id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12563v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12563v3 | Confidence Matters: Revisiting Intrinsic Self-Correction Capabilities of Large Language Models | 2024-02-19T21:38:02 | 2024-05-13T11:01:17 | Loka Li, Zhenhao Chen, Guangyi Chen, Yixuan Zhang, Yusheng Su, Eric Xing, Kun Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The recent success of Large Language Models (LLMs) has catalyzed an
increasing interest in their self-correction capabilities. This paper presents
a comprehensive investigation into the intrinsic self-correction of LLMs,
attempting to address the ongoing debate about its feasibility. Our research
has identified an important latent factor - the "confidence" of LLMs - during
the self-correction process. Overlooking this factor may cause the models to
over-criticize themselves, resulting in unreliable conclusions regarding the
efficacy of self-correction. We have experimentally observed that LLMs possess
the capability to understand the "confidence" in their own responses. It
motivates us to develop an "If-or-Else" (IoE) prompting framework, designed to
guide LLMs in assessing their own "confidence", facilitating intrinsic
self-corrections. We conduct extensive experiments and demonstrate that our
IoE-based Prompt can achieve a consistent improvement regarding the accuracy of
self-corrected responses over the initial answers. Our study not only sheds
light on the underlying factors affecting self-correction in LLMs, but also
introduces a practical framework that utilizes the IoE prompting principle to
efficiently improve self-correction capabilities with "confidence". The code is
available at https://github.com/MBZUAI-CLeaR/IoE-Prompting.git. | [
-0.1467898190021515,
-0.7218553423881531,
0.7342556715011597,
0.46366509795188904,
0.2482159435749054,
0.015671484172344208,
-0.40558725595474243,
-0.3363783061504364,
0.003426371840760112,
0.17170797288417816,
-0.4325738251209259,
-0.2852655053138733,
-0.6178808808326721,
0.5152353644371033,
-0.544337809085846,
0.6521834135055542,
-0.09173212200403214,
0.2939845621585846,
-0.1813313215970993,
0.14531376957893372,
-0.606069028377533,
-0.43204623460769653,
-0.7427747249603271,
-0.23387901484966278,
0.8366288542747498,
0.7014251351356506,
0.34780120849609375,
0.360439658164978,
0.49466362595558167,
0.32945141196250916,
-0.007791719399392605,
-0.05484709143638611,
-0.5590397715568542,
0.23923484981060028,
-0.35593539476394653,
-0.8182731866836548,
-0.5747624039649963,
-0.08969821780920029,
0.8814038634300232,
0.4636012315750122,
-0.12851238250732422,
0.04470443353056908,
0.3827142119407654,
0.6754004955291748,
-0.6160231232643127,
0.16252586245536804,
-0.6702291369438171,
-0.1627587527036667,
-0.13309656083583832,
-0.3003671169281006,
-0.5500280261039734,
-0.05061737075448036,
-0.06614300608634949,
-0.2989761531352997,
0.16877281665802002,
0.01650211028754711,
0.3709356188774109,
0.31980323791503906,
-0.3344686031341553,
-0.21612770855426788,
-0.7119187116622925,
0.5331740975379944,
-0.8348930478096008,
0.12282594293355942,
0.4205623269081116,
-0.25164300203323364,
-0.3124876320362091,
-0.4785977303981781,
-0.6933238506317139,
-0.29326939582824707,
0.002651314716786146,
0.057823460549116135,
-0.09102017432451248,
0.15795832872390747,
0.27472013235092163,
0.40634068846702576,
-0.2518901526927948,
0.2678966820240021,
-0.27299731969833374,
-0.09668461233377457,
0.44174131751060486,
-0.0890529528260231,
0.07786478847265244,
-0.02653518132865429,
0.04625760018825531,
-0.20454922318458557,
-0.9952362775802612,
0.2791721224784851,
0.29838621616363525,
0.2339530885219574,
0.1413167268037796,
0.7094866037368774,
-0.29056283831596375,
0.35514578223228455,
0.6070350408554077,
-0.21875490248203278,
-0.16091884672641754,
-0.11152953654527664,
0.0026222120504826307,
0.28533563017845154,
0.46479353308677673,
0.4759245216846466,
0.21720319986343384,
0.12546077370643616,
-0.3547820448875427,
-0.09849227964878082,
0.25445929169654846,
-0.8163160681724548,
-0.07124476879835129,
0.6010958552360535,
-0.04332093521952629,
-0.14133985340595245,
0.12034054845571518,
-0.03036903776228428,
-0.4872988164424896,
-0.2805453836917877,
0.7352849245071411,
-0.2270652949810028,
-0.037164658308029175,
0.20347099006175995,
0.28609156608581543,
0.013877655379474163,
0.5897160172462463,
-0.8237096071243286,
-0.00543988635763526,
0.7554321885108948,
0.7018288373947144,
-0.15689998865127563,
-0.4194519519805908,
-0.45280519127845764,
0.010966075584292412,
-0.7316056489944458,
0.783012866973877,
-0.2726081311702728,
-0.612676739692688,
0.07967221736907959,
0.009881063364446163,
0.01682191528379917,
-0.358645498752594,
0.461917906999588,
-0.2552306652069092,
0.2025570273399353,
-0.5434126257896423,
-0.738045334815979,
0.006238454021513462,
0.29862475395202637,
-0.29084259271621704,
0.9159557819366455,
-0.19813355803489685,
-0.676787793636322,
0.12320234626531601,
-0.41619426012039185,
-0.33577120304107666,
0.009982899762690067,
-0.2545703947544098,
-0.28734442591667175,
0.446320116519928,
0.04485182836651802,
0.5385411977767944,
-0.013339238241314888,
0.28355085849761963,
-0.3628208041191101,
-0.26301318407058716,
0.6842840909957886,
-0.41341087222099304,
0.3840762972831726,
-0.18350955843925476,
-0.49599820375442505,
0.23397783935070038,
-0.38802382349967957,
0.11513827741146088,
-0.06463286280632019,
-0.12823176383972168,
-0.10950081050395966,
-0.052565623074769974,
-0.6445959210395813,
0.02930828556418419,
0.4204745590686798,
-0.6368939876556396,
0.4876888692378998,
-0.2520945966243744,
0.5263877511024475,
1.1535149812698364,
-0.11023565381765366,
0.4151608943939209,
-0.21340467035770416,
0.41583776473999023,
-0.19222141802310944,
0.16793212294578552,
-0.5362375974655151,
-0.41701292991638184,
-0.9514467716217041,
0.019036713987588882,
0.48504549264907837,
0.4714987277984619,
-0.5340560674667358,
0.3687881827354431,
-0.17838819324970245,
-0.27996429800987244,
-0.6143583655357361,
0.21406666934490204,
0.3301897943019867,
0.6236715912818909,
0.24317803978919983,
-0.12869994342327118,
-0.35425910353660583,
-0.8274641633033752,
-0.28030744194984436,
-0.6493064165115356,
0.1985231190919876,
0.20250001549720764,
0.45595401525497437,
-0.1617390215396881,
1.1552494764328003,
-0.2389998584985733,
-0.19142727553844452,
0.03517743572592735,
0.33286550641059875,
0.11221767216920853,
0.5206480026245117,
0.2764306664466858,
-0.4778079092502594,
-0.6468607187271118,
-0.2223612368106842,
-0.5453366041183472,
-0.3907108008861542,
-0.040367841720581055,
0.1871887743473053,
0.33600303530693054,
0.789069652557373,
-0.48075392842292786,
0.4826820194721222,
0.6963169574737549,
-0.1986016482114792,
0.60638028383255,
-0.5566088557243347,
0.42551881074905396,
-0.6574984192848206,
-0.050403889268636703,
-0.20495986938476562,
-0.15154555439949036,
-0.4017864167690277,
-0.024906011298298836,
0.4364320933818817,
0.21435673534870148,
-0.14273351430892944,
0.6733842492103577,
-0.4782070815563202,
0.17140670120716095,
-0.4946669042110443,
0.028322899714112282,
-0.07228714227676392,
0.160373255610466,
-0.06673909723758698,
1.117932677268982,
0.7144264578819275,
-0.7691158056259155,
-0.14872673153877258,
0.012080552987754345,
-0.2395726442337036,
0.8426985144615173,
-0.7681017518043518,
0.33470413088798523,
-0.1334696263074875,
0.23109838366508484,
-1.2010480165481567,
-0.3240838348865509,
0.11808587610721588,
-0.5759305953979492,
0.5871765613555908,
-0.17713896930217743,
-0.48090019822120667,
-0.44991010427474976,
-0.24292728304862976,
0.05105853080749512,
0.2917722761631012,
-0.587377667427063,
0.5959140658378601,
0.11314640194177628,
-0.6502419710159302,
-0.6961579322814941,
-0.6276034116744995,
0.38917723298072815,
0.06724971532821655,
-0.5972887277603149,
0.3039231300354004,
-0.621606171131134,
-0.4289787709712982,
-0.13194751739501953,
-0.20930688083171844,
0.12226241081953049,
0.2752857506275177,
0.2503865361213684,
0.1900380700826645,
-0.14102797210216522,
0.4862280488014221,
0.0364508181810379,
-0.24536126852035522,
0.22571918368339539,
-0.4622105360031128,
0.29411956667900085,
-0.49246588349342346,
-0.5628748536109924,
-0.5542450547218323,
0.13591453433036804,
0.3372683823108673,
0.0019272291101515293,
0.7067168354988098,
0.2852661609649658,
-0.12367328256368637,
-0.05368640273809433,
-0.8560377359390259,
-0.6696035861968994,
-0.4981706440448761,
0.23774762451648712,
-0.321819931268692,
-1.1738370656967163,
0.4274074137210846,
0.1585865318775177,
0.08415623009204865,
0.4055861234664917,
0.6052287817001343,
-0.46708327531814575,
1.1541829109191895,
0.6382189393043518,
-0.006951472256332636,
0.3903157711029053,
0.08290772140026093,
0.27993348240852356,
-0.810589075088501,
0.05666578188538551,
-0.745598316192627,
-0.23506958782672882,
-0.47058477997779846,
-0.42133665084838867,
0.42146822810173035,
0.07056201994419098,
-0.0637732520699501,
-0.11849386245012283,
-0.2114643007516861,
0.5435261130332947,
0.3675394058227539,
-0.061856236308813095,
0.4861166775226593,
-0.1746034026145935,
0.08077507466077805,
-0.1740819215774536,
-0.6942696571350098,
-0.5136806964874268,
0.9488571286201477,
0.4806308448314667,
1.0927181243896484,
0.26709669828414917,
0.5567278265953064,
0.325312077999115,
0.4980389177799225,
-0.8695111870765686,
0.5122911930084229,
0.11795945465564728,
-0.7118784189224243,
-0.42165276408195496,
-0.4410940408706665,
-0.9010464549064636,
0.09047555923461914,
-0.2334727644920349,
-0.5733664631843567,
0.4304645359516144,
0.558349609375,
-0.5221346616744995,
0.2641759514808655,
-0.6419625282287598,
0.46404266357421875,
-0.430157333612442,
-0.521841824054718,
-0.3522796332836151,
-0.566436767578125,
0.11039000749588013,
-0.24163329601287842,
0.08564877510070801,
-0.13121725618839264,
-0.1400572955608368,
0.29324737191200256,
-0.28711998462677,
1.1494954824447632,
0.08854716271162033,
-0.6254060864448547,
0.26099416613578796,
0.29769280552864075,
0.6668207049369812,
0.2068607211112976,
-0.12095868587493896,
0.1565624177455902,
-0.1870100498199463,
-0.24094489216804504,
-0.8088881969451904,
0.6787939667701721,
-0.5299171209335327,
-0.9373241662979126,
-0.4552648067474365,
-0.21770180761814117,
-0.2937382459640503,
0.19329045712947845,
0.33559685945510864,
0.4651630222797394,
-0.060860998928546906,
0.6595672369003296,
1.0148333311080933,
0.10830669850111008,
0.44348105788230896,
0.9250915050506592,
-0.4415706694126129,
-0.19086895883083344,
0.6052535772323608,
0.4130721986293793,
0.4507015347480774,
0.2598862051963806,
0.4638202488422394,
-0.41493603587150574,
-0.5642210245132446,
-0.36017927527427673,
0.2990919053554535,
-0.7181137800216675,
-0.12801697850227356,
-0.4925936162471771,
0.030598247423768044,
-0.6328887343406677,
-0.10873879492282867,
-0.5962823033332825,
-0.23048518598079681,
-0.3175053894519806,
-0.05114907771348953,
0.32904478907585144,
0.9725626707077026,
-0.2904280126094818,
0.4301171600818634,
-0.7148317694664001,
-0.11093969643115997,
0.5509551763534546,
0.2791898250579834,
-0.02706211246550083,
-0.886664092540741,
-0.0790325477719307,
-0.003951148595660925,
0.03462938591837883,
-0.6465526819229126,
0.14987421035766602,
0.08585875481367111,
0.5355256795883179,
0.20411454141139984,
0.07251028716564178,
0.7484490275382996,
-0.3586888611316681,
0.5968080163002014,
0.05734594911336899,
-1.3304026126861572,
0.5157893300056458,
-0.3254619538784027,
0.25040650367736816,
0.6612164378166199,
0.15765666961669922,
-0.6587272882461548,
-0.3750818371772766,
-0.8549168109893799,
-0.6837416291236877,
0.5105251669883728,
0.28460338711738586,
0.16606025397777557,
-0.10224690288305283,
0.7515043616294861,
-0.16787028312683105,
0.34697768092155457,
-0.8358947038650513,
-0.21427021920681,
0.08408030867576599,
-0.031446363776922226,
-0.13745352625846863,
-0.5732318162918091,
-0.03957263380289078,
0.0020002485252916813,
1.0226402282714844,
-0.45779797434806824,
0.029867852106690407,
0.7718001008033752,
-0.17690716683864594,
-0.3018644154071808,
0.48599714040756226,
0.7201094031333923,
0.7313456535339355,
-0.12661483883857727,
0.08686090260744095,
0.26132774353027344,
-0.20943838357925415,
0.16197922825813293,
-0.352318674325943,
-0.2945386469364166,
-0.228540301322937,
0.2755819857120514,
0.638896107673645,
0.18554185330867767,
-0.39551305770874023,
0.5900946855545044,
-0.30043044686317444,
0.04731792211532593,
-0.2184520959854126,
0.05677257850766182,
0.025533778592944145,
-0.009629873558878899,
0.41247886419296265,
0.012160750105977058,
0.012327476404607296,
-0.609115481376648,
0.08451063930988312,
0.24650533497333527,
-0.4221837520599365,
-0.2262805849313736,
0.2639079689979553,
0.2635311186313629,
-0.4333481192588806,
0.4307189881801605,
-0.2892153561115265,
-0.541632890701294,
0.28402209281921387,
0.6079885959625244,
0.7346565127372742,
-0.6429110169410706,
0.1279592216014862,
0.3613968789577484,
0.49519193172454834,
-0.3574453890323639,
0.13255377113819122,
0.2489352524280548,
-0.713123619556427,
-0.7497542500495911,
-0.0706624686717987,
-0.8149105310440063,
0.020197881385684013,
-0.6329434514045715,
0.07538511604070663,
-0.6629686951637268,
-0.295716792345047,
-0.4759591817855835,
-0.09408039599657059,
-0.1506022810935974,
0.1986485868692398,
0.12932999432086945,
0.848289430141449,
-0.4275044798851013,
0.6006787419319153,
0.4719005525112152,
-0.12140937149524689,
-0.9681180119514465,
0.23337987065315247,
0.019403915852308273,
-0.8679969310760498,
0.6104918122291565,
0.1164596676826477,
-0.5554330348968506,
0.09149853140115738,
-0.9557027816772461,
-0.8904191851615906,
0.7267123460769653,
0.3766798675060272,
-0.8261655569076538,
0.33009469509124756,
-0.21442534029483795,
0.5127152800559998,
-0.25387585163116455,
0.2927338778972626,
0.3027803897857666,
0.6065818071365356,
0.09102266281843185,
-0.9364042282104492,
-0.26766252517700195,
-0.14159999787807465,
-0.1444336324930191,
-0.009035805240273476,
-0.646960437297821,
1.0213534832000732,
-0.44284000992774963,
-0.0769445076584816,
0.17593075335025787,
0.8518609404563904,
0.09521207958459854,
-0.10990311950445175,
0.565952479839325,
0.21227116882801056,
1.0123323202133179,
-0.15362587571144104,
1.0964552164077759,
-0.5002077221870422,
0.2920733392238617,
1.2995200157165527,
-0.43684160709381104,
1.060076117515564,
0.414016455411911,
-0.08582888543605804,
0.5439145565032959,
0.46174803376197815,
0.3246893584728241,
-0.12441708147525787,
0.011790789663791656,
-0.22188131511211395,
-0.42905735969543457,
-0.07902860641479492,
-0.37748774886131287,
0.35240134596824646,
0.48833268880844116,
-0.1352476328611374,
0.16626088321208954,
-0.19828970730304718,
0.08528344333171844,
-0.021113090217113495,
-0.4482210576534271,
0.6853597164154053,
0.1535230278968811,
-0.9120532274246216,
0.22940249741077423,
0.100032739341259,
0.5480669140815735,
-0.7683203816413879,
0.09253767132759094,
-0.34886622428894043,
0.2133835405111313,
-0.2621202766895294,
-1.0913844108581543,
0.0072804782539606094,
-0.09540730714797974,
-0.2799359858036041,
-0.40309181809425354,
0.749752402305603,
-0.4682936668395996,
-0.30195310711860657,
0.18361809849739075,
0.3966197669506073,
-0.09944256395101547,
-0.3698521554470062,
-0.6825080513954163,
0.06298598647117615,
0.10544443875551224,
-0.06728056073188782,
0.13444387912750244,
0.518738865852356,
0.11062682420015335,
0.859533965587616,
0.7071043848991394,
0.10136506706476212,
-0.12946544587612152,
0.14656580984592438,
0.41450878977775574,
-0.5444915890693665,
-0.4095894992351532,
-0.7986186146736145,
0.5607866048812866,
-0.07859914004802704,
-0.27234596014022827,
1.043194055557251,
0.16472578048706055,
0.6271301507949829,
-0.09388871490955353,
0.7307930588722229,
0.1465224325656891,
0.6054683327674866,
-0.7357534170150757,
0.42456719279289246,
-0.5270077586174011,
0.3836837112903595,
-0.06561899930238724,
-0.653638482093811,
-0.18707647919654846,
0.9761619567871094,
-0.42909443378448486,
0.1391204595565796,
0.7712817192077637,
0.9232650399208069,
0.5311287045478821,
-0.05615270510315895,
0.3857569396495819,
0.7117578387260437,
0.3113020658493042,
0.041480451822280884,
0.9968111515045166,
-0.2190699428319931,
0.23666520416736603,
-0.24406149983406067,
-0.25642234086990356,
-0.3587566018104553,
-1.2654494047164917,
-0.6929548382759094,
-0.4235840439796448,
-0.5859271287918091,
-0.605672299861908,
0.08177578449249268,
1.0175974369049072,
0.6083877682685852,
-0.8451484441757202,
-0.3332274258136749,
-0.06387630105018616,
0.13023178279399872,
0.1513352245092392,
-0.10806381702423096,
0.05860111117362976,
-0.5189023613929749,
-0.8002051711082458,
0.44299018383026123,
0.6504082083702087,
0.37035951018333435,
-0.5599371790885925,
-0.006924500688910484,
0.1383177787065506,
0.23121042549610138,
0.46271616220474243,
0.37238579988479614,
-0.8325324654579163,
-0.35979050397872925,
0.17140325903892517,
-0.37825676798820496,
0.3171069920063019,
0.8599033355712891,
-0.43720436096191406,
0.5355077385902405,
0.36130595207214355,
0.5682392120361328,
0.028378313407301903,
0.018400585278868675,
0.7373598217964172,
-0.688360333442688,
-0.3027700185775757,
0.026010802015662193,
0.6047970652580261,
0.5531168580055237,
-0.5898772478103638,
0.4636632204055786,
0.2049337774515152,
-0.7055981755256653,
-0.6420639753341675,
0.09419461339712143,
-0.8419313430786133,
-0.22872206568717957,
1.2023890018463135,
-0.2014831304550171,
-0.3218814432621002,
0.032762136310338974,
-0.550841748714447,
-0.2969418168067932,
-0.4712776243686676,
0.8831444382667542,
1.0086528062820435,
0.030273424461483955,
-0.15371465682983398,
-0.06645890325307846,
0.2792385518550873,
0.8142621517181396,
-0.6173596382141113,
0.31013187766075134,
0.3038046658039093,
0.28371986746788025,
0.3054543733596802,
0.8024802207946777,
0.09916052967309952,
0.20175431668758392,
-0.2042657881975174,
0.18477725982666016,
0.2705097496509552,
-0.6096597909927368,
-0.7391731142997742,
-0.08703877031803131,
0.5360133051872253,
0.5884370803833008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12560v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12560v1 | CausalGym: Benchmarking causal interpretability methods on linguistic tasks | 2024-02-19T21:35:56 | 2024-02-19T21:35:56 | Aryaman Arora, Dan Jurafsky, Christopher Potts | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Language models (LMs) have proven to be powerful tools for psycholinguistic
research, but most prior work has focused on purely behavioural measures (e.g.,
surprisal comparisons). At the same time, research in model interpretability
has begun to illuminate the abstract causal mechanisms shaping LM behavior. To
help bring these strands of research closer together, we introduce CausalGym.
We adapt and expand the SyntaxGym suite of tasks to benchmark the ability of
interpretability methods to causally affect model behaviour. To illustrate how
CausalGym can be used, we study the pythia models (14M--6.9B) and assess the
causal efficacy of a wide range of interpretability methods, including linear
probing and distributed alignment search (DAS). We find that DAS outperforms
the other methods, and so we use it to study the learning trajectory of two
difficult linguistic phenomena in pythia-1b: negative polarity item licensing
and filler--gap dependencies. Our analysis shows that the mechanism
implementing both of these tasks is learned in discrete stages, not gradually. | [
-0.0014597169356420636,
-0.8414303064346313,
0.6797725558280945,
0.43332305550575256,
0.01560046523809433,
-0.34213539958000183,
-0.39000189304351807,
-0.4230347275733948,
-0.07378826290369034,
0.3612980842590332,
-0.45922061800956726,
-0.24797038733959198,
-0.6744791269302368,
0.04035883769392967,
-0.42137399315834045,
0.8405544757843018,
-0.11651059240102768,
0.17979936301708221,
-0.2552390694618225,
-0.26486268639564514,
-0.8167911767959595,
-0.3770378828048706,
-0.6004078984260559,
-0.7494924664497375,
0.9119682908058167,
0.21158629655838013,
0.8288922309875488,
0.6748082637786865,
0.4307864308357239,
0.267973393201828,
-0.1740085929632187,
-0.2812965214252472,
-0.5041401386260986,
0.21169407665729523,
-0.5710727572441101,
-0.7648061513900757,
-0.17338593304157257,
0.2599102854728699,
0.5973621606826782,
0.9857564568519592,
-0.48826318979263306,
0.1692122220993042,
-0.03901830315589905,
0.35317763686180115,
-0.6532009243965149,
0.39921024441719055,
-0.5026070475578308,
-0.25262561440467834,
-0.23492641746997833,
-0.12932877242565155,
-0.5966182947158813,
-0.5387066602706909,
0.1808915138244629,
-0.6063384413719177,
0.14033488929271698,
0.0756642147898674,
0.7549262642860413,
0.1876673400402069,
-0.5546179413795471,
-0.3775951862335205,
-0.7009304165840149,
0.676382839679718,
-0.7032018899917603,
0.4624726474285126,
0.446777880191803,
0.1649947315454483,
-0.2947206199169159,
-0.8978641033172607,
-0.5365415811538696,
-0.43160679936408997,
-0.42794984579086304,
-0.09939012676477432,
-0.3338152766227722,
0.06244390830397606,
0.5022171139717102,
0.10485857725143433,
-0.6847202777862549,
0.24959757924079895,
-0.3086911737918854,
-0.05181048810482025,
0.5092495679855347,
0.2787679433822632,
0.7007402181625366,
-0.1780644953250885,
-0.2520638704299927,
0.03194832429289818,
-0.7737008929252625,
-0.20877768099308014,
0.5480994582176208,
0.2398311197757721,
0.011843803338706493,
0.488080233335495,
-0.26739707589149475,
0.8825696110725403,
-0.21322934329509735,
0.21209032833576202,
-0.14691919088363647,
-0.26075002551078796,
-0.11843368411064148,
0.00080543925287202,
0.4195355176925659,
0.06351013481616974,
0.1844063699245453,
-0.38548028469085693,
0.07420798391103745,
0.3075536787509918,
0.36256521940231323,
-0.582628071308136,
-0.5764131546020508,
0.06415688246488571,
-0.32118651270866394,
-0.1512918770313263,
-0.22438810765743256,
-0.5652469396591187,
-0.5772879719734192,
-0.5619878172874451,
0.6765621304512024,
-0.20450972020626068,
-0.5645381808280945,
0.28516247868537903,
-0.0019172369502484798,
0.23642374575138092,
0.11652451008558273,
-0.7607440948486328,
0.4543711543083191,
0.8130190372467041,
0.8122434616088867,
-0.0034209340810775757,
-0.6920449137687683,
-0.5504670739173889,
-0.06998047232627869,
-0.30470773577690125,
0.5763123035430908,
-0.24657650291919708,
0.15607836842536926,
0.003354485612362623,
-0.048737600445747375,
-0.5099313855171204,
-0.5908538699150085,
0.5905899405479431,
-0.6280266046524048,
0.13739943504333496,
-0.367911159992218,
-0.7510305047035217,
-0.6522282361984253,
0.011889977380633354,
-0.5250774621963501,
0.7470324635505676,
-0.019324975088238716,
-0.6888531446456909,
0.49263790249824524,
-0.0820767804980278,
-0.3773612678050995,
0.06741832941770554,
-0.08014515042304993,
-0.32918334007263184,
0.3328181207180023,
-0.2777014672756195,
0.385547935962677,
-0.5245953798294067,
0.8307303190231323,
-0.34567633271217346,
-0.42290326952934265,
0.2997913658618927,
-0.4616113007068634,
0.8408740758895874,
-0.16911835968494415,
-0.6218960881233215,
0.29209548234939575,
-0.7412242889404297,
-0.1384480893611908,
0.17666752636432648,
0.00803280621767044,
-0.35203278064727783,
0.5296474695205688,
0.12822291254997253,
0.46051478385925293,
-0.03724875673651695,
-0.049857743084430695,
0.006354485638439655,
-0.4794953465461731,
0.26746124029159546,
0.5458454489707947,
-0.1962212473154068,
0.0914015993475914,
-0.253231942653656,
0.3183537423610687,
-0.028966089710593224,
0.05081535875797272,
0.1274893879890442,
-0.31592223048210144,
-0.8033953905105591,
-0.15226086974143982,
-0.04990200698375702,
0.3857290744781494,
-0.5466234683990479,
0.2774934768676758,
-0.0688091591000557,
-0.7435465455055237,
-0.09755250066518784,
0.01442056242376566,
0.6083045601844788,
0.44760361313819885,
0.2591700553894043,
-0.3878212571144104,
-0.2830392122268677,
-0.7477442026138306,
-0.7825397849082947,
-0.45998939871788025,
0.2735084593296051,
0.17167781293392181,
0.3448047339916229,
0.0033134599216282368,
0.46748414635658264,
-0.5972665548324585,
0.01583162136375904,
-0.27116742730140686,
0.48594051599502563,
0.5039494037628174,
0.2709697186946869,
0.25529617071151733,
-0.5978164076805115,
-0.1620364934206009,
-0.2740478515625,
-0.7606903314590454,
-0.5236944556236267,
-0.1812133640050888,
-0.013832835480570793,
0.021684303879737854,
0.7097566723823547,
-0.7235062122344971,
0.27349939942359924,
0.41174986958503723,
-0.8572850227355957,
0.6754833459854126,
-0.14929452538490295,
-0.026481347158551216,
-0.5010301470756531,
0.2166609913110733,
0.03069395385682583,
-0.08188735693693161,
-0.8261058926582336,
0.2329525202512741,
0.1533541977405548,
0.07203909754753113,
-0.4447176456451416,
0.389120876789093,
-0.4759204685688019,
-0.16995206475257874,
-0.3101974129676819,
0.33918294310569763,
-0.3227849006652832,
0.5346202850341797,
-0.08259930461645126,
0.485507994890213,
0.5756341218948364,
-0.5858235955238342,
0.16839814186096191,
0.10285624861717224,
-0.37540772557258606,
0.6251896619796753,
-0.625860333442688,
-0.15747414529323578,
-0.20237970352172852,
-0.019942106679081917,
-1.1201800107955933,
-0.08939026296138763,
0.3719363510608673,
-0.16404499113559723,
0.2744975984096527,
-0.07751064002513885,
-0.533436119556427,
0.12060956656932831,
0.1373380720615387,
0.6423090100288391,
0.37660685181617737,
-0.6432039141654968,
0.43582287430763245,
-0.049774155020713806,
-0.05559028685092926,
-0.3592356741428375,
-0.23482076823711395,
0.03821048513054848,
-0.5853828191757202,
-0.3433362543582916,
-0.03086385503411293,
0.21584951877593994,
-0.45168182253837585,
-0.044103916734457016,
-0.2227976769208908,
0.30434972047805786,
0.5091300010681152,
0.21686264872550964,
0.08594132959842682,
-0.20586338639259338,
0.08506442606449127,
-0.2939707636833191,
-0.3353784680366516,
0.4024727940559387,
-0.43079274892807007,
0.5873756408691406,
0.2540954053401947,
-0.34298965334892273,
-0.24808776378631592,
-0.14413249492645264,
0.47314366698265076,
-0.06781397014856339,
0.9071373343467712,
0.6287848353385925,
-0.3824753165245056,
-0.18290141224861145,
-0.5350040793418884,
-0.09310727566480637,
-0.3861042261123657,
0.3601495921611786,
-0.18617525696754456,
-0.5982336401939392,
0.4265141785144806,
-0.1263885647058487,
-0.4378063678741455,
0.45243555307388306,
0.5765693187713623,
0.25619426369667053,
0.9967061877250671,
0.4111599624156952,
-0.17489849030971527,
0.5861560106277466,
0.13157592713832855,
0.36867889761924744,
-0.6098020076751709,
-0.14087124168872833,
-0.5496215224266052,
-0.2043447494506836,
-0.8851343393325806,
-0.32083484530448914,
0.3226098120212555,
0.5654946565628052,
-0.201629176735878,
0.5345953702926636,
-0.06312563270330429,
0.3696395456790924,
0.34402403235435486,
0.13284438848495483,
0.3546715974807739,
-0.37863099575042725,
0.008636074140667915,
-0.11837450414896011,
-0.8235808610916138,
-0.2850323021411896,
0.9845688343048096,
0.16963881254196167,
0.7353667616844177,
0.3386659622192383,
0.3069457709789276,
-0.10327029228210449,
0.5628453493118286,
-0.6792554259300232,
0.5250692367553711,
0.09862127155065536,
-0.544944167137146,
-0.20117491483688354,
-0.4649653434753418,
-1.0134358406066895,
0.4812113046646118,
0.0016628862358629704,
-1.1252753734588623,
0.21726921200752258,
0.06985285878181458,
0.0967048853635788,
0.053542185574769974,
-0.6822349429130554,
1.0387568473815918,
-0.23305313289165497,
-0.6614670753479004,
-0.5422071218490601,
-0.6023622751235962,
0.4248507618904114,
0.16710582375526428,
0.14223521947860718,
-0.29221194982528687,
0.22684185206890106,
0.7638745307922363,
-0.0431235246360302,
0.8570104837417603,
-0.17202119529247284,
-0.1388206034898758,
-0.18173353374004364,
0.2892749607563019,
0.5433912873268127,
0.11630479991436005,
0.16801269352436066,
0.2926895320415497,
0.14156071841716766,
-0.4305327832698822,
-0.7249893546104431,
0.7029116153717041,
-0.6187745928764343,
-0.6777558326721191,
-0.6906837821006775,
-0.5942496657371521,
-0.26913881301879883,
0.3078742027282715,
0.0840616449713707,
0.5664199590682983,
-0.2756514251232147,
-0.19972941279411316,
0.5714902281761169,
-0.24846990406513214,
0.38809752464294434,
0.7590194344520569,
-0.3779107928276062,
-0.20427006483078003,
0.948907196521759,
0.08691126853227615,
0.38568630814552307,
0.3165942132472992,
0.3367690145969391,
-0.1854589581489563,
-0.6261780261993408,
-0.1303914487361908,
0.3533349931240082,
-0.7437357902526855,
-0.017021898180246353,
-0.4242582619190216,
0.044870778918266296,
-0.018052000552415848,
0.040493451058864594,
-0.13330623507499695,
-0.2934919595718384,
-0.19188255071640015,
-0.030891982838511467,
0.23056660592556,
0.8465895652770996,
-0.07848823070526123,
0.3363232910633087,
-0.27526596188545227,
0.2355303317308426,
0.2120032161474228,
0.4009149968624115,
0.17534638941287994,
-0.3021746277809143,
-0.28567203879356384,
-0.23318134248256683,
-0.23191986978054047,
-1.1009612083435059,
0.2641448378562927,
-0.06425168365240097,
0.5299420356750488,
0.23872604966163635,
-0.38561248779296875,
0.6119735240936279,
-0.438347727060318,
0.6217002272605896,
0.11675156652927399,
-1.0676823854446411,
0.3687056303024292,
-0.5555410981178284,
0.10101917386054993,
0.30070260167121887,
0.44627973437309265,
-0.7618725299835205,
-0.476678729057312,
-0.6547986268997192,
-0.9950457811355591,
0.8389769792556763,
0.3663271963596344,
-0.2529284954071045,
0.042973101139068604,
0.418826162815094,
0.05558772385120392,
0.055567678064107895,
-0.5822163224220276,
-0.33033233880996704,
0.2774002254009247,
-0.2505991458892822,
-0.7042238712310791,
-0.26088857650756836,
-0.0695890337228775,
-0.26148906350135803,
0.6333929896354675,
0.029808668419718742,
-0.05314968153834343,
0.16777390241622925,
-0.576610803604126,
-0.0886773020029068,
0.12727147340774536,
0.5324194431304932,
1.0261898040771484,
-0.03683280944824219,
0.35115861892700195,
-0.09815241396427155,
-0.3003649413585663,
0.20456571877002716,
0.37375664710998535,
-0.27294230461120605,
-0.03983660787343979,
0.627228856086731,
0.942685067653656,
0.6024422645568848,
-0.6059703230857849,
0.31469258666038513,
0.02125185914337635,
0.17341835796833038,
-0.09644924104213715,
0.008446465246379375,
0.12983964383602142,
0.4354531466960907,
-0.04075643792748451,
-0.2692911922931671,
0.3570306897163391,
-0.6536828875541687,
0.12495055794715881,
0.17085999250411987,
-0.46789461374282837,
-0.5165994763374329,
0.7233949303627014,
-0.19280728697776794,
-0.250011682510376,
0.5691363215446472,
-0.18674224615097046,
-0.4694138765335083,
0.6082143783569336,
0.6453938484191895,
0.8835861682891846,
-0.22291728854179382,
0.2846122086048126,
0.3452380299568176,
0.42446091771125793,
-0.40727561712265015,
0.328957736492157,
0.04813985154032707,
-0.6650000810623169,
-0.30644720792770386,
-0.3655763268470764,
-0.3055545389652252,
0.0072698649019002914,
-0.9889691472053528,
0.3120327591896057,
0.034255851060152054,
0.15371114015579224,
0.25157296657562256,
-0.1017078161239624,
-0.7036280035972595,
0.2301551103591919,
-0.13560795783996582,
0.5300549864768982,
-1.2027702331542969,
0.49956372380256653,
0.6482114791870117,
-0.5727366805076599,
-1.0282107591629028,
0.15244325995445251,
0.1402749866247177,
-0.7451735138893127,
0.48985525965690613,
0.03738876432180405,
0.11530549824237823,
0.18906445801258087,
-0.26789093017578125,
-0.8156281113624573,
0.9566340446472168,
0.3542059361934662,
-0.6065929532051086,
0.17761032283306122,
-0.032595958560705185,
0.6164013743400574,
0.21720761060714722,
0.48013272881507874,
0.9765726327896118,
0.37232404947280884,
-0.34563127160072327,
-0.8743284344673157,
0.35151252150535583,
0.10208189487457275,
-0.04386291652917862,
0.5183351635932922,
-0.46837756037712097,
0.7242721915245056,
0.08790218085050583,
-0.24508868157863617,
0.10554762184619904,
0.3460465967655182,
0.20605844259262085,
0.4690624177455902,
0.3547012209892273,
0.6084462404251099,
0.7479726076126099,
-0.17220085859298706,
0.8599655032157898,
-0.1933908611536026,
0.6431843638420105,
1.090707778930664,
-0.2994661033153534,
0.7038431763648987,
0.7151369452476501,
-0.2113456428050995,
0.43591880798339844,
0.4594203233718872,
0.2306917905807495,
0.4402202367782593,
0.6819073557853699,
-0.2034720927476883,
-0.21582789719104767,
-0.14036069810390472,
-0.006979001220315695,
0.44582289457321167,
0.3201234042644501,
-0.15721359848976135,
-0.2911408841609955,
-0.15213195979595184,
0.15065908432006836,
0.22799824178218842,
-0.23825103044509888,
0.8149427771568298,
0.24340814352035522,
-0.7361730337142944,
0.340231716632843,
0.031859882175922394,
0.35373860597610474,
-0.5195701718330383,
0.036770205944776535,
-0.3223448693752289,
0.25861573219299316,
-0.22620274126529694,
-0.4308789074420929,
0.38658514618873596,
-0.36350783705711365,
0.02665950544178486,
-0.1477275788784027,
0.7824500203132629,
-0.6275553703308105,
-0.3327593505382538,
0.5688226819038391,
0.7347873449325562,
-0.03441016003489494,
0.10353866964578629,
-0.29217851161956787,
0.025690700858831406,
-0.5462267398834229,
-0.21027836203575134,
0.35031527280807495,
0.3086765706539154,
-0.22520431876182556,
0.6294693946838379,
0.3210342526435852,
0.4443530738353729,
-0.03749240189790726,
0.1824248880147934,
0.5079277157783508,
-0.7700325846672058,
-0.3488783836364746,
-1.0847934484481812,
0.28281769156455994,
0.24614299833774567,
-0.325100302696228,
0.9636146426200867,
0.26431453227996826,
1.0286612510681152,
0.04869828000664711,
0.31593701243400574,
-0.11354772001504898,
0.1657329648733139,
-0.7160232067108154,
0.7758338451385498,
-0.3796132504940033,
0.18538407981395721,
-0.3048005998134613,
-0.8944909572601318,
-0.3219544589519501,
0.4045107066631317,
-0.5387094616889954,
-0.04500328749418259,
1.0033934116363525,
0.7676440477371216,
-0.13683882355690002,
0.07630546391010284,
0.3124645948410034,
0.4649369716644287,
0.09886981546878815,
0.5439119338989258,
1.1970794200897217,
-0.46208474040031433,
0.08776067197322845,
-0.05285391956567764,
-0.06243133172392845,
-0.029893221333622932,
-0.8377223014831543,
-0.8493696451187134,
-0.5437450408935547,
-0.5862877368927002,
-0.4160885810852051,
0.20677782595157623,
0.6780514717102051,
0.4837406575679779,
-0.6528647541999817,
-0.5110177397727966,
-0.5357900857925415,
0.5584620833396912,
-0.6393061280250549,
-0.2282465696334839,
0.3118918538093567,
-0.4842836260795593,
-0.28795742988586426,
0.2766152322292328,
0.18010346591472626,
-0.5145094394683838,
-0.15386831760406494,
0.06183624267578125,
-0.34251055121421814,
0.0825936570763588,
0.3420708477497101,
0.1762954443693161,
-0.8150741457939148,
-0.3965662717819214,
-0.28264206647872925,
0.11121684312820435,
-0.17173081636428833,
1.2609387636184692,
-0.43034327030181885,
0.5173372030258179,
0.5876227021217346,
0.38933292031288147,
0.42074522376060486,
-0.261966347694397,
0.763965368270874,
-0.4134558141231537,
0.07630190998315811,
0.04577651992440224,
0.30602914094924927,
0.1277041882276535,
-0.17347808182239532,
0.44644999504089355,
0.46304771304130554,
-0.5346004366874695,
-0.8777675628662109,
0.31571877002716064,
-0.6697462797164917,
-0.16982463002204895,
1.138602614402771,
-0.22104261815547943,
0.17939507961273193,
-0.2092418521642685,
0.023713361471891403,
0.488288015127182,
0.26718366146087646,
0.8740992546081543,
0.8209706544876099,
-0.05032312497496605,
-0.0479043684899807,
-0.675477921962738,
0.5790066123008728,
0.7967427968978882,
-0.7059561610221863,
0.17900840938091278,
0.5124443173408508,
0.47222429513931274,
-0.09339596331119537,
0.4890037477016449,
0.016475889831781387,
0.3478604853153229,
0.03084893524646759,
-0.154978409409523,
0.2633015513420105,
-0.4331410825252533,
-0.8269879221916199,
-0.05085686966776848,
0.3962181806564331,
0.18313172459602356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12557v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12557v1 | Creating a Fine Grained Entity Type Taxonomy Using LLMs | 2024-02-19T21:32:19 | 2024-02-19T21:32:19 | Michael Gunn, Dohyun Park, Nidhish Kamath | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, we investigate the potential of GPT-4 and its advanced
iteration, GPT-4 Turbo, in autonomously developing a detailed entity type
taxonomy. Our objective is to construct a comprehensive taxonomy, starting from
a broad classification of entity types - including objects, time, locations,
organizations, events, actions, and subjects - similar to existing manually
curated taxonomies. This classification is then progressively refined through
iterative prompting techniques, leveraging GPT-4's internal knowledge base. The
result is an extensive taxonomy comprising over 5000 nuanced entity types,
which demonstrates remarkable quality upon subjective evaluation.
