.2148156315088272,
0.15574882924556732,
0.20409706234931946,
-0.07228924334049225,
-0.14160524308681488,
0.2080455720424652,
0.25391095876693726,
-0.7483064532279968,
-0.5786445736885071,
0.7492002248764038,
-1.016961693763733,
-0.42737218737602234,
-0.43854275345802307,
-1.0878592729568481,
-0.343005508184433,
0.060968197882175446,
-0.2573615312576294,
0.4875984787940979,
-0.2358323633670807,
-0.08024228364229202,
-0.0410408079624176,
0.0026525326538830996,
0.3120580315589905,
0.7627003788948059,
-0.45836639404296875,
-0.106780506670475,
0.8065431714057922,
0.09149561077356339,
0.1094110980629921,
0.03592509403824806,
0.07355283945798874,
-0.411933034658432,
-0.6607019901275635,
-0.9289582967758179,
0.30933427810668945,
-0.809316873550415,
0.04361821711063385,
-0.773566722869873,
-0.11196330189704895,
-0.165616974234581,
0.13128039240837097,
-0.4718708097934723,
-0.053688809275627136,
-0.007811743300408125,
-0.005881177727133036,
0.0657225176692009,
1.0094276666641235,
0.24926875531673431,
0.3562396764755249,
-1.0596646070480347,
0.16883321106433868,
0.17268463969230652,
0.20288781821727753,
0.30073803663253784,
-0.7524365186691284,
-0.5594942569732666,
0.026792095974087715,
-0.3379577100276947,
-0.8157467842102051,
0.41013509035110474,
0.4220222234725952,
0.46974486112594604,
0.640080451965332,
-0.1090073361992836,
0.7983104586601257,
-0.5596070885658264,
0.5717570185661316,
-0.06610166281461716,
-1.0217418670654297,
0.2092103809118271,
-0.06311438232660294,
0.9025267958641052,
0.7252597212791443,
0.6812069416046143,
-0.8166064620018005,
-0.4547699987888336,
-0.18769913911819458,
-0.5783060789108276,
0.5985459685325623,
0.30628788471221924,
0.08663636445999146,
0.34968188405036926,
0.13584306836128235,
0.4857732653617859,
0.21638916432857513,
-0.3602086305618286,
-0.7088823318481445,
-0.025141702964901924,
-0.3808361291885376,
-0.5706117749214172,
-0.30821505188941956,
-0.1586364507675171,
-0.2751547396183014,
0.6031476259231567,
-0.17932802438735962,
-0.0872933641076088,
-0.38066303730010986,
-0.641741156578064,
0.05119161680340767,
0.43024930357933044,
0.9905022978782654,
1.2685211896896362,
-0.155203714966774,
0.3031761050224304,
0.10066454857587814,
-0.8592479825019836,
0.26180195808410645,
0.31377872824668884,
0.10568951070308685,
0.03126390278339386,
0.3012072443962097,
0.5683855414390564,
0.24207520484924316,
-1.0651249885559082,
0.3987443149089813,
-0.1897106170654297,
-0.19437649846076965,
-0.13951627910137177,
-0.02980562299489975,
0.2033873051404953,
0.0654921606183052,
0.49569323658943176,
0.03652883693575859,
0.06357079744338989,
-0.5530820488929749,
0.26951977610588074,
0.3783648610115051,
-0.3981423079967499,
-0.4273338317871094,
0.4266476333141327,
-0.0042964620515704155,
-0.01894334703683853,
0.48932257294654846,
-0.2323036640882492,
-0.5702474117279053,
0.6566494107246399,
0.3838264048099518,
0.4324953556060791,
-0.37667030096054077,
0.2924835681915283,
0.5967809557914734,
0.4467441439628601,
0.1659972369670868,
0.6685760617256165,
-0.22380533814430237,
-0.8187616467475891,
-0.5811981558799744,
-0.622712254524231,
-0.5886595845222473,
0.45547112822532654,
-0.476589560508728,
-0.1931568682193756,
-0.35638436675071716,
-0.07499570399522781,
0.0946085974574089,
0.24504756927490234,
-0.8005194664001465,
0.28733471035957336,
0.07360481470823288,
1.012109398841858,
-0.9874241352081299,
1.1574935913085938,
0.8494308590888977,
-0.2036161720752716,
-0.48661723732948303,
-0.2664489150047302,
0.23216183483600616,
-0.9800000786781311,
0.6665112972259521,
0.6662421226501465,
-0.22189898788928986,
-0.018755322322249413,
-0.061721108853816986,
-0.9542156457901001,
0.6862085461616516,
0.25758445262908936,
-0.4938115179538727,
0.3028219938278198,
0.15391528606414795,
0.16693493723869324,
-0.24513471126556396,
0.8582407832145691,
0.8246240019798279,
0.5556578636169434,
-0.18837203085422516,
-0.9039746522903442,
-0.173569455742836,
-0.4069860577583313,
-0.5855798125267029,
0.2707504332065582,
-0.4488794803619385,
0.854367196559906,
-0.2581202983856201,
-0.36533215641975403,
0.14882494509220123,
0.7569411993026733,
0.38050878047943115,
0.4282320737838745,
0.632447361946106,
0.6594148874282837,
0.7727749943733215,
-0.0261058509349823,
0.8505833745002747,
-0.5390098690986633,
0.19146648049354553,
1.1297303438186646,
-0.3083559274673462,
1.0014170408248901,
0.30082276463508606,
-0.4324324429035187,
0.3578377664089203,
0.5590723156929016,
0.4758790135383606,
0.3380594849586487,
0.18917573988437653,
-0.49069103598594666,
-0.39474940299987793,
-0.3784320652484894,
-0.37577593326568604,
0.7797008752822876,
0.5134091973304749,
-0.011234521865844727,
-0.47000524401664734,
0.13741646707057953,
0.1768546998500824,
0.03301063925027847,
-0.3616809546947479,
0.30147287249565125,
0.11477351933717728,
-0.673785388469696,
0.7674615383148193,
0.24484537541866302,
0.45779523253440857,
-0.6327319145202637,
0.03200988098978996,
-0.28463926911354065,
0.13838709890842438,
0.001764951623044908,
-0.7446157336235046,
0.2803994417190552,
0.14686526358127594,
0.00799818616360426,
0.0820358619093895,
0.33936038613319397,
-0.5929403305053711,
-0.5124369263648987,
0.3827400803565979,
0.7538365125656128,
0.4494999051094055,
-0.45189404487609863,
-0.7962900400161743,
0.12812936305999756,
-0.2834908068180084,
-0.015682417899370193,
0.45059624314308167,
0.03061610646545887,
0.2532806694507599,
0.7532551288604736,
0.6821103096008301,
-0.14007332921028137,
0.016608797013759613,
0.27772337198257446,
0.5563716292381287,
-0.4812607765197754,
-0.31377410888671875,
-0.8131782412528992,
0.29698997735977173,
0.3218841552734375,
-0.6720432043075562,
0.9170321226119995,
0.6202676296234131,
0.8588026762008667,
-0.09077312052249908,
0.7036147713661194,
0.3645801246166229,
0.2026865929365158,
-0.42282864451408386,
1.1729809045791626,
-0.8246335387229919,
-0.3403420150279999,
-0.06727125495672226,
-0.9135795831680298,
-0.06405708938837051,
0.4206679165363312,
-0.24901726841926575,
0.04829715937376022,
0.7388238310813904,
0.7162875533103943,
-0.04189196974039078,
0.14757591485977173,
0.6898602843284607,
0.02808992564678192,
0.08837735652923584,
0.946615993976593,
0.9185566306114197,
-0.4841000437736511,
0.45482686161994934,
-0.23493929207324982,
-0.1497369110584259,
-0.1604042947292328,
-0.4796326160430908,
-1.015305995941162,
-0.6733036637306213,
-0.2583649456501007,
-0.040871985256671906,
0.0238355565816164,
1.0025041103363037,
0.6657213568687439,
-1.0638477802276611,
-0.6058836579322815,
0.31835973262786865,
0.1601918488740921,
-0.5643354654312134,
-0.07043218612670898,
0.4903929531574249,
-0.2689846158027649,
-0.6740628480911255,
0.6752069592475891,
0.10594453662633896,
-0.25720471143722534,
-0.2319825291633606,
-0.1886642873287201,
-0.5092240571975708,
-0.06300919502973557,
0.7662274837493896,
0.22949686646461487,
-0.8308678865432739,
-0.021705275401473045,
-0.12038842588663101,
-0.31320956349372864,
-0.003136879066005349,
0.645735502243042,
-0.5611158609390259,
0.5054394006729126,
0.12462043762207031,
0.8805768489837646,
0.4331763684749603,
-0.2643779516220093,
0.32418471574783325,
-0.31235969066619873,
0.03817068040370941,
-0.10016358643770218,
0.4474351704120636,
0.25150904059410095,
0.10753163695335388,
0.3245909810066223,
-0.10811937600374222,
-0.4778236448764801,
-0.5728641152381897,
0.21621131896972656,
-0.6936811208724976,
-0.21239939332008362,
0.9873028993606567,
-0.4573148787021637,
-0.09393942356109619,
-0.44553402066230774,
-0.2578533887863159,
0.2030239701271057,
-0.32953688502311707,
0.7016188502311707,
1.0395976305007935,
0.2085420936346054,
-0.2748393416404724,
-0.909785270690918,
0.2580416202545166,
0.8894520998001099,
-0.8596096634864807,
0.02379153110086918,
0.3058454394340515,
0.06821791082620621,
-0.012431380338966846,
0.5299331545829773,
0.23790690302848816,
0.5244699716567993,
-0.11803362518548965,
-0.07782509177923203,
-0.04967225715517998,
-0.5955227017402649,
-0.412422239780426,
0.34985703229904175,
0.40490296483039856,
-0.2586348354816437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12835v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12835v2 | PANDA: Preference Adaptation for Enhancing Domain-Specific Abilities of LLMs | 2024-02-20T09:02:55 | 2024-06-18T03:08:37 | An Liu, Zonghan Yang, Zhenhe Zhang, Qingyuan Hu, Peng Li, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated considerable
capabilities across various natural language tasks, they often fall short of
the performance achieved by domain-specific state-of-the-art models. One
potential approach to enhance domain-specific capabilities of LLMs involves
fine-tuning them using corresponding datasets. However, this method can be both
resource and time-intensive, and not applicable to closed-source commercial
LLMs. In this paper, we propose Preference Adaptation for Enhancing
Domain-specific Abilities of LLMs (PANDA), a method designed to augment the
domain-specific capabilities of LLMs by leveraging insights from the response
preference of expert models without requiring fine-tuning. Our experimental
results reveal that PANDA significantly enhances the domain-specific ability of
LLMs on text classification and interactive decision tasks. Moreover, LLM with
PANDA even outperforms the expert model that being learned on 4 tasks of
ScienceWorld. This finding highlights the potential of exploring tuning-free
approaches to achieve weak-to-strong generalization. | [
-0.3181164562702179,
-0.7351176142692566,
0.2966305911540985,
0.41805383563041687,
-0.39568763971328735,
0.11669604480266571,
-0.648377001285553,
-0.2839055061340332,
0.2522699534893036,
0.712306797504425,
-0.44601863622665405,
-0.3866591155529022,
-0.6689202785491943,
0.3267792761325836,
0.08101315051317215,
1.3201360702514648,
-0.11736742407083511,
-0.12982478737831116,
-0.5832512974739075,
0.017699575051665306,
-0.40611177682876587,
-0.5293245315551758,
-0.577824056148529,
-0.18385827541351318,
0.37622249126434326,
0.427369087934494,
0.6268847584724426,
0.5170379281044006,
0.6607276797294617,
0.23129098117351532,
-0.10674348473548889,
0.49247464537620544,
-0.6164669990539551,
0.16031353175640106,
-0.5716671943664551,
-0.8105528354644775,
-0.9381436109542847,
-0.12342241406440735,
0.48884886503219604,
0.6912947297096252,
0.04341031238436699,
0.10281150043010712,
0.3728242814540863,
0.863353431224823,
-0.5232412815093994,
0.47268936038017273,
-0.9039084911346436,
0.01896391622722149,
-0.04747336357831955,
-0.6270182728767395,
-0.3115193247795105,
-0.1741727888584137,
0.39869049191474915,
-1.148216724395752,
0.394357830286026,
0.18390055000782013,
0.5147261023521423,
0.5876891613006592,
-0.24047625064849854,
0.051985982805490494,
-0.5130887031555176,
0.903488039970398,
-0.6108266115188599,
0.1504230797290802,
0.4842650294303894,
0.11403407156467438,
-0.3614330589771271,
-0.24180179834365845,
-0.49739012122154236,
-0.20744070410728455,
0.0995817556977272,
0.07460473477840424,
0.007148062810301781,
0.0984378382563591,
0.21535652875900269,
0.22147908806800842,
-0.3634985089302063,
0.25762468576431274,
0.013346860185265541,
0.008002583868801594,
0.5517037510871887,
0.23877239227294922,
0.03209418058395386,
-0.18392616510391235,
-0.06047898903489113,
-0.0067422338761389256,
-0.47770118713378906,
0.30604469776153564,
0.15234124660491943,
0.5959032773971558,
-0.08070426434278488,
0.6038569211959839,
-0.43302085995674133,
0.762324333190918,
0.39848193526268005,
-0.19978760182857513,
0.23047509789466858,
-0.26089468598365784,
-0.2501658797264099,
-0.1611403375864029,
0.3635513186454773,
0.4200283885002136,
0.39780911803245544,
-0.20261451601982117,
-0.03495369106531143,
-0.07963158190250397,
0.20346233248710632,
-0.8898270726203918,
-0.37439897656440735,
0.17158319056034088,
-0.46904271841049194,
-0.2408907562494278,
-0.4301946759223938,
-0.7258907556533813,
-0.6602429151535034,
-0.4766143262386322,
0.2115774154663086,
-0.23616506159305573,
-0.4591609239578247,
0.38006436824798584,
-0.143550306558609,
-0.05981820449233055,
0.6110135316848755,
-1.292794108390808,
0.37490564584732056,
0.7158162593841553,
0.7274553179740906,
-0.8316094875335693,
-0.31006279587745667,
-0.6834703683853149,
0.29405972361564636,
-0.3059850335121155,
1.1241308450698853,
-0.9162617325782776,
-0.5122509002685547,
-0.2144387811422348,
0.16480039060115814,
-0.16909243166446686,
-0.7938644289970398,
0.6389403939247131,
-0.6524982452392578,
-0.188432514667511,
-0.2639833688735962,
-0.4802505373954773,
-0.10713142901659012,
-0.023796644061803818,
-0.5642219185829163,
0.8346746563911438,
0.306124746799469,
-0.6715679168701172,
0.6608732342720032,
-0.9495835304260254,
-0.539340615272522,
0.007041653152555227,
0.17586125433444977,
-0.4173663258552551,
0.13255278766155243,
0.4359355568885803,
0.8001478314399719,
-0.11512893438339233,
0.07604125142097473,
-0.805573046207428,
-0.07473137229681015,
0.37615785002708435,
-0.10615497827529907,
0.5870538353919983,
-0.02693474479019642,
0.09900088608264923,
0.4131649136543274,
-0.8523058891296387,
-0.08997326344251633,
0.22139596939086914,
-0.5299984812736511,
-0.6064768433570862,
0.18491660058498383,
-0.17894597351551056,
-0.2978210747241974,
0.4175015389919281,
-0.13828206062316895,
0.4839676022529602,
-0.3372638523578644,
0.2599128484725952,
1.0436441898345947,
-0.12974746525287628,
0.7697255611419678,
-0.38993680477142334,
0.40175139904022217,
0.07506491988897324,
-0.1197066381573677,
0.24485407769680023,
-0.36584898829460144,
-0.9857624769210815,
-0.4491770565509796,
0.4821416735649109,
0.5181689262390137,
-0.8285048007965088,
0.5802934169769287,
-0.5368258953094482,
-0.28079521656036377,
-0.5476964116096497,
0.6234034299850464,
-0.032004568725824356,
0.43001946806907654,
0.48375409841537476,
-0.5652887225151062,
-0.3441145718097687,
-0.6403031945228577,
-0.27525272965431213,
-0.08997397124767303,
-0.20610854029655457,
0.754742443561554,
0.20081333816051483,
-0.1456373929977417,
1.053655743598938,
-0.7622050046920776,
-0.389615923166275,
-0.32004493474960327,
-0.17683465778827667,
0.3248441517353058,
0.1572464257478714,
0.7062886357307434,
-0.8110679388046265,
-0.652201235294342,
0.007337863091379404,
-0.5380014777183533,
-0.2322828620672226,
0.017071731388568878,
-0.1350330412387848,
0.3500747084617615,
0.03507303074002266,
-0.3729476034641266,
0.10804365575313568,
0.43095436692237854,
-0.24470385909080505,
0.5541797280311584,
-0.3044632375240326,
0.0009203245863318443,
-0.8111165165901184,
-0.15993133187294006,
0.25777068734169006,
-0.1793449968099594,
-0.7042537927627563,
-0.24686597287654877,
0.18555356562137604,
0.17050272226333618,
-0.2606867551803589,
0.6570738554000854,
-0.28734198212623596,
-0.13513080775737762,
-0.5077157616615295,
0.061940714716911316,
-0.04136597737669945,
0.5305127501487732,
0.5659978985786438,
0.9365681409835815,
0.8402701020240784,
-1.084474802017212,
0.37066420912742615,
0.4195442497730255,
-0.3702380657196045,
0.617084801197052,
-0.3749890923500061,
0.0501723438501358,
0.03364182636141777,
0.1914590746164322,
-0.5059376358985901,
-0.3014751970767975,
0.191269189119339,
-0.27823367714881897,
0.3868900239467621,
-0.07358880341053009,
-0.25554704666137695,
0.006280332338064909,
-0.3742479979991913,
0.14136207103729248,
0.27553391456604004,
-0.8203774094581604,
0.5426726341247559,
0.36156928539276123,
-0.6430565714836121,
-0.4496805965900421,
-0.26243460178375244,
0.14211033284664154,
-0.3819485008716583,
-0.4708554446697235,
0.4008767306804657,
-0.4860566258430481,
-0.04798530787229538,
-0.03859993442893028,
-0.02054748125374317,
0.10077540576457977,
0.35038718581199646,
0.08397471904754639,
0.22339659929275513,
-0.28305238485336304,
0.06486890465021133,
0.2736855745315552,
-0.1813940852880478,
-0.13216830790042877,
-0.12839952111244202,
0.13630524277687073,
0.017215171828866005,
0.031218476593494415,
-0.16065634787082672,
0.11654074490070343,
0.3984663188457489,
-0.2595558166503906,
0.5458267331123352,
0.4368504285812378,
-0.11914242804050446,
-0.6995253562927246,
-0.20962384343147278,
-0.20391765236854553,
-0.5323283672332764,
0.5314387679100037,
-0.5661957263946533,
-1.0021957159042358,
0.05127658694982529,
-0.499769926071167,
-0.14576058089733124,
0.22045086324214935,
0.5798474550247192,
0.04673493281006813,
0.9304330348968506,
0.9509680271148682,
-0.4049164056777954,
0.5806724429130554,
-0.000998661620542407,
0.16736002266407013,
-1.096846580505371,
0.011846678331494331,
-0.47194644808769226,
-0.06760110706090927,
-0.3527887761592865,
-0.3536878228187561,
0.36401745676994324,
-0.018385818228125572,
-0.12215913832187653,
0.2516902983188629,
-0.5353642106056213,
0.379568874835968,
0.40795382857322693,
0.22835013270378113,
0.3409084677696228,
0.37815743684768677,
0.09766620397567749,
-0.11693363636732101,
-0.7097441554069519,
-0.39380505681037903,
1.29636812210083,
0.2079925537109375,
0.906988263130188,
0.11548678576946259,
0.14412133395671844,
0.5886384844779968,
0.3294160068035126,
-0.8493445515632629,
0.567537248134613,
-0.4602521061897278,
-0.23403698205947876,
-0.4528311491012573,
-0.3704012334346771,
-0.7711426019668579,
0.15170665085315704,
-0.5550601482391357,
-0.3979761004447937,
0.16343238949775696,
-0.017314627766609192,
-0.3840765058994293,
0.09837323427200317,
-0.5663493275642395,
0.4741087853908539,
-0.3364154100418091,
-0.3910166621208191,
-0.3539569079875946,
-0.16381926834583282,
0.08593298494815826,
-0.5158725380897522,
0.0076117441058158875,
-0.37110641598701477,
-0.32858806848526,
0.8471909165382385,
0.193720743060112,
1.105634331703186,
-0.10433326661586761,
-0.15527556836605072,
-0.10262536257505417,
0.08014996349811554,
0.4236741364002228,
0.11832746118307114,
-0.3788103461265564,
0.21887977421283722,
-0.15970008075237274,
-0.40164506435394287,
-0.727197527885437,
0.8147918581962585,
-1.0487377643585205,
-1.0585699081420898,
-0.2852303683757782,
-0.6328185796737671,
-0.5808563828468323,
0.20998546481132507,
-0.296036958694458,
0.02328863926231861,
-0.2309502512216568,
0.03802389279007912,
0.7008266448974609,
-0.11888467520475388,
0.29104310274124146,
0.8312832117080688,
-0.12681427597999573,
-0.38454338908195496,
1.1559898853302002,
-0.10343579947948456,
0.2097073644399643,
0.5060760974884033,
0.11364125460386276,
-0.2885180711746216,
-0.922308623790741,
-0.48217982053756714,
0.16889362037181854,
-0.6730148196220398,
-0.26116785407066345,
-0.666549026966095,
0.003999602515250444,
-0.47246837615966797,
-0.347721666097641,
0.1302841603755951,
-0.6956943273544312,
-0.9523921012878418,
-0.09463554620742798,
0.6758103370666504,
0.34015214443206787,
0.13516947627067566,
0.2820562422275543,
-0.5121631026268005,
0.5943886041641235,
0.5304863452911377,
0.6253325343132019,
-0.22429534792900085,
-0.7969272136688232,
-0.21757060289382935,
-0.08860370516777039,
-0.33925512433052063,
-0.27814745903015137,
0.44477778673171997,
0.5452457070350647,
0.634899377822876,
0.43985581398010254,
0.25008851289749146,
0.513444185256958,
-0.4616168439388275,
0.7600835561752319,
-0.10665750503540039,
-0.9300349354743958,
0.555757999420166,
-0.29638350009918213,
-0.149711474776268,
0.2770928740501404,
0.39704835414886475,
-0.17467989027500153,
-0.12436436861753464,
-0.2211812287569046,
-0.4524126350879669,
0.8631078600883484,
-0.07572399079799652,
0.21934731304645538,
0.31523436307907104,
0.5234367847442627,
0.5093448758125305,
0.12388475984334946,
-0.4747672379016876,
-0.06286969035863876,
-0.4075905382633209,
-0.019012046977877617,
-0.4111490845680237,
-0.0949246734380722,
-0.08346810191869736,
-0.3503653109073639,
0.7927020788192749,
-0.6687880754470825,
0.06285395473241806,
0.007765062153339386,
-0.159876748919487,
-0.31672805547714233,
0.40358108282089233,
0.32675790786743164,
0.6278625130653381,
-0.3158741295337677,
-0.0035500803496688604,
0.5057665109634399,
-0.28650468587875366,
-0.04796209931373596,
0.18222801387310028,
-0.026894191280007362,
-0.36594158411026,
0.10919325798749924,
0.9249096512794495,
0.03609084337949753,
-0.49716806411743164,
0.2961236536502838,
-0.19852344691753387,
-0.021178685128688812,
0.20629365742206573,
0.736801266670227,
0.0657888725399971,
0.2993621528148651,
0.34157201647758484,
0.19855540990829468,
0.059434883296489716,
-0.2744726240634918,
-0.17724809050559998,
0.4970215857028961,
-0.13437575101852417,
-0.34568458795547485,
0.5793256759643555,
0.4546830952167511,
-0.2504163980484009,
0.013052175752818584,
0.14569024741649628,
-0.3742155134677887,
0.6279908418655396,
0.7434131503105164,
0.8247473239898682,
-0.19142189621925354,
0.1435021162033081,
-0.0023775699082762003,
-0.022048022598028183,
0.08980289846658707,
0.13721512258052826,
-0.1314363032579422,
-0.979051947593689,
-0.2920015752315521,
-0.678527295589447,
-0.7931479811668396,
0.06818199157714844,
-0.5201531052589417,
0.3589552044868469,
-0.5509519577026367,
-0.24093787372112274,
0.16844625771045685,
0.26554208993911743,
-0.6150102615356445,
0.17995615303516388,
-0.15824903547763824,
1.0246036052703857,
-0.5867578387260437,
0.9262575507164001,
0.8718389868736267,
-0.0633254423737526,
-0.03432874009013176,
0.03367568552494049,
-0.28986483812332153,
-0.8180755376815796,
0.5451712012290955,
-0.1801651567220688,
-0.12518100440502167,
-0.04252069070935249,
-0.6578021049499512,
-0.664517879486084,
1.0195388793945312,
0.467441201210022,
-0.31452760100364685,
0.332030713558197,
0.27312204241752625,
0.7078601121902466,
-0.6389136910438538,
0.016592709347605705,
0.6469554901123047,
0.43801331520080566,
-0.4442269504070282,
-1.0688722133636475,
0.15987005829811096,
-0.23371343314647675,
0.19033290445804596,
-0.1365162432193756,
-0.8582973480224609,
0.42009225487709045,
-0.5062032341957092,
0.047225918620824814,
-0.006705694831907749,
0.961691677570343,
0.12388017773628235,
0.2634173631668091,
0.7323028445243835,
0.12648504972457886,
0.9996967315673828,
0.2523263096809387,
0.7997841835021973,
-0.3337639570236206,
0.10440954566001892,
0.6944639682769775,
-0.5990248322486877,
0.9699304699897766,
0.2272004634141922,
-0.3738703429698944,
0.3347321152687073,
0.7846068739891052,
0.022466862574219704,
0.7849047183990479,
0.015094699338078499,
-0.3690601587295532,
-0.6250028014183044,
-0.40141570568084717,
-0.35870587825775146,
0.23506604135036469,
0.7732580304145813,
-0.0352289192378521,
0.22406141459941864,
-0.05702387914061546,
-0.20456238090991974,
0.029437579214572906,
-0.47004184126853943,
0.9608955979347229,
0.15554751455783844,
-0.6455170512199402,
0.7832635045051575,
0.0010070084827020764,
0.8708356618881226,
-0.49618667364120483,
0.012693380936980247,
-0.14877453446388245,
0.2624571621417999,
-0.28984808921813965,
-0.8783896565437317,
-0.08164411783218384,
0.04083539918065071,
-0.6011372208595276,
-0.09295699745416641,
0.9563167691230774,
-0.3095141649246216,
-0.36533254384994507,
0.3285507261753082,
0.36114194989204407,
-0.05328228697180748,
-0.0020395126193761826,
-0.6810694336891174,
-0.1493997424840927,
0.012768442742526531,
-0.13607870042324066,
0.7365285158157349,
0.40374428033828735,
-0.019615724682807922,
0.9300387501716614,
0.7936761379241943,
0.33692190051078796,
-0.26816749572753906,
-0.11379442363977432,
1.037954330444336,
-0.5260373950004578,
-0.38417086005210876,
-0.44715550541877747,
0.007569642271846533,
-0.050709184259176254,
-0.18016089498996735,
0.6139018535614014,
0.41504400968551636,
0.8644054532051086,
-0.27973562479019165,
1.3960299491882324,
0.38196438550949097,
0.6529454588890076,
-0.6040225625038147,
0.6501665115356445,
-0.6559830904006958,
0.3395784795284271,
-0.1955866813659668,
-0.9534966945648193,
-0.37032535672187805,
0.40150898694992065,
-0.5132518410682678,
-0.07585206627845764,
0.5776668787002563,
0.8004081845283508,
-0.2557421028614044,
0.09806321561336517,
0.2600359618663788,
0.17950208485126495,
0.29541847109794617,
0.46043381094932556,
0.5593048334121704,
0.34504398703575134,
0.49684831500053406,
-0.13478636741638184,
-0.572207510471344,
-0.37234610319137573,
-1.08724844455719,
-1.220650553703308,
-0.5014590620994568,
-0.33248573541641235,
-0.19808250665664673,
0.1456863433122635,
0.9869124293327332,
0.5035486817359924,
-0.9484751224517822,
-0.026373423635959625,
0.4372805655002594,
0.20404161512851715,
-0.26215261220932007,
-0.19309650361537933,
0.6503328084945679,
-0.49331212043762207,
-0.808424174785614,
0.5299158096313477,
0.3147508203983307,
-0.026770979166030884,
-0.02208915911614895,
-0.1692412793636322,
0.47335514426231384,
0.21650762856006622,
0.703838586807251,
0.20017799735069275,
-0.48132139444351196,
-0.3174048066139221,
0.08547309041023254,
0.14263686537742615,
0.22554972767829895,
0.7730703949928284,
-0.6864271759986877,
0.46085935831069946,
0.37490761280059814,
0.8039846420288086,
0.33181947469711304,
-0.07960876822471619,
0.5000235438346863,
-0.34163013100624084,
-0.14654980599880219,
-0.056638170033693314,
0.31974297761917114,
0.44010719656944275,
-0.5760439038276672,
0.4204399883747101,
0.3009010851383209,
-0.6252824664115906,
-0.5594071745872498,
0.06541034579277039,
-1.2611136436462402,
-0.33681192994117737,
1.5983935594558716,
-0.10449368506669998,
-0.15173664689064026,
-0.362161248922348,
-0.44333189725875854,
0.07905352860689163,
-0.7427487969398499,
1.0880882740020752,
0.574892520904541,
-0.3242509067058563,
0.1672428846359253,
-0.3073876202106476,
0.7574236989021301,
0.6030802130699158,
-0.8402942419052124,
0.38808393478393555,
0.11702195554971695,
0.5246263146400452,
-0.09615455567836761,
0.5912479758262634,
0.3006708025932312,
0.16318142414093018,
-0.5150152444839478,
-0.16457584500312805,
-0.16648873686790466,
-0.30702778697013855,
-0.4674696624279022,
0.016637111082673073,
0.3475610911846161,
0.11370338499546051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12821v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12821v2 | Identifying Factual Inconsistencies in Summaries: Grounding Model Inference via Task Taxonomy | 2024-02-20T08:41:23 | 2024-06-20T03:45:51 | Liyan Xu, Zhenlin Su, Mo Yu, Jin Xu, Jinho D. Choi, Jie Zhou, Fei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Factual inconsistencies pose a significant hurdle for the faithful
summarization by generative models. While a major direction to enhance
inconsistency detection is to derive stronger Natural Language Inference (NLI)
models, we propose an orthogonal aspect that underscores the importance of
incorporating task-specific taxonomy into the inference. To this end, we
consolidate key error types of inconsistent facts in summaries, and incorporate
them to facilitate both the zero-shot and supervised paradigms of LLMs.
Extensive experiments on ten datasets of five distinct domains suggest that,
zero-shot LLM inference could benefit from the explicit solution space depicted
by the error type taxonomy, and achieves state-of-the-art performance overall,
surpassing specialized non-LLM baselines, as well as recent LLM baselines. We
further distill models that fuse the taxonomy into parameters through our
designed prompt completions and supervised training strategies, efficiently
substituting state-of-the-art zero-shot inference with much larger LLMs. | [
0.0418766550719738,
-0.7829495072364807,
0.7805222868919373,
0.1755189448595047,
0.008729194290935993,
0.12255647033452988,
-0.008244385942816734,
-0.28235167264938354,
0.2043667584657669,
0.43895119428634644,
-0.5204067826271057,
-0.639420211315155,
-0.9240846633911133,
0.24690580368041992,
-0.41147786378860474,
1.1011165380477905,
-0.13228003680706024,
-0.2614940106868744,
-0.6073275208473206,
-0.3483581840991974,
-0.3820596933364868,
-0.5101401805877686,
-0.400041401386261,
-0.4074769914150238,
0.5956584215164185,
0.4567486345767975,
0.5291343331336975,
0.6893864274024963,
0.3982701003551483,
0.15548266470432281,
-0.1417824625968933,
0.5814054608345032,
-0.21479745209217072,
0.17437590658664703,
-0.09170792251825333,
-0.8489649295806885,
-0.6691864728927612,
-0.02848813496530056,
0.36908209323883057,
1.1193829774856567,
-0.12285104393959045,
0.07648395746946335,
-0.06641583144664764,
0.4160343408584595,
-0.9317263960838318,
0.3656614422798157,
-0.5709058046340942,
0.2517743706703186,
-0.12139198929071426,
-0.3794671595096588,
-0.4819025695323944,
-0.06502126157283783,
-0.028646521270275116,
-0.557494044303894,
0.6736158132553101,
-0.11671575903892517,
1.0136336088180542,
0.37315940856933594,
-0.6631724238395691,
-0.15767909586429596,
-0.7509757876396179,
0.9262847304344177,
-1.1813082695007324,
0.13029488921165466,
0.23053456842899323,
-0.18499687314033508,
-0.11164747178554535,
-0.37015479803085327,
-0.550584077835083,
-0.18923290073871613,
-0.283043771982193,
0.4369553029537201,
-0.30976602435112,
0.2992298901081085,
0.3766210079193115,
0.3681735098361969,
-0.5476322770118713,
0.24558806419372559,
-0.006435825023800135,
-0.02096341922879219,
0.6184536218643188,
0.40741753578186035,
0.19156178832054138,
-0.3194328546524048,
-0.15036407113075256,
0.1909625232219696,
-0.8964866399765015,
-0.07597561180591583,
0.1650172472000122,
0.42802509665489197,
-0.46537959575653076,
0.8058278560638428,
-0.43932029604911804,
0.9082934260368347,
0.17797395586967468,
-0.5451053977012634,
0.2088117152452469,
-0.37427830696105957,
-0.4683244824409485,
-0.050920985639095306,
0.41027212142944336,
0.45719099044799805,
-0.12376745790243149,
-0.4736088812351227,
-0.19980356097221375,
0.136348158121109,
0.17439891397953033,
-0.34387466311454773,
-0.08178432285785675,
0.5742782354354858,
-0.2205440104007721,
-0.30116233229637146,
-0.005855619441717863,
-0.44233202934265137,
-0.3911726772785187,
-0.6751703023910522,
0.4234110116958618,
-0.1840527504682541,
-0.27511677145957947,
-0.019570477306842804,
-0.46488815546035767,
0.23260167241096497,
0.6526634097099304,
-0.9099905490875244,
0.06292940676212311,
0.8381803631782532,
0.8430919647216797,
-0.252190500497818,
-0.1811160296201706,
-0.3280637264251709,
0.3308185338973999,
-0.5712332725524902,
1.119260311126709,
-0.11930274218320847,
-0.3041088283061981,
0.06108842417597771,
-0.18740995228290558,
-0.254445880651474,
-0.5743787288665771,
0.5257177948951721,
-0.3470297157764435,
0.2563977837562561,
-0.27076250314712524,
-0.9422433376312256,
-0.3464635908603668,
0.5732521414756775,
-0.35305511951446533,
0.8900762796401978,
0.11611782014369965,
-0.9140262007713318,
0.4851217269897461,
-0.4665408730506897,
-0.4572240114212036,
0.025615133345127106,
-0.4086197018623352,
-0.3468102216720581,
0.40287289023399353,
-0.013067536056041718,
0.566413938999176,
-0.2148730307817459,
0.7645738124847412,
-0.30894985795021057,
-0.19507035613059998,
0.012008048593997955,
-0.33868786692619324,
0.8257959485054016,
-0.0492645800113678,
-0.23540861904621124,
0.14735019207000732,
-0.8773650527000427,
-0.37187573313713074,
0.07740159332752228,
-0.17873674631118774,
-0.30456042289733887,
0.2124049812555313,
-0.31181827187538147,
-0.16392767429351807,
0.06729764491319656,
-0.3806389272212982,
0.10686410218477249,
-0.2279309779405594,
0.09181764721870422,
0.3691044747829437,
0.1885661482810974,
0.44931286573410034,
-0.6763125658035278,
0.4155438542366028,
0.24838308990001678,
-0.16583286225795746,
-0.5073638558387756,
-0.5104605555534363,
-0.9962551593780518,
-0.34664276242256165,
0.0726761519908905,
0.8219131827354431,
-0.8403725028038025,
0.4947616457939148,
-0.4531981647014618,
-0.4584052860736847,
-0.11752931028604507,
0.01122472994029522,
0.3785146474838257,
1.0095661878585815,
0.32915201783180237,
0.03304978832602501,
-0.6691641211509705,
-0.8176120519638062,
-0.3498832583427429,
-0.329727441072464,
-0.28683149814605713,
0.08924078941345215,
0.552661657333374,
-0.08658206462860107,
1.2512568235397339,
-0.4408819079399109,
-0.17316393554210663,
-0.5132303833961487,
0.6066203117370605,
0.46116018295288086,
0.33094078302383423,
0.5676766037940979,
-0.6270996332168579,
-0.19631822407245636,
-0.4124371409416199,
-1.2857249975204468,
-0.1972007304430008,
-0.3121525049209595,
0.30395230650901794,
0.1749178022146225,
0.4017404317855835,
-0.7811864614486694,
0.5330094695091248,
0.21063807606697083,
-0.15074406564235687,
0.5376076698303223,
-0.19059538841247559,
0.059735022485256195,
-0.8208290934562683,
-0.16350214183330536,
0.24109432101249695,
-0.24144858121871948,
-0.8512635827064514,
0.11715304851531982,
0.012074308469891548,
0.46620315313339233,
-0.18992450833320618,
0.2641966938972473,
-0.36172789335250854,
0.06578214466571808,
-0.20801401138305664,
0.1865355670452118,
0.1884755939245224,
0.4783138632774353,
0.16755546629428864,
0.6664009690284729,
0.4714896082878113,
-0.7353813052177429,
0.18115293979644775,
0.3104991912841797,
-0.0051971375942230225,
0.7435378432273865,
-0.6405596733093262,
-0.37365543842315674,
-0.508024275302887,
0.3015705347061157,
-1.1348986625671387,
-0.6445096135139465,
0.2819097936153412,
-0.4148732125759125,
0.5144568085670471,
-0.13538828492164612,
-0.4728275239467621,
0.08238904923200607,
-0.3948226273059845,
0.198322594165802,
0.30718889832496643,
-0.39227622747421265,
0.8432170748710632,
0.32920515537261963,
-0.16242727637290955,
-0.704949140548706,
-0.8369314670562744,
0.4200560748577118,
-0.24117815494537354,
-0.3935464918613434,
0.3661406934261322,
0.22935736179351807,
-0.4933828115463257,
-0.024127040058374405,
-0.32350775599479675,
-0.1142241358757019,
0.27886325120925903,
0.3116794228553772,
0.4508945941925049,
-0.39983606338500977,
0.08811236917972565,
-0.05876893550157547,
-0.026522887870669365,
0.09414834529161453,
-0.03742087632417679,
-0.0693957582116127,
0.23187927901744843,
-0.40528371930122375,
-0.2395811676979065,
0.39431044459342957,
0.3597075343132019,
0.17166352272033691,
0.5865024328231812,
0.028126457706093788,
-0.40109142661094666,
-0.127683624625206,
-0.7578008770942688,
0.08679568022489548,
-0.2927893102169037,
0.25102436542510986,
-0.08920926600694656,
-0.9204327464103699,
0.45977580547332764,
0.12015150487422943,
0.26986417174339294,
0.5218934416770935,
0.2809833288192749,
-0.29123422503471375,
0.6686397194862366,
0.8027873039245605,
0.21544983983039856,
0.08569760620594025,
-0.2864310145378113,
0.2524107098579407,
-0.8040953874588013,
-0.2050343155860901,
-0.3850555419921875,
0.02184217795729637,
-0.3574936091899872,
-0.41601869463920593,
0.4910314679145813,
0.06418152153491974,
-0.23336513340473175,
0.22266390919685364,
0.02851257100701332,
0.23986031115055084,
0.46201658248901367,
-0.07460936158895493,
0.5522453188896179,
0.021778227761387825,
0.06991277635097504,
-0.07614299654960632,
-0.9096662998199463,
-0.5397345423698425,
1.0409950017929077,
0.30342283844947815,
0.6451111435890198,
0.2523510456085205,
0.6012772917747498,
0.40179604291915894,
0.6551536917686462,
-0.8378233909606934,
0.3315238058567047,
-0.2443934679031372,
-0.6048020720481873,
-0.019457409158349037,
-0.4065965414047241,
-0.6538302302360535,
0.4314705729484558,
-0.18554091453552246,
-0.6217624545097351,
0.27221378684043884,
0.27418893575668335,
-0.6091039180755615,
0.36899465322494507,
-0.5960203409194946,
0.7947783470153809,
0.06002328544855118,
-0.07245280593633652,
0.14444249868392944,
-0.7173475623130798,
0.9422476887702942,
0.18607859313488007,
0.20604833960533142,
-0.3407878875732422,
-0.25427907705307007,
0.5339163541793823,
-0.43568167090415955,
1.1655751466751099,
-0.06554115563631058,
-0.28279435634613037,
0.2365531325340271,
-0.023256732150912285,
0.3920680582523346,
-0.09160409867763519,
0.18641036748886108,
0.31499969959259033,
-0.2837466299533844,
-0.389855295419693,
-0.682680070400238,
0.1728488951921463,
-0.5304504632949829,
-0.7588806748390198,
-0.5291619896888733,
-0.7953281402587891,
-0.5521624088287354,
-0.22958102822303772,
0.5102353096008301,
0.6268561482429504,
0.003294573398306966,
-0.050740376114845276,
0.886430561542511,
-0.04366487264633179,
0.42683902382850647,
0.7040712237358093,
-0.018528003245592117,
-0.061790864914655685,
0.7041084170341492,
0.2038463056087494,
0.36718446016311646,
0.6306958794593811,
-0.2383439689874649,
-0.21307377517223358,
-0.9345539212226868,
-0.3070760667324066,
0.23140226304531097,
-0.8126572966575623,
-0.5640992522239685,
-1.0026110410690308,
-0.36116430163383484,
-0.4697254002094269,
-0.12584620714187622,
-0.1371091604232788,
-0.5002041459083557,
-0.5138583183288574,
-0.38090771436691284,
0.43181267380714417,
0.653465986251831,
-0.2094622254371643,
0.46548038721084595,
-0.9571465849876404,
0.594407320022583,
0.13429147005081177,
-0.02297094278037548,
0.056534409523010254,
-0.9389011263847351,
-0.0030164073687046766,
-0.020421115681529045,
-0.2421284317970276,
-0.824974775314331,
0.3500782549381256,
0.30426955223083496,
0.5130431056022644,
0.4251061975955963,
0.052057236433029175,
0.820380449295044,
-0.328051894903183,
0.95098477602005,
0.3156271278858185,
-0.8672175407409668,
0.5169718861579895,
-0.4565587043762207,
0.23261377215385437,
0.3422575294971466,
0.3505050241947174,
-0.6163942217826843,
-0.8334888815879822,
-0.7204837203025818,
-0.9305543303489685,
0.6175243854522705,
0.09034182131290436,
0.0818561539053917,
-0.35269224643707275,
0.4476451277732849,
0.08818941563367844,
0.30734336376190186,
-0.6709471940994263,
-0.5927712917327881,
-0.01311849057674408,
-0.286998450756073,
-0.038233786821365356,
-0.5858244299888611,
-0.23981861770153046,
-0.0608040876686573,
0.6871967315673828,
-0.33904963731765747,
0.016728784888982773,
0.494006484746933,
-0.3280186951160431,
-0.08758042007684708,
0.28030839562416077,
0.7493451237678528,
1.0127452611923218,
-0.32419687509536743,
0.4211125075817108,
0.35498514771461487,
-0.08395189791917801,
0.23227688670158386,
-0.06990408897399902,
-0.5092083811759949,
0.42398664355278015,
1.0901784896850586,
0.6996548175811768,
0.4354607164859772,
-0.716266393661499,
0.7452787756919861,
0.21931326389312744,
-0.21838362514972687,
-0.3076000213623047,
0.1653299480676651,
0.053336601704359055,
0.005649270955473185,
0.5829907655715942,
0.28424325585365295,
0.20950354635715485,
-0.4737933874130249,
0.22642795741558075,
0.4229036569595337,
-0.18752159178256989,
-0.2862227261066437,
0.6874761581420898,
0.04881332814693451,
0.15348556637763977,
0.20805753767490387,
-0.5181904435157776,
-0.24540382623672485,
0.8004447817802429,
0.28369179368019104,
0.8455032110214233,
0.04809420928359032,
0.4614877700805664,
0.3166911005973816,
0.3344257175922394,
-0.1291074901819229,
0.10009109973907471,
-0.023762645199894905,
-0.9945924878120422,
-0.9059323668479919,
-0.335015207529068,
-0.6553013324737549,
0.09361159801483154,
-0.7283574342727661,
-0.021998263895511627,
-0.3441615104675293,
0.08524587005376816,
0.1492648720741272,
-0.47286850214004517,
-0.26651430130004883,
0.18825334310531616,
0.31918156147003174,
0.9841437935829163,
-0.9935330748558044,
0.4297998547554016,
0.5337123274803162,
-0.5175377726554871,
-0.5824781060218811,
0.00660943565890193,
0.41766053438186646,
-0.7010933756828308,
0.9537134766578674,
-0.08109943568706512,
-0.05052466690540314,
-0.3397582173347473,
-0.5557821989059448,
-0.7452052235603333,
1.0877032279968262,
0.4414076805114746,
-0.5188471078872681,
-0.13279195129871368,
0.08129944652318954,
0.3394168019294739,
-0.4576965868473053,
0.3219316899776459,
0.6178150177001953,
0.286922812461853,
0.24463912844657898,
-0.6892152428627014,
-0.04712553694844246,
0.148399218916893,
0.19696517288684845,
-0.009487776085734367,
-0.29278695583343506,
0.8927652835845947,
-0.36020728945732117,
-0.3610760271549225,
0.06881160289049149,
0.9106757044792175,
0.382116436958313,
0.5299027562141418,
0.3238167464733124,
0.9175817966461182,
0.8044236302375793,
-0.19893120229244232,
1.1354981660842896,
-0.05071670562028885,
0.4436074197292328,
1.5066426992416382,
-0.4159662425518036,
0.668963611125946,
0.36642688512802124,
-0.34076032042503357,
0.36564871668815613,
0.5094847083091736,
-0.14085927605628967,
0.32285287976264954,
-0.20860345661640167,
-0.5357720255851746,
-0.41503676772117615,
-0.35127678513526917,
-0.1976613700389862,
0.43527254462242126,
0.421176940202713,
-0.050183288753032684,
-0.8413596153259277,
-0.2440086156129837,
0.23609709739685059,
0.04294930770993233,
-0.33484819531440735,
0.8566427826881409,
0.02770538441836834,
-0.7246245741844177,
0.4713134765625,
0.11968358606100082,
0.9103407263755798,
-0.5279205441474915,
-0.14690634608268738,
-0.5109269618988037,
-0.06172039359807968,
-0.41280457377433777,
-0.5666384100914001,
0.6218606233596802,
0.19725610315799713,
-0.3940664827823639,
-0.18827395141124725,
0.5977686643600464,
-0.4281439781188965,
-0.4297989308834076,
0.10823222249746323,
0.7631450891494751,
-0.007086641620844603,
-0.0993521586060524,
-0.4476436972618103,
-0.20668469369411469,
-0.07157382369041443,
0.17884333431720734,
0.08129576593637466,
0.48490110039711,
0.08113769441843033,
0.47493404150009155,
0.5384936332702637,
-0.007824036292731762,
-0.04204128310084343,
0.03171273693442345,
0.4613836407661438,
-0.6146891713142395,
-0.16294856369495392,
-0.9898595809936523,
0.5882895588874817,
-0.11191092431545258,
-0.3014860153198242,
0.9608920812606812,
0.5504897236824036,
0.6166673898696899,
-0.2714439630508423,
0.9032940864562988,
-0.031333427876234055,
0.7165842056274414,
-0.5780390501022339,
0.3226327896118164,
-0.4833865463733673,
0.3051270842552185,
0.1398972123861313,
-0.5696133375167847,
-0.6644248962402344,
0.3150300085544586,
-0.1502019166946411,
-0.16117098927497864,
0.5875816941261292,
0.6209282279014587,
-0.007406784687191248,
-0.13121750950813293,
0.3712065815925598,
0.4103240966796875,
0.27240005135536194,
0.37978842854499817,
0.9173330664634705,
-0.3752225935459137,
0.15263770520687103,
-0.17987331748008728,
-0.2206190526485443,
-0.3313610255718231,
-1.221748948097229,
-0.6894632577896118,
-0.18441209197044373,
-0.9176455140113831,
-0.21747735142707825,
-0.04421604424715042,
0.7887296080589294,
0.6648707985877991,
-1.1131540536880493,
-0.17270612716674805,
-0.37899476289749146,
0.5270686745643616,
-0.18693314492702484,
-0.3075544834136963,
0.13059359788894653,
-0.833479106426239,
-0.438386470079422,
0.31768667697906494,
0.7397128343582153,
0.06396970897912979,
0.05130888149142265,
0.2570636570453644,
-0.22947929799556732,
0.34158405661582947,
0.6510929465293884,
0.4263319969177246,
-1.1208361387252808,
-0.2133033275604248,
-0.11325662583112717,
-0.06839592754840851,
0.26019102334976196,
0.8004450798034668,
-0.6282751560211182,
0.1841961294412613,
0.27660971879959106,
0.7132117748260498,
0.08072511106729507,
-0.008835239335894585,
0.45786377787590027,
-1.1031486988067627,
0.106681689620018,
0.1614154428243637,
0.5913629531860352,
0.4585389792919159,
-0.2898721694946289,
0.631954550743103,
0.6473119258880615,
-0.1256408840417862,
-0.9175572395324707,
0.18424971401691437,
-1.1849912405014038,
-0.23482352495193481,
0.9533277750015259,
-0.4569615423679352,
-0.1598387509584427,
-0.3066282272338867,
0.25872835516929626,
0.14648450911045074,
0.036309339106082916,
0.7471693158149719,
0.7858978509902954,
-0.3213241398334503,
-0.19155673682689667,
-0.7007386088371277,
0.4334864914417267,
0.4423690140247345,
-0.999687910079956,
0.10578685253858566,
0.5594524145126343,
0.3700101673603058,
0.4111403226852417,
0.5866621136665344,
0.08402775973081589,
0.31446573138237,
0.02221926487982273,
-0.0025821274612098932,
0.054398633539676666,
-0.1820148527622223,
-0.3618285357952118,
0.18985381722450256,
-0.06662110239267349,
0.02800055220723152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12819v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12819v2 | Comparing Specialised Small and General Large Language Models on Text Classification: 100 Labelled Samples to Achieve Break-Even Performance | 2024-02-20T08:38:24 | 2024-04-26T08:20:40 | Branislav Pecher, Ivan Srba, Maria Bielikova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | When solving NLP tasks with limited labelled data, researchers can either use
a general large language model without further update, or use a small number of
labelled examples to tune a specialised smaller model. In this work, we address
the research gap of how many labelled samples are required for the specialised
small models to outperform general large models, while taking the performance
variance into consideration. By observing the behaviour of fine-tuning,
instruction-tuning, prompting and in-context learning on 7 language models, we
identify such performance break-even points across 8 representative text
classification tasks of varying characteristics. We show that the specialised
models often need only few samples (on average $10 - 1000$) to be on par or
better than the general ones. At the same time, the number of required labels
strongly depends on the dataset or task characteristics, with this number being
significantly lower on multi-class datasets (up to $100$) than on binary
datasets (up to $5000$). When performance variance is taken into consideration,
the number of required labels increases on average by $100 - 200\%$ and even up
to $1500\%$ in specific cases. | [
-0.5538434982299805,
-0.7004467248916626,
0.32628902792930603,
0.19771718978881836,
0.11855954676866531,
-0.24548931419849396,
-0.20505890250205994,
-0.8230016231536865,
-0.0988784208893776,
0.5753033757209778,
-0.40289658308029175,
-0.2615002989768982,
-0.8139750957489014,
0.30012500286102295,
-0.4320480227470398,
0.8725588917732239,
0.23275500535964966,
-0.14129897952079773,
-0.29432186484336853,
-0.09530207514762878,
-0.6196892857551575,
-0.44690510630607605,
-0.8081980347633362,
-0.5037426352500916,
0.6172969937324524,
0.44288739562034607,
0.7024761438369751,
0.5485721230506897,
0.5528694987297058,
0.2406967729330063,
-0.5142108798027039,
0.4058102071285248,
-0.19007663428783417,
-0.1500370353460312,
-0.42373132705688477,
-0.5989904403686523,
-0.47122618556022644,
-0.008084304630756378,
0.5050287246704102,
0.6682870388031006,
0.13731102645397186,
0.19659769535064697,
0.28716424107551575,
0.5957756042480469,
-0.4478203356266022,
0.164236918091774,
-0.2597501575946808,
-0.008242100477218628,
-0.3296342194080353,
0.1749192625284195,
-0.609002947807312,
-0.09129790961742401,
0.11509881913661957,
-0.36051860451698303,
0.3770650625228882,
0.01752331480383873,
0.8915023803710938,
0.42531532049179077,
-0.2539098262786865,
-0.5269971489906311,
-0.572864294052124,
0.8867776393890381,
-0.8543599247932434,
0.09904196858406067,
0.6094517111778259,
-0.007350126747041941,
0.016603665426373482,
-0.7313231825828552,
-0.2493995726108551,
-0.14024792611598969,
-0.21191608905792236,
-0.2757352590560913,
-0.30263257026672363,
-0.039792947471141815,
0.42342960834503174,
0.24642212688922882,
-0.3439667224884033,
0.7426847815513611,
-0.5272523760795593,
0.15229520201683044,
0.5926334857940674,
0.22993993759155273,
0.2408096343278885,
-0.15144285559654236,
0.11132863163948059,
-0.2713230848312378,
-0.48273172974586487,
0.2178766280412674,
0.27514809370040894,
0.5865942239761353,
0.08984797447919846,
0.564786970615387,
-0.06217062473297119,
0.9993273615837097,
0.11298420280218124,
-0.19339397549629211,
0.26837944984436035,
-0.3815291225910187,
-0.40047571063041687,
-0.301452100276947,
0.8682816624641418,
0.06327163428068161,
0.3500843346118927,
-0.05118199810385704,
-0.41169047355651855,
-0.07556712627410889,
0.37351474165916443,
-0.8310364484786987,
-0.28996577858924866,
0.10071495175361633,
-0.28032585978507996,
-0.22304612398147583,
-0.19261251389980316,
-0.8148487210273743,
-0.1057281494140625,
-0.43576329946517944,
0.4754881262779236,
-0.23571263253688812,
-0.027824655175209045,
0.2946993410587311,
-0.09377817064523697,
-0.054003313183784485,
0.3067362904548645,
-1.1783050298690796,
0.4803904891014099,
0.6650048494338989,
0.9663940668106079,
-0.359529584646225,
-0.2486008107662201,
-0.4613129794597626,
-0.29365211725234985,
-0.3964645564556122,
0.8151386976242065,
-0.6714510917663574,
-0.44580158591270447,
-0.12984348833560944,
0.0359230563044548,
-0.1636369377374649,
-0.807640790939331,
0.6395848393440247,
-0.40736714005470276,
0.20675724744796753,
-0.15409496426582336,
-0.7480804324150085,
-0.03398285433650017,
0.1741417795419693,
-0.9786179661750793,
1.2520047426223755,
0.17725162208080292,
-0.7824366688728333,
0.6332235336303711,
-0.6224375367164612,
-0.3791279196739197,
0.17460165917873383,
-0.19752447307109833,
-0.4949585795402527,
0.10887563973665237,
0.05209748446941376,
0.6706056594848633,
-0.4741768538951874,
0.221477672457695,
-0.2304472178220749,
-0.398087739944458,
0.33869990706443787,
-0.3182313144207001,
0.601465106010437,
0.013300380669534206,
-0.5699203014373779,
-0.12633052468299866,
-0.9530490636825562,
0.2784000337123871,
-0.349465012550354,
-0.6347216963768005,
-0.6606729030609131,
0.0032242382876574993,
0.13669046759605408,
0.4691782593727112,
-0.07479947805404663,
-0.22087879478931427,
0.416811466217041,
-0.4950296878814697,
0.38808465003967285,
0.3593539297580719,
-0.23093301057815552,
0.4097388684749603,
-0.30211400985717773,
0.5358728766441345,
-0.261269748210907,
-0.046277523040771484,
-0.0140060530975461,
-0.733125627040863,
-0.7723177671432495,
-0.59912109375,
0.9178701639175415,
0.36834442615509033,
-0.5408864617347717,
0.39707493782043457,
-0.028833355754613876,
-0.44078102707862854,
-0.8627244234085083,
0.1047833114862442,
0.5072277784347534,
0.12405930459499359,
0.5605315566062927,
-0.31301403045654297,
-0.2961520552635193,
-1.006761074066162,
-0.2256055623292923,
0.14655566215515137,
-0.474470853805542,
0.5082093477249146,
0.8384288549423218,
-0.39857786893844604,
1.0583146810531616,
-0.33515235781669617,
-0.29572853446006775,
-0.1245824545621872,
0.4325997829437256,
0.26564735174179077,
0.3353484570980072,
0.6235308051109314,
-0.7439165711402893,
-0.4743710160255432,
0.06437069922685623,
-0.40827476978302,
-0.1690724641084671,
-0.06702492386102676,
0.25066280364990234,
0.4930744171142578,
0.46167612075805664,
-0.4154706299304962,
0.450864315032959,
0.7033280730247498,
-0.46902400255203247,
0.5691726803779602,
-0.34636858105659485,
-0.0745629370212555,
-0.6141405701637268,
0.04646657407283783,
0.2659534215927124,
-0.19004501402378082,
-0.6947771906852722,
-0.004646664950996637,
0.22698307037353516,
0.0722125917673111,
-0.2748662531375885,
0.5607227683067322,
-0.2504854202270508,
0.19401168823242188,
-0.48148104548454285,
0.01067820843309164,
0.015907524153590202,
0.20001086592674255,
0.03330514207482338,
0.6635886430740356,
0.4152768850326538,
-0.7996200919151306,
-0.11395786702632904,
0.049469225108623505,
-0.7302898168563843,
0.1171712875366211,
-0.7997080087661743,
0.08310806006193161,
0.30257537961006165,
0.009489011950790882,
-0.9230386018753052,
-0.34583580493927,
-0.010731605812907219,
-0.2209896445274353,
0.5311892628669739,
0.08699755370616913,
-0.6291785836219788,
-0.20538222789764404,
0.06382486969232559,
0.3301483988761902,
0.484095960855484,
-0.6068357825279236,
0.4771662950515747,
0.35306867957115173,
-0.29560258984565735,
-0.4985843598842621,
-0.9347235560417175,
-0.07730162888765335,
-0.10412527620792389,
-0.43676140904426575,
0.33889830112457275,
0.13855046033859253,
-0.2530449628829956,
-0.048894282430410385,
-0.049917884171009064,
-0.1791456937789917,
0.010773029178380966,
0.14515678584575653,
-0.1016160175204277,
-0.08204773813486099,
0.4150782525539398,
0.02884713001549244,
-0.05076087266206741,
0.055007725954055786,
-0.1665058732032776,
0.32358017563819885,
-0.0621403232216835,
-0.13520947098731995,
-0.20053060352802277,
0.320956826210022,
0.4584665298461914,
-0.04981464147567749,
0.8765374422073364,
0.4274275600910187,
-0.23745505511760712,
-0.5911312103271484,
-0.41960325837135315,
0.022700656205415726,
-0.4739472568035126,
0.33120498061180115,
-0.5765271186828613,
-0.9666261076927185,
0.18657517433166504,
0.09152107685804367,
-0.0014144884189590812,
0.7242355346679688,
0.5482853055000305,
-0.006989519111812115,
0.9691013097763062,
0.9482783079147339,
-0.1744287610054016,
0.20853745937347412,
-0.03872544318437576,
0.15780594944953918,
-0.2518649399280548,
-0.1878724992275238,
-1.0500872135162354,
-0.2793883681297302,
-0.7679856419563293,
-0.6471952795982361,
0.13000603020191193,
0.19916896522045135,
-0.019471654668450356,
0.10849183797836304,
-0.6694118976593018,
0.5829889178276062,
0.7391433715820312,
0.006268281023949385,
0.3173964321613312,
-0.058944057673215866,
-0.09721463173627853,
-0.14748938381671906,
-0.9726836681365967,
-0.5422826409339905,
0.8782679438591003,
0.3802157938480377,
0.7171375155448914,
0.028453001752495766,
0.4989433288574219,
0.4063231348991394,
0.3130923807621002,
-0.8621546030044556,
0.3179124593734741,
-0.537476658821106,
-0.6704102158546448,
-0.5615293979644775,
-0.4086325764656067,
-0.9941840171813965,
0.34809160232543945,
-0.16726720333099365,
-0.6182431578636169,
0.4755973517894745,
0.017153508961200714,
-0.05995822697877884,
0.1319933980703354,
-0.5955668091773987,
0.7361898422241211,
-0.10311473160982132,
-0.10434199869632721,
-0.012235657311975956,
-0.4014420807361603,
0.4288550317287445,
-0.5332860946655273,
0.4741288423538208,
0.10326987504959106,
-0.09970871359109879,
0.9471589922904968,
-0.25554272532463074,
1.172993540763855,
0.09723009914159775,
-0.21920056641101837,
0.16283075511455536,
-0.15543611347675323,
0.38743820786476135,
-0.26408836245536804,
-0.20434187352657318,
0.15005025267601013,
0.17480672895908356,
-0.5064873099327087,
-0.3992120921611786,
0.22182372212409973,
-0.7109766006469727,
-0.2464022934436798,
-0.37128719687461853,
-0.35182538628578186,
-0.26181426644325256,
0.08773002028465271,
0.6671903133392334,
0.3409122824668884,
-0.0017902329564094543,
0.49005231261253357,
0.8465999364852905,
-0.2966809868812561,
0.35744237899780273,
0.39989200234413147,
-0.2079319953918457,
-0.0937567725777626,
0.768252968788147,
0.39208173751831055,
0.3476176857948303,
0.39864492416381836,
0.3080289363861084,
-0.08796104043722153,
-0.5876591801643372,
-0.260906845331192,
0.16556741297245026,
-0.5319898724555969,
-0.1792304515838623,
-0.7093119621276855,
-0.10336953401565552,
-0.2162213772535324,
-0.06567178666591644,
-0.5191418528556824,
-0.4322197735309601,
-0.48686665296554565,
0.06147298961877823,
0.25264063477516174,
0.8444862961769104,
-0.07299387454986572,
0.3151489794254303,
-0.7472572326660156,
0.3451921045780182,
0.37608903646469116,
0.30601581931114197,
0.09696201980113983,
-0.824547529220581,
-0.5022186636924744,
-0.16890278458595276,
-0.23872973024845123,
-0.7012259364128113,
0.4660974442958832,
0.36379945278167725,
0.5095962882041931,
0.3322802186012268,
0.020086484029889107,
0.5520936846733093,
-0.6025775671005249,
0.7863503098487854,
0.15396881103515625,
-1.069824457168579,
0.4245726764202118,
-0.2569029927253723,
0.3369107246398926,
0.5222474336624146,
0.5979180335998535,
-0.513286292552948,
-0.5008735656738281,
-0.6820708513259888,
-1.2309191226959229,
0.7725474238395691,
0.03898152336478233,
-0.09270550310611725,
0.14254997670650482,
0.3030287027359009,
0.2498699575662613,
0.0621044896543026,
-0.6979214549064636,
-0.22233924269676208,
0.3255867063999176,
-0.02721591852605343,
-0.35623395442962646,
-0.38469570875167847,
-0.16952398419380188,
-0.3645566403865814,
0.5528123378753662,
-0.14264506101608276,
0.01719949021935463,
-0.18597330152988434,
-0.010076365433633327,
0.3417307734489441,
0.5301846265792847,
0.5888935923576355,
0.7367684841156006,
-0.1490713655948639,
-0.007358812261372805,
0.19095277786254883,
-0.36402368545532227,
0.14543087780475616,
-0.09022434055805206,
-0.35008740425109863,
0.38735389709472656,
0.5052656531333923,
0.8638030886650085,
0.4229305386543274,
-0.7265662550926208,
0.1654009073972702,
-0.072585828602314,
-0.4164358377456665,
0.3615395724773407,
0.41693314909935,
0.05104626342654228,
0.13847722113132477,
0.2695445418357849,
0.03846996650099754,
0.20358631014823914,
-0.42446863651275635,
0.27861863374710083,
0.04844213277101517,
-0.2156069576740265,
-0.07005944848060608,
0.334791362285614,
0.11423726379871368,
-0.6376733779907227,
0.3754793405532837,
-0.23649707436561584,
-0.2025798261165619,
0.643779456615448,
0.39544886350631714,
0.5876443982124329,
-0.24651847779750824,
0.43211114406585693,
0.2632003724575043,
0.4776972234249115,
-0.7871525883674622,
-0.09757540374994278,
-0.003663762006908655,
-0.488802433013916,
-0.6889035701751709,
-0.7435763478279114,
-0.9376723170280457,
0.33319929242134094,
-0.9975229501724243,
0.1539977788925171,
-0.1165122240781784,
-0.19702871143817902,
0.42435964941978455,
0.07562454044818878,
-0.7117331624031067,
0.5926019549369812,
-0.12422419339418411,
1.0724231004714966,
-0.8497517704963684,
0.8647011518478394,
0.5560927391052246,
-0.11873733252286911,
-0.7121607065200806,
-0.1789836287498474,
-0.18211622536182404,
-0.19709520041942596,
0.8204806447029114,
0.2985372245311737,
-0.1328706294298172,
-0.3384273946285248,
-0.4349941313266754,
-0.767538845539093,
0.43085938692092896,
0.03830525651574135,
-0.9537582993507385,
-0.100917287170887,
0.1648276001214981,
0.8627538681030273,
-0.37145259976387024,
0.14853061735630035,
1.084322214126587,
0.47423481941223145,
-0.1847534477710724,
-1.1168385744094849,
-0.19100898504257202,
-0.19160978496074677,
-0.08176467567682266,
0.1281633824110031,
-0.5233184695243835,
0.8929229974746704,
0.10098019242286682,
-0.022153979167342186,
-0.013431668281555176,
0.2308390885591507,
0.18079152703285217,
0.5298177599906921,
0.40238070487976074,
0.37269604206085205,
1.0915677547454834,
-0.1742786467075348,
1.0995107889175415,
0.10502725839614868,
0.41033488512039185,
1.2064237594604492,
-0.0065774680115282536,
1.0372307300567627,
0.18893024325370789,
-0.3547150790691376,
0.11645181477069855,
0.7949684858322144,
-0.26806631684303284,
0.42392459511756897,
0.17884831130504608,
-0.09235928952693939,
-0.26207435131073,
0.18834544718265533,
-0.3935953378677368,
0.47774937748908997,
0.451455682516098,
-0.46712353825569153,
0.1167827770113945,
0.27582672238349915,
-0.11257288604974747,
-0.09669726341962814,
-0.4260389804840088,
0.7827972769737244,
0.1457451730966568,
-0.7230322957038879,
0.7583910226821899,
0.2749794125556946,
0.8897513151168823,
-0.48096945881843567,
0.37654367089271545,
-0.0763930082321167,
0.33476823568344116,
-0.28792235255241394,
-0.7140197157859802,
0.27606916427612305,
0.24866271018981934,
-0.50872802734375,
-0.3476386070251465,
0.7827673554420471,
-0.3165852725505829,
-0.6110396981239319,
0.42825543880462646,
0.3239661157131195,
0.28372734785079956,
0.006391672883182764,
-0.4959484040737152,
0.0013639398384839296,
0.017920732498168945,
-0.4919952154159546,
0.670666515827179,
0.631216287612915,
0.16633926331996918,
0.5323083996772766,
0.24612130224704742,
0.20588652789592743,
0.03307377174496651,
0.03192415088415146,
0.7995772957801819,
-0.7962737083435059,
-0.5166134238243103,
-0.8699492812156677,
0.5189409852027893,
-0.09867458790540695,
-0.6105313897132874,
0.6888443827629089,
0.4037925601005554,
0.9584571123123169,
-0.13183802366256714,
0.8101462125778198,
0.0625990480184555,
0.5976566076278687,
-0.6171396374702454,
0.4084557592868805,
-0.7127587795257568,
0.29985663294792175,
-0.2671545147895813,
-0.6654611229896545,
-0.37952345609664917,
0.5951813459396362,
-0.41104432940483093,
-0.03974837064743042,
0.6153731942176819,
0.5351540446281433,
-0.006855902262032032,
0.07497309893369675,
0.42128798365592957,
-0.019177459180355072,
0.3288685083389282,
0.3465288281440735,
0.5826261639595032,
-0.2555377781391144,
0.41702190041542053,
-0.06422799080610275,
-0.24838602542877197,
-0.21913698315620422,
-0.7561014890670776,
-0.9674379229545593,
-0.2812848389148712,
-0.3921245038509369,
-0.4072200059890747,
-0.08022648841142654,
0.5536815524101257,
0.6896163821220398,
-0.9212518930435181,
-0.1743815541267395,
0.17657651007175446,
0.10831716656684875,
-0.36145591735839844,
-0.20740333199501038,
0.4114528000354767,
-0.6785465478897095,
-1.024725317955017,
0.30687370896339417,
0.19983381032943726,
-0.08836458623409271,
-0.021776845678687096,
0.18538977205753326,
-0.0908445417881012,
0.20146885514259338,
0.6590906977653503,
0.44902491569519043,
-0.48724737763404846,
-0.015930691733956337,
-0.1859031319618225,
-0.2539806365966797,
-0.027944711968302727,
0.7853708863258362,
-0.5051741003990173,
0.29431071877479553,
0.3404547870159149,
0.9634032845497131,
0.8132730722427368,
-0.12989871203899384,
0.31127089262008667,
-0.9949619174003601,
0.022110920399427414,
0.3557341396808624,
-0.11925521492958069,
0.1519695371389389,
-0.11103451997041702,
0.6219395995140076,
0.017321176826953888,
-0.8168179988861084,
-1.0029717683792114,
0.08432458341121674,
-0.7552342414855957,
-0.6800979971885681,
1.196932315826416,
-0.11520721763372421,
-0.009415104053914547,
-0.17030130326747894,
-0.03595534339547157,
-0.1800469160079956,
-0.08427036553621292,
0.8670063614845276,
1.0506162643432617,
-0.3387576639652252,
0.02125941403210163,
-0.789638102054596,
0.6817397475242615,
0.4530133306980133,
-0.7643263339996338,
-0.04482264816761017,
0.3133981227874756,
0.11990105360746384,
0.31791940331459045,
0.48083752393722534,
0.1909034252166748,
0.15529951453208923,
0.2313392013311386,
0.03631015121936798,
0.08048432320356369,
-0.5484334826469421,
-0.5018787384033203,
0.5178543925285339,
-0.026205012574791908,
-0.08155369013547897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12817v1 | On Sensitivity of Learning with Limited Labelled Data to the Effects of Randomness: Impact of Interactions and Systematic Choices | 2024-02-20T08:38:19 | 2024-02-20T08:38:19 | Branislav Pecher, Ivan Srba, Maria Bielikova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | While learning with limited labelled data can improve performance when the
labels are lacking, it is also sensitive to the effects of uncontrolled
randomness introduced by so-called randomness factors (e.g., varying order of
data). We propose a method to systematically investigate the effects of
randomness factors while taking the interactions between them into
consideration. To measure the true effects of an individual randomness factor,
our method mitigates the effects of other factors and observes how the
performance varies across multiple runs. Applying our method to multiple
randomness factors across in-context learning and fine-tuning approaches on 7
representative text classification tasks and meta-learning on 3 tasks, we show
that: 1) disregarding interactions between randomness factors in existing works
caused inconsistent findings due to incorrect attribution of the effects of
randomness factors, such as disproving the consistent sensitivity of in-context
learning to sample order even with random sample selection; and 2) besides
mutual interactions, the effects of randomness factors, especially sample
order, are also dependent on more systematic choices unexplored in existing
works, such as number of classes, samples per class or choice of prompt format. | [
-0.5504189133644104,
-0.7314168810844421,
0.26356741786003113,
0.00881888996809721,
-0.1574326753616333,
-0.28280267119407654,
-0.2689974904060364,
-0.768570601940155,
0.09050837904214859,
0.4001255929470062,
-0.4923827648162842,
-0.06227549910545349,
-0.675834059715271,
0.3893064260482788,
0.004559756256639957,
1.19394850730896,
0.05144980922341347,
0.24597345292568207,
-0.3290295898914337,
-0.5737292170524597,
-0.3638477921485901,
-0.6357290744781494,
-0.38692063093185425,
-0.5376362800598145,
0.8956950306892395,
0.6247161626815796,
0.5645694732666016,
0.44224289059638977,
0.8893576860427856,
0.24390588700771332,
-0.0682070404291153,
0.037562668323516846,
-0.6352148652076721,
0.17826218903064728,
-0.42015859484672546,
-0.5645225048065186,
-0.2189778834581375,
0.23096400499343872,
0.7171458601951599,
0.6158667802810669,
0.1786753237247467,
0.30376508831977844,
0.47773057222366333,
0.4014255404472351,
-0.6169071793556213,
-0.08540809899568558,
-0.2825051248073578,
0.0138769019395113,
-0.23078496754169464,
-0.5470256805419922,
-0.5905084013938904,
-0.06415246427059174,
0.4047527015209198,
-0.5650411248207092,
0.43354204297065735,
0.10428743064403534,
0.5925637483596802,
0.4146336019039154,
-0.46755972504615784,
-0.34490489959716797,
-0.8359281420707703,
0.893095076084137,
-0.3385024666786194,
0.07119600474834442,
0.2651234567165375,
0.08737625926733017,
-0.12114652246236801,
-0.7969135642051697,
-0.23637571930885315,
0.12823368608951569,
-0.1707470417022705,
0.18786928057670593,
0.38030046224594116,
0.19475647807121277,
0.8124575018882751,
0.10122434794902802,
-0.004452263005077839,
0.06845475733280182,
-0.4647209048271179,
-0.15896667540073395,
0.5597125887870789,
0.24834634363651276,
0.30681657791137695,
0.15084825456142426,
-0.2889364957809448,
-0.36236339807510376,
-0.4511181712150574,
0.3865874707698822,
0.5520305633544922,
0.6461142897605896,
0.1808333694934845,
0.6569937467575073,
-0.3035317659378052,
0.6750215291976929,
0.07491150498390198,
-0.36702075600624084,
0.4032406806945801,
-0.56865394115448,
-0.0987260490655899,
-0.11345034092664719,
0.6864387392997742,
0.11762692779302597,
0.02082248590886593,
0.075921431183815,
-0.12398523092269897,
-0.2617388665676117,
0.03872212395071983,
-0.7044280767440796,
-0.1440044790506363,
-0.08858274668455124,
-0.5471521615982056,
-0.45350882411003113,
0.28808656334877014,
-0.710993230342865,
-0.41577109694480896,
-0.3786364197731018,
0.546232283115387,
-0.18560631573200226,
0.02828904427587986,
-0.18906696140766144,
-0.27967390418052673,
-0.11165361106395721,
0.3110719621181488,
-0.7924968600273132,
0.4838995933532715,
0.20630672574043274,
0.4446188807487488,
-0.3063203990459442,
-0.44620388746261597,
-0.5133504271507263,
0.05688035488128662,
0.04297976940870285,
0.6260432004928589,
-0.9267099499702454,
-0.3691616952419281,
-0.18197420239448547,
-0.15522098541259766,
-0.1907799392938614,
-0.45932814478874207,
0.42081418633461,
-0.3628849983215332,
0.15909673273563385,
-0.5270752310752869,
-0.6365079879760742,
-0.3030366897583008,
-0.2581528127193451,
-0.8400989770889282,
0.991009533405304,
0.1412518173456192,
-1.0023518800735474,
0.8324351906776428,
-0.39272117614746094,
-0.5437933802604675,
-0.13988861441612244,
-0.25888389348983765,
-0.4557483196258545,
0.06837636977434158,
-0.22872847318649292,
0.3268665075302124,
0.1787542849779129,
0.16704045236110687,
-0.49953606724739075,
-0.38575804233551025,
0.6896370649337769,
-0.3768758475780487,
0.839886486530304,
0.002291611162945628,
-0.33376049995422363,
0.06933367252349854,
-0.9781271815299988,
0.08697076141834259,
-0.34042713046073914,
-0.6059356331825256,
-0.4926372766494751,
0.1703859567642212,
0.021092401817440987,
0.39031627774238586,
-0.13075654208660126,
-0.30803757905960083,
0.23845966160297394,
-0.01937234215438366,
0.1017535924911499,
0.7004331350326538,
0.3936576545238495,
0.6745973229408264,
-0.5292274355888367,
0.34660229086875916,
0.22166605293750763,
0.1776018738746643,
0.1731962114572525,
-0.6282867193222046,
-0.6250016093254089,
-0.18867848813533783,
0.5598465204238892,
0.34347403049468994,
-0.5644347667694092,
-0.17352402210235596,
0.05328502506017685,
-0.19436076283454895,
-0.37105831503868103,
0.32394272089004517,
0.5552570223808289,
0.41513141989707947,
0.29837092757225037,
-0.7392346858978271,
-0.43058180809020996,
-0.7145306468009949,
-0.41029420495033264,
0.0419931523501873,
-0.07218555361032486,
0.5927435159683228,
0.5229455828666687,
-0.17613261938095093,
0.9666348099708557,
-0.3915073275566101,
-0.1241583377122879,
0.02829127199947834,
0.4654240906238556,
-0.09992356598377228,
0.5132655501365662,
0.48856237530708313,
-0.7137614488601685,
-0.4617871046066284,
-0.2434990108013153,
-0.30231955647468567,
-0.1530126929283142,
-0.2890276610851288,
0.038659170269966125,
0.18987436592578888,
0.4914533793926239,
-0.21461811661720276,
0.3345686197280884,
0.024649403989315033,
-0.15501584112644196,
0.267890989780426,
-0.03826897591352463,
-0.05436186119914055,
-0.47105884552001953,
-0.02875138819217682,
0.07686465233564377,
0.10374437272548676,
-0.7632573843002319,
-0.009015980176627636,
0.1612035483121872,
0.12169792503118515,
-0.5923305153846741,
0.5632373690605164,
-0.29975903034210205,
0.2288166880607605,
-0.061569489538669586,
-0.16214554011821747,
-0.08787558227777481,
0.5205259323120117,
-0.07010076195001602,
0.5588294863700867,
0.30664461851119995,
-0.6579331159591675,
-0.24774886667728424,
0.00013266173482406884,
-0.20656883716583252,
0.4016711711883545,
-0.36430972814559937,
0.06606823951005936,
-0.2836163640022278,
0.1395738124847412,
-0.9475744366645813,
-0.40319791436195374,
0.5635356307029724,
-0.42592138051986694,
0.49996674060821533,
0.25793221592903137,
-0.5620442628860474,
-0.13166643679141998,
-0.3510149121284485,
0.4294074773788452,
-0.016494445502758026,
-0.3696116805076599,
0.554914116859436,
0.033774785697460175,
0.1407088190317154,
-0.664031445980072,
-0.5784703493118286,
-0.5884686708450317,
-0.25903841853141785,
-0.187855064868927,
0.005277296062558889,
-0.4577600061893463,
-0.3721759021282196,
-0.16014538705348969,
-0.3762497305870056,
-0.2625763714313507,
0.26425743103027344,
0.308602899312973,
0.020270852372050285,
0.1842539757490158,
0.3050467073917389,
0.08473597466945648,
0.016100218519568443,
0.15580326318740845,
0.11182348430156708,
-0.015421819873154163,
0.174184650182724,
0.0373242013156414,
-0.06875652819871902,
0.05162283405661583,
0.20309090614318848,
-0.04231884330511093,
0.7357034683227539,
0.5076442360877991,
-0.15669767558574677,
-0.4459947645664215,
-0.28795310854911804,
-0.4107927083969116,
-0.48704421520233154,
0.2875443994998932,
-0.40603548288345337,
-0.9131043553352356,
0.5647706985473633,
0.11231233924627304,
-0.03553014621138573,
0.5178532004356384,
0.3990793526172638,
-0.29892268776893616,
0.8833752870559692,
0.8765259385108948,
-0.017995644360780716,
0.7062463164329529,
0.1117655411362648,
0.045958951115608215,
-0.7470843195915222,
-0.13194185495376587,
-0.5548447370529175,
-0.5499969720840454,
-0.8944687247276306,
-0.13263827562332153,
0.15783584117889404,
0.12490486353635788,
-0.15952864289283752,
0.00706153130158782,
-0.42715099453926086,
0.5942890048027039,
0.635917603969574,
0.5632572174072266,
0.41290056705474854,
0.02813674323260784,
-0.26224878430366516,
-0.01714925281703472,
-0.8683639168739319,
-0.03514263778924942,
1.347976565361023,
0.30473384261131287,
0.7472770810127258,
-0.018278999254107475,
0.771987795829773,
-0.1332138180732727,
0.6041302680969238,
-0.45263180136680603,
0.25587621331214905,
0.11053327471017838,
-0.9681565761566162,
-0.6263115406036377,
-0.505730390548706,
-0.831821084022522,
0.17773355543613434,
-0.4487338662147522,
-0.8122546076774597,
0.4607667922973633,
-0.02675633691251278,
-0.40253981947898865,
0.02973310649394989,
-0.8031182885169983,
0.4152667820453644,
-0.0829252079129219,
-0.6260312795639038,
0.05511593818664551,
-0.8534639477729797,
0.4164501428604126,
-0.2180580198764801,
0.32577836513519287,
0.07098213583230972,
-0.038110289722681046,
0.9930360317230225,
-0.01488096546381712,
1.3091461658477783,
-0.021538440138101578,
0.0561477430164814,
0.4875313341617584,
-0.10123221576213837,
0.4561026692390442,
0.18423551321029663,
0.05049624666571617,
-0.01824002154171467,
-0.16979822516441345,
-0.49075067043304443,
-0.4485543370246887,
0.469768762588501,
-0.8328897356987,
-0.3217810094356537,
-0.5258645415306091,
-0.8625339865684509,
-0.24865594506263733,
0.4507274627685547,
0.6067383885383606,
0.4124283492565155,
0.05670803412795067,
0.19284597039222717,
1.0115621089935303,
-0.1400555521249771,
0.4170413613319397,
0.5302756428718567,
0.10894901305437088,
-0.3303079605102539,
1.0689647197723389,
0.6996979117393494,
0.4270155727863312,
0.4073520302772522,
0.2168356329202652,
0.04403141140937805,
-0.46048372983932495,
0.132841095328331,
0.12238266319036484,
-0.7239319086074829,
-0.23847892880439758,
-0.44447094202041626,
0.04566798731684685,
-0.14043931663036346,
-0.08390364795923233,
0.13573943078517914,
-0.44428524374961853,
-0.5820171236991882,
-0.12369419634342194,
0.24737903475761414,
0.6404386758804321,
-0.17733794450759888,
0.27661705017089844,
-0.47885662317276,
0.17056319117546082,
0.5077060461044312,
0.6399247050285339,
0.013282714411616325,
-0.5223744511604309,
-0.32424458861351013,
-0.2372993677854538,
-0.442436546087265,
-0.6563306450843811,
-0.13198970258235931,
0.21079334616661072,
0.6107385158538818,
0.5056599974632263,
0.14963240921497345,
0.368166446685791,
-0.281821072101593,
0.24643416702747345,
0.11729785054922104,
-0.5544654130935669,
0.315083384513855,
-0.5178869962692261,
0.2156531810760498,
0.8968707323074341,
0.5156928896903992,
0.045884497463703156,
-0.6162279844284058,
-0.9464208483695984,
-0.847676694393158,
0.8561782836914062,
0.2731581926345825,
-0.23167499899864197,
0.04832112044095993,
0.41854211688041687,
0.2524634301662445,
0.174348384141922,
-0.7223137021064758,
-0.5852664113044739,
0.1480332762002945,
0.08659934997558594,
-0.2872498631477356,
-0.5033856630325317,
-0.4523397386074066,
-0.48314473032951355,
0.46048226952552795,
0.003609992563724518,
0.022021008655428886,
0.26384732127189636,
-0.1076681986451149,
-0.40917080640792847,
0.16377633810043335,
0.7667936682701111,
0.6954284906387329,
-0.3819648325443268,
0.08333242684602737,
0.3183450400829315,
-0.5353577733039856,
0.0784822478890419,
-0.02852644771337509,
-0.45302456617355347,
-0.08966758847236633,
0.48262351751327515,
0.5283474922180176,
0.36583420634269714,
-0.3197690546512604,
0.23088087141513824,
-0.15103988349437714,
-0.23351964354515076,
0.316873162984848,
0.41490352153778076,
-0.31315743923187256,
0.19405274093151093,
0.3137793242931366,
0.4158434271812439,
0.33757439255714417,
-0.36115512251853943,
0.43182873725891113,
0.2520459294319153,
-0.4198247790336609,
0.04513341188430786,
0.3951217234134674,
0.19555412232875824,
-0.1536075919866562,
0.2526923418045044,
0.019631316885352135,
-0.1495586782693863,
0.9064279794692993,
0.4882991909980774,
0.46883100271224976,
-0.3237166702747345,
0.2575174868106842,
0.5012116432189941,
0.4674708843231201,
-0.2253732979297638,
0.17147989571094513,
-0.018737884238362312,
-0.537145733833313,
-0.20113399624824524,
-0.23687176406383514,
-0.6745327115058899,
0.04230779409408569,
-0.9658103585243225,
0.1124376580119133,
-0.4005001485347748,
-0.3413968086242676,
0.11688678711652756,
0.27555927634239197,
-0.8035608530044556,
0.4995417594909668,
-0.22698092460632324,
0.8368580341339111,
-0.9488264918327332,
0.5898744463920593,
0.7446083426475525,
-0.37537145614624023,
-0.7800908088684082,
0.08918323367834091,
-0.06768827885389328,
-0.332211971282959,
0.45293229818344116,
0.14087854325771332,
0.2501620948314667,
0.0593867264688015,
-0.6515670418739319,
-1.1144882440567017,
0.868068516254425,
-0.1043814867734909,
-0.636881947517395,
0.5481714606285095,
0.2680920958518982,
0.5960207581520081,
-0.03956924006342888,
0.43410494923591614,
0.45304566621780396,
0.5232919454574585,
-0.28810158371925354,
-0.5215069651603699,
0.12991079688072205,
-0.11647514253854752,
-0.1251082718372345,
0.16720466315746307,
-0.8176626563072205,
0.5445498824119568,
-0.15630759298801422,
-0.3244348168373108,
-0.13831426203250885,
0.5541268587112427,
-0.025598470121622086,
0.48956239223480225,
0.19247253239154816,
0.3585655689239502,
1.0519965887069702,
-0.0344599112868309,
0.9184146523475647,
-0.11467934399843216,
0.40662363171577454,
1.1691358089447021,
-0.10672509670257568,
0.563643217086792,
0.6669790744781494,
-0.2354671061038971,
0.13433656096458435,
0.7560703158378601,
-0.12013363093137741,
0.7015984058380127,
0.3640841543674469,
-0.3007373511791229,
0.149261936545372,
-0.09371032565832138,
-0.34029051661491394,
-0.017792418599128723,
0.2041996717453003,
-0.3041849732398987,
-0.12220647931098938,
0.3197995126247406,
-0.24598947167396545,
-0.11094421148300171,
-0.2764875888824463,
0.6407855749130249,
0.062180083245038986,
-0.5246263146400452,
0.22142507135868073,
-0.07819259911775589,
0.6878163814544678,
-0.41395461559295654,
0.11426852643489838,
-0.23211681842803955,
0.12467285245656967,
-0.49571916460990906,
-0.6786246299743652,
0.014026589691638947,
-0.35237476229667664,
-0.6393623352050781,
-0.0949929803609848,
0.8961957097053528,
-0.3372722864151001,
-0.4200487434864044,
0.30498865246772766,
0.31491345167160034,
-0.1627274751663208,
0.4183080792427063,
-0.3648408353328705,
0.03255004063248634,
-0.08166158199310303,
-0.6370344161987305,
0.919529914855957,
0.6826845407485962,
0.024411039426922798,
0.47044673562049866,
0.44673484563827515,
-0.3829502463340759,
0.10740003734827042,
-0.08157909661531448,
0.811130166053772,
-0.38268527388572693,
-0.1669209748506546,
-0.55552077293396,
0.4682590961456299,
0.12008689343929291,
-0.6080490350723267,
0.8561204075813293,
0.32695990800857544,
1.1050859689712524,
-0.13572023808956146,
0.8028338551521301,
0.018075745552778244,
0.3810880780220032,
-0.274723082780838,
0.45505043864250183,
-0.28252580761909485,
0.2972807288169861,
-0.42556631565093994,
-0.8164157271385193,
-0.43405112624168396,
0.25981447100639343,
-0.40237244963645935,
0.04356704279780388,
1.0055469274520874,
0.5467473864555359,
-0.0058318194933235645,
-0.02991836704313755,
0.0924968272447586,
0.04538177698850632,
-0.16587390005588531,
0.3358950912952423,
0.4078706204891205,
-0.35940298438072205,
0.554958164691925,
-0.7806372046470642,
-0.47569188475608826,
-0.13091370463371277,
-0.6443895697593689,
-1.1720173358917236,
-0.5075932145118713,
-0.3866561949253082,
-0.41819626092910767,
0.013294416479766369,
0.4861610233783722,
0.10038889944553375,
-0.7966100573539734,
-0.1018102616071701,
-0.10354725271463394,
0.42220747470855713,
-0.4429265856742859,
-0.27860599756240845,
0.2946261465549469,
-0.5178781747817993,
-0.5486390590667725,
-0.04656130075454712,
-0.24517837166786194,
0.06514156609773636,
0.2610904574394226,
-0.04058556258678436,
-0.13817143440246582,
0.15921682119369507,
0.4707956612110138,
0.6013016104698181,
-0.1538277566432953,
-0.3459256887435913,
-0.14846521615982056,
-0.3557909429073334,
0.04761595278978348,
0.7890394330024719,
-0.5345215797424316,
0.4419596493244171,
0.578112781047821,
0.37474796175956726,
0.31564861536026,
-0.08017921447753906,
0.25989076495170593,
-0.8768397569656372,
0.05650619789958,
0.10886377841234207,
0.047058675438165665,
-0.20163869857788086,
-0.5724802017211914,
0.68507319688797,
0.3306313753128052,
-0.6654005646705627,
-0.913612961769104,
0.21081461012363434,
-0.7426386475563049,
-0.4124976098537445,
1.1352837085723877,
0.06792177259922028,
0.02033151127398014,
-0.0652913898229599,
-0.032971229404211044,
0.2764839828014374,
-0.2901836633682251,
1.0059740543365479,
1.0795003175735474,
-0.4786238968372345,
0.04442601650953293,
-0.7542815208435059,
0.6665506958961487,
0.594405472278595,
-0.3920283317565918,
-0.18776877224445343,
0.2838040292263031,
0.25970739126205444,
0.15022391080856323,
0.6126107573509216,
0.13778311014175415,
0.23551538586616516,
-0.05023714527487755,
-0.16055279970169067,
0.09068167954683304,
-0.6118939518928528,
-0.4344443082809448,
0.15675735473632812,
-0.11851650476455688,
0.06673979759216309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12806v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12806v1 | SymBa: Symbolic Backward Chaining for Multi-step Natural Language Reasoning | 2024-02-20T08:27:05 | 2024-02-20T08:27:05 | Jinu Lee, Wonseok Hwang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently demonstrated remarkable reasoning
ability as in Chain-of-thought prompting, but faithful multi-step reasoning
remains a challenge. We specifically focus on backward chaining, where the
query is recursively decomposed using logical rules until proven. To address
the limitations of current backward chaining implementations, we propose SymBa
(Symbolic Backward Chaining). In SymBa, the symbolic top-down solver controls
the entire proof process and the LLM is called to generate a single reasoning
step only when the solver encounters a dead end. By this novel solver-LLM
integration, while being able to produce an interpretable, structured proof,
SymBa achieves significant improvement in performance, proof faithfulness, and
efficiency in diverse multi-step reasoning benchmarks (ProofWriter,
Birds-Electricity, GSM8k, CLUTRR-TF, ECtHR Article 6) compared to backward
chaining baselines. | [
-0.18362568318843842,
-0.7678253054618835,
0.7128554582595825,
0.5894853472709656,
-0.4549592435359955,
0.2203426957130432,
-0.02809401974081993,
-0.3420781195163727,
0.06703809648752213,
0.8092297911643982,
-0.68197101354599,
-0.6225169897079468,
-0.6753343343734741,
0.4476132392883301,
-0.42943817377090454,
0.8052570223808289,
-0.11646270006895065,
0.05933814123272896,
-0.07755744457244873,
-0.16905559599399567,
-0.684016227722168,
-0.5922453999519348,
-0.839055061340332,
-0.5056754350662231,
0.4425218403339386,
0.13832414150238037,
0.6605523824691772,
0.5446098446846008,
0.29039672017097473,
0.2903522849082947,
-0.23608998954296112,
0.4450026750564575,
-0.36322373151779175,
0.690678060054779,
-0.21215656399726868,
-0.7834665775299072,
-0.3676975965499878,
-0.19939668476581573,
0.7467156648635864,
0.418997198343277,
-0.42678070068359375,
-0.054073967039585114,
-0.3345480263233185,
0.8760226964950562,
-0.8512284755706787,
0.3357411026954651,
-0.6263233423233032,
-0.10228609293699265,
-0.165657639503479,
-0.16083784401416779,
-0.7527105808258057,
-0.8651739954948425,
-0.5035452842712402,
-0.4914166033267975,
-0.29225537180900574,
-0.1308562159538269,
0.5151193737983704,
0.3376874327659607,
-0.40793368220329285,
-0.411266565322876,
-0.8414223194122314,
0.7054781913757324,
-0.6688497066497803,
0.7049383521080017,
0.2837279140949249,
0.5617617964744568,
-0.4881225526332855,
-0.6556620597839355,
-0.5797524452209473,
-0.18994572758674622,
-0.008193573914468288,
-0.10942256450653076,
-0.34101375937461853,
0.15660060942173004,
0.3536449670791626,
0.168859601020813,
-0.4406086206436157,
-0.18515117466449738,
-0.2068827897310257,
-0.0833761990070343,
0.566916823387146,
0.31556135416030884,
0.2544044554233551,
-0.009123306721448898,
-0.012017651461064816,
0.040787916630506516,
-0.943788468837738,
-0.1809486299753189,
0.10524745285511017,
0.42588600516319275,
-0.022888369858264923,
0.6423158645629883,
-0.19152015447616577,
0.9371228218078613,
0.017251668497920036,
-0.4158937931060791,
-0.051582787185907364,
-0.5358227491378784,
-0.2993873953819275,
0.3700367212295532,
0.6173194050788879,
0.11748438328504562,
0.3875718414783478,
0.0010099512292072177,
-0.2373509258031845,
0.30327939987182617,
0.10132502764463425,
-0.8638666868209839,
-0.15813596546649933,
0.15802156925201416,
-0.2940007448196411,
-0.15711474418640137,
-0.09700022637844086,
-0.5448641180992126,
-0.3800528645515442,
-0.3686169683933258,
0.38207313418388367,
-0.42370709776878357,
0.01265756506472826,
0.24150438606739044,
-0.03679386526346207,
0.06776324659585953,
0.43470320105552673,
-0.5186448693275452,
0.5823715925216675,
0.8540815114974976,
0.889979362487793,
0.42537349462509155,
-0.15700100362300873,
-0.8510304689407349,
0.4176299571990967,
-0.5995752811431885,
0.8794182538986206,
-0.7975318431854248,
-0.34926894307136536,
-0.26415181159973145,
-0.001152359414845705,
0.09577994048595428,
-0.4218464493751526,
0.3143531084060669,
-0.32934513688087463,
-0.02947275899350643,
-0.1782393604516983,
-0.24091774225234985,
-0.24651964008808136,
0.390042781829834,
-0.4914524257183075,
1.0745015144348145,
-0.34641972184181213,
-0.5301516652107239,
0.15260368585586548,
-0.3589659035205841,
-0.7882288098335266,
-0.2916090190410614,
-0.2213878035545349,
-0.29436200857162476,
0.03881106898188591,
0.3953607678413391,
0.3076794445514679,
-0.5519864559173584,
0.3003895878791809,
-0.49862590432167053,
-0.4346119165420532,
-0.05461840331554413,
-0.1729496419429779,
1.027938723564148,
0.1566137969493866,
-0.17930109798908234,
0.23117271065711975,
-0.8746789693832397,
-0.1737615466117859,
0.2991815507411957,
-0.2851373851299286,
-0.5650768876075745,
0.03335444629192352,
-0.6849100589752197,
0.4804765582084656,
-0.01719444803893566,
-0.5138562321662903,
0.4381299614906311,
-0.5074453353881836,
0.3692042827606201,
0.8855524063110352,
-0.0036570304073393345,
0.1351214349269867,
-0.04406704381108284,
0.523888111114502,
0.03336729109287262,
0.08409378677606583,
-0.45953404903411865,
-0.6836221814155579,
-0.6663869619369507,
-0.0465756319463253,
0.034953873604536057,
0.4642345905303955,
-0.5594607591629028,
0.3358554542064667,
0.05602789297699928,
-0.6577051877975464,
-0.5415396690368652,
0.11011002212762833,
0.4929201602935791,
0.3936559557914734,
0.6061328649520874,
0.017266947776079178,
-0.7004758715629578,
-0.6807428002357483,
-0.33742454648017883,
-0.4346466362476349,
0.09095057100057602,
-0.034355711191892624,
0.4413769543170929,
-0.29781925678253174,
0.559212863445282,
-0.5815370678901672,
-0.23576660454273224,
-0.5244352221488953,
0.1976783275604248,
0.5620672702789307,
0.3492870330810547,
0.04734298586845398,
-0.4961547553539276,
0.012408439069986343,
0.034170862287282944,
-0.8342180848121643,
-0.17882411181926727,
-0.3018912971019745,
-0.2957737147808075,