We employed a straightforward yet effective prompting strategy, enabling the
taxonomy to be dynamically expanded. The practical applications of this
detailed taxonomy are diverse and significant. It facilitates the creation of
new, more intricate branches through pattern-based combinations and notably
enhances information extraction tasks, such as relation extraction and event
argument extraction. Our methodology not only introduces an innovative approach
to taxonomy creation but also opens new avenues for applying such taxonomies in
various computational linguistics and AI-related fields. | [
-0.6682051420211792,
-0.8111952543258667,
0.8000509142875671,
0.10148419439792633,
-0.3392132818698883,
0.4215124845504761,
-0.34183067083358765,
-0.3398706316947937,
0.23957066237926483,
0.21800488233566284,
-0.3787011504173279,
-0.5588473081588745,
-0.2616882622241974,
0.2257809340953827,
-0.34651076793670654,
1.1462781429290771,
-0.17416273057460785,
-0.2892625033855438,
-0.05959802120923996,
0.21766524016857147,
-0.18960313498973846,
-0.41473352909088135,
-0.8345697522163391,
-0.15171465277671814,
0.6317210793495178,
0.4249539077281952,
0.4233115017414093,
0.7886099815368652,
0.633219301700592,
0.3085476756095886,
0.0923871248960495,
0.30305391550064087,
-0.3220233917236328,
0.18148396909236908,
-0.3292240500450134,
-0.34414976835250854,
-0.6403026580810547,
-0.15288081765174866,
0.5385422110557556,
0.42884182929992676,
-0.31853610277175903,
0.290010541677475,
0.08144659548997879,
0.16503028571605682,
-0.3617832064628601,
0.40009400248527527,
-0.883163571357727,
0.08831857889890671,
-0.7530097961425781,
-0.5397994518280029,
-0.00006045657937647775,
-0.06110772490501404,
0.22525151073932648,
-0.6518992185592651,
0.16065143048763275,
-0.09892481565475464,
0.8712833523750305,
0.29282939434051514,
-0.2992587685585022,
-0.5049025416374207,
-0.8238405585289001,
0.4135670065879822,
-0.5184933543205261,
0.2596587836742401,
-0.08105450868606567,
0.37202736735343933,
0.0163850300014019,
-1.2551904916763306,
-0.2378406971693039,
-0.13183876872062683,
0.24249885976314545,
0.13728970289230347,
-0.09086014330387115,
0.24852849543094635,
0.03514432534575462,
0.5176733732223511,
-0.36368468403816223,
0.29128849506378174,
-0.20452621579170227,
-0.13104042410850525,
0.38085639476776123,
0.46993201971054077,
0.1058206707239151,
-0.12534506618976593,
-0.23594757914543152,
0.6231322884559631,
-0.7668384313583374,
-0.11933234333992004,
0.29114481806755066,
0.28182679414749146,
0.223469540476799,
0.6498512625694275,
-0.34020134806632996,
0.43136462569236755,
0.08462411910295486,
-0.28310850262641907,
0.028850194066762924,
-0.3854706585407257,
-0.23350505530834198,
-0.11866305023431778,
0.8092250823974609,
0.21962378919124603,
0.16617918014526367,
-0.489483118057251,
-0.39038172364234924,
0.09630551934242249,
0.3392484188079834,
-0.7800212502479553,
-0.1744007021188736,
0.2849239706993103,
-0.22004790604114532,
-0.4443056881427765,
-0.27083268761634827,
-0.8215876221656799,
-0.05671621859073639,
-0.5176368355751038,
0.27517005801200867,
-0.5321966409683228,
-0.2499697506427765,
-0.04407481104135513,
0.0189110916107893,
0.4050002992153168,
0.4648289382457733,
-0.9902121424674988,
0.35237085819244385,
0.9109997749328613,
0.895769476890564,
-0.4156160354614258,
-0.09368947148323059,
-0.21109639108181,
0.4963388741016388,
-0.23479318618774414,
1.0727988481521606,
-0.7402637004852295,
-0.41672664880752563,
-0.14182697236537933,
-0.418318510055542,
0.4393203854560852,
-0.6364101767539978,
0.5130623579025269,
-0.6351486444473267,
-0.005980048794299364,
0.006001268979161978,
-0.7747834920883179,
-0.18794016540050507,
0.6122015714645386,
-0.4567273259162903,
0.9945518374443054,
0.20769643783569336,
-0.6826037764549255,
0.5013365149497986,
-0.7932375073432922,
-0.16089323163032532,
0.7887063026428223,
-0.6800557374954224,
-0.15197843313217163,
0.1352497786283493,
0.04292842373251915,
0.544814944267273,
-0.3679508864879608,
0.7174676060676575,
-0.26886865496635437,
-0.07143273949623108,
-0.1348010152578354,
-0.11565324664115906,
0.2351195216178894,
0.21578389406204224,
-0.38500332832336426,
0.14107002317905426,
-0.7055057883262634,
0.024061204865574837,
0.02616552822291851,
-0.3097700774669647,
-0.32638776302337646,
-0.019654083997011185,
-0.3364487886428833,
0.04867072030901909,
0.3688843250274658,
-0.14672519266605377,
0.6749100089073181,
-0.18803828954696655,
0.6630410552024841,
0.7012759447097778,
0.43693676590919495,
0.5631328225135803,
-0.08437927812337875,
0.5902084112167358,
0.07016836106777191,
0.03721889108419418,
-0.126348614692688,
-0.5724719762802124,
-0.6559627056121826,
-0.384799987077713,
0.3527250289916992,
0.42333102226257324,
-0.8615432381629944,
0.41548559069633484,
-0.4540514349937439,
-0.5597941875457764,
-0.1533069759607315,
-0.12658479809761047,
0.06212279573082924,
0.6023364663124084,
0.265785813331604,
-0.34387725591659546,
-0.4151039719581604,
-0.9163476228713989,
-0.1108354851603508,
-0.1324014663696289,
-0.05030185729265213,
0.2883279621601105,
0.42000389099121094,
-0.529529869556427,
1.0992310047149658,
-0.4864445626735687,
-0.17025601863861084,
0.07382060587406158,
0.20869503915309906,
-0.05207951366901398,
0.2834163010120392,
0.4655195474624634,
-0.529700517654419,
-0.19003169238567352,
-0.04224982112646103,
-0.628778338432312,
0.10181018710136414,
-0.05996153503656387,
-0.26823022961616516,
-0.03713966906070709,
0.20872078835964203,
-0.6520124077796936,
0.0849304124712944,
-0.22558265924453735,
0.024694344028830528,
0.5674306154251099,
0.14566439390182495,
-0.15732750296592712,
-1.11806058883667,
-0.26334935426712036,
0.01131258811801672,
-0.09803184121847153,
-0.6415773630142212,
0.26407143473625183,
-0.0704505667090416,
0.20012035965919495,
-0.35106217861175537,
0.5381983518600464,
-0.5050352215766907,
-0.4332694709300995,
0.09039521962404251,
0.14020618796348572,
-0.1767139732837677,
0.37815991044044495,
0.07240074127912521,
0.7163376212120056,
0.8793975710868835,
-0.9512283802032471,
0.40094974637031555,
0.094655342400074,
-0.10358971357345581,
0.5069909691810608,
-0.27042824029922485,
0.104749895632267,
-0.024774465709924698,
0.13357630372047424,
-0.42260751128196716,
-0.45804497599601746,
0.22789190709590912,
-0.22148030996322632,
0.48946255445480347,
-0.2686358094215393,
-0.6743050813674927,
-0.4235113859176636,
-0.3297094404697418,
0.28438326716423035,
0.305459588766098,
-0.36095142364501953,
0.6822410225868225,
0.4399241507053375,
-0.42557671666145325,
-0.09625926613807678,
-0.43055880069732666,
0.3377048671245575,
-0.6446899771690369,
-0.4973278045654297,
0.6665178537368774,
-0.07879979908466339,
-0.3878234326839447,
0.15580743551254272,
-0.2487085908651352,
-0.1544840931892395,
0.22795134782791138,
-0.1723392754793167,
0.2431963086128235,
-0.4207104742527008,
0.10215490311384201,
0.09483131766319275,
0.15506234765052795,
0.08575870841741562,
-0.5354570150375366,
0.6498730778694153,
-0.4159090518951416,
-0.1302708089351654,
-0.3194911479949951,
0.21102198958396912,
0.21640481054782867,
-0.3301878571510315,
-0.08019233494997025,
0.5806034803390503,
-0.6023146510124207,
-0.20864476263523102,
-0.43983256816864014,
-0.08752156049013138,
-0.5011938214302063,
0.2526387870311737,
-0.7839131355285645,
-1.2808887958526611,
0.5851021409034729,
-0.3793775737285614,
0.16611391305923462,
0.4674947261810303,
0.8268287777900696,
0.2186189889907837,
0.565627932548523,
0.41673943400382996,
0.08267736434936523,
0.25160568952560425,
-0.31095027923583984,
0.11154044419527054,
-0.8157680034637451,
-0.34688976407051086,
-0.3856230676174164,
-0.12671342492103577,
-0.9315219521522522,
-0.5176637172698975,
0.2001934051513672,
0.14588883519172668,
-0.5147547721862793,
0.061674896627664566,
-0.7596938014030457,
0.28645363450050354,
0.41382014751434326,
-0.14379315078258514,
0.48630788922309875,
-0.10036579519510269,
-0.11839935928583145,
0.13124100863933563,
-0.35600000619888306,
-0.860904335975647,
1.0850166082382202,
0.3831694722175598,
0.6806273460388184,
0.13719119131565094,
1.2204376459121704,
0.09683028608560562,
0.6046282052993774,
-1.2090510129928589,
0.5505574345588684,
0.015721755102276802,
-0.4242939352989197,
-0.18488995730876923,
-0.4093937575817108,
-0.7373505234718323,
-0.08108072727918625,
0.23093414306640625,
-0.8310436010360718,
0.02202293463051319,
0.05130081996321678,
-0.6732901334762573,
0.2653977572917938,
-0.43865224719047546,
0.4622291624546051,
-0.49594584107398987,
-0.13369649648666382,
0.25272080302238464,
-0.4027678072452545,
0.6780962347984314,
-0.4397377669811249,
0.16084447503089905,
-0.16416782140731812,
-0.65220707654953,
0.6147939562797546,
-0.21663615107536316,
0.46419966220855713,
-0.024273760616779327,
-0.4272311329841614,
0.5425949692726135,
0.2593971788883209,
0.4637521505355835,
0.5953559279441833,
0.11138986796140671,
0.10932400077581406,
-0.31170663237571716,
-0.06583103537559509,
-0.607547402381897,
0.7382329702377319,
-0.6074244379997253,
-0.6853448748588562,
-0.20382151007652283,
-0.32403501868247986,
-0.5026591420173645,
0.4108577370643616,
0.14345723390579224,
0.4591970145702362,
-0.10962672531604767,
-0.20060504972934723,
0.5930717587471008,
0.06180722266435623,
0.5674751400947571,
0.4945734143257141,
-0.288897842168808,
-0.4630829095840454,
0.9514997601509094,
0.21187609434127808,
-0.014160417020320892,
0.4230043292045593,
0.047611139714717865,
-0.33811378479003906,
-0.9894772171974182,
-0.4803103506565094,
0.05213811993598938,
-0.46673691272735596,
-0.5806847214698792,
-0.7055315375328064,
-0.1572515070438385,
-0.47644904255867004,
-0.10599207133054733,
-0.20738595724105835,
-0.4586945176124573,
-0.531836211681366,
-0.16010907292366028,
0.4466075897216797,
1.018042802810669,
0.23928257822990417,
0.33046022057533264,
-0.8472660183906555,
0.3186325430870056,
0.36500072479248047,
0.6139400601387024,
-0.2039785385131836,
-0.3009662330150604,
0.1180192157626152,
-0.30690091848373413,
-0.4296804666519165,
-0.6864847540855408,
0.36593011021614075,
0.3218640983104706,
0.6800175309181213,
0.4877239763736725,
-0.2009173482656479,
0.851436972618103,
-0.8223394155502319,
1.0566033124923706,
-0.035658713430166245,
-0.8743593096733093,
0.5438717007637024,
-0.7245099544525146,
-0.030184010043740273,
0.49093207716941833,
0.5268375277519226,
-0.14373058080673218,
-0.4105854034423828,
-0.941666841506958,
-1.1150643825531006,
0.4596847593784332,
0.25879594683647156,
-0.022068651393055916,
-0.15865354239940643,
0.8482826948165894,
0.13094402849674225,
0.39971601963043213,
-0.42726796865463257,
-0.4194236695766449,
-0.24553383886814117,
-0.1351451426744461,
0.09221746027469635,
-0.18433822691440582,
-0.09138283878564835,
-0.07890670746564865,
0.5629570484161377,
-0.3437965512275696,
0.4195587933063507,
0.03960924968123436,
0.004294738173484802,
0.2788781225681305,
0.45543384552001953,
0.7201415300369263,
0.6766899228096008,
-0.14852796494960785,
0.31390976905822754,
0.005373905412852764,
-0.3998546600341797,
-0.024527227506041527,
0.3244221806526184,
-0.12048011273145676,
-0.014805966056883335,
0.14314506947994232,
0.6447916626930237,
0.18754829466342926,
-0.2148170918226242,
0.12495743483304977,
-0.005662128794938326,
-0.23160994052886963,
-0.3027893602848053,
-0.00422662403434515,
0.2873239815235138,
0.29714521765708923,
0.36236485838890076,
-0.2501831650733948,
0.5151629447937012,
-0.5560497641563416,
0.4988119900226593,
0.3875690996646881,
-0.06435246020555496,
-0.36866700649261475,
0.5629445910453796,
0.2589632272720337,
-0.1393381506204605,
0.2854228913784027,
-0.6107208728790283,
-0.41851839423179626,
0.4779784679412842,
0.4123247265815735,
0.8986992835998535,
-0.057060763239860535,
0.06286880373954773,
0.2015077769756317,
0.15619315207004547,
-0.12985573709011078,
0.2447470724582672,
-0.11394523084163666,
-0.8031399846076965,
-0.3034835755825043,
-0.8779854774475098,
-0.4604753255844116,
0.34238433837890625,
-0.556679904460907,
0.4134143590927124,
-0.4977722764015198,
-0.2515941560268402,
0.3130098581314087,
0.11806502938270569,
-0.6325376629829407,
0.08547653257846832,
0.3002670407295227,
1.058290719985962,
-0.21786142885684967,
0.7072302103042603,
0.9875222444534302,
-0.6778784394264221,
-1.0551306009292603,
0.10427988320589066,
0.10292957723140717,
-0.842258632183075,
0.49725577235221863,
0.03664727136492729,
0.09439482539892197,
0.3882882595062256,
-0.4935736060142517,
-1.0695960521697998,
1.379531741142273,
0.003850688226521015,
-0.6949511170387268,
-0.474231094121933,
0.06722477078437805,
0.5082595944404602,
-0.6006278991699219,
0.3278048038482666,
0.9133779406547546,
0.5828859806060791,
0.1724146455526352,
-0.742804765701294,
0.001494330121204257,
0.023827431723475456,
0.21767382323741913,
0.34019654989242554,
-0.6377993822097778,
0.7716418504714966,
0.026821419596672058,
-0.28654345870018005,
0.014723711647093296,
0.7856149077415466,
0.21264562010765076,
0.0936160683631897,
0.2976612150669098,
0.6561942100524902,
0.9752649068832397,
-0.2395671010017395,
0.7043519616127014,
-0.4001608192920685,
0.5639809370040894,
1.2888661623001099,
-0.37696024775505066,
0.3324344754219055,
0.19947636127471924,
-0.14953848719596863,
0.3733005225658417,
1.1955969333648682,
-0.17673857510089874,
0.3271903395652771,
0.3491572141647339,
-0.5608436465263367,
-0.1267222911119461,
-0.015196891501545906,
-0.22473539412021637,
0.4888666272163391,
0.8948865532875061,
-0.07260185480117798,
-0.6063385605812073,
-0.1554248183965683,
0.06691616773605347,
-0.5179725289344788,
-0.7861320376396179,
1.0475175380706787,
0.14092902839183807,
-0.6345146298408508,
0.26179057359695435,
0.009823710657656193,
0.9081085920333862,
-0.3384130001068115,
0.09824442863464355,
-0.1379774510860443,
-0.23906660079956055,
-0.3593086302280426,
-1.1370257139205933,
0.2170633226633072,
0.16456429660320282,
0.21547815203666687,
-0.1642581969499588,
0.7985796332359314,
-0.47568002343177795,
-0.12377741932868958,
-0.012195345014333725,
0.6141098141670227,
0.3120630085468292,
-0.09335952252149582,
-0.6553800106048584,
-0.22188326716423035,
-0.0929996520280838,
-0.409713476896286,
0.12808765470981598,
1.061248779296875,
-0.44629183411598206,
0.5771904587745667,
0.3010651171207428,
0.06644194573163986,
0.18362775444984436,
0.2215030938386917,
1.056795358657837,
-0.8047639727592468,
-0.20559976994991302,
-0.9042606353759766,
0.3288195729255676,
0.09938012808561325,
-0.1955878883600235,
0.5165878534317017,
0.9058718085289001,
0.7500379085540771,
0.0732199177145958,
0.989020049571991,
-0.17034709453582764,
0.2103988379240036,
-0.298517107963562,
0.18752440810203552,
-0.32759952545166016,
0.21047690510749817,
-0.21024921536445618,
-0.8535866737365723,
-0.4242073893547058,
0.06288061290979385,
-0.016993822529911995,
0.03819822892546654,
0.6595333218574524,
0.4259687066078186,
-0.007751543540507555,
0.05421426519751549,
0.17514656484127045,
0.19856566190719604,
0.7047410011291504,
0.1930781900882721,
0.8911296725273132,
0.21755479276180267,
0.4827079474925995,
-0.19433845579624176,
-0.3818632662296295,
-0.0658135861158371,
-0.9412760734558105,
-0.4957332909107208,
-0.44737598299980164,
-0.3737306296825409,
-0.0957651287317276,
-0.1566120833158493,
0.7829742431640625,
0.31230834126472473,
-0.46422702074050903,
0.09522972255945206,
-0.3660445511341095,
-0.08134892582893372,
0.38126182556152344,
-0.31867438554763794,
0.10619983822107315,
-0.8555012941360474,
-0.6834803223609924,
0.23265618085861206,
0.651820957660675,
0.19782252609729767,
-0.31541118025779724,
0.28688305616378784,
0.09221262484788895,
-0.09207291901111603,
0.769054651260376,
0.14648303389549255,
-0.8623642325401306,
-0.30638888478279114,
-0.02315097488462925,
0.002842012094333768,
0.15656678378582,
0.9447044730186462,
-0.6020524501800537,
0.12472865730524063,
0.14702020585536957,
0.7792226076126099,
0.5312705039978027,
0.029392646625638008,
0.47600820660591125,
-0.67356938123703,
-0.3353070616722107,
0.5047798752784729,
0.45935699343681335,
0.18585777282714844,
-0.577862024307251,
0.6606963872909546,
0.3150399327278137,
-0.5518804788589478,
-0.548366904258728,
0.3673800826072693,
-1.33319091796875,
-0.05789319425821304,
1.368092656135559,
0.07418115437030792,
-0.09800497442483902,
-0.15389661490917206,
-0.08735699951648712,
0.2350107878446579,
-0.6613787412643433,
0.5630409121513367,
0.5770757794380188,
-0.7050082683563232,
-0.07097481936216354,
-0.4044914245605469,
0.7744365334510803,
-0.41356945037841797,
-1.2392505407333374,
-0.1408354640007019,
0.4466765522956848,
0.4953940510749817,
0.39484959840774536,
0.870817244052887,
-0.2707396149635315,
-0.1124594435095787,
-0.4081752598285675,
0.23390552401542664,
0.07037881016731262,
-0.22066915035247803,
-0.24217619001865387,
0.17447519302368164,
0.15364444255828857,
0.14280100166797638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12556v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12556v1 | IMBUE: Improving Interpersonal Effectiveness through Simulation and Just-in-time Feedback with Human-Language Model Interaction | 2024-02-19T21:31:11 | 2024-02-19T21:31:11 | Inna Wanyin Lin, Ashish Sharma, Christopher Michael Rytting, Adam S. Miner, Jina Suh, Tim Althoff | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | Navigating certain communication situations can be challenging due to
individuals' lack of skills and the interference of strong emotions. However,
effective learning opportunities are rarely accessible. In this work, we
conduct a human-centered study that uses language models to simulate bespoke
communication training and provide just-in-time feedback to support the
practice and learning of interpersonal effectiveness skills. We apply the
interpersonal effectiveness framework from Dialectical Behavioral Therapy
(DBT), DEAR MAN, which focuses on both conversational and emotional skills. We
present IMBUE, an interactive training system that provides feedback 25% more
similar to experts' feedback, compared to that generated by GPT-4. IMBUE is the
first to focus on communication skills and emotion management simultaneously,
incorporate experts' domain knowledge in providing feedback, and be grounded in
psychology theory. Through a randomized trial of 86 participants, we find that
IMBUE's simulation-only variant significantly improves participants'
self-efficacy (up to 17%) and reduces negative emotions (up to 25%). With
IMBUE's additional just-in-time feedback, participants demonstrate 17%
improvement in skill mastery, along with greater enhancements in self-efficacy
(27% more) and reduction of negative emotions (16% more) compared to
simulation-only. The improvement in skill mastery is the only measure that is
transferred to new and more difficult situations; situation specific training
is necessary for improving self-efficacy and emotion reduction. | [
-0.49242815375328064,
-1.16120445728302,
0.06446430832147598,
0.8693064451217651,
-0.08973697572946548,
0.5975333452224731,
-0.4047948718070984,
-0.4576343595981598,
0.4622190594673157,
-0.1874447911977768,
-0.4742361605167389,
0.0572570264339447,
-0.5798842906951904,
-0.009759744629263878,
-0.2512408494949341,
0.6672972440719604,
0.2555314004421234,
0.4818793535232544,
0.18729016184806824,
0.0616108700633049,
-0.43766140937805176,
-0.8446118831634521,
-0.6872106194496155,
-0.8867995142936707,
0.169636070728302,
0.6452921032905579,
0.2654142379760742,
-0.15785881876945496,
0.5197646617889404,
0.2648185193538666,
0.043845582753419876,
-0.1783209890127182,
-0.7777990698814392,
-0.1327124834060669,
-0.4177156090736389,
-0.2281953990459442,
-0.3886520266532898,
0.275057315826416,
0.43488648533821106,
0.42175397276878357,
-0.7360146045684814,
-0.03992548584938049,
0.5221654772758484,
0.3495510220527649,
-0.5694556832313538,
0.005654120817780495,
-0.3414309322834015,
0.011352257803082466,
0.04126366972923279,
-0.25086748600006104,
-0.36240822076797485,
-0.4045517146587372,
0.19247595965862274,
-0.2310331165790558,
-0.20660191774368286,
0.0349126011133194,
0.8397414684295654,
-0.1332281082868576,
-0.42063552141189575,
-0.07759518176317215,
-0.880284309387207,
0.36868414282798767,
-1.208748459815979,
0.26582595705986023,
0.2256687581539154,
0.197624072432518,
-0.36242032051086426,
-0.27082914113998413,
-0.5159897208213806,
-0.6297042369842529,
0.023087063804268837,
0.5955747961997986,
-0.01948309876024723,
0.4212283492088318,
0.387309193611145,
0.06884549558162689,
-0.03420061618089676,
0.08481995761394501,
-0.2599423825740814,
0.09425105154514313,
0.6638518571853638,
-0.06047825887799263,
0.19490794837474823,
0.03714028000831604,
-0.19068937003612518,
-0.10651465505361557,
-0.3876523971557617,
0.2377176135778427,
0.1100618839263916,
-0.25573381781578064,
-0.23574411869049072,
0.3933963179588318,
-0.28409215807914734,
0.19432978332042694,
0.38678616285324097,
-0.5008825659751892,
-0.24188020825386047,
-0.08410615473985672,
0.022672254592180252,
0.002036303048953414,
0.520271360874176,
0.348000168800354,
0.3941453695297241,
-0.46849989891052246,
0.041189223527908325,
0.08597590029239655,
0.6342232823371887,
-1.2342995405197144,
-0.2163725644350052,
0.09882223606109619,
-0.4173083007335663,
-0.36494946479797363,
0.1552828699350357,
-0.7767597436904907,
-0.05664242058992386,
-0.4711759090423584,
0.48783114552497864,
-0.5603805780410767,
-0.7510921955108643,
-0.15479250252246857,
0.07803402096033096,
0.18633024394512177,
0.44969886541366577,
-0.8253857493400574,
0.6746503114700317,
0.30622735619544983,
0.8430742025375366,
0.08138425648212433,
-0.2818722426891327,
-0.4800267219543457,
-0.008439094759523869,
-0.24150681495666504,
0.7013996839523315,
-0.5139698386192322,
-0.5603049993515015,
-0.11252585798501968,
-0.1703874170780182,
0.020246723666787148,
-0.7075186371803284,
0.2335343062877655,
0.0020369228441268206,
0.13504889607429504,
-0.07112311571836472,
-0.8264698386192322,
-0.09102685004472733,
0.48544538021087646,
0.05678800866007805,
0.8545187711715698,
0.38633543252944946,
-0.31298068165779114,
0.09871898591518402,
-0.8831780552864075,
-0.3734875023365021,
0.01971866376698017,
-0.08261715620756149,
-0.26753103733062744,
0.32130980491638184,
-0.13964076340198517,
0.21780288219451904,
-0.1530933976173401,
0.07840627431869507,
-0.6375138163566589,
-0.575714111328125,
0.4014345109462738,
-0.07313638180494308,
0.3309601843357086,
0.10574942082166672,
-0.7158360481262207,
-0.13551266491413116,
-0.6955474019050598,
0.5183166861534119,
-0.06142427772283554,
-0.49957275390625,
-0.057988863438367844,
-0.3888276219367981,
0.15231886506080627,
0.23479017615318298,
-0.2740020453929901,
-0.7462753057479858,
0.21167735755443573,
-0.31320086121559143,
0.09660249203443527,
0.6627165675163269,
0.2507842183113098,
0.3719094395637512,
-0.2930675446987152,
0.8062950968742371,
0.08365491777658463,
0.2954067885875702,
0.09036217629909515,
-0.0800088569521904,
-0.5053573250770569,
-0.25165867805480957,
0.2661496102809906,
0.7477847933769226,
-0.6512433290481567,
0.12319190055131912,
-0.06581639498472214,
-0.5406007170677185,
-0.6310890316963196,
0.2051229178905487,
0.710311770439148,
0.553390622138977,
0.10301249474287033,
-0.8493443131446838,
-0.22359943389892578,
-0.6333094835281372,
-0.34279295802116394,
-0.39392492175102234,
0.33625155687332153,
-0.10509642213582993,
0.35890135169029236,
-0.21958857774734497,
0.832009494304657,
0.03192611783742905,
-0.038084495812654495,
-0.3162703812122345,
0.5910229086875916,
-0.14672599732875824,
0.5492891073226929,
0.4650684595108032,
-0.3115875720977783,
-0.861801028251648,
0.01956116035580635,
-0.81276535987854,
-0.39408794045448303,
-0.09633594006299973,
-0.09749045968055725,
-0.07417439669370651,
0.3952270448207855,
-0.10300470143556595,
0.718934953212738,
0.36853188276290894,
-0.3024734854698181,
0.6037116050720215,
-0.4938044548034668,
0.7361751198768616,
-0.6481679677963257,
0.014826033264398575,
0.08101882040500641,
-0.3200438916683197,
-0.728203296661377,
-0.37391147017478943,
0.28690335154533386,
-0.11595064401626587,
-0.3731250762939453,
0.615788996219635,
-0.3019363582134247,
0.20651860535144806,
-0.4417436420917511,
0.1037922203540802,
-0.3235706388950348,
0.8091368675231934,
-0.19463030993938446,
0.7581023573875427,
-0.021731138229370117,
-0.5598350763320923,
0.18304264545440674,
0.3614369332790375,
-0.5503275394439697,
1.3717000484466553,
-0.618723452091217,
0.21848365664482117,
-0.2391171008348465,
-0.17564252018928528,
-0.6719833016395569,
-0.34603267908096313,
0.14393723011016846,
-0.35197338461875916,
0.5229692459106445,
0.004690070636570454,
-0.40164244174957275,
-0.3019808828830719,
0.03943406417965889,
-0.10698648542165756,
0.5758047103881836,
-0.2846691906452179,
0.41193246841430664,
0.16207779943943024,
-0.3986941874027252,
-0.5236631631851196,
-0.4430486559867859,
0.28480467200279236,
-0.05816004425287247,
-0.5700955986976624,
0.11056044697761536,
-0.6282615065574646,
-0.5514503717422485,
-0.021528221666812897,
0.11757053434848785,
-0.29498347640037537,
0.4028303027153015,
0.16393671929836273,
-0.30308714509010315,
0.4033624231815338,
0.23977693915367126,
0.1904199719429016,
-0.14868053793907166,
0.05865050107240677,
0.282868891954422,
0.284868061542511,
-0.4086017906665802,
-0.5667697191238403,
-0.614010751247406,
0.6032008528709412,
0.3287021517753601,
-0.1020047664642334,
0.7833031415939331,
0.46960321068763733,
-0.2128802239894867,
-0.004769894760102034,
-0.8140779733657837,
-0.9107208847999573,
-0.379471093416214,
0.47484061121940613,
-0.44750910997390747,
-0.5398191213607788,
0.1967870444059372,
-0.5176313519477844,
0.0639130175113678,
-0.6250808238983154,
0.4782780706882477,
-0.6225630044937134,
1.046718716621399,
0.767018735408783,
0.06783197820186615,
0.8837335705757141,
-0.24679246544837952,
0.432166188955307,
-0.6923085451126099,
-0.1795671135187149,
0.09514076262712479,
-0.44037926197052,
0.1404474526643753,
0.052123505622148514,
0.7122042775154114,
0.3405785858631134,
-0.22784659266471863,
-0.1508028209209442,
-0.2551676034927368,
0.2757892310619354,
0.5727522373199463,
0.4765666723251343,
0.28851237893104553,
-0.16464701294898987,
0.15549156069755554,
-0.5699010491371155,
-0.7971447706222534,
-0.3922676146030426,
0.6169450283050537,
0.2241630256175995,
0.8753857612609863,
0.262803852558136,
0.7230486869812012,
0.37119874358177185,
1.057814359664917,
-0.5652836561203003,
0.37811198830604553,
0.47588828206062317,
-0.6966100931167603,
-0.010623608715832233,
-0.26211750507354736,
-0.7053974270820618,
0.479519784450531,
-0.4766721725463867,
-0.6933363080024719,
-0.11993773281574249,
0.43604469299316406,
-0.10079537332057953,
0.13434205949306488,
-1.1187348365783691,
0.7589302659034729,
-0.3964489698410034,
-0.5874090194702148,
-0.6528990864753723,
-0.6736438870429993,
0.20487160980701447,
-0.1481325924396515,
0.24415409564971924,
-0.25803911685943604,
0.39083901047706604,
0.35870662331581116,
-0.6953484416007996,
0.8618654012680054,
-0.22990088164806366,
0.1615368127822876,
0.23685573041439056,
0.2224482148885727,
0.5878725051879883,
-0.04791606217622757,
-0.21302767097949982,
-0.16183370351791382,
0.08834131062030792,
-0.6521114110946655,
-1.0870531797409058,
0.24442969262599945,
-0.6836915612220764,
-0.5243861079216003,
-0.3169156014919281,
-0.2813807427883148,
-0.324491947889328,
0.031126823276281357,
0.30575019121170044,
0.595173180103302,
-0.6277101039886475,
0.3551320731639862,
0.7971398234367371,
-0.01216099876910448,
0.26797476410865784,
0.929006040096283,
-0.22800645232200623,
-0.5993848443031311,
0.5230168104171753,
0.3829193711280823,
0.6537249684333801,
0.1863216906785965,
0.2469557523727417,
-0.06370651721954346,
0.0020282159093767405,
0.09619603306055069,
0.37256577610969543,
-0.6892720460891724,
0.014750368893146515,
-0.6046168208122253,
-0.19085398316383362,
-0.32209673523902893,
-0.31847310066223145,
-0.4923325777053833,
-0.04039384052157402,
0.1847894936800003,
-0.1901734322309494,
0.25076115131378174,
0.7602225542068481,
-0.6254047155380249,
0.9124084711074829,
-0.48889264464378357,
-0.12687723338603973,
0.2939578890800476,
0.32214465737342834,
0.27827537059783936,
-0.3459727168083191,
-0.7124659419059753,
0.24474374949932098,
-0.664449155330658,
-1.0439003705978394,
0.45798376202583313,
0.13028982281684875,
0.38329029083251953,
0.14890938997268677,
-0.09181900322437286,
0.8384265303611755,
-0.07175673544406891,
0.35507407784461975,
0.36761072278022766,
-1.2099125385284424,
0.47188663482666016,
-0.1185622438788414,
0.25364813208580017,
0.5363405346870422,
-0.08584490418434143,
-0.5989222526550293,
-0.5976210832595825,
-0.8750190734863281,
-0.42618876695632935,
0.6638416647911072,
0.3662809729576111,
-0.07843650132417679,
0.10009826719760895,
0.6288668513298035,
-0.1608509123325348,
0.5089921951293945,
-0.8646517992019653,
-0.20726539194583893,
-0.1542128473520279,
-0.21077695488929749,
0.15406884253025055,
-0.4195173978805542,
-0.21736431121826172,
-0.3262844979763031,
1.0393210649490356,
-0.05702643841505051,
0.347624808549881,
0.3011873662471771,
-0.15910546481609344,
-0.30826711654663086,
0.48144790530204773,
0.2463103085756302,
0.6409305334091187,
-0.356964111328125,
-0.14727260172367096,
0.3969472050666809,
-0.25567588210105896,
0.5481832027435303,
-0.23846778273582458,
0.34266015887260437,
-0.1789972484111786,
0.08731453865766525,
0.5521857142448425,
0.5383261442184448,
-0.5889723896980286,
0.668376624584198,
-0.11530834436416626,
0.021920781582593918,
-0.2554067373275757,
-0.008182290941476822,
-0.0385955385863781,
0.4318147301673889,
-0.12071307748556137,
-0.07349054515361786,
0.07256830483675003,
-0.49149376153945923,
0.3051954209804535,
0.45414015650749207,
-0.46403446793556213,
-0.3992609977722168,
0.6489101648330688,
0.49208492040634155,
-0.4505041539669037,
0.6008707284927368,
-0.3190827965736389,
-0.3197580873966217,
0.48860853910446167,
0.6848950386047363,
0.6708487272262573,
-0.47324228286743164,
0.4129221737384796,
0.3207043409347534,
0.42783409357070923,
-0.10703477263450623,
0.38649821281433105,
-0.09406859427690506,
-0.4641525149345398,
-0.46518394351005554,
-0.0916217789053917,
-0.9393173456192017,
-0.09961988031864166,
-0.6876616477966309,
0.21432307362556458,
-0.5125204920768738,
-0.36499911546707153,
-0.5498104095458984,
0.09188918024301529,
-0.6593132019042969,
0.04967392608523369,
-0.1474442034959793,
0.7957090139389038,
-0.5199785828590393,
0.9214565753936768,
0.8256715536117554,
-0.5584672689437866,
-0.8878185153007507,
-0.15195031464099884,
0.012687933631241322,
-0.6015940308570862,
0.49805954098701477,
-0.00163111905567348,
-0.21620558202266693,
0.32618531584739685,
-0.6491185426712036,
-0.609715461730957,
0.9443299174308777,
0.6806778311729431,
-0.30766093730926514,
0.34333568811416626,
-0.16061995923519135,
0.6605982184410095,
-0.08489713817834854,
0.8810832500457764,
0.38381892442703247,
0.47706326842308044,
-0.13651007413864136,
-1.144368290901184,
-0.46840256452560425,
-0.5655307769775391,
0.10261017084121704,
0.014712277799844742,
-1.1130669116973877,
0.3400193452835083,
-0.1956188976764679,
-0.128041610121727,
0.1188734695315361,
0.7024251222610474,
0.17574946582317352,
0.16419219970703125,
0.5166748762130737,
0.545500636100769,
0.7483404874801636,
-0.1155005693435669,
0.962225615978241,
-0.40347087383270264,
0.2679467797279358,
1.059631109237671,
-0.2357516884803772,
0.5210249423980713,
0.36573100090026855,
-0.010958771221339703,
0.7485766410827637,
0.4472475051879883,
0.5747862458229065,
0.44919565320014954,
0.20103874802589417,
-0.4651910960674286,
-0.2754242420196533,
-0.19234241545200348,
-0.1380215436220169,
0.11776037514209747,
0.3115086853504181,
0.3226255476474762,
-0.1688549965620041,
0.5271350145339966,
0.34595736861228943,
0.23665256798267365,
0.12548726797103882,
0.7358611226081848,
0.33994758129119873,
-0.6317219138145447,
0.535144031047821,
-0.34545499086380005,
0.5155709385871887,
-0.940661609172821,
-0.0966954156756401,
-0.3599764406681061,
0.487871378660202,
-0.1964540034532547,
-0.43810564279556274,
-0.09970331937074661,
-0.1723436713218689,
-0.03079308196902275,
-0.3969086706638336,
0.48322245478630066,
-0.8817903995513916,
0.001126682385802269,
0.573666512966156,
0.6812344789505005,
0.1512865275144577,
-0.1989428699016571,
-0.682802677154541,
-0.09187956154346466,
-0.16142280399799347,
-0.3491779565811157,
0.4871436357498169,
0.4873478412628174,
0.2881239056587219,
0.9243811964988708,
0.2904774248600006,
0.2146662026643753,
0.1308138519525528,
-0.061460159718990326,
0.614730954170227,
-0.7487980127334595,
-0.5461366772651672,
-0.5847263932228088,
0.7241078615188599,
-0.4964762032032013,
-0.13411515951156616,
0.6586105823516846,
0.044205378741025925,
0.5706452131271362,
-0.0351080484688282,
0.963840126991272,
-0.2879329323768616,
0.675719678401947,
-0.10767925530672073,
0.32288309931755066,
-0.6491273045539856,
0.0464453361928463,
-0.4091089367866516,
-0.8985961079597473,
0.1384914368391037,
0.61529141664505,
-0.09961982071399689,
-0.10427633672952652,
0.6885083317756653,
0.7952380180358887,
0.054138388484716415,
-0.13015766441822052,
0.40095046162605286,
0.4163711667060852,
0.8744903802871704,
0.39774149656295776,
1.0063579082489014,
-0.15094444155693054,
0.16561931371688843,
-0.7931599020957947,
-0.6984936594963074,
-0.32031476497650146,
-0.8760147094726562,
-0.8638082146644592,
-0.3615829050540924,
-0.33549973368644714,
-0.4519384801387787,
0.2717704474925995,
1.3606704473495483,
0.9388983845710754,
-0.3466477692127228,
-0.6887430548667908,
0.1952686607837677,
-0.24762628972530365,
-0.34682074189186096,
-0.2414306104183197,
-0.3252900242805481,
-0.5335802435874939,
-0.6913202404975891,
0.43029817938804626,
0.5321375727653503,
0.422065794467926,
-0.10681991279125214,
-0.19920459389686584,
-0.04923709109425545,
0.15387926995754242,
0.7043812870979309,
0.4456934928894043,
-0.4095892012119293,
-0.2075178474187851,
-0.1615387201309204,
-0.11459489911794662,
0.15887777507305145,
0.7101634740829468,
-0.6708189249038696,
0.874093234539032,
0.04526759684085846,
0.485158234834671,
0.5327364206314087,
0.2557530105113983,
0.8172579407691956,
-0.6434582471847534,
0.4938122630119324,
0.03205282241106033,
0.3420305550098419,
0.28086546063423157,
-0.39003226161003113,
0.8933281302452087,
0.3190009593963623,
-0.7094435691833496,
-0.6952270269393921,
0.17108330130577087,
-0.7620368599891663,
-0.07038383185863495,
1.0418044328689575,
-0.26424896717071533,
0.19406184554100037,
-0.042188674211502075,
-0.6672089099884033,
0.26250705122947693,
-0.5047696828842163,
1.246726393699646,
1.0423016548156738,
-0.4555101692676544,
-0.21453876793384552,
-0.4261552691459656,
0.20401202142238617,
0.9238327145576477,
-1.1241507530212402,
-0.41475918889045715,
0.1785382181406021,
0.24094481766223907,
-0.1441466212272644,
1.1537641286849976,
0.09510952234268188,
0.043134905397892,
-0.3142796456813812,
0.4210919737815857,
0.4111160635948181,
-0.14927032589912415,
-0.15479446947574615,
-0.1394825279712677,
0.25546202063560486,
0.3053979277610779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12554v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12554v2 | Archer: A Human-Labeled Text-to-SQL Dataset with Arithmetic, Commonsense and Hypothetical Reasoning | 2024-02-19T21:24:36 | 2024-02-25T00:12:38 | Danna Zheng, Mirella Lapata, Jeff Z. Pan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present Archer, a challenging bilingual text-to-SQL dataset specific to
complex reasoning, including arithmetic, commonsense and hypothetical
reasoning. It contains 1,042 English questions and 1,042 Chinese questions,
along with 521 unique SQL queries, covering 20 English databases across 20
domains. Notably, this dataset demonstrates a significantly higher level of
complexity compared to existing publicly available datasets. Our evaluation
shows that Archer challenges the capabilities of current state-of-the-art
models, with a high-ranked model on the Spider leaderboard achieving only 6.73%
execution accuracy on Archer test set. Thus, Archer presents a significant
challenge for future research in this field. | [
-0.16042044758796692,
-0.8452437520027161,
0.2941061556339264,
0.17039243876934052,
-0.07338649034500122,
0.13436803221702576,
0.3006337583065033,
-0.5305254459381104,
-0.013482829555869102,
0.41319575905799866,
-0.6136617660522461,
-0.5257638692855835,
-0.5775973200798035,
0.5784280300140381,
-0.3377504050731659,
0.9463148713111877,
0.14399436116218567,
0.16943861544132233,
-0.14572693407535553,
-0.4563773274421692,
-0.678054928779602,
-0.7055593132972717,
-0.637191891670227,
-0.04551919177174568,
0.48891690373420715,
0.5757480263710022,
1.0293235778808594,
0.3873222768306732,
0.7153649926185608,
0.24679724872112274,
0.057978346943855286,
0.5417670607566833,
-0.42727166414260864,
-0.07250585407018661,
-0.5869768261909485,
-0.6227202415466309,
-0.7257063984870911,
-0.23670844733715057,
0.42227187752723694,
0.9534371495246887,
0.07335753738880157,
0.3421759009361267,
-0.45741134881973267,
0.979942798614502,
-0.4391257166862488,
0.1806425005197525,
-0.7302637100219727,
0.1136387512087822,
-0.40680864453315735,
0.049294259399175644,
-0.6915557980537415,
-0.09184946119785309,
0.2759762406349182,
-0.757041871547699,
0.10729718953371048,
0.8650248050689697,
0.9690631628036499,
0.11467455327510834,
-1.1861902475357056,
-0.16101917624473572,
-0.5530558228492737,
0.8811046481132507,
-0.3126879334449768,
0.1285409778356552,
0.5560248494148254,
0.6698871850967407,
-0.1998368501663208,
-0.6865081787109375,
-0.5697614550590515,
0.061448026448488235,
-0.26873883605003357,
-0.1755765825510025,
-0.4310031533241272,
-0.13121041655540466,
0.22111839056015015,
0.010512413457036018,
-0.882645308971405,
-0.040509577840566635,
-0.3582398295402527,
0.030129458755254745,
1.181505799293518,
0.5409198999404907,
0.48474910855293274,
-0.21390236914157867,
0.14002537727355957,
0.18938162922859192,
-0.9017025232315063,
-0.023442566394805908,
0.2920575737953186,
0.2887093722820282,
0.1848994791507721,
0.9527193307876587,
-0.3772922158241272,
1.0944782495498657,
0.025847988203167915,
0.2132619023323059,
-0.09777755290269852,
-0.0274329986423254,
-0.2596262991428375,
0.14099304378032684,
0.6222892999649048,
0.29695066809654236,
0.28288733959198,
-0.03738512098789215,
-0.17323902249336243,
-0.1332818567752838,
-0.011661972850561142,
-0.6679480671882629,
-0.294973760843277,
0.6572462320327759,
-0.22964903712272644,
-0.22580231726169586,
-0.11422473937273026,
-0.4740733504295349,
-0.4357815086841583,
-0.27415233850479126,
0.6230082511901855,
-0.3514861464500427,
-0.2220764458179474,
0.32366105914115906,
-0.026830384507775307,
0.3240295350551605,
0.4167783856391907,
-0.8382968902587891,
0.3554888367652893,
0.9629353880882263,
0.515820324420929,
-0.27845942974090576,
-0.32706552743911743,
-0.3595329225063324,
0.07658328860998154,
-0.6101098656654358,
0.9490249752998352,
-0.758772075176239,
-0.1131824180483818,
-0.34948673844337463,
0.13843539357185364,
-0.04174096882343292,
-0.5238938927650452,
0.534548819065094,
-0.6341342926025391,
0.2968662977218628,
-0.40700069069862366,
-0.7859077453613281,
-0.267384797334671,
0.25562411546707153,
-0.937021791934967,
0.6924291253089905,
-0.07991797477006912,
-0.7708384394645691,
0.26448458433151245,
-0.5639294981956482,
-0.7826780676841736,
0.3136465847492218,
-0.2293594926595688,
-0.3552568256855011,
-0.18150772154331207,
0.2833632826805115,
0.39271071553230286,
-0.7463967204093933,
0.5846314430236816,
-0.16056938469409943,
-0.38845643401145935,
0.24350950121879578,
-0.3122327923774719,
1.1058909893035889,
0.4605734646320343,
-0.18509024381637573,
-0.1406933218240738,
-0.8494671583175659,
-0.012013483792543411,
0.35071995854377747,
0.06725585460662842,
-0.199213445186615,
0.3353939354419708,
-0.30889976024627686,
-0.2792654037475586,
0.15780894458293915,
-0.5009902119636536,
0.3118620216846466,
-0.21707290410995483,
0.2855125069618225,
0.40100640058517456,
0.041127316653728485,
0.08608780056238174,
-0.46261492371559143,
0.6478874087333679,
0.04292257875204086,
-0.14828574657440186,
-0.18471258878707886,
-0.8564521670341492,
-0.6366919279098511,
-0.11634156852960587,
0.12934176623821259,
0.919033944606781,
-0.734066367149353,
0.29831910133361816,
-0.4373806118965149,
-0.6074396967887878,
-0.5217750072479248,
-0.46796220541000366,
0.4492358863353729,
0.6783163547515869,
0.3449571132659912,
0.36175835132598877,
-0.2772460877895355,
-1.083442211151123,
-0.5911049842834473,
-0.023147685453295708,
-0.024441668763756752,
0.4737990200519562,
0.8582332134246826,
0.2801249027252197,
0.8661743998527527,
-0.8378692269325256,
-0.355158269405365,
-0.30946263670921326,
0.37736979126930237,
0.35852164030075073,
0.34569522738456726,
0.3118419945240021,
-1.1348439455032349,
-0.6122174263000488,
0.2394457757472992,
-1.0367952585220337,
0.29489031434059143,
-0.23751677572727203,
0.014951725490391254,
0.280696839094162,
0.06315983086824417,
-0.6516663432121277,
0.4474518299102783,
0.2830018699169159,
-0.7617648839950562,
0.7326511740684509,
-0.0932183563709259,
0.631223738193512,
-1.137848138809204,
0.15202440321445465,
0.05615970864892006,
0.009634893387556076,
-0.7095197439193726,
0.17040474712848663,
0.00980184692889452,
-0.4825633466243744,
-0.5270050168037415,
0.5266358852386475,
-0.45157966017723083,
0.019022131338715553,
0.27729305624961853,
-0.05950659140944481,
0.18087564408779144,
0.47265568375587463,
0.05365968123078346,
1.0552468299865723,
0.6082721948623657,
-0.24951492249965668,
0.8676227331161499,
0.31710392236709595,
-0.42143720388412476,
0.9683490991592407,
-1.0108425617218018,
0.10455529391765594,
-0.38781529664993286,
0.16181541979312897,
-1.0258885622024536,
-0.6231867671012878,
-0.2600468397140503,
-0.6682178378105164,
-0.020181525498628616,
-0.19434015452861786,
-0.5020463466644287,
-0.14217166602611542,
-0.03872096911072731,
0.708061933517456,
0.3229605257511139,
-0.4647895395755768,
0.6278209090232849,
0.5612915754318237,
-0.035337720066308975,
-0.6895061731338501,
-0.7185250520706177,
0.39848625659942627,
-0.22935830056667328,
-1.0530341863632202,
0.1175503060221672,
0.3592228889465332,
-0.5306218266487122,
0.12245157361030579,
0.1740790754556656,
-0.5105605125427246,
-0.12064363807439804,
-0.09124747663736343,
0.4485056400299072,
-0.2580348253250122,
0.3192627429962158,
0.18676991760730743,
0.19842509925365448,
0.14279486238956451,
-0.1371009200811386,
-0.09500940144062042,
-0.47461026906967163,
-0.5518261194229126,
-0.4706214964389801,
0.6281907558441162,
0.23951047658920288,
-0.3188130259513855,
0.7334946990013123,
-0.21265536546707153,
-0.6435155272483826,
-0.22794431447982788,
-0.05364347994327545,
0.13008594512939453,
-0.47517767548561096,
0.64263516664505,
-0.8111929297447205,
-0.6890974640846252,
0.35848626494407654,
0.1030908077955246,
0.1836315393447876,
0.6714514493942261,
0.19015872478485107,
-0.16870048642158508,
1.536847472190857,
-0.18429778516292572,
0.0770559012889862,
-0.6536509394645691,
-0.25653275847435,
0.33525440096855164,
-0.2768785357475281,
-0.5328482985496521,
-0.6813586950302124,
-0.26903706789016724,
-0.438200443983078,
-0.2807917594909668,
0.3172483444213867,
-0.24982000887393951,
-0.6288666725158691,
0.3334968388080597,
-0.7398511171340942,
0.9121220111846924,
0.18502911925315857,
0.0583365224301815,
0.5684592723846436,
-0.1493634283542633,
0.3791283667087555,
-0.2389993816614151,
-0.5167681574821472,
-0.4657535254955292,
1.1839008331298828,
-0.14056187868118286,
0.7221232652664185,
0.606904149055481,
0.10176634788513184,
0.7544384002685547,
-0.07090052962303162,
-0.6680892705917358,
0.7166497111320496,
-0.32660767436027527,
-1.2714767456054688,
-0.5175108909606934,
-0.46588483452796936,
-1.2991023063659668,
0.24753513932228088,
-0.30699223279953003,
-0.7070009112358093,
-0.11540156602859497,
0.2687658369541168,
-0.13728930056095123,
0.3832024335861206,
-0.996181845664978,
0.9697796106338501,
-0.4983308017253876,
-0.4478342831134796,
-0.15655182301998138,
-0.7586085200309753,
0.49536797404289246,
-0.10681036114692688,
0.2422572523355484,
-0.15097588300704956,
-0.055878084152936935,
0.7580715417861938,
-0.5659842491149902,
0.548604428768158,
0.05159372091293335,
0.2839840352535248,
0.4618234932422638,
0.2972576320171356,
0.7643257975578308,
-0.14430974423885345,
-0.21494083106517792,
-0.07557042688131332,
0.3270213007926941,
-0.7460917830467224,
-0.6678979992866516,
0.43263691663742065,
-0.6292280554771423,
-0.7638145089149475,
-0.9665176868438721,
-0.44159579277038574,
-0.4230908453464508,
0.3889516294002533,
0.07952693849802017,
0.7387256622314453,
-0.049959853291511536,
0.2629397213459015,
0.7263201475143433,
-0.2568325400352478,
-0.1841006577014923,
0.32861563563346863,
-0.29233071208000183,
-0.2482711374759674,
1.2216671705245972,
0.18357734382152557,
0.12334281951189041,
0.5414807200431824,
-0.00171692727599293,
-0.3912191092967987,
-0.46774283051490784,
-0.700764000415802,
0.27822375297546387,
-0.7090792059898376,
-0.19504669308662415,
-0.3501981496810913,
-0.07106268405914307,
-0.34852737188339233,
-0.18402099609375,
-0.19436565041542053,
-0.7131645083427429,
-0.35069841146469116,
-0.07134494185447693,
0.4307226836681366,
0.9110907912254333,
0.6305065751075745,
-0.08035917580127716,
-0.6451377272605896,
0.36771705746650696,
0.48631221055984497,
0.2982727587223053,
-0.014637577347457409,
-0.5420353412628174,
0.08388474583625793,
0.15857702493667603,
-0.07719859480857849,
-1.0784010887145996,
0.3798670172691345,
0.36874493956565857,
0.3080691993236542,
0.16863596439361572,
0.43285223841667175,
0.7565127015113831,
-0.4347398579120636,
0.8609236478805542,
-0.06120846047997475,
-0.8993995785713196,
0.5095441937446594,
-0.48346447944641113,
0.17644532024860382,
0.4887809753417969,
0.9637390971183777,
-0.2829495072364807,
0.04090569168329239,
-0.45875847339630127,
-0.4844444990158081,
0.7670720219612122,
0.19029177725315094,
-0.1275181919336319,
0.20273999869823456,
0.17661046981811523,
-0.07787667959928513,
-0.03597631677985191,
-0.37825119495391846,
-0.33929702639579773,
0.04093479365110397,
-0.28529560565948486,
0.20713485777378082,
-0.04393449425697327,
0.028254084289073944,
-0.5729457139968872,
0.5133218169212341,
-0.027033288031816483,
-0.08917637914419174,
-0.028715256601572037,
-0.058946408331394196,
0.2727968096733093,
0.2194778472185135,
0.3832719922065735,
0.858289361000061,
-0.21306473016738892,
0.1529283970594406,
0.4334874451160431,
-0.3609280288219452,
0.23069751262664795,
-0.0013255778467282653,
-0.1703222244977951,
-0.22603513300418854,
0.5767616033554077,
0.6746577024459839,
-0.14573954045772552,
-1.0582548379898071,
0.5423089861869812,
-0.04215719923377037,
-0.25777098536491394,
-0.3201535642147064,
-0.10349184274673462,
0.23332251608371735,
-0.21787168085575104,
0.7001999020576477,
-0.0768028274178505,
0.3515494763851166,
-0.5283758044242859,
0.24064235389232635,
0.3424334228038788,
-0.17114853858947754,
-0.2553010880947113,
0.8339749574661255,
0.46592023968696594,
-0.6922548413276672,
0.7077605724334717,
-0.4921472668647766,
-0.42331624031066895,
0.8209987878799438,
0.44155153632164,
0.5629061460494995,
0.12817221879959106,
0.19445231556892395,
0.4472605288028717,
0.3473440408706665,
0.030250918120145798,
0.4434570372104645,
0.12656338512897491,
-0.4616328477859497,
-0.3752346634864807,
-0.23298214375972748,
-0.7519195675849915,
-0.2654949128627777,
-0.541610836982727,
0.5601284503936768,
-0.30196288228034973,
0.03286684677004814,
0.4787847399711609,
0.15951040387153625,
-0.2537297010421753,
0.31244415044784546,
-0.48589885234832764,
1.0255506038665771,
-0.8559602499008179,
0.8277250528335571,
0.7460523843765259,
-0.3500637710094452,
-0.8818878531455994,
-0.4399926960468292,
0.2692956328392029,
-0.7346391677856445,
0.7074828147888184,
0.16738642752170563,
-0.3359315097332001,
0.03527037054300308,
-0.6521868705749512,
-0.706536591053009,
1.0910911560058594,
0.3387792706489563,
-0.3216800093650818,
-0.014795145951211452,
0.5214170813560486,
0.5898041725158691,
-0.364430695772171,
0.1878025084733963,
0.7640436291694641,
0.4916994571685791,
0.4016718566417694,
-0.7305817604064941,
-0.06392338126897812,
-0.47097843885421753,
-0.3192756474018097,
0.25680917501449585,
-0.5963984131813049,
0.9017598628997803,
-0.4933702051639557,
-0.2922423481941223,
-0.21325966715812683,
0.7356939315795898,
0.38124001026153564,
0.5620546936988831,
0.2945275902748108,
0.48619917035102844,
0.8812840580940247,
-0.13415022194385529,
0.8054251074790955,
0.12535010278224945,
0.2752612829208374,
1.178357720375061,
-0.649303138256073,
0.8511666059494019,
0.07311059534549713,
-0.641924262046814,
0.36584800481796265,
0.6027178168296814,
-0.11763359606266022,
0.10311374813318253,
0.11030101776123047,
-0.36523762345314026,
-0.3836587965488434,
-0.1236223429441452,
-0.20068906247615814,
0.3534031808376312,
0.28924596309661865,
0.3413149118423462,
-0.13461223244667053,
-0.26742565631866455,
0.2005818486213684,
0.4362426698207855,
-0.12097823619842529,
0.6536796689033508,
-0.2260230928659439,
-1.006195306777954,
0.6218852400779724,
-0.017078157514333725,
0.29654720425605774,
-0.45765846967697144,
-0.40134090185165405,
-0.3893963694572449,
0.06012509763240814,
-0.46429136395454407,
-1.210576057434082,
0.5855271220207214,
0.23167148232460022,
0.2693716585636139,
0.2093433290719986,
0.5236716270446777,
-0.2266748696565628,
-0.7770336270332336,
-0.3501221537590027,
0.04505086690187454,
0.45439666509628296,
-0.13030081987380981,
-0.6755574941635132,
-0.1317230463027954,
0.22325214743614197,
-0.19579115509986877,
0.19406205415725708,
0.8084038496017456,
-0.2605527937412262,
1.1259938478469849,
0.46414849162101746,
0.005582059267908335,
0.030692216008901596,
-0.4622405767440796,
0.4965868890285492,
-0.7036134600639343,
-0.24500161409378052,
-0.7130569815635681,
0.4479205310344696,
-0.33309635519981384,
-0.4194335341453552,
0.8365840911865234,
0.8584848046302795,
0.5106272101402283,
-0.03390660136938095,
0.5506495237350464,
-0.23779456317424774,
0.6421487927436829,
-0.21214303374290466,
0.7755128741264343,
-0.813568115234375,
0.37281110882759094,
0.010284841991961002,
-0.25894010066986084,
-0.6389697194099426,
0.22391434013843536,
-0.20838522911071777,
-0.17582669854164124,
0.7059890031814575,
0.8324930667877197,
0.10961124300956726,
0.38064393401145935,
0.33160799741744995,
-0.01717262528836727,
0.4611886143684387,
0.9269881248474121,
0.5281720161437988,
-0.39217308163642883,
0.7597976922988892,
-0.05451073497533798,
-0.23062008619308472,
-0.1144571304321289,
-0.811798632144928,
-1.0124735832214355,
-0.8137562274932861,
-0.08240488171577454,
-0.20666536688804626,
0.15858669579029083,
1.0161402225494385,
0.6268485188484192,
-1.118828535079956,
-0.38427045941352844,
-0.10308142006397247,
0.3387656807899475,
-0.08026855438947678,
-0.22040516138076782,
0.6933621764183044,
-0.051475636661052704,
-0.634859025478363,
-0.026485707610845566,
0.09916133433580399,
-0.07575764507055283,
-0.14754781126976013,
0.022001920267939568,
-0.5193618535995483,
0.19986246526241302,
0.7156777381896973,
0.4374145269393921,
-0.47333624958992004,
-0.23458537459373474,
0.1819719821214676,
-0.09258829802274704,
-0.1412602663040161,
0.44588664174079895,
-0.6591450572013855,
0.5682596564292908,
0.5807314515113831,
0.8535518646240234,
0.4591312110424042,
0.13879099488258362,
0.5011796355247498,
-0.5390397906303406,
0.13591375946998596,
0.5515368580818176,
0.26326364278793335,
0.2610321342945099,
-0.45200130343437195,
0.5520680546760559,
0.24988014996051788,
-0.6621642708778381,
-0.9871256351470947,
0.29768291115760803,
-0.890568196773529,
-0.4747263491153717,
0.8292127847671509,
-0.1296427994966507,
-0.22579282522201538,
-0.4170754849910736,
-0.3750312626361847,
-0.3298109173774719,
-0.18135428428649902,
0.6609636545181274,
0.8009695410728455,
-0.5226284861564636,
-0.006981194019317627,
-0.13451677560806274,
0.48653751611709595,
0.51213538646698,
-1.1374704837799072,
0.18310214579105377,
0.6822819113731384,
0.02811124362051487,
-0.15575024485588074,
0.4635770916938782,
0.13745075464248657,
0.43408602476119995,
0.16763539612293243,
-0.36452120542526245,
-0.2072259932756424,
-0.47578874230384827,
-0.009473397396504879,
0.2821984887123108,
0.14359387755393982,
0.023266088217496872
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12545v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12545v2 | TrustScore: Reference-Free Evaluation of LLM Response Trustworthiness | 2024-02-19T21:12:14 | 2024-05-06T22:02:10 | Danna Zheng, Danyang Liu, Mirella Lapata, Jeff Z. Pan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities across
various domains, prompting a surge in their practical applications. However,
concerns have arisen regarding the trustworthiness of LLMs outputs,
particularly in closed-book question-answering tasks, where non-experts may
struggle to identify inaccuracies due to the absence of contextual or ground
truth information. This paper introduces TrustScore, a framework based on the
concept of Behavioral Consistency, which evaluates whether an LLMs response
aligns with its intrinsic knowledge. Additionally, TrustScore can seamlessly
integrate with fact-checking methods, which assesses alignment with external
knowledge sources. The experimental results show that TrustScore achieves
strong correlations with human judgments, surpassing existing reference-free
metrics, and achieving results on par with reference-based metrics. | [
-0.112652987241745,
-0.6058506369590759,
0.8709999918937683,
0.05194281041622162,
-0.0697876587510109,
0.2636331021785736,
-0.28642162680625916,
-0.4486066699028015,
-0.0836908295750618,
0.2854761481285095,
-0.39872679114341736,
-0.5275017023086548,
-0.8011173605918884,
-0.08938784152269363,
-0.5387185215950012,
0.9398767352104187,
-0.15763621032238007,
-0.007584774401038885,
-0.9408342838287354,
-0.28827735781669617,
-0.23476359248161316,
-0.4836503267288208,
-0.5009341835975647,
-0.6826038956642151,
0.09464186429977417,
0.34367063641548157,
0.854594349861145,
0.5553516149520874,
0.7200453281402588,
0.23009109497070312,
-0.0032402349170297384,
0.42727309465408325,
-0.5907237529754639,
0.21021467447280884,
-0.5372487902641296,
-0.3982396423816681,
-0.6697885394096375,
0.24406255781650543,
0.5609126687049866,
0.23543690145015717,
-0.32610735297203064,
0.4453754425048828,
0.24973416328430176,
0.6022347211837769,
-0.6076875925064087,
0.25684964656829834,
-0.6914900541305542,
-0.040214311331510544,
0.0979977697134018,
-0.19695034623146057,
-0.3632356524467468,
-0.7913577556610107,
0.0018316225614398718,
-0.41470861434936523,
-0.0011869370937347412,
0.3177874982357025,
0.8090757727622986,
0.3144803047180176,
-0.3342406749725342,
-0.350284606218338,
-0.4698871076107025,
0.7529479265213013,
-0.6225113272666931,
0.694567859172821,
0.5514630675315857,
0.16433632373809814,
-0.03391840308904648,
-0.45375725626945496,
-0.6028525233268738,
-0.5299695730209351,
-0.10309276729822159,
0.2763158679008484,
0.015635734423995018,
-0.2136562317609787,
0.05957407504320145,
0.45470622181892395,
-0.45760464668273926,
-0.2168012261390686,
0.06754173338413239,
-0.5005165338516235,
0.53429114818573,
0.2760148346424103,
0.13181911408901215,
0.0033337976783514023,
-0.5484957098960876,
0.05424090102314949,
-0.6124143600463867,
0.08120878785848618,
0.22690467536449432,
0.2502220869064331,
-0.2650526463985443,
0.7548112869262695,
-0.24543705582618713,
0.46665120124816895,
0.3116990327835083,
-0.44674503803253174,
-0.017956459894776344,
-0.41849762201309204,
-0.2817736864089966,
0.06672944128513336,
0.683148980140686,
0.5538468956947327,
0.5003622174263,
-0.4326111674308777,
-0.17909331619739532,
0.2320934683084488,
0.23307327926158905,
-0.637671709060669,
0.23616957664489746,
0.5191105604171753,
-0.2757683992385864,
-0.34770384430885315,
0.08767516165971756,
-0.28691211342811584,
-0.5477606654167175,
-0.4254493713378906,
0.23257939517498016,
-0.5609914064407349,
-0.40181976556777954,
0.025607246905565262,
0.12442688643932343,
0.3677048087120056,
0.3559741973876953,
-0.3318914473056793,
0.5167412757873535,
0.9956734776496887,
0.822163999080658,
-0.5414921045303345,
-0.17379289865493774,
-0.8635578751564026,
0.37742310762405396,
-0.3100435137748718,
0.7327145338058472,
-0.480206161737442,
-0.5238566994667053,
0.007276172749698162,
-0.24637773633003235,
0.013964658603072166,
-0.5669259428977966,
0.711270809173584,
-0.7242737412452698,
-0.1521623283624649,
-0.30087271332740784,
-0.8843638300895691,
0.11219481378793716,
0.8672770261764526,
-0.3189811706542969,
1.1796042919158936,
-0.017192061990499496,
-0.7158228754997253,
-0.06807151436805725,
-0.28831958770751953,
-0.22106264531612396,
-0.1356157809495926,
-0.2019355148077011,
-0.12109801918268204,
0.1586141735315323,
-0.18375878036022186,
0.21450600028038025,
-0.408214271068573,
0.5033089518547058,
-0.540170431137085,
-0.283602237701416,
0.6812997460365295,
-0.19848059117794037,
0.576624870300293,
0.22875480353832245,
-0.1474323719739914,
0.11596215516328812,
-0.6389235854148865,
0.4259878396987915,
-0.05722949653863907,
-0.1891075074672699,
-0.2963216006755829,
-0.07249810546636581,
-0.2602333426475525,
0.15925002098083496,
0.6264217495918274,
-0.7745270729064941,
-0.22556404769420624,
0.045034632086753845,
0.12258424609899521,
0.9109373092651367,
-0.07391319423913956,
0.17781083285808563,
-0.6172910332679749,
0.2771119773387909,
0.4242621660232544,
0.2701543867588043,
0.3315831124782562,
-0.2905816435813904,
-0.7126353979110718,
-0.07873865216970444,
0.1037796214222908,
0.5765860080718994,
-0.26870712637901306,
0.42696037888526917,
-0.5151817798614502,
-0.5689736604690552,
-0.34927651286125183,
0.31983619928359985,
0.7021862268447876,
0.9391204118728638,
0.2585490047931671,
-0.4618130624294281,
-0.40903133153915405,
-1.0392000675201416,
-0.4992506802082062,
-0.5629891157150269,
0.1664305478334427,
0.3355565071105957,
0.31086233258247375,
-0.13510698080062866,
1.0903809070587158,
-0.5732964873313904,
-0.13453078269958496,
0.2017211765050888,
-0.1145576685667038,
0.028317101299762726,
0.3629910349845886,
0.08937622606754303,
-0.4333307147026062,
-0.37447699904441833,
-0.05878589302301407,
-0.9658092856407166,
0.03935994207859039,
0.4792777895927429,
-0.15795908868312836,
0.035856686532497406,
0.42647454142570496,
-0.7580423951148987,
-0.004204199183732271,
0.6798479557037354,
-0.2835681140422821,
0.685736894607544,
0.058059804141521454,
0.31126081943511963,
-1.1098018884658813,
0.22098812460899353,
0.07536105811595917,
-0.5400039553642273,
-0.2604624927043915,
0.1866287887096405,
0.18757201731204987,
0.06187828257679939,
-0.3546788692474365,
0.7466359734535217,
-0.21432463824748993,
-0.31191614270210266,
-0.009175039827823639,
0.5112561583518982,
-0.013592047616839409,
0.06607463955879211,
0.032718874514102936,
1.0824369192123413,
0.22868135571479797,
-0.5650563836097717,
0.36778971552848816,
0.5492104291915894,
-0.4297614097595215,
1.1691282987594604,
-0.6539596319198608,
0.47871530055999756,
0.05115148052573204,
-0.02384924329817295,
-0.8398134112358093,
-0.06674371659755707,
-0.09325224906206131,
-0.6564720273017883,
-0.03793293237686157,
-0.007176327519118786,
-0.5711913704872131,
-0.17666907608509064,
-0.32615479826927185,
0.05435052886605263,
0.4434605538845062,
-0.22506828606128693,
0.7348579168319702,
0.26569345593452454,
0.08678218722343445,
-0.6901337504386902,
-0.537695586681366,
-0.14955417811870575,
0.14157742261886597,
-0.5951682925224304,
-0.05936254933476448,
-0.5369150638580322,
-0.5475179553031921,
0.15723644196987152,
-0.34803542494773865,
-0.20263731479644775,
0.2726213335990906,
0.3600812554359436,
0.24378354847431183,
-0.3668232262134552,
0.06372632831335068,
-0.38378578424453735,
-0.04786481708288193,
0.24373272061347961,
-0.12008345127105713,
0.2659896910190582,
-0.562503457069397,
-0.6183688044548035,
-0.2934967279434204,
0.040050018578767776,
0.7236613631248474,
-0.29261332750320435,
0.6177255511283875,
0.3498867154121399,
-0.39082977175712585,
0.0005180284497328103,
-0.632846474647522,
-0.13700264692306519,
-0.4894005358219147,
0.17293968796730042,
-0.21781112253665924,
-1.1082851886749268,
0.4504806399345398,
0.024827636778354645,
-0.13509763777256012,
0.24788610637187958,
0.5212571024894714,
-0.1785387396812439,
0.6204416751861572,
0.4333712160587311,
-0.0977947860956192,
-0.028289318084716797,
0.38852107524871826,
0.3461207151412964,
-0.9973606467247009,
-0.41361549496650696,
-0.5596455335617065,
0.03184632584452629,
-0.2599598169326782,
-0.42666715383529663,
0.3684081733226776,
0.012902522459626198,
-0.4799489676952362,
0.05460842326283455,
-0.010839917697012424,
0.43906933069229126,
0.39496344327926636,
0.2219078689813614,
0.8319495320320129,
-0.16237084567546844,
-0.2977590262889862,
0.02463068999350071,
-0.1818743199110031,
-0.750209391117096,
1.0720463991165161,
0.25870445370674133,
0.7756126523017883,
0.41785508394241333,
0.4369529187679291,
0.5416948795318604,
0.7433079481124878,
-0.8748282790184021,
0.6843609809875488,
0.11831033229827881,
-0.7325716018676758,
-0.051000937819480896,
-0.3100236654281616,
-0.2573671042919159,
-0.1325991153717041,
-0.39625731110572815,
-0.6497918367385864,
-0.3970586657524109,
0.18941421806812286,
-0.28791922330856323,
0.25418931245803833,
-0.5204784870147705,
0.3440472185611725,
-0.3632979393005371,
-0.6481095552444458,
-0.1719692349433899,
-0.36041226983070374,
0.5748139023780823,
-0.10470779985189438,
0.016337275505065918,
-0.3609068989753723,
-0.05027533695101738,
0.6113789677619934,
-0.17231900990009308,
0.8684110641479492,
0.07090198993682861,
-0.2053723931312561,
0.4207439720630646,
0.4478296637535095,
0.6416226625442505,
0.2242572158575058,
-0.22901469469070435,
0.1825682520866394,
0.15952113270759583,
-0.21514195203781128,
-0.7325557470321655,
0.9636262059211731,
-0.9324949383735657,
-0.8963617086410522,
-0.537150502204895,
-0.7152352929115295,
-0.9889558553695679,
0.34009233117103577,
-0.319683700799942,
0.2761616110801697,
-0.5337586402893066,
0.18604515492916107,
1.0065324306488037,
0.0851043090224266,
0.016207169741392136,
1.0444364547729492,
-0.17454273998737335,
-0.304000586271286,
0.5136545896530151,
-0.25297537446022034,
0.2169283777475357,
0.30640971660614014,
0.15503306686878204,
-0.5388109683990479,
-0.6031404137611389,
-0.16025733947753906,
0.333351731300354,
-0.7247611284255981,
-0.503136932849884,
-0.4952908754348755,
-0.4532916247844696,
-0.3910294771194458,
0.13027307391166687,
-0.5715535283088684,
-0.20759478211402893,
0.04631860554218292,
-0.458487868309021,
0.38651394844055176,
0.7034852504730225,
0.21509386599063873,
0.1437271237373352,
-1.0410356521606445,
0.03225415199995041,
0.3471197485923767,
0.8085078001022339,
-0.04107094183564186,
-0.48527243733406067,
-0.24120058119297028,
-0.015241952612996101,
-0.3332407474517822,
-0.5887026190757751,
-0.23936201632022858,
0.057333704084157944,
0.6191797256469727,
0.4162939190864563,
0.16207456588745117,
0.6238906383514404,
-0.3841157555580139,
0.863953173160553,
0.24595819413661957,
-1.1645667552947998,
0.2589724361896515,
-0.36413511633872986,
0.07268767803907394,
0.7875350713729858,
0.4390380382537842,
-0.5755876898765564,
-0.48558273911476135,
-0.676904022693634,
-0.2696349322795868,
0.16985385119915009,
0.17411930859088898,
0.0018407573224976659,
-0.18341191112995148,
0.4358753561973572,
-0.00287432549521327,
0.45330899953842163,
-0.3361533582210541,
-0.13578204810619354,
-0.08742806315422058,
-0.4545719623565674,
-0.1478240191936493,
-0.34443119168281555,
-0.5146888494491577,
0.16510502994060516,
0.628501832485199,
-0.20042575895786285,
0.1940128058195114,
0.31997358798980713,
-0.3339950442314148,
-0.25555071234703064,
0.45359504222869873,
0.6461795568466187,
0.9166426658630371,
-0.3809487223625183,
0.46362316608428955,
0.048676542937755585,
-0.47809872031211853,
0.28423789143562317,
-0.27602025866508484,
-0.10283344238996506,
-0.3491750955581665,
0.45138368010520935,
0.19371193647384644,
0.1263786256313324,
-0.7476983666419983,
0.7083054780960083,
-0.06095145642757416,
-0.05607376620173454,
-0.37503713369369507,
0.17396095395088196,
0.36059874296188354,
0.2516561448574066,
0.14778508245944977,
0.07142242044210434,
-0.15863052010536194,
-0.4415005147457123,
0.549808144569397,
0.6427311897277832,
-0.6418517827987671,
-0.419663667678833,
0.5359585881233215,
0.2271302342414856,
-0.17634335160255432,
0.8043401837348938,
0.10747849941253662,
-0.43384960293769836,
0.4024626910686493,
0.574871301651001,
0.8106051087379456,
-0.2985142469406128,
0.16490493714809418,
0.3757622539997101,
0.3689884543418884,
-0.05959343537688255,
0.342982679605484,
0.11140468716621399,
-1.1384663581848145,
-0.2212224304676056,
-0.6344236731529236,
-0.837410569190979,
0.0992184653878212,
-0.9409121870994568,
-0.16229009628295898,
-0.7806366682052612,
-0.3072958290576935,
-0.5557077527046204,
0.1359349638223648,
-0.6690310835838318,
0.4243931174278259,
-0.04237513616681099,
1.3236502408981323,
-0.8452304601669312,
0.8302382826805115,
0.6678766012191772,
-0.23471128940582275,
-0.7883802056312561,
0.11192509531974792,
0.1214665025472641,
-1.2025831937789917,
0.6063871383666992,
-0.11794580519199371,
-0.6622986793518066,
-0.12292052060365677,
-0.5441939830780029,
-0.9771902561187744,
1.228339672088623,
0.5038687586784363,
-0.4061200022697449,
0.24979354441165924,
0.09866992384195328,
0.5895184874534607,
-0.34014958143234253,
0.23128578066825867,
0.497592955827713,
0.6145535707473755,
-0.05802753195166588,
-1.0101159811019897,
0.31515705585479736,
-0.18245837092399597,
-0.11066452413797379,
-0.09240652620792389,
-1.0242047309875488,
0.4703722298145294,
-0.09459413588047028,
-0.03289947658777237,
0.07914119213819504,
0.8840758204460144,
0.502752959728241,
0.1280379742383957,
0.3778749704360962,
0.7016560435295105,
1.1284841299057007,
-0.02766496129333973,
1.1270588636398315,
-0.6318073868751526,
0.3874252736568451,
1.3882465362548828,
-0.6523889303207397,
1.0760877132415771,
0.5378007888793945,
-0.14519861340522766,
0.6091073751449585,
0.4127686321735382,
0.2971667945384979,
0.390567809343338,
-0.039622966200113297,
-0.17605742812156677,
-0.5200405716896057,
-0.4694785177707672,
-0.2913151681423187,
0.3825349509716034,
0.115167036652565,
-0.14641152322292328,
-0.15039266645908356,
-0.7697992324829102,
0.15763959288597107,
0.3797898292541504,
-0.26801836490631104,
0.5001481771469116,
0.29092979431152344,
-0.7454783916473389,
0.26201531291007996,
-0.11296231299638748,
0.4353136420249939,
-0.7460882663726807,
0.19707438349723816,
-0.42654871940612793,
0.32847416400909424,
-0.3749335706233978,
-1.0798826217651367,
0.512265145778656,
0.016412902623414993,
-0.3974578082561493,
-0.024069897830486298,
0.6015913486480713,
-0.28421321511268616,
-0.1928195357322693,
0.3228874206542969,
0.8789142966270447,
-0.14248226583003998,
0.09444016218185425,
-0.7114143371582031,
0.17731323838233948,
-0.40157589316368103,
-0.04815765470266342,
0.47076037526130676,
0.12328774482011795,
-0.0009798434330150485,
0.8425126075744629,
0.5418272018432617,
-0.018041107803583145,
-0.3398604393005371,
-0.25930848717689514,
0.624169647693634,
-0.44672825932502747,
-0.34166470170021057,
-0.6906903386116028,
0.2273274064064026,
-0.23856127262115479,
-0.15450945496559143,
1.1015267372131348,
0.7178272008895874,
0.6748508810997009,
0.0386517159640789,
0.8764656186103821,
0.2684045732021332,
0.5511265397071838,
-0.49601227045059204,
0.5448451638221741,
-0.3039998710155487,
0.019790537655353546,
-0.018266815692186356,
-0.7416635155677795,
0.0361691415309906,
0.39659106731414795,
-0.31465381383895874,
0.0839090421795845,
1.0392895936965942,
0.7532042860984802,
-0.26149415969848633,
0.13237588107585907,
0.35945311188697815,
0.38014140725135803,
0.11779814958572388,
0.47855138778686523,
0.8817259669303894,
-0.2331068217754364,
0.35863029956817627,
0.1744065135717392,
-0.07267540693283081,
-0.008406996726989746,
-1.315841794013977,
-0.7777704000473022,
-0.34291309118270874,
-0.3853430449962616,
-0.8421292901039124,
0.18187592923641205,
0.8933898210525513,
0.5820488929748535,
-1.0230424404144287,
-0.3618680238723755,
0.3626636862754822,
0.19389136135578156,
-0.2516288459300995,
-0.1933681070804596,
0.24595515429973602,
-0.20688319206237793,
-0.4535766541957855,
0.2947622537612915,
0.3038782477378845,
-0.03606577217578888,
-0.2839915454387665,
-0.26126769185066223,
0.06794434785842896,
0.4365198314189911,
0.5520169734954834,
0.03646048158407211,
-0.5947504043579102,
-0.6465506553649902,
0.24186256527900696,
-0.40627914667129517,
0.11695364862680435,
0.863295316696167,
-0.47852838039398193,
0.06202545017004013,
0.24123884737491608,
0.8137099146842957,
0.14176470041275024,
0.31634604930877686,
0.5211188793182373,
-0.6497889161109924,
-0.18591131269931793,
0.09013073146343231,
0.3040309548377991,
0.5749062895774841,
-0.4415692090988159,
0.5208441615104675,
0.12647055089473724,
-0.40081125497817993,
-0.5899386405944824,
0.43095606565475464,
-1.1932728290557861,
0.13473094999790192,
1.3142411708831787,
-0.3658740222454071,
-0.3611994981765747,
-0.06316716969013214,
0.26032260060310364,
0.037024155259132385,
-0.3968566358089447,
0.7450860738754272,
1.0532879829406738,
-0.18713094294071198,
-0.0169843640178442,
-0.3283143937587738,
0.42516520619392395,
0.34314003586769104,
-0.8120372295379639,
0.14925315976142883,
0.5383633375167847,
0.8365044593811035,
0.24222023785114288,
0.8485952615737915,
-0.2758950889110565,
0.07266020029783249,
-0.3432685434818268,
-0.17874588072299957,
-0.32187697291374207,
-0.013937155716121197,
0.01099301129579544,
0.3538892865180969,
0.6368522047996521,
0.23458002507686615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12530v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12530v1 | Parallel Structures in Pre-training Data Yield In-Context Learning | 2024-02-19T20:40:48 | 2024-02-19T20:40:48 | Yanda Chen, Chen Zhao, Zhou Yu, Kathleen McKeown, He He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Pre-trained language models (LMs) are capable of in-context learning (ICL):
they can adapt to a task with only a few examples given in the prompt without
any parameter update. However, it is unclear where this capability comes from
as there is a stark distribution shift between pre-training text and ICL
prompts. In this work, we study what patterns of the pre-training data
contribute to ICL. We find that LMs' ICL ability depends on $\textit{parallel
structures}$ in the pre-training data -- pairs of phrases following similar
templates in the same context window. Specifically, we detect parallel
structures by checking whether training on one phrase improves prediction of
the other, and conduct ablation experiments to study their effect on ICL. We
show that removing parallel structures in the pre-training data reduces LMs'
ICL accuracy by 51% (vs 2% from random ablation). This drop persists even when
excluding common patterns such as n-gram repetitions and long-range dependency,
showing the diversity and generality of parallel structures. A closer look at
the detected parallel structures indicates that they cover diverse linguistic
tasks and span long distances in the data. | [
-0.47183892130851746,
-0.7507042288780212,
0.47305116057395935,
0.1912706196308136,
-0.4157841205596924,
-0.04090501740574837,
-0.29995235800743103,
-0.2300817370414734,
-0.1034734845161438,
0.28664714097976685,
-0.46516963839530945,
-0.737195611000061,
-0.5888470411300659,
0.17937617003917694,
-0.5439519882202148,
1.0945765972137451,
-0.24082112312316895,
0.14878076314926147,
-0.4624320864677429,
-0.21943560242652893,
-0.26768264174461365,
-0.7281069755554199,
-0.24570541083812714,
-0.16274498403072357,
0.5465470552444458,
0.5071182250976562,
0.29942309856414795,
0.9351240396499634,
0.30718934535980225,
0.3174462616443634,
-0.1250472217798233,
-0.24101893603801727,
-0.45050063729286194,
-0.03540729358792305,
-0.04282986745238304,
-0.7747172117233276,
-0.16670554876327515,
-0.08217623829841614,
1.1744296550750732,
1.153922200202942,
0.06319936364889145,
0.12141433358192444,
0.6231511831283569,
0.7544401288032532,
-0.4118543267250061,
0.21533533930778503,
-0.7723338007926941,
-0.0963849350810051,
-0.8957634568214417,
-0.14910759031772614,
-0.37529999017715454,
0.02570807933807373,
0.17905277013778687,
-0.20454329252243042,
0.3900810480117798,
0.16971150040626526,
0.7815449237823486,
0.24674053490161896,
-0.2818090617656708,
-0.33540934324264526,
-0.4083470106124878,
0.6068030595779419,
-0.3595629632472992,
0.5087792277336121,
0.432678759098053,
0.03976192697882652,
-0.2771865427494049,
-0.5782685875892639,
-0.3798305094242096,
-0.30419549345970154,
-0.3821687698364258,
-0.14579792320728302,
0.37285342812538147,
0.11760923266410828,
0.4497886002063751,
0.2128073275089264,
-0.4384227693080902,
0.34425997734069824,
-0.4455857276916504,
0.0762023851275444,
0.039526522159576416,
0.16299767792224884,
0.33840546011924744,
0.14156687259674072,
-0.3776381313800812,
-0.1843879222869873,
-1.1186507940292358,
0.39406830072402954,
0.23285232484340668,
0.40934857726097107,
-0.48753640055656433,
0.37122032046318054,
-0.03850380703806877,
0.8016603589057922,
0.1035551205277443,
-0.05844934657216072,
0.48888111114501953,
-0.22214826941490173,
-0.25891605019569397,
0.2731168568134308,
0.5839388966560364,
-0.1571718007326126,
0.2927316427230835,
-0.24111558496952057,
-0.09284887462854385,
-0.1386432647705078,
-0.017350902780890465,
-0.7825547456741333,
-0.2162926346063614,
-0.093539297580719,
-0.6324053406715393,
0.02298634499311447,
0.1416541337966919,
-0.22811497747898102,
0.00839504599571228,
-0.3873925805091858,
0.12084173411130905,
-0.33833006024360657,
0.017286714166402817,
0.16757477819919586,
-0.0724838450551033,
0.09117498993873596,
0.029856890439987183,
-0.687404990196228,
0.37832802534103394,
0.4051021933555603,
0.8143311142921448,
-0.243203267455101,
-0.7651349306106567,
-0.4481638967990875,
0.22358739376068115,
-0.21084840595722198,
0.8974828720092773,
-0.6683263778686523,
-0.2409038543701172,
-0.15628108382225037,
0.06621643900871277,
-0.4092935621738434,
-0.766893744468689,
0.2101617008447647,
-0.3484569489955902,
0.09931334853172302,
-0.5205550193786621,
-0.7026317119598389,
0.028689740225672722,
0.19008642435073853,
-0.5518313050270081,
0.6399606466293335,
-0.11994178593158722,
-0.9236634373664856,
0.4847177267074585,
-0.5519315600395203,
-0.49235790967941284,
-0.04608243331313133,
-0.6529792547225952,
-0.44461432099342346,
0.28983938694000244,
0.12812280654907227,
0.3414613604545593,
-0.09156651794910431,
0.06945696473121643,
-0.4438883364200592,
-0.5025519132614136,
0.397796094417572,
-0.186509370803833,
0.6073469519615173,
0.013285699300467968,
-0.4578191339969635,
0.1260080486536026,
-0.6888402104377747,
-0.2660696506500244,
-0.0769210010766983,
-0.4216028153896332,
-0.5750312209129333,
0.26902082562446594,
-0.20963747799396515,
0.31862276792526245,
-0.1395094245672226,
-0.5071518421173096,
0.07908176630735397,
-0.5523754358291626,
0.030009498819708824,
0.7864903807640076,
-0.19083765149116516,
0.3994036316871643,
-0.4472363591194153,
0.38294652104377747,
0.5747547745704651,
-0.07486671954393387,
-0.33926910161972046,
-0.2141948640346527,
-0.6471298933029175,
-0.4371736943721771,
-0.03083033673465252,
0.29316243529319763,
-0.5159854888916016,
0.17344097793102264,
-0.1600988656282425,
-0.23470808565616608,
-0.2720080316066742,
0.1442401111125946,
0.7168866991996765,
0.8471545577049255,
0.4266011416912079,
-0.2697804868221283,
-0.5724868178367615,
-0.9514064788818359,
-0.5780534148216248,
0.12191988527774811,
0.14208358526229858,
0.17725533246994019,
0.322245329618454,
0.09800712764263153,
0.9646978378295898,
-0.34138011932373047,
-0.19848352670669556,
-0.16156621277332306,
0.06352758407592773,
0.1906145215034485,
0.5318554043769836,
0.7412752509117126,
-0.8171756863594055,
-0.7985421419143677,
-0.2609715461730957,
-0.6213208436965942,
-0.1386830359697342,
-0.024065867066383362,
0.04986110329627991,
0.10189558565616608,
0.8897301554679871,
-0.5111364126205444,
0.503637969493866,
0.2847168445587158,
-0.19087693095207214,
0.46423354744911194,
-0.14427174627780914,
-0.08512858301401138,
-1.081830382347107,
-0.11108707636594772,
-0.1205897405743599,
0.1255262792110443,
-0.7094534039497375,
-0.23651237785816193,
0.17378155887126923,
0.1917448490858078,
-0.5097962617874146,
0.49495455622673035,
-0.5528038144111633,
-0.34804049134254456,
-0.24187801778316498,
-0.22347335517406464,
-0.2769848704338074,
0.4115135371685028,
0.0449376106262207,
0.7746178507804871,
0.7336928248405457,
-0.6909403204917908,
-0.4941147565841675,
0.23453131318092346,
-0.7835366725921631,
0.14724813401699066,
-0.47313743829727173,
0.1296263039112091,
-0.5073410272598267,
0.2872096300125122,
-0.953160285949707,
-0.11719562113285065,
0.16481836140155792,
-0.11052346974611282,
0.13758040964603424,
-0.008762691169977188,
-0.5071701407432556,
-0.02632187120616436,
-0.04017987474799156,
0.7211667895317078,
0.27821993827819824,
-0.564903199672699,
0.008370834402740002,
0.21803617477416992,
-0.10644566267728806,
-0.6939435601234436,
-0.6326093077659607,
-0.33930301666259766,
-0.35174012184143066,
-0.1942506581544876,
0.3945474624633789,
-0.23862184584140778,
-0.3287726044654846,
0.1526571810245514,
-0.036385271698236465,
-0.13854408264160156,
0.3492629826068878,
0.3804379403591156,
0.03131410479545593,
-0.3728272020816803,
0.2868161201477051,
0.028142636641860008,
0.216657355427742,
0.11411663144826889,
-0.34363827109336853,
0.884060800075531,
-0.30859610438346863,
-0.4377501308917999,
-0.3710770606994629,
0.29360029101371765,
0.6024869680404663,
-0.3985860049724579,
1.006739616394043,
0.2563360929489136,
-0.19543126225471497,
-0.29885047674179077,
-0.3092806935310364,
-0.08446704596281052,
-0.4987890422344208,
0.5440196394920349,
-0.6646744012832642,
-0.8784051537513733,
0.6255401968955994,
0.05051953345537186,
-0.0942942276597023,
0.17528319358825684,
0.46115028858184814,
-0.31544792652130127,
0.9504874348640442,
0.5146229267120361,
-0.07331610471010208,
0.7517530918121338,
0.013258629478514194,
0.058878280222415924,
-0.6597768068313599,
-0.3124901056289673,
-0.6483182311058044,
-0.3768276572227478,
-0.3686133623123169,
-0.1238846406340599,
0.24186579883098602,
0.5301539897918701,
-0.24196772277355194,
0.08380135893821716,
-0.18045088648796082,
0.6438741087913513,
0.46087342500686646,
0.14546559751033783,
0.036160312592983246,
0.2696152627468109,
-0.2586227059364319,
0.12051974982023239,
-0.515485942363739,
-0.1037946566939354,
1.092409372329712,
0.13462477922439575,
0.4712531864643097,
-0.21394206583499908,
0.8877670764923096,
-0.06815429776906967,
0.523875892162323,
-0.39694324135780334,
0.4679940938949585,
-0.3705000877380371,
-0.2690761983394623,
-0.212172269821167,
-0.3741242587566376,
-0.927808403968811,
0.16696414351463318,
-0.11024147272109985,
-0.4733884632587433,
0.18389350175857544,
0.30913999676704407,
-0.06619134545326233,
0.28953787684440613,
-0.5737574100494385,
0.7639085650444031,
-0.2668727934360504,
-0.03744952753186226,
-0.18352635204792023,
-0.6162012815475464,
0.16473257541656494,
-0.17655892670154572,
0.21447406709194183,
-0.017824267968535423,
0.12254098802804947,
0.4911159574985504,
-0.370853453874588,
0.8309555649757385,
-0.18368451297283173,
0.24108704924583435,
0.1142791286110878,
-0.23980729281902313,
0.5555004477500916,
-0.1421266347169876,
0.06606706231832504,
0.1054566502571106,
-0.40600597858428955,
-0.5083500146865845,
-0.5091193318367004,
0.5406612753868103,
-0.7786194086074829,
-0.6781918406486511,
-0.14412976801395416,
-0.7283672094345093,
-0.13037775456905365,
0.24962662160396576,
0.5487760305404663,
0.672156572341919,
-0.015243162401020527,
0.5005035400390625,
0.539848804473877,
-0.16208995878696442,
0.5107606649398804,
0.36668866872787476,
0.002996521769091487,
-0.01921878196299076,
0.49745288491249084,
0.3493032455444336,
0.30711203813552856,
0.48786792159080505,
0.15290014445781708,
-0.25091657042503357,
-1.119132399559021,
-0.13514703512191772,
0.23785154521465302,
-0.7062283754348755,
0.20285944640636444,
-0.6329570412635803,
-0.11896597594022751,
-0.3860555589199066,
-0.24810726940631866,
-0.11342086642980576,
-0.05931553244590759,
-0.25814977288246155,
-0.23667016625404358,
0.008412332274019718,
0.6934160590171814,
0.26302313804626465,
0.49705174565315247,
-0.7590761184692383,
0.08003231883049011,
0.03312380239367485,
0.3837653398513794,
-0.1723189651966095,
-0.2955038845539093,
-0.4984692335128784,
-0.041888024657964706,
0.20795515179634094,
-0.6761376261711121,
0.29477787017822266,
0.33128029108047485,
0.627391517162323,
0.3595927953720093,
-0.14038752019405365,
0.942329466342926,
-0.7240878939628601,
0.4378294050693512,
0.12401087582111359,
-0.7913216948509216,
0.3756130337715149,
-0.4088593125343323,
0.5608894228935242,
0.6510708332061768,
0.5668304562568665,
-0.22301439940929413,
-0.372062623500824,
-0.4476121962070465,
-0.5514827966690063,
0.8447033166885376,
-0.04446284845471382,
-0.12724871933460236,
-0.23075808584690094,
0.518839955329895,
0.12256467342376709,
0.3409024477005005,
-0.7050855755805969,
-0.3962201476097107,
-0.1457492709159851,
-0.4162759482860565,
-0.31766805052757263,
-0.22140176594257355,
-0.0371226966381073,
-0.26842889189720154,
-0.0027144935447722673,
-0.05066888779401779,
-0.10695873200893402,
0.044642940163612366,
-0.5145595073699951,
0.1758861243724823,
0.20306004583835602,
0.6770058870315552,
0.6325054168701172,
-0.28827446699142456,
0.19805432856082916,
0.08681023865938187,
-0.45727622509002686,
0.06721370667219162,
0.04255646467208862,
-0.09704603254795074,
-0.056020647287368774,
0.3852904140949249,
1.0236541032791138,
0.3526865839958191,
-0.5349755883216858,
0.41187620162963867,
0.029383307322859764,
-0.05498551204800606,
-0.26974570751190186,
-0.04565838351845741,
-0.12570734322071075,
0.16998617351055145,
0.20841237902641296,
0.2643703818321228,
0.05270545557141304,
-0.6176695823669434,
0.45691224932670593,
0.2333168089389801,
-0.13523319363594055,
-0.5850781202316284,
0.3833164572715759,
-0.04754454642534256,
-0.27021121978759766,
0.7529151439666748,
0.03896404057741165,
-0.37650489807128906,
0.7596104145050049,
0.8484907150268555,
0.8812437057495117,
-0.27132391929626465,
-0.05151832103729248,
0.1174774095416069,
0.08551431447267532,
-0.10265765339136124,
0.11716461181640625,
-0.3572964370250702,
-0.7977247834205627,
-0.2996453642845154,
-0.6984285712242126,
0.03296518698334694,
0.18307124078273773,
-0.7358845472335815,
0.3315846621990204,
-0.5143799781799316,
0.33996888995170593,
-0.27366170287132263,
-0.4019705057144165,
-0.8776240348815918,
0.1892591416835785,
0.35493335127830505,
0.7500032782554626,
-0.9049856662750244,
1.389875888824463,
0.7785213589668274,
-0.16978095471858978,
-0.9130821824073792,
0.2896793782711029,
-0.09593448042869568,
-0.5773676037788391,
1.1468579769134521,
0.5465635657310486,
0.014151622541248798,
0.13759995996952057,
-0.3836040496826172,
-1.101320743560791,
0.8343778252601624,
0.5429741740226746,
-0.6380104422569275,
-0.23156720399856567,
0.5626600980758667,
0.41340455412864685,
-0.6672394275665283,
0.09774713963270187,
0.3538505733013153,
0.07440550625324249,
-0.2442706674337387,
-0.8432213664054871,
-0.09240361303091049,
-0.11368274688720703,
-0.10258987545967102,
0.335367888212204,
-0.3887460231781006,
1.4215103387832642,
0.08759099245071411,
-0.4393371343612671,
-0.13395115733146667,
0.4626293182373047,
0.5051140785217285,
0.21596582233905792,
0.8008155822753906,
0.49589550495147705,
0.6066597104072571,
0.13653208315372467,
1.0219827890396118,
-0.3394862115383148,
0.07236996293067932,
1.3330484628677368,
-0.19215454161167145,
0.814917266368866,
0.5108049511909485,
0.21762138605117798,
0.7915812730789185,
0.5763748288154602,
0.29230573773384094,
0.762397050857544,
0.20213685929775238,
-0.148203507065773,
-0.17936068773269653,
0.006717788986861706,
-0.4592759609222412,
0.43386101722717285,
0.6293003559112549,
-0.3574525713920593,
-0.43836095929145813,
0.373587429523468,
-0.010461889207363129,
0.11204244196414948,
-0.37686288356781006,
0.48764950037002563,
0.19624176621437073,
-0.6470329761505127,
0.6011016964912415,
-0.32517075538635254,
0.47865402698516846,
-0.6508317589759827,
0.07514701783657074,
-0.2607010304927826,
0.3765559494495392,
-0.14751429855823517,
-0.5323323011398315,
0.3949590027332306,
-0.24501141905784607,
-0.3706890940666199,
-0.4439693093299866,
0.43672776222229004,
-0.6877263188362122,
-0.1410997360944748,
0.3927178978919983,
0.36249664425849915,
0.2519775331020355,
-0.10615496337413788,
-0.612678587436676,
0.0647592544555664,
-0.09976722300052643,
-0.3123236298561096,
0.756671130657196,
0.27868345379829407,
-0.26718848943710327,
0.28444233536720276,
0.6419980525970459,
0.06992466747760773,
0.4083383083343506,
0.12655486166477203,
0.9957751035690308,
-0.5805230140686035,
-0.6390663385391235,
-0.9929856061935425,
0.44740211963653564,
-0.027635496109724045,
-0.4198267161846161,
0.912513017654419,
0.5360433459281921,
1.4752405881881714,
-0.12605053186416626,
0.6200439929962158,
0.17101094126701355,
0.41977110505104065,
-0.7486061453819275,
0.601422131061554,
-0.5314380526542664,
0.33927828073501587,
-0.16805152595043182,
-0.8398129940032959,
-0.39024847745895386,
0.2099168300628662,
-0.4516812264919281,
-0.311792254447937,
0.9419455528259277,
0.7602030038833618,
-0.08215010911226273,
-0.13091768324375153,
0.18445923924446106,
0.3156220614910126,
0.24326997995376587,
0.3451046645641327,
0.8572826981544495,
-0.004641145002096891,
0.40846794843673706,
-0.27134212851524353,
-0.11066161841154099,
-0.00013162099639885128,
-0.48284590244293213,
-1.2337018251419067,
-0.7731180787086487,
-0.0023039928637444973,
-0.012351492419838905,
0.11047616600990295,
0.9147613644599915,
0.6398642659187317,
-0.8215619325637817,
-0.5095243453979492,
-0.4663909375667572,
0.005301908124238253,
-0.10362707078456879,
-0.11586406081914902,
0.6472817063331604,
-0.8394179344177246,
-0.6571084856987,
0.779610276222229,
0.24662832915782928,
0.11950377374887466,
0.2907553017139435,
0.030688833445310593,
-0.15327738225460052,
-0.20437225699424744,
0.48428305983543396,
0.3857805132865906,
-0.5306035280227661,
-0.31157898902893066,
0.011293996125459671,
-0.09003156423568726,
0.20695392787456512,
1.001212239265442,
-0.8205586671829224,
0.27570798993110657,
0.6693102121353149,
0.6547053456306458,
0.3281908333301544,
0.041997604072093964,
0.5831514000892639,
-0.9994853734970093,
0.719954252243042,
-0.02560250088572502,
0.43865934014320374,
-0.034341588616371155,
-0.23882195353507996,
-0.03373090177774429,
0.23465101420879364,
-0.4037091135978699,
-0.973660409450531,
0.34520211815834045,
-0.4642695486545563,
-0.5079934597015381,
0.8055545091629028,
-0.25845614075660706,
-0.3756803572177887,
-0.3228384256362915,
0.17760194838047028,
0.2524147033691406,
0.15325827896595,
0.7291428446769714,
0.6471396684646606,
-0.2341623157262802,
-0.14311784505844116,
-0.10781848430633545,
0.8463465571403503,
0.7566031813621521,
-0.8042891025543213,
-0.19027480483055115,
0.2668110728263855,
0.3669988214969635,
-0.07461800426244736,
0.7068645358085632,
-0.12027747929096222,
0.06311806291341782,
-0.2824351489543915,
-0.17075049877166748,
-0.17408540844917297,
-0.6944573521614075,
-0.4203571081161499,
0.4195326268672943,
0.10841794312000275,
-0.4628094732761383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12513v1 | Induced Model Matching: How Restricted Models Can Help Larger Ones | 2024-02-19T20:21:09 | 2024-02-19T20:21:09 | Usama Muneeb, Mesrob I. Ohannessian | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We consider scenarios where a very accurate predictive model using restricted
features is available at the time of training of a larger, full-featured,
model. This restricted model may be thought of as "side-information", derived
either from an auxiliary exhaustive dataset or on the same dataset, by forcing
the restriction. How can the restricted model be useful to the full model? We
propose an approach for transferring the knowledge of the restricted model to
the full model, by aligning the full model's context-restricted performance
with that of the restricted model's. We call this methodology Induced Model
Matching (IMM) and first illustrate its general applicability by using logistic
regression as a toy example. We then explore IMM's use in language modeling,
the application that initially inspired it, and where it offers an explicit
foundation in contrast to the implicit use of restricted models in techniques
such as noising. We demonstrate the methodology on both LSTM and transformer
full models, using $N$-grams as restricted models. To further illustrate the
potential of the principle whenever it is much cheaper to collect restricted
rather than full information, we conclude with a simple RL example where POMDP
policies can improve learned MDP policies via IMM. | [
-0.39560243487358093,
-0.5806710124015808,
0.5442679524421692,
-0.05798511207103729,
-0.16722777485847473,
-0.32144322991371155,
-0.051086828112602234,
-0.804533839225769,
0.049867384135723114,
0.9522712826728821,
-0.4091030955314636,
0.006036142352968454,
-0.48658305406570435,
-0.036732014268636703,
-0.6935806274414062,
0.754109799861908,
-0.09533584117889404,
0.2642616033554077,
-0.5961447954177856,
-0.06562622636556625,
-0.46512553095817566,
-0.7221707701683044,
-0.3622564673423767,
-0.495218962430954,
0.411088764667511,
0.15304121375083923,
0.6474637985229492,
0.869979739189148,
0.5653811097145081,
0.202772855758667,
-0.07318948954343796,
0.12184422463178635,
-0.4080699384212494,
0.1420210301876068,
-0.3030039072036743,
-0.7077053785324097,
0.005385465454310179,
0.08949820697307587,
0.7545043230056763,
0.5579678416252136,
0.15219387412071228,
-0.045719657093286514,
0.31639131903648376,
0.602110743522644,
-0.7754766345024109,
0.07232025265693665,
-0.7466862797737122,
0.13380753993988037,
0.0668836161494255,
-0.24901245534420013,
-0.48774266242980957,
-0.1103324145078659,
0.31985512375831604,
-0.43529319763183594,
0.39875534176826477,
0.09505956619977951,
0.9003751277923584,
0.27363938093185425,
-0.6947368383407593,
-0.31488412618637085,
-1.1003100872039795,
0.5869600176811218,
-0.725530743598938,
0.25607848167419434,
0.4309316873550415,
0.43692082166671753,
-0.19947996735572815,
-0.5627548694610596,
-0.502613365650177,
-0.32981809973716736,
-0.5914602875709534,
-0.009868374094367027,
-0.12797516584396362,
0.2630236744880676,
0.6667697429656982,
0.24195314943790436,
-0.3440384566783905,
0.2532849907875061,
-0.47900640964508057,
-0.012873640283942223,
0.6344666481018066,
0.16171151399612427,
0.12980756163597107,
0.16220085322856903,
-0.4145084023475647,
0.041037771850824356,
-1.0150361061096191,
-0.3746243119239807,
0.4097864329814911,
0.6039000749588013,
0.0317530483007431,
0.9844832420349121,
-0.09886673837900162,
0.8712376356124878,
0.057385753840208054,
0.026425017043948174,
-0.05619488283991814,
-0.31415292620658875,
-0.32184168696403503,
0.01468301098793745,
0.41124260425567627,
0.26292654871940613,
0.34210360050201416,
-0.08107023686170578,
-0.30280354619026184,
0.03511039540171623,
-0.10846109688282013,
-0.8428949117660522,
0.08136653900146484,
-0.12312053143978119,
-0.31344011425971985,
-0.07729615271091461,
0.17488417029380798,
-0.7088266015052795,
-0.6637288331985474,
-0.5101919174194336,
0.7629826664924622,
-0.009804172441363335,
-0.39563289284706116,
0.02897036075592041,
-0.25751200318336487,
0.7588034272193909,
0.09012876451015472,
-1.05563485622406,
0.4143022298812866,
0.8199049830436707,
0.8767905831336975,
0.07090018689632416,
-0.058406759053468704,
-0.43978413939476013,
0.06642061471939087,
-0.2858080565929413,
0.4866170287132263,
-0.5481336116790771,
-0.32083743810653687,
0.09474365413188934,
-0.003908126149326563,
-0.2896634042263031,
-0.9227554798126221,
0.027518659830093384,
-0.484500914812088,
0.2165810465812683,
-0.03090624511241913,
-0.7601239085197449,
-0.07337135821580887,
0.02999044768512249,
-0.7721115946769714,
0.6092166304588318,
0.07917880266904831,
-0.7403531670570374,
0.43728119134902954,
-0.6500921845436096,
-0.46444153785705566,
-0.3473412096500397,
-0.2774611711502075,
-0.38530686497688293,
0.2864221930503845,
0.03401944413781166,
0.4414307475090027,
-0.45115581154823303,
0.1702665090560913,
-0.5995301604270935,
-0.08662985265254974,
0.4414261281490326,
-0.18680186569690704,
0.6350054740905762,
0.2056230902671814,
0.06703591346740723,
0.3406006097793579,
-0.5276147723197937,
-0.35887905955314636,
0.14052562415599823,
-0.06907658278942108,
-0.5493155121803284,
-0.08535762876272202,
-0.11359838396310806,
0.3690829873085022,
0.044399239122867584,
-0.3529830276966095,
0.24431173503398895,
-0.17818725109100342,
0.5110111832618713,
0.7522764801979065,
0.12475846707820892,
0.6879744529724121,
-0.4986822307109833,
0.6491246819496155,
0.050533000379800797,
0.172139972448349,
0.07993373274803162,
-0.4247419238090515,
-0.733284056186676,
-0.37027671933174133,
0.6720574498176575,
0.5762351155281067,
-0.57558274269104,
0.23785558342933655,
0.16363781690597534,
-0.26936009526252747,
-0.5263548493385315,
-0.0199454203248024,
0.2198028415441513,
0.47547850012779236,
0.2570289373397827,
-0.3194744288921356,
-0.7707069516181946,
-1.0019651651382446,
-0.3734007179737091,
0.13359764218330383,
-0.26373618841171265,
0.5506156086921692,
0.4067070782184601,
-0.13678821921348572,
0.9236063361167908,
-0.4417358636856079,
-0.34191766381263733,
-0.31212225556373596,
-0.2864086925983429,
0.20743033289909363,
0.7677838206291199,
0.6686521768569946,
-0.7701302170753479,
-0.5642340779304504,
-0.04427535459399223,
-0.6747758984565735,
-0.06572455167770386,
-0.10445749014616013,
-0.271642804145813,
-0.16049474477767944,
0.5315914750099182,
-0.6781441569328308,
0.5321496725082397,
0.606246829032898,
-0.41268306970596313,
0.5247515439987183,
-0.3672555685043335,
-0.07844719290733337,
-1.1452544927597046,
-0.04956568777561188,
0.25266674160957336,
-0.35640639066696167,
-0.6886740326881409,
0.16081474721431732,
0.1981409192085266,
-0.30597054958343506,
-0.29134151339530945,
0.7711812853813171,
-0.5854495167732239,
-0.09717864543199539,
-0.5885622501373291,
0.018855059519410133,
-0.05488450080156326,
0.13520537316799164,
0.09324333816766739,
0.6087536215782166,
0.6085372567176819,
-0.7102946043014526,
0.2728915512561798,
0.275052011013031,
-0.5521864295005798,
0.40663501620292664,
-0.35472607612609863,
0.036325715482234955,
-0.16516341269016266,
0.08510803431272507,
-0.5750714540481567,
-0.344970166683197,
0.1335066258907318,
-0.15152841806411743,
0.5059564113616943,
-0.37354376912117004,
-0.3373417854309082,
-0.13766588270664215,
0.08562876284122467,
0.4076831042766571,
0.7764312624931335,
-0.7712697982788086,
0.7567669153213501,
0.2643547058105469,
0.15397284924983978,
-0.5586703419685364,
-0.5589457750320435,
-0.1733689308166504,
-0.6368710398674011,
-0.36744457483291626,
0.4145951569080353,
-0.24805374443531036,
-0.47245335578918457,
0.18517859280109406,
-0.08499472588300705,
-0.2054230123758316,
0.2969622313976288,
0.16068139672279358,
0.2208772450685501,
-0.29683831334114075,
0.19253171980381012,
0.1031288355588913,
0.010561483912169933,
-0.06467685103416443,
-0.13118283450603485,
0.43685245513916016,
0.452696830034256,
-0.29857921600341797,
-0.3944690227508545,
0.4568807780742645,
0.38168954849243164,
-0.09101233631372452,
1.0439523458480835,
0.12988099455833435,
-0.5553932189941406,
-0.22158282995224,
-0.45905545353889465,
-0.5468953251838684,
-0.41717055439949036,
0.3984282314777374,
-0.5567431449890137,
-0.7843545079231262,
0.4572652578353882,
0.05203527212142944,
-0.15363091230392456,
0.48797696828842163,
0.37658554315567017,
0.34315192699432373,
1.40131676197052,
1.1505600214004517,
-0.12637436389923096,
0.9204986691474915,
0.06012370064854622,
0.07580440491437912,
-0.8800899982452393,
-0.14056384563446045,
-0.6074212789535522,
-0.31417685747146606,
-0.6629111766815186,
-0.1276833415031433,
-0.07287300378084183,
0.21105293929576874,
-0.022403327748179436,
0.4039148986339569,
-0.25379467010498047,
0.5836705565452576,
0.7069409489631653,
0.4158343970775604,
0.32296818494796753,
-0.24030467867851257,
-0.013570591807365417,
0.10399606823921204,
-0.8361626267433167,
0.017687752842903137,
1.222782015800476,
0.2762800455093384,
1.038098692893982,
-0.03407119959592819,
0.33717191219329834,
0.18499106168746948,
0.6218291521072388,
-0.8948712944984436,
0.41255632042884827,
-0.043077725917100906,
-0.7919497489929199,
0.02234727144241333,
-0.6888081431388855,
-0.7937262058258057,
0.15185628831386566,
-0.5573403835296631,
-0.572557806968689,
0.5106685757637024,
0.29698076844215393,
-0.10035967081785202,
0.3003332018852234,
-0.7646459341049194,
0.5394237041473389,
-0.25735893845558167,
-0.3156324625015259,
-0.17750340700149536,
-0.5231596231460571,
0.47912558913230896,
-0.348916232585907,
-0.018518537282943726,
-0.24391265213489532,
0.14994464814662933,
0.785998523235321,
-0.35945945978164673,
0.7147619128227234,
-0.33451980352401733,
0.005116653628647327,
0.03303550183773041,
0.05283433198928833,
0.45531684160232544,
-0.13939693570137024,
-0.08408351242542267,
-0.06039281189441681,
0.010526894591748714,
-0.3858599364757538,
-0.7243063449859619,
0.6393247842788696,
-0.6553463935852051,
-1.0456496477127075,
-0.15172652900218964,
-0.8666716814041138,
-0.1734798550605774,
0.19003163278102875,
0.24000470340251923,
0.2136242687702179,
0.1639232635498047,
0.37558257579803467,
0.6189428567886353,
0.04223491623997688,
0.0046941074542701244,
0.6126480102539062,
-0.555172860622406,
-0.08427530527114868,
0.41940173506736755,
0.17604458332061768,
0.5651640892028809,
0.6597568988800049,
0.3903661072254181,
-0.3121396601200104,
-0.46964457631111145,
0.06229362264275551,
0.4000200033187866,
-0.7169950604438782,
-0.2883894741535187,
-0.39509937167167664,
-0.39830175042152405,
-0.41742441058158875,
0.07694864273071289,
-0.1337868571281433,
-0.5711339712142944,
-0.33373111486434937,
-0.20732054114341736,
0.28215649724006653,
0.8137208223342896,
-0.3070446848869324,
0.2942250370979309,
-0.38207709789276123,
0.017854440957307816,
0.41246354579925537,
0.28987306356430054,
-0.12553061544895172,
-0.7599138021469116,
-0.30880627036094666,
0.003963252529501915,
0.05474922060966492,
-0.8910810947418213,
0.29748380184173584,
0.33760637044906616,
0.598046600818634,
0.49670904874801636,
0.21616867184638977,
0.5660707354545593,
-0.39036354422569275,
0.1732705980539322,
0.0820847824215889,
-0.8211730718612671,
0.3689202666282654,
0.05047321692109108,
-0.05325959622859955,
0.13042579591274261,
0.5720080137252808,
-0.402461975812912,
-0.4251868426799774,
-0.41228920221328735,
-0.6582793593406677,
0.44127970933914185,
-0.07338475435972214,
0.20622479915618896,
0.1589375138282776,
0.747307538986206,
0.17059077322483063,
0.20634905993938446,
-0.9314090609550476,
-0.007218027487397194,
0.07582230120897293,
-0.34961193799972534,
-0.15262773633003235,
-0.46871232986450195,
-0.40482592582702637,
-0.11807502806186676,
0.7241612672805786,
-0.14653380215168,
0.33422353863716125,
0.3112157881259918,
-0.22516538202762604,
0.006206035614013672,
0.03740578517317772,
0.612406849861145,
0.7509649395942688,
-0.2207004427909851,
0.12593959271907806,
0.049008555710315704,
0.01113164983689785,
0.05295049399137497,
0.3011724054813385,
-0.23683585226535797,
-0.21356280148029327,
0.20015449821949005,
0.870556652545929,
-0.24187830090522766,
-0.6759054064750671,
0.3000655472278595,
-0.11167693138122559,
-0.27719300985336304,
-0.04045134410262108,
0.24972403049468994,
-0.19289062917232513,
0.6952915191650391,
0.2224503457546234,
-0.14788322150707245,
-0.11407612264156342,
-0.5329617261886597,
0.2567092776298523,
0.8212733864784241,
-0.6621155738830566,
-0.19783808290958405,
0.8277778625488281,
-0.014385581947863102,
-0.3673917055130005,
0.5874813199043274,
0.290517121553421,
-0.3409385681152344,
0.7740206122398376,
0.9840952157974243,
0.7258877158164978,
-0.308926522731781,
-0.1411665976047516,
0.3327517509460449,
0.41061484813690186,
-0.1450456976890564,
-0.09969480335712433,
-0.03406871482729912,
-0.9605695605278015,
-0.44720616936683655,
-0.30655744671821594,
-0.43646693229675293,
0.32894331216812134,
-0.784477949142456,
0.4051327109336853,
-0.4895632266998291,
-0.07312256097793579,
-0.11060385406017303,
-0.38393160700798035,
-0.7918569445610046,
-0.01985306106507778,
0.08267290145158768,
1.0775651931762695,
-1.1392693519592285,
0.8317837119102478,
0.3452679514884949,
-0.40665385127067566,
-0.6883355975151062,
0.014471800997853279,
-0.35139358043670654,
-0.9361470341682434,
0.3647177815437317,
0.30320489406585693,
0.37373265624046326,
0.05141255632042885,
-0.5656291842460632,
-0.7333666086196899,
1.0212936401367188,
0.3894633650779724,
-0.6355783343315125,
-0.0832221731543541,
0.0799998864531517,
0.32223623991012573,
-0.5883776545524597,
0.09958835691213608,
0.5550082921981812,
0.1001034528017044,
0.002877701073884964,
-0.8993858098983765,
0.35786640644073486,
0.0270003080368042,
-0.1260906308889389,
0.4120129644870758,
-0.3628428280353546,
0.8093029856681824,
-0.2494058758020401,
-0.27617841958999634,
0.35901492834091187,
0.4572620093822479,
0.01150564569979906,
0.17452117800712585,
0.5739898085594177,
0.25433358550071716,
0.5563033819198608,
0.02792028896510601,
0.8742576241493225,
-0.3108522891998291,
0.5105592608451843,
1.0575135946273804,
-0.5447410941123962,
0.6541622877120972,
0.5405744314193726,
-0.04758286476135254,
0.11661706119775772,
0.6281564831733704,
-0.04241272062063217,
0.7304173111915588,
0.26637423038482666,
-0.31690558791160583,
-0.11214832961559296,
-0.34174996614456177,
-0.5426515936851501,
0.23646342754364014,
0.35960695147514343,
-0.6298567652702332,
-0.10783747583627701,
0.3122211992740631,
-0.19568097591400146,
-0.05869119614362717,
-0.3416714370250702,
1.1204642057418823,
0.2401248961687088,
-0.43572095036506653,
0.26928988099098206,
-0.1306285858154297,
0.4849798381328583,
-0.8123795986175537,
-0.019081581383943558,
-0.35449743270874023,
0.2684589922428131,
-0.1210334375500679,
-0.4819711446762085,
0.30490830540657043,
-0.27061226963996887,
-0.2822524607181549,
-0.09817789494991302,
1.0048706531524658,
-0.5994939804077148,
-0.35533782839775085,
0.48960745334625244,
0.5284255743026733,
-0.15401123464107513,
-0.10384541749954224,
-0.513322114944458,
-0.41668906807899475,
0.019632535055279732,
-0.06519614160060883,
0.6546819806098938,
0.2541854977607727,
0.05856815725564957,
0.7261136174201965,
0.5075005292892456,
0.13055182993412018,
-0.03767142444849014,
-0.20252615213394165,
0.767288863658905,
-0.6874037384986877,
-0.3423265218734741,
-0.9714482426643372,
0.18457211554050446,
0.05260070040822029,
0.1409022957086563,
0.7049441337585449,
0.5793055891990662,
0.8537464737892151,
-0.06579644232988358,
0.9703245759010315,
0.03582621365785599,
0.4885396361351013,
-0.8024505972862244,
0.40777191519737244,
-0.6674981713294983,
0.2215137928724289,
0.05591324344277382,
-1.0954806804656982,
-0.4778948426246643,
0.39161917567253113,
-0.5189306735992432,
-0.08278696238994598,
0.49166712164878845,
0.8746318221092224,
-0.312053382396698,
-0.1939437836408615,
0.5215333104133606,
0.15981656312942505,
0.31775766611099243,
0.4105214476585388,
1.069769024848938,
0.05624724179506302,
0.3927901089191437,
-0.41427522897720337,
-0.4271972179412842,
-0.28251737356185913,
-0.8285630941390991,
-0.9670138955116272,
-0.49135875701904297,
-0.19797031581401825,
-0.6812186241149902,
-0.05702042207121849,
0.8830671310424805,
0.6794481873512268,
-0.6984965205192566,
-0.2971458435058594,
-0.12723545730113983,
0.3082823157310486,
-0.15999871492385864,
-0.21224583685398102,
0.09964097291231155,
0.03684429079294205,
-0.5966901779174805,
0.2977645993232727,
-0.05797470360994339,
0.3993698060512543,
-0.22287197411060333,
0.10855825990438461,
-0.18301783502101898,
0.2404552549123764,
0.4519656300544739,
0.4032531678676605,
-0.17758551239967346,
-0.3412081301212311,
-0.1541701704263687,
0.1878252923488617,
0.1361057460308075,
1.2307246923446655,
-0.6548182368278503,
0.4828607439994812,
0.45176512002944946,
0.7616987824440002,
0.7384767532348633,
-0.11635448783636093,
0.8649240732192993,
-0.7245797514915466,
0.4391462504863739,
0.1378132402896881,
0.5104586482048035,
0.2975631356239319,
-0.39577534794807434,
0.5799076557159424,
0.1682136207818985,
-0.5308383703231812,
-0.9974969625473022,
0.6888013482093811,
-0.5317309498786926,
-0.2500746548175812,
1.087685465812683,
-0.03755202889442444,
-0.049696702510118484,
0.036053936928510666,
-0.18397057056427002,
0.32459935545921326,
0.010250953026115894,
0.8097386956214905,
0.5697996616363525,
-0.33717265725135803,
-0.25619447231292725,
-0.5913923978805542,
0.46557432413101196,
0.27889692783355713,
-0.7977942824363708,
0.015398390591144562,
0.14596304297447205,
0.271519273519516,
-0.08849971741437912,
0.2685880661010742,
0.12503473460674286,
-0.11208739876747131,
-0.0550304614007473,
-0.1508735567331314,
0.024743251502513885,
-0.25310513377189636,
-0.5055940747261047,
-0.08506268262863159,
0.396160364151001,
-0.09435462951660156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12501v1 | Your Vision-Language Model Itself Is a Strong Filter: Towards High-Quality Instruction Tuning with Data Selection | 2024-02-19T20:08:48 | 2024-02-19T20:08:48 | Ruibo Chen, Yihan Wu, Lichang Chen, Guodong Liu, Qi He, Tianyi Xiong, Chenxi Liu, Junfeng Guo, Heng Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data selection in instruction tuning emerges as a pivotal process for
acquiring high-quality data and training instruction-following large language
models (LLMs), but it is still a new and unexplored research area for
vision-language models (VLMs). Existing data selection approaches on LLMs
either rely on single unreliable scores, or use downstream tasks for selection,
which is time-consuming and can lead to potential over-fitting on the chosen
evaluation datasets. To address this challenge, we introduce a novel dataset
selection method, Self-Filter, that utilizes the VLM itself as a filter. This
approach is inspired by the observation that VLMs benefit from training with
the most challenging instructions. Self-Filter operates in two stages. In the
first stage, we devise a scoring network to evaluate the difficulty of training
instructions, which is co-trained with the VLM. In the second stage, we use the
trained score net to measure the difficulty of each instruction, select the
most challenging samples, and penalize similar samples to encourage diversity.