0.3356422483921051,
0.4717867374420166,
-0.900358259677887,
0.40097546577453613,
0.33645716309547424,
-0.16695839166641235,
0.6216132640838623,
-0.39082756638526917,
0.03911126032471657,
-0.9609346985816956,
0.02987942099571228,
-0.04258660972118378,
-0.10031566023826599,
-0.3871220648288727,
0.2537204623222351,
0.04927811026573181,
-0.09782599657773972,
-0.04974003881216049,
0.32213661074638367,
-0.5139108300209045,
-0.2453835904598236,
-0.22709184885025024,
0.23785898089408875,
0.00452026491984725,
0.2251247614622116,
-0.07052502781152725,
0.5427696108818054,
0.515144944190979,
-0.7447453737258911,
0.6262809038162231,
0.23055534064769745,
0.15621738135814667,
0.6240900754928589,
-0.5823002457618713,
0.3153574466705322,
-0.19764260947704315,
0.7899731397628784,
-1.0517842769622803,
0.11472947895526886,
0.43411901593208313,
-0.22753176093101501,
0.15893244743347168,
-0.19426600635051727,
-0.7261067628860474,
-0.5250029563903809,
-0.2546594738960266,
0.4840012192726135,
0.2708354890346527,
-0.4858979880809784,
0.9596700072288513,
0.28868013620376587,
-0.12470454722642899,
-0.5858802795410156,
-0.7235648036003113,
0.34035831689834595,
0.07915915548801422,
-0.4900829792022705,
0.24278990924358368,
0.049738507717847824,
-0.2555975615978241,
-0.2811567485332489,
-0.5233154296875,
0.06779012084007263,
0.02951568178832531,
0.1949065923690796,
-0.0037960135377943516,
-0.24075086414813995,
0.1229119673371315,
0.529248058795929,
-0.4552447199821472,
0.38313204050064087,
-0.4881046712398529,
0.5879751443862915,
-0.13972951471805573,
-0.47313830256462097,
-0.5104841589927673,
0.32184597849845886,
0.6141335368156433,
-0.3167841136455536,
0.6383615136146545,
-0.04938753321766853,
-0.7559013962745667,
-0.20124027132987976,
-0.4480176270008087,
-0.10221870988607407,
-0.3868831992149353,
-0.14773641526699066,
-0.6299381852149963,
-0.6425537467002869,
0.2832205593585968,
-0.2855403423309326,
0.1728747934103012,
0.14609450101852417,
0.5613096356391907,
0.10897623747587204,
1.15146803855896,
0.46741053462028503,
0.026161853224039078,
-0.2339371144771576,
0.0157393179833889,
0.4587809145450592,
-0.42303434014320374,
-0.6844397783279419,
-0.8067090511322021,
-0.15653583407402039,
-0.5665819644927979,
-0.25704652070999146,
0.20808491110801697,
0.46898558735847473,
-0.41405385732650757,
0.4628259837627411,
-0.36797308921813965,
0.5295482277870178,
0.3027080297470093,
0.1897735297679901,
0.6659258008003235,
-0.3571547269821167,
-0.4144885838031769,
0.2779211699962616,
-0.5090852379798889,
-0.33408740162849426,
0.7123844027519226,
0.1209399402141571,
1.1126232147216797,
0.2015531361103058,
0.8872260451316833,
0.0306925680488348,
0.29602065682411194,
-0.7042621970176697,
0.9335185289382935,
-0.2121003419160843,
-0.4321756958961487,
-0.1166931763291359,
-0.42010051012039185,
-0.832740068435669,
0.294808030128479,
0.07514022290706635,
-0.8718411922454834,
-0.004313412122428417,
0.2045743465423584,
-0.16474787890911102,
0.3044133186340332,
-0.29932230710983276,
0.7065181136131287,
-0.17941483855247498,
0.02127351611852646,
-0.4971538782119751,
-0.8788604140281677,
0.5687552690505981,
-0.1313844472169876,
0.2406259924173355,
-0.02059619314968586,
0.1566612422466278,
0.6151248812675476,
-0.684047281742096,
0.6223235726356506,
-0.05789206176996231,
-0.38284584879875183,
0.20020513236522675,
0.5412566065788269,
0.7599920630455017,
0.0018500746227800846,
-0.03375754877924919,
0.13146208226680756,
-0.0535963699221611,
-0.26852482557296753,
-0.733841598033905,
0.6332910060882568,
-0.19013728201389313,
-0.7934206128120422,
-0.4737290143966675,
-0.44307053089141846,
-0.25149011611938477,
0.4086582660675049,
-0.14886818826198578,
0.2745768129825592,
0.33359619975090027,
-0.07396174222230911,
0.3286297619342804,
-0.21968306601047516,
0.15869088470935822,
0.16430556774139404,
-0.6835958361625671,
-0.6161242127418518,
0.6595112085342407,
-0.03722517937421799,
0.24955540895462036,
0.5548477172851562,
0.2689023017883301,
-0.5234829783439636,
-0.35976311564445496,
-0.3848952054977417,
0.4641212821006775,
-0.9650347232818604,
-0.37215322256088257,
-0.5140855312347412,
-0.1616981476545334,
-0.32624897360801697,
-0.08612272143363953,
-0.5505645871162415,
-0.4306298494338989,
0.16016867756843567,
-0.14787928760051727,
0.1880793273448944,
0.9182366132736206,
-0.09161901473999023,
0.02849092334508896,
-0.8913282752037048,
0.7756404280662537,
0.09931252151727676,
0.32033032178878784,
0.015868358314037323,
0.008014961145818233,
0.0024303067475557327,
0.061341527849435806,
-0.36946240067481995,
-1.1118557453155518,
0.16160324215888977,
-0.11061116307973862,
0.4669022858142853,
0.4821925163269043,
0.07307945936918259,
1.1375771760940552,
-0.3700415790081024,
0.5472587943077087,
0.401858389377594,
-1.1829628944396973,
1.0255793333053589,
0.013197807595133781,
0.3542434275150299,
0.19503507018089294,
0.44730961322784424,
-0.5262112021446228,
-0.8185473084449768,
-0.18399342894554138,
-0.7298588752746582,
0.5686572194099426,
0.40101680159568787,
-0.2965001165866852,
-0.12079984694719315,
0.19163525104522705,
0.23140810430049896,
0.04680994898080826,
-0.637281596660614,
-0.2907419204711914,
-0.11428797245025635,
0.0772576853632927,
0.22875775396823883,
-0.021393798291683197,
-0.01209774799644947,
-0.30523887276649475,
0.7110081911087036,
-0.08998143672943115,
0.20606446266174316,
0.038441337645053864,
-0.07106391340494156,
-0.24428561329841614,
0.3555706739425659,
0.48361945152282715,
0.8463066220283508,
-0.175005242228508,
0.42603451013565063,
0.08064915239810944,
-0.333034873008728,
0.4138666093349457,
0.297044962644577,
-0.1473330557346344,
0.050421468913555145,
0.31118249893188477,
0.4637306034564972,
0.3371012210845947,
-0.4576873183250427,
-0.01321699470281601,
-0.008959341794252396,
0.08709785342216492,
0.008025266230106354,
-0.0015562092885375023,
0.15958380699157715,
0.3841904103755951,
0.37992924451828003,
0.030052846297621727,
-0.05368010327219963,
-0.4881637990474701,
0.10344259440898895,
0.26749831438064575,
-0.09105058759450912,
-0.1643374264240265,
0.6456579566001892,
-0.021416999399662018,
-0.26715952157974243,
0.7425501346588135,
0.013238148763775826,
-0.5271921157836914,
0.5160995721817017,
0.942457377910614,
0.8707356452941895,
-0.2646919786930084,
0.16450820863246918,
0.37788426876068115,
0.5051741600036621,
-0.23393408954143524,
0.5003884434700012,
-0.2615378499031067,
-0.46779680252075195,
-0.7851471900939941,
-0.662065327167511,
-0.4670954644680023,
-0.22367939352989197,
-0.6157723665237427,
0.38222625851631165,
-0.5757066011428833,
0.017327355220913887,
-0.1044844314455986,
-0.404567688703537,
-0.06888630986213684,
0.2205888330936432,
0.2290482223033905,
1.041712999343872,
-0.5124450325965881,
0.9040074348449707,
0.611401379108429,
-0.4175774157047272,
-0.6854383945465088,
0.18002952635288239,
0.17681185901165009,
-0.6349096298217773,
0.8659772872924805,
0.45699170231819153,
-0.6489248275756836,
0.006270197220146656,
-0.3435654044151306,
-0.5908746123313904,
0.9820351600646973,
0.7284015417098999,
-0.6634820103645325,
-0.11006196588277817,
0.12778626382350922,
0.33781328797340393,
-0.16804002225399017,
0.17540843784809113,
0.65451979637146,
0.5886855125427246,
0.28713375329971313,
-0.7847212553024292,
0.5078330636024475,
-0.013447283767163754,
-0.04869154095649719,
0.7194473147392273,
-0.46450161933898926,
0.5680782794952393,
-0.5830513834953308,
-0.4441137909889221,
0.22214506566524506,
0.700807511806488,
0.901863694190979,
0.5970876812934875,
0.3823208808898926,
0.9615603685379028,
0.8760970234870911,
-0.19462692737579346,
1.0688350200653076,
-0.1497657150030136,
0.17923694849014282,
0.9100164175033569,
-0.30373066663742065,
0.7205737233161926,
0.471839964389801,
-0.3813911974430084,
0.7909647822380066,
0.5591827630996704,
0.28126007318496704,
0.38891497254371643,
0.32285451889038086,
-0.18771256506443024,
-0.7396787405014038,
-0.13022342324256897,
-0.530346691608429,
0.23697428405284882,
0.2631062865257263,
-0.11191941797733307,
-0.5006930232048035,
-0.3209112584590912,
0.18891145288944244,
0.00048432336188852787,
-0.44747063517570496,
0.457973837852478,
0.4487031102180481,
-0.615703284740448,
0.7366470694541931,
0.07957429438829422,
0.24767349660396576,
-0.6378110647201538,
-0.38024836778640747,
-0.4277466833591461,
0.23703715205192566,
-0.13890430331230164,
-1.0315499305725098,
0.45236238837242126,
0.017120925709605217,
0.18258611857891083,
-0.1289035975933075,
0.8174505233764648,
-0.08310586959123611,
-0.5546897053718567,
0.5613007545471191,
0.2871261239051819,
0.020062938332557678,
0.0053199222311377525,
-0.6182584166526794,
0.2091960906982422,
-0.32526955008506775,
-0.030743423849344254,
0.008784214965999126,
0.5621911883354187,
-0.14434359967708588,
1.21113121509552,
0.8409550786018372,
0.08907431364059448,
-0.06072840094566345,
0.20863787829875946,
1.031770944595337,
-1.0206258296966553,
-0.7271642684936523,
-1.2370778322219849,
0.2704184055328369,
0.10908850282430649,
-0.04218817502260208,
0.6265896558761597,
0.5810849666595459,
0.7677278518676758,
0.09634074568748474,
0.4887616038322449,
0.21075008809566498,
-0.05184626951813698,
-0.7623080611228943,
0.4131154716014862,
-0.44014719128608704,
0.4777122139930725,
-0.4984390437602997,
-0.8863978385925293,
-0.634648859500885,
0.5836278796195984,
-0.07487802952528,
-0.052861813455820084,
0.8274648189544678,
0.6300281286239624,
0.08186858892440796,
0.4058898091316223,
0.09863399714231491,
0.5092136263847351,
0.3505173325538635,
0.8770041465759277,
0.9373258948326111,
-0.3480243980884552,
0.7352983951568604,
-0.27154839038848877,
0.06731723994016647,
0.23714421689510345,
-1.0196783542633057,
-0.8040246963500977,
-0.31104782223701477,
-0.23013761639595032,
-0.6173418164253235,
0.4297634959220886,
0.904335081577301,
0.5027817487716675,
-0.8669571876525879,
-0.4223603904247284,
-0.5676907896995544,
0.6504932641983032,
-0.479682981967926,
-0.1566351354122162,
0.11237893253564835,
-0.26019561290740967,
-0.2640824317932129,
0.4008069336414337,
0.7405392527580261,
-0.30049508810043335,
-0.28851109743118286,
-0.37067797780036926,
-0.4575822353363037,
0.09378892928361893,
0.79971843957901,
0.19390437006950378,
-1.001502513885498,
0.011888822540640831,
-0.2479272335767746,
0.14324411749839783,
0.08142133057117462,
1.0147075653076172,
-0.9511532783508301,
0.3297531306743622,
0.5533583164215088,
0.7912561893463135,
0.6228690147399902,
-0.08943840116262436,
0.6308653950691223,
-0.45438170433044434,
-0.1947215497493744,
0.13479281961917877,
0.4598376452922821,
-0.012037547305226326,
-0.10264354199171066,
0.468923419713974,
0.593970775604248,
-0.22448770701885223,
-0.9423183798789978,
0.3086498975753784,
-1.084335446357727,
-0.47066283226013184,
0.9778050184249878,
-0.10263927280902863,
-0.04439238831400871,
-0.11038915067911148,
-0.22209632396697998,
0.36824625730514526,
-0.4423460364341736,
0.5943077802658081,
0.535114049911499,
-0.4317229986190796,
-0.4102891981601715,
-0.06324446201324463,
-0.10129854083061218,
0.15969279408454895,
-1.048244595527649,
0.23602087795734406,
0.597544252872467,
0.01881951279938221,
0.21624340116977692,
0.5258844494819641,
-0.27710017561912537,
0.2138037234544754,
-0.06874063611030579,
-0.3444032073020935,
-0.2605019807815552,
-0.6475834250450134,
-0.2053198665380478,
0.2793453335762024,
-0.16295874118804932,
-0.04791782423853874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12801v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12801v1 | Few shot clinical entity recognition in three languages: Masked language models outperform LLM prompting | 2024-02-20T08:20:49 | 2024-02-20T08:20:49 | Marco Naguib, Xavier Tannier, Aurélie Névéol | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models are becoming the go-to solution for many natural
language processing tasks, including in specialized domains where their
few-shot capacities are expected to yield high performance in low-resource
settings. Herein, we aim to assess the performance of Large Language Models for
few shot clinical entity recognition in multiple languages. We evaluate named
entity recognition in English, French and Spanish using 8 in-domain (clinical)
and 6 out-domain gold standard corpora. We assess the performance of 10
auto-regressive language models using prompting and 16 masked language models
used for text encoding in a biLSTM-CRF supervised tagger. We create a few-shot
set-up by limiting the amount of annotated data available to 100 sentences. Our
experiments show that although larger prompt-based models tend to achieve
competitive F-measure for named entity recognition outside the clinical domain,
this level of performance does not carry over to the clinical domain where
lighter supervised taggers relying on masked language models perform better,
even with the performance drop incurred from the few-shot set-up. In all
experiments, the CO2 impact of masked language models is inferior to that of
auto-regressive models. Results are consistent over the three languages and
suggest that few-shot learning using Large language models is not production
ready for named entity recognition in the clinical domain. Instead, models
could be used for speeding-up the production of gold standard annotated data. | [
-0.15186572074890137,
-0.7265660762786865,
0.8325740098953247,
0.15030233561992645,
-0.20657585561275482,
-0.057259075343608856,
-0.3722107708454132,
-0.8577777147293091,
0.0794728696346283,
0.5593840479850769,
-0.37693941593170166,
-0.6248766779899597,
-0.7119139432907104,
0.7451097369194031,
-0.14798423647880554,
0.7717272639274597,
-0.15101119875907898,
0.4820956587791443,
0.07621024549007416,
-0.10123412311077118,
-0.6013363599777222,
-0.5144155621528625,
-0.9077678322792053,
-0.4476035535335541,
0.5724712610244751,
0.30814769864082336,
0.37755027413368225,
0.5016802549362183,
0.8682536482810974,
0.1918879598379135,
0.2126554548740387,
0.1871962696313858,
-0.22711893916130066,
-0.027347687631845474,
0.12647517025470734,
-0.388256698846817,
-0.4931957423686981,
-0.14882314205169678,
0.78483647108078,
0.7124741077423096,
-0.008356988430023193,
-0.114985391497612,
-0.2259303331375122,
0.29298335313796997,
-0.56710284948349,
0.23897753655910492,
-0.7009388208389282,
-0.1042371392250061,
-0.29951751232147217,
-0.0618399977684021,
-0.6207737326622009,
-0.03988709673285484,
0.31735384464263916,
-0.5095312595367432,
0.333914577960968,
0.1335940659046173,
0.8943423628807068,
0.13964234292507172,
-0.17818506062030792,
-0.506504237651825,
-0.6441482901573181,
0.6037049889564514,
-0.6190194487571716,
0.5355798602104187,
0.6581869125366211,
0.23526664078235626,
-0.07531402260065079,
-0.6551767587661743,
-0.49637582898139954,
-0.3918195962905884,
-0.1729607731103897,
-0.0881941020488739,
-0.6826670169830322,
0.17703327536582947,
0.5561720132827759,
-0.17051978409290314,
-0.7956024408340454,
0.5687838196754456,
-0.3392825126647949,
-0.3820299506187439,
0.5557082891464233,
0.262517511844635,
0.18123410642147064,
-0.1130044013261795,
-0.49964582920074463,
0.20562008023262024,
-0.9240411520004272,
-0.1503554731607437,
0.04994720593094826,
0.5790924429893494,
-0.009296693839132786,
0.456706166267395,
-0.15024760365486145,
0.6690486073493958,
-0.0415034219622612,
-0.6378398537635803,
0.010108103975653648,
0.008641055785119534,
-0.4784255921840668,
0.180704727768898,
0.92901611328125,
0.1085876077413559,
0.20442986488342285,
-0.178826704621315,
-0.1543782502412796,
0.18086044490337372,
-0.05300206318497658,
-0.7876672148704529,
-0.4461611211299896,
0.14074961841106415,
-0.2820888161659241,
0.10296031832695007,
-0.3515655994415283,
-0.46655648946762085,
-0.4685917794704437,
-0.006775292102247477,
0.29292604327201843,
-0.5511308908462524,
0.14292189478874207,
0.36252498626708984,
0.06327395886182785,
0.07033269852399826,
0.613191545009613,
-0.7889592051506042,
0.5034867525100708,
0.46005240082740784,
0.8511408567428589,
-0.39313367009162903,
-0.08241205662488937,
-0.6938270330429077,
0.0021751506719738245,
-0.3796209692955017,
1.0375570058822632,
-0.5445670485496521,
-0.3311558961868286,
0.1669801026582718,
0.13364918529987335,
-0.26298341155052185,
-0.6848641633987427,
0.31045669317245483,
-0.6494752764701843,
0.013657579198479652,
-0.15442858636379242,
-0.6585679650306702,
-0.04305565729737282,
0.19333268702030182,
-0.6987736225128174,
0.613836944103241,
-0.12060868740081787,
-0.4437999129295349,
0.6852110028266907,
-0.34675565361976624,
-0.34473416209220886,
0.5817417502403259,
-0.33356600999832153,
-0.4748757779598236,
-0.03738132864236832,
0.19418871402740479,
0.7343233227729797,
-0.20826537907123566,
0.24667729437351227,
-0.13825175166130066,
-0.17266255617141724,
0.14911220967769623,
-0.37024468183517456,
0.5567319393157959,
0.036574237048625946,
-0.006116222124546766,
-0.3120008409023285,
-0.817672848701477,
-0.16264955699443817,
0.26811107993125916,
-0.1952652782201767,
-0.32731565833091736,
-0.4149453938007355,
0.07067317515611649,
0.13267575204372406,
-0.15935224294662476,
-0.40978342294692993,
0.33291566371917725,
-0.28556162118911743,
0.3695419430732727,
0.03550698235630989,
0.44058242440223694,
0.28312230110168457,
-0.15593485534191132,
0.7361338138580322,
0.12979981303215027,
-0.2796878218650818,
-0.3126119077205658,
-0.5919989347457886,
-0.6390604972839355,
-0.8213825821876526,
0.5623180866241455,
0.5563921332359314,
-0.6546676754951477,
-0.1110033169388771,
-0.18926678597927094,
-0.26471006870269775,
-0.6460510492324829,
0.09638314694166183,
0.509711742401123,
0.6213168501853943,
0.44086769223213196,
-0.5109818577766418,
-0.4755255877971649,
-1.027725100517273,
-0.09841806441545486,
-0.2590445578098297,
0.09116663038730621,
0.3968009054660797,
0.7865422368049622,
-0.30244380235671997,
0.5597054958343506,
-0.39185240864753723,
-0.6231728792190552,
-0.35179704427719116,
0.3275804817676544,
0.05146472156047821,
0.278199166059494,
0.524769127368927,
-0.3088468015193939,
-0.46081826090812683,
-0.1171170249581337,
-0.5736289620399475,
-0.07260724157094955,
-0.18487809598445892,
0.23754844069480896,
0.34688806533813477,
0.24585528671741486,
-0.6586632132530212,
0.3541380763053894,
0.43569624423980713,
0.21994301676750183,
0.2985075116157532,
-0.15531469881534576,
-0.003075595013797283,
-0.6129360795021057,
0.021921057254076004,
0.05247464403510094,
-0.6082291603088379,
-0.7519871592521667,
-0.27360883355140686,
0.19271478056907654,
-0.1446312665939331,
-0.7115142941474915,
0.8111085295677185,
-0.6729225516319275,
0.035087473690509796,
-0.29477643966674805,
0.2928915023803711,
0.1911277323961258,
0.2450130730867386,
0.6645453572273254,
0.5986455082893372,
0.6897137761116028,
-0.7009800672531128,
0.21148255467414856,
0.4233771562576294,
-0.3696308732032776,
0.5289148688316345,
-0.5402451753616333,
0.2628272473812103,
-0.05711855739355087,
0.3569534122943878,
-0.7745108008384705,
-0.6307283043861389,
0.2163848578929901,
-0.2603299021720886,
0.6188790202140808,
-0.3137636184692383,
-0.6428364515304565,
-0.28908440470695496,
0.14581084251403809,
0.2734946012496948,
0.2151763141155243,
-0.3948025703430176,
0.06300413608551025,
0.23496493697166443,
-0.14446789026260376,
-0.3947531580924988,
-0.9752988815307617,
0.2598181366920471,
-0.17130382359027863,
-0.3193526268005371,
0.30822843313217163,
0.19192780554294586,
-0.14683985710144043,
-0.22391407191753387,
0.08637171238660812,
-0.29205751419067383,
-0.0006461968878284097,
0.09568879753351212,
0.5131061673164368,
-0.371864378452301,
0.46236106753349304,
-0.2475472241640091,
-0.22536444664001465,
-0.15456189215183258,
-0.14739364385604858,
0.46340277791023254,
-0.08586688339710236,
-0.31847062706947327,
-0.6822069883346558,
0.5012799501419067,
0.048029329627752304,
-0.17889536917209625,
0.8899055123329163,
0.47281119227409363,
-0.9704605340957642,
-0.019581500440835953,
-0.6532387137413025,
-0.10240542888641357,
-0.29989075660705566,
0.21098965406417847,
-0.514136016368866,
-0.9444212317466736,
0.5877066850662231,
0.10905216634273529,
-0.13325631618499756,
0.6063089966773987,
0.8027679324150085,
-0.06371711194515228,
1.025341272354126,
0.5125426054000854,
0.1771136075258255,
0.2295069843530655,
-0.15666188299655914,
0.25778868794441223,
-0.6182719469070435,
-0.08500634133815765,
-0.5088578462600708,
0.11706321686506271,
-0.7179731726646423,
-0.23655207455158234,
0.575150728225708,
0.1813555359840393,
0.21412064135074615,
0.49928879737854004,
-0.2091190665960312,
0.3865288197994232,
0.2245427370071411,
0.08662170171737671,
0.5626400709152222,
-0.10358524322509766,
-0.011554451659321785,
-0.11504129320383072,
-0.7939251661300659,
-0.911229133605957,
0.7524322271347046,
0.5336668491363525,
0.7704711556434631,
-0.04715749993920326,
0.9596853852272034,
0.09332026541233063,
0.3550061583518982,
-1.0264997482299805,
0.3202012777328491,
-0.11182409524917603,
-0.6746447086334229,
-0.018868762999773026,
-0.13107268512248993,
-1.0683351755142212,
0.01818731240928173,
-0.33089661598205566,
-0.7550640106201172,
0.364520400762558,
0.018912430852651596,
-0.9551926851272583,
-0.0322074368596077,
-0.6668078899383545,
0.7455177903175354,
-0.10305189341306686,
-0.21247737109661102,
0.1548352688550949,
-0.5380066633224487,
0.4080635607242584,
-0.17250053584575653,
-0.03734641894698143,
-0.17761601507663727,
-0.22038647532463074,
0.6026678085327148,
-0.13480959832668304,
0.8393847346305847,
0.0764990895986557,
-0.013033664785325527,
0.23178574442863464,
0.12168493121862411,
0.5718708634376526,
0.2339831441640854,
0.22043061256408691,
0.3397939205169678,
0.16535258293151855,
-0.2602478563785553,
-0.3419695496559143,
0.5005585551261902,
-0.45194709300994873,
-0.4446738660335541,
-0.5943896174430847,
-0.19095028936862946,
-0.34581485390663147,
0.37006714940071106,
0.6587043404579163,
0.45068252086639404,
-0.38461852073669434,
-0.173446923494339,
0.6747634410858154,
-0.2283504754304886,
0.4292565882205963,
0.7691065669059753,
-0.02103627659380436,
-0.3448638916015625,
0.466815322637558,
0.1779373586177826,
0.35799792408943176,
0.3520912826061249,
-0.13865916430950165,
-0.14493298530578613,
-0.7069068551063538,
-0.49314355850219727,
0.5533530712127686,
-0.6745272874832153,
-0.6634936332702637,
-0.9899271726608276,
-0.10524776577949524,
-0.6246521472930908,
-0.14561764895915985,
-0.30878376960754395,
-0.2771427631378174,
-0.40021994709968567,
-0.019647641107439995,
0.3183755874633789,
0.680004358291626,
0.09898559749126434,
0.5363084077835083,
-1.0192317962646484,
0.2451595664024353,
0.06736349314451218,
0.21812061965465546,
-0.3745978772640228,
-0.39404335618019104,
-0.25108104944229126,
-0.38234326243400574,
0.021951204165816307,
-1.2119966745376587,
0.6440184116363525,
0.2980186641216278,
0.5064522624015808,
0.4800017476081848,
-0.13961896300315857,
0.7662123441696167,
-0.8312896490097046,
0.6254304647445679,
0.2652401328086853,
-0.6868229508399963,
0.49124518036842346,
-0.12077848613262177,
0.14352162182331085,
0.6932687759399414,
0.6663302779197693,
-0.526134192943573,
-0.24445503950119019,
-0.7179649472236633,
-0.3408266603946686,
0.7016572952270508,
0.11123508214950562,
-0.0371524877846241,
-0.43057844042778015,
0.24798628687858582,
0.25344550609588623,
0.157009094953537,
-0.6427444219589233,
-0.10248611122369766,
0.5244954228401184,
-0.05330860987305641,
0.11368419229984283,
-0.22133769094944,
-0.15223009884357452,
0.20677784085273743,
0.6709815859794617,
-0.2744801640510559,
0.5369229912757874,
0.5192515254020691,
-0.3840752840042114,
-0.3086731731891632,
0.41372963786125183,
0.6872297525405884,
0.19454243779182434,
-0.11230974644422531,
0.15749035775661469,
0.4015211760997772,
-0.5068358182907104,
0.0081197964027524,
0.23078258335590363,
-0.10573678463697433,
0.3490057587623596,
0.7918232679367065,
1.0281111001968384,
0.21342825889587402,
-0.6994906663894653,
0.4450240135192871,
-0.07965043187141418,
-0.032768614590168,
-0.24589279294013977,
0.031657006591558456,
-0.2995482087135315,
0.3953423500061035,
-0.03384650871157646,
-0.0041379318572580814,
0.24427452683448792,
-0.4497460126876831,
0.10649825632572174,
0.5819940567016602,
-0.29292237758636475,
-0.3090999722480774,
0.6161370873451233,
-0.12410267442464828,
-0.298145592212677,
0.5886262059211731,
-0.4009246230125427,
-0.4454464018344879,
0.4017794132232666,
0.6873915195465088,
0.8083441853523254,
-0.06851302087306976,
0.17943033576011658,
0.5430564284324646,
0.2657918334007263,
-0.3655104637145996,
0.043007321655750275,
0.14940325915813446,
-0.7385454177856445,
-0.26107293367385864,
-0.3887661099433899,
-0.5133112072944641,
0.3488055169582367,
-0.5708058476448059,
0.6216633915901184,
-0.45773079991340637,
-0.4977891445159912,
0.43639054894447327,
0.17325282096862793,
-1.1675325632095337,
0.26506656408309937,
0.5579703450202942,
0.8545231819152832,
-0.8540207147598267,
0.7709696888923645,
0.7485862374305725,
-0.5763446092605591,
-0.6574610471725464,
-0.32247987389564514,
0.22722302377223969,
-1.0783236026763916,
0.70384281873703,
0.29680025577545166,
0.04709727689623833,
0.014160079881548882,
-0.6107083559036255,
-0.7823982834815979,
0.9397861957550049,
0.20699168741703033,
-0.7676330208778381,
-0.14723967015743256,
0.16143544018268585,
0.863726019859314,
-0.8174192309379578,
0.29121872782707214,
0.7311460375785828,
0.17518717050552368,
0.08432523906230927,
-1.156338095664978,
-0.17177358269691467,
0.29065001010894775,
-0.10005016624927521,
-0.07437220215797424,
-0.480181485414505,
0.41451120376586914,
-0.49691805243492126,
-0.47956880927085876,
0.0795721635222435,
0.41458559036254883,
0.5488954782485962,
0.5721311569213867,
0.25972265005111694,
0.2660005986690521,
0.923367440700531,
0.0015757156070321798,
1.1114572286605835,
-0.09903126209974289,
0.2739989459514618,
1.029747724533081,
-0.6642934083938599,
1.0586413145065308,
0.22574013471603394,
-0.1895124465227127,
0.32400816679000854,
0.694874107837677,
-0.07702188938856125,
0.4242226183414459,
-0.17942023277282715,
-0.15013541281223297,
-0.35058483481407166,
-0.38919633626937866,
-0.061321914196014404,
0.6127339005470276,
0.4194203019142151,
-0.5298216342926025,
-0.153219535946846,
0.3748232424259186,
0.24383415281772614,
-0.3215080201625824,
-0.17834755778312683,
0.9019300937652588,
0.39269936084747314,
-0.6848622560501099,
0.577685534954071,
0.028858428820967674,
0.26072707772254944,
-0.519558846950531,
-0.06025317311286926,
-0.10121086239814758,
-0.03422613814473152,
-0.24862509965896606,
-0.4105319082736969,
0.05887787789106369,
0.3356955945491791,
-0.1054481491446495,
-0.12517662346363068,
0.8692319989204407,
-0.6584466695785522,
-0.43972983956336975,
0.1337527185678482,
0.5807149410247803,
0.39794257283210754,
0.10098350793123245,
-0.57535320520401,
-0.025823617354035378,
-0.3998784124851227,
0.04172633960843086,
0.32004672288894653,
0.37958863377571106,
-0.24722927808761597,
0.44878095388412476,
0.40806886553764343,
0.3376341462135315,
0.09541484713554382,
0.323273241519928,
0.44352927803993225,
-0.5294094085693359,
-0.21961945295333862,
-0.7621666193008423,
0.17143550515174866,
0.25530800223350525,
-0.20203205943107605,
0.45712628960609436,
0.4595845639705658,
0.7382789254188538,
-0.17602872848510742,
0.43003058433532715,
0.3303958773612976,
0.5726276636123657,
-0.6897435188293457,
0.40089377760887146,
-0.32080796360969543,
0.19495785236358643,
-0.2453681230545044,
-0.6197879314422607,
-0.7602221369743347,
0.5411062240600586,
-0.4338536858558655,
-0.1496705859899521,
0.7377830147743225,
0.6516282558441162,
0.14021489024162292,
-0.1554109901189804,
0.6384888887405396,
0.13816414773464203,
0.17939631640911102,
0.6480919122695923,
0.66948002576828,
-0.5339125990867615,
0.1099335327744484,
-0.24803993105888367,
0.040034130215644836,
-0.3149886131286621,
-0.8885374069213867,
-0.9491999745368958,
-0.3159315288066864,
-0.6672621369361877,
-0.31357720494270325,
-0.11796964704990387,
1.215032935142517,
0.6769630312919617,
-0.9271389842033386,
0.3160429000854492,
0.21088054776191711,
-0.17193619906902313,
-0.0374659039080143,
-0.1754077970981598,
0.38978463411331177,
-0.33642733097076416,
-0.7583140730857849,
0.46172621846199036,
0.579875648021698,
0.18964369595050812,
-0.24716460704803467,
0.11072677373886108,
-0.10904470831155777,
-0.018076179549098015,
0.5120814442634583,
0.3826666474342346,
-0.8704004287719727,
-0.05687911808490753,
0.29452988505363464,
-0.65069580078125,
0.23852336406707764,
0.7344793677330017,
-0.882725179195404,
0.6105546355247498,
0.311840295791626,
0.5079878568649292,
0.4009956419467926,
-0.25405222177505493,
0.12583641707897186,
-0.7200209498405457,
0.0731869488954544,
0.44748422503471375,
0.6134088039398193,
0.437043160200119,
-0.40909576416015625,
0.4607277810573578,
0.30657315254211426,
-0.44216614961624146,
-0.8662427067756653,
0.13948123157024384,
-0.8620971441268921,
0.29779505729675293,
1.2565534114837646,
-0.2893323600292206,
-0.06259388476610184,
-0.18528598546981812,
-0.12040136009454727,
0.1189437061548233,
-0.37562239170074463,
0.497821569442749,
0.8695744276046753,
-0.4711357653141022,
-0.3532203137874603,
-0.8552274703979492,
0.6411730647087097,
0.1492079198360443,
-0.788904070854187,
-0.24227191507816315,
0.658661425113678,
0.2256515920162201,
0.15706801414489746,
1.0023845434188843,
-0.12167836725711823,
0.27814412117004395,
-0.1396765112876892,
-0.19080577790737152,
0.22669650614261627,
-0.4739736020565033,
-0.7722209692001343,
-0.10864154249429703,
0.18079876899719238,
-0.012099855579435825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12786v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12786v2 | Advancing Large Language Models to Capture Varied Speaking Styles and Respond Properly in Spoken Conversations | 2024-02-20T07:51:43 | 2024-05-30T09:06:34 | Guan-Ting Lin, Cheng-Han Chiang, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | In spoken dialogue, even if two current turns are the same sentence, their
responses might still differ when they are spoken in different styles. The
spoken styles, containing paralinguistic and prosodic information, mark the
most significant difference between text and speech modality. When using
text-only LLMs to model spoken dialogue, text-only LLMs cannot give different
responses based on the speaking style of the current turn. In this paper, we
focus on enabling LLMs to listen to the speaking styles and respond properly.
Our goal is to teach the LLM that "even if the sentences are identical if they
are spoken in different styles, their corresponding responses might be
different". Since there is no suitable dataset for achieving this goal, we
collect a speech-to-speech dataset, StyleTalk, with the following desired
characteristics: when two current speeches have the same content but are spoken
in different styles, their responses will be different. To teach LLMs to
understand and respond properly to the speaking styles, we propose the
Spoken-LLM framework that can model the linguistic content and the speaking
styles. We train Spoken-LLM using the StyleTalk dataset and devise a two-stage
training pipeline to help the Spoken-LLM better learn the speaking styles.
Based on extensive experiments, we show that Spoken-LLM outperforms text-only
baselines and prior speech LLMs methods. | [
-0.19225256145000458,
-0.8839336633682251,
0.5072934031486511,
0.4304206371307373,
-0.33960381150245667,
0.18002203106880188,
-0.5268459916114807,
-0.3993447422981262,
0.255085289478302,
0.7213018536567688,
-0.6408913135528564,
-0.5120142698287964,
-0.5108123421669006,
0.3084803819656372,
-0.3708236813545227,
0.7361823320388794,
0.16119956970214844,
0.49980637431144714,
-0.3107576072216034,
-0.08571713417768478,
-0.4324839115142822,
-0.5232967138290405,
-0.7949638962745667,
-0.5316461324691772,
0.23502182960510254,
0.6130349636077881,
0.48288586735725403,
0.3472430109977722,
0.2774558663368225,
0.23561449348926544,
-0.2218581885099411,
0.23291803896427155,
-0.6122809648513794,
0.355922132730484,
-0.1062416285276413,
-0.5117129683494568,
-0.44647419452667236,
-0.08977710455656052,
0.6380120515823364,
0.43046438694000244,
-0.2684714198112488,
-0.13925674557685852,
0.12956146895885468,
0.33073240518569946,
-0.023139918223023415,
0.2930647134780884,
-0.7775309085845947,
-0.00960448570549488,
-0.03582450747489929,
-0.5302619934082031,
-0.5464767217636108,
-0.19758112728595734,
0.16904257237911224,
-0.48411422967910767,
-0.13555102050304413,
0.10777103155851364,
0.57151198387146,
0.06879820674657822,
-0.5298961400985718,
-0.39140480756759644,
-0.7981865406036377,
0.5593072772026062,
-0.9544952511787415,
0.5259457230567932,
0.3837415277957916,
0.25164395570755005,
-0.04819506034255028,
-0.5594327449798584,
-0.5887376666069031,
-0.2704869210720062,
0.03266916051506996,
0.11877156049013138,
0.26222193241119385,
0.12055760622024536,
0.02003595419228077,
0.09685536473989487,
-0.5330918431282043,
0.44178417325019836,
-0.1049732118844986,
-0.13770921528339386,
0.6887875199317932,
0.1990819275379181,
0.0016821804456412792,
-0.2920701205730438,
-0.47361281514167786,
-0.2415221482515335,
-0.7780196070671082,
0.04663969948887825,
0.23768378794193268,
0.5267661809921265,
-0.41273075342178345,
0.2589353024959564,
-0.009856106713414192,
0.7713990211486816,
0.03211195766925812,
-0.7890757322311401,
0.07358697801828384,
-0.24612469971179962,
-0.3211367130279541,
0.14699789881706238,
0.8071535229682922,
0.4459262788295746,
0.5366106629371643,
-0.1727505326271057,
-0.22231760621070862,
-0.40170010924339294,
0.08861777931451797,
-0.7528817653656006,
-0.06312324851751328,
0.0891181230545044,
-0.2993806004524231,
-0.171420156955719,
-0.27327096462249756,
-0.7752413153648376,
-0.4538552463054657,
-0.6636185050010681,
0.5144283175468445,
-0.3114824593067169,
-0.3469012975692749,
0.23254059255123138,
0.048431918025016785,
0.5741108059883118,
0.37379199266433716,
-1.0482898950576782,
0.5037397146224976,
0.6647734642028809,
0.8332228660583496,
-0.2992294132709503,
-0.09103848040103912,
-0.5036236047744751,
0.02451636642217636,
-0.37837910652160645,
0.6154325604438782,
-0.7506259083747864,
-0.6251717805862427,
0.18191365897655487,
-0.07206515967845917,
-0.0875982791185379,
-0.610222339630127,
0.4175903797149658,
-0.39058735966682434,
0.23320451378822327,
-0.14586246013641357,
-0.6520249843597412,
0.039791304618120193,
0.03799401968717575,
-0.2156682014465332,
0.7455433011054993,
-0.04157594218850136,
-0.553539514541626,
0.10283687710762024,
-0.2233283668756485,
-0.5031297206878662,
-0.000261814973782748,
-0.4078328609466553,
-0.4319606423377991,
0.030681956559419632,
0.04191169887781143,
0.6378616094589233,
-0.22343114018440247,
0.37621134519577026,
-0.24428826570510864,
-0.29128506779670715,
0.3360651731491089,
-0.36841070652008057,
0.4299708604812622,
0.02671745792031288,
-0.0374118871986866,
0.33178433775901794,
-0.7614903450012207,
0.08400126546621323,
0.31067365407943726,
-0.3997892141342163,
0.011846781708300114,
0.15947994589805603,
0.23605869710445404,
0.23326615989208221,
0.09216256439685822,
-0.4347611963748932,
0.19769182801246643,
-0.2309291958808899,
0.6411363482475281,
0.8654596209526062,
-0.11284319311380386,
0.40793922543525696,
-0.5330250859260559,
0.46039414405822754,
-0.16561384499073029,
-0.2313469648361206,
-0.2994418740272522,
-0.3101368546485901,
-0.8754966855049133,
-0.20237471163272858,
-0.05523956939578056,
0.7861679196357727,
-0.624459445476532,
0.2667156457901001,
-0.12722134590148926,
-0.37808018922805786,
-0.2883150279521942,
0.10315515100955963,
0.4033096134662628,
0.6589282155036926,
0.3454354405403137,
-0.2922632396221161,
-0.7831096649169922,
-0.7612817883491516,
-0.2418418526649475,
-0.41960960626602173,
-0.1459895521402359,
0.4406498670578003,
0.0688379555940628,
0.08293525129556656,
0.9757590293884277,
-0.243671715259552,
0.11962290853261948,
-0.5760045051574707,
-0.05564142018556595,
0.011717552319169044,
0.10690652579069138,
0.2600829303264618,
-0.6847091317176819,
-0.4388904571533203,
-0.16472621262073517,
-0.5615700483322144,
-0.407680869102478,
-0.33081114292144775,
0.11013484746217728,
0.10564284026622772,
0.701246976852417,
-0.18794310092926025,
-0.054909490048885345,
0.743583619594574,
-0.0008453975315205753,
0.5060101747512817,
0.08930309861898422,
0.042284682393074036,
-1.3436554670333862,
-0.4142499268054962,
0.07617885619401932,
-0.5436512231826782,
-0.8716426491737366,
-0.3846796751022339,
-0.04977237805724144,
-0.35550791025161743,
-0.6224730610847473,
0.6623460650444031,
-0.2704840302467346,
-0.32723304629325867,
-0.33827799558639526,
0.24953781068325043,
0.10773693770170212,
0.6018807291984558,
0.4692395031452179,
0.9980347752571106,
0.7337988615036011,
-0.7041850686073303,
0.5164729952812195,
0.4909532964229584,
-0.5225158333778381,
0.6706556677818298,
-0.7028324604034424,
0.4440062642097473,
-0.15283730626106262,
0.4022206962108612,
-0.9977970719337463,
-0.3306443691253662,
0.03287356719374657,
-0.15974605083465576,
0.668860137462616,
-0.13241241872310638,
-0.3642120659351349,
-0.0056382170878350735,
-0.06446438282728195,
-0.1870984435081482,
0.37602874636650085,
-0.5354191660881042,
0.7479910850524902,
0.2516546845436096,
-0.6951743364334106,
-0.2902674973011017,
-0.5995775461196899,
0.1890341341495514,
-0.42504388093948364,
-0.8259997963905334,
0.31754711270332336,
-0.3031526505947113,
-0.34704074263572693,
-0.6729962825775146,
-0.28222325444221497,
-0.1053469106554985,
0.1084999293088913,
0.04252827167510986,
0.19556881487369537,
-0.15293900668621063,
0.2734783887863159,
-0.09874945133924484,
0.038586169481277466,
-0.0614825040102005,
-0.16578525304794312,
0.9416348338127136,
0.11177189648151398,
-0.4628247320652008,
-0.6482617259025574,
0.45969632267951965,
0.4508708417415619,
-0.13964225351810455,
0.5031859278678894,
0.45954373478889465,
0.15858997404575348,
-0.07666195929050446,
-0.44040578603744507,
-0.411613404750824,
-0.47693657875061035,
0.5227969884872437,
-0.2802988588809967,
-1.139829158782959,
0.26947876811027527,
-0.04512479156255722,
0.3266071677207947,
-0.23146896064281464,
0.6789028644561768,
-0.1746423840522766,
0.7758585810661316,
0.6972988247871399,
-0.0007945812540128827,
0.7982264757156372,
0.14771582186222076,
0.19265183806419373,
-0.7448890209197998,
-0.5116856098175049,
-0.4536358118057251,
-0.2582266330718994,
-0.5336369872093201,
-0.2579224407672882,
0.31907016038894653,
-0.03394879773259163,
-0.11380898952484131,
0.22140906751155853,
-0.13317863643169403,
0.25762495398521423,
0.4409864842891693,
0.22813916206359863,
0.2567116320133209,
0.1321515142917633,
0.09971026331186295,
-0.08702180534601212,
-0.4742494225502014,
-0.7682157158851624,
0.9266790151596069,
0.45999372005462646,
1.0432705879211426,
0.15174172818660736,
0.7259883284568787,
-0.08752210438251495,
-0.05783965438604355,
-1.107414960861206,
0.7124555706977844,
-0.09874113649129868,
-0.1906968057155609,
-0.20698235929012299,
-0.3877981901168823,
-0.5317856669425964,
0.3154054284095764,
-0.1250249743461609,
-0.7482830882072449,
0.05278449505567551,
0.18228477239608765,
-0.16140924394130707,
0.1002262681722641,
-0.6031904816627502,
0.46102824807167053,
-0.27779582142829895,
-0.1377655267715454,
-0.11839408427476883,
-0.753115713596344,
0.06396374851465225,
-0.10588911175727844,
0.20332258939743042,
-0.21030473709106445,
0.05541130155324936,
0.7554396390914917,
-0.18031680583953857,
1.105724811553955,
0.2543732523918152,
-0.3583105504512787,
0.23307888209819794,
0.20684002339839935,
0.35562947392463684,
0.11689365655183792,
-0.143659308552742,
0.06325661391019821,
-0.0795295387506485,
-0.2818702161312103,
-0.6228122711181641,
0.45334428548812866,
-0.7955313920974731,
-0.9324605464935303,
-0.12485004216432571,
-0.6061822772026062,
-0.7049797773361206,
-0.2093970626592636,
0.2539878487586975,
0.7346498370170593,
-0.2653205990791321,
0.22192201018333435,
0.8937337398529053,
-0.054990652948617935,
0.5387395620346069,
0.8453457951545715,
-0.3355916738510132,
-0.3245790898799896,
0.6104006171226501,
-0.051039814949035645,
0.9294352531433105,
0.5427281260490417,
0.31259509921073914,
-0.44892027974128723,
-0.5116146206855774,
-0.3368689715862274,
0.20300032198429108,
-0.7795299887657166,
-0.010334723629057407,
-0.6365045309066772,
-0.16242817044258118,
-0.5230037569999695,
-0.09751833975315094,
-0.04538441449403763,
-0.4184242784976959,
-0.3762127459049225,
-0.10945401340723038,
0.5939035415649414,
0.5412114858627319,
-0.15241971611976624,
0.5444815158843994,
-0.6070348620414734,
0.17657607793807983,
0.7219665050506592,
-0.09230715036392212,
-0.29030367732048035,
-0.9662283658981323,
0.19461847841739655,
0.07655469328165054,
-0.3445327579975128,
-0.9939424395561218,
0.38431528210639954,
0.5968422293663025,
0.41818758845329285,
0.3000321686267853,
-0.24222949147224426,
0.4790732264518738,
-0.5907192230224609,
0.8539687395095825,
0.16744843125343323,
-0.9141890406608582,
0.6330752372741699,
-0.3139849901199341,
0.3319920003414154,
0.3611259460449219,
0.4189102053642273,
-1.0737963914871216,
-0.3615947365760803,
-0.4170668125152588,
-0.6222994923591614,
0.7621588110923767,
-0.005839071702212095,
0.4114792048931122,
-0.009532838128507137,
0.21201008558273315,
0.05144171044230461,
0.3372496962547302,
-0.697845995426178,
-0.20618601143360138,
-0.453955739736557,
-0.14261746406555176,
-0.19186198711395264,
-0.27224889397621155,
-0.4364767074584961,
0.0577973872423172,
0.5455086827278137,
-0.2884621024131775,
0.3559300899505615,
-0.029849383980035782,
0.017799008637666702,
0.0704105868935585,
0.6031780242919922,
0.6662959456443787,
0.7028492093086243,
-0.049519509077072144,
0.23513245582580566,
0.2487078756093979,
-0.25571683049201965,
0.11262049525976181,
-0.033476680517196655,
0.03627759963274002,
0.041673123836517334,
0.6009687781333923,
1.2144404649734497,
0.401919424533844,
-0.7175920009613037,
0.33939436078071594,
-0.07461981475353241,
0.03184499219059944,
-0.015048052184283733,
0.25506141781806946,
0.4007500112056732,
0.24617357552051544,
0.14008253812789917,
-0.2317473292350769,
-0.11473706364631653,
-0.7940480709075928,
0.22640228271484375,
0.3980410099029541,
-0.27204617857933044,
-0.14375784993171692,
0.29430460929870605,
0.3900684714317322,
-0.7775319814682007,
0.3589252531528473,
0.1071614921092987,
-0.6092647910118103,
0.6258768439292908,
0.9513581991195679,
0.6378445029258728,
-0.3893570303916931,
0.25459861755371094,
-0.023058440536260605,
-0.16953641176223755,
0.008675365708768368,
0.37867307662963867,
-0.2639203667640686,
-0.7832891941070557,
-0.41862040758132935,
-0.6643824577331543,
-0.7999155521392822,
0.15103651583194733,
-0.7400367259979248,
0.36307528614997864,
-0.5093514919281006,
0.0005769437411800027,
-0.1452031433582306,
-0.21605032682418823,
-0.40624964237213135,
0.139896959066391,
0.25229212641716003,
0.8137211799621582,
-0.931315541267395,
0.621928334236145,
0.6456605792045593,
-0.10159695148468018,
-0.9343928694725037,
0.13152340054512024,
0.3243796229362488,
-1.124699592590332,
0.5361213684082031,
0.10103560239076614,
-0.2534893751144409,
0.05247776582837105,
-0.6515252590179443,
-0.7032191753387451,
0.9633075594902039,
0.4296545684337616,
-1.0135045051574707,
-0.07920872420072556,
0.1539175808429718,
0.3294357359409332,
-0.46720901131629944,
0.20849500596523285,
0.612420380115509,
0.06638223677873611,
0.6472325325012207,
-1.3583077192306519,
-0.4977102279663086,
0.31682130694389343,
0.0849219337105751,
0.04467179253697395,
-0.8200579285621643,
0.6945673227310181,
0.030977103859186172,
-0.21043802797794342,
0.1069871261715889,
0.6990031003952026,
0.348988801240921,
0.158540278673172,
0.37653154134750366,
0.20466525852680206,
0.8237137794494629,
-0.2439732849597931,
0.7654331922531128,
-0.24248948693275452,
0.1429576426744461,
1.3061277866363525,
-0.4118582606315613,
1.0128984451293945,
0.24301914870738983,
-0.06062721088528633,
0.28153419494628906,
0.7075927257537842,
0.3597489297389984,
0.5112264156341553,
0.15992458164691925,
-0.5800358653068542,
-0.505946159362793,
-0.24153301119804382,
-0.27573105692863464,
0.7761831879615784,
0.3704254627227783,
-0.19159676134586334,
-0.0973288044333458,
0.15244853496551514,
0.4261607527732849,
0.2795243561267853,
-0.3323681950569153,
0.9070350527763367,
0.4285789728164673,
-0.41089755296707153,
0.6785097122192383,
-0.14791369438171387,
0.804751992225647,
-0.8049042820930481,
0.2510760426521301,
-0.23152175545692444,
-0.2234637588262558,
-0.2878558039665222,
-0.934866189956665,
0.11345785111188889,
-0.019203172996640205,
-0.11387523263692856,
-0.5620033740997314,
0.6069953441619873,
-0.6836825609207153,
-0.3183983266353607,
0.21481995284557343,
0.35202866792678833,
0.1702335923910141,
0.3596290349960327,
-0.5045390725135803,
0.40256261825561523,
-0.018908703699707985,
-0.07880914211273193,
0.4214121699333191,
0.3346630930900574,
0.2039177268743515,
0.8355869054794312,
0.247759610414505,
0.07953286170959473,
-0.06818971037864685,
0.49324044585227966,
0.7241953611373901,
-0.23250186443328857,
-0.3854452073574066,
-0.7540583610534668,
0.25653746724128723,
-0.041509270668029785,
-0.3752784729003906,
0.5597397685050964,
0.2500745356082916,
0.7259183526039124,
0.12529636919498444,
0.5222949385643005,
0.21710437536239624,
0.5098342299461365,
-0.9389709234237671,
0.22822293639183044,
-0.38918614387512207,
0.137490376830101,
-0.24560415744781494,
-0.8696871399879456,
0.1286725103855133,
0.9307020306587219,
-0.23643730580806732,
0.16504664719104767,
0.5610698461532593,
0.9333908557891846,
0.1604626327753067,
0.31828758120536804,
0.4889596104621887,
0.20788167417049408,
0.533702552318573,
0.46783730387687683,
0.7546749711036682,
0.0775393396615982,
0.4305743873119354,
0.10067534446716309,
-0.1592530757188797,
-0.11315993964672089,
-0.9338698983192444,
-0.9067022800445557,
-0.5698085427284241,
-0.2721754312515259,
-0.34968093037605286,
0.18352140486240387,
1.0344915390014648,
0.9034531116485596,
-0.5000277161598206,
-0.48786547780036926,
0.11480142176151276,
-0.09947994351387024,
0.03640696033835411,
-0.18596386909484863,
-0.09127454459667206,
-0.3192034959793091,
-0.8183629512786865,
0.8917929530143738,
0.5285844206809998,
0.23873353004455566,
-0.3483080565929413,
-0.10983281582593918,
0.04123856872320175,
0.42191746830940247,
0.6635541319847107,
0.216192364692688,
-0.6576390862464905,
-0.4062258005142212,
-0.03607768565416336,
-0.1674974262714386,
0.31724321842193604,
0.9232670068740845,
-0.4805276095867157,
0.38679733872413635,
0.28364405035972595,
0.5657947659492493,
0.5755428075790405,
-0.15987738966941833,
0.6236210465431213,
-0.8963999152183533,
0.2259964644908905,
0.380989134311676,
0.30078181624412537,
0.6980099081993103,
-0.17074361443519592,
0.14092282950878143,
0.12922295928001404,
-0.5988048315048218,
-0.4678654074668884,
0.7164044976234436,
-1.140762448310852,
-0.10354067385196686,
1.5299692153930664,
-0.009242233820259571,
0.1561930775642395,
-0.04340670257806778,
-0.36234429478645325,
0.2596118748188019,
-0.37748533487319946,
0.41162800788879395,
0.8154067397117615,
-0.3042566776275635,
-0.2993532121181488,
-0.4035756587982178,
0.4336460530757904,
0.48101305961608887,
-0.8785451650619507,
0.07178406417369843,
0.31527501344680786,
0.508459210395813,
-0.15806257724761963,
0.7671228647232056,
0.1484781801700592,
-0.06274909526109695,
-0.282781183719635,
-0.3145555853843689,
0.05414466932415962,
-0.4328269064426422,
-0.32134225964546204,
-0.03554606810212135,
0.20937426388263702,
0.014097951352596283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12784v1 | Understanding and Mitigating the Threat of Vec2Text to Dense Retrieval Systems | 2024-02-20T07:49:30 | 2024-02-20T07:49:30 | Shengyao Zhuang, Bevan Koopman, Xiaoran Chu, Guido Zuccon | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | The introduction of Vec2Text, a technique for inverting text embeddings, has
raised serious privacy concerns within dense retrieval systems utilizing text
embeddings, including those provided by OpenAI and Cohere. This threat comes
from the ability for a malicious attacker with access to text embeddings to
reconstruct the original text.
In this paper, we investigate various aspects of embedding models that could
influence the recoverability of text using Vec2Text. Our exploration involves
factors such as distance metrics, pooling functions, bottleneck pre-training,
training with noise addition, embedding quantization, and embedding dimensions
-- aspects not previously addressed in the original Vec2Text paper. Through a
thorough analysis of these factors, our aim is to gain a deeper understanding
of the critical elements impacting the trade-offs between text recoverability
and retrieval effectiveness in dense retrieval systems. This analysis provides
valuable insights for practitioners involved in designing privacy-aware dense
retrieval systems. Additionally, we propose a straightforward fix for embedding
transformation that ensures equal ranking effectiveness while mitigating the
risk of text recoverability.
Furthermore, we extend the application of Vec2Text to the separate task of
corpus poisoning, where, theoretically, Vec2Text presents a more potent threat
compared to previous attack methods. Notably, Vec2Text does not require access
to the dense retriever's model parameters and can efficiently generate numerous
adversarial passages.
In summary, this study highlights the potential threat posed by Vec2Text to
existing dense retrieval systems, while also presenting effective methods to
patch and strengthen such systems against such risks. | [
-0.025193005800247192,
-0.8352447748184204,
0.630791187286377,
0.05781383067369461,
0.010997130535542965,
0.01531615573912859,
-0.04491405934095383,
-0.6897119879722595,
-0.0438404306769371,
0.7847818732261658,
0.010203278623521328,
-0.12680816650390625,
-0.7177435159683228,
-0.09028726816177368,
-0.6294444799423218,
0.9188957214355469,
-0.10786556452512741,
-0.22279374301433563,
-0.44470512866973877,
-0.12368042021989822,
-0.5188989043235779,
-0.8606298565864563,
-0.5871840715408325,
0.20572587847709656,
0.4968406558036804,
0.41573846340179443,
0.6536189913749695,
0.4013858139514923,
0.6165722608566284,
0.27830854058265686,
-0.0377025231719017,
-0.19059662520885468,
-0.988943874835968,
0.48337140679359436,
-0.15446186065673828,
-0.537992000579834,
0.09178458899259567,
-0.15744444727897644,
0.6770352721214294,
0.23411768674850464,
-0.12351256608963013,
-0.3095424175262451,
0.3295821249485016,
0.7076846361160278,
-1.0438060760498047,
-0.4946304261684418,
-0.8018779158592224,
0.19129227101802826,
-0.16087843477725983,
-0.235008105635643,
-0.6198253035545349,
-0.32283732295036316,
0.430507630109787,
-0.4518313705921173,
0.09048935770988464,
0.09157562255859375,
0.8101473450660706,
0.24364882707595825,
-0.4145169258117676,
-0.31868603825569153,
-0.8783900737762451,
0.6922023892402649,
-0.07220832258462906,
0.22432945668697357,
0.6297988295555115,
0.3553684949874878,
0.1272319108247757,
-0.9673765301704407,
-0.1560402363538742,
0.05195007100701332,
-0.28864091634750366,
0.12301350384950638,
-0.20379941165447235,
-0.26685065031051636,
0.24267041683197021,
0.4162672758102417,
-0.4464782178401947,
0.23923230171203613,
-0.3008529841899872,
-0.2624013423919678,
0.40405383706092834,
0.2753702998161316,
0.4141189455986023,
-0.10338158905506134,
-0.8784659504890442,
-0.15844690799713135,
-0.8105119466781616,
-0.07240339368581772,
0.42618855834007263,
-0.14519573748111725,
0.1333186775445938,
0.5324501991271973,
0.14076104760169983,
0.11013109982013702,
-0.28256410360336304,
0.48453885316848755,
-0.08827578276395798,
-0.7298132181167603,
-0.026213299483060837,
0.15405809879302979,
0.4945381283760071,
0.06771154701709747,
0.07689554989337921,
-0.3097275495529175,
-0.23050203919410706,
-0.46279996633529663,
0.8531398773193359,
-1.0314139127731323,
-0.01978336274623871,
0.178971067070961,
-0.5217661261558533,
-0.45936086773872375,
0.2464979588985443,
-0.7097027897834778,
-0.4896230101585388,
0.046544864773750305,
0.6206851601600647,
-0.5820834636688232,
-0.20219549536705017,
0.0459953173995018,
-0.3531443476676941,
0.14577354490756989,
0.32508066296577454,
-0.9195588827133179,
0.6115294098854065,
0.7815003395080566,
0.8652253150939941,
-0.1293713003396988,
-0.029987888410687447,
-0.27151864767074585,
0.36639055609703064,
0.06707975268363953,
0.4577653706073761,
-0.5074783563613892,
-0.7063702344894409,
0.2186073362827301,
-0.030930835753679276,
-0.0179411880671978,
-0.37679123878479004,
0.6109695434570312,
-0.670769989490509,
0.2065461277961731,
-0.606402575969696,
-0.5939937233924866,
-0.20158922672271729,
0.29344913363456726,
-0.8580247163772583,
0.7465039491653442,
0.19289550185203552,
-1.122940182685852,
-0.04016086459159851,
0.12498040497303009,
-0.3940005600452423,
-0.13226012885570526,
-0.046088553965091705,
-0.5515435934066772,
0.2589721977710724,
-0.19140437245368958,
0.2497018426656723,
-0.10204508155584335,
-0.5184838771820068,
-0.38919684290885925,
-0.49739429354667664,
0.36636242270469666,
-0.5112069249153137,
0.6736862063407898,
0.21791397035121918,
-0.02017238736152649,
-0.36732935905456543,
-0.4552103877067566,
0.22401675581932068,
0.004052732139825821,
-0.26893293857574463,
-0.8656235933303833,
0.06545282900333405,
0.16327254474163055,
-0.11378801614046097,
0.3294159770011902,
-0.4748154580593109,
-0.10507553815841675,
-0.6349321007728577,
0.6380482912063599,
0.6246286630630493,
0.25357887148857117,
0.7834538221359253,
-0.04061337187886238,
0.2542355954647064,
-0.14013348519802094,
0.14421409368515015,
-0.07733787596225739,
-0.09251715987920761,
-0.0718337744474411,
-0.46834853291511536,
0.34883055090904236,
0.8133196234703064,
-0.5683220028877258,
0.03414897993206978,
-0.1932830661535263,
-0.4120008647441864,
-0.14883656799793243,
-0.016323789954185486,
0.5968826413154602,
0.16900673508644104,
0.13951872289180756,
-0.1786402016878128,
-0.5352122783660889,
-0.8513385653495789,
-0.5155729055404663,
0.07555347681045532,
0.03310104086995125,
0.5692833662033081,
0.552301824092865,
-0.30171531438827515,
0.7091295719146729,
-0.5411363244056702,
-0.3629026710987091,
0.2742185890674591,
-0.44750264286994934,
-0.24333344399929047,
0.7208327651023865,
0.641509473323822,
-1.074769377708435,
-0.37051528692245483,
-0.029950711876153946,
-0.8345762491226196,
0.2971082329750061,
-0.055286262184381485,
-0.27253279089927673,
0.16990765929222107,
0.607504665851593,
-0.38762542605400085,
0.8313075304031372,
0.18752259016036987,
-0.28377988934516907,
0.35082241892814636,
-0.5403231978416443,
-0.0077788024209439754,
-0.9548541903495789,
0.10793566703796387,
-0.34565049409866333,
-0.2769721746444702,
-0.5992215871810913,
0.3854812681674957,
0.12641975283622742,
-0.20288139581680298,
-0.48969605565071106,
0.3790668547153473,
-0.34644967317581177,
-0.13721975684165955,
-0.22319960594177246,
0.18858970701694489,
0.24902307987213135,
-0.11455568671226501,
-0.283165842294693,
0.5941300988197327,
0.23994995653629303,
-0.6726951599121094,
-0.33732494711875916,
0.3132226765155792,
-0.08447618037462234,
0.5474551916122437,
-1.0442359447479248,
0.37293899059295654,
-0.014208425767719746,
0.010684016160666943,
-1.027112364768982,
-0.03608092665672302,
0.30884140729904175,
-0.5369476079940796,
0.6379884481430054,
0.019972488284111023,
-0.5991387367248535,
0.08761841803789139,
-0.6615667939186096,
0.7237874269485474,
0.19236283004283905,
-0.5713778734207153,
0.44463932514190674,
0.48543843626976013,
-0.1723536103963852,
-0.7483714818954468,
-0.6718367338180542,
0.3401336073875427,
-0.11832059174776077,
-0.8004153966903687,
0.76593416929245,
-0.04946909099817276,
-0.10835157334804535,
0.21981263160705566,
0.0543607734143734,
-0.13620290160179138,
0.6046624779701233,
0.4472631514072418,
0.053593240678310394,
0.35844603180885315,
0.0019267738098278642,
0.284712553024292,
-0.48403453826904297,
0.10218381881713867,
-0.34663888812065125,
0.21178574860095978,
0.06294922530651093,
-0.18861393630504608,
-0.16729170083999634,
0.6445793509483337,
-0.02368577942252159,
-0.2601601481437683,
0.9592774510383606,
0.6342587471008301,
-0.58059161901474,
-0.025869188830256462,
-0.28765806555747986,
-0.28788310289382935,
-0.42415592074394226,
0.5538781881332397,
-0.19895990192890167,
-1.0231918096542358,
0.42970216274261475,
0.22760866582393646,
-0.14019739627838135,
0.2241053283214569,
0.641150951385498,
-0.06859251111745834,
0.8820832371711731,
0.7449191808700562,
-0.012983269989490509,
0.5237852931022644,
-0.1273292750120163,
0.08357187360525131,
-0.7867209911346436,
-0.5118045806884766,
-0.8158091902732849,
-0.20154312252998352,
-0.7944652438163757,
-0.16142302751541138,
0.28446483612060547,
-0.06448155641555786,
-0.14081788063049316,
0.47117069363594055,
-0.5557498931884766,
0.4612152576446533,
0.3851839303970337,
0.26157718896865845,
0.029450910165905952,
0.5551359057426453,
0.13715185225009918,
-0.13752314448356628,
-0.3590238690376282,
-0.41817882657051086,
0.9639840722084045,
0.4245682954788208,
0.7376968860626221,
0.5172057151794434,
0.8115943670272827,
0.26765117049217224,
-0.24005186557769775,
-0.4301404356956482,
0.14652134478092194,
-0.3409339487552643,
-0.7860422730445862,
-0.27570050954818726,
-0.4716748297214508,
-1.0234715938568115,
0.4311767518520355,
-0.3069062829017639,
-1.0448881387710571,
0.27960851788520813,
-0.2546459436416626,
-0.22586584091186523,
0.0567026361823082,
-0.7238293886184692,
0.5228163003921509,
0.1087351143360138,
-0.7998082637786865,
-0.4386517405509949,
-0.5639769434928894,
0.178879514336586,
-0.11392559111118317,
0.007804075255990028,
0.4522577226161957,
-0.30890390276908875,
0.5354320406913757,
-0.4295848309993744,
0.7088894844055176,
-0.028885161504149437,
-0.13020233809947968,
0.3126090168952942,
0.3464263379573822,
0.5024637579917908,
0.4645187258720398,
-0.09984701871871948,
0.2062644511461258,
0.41290631890296936,
-0.5083792805671692,
-0.49434831738471985,
1.0389491319656372,
-0.8649117350578308,
-0.6623700261116028,
-0.3194830119609833,
-0.24226076900959015,
0.22305366396903992,
0.2949282228946686,
0.47526031732559204,
0.5154328346252441,
-0.33733657002449036,
0.6372615098953247,
1.1320654153823853,
-0.4705028533935547,
0.3608182370662689,
0.3294917941093445,
0.036466825753450394,
-0.6419128775596619,
1.055229902267456,
0.39234980940818787,
0.27011486887931824,
0.5886000394821167,
-0.011922487057745457,
-0.3375398516654968,
-0.4902663826942444,
0.026566511020064354,
0.013071412220597267,
-0.5874236822128296,
-0.13470150530338287,
-0.8296144604682922,
-0.22626179456710815,
-0.39535826444625854,
-0.17141397297382355,
-0.24260835349559784,
-0.48616087436676025,
-0.6372615694999695,
-0.1877373605966568,
-0.041593391448259354,
0.5282973051071167,
-0.029487794265151024,
0.16489528119564056,
-0.8007698059082031,
-0.07026970386505127,
0.13367082178592682,
0.2918798327445984,
-0.08543343096971512,
-0.6757569313049316,
-0.4001391530036926,
-0.10240621864795685,
-0.24685323238372803,
-0.806532084941864,
0.2704564034938812,
0.0008606297778896987,
0.3538753390312195,
0.11069000512361526,
0.0886915773153305,
0.11337731778621674,
-0.46582141518592834,
0.5893924236297607,
-0.12556461989879608,
-0.6420190930366516,
0.38247135281562805,
0.10491839051246643,
-0.25578200817108154,
0.6047707200050354,
0.3507615029811859,
-0.1425013691186905,
0.06637052446603775,
-0.5219746828079224,
-1.087581992149353,
0.36100995540618896,
0.6201639175415039,
0.45092806220054626,
0.06290238350629807,
0.6731236577033997,
0.17367970943450928,
0.08994560688734055,
-0.2262658327817917,
-0.06275250762701035,
-0.30791789293289185,
-0.07528728991746902,
0.21677711606025696,
-0.9516708254814148,
-0.10877758264541626,
0.18988285958766937,
0.445158451795578,
0.2958786189556122,
0.32829999923706055,
0.3758450448513031,
-0.33043384552001953,
0.32926687598228455,
-0.03112182207405567,
0.42480358481407166,
0.03846831992268562,
-0.18315808475017548,
0.26005205512046814,
0.06014638394117355,
-0.8436172604560852,
-0.01457455474883318,
0.15615299344062805,
-0.5005061626434326,
-0.3198906183242798,
0.3065495789051056,
0.5794320106506348,
0.44355860352516174,
-0.2953945994377136,
0.6614118814468384,
-0.3858010768890381,
0.019383249804377556,
-0.6928234100341797,
-0.03955335542559624,
-0.4089902639389038,
0.03341900184750557,
0.2013847678899765,
0.10878298431634903,
0.4902859628200531,
-0.3160027861595154,
0.307395875453949,
0.4648778438568115,
-0.6330984234809875,
-0.3316985070705414,
0.6948313117027283,
0.000548647076357156,
-0.2978762686252594,
0.5462522506713867,
0.3226235508918762,
-0.3468489944934845,
0.5204412341117859,
0.5300310254096985,
0.8754085898399353,
-0.16014105081558228,
0.07162024825811386,
0.34839311242103577,
0.4307817816734314,
0.06830298900604248,
0.12974274158477783,
0.07620477676391602,
-0.4496622681617737,
0.21008816361427307,
-0.23635543882846832,
0.018838291987776756,
-0.5478580594062805,
-0.8308603167533875,
0.028989920392632484,
-0.6732993721961975,
-0.21072448790073395,
-0.24110201001167297,
0.10503285378217697,
-0.6052122712135315,
-0.05376243591308594,
-0.007493679877370596,
0.8921930193901062,
-0.305934876203537,
0.4511423707008362,
0.30753180384635925,
-0.5889484286308289,
-0.5047430396080017,
-0.03289208561182022,
0.07728162407875061,
-0.6415098905563354,
0.2740461528301239,
0.18377085030078888,
-0.08904553949832916,
0.02467942424118519,
-0.5920202136039734,
-0.885151207447052,
1.1229835748672485,
0.3291270136833191,
-0.3535727560520172,
0.046384092420339584,
0.11064586788415909,
0.4719664454460144,
-0.03609052300453186,
0.44508665800094604,
0.3292531669139862,
0.30328822135925293,
-0.24475057423114777,
-0.24505090713500977,
0.45617395639419556,
-0.02264774590730667,
0.31006383895874023,
0.053747862577438354,
-0.49862104654312134,
0.6196370720863342,
-0.1623617559671402,
-0.4315856099128723,
0.41968438029289246,
0.4810396730899811,
-0.14830927550792694,
0.3511434495449066,
0.29515257477760315,
0.7020285725593567,
0.6679480671882629,
-0.015431948006153107,
1.5836410522460938,
0.0009519500890746713,
0.37677299976348877,
0.845663845539093,
-0.2985726594924927,
1.064440131187439,
0.4549902379512787,
0.006144676823168993,
0.49672815203666687,
0.2713935971260071,
-0.015239507891237736,
0.6867201924324036,
0.14893944561481476,
-0.16053976118564606,
-0.07198096811771393,
-0.07014150172472,
-0.537878692150116,
0.29302963614463806,
0.5287681818008423,
-0.5597310662269592,
0.041196051985025406,
0.0886409804224968,
0.18885906040668488,
0.3332923948764801,
0.17530065774917603,
0.8324548602104187,
0.25672826170921326,
-0.2611809968948364,
0.3626817762851715,
0.00966972392052412,
0.1407497376203537,
-0.2807711064815521,
0.15498597919940948,
-0.05491935834288597,
0.3916689157485962,
-0.3623979389667511,
-0.8348838686943054,
0.372207373380661,
-0.3640140891075134,
-0.49344000220298767,
0.022626753896474838,
1.0166454315185547,
-0.18539667129516602,
-0.14443272352218628,
0.4746246337890625,
0.20980720221996307,
-0.05762404948472977,
-0.33558714389801025,
-0.4740094244480133,
0.3377910554409027,
-0.03431668132543564,
-0.31032148003578186,
0.7591368556022644,
0.49266430735588074,
0.07748445868492126,
0.4860300123691559,
0.4664009213447571,
-0.30922141671180725,
-0.14700394868850708,
-0.02434816025197506,
0.8508874773979187,
-0.5211337804794312,
-0.28563135862350464,
-0.926475465297699,
0.3964904248714447,
-0.2201830893754959,
0.0865335762500763,
0.9398686289787292,
0.5396646857261658,
0.6240109205245972,
0.09926391392946243,
0.7402708530426025,
0.03162319213151932,
0.34329134225845337,
-0.6083706617355347,
0.9528562426567078,
-0.46661803126335144,
0.5141502022743225,
-0.28090259432792664,
-0.8027774095535278,
0.0015352665213868022,
0.08935373276472092,
-0.20120124518871307,
-0.06990668922662735,
0.7794076800346375,
0.9245436787605286,
0.23519015312194824,
0.07227178663015366,
0.238087460398674,
0.2335139513015747,
0.46478670835494995,
0.6129980087280273,
0.742219865322113,
-0.733212947845459,
0.8612680435180664,
-0.03451402112841606,
-0.14691311120986938,
-0.327504962682724,
-0.5771701335906982,
-0.592715322971344,
-0.5837792158126831,
-0.24122005701065063,
-0.728001594543457,
0.19851943850517273,
0.01412320788949728,
0.4031125009059906,
-0.504926860332489,
0.3224961459636688,
0.08980365097522736,
0.2789158821105957,
0.09207390993833542,
-0.22140777111053467,
0.31222662329673767,
-0.14300405979156494,
-0.5060411095619202,
0.014913494698703289,
0.26004278659820557,
0.09998881071805954,
-0.28168538212776184,
-0.028094593435525894,
0.004873014520853758,
-0.04005169868469238,
0.5588370561599731,
0.33591243624687195,
-0.32434535026550293,
-0.6897916793823242,
0.010529961436986923,
-0.40794500708580017,
-0.3709127902984619,
0.8205873966217041,
-0.7556196451187134,
0.3856821656227112,
0.6812716722488403,
1.054486870765686,
0.493451327085495,
-0.11064189672470093,
0.4572817087173462,
-0.8065738081932068,
0.06600786000490189,
0.05394890904426575,
0.28080156445503235,
0.22694043815135956,
-0.8125231862068176,
0.5563477873802185,
0.31494930386543274,
-0.6370803117752075,
-1.0360759496688843,
0.27808138728141785,
-0.810718834400177,
-0.3644680678844452,
1.145186424255371,
-0.3275398015975952,
-0.34206777811050415,
-0.0008350550779141486,
-0.4195404350757599,
0.019446533173322678,
-0.06072472035884857,
0.6858717203140259,
0.47112005949020386,
0.6696632504463196,
0.04050369933247566,
-0.5172784328460693,
0.34029892086982727,
0.31063151359558105,
-0.38920286297798157,
-0.10056164115667343,
0.1755826622247696,
0.3250429034233093,
0.09506532549858093,
0.37816837430000305,
-0.5364039540290833,
0.17848949134349823,
0.15627287328243256,
-0.4157971441745758,
-0.0293275099247694,
-0.31224027276039124,
-0.21976180374622345,
0.369635671377182,
-0.1589546799659729,
-0.08227892965078354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12770v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12770v1 | Acknowledgment of Emotional States: Generating Validating Responses for Empathetic Dialogue | 2024-02-20T07:20:03 | 2024-02-20T07:20:03 | Zi Haur Pang, Yahui Fu, Divesh Lala, Keiko Ochi, Koji Inoue, Tatsuya Kawahara | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the realm of human-AI dialogue, the facilitation of empathetic responses
is important. Validation is one of the key communication techniques in
psychology, which entails recognizing, understanding, and acknowledging others'
emotional states, thoughts, and actions. This study introduces the first
framework designed to engender empathetic dialogue with validating responses.
Our approach incorporates a tripartite module system: 1) validation timing
detection, 2) users' emotional state identification, and 3) validating response
generation. Utilizing Japanese EmpatheticDialogues dataset - a textual-based
dialogue dataset consisting of 8 emotional categories from Plutchik's wheel of
emotions - the Task Adaptive Pre-Training (TAPT) BERT-based model outperforms
both random baseline and the ChatGPT performance, in term of F1-score, in all
modules. Further validation of our model's efficacy is confirmed in its
application to the TUT Emotional Storytelling Corpus (TESC), a speech-based
dialogue dataset, by surpassing both random baseline and the ChatGPT. This
consistent performance across both textual and speech-based dialogues
underscores the effectiveness of our framework in fostering empathetic human-AI
communication. | [
-0.4054502844810486,
-0.6954905986785889,
0.6693710088729858,
0.4638955593109131,
-0.20405104756355286,
0.0678391307592392,
-0.20212221145629883,
-0.24286724627017975,
0.3075963854789734,
-0.0058258757926523685,
-0.9034661054611206,
-0.2572615444660187,
-0.16586704552173615,
0.4575633406639099,
-0.18593071401119232,
0.8612109422683716,
-0.28605151176452637,
-0.01631702482700348,
-0.13775013387203217,
-0.18638844788074493,
-0.39361461997032166,
-0.6357318162918091,
-0.6572046875953674,
-0.606749415397644,
0.44644713401794434,
0.33415329456329346,
0.0802813395857811,
0.21090900897979736,
0.25312212109565735,
0.2198885828256607,
0.1605147421360016,
0.22934198379516602,
-0.19565579295158386,
0.4527657926082611,
0.09942171722650528,
-0.5174753665924072,
-0.4846322536468506,
-0.1886139214038849,
0.25329458713531494,
0.05439813807606697,
-0.4766920804977417,
0.046334799379110336,
0.13300783932209015,
0.5366933345794678,
-0.5225568413734436,
0.12437456101179123,
-0.23736989498138428,
0.49044468998908997,
0.2813238799571991,
-0.1237100139260292,
-0.5274667739868164,
-0.5031048059463501,
0.17674919962882996,
-0.691800057888031,
-0.13059329986572266,
0.18464134633541107,
0.8477697372436523,
0.3709537386894226,
-0.25146540999412537,
-0.3537444472312927,
-0.6625761389732361,
0.25890037417411804,
-0.5059676170349121,
0.30488935112953186,
0.5805441737174988,
0.19301043450832367,
0.2825346887111664,
-0.26444336771965027,
-0.7767083048820496,
-0.3615783154964447,
0.03996479511260986,
0.49369367957115173,
-0.14131507277488708,
0.24011552333831787,
0.4788765013217926,
0.19600513577461243,
-0.4297098219394684,
-0.06456665694713593,
0.19902567565441132,
-0.3216719627380371,
0.27640262246131897,
0.32259082794189453,
0.14762842655181885,
-0.15819613635540009,
-0.2746492922306061,
-0.15617665648460388,
-0.3392370343208313,
0.15086093544960022,
0.08077950030565262,
0.04634067043662071,
-0.49973082542419434,
0.5190213322639465,
-0.24085381627082825,
0.2591041624546051,
0.4710797667503357,
0.23635028302669525,
0.2577822506427765,
-0.09294937551021576,
-0.27976560592651367,
0.14575205743312836,
0.5504752397537231,
0.662433385848999,
0.17692765593528748,
-0.09086932986974716,
-0.1275816559791565,
0.3774482011795044,
0.3380562961101532,
-0.7180874943733215,
-0.056677162647247314,
0.3678353726863861,
-0.3791663348674774,
-0.11010510474443436,
-0.06102186068892479,
-0.7533165812492371,
-0.517402172088623,
-0.28280729055404663,
0.44024062156677246,
-0.46440786123275757,
-0.3409769833087921,
-0.23542235791683197,
-0.02991791069507599,
0.22759145498275757,
0.6589077115058899,
-0.5756137371063232,
0.07878143340349197,
0.5346167683601379,
0.7962236404418945,
0.29112619161605835,
-0.3827894628047943,
-0.23425620794296265,
0.09171135723590851,
-0.16017256677150726,
0.6754732728004456,
-0.460005521774292,
-0.3253868818283081,
0.09858212620019913,
-0.13972799479961395,
0.06944742798805237,
-0.2139892578125,
0.7370079755783081,
-0.07766406983137131,
0.08889811486005783,
-0.40901443362236023,
-0.48422640562057495,
-0.09259449690580368,
0.7758920192718506,
-0.3240111768245697,
0.6947203278541565,
0.09032192081212997,
-0.6242243647575378,
0.3823122978210449,
-0.9879266023635864,
-0.4507707953453064,
-0.1190418228507042,
0.019931292161345482,
-0.12573286890983582,
0.27847445011138916,
0.3109526038169861,
0.29229429364204407,
-0.15252326428890228,
0.03280911594629288,
-0.2387220710515976,
-0.19415320456027985,
0.32728391885757446,
-0.38298046588897705,
0.34246745705604553,
0.4495171308517456,
-0.2930305004119873,
-0.06457572430372238,
-0.7237846851348877,
0.10130085051059723,
0.004444540478289127,
-0.39734721183776855,
-0.09408053755760193,
-0.3400154411792755,
0.07263296097517014,
0.3717970550060272,
-0.07520849257707596,
-1.015397310256958,
-0.06269282102584839,
-0.2898009717464447,
0.48590222001075745,
0.7460911870002747,
0.18742163479328156,
0.14666470885276794,
-0.3972737193107605,
0.5920825004577637,
0.3690372705459595,
0.1295977681875229,
-0.768907904624939,
-0.224336177110672,
-0.7379701733589172,
-0.01193140633404255,
0.06736575812101364,
0.5715833306312561,
-0.6648439168930054,
0.6594980359077454,
-0.03286638855934143,
-0.6950663328170776,
-0.8001852631568909,
-0.45179006457328796,
0.3492070436477661,
0.7304394841194153,
0.18715524673461914,
-0.4327567219734192,
-0.6751229763031006,
-0.5887725353240967,
-0.11716562509536743,
-0.5692964792251587,
-0.19213159382343292,
0.6033477187156677,
0.1723877489566803,
-0.1573413461446762,
0.9390110373497009,
-0.10018635541200638,
-0.0246712788939476,
-0.03685900568962097,
0.563427746295929,
-0.23264946043491364,
0.4251145124435425,
0.23155181109905243,
-0.4993545413017273,
-0.4016510546207428,
-0.03593255206942558,
-0.6927226781845093,
-0.2508479356765747,
-0.1157502606511116,
-0.18646839261054993,
0.2848193645477295,
0.04122619703412056,
-0.4215899705886841,
0.5833980441093445,
0.4524601697921753,
-0.5860667824745178,
0.1994955837726593,
-0.11442292481660843,
0.8251168727874756,
-1.1173592805862427,
0.08132410049438477,
-0.03629863262176514,
-0.5044283866882324,
-0.46717631816864014,
-0.43973779678344727,
-0.12473499029874802,
-0.1736871898174286,
-0.22453853487968445,
0.4328610897064209,
0.10226569324731827,
0.15902435779571533,
-0.19256186485290527,
0.2716796398162842,
0.04623757675290108,
0.6234278678894043,
0.28546762466430664,
0.0943843200802803,
0.4129641652107239,
-0.5618728995323181,
0.6069870591163635,
0.7161568403244019,
0.00941078457981348,
1.2714591026306152,
-0.6269060373306274,
0.3976457118988037,
-0.20076337456703186,
0.6603699326515198,
-0.9129971265792847,
-0.16758230328559875,
0.3705310821533203,
-0.6196192502975464,
0.05559481680393219,
0.041830819100141525,
-0.32978278398513794,
-0.3662557303905487,
0.00624718377366662,
0.3195083439350128,
0.48404762148857117,
-0.6161982417106628,
1.098523497581482,
0.1313842535018921,
-0.17596741020679474,
-0.21158276498317719,
-0.7037332057952881,
0.10107720643281937,
-0.09385702013969421,
-0.5586698055267334,
-0.20404376089572906,
-0.33755701780319214,
-0.10961468517780304,
-0.21623124182224274,
0.11434602737426758,
0.0729166641831398,
0.10366687178611755,
0.5076292157173157,
-0.016144338995218277,
-0.008067077025771141,
0.20023605227470398,
0.1298108696937561,
-0.1592090129852295,
0.2390507459640503,
0.23416668176651,
0.7010725736618042,
-0.19206464290618896,
-0.5143977403640747,
-0.8437369465827942,
0.37554141879081726,
0.5002697706222534,
-0.08785590529441833,
0.397413969039917,
0.7170290350914001,
-0.6419238448143005,
0.10371453315019608,
-0.5312365889549255,
-0.4472518265247345,
-0.34766849875450134,
0.16847114264965057,
-0.25925764441490173,
-0.7981112599372864,
0.5133160352706909,
-0.12420564889907837,
0.09402020275592804,
0.23717756569385529,
0.9241792559623718,
-0.1731305718421936,
1.3355872631072998,
0.38508594036102295,
-0.07656515389680862,
0.4144585132598877,
0.37020930647850037,
0.3704092502593994,
-0.9433990716934204,
-0.17437994480133057,
-0.6633312106132507,
-0.23906929790973663,
-0.48990827798843384,
0.01968534290790558,
0.29347914457321167,
-0.5490606427192688,
-0.6105437278747559,
-0.11417627334594727,
-0.21475493907928467,
-0.02218589372932911,
0.388931542634964,
0.4187820553779602,
0.07898354530334473,
-0.09690719842910767,
-0.1953519880771637,
-0.11366858333349228,
-0.4481377899646759,
-0.46881103515625,
0.7087349891662598,
0.6284769773483276,
0.7706013321876526,
-0.005026176571846008,
0.9830788969993591,
0.4278149902820587,
0.744693398475647,
-0.8046284914016724,
0.4057703912258148,
0.4041779339313507,
-0.4953230619430542,
-0.08954993635416031,
-0.30574989318847656,
-0.46808701753616333,
-0.17211294174194336,
-0.1546408087015152,
-1.0379838943481445,
-0.02732226997613907,
0.34095460176467896,
-0.6136600971221924,
-0.07747424393892288,
-0.725788950920105,
0.4301298260688782,
-0.1932966709136963,
-0.2516666650772095,
-0.32012245059013367,
-0.7011591196060181,
-0.08452394604682922,
0.08223072439432144,
-0.0019513487350195646,
-0.20491419732570648,
0.27321961522102356,
0.776761531829834,
-0.3114731013774872,
0.8542541265487671,
-0.4268054664134979,
0.013896266929805279,
0.20387206971645355,
0.31075623631477356,
0.45703136920928955,
0.01895047537982464,
0.05610981956124306,
-0.12636291980743408,
-0.10127145051956177,
0.005044356919825077,
-0.6016713380813599,
0.39185985922813416,
-0.8099665641784668,
-0.3544822335243225,
-0.2801404893398285,
-0.33365511894226074,
-0.4981323182582855,
0.00238447985611856,
0.15933740139007568,
0.19419263303279877,
-0.35594725608825684,
0.1039561778306961,
0.46765372157096863,
-0.18597614765167236,
0.1785164177417755,
0.5425687432289124,
-0.21886102855205536,
-0.34937310218811035,
0.6724712252616882,
-0.49366295337677,
0.12681441009044647,
0.31529152393341064,
0.31055745482444763,
-0.1979856938123703,
0.26258140802383423,
-0.307392954826355,
0.10570216178894043,
-0.710019588470459,
-0.3821462094783783,
-0.6383606791496277,
0.03097609616816044,
-0.2761811316013336,
-0.2633117437362671,
-0.3802691400051117,
-0.35791367292404175,
-0.035847824066877365,
-0.3811090886592865,
0.4124913215637207,
0.9104304313659668,
-0.3205251693725586,
0.22295542061328888,
-0.9414329528808594,
0.1199188381433487,
0.013027375563979149,
0.3328343331813812,
0.25541970133781433,
-0.5436867475509644,
-0.27745604515075684,
0.3604600727558136,
-0.3994309604167938,
-0.81392902135849,
0.23852984607219696,
0.1894628405570984,
0.23666250705718994,
0.5181984305381775,
-0.05394142493605614,
0.6416684985160828,
-0.36217817664146423,
1.0799121856689453,
0.3432770371437073,
-1.1815516948699951,
1.0237736701965332,
-0.29049113392829895,
0.15981002151966095,
0.5097598433494568,
0.21484434604644775,
-0.9030555486679077,
-0.521944522857666,
-0.8615167737007141,
-0.8217690587043762,
0.7902201414108276,
0.1786792129278183,
0.22524084150791168,
0.07870355248451233,
0.45998501777648926,
-0.09028633683919907,
0.3062501549720764,
-0.5759094953536987,
-0.23242878913879395,
-0.4387890100479126,
-0.6568829417228699,
0.05865911766886711,
-0.12229599803686142,
-0.4867282211780548,
-0.013575883582234383,
0.6985772252082825,
-0.2355187088251114,
0.7701879143714905,
0.46657824516296387,
-0.10902253538370132,
-0.3935536742210388,
0.22504141926765442,
0.45946648716926575,
0.09473181515932083,
-0.12180238962173462,
-0.14022882282733917,
0.003781929612159729,
-0.3030761182308197,
0.3414456248283386,
0.05060674995183945,
0.1428370624780655,
-0.2534823417663574,
0.06874462217092514,
0.7655407190322876,
-0.09735723584890366,
-0.5889206528663635,
0.3901449143886566,
-0.4994117021560669,
0.024432767182588577,
0.06113877892494202,
-0.10723578929901123,
-0.18352441489696503,
0.357695996761322,
0.08752232789993286,
0.00949817430227995,
0.1577821522951126,
-0.3349810242652893,
0.23933951556682587,
-0.17523866891860962,
-0.42929863929748535,
-0.5691606402397156,
0.3491087853908539,
0.5033757090568542,
-0.400930255651474,
0.7602183818817139,
-0.040510207414627075,
-0.8848075866699219,
0.4037874937057495,
0.569176197052002,
1.045763373374939,
-0.42334455251693726,
0.28665900230407715,
0.5590475797653198,
0.03752851486206055,
0.04193016514182091,
0.5195126533508301,
-0.4909535050392151,
-0.9815950989723206,
0.24462080001831055,
-0.5046004056930542,
-0.7795268297195435,
-0.3877367377281189,
-0.9896916747093201,
-0.07440753281116486,
-0.5230926871299744,
-0.2942918539047241,
-0.42930710315704346,
-0.2213965803384781,
-0.9875138401985168,
0.4011736214160919,
0.5884878039360046,
0.9414520263671875,
-1.1791223287582397,
0.229717418551445,
0.8758101463317871,
-0.4515320360660553,
-1.1155543327331543,
0.11819435656070709,
0.19333821535110474,
-0.9221644401550293,
0.36814144253730774,
0.24527159333229065,
-0.13344396650791168,
0.011771725490689278,
-0.3335023820400238,
-0.26915258169174194,
1.0180542469024658,
0.10697134584188461,
-0.4525431990623474,
0.1319819688796997,
0.09981416165828705,
0.7503746151924133,
-0.6050605773925781,
0.7131044268608093,
0.5325698852539062,
0.5805121660232544,
0.033105336129665375,
-1.112459659576416,
0.10410086810588837,
-0.38898003101348877,
-0.090891994535923,
-0.23738467693328857,
-0.878110408782959,
0.3108901083469391,
-0.06758446246385574,
-0.10231469571590424,
0.28196531534194946,
0.5971562266349792,
0.5098636150360107,
0.41602596640586853,
0.6777001023292542,
0.6489782333374023,
0.9603061676025391,
-0.5371832251548767,
0.8657196164131165,
-0.4051956832408905,
0.2958245575428009,
0.8419232964515686,
-0.5134788751602173,
0.9149762988090515,
0.48375028371810913,
-0.10020465403795242,
0.6204016208648682,
0.8017759323120117,
0.163483664393425,
0.31332194805145264,
-0.041169650852680206,
-0.39240264892578125,
-0.1904805451631546,
-0.6706275939941406,
-0.16785535216331482,
0.5184442400932312,
0.43061867356300354,
-0.3785642385482788,
-0.060768287628889084,
0.3095036745071411,
-0.03460794687271118,
-0.10728658735752106,
-0.4685037434101105,
0.9569705724716187,
0.06655068695545197,
-0.7947816252708435,
0.0712956115603447,
-0.1685013473033905,
0.44593364000320435,
-0.477232426404953,
0.042575228959321976,
-0.3236088752746582,
0.1587027609348297,
-0.18313995003700256,
-0.769231915473938,
-0.11611311882734299,
0.35198134183883667,
-0.0969376415014267,
-0.2840510606765747,
0.5047427415847778,
-0.5583899021148682,
-0.11862365156412125,
0.005279102362692356,
0.4568397104740143,
-0.045205261558294296,
0.129158154129982,
-0.6285836100578308,
0.22590577602386475,
-0.02911151945590973,
-0.4421956539154053,
0.04776805266737938,
0.655642032623291,
0.47699400782585144,
0.5446857213973999,
0.23435866832733154,
-0.08496986329555511,
-0.26892590522766113,
0.480771005153656,
0.7364597320556641,
-0.5257598161697388,
-0.9851469397544861,
-0.6241469383239746,
0.6831818222999573,
0.08317737281322479,
-0.19207361340522766,
0.501549243927002,
0.08206568658351898,
0.5055013298988342,
0.08651846647262573,
1.01945960521698,
-0.29540807008743286,
0.5536479949951172,
-0.4385946989059448,
0.4569171667098999,
-0.36589258909225464,
-0.10200516134500504,
-0.3817031681537628,
-0.6411145925521851,
-0.05796825885772705,
1.004117488861084,
-0.010227222926914692,
0.5001085996627808,
0.5870806574821472,
0.5698323845863342,
0.43742847442626953,
0.49519991874694824,
0.22485768795013428,
0.48819905519485474,
0.5112512707710266,
0.8238587379455566,
1.2632861137390137,
-0.22044137120246887,
0.08886255323886871,
-0.18385684490203857,
-0.4598855674266815,
-0.16116636991500854,
-1.0733634233474731,
-0.6118704080581665,
-0.6198801398277283,
-0.2455127090215683,
-0.6499212980270386,
-0.0500645637512207,
1.4815603494644165,
0.4500002861022949,
-0.601105272769928,
-0.012554739601910114,
0.08458440005779266,
-0.32834064960479736,
-0.12010160833597183,
-0.24873673915863037,
-0.10041273385286331,
-0.14921967685222626,
-0.5666264891624451,
0.013243659399449825,
0.43669769167900085,
0.09319595992565155,
-0.14946243166923523,
-0.41204044222831726,
0.15024054050445557,
0.09891211241483688,
0.4625430107116699,
0.2691139876842499,
-0.5136030316352844,
-0.4481598436832428,
-0.10347042977809906,
0.10507082939147949,
0.2944011688232422,
1.1406611204147339,
-0.5668467879295349,
0.4852725863456726,
0.1661139875650406,
0.6592972278594971,
0.07419663667678833,
0.23083627223968506,
0.9025835394859314,
-0.7609798312187195,
0.04330659657716751,
0.4240042567253113,
0.5145992040634155,
0.4740033447742462,
-0.5755683183670044,
0.25342345237731934,
0.11556875705718994,
-0.7205984592437744,
-0.8360674977302551,
0.2723381519317627,
-1.0184701681137085,
0.6129202842712402,
0.9459995031356812,
-0.61262446641922,
-0.1475774049758911,
0.08899615705013275,
-0.5203728675842285,
0.38632485270500183,
-0.7343602180480957,
0.8263980746269226,
1.1323546171188354,
-0.48837924003601074,
-0.23981823027133942,
0.18261225521564484,
0.46001169085502625,
0.36806705594062805,
-1.1166409254074097,
0.43257617950439453,
0.4952937364578247,
-0.001120728556998074,
0.2636256814002991,
0.593757152557373,
0.12659384310245514,
0.5816261768341064,
-0.048363350331783295,
-0.0336274579167366,
0.04306425154209137,
-0.2672041058540344,
-0.4582200348377228,
-0.10124257206916809,
0.21231795847415924,
0.044169045984745026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12750v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12750v1 | Model Composition for Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-02-20T06:38:10 | 2024-02-20T06:38:10 | Chi Chen, Yiyang Du, Zheng Fang, Ziyue Wang, Fuwen Luo, Peng Li, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Maosong Sun, Yang Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent developments in Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have shown
rapid progress, moving towards the goal of creating versatile MLLMs that
understand inputs from various modalities. However, existing methods typically
rely on joint training with paired multimodal instruction data, which is
resource-intensive and challenging to extend to new modalities. In this paper,
we propose a new paradigm through the model composition of existing MLLMs to
create a new model that retains the modal understanding capabilities of each
original model. Our basic implementation, NaiveMC, demonstrates the
effectiveness of this paradigm by reusing modality encoders and merging LLM
parameters. Furthermore, we introduce DAMC to address parameter interference
and mismatch issues during the merging process, thereby enhancing the model
performance. To facilitate research in this area, we propose MCUB, a benchmark
for assessing ability of MLLMs to understand inputs from diverse modalities.