Comprehensive experiments on LLaVA and MiniGPT-4 show that Self-Filter can
reach better results compared to full data settings with merely about 15%
samples, and can achieve superior performance against competitive baselines. | [
-0.6037439107894897,
-0.4053137004375458,
0.39263367652893066,
-0.036063216626644135,
-0.4520941972732544,
0.023657197132706642,
-0.1315809041261673,
-0.2725312411785126,
0.09382061660289764,
0.8472470641136169,
-0.7099842429161072,
-0.6159593462944031,
-0.3873712122440338,
-0.00958616565912962,
-0.4763510227203369,
1.0029343366622925,
0.13459844887256622,
0.29966047406196594,
-0.3175981938838959,
-0.060215625911951065,
-0.540055513381958,
-0.26818931102752686,
-0.5492572784423828,
-0.41974103450775146,
0.4102412164211273,
0.37766674160957336,
0.2667061388492584,
1.0211186408996582,
0.6442822217941284,
0.2719089984893799,
0.128219872713089,
0.3370470404624939,
-0.5608449578285217,
0.3322941064834595,
-0.10719530284404755,
-0.42187124490737915,
-0.21365250647068024,
0.09543251246213913,
0.5064045786857605,
0.4029166102409363,
-0.15390481054782867,
0.49725663661956787,
0.2932748794555664,
0.9355456829071045,
-0.8376264572143555,
-0.05501779913902283,
-0.6362283825874329,
0.3316349685192108,
-0.3309384286403656,
-0.09625624120235443,
-0.37272441387176514,
-0.06766434758901596,
-0.1991848647594452,
-0.27104055881500244,
0.2902332544326782,
0.24146175384521484,
0.6619864702224731,
0.5446707010269165,
-0.10749433189630508,
0.007345604710280895,
-0.5950826406478882,
0.9040515422821045,
-0.34593382477760315,
0.4752447307109833,
0.6543176174163818,
0.48280197381973267,
0.13484017550945282,
-0.5299779772758484,
-0.2516186237335205,
-0.11971747875213623,
0.14230509102344513,
0.36572331190109253,
0.12096734344959259,
0.11238254606723785,
0.05781659856438637,
0.40712079405784607,
-0.74808669090271,
0.3067481517791748,
-0.6367759108543396,
-0.2084030658006668,
0.614358127117157,
0.2493010014295578,
-0.12460467964410782,
-0.2259320467710495,
-0.25373759865760803,
-0.1994812935590744,
-0.7246136665344238,
-0.06889849156141281,
0.4343145489692688,
0.3068903982639313,
0.26921728253364563,
0.44704869389533997,
-0.4639812707901001,
1.2599295377731323,
0.04844199866056442,
0.021400513127446175,
0.13722079992294312,
-0.22385935485363007,
-0.41735491156578064,
-0.09537597000598907,
0.6457151770591736,
0.19924335181713104,
0.20921224355697632,
0.22206193208694458,
-0.4760497212409973,
-0.031251538544893265,
0.4549713134765625,
-0.6951980590820312,
-0.5925354361534119,
-0.11944802850484848,
-0.4719208776950836,
-0.3140668570995331,
-0.11124160140752792,
-0.9317503571510315,
-0.09192553907632828,
-0.4891888499259949,
0.327287495136261,
0.025781864300370216,
0.09056288003921509,
0.04347200319170952,
0.2509499788284302,
0.2796700894832611,
0.2167547196149826,
-0.9086439609527588,
0.24385079741477966,
0.4331135153770447,
0.6302980184555054,
-0.4609118402004242,
-0.3758001923561096,
-0.8403184413909912,
-0.24155773222446442,
-0.5289974212646484,
0.8521470427513123,
-0.8824992775917053,
-0.3337758183479309,
-0.2623872756958008,
-0.31772035360336304,
-0.06783280521631241,
-0.5717076659202576,
0.3922063112258911,
-0.6163944005966187,
0.21873830258846283,
-0.0841938778758049,
-0.5911549925804138,
-0.019491855055093765,
0.04856804013252258,
-0.6596955060958862,
1.2892932891845703,
0.3036019802093506,
-0.26647940278053284,
0.5998085737228394,
-0.2552698850631714,
-0.4626706540584564,
0.20916114747524261,
-0.26472190022468567,
-0.6208910942077637,
0.13167905807495117,
0.5202098488807678,
0.4484351873397827,
-0.13470496237277985,
-0.10387896001338959,
-0.556609570980072,
-0.4349449872970581,
-0.28576043248176575,
-0.6403007507324219,
0.5260609984397888,
0.3008035719394684,
-0.3910563886165619,
0.06567732989788055,
-0.8807178139686584,
0.5495607256889343,
-0.1121131107211113,
-0.40857967734336853,
-0.2639450132846832,
0.037642817944288254,
-0.33264121413230896,
0.3521560728549957,
0.11946997791528702,
-0.484578937292099,
0.13444297015666962,
-0.25546374917030334,
0.15167993307113647,
1.0027859210968018,
-0.16359956562519073,
0.1145978569984436,
-0.10640273243188858,
0.5787354707717896,
-0.2707882821559906,
0.6446647047996521,
-0.00896076112985611,
-0.4896886646747589,
-1.0148216485977173,
-0.16765354573726654,
0.16936281323432922,
0.5263586044311523,
-0.9409908056259155,
0.5538874268531799,
0.034468621015548706,
-0.4155347943305969,
-0.9906736612319946,
0.8913964629173279,
0.5829620361328125,
0.4825967252254486,
0.6155683398246765,
-0.3378085196018219,
-0.3644261658191681,
-0.7421676516532898,
-0.05063041299581528,
-0.04355667158961296,
0.20738312602043152,
0.4045148491859436,
0.26729753613471985,
0.16646212339401245,
0.8377701640129089,
-0.6343731880187988,
-0.5277037024497986,
-0.25589048862457275,
-0.28258657455444336,
0.3436569273471832,
0.32752034068107605,
0.4336474537849426,
-0.8078038692474365,
-0.5604419708251953,
-0.19249588251113892,
-0.754084587097168,
-0.2823695242404938,
0.08155886828899384,
-0.2487090677022934,
0.015227884985506535,
0.4611164927482605,
-0.0011030721943825483,
0.501128077507019,
0.7431407570838928,
-0.34094908833503723,
0.35544249415397644,
-0.39740264415740967,
0.1148715391755104,
-0.5269723534584045,
-0.3336743116378784,
0.11528085917234421,
-0.43056899309158325,
-0.2472158521413803,
-0.0461873896420002,
0.1714172512292862,
0.16287297010421753,
-0.4526183605194092,
0.4578271806240082,
-0.6383816599845886,
-0.08190445601940155,
-0.5104308128356934,
-0.08978655189275742,
0.16235141456127167,
0.5144643783569336,
-0.041029192507267,
0.6606646180152893,
0.834860622882843,
-0.7517347931861877,
0.6424195766448975,
0.17877459526062012,
-0.7299656271934509,
0.5592468976974487,
-0.40967971086502075,
0.2853964567184448,
-0.12929971516132355,
-0.1639862358570099,
-0.8301022052764893,
0.086271733045578,
0.18320360779762268,
-0.0321505144238472,
0.42160892486572266,
-0.46995845437049866,
-0.14400748908519745,
-0.6921855807304382,
-0.11915016919374466,
0.16368485987186432,
0.4962684214115143,
-0.887297511100769,
0.3597027361392975,
0.2907835841178894,
0.2253398895263672,
-0.47837212681770325,
-0.6210654973983765,
0.03070329874753952,
-0.08300602436065674,
-0.2383469045162201,
-0.01860783062875271,
-0.24409537017345428,
0.1478879153728485,
-0.12778887152671814,
-0.2835999131202698,
-0.08351200819015503,
0.11109206825494766,
0.11098796874284744,
0.49859291315078735,
-0.24233697354793549,
0.0825866162776947,
0.0024966271594166756,
-0.20337021350860596,
-0.058442577719688416,
-0.43007031083106995,
0.39349719882011414,
0.005881637334823608,
-0.6470937132835388,
-0.3417375683784485,
0.1720900982618332,
0.292452335357666,
-0.6230360269546509,
0.433188796043396,
0.5430975556373596,
0.16850119829177856,
-0.7398725152015686,
-0.5993674397468567,
-0.35364383459091187,
-0.5518712401390076,
0.4912068247795105,
-0.466166228055954,
-0.7970521450042725,
-0.10037041455507278,
0.34038081765174866,
0.01225972082465887,
0.2058754563331604,
0.34100010991096497,
-0.325626015663147,
1.078731894493103,
0.35943153500556946,
-0.21880239248275757,
0.6896365880966187,
-0.31305307149887085,
0.10422313213348389,
-0.9178521633148193,
-0.0854741781949997,
-0.2844257354736328,
-0.3108018934726715,
-0.46233922243118286,
-0.2683471143245697,
0.5616751313209534,
-0.22265292704105377,
-0.06647784262895584,
0.08713104575872421,
-0.7700386047363281,
0.8142500519752502,
0.7522560954093933,
0.3913423418998718,
0.01205864641815424,
0.18168918788433075,
0.07442109286785126,
-0.0765475258231163,
-0.6597300171852112,
-0.18005970120429993,
1.2085505723953247,
0.029332954436540604,
1.0258716344833374,
-0.2607651650905609,
0.8708533048629761,
0.26119035482406616,
0.12450292706489563,
-0.5553652048110962,
0.7082772850990295,
-0.7896610498428345,
-0.6132596731185913,
-0.5205408930778503,
-0.5237967371940613,
-0.8789350986480713,
0.4545156955718994,
-0.18903370201587677,
-0.4939882159233093,
-0.01071425061672926,
0.41265812516212463,
-0.43574297428131104,
0.27773693203926086,
-0.6536861658096313,
0.8338001370429993,
-0.5497180819511414,
-0.4570583701133728,
-0.1946781873703003,
-0.4885619282722473,
0.20251375436782837,
-0.15954571962356567,
0.06789140403270721,
-0.2693997919559479,
0.28315454721450806,
0.5782347321510315,
-0.19330979883670807,
0.9144219160079956,
-0.3131307363510132,
0.09922199696302414,
0.4170302450656891,
0.15203401446342468,
0.2635921239852905,
-0.18319791555404663,
-0.176200270652771,
0.17464950680732727,
-0.22494299709796906,
-0.32831987738609314,
-0.7544359564781189,
0.7290465235710144,
-0.6152956485748291,
-0.7766278982162476,
-0.22934484481811523,
-0.0036635363940149546,
-0.1670188456773758,
0.19614198803901672,
0.2870733141899109,
0.5884674787521362,
0.18645846843719482,
0.3211982548236847,
0.6146945953369141,
0.015621811151504517,
0.37947380542755127,
0.5540230870246887,
-0.3359394371509552,
-0.41070690751075745,
1.2754462957382202,
0.3112297058105469,
0.4793069362640381,
0.2703606188297272,
0.3868011236190796,
-0.17260219156742096,
-0.7857380509376526,
-0.6170033812522888,
-0.03028571978211403,
-0.8794777989387512,
-0.29878443479537964,
-0.21972593665122986,
-0.5049327611923218,
-0.1993575096130371,
0.20693130791187286,
-0.6591745018959045,
-0.025560300797224045,
-0.27229630947113037,
0.007161930203437805,
0.12580153346061707,
0.7687029838562012,
-0.09370724856853485,
0.16224521398544312,
-0.5549318790435791,
0.602191150188446,
0.6465712785720825,
0.682202160358429,
-0.3736964464187622,
-0.7404625415802002,
-0.3424261212348938,
-0.1556987166404724,
-0.13637107610702515,
-0.47584763169288635,
0.3567048907279968,
0.6588446497917175,
0.7528174519538879,
0.12444952130317688,
0.044172778725624084,
0.7884570956230164,
-0.5842013955116272,
0.5064209699630737,
-0.09290935099124908,
-0.6999313235282898,
0.9227306842803955,
0.19383345544338226,
0.37101271748542786,
0.7899321913719177,
0.0015924160834401846,
-0.15257221460342407,
-0.38488155603408813,
-0.12911120057106018,
-0.8300691246986389,
0.8622041940689087,
0.19497670233249664,
0.14934714138507843,
0.18767954409122467,
0.4993208944797516,
0.04059648886322975,
0.15687914192676544,
-0.5655979514122009,
-0.5197038650512695,
-0.4114955961704254,
-0.3422935903072357,
-0.07170334458351135,
-0.14920806884765625,
0.1096084862947464,
-0.3917779326438904,
0.6963998675346375,
-0.27647337317466736,
-0.06835787743330002,
0.13581155240535736,
-0.03456724062561989,
-0.2044059783220291,
-0.1796608865261078,
0.12225686013698578,
0.49388444423675537,
-0.010405503213405609,
0.0624697208404541,
0.1439102739095688,
-0.6278947591781616,
0.021607665345072746,
-0.2993023991584778,
-0.3365020751953125,
-0.18497633934020996,
0.4070809781551361,
1.1672031879425049,
0.1562340259552002,
-0.2969229519367218,
0.5464373826980591,
-0.06466248631477356,
0.02589629963040352,
-0.06264492869377136,
0.8053129315376282,
-0.5439717769622803,
0.108543261885643,
0.15288415551185608,
0.00044964163680560887,
0.3198307752609253,
-0.2459193617105484,
0.37150251865386963,
0.3046357035636902,
-0.46910375356674194,
0.03605718910694122,
0.42476940155029297,
0.19872929155826569,
-0.2671484053134918,
0.7950706481933594,
-0.25161078572273254,
-0.48852604627609253,
0.572677493095398,
0.3486395478248596,
0.8165464401245117,
-0.4874321222305298,
0.3637649416923523,
0.370066374540329,
0.2615090012550354,
-0.16082356870174408,
0.26374122500419617,
-0.20119883120059967,
-0.695938766002655,
-0.4843907058238983,
-0.9757412672042847,
-0.18782122433185577,
0.2022891342639923,
-0.8614764213562012,
0.3113672733306885,
-0.27772238850593567,
0.011566962115466595,
-0.14433898031711578,
0.0675390213727951,
-0.8181825876235962,
0.6853513717651367,
0.39358657598495483,
0.6821926832199097,
-0.7156052589416504,
1.0532218217849731,
0.3853827118873596,
0.050133880227804184,
-0.7156355977058411,
-0.19770413637161255,
-0.0372253954410553,
-1.1794002056121826,
0.7530391812324524,
0.11536998301744461,
-0.3072785437107086,
0.13604778051376343,
-0.5396124720573425,
-1.0209084749221802,
0.7467921376228333,
0.3706323206424713,
-0.8400235772132874,
0.03408540040254593,
-0.17232604324817657,
0.48714062571525574,
-0.39946845173835754,
0.19719453155994415,
0.8109774589538574,
0.3721781373023987,
0.4322313070297241,
-0.6977437734603882,
-0.45376676321029663,
-0.26643696427345276,
0.0323711521923542,
0.20342415571212769,
-0.846222996711731,
0.5493245720863342,
-0.05304329842329025,
0.08259603381156921,
-0.20519253611564636,
0.6668350696563721,
0.12575483322143555,
0.2849489450454712,
0.7389847040176392,
0.4169504642486572,
0.5283482670783997,
0.06894034892320633,
0.9614579677581787,
-0.3496808409690857,
0.36949506402015686,
1.3454471826553345,
-0.24926967918872833,
0.7782382965087891,
0.3251815438270569,
-0.2627701461315155,
0.23317892849445343,
0.7427608370780945,
-0.6030145883560181,
0.7276553511619568,
0.1894376426935196,
0.052411384880542755,
-0.7813092470169067,
0.27791035175323486,
-0.07191870361566544,
1.0653122663497925,
0.13639268279075623,
-0.23002882301807404,
-0.1711496263742447,
0.17369678616523743,
-0.5214329957962036,
0.02733786217868328,
-0.4749753773212433,
0.7966386079788208,
0.08306168019771576,
-0.8617678880691528,
0.5878875851631165,
-0.4420106112957001,
0.3304058611392975,
-0.6339820027351379,
-0.10044209659099579,
-0.2259899228811264,
0.08667243272066116,
-0.14252647757530212,
-1.0665339231491089,
0.15697753429412842,
0.025615360587835312,
-0.02783993072807789,
-0.29062631726264954,
0.6369597911834717,
-0.49423179030418396,
-0.7082386612892151,
0.4776988625526428,
0.5254198312759399,
0.2595060467720032,
-0.09539450705051422,
-0.7069938778877258,
0.07763419300317764,
0.19427785277366638,
-0.6038515567779541,
0.25439074635505676,
0.2237389087677002,
0.18302759528160095,
0.910496175289154,
0.6241950392723083,
0.5199818015098572,
0.2022726684808731,
0.24167636036872864,
0.8625368475914001,
-0.5891422033309937,
-0.5567125082015991,
-0.9547560214996338,
0.20454905927181244,
-0.201450377702713,
-0.5161791443824768,
0.5561724305152893,
0.5505560636520386,
0.9338836073875427,
0.08627082407474518,
0.6821507811546326,
0.23184217512607574,
0.4394535720348358,
-0.8699421286582947,
0.6684542894363403,
-0.7042734622955322,
0.30886468291282654,
0.003820565529167652,
-0.9647464156150818,
-0.19183005392551422,
0.8177191615104675,
-0.44404274225234985,
0.31399720907211304,
0.40257561206817627,
0.8294314742088318,
-0.1261933147907257,
-0.15576328337192535,
0.7679227590560913,
0.044572774320840836,
0.18383648991584778,
0.577498733997345,
0.6320050358772278,
-0.24338506162166595,
0.6487881541252136,
-0.41379278898239136,
-0.15655742585659027,
-0.23619036376476288,
-0.6306256055831909,
-1.0913934707641602,
-0.5731708407402039,
-0.3419480323791504,
-0.06935995817184448,
0.10963506251573563,
0.7202323079109192,
1.2179425954818726,
-0.8095707893371582,
-0.227054625749588,
0.0801059901714325,
0.23385915160179138,
-0.2581375539302826,
-0.1129082590341568,
0.2735854685306549,
-0.5898798704147339,
-0.6513864398002625,
0.7436888813972473,
0.392675518989563,
-0.02886214666068554,
-0.5296863317489624,
-0.041770316660404205,
0.19485637545585632,
-0.11733042448759079,
0.4021001160144806,
0.059634752571582794,
-0.43561309576034546,
-0.2746334671974182,
-0.18069347739219666,
-0.14061132073402405,
0.34375065565109253,
0.569038987159729,
-0.8736521601676941,
0.9531496167182922,
0.0913548693060875,
0.5764883756637573,
0.7504509687423706,
-0.29795098304748535,
0.30122822523117065,
-0.6436424255371094,
-0.21173478662967682,
0.31686708331108093,
0.3419084846973419,
0.4015185236930847,
-0.4941600263118744,
0.5458019971847534,
0.16029760241508484,
-0.601517915725708,
-0.7234066724777222,
0.342083215713501,
-0.5633458495140076,
-0.23373252153396606,
1.0718634128570557,
-0.0395229272544384,
-0.46456393599510193,
-0.02139206975698471,
-0.12041627615690231,
0.09576559066772461,
-0.19047226011753082,
0.9939733743667603,
0.6086834669113159,
-0.17704391479492188,
-0.37387681007385254,
-0.7870400547981262,
0.5235410928726196,
0.40924564003944397,
-0.6223182678222656,
-0.060589808970689774,
0.4333352744579315,
0.25083035230636597,
-0.2522718906402588,
0.26913365721702576,
0.2676122486591339,
0.29618483781814575,
-0.17800720036029816,
-0.14987409114837646,
-0.26196545362472534,
-0.7202771306037903,
-0.3369138836860657,
0.2115546613931656,
-0.07527859508991241,
-0.4179133474826813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12486v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12486v2 | Do Pre-Trained Language Models Detect and Understand Semantic Underspecification? Ask the DUST! | 2024-02-19T19:49:29 | 2024-06-12T09:09:47 | Frank Wildenburg, Michael Hanna, Sandro Pezzelle | cs.CL | cs.CL | In everyday language use, speakers frequently utter and interpret sentences
that are semantically underspecified, namely, whose content is insufficient to
fully convey their message or interpret them univocally. For example, to
interpret the underspecified sentence "Don't spend too much", which leaves
implicit what (not) to spend, additional linguistic context or outside
knowledge is needed. In this work, we propose a novel Dataset of semantically
Underspecified Sentences grouped by Type (DUST) and use it to study whether
pre-trained language models (LMs) correctly identify and interpret
underspecified sentences. We find that newer LMs are reasonably able to
identify underspecified sentences when explicitly prompted. However,
interpreting them correctly is much harder for any LMs. Our experiments show
that when interpreting underspecified sentences, LMs exhibit little
uncertainty, contrary to what theoretical accounts of underspecification would
predict. Overall, our study reveals limitations in current models' processing
of sentence semantics and highlights the importance of using naturalistic data
and communicative scenarios when evaluating LMs' language capabilities. | [
-0.27700215578079224,
-0.606002926826477,
1.0065876245498657,
-0.2740807831287384,
-0.5014153718948364,
-0.2967360019683838,
-0.26716747879981995,
-0.5933758020401001,
0.08659536391496658,
0.6929333806037903,
-0.922534704208374,
-0.42983609437942505,
-0.7572503089904785,
-0.08483169227838516,
-0.8229435086250305,
1.009913682937622,
0.04219410941004753,
-0.27233266830444336,
-0.6273980140686035,
0.3611947298049927,
-0.30325669050216675,
-0.4439610242843628,
0.20528413355350494,
-0.4270831048488617,
0.11977406591176987,
0.47512099146842957,
0.8428962230682373,
0.22947965562343597,
0.4117964208126068,
0.34718915820121765,
-0.15141111612319946,
0.1628330498933792,
-0.5474342107772827,
-0.2280416041612625,
-0.003995735198259354,
-0.3693291246891022,
0.039934951812028885,
0.08957351744174957,
0.4460044205188751,
1.0286576747894287,
-0.13550542294979095,
0.19798095524311066,
0.054517555981874466,
0.15655241906642914,
-1.0252383947372437,
0.25118228793144226,
-1.1738497018814087,
0.044293224811553955,
-0.35332000255584717,
-0.3305632770061493,
-0.23405206203460693,
-0.1131649985909462,
0.03407711535692215,
-0.5797948241233826,
0.2093484103679657,
-0.24297787249088287,
0.9147877097129822,
0.5726515054702759,
-0.37127649784088135,
-0.35681331157684326,
-0.6254517436027527,
0.6594814658164978,
-0.6712616682052612,
0.23416784405708313,
0.6316843032836914,
0.016002483665943146,
-0.3050403594970703,
-0.7570745348930359,
-0.5870359539985657,
-0.23090074956417084,
-0.5847219228744507,
-0.05787961184978485,
-0.22584503889083862,
0.06891832500696182,
0.04012952744960785,
0.3294539153575897,
-0.2934366762638092,
0.26711034774780273,
-0.4128180146217346,
-0.19116713106632233,
0.3466516435146332,
0.1769993007183075,
0.43323302268981934,
-0.4413771331310272,
-0.5445138216018677,
0.4123687744140625,
-0.5360933542251587,
-0.06944630295038223,
0.15670785307884216,
0.416515052318573,
0.10632488131523132,
0.5414324402809143,
-0.31556734442710876,
0.6499929428100586,
-0.2803429961204529,
0.4683293402194977,
0.14553596079349518,
-0.2609859108924866,
-0.4798837900161743,
0.008420553989708424,
0.6596082448959351,
0.10968159139156342,
0.7148572206497192,
-0.3222956359386444,
-0.2881728708744049,
0.33122575283050537,
0.5492110848426819,
-0.6651192307472229,
-0.3065575361251831,
0.22266146540641785,
-0.309953510761261,
-0.5253223776817322,
0.07451014220714569,
-0.31189340353012085,
-0.4802059531211853,
-0.18312616646289825,
0.6216061115264893,
-0.19233597815036774,
-0.22857007384300232,
0.5676478743553162,
-0.08295035362243652,
-0.19256898760795593,
0.3440961241722107,
-0.8103184103965759,
0.6622706055641174,
0.7340488433837891,
0.40404629707336426,
0.22658587992191315,
-0.2998104393482208,
-0.33498474955558777,
-0.1537788063287735,
-0.33998170495033264,
1.0105195045471191,
-0.7771888375282288,
-0.23582284152507782,
0.006619696505367756,
-0.09629572927951813,
-0.5131365656852722,
-0.4212668836116791,
0.7891409993171692,
-0.4783056974411011,
0.35728535056114197,
0.10790638625621796,
-0.8102531433105469,
-0.05556653067469597,
-0.032853543758392334,
-0.2690289318561554,
0.7176653146743774,
-0.024500593543052673,
-1.1190487146377563,
0.6706624031066895,
-0.3450811207294464,
-0.08108386397361755,
0.11627165973186493,
-0.262798935174942,
-0.16593919694423676,
0.38713982701301575,
0.24349454045295715,
0.622295081615448,
-0.10265151411294937,
0.5553531050682068,
-0.3256942331790924,
-0.6208536028862,
0.6007764935493469,
-0.504909336566925,
0.43650656938552856,
0.18178874254226685,
-0.13462921977043152,
-0.15160641074180603,
-0.7204535007476807,
0.2514002323150635,
-0.02325424551963806,
0.2142215222120285,
-0.333265483379364,
0.2848042845726013,
-0.1475144922733307,
0.25602394342422485,
0.4007132351398468,
-0.6330444812774658,
0.08214271813631058,
-0.46596720814704895,
0.31730028986930847,
0.6029408574104309,
-0.10415970534086227,
0.21880578994750977,
-0.0426955483853817,
0.2538783550262451,
0.09663897752761841,
0.11791732907295227,
0.05161016434431076,
-0.16079235076904297,
-0.98810875415802,
0.0936836302280426,
0.12560373544692993,
0.4654676914215088,
-0.4150191843509674,
0.28782421350479126,
-0.5637533068656921,
-0.3808686137199402,
-0.40888988971710205,
0.26941609382629395,
0.3149394989013672,
0.3848903477191925,
0.4803963899612427,
-0.19307927787303925,
-0.46225717663764954,
-0.8203034996986389,
-0.2861808240413666,
-0.11047900468111038,
-0.014059342443943024,
0.23447148501873016,
0.6175012588500977,
-0.4823625087738037,
1.1663388013839722,
-0.6903352737426758,
-0.24336683750152588,
-0.28306278586387634,
0.3749866783618927,
0.07002371549606323,
0.285017192363739,
0.20442332327365875,
-0.7141388654708862,
0.1887763887643814,
-0.28374624252319336,
-0.5171036124229431,
-0.37305915355682373,
-0.04804690182209015,
0.20332202315330505,
-0.11832068115472794,
0.7236882448196411,
-0.8702397346496582,
0.576870322227478,
0.5044220685958862,
-0.36301732063293457,
0.25872334837913513,
-0.44725871086120605,
-0.012325079180300236,
-0.5407928228378296,
0.06900864094495773,
-0.2839227020740509,
-0.19010837376117706,
-0.6886165738105774,
-0.017695311456918716,
0.004892580211162567,
-0.0771816074848175,
-0.6448872685432434,
0.4648818075656891,
-0.40796148777008057,
-0.09882117807865143,
-0.48778268694877625,
0.202989861369133,
-0.20153021812438965,
0.47682324051856995,
0.44133514165878296,
0.40695300698280334,
0.40290483832359314,
-0.6371268630027771,
-0.14575918018817902,
0.08458106219768524,
-0.733425498008728,
-0.08660459518432617,
-0.4852713644504547,
0.059707168489694595,
-0.3532063663005829,
0.42553403973579407,
-0.8747560381889343,
-0.23333212733268738,
0.17590837180614471,
-0.3290945887565613,
0.006125955376774073,
-0.1890270709991455,
-0.5975528955459595,
-0.3943682610988617,
0.06938043981790543,
0.40128257870674133,
0.34770482778549194,
-0.1048755794763565,
0.2628650665283203,
0.3677961528301239,
0.2483864277601242,
-0.5425921678543091,
-0.8142763376235962,
-0.2531866431236267,
-0.1937057077884674,
-0.4826275706291199,
0.04620015248656273,
0.2901454567909241,
-0.3729771375656128,
0.14528389275074005,
-0.4063080847263336,
-0.4343075454235077,
0.5443432331085205,
0.548384428024292,
0.1146634891629219,
-0.29318132996559143,
0.3529222905635834,
-0.12794147431850433,
-0.16316059231758118,
0.06685363501310349,
-0.28068646788597107,
0.49035778641700745,
0.0761144831776619,
-0.34797200560569763,
-0.5612521171569824,
-0.0019536453764885664,
0.2956033945083618,
-0.090826116502285,
0.8105844855308533,
0.37991341948509216,
-0.42308956384658813,
-0.19357091188430786,
-0.43389996886253357,
-0.3051846921443939,
-0.4660510718822479,
0.16306398808956146,
-0.40455248951911926,
-0.7494335174560547,
0.41103988885879517,
0.06934519857168198,
-0.2504599988460541,
0.6787436604499817,
0.20239490270614624,
-0.20895196497440338,
0.6734148263931274,
0.6204298138618469,
0.0005255253054201603,
0.18937459588050842,
-0.053665656596422195,
0.01927792653441429,
-0.22941270470619202,
-0.0645146444439888,
-0.6091174483299255,
0.045716021209955215,
-0.6005659699440002,
-0.4410206377506256,
-0.007167456205934286,
-0.05496935173869133,
-0.015606419183313847,
0.3464880585670471,
-0.2138751894235611,
0.7985893487930298,
0.28840821981430054,
0.18370166420936584,
0.16055065393447876,
-0.45260193943977356,
0.14891286194324493,
0.10513611137866974,
-0.6227286458015442,
-0.5631079077720642,
0.7788693904876709,
0.3811924457550049,
0.8032414317131042,
-0.2727992534637451,
0.7553470730781555,
0.3443329930305481,
0.035110220313072205,
-0.5028789639472961,
0.5378031730651855,
-0.6564568877220154,
-0.6689965724945068,
-0.20798645913600922,
-0.4787280857563019,
-1.1559233665466309,
0.37976688146591187,
-0.4828929603099823,
-0.9659066200256348,
0.17219161987304688,
0.11412924528121948,
-0.5740867853164673,
0.27913984656333923,
-0.8038875460624695,
1.177747368812561,
-0.09106318652629852,
0.3402697741985321,
-0.29360339045524597,
-0.849140465259552,
0.3713848292827606,
-0.2871723771095276,
0.6208310127258301,
-0.36726847290992737,
0.01240464299917221,
0.5954139828681946,
-0.5812610387802124,
1.0673376321792603,
-0.16694357991218567,
-0.015681223943829536,
0.309468537569046,
0.11154055595397949,
0.27033743262290955,
-0.2854965329170227,
0.1226469874382019,
0.10746089369058609,
0.1007472351193428,
-0.3121193051338196,
-0.7753832936286926,
0.45352116227149963,
-0.831008791923523,
-0.5473772883415222,
-0.28986895084381104,
-0.3256963789463043,
-0.2855522036552429,
0.17049852013587952,
0.2567022442817688,
0.5980815887451172,
-0.21722204983234406,
0.02179146371781826,
0.4254659414291382,
-0.07309797406196594,
0.09858687967061996,
0.6254679560661316,
-0.05252574756741524,
0.26586034893989563,
0.784960925579071,
0.09244772046804428,
0.40843167901039124,
0.5066818594932556,
0.400399386882782,
-0.17574717104434967,
-0.6606864333152771,
-0.18738017976284027,
0.028652096167206764,
-0.8534979820251465,
-0.0003855549148283899,
-0.996979296207428,
-0.2904631495475769,
-0.49568450450897217,
0.04299383983016014,
-0.20626771450042725,
-0.5729835033416748,
-0.47376829385757446,
-0.05663926899433136,
0.21193937957286835,
0.9511063694953918,
0.21943248808383942,
0.5404069423675537,
-0.8910577893257141,
0.3735305666923523,
0.3267837166786194,
0.1627827286720276,
-0.2511770725250244,
-0.7087492346763611,
-0.05654175952076912,
0.2187713235616684,
0.14625023305416107,
-0.6345846056938171,
0.30606430768966675,
0.30136120319366455,
0.4984157085418701,
0.2872519791126251,
0.20416951179504395,
0.7386111617088318,
-0.5975670218467712,
0.6618286371231079,
-0.3634295165538788,
-1.0861624479293823,
0.5567564368247986,
-0.27237632870674133,
0.3600876033306122,
0.7598170638084412,
0.3920452296733856,
-0.45697614550590515,
-0.7990877032279968,
-1.042237639427185,
-0.775404691696167,
0.9914063215255737,
0.2544602155685425,
0.45613157749176025,
-0.004784212913364172,
0.14442028105258942,
0.10232061892747879,
0.36561793088912964,
-0.792319655418396,
0.15565799176692963,
-0.17024916410446167,
-0.26165109872817993,
-0.4385911226272583,
-0.4886268377304077,
0.2257438451051712,
0.10363662242889404,
0.43282732367515564,
0.06565169245004654,
0.06106618046760559,
-0.16715146601200104,
-0.5076602101325989,
-0.12890562415122986,
0.5040233731269836,
0.6184895038604736,
0.4456263482570648,
-0.4866388738155365,
0.27400413155555725,
0.29159167408943176,
-0.29255855083465576,
-0.21461960673332214,
0.12006751447916031,
0.044731657952070236,
-0.07753236591815948,
0.7039291262626648,
0.9414850473403931,
0.6289402842521667,
-0.7375759482383728,
0.9555959105491638,
-0.05335456132888794,
0.057711441069841385,
-0.3956088721752167,
0.12691788375377655,
-0.1884990632534027,
-0.09968803822994232,
0.1758643239736557,
0.09233821928501129,
0.26250243186950684,
-0.6967623233795166,
0.42423832416534424,
0.38546788692474365,
-0.42697373032569885,
-0.06468331813812256,
0.3785664439201355,
0.14978735148906708,
0.3271515965461731,
0.6700648665428162,
0.14612184464931488,
-0.7347036600112915,
0.3952178657054901,
0.1727576106786728,
0.7307676672935486,
0.27966946363449097,
0.2534451186656952,
-0.2091323882341385,
0.4361536204814911,
-0.04018045589327812,
0.07203711569309235,
-0.3834863603115082,
-1.1357723474502563,
-0.4475538432598114,
-0.7063780426979065,
-0.23820467293262482,
0.09690339863300323,
-0.5231156349182129,
0.3826701045036316,
-0.09036903083324432,
0.06640627980232239,
0.13078853487968445,
-0.03630318492650986,
-0.5573694705963135,
0.6650940179824829,
0.4798390567302704,
0.7530456185340881,
-1.4309486150741577,
0.8704392313957214,
0.3945372700691223,
-0.3294495940208435,
-0.7686014771461487,
0.2368619292974472,
-0.014159954153001308,
-0.9797961711883545,
0.8955227136611938,
0.2981397807598114,
-0.3184875249862671,
-0.13737806677818298,
-0.4378223419189453,
-0.7851037383079529,
0.4113963842391968,
0.43207424879074097,
-0.13100114464759827,
-0.1905018538236618,
0.2201089859008789,
0.7362135648727417,
-0.08774523437023163,
0.5966672301292419,
0.5174136757850647,
0.2618776261806488,
0.2474425882101059,
-1.091952919960022,
-0.10619177669286728,
-0.08510994911193848,
-0.35995790362358093,
0.42992547154426575,
-0.2015284299850464,
0.9314261674880981,
-0.07792139053344727,
-0.5347824692726135,
0.18393096327781677,
0.5831776261329651,
-0.2959672510623932,
0.24736779928207397,
0.7120813727378845,
0.49787160754203796,
0.6949067115783691,
-0.06541422009468079,
1.0804495811462402,
-0.09332787245512009,
0.37158071994781494,
1.2217649221420288,
-0.048448022454977036,
0.8739174008369446,
0.14816804230213165,
0.08821537345647812,
0.7170445919036865,
0.6648637652397156,
0.37786605954170227,
0.5513341426849365,
0.38226497173309326,
-0.11478859186172485,
-0.8672330379486084,
-0.15849067270755768,
-0.2024463266134262,
0.7029678225517273,
0.4968186616897583,
-0.19887815415859222,
-0.5179634690284729,
0.10705014318227768,
-0.0692652240395546,
0.25235089659690857,
-0.34893718361854553,
0.9010835289955139,
0.10174273699522018,
-0.49939465522766113,
0.6193307638168335,
-0.2756398022174835,
0.7011251449584961,
-0.564213752746582,
0.33507272601127625,
-0.010425057262182236,
0.2456246167421341,
-0.46176692843437195,
-0.9121361970901489,
0.34859785437583923,
0.025373876094818115,
0.11819671839475632,
-0.31440696120262146,
0.9143300652503967,
-0.594803512096405,
-0.5875743627548218,
0.006869116332381964,
0.530565083026886,
0.6276560425758362,
-0.15686346590518951,
-0.4338328540325165,
-0.03480702266097069,
-0.16369661688804626,
0.12901657819747925,
0.08612912893295288,
0.6824837327003479,
-0.20992645621299744,
0.8031048774719238,
0.2828275263309479,
0.16488026082515717,
0.05448785796761513,
0.16565951704978943,
0.8220822811126709,
-0.41464388370513916,
-0.3840571343898773,
-0.7324018478393555,
0.5097009539604187,
0.1487194299697876,
-0.2283572256565094,
0.5831544399261475,
0.24187129735946655,
0.9168803691864014,
-0.08482012897729874,
0.35766202211380005,
0.19307862222194672,
0.6672323346138,
-0.8114997148513794,
0.4805379807949066,
-0.7874149084091187,
0.0625682920217514,
-0.5066866874694824,
-0.3221586346626282,
-0.31294161081314087,
0.6251969933509827,
-0.7662568092346191,
-0.07400542497634888,
0.6362993717193604,
0.5276938080787659,
-0.39253732562065125,
0.3179759383201599,
0.2676852345466614,
0.0638679713010788,
-0.14426061511039734,
0.5461634397506714,
1.0954114198684692,
-0.17383769154548645,
0.4525459110736847,
-0.18225683271884918,
0.23796197772026062,
-0.17354115843772888,
-0.7761238813400269,
-0.7836311459541321,
-0.5239412784576416,
-0.24719543755054474,
0.17785079777240753,
0.04220036044716835,
0.8733887672424316,
0.6607022285461426,
-0.8273727297782898,
-0.02729981020092964,
-0.40458348393440247,
-0.05993342772126198,
0.31950175762176514,
-0.15575431287288666,
0.20390471816062927,
-0.5939087867736816,
-0.43706923723220825,
0.43575319647789,
-0.24655307829380035,
0.2245538979768753,
-0.030942553654313087,
0.40060144662857056,
-0.07747424393892288,
0.28190699219703674,
0.24686254560947418,
-0.09513061493635178,
-0.6959495544433594,
-0.4397004246711731,
-0.2921193838119507,
-0.14438334107398987,
-0.1495547741651535,
0.9889901876449585,
-0.9123640656471252,
0.3246433138847351,
0.4349363446235657,
0.5405129790306091,
0.2844126522541046,
0.1537613868713379,
0.3986506760120392,
-0.9359048008918762,
0.43373584747314453,
0.3293628990650177,
0.3306683301925659,
0.1782335638999939,
-0.31546252965927124,
0.1569780558347702,
0.1513783484697342,
-0.4372101426124573,
-0.8346552848815918,
0.20285865664482117,
-0.5924456119537354,
-0.690376877784729,
1.1700540781021118,
-0.030592145398259163,
-0.0921197161078453,
-0.162588968873024,
-0.07095959037542343,
0.0829337015748024,
-0.09309525042772293,
0.5967305302619934,
0.7380906343460083,
0.024076202884316444,
-0.13364648818969727,
-0.37433844804763794,
0.6488674879074097,
0.5336575508117676,
-0.7264440655708313,
0.20780302584171295,
0.7240643501281738,
0.17005108296871185,
0.1223895326256752,
0.6803476214408875,
0.2232360541820526,
0.20431090891361237,
-0.07823244482278824,
-0.30500662326812744,
0.09520149230957031,
-0.3296971619129181,
-0.2757248282432556,
0.07573623210191727,
0.13370835781097412,
-0.27417877316474915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14849v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14849v1 | Asynchronous and Segmented Bidirectional Encoding for NMT | 2024-02-19T19:48:02 | 2024-02-19T19:48:02 | Jingpu Yang, Zehua Han, Mengyu Xiang, Helin Wang, Yuxiao Huang, Miao Fang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | With the rapid advancement of Neural Machine Translation (NMT), enhancing
translation efficiency and quality has become a focal point of research.
Despite the commendable performance of general models such as the Transformer
in various aspects, they still fall short in processing long sentences and
fully leveraging bidirectional contextual information. This paper introduces an
improved model based on the Transformer, implementing an asynchronous and
segmented bidirectional decoding strategy aimed at elevating translation
efficiency and accuracy. Compared to traditional unidirectional translations
from left-to-right or right-to-left, our method demonstrates heightened
efficiency and improved translation quality, particularly in handling long
sentences. Experimental results on the IWSLT2017 dataset confirm the
effectiveness of our approach in accelerating translation and increasing
accuracy, especially surpassing traditional unidirectional strategies in long
sentence translation. Furthermore, this study analyzes the impact of sentence
length on decoding outcomes and explores the model's performance in various
scenarios. The findings of this research not only provide an effective encoding
strategy for the NMT field but also pave new avenues and directions for future
studies. | [
0.07999742031097412,
-0.16861677169799805,
0.4014027714729309,
0.46550774574279785,
-0.7085183262825012,
0.17788144946098328,
-0.3857456147670746,
-0.3100089430809021,
0.14617200195789337,
0.38877421617507935,
-0.5328090190887451,
-0.2832678258419037,
-0.9332314729690552,
0.39520081877708435,
-0.532214343547821,
0.6703678965568542,
-0.10037077963352203,
0.334160715341568,
-0.0759383887052536,
0.06265491992235184,
-0.5491856336593628,
-0.42787620425224304,
-0.5276964902877808,
-0.5154705047607422,
0.20608745515346527,
0.3341169059276581,
0.7079508304595947,
0.8027227520942688,
0.8532966375350952,
0.267513632774353,
-0.19197940826416016,
0.09733579307794571,
-0.18621554970741272,
0.16018497943878174,
-0.046176016330718994,
-0.17846974730491638,
-0.4489734172821045,
-0.2540208697319031,
0.6823466420173645,
0.6725425720214844,
-0.16623380780220032,
-0.15062858164310455,
0.15216709673404694,
0.7136009931564331,
-0.2919754981994629,
0.12673453986644745,
-0.37155604362487793,
-0.020334485918283463,
-0.05045507103204727,
-0.4084603190422058,
-0.7310665249824524,
-0.1470060497522354,
0.16067712008953094,
-0.18846487998962402,
0.13047479093074799,
-0.19375121593475342,
0.7234959006309509,
0.39441442489624023,
-0.6497282981872559,
-0.3271258771419525,
-0.5905613899230957,
0.4997864365577698,
-0.9438076019287109,
0.6755390167236328,
0.14707908034324646,
0.2935192286968231,
0.13056398928165436,
-0.9451236724853516,
-0.279623419046402,
-0.23742952942848206,
-0.18346776068210602,
0.43192750215530396,
-0.272716224193573,
0.23793832957744598,
0.06475967168807983,
0.17922085523605347,
-0.4141733944416046,
0.04888540878891945,
-0.3134101927280426,
-0.010772439651191235,
0.508032500743866,
0.14371098577976227,
0.13891446590423584,
-0.7012073993682861,
-0.6507440209388733,
-0.18038135766983032,
-0.4850514531135559,
-0.021355994045734406,
0.25766071677207947,
0.21754297614097595,
0.04099120572209358,
0.700761616230011,
-0.4393906891345978,
0.342755526304245,
0.12758076190948486,
0.21253694593906403,
0.10202152281999588,
-0.4703163504600525,
0.0894174799323082,
0.2720438241958618,
0.6600003838539124,
0.6856305003166199,
-0.10928674787282944,
-0.4012356400489807,
-0.4674857556819916,
-0.20225012302398682,
0.5003464818000793,
-1.1254563331604004,
0.06277117878198624,
0.03890237957239151,
-0.4344814419746399,
-0.04464128613471985,
0.08706094324588776,
-0.5760328769683838,
0.13827818632125854,
-0.30012190341949463,
0.3560822308063507,
-0.7481775879859924,
0.007286366540938616,
0.522178053855896,
-0.07168892025947571,
0.10862120985984802,
0.21873514354228973,
-0.7852855324745178,
0.07131443917751312,
0.6930874586105347,
0.9664510488510132,
-0.4596950113773346,
-0.3313116133213043,
-0.24695436656475067,
-0.09883243590593338,
-0.11904852092266083,
0.3424263894557953,
-0.23911994695663452,
-0.2928394675254822,
-0.014135871082544327,
0.05671186372637749,
-0.3639277219772339,
-0.12718935310840607,
0.7406625747680664,
-1.0175668001174927,
0.21796268224716187,
-0.09932960569858551,
-0.390800416469574,
-0.35743817687034607,
0.1537920981645584,
-0.5383945107460022,
0.42918506264686584,
0.020733019337058067,
-0.5971147418022156,
-0.15174737572669983,
-1.0725077390670776,
-0.7815263271331787,
0.04164309799671173,
0.2500856816768646,
-0.3695656657218933,
0.28695282340049744,
0.25892508029937744,
0.35822299122810364,
-0.4022532105445862,
0.5385384559631348,
0.5553537607192993,
-0.506839394569397,
0.4053005874156952,
-0.9521340131759644,
0.6747900247573853,
0.16782435774803162,
-0.5110824108123779,
0.2298373430967331,
-0.6542103886604309,
-0.1528955101966858,
0.16157251596450806,
-0.6514269113540649,
0.05217525362968445,
-0.04785817489027977,
0.24489150941371918,
-0.0026454392354935408,
0.1720685064792633,
-0.6176846623420715,
-0.01657537743449211,
-0.4393080472946167,
0.8132408857345581,
0.5839491486549377,
-0.13016046583652496,
0.7316800951957703,
0.22473308444023132,
0.4363250732421875,
0.13944406807422638,
0.13385364413261414,
-0.27197492122650146,
-0.13037320971488953,
-0.9286462068557739,
-0.0022848283406347036,
0.6832817792892456,
0.35968688130378723,
-1.231463074684143,
0.34028691053390503,
-0.8074577450752258,
0.03172001615166664,
-0.5923560261726379,
-0.5700063705444336,
0.3705514967441559,
0.5967033505439758,
0.6876275539398193,
-0.3999912142753601,
-0.5253946781158447,
-0.7479745149612427,
-0.02781619504094124,
0.35270166397094727,
-0.11045293509960175,
-0.017634913325309753,
0.3779565989971161,
-0.5656655430793762,
0.7405533194541931,
-0.38493576645851135,
0.31246283650398254,
-0.36442771553993225,
0.17192907631397247,
0.4394679367542267,
0.6419236063957214,
-0.021425627171993256,
-0.8608153462409973,
-0.5217214822769165,
0.013311331160366535,
-0.47357475757598877,
0.20917068421840668,
-0.01277058944106102,
-0.23038429021835327,
0.14025843143463135,
0.41973114013671875,
-0.7363510727882385,
0.2906399071216583,
0.5660187005996704,
-0.4997744560241699,
0.40840235352516174,
-0.3490596115589142,
0.42448657751083374,
-1.2307071685791016,
0.0013752623926848173,
-0.45358991622924805,
-0.3897656798362732,
-0.8087719678878784,
0.09445468336343765,
0.6468410491943359,
-0.06753265857696533,
-0.3698241114616394,
-0.3411043882369995,
-0.6203860640525818,
0.13214237987995148,
-0.4349907338619232,
-0.10012523829936981,
0.21394771337509155,
0.44823408126831055,
0.12028113007545471,
0.9880883693695068,
0.00875595398247242,
-0.24521298706531525,
0.21647867560386658,
0.3105594217777252,
-0.22599957883358002,
0.34158673882484436,
-0.7498857378959656,
0.27724960446357727,
-0.3738866448402405,
0.20698271691799164,
-0.5379838347434998,
-0.02734300121665001,
-0.026531200855970383,
-0.4976162314414978,
0.49143290519714355,
-0.14355768263339996,
-0.2540093660354614,
-0.6043683886528015,
-0.10068638622760773,
0.42311540246009827,
0.6715285778045654,
-0.630028486251831,
0.4644615054130554,
-0.22091956436634064,
0.20786914229393005,
-0.6914317607879639,
-0.7335116863250732,
0.3188462257385254,
-0.13062332570552826,
-0.7073822617530823,
0.5192607641220093,
0.07003389298915863,
0.3356180191040039,
-0.1788879632949829,
-0.11775584518909454,
0.0645180270075798,
-0.03834084793925285,
0.10838260501623154,
0.360970139503479,
-0.4855521619319916,
-0.07731474936008453,
0.19084087014198303,
-0.5591461062431335,
0.11158179491758347,
-0.5547762513160706,
0.7298009991645813,
-0.014509680680930614,
-0.3573343753814697,
-0.5510018467903137,
0.41887301206588745,
0.7633393406867981,
-0.3249221742153168,
0.7144384384155273,
0.6158971190452576,
-0.10597892850637436,
0.0422237291932106,
-0.3177878260612488,
-0.48513147234916687,
-0.47971686720848083,
0.5551885962486267,
-0.41473451256752014,
-0.9303196668624878,
0.2705615758895874,
-0.11415525525808334,
-0.34748363494873047,
0.35920295119285583,
0.2039956897497177,
-0.15273314714431763,
0.9846169948577881,
0.69452303647995,
0.1537892371416092,
0.42205891013145447,
-0.35704469680786133,
0.42976564168930054,
-1.1215331554412842,
-0.24437697231769562,
-0.247321218252182,
-0.30687418580055237,
-0.36863675713539124,
-0.9002971649169922,
0.28634366393089294,
0.0832889974117279,
-0.02449840120971203,
0.8006711602210999,
-0.6323570013046265,
0.4710530638694763,
0.6169573068618774,
0.2770822048187256,
0.4338536262512207,
-0.17289504408836365,
0.047065138816833496,
-0.20847052335739136,
-0.6812822818756104,
-0.37291887402534485,
0.9310970902442932,
0.49859336018562317,
0.4986673593521118,
0.17639213800430298,
0.3747902810573578,
0.3149670660495758,
-0.14824005961418152,
-0.7819443941116333,
0.392244815826416,
-0.29206013679504395,
-0.1576969176530838,
-0.3301975429058075,
-0.37248730659484863,
-0.858506977558136,
0.277484267950058,
0.2603966295719147,
-0.2556247115135193,
0.2578863203525543,
-0.17200639843940735,
-0.37497034668922424,
0.0940050557255745,
-0.5500149130821228,
0.7641199231147766,
-0.21573364734649658,
-0.27046895027160645,
-0.11443059891462326,
-0.9334721565246582,
0.0009111750405281782,
0.17632274329662323,
-0.5078189373016357,
0.008078979328274727,
0.10752792656421661,
0.838860809803009,
-0.4339016377925873,
0.5032631158828735,
-0.1885426789522171,
0.1721058338880539,
0.04573581740260124,
-0.18193648755550385,
0.8369728326797485,
0.05054011195898056,
-0.18557319045066833,
0.2716626822948456,
-0.20499251782894135,
-0.31701555848121643,
-0.5698283314704895,
0.3665316700935364,
-0.6759079098701477,
-0.5030215382575989,
-0.15732674300670624,
-0.8313988447189331,
-0.12019805610179901,
0.3299253582954407,
0.5036559104919434,
0.5246613621711731,
-0.0934486910700798,
0.37911221385002136,
0.7020033597946167,
0.17704857885837555,
0.9164408445358276,
0.36297810077667236,
0.29833388328552246,
-0.5232155323028564,
0.5574823617935181,
-0.03867647051811218,
0.3250589966773987,
0.6451454758644104,
-0.024980071932077408,
-0.6555553078651428,
-0.9678516983985901,
-0.7027961015701294,
0.12210296839475632,
-0.6593183279037476,
-0.6609683632850647,
-0.8457754254341125,
-0.455307275056839,
-0.3610261082649231,
-0.2593037784099579,
-0.8037240505218506,
-0.3574114739894867,
-0.17155112326145172,
-0.008863480761647224,
0.26262515783309937,
0.537397027015686,
0.11126111447811127,
0.6641495823860168,
-0.7581034898757935,
0.0813651978969574,
0.19750574231147766,
0.2487230747938156,
0.05115316063165665,
-0.7159210443496704,
-0.3950251340866089,
0.17984071373939514,
0.045484259724617004,
-0.7872089743614197,
0.5004278421401978,
-0.27146393060684204,
0.14226746559143066,
0.2281891405582428,
0.039054252207279205,
0.6313830614089966,
-0.8592422604560852,
0.43462273478507996,
0.4047697186470032,
-1.099606990814209,
0.3220497667789459,
-0.22151458263397217,
0.5906835198402405,
0.6251131296157837,
0.23336070775985718,
-0.6670021414756775,
0.17284582555294037,
-0.20296114683151245,
-0.8426265716552734,
0.8916515111923218,
0.4677278399467468,
0.2732425630092621,
0.1253817081451416,
0.12438302487134933,
0.011316231451928616,
0.2645794749259949,
-0.5188361406326294,
0.11910471320152283,
-0.4261890947818756,
-0.31834831833839417,
-0.28850382566452026,
-0.6792616248130798,
0.21061323583126068,
-0.36383259296417236,
0.5581852793693542,
-0.20991984009742737,
0.6095839738845825,
0.33299964666366577,
-0.4474489390850067,
0.12760215997695923,
0.41243892908096313,
0.7095924019813538,
0.3137022852897644,
-0.2752475142478943,
0.38243958353996277,
0.16178405284881592,
-0.6122620701789856,
0.14644530415534973,
0.2645450830459595,
-0.28623101115226746,
0.1421092003583908,
0.25768712162971497,
1.0850324630737305,
0.23050746321678162,
-0.369524747133255,
0.7540923953056335,
-0.07989493757486343,
0.05625499412417412,
0.07651731371879578,
-0.4872099459171295,
0.32416555285453796,
0.5413311123847961,
0.2620488107204437,
0.25661802291870117,
0.4860641062259674,
-0.14721855521202087,
0.25064006447792053,
0.13725464046001434,
-0.5541526079177856,
-0.4094984233379364,
0.7286726832389832,
0.3936113119125366,
-0.4967842698097229,
0.9764367341995239,
-0.046469397842884064,
-0.8740682601928711,
0.4690869152545929,
1.0069911479949951,
0.9730433821678162,
-0.27504482865333557,
0.20908719301223755,
0.3950771689414978,
0.37091130018234253,
-0.1828918755054474,
-0.19419294595718384,
-0.3948259651660919,
-0.6026625037193298,
-0.5521306991577148,
-0.890945553779602,
-0.11748933047056198,
-0.40178531408309937,
-0.8650330901145935,
-0.1032077893614769,
0.20895753800868988,
-0.10075319558382034,
-0.3706580102443695,
-0.24149730801582336,
-0.30136242508888245,
0.09952884912490845,
-0.006218244321644306,
0.8947515487670898,
-0.44496220350265503,
1.0708039999008179,
0.3408813774585724,
-0.101344995200634,
-0.5179039835929871,
0.18353040516376495,
-0.4727339446544647,
-0.8172978162765503,
0.42619213461875916,
0.32651257514953613,
-0.4315028488636017,
0.26978492736816406,
0.03043951280415058,
-0.9537122249603271,
1.3330199718475342,
0.1164746806025505,
-0.6144751906394958,
-0.26055222749710083,
0.6281988024711609,
0.4775506854057312,
-0.35638242959976196,
0.14731824398040771,
0.7444828152656555,
0.34003835916519165,
0.2773626148700714,
-0.6684187054634094,
0.2416367530822754,
-0.3871694803237915,
0.600722074508667,
0.16047781705856323,
-0.49167200922966003,
0.6277396082878113,
-0.15162554383277893,
-0.3936343789100647,
0.020661545917391777,
0.8592861294746399,
-0.41683030128479004,
0.12949955463409424,
0.17995084822177887,
0.18035604059696198,
0.38301870226860046,
-0.15001356601715088,
0.9010077118873596,
-0.31874266266822815,
0.36398401856422424,
1.0312464237213135,
0.19317340850830078,
0.9119573831558228,
0.5527713894844055,
0.007314654532819986,
0.2453179657459259,
0.34222495555877686,
0.1499132215976715,
0.8149362206459045,
-0.23470427095890045,
-0.08983459323644638,
-0.16009946167469025,
0.017564663663506508,
-0.3634898066520691,
0.599102258682251,
0.00959588773548603,
-0.6180229783058167,
-0.13079074025154114,
0.49150800704956055,
0.16488079726696014,
0.1199224516749382,
-0.08868825435638428,
0.5245537757873535,
-0.11555366218090057,
-0.7251045107841492,
0.7441949248313904,
0.4169992506504059,
0.9470916986465454,
-0.38305920362472534,
0.23867519199848175,
-0.312336266040802,
0.24203723669052124,
0.08762851357460022,
-0.7553755640983582,
0.44115355610847473,
-0.17217615246772766,
-0.33844950795173645,
-0.5404111742973328,
0.6882514357566833,
-0.6547688245773315,
-0.2614313066005707,
0.2896178662776947,
0.35343673825263977,
-0.08406993001699448,
-0.2802513539791107,
-0.46348097920417786,
0.13310182094573975,
0.2848035991191864,
-0.15699759125709534,
-0.03519425541162491,
0.23462265729904175,
0.18162190914154053,
0.2699199914932251,
0.5657585263252258,
-0.3440878689289093,
0.14390911161899567,
0.26784202456474304,
0.7668665647506714,
-0.8399372100830078,
-0.5760853886604309,
-0.9275871515274048,
0.7954699397087097,
-0.21306025981903076,
0.06187015399336815,
0.9285977482795715,
0.5618146657943726,
0.5871706604957581,
-0.2640071213245392,
0.18833427131175995,
0.12703052163124084,
0.17399629950523376,
-0.5718251466751099,
0.8937284350395203,
-0.2552412152290344,
0.12475962936878204,
0.3355487883090973,
-0.691470742225647,
-0.32348933815956116,
0.33405810594558716,
-0.2933577597141266,
-0.24840396642684937,
0.9216483235359192,
0.5785992741584778,
-0.21734541654586792,
0.3367757499217987,
0.5032059550285339,
0.18924909830093384,
0.11438429355621338,
0.6088946461677551,
0.8135071992874146,
-0.8739438056945801,
0.3005700409412384,
-0.4961768090724945,
0.03740790858864784,
-0.5157091021537781,
-0.4967864155769348,
-0.8200371861457825,
-0.7630185484886169,
-0.008321624249219894,
-0.4124111533164978,
0.3399412930011749,
0.6994273066520691,
0.6931119561195374,
-0.6110761165618896,
-0.17208100855350494,
-0.2411777675151825,
-0.026929382234811783,
-0.24937932193279266,
-0.15116161108016968,
0.4167693555355072,
-0.23854830861091614,
-0.9123621582984924,
0.7100458741188049,
0.5442837476730347,
-0.007843639701604843,
0.17085932195186615,
-0.28226545453071594,
-0.22999592125415802,
0.16236135363578796,
1.07230544090271,
-0.2714369595050812,
-0.42870333790779114,
-0.17257840931415558,
0.17112334072589874,
-0.276228129863739,
0.5893133282661438,
0.8445696830749512,
-0.27210915088653564,
0.4109684228897095,
0.45533546805381775,
0.7346323728561401,
0.6628379821777344,
0.19401206076145172,
0.5756068229675293,
-0.3959091305732727,
-0.01272984966635704,
0.6069303750991821,
0.2427249699831009,
0.512301504611969,
-0.5972549319267273,
0.4413808584213257,
0.1266545206308365,
-0.48582321405410767,
-0.6857741475105286,
0.012271711602807045,
-1.051102638244629,
-0.21069133281707764,
1.1071873903274536,
-0.005812871269881725,
-0.4022544324398041,
0.10728593170642853,
-0.04034828394651413,
0.48358845710754395,
-0.34012582898139954,
0.5246448516845703,
0.24585913121700287,
-0.07247676700353622,
-0.18800392746925354,
-0.3003138601779938,
0.3125011920928955,
0.5035098195075989,
-0.5720657706260681,
0.03440893441438675,
0.26476603746414185,
0.13813520967960358,
0.22156676650047302,
0.34060344099998474,
-0.0980071872472763,
0.3387351632118225,
0.20986633002758026,
-0.018791215494275093,
-0.19684119522571564,
-0.4575861692428589,
-0.6797340512275696,
0.3179304301738739,
-0.12366132438182831,
-0.5247395634651184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12483v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12483v2 | Artifacts or Abduction: How Do LLMs Answer Multiple-Choice Questions Without the Question? | 2024-02-19T19:38:58 | 2024-06-07T23:11:14 | Nishant Balepur, Abhilasha Ravichander, Rachel Rudinger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multiple-choice question answering (MCQA) is often used to evaluate large
language models (LLMs). To see if MCQA assesses LLMs as intended, we probe if
LLMs can perform MCQA with choices-only prompts, where models must select the
correct answer only from the choices. In three MCQA datasets and four LLMs,
this prompt bests a majority baseline in 11/12 cases, with up to 0.33 accuracy
gain. To help explain this behavior, we conduct an in-depth, black-box analysis
on memorization, choice dynamics, and question inference. Our key findings are
threefold. First, we find no evidence that the choices-only accuracy stems from
memorization alone. Second, priors over individual choices do not fully explain
choices-only accuracy, hinting that LLMs use the group dynamics of choices.