Experiments on this benchmark and four other multimodal understanding tasks
show significant improvements over baselines, proving that model composition
can create a versatile model capable of processing inputs from multiple
modalities. | [
-0.5011911988258362,
-0.8132771253585815,
0.5231712460517883,
0.26945292949676514,
-0.14551758766174316,
0.2666226327419281,
-0.39672887325286865,
-0.2896728515625,
-0.1850840449333191,
0.3847188651561737,
-0.4488126039505005,
-0.3151673674583435,
-0.4992177188396454,
-0.003763671265915036,
-0.05032971128821373,
0.9718410968780518,
-0.14275631308555603,
0.3388757109642029,
-0.48220184445381165,
-0.24047809839248657,
-0.6432511806488037,
-0.2861436903476715,
-0.27122193574905396,
-0.11711116135120392,
0.7810788750648499,
0.3275267779827118,
0.5561062693595886,
0.46792811155319214,
0.4177868068218231,
0.34484899044036865,
0.0310748890042305,
0.6037227511405945,
-0.2718678414821625,
0.27267301082611084,
-0.11472868919372559,
-0.32081469893455505,
-0.6421842575073242,
0.02102869376540184,
1.1494542360305786,
0.9838476777076721,
-0.07143738865852356,
0.0031609185971319675,
0.16277813911437988,
0.2646741271018982,
-1.0145885944366455,
0.13645100593566895,
-0.5785865187644958,
-0.10977943241596222,
0.11930619925260544,
-0.048000749200582504,
-0.7483018040657043,
0.2185736447572708,
-0.13347378373146057,
-0.374714732170105,
0.008695093914866447,
0.004970860667526722,
0.29070863127708435,
-0.0074811228550970554,
-0.8799922466278076,
-0.10392686724662781,
-0.6517256498336792,
0.9365226030349731,
-0.750212550163269,
0.9572610259056091,
0.2602487802505493,
0.3530098497867584,
0.001957876840606332,
-0.5457248091697693,
-0.6029004454612732,
-0.6641252040863037,
-0.058050885796546936,
0.04457749426364899,
0.075919970870018,
0.0008971492643468082,
0.055371325463056564,
0.11057672649621964,
-0.6267715692520142,
0.1167076975107193,
-0.2634485065937042,
-0.3206171691417694,
0.3088149130344391,
0.4519115686416626,
0.2443249225616455,
-0.26089420914649963,
-0.5390027761459351,
-0.03770182281732559,
-0.3570774495601654,
0.025308571755886078,
0.2358357161283493,
0.35824066400527954,
-0.4015906751155853,
0.6118677258491516,
-0.05786673724651337,
1.0888148546218872,
-0.2019507884979248,
-0.6044632196426392,
0.16550777852535248,
-0.6228872537612915,
-0.3569687604904175,
-0.25317999720573425,
0.7498263716697693,
0.27470481395721436,
-0.10471568256616592,
-0.2143092155456543,
-0.32851412892341614,
-0.19308380782604218,
0.2895856201648712,
-0.7192595601081848,
-0.20180219411849976,
-0.03424955904483795,
-0.44856947660446167,
-0.2503872513771057,
-0.18871182203292847,
-0.48612889647483826,
-0.3964964747428894,
-0.7617721557617188,
0.4007771909236908,
-0.4322509169578552,
-0.4816872775554657,
-0.09915343672037125,
0.21818161010742188,
0.049749359488487244,
0.35904935002326965,
-0.9457506537437439,
0.08875904977321625,
0.6331466436386108,
0.812364935874939,
-0.14990973472595215,
-0.44082608819007874,
-0.6099653244018555,
0.46773114800453186,
-0.17416532337665558,
0.5283886194229126,
-0.8016101717948914,
-0.29410430788993835,
-0.20234403014183044,
0.024107428267598152,
-0.31737908720970154,
-0.24754753708839417,
0.25949230790138245,
-0.5109699964523315,
0.17377331852912903,
-0.09710951894521713,
-0.4436132311820984,
-0.33280515670776367,
0.5814801454544067,
-0.7256283164024353,
0.7907780408859253,
0.1753372699022293,
-0.6268638968467712,
0.2525360584259033,
-0.3744620978832245,
-0.5152527093887329,
-0.11105374246835709,
-0.048130929470062256,
-0.11009546369314194,
0.3251567482948303,
0.2894875705242157,
0.7316989302635193,
-0.25335693359375,
0.41515761613845825,
-0.6065961718559265,
-0.02509734034538269,
0.7905437350273132,
-0.8330726623535156,
0.6219218969345093,
0.3846805691719055,
0.2362103909254074,
0.3015533983707428,
-0.9027957916259766,
-0.03312899172306061,
-0.29017573595046997,
-0.4951547682285309,
-0.21784834563732147,
-0.12199129164218903,
0.3490114212036133,
0.20027479529380798,
0.31922927498817444,
-0.23513908684253693,
0.203664168715477,
0.14773672819137573,
0.3383611738681793,
0.6743733882904053,
-0.14210708439350128,
0.6827747821807861,
-0.4414774477481842,
0.41424551606178284,
0.2451108992099762,
0.1560022532939911,
-0.31763365864753723,
-0.15957173705101013,
-0.838080108165741,
-0.6860732436180115,
0.4909674823284149,
0.23395974934101105,
-0.776367723941803,
0.09758023172616959,
-0.34233152866363525,
-0.39776018261909485,
-0.4618460536003113,
0.3129003345966339,
0.29981765151023865,
0.378953754901886,
0.28302520513534546,
-0.2656984329223633,
-0.6206347942352295,
-0.9693403244018555,
0.03800399601459503,
0.05823690444231033,
-0.0093624172732234,
0.29714396595954895,
0.21300940215587616,
-0.3046245872974396,
0.7005116939544678,
-0.1063820943236351,
0.029267024248838425,
-0.5057305693626404,
0.20391853153705597,
-0.08726933598518372,
0.6569816470146179,
0.3296898901462555,
-0.7998836636543274,
-0.3908047080039978,
0.1310434192419052,
-0.6242099404335022,
0.07430939376354218,
-0.13063029944896698,
0.021096613258123398,
0.052601613104343414,
0.5096404552459717,
-0.3854420483112335,
-0.2508465051651001,
0.8532267808914185,
-0.0651186853647232,
0.5214341282844543,
-0.22135718166828156,
0.5216333866119385,
-1.218532919883728,
0.11490734666585922,
-0.1585986167192459,
-0.3297128975391388,
-0.7144573330879211,
0.22004467248916626,
0.32991287112236023,
0.004213722422719002,
-0.7185783982276917,
0.36851921677589417,
-0.6723402738571167,
0.08139092475175858,
-0.26138994097709656,
0.10575762391090393,
0.07648347318172455,
0.4757883846759796,
-0.13197746872901917,
0.44541290402412415,
0.50957852602005,
-0.6667781472206116,
0.4914795160293579,
-0.14370959997177124,
-0.39320147037506104,
0.6547240614891052,
-0.40901124477386475,
-0.043714847415685654,
-0.23954299092292786,
0.25339826941490173,
-1.0174254179000854,
-0.4715007245540619,
0.2612919509410858,
-0.19486944377422333,
0.5728276968002319,
-0.3727044463157654,
-0.5396270155906677,
0.07009753584861755,
0.026054836809635162,
0.6179044246673584,
0.2416713386774063,
-0.04244082793593407,
1.1996372938156128,
0.15688355267047882,
-0.13775616884231567,
-0.5937227606773376,
-0.6343480348587036,
-0.011003406718373299,
0.004534608218818903,
-0.5801128149032593,
0.1612377017736435,
-0.2882622182369232,
-0.03429948538541794,
0.010328127071261406,
0.18005897104740143,
-0.08963785320520401,
0.08851609379053116,
0.20727171003818512,
0.4053555130958557,
-0.5053920149803162,
0.27526143193244934,
0.10961733013391495,
0.10551773011684418,
-0.23882035911083221,
0.19794073700904846,
0.7424145936965942,
-0.019047601148486137,
-0.5727258324623108,
-0.3075169622898102,
0.5111663341522217,
0.9411422610282898,
-0.5372955799102783,
1.0505766868591309,
0.9969598054885864,
-0.19847247004508972,
0.032231200486421585,
-0.7475925087928772,
-0.05085572227835655,
-0.39880648255348206,
0.5110280513763428,
-0.6672343015670776,
-0.8584139347076416,
0.39563262462615967,
0.0396539606153965,
0.058487482368946075,
0.11278165131807327,
0.6918243765830994,
-0.2676793336868286,
1.0406213998794556,
0.6700096130371094,
0.01592780463397503,
0.5184546709060669,
-0.0658392384648323,
-0.04220245033502579,
-1.1017762422561646,
-0.4303087592124939,
-0.13584420084953308,
-0.5783547163009644,
-0.4387868344783783,
-0.7135869264602661,
0.24415451288223267,
0.07450571656227112,
-0.0847058966755867,
0.20325630903244019,
0.03998330608010292,
0.40899011492729187,
0.3335948586463928,
0.2892495393753052,
0.4608730375766754,
-0.051130540668964386,
-0.2030443400144577,
-0.05890107527375221,
-0.6955805420875549,
-0.4475569725036621,
1.1346849203109741,
0.30788499116897583,
0.8243396878242493,
0.3633056879043579,
0.3608229458332062,
-0.04279999062418938,
0.521718442440033,
-0.716739296913147,
0.585528552532196,
-0.1402422934770584,
-0.6874028444290161,
0.01896006241440773,
-0.5332726836204529,
-0.6024584174156189,
0.716961145401001,
-0.4067496955394745,
-0.4900711476802826,
0.04064907506108284,
0.05536259338259697,
-0.19454620778560638,
0.30008190870285034,
-0.5984179973602295,
1.028206706047058,
-0.3047052025794983,
-0.39738693833351135,
-0.2816210091114044,
-0.5716132521629333,
0.7983861565589905,
-0.09393545240163803,
0.3160872161388397,
-0.21033550798892975,
-0.2930828332901001,
0.43555209040641785,
0.11167765408754349,
0.7201812863349915,
0.11877844482660294,
-0.17359545826911926,
0.12068508565425873,
0.20329293608665466,
0.28283512592315674,
-0.012498943135142326,
0.11949243396520615,
-0.06766434758901596,
-0.030335361137986183,
-0.2547406256198883,
-0.6932249665260315,
0.7922764420509338,
-0.562968373298645,
-0.2805843949317932,
-0.04277102276682854,
-1.0718265771865845,
-0.44583165645599365,
0.0026915480848401785,
-0.1469683051109314,
0.8173948526382446,
-0.09963784366846085,
0.6856068968772888,
0.5696954131126404,
0.005830272100865841,
0.48110491037368774,
0.6958780884742737,
-0.17308208346366882,
-0.5522056818008423,
0.8187645077705383,
-0.16023866832256317,
0.5396394729614258,
0.48006024956703186,
-0.03181483596563339,
-0.22050456702709198,
-0.5108687877655029,
-0.39464566111564636,
0.17204542458057404,
-0.8282390236854553,
-0.15047495067119598,
-0.9471502304077148,
-0.05150558426976204,
-0.43614819645881653,
-0.02516254596412182,
-0.42226046323776245,
0.028115713968873024,
-0.3339727818965912,
0.2866329848766327,
-0.07219631969928741,
0.6065746545791626,
-0.10552064329385757,
0.3483699560165405,
-1.1020585298538208,
0.37590599060058594,
0.3921424150466919,
0.2462644875049591,
0.15971516072750092,
-0.6371869444847107,
-0.37439852952957153,
0.3371581733226776,
-0.2968830466270447,
-0.7914326190948486,
0.17853446304798126,
0.11865632981061935,
0.8148537278175354,
0.36898165941238403,
-0.18303357064723969,
0.7643461227416992,
-0.46094802021980286,
0.6299200057983398,
0.44976308941841125,
-0.962764322757721,
0.17121222615242004,
-0.22599662840366364,
0.43497011065483093,
0.4672596752643585,
0.4434398114681244,
-0.6374463438987732,
-0.3537450432777405,
-0.17753547430038452,
-0.3287624418735504,
0.5522065758705139,
-0.12371576577425003,
0.21874673664569855,
0.2549751400947571,
-0.2003900557756424,
0.2216057926416397,
0.18120336532592773,
-0.9268092513084412,
0.05476117134094238,
0.020731156691908836,
-0.5249596238136292,
-0.25361359119415283,
-0.43135207891464233,
-0.17843730747699738,
-0.2849480211734772,
0.4064737856388092,
0.001892120111733675,
-0.0009271800518035889,
-0.40356236696243286,
-0.5544029474258423,
0.07707422226667404,
0.4141908586025238,
0.850416898727417,
0.800609290599823,
0.047595877200365067,
0.5371325016021729,
0.13983096182346344,
-0.3388320803642273,
0.21977326273918152,
-0.06461581587791443,
0.16593679785728455,
-0.16359831392765045,
0.6621660590171814,
0.7740058302879333,
0.683263897895813,
-0.7279159426689148,
0.4483020603656769,
0.05831342190504074,
-0.1008593961596489,
0.3230679929256439,
0.18269699811935425,
0.1479811817407608,
0.42661526799201965,
0.06414791941642761,
0.2982136309146881,
0.04266669601202011,
-0.7064045071601868,
0.069431833922863,
0.48280829191207886,
-0.22070559859275818,
-0.2724941670894623,
0.38424986600875854,
0.17311502993106842,
0.10675594955682755,
0.5518245697021484,
-0.01982128620147705,
-0.4744340479373932,
0.2614692747592926,
0.513312041759491,
0.6091889142990112,
-0.21890850365161896,
0.09695503860712051,
0.1364704817533493,
0.4602186977863312,
0.12849612534046173,
0.06307147443294525,
-0.3534921109676361,
-0.6651026606559753,
-0.7349132895469666,
-0.7162970900535583,
-0.2773151993751526,
0.12702332437038422,
-0.45616158843040466,
0.22547000646591187,
-0.2877560555934906,
-0.09396139532327652,
-0.07530289143323898,
-0.33681467175483704,
-0.7596331834793091,
0.08570893853902817,
0.19287870824337006,
0.4238628149032593,
-1.0076984167099,
0.8275265097618103,
0.7351886630058289,
-0.4704068601131439,
-0.8122678399085999,
-0.24822376668453217,
-0.1623084396123886,
-0.5159611105918884,
0.8798144459724426,
0.11840491741895676,
-0.03366183489561081,
-0.21199175715446472,
-0.349905788898468,
-0.7494032382965088,
0.7652776837348938,
0.46993544697761536,
-0.46110308170318604,
0.07830508053302765,
0.132271870970726,
0.1649898886680603,
-0.5874799489974976,
0.27146926522254944,
0.36582672595977783,
0.5868290662765503,
0.29792365431785583,
-1.0746625661849976,
-0.0420684814453125,
-0.07553713768720627,
0.10409235954284668,
0.09932254254817963,
-0.21896834671497345,
1.080688238143921,
-0.12347619980573654,
-0.15385478734970093,
0.04412860795855522,
0.7343249917030334,
0.12218520790338516,
0.19635243713855743,
0.48445814847946167,
0.45512309670448303,
0.4135328531265259,
0.010358991101384163,
0.7611141204833984,
-0.10680557787418365,
0.19012263417243958,
1.3026237487792969,
-0.0638510063290596,
0.8858857750892639,
0.4567994177341461,
-0.0974789708852768,
0.4634571373462677,
0.42765191197395325,
0.12417476624250412,
0.5366569757461548,
-0.14891952276229858,
-0.4702093005180359,
-0.6220155954360962,
-0.12382100522518158,
-0.42141634225845337,
0.8588672876358032,
0.2788848578929901,
-0.44950178265571594,
-0.19268083572387695,
0.4592892527580261,
-0.30515414476394653,
-0.017338868230581284,
-0.288719117641449,
0.7441132068634033,
-0.11344615370035172,
-0.5545642971992493,
0.5470559000968933,
0.18394365906715393,
0.591041624546051,
-0.6690502762794495,
0.10362567752599716,
-0.1923832893371582,
0.16926179826259613,
-0.027532534673810005,
-0.6117902398109436,
0.05435168743133545,
-0.23660524189472198,
-0.41251054406166077,
-0.13089250028133392,
0.40171512961387634,
-0.9430199861526489,
-0.6611143946647644,
-0.19843381643295288,
0.5381819009780884,
-0.057329725474119186,
0.027724435552954674,
-0.49988460540771484,
0.6165544986724854,
-0.23146815598011017,
0.17118987441062927,
0.24093052744865417,
0.4036274552345276,
0.2031395584344864,
0.7230125665664673,
0.6186764240264893,
-0.12747617065906525,
0.21007665991783142,
0.29748862981796265,
0.7501382231712341,
-0.3621009588241577,
-0.30084550380706787,
-0.8890209197998047,
0.8007069826126099,
-0.03630886971950531,
-0.10706347972154617,
0.7649084329605103,
0.5186465382575989,
0.6343048214912415,
-0.3816758692264557,
0.46768811345100403,
-0.015285144560039043,
0.08115106076002121,
-0.7504979372024536,
0.6398997902870178,
-0.8139171004295349,
0.07312590628862381,
-0.1548963338136673,
-1.2112525701522827,
-0.17560191452503204,
0.38847512006759644,
-0.021480867639183998,
0.28517431020736694,
0.617919385433197,
0.7879869937896729,
-0.4877130389213562,
-0.11579151451587677,
0.619490385055542,
0.01398391555994749,
0.33830979466438293,
0.5580679178237915,
1.0361542701721191,
-0.21609169244766235,
0.42335668206214905,
-0.2034095674753189,
-0.20770427584648132,
-0.4217982888221741,
-0.9199692606925964,
-1.0302678346633911,
-0.6565753817558289,
-0.2878287732601166,
-0.028966715559363365,
-0.33219948410987854,
0.8967679142951965,
0.86317378282547,
-0.6717149615287781,
-0.16419920325279236,
0.3383442759513855,
0.022329796105623245,
-0.1833503693342209,
-0.16260284185409546,
-0.015538511797785759,
-0.4415373206138611,
-0.871278703212738,
0.551344633102417,
0.3967168927192688,
0.15303683280944824,
-0.6546934247016907,
-0.0867428332567215,
-0.27491647005081177,
0.024920817464590073,
0.9034678339958191,
-0.20961566269397736,
-0.926504909992218,
-0.13491123914718628,
0.02828316017985344,
-0.30756643414497375,
-0.23910202085971832,
1.059810757637024,
-0.5071901679039001,
0.7898261547088623,
0.4333727955818176,
0.7313632369041443,
0.2853758633136749,
-0.389906108379364,
0.5775571465492249,
-0.8107346296310425,
0.1994214951992035,
0.16915848851203918,
0.5621296167373657,
0.5883641839027405,
0.21642239391803741,
0.08238745480775833,
0.11798691004514694,
-0.13565483689308167,
-0.9241418838500977,
0.24402351677417755,
-1.3435651063919067,
-0.39198359847068787,
1.061496376991272,
0.13845644891262054,
-0.011791015043854713,
0.11013580858707428,
-0.2826533913612366,
0.2970474362373352,
-0.08623748272657394,
0.186489075422287,
0.7652738094329834,
0.25936007499694824,
-0.5715557932853699,
-0.4920951724052429,
-0.12192322313785553,
0.2685233950614929,
-0.6504506468772888,
0.008825896307826042,
0.7510246634483337,
0.33350738883018494,
-0.014517052099108696,
0.1364622265100479,
0.025387438014149666,
0.1948479861021042,
0.10355637967586517,
-0.06925074756145477,
-0.49174532294273376,
-0.457478791475296,
-0.03913239389657974,
0.37141019105911255,
-0.06914503872394562,
-0.21147893369197845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12749v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12749v4 | Me LLaMA: Foundation Large Language Models for Medical Applications | 2024-02-20T06:37:31 | 2024-04-11T16:42:55 | Qianqian Xie, Qingyu Chen, Aokun Chen, Cheng Peng, Yan Hu, Fongci Lin, Xueqing Peng, Jimin Huang, Jeffrey Zhang, Vipina Keloth, Xinyu Zhou, Huan He, Lucila Ohno-Machado, Yonghui Wu, Hua Xu, Jiang Bian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and LLaMA
have hinted at their potential to revolutionize medical applications, yet their
application in clinical settings often reveals limitations due to a lack of
specialized training on medical-specific data. In response to this challenge,
this study introduces Me-LLaMA, a novel medical LLM family that includes
foundation models - Me-LLaMA 13/70B, along with their chat-enhanced versions -
Me-LLaMA 13/70B-chat, developed through continual pre-training and instruction
tuning of LLaMA2 using large medical datasets. Our methodology leverages a
comprehensive domain-specific data suite, including a large-scale, continual
pre-training dataset with 129B tokens, an instruction tuning dataset with 214k
samples, and a new medical evaluation benchmark (MIBE) across six critical
medical tasks with 12 datasets. Our extensive evaluation using the MIBE shows
that Me-LLaMA models achieve overall better performance than existing
open-source medical LLMs in zero-shot, few-shot and supervised learning
abilities. With task-specific instruction tuning, Me-LLaMA models outperform
ChatGPT on 7 out of 8 datasets and GPT-4 on 5 out of 8 datasets. In addition,
we investigated the catastrophic forgetting problem, and our results show that
Me-LLaMA models outperform other open-source medical LLMs in mitigating this
issue. Me-LLaMA is one of the largest open-source medical foundation LLMs that
use both biomedical and clinical data. It exhibits superior performance across
both general and medical tasks compared to other open-source medical LLMs,
rendering it an attractive choice for medical AI applications. We release our
models, datasets, and evaluation scripts at:
https://github.com/BIDS-Xu-Lab/Me-LLaMA. | [
0.03937099128961563,
-0.7786813974380493,
0.5451213121414185,
0.2352127879858017,
-0.3211964964866638,
0.2848915755748749,
-0.20830515027046204,
-0.5120009779930115,
0.35816311836242676,
0.5162384510040283,
-0.5663644075393677,
-0.6012367010116577,
-0.8556616306304932,
0.10650397837162018,
-0.3418450653553009,
0.956960141658783,
-0.20006583631038666,
0.3547886312007904,
-0.16989076137542725,
-0.21326754987239838,
-0.45089977979660034,
-0.690769374370575,
-0.5971943140029907,
-0.5953655242919922,
0.4629368484020233,
0.47425198554992676,
0.4938102960586548,
0.6154817342758179,
0.7248480916023254,
0.22388839721679688,
0.05952445790171623,
-0.01275650504976511,
-0.6238141059875488,
0.00474918307736516,
-0.059394076466560364,
-0.4274318218231201,
-0.6310378313064575,
-0.18959060311317444,
0.35653623938560486,
0.754758358001709,
-0.3287403881549835,
0.2082861214876175,
-0.3529222309589386,
0.6643811464309692,
-0.4469442069530487,
0.10574295371770859,
-0.5228071212768555,
0.04670555517077446,
-0.3034123182296753,
-0.2709037661552429,
-0.18360376358032227,
-0.13027070462703705,
0.20888274908065796,
-0.3720903694629669,
-0.04719037190079689,
-0.11756203323602676,
0.6185876131057739,
0.5583764314651489,
-0.3024681806564331,
-0.4485955536365509,
-0.4977928102016449,
0.6910857558250427,
-0.8192608952522278,
0.2443581074476242,
0.28359854221343994,
0.4063730537891388,
-0.4034363627433777,
-0.772528350353241,
-0.2703641355037689,
-0.5712710022926331,
0.3641502559185028,
0.167365163564682,
-0.23931610584259033,
0.12549208104610443,
-0.1003757193684578,
0.5100314021110535,
-0.6935492157936096,
0.4393405318260193,
-0.4550059735774994,
-0.10016535222530365,
0.3648730516433716,
0.44716399908065796,
0.31056129932403564,
0.31479504704475403,
-0.2740766704082489,
0.15175025165081024,
-1.120760202407837,
-0.2828463017940521,
-0.25985902547836304,
-0.09992633014917374,
-0.3014276623725891,
0.7945076823234558,
-0.4591427147388458,
0.6118226051330566,
-0.287222683429718,
-0.5954764485359192,
0.38428983092308044,
-0.059655025601387024,
-0.35935431718826294,
-0.03282554820179939,
0.7218425273895264,
0.3012274503707886,
0.43570709228515625,
-0.20175574719905853,
-0.024361545220017433,
0.2629496455192566,
0.0546792633831501,
-0.9090256094932556,
-0.25330284237861633,
0.23032121360301971,
-0.6025262475013733,
-0.3752775490283966,
-0.6097187995910645,
-0.4069492816925049,
-0.36589059233665466,
-0.22068721055984497,
0.21408596634864807,
-0.36732760071754456,
-0.15553849935531616,
0.4936245381832123,
0.44931939244270325,
0.13596032559871674,
0.42846906185150146,
-0.9201120734214783,
0.3319595754146576,
0.5729554295539856,
0.7821124792098999,
-0.2208624631166458,
-0.21048597991466522,
-0.3958103060722351,
0.07050241529941559,
-0.36306560039520264,
0.7863358855247498,
-0.7574647665023804,
-0.4293815493583679,
-0.20765839517116547,
-0.18357601761817932,
-0.16162776947021484,
-0.810847818851471,
0.3409810960292816,
-0.2291814088821411,
-0.08016052842140198,
0.09710247069597244,
-0.46252182126045227,
-0.02021411992609501,
0.3515131175518036,
-0.4626794755458832,
0.6347903609275818,
0.14920517802238464,
-0.2509276568889618,
0.08335930854082108,
-0.7320001721382141,
-0.5497400164604187,
0.03555035963654518,
-0.41076886653900146,
-0.47659197449684143,
0.11694113165140152,
0.24073287844657898,
0.7580883502960205,
-0.8817879557609558,
0.5010277628898621,
-0.22808600962162018,
-0.4824928045272827,
0.25139325857162476,
-0.35806572437286377,
0.5133156776428223,
0.18087518215179443,
-0.08800097554922104,
0.02779318019747734,
-0.7274129390716553,
-0.3452526032924652,
0.42220383882522583,
-0.5621426105499268,
-0.09376762807369232,
-0.02218766324222088,
-0.1620623767375946,
0.08260520547628403,
0.3823528587818146,
-0.5040983557701111,
0.1742875725030899,
-0.4207623600959778,
0.6249479651451111,
0.6050838828086853,
0.01706795208156109,
0.06581435352563858,
-0.4258745312690735,
0.6464270949363708,
-0.006528572645038366,
0.3152330815792084,
-0.27761346101760864,
-0.5624017119407654,
-0.5884393453598022,
-0.4653678238391876,
0.2099156379699707,
0.6751995086669922,
-0.44855812191963196,
0.16982227563858032,
-0.31526875495910645,
-0.47867077589035034,
-0.5980865955352783,
0.24069924652576447,
0.5324408411979675,
0.7597878575325012,
0.4469291865825653,
-0.1881999373435974,
-0.36207181215286255,
-0.959980309009552,
0.15706296265125275,
-0.1964191198348999,
-0.07085400819778442,
0.6449084281921387,
0.4834043085575104,
-0.8401039838790894,
0.40913400053977966,
-0.45038825273513794,
-0.4259670674800873,
-0.1454302817583084,
-0.11628150939941406,
0.3664968013763428,
0.40842577815055847,
0.6155098676681519,
-0.3730902373790741,
-0.14894577860832214,
0.19471123814582825,
-0.8145573735237122,
-0.23847489058971405,
-0.09951126575469971,
0.08637820929288864,
-0.03506021201610565,
0.32194116711616516,
-0.4252944588661194,
0.27637723088264465,
0.8170143365859985,
-0.2300601601600647,
0.627654492855072,
-0.2189212292432785,
0.1535365730524063,
-1.1922320127487183,
0.1987943947315216,
-0.2807092070579529,
-0.1874900907278061,
-0.40089383721351624,
-0.08107919991016388,
-0.072724349796772,
0.014035837724804878,
-0.35477301478385925,
0.5433286428451538,
-0.3047926723957062,
0.04333191365003586,
-0.28358328342437744,
-0.20569439232349396,
-0.1952136904001236,
0.33908766508102417,
-0.20638366043567657,
0.7628729939460754,
0.4884743094444275,
-0.567213237285614,
0.2471458911895752,
0.411813884973526,
-0.3083631694316864,
0.47090139985084534,
-0.8253734111785889,
0.0630110576748848,
0.20295624434947968,
0.21567079424858093,
-0.7271409034729004,
-0.388994425535202,
0.2513621747493744,
-0.3287665843963623,
0.3894856572151184,
0.13466016948223114,
-0.48597007989883423,
-0.44907519221305847,
-0.0526847317814827,
0.3266189694404602,
0.4742850363254547,
-0.47820737957954407,
0.3521595597267151,
0.5835974812507629,
-0.27905964851379395,
-0.8004366755485535,
-0.6669189929962158,
0.3114566206932068,
-0.0743197575211525,
-0.4420730769634247,
0.4036174416542053,
-0.2505245804786682,
-0.007681614253669977,
-0.13644446432590485,
-0.1955973207950592,
-0.1504068672657013,
0.2895534038543701,
0.3698734939098358,
0.33617472648620605,
-0.46181949973106384,
0.3091908395290375,
0.44608524441719055,
-0.35410940647125244,
-0.17488013207912445,
0.10922770202159882,
0.6000487804412842,
-0.2708773910999298,
-0.5313425064086914,
-0.30787646770477295,
0.16956639289855957,
0.6511595249176025,
-0.14453871548175812,
0.6639890670776367,
0.1599549502134323,
-0.49042680859565735,
0.18411943316459656,
-0.7180753946304321,
-0.11602512747049332,
-0.4137801229953766,
0.6498527526855469,
-0.35885244607925415,
-1.2992584705352783,
0.3480187654495239,
-0.4808046221733093,
0.12085926532745361,
0.16333246231079102,
0.9875184893608093,
-0.2602616548538208,
0.6670807600021362,
0.48064520955085754,
-0.3819933235645294,
0.21963049471378326,
-0.05621650442481041,
-0.1469760239124298,
-0.7577347755432129,
-0.1934344619512558,
-0.23019437491893768,
-0.3191351592540741,
-0.09157434105873108,
-0.5924188494682312,
0.5790364146232605,
-0.09351082146167755,
-0.21443131566047668,
-0.09910319745540619,
-0.4046623110771179,
0.5040422081947327,
0.2121191769838333,
0.23853899538516998,
0.39429205656051636,
-0.13370707631111145,
-0.08958546817302704,
0.11883080750703812,
-0.5171685218811035,
-0.5587417483329773,
1.5397701263427734,
0.4763127267360687,
0.9795562028884888,
-0.09534820914268494,
0.5300964713096619,
0.2373693734407425,
0.6179128885269165,
-0.6233052015304565,
0.4307689070701599,
-0.4303988814353943,
-0.4634764790534973,
-0.008694478310644627,
-0.21359899640083313,
-1.0202239751815796,
-0.010283244773745537,
-0.28463441133499146,
-0.5266299843788147,
-0.3551746904850006,
0.22330880165100098,
-0.2929019033908844,
0.10476196557283401,
-0.5423786640167236,
0.6610697507858276,
-0.4840551018714905,
-0.03461035341024399,
-0.5428654551506042,
-0.6848275065422058,
0.5200402140617371,
-0.38745391368865967,
-0.18042472004890442,
-0.5029811263084412,
-0.20095840096473694,
0.510870099067688,
-0.3113989531993866,
0.9996727108955383,
0.03408218175172806,
0.04618394747376442,
0.12555959820747375,
-0.10699912905693054,
0.22136898338794708,
0.055599603801965714,
0.03437786176800728,
0.5415988564491272,
-0.06457304954528809,
-0.32776832580566406,
-0.2468537539243698,
0.8984463810920715,
-0.7505210638046265,
-0.5249485969543457,
-0.21655026078224182,
-0.5452859997749329,
-0.3852193057537079,
0.08803626894950867,
0.05945095792412758,
0.34980639815330505,
-0.3573703169822693,
0.4311676025390625,
0.5861892104148865,
-0.5095620155334473,
-0.018761713057756424,
0.7226130366325378,
-0.10233555734157562,
-0.3967398703098297,
0.7644355893135071,
0.010173910297453403,
0.13513609766960144,
0.6087328791618347,
0.26362383365631104,
-0.039879314601421356,
-0.8322909474372864,
-0.7127700448036194,
0.5251722931861877,
-0.4891279935836792,
-0.3980192244052887,
-0.5618147253990173,
-0.1739143580198288,
0.05576351284980774,
-0.1722736805677414,
-0.43482255935668945,
-0.4110134243965149,
-0.39807140827178955,
-0.09409163147211075,
0.4951139986515045,
0.7374613285064697,
0.32420289516448975,
0.6260562539100647,
-0.7016866207122803,
0.38826221227645874,
0.059422217309474945,
0.5636494755744934,
-0.12285608053207397,
-0.29242178797721863,
-0.2025431990623474,
-0.054690320044755936,
-0.23789620399475098,
-0.8175982236862183,
0.1184534877538681,
0.28996527194976807,
0.6731307506561279,
0.48710203170776367,
-0.3501474857330322,
0.6773771643638611,
-0.6673983931541443,
0.44609469175338745,
0.2849513292312622,
-0.6564040184020996,
0.49684983491897583,
-0.2692573666572571,
0.16256888210773468,
0.5196273326873779,
0.15720118582248688,
-0.29795026779174805,
-0.20472484827041626,
-0.23526258766651154,
-0.6519795060157776,
0.39772266149520874,
0.05831575021147728,
0.12740308046340942,
-0.026990890502929688,
0.757938802242279,
0.2528028190135956,
0.27075594663619995,
-0.5729618668556213,
-0.31285911798477173,
0.08430750668048859,
-0.6000378131866455,
-0.13588981330394745,
-0.3662046194076538,
-0.10405955463647842,
-0.04715098813176155,
0.4909733235836029,
-0.24630878865718842,
0.30173933506011963,
0.16055454313755035,
-0.23739394545555115,
-0.08609667420387268,
0.06548768281936646,
0.696817934513092,
0.5496346354484558,
-0.046000730246305466,
-0.18145626783370972,
0.3962017893791199,
-0.8198412656784058,
0.20606276392936707,
0.07104091346263885,
0.13895218074321747,
-0.26932790875434875,
0.3476788401603699,
0.5537111759185791,
0.4683435261249542,
-1.3003054857254028,
0.47712934017181396,
0.053540799766778946,
-0.03357725217938423,
-0.19543607532978058,
0.2136034071445465,
0.3302190601825714,
0.37897592782974243,
0.06055018678307533,
-0.021858450025320053,
0.2737603783607483,
-0.09733080863952637,
0.16165125370025635,
0.45370420813560486,
-0.15910257399082184,
-0.3132947087287903,
0.7536706924438477,
0.14096949994564056,
0.01087121106684208,
0.447821706533432,
0.4177684187889099,
-0.09438837319612503,
0.6780565977096558,
0.774443507194519,
0.5698831081390381,
-0.444976270198822,
0.011331235058605671,
0.21392284333705902,
0.3759118318557739,
-0.04779724404215813,
0.22409339249134064,
0.07400590926408768,
-0.4770432710647583,
-0.5220061540603638,
-0.6356086134910583,
-0.642244815826416,
0.3823610544204712,
-0.3063834309577942,
0.3497348725795746,
-0.6765881776809692,
-0.09141705185174942,
-0.23355291783809662,
-0.11481843888759613,
-0.5769719481468201,
0.3642929196357727,
0.2193964272737503,
0.9355243444442749,
-0.559028148651123,
1.0332568883895874,
0.561695396900177,
-0.20753811299800873,
-0.4786617159843445,
-0.2968171536922455,
-0.03705805540084839,
-1.2428988218307495,
0.16616703569889069,
0.23107795417308807,
-0.07738557457923889,
-0.09946990013122559,
-0.5716820359230042,
-0.8375604152679443,
1.4132338762283325,
0.6964297890663147,
-0.8193164467811584,
0.02444508671760559,
0.2601507306098938,
0.6397989392280579,
-0.6196591854095459,
-0.01273951306939125,
0.6913365721702576,
0.003663518698886037,
0.18405230343341827,
-0.9643261432647705,
-0.033530816435813904,
-0.3201194405555725,
-0.3257787525653839,
0.12544211745262146,
-0.8011001944541931,
0.7544692754745483,
-0.5576353669166565,
0.18122439086437225,
0.3822380006313324,
0.29420948028564453,
0.6185992956161499,
0.44054004549980164,
0.16923487186431885,
0.5689316987991333,
0.8751533627510071,
0.03382789343595505,
0.9983062148094177,
-0.370784729719162,
-0.02313912846148014,
1.0086179971694946,
-0.4317377805709839,
0.8628770112991333,
0.33334222435951233,
-0.17265233397483826,
0.3678371012210846,
0.630614697933197,
0.06949911266565323,
0.45416486263275146,
0.24895693361759186,
-0.31901079416275024,
-0.09070385247468948,
-0.04442640766501427,
-0.5548409223556519,
0.39322200417518616,
0.7781002521514893,
-0.519280195236206,
-0.004368908703327179,
-0.007690325379371643,
0.15968185663223267,
-0.18192073702812195,
-0.30964845418930054,
0.6902613043785095,
0.34383174777030945,
-0.2595842182636261,
0.7384577393531799,
-0.07529646903276443,
0.4856588542461395,
-0.8075664043426514,
-0.06544745713472366,
-0.19710582494735718,
0.2666904330253601,
-0.0707109123468399,
-0.38606536388397217,
0.12421989440917969,
0.10576307028532028,
-0.12342633306980133,
0.240926131606102,
0.6536573767662048,
-0.15629015862941742,
-0.4819456934928894,
0.3480782210826874,
0.5432961583137512,
0.24451585114002228,
0.11360356211662292,
-0.7789536714553833,
0.09951857477426529,
-0.060094110667705536,
-0.27819377183914185,
0.3631952702999115,
0.10471844673156738,
-0.38302209973335266,
1.034346103668213,
0.7222217917442322,
0.14219821989536285,
0.04796258732676506,
0.17243440449237823,
1.0506962537765503,
-0.611698567867279,
-0.12906211614608765,
-0.9234868884086609,
0.1493787318468094,
0.29972466826438904,
-0.4493567645549774,
0.13988323509693146,
0.5363953709602356,
0.34038102626800537,
-0.1655494123697281,
0.6820650696754456,
0.2698992192745209,
0.572843074798584,
-0.4667794406414032,
0.7451698184013367,
-0.5349039435386658,
0.27365052700042725,
-0.08059848099946976,
-0.5326620936393738,
-0.5798133611679077,
0.6027806401252747,
-0.31564486026763916,
-0.05437147617340088,
0.36323291063308716,
0.621324896812439,
0.019633661955595016,
-0.027938392013311386,
0.48961907625198364,
0.4098591208457947,
0.43291857838630676,
1.0668766498565674,
0.8213120698928833,
-0.24581679701805115,
0.40229880809783936,
-0.018432848155498505,
-0.498965322971344,
-0.5652974843978882,
-0.7237911224365234,
-1.0551774501800537,
-0.23565945029258728,
-0.17742057144641876,
-0.018675634637475014,
0.16877341270446777,
0.9962003231048584,
0.6717391610145569,
-0.8087793588638306,
-0.17565445601940155,
0.10764191299676895,
-0.2178165316581726,
-0.031281132251024246,
-0.018727246671915054,
0.2843298614025116,
-0.0496307797729969,
-0.5184605121612549,
0.7160770297050476,
0.6513804793357849,
0.29417431354522705,
-0.18602466583251953,
-0.2994108498096466,
-0.08921054005622864,
0.04099482297897339,
0.49299192428588867,
0.307956725358963,
-0.7926813960075378,
0.07781022787094116,
0.10446822643280029,
-0.21738238632678986,
0.1957344114780426,
0.5680491924285889,
-0.8037975430488586,
0.37969058752059937,
-0.11861085146665573,
0.8882560729980469,
0.5039272308349609,
-0.20211197435855865,
0.5779433846473694,
-0.3251253366470337,
0.1966675966978073,
0.319400429725647,
0.5988709926605225,
0.31528764963150024,
-0.37515273690223694,
0.8481919765472412,
0.01683461293578148,
-0.5552229881286621,
-0.7931457757949829,
-0.015744362026453018,
-0.9611524939537048,
-0.12193763256072998,
0.8991611003875732,
-0.052154455333948135,
-0.08389900624752045,
-0.08498502522706985,
-0.38115593791007996,
0.1559481918811798,
-0.1415843814611435,
0.9241809844970703,
0.5434984564781189,
-0.27121269702911377,
0.07499010860919952,
-0.808152973651886,
0.14420413970947266,
0.5463400483131409,
-0.9535204768180847,
-0.2705264985561371,
0.44905877113342285,
0.47075581550598145,
-0.2015160620212555,
0.9979126453399658,
-0.27242735028266907,
0.48517894744873047,
-0.2741997241973877,
-0.01372497994452715,
-0.15195252001285553,
-0.4297530949115753,
-0.26900798082351685,
-0.03440960496664047,
0.13580718636512756,
-0.22686351835727692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14855v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14855v1 | An LLM Maturity Model for Reliable and Transparent Text-to-Query | 2024-02-20T06:20:09 | 2024-02-20T06:20:09 | Lei Yu, Abir Ray | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recognizing the imperative to address the reliability and transparency issues
of Large Language Models (LLM), this work proposes an LLM maturity model
tailored for text-to-query applications. This maturity model seeks to fill the
existing void in evaluating LLMs in such applications by incorporating
dimensions beyond mere correctness or accuracy. Moreover, this work introduces
a real-world use case from the law enforcement domain and showcases QueryIQ, an
LLM-powered, domain-specific text-to-query assistant to expedite user workflows
and reveal hidden relationship in data. | [
0.04571256414055824,
-0.5727748870849609,
0.9310382008552551,
0.44123849272727966,
0.00688413018360734,
0.2745748460292816,
0.1447896957397461,
-0.6468750834465027,
-0.2854129374027252,
0.9277991652488708,
-0.5275529026985168,
-0.848109245300293,
-0.5046716928482056,
-0.2405165731906891,
-0.7234520316123962,
0.725959300994873,
0.011569743975996971,
-0.010861186310648918,
-0.5860822796821594,
-0.30191299319267273,
-0.5158023834228516,
-0.4695546329021454,
-0.6866052746772766,
-0.4056151509284973,
0.32921645045280457,
0.49325278401374817,
0.5134559273719788,
0.5854429006576538,
0.5054637789726257,
0.2600652277469635,
-0.08562672138214111,
0.09920040518045425,
-0.619500994682312,
0.4494662284851074,
-0.5433216094970703,
-0.6085436344146729,
-0.7105668783187866,
0.07490836083889008,
0.4726372957229614,
0.5712956190109253,
-0.2274879664182663,
-0.04350782185792923,
-0.2616155445575714,
0.9818996787071228,
-0.8733626008033752,
-0.0517217218875885,
-0.9220899939537048,
-0.18817904591560364,
-0.07973334938287735,
-0.10446527600288391,
-0.5853709578514099,
-0.42336538434028625,
0.02682974375784397,
-0.3948500454425812,
-0.16803523898124695,
0.36506062746047974,
0.6265797019004822,
-0.0053709689527750015,
-0.5280464291572571,
-0.34985753893852234,
-0.8772739171981812,
0.6531190872192383,
-0.6998253464698792,
0.5371680855751038,
0.70311039686203,
0.5925501585006714,
-0.038239434361457825,
-0.9856034517288208,
-0.3832763135433197,
-0.690944254398346,
-0.01223751250654459,
0.04775461181998253,
0.02285003662109375,
0.004873788449913263,
-0.24250009655952454,
0.5510979294776917,
-0.602721095085144,
0.21644176542758942,
-0.17240533232688904,
-0.1987379938364029,
0.6708468794822693,
0.3605743646621704,
0.01535970252007246,
-0.0075293187983334064,
-0.47642937302589417,
0.308284729719162,
-0.839549720287323,
-0.22521422803401947,
0.4858332574367523,
0.1736774742603302,
-0.05506915971636772,
0.8449923992156982,
-0.4496656656265259,
0.5378924608230591,
0.06388223171234131,
-0.08376335352659225,
-0.0335862822830677,
-0.40890640020370483,
-0.29094675183296204,
-0.2479606568813324,
0.7985846400260925,
0.27426794171333313,
0.300858736038208,
-0.45193779468536377,
-0.504124104976654,
-0.5799846649169922,
0.3887830078601837,
-0.8039660453796387,
0.1614653617143631,
0.6251108646392822,
-0.320562481880188,
-0.432754248380661,
0.20151837170124054,
-0.48998478055000305,
-0.5052169561386108,
-0.1281789243221283,
0.4269644021987915,
-0.35628432035446167,
0.04852307215332985,
0.0280099269002676,
0.006302222143858671,
0.12501230835914612,
0.4530870020389557,
-0.5080863833427429,
0.3804950714111328,
0.7113841772079468,
0.7847270965576172,
-0.411187082529068,
-0.026855533942580223,
-0.35329291224479675,
0.47417840361595154,
-0.31666064262390137,
0.38421690464019775,
-0.703792929649353,
-0.4560135006904602,
0.17956142127513885,
0.1395731270313263,
0.09424948692321777,
-0.7894763350486755,
0.7038365602493286,
-1.0867297649383545,
0.19533753395080566,
0.33902108669281006,
-0.6885688304901123,
0.05384666845202446,
0.7007843255996704,
-0.7635404467582703,
1.0590003728866577,
0.16383638978004456,
-0.5064359307289124,
0.3978555202484131,
-0.5678907632827759,
-0.1104520708322525,
0.26584526896476746,
0.04217388480901718,
-0.7498983144760132,
-0.06601841002702713,
0.1683783084154129,
0.35684898495674133,
-0.3440924286842346,
0.3658900856971741,
-0.2073616236448288,
-0.3241463601589203,
0.16079562902450562,
-0.4224301278591156,
0.6973659992218018,
0.26324462890625,
0.054482776671648026,
0.17018595337867737,
-0.7929340600967407,
-0.12957096099853516,
0.29004091024398804,
-0.4523099958896637,
-0.34868404269218445,
0.12456352263689041,
-0.0934264212846756,
-0.22745762765407562,
0.7439587116241455,
-0.5742877125740051,
0.05590885505080223,
-0.33420413732528687,
0.46380048990249634,
0.27265024185180664,
0.05769483745098114,
0.6226096153259277,
-0.325293630361557,
0.5177196264266968,
-0.011950105428695679,
0.39585596323013306,
-0.409394770860672,
-0.4438289701938629,
-0.40966710448265076,
-0.07414628565311432,
0.20227336883544922,
0.7864311933517456,
-0.4956299364566803,
0.42925775051116943,
-0.35494789481163025,
-0.7245091199874878,
0.06437699496746063,
0.08480674028396606,
0.10723770409822464,
0.4732048511505127,
0.10568741708993912,
-0.20440830290317535,
-0.21499472856521606,
-0.7945528626441956,
-0.41609346866607666,
-0.6868272423744202,
-0.1656642109155655,
0.7613768577575684,
0.4797111451625824,
-0.420479953289032,
0.9155083298683167,
-0.3385104238986969,
-0.4296802580356598,
-0.10498092323541641,
0.21994464099407196,
0.0783352479338646,
0.4034373164176941,
0.29894712567329407,
-0.8781107068061829,
-0.25967103242874146,
-0.034112438559532166,
-0.6021421551704407,
-0.09010949730873108,
0.03439212962985039,
-0.12022270262241364,
-0.0055327098816633224,
0.8613624572753906,
-0.31192731857299805,
0.41911980509757996,
0.6048842668533325,
-0.4440642297267914,
0.5080580115318298,
-0.11085198074579239,
0.3531533181667328,
-0.7248731255531311,
0.15080413222312927,
-0.06703411042690277,
-0.7117896676063538,
-0.5093147158622742,
0.1842603236436844,
0.5039408802986145,
-0.3249107599258423,
-0.7031845450401306,
0.5042003393173218,
-0.41364631056785583,
-0.2394559532403946,
0.006914867088198662,
0.1676604002714157,
0.27991485595703125,
0.05935666710138321,
-0.26209667325019836,
1.169082522392273,
0.3193623423576355,
-0.6865499019622803,
0.33651140332221985,
0.06872490048408508,
-0.2770911455154419,
0.7701157927513123,
-0.6959818601608276,
0.17841428518295288,
-0.047041382640600204,
-0.048756178468465805,
-0.8887107372283936,
-0.23513001203536987,
-0.08673539012670517,
-0.6966701745986938,
0.39969730377197266,
-0.32062962651252747,
-0.6766618490219116,
-0.18815630674362183,
-0.5586407780647278,
0.6137540936470032,
0.06065107136964798,
-0.3520601987838745,
0.6503511667251587,
0.2487158626317978,
0.018756074830889702,
-0.44566231966018677,
-0.958611249923706,
0.4298030436038971,
-0.07614114135503769,
-0.884984016418457,
0.6358243823051453,
0.015229715034365654,
-0.09640897810459137,
-0.026639558374881744,
0.04589439183473587,
-0.4090255796909332,
0.16385218501091003,
0.17278361320495605,
0.1328822374343872,
-0.33024969696998596,
0.14435186982154846,
-0.06239454448223114,
0.2202387899160385,
0.09586194902658463,
-0.2163342982530594,
0.5075300931930542,
0.01221803855150938,
-0.6494941711425781,
0.044870857149362564,
0.38202834129333496,
0.812351644039154,
-0.38962435722351074,
1.0085159540176392,
0.14958177506923676,
-0.3125872313976288,
-0.10949870198965073,
-0.5740833878517151,
0.057923976331949234,
-0.5101144909858704,
0.35960161685943604,
-0.08926539868116379,
-1.237870693206787,
0.6223948001861572,
-0.27545982599258423,
-0.09511598199605942,
0.38250333070755005,
0.5332555174827576,
-0.009319025091826916,
0.816284716129303,
0.8507418036460876,
0.06947225332260132,
0.5773041248321533,
0.083864726126194,
0.05827350169420242,
-0.8143659830093384,
-0.8654451370239258,
-0.6881293654441833,
0.16157449781894684,
-0.4733159840106964,
-0.28449746966362,
0.42427608370780945,
0.37165123224258423,
-0.45522060990333557,
0.190683051943779,
-0.3644333481788635,
0.4500003159046173,
0.2678689956665039,
0.08832737058401108,
0.6727372407913208,
-0.04318320378661156,
0.029031451791524887,
0.05037582665681839,
-0.28044459223747253,
-0.686318576335907,
1.1908807754516602,
0.5377424359321594,
1.0102676153182983,
0.42235836386680603,
0.5403590798377991,
0.4232932925224304,
0.2606297731399536,
-0.9627671241760254,
0.566705048084259,
-0.20645512640476227,
-0.9017874598503113,
-0.5612569451332092,
-0.5263298153877258,
-1.0231742858886719,
-0.12252432852983475,
0.12006538361310959,
-0.8616407513618469,
0.21833427250385284,
-0.18182668089866638,
0.11733821034431458,
0.2343340367078781,
-0.5382609367370605,
0.7807790040969849,
-0.20498816668987274,
-0.661239743232727,
0.06453096866607666,
-0.3910890519618988,
0.6803703308105469,
-0.1786687821149826,
0.04818512499332428,
-0.34443607926368713,
-0.6603184938430786,
0.42917051911354065,
-0.5516866445541382,
0.4732223451137543,
0.05351194366812706,
-0.2838798463344574,
0.28762349486351013,
0.278254896402359,
0.7421727776527405,
0.2844725251197815,
-0.4196825921535492,
-0.13276264071464539,
-0.19870615005493164,
-0.19571906328201294,
-0.5445438623428345,
0.6887321472167969,
-0.3159708082675934,
-0.751003086566925,
-0.2852891981601715,
-0.6342265009880066,
-0.5745277404785156,
0.31051936745643616,
-0.030353689566254616,
0.05262628570199013,
-0.3856830894947052,
0.30306363105773926,
0.7538735866546631,
-0.28313159942626953,
0.2463153898715973,
0.7714599967002869,
-0.4952872693538666,
-0.2097318023443222,
0.48987704515457153,
-0.057240646332502365,
0.471451073884964,
0.5723135471343994,
-0.0070169419050216675,
-0.5904836058616638,
-0.979537844657898,
-0.5794240832328796,
0.24862195551395416,
-0.636193573474884,
-0.32612138986587524,
-0.5023274421691895,
-0.38708293437957764,
-0.4565548598766327,
0.11273685097694397,
-0.36800074577331543,
-0.4120360016822815,
-0.41626837849617004,
0.1024775579571724,
0.6251602172851562,
0.4695439338684082,
0.26012858748435974,
0.33251264691352844,
-0.9074625968933105,
0.33144620060920715,
0.32563158869743347,
0.7275128960609436,
-0.21124868094921112,
-0.8684878349304199,
-0.09906516224145889,
-0.19360670447349548,
-0.3942091763019562,
-0.965758740901947,
0.2375112920999527,
0.3979400098323822,
0.5819018483161926,
0.26430124044418335,
0.10049073398113251,
0.0631534606218338,
-0.42264464497566223,
0.9216378927230835,
-0.023434123024344444,
-0.9282690286636353,
0.8522381782531738,
-0.47075721621513367,
0.29150867462158203,
0.7778081893920898,
0.4278557300567627,
-0.2635478675365448,
-0.6077240705490112,
-0.17215554416179657,
-0.9642555713653564,
0.48259711265563965,
0.3543860614299774,
0.3938732445240021,
0.2612379491329193,
0.549750030040741,
-0.16532792150974274,
0.3834592401981354,
-0.7485780119895935,
-0.3828970193862915,
-0.09812869876623154,
-0.3015512526035309,
0.3364012837409973,
-0.5388714075088501,
0.038942575454711914,
0.02753221057355404,
0.445096880197525,
-0.06737447530031204,
0.19796746969223022,
0.00966284703463316,
-0.03997838869690895,
0.13188815116882324,
0.5104283690452576,
0.37066781520843506,
0.9430838823318481,
-0.4925187826156616,
-0.023645013570785522,
0.10551546514034271,
-0.752446711063385,
0.2706240117549896,
-0.019467785954475403,
-0.27004024386405945,
-0.33773699402809143,
0.37837862968444824,
0.37053182721138,
-0.18854837119579315,
-0.7955526113510132,
0.7983981370925903,
-0.11351467669010162,
-0.2540082633495331,
-0.2408445030450821,
0.060306280851364136,
0.22811973094940186,
0.2160434126853943,
0.5356600284576416,
-0.3101961016654968,
0.3778190314769745,
-0.8693798780441284,
0.3172719180583954,
0.3765009045600891,
-0.721508264541626,
0.26764947175979614,
0.8455067873001099,
0.08455314487218857,
-0.20570655167102814,
0.4284679591655731,
-0.25162962079048157,
-0.46093499660491943,
0.49787437915802,
0.47647592425346375,
0.8220920562744141,
-0.2672080099582672,
0.18998171389102936,
0.005951574072241783,
0.6446608304977417,
-0.12671267986297607,
0.3210473656654358,
0.1387796252965927,
-0.4161672294139862,
-0.39918026328086853,
-0.4988180994987488,
-0.5319874286651611,
0.2619169056415558,
-0.5946712493896484,
0.17062653601169586,
-0.595177412033081,
-0.18702614307403564,
-0.3179321587085724,
0.024792954325675964,
-0.19245228171348572,
0.5130663514137268,
-0.21423682570457458,
1.1757861375808716,
-0.4392457604408264,
0.8696602582931519,
0.4695826470851898,
-0.3363405466079712,
-0.44897669553756714,
-0.1223524734377861,
-0.13983581960201263,
-0.980803906917572,
0.5408722758293152,
-0.05454811081290245,
-0.216289222240448,
-0.2758561372756958,
-0.8353032469749451,
-0.5006650686264038,
1.3844785690307617,
0.3758021891117096,
-0.8019822835922241,
0.1627061814069748,
0.5295590162277222,
0.5140421390533447,
-0.4767579436302185,
0.013645164668560028,
0.7325087785720825,
0.42130255699157715,
0.4285118281841278,
-0.6598934531211853,
0.09763413667678833,
0.09946353733539581,
0.14069443941116333,
0.09397154301404953,
-0.40537235140800476,
0.8132684826850891,
-0.09890246391296387,
-0.30069658160209656,
0.23315569758415222,
0.7177518606185913,
0.43127214908599854,
0.8474252223968506,
0.27933216094970703,
0.5760703682899475,
0.6292291879653931,
-0.0522332526743412,
1.0088040828704834,
-0.19105572998523712,
0.14580926299095154,
1.1940441131591797,
-0.26417580246925354,
0.9517726898193359,
0.39940330386161804,
-0.167909637093544,
0.36993932723999023,
0.39623934030532837,
-0.16887152194976807,
0.4217144250869751,
0.13539385795593262,
-0.34312674403190613,
-0.08903460204601288,
-0.24555467069149017,
-0.0016051107086241245,
0.08877458423376083,
0.4760344326496124,
-0.5960775017738342,
0.048675961792469025,
-0.22347290813922882,
-0.08089576661586761,
0.45189106464385986,
-0.6120365262031555,
0.755603551864624,
0.16412453353405,
-0.2986096143722534,
0.17540112137794495,
0.4303651750087738,
0.6428653597831726,
-0.3743061125278473,
0.19244086742401123,
-0.4114856421947479,
-0.12331611663103104,
-0.36439818143844604,
-1.2234328985214233,
0.5870615243911743,
0.1178922951221466,
-0.20669066905975342,
0.1436668187379837,
0.9564430713653564,
-0.293649286031723,
-0.5353561043739319,
0.4863920211791992,
0.521919846534729,
0.05789394676685333,
-0.40875956416130066,
-0.8171688318252563,
0.12630634009838104,
-0.22536759078502655,
-0.17563849687576294,
0.03658891096711159,
0.7888748049736023,
-0.0705544576048851,
1.05811607837677,
0.4848361313343048,
0.2419227659702301,
0.13974960148334503,
0.2857314944267273,
0.7003223896026611,
-0.5601685047149658,
-0.19123175740242004,
-0.7454109787940979,
0.4466557800769806,
-0.19090375304222107,
-0.07924482226371765,
0.6801493167877197,
0.7551162838935852,
0.5356889367103577,
0.26860907673835754,
0.5973439812660217,
0.27301448583602905,
0.5547431111335754,
-0.7122725248336792,
0.8631427884101868,
-0.8108062744140625,
0.8142016530036926,
0.14606885612010956,
-0.9526315331459045,
-0.2994721233844757,
0.07769123464822769,
-0.26940518617630005,
0.3996242880821228,
0.3599618375301361,
1.0088157653808594,
-0.18064312636852264,
-0.28288787603378296,
0.663933277130127,
-0.04364040121436119,
0.32325175404548645,
0.4249023497104645,
0.9897394180297852,
-0.6095471978187561,
0.7684535384178162,
0.12778505682945251,
0.008009016513824463,
-0.37634944915771484,
-0.9929990172386169,
-0.8618718385696411,
-0.3402520418167114,
-0.16479231417179108,
-0.2712439000606537,
0.14814887940883636,
0.09862547367811203,
0.762260913848877,
-0.6512088775634766,
-0.127400204539299,
-0.3246384859085083,
0.2492147535085678,
0.34810131788253784,
-0.20810651779174805,
0.011382006108760834,
-0.23285001516342163,
-0.6015256643295288,
0.34712955355644226,
0.49470949172973633,
0.3321956992149353,
-0.50279700756073,
-0.17203164100646973,
0.018636329099535942,
0.47930797934532166,
0.547875165939331,
0.1682385355234146,
-0.4410346746444702,
-0.001233768416568637,
0.07358656823635101,
-0.49261680245399475,
0.11845618486404419,
0.8085248470306396,
-0.5229932069778442,
0.2699030041694641,
0.4649595320224762,
0.6409674286842346,
0.9119732975959778,
0.01749337650835514,
0.6611149311065674,
-0.9298534393310547,
-0.07020033150911331,
0.49560070037841797,
0.06313882023096085,
0.5278356075286865,
-0.5005597472190857,
0.5236459374427795,
-0.08762781322002411,
-0.6567954421043396,
-0.7562066912651062,
0.3914206922054291,
-0.9326798915863037,
-0.29538822174072266,
1.0079076290130615,
-0.23309341073036194,
-0.09689944982528687,
-0.398261696100235,
0.061981890350580215,
-0.08685018867254257,
-0.5115341544151306,
0.35059255361557007,
0.6347635388374329,
0.18309292197227478,
-0.4097035527229309,
-0.5959050059318542,
0.3505959212779999,
0.1701381504535675,
-1.0745296478271484,
0.07306648790836334,
0.28599706292152405,
0.11280056089162827,
-0.014043452218174934,
0.474298357963562,
-0.6210283637046814,
0.02502456121146679,
-0.06417879462242126,
-0.3701245188713074,
-0.2348480373620987,
-0.3224979639053345,
-0.0760517343878746,
0.32910653948783875,
0.4554099142551422,
0.044758591800928116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14854v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14854v1 | A Dual-Prompting for Interpretable Mental Health Language Models | 2024-02-20T06:18:02 | 2024-02-20T06:18:02 | Hyolim Jeon, Dongje Yoo, Daeun Lee, Sejung Son, Seungbae Kim, Jinyoung Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the increasing demand for AI-based mental health monitoring tools,
their practical utility for clinicians is limited by the lack of
interpretability.The CLPsych 2024 Shared Task (Chim et al., 2024) aims to
enhance the interpretability of Large Language Models (LLMs), particularly in
mental health analysis, by providing evidence of suicidality through linguistic
content. We propose a dual-prompting approach: (i) Knowledge-aware evidence
extraction by leveraging the expert identity and a suicide dictionary with a
mental health-specific LLM; and (ii) Evidence summarization by employing an
LLM-based consistency evaluator. Comprehensive experiments demonstrate the
effectiveness of combining domain-specific information, revealing performance
improvements and the approach's potential to aid clinicians in assessing mental
state progression. | [
-0.291725754737854,
-0.571505069732666,
1.1097928285598755,
0.2552739381790161,
-0.1004960909485817,
-0.2378564327955246,
-0.5502954125404358,
-0.26918530464172363,
0.06791578978300095,
0.39601483941078186,
-0.9581186771392822,
-0.6181032657623291,
-0.831995964050293,
0.21563854813575745,
-0.2137361764907837,
1.119673490524292,
-0.11542510241270065,
0.19731862843036652,
-0.15855427086353302,
0.018241524696350098,
-0.8499966859817505,
-0.24032486975193024,
-1.094859004020691,
-0.380024790763855,
0.8130883574485779,
0.3960314095020294,
0.7904382944107056,
-0.007904124446213245,
0.18017303943634033,
0.1431008279323578,
0.21540339291095734,
0.18964512646198273,
-0.26181602478027344,
0.08307525515556335,
-0.21218514442443848,
-0.28016945719718933,
-0.6911525726318359,
0.09601189941167831,
0.3189668357372284,
0.6703885197639465,
-0.24690043926239014,
0.04102352261543274,
0.19344165921211243,
0.43047967553138733,
-0.4678579568862915,
0.28371134400367737,
-0.3644826412200928,
-0.061008721590042114,
-0.10194099694490433,
-0.036078087985515594,
-0.469832181930542,
-0.22177091240882874,
0.1317758560180664,
-0.44720372557640076,
0.18521524965763092,
-0.5230209231376648,
0.39568018913269043,
0.5724411606788635,
-0.6247722506523132,
-0.33460044860839844,
-0.39270442724227905,
0.7072570323944092,
-0.9075338244438171,
0.49907857179641724,
0.46807217597961426,
0.16993533074855804,
-0.180632084608078,
-0.6326615214347839,
-0.6585565209388733,
-0.04714754968881607,
-0.22423088550567627,
0.3002699017524719,
-0.23560059070587158,
0.4353453516960144,
0.24626672267913818,
0.0638398826122284,
-0.508977472782135,
0.11686192452907562,
-0.19446197152137756,
-0.4005638659000397,
0.8483585119247437,
0.26821979880332947,
0.6939588189125061,
-0.029802490025758743,
-0.28012746572494507,
0.36549559235572815,
-0.4211766719818115,
-0.041261978447437286,
0.16195735335350037,
0.04336002096533775,
-0.2345496118068695,
0.3992016017436981,
-0.049593523144721985,
0.6302344799041748,
0.06366579234600067,
-0.2012912482023239,
0.02740587666630745,
-0.3679162561893463,
0.008648432791233063,
0.0517243891954422,
0.9139199256896973,
0.799098551273346,
-0.01842666044831276,
0.023388490080833435,
-0.00023218504793476313,
0.11143466830253601,
0.4947906732559204,
-0.5781493186950684,
-0.6290056109428406,
0.7604479789733887,
-0.4337911605834961,
0.1218687891960144,
-0.3129751682281494,
-1.0499948263168335,
-0.6733464598655701,
-0.44921138882637024,
0.5458401441574097,
-0.5440016984939575,
-0.5248474478721619,
0.4902430772781372,
-0.33959197998046875,
-0.3783911168575287,
0.4471057951450348,
-0.742394745349884,
0.16324089467525482,
0.6953327059745789,
0.9619159698486328,
-0.389229416847229,
-0.30798667669296265,
-0.3233821988105774,
0.18290454149246216,
-0.09375888109207153,
0.7767255306243896,
-0.26347485184669495,
-0.21076153218746185,
0.07486061006784439,
0.07866229861974716,
-0.23982486128807068,
-0.3732491731643677,
0.6879039406776428,
-0.1894521713256836,
0.3027612864971161,
-0.6478080749511719,
-0.5190109610557556,
-0.2437766194343567,
0.028044046834111214,
-0.6501879692077637,
0.9384034872055054,
-0.11353413015604019,
-1.0183602571487427,
0.5448583364486694,
-0.7662594318389893,
-0.17452527582645416,
0.30030718445777893,
-0.3199246823787689,
-0.2252682000398636,
0.057668477296829224,
0.17331978678703308,
0.6105056405067444,
-0.08829411119222641,
0.806995689868927,
-0.48344093561172485,
-0.13969826698303223,
-0.0472739152610302,
-0.5243048071861267,
0.8312935829162598,
0.009159564040601254,
-0.25031429529190063,
0.18121980130672455,
-0.5734672546386719,
-0.03205898404121399,
0.11003858596086502,
-0.31021714210510254,
-0.34255945682525635,
0.23787495493888855,
-0.10807468742132187,
0.14622440934181213,
0.7754318118095398,
-0.479056715965271,
-0.13151457905769348,
-0.19556225836277008,
0.147172212600708,
0.6004642844200134,
0.2862423062324524,
-0.06332661211490631,
-0.4850958585739136,
0.6482722163200378,
-0.23449161648750305,
0.13353995978832245,
0.09546031802892685,
-0.6957755088806152,
-0.28607088327407837,
-0.8998908996582031,
-0.24772730469703674,
0.697382926940918,
-0.28152140974998474,
0.7899888753890991,
-0.03647903352975845,
-0.29970553517341614,
-0.47685328125953674,
-0.07972339540719986,
0.22992463409900665,
0.609003484249115,
0.4645436108112335,
-0.159799724817276,
-0.8434939384460449,
-0.9091354012489319,
-0.4677284061908722,
-0.0583907850086689,
-0.016668668016791344,
-0.06340623646974564,
0.2165774703025818,
-0.4944026470184326,
0.8947077989578247,
-0.45223116874694824,
-0.05865854769945145,
-0.6088341474533081,
0.3129119575023651,
0.3297005295753479,
0.08199442923069,
0.17581121623516083,
-0.6400606632232666,
-0.5588549375534058,
-0.28636792302131653,
-0.9786560535430908,
-0.5454714298248291,
-0.12840606272220612,
-0.1330864429473877,
-0.271244078874588,
0.2239655703306198,
-0.653111457824707,
0.4993366301059723,
0.5616008043289185,
-0.2831721007823944,
0.8461576104164124,
-0.224982351064682,
0.12657701969146729,
-0.9244431257247925,
0.16348755359649658,
-0.26467761397361755,
-0.14204813539981842,
-1.005631923675537,
-0.30209651589393616,
0.01863083615899086,
0.07239022850990295,
-0.050653159618377686,
0.6272746324539185,
-0.3559774160385132,
0.31346893310546875,
-0.4968235492706299,
0.2055702805519104,
-0.040290191769599915,
0.11188299208879471,
0.16897298395633698,
0.8479560017585754,
0.48843297362327576,
-0.3185916244983673,
0.28682199120521545,
0.2841368317604065,
-0.0825878158211708,
0.7788340449333191,
-0.4865553379058838,
-0.2064152956008911,
-0.19471117854118347,
0.345547616481781,
-0.8876155614852905,
-0.48855143785476685,
0.19619664549827576,
-0.18722407519817352,
0.12426096946001053,
0.15352316200733185,
-0.23805803060531616,
-0.460158109664917,
-0.27072155475616455,
0.3381635546684265,
0.39053094387054443,
-0.43222886323928833,
0.3237629532814026,
0.38838931918144226,
-0.499101847410202,
-0.5836513042449951,
-0.3207898437976837,
0.22247734665870667,
-0.43495506048202515,
-0.5192334651947021,
0.09203306585550308,
-0.4365015923976898,
-0.2862081825733185,
-0.17720481753349304,
-0.1468103677034378,
0.058221034705638885,
0.2437496781349182,
0.43422096967697144,
0.3587506115436554,
-0.038475945591926575,
0.2732102870941162,
0.28961196541786194,
-0.10795014351606369,
0.46647101640701294,
-0.15124359726905823,
0.4682636559009552,
0.04249924421310425,
-0.2558099925518036,
-0.9803252220153809,
0.7167230844497681,
0.35341876745224,
0.00011612357047852129,
0.8805578351020813,
0.3731132447719574,
-0.5861302614212036,
-0.15823408961296082,
-0.47936102747917175,
-0.24746699631214142,
-0.3765738606452942,
0.16083146631717682,
-0.1599409580230713,
-0.8939336538314819,
0.322336345911026,
-0.30903029441833496,
0.14929333329200745,
0.3867775797843933,
0.7359319925308228,
-0.073328897356987,
1.3703738451004028,
0.6174069046974182,
0.15345832705497742,
0.16196061670780182,
0.14617222547531128,
0.5699013471603394,
-0.585338294506073,
-0.09601617604494095,
-0.13151240348815918,
0.028323868289589882,
0.04396224394440651,
-0.20421867072582245,
0.851345956325531,
0.28571879863739014,
-0.16501180827617645,
0.1583382785320282,
-0.5306252837181091,
0.132541224360466,
0.24634364247322083,
0.3026426136493683,
0.3734486401081085,
-0.12436758726835251,
-0.1786383092403412,
-0.4422339200973511,
-0.41752877831459045,
-0.5827522277832031,
0.861352264881134,
0.3279385566711426,
0.3129914402961731,
-0.0011781472712755203,
0.7811222672462463,
0.43098893761634827,
0.3943084478378296,
-0.6373064517974854,
0.4612399935722351,
-0.008420344442129135,
-0.6557958722114563,
-0.2773996889591217,
-0.2541194558143616,
-0.7834806442260742,
0.11673352867364883,
-0.03137917444109917,
-1.1231269836425781,
0.0010981123195961118,
0.2220134139060974,
-0.5289579033851624,
0.0207841619849205,
-0.5231194496154785,
1.0802217721939087,
-0.38581401109695435,
0.2655278742313385,
-0.5738193392753601,
-0.5079082250595093,
0.6136112213134766,
-0.5134472846984863,
0.5877923965454102,
-0.4167112410068512,
-0.21123182773590088,
0.8479121327400208,
-0.4070696532726288,
0.9715821146965027,
-0.38471007347106934,
-0.2929348349571228,
0.010988723486661911,
-0.03989836201071739,
0.30588456988334656,
0.2949889898300171,
-0.28360506892204285,
0.20292891561985016,
0.41248804330825806,
-0.2122136950492859,
-0.7070536017417908,
0.5057855248451233,
-0.5971879959106445,
-0.8751696348190308,
-0.22895541787147522,
-0.8256727457046509,
-0.5501179099082947,
0.5180193185806274,
0.3412562310695648,
0.34186580777168274,
-0.14526888728141785,
-0.467305064201355,
0.5452221632003784,
-0.32115986943244934,
0.031878579407930374,
0.6449328660964966,
-0.120182566344738,
-0.45016413927078247,
0.6504615545272827,
-0.1415223330259323,
0.27176475524902344,
-0.014146989211440086,
0.4314287304878235,
-0.2676106095314026,
-0.6828851699829102,
-0.20118147134780884,
0.5905290246009827,
-0.6288149952888489,
-0.057393934577703476,
-0.962565541267395,
-0.17857500910758972,
-0.49655547738075256,
-0.1777205914258957,
-0.1845550388097763,
-0.132674902677536,
-0.06031084805727005,
-0.28637948632240295,
0.49394315481185913,
0.9976049065589905,
-0.5519347786903381,
0.24634674191474915,
-0.8713504076004028,
0.3428218364715576,
0.19569526612758636,
0.07415984570980072,
0.029170768335461617,
-0.2343079298734665,
-0.2701568901538849,
0.2401832789182663,
0.0006458840216509998,
-1.3474750518798828,
0.2384934276342392,
0.18330928683280945,
0.609058678150177,
0.6352197527885437,
0.26272764801979065,
0.7126076817512512,
-0.471647173166275,
0.8468666672706604,
0.5082775354385376,
-0.9549999237060547,
0.8423817157745361,
-0.43964025378227234,
0.21493689715862274,
0.8063313961029053,
0.8677842020988464,
-0.9890486598014832,
-0.646930992603302,
-0.5378682017326355,
-0.5550251603126526,
0.5913121104240417,
-0.27834513783454895,
-0.27696284651756287,
-0.1246485635638237,
0.20347778499126434,
0.4235404133796692,
0.21917197108268738,
-0.2892248034477234,
-0.11906544864177704,
0.028548626229166985,
-0.7957165241241455,
0.03939961642026901,
-0.33729496598243713,
-0.6092315316200256,
-0.11734120547771454,
0.6218081712722778,
-0.33169102668762207,
0.30664679408073425,
0.2636040449142456,
0.24292995035648346,
-0.15329603850841522,
0.34788650274276733,
0.2564314603805542,
0.782172679901123,
-0.17163044214248657,
0.4225729703903198,
0.29685860872268677,
-0.4597361981868744,
0.0897638276219368,
0.2160230576992035,
-0.20680437982082367,
0.055709462612867355,
0.5535517334938049,
0.5030544400215149,
0.19837139546871185,
-1.092782735824585,
0.8326296806335449,
-0.1468418687582016,
-0.098374143242836,
-0.36767470836639404,
0.03488035500049591,
0.17090919613838196,
0.3122161030769348,
0.0931042805314064,
-0.11041881889104843,
0.3372490704059601,
-0.35137346386909485,
0.4155954122543335,
0.5518999695777893,
-0.3127196729183197,
-0.575581431388855,
0.6052237153053284,
-0.13966338336467743,
-0.17665733397006989,
0.32960957288742065,
-0.05362825468182564,
-0.59630286693573,
0.2806076407432556,
0.33586663007736206,
0.6145703196525574,
-0.17891184985637665,
0.4260849952697754,
0.4523429274559021,
-0.016980303451418877,
-0.28721851110458374,
0.7239974141120911,
-0.07405500113964081,
-0.6398226022720337,
-0.31257566809654236,
-0.4529910385608673,
-0.2635037302970886,
0.2370808720588684,
-0.987377941608429,
0.26601868867874146,
-0.39181235432624817,
-0.22770844399929047,
0.04886838421225548,
-0.06804092973470688,
-0.4691515564918518,
0.281244158744812,
0.3202971816062927,
0.8925068974494934,
-0.85328209400177,
0.7283092141151428,
0.6092527508735657,
-0.11436611413955688,
-0.8499319553375244,
0.1969451755285263,
0.5184297561645508,
-0.722449541091919,
0.2204802930355072,
0.33954474329948425,
-0.03968221694231033,
-0.3007974624633789,
-0.6162691116333008,
-0.7488288879394531,
1.0203485488891602,
0.3182595372200012,
-0.39735305309295654,
-0.31712645292282104,
0.011754623614251614,
0.556363582611084,
-0.188745379447937,
0.16358694434165955,
0.6574615836143494,
0.8283084630966187,
-0.296303927898407,
-1.0026339292526245,
0.2624930739402771,
0.06895061582326889,
-0.4649990200996399,
0.2761062979698181,
-0.38223153352737427,
0.40829789638519287,
-0.2978845238685608,
-0.5923048257827759,
0.004468000493943691,
0.5955596566200256,
0.34859222173690796,
0.5996735692024231,
0.662606954574585,
0.4828655421733856,
1.282951831817627,
0.4384699761867523,
0.6219365000724792,
-0.3569200038909912,
0.31751692295074463,
1.2661526203155518,
-0.36275890469551086,
0.864443838596344,
0.29384854435920715,
-0.2572323679924011,
0.6048451066017151,
0.4678681492805481,
0.15479734539985657,
0.512033224105835,
-0.27598053216934204,
-0.6787201166152954,
-0.5651047229766846,
-0.3636839985847473,
-0.1615844964981079,
0.08346239477396011,
0.7107341885566711,
-0.1825154423713684,
-0.36720189452171326,
0.14782631397247314,
0.4242860972881317,
0.03471951186656952,
0.04008181765675545,
0.6511029005050659,
0.37630173563957214,
-0.9422237873077393,
0.49888381361961365,
-0.15556298196315765,
0.5407838821411133,
-0.5945671796798706,
-0.021883776411414146,
0.13361643254756927,
0.07113485783338547,
-0.3334534764289856,
-0.9034074544906616,
0.6490444540977478,
0.0037599296774715185,
-0.31639355421066284,
-0.35291317105293274,
0.644981324672699,
-0.6117730736732483,
-0.2499760389328003,
0.7021511793136597,
0.6125780940055847,
0.2763201594352722,
-0.17254652082920074,
-0.7834395170211792,
-0.09115064889192581,
0.04644504934549332,
0.12953080236911774,
0.23766185343265533,
0.33457377552986145,
-0.07751911878585815,
0.43769991397857666,
0.4574698209762573,
0.4051617980003357,
-0.018791094422340393,
-0.0023898195941001177,
0.514924168586731,
-0.5287233591079712,
-0.32720860838890076,
-0.7255562543869019,
0.4682251811027527,
-0.09196227788925171,
-0.12025671452283859,
0.7528144121170044,
0.28593337535858154,
0.31857118010520935,
0.1976677030324936,
1.141624927520752,
-0.18504208326339722,
0.8502405881881714,
-0.38658979535102844,
0.8104590177536011,
-0.6627241373062134,
0.014256574213504791,
0.27064549922943115,
-0.30458080768585205,
-0.09670672565698624,
0.18165980279445648,
-0.47881945967674255,
-0.2200830578804016,
0.9794005751609802,
0.7214760184288025,
0.1719035804271698,
0.30473703145980835,
0.2850210964679718,
0.42212867736816406,
0.3064587414264679,
0.7959708571434021,
0.8464446067810059,
-0.05026299133896828,
0.017373984679579735,
-0.18186937272548676,
-0.5006087422370911,
0.09257657825946808,
-0.687228262424469,
-1.0804028511047363,
-0.7217101454734802,
-0.36141544580459595,
-0.22462952136993408,
0.15637905895709991,
0.7728109359741211,
0.4521200656890869,
-0.8476845026016235,
0.08071623742580414,
-0.0338544026017189,
0.001416049082763493,
-0.4265645444393158,
-0.18427041172981262,
0.2950897514820099,
-0.2556748390197754,
-0.3288758397102356,
0.6604140400886536,
0.375773549079895,
-0.4203934669494629,
-0.2903517484664917,
0.03735571354627609,
-0.1540849506855011,
0.15287207067012787,
0.21757598221302032,
0.1278776079416275,
-1.0129579305648804,
-0.3409236669540405,
-0.4747040271759033,
-0.09801089018583298,
-0.01808360405266285,
0.909665048122406,
-0.531958281993866,
0.3500024378299713,
0.47368040680885315,
0.43478795886039734,
-0.09580955654382706,
-0.004658597055822611,
0.8338413834571838,
-0.3085004985332489,
-0.21944162249565125,
0.15788859128952026,
0.34573566913604736,
0.24308907985687256,
-0.8676433563232422,
0.25917837023735046,
0.2304849624633789,
-0.6544779539108276,
-0.6104064583778381,
0.2800505757331848,
-0.9592555165290833,
-0.21103183925151825,
0.9605015516281128,
-0.45393088459968567,
-0.10578726977109909,
-0.48861345648765564,
-0.32968011498451233,
0.328360915184021,
-0.4850618541240692,
0.6153795719146729,
0.7439166307449341,
-0.3487904965877533,
-0.31613659858703613,
-0.8690085411071777,
0.8217571973800659,
0.48125389218330383,
-0.8643866777420044,
0.28877678513526917,
0.4383509159088135,
0.5430259704589844,
-0.05146448314189911,
0.7895725965499878,
0.06998643279075623,
0.5079972147941589,
-0.253244549036026,
0.09250515699386597,
0.23340408504009247,
-0.28503257036209106,
-0.5267952084541321,
-0.06881271302700043,
-0.10403213649988174,
0.4002330005168915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12738v1 | Can Large Language Models be Used to Provide Psychological Counselling? An Analysis of GPT-4-Generated Responses Using Role-play Dialogues | 2024-02-20T06:05:36 | 2024-02-20T06:05:36 | Michimasa Inaba, Mariko Ukiyo, Keiko Takamizo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Mental health care poses an increasingly serious challenge to modern
societies. In this context, there has been a surge in research that utilizes
information technologies to address mental health problems, including those
aiming to develop counseling dialogue systems. However, there is a need for
more evaluations of the performance of counseling dialogue systems that use
large language models. For this study, we collected counseling dialogue data
via role-playing scenarios involving expert counselors, and the utterances were
annotated with the intentions of the counselors. To determine the feasibility
of a dialogue system in real-world counseling scenarios, third-party counselors
evaluated the appropriateness of responses from human counselors and those
generated by GPT-4 in identical contexts in role-play dialogue data. Analysis
of the evaluation results showed that the responses generated by GPT-4 were
competitive with those of human counselors. | [
-0.46498048305511475,
-0.7346317768096924,
0.9939050078392029,
0.3664133548736572,
-0.1390186846256256,
-0.3016374409198761,
-0.3686731159687042,
-0.6439715623855591,
-0.08829762041568756,
0.3080954849720001,
-0.6172902584075928,
-0.27109065651893616,
-0.42190396785736084,
0.3854614198207855,
-0.1501844823360443,
0.8966203331947327,
0.09307664632797241,
0.5267672538757324,
0.16158507764339447,
0.3832058012485504,
-0.953727126121521,
-0.7561929821968079,
-1.045706868171692,
-0.2640412449836731,
0.36464986205101013,
0.19416619837284088,
0.8123204708099365,
-0.13060176372528076,
0.45726004242897034,
0.37931951880455017,
0.20185767114162445,
-0.20381367206573486,
-0.4206573963165283,
0.22504903376102448,
-0.30399271845817566,
-0.4028564393520355,
-0.8100581169128418,
0.38104239106178284,
0.45220011472702026,
0.293326199054718,
-0.3899748921394348,
0.07308433204889297,
0.0432414673268795,
0.16372588276863098,
-0.10252208262681961,
0.39668482542037964,
-0.42685896158218384,
0.32555145025253296,
0.053521692752838135,
-0.14510853588581085,
-0.41305914521217346,
-0.3317246437072754,
0.4952771067619324,
-0.6930846571922302,
0.1358848214149475,
-0.13072071969509125,
0.49562087655067444,
-0.06822813302278519,
-0.42838287353515625,
-0.4338415563106537,
-1.0762462615966797,
0.37771573662757874,
-1.084622859954834,
0.15813708305358887,
0.7689353227615356,
0.5459496974945068,
-0.36899328231811523,
-0.32528775930404663,
-0.5074581503868103,
-0.25191497802734375,
-0.14104250073432922,
0.3070809841156006,
-0.1696338653564453,
0.24311023950576782,
0.6609407663345337,
0.14952999353408813,
-0.4034979045391083,
-0.014807776547968388,
-0.4694933295249939,
-0.1131225973367691,
0.730050802230835,
0.362300843000412,
0.35990139842033386,
0.0842432752251625,
0.21942110359668732,
0.17641499638557434,
-0.2843133807182312,
-0.16961288452148438,
0.2723256051540375,
0.23611095547676086,
0.044117994606494904,
0.5241041779518127,
0.18828116357326508,
0.483773797750473,
0.2326231449842453,
-0.6577956080436707,
-0.2972872853279114,
-0.07383372634649277,
-0.22848133742809296,
0.09614085406064987,
0.8490843176841736,
0.9295706152915955,
0.4422009587287903,
-0.05100882798433304,
-0.09468697756528854,
0.030098432675004005,
0.5042060017585754,
-0.8471092581748962,
-0.13133583962917328,
-0.026653993874788284,
-0.4207681715488434,
-0.06990210711956024,
-0.43483462929725647,
-0.9515630006790161,
-0.44353458285331726,
-0.2868705689907074,
0.28467851877212524,
-0.40893277525901794,
-0.5074018239974976,
0.013913428410887718,
0.04150625690817833,
0.18411725759506226,
0.25479674339294434,
-0.8484180569648743,
0.5938051342964172,
0.5307172536849976,
0.942621111869812,
0.0667443573474884,
-0.036004792898893356,
-0.38622674345970154,
0.09550473093986511,
-0.4286477863788605,
0.5157681703567505,
-0.5649930238723755,
-0.7767403721809387,
0.17824603617191315,
-0.11130789667367935,
-0.04964539408683777,
-0.4527877867221832,
0.6220852732658386,
-0.38649970293045044,
0.4249570369720459,
-0.5716356039047241,
-0.4790045917034149,
0.41111132502555847,
0.45805197954177856,
-0.5075048804283142,
0.5171172618865967,
0.21444649994373322,
-0.8511901497840881,
0.31153109669685364,
-0.7195711731910706,
-0.27673882246017456,
0.19366799294948578,
-0.36605823040008545,
-0.060634076595306396,
0.048362329602241516,
0.17900057137012482,
0.4347839653491974,
-0.6336485147476196,
0.5840201377868652,
-0.40371599793434143,
-0.6506855487823486,
0.5700850486755371,
-0.686373770236969,
0.26036763191223145,
0.2177899032831192,
-0.48999759554862976,
-0.1988716572523117,
-0.24981608986854553,
0.03967573121190071,
0.08385828882455826,
-0.38899093866348267,
-0.1518131047487259,
-0.1007671132683754,
-0.06398500502109528,
0.5552512407302856,
-0.15531647205352783,
-0.7116348743438721,
0.2972797453403473,
-0.2884541153907776,
0.4162638783454895,
0.6467543244361877,
0.09218979626893997,
-0.03725599870085716,
-0.20874693989753723,
1.044344186782837,
-0.2382345348596573,
0.07931183278560638,
0.02651989832520485,
-0.768174409866333,
-0.15388476848602295,
-0.4161919355392456,
-0.08240456134080887,
0.41963326930999756,
-0.8877537250518799,
0.22257564961910248,
0.006609954405575991,
-0.3956316113471985,
-0.22419306635856628,
-0.5200807452201843,
0.47246354818344116,
0.535560131072998,
0.16137893497943878,
-0.09658830612897873,
-0.4353851079940796,
-0.9723341464996338,
-0.51540607213974,
-0.31992918252944946,
-0.07806309312582016,
0.5199235677719116,
0.13368700444698334,
-0.07326020300388336,
0.979492723941803,
-0.5864540934562683,
-0.19674645364284515,
-0.19606532156467438,
0.12304096668958664,
-0.02943209931254387,
0.3633781373500824,
0.6901921033859253,
-0.2867374122142792,
-0.4355560541152954,
-0.1416306495666504,
-0.8197745084762573,
-0.29050934314727783,
0.13814343512058258,
-0.10543352365493774,
0.027971409261226654,
0.2287546694278717,
-0.6168010830879211,
0.38667020201683044,
0.7786223888397217,
-0.5215370655059814,
0.9266614317893982,
-0.45461881160736084,
0.30316510796546936,
-0.9312066435813904,
0.05410221964120865,
0.15028902888298035,
-0.12789438664913177,
-0.6764349341392517,
-0.3360520601272583,
-0.31632980704307556,
-0.4981347322463989,
0.025303354486823082,
0.38467466831207275,
-0.101705402135849,
-0.09036269783973694,
-0.2275419533252716,
0.15859079360961914,
-0.5054754614830017,
0.4481794834136963,
0.03778650611639023,
0.8860512375831604,
0.4562835395336151,
-0.22861622273921967,
0.4273747503757477,
0.2995181381702423,
-0.22425299882888794,
0.9816676378250122,
-0.49930769205093384,
0.1565045714378357,
0.1724100261926651,
0.9317380785942078,
-0.7576208710670471,
-0.6853547096252441,
0.057611893862485886,
-0.058748915791511536,
0.03592019900679588,
-0.10278091579675674,
-0.38874751329421997,
-0.7279034852981567,
0.11572308838367462,
0.5699924826622009,
0.27697643637657166,
-0.02515660598874092,
0.2333606332540512,
0.29979315400123596,
-0.6236802935600281,
-0.2710733711719513,
-0.4600328803062439,
0.3461950421333313,
-0.4773269593715668,
-0.43665850162506104,
-0.0011269573587924242,
-0.08735783398151398,
-0.13911192119121552,
-0.23348122835159302,
0.07663445174694061,
-0.017168568447232246,
-0.14206156134605408,
0.21517381072044373,
0.3005642592906952,
-0.1249128133058548,
0.23376710712909698,
-0.05540115386247635,
-0.22423870861530304,
0.32357388734817505,
-0.2779921293258667,
0.5104866027832031,
-0.28057992458343506,
-0.660538911819458,
-0.5425060987472534,
0.7067242860794067,
0.6308570504188538,
-0.21342085301876068,
0.6387948393821716,
0.5734285712242126,
-0.5240562558174133,
0.2756463289260864,
-0.7679089307785034,
-0.26441138982772827,
-0.47045502066612244,
0.29770106077194214,
-0.3239877223968506,
-1.1316490173339844,
0.3507141172885895,
-0.07811697572469711,
0.010704005137085915,
0.033969148993492126,
0.6630051732063293,
0.04782140254974365,
1.6378028392791748,
0.15947553515434265,
0.24352788925170898,
0.4171328544616699,
-0.10265035927295685,
0.6891905665397644,
-0.666480541229248,
0.003397384425625205,
-0.18224866688251495,
-0.2745461165904999,
-0.8065618276596069,
-0.1348927915096283,
0.6405893564224243,
-0.01568971760571003,
-0.5048078894615173,
0.10832663625478745,
-0.381753534078598,
0.11227788776159286,
0.24826543033123016,
0.17242515087127686,
0.3053174614906311,
-0.22675243020057678,
-0.32182541489601135,
-0.44420838356018066,
-0.36455225944519043,
-0.7278124094009399,
0.7611385583877563,
0.43533429503440857,
0.5554391741752625,
0.33342787623405457,
0.3892727196216583,
-0.058847978711128235,
0.8046188950538635,
-0.8003299832344055,
0.6347838044166565,
0.2961438000202179,
-0.8590047955513,
-0.4682098627090454,
-0.4458980858325958,
-0.9408586621284485,
0.3738214373588562,
-0.20624834299087524,
-1.224027156829834,
0.04069224372506142,
0.1220664530992508,
-0.5966899394989014,
0.08238506317138672,
-0.8236171007156372,
0.8280662298202515,
-0.18274632096290588,
0.021362684667110443,
-0.21296027302742004,
-0.4344787299633026,
0.5840806365013123,
-0.4251912534236908,
0.3675316572189331,
-0.1596686989068985,
0.42058828473091125,
0.7540895342826843,
-0.47186946868896484,
0.5896768569946289,
-0.4659942090511322,
-0.5335518717765808,
0.15736772119998932,
0.2510083317756653,
0.3361809551715851,
0.2625049352645874,
-0.25028514862060547,
-0.49411261081695557,
0.5564700365066528,
-0.13876672089099884,
-0.862026035785675,
0.8102699518203735,
-0.8902415037155151,
-0.9412223100662231,
-0.39841392636299133,
-0.549338698387146,
-0.8925905227661133,
0.166965052485466,
0.1199367344379425,
0.7784386277198792,
-0.3357369899749756,
-0.1501835584640503,
0.044903259724378586,
-0.32630056142807007,
0.21427924931049347,
0.6822420358657837,
-0.45141923427581787,
-0.32948923110961914,
0.6784650087356567,
0.24012497067451477,
0.19273363053798676,
-0.5886939167976379,
0.39205145835876465,
-0.1266613006591797,
-0.2197316288948059,
-0.08315234631299973,
0.5158136487007141,
-0.48235365748405457,
-0.07311147451400757,
-0.5202740430831909,
-0.02824801579117775,
-0.3635171949863434,
-0.14994056522846222,
-0.15821515023708344,
0.03032456710934639,
0.32022330164909363,
-0.3510068356990814,
0.23595160245895386,
1.0624334812164307,
-0.1252897083759308,
0.3792973756790161,
-0.8732585906982422,
0.07090562582015991,
0.4808286428451538,
0.5936861038208008,
0.24855352938175201,
-0.056329626590013504,
-0.3294607996940613,
0.19747032225131989,
-0.31592661142349243,
-1.1753499507904053,
0.3070182502269745,
-0.12433329969644547,
0.35275185108184814,
0.38880759477615356,
0.054200172424316406,
0.8146153092384338,
-0.6467651724815369,
1.0556349754333496,
0.2072816640138626,
-0.7692994475364685,
0.41521018743515015,
-1.0131593942642212,
0.32676905393600464,
0.40496814250946045,
0.31663691997528076,
-0.7844229936599731,
-0.43690183758735657,
-0.6350629925727844,
-0.5710219740867615,
1.21525239944458,
0.32636573910713196,
0.10370011627674103,
-0.1979670375585556,
0.5060835480690002,
-0.23086880147457123,
0.17744623124599457,
-0.5385536551475525,
0.19849063456058502,
-0.08603495359420776,
-0.20385749638080597,
0.06207362189888954,
-0.15454863011837006,
-0.4880259037017822,
0.041765376925468445,
0.49498406052589417,
-0.037731561809778214,
0.7994055151939392,
0.2541327178478241,
0.3732368052005768,
-0.3648500442504883,
0.37007904052734375,
0.5015323162078857,
0.49494796991348267,
-0.15229082107543945,
-0.02776496298611164,
0.23652444779872894,
-0.572056233882904,
0.3333025276660919,
0.12582293152809143,
0.39632076025009155,
-0.36992931365966797,
0.35919150710105896,
0.6681882739067078,
0.25779294967651367,
-0.6680317521095276,
0.6649130582809448,
-0.49845269322395325,
-0.2823162078857422,
-0.27619656920433044,
0.06790757179260254,
0.17469491064548492,
0.4745419919490814,
0.08694326132535934,
-0.24005301296710968,
0.2521601915359497,
-0.8504365086555481,
-0.013981396332383156,
0.41208845376968384,
-0.47309380769729614,
-0.37277325987815857,
0.4690486788749695,
0.24352023005485535,
-0.6405518651008606,
0.6439974308013916,
-0.037970829755067825,
-0.4822133779525757,
0.25310006737709045,
1.050673246383667,
0.5933488011360168,
-0.4344548285007477,
0.36754634976387024,
0.29171955585479736,
-0.06417310982942581,
-0.40932634472846985,
0.15877221524715424,
0.21376866102218628,
-0.5489575266838074,
-0.606895387172699,
-0.3185146152973175,
-0.43961915373802185,
0.43110910058021545,
-0.7673866152763367,
0.023859262466430664,
-0.28170686960220337,
-0.7728816866874695,
-0.2871010899543762,
-0.16122916340827942,
-0.9278330206871033,
0.2812325954437256,
0.2494058907032013,
0.5090303421020508,
-0.8335943818092346,
0.5605061054229736,
0.7858737707138062,
-0.23873774707317352,
-1.255491018295288,
0.1572609394788742,
0.193838968873024,
-0.21639487147331238,
0.4551103711128235,
0.18076592683792114,
-0.24814648926258087,
-0.16711802780628204,
-0.4277082681655884,
-0.8122480511665344,
1.1441563367843628,
0.689846396446228,
-0.20907215774059296,
-0.5194071531295776,
0.19660553336143494,
0.9643651247024536,
-0.5041136145591736,
0.7190228700637817,
0.8524837493896484,
0.6364420652389526,
0.0233262088149786,
-1.5402294397354126,
0.18252328038215637,
-0.3474363088607788,
0.13073575496673584,
-0.22628432512283325,
-0.5241195559501648,
0.6144067645072937,
0.2542736828327179,
-0.16252091526985168,
0.22244088351726532,
0.26780956983566284,
0.4395950734615326,
-0.07121451944112778,
0.5181344151496887,
0.04086754098534584,
0.6827682852745056,
0.0013924745144322515,
1.048197627067566,
-0.3030746877193451,
0.40816953778266907,
1.1291580200195312,
-0.609284520149231,
0.5254845023155212,
-0.058591652661561966,
-0.2275831252336502,
0.2626711130142212,
0.5010471343994141,
0.2281382530927658,
0.1657758504152298,
0.31280386447906494,
-0.3222896158695221,
-0.25845056772232056,
-0.11238222569227219,
-0.31451547145843506,
0.35665103793144226,
0.6929677724838257,
-0.17124724388122559,
-0.09111694991588593,
0.21745742857456207,
0.16780295968055725,
-0.13712993264198303,
0.03189186379313469,
0.6968843340873718,
0.2707999050617218,
-1.002974033355713,
0.32041606307029724,
0.13068200647830963,
0.3326268792152405,
-0.5519464612007141,
-0.2537013292312622,
0.033996887505054474,
0.31293120980262756,
-0.20630215108394623,
-0.6896490454673767,
0.023485157638788223,
0.36398038268089294,
0.2629963457584381,
-0.14934132993221283,
0.6121267676353455,
-0.35946640372276306,
-0.44302359223365784,
0.26809537410736084,
0.5988496541976929,
0.2958304286003113,
0.013810018077492714,
-0.4411572515964508,
-0.2637459337711334,
-0.35474342107772827,
-0.25338688492774963,
0.5730586051940918,
0.5813779234886169,
-0.22442041337490082,
0.5340887308120728,
0.3911302387714386,
0.060553956776857376,
-0.2230122685432434,
0.15587222576141357,
0.801751971244812,
-0.521254301071167,
-0.6369662880897522,
-0.6073237657546997,
0.14670924842357635,
-0.23804037272930145,
-0.2205488532781601,
0.7443639039993286,
0.15032435953617096,
0.24325793981552124,
0.1187969446182251,
1.026537299156189,
0.05386990308761597,
0.4670288860797882,
-0.23714877665042877,
0.3606639504432678,
-0.11538255959749222,
0.07968230545520782,
-0.8033758997917175,
-1.0115536451339722,
-0.09449749439954758,
0.8885498642921448,
-0.8016207814216614,
0.41199973225593567,
0.8276197910308838,
0.6283197402954102,
0.03026752732694149,
0.46351057291030884,
0.4200257658958435,
0.35528111457824707,
0.921604573726654,
0.3973448872566223,
0.9519352912902832,
0.06558071821928024,
0.3553194999694824,
0.3179277181625366,
-0.39910098910331726,
-0.05172492563724518,
-0.6470537781715393,
-1.0349738597869873,
-0.4444187581539154,
0.1959383189678192,
-0.2750380039215088,
-0.021526142954826355,
1.1809101104736328,
0.42415758967399597,
-0.4807528853416443,
-0.20330914855003357,
0.23021294176578522,
-0.7301202416419983,
-0.06344623118638992,
-0.22273054718971252,
0.23506957292556763,
-0.046225983649492264,
-0.4938047528266907,
0.4407165050506592,
0.05123376473784447,
-0.04792125150561333,
-0.564690113067627,
0.04134199768304825,
0.06922845542430878,
0.2646653652191162,
0.6695095300674438,
-0.06112261116504669,
-0.8092519640922546,
-0.4823013246059418,
-0.1069074496626854,
-0.06641125679016113,
-0.16653572022914886,
1.2444335222244263,
-0.5211992263793945,
0.4207686483860016,
0.0588158518075943,
0.3000718057155609,
0.47851550579071045,
0.10130888968706131,
1.3325954675674438,
-0.37587910890579224,
-0.04446160048246384,
0.14003486931324005,
0.3760007321834564,
0.2837759256362915,
-0.5721686482429504,
0.5007306337356567,
-0.10068455338478088,
-0.7958616018295288,
-0.5939574837684631,
0.21351557970046997,
-0.4408275783061981,
0.0392446368932724,
1.212540626525879,
-0.6285777688026428,
0.42911145091056824,
-0.36919376254081726,
-0.9010676741600037,
0.3618808686733246,
-0.6489842534065247,
0.6382585763931274,
1.110315203666687,
-0.5126647353172302,
0.043338190764188766,
-0.8996336460113525,
0.7048673629760742,
0.1362553983926773,
-0.7220490574836731,
0.00983557477593422,
0.6487789154052734,
0.17985303699970245,
0.1634044647216797,
1.058749794960022,
-0.1361270248889923,
0.10179939866065979,
-0.2960892915725708,
-0.4015972912311554,
0.24592448770999908,
0.1421608179807663,
-0.07499587535858154,
-0.011196920648217201,
0.27866142988204956,
0.7239981293678284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14853v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14853v1 | NL2Formula: Generating Spreadsheet Formulas from Natural Language Queries | 2024-02-20T05:58:05 | 2024-02-20T05:58:05 | Wei Zhao, Zhitao Hou, Siyuan Wu, Yan Gao, Haoyu Dong, Yao Wan, Hongyu Zhang, Yulei Sui, Haidong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Writing formulas on spreadsheets, such as Microsoft Excel and Google Sheets,
is a widespread practice among users performing data analysis. However,
crafting formulas on spreadsheets remains a tedious and error-prone task for
many end-users, particularly when dealing with complex operations. To alleviate
the burden associated with writing spreadsheet formulas, this paper introduces
a novel benchmark task called NL2Formula, with the aim to generate executable
formulas that are grounded on a spreadsheet table, given a Natural Language
(NL) query as input. To accomplish this, we construct a comprehensive dataset
consisting of 70,799 paired NL queries and corresponding spreadsheet formulas,
covering 21,670 tables and 37 types of formula functions. We realize the
NL2Formula task by providing a sequence-to-sequence baseline implementation
called fCoder. Experimental results validate the effectiveness of fCoder,
demonstrating its superior performance compared to the baseline models.