Third, LLMs have some ability to infer a relevant question from choices, and
surprisingly can sometimes even match the original question. Inferring the
original question is an impressive reasoning strategy, but it cannot fully
explain the high choices-only accuracy of LLMs in MCQA. Thus, while LLMs are
not fully incapable of reasoning in MCQA, we still advocate for the use of
stronger baselines in MCQA benchmarks, the design of robust MCQA datasets for
fair evaluations, and further efforts to explain LLM decision-making. | [
-0.5202035307884216,
-0.8757832050323486,
1.0904324054718018,
-0.24626287817955017,
-0.0248248390853405,
0.3260236382484436,
0.08383218199014664,
-0.1627441793680191,
0.008243048563599586,
0.6127228140830994,
-0.9174726605415344,
-0.1901332587003708,
-0.42174622416496277,
0.20382286608219147,
-0.2187609076499939,
0.8501071333885193,
0.025628570467233658,
0.1563141644001007,
-0.6299436688423157,
-0.2528144419193268,
-0.2956140637397766,
-0.6369489431381226,
-0.7062767148017883,
-0.21860437095165253,
0.6316190361976624,
0.6225820779800415,
0.7877849340438843,
0.7908775806427002,
0.10485947132110596,
0.21447043120861053,
-0.295952707529068,
0.3116258680820465,
-0.40855205059051514,
-0.0644940659403801,
-0.007295757997781038,
-0.7865233421325684,
-0.0998348593711853,
0.3111540675163269,
0.5615145564079285,
0.7916667461395264,
-0.03983156755566597,
0.47497761249542236,
-0.0011838292703032494,
0.5858210921287537,
-0.6557151079177856,
-0.31109359860420227,
-0.7596410512924194,
-0.08790158480405807,
-0.04304030165076256,
-0.24961566925048828,
-0.426756888628006,
-0.38058552145957947,
0.18592257797718048,
-0.29360583424568176,
0.051609721034765244,
0.18369318544864655,
0.7042633891105652,
0.19836580753326416,
-0.6606056094169617,
-0.6351487040519714,
-0.45504993200302124,
0.8333609700202942,
-0.18520423769950867,
0.23609060049057007,
0.34987807273864746,
0.2737237513065338,
-0.27017292380332947,
-0.5919805765151978,
-0.5573776364326477,
-0.4994937479496002,
0.03386595845222473,
0.3225952088832855,
-0.004354638978838921,
0.032287437468767166,
0.6801484227180481,
0.4633886218070984,
-0.46519193053245544,
0.1170920729637146,
-0.5960047245025635,
-0.2557229995727539,
0.30426791310310364,
0.2016950398683548,
0.24160295724868774,
-0.18014350533485413,
-0.6434364914894104,
0.07365033775568008,
-0.9212515950202942,
0.4088697135448456,
0.391266793012619,
0.15041914582252502,
0.2076931595802307,
1.0990519523620605,
-0.07419097423553467,
0.681958019733429,
0.13388855755329132,
-0.0776972696185112,
0.1868056207895279,
-0.044007956981658936,
-0.22765590250492096,
-0.1301814615726471,
0.5541322827339172,
0.0905461385846138,
0.3119231164455414,
-0.01795017533004284,
-0.044015929102897644,
-0.13292215764522552,
0.20856882631778717,
-0.4453873634338379,
0.07046979665756226,
0.588681697845459,
-0.36712542176246643,
-0.057217806577682495,
-0.19969409704208374,
-0.6023977398872375,
-0.3938237130641937,
-0.2567926049232483,
0.6301650404930115,
-0.13928380608558655,
-0.14236649870872498,
0.05254308506846428,
-0.3612445294857025,
0.3201828896999359,
0.29911667108535767,
-0.5147385597229004,
0.37123140692710876,
0.4233481287956238,
0.6144150495529175,
-0.43654942512512207,
-0.5326841473579407,
-0.6786397099494934,
-0.058196280151605606,
-0.568493664264679,
0.8396962285041809,
-0.4951398968696594,
-0.49671050906181335,
-0.15209746360778809,
0.06159543991088867,
-0.20454557240009308,
-0.6641307473182678,
0.7495913505554199,
-0.5782368779182434,
0.31109288334846497,
-0.8225868344306946,
-0.5600428581237793,
-0.34868544340133667,
0.13071607053279877,
-0.6390476822853088,
1.0718402862548828,
-0.19260114431381226,
-0.5506760478019714,
0.40074464678764343,
-0.5985114574432373,
0.04773910343647003,
-0.2275485396385193,
-0.3421218991279602,
0.022077979519963264,
0.2152201384305954,
0.3423367738723755,
0.14215750992298126,
-0.07016737014055252,
0.006695651914924383,
-0.45268985629081726,
-0.4843234419822693,
0.6945350766181946,
-0.7449156045913696,
1.0733087062835693,
0.15886756777763367,
-0.12836898863315582,
-0.2692863643169403,
-0.5613493919372559,
0.0036975156981498003,
0.14429974555969238,
-0.49563854932785034,
-0.05339910089969635,
0.08429864048957825,
-0.6482810378074646,
0.4441610276699066,
-0.021297995001077652,
-0.571204423904419,
0.2777136266231537,
-0.1015370711684227,
-0.014928779564797878,
0.7720844745635986,
0.15106575191020966,
0.4887799918651581,
-0.9212556481361389,
0.7576514482498169,
0.011925976723432541,
-0.0777813121676445,
-0.07977724820375443,
-0.6122527122497559,
-0.8912467360496521,
-0.222152978181839,
0.07026821374893188,
0.6232679486274719,
-0.828266441822052,
-0.47604116797447205,
-0.12297637015581131,
-0.25821954011917114,
-0.7550749182701111,
0.1604773849248886,
0.2246505618095398,
0.6365304589271545,
0.4272884726524353,
0.015397329814732075,
-0.532150149345398,
-0.9867941737174988,
-0.2794378995895386,
-0.3528747856616974,
-0.008729001507163048,
0.5028932690620422,
0.4541719853878021,
0.25390690565109253,
0.8567439913749695,
-0.28851422667503357,
0.2922414243221283,
-0.13992124795913696,
0.02642211876809597,
0.31685546040534973,
0.14344742894172668,
0.3409619629383087,
-0.8032787442207336,
0.15344136953353882,
-0.4612875282764435,
-0.7216202616691589,
-0.2447873204946518,
-0.30457067489624023,
-0.20757879316806793,
0.18260246515274048,
0.39770039916038513,
-0.9382489919662476,
0.22962018847465515,
0.39511752128601074,
0.0020574836526066065,
0.900327742099762,
0.03993302956223488,
0.1926725059747696,
-0.5956712961196899,
-0.07642862200737,
-0.5184488296508789,
-0.04782894253730774,
-0.6823562979698181,
0.14139549434185028,
0.1922188550233841,
0.2542372941970825,
-0.7995239496231079,
0.8074929118156433,
-0.6892977952957153,
-0.22783389687538147,
-0.05791261047124863,
0.210153728723526,
0.012412402778863907,
0.5012228488922119,
0.08814013004302979,
1.0027196407318115,
0.3902605175971985,
-0.9020573496818542,
0.06341490894556046,
0.25037679076194763,
-0.38499653339385986,
0.5245705842971802,
-0.22664380073547363,
0.44484490156173706,
-0.35341566801071167,
-0.09056977927684784,
-1.1983624696731567,
-0.029118280857801437,
0.34777113795280457,
-0.5692270398139954,
0.006983909755945206,
-0.18125373125076294,
-0.17839260399341583,
-0.4465204179286957,
-0.3029797375202179,
0.20124275982379913,
0.45553603768348694,
-0.5968080163002014,
0.7120710611343384,
0.12172599136829376,
-0.13788557052612305,
-1.0625665187835693,
-0.7897845506668091,
0.029786331579089165,
-0.27561601996421814,
-0.0726236030459404,
-0.1982104778289795,
-0.6970849633216858,
-0.5071182250976562,
-0.27460184693336487,
-0.49366340041160583,
-0.22985857725143433,
0.3441321551799774,
0.38571083545684814,
0.4083757698535919,
-0.3753538727760315,
0.3165472745895386,
0.10786851495504379,
0.15393471717834473,
0.30449336767196655,
-0.010130343027412891,
0.2807135283946991,
-0.01716979220509529,
-0.6177403926849365,
-0.09166263788938522,
0.21826152503490448,
0.6632881760597229,
-0.1160687580704689,
0.5880426168441772,
0.11667396128177643,
-0.21121779084205627,
-0.03929224982857704,
-0.8857609629631042,
0.09996289759874344,
-0.4487614333629608,
0.05126287415623665,
-0.7793367505073547,
-0.9802168011665344,
0.6114374995231628,
0.06724265217781067,
0.20736773312091827,
0.3937939405441284,
0.699789822101593,
-0.48459431529045105,
0.8211907148361206,
-0.020589955151081085,
0.3355778455734253,
0.08152992278337479,
0.04712783917784691,
-0.27695432305336,
-0.9298925399780273,
-0.24327482283115387,
-0.6172363758087158,
-0.23232460021972656,
-0.31393998861312866,
-0.3133348524570465,
0.13196934759616852,
0.11351552605628967,
-0.3518563508987427,
-0.170640230178833,
-0.08758775889873505,
0.7846499681472778,
0.5833902955055237,
0.1896040290594101,
0.48328882455825806,
-0.1965213567018509,
-0.49229684472084045,
0.09218483418226242,
-0.6851207613945007,
-0.6813299655914307,
1.366135835647583,
0.09995544701814651,
0.4594763219356537,
0.20731188356876373,
0.7163451313972473,
-0.0028196785133332014,
0.3445165753364563,
-0.9168789982795715,
0.6408888697624207,
0.4204813539981842,
-0.9434095621109009,
-0.2598525285720825,
-0.3312705159187317,
-0.9626181125640869,
0.529190182685852,
-0.29847046732902527,
-0.7533347606658936,
0.20929507911205292,
0.07015572488307953,
-0.5638919472694397,
0.20964887738227844,
-0.5416871905326843,
0.6776236891746521,
-0.37838315963745117,
-0.14468742907047272,
0.3151512145996094,
-0.50174480676651,
0.6865564584732056,
-0.1331033855676651,
0.2920984625816345,
0.04467005655169487,
-0.3642185628414154,
0.6202500462532043,
0.07952519506216049,
0.5492899417877197,
-0.03201398253440857,
0.02705627679824829,
0.5914273858070374,
0.3665240705013275,
0.3055408000946045,
0.07652399688959122,
-0.2852727770805359,
-0.06642357259988785,
0.16848978400230408,
-0.4637497663497925,
-0.8264918923377991,
0.47389325499534607,
-0.46781402826309204,
-1.0704854726791382,
-0.3981315493583679,
-0.6419817209243774,
-0.2569012939929962,
0.10442616790533066,
0.08880855143070221,
0.3099583089351654,
-0.11842543631792068,
0.11975686252117157,
0.7629293203353882,
-0.13526977598667145,
0.6055746078491211,
0.5272783637046814,
-0.3464111387729645,
-0.3006855547428131,
0.3859650194644928,
0.39667776226997375,
0.670723021030426,
0.23648075759410858,
0.1208885982632637,
-0.5900445580482483,
-0.8641155958175659,
-0.6884818077087402,
0.25856244564056396,
-0.9878060221672058,
0.17553959786891937,
-0.8082970380783081,
-0.09551242738962173,
0.12182179093360901,
0.09367319941520691,
-0.02004440687596798,
-0.5886396169662476,
-0.41218113899230957,
-0.5668777227401733,
-0.23097310960292816,
0.6081110835075378,
0.07587853819131851,
0.03657408803701401,
-0.6259588003158569,
0.5541698336601257,
0.6060519218444824,
-0.09392618387937546,
-0.05821959301829338,
-0.5630596280097961,
0.2021118402481079,
0.3211360573768616,
-0.2521350085735321,
-1.0585025548934937,
-0.04327710345387459,
-0.019766459241509438,
0.9266259670257568,
0.16707924008369446,
0.0778447762131691,
0.9552463293075562,
-0.5608938336372375,
0.9710783958435059,
-0.4272918105125427,
-0.8349236249923706,
0.12310702353715897,
-0.12745167315006256,
0.40009167790412903,
0.6812109351158142,
0.49494385719299316,
-0.3958301246166229,
-0.5500697493553162,
-0.7279821038246155,
-0.15072819590568542,
0.598690390586853,
0.079421266913414,
0.23834356665611267,
-0.2338234931230545,
0.5946276783943176,
0.12897330522537231,
0.31902799010276794,
-0.8561125993728638,
-0.5089632868766785,
0.1449202597141266,
0.0663265585899353,
-0.13731306791305542,
-0.47248125076293945,
-0.23745021224021912,
0.05048109591007233,
0.3593212068080902,
-0.12804098427295685,
0.29146578907966614,
0.3288482427597046,
-0.3596396744251251,
-0.14283934235572815,
0.39397475123405457,
0.7988228797912598,
0.959006667137146,
-0.12459494173526764,
0.2678428888320923,
0.6835271120071411,
-0.2522106468677521,
0.34194502234458923,
-0.2804698646068573,
-0.05004090070724487,
-0.07282544672489166,
0.24915790557861328,
0.45775511860847473,
0.012158946134150028,
-0.801433265209198,
0.5238116383552551,
-0.10839437693357468,
-0.38535287976264954,
-0.273860365152359,
0.14564883708953857,
0.21469669044017792,
0.2722893953323364,
0.5704116821289062,
0.19809262454509735,
0.13792581856250763,
-0.6314177513122559,
0.28320255875587463,
0.7210344076156616,
-0.2536887228488922,
-0.04135371372103691,
0.5947537422180176,
-0.46148937940597534,
-0.37659746408462524,
0.6295891404151917,
-0.009758631698787212,
-0.37442746758461,
0.7889798283576965,
0.4081154763698578,
0.5296980142593384,
-0.3419526219367981,
0.3970893323421478,
0.2036086916923523,
0.6018988490104675,
-0.13418449461460114,
0.5564028024673462,
-0.11914990842342377,
-0.8308780193328857,
-0.4987168312072754,
-0.403431236743927,
-0.6741999387741089,
0.3733454942703247,
-0.7984212040901184,
0.11721957474946976,
-0.3947995901107788,
0.07654847949743271,
-0.12181437015533447,
-0.1100466325879097,
-0.5700296759605408,
0.4158431887626648,
0.18151399493217468,
1.103083610534668,
-0.646338164806366,
0.599431037902832,
0.4255247116088867,
-0.272760272026062,
-0.7258730530738831,
-0.027894485741853714,
0.37597402930259705,
-1.0447176694869995,
0.4039212167263031,
0.18398582935333252,
-0.08770707249641418,
-0.1576366424560547,
-0.7464200854301453,
-1.0525532960891724,
0.9152387380599976,
0.5690569281578064,
-0.07852168381214142,
0.13199540972709656,
0.02006206475198269,
0.3109399676322937,
-0.4175368547439575,
0.5446183681488037,
0.5988790988922119,
0.4230451285839081,
0.4632282555103302,
-0.7257631421089172,
-0.01840987801551819,
0.05632990598678589,
-0.3889676332473755,
0.06074181944131851,
-0.39744874835014343,
0.9242314696311951,
-0.5124399662017822,
-0.4211527109146118,
0.33162131905555725,
0.39648064970970154,
0.556932806968689,
0.2804088890552521,
0.32785990834236145,
0.3171796202659607,
1.019707202911377,
-0.15652498602867126,
1.1762549877166748,
0.2126704603433609,
-0.005980412941426039,
1.3198567628860474,
-0.1764671951532364,
0.8741844892501831,
0.6756818294525146,
-0.14102205634117126,
0.36666935682296753,
0.885459303855896,
0.14352597296237946,
0.21686895191669464,
0.19459979236125946,
-0.11209901422262192,
-0.44739440083503723,
0.10972873866558075,
-0.09673616290092468,
0.41949597001075745,
0.32844841480255127,
-0.2979063391685486,
0.01651359535753727,
-0.026987606659531593,
0.07835029065608978,
-0.3242571949958801,
-0.36366310715675354,
0.6787981390953064,
0.08993268758058548,
-0.9566851854324341,
0.7065354585647583,
-0.4887438416481018,
0.05814588814973831,
-0.5013508200645447,
-0.04945046827197075,
-0.2861284911632538,
-0.4124752879142761,
-0.1228564977645874,
-0.9877318143844604,
0.08187992870807648,
-0.17131328582763672,
-0.08889766782522202,
-0.15320086479187012,
0.3768802285194397,
-0.38021120429039,
-0.3330141305923462,
-0.02644106186926365,
1.098684549331665,
0.43005746603012085,
0.04119459539651871,
-0.6753014326095581,
-0.32193389534950256,
-0.011991633102297783,
-0.5032882690429688,
0.2537568211555481,
0.3604004681110382,
-0.047107767313718796,
1.0145232677459717,
0.7991518378257751,
0.13479554653167725,
0.27141544222831726,
-0.19173572957515717,
0.6290149092674255,
-0.5435039401054382,
-0.02019989676773548,
-1.0702753067016602,
0.7067928314208984,
0.015631623566150665,
-0.23555970191955566,
0.8050965666770935,
0.6786096096038818,
0.7340214848518372,
-0.026064924895763397,
0.71002197265625,
0.3968295753002167,
0.6250796318054199,
-0.8830775022506714,
0.3087998032569885,
-0.639767050743103,
0.3427765369415283,
-0.2196483612060547,
-0.8143427968025208,
-0.21986038982868195,
0.26545822620391846,
-0.4251948893070221,
0.0744488388299942,
0.9523150324821472,
0.8596305847167969,
0.08762720227241516,
0.13877850770950317,
0.42621976137161255,
0.1669885516166687,
0.03695528209209442,
0.5232506990432739,
1.4861551523208618,
-0.11493343114852905,
0.8124508857727051,
0.01826314441859722,
-0.05838523805141449,
0.2748998999595642,
-0.7717946171760559,
-1.0267528295516968,
-0.418656587600708,
-0.06119083613157272,
-0.2707708179950714,
-0.17198282480239868,
0.8993211984634399,
0.16178588569164276,
-0.6340017318725586,
-0.3650963008403778,
0.3927915394306183,
0.5316476821899414,
-0.359331339597702,
-0.1431625634431839,
0.30572575330734253,
-0.281597763299942,
-0.750735878944397,
0.5652239322662354,
0.14141330122947693,
0.3601648211479187,
0.14368782937526703,
-0.024156862869858742,
-0.28280743956565857,
0.3504750728607178,
0.3241109549999237,
0.284120112657547,
-1.0480231046676636,
-0.4669148027896881,
0.23171760141849518,
0.07741864025592804,
0.4308348298072815,
0.646393358707428,
-0.7726359367370605,
0.43057873845100403,
0.1235693022608757,
0.7547473311424255,
0.3800509572029114,
0.23640798032283783,
0.27932679653167725,
-0.47053641080856323,
-0.21670269966125488,
0.29306548833847046,
0.3928084671497345,
-0.004332391079515219,
-0.1793030947446823,
0.2905537486076355,
0.028878314420580864,
-0.6020106673240662,
-0.865249752998352,
0.34863272309303284,
-0.9438759088516235,
-0.410820871591568,
1.1933135986328125,
0.04287112131714821,
-0.13711364567279816,
-0.34418433904647827,
-0.5493285059928894,
-0.06282607465982437,
-0.09656447172164917,
0.48023512959480286,
1.261870265007019,
-0.34534770250320435,
-0.5692638754844666,
-0.9662678241729736,
0.5015281438827515,
0.4195222854614258,
-0.638448178768158,
-0.007321320008486509,
0.6571557521820068,
0.3730902373790741,
0.17319335043430328,
0.7927385568618774,
0.05961975082755089,
0.46751290559768677,
-0.11769385635852814,
-0.3720056712627411,
-0.23833605647087097,
-0.29607024788856506,
-0.5847423672676086,
0.486415296792984,
0.2053142488002777,
-0.2538968324661255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12451v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12451v2 | The Revolution of Multimodal Large Language Models: A Survey | 2024-02-19T19:01:01 | 2024-06-06T16:13:43 | Davide Caffagni, Federico Cocchi, Luca Barsellotti, Nicholas Moratelli, Sara Sarto, Lorenzo Baraldi, Lorenzo Baraldi, Marcella Cornia, Rita Cucchiara | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM | Connecting text and visual modalities plays an essential role in generative
intelligence. For this reason, inspired by the success of large language
models, significant research efforts are being devoted to the development of
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs). These models can seamlessly integrate
visual and textual modalities, while providing a dialogue-based interface and
instruction-following capabilities. In this paper, we provide a comprehensive
review of recent visual-based MLLMs, analyzing their architectural choices,
multimodal alignment strategies, and training techniques. We also conduct a
detailed analysis of these models across a wide range of tasks, including
visual grounding, image generation and editing, visual understanding, and
domain-specific applications. Additionally, we compile and describe training
datasets and evaluation benchmarks, conducting comparisons among existing
models in terms of performance and computational requirements. Overall, this
survey offers a comprehensive overview of the current state of the art, laying
the groundwork for future MLLMs. | [
-0.6017910838127136,
-0.8586606979370117,
0.5084202289581299,
0.1386663019657135,
0.09408853948116302,
0.051738884299993515,
-0.39356037974357605,
-0.3670433461666107,
-0.1392485648393631,
0.5347274541854858,
-0.4678584039211273,
-0.5047016143798828,
-0.5679755806922913,
-0.16210436820983887,
-0.4221857488155365,
0.6377872824668884,
-0.02086344175040722,
0.264868825674057,
-0.584252655506134,
-0.38707292079925537,
-0.620809018611908,
-0.5717143416404724,
-0.2414446324110031,
0.0076371789909899235,
0.7425710558891296,
-0.05501160770654678,
0.7090244889259338,
0.3654724359512329,
0.561093270778656,
0.4333825707435608,
-0.016163036227226257,
0.40779614448547363,
-0.434344619512558,
0.36094602942466736,
0.009518111124634743,
-0.17786185443401337,
-0.4376603662967682,
-0.07452642172574997,
0.6850184798240662,
0.7250936031341553,
0.16491220891475677,
0.09103658050298691,
-0.11162006109952927,
0.5815942883491516,
-0.6422830820083618,
0.2825697958469391,
-0.4123874008655548,
0.062139417976140976,
-0.11809778213500977,
-0.1257631629705429,
-0.6734670400619507,
-0.023612763732671738,
0.19401684403419495,
-0.37850937247276306,
-0.051936738193035126,
0.039330895990133286,
0.4352164566516876,
0.10553484410047531,
-0.7728471755981445,
-0.3401775658130646,
-0.832432210445404,
0.9499598741531372,
-0.564674437046051,
0.8744314312934875,
0.08448915183544159,
0.3494039475917816,
0.03821016848087311,
-0.7895843982696533,
-0.5690765976905823,
-0.4562437832355499,
0.17361263930797577,
0.16586944460868835,
-0.07982919365167618,
0.044615790247917175,
0.2087608128786087,
0.29805201292037964,
-0.777423620223999,
0.18230564892292023,
-0.2738581895828247,
0.08703947812318802,
0.4437703788280487,
0.3490470051765442,
0.6041601896286011,
-0.11795578896999359,
-0.4984881281852722,
-0.19320234656333923,
-0.5371652841567993,
-0.025091594085097313,
0.12271881848573685,
0.10727844387292862,
-0.276144415140152,
0.8351961970329285,
-0.08944614231586456,
1.1460230350494385,
-0.4530542492866516,
-0.45658355951309204,
0.20788419246673584,
-0.79170161485672,
-0.3141327202320099,
-0.514155387878418,
0.9196573495864868,
0.636019229888916,
0.34362033009529114,
0.11281049251556396,
-0.38482123613357544,
-0.045752812176942825,
0.19985248148441315,
-0.7221580743789673,
-0.20073018968105316,
0.05724811553955078,
-0.6927940845489502,
-0.2214217633008957,
-0.221144437789917,
-0.8192684650421143,
-0.5465349555015564,
-0.7315695285797119,
0.21234063804149628,
-0.6531562209129333,
-0.32825785875320435,
-0.05981528386473656,
-0.15264029800891876,
0.17943185567855835,
0.6948643326759338,
-0.9505563974380493,
-0.2649499475955963,
0.4851803481578827,
0.662541925907135,
0.0038492674939334393,
-0.4198780357837677,
-0.3115859925746918,
0.06957664340734482,
-0.40708816051483154,
0.7583351731300354,
-0.7150939702987671,
-0.18378978967666626,
0.4954647123813629,
-0.09744677692651749,
-0.1384802758693695,
-0.19518490135669708,
0.15902701020240784,
-0.5709629058837891,
0.3642512559890747,
-0.1500573307275772,
-0.32511579990386963,
-0.4033322036266327,
0.6851306557655334,
-0.7589784264564514,
0.6961945295333862,
-0.0412481427192688,
-0.7027468085289001,
0.30007264018058777,
-0.4131030738353729,
-0.21206508576869965,
0.1048385426402092,
-0.4112372100353241,
-0.2528766095638275,
0.06932453066110611,
0.2638694643974304,
0.6654977202415466,
-0.4549270272254944,
0.37623077630996704,
-0.34365126490592957,
-0.0636339783668518,
0.47425487637519836,
-0.8653921484947205,
0.6936839818954468,
0.18047916889190674,
-0.1058635339140892,
0.5613939762115479,
-0.808451235294342,
0.08921456336975098,
0.000594196782913059,
-0.22788091003894806,
-0.2349688559770584,
0.14450998604297638,
0.44980567693710327,
0.4354647696018219,
0.21063178777694702,
-0.13925346732139587,
0.34348058700561523,
0.10523565113544464,
0.4734613597393036,
0.6127086281776428,
-0.246034637093544,
0.47673338651657104,
-0.01837722584605217,
0.4371691942214966,
0.04528912529349327,
0.41393110156059265,
-0.7727914452552795,
-0.45019710063934326,
-0.7953593134880066,
-0.5501053929328918,
0.20736190676689148,
0.4475362002849579,
-1.0100080966949463,
0.15085813403129578,
-0.37260767817497253,
-0.6075325012207031,
-0.30358144640922546,
0.2568801939487457,
0.294809490442276,
0.0032325121574103832,
0.2464793175458908,
0.003990502562373877,
-0.4024204909801483,
-0.8903782963752747,
0.18393374979496002,
-0.07998351007699966,
0.2075788676738739,
0.2524753212928772,
0.459979385137558,
-0.5207661390304565,
0.6424573063850403,
-0.19039314985275269,
-0.029721371829509735,
-0.3495330512523651,
0.19593048095703125,
-0.19325430691242218,
0.3462887108325958,
0.7270672917366028,
-1.005424976348877,
-0.37120550870895386,
0.3091839849948883,
-0.9465088844299316,
0.39101913571357727,
-0.1281091719865799,
0.13393692672252655,
0.10209842771291733,
0.6122511029243469,
-0.7119397521018982,
0.2101055085659027,
0.8257231116294861,
-0.15117597579956055,
0.5226906538009644,
-0.09954854100942612,
0.36232855916023254,
-0.9535850882530212,
0.16739113628864288,
0.09583398699760437,
-0.09778734296560287,
-0.7716346979141235,
0.17403265833854675,
0.12330157309770584,
-0.3222377300262451,
-0.4038308560848236,
0.4732837677001953,
-0.867952823638916,
0.019569316878914833,
-0.11895803362131119,
0.1087832897901535,
-0.09388168156147003,
0.5068801641464233,
-0.06434673815965652,
0.6609103679656982,
0.6260008215904236,
-0.33393970131874084,
0.8829655647277832,
0.3317526876926422,
-0.5636050701141357,
0.5761327743530273,
-0.38834357261657715,
-0.09143140912055969,
-0.47904732823371887,
0.17648951709270477,
-1.141247272491455,
-0.35223376750946045,
0.07577542215585709,
-0.21696600317955017,
0.2624138593673706,
-0.050567448139190674,
-0.48945945501327515,
-0.33130455017089844,
-0.3221314549446106,
0.5823556184768677,
0.4084088206291199,
-0.3895774185657501,
0.9916124939918518,
0.20031319558620453,
-0.39644038677215576,
-0.6111912131309509,
-0.4900074899196625,
0.3818705677986145,
-0.032012857496738434,
-0.6757667064666748,
-0.023306988179683685,
-0.10001958161592484,
-0.32340487837791443,
-0.2110956609249115,
0.6145045161247253,
0.07149367034435272,
-0.35178306698799133,
0.12490987032651901,
0.4866349399089813,
-0.32818806171417236,
0.28835174441337585,
-0.429126113653183,
0.174855574965477,
-0.2570028305053711,
-0.010735027492046356,
0.6765018701553345,
-0.1407604068517685,
-0.5677751302719116,
-0.3270740211009979,
0.5624532103538513,
1.1633833646774292,
-0.8706102967262268,
0.7353300452232361,
0.8138404488563538,
-0.10277263075113297,
-0.013020522892475128,
-0.7604114413261414,
0.20499876141548157,
-0.3401488959789276,
0.7023796439170837,
-0.2734307646751404,
-0.8490317463874817,
0.09525381028652191,
-0.057706717401742935,
0.2221314162015915,
0.21243667602539062,
0.8882766962051392,
-0.22168096899986267,
1.1977506875991821,
0.8437102437019348,
0.1659902185201645,
0.7982991933822632,
-0.14310568571090698,
0.24459221959114075,
-0.7297155857086182,
-0.5175458788871765,
-0.29443708062171936,
-0.11083455383777618,
-0.509880542755127,
-0.6783367991447449,
0.37638935446739197,
-0.17321190237998962,
-0.10803909599781036,
-0.01974961906671524,
-0.16621249914169312,
0.014192945323884487,
0.42072540521621704,
-0.24520547688007355,
0.12686435878276825,
0.07233484089374542,
-0.005630565341562033,
-0.0164607185870409,
-0.7708162069320679,
-0.4753616452217102,
0.9344146847724915,
0.4212067723274231,
0.9280314445495605,
0.12267088890075684,
-0.015756864100694656,
-0.045696694403886795,
0.3811306357383728,
-0.7870277762413025,
0.5738953351974487,
-0.24260100722312927,
-0.38843661546707153,
-0.33653247356414795,
-0.17417287826538086,
-0.641216516494751,
0.4394386112689972,
-0.48495838046073914,
-0.37978294491767883,
0.14880383014678955,
0.06444714963436127,
0.013917587697505951,
0.3037835359573364,
-0.702226996421814,
1.1239701509475708,
-0.4657468795776367,
-0.3154836893081665,
-0.17831577360630035,
-0.6260681748390198,
0.6015315055847168,
0.041512541472911835,
0.15606388449668884,
0.04733145236968994,
0.07884370535612106,
0.35296866297721863,
-0.006052388343960047,
0.8891392946243286,
-0.024594297632575035,
-0.3874792754650116,
0.1661527305841446,
-0.24465198814868927,
0.33200934529304504,
-0.39840394258499146,
0.26289674639701843,
0.04496817663311958,
-0.05400921404361725,
-0.16702120006084442,
-0.5893335938453674,
0.6192389130592346,
-0.46265414357185364,
-0.3404023349285126,
-0.11924576759338379,
-0.7041916251182556,
-0.39312854409217834,
0.15505310893058777,
0.032144781202077866,
0.9737783670425415,
-0.41204720735549927,
0.597670316696167,
0.7298478484153748,
-0.34556999802589417,
0.6227964758872986,
0.02684488147497177,
-0.6150238513946533,
-0.6774846315383911,
1.0369138717651367,
0.025002039968967438,
0.36641913652420044,
0.5187109708786011,
-0.2511340379714966,
-0.34957200288772583,
-0.5416290163993835,
-0.7633209824562073,
0.13665549457073212,
-0.7463003396987915,
-0.06955213099718094,
-0.734879732131958,
-0.3262940049171448,
-0.38886407017707825,
-0.0765736773610115,
-0.3549003005027771,
0.03275536000728607,
-0.15491697192192078,
0.28750020265579224,
0.09453122317790985,
0.8940091133117676,
0.5084107518196106,
0.06823036819696426,
-0.8583215475082397,
0.3518927991390228,
0.6304131746292114,
0.30337318778038025,
0.24653412401676178,
-0.04927320405840874,
-0.21579265594482422,
0.020784597843885422,
-0.1773601472377777,
-0.6968909502029419,
0.19334673881530762,
0.03996516019105911,
0.5137749314308167,
0.5756152272224426,
-0.4699627459049225,
0.6392402052879333,
-0.828123152256012,
0.9589003920555115,
0.6492936015129089,
-0.5355790853500366,
0.22423486411571503,
-0.4691338837146759,
0.4507129490375519,
0.11397138237953186,
0.30071020126342773,
-0.8102464079856873,
-0.1559608280658722,
-0.05581975355744362,
-0.5576947331428528,
0.17478768527507782,
-0.04810551553964615,
0.30398356914520264,
0.11565911024808884,
-0.28671616315841675,
-0.023941349238157272,
0.39079445600509644,
-0.6922986507415771,
-0.015373432077467442,
-0.40703895688056946,
-0.4549095630645752,
-0.09728077054023743,
-0.33088240027427673,
-0.23160918056964874,
-0.19945834577083588,
0.32448285818099976,
-0.329833060503006,
0.09860152006149292,
-0.3004043996334076,
-0.286593496799469,
0.3113919496536255,
0.35784322023391724,
0.8967971205711365,
0.8883134126663208,
0.22828209400177002,
0.19079087674617767,
-0.16726885735988617,
-0.24618351459503174,
0.09856929630041122,
-0.053907353430986404,
-0.054050520062446594,
-0.035823624581098557,
0.6260340213775635,
1.228721261024475,
0.1457701027393341,
-1.0370196104049683,
0.9011277556419373,
0.0034838614519685507,
-0.10438254475593567,
-0.30510467290878296,
-0.11524362117052078,
0.11088523268699646,
0.45730942487716675,
0.1088838279247284,
0.1886722594499588,
-0.04340009018778801,
-0.7024524211883545,
-0.23662744462490082,
0.923133909702301,
-0.39287620782852173,
-0.32479503750801086,
0.5078256130218506,
0.330859512090683,
-0.09162264317274094,
0.6825394630432129,
0.25339275598526,
-0.3797846734523773,
0.2220960557460785,
0.32625043392181396,
0.6903247237205505,
-0.16740992665290833,
0.18106545507907867,
0.10651504248380661,
0.3978693187236786,
0.1665639877319336,
0.10302053391933441,
-0.04091903194785118,
-0.6204190254211426,
-0.5483464002609253,
-0.6004947423934937,
-0.13068969547748566,
0.21979404985904694,
-0.24905405938625336,
0.20803327858448029,
-0.3023163676261902,
-0.20891280472278595,
0.02067764848470688,
-0.5772659182548523,
-0.7375617623329163,
0.39802679419517517,
0.514523983001709,
0.8066174387931824,
-0.7696497440338135,
0.6399626731872559,
0.9023778438568115,
-0.5115489959716797,
-0.22263064980506897,
-0.2825879156589508,
-0.007169246673583984,
-0.550711452960968,
0.792615532875061,
0.14054159820079803,
-0.14967218041419983,
-0.10479188710451126,
-0.63462233543396,
-0.6630208492279053,
0.9072702527046204,
0.08201133459806442,
-0.5589914917945862,
-0.2269262671470642,
0.06763561069965363,
0.5340880155563354,
-0.38129106163978577,
0.2816784977912903,
0.22324812412261963,
0.508452832698822,
0.0530807189643383,
-0.7465095520019531,
-0.3837473392486572,
-0.4892398715019226,
0.4657527804374695,
0.1993081271648407,
-0.6940137147903442,
0.832494854927063,
0.03359771519899368,
-0.19142833352088928,
0.28717172145843506,
0.7476515173912048,
0.05785862356424332,
0.00953277014195919,
0.42889219522476196,
0.4763352572917938,
0.3627111315727234,
-0.0644386038184166,
0.9190337657928467,
-0.2448398917913437,
0.021200058981776237,
0.7054048180580139,
-0.25813978910446167,
0.9122344255447388,
0.5040140748023987,
-0.02114729955792427,
0.3710518777370453,
0.18818190693855286,
-0.21729502081871033,
0.32471993565559387,
-0.13239504396915436,
-0.4289013147354126,
-0.3391377925872803,
-0.27046987414360046,
-0.40996360778808594,
0.5554822087287903,
0.2890043556690216,
-0.4512338638305664,
-0.1440114676952362,
0.401040256023407,
-0.2884063422679901,
-0.010291898623108864,
-0.286486953496933,
0.8545860052108765,
-0.22882796823978424,
-0.5928975343704224,
0.4722420871257782,
-0.10191818326711655,
0.6148197650909424,
-0.6538544297218323,
-0.2237512320280075,
-0.018820323050022125,
0.01396966353058815,
0.06751454621553421,
-0.8007699847221375,
-0.2523425817489624,
-0.05324580892920494,
-0.357871413230896,
-0.5026379823684692,
0.635334312915802,
-0.6778690814971924,
-0.4331164062023163,
0.057858843356370926,
0.8106949329376221,
-0.2771773338317871,
0.13044516742229462,
-0.5141533613204956,
0.5648237466812134,
-0.026680540293455124,
-0.13452975451946259,
0.23461410403251648,
0.4612247943878174,
-0.1581263691186905,
0.7710139751434326,
0.6633685231208801,
-0.19128325581550598,
0.2837648093700409,
0.29325440526008606,
0.9339330196380615,
-0.7842208743095398,
-0.22103655338287354,
-0.6870966553688049,
0.8780356049537659,
-0.11158724129199982,
-0.3435157835483551,
0.6808261871337891,
0.5717152953147888,
0.5874338150024414,
-0.39920300245285034,
0.7610719203948975,
0.13975293934345245,
0.058330561965703964,
-0.7659987807273865,
0.7357327938079834,
-0.7004299163818359,
-0.3418425917625427,
-0.2220040112733841,
-1.0335055589675903,
-0.25921207666397095,
0.2380010336637497,
-0.09954334795475006,
0.13730888068675995,
0.6040231585502625,
0.6973049640655518,
-0.07776747643947601,
-0.05965524539351463,
0.6068031191825867,
0.19128714501857758,
0.4360448122024536,
0.2403363585472107,
1.3535892963409424,
-0.21829915046691895,
0.3398883640766144,
0.10981221497058868,
-0.2440645396709442,
-0.2802208960056305,
-0.7349806427955627,
-1.0774643421173096,
-0.8791819214820862,
-0.07277398556470871,
0.22124089300632477,
-0.14368237555027008,
0.6826308369636536,
0.693838357925415,
-0.4516480565071106,
-0.20035487413406372,
0.18642954528331757,
-0.2743610441684723,
0.02907409891486168,
-0.13201482594013214,
0.12457054853439331,
-0.3686242699623108,
-0.9208265542984009,
0.39091503620147705,
0.6500746011734009,
0.22508573532104492,
-0.7229692339897156,
0.07210849225521088,
-0.3432103395462036,
0.031166039407253265,
1.2158795595169067,
0.14871978759765625,
-1.039968490600586,
-0.14365077018737793,
0.03222394362092018,
-0.4432581663131714,
0.006999399047344923,
0.8370674848556519,
-0.5440380573272705,
0.7074226140975952,
0.6112297177314758,
0.780552089214325,
0.2576795220375061,
-0.2185845971107483,
0.5209802389144897,
-0.3870779275894165,
0.2831091284751892,
0.11566519737243652,
0.461414098739624,
0.6215896010398865,
0.2074510157108307,
0.16806581616401672,
0.1400403380393982,
-0.3860268294811249,
-0.7644293308258057,
0.3158474862575531,
-1.0087988376617432,
-0.2451319545507431,
0.9846577048301697,
0.19113501906394958,
-0.17443276941776276,
0.08565822243690491,
-0.5163716673851013,
-0.04568066820502281,
0.14811347424983978,
0.319486528635025,
0.9335672855377197,
0.05360443517565727,
-0.5863239765167236,
-0.7656388878822327,
0.26524290442466736,
0.153519406914711,
-0.9342496395111084,
0.14298398792743683,
1.1021580696105957,
-0.08676393330097198,
0.29371556639671326,
0.3444911241531372,
-0.1376197338104248,
0.151896134018898,
0.026281554251909256,
0.2928837537765503,
-0.004932906944304705,
-0.6733071208000183,
-0.2770681083202362,
0.4243423044681549,
0.06099680811166763,
0.054389677941799164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12431v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12431v1 | Understanding Fine-grained Distortions in Reports of Scientific Findings | 2024-02-19T19:00:01 | 2024-02-19T19:00:01 | Amelie Wührl, Dustin Wright, Roman Klinger, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL | Distorted science communication harms individuals and society as it can lead
to unhealthy behavior change and decrease trust in scientific institutions.
Given the rapidly increasing volume of science communication in recent years, a
fine-grained understanding of how findings from scientific publications are
reported to the general public, and methods to detect distortions from the
original work automatically, are crucial. Prior work focused on individual
aspects of distortions or worked with unpaired data. In this work, we make
three foundational contributions towards addressing this problem: (1)
annotating 1,600 instances of scientific findings from academic papers paired
with corresponding findings as reported in news articles and tweets wrt. four
characteristics: causality, certainty, generality and sensationalism; (2)
establishing baselines for automatically detecting these characteristics; and
(3) analyzing the prevalence of changes in these characteristics in both
human-annotated and large-scale unlabeled data. Our results show that
scientific findings frequently undergo subtle distortions when reported. Tweets
distort findings more often than science news reports. Detecting fine-grained
distortions automatically poses a challenging task. In our experiments,
fine-tuned task-specific models consistently outperform few-shot LLM prompting. | [
-0.2727402150630951,
-0.7346909046173096,
0.7004113793373108,
0.43658584356307983,
-0.3036693036556244,
-0.13028685748577118,
-0.023930491879582405,
-0.9665737748146057,
0.5375522971153259,
0.47323986887931824,
-0.061627183109521866,
-0.2523600161075592,
-0.9639665484428406,
0.2853645980358124,
-0.6373820900917053,
1.139967918395996,
-0.09254278987646103,
0.3192708492279053,
-0.1826961487531662,
0.13246996700763702,
-0.14446844160556793,
-0.013722368516027927,
-0.2643924057483673,
-0.45871320366859436,
0.44508787989616394,
0.30643773078918457,
0.6058579087257385,
0.5887110233306885,
0.552945613861084,
0.19268155097961426,
-0.21678432822227478,
0.33484840393066406,
-0.6500665545463562,
-0.12026192247867584,
-0.3111172914505005,
-0.6229691505432129,
-0.20663084089756012,
0.19669923186302185,
0.565092921257019,
0.8785340189933777,
0.35073909163475037,
0.4897266626358032,
0.5303640961647034,
0.5525550842285156,
-0.3327406942844391,
0.4034404158592224,
-0.49984464049339294,
-0.042124416679143906,
-0.49746716022491455,
-0.5906585454940796,
-0.3421439230442047,
-0.1501448005437851,
-0.045578181743621826,
-0.6816229820251465,
0.5969443321228027,
0.0529024600982666,
0.7729061841964722,
0.33848321437835693,
-0.4230777621269226,
-0.4320770502090454,
-0.9064939618110657,
0.5843856930732727,
-0.43977785110473633,
0.06593714654445648,
0.5249279141426086,
-0.13873101770877838,
-0.4119156301021576,
-0.6563382744789124,
-0.24888822436332703,
-0.20113857090473175,
-0.263288676738739,
-0.03486446663737297,
-0.2304544299840927,
-0.0758727639913559,
0.2857878804206848,
0.13840873539447784,
-0.21102428436279297,
-0.009137065149843693,
-0.5632860660552979,
-0.43304383754730225,
0.6724103689193726,
0.01902790181338787,
0.024616044014692307,
-0.34188446402549744,
0.028868742287158966,
-0.09921704977750778,
-0.49287495017051697,
-0.0786750465631485,
0.24944542348384857,
0.340844064950943,
0.006119917146861553,
0.7525249123573303,
-0.3535960018634796,
0.4210505783557892,
0.4556114375591278,
-0.019507996737957,
0.2325647622346878,
-0.47659724950790405,
-0.21360884606838226,
0.3670797646045685,
0.688338577747345,
0.6696518063545227,
0.03967362269759178,
-0.28119954466819763,
0.0938030481338501,
0.2546508312225342,
0.1945246011018753,
-0.6369682550430298,
-0.277438759803772,
-0.15769775211811066,
-0.33325907588005066,
-0.5006751418113708,
0.12197893112897873,
-0.6866179704666138,
-0.8775761127471924,
-0.44176945090293884,
0.4757940173149109,
-0.15995238721370697,
0.1381777822971344,
0.20895446836948395,
-0.12506414949893951,
-0.461338609457016,
0.606012761592865,
-0.6686090230941772,
0.10762719810009003,
0.4769652187824249,
0.8049578666687012,
-0.022856274619698524,
-0.16850389540195465,
-0.2911626994609833,
0.22647592425346375,
-0.2902258336544037,
1.049696683883667,
-0.41332679986953735,
-0.38264521956443787,
-0.4038105607032776,
0.08134308457374573,
0.3350149393081665,
-0.3598891496658325,
0.6704379320144653,
-0.1925901174545288,
0.03728213906288147,
-0.48191291093826294,
-0.32793885469436646,
0.019628075882792473,
-0.020796598866581917,
-0.4702436625957489,
0.5938661694526672,
0.0169582087546587,
-1.0950769186019897,
0.48578399419784546,
-0.526081919670105,
-0.39451324939727783,
-0.2981339395046234,
0.018689369782805443,
-0.31234294176101685,
0.4976074695587158,
0.17681419849395752,
0.2880784273147583,
-0.018001167103648186,
0.36088111996650696,
-0.18933342397212982,
-0.15455734729766846,
0.3285420536994934,
-0.6506228446960449,
0.3287935256958008,
0.14992372691631317,
-0.21719782054424286,
0.111396424472332,
-0.6639189124107361,
-0.25588101148605347,
-0.048021648079156876,
-0.2095309942960739,
-0.609049916267395,
0.11840764433145523,
0.1983540952205658,
-0.09606974571943283,
-0.022143878042697906,
-0.683862030506134,
0.3721681237220764,
-0.32927513122558594,
0.42418649792671204,
0.5565707683563232,
0.25018876791000366,
0.3695155084133148,
-0.4405541718006134,
-0.2461049109697342,
0.3375050127506256,
0.3831048607826233,
-0.0762002244591713,
-0.4036175012588501,
-0.36732321977615356,
0.15668700635433197,
0.24858355522155762,
0.11297273635864258,
-0.23598185181617737,
0.006859237793833017,
-0.2668911814689636,
-0.5290459394454956,
-0.6928116083145142,
-0.021831678226590157,
0.22280597686767578,
0.6631215810775757,
0.7509421110153198,
-0.40560808777809143,
-0.5182446837425232,
-0.9705796837806702,
-0.9489198923110962,
-0.009842442348599434,
-0.30792468786239624,
0.07815602421760559,
0.5925368070602417,
-0.25629866123199463,
0.8291866183280945,
-0.45234036445617676,
-0.33520910143852234,
0.47372356057167053,
0.9079089164733887,
-0.2553761303424835,
0.5029083490371704,
0.1464526206254959,
-0.7367802858352661,
-0.33816230297088623,
-0.2624034881591797,
-0.534052312374115,
-0.3740198612213135,
-0.2641506493091583,
0.24540778994560242,
0.05090610682964325,
0.44638791680336,
-0.3191532492637634,
0.608649492263794,
0.31288614869117737,
-0.6770371198654175,
0.7515392899513245,
-0.0032734121195971966,
0.48789259791374207,
-0.5711917877197266,
-0.003857487114146352,
0.35316312313079834,
-0.22094739973545074,
-0.5454382300376892,
-0.5067607760429382,
-0.1052861213684082,
0.5863282084465027,
-0.1988869309425354,
0.28676095604896545,
-0.4161573350429535,
-0.002820159075781703,
-0.26405373215675354,
-0.051771700382232666,
0.1366795301437378,
-0.2836689352989197,
-0.2643890678882599,
0.41396448016166687,
0.15485259890556335,
-0.42251527309417725,
0.133890300989151,
0.26867154240608215,
-0.4232233762741089,
0.5140074491500854,
-0.6230894923210144,
-0.17679886519908905,
-0.5160868167877197,
0.44790932536125183,
-0.7465509176254272,
-0.6296815276145935,
0.30126529932022095,
-0.5318872332572937,
0.20259740948677063,
-0.008960648439824581,
-0.5761916637420654,
-0.27945375442504883,
-0.23492386937141418,
0.2460785210132599,
0.06054598465561867,
-0.3062078654766083,
0.10098326951265335,
0.3424714505672455,
0.06743771582841873,
-0.20531953871250153,
-0.982315182685852,
0.21540610492229462,
-0.07376783341169357,
-0.5257453918457031,
0.5343058109283447,
0.05768397077918053,
-0.5148269534111023,
0.13109281659126282,
-0.6295337677001953,
-0.09166543185710907,
-0.02693386748433113,
0.4966338574886322,
-0.09634572267532349,
-0.025098321959376335,
0.07760879397392273,
-0.03999033197760582,
0.08910191059112549,
0.30247417092323303,
0.11958102136850357,
0.34173160791397095,
-0.20846354961395264,
-0.23581799864768982,
-0.5836212038993835,
0.17313995957374573,
0.6504955887794495,
0.19135244190692902,
0.561309278011322,
0.5370160341262817,
-0.20487861335277557,
0.1695699840784073,
-0.47884300351142883,
-0.5501943230628967,
-0.37870824337005615,
0.38235220313072205,
0.3018231987953186,
-0.6633523106575012,
0.4408898651599884,
-0.18202324211597443,
-0.13985353708267212,
0.39759328961372375,
0.21051229536533356,
-0.04778771474957466,
1.0544770956039429,
0.6570395827293396,
0.10015802830457687,
0.3256255090236664,
0.03928494453430176,
0.1118401363492012,
-0.6744498610496521,
-0.45264866948127747,
-0.5224263072013855,
-0.19923889636993408,
-0.442943811416626,
-0.4710700213909149,
0.5598192811012268,
0.16749076545238495,
-0.2040313184261322,
-0.15408554673194885,
-0.8267919421195984,
0.6633159518241882,
0.40964028239250183,
0.2934836745262146,
0.6590451002120972,
0.05560366436839104,
0.37952324748039246,
-0.031091153621673584,
-0.33602669835090637,
-0.7471874356269836,
0.9563078880310059,
0.47786587476730347,
1.0442157983779907,
-0.41900208592414856,
0.6133220791816711,
0.47701123356819153,
0.4987703561782837,
-0.7738490104675293,
0.022500863298773766,
0.1350400596857071,
-0.4612874984741211,
-0.2680942416191101,
-0.35310661792755127,
-0.897193968296051,
0.04068589210510254,
-0.3438051640987396,
-0.8365210890769958,
0.30251646041870117,
0.35952043533325195,
-0.24236170947551727,
0.12938357889652252,
-0.6680911779403687,
0.41401535272598267,
-0.17655561864376068,
-0.3032948076725006,
-0.2690069377422333,
-0.6811110377311707,
0.5418065786361694,
-0.272611141204834,
0.37088748812675476,
-0.16488252580165863,
0.33903902769088745,
0.9178653955459595,
0.17973075807094574,
1.1698004007339478,
-0.11062192916870117,
-0.020194411277770996,
0.0008282661437988281,
0.22709614038467407,
0.5863922238349915,
0.3963896632194519,
0.17478342354297638,
0.22315961122512817,
0.34174755215644836,
-0.3311786651611328,
-0.32666686177253723,
0.6127903461456299,
-0.724120557308197,
-0.6340553164482117,
-0.5224432349205017,
-0.8153562545776367,
-0.24387703835964203,
0.20656868815422058,
0.47870975732803345,
0.3289414346218109,
-0.29233404994010925,
-0.005992505699396133,
0.56131511926651,
0.1417292058467865,
0.0966816246509552,
0.5811277627944946,
-0.0018740115920081735,
0.17756162583827972,
0.6179360151290894,
0.3040015399456024,
0.15794532001018524,
-0.04375389218330383,
0.2955806255340576,
0.11076588928699493,
-0.6474167108535767,
0.22841733694076538,
0.25558215379714966,
-0.4193060100078583,
-0.3980588912963867,
-0.3655755817890167,
0.025871051475405693,
-0.5182733535766602,
-0.03945840895175934,
-0.5463890433311462,
-0.34005436301231384,
-0.7084161639213562,
0.06880056113004684,
0.129706010222435,
0.9746198654174805,
-0.42436131834983826,
0.20663736760616302,
-0.6830604076385498,
0.48551252484321594,
-0.06333652883768082,
0.355477899312973,
-0.08713052421808243,
-0.43074831366539,
-0.2878586947917938,
0.6907326579093933,
-0.5192437171936035,
-0.8238013982772827,
0.4068528115749359,
0.019796887412667274,
0.25031778216362,
0.6379162669181824,
0.23473428189754486,
0.7435490489006042,
-0.420880526304245,
0.7002159357070923,
0.2313476800918579,
-0.8618103861808777,
0.5939998626708984,
-0.3051088750362396,
0.03000571019947529,
0.45248332619667053,
0.4832438826560974,
-0.619242787361145,
-0.5777562260627747,
-0.7490517497062683,
-0.6201322674751282,
0.5697680115699768,
0.026465050876140594,
0.011689755134284496,
-0.06414070725440979,
0.21590018272399902,
0.3097158372402191,
-0.07143077999353409,
-0.5073453783988953,
-0.07933627814054489,
-0.43441835045814514,
0.0903041884303093,
-0.16553683578968048,
-0.26820945739746094,
-0.738884449005127,
-0.4003998637199402,
0.38706138730049133,
-0.13530202209949493,
0.24645006656646729,
0.7512902617454529,
-0.10160958021879196,
-0.6627646684646606,
0.2919772267341614,
0.8175525069236755,
0.6143651604652405,
-0.19888217747211456,
0.5045385360717773,
-0.25604188442230225,
-0.6478864550590515,
-0.10261085629463196,
0.026043975725769997,
-0.2714049518108368,
0.011916965246200562,
0.37993648648262024,
0.5558412671089172,
0.20965850353240967,
-0.1976441890001297,
0.3156212568283081,
0.11231765896081924,
-0.21547837555408478,
0.03420691564679146,
0.017050117254257202,
-0.15058454871177673,
0.246073380112648,
0.5559611320495605,
0.6812847852706909,
0.3156943619251251,
-0.6152599453926086,
0.19864648580551147,
0.3585127592086792,
-0.24243728816509247,
-0.7756927013397217,
0.6337409615516663,
0.0669076144695282,
0.1041007936000824,
0.15542104840278625,
-0.08627039939165115,
-0.26006829738616943,
0.3822285830974579,
0.5935040712356567,
0.3683260679244995,
-0.19994866847991943,
0.54432213306427,
0.13623422384262085,
0.4858909249305725,
-0.6073887944221497,
-0.2893909811973572,
0.23332500457763672,
-0.6627741456031799,
-0.4760260581970215,
-0.6024779677391052,
-0.0662083551287651,
0.35856351256370544,
-0.7220802903175354,
0.034695617854595184,
-0.1914375275373459,
-0.2650729715824127,
0.6438872218132019,
-0.06831912696361542,
-0.4034532308578491,
-0.13861659169197083,
0.21161209046840668,
0.8337652087211609,
-1.3048768043518066,
0.5663918852806091,
0.5033278465270996,
-0.3507201671600342,
-0.5680218935012817,
0.20808616280555725,
0.4646841585636139,
-0.6461551785469055,
0.7190579175949097,
-0.028335027396678925,
-0.02345130406320095,
-0.10802088677883148,
-1.0553654432296753,
-0.9692343473434448,
0.7043837308883667,
0.3632783889770508,
-0.49495622515678406,
-0.003440111642703414,
0.39827945828437805,
0.6082731485366821,
-0.17173463106155396,
0.12950778007507324,
0.7453250288963318,
0.8771078586578369,
0.12107179313898087,
-1.2961615324020386,
0.14823684096336365,
0.14617203176021576,
-0.30230358242988586,
0.29562145471572876,
-0.5206019878387451,
0.67768394947052,
-0.230121910572052,
-0.14115814864635468,
-0.2533469796180725,
0.4749525785446167,
-0.09398580342531204,
0.7573121190071106,
0.17051170766353607,
0.2062310129404068,
0.8520647883415222,
-0.12851808965206146,
0.6416459679603577,
0.019552722573280334,
0.4067726135253906,
0.951283872127533,
0.13770972192287445,
0.358707457780838,
0.9094886183738708,
0.04450161010026932,
0.049425072968006134,
0.6309972405433655,
-0.40846124291419983,
0.48428967595100403,
0.21629320085048676,
-0.11736883223056793,
-0.009883809834718704,
-0.47055402398109436,
-0.35275474190711975,
0.4001745879650116,
0.66148442029953,
-0.4065442383289337,
-0.5133446455001831,
0.17451739311218262,
0.2866765260696411,
0.05313700810074806,
-0.5773999094963074,
0.3995477855205536,
0.11862698197364807,
-0.46464911103248596,
0.5519827008247375,
-0.030184926465153694,
0.8200246691703796,
-0.18205921351909637,
0.014719415456056595,
-0.06045990064740181,
0.014972847886383533,
-0.6926536560058594,
-0.8675787448883057,
0.799554705619812,
-0.029103567823767662,
-0.4140377342700958,
-0.16708360612392426,
0.7283632159233093,
-0.3550913631916046,
-0.1761295199394226,
-0.11252094805240631,
0.19875453412532806,
0.17397606372833252,
-0.3092307448387146,
-0.43241000175476074,
0.24390046298503876,
0.10044697672128677,
-0.3149014115333557,
0.38769957423210144,
0.3994780480861664,
-0.21331103146076202,
0.4776090979576111,
0.38873767852783203,
0.3536929190158844,
-0.06502851098775864,
-0.1607336848974228,
0.8259774446487427,
-0.41994166374206543,
-0.03205930441617966,
-0.6182019710540771,
0.18521179258823395,
-0.18089868128299713,
-0.3039934039115906,
0.9685173630714417,
0.4828811585903168,
0.7432389259338379,
-0.22855371236801147,
0.6441025137901306,
0.025602562353014946,
0.2896110415458679,
-0.30021193623542786,
0.6897309422492981,
-0.2491176426410675,
0.21265873312950134,
-0.14038272202014923,
-0.5318868160247803,
-0.6266588568687439,
0.40614715218544006,
-0.45329803228378296,
-0.2492021918296814,
0.7611158490180969,
0.5203901529312134,
-0.1659032106399536,
0.15786071121692657,
-0.007778409868478775,
0.8052197098731995,
0.3546279966831207,
0.07309723645448685,
0.603102445602417,
-0.22703352570533752,
0.27564510703086853,
-0.3699040114879608,
-0.24296928942203522,
-0.5105380415916443,
-0.9134289622306824,
-0.6899175047874451,
-0.5288459062576294,
-0.5216944813728333,
-0.5027973651885986,
-0.02231881022453308,
0.5474197268486023,
0.41879454255104065,
-0.7875426411628723,
0.27416113018989563,
-0.4010726511478424,
0.07082019746303558,
-0.11226571351289749,
-0.2932763695716858,
0.46577537059783936,
-0.2890925407409668,
-0.5110914707183838,
0.12812048196792603,
0.09619466960430145,
0.2471207231283188,
-0.11372887343168259,
0.31398165225982666,
0.20818200707435608,
0.23084378242492676,
0.5645511150360107,
0.45714953541755676,
-0.7311742901802063,
-0.5552147626876831,
-0.343087375164032,
-0.15572471916675568,
0.058001961559057236,
0.7408106327056885,
-0.6997703313827515,
0.34261229634284973,
0.3546595871448517,
0.08409229665994644,
0.39784321188926697,
0.10090158134698868,
0.23060713708400726,
-0.7651335597038269,
0.03692590072751045,
0.4136279225349426,
0.012105788104236126,
0.3729571998119354,
-0.6626715660095215,
0.38146471977233887,
0.351352334022522,
-0.8107227087020874,
-1.103723168373108,
-0.13109932839870453,
-1.025310754776001,
-0.5111348628997803,
1.034118890762329,
0.30613696575164795,
-0.28303954005241394,
-0.24756909906864166,
-0.24583394825458527,
0.3709990084171295,
-0.43609198927879333,
1.4265462160110474,
0.6661989688873291,
-0.5987309217453003,
0.2697255313396454,
-0.5923886299133301,
0.8017879128456116,
0.10886310786008835,
-0.6870409846305847,
0.3375241458415985,
0.584389865398407,
0.4085236191749573,
0.527546763420105,
0.2024466097354889,
-0.16109569370746613,
0.1636161059141159,
0.011153672821819782,
-0.13906382024288177,
-0.3129531443119049,
-0.2827417552471161,
-0.09605705738067627,
-0.05586777254939079,
-0.13405562937259674,
0.17261117696762085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12374v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12374v2 | Sequoia: Scalable, Robust, and Hardware-aware Speculative Decoding | 2024-02-19T18:58:32 | 2024-02-29T18:48:38 | Zhuoming Chen, Avner May, Ruslan Svirschevski, Yuhsun Huang, Max Ryabinin, Zhihao Jia, Beidi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | As the usage of large language models (LLMs) grows, performing efficient
inference with these models becomes increasingly important. While speculative
decoding has recently emerged as a promising direction for speeding up
inference, existing methods are limited in their ability to scale to larger
speculation budgets, and adapt to different hyperparameters and hardware. This
paper introduces Sequoia, a scalable, robust, and hardware-aware algorithm for
speculative decoding. To attain better scalability, Sequoia introduces a
dynamic programming algorithm to find the optimal tree structure for the
speculated tokens. To achieve robust speculative performance, Sequoia uses a
novel sampling and verification method that outperforms prior work across
different decoding temperatures. Finally, Sequoia introduces a hardware-aware
tree optimizer that maximizes speculative performance by automatically
selecting the token tree size and depth for a given hardware platform.
Evaluation shows that Sequoia improves the decoding speed of Llama2-7B,
Llama2-13B, and Vicuna-33B on an A100 by up to $4.04\times$, $3.73\times$, and
$2.27\times$. For offloading setting on L40, Sequoia achieves as low as 0.56
s/token for exact Llama2-70B inference latency, which is $9.96\times$ on our
optimized offloading system (5.6 s/token), $9.7\times$ than
DeepSpeed-Zero-Inference, $19.5\times$ than Huggingface Accelerate. | [
0.08146414160728455,
-0.8822177648544312,
0.37870046496391296,
0.6274098753929138,
-0.4665597975254059,
0.597652792930603,
0.2477683126926422,
-0.7991569638252258,
0.6887220740318298,
0.4380257725715637,
-0.5340492725372314,
-0.2916313707828522,
-0.4481338858604431,
-0.11195777356624603,
-0.5618427395820618,
0.4376614987850189,
0.04763809219002724,
-0.39410969614982605,
0.08397410809993744,
0.018406780436635017,
-0.08451344072818756,
-0.5224326848983765,
-0.5791164040565491,
0.3878537118434906,
0.11552847921848297,
0.26565083861351013,
0.6663629412651062,
0.9132063984870911,
0.2736743092536926,
0.34016939997673035,
-0.3829222619533539,
0.16695109009742737,
-0.5150186419487,
0.6159679889678955,
0.30909764766693115,
-0.5062681436538696,
-0.32517921924591064,
-0.8027908205986023,
0.6362071633338928,
0.2555728852748871,
-0.2889610826969147,
0.34573522210121155,
-0.32483041286468506,
0.223098486661911,
-0.7368797063827515,
-0.12305953353643417,
-1.0485225915908813,
0.14621128141880035,
-0.6138396263122559,
-0.7508436441421509,
-0.47729164361953735,
-0.22346027195453644,
-0.2967716157436371,
-0.9030269384384155,
0.2929772436618805,
0.5345485210418701,
0.6585448980331421,
0.5298112034797668,
-0.44057050347328186,
0.0309497881680727,
-0.4759713411331177,
0.8340277671813965,
-0.7215254306793213,
0.23538587987422943,
0.4581139087677002,
0.1521834284067154,
-0.11271242052316666,
-0.7213342189788818,
-0.3672950565814972,
0.15930385887622833,
0.261128306388855,
-0.06255729496479034,
-0.2754634916782379,
0.08866234123706818,
0.4132978022098541,
0.5047799348831177,
-0.3201413154602051,
0.36480629444122314,
0.037154167890548706,
-0.6730445623397827,
0.2742076516151428,
0.299793541431427,
0.08016315847635269,
-0.2614913284778595,
-0.0322379469871521,
0.0684226006269455,
-0.6610482931137085,
0.016207151114940643,
0.31783321499824524,
-0.14276964962482452,
0.09397459030151367,
0.3146878480911255,
-0.2960435450077057,
0.18392491340637207,
0.043262843042612076,
-0.016192486509680748,
0.23511777818202972,
-0.32853084802627563,
-0.3806690275669098,
0.3896639049053192,
0.43797293305397034,
0.17782334983348846,
-0.7186097502708435,
-0.3250402808189392,
-0.22815391421318054,
0.25718265771865845,
-0.127135768532753,
-1.0733165740966797,
-0.08257603645324707,
0.4344116449356079,
-0.5812268853187561,
-0.5428516268730164,
-0.574940025806427,
-0.7724023461341858,
-0.3820618987083435,
0.3309168219566345,
-0.026794271543622017,
-0.4090898036956787,
-0.386652410030365,
0.27461281418800354,
-0.244354709982872,
0.2302922159433365,
0.33355167508125305,
-1.3402067422866821,
0.39859679341316223,
0.8056175112724304,
0.8133090734481812,
-0.12868158519268036,
0.005964151117950678,
-0.6838523149490356,
0.3387441337108612,
-0.5133278369903564,
0.6630874276161194,
-0.49976661801338196,
-0.3838809132575989,
-0.26265576481819153,
-0.01927785575389862,
0.2974252998828888,
-0.06740555167198181,
0.8679770827293396,
-0.836003303527832,
-0.46650946140289307,
-0.492168128490448,
-0.36227938532829285,
-0.21958138048648834,
0.16787561774253845,
-0.6585005521774292,
1.225258231163025,
-0.07929658889770508,
-1.2349680662155151,
0.4416104257106781,
-0.20880527794361115,
-0.6524907350540161,
0.23276695609092712,
-0.1543334722518921,
-0.0559285543859005,
0.47011345624923706,
0.517478346824646,
0.3197864592075348,
-0.4504096806049347,
0.20024916529655457,
-0.4764389395713806,
-0.9168381094932556,
0.010575476102530956,
-0.7878439426422119,
0.7744264006614685,
0.49262920022010803,
-0.44524696469306946,
0.009233192540705204,
-0.6173014640808105,
0.1577979177236557,
0.12838110327720642,
-0.07936970144510269,
-0.2982059717178345,
0.07057712227106094,
0.0019529396668076515,
-0.567571222782135,
0.29963400959968567,
-0.6567080020904541,
0.10729275643825531,
-0.5672778487205505,
0.7590674161911011,
0.8628409504890442,
-0.08374758064746857,
0.1185833290219307,
0.1791110783815384,
0.6766973733901978,
-0.08729048818349838,
-0.024669233709573746,
-0.5104678273200989,
-0.04049421474337578,
-0.7572396993637085,
-0.28543809056282043,
0.19888237118721008,
0.38920706510543823,
-0.8314380049705505,
0.17116566002368927,
0.08123244345188141,
-0.41922447085380554,
-0.5826900601387024,
-0.2594462037086487,
0.1655137836933136,
0.35346826910972595,
0.18185023963451385,
-0.06013757362961769,
-0.8593511581420898,
-0.5764243006706238,
-0.2924535572528839,
-0.26036426424980164,
0.5776959657669067,
0.3667634427547455,
0.15337210893630981,
-0.3639417886734009,
0.33666980266571045,
-0.3860709071159363,
0.5462700724601746,
0.16821900010108948,
0.0690152645111084,
0.6069779396057129,
0.52008455991745,
0.45699644088745117,
-0.2411089390516281,
-0.2177792638540268,
0.44396764039993286,
-0.5631872415542603,
0.15376807749271393,
-0.2098923623561859,
-0.16859038174152374,
0.4508928954601288,
0.6123215556144714,
-0.6201401948928833,
0.35616153478622437,
0.7631944417953491,
-0.41704192757606506,
0.6810704469680786,
-0.39769572019577026,
0.21505489945411682,
-1.1004689931869507,
0.07731189578771591,
-0.5517190098762512,
-0.3090134561061859,
-0.0826793760061264,
0.2530456781387329,
-0.018041502684354782,
0.23803819715976715,
-0.11741399765014648,
0.08422861248254776,
-0.4770349860191345,
-0.34467920660972595,
-0.11553334444761276,
-0.567809522151947,
0.01940598525106907,
0.1889469176530838,
0.07382456958293915,
1.032688021659851,
0.7787256836891174,
-0.2191992998123169,
0.20649102330207825,
-0.2455868124961853,
-0.46154895424842834,
-0.08040312677621841,
-0.7660718560218811,
0.25052300095558167,
-0.07033293694257736,
0.29614490270614624,
-0.7290623784065247,
-0.2317167967557907,
0.09005142003297806,
-0.16191408038139343,
0.06145557761192322,
-0.08606966584920883,
-0.5021314024925232,
-0.40041813254356384,
-0.4079374670982361,
0.7430456280708313,
0.4526287019252777,
-0.6728512644767761,
0.6314322352409363,
0.4565667510032654,
0.05358441174030304,
-1.014916181564331,
-0.9009937644004822,
0.26259633898735046,
-0.2718968689441681,
-0.5307601690292358,
0.5921267867088318,
0.12157956510782242,
0.030609695240855217,
0.15144070982933044,
-0.2896703779697418,
-0.13310867547988892,
0.3077456057071686,
0.4768884778022766,
0.20563945174217224,
-0.4522537887096405,
-0.1373291313648224,
0.6570501327514648,
-0.159878671169281,
0.1110234335064888,
-0.5520282983779907,
0.43858492374420166,
-0.3703504800796509,
-0.32068976759910583,
-0.41033053398132324,
0.2619050443172455,
0.6570025682449341,
-0.07407564669847488,
0.3582378029823303,
0.5989323258399963,
-0.256178081035614,
-0.3065307140350342,
-0.6211143136024475,
-0.12746302783489227,
-0.5737674236297607,
0.4911974370479584,
-0.7518600821495056,
-1.2103564739227295,
0.4941970407962799,
-0.18813522160053253,
0.14170107245445251,
0.46605801582336426,
0.3235224783420563,
-0.012793687172234058,
0.9439342617988586,
0.4638204276561737,
-0.16493971645832062,
0.2112717181444168,
-0.3127885162830353,
0.0917927548289299,
-0.6136086583137512,
-0.25051236152648926,
-0.5902431011199951,
-0.2572367191314697,
-0.39512306451797485,
-0.8540478348731995,
-0.0884675681591034,
0.093714639544487,
-0.2290714532136917,
0.3172740042209625,
-0.6498841643333435,
0.7079493403434753,
0.4327911138534546,
-0.20450228452682495,
0.4535483717918396,
0.47536608576774597,
-0.3272976279258728,
-0.13036532700061798,
-0.687024712562561,
-0.10889313369989395,
0.7745599746704102,
0.6668106913566589,
0.9987383484840393,
0.10928701609373093,
0.6632747650146484,
0.41472065448760986,
-0.18815593421459198,
-0.647213339805603,
0.4898908734321594,
-0.056557416915893555,
-0.5350295901298523,
-0.24565814435482025,
-0.40080684423446655,
-0.651607096195221,
0.1920168697834015,
-0.09308937191963196,
-0.8574299812316895,
0.2979547083377838,
0.35590216517448425,
-0.4976622760295868,
0.4070422351360321,
-0.44426846504211426,
0.44814661145210266,
-0.40966665744781494,
-0.4211507737636566,
-0.7278112769126892,
-0.2963348925113678,
0.5505979061126709,
-0.03358345851302147,
-0.08848723024129868,
-0.17886973917484283,
-0.12390054762363434,
0.6708881258964539,
-0.5054968595504761,
0.7335451245307922,
-0.13473856449127197,
0.19266432523727417,
0.26782578229904175,
0.45312169194221497,
0.8183817863464355,
0.36706647276878357,
-0.47189056873321533,
0.08477704972028732,
0.8020684719085693,
-0.44050636887550354,
-0.2857898473739624,
0.76899254322052,
-1.0346951484680176,
-0.6050847768783569,
-0.7554891705513,
-0.413863867521286,
-0.11876850575208664,
0.29777759313583374,
0.4170527458190918,
0.4615834057331085,
-0.28230345249176025,
0.42417705059051514,
0.6481619477272034,
-0.10246115922927856,
0.5169597268104553,
0.35826000571250916,
-0.44505900144577026,
-0.2553532123565674,
1.0714787244796753,
-0.16564396023750305,
-0.24359074234962463,
0.5201103091239929,
-0.04484033212065697,
-0.42249733209609985,
-0.9728485345840454,
-0.5507055521011353,
0.041123174130916595,
-0.4752078652381897,
-0.3189472258090973,
-0.8116342425346375,
-0.2227831482887268,
-0.22661970555782318,
-0.14284801483154297,
-0.42544323205947876,
-0.6432678699493408,
-0.39788126945495605,
-0.22977663576602936,
0.5764047503471375,
0.49440258741378784,
0.046664729714393616,
0.45007506012916565,
-0.575889527797699,
0.030519617721438408,
-0.026101790368556976,
0.05805908143520355,
0.3191920816898346,
-0.6367440819740295,
-0.11278314888477325,
-0.27253299951553345,
0.11132253706455231,
-0.5900671482086182,
0.39184531569480896,
-0.14955255389213562,
0.33998027443885803,
0.6252861022949219,
0.21884393692016602,
1.0253934860229492,
-0.049766264855861664,
0.4714905023574829,
0.15579873323440552,
-1.2106397151947021,
0.20122165977954865,
-0.1932429075241089,
0.31075817346572876,
0.6320188641548157,
-0.0683465227484703,
-0.5728002786636353,
-0.11537724733352661,
-0.4307005703449249,
-0.8480004072189331,
0.9142505526542664,
-0.14478035271167755,
0.18447384238243103,
0.062113672494888306,
0.18741990625858307,
0.24243049323558807,
0.06811601668596268,
-0.2516700327396393,
0.07930917292833328,
-0.36107927560806274,
0.025525109842419624,
0.17582756280899048,
-0.6673567891120911,
0.17465908825397491,
-0.27513277530670166,
0.5828263163566589,
-0.3168030083179474,
0.20950189232826233,
0.07361508905887604,
0.06951620429754257,
-0.14033862948417664,
0.149184450507164,
0.04739631712436676,
0.14814189076423645,
-0.4369446039199829,
0.43160301446914673,
0.42726758122444153,
-0.5432608127593994,
-0.016544312238693237,
0.04214470461010933,
-0.4769396483898163,
-0.07200754433870316,
0.34882137179374695,
1.1267033815383911,
0.19052238762378693,
-0.7492532730102539,
0.13660244643688202,
-0.4201807379722595,
-0.22994285821914673,
-0.16353969275951385,
0.04452585056424141,
0.1470576971769333,
0.2733321487903595,
0.21960105001926422,
0.439883291721344,
0.4812634289264679,
-0.3705412447452545,
-0.15522879362106323,
0.4988604485988617,
-0.032366570085287094,
-0.4819783866405487,
0.676807165145874,
0.3606894910335541,
0.06832842528820038,
0.5920066237449646,
-0.2315003126859665,
-0.31957316398620605,
0.7581255435943604,
0.9313299059867859,
0.8940356373786926,
0.13209885358810425,
0.28453561663627625,
0.30613383650779724,
0.3397599756717682,
-0.12625513970851898,
0.6082940101623535,
-0.564391016960144,
-0.6260669231414795,
-0.6048668622970581,
-0.9519046545028687,
-0.32325586676597595,
-0.33039021492004395,
-0.3912866711616516,
-0.10050748288631439,
-0.8482514023780823,
-0.1937495917081833,
-0.20437727868556976,
0.12267838418483734,
-0.5274510979652405,
-0.1118195578455925,
-0.07972441613674164,
1.2483603954315186,
-0.37061551213264465,
1.1405556201934814,
0.18388032913208008,
0.406363308429718,
-1.0833189487457275,
0.03919588774442673,
-0.018056146800518036,
-1.0100458860397339,
0.2711049020290375,
0.22969049215316772,
-0.515848696231842,
0.1650094836950302,
-0.08907914161682129,
-1.2827491760253906,
1.2285488843917847,
0.5426595211029053,
-0.8433126211166382,
-0.13106711208820343,
-0.3101990520954132,
0.26933106780052185,
-0.16017551720142365,
0.5848693251609802,
0.6423113346099854,
0.2487502545118332,
0.7406023740768433,
-0.46415597200393677,
0.3154434561729431,
-0.24495714902877808,
0.09086699038743973,
0.16489467024803162,
-0.6962648034095764,
0.5843814611434937,
-0.3427453339099884,
-0.35715198516845703,
0.4464523196220398,
0.8236787915229797,
0.18911214172840118,
0.28053179383277893,
0.4409094452857971,
0.5309820771217346,
1.4342386722564697,
0.0864994004368782,
0.9954376816749573,
-0.6344844102859497,
0.029542241245508194,
0.8298606276512146,
-0.17751669883728027,
1.0858315229415894,
0.5441839098930359,
-0.21021798253059387,
0.4081021845340729,
0.8609091639518738,
0.21608032286167145,
0.4675447344779968,
-0.18789783120155334,
-0.3798013925552368,
-0.38117435574531555,
-0.40996864438056946,
-0.6592007875442505,
0.34233349561691284,
0.5792952179908752,
-0.23647116124629974,
0.2359522581100464,
-0.6463983058929443,
-0.10027217119932175,
-0.4654061496257782,
-0.23874810338020325,
0.14320482313632965,
0.007703978102654219,
-0.7230340838432312,
0.6304957866668701,
0.2954186797142029,
0.799709141254425,
-0.5704675316810608,
0.38491764664649963,
-0.1544976681470871,
0.12172844260931015,
-0.417452871799469,
-0.4747278392314911,
0.4287286698818207,
-0.14767234027385712,
-0.07632660120725632,
0.01593717187643051,
0.8395531177520752,
0.002604958601295948,
-0.6130645275115967,
0.04681813344359398,
0.02242322638630867,
0.20393960177898407,
0.13523295521736145,
-0.5000264644622803,
1.0027509927749634,
0.2295372635126114,
-0.13106578588485718,
-0.06955147534608841,
0.5234739780426025,
-0.1207808256149292,
0.5928694009780884,
0.9149145483970642,
0.1446623057126999,
0.08485794812440872,
-0.08257921785116196,
0.9966127276420593,
-0.8196955323219299,
-0.8126967549324036,
-0.702431321144104,
0.05699613690376282,
-0.1599847376346588,
-0.2876927852630615,
0.9582958817481995,
0.566477358341217,
0.1689070463180542,
0.20930172502994537,
0.5922883749008179,
-0.08484406024217606,
0.14179189503192902,
-0.5234278440475464,
0.23577554523944855,
-0.31225576996803284,
0.606110155582428,
-0.059352703392505646,
-0.7105833888053894,
-0.019274860620498657,
0.2859586179256439,
-0.14500898122787476,
-0.29651162028312683,
0.62762451171875,
0.9889351725578308,
-0.006364127621054649,
0.5312684178352356,
0.126285582780838,
0.5011911392211914,
0.1733081191778183,
0.6261559724807739,
0.9261354804039001,
-0.3016919791698456,
0.4478340446949005,
-0.058020420372486115,
-0.22803369164466858,
-0.41420283913612366,
-0.9328979253768921,
-0.6259613037109375,
-0.10970138758420944,
-0.07317377626895905,
-0.38991713523864746,
0.1326967179775238,
0.5924278497695923,
0.9477934241294861,
-0.6875141263008118,
-0.14399150013923645,
-0.35175204277038574,
0.08858098834753036,
-0.18077798187732697,
-0.15432438254356384,
0.40495237708091736,
-0.10900712758302689,
-0.3923840820789337,
0.6048652529716492,
0.6228740811347961,
-0.058016981929540634,
-0.35097914934158325,
-0.353540301322937,
0.39180436730384827,
0.27894315123558044,
0.5601853728294373,
0.5246047377586365,
-0.7969380021095276,
0.0851028636097908,
0.3276650905609131,
0.01877021975815296,
-0.30554336309432983,
0.8894180655479431,
-0.8923265933990479,
0.36318472027778625,
0.665772020816803,
1.1023672819137573,
1.1473323106765747,
-0.040201108902692795,
0.3758169114589691,
-0.2892382740974426,
0.5297351479530334,
0.48287954926490784,
0.31416910886764526,
0.03349389135837555,
-0.6569205522537231,
0.14229623973369598,
0.3404523730278015,
-0.48002898693084717,
-0.99886554479599,
0.02513587288558483,
-0.9222024083137512,
-0.38302502036094666,
0.8341029286384583,
-0.003861011005938053,
-0.6809607744216919,
0.046637628227472305,
-0.35590484738349915,
-0.22652330994606018,
-0.6398661136627197,
0.4963121712207794,
0.39382264018058777,
0.006142161320894957,
-0.32472115755081177,
-0.05209444463253021,
0.41426199674606323,
0.7625154852867126,
-0.6135461926460266,
0.15614910423755646,
0.3874117434024811,
-0.060925792902708054,
-0.1452530026435852,
0.9115267395973206,
0.10821733623743057,
0.33069130778312683,
0.7564693689346313,
-0.48824983835220337,
-0.03314019739627838,
-0.2935069501399994,
0.03751946613192558,
0.3184383809566498,
0.5102280378341675,
-0.07175315916538239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12372v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12372v2 | HunFlair2 in a cross-corpus evaluation of biomedical named entity recognition and normalization tools | 2024-02-19T18:58:18 | 2024-02-20T13:10:27 | Mario Sänger, Samuele Garda, Xing David Wang, Leon Weber-Genzel, Pia Droop, Benedikt Fuchs, Alan Akbik, Ulf Leser | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the exponential growth of the life science literature, biomedical text
mining (BTM) has become an essential technology for accelerating the extraction
of insights from publications. Identifying named entities (e.g., diseases,
drugs, or genes) in texts and their linkage to reference knowledge bases are
crucial steps in BTM pipelines to enable information aggregation from different
documents. However, tools for these two steps are rarely applied in the same
context in which they were developed. Instead, they are applied in the wild,
i.e., on application-dependent text collections different from those used for
the tools' training, varying, e.g., in focus, genre, style, and text type. This
raises the question of whether the reported performance of BTM tools can be
trusted for downstream applications. Here, we report on the results of a
carefully designed cross-corpus benchmark for named entity extraction, where
tools were applied systematically to corpora not used during their training.
Based on a survey of 28 published systems, we selected five for an in-depth
analysis on three publicly available corpora encompassing four different entity
types. Comparison between tools results in a mixed picture and shows that, in a
cross-corpus setting, the performance is significantly lower than the one
reported in an in-corpus setting. HunFlair2 showed the best performance on
average, being closely followed by PubTator. Our results indicate that users of
BTM tools should expect diminishing performances when applying them in the wild
compared to original publications and show that further research is necessary
to make BTM tools more robust. | [
-0.1939612478017807,
-0.6126306056976318,
0.20129461586475372,
0.20693166553974152,
-0.2706215977668762,
0.19353190064430237,
-0.19718727469444275,
-0.9746869802474976,
0.18592838943004608,
0.5188112258911133,
-0.10575253516435623,
-0.6025757193565369,
-0.7259026765823364,
0.48443374037742615,
-0.5403794646263123,
1.1141248941421509,
0.019156713038682938,
-0.05772579088807106,
-0.4921317398548126,
-0.34976834058761597,
-0.1932094693183899,
-0.35583770275115967,
-0.4984954595565796,
-0.3229673206806183,
0.7773364782333374,
0.19214767217636108,
0.6943018436431885,
0.5024595260620117,
0.8954954743385315,
0.1500665694475174,
-0.265981525182724,
0.0986073836684227,
-0.35285621881484985,
0.20244666934013367,
-0.4042070209980011,
-0.2974800169467926,
-0.30791375041007996,
-0.10531391948461533,
0.6183292269706726,
0.772861659526825,
0.20622333884239197,
0.15632084012031555,
0.1902080774307251,
0.6031025052070618,
-0.7460916042327881,
0.005392937455326319,
-0.5442602634429932,
0.08364603668451309,
-0.5806734561920166,
-0.1763252466917038,
-0.19963639974594116,
-0.3285984396934509,
0.4280542731285095,
-0.5597094893455505,
0.3257935643196106,
0.08775223046541214,
1.1325541734695435,
0.15291139483451843,
-0.42397016286849976,
-0.2993433177471161,
-0.6983534693717957,
0.696007490158081,
-0.6252410411834717,
0.5571337938308716,
0.21378666162490845,
0.18632960319519043,
-0.27030786871910095,
-0.9622604250907898,
-0.09943073987960815,
0.1277167946100235,
-0.29764652252197266,
0.13546550273895264,
-0.4044947028160095,
0.050089724361896515,
0.2595401704311371,
0.22617186605930328,
-0.5799888372421265,
0.2906731963157654,
-0.5233045220375061,
-0.6449013352394104,
0.44736579060554504,
-0.18422813713550568,
0.006805077660828829,
-0.27476829290390015,
-0.5898266434669495,
-0.025774966925382614,
-0.7193873524665833,
0.26058822870254517,
0.02105909213423729,
0.16474851965904236,
0.06143670901656151,
0.6310562491416931,
0.0068214149214327335,
0.44285619258880615,
-0.11126634478569031,
-0.19854696094989777,
0.3396261930465698,
-0.2797069251537323,
-0.42043793201446533,
0.3347896635532379,
0.7305507063865662,
0.1947353333234787,
0.08406160026788712,
-0.5530169606208801,
-0.15820589661598206,
-0.08565545827150345,
0.2514987289905548,
-1.0788781642913818,
-0.26370033621788025,
0.34775617718696594,
-0.4652300179004669,
-0.38819465041160583,
-0.02908654510974884,
-0.9807878732681274,
-0.42488715052604675,
0.06356127560138702,
0.382290780544281,
-0.44010981917381287,
-0.23635654151439667,
-0.38066694140434265,
-0.47576069831848145,
0.12808416783809662,
0.07937046140432358,
-0.6319194436073303,
0.3580131232738495,
0.7636431455612183,
0.7713552117347717,
-0.5511468648910522,
-0.10170266032218933,
-0.6926818490028381,
0.19969505071640015,
-0.3876502513885498,
1.0390480756759644,
-0.5577394962310791,
-0.6972606778144836,
0.027024343609809875,
0.07022533565759659,
-0.07749210298061371,
-1.0015349388122559,
0.6585971713066101,
-0.614082932472229,
0.061220090836286545,
-0.39256012439727783,
-0.8620476126670837,
-0.13766223192214966,
-0.08314020931720734,
-0.7885751724243164,
1.2117880582809448,
0.3052799105644226,
-1.1431374549865723,
0.7668784260749817,
-0.5095714926719666,
-0.49826130270957947,
0.24465864896774292,
-0.26749467849731445,
-0.5743266940116882,
-0.0520910881459713,
-0.06009596958756447,
0.44248706102371216,
-0.2412414401769638,
0.08715970814228058,
-0.6697639226913452,
-0.4966667890548706,
0.20063094794750214,
0.020318884402513504,
0.8376893401145935,
0.11876378953456879,
-0.5008493661880493,
-0.059963490813970566,
-0.6185527443885803,
0.0687868744134903,
-0.3318268954753876,
-0.3982941508293152,
-0.7190224528312683,
-0.18992306292057037,
0.4111064076423645,
0.12957164645195007,
-0.1270708292722702,
-0.7128362059593201,
-0.11394961923360825,
-0.5276813507080078,
0.1966812014579773,
0.3401242792606354,
0.19062525033950806,
0.32385995984077454,
-0.20966529846191406,
0.3936373293399811,
0.15603366494178772,
-0.12251824885606766,
0.22834524512290955,
-0.6831835508346558,
-0.3577243983745575,
-0.49584922194480896,
0.8328565359115601,
0.4952150285243988,
-0.38367196917533875,
0.4347119927406311,
-0.29816943407058716,
-0.6389670372009277,
-0.4140477180480957,
0.2716814875602722,
0.35866454243659973,
0.5764332413673401,
0.4960722029209137,
-0.19947175681591034,
-0.7720603942871094,
-1.0389760732650757,
-0.7260716557502747,
-0.09116437286138535,
-0.07618622481822968,
0.3789048194885254,
0.49442538619041443,
-0.7969620227813721,
1.0968220233917236,
-0.08633440732955933,
-0.11576563864946365,
0.08347971737384796,
0.3055803179740906,
-0.22812581062316895,
0.4032230079174042,
0.6374873518943787,
-0.7996715903282166,
-0.2577369213104248,
0.12068036198616028,
-0.7010377645492554,
-0.3032311201095581,
0.16083957254886627,
-0.36760520935058594,
0.30784502625465393,
0.4485381245613098,
-0.4330676794052124,
0.6436831951141357,
0.5233639478683472,
-0.24318699538707733,
0.4631730914115906,
-0.032632943242788315,
-0.07124107331037521,
-0.8125701546669006,
0.6027824282646179,
0.016704784706234932,
-0.29579970240592957,
-0.4608561396598816,
-0.1927473098039627,
0.17723442614078522,
0.10990950465202332,
-0.39099887013435364,
0.916411280632019,
-0.5071543455123901,
-0.20257249474525452,
-0.33459988236427307,
0.026196597144007683,
0.19205108284950256,
-0.053903840482234955,
0.17268948256969452,
0.6030151844024658,
0.4413464069366455,
-0.6553767323493958,
0.11015010625123978,
0.1888623833656311,
-0.3162083327770233,
0.48285019397735596,
-0.5923309922218323,
-0.02883203700184822,
0.14954383671283722,
0.1615482121706009,
-0.6486611366271973,
-0.18060851097106934,
0.11484405398368835,
-0.41189467906951904,
0.33728134632110596,
0.0566544272005558,
-0.5412467122077942,
-0.22198140621185303,
-0.19987620413303375,
0.12804579734802246,
0.4112921357154846,
-0.3798682689666748,
0.5054306983947754,
0.6075296401977539,
-0.027337294071912766,
-0.5159989595413208,
-0.8988404273986816,
0.03798820823431015,
-0.318387508392334,
-0.47749921679496765,
0.7126640677452087,
0.24033120274543762,
-0.30855828523635864,
0.2624465525150299,
-0.5498091578483582,
-0.3661055564880371,
0.12079659104347229,
0.5328327417373657,
0.350119948387146,
-0.1347794532775879,
0.24231916666030884,
0.5380975604057312,
0.056770578026771545,
0.2619531750679016,
-0.05985012277960777,
-0.17714178562164307,
0.14468441903591156,
0.0349179171025753,
-0.07385250926017761,
0.22551172971725464,
0.3838794231414795,
-0.16110920906066895,
0.5774584412574768,
1.0091781616210938,
-0.8086847066879272,
0.06044689565896988,
-0.5174373388290405,
-0.10489032417535782,
-0.38346928358078003,
0.15369555354118347,
-0.10235816240310669,
-0.8832114338874817,
0.44753074645996094,
-0.36918333172798157,
0.14363962411880493,
0.6156712770462036,
0.5538561344146729,
-0.2619016468524933,
0.41752952337265015,
0.6719974279403687,
0.20065034925937653,
0.20624184608459473,
-0.12018612027168274,
0.06479912996292114,
-0.7705799341201782,
-0.48972538113594055,
-0.7142146825790405,
-0.44980740547180176,
-0.7842870354652405,
-0.34607994556427,
0.3513743281364441,
0.21205414831638336,
0.18523883819580078,
0.5231783390045166,
-0.2922181487083435,
-0.06441222876310349,
0.5047322511672974,
-0.07201826572418213,
0.21490515768527985,
0.16367939114570618,
-0.39690345525741577,
0.041911277920007706,
-0.5820651650428772,
-0.5628491640090942,
1.1906273365020752,
0.2549933195114136,
0.35676896572113037,
-0.18789182603359222,
0.9388766884803772,
0.2886457145214081,
0.6582532525062561,
-0.7323658466339111,
0.16842947900295258,
-0.12508231401443481,
-1.0813103914260864,
-0.2649597227573395,
-0.44731974601745605,
-1.3791179656982422,
-0.006897263694554567,
-0.3980734050273895,
-0.6071786284446716,
0.5573924779891968,
-0.18232659995555878,
-0.5628554224967957,
0.1258271187543869,
-0.6304419636726379,
0.8963074684143066,
-0.022004857659339905,
-0.2943601906299591,
-0.061209045350551605,
-0.7044574022293091,
0.14470326900482178,
-0.43634840846061707,
0.22812139987945557,
-0.08555791527032852,
-0.2609599232673645,
1.2497104406356812,
-0.3184496760368347,
0.3667157292366028,
-0.11944008618593216,
0.12536241114139557,
0.4084930419921875,
0.031754348427057266,
0.21482762694358826,
0.24744346737861633,
-0.15416912734508514,
0.6590155363082886,
0.5600035190582275,
-0.49537497758865356,
-0.32049405574798584,
0.8671054244041443,
-0.5872798562049866,
-0.17834271490573883,
-0.48416271805763245,
-0.24447742104530334,
-0.39283573627471924,
0.5644903182983398,
0.5383845567703247,
0.33137091994285583,
-0.25178062915802,
0.4550861120223999,
0.626535177230835,
-0.0987951010465622,
0.36504343152046204,
0.34532463550567627,
-0.24094349145889282,
-0.4932635426521301,
0.5389729738235474,
0.21788351237773895,
-0.007482205517590046,
0.6401828527450562,
0.11411761492490768,
-0.34441640973091125,
-0.5868544578552246,
-0.2594441771507263,
0.09708472341299057,
-0.39625442028045654,
-0.4005867838859558,
-0.824697732925415,
-0.15724681317806244,
-0.6023876070976257,
0.1255737543106079,
-0.15566754341125488,
-0.34911221265792847,
-0.21567685902118683,
-0.15211424231529236,
0.36883947253227234,
0.36542823910713196,
-0.09442136436700821,
-0.09149250388145447,
-1.0801753997802734,
0.26692870259284973,
0.1339961737394333,
0.34648433327674866,
-0.4539456367492676,
-0.27078956365585327,
-0.5821384787559509,
-0.045086830854415894,
-0.07973659783601761,
-0.9110448956489563,
0.23740649223327637,
0.25942865014076233,
0.6958709359169006,
0.4717358350753784,
0.030221950262784958,
0.6218882203102112,
-0.2023329883813858,
0.3824288547039032,
-0.28762707114219666,
-0.5462421774864197,
0.40833398699760437,
-0.022380007430911064,
-0.05370146781206131,
0.7433115839958191,
0.5020647644996643,
-0.4286509156227112,
-0.3021765649318695,
-0.726775586605072,
-0.7710193991661072,
0.4548022150993347,
0.563204288482666,
-0.394964337348938,
0.10403329133987427,
0.47666752338409424,
0.4060516059398651,
0.18838390707969666,
-0.11660239100456238,
-0.3646475672721863,
-0.0676453709602356,
0.016756301745772362,
0.14250436425209045,
-0.1663590967655182,
-0.16459804773330688,
-0.12997573614120483,
0.5393762588500977,
0.06781184673309326,
0.37199777364730835,
0.5428755879402161,
-0.19189824163913727,
-0.16850025951862335,
0.08803167939186096,
0.13070650398731232,
0.3153868317604065,
-0.49656376242637634,
0.11809161305427551,
-0.026038339361548424,
-0.8099875450134277,
-0.2615882158279419,
0.4682462513446808,
-0.1754641830921173,
0.40414100885391235,
0.6298822164535522,
0.4800665080547333,
0.4965885579586029,
-0.831087589263916,
0.33534279465675354,
0.13803726434707642,
-0.08319107443094254,
-0.029604904353618622,
0.06658244878053665,
-0.044812124222517014,
0.15292415022850037,
0.225385844707489,
0.4287433326244354,
0.6005749106407166,
-0.3862685263156891,
0.40570366382598877,
0.32604146003723145,
-0.6363229155540466,
-0.3395291268825531,
0.559935986995697,
0.22259752452373505,
-0.10595962405204773,
0.3631456196308136,
-0.11190123856067657,
-0.1380351483821869,
0.6064658761024475,
0.19943532347679138,
0.9961957931518555,
0.05975934490561485,
-0.0014771451242268085,
0.22441060841083527,
0.14750048518180847,
0.1876201629638672,
0.10626037418842316,
-0.008949563838541508,
-0.5395527482032776,
-0.20762161910533905,
-0.6751329898834229,
-0.45597830414772034,
0.10236630588769913,
-0.8157334327697754,
0.44043394923210144,
-0.16196522116661072,
-0.5439878702163696,
0.5154039859771729,
0.2174527645111084,
-0.8359745144844055,
0.2371281236410141,
0.18789803981781006,
1.2023351192474365,
-0.5810259580612183,
0.922453761100769,
1.0666879415512085,
-0.10483387857675552,
-0.6193146109580994,
0.08991317451000214,
0.13310356438159943,
-0.3051307201385498,
0.5528419613838196,
0.2631411552429199,
0.11690808087587357,
-0.1795279085636139,
-0.0735614225268364,
-0.8040629625320435,
1.1962745189666748,
0.20429185032844543,
-0.58905428647995,
-0.24481922388076782,
0.044614873826503754,
0.7448742985725403,
-0.14264796674251556,
0.36171042919158936,
0.5554759502410889,
0.6560123562812805,
-0.0657150149345398,
-1.093389630317688,
0.07073092460632324,
-0.346809446811676,
0.05980546027421951,
0.03926889970898628,
-0.371503621339798,
0.3602745532989502,
-0.167945995926857,
-0.34434688091278076,
0.006391465198248625,
0.5959973335266113,
0.24842461943626404,
0.7885307669639587,
0.3709737956523895,
0.47967976331710815,
0.8846611976623535,
0.032774683088064194,
0.7933727502822876,
-0.30590227246284485,
0.3492336571216583,
0.7208110690116882,
-0.4080624282360077,
0.7978081703186035,
0.5374005436897278,
-0.25821828842163086,
0.7288435101509094,
0.7511691451072693,
0.06399326771497726,
0.49407604336738586,
-0.0034887902438640594,
0.007188231218606234,
-0.1653524786233902,
-0.008727499283850193,
-0.48465949296951294,
0.3831283152103424,
0.401364266872406,
-0.419295072555542,
-0.31270071864128113,
0.059867192059755325,
0.08858457952737808,
-0.19847875833511353,
-0.09325218200683594,
0.6857478618621826,
0.17181216180324554,
-0.552478551864624,
0.4788990318775177,
0.03978541120886803,
0.6110825538635254,
-0.38919156789779663,
0.09781378507614136,
-0.10698910802602768,
0.13364236056804657,
-0.49471089243888855,
-0.573580801486969,
0.6478073596954346,
0.07339534908533096,
-0.1637088656425476,
0.18216077983379364,
0.9629959464073181,
-0.16813446581363678,
-0.4752548038959503,
0.5106297731399536,
0.6169875264167786,
0.29783904552459717,
-0.15102364122867584,
-0.6197823882102966,
-0.08578900247812271,
-0.32254496216773987,
-0.26860663294792175,
0.3998958170413971,
0.6824342608451843,
-0.2926044166088104,
0.4269464313983917,
0.6628994941711426,
0.24829593300819397,
-0.05093264579772949,
-0.14231060445308685,
0.7065593004226685,
-0.7308102250099182,
-0.12936364114284515,
-0.684304416179657,
0.10915210843086243,
-0.20772887766361237,
-0.3905687928199768,
0.7733951807022095,
1.0676920413970947,
0.7521873116493225,
0.11148018389940262,
0.7102202773094177,
0.0032121858093887568,
0.8405167460441589,
-0.21735364198684692,
0.7841135263442993,
-0.4096260070800781,
0.1372065395116806,
-0.3165273368358612,
-0.8300663232803345,
-0.37903666496276855,
0.193275585770607,
-0.07450684905052185,
-0.016534294933080673,
0.98264479637146,
0.6693514585494995,
0.12253087013959885,
0.017629684880375862,
0.10356812179088593,
0.18783514201641083,
0.2727629840373993,
0.2825126349925995,
0.2516249716281891,
-0.5029840469360352,
0.6839497685432434,
-0.5151858925819397,
-0.2159327119588852,
-0.4346526265144348,
-0.7857159376144409,
-0.8702376484870911,
-0.2595912516117096,
-0.5074334144592285,
-0.5039141178131104,
0.23618219792842865,
0.7039185762405396,
0.7452494502067566,
-0.9812687039375305,
0.12631145119667053,
0.01288680825382471,
0.07987228035926819,
-0.5149767994880676,
-0.22361813485622406,
0.3398665487766266,
-0.08430007100105286,
-0.6032894849777222,
0.27780017256736755,
0.46703699231147766,
-0.06237363442778587,
-0.2053891122341156,
0.015204157680273056,
0.008779692463576794,
0.09266532212495804,
0.46833208203315735,
0.415746808052063,
-0.6100755929946899,
-0.07720986008644104,
0.35202327370643616,
-0.4666326642036438,
-0.030283501371741295,
0.7881702184677124,
-1.0941736698150635,
0.3291124701499939,
0.5655027031898499,
0.8099156618118286,
0.44667595624923706,
-0.07406141608953476,
0.1272897869348526,
-0.43135958909988403,
-0.11447382718324661,
0.4019218683242798,
0.28874021768569946,
0.29057565331459045,
-0.4917565584182739,
0.5163684487342834,
0.5999793410301208,
-0.599417507648468,
-0.94980788230896,
-0.3061942160129547,
-1.1697403192520142,
-0.06723331660032272,
1.3394901752471924,
-0.1254749298095703,
-0.29548338055610657,
-0.3343658149242401,
-0.04765996336936951,
0.4020366668701172,
-0.494202196598053,
0.7606073617935181,
0.6135989427566528,
-0.3398189842700958,
0.41824474930763245,
-0.41116467118263245,
0.7166150212287903,
0.27491655945777893,
-0.8354520797729492,
-0.17716611921787262,
0.18618659675121307,
0.39464667439460754,
0.1918053776025772,
0.4813857078552246,
-0.413432240486145,
0.3960729241371155,
-0.14853015542030334,
0.06661409139633179,
0.015216855332255363,
-0.2108638733625412,
-0.1624489426612854,
-0.02135750837624073,
-0.14278346300125122,
0.035280030220746994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12370v1 | AnaloBench: Benchmarking the Identification of Abstract and Long-context Analogies | 2024-02-19T18:56:44 | 2024-02-19T18:56:44 | Xiao Ye, Andrew Wang, Jacob Choi, Yining Lu, Shreya Sharma, Lingfeng Shen, Vijay Tiyyala, Nicholas Andrews, Daniel Khashabi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Humans regularly engage in analogical thinking, relating personal experiences
to current situations ($X$ is analogous to $Y$ because of $Z$). Analogical
thinking allows humans to solve problems in creative ways, grasp difficult
concepts, and articulate ideas more effectively. Can language models (LMs) do
the same? To answer this question, we propose ANALOBENCH, a benchmark to
determine analogical reasoning ability in LMs. Our benchmarking approach
focuses on aspects of this ability that are common among humans: (i) recalling
related experiences from a large amount of information, and (ii) applying
analogical reasoning to complex and lengthy scenarios. We test a broad
collection of proprietary models (e.g., GPT family, Claude V2) and open source
models such as LLaMA2. As in prior results, scaling up LMs results in some
performance boosts. Surprisingly, scale offers minimal gains when, (i)
analogies involve lengthy scenarios, or (ii) recalling relevant scenarios from
a large pool of information, a process analogous to finding a needle in a
haystack. We hope these observations encourage further research in this field. | [
-0.3370867073535919,
-0.5765161514282227,
0.6610744595527649,
-0.1665436178445816,
-0.1664789319038391,
0.07912315428256989,
-0.20174580812454224,
-0.6387680768966675,
0.04068930447101593,
0.22875458002090454,
-0.3207109868526459,
-0.32055169343948364,
-0.10518350452184677,
0.10094290971755981,
-0.5838062763214111,
0.6081959009170532,
-0.08289644867181778,
-0.05513450875878334,
-0.0982845202088356,
-0.465048611164093,
-0.5193300247192383,
-0.4137195348739624,
-0.7821868062019348,
-0.40950098633766174,
0.33982449769973755,
-0.0666956752538681,
0.7839314341545105,
0.9488760828971863,
0.21623288094997406,
0.34840524196624756,
-0.15832728147506714,
-0.17516759037971497,
-0.40063443779945374,
0.10917560011148453,
-0.5761138200759888,
-0.6522282361984253,
-0.24223092198371887,
-0.011441412381827831,
0.5330663323402405,
1.008204698562622,
-0.3322809934616089,
0.32493293285369873,
-0.12769301235675812,
0.5400218367576599,
-0.8910227417945862,
-0.0752943679690361,
-0.85984206199646,
-0.15188506245613098,
0.03892903029918671,
0.03547629341483116,
-0.14846311509609222,
-0.636102557182312,
-0.009348297491669655,
-0.774864912033081,
-0.04298146814107895,
0.3511359393596649,
0.7109707593917847,
0.13554121553897858,
-0.21989601850509644,
-0.4933207333087921,
-0.8327012062072754,
0.5920750498771667,
-0.9387128353118896,
0.4406525194644928,
0.4050394594669342,
0.35102418065071106,
-0.013610352762043476,
-0.845603883266449,
-0.6237562894821167,
-0.26360154151916504,
-0.29201123118400574,
-0.06289646774530411,
-0.45439302921295166,
-0.13728900253772736,
0.36918896436691284,
0.22695069015026093,
-0.7688769102096558,
0.19594985246658325,
-0.5709639191627502,
0.19338539242744446,
0.43665528297424316,
0.3881993591785431,
0.026231564581394196,
0.006178324110805988,
-0.35462209582328796,
-0.19089758396148682,
-0.6884773373603821,
0.18102742731571198,
0.32058990001678467,
0.01623530127108097,
0.09006797522306442,
0.20960943400859833,
-0.27513718605041504,
0.6611829400062561,
-0.08219175785779953,
0.19119992852210999,
0.28177863359451294,
-0.12920072674751282,
0.025735387578606606,
-0.08608528226613998,
0.5403001308441162,
0.5893905162811279,
0.37527963519096375,
-0.2778970003128052,
-0.3407147228717804,
0.22109338641166687,
0.4333401620388031,
-0.6776619553565979,
-0.2581270933151245,
0.19915270805358887,
-0.4002751410007477,
-0.032994356006383896,
-0.10187045484781265,
-0.7358692288398743,
-0.6144996881484985,
-0.4317750632762909,
0.7161815166473389,
-0.5234882235527039,
-0.24724696576595306,
0.11031055450439453,
-0.17712610960006714,
0.05843394622206688,
0.007976852357387543,
-0.8138042092323303,
0.8795115947723389,
0.8951718211174011,
0.8213740587234497,
-0.09836886823177338,
-0.37374457716941833,
-0.29076632857322693,
-0.07502585649490356,
-0.6492223739624023,
1.0815393924713135,
-0.6237333416938782,
-0.3131564259529114,
0.01925259456038475,
-0.38299083709716797,
-0.010731769725680351,
-1.2300394773483276,
0.5776070356369019,
-0.21463008224964142,
-0.17078115046024323,
-0.14475712180137634,
-0.7463518381118774,
-0.18633589148521423,
0.3656473159790039,
-0.7229596972465515,
1.1678322553634644,
0.032191477715969086,
-0.6656061410903931,
0.1484723836183548,
-0.3250378370285034,
-0.09823688119649887,
-0.049682050943374634,
-0.421947717666626,
-0.15053030848503113,
0.3395865559577942,
-0.040811195969581604,
0.12007004022598267,
-0.6864149570465088,
0.17791952192783356,
-0.446039080619812,
-0.662755012512207,
0.4805140793323517,
0.03181072697043419,
0.6438246965408325,
0.17316564917564392,
-0.24855220317840576,
0.11571530252695084,
-0.6978052854537964,
0.256671279668808,
0.1867062896490097,
0.09740637987852097,
-0.9150056838989258,
0.042397916316986084,
-0.21860823035240173,
0.18670915067195892,
-0.0512591190636158,
-0.40638086199760437,
0.1685926765203476,
-0.4738081991672516,
0.4392322301864624,
0.677131175994873,
-0.10434088110923767,
0.1090424656867981,
-0.605523407459259,
0.6073477268218994,
-0.15793226659297943,
-0.3176264762878418,
-0.4358876347541809,
0.014888332225382328,
-0.6559799909591675,
-0.29977139830589294,
0.4086516201496124,
0.40559646487236023,
-0.37913957238197327,
0.38773781061172485,
-0.3136396110057831,
-0.6341574192047119,
-0.6098840832710266,
-0.014104987494647503,
0.4110567569732666,
0.44173505902290344,
0.15723687410354614,
-0.45065295696258545,
-0.5945719480514526,
-1.1945011615753174,
-0.5968278646469116,
-0.41624972224235535,
-0.5762817859649658,
0.25809457898139954,
0.5807549357414246,
0.07637681066989899,
0.9596754312515259,
-0.553246021270752,
-0.17620371282100677,
0.10049556940793991,
0.4635935425758362,
0.30098843574523926,
-0.01995466649532318,
0.5136140584945679,
-0.540798008441925,
-0.2406771034002304,
0.02950979955494404,
-0.8136210441589355,
-0.5208631753921509,
-0.12451204657554626,
0.10792515426874161,
-0.1770913153886795,
0.860188364982605,
-0.5475615859031677,
0.33201053738594055,
0.38204628229141235,
-0.30397605895996094,
0.801231861114502,
-0.28296998143196106,
0.02003324031829834,
-0.7698746919631958,
0.681026816368103,
-0.05670139938592911,
-0.058484528213739395,
-0.45471811294555664,
0.3072931170463562,
0.24451124668121338,
-0.13754400610923767,
-0.35559457540512085,
0.9982969760894775,
-0.4554751217365265,
-0.12627571821212769,
-0.26389026641845703,
0.24874503910541534,
-0.11235246062278748,
0.4301159977912903,
0.07047630846500397,
0.8654683828353882,
0.32328736782073975,
-0.4388556480407715,
0.26899635791778564,
-0.2503628730773926,
-0.6860670447349548,
0.9205308556556702,
-0.8107433915138245,
0.11677131801843643,
-0.048833683133125305,
0.4693072736263275,
-1.0478153228759766,
0.19689781963825226,
-0.10022973269224167,
-0.10934171080589294,
-0.1778000444173813,
0.188264399766922,
-0.7409548759460449,
-0.4083315432071686,
-0.48127850890159607,
0.721867561340332,
0.6320860981941223,
-0.44048011302948,
0.8812428712844849,
0.15723173320293427,
-0.482128769159317,
-0.32848483324050903,
-0.10109258443117142,
-0.08278646320104599,
-0.5727561116218567,
0.10761772841215134,
0.2121497243642807,
-0.061304014176130295,
-0.5775777697563171,
0.17831358313560486,
-0.1338556706905365,
-0.18109571933746338,
0.04887992888689041,
0.1998443305492401,
0.019266245886683464,
-0.25409623980522156,
0.3732890784740448,
-0.15344148874282837,
-0.13504689931869507,
0.3743055760860443,
0.013425419107079506,
0.3406447172164917,
-0.23485933244228363,
-0.23129232227802277,
0.08433835208415985,
0.47842997312545776,
0.4318371117115021,
-0.22694239020347595,
0.4208449721336365,
0.08323067426681519,
-0.5797051191329956,
-0.22008652985095978,
-0.5719739198684692,
-0.3052771985530853,
-0.462706983089447,
0.478934109210968,
-0.4573785662651062,
-0.37916481494903564,
0.7822012305259705,
-0.45603007078170776,
0.1675407588481903,
-0.013561572879552841,
0.4332983195781708,
-0.1849355846643448,
0.5892800688743591,
0.28010502457618713,
-0.024364590644836426,
0.09159672260284424,
-0.0021351762115955353,
0.3174273371696472,
-0.9415218830108643,
0.17213726043701172,
-0.4311518371105194,
-0.5103784203529358,
-0.2754764258861542,
-0.41918063163757324,
0.41805124282836914,
0.14358946681022644,
-0.26749375462532043,
0.45081546902656555,
-0.12943479418754578,
0.6639878153800964,
0.4234476685523987,
-0.11965516954660416,
0.47423693537712097,
-0.4781271815299988,
-0.41500571370124817,
-0.03295837342739105,
-0.49000421166419983,
-0.5316744446754456,
1.2284159660339355,
0.23287208378314972,
0.7308557033538818,
0.04484928771853447,
0.3773968815803528,
0.08926386386156082,
0.7038163542747498,
-0.5490962862968445,
0.7735975980758667,
0.09149085730314255,
-0.9641719460487366,
-0.11074532568454742,
-0.21678584814071655,
-1.1050225496292114,
0.664885401725769,
-0.2799825966358185,
-1.2700449228286743,
0.010802030563354492,
0.38846081495285034,
-0.2594338357448578,
0.402874618768692,
-0.5858460068702698,
0.7221314311027527,
-0.154478520154953,
-0.37349918484687805,
-0.41593921184539795,
-0.6502270698547363,
0.27283909916877747,
-0.5367419123649597,
0.437477171421051,
-0.26276835799217224,
-0.16018420457839966,
0.7026068568229675,
-0.015022117644548416,
0.7237625122070312,
0.3114606440067291,
0.1177951842546463,
0.24176150560379028,
0.4357213079929352,
0.33866775035858154,
-0.42808082699775696,
-0.25414708256721497,
0.20210057497024536,