Furthermore, we also compare fCoder with an initial GPT-3.5 model (i.e.,
text-davinci-003). Lastly, through in-depth error analysis, we identify
potential challenges in the NL2Formula task and advocate for further
investigation. | [
0.15422634780406952,
-0.8826326727867126,
0.1942640095949173,
0.3689757287502289,
0.1322118043899536,
-0.0532018318772316,
-0.3019962012767792,
-0.47431302070617676,
-0.1372145563364029,
0.5401879549026489,
-0.5523971915245056,
-0.5762239098548889,
-0.27187418937683105,
0.33980652689933777,
-0.6064737439155579,
1.018890380859375,
-0.28151631355285645,
-0.09495273977518082,
-0.4109366834163666,
-0.04639890044927597,
-0.32928720116615295,
-0.33028021454811096,
-0.2489246279001236,
0.23006176948547363,
0.276525616645813,
0.6380446553230286,
0.414867103099823,
0.42531898617744446,
0.5187873840332031,
0.19069194793701172,
0.13110202550888062,
0.24605758488178253,
-0.5720732808113098,
0.5102761387825012,
0.3018452823162079,
-0.578332781791687,
-0.4144010543823242,
0.03151148185133934,
0.6856585144996643,
0.7054726481437683,
-0.3491784632205963,
0.41392916440963745,
-0.04718538373708725,
0.9978885054588318,
-0.4110589623451233,
0.23990707099437714,
-0.802061915397644,
0.24064455926418304,
-0.5132946372032166,
0.18427179753780365,
-0.4548218548297882,
-0.8103471398353577,
0.03987206891179085,
-0.7524585723876953,
0.36079153418540955,
0.05574312061071396,
0.5839118361473083,
0.4055033028125763,
-0.044593747705221176,
-0.7421364784240723,
-0.48672056198120117,
0.4635132849216461,
-0.7692379355430603,
0.18039558827877045,
0.3059801161289215,
0.591654360294342,
-0.49156492948532104,
-0.8469418287277222,
-0.6206343770027161,
-0.3914951682090759,
-0.3319409489631653,
0.19812190532684326,
-0.30163097381591797,
-0.6043143272399902,
0.6492947340011597,
-0.034151941537857056,
-0.8154416084289551,
-0.05644269660115242,
-0.5174217224121094,
0.06534814834594727,
0.45070433616638184,
0.15519733726978302,
0.23884107172489166,
-0.21636058390140533,
-0.2213219702243805,
-0.16257795691490173,
-0.6432377696037292,
0.24064160883426666,
0.3704586923122406,
0.4246387183666229,
-0.13164763152599335,
0.5728776454925537,
-0.18809957802295685,
0.59305739402771,
-0.27707910537719727,
0.2300363928079605,
0.001752784475684166,
-0.20045065879821777,
-0.31599244475364685,
0.1027868241071701,
0.6981322765350342,
0.32495537400245667,
0.18291817605495453,
-0.45825526118278503,
0.09523486346006393,
0.11241501569747925,
0.4081103503704071,
-0.8086800575256348,
-0.3469257354736328,
0.2496240735054016,
0.11650906503200531,
-0.33315619826316833,
0.206273153424263,
-0.8211771249771118,
0.024541353806853294,
-0.48820918798446655,
0.13266222178936005,
-0.4691696763038635,
0.1443142145872116,
-0.5296725034713745,
0.051564887166023254,
0.0880841612815857,
0.3217693567276001,
-0.74711012840271,
0.6383231282234192,
0.7723557353019714,
0.8251206278800964,
-0.1589125245809555,
-0.0785854309797287,
-1.0122597217559814,
0.2238471508026123,
-0.3464893102645874,
0.937279224395752,
-0.3076973259449005,
-0.4895329177379608,
-0.16386981308460236,
-0.2533743679523468,
-0.1833314746618271,
-0.5637462139129639,
0.630162239074707,
-0.22127756476402283,
0.35569241642951965,
-0.6183293461799622,
-0.7204806804656982,
0.07828471064567566,
0.026509912684559822,
-0.9847249388694763,
1.3917219638824463,
0.4080963730812073,
-0.5176659226417542,
0.26356667280197144,
-0.947443425655365,
-0.5317665934562683,
0.23504042625427246,
-0.2852729856967926,
-0.509039044380188,
-0.055981360375881195,
-0.004192034248262644,
0.18793413043022156,
-0.5737159848213196,
0.21398654580116272,
0.09663734585046768,
-0.20253467559814453,
0.04444942623376846,
-0.0440804623067379,
0.5069969892501831,
-0.06824689358472824,
-0.5828922390937805,
0.11845944821834564,
-0.7784401774406433,
0.24080468714237213,
0.09114217758178711,
-0.12984994053840637,
-0.11296287924051285,
-0.05651112273335457,
0.21905513107776642,
0.0441267304122448,
-0.03569255769252777,
-0.3774316608905792,
0.21455223858356476,
-0.27893874049186707,
0.3955647349357605,
0.2247704267501831,
-0.4365980923175812,
0.3556172251701355,
-0.2039683610200882,
0.39926621317863464,
-0.3562778830528259,
-0.2000267505645752,
0.04585912451148033,
-0.5665283203125,
-0.36923936009407043,
0.092350073158741,
0.2609708607196808,
0.7467178702354431,
-0.4073495864868164,
0.19003450870513916,
-0.13175787031650543,
-0.7649272084236145,
-0.06369233876466751,
0.4773321747779846,
0.6309808492660522,
1.1260942220687866,
0.5147436857223511,
0.2766262888908386,
-0.6563131213188171,
-0.8596964478492737,
-0.29274559020996094,
0.06244712322950363,
-0.023976685479283333,
0.28691279888153076,
0.4790237843990326,
-0.02614859864115715,
1.0456602573394775,
-0.5923663377761841,
-0.4062328040599823,
-0.16000516712665558,
0.46657663583755493,
0.3975386321544647,
0.3168468773365021,
0.7066039443016052,
-0.7444411516189575,
-0.8170905709266663,
-0.03644662722945213,
-0.7147736549377441,
-0.33107268810272217,
0.0877218171954155,
-0.5096816420555115,
0.6667967438697815,
0.44030365347862244,
-0.33843693137168884,
0.320831298828125,
0.4054815471172333,
-0.21313336491584778,
0.7132506370544434,
-0.15893082320690155,
-0.16922083497047424,
-1.0578129291534424,
0.7138680815696716,
0.02134062349796295,
0.02258889377117157,
-0.7154787182807922,
-0.19620774686336517,
0.4801150858402252,
0.05858001485466957,
-0.1641412079334259,
0.3949754536151886,
-0.2268206775188446,
-0.15766078233718872,
0.1914745718240738,
-0.08560308814048767,
-0.012806979939341545,
0.23935739696025848,
-0.13701879978179932,
1.0577373504638672,
-0.138718843460083,
-0.38899850845336914,
-0.04555113613605499,
0.6593379378318787,
-0.22427795827388763,
0.49156051874160767,
-0.7501667141914368,
0.12098266929388046,
0.08814327418804169,
0.28985732793807983,
-1.0202460289001465,
-0.36796361207962036,
-0.19984853267669678,
-0.3031024932861328,
0.20831288397312164,
-0.09822675585746765,
-0.44864580035209656,
-0.5222985148429871,
-0.19030028581619263,
0.060078226029872894,
0.517228901386261,
-0.3332021236419678,
0.3542073667049408,
0.343649685382843,
-0.27373525500297546,
-0.5114916563034058,
-0.5127634406089783,
0.22605830430984497,
-0.0821666568517685,
-0.7097014784812927,
0.6639589667320251,
0.11210443824529648,
-0.2904254198074341,
-0.01919638179242611,
-0.19024445116519928,
0.03502177447080612,
0.01330927200615406,
0.3010968267917633,
0.2939641773700714,
-0.19229723513126373,
-0.11269766092300415,
0.28022104501724243,
-0.09368223696947098,
0.19266898930072784,
-0.05477899685502052,
0.4263332188129425,
-0.15752747654914856,
0.09973679482936859,
-0.1711239218711853,
0.6239574551582336,
0.35584622621536255,
-0.07317372411489487,
0.22868332266807556,
0.5838443636894226,
-0.44843631982803345,
-0.3931307792663574,
-0.4150758385658264,
-0.0018147892551496625,
-0.3787626624107361,
0.0974498987197876,
-0.19069938361644745,
-0.5235890746116638,
0.4962204396724701,
0.33684390783309937,
0.39267686009407043,
0.7549557089805603,
0.7158742547035217,
-0.20245161652565002,
0.4346388876438141,
0.32835930585861206,
0.31746187806129456,
0.11287171393632889,
-0.3780170977115631,
-0.011233178898692131,
-0.7656593322753906,
-0.44610992074012756,
-0.6581767201423645,
-0.28604674339294434,
-0.36192214488983154,
-0.5410556197166443,
0.5632131099700928,
0.19243228435516357,
-0.10305934399366379,
0.9901435971260071,
-0.34945595264434814,
0.30789914727211,
0.7618067860603333,
-0.22853416204452515,
0.11303360760211945,
0.0324854850769043,
-0.47657516598701477,
-0.18622756004333496,
-0.47545352578163147,
-0.636377215385437,
1.201715350151062,
-0.1938391923904419,
0.26250046491622925,
0.4654782712459564,
0.6788985729217529,
0.2841704189777374,
0.8854848742485046,
-0.4119279086589813,
0.2632324993610382,
-0.454036146402359,
-0.3778592050075531,
-0.32098183035850525,
-0.6053060293197632,
-0.6337488293647766,
-0.08329296857118607,
-0.157473623752594,
-0.7200633883476257,
-0.3284248411655426,
0.28426384925842285,
-0.3326560854911804,
-0.05789565294981003,
-0.8911217451095581,
1.0751146078109741,
-0.30278822779655457,
-0.7507805824279785,
0.42500734329223633,
-0.6062303185462952,
0.5118130445480347,
-0.24836145341396332,
0.283257395029068,
-0.37853431701660156,
0.26153987646102905,
0.8858993649482727,
-0.9244208931922913,
0.4287700355052948,
-0.27622172236442566,
-0.21080325543880463,
0.18350526690483093,
0.19178088009357452,
0.5640745759010315,
0.20213913917541504,
-0.4099194407463074,
-0.12865479290485382,
0.1832529753446579,
-0.2655506730079651,
-0.49109017848968506,
0.6835762858390808,
-0.2132461816072464,
-0.07442638278007507,
-0.22904546558856964,
-0.5881476998329163,
-0.32441186904907227,
0.25457659363746643,
0.31035640835762024,
0.5756922960281372,
-0.4034254252910614,
0.11975398659706116,
-0.006848854478448629,
-0.06399461627006531,
0.5988470911979675,
0.42707687616348267,
0.07621071487665176,
-0.4738271236419678,
0.42051443457603455,
0.21143823862075806,
0.0809730589389801,
0.49117720127105713,
0.2651847004890442,
-0.612080454826355,
-0.31763938069343567,
-0.7196053266525269,
-0.23158632218837738,
-0.30324074625968933,
-0.5319221615791321,
-0.6255881786346436,
0.1333870142698288,
-0.4759445786476135,
-0.07576176524162292,
-0.1426158994436264,
-0.607231855392456,
-0.1044224202632904,
0.14186668395996094,
0.7129687070846558,
0.4661485552787781,
-0.10214191675186157,
0.0828709527850151,
-0.6495459675788879,
0.49454864859580994,
0.31668099761009216,
0.33783283829689026,
-0.11487375944852829,
-0.06817275285720825,
0.016005707904696465,
0.03910023719072342,
-0.30369001626968384,
-0.7594248056411743,
0.657785177230835,
0.390876829624176,
0.46910494565963745,
-0.1169566959142685,
0.07791563123464584,
0.7800834774971008,
-0.8751441836357117,
0.4410593807697296,
0.15135332942008972,
-0.9133759140968323,
0.5545948147773743,
-0.4071653187274933,
0.0743127390742302,
0.9404528141021729,
0.3221733868122101,
-0.4067705571651459,
-0.30012351274490356,
-0.3588712513446808,
-1.2523521184921265,
0.6528644561767578,
0.7798625826835632,
-0.06834249943494797,
-0.11242284625768661,
0.3823994994163513,
0.41704750061035156,
0.13803549110889435,
-0.19374620914459229,
-0.19272160530090332,
-0.24367311596870422,
-0.34292516112327576,
0.05023780092597008,
-0.11343134194612503,
-0.07350736111402512,
-0.27099746465682983,
0.4722004532814026,
-0.3566538095474243,
0.27039578557014465,
0.289955198764801,
-0.38043931126594543,
-0.18413208425045013,
0.1732879877090454,
0.9108631014823914,
0.5598275065422058,
-0.7276648879051208,
-0.279633492231369,
0.07155177742242813,
-0.6841359734535217,
-0.2794526219367981,
0.5795725584030151,
-0.2912702262401581,
0.11112219840288162,
0.18828460574150085,
0.3794008493423462,
0.5397771000862122,
-0.8009452819824219,
0.19036850333213806,
-0.21089676022529602,
-0.2718590199947357,
-0.5416731834411621,
0.019717346876859665,
0.23051705956459045,
-0.331199586391449,
0.6822962164878845,
-0.18915553390979767,
0.26737675070762634,
-0.41358983516693115,
0.647859513759613,
0.38153982162475586,
-0.22147971391677856,
-0.08705126494169235,
1.0811471939086914,
-0.004668027628213167,
-0.2696388065814972,
0.598434329032898,
-0.24875643849372864,
-0.5340684056282043,
0.8249343633651733,
0.6409902572631836,
0.6154026985168457,
0.15952655673027039,
0.1308385133743286,
0.6644126772880554,
0.0003608209080994129,
-0.07879970967769623,
0.5747218728065491,
-0.02379167079925537,
-0.2632617652416229,
-0.25002750754356384,
-0.9204266667366028,
-0.976020872592926,
-0.030131537467241287,
-0.9323517680168152,
0.16182808578014374,
-0.34992319345474243,
-0.014433720149099827,
0.501098096370697,
0.0812675878405571,
-0.8072948455810547,
0.01541816908866167,
-0.04516058415174484,
0.8723016977310181,
-0.5021414756774902,
0.6250729560852051,
0.46532773971557617,
-0.2839621901512146,
-0.9361855983734131,
-0.28508952260017395,
0.18352098762989044,
-0.5457825660705566,
0.6900075078010559,
0.5732323527336121,
0.29047873616218567,
-0.08453398197889328,
-0.2788671851158142,
-0.6549795866012573,
1.2339799404144287,
0.20143844187259674,
-0.8426778316497803,
-0.19231320917606354,
0.3062697947025299,
0.4093678295612335,
-0.293233722448349,
0.3582155108451843,
0.9570685625076294,
0.5570326447486877,
0.1318470686674118,
-0.8360827565193176,
0.2838699519634247,
-0.774405837059021,
-0.08032073825597763,
0.3644614517688751,
-0.09517373889684677,
0.7663609385490417,
-0.21559998393058777,
0.0325729176402092,
0.4202146530151367,
0.4217519164085388,
0.3055485188961029,
0.38701120018959045,
0.1840643286705017,
0.5033490061759949,
1.0061393976211548,
-0.4341602325439453,
1.038955807685852,
-0.2533522844314575,
0.16976815462112427,
1.407475233078003,
-0.6876512765884399,
1.0937992334365845,
0.31056100130081177,
-0.3832137882709503,
0.5752293467521667,
0.014684655703604221,
-0.348552405834198,
0.22220809757709503,
0.39579400420188904,
0.16404186189174652,
0.27139994502067566,
0.33788543939590454,
-0.39229702949523926,
0.3848373591899872,
0.4520590305328369,
-0.22403647005558014,
-0.6165722012519836,
-0.5356106758117676,
0.19818702340126038,
0.44658899307250977,
0.17217989265918732,
0.7076812982559204,
-0.1703837662935257,
-0.7237799763679504,
0.46439406275749207,
-0.13113580644130707,
0.3120374381542206,
-0.5400926470756531,
-0.05950669199228287,
-0.3178567886352539,
-0.09704338014125824,
-0.18348446488380432,
-0.5273227095603943,
0.6611960530281067,
0.513995885848999,
-0.12791039049625397,
-0.08794310688972473,
0.11527222394943237,
-0.40788015723228455,
-0.8596363663673401,
-0.1297205537557602,
0.3744254410266876,
-0.10072170197963715,
-0.2105591893196106,
-0.5976131558418274,
-0.1821395605802536,
-0.1614610105752945,
-0.14133663475513458,
-0.10459822416305542,
0.17863252758979797,
-0.1881885826587677,
0.1983075588941574,
1.1615813970565796,
-0.2628806531429291,
-0.01534298062324524,
0.14821304380893707,
0.7175957560539246,
-0.8297750949859619,
-0.4605105221271515,
-0.6519110798835754,
0.48085445165634155,
-0.43095269799232483,
-0.4396113455295563,
0.6429727077484131,
1.0062885284423828,
0.307721346616745,
-0.03800935298204422,
0.6942474246025085,
-0.32562947273254395,
0.6663673520088196,
-0.7298759818077087,
0.9637419581413269,
-0.26630428433418274,
0.12166853994131088,
-0.5314369797706604,
-0.9070695042610168,
-0.5999405384063721,
0.4945570230484009,
-0.3167523741722107,
-0.3670576810836792,
0.6052359938621521,
0.6201631426811218,
0.17785242199897766,
0.27711617946624756,
-0.07184414565563202,
0.15527138113975525,
0.537144124507904,
0.5668460726737976,
0.24386274814605713,
-0.5872127413749695,
0.48732349276542664,
-0.40173014998435974,
-0.001572550623677671,
-0.36957070231437683,
-1.0774884223937988,
-0.6239222288131714,
-0.4457133412361145,
-0.1692502349615097,
-0.36937177181243896,
-0.11208094656467438,
0.9000323414802551,
0.44824573397636414,
-1.095038652420044,
-0.28735628724098206,
-0.5056307315826416,
-0.1417221575975418,
-0.07107249647378922,
-0.2547850012779236,
0.6118080019950867,
-0.5055708289146423,
-0.641890287399292,
0.3843933641910553,
0.19010411202907562,
0.1238585039973259,
0.17905005812644958,
0.09034237265586853,
-0.02109762467443943,
-0.1615944653749466,
0.6247230768203735,
0.5281780958175659,
-0.442702978849411,
0.2367243766784668,
0.26753926277160645,
-0.1865481585264206,
0.1835593730211258,
0.7945689558982849,
-0.6701403856277466,
0.12139570713043213,
0.28666070103645325,
0.4066811800003052,
0.5562675595283508,
0.2207213193178177,
0.7916550636291504,
-0.5818948149681091,
-0.10870519280433655,
0.36047524213790894,
0.2692817449569702,
0.44434860348701477,
-0.29572543501853943,
0.7163693904876709,
-0.04859507083892822,
-0.13415616750717163,
-1.019441843032837,
0.013977760449051857,
-1.505580186843872,
0.10880476236343384,
1.161131739616394,
0.1490492969751358,
-0.40526753664016724,
0.16536100208759308,
-0.17276914417743683,
0.1903952956199646,
-0.4949173629283905,
0.7705833315849304,
0.22876310348510742,
-0.14055828750133514,
0.42201292514801025,
-0.7754336595535278,
0.876944899559021,
0.35847008228302,
-1.2079867124557495,
0.1475803703069687,
0.3802773654460907,
0.3685016334056854,
0.10840244591236115,
0.32627594470977783,
-0.2574043571949005,
0.4286024272441864,
-0.06297041475772858,
-0.3148983120918274,
-0.26257580518722534,
-0.021060628816485405,
0.3515665829181671,
0.35988086462020874,
-0.5058289170265198,
0.42151927947998047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12730v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12730v2 | UMBCLU at SemEval-2024 Task 1A and 1C: Semantic Textual Relatedness with and without machine translation | 2024-02-20T05:46:29 | 2024-04-12T00:53:29 | Shubhashis Roy Dipta, Sai Vallurupalli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The aim of SemEval-2024 Task 1, "Semantic Textual Relatedness for African and
Asian Languages" is to develop models for identifying semantic textual
relatedness (STR) between two sentences using multiple languages (14 African
and Asian languages) and settings (supervised, unsupervised, and
cross-lingual). Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive performance
on several natural language understanding tasks such as multilingual machine
translation (MMT), semantic similarity (STS), and encoding sentence embeddings.
Using a combination of LLMs that perform well on these tasks, we developed two
STR models, $\textit{TranSem}$ and $\textit{FineSem}$, for the supervised and
cross-lingual settings. We explore the effectiveness of several training
methods and the usefulness of machine translation. We find that direct
fine-tuning on the task is comparable to using sentence embeddings and
translating to English leads to better performance for some languages. In the
supervised setting, our model performance is better than the official baseline
for 3 languages with the remaining 4 performing on par. In the cross-lingual
setting, our model performance is better than the baseline for 3 languages
(leading to $1^{st}$ place for Africaans and $2^{nd}$ place for Indonesian), is
on par for 2 languages and performs poorly on the remaining 7 languages. Our
code is publicly available at https://github.com/dipta007/SemEval24-Task8. | [
-0.42913082242012024,
-0.8522576689720154,
0.5511192679405212,
0.33466649055480957,
-0.5154160857200623,
-0.3356677293777466,
-0.3984423577785492,
-0.6713533997535706,
0.21414703130722046,
0.9019912481307983,
-0.6482486128807068,
-0.5504693388938904,
-0.5823283791542053,
0.478181928396225,
-0.2813657522201538,
0.8420639038085938,
-0.3529054522514343,
0.16504305601119995,
-0.3636425733566284,
-0.5531309247016907,
-0.5716399550437927,
-0.6864513754844666,
-0.5598084926605225,
-0.29833677411079407,
0.5511251091957092,
0.3713279068470001,
0.5540042519569397,
0.6543415188789368,
0.7339230179786682,
0.30749017000198364,
0.052576325833797455,
0.2129693180322647,
-0.35090193152427673,
0.0888911709189415,
-0.4043016731739044,
-0.3718748092651367,
-0.24643434584140778,
-0.16601137816905975,
0.42948901653289795,
0.90462327003479,
0.41066834330558777,
0.1287475973367691,
0.35061362385749817,
0.6562578082084656,
-0.40247881412506104,
0.03593851998448372,
-0.49757611751556396,
-0.019795095548033714,
-0.33227771520614624,
-0.42972901463508606,
-0.2993741035461426,
-0.10355071723461151,
0.04529467597603798,
-0.6116158366203308,
0.12109564989805222,
-0.04291767254471779,
1.0368072986602783,
0.45315083861351013,
-0.9925834536552429,
-0.45244300365448,
-0.32271215319633484,
0.7186345458030701,
-0.7047577500343323,
0.34125497937202454,
0.8944975137710571,
0.06613784283399582,
-0.005440756678581238,
-0.6650046706199646,
-0.3071601688861847,
0.0924961045384407,
-0.09839808940887451,
0.24297934770584106,
0.06496893614530563,
-0.010276717133820057,
0.17624014616012573,
0.16278742253780365,
-0.678304135799408,
0.15947027504444122,
-0.26175180077552795,
-0.23924945294857025,
0.5680644512176514,
0.12969869375228882,
0.27068325877189636,
-0.3608952462673187,
-0.49126875400543213,
0.16848503053188324,
-0.8946783542633057,
-0.04790009558200836,
0.3730470538139343,
0.36948317289352417,
-0.14206042885780334,
0.6995666027069092,
-0.16544046998023987,
0.4794234335422516,
-0.3305501639842987,
0.16414128243923187,
0.33615338802337646,
-0.7988833785057068,
-0.06945538520812988,
0.010669036768376827,
0.5754262804985046,
0.21150606870651245,
0.20698805153369904,
-0.031034892424941063,
-0.10698075592517853,
0.23301343619823456,
0.17765240371227264,
-0.7299671769142151,
0.0025951103307306767,
-0.12689469754695892,
-0.6551017761230469,
-0.13337342441082,
-0.16960223019123077,
-0.47153136134147644,
-0.02805115468800068,
-0.7137991786003113,
0.6892831921577454,
-0.6032586693763733,
-0.07868104428052902,
-0.2004355788230896,
0.23465242981910706,
0.32758310437202454,
0.30957329273223877,
-0.886701226234436,
0.26824867725372314,
0.6840582489967346,
0.7054581046104431,
-0.33616963028907776,
-0.5621534585952759,
-0.31087201833724976,
0.06805089116096497,
-0.16364780068397522,
0.7234677672386169,
-0.584104597568512,
-0.2466135174036026,
0.06608578562736511,
0.45055893063545227,
-0.25767412781715393,
-0.35589638352394104,
0.8505781292915344,
-0.3730562925338745,
-0.04836072772741318,
-0.5034332871437073,
-0.6477121710777283,
-0.5407893657684326,
0.23726540803909302,
-0.7401232123374939,
1.114637851715088,
-0.08230574429035187,
-0.8076446652412415,
0.3663918673992157,
-0.6658028364181519,
-0.7325013875961304,
-0.08587787300348282,
0.015964768826961517,
-0.35799944400787354,
0.12320081889629364,
0.16285838186740875,
0.5267290472984314,
-0.09443268924951553,
0.16826516389846802,
-0.3092159032821655,
-0.5149853229522705,
0.11432483047246933,
-0.45740067958831787,
0.9427741765975952,
0.39979398250579834,
-0.3552784323692322,
-0.032577503472566605,
-0.663180947303772,
-0.09597870707511902,
0.16906580328941345,
-0.30885574221611023,
-0.7389270663261414,
-0.3232291638851166,
0.19617272913455963,
0.26052218675613403,
0.3112635612487793,
-0.32801803946495056,
-0.05675915256142616,
-0.43031787872314453,
0.38742542266845703,
0.5189667344093323,
0.10290653258562088,
0.3643137812614441,
-0.08418052643537521,
0.4286544919013977,
0.15834099054336548,
-0.2229350209236145,
-0.4380112886428833,
-0.3999514579772949,
-0.9236168265342712,
-0.04673650488257408,
0.6454821825027466,
0.5245063304901123,
-0.9282546639442444,
0.21362914144992828,
-0.2836644947528839,
-0.26982390880584717,
-0.5432786345481873,
0.19782930612564087,
0.30250951647758484,
0.2412983775138855,
0.3310107886791229,
-0.2834041714668274,
-0.7521930932998657,
-0.9673035144805908,
-0.37059250473976135,
0.11839208751916885,
0.09869220852851868,
0.07850256562232971,
0.8423935174942017,
-0.49951571226119995,
0.39738303422927856,
0.10103995352983475,
-0.2697312831878662,
-0.044210199266672134,
0.2502443790435791,
-0.005383155774325132,
0.4691300094127655,
0.59075927734375,
-0.8679599761962891,
-0.38273030519485474,
0.3398236036300659,
-0.8953202962875366,
-0.3154003918170929,
0.24873685836791992,
-0.23842276632785797,
0.6991720199584961,
0.5476706624031067,
-0.032571472227573395,
0.753021776676178,
0.7019674181938171,
-0.5579879283905029,
0.18394452333450317,
-0.3632662892341614,
0.5170217156410217,
-1.3249003887176514,
0.14677628874778748,
-0.182554230093956,
-0.438570111989975,
-0.6430419683456421,
0.1475682258605957,
0.18463517725467682,
-0.20028334856033325,
-0.5107357501983643,
0.3858502507209778,
-0.38327017426490784,
-0.21698689460754395,
-0.4441453814506531,
0.1482391357421875,
-0.12696976959705353,
0.5982538461685181,
0.15944375097751617,
0.7249477505683899,
0.12113218754529953,
-0.7997857928276062,
-0.007440629415214062,
0.32634633779525757,
-0.21939215064048767,
0.6348503828048706,
-0.6160057783126831,
0.005975658074021339,
0.03977867588400841,
-0.056149981915950775,
-0.8752179741859436,
-0.047041479498147964,
-0.032682016491889954,
-0.4428865313529968,
0.20387710630893707,
-0.01392130646854639,
-0.5137161612510681,
-0.10068397223949432,
-0.09892476350069046,
0.6313245892524719,
0.18829074501991272,
-0.4378322660923004,
0.5258015394210815,
0.427665114402771,
-0.49435216188430786,
-0.44989100098609924,
-1.0440818071365356,
0.2045065313577652,
-0.29449334740638733,
-0.7863338589668274,
0.21868053078651428,
0.18655338883399963,
0.03031764179468155,
0.13070036470890045,
0.06058480963110924,
-0.08871351927518845,
0.31459227204322815,
0.2363988757133484,
0.29842016100883484,
-0.14692868292331696,
0.1737973541021347,
0.3141477704048157,
-0.2977865934371948,
0.05334960296750069,
-0.34391748905181885,
0.358961284160614,
-0.011808204464614391,
-0.4303729236125946,
-0.0029785579536110163,
0.4167572259902954,
0.1784452646970749,
-0.31644099950790405,
0.8157089352607727,
0.7637413144111633,
-0.5765949487686157,
0.17060182988643646,
-0.46798887848854065,
-0.0024982690811157227,
-0.3837655782699585,
0.3701510429382324,
-0.7992296814918518,
-1.167823314666748,
0.582883894443512,
-0.18117429316043854,
0.06472596526145935,
0.5379548668861389,
0.7438865303993225,
-0.06769668310880661,
1.0002284049987793,
0.8011820316314697,
0.15523916482925415,
0.2990862727165222,
-0.12527380883693695,
0.046942874789237976,
-0.7254191040992737,
-0.20549191534519196,
-0.7781587839126587,
-0.20458044111728668,
-1.0989774465560913,
-0.5144299864768982,
0.16410383582115173,
-0.17918206751346588,
-0.21267105638980865,
0.8228321075439453,
0.004810224752873182,
0.27660438418388367,
0.540776789188385,
-0.0845935046672821,
0.4562542736530304,
0.12121351063251495,
-0.5404518246650696,
-0.3231796324253082,
-0.6348472237586975,
-0.7896139025688171,
1.0462315082550049,
0.2977277934551239,
0.5876287817955017,
0.10093161463737488,
0.6901466250419617,
0.18625998497009277,
-0.08621358871459961,
-0.46400687098503113,
0.40990373492240906,
-0.3530981242656708,
-0.5127768516540527,
-0.31799212098121643,
-0.5344626903533936,
-1.1527444124221802,
0.4806801676750183,
-0.10540814697742462,
-0.4952734112739563,
0.07292301952838898,
-0.2582192122936249,
0.3386741578578949,
-0.023355787619948387,
-0.44502556324005127,
1.0895326137542725,
-0.2865734398365021,
-0.40142199397087097,
-0.21250320971012115,
-0.8544051647186279,
0.11115019768476486,
-0.24154333770275116,
0.2570643723011017,
-0.1844491958618164,
-0.29218316078186035,
0.7907151579856873,
-0.49300068616867065,
0.6189300417900085,
0.08748923987150192,
-0.2670922577381134,
0.15829159319400787,
0.028520511463284492,
0.3802010416984558,
-0.06888557225465775,
-0.22104763984680176,
0.3896215558052063,
0.3114919364452362,
-0.6770816445350647,
-0.35711967945098877,
0.7711963057518005,
-0.7827780246734619,
-0.2564513385295868,
-0.3808319866657257,
-0.4978835880756378,
-0.11951746791601181,
0.3960224986076355,
0.4591551125049591,
0.40635377168655396,
-0.3933764696121216,
0.2868356704711914,
0.6069092154502869,
-0.2051927149295807,
0.31664344668388367,
0.49712660908699036,
-0.2020951807498932,
-0.3162626326084137,
0.8188204169273376,
0.15927372872829437,
0.19052471220493317,
0.5946717858314514,
-0.18564295768737793,
-0.43274834752082825,
-0.36633598804473877,
-0.44388025999069214,
0.2370401918888092,
-0.7277193069458008,
-0.20728564262390137,
-0.8201963305473328,
-0.18586140871047974,
-0.4303414523601532,
-0.15772390365600586,
-0.13593445718288422,
-0.5943170785903931,
-0.28460490703582764,
-0.11147560924291611,
0.09145693480968475,
0.4960166811943054,
0.033842116594314575,
-0.0004178851086180657,
-0.7715122103691101,
0.1548098474740982,
0.009560330770909786,
-0.004803020972758532,
-0.3697632849216461,
-0.9867610931396484,
-0.41154420375823975,
0.20872831344604492,
-0.277677446603775,
-0.5735201239585876,
0.30495569109916687,
0.16886311769485474,
0.4334782361984253,
0.32716119289398193,
0.06517656147480011,
0.8015859127044678,
-0.6260880827903748,
0.5664274096488953,
-0.09865237027406693,
-0.9863141775131226,
0.7248629927635193,
-0.30606552958488464,
0.4615578353404999,
0.9232577681541443,
0.5029886960983276,
-0.5576218962669373,
-0.566044807434082,
-0.37154024839401245,
-0.7183890342712402,
0.6361690163612366,
0.5978735089302063,
0.16738425195217133,
-0.02337663806974888,
-0.016816066578030586,
0.2974463999271393,
0.1016499325633049,
-0.6743929386138916,
-0.2595990002155304,
-0.21514207124710083,
-0.29281365871429443,
-0.15568555891513824,
-0.26490503549575806,
0.2370644509792328,
-0.054141461849212646,
0.9739475250244141,
-0.25303444266319275,
0.26959261298179626,
0.14563874900341034,
-0.4270363748073578,
-0.1212722584605217,
0.40154287219047546,
0.43398305773735046,
0.7118547558784485,
0.10620091110467911,
0.23903165757656097,
0.6173334717750549,
-0.34544143080711365,
0.1421188861131668,
0.3340235948562622,
-0.27610012888908386,
0.11317901313304901,
0.5198475122451782,
0.8805404901504517,
0.5331701636314392,
-0.5504458546638489,
0.4595497250556946,
-0.0612671934068203,
-0.3355342745780945,
-0.37890851497650146,
-0.3474745452404022,
0.16835848987102509,
0.04295174777507782,
0.11014197021722794,
-0.025220779702067375,
0.3871212899684906,
-0.6549800038337708,
0.09506244957447052,
0.18635988235473633,
-0.6620425581932068,
-0.3651728928089142,
0.6621888875961304,
0.36516425013542175,
0.10298854857683182,
0.3587512671947479,
-0.08964226394891739,
-0.7598637938499451,
0.6209404468536377,
0.7072186470031738,
0.5356134176254272,
-0.20851898193359375,
0.06680376082658768,
0.47433099150657654,
0.5135902166366577,
0.17865028977394104,
0.28444012999534607,
0.007040961179882288,
-0.6119523048400879,
-0.5580248236656189,
-0.6447802782058716,
-0.2030889391899109,
-0.16145239770412445,
-0.691696047782898,
0.6282522678375244,
0.17196474969387054,
-0.020839573815464973,
-0.03210584819316864,
0.335068941116333,
-0.9389180541038513,
0.1101718619465828,
0.11776676774024963,
0.9060230255126953,
-0.8438390493392944,
0.8901651501655579,
1.1170026063919067,
-0.45523035526275635,
-0.7757582068443298,
-0.38534072041511536,
0.14064963161945343,
-0.555368959903717,
0.4608532190322876,
0.33068764209747314,
0.14560997486114502,
-0.15994754433631897,
-0.18710117042064667,
-0.6287667155265808,
1.2328810691833496,
0.4193199872970581,
-0.49224376678466797,
0.13301031291484833,
0.46442678570747375,
0.5262170433998108,
-0.31986239552497864,
0.1899978667497635,
0.6599341034889221,
0.5081517696380615,
0.06382313370704651,
-0.9206593036651611,
0.04249032959342003,
-0.36528024077415466,
0.17888173460960388,
0.46990966796875,
-0.6307140588760376,
0.44075271487236023,
0.044356755912303925,
-0.3303656280040741,
0.36001458764076233,
0.7488698363304138,
0.11144141852855682,
0.6424811482429504,
0.29229214787483215,
0.7350205779075623,
0.707632303237915,
-0.24019889533519745,
0.8536786437034607,
-0.25100794434547424,
0.27724117040634155,
1.0831207036972046,
-0.3917072117328644,
0.689056396484375,
0.4933706521987915,
-0.13051101565361023,
0.33632692694664,
0.8029934167861938,
0.23418904840946198,
0.40583565831184387,
-0.14093135297298431,
-0.055718518793582916,
-0.1959877908229828,
-0.40845900774002075,
-0.5024370551109314,
0.5530370473861694,
0.2377915382385254,
-0.46465766429901123,
-0.06022322177886963,
0.3028827905654907,
0.07877928763628006,
0.28640344738960266,
-0.3462349772453308,
0.9124338030815125,
0.33496981859207153,
-0.6805691719055176,
0.3483891189098358,
0.13104620575904846,
0.597210705280304,
-0.7079595327377319,
-0.015997497364878654,
-0.23107723891735077,
0.08914821594953537,
-0.1453598439693451,
-0.578639566898346,
0.5573985576629639,
0.10449028015136719,
-0.015857888385653496,
-0.05755724757909775,
1.0212371349334717,
-0.7423685193061829,
-0.6504930257797241,
0.417238712310791,
0.6072239279747009,
0.3245525062084198,
0.11898402869701385,
-0.5798649191856384,
0.07828503102064133,
0.08013612776994705,
-0.02459532581269741,
0.39302822947502136,
0.9119661450386047,
-0.2759813368320465,
0.42908331751823425,
0.5223656892776489,
0.02385830692946911,
-0.07224471122026443,
0.24149318039417267,
0.543276846408844,
-0.7844476103782654,
-0.5368719696998596,
-0.7264066338539124,
0.06218064948916435,
0.04839009419083595,
-0.26971665024757385,
1.040856122970581,
0.6428913474082947,
1.168336033821106,
-0.07286695390939713,
0.7341795563697815,
0.0014638941502198577,
0.505672812461853,
-0.6815649271011353,
0.5569090247154236,
-0.6932256817817688,
0.16805925965309143,
-0.44109678268432617,
-1.2429943084716797,
-0.1086830422282219,
0.6071866750717163,
-0.2952553927898407,
-0.052812278270721436,
1.0981062650680542,
0.6715909838676453,
-0.13996481895446777,
0.3085799217224121,
0.5700737237930298,
-0.13105730712413788,
-0.0914040356874466,
0.6533073782920837,
0.832821786403656,
-0.7551443576812744,
0.702122151851654,
-0.22143425047397614,
0.05246114730834961,
-0.19014908373355865,
-0.7613716125488281,
-1.1103087663650513,
-0.7580119967460632,
-0.2392004132270813,
-0.18855977058410645,
0.10707640647888184,
1.0326184034347534,
0.4794222116470337,
-0.9552154541015625,
-0.10582172125577927,
0.009144838899374008,
-0.10737693309783936,
-0.18359969556331635,
-0.17044462263584137,
0.3419194519519806,
-0.30429068207740784,
-0.7553393840789795,
0.09735911339521408,
0.34057727456092834,
0.08046265691518784,
0.0025066970847547054,
-0.31936606764793396,
-0.5558696985244751,
0.12116510421037674,
0.7754607796669006,
0.0005074305809102952,
-0.6408130526542664,
-0.33218464255332947,
-0.06808304041624069,
-0.3044503331184387,
-0.31878870725631714,
0.7798547148704529,
-0.5094850063323975,
0.42954251170158386,
0.5763022899627686,
1.0796973705291748,
0.6851018667221069,
0.027758197858929634,
0.45837289094924927,
-0.4413597285747528,
0.2625221312046051,
0.05997420847415924,
0.5860434174537659,
0.4205284118652344,
-0.17021766304969788,
1.18987238407135,
0.12031182646751404,
-0.7915263772010803,
-0.48600465059280396,
0.08976554125547409,
-0.7751550078392029,
-0.14242881536483765,
0.9883195757865906,
-0.3750759959220886,
-0.3159686326980591,
-0.32682231068611145,
-0.2697566747665405,
0.4195607006549835,
0.0094631751999259,
0.37234508991241455,
0.8514125347137451,
0.247802272439003,
0.06773756444454193,
-0.7198169827461243,
0.12138507515192032,
0.7580006122589111,
-0.9805015325546265,
-0.3027745187282562,
0.3642684817314148,
0.11529131233692169,
-0.06886277347803116,
0.4724580943584442,
-0.24793139100074768,
0.4233149290084839,
-0.12709452211856842,
-0.16962367296218872,
-0.014830023050308228,
-0.16419987380504608,
-0.4335235357284546,
-0.25681132078170776,
-0.09209361672401428,
-0.06122070178389549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12728v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12728v2 | Modality-Aware Integration with Large Language Models for Knowledge-based Visual Question Answering | 2024-02-20T05:32:24 | 2024-03-03T04:51:28 | Junnan Dong, Qinggang Zhang, Huachi Zhou, Daochen Zha, Pai Zheng, Xiao Huang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Knowledge-based visual question answering (KVQA) has been extensively studied
to answer visual questions with external knowledge, e.g., knowledge graphs
(KGs). While several attempts have been proposed to leverage large language
models (LLMs) as an implicit knowledge source, it remains challenging since
LLMs may generate hallucinations. Moreover, multiple knowledge sources, e.g.,
images, KGs and LLMs, cannot be readily aligned for complex scenarios. To
tackle these, we present a novel modality-aware integration with LLMs for KVQA
(MAIL). It carefully leverages multimodal knowledge for both image
understanding and knowledge reasoning. Specifically, (i) we propose a two-stage
prompting strategy with LLMs to densely embody the image into a scene graph
with detailed visual features; (ii) We construct a coupled concept graph by
linking the mentioned entities with external facts. (iii) A tailored
pseudo-siamese graph medium fusion is designed for sufficient multimodal
fusion. We utilize the shared mentioned entities in two graphs as mediums to
bridge a tight inter-modal exchange, while maximally preserving insightful
intra-modal learning by constraining the fusion within mediums. Extensive
experiments on two benchmark datasets show the superiority of MAIL with 24x
less resources. | [
-0.5709981918334961,
-0.9423968195915222,
0.8157446384429932,
0.018215203657746315,
-0.5374693274497986,
-0.14244863390922546,
-0.21096809208393097,
-0.41783109307289124,
0.0905296802520752,
0.43432697653770447,
-0.6888555288314819,
-0.39714667201042175,
-0.27035626769065857,
-0.06300857663154602,
0.05831824243068695,
0.35703057050704956,
-0.25465890765190125,
0.31581851840019226,
-0.564537525177002,
-0.24836385250091553,
-0.7375785708427429,
-0.1153203621506691,
-0.11567410826683044,
0.14418207108974457,
0.6602422595024109,
0.42677396535873413,
0.47559836506843567,
0.14664626121520996,
0.4593944847583771,
0.31819769740104675,
0.316496878862381,
0.4888623058795929,
-0.3900288939476013,
0.31370821595191956,
-0.18118369579315186,
-0.47275203466415405,
-0.21767862141132355,
-0.18770819902420044,
0.6780076622962952,
0.5761853456497192,
0.21185053884983063,
0.020208971574902534,
-0.21180863678455353,
0.4049333333969116,
-0.6488083600997925,
0.3230114281177521,
-0.5546286702156067,
0.0020176838152110577,
0.13399778306484222,
-0.3083253502845764,
-0.44730129837989807,
-0.2734932601451874,
0.1393941342830658,
-0.7982974648475647,
-0.3816632926464081,
0.10503454506397247,
0.5712265968322754,
0.3173365890979767,
-0.8113189339637756,
-0.07550334930419922,
-0.4212143123149872,
0.4388171136379242,
-0.24315761029720306,
0.7436367869377136,
0.3088056147098541,
0.6545889377593994,
0.0215783528983593,
-0.6873723864555359,
-0.9528123140335083,
-0.0762629583477974,
-0.15607163310050964,
0.31508544087409973,
-0.1501380205154419,
0.2519361674785614,
0.14569911360740662,
0.1625678390264511,
-0.7705486416816711,
-0.18981967866420746,
-0.2634294331073761,
-0.35465821623802185,
0.18118897080421448,
0.15076632797718048,
0.34025824069976807,
-0.3623386323451996,
-0.4577987492084503,
-0.0516197606921196,
-0.4341684877872467,
0.25364941358566284,
-0.039301980286836624,
0.04591498151421547,
-0.06461362540721893,
0.8023446202278137,
-0.2005596160888672,
0.8162233829498291,
-0.050274550914764404,
-0.17762333154678345,
0.060438863933086395,
-0.4979698956012726,
-0.33444252610206604,
-0.3220153748989105,
0.8134048581123352,
0.449723482131958,
0.02935604937374592,
-0.17751680314540863,
-0.10369332134723663,
0.16432267427444458,
0.03078836388885975,
-0.7510647773742676,
-0.17368753254413605,
0.004802670329809189,
-0.41226768493652344,
-0.07439521700143814,
-0.2558760941028595,
-0.6118636727333069,
-0.399296373128891,
-0.33750119805336,
0.8945794105529785,
-0.4646512269973755,
-0.28377097845077515,
-0.030170809477567673,
-0.08086977899074554,
0.3471725583076477,
0.708085298538208,
-0.4329754114151001,
-0.13648664951324463,
0.3041944205760956,
0.5122420787811279,
0.18726199865341187,
-0.17611819505691528,
-0.7561413049697876,
0.31694233417510986,
-0.2608664929866791,
0.8358184099197388,
-0.7695426940917969,
-0.19112856686115265,
0.03424965217709541,
0.13669651746749878,
-0.1912267655134201,
-0.2887437343597412,
0.07317651063203812,
-1.0499566793441772,
0.500002920627594,
-0.5775479674339294,
-0.3469092845916748,
-0.5715303421020508,
0.6320337057113647,
-0.5427605509757996,
0.8365607261657715,
0.30923765897750854,
-0.7379862666130066,
0.35492008924484253,
-0.6093475818634033,
-0.18280930817127228,
0.09220689535140991,
-0.3221231997013092,
0.024778122082352638,
-0.044975705444812775,
0.2925032079219818,
0.5845513939857483,
-0.4801528751850128,
0.26891762018203735,
-0.47488072514533997,
-0.154960036277771,
0.3351534605026245,
-0.39003241062164307,
0.33347490429878235,
0.18295492231845856,
-0.10511983186006546,
0.22578191757202148,
-0.49923115968704224,
0.022591296583414078,
0.0012977173319086432,
-0.130696102976799,
-0.32564643025398254,
-0.5849263072013855,
-0.05277983099222183,
0.49127787351608276,
0.19006133079528809,
-0.4255810081958771,
0.5135127305984497,
0.1682865172624588,
0.35717472434043884,
0.7173501253128052,
0.09744627773761749,
0.5333042144775391,
-0.1632867008447647,
0.6427322030067444,
0.4606170654296875,
0.2888794541358948,
-0.32673656940460205,
-0.41156622767448425,
-0.7174712419509888,
-0.6186386346817017,
0.1030825823545456,
0.4510669410228729,
-1.5642222166061401,
-0.15006248652935028,
-0.445639431476593,
-0.23929965496063232,
-0.40052536129951477,
0.17194288969039917,
0.2599523961544037,
0.6694015860557556,
0.30802586674690247,
-0.2849636971950531,
-0.175760880112648,
-1.080520749092102,
0.20765210688114166,
-0.27879077196121216,
0.2530958354473114,
0.7530297636985779,
0.4199945330619812,
-0.2149323970079422,
0.8210222125053406,
-0.4730686545372009,
-0.1546517014503479,
-0.14583347737789154,
0.134662464261055,
-0.11587295681238174,
0.271618515253067,
0.43157315254211426,
-0.9281113147735596,
-0.3462258279323578,
-0.1052858978509903,
-0.7921107411384583,
0.12002266198396683,
-0.1356848031282425,
-0.43019869923591614,
0.06206807494163513,
0.5682874321937561,
-0.7390909790992737,
0.13206583261489868,
0.4962318241596222,
-0.4561592638492584,
0.3719346821308136,
-0.05650496110320091,
0.5005645751953125,
-1.2674275636672974,
0.05695722624659538,
0.10914889723062515,
-0.30665940046310425,
-0.4821557402610779,
-0.2032235711812973,
0.24036094546318054,
-0.1669214814901352,
-0.5446061491966248,
0.5739755630493164,
-0.4909946918487549,
-0.03721902146935463,
0.02104143425822258,
0.08124639093875885,
0.15477719902992249,
0.7372944355010986,
0.15959800779819489,
0.7293617725372314,
0.6658401489257812,
-0.16212938725948334,
0.5744052529335022,
0.2892676889896393,
-0.3402552306652069,
0.8738529682159424,
-0.42926380038261414,
0.06689111143350601,
-0.5020493268966675,
0.3800259530544281,
-1.2822743654251099,
-0.3309991955757141,
0.48143765330314636,
-0.2136790007352829,
0.33369123935699463,
-0.23064912855625153,
-0.7099012136459351,
-0.30122146010398865,
-0.02689330466091633,
0.7757786512374878,
0.3965807855129242,
-0.4769795835018158,
1.0109449625015259,
0.02848689816892147,
-0.001450663316063583,
-0.44430842995643616,
-0.5902778506278992,
0.19948430359363556,
-0.15265819430351257,
-0.9852379560470581,
-0.06854022294282913,
-0.25669121742248535,
0.0472295805811882,
0.16949625313282013,
0.06640680134296417,
-0.20377923548221588,
-0.31880202889442444,
0.09698201715946198,
0.4249283969402313,
-0.38370975852012634,
0.3190181851387024,
0.13008832931518555,
0.09426567703485489,
-0.007571601774543524,
-0.3902580440044403,
0.32610517740249634,
-0.13106346130371094,
-0.6963469386100769,
-0.470983624458313,
0.5418874025344849,
1.1027028560638428,
-0.326743483543396,
0.6825563907623291,
0.8291927576065063,
-0.1649142950773239,
0.07782522588968277,
-0.8547284007072449,
-0.3884672224521637,
-0.4280158281326294,
0.2590719759464264,
-0.5639714598655701,
-1.002958059310913,
0.4094357490539551,
-0.17882952094078064,
-0.32747623324394226,
-0.09104668349027634,
0.39394062757492065,
-0.1943841278553009,
1.0792676210403442,
0.6563143134117126,
0.20636357367038727,
0.4861394464969635,
-0.3594309091567993,
0.21196313202381134,
-0.8939248919487,
-0.5191683769226074,
0.1233755573630333,
-0.3584434986114502,
-0.1305830180644989,
-0.8774093985557556,
0.6872413754463196,
0.10634871572256088,
-0.12694372236728668,
-0.03502641245722771,
-0.24534206092357635,
0.3294331431388855,
0.4711899161338806,
0.31700363755226135,
0.37170228362083435,
-0.06236020103096962,
-0.2842279374599457,
-0.038520559668540955,
-0.9836320877075195,
-0.00397608894854784,
0.7851139307022095,
0.14180941879749298,
0.9096487164497375,
0.2266879677772522,
0.15945206582546234,
-0.15002013742923737,
0.22607146203517914,
-0.7664211392402649,
0.7336517572402954,
0.2140442430973053,
-0.3363228440284729,
-0.09511202573776245,
-0.28853321075439453,
-0.5209740996360779,
0.3683299422264099,
-0.5148608088493347,
-0.6577965617179871,
0.40488868951797485,
0.13392885029315948,
-0.06567574292421341,
0.15486100316047668,
-0.6923741698265076,
0.9570590853691101,
-0.10655849426984787,
-0.4460217356681824,
-0.08535781502723694,
-0.7421729564666748,
0.6913043856620789,
0.10779299587011337,
0.24485540390014648,
0.052446939051151276,
-0.14295940101146698,
0.32179513573646545,
-0.20746789872646332,
0.970461368560791,
-0.13811977207660675,
-0.133525088429451,
0.14698180556297302,
0.2738490402698517,
0.5531407594680786,
0.10652730613946915,
0.4478927254676819,
-0.13901716470718384,
-0.02913750149309635,
-0.2711520493030548,
-0.9523138999938965,
0.6615510582923889,
-0.5758928656578064,
-0.6193708777427673,
-0.08653091639280319,
-0.9995526075363159,
-0.5711072087287903,
0.11896301805973053,
0.012567618861794472,
0.7566343545913696,
0.327353298664093,
0.35492584109306335,
0.893484890460968,
-0.010199649259448051,
0.24794605374336243,
0.47120046615600586,
-0.19563616812229156,
-0.6784568428993225,
1.0166491270065308,
-0.016194161027669907,
0.4215930998325348,
0.4620225429534912,
0.09983832389116287,
-0.5283759832382202,
-0.1743883341550827,
-0.7182278037071228,
0.4317283630371094,
-1.0263168811798096,
-0.2556746006011963,
-0.8927404284477234,
0.026328975334763527,
-0.30313703417778015,
-0.34653520584106445,
-0.039903949946165085,
-0.22078974545001984,
-0.25897103548049927,
0.3031402826309204,
0.42798951268196106,
0.31421294808387756,
0.1163448691368103,
-0.003764766501262784,
-0.937532901763916,
0.4821034073829651,
0.8788813948631287,
0.38970303535461426,
0.03167145699262619,
-0.3531908392906189,
-0.017881520092487335,
0.08010859042406082,
0.047781337052583694,
-1.1015712022781372,
-0.05931931734085083,
0.03939041867852211,
0.5986372828483582,
0.42053139209747314,
0.036580879241228104,
0.794833779335022,
-0.15299490094184875,
0.837705671787262,
0.5035441517829895,
-0.7422147393226624,
0.4185025990009308,
-0.5240875482559204,
0.486240953207016,
0.3980184495449066,
0.41154277324676514,
-0.7721394300460815,
-0.3422068953514099,
-0.26933497190475464,
-0.501507043838501,
0.4377360939979553,
-0.16743071377277374,
0.049524109810590744,
0.056446757167577744,
0.020827004685997963,
-0.0037675572093576193,
0.2993980050086975,
-0.7697815895080566,
0.04403318464756012,
-0.3600770831108093,
-0.29592663049697876,
0.14523309469223022,
-0.174240842461586,
-0.43580102920532227,
-0.45007678866386414,
0.38100144267082214,
-0.5010074973106384,
0.16304779052734375,
0.21918879449367523,
-0.5327697992324829,
-0.04234687238931656,
0.14334145188331604,
0.6198579668998718,
0.597039520740509,
0.3089776635169983,
0.3503846824169159,
0.16674844920635223,
-0.26990756392478943,
0.0785181075334549,
-0.011755925603210926,
0.007677642162889242,
-0.20960162580013275,
0.2856518030166626,
0.8307909965515137,
0.24132215976715088,
-0.8426641225814819,
0.7453368306159973,
-0.18043935298919678,
-0.30326521396636963,
0.12690463662147522,
-0.18449215590953827,
0.2458014190196991,
0.6951102018356323,
0.20015394687652588,
-0.07095746695995331,
-0.001968247350305319,
-0.6056711673736572,
0.028357237577438354,
0.7662701606750488,
-0.5955910086631775,
-0.20029199123382568,
0.5798884630203247,
0.1321905255317688,
0.2545079290866852,
0.4190983772277832,
-0.033150531351566315,
-0.6577662229537964,
0.3320677876472473,
0.3930091857910156,
0.5298005938529968,
0.19192564487457275,
0.3785354793071747,
0.16944357752799988,
0.2757048010826111,
0.2576741576194763,
0.6079068183898926,
-0.39717456698417664,
-0.6242290735244751,
-0.6179346442222595,
-0.31824928522109985,
-0.12430311739444733,
-0.01138181984424591,
-0.23547296226024628,
0.23300299048423767,
-0.16934795677661896,
0.11664815247058868,
-0.20720961689949036,
-0.32094699144363403,
-0.7966693043708801,
0.12427683919668198,
0.25257623195648193,
0.8769627809524536,
-1.027940273284912,
0.7190198302268982,
0.9058345556259155,
-0.5907352566719055,
-0.9280644059181213,
-0.16922815144062042,
-0.03391731157898903,
-0.8758189082145691,
0.8549985289573669,
-0.045061949640512466,
-0.025139080360531807,
0.04117310047149658,
-0.46149635314941406,
-0.7097986340522766,
1.2483794689178467,
0.31987011432647705,
-0.1795278936624527,
0.13902683556079865,
0.06049950420856476,
0.23684662580490112,
-0.39148181676864624,
0.3148173391819,
0.06976749002933502,
0.7409816384315491,
0.7257903814315796,
-0.7520639896392822,
0.32824718952178955,
-0.3706161379814148,
0.09350591897964478,
0.2991526126861572,
-0.6492406129837036,
0.5769798159599304,
-0.1271398365497589,
-0.12337152659893036,
-0.17717522382736206,
0.630405068397522,
-0.02175597846508026,
0.18420295417308807,
0.7881975173950195,
0.5826015472412109,
0.5377355813980103,
0.08395024389028549,
0.6497179269790649,
-0.2837425768375397,
-0.12521378695964813,
0.6808002591133118,
0.08206439018249512,
0.452388197183609,
0.6460901498794556,
0.3162757456302643,
0.447365939617157,
0.544801652431488,
0.18665403127670288,
0.548255443572998,
-0.17719228565692902,
-0.4859375059604645,
-0.7146119475364685,
-0.4533778131008148,
-0.5005646347999573,
0.5268158316612244,
0.18893150985240936,
-0.12836088240146637,
-0.30684155225753784,
0.3644600510597229,
-0.2564747929573059,
-0.22473591566085815,
-0.20525331795215607,
0.9578452706336975,
-0.15966609120368958,
-0.7410019040107727,
0.5773842334747314,
-0.5540092587471008,
0.42220303416252136,
-0.5987463593482971,
-0.2252333015203476,
-0.033953748643398285,
-0.3930809199810028,
0.001449942123144865,
-0.8101001977920532,
-0.15346971154212952,
-0.37775513529777527,
-0.23121334612369537,
-0.15928678214550018,
0.6899273991584778,
-0.9614217281341553,
-0.35038843750953674,
-0.12118309736251831,
0.8278999328613281,
-0.1965513527393341,
0.04633454233407974,
-0.4228920042514801,
0.16233958303928375,
-0.2841152548789978,
-0.24792823195457458,
0.3095422387123108,
0.62211012840271,
-0.12214735895395279,
0.726570725440979,
0.7411670088768005,
-0.29776516556739807,
-0.13475728034973145,
0.09420015662908554,
1.2634097337722778,
-0.39616650342941284,
-0.4850285053253174,
-0.447266548871994,
0.7972689270973206,
-0.0004279939748812467,
-0.10481947660446167,
0.6183558702468872,
0.2904343008995056,
0.3697609603404999,
-0.05862323194742203,
0.624193549156189,
0.05546519532799721,
-0.1949620544910431,
-0.696451723575592,
0.5605618953704834,
-1.0108823776245117,
0.010415204800665379,
-0.28597158193588257,
-0.9945698976516724,
-0.15450070798397064,
0.18082663416862488,
-0.2797076404094696,
-0.08998380601406097,
0.8085992932319641,
1.026826024055481,
-0.23140834271907806,
-0.03745663911104202,
0.5666989684104919,
0.1317252367734909,
0.2632341980934143,
0.735190212726593,
1.0342000722885132,
-0.14220616221427917,
0.6773170232772827,
-0.2977140545845032,
-0.14228813350200653,
-0.34414142370224,
-0.8314256072044373,
-0.8206747770309448,
-1.037093997001648,
-0.20398403704166412,
-0.2625543773174286,
-0.22291602194309235,
0.7475939393043518,
0.7557877898216248,
-0.13906273245811462,
0.3292829096317291,
0.24640077352523804,
0.1090635359287262,
0.11283750087022781,
-0.20174255967140198,
0.26593565940856934,
-0.11454937607049942,
-0.5190121531486511,
0.24730047583580017,
0.5401674509048462,
0.1663092076778412,
-0.4992999732494354,
0.11792062968015671,
-0.16582854092121124,
0.0744350478053093,
0.7751857042312622,
0.09036359190940857,
-0.7185772657394409,
-0.509833574295044,
0.40335115790367126,
-0.22016167640686035,
-0.016323937103152275,
0.9519109129905701,
-0.8186103105545044,
0.8263077735900879,
0.7344619631767273,
0.627977192401886,
0.4056999981403351,
-0.16821721196174622,
0.4108578860759735,
-0.4853004813194275,
0.281023770570755,
0.28543567657470703,
0.44145891070365906,
0.2826726734638214,
-0.3062871992588043,
0.11215464025735855,
0.4321914315223694,
-0.18781201541423798,
-0.6922928094863892,
0.4683694541454315,
-1.272767424583435,
-0.39489370584487915,
1.1650307178497314,
0.17762894928455353,
-0.282749742269516,
-0.08250198513269424,
-0.43478918075561523,
-0.006416840944439173,
-0.12028120458126068,
0.435822069644928,
0.679622232913971,
0.026875527575612068,
-0.6826016306877136,
-0.4485064446926117,
0.19611281156539917,
0.3673204481601715,
-0.7826037406921387,
-0.28585904836654663,
0.9992021322250366,
0.07001206278800964,
-0.12866809964179993,
0.698698103427887,
0.09812206029891968,
0.6767004132270813,
-0.041277311742305756,
-0.06093788892030716,
-0.3967849910259247,
-0.45505452156066895,
-0.10066650807857513,
0.15301810204982758,
-0.08959747850894928,
-0.09801822900772095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00788v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00788v1 | PRECISE Framework: GPT-based Text For Improved Readability, Reliability, and Understandability of Radiology Reports For Patient-Centered Care | 2024-02-20T04:26:31 | 2024-02-20T04:26:31 | Satvik Tripathi, Liam Mutter, Meghana Muppuri, Suhani Dheer, Emiliano Garza-Frias, Komal Awan, Aakash Jha, Michael Dezube, Azadeh Tabari, Christopher P. Bridge, Dania Daye | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | This study introduces and evaluates the PRECISE framework, utilizing OpenAI's
GPT-4 to enhance patient engagement by providing clearer and more accessible
chest X-ray reports at a sixth-grade reading level. The framework was tested on
500 reports, demonstrating significant improvements in readability,
reliability, and understandability. Statistical analyses confirmed the
effectiveness of the PRECISE approach, highlighting its potential to foster
patient-centric care delivery in healthcare decision-making. | [
0.011743983253836632,
-0.43711426854133606,
0.8181731104850769,
-0.04385392740368843,
-0.252810001373291,
-0.342685341835022,
0.2942666709423065,
-0.520679771900177,
-0.00031227071303874254,
0.279705673456192,
-0.47823435068130493,
-0.6395560503005981,
-0.5020167231559753,
0.07762894779443741,
-0.32679086923599243,
0.9992696046829224,
-0.26450660824775696,
0.04704566299915314,
0.15074370801448822,
-0.08280716091394424,
-0.40154093503952026,
-0.23957200348377228,
-0.3076847791671753,
-0.5322207808494568,
0.5018527507781982,
0.501846969127655,
1.2106597423553467,
0.908871054649353,
1.0740187168121338,
0.13651320338249207,
0.23194141685962677,
-0.39568403363227844,
-0.31320539116859436,
-0.16884392499923706,
-0.2420661747455597,
-0.3533013164997101,
-0.8047899007797241,
-0.06885013729333878,
0.6202743649482727,
0.6237292885780334,
-0.214583620429039,
-0.07654215395450592,
-0.3663797378540039,
0.9495076537132263,
-0.4453226923942566,
0.16257624328136444,
0.12780050933361053,
0.3760402500629425,
-0.23811088502407074,
-0.5144345164299011,
-0.28332412242889404,
-0.33370864391326904,
0.6181456446647644,
-0.9275798797607422,
0.3087681531906128,
-0.2858368158340454,
0.9656862616539001,
-0.0776483565568924,
-0.5076290965080261,
-0.4631386399269104,
-0.702275812625885,
0.5564597845077515,
-0.47178661823272705,
0.4385038912296295,
0.5248717069625854,
0.5510602593421936,
0.21157455444335938,
-1.3602290153503418,
-0.07149145007133484,
0.10690507292747498,
-0.31829917430877686,
0.3258580267429352,
-0.10131914168596268,
0.4356996417045593,
0.2861190140247345,
0.7900972962379456,
-0.9715834259986877,
-0.26649418473243713,
-0.23488165438175201,
0.05334039032459259,
0.5131874680519104,
0.004755562171339989,
0.4499543607234955,
-0.25735142827033997,
-0.4068094491958618,
0.059229008853435516,
-0.6316900849342346,
-0.2252916395664215,
-0.2633651793003082,
0.017556793987751007,
-0.1242024153470993,
0.3753643035888672,
-0.5027627944946289,
0.6481420397758484,
0.30382946133613586,
-0.4897303283214569,
0.7126513719558716,
-0.30225837230682373,
-0.6271325945854187,
0.3576730191707611,
0.22444841265678406,
0.41157960891723633,
-0.03130203112959862,
-0.2218448519706726,
-0.16848890483379364,
0.08692685514688492,
0.3779833912849426,
-0.9254962205886841,
-0.32516422867774963,
0.41583094000816345,
-0.8312370777130127,
-0.6537113189697266,
0.32543373107910156,
-0.3231312036514282,
-0.031137917190790176,
-0.44275492429733276,
0.3995901048183441,
-0.48106080293655396,
-0.3357066512107849,
0.3317660987377167,
0.0579596571624279,
0.3888467252254486,
0.4226708710193634,
-0.8020073175430298,
0.1662576049566269,
0.5044832825660706,
1.010208249092102,
0.178522527217865,
0.2597103714942932,
-0.584884524345398,
0.5788159966468811,
-0.3010852634906769,
0.8451149463653564,
-0.40306076407432556,
-0.48317375779151917,
0.009746944531798363,
-0.09622274339199066,
-0.1721048653125763,
-0.20466604828834534,
0.7629700303077698,
-0.3811804950237274,
0.32456129789352417,
-0.41747042536735535,
-0.57191002368927,
-0.3894726037979126,
0.5677953958511353,
-0.6245400905609131,
0.5472243428230286,
0.5694013237953186,
-0.6461448669433594,
0.5313165783882141,
-0.8447234630584717,
-0.4830232858657837,
0.3976404070854187,
-0.5767824053764343,
-0.33998405933380127,
0.09824545681476593,
0.21554560959339142,
0.485999196767807,
-0.05840830132365227,
0.36010846495628357,
0.3009539246559143,
-0.37472787499427795,
0.048907991498708725,
-0.47290006279945374,
0.4763300120830536,
0.38536232709884644,
-0.7359998226165771,
0.3488532602787018,
-0.7699636816978455,
0.5228335857391357,
-0.0006454288959503174,
-0.04452824592590332,
0.06346309930086136,
-0.27682244777679443,
-0.024255970492959023,
0.027262898162007332,
-0.13075479865074158,
-0.45329180359840393,
0.20476685464382172,
-0.2478027641773224,
0.4331129193305969,
0.5049930214881897,
0.08596865087747574,
0.3551473021507263,
-0.793152391910553,
0.7209431529045105,
-0.2123899608850479,
0.5242018103599548,
-0.44244420528411865,
-0.6183822751045227,
-0.060841210186481476,
-0.425650030374527,
0.021238690242171288,
0.5188173651695251,
-0.4746910631656647,
0.17989680171012878,
-0.10532055050134659,
-0.5740848183631897,
-0.3440055549144745,
-0.28657087683677673,
0.7478770613670349,
0.9445788264274597,
0.0456521175801754,
-0.7045696377754211,
-0.3839573562145233,
-0.7558766603469849,
0.14934052526950836,
-0.3070107400417328,
0.06654752045869827,
0.19469048082828522,
0.240298330783844,
-0.4307907223701477,
0.7132257223129272,
-0.7905901670455933,
-0.5046098232269287,
-0.06131039559841156,
0.1290629804134369,
0.3711262047290802,
0.37491098046302795,
0.597865641117096,
-1.1992558240890503,
-0.849578320980072,
0.3199213147163391,
-1.0221806764602661,
0.0466642826795578,
0.05696811154484749,
-0.19489702582359314,
0.021942025050520897,
0.4866207242012024,
-0.20557163655757904,
0.8730858564376831,
0.4316302537918091,
-0.415643572807312,
0.41293132305145264,
-0.29512569308280945,
0.5060740113258362,
-0.7845163345336914,
0.5655309557914734,
-0.0028553903102874756,
-0.6143140196800232,
-0.8530194163322449,
0.06718533486127853,
0.2943393588066101,
-0.07812527567148209,
-0.2739928364753723,
0.11705426126718521,
-0.48712947964668274,
0.1603548228740692,
0.069049172103405,
-0.001876363530755043,
0.26700833439826965,
-0.06528028100728989,
0.20680518448352814,
0.671163022518158,
0.15229934453964233,
-0.2745170295238495,
-0.06641063839197159,
0.45089349150657654,
-0.35119664669036865,
1.0818954706192017,
-0.9122650027275085,
0.24337609112262726,
-0.06942467391490936,
0.2131066620349884,
-0.7902880907058716,
-0.4764409065246582,
0.21634694933891296,
-0.49366575479507446,
0.6635637879371643,
0.029909035190939903,
-0.14381901919841766,
-0.19369123876094818,
-0.2991909384727478,
0.3626621961593628,
0.26947328448295593,
-0.15082389116287231,
0.5163269639015198,
0.18106143176555634,
-0.16958433389663696,
-0.44041907787323,
-1.000519871711731,
-0.13090744614601135,
0.16661427915096283,
-0.8207624554634094,
0.5520093441009521,
-0.4264649450778961,
-0.17708344757556915,
-0.013591260649263859,
-0.2234179824590683,
-0.5277645587921143,
-0.15089718997478485,
0.3802514970302582,
-0.0225041676312685,
-0.5978156924247742,
-0.02226438745856285,
-0.2961791455745697,
-0.41166943311691284,
-0.18155987560749054,
-0.26556888222694397,
0.3883882164955139,
-0.7355821132659912,
-0.46968695521354675,
-0.9236878156661987,
0.5250561237335205,
0.4582250714302063,
0.023928934708237648,
0.3324483036994934,
0.549809455871582,
-0.47406205534935,
0.6416993737220764,
-0.4441438913345337,
-0.0958305075764656,
-0.44518810510635376,
0.23497632145881653,
-0.6441137194633484,
-0.7557725310325623,
0.446399062871933,
0.09291116148233414,
-0.020308997482061386,
0.48265209794044495,
0.4952048659324646,
0.010066752322018147,
1.0814427137374878,
0.8330636620521545,
0.22882682085037231,
0.23912103474140167,
-0.10293901711702347,
0.25883954763412476,
-0.7442666292190552,
-0.5163317322731018,
-0.6421186923980713,
-0.009352288208901882,
-0.1746501922607422,
0.13892775774002075,
0.40330731868743896,
-0.019548626616597176,
-0.39501503109931946,
-0.27800217270851135,
-0.9834486842155457,
0.4663618505001068,
0.3334495723247528,
0.4825080931186676,
0.6814988851547241,
-0.03587258979678154,
0.006198438815772533,
-0.3898674249649048,
-0.6611686944961548,
-0.48860540986061096,
1.0215682983398438,
0.4296482801437378,
0.39579424262046814,
0.5185931324958801,
0.580594003200531,
0.25754374265670776,
0.5531465411186218,
-0.7425448894500732,
-0.10093223303556442,
-0.15912000834941864,
-1.044189214706421,
-0.2607935965061188,
-0.23096336424350739,
-1.0046377182006836,
0.03238441422581673,
0.2947852313518524,
-0.5292011499404907,
0.1719125658273697,
0.06089504808187485,
-0.4675685465335846,
0.18121425807476044,
-0.7865713238716125,
0.8672860860824585,
-0.3601227104663849,
0.04922403022646904,
0.19863364100456238,
-0.9850200414657593,
0.12686917185783386,
-0.22414764761924744,
0.2756170332431793,
0.012311172671616077,
-0.20810259878635406,
0.43274444341659546,
-0.5285634994506836,
0.8381758332252502,
-0.09868738800287247,
0.03163775056600571,
0.12019442021846771,
0.02843955159187317,
0.0825624093413353,
0.34072309732437134,
-0.060208484530448914,
-0.045194968581199646,
0.215816929936409,
-0.5085016489028931,
-0.5650082230567932,
0.4741891920566559,
-1.0330681800842285,
-0.2552846074104309,
-0.8459876775741577,
-0.6727677583694458,
0.07020318508148193,
0.7920719981193542,
0.49385306239128113,
0.9048147201538086,
-0.39443764090538025,
0.12189874053001404,
1.0356053113937378,
0.20004433393478394,
-0.10924950242042542,
0.6553593277931213,
-0.1525464653968811,
-0.689956545829773,
0.5086982846260071,
0.2549362778663635,
0.29449722170829773,
0.7379533052444458,
0.32935768365859985,
-0.07067862153053284,
-0.6969370245933533,
-0.5189550518989563,
0.19149811565876007,
-0.7359074354171753,
-0.17532160878181458,
-0.41706788539886475,
-0.23436759412288666,
-0.5092082023620605,
-0.7684066891670227,
-0.1790747493505478,
-0.13000032305717468,
-0.19017598032951355,
-0.09681234508752823,
0.1944231241941452,
0.9351457357406616,
-0.09269247949123383,
0.6215053200721741,
-0.811289370059967,
0.07321283221244812,
-0.15370887517929077,
0.5386391282081604,
-0.33563268184661865,
-0.5829230546951294,
-0.21999530494213104,
-0.25710180401802063,
-0.21514657139778137,
-0.8515661358833313,
0.33211174607276917,
0.12488105893135071,
0.5598306059837341,
0.6393634080886841,
0.07224558293819427,
0.6398556232452393,
-0.10962522029876709,
0.6732375025749207,
0.6049802303314209,
-1.1272999048233032,
0.7443372011184692,
-0.7745357751846313,
0.7199239730834961,
0.806838870048523,
0.35047051310539246,
-0.4306330978870392,
0.335027813911438,
-0.9319223761558533,
-0.8432169556617737,
0.5222265124320984,
0.23733381927013397,
-0.3353820741176605,
0.14542028307914734,
0.7366437911987305,
0.05194762721657753,
0.1189904436469078,
-0.4205957353115082,
-0.07213987410068512,
-0.39137300848960876,
-0.45579811930656433,
-0.14163143932819366,
-0.48959678411483765,
-0.4759024381637573,
-0.1889428049325943,
0.6969125270843506,
-0.4372495412826538,
0.4861602783203125,
0.8392670750617981,
-0.04958000034093857,
-0.27926069498062134,
0.14762306213378906,
0.7379854321479797,
1.248389720916748,
-0.546021580696106,
0.13683979213237762,
-0.369931161403656,
-0.9817755818367004,
0.06430123001337051,
-0.0075653186067938805,
-0.2386050671339035,
0.07729368656873703,
0.47185322642326355,
0.3939017057418823,
0.22432948648929596,
-0.3167930841445923,
0.7682322859764099,
-0.47777992486953735,
-0.48536014556884766,
-0.4509054124355316,
-0.24021650850772858,
-0.16519387066364288,
0.16042067110538483,
0.2126467227935791,
0.09316357225179672,
0.3805587887763977,
-0.3686172068119049,
0.7523614168167114,
-0.2795814871788025,
-1.1104854345321655,
-0.24914231896400452,
0.44071656465530396,
0.18449097871780396,
0.1361590176820755,
0.7608145475387573,
0.27104198932647705,
-0.22236858308315277,
0.6044431328773499,
0.7347708344459534,
0.7522047162055969,
-0.3450013995170593,
0.6233177185058594,
0.1520581990480423,
0.3456898331642151,
-0.3027483820915222,
0.44078752398490906,
0.17558170855045319,
-0.45804786682128906,
-0.5727450847625732,
0.20372243225574493,
-0.47176557779312134,
-0.11496808379888535,
-1.2360566854476929,
0.11202522367238998,
-0.8585708141326904,
-0.08902566879987717,
0.05363365262746811,
0.3816473186016083,
-0.46550241112709045,
0.7800328731536865,
-0.20458124577999115,
0.954353928565979,
-0.5212593078613281,
0.7787760496139526,
0.9592480063438416,
-0.7252461314201355,
-1.2614561319351196,
-0.07081837952136993,
0.37570664286613464,
-0.827769935131073,
0.23367129266262054,
0.4265318214893341,
0.07309883087873459,
-0.012255505658686161,
-0.3136599361896515,
-0.9329342246055603,
1.4902878999710083,
0.3194833993911743,
-0.6119303107261658,
0.12964341044425964,
-0.06749396026134491,
0.40146440267562866,
-0.3677603006362915,
0.4984916150569916,
0.5707533359527588,
0.5510023832321167,
0.401180624961853,
-1.1601732969284058,
0.14071054756641388,
-0.3260766267776489,
-0.1804416924715042,
0.22939758002758026,
-0.5505416393280029,
0.5844364762306213,
-0.2632881999015808,
0.026401430368423462,
0.1269414722919464,
0.5719953179359436,
0.010565172880887985,
0.7634627223014832,
0.1536194235086441,
0.6870269179344177,
1.2592787742614746,
-0.17391471564769745,
1.5062940120697021,
0.052881013602018356,
0.2265915721654892,
0.9059388041496277,
-0.15586969256401062,
0.43359997868537903,
0.11165313422679901,
0.09587080031633377,
0.4143359959125519,
0.4823532700538635,
0.23175901174545288,
0.7049771547317505,
-0.3882611393928528,
-0.4030536115169525,
0.12146634608507156,
-0.02737865038216114,
-0.8348769545555115,
0.09946472197771072,
0.3503442704677582,
-0.52106773853302,
0.06324772536754608,
-0.08870809525251389,
0.611985981464386,
-0.004436684772372246,
-0.47495657205581665,
0.6773874759674072,
0.1196412593126297,
-0.30473408102989197,
0.5660737752914429,
-0.07478289306163788,
0.35176801681518555,
-0.8547831177711487,
0.15029287338256836,
0.015190890990197659,
0.573775589466095,
-0.8743000626564026,
-0.9981862306594849,
0.6607935428619385,
-0.09201207756996155,
-0.7013246417045593,
-0.2727314829826355,
0.7923409342765808,
-0.031564224511384964,
-0.13895376026630402,
-0.047908831387758255,
0.20018799602985382,
0.19543437659740448,
-0.14993739128112793,
-0.7105581164360046,
0.3884013593196869,
0.4898335635662079,
-0.3340856432914734,
0.33627384901046753,
0.46780309081077576,
-0.023486295714974403,
0.3468685448169708,
0.47154420614242554,
-0.17408566176891327,
-0.4663100838661194,
0.16878877580165863,
0.7426831126213074,
-0.4469331204891205,
-0.47725120186805725,
-0.37892329692840576,
0.47835996747016907,
-0.10818322747945786,
-0.5899349451065063,
0.4363369047641754,
0.5438039302825928,
0.6452846527099609,
0.18467187881469727,
1.1228301525115967,
-0.17176474630832672,
0.40834859013557434,
-0.4776517450809479,
0.6593143343925476,
-0.2719973921775818,
0.04458635672926903,
-0.449214905500412,
-0.535726010799408,
-1.146443247795105,
1.0419851541519165,
-0.4215131402015686,
0.14799192547798157,
0.8895625472068787,
0.532808244228363,
0.09665761888027191,
0.3451303243637085,
0.45630118250846863,
0.21056495606899261,
0.8068923950195312,
0.41159507632255554,
0.13841062784194946,
-0.567338228225708,
0.40614402294158936,
-0.3682320713996887,
-0.8637746572494507,
-0.16220445930957794,
-0.8973934650421143,
-0.5837488174438477,
-0.29063892364501953,
-0.5933377742767334,
-0.5432109832763672,
0.42464134097099304,
0.4488082230091095,
0.9492140412330627,
-0.6025049686431885,
0.11751861125230789,
-0.09238135069608688,
-0.40690678358078003,
-0.19405558705329895,
-0.22625026106834412,
0.8025996088981628,
-0.14345359802246094,
-0.18253856897354126,
0.022739924490451813,
0.5189686417579651,
-0.1326507031917572,
0.04299918934702873,
-0.2908276915550232,
0.07240867614746094,
-0.2012258917093277,
0.5682119727134705,
0.45961493253707886,
-0.1363586038351059,
-0.3010750710964203,
0.04716265946626663,
-0.4517904222011566,
0.3460860550403595,
0.7393525242805481,
-0.5477254390716553,
0.7774010896682739,
0.4563535451889038,
0.424411803483963,
0.5758123993873596,
0.004477433394640684,
0.7247283458709717,
-0.27094969153404236,
0.17066845297813416,
0.4425739347934723,
0.05586806312203407,
0.321283221244812,
-0.7524436116218567,
0.7813875079154968,
0.38080132007598877,
-0.9369261264801025,
-0.5328207612037659,
0.18332725763320923,
-1.311810851097107,
-0.08045966178178787,
0.9056150317192078,
-0.49204137921333313,
-0.27209094166755676,
-0.4311555325984955,
-0.35680675506591797,
-0.014956721104681492,
-0.41544920206069946,
0.30485260486602783,
0.2032078057527542,
-0.4003489315509796,
-0.18419133126735687,
-0.7282097935676575,
0.4297143518924713,
0.28626808524131775,
-0.6247774958610535,
-0.6515536904335022,
0.3737206757068634,
0.4678080677986145,
0.11789001524448395,
1.1803839206695557,
-0.8651560544967651,
0.5268669724464417,
-0.10678138583898544,
-0.01998748444020748,
-0.08540242165327072,
-0.19456610083580017,
-0.2852110266685486,
0.39792242646217346,
0.28274720907211304,
0.042027685791254044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12713v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12713v2 | Are LLMs Rational Investors? A Study on Detecting and Reducing the Financial Bias in LLMs | 2024-02-20T04:26:08 | 2024-07-01T15:42:15 | Yuhang Zhou, Yuchen Ni, Yunhui Gan, Zhangyue Yin, Xiang Liu, Jian Zhang, Sen Liu, Xipeng Qiu, Guangnan Ye, Hongfeng Chai | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly adopted in financial analysis
for interpreting complex market data and trends. However, their use is
challenged by intrinsic biases (e.g., risk-preference bias) and a superficial
understanding of market intricacies, necessitating a thorough assessment of
their financial insight. To address these issues, we introduce Financial Bias
Indicators (FBI), a framework with components like Bias Unveiler, Bias
Detective, Bias Tracker, and Bias Antidote to identify, detect, analyze, and
eliminate irrational biases in LLMs. By combining behavioral finance principles
with bias examination, we evaluate 23 leading LLMs and propose a de-biasing
method based on financial causal knowledge. Results show varying degrees of
financial irrationality among models, influenced by their design and training.
Models trained specifically on financial datasets may exhibit more
irrationality, and even larger financial language models (FinLLMs) can show
more bias than smaller, general models. We utilize four prompt-based methods
incorporating causal debiasing, effectively reducing financial biases in these
models. This work enhances the understanding of LLMs' bias in financial
applications, laying the foundation for developing more reliable and rational
financial analysis tools. | [
-0.39876651763916016,
-0.8842877149581909,
0.40113314986228943,
0.1998782604932785,
0.07051834464073181,
0.2617763578891754,
-0.036082491278648376,
-0.14456214010715485,
0.14258137345314026,
0.606073796749115,
-0.7071179151535034,
-0.37358906865119934,
-0.524416983127594,
0.04218410700559616,
-0.22580842673778534,
0.8388083577156067,
-0.010105804540216923,
0.6898314952850342,
0.05841657891869545,
0.1300688534975052,
-0.3733384311199188,
-0.35615110397338867,
-0.9663585424423218,
-0.3490420877933502,
0.39023780822753906,
0.012017181143164635,
0.541749894618988,
0.599911093711853,
0.5251117944717407,
0.33247390389442444,
-0.00924064964056015,
-0.08330678194761276,
-0.6265823841094971,
-0.16095973551273346,
-0.1879490166902542,
-0.4874636232852936,
-0.48052144050598145,
0.40343666076660156,
0.3343004882335663,
0.669304609298706,
0.11235785484313965,
0.25960928201675415,
-0.13553260266780853,
0.9922075271606445,
-0.637190043926239,
0.4046099781990051,
-0.5644629001617432,
0.19660966098308563,
-0.4334290325641632,
-0.6120471954345703,
-0.5988816618919373,
-0.43749839067459106,
0.34196269512176514,
-0.4391579031944275,
-0.10689027607440948,
0.4067517817020416,
0.5702604055404663,
0.3052111566066742,
-0.7809280753135681,
-0.31813114881515503,
-0.5292758345603943,
1.0519641637802124,
-0.7185298204421997,
0.33234646916389465,
0.5022145509719849,
0.36289072036743164,
-0.27458539605140686,
0.1580389142036438,
-0.3154798448085785,
-0.1356631964445114,
0.16998915374279022,
-0.1445322334766388,
-0.3203429877758026,
0.031130362302064896,
0.30868661403656006,
0.10882291942834854,
-0.12509901821613312,
0.19505783915519714,
-0.22165881097316742,
-0.39477962255477905,
0.596755862236023,
0.2021339237689972,
0.09341828525066376,
0.185773566365242,
-0.547018826007843,
0.010084775276482105,
-0.9662105441093445,
-0.005032349843531847,
0.7767297625541687,
-0.004239863250404596,
0.06443987041711807,
0.6051582098007202,
0.04617549479007721,
0.2539486885070801,
0.46530845761299133,
-0.6146325469017029,
0.08918581157922745,
0.12823368608951569,
-0.4410168528556824,
0.1216849684715271,
0.08784931153059006,
0.5778083205223083,
0.7491275668144226,
-0.04070381820201874,
-0.583000123500824,
0.03488900884985924,
-0.08810365945100784,
-0.6679247617721558,
0.06105540692806244,
0.23464345932006836,
-0.7749707102775574,
-0.47360286116600037,
-0.12606312334537506,
-0.7112947106361389,
-0.6918867826461792,
-0.5489087104797363,
0.0480102077126503,
-0.15017929673194885,
-0.2071567177772522,
0.09681280702352524,
-0.3026861250400543,
0.5709340572357178,
0.23647230863571167,
-0.8327900171279907,
0.21097895503044128,
0.8140852451324463,
0.3160111606121063,
0.13172145187854767,
0.027256326749920845,
-0.6304033994674683,
0.420847624540329,
-0.36090371012687683,
0.8711745738983154,
-0.5285702347755432,
-0.2809242010116577,
0.07765498012304306,
-0.3084050118923187,
-0.02706528827548027,
-0.6441956162452698,
0.11819495260715485,
-0.6008256077766418,
0.09312747418880463,
-0.6029607057571411,
-0.782464861869812,
-0.4761776030063629,
0.25118350982666016,
-0.4183761477470398,
0.5394865870475769,
0.12937521934509277,
-0.9790083765983582,
0.7279815673828125,
-0.8107050061225891,
-0.06281869113445282,
-0.1914559006690979,
-0.23772530257701874,
-0.180572509765625,
-0.06565828621387482,
0.32641974091529846,
0.3074500858783722,
-0.611724853515625,
0.5829765796661377,
-0.7416164875030518,
-0.32645171880722046,
0.9511082172393799,
-0.8363680243492126,
0.615141749382019,
-0.034799568355083466,
-0.5500383973121643,
0.30041465163230896,
-0.6454058289527893,
-0.5851092338562012,
0.06653661280870438,
0.06815196573734283,
-0.5867481827735901,
0.30302080512046814,
0.11520222574472427,
0.029393022879958153,
0.21510626375675201,
-0.2750959098339081,
0.30420857667922974,
-0.3308735191822052,
0.31334996223449707,
1.5122731924057007,
0.07829942554235458,
0.5256317257881165,
-0.4417230188846588,
0.5620669722557068,
0.22088052332401276,
0.3632471561431885,
0.13214460015296936,
-0.07229042053222656,
-0.8731076717376709,
-0.7700487971305847,
-0.09417155385017395,
0.6588409543037415,
-0.10331419110298157,
0.34425845742225647,
0.11943940073251724,
-0.039996035397052765,
-0.23774784803390503,
0.37172722816467285,
0.18611596524715424,
0.5631184577941895,
0.024435268715023994,
0.2588976323604584,
-0.48732736706733704,
-1.2393841743469238,
-0.5550143718719482,
-0.12297683954238892,
-0.011106030084192753,
0.10943860560655594,
0.5097585916519165,
-0.5398021340370178,
0.8898845911026001,
-0.5290683507919312,
-0.14954593777656555,
0.025493882596492767,
-0.03698477894067764,
0.3547256290912628,
0.26858294010162354,
0.8502371311187744,
-0.633872926235199,
-0.17576582729816437,
-0.03670502454042435,
-0.5849704742431641,
-0.11584486067295074,
-0.4499947726726532,
-0.11078322678804398,
0.34862571954727173,
0.42594805359840393,
-0.36985090374946594,
0.5146395564079285,
-0.04435625299811363,
-0.6029435992240906,
0.27614903450012207,
0.23656105995178223,
-0.14002177119255066,
-0.4178851842880249,
0.07265926897525787,
0.5188479423522949,
-0.13435757160186768,
-0.3893527388572693,
-0.4917078912258148,
-0.1630135476589203,
0.5072270035743713,
-0.006949341855943203,
0.808549702167511,
-0.25594860315322876,
-0.2545073330402374,
-0.2516143321990967,
0.28901228308677673,
-0.09152480959892273,
0.47644364833831787,
-0.2833901047706604,
0.7702921628952026,
0.630579948425293,
-0.1935521364212036,
0.2268252670764923,
-0.09070126712322235,
-0.49120184779167175,
0.5207773447036743,
-0.29843851923942566,
-0.0991259440779686,
-0.08896853774785995,
0.16338148713111877,
-1.0009548664093018,
-0.10803915560245514,
0.6596355438232422,
-0.08052452653646469,
0.22020690143108368,
0.12131848931312561,
-0.23269005119800568,
-0.27124732732772827,
-0.4988497495651245,
0.2357574701309204,
0.20729298889636993,
-0.47073808312416077,
0.5652406215667725,
0.28918033838272095,
-0.43937212228775024,
-0.995340883731842,
-0.4369286596775055,
-0.2968073785305023,
-0.5897260904312134,
-0.7224233746528625,
-0.2245122343301773,
0.016928717494010925,
-0.9737973809242249,
-0.15374712646007538,
-0.355229914188385,
0.01308218203485012,
0.3305193781852722,
0.014102522283792496,
0.863631546497345,
-0.19587798416614532,
0.075789675116539,
0.07136993110179901,
-0.4076939821243286,
0.42538443207740784,
-0.32387518882751465,
0.3894423544406891,
-0.172522634267807,
-0.36496421694755554,
-0.36978697776794434,
0.11174682527780533,
0.6381716132164001,
-0.12020090967416763,
0.6162511706352234,
0.2623940408229828,
-0.32190266251564026,
-0.1507645547389984,
-1.0455471277236938,
-0.18421247601509094,
-0.5367450714111328,
0.1262950897216797,
-0.10499550402164459,
-0.953097939491272,
0.8977096080780029,
-0.13443373143672943,
-0.04532688483595848,
0.5088158249855042,
0.8576431274414062,
0.17842091619968414,
0.9909305572509766,
0.659375011920929,
-0.442617803812027,
0.3580070734024048,
-0.15625116229057312,
0.4398568868637085,
-0.5427766442298889,
-0.35445505380630493,
-0.2217835783958435,
-0.3461320698261261,
-0.2325035184621811,
-0.23058892786502838,
0.04237235710024834,
0.15301182866096497,
-0.5695191025733948,
-0.3727011978626251,
-0.18487276136875153,
0.5710393190383911,
0.1622467339038849,
-0.12410611659288406,
0.16500608623027802,
-0.15478633344173431,
-0.11703213304281235,
-0.20185789465904236,
-0.18667222559452057,
-0.6995521783828735,
1.3209835290908813,
0.9282147288322449,
0.86899733543396,
-0.060663510113954544,
0.2578638195991516,
0.642628014087677,
0.7745673060417175,
-0.7892770171165466,
0.30620113015174866,
0.3844611644744873,
-0.6278740763664246,
-0.2256333976984024,
-0.6610433459281921,
-0.22527547180652618,
0.10191051661968231,
-0.1694469302892685,
-0.4953089654445648,
0.604831874370575,
0.027153151109814644,
-0.3265235424041748,
0.24051588773727417,
-0.46788290143013,
0.6271552443504333,
-0.39025089144706726,
-0.31407520174980164,
-0.2336917221546173,
-0.011468406766653061,
0.7911987900733948,
-0.5184538960456848,
0.5116491913795471,
-0.42234212160110474,
-0.20222945511341095,
0.4665256440639496,
-0.4512186050415039,
0.9370678663253784,
-0.36163586378097534,
-0.5704077482223511,
0.15779492259025574,
-0.08168483525514603,
0.6270225644111633,
0.4645654261112213,
-0.1619836539030075,
-0.1461717039346695,
-0.29669830203056335,
-0.572350800037384,
-0.4455850124359131,
0.658877968788147,
-0.7192617654800415,
-0.6772586107254028,
-0.4890364706516266,
-0.67237389087677,
-0.2327423095703125,
-0.04785360023379326,
-0.3051556348800659,
0.10212834924459457,
-0.1849692165851593,
-0.13487617671489716,
0.48044607043266296,
-0.1262834519147873,
0.24892911314964294,
0.5148965716362,
-0.45252931118011475,
-0.5444396734237671,
0.6941981315612793,
-0.0020507248118519783,
0.09457112848758698,
0.09890098124742508,
0.3004150986671448,
-0.5332058668136597,
-0.5461806654930115,
0.01078739482909441,
0.23027369379997253,
-0.7126413583755493,
-0.10770903527736664,
-0.2544606924057007,
0.2080986201763153,
-0.6287596821784973,
-0.5101727247238159,
-0.15168331563472748,
-0.11340396851301193,
-0.2574901878833771,
-0.45999929308891296,
0.6498379111289978,
0.5982010364532471,
-0.07986766844987869,
0.34497296810150146,
-0.48409029841423035,
0.25825849175453186,
0.4334230422973633,
0.27133506536483765,
0.28352928161621094,
-0.4809277653694153,
-0.22946782410144806,
-0.04096832126379013,
-0.011176107451319695,
-0.7087244987487793,
0.6026203632354736,
-0.20896026492118835,
0.6270838379859924,
1.3666744232177734,
0.08393202722072601,
0.5306076407432556,
0.10481210052967072,
0.12811216711997986,
0.2007858008146286,
-1.2722253799438477,
0.2890625298023224,
-0.6437669992446899,
-0.26694464683532715,
0.4246555268764496,
0.3916786313056946,
-0.30586734414100647,
-0.3733564615249634,
-0.14571534097194672,
-0.6729307770729065,
0.5457075834274292,
-0.10373356938362122,
-0.25537511706352234,
-0.18137089908123016,
0.524493932723999,
0.08762188255786896,
0.5179928541183472,
-0.9058271050453186,
-0.3161143958568573,
-0.11116853356361389,
-0.03448256477713585,
0.24194587767124176,
-0.468902051448822,
-0.3028053641319275,
-0.20523829758167267,
0.7637048959732056,
-0.22393053770065308,
-0.27004972100257874,
0.08706296235322952,
0.08810970187187195,
-0.2938830852508545,
0.17380666732788086,
0.4726763963699341,
0.8609894514083862,
-0.5587278604507446,
-0.12566745281219482,
0.14391012489795685,
-0.22285790741443634,
0.2003379613161087,
-0.16894371807575226,
-0.32721227407455444,
-0.2797488272190094,
0.22926880419254303,
0.40951865911483765,
0.29912176728248596,
-1.1231271028518677,
0.6767464280128479,
0.024505672976374626,
-0.07177092134952545,
-0.68918776512146,
-0.22941234707832336,
-0.01998642459511757,
0.5922234654426575,
0.6511542797088623,
0.3043457269668579,
0.24081794917583466,
-0.6659889221191406,
0.04506543651223183,
0.6559758186340332,
-0.37755411863327026,
-0.14008726179599762,
0.34607917070388794,
0.5490651726722717,
0.16436432301998138,
0.5689303874969482,
0.09682917594909668,
-0.5454584360122681,
0.7696999907493591,
0.32952776551246643,
1.1711721420288086,
0.007033627480268478,
0.05340190976858139,
-0.12268820405006409,
0.5396039485931396,
-0.1477755457162857,
0.22666238248348236,
0.118968665599823,
-0.9484714865684509,
-0.5775201320648193,
-0.46511605381965637,
-0.3349299132823944,
0.10432480275630951,
-0.794284462928772,
0.3759271502494812,
-0.856999933719635,
-0.34396764636039734,
0.19956143200397491,
-0.005951607134193182,
-0.3894849717617035,
-0.004984118510037661,
0.2719898223876953,
0.9614264965057373,
-0.6990548968315125,
0.8195467591285706,
0.2833488881587982,
-0.1910734325647354,
-0.31767818331718445,
-0.17372381687164307,
0.45715969800949097,
-0.8087694048881531,
1.0097788572311401,
0.38844195008277893,
-0.07908585667610168,
-0.489732027053833,
-0.6138753294944763,
-0.5670307874679565,
0.9124712944030762,
0.4289024770259857,
-0.8477683067321777,
0.04032460227608681,
0.09725318104028702,
0.11111888289451599,
-0.6679859161376953,
0.2869420349597931,
0.7493407726287842,
1.0589162111282349,
-0.053948793560266495,
-0.30130335688591003,
-0.26507818698883057,
-0.33140629529953003,
-0.22580397129058838,
0.3473939895629883,
-0.7251458168029785,
0.8295641541481018,
-0.17713290452957153,
0.010456308722496033,
-0.15440315008163452,
0.5066434741020203,
0.4327235817909241,
0.7027642130851746,
0.5919687151908875,
0.09992310404777527,
0.9482166767120361,
-0.09109170734882355,
0.7059029936790466,
-0.5051392912864685,
0.386247456073761,
0.6973034143447876,
-0.7394818663597107,
0.5312913656234741,
0.7198616862297058,
-0.07268781960010529,
0.10088568180799484,
0.6538323760032654,
-0.3811684548854828,
0.269228994846344,
0.6914905905723572,
-0.30859217047691345,
-0.6973522305488586,
-0.09954784065485,
-0.20929862558841705,
0.2680727243423462,
0.43360424041748047,
-0.40831518173217773,
0.22170226275920868,
-0.029367221519351006,
0.3155590295791626,
0.0890979915857315,
-0.3936094343662262,
0.37372297048568726,
0.28878769278526306,
-0.16101579368114471,
0.029848726466298103,
0.1192854717373848,
0.9473508596420288,
-0.7447180151939392,
0.33837661147117615,
-0.5374184846878052,
0.48762962222099304,
0.028933046385645866,
-0.3038986623287201,
0.3422025740146637,
0.21641360223293304,
-0.3851148784160614,
-0.3301345705986023,
0.7481924295425415,
-0.025634797289967537,
-0.5978478789329529,
0.6402246356010437,
0.343006432056427,
-0.18030567467212677,
-0.1596716195344925,
-0.4764414429664612,
-0.17877382040023804,
0.2802267074584961,
-0.4469784200191498,
0.3210082948207855,
0.5711135864257812,
-0.02219974808394909,
1.1334965229034424,
1.034798502922058,
-0.17927749454975128,
-0.14922641217708588,
0.1245044469833374,
0.7553868293762207,
-1.0760141611099243,
-0.08210331201553345,
-1.0814228057861328,
0.09590530395507812,
-0.03320620208978653,
-0.34606608748435974,
0.8692960739135742,
0.7351362705230713,
0.672234058380127,
-0.20026899874210358,
0.6265590190887451,
0.7832046151161194,
0.3555334210395813,
-0.5789945721626282,
0.8506181836128235,
-0.3044033348560333,
0.6996737122535706,
-0.31988680362701416,
-0.9536092877388,
-0.11907372623682022,
0.6697787642478943,
-0.5124925374984741,
-0.11182396858930588,
0.1734296828508377,
0.7139363884925842,
0.2361629605293274,
0.3062174916267395,
0.1759827435016632,
0.3842155337333679,
0.24497580528259277,
0.021878821775317192,
1.1491069793701172,
-0.09181783348321915,
0.19816197454929352,
-0.11345738172531128,
-0.3413968086242676,
-0.4335448443889618,
-0.8568856716156006,
-1.2573200464248657,
0.2455417513847351,
-0.5637320876121521,
-0.05538748949766159,
-0.1466236263513565,
1.0882649421691895,
0.11491629481315613,
-0.8485730290412903,
-0.4116012454032898,
0.2507438659667969,
0.36714789271354675,
-0.05566316097974777,
-0.260379821062088,
0.2188224196434021,
-0.21634477376937866,
-0.4825645089149475,
0.34452706575393677,
0.8215769529342651,
0.17747439444065094,
-0.6535789966583252,
-0.03837639093399048,
0.010005068965256214,
0.7333903312683105,
0.5825138688087463,
-0.026599090546369553,
-0.7045585513114929,
-0.2704555094242096,
0.2773877680301666,
-0.06512746214866638,
-0.29557153582572937,
0.806377112865448,
-0.33460310101509094,
-0.00916394591331482,
0.40866562724113464,
0.394554078578949,
-0.03123334050178528,
-0.1731874793767929,
0.6171004772186279,
0.015014921315014362,
0.4380892515182495,
0.12841403484344482,
0.5520074963569641,
-0.24253125488758087,
-0.3779662847518921,
0.3730643093585968,
0.2705855071544647,
-0.5489351153373718,
-0.7300029397010803,
-0.25005561113357544,
-0.9861531257629395,
-0.2042258381843567,
0.9777125716209412,
0.012676180340349674,
-0.3559974133968353,
-0.21316418051719666,
-0.2868979573249817,
-0.3177244961261749,
-0.6168303489685059,
0.7921575307846069,
0.649909496307373,
0.19189588725566864,
0.07897806912660599,
-0.5256295800209045,
0.4092790484428406,
0.4324706196784973,
-0.5100340843200684,
0.39623406529426575,
0.5765594244003296,
0.2614912688732147,
-0.09701447188854218,
0.6074536442756653,
-0.06573162972927094,
0.1430787593126297,
-0.03726702183485031,
0.04047771915793419,
-0.06707580387592316,
-0.09458617120981216,
-0.16452430188655853,
-0.17137432098388672,
-0.03253624588251114,
0.2281295359134674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14852v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14852v1 | HumanEval on Latest GPT Models -- 2024 | 2024-02-20T04:17:21 | 2024-02-20T04:17:21 | Daniel Li, Lincoln Murr | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In 2023, we are using the latest models of GPT-4 to advance program
synthesis. The large language models have significantly improved the
state-of-the-art for this purpose. To make these advancements more accessible,
we have created a repository that connects these models to Huamn Eval. This
dataset was initally developed to be used with a language model called CODEGEN
on natural and programming language data. The utility of these trained models
is showcased by demonstrating their competitive performance in zero-shot Python
code generation on HumanEval tasks compared to previous state-of-the-art
solutions. Additionally, this gives way to developing more multi-step paradigm
synthesis. This benchmark features 160 diverse problem sets factorized into
multistep prompts that our analysis shows significantly improves program
synthesis over single-turn inputs. All code is open source at
https://github.com/daniel442li/gpt-human-eval . | [
-0.3615497648715973,
-0.5779514312744141,
0.40161269903182983,
0.07051863521337509,
0.08927327394485474,
0.04992915317416191,
-0.003213461022824049,
-0.3864867091178894,
-0.36492714285850525,
0.5347109436988831,
-0.4150440990924835,
-0.626322329044342,
-0.11593279987573624,
0.390249103307724,
0.007608180865645409,
1.2805513143539429,
-0.013753009960055351,
0.25117748975753784,
0.056766703724861145,
-0.30014753341674805,
-0.23290066421031952,
-0.8374645113945007,
-0.45232903957366943,
-0.3200015425682068,
0.4645119905471802,
0.18285299837589264,
0.661657452583313,
0.6685947179794312,
0.7058591246604919,
0.2689695954322815,
0.2771715521812439,
-0.461060106754303,
-0.11632594466209412,
0.0051160636357963085,
0.08664125949144363,
-0.021721752360463142,
-0.9087684750556946,
0.460684597492218,
0.6256449222564697,
0.43759649991989136,
-0.133083313703537,
0.0947200283408165,
-0.25600844621658325,
0.4966898262500763,
-0.28315672278404236,
0.216518834233284,
-0.5888345241546631,
0.013196601532399654,
-0.06766511499881744,
-0.1416304111480713,
-0.19568954408168793,
-0.7382985949516296,
-0.04397837445139885,
-0.47777676582336426,
0.34174370765686035,
-0.25621551275253296,
0.7100793123245239,
0.44508057832717896,
-0.33746814727783203,
0.010515943169593811,
-0.4668304920196533,
0.732566773891449,
-0.8617681264877319,
0.42198023200035095,
0.3727443516254425,
0.3871583342552185,
-0.4080422520637512,
-0.9731811285018921,
-0.2599356472492218,
-0.6964839100837708,
0.6469154357910156,
-0.019207485020160675,
-0.15137560665607452,
0.3785448372364044,
0.3908018171787262,
0.4882526397705078,
-0.6800658106803894,
-0.1283234804868698,
-0.544359564781189,
-0.5447944402694702,
0.6221965551376343,
0.3726593554019928,
0.39952826499938965,
-0.15978260338306427,
-0.4473821222782135,
-0.2915216386318207,
-0.9178497195243835,
0.028235971927642822,
0.45589742064476013,
0.014860075898468494,
-0.024052241817116737,
0.4729909300804138,
-0.37321004271507263,
0.7352708578109741,
-0.37992584705352783,
0.07476650178432465,
0.29314449429512024,
-0.7888656258583069,
-0.20655769109725952,
-0.12399923801422119,
0.7480375170707703,
0.4345778226852417,
0.02134815976023674,
0.06265967339277267,
-0.4133421778678894,
0.2429535984992981,
0.38986682891845703,
-0.9541724324226379,
-0.6954981088638306,
0.1451638787984848,
-0.253965824842453,
-0.7074321508407593,
-0.2708854377269745,
-0.6076951622962952,
-0.2977136969566345,
-0.258211225271225,
0.39644181728363037,
-0.23675106465816498,
-0.09093526005744934,
0.42888978123664856,
-0.04434150829911232,
0.4802115261554718,
0.26506486535072327,
-0.6503875851631165,
0.13341982662677765,
0.5651139616966248,
0.6306501030921936,
0.07533380389213562,
-0.4502660036087036,
-0.9366425275802612,
-0.3304394781589508,
-0.6243727803230286,
0.6632965207099915,
-0.48712801933288574,
-0.16737109422683716,
-0.1063067689538002,
0.00036647083470597863,
0.4157961308956146,
-0.46551984548568726,
0.6240395903587341,
-0.40637895464897156,
0.23903751373291016,
-0.3861638605594635,
-0.23477882146835327,
-0.13794323801994324,
0.2918718457221985,
-0.7512565851211548,
1.170676827430725,
0.3614529073238373,
-0.8231450915336609,
0.2547394037246704,
-0.9662625789642334,
-0.1462562531232834,
0.20267710089683533,
-0.13221001625061035,
-0.5156956911087036,
-0.14758382737636566,
0.15804316103458405,
0.33076560497283936,
-0.422309935092926,
0.5192820429801941,
-0.42629390954971313,
-0.38976529240608215,
0.04097206890583038,
-0.43658211827278137,
0.8417528867721558,
0.3360561728477478,
-0.29789745807647705,
0.5457460880279541,
-0.7487511038780212,
0.04730606451630592,
0.11560644954442978,
-0.6171074509620667,
-0.06193222105503082,
-0.3024125397205353,
0.03202393651008606,
0.4564420282840729,
0.20371927320957184,
-0.560526430606842,
0.5754843950271606,
-0.379230260848999,
0.7228367328643799,
0.7277058362960815,
0.19083981215953827,
0.4404148757457733,
-0.3081621527671814,
0.8365775942802429,
-0.5750380754470825,
0.47742918133735657,
-0.14251701533794403,
-0.8417757749557495,
-0.3692912459373474,
0.03823668137192726,
0.27200815081596375,
0.4944228529930115,
-0.756122887134552,
0.21417996287345886,
0.07865917682647705,
-0.3692688047885895,
-0.356475293636322,
-0.24445697665214539,
0.19164936244487762,
0.46952417492866516,
0.29069843888282776,
-0.400015652179718,
-0.6860753893852234,
-0.8516800999641418,
-0.10719209909439087,
-0.20893459022045135,
-0.2799125015735626,
-0.07501468807458878,
0.6581313014030457,
-0.4252708852291107,
0.6209666728973389,
-0.17998561263084412,
0.3072860836982727,
-0.23546102643013,
0.3852598965167999,
0.21930915117263794,
0.4804169833660126,
0.37895911931991577,
-0.6133900880813599,
-0.19326093792915344,
0.008718504570424557,
-0.6489620208740234,
-0.13607949018478394,
-0.031853411346673965,
-0.3670785129070282,
0.1641511470079422,
0.28996554017066956,
-0.28702983260154724,
0.30039462447166443,
0.5668449401855469,
-0.08417195826768875,
0.8277655839920044,
-0.32864823937416077,
0.37793946266174316,
-0.9455305933952332,
0.2070396989583969,
-0.08598358929157257,
-0.13697974383831024,
-0.7459324598312378,
0.15156306326389313,
0.16425621509552002,
-0.30424803495407104,
-0.542424201965332,
0.5123507380485535,
-0.3321704864501953,
-0.25191858410835266,
-0.07900869101285934,
-0.30821940302848816,
-0.11363953351974487,
0.528250515460968,
0.07929696142673492,
1.1589363813400269,
0.5281158089637756,
-0.45354411005973816,
0.7208064198493958,
0.11901990324258804,
-0.21977728605270386,
0.009393038228154182,
-0.8327627182006836,
0.4187396168708801,
0.42958149313926697,
0.37917789816856384,
-0.4985599219799042,
-0.45482560992240906,
0.2752423584461212,
-0.5629978775978088,
-0.07906804978847504,
-0.24006782472133636,
-0.3273683488368988,
-0.5977652668952942,
-0.7690859436988831,
0.37487566471099854,
0.7447391748428345,
-0.2451978623867035,
0.1086931824684143,
0.46074891090393066,
-0.4142485558986664,
-0.330787718296051,
-0.46946102380752563,
0.38426458835601807,
-0.29640862345695496,
-0.4466853439807892,
0.04970890283584595,
-0.455028235912323,
-0.14981001615524292,
-0.24768327176570892,
0.09166979789733887,
-0.17157208919525146,
-0.1440403312444687,
-0.05005459114909172,
0.5964791774749756,
-0.2490289807319641,
-0.1583017110824585,
-0.1211015060544014,
-0.2955372631549835,
0.24194486439228058,
-0.4614671766757965,
0.31344226002693176,
-0.5667713284492493,
-0.14265817403793335,
-0.2874073386192322,
0.2719587981700897,
0.7743449807167053,
-0.5052767992019653,
0.1672506034374237,
0.7020578384399414,
-0.4754944145679474,
0.08214917033910751,
-0.3674294650554657,
-0.15222936868667603,
-0.48674148321151733,
0.40797412395477295,
-0.28230714797973633,
-0.8775840997695923,
0.40449610352516174,
-0.051622647792100906,
0.22383137047290802,
0.2585347592830658,
0.8100625276565552,
0.4961665868759155,
1.273625135421753,
0.5601015686988831,
-0.07108478248119354,
0.39663219451904297,
-0.17617745697498322,
0.004018181003630161,
-0.8498188257217407,
-0.03025752305984497,
-0.5708537101745605,
0.2550107538700104,
-0.6983767151832581,
-0.6294438242912292,
0.6767354011535645,
-0.019212428480386734,
-0.693475604057312,
0.4873749315738678,
-0.86711186170578,
0.3176165521144867,
0.6789674162864685,
-0.04702446609735489,
0.19210632145404816,
-0.0649157464504242,
-0.34252050518989563,
0.0021555530838668346,
-0.6852539777755737,
-0.49473047256469727,
1.3586803674697876,
0.344638854265213,
0.7104507088661194,
-0.3067976236343384,
0.773509681224823,
0.40461283922195435,
0.3247833549976349,
-0.6203742623329163,
0.46340805292129517,
0.33021998405456543,
-0.586830198764801,
-0.41114312410354614,
-0.41838589310646057,
-0.8802024722099304,
0.11506698280572891,
0.18669049441814423,
-0.39420440793037415,
-0.25383609533309937,
0.03386956453323364,
-0.44049325585365295,
0.24406220018863678,
-0.4211231470108032,
1.0353330373764038,
-0.15412026643753052,
-0.4965381324291229,
0.020711049437522888,
-0.9245014190673828,
0.46561411023139954,
-0.22522501647472382,
0.00644683325663209,
-0.20272140204906464,
0.17833301424980164,
0.6680722832679749,
-0.5513827204704285,
0.4179127812385559,
-0.0735820084810257,
-0.24765875935554504,
0.449484646320343,
0.08134077489376068,
0.5988430976867676,
0.0897589772939682,
-0.39347997307777405,
0.12809798121452332,
-0.06091910973191261,
-0.4558722972869873,
-0.08062039315700531,
0.6111695170402527,
-0.4030788540840149,
-0.3750905990600586,
-0.46803587675094604,
-0.5729953646659851,
-0.13559284806251526,
0.18225666880607605,
0.304227739572525,
0.9125247597694397,
-0.31571197509765625,
0.0184649545699358,
0.4750033915042877,
-0.6608673334121704,
0.36716026067733765,
0.22743089497089386,
-0.11534695327281952,
-0.6832915544509888,
0.8869936466217041,
-0.25570619106292725,
0.20331215858459473,
0.08460371941328049,
0.3473753333091736,
-0.4599400460720062,
-0.4613398611545563,
-0.7243546843528748,
0.08177563548088074,
-0.6317021250724792,
-0.34913164377212524,
-0.43712425231933594,
-0.19413603842258453,
-0.4876123368740082,
-0.2547786831855774,
-0.40444639325141907,
-0.24282100796699524,
0.27598074078559875,
-0.04482651129364967,
0.462158739566803,
1.1089396476745605,
-0.27253055572509766,
-0.4146555960178375,
-1.16036057472229,
0.5056218504905701,
0.3486887812614441,
0.38248932361602783,
-0.3827250301837921,
-0.3014548718929291,
-0.2540142238140106,
0.1318572759628296,
-0.41144177317619324,
-0.8568328619003296,
0.40585145354270935,
-0.01111778523772955,
0.5228834748268127,
-0.1493973731994629,
0.2591719925403595,
0.1538730263710022,
-0.6098718047142029,
1.0595779418945312,
0.18563903868198395,
-0.8999841213226318,
0.7370896339416504,
-0.8932019472122192,
0.437176913022995,
0.31181812286376953,
0.28295573592185974,
-0.5926473140716553,
-0.43410390615463257,
-0.5619244575500488,
-0.4477541446685791,
0.6573746800422668,
0.19526945054531097,
-0.008791867643594742,
0.03902537375688553,
0.18849724531173706,
0.17028163373470306,
0.21548302471637726,
-0.5315310955047607,
0.18849769234657288,
-0.2729654312133789,
-0.05249202996492386,
0.2277933955192566,
-0.018129318952560425,
0.020304031670093536,
-0.6317473649978638,
0.5710055828094482,
-0.23327390849590302,
0.610279381275177,
-0.08094096183776855,
0.28342634439468384,
-0.1266327053308487,
0.3232263922691345,
0.6683226823806763,
0.5797439217567444,
-0.26283133029937744,
-0.08249685913324356,
0.14872990548610687,
-0.4624357223510742,
0.22436046600341797,
0.18987725675106049,
0.033194851130247116,
-0.27736636996269226,
0.2667999565601349,
0.8048188090324402,
-0.0020575234666466713,
-0.5378784537315369,
0.5847548842430115,
-0.08785039186477661,
-0.3882671296596527,
-0.162451833486557,
0.07132645696401596,
-0.09992244839668274,
0.26901257038116455,
0.05369025468826294,
0.20938408374786377,
0.5154118537902832,
-0.43138813972473145,
0.4320616126060486,
0.08887679874897003,
-0.2560516595840454,
-0.6397196650505066,
1.137579321861267,
0.2083214521408081,
-0.15280185639858246,
0.8395178318023682,
-0.45468780398368835,
-0.8182880878448486,
0.6309164762496948,
0.3840092718601227,
1.008132815361023,
-0.39193856716156006,
0.3044799268245697,
0.6645164489746094,
0.13248609006404877,
-0.13541992008686066,
0.40731722116470337,
-0.07373038679361343,
-0.4143756628036499,
-0.6641864776611328,
-0.612697958946228,
-0.6304582357406616,
0.3282828629016876,
-0.5785030722618103,
0.3393552601337433,
-0.27218273282051086,
-0.098399318754673,
-0.30863770842552185,
0.03740670531988144,
-0.5197126269340515,
0.03704940527677536,
0.0657881498336792,
0.5549694895744324,
-0.7835364937782288,
1.2663395404815674,
0.9517150521278381,
-0.6772118210792542,
-0.9790545105934143,
-0.14795593917369843,
0.1276548057794571,
-0.4545725882053375,
0.2995218336582184,
-0.018628442659974098,
-0.09954975545406342,
0.1436796486377716,
-0.8544679880142212,
-0.46184518933296204,
0.7898162603378296,
0.3589596450328827,
-0.21314078569412231,
-0.08864805847406387,
-0.0544249601662159,
0.5547431111335754,
-0.03421971946954727,
0.028789062052965164,
0.5417771339416504,
0.5341652035713196,
0.13015300035476685,
-0.9662193655967712,
-0.09135136753320694,
-0.5183741450309753,
0.1267480105161667,
0.22731177508831024,
-0.2519786059856415,
1.0542017221450806,
-0.36051681637763977,
0.0574980191886425,
0.227789968252182,
0.427631139755249,
0.46969011425971985,
0.20387989282608032,
0.012588166631758213,
0.23980151116847992,
0.6286318898200989,
-0.12151920050382614,
1.200327754020691,
-0.31570762395858765,
0.5382018089294434,
0.8551619648933411,
-0.3983646035194397,
0.6326190829277039,
0.06137596443295479,
-0.5595391392707825,
0.09734679758548737,
0.8407293558120728,
-0.14327140152454376,
0.5128204226493835,
0.2797578275203705,
-0.4273117482662201,
-0.3228651285171509,
0.03175099939107895,
-0.5768687725067139,
0.25012442469596863,
0.06381697207689285,
0.14325277507305145,
-0.2830689549446106,
0.2631177604198456,
0.006008494179695845,
-0.30322301387786865,
-0.0139022096991539,
0.6171273589134216,
-0.12900957465171814,
-0.5582321882247925,
1.0162005424499512,
0.13041749596595764,
0.6657320857048035,
-0.49073174595832825,
-0.5625395178794861,
-0.2934803068637848,
0.09853480011224747,
0.15718653798103333,
-0.7287800908088684,
0.07447941601276398,
0.12113732099533081,
0.24258536100387573,
-0.20170876383781433,
0.8550083041191101,
-0.36642637848854065,
-0.24575720727443695,
0.04437835142016411,
0.32344722747802734,
0.4047202169895172,
-0.32380080223083496,
-0.8998220562934875,
0.16814252734184265,
0.19705547392368317,
-0.17200659215450287,
0.3105970323085785,
0.3264266848564148,
-0.48487985134124756,
0.5960139632225037,
0.8102850914001465,
0.09524332731962204,
0.36199361085891724,
0.12456830590963364,
0.9546845555305481,
-0.7324362397193909,
-0.316091388463974,
-0.504911482334137,
0.41265466809272766,
0.28629323840141296,
-0.3673359155654907,
0.5004900097846985,
0.4943770170211792,
0.7854653596878052,
-0.2955609858036041,
0.9881951808929443,
-0.009279471822082996,
0.11406899243593216,
-0.391570508480072,
0.6974552273750305,
-0.44141173362731934,
0.05704342946410179,
-0.3858298659324646,
-0.9532989263534546,
-0.43941715359687805,
0.646346926689148,
-0.14810672402381897,
0.15225383639335632,
0.6530339121818542,
0.8860968351364136,
0.21209663152694702,
0.029165372252464294,
0.4256459176540375,
-0.09632589668035507,
0.6660008430480957,
0.7280066609382629,
1.0852792263031006,
-0.5218853950500488,
0.3854828178882599,
-0.27721136808395386,
-0.2972380518913269,
-0.19469675421714783,
-0.9260349869728088,
-0.5547124743461609,
-0.6880506277084351,
-0.3458912968635559,
-0.25547894835472107,
0.15215134620666504,
1.0403413772583008,
0.4969133734703064,
-0.7112389802932739,
-0.05246266722679138,
-0.422208309173584,
-0.17888347804546356,
0.008163043297827244,
-0.14553971588611603,
0.2559182047843933,
-0.2950531244277954,
-0.7668147683143616,
0.5261560678482056,
0.4742544889450073,
-0.10096171498298645,
-0.23967809975147247,
-0.5209953784942627,
-0.09533458203077316,
0.08939386159181595,
0.5088320970535278,
0.4090672433376312,
-0.6503304839134216,
-0.4382975697517395,
0.1826419085264206,
-0.381140798330307,
0.2378692924976349,
0.8878145813941956,
-0.7653170228004456,
0.5371589660644531,
0.6738809943199158,
0.6822492480278015,
0.23836560547351837,
0.08220413327217102,
0.7767422199249268,
-0.2514713406562805,
0.06674747914075851,
0.4181343615055084,
0.2174513339996338,
0.3527487814426422,
-0.19326892495155334,
0.6555705070495605,
0.16855250298976898,
-0.9437037706375122,
-0.6981334090232849,
0.12522180378437042,
-0.8081522583961487,
0.09505604207515717,
1.1908906698226929,
-0.0575108677148819,
-0.10104425996541977,
-0.24674548208713531,
-0.3228617012500763,
0.4460025429725647,
-0.3932841420173645,
0.4383440315723419,
0.6251068711280823,
-0.42462974786758423,
-0.032940465956926346,
-1.0320650339126587,
0.5974332094192505,
0.2491629719734192,
-1.0329660177230835,
-0.0024427876342087984,
0.8900097012519836,
0.39252471923828125,
-0.3381820321083069,
0.9093207120895386,
-0.5928166508674622,
0.6180312037467957,
0.2536003887653351,
0.6383435130119324,
-0.12470881640911102,
-0.4385904371738434,
-0.53707355260849,
-0.17993046343326569,
0.2587766945362091,
-0.2309468388557434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08819v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08819v2 | Thermometer: Towards Universal Calibration for Large Language Models | 2024-02-20T04:13:48 | 2024-06-27T16:30:32 | Maohao Shen, Subhro Das, Kristjan Greenewald, Prasanna Sattigeri, Gregory Wornell, Soumya Ghosh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | We consider the issue of calibration in large language models (LLM). Recent
studies have found that common interventions such as instruction tuning often
result in poorly calibrated LLMs. Although calibration is well-explored in
traditional applications, calibrating LLMs is uniquely challenging. These
challenges stem as much from the severe computational requirements of LLMs as
from their versatility, which allows them to be applied to diverse tasks.