0.2352854162454605,
-0.14828543365001678,
-0.9327104687690735,
0.678562343120575,
-0.3781099319458008,
-0.5551371574401855,
-0.32314634323120117,
-0.5822548866271973,
-0.2694786787033081,
0.1897040158510208,
0.06680485606193542,
0.20707911252975464,
-0.5200133919715881,
0.22967910766601562,
0.3687385618686676,
0.05742917209863663,
0.23770689964294434,
0.6347095966339111,
-0.38955339789390564,
-0.11459285020828247,
0.5927144289016724,
0.0637560486793518,
0.2031216025352478,
0.4336967468261719,
0.2922042906284332,
-0.3872917592525482,
-0.2432040125131607,
-0.45270708203315735,
0.40533363819122314,
-0.7814213037490845,
-0.23564788699150085,
-0.6185562610626221,
0.04811958596110344,
0.06735733151435852,
-0.07754147797822952,
-0.6960698366165161,
-0.4079475700855255,
0.3103642463684082,
-0.06491208076477051,
0.12434129416942596,
0.610942006111145,
-0.11248413473367691,
0.09015549719333649,
-0.1981315314769745,
0.5225019454956055,
0.34664419293403625,
0.6131203770637512,
0.4308529198169708,
-0.44585567712783813,
-0.2971738278865814,
-0.12038888037204742,
-0.6513699889183044,
-0.8842021226882935,
0.16353172063827515,
0.12431976199150085,
0.6254832744598389,
0.510485827922821,
0.22864645719528198,
0.5734275579452515,
-0.805427610874176,
0.3246651291847229,
-0.0878046452999115,
-0.9553634524345398,
0.18477870523929596,
-0.26601842045783997,
0.5197325348854065,
0.5939211845397949,
0.6612190008163452,
-0.7206705808639526,
-0.4418832063674927,
-0.48248302936553955,
-1.0289242267608643,
0.18988783657550812,
0.3651273250579834,
-0.14969171583652496,
0.1006159782409668,
0.2306063026189804,
0.3384871184825897,
0.292596697807312,
-0.6968391537666321,
-0.11706062406301498,
0.1446692943572998,
-0.16159681975841522,
-0.27445077896118164,
0.11753027141094208,
-0.1294238269329071,
-0.31018760800361633,
0.2422429621219635,
0.03213322535157204,
0.15354523062705994,
-0.24455775320529938,
0.0877339243888855,
-0.07686025649309158,
0.3965647518634796,
0.4187885522842407,
1.0080169439315796,
-0.4360528886318207,
0.4977576732635498,
0.459106981754303,
0.041447438299655914,
0.27223140001296997,
0.29527920484542847,
0.1506023406982422,
0.005642757751047611,
0.48298218846321106,
0.43766528367996216,
0.5746493935585022,
-1.3731553554534912,
0.29182443022727966,
0.09951120615005493,
-0.0538240410387516,
-0.4106307029724121,
0.04103946313261986,
0.4833885431289673,
0.24249760806560516,
0.5351301431655884,
-0.3582773208618164,
0.4265936613082886,
-0.9086258411407471,
0.04045994579792023,
0.37405267357826233,
-0.09200284630060196,
-0.5264225006103516,
0.7916746139526367,
0.09630955010652542,
-0.5399863719940186,
0.3946652114391327,
0.16943047940731049,
-0.2740997076034546,
0.6291994452476501,
0.5604938864707947,
0.8106501698493958,
-0.38528352975845337,
-0.35573193430900574,
0.5396462678909302,
0.17958712577819824,
-0.058911655098199844,
-0.09232018887996674,
0.03646456077694893,
-0.47034668922424316,
-0.07427461445331573,
-0.4468165934085846,
-0.46745580434799194,
0.5292829871177673,
-0.9042672514915466,
0.24172809720039368,
-0.35538405179977417,
-0.1406896710395813,
0.3090454041957855,
-0.31617996096611023,
-0.7721781134605408,
0.16189876198768616,
-0.03553427755832672,
0.9139712452888489,
-1.3161511421203613,
0.5733129978179932,
0.857783317565918,
0.0661625787615776,
-0.5354518890380859,
-0.015299477614462376,
0.17577248811721802,
-0.6426238417625427,
0.4372197091579437,
0.30207592248916626,
-0.31518372893333435,
-0.25342071056365967,
-0.07174394279718399,
-0.6871925592422485,
0.9000610709190369,
0.18083694577217102,
-0.551719605922699,
-0.08028803020715714,
-0.15043911337852478,
0.9840143322944641,
-0.5792104601860046,
0.5159958600997925,
0.8915237784385681,
0.2097366601228714,
-0.15613210201263428,
-1.266093134880066,
0.18129299581050873,
-0.5145390033721924,
0.10144126415252686,
0.2935415208339691,
-0.2307371348142624,
0.8656152486801147,
-0.28171220421791077,
-0.37520837783813477,
0.3762649595737457,
0.3680190443992615,
0.4946281611919403,
0.40934672951698303,
0.626528263092041,
0.5384091734886169,
0.3967722952365875,
0.37453389167785645,
0.9182344079017639,
-0.15293113887310028,
0.0677822008728981,
1.5498732328414917,
-0.5186828970909119,
1.2759047746658325,
0.5560541749000549,
-0.19598469138145447,
0.5589997172355652,
0.3785441815853119,
0.3916875720024109,
0.5402945876121521,
0.4595364034175873,
-0.04020315036177635,
-0.009198956191539764,
0.0399734266102314,
-0.40131399035453796,
0.36497825384140015,
0.4927368462085724,
-0.41359570622444153,
-0.3399057984352112,
-0.30466020107269287,
-0.013566335663199425,
0.5945740938186646,
0.0654539242386818,
0.8165913224220276,
0.11789672076702118,
-0.7118751406669617,
0.8812887072563171,
-0.17094743251800537,
0.28141719102859497,
-0.5862402319908142,
-0.23405048251152039,
-0.31895962357521057,
0.40695610642433167,
0.3113897442817688,
-0.7484180331230164,
0.17002306878566742,
-0.08238881826400757,
0.06312654167413712,
0.21262100338935852,
0.21129581332206726,
-0.2627570629119873,
-0.46161845326423645,
0.38412123918533325,
0.4998040497303009,
0.2944386303424835,
0.1157703623175621,
-0.4646959602832794,
0.23569256067276,
-0.3200826346874237,
-0.1507936418056488,
0.2636755108833313,
0.4944721460342407,
-0.32729920744895935,
1.0790263414382935,
0.1303471326828003,
0.3115861713886261,
-0.15754112601280212,
-0.4400464594364166,
0.8995110988616943,
-0.803815484046936,
-0.6316238641738892,
-0.6336504220962524,
0.24187812209129333,
-0.12334057688713074,
-0.5251277685165405,
0.4062430262565613,
0.8500804305076599,
1.1008729934692383,
-0.11720525473356247,
0.5517720580101013,
0.24972887337207794,
0.9819849729537964,
-0.359436571598053,
0.4190356731414795,
-0.5823454856872559,
0.326805055141449,
-0.3017745316028595,
-1.106458306312561,
-0.0552908219397068,
0.8436570167541504,
-0.5301802754402161,
-0.0010801473399624228,
0.9756441116333008,
0.822325587272644,
-0.4818022549152374,
-0.14133821427822113,
0.3645513355731964,
0.3372400403022766,
0.08343589305877686,
0.6975685954093933,
0.87099289894104,
-0.24487519264221191,
0.5077745914459229,
0.01577639952301979,
-0.23892779648303986,
-0.36843377351760864,
-0.9909726977348328,
-0.9214086532592773,
-0.7074851989746094,
-0.09845991432666779,
0.0669298842549324,
0.3347417116165161,
0.991717517375946,
0.6912155151367188,
-0.39462846517562866,
-0.6731787919998169,
0.1762997806072235,
-0.2332613319158554,
-0.6153974533081055,
-0.13289692997932434,
0.3700183629989624,
0.23151376843452454,
-0.5286847352981567,
-0.009213073179125786,
0.11137473583221436,
-0.14709751307964325,
-0.2093954086303711,
0.15042908489704132,
-0.08323445171117783,
0.5079343318939209,
0.3968815803527832,
0.6113268733024597,
-1.0674550533294678,
-0.2556971609592438,
-0.2868506610393524,
-0.002064984291791916,
0.09412021934986115,
1.0160695314407349,
-1.0508157014846802,
0.78416508436203,
0.06315906345844269,
0.4275773763656616,
0.4632655084133148,
0.2484741061925888,
0.6090805530548096,
-0.48837897181510925,
0.3151330053806305,
0.34982267022132874,
0.22023089230060577,
0.22523130476474762,
0.2931457757949829,
0.6638559103012085,
-0.28322964906692505,
-0.35406726598739624,
-0.9996324181556702,
0.34093767404556274,
-0.7451758980751038,
-0.7051483988761902,
0.9603743553161621,
-0.26009148359298706,
-0.051417384296655655,
0.0034941965714097023,
-0.270816445350647,
-0.2848481833934784,
-0.17989970743656158,
1.1525540351867676,
0.6852527856826782,
-0.21971395611763,
-0.18121080100536346,
-0.6240402460098267,
0.21670962870121002,
0.5465025901794434,
-0.7954682111740112,
0.3262951672077179,
0.2986201345920563,
0.2990841269493103,
0.07689712196588516,
0.5834811329841614,
0.08013549447059631,
0.3679347038269043,
0.15500660240650177,
-0.04127884656190872,
0.1529870480298996,
-0.1394844651222229,
-0.09173993021249771,
-0.000384198734536767,
0.13908283412456512,
0.012760141864418983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12368v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12368v2 | A synthetic data approach for domain generalization of NLI models | 2024-02-19T18:55:16 | 2024-06-28T10:36:27 | Mohammad Javad Hosseini, Andrey Petrov, Alex Fabrikant, Annie Louis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural Language Inference (NLI) remains an important benchmark task for
LLMs. NLI datasets are a springboard for transfer learning to other semantic
tasks, and NLI models are standard tools for identifying the faithfulness of
model-generated text. There are several large scale NLI datasets today, and
models have improved greatly by hill-climbing on these collections. Yet their
realistic performance on out-of-distribution/domain data is less
well-understood. We explore the opportunity for synthetic high-quality datasets
to adapt NLI models for zero-shot use in downstream applications across new and
unseen text domains. We demonstrate a new approach for generating NLI data in
diverse domains and lengths, so far not covered by existing training sets. The
resulting examples have meaningful premises, the hypotheses are formed in
creative ways rather than simple edits to a few premise tokens, and the labels
have high accuracy. We show that models trained on this data ($685$K synthetic
examples) have the best generalization to completely new downstream test
settings. On the TRUE benchmark, a T5-small model trained with our data
improves around $7\%$ on average compared to training on the best alternative
dataset. The improvements are more pronounced for smaller models, while still
meaningful on a T5 XXL model. We also demonstrate gains on test sets when
in-domain training data is augmented with our domain-general synthetic data. | [
-0.26040899753570557,
-0.6234541535377502,
0.6443449258804321,
0.00657301489263773,
-0.05053981393575668,
0.13092128932476044,
-0.2765827178955078,
-0.4874533414840698,
0.06901621073484421,
0.7272015810012817,
-0.7239658832550049,
-0.7538809776306152,
-0.3900772035121918,
0.23225390911102295,
-0.48619580268859863,
0.8866308331489563,
-0.013554548844695091,
-0.2392626404762268,
0.06826747953891754,
-0.2336111217737198,
-0.3686014711856842,
-0.5669527053833008,
-0.434315025806427,
-0.3662945628166199,
0.516840934753418,
0.03538285568356514,
0.5534330606460571,
0.6434481143951416,
0.2322261780500412,
0.14127792418003082,
0.16233399510383606,
0.5111532211303711,
-0.5070222020149231,
-0.019553715363144875,
-0.38572800159454346,
-0.47721102833747864,
-0.4092463552951813,
0.211312398314476,
0.6751319169998169,
1.1916530132293701,
0.1464228481054306,
0.1890949159860611,
-0.05726461485028267,
0.503322958946228,
-0.7790966033935547,
-0.11715476214885712,
-0.872482180595398,
0.12941646575927734,
-0.07378129661083221,
-0.14504212141036987,
-0.7030435800552368,
-0.2930228114128113,
0.3011263906955719,
-0.9892831444740295,
0.6663074493408203,
0.1643945723772049,
0.9349414110183716,
0.11382011324167252,
-0.5607986450195312,
-0.14965958893299103,
-1.0655049085617065,
1.2608389854431152,
-1.0290604829788208,
0.3851560354232788,
0.1278911530971527,
0.45520323514938354,
-0.2981013059616089,
-0.7562662363052368,
-0.6811990141868591,
-0.07853998988866806,
-0.042939089238643646,
0.19007302820682526,
-0.18138042092323303,
-0.1049451157450676,
0.20618677139282227,
0.3121708631515503,
-0.6429303884506226,
0.0863790512084961,
-0.17955203354358673,
0.12279891967773438,
0.9256054162979126,
0.13518571853637695,
0.20388856530189514,
0.1628345400094986,
-0.20585620403289795,
-0.1421048641204834,
-0.9614104628562927,
-0.4308905005455017,
0.31862619519233704,
0.6248483657836914,
-0.008248396217823029,
0.6261823177337646,
-0.3519544303417206,
0.9011866450309753,
-0.11011791974306107,
0.005980449263006449,
0.25368019938468933,
-0.5215928554534912,
-0.512757420539856,
-0.08911021053791046,
0.5485608577728271,
0.31088829040527344,
0.5986146330833435,
-0.5417513251304626,
-0.2369813621044159,
0.1335022896528244,
0.3347451686859131,
-0.5578500628471375,
-0.08605348318815231,
0.20980437099933624,
-0.29487326741218567,
-0.29876410961151123,
0.02746802754700184,
-0.5833396911621094,
-0.21956926584243774,
-0.8753109574317932,
0.38829684257507324,
-0.5175310373306274,
-0.17871703207492828,
0.19498763978481293,
-0.3341553509235382,
0.4129619598388672,
0.18750368058681488,
-0.8275014162063599,
0.4626626670360565,
0.6559325456619263,
0.7126790881156921,
-0.43011513352394104,
-0.1313149780035019,
-0.4401850700378418,
0.493146151304245,
-0.634609043598175,
0.8028901219367981,
-0.39973026514053345,
-0.3124982714653015,
0.11179221421480179,
-0.018778033554553986,
-0.3402841091156006,
-0.9903019070625305,
0.5535593628883362,
-0.4562358260154724,
0.08289483189582825,
0.2312147617340088,
-0.8879411220550537,
-0.03275620937347412,
0.15654370188713074,
-0.62337726354599,
0.8803776502609253,
0.19551903009414673,
-0.43400928378105164,
0.40375590324401855,
-0.6214398145675659,
-0.33839383721351624,
-0.16231422126293182,
0.12501654028892517,
-0.24658164381980896,
0.27758148312568665,
0.17120304703712463,
0.25702372193336487,
-0.2576097846031189,
0.32055988907814026,
-0.530579149723053,
-0.44773492217063904,
0.2505693733692169,
-0.452665776014328,
0.4969073235988617,
0.061803001910448074,
-0.07124128937721252,
-0.2072780877351761,
-0.9983323216438293,
0.30895179510116577,
-0.052065711468458176,
-0.0493743009865284,
-0.574985682964325,
-0.14273789525032043,
0.03797538951039314,
-0.21987706422805786,
-0.35614854097366333,
-0.6746999621391296,
0.24641364812850952,
-0.6847291588783264,
0.23888026177883148,
0.4868173897266388,
0.3727251887321472,
0.6663652062416077,
-0.3201703727245331,
0.34011152386665344,
-0.07358455657958984,
0.02681204490363598,
0.20359750092029572,
-0.43512052297592163,
-0.8234359622001648,
-0.18120445311069489,
0.6866070628166199,
0.4346316456794739,
-0.7931851744651794,
0.3332020938396454,
-0.5363895893096924,
-0.3010837733745575,
-0.4654529094696045,
0.012156210839748383,
0.004601211752742529,
0.37375345826148987,
0.4362889528274536,
0.045381203293800354,
-0.6523812413215637,
-1.0535129308700562,
-0.4806094169616699,
0.19608339667320251,
-0.541678249835968,
0.18270467221736908,
0.4721015393733978,
-0.38904422521591187,
1.375174880027771,
-0.6030262112617493,
-0.13381510972976685,
-0.5399492979049683,
0.35108786821365356,
0.47975075244903564,
0.3867025077342987,
0.6000231504440308,
-0.6624097228050232,
-0.4709922671318054,
0.04204973950982094,
-0.7773387432098389,
-0.18242357671260834,
-0.3867127299308777,
-0.4959404766559601,
0.20626193284988403,
0.08605135977268219,
-0.5490241646766663,
0.43973278999328613,
0.6046501398086548,
-0.06454449146986008,
0.4448424279689789,
-0.06766607612371445,
-0.24820032715797424,
-1.1759917736053467,
0.060969240963459015,
0.22048072516918182,
-0.193566232919693,
-1.183226227760315,
-0.06644376367330551,
-0.1246117576956749,
-0.05723663046956062,
-0.5070193409919739,
0.8862600326538086,
-0.2998826801776886,
-0.004395711235702038,
-0.28049761056900024,
0.13319149613380432,
0.2027188092470169,
0.44102761149406433,
0.16967375576496124,
0.8136414289474487,
0.33029380440711975,
-0.7919798493385315,
0.11649647355079651,
0.29351887106895447,
-0.22853681445121765,
0.22573766112327576,
-0.7615371942520142,
0.12811091542243958,
-0.058723147958517075,
0.31462499499320984,
-0.6454482078552246,
-0.2761150598526001,
0.0570145808160305,
-0.4115155041217804,
0.24410122632980347,
-0.2554972767829895,
-0.3353756070137024,
0.019228944554924965,
-0.20942972600460052,
0.2181873917579651,
0.6965163946151733,
-0.7338367700576782,
0.7595099806785583,
0.18820951879024506,
0.1724303513765335,
-0.2861905097961426,
-0.8774760365486145,
0.1564931422472,
-0.3174167275428772,
-0.4393462538719177,
0.7565029859542847,
-0.015561578795313835,
-0.25201112031936646,
0.016004005447030067,
-0.07346323132514954,
-0.459661602973938,
-0.19049468636512756,
0.04465082287788391,
0.3371467590332031,
-0.36527523398399353,
0.05619950592517853,
0.09436564147472382,
-0.002146647311747074,
-0.040758419781923294,
-0.4517489969730377,
0.134883314371109,
0.2915581464767456,
-0.11005079001188278,
-0.2884014844894409,
0.4299965500831604,
0.20647676289081573,
0.07497848570346832,
0.7553452849388123,
0.3014037013053894,
-0.4891960024833679,
-0.913966715335846,
-0.3353826403617859,
-0.1568061113357544,
-0.4375937581062317,
-0.07441405951976776,
-0.3888096809387207,
-0.5457797050476074,
0.10009723901748657,
-0.33142539858818054,
0.16234642267227173,
0.40871676802635193,
0.20485807955265045,
-0.10540767759084702,
0.8703189492225647,
0.6892240047454834,
0.08996356278657913,
0.10734330117702484,
-0.6656379699707031,
0.5341736078262329,
-0.8257960677146912,
0.227385476231575,
-0.23687288165092468,
-0.09542542695999146,
-0.6409283876419067,
-0.5108208060264587,
0.17134112119674683,
0.038261231034994125,
-0.12691758573055267,
0.4165125787258148,
-0.18210750818252563,
0.44168514013290405,
0.5367913246154785,
-0.04937320202589035,
0.3776889443397522,
0.24194365739822388,
0.07369253784418106,
-0.028624743223190308,
-0.6419438719749451,
-0.6519314646720886,
1.3538751602172852,
0.2096477448940277,
0.5377431511878967,
0.19537630677223206,
0.6969118714332581,
0.4779849648475647,
0.6850878000259399,
-0.68372642993927,
0.3820646107196808,
-0.44009140133857727,
-0.4946022033691406,
-0.19915224611759186,
-0.44977954030036926,
-0.8714668154716492,
0.17954039573669434,
-0.21187493205070496,
-0.3915046155452728,
0.3028215765953064,
0.07875913381576538,
-0.3522314429283142,
0.2980771064758301,
-0.9997549057006836,
0.5808331370353699,
0.22197183966636658,
-0.25106751918792725,
0.1940382570028305,
-0.3050576448440552,
0.5430653095245361,
-0.3366119861602783,
0.07170936465263367,
-0.3175429403781891,
0.110783651471138,
0.387735515832901,
-0.4125276803970337,
0.9744547009468079,
-0.12402497977018356,
-0.15282587707042694,
0.5274038910865784,
-0.13696126639842987,
0.45400020480155945,
-0.013657821342349052,
-0.39307451248168945,
0.23739516735076904,
-0.1511252522468567,
-0.42495325207710266,
-1.1037862300872803,
0.5512498021125793,
-0.62090665102005,
-0.4594331681728363,
-0.1654924899339676,
-0.5463563799858093,
-0.628928005695343,
-0.052409425377845764,
0.11826525628566742,
0.568454384803772,
-0.16603350639343262,
0.10665815323591232,
0.5905426144599915,
-0.24728375673294067,
0.3624785840511322,
0.3631201684474945,
0.18362949788570404,
-0.32040926814079285,
0.9423282742500305,
-0.04380730539560318,
0.5709421038627625,
0.35407179594039917,
-0.018894052132964134,
-0.5006962418556213,
-0.69692462682724,
-0.5333260297775269,
0.2963378429412842,
-0.5210898518562317,
-0.24786484241485596,
-0.526421844959259,
-0.5199680328369141,
-0.4377342164516449,
-0.0661550834774971,
-0.27634578943252563,
-0.4553978741168976,
-0.18687625229358673,
-0.0826876312494278,
0.272656112909317,
0.5871965885162354,
0.1363999843597412,
0.23050068318843842,
-0.8015737533569336,
0.462101548910141,
0.16286708414554596,
0.19874714314937592,
-0.08610314875841141,
-0.6686053276062012,
-0.007554394658654928,
0.3075807988643646,
-0.19267535209655762,
-0.5179442167282104,
0.7691646218299866,
0.6778692603111267,
0.4966543912887573,
-0.03790951892733574,
0.34354642033576965,
0.66922527551651,
-0.6773726344108582,
0.7179436087608337,
-0.14980028569698334,
-0.779694676399231,
0.4936225116252899,
-0.47468823194503784,
0.1495007872581482,
0.45958054065704346,
0.4676622450351715,
-0.40163540840148926,
-0.4808136224746704,
-0.5249179601669312,
-0.7614937424659729,
0.27061745524406433,
0.5645930767059326,
0.3523655831813812,
0.05045948922634125,
0.5929797291755676,
0.2821980118751526,
0.12555697560310364,
-0.5756687521934509,
-0.16606968641281128,
-0.02591952495276928,
-0.5546707510948181,
-0.055498044937849045,
0.168288454413414,
0.04588109999895096,
-0.2147386372089386,
0.6944283843040466,
-0.5556473731994629,
0.34101200103759766,
0.28806185722351074,
-0.10541872680187225,
0.23151616752147675,
0.2024906873703003,
0.401949018239975,
0.7377220392227173,
-0.33468687534332275,
0.16611945629119873,
0.4269409775733948,
-0.2920301854610443,
0.2548891305923462,
-0.1710115373134613,
-0.3276689648628235,
0.23556126654148102,
0.5388113260269165,
0.8126996755599976,
-0.08061064779758453,
-0.7316569089889526,
0.28706446290016174,
0.0521700456738472,
-0.4137316048145294,
-0.34086865186691284,
0.26132914423942566,
-0.10735882818698883,
0.002592263976112008,
0.3259762227535248,
0.026512103155255318,
0.25076913833618164,
-0.5909594297409058,
0.3073072135448456,
0.2687498927116394,
-0.05679609626531601,
-0.4558437764644623,
0.5071670413017273,
-0.036174677312374115,
-0.09315233677625656,
0.5365564227104187,
-0.16354836523532867,
-0.053761836141347885,
0.5007445812225342,
0.6342233419418335,
0.8394755721092224,
0.12936511635780334,
0.4006412625312805,
0.4428376257419586,
-0.05734776705503464,
0.1012645736336708,
0.004851932171732187,
0.2395673543214798,
-1.0260467529296875,
-0.7299579381942749,
-0.677038848400116,
-0.6182190179824829,
0.4008485972881317,
-0.5463659167289734,
0.21229079365730286,
-0.44419267773628235,
-0.13949693739414215,
0.1861712783575058,
-0.23119023442268372,
-0.5136029720306396,
0.5455502867698669,
0.188298761844635,
0.9265643954277039,
-0.8755257725715637,
0.9615460634231567,
0.330682635307312,
-0.14116592705249786,
-0.506207287311554,
0.2879388928413391,
-0.24783724546432495,
-0.4444446563720703,
0.6594244837760925,
0.05394571274518967,
-0.015843044966459274,
0.07989095151424408,
-0.6018393635749817,
-0.8910601139068604,
0.9805920124053955,
0.3435265123844147,
-0.3924557566642761,
-0.002979833632707596,
0.6878085136413574,
0.7517996430397034,
-0.6938415765762329,
0.04161161929368973,
0.8461757898330688,
0.21586748957633972,
0.17511790990829468,
-0.37750479578971863,
-0.05107799172401428,
-0.19741053879261017,
0.4431266188621521,
0.03524339199066162,
-0.21750250458717346,
0.476715087890625,
-0.08090737462043762,
-0.38928306102752686,
0.14772383868694305,
0.6231932640075684,
0.5923656225204468,
0.37029924988746643,
0.3866562247276306,
0.485893189907074,
0.5379673838615417,
-0.0930318683385849,
1.2346948385238647,
-0.08150218427181244,
0.2593492865562439,
1.2723674774169922,
-0.6230637431144714,
0.9744267463684082,
0.4380711615085602,
-0.06408326327800751,
0.469231516122818,
0.5524610280990601,
-0.16108442842960358,
0.5846158862113953,
0.3783767819404602,
-0.47850194573402405,
-0.1549568474292755,
-0.49765196442604065,
0.004691059701144695,
0.14104680716991425,
0.21056802570819855,
-0.2275737076997757,
-0.21004261076450348,
-0.07937997579574585,
-0.37198930978775024,
0.06034056842327118,
0.1599418818950653,
0.6556553244590759,
0.0985366627573967,
-0.4944785237312317,
0.9003580212593079,
0.05018141120672226,
0.5903128385543823,
-0.5514495372772217,
-0.23660802841186523,
-0.46904054284095764,
0.30153754353523254,
0.022358743473887444,
-0.5510499477386475,
0.672746479511261,
0.10488512367010117,
-0.28429633378982544,
-0.3931703269481659,
0.6180393695831299,
-0.43344587087631226,
-0.6482445597648621,
0.2479107677936554,
0.386583536863327,
0.0077308164909482,
-0.09645014256238937,
-0.24189242720603943,
-0.16575855016708374,
-0.029768558219075203,
-0.14706943929195404,
0.26748695969581604,
0.33536866307258606,
-0.09760084748268127,
0.5471245050430298,
0.9016594290733337,
0.2242923229932785,
0.25987082719802856,
0.4020870625972748,
0.7520355582237244,
-0.6917378902435303,
0.014585494995117188,
-0.5059407949447632,
0.5128161311149597,
-0.33677998185157776,
-0.3441449999809265,
0.628170907497406,
0.5554903149604797,
0.8947917819023132,
-0.3823601305484772,
0.9878041744232178,
0.29502153396606445,
0.8344749212265015,
-0.7196463346481323,
0.4240497052669525,
-0.45227551460266113,
0.02573201060295105,
0.15553484857082367,
-1.0477523803710938,
-0.48834189772605896,
0.21789972484111786,
-0.19708892703056335,
-0.07264462858438492,
0.6692522168159485,
0.7935335636138916,
-0.2982448637485504,
0.15385589003562927,
0.41708698868751526,
0.04273654893040657,
0.4324108362197876,
0.4980299472808838,
0.8217706680297852,
-0.8325098156929016,
0.13980311155319214,
-0.2364310324192047,
-0.014244796708226204,
0.2627718448638916,
-0.7927298545837402,
-0.8185571432113647,
-0.2287529706954956,
-0.4390976130962372,
0.03164059296250343,
0.1895952820777893,
0.7387241721153259,
0.9652941823005676,
-1.1437996625900269,
-0.1707865297794342,
-0.42238345742225647,
-0.19748829305171967,
-0.08852863311767578,
-0.2803860008716583,
0.14442723989486694,
-0.4006465971469879,
-0.9674552083015442,
0.7842991352081299,
0.0195450522005558,
0.410108745098114,
-0.01643489859998226,
0.08075464516878128,
-0.17169226706027985,
0.43449848890304565,
0.7430052757263184,
0.12146159261465073,
-0.6660804152488708,
-0.32675787806510925,
0.1612759232521057,
0.2227320522069931,
-0.08069200068712234,
0.8448276519775391,
-0.7969534993171692,
0.010845242999494076,
0.18067115545272827,
0.8713949918746948,
0.5361021161079407,
0.12917250394821167,
0.9922640323638916,
-1.0859084129333496,
0.10455837100744247,
0.15125352144241333,
0.06452181935310364,
0.3672230839729309,
-0.193033829331398,
0.8542850613594055,
0.3256602883338928,
-0.16231684386730194,
-0.8275647759437561,
0.15376830101013184,
-0.7508625388145447,
-0.23373356461524963,
1.2607841491699219,
-0.09288258105516434,
-0.38029348850250244,
-0.15520530939102173,
0.10834979265928268,
0.12664511799812317,
-0.09410043060779572,
0.5695710778236389,
0.4746380150318146,
-0.16487960517406464,
0.0662885308265686,
-0.7910400032997131,
0.4588787853717804,
0.3251781761646271,
-1.0768003463745117,
0.19057005643844604,
0.2659408450126648,
0.38706743717193604,
0.04957692325115204,
0.1485627442598343,
0.14250975847244263,
-0.28595682978630066,
-0.07753148674964905,
0.006489994470030069,
0.2904018759727478,
-0.3533800542354584,
-0.2269357293844223,
0.009661732241511345,
-0.25525274872779846,
-0.15351048111915588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12366v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12366v1 | A Critical Evaluation of AI Feedback for Aligning Large Language Models | 2024-02-19T18:53:54 | 2024-02-19T18:53:54 | Archit Sharma, Sedrick Keh, Eric Mitchell, Chelsea Finn, Kushal Arora, Thomas Kollar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Reinforcement learning with AI feedback (RLAIF) is a popular paradigm for
improving the instruction-following abilities of powerful pre-trained language
models. RLAIF first performs supervised fine-tuning (SFT) using demonstrations
from a teacher model and then further fine-tunes the model with reinforcement
learning (RL), using feedback from a critic model. While recent popular
open-source models have demonstrated substantial improvements in performance
from the RL step, in this paper we question whether the complexity of this RL
step is truly warranted for AI feedback. We show that the improvements of the
RL step are virtually entirely due to the widespread practice of using a weaker
teacher model (e.g. GPT-3.5) for SFT data collection than the critic (e.g.,
GPT-4) used for AI feedback generation. Specifically, we show that simple
supervised fine-tuning with GPT-4 as the teacher outperforms existing RLAIF
pipelines. More generally, we find that the gains from RLAIF vary substantially
across base model families, test-time evaluation protocols, and critic models.
Finally, we provide a mechanistic explanation for when SFT may outperform the
full two-step RLAIF pipeline as well as suggestions for making RLAIF maximally
useful in practice. | [
-0.32002580165863037,
-0.8359943628311157,
0.5000309348106384,
-0.06217596307396889,
0.007168719545006752,
0.027458205819129944,
-0.5644975900650024,
-0.41774821281433105,
-0.4010385572910309,
0.3304368555545807,
-0.6385681629180908,
-0.40988633036613464,
-0.7608098387718201,
0.03059335984289646,
-0.39842459559440613,
1.4784854650497437,
-0.16590428352355957,
0.166202574968338,
-0.05051284283399582,
-0.21682590246200562,
-0.571579098701477,
-0.13322950899600983,
-0.8148007988929749,
-0.6061819791793823,
0.6390491127967834,
0.5884827971458435,
0.8801629543304443,
0.828816294670105,
0.5618104934692383,
0.2872198820114136,
0.3075844645500183,
0.41189292073249817,
-0.6006945371627808,
0.11973848938941956,
-0.3069103956222534,
-0.5000693202018738,
-0.16341394186019897,
0.1946955770254135,
0.7195324301719666,
0.5088363885879517,
-0.2597687840461731,
0.17581801116466522,
0.15204384922981262,
0.9894661903381348,
-0.7355960607528687,
0.2646462321281433,
-0.06015671044588089,
0.16856032609939575,
0.15918616950511932,
-0.015236646868288517,
-0.7423529624938965,
-0.45980679988861084,
0.16093997657299042,
-0.5588335990905762,
0.08112936466932297,
0.07717613130807877,
0.7849903702735901,
0.8347101807594299,
-0.24535080790519714,
-0.2321285903453827,
-1.1234174966812134,
0.7095962166786194,
-0.5792124271392822,
0.5095445513725281,
0.32661402225494385,
0.34721845388412476,
-0.05008603632450104,
-0.6513124704360962,
-0.33543670177459717,
-0.8109428286552429,
-0.2663571238517761,
0.24033015966415405,
0.06504844129085541,
0.3872770667076111,
0.5058171153068542,
0.23944531381130219,
-0.3789622485637665,
0.28382936120033264,
-0.5246069431304932,
0.033118464052677155,
0.655425488948822,
0.1586649864912033,
0.05402585119009018,
0.13327601552009583,
-0.14165250957012177,
-0.40281155705451965,
-0.6488127708435059,
0.31657588481903076,
0.4553918242454529,
0.2458401322364807,
-0.03606225550174713,
0.2752426266670227,
-0.22694219648838043,
0.8610151410102844,
0.31344136595726013,
-0.185696080327034,
-0.06627769768238068,
-0.03058517910540104,
-0.07939961552619934,
-0.1555614024400711,
0.9258948564529419,
0.27611249685287476,
0.5428664088249207,
-0.03056483343243599,
-0.42630890011787415,
0.0779058188199997,
0.4865448474884033,
-0.832263708114624,
-0.4607056677341461,
0.11860929429531097,
-0.3690260648727417,
-0.3429826498031616,
0.44264864921569824,
-0.3932499885559082,
-0.2851482331752777,
-0.38702845573425293,
0.3753218948841095,
-0.2791648507118225,
-0.1812981814146042,
-0.24795858561992645,
0.198197141289711,
0.03120058961212635,
0.5022359490394592,
-0.8994886875152588,
0.2426050752401352,
1.0268150568008423,
0.5236545205116272,
-0.2134457230567932,
-0.7546302080154419,
-1.0397653579711914,
-0.29470449686050415,
-0.7059521675109863,
0.7741328477859497,
-0.6126865744590759,
-0.2720184028148651,
0.11041730642318726,
-0.1666775941848755,
-0.2684611976146698,
-0.7041857242584229,
0.2662962079048157,
-0.3513512909412384,
0.16936588287353516,
-0.09338875859975815,
-0.5309011936187744,
-0.2236206978559494,
0.19529098272323608,
-0.6506999731063843,
1.0782328844070435,
0.16336092352867126,
-0.7006895542144775,
0.5984521508216858,
-0.5603378415107727,
-0.46191614866256714,
-0.01667974144220352,
-0.2787521481513977,
-0.5346720814704895,
-0.07917972654104233,
0.38811296224594116,
0.33544930815696716,
-0.24412314593791962,
0.3491438627243042,
-0.30098477005958557,
-0.8205533623695374,
0.2546212673187256,
-0.6291661858558655,
0.2503145635128021,
0.19533461332321167,
-0.7381083965301514,
0.43848541378974915,
-0.580276370048523,
0.03449233993887901,
-0.3252638876438141,
-0.6277617812156677,
0.05975820869207382,
0.16203439235687256,
-0.20616008341312408,
-0.04033658653497696,
-0.1226007267832756,
-0.23116548359394073,
0.1949990838766098,
-0.32845669984817505,
0.5256142616271973,
0.9980077743530273,
-0.005635467823594809,
0.36486849188804626,
-0.4398127794265747,
0.8955057859420776,
-0.35074082016944885,
0.24014510214328766,
-0.1399635374546051,
-0.08586917072534561,
-0.8380522131919861,
-0.23935000598430634,
0.6384579539299011,
0.4737028479576111,
-0.4817308783531189,
-0.0015808306634426117,
-0.17155766487121582,
-0.4736601710319519,
-1.0121526718139648,
0.1411387175321579,
0.7007368803024292,
0.39603474736213684,
0.32242414355278015,
-0.2650326192378998,
-0.1512521356344223,
-0.9697139263153076,
-0.296417772769928,
-0.5588042736053467,
0.3324078917503357,
0.4845035970211029,
0.38483214378356934,
-0.11414468288421631,
0.656531572341919,
-0.18187549710273743,
-0.15754574537277222,
-0.33204981684684753,
0.24506576359272003,
-0.05571631342172623,
0.5023379921913147,
0.23190774023532867,
-0.3810541033744812,
-0.5178069472312927,
0.11384420841932297,
-0.5563858151435852,
0.012154973112046719,
-0.13530239462852478,
0.1765158474445343,
0.43652576208114624,
0.7049926519393921,
-0.42315542697906494,
0.3559645414352417,
0.5655556917190552,
0.06926672160625458,
0.5346555709838867,
-0.33696475625038147,
0.32709112763404846,
-0.42648565769195557,
0.007279003504663706,
-0.16397108137607574,
-0.3290727436542511,
-0.3137281537055969,
0.44184571504592896,
0.05440136790275574,
0.1402559131383896,
-0.34200340509414673,
0.290373295545578,
-0.05259920656681061,
0.019177697598934174,
-0.3675801455974579,
0.24215224385261536,
-0.43819761276245117,
0.6348186731338501,
-0.04090059548616409,
0.9711751341819763,
0.2253839522600174,
-0.6037641763687134,
0.3674096465110779,
-0.12327168881893158,
-0.38141971826553345,
0.5355234146118164,
-0.6910180449485779,
0.17631706595420837,
-0.03427169471979141,
0.5499955415725708,
-0.7593517899513245,
-0.22721683979034424,
0.42255619168281555,
-0.32469862699508667,
0.32895103096961975,
-0.2069728970527649,
-0.3205919563770294,
-0.32867854833602905,
-0.17997771501541138,
0.3659493327140808,
0.3579987585544586,
-0.7807855606079102,
0.6037130951881409,
-0.028742291033267975,
0.07946451753377914,
-0.8374492526054382,
-0.357654333114624,
-0.25800779461860657,
-0.0011871906463056803,
-0.5096754431724548,
-0.11754656583070755,
-0.10534923523664474,
-0.23764169216156006,
0.1489666849374771,
-0.048164401203393936,
0.33191609382629395,
0.16610872745513916,
0.5110215544700623,
0.05618404597043991,
-0.1483028084039688,
0.2457233965396881,
-0.1427093893289566,
-0.34494486451148987,
0.018338408321142197,
-0.2216229885816574,
0.1861318200826645,
-0.3611243963241577,
-0.6231802701950073,
-0.6364090442657471,
0.14955948293209076,
0.5200636386871338,
-0.3403892517089844,
0.45692887902259827,
0.745843768119812,
0.059728942811489105,
-0.6272670030593872,
-0.3924391567707062,
-0.4514264166355133,
-0.38360458612442017,
0.5411600470542908,
-0.1683192402124405,
-1.1789041757583618,
0.1281292736530304,
-0.04506731033325195,
0.2912875711917877,
0.4467483460903168,
0.4731588661670685,
0.05824192240834236,
1.3188953399658203,
0.6944287419319153,
-0.1202075257897377,
0.45541906356811523,
-0.3056396543979645,
0.40037134289741516,
-0.6536699533462524,
-0.21506507694721222,
-0.5315728783607483,
-0.26954084634780884,
-0.9295300841331482,
0.07468532770872116,
0.10969085991382599,
-0.07464330643415451,
-0.4840005338191986,
0.030442481860518456,
-0.4271102249622345,
0.5332951545715332,
0.8006973266601562,
0.14846426248550415,
0.2988252639770508,
-0.2759256362915039,
-0.0035051803570240736,
0.02945842035114765,
-0.8503080606460571,
-0.29013311862945557,
0.8660210371017456,
0.5546135902404785,
1.0262645483016968,
-0.03711729869246483,
0.7853404879570007,
0.3191131055355072,
0.6095888614654541,
-0.8440384864807129,
0.3211927115917206,
-0.19983001053333282,
-0.30775976181030273,
-0.372227281332016,
-0.39004039764404297,
-0.624752402305603,
0.26457077264785767,
-0.20230917632579803,
-0.27713122963905334,
-0.3171275854110718,
0.42289838194847107,
-0.6174041628837585,
0.06771811842918396,
-0.7645019888877869,
0.8676734566688538,
-0.12912017107009888,
-0.4559239447116852,
-0.5283069014549255,
-0.5520337224006653,
0.3912700414657593,
0.23429988324642181,
0.2894454300403595,
0.2878158986568451,
0.3787281811237335,
0.8221557140350342,
-0.7252857685089111,
0.7746955752372742,
-0.27946048974990845,
-0.14399303495883942,
0.32458528876304626,
0.13942007720470428,
0.6363149285316467,
0.23690828680992126,
0.41479068994522095,
-0.3190230131149292,
0.10724051296710968,
-0.15886744856834412,
-0.8915314078330994,
0.7515882253646851,
-1.1293326616287231,
-0.9284313321113586,
-0.5094863772392273,
-0.4684588611125946,
-0.21962343156337738,
-0.051769934594631195,
0.10249700397253036,
0.2837786078453064,
0.1411852240562439,
0.21056754887104034,
0.5627653002738953,
0.08294743299484253,
0.16194139420986176,
0.5321714878082275,
-0.46481072902679443,
-0.42983338236808777,
1.0568503141403198,
0.0797571912407875,
0.404420405626297,
0.24575243890285492,
0.11383873224258423,
-0.027876432985067368,
-0.3832029402256012,
-0.6790201663970947,
0.2769697606563568,
-0.6644323468208313,
-0.07086724787950516,
-0.3667958974838257,
-0.28830990195274353,
-0.2138526886701584,
-0.043070413172245026,
-0.5755659937858582,
-0.27259883284568787,
-0.19685980677604675,
-0.3790319561958313,
0.15886473655700684,
1.3311853408813477,
-0.313721626996994,
0.19082465767860413,
-0.5431178212165833,
-0.07377202063798904,
0.47924214601516724,
0.32073357701301575,
0.2473260909318924,
-0.5275351405143738,
-0.44781211018562317,
-0.08468034863471985,
-0.20484641194343567,
-0.47304072976112366,
-0.20929667353630066,
0.11610432714223862,
0.3253827393054962,
0.39829951524734497,
-0.025471745058894157,
0.7718024849891663,
-0.39908674359321594,
0.8817817568778992,
-0.23901639878749847,
-0.7115498185157776,
0.35121333599090576,
-0.17752623558044434,
0.1666521579027176,
0.6483101844787598,
0.10263301432132721,
-0.40178588032722473,
-0.5770723819732666,
-0.7227137088775635,
-0.7579286098480225,
0.8684043884277344,
-0.30691391229629517,
-0.09627199918031693,
0.2467331737279892,
0.494846373796463,
0.057646043598651886,
0.12179706990718842,
-0.7014057636260986,
-0.10294187068939209,
-0.1515589952468872,
-0.03467855602502823,
-0.10928796976804733,
-0.0010697314282879233,
-0.23214346170425415,
-0.15546883642673492,
0.8681734800338745,
-0.16608650982379913,
-0.06584443151950836,
0.06648334860801697,
-0.040691569447517395,
-0.41983097791671753,
0.2794993221759796,
0.7056596875190735,
0.6304684281349182,
-0.07632169872522354,
0.057280030101537704,
0.16413186490535736,
-0.20404355227947235,
0.03917885571718216,
0.06504607945680618,
-0.3109667897224426,
-0.4217188358306885,
0.8182454109191895,
1.0699036121368408,
0.15438897907733917,
-0.6536105275154114,
0.5368741154670715,
-0.19423480331897736,
-0.3574439287185669,
-0.19163179397583008,
0.6027419567108154,
-0.32918745279312134,
0.5014573335647583,
0.04059069976210594,
0.2066553831100464,
-0.0869680643081665,
-0.4193444550037384,
0.3293551802635193,
0.34841564297676086,
-0.7703290581703186,
-0.12051312625408173,
0.473315954208374,
0.03734685480594635,
-0.3869946002960205,
0.9686498641967773,
0.057141054421663284,
-0.6130837202072144,
0.45338964462280273,
0.42439258098602295,
0.7157987356185913,
-0.17670324444770813,
0.5272578597068787,
0.5308150053024292,
0.4155561029911041,
-0.27404239773750305,
-0.2362680733203888,
-0.36878666281700134,
-0.2754354476928711,
-0.7599241733551025,
-0.4230273365974426,
-0.6250001788139343,
0.09356383979320526,
-0.8318184018135071,
0.09765493124723434,
-0.8134678602218628,
0.04475383833050728,
-0.31485626101493835,
0.02190912887454033,
-0.4993603229522705,
0.298159122467041,
-0.29759302735328674,
0.6264774203300476,
-0.8041029572486877,
0.5961974859237671,
0.6249253749847412,
-0.5237074494361877,
-1.4424159526824951,
0.26816123723983765,
-0.1097559854388237,
-0.7758240103721619,
0.6985134482383728,
0.1554805189371109,
-0.2798154354095459,
-0.013397290371358395,
-0.6291948556900024,
-0.6194471120834351,
0.8501228094100952,
0.298742413520813,
-0.674553632736206,
0.014016233384609222,
-0.16471102833747864,
0.7872356176376343,
-0.3733552098274231,
0.4949352741241455,
0.7503469586372375,
0.607989490032196,
-0.04257667437195778,
-0.8673291802406311,
-0.0015663515077903867,
-0.1136171743273735,
0.0538514070212841,
0.2558455169200897,
-0.8498890995979309,
0.6899157762527466,
-0.5637733340263367,
-0.19674494862556458,
0.06581613421440125,
0.9322850108146667,
0.20185868442058563,
-0.08241522312164307,
0.5869758129119873,
0.7401109933853149,
0.5682055354118347,
-0.05918612703680992,
1.1876368522644043,
-0.2725867033004761,
0.42013120651245117,
1.1365293264389038,
0.04885208234190941,
0.9765685796737671,
0.26992931962013245,
-0.24339404702186584,
0.5666188597679138,
0.7227506637573242,
-0.0499405562877655,
0.5141521096229553,
0.3131231963634491,
0.06425438076257706,
-0.40553760528564453,
-0.12402868270874023,
-0.3741690516471863,
0.16040925681591034,
0.08006822317838669,
-0.17036378383636475,
-0.1501457840204239,
-0.05092896521091461,
0.08575567603111267,
0.253065824508667,
-0.2410232573747635,
0.8264573216438293,
-0.012301743030548096,
-1.424551010131836,
0.5973619818687439,
0.07098796218633652,
0.2931163012981415,
-0.24352221190929413,
-0.29466062784194946,
-0.1824077069759369,
0.5104022026062012,
-0.4044654667377472,
-0.7091673016548157,
0.03787282109260559,
-0.02162628434598446,
-0.02156519889831543,
-0.050813861191272736,
0.24809494614601135,
-0.4777815341949463,
-0.10869301110506058,
0.4117678701877594,
0.17735786736011505,
-0.17182612419128418,
0.42173826694488525,
-0.6789946556091309,
0.19220806658267975,
0.1508544385433197,
-0.19824109971523285,
0.2945937216281891,
0.08010177314281464,
0.001314676832407713,
0.6374949216842651,
0.6040176749229431,
0.11829472333192825,
-0.11863444745540619,
0.35316091775894165,
0.6169381141662598,
-0.32461199164390564,
-0.32588472962379456,
-0.7625940442085266,
0.40764209628105164,
0.46423035860061646,
-0.4787963926792145,
0.4370260536670685,
0.1266227662563324,
1.1938143968582153,
0.04795556142926216,
0.9247470498085022,
0.1364903748035431,
0.506510853767395,
-0.6430911421775818,
0.46212223172187805,
-0.4305705428123474,
0.19037874042987823,
-0.24377329647541046,
-0.834560751914978,
-0.18865492939949036,
0.8905815482139587,
-0.29993459582328796,
0.4744797646999359,
0.8381431698799133,
0.8518790006637573,
0.10888537019491196,
0.15064601600170135,
0.15073278546333313,
0.3035094141960144,
0.5110071301460266,
0.47599831223487854,
0.9547731876373291,
-0.3411644995212555,
0.5027864575386047,
-0.34588319063186646,
-0.3998681306838989,
-0.23587515950202942,
-0.6208476424217224,
-0.9231299757957458,
-0.6118779182434082,
-0.38368600606918335,
-0.6231281161308289,
0.43909358978271484,
1.1165910959243774,
0.6758628487586975,
-0.8791595697402954,
-0.19774852693080902,
-0.2413974106311798,
0.055358532816171646,
-0.5451160073280334,
-0.22693240642547607,
0.49889782071113586,
-0.5942891240119934,
-0.7563380002975464,
0.3770807683467865,
0.15648236870765686,
-0.29678046703338623,
-0.593995213508606,
-0.5475878715515137,
0.13218234479427338,
-0.09385787695646286,
0.28485140204429626,
0.39918282628059387,
-0.8280906081199646,
-0.6761298179626465,
-0.12655793130397797,
-0.06856614351272583,
-0.2467794567346573,
0.8124343752861023,
-0.7399260997772217,
0.2657804787158966,
0.3428160548210144,
0.8154183626174927,
0.3845566511154175,
0.08524269610643387,
0.6037789583206177,
-0.32861223816871643,
-0.17474719882011414,
0.0025323498994112015,
0.1266578584909439,
0.281724214553833,
-0.16358928382396698,
0.5516975522041321,
0.04070248454809189,
-0.9444475173950195,
-0.8452852964401245,
0.3186596632003784,
-0.5681344270706177,
0.036330439150333405,
1.0462121963500977,
-0.2025759369134903,
-0.1541980654001236,
0.3608029782772064,
-0.2838364839553833,
0.022850241512060165,
-0.6646709442138672,
0.9046321511268616,
0.8353656530380249,
-0.31767433881759644,
-0.3649865984916687,
-0.5392342209815979,
0.6841516494750977,
0.7022767066955566,
-0.4056239724159241,
0.1899949461221695,
0.5310934782028198,
0.22788164019584656,
0.09728716313838959,
0.5556827783584595,
0.05927548184990883,
0.5907081365585327,
-0.31719541549682617,
-0.4776087701320648,
-0.21343672275543213,
-0.7607550621032715,
-0.449055939912796,
0.1828981339931488,
0.7153183221817017,
0.167533278465271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12363v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12363v2 | Emergent Word Order Universals from Cognitively-Motivated Language Models | 2024-02-19T18:49:57 | 2024-06-07T18:21:47 | Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Ryo Ueda, Ryo Yoshida, Yohei Oseki, Ted Briscoe, Timothy Baldwin | cs.CL | cs.CL | The world's languages exhibit certain so-called typological or implicational
universals; for example, Subject-Object-Verb (SOV) languages typically use
postpositions. Explaining the source of such biases is a key goal of
linguistics. We study word-order universals through a computational simulation
with language models (LMs). Our experiments show that typologically-typical
word orders tend to have lower perplexity estimated by LMs with cognitively
plausible biases: syntactic biases, specific parsing strategies, and memory
limitations. This suggests that the interplay of cognitive biases and
predictability (perplexity) can explain many aspects of word-order universals.