Addressing these challenges, we propose THERMOMETER, a calibration approach
tailored to LLMs. THERMOMETER learns an auxiliary model, given data from
multiple tasks, for calibrating a LLM. It is computationally efficient,
preserves the accuracy of the LLM, and produces better-calibrated responses for
new tasks. Extensive empirical evaluations across various benchmarks
demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method. | [
0.03438036888837814,
-0.33387327194213867,
0.7096385359764099,
-0.08478724211454391,
-0.12542518973350525,
-0.11081244051456451,
-0.5770466923713684,
-0.1656123399734497,
-0.021435575559735298,
0.5216522216796875,
-0.338290810585022,
-0.503612220287323,
-0.3399835228919983,
-0.08706817030906677,
-0.18470589816570282,
0.740673303604126,
-0.03400862216949463,
0.20120705664157867,
-0.47285518050193787,
-0.019343366846442223,
-0.44956883788108826,
-0.5091965794563293,
-0.7352529764175415,
-0.8992210626602173,
0.645950198173523,
0.6445391774177551,
0.5841550827026367,
0.6683112978935242,
0.15655992925167084,
0.39089980721473694,
0.20299120247364044,
0.2638360559940338,
-0.6790391206741333,
0.3493556082248688,
-0.10193084925413132,
-0.42625683546066284,
-0.22347448766231537,
-0.2604743540287018,
0.5775671601295471,
0.828019917011261,
-0.2445966899394989,
0.4502934515476227,
0.049479708075523376,
0.6854214072227478,
-0.6622970104217529,
0.22626787424087524,
-0.5684217214584351,
-0.2644285559654236,
-0.13983170688152313,
-0.30344489216804504,
-0.41223466396331787,
-0.3059760630130768,
0.06957223266363144,
-0.5898443460464478,
0.04293376952409744,
0.0257990974932909,
0.12626178562641144,
0.39442047476768494,
-0.8607193827629089,
-0.22459454834461212,
-0.9465107917785645,
1.1636449098587036,
-0.7151755690574646,
0.49667075276374817,
0.30567002296447754,
0.22297970950603485,
0.013308248482644558,
-0.4577508568763733,
-0.26660460233688354,
-0.45930731296539307,
0.449831485748291,
0.011113288812339306,
0.21323145925998688,
-0.1204458624124527,
-0.1813890039920807,
0.290721595287323,
-0.613665759563446,
0.4440130293369293,
-0.19841328263282776,
-0.3104684054851532,
0.5316119194030762,
0.4532737731933594,
0.20312897861003876,
0.1177426278591156,
0.036335788667201996,
-0.272898405790329,
-0.8290834426879883,
-0.17343907058238983,
0.2467377781867981,
0.4456324577331543,
-0.10148897767066956,
0.33894336223602295,
0.28443169593811035,
0.9864518046379089,
-0.16715368628501892,
-0.41456910967826843,
-0.17357254028320312,
-0.07672863453626633,
-0.05524424836039543,
0.20791015028953552,
0.4657382667064667,
0.2299087643623352,
0.505852460861206,
-0.3452059030532837,
0.060006000101566315,
-0.1214153990149498,
0.28598737716674805,
-0.7856841683387756,
-0.5854486227035522,
0.027390727773308754,
0.5418992638587952,
-0.1193724200129509,
-0.046065159142017365,
-0.35823163390159607,
-0.45016658306121826,
-0.5829516649246216,
0.391032874584198,
-0.08108281344175339,
-0.25712376832962036,
0.04740649089217186,
0.22064365446567535,
0.13191981613636017,
0.4392215609550476,
-1.1057523488998413,
0.21415521204471588,
0.9589532017707825,
0.553594172000885,
0.12121856957674026,
-0.3972207307815552,
-0.5537030100822449,
0.3897467255592346,
-0.4504666328430176,
0.6215150356292725,
-0.7514488697052002,
-0.522649347782135,
-0.28276166319847107,
-0.21849936246871948,
-0.1350659281015396,
-0.2952691912651062,
0.4899039566516876,
-0.6077195405960083,
0.03930217772722244,
-0.4709451198577881,
-0.9005470871925354,
-0.33681586384773254,
0.4183299243450165,
-0.7302180528640747,
1.1288145780563354,
0.043599989265203476,
-0.37691789865493774,
-0.08465190976858139,
-0.42653563618659973,
-0.26635506749153137,
0.031945593655109406,
-0.2190128117799759,
-0.0692770853638649,
0.25064441561698914,
0.13438253104686737,
0.1851799339056015,
-0.8408847451210022,
0.1634438931941986,
-0.42059487104415894,
-0.46022918820381165,
0.17223834991455078,
-0.641941249370575,
0.6074621081352234,
-0.023686029016971588,
0.14529237151145935,
0.1716868281364441,
-0.5270013809204102,
0.3282763361930847,
-0.010828492231667042,
-0.3728219270706177,
-0.32844316959381104,
0.011074976995587349,
0.09447754174470901,
-0.4654863774776459,
0.40304747223854065,
-0.6789128184318542,
0.011835538782179356,
-0.4524555504322052,
0.3449763059616089,
0.7725751399993896,
-0.20524649322032928,
0.6958593726158142,
-0.55170077085495,
0.4246717691421509,
-0.4059581458568573,
-0.2554686963558197,
-0.12234192341566086,
-0.19132591784000397,
-0.7158876061439514,
-0.35418081283569336,
0.4409674108028412,
0.8104494214057922,
-0.3747410178184509,
0.53703773021698,
-0.3050845265388489,
-1.04746413230896,
-0.19535458087921143,
0.5652404427528381,
0.20152732729911804,
0.6733865737915039,
0.09963023662567139,
0.17923562228679657,
-0.5250625610351562,
-0.24050937592983246,
-0.33473634719848633,
-0.21490871906280518,
-0.41382914781570435,
0.36815041303634644,
0.21416357159614563,
0.03819898143410683,
0.608443021774292,
-0.2539461553096771,
-0.06963755190372467,
0.11874499171972275,
0.04700686037540436,
0.5700470805168152,
0.5204684734344482,
0.26456451416015625,
-0.3989261984825134,
-0.38976049423217773,
0.23246675729751587,
-0.7379883527755737,
-0.2541811168193817,
0.18420268595218658,
0.15945158898830414,
0.04155439883470535,
0.5963369607925415,
-0.27797046303749084,
-0.1922568529844284,
0.9767960906028748,
-0.021358313038945198,
0.5021740794181824,
-0.5397832989692688,
0.16182661056518555,
-1.0310122966766357,
0.055376484990119934,
0.04189465567469597,
-0.41473740339279175,
-0.6286554932594299,
0.185124009847641,
0.15191517770290375,
-0.05678523704409599,
-0.49670422077178955,
0.9032851457595825,
-0.5145180225372314,
0.24351009726524353,
-0.28007251024246216,
0.0858108326792717,
0.18396933376789093,
-0.14172150194644928,
-0.11693426966667175,
0.6334238648414612,
0.683069109916687,
-0.7059404850006104,
1.1428823471069336,
-0.0072244093753397465,
-0.5020401477813721,
0.6328179240226746,
-0.68257075548172,
0.5320466160774231,
0.06036686524748802,
0.2958069145679474,
-0.9288733601570129,
-0.3794253468513489,
-0.13924236595630646,
-0.16544266045093536,
0.27472588419914246,
0.0708811804652214,
-0.633070707321167,
-0.43505656719207764,
-0.27222687005996704,
0.7366123795509338,
0.33598795533180237,
-0.7063130140304565,
0.7293701767921448,
0.26833727955818176,
-0.1512693613767624,
-0.29669827222824097,
-0.32894372940063477,
0.09368503838777542,
-0.09408988058567047,
-0.6059368848800659,
0.060477349907159805,
-0.2760010063648224,
-0.07257281243801117,
-0.3647567927837372,
-0.3760894536972046,
0.05759143456816673,
0.05488935858011246,
0.28687575459480286,
0.26930493116378784,
-0.3402075171470642,
0.3646916449069977,
-0.38937699794769287,
-0.029749911278486252,
0.006336207501590252,
-0.1586933434009552,
0.7214446663856506,
-0.1690022498369217,
-0.5592369437217712,
-0.28524860739707947,
0.23663954436779022,
0.7322513461112976,
0.03648630529642105,
0.5654510855674744,
0.41273635625839233,
-0.5247499346733093,
-0.3159922957420349,
-0.7329159379005432,
-0.1597759872674942,
-0.5984127521514893,
0.423243910074234,
-0.48173049092292786,
-0.7710416913032532,
0.47194451093673706,
-0.08359783887863159,
0.03103659488260746,
0.28388267755508423,
0.6565338373184204,
0.004803601186722517,
1.0308592319488525,
0.7597036957740784,
-0.17233741283416748,
0.3720804452896118,
0.28657856583595276,
0.26533088088035583,
-0.828058660030365,
-0.20099857449531555,
-0.7859343886375427,
-0.25614628195762634,
-0.4351896345615387,
-0.3755897283554077,
0.7411981225013733,
-0.2258596569299698,
-0.7105636596679688,
0.24419213831424713,
-0.3470131456851959,
0.7843294143676758,
0.7831530570983887,
0.3827543556690216,
0.23997968435287476,
-0.06525016576051712,
-0.0030292191077023745,
-0.3340100944042206,
-0.4873083829879761,
-0.7144237160682678,
1.146449327468872,
0.1465216726064682,
1.2303489446640015,
0.11274175345897675,
0.44780728220939636,
-0.12159747630357742,
0.6823755502700806,
-0.7804673314094543,
0.5243385434150696,
-0.443104088306427,
-0.7257713675498962,
-0.47380179166793823,
-0.6354112029075623,
-0.495778888463974,
0.011559851467609406,
0.0989067405462265,
-1.0648632049560547,
-0.438469797372818,
0.3372681438922882,
-0.36414381861686707,
0.44434550404548645,
-0.6894979476928711,
0.8945733904838562,
-0.45853573083877563,
-0.361873984336853,
-0.1161927804350853,
-0.038633909076452255,
0.15170498192310333,
-0.35371848940849304,
0.08322219550609589,
-0.4064556956291199,
-0.20901893079280853,
0.5839381814002991,
-0.2682943642139435,
0.9947940111160278,
-0.09888622909784317,
-0.41990840435028076,
0.013652223162353039,
0.3253837823867798,
0.42043015360832214,
0.17660635709762573,
-0.9682101011276245,
-0.08798158913850784,
0.6396560668945312,
-0.3913232982158661,
-0.4023946523666382,
1.0819443464279175,
-0.6984004378318787,
-0.6841409802436829,
-0.4129686951637268,
-1.0181306600570679,
-0.6103516817092896,
0.1165037453174591,
0.04648025333881378,
0.498020738363266,
-0.5454400181770325,
0.14787523448467255,
0.4221647083759308,
-0.24028386175632477,
0.07863856852054596,
0.8052641749382019,
-0.087897889316082,
-0.0406399741768837,
1.1587473154067993,
-0.1782444268465042,
0.12414230406284332,
0.4978121817111969,
0.37410375475883484,
-0.28014320135116577,
-0.1230740174651146,
-0.6415449380874634,
0.06135941669344902,
-0.7801336050033569,
-0.3311383128166199,
-0.049547869712114334,
-0.044864218682050705,
-0.39138853549957275,
-0.3729260265827179,
-0.41407638788223267,
-0.16880634427070618,
-0.767588198184967,
0.1643468737602234,
0.6341596841812134,
0.6991397142410278,
-0.19044436514377594,
0.3876509964466095,
-0.9391476511955261,
0.030494291335344315,
0.5713682770729065,
0.2704406976699829,
-0.057371675968170166,
-0.8893303275108337,
0.0652819573879242,
0.3419708013534546,
-0.1777176707983017,
-0.5500235557556152,
0.31918638944625854,
0.610824704170227,
0.28670692443847656,
0.45735886693000793,
0.09090740233659744,
0.6541093587875366,
-0.6343726515769958,
0.6947405338287354,
0.29259833693504333,
-1.2623465061187744,
0.1377575695514679,
-0.21394887566566467,
0.966273844242096,
0.7106489539146423,
0.30299702286720276,
-0.8385773301124573,
-0.32213231921195984,
0.0649389997124672,
-0.7177974581718445,
0.3050859272480011,
-0.6748884320259094,
0.6570417284965515,
0.28454455733299255,
0.38582342863082886,
0.1791466623544693,
0.0057503473944962025,
-0.47397613525390625,
-0.029108792543411255,
0.2754574120044708,
-0.6035748720169067,
-0.481414794921875,
-0.027416381984949112,
-0.27869153022766113,
-0.6232032775878906,
0.6391817331314087,
-0.25422707200050354,
0.03508751839399338,
-0.3454659581184387,
-0.314776211977005,
-0.5556367039680481,
0.25266575813293457,
0.3367968797683716,
1.0008846521377563,
-0.33348000049591064,
0.4071374535560608,
0.42368024587631226,
-0.3581193685531616,
0.11299705505371094,
-0.11798468232154846,
-0.09443788230419159,
-0.12475408613681793,
0.3861243426799774,
0.627802848815918,
0.6440029740333557,
-0.7178796529769897,
0.29079481959342957,
0.05617120862007141,
-0.038490179926157,
-0.6262245178222656,
0.3089871108531952,
0.34538236260414124,
0.19259144365787506,
0.24094770848751068,
-0.2192741185426712,
-0.144644096493721,
-0.5206380486488342,
0.11296109110116959,
0.5931301116943359,
-0.2726454734802246,
-0.4011821746826172,
0.7022765278816223,
0.2747156322002411,
-0.365233838558197,
0.6878150105476379,
0.22390684485435486,
-0.6805859208106995,
0.7824209332466125,
0.7825295329093933,
0.6298409104347229,
-0.5061901807785034,
0.11898981034755707,
0.4563685357570648,
0.5636199116706848,
-0.12015695869922638,
0.31189993023872375,
-0.02248351089656353,
-0.8251469135284424,
-0.46277403831481934,
-0.8062252402305603,
-1.0657665729522705,
0.016556445509195328,
-0.6330079436302185,
-0.1254720240831375,
-0.43127572536468506,
0.13267207145690918,
0.1616915911436081,
-0.04242177680134773,
-0.9922823905944824,
0.23005467653274536,
0.5118991732597351,
0.9194271564483643,
-0.8087761998176575,
0.8844622373580933,
0.8499183058738708,
0.40806514024734497,
-0.7917237877845764,
-0.4311279058456421,
0.22274380922317505,
-1.196620225906372,
0.26602476835250854,
0.27030324935913086,
-0.27406686544418335,
0.10424646735191345,
-0.5578356981277466,
-0.8537718653678894,
0.9748325943946838,
0.927397608757019,
-0.8384425640106201,
-0.08514992892742157,
0.3013412058353424,
0.5731954574584961,
-0.2792426347732544,
0.26969805359840393,
0.6719295978546143,
0.6879684925079346,
0.2970348000526428,
-1.2137600183486938,
0.07600314915180206,
-0.0760311484336853,
-0.02660195343196392,
0.3256025016307831,
-0.4295605719089508,
0.5494990944862366,
-0.32304847240448,
-0.07087679952383041,
0.3535197973251343,
0.4424096643924713,
0.013289484195411205,
0.13884802162647247,
0.45655789971351624,
0.492872029542923,
0.9534927010536194,
-0.27958065271377563,
0.9989154934883118,
-0.47783559560775757,
0.24022291600704193,
1.215356469154358,
-0.5596491098403931,
0.9263269901275635,
0.5322913527488708,
-0.0507357232272625,
0.1426733136177063,
0.6764439344406128,
-0.037380922585725784,
0.31215181946754456,
0.627425491809845,
-0.9142103791236877,
-0.5429384112358093,
-0.06513343751430511,
-0.3010885715484619,
0.46841853857040405,
0.5738150477409363,
0.051383525133132935,
-0.34797120094299316,
-0.05939921364188194,
-0.04864684119820595,
0.03178120031952858,
-0.5956634283065796,
0.555657684803009,
0.28281369805336,
-0.5865665674209595,
0.5514565706253052,
0.168684720993042,
0.43786725401878357,
-0.5254770517349243,
0.23219163715839386,
0.015500170178711414,
0.5674997568130493,
0.030332742258906364,
-0.5492931008338928,
0.23523665964603424,
-0.028690597042441368,
-0.033780522644519806,
-0.18921808898448944,
0.26388275623321533,
-0.6672625541687012,
-0.8907188773155212,
0.11951037496328354,
0.5093012452125549,
0.008098980411887169,
-0.19999228417873383,
-0.3090253472328186,
0.4179183542728424,
-0.20273353159427643,
-0.3563864827156067,
0.040917981415987015,
0.18582724034786224,
0.4347720742225647,
0.5137717723846436,
0.38914212584495544,
0.12666650116443634,
0.09669780731201172,
-0.007618296425789595,
0.5606096386909485,
-0.556108832359314,
-0.2534473240375519,
-0.7793262004852295,
0.07271325588226318,
0.32352080941200256,
-0.27478596568107605,
0.7173264622688293,
0.37692582607269287,
0.6247994303703308,
-0.06409523636102676,
0.5762604475021362,
0.31472328305244446,
0.5957880020141602,
-0.5720427632331848,
0.4829052984714508,
-0.6748413443565369,
0.3941301107406616,
0.06117667630314827,
-1.1685383319854736,
-0.626991331577301,
0.5426678657531738,
-0.4179549813270569,
0.07844899594783783,
0.6062079071998596,
0.911486029624939,
-0.1925715208053589,
0.2896314263343811,
0.4953109323978424,
0.14204375445842743,
0.1580183207988739,
0.8797401785850525,
0.5014186501502991,
-0.31226348876953125,
0.40130120515823364,
-0.15910127758979797,
-0.399854451417923,
0.053685788065195084,
-1.1983011960983276,
-0.8702595233917236,
-0.43374037742614746,
-0.16552729904651642,
-0.13209223747253418,
0.08477085828781128,
1.0457966327667236,
0.7180938124656677,
-1.130277156829834,
-0.6884924173355103,
0.23154495656490326,
-0.05217554047703743,
0.0888824388384819,
-0.142894446849823,
0.09961944073438644,
-0.04022207111120224,
-0.9239501357078552,
0.5738881230354309,
0.2195940464735031,
-0.3027024567127228,
-0.41636422276496887,
-0.024861659854650497,
0.15955811738967896,
0.45768454670906067,
0.5624123811721802,
0.5878806710243225,
-0.4661044776439667,
-0.3665364980697632,
-0.06842280179262161,
-0.24224695563316345,
-0.17874498665332794,
0.6470500826835632,
-0.3272899091243744,
0.642705500125885,
0.288093239068985,
0.9736776351928711,
0.7423372268676758,
-0.4968213737010956,
0.8400030732154846,
-0.7525856494903564,
0.07210738956928253,
0.2658766210079193,
0.22327114641666412,
0.6803963780403137,
-0.09221740812063217,
0.28273633122444153,
-0.3571074604988098,
-0.7681891918182373,
-1.03572678565979,
0.2982690632343292,
-0.8016496300697327,
0.11549829691648483,
1.0646257400512695,
0.09325453639030457,
-0.43336713314056396,
0.17481550574302673,
-0.03398505225777626,
0.28193995356559753,
-0.3797076344490051,
0.752492368221283,
0.8162745833396912,
0.2071293741464615,
-0.22527694702148438,
-0.7320550680160522,
-0.00006247327837627381,
0.6631166338920593,
-0.8026284575462341,
0.07940877974033356,
0.48947516083717346,
0.5988622903823853,
0.030773472040891647,
0.3511122763156891,
0.27657538652420044,
0.3034001588821411,
-0.22761356830596924,
0.02028796635568142,
-0.034419793635606766,
-0.1775805652141571,
-0.27562466263771057,
0.023639947175979614,
0.3807138204574585,
0.1711365282535553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14851v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14851v1 | SQL-CRAFT: Text-to-SQL through Interactive Refinement and Enhanced Reasoning | 2024-02-20T03:57:55 | 2024-02-20T03:57:55 | Hanchen Xia, Feng Jiang, Naihao Deng, Cunxiang Wang, Guojiang Zhao, Rada Mihalcea, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | Modern LLMs have become increasingly powerful, but they are still facing
challenges in specialized tasks such as Text-to-SQL. We propose SQL-CRAFT, a
framework to advance LLMs' SQL generation Capabilities through inteRActive
reFinemenT and enhanced reasoning. We leverage an Interactive Correction Loop
(IC-Loop) for LLMs to interact with databases automatically, as well as
Python-enhanced reasoning. We conduct experiments on two Text-to-SQL datasets,
Spider and Bird, with performance improvements of up to 5.7% compared to the
naive prompting method. Moreover, our method surpasses the current
state-of-the-art on the Spider Leaderboard, demonstrating the effectiveness of
our framework. | [
-0.09347575902938843,
-1.2024599313735962,
0.7385880947113037,
0.24111196398735046,
-0.31227564811706543,
0.20834432542324066,
-0.21841126680374146,
-0.30911535024642944,
0.19548270106315613,
0.6473811864852905,
-1.0016484260559082,
-0.5945793390274048,
-0.01046774722635746,
0.5024121403694153,
-0.46389228105545044,
0.6850565671920776,
0.06704723834991455,
-0.08891377598047256,
-0.6246171593666077,
0.18673564493656158,
-0.5578080415725708,
-0.4626953601837158,
-0.42493489384651184,
-0.33836954832077026,
0.641971230506897,
0.569961428642273,
0.7222775220870972,
0.8098082542419434,
0.5512935519218445,
0.3309183120727539,
-0.0001296890404773876,
1.011885166168213,
-0.3631347119808197,
0.7122186422348022,
-0.6674940586090088,
-0.8272441625595093,
-0.6623955965042114,
-0.3438744843006134,
0.3129919171333313,
0.5885730385780334,
-0.17890560626983643,
0.08234455436468124,
-0.10553563386201859,
0.953512966632843,
-0.4185565412044525,
-0.09009800106287003,
-1.1480605602264404,
-0.029565855860710144,
-0.4660014510154724,
-0.5121476054191589,
-0.5527591705322266,
-0.391375333070755,
-0.008052581921219826,
-0.9132825136184692,
0.08884049952030182,
0.5667458176612854,
0.4507353901863098,
0.33904725313186646,
-0.3317251205444336,
-0.39578309655189514,
-0.5299339890480042,
0.4699746072292328,
-0.5409290790557861,
0.12134695798158646,
0.05865686386823654,
0.18104444444179535,
-0.6643621921539307,
-1.0204888582229614,
-0.7288960814476013,
-0.428238183259964,
-0.08600454777479172,
-0.05245254188776016,
0.19630400836467743,
0.02230130322277546,
0.5383768677711487,
0.4020305573940277,
-0.33321624994277954,
-0.05844883993268013,
-0.1425379514694214,
0.19543874263763428,
0.8105936646461487,
0.44051241874694824,
0.10355306416749954,
0.09233900159597397,
-0.1339598000049591,
0.32036882638931274,
-0.9294522404670715,
-0.3511265218257904,
0.43165165185928345,
0.5374395251274109,
0.2397080808877945,
1.1549452543258667,
-0.2995889484882355,
0.9092062711715698,
0.27178892493247986,
0.16942745447158813,
-0.1160859689116478,
-0.45253315567970276,
-0.31270697712898254,
0.06872812658548355,
0.5052715539932251,
0.5454317331314087,
0.303637832403183,
-0.24003350734710693,
-0.12528018653392792,
-0.15319041907787323,
0.2643599212169647,
-0.4275447130203247,
-0.3758464753627777,
0.7026308178901672,
-0.2199310064315796,
-0.32935234904289246,
0.037546027451753616,
-0.6552881598472595,
-0.8395670056343079,
-0.5828725099563599,
0.4104654788970947,
-0.34598809480667114,
-0.31998541951179504,
-0.08493112772703171,
-0.48921388387680054,
0.0023711014073342085,
0.6515209078788757,
-0.6780477166175842,
0.22621901333332062,
0.719663679599762,
0.7173252701759338,
-0.8228754997253418,
-0.21558323502540588,
-0.586581289768219,
0.7025451064109802,
-0.49672529101371765,
1.167190670967102,
-0.6473357081413269,
-0.44839638471603394,
-0.11687257885932922,
-0.030004654079675674,
0.18791498243808746,
-0.8137903809547424,
-0.041007641702890396,
-0.3386455774307251,
0.17670276761054993,
-0.34509867429733276,
-0.6594629883766174,
0.19193102419376373,
0.42847830057144165,
-0.6262091398239136,
1.344354271888733,
0.044310830533504486,
-0.5561808943748474,
0.6122613549232483,
-0.7864046692848206,
-0.5648694634437561,
0.07662487775087357,
-0.10297389328479767,
-0.4735729992389679,
0.1559738963842392,
0.2329808473587036,
0.14858795702457428,
-0.40364667773246765,
0.18776565790176392,
-0.5417341589927673,
-0.728518545627594,
0.36702555418014526,
-0.06420561671257019,
0.4366779625415802,
0.16755621135234833,
-0.3174872100353241,
0.275056928396225,
-0.9236719608306885,
0.403504878282547,
0.008160294964909554,
-0.37296062707901,
0.0904591977596283,
0.17994658648967743,
-0.34050968289375305,
-0.23678049445152283,
0.17450688779354095,
-0.245420902967453,
0.7305755615234375,
-0.5659441351890564,
0.34841474890708923,
0.659977376461029,
0.11877159029245377,
0.43852150440216064,
-0.4396931827068329,
0.34402140974998474,
0.10360834002494812,
-0.0010115690529346466,
-0.4631459712982178,
-0.284625381231308,
-1.0156903266906738,
-0.16252414882183075,
0.17875854671001434,
0.8644865155220032,
-0.9015296697616577,
0.4194469749927521,
0.1509639471769333,
-0.44826894998550415,
-0.40934592485427856,
0.0749189555644989,
-0.054502468556165695,
0.16679352521896362,
0.5651553273200989,
-0.12164691835641861,
-0.6726330518722534,
-0.47439876198768616,
-0.7884229421615601,
-0.16163063049316406,
0.09196942299604416,
0.35428526997566223,
0.2936033308506012,
-0.009067635983228683,
1.0709627866744995,
-0.41656216979026794,
-0.20385223627090454,
-0.05242176353931427,
-0.18876847624778748,
0.25057196617126465,
0.6384856104850769,
0.0960332602262497,
-0.39022213220596313,
-0.4801534414291382,
0.030193567276000977,
-0.7650858759880066,
-0.20273691415786743,
-0.4782487452030182,
-0.2663431763648987,
0.5859911441802979,
0.5606771111488342,
-0.7089186906814575,
0.5300846099853516,
-0.17246496677398682,
-0.33188948035240173,
0.7435259222984314,
-0.2662256062030792,
0.21709376573562622,
-0.8427719473838806,
-0.022097870707511902,
-0.28480425477027893,
-0.021344676613807678,
-0.4020319879055023,
-0.03936627507209778,
-0.17272289097309113,
-0.1797962635755539,
-0.3029807209968567,
0.3872886002063751,
-0.8390838503837585,
-0.12955918908119202,
-0.1156904548406601,
0.23821906745433807,
0.10257065296173096,
0.07397887110710144,
0.20305678248405457,
0.9742352366447449,
0.6478663682937622,
-0.7269992232322693,
0.8884994387626648,
0.1278049796819687,
-0.16015377640724182,
0.9051287770271301,
-0.541301429271698,
0.3572986423969269,
0.06062537804245949,
0.08219285309314728,
-0.9351829290390015,
-0.3537460267543793,
0.043081462383270264,
-0.30059394240379333,
0.2067839503288269,
-0.19765245914459229,
-0.7514351010322571,
-0.2705761790275574,
-0.4369655251502991,
-0.2172570824623108,
0.23899200558662415,
-0.7914703488349915,
0.7084915637969971,
-0.11474162340164185,
-0.09364895522594452,
-0.31146201491355896,
-0.8166798949241638,
0.4552900195121765,
-0.29830577969551086,
-0.6824295520782471,
0.5760054588317871,
-0.08437476307153702,
-0.5504708290100098,
-0.13654722273349762,
-0.015523451380431652,
-0.13969841599464417,
-0.19414618611335754,
0.07165346294641495,
0.24288158118724823,
-0.1268114298582077,
0.3945606052875519,
0.3989875316619873,
-0.04982197284698486,
-0.0066200434230268,
-0.2848416566848755,
0.24839895963668823,
0.06106865406036377,
-0.6332250237464905,
-0.28283432126045227,
0.4194353222846985,
0.422722190618515,
-0.28312674164772034,
0.6597383618354797,
0.2092476785182953,
-0.16506636142730713,
-0.5103974342346191,
-0.646052360534668,
-0.29483187198638916,
-0.5735602378845215,
0.02884867787361145,
-0.5943586826324463,
-0.6929281949996948,
0.14198656380176544,
-0.7948817610740662,
0.20635494589805603,
0.3075712323188782,
0.4876812994480133,
-0.3976532816886902,
1.207885503768921,
0.3796705901622772,
0.7251612544059753,
0.20748186111450195,
-0.05737294629216194,
0.008619876578450203,
-0.6678575873374939,
-0.5947688221931458,
-0.48456597328186035,
-0.08321791142225266,
-0.37643203139305115,
-0.565244197845459,
0.2384132295846939,
0.32355430722236633,
-0.45797252655029297,
0.1855979710817337,
-1.0621914863586426,
0.744386613368988,
0.4609048664569855,
0.22997303307056427,
0.6453692317008972,
0.1532301902770996,
-0.3752657473087311,
-0.07865090668201447,
-0.5780173540115356,
-0.5230547189712524,
0.8702071309089661,
-0.26076897978782654,
1.0106661319732666,
0.0739162489771843,
0.6660392880439758,
0.4191822409629822,
0.27802976965904236,
-0.5686619877815247,
0.7490811347961426,
0.09934230148792267,
-0.5018610954284668,
-0.2106502652168274,
-0.08827421814203262,
-0.5177581310272217,
0.1155647486448288,
-0.5818551778793335,
-0.5792312622070312,
-0.004428413230925798,
0.43991509079933167,
-0.027807585895061493,
0.3267981708049774,
-0.8499339818954468,
0.47661292552948,
-0.4124061167240143,
-0.9063646197319031,
-0.14406345784664154,
-0.32567837834358215,
0.3288790285587311,
-0.0716114342212677,
-0.09297782927751541,
-0.12598079442977905,
-0.4743812382221222,
0.030787654221057892,
-0.8971304893493652,
0.7279098033905029,
-0.13489115238189697,
0.0043084099888801575,
0.4432666003704071,
0.20851975679397583,
0.8118410706520081,
0.09559021890163422,
-0.8249155879020691,
-0.31510505080223083,
0.14984919130802155,
-0.01797947846353054,
-0.713455319404602,
0.7119494080543518,
-0.15400230884552002,
-0.8306682109832764,
-0.5197427868843079,
-0.5253135561943054,
-0.20106162130832672,
0.19927667081356049,
0.05668042600154877,
0.15924963355064392,
0.04347112402319908,
0.15205751359462738,
0.5368490219116211,
-0.16467085480690002,
0.1673198938369751,
0.5829046964645386,
-0.3757691979408264,
-0.4764188230037689,
0.6838992238044739,
0.16174769401550293,
0.07403594255447388,
0.31189393997192383,
0.0258728489279747,
-0.6628644466400146,
-0.6441190838813782,
-0.7222371697425842,
0.07979381084442139,
-0.5807808041572571,
-0.2463344782590866,
-0.3622016906738281,
0.1632126271724701,
-0.1283501237630844,
-0.416339635848999,
0.03856035694479942,
-0.751089870929718,
-0.5162814855575562,
-0.033278971910476685,
0.8971471190452576,
0.6873377561569214,
0.145424947142601,
0.19806841015815735,
-0.6221514344215393,
0.12668626010417938,
0.08203514665365219,
0.5897308588027954,
-0.13532325625419617,
-0.1449773907661438,
0.1441873162984848,
-0.16653849184513092,
-0.32479527592658997,
-1.0308274030685425,
-0.04415902495384216,
0.47192075848579407,
0.5382806062698364,
-0.0928569808602333,
0.2621467113494873,
1.1454676389694214,
-0.5367597937583923,
1.0437726974487305,
0.09707164019346237,
-0.9933620691299438,
1.116808533668518,
-0.25367745757102966,
0.2754269242286682,
0.5636553168296814,
0.1376083940267563,
-0.15057267248630524,
-0.41749757528305054,
-0.4648323953151703,
-0.7151992917060852,
0.5768079161643982,
0.13396237790584564,
-0.11600212752819061,
-0.16604942083358765,
0.8474194407463074,
0.23307816684246063,
0.39495837688446045,
-0.5587839484214783,
-0.21069858968257904,
-0.05760259926319122,
-0.07498554140329361,
0.5712680816650391,
0.029245076701045036,
0.14683237671852112,
-0.4413470923900604,
0.5781854391098022,
-0.4726705551147461,
0.02497294545173645,
0.26406535506248474,
-0.08862608671188354,
-0.17998304963111877,
0.17567002773284912,
0.2641366720199585,
0.9374551773071289,
0.05612718313932419,
0.03636089339852333,
0.779249370098114,
-0.1459352821111679,
-0.08371355384588242,
-0.055928654968738556,
-0.05118877440690994,
-0.040647514164447784,
0.2702329754829407,
0.5475173592567444,
-0.25393885374069214,
-0.8037773370742798,
0.13964368402957916,
0.175683856010437,
-0.15045279264450073,
-0.2809222638607025,
0.45546314120292664,
0.3265824615955353,
0.30121830105781555,
0.2137611359357834,
-0.04282500594854355,
0.13997206091880798,
-0.6529088020324707,
0.2435382753610611,
0.41300007700920105,
-0.20255820453166962,
0.18444333970546722,
0.7925388813018799,
0.32140612602233887,
-0.6033857464790344,
0.7559190392494202,
0.01272666733711958,
-0.23440751433372498,
0.6149867177009583,
0.7588790655136108,
0.6265818476676941,
-0.0009709669975563884,
-0.15702496469020844,
0.4281402826309204,
0.24563229084014893,
0.07925069332122803,
0.9006978869438171,
-0.252938836812973,
-0.2634546756744385,
-0.4827345311641693,
-0.3794727921485901,
-0.9083465933799744,
-0.3278977572917938,
-0.4948734641075134,
0.6272279620170593,
-0.404911607503891,
-0.2083328813314438,
-0.14273673295974731,
0.030309336259961128,
-0.1563311368227005,
0.18759934604167938,
-0.3233223259449005,
1.2609838247299194,
-0.2595267593860626,
0.851205050945282,
0.8750873804092407,
-0.34344589710235596,
-0.48010748624801636,
-0.30149051547050476,
0.07372161746025085,
-0.6222828030586243,
0.3580133318901062,
0.26918497681617737,
-0.17925114929676056,
0.12623535096645355,
-0.7849295139312744,
-0.44548124074935913,
1.2884055376052856,
0.34696662425994873,
-0.6298309564590454,
0.019874894991517067,
0.3811487555503845,
0.5648823976516724,
-0.4924148619174957,
0.37536826729774475,
0.8618683815002441,
0.6918708682060242,
0.281846821308136,
-0.5786110758781433,
-0.016414029523730278,
-0.3011343479156494,
0.09223565459251404,
0.2293606698513031,
-0.36879292130470276,
0.4877792298793793,
-0.6908525824546814,
-0.10724465548992157,
0.2992221415042877,
0.7514541745185852,
0.9396823644638062,
0.35818445682525635,
0.5310208201408386,
0.30619627237319946,
0.9464150071144104,
-0.4733240008354187,
0.7453555464744568,
-0.12344153225421906,
-0.09359101951122284,
1.1635233163833618,
-0.6952385306358337,
0.93604975938797,
0.6153969168663025,
-0.3322664499282837,
0.8035452365875244,
0.6861146092414856,
-0.27324843406677246,
0.26352933049201965,
0.6165317296981812,
-0.44026175141334534,
-0.4543393850326538,
-0.18254826962947845,
-0.24991454184055328,
0.10509204864501953,
0.6053937077522278,
-0.06130799651145935,
0.009150858037173748,
-0.18288126587867737,
-0.15954987704753876,
0.39593270421028137,
-0.29655221104621887,
1.0974992513656616,
-0.04363004490733147,
-0.8391687870025635,
0.39571982622146606,
-0.20878921449184418,
0.6650296449661255,
-0.5727543830871582,
-0.5595880150794983,
-0.1048000380396843,
0.21949179470539093,
-0.6906914710998535,
-1.2015671730041504,
0.5027039051055908,
0.11025851219892502,
-0.11985141783952713,
-0.10722251981496811,
1.0735890865325928,
-0.7279129028320312,
-0.2307092845439911,
-0.041710034012794495,
0.35390353202819824,
0.2265736609697342,
-0.22840848565101624,
-0.8283040523529053,
0.32227230072021484,
0.04593397676944733,
-0.13581912219524384,
0.019162911921739578,
0.7181123495101929,
-0.053648024797439575,
0.7991886138916016,
0.9299114942550659,
0.21703772246837616,
0.08011329174041748,
0.07650189846754074,
0.8924951553344727,
-0.733537495136261,
-0.35836923122406006,
-0.9239993691444397,
0.7170448899269104,
-0.56634521484375,
-0.07073305547237396,
0.760172963142395,
0.8246071934700012,
0.4041692912578583,
-0.15437737107276917,
0.6508612632751465,
-0.02557813934981823,
0.7164608836174011,
-0.618385374546051,
0.5939995050430298,
-0.6949470639228821,
0.6698008179664612,
0.024096865206956863,
-1.057399868965149,
-0.29038920998573303,
0.4535042941570282,
0.042368385940790176,
-0.01316476333886385,
0.7551212310791016,
1.1273105144500732,
0.29465505480766296,
0.16290061175823212,
-0.04314347729086876,
0.02429981343448162,
0.35494545102119446,
0.2385939657688141,
1.0251250267028809,
-0.11991332471370697,
0.5771778225898743,
-0.12347082793712616,
-0.11179026961326599,
-0.05850237235426903,
-1.3376538753509521,
-1.0828830003738403,
-0.36523714661598206,
-0.4090184271335602,
-0.5485370755195618,
0.25672098994255066,
1.0314754247665405,
0.5317027568817139,
-0.6904544234275818,
-0.25280189514160156,
-0.32650694251060486,
0.34439942240715027,
-0.32383668422698975,
-0.2761578857898712,
0.3528033494949341,
-0.5186248421669006,
-0.5701871514320374,
0.6278278827667236,
0.6385061740875244,
0.018160894513130188,
-0.2772159278392792,
0.1885228306055069,
-0.10654495656490326,
0.27916795015335083,
0.7836446166038513,
-0.007354394998401403,
-0.7761098146438599,
-0.06069180369377136,
0.024964364245533943,
0.06220879405736923,
0.03049442730844021,
0.8389505743980408,
-1.044425368309021,
0.6306682825088501,
0.6069766879081726,
0.37222185730934143,
0.652163028717041,
0.09138738363981247,
0.7857298254966736,
-0.7592997550964355,
-0.16920006275177002,
0.14325284957885742,
-0.0238757636398077,
0.2944211959838867,
-0.5972818732261658,
0.7042396664619446,
0.3686997592449188,
-0.39327239990234375,
-0.9465479850769043,
0.19963251054286957,
-0.9304851293563843,
-0.25066572427749634,
0.9764745235443115,
0.18738359212875366,
-0.15346306562423706,
-0.3993058502674103,
-0.6246142983436584,
0.03595597296953201,
-0.14782796800136566,
0.541698157787323,
0.48296040296554565,
-0.47292360663414,
-0.23367777466773987,
0.06689143180847168,
0.6908524036407471,
0.1525076925754547,
-1.4140357971191406,
0.3161155581474304,
0.49692463874816895,
0.24236759543418884,
-0.14440780878067017,
0.6317269802093506,
-0.23517632484436035,
0.3776242733001709,
0.12280892580747604,
-0.21299244463443756,
-0.43052154779434204,
-0.32889676094055176,
0.03905193880200386,
0.015269596129655838,
0.14879201352596283,
0.4347596764564514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12692v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12692v3 | FormulaReasoning: A Dataset for Formula-Based Numerical Reasoning | 2024-02-20T03:39:49 | 2024-06-12T13:19:55 | Xiao Li, Bolin Zhu, Sichen Liu, Yin Zhu, Yiwei Liu, Gong Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | The application of formulas is a fundamental ability of humans when
addressing numerical reasoning problems. However, existing numerical reasoning
datasets seldom explicitly indicate the formulas employed during the reasoning
steps. To bridge this gap, we construct a dataset for formula-based numerical
reasoning called FormulaReasoning, which consists of 5,420 reasoning-based
questions. We employ it to conduct evaluations of LLMs with size ranging from
7B to over 100B parameters utilizing zero-shot and few-shot chain-of-thought
methods, and we further explore using retrieval-augmented LLMs provided with an
external formula database associated with our dataset. We also experiment with
supervised methods where we divide the reasoning process into formula
generation, parameter extraction, and numerical calculation, and perform data
augmentation. Our empirical findings underscore the significant potential for
improvement in existing models when applied to our complex, formula-driven
FormulaReasoning. | [
-0.22826607525348663,
-0.648829996585846,
0.694035530090332,
0.6126807928085327,
-0.03321000561118126,
0.26032912731170654,
-0.025591885671019554,
-0.21602512896060944,
0.0298633836209774,
0.5350733995437622,
-0.8014134764671326,
-0.47828853130340576,
-0.27118128538131714,
0.4436987042427063,
-0.3276570737361908,
0.8370084166526794,
-0.4544283449649811,
0.39795389771461487,
-0.7049050331115723,
0.08095195889472961,
-0.4598408341407776,
-0.4754787087440491,
-0.13263776898384094,
-0.37994512915611267,
0.6123015880584717,
0.6144580245018005,
0.2289329320192337,
0.7386650443077087,
0.8344985246658325,
0.1342574506998062,
-0.1705515831708908,
0.4332279562950134,
-0.6319783329963684,
0.12947972118854523,
0.16152845323085785,
-0.8422231078147888,
-0.29418057203292847,
0.2805953323841095,
0.7040868401527405,
0.9174970388412476,
-0.18013924360275269,
0.36596670746803284,
-0.5569576621055603,
0.8169586658477783,
-0.8366841673851013,
0.34069162607192993,
-0.4543187916278839,
0.2610222399234772,
-0.11695665121078491,
-0.29575255513191223,
-0.3962932229042053,
-0.6491873264312744,
-0.07562202960252762,
-0.7001967430114746,
0.29417648911476135,
0.2618792653083801,
0.2534850239753723,
0.3264145255088806,
-0.17427362501621246,
-0.5143418908119202,
-0.5960744023323059,
0.7800405025482178,
-0.5097430348396301,
0.297582745552063,
0.4962424635887146,
0.2608047425746918,
-0.28435590863227844,
-0.6945631504058838,
-0.26389697194099426,
-0.4055606722831726,
-0.20986631512641907,
0.17793847620487213,
0.05137138441205025,
-0.08044527471065521,
0.9405282139778137,
0.2022315412759781,
-0.5132321119308472,
-0.36059749126434326,
-0.715748131275177,
-0.19634655117988586,
0.7961552739143372,
0.5053929090499878,
0.20737777650356293,
-0.08493663370609283,
-0.31121352314949036,
0.10514416545629501,
-1.0520118474960327,
0.01077187992632389,
0.21629200875759125,
0.35961008071899414,
0.0007882922072894871,
0.7594942450523376,
-0.4486164450645447,
0.8344598412513733,
-0.20790618658065796,
-0.08865883946418762,
-0.03516487404704094,
-0.5437822937965393,
-0.23782210052013397,
0.3178773522377014,
0.5018757581710815,
0.23387236893177032,
0.3332211375236511,
-0.26140639185905457,
0.025186365470290184,
-0.16093577444553375,
0.16281583905220032,
-1.1287548542022705,
-0.1333598792552948,
0.09592285752296448,
0.08814867585897446,
-0.42812779545783997,
0.10177754610776901,
-0.45862534642219543,
-0.2263149470090866,
-0.5092624425888062,
0.09995617717504501,
-0.19436949491500854,
0.34123238921165466,
0.18636281788349152,
-0.3551925718784332,
-0.09294440597295761,
0.588655412197113,
-0.8111400604248047,
0.32707101106643677,
0.8142966032028198,
0.8699371218681335,
-0.1298690140247345,
-0.03608374297618866,
-0.45286116003990173,
0.11081904172897339,
-0.5905939936637878,
1.1014704704284668,
-0.6816136837005615,
-0.5435208082199097,
-0.3732375204563141,
-0.21367785334587097,
-0.08496270328760147,
-0.7889285087585449,
0.5300318598747253,
-0.5651814341545105,
-0.12118179351091385,
-0.6343381404876709,
-0.7899919152259827,
-0.061129339039325714,
0.301561564207077,
-0.8921023607254028,
0.9051541090011597,
-0.04148849472403526,
-0.4442504942417145,
0.3954036831855774,
-0.8976714611053467,
-0.40860652923583984,
0.11894603073596954,
-0.09526772052049637,
-0.45362794399261475,
0.2922128438949585,
0.3327188193798065,
0.151567280292511,
-0.5002290606498718,
0.038838520646095276,
-0.5108354091644287,
-0.531386137008667,
0.35365498065948486,
-0.43078845739364624,
0.7538059949874878,
0.23609966039657593,
0.17806172370910645,
-0.18810276687145233,
-0.6903195977210999,
0.3050536811351776,
-0.04335995391011238,
-0.11151819676160812,
-0.009532138705253601,
-0.21966446936130524,
-0.5807240605354309,
0.11796344816684723,
0.221302330493927,
-0.5842990875244141,
0.2437780201435089,
-0.10229025036096573,
0.24801519513130188,
0.42982885241508484,
0.21428722143173218,
0.5110924243927002,
-0.46219995617866516,
0.8889623284339905,
0.06541193276643753,
-0.1222672238945961,
-0.19843102991580963,
-0.3031518757343292,
-0.5559328198432922,
-0.1997825801372528,
0.3394410312175751,
0.6083661317825317,
-0.3216760456562042,
-0.13505084812641144,
0.1273583620786667,
-0.3797587752342224,
-0.20680616796016693,
0.3147600293159485,
0.38981837034225464,
0.7841237187385559,
0.3999667167663574,
0.6606965065002441,
-0.7283058762550354,
-0.7714231014251709,
-0.21365417540073395,
-0.11273133754730225,
-0.05229916796088219,
0.45237788558006287,
0.611194908618927,
0.2746398448944092,
0.8872587084770203,
-0.9472686648368835,
-0.0870717391371727,
-0.19334791600704193,
0.26481103897094727,
0.2554209530353546,
0.10114428400993347,
0.28840571641921997,
-0.5469167828559875,
-0.5240265727043152,
-0.12415523082017899,
-1.0732996463775635,
-0.33930084109306335,
-0.09007999300956726,
-0.41842415928840637,
-0.12727686762809753,
0.6266067028045654,
-0.4511289596557617,
0.4476609528064728,
0.09006648510694504,
0.004635173827409744,
0.7475458383560181,
-0.043898116797208786,
0.07791636139154434,
-0.7752770781517029,
-0.03340627998113632,
0.3318718671798706,
-0.03895309194922447,
-0.4923416078090668,
0.07198312878608704,
0.09364166855812073,
0.17755413055419922,
-0.607648491859436,
0.5819202065467834,
-0.5277557969093323,
-0.050691165030002594,
0.053399570286273956,
-0.12346230447292328,
0.17228588461875916,
0.15309670567512512,
0.10746311396360397,
1.2112667560577393,
0.23994676768779755,
-0.35074833035469055,
0.6839724779129028,
0.21501761674880981,
-0.29853391647338867,
0.49299123883247375,
-0.7380117774009705,
-0.008616525679826736,
-0.2596745789051056,
0.3493184447288513,
-0.6702475547790527,
-0.38514113426208496,
0.05301673337817192,
-0.13430672883987427,
-0.12051558494567871,
-0.2269962728023529,
-0.5699532628059387,
-0.45436522364616394,
-0.34938618540763855,
0.5583094358444214,
0.293506920337677,
-0.5344725251197815,
0.3821355402469635,
0.11940796673297882,
-0.3485393524169922,
-0.3929601311683655,
-0.40381819009780884,
-0.17991973459720612,
-0.36657047271728516,
-0.622108519077301,
0.19508521258831024,
-0.23255540430545807,
-0.48692968487739563,
-0.16096580028533936,
-0.2659423053264618,
-0.1929304003715515,
-0.19386187195777893,
0.17682375013828278,
0.40421563386917114,
-0.18127794563770294,
0.1749531328678131,
0.15740688145160675,
-0.09498637169599533,
0.45116496086120605,
0.09466581791639328,
0.03146366402506828,
-0.16758522391319275,
-0.25939029455184937,
-0.3002508282661438,
0.32730069756507874,
0.30938196182250977,
-0.03158587962388992,
0.5244057774543762,
0.04917999729514122,
-0.5728747844696045,
-0.40642836689949036,
-0.3115464150905609,
-0.2074381560087204,
-0.4109271466732025,
0.14034467935562134,
-0.5364465713500977,
-0.7184797525405884,
0.6277883648872375,
-0.05004121735692024,
-0.0019043737556785345,
0.4043901860713959,
0.6921001076698303,
-0.449871689081192,
1.2349315881729126,
0.12710009515285492,
0.26592257618904114,
0.15460729598999023,
-0.36559444665908813,
-0.061260778456926346,
-0.7918983697891235,
-0.659296452999115,
-0.3895328640937805,
-0.20081306993961334,
-0.13373921811580658,
-0.5458345413208008,
0.4152192771434784,
0.3585905432701111,
-0.2727010250091553,
0.18077364563941956,
-0.39925727248191833,
0.8103993535041809,
0.32468611001968384,
0.3370703458786011,
0.5848509669303894,
0.15393076837062836,
-0.16382703185081482,
-0.21688827872276306,
-0.5962933897972107,
-0.28203704953193665,
1.1311607360839844,
0.1496094912290573,
0.9242181181907654,
0.06053485348820686,
0.503845751285553,
0.2697972059249878,
0.9262416958808899,
-0.9051452279090881,
0.518319845199585,
-0.01596400886774063,
-0.6987153887748718,
-0.263653963804245,
-0.940777599811554,
-0.3874668478965759,
0.10631353408098221,
0.05176173150539398,
-0.47736266255378723,
-0.19730257987976074,
0.04698656499385834,
-0.4125920534133911,
-0.0036040106788277626,
-0.6780902147293091,
0.5991749167442322,
-0.38465672731399536,
-0.33433520793914795,
0.06557254493236542,
-0.273278146982193,
0.5501014590263367,
-0.3334048390388489,
-0.06499173492193222,
-0.20799340307712555,
0.20468257367610931,
0.718338668346405,
-0.9663204550743103,
0.6352629065513611,
0.0224158838391304,
-0.17125484347343445,
0.5908533930778503,
-0.006684723310172558,
0.30626779794692993,
0.28120699524879456,
-0.25561514496803284,
-0.19290690124034882,
0.2155337780714035,
-0.3894343674182892,
-1.1336857080459595,
0.5789946913719177,
-0.27727824449539185,
-0.5670869946479797,
-0.5009421110153198,
-0.914841890335083,
-0.3140362501144409,
0.041260913014411926,
0.05455983430147171,
0.3486398458480835,
-0.03303401917219162,
0.15011164546012878,
0.4696316719055176,
0.40613287687301636,
0.1379670351743698,
0.5057758688926697,
-0.09768951684236526,
-0.4789396822452545,
0.877117931842804,
0.2601681351661682,
0.1892068088054657,
0.3862398862838745,
0.2481263130903244,
-0.7289016246795654,
-0.3378048837184906,
-0.4561585485935211,
0.4176812767982483,
-0.5145288109779358,
-0.4406393766403198,
-0.21306346356868744,
-0.3191746473312378,
-0.018717756494879723,
-0.08756963908672333,
-0.06161406636238098,
-0.5528357625007629,
-0.39492127299308777,
-0.3506720960140228,
0.718529462814331,
0.6738428473472595,
-0.04643256589770317,
0.03439698740839958,
-0.6104709506034851,
0.3221185803413391,
0.31714025139808655,
0.45974400639533997,
-0.14418597519397736,
-0.40665432810783386,
-0.17700153589248657,
0.44230449199676514,
-0.16021661460399628,
-0.6557573080062866,
0.3131279945373535,
0.04339969530701637,
0.4443669021129608,
0.2357044816017151,
-0.025890473276376724,
1.082641839981079,
-0.5689366459846497,
0.256944864988327,
0.1156315878033638,
-0.6843746304512024,
0.5031716823577881,
-0.24700652062892914,
0.06794116646051407,
0.4702428877353668,
0.45829689502716064,
-0.25105413794517517,
-0.016330687329173088,
-0.4420791566371918,
-0.18228890001773834,
0.592524528503418,
0.3194226622581482,
-0.08117552101612091,
-0.06120266765356064,
0.8401670455932617,
-0.15155723690986633,
0.11589660495519638,
-0.1197928711771965,
-0.12268620729446411,
0.059215713292360306,
-0.21110861003398895,
0.2159654200077057,
0.013751275837421417,
-0.28094038367271423,
-0.6026651263237,
0.4514982998371124,
-0.31639617681503296,
0.025398705154657364,
-0.012524785473942757,
-0.11345280706882477,
-0.1765943169593811,
-0.04689168557524681,
0.9165724515914917,
0.6392443180084229,
-0.48587965965270996,
-0.02808787301182747,
0.3920285403728485,
-0.5650059580802917,
0.19269001483917236,
0.19951759278774261,
-0.29566070437431335,
-0.11037617921829224,
0.2664159834384918,
0.5973804593086243,
0.1592279076576233,
-0.917301595211029,
0.2364898920059204,
-0.03757351264357567,
-0.5466294884681702,
-0.3671196699142456,
0.26343104243278503,
0.17357032001018524,
0.06652714312076569,
0.3752168118953705,
-0.2280157059431076,
0.18471291661262512,
-0.3504475951194763,
0.3920944631099701,
0.39482444524765015,
-0.3409329056739807,
-0.18739424645900726,
0.7192374467849731,
-0.2450091391801834,
-0.1464734524488449,
0.7268682718276978,
-0.16929787397384644,
-0.34764209389686584,
1.0172377824783325,
0.703705906867981,
0.34935078024864197,
0.28146424889564514,
0.35033097863197327,
0.38617148995399475,
-0.054152172058820724,
-0.35999244451522827,
0.5521875619888306,
-0.04790003225207329,
-0.6061743497848511,
-0.6735740900039673,
-0.6307021379470825,
-0.8430238962173462,
-0.1384345442056656,
-0.8371123671531677,
0.24665021896362305,
-0.574641764163971,
-0.11436934024095535,
0.21121029555797577,
0.15029850602149963,
-0.5254769921302795,
0.17052148282527924,
-0.12512357532978058,
1.1285724639892578,
-0.7134143114089966,
0.146023690700531,
0.6323670148849487,
-0.7014272212982178,
-0.7686737179756165,
-0.3174380660057068,
-0.06396925449371338,
-0.7770168781280518,
1.0175771713256836,
0.08293227851390839,
-0.1261887401342392,
-0.07359473407268524,
-0.8711079955101013,
-0.6642791032791138,
1.0472365617752075,
0.3958836793899536,
-0.33238300681114197,
-0.08173386752605438,
0.5531752705574036,
0.5438165664672852,
-0.5384631752967834,
0.3422781229019165,
0.7591952681541443,
0.43611639738082886,
0.7508058547973633,
-0.49193114042282104,
0.04668419435620308,
-0.2916092574596405,
-0.19276143610477448,
0.1881646364927292,
-0.4925139844417572,
0.613227367401123,
-0.6480312943458557,
0.08247610926628113,
0.23675154149532318,
0.5008944869041443,
0.9072319269180298,
0.4990064203739166,
0.05575277656316757,
0.6840593814849854,
0.8253938555717468,
-0.2126171886920929,
0.9925038814544678,
-0.046176984906196594,
0.35447320342063904,
0.9618312120437622,
-0.35273298621177673,
0.7802802920341492,
0.26029548048973083,
-0.5155332088470459,
0.40728622674942017,
0.5329668521881104,
-0.054885659366846085,
0.3062671422958374,
0.5851690769195557,
-0.5194392204284668,
-0.48068514466285706,
-0.17367759346961975,
-0.20167480409145355,
0.22601866722106934,
0.6712779998779297,
-0.31103357672691345,
-0.44363901019096375,
-0.43483051657676697,
-0.0019929076079279184,
-0.11569693684577942,
-0.41482195258140564,
0.6705250144004822,
0.33503788709640503,
-0.49454236030578613,
0.49438005685806274,
-0.15778595209121704,
-0.02916708029806614,
-0.271218478679657,
-0.4573461413383484,
-0.37520283460617065,
-0.0945267528295517,
-0.3785698115825653,
-0.9207765460014343,
0.35807791352272034,
0.24092884361743927,
-0.3942154049873352,
-0.16578979790210724,
0.4250979423522949,
-0.25544971227645874,
-1.0957287549972534,
-0.3463975787162781,
0.6186406016349792,
0.3155156075954437,
-0.061920322477817535,
-0.4729170501232147,
-0.10710476338863373,
-0.0852334201335907,
0.06211192160844803,
0.08343814313411713,
0.5000898241996765,
-0.3004477322101593,
0.907868504524231,
0.9910086989402771,
0.16971221566200256,
0.1434483826160431,
0.37662217020988464,
0.8938360214233398,
-0.8962253332138062,
-0.15117236971855164,
-0.8922502994537354,
0.24977783858776093,
-0.1589438021183014,
-0.20558449625968933,
0.7176794409751892,
0.8373798131942749,
0.4277961552143097,
0.05935625731945038,
0.7466616034507751,
0.6142048835754395,
0.6705213785171509,
-0.6912797689437866,
0.34204572439193726,
-0.3866300582885742,
0.5398885011672974,
-0.13474693894386292,
-0.7767645716667175,
-0.735567033290863,
0.7363423705101013,
-0.5500519871711731,
0.0709649994969368,
0.4720621705055237,
0.6778581142425537,
0.09437435865402222,
0.4591907858848572,
0.1666320562362671,
0.02252526767551899,
0.2909385859966278,
0.31740278005599976,
0.9224797487258911,
-0.15596750378608704,
0.32996922731399536,
-0.26422059535980225,
-0.10547661781311035,
-0.20500890910625458,
-1.011391282081604,
-0.8540446162223816,
0.03679657727479935,
-0.1619631052017212,
-0.3418465852737427,
0.043788325041532516,
0.7888323068618774,
0.5831020474433899,
-0.8060194849967957,
-0.12173665314912796,
-0.5228390693664551,
0.29649800062179565,
0.07086550444364548,
-0.26117563247680664,
0.16518276929855347,
-0.32368457317352295,
-0.45615702867507935,
0.4163168668746948,
0.2385452538728714,
0.10996492952108383,
-0.39712756872177124,
0.03632538765668869,
0.20280484855175018,
0.19475752115249634,
0.7125954627990723,
0.5156141519546509,
-0.3681497871875763,
0.09286243468523026,
0.49669671058654785,
0.039103202521800995,
0.11220864951610565,
0.911242663860321,
-0.8089317083358765,
0.33884692192077637,
0.5199058651924133,
0.496505469083786,
0.6904878616333008,
0.48378047347068787,
0.6503185033798218,
-0.6625790596008301,
-0.0938262864947319,
0.26549145579338074,
0.28278884291648865,
0.08284468948841095,
-0.3139773905277252,
0.5196317434310913,
0.37297871708869934,
-0.2466297596693039,
-0.947364330291748,
0.14585000276565552,
-0.8499053120613098,
0.07403532415628433,
0.9412078857421875,
0.14513443410396576,
-0.263654500246048,
0.16203300654888153,
-0.06384056061506271,
-0.15930140018463135,
-0.5040656328201294,
0.6200639605522156,
0.7842285633087158,
-0.7161466479301453,
-0.2319776564836502,
-0.5720689296722412,
0.4880009889602661,
0.2075556218624115,
-1.2478108406066895,
0.09247827529907227,
0.6168434619903564,
0.280085951089859,
0.03127940744161606,
0.49309679865837097,
-0.23639270663261414,
0.34464776515960693,
0.041179776191711426,
-0.47924724221229553,
-0.22693173587322235,
-0.4959595799446106,
0.013945766724646091,
0.14574410021305084,
-0.2948746383190155,
0.26431846618652344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12691v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12691v2 | Tree-Planted Transformers: Unidirectional Transformer Language Models with Implicit Syntactic Supervision | 2024-02-20T03:37:24 | 2024-06-06T13:16:16 | Ryo Yoshida, Taiga Someya, Yohei Oseki | cs.CL | cs.CL | Syntactic Language Models (SLMs) can be trained efficiently to reach
relatively high performance; however, they have trouble with inference
efficiency due to the explicit generation of syntactic structures. In this
paper, we propose a new method dubbed tree-planting: instead of explicitly
generating syntactic structures, we "plant" trees into attention weights of
unidirectional Transformer LMs to implicitly reflect syntactic structures of
natural language. Specifically, unidirectional Transformer LMs trained with
tree-planting will be called Tree-Planted Transformers (TPT), which inherit the
training efficiency from SLMs without changing the inference efficiency of
their underlying Transformer LMs. Targeted syntactic evaluations on the
SyntaxGym benchmark demonstrated that TPTs, despite the lack of explicit
generation of syntactic structures, significantly outperformed not only vanilla
Transformer LMs but also various SLMs that generate hundreds of syntactic
structures in parallel. This result suggests that TPTs can learn human-like
syntactic knowledge as data-efficiently as SLMs while maintaining the modeling
space of Transformer LMs unchanged. | [
0.026424331590533257,
-0.6394068002700806,
0.4938911497592926,
0.38407519459724426,
-0.1733328253030777,
0.38990479707717896,
-0.369087815284729,
-0.3319694697856903,
-0.002178422175347805,
0.488544762134552,
-0.5122644305229187,
-0.5720897912979126,
-0.5740129947662354,
0.07589640468358994,
-0.585814893245697,
0.9524790644645691,
-0.12044478952884674,
-0.0734320729970932,
0.06004723533987999,
0.06657841056585312,
-0.07246895134449005,
-0.07970206439495087,
-0.22020110487937927,
-0.33277907967567444,
0.5024170875549316,
0.19375966489315033,
0.8208680748939514,
0.711410641670227,
0.11820490658283234,
0.4036152958869934,
-0.17043761909008026,
-0.15618254244327545,
-0.06384404748678207,
0.0006308499141596258,
-0.09754404425621033,
-0.6257482767105103,
0.014437477104365826,
-0.2661251425743103,
0.7882834672927856,
1.0355156660079956,
-0.23732641339302063,
0.18715552985668182,
0.1757788509130478,
0.4420791268348694,
-0.42249393463134766,
0.49789920449256897,
-0.792094886302948,
0.13818617165088654,
-0.10796370357275009,
-0.33619657158851624,
-0.7635952830314636,
-0.4688343405723572,
0.2373303472995758,
-0.48280981183052063,
0.43770942091941833,
-0.026477426290512085,
0.7276859283447266,
0.4649241864681244,
-0.5024384260177612,
0.22431953251361847,
-0.8540164232254028,
0.7789815068244934,
-0.5685981512069702,
0.27835673093795776,
-0.10963411629199982,
0.4849315285682678,
-0.09902635216712952,
-0.7880253791809082,
-0.2620353400707245,
-0.2017257660627365,
-0.4734671413898468,
-0.0357479564845562,
-0.28811171650886536,
0.2899923622608185,
0.39654332399368286,
0.11377127468585968,
-0.23338089883327484,
-0.06131308153271675,
-0.1247328668832779,
0.11015313863754272,
0.17616070806980133,
-0.2348662167787552,
0.27823781967163086,
-0.23218122124671936,
-0.3947858214378357,
-0.27614638209342957,
-0.6951177716255188,
0.003619093680754304,
-0.04273904860019684,
0.5379312634468079,
0.16681644320487976,
0.585519552230835,
0.023319436237215996,
0.4654272496700287,
0.11230558156967163,
-0.2364632487297058,
0.16332148015499115,
-0.4276108741760254,
-0.3924558758735657,
0.06963146477937698,
0.6048237085342407,
0.18057923018932343,
0.6965437531471252,
-0.6919519305229187,
-0.2241951823234558,
0.3867456018924713,
0.442495197057724,
-0.5239457488059998,
-0.18726889789104462,
-0.1850454956293106,
-0.1476864218711853,
-0.43474698066711426,
-0.1965622752904892,
-0.7000695466995239,
-0.023831145837903023,
-0.13663597404956818,
0.14050842821598053,
-0.2994028627872467,
-0.4087409973144531,
-0.22667430341243744,
-0.00806733313947916,
0.16606108844280243,
0.2603149712085724,
-1.0045664310455322,
0.491766095161438,
0.5647625923156738,
0.7646413445472717,
0.0717943012714386,
-0.22688384354114532,
-0.14302028715610504,
0.5515506863594055,
-0.2917346656322479,
0.7836565971374512,
-0.39499208331108093,
-0.13368239998817444,
0.30425214767456055,
0.10199841856956482,
-0.2869722843170166,
-0.30035024881362915,
0.5495374798774719,
-0.20832322537899017,
0.3684690594673157,
0.01627556048333645,
-0.2041168361902237,
-0.26110130548477173,
-0.00755942240357399,
-0.29275500774383545,
1.145480990409851,
0.4881042540073395,
-0.8925918936729431,
0.6290041208267212,
-0.5866762399673462,
-0.5178332328796387,
0.21971142292022705,
-0.3243640661239624,
-0.402801513671875,
0.1258377581834793,
0.23323257267475128,
0.2563389837741852,
-0.15902280807495117,
0.6085834503173828,
0.024907192215323448,
-0.03908461704850197,
-0.2067444920539856,
-0.24021971225738525,
0.8431268334388733,
-0.19413894414901733,
-0.7156480550765991,
0.2960796058177948,
-0.39460626244544983,
0.24984875321388245,
0.15215753018856049,
-0.12845945358276367,
-0.3359110951423645,
0.148167684674263,
0.12391388416290283,
0.15567508339881897,
-0.0324423685669899,
-0.7046200037002563,
0.2900390923023224,
-0.7529869675636292,
0.5530648827552795,
0.5777720212936401,
-0.05479923635721207,
0.7310670018196106,
-0.1528092473745346,
0.5755748152732849,
-0.02507001720368862,
0.11710277199745178,
-0.36926957964897156,
-0.10773707181215286,
-0.9910721778869629,
0.02103240042924881,
0.20106081664562225,
0.21082502603530884,
-0.6952730417251587,
0.4042123556137085,
-0.29477083683013916,
-0.36328423023223877,
-0.4294353425502777,
0.07431042939424515,
0.6130688786506653,
0.4626217186450958,
0.3554181158542633,
-0.10858523100614548,
-0.6182323098182678,
-0.9223268628120422,
-0.42770707607269287,
-0.24510417878627777,
0.09156086295843124,
0.19909675419330597,
0.12284640222787857,
0.07483824342489243,
1.0569711923599243,
-0.4927949905395508,
-0.36143380403518677,
-0.46171221137046814,
0.18998292088508606,
0.07970032840967178,
0.41135087609291077,
0.584907054901123,
-0.4490112066268921,
-0.7912773489952087,
-0.21890927851200104,
-0.4789204001426697,
-0.3325362205505371,
-0.023573346436023712,
0.04628331586718559,
0.4844055771827698,
0.5208093523979187,
-1.1521719694137573,
0.07840054482221603,
0.31293314695358276,
-0.2847709059715271,
0.3784253001213074,
-0.09648995101451874,
-0.5613633990287781,
-1.093207597732544,
-0.028297577053308487,
-0.1962549239397049,
-0.4451393187046051,
-0.6433915495872498,
0.030008714646100998,
0.1384972184896469,
0.10590770095586777,
-0.44353529810905457,
0.11113645881414413,
-0.8591941595077515,
-0.30810487270355225,
-0.08117486536502838,
-0.03718079254031181,
-0.013133687898516655,
0.931073784828186,
-0.04389137402176857,
0.6295028924942017,
0.6385844349861145,
-0.2503853142261505,
0.002260118257254362,
0.008372664451599121,
-0.27840015292167664,
0.17903484404087067,
-0.5073272585868835,
0.02160070464015007,
-0.24714207649230957,
0.37272724509239197,
-0.8758835196495056,
0.058214250952005386,
0.257198303937912,
-0.12833398580551147,
0.5618153810501099,
-0.3154449164867401,
-0.632047176361084,
-0.4001276195049286,
-0.19091796875,
0.16709008812904358,
0.6521979570388794,
-0.6719949245452881,
0.734399139881134,
0.26751306653022766,
0.025710830464959145,
-0.40864649415016174,
-0.6354049444198608,
-0.002774393418803811,
-0.4216614067554474,
-0.42903169989585876,
0.30899086594581604,
0.40067246556282043,
-0.15269316732883453,
0.10933058708906174,
-0.24635900557041168,
0.2528698742389679,
0.05029739439487457,
0.40369105339050293,
-0.03721878305077553,
-0.4665432572364807,
0.30348891019821167,
-0.08003533631563187,
-0.13966168463230133,
0.4083763062953949,
-0.7956116795539856,
0.42148488759994507,
-0.12538792192935944,
-0.2660793662071228,
-0.2659313380718231,
0.19547013938426971,
0.3431801497936249,
-0.2460722029209137,
0.4170335829257965,
0.09933038055896759,
-0.25390681624412537,
-0.44483962655067444,
-0.34840333461761475,
-0.1685495227575302,
-0.4848044514656067,
0.23227068781852722,
-0.13438308238983154,
-0.6533823013305664,
-0.3874167799949646,
-0.29906073212623596,
0.3692200481891632,
0.5826500654220581,
0.3041257858276367,
-0.2155066430568695,
1.2384635210037231,
0.8249030113220215,
0.0033340370282530785,
0.563327431678772,
-0.343961238861084,
0.08452928811311722,
-0.5639210343360901,
-0.2912265360355377,
-0.6750947833061218,
-0.2983332574367523,
-0.5735476016998291,
-0.5011178255081177,
0.06528307497501373,
0.06355679035186768,
-0.28566569089889526,
0.621334433555603,
-0.6437062621116638,
0.3565610349178314,
0.6169729232788086,
-0.1354786604642868,
0.5146421790122986,
0.1590861678123474,
-0.23114396631717682,
-0.007871649228036404,
-0.6790284514427185,
-0.6704609990119934,
0.8584880828857422,
0.37716877460479736,
0.6864809989929199,
-0.017716262489557266,
0.3859850764274597,
-0.06708678603172302,
0.607720136642456,
-0.7525793313980103,
0.5329450368881226,
-0.09198206663131714,
-0.17735347151756287,
-0.3587031662464142,
-0.1419321894645691,
-0.8457460403442383,
0.11265905201435089,
0.13169606029987335,
-0.9347087740898132,
-0.12786157429218292,
0.3339427709579468,
-0.18387942016124725,
0.37916019558906555,
-1.0050607919692993,
0.8633178472518921,
-0.4470614492893219,
-0.12802442908287048,
-0.0955846756696701,
-0.7351516485214233,
0.23375888168811798,
-0.013400709256529808,
-0.13731414079666138,
-0.09174152463674545,
-0.012858103960752487,
0.5366527438163757,
-0.3558904826641083,
1.0697921514511108,
-0.5905954837799072,
-0.08093959093093872,
0.3043103516101837,
0.10592519491910934,
0.6641896963119507,
-0.22476555407047272,
0.41784602403640747,
-0.07012894004583359,
-0.20135341584682465,
-0.21625415980815887,
-0.8280126452445984,
0.4321783483028412,
-0.6173736453056335,
-0.8448916077613831,
-0.4260685443878174,
-0.7714995741844177,
-0.3240799903869629,
0.3991762399673462,
-0.03856077790260315,
0.07493100315332413,
-0.13338206708431244,
0.15933851897716522,
0.30132371187210083,
0.1849866807460785,
0.7411223649978638,
0.5093711614608765,
-0.33617478609085083,
-0.05498471111059189,
0.4326799511909485,
0.0713263750076294,
0.34893545508384705,
0.6270619034767151,
0.19434085488319397,
-0.4907068908214569,
-0.46057820320129395,
-0.3463132977485657,
0.22412917017936707,
-0.2703961730003357,
-0.34485262632369995,
-1.0145114660263062,
-0.29258278012275696,
-0.07987690716981888,
0.08803147822618484,
-0.35094502568244934,
-0.5683225393295288,
0.0732928216457367,
-0.1851656436920166,
0.47355377674102783,
0.8607023358345032,
0.38526102900505066,
0.8508129715919495,
-0.4539532959461212,
0.09101083874702454,
0.1656409502029419,
0.33480721712112427,
-0.04300887510180473,
-0.2803727388381958,
-0.06392481178045273,
0.218694269657135,
-0.6248577833175659,
-0.7668514251708984,
0.4171563982963562,
0.25824034214019775,
0.271201491355896,
0.4711199402809143,
-0.22569991648197174,
0.5281878709793091,
-0.5930227637290955,
0.3082207143306732,
0.23603329062461853,
-0.7368026375770569,
0.41375598311424255,
-0.4225679636001587,
0.48659586906433105,
0.45770499110221863,
0.19382359087467194,
-0.39262107014656067,
-0.781208336353302,
-0.8799988627433777,
-0.7204545140266418,
1.0538103580474854,
0.2080332636833191,
0.06056409701704979,
0.07801559567451477,
-0.06056969612836838,
-0.07520245760679245,
0.3130759596824646,
-0.9016634225845337,
0.05404128506779671,
-0.3602263331413269,
-0.20856688916683197,
-0.3583236038684845,
-0.21583688259124756,
-0.0724850744009018,
-0.2317226082086563,
0.5310997366905212,
-0.2311560958623886,
-0.021389065310359,
0.04970300570130348,
-0.21483807265758514,
-0.5787477493286133,
0.46711796522140503,
0.10665581375360489,
0.39822208881378174,
-0.23214012384414673,
0.6908847689628601,
0.12058352679014206,
-0.07016714662313461,
0.2520628273487091,
-0.08127691596746445,
-0.7150532603263855,
0.14358662068843842,
0.2717536985874176,
0.8434200286865234,
0.6057958602905273,
-0.407028466463089,
0.3648603856563568,
0.1926453560590744,
-0.07869426906108856,
-0.3938368856906891,
0.09791222959756851,
0.48840412497520447,
0.305440217256546,
0.28672704100608826,
0.2021077275276184,
-0.23662765324115753,
-0.4990397095680237,
0.2459782361984253,
0.5739090442657471,
-0.3696093261241913,
-0.4736520051956177,
0.5888649821281433,
0.138349711894989,
-0.5578243732452393,
0.5595897436141968,
0.1790713220834732,
-0.7007060647010803,
0.553322970867157,
0.906414806842804,
1.0570439100265503,
-0.2403894066810608,
0.4281117618083954,
0.3024502992630005,
0.4049585461616516,
-0.1313227266073227,
-0.00046497653238475323,
-0.43336281180381775,
-0.5614604949951172,
-0.525442898273468,
-0.7032800912857056,
-0.16297169029712677,
-0.09078216552734375,
-0.3383525311946869,
0.20112639665603638,
-0.4314606189727783,
-0.11301009356975555,
0.07974330335855484,
-0.16345933079719543,
-0.430997759103775,
0.0030246058013290167,
-0.19862507283687592,
1.0368857383728027,
-1.02871572971344,
1.0294082164764404,
0.656903088092804,
-0.2893788814544678,
-1.0324877500534058,
0.3741685450077057,
-0.4458495080471039,
-0.686809778213501,
0.6855114102363586,
0.3823818862438202,
-0.09487929195165634,
0.4005384147167206,
-0.366780161857605,
-0.8526269793510437,
1.0962942838668823,
0.695648193359375,
-0.4625522792339325,
-0.42382174730300903,
0.4744604527950287,
0.7608317732810974,
-0.28283360600471497,
0.4741266965866089,
0.6296249628067017,
0.4518369734287262,
0.09661155194044113,
-0.6944964528083801,
0.049420565366744995,
-0.12935438752174377,
0.2093266397714615,
0.6581032276153564,
-0.5445297956466675,
0.41263261437416077,
-0.29280877113342285,
-0.711649477481842,
-0.12478312104940414,
0.6211293339729309,
0.02062445506453514,
-0.11751241981983185,
0.908723771572113,
0.6489162445068359,
0.25854936242103577,
-0.2923020124435425,
0.9459924101829529,
-0.4058186411857605,
0.2696170210838318,
1.1943817138671875,
-0.0285043828189373,
0.5879579782485962,
0.7709715366363525,
-0.39988017082214355,
0.5129580497741699,
0.37922245264053345,
-0.0964704304933548,
0.4816233515739441,
0.23279322683811188,
-0.11430943757295609,
-0.061708077788352966,
-0.8069080114364624,
-0.03457977995276451,
0.31037625670433044,
-0.05470027029514313,
-0.40687283873558044,
-0.6841090321540833,
-0.3190203607082367,
0.050915323197841644,
0.27447426319122314,
0.034067731350660324,
0.7258592844009399,
0.18810154497623444,
-1.0314959287643433,
0.5802729725837708,
0.0258078183978796,
0.4400968849658966,
-0.6468073129653931,
-0.0466306135058403,
-0.2746579945087433,
0.2114657312631607,
-0.2684749364852905,
-0.6240987181663513,
0.5169235467910767,
0.0683935135602951,
-0.04000989720225334,
-0.8790026307106018,
0.5315595269203186,
-0.6666805148124695,
-0.5297911167144775,
0.6636478304862976,
0.35727447271347046,
0.026789439842104912,
-0.12327811121940613,
-0.43080204725265503,
-0.5083383321762085,
-0.0635211169719696,
-0.29246699810028076,
0.08837351202964783,
0.433885782957077,
-0.3110690712928772,
0.5284646153450012,
0.4754221439361572,
0.18420283496379852,
0.1873045563697815,
0.4482800364494324,
0.8451810479164124,
-0.6434357762336731,
-0.2433207929134369,
-0.8632174730300903,
0.27503180503845215,
0.10814562439918518,
0.039773110300302505,
0.861864447593689,
0.6147410869598389,
0.8194183707237244,
-0.10473742336034775,
0.555304229259491,
-0.040490053594112396,
0.47472909092903137,
-0.24949027597904205,
0.44428750872612,
-0.33841434121131897,
0.04400988668203354,
-0.2688944935798645,
-1.1925201416015625,
-0.09646265208721161,
0.27847206592559814,
-0.13848188519477844,
0.11341764032840729,
0.9251601696014404,
0.7728750109672546,
-0.23212748765945435,
-0.09221187233924866,
0.08085861057043076,
0.6419458985328674,
0.041173435747623444,
0.7588274478912354,
0.7724323272705078,
-0.16199693083763123,
0.6735520362854004,
-0.4749564528465271,
-0.11748621612787247,
0.24144887924194336,
-0.8824062943458557,
-0.8592998385429382,
-0.36819371581077576,
-0.11894745379686356,
0.09338317066431046,
0.1194654032588005,
0.8482698202133179,
0.5226448178291321,
-0.808412492275238,
-0.17650797963142395,
-0.9351698160171509,
0.05660996958613396,
-0.1581367701292038,
-0.26896458864212036,
0.5520960688591003,
-0.4739386737346649,
-0.8870849609375,
0.5177851915359497,
0.33839139342308044,
0.17889481782913208,
-0.5841980576515198,
0.02998778410255909,
-0.33997592329978943,
-0.36676162481307983,
0.29917749762535095,
0.18641404807567596,
-0.8780733346939087,
-0.2598702013492584,
-0.034070879220962524,
-0.25720375776290894,
0.2978415787220001,
0.9213838577270508,
-1.033991813659668,
0.23802129924297333,
0.38857799768447876,
0.4611743092536926,
0.5398930907249451,
0.23604989051818848,
0.7852371335029602,
-1.0913830995559692,
0.26793423295021057,
0.28423574566841125,
0.36055850982666016,
0.4365805387496948,
-0.17922736704349518,
0.48726388812065125,
0.1900203675031662,
-0.16577748954296112,
-0.8100448250770569,
0.14473597705364227,
-0.8409315943717957,
-0.05271993950009346,
1.2602123022079468,
-0.0772763192653656,
-0.31394049525260925,
-0.09100167453289032,
-0.21060773730278015,
0.7532282471656799,
-0.3366204500198364,
0.7747344970703125,
0.1937815248966217,
0.2632770836353302,
-0.28092512488365173,
-0.3022821545600891,
0.652064859867096,
0.9777740240097046,
-0.906012237071991,
0.31991463899612427,
0.10119616240262985,
0.18514826893806458,
0.3202243745326996,
0.5308166146278381,
-0.03247356042265892,
-0.030597355216741562,
-0.15304826200008392,
0.40387192368507385,
-0.010349600575864315,
-0.5288611650466919,
-0.13835914433002472,
0.13611088693141937,
0.26486659049987793,
-0.08398246765136719
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12690v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12690v2 | Simpson's Paradox and the Accuracy-Fluency Tradeoff in Translation | 2024-02-20T03:37:16 | 2024-06-10T05:59:26 | Zheng Wei Lim, Ekaterina Vylomova, Trevor Cohn, Charles Kemp | cs.CL | cs.CL | A good translation should be faithful to the source and should respect the
norms of the target language. We address a theoretical puzzle about the
relationship between these objectives. On one hand, intuition and some prior
work suggest that accuracy and fluency should trade off against each other, and
that capturing every detail of the source can only be achieved at the cost of
fluency. On the other hand, quality assessment researchers often suggest that
accuracy and fluency are highly correlated and difficult for human raters to
distinguish (Callison-Burch et al., 2007). We show that the tension between
these views is an instance of Simpson's paradox, and that accuracy and fluency
are positively correlated at the level of the corpus but trade off at the level
of individual source segments. We further suggest that the relationship between
accuracy and fluency is best evaluated at the segment (or sentence) level, and
that the trade off between these dimensions has implications both for assessing
translation quality and developing improved MT systems. | [
-0.30900469422340393,
-0.7037736773490906,
0.7011972069740295,
0.17684833705425262,
-0.02407652884721756,
0.05298649147152901,
-0.05717218667268753,
-0.50002521276474,
0.25859642028808594,
0.17195278406143188,
-0.2930295765399933,
0.31335335969924927,
-0.9430932402610779,
0.2132929414510727,
-0.5058963894844055,
0.9004082083702087,
-0.4281716048717499,
-0.10090161859989166,
-0.4970928132534027,
-0.28989771008491516,
-0.6523217558860779,
-0.5204051733016968,
-0.426075279712677,
-0.30036064982414246,
0.5400175452232361,
0.3050670325756073,
1.3830498456954956,
0.4960913360118866,
0.6869911551475525,
0.2605760991573334,
-0.13023711740970612,
-0.11739600449800491,
-0.54132479429245,
0.2303570806980133,
-0.2972263991832733,
-0.5931801199913025,
-0.24960678815841675,
0.15064892172813416,
0.6447932124137878,
0.8650310635566711,
-0.10289979726076126,
0.10949237644672394,
0.2028476595878601,
0.942984938621521,
-0.5433589220046997,
0.09103050827980042,
-0.4379097819328308,
-0.08895646035671234,
-0.48059746623039246,
-0.3783417344093323,
-0.12880097329616547,
-0.36007657647132874,
-0.013413737528026104,
-0.8027657270431519,
0.2020576447248459,
0.13540887832641602,
1.274280071258545,
0.3963303565979004,
-0.505377471446991,
-0.19132943451404572,
-0.5767663717269897,
0.7709532380104065,
-0.4857522249221802,
0.09377595782279968,
0.4981101453304291,
0.22310908138751984,
-0.29247355461120605,
-0.5569804906845093,
-0.6344740986824036,
0.04803739860653877,
-0.02613205648958683,
0.446899950504303,
-0.4577977657318115,
-0.36672547459602356,
0.37250202894210815,
0.6420503258705139,
-0.4998864531517029,
-0.3710782527923584,
-0.3446944057941437,
-0.11963315308094025,
0.5156835317611694,
0.34621742367744446,
0.41367197036743164,
-0.12090375274419785,
-0.36755532026290894,
-0.15166950225830078,
-0.24426807463169098,
0.41178417205810547,
0.41841956973075867,
0.26387763023376465,
0.21598365902900696,
0.639850378036499,
-0.21699076890945435,
0.5341790318489075,
-0.008537018671631813,
-0.010538983158767223,
0.35953056812286377,
-0.6171121001243591,
0.1143370196223259,
-0.24773697555065155,
0.8945698738098145,
0.39164477586746216,
0.5479475259780884,
-0.16724348068237305,
-0.21058595180511475,
0.18387165665626526,
0.4326673150062561,
-0.42651498317718506,
0.11245044320821762,
0.12562958896160126,
-0.43204987049102783,
-0.14416584372520447,
0.4145033061504364,
-0.5861206650733948,
0.5121006369590759,
-0.26970410346984863,
0.5950685143470764,
-0.45861107110977173,
-0.18052823841571808,
0.3747403025627136,
-0.21106627583503723,
-0.3650665879249573,
0.09282755106687546,
-0.8513805866241455,
0.34824272990226746,
0.6056300401687622,
0.8449472784996033,
-0.15904243290424347,
-0.399896502494812,
-0.5179338455200195,
0.2329426109790802,
-0.6358985304832458,
0.5836853384971619,
-0.5632833242416382,
-0.395914226770401,
-0.123716339468956,
-0.12921476364135742,
-0.342339426279068,
-0.28037285804748535,
0.629412829875946,
-0.26893603801727295,
0.23777425289154053,
-0.49136683344841003,
-0.7235297560691833,
-0.24943839013576508,
-0.0742378756403923,
-0.590349018573761,
0.9760348796844482,
0.49315983057022095,
-0.5969054698944092,
0.41068020462989807,
-0.24345162510871887,
-0.6213903427124023,
-0.06688377261161804,
0.08468849956989288,
-0.4785074293613434,
0.4471982717514038,
-0.08288472145795822,
0.1692878007888794,
-0.06562460213899612,
0.2456623911857605,
-0.09847944974899292,
-0.6671031713485718,
0.8614858984947205,
-0.48004627227783203,
0.6388421058654785,
0.5528232455253601,
0.024777507409453392,
-0.4570530354976654,
-0.410919189453125,
0.13684186339378357,
0.05161282792687416,
-0.40738770365715027,
-0.5396810173988342,
-0.011847113259136677,
-0.057286106050014496,
0.19157764315605164,
0.186817929148674,
-0.31876838207244873,
0.005923860240727663,
-0.14419959485530853,
0.2568339407444,
0.3294597268104553,
-0.09270729124546051,
0.42354944348335266,
-0.6539687514305115,
0.5323591232299805,
0.00404520146548748,
0.2596031129360199,
0.1756688356399536,
-0.6787163019180298,
-0.45380228757858276,
-0.10639303177595139,
0.5332078337669373,
0.5942150354385376,
-0.40710967779159546,
0.4117187261581421,
-0.532036304473877,
-0.15735715627670288,
-0.48430925607681274,
0.15580621361732483,
0.3867758512496948,
0.384971022605896,
0.27679887413978577,
-0.9597684741020203,
-0.07789499312639236,
-0.6735711097717285,
-0.752720832824707,
-0.2830912172794342,
0.161215141415596,
-0.1295706331729889,
0.361635684967041,
0.1107892245054245,
0.9544507265090942,
-0.35371384024620056,
-0.30316734313964844,
-0.07708278298377991,
0.30666613578796387,
0.2993093729019165,
0.7469680905342102,
0.624640941619873,
-0.7708391547203064,
-0.6843064427375793,
0.09730464965105057,
-0.48126423358917236,
-0.26279503107070923,
-0.2258864939212799,
-0.32075321674346924,
-0.08886121958494186,
0.3285175859928131,
-0.5554085373878479,
0.5289022326469421,
0.46589916944503784,
-0.2819896638393402,
0.5112543702125549,
-0.1031469851732254,
0.5047839283943176,
-0.9125301837921143,
0.3684309124946594,
-0.31971725821495056,
-0.32083746790885925,
-0.6925790309906006,
0.2389599084854126,
0.3494325280189514,
0.2674875855445862,
-0.3589233458042145,
0.1913958489894867,
-0.18893395364284515,
-0.03418809920549393,
-0.2499115914106369,
0.08380114287137985,
0.4027300775051117,
0.1930370032787323,
-0.30021408200263977,
1.1438300609588623,
0.05480024218559265,
-0.42899832129478455,
0.07823106646537781,
0.6006419062614441,
-0.5555447340011597,
1.0631356239318848,
-0.3817198872566223,
-0.23460406064987183,
0.14705660939216614,
0.06151653081178665,
-0.9153672456741333,
-0.12562479078769684,
0.3214254081249237,
-0.7065615653991699,
0.4371829032897949,
-0.03500266745686531,
-0.5121052861213684,
-0.33651837706565857,
0.05674313008785248,
0.45851194858551025,
0.6730993986129761,
0.06396322697401047,
0.0051681105978786945,
0.05674529820680618,
-0.09812309592962265,
-0.7564095258712769,
-1.0817724466323853,
0.17098009586334229,
-0.013253740034997463,
-0.6197900772094727,
0.10066260397434235,
-0.04362441226840019,
-0.33847925066947937,
0.24037116765975952,
-0.3451346457004547,
-0.0932188555598259,
0.19854412972927094,
0.17921574413776398,
-0.033155590295791626,
-0.20099645853042603,
-0.11711133271455765,
0.07710234820842743,
-0.5077716708183289,
0.030815260484814644,
-0.10346736758947372,
0.09314212948083878,
0.006053349003195763,
-0.36584794521331787,
-0.5446769595146179,
0.4427236020565033,
0.39194485545158386,
0.03932204842567444,
0.6716331839561462,
0.4339260756969452,
0.13302211463451385,
0.504346489906311,
-0.4810614585876465,
0.18483518064022064,
-0.41110336780548096,
0.19778627157211304,
-0.8878713846206665,
-0.3733516335487366,
0.5623620748519897,
0.21829013526439667,
-0.37475302815437317,
0.7561991810798645,
0.2826206684112549,
-0.2629919648170471,
1.011176347732544,
0.34120824933052063,
-0.06740159541368484,
0.4613206386566162,
0.00864117406308651,
0.35233187675476074,
-0.874564528465271,
0.050907257944345474,
-0.7044234275817871,
-0.293093740940094,
-0.349560022354126,
-0.05546695366501808,
0.22405262291431427,
0.2537626624107361,
-0.06306751072406769,
0.5782803297042847,
-0.1289399117231369,
0.7351710200309753,
0.6598516702651978,
-0.1777113974094391,
0.5855989456176758,
0.029234474524855614,
-0.19821131229400635,
-0.3395693004131317,
-0.8641097545623779,
-0.5561746954917908,
0.9865197539329529,
0.23132485151290894,
0.49403733015060425,
0.2522139549255371,
0.28405824303627014,
0.13985267281532288,
-0.07751758396625519,
-0.7090848684310913,
0.12687468528747559,
-0.08527305722236633,
-0.822885274887085,
-0.27590036392211914,
-0.6511296629905701,
-1.2483633756637573,
0.26327070593833923,
-0.28002429008483887,
-0.3870527446269989,
0.43146708607673645,
0.08743405342102051,
-0.15201792120933533,
0.28268298506736755,
-0.7064307928085327,
1.0050843954086304,
0.08046095818281174,
-0.3912097215652466,
-0.16303926706314087,
-0.878309965133667,
0.21425725519657135,
-0.11327867954969406,
0.4534226059913635,
-0.2956874966621399,
-0.03974342346191406,
0.40329626202583313,
-0.3935931324958801,
0.24055685102939606,
0.4615768492221832,
0.0754655972123146,
0.15492191910743713,
0.7729690074920654,
0.34422096610069275,
-0.1936274617910385,
-0.2045847326517105,
0.5347477197647095,
0.4529404044151306,
-0.8831497430801392,
-0.6257438659667969,
0.3155801594257355,
-0.808575451374054,
-0.5194348692893982,
-0.7814987301826477,
-0.894973874092102,
-0.11331780254840851,
0.14843255281448364,
0.45954176783561707,
0.3706366717815399,
-0.333466500043869,
-0.2086651772260666,
0.3386731445789337,
0.07576024532318115,
0.1433115005493164,
0.15511202812194824,
0.03951261565089226,
-0.21433119475841522,
1.0204403400421143,
0.19971701502799988,
1.005592942237854,
0.4411325752735138,
0.06217750906944275,
-0.043775465339422226,
-0.5230896472930908,
-0.48162221908569336,
0.2126418650150299,
-0.6579251289367676,
-0.13993141055107117,
-0.27407655119895935,
-0.1444995254278183,
-0.1567099243402481,
-0.32943829894065857,
-0.3382253646850586,
-0.5859796404838562,
-0.2605423927307129,
0.28676220774650574,
0.030085761100053787,
0.538200855255127,
-0.3379027843475342,
0.21065840125083923,
-0.8070015907287598,
0.06175178289413452,
0.07636135071516037,
0.1093970388174057,
-0.10827828198671341,
-0.7941523790359497,
-0.43528643250465393,
0.2313772737979889,
-0.49142345786094666,
-0.586705207824707,
0.43298161029815674,
0.0062986440025269985,
0.4982295632362366,
0.5203890204429626,
0.05760566517710686,
0.876897394657135,
-0.5708178281784058,
0.80179363489151,
0.45124462246894836,
-1.2598644495010376,
0.1250961869955063,
-0.17704808712005615,
0.2465595304965973,
0.7318940758705139,
0.3006737530231476,
-0.9441378116607666,
-0.8411653637886047,
-0.73541659116745,
-0.5991266965866089,
0.5968703627586365,
0.6855287551879883,
0.1749376803636551,
-0.09297849237918854,
0.15721480548381805,
0.3612842261791229,
0.2232062816619873,
-0.49073755741119385,
-0.11090298742055893,
-0.2275834083557129,
-0.3462707996368408,
-0.30396756529808044,
-0.24159526824951172,
-0.4600645899772644,
-0.07485710084438324,
0.37473413348197937,
0.17505668103694916,
0.34012195467948914,
0.282968670129776,
-0.3382071554660797,
-0.7097740769386292,
0.3022879660129547,
0.6913131475448608,
1.0577281713485718,
-0.34071534872055054,
0.22426697611808777,
0.0844937190413475,
-0.6122457385063171,
0.16480351984500885,
-0.3487737476825714,
-0.23561842739582062,
0.15109074115753174,
0.4908671975135803,
0.5841214060783386,
0.08987502008676529,
-0.3758704662322998,
0.8052689433097839,
0.19908227026462555,
-0.3169531226158142,
-0.11491724103689194,
0.059833019971847534,
-0.1564580500125885,
0.08158009499311447,
0.31247055530548096,
0.7741536498069763,
0.10610830783843994,
-0.6333944797515869,
0.10570470988750458,
0.40417245030403137,
-0.11230315268039703,
-0.24814832210540771,
0.8099212646484375,
0.16391834616661072,
-0.36630409955978394,
0.41938695311546326,
-0.07144200056791306,
-0.6688901782035828,
0.4751040041446686,
0.36175233125686646,
0.42795881628990173,
-0.15005160868167877,
0.15607520937919617,
0.39363011717796326,
0.3149155378341675,
-0.3467026352882385,
0.0925920382142067,
0.22715194523334503,
-0.5373749732971191,
-0.569256603717804,
-0.1369457244873047,
-0.4511258900165558,
-0.40236422419548035,
-1.0953975915908813,
-0.1572420746088028,
0.2106723189353943,
-0.2598773241043091,
-0.28460752964019775,
-0.06336694210767746,
-0.46629902720451355,
0.054433200508356094,
-0.19342441856861115,
0.5404298901557922,
-0.7014789581298828,
0.6391708254814148,
-0.04456663876771927,
-0.804082989692688,
-0.5476810336112976,
0.14627666771411896,
-0.12878914177417755,
-0.7169916033744812,
0.48701751232147217,
-0.058200251311063766,
0.05273079127073288,
-0.04744299501180649,
-0.35313111543655396,
-0.9359735250473022,
0.7776426076889038,
0.32160496711730957,
-0.550320029258728,
0.3790941834449768,
0.3851543962955475,
0.5138751268386841,
0.042837366461753845,
0.14793230593204498,
0.5544975996017456,
0.4677327573299408,
-0.03250724449753761,
-1.1882388591766357,
-0.02451477199792862,
-0.009734442457556725,
0.19661495089530945,
0.3538817763328552,
-0.7438108325004578,
0.7339816093444824,
-0.029259100556373596,
-0.40015387535095215,
0.34232407808303833,
0.43479979038238525,
-0.4029481112957001,
0.3485565781593323,
0.30221104621887207,
0.6245571970939636,
0.38011986017227173,
-0.2763446569442749,
1.445839524269104,
-0.32103240489959717,
0.469938725233078,
0.4916095733642578,
-0.036664433777332306,
0.9465316534042358,
0.8360964059829712,
-0.5661134123802185,
0.5497150421142578,
0.6851906776428223,
0.20693743228912354,
0.47292882204055786,
-0.0321178175508976,
0.0513162799179554,
-0.2831193506717682,
0.228371262550354,
-0.5874951481819153,
-0.12588916718959808,
0.29518309235572815,
-0.11714961379766464,
0.1709485799074173,
-0.32849180698394775,
0.17570143938064575,
0.42537927627563477,
0.054300736635923386,
0.3827834725379944,
0.18607169389724731,
-0.8291086554527283,
0.6255288124084473,
-0.17895442247390747,
0.23993103206157684,
-0.5332476496696472,
0.31806737184524536,
-0.38417795300483704,
-0.07174117863178253,
-0.10313683748245239,
-1.1086446046829224,
0.5776796340942383,
-0.4701049327850342,
-0.14666716754436493,
-0.30505672097206116,
0.2162342667579651,
-0.5464943051338196,
-0.36165499687194824,
0.09852948784828186,
0.7181196212768555,
0.4317692816257477,
0.02414878085255623,
-0.7040465474128723,
0.050684310495853424,
-0.20346440374851227,
-0.1849609762430191,
0.21626843512058258,
0.5920037627220154,
0.3282398581504822,
0.4916127622127533,
0.8123562932014465,
0.3748576045036316,
0.02166789583861828,
-0.17452813684940338,
0.35925906896591187,
-0.5047619938850403,
-0.5562613010406494,
-0.5979927182197571,
0.3057118356227875,
-0.14920534193515778,
-0.47308188676834106,
0.6851159334182739,
0.3705737888813019,
1.1310198307037354,
-0.14979764819145203,
0.5755008459091187,
0.041374824941158295,
0.49378806352615356,
-0.5412297248840332,
0.45570850372314453,
-0.8033041954040527,
-0.046754542738199234,
-0.4530152380466461,
-1.0136127471923828,
-0.49030327796936035,
0.9867687821388245,
-0.3575737774372101,
-0.18470478057861328,
1.4155851602554321,
0.6357450485229492,
-0.3940458297729492,
-0.20276722311973572,
0.5394775867462158,
-0.026099368929862976,
-0.04650896042585373,
0.8530327081680298,
0.8625405430793762,
-0.7687891721725464,
0.7675758600234985,
0.1372525542974472,
0.0016198813682422042,
-0.43913084268569946,
-0.6391922831535339,
-0.5143844485282898,
-0.5964609384536743,
-0.35719579458236694,
-0.6019760966300964,
0.16596882045269012,
0.5744526982307434,
0.39803409576416016,
-0.5957034826278687,
-0.46403762698173523,
-0.11319272220134735,
0.13644826412200928,
-0.9041484594345093,
-0.19324751198291779,
0.15058965981006622,
-0.5484448671340942,
-0.9156803488731384,
0.05412820726633072,
0.22743923962116241,
0.26054373383522034,
0.08554238080978394,
-0.33376798033714294,
-0.03915692865848541,
0.28308749198913574,
0.21195004880428314,
0.4003100097179413,
-0.7557370066642761,
-0.37127187848091125,
-0.21800899505615234,
-0.5027920007705688,
0.40929046273231506,
0.8437982797622681,
-0.4065205752849579,
0.5924691557884216,
0.5350949764251709,
0.6903236508369446,
0.4753563404083252,
0.12789206206798553,
0.7925896644592285,
-0.49160635471343994,
0.06858120113611221,
-0.16607899963855743,
0.22129523754119873,
0.30950188636779785,
-0.26054829359054565,
0.6563608050346375,
0.6809723377227783,
-0.6731909513473511,
-0.7469032406806946,
0.39400336146354675,
-1.1379586458206177,
-0.41364771127700806,
0.9783608317375183,
-0.19688819348812103,
0.052626024931669235,
-0.3493852913379669,
-0.2500229477882385,
0.2941027879714966,
-0.30149969458580017,
0.9453325271606445,
1.1209505796432495,
0.05608149245381355,
0.2766694724559784,
-0.8477357625961304,
0.3126717507839203,
0.8976091146469116,
-0.30377015471458435,
-0.3108026683330536,
0.19000957906246185,
0.2602374255657196,
0.3849574625492096,
0.2980634868144989,
0.019999181851744652,
0.2718927562236786,
0.26603999733924866,
-0.1159357950091362,
0.02270609140396118,
0.022905761376023293,
-0.11730515211820602,
-0.1296195238828659,
-0.009035738185048103,
-0.2827540338039398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12663v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12663v1 | SoftQE: Learned Representations of Queries Expanded by LLMs | 2024-02-20T02:23:15 | 2024-02-20T02:23:15 | Varad Pimpalkhute, John Heyer, Xusen Yin, Sameer Gupta | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | We investigate the integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) into query
encoders to improve dense retrieval without increasing latency and cost, by
circumventing the dependency on LLMs at inference time. SoftQE incorporates
knowledge from LLMs by mapping embeddings of input queries to those of the
LLM-expanded queries. While improvements over various strong baselines on
in-domain MS-MARCO metrics are marginal, SoftQE improves performance by 2.83
absolute percentage points on average on five out-of-domain BEIR tasks. | [
-0.3003893196582794,
-0.7503841519355774,
0.7126802206039429,
-0.12025430798530579,
-0.001491777366027236,
0.1652020961046219,
-0.364989310503006,
-0.3381795585155487,
0.14540976285934448,
0.8464304208755493,
-0.3460392355918884,
-0.48796677589416504,
-0.5166100859642029,
-0.10463713854551315,
-0.28889480233192444,
0.6479125618934631,
0.16679270565509796,
0.3588141202926636,
-0.13917450606822968,
-0.12449324131011963,
-0.18235421180725098,
-0.6400619745254517,
-0.5511927604675293,
-0.18550844490528107,
0.5431727170944214,
0.2938080132007599,
0.8928599953651428,
0.0971578061580658,
0.5808267593383789,
0.3348124921321869,
-0.05157427489757538,
0.423235148191452,
-0.7609364986419678,
0.5145458579063416,
-0.263049453496933,
-1.0659754276275635,
-0.42728281021118164,
-0.2558811902999878,
0.7854068279266357,
1.1193220615386963,
-0.3767619729042053,
-0.1523047536611557,
0.28955578804016113,
0.9110638499259949,
-0.723911702632904,
0.08614227175712585,
-0.6300637125968933,
0.09492164850234985,
-0.1150706484913826,
-0.07889505475759506,
-0.3225218653678894,
-0.5247195363044739,
0.1361466646194458,
-0.40734967589378357,
0.13840414583683014,
-0.17969545722007751,
0.39049285650253296,
0.07522591948509216,
-0.7177724838256836,
-0.2701603174209595,
-0.8345532417297363,
0.8813624382019043,
-0.6688310503959656,
0.8344656825065613,
-0.006312896963208914,
0.3449351191520691,
-0.5062348246574402,
-0.9891038537025452,
-0.41296568512916565,
-0.08738820999860764,
-0.017227109521627426,
0.15974083542823792,
0.23697438836097717,
0.36972954869270325,
0.3781188428401947,
0.4695606231689453,
-0.27675092220306396,
-0.03141508623957634,
-0.23404012620449066,
0.05719785392284393,
0.8298360109329224,
0.32467058300971985,
0.0880170688033104,
0.16679638624191284,
-0.0856364369392395,
0.23426973819732666,
-0.8554480075836182,
-0.1169423758983612,
-0.09069395810365677,
0.1947326958179474,
0.4421824514865875,
0.6499929428100586,
-0.30670762062072754,
0.6998165845870972,
-0.04483243077993393,
-0.2058870941400528,
0.2227960228919983,
-0.24228866398334503,
-0.16922836005687714,
-0.3582671582698822,
0.5711114406585693,
0.06550691276788712,
0.418731153011322,
-0.6518118381500244,
-0.5492983460426331,
-0.5317901968955994,
-0.07896804809570312,
-0.8956374526023865,
0.1987525373697281,
0.23591230809688568,
-0.4981938600540161,
0.2853890061378479,
0.31381163001060486,
-0.5192044973373413,
-0.504582941532135,
-0.3209422826766968,
0.46830877661705017,
-0.42888689041137695,
-0.3118494153022766,
0.1986592561006546,
-0.26102495193481445,
0.43502411246299744,
0.26934579014778137,
-0.6551831364631653,
0.6738967895507812,
0.6723237633705139,
0.5849318504333496,
-0.23694655299186707,
0.12049514055252075,
-0.6351277828216553,
0.2635331153869629,
-0.3976747989654541,
0.8469041585922241,
-0.5809698700904846,
-0.5707398056983948,
0.400808721780777,
0.28658202290534973,
-0.24818359315395355,
-0.8272689580917358,
0.5757843255996704,
-1.0364395380020142,
0.21930453181266785,
-0.30720922350883484,
-1.0491286516189575,
-0.38557177782058716,
0.03174040839076042,
-0.7795318365097046,
1.1507322788238525,
0.3653727173805237,
-0.19186216592788696,
0.3948393762111664,
-0.7638257145881653,
-0.21079877018928528,
0.31456229090690613,
-0.09107053279876709,
0.034818582236766815,
0.32870084047317505,
0.16729766130447388,
0.5335116982460022,
-0.3941146433353424,
0.24565933644771576,
-0.3333975374698639,
-0.7114161252975464,
0.4988161027431488,
-0.15607589483261108,
0.7486072182655334,
0.19749313592910767,
-0.213480144739151,
-0.05298205837607384,
-0.5809831023216248,
0.26968181133270264,
0.2006426900625229,
-0.7281213402748108,
-0.5006742477416992,
0.09387177228927612,
-0.14984232187271118,
-0.13398762047290802,
0.3669435977935791,
-0.3565910756587982,
0.5283553004264832,
-0.787478506565094,
0.3515952229499817,
0.2891284227371216,
0.028423789888620377,
0.8214950561523438,
-0.1437150090932846,
0.4948595464229584,
0.19079957902431488,
0.14960595965385437,
0.12910501658916473,
-0.34420639276504517,
-0.7738233208656311,
-0.12220018357038498,
0.587385356426239,
0.7367558479309082,
-0.9657565951347351,
0.051783036440610886,
-0.3178134858608246,
-0.27726346254348755,
-0.48492568731307983,
0.7763369679450989,
-0.008051698096096516,
0.0074200257658958435,
0.26780399680137634,
-0.20681847631931305,
-0.26346996426582336,
-0.7836775183677673,
-0.27851971983909607,
0.15500865876674652,
-0.41350817680358887,
0.5725242495536804,
0.3404363989830017,
-0.17179962992668152,
0.5147703886032104,
-0.5213432312011719,
-0.17693132162094116,
-0.29067444801330566,
-0.15710709989070892,
0.5527849197387695,
0.3574177920818329,
0.48824018239974976,
-0.8499853610992432,
-0.5808895230293274,
-0.30146822333335876,
-0.7092063426971436,
-0.07464820146560669,
0.1806422919034958,
-0.24053438007831573,
0.17386898398399353,
0.6380183100700378,
-0.7975711822509766,
0.1587931513786316,
0.13557590544223785,
-0.2609747350215912,
0.3094637393951416,
-0.11141541600227356,
0.36093756556510925,
-0.932640552520752,
-0.4747864305973053,
-0.1609892100095749,
-0.213906392455101,
-0.5177688002586365,
0.21949981153011322,
0.2998655140399933,
-0.06701768189668655,
-0.5103302597999573,
0.290132075548172,
-0.8861122727394104,
-0.2590249180793762,
-0.041078563779592514,
0.5275143384933472,
0.2465273141860962,
0.3964722454547882,
-0.07509399950504303,
1.0354877710342407,
0.5813124179840088,
-0.6890097856521606,
0.448546826839447,
-0.006231711711734533,
-0.3100646138191223,
0.5050707459449768,
-0.8100841045379639,
0.3539426028728485,
-0.1793045550584793,
-0.056084878742694855,
-1.0721007585525513,
0.06600389629602432,
-0.1527235358953476,
-0.26510781049728394,
0.5803123116493225,
-0.38495007157325745,
-0.7092750072479248,
-0.2508333623409271,
-0.4568328857421875,
0.3056282103061676,
0.4551291763782501,
-0.6021447777748108,
0.80168616771698,
0.3208714425563812,
-0.08516661077737808,
-0.5564013123512268,
-0.6349754333496094,
0.08625587075948715,
-0.1099805012345314,
-0.7682094573974609,
0.6153699159622192,
-0.02086414396762848,
-0.3567556142807007,
0.17126041650772095,
0.4025832414627075,
-0.3275638520717621,
-0.06900084763765335,
-0.06928377598524094,
0.001119793625548482,
-0.9057883024215698,
0.40454331040382385,
0.12933699786663055,
0.370816707611084,
0.06299762427806854,
-0.43005260825157166,
0.4871453642845154,
-0.12408041208982468,
-0.4542059302330017,
-0.05353839695453644,
0.5809487700462341,
0.5800633430480957,
-0.10149367153644562,
0.995526134967804,
0.4045136868953705,
-0.3517196774482727,
-0.2455873042345047,
-0.8857076168060303,
-0.3517167866230011,
-0.5306577682495117,
0.373259961605072,
-0.4715016484260559,
-1.0343657732009888,
0.5315015316009521,
-0.35999223589897156,
-0.11727787554264069,
0.4195401966571808,
0.15909087657928467,
-0.16658034920692444,
1.3299823999404907,
0.6629451513290405,
0.055825356394052505,
0.5773679614067078,
-0.38493114709854126,
-0.22944097220897675,
-0.9817463159561157,
-0.4386537969112396,
-0.38875332474708557,
-0.31591010093688965,
-0.8079780340194702,
-0.7801463603973389,
0.3572200834751129,
0.2394743263721466,
-0.39427199959754944,
-0.033375486731529236,
-0.2489270269870758,
0.4840983748435974,
0.5362748503684998,
0.4417790472507477,
0.32580670714378357,
-0.02367267943918705,
0.0366380549967289,
-0.25593599677085876,
-1.0124475955963135,
-0.2473505586385727,
1.3529486656188965,
0.13774847984313965,
0.9114994406700134,
0.43466541171073914,
0.6074607968330383,
0.26684877276420593,
0.23851029574871063,
-1.1848071813583374,
0.650003969669342,
-0.36661842465400696,
-0.5589007139205933,
-0.1885320395231247,
-0.4471438229084015,
-1.0689054727554321,
0.4078344702720642,
-0.4120572507381439,
-0.5282984375953674,
0.3902173936367035,
-0.38250553607940674,
-0.24853265285491943,
0.18195369839668274,
-0.7011211514472961,
0.4235582947731018,
-0.5461786389350891,
-0.8064276576042175,
-0.3285442888736725,
-0.10982906073331833,
0.3706009089946747,
0.11657469719648361,
-0.07348617166280746,
0.12572234869003296,
-0.5547056794166565,
1.0172820091247559,
-0.3881072998046875,
0.7094751000404358,
-0.40818068385124207,
0.04683670774102211,
0.4746329188346863,
0.04749317839741707,
0.6273118257522583,
0.10840542614459991,
-0.44592922925949097,
0.09123964607715607,
-0.07422363758087158,
-0.5535101890563965,
-1.117231011390686,
0.5942175984382629,
-0.5228478908538818,
-0.9054919481277466,
-0.12184900790452957,
-0.4828161895275116,
-0.5270364880561829,
0.15667304396629333,
-0.2241324931383133,
0.5499045848846436,
-0.1333508938550949,
0.589931070804596,
1.0471916198730469,
-0.3182540237903595,
0.19136568903923035,
0.9133275151252747,
-0.1894124299287796,
-0.32972607016563416,
0.3990996778011322,
0.4652060270309448,
0.16865967214107513,
0.510431706905365,
-0.07354374974966049,
-0.6402664184570312,
-0.7047558426856995,
-0.15181544423103333,
0.4865766167640686,
-0.7871074080467224,
-0.5117980241775513,
-0.6410302519798279,
-0.3988105058670044,
-0.4797288179397583,
-0.11702685058116913,
-0.367547869682312,
-0.5824128985404968,
-0.24318580329418182,
-0.07186760753393173,
0.4452490210533142,
0.8466224074363708,
0.14990083873271942,
0.6366688013076782,
-0.9428285956382751,
0.0508345365524292,
0.2748725116252899,
0.5151761770248413,
-0.2607609033584595,
-0.7675263285636902,
-0.2955324947834015,
-0.04689346253871918,
-0.2863747477531433,
-1.029185175895691,
0.396041601896286,
0.42221570014953613,
0.9252225160598755,
0.47436535358428955,
-0.07061981409788132,
0.5878505706787109,
-0.3699242174625397,
0.8890586495399475,
0.05702880024909973,
-0.7909146547317505,
0.5897663831710815,
-0.09953721612691879,
0.25962767004966736,
0.4833424389362335,
0.6754474639892578,
-0.09616264700889587,
-0.22975601255893707,
-0.4089941680431366,
-0.8411495089530945,
0.2439635545015335,
-0.21596981585025787,
0.34413236379623413,
-0.04320024698972702,
0.8127247095108032,
-0.04805990681052208,
0.12084554135799408,
-0.33596110343933105,
-0.1401316523551941,
0.33946606516838074,
-0.13218675553798676,
0.11487197875976562,
-0.8222687244415283,
0.1607428789138794,
-0.35146936774253845,
0.5446522235870361,
-0.1732204705476761,
0.38341736793518066,
0.16958151757717133,
-0.34110337495803833,
0.061759352684020996,
0.22728553414344788,
0.07384294271469116,
0.6508031487464905,
-0.17373013496398926,
0.06810808181762695,
0.5710808634757996,
-0.273875892162323,
-0.2248590886592865,
0.016432562842965126,
0.005752044729888439,
-0.08316787332296371,
0.25520727038383484,
0.43571290373802185,
0.4582137167453766,
-0.6576890349388123,
0.4794909358024597,
-0.0536426417529583,
-0.16107340157032013,
-0.3083342909812927,
0.31102079153060913,
0.278486430644989,
0.5707693696022034,
0.5660411715507507,
-0.5688991546630859,
0.690743625164032,
-0.5244267582893372,
0.28412675857543945,
0.756873369216919,
-0.39611750841140747,
-0.05835767462849617,
0.6268219947814941,
0.2824191749095917,
-0.20643089711666107,
0.838645339012146,
0.17611832916736603,
-0.5728947520256042,
0.4606632590293884,
0.6195489764213562,
0.5109531283378601,
-0.3653894364833832,
-0.07600528001785278,
0.3937162756919861,
0.3092708885669708,
0.033251501619815826,
0.6485578417778015,
-0.0511234886944294,
-0.7886895537376404,
-0.7403663992881775,
-0.5491507053375244,
-0.4704844355583191,
0.08890514075756073,
-0.5737465023994446,
0.3703859746456146,
-0.16767366230487823,
-0.3711622357368469,
-0.39238977432250977,
0.4223749041557312,
-0.854620635509491,
0.15401236712932587,
-0.045674096792936325,
1.1406455039978027,
-0.36646923422813416,
0.8078640103340149,
0.6046671867370605,
-0.5714724659919739,
-0.7188529968261719,
-0.2561309337615967,
-0.33146464824676514,
-1.017311930656433,
0.8093669414520264,
-0.18799982964992523,
-0.18642236292362213,
-0.03673342242836952,
-0.6663690209388733,
-1.063623070716858,
1.0889006853103638,
0.46402448415756226,
-0.6096305847167969,
0.19189441204071045,
0.2902074456214905,
0.42829832434654236,
-0.4786468744277954,
0.597251296043396,
0.6001368761062622,
0.3161669969558716,
-0.05331895872950554,
-0.6039658188819885,
0.1724841296672821,
-0.06821251660585403,
-0.02832505851984024,
0.22608061134815216,
-0.559637725353241,
0.48640885949134827,
-0.3292650580406189,
-0.14277808368206024,
-0.23155023157596588,
1.001440167427063,
-0.15800413489341736,
0.26292353868484497,
0.3876081109046936,
0.03085928037762642,
0.9817439913749695,
-0.056127797812223434,
1.0694950819015503,
-0.40476998686790466,
0.05385490134358406,
0.9916908144950867,
-0.20650069415569305,
1.0009182691574097,
0.38528430461883545,
-0.46172821521759033,
0.6095456480979919,
0.4230774939060211,
0.20791752636432648,
0.2621440887451172,
0.026301076635718346,
-0.439558207988739,
-0.29643765091896057,
-0.1552097201347351,
-0.4705876410007477,
0.4386175572872162,
0.9085887670516968,
-0.487892746925354,
0.146539106965065,
-0.21057730913162231,
-0.1248810738325119,
0.12549835443496704,
-0.26372870802879333,
1.0462772846221924,
0.2936614751815796,
-0.5997687578201294,
0.7020171880722046,
-0.1700613647699356,
0.8649429082870483,
-0.6668462157249451,
-0.055591780692338943,
-0.6344999074935913,
0.16160303354263306,
-0.2702002227306366,
-0.8984822034835815,
0.32822802662849426,
-0.4218055307865143,
-0.08154384791851044,
0.07362666726112366,
1.0892986059188843,
-0.6221895813941956,
-0.48162245750427246,
0.6257247924804688,
0.9653198719024658,
0.17801611125469208,
-0.30021458864212036,
-0.8256554007530212,
-0.2056690901517868,
-0.29818427562713623,
-0.6690170168876648,
0.39583370089530945,
0.8921791315078735,
0.18400585651397705,
0.6783362030982971,
0.41766420006752014,
0.04970680922269821,
0.21113695204257965,
0.25240227580070496,
0.9791520833969116,
-0.96592777967453,
0.09817177057266235,
-0.6073930859565735,
0.3024669289588928,
-0.1994735300540924,
0.2637702226638794,
0.6547185182571411,
0.7039570212364197,
0.4478241205215454,
-0.04292662441730499,
0.6573570966720581,
0.2837642431259155,
0.4631059467792511,
-0.7102286219596863,
0.6854232549667358,
-0.814144492149353,
0.4768868684768677,
0.13960762321949005,
-1.1224746704101562,
-0.2892540395259857,
0.36104509234428406,
-0.3724316656589508,
0.21011604368686676,
0.6283679008483887,
0.9936792254447937,
-0.12826882302761078,
-0.21737982332706451,
0.6210373044013977,
0.2424268275499344,
0.064242422580719,
0.7007266879081726,
0.9532027840614319,
-0.4642491638660431,
0.5882149338722229,
-0.1437712460756302,
-0.22914640605449677,
-0.253559947013855,
-0.6084246635437012,
-0.708125114440918,
-0.36386632919311523,
-0.4366168975830078,
-0.4345353841781616,
0.18686264753341675,
0.7539651393890381,
0.6063357591629028,
-0.9126232266426086,
-0.4319424331188202,
0.3493044972419739,
0.4784938097000122,
-0.14754432439804077,
-0.3303053677082062,
0.16423217952251434,
-0.6904511451721191,
-0.9308518171310425,
0.5701932311058044,
0.13272055983543396,
-0.17839306592941284,
-0.2269906997680664,
-0.07486709207296371,
-0.12510795891284943,
0.42161431908607483,
0.9644109606742859,
-0.07867185026407242,
-0.30155494809150696,
-0.026580017060041428,
0.30629613995552063,
-0.07558014243841171,
0.0568237267434597,
0.8572461009025574,
-0.7778153419494629,
0.013375725597143173,
0.566955029964447,
0.6304536461830139,
0.6793849468231201,
-0.20666950941085815,
0.7480010986328125,
-0.516332745552063,
0.07829166203737259,
0.3064917027950287,
0.6140535473823547,
0.3438869118690491,
-0.6057215332984924,
0.7722790837287903,
0.2920438051223755,
-0.5337919592857361,
-0.627109169960022,
0.0881010964512825,
-0.8949156999588013,
-0.33389613032341003,
1.290481448173523,
-0.07135219871997833,
-0.3877709209918976,
-0.30472511053085327,
0.034131575375795364,
0.11867634207010269,
-0.357829213142395,
0.40374085307121277,
0.336833119392395,
-0.2743459641933441,
-0.2317834496498108,
-0.8866151571273804,
0.23244419693946838,
0.41551268100738525,
-0.4975574314594269,
-0.26313549280166626,
0.5970867872238159,
0.4574917256832123,
-0.15870623290538788,
0.7007188200950623,
-0.38837847113609314,
-0.03143656998872757,
-0.1101820170879364,
-0.12390052527189255,
0.18073353171348572,
0.0574687160551548,
0.008860847912728786,
0.6174368858337402,
0.3849186301231384,
0.12269998341798782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12659v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12659v2 | FinBen: A Holistic Financial Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-02-20T02:16:16 | 2024-06-19T03:38:56 | Qianqian Xie, Weiguang Han, Zhengyu Chen, Ruoyu Xiang, Xiao Zhang, Yueru He, Mengxi Xiao, Dong Li, Yongfu Dai, Duanyu Feng, Yijing Xu, Haoqiang Kang, Ziyan Kuang, Chenhan Yuan, Kailai Yang, Zheheng Luo, Tianlin Zhang, Zhiwei Liu, Guojun Xiong, Zhiyang Deng, Yuechen Jiang, Zhiyuan Yao, Haohang Li, Yangyang Yu, Gang Hu, Jiajia Huang, Xiao-Yang Liu, Alejandro Lopez-Lira, Benyou Wang, Yanzhao Lai, Hao Wang, Min Peng, Sophia Ananiadou, Jimin Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE | LLMs have transformed NLP and shown promise in various fields, yet their
potential in finance is underexplored due to a lack of comprehensive evaluation
benchmarks, the rapid development of LLMs, and the complexity of financial
tasks. In this paper, we introduce FinBen, the first extensive open-source
evaluation benchmark, including 36 datasets spanning 24 financial tasks,
covering seven critical aspects: information extraction (IE), textual analysis,
question answering (QA), text generation, risk management, forecasting, and
decision-making. FinBen offers several key innovations: a broader range of
tasks and datasets, the first evaluation of stock trading, novel agent and
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) evaluation, and three novel open-source
evaluation datasets for text summarization, question answering, and stock
trading. Our evaluation of 15 representative LLMs, including GPT-4, ChatGPT,
and the latest Gemini, reveals several key findings: While LLMs excel in IE and
textual analysis, they struggle with advanced reasoning and complex tasks like
text generation and forecasting. GPT-4 excels in IE and stock trading, while
Gemini is better at text generation and forecasting. Instruction-tuned LLMs
improve textual analysis but offer limited benefits for complex tasks such as
QA. FinBen has been used to host the first financial LLMs shared task at the
FinNLP-AgentScen workshop during IJCAI-2024, attracting 12 teams. Their novel
solutions outperformed GPT-4, showcasing FinBen's potential to drive innovation
in financial LLMs. All datasets, results, and codes are released for the
research community: https://github.com/The-FinAI/PIXIU. | [
-0.3384176790714264,
-0.521098792552948,
0.2748817503452301,
0.4194820821285248,
-0.08692144602537155,
0.39554399251937866,
-0.45504334568977356,
-0.47644826769828796,
-0.11657347530126572,
0.5977844595909119,
-0.3522556722164154,
-0.7915352582931519,
-0.358083575963974,
-0.10857453942298889,
-0.5694689154624939,
1.0017671585083008,
-0.05274609103798866,
0.15304693579673767,
-0.14968635141849518,
0.06691049784421921,
-0.06361629068851471,
-0.3917490541934967,
-0.9639968872070312,
-0.3723946809768677,
0.4611116945743561,
0.2901780307292938,
0.4351230263710022,
0.41071292757987976,
1.0483053922653198,
0.3079428970813751,
0.24709290266036987,
-0.14225053787231445,
-0.4122692048549652,
0.02692798338830471,
-0.4555656313896179,
-0.25761938095092773,
-0.5929388403892517,
0.14638711512088776,
0.6344755291938782,
0.8012462258338928,
-0.23834466934204102,
0.4561297595500946,
-0.011154793202877045,
0.8907156586647034,
-0.6803882122039795,
0.573752224445343,
-0.39154666662216187,
-0.11305951327085495,
-0.6315428614616394,
0.03161102160811424,
-0.08897948265075684,
-0.351980596780777,
0.07402222603559494,
-0.41798073053359985,
-0.09912309050559998,
0.4480222761631012,
0.7041183710098267,
0.16989067196846008,
-0.21019387245178223,
-0.21333198249340057,
-0.43262428045272827,
0.6043506860733032,
-0.7565323710441589,
0.3677632808685303,
0.04047665745019913,
0.5350332856178284,
-0.28996357321739197,
-0.8141743540763855,
-0.2388908714056015,
-0.07467789202928543,
0.2143346667289734,
0.26097437739372253,
-0.44833245873451233,
0.03030846267938614,
0.05905131995677948,
0.47617605328559875,
-0.31496167182922363,
0.18987467885017395,
-0.45960837602615356,
-0.07543762028217316,
0.6772634387016296,
0.10220668464899063,
-0.2304581105709076,
0.029248088598251343,
-0.7996703386306763,
-0.5588469505310059,
-0.5482560992240906,
0.06334055960178375,
0.5702785849571228,
0.39988264441490173,
-0.03726767376065254,
0.4784959554672241,
-0.1519555151462555,
0.5785788893699646,
-0.06942234188318253,
-0.1426781415939331,
0.3313087224960327,
-0.19178371131420135,
-0.34809231758117676,
0.1264728605747223,
0.8107196092605591,
0.4907000660896301,
0.32329896092414856,
-0.18954961001873016,
-0.4628032147884369,
-0.0976085215806961,
0.03137104958295822,
-0.4525928497314453,
-0.0047470745630562305,
0.21180345118045807,
-0.4088361859321594,
-0.25010979175567627,
0.22471538186073303,
-0.9185844659805298,
-0.3782690167427063,
-0.19540274143218994,
0.10554294288158417,
-0.22569262981414795,
-0.22802379727363586,
0.38095027208328247,
-0.3391133248806,
0.5632372498512268,
0.021988684311509132,
-0.8459669351577759,
0.9743449687957764,
1.2992652654647827,
0.5695798993110657,
-0.44933846592903137,
-0.18465089797973633,
-0.6757635474205017,
-0.06456463038921356,
-0.5046029686927795,
1.052559733390808,
-0.1859275996685028,
-0.22695408761501312,
-0.29883137345314026,
-0.2881508469581604,
-0.01644064113497734,
-0.6667585372924805,
0.43965965509414673,
-0.23078007996082306,
0.07851825654506683,
-0.19998937845230103,
-0.7654679417610168,
-0.17344370484352112,
0.12289432436227798,
-0.6619482040405273,
1.2566097974777222,
0.3054124712944031,
-0.748207151889801,
0.28257283568382263,
-0.9695217609405518,
-0.14618253707885742,
0.09453624486923218,
-0.22453182935714722,
-0.25239598751068115,
-0.09859398007392883,
-0.17660187184810638,
0.547701358795166,
-1.0011589527130127,
0.5050039887428284,
-0.4420112669467926,
-0.4657663106918335,
0.37661728262901306,
-0.43221867084503174,
0.24202175438404083,
0.03981110826134682,
-0.5620052218437195,
0.3135651648044586,
-0.8565629124641418,
0.08326984941959381,
0.20871040225028992,
0.021185778081417084,
-0.3501383066177368,
-0.2167762666940689,
0.41081637144088745,
0.05722951516509056,
0.5526813268661499,
-0.5522775053977966,
-0.24449275434017181,
-0.7482489347457886,
0.25485071539878845,
0.9682235717773438,
-0.1418348252773285,
0.09607382863759995,
-0.48047611117362976,
0.42205166816711426,
-0.3339475393295288,
0.11474168300628662,
0.0005267494707368314,
-0.08467309176921844,
-0.49697691202163696,
-0.17612740397453308,
0.432237446308136,
0.5709986686706543,
-0.3197247385978699,
0.26200228929519653,
-0.19887718558311462,
-0.6608793139457703,
-0.18809384107589722,
0.5179287791252136,
0.4706954061985016,
0.17778030037879944,
-0.006045397371053696,
-0.2394198328256607,
-0.263374000787735,
-1.2717324495315552,
-0.41188082098960876,
-0.1729598045349121,
-0.059974655508995056,
-0.060142505913972855,
0.40080907940864563,
0.1221703365445137,
0.7271708846092224,
-0.3494756519794464,
-0.09832289069890976,
-0.28373128175735474,
0.15664221346378326,
0.5510057806968689,
0.2684607207775116,
0.7434190511703491,
-0.7275328040122986,
-0.27479612827301025,
0.15506812930107117,
-0.4450613260269165,
-0.20288261771202087,
-0.15325920283794403,
-0.4437658190727234,
0.08423236757516861,
0.5274217128753662,
-0.21394279599189758,
0.07845412939786911,
0.5321958065032959,
-0.43569356203079224,
0.2813693583011627,
-0.04751380905508995,
-0.1788141429424286,
-0.9209945797920227,
0.5712836980819702,
0.036709073930978775,
-0.414244145154953,
-0.19833965599536896,
-0.06456112116575241,
-0.00008108002657536417,
0.1349971741437912,
-0.20250453054904938,
1.032223105430603,
-0.16703863441944122,
-0.7695286870002747,
-0.3061222732067108,
0.6104653477668762,
-0.12108313292264938,
0.5394847393035889,
-0.3532429039478302,
0.8429752588272095,
0.2104918509721756,
-0.21087339520454407,
0.6400346159934998,
0.11906285583972931,
-0.5326355695724487,
0.6201061606407166,
-0.6090931296348572,
-0.09197204560041428,
0.20233097672462463,
-0.12343423068523407,
-0.9082072377204895,
0.00008881060784915462,
0.3759721517562866,
0.042497418820858,
0.0970020741224289,
0.5948309898376465,
-0.6601428389549255,
-0.38371580839157104,
-0.36573705077171326,
-0.11412613838911057,
0.1822018027305603,
-0.4257383942604065,
0.5204991698265076,
0.22641821205615997,
-0.646564245223999,
-0.8011670708656311,
-0.36734089255332947,
0.18529261648654938,
-0.1271793097257614,
-0.38207077980041504,
0.41749197244644165,
-0.040785979479551315,
-0.7309812903404236,
0.12551109492778778,
-0.61905837059021,
0.2421015352010727,
0.4490210711956024,
0.16828344762325287,
0.7476255297660828,
-0.26804468035697937,
0.205523282289505,
0.053290560841560364,
-0.5105187892913818,
0.032517146319150925,
-0.3229762017726898,
0.41767600178718567,
-0.7983292937278748,
-0.40984907746315,
0.1701725721359253,
0.02800380066037178,
0.34521380066871643,
-0.2706565856933594,
0.32165825366973877,
0.53074049949646,
-0.23669490218162537,
-0.07597347348928452,
-0.7273426055908203,
0.23488552868366241,
-0.47166621685028076,
0.07865947484970093,
-0.1711016595363617,
-0.996065080165863,
0.5303823351860046,
-0.5946851372718811,
0.6324462890625,
0.829871654510498,
0.5598796010017395,
0.06196608766913414,
0.1474950760602951,
0.7636286616325378,
-0.019952595233917236,
0.42168930172920227,
-0.02099037729203701,
-0.032149799168109894,
-0.45641401410102844,
-0.11105930805206299,
-0.34673741459846497,
-0.4316270351409912,
-0.3299657106399536,
-0.38032373785972595,
0.33535367250442505,
0.23194338381290436,
-0.3594644069671631,
0.18754099309444427,
0.03652466833591461,
0.4627797603607178,
0.604792594909668,
-0.18529196083545685,
0.38400155305862427,
-0.20665962994098663,
-0.46013975143432617,
0.16998594999313354,
-0.49087175726890564,
-0.5645748376846313,
1.4189088344573975,
0.390277624130249,
0.6687038540840149,
-0.23475787043571472,
0.5518189072608948,
0.4851139485836029,
0.7336782813072205,
-0.4751344621181488,
0.5385298728942871,
-0.36247098445892334,
-0.5883379578590393,
-0.33511361479759216,
-0.43002012372016907,
-0.5925853848457336,
0.15478426218032837,
-0.16952288150787354,
-0.64798903465271,
0.03875529393553734,
-0.308432936668396,
-0.5310875177383423,
0.1478145271539688,
-0.31963881850242615,
0.936015784740448,
-0.7534934282302856,
-0.5756205916404724,
-0.14665092527866364,
-0.5679473280906677,
0.4241185188293457,
-0.6432486176490784,
0.4475526809692383,
-0.6316918134689331,
-0.2976766526699066,
0.870050311088562,
-0.24814791977405548,
0.7071508765220642,
0.024191904813051224,
-0.33444708585739136,
0.09346222877502441,
-0.23187929391860962,
0.29782038927078247,
-0.09265828132629395,
-0.3075384795665741,
0.26837828755378723,
0.25237616896629333,
-0.3285852074623108,
-0.5932650566101074,
0.6550292372703552,
-0.34362107515335083,
-0.4448845386505127,
-0.39784908294677734,
-0.2885574400424957,
-0.4302196204662323,
0.2644099295139313,
-0.29479989409446716,
0.1546372026205063,
-0.5531736612319946,
0.33983710408210754,
0.20888648927211761,
-0.15912789106369019,
0.4598185420036316,
0.6301023960113525,
-0.6883047819137573,
-0.6793377995491028,
0.7744749188423157,
-0.31020382046699524,
0.10247302800416946,
0.29587218165397644,
0.21542516350746155,
-0.3997325897216797,
-0.23386886715888977,
-0.2728095054626465,
0.21189895272254944,
-0.9853741526603699,
-0.396475225687027,
-0.2392335832118988,
-0.13846555352210999,
-0.1283111721277237,
-0.21439699828624725,
-0.7616345882415771,
-0.40452733635902405,
0.3161749541759491,
-0.4416595697402954,
0.5343198776245117,
0.7682613134384155,
-0.38300296664237976,
0.18479664623737335,
-0.692195475101471,
0.2716663181781769,
0.03899472579360008,
0.872848391532898,
-0.044090352952480316,
0.2525603473186493,
-0.3393799662590027,
-0.3552069664001465,
0.03941803425550461,
-0.25875934958457947,
0.13931980729103088,
0.05081593245267868,
0.7308272123336792,
0.6155040264129639,
0.1324138343334198,
0.3321874737739563,
-0.0022596768103539944,
0.28239837288856506,
0.24232691526412964,
-0.9795087575912476,
0.18718217313289642,
-0.3278404772281647,
0.12756499648094177,
0.7549435496330261,
0.1060459315776825,
-0.6566424369812012,
-0.3469681441783905,
-0.4600965976715088,
-0.9864526987075806,
0.42206406593322754,
0.18152424693107605,
-0.21242868900299072,
0.1031569316983223,
0.45540758967399597,
0.635491669178009,
0.6848818063735962,
-0.4360763132572174,
-0.2778809666633606,
0.033819153904914856,
-0.2642141580581665,
-0.26580435037612915,
-0.03517990931868553,
-0.06422936171293259,
-0.09149320423603058,
0.5780885219573975,
-0.20655480027198792,
-0.1218632236123085,
-0.1158623918890953,
0.34931480884552,
0.0033563999459147453,
0.2766234576702118,
0.22043636441230774,
0.6626297235488892,
-0.342756062746048,
-0.050310857594013214,
0.15834936499595642,
-0.16250237822532654,
-0.0369049608707428,
0.518166720867157,
0.22958187758922577,
-0.04360351338982582,
0.3881092369556427,
0.6911933422088623,
1.0428593158721924,
-1.1152935028076172,
0.45078587532043457,
-0.036304548382759094,
-0.31792575120925903,
-0.5853003263473511,
0.1725933700799942,
0.14207734167575836,
0.741605818271637,
0.5042091012001038,
0.0008987027104012668,
0.0991298258304596,
-0.4992017149925232,
0.28309568762779236,
0.26659083366394043,
-0.2050820291042328,
0.1564970314502716,
0.6837506294250488,
0.1625385880470276,
0.19083519279956818,
0.3775613009929657,
0.17996841669082642,
-0.3087589144706726,
0.4181848466396332,
0.18474820256233215,
0.9637587070465088,
0.07038480788469315,
0.14121484756469727,
-0.01284067053347826,
0.23380886018276215,
-0.39251428842544556,
0.5489180088043213,
-0.15294526517391205,
-0.5719953775405884,
-0.25155624747276306,
-1.064220905303955,
-0.8306337594985962,
-0.03824499994516373,
-0.7807241678237915,
0.24215348064899445,
-0.6978343725204468,
-0.4286574423313141,
0.2127649188041687,
0.29795169830322266,
-0.6980202794075012,
-0.11010962724685669,
0.11901603639125824,
1.215753436088562,
-0.26088592410087585,
0.38404786586761475,
0.485588014125824,
-0.039247140288352966,
-0.1942291259765625,
-0.3099084198474884,
-0.01169207226485014,
-0.7030746340751648,
0.517799973487854,
0.022583501413464546,
-0.2613881826400757,
-0.028978925198316574,
-0.4023593068122864,
-0.873077392578125,
1.0753779411315918,
0.556545615196228,
-0.9179859757423401,
-0.13621868193149567,
0.21591801941394806,
0.4253333508968353,
-0.33393338322639465,
0.026054175570607185,
0.7639108300209045,
0.9461796283721924,
0.06223144382238388,
-0.9342817068099976,
-0.19272257387638092,
-0.600277841091156,
-0.10877624154090881,
0.2093505710363388,
-0.8148437738418579,
0.8267347812652588,
0.06307951360940933,
-0.2201930284500122,
0.12678928673267365,
0.47724995017051697,
0.11046916246414185,
0.5050488114356995,
0.43520960211753845,
0.10978028178215027,
0.900860607624054,
-0.30582746863365173,
1.1572637557983398,
-0.8225083351135254,
0.24474334716796875,
1.1678340435028076,
-0.5769574046134949,
1.1422851085662842,
0.21912020444869995,
-0.25620120763778687,
0.36100441217422485,
0.6504250168800354,
-0.2995375096797943,
0.11248651891946793,
0.534656286239624,
-0.14246931672096252,
-0.42392557859420776,
0.09667853266000748,
-0.26473063230514526,
0.5622445940971375,
0.4363744258880615,
-0.14795903861522675,
-0.3619958758354187,
0.07772085815668106,
-0.02215700037777424,
0.1812567114830017,
-0.26000121235847473,
0.7061437368392944,
0.3533693552017212,
-0.2730509042739868,
0.06310735642910004,
0.4341809153556824,
0.6519421935081482,
-0.9922456741333008,
0.20555414259433746,
-0.20799344778060913,
0.3835398554801941,
0.2113843411207199,
-0.6142475605010986,
0.3134486675262451,
0.11776579916477203,
0.2236395925283432,
-0.4521736204624176,
0.8469445705413818,
-0.10061121731996536,
-0.7385172843933105,
0.5614729523658752,
0.750575840473175,
0.12337897717952728,
-0.2446065992116928,
-0.5636285543441772,
-0.026522137224674225,
-0.4926299750804901,
-0.44659197330474854,
0.2580036520957947,
0.38332656025886536,
0.03030548244714737,
0.6827618479728699,
0.9276814460754395,
-0.16718637943267822,
-0.3291380703449249,
-0.0635923445224762,
0.8765669465065002,
-1.0812920331954956,
-0.3937472999095917,
-0.8287984728813171,
-0.10060617327690125,
-0.2143649458885193,
-0.3930906057357788,
0.8117585778236389,
0.9019723534584045,
0.8281473517417908,
0.19640105962753296,
0.7685892581939697,
0.4698410928249359,
0.5067011713981628,
-0.4814564287662506,
0.7016305327415466,
-0.41030099987983704,
0.28447550535202026,
-0.429910272359848,
-1.0064564943313599,
-0.19919490814208984,
0.4303959608078003,
-0.41530975699424744,
-0.17380201816558838,
0.5910370349884033,
0.17984652519226074,
0.19530239701271057,
0.33657148480415344,
0.3929336369037628,
-0.06022238731384277,
-0.0544046051800251,
0.40917888283729553,
0.5413483381271362,
-0.25754958391189575,
0.425955206155777,
-0.17806074023246765,
-0.10751605778932571,
-0.2527676820755005,
-0.8407584428787231,
-0.9007057547569275,
-0.3647630512714386,
-0.18653525412082672,
0.06420815736055374,
0.18002104759216309,
1.1975431442260742,
0.07606732845306396,
-0.6907951831817627,
-0.7202821969985962,
0.16441625356674194,
0.06648243963718414,
-0.4993360638618469,
-0.15837211906909943,
0.2864447832107544,
-0.2082289457321167,
-0.5750220417976379,
0.448884516954422,
0.852872908115387,
0.1330583095550537,
-0.5802410840988159,
0.19340293109416962,
0.16817361116409302,
0.15642766654491425,
0.40385642647743225,
0.09315843135118484,
-0.4047231376171112,
0.03644318878650665,
0.040850065648555756,
-0.1670941561460495,
-0.03216199949383736,
0.7668784260749817,
-0.35398319363594055,
0.08286644518375397,
0.15529152750968933,
0.7590779662132263,
0.5897338390350342,
-0.09560614824295044,
0.8666988015174866,
-0.2697957158088684,
-0.022164253517985344,
-0.005813785828649998,
0.32599014043807983,
0.020733531564474106,
0.012078373692929745,
0.9215406775474548,
0.0956626906991005,
-0.021402498707175255,
-0.5102003216743469,
-0.46211162209510803,
-0.8903704881668091,
-0.3001399040222168,
0.7795386910438538,
-0.23192106187343597,
-0.575524091720581,
0.04018493741750717,
-0.03799887374043465,
-0.09543100744485855,
-0.43303316831588745,
0.49776917695999146,
0.9333779215812683,
0.16687819361686707,
0.007350114639848471,
-0.8849517107009888,
0.33562391996383667,
0.16951759159564972,
-0.9044124484062195,
0.30397799611091614,
0.23358820378780365,
0.1773591786623001,
-0.054671481251716614,
0.6461250185966492,
-0.11784286797046661,
0.3285079598426819,
0.21803542971611023,
0.22764085233211517,
-0.2566295862197876,
-0.19005611538887024,
-0.055252861231565475,
0.2280157059431076,
-0.030830927193164825,
0.22320964932441711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12654v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12654v2 | OWSM-CTC: An Open Encoder-Only Speech Foundation Model for Speech Recognition, Translation, and Language Identification | 2024-02-20T02:04:38 | 2024-06-16T20:58:43 | Yifan Peng, Yui Sudo, Muhammad Shakeel, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | There has been an increasing interest in large speech models that can perform
multiple tasks in a single model. Such models usually adopt an encoder-decoder
or decoder-only architecture due to their popularity and good performance in
many domains. However, autoregressive models can be slower during inference
compared to non-autoregressive models and also have potential risks of
hallucination. Though prior studies observed promising results of
non-autoregressive models for certain tasks at small scales, it remains unclear
if they can be scaled to speech-to-text generation in diverse languages and
tasks. Inspired by the Open Whisper-style Speech Model (OWSM) project, we
propose OWSM-CTC, a novel encoder-only speech foundation model based on
Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC). It is trained on 180k hours of
public audio data for multilingual automatic speech recognition (ASR), speech
translation (ST), and language identification (LID). Compared to
encoder-decoder OWSM, our OWSM-CTC achieves competitive results on ASR and up
to 24% relative improvement on ST, while it is more robust and 3 to 4 times
faster for inference. OWSM-CTC also improves the long-form ASR result with 20x
speed-up. We will publicly release our code, pre-trained model, and training
logs to promote open science in speech foundation models. | [
-0.23266349732875824,
-0.7184979915618896,
0.20041604340076447,
0.1438322812318802,
-0.25572264194488525,
-0.18608076870441437,
-0.270172655582428,
-0.6268624067306519,
-0.0372384674847126,
0.38739892840385437,
-0.4700106680393219,
-0.4754580855369568,
-0.7025379538536072,
0.25956597924232483,
-0.7394401431083679,
0.6242160201072693,
0.242855042219162,
-0.01650882698595524,
0.050009261816740036,
-0.21011678874492645,
0.031615741550922394,
-0.5683472752571106,
-0.7287349104881287,
-0.037208400666713715,
0.21406729519367218,
-0.0020732581615448,
0.546779215335846,
0.9000793695449829,
0.3295477628707886,
0.32243210077285767,
-0.21021103858947754,
-0.030848374590277672,
-0.3505394160747528,
-0.023919938132166862,
0.1883140653371811,
-0.40637046098709106,
-0.2072826623916626,
-0.120095394551754,
0.7195367217063904,
0.8652358651161194,
-0.4804374873638153,
0.05458713322877884,
0.1311393529176712,
0.44107547402381897,
-0.7534719705581665,
0.25279951095581055,
-0.6222556829452515,
0.002834661165252328,
-0.23741699755191803,
-0.06905233860015869,
-0.5422824621200562,
-0.39521872997283936,
0.33786728978157043,
-0.2336580753326416,
0.26161205768585205,
-0.1356363296508789,
0.4465373456478119,
0.1671392023563385,
-0.5581469535827637,
-0.21828807890415192,
-0.8000091910362244,
0.7289695143699646,
-0.7230122089385986,
0.8078963756561279,
0.20829911530017853,
0.3038884699344635,
0.04093938320875168,
-0.625112771987915,
-0.43454739451408386,
-0.17214293777942657,
0.17977827787399292,
0.005906577687710524,
-0.2651897668838501,
0.18674616515636444,
0.12614379823207855,
0.23732534050941467,
-0.709091067314148,
0.1418629288673401,
-0.33585119247436523,
-0.2509898841381073,
0.3761058747768402,
0.0844881683588028,
0.08888822793960571,
0.23079831898212433,
-0.4271387755870819,
0.009918536059558392,
-0.5990651845932007,
0.12360493838787079,
0.11381135135889053,
0.5715793371200562,
-0.4611515998840332,
0.46898722648620605,
-0.28718891739845276,
0.7439823150634766,
-0.07933325320482254,
-0.07301025092601776,
0.2620227336883545,
-0.12463623285293579,
-0.22537289559841156,
0.4500274062156677,
0.9295564889907837,
-0.25427448749542236,
-0.05060766264796257,
-0.38017454743385315,
-0.21320107579231262,
0.4155595600605011,
-0.0279485322535038,
-0.845065712928772,
-0.05737844482064247,
0.11754079908132553,
-0.7087744474411011,
-0.24815303087234497,
0.16185136139392853,
-0.5121319890022278,
0.11753686517477036,
-0.2899419367313385,
0.5391557216644287,
-0.1364917755126953,
-0.38076621294021606,
0.20387442409992218,
0.05859433114528656,
0.11270897835493088,
0.3164709508419037,
-0.590129017829895,
0.34250712394714355,
0.3698723018169403,
1.1204465627670288,
-0.3467739522457123,
-0.23049254715442657,
-0.605270504951477,
0.12511685490608215,
-0.373605340719223,
0.589430570602417,
-0.5448388457298279,
-0.5885239839553833,
0.041696131229400635,
0.04285790026187897,
-0.168355330824852,
-0.2173062562942505,
0.31478214263916016,
-0.3917689621448517,
0.040304653346538544,
0.11107586324214935,
-0.27100303769111633,
0.14992809295654297,
-0.18363887071609497,
-0.7335717082023621,
0.7045098543167114,
-0.1567673683166504,
-0.7015256881713867,
0.026489099487662315,
-0.8652920126914978,
-0.5280439257621765,
-0.14728300273418427,
-0.10877624154090881,
-0.2540283799171448,
0.07603681087493896,
0.19105243682861328,
0.2033722847700119,
-0.4699126183986664,
0.3102239668369293,
-0.2939832806587219,
-0.25266560912132263,
0.26822629570961,
-0.6585495471954346,
0.9887529015541077,
0.6600121259689331,
-0.3471857011318207,
0.04462748020887375,
-0.8605368137359619,
-0.007428002078086138,
0.05839022621512413,
-0.4786231517791748,
-0.15478065609931946,
-0.03560102358460426,
0.11999937891960144,
0.2851956784725189,
0.23081672191619873,
-0.8792787790298462,
-0.22553013265132904,
-0.5410709381103516,
0.7526451349258423,
0.614136278629303,
-0.22452564537525177,
0.3321433663368225,
-0.25900009274482727,
0.2741185426712036,
0.07419916242361069,
0.11094490438699722,
-0.17664271593093872,
-0.5272427797317505,
-0.7293020486831665,
-0.3496951162815094,
0.2785589396953583,
0.43426546454429626,
-0.6342044472694397,
0.5632149577140808,
-0.32058948278427124,
-0.637750506401062,
-0.715223491191864,
-0.4658704698085785,
0.48826736211776733,
0.5134202837944031,
0.4098314344882965,
-0.18896116316318512,
-0.5050293803215027,
-0.6851146817207336,
-0.18530230224132538,
-0.22520042955875397,
-0.19747556746006012,
0.028272777795791626,
0.43563759326934814,
-0.09447353333234787,
0.9610008001327515,
-0.2636224925518036,
-0.31376758217811584,
-0.1426304578781128,
0.29068270325660706,
0.05617854371666908,
0.5094078779220581,
0.3791324198246002,
-0.6811161041259766,
-0.315200537443161,
-0.025039056316018105,
-0.43860915303230286,
-0.3468559980392456,
0.25031542778015137,
0.08369103819131851,
0.33354178071022034,
0.4290377199649811,
-0.501274049282074,
0.50874924659729,
0.7542215585708618,
-0.15500234067440033,
0.37805020809173584,
-0.08642778545618057,
0.258680522441864,
-1.017715573310852,
0.259358674287796,
-0.23113076388835907,
-0.08944807201623917,
-0.6220687627792358,
-0.003752748016268015,
-0.06545059382915497,
-0.5249641537666321,
-0.5522788166999817,
0.4631364643573761,
-0.3664207458496094,
0.0737161934375763,
-0.16003133356571198,
0.08919882029294968,
-0.30006080865859985,
0.5288779139518738,
0.4812932014465332,
0.7196369171142578,
0.6524602770805359,
-0.8413973450660706,
0.06505217403173447,
0.34354937076568604,
-0.2654324173927307,
0.30625855922698975,
-0.6506847739219666,
0.3026750683784485,
0.004549545701593161,
0.2493649125099182,
-0.6837438941001892,
0.1359288990497589,
-0.2841450273990631,
-0.6708735227584839,
0.12125036120414734,
-0.040522389113903046,
-0.4274502694606781,
-0.3434331715106964,
0.1049816757440567,
0.22867095470428467,
0.49602097272872925,
-0.8686073422431946,
0.7884253859519958,
0.5500497817993164,
0.03579581156373024,
-0.3751598596572876,
-0.9553730487823486,
-0.24893616139888763,
0.07119795680046082,
-0.5799281001091003,
0.4385289251804352,
-0.19426707923412323,
0.03431081771850586,
-0.03414564207196236,
-0.25175702571868896,
-0.2929454743862152,
-0.10379903018474579,
0.252722829580307,
-0.0006065221969038248,
-0.4126904308795929,
0.09053143858909607,
-0.010775125585496426,
-0.12407290190458298,
-0.02967473492026329,
-0.37275949120521545,
0.3776439130306244,
-0.1509346067905426,
-0.41142550110816956,
-0.6760265827178955,
0.7121204137802124,
0.5856162309646606,
-0.5044304132461548,
0.6960967779159546,
0.40783241391181946,
-0.5296632647514343,
-0.07654136419296265,
-0.5762912034988403,
-0.2629658877849579,
-0.4559280276298523,
0.2571007013320923,
-0.5110824704170227,
-1.0282913446426392,
0.3072258532047272,
-0.008454177528619766,
0.33325350284576416,
0.4622284770011902,
0.5409356951713562,
0.14745192229747772,
1.3064990043640137,
0.6669230461120605,
-0.3454045355319977,
0.5102472901344299,
-0.12199615687131882,
0.08933695405721664,
-0.4162387251853943,
-0.2573275864124298,
-1.1322801113128662,
0.040930211544036865,
-0.466961532831192,
-0.38768893480300903,
0.35447895526885986,
-0.0788348987698555,
-0.27100858092308044,
0.5482230186462402,
-0.4337000846862793,
-0.014266195707023144,
0.3052951991558075,
-0.03845035284757614,
0.3926180601119995,
0.0054490938782691956,
-0.21271057426929474,
0.22156332433223724,
-0.6883911490440369,
-0.37435391545295715,
1.0337132215499878,
0.26645103096961975,
0.808383584022522,
0.2482348382472992,
0.5909918546676636,
0.25622034072875977,
0.08382640033960342,
-0.5749722719192505,
0.4701690077781677,
-0.42203861474990845,
-0.532077431678772,
-0.2817021906375885,
-0.6424661874771118,
-0.853912353515625,
0.3786841332912445,
-0.16043108701705933,
-0.7225803136825562,
0.29450464248657227,
0.3084714114665985,
-0.19020161032676697,
0.3889645040035248,
-0.4986000955104828,
0.6768548488616943,
-0.06357445567846298,
0.02051781862974167,
-0.24179904162883759,
-0.7172495722770691,
-0.09005117416381836,
0.07767047733068466,
0.29823654890060425,
-0.021091686561703682,
-0.10232499241828918,
0.7610805034637451,
-0.4835730791091919,
0.7536148428916931,
-0.3064879775047302,
0.027378393337130547,
0.5674352049827576,
0.09944432228803635,
0.6052803993225098,
-0.2836271822452545,
-0.14304210245609283,
0.5502647757530212,
0.08704730123281479,
-0.08239513635635376,
-0.4206070601940155,
0.6064878106117249,
-0.764575183391571,
-0.3742043673992157,
-0.13695000112056732,
-0.1632423996925354,
-0.32178372144699097,
0.041464533656835556,
0.3761747181415558,
0.727295994758606,
-0.4269956648349762,
0.6047460436820984,
0.660772979259491,
0.27716195583343506,
0.5635664463043213,
0.8053001761436462,
0.18723247945308685,
-0.44157785177230835,
0.7630512118339539,
-0.04787537828087807,
0.41003915667533875,
0.7321750521659851,
0.2830604910850525,
-0.3962111175060272,
-0.6069095730781555,
-0.2685803472995758,
0.09632905572652817,
-0.48119741678237915,
-0.11500024795532227,
-1.0599586963653564,
-0.3958560824394226,
-0.6464921832084656,
-0.13274404406547546,
-0.6782979965209961,
-0.4440177083015442,
-0.4659835994243622,
0.14325003325939178,
0.21595069766044617,
0.36586740612983704,
-0.19572249054908752,
0.40691158175468445,
-0.8741478323936462,
0.38367199897766113,
0.30876314640045166,
0.08922220021486282,
-0.0963030681014061,
-0.6718246936798096,
-0.14883722364902496,
0.22140629589557648,
-0.1450645625591278,
-0.7645552158355713,
0.3380962312221527,
0.439365953207016,
0.5131738185882568,
0.6069402694702148,
0.22708064317703247,
0.73389732837677,
-0.38327157497406006,
0.687338650226593,
0.4342459738254547,
-1.0710560083389282,
0.5051786303520203,
-0.11856083571910858,
0.5381098389625549,
0.26952263712882996,
0.22597210109233856,
-0.5187110304832458,
-0.4667782783508301,
-0.3680078685283661,
-0.5347552299499512,
0.7744799256324768,
0.3876340985298157,
-0.11898832023143768,
-0.16396914422512054,
-0.12525412440299988,
0.16015635430812836,
0.305122971534729,
-0.4779748022556305,
-0.035143401473760605,
-0.43259531259536743,
-0.38158777356147766,
0.04881865903735161,
-0.07962603867053986,
0.0777549296617508,
0.04928639158606529,
0.6892383694648743,
-0.3362317979335785,
0.5441238284111023,
0.40620535612106323,
-0.14840251207351685,
-0.12959933280944824,
0.4563184976577759,
0.3589705228805542,
0.1582793891429901,
-0.03550742566585541,
0.057280056178569794,
0.1613287627696991,
-0.46713787317276,
-0.032988905906677246,
0.2124013602733612,
0.07726266235113144,
0.01686755195260048,
0.3878706991672516,
0.910929262638092,
0.24411283433437347,
-0.6756104230880737,
0.5575606226921082,
0.020436203107237816,
-0.21267962455749512,
-0.3432820439338684,
-0.02993013523519039,
0.024342745542526245,
0.12473972886800766,
0.36028239130973816,
0.1806902140378952,
0.2584935128688812,
-0.41533324122428894,
0.06509925425052643,
0.39945635199546814,
-0.6015618443489075,
-0.4427327811717987,
0.8569797873497009,
0.47847867012023926,
-0.20498746633529663,
0.5963477492332458,
0.22613222897052765,
-0.2953636348247528,
0.7404335737228394,
0.7415544390678406,
1.067871332168579,
-0.6691502928733826,
-0.24932309985160828,
0.4236198663711548,
0.34039366245269775,
-0.16138599812984467,
0.3146974742412567,
-0.44488123059272766,
-0.5302545428276062,
-0.04574436694383621,
-0.7951588034629822,
-0.06923915445804596,
0.05708272382616997,
-0.8728707432746887,
0.24260658025741577,
-0.056884344667196274,
-0.29357343912124634,
-0.22774146497249603,
-0.350589781999588,
-0.6298916935920715,
0.1912713646888733,
0.0761861503124237,
1.0980416536331177,
-0.7427926063537598,
1.168980360031128,
0.26418131589889526,
0.03999347239732742,
-0.5124638676643372,
-0.1265808343887329,
0.15951156616210938,
-0.5686442852020264,
0.3931125998497009,
0.31521302461624146,
-0.6159780621528625,
0.29790201783180237,
-0.341932088136673,
-0.960617184638977,
1.0365487337112427,
0.3420311510562897,
-0.8560413718223572,
-0.35650473833084106,
0.12520287930965424,
0.4882585406303406,
-0.6756311655044556,
-0.04672420769929886,
0.34008514881134033,
0.16445618867874146,
0.17474772036075592,
-1.3236501216888428,
-0.1940944492816925,
-0.0725189670920372,
0.23800696432590485,
0.26804640889167786,
-0.46960678696632385,
0.8404831886291504,
-0.5157577991485596,
-0.5160719752311707,
0.4453209638595581,
0.6676040291786194,
0.1657896488904953,
0.031200820580124855,
0.6755171418190002,
0.47087913751602173,
0.28838205337524414,
-0.1362120360136032,
0.6130692958831787,
-0.30629998445510864,
0.23423612117767334,
1.1377569437026978,
-0.1481810212135315,
1.085379719734192,
0.3506139814853668,
-0.1793985515832901,
0.2409103363752365,
0.34714430570602417,
0.15524819493293762,
0.8764370679855347,
-0.10665043443441391,
-0.2454492449760437,
-0.3449270725250244,
-0.24495480954647064,
-0.5265800356864929,
0.6265435814857483,
0.4230208694934845,
-0.5044735670089722,
-0.11981215327978134,
0.24938663840293884,
-0.19347986578941345,
0.047834061086177826,
-0.3489653468132019,
0.8237943053245544,
0.19646099209785461,
-0.2853230834007263,
0.4409727156162262,
0.017696229740977287,
0.6997365951538086,
-0.9747523069381714,
-0.050742410123348236,
0.28070253133773804,
0.0631343349814415,
0.009919983334839344,
-0.30364710092544556,
0.33991748094558716,
-0.05477520823478699,
-0.06167813390493393,
-0.08654266595840454,
0.5033990740776062,
-0.7007138729095459,
-0.21480292081832886,
0.48545175790786743,
0.2781452536582947,
0.09607688337564468,
-0.1658550202846527,
-0.5081212520599365,
0.18578855693340302,
-0.15119506418704987,
-0.07048199325799942,
0.09615416079759598,
0.273384153842926,
0.10487080365419388,
0.6416172981262207,
0.8401314616203308,
0.003674675477668643,
0.14290378987789154,
0.14676633477210999,
0.5752797722816467,
-0.5256406664848328,
-0.9432482123374939,
-0.5482721924781799,
0.28205424547195435,
0.2025885283946991,
-0.24927076697349548,
0.25820279121398926,
0.6700013279914856,
0.7881329655647278,
-0.18781834840774536,
0.7249906063079834,
-0.1013287603855133,
0.5537168383598328,
-0.5281397700309753,
0.8788708448410034,
-0.584810733795166,
-0.18509286642074585,
-0.019281161949038506,
-0.4878346621990204,
-0.006009459961205721,
0.49537593126296997,
0.16135351359844208,
-0.04204445704817772,
0.8383005857467651,
0.7351391315460205,
0.2496403455734253,
0.520659863948822,
0.5164442658424377,
0.25851574540138245,
0.26308125257492065,
0.5834338665008545,
0.558235228061676,
-0.31681379675865173,
0.9448525905609131,
-0.4065481424331665,
-0.20428621768951416,
-0.16940711438655853,
-0.6125730276107788,
-0.9366585612297058,
-0.9511573910713196,
-0.36960652470588684,
-0.11282680928707123,
0.13894662261009216,
1.0300525426864624,
0.9041396975517273,
-0.8671227097511292,
-0.31142836809158325,
-0.09644556045532227,
-0.3400622010231018,
-0.49726027250289917,
-0.20582351088523865,
0.30223751068115234,
-0.049841925501823425,
-0.7199655175209045,
0.6960853338241577,
0.2925572097301483,
0.14032018184661865,
-0.20381204783916473,
0.013056622818112373,
0.06720640510320663,
0.1400553584098816,
0.5691000819206238,
0.2736736238002777,
-0.9247795939445496,
-0.169398233294487,
-0.06622228771448135,
-0.18282368779182434,
0.07321424782276154,
1.0908507108688354,
-0.7099946737289429,
0.6851629018783569,
0.40334415435791016,
0.4377721846103668,
0.4614000618457794,
-0.44069406390190125,
0.5184800624847412,
-0.4046506881713867,
0.3071292042732239,
0.386726438999176,
0.43805640935897827,
0.09809735417366028,
-0.23234285414218903,
0.3011943995952606,
0.2467096447944641,
-0.3138674795627594,
-0.7824395895004272,
0.24093669652938843,
-0.8849968314170837,
-0.1590365320444107,
0.7850117683410645,
-0.1992238610982895,
-0.3728905916213989,
-0.2270367443561554,
0.04108266532421112,
0.46037739515304565,
-0.7410116791725159,
0.5938428640365601,
0.29736021161079407,
-0.002422929974272847,
0.05072269216179848,
-0.3304425776004791,
0.31801584362983704,
-0.18115314841270447,
-0.800195038318634,
0.2499905675649643,
0.3022003769874573,
0.28000205755233765,
0.08582725375890732,
0.697823703289032,
-0.5035879015922546,
0.3055903911590576,
0.18689914047718048,
0.10055231302976608,
-0.2236226201057434,
-0.4989425539970398,
-0.33827823400497437,
0.3936518132686615,
-0.12691107392311096,
-0.4036291837692261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14850v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14850v1 | CHATATC: Large Language Model-Driven Conversational Agents for Supporting Strategic Air Traffic Flow Management | 2024-02-20T01:59:11 | 2024-02-20T01:59:11 | Sinan Abdulhak, Wayne Hubbard, Karthik Gopalakrishnan, Max Z. Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generative artificial intelligence (AI) and large language models (LLMs) have
gained rapid popularity through publicly available tools such as ChatGPT. The
adoption of LLMs for personal and professional use is fueled by the natural
interactions between human users and computer applications such as ChatGPT,
along with powerful summarization and text generation capabilities. Given the
widespread use of such generative AI tools, in this work we investigate how
these tools can be deployed in a non-safety critical, strategic traffic flow
management setting. Specifically, we train an LLM, CHATATC, based on a large
historical data set of Ground Delay Program (GDP) issuances, spanning 2000-2023
and consisting of over 80,000 GDP implementations, revisions, and
cancellations. We test the query and response capabilities of CHATATC,
documenting successes (e.g., providing correct GDP rates, durations, and
reason) and shortcomings (e.g,. superlative questions). We also detail the
design of a graphical user interface for future users to interact and
collaborate with the CHATATC conversational agent. | [
-0.45158660411834717,
-1.059157371520996,
0.535647451877594,
0.5203267931938171,
-0.1184096410870552,
0.5507882833480835,
-0.23763419687747955,
-0.23618826270103455,
0.13173410296440125,
0.5634140372276306,
-0.5859127640724182,
-0.4478512406349182,
-0.41259390115737915,
-0.1467931568622589,
-0.6853287816047668,
0.9475120902061462,
0.017148662358522415,
-0.31197282671928406,
-0.11980701982975006,
-0.0055244783870875835,
-0.5366421937942505,
-0.8641458749771118,
-0.9640135169029236,
-0.3322236239910126,
0.41082867980003357,
0.5197630524635315,
1.2060341835021973,
0.09042350202798843,
0.711786687374115,
0.35375940799713135,
-0.04552360624074936,
0.2623320519924164,
-0.5706947445869446,
0.12284103780984879,
-0.03605210781097412,
-0.15432782471179962,
-0.3890627920627594,
-0.031647711992263794,
0.6865774989128113,
0.5535935163497925,
-0.6321545243263245,
-0.38285547494888306,
-0.08514247834682465,
0.4819307029247284,
-0.20492112636566162,
0.5004153847694397,
-0.7084602117538452,
-0.2643117308616638,
-0.10006015747785568,
-0.4029631018638611,
-0.30408570170402527,
-0.3316175639629364,
0.3124299943447113,
-0.6031112670898438,
-0.10565198212862015,
0.10246049612760544,
0.8654441237449646,
0.34024518728256226,
-0.6007968783378601,
-0.5037086606025696,
-0.7701247334480286,
0.46691620349884033,
-0.5351423025131226,
0.15299709141254425,
0.11601084470748901,
0.573434054851532,
-0.5348580479621887,
-0.6726251840591431,
-0.4781593680381775,
-0.48640763759613037,
0.1851978451013565,
0.45353999733924866,
0.0023351081181317568,
0.31060734391212463,
0.09090200066566467,
0.1573302298784256,
-0.9440664052963257,
0.11257320642471313,
-0.2622188925743103,
-0.026084251701831818,
0.6752654910087585,
0.6301013827323914,
0.13085143268108368,
0.2563169300556183,
-0.3237220346927643,
-0.01682382822036743,
-0.7686008214950562,
-0.20611372590065002,
0.2609560489654541,
0.21448978781700134,
-0.3797577917575836,
0.5254459977149963,
-0.32174184918403625,
0.6041839122772217,
-0.45110568404197693,
0.08507958054542542,
0.1303456574678421,
0.014853660017251968,
-0.3655943274497986,
-0.23515525460243225,
0.7985355854034424,
0.05383368581533432,
0.5506443977355957,
-0.353298544883728,
-0.14105258882045746,
-0.16350607573986053,
0.38691362738609314,
-0.7955525517463684,
-0.333906352519989,
0.21468999981880188,
-0.23872071504592896,
-0.42474016547203064,
0.09139259904623032,
-0.703595757484436,
-0.2899884879589081,
-0.5396586060523987,
0.06653707474470139,
-0.3987046480178833,
-0.39124783873558044,
0.009020323865115643,
0.06358151137828827,
0.6543628573417664,
0.6087106466293335,
-0.6920568346977234,
0.06540185213088989,
0.7520891427993774,
1.110409140586853,
-0.10406087338924408,
-0.37539544701576233,
-0.39280685782432556,
0.0047801160253584385,
-0.5714086890220642,
0.954468309879303,
-0.6760469079017639,
-0.7674503922462463,
0.09909813851118088,
0.0009176019812002778,
-0.22301965951919556,
-0.5147432684898376,
0.32245883345603943,
-0.7884233593940735,
-0.11683973670005798,
0.20546860992908478,
-0.3371611535549164,
-0.10149363428354263,
0.356984406709671,
-0.3835545778274536,
0.7079415917396545,
0.1438111960887909,
-0.34320852160453796,
0.04941893368959427,
-0.7855459451675415,
-0.5593269467353821,
0.2896639108657837,
-0.308803528547287,
-0.4366075098514557,
-0.2636658847332001,
0.11410681903362274,
0.3554210066795349,
-0.33022981882095337,
0.33593931794166565,
-0.007127008866518736,
-0.20562556385993958,
0.31735607981681824,
-0.6300594210624695,
0.6174301505088806,
0.5370422005653381,
-0.13626152276992798,
0.39065417647361755,
-0.36221203207969666,
0.10111134499311447,
0.09781160950660706,
-0.4994460940361023,
0.42821159958839417,
0.21361100673675537,
0.26661980152130127,
0.19574958086013794,
-0.05123349279165268,
0.037205833941698074,
0.08241332322359085,
-0.19935375452041626,
0.6354491114616394,
0.8514487147331238,
0.20191675424575806,
-0.024592801928520203,
-0.5367415547370911,
0.7203867435455322,
-0.04270778223872185,
0.0013438528403639793,
-0.12721531093120575,
-0.8229926228523254,
-0.7918740510940552,
0.03489101678133011,
-0.027741873636841774,
0.6793956160545349,
-0.8165451884269714,
0.16953317821025848,
-0.4359833002090454,
-0.7300588488578796,
0.1110590472817421,
-0.06486891210079193,
-0.2716215252876282,
0.4731029272079468,
-0.07358702272176743,
0.10518383234739304,
-0.3452097177505493,
-0.5266488790512085,
0.13449227809906006,
-0.7503206133842468,
0.007958627305924892,
0.4208180606365204,
0.2936655879020691,
-0.24452273547649384,
0.7591055035591125,
-0.4671981632709503,
-0.01139073632657528,
-0.527072012424469,
0.5817103981971741,
-0.05484338104724884,
0.3165200650691986,
0.4572869539260864,
-0.7516703009605408,
-0.3478376865386963,
0.0002637296565808356,
-0.5951058268547058,
-0.12747658789157867,
-0.3690090775489807,
-0.42364928126335144,
0.27781856060028076,
0.6570910811424255,
-0.6392667293548584,
0.35655903816223145,
0.6415174007415771,
-0.3066500425338745,
0.5403315424919128,
-0.19377337396144867,
0.260996013879776,
-0.765520453453064,
0.11544855684041977,
-0.25438952445983887,
-0.37447452545166016,
-0.6879103779792786,
-0.019599758088588715,
-0.33002975583076477,
-0.6250630617141724,
-0.622847318649292,
0.3027673065662384,
-0.039615750312805176,
0.12005197256803513,
-0.3174666166305542,
0.11835842579603195,
-0.3328102231025696,
0.5408455729484558,
0.36728695034980774,
1.1448228359222412,
0.7147905826568604,
-0.6693023443222046,
0.3145034611225128,
0.381573349237442,
-0.13626983761787415,
0.6641315221786499,
-0.6091557741165161,
0.2834448218345642,
-0.20543146133422852,
0.18860357999801636,
-0.9703231453895569,
-0.39296531677246094,
0.08203419297933578,
-0.2842704653739929,
-0.2104821503162384,
-0.2512846887111664,
-0.4708760976791382,
-0.18974964320659637,
0.2981739938259125,
0.05070130527019501,
0.8377990126609802,
-0.44456154108047485,
0.8684666156768799,
0.5231502652168274,
-0.1462729126214981,
0.16988182067871094,
-0.6066194772720337,
0.6156423687934875,
-0.33727967739105225,
-0.8856139779090881,
-0.10917405039072037,
-0.07597770541906357,
-0.24873903393745422,
-0.34004804491996765,
0.22307424247264862,
-0.17383363842964172,
0.4044102728366852,
0.5910805463790894,
0.27439233660697937,
-0.17695386707782745,
0.1583896279335022,
-0.6160865426063538,
-0.08965802937746048,
0.2321140617132187,
-0.244923397898674,
0.7045776844024658,
-0.478156179189682,
-0.5805528163909912,
-0.38033586740493774,
0.40994536876678467,
0.7492379546165466,
-0.30994322896003723,
0.8390427231788635,
0.5302544832229614,
-0.02110643871128559,
0.084684818983078,
-0.5281063914299011,
0.05936490744352341,
-0.5030073523521423,
0.3083738684654236,
-0.2693662643432617,
-0.7941539883613586,
0.4556933343410492,
-0.3086104094982147,
0.2427818477153778,
0.19566376507282257,
0.8382401466369629,
-0.07508862763643265,
1.0422923564910889,
0.4083545207977295,
-0.2937500774860382,
0.5529912710189819,
-0.3824630677700043,
0.1956861913204193,
-0.28033143281936646,
-0.554608941078186,
-0.3728310465812683,
-0.13936683535575867,
-0.652885913848877,
-0.4142339527606964,
0.47818368673324585,
-0.31863582134246826,
-0.3577568829059601,
-0.13064363598823547,
0.032275985926389694,
0.28900831937789917,
0.4789906442165375,
-0.06993165612220764,
0.2238343209028244,
-0.006751955021172762,
0.428426593542099,
0.5098462700843811,
-0.6636985540390015,
-0.6285110116004944,
0.8318437337875366,
0.22923168540000916,
1.1041969060897827,
0.31074416637420654,
0.2500121593475342,
0.3133147358894348,
0.3531220555305481,
-0.9120400547981262,
0.826873242855072,
-0.010191794484853745,
-0.3514416813850403,
-0.175007626414299,
-0.6302117109298706,
-1.0742286443710327,
0.03956042230129242,
0.036123376339673996,
-0.5208832621574402,
-0.33287960290908813,
0.18784897029399872,
-0.315292090177536,
0.3059474527835846,
-0.8721378445625305,
0.7499901056289673,
-0.4569939076900482,
-0.034949470311403275,
-0.46500301361083984,
-0.519779622554779,
-0.02160820923745632,
0.011622012592852116,
-0.14911171793937683,
-0.3780094385147095,
0.006935330107808113,
0.5287511348724365,
-0.6587085723876953,
0.5422772765159607,
-0.004643419291824102,
0.10200253129005432,
0.7072600722312927,
0.16148926317691803,
0.733725368976593,
0.02555648423731327,
-0.0016782846068963408,
0.44076672196388245,
-0.34042710065841675,
-0.3878763020038605,
-0.5274339914321899,
0.5938319563865662,
-0.8553869128227234,
-0.7539778351783752,
-0.31463199853897095,
-0.4874367415904999,
-0.42112165689468384,
-0.028087865561246872,
-0.2913743257522583,
0.4301292598247528,
-0.38671955466270447,
0.16600051522254944,
0.26064562797546387,
-0.08476634323596954,
0.444210410118103,
0.6034940481185913,
-0.13614732027053833,
-0.026385346427559853,
0.7874860167503357,
-0.15286213159561157,
0.4314207136631012,
0.2638992369174957,
0.11862338334321976,
-0.30398690700531006,
-0.6932907104492188,
-0.3712984025478363,
-0.11281952261924744,
-0.35066038370132446,
-0.020743604749441147,
-0.6505373120307922,
-0.7040577530860901,
-0.2374846190214157,
-0.23352012038230896,
-0.12598660588264465,
-0.06290559470653534,
-0.23435084521770477,
-0.06558545678853989,
0.5786141753196716,
0.5866503119468689,
0.08478228002786636,
0.8530991077423096,
-0.37236329913139343,
0.14705097675323486,
0.34155508875846863,
0.1936839520931244,
-0.04926352947950363,
-0.3199891448020935,
-0.25779926776885986,
0.01200086995959282,
-0.577429473400116,
-0.593403697013855,
0.42385268211364746,
0.19948098063468933,
0.4943726360797882,
0.4309569299221039,
-0.17106831073760986,
0.7547897100448608,
-0.3014694154262543,
0.9182332754135132,
-0.16629557311534882,
-0.5735388398170471,
0.5917943716049194,
-0.45409974455833435,
0.3085837662220001,
0.24745570123195648,
0.025104977190494537,
-0.8786767721176147,
-0.7156509160995483,
-0.5370014905929565,
-0.7203081846237183,
0.7321268916130066,
0.6235225796699524,
0.1700446456670761,
-0.07965501397848129,
-0.08499541133642197,
-0.43303677439689636,
0.3001912832260132,
-0.07517319917678833,
0.022493725642561913,
-0.35672739148139954,
-0.1617077887058258,
-0.019020015373826027,
0.01947632245719433,
-0.004864799324423075,
0.5293881893157959,
0.7924449443817139,
-0.24699006974697113,
0.1442490667104721,
-0.04023326188325882,
0.09242847561836243,
0.2520696222782135,
0.4040667414665222,
0.48141732811927795,
0.8426331281661987,
-0.1396225541830063,
0.0265912264585495,
0.028369108214974403,
-0.43144118785858154,
0.09328960627317429,
0.07990656793117523,
-0.08409659564495087,
-0.18465866148471832,
0.18619967997074127,
0.6762246489524841,
-0.21000936627388,
-1.0999642610549927,
0.32366082072257996,
0.015649449080228806,
-0.1721762716770172,
-0.4930115342140198,
0.06647424399852753,
-0.10565458983182907,
0.21693986654281616,
0.11644569039344788,
-0.08162442594766617,
0.031179269775748253,
-0.34453994035720825,
0.09762027859687805,
0.6217814683914185,
-0.1868429183959961,
-0.054637107998132706,
0.870599627494812,
0.5057511329650879,
-0.2649305462837219,
0.9966617822647095,
-0.21981434524059296,
-0.6243979334831238,
0.7316682934761047,
0.044378094375133514,
0.8519567251205444,
0.04406401887536049,
0.4144464433193207,
-0.0071807801723480225,
0.26635733246803284,
-0.03820362314581871,
0.3371817171573639,
0.21226468682289124,
-0.5156700015068054,
-0.41874024271965027,
-0.09330693632364273,
-0.6341182589530945,
0.3564552664756775,
-0.15927627682685852,
0.24991728365421295,
-0.5015047192573547,
-0.2736735939979553,
-0.36667636036872864,
-0.02024558000266552,
-0.8828551173210144,
-0.11758064478635788,
0.25863730907440186,
0.8677613735198975,
-0.6907439827919006,
0.38790348172187805,
0.6749361157417297,
-0.45854631066322327,
-1.092930793762207,
0.13026927411556244,
0.2900190055370331,
-1.0194647312164307,
0.5636313557624817,
0.038230810314416885,
-0.13644540309906006,
0.04852752014994621,
-0.34682610630989075,
-0.6595128178596497,
0.9851005673408508,
0.04087531566619873,
-0.37642887234687805,
0.01846381649374962,
0.5755382776260376,
0.5755620002746582,
0.026243820786476135,
0.47777602076530457,
0.492850661277771,
0.31102854013442993,
0.5818591117858887,
-0.8694072961807251,
-0.21652309596538544,
0.14880502223968506,
0.1282976120710373,
0.13220636546611786,
-1.0939546823501587,
0.5762590169906616,
-0.05661456286907196,
-0.3948844373226166,
0.2763545513153076,
0.5693249702453613,
0.18573100864887238,
0.16765567660331726,
0.5452168583869934,
0.40132197737693787,
0.6689121127128601,
-0.3063623905181885,
0.8869273066520691,
-0.32156312465667725,
0.020658444613218307,
0.8848434686660767,
-0.3661315143108368,
0.5993977785110474,
0.4491719603538513,
-0.11865994334220886,
0.5892952084541321,
0.5622458457946777,
0.07529360800981522,
0.4332488179206848,
0.2380819320678711,
-0.3345414698123932,
-0.34827983379364014,
-0.26577791571617126,
-0.13403931260108948,
0.5244624018669128,
0.29980480670928955,
0.08554904907941818,
-0.41868671774864197,
-0.004141667392104864,
0.15092210471630096,
-0.296817809343338,
-0.38227951526641846,
0.9094283580780029,
-0.003515357617288828,
-0.819183886051178,
0.3316437304019928,
-0.1257687509059906,
0.15818342566490173,
-0.7859301567077637,
-0.03428955003619194,
-0.3756023943424225,
0.09387771040201187,
-0.01974945329129696,
-1.1530113220214844,
0.36249083280563354,
0.04972026124596596,
0.3858872056007385,
-0.323419451713562,
0.3652673661708832,
-0.20742158591747284,
-0.4290347397327423,
-0.14554192125797272,
0.6442709565162659,
0.40997329354286194,
-0.35437238216400146,
-0.6357486844062805,
0.06637565791606903,
-0.20707818865776062,
-0.06937626749277115,
-0.023381656035780907,
0.5941051840782166,
-0.21638527512550354,
1.2330232858657837,
0.6622409820556641,
0.33184102177619934,
-0.107997365295887,
0.5440079569816589,
0.8453118205070496,
-0.5740241408348083,
-0.8074610233306885,
-0.8323121070861816,
0.44258764386177063,
-0.02200646512210369,
-0.12593136727809906,
0.502630352973938,
0.5421807765960693,
0.36467716097831726,
0.0729236751794815,
0.9330757260322571,
-0.07382088899612427,
0.1908566802740097,
-0.6676357388496399,
0.527765691280365,
-0.1978776901960373,
0.4503738582134247,
0.06952814757823944,
-0.3700813055038452,
-0.05948345735669136,
0.38052767515182495,
-0.2800156772136688,
0.05368024483323097,
0.2960752546787262,
1.151861548423767,
0.14280740916728973,
0.12606637179851532,
0.3022541105747223,
-0.0287602711468935,
1.0644762516021729,
0.7866345643997192,
1.3890998363494873,
0.0835578590631485,
1.068092703819275,
0.03703748807311058,
-0.16269844770431519,
-0.4837011396884918,
-0.7385600805282593,
-1.1487914323806763,
-0.3695632517337799,
-0.4934792220592499,
-0.22188742458820343,
0.30671700835227966,
0.9022086262702942,
1.0190035104751587,
-0.6389378309249878,
-0.33669281005859375,
-0.5284400582313538,
0.14483484625816345,
-0.010347421281039715,
-0.3061383068561554,
0.10327593982219696,
-0.4097799062728882,
-0.44272834062576294,
0.2103736698627472,
0.23087738454341888,
0.5578805804252625,
-0.42866963148117065,
-0.2636534869670868,
0.23123914003372192,
0.14680585265159607,
0.3156263828277588,
0.24990400671958923,
-0.41432514786720276,
-0.23636017739772797,
-0.040896546095609665,
0.07382125407457352,
0.11645814031362534,
1.125874400138855,
-0.7286798357963562,
0.09625218063592911,
0.27459895610809326,
0.7556246519088745,
0.22397693991661072,
0.38626694679260254,
0.5417221784591675,
-0.5806847214698792,
0.3306214213371277,
0.2625112533569336,
0.17168670892715454,
0.23584334552288055,
-0.1558108627796173,
0.49994397163391113,
0.07628238946199417,
-0.8600617051124573,
-0.3492962419986725,
0.046369604766368866,
-0.9827976822853088,
0.008005370385944843,
1.3006515502929688,
0.021417781710624695,
0.1667986512184143,
-0.2881368398666382,
-0.4852342903614044,
-0.1301245093345642,
-0.7140405774116516,
0.6893901824951172,
0.5544869899749756,
-0.2464618980884552,
-0.07973219454288483,
-0.6937462687492371,
0.2775847017765045,
0.10678956657648087,
-1.2573484182357788,
0.1951438933610916,
0.5457638502120972,
0.0453130342066288,
-0.1514633297920227,
0.7370398640632629,
0.08061712235212326,
-0.1018480584025383,
0.0003800257691182196,
-0.4025099277496338,
-0.05717862397432327,
-0.30461329221725464,
0.009932422079145908,
-0.028050009161233902,
0.22385692596435547,
-0.24142694473266602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12649v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12649v1 | Bias in Language Models: Beyond Trick Tests and Toward RUTEd Evaluation | 2024-02-20T01:49:15 | 2024-02-20T01:49:15 | Kristian Lum, Jacy Reese Anthis, Chirag Nagpal, Alexander D'Amour | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.AP | Bias benchmarks are a popular method for studying the negative impacts of
bias in LLMs, yet there has been little empirical investigation of whether
these benchmarks are actually indicative of how real world harm may manifest in
the real world. In this work, we study the correspondence between such
decontextualized "trick tests" and evaluations that are more grounded in
Realistic Use and Tangible {Effects (i.e. RUTEd evaluations). We explore this
correlation in the context of gender-occupation bias--a popular genre of bias
evaluation. We compare three de-contextualized evaluations adapted from the
current literature to three analogous RUTEd evaluations applied to long-form
content generation. We conduct each evaluation for seven instruction-tuned
LLMs. For the RUTEd evaluations, we conduct repeated trials of three text
generation tasks: children's bedtime stories, user personas, and English
language learning exercises. We found no correspondence between trick tests and
RUTEd evaluations. Specifically, selecting the least biased model based on the
de-contextualized results coincides with selecting the model with the best
performance on RUTEd evaluations only as often as random chance. We conclude
that evaluations that are not based in realistic use are likely insufficient to
mitigate and assess bias and real-world harms. | [
-0.034725841134786606,
-0.8569889664649963,
0.2717161178588867,
0.38440853357315063,
0.042112234979867935,
-0.10050822794437408,
-0.16822683811187744,
-0.4040270149707794,
-0.0676853358745575,
0.25928419828414917,
-0.7269260883331299,
-0.1823950558900833,
-0.5044394731521606,
-0.04502970352768898,
-0.599207878112793,
1.1180288791656494,
0.0905207097530365,
0.4964125156402588,
-0.5357276797294617,
0.16022424399852753,
-0.7579881548881531,
-0.4441733658313751,
0.023554353043437004,
-0.6205930113792419,
0.5174959897994995,
0.20780637860298157,
0.511635959148407,
0.4718065857887268,
0.3509224057197571,
0.1592124104499817,
-0.026668280363082886,
-0.37559640407562256,
-0.5163334608078003,
0.254773885011673,
-0.28666916489601135,
-0.5174726247787476,
-0.11019067466259003,
0.4695548117160797,
0.3409944772720337,
0.9069975018501282,
0.03243507444858551,
0.3238709568977356,
0.1811365932226181,
0.6600351333618164,
-0.8244013786315918,
-0.17076042294502258,
-0.4764615595340729,
0.25729236006736755,
-0.10482902079820633,
-0.11238053441047668,
-0.49351152777671814,
-0.41110754013061523,
0.19188274443149567,
-0.1722591072320938,
0.24697697162628174,
-0.04356370121240616,
1.0056506395339966,
0.22653459012508392,
-0.5950847268104553,
-0.468014657497406,
-0.6935173273086548,
1.2091223001480103,
-0.39270901679992676,
0.6256051063537598,
0.3788038492202759,
0.20915870368480682,
-0.211326003074646,
-0.4062352478504181,
-0.20879951119422913,
-0.49022969603538513,
0.015627915039658546,
0.17588716745376587,
-0.16627967357635498,
-0.12355948239564896,
0.522761344909668,
0.045024413615465164,
-0.20144015550613403,
0.154425710439682,
-0.2233278751373291,
-0.08993609249591827,
0.6572483777999878,
0.18664903938770294,
0.31910935044288635,
-0.22111934423446655,
-0.5216903686523438,
-0.294475257396698,
-0.9990777373313904,
-0.1180807501077652,
0.719655454158783,
0.1765921413898468,
-0.07365091890096664,
0.5369088053703308,
0.09188063442707062,
0.5419521927833557,
-0.024528449401259422,
-0.39612099528312683,
0.09682554751634598,
-0.14125634729862213,
-0.22366496920585632,
-0.194001242518425,
0.5797982811927795,
0.4269346594810486,
0.5321118831634521,
-0.3651796877384186,
-0.19414503872394562,
0.40848878026008606,
0.2934315800666809,
-0.6059486865997314,
0.060533855110406876,
-0.20363031327724457,
-0.36688339710235596,
-0.632627546787262,
0.0435904897749424,
-1.1162980794906616,
-0.5247761011123657,
-0.1551237553358078,
0.3089621067047119,
-0.15831243991851807,
-0.07556197047233582,
-0.01036022324115038,
-0.3411061763763428,
0.1478482335805893,
0.0030180644243955612,
-0.680508017539978,
0.3138475716114044,
0.649151623249054,
0.35107219219207764,
-0.34514907002449036,
-0.23146572709083557,
-0.5050603747367859,
-0.027882501482963562,
-0.3890685439109802,
0.7427447438240051,
-0.562440037727356,
-0.449824720621109,
0.13675837218761444,
-0.29212522506713867,
-0.09463595598936081,
-0.6713590025901794,
0.7485334277153015,
-0.17579905688762665,
0.537312924861908,
-0.5428750514984131,
-0.252511203289032,
0.10359412431716919,
0.21374456584453583,
-0.544607400894165,
1.1316860914230347,
0.19144411385059357,
-0.8725312352180481,
1.0269525051116943,
-0.3954941928386688,
-0.7264907360076904,
-0.3255508840084076,
-0.3527437746524811,
-0.35606351494789124,
0.05489804595708847,
-0.05357273668050766,
0.18775910139083862,
-0.5091644525527954,
0.527949869632721,
-0.19776342809200287,
-0.5511114597320557,
0.5545011162757874,
-0.8662614226341248,
0.7717460989952087,
0.05937492847442627,
-0.8676925897598267,
-0.19566164910793304,
-0.5092161893844604,
-0.11164897680282593,
0.13321954011917114,
-0.43144896626472473,
-0.6692602634429932,
0.06040482223033905,
0.07037939876317978,
0.3058525025844574,
-0.22935323417186737,
-0.45920994877815247,
-0.1133081316947937,
-0.29721760749816895,
0.0871196761727333,
0.7295169234275818,
-0.1026182472705841,
0.45524394512176514,
-0.5965985059738159,
0.768625795841217,
-0.10668281465768814,
0.08350633084774017,
-0.06511607021093369,
-0.18884128332138062,
-0.8673266768455505,
-0.19300958514213562,
0.6349178552627563,
0.34967052936553955,
-0.47924473881721497,
0.1714068502187729,
-0.4714874029159546,
-0.2683127224445343,
-0.425708532333374,
-0.05569952726364136,
0.769866943359375,
0.5590440630912781,
0.01786823943257332,
-0.3473353385925293,
-0.4309222400188446,
-1.0814731121063232,
-0.9097815752029419,
0.11850078403949738,
-0.04464927315711975,
0.4087381660938263,
0.6491122245788574,
-0.12396479398012161,
0.8852353096008301,
-0.3652547001838684,
-0.33181285858154297,
-0.14210982620716095,
0.18851891160011292,
-0.23932063579559326,
0.3526153862476349,
0.5800125598907471,
-0.5001806020736694,
-0.3121873438358307,
-0.44513940811157227,
-0.42167913913726807,
-0.5718584656715393,
-0.13432933390140533,
-0.13508708775043488,
0.3115164339542389,
0.2310067117214203,
-0.483378142118454,
0.6473534107208252,
0.4147615432739258,
-0.4671967029571533,
0.7667081356048584,
0.3714962899684906,
0.19772030413150787,
-0.4965732991695404,
-0.054500140249729156,
0.12365582585334778,
-0.15209971368312836,
-0.47201550006866455,
0.16736286878585815,
0.04803444817662239,
0.2624533772468567,
-0.46869325637817383,
0.631828784942627,
-0.530936598777771,
-0.26102980971336365,
-0.10223841667175293,
0.27419018745422363,
0.27203163504600525,
-0.011430821381509304,
-0.05891330912709236,
0.7113314867019653,
0.15666264295578003,
-0.5530774593353271,
-0.09730884432792664,
-0.19755084812641144,
-0.4550689458847046,
0.5018996000289917,
-0.45884937047958374,
0.1942632794380188,
-0.11225651949644089,
0.2261141836643219,
-0.8269527554512024,
-0.0011146517936140299,
0.18563179671764374,
-0.18718799948692322,
0.3504820168018341,
-0.14372718334197998,
-0.43346086144447327,
-0.33997124433517456,
-0.6725362539291382,
0.38108524680137634,
0.729026734828949,
-0.5592993497848511,
0.08260608464479446,
0.2695956826210022,
0.24798689782619476,
-0.9903942346572876,
-1.0287615060806274,
-0.0810147076845169,
-0.5104818940162659,
-0.3991997241973877,
0.2436554729938507,
-0.04329545795917511,
-0.7136409282684326,
-0.2271357625722885,
-0.3401201665401459,
0.1843084990978241,
0.09710067510604858,
0.31378522515296936,
0.07414346188306808,
0.10852118581533432,
0.0001844214420998469,
0.20301377773284912,
0.03923485428094864,
0.21104155480861664,
0.3535361886024475,
0.5044707655906677,
0.21686694025993347,
-0.47626206278800964,
0.2730758488178253,
0.10610868036746979,
0.1765044629573822,
0.25644761323928833,
0.42133599519729614,
0.28424811363220215,
-0.2784866988658905,
-0.551716148853302,
-0.769260585308075,
-0.44042158126831055,
-0.4291057884693146,
0.28882449865341187,
-0.3959789276123047,
-0.5992410182952881,
0.2528688609600067,
-0.028501972556114197,
-0.01908077858388424,
0.04923134297132492,
0.4232737720012665,
-0.17671990394592285,
0.8028542995452881,
0.38879671692848206,
0.0920555517077446,
0.5241273641586304,
-0.21662688255310059,
0.06490124017000198,
-0.8843605518341064,
-0.05079915374517441,
-0.5370151996612549,
-0.43294376134872437,
-0.46550431847572327,
-0.3984600305557251,
0.10908883064985275,
-0.09652519971132278,
-0.047803036868572235,
0.05894364416599274,
-0.3126717507839203,
0.5245303511619568,
0.534095048904419,
-0.06809893250465393,
0.27158331871032715,
0.08186634629964828,
-0.28269949555397034,
-0.6285995244979858,
-0.9148501753807068,
-0.6117940545082092,
1.2968049049377441,
0.3846447467803955,
0.9518041610717773,
-0.1685086339712143,
0.4758966565132141,
0.3407517969608307,
0.7681987285614014,
-0.6758904457092285,
0.5945419073104858,
0.22120791673660278,
-0.9414745569229126,
-0.08146660774946213,
-0.20665596425533295,
-1.162699580192566,
0.4961497485637665,
-0.3557378649711609,
-0.7131533026695251,
0.1653227061033249,
0.03512144088745117,
0.1973365992307663,
0.019590049982070923,
-0.6372604966163635,
0.6108924746513367,
-0.337191104888916,
-0.9122288227081299,
-0.14810417592525482,
-0.2937279939651489,
0.8152651786804199,
0.08054753392934799,
0.5325949192047119,
0.04631385579705238,
0.03025093302130699,
0.7479212284088135,
-0.07872631400823593,
0.9764021039009094,
-0.10716862976551056,
-0.414736807346344,
0.13405776023864746,
0.5352692604064941,
0.25275370478630066,
-0.00603485619649291,
-0.11944195628166199,
0.07440159469842911,
-0.04454635828733444,
-0.24433478713035583,
-0.48882514238357544,
0.948362410068512,
-0.5242570638656616,
-0.7027729749679565,
-0.780625581741333,
-0.6720010042190552,
-0.15641345083713531,
0.16902701556682587,
0.12597881257534027,
0.4969531297683716,
-0.50611811876297,
-0.1125708743929863,
0.6041896939277649,
-0.40461021661758423,
0.41446638107299805,
0.5548046231269836,
-0.24946773052215576,
-0.07244591414928436,
0.6614083647727966,
0.14136819541454315,
0.33063486218452454,
0.2166742980480194,
0.3960976302623749,
-0.19917680323123932,
-0.23049041628837585,
-0.33178260922431946,
0.20799951255321503,
-0.7723115682601929,
-0.12747031450271606,
-0.26550695300102234,
0.1134556233882904,
-0.41366297006607056,
-0.13158024847507477,
-0.3207497298717499,
-0.23890039324760437,
0.07835889607667923,
-0.22995229065418243,
-0.07498299330472946,
0.7081828117370605,
0.08098822087049484,
0.09228053689002991,
-0.18354327976703644,
0.3425283432006836,
0.26124417781829834,
0.27142471075057983,
0.005004095379263163,
-0.4440017342567444,
-0.08426988869905472,
0.16411231458187103,
-0.5162838101387024,
-1.0444215536117554,
0.15340185165405273,
-0.129813089966774,
0.5117326974868774,
0.3064359128475189,
0.0636913850903511,
0.6692148447036743,
-0.4785447418689728,
0.8010118007659912,
-0.018186373636126518,
-0.7956123948097229,
0.23753321170806885,
-0.4491608738899231,
0.0989711731672287,
0.5094186067581177,
0.15408310294151306,
-0.438205748796463,
-0.2868369221687317,
-0.6381930112838745,
-0.7964971661567688,
0.7389113306999207,
0.04216315969824791,
0.400743305683136,
-0.14186608791351318,
0.2714996635913849,
0.45996442437171936,
0.4941191077232361,
-1.20179283618927,
-0.41378915309906006,
0.05681617185473442,
-0.07232464104890823,
0.19976814091205597,
-0.48004499077796936,
-0.30069875717163086,
-0.22690875828266144,
0.6724965572357178,
0.16423222422599792,
0.27891987562179565,
0.08291290700435638,
-0.49840983748435974,
-0.2982082664966583,
0.44621747732162476,
0.5824211239814758,
0.7846781015396118,
-0.020441338419914246,
0.20725971460342407,
0.2228124737739563,
-0.5582943558692932,
0.1073400154709816,
-0.1009279191493988,
-0.7110300064086914,
-0.04176153242588043,
0.5982255935668945,
0.7045116424560547,
0.44921430945396423,
-0.8566268086433411,
0.6729506850242615,
0.21624109148979187,
-0.22588849067687988,
-0.36362162232398987,
0.10617106407880783,
-0.04591047018766403,
-0.055578820407390594,
0.24841737747192383,
-0.21625345945358276,
0.2356824278831482,
-0.709439218044281,
0.053597088903188705,
0.7520577907562256,
-0.5119178891181946,
-0.25532761216163635,
0.5971891283988953,
0.3107548654079437,
-0.44701188802719116,
0.26280853152275085,
-0.046223562210798264,
-0.47113293409347534,
0.5410086512565613,
0.6999845504760742,
1.0039616823196411,
-0.09992861747741699,
0.2223609834909439,
0.11554954200983047,
0.6494820713996887,
0.17903214693069458,
0.14008615911006927,
0.07723172008991241,
-0.6101695895195007,
-0.4439314901828766,
-0.3864138722419739,
-0.13089975714683533,
0.47409287095069885,
-0.5938793420791626,
0.38728001713752747,
-0.16410809755325317,
-0.14144408702850342,
-0.370942085981369,
-0.10496427118778229,
-0.6770540475845337,
0.29483404755592346,
0.083010233938694,
0.7606947422027588,
-1.0696772336959839,
0.39405134320259094,
0.7476380467414856,
-0.2581777274608612,
-0.3780165910720825,
0.4280220568180084,
-0.09473392367362976,
-0.5473178029060364,
0.7689052224159241,
0.18321838974952698,
-0.07026475667953491,
-0.3519176244735718,
-0.2521003186702728,
-0.7121310234069824,
0.8586044907569885,
0.4358401596546173,
-0.5034632086753845,
0.1614370048046112,
0.43197938799858093,
0.5727213025093079,
-0.2271452695131302,
0.652415931224823,
0.8666110634803772,
0.6004734039306641,
-0.43517646193504333,
-0.8429144024848938,
0.1203378438949585,
0.09670351445674896,
-0.018719663843512535,
0.11059146374464035,
-0.665141224861145,
0.5394086241722107,
-0.08204352110624313,
-0.29312676191329956,
-0.2544567883014679,
0.26289796829223633,
0.4395521581172943,
0.34450480341911316,
0.5193784832954407,
0.4046083390712738,
0.24783968925476074,
-0.2686780095100403,
1.1485528945922852,
-0.01711362972855568,
0.1122346892952919,
1.0061612129211426,
-0.28980234265327454,
0.4154350757598877,
0.7808202505111694,
-0.3322848677635193,
0.6554228663444519,
0.27044665813446045,
0.2600001096725464,
0.5110329985618591,
0.6821727752685547,
0.02747487463057041,
0.05861401930451393,
-0.11345183104276657,
-0.1462867259979248,
0.16933633387088776,
0.1700245589017868,
-0.40002116560935974,
-0.19752758741378784,
0.06407123804092407,
0.4497281014919281,
0.5398697257041931,
0.1519840806722641,
0.5015794038772583,
0.23474924266338348,
-0.8844979405403137,
0.4953343868255615,
0.26646700501441956,
0.998837947845459,
-0.4617481827735901,
-0.025949180126190186,
-0.4002175033092499,
0.04826363921165466,
-0.12995697557926178,
-0.4601995348930359,
0.02233937568962574,
0.17677904665470123,
-0.13711491227149963,
-0.3110700249671936,
1.0847705602645874,
-0.5114668011665344,
-0.47987914085388184,
0.3149629533290863,
0.6727315783500671,
0.05972406640648842,
0.2856963872909546,
-0.7009583711624146,
0.19419094920158386,
-0.06834284961223602,
-0.6638825535774231,
0.6181155443191528,
0.07487174868583679,
-0.3140547275543213,
0.8917825222015381,
0.40682920813560486,
0.1175929605960846,
0.17364779114723206,
0.36547330021858215,
0.649840235710144,
-0.603080153465271,
-0.16564249992370605,
-0.7816684246063232,
0.43246394395828247,
0.1647978276014328,
-0.3492673337459564,
0.9472958445549011,
0.5627955198287964,
0.7330427765846252,
-0.23167552053928375,
0.9268603324890137,
-0.012812329456210136,
0.4297638237476349,
-0.4278195798397064,
0.5321251749992371,
-0.3452922999858856,
0.3626704514026642,
-0.8243890404701233,
-1.1575170755386353,
-0.05812705308198929,
0.6924190521240234,
-0.5579432249069214,
0.5421671271324158,
0.8605062365531921,
0.5124351978302002,
-0.21246318519115448,
-0.1872507482767105,
0.28525614738464355,
0.10493921488523483,
0.1590982973575592,
0.2912629246711731,
1.1581571102142334,
-0.6745153665542603,
0.3019566237926483,
-0.3946671187877655,
-0.21335473656654358,
-0.1398056596517563,
-1.1377443075180054,
-1.28923761844635,
-0.2924351394176483,
-0.34457099437713623,
-0.2506498694419861,
0.26475995779037476,
0.6439935564994812,
0.4086366593837738,
-0.2975200414657593,
-0.2937946319580078,
-0.0781279057264328,
0.36707568168640137,
-0.17698127031326294,
-0.36138689517974854,
0.25675368309020996,
-0.2219691276550293,
-1.0649871826171875,
0.4041585326194763,
-0.21883158385753632,
-0.10625605285167694,
-0.6087614893913269,
-0.05302848666906357,
0.04223787039518356,
0.22592735290527344,
0.583665132522583,
-0.20514295995235443,
-0.672045886516571,
-0.496034175157547,
-0.06659100204706192,
0.009520696476101875,
-0.20274178683757782,
0.7955521941184998,
-1.0139422416687012,
0.19173173606395721,
0.4443691074848175,
0.0731334239244461,
0.45222190022468567,
0.06623813509941101,
0.7206022143363953,
-0.8034603595733643,
0.27583321928977966,
0.2029370367527008,
0.026089239865541458,
0.4366079568862915,
-0.26030808687210083,
0.7011607885360718,
0.28690946102142334,
-0.3198263943195343,
-1.3782120943069458,
0.3183385729789734,
-0.43958088755607605,
-0.26489803194999695,
1.5985051393508911,
0.03442901745438576,
-0.16460436582565308,
0.03664568066596985,
-0.16554954648017883,
0.15023311972618103,
-0.12543869018554688,
0.893638014793396,
0.887584388256073,
0.08943527936935425,
0.10490291565656662,
-0.8307914137840271,
0.6018048524856567,
0.7421999573707581,
-0.5436897873878479,
0.19316434860229492,
0.6650412082672119,
0.6777532696723938,
-0.022340817376971245,
0.2922983765602112,
-0.33473634719848633,
0.23063480854034424,
0.0821060985326767,
0.25911977887153625,
0.02344612032175064,
-0.3370201289653778,
-0.35451218485832214,
-0.2878548502922058,
0.15359076857566833,
0.24785073101520538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12636v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12636v3 | StyleDubber: Towards Multi-Scale Style Learning for Movie Dubbing | 2024-02-20T01:28:34 | 2024-07-02T03:42:36 | Gaoxiang Cong, Yuankai Qi, Liang Li, Amin Beheshti, Zhedong Zhang, Anton van den Hengel, Ming-Hsuan Yang, Chenggang Yan, Qingming Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Given a script, the challenge in Movie Dubbing (Visual Voice Cloning, V2C) is
to generate speech that aligns well with the video in both time and emotion,
based on the tone of a reference audio track. Existing state-of-the-art V2C
models break the phonemes in the script according to the divisions between
video frames, which solves the temporal alignment problem but leads to
incomplete phoneme pronunciation and poor identity stability. To address this
problem, we propose StyleDubber, which switches dubbing learning from the frame
level to phoneme level. It contains three main components: (1) A multimodal
style adaptor operating at the phoneme level to learn pronunciation style from
the reference audio, and generate intermediate representations informed by the
facial emotion presented in the video; (2) An utterance-level style learning
module, which guides both the mel-spectrogram decoding and the refining
processes from the intermediate embeddings to improve the overall style
expression; And (3) a phoneme-guided lip aligner to maintain lip sync.
Extensive experiments on two of the primary benchmarks, V2C and Grid,
demonstrate the favorable performance of the proposed method as compared to the
current stateof-the-art. The code will be made available at
https://github.com/GalaxyCong/StyleDubber. | [
-0.24905022978782654,
-0.41769102215766907,
-0.05018933489918709,
0.16306547820568085,
-0.1643885374069214,
0.4462389051914215,
-0.09767177700996399,
0.09112782776355743,
0.5820463299751282,
0.3781631588935852,
-0.5315624475479126,
-0.39907902479171753,
-0.37259170413017273,
-0.24644505977630615,
-0.028987731784582138,
1.1395974159240723,
0.05305148661136627,
0.26857274770736694,
-0.2165597528219223,
-0.1971019059419632,
-0.4587722718715668,
-0.37126678228378296,
-0.4715973734855652,
-0.23256909847259521,
0.40528926253318787,
0.8027817010879517,
0.603040874004364,
0.5785926580429077,
0.5905407667160034,
0.16687050461769104,
0.01644803024828434,
0.16965056955814362,
-0.45047786831855774,
0.4168689548969269,
0.23110456764698029,
-0.49124452471733093,
-0.7889659404754639,
0.10405594110488892,
0.5125556588172913,
0.04590514302253723,
-0.30781787633895874,
0.2687070071697235,
-0.28409621119499207,
0.8290352821350098,
-0.7104284763336182,
0.1998213231563568,
-0.5071858763694763,
0.09793425351381302,
-0.18826913833618164,
-0.33712953329086304,
-0.46778276562690735,
-0.19292370975017548,
-0.20795635879039764,
-0.20241877436637878,
0.3475227355957031,
-0.09113501757383347,
0.7796644568443298,
0.6172598600387573,
-0.31485310196876526,
-0.12835289537906647,
-0.7312548160552979,
0.43063274025917053,
-0.5701364278793335,
0.7042753100395203,
0.24809780716896057,
0.5191574692726135,
0.2711564302444458,
-0.6312445998191833,
-0.5208447575569153,
-0.016551831737160683,
0.16750890016555786,
0.4756443202495575,
0.046408768743276596,
-0.055783528834581375,
0.2580908238887787,
0.34790974855422974,
-0.5138413906097412,
0.0018566516228020191,
-0.42635929584503174,
-0.1537061184644699,
0.4265505075454712,
-0.07401816546916962,
0.4008428156375885,
-0.6124593615531921,
-0.4318404197692871,
-0.4004055857658386,
-0.1881113350391388,
0.5960578918457031,
0.5077436566352844,
0.21877939999103546,
-0.27128785848617554,
0.22237052023410797,
0.06725013256072998,
0.15566474199295044,
0.2760830521583557,
-0.5810158252716064,
0.5378750562667847,
-0.29850080609321594,
0.174245685338974,
0.45730140805244446,
0.458949476480484,
0.8654137849807739,
0.2275228351354599,
0.1706092655658722,
-0.09033755213022232,
-0.10502950102090836,
0.7408590912818909,
-1.1397078037261963,
-0.4754267632961273,
0.2057611495256424,
-0.10658950358629227,
-0.10070044547319412,
0.021161777898669243,
-1.2244837284088135,
-0.396468847990036,
-0.5616028904914856,
0.5180866122245789,
-0.5263447761535645,
-0.43451523780822754,
-0.5167226195335388,
-0.27861401438713074,
0.533943772315979,
0.08783116191625595,
-0.884296715259552,
0.12899066507816315,
0.18265242874622345,
0.9552525281906128,
-0.09267105162143707,
0.0732254758477211,
-0.6262666583061218,
-0.012271963059902191,
-0.6250317692756653,
0.4572489559650421,
-0.5794637203216553,
-0.5374229550361633,
0.05456467717885971,
-0.12022226303815842,
0.17516759037971497,
-0.5510273575782776,
0.20689889788627625,
-0.3205322027206421,
-0.15163493156433105,
0.005967879202216864,
-0.053284987807273865,
0.20582379400730133,
-0.2822761535644531,
-0.5428876280784607,
0.9391663074493408,
0.07809369266033173,
-0.3794339895248413,
0.34359467029571533,
-0.3015369772911072,
-0.26985791325569153,
-0.020763684064149857,
0.1958712339401245,
-0.8300574421882629,
0.03362097218632698,
0.191470205783844,
0.3444853723049164,
0.16698406636714935,
0.05185018479824066,
-0.5041376948356628,
-0.21573682129383087,
-0.008168509230017662,
0.047933004796504974,
0.15504419803619385,
0.3763538599014282,
-0.052387602627277374,
0.2882453203201294,
-0.8234643340110779,
0.2136460691690445,
-0.08161601424217224,
0.14035940170288086,
-0.19072523713111877,
-0.2925989031791687,
0.279335618019104,
0.2579305171966553,
-0.04759737476706505,
-0.3232041895389557,
0.39101386070251465,
0.11323866248130798,
0.49044984579086304,
0.6087092161178589,
0.005399534944444895,
0.6761719584465027,
-0.12902434170246124,
0.6360916495323181,
-0.13784246146678925,
0.05859493836760521,
-0.33849379420280457,
0.05179541930556297,
-0.9017592072486877,
-0.594632089138031,
0.026175767183303833,
0.4912867844104767,
-0.6279350519180298,
-0.015088079497218132,
-0.1514897346496582,
-0.6647093892097473,
-0.7167067527770996,
0.15341605246067047,
0.4069642722606659,
0.15668801963329315,
0.7272200584411621,
-0.46850642561912537,
-0.6367971897125244,
-0.9174827337265015,
-0.0395941361784935,
-0.04709275811910629,
0.0012748113367706537,
0.3526107668876648,
0.11028236150741577,
-0.26811620593070984,
1.0373679399490356,
-0.28282126784324646,
-0.30627205967903137,
-0.3299544155597687,
0.09290589392185211,
-0.10036932677030563,
0.5583298206329346,
0.5170157551765442,
-0.8589185476303101,
-0.32990533113479614,
-0.10276065021753311,
-0.4614647626876831,
-0.324982613325119,
-0.10304857045412064,
-0.05069996789097786,
0.13306330144405365,
0.9431135058403015,
-0.04379645735025406,
0.16594406962394714,
0.6527246832847595,
0.03307463601231575,
0.6210756897926331,
-0.22157549858093262,
0.4162498116493225,
-1.4143458604812622,
-0.18344050645828247,
0.391817569732666,
-0.09282702207565308,
-0.6389941573143005,
-0.3230462074279785,
0.18903355300426483,
-0.4301222562789917,
-0.3675819933414459,
0.4600718319416046,
-0.19939281046390533,
-0.12746462225914001,
-0.18290399014949799,
0.21772107481956482,
0.06469634175300598,
0.7549021244049072,
-0.03419705107808113,
0.7896547913551331,
0.3403889834880829,
-0.30953821539878845,
0.4941808879375458,
0.032262835651636124,
-0.1510956883430481,
0.9003757238388062,
-0.5487364530563354,
0.5215145349502563,
-0.17799875140190125,
0.3698960244655609,
-1.3989529609680176,
-0.5292832851409912,
0.01251758448779583,
-0.46055081486701965,
0.632591962814331,
-0.6976820826530457,
-0.33195239305496216,
-0.18848417699337006,
-0.22864335775375366,
0.41230201721191406,
0.8182058930397034,
-0.6333612203598022,
0.8646220564842224,
0.33225110173225403,
-0.49006566405296326,
-0.461573988199234,
-0.27419278025627136,
-0.07436423003673553,
-0.39852088689804077,
-0.3987162411212921,
0.4695657193660736,
-0.08173318207263947,
-0.06650376319885254,
-0.4575452506542206,
-0.7039932608604431,
-0.3187425136566162,
-0.38556191325187683,
0.5448046326637268,
0.4909389317035675,
-0.004226858261972666,
-0.16666895151138306,
0.17005206644535065,
0.15023121237754822,
-0.1615017205476761,
0.014410742558538914,
0.4596230387687683,
-0.2398819923400879,
0.18248935043811798,
-0.6507250666618347,
0.0626852735877037,
0.8724064230918884,
-0.5372268557548523,
0.19690480828285217,
1.1379389762878418,
0.07326091080904007,
-0.3746500611305237,
-0.5721200704574585,
-0.20636652410030365,
-0.43913203477859497,
0.6203764081001282,
-0.42358580231666565,
-0.5183918476104736,
0.4738208055496216,
-0.37879687547683716,
-0.07791264355182648,
-0.228709414601326,
0.4322423040866852,
-0.3197318911552429,
0.7429308891296387,
0.6678162217140198,
0.18768511712551117,
1.0094146728515625,
-0.3605688214302063,
0.32215285301208496,
-0.8893375396728516,
-0.4323844313621521,
-0.2531636357307434,
-0.5011124014854431,
-0.7926867008209229,
-0.5950761437416077,
0.5822716355323792,
0.4053918421268463,
-0.10447511821985245,
0.5771834254264832,
-0.15025977790355682,
0.6072907447814941,
0.4759180545806885,
0.12236533313989639,
-0.07462158054113388,
0.051339056342840195,
0.0411691814661026,
-0.23801881074905396,
-0.3644596040248871,
-0.21423403918743134,
0.6959806680679321,
0.22409158945083618,
0.9254677295684814,
0.30130720138549805,
0.7578611373901367,
0.24085912108421326,
-0.10440970212221146,
-1.0407627820968628,
0.3988327085971832,
-0.13054639101028442,
-0.4075709581375122,
-0.17466183006763458,
-0.23271483182907104,
-0.1411815583705902,
0.17755474150180817,
-0.1395360380411148,
-0.7960264086723328,
0.17075319588184357,
0.46819496154785156,
-0.20264562964439392,
0.22627927362918854,
-0.7478742003440857,
0.6851528286933899,
0.020077720284461975,
-0.671029269695282,
-0.3086138963699341,
-0.9763431549072266,
0.13651439547538757,
-0.0502873919904232,
0.30844980478286743,
0.005723712500184774,
0.2009081095457077,
0.7404146790504456,
-0.07366050034761429,
0.7722987532615662,
-0.0428888276219368,
0.05510663241147995,
0.3341427743434906,
0.39820432662963867,
0.09518620371818542,
0.2105790674686432,
0.18531188368797302,
0.20996874570846558,
0.11496439576148987,
-0.28974881768226624,
-0.8834404945373535,
0.6441400647163391,
-0.6344297528266907,
-0.43505778908729553,
-0.10950110107660294,
-0.5220692157745361,
-0.3974064886569977,
-0.024970874190330505,
0.031721703708171844,
0.8729243874549866,
0.01928245648741722,
0.31390824913978577,
0.5207173824310303,
-0.11364255100488663,
0.552054762840271,
0.17327706515789032,
-0.4207705557346344,
-0.9981502890586853,
1.1259331703186035,
0.07039885967969894,
0.6565572023391724,
0.16928893327713013,
0.12468191236257553,
-0.06251788884401321,
0.02971162088215351,
-0.5287184715270996,
0.08355364948511124,
-0.4970182180404663,
0.016275621950626373,
-0.37103256583213806,
-0.09265949577093124,
-0.49162256717681885,
-0.4010424017906189,
-0.800998330116272,
-0.13092412054538727,
0.12805283069610596,
0.056052062660455704,
0.33760908246040344,
0.5097841620445251,
-0.23619122803211212,
0.3518214523792267,
-0.5374569892883301,
0.4906803369522095,
0.4657336175441742,
0.33271682262420654,
-0.4205455183982849,
-0.9529882073402405,
-0.24264687299728394,
-0.35029417276382446,
-0.32354068756103516,
-0.602493405342102,
0.35800600051879883,
0.22561247646808624,
-0.02130841463804245,
0.46988824009895325,
-0.07289126515388489,
0.838469386100769,
-0.6945239305496216,
0.6841549277305603,
0.393959105014801,
-0.8904438614845276,
0.5135564208030701,
-0.22716668248176575,
0.2935985028743744,
0.42418578267097473,
0.43605226278305054,
-1.0351536273956299,
0.035928063094615936,
-0.537199854850769,
-0.8770433664321899,
0.6679810881614685,
0.03877075016498566,
0.17584127187728882,
0.3538958728313446,
0.3544953167438507,
0.0663779228925705,
0.26673975586891174,
-0.2312173992395401,
-0.3662244975566864,
-0.7924690246582031,
0.01194765791296959,
-0.3272671401500702,
-0.23455406725406647,
0.1737503558397293,
-0.24660846590995789,
0.5837495923042297,
-0.2759789228439331,
0.1450711041688919,
-0.002383036073297262,
0.16016767919063568,
-0.09340736269950867,
0.3891563415527344,
0.5192300081253052,
0.09276702255010605,
-0.5510477423667908,
0.07331781089305878,
-0.12212479114532471,
-0.5788429379463196,
0.09106563031673431,
-0.2504459321498871,
0.22792306542396545,
0.043823905289173126,
0.36455366015434265,
1.1915557384490967,
0.24893808364868164,
-0.45401501655578613,
0.33966055512428284,
0.21741436421871185,
-0.07842673361301422,
-0.17372676730155945,
0.11450940370559692,
-0.1094149574637413,
0.17552988231182098,
0.14608518779277802,
0.3854530155658722,
-0.030581321567296982,
-0.7682430744171143,
0.4754132330417633,
0.18143750727176666,
-0.6864526867866516,
-0.41870877146720886,
0.6415013670921326,
0.2823023200035095,
-0.6308280825614929,
0.47029420733451843,
0.0052910903468728065,
-0.518404483795166,
0.5905529856681824,
0.43833091855049133,
0.7973198890686035,
-0.5113330483436584,
0.284469872713089,
0.6429982781410217,
-0.06923002004623413,
0.18782161176204681,
-0.11372080445289612,
-0.3475358188152313,
-0.5989223718643188,
-0.1779051572084427,
-0.6908766627311707,
-0.6048738956451416,
-0.04867903143167496,
-0.9298868179321289,
0.6574134826660156,
-0.6272470355033875,
-0.2597581744194031,
-0.025789091363549232,
-0.4893380403518677,
-0.2963160276412964,
-0.03454926609992981,
0.5788494348526001,
0.5057013630867004,
-0.7622709274291992,
0.7781282663345337,
0.7149831652641296,
-0.5136858224868774,
-0.9356328248977661,
0.26920852065086365,
0.4961256980895996,
-0.5020639896392822,
0.8589000105857849,
0.34056785702705383,
-0.5260953903198242,
0.17962747812271118,
-0.5618011951446533,
-0.7688705921173096,
0.8533622026443481,
-0.035596586763858795,
-0.6662262082099915,
-0.2696894109249115,
-0.3890554904937744,
0.5463071465492249,
-0.32369866967201233,
0.29768818616867065,
0.6363480687141418,
0.023309573531150818,
0.6299444437026978,
-1.1636875867843628,
-0.689587414264679,
-0.3367505371570587,
0.09037136286497116,
0.2676619291305542,
-0.9711295366287231,
0.4656919240951538,
-0.657074511051178,
-0.027483129873871803,
-0.05172457918524742,
0.6353811025619507,
-0.059711482375860214,
0.17922067642211914,
0.43588986992836,
0.4154757261276245,
0.3849928677082062,
-0.12229455262422562,
0.6130674481391907,
-0.17311224341392517,
0.3665454089641571,
1.211669683456421,
-0.20251253247261047,
0.8234427571296692,
0.5539595484733582,
-0.11102499067783356,
0.719978392124176,
0.46655938029289246,
0.019002217799425125,
0.6675792932510376,
0.07468307018280029,
-0.06626252830028534,
-0.4843648076057434,
-0.36320602893829346,
-0.10012210160493851,
0.7408930063247681,
0.19289946556091309,
0.0167569387704134,
0.037517763674259186,
0.2694043219089508,
0.24097990989685059,
-0.0429997555911541,
-0.3138290345668793,
0.9122747182846069,
0.11097423732280731,
-0.45509639382362366,
0.7066991329193115,
-0.48540788888931274,
0.4523181617259979,
-0.7510930299758911,
-0.3552676737308502,
-0.2698909342288971,
0.17286653816699982,
-0.2605254352092743,
-0.5584818124771118,
-0.21201804280281067,
0.049376651644706726,
-0.12593792378902435,
-0.22092664241790771,
0.16006766259670258,
-0.7887522578239441,
-0.21799562871456146,
0.047096796333789825,
-0.04330878704786301,
0.12067654728889465,
0.46447375416755676,
-0.44474542140960693,
0.271938681602478,
0.06164288520812988,
-0.029610751196742058,
0.211659774184227,
0.2289046198129654,
0.1378244310617447,
0.7088634371757507,
0.3396509885787964,
-0.03849412500858307,
-0.034558992832899094,
0.5006360411643982,
0.37613439559936523,
-0.30646607279777527,
-0.2918567359447479,
-0.6697691679000854,
0.5321899056434631,
0.09949854016304016,
-0.21831244230270386,
0.5456504225730896,
0.3637979328632355,
0.9023047685623169,
-0.2598627805709839,
0.37675708532333374,
-0.03093685396015644,
-0.0521952249109745,
-0.6774285435676575,
0.41564083099365234,
-0.6870959997177124,
-0.24165809154510498,
-0.8161877989768982,
-1.0608651638031006,
-0.19528734683990479,
0.48942387104034424,
-0.17237022519111633,
0.05103013664484024,
0.7717610001564026,
0.9723973870277405,
0.06442887336015701,
-0.12815342843532562,
0.2877882122993469,
-0.05578901618719101,
0.3510204255580902,
0.0022179116494953632,
0.39023321866989136,
-0.23177377879619598,
0.5375944375991821,
-0.4323793649673462,
-0.4087257981300354,
-0.502163827419281,
-0.6535454392433167,
-0.8531491160392761,
-0.8965705037117004,
-0.47908616065979004,
-0.5662527084350586,
0.06880549341440201,
1.289494514465332,
1.0148340463638306,
-0.6126402020454407,
-0.3940006494522095,
0.6197600364685059,
-0.22285953164100647,
-0.39603397250175476,
-0.19424451887607574,
0.08654600381851196,
-0.4083382785320282,
-1.0674924850463867,
0.45728421211242676,
0.4332799017429352,
0.04332570359110832,
-0.006831921637058258,
0.13985846936702728,
0.2194862812757492,
0.12921959161758423,
0.5191701650619507,
0.15131328999996185,
-0.7541710138320923,
-0.23015812039375305,
-0.23220202326774597,
0.01353253610432148,
0.2390381097793579,
0.9891204237937927,
-0.32797300815582275,
0.8779226541519165,
0.2813151776790619,
0.5355457067489624,
0.4984360635280609,
0.34026890993118286,
0.3425571024417877,
-0.7997245788574219,
-0.03023659437894821,
-0.19907426834106445,
0.3518320918083191,
0.33636555075645447,
-0.03228689357638359,
0.27257195115089417,
0.34818246960639954,
-0.4885998070240021,
-0.6472920775413513,
0.3704841136932373,
-1.4579174518585205,
0.13068121671676636,
1.3096494674682617,
0.3590911626815796,
-0.03532997891306877,
0.5011671185493469,
-0.525810956954956,
0.43880438804626465,
-0.8495566844940186,
0.5030112862586975,
0.5989720225334167,
-0.23582175374031067,
-0.19280536472797394,
-0.5489476323127747,
0.6720207333564758,
0.2632434666156769,
-0.35545021295547485,
0.28856179118156433,
0.5473230481147766,
0.4095050096511841,
0.46789786219596863,
0.06482087075710297,
-0.17919370532035828,
0.2830641567707062,
0.06320833414793015,
0.6964408159255981,
-0.12026325613260269,
-0.9173679947853088,
-0.18958687782287598,
0.09273163229227066,
-0.12114373594522476,
-0.08066309988498688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12621v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12621v2 | Reflect-RL: Two-Player Online RL Fine-Tuning for LMs | 2024-02-20T01:04:21 | 2024-06-06T17:04:41 | Runlong Zhou, Simon S. Du, Beibin Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | As language models (LMs) demonstrate their capabilities in various fields,
their application to tasks requiring multi-round interactions has become
increasingly popular. These tasks usually have complex dynamics, so supervised
fine-tuning (SFT) on a limited offline dataset does not yield good performance.
However, only a few works attempted to directly train the LMs within
interactive decision-making environments. We aim to create an effective
approach to fine-tune LMs with online reinforcement learning (RL) in these
environments. We propose Reflect-RL, a two-player system to fine-tune an LM
using SFT and online RL, where a frozen reflection model (player) assists the
policy model (player). To generate data for the warm-up SFT stage, we use
negative example generation to enhance the error-correction ability of the
reflection model. Furthermore, we designed single-prompt action enumeration and
applied curriculum learning to allow the policy model to learn more
efficiently. Empirically, we verify that Reflect-RL outperforms SFT and online
RL without reflection. Testing results indicate GPT-2 XL 1.56B fine-tuned with
Reflect-RL outperforms larger open-source LMs, such as Mistral 7B. The
benchmarks, dataset, and code involved in this work are publicly available:
https://github.com/zhourunlong/Reflect-RL. | [
-0.4353485703468323,
-0.9768898487091064,
0.4294307827949524,
0.39515841007232666,
0.0292353592813015,
0.21938906610012054,
-0.580292820930481,
-0.460940420627594,
0.08974271267652512,
0.6826220750808716,
-0.7007291913032532,
-0.2045605629682541,
-0.10036710649728775,
-0.09133517742156982,
0.1625266820192337,
1.212260127067566,
-0.06284493952989578,
0.14067845046520233,
0.10093856602907181,
-0.1898982971906662,
-0.4274471402168274,
0.27989286184310913,
-1.0396302938461304,
-0.4064513146877289,
0.4905563294887543,
0.5611847043037415,
0.6254897713661194,
0.4182109832763672,
0.38730791211128235,
0.2676752209663391,
0.12497080862522125,
1.0434565544128418,
-0.8722484707832336,
0.20074494183063507,
-0.4106247127056122,
-0.1820783019065857,
-0.4238285720348358,
-0.12219522893428802,
0.5076577663421631,
0.029243990778923035,
-0.5484858155250549,
0.16155008971691132,
0.1778232306241989,
0.6925206184387207,
-0.5220025181770325,
0.3737603425979614,
-0.43558311462402344,
0.23092196881771088,
0.35168352723121643,
-0.3694702088832855,
-0.6757634878158569,
-0.6849526166915894,
0.012997966259717941,
-0.9529104828834534,
0.14054985344409943,
0.2814152240753174,
0.9628315567970276,
0.530096173286438,
-0.13862352073192596,
-0.240901380777359,
-1.0048530101776123,
0.7558876276016235,
-0.8380941152572632,
0.28243839740753174,
0.2769361436367035,
0.5405813455581665,
-0.2169913798570633,
-0.5456056594848633,
-0.22072598338127136,
-0.3084205090999603,
-0.1066327765583992,
0.43560081720352173,
0.4417034685611725,
0.21416911482810974,
0.32684963941574097,
-0.037021588534116745,
-0.3958778977394104,
0.1100403219461441,
-0.30944153666496277,
0.13554760813713074,
0.656315803527832,
0.23849187791347504,
-0.053000837564468384,
0.4829534888267517,
-0.30493617057800293,
0.006423846818506718,
-0.7088768482208252,
0.1670297086238861,
0.18174625933170319,
0.7829073071479797,
-0.11004400253295898,
0.12760721147060394,
-0.15172691643238068,
0.5553960204124451,
0.23661410808563232,
-0.013796628452837467,
-0.07751356810331345,
0.10146868973970413,
0.08443579822778702,
-0.08583980053663254,
0.4422012269496918,
0.5870391726493835,
0.3874775171279907,
-0.16683408617973328,
-0.5239502787590027,
-0.16784203052520752,
0.3946525454521179,
-0.8234583139419556,
-0.4692837595939636,
-0.05635129660367966,
-0.13239170610904694,
-0.36236855387687683,
0.3937649428844452,
-0.8008185625076294,
-0.5629916787147522,
-0.4829322099685669,
0.8713948726654053,
-0.05985309183597565,
-0.4064115583896637,
0.08451029658317566,
0.09705645591020584,
0.07328683882951736,
0.648833155632019,
-0.6659287214279175,
0.5926337838172913,
0.6134796142578125,
0.861682116985321,
-0.32060760259628296,
-0.31051871180534363,
-1.0135858058929443,
0.011340218596160412,
-0.30236828327178955,
0.6721066236495972,
-0.42885345220565796,
-0.12142300605773926,
0.38931241631507874,
-0.046754878014326096,
0.013618654571473598,
-0.6814032793045044,
0.15670569241046906,
-0.5614253878593445,
0.3881188631057739,
-0.35001400113105774,
-0.5660696625709534,
-0.07667221128940582,
0.35215768218040466,
-0.745652973651886,
1.256533145904541,
0.16073374450206757,
-0.32438772916793823,
0.5490871071815491,
-0.7928857207298279,
-0.32424676418304443,
0.11581345647573471,
-0.041856542229652405,
-0.7822801470756531,
-0.07522257417440414,
0.08023541420698166,
0.32967132329940796,
0.0031734576914459467,
0.11812776327133179,
-0.3711959421634674,
-0.9214619398117065,
0.05046527832746506,
-0.09825599938631058,
0.20049543678760529,
0.17911915481090546,
-0.5942960977554321,
0.4252573549747467,
-0.7049214243888855,
0.3964645266532898,
0.01564600132405758,
-0.8011715412139893,
0.15873217582702637,
0.5349588990211487,
0.3474700450897217,
0.41239798069000244,
0.06293155997991562,
-0.4004269242286682,
0.336017370223999,
-0.4242941439151764,
0.43411195278167725,
0.614470362663269,
0.04340500384569168,
0.24146805703639984,
-0.47975867986679077,
0.4660619795322418,
-0.28909531235694885,
0.2528495192527771,
0.09352389723062515,
-0.2502771019935608,
-0.8257356882095337,
-0.13564501702785492,
0.09970417618751526,
0.6078271269798279,
-0.9317184686660767,
-0.1290019303560257,
0.12710002064704895,
-0.09874097257852554,
-0.872403085231781,
0.12911958992481232,
0.7693731188774109,
0.06388771533966064,
0.7669941186904907,
-0.09974315762519836,
-0.4551628828048706,
-0.5429054498672485,
-0.484841912984848,
0.17241060733795166,
0.06337291747331619,
0.7911191582679749,
0.24007399380207062,
0.018466029316186905,
0.9680988192558289,
-0.554994523525238,
-0.6956454515457153,
-0.20897895097732544,
0.21118421852588654,
-0.11835186928510666,
0.20175521075725555,
0.2361876368522644,
-0.6061259508132935,
-0.8152391910552979,
-0.07712634652853012,
-0.3891940414905548,
-0.030011698603630066,
-0.1977401077747345,
0.24386823177337646,
0.4321097135543823,
0.4615710377693176,
-0.1363373100757599,
0.1093987300992012,
0.30582404136657715,
-0.45038026571273804,
0.19243621826171875,
-0.9610233902931213,
0.21860253810882568,
-0.549708366394043,
-0.18527375161647797,
0.04373770207166672,
-0.5598558783531189,
-0.6065382361412048,
0.543170154094696,
0.14159227907657623,
0.22433656454086304,
-0.5492039322853088,
0.4380241334438324,
-0.4656824469566345,
-0.12268365174531937,
-0.4384657144546509,
0.36189132928848267,
-0.011615298688411713,
0.7183020114898682,
0.2066233903169632,
0.7703129649162292,
0.09734158962965012,
-0.6833528876304626,
0.17991049587726593,
-0.13937868177890778,
-0.30529290437698364,
0.23957037925720215,
-0.41221141815185547,
0.18399104475975037,
-0.055481649935245514,
0.18238630890846252,
-0.5507124662399292,
-0.10300280153751373,
0.33580729365348816,
0.17518365383148193,
0.3661784827709198,
-0.06803782284259796,
-0.3159746527671814,
0.09499717503786087,
-0.35597893595695496,
0.10912910848855972,
0.43039649724960327,
-0.60982346534729,
0.48609137535095215,
0.27472129464149475,
0.3864125907421112,
-0.25159114599227905,
-0.4771038591861725,
-0.19779817759990692,
-0.10418426245450974,
-0.19641615450382233,
0.20512740314006805,
-0.26567113399505615,
-0.14578862488269806,
-0.09299761801958084,
0.28895333409309387,
-0.1022283211350441,
0.2132093757390976,
0.24115684628486633,
0.006255556829273701,
-0.23651441931724548,
0.022410180419683456,
0.025160862132906914,
0.023245954886078835,
-0.13276103138923645,
-0.03952730447053909,
0.2656904458999634,
-0.43500497937202454,
-0.2077702134847641,
-0.18657352030277252,
0.0637107715010643,
0.3140493929386139,
-0.16265293955802917,
0.8535700440406799,
0.6152908802032471,
-0.0933394581079483,
-0.8690646290779114,
-0.5012709498405457,
-0.33819764852523804,
-0.5068293213844299,
0.3365764319896698,
-0.2232489138841629,
-1.0031168460845947,
0.5313364863395691,
-0.32002243399620056,
0.2695482671260834,
0.09414207190275192,
0.43312734365463257,
-0.17269907891750336,
1.25547194480896,
0.5735902190208435,
0.39467325806617737,
0.5191684365272522,
-0.12891770899295807,
-0.071052685379982,
-0.6316277384757996,
-0.3526642322540283,
-0.08274326473474503,
-0.3316018581390381,
-0.6127867698669434,
-0.3416438400745392,
0.24285630881786346,
0.13103963434696198,
-0.487949937582016,
0.2929302453994751,
-0.6034820079803467,
0.8584326505661011,
0.427584171295166,
0.7257546782493591,
0.2712927460670471,
-0.38599175214767456,
-0.034570224583148956,
-0.1379128396511078,
-0.5200899243354797,
-0.2508451044559479,
0.4728774130344391,
0.4365178048610687,
0.7011234760284424,
0.32179319858551025,
0.518475353717804,
0.38106784224510193,
0.23622621595859528,
-0.5269405245780945,
0.42490193247795105,
0.02525339648127556,
-0.4729585647583008,
-0.5027971267700195,
-0.4506665766239166,
-0.4634259343147278,
0.3033764958381653,
-0.44746851921081543,
-0.21918247640132904,
-0.2343379706144333,
0.5588539242744446,
-0.5271607637405396,
0.3367581069469452,
-0.4667041599750519,
0.7059693336486816,
-0.28725963830947876,
-0.7585974335670471,
-0.5120692849159241,
-0.5926036238670349,
0.2967718839645386,
0.030518798157572746,
0.38583511114120483,
-0.038189057260751724,
0.025319475680589676,
0.26674535870552063,
-0.21209774911403656,
0.8099716305732727,
-0.6140010952949524,
-0.192012757062912,
0.089257150888443,
0.4743044376373291,
0.8504937291145325,
0.09790228307247162,
0.14387047290802002,
-0.35642746090888977,
0.2257547825574875,
-0.08446161448955536,
-0.6691738963127136,
0.7578003406524658,
-0.7204132676124573,
-0.2551421523094177,
-0.2948327660560608,
-0.2668852210044861,
-0.1920066475868225,
-0.04009693115949631,
-0.09949889779090881,
0.32680144906044006,
-0.20023056864738464,
-0.11806885153055191,
0.9572661519050598,
-0.32135671377182007,
0.2750309407711029,
1.1609256267547607,
-0.7109341025352478,
-0.19636361300945282,
1.4558436870574951,
0.1282804161310196,
0.44535768032073975,
0.328485369682312,
0.3483653962612152,
-0.025337781757116318,
-0.32256433367729187,
-0.4927515387535095,
-0.07250704616308212,
-0.39847755432128906,
-0.10142055153846741,
-0.027415746822953224,
-0.1945735365152359,
0.13825872540473938,
-0.009488609619438648,
-0.5710720419883728,
-0.2497197836637497,
-0.47349387407302856,
0.1554916948080063,
0.27200183272361755,
1.1368886232376099,
-0.11588021367788315,
0.10951845347881317,
-0.49970701336860657,
0.20662268996238708,
0.06407954543828964,
0.8475416898727417,
-0.05142267048358917,
-0.6170184016227722,
-0.536942720413208,
0.12035837769508362,
-0.13410189747810364,
-0.5083529949188232,
0.21414612233638763,
0.7640892267227173,
0.2169170081615448,
0.6092503070831299,
0.188247948884964,
0.5699398517608643,
-0.8081159591674805,
0.5332096815109253,
-0.31864723563194275,
-0.5607559680938721,
0.5373440384864807,
-0.4003039002418518,
0.18285536766052246,
0.7770262360572815,
0.025578292086720467,
-0.5320338606834412,
-0.5242089629173279,
-0.2956710457801819,
-0.7344335317611694,
1.0288047790527344,
-0.213077113032341,
-0.16120025515556335,
0.08631611615419388,
0.38123616576194763,
0.1594974547624588,
0.021106664091348648,
-0.5639554858207703,
-0.2714068293571472,
-0.22413353621959686,
0.041236408054828644,
-0.06417122483253479,
-0.024347230792045593,
-0.02220604009926319,
-0.18229083716869354,
0.9070487022399902,
-0.22452153265476227,
-0.021467821672558784,
-0.07644672691822052,
-0.1523762047290802,
-0.4799524247646332,
0.1395191252231598,
1.052940845489502,
0.4664212465286255,
-0.4000273644924164,
-0.02120085060596466,
0.5596593618392944,
-0.12608417868614197,
-0.1379113346338272,
-0.26501908898353577,
-0.3669204115867615,
-0.3944741487503052,
0.1616470366716385,
0.8927522897720337,
0.7987704873085022,
-0.7325868606567383,
0.3012022376060486,
-0.14483244717121124,
-0.30083349347114563,
-0.24091975390911102,
0.4190996587276459,
-0.03674881160259247,
0.613261878490448,
0.005318593233823776,
0.002459778217598796,
-0.008302324451506138,
-0.5726057291030884,
0.3747047781944275,
0.4153072237968445,
-0.6642455458641052,
-0.17244362831115723,
0.6341962814331055,
0.1913505494594574,
-0.6014295220375061,
0.5327714681625366,
-0.42193859815597534,
-0.6357871294021606,
0.3667578101158142,
0.6121014356613159,
0.6405008435249329,
-0.07251787185668945,
0.6262369751930237,
0.505190372467041,
0.125425323843956,
-0.5904884934425354,
0.47112876176834106,
-0.022097056731581688,
-0.5817286968231201,
-0.4464127719402313,
-0.5161781311035156,
-0.6417291760444641,
-0.12814250588417053,
-0.8137810826301575,
0.2559092938899994,
-0.6410067677497864,
0.10493095964193344,
-0.5643246173858643,
0.17074312269687653,
-0.4787823557853699,
0.0432979054749012,
-0.008612514473497868,
0.5784419178962708,
-0.836471676826477,
0.7384815812110901,
0.5183233618736267,
-0.47755423188209534,
-0.9480246901512146,
-0.248225599527359,
-0.1187615618109703,
-0.6029752492904663,
0.5188988447189331,
-0.018235066905617714,
-0.3026421368122101,
0.22581921517848969,
-0.435207724571228,
-0.647566556930542,
1.0169728994369507,
0.23768457770347595,
-0.6999350190162659,
0.03462614864110947,
0.08851700276136398,
0.7428377866744995,
-0.2180524468421936,
0.6458030939102173,
0.43895065784454346,
0.5520396828651428,
-0.052313968539237976,
-1.0716601610183716,
0.1396474689245224,
0.1999787837266922,
-0.1999255120754242,
0.4343422055244446,
-0.9854841232299805,
0.7298624515533447,
-0.35832759737968445,
-0.23158849775791168,
-0.23198743164539337,
0.5436871647834778,
0.13726790249347687,
0.10596905648708344,
0.43147122859954834,
0.4409535825252533,
0.4980801045894623,
-0.12832461297512054,
0.48799920082092285,
-0.2273256778717041,
0.7377054691314697,
1.3773167133331299,
-0.4419683516025543,
1.0754460096359253,
0.24703875184059143,
-0.10180043429136276,
0.3884042501449585,
0.47049981355667114,
-0.26982471346855164,
0.7201581597328186,
0.3071972131729126,
-0.2742619216442108,
-0.5887467265129089,
-0.010097891092300415,
-0.17712268233299255,
-0.013860787265002728,
0.27800074219703674,
-0.008575398474931717,
-0.45042404532432556,
0.0744088739156723,
-0.28149428963661194,
0.5060123801231384,
-0.3231215476989746,
1.1165732145309448,
-0.03830686956644058,
-0.8202759623527527,
0.0969543308019638,
0.3213120996952057,
0.6444780230522156,
-0.42602112889289856,
-0.550217866897583,
-0.16345487534999847,
0.7145900130271912,
-0.40688782930374146,
-0.7060208916664124,
-0.009764859452843666,
-0.2763986885547638,
0.05755193531513214,
-0.3698786497116089,
0.5825409293174744,
-0.8213376402854919,
-0.14846770465373993,
0.48127463459968567,
0.3312385678291321,
0.11423573642969131,
0.07999522238969803,
-0.7481783032417297,
-0.020592916756868362,
-0.06976395845413208,
-0.43497544527053833,
0.5896471738815308,
0.15676534175872803,
0.022915296256542206,
0.8122192621231079,
0.24004538357257843,
0.28822872042655945,
0.03496718034148216,
0.2194099724292755,
0.7050732970237732,
-0.34647154808044434,
-0.33271899819374084,
-0.6788679957389832,
0.3795950412750244,
0.09493046998977661,
-0.40417295694351196,
0.5958630442619324,
0.6357011795043945,
0.9606322050094604,
-0.09338551014661789,
0.42743954062461853,
0.14215177297592163,
0.790510892868042,
-0.6427449584007263,
0.8712159395217896,
-0.5088094472885132,
0.2213333547115326,
-0.027027282863855362,
-0.900894284248352,
-0.27206745743751526,
0.9023062586784363,
0.019539428874850273,
0.16402246057987213,
0.3450040817260742,
0.9992095828056335,
-0.15803781151771545,
-0.012502611614763737,
0.38925668597221375,
0.024441873654723167,
0.4077507555484772,
0.48475486040115356,
0.771091639995575,
-0.38855719566345215,
0.33504438400268555,
-0.23696425557136536,
-0.11172039806842804,
-0.3288664221763611,
-0.9600860476493835,
-1.0797079801559448,
-0.3928942382335663,
-0.4085404574871063,
-0.470943808555603,
0.45075365900993347,
1.4058334827423096,
0.456754595041275,
-1.0244994163513184,
-0.18226711452007294,
-0.19291771948337555,
-0.20544371008872986,
-0.6296965479850769,
-0.2866067588329315,
0.2704840898513794,
-0.4899885952472687,
-0.32488638162612915,
0.6778356432914734,
0.02180512808263302,
-0.44581136107444763,
-0.6120001077651978,
-0.77519291639328,
-0.2399100512266159,
0.07271758466959,
0.524310290813446,
0.43971484899520874,
-0.7855492830276489,
-0.6512805819511414,
-0.19043155014514923,
-0.14136336743831635,
0.022556718438863754,
0.8140943646430969,
-0.8778570890426636,
0.41315338015556335,
0.23517239093780518,
0.39360448718070984,
0.7739766836166382,
0.10577442497015,
0.4578402042388916,
-0.6473600268363953,
-0.39970365166664124,
0.24884194135665894,
-0.038168616592884064,
-0.001287747174501419,
-0.21055880188941956,
0.4373268187046051,
-0.25711122155189514,
-0.9148120284080505,
-0.839694082736969,
0.16947808861732483,
-0.6484655141830444,
-0.3919537663459778,
1.0625680685043335,
-0.19528613984584808,
0.3556288480758667,
-0.13340263068675995,
-0.48722293972969055,
0.30704519152641296,
-0.5337987542152405,
0.9416617751121521,
0.5033444762229919,
-0.11189042776823044,
-0.4190122187137604,
-0.8258498907089233,
0.9699944257736206,
0.27771908044815063,
-0.6049990057945251,
0.15578670799732208,
0.35618898272514343,
0.2661800980567932,
-0.17522872984409332,
0.2952142059803009,
0.5509976148605347,
0.2356770783662796,
-0.29742002487182617,
-0.024779386818408966,
-0.6017528772354126,
-0.6138090491294861,
-0.3487130105495453,
0.200563445687294,
0.2611439824104309,
0.18672379851341248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12617v1 | Generative AI Security: Challenges and Countermeasures | 2024-02-20T00:51:05 | 2024-02-20T00:51:05 | Banghua Zhu, Norman Mu, Jiantao Jiao, David Wagner | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Generative AI's expanding footprint across numerous industries has led to
both excitement and increased scrutiny. This paper delves into the unique
security challenges posed by Generative AI, and outlines potential research
directions for managing these risks. | [
-0.4581916332244873,
-0.900762140750885,
0.2428436130285263,
0.07494888454675674,
0.15627798438072205,
0.34423089027404785,
0.4919794797897339,
-0.8277535438537598,
-0.19711816310882568,
0.6198318600654602,
-0.872393786907196,
-0.07259860634803772,
-1.0780527591705322,
0.09727761149406433,
-0.45911988615989685,
0.8242034912109375,
0.03018973022699356,
-0.306057333946228,
-0.4855860471725464,
-0.22009612619876862,
-0.7020496726036072,
-0.9221583604812622,
-0.6219298243522644,
-0.26868510246276855,
0.3189806640148163,
0.27988407015800476,
0.7274022698402405,
0.015693804249167442,
0.872230589389801,
0.5135818123817444,
0.26728254556655884,
-0.2521109879016876,
-0.0425841361284256,
0.6226966977119446,
0.026272688060998917,
-0.6851425170898438,
-0.14473743736743927,
-0.08961533010005951,
0.3074856400489807,
0.4504649341106415,
-0.1949421912431717,
0.08457525074481964,
-0.1983271986246109,
0.8148086667060852,
-0.6378918886184692,
0.04912980645895004,
-0.622730016708374,
0.3295776844024658,
-0.8334170579910278,
0.01861044391989708,
-0.3073216676712036,
-0.04292937368154526,
0.12340065836906433,
-0.6225744485855103,
0.17136110365390778,
-0.25036805868148804,
0.68203204870224,
0.6285538077354431,
-0.5536180138587952,
-0.28750550746917725,
-1.2041468620300293,
0.5743599534034729,
0.2334873527288437,
0.018533768132328987,
0.13593721389770508,
0.4619242548942566,
-0.04091011360287666,
-0.7819497585296631,
-0.19352516531944275,
-0.04740217328071594,
0.4647955596446991,
0.11039922386407852,
-0.7042632102966309,
-0.016355549916625023,
0.34520331025123596,
0.5405856966972351,
-0.6094682812690735,
0.3837997317314148,
-0.4146847426891327,
0.021359143778681755,
0.7667275071144104,
0.35010260343551636,
0.9419009685516357,
0.4046309292316437,
-0.48687151074409485,
-0.43504273891448975,
-0.8658339977264404,
-0.06018335372209549,
0.6675009727478027,
-0.31780263781547546,
-0.11804050952196121,
0.6250597238540649,
-0.07914792001247406,
0.4326690137386322,
-0.18127381801605225,
0.5660521388053894,
0.14904779195785522,
-0.13722775876522064,
-0.1767086684703827,
-0.03832722827792168,
0.5657452344894409,
0.04056370258331299,
-0.0832720622420311,
-0.15770843625068665,
-0.11179094016551971,
0.053209807723760605,
0.7579466700553894,
-0.35941562056541443,
-0.0939541831612587,
0.627859354019165,
-0.23919375240802765,
-0.476754367351532,
0.21669958531856537,
-0.9137628078460693,
-0.5700085759162903,
0.28418511152267456,
0.23469625413417816,
-0.29169976711273193,
-0.44722211360931396,
-0.41938087344169617,
-0.7838984131813049,
0.7075977921485901,
0.266730934381485,
-0.9187929630279541,
-0.3679350018501282,
0.8978848457336426,
0.8907445669174194,
0.150635227560997,
-0.008366047404706478,
-0.14275872707366943,
0.35930392146110535,
-0.44881466031074524,
0.7836291790008545,
-0.4231702983379364,
-0.9403753876686096,
-0.20711910724639893,
-0.416632741689682,
-0.05869845300912857,
-0.5902416706085205,
-0.04845908656716347,
-0.6981710195541382,
-0.1957392543554306,
-0.0914846807718277,
-0.2026747614145279,
0.18110081553459167,
0.6784678101539612,
-0.7189189791679382,
0.39820823073387146,
0.24907232820987701,
-0.7089344263076782,
0.15870243310928345,
-0.7891387343406677,
-0.4601329565048218,
0.5606322288513184,
-0.5008651614189148,
-0.4702237844467163,
0.22804886102676392,
0.12598726153373718,
-0.2672877609729767,
-0.10435452312231064,
-0.3217935562133789,
-0.2639504671096802,
0.00041489818249829113,
0.4414732754230499,
-0.6147139072418213,
1.134412169456482,
0.44236260652542114,
-0.44088080525398254,
0.3055185377597809,
-0.5103743672370911,
-0.27521491050720215,
0.16609472036361694,
0.2891579568386078,
-0.20131610333919525,
0.018304044380784035,
-0.20029032230377197,
-0.12949545681476593,
0.28101930022239685,
-0.20507735013961792,
0.08295217156410217,
-0.2503206431865692,
0.5653051137924194,
0.8063960075378418,
0.45270276069641113,
0.4034658670425415,
-0.520732581615448,
1.1236821413040161,
0.18146024644374847,
0.6014866232872009,
-0.01222691684961319,
-0.6753283143043518,
-0.37921714782714844,
-0.3453153669834137,
0.07467098534107208,
1.0177552700042725,
-0.9451221823692322,
0.4687557816505432,
0.19840848445892334,
-0.7715886831283569,
-0.49829190969467163,
-0.10944713652133942,
0.1303509771823883,
0.05260119587182999,
0.09610658884048462,
-0.33544349670410156,
-0.2550252079963684,
-0.6229332685470581,
-0.05778880789875984,
-0.2525239586830139,
-0.11265306174755096,
0.027604693546891212,
0.33898308873176575,
-0.7307146787643433,
0.49465811252593994,
-0.5784522294998169,
-0.524881899356842,
-0.18133704364299774,
0.5636759400367737,
-0.2413266897201538,
0.970823347568512,
0.6237159967422485,
-1.151366114616394,
-0.35315054655075073,
-0.05177450180053711,
-1.0031241178512573,
0.22401517629623413,
-0.5981029868125916,
0.10218586772680283,
-0.05878867954015732,
0.8315125107765198,
-1.135838508605957,
0.5126911401748657,
0.2131091058254242,
-0.019223356619477272,
0.6571345925331116,
0.03416391834616661,
0.08089157938957214,
-1.101809024810791,
0.16102245450019836,
-0.3153426945209503,
0.3699609637260437,
-0.7746208906173706,
0.7164013385772705,
-0.5871173143386841,
-0.58127361536026,
-0.20231780409812927,
0.12188685685396194,
-0.3355122208595276,
0.05120013654232025,
-0.06969071924686432,
-0.22309964895248413,
-0.09100627154111862,
-0.36663252115249634,
-0.31451553106307983,
0.8411180973052979,
1.0014625787734985,
-0.6184863448143005,
0.809810221195221,
0.2840740978717804,
-0.4479694962501526,
0.5488628149032593,
-0.7664703130722046,
0.408486008644104,
-0.10325787216424942,
0.13088807463645935,
-0.911857008934021,
-0.10502585768699646,
0.4128260314464569,
-0.686901867389679,
0.5475067496299744,
0.09644383192062378,
-0.26316943764686584,
-0.38825491070747375,
-0.3461967408657074,
0.6400210857391357,
0.5576413869857788,
-0.28945422172546387,
0.9387977719306946,
0.2534608542919159,
-0.2908366024494171,
-0.8835254311561584,
-0.8038954734802246,
0.6731160283088684,
-0.5344106554985046,
-0.4263346195220947,
0.4007479250431061,
0.04225511848926544,
-0.754242479801178,
0.03587733209133148,
0.09770622104406357,
0.1464933305978775,
0.6893719434738159,
0.40098893642425537,
0.015963150188326836,
-0.04804164543747902,
-0.3703886866569519,
-0.13903364539146423,
-0.41871020197868347,
0.6095691323280334,
-0.18008536100387573,
0.2641580402851105,
0.16112692654132843,
-0.5870668292045593,
-0.4165925681591034,
0.825761079788208,
0.7224234938621521,
-0.33906251192092896,
0.7218676805496216,
0.6873212456703186,
-0.2907346487045288,
-0.1395585834980011,
-0.43753328919410706,
-0.015634100884199142,
-0.6259620785713196,
0.4924390912055969,
-0.4662185609340668,
-0.5474949479103088,
0.6942929029464722,
-0.05076673999428749,
0.0369570255279541,
0.4663441479206085,
0.48976996541023254,
-0.22963941097259521,
0.95840984582901,
0.7296981811523438,
-0.24235747754573822,
0.4209161698818207,
-0.20242378115653992,
0.4602971374988556,
-0.5031300783157349,
-0.6845307350158691,
-0.6224139928817749,
-0.07559923827648163,
-1.0187324285507202,
-0.08007274568080902,
0.4870585799217224,
-0.1925477683544159,
-0.1515580713748932,
0.2233489751815796,
-0.6135590672492981,
0.29805058240890503,
0.9226788878440857,
-0.17469266057014465,
0.0643720030784607,
-0.2112564891576767,
0.3589032292366028,
0.36065173149108887,
-0.38972947001457214,
-0.15319038927555084,
0.8043271899223328,
0.40086469054222107,
1.0812879800796509,
0.6490690112113953,
0.6017645597457886,
0.6437848806381226,
0.22246550023555756,
-0.44251057505607605,
0.3636859953403473,
-0.12304715812206268,
-0.9115670323371887,
-0.3823755085468292,
-0.47192686796188354,
-0.9622350931167603,
-0.054278384894132614,
-0.11685074120759964,
-0.7193990349769592,
0.2150377631187439,
0.1731891632080078,
-0.44779711961746216,
0.3316021263599396,
-0.6466532945632935,
0.5959559679031372,
-0.3519223928451538,
0.09957094490528107,
-0.26579007506370544,
-0.6364899277687073,
0.32212725281715393,
0.17011336982250214,
-0.1121331974864006,
0.043930958956480026,
0.3117738962173462,
0.2567482888698578,
-0.28249073028564453,
0.9918229579925537,
0.03332745283842087,
-0.1991550177335739,
0.6192288398742676,
0.06433430314064026,
0.2145741730928421,
0.21555687487125397,
0.27255529165267944,
0.29392698407173157,
-0.05121295154094696,
-0.5471709966659546,
-0.2604360282421112,
0.600214421749115,
-0.7947609424591064,
-1.312343955039978,
-0.9791556596755981,
-0.3762190639972687,
-0.40849804878234863,
0.11396472156047821,
0.8858646750450134,
0.120029017329216,
-0.6461201906204224,
0.2869081497192383,
0.9976938962936401,
-0.44924691319465637,
0.46721217036247253,
-0.22996076941490173,
0.43561726808547974,
-0.42612501978874207,
0.9571259617805481,
0.07063985615968704,
0.3473477065563202,
0.4158032536506653,
-0.25944018363952637,
-0.2925320267677307,
-0.4936503767967224,
-0.8520092368125916,
-0.6308338642120361,
-0.46328744292259216,
-0.3339655101299286,
-0.42300376296043396,
-0.6460353136062622,
-0.6938773393630981,
-0.3439425826072693,
-0.15138642489910126,
-0.2145329713821411,
-0.4365118741989136,
-0.2839224934577942,
0.3975028395652771,
0.834878146648407,
-0.09691133350133896,
0.14072388410568237,
-0.7549521327018738,
0.3627494275569916,
0.7081872224807739,
0.22406716644763947,
0.20636491477489471,
0.028305284678936005,
0.19149845838546753,
-0.30928006768226624,
-0.485571026802063,
-0.7320770621299744,
0.05205480381846428,
-0.14012813568115234,
0.6322152614593506,
0.8929620385169983,
0.1389443278312683,
0.09216319769620895,
-0.3022111654281616,
1.0369963645935059,
0.37755078077316284,
-0.618764340877533,
0.5586600303649902,
-0.30711469054222107,
0.31788551807403564,
0.4640711545944214,
0.5118334293365479,
-0.20115889608860016,
-0.3381521999835968,
-0.6945128440856934,
-0.9616531729698181,
0.18267683684825897,
0.47673553228378296,
0.5681421756744385,
0.06155078113079071,
0.08664634078741074,
-0.24773675203323364,
0.1735420674085617,
-0.6180189847946167,
-0.400519460439682,
-0.552497923374176,
0.03442004695534706,
0.1865476667881012,
-0.16607603430747986,
-0.5764973759651184,
0.07427268475294113,
0.39446452260017395,
0.3968110680580139,
0.3369690179824829,
0.059386417269706726,
0.05303911119699478,
0.1210295632481575,
0.3482167720794678,
0.7409358024597168,
0.2833145260810852,
0.11754050105810165,
0.14687100052833557,
-0.07743226736783981,
-0.510638415813446,
0.24940364062786102,
0.30130860209465027,
-0.35659027099609375,
-0.1877589374780655,
0.6253872513771057,
0.6352471709251404,
-0.6304337978363037,
-0.5005106925964355,
0.3178643584251404,
0.1498590111732483,
-0.3762490153312683,
-0.753063976764679,
0.2538336515426636,
-0.19385716319084167,
0.1786133348941803,
0.6209617853164673,
0.23180720210075378,
0.11526966094970703,
-0.8264734745025635,
0.15532712638378143,
0.7291917204856873,
-0.4718136191368103,
-0.43130919337272644,
0.872174859046936,
0.35847291350364685,
-0.22278426587581635,
0.9246974587440491,
-0.15343141555786133,
-0.5685343146324158,
1.1656666994094849,
0.5965127348899841,
1.166446566581726,
-0.5482207536697388,
0.15920622646808624,
-0.14086751639842987,
0.8001593947410583,
0.2497754693031311,
0.19448265433311462,
-0.1356995403766632,
-0.7093807458877563,
0.257651150226593,
0.0018264394020661712,
-0.8287238478660583,
0.2591816186904907,
-0.7052069306373596,
-0.29610317945480347,
-0.7952316403388977,
-0.4923936128616333,
-0.051550742238759995,
-0.29176363348960876,
-0.5486283898353577,
0.13619132339954376,
0.138572558760643,
0.7111569046974182,
-0.5048882961273193,
0.2208966612815857,
0.6081307530403137,
-0.6782354712486267,
0.05603635311126709,
0.06993956863880157,
0.20035305619239807,
-0.7260957360267639,
0.515236496925354,
0.2604106068611145,
-0.1501699686050415,
-0.05588848143815994,
-0.41913551092147827,
-0.7563906908035278,
0.937899649143219,
-0.03493432328104973,
-0.20878006517887115,
0.05981159955263138,
0.6668077707290649,
0.3502926230430603,
-0.11460456252098083,
-0.23658688366413116,
0.38235947489738464,
0.4781852960586548,
-0.15626558661460876,
0.0013377029681578279,
-0.0879051685333252,
-0.42159438133239746,
0.09924472123384476,
0.17551422119140625,
-0.7419329285621643,
0.5369789600372314,
-0.17809666693210602,
-0.35321128368377686,
0.08032205700874329,
0.7287408709526062,
0.06864317506551743,
0.5406456589698792,
0.37584778666496277,
0.8253896832466125,
0.33217576146125793,
-0.20636801421642303,
0.8553811311721802,
0.05472579970955849,
-0.23683184385299683,
0.6895842552185059,
-0.4500143229961395,
0.2101491242647171,
0.2742394506931305,
-0.3009335398674011,
0.7145622372627258,
0.5391923785209656,
-0.6478179693222046,
0.25412172079086304,
0.15349023044109344,
-0.8306643962860107,
0.08049654960632324,
-0.2898012399673462,
-0.7654067873954773,
0.6211463212966919,
0.814368486404419,
0.045313261449337006,
0.054377663880586624,
0.27151989936828613,
-0.5479032397270203,
-0.009199120104312897,
-0.2093997448682785,
1.0641165971755981,
0.22280322015285492,
-0.3611673414707184,
-0.40362033247947693,
0.023895975202322006,
0.5107166767120361,
-0.6454365253448486,
0.035332802683115005,
-0.11839985102415085,
-0.0732804611325264,
0.0711049810051918,
-0.5237172842025757,
0.6517537236213684,
0.09448649734258652,
0.01965697854757309,
-0.14900709688663483,
0.46572375297546387,
-0.008254943415522575,
-0.29737821221351624,
0.10463438183069229,
0.1839674711227417,
-0.49575793743133545,
-0.1939661204814911,
-0.7161787748336792,
0.16590379178524017,
-0.3165223002433777,
-0.046915002167224884,
0.41611576080322266,
0.3517090380191803,
-0.06476588547229767,
0.8845115303993225,
0.4573536813259125,
-0.2132083773612976,
0.033125486224889755,
0.04227367788553238,
0.516598641872406,
-0.6357144117355347,
-0.5638903975486755,
-1.019792079925537,
0.2677116394042969,
-0.3502556383609772,
-0.49739062786102295,
0.774996817111969,
0.1945321410894394,
0.763582170009613,
-0.25097885727882385,
0.9323060512542725,
-0.2538146376609802,
-0.3748466372489929,
-0.3972679674625397,
1.035803198814392,
-0.15155981481075287,
0.25528013706207275,
-0.02908410131931305,
-0.5038465857505798,
-0.33151042461395264,
0.16234621405601501,
0.03661210834980011,
0.21912863850593567,
0.25975626707077026,
0.4998420774936676,
0.2907136380672455,
-0.26614803075790405,
0.1840035319328308,
-0.22854790091514587,
0.625740647315979,
0.36483341455459595,
0.9737474918365479,
-0.4057829678058624,
0.31549784541130066,
-0.22276829183101654,
-0.1407606452703476,
-0.20446652173995972,
-0.6589645147323608,
-0.5375551581382751,
-0.6921748518943787,
-0.7260317206382751,
-0.33491045236587524,
-0.09991216659545898,
0.263347864151001,
0.7279430031776428,
-1.1317899227142334,
0.2199813276529312,
-0.35197725892066956,
0.4789544343948364,
-0.5235625505447388,
-0.2749166488647461,
0.06667061150074005,
-0.34334123134613037,
-0.4680687487125397,
0.2794278562068939,
0.3259105384349823,
0.587450385093689,
-0.37661945819854736,
0.5167440176010132,
-0.060425616800785065,
0.17801669239997864,
0.5153846740722656,
0.8395910859107971,
-0.4168102741241455,
-0.2520614564418793,
-0.26307380199432373,
-0.021890155971050262,
-0.40077513456344604,
0.8957422971725464,
-0.07572075724601746,
0.4751228094100952,
0.6503720879554749,
1.2630226612091064,
-0.0023245883639901876,
0.2591457664966583,
0.8619306683540344,
-1.0647608041763306,
0.24765188992023468,
0.2824925482273102,
0.08940525352954865,
0.19837579131126404,
-1.0115151405334473,
0.42442360520362854,
0.2451232671737671,
-0.27226001024246216,
-0.8026412725448608,
0.823380172252655,
-0.6754480004310608,
-0.4657348096370697,
0.3592335879802704,
-0.025177227333188057,
0.4241463243961334,
-0.3509232997894287,
0.3452148139476776,
0.12847405672073364,
0.22950688004493713,
1.0907636880874634,
0.6852982044219971,
-0.26786309480667114,
-0.21720920503139496,
-0.2672696113586426,
0.8030523061752319,
0.46497756242752075,
-0.8456314206123352,
-0.013330081477761269,
0.10850700736045837,
-0.22153685986995697,
0.5400044918060303,
0.40119338035583496,
-0.2752377390861511,
0.4144899845123291,
0.5444624423980713,
-0.21195575594902039,
-0.07572910189628601,
-0.6318256855010986,
-0.37621814012527466,
0.419325053691864,
0.31542468070983887,
-0.4515492618083954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12605v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12605v1 | What is a word? | 2024-02-19T23:58:20 | 2024-02-19T23:58:20 | Elliot Murphy | cs.CL | cs.CL | In order to design strong paradigms for isolating lexical access and
semantics, we need to know what a word is. Surprisingly few linguists and
philosophers have a clear model of what a word is, even though words impact
basically every aspect of human life. Researchers that regularly publish
academic papers about language often rely on outdated, or inaccurate,
assumptions about wordhood. This short pedagogical document outlines what the
lexicon is most certainly not (though is often mistakenly taken to be), what it
might be (based on current good theories), and what some implications for
experimental design are. | [
-0.29509133100509644,
-1.1179155111312866,
0.6598842144012451,
0.27325087785720825,
-0.22746069729328156,
0.09855948388576508,
-0.12327837944030762,
-0.6667994260787964,
0.2408292293548584,
0.04773024097084999,
-0.28141021728515625,
-0.10616742074489594,
-0.819991409778595,
-0.023710504174232483,
-0.563523530960083,
0.6573928594589233,
0.014462394639849663,
0.16538411378860474,
-0.2297079861164093,
-0.3537024259567261,
-0.4834928512573242,
-0.09488452970981598,
-0.3089310824871063,
-0.4666602611541748,
0.5656594634056091,
0.08426696062088013,
1.0380196571350098,
0.5927717685699463,
0.4647611677646637,
0.3526855707168579,
-0.6421365737915039,
-0.29358285665512085,
-0.16440235078334808,
-0.2575565576553345,
-0.45648249983787537,
-0.6584504246711731,
-0.14534145593643188,
0.2525372803211212,
0.43893492221832275,
1.4275277853012085,
-0.09819570928812027,
0.2165452241897583,
0.16786344349384308,
0.5980874300003052,
-0.8066973686218262,
0.17077012360095978,
-0.35230958461761475,
0.029023120179772377,
-0.41544079780578613,
0.05562863498926163,
0.0004976280033588409,
-0.42136257886886597,
0.1874164491891861,
-0.9221490621566772,
0.2122495174407959,
0.14792223274707794,
1.0205200910568237,
-0.06128612160682678,
-0.4027521014213562,
-0.42981329560279846,
-0.6286108493804932,
0.5569312572479248,
-0.4293629825115204,
0.7076852321624756,
0.5314240455627441,
-0.027238240465521812,
-0.23782669007778168,
-0.9163419008255005,
-0.6527480483055115,
-0.08377125859260559,
-0.08901592344045639,
0.032318368554115295,
0.10893014073371887,
0.5054430961608887,
0.34557631611824036,
0.4712904393672943,
-0.27791520953178406,
-0.3360510766506195,
-0.7062183618545532,
-0.1391429305076599,
0.5045225620269775,
-0.03247837722301483,
0.6678653955459595,
-0.19549083709716797,
-0.3344280421733856,
0.3459376394748688,
-0.5656024813652039,
-0.1541944146156311,
0.33137986063957214,
0.11321919411420822,
-0.006732151843607426,
0.6249815225601196,
0.13835874199867249,
0.6635298132896423,
-0.40326133370399475,
-0.11986438930034637,
0.21263431012630463,
-0.2092423439025879,
0.14619842171669006,
0.09366098046302795,
0.6380364298820496,
0.27581167221069336,
0.1193208247423172,
-0.5864169597625732,
-0.248148113489151,
0.44089603424072266,
0.5765915513038635,
-0.4479821026325226,
-0.28237155079841614,
0.1000693291425705,
-0.0877823755145073,
-0.06646475940942764,
0.15613248944282532,
-0.5556195974349976,
-0.33063825964927673,
-0.3472524583339691,
0.7641146183013916,
-0.3239666521549225,
-0.33478212356567383,
0.2346031367778778,
-0.7794885039329529,
0.03373068571090698,
0.26227661967277527,
-0.9622633457183838,
0.609440267086029,
0.6342413425445557,
0.6551681756973267,
-0.0723525658249855,
-0.47337430715560913,
0.38976454734802246,
0.0907169058918953,
-0.7240551710128784,
0.7197468876838684,
-0.480111688375473,
-0.9397697448730469,
0.07869190722703934,
0.23974184691905975,
0.30913567543029785,
-0.20444554090499878,
0.49519309401512146,
-0.425099641084671,
0.32925164699554443,
-0.6643128395080566,
-0.935400128364563,
-0.3422815203666687,
0.07584653794765472,
-0.5019711852073669,
0.4608651101589203,
0.13952404260635376,
-0.9083631634712219,
0.6072548627853394,
-0.566347062587738,
-0.34061384201049805,
0.5142875909805298,
-0.36493605375289917,
0.3859173059463501,
0.6060612797737122,
-0.6293747425079346,
-0.2555336654186249,
-0.36204564571380615,
0.2101173996925354,
-0.29511237144470215,
-0.17118816077709198,
0.5752336382865906,
0.10332981497049332,
0.5542704463005066,
0.35125118494033813,
-0.11763463169336319,
-0.1028648391366005,
-0.6732228994369507,
0.06224793568253517,
0.19923186302185059,
-0.3968547284603119,
-0.7085287570953369,
0.5941064953804016,
0.026827221736311913,
-0.1904619336128235,
0.30372023582458496,
-1.0571303367614746,
0.19609498977661133,
-0.2483183741569519,
0.6440285444259644,
0.2939557433128357,
-0.26932114362716675,
0.5318084955215454,
-0.4132102429866791,
0.42344963550567627,
-0.48509591817855835,
-0.029008354991674423,
0.31582167744636536,
-0.5253587365150452,
-0.5668553113937378,
0.019829699769616127,
0.5900034308433533,
0.3485717475414276,
-0.27493059635162354,
0.22115828096866608,
0.20152419805526733,
-0.3675927221775055,
-0.42013344168663025,
0.1973201334476471,
0.2408093810081482,
0.31612205505371094,
0.03668463975191116,
-0.414365291595459,
-0.4366372227668762,
-0.9091232419013977,
-0.5883066654205322,
-0.4167407155036926,
0.052759114652872086,
-0.05071103945374489,
0.5264227986335754,
0.02609897032380104,
0.9588398933410645,
-0.7021787166595459,
-0.11189725995063782,
-0.3678009808063507,
0.31491270661354065,
-0.08855626732110977,
-0.1521124243736267,
0.3901570439338684,
-0.6132156252861023,
0.3732055723667145,
-0.5202586054801941,
-0.7922685146331787,
-0.024857809767127037,
0.31592172384262085,
-0.1536944955587387,
-0.40800800919532776,
0.6188980937004089,
-0.3011532425880432,
0.473603218793869,
0.45134440064430237,
-0.5078192949295044,
0.26649653911590576,
-0.44795286655426025,
-0.5146108269691467,
-0.7908298969268799,
0.09792603552341461,
0.00667339563369751,
0.24465951323509216,
-0.5514949560165405,
0.4989995062351227,
0.2818332314491272,
-0.05967159569263458,
-0.6673715114593506,
0.7589206695556641,
-0.4956464469432831,
0.21524621546268463,
-0.7873310446739197,
0.31713438034057617,
0.32612475752830505,
0.00868268497288227,
0.013028368353843689,
0.6384075284004211,
0.3102571666240692,
-0.6998680830001831,
0.06303563714027405,
0.3239060640335083,
-0.30369439721107483,
0.40189090371131897,
-0.6474584937095642,
-0.057110775262117386,
-0.5351002812385559,
-0.03036677837371826,
-0.7676835060119629,
-0.26466408371925354,
-0.09580343961715698,
-0.20329280197620392,
0.15457211434841156,
0.19734641909599304,
-0.48292896151542664,
-0.4303688704967499,
-0.015117388218641281,
0.4797685146331787,
0.14781497418880463,
-0.1119304746389389,
0.1497592031955719,
1.068372368812561,
0.15404094755649567,
-0.14579707384109497,
-0.7664775848388672,
-0.03870467469096184,
0.11610119789838791,
-0.4124945104122162,
0.18098241090774536,
-0.039731863886117935,
-0.8414890766143799,
0.13697242736816406,
-0.040043722838163376,
-0.37605634331703186,
0.4298746585845947,
0.4876275062561035,
-0.04267458617687225,
0.028559891507029533,
0.8181834816932678,
-0.28882017731666565,
0.2266635298728943,
0.35723984241485596,
0.09984421730041504,
0.2592662274837494,
-0.24596336483955383,
-0.022556591778993607,
0.18692246079444885,
0.550818145275116,
0.4100725054740906,
0.07715088129043579,
0.43880337476730347,
0.004962681792676449,
-0.6827310919761658,
-0.3214397728443146,
-0.13244619965553284,
-0.042371563613414764,
-0.45911508798599243,
0.32289785146713257,
-0.2538148760795593,
-0.3012825548648834,
0.22640636563301086,
-0.06683554500341415,
-0.13126058876514435,
0.3432193398475647,
0.13578836619853973,
-0.09316788613796234,
0.4768370985984802,
0.9049196243286133,
0.1668979972600937,
0.07084575295448303,
-0.08434805274009705,
0.312462717294693,
-0.7427967190742493,
-0.17439903318881989,
-0.5159581899642944,
-0.22520852088928223,
-0.596657395362854,
-0.09059983491897583,
0.059254445135593414,
0.2723306119441986,
0.12042184174060822,
0.27187806367874146,
-0.2848343253135681,
0.4277065098285675,
0.3370598554611206,
-0.1406712532043457,
0.09422698616981506,
-0.6427003145217896,
-0.26070716977119446,
0.0396333783864975,
-0.6159144043922424,
-0.6969627737998962,
0.6601301431655884,
0.3023768365383148,
1.1012083292007446,
0.13031357526779175,
0.338426798582077,
0.056242961436510086,
0.15025630593299866,
-1.0378319025039673,
0.6285293102264404,
0.19614581763744354,
-1.175911784172058,
-0.10673445463180542,
0.22068458795547485,
-1.1777817010879517,
0.24831058084964752,
-0.4086449444293976,
-0.7024980187416077,
0.18117685616016388,
0.1539764255285263,
-0.08482759445905685,
0.31845492124557495,
-0.7536479830741882,
0.6816636323928833,
-0.3519207239151001,
-0.3267943859100342,
0.01627156138420105,
-0.4237242639064789,
0.40797996520996094,
-0.1043701022863388,
0.7675741314888,
-0.4137679636478424,
-0.15600383281707764,
0.9197221994400024,
-0.25635597109794617,
0.5258269309997559,
0.1249823048710823,
-0.05496084317564964,
0.5997418165206909,
0.35951459407806396,
-0.04293516278266907,
-0.18480385839939117,
0.16104280948638916,
0.28288909792900085,
0.5174133777618408,
-0.1738969087600708,
-0.5102076530456543,
0.16145779192447662,
-0.6223889589309692,
-0.5599690079689026,
-0.4197717010974884,
-0.630588173866272,
-0.3579337000846863,
0.12671907246112823,
0.4922771155834198,
0.44883814454078674,
-0.5403872132301331,
0.0036974404938519,
0.44660601019859314,
-0.20548948645591736,
0.32706570625305176,
0.44204720854759216,
-0.5195139050483704,
0.10341473668813705,
0.982062816619873,
0.4984821379184723,
0.125652015209198,
0.2704135775566101,
0.7051692008972168,
-0.4186877906322479,
-0.4358917772769928,
-0.18645025789737701,
0.24996936321258545,
-0.7196091413497925,
0.4910981059074402,
-0.4139809310436249,
-0.41991284489631653,
-0.15914927423000336,
-0.13867740333080292,
-0.2784609794616699,
-0.4225222170352936,
-0.07044758647680283,
-0.133386492729187,
0.19973790645599365,
1.2361012697219849,
-0.2126913219690323,
0.30975058674812317,
-0.5745261907577515,
0.4133753776550293,
0.5632812976837158,
0.3866575360298157,
-0.2783699631690979,
-0.22657425701618195,
0.11304573714733124,
-0.09832847118377686,
-0.3658014237880707,
-1.2370563745498657,
0.037184443324804306,
0.43930289149284363,
0.6682435274124146,
0.5282040238380432,
0.020518818870186806,
0.13300704956054688,
-0.6781619787216187,
0.9433980584144592,
0.2798005938529968,
-0.9268982410430908,
0.5999851226806641,
-0.22411200404167175,
0.38332077860832214,
0.5072901844978333,
0.3644351363182068,
-0.9810171127319336,
-0.5148131847381592,
-0.9953348636627197,
-1.129855751991272,
-0.01247982308268547,
-0.28479650616645813,
0.30022522807121277,
-0.4727374017238617,
0.2112588733434677,
0.13799253106117249,
0.5187017321586609,
-0.21499784290790558,
-0.2183471918106079,
-0.18928313255310059,
-0.04607848450541496,
-0.11725328117609024,
-0.42989110946655273,
-0.5335009694099426,
-0.08604925125837326,
0.274863064289093,
0.06321051716804504,
0.12142188102006912,
0.06944030523300171,
-0.261360228061676,
-0.09488335251808167,
0.45334142446517944,
0.44717538356781006,
1.2146618366241455,
0.018610214814543724,
0.5793317556381226,
0.0948762595653534,
-0.7978029251098633,
0.1935771405696869,
-0.2542613744735718,
-0.26627951860427856,
0.24155721068382263,
0.338265597820282,
0.3909255862236023,
0.3778509795665741,
-0.6690061092376709,
0.5656169652938843,
-0.0033831577748060226,
-0.5560898184776306,
-0.40310317277908325,
0.12767434120178223,
0.20854690670967102,
-0.18136096000671387,
0.2829252779483795,
-0.4197823107242584,
0.15716353058815002,
-0.9173678755760193,
0.04014120623469353,
0.5145750045776367,
-0.3179580569267273,
-0.6165683269500732,
0.7831452488899231,
0.21016664803028107,
-0.5630645155906677,
0.07803604006767273,
-0.13503369688987732,
-0.4534992277622223,
0.3152220845222473,
0.517160177230835,
0.6881586909294128,
0.02389240637421608,
0.178745836019516,
0.2208983153104782,
0.3132675886154175,
-0.37372174859046936,
0.6215413808822632,
0.15040694177150726,
-1.0070910453796387,
-0.04339329153299332,
-0.8532626032829285,
-0.5321743488311768,
0.3221035599708557,
-0.5522623658180237,
0.1070471778512001,
-0.6707005500793457,
-0.3387066423892975,
0.321896493434906,
-0.050853319466114044,
-0.5174931287765503,
0.3314949870109558,
0.29216164350509644,
1.3151671886444092,
-0.8135568499565125,
0.44333475828170776,
0.8310969471931458,
-0.31984952092170715,
-0.9114505052566528,
-0.16978295147418976,
0.33466553688049316,
-0.4927348494529724,
0.6402773857116699,
-0.12680993974208832,
-0.06827893853187561,
-0.32770878076553345,
-0.7705757021903992,
-1.0299339294433594,
0.4932555854320526,
0.08235330134630203,
-0.34929555654525757,
-0.16187867522239685,
0.06836045533418655,
0.510837197303772,
0.11786027997732162,
-0.025592748075723648,
0.3039678633213043,
0.6367817521095276,
-0.1421981155872345,
-0.6460634469985962,
-0.1471427083015442,
-0.35245659947395325,
0.17915090918540955,
0.36524251103401184,
-0.4215250015258789,
0.7509679794311523,
-0.13127656280994415,
-0.431184858083725,
-0.09568853676319122,
0.5599515438079834,
-0.21009817719459534,
0.02144692651927471,
0.37339332699775696,
0.6161108016967773,
0.7085361480712891,
-0.27488526701927185,
1.0148811340332031,
-0.538822591304779,
0.03981319069862366,
0.8246873617172241,
-0.03329039365053177,
0.4920804500579834,
0.5849800705909729,
-0.41643479466438293,
0.20224153995513916,
0.6567782759666443,
0.29179567098617554,
0.3758806586265564,
0.6468082666397095,
-0.34875741600990295,
-0.09738536924123764,
-0.2555142641067505,
-0.3174157738685608,
0.9162051677703857,
0.7854936122894287,
-0.38122066855430603,
-0.28099963068962097,
-0.1723387986421585,
0.10178501904010773,
0.16927304863929749,
-0.11817920207977295,
0.6380232572555542,
0.17232754826545715,
-0.6116443872451782,
0.08786201477050781,
-0.1649627983570099,
0.2898868918418884,
-0.7207835912704468,
0.09904056787490845,
0.06216837465763092,
0.1553194671869278,
-0.0718131884932518,
-0.7923750877380371,
0.3447439670562744,
-0.5291336178779602,
0.0731598287820816,
0.0955314040184021,
0.7283346652984619,
-0.2768939435482025,
-0.4474797546863556,
0.2052643895149231,
0.8175864219665527,
0.3070133626461029,
0.3848927915096283,
-0.31468090415000916,
0.11956097185611725,
-0.7708998918533325,
-0.08078436553478241,
0.13552090525627136,
0.4890648126602173,
0.017909901216626167,
0.568555474281311,
0.2159198522567749,
0.7071257829666138,
0.21781496703624725,
-0.13892433047294617,
0.4124975800514221,
-0.7692238092422485,
-0.3487561345100403,
-0.4100331962108612,
0.07015398144721985,
0.005187956616282463,
-0.7915652394294739,
0.6639180183410645,
0.42242223024368286,
0.8424526453018188,
0.22336435317993164,
0.9186308979988098,
-0.2567419409751892,
0.375051349401474,
-0.1799704134464264,
0.878801167011261,
-0.6418882608413696,
-0.10613582283258438,
-0.3358125388622284,
-0.5403102040290833,
-0.28987056016921997,
0.7053779363632202,
-0.17975378036499023,
-0.2774452567100525,
0.9118031859397888,
0.4115390479564667,
0.16065190732479095,
0.45449012517929077,
0.33636999130249023,
0.059458136558532715,
-0.09682150185108185,
-0.14900463819503784,
1.0575852394104004,
-0.1988557130098343,
0.012097608298063278,
-0.3554896116256714,
-0.14010167121887207,
-0.07233092933893204,
-0.8370122313499451,
-0.3618943393230438,
-0.8378807902336121,
-0.27735310792922974,
-0.3611065745353699,
0.42128023505210876,
0.65981125831604,
0.5159335732460022,
-0.2530268430709839,
-0.40273165702819824,
-0.2385750412940979,
0.158055379986763,
-0.03609898313879967,
-0.1641078144311905,
-0.011484273709356785,
-0.47062385082244873,
-0.45390406250953674,
0.12826278805732727,
0.06205521523952484,
0.055668119341135025,
-0.43271273374557495,
0.2616793215274811,
-0.06262016296386719,
0.5205153226852417,
0.5136107802391052,
0.5838644504547119,
-0.49273064732551575,
-0.6152957677841187,
-0.2282600998878479,
-0.22486288845539093,
0.04699046537280083,
0.8979566097259521,
-0.4675406813621521,
0.6878023147583008,
0.6910572052001953,
0.3217836022377014,
-0.22677350044250488,
-0.27903759479522705,
0.6003671884536743,
-0.5618932247161865,
0.23786577582359314,
0.16981934010982513,
0.6500900983810425,
0.1521235853433609,
-0.08440537750720978,
0.43027201294898987,
0.5857285261154175,
-0.42060279846191406,
-0.5575622320175171,
0.4997989237308502,
-0.7137607932090759,
-0.797667920589447,
1.254550576210022,
0.2931567132472992,
-0.9468261003494263,
-0.2455960214138031,
-0.0481901578605175,
0.13511517643928528,
-0.03492675721645355,
0.9095108509063721,
1.002805471420288,
0.16389256715774536,
-0.14348648488521576,
-0.8262311220169067,
0.6856659650802612,
-0.06627696752548218,
-0.4786677658557892,
-0.10262368619441986,
0.2297806441783905,
0.4848370850086212,
0.46113860607147217,
0.4667365550994873,
-0.08651574701070786,
0.11993265897035599,
0.18987521529197693,
0.2994231879711151,
0.2831170856952667,
-0.1699199080467224,
0.14481578767299652,
0.23407992720603943,
0.3867921829223633,
-0.3037550151348114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08818v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08818v1 | Multimodal Fusion of EHR in Structures and Semantics: Integrating Clinical Records and Notes with Hypergraph and LLM | 2024-02-19T23:48:40 | 2024-02-19T23:48:40 | Hejie Cui, Xinyu Fang, Ran Xu, Xuan Kan, Joyce C. Ho, Carl Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Electronic Health Records (EHRs) have become increasingly popular to support
clinical decision-making and healthcare in recent decades. EHRs usually contain
heterogeneous information, such as structural data in tabular form and
unstructured data in textual notes. Different types of information in EHRs can
complement each other and provide a more complete picture of the health status
of a patient. While there has been a lot of research on representation learning
of structured EHR data, the fusion of different types of EHR data (multimodal
fusion) is not well studied. This is mostly because of the complex medical
coding systems used and the noise and redundancy present in the written notes.
In this work, we propose a new framework called MINGLE, which integrates both
structures and semantics in EHR effectively. Our framework uses a two-level
infusion strategy to combine medical concept semantics and clinical note
semantics into hypergraph neural networks, which learn the complex interactions
between different types of data to generate visit representations for
downstream prediction. Experiment results on two EHR datasets, the public
MIMIC-III and private CRADLE, show that MINGLE can effectively improve
predictive performance by 11.83% relatively, enhancing semantic integration as
well as multimodal fusion for structural and textual EHR data. | [
-0.07262910902500153,
-0.7742374539375305,
0.7109204530715942,
0.14437778294086456,
-0.20141297578811646,
-0.0071422685869038105,
0.07936330884695053,
-0.6535226702690125,
0.5760601162910461,
0.5361697673797607,
-0.27339187264442444,
-0.6946494579315186,
-0.32587945461273193,
-0.2698270082473755,
-0.08463957905769348,
1.1951231956481934,
0.01762695424258709,
0.24191367626190186,
-0.7188772559165955,
-0.2717600166797638,
-0.4920135736465454,
-0.6765798330307007,
-0.18543288111686707,
-0.5551015138626099,
0.40430647134780884,
0.3323545455932617,
0.5932711362838745,
0.7354229688644409,
0.7142148017883301,
0.34761473536491394,
0.11449388414621353,
0.30999818444252014,
-0.17410501837730408,
0.3332945704460144,
0.27125832438468933,
-0.305891752243042,
-0.8321805000305176,
-0.5176376104354858,
0.7394046783447266,
0.5595663189888,
-0.24472668766975403,
-0.019415922462940216,
0.1258462816476822,
0.6198257803916931,
-0.3853214383125305,
0.5687602162361145,
-0.23236091434955597,
0.13746215403079987,
-0.2649190127849579,
-0.4467153251171112,
-0.4959583580493927,
-0.20966820418834686,
0.23591724038124084,
-0.5596629977226257,
-0.05867382511496544,
0.28283384442329407,
0.7526400685310364,
0.2879278063774109,
-0.6725832223892212,
0.07870633155107498,
-0.6189329624176025,
0.5738990902900696,
-0.416103333234787,
0.6180128455162048,
0.38321593403816223,
0.4036889374256134,
-0.15166230499744415,
-0.8605567812919617,
-0.5106143951416016,
-0.025860540568828583,
-0.5518926978111267,
0.48401781916618347,
-0.012451537884771824,
0.45484334230422974,
0.05771801620721817,
0.2826480567455292,
-0.6181621551513672,
-0.0960780531167984,
-0.168819397687912,
-0.3232496380805969,
0.5079827308654785,
0.42048555612564087,
0.4174979031085968,
-0.47415193915367126,
-0.6683956980705261,
-0.15289445221424103,
-0.3805772066116333,
-0.3808897137641907,
-0.30747121572494507,
0.27304649353027344,
-0.47959017753601074,
0.5740478038787842,
0.0031506626401096582,
0.5891039371490479,
0.1563945859670639,
-0.5798738598823547,
0.7949517965316772,
-0.4131639003753662,
-0.3150589168071747,
0.5679057240486145,
0.8065131306648254,
0.4827830493450165,
-0.34869614243507385,
-0.11885862052440643,
0.060368698090314865,
0.30734673142433167,
-0.05299749597907066,
-0.575701117515564,
-0.3360425531864166,
0.6529579758644104,
-0.8186473250389099,
-0.11760346591472626,
-0.02260691300034523,
-0.8881603479385376,
-0.5449008345603943,
-0.29327452182769775,
0.2288956493139267,
-0.6651456952095032,
-0.14782844483852386,
0.033215273171663284,
-0.31622856855392456,
-0.12667635083198547,
0.4926437735557556,
-0.6489984393119812,
0.39786750078201294,
0.5336931347846985,
0.8094589710235596,
0.038593508303165436,
-0.292942076921463,
-0.7417608499526978,
0.6589208245277405,
0.2820360064506531,
0.8096805810928345,
-0.3432113826274872,
-0.43980875611305237,
0.13939277827739716,
-0.09656357765197754,
-0.39943814277648926,
-0.5774757862091064,
0.48101913928985596,
-0.3845687508583069,
0.252322256565094,
0.1906040608882904,
-0.6456174850463867,
-0.07743597775697708,
0.4766876995563507,
-0.9949671626091003,
0.7982545495033264,
0.35302966833114624,
-0.8827173709869385,
0.49275174736976624,
-0.5731566548347473,
-0.7067630290985107,
0.3450750708580017,
-0.3726351857185364,
-0.6553775668144226,
-0.3124799132347107,
-0.00295966281555593,
0.537000834941864,
-0.18607187271118164,
0.1993923783302307,
-0.27727076411247253,
0.03384725749492645,
0.20322749018669128,
0.12958934903144836,
0.4595825970172882,
0.16915850341320038,
0.1600644886493683,
0.3109447658061981,
-1.0101776123046875,
-0.002961277961730957,
-0.19355739653110504,
-0.5528001189231873,
-0.44384193420410156,
0.07548267394304276,
0.5459718108177185,
0.495591938495636,
0.09974044561386108,
-0.5503092408180237,
-0.18618538975715637,
-0.19718605279922485,
0.31304237246513367,
0.15830078721046448,
0.189846470952034,
0.38617679476737976,
-0.8617373704910278,
0.2715744376182556,
0.6324469447135925,
0.13258591294288635,
-0.34132781624794006,
-0.4490925073623657,
-0.2832754850387573,
-0.6163066625595093,
0.1552935093641281,
0.6512178778648376,
-0.4844323694705963,
0.4185391962528229,
-0.3923565447330475,
-0.22239595651626587,
-0.7250964045524597,
0.02632175199687481,
0.33722177147865295,
0.8782099485397339,
0.6591596603393555,
-0.29774531722068787,
-0.5914183855056763,
-0.6529160737991333,
0.3101421296596527,
-0.4717893898487091,
0.018201623111963272,
0.4512959420681,
0.2130243331193924,
-0.48757973313331604,
0.6373555064201355,
-0.310519278049469,
-0.8236333727836609,
-0.4819217324256897,
0.03383385390043259,
-0.016874078661203384,
0.6444534659385681,
0.12837111949920654,
-0.9790987968444824,
-0.43381601572036743,
0.2751859724521637,
-0.8941611647605896,
0.4046275317668915,
-0.09440302103757858,
0.0140627296641469,
-0.15279778838157654,
0.47602608799934387,
-0.5466229319572449,
0.027440061792731285,
0.4924246072769165,
-0.13306714594364166,
0.21436190605163574,
-0.4803539216518402,
0.15399686992168427,
-1.4082564115524292,
-0.1497865617275238,
0.0887085571885109,
-0.34890273213386536,
-0.7227673530578613,
-0.2336387038230896,
0.18397648632526398,
-0.13501964509487152,
-0.37956345081329346,
0.3795304596424103,
-0.47122177481651306,
0.2533194422721863,
0.20759868621826172,
0.17425665259361267,
0.19155478477478027,
0.3404240608215332,
0.008789601735770702,
-0.16131040453910828,
0.5028828978538513,
-0.3035513758659363,
0.3794153034687042,
0.7713163495063782,
-0.23575584590435028,
0.8258126378059387,
-0.46253708004951477,
-0.1346661001443863,
-0.32363590598106384,
0.5595515966415405,
-0.9339336156845093,
-0.7394275665283203,
0.09108267724514008,
-0.34951305389404297,
0.5202519297599792,
-0.15989209711551666,
-0.46994486451148987,
-0.17338073253631592,
-0.24431851506233215,
0.42645159363746643,
0.39859434962272644,
-0.1807001531124115,
1.1622565984725952,
0.5921584367752075,
0.05694761499762535,
-0.3426905870437622,
-0.9471391439437866,
-0.07078151404857635,
-0.1389622688293457,
-0.9300381541252136,
0.8638127446174622,
0.2184242308139801,
-0.20323416590690613,
0.3400099277496338,
0.284559041261673,
-0.13261033594608307,
-0.35526490211486816,
0.7000914216041565,
0.7215119004249573,
-0.3781565725803375,
0.3836532235145569,
0.043099112808704376,
-0.13024058938026428,
-0.005676920060068369,
-0.22570613026618958,
0.4555317461490631,
0.08646873384714127,
-0.5722903609275818,
-0.7267385125160217,
0.5660827159881592,
0.9117929339408875,
-0.34451308846473694,
0.7971674203872681,
0.4193808138370514,
-0.6004313826560974,
0.07418114691972733,
-0.6191288232803345,
-0.017291584983468056,
-0.3329090476036072,
0.39788705110549927,
-0.15013326704502106,
-0.7106125354766846,
0.47750183939933777,
-0.10502833873033524,
-0.1773635298013687,
0.2872752845287323,
0.5800751447677612,
-0.38726237416267395,
1.1015831232070923,
0.5098661780357361,
-0.02052268572151661,
0.31739553809165955,
-0.11270651966333389,
0.018059536814689636,
-0.9623753428459167,
-0.7870669364929199,
-0.3605368137359619,
-0.23954345285892487,
-0.9187771677970886,
-0.2576805353164673,
0.8053553104400635,
-0.42085886001586914,
-0.06715002655982971,
-0.05036474019289017,
-0.1471300572156906,
0.033979110419750214,
0.2550031244754791,
0.6157289743423462,
0.35359078645706177,
-0.10263501852750778,
-0.18501152098178864,
0.20026324689388275,
-0.8137531876564026,
-0.19773204624652863,
0.8352728486061096,
0.30390462279319763,
0.7457922101020813,
0.1045568659901619,
0.9197866916656494,
0.089215949177742,
0.1571667641401291,
-0.8630342483520508,
0.32127031683921814,
-0.1856464296579361,
-0.46220606565475464,
-0.12274780869483948,
-0.19026896357536316,
-0.8192794322967529,
0.2287541776895523,
-0.7838509678840637,
-0.541739821434021,
0.22692248225212097,
0.546846330165863,
-0.49720489978790283,
0.05976893752813339,
-0.566649854183197,
0.8620059490203857,
-0.012060207314789295,
-0.3578897714614868,
-0.20303115248680115,
-1.1759018898010254,
0.22455668449401855,
-0.010241232812404633,
0.2749024033546448,
0.21323081851005554,
0.3415040969848633,
0.5416732430458069,
-0.43683508038520813,
0.6902402639389038,
0.19244487583637238,
0.4018579125404358,
0.18400128185749054,
0.0514460988342762,
0.4732936918735504,
-0.23478420078754425,
0.05241747573018074,
-0.008367234840989113,
0.2095920741558075,
-0.19489142298698425,
-0.6318069100379944,
0.6304213404655457,
-0.5818367600440979,
-0.10119976848363876,
-0.435293048620224,
-0.655422031879425,
-0.5623652338981628,
0.14016954600811005,
0.1389055848121643,
0.9178023934364319,
-0.19000598788261414,
0.1275353580713272,
0.5792605876922607,
0.07674777507781982,
0.033396560698747635,
0.13641609251499176,
0.062446169555187225,
-0.5075887441635132,
0.8096504211425781,
0.013153488747775555,
0.22251005470752716,
0.7022616863250732,
0.364456444978714,
-0.38141846656799316,
-0.245239719748497,
-0.43318068981170654,
0.48213455080986023,
-0.667757511138916,
-0.04824947193264961,
-1.025284767150879,
-0.26902449131011963,
-0.27363643050193787,
-0.17408543825149536,
0.1288747787475586,
-0.141494020819664,
-0.1492488980293274,
-0.10100172460079193,
0.27941668033599854,
0.5463175773620605,
0.11531691253185272,
0.3099895119667053,
-1.3676109313964844,
0.17710918188095093,
0.041292954236269,
0.23771028220653534,
-0.042941864579916,
-0.006750368047505617,
-0.335115522146225,
-0.23245349526405334,
-0.1241685152053833,
-0.9056249260902405,
0.059979695826768875,
0.038517896085977554,
0.6112702488899231,
0.5357547402381897,
-0.15350471436977386,
0.7153701782226562,
-0.6786561608314514,
0.5785849690437317,
0.5481878519058228,
-0.491210013628006,
0.5048961639404297,
-0.24806822836399078,
0.06236159801483154,
0.6808812618255615,
0.4249211847782135,
-0.6929976344108582,
-0.13714580237865448,
-0.7177744507789612,
-0.7539698481559753,
0.3982139825820923,
-0.3573935627937317,
-0.1634865701198578,
-0.09175269305706024,
-0.029183512553572655,
-0.24791406095027924,
0.07705539464950562,
-0.35297641158103943,
-0.2707938551902771,
-0.18299736082553864,
-0.7684951424598694,
-0.0020305488724261522,
-0.21751803159713745,
-0.36294621229171753,
-0.01391818467527628,
0.26867127418518066,
-0.003428128780797124,
0.19518713653087616,
0.3002876043319702,
-0.2579948902130127,
-0.19930629432201385,
0.1674848198890686,
0.20292630791664124,
0.24786697328090668,
-0.3735828697681427,
0.37627431750297546,
-0.08099804073572159,
-0.5470965504646301,
-0.04977377876639366,
0.07896233350038528,
0.12789008021354675,
0.05051953345537186,
0.5638283491134644,
0.7785257697105408,
0.27945178747177124,
-0.6200276613235474,
0.5674770474433899,
0.25317367911338806,
-0.09077733010053635,
-0.18250522017478943,
-0.06725907325744629,
0.21921205520629883,
0.22893059253692627,
-0.320003867149353,
-0.01848592795431614,
0.3777218759059906,
-0.6565278768539429,
0.44089847803115845,
0.25244569778442383,
-0.6510265469551086,
-0.17781710624694824,
0.746396541595459,
0.29051682353019714,
-0.00008182206511264667,
0.6963754296302795,
0.29642659425735474,
-0.34075596928596497,
0.38126102089881897,
0.8561916351318359,
0.5516614317893982,
-0.20725032687187195,
0.137239009141922,
0.3858870565891266,
-0.21266070008277893,
-0.01565515249967575,
0.16433709859848022,
-0.1195102334022522,
-0.6882333755493164,
-0.4447843134403229,
-0.42543166875839233,
-0.4866403341293335,
-0.13063573837280273,
-0.6384238004684448,
0.3513845205307007,
-0.25270378589630127,
-0.21280595660209656,
0.10022283345460892,
-0.3207685947418213,
-0.506267249584198,
0.3345271050930023,
0.2634824216365814,
0.6915823817253113,
-0.9686063528060913,
0.6937760710716248,
0.88569575548172,
-0.6042487025260925,
-0.7690138220787048,
-0.14822104573249817,
0.5084623694419861,
-0.6407434344291687,
0.6954399347305298,
-0.00713199470192194,
-0.07064317166805267,
-0.18925893306732178,
0.06196155026555061,
-0.5245897769927979,
1.042790174484253,
-0.07493337988853455,
-0.3875308632850647,
-0.12692967057228088,
0.043524861335754395,
0.45622414350509644,
-0.34232017397880554,
0.2535341680049896,
0.4276096522808075,
0.42186886072158813,
0.4106307327747345,
-0.9370334148406982,
0.14792068302631378,
-0.21528594195842743,
-0.20885345339775085,
0.5047796964645386,
-0.6013798117637634,
0.754055917263031,
-0.29128894209861755,
-0.11574281752109528,
-0.3240959346294403,
0.5911909341812134,
0.1984064280986786,
0.5155529975891113,
0.42411115765571594,
0.6389027833938599,
0.8608595132827759,
0.1398342102766037,
1.0514602661132812,
-0.30003082752227783,
0.15784797072410583,
1.1457315683364868,
-0.7204261422157288,
0.7542011141777039,
0.4169749319553375,
-0.03282688558101654,
0.8123248219490051,
0.35136380791664124,
0.09205538779497147,
0.44488152861595154,
-0.05886974558234215,
-0.5561172366142273,
-0.08194587379693985,
-0.3876243233680725,
-0.3682866394519806,
0.5089654326438904,
0.4649679660797119,
-0.30023741722106934,
-0.29899778962135315,
0.0024567965883761644,
0.194291889667511,
-0.033065132796764374,
-0.07240813970565796,
1.0813442468643188,
0.01096541341394186,
-0.47155019640922546,
0.025347748771309853,
-0.2545611560344696,
0.20318777859210968,
-0.7254724502563477,
-0.4100865423679352,
0.10046133399009705,
0.2001095414161682,
-0.619651734828949,
-0.5733996033668518,
0.10693968832492828,
-0.5524059534072876,
-0.24567419290542603,
-0.082182876765728,
0.8701801300048828,
-0.7368556261062622,
-0.22393107414245605,
0.28803130984306335,
0.6167986989021301,
0.03445117175579071,
0.26444920897483826,
-0.5003438591957092,
-0.1422612965106964,
-0.331318736076355,
0.2241668701171875,
0.5649300813674927,
0.5212725400924683,
-0.03407398238778114,
0.5029634237289429,
0.689954400062561,
0.3566523790359497,
-0.29959815740585327,
0.2727433741092682,
0.8297640681266785,
-0.48787593841552734,
-0.7945235967636108,
-0.8438024520874023,
0.619217574596405,
-0.08325521647930145,
-0.17255736887454987,
0.5097602605819702,
0.6744011640548706,
0.6727525591850281,
0.17136581242084503,
0.7830023765563965,
-0.013344965875148773,
0.5512611865997314,
-0.6243770718574524,
0.6689945459365845,
-0.626744270324707,
-0.3438347280025482,
-0.35626479983329773,
-0.5038045048713684,
-0.5221644043922424,
0.2857235074043274,
0.11946626752614975,
-0.14682020246982574,
0.8659286499023438,
0.6489046812057495,
-0.06862740963697433,
-0.045967426151037216,
0.32625266909599304,
0.2395690530538559,
0.1803373247385025,
0.5362855195999146,
0.6409391760826111,
-0.24821880459785461,
0.2185543179512024,
-0.29717227816581726,
-0.36229148507118225,
-0.5378802418708801,
-0.7354053854942322,
-0.5455915331840515,
-0.7658836245536804,
-0.4086849093437195,
-0.7312933802604675,
-0.28021255135536194,
1.2034080028533936,
0.7250769734382629,
-0.585745096206665,
-0.17956508696079254,
0.44930142164230347,
0.021149368956685066,
-0.2656440734863281,
-0.13236233592033386,
0.7490370869636536,
-0.1962847262620926,
-0.4040272533893585,
0.23804441094398499,
0.6125744581222534,
0.184194877743721,
0.07645946741104126,
-0.00378849683329463,
-0.15765981376171112,
-0.2389150857925415,
0.7807459235191345,
0.012068566866219044,
-0.33829066157341003,
-0.08456235378980637,
-0.028445586562156677,
-0.3061658442020416,
0.4399540424346924,
0.8500385284423828,
-0.7354824542999268,
0.63652104139328,
0.6116153597831726,
0.5058022141456604,
0.5104268193244934,
0.20878826081752777,
0.09553660452365875,
-0.30709853768348694,
0.03037705272436142,
0.4057849943637848,
0.6712578535079956,
0.30077454447746277,
-0.4761244058609009,
0.0740940049290657,
0.14123030006885529,
-0.3907545804977417,
-0.5988560318946838,
0.13504824042320251,
-1.4501928091049194,
0.03503826633095741,
1.0078761577606201,
0.12867975234985352,
-0.31672224402427673,
-0.4100726544857025,
-0.14557196199893951,
0.27722999453544617,
-0.22308151423931122,
0.48353490233421326,
0.46771809458732605,
-0.7069178819656372,
0.16874928772449493,
-0.5357288718223572,
0.41200751066207886,
0.2374820113182068,
-0.9740771651268005,
-0.20971468091011047,
0.921891450881958,
0.03648075461387634,
0.33965423703193665,
0.7720549702644348,
-0.510578453540802,
0.3730897605419159,
-0.03261280059814453,
-0.012504367157816887,
-0.12066462635993958,
-0.49578776955604553,
-0.1769324094057083,
0.3172883093357086,
-0.10771677643060684,
-0.4678768217563629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12593v1 | Standardize: Aligning Language Models with Expert-Defined Standards for Content Generation | 2024-02-19T23:18:18 | 2024-02-19T23:18:18 | Joseph Marvin Imperial, Gail Forey, Harish Tayyar Madabushi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Domain experts across engineering, healthcare, and education follow strict
standards for producing quality content such as technical manuals, medication
instructions, and children's reading materials. However, current works in
controllable text generation have yet to explore using these standards as
references for control. Towards this end, we introduce Standardize, a
retrieval-style in-context learning-based framework to guide large language
models to align with expert-defined standards. Focusing on English language
standards in the education domain as a use case, we consider the Common
European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR) and Common Core Standards
(CCS) for the task of open-ended content generation. Our findings show that
models can gain 40% to 100% increase in precise accuracy for Llama2 and GPT-4,
respectively, demonstrating that the use of knowledge artifacts extracted from
standards and integrating them in the generation process can effectively guide
models to produce better standard-aligned content. | [
-0.1997089684009552,
-0.332520991563797,
0.38722771406173706,
-0.20569966733455658,
-0.1668354570865631,
-0.15658868849277496,
-0.5530630946159363,
-0.30341073870658875,
-0.40368980169296265,
0.698197603225708,
-0.21981292963027954,
-0.7180688381195068,
-0.5886437892913818,
0.07336385548114777,
-0.42687466740608215,
0.7118006944656372,
-0.5192228555679321,
-0.046678345650434494,
-0.45020154118537903,
-0.06458557397127151,
-0.43880417943000793,
-0.3301105499267578,
-0.5334163308143616,
-0.33073684573173523,
0.31770262122154236,
0.6760950684547424,
0.8690197467803955,
0.8366460204124451,
0.6790100336074829,
0.17282040417194366,
-0.12512195110321045,
0.34804514050483704,
-0.6090306639671326,
0.24093399941921234,
-0.6029747724533081,
-0.018211891874670982,
-0.6525710225105286,
-0.054025787860155106,
0.45290273427963257,
0.7532523274421692,
-0.26677924394607544,
0.11972436308860779,
0.3262966573238373,
0.4006217420101166,
-0.5607532858848572,
0.19385935366153717,
-0.5158318877220154,
-0.23528121411800385,
-0.018221227452158928,
-0.25486165285110474,
-0.45783373713493347,
-0.5141528844833374,
0.08173764497041702,
-0.6262900829315186,
0.31848129630088806,
-0.10910247266292572,
0.9945698976516724,
0.13089141249656677,
-0.6781625151634216,
-0.5531101822853088,
-0.5617627501487732,
1.0949864387512207,
-0.832144021987915,
0.6758018136024475,
0.28100094199180603,
0.38235777616500854,
-0.23838090896606445,
-0.8001766204833984,
-0.48852279782295227,
-0.030448535457253456,
-0.09477870166301727,
-0.16672028601169586,
0.0989394336938858,
0.08905564993619919,
-0.02056060917675495,
0.18591055274009705,
-0.4779903292655945,
0.273497998714447,
-0.5199621319770813,
-0.0015752854524180293,
0.8736512064933777,
-0.05269589647650719,
0.43059971928596497,
0.12114671617746353,
-0.2325080931186676,
-0.014024658128619194,
-1.0757837295532227,
-0.13995948433876038,
0.14229951798915863,
0.4140153229236603,
0.1818685531616211,
0.5025889277458191,
-0.2713531255722046,
0.6101775765419006,
0.19732806086540222,
-0.24894557893276215,
0.15612152218818665,
-0.3640395402908325,
-0.23959003388881683,
-0.004862035624682903,
0.4930797219276428,
0.6594946980476379,
0.40286949276924133,
-0.15508736670017242,
-0.48327404260635376,
-0.3074036240577698,
0.28973907232284546,
-0.8385988473892212,
-0.04405965283513069,
-0.06387121975421906,
-0.22259169816970825,
-0.26694557070732117,
-0.07252921909093857,
-0.4813280701637268,
-0.031061474233865738,
-0.7238644361495972,
0.3479335606098175,
-0.20903851091861725,
-0.18441635370254517,
0.35875204205513,
0.04813213646411896,
0.1457555890083313,
0.25676169991493225,
-1.0850763320922852,
0.34595009684562683,
0.4736471474170685,
0.42850902676582336,
-0.3456449508666992,
0.0650843009352684,
-0.1134951114654541,
0.3955535590648651,
-0.6719837784767151,
0.6931455135345459,
-0.5786923766136169,
-0.5573956966400146,
0.4265078902244568,
-0.13537423312664032,
0.2541864216327667,
-0.61102694272995,
0.634242594242096,
-0.6174778342247009,
0.17978312075138092,
-0.4296286404132843,
-0.474118709564209,
0.04855894669890404,
0.1203819066286087,
-0.4983975291252136,
0.9291398525238037,
0.13413728773593903,
-0.4097307622432709,
0.5718262195587158,
-0.39383503794670105,
-0.21715562045574188,
0.08538064360618591,
-0.40981313586235046,
-0.17537830770015717,
0.09257424622774124,
0.14141975343227386,
0.5242242217063904,
-0.40030068159103394,
0.660152792930603,
0.1858966052532196,
0.004858382046222687,
-0.2873269021511078,
-0.20457004010677338,
0.3324251174926758,
0.533707857131958,
-0.2711356282234192,
-0.05018838495016098,
-0.4265677332878113,
0.12959696352481842,
0.11926024407148361,
-0.6572600603103638,
-0.28232839703559875,
0.2843577265739441,
0.14190268516540527,
0.10974966734647751,
0.5409682989120483,
-0.4193764328956604,
0.0363738015294075,
0.05097367241978645,
0.18002639710903168,
0.5008285045623779,
0.09024626761674881,
0.6557878851890564,
-0.33439767360687256,
0.2716905474662781,
-0.00027338817017152905,
0.11388199031352997,
-0.16975831985473633,
-0.14027218520641327,
-0.5729754567146301,
0.11497681587934494,
0.3202982544898987,
0.12824563682079315,
-0.43429437279701233,
0.4687150716781616,
-0.3333209753036499,
-0.5102624297142029,
-0.47671493887901306,
0.33099523186683655,
0.4270513951778412,
0.8289527893066406,
0.6849113702774048,
-0.38442447781562805,
-0.4060184359550476,
-0.923516571521759,
-0.19509293138980865,
0.1903076171875,
-0.2122495174407959,
0.26141807436943054,
0.15668660402297974,
-0.2698347270488739,
1.0879509449005127,
-0.358215868473053,
-0.03258730471134186,
-0.14934121072292328,
0.0752563327550888,
-0.05443897098302841,
0.7411112189292908,
0.45007559657096863,
-0.8751211762428284,
-0.7868859767913818,
0.1786208301782608,
-0.7146037220954895,
-0.2986714243888855,
0.17380794882774353,
-0.2515445351600647,
0.15162360668182373,
0.5987164378166199,
-0.08697955310344696,
0.17760559916496277,
0.5271711945533752,
-0.21625569462776184,
0.36701056361198425,
-0.10145551711320877,
0.2606308162212372,
-1.1453715562820435,
0.15651732683181763,
0.14036177098751068,
-0.24865709245204926,
-0.71429443359375,
0.3989548981189728,
0.29875513911247253,
-0.10376082360744476,
-0.3861483335494995,
0.6718063354492188,
-0.49607962369918823,
0.12045060843229294,
-0.1703941524028778,
0.45133763551712036,
0.28195688128471375,
0.04594885930418968,
0.3672907054424286,
0.8954591751098633,
0.18356305360794067,
-0.4753466248512268,
0.032771069556474686,
0.3360212445259094,
-0.17602810263633728,
0.734671950340271,
-0.7870079278945923,
0.05234020575881004,
-0.006678890902549028,
0.005270424764603376,
-0.4355861246585846,
-0.30876603722572327,
-0.3409191966056824,
-0.38015124201774597,
0.5519377589225769,
0.207699716091156,
-0.658534586429596,
-0.12062377482652664,
0.17272764444351196,
0.2258802205324173,
0.728081464767456,
-0.6180301308631897,
0.26103314757347107,
0.46186649799346924,
-0.3505144715309143,
-0.6848858594894409,
-0.5304223895072937,
-0.13768109679222107,
0.28653520345687866,
-0.5626617074012756,
0.4430519640445709,
-0.402401328086853,
-0.2998635172843933,
-0.10024375468492508,
-0.3145734369754791,
-0.22069957852363586,
-0.043496765196323395,
-0.24916893243789673,
0.1458388715982437,
-0.4535963237285614,
0.21290293335914612,
0.5773857831954956,
0.2056218981742859,
-0.09512045979499817,
-0.2108755260705948,
0.27624285221099854,
0.13817471265792847,
-0.4131312966346741,
-0.250902384519577,
0.5730646848678589,
0.37164047360420227,
-0.45894402265548706,
0.43887993693351746,
0.01550382375717163,
-0.48288294672966003,
-0.2960534393787384,
-0.588883101940155,
-0.2173873335123062,
-0.5257704257965088,
0.31160271167755127,
-0.2850501239299774,
-0.8347440958023071,
0.21957296133041382,
-0.1106155663728714,
0.4946848154067993,
0.46035832166671753,
0.45117491483688354,
0.08465961366891861,
1.2956360578536987,
0.9739131927490234,
0.3706710636615753,
0.21940256655216217,
0.03859696909785271,
0.23488959670066833,
-0.639979362487793,
-0.3363838791847229,
-0.6082006096839905,
-0.26301291584968567,
-0.31417006254196167,
-0.35308268666267395,
0.06214872747659683,
0.44278115034103394,
-0.3178175091743469,
0.4404992461204529,
-0.7153228521347046,
0.6076034307479858,
0.36894023418426514,
0.08545025438070297,
0.46703392267227173,
-0.1765066236257553,
-0.3551538288593292,
-0.07813973724842072,
-0.5687588453292847,
-1.0112444162368774,
1.2141387462615967,
0.4048149883747101,
0.6344357132911682,
0.15295663475990295,
0.9058008193969727,
0.032528091222047806,
0.4791993796825409,
-0.5183665156364441,
0.39990532398223877,
-0.3751676380634308,
-0.742988646030426,
-0.3084459602832794,
-0.10861972719430923,
-0.6841787099838257,
-0.1946440041065216,
-0.08583318442106247,
-0.3709505498409271,
0.40734994411468506,
0.05103641375899315,
-0.09749175608158112,
0.225447416305542,
-0.5548620820045471,
0.7232028245925903,
0.188323974609375,
-0.14848369359970093,
-0.233358696103096,
-0.28428471088409424,
0.16827723383903503,
-0.3561057448387146,
0.32789182662963867,
0.053808026015758514,
-0.30242565274238586,
0.6595122218132019,
-0.16220404207706451,
0.7523230910301208,
0.05280959606170654,
-0.2804681360721588,
0.5238436460494995,
0.1771562695503235,
0.3880397379398346,
-0.1665290743112564,
-0.170113667845726,
0.013276762329041958,
-0.05091407522559166,
-0.5547947883605957,
-0.32363924384117126,
0.7738028764724731,
-0.9321609139442444,
-0.646283745765686,
0.11418262124061584,
-0.5182351469993591,
-0.015417465940117836,
0.4402449429035187,
0.30247795581817627,
0.3894156813621521,
-0.3563453257083893,
0.31712374091148376,
1.2280938625335693,
0.07669783383607864,
0.31748074293136597,
0.8656763434410095,
0.1827649474143982,
-0.25963088870048523,
0.7677069902420044,
0.4832659363746643,
0.5031741857528687,
0.31281793117523193,
-0.06424440443515778,
-0.07056631147861481,
-0.6414250731468201,
-0.2304317206144333,
0.1515311598777771,
-0.9444664716720581,
-0.30933448672294617,
-0.46113428473472595,
-0.3644072115421295,
-0.7733854055404663,
-0.6776906251907349,
-0.304698646068573,
-0.17951884865760803,
-0.573584794998169,
-0.2511211633682251,
-0.03742888942360878,
1.0566017627716064,
-0.03224238380789757,
0.3897787928581238,
-0.73993980884552,
-0.1608845591545105,
0.3879958391189575,
0.2843518555164337,
-0.3319864869117737,
-0.6463771462440491,
-0.49480530619621277,
-0.2573436498641968,
-0.62733393907547,
-1.0377483367919922,
0.22025924921035767,
0.3063350021839142,
0.8466510772705078,
0.3663645386695862,
0.10283109545707703,
0.17137186229228973,
-0.6958828568458557,
1.006542444229126,
0.10549318790435791,
-1.036454439163208,
0.614010751247406,
-0.36992624402046204,
0.2318693995475769,
0.4799019396305084,
0.681574285030365,
-0.7054165601730347,
-0.36334407329559326,
-0.7192786931991577,
-0.8420853018760681,
0.11323177069425583,
-0.27299126982688904,
0.39084750413894653,
-0.2325504869222641,
0.327775776386261,
0.25772443413734436,
0.3059813380241394,
-0.4156442880630493,
0.18426774442195892,
-0.05838616564869881,
-0.7949666976928711,
-0.1305873692035675,
-0.2977382242679596,
-0.31289637088775635,
0.20779193937778473,
0.5887179970741272,
-0.2900080680847168,
-0.08845232427120209,
0.16920143365859985,
-0.1483616679906845,
-0.4072599709033966,
0.39993858337402344,
0.5360907912254333,
1.0588271617889404,
0.13068202137947083,
-0.017789803445339203,
0.005994895473122597,
-0.4093984365463257,
-0.055581215769052505,
0.05069510266184807,
-0.30141228437423706,
0.08295183628797531,
0.20018193125724792,
0.1967868208885193,
0.4741824269294739,
-0.6833856105804443,
0.6606159210205078,
0.16275539994239807,
-0.4650478959083557,
-0.11462991684675217,
0.4208187758922577,
-0.05272769182920456,
0.1644613891839981,
0.31824594736099243,
-0.11821547895669937,
-0.12166356295347214,
-0.16027408838272095,
0.6203580498695374,
0.22072280943393707,
-0.5318804979324341,
-0.3537534475326538,
0.8218858242034912,
0.5713291764259338,
-0.1786106377840042,
0.47502851486206055,
-0.05697125568985939,
-0.032881878316402435,
0.5498369336128235,
0.5965899229049683,
0.6039997935295105,
-0.42450380325317383,
0.0952894315123558,
0.6409908533096313,
0.17328278720378876,
-0.45226189494132996,
0.40867379307746887,
-0.02593083865940571,
-0.8082825541496277,
-0.4628950357437134,
-0.5753716230392456,
-0.5254241824150085,
-0.11454841494560242,
-0.7886745929718018,
0.6588605046272278,
-0.5589533448219299,
-0.026921620592474937,
-0.3196347653865814,
0.05130938068032265,
-0.8394291400909424,
0.47297194600105286,
0.18309801816940308,
1.2824209928512573,
-0.9653062224388123,
0.9131556153297424,
0.6108752489089966,
-0.6088641881942749,
-1.0452468395233154,
-0.19764509797096252,
-0.13875828683376312,
-0.48629897832870483,
0.6135433316230774,
-0.15873214602470398,
0.3012698292732239,
0.28590333461761475,
-0.7931514382362366,
-1.040665864944458,
1.4127428531646729,
0.034640613943338394,
-0.7505098581314087,
-0.3980542719364166,
-0.09177395701408386,
0.5476837754249573,
-0.7175852060317993,
0.1474059671163559,
0.6096622347831726,
0.3477921485900879,
0.1796196848154068,
-0.9392329454421997,
0.08979278057813644,
-0.0851282998919487,
-0.03761029243469238,
0.18557772040367126,
-0.4341622591018677,
0.8071771264076233,
-0.19498825073242188,
-0.2608864903450012,
-0.1165061891078949,
0.8783640265464783,
0.3624070882797241,
0.08068519085645676,
0.11290963739156723,
0.4696057438850403,
0.7696587443351746,
0.07160782068967819,
0.42026594281196594,
-0.579054594039917,
0.14714732766151428,
1.1017327308654785,
-0.0645192414522171,
1.1844772100448608,
0.4723932147026062,
0.204301655292511,
0.5952060222625732,
0.717952311038971,
0.10709483921527863,
0.4984518587589264,
-0.11307748407125473,
-0.31585535407066345,
-0.0811331644654274,
-0.23121929168701172,
-0.4543871283531189,
-0.08082102984189987,
0.47449856996536255,
-0.698273241519928,
-0.3130224943161011,
-0.13241881132125854,
0.3791230320930481,
0.5893493294715881,
-0.33629509806632996,
0.7468293905258179,
-0.027601324021816254,
-0.7543296813964844,
0.6510040760040283,
-0.000573215598706156,
0.4087701141834259,
-0.3755119740962982,
-0.018765168264508247,
-0.23965699970722198,
-0.08782841265201569,
-0.20138715207576752,
-0.7869532704353333,
0.20696379244327545,
0.12992191314697266,
-0.22743727266788483,
-0.4106343686580658,
0.4872724115848541,
-0.8203471302986145,
-0.26493021845817566,
0.06943966448307037,
0.32571667432785034,
0.028899800032377243,
0.3791811764240265,
-0.35724231600761414,
-0.18066845834255219,
-0.01400852669030428,
-0.3170277774333954,
0.3547319173812866,
0.4413687288761139,
-0.11124535650014877,
0.3595128059387207,
0.33879244327545166,
0.10810843110084534,
0.10124227404594421,
-0.06257372349500656,
0.9082543253898621,
-0.18446317315101624,
-0.15895764529705048,
-0.17778699100017548,
0.8345698714256287,
-0.09281233698129654,
-0.3895966410636902,
0.28766927123069763,
0.5190184116363525,
1.223625659942627,
0.13299988210201263,
0.8571590781211853,
-0.09196984022855759,
0.4238094687461853,
-0.3479703664779663,
0.7327024936676025,
-0.6753683090209961,
0.10722749680280685,
0.2054091840982437,
-0.889430046081543,
-0.34450405836105347,
0.1690523624420166,
-0.4065570533275604,
-0.07562475651502609,
0.7275657653808594,
0.8012675642967224,
-0.07066120952367783,
-0.21028470993041992,
0.4228084981441498,
-0.0006931321113370359,
0.5762900114059448,
0.19562417268753052,
0.19113753736019135,
-0.3110073208808899,
0.5405015349388123,
-0.0634855404496193,
-0.5715640783309937,
-0.19372661411762238,
-0.8062020540237427,
-0.8085665106773376,
-0.6003478765487671,
-0.3227696418762207,
-0.10336855053901672,
0.18362614512443542,
0.9623731970787048,
0.6957568526268005,
-0.7641782760620117,
-0.2547451853752136,
-0.03481888025999069,
-0.12451085448265076,
-0.12909546494483948,
-0.15087708830833435,
0.23279784619808197,
-0.9098250865936279,
-0.9536376595497131,
0.43809905648231506,
-0.15000374615192413,
0.1753794252872467,
-0.46000927686691284,
-0.18726786971092224,
0.1327810287475586,
0.5655003190040588,
0.3318260610103607,
0.28636670112609863,
-0.5725252628326416,
-0.42293959856033325,
0.219236820936203,
-0.6608746647834778,
0.06098088249564171,
0.7059342861175537,
-0.42629387974739075,
0.5603206157684326,
0.5860298275947571,
0.39330923557281494,
-0.04655243828892708,
-0.05183667689561844,
0.8788066506385803,
-0.7989266514778137,
-0.1620551198720932,
0.37471288442611694,
0.2055838406085968,
0.4111734926700592,
-0.48794329166412354,
0.3648596405982971,
-0.11069948971271515,
-1.060768961906433,
-0.6363828182220459,
0.4570164680480957,
-0.4831869900226593,
-0.21904131770133972,
1.014983892440796,
-0.13806010782718658,
-0.25173547863960266,
0.060369886457920074,
-0.06013611704111099,
0.32324478030204773,
-0.4538656771183014,
0.5960506200790405,
0.5118262767791748,
0.17490705847740173,
-0.13508357107639313,
-0.7655311822891235,
0.7095838189125061,
0.10372684895992279,
-0.4620653986930847,
0.03997990861535072,
0.29637181758880615,
0.3261772394180298,
0.18848635256290436,
0.45160403847694397,
-0.2803548574447632,
0.21286870539188385,
-0.17047977447509766,
0.49414679408073425,
0.1169748306274414,
-0.36930757761001587,
-0.04617830738425255,
0.01979176141321659,
0.32966020703315735,
0.22261206805706024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12590v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12590v2 | Evolving AI Collectives to Enhance Human Diversity and Enable Self-Regulation | 2024-02-19T22:59:43 | 2024-06-18T23:28:46 | Shiyang Lai, Yujin Potter, Junsol Kim, Richard Zhuang, Dawn Song, James Evans | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Large language model behavior is shaped by the language of those with whom
they interact. This capacity and their increasing prevalence online portend
that they will intentionally or unintentionally "program" one another and form
emergent AI subjectivities, relationships, and collectives. Here, we call upon
the research community to investigate these "societies" of interacting
artificial intelligences to increase their rewards and reduce their risks for
human society and the health of online environments. We use a small "community"
of models and their evolving outputs to illustrate how such emergent,
decentralized AI collectives can spontaneously expand the bounds of human
diversity and reduce the risk of toxic, anti-social behavior online. Finally,
we discuss opportunities for AI cross-moderation and address ethical issues and
design challenges associated with creating and maintaining free-formed AI
collectives. | [
-0.33860230445861816,
-0.4143356382846832,
0.22460325062274933,
0.027355356141924858,
0.1710224151611328,
0.4396534562110901,
-0.15387381613254547,
-1.0333367586135864,
0.37081414461135864,
0.46316131949424744,
-0.5222557783126831,
0.14383791387081146,
-0.5545671582221985,
0.08165005594491959,
-0.3990204334259033,
1.1506787538528442,
0.4415537118911743,
-0.06342664361000061,
-0.2771250605583191,
-0.3227405548095703,
-0.3069606125354767,
-0.5685262084007263,
-0.6568342447280884,
-0.17570894956588745,
0.6906344890594482,
0.32450127601623535,
0.6735279560089111,
0.6255341172218323,
0.5759496092796326,
0.42320457100868225,
0.07057744264602661,
0.12977679073810577,
-0.7256308197975159,
0.26445263624191284,
-0.1831303983926773,
-0.4296681880950928,
-0.16171078383922577,
0.1985815316438675,
0.27328458428382874,
0.6424901485443115,
-0.18513965606689453,
0.227216899394989,
0.09832347929477692,
0.4958125650882721,
-0.5133581757545471,
-0.04788736253976822,
-0.4142824709415436,
-0.07949527353048325,
-0.06424371153116226,
0.1581508219242096,
-0.132643461227417,
-0.43604546785354614,
0.10761003196239471,
-0.4917175769805908,
-0.20728415250778198,
0.07949879765510559,
0.3409579396247864,
0.2966878414154053,
-0.24475179612636566,
-0.07788021117448807,
-1.1013537645339966,
0.5992497801780701,
-0.23337478935718536,
0.26342231035232544,
0.34832796454429626,
0.23628729581832886,
-0.13277927041053772,
-0.7465500831604004,
-0.3902113139629364,
-0.13426807522773743,
-0.0027573932893574238,
0.017096547409892082,
-0.5174045562744141,
-0.022344980388879776,
-0.3209088444709778,
0.3394550085067749,
-0.30384793877601624,
0.3000134229660034,
-0.8888267874717712,
-0.11268613487482071,
0.9184327125549316,
0.22708012163639069,
0.9049747586250305,
0.3417840003967285,
0.08870575577020645,
0.01226101815700531,
-0.616338312625885,
0.13684473931789398,
0.4243925213813782,
0.29513925313949585,
-0.20074892044067383,
0.3425957262516022,
-0.021900270134210587,
0.1514216512441635,
0.11073511838912964,
0.4998989701271057,
0.1720062494277954,
-0.5399095416069031,
-0.05698133260011673,
-0.046116869896650314,
0.7584984302520752,
0.1718452274799347,
0.23350808024406433,
-0.20194466412067413,
-0.036493413150310516,
0.09562449157238007,
0.49824288487434387,
-0.4493318200111389,
-0.45967674255371094,
0.11438857764005661,
-0.8313847184181213,
-0.5516713857650757,
0.2978258430957794,
-0.6560466289520264,
-0.6506688594818115,
-0.10611507296562195,
0.3451709449291229,
0.09427827596664429,
-0.5843944549560547,
-0.2411475032567978,
-0.45922693610191345,
0.1126500591635704,
0.23486074805259705,
-0.9116832613945007,
0.517081618309021,
0.6079766750335693,
0.738925576210022,
-0.06823067367076874,
-0.370611310005188,
-0.33168691396713257,
0.1688777208328247,
-0.2807534635066986,
0.536944568157196,
-0.4645199477672577,
-0.6159247159957886,
-0.21508841216564178,
-0.25028935074806213,
0.3450886011123657,
-0.6156229972839355,
-0.07007208466529846,
-0.42915043234825134,
0.4100380539894104,
-0.16270197927951813,
-0.2931615114212036,
0.013785279355943203,
0.239274799823761,
-0.7017456889152527,
0.5603721141815186,
0.2527323067188263,
-0.35668981075286865,
0.12702687084674835,
-1.1941649913787842,
-0.5100235939025879,
0.44717180728912354,
-0.27357199788093567,
-0.1275574117898941,
0.054052047431468964,
0.0578233040869236,
0.050227150321006775,
-0.1383460909128189,
0.0009419989073649049,
-0.45489415526390076,
-0.11759352684020996,
0.28956130146980286,
-0.29982680082321167,
1.2478454113006592,
0.3756689131259918,
-0.3981662094593048,
0.6636764407157898,
-0.1467656046152115,
-0.09026338905096054,
-0.0008750471170060337,
-0.27253586053848267,
-0.6186864376068115,
0.22973766922950745,
-0.21166324615478516,
0.31639543175697327,
0.1273677796125412,
-0.31260576844215393,
0.21768537163734436,
-0.2758236229419708,
0.9725068211555481,
1.0430434942245483,
0.16383212804794312,
0.5415228009223938,
-0.9522970914840698,
0.5046585202217102,
-0.1430085450410843,
0.8040863871574402,
0.1639719307422638,
-0.6882124543190002,
-0.7661197781562805,
-0.2685723900794983,
0.006989781744778156,
0.4130222201347351,
-0.5167093873023987,
0.7417664527893066,
-0.10368487238883972,
-0.7443569898605347,
-0.7786155343055725,
0.1767653226852417,
0.003568014595657587,
-0.19457203149795532,
0.3484404385089874,
-0.3114423453807831,
-0.29987406730651855,
-0.6895661354064941,
-0.20352695882320404,
-0.32944074273109436,
-0.24409255385398865,
0.34688031673431396,
0.33655136823654175,
-0.6462075114250183,
1.0020523071289062,
-0.01298013236373663,
-0.19650262594223022,
-0.4264829158782959,
0.29449373483657837,
-0.3825702965259552,
0.6719675064086914,
0.539677083492279,
-0.7874501943588257,
-0.3258254826068878,
-0.05291811004281044,
-0.5675440430641174,
0.05113569647073746,
-0.06650247424840927,
-0.1438102275133133,
-0.2388812154531479,
0.5588660836219788,
-0.40524354577064514,
0.10441713780164719,
0.578467071056366,
-0.38204407691955566,
0.1363072544336319,
-0.17800496518611908,
0.22414399683475494,
-1.1122450828552246,
-0.12797169387340546,
-0.3236141502857208,
-0.09453139454126358,
-0.8057382702827454,
0.3066923916339874,
-0.531653106212616,
-0.052234943956136703,
-0.31762662529945374,
0.6361858248710632,
-0.41873106360435486,
0.011729508638381958,
-0.31299418210983276,
0.09552445262670517,
-0.3582834303379059,
-0.08166899532079697,
-0.3131779432296753,
0.5247980356216431,
0.6274402737617493,
-0.7846147418022156,
0.36833226680755615,
0.25446027517318726,
-0.33101409673690796,
0.08818540722131729,
-0.5839858055114746,
0.0791524350643158,
-0.21939097344875336,
0.38914480805397034,
-0.5595734119415283,
-0.3559228479862213,
0.356591135263443,
-0.41799288988113403,
-0.2510007917881012,
0.37880900502204895,
-0.1997552216053009,
-0.43256571888923645,
-0.27952396869659424,
0.9271440505981445,
0.6894598007202148,
-0.4839254319667816,
0.5773013830184937,
0.9817412495613098,
-0.21184168756008148,
-0.2685491442680359,
-0.8643448352813721,
0.24670661985874176,
-0.3474220931529999,
-0.595678985118866,
-0.11756455898284912,
-0.4179533123970032,
-0.9061703085899353,
0.09005182981491089,
0.45290449261665344,
0.08557763695716858,
0.5107309222221375,
0.323575884103775,
0.06757628917694092,
0.00987344142049551,
0.24413970112800598,
0.011870639398694038,
0.13845619559288025,
0.08060435950756073,
-0.3282908499240875,
0.6707329750061035,
-0.27522337436676025,
-0.2632767856121063,
-0.5377191305160522,
0.606268584728241,
0.6259398460388184,
-0.4410375654697418,
0.8059049248695374,
0.25945979356765747,
-0.4290787875652313,
-0.16587629914283752,
-0.25669556856155396,
-0.42081257700920105,
-0.5850134491920471,
0.28997358679771423,
0.19669869542121887,
-1.383316159248352,
0.5771567821502686,
0.023328937590122223,
0.2478860765695572,
0.6039648652076721,
0.8404459357261658,
0.007472080644220114,
0.9190575480461121,
0.8527157306671143,
-0.25903624296188354,
0.6430363655090332,
0.1258048117160797,
0.18423938751220703,
-0.3535286486148834,
-0.1740400344133377,
-0.5231420397758484,
-0.5477033257484436,
-0.9527010321617126,
-0.4676192104816437,
0.4992070496082306,
-0.2485131323337555,
-0.3965872824192047,
-0.019925447180867195,
-0.789905846118927,
0.7382103800773621,
0.682174026966095,
0.19569753110408783,
0.10638032853603363,
-0.44169753789901733,
0.4717051386833191,
0.30426618456840515,
-0.6915982365608215,
-0.18338319659233093,
0.8900015950202942,
0.26130518317222595,
0.8404132127761841,
0.48422205448150635,
0.8118481040000916,
0.9393479824066162,
0.6979338526725769,
-0.4403739273548126,
0.27199122309684753,
-0.09852822870016098,
-0.8011196851730347,
-0.42911282181739807,
-0.5381253361701965,
-1.2502058744430542,
-0.13683751225471497,
-0.3701782524585724,
-0.7599297761917114,
0.3276725709438324,
0.05798367038369179,
-0.6078704595565796,
0.3284790515899658,
-0.24219083786010742,
0.5529482960700989,
-0.514656126499176,
-0.12295086681842804,
-0.6732713580131531,
-0.8091096878051758,
0.4466104805469513,
-0.08573555201292038,
0.5323019027709961,
-0.05015116557478905,
0.1527201384305954,
0.5163751244544983,
-0.11494215577840805,
1.1058447360992432,
0.3085581064224243,
0.05295270308852196,
0.6023930311203003,
0.13532443344593048,
0.11470042169094086,
0.038383711129426956,
-0.10767625272274017,
0.28886643052101135,
-0.26483872532844543,
-0.3838905096054077,
-0.31329095363616943,
0.548963189125061,
-1.3568941354751587,
-0.8204494714736938,
-0.1954844892024994,
-0.38345831632614136,
0.2033901959657669,
0.29114019870758057,
0.06532999873161316,
0.07135292142629623,
-0.43790748715400696,
0.32565343379974365,
0.39607080817222595,
-0.07832076400518417,
0.4211980998516083,
0.15346145629882812,
-0.21304059028625488,
-0.44966089725494385,
0.9372127056121826,
-0.12520770728588104,
0.4984276294708252,
0.013937342911958694,
0.49829813838005066,
-0.09556104987859726,
-0.32851144671440125,
-0.1665726602077484,
-0.1689450442790985,
-0.5266467928886414,
-0.11956282705068588,
-0.43206608295440674,
-0.23632201552391052,
-0.9317173957824707,
-0.2992435693740845,
-0.11489852517843246,
-0.35940301418304443,
-0.48041588068008423,
-0.05277526006102562,
0.33426085114479065,
1.3477824926376343,
-0.5376421809196472,
0.2734743356704712,
-1.1402778625488281,
-0.08126500248908997,
0.6499236822128296,
0.3197212517261505,
-0.0567031092941761,
-0.18885914981365204,
-0.04699863865971565,
0.13928896188735962,
-0.011681918986141682,
-0.8605501651763916,
0.2488163709640503,
0.28717267513275146,
0.7925761342048645,
0.7112897038459778,
0.3605945110321045,
0.3020995557308197,
-0.22805753350257874,
0.806205689907074,
0.13987500965595245,
-0.9376847743988037,
0.37354469299316406,
-0.45300260186195374,
0.014085130766034126,
0.6578725576400757,
0.25632473826408386,
-0.9500872492790222,
-0.7302407026290894,
-0.6364844441413879,
-0.7071152925491333,
0.4567665755748749,
0.3223420977592468,
0.6576459407806396,
-0.0770251527428627,
0.465541273355484,
0.01964350789785385,
0.11358866095542908,
-1.0297770500183105,
-0.1655617654323578,
-0.3418497145175934,
-0.2129269540309906,
0.18170616030693054,
0.2118130922317505,
-0.5706748962402344,
-0.24145136773586273,
0.4766600728034973,
-0.047457803040742874,
0.11082861572504044,
-0.05519169941544533,
0.2892109453678131,
-0.4257640242576599,
0.12613099813461304,
0.5675933361053467,
0.24742771685123444,
0.49864184856414795,
0.17406150698661804,
-0.13394851982593536,
-0.14233292639255524,
0.16533693671226501,
-0.23164480924606323,
-0.1560031622648239,
-0.8217225670814514,
0.20929458737373352,
0.5283500552177429,
-0.2115750014781952,
-0.872888445854187,
0.23788060247898102,
-0.4347505271434784,
-0.1410425901412964,
-0.26777154207229614,
0.6285091042518616,
0.04574687033891678,
0.5387988090515137,
0.2551489472389221,
0.26363199949264526,
0.1608322113752365,
-0.9762427806854248,
0.34021931886672974,
0.45271551609039307,
-0.32441461086273193,
-0.15322425961494446,
0.6374397277832031,
0.6710095405578613,
-0.8175719380378723,
0.77394700050354,
-0.34666237235069275,
-0.48114338517189026,
0.828181266784668,
0.4326203763484955,
0.8622896671295166,
-0.27215784788131714,
0.15055538713932037,
0.1335153579711914,
0.614067018032074,
-0.03182799741625786,
-0.19159875810146332,
0.05944106727838516,
-1.0355268716812134,
0.05607342720031738,
-0.3729199767112732,
-0.44587424397468567,
-0.04036742076277733,
-0.21719492971897125,
0.08463649451732635,
-0.6041068434715271,
-0.09426616132259369,
-0.1231456845998764,
-0.3089038133621216,
-0.2201949506998062,
-0.026636997237801552,
0.2614070475101471,
0.41863763332366943,
-0.7935044765472412,
0.6123534440994263,
0.6821507215499878,
-0.554920494556427,
-0.5415784120559692,
0.15617436170578003,
-0.012765591964125633,
-0.7053247690200806,
0.2432708591222763,
0.22806888818740845,
-0.08681279420852661,
0.1087116226553917,
-0.7678616046905518,
-1.069146752357483,
0.9591844081878662,
-0.08349334448575974,
-0.3412441313266754,
0.049696214497089386,
0.10209261626005173,
0.7798751592636108,
-0.47357165813446045,
0.03484586626291275,
0.27855682373046875,
0.644507884979248,
-0.24888665974140167,
-0.820933997631073,
-0.009792299941182137,
-0.4830845296382904,
-0.34171685576438904,
0.12350349128246307,
-0.9968346953392029,
0.991736888885498,
-0.32002320885658264,
-0.15981267392635345,
0.1766768991947174,
0.8089898824691772,
-0.027843264862895012,
0.04298236966133118,
0.7694313526153564,
0.06791327893733978,
0.903796911239624,
0.24832288920879364,
0.809169352054596,
-0.23920027911663055,
0.09296610951423645,
0.9460945725440979,
-0.303308367729187,
0.49184221029281616,
0.1832307130098343,
-0.016072051599621773,
0.6252070069313049,
0.7578033208847046,
-0.349222868680954,
0.26571792364120483,
0.32028627395629883,
-0.5237748026847839,
-0.4348534643650055,
-0.3777645528316498,
-0.12032631784677505,
0.8512365221977234,
0.3971894085407257,
-0.3049846589565277,
0.06533575803041458,
0.08617331832647324,
-0.36406081914901733,
0.23678706586360931,
-0.4345930814743042,
0.9264950156211853,
-0.18525584042072296,
-0.7178628444671631,
-0.28270724415779114,
-0.09397523105144501,
0.7626474499702454,
-0.2630934715270996,
0.130014106631279,
-0.13946311175823212,
0.10428863018751144,
-0.1153460144996643,
-0.4785231649875641,
0.30337467789649963,
-0.3231966197490692,
-0.019360389560461044,
-0.16762417554855347,
0.6236986517906189,
-0.4236440360546112,
-0.4720373749732971,
0.5577004551887512,
0.8171618580818176,
0.12295932322740555,
0.27250856161117554,
-0.7244841456413269,
-0.15530270338058472,
-0.22381563484668732,
0.15959838032722473,
0.41550421714782715,
0.20662850141525269,
-0.2861067056655884,
0.8463468551635742,
0.7625618577003479,
0.02297266572713852,
0.1708962619304657,
-0.03854294493794441,
1.0155552625656128,
-0.2865201532840729,
-0.7505033016204834,
-0.8695937991142273,
0.3206387460231781,
-0.14950381219387054,
-0.4449368417263031,
0.35413703322410583,
0.1550522893667221,
0.7851436138153076,
0.31967893242836,
1.119948387145996,
-0.4144752621650696,
0.033109426498413086,
0.08322195708751678,
1.3397622108459473,
-0.6985009908676147,
-0.10066109895706177,
0.14539304375648499,
-0.39639806747436523,
-0.44082629680633545,
0.44237515330314636,
0.04060783609747887,
0.27371010184288025,
-0.027705218642950058,
0.48845046758651733,
0.23724816739559174,
0.08511318266391754,
0.3109223544597626,
0.33079993724823,
0.6197940111160278,
0.07788152247667313,
1.0380061864852905,
0.21255511045455933,
0.5140858292579651,
-0.12728725373744965,
-0.35999608039855957,
-0.13176637887954712,
-0.5372848510742188,
-0.7185693979263306,
-0.3648242950439453,
-0.24957069754600525,
-0.20710614323616028,
-0.04906916618347168,
1.312731385231018,
0.6570944786071777,
-0.8954682350158691,
-0.373527854681015,
-0.20163123309612274,
0.2522207200527191,
-0.22970344126224518,
-0.24961011111736298,
-0.29011020064353943,
-0.23490948975086212,
-0.6768860220909119,
0.47364720702171326,
0.24862590432167053,
0.14320141077041626,
-0.7061746120452881,
-0.3109948933124542,
-0.17233280837535858,
0.26810571551322937,
0.44325539469718933,
0.7117637991905212,
-0.44990968704223633,
-0.5330404043197632,
0.022128943353891373,
-0.2645517885684967,
-0.015209113247692585,
0.9542537927627563,
-0.3984701931476593,
0.3963474631309509,
0.4625815451145172,
0.8048578500747681,
-0.25858670473098755,
0.04232095927000046,
0.7755393385887146,
-0.5068702697753906,
-0.09270401298999786,
0.58107590675354,
0.1448352336883545,
0.016659069806337357,
-0.5388475060462952,
0.4550560712814331,
0.27619507908821106,
-0.9575060606002808,
-0.6250187158584595,
0.3265339732170105,
-0.5874605178833008,
-0.5927823185920715,
0.7806340456008911,
0.03609450161457062,
-0.04147166758775711,
-0.35541069507598877,
0.012794524431228638,
0.4863611161708832,
-0.48908641934394836,
1.5437960624694824,
0.4019671380519867,
-0.6822784543037415,
-0.1712978184223175,
-0.12074147909879684,
0.5657726526260376,
0.2800402343273163,
-1.446999192237854,
0.18425868451595306,
0.5832284688949585,
0.11680608242750168,
0.39917150139808655,
0.7506085634231567,
0.15386858582496643,
0.3160475194454193,
-0.20869390666484833,
0.08184725046157837,
0.2917550504207611,
-0.35607534646987915,
-0.39252904057502747,
0.0833459198474884,
0.10989976674318314,
0.09755805879831314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15525v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15525v1 | Detecting misinformation through Framing Theory: the Frame Element-based Model | 2024-02-19T21:50:42 | 2024-02-19T21:50:42 | Guan Wang, Rebecca Frederick, Jinglong Duan, William Wong, Verica Rupar, Weihua Li, Quan Bai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | In this paper, we delve into the rapidly evolving challenge of misinformation
detection, with a specific focus on the nuanced manipulation of narrative
frames - an under-explored area within the AI community. The potential for
Generative AI models to generate misleading narratives underscores the urgency
of this problem. Drawing from communication and framing theories, we posit that
the presentation or 'framing' of accurate information can dramatically alter
its interpretation, potentially leading to misinformation. We highlight this
issue through real-world examples, demonstrating how shifts in narrative frames
can transmute fact-based information into misinformation. To tackle this
challenge, we propose an innovative approach leveraging the power of
pre-trained Large Language Models and deep neural networks to detect
misinformation originating from accurate facts portrayed under different
frames. These advanced AI techniques offer unprecedented capabilities in
identifying complex patterns within unstructured data critical for examining
the subtleties of narrative frames. The objective of this paper is to bridge a
significant research gap in the AI domain, providing valuable insights and
methodologies for tackling framing-induced misinformation, thus contributing to
the advancement of responsible and trustworthy AI technologies. Several
experiments are intensively conducted and experimental results explicitly
demonstrate the various impact of elements of framing theory proving the
rationale of applying framing theory to increase the performance in
misinformation detection. | [
-0.4644923210144043,
-1.1229475736618042,
0.6833338737487793,
-0.1492830365896225,
-0.01792886108160019,
0.1313251107931137,
0.19372639060020447,
-0.7541647553443909,
0.08375942707061768,
0.2655990719795227,
-0.5354005694389343,
-0.16909776628017426,
-0.9067009091377258,
-0.20835810899734497,
-0.5543365478515625,
0.7959786057472229,
0.07878611981868744,
0.1646755486726761,
0.04756065085530281,
-0.04983479157090187,
-0.7874912619590759,
-0.41194725036621094,
-0.32269471883773804,
-0.48749038577079773,
0.16846229135990143,
0.24199946224689484,
0.913834273815155,
0.7583139538764954,
0.28696227073669434,
0.1767253279685974,
-0.053164344280958176,
0.26908180117607117,
-0.32241517305374146,
0.05106808990240097,
-0.060160841792821884,
-0.8647412061691284,
-0.17279963195323944,
0.2762715518474579,
0.6585517525672913,
0.45207929611206055,
0.06811109185218811,
0.19612310826778412,
0.013668486848473549,
0.43514367938041687,
-0.7229321002960205,
0.36987513303756714,
-0.4943780303001404,
0.32498204708099365,
-0.48928213119506836,
-0.3465818166732788,
-0.6227806806564331,
-0.13853617012500763,
-0.04819272458553314,
-0.5712701082229614,
0.40382909774780273,
0.5305973887443542,
0.894493579864502,
0.31799429655075073,
-0.3053807020187378,
-0.3186235725879669,
-0.8818590044975281,
0.3143095374107361,
-0.8261550068855286,
0.1922103315591812,
0.47730910778045654,
0.056333065032958984,
0.04654316604137421,
-0.4915924072265625,
-0.732613742351532,
-0.08790995180606842,
-0.28834328055381775,
-0.11217725276947021,
-0.5200818181037903,
-0.13184064626693726,
0.5808794498443604,
0.10486086457967758,
-0.7470784187316895,
0.06927075237035751,
-0.3555017113685608,
-0.341787189245224,
0.6027632355690002,
0.05408617481589317,
0.6388355493545532,
-0.260227769613266,
-0.43469294905662537,
-0.1671006679534912,
-0.7898948192596436,
-0.18911249935626984,
0.2779539227485657,
0.11503210663795471,
-0.18041476607322693,
0.49706214666366577,
-0.0229052547365427,
0.3683163523674011,
0.484912633895874,
0.14669263362884521,
0.2128569781780243,
-0.29333069920539856,
-0.27346065640449524,
0.6227931380271912,
0.43605801463127136,
0.5522202849388123,
0.19582460820674896,
0.015804920345544815,
-0.2826806604862213,
0.46116405725479126,
0.38916832208633423,
-0.6677560806274414,
-0.0010362891480326653,
-0.3325340449810028,
-0.6289851069450378,
-0.4430201053619385,
0.2649349868297577,
-0.8601433634757996,
-0.5880185961723328,
-0.20794066786766052,
0.39908668398857117,
-0.5330931544303894,
-0.36692488193511963,
-0.038714487105607986,
-0.3183138966560364,
0.2714724838733673,
0.20408697426319122,
-0.5082067847251892,
-0.2571226954460144,
0.674026608467102,
0.7087312340736389,
0.09580612927675247,
-0.20505057275295258,
-0.5249696373939514,
0.21464316546916962,
-0.6146502494812012,
0.7992683053016663,
-0.7273402810096741,
0.01190548948943615,
0.03021816909313202,
-0.22577343881130219,
-0.08553557097911835,
-0.356630802154541,
0.24279722571372986,
-0.7059500217437744,
0.4367158114910126,
0.06132983788847923,
-0.7229681015014648,
-0.44675612449645996,
0.5286999940872192,
-0.8923747539520264,
0.6416699886322021,
-0.10889148712158203,
-0.8245632648468018,
0.23440112173557281,
-0.7025701403617859,
-0.4071996212005615,
0.02163737453520298,
-0.23081502318382263,
-0.4584299921989441,
0.3340669274330139,
0.42918363213539124,
0.25223398208618164,
-0.17314386367797852,
0.7528548240661621,
-0.23173484206199646,
-0.4581765830516815,
0.4536505341529846,
-1.181428074836731,
0.3903786242008209,
0.2904590964317322,
-0.7380614876747131,
-0.04844512790441513,
-0.4258032441139221,
-0.17869481444358826,
0.07758232206106186,
-0.012277798727154732,
-0.2554367184638977,
-0.1990421563386917,
-0.12808218598365784,
-0.13363385200500488,
-0.12330012023448944,
-0.2581368088722229,
-0.10808131098747253,
-0.3772773742675781,
0.2225552648305893,
0.46386754512786865,
-0.01679491251707077,
0.535033106803894,
-0.5419396162033081,
0.39775195717811584,
0.3166022300720215,
0.07674901187419891,
-0.683346688747406,
-0.47190913558006287,
-0.4971473813056946,
0.33210745453834534,
0.3163979649543762,
0.5972773432731628,
-1.1468937397003174,
0.23832657933235168,
-0.15329419076442719,
-0.13055776059627533,
-0.5933574438095093,
-0.31810644268989563,
0.4564066231250763,
0.6339375376701355,
0.36573928594589233,
-0.2796146273612976,
-0.3802659809589386,
-0.7925435304641724,
-0.566419243812561,
-0.2831953167915344,
0.12854497134685516,
-0.2658337950706482,
0.2929892838001251,
-0.13081040978431702,
1.1393992900848389,
-0.43884965777397156,
-0.022558273747563362,
-0.1807224601507187,
0.7111819982528687,
-0.1390542984008789,
0.5378861427307129,
0.6915964484214783,
-1.2767736911773682,
-0.06823411583900452,
-0.4429546892642975,
-0.9183205962181091,
0.19171805679798126,
-0.3460466265678406,
0.42396223545074463,
0.2982620596885681,
0.6157941222190857,
-0.7578912377357483,
0.8652507066726685,
0.2665732204914093,
-0.5381224751472473,
0.5008038282394409,
-0.02386806346476078,
0.47797614336013794,
-1.01669180393219,
-0.11035887897014618,
0.13767223060131073,
-0.2789303958415985,
-0.6084997653961182,
-0.06158317252993584,
-0.028254253789782524,
-0.15530380606651306,
-0.2613707184791565,
0.2513129711151123,
-0.3904056251049042,
0.00020965318253729492,
-0.5062772035598755,
0.14948759973049164,
0.18057674169540405,
0.4688625633716583,
-0.26428690552711487,
0.6954221129417419,
0.2521404027938843,
-0.328119695186615,
0.38899555802345276,
0.2598404884338379,
-0.7257534861564636,
0.6938365697860718,
-0.21286724507808685,
-0.19295869767665863,
-0.5592249035835266,
0.5050587058067322,
-0.8591476082801819,
-0.35745227336883545,
0.8317058086395264,
-0.7711045742034912,
0.5337303876876831,
-0.058211736381053925,
-0.358723521232605,
-0.0023396224714815617,
-0.132818803191185,
0.5260385870933533,
0.014649665914475918,
-0.5572513937950134,
0.4526923596858978,
0.33411705493927,
0.012757007032632828,
-0.7380093336105347,
-1.056371808052063,
0.25560301542282104,
-0.32970425486564636,
-0.5411243438720703,
0.3457394540309906,
-0.11003643274307251,
-0.40626153349876404,
0.4079228937625885,
-0.3139801025390625,
-0.2289423793554306,
0.27725598216056824,
0.3238545358181,
0.25422245264053345,
-0.6139196157455444,
0.4198194444179535,
-0.13120029866695404,
-0.4389653503894806,
0.04046260938048363,
-0.18451127409934998,
0.3092055916786194,
-0.1866174191236496,
-0.588951587677002,
-0.8121857643127441,
0.46241164207458496,
0.6124382019042969,
-0.2518312335014343,
0.6916745901107788,
0.6948121190071106,
-0.5164384245872498,
-0.1746959388256073,
-0.6571614742279053,
-0.25271502137184143,
-0.34718984365463257,
0.5546115040779114,
-0.11391030997037888,
-0.8449785709381104,
-0.016894742846488953,
-0.2454623430967331,
-0.4210081398487091,
0.5458859801292419,
0.11698180437088013,
-0.10108167678117752,
0.9542654156684875,
0.7210019826889038,
-0.4192623198032379,
0.5527827143669128,
-0.1959320455789566,
0.6431319713592529,
-0.5719159245491028,
-0.06199180334806442,
-0.273442804813385,
-0.452155202627182,
-0.1937451958656311,
-0.48257002234458923,
0.33611536026000977,
0.2044251561164856,
-0.26051852107048035,
0.10772493481636047,
-0.32769376039505005,
0.6480528712272644,
0.3942267894744873,
-0.04830503463745117,
0.40218186378479004,
-0.19268754124641418,
0.3129967451095581,
0.17452597618103027,
-0.8693690299987793,
-0.559742271900177,
1.0094795227050781,
0.46766817569732666,
0.5909685492515564,
-0.088019460439682,
0.02378801256418228,
1.0165141820907593,
0.5039727091789246,
-0.4538612365722656,
0.17874537408351898,
0.3550940155982971,
-0.9305492043495178,
-0.19021296501159668,
-0.30285927653312683,
-0.4774196743965149,
0.082329660654068,
-0.5746957659721375,
-0.5110161900520325,
0.2849739193916321,
0.0837305411696434,
-0.46362781524658203,
0.6645849943161011,
-0.6573269963264465,
0.7177569270133972,
-0.38756707310676575,
-0.00006269034929573536,
-0.5488170981407166,
-0.7108402848243713,
0.38419219851493835,
-0.06981005519628525,
0.40361306071281433,
-0.344654381275177,
0.5004309415817261,
0.3671412467956543,
0.24093550443649292,
1.086410641670227,
-0.1783750057220459,
0.17689059674739838,
0.11506179720163345,
0.17508907616138458,
0.4331536889076233,
0.17124344408512115,
0.010925433598458767,
0.330096036195755,
-0.3169897794723511,
-0.09542468935251236,
-0.7685462832450867,
0.14802131056785583,
-0.503913402557373,
-0.6438588500022888,
-0.44290870428085327,
-0.6281615495681763,
-0.10116178542375565,
0.009356117807328701,
0.4997496008872986,
0.516925036907196,
-0.48364490270614624,
0.14066942036151886,
0.7003317475318909,
0.03392048180103302,
0.6689873337745667,
0.35886886715888977,
0.033127088099718094,
-0.015025673434138298,
0.7111813426017761,
0.1518581658601761,
-0.10517719388008118,
0.5089541077613831,
-0.08264654129743576,
-0.0253450870513916,
-0.5806992650032043,
-0.7001138925552368,
-0.0658310279250145,
-0.6532217264175415,
-0.46253347396850586,
-0.08636550605297089,
-0.42107093334198,
-0.18347808718681335,
-0.07263438403606415,
-0.38183271884918213,
-0.2741980254650116,
-0.37885671854019165,
-0.48945000767707825,
-0.10170631855726242,
0.8756477236747742,
-0.03906372934579849,
0.5697395205497742,
-0.8233016133308411,
0.2661491632461548,
-0.037541307508945465,
0.24926838278770447,
-0.006069697439670563,
-0.23939169943332672,
-0.3647322952747345,
0.594236433506012,
-0.40682098269462585,
-0.8450490236282349,
0.3264075815677643,
-0.2401018589735031,
0.7527613043785095,
0.6927036046981812,
0.11221223324537277,
0.505170464515686,
-0.2748471200466156,
0.8267163038253784,
0.27279046177864075,
-1.0076011419296265,
0.4088137149810791,
-0.05158603936433792,
-0.11967936158180237,
0.3413926362991333,
0.44533392786979675,
-0.6080238223075867,
-0.1555762141942978,
-0.856225311756134,
-0.44712772965431213,
0.8109742403030396,
0.03797939047217369,
0.14390459656715393,
0.23308971524238586,
0.31686800718307495,
0.05977075919508934,
0.42698320746421814,
-0.8070492744445801,
-0.22277948260307312,
-0.22019782662391663,
-0.30548542737960815,
-0.02913718856871128,
-0.4066905379295349,
-0.280678391456604,
0.10191719233989716,
0.823411762714386,
-0.30552709102630615,
0.23741008341312408,
0.20782671868801117,
-0.4688794016838074,
-0.05179537832736969,
0.19585731625556946,
0.6523669958114624,
0.8373154997825623,
0.268572598695755,
0.2193361222743988,
0.037800274789333344,
-0.08127926290035248,
0.08847912400960922,
0.11132689565420151,
-0.45355865359306335,
0.07636997103691101,
0.7841265201568604,
1.0749000310897827,
0.28317850828170776,
-0.3627937138080597,
0.8046950697898865,
0.038130637258291245,
0.061512600630521774,
-0.19354628026485443,
0.13755840063095093,
-0.1058335080742836,
0.7846900224685669,
0.4889479875564575,
0.6708576083183289,
-0.06441473215818405,
-0.7462416291236877,
0.4186904728412628,
0.2917983829975128,
-0.3496871590614319,
-0.3505506217479706,
0.6197526454925537,
0.23144231736660004,
-0.5943031907081604,
0.6695518493652344,
0.0742129236459732,
-0.42430925369262695,
0.5699617266654968,
0.4331183433532715,
0.7713810205459595,
-0.2545359134674072,
0.52632737159729,
-0.10534528642892838,
0.43889304995536804,
-0.3588602840900421,
-0.7107082009315491,
-0.21826456487178802,
-1.3114804029464722,
-0.24033696949481964,
-0.2571438252925873,
-0.09798754751682281,
0.1188625916838646,
-0.5290809273719788,
-0.15734274685382843,
-0.2679211497306824,
-0.20831924676895142,
0.07036338746547699,
-0.43979522585868835,
-0.31319335103034973,
0.08630117774009705,
0.8118664026260376,
0.8081361651420593,
-0.8992672562599182,
0.6839471459388733,
0.20953747630119324,
-0.48291730880737305,
-0.6017528772354126,
0.7111617922782898,
0.46720197796821594,
-0.7742079496383667,
0.41353318095207214,
0.3667225241661072,
-0.18612392246723175,
-0.32553109526634216,
-0.9241524338722229,
-0.8972204923629761,
1.1463861465454102,
0.6177881956100464,
-0.4536077380180359,
-0.30101683735847473,
0.2525520324707031,
0.21061843633651733,
-0.851700484752655,
0.15284696221351624,
0.6274799704551697,
0.7482919692993164,
0.06221762299537659,
-0.6166090369224548,
-0.11322592943906784,
-0.30003172159194946,
0.12187875062227249,
-0.057126741856336594,
-0.4332100450992584,
0.737565815448761,
0.038125552237033844,
-0.28953471779823303,
-0.2078694850206375,
0.6141186952590942,
-0.04376808926463127,
0.8995793461799622,
0.4438337981700897,
0.5191776752471924,
0.8351647257804871,
-0.14620856940746307,
0.7884911298751831,
-0.43212059140205383,
0.26455363631248474,
0.9745549559593201,
-0.15813519060611725,
0.38037005066871643,
0.1649111658334732,
0.4139014780521393,
0.6142577528953552,
0.3563653826713562,
-0.12015282362699509,
0.27816131711006165,
-0.12291791290044785,
-0.037643395364284515,
-0.275070458650589,
-0.020206376910209656,
-0.36740541458129883,
0.6336816549301147,
0.5574735999107361,
-0.3273158073425293,
-0.35941219329833984,
0.4262455403804779,
0.28559476137161255,
0.27804988622665405,
-0.3552117943763733,
0.5736090540885925,
-0.11192705482244492,
-0.5840417146682739,
0.12401649355888367,
0.33616188168525696,
0.7410727143287659,
-0.49366456270217896,
-0.18889671564102173,
-0.09656541794538498,
0.19357992708683014,
-0.07737747579813004,
-0.6530072689056396,
0.7694288492202759,
-0.10407981276512146,
-0.4638289213180542,
-0.5636955499649048,
1.0091676712036133,
-0.4354300796985626,
-0.27257153391838074,
0.22062411904335022,
0.6143761277198792,
-0.31748461723327637,
-0.33653661608695984,
-0.5669123530387878,
0.28289324045181274,
0.1369037926197052,
-0.11431010812520981,
0.13204070925712585,
0.3690854609012604,
0.0056060501374304295,
0.4915792644023895,
0.48778510093688965,
-0.2421153485774994,
-0.21801108121871948,
-0.5353546142578125,
0.7563036680221558,
-0.6825172305107117,
-0.6953033804893494,
-0.8737258315086365,
0.39863067865371704,
-0.22453367710113525,
-0.13562892377376556,
0.5572737455368042,
0.4915614128112793,
1.0020583868026733,
0.1578020453453064,
0.9237639904022217,
0.14074109494686127,
0.23494355380535126,
-0.6699427366256714,
1.1150881052017212,
-0.29887068271636963,
0.36622917652130127,
-0.03682783246040344,
-0.6924993991851807,
-0.28970593214035034,
0.5088514685630798,
-0.3299527168273926,
-0.19377470016479492,
0.6081993579864502,
0.7315987348556519,
-0.0365799255669117,
0.9036710262298584,
0.2695406377315521,
0.5904679894447327,
0.322683185338974,
0.32164978981018066,
0.9142274856567383,
-0.35326409339904785,
0.3877582252025604,
0.2518286108970642,
-0.1596633940935135,
-0.39334195852279663,
-0.6767445802688599,
-0.4569413661956787,
-0.7393349409103394,
-0.31369802355766296,
-0.14257414638996124,
0.38677552342414856,
0.6373176574707031,
0.9131999611854553,
-0.6128806471824646,
0.18874827027320862,
0.03816281631588936,
0.44476354122161865,
-0.15879729390144348,
-0.2828291952610016,
0.17085540294647217,
-0.19605068862438202,
-0.46516257524490356,
0.8434119820594788,
0.3872920274734497,
0.07966196537017822,
-0.1587361842393875,
0.0262554120272398,
-0.2692478895187378,
0.3129962086677551,
0.37189382314682007,
0.2091159075498581,
-0.4094180464744568,
-0.5850791335105896,
-0.6200024485588074,
-0.06946644932031631,
0.37613922357559204,
1.0275444984436035,
-1.0237807035446167,
0.32343143224716187,
0.16826237738132477,
0.8751064538955688,
0.577303946018219,
0.16684874892234802,
0.628737211227417,
-0.8207686543464661,
0.1264399141073227,
0.25150781869888306,
0.14683637022972107,
0.3856346607208252,
-0.622912585735321,
0.34132465720176697,
0.6727246046066284,
-0.09560716152191162,
-0.7221517562866211,
0.28011825680732727,
-0.46181127429008484,
-0.7950786352157593,
0.5946637988090515,
-0.007221049629151821,
-0.2668859362602234,
-0.06524733453989029,
-0.01780264638364315,
0.2234879583120346,
-0.19510380923748016,
0.9855342507362366,
0.9416048526763916,
-0.2124011516571045,
0.008862676098942757,
-0.480028361082077,
0.5965231657028198,
0.24469953775405884,
-0.6700966358184814,
0.006452367175370455,
0.7219668626785278,
0.26910871267318726,
0.5214169025421143,
0.527249276638031,
0.061036501079797745,
0.1995750516653061,
0.22401291131973267,
-0.2018301784992218,
-0.516533374786377,
-0.5987890958786011,
-0.39579179883003235,
0.5528535842895508,
-0.6260990500450134,
-0.3405000865459442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12566v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12566v2 | GenAudit: Fixing Factual Errors in Language Model Outputs with Evidence | 2024-02-19T21:45:55 | 2024-03-16T21:14:16 | Kundan Krishna, Sanjana Ramprasad, Prakhar Gupta, Byron C. Wallace, Zachary C. Lipton, Jeffrey P. Bigham | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | LLMs can generate factually incorrect statements even when provided access to
reference documents. Such errors can be dangerous in high-stakes applications
(e.g., document-grounded QA for healthcare or finance). We present GenAudit --
a tool intended to assist fact-checking LLM responses for document-grounded
tasks. GenAudit suggests edits to the LLM response by revising or removing
claims that are not supported by the reference document, and also presents
evidence from the reference for facts that do appear to have support. We train
models to execute these tasks, and design an interactive interface to present
suggested edits and evidence to users. Comprehensive evaluation by human raters
shows that GenAudit can detect errors in 8 different LLM outputs when
summarizing documents from diverse domains. To ensure that most errors are
flagged by the system, we propose a method that can increase the error recall
while minimizing impact on precision. We release our tool (GenAudit) and
fact-checking model for public use. | [
0.04381837323307991,
-0.6248228549957275,
0.7179079055786133,
0.1779857724905014,
-0.12207891792058945,
0.24776428937911987,
0.03964250534772873,
-0.24636557698249817,
0.027491647750139236,
0.5800271034240723,
-0.3166190981864929,
-0.7229835987091064,
-0.6513813734054565,
0.0031490495894104242,
-0.6804312467575073,
0.836858868598938,
-0.19402669370174408,
0.20762982964515686,
-0.6905518174171448,
-0.2521997392177582,
-0.29936274886131287,
-0.6638083457946777,
-0.6443043351173401,
-0.36370840668678284,
0.34606391191482544,
0.8406373262405396,
0.476232647895813,
0.31081917881965637,
0.6583675742149353,
0.36922991275787354,
0.01139759086072445,
0.3728051781654358,
-0.5360053777694702,
0.021346565335989,
-0.2955794036388397,
-0.6244271397590637,
-0.9515061378479004,
0.2480747252702713,
0.42328333854675293,
0.4401680529117584,
-0.23022186756134033,
0.3145390748977661,
-0.06524638086557388,
0.6188732981681824,
-0.34895217418670654,
0.22835487127304077,
-0.3695429861545563,
-0.24360044300556183,
-0.057901911437511444,
-0.5038286447525024,
-0.5205855369567871,
-0.6987061500549316,
-0.1569032222032547,
-0.5409268736839294,
0.7018048167228699,
0.1573362499475479,
1.0112148523330688,
0.46025776863098145,
-0.37526461482048035,
-0.28816527128219604,
-0.7022901773452759,
0.41475212574005127,
-0.9966588616371155,
0.5022608637809753,
0.3039095997810364,
0.07739085704088211,
-0.23039087653160095,
-0.5939822793006897,
-0.4919406771659851,
-0.10611314326524734,
-0.16490615904331207,
0.22894187271595,
-0.014564309269189835,
0.317231148481369,
0.6112526059150696,
0.26709040999412537,
-0.43915554881095886,
-0.037264373153448105,
-0.39051392674446106,
-0.47732847929000854,
0.5709068179130554,
-0.10980094969272614,
0.4785749614238739,
-0.11208923906087875,
-0.05861378461122513,
-0.23387481272220612,
-1.2058926820755005,
-0.24068570137023926,
0.3677200675010681,
-0.012846394442021847,
-0.0668613463640213,
0.8724814057350159,
-0.29488715529441833,
0.4645532965660095,
0.17435002326965332,
-0.3085433542728424,
0.12317829579114914,
-0.29150840640068054,
-0.37975266575813293,
0.33379310369491577,
0.35383424162864685,
0.5512915253639221,
0.026544244959950447,
-0.1787092089653015,
-0.3261840343475342,
0.015859045088291168,
0.029180925339460373,
-0.7664304375648499,
-0.0959349200129509,
0.4522888660430908,
-0.15319721400737762,
-0.3618422746658325,
0.17090511322021484,
-0.7745192646980286,
-0.756919264793396,
-0.44364097714424133,
0.16779591143131256,
-0.31905579566955566,
0.06312529742717743,
0.2197556346654892,
-0.3426949083805084,
-0.09600916504859924,
0.7129449248313904,
-0.6274962425231934,
0.09090975672006607,
0.5439544916152954,
0.5188440680503845,
0.27436354756355286,
-0.14243488013744354,
-0.8738690614700317,
0.22341430187225342,
-0.23331426084041595,
1.0596147775650024,
-0.1619945764541626,
-0.567105770111084,
-0.03320299834012985,
-0.010347217321395874,
0.03355347365140915,
-0.7076050043106079,
0.936438798904419,
-0.4463953375816345,
0.27272069454193115,
-0.4664262533187866,
-0.8172509074211121,
-0.12238000333309174,
0.1898222118616104,
-0.620437741279602,
0.9407981634140015,
0.07025498151779175,
-0.8662346005439758,
0.4854260981082916,
-0.6654086709022522,
-0.19577158987522125,
-0.016926756128668785,
-0.24437275528907776,
-0.5007753372192383,
0.1624789834022522,
0.24395927786827087,
0.2867060601711273,
-0.24780923128128052,
0.6062721014022827,
-0.24081498384475708,
-0.22131940722465515,
0.16607704758644104,
-0.4330788552761078,
0.7868432402610779,
-0.08715265989303589,
-0.31253737211227417,
0.3554346263408661,
-1.238008975982666,
-0.5460798144340515,
0.1883019655942917,
-0.7741407752037048,
-0.44219183921813965,
0.29274386167526245,
-0.07021165639162064,
0.12778820097446442,
0.09746646136045456,
-0.7972558736801147,
0.16063781082630157,
-0.1265588104724884,
0.20526890456676483,
0.5934284329414368,
-0.03732201084494591,
0.12720756232738495,
-0.5559528470039368,
0.3551792800426483,
0.03487560898065567,
0.0432773195207119,
-0.08351244032382965,
-0.4947640597820282,
-1.0052683353424072,
-0.22892268002033234,
0.5406506061553955,
0.7457053661346436,
-0.6478484869003296,
0.41322803497314453,
-0.41597822308540344,
-0.31310492753982544,
-0.6936317682266235,
0.29980233311653137,
-0.05475246161222458,
0.9553552865982056,
0.10011256486177444,
-0.020833399146795273,
-0.6769499778747559,
-0.7850743532180786,
-0.2821076214313507,
-0.5928360223770142,
-0.18413585424423218,
0.04654410481452942,
0.326175332069397,
-0.36282071471214294,
1.241131067276001,
-0.3211236596107483,
-0.058725643903017044,
0.10936692357063293,
0.7070549130439758,
-0.002654015552252531,
0.2583772838115692,
0.545489490032196,
-0.6148731708526611,
0.14079782366752625,
-0.2649332582950592,
-0.9238216280937195,
-0.604645848274231,
-0.31707221269607544,
0.21615047752857208,
0.10179432481527328,
0.5058523416519165,
-0.6375332474708557,
0.26620587706565857,
0.4865172207355499,
-0.5316104292869568,
0.5345250964164734,
-0.34392616152763367,
0.38837432861328125,
-0.8546342849731445,
0.04385786131024361,
-0.17482608556747437,
-0.5470320582389832,
-0.43692532181739807,
0.04790802299976349,
0.36289259791374207,
-0.004033271688967943,
-0.4016942083835602,
0.35275644063949585,
-0.1078483983874321,
-0.03580339998006821,
-0.1757422238588333,
0.2709062993526459,
0.295228511095047,
0.04380827024579048,
-0.09558414667844772,
1.0527058839797974,
-0.00024764868430793285,
-0.28539958596229553,
0.5690780282020569,
0.4407700300216675,
-0.35251790285110474,
0.6022154688835144,
-0.543008029460907,
0.084152951836586,
-0.1777881681919098,
0.012186181731522083,
-1.0369091033935547,
-0.4268461763858795,
0.17403045296669006,
-0.36568379402160645,
0.2747640609741211,
-0.09535931050777435,
-0.6784029603004456,
-0.17488746345043182,
-0.3124959170818329,
-0.0031796398106962442,
0.15756742656230927,
-0.5898099541664124,
0.9144529700279236,
0.15682527422904968,
-0.5111957788467407,
-0.36553025245666504,
-0.5257821679115295,
0.32473355531692505,
0.025164062157273293,
-0.7962992191314697,
-0.023975186049938202,
-0.2133364975452423,
-0.4942324757575989,
0.09824049472808838,
0.018826311454176903,
0.062485408037900925,
0.4292468726634979,
0.4700321555137634,
0.49493634700775146,
-0.10058937221765518,
0.176817387342453,
0.12328176200389862,
-0.0299959946423769,
0.41818639636039734,
0.1678701490163803,
0.08629117161035538,
-0.049947336316108704,
-0.8681237101554871,
0.0023331225384026766,
0.09402917325496674,
0.9411455392837524,
-0.1919005811214447,
0.2135753184556961,
0.44762036204338074,
-0.2784106731414795,
0.14666740596294403,
-0.9756309390068054,
-0.2324540913105011,
-0.4563210606575012,
0.20528656244277954,
0.06276179105043411,
-0.7095568180084229,
0.4668556749820709,
-0.39272916316986084,
0.32929152250289917,
0.5042135715484619,
0.6119589805603027,
-0.1939954310655594,
0.7066311836242676,
0.4941999614238739,
0.047277238219976425,
0.12013222277164459,
-0.04027130454778671,
0.2978827655315399,
-0.5736311674118042,
-0.16848422586917877,
-0.6215165257453918,
0.16457346081733704,
-0.274647057056427,
-0.47924375534057617,
0.3590001165866852,
-0.11430041491985321,
0.11467254906892776,
-0.15412867069244385,
0.005845184903591871,
0.2764127552509308,
0.8478505611419678,
0.05164347216486931,
0.707013726234436,
-0.07508038729429245,
-0.16391049325466156,
0.06755326688289642,
-0.7545933723449707,
-0.7158212065696716,
1.0678484439849854,
0.45257559418678284,
0.8391427397727966,
0.09884481877088547,
0.7166460752487183,
0.456320583820343,
0.7794827818870544,
-0.5930331349372864,
0.46025440096855164,
0.10152442008256912,
-0.7592862248420715,
-0.22463594377040863,
-0.30048587918281555,
-0.18903939425945282,
-0.05855298787355423,
-0.38800787925720215,
-0.12448029220104218,
0.4031527042388916,
0.36870133876800537,
-0.4537498950958252,
0.44698479771614075,
-0.6595133543014526,
0.6005536317825317,
-0.24500656127929688,
-0.28967905044555664,
-0.2397921234369278,
-0.34386730194091797,
0.5754888653755188,
-0.21951045095920563,
0.3614230155944824,
-0.18290992081165314,
0.45006486773490906,
0.6992376446723938,
-0.3494187891483307,
1.092955470085144,
-0.014584856107831001,
-0.2849861681461334,
0.30119267106056213,
0.22145341336727142,
0.6996741890907288,
0.15107318758964539,
-0.07382295280694962,
0.12485403567552567,
-0.053834326565265656,
-0.17836180329322815,
-0.5586342811584473,
0.416230171918869,
-0.6621727347373962,
-0.9175282716751099,
-0.5803313255310059,
-0.6785628795623779,
-0.28586262464523315,
0.04577452689409256,
0.09584490209817886,
0.5396541953086853,
-0.5631763935089111,
0.010026700794696808,
0.8657108545303345,
-0.29555797576904297,
0.09580264985561371,
0.864983320236206,
-0.246512308716774,
-0.21594643592834473,
0.7982136607170105,
0.006712593603879213,
0.2503541111946106,
0.2434588074684143,
0.12985575199127197,
-0.21971559524536133,
-0.5803778171539307,
-0.543454647064209,
0.22567172348499298,
-0.9522795081138611,
-0.10459676384925842,
-0.4711160659790039,
-0.05696289986371994,
-0.5860689878463745,
0.022923171520233154,
-0.12367082387208939,
-0.6432684063911438,
-0.2098415344953537,
-0.552206814289093,
0.3283592164516449,
0.6897149085998535,
-0.3806222677230835,
0.16272218525409698,
-0.9267475008964539,
0.46957695484161377,
0.6306641101837158,
0.21397632360458374,
-0.5564368963241577,
-0.39256998896598816,
-0.1299957036972046,
0.03140757232904434,
-0.23326840996742249,
-0.8466782569885254,
0.09192992001771927,
0.10263007134199142,
0.34808170795440674,
0.5636955499649048,
0.023590175434947014,
0.30876728892326355,
-0.6095670461654663,
0.654840350151062,
-0.01836760900914669,
-0.881997287273407,
0.5479702353477478,
-0.34139561653137207,
0.021693332120776176,
0.5904732942581177,
0.0026078636292368174,
-0.6577597260475159,
-0.707953155040741,
-0.7012580037117004,
-0.5060908794403076,
0.34476935863494873,
-0.05924011394381523,
-0.2541762888431549,
0.04390329867601395,
0.3002706468105316,
-0.09704407304525375,
0.29639917612075806,
-0.2207629680633545,
-0.07524541020393372,
-0.2881344258785248,
-0.31036457419395447,
0.03608563169836998,
-0.8554800748825073,
-0.6423786282539368,
-0.25580716133117676,
0.8786823153495789,
-0.19766728579998016,
-0.039259325712919235,
0.6282883286476135,
-0.2407304346561432,
-0.5072935223579407,
0.588218629360199,
0.9669603109359741,
1.0446892976760864,
-0.721749484539032,
0.258535772562027,
0.12457751482725143,
-0.43299251794815063,
0.26871928572654724,
0.1566116362810135,
-0.5801059007644653,
0.3271920382976532,
0.3945017158985138,
0.40809565782546997,
0.35658717155456543,
-0.9440746903419495,
0.6227419972419739,
-0.17999784648418427,
-0.22218461334705353,
-0.13850581645965576,
-0.17987003922462463,
0.33640483021736145,
-0.007416284177452326,
0.15457706153392792,
0.1888258457183838,
0.20661740005016327,
-0.4892110228538513,
0.27169883251190186,
0.06631433218717575,
-0.0853053629398346,
-0.21198341250419617,
0.8518604636192322,
0.5557346343994141,
-0.08820735663175583,
0.5932034254074097,
-0.19000907242298126,
-0.5635263323783875,
0.5431931018829346,
0.287670761346817,
0.915224015712738,
-0.2123570740222931,
0.39822912216186523,
0.08785667270421982,
0.4855104088783264,
-0.10065898299217224,
0.3140958547592163,
0.5350207090377808,
-0.8916558623313904,
-0.6610550284385681,
-0.27042296528816223,
-0.7863906025886536,
-0.0010494805173948407,
-0.3802359104156494,
0.16767024993896484,
-0.608363687992096,
-0.2082396000623703,
-0.08250792324542999,
-0.4065322279930115,
-0.583884060382843,
0.19943401217460632,
0.09811608493328094,
1.036647915840149,
-1.0530165433883667,
0.7111821174621582,
0.7715408802032471,
-0.48523613810539246,
-0.6288339495658875,
-0.3109930455684662,
0.3397568166255951,
-0.6953302621841431,
0.9133948683738708,
-0.39224159717559814,
-0.28749576210975647,
-0.20344489812850952,
-0.7272618412971497,
-0.6086627244949341,
1.0013307332992554,
0.6298906803131104,
-0.7887545228004456,
0.0030743207316845655,
0.26151007413864136,
0.20833367109298706,
-0.04110923036932945,
0.21505442261695862,
0.5829592943191528,
0.6721274256706238,
-0.17387253046035767,
-0.6758536100387573,
0.09315237402915955,
0.020724330097436905,
-0.506881594657898,
-0.11702783405780792,
-0.4513089954853058,
0.7825785875320435,
-0.12183120846748352,
-0.1478623002767563,
-0.15383616089820862,
0.5760473608970642,
0.3423381745815277,
0.5376789569854736,
0.38665035367012024,
0.7048831582069397,
1.1622413396835327,
-0.25951462984085083,
1.0770463943481445,
-0.42355772852897644,
0.350844144821167,
1.2583438158035278,
-0.5653533339500427,
0.49892234802246094,
0.5946295261383057,
-0.03047783114016056,
0.4233399033546448,
0.5487977862358093,
-0.20987942814826965,
0.08053163439035416,
-0.016112692654132843,
-0.3152081072330475,
-0.29749536514282227,
-0.26306357979774475,
0.03358299285173416,
0.07287155836820602,
0.2971956431865692,
-0.1566910743713379,
-0.3449864685535431,
-0.21361678838729858,
0.21186676621437073,
0.07212025672197342,
-0.012739157304167747,
0.5424085259437561,
-0.05080106481909752,
-0.35680705308914185,
0.33241212368011475,
0.16250692307949066,
0.28187134861946106,
-0.3794081211090088,
-0.3259873390197754,
-0.3692203760147095,
0.031443215906620026,
-0.30558890104293823,
-0.3764636218547821,
0.185784712433815,
0.12381269037723541,
-0.42008718848228455,
-0.11173176020383835,
0.9631387591362,
-0.4029883146286011,
-0.631948709487915,
0.18681512773036957,
0.6635058522224426,
-0.14163203537464142,
-0.16902805864810944,
-0.5887028574943542,
-0.0017986007733270526,
-0.053567979484796524,
0.0918968915939331,
-0.024108141660690308,
0.36304783821105957,
0.04399649053812027,
0.6940209269523621,
0.6999583840370178,
0.4003151059150696,
0.1680545210838318,
0.32253119349479675,
0.7298493981361389,
-0.44373470544815063,
-0.19318991899490356,
-0.6539114117622375,
0.35462260246276855,
-0.34890010952949524,
-0.018431589007377625,
0.7600975036621094,
0.6014123558998108,
0.6397497653961182,
-0.07724630832672119,
0.9622822403907776,
0.15283548831939697,
0.7198275327682495,
-0.5862264633178711,
0.6090391874313354,
-0.31450602412223816,
0.3961986005306244,
0.024271884933114052,
-0.6814936399459839,
-0.3537113666534424,
0.1341942995786667,
-0.29965832829475403,
-0.4647170603275299,
0.7033173441886902,
0.9324208498001099,
-0.18704381585121155,
-0.019479703158140182,
0.30489787459373474,
0.6075513958930969,
0.5505377650260925,
0.09253739565610886,
0.8059268593788147,
-0.3809951841831207,
0.1889314502477646,
-0.1690831333398819,
-0.27473053336143494,
-0.5133065581321716,
-0.9801561236381531,
-0.8450961709022522,
-0.16385005414485931,
-0.6243810653686523,
-0.5175514817237854,
0.18937300145626068,
1.039039134979248,
0.5070063471794128,
-1.1049875020980835,
-0.13387468457221985,
0.11839904636144638,
0.38284263014793396,
-0.06215415522456169,
-0.17332148551940918,
0.4170871078968048,
-0.2751767337322235,
-0.519800066947937,
0.694564163684845,
0.3543504774570465,
0.1180661991238594,
-0.1621207892894745,
-0.0110868439078331,
-0.25142404437065125,
0.2924034595489502,
0.43594956398010254,
0.2827844023704529,
-0.5847286581993103,
-0.6344955563545227,
-0.24424229562282562,
-0.14614827930927277,
0.1883457452058792,
1.0829144716262817,
-0.42020383477211,
0.5319771766662598,
0.6931999325752258,
0.8452343940734863,
0.15450136363506317,
0.20728793740272522,
0.7449113726615906,
-0.759308934211731,
0.02828359045088291,
-0.06450454890727997,
0.7582373023033142,
0.6404356360435486,
-0.4934219717979431,
0.6715967655181885,
0.6375094056129456,
-0.5919587016105652,
-0.6792982220649719,
-0.01689409837126732,
-0.9328951239585876,
-0.16551955044269562,
1.046260118484497,
-0.1477307826280594,
-0.27794480323791504,
-0.2746182382106781,
-0.3730645179748535,
0.29214707016944885,
-0.3274679481983185,
1.0295482873916626,
1.0441597700119019,
0.28346142172813416,
-0.034723736345767975,
-0.8032540678977966,
0.6429650187492371,
0.38076716661453247,
-0.8460323214530945,
0.191917285323143,
0.7478867173194885,
0.689695417881012,
0.3138903081417084,
0.48932430148124695,
-0.14054006338119507,
0.5528983473777771,
-0.16049368679523468,
0.5052453875541687,
-0.27148720622062683,
-0.07280050218105316,
-0.37219473719596863,
0.04993993788957596,
0.42072564363479614,
0.04121194779872894
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.