It also showcases the advantage of cognitively-motivated LMs, typically
employed in cognitive modeling, in the simulation of language universals. | [
-0.3475167751312256,
-0.8800209760665894,
0.8587223887443542,
0.30596742033958435,
-0.12366776913404465,
-0.10630784928798676,
-0.15613240003585815,
-0.4527363181114197,
0.03432910516858101,
0.7256510257720947,
-0.6174550652503967,
-0.36476990580558777,
-0.5047963857650757,
-0.01619776338338852,
-0.43043413758277893,
0.8616515398025513,
0.14161649346351624,
0.011941036209464073,
-0.2500033974647522,
-0.1672171950340271,
-0.20950274169445038,
-1.0088908672332764,
-0.13192525506019592,
-0.5341140031814575,
0.5039560794830322,
0.2393820732831955,
1.1210708618164062,
0.5467936992645264,
0.3439111113548279,
0.2738015949726105,
-0.17529620230197906,
-0.32071977853775024,
-0.2950458228588104,
0.3269854784011841,
-0.42567217350006104,
-0.7361206412315369,
-0.10835376381874084,
0.28308960795402527,
0.39026975631713867,
0.8938407301902771,
-0.2388324737548828,
0.09463261812925339,
-0.10536998510360718,
0.48971986770629883,
-0.6026059985160828,
0.01626485399901867,
-0.9051695466041565,
0.0811176523566246,
-0.2235475480556488,
-0.17853528261184692,
-0.31553107500076294,
-0.19094763696193695,
0.6563685536384583,
-0.4986824691295624,
0.25473618507385254,
0.0716220811009407,
0.6756224036216736,
-0.07931575179100037,
0.007854281924664974,
-0.41690176725387573,
-0.9561637043952942,
0.7735214233398438,
-0.3824652135372162,
0.5365242958068848,
-0.0750274807214737,
0.030139796435832977,
-0.35352823138237,
-0.5855882167816162,
-0.7116816639900208,
-0.23241984844207764,
0.2354990392923355,
0.2272910326719284,
-0.04156158119440079,
0.3323071300983429,
0.33351340889930725,
0.09078755974769592,
-0.46726033091545105,
0.3190215528011322,
0.02424885332584381,
0.05607078969478607,
0.5472963452339172,
0.30943313241004944,
0.601879894733429,
-0.28530174493789673,
-0.29472023248672485,
-0.06844502687454224,
-0.8381579518318176,
0.24392543733119965,
0.12973088026046753,
0.3566530644893646,
0.1888589709997177,
0.6649233102798462,
-0.17183904349803925,
0.5698216557502747,
-0.1302647590637207,
0.12789638340473175,
-0.04317832365632057,
-0.28096017241477966,
-0.20108948647975922,
0.1954362988471985,
0.6580084562301636,
0.10264767706394196,
0.5022990703582764,
-0.12017261236906052,
-0.06965740025043488,
0.5388168692588806,
0.26090529561042786,
-0.49375632405281067,
0.0247208084911108,
0.4551272392272949,
-0.07949553430080414,
-0.44659605622291565,
0.09358308464288712,
-0.5769672989845276,
-0.22154828906059265,
-0.2194388210773468,
0.3288117051124573,
-0.4128444790840149,
-0.12572793662548065,
0.2866247892379761,
-0.028597882017493248,
0.07554983347654343,
0.3983794152736664,
-0.793615460395813,
0.13950727880001068,
0.6665170788764954,
0.315013587474823,
-0.2206915020942688,
-0.45344439148902893,
-0.061711180955171585,
0.15202870965003967,
-0.49440574645996094,
1.0276051759719849,
-0.7354680895805359,
-0.48172780871391296,
0.16367147862911224,
-0.4208921194076538,
0.031350027769804,
-0.6083576679229736,
0.5086183547973633,
-0.6992334127426147,
0.3047811985015869,
-0.3510970175266266,
-0.5293354392051697,
-0.12546640634536743,
0.043500691652297974,
-0.3056640326976776,
0.8132693767547607,
-0.31501856446266174,
-0.6763331890106201,
0.4157398045063019,
-0.4634661078453064,
-0.25754669308662415,
0.1966487020254135,
-0.534031093120575,
0.10406441241502762,
0.5174265503883362,
-0.10107500851154327,
0.36210858821868896,
-0.5202814340591431,
0.46385934948921204,
-0.2852528989315033,
-0.16340455412864685,
0.4864727258682251,
-0.4259438216686249,
0.8888247609138489,
0.2210291177034378,
-0.38126978278160095,
0.1729704737663269,
-0.5048463940620422,
0.13233910501003265,
0.4096306264400482,
-0.44473639130592346,
-0.5856500864028931,
0.36293119192123413,
-0.27687475085258484,
0.42730385065078735,
0.2070961445569992,
-0.46849578619003296,
0.29363226890563965,
-0.4436977505683899,
0.1901281774044037,
0.6814056038856506,
-0.06773655861616135,
0.5376072525978088,
-0.012564572505652905,
0.6033784747123718,
0.14226235449314117,
0.24486464262008667,
0.08839593082666397,
-0.720515787601471,
-0.5241792798042297,
-0.11953884363174438,
0.2714496850967407,
0.7979574799537659,
-0.5702515244483948,
0.15609480440616608,
-0.3730226457118988,
-0.15790671110153198,
-0.24072910845279694,
-0.05662500113248825,
0.5854902267456055,
-0.06265172362327576,
0.03834756463766098,
-0.11679157614707947,
-0.4045482873916626,
-0.7926521301269531,
-0.592585027217865,
-0.125889852643013,
-0.188690185546875,
0.23446166515350342,
0.25777190923690796,
-0.20227983593940735,
0.9548562169075012,
-0.5626422762870789,
0.2063841074705124,
-0.3569374084472656,
0.29542532563209534,
0.25643280148506165,
0.16549646854400635,
0.3236980736255646,
-0.8535237312316895,
-0.047307852655649185,
-0.396137535572052,
-0.7401824593544006,
-0.2373160868883133,
0.09111723303794861,
-0.1175924688577652,
0.20811988413333893,
0.7349013686180115,
-0.7171484231948853,
0.5645166039466858,
0.3348495364189148,
-0.2648698389530182,
0.971785843372345,
-0.4747835099697113,
-0.37081584334373474,
-1.019755482673645,
-0.30763205885887146,
-0.33429569005966187,
0.1876937448978424,
-0.8462075591087341,
0.4341614544391632,
-0.27268439531326294,
-0.04926494508981705,
-0.3436622619628906,
0.2999628186225891,
-0.6740149855613708,
-0.10358801484107971,
-0.11662548035383224,
0.25760775804519653,
-0.12018900364637375,
0.20538830757141113,
0.2030358612537384,
0.47413769364356995,
0.43942227959632874,
-0.86040860414505,
-0.03281541168689728,
-0.0031637665815651417,
-0.4179079234600067,
0.13153445720672607,
-0.5967428684234619,
-0.10220709443092346,
-0.43677034974098206,
0.09093372523784637,
-1.104311466217041,
-0.12894600629806519,
-0.26477205753326416,
-0.33701491355895996,
0.15145497024059296,
0.14317211508750916,
-0.6739181876182556,
-0.4901143014431,
-0.13109278678894043,
0.5822155475616455,
0.3711990714073181,
-0.3914753198623657,
0.3410859704017639,
0.34441643953323364,
-0.03521254286170006,
-0.34860947728157043,
-0.6226994395256042,
-0.15653105080127716,
0.08344770222902298,
-0.34992361068725586,
0.40278545022010803,
-0.4130275547504425,
-0.642900288105011,
-0.23989766836166382,
-0.07406780868768692,
0.29289132356643677,
0.14648652076721191,
0.2777143716812134,
0.4483944773674011,
-0.20443031191825867,
0.09498295187950134,
-0.031010018661618233,
0.1592259556055069,
0.19761434197425842,
-0.7425546646118164,
0.8666446805000305,
0.0076405382715165615,
-0.22015248239040375,
0.045152533799409866,
0.34205979108810425,
0.7113934755325317,
-0.10024535655975342,
0.6983301043510437,
-0.18621747195720673,
-0.2932737469673157,
-0.07901216298341751,
-0.6798613667488098,
-0.021941017359495163,
-0.48773902654647827,
0.28974294662475586,
-0.5778447985649109,
-0.8052525520324707,
0.6018878221511841,
0.01316410955041647,
0.1853586733341217,
0.34928688406944275,
0.5604366660118103,
-0.16998247802257538,
1.3216724395751953,
0.30360379815101624,
0.11840231716632843,
0.6639793515205383,
-0.09523127973079681,
0.006716972216963768,
-0.575059711933136,
-0.1266365945339203,
-0.40501168370246887,
0.06884314864873886,
-0.8780953288078308,
-0.4375894069671631,
0.21953794360160828,
0.33993542194366455,
-0.1988184154033661,
0.12732791900634766,
-0.38854530453681946,
0.7544443607330322,
0.4094480872154236,
-0.26747927069664,
0.220326766371727,
0.3399147391319275,
-0.9541590213775635,
0.04975399747490883,
-0.7280811667442322,
-0.496761679649353,
1.115933895111084,
-0.14588624238967896,
0.5816558599472046,
0.01708674430847168,
0.6679515242576599,
0.041614409536123276,
0.25063809752464294,
-0.5501583218574524,
0.6886816024780273,
-0.38802003860473633,
-0.8696284890174866,
-0.2427472472190857,
-0.05658365786075592,
-1.4057214260101318,
0.42161354422569275,
-0.4431314170360565,
-1.359921932220459,
0.12376148253679276,
-0.08072944730520248,
-0.4356883764266968,
0.054499778896570206,
-0.549170732498169,
0.6860489249229431,
-0.14178726077079773,
-0.2134193629026413,
-0.23316241800785065,
-0.5609084367752075,
0.36148378252983093,
0.1625954955816269,
0.44871681928634644,
-0.027915434911847115,
0.0990426316857338,
0.6246229410171509,
-0.5856643319129944,
0.41060495376586914,
0.1617773324251175,
-0.3534616231918335,
0.5042501091957092,
0.5049161911010742,
0.3973188102245331,
-0.14590714871883392,
-0.09576893597841263,
0.2396765500307083,
-0.14890511333942413,
-0.47217103838920593,
-0.5563708543777466,
0.6913577318191528,
-0.7986219525337219,
-1.0027323961257935,
-0.3408731520175934,
-0.7267572283744812,
-0.3118206560611725,
0.29327094554901123,
0.8351290225982666,
0.5053126811981201,
-0.36316826939582825,
-0.41715410351753235,
0.7121254801750183,
-0.23575015366077423,
0.45069175958633423,
0.6557349562644958,
-0.7756508588790894,
-0.18514257669448853,
0.8394011855125427,
0.6123552918434143,
0.46099328994750977,
0.5148314833641052,
0.33913686871528625,
-0.22243809700012207,
-0.6085062026977539,
-0.15777570009231567,
0.12574851512908936,
-0.45060795545578003,
0.44654417037963867,
-0.6332093477249146,
-0.32299765944480896,
-0.4449671804904938,
-0.277344286441803,
-0.281345009803772,
-0.5461146831512451,
-0.12614192068576813,
-0.06758423149585724,
-0.029860010370612144,
1.104585886001587,
0.16405977308750153,
0.2581692039966583,
-0.6063715219497681,
0.3263491690158844,
0.47855275869369507,
0.2391890287399292,
-0.08155243843793869,
-0.5753815174102783,
0.2655391991138458,
0.033901628106832504,
-0.2641254663467407,
-0.9443325996398926,
0.06680411845445633,
-0.275018572807312,
0.5535935163497925,
0.813663899898529,
-0.11272478848695755,
0.508527934551239,
-0.7269873023033142,
0.6816381812095642,
0.2592252194881439,
-0.8621967434883118,
0.47854524850845337,
-0.7291711568832397,
0.5945088863372803,
0.3572261929512024,
0.29454952478408813,
-0.4863431751728058,
-0.6437271237373352,
-0.9444348216056824,
-0.8732091784477234,
0.8039388656616211,
0.17819330096244812,
0.021705683320760727,
-0.13049814105033875,
0.5609700083732605,
0.08227317780256271,
0.24566930532455444,
-0.658851683139801,
-0.343908429145813,
0.011683905497193336,
-0.02928399108350277,
-0.2673224210739136,
-0.48582223057746887,
0.14024628698825836,
-0.20312871038913727,
0.3299388587474823,
0.12635064125061035,
0.35054993629455566,
0.16776353120803833,
-0.23904933035373688,
0.04226987063884735,
0.3996437191963196,
0.804520308971405,
0.5217863321304321,
-0.19140146672725677,
0.33158376812934875,
-0.003001016564667225,
-0.46649250388145447,
0.26150286197662354,
-0.03811134770512581,
-0.4541991353034973,
-0.09397944062948227,
0.19988933205604553,
0.5729871988296509,
0.25666141510009766,
-0.648851752281189,
0.24452729523181915,
0.047852855175733566,
0.04564904794096947,
-0.36273908615112305,
0.049477607011795044,
0.39895015954971313,
0.2914290428161621,
0.270258367061615,
0.06250610947608948,
0.1076975092291832,
-0.7519385814666748,
-0.07952265441417694,
0.7077843546867371,
-0.19762800633907318,
-0.6044027209281921,
0.6215340495109558,
-0.20685195922851562,
-0.48245885968208313,
0.4655010402202606,
-0.28052181005477905,
-0.770811915397644,
0.5016086101531982,
0.6978311538696289,
0.8110025525093079,
-0.5184943079948425,
0.1380549967288971,
0.02807183936238289,
0.2920447885990143,
-0.22932124137878418,
0.6155244708061218,
0.05028516799211502,
-1.2030984163284302,
-0.07628517597913742,
-0.7572785019874573,
-0.3400181829929352,
0.1647620052099228,
-0.6686787009239197,
0.08926843106746674,
-0.7863888740539551,
-0.37217769026756287,
0.2243480682373047,
-0.33560889959335327,
-0.684201180934906,
0.1595381647348404,
0.5547081828117371,
0.7435493469238281,
-0.6807212233543396,
0.8575807213783264,
0.9415217638015747,
-0.36887481808662415,
-0.7990805506706238,
0.3746758699417114,
0.09254876524209976,
-0.9787801504135132,
0.7654545307159424,
0.22496043145656586,
-0.17497915029525757,
-0.005391051061451435,
-0.6611889600753784,
-1.126853346824646,
0.723483145236969,
0.42206379771232605,
-0.3009408414363861,
-0.22933277487754822,
0.380920946598053,
0.7480929493904114,
-0.4951916038990021,
0.28761929273605347,
0.47029274702072144,
0.2252141684293747,
-0.0666552484035492,
-0.49198681116104126,
0.18075613677501678,
-0.05497138202190399,
0.4972781240940094,
0.22893105447292328,
-0.4590352177619934,
0.869912326335907,
-0.3721255362033844,
-0.3884999752044678,
-0.09629931300878525,
0.6247378587722778,
0.5009212493896484,
-0.012258635833859444,
0.4512277841567993,
0.5488506555557251,
0.5461947917938232,
0.039165198802948,
1.2421174049377441,
-0.3618822991847992,
0.09525682777166367,
0.9209248423576355,
-0.3510759174823761,
0.8718275427818298,
0.5102415680885315,
-0.43031033873558044,
0.8793535232543945,
0.5123087167739868,
0.49269089102745056,
0.2486695498228073,
0.5399163961410522,
-0.09060115367174149,
-0.40303143858909607,
-0.2510918974876404,
-0.11044712364673615,
0.5155943632125854,
0.6705595254898071,
-0.02585562691092491,
-0.10945549607276917,
-0.18698939681053162,
0.1259901523590088,
-0.13580109179019928,
-0.3253552317619324,
0.6991159915924072,
0.15914839506149292,
-1.0171223878860474,
0.71852046251297,
-0.17545241117477417,
0.6555140614509583,
-0.5625212788581848,
0.38104674220085144,
-0.04095577821135521,
0.18291214108467102,
0.013041525147855282,
-0.751067042350769,
-0.08393131196498871,
-0.13037124276161194,
-0.46391451358795166,
-0.19406592845916748,
0.4948866069316864,
-0.40060287714004517,
-0.4721771478652954,
0.6932246685028076,
0.5586318373680115,
0.10129013657569885,
-0.18177835643291473,
-0.7155874371528625,
-0.29108813405036926,
-0.14214004576206207,
-0.6257268190383911,
0.5589150190353394,
0.4549771249294281,
-0.4099433124065399,
0.6164039969444275,
0.7163712382316589,
0.10586895793676376,
0.35026711225509644,
0.04185056313872337,
0.555479884147644,
-0.6560847759246826,
-0.6436517834663391,
-0.9140998125076294,
0.08871696144342422,
0.13571830093860626,
-0.12882910668849945,
0.6270068287849426,
0.14357690513134003,
0.6979291439056396,
-0.06138656660914421,
0.7354384660720825,
0.2239583134651184,
0.12220003455877304,
-0.39156147837638855,
0.5878092050552368,
-0.6051375269889832,
0.32640770077705383,
-0.49799391627311707,
-0.9546563029289246,
-0.37818941473960876,
0.0028012751135975122,
-0.5888981819152832,
-0.10504783689975739,
0.8472586870193481,
0.5045846700668335,
0.060135144740343094,
0.3692999482154846,
0.4423360526561737,
0.5105980634689331,
-0.14914853870868683,
0.37359485030174255,
0.9296990036964417,
0.05750466510653496,
0.5000102519989014,
-0.19637954235076904,
-0.19690239429473877,
-0.2291596531867981,
-0.5949636697769165,
-0.7782381176948547,
-0.35174110531806946,
-0.04330001026391983,
-0.5064246654510498,
0.03600078821182251,
1.1328117847442627,
0.24989387392997742,
-0.9701731204986572,
-0.43275678157806396,
-0.6377731561660767,
0.27217742800712585,
0.05686953663825989,
-0.29110729694366455,
0.17481210827827454,
-0.34513530135154724,
-0.5267924070358276,
0.1539120376110077,
0.3075847923755646,
0.20954529941082,
-0.13185906410217285,
0.1724468320608139,
-0.4076799750328064,
0.7454832196235657,
0.7258968949317932,
0.22946850955486298,
-1.060787320137024,
-0.31866374611854553,
-0.002044382970780134,
-0.32365208864212036,
0.03295865282416344,
0.9884629845619202,
-0.7371938228607178,
0.3871919810771942,
0.6471005082130432,
0.1757103055715561,
0.0211632139980793,
-0.17730332911014557,
0.7668050527572632,
-0.4388903081417084,
0.20398513972759247,
-0.11552807688713074,
0.44341325759887695,
-0.13574665784835815,
-0.28690794110298157,
0.19516494870185852,
0.5223888754844666,
-0.3017561137676239,
-0.6547268629074097,
0.6875285506248474,
-0.6401875615119934,
-0.6429497599601746,
1.144191861152649,
-0.07030569016933441,
-0.2056940495967865,
-0.09470561146736145,
0.060805514454841614,
0.28539690375328064,
-0.14722800254821777,
0.9071715474128723,
0.8014690279960632,
-0.2317572385072708,
0.328130841255188,
-0.3707638084888458,
0.5046844482421875,
0.9621126055717468,
-0.5940628051757812,
0.17139792442321777,
0.2542553246021271,
0.3700118362903595,
0.5638486742973328,
0.6146084070205688,
-0.05797775834798813,
0.12025280296802521,
-0.12746383249759674,
0.18047426640987396,
0.5325825214385986,
-0.37348297238349915,
-0.3699857294559479,
0.23908357322216034,
0.18509797751903534,
0.0839192196726799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12354v1 | LoRA+: Efficient Low Rank Adaptation of Large Models | 2024-02-19T18:33:49 | 2024-02-19T18:33:49 | Soufiane Hayou, Nikhil Ghosh, Bin Yu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | In this paper, we show that Low Rank Adaptation (LoRA) as originally
introduced in Hu et al. (2021) leads to suboptimal finetuning of models with
large width (embedding dimension). This is due to the fact that adapter
matrices A and B in LoRA are updated with the same learning rate. Using scaling
arguments for large width networks, we demonstrate that using the same learning
rate for A and B does not allow efficient feature learning. We then show that
this suboptimality of LoRA can be corrected simply by setting different
learning rates for the LoRA adapter matrices A and B with a well-chosen ratio.
We call this proposed algorithm LoRA$+$. In our extensive experiments, LoRA$+$
improves performance (1-2 $\%$ improvements) and finetuning speed (up to $\sim$
2X SpeedUp), at the same computational cost as LoRA. | [
-0.4143099784851074,
-0.781254768371582,
0.4210978150367737,
-0.04308588057756424,
-0.2794540524482727,
-0.2562713027000427,
-0.058396920561790466,
-0.6993684768676758,
0.6679301857948303,
0.3562459647655487,
-0.3358480632305145,
-0.09631973505020142,
-0.5616989731788635,
-0.3098967671394348,
-0.27069875597953796,
0.824591875076294,
0.15247659385204315,
0.1760583221912384,
0.1237863302230835,
-0.5910822749137878,
-0.3065762519836426,
-0.36744245886802673,
-0.9222550392150879,
-0.381123811006546,
1.2332098484039307,
0.6790004372596741,
0.8516666293144226,
0.7074151635169983,
0.7065626382827759,
0.3369255065917969,
-0.280929297208786,
0.16806252300739288,
-0.8448960781097412,
-0.04601593315601349,
-0.10621192306280136,
-0.6456113457679749,
-1.0556832551956177,
-0.40021878480911255,
0.715653657913208,
0.8859160542488098,
0.03709699586033821,
0.3724409341812134,
0.17908862233161926,
1.1015112400054932,
-0.9449551105499268,
-0.34552139043807983,
-0.7462538480758667,
0.10638907551765442,
-0.10252396017313004,
-0.2739883065223694,
-0.3319385051727295,
-0.5685392022132874,
0.0622129812836647,
-0.8636690974235535,
-0.07270549237728119,
-0.1998903602361679,
0.5615361332893372,
0.4982348084449768,
-0.16079872846603394,
0.004379274323582649,
-0.7035627365112305,
0.7257511019706726,
-0.5954614281654358,
0.19848956167697906,
0.021839071065187454,
0.6226717233657837,
0.11273561418056488,
-0.5352959036827087,
-0.16820180416107178,
0.06288468837738037,
0.4145618677139282,
-0.05048022046685219,
-0.36078792810440063,
-0.11418579518795013,
0.6183627247810364,
0.3944671154022217,
-0.008310269564390182,
0.6527751088142395,
-0.6035818457603455,
0.1822453886270523,
0.7164625525474548,
0.02875848487019539,
-0.2779993414878845,
0.19678105413913727,
-0.2357119917869568,
-0.2441554069519043,
-0.9625481963157654,
0.20014090836048126,
0.3770749270915985,
0.5231064558029175,
-0.19427435100078583,
0.5106955766677856,
-0.07202145457267761,
0.5976741313934326,
0.10666090995073318,
-0.26796048879623413,
0.45305755734443665,
0.1719718873500824,
-0.2894567549228668,
0.23212040960788727,
0.21093212068080902,
0.19211651384830475,
0.20682138204574585,
0.31766560673713684,
-0.0979209616780281,
0.02540605328977108,
-0.05201326683163643,
-0.9431732892990112,
-0.09965591132640839,
-0.12480087578296661,
-0.6252617239952087,
-0.28406980633735657,
-0.23256158828735352,
-0.6798027157783508,
-0.830394446849823,
-0.2713595926761627,
1.188422679901123,
-0.009158557280898094,
0.019357679411768913,
0.17792090773582458,
-0.1180344820022583,
0.4874424934387207,
0.852933406829834,
-0.7226051092147827,
0.407120019197464,
0.544480562210083,
0.8605377078056335,
-0.022254474461078644,
-0.23918746411800385,
-0.9856443405151367,
-0.21836617588996887,
-0.2990853488445282,
0.8262482285499573,
-0.23606403172016144,
-0.1355413943529129,
-0.35746583342552185,
-0.05770273134112358,
-0.023296551778912544,
-0.512148916721344,
0.3491820693016052,
-0.5736812353134155,
-0.13549092411994934,
-0.4761578142642975,
-0.22561781108379364,
-0.31540319323539734,
-0.06206372752785683,
-0.9284201264381409,
0.6547024250030518,
0.23223373293876648,
-0.6928028464317322,
0.34978872537612915,
-1.2979198694229126,
-0.4422740042209625,
-0.39731961488723755,
0.4706467092037201,
-0.5946819186210632,
0.2997165024280548,
0.1714591085910797,
0.19361811876296997,
-0.15766999125480652,
-0.4284656345844269,
-0.7275097966194153,
-0.7638779878616333,
0.22346231341362,
-0.3618113100528717,
0.688430905342102,
0.14148250222206116,
-0.01607067510485649,
0.3782788813114166,
-0.9138718843460083,
0.09803441166877747,
0.08306977152824402,
-0.44077298045158386,
-0.47056257724761963,
0.038439005613327026,
0.02873053029179573,
0.00908423587679863,
0.22612781822681427,
-0.4028240442276001,
0.44379663467407227,
-0.4099283516407013,
0.6169686913490295,
0.9509455561637878,
-0.011955121532082558,
0.6410523056983948,
-0.46597278118133545,
0.3241789638996124,
-0.08077642321586609,
0.336843341588974,
0.2060009241104126,
-0.36557674407958984,
-1.1290267705917358,
-0.305265873670578,
0.6936236619949341,
0.3308503031730652,
-0.4278101325035095,
0.3345578908920288,
-0.4295026957988739,
-0.5228488445281982,
-0.527229905128479,
0.2748108506202698,
0.10853318870067596,
0.15472763776779175,
0.6547170281410217,
-0.4759899377822876,
-0.6522439122200012,
-0.818675696849823,
0.13153430819511414,
0.21796748042106628,
0.1384059488773346,
0.20051251351833344,
0.48466041684150696,
-0.08043476939201355,
0.5671527981758118,
-0.718763530254364,
-0.40597042441368103,
-0.3236466646194458,
-0.43601569533348083,
0.44672510027885437,
0.5442769527435303,
0.6983250975608826,
-0.599892795085907,
-0.5266077518463135,
-0.022201525047421455,
-0.5205863118171692,
0.2857590913772583,
0.3093748688697815,
-0.15646903216838837,
0.05072048678994179,
0.49638617038726807,
-0.2230248749256134,
0.37628376483917236,
0.8826792240142822,
-0.23682206869125366,
0.015193336643278599,
-0.5121666789054871,
-0.29516327381134033,
-1.2427996397018433,
-0.027074094861745834,
0.17604708671569824,
-0.42413395643234253,
-0.30976787209510803,
-0.007081691641360521,
-0.10700606554746628,
-0.30021435022354126,
-0.48783937096595764,
0.4393453598022461,
-0.22976994514465332,
-0.5435923933982849,
-0.21533100306987762,
0.2404979169368744,
0.05931217223405838,
0.6270527243614197,
-0.4255504310131073,
0.5997930765151978,
0.5146519541740417,
-0.6565060615539551,
0.20506775379180908,
0.20338399708271027,
-0.3934707045555115,
0.6109678149223328,
-0.5759370923042297,
0.06690759211778641,
-0.08067511022090912,
0.352059543132782,
-0.555173933506012,
-0.12260091304779053,
-0.04676949605345726,
-0.02916247583925724,
0.08897242695093155,
-0.30544227361679077,
-0.04465894401073456,
-0.20333290100097656,
-0.6573047637939453,
0.38439324498176575,
0.7291527390480042,
-0.8105388283729553,
0.5743392705917358,
0.4146590530872345,
0.2296157330274582,
-0.5717016458511353,
-0.6321897506713867,
-0.3912840783596039,
-0.4692510664463043,
-0.436798095703125,
0.126469224691391,
-0.24020308256149292,
-0.21002909541130066,
-0.03750719130039215,
0.10594236850738525,
0.03178348019719124,
0.513776421546936,
0.3271963894367218,
-0.07063373923301697,
-0.6968752145767212,
-0.10962139070034027,
0.18055163323879242,
-0.1926007717847824,
-0.3792435824871063,
-0.08839032053947449,
0.5158435702323914,
0.04317054897546768,
-0.4412494897842407,
-0.6229873895645142,
0.09296366572380066,
0.7940627932548523,
-0.1166749969124794,
0.7582710385322571,
0.7174075841903687,
-0.3611191213130951,
-0.22650626301765442,
-0.29049718379974365,
-0.16579794883728027,
-0.47947952151298523,
0.6713603138923645,
-0.5499240159988403,
-0.6204403042793274,
0.8303185105323792,
-0.13387587666511536,
-0.16096131503582,
0.6408297419548035,
0.2283780723810196,
-0.06605570763349533,
0.9470164179801941,
1.1091772317886353,
-0.26146766543388367,
0.8495868444442749,
-0.6683309674263,
0.07543819397687912,
-1.1115920543670654,
0.1878780871629715,
-0.5006080865859985,
-1.0812747478485107,
-0.9110247492790222,
-0.3549184501171112,
0.6147707104682922,
0.3562442362308502,
-0.4823220670223236,
0.3565274775028229,
-0.2608124017715454,
0.48921287059783936,
0.5436795353889465,
0.557506799697876,
0.43893298506736755,
0.1913851946592331,
0.40605002641677856,
0.18799829483032227,
-0.9245876669883728,
0.24101388454437256,
1.0963109731674194,
0.5200403928756714,
1.1124756336212158,
0.43417343497276306,
0.5652508735656738,
0.41802915930747986,
0.42442458868026733,
-1.146784782409668,
0.35845014452934265,
-0.6515151858329773,
-0.25935670733451843,
-0.651374101638794,
-0.37677907943725586,
-1.014646053314209,
0.20372821390628815,
-0.5530413389205933,
-0.6497833132743835,
0.8038233518600464,
0.3015119135379791,
-0.6157630681991577,
0.41059261560440063,
-0.8262875080108643,
0.6230561137199402,
-0.09395187348127365,
-0.35361793637275696,
-0.5697290897369385,
-0.1959814578294754,
0.166334331035614,
-0.37840530276298523,
0.10268638283014297,
-0.08624057471752167,
0.027616752311587334,
0.9116362929344177,
-0.4829665422439575,
0.6776788830757141,
-0.6016330122947693,
-0.1671951711177826,
0.06578227877616882,
-0.08602315187454224,
0.632379412651062,
0.07700216770172119,
-0.4460636377334595,
-0.15526820719242096,
-0.23436099290847778,
-0.5676833987236023,
-0.6405124664306641,
0.9770169258117676,
-1.039332389831543,
-0.401373028755188,
-0.0411190502345562,
-0.6322577595710754,
-0.28140467405319214,
0.03358634561300278,
0.16727174818515778,
0.6957109570503235,
-0.09753335267305374,
0.5764222741127014,
0.6989175081253052,
-0.1215708926320076,
0.4098016023635864,
0.28429102897644043,
-0.2551298141479492,
-0.3936804533004761,
1.0752577781677246,
0.5426852703094482,
0.39757949113845825,
0.4540059268474579,
0.30430832505226135,
0.12775813043117523,
-0.6046249270439148,
-0.4117068350315094,
0.14261890947818756,
-0.7752284407615662,
-0.39103251695632935,
-0.31510695815086365,
-0.3777386248111725,
0.2574368119239807,
-0.39519932866096497,
-0.5552057027816772,
-0.8035781979560852,
-0.1254119575023651,
0.23154135048389435,
0.7372050881385803,
0.6239668130874634,
-0.25157076120376587,
0.6111637949943542,
-0.33022722601890564,
0.2408432960510254,
0.5482359528541565,
0.28069010376930237,
0.24035486578941345,
-0.9393937587738037,
-0.49137723445892334,
-0.02428247779607773,
-0.26542535424232483,
-0.30234798789024353,
-0.11291059106588364,
0.5068181157112122,
0.3695807456970215,
0.43396955728530884,
-0.072221539914608,
0.8740149140357971,
-0.32476359605789185,
0.34299081563949585,
0.24662451446056366,
-0.8697876930236816,
0.3215388059616089,
-0.27594882249832153,
0.36060070991516113,
0.42651867866516113,
0.23494172096252441,
-0.09171729534864426,
0.24976155161857605,
-0.4135873019695282,
-0.66161048412323,
0.5777071714401245,
-0.2636788785457611,
0.338595449924469,
0.7924256324768066,
0.36687037348747253,
0.09924328327178955,
-0.26832470297813416,
-0.6701957583427429,
-0.17141258716583252,
-0.16966572403907776,
0.022551052272319794,
-0.3192531168460846,
-0.42924678325653076,
-0.19002652168273926,
-0.42527487874031067,
0.756794810295105,
-0.4653207063674927,
0.4184606373310089,
0.10847547650337219,
-0.3437683880329132,
-0.3601604700088501,
0.28163281083106995,
0.5610112547874451,
1.0266939401626587,
-0.47356095910072327,
-0.17588423192501068,
0.6630045771598816,
-0.33434179425239563,
0.027706820517778397,
0.08762099593877792,
-0.10866081714630127,
-0.3801499605178833,
0.41938331723213196,
1.146788477897644,
0.3986639976501465,
-0.13822412490844727,
0.45942458510398865,
0.047661591321229935,
-0.27372661232948303,
-0.04561982676386833,
0.462470144033432,
0.025100737810134888,
0.583516538143158,
0.5254432559013367,
0.40652599930763245,
-0.023999430239200592,
-0.5584263205528259,
-0.20132380723953247,
0.4030005931854248,
-0.46636566519737244,
-0.3067803382873535,
0.33745336532592773,
0.1956217885017395,
-0.23623712360858917,
0.11449237167835236,
0.07131557166576385,
-0.21419134736061096,
0.6311727166175842,
0.5617200136184692,
0.5423979163169861,
-0.2334001213312149,
0.02979813702404499,
0.45125824213027954,
0.021654147654771805,
-0.26472559571266174,
0.21865256130695343,
0.18645638227462769,
-0.670128583908081,
-0.6062883138656616,
-0.6939630508422852,
-0.5361458659172058,
0.2646445631980896,
-0.7506083250045776,
0.4675132632255554,
-0.6069732308387756,
-0.21546639502048492,
0.3795275092124939,
0.20378418266773224,
-0.5472336411476135,
0.008059152401983738,
0.09559298306703568,
1.10557222366333,
-0.9222907423973083,
0.9458874464035034,
0.5648391246795654,
-0.1830974519252777,
-0.7053011655807495,
-0.16927362978458405,
-0.28228887915611267,
-0.7404311299324036,
0.37448418140411377,
-0.059332843869924545,
-0.23869439959526062,
0.32715803384780884,
-0.32676199078559875,
-1.1716938018798828,
1.2834837436676025,
0.5955673456192017,
-0.5570417642593384,
-0.08077100664377213,
-0.2900843024253845,
0.48939749598503113,
-0.47876057028770447,
-0.10928381979465485,
0.2699163854122162,
0.3992209732532501,
-0.026997709646821022,
-0.9392514228820801,
-0.061854079365730286,
0.03788721561431885,
0.01995307207107544,
0.24502672255039215,
-0.7482694983482361,
1.071391224861145,
-0.5544121265411377,
0.36112478375434875,
0.474697083234787,
0.5014188885688782,
-0.05767152085900307,
0.12472986429929733,
0.6859990954399109,
0.5775794386863708,
0.776328444480896,
0.13193990290164948,
0.8261991739273071,
0.09610366076231003,
0.46383237838745117,
0.9170491099357605,
-0.2597751319408417,
1.1325461864471436,
0.31752723455429077,
-0.2776777744293213,
0.7057834267616272,
0.38770592212677,
-0.04333416000008583,
0.5257200002670288,
0.06774803251028061,
0.11389364302158356,
-0.24200479686260223,
-0.025522619485855103,
-0.73152756690979,
0.6488059759140015,
0.31819355487823486,
-0.4275498390197754,
-0.2680899500846863,
0.27012884616851807,
-0.20278601348400116,
-0.10693978518247604,
-0.8991569876670837,
0.7371430397033691,
0.1690848171710968,
-0.22311584651470184,
0.9523394107818604,
-0.03176257386803627,
0.6556298136711121,
-0.6140629649162292,
0.005676316563040018,
-0.41046595573425293,
0.7194188237190247,
-0.44040998816490173,
-0.37901291251182556,
-0.041980911046266556,
-0.10627949982881546,
-0.437040239572525,
0.3996441066265106,
0.576601505279541,
0.08656555414199829,
-0.6455835103988647,
0.4471161961555481,
0.5780627727508545,
-0.09360654652118683,
0.14070388674736023,
-0.641889214515686,
0.24965250492095947,
-0.12006661295890808,
-0.29459109902381897,
0.6453272700309753,
0.2943900525569916,
-0.40528005361557007,
0.6587705612182617,
0.8000137805938721,
0.0333855077624321,
-0.16469930112361908,
0.2132052630186081,
1.1203690767288208,
-0.5285561084747314,
-0.5259479880332947,
-0.6337077617645264,
0.28906571865081787,
0.05857907980680466,
-0.10665351897478104,
0.5112073421478271,
0.47537291049957275,
0.5613741278648376,
0.030609048902988434,
0.4742908179759979,
0.015232104808092117,
0.34029191732406616,
-0.745966911315918,
0.7201201915740967,
-0.7800872325897217,
0.212502583861351,
-0.31868356466293335,
-1.4045695066452026,
-0.26186689734458923,
0.6513662338256836,
-0.4964523911476135,
0.032860059291124344,
0.6963768601417542,
0.6581785678863525,
-0.5827900171279907,
-0.38755685091018677,
0.40093860030174255,
0.40325435996055603,
0.05166787654161453,
0.7390923500061035,
0.5032671093940735,
-0.8222091197967529,
0.37064433097839355,
-0.1691315919160843,
-0.15191398561000824,
-0.6553656458854675,
-0.8757314085960388,
-0.6603413820266724,
-0.29931893944740295,
-0.28353452682495117,
-0.4798240661621094,
0.28006893396377563,
0.880760133266449,
0.9153425097465515,
-0.7410580515861511,
-0.11603570729494095,
0.35290980339050293,
0.32651054859161377,
-0.4615182876586914,
-0.10464005917310715,
0.6604716181755066,
0.08931682258844376,
-0.5827364325523376,
0.3510631024837494,
-0.09315194934606552,
-0.1370740830898285,
-0.36541256308555603,
-0.37495681643486023,
-0.10778677463531494,
0.14583295583724976,
0.7349602580070496,
0.43697118759155273,
-0.19592101871967316,
-0.46530264616012573,
-0.41341811418533325,
0.01484209019690752,
0.44090309739112854,
0.5988415479660034,
-0.7853531837463379,
0.007440990302711725,
0.37684866786003113,
0.5353049635887146,
0.7344751358032227,
-0.053610824048519135,
0.14811593294143677,
-0.3821857273578644,
0.496379554271698,
-0.23212938010692596,
0.42084380984306335,
0.4081053137779236,
-0.16395409405231476,
0.5265050530433655,
0.019794447347521782,
-0.4327737092971802,
-0.9719666838645935,
0.18492941558361053,
-1.2566189765930176,
-0.08773442357778549,
0.9016491770744324,
0.039474375545978546,
-0.4305083155632019,
0.3315887153148651,
-0.22180241346359253,
0.05299660935997963,
-0.28606122732162476,
0.5607517957687378,
-0.11088407784700394,
-0.19961482286453247,
0.025449585169553757,
-0.5266817808151245,
0.4813638925552368,
0.1736985146999359,
-0.795555830001831,
-0.27777600288391113,
0.14459966123104095,
0.44668224453926086,
0.36387109756469727,
0.2733035683631897,
0.0027486272156238556,
0.4752798080444336,
-0.16251590847969055,
-0.2672296166419983,
-0.16919493675231934,
-0.3492000699043274,
-0.623621940612793,
0.2209017425775528,
0.6673354506492615,
-0.04600941762328148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12352v1 | Graph-Based Retriever Captures the Long Tail of Biomedical Knowledge | 2024-02-19T18:31:11 | 2024-02-19T18:31:11 | Julien Delile, Srayanta Mukherjee, Anton Van Pamel, Leonid Zhukov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Large language models (LLMs) are transforming the way information is
retrieved with vast amounts of knowledge being summarized and presented via
natural language conversations. Yet, LLMs are prone to highlight the most
frequently seen pieces of information from the training set and to neglect the
rare ones. In the field of biomedical research, latest discoveries are key to
academic and industrial actors and are obscured by the abundance of an
ever-increasing literature corpus (the information overload problem). Surfacing
new associations between biomedical entities, e.g., drugs, genes, diseases,
with LLMs becomes a challenge of capturing the long-tail knowledge of the
biomedical scientific production. To overcome this challenge, Retrieval
Augmented Generation (RAG) has been proposed to alleviate some of the
shortcomings of LLMs by augmenting the prompts with context retrieved from
external datasets. RAG methods typically select the context via maximum
similarity search over text embeddings. In this study, we show that RAG methods
leave out a significant proportion of relevant information due to clusters of
over-represented concepts in the biomedical literature. We introduce a novel
information-retrieval method that leverages a knowledge graph to downsample
these clusters and mitigate the information overload problem. Its retrieval
performance is about twice better than embedding similarity alternatives on
both precision and recall. Finally, we demonstrate that both embedding
similarity and knowledge graph retrieval methods can be advantageously combined
into a hybrid model that outperforms both, enabling potential improvements to
biomedical question-answering models. | [
-0.3491477966308594,
-0.9236544370651245,
0.7432112097740173,
-0.418671190738678,
-0.28296107053756714,
0.5386821031570435,
0.09918413311243057,
-0.6007189750671387,
0.670891523361206,
0.6591876745223999,
-0.13270175457000732,
-0.5374653935432434,
-0.6602145433425903,
0.16402778029441833,
-0.3574904799461365,
1.0676119327545166,
0.1561867743730545,
-0.1097894161939621,
-0.6965081095695496,
-0.3142947256565094,
-0.11947715282440186,
-0.41162222623825073,
-0.726152777671814,
-0.7554048895835876,
0.7582007646560669,
-0.13884571194648743,
0.3639017939567566,
0.5830118060112,
0.39788398146629333,
0.17625078558921814,
-0.5198924541473389,
0.5242267847061157,
-0.9109222292900085,
0.04426785558462143,
-0.3716464042663574,
-0.2613663375377655,
-0.241123765707016,
-0.3460012972354889,
0.7415508031845093,
0.9998222589492798,
0.19221344590187073,
0.18640562891960144,
0.05705302953720093,
0.9379903674125671,
-0.6129584312438965,
0.21272321045398712,
-0.6342624425888062,
-0.12577946484088898,
-0.3391417860984802,
-0.5160319209098816,
-0.4154983460903168,
-0.32087287306785583,
-0.04880639165639877,
-0.6255795955657959,
0.20958685874938965,
0.206565260887146,
0.8163522481918335,
0.24719803035259247,
-0.6465929746627808,
-0.2847098708152771,
-0.299858033657074,
0.5779876708984375,
-0.4213106632232666,
0.3209904134273529,
0.2894131541252136,
0.22343580424785614,
-0.3979446291923523,
-0.8537497520446777,
-0.4368584156036377,
-0.04392240196466446,
-0.42262062430381775,
0.11495505273342133,
-0.22928324341773987,
0.045037608593702316,
0.33573001623153687,
0.21121183037757874,
-0.5157402157783508,
-0.08808904886245728,
-0.5339605808258057,
-0.17580914497375488,
0.31470414996147156,
0.06811806559562683,
0.23225918412208557,
-0.43715184926986694,
-0.3134927749633789,
0.006639379076659679,
-0.961127758026123,
-0.10707779228687286,
-0.12063920497894287,
0.25143665075302124,
0.32600370049476624,
0.7597517967224121,
-0.05206026881933212,
0.9639686346054077,
0.025598904117941856,
-0.12485726177692413,
0.5977876782417297,
-0.3008115589618683,
0.10979938507080078,
0.07046984881162643,
0.7105904817581177,
0.33604443073272705,
-0.20809713006019592,
-0.33152347803115845,
0.14433257281780243,
-0.1896355301141739,
0.10508707910776138,
-0.9349783658981323,
0.13110728561878204,
0.24273669719696045,
-0.3994574248790741,
-0.08043269068002701,
-0.28649359941482544,
-0.9547280073165894,
-0.7372068166732788,
0.018420029431581497,
0.3646603524684906,
-0.621483564376831,
-0.04828799515962601,
-0.061024975031614304,
-0.6662216186523438,
0.08919233083724976,
0.0849573165178299,
-0.3130733072757721,
0.19694066047668457,
0.7243884801864624,
0.967494010925293,
-0.31198498606681824,
0.20795205235481262,
-0.7179622650146484,
0.6288217902183533,
-0.25457698106765747,
0.6882373094558716,
-0.619908332824707,
-0.6603904962539673,
-0.26622891426086426,
-0.03819025307893753,
-0.08574815839529037,
-0.6548969149589539,
0.2277660369873047,
-0.8501212000846863,
-0.002610319759696722,
-0.4557529389858246,
-0.8935772180557251,
-0.16234788298606873,
0.3641318082809448,
-0.636990487575531,
0.9685102701187134,
0.18111971020698547,
-1.330701231956482,
0.38696300983428955,
-0.45480799674987793,
-0.5318726301193237,
0.19106832146644592,
-0.6552501320838928,
-0.4972246587276459,
-0.22998853027820587,
0.2715059518814087,
0.2526059150695801,
-0.35368436574935913,
0.26485052704811096,
-0.523145318031311,
-0.3338867127895355,
0.10220720618963242,
0.22201542556285858,
0.670581042766571,
0.05699349194765091,
0.09145552664995193,
-0.08968774974346161,
-0.7776477336883545,
-0.03839980810880661,
0.2190515100955963,
-0.3180798888206482,
-0.844391942024231,
-0.013516345992684364,
-0.47984275221824646,
0.11348887532949448,
0.2998064458370209,
-1.0509635210037231,
0.24758601188659668,
-0.5237845778465271,
0.5100635886192322,
0.30811357498168945,
0.3469753563404083,
0.2647720277309418,
-0.5358190536499023,
0.27330225706100464,
0.0279969684779644,
-0.3324984312057495,
-0.058594800531864166,
-0.4871538281440735,
-0.345994770526886,
-0.39717748761177063,
0.26957130432128906,
0.33859744668006897,
-0.9243051409721375,
0.43153706192970276,
-0.5322064161300659,
-0.41072550415992737,
-0.6778656244277954,
0.08666756004095078,
0.30914306640625,
1.0528841018676758,
0.6688944697380066,
-0.15789970755577087,
-0.4553375840187073,
-0.7663906812667847,
-0.04383472353219986,
0.06327389180660248,
-0.04534464329481125,
0.6866099238395691,
0.41753798723220825,
-0.5117805004119873,
1.1468784809112549,
-0.79668790102005,
-0.2888981103897095,
-0.33673563599586487,
0.1529446542263031,
0.4006136357784271,
0.27935388684272766,
0.5274523496627808,
-0.8769310116767883,
-0.24964813888072968,
0.17894510924816132,
-0.7238754034042358,
0.02547762356698513,
0.3168475031852722,
-0.3046773374080658,
-0.004251942038536072,
0.7120417356491089,
-0.7627032995223999,
0.38259610533714294,
0.3025208115577698,
-0.17137424647808075,
0.26903101801872253,
-0.328681081533432,
0.1433381289243698,
-1.1879351139068604,
0.6912404298782349,
-0.2820901572704315,
-0.3675793409347534,
-0.27927887439727783,
-0.07253976166248322,
0.13789783418178558,
-0.22557847201824188,
0.016939343884587288,
0.898046612739563,
-0.48105520009994507,
-0.22560742497444153,
-0.3869244456291199,
0.24452455341815948,
0.4315585494041443,
0.09622174501419067,
-0.019285183399915695,
0.6529485583305359,
0.26919445395469666,
-0.5830242037773132,
0.15281419456005096,
0.4925687313079834,
-0.03516925126314163,
0.3424453139305115,
-0.5892961621284485,
0.2279028445482254,
-0.6652752161026001,
0.5852328538894653,
-0.8767988085746765,
-0.17460748553276062,
-0.03086896240711212,
-0.5469382405281067,
0.6991832852363586,
-0.29362982511520386,
-0.49641427397727966,
-0.8244205713272095,
-0.28040239214897156,
0.4397171139717102,
0.6067605018615723,
-0.5495761036872864,
0.6923725008964539,
0.7381138801574707,
-0.23197174072265625,
-0.7434130907058716,
-0.4276871681213379,
-0.12550826370716095,
-0.11791376024484634,
-0.4796272814273834,
0.4521549344062805,
0.1358148455619812,
0.03665550425648689,
0.1005367785692215,
-0.0566401407122612,
0.06501094996929169,
-0.2692214548587799,
0.042306240648031235,
0.2721230983734131,
0.046985089778900146,
0.5445988774299622,
0.22930686175823212,
-0.16952577233314514,
-0.13188184797763824,
-0.27693822979927063,
0.5743647813796997,
0.33022764325141907,
-0.3246782422065735,
0.22767353057861328,
0.38477566838264465,
0.3269602060317993,
-0.3016328513622284,
0.6658332347869873,
0.5628485679626465,
-0.3062129616737366,
0.04712216183543205,
-0.5006425976753235,
-0.3075074553489685,
-0.43109869956970215,
0.6877807378768921,
-0.15683601796627045,
-1.0256410837173462,
0.5367241501808167,
-0.45354753732681274,
-0.16128435730934143,
0.4344014525413513,
0.2612852156162262,
-0.14534957706928253,
0.9587316513061523,
0.44093212485313416,
-0.17682842910289764,
0.15568594634532928,
-0.38830652832984924,
0.06681327521800995,
-1.0545703172683716,
-0.319830983877182,
-0.5374413728713989,
-0.2171136885881424,
-0.4219377040863037,
-0.6366599202156067,
0.8038069605827332,
0.20173530280590057,
-0.23850321769714355,
0.030506784096360207,
-0.5521273016929626,
0.295378714799881,
0.5508989095687866,
0.42872220277786255,
0.4580218195915222,
0.00418620090931654,
-0.2897784113883972,
0.1739259660243988,
-0.9747949838638306,
-0.1197294369339943,
1.0853512287139893,
0.11474881321191788,
0.7456870675086975,
-0.10985805839300156,
0.9398183822631836,
0.058325767517089844,
0.296537846326828,
-0.5778517723083496,
0.46658316254615784,
-0.2521790862083435,
-0.6360188126564026,
-0.2853240370750427,
-0.8665992617607117,
-1.4386693239212036,
0.02271912433207035,
-0.29667559266090393,
-0.758880615234375,
0.1737174540758133,
0.1809038370847702,
-0.27883613109588623,
0.47716617584228516,
-0.23327359557151794,
0.5495985746383667,
0.011786391027271748,
-0.335077166557312,
-0.16691052913665771,
-0.8537639379501343,
0.19975809752941132,
-0.302257239818573,
0.45268672704696655,
0.012014244683086872,
0.002220590366050601,
0.7269498705863953,
-0.38155144453048706,
0.6725870966911316,
-0.1640859693288803,
0.16910722851753235,
0.4008115828037262,
0.032410360872745514,
0.6797234416007996,
-0.2123626172542572,
-0.07019796222448349,
-0.10768284648656845,
0.07127498090267181,
-0.45222967863082886,
-0.5907933712005615,
0.7013958692550659,
-0.5172388553619385,
-0.5115863084793091,
-0.17615440487861633,
-0.6271746754646301,
-0.3705774247646332,
0.4362265169620514,
0.4116494655609131,
0.49747776985168457,
0.046751055866479874,
0.2148314267396927,
0.6702391505241394,
-0.6455835700035095,
-0.08449078351259232,
0.44041985273361206,
-0.529895007610321,
-0.39275872707366943,
1.067344307899475,
0.2789471745491028,
0.3129843771457672,
0.5192863345146179,
0.26391810178756714,
-0.46102777123451233,
-0.511559784412384,
-0.33990800380706787,
0.6088300347328186,
-0.568784236907959,
-0.46259093284606934,
-1.0176737308502197,
-0.29507309198379517,
-0.4671343266963959,
0.0007570356247015297,
-0.21092216670513153,
-0.3239426016807556,
-0.22799058258533478,
-0.17076298594474792,
0.7723342180252075,
0.7066656947135925,
-0.11096326261758804,
-0.10505934059619904,
-0.9891434907913208,
0.49677038192749023,
0.13808807730674744,
0.3498593866825104,
-0.045316364616155624,
-0.24826140701770782,
-0.24128231406211853,
-0.013983127661049366,
-0.14615783095359802,
-0.8914703130722046,
0.3658777177333832,
0.0699525848031044,
0.6278585195541382,
0.08650071918964386,
0.08535198122262955,
0.6249135136604309,
-0.5060638189315796,
0.298513799905777,
0.2542876601219177,
-0.2833878993988037,
0.4108448028564453,
-0.4674757122993469,
0.038462068885564804,
0.4517282545566559,
0.4749876856803894,
-0.3851207196712494,
-0.42997369170188904,
-0.6488454937934875,
-1.1186240911483765,
0.2474808692932129,
-0.015384256839752197,
-0.19556541740894318,
-0.3550921380519867,
0.40367332100868225,
0.08224774152040482,
0.2735976576805115,
-0.2562743127346039,
-0.2742094099521637,
0.183598130941391,
-0.2935449182987213,
-0.06468787044286728,
-0.1671159565448761,
-0.382391095161438,
-0.18655487895011902,
0.5661494135856628,
-0.25893649458885193,
0.35252901911735535,
0.3928394615650177,
0.03151870146393776,
-0.1480543166399002,
0.20759443938732147,
0.027239803224802017,
0.4913148880004883,
-0.37063083052635193,
0.10910916328430176,
0.11529483646154404,
-0.36638376116752625,
-0.15364272892475128,
0.5710707902908325,
-0.4160659909248352,
0.11157013475894928,
0.23290042579174042,
0.4911779761314392,
0.04645822197198868,
-0.813564121723175,
0.4273907542228699,
0.4791329503059387,
0.1378200799226761,
-0.0047248778864741325,
-0.09149370342493057,
0.26725906133651733,
0.28182655572891235,
0.6297809481620789,
-0.18211892247200012,
0.4350864887237549,
-0.4258953034877777,
0.5130518674850464,
0.6932005882263184,
-0.3401690125465393,
0.15640321373939514,
0.5892956852912903,
-0.015536817722022533,
0.09758701175451279,
0.327496200799942,
-0.1472935825586319,
-0.39525341987609863,
0.6609925627708435,
0.6718705296516418,
0.14739467203617096,
0.3480669856071472,
0.13445410132408142,
0.48922714591026306,
-0.24276666343212128,
0.09041066467761993,
0.1517336219549179,
0.27681273221969604,
-0.5469889044761658,
-0.6643689870834351,
-0.7001993060112,
-0.1848686933517456,
0.08187444508075714,
-0.6107574105262756,
0.10879258811473846,
-0.11397643387317657,
-0.5804049372673035,
0.08198703825473785,
0.08161522448062897,
-0.4309770166873932,
-0.02795792743563652,
-0.0030914186500012875,
0.8386993408203125,
-0.5075280070304871,
0.7241660356521606,
0.5971649885177612,
-0.4827483296394348,
-0.5957549810409546,
-0.3503635823726654,
-0.23322494328022003,
-0.8979660272598267,
0.732050359249115,
0.013590112328529358,
0.01851819083094597,
0.32828694581985474,
-0.38868194818496704,
-1.103459358215332,
1.1390007734298706,
0.24922914803028107,
-0.533448338508606,
-0.410198450088501,
-0.112066350877285,
0.6096932888031006,
-0.20078548789024353,
0.11702678352594376,
0.42902788519859314,
0.3135458827018738,
0.46570056676864624,
-0.8411420583724976,
0.11138083040714264,
-0.19372601807117462,
-0.29977336525917053,
0.646030068397522,
-0.5721433758735657,
0.7424231767654419,
-0.378450870513916,
-0.1739753782749176,
0.13090473413467407,
0.28701052069664,
0.8003190159797668,
0.6340169310569763,
0.1426851451396942,
0.6091124415397644,
1.0446393489837646,
0.17824630439281464,
1.2648979425430298,
-0.36467763781547546,
0.45259469747543335,
1.074347972869873,
-0.25232064723968506,
0.6559106707572937,
0.6457715034484863,
-0.20148587226867676,
0.4406873285770416,
0.337959885597229,
0.14473649859428406,
0.42601698637008667,
0.28187811374664307,
-0.04853684827685356,
-0.16154411435127258,
-0.3753666877746582,
-0.6923710107803345,
-0.0879700779914856,
0.6799513697624207,
-0.6695364713668823,
-0.385346919298172,
0.0629473552107811,
-0.010288452729582787,
0.09521655738353729,
-0.4401892125606537,
0.8873720169067383,
0.2455463409423828,
-0.4140945076942444,
0.6318663358688354,
-0.514936625957489,
0.4915565848350525,
-0.5918477177619934,
-0.23379722237586975,
-0.08427537232637405,
0.04977978765964508,
-0.03866848349571228,
-0.8293839693069458,
0.05926372483372688,
-0.3190338909626007,
-0.14596250653266907,
0.23404443264007568,
1.0165563821792603,
-0.5120216608047485,
-0.5970103144645691,
0.6667230725288391,
0.6633230447769165,
0.20248766243457794,
0.2604174315929413,
-0.52696692943573,
-0.18278566002845764,
-0.10327260196208954,
-0.032896775752305984,
0.3549904227256775,
0.45800381898880005,
-0.006795960478484631,
0.8349891901016235,
0.5939385294914246,
0.4618886113166809,
-0.1193738803267479,
-0.02388933300971985,
1.2089636325836182,
-0.6908137798309326,
-0.3574715554714203,
-0.5385347008705139,
0.039912283420562744,
-0.4856247007846832,
0.18471385538578033,
0.5301284790039062,
0.8020154237747192,
0.46755361557006836,
0.16237786412239075,
0.8910717964172363,
-0.013452309183776379,
1.3407396078109741,
-0.3740249574184418,
0.7973722219467163,
-0.6813042163848877,
0.05505596846342087,
-0.32870543003082275,
-0.4759244918823242,
-0.2339978665113449,
0.29654499888420105,
-0.41117557883262634,
0.07561001181602478,
0.4686805307865143,
0.5933992266654968,
0.00486032385379076,
-0.25450026988983154,
0.17398306727409363,
0.42259472608566284,
0.2980960011482239,
0.5229905247688293,
0.510108470916748,
-0.07465795427560806,
0.59923255443573,
0.15985897183418274,
-0.16802391409873962,
-0.22431211173534393,
-0.6514942049980164,
-0.8770761489868164,
-0.30269473791122437,
-0.07947256416082382,
-0.6725449562072754,
0.33012476563453674,
0.7197529673576355,
0.4348284602165222,
-0.5502907037734985,
0.20420286059379578,
0.046602435410022736,
0.0818396732211113,
0.10456398874521255,
-0.20236778259277344,
0.7051316499710083,
-0.3475673794746399,
-0.3087005019187927,
0.34621673822402954,
0.17904040217399597,
0.14407789707183838,
0.08583498001098633,
-0.013290378265082836,
-0.33234649896621704,
-0.05941259115934372,
0.5497479438781738,
0.5568341612815857,
-0.2625983655452728,
-0.1747836023569107,
0.049247849732637405,
-0.24184668064117432,
0.2511841654777527,
0.6955356001853943,
-1.2275612354278564,
0.5297111868858337,
0.5975852608680725,
0.9504356384277344,
0.9886900782585144,
0.23087498545646667,
0.5124485492706299,
-0.8179543614387512,
0.17257902026176453,
0.41325291991233826,
0.35285940766334534,
0.4509151577949524,
-0.4450961947441101,
0.520356297492981,
0.3365683853626251,
-0.5444331765174866,
-0.6685800552368164,
0.20993439853191376,
-0.8898619413375854,
-0.5267614722251892,
1.203536033630371,
0.10106144100427628,
-0.3474302887916565,
-0.2833481729030609,
-0.2907624840736389,
0.5478252172470093,
-0.3314434885978699,
0.8007634878158569,
0.23031404614448547,
-0.27350226044654846,
0.30684828758239746,
-0.4292057156562805,
0.5351154208183289,
0.1632419377565384,
-0.6609178781509399,
0.037924736738204956,
0.5384373068809509,
0.2682461738586426,
0.42163020372390747,
0.8784834146499634,
-0.3176671266555786,
0.011202382855117321,
-0.1474432796239853,
-0.0719013586640358,
-0.08036582171916962,
-0.02970750257372856,
0.13427570462226868,
0.2937059998512268,
-0.10932183265686035,
0.09777769446372986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12348v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12348v2 | GTBench: Uncovering the Strategic Reasoning Limitations of LLMs via Game-Theoretic Evaluations | 2024-02-19T18:23:36 | 2024-06-10T17:14:09 | Jinhao Duan, Renming Zhang, James Diffenderfer, Bhavya Kailkhura, Lichao Sun, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal, Tianlong Chen, Kaidi Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | As Large Language Models (LLMs) are integrated into critical real-world
applications, their strategic and logical reasoning abilities are increasingly
crucial. This paper evaluates LLMs' reasoning abilities in competitive
environments through game-theoretic tasks, e.g., board and card games that
require pure logic and strategic reasoning to compete with opponents. We first
propose GTBench, a language-driven environment composing 10 widely recognized
tasks, across a comprehensive game taxonomy: complete versus incomplete
information, dynamic versus static, and probabilistic versus deterministic
scenarios. Then, we (1) Characterize the game-theoretic reasoning of LLMs; and
(2) Perform LLM-vs.-LLM competitions as reasoning evaluation. We observe that
(1) LLMs have distinct behaviors regarding various gaming scenarios; for
example, LLMs fail in complete and deterministic games yet they are competitive
in probabilistic gaming scenarios; (2) Most open-source LLMs, e.g.,
CodeLlama-34b-Instruct and Llama-2-70b-chat, are less competitive than
commercial LLMs, e.g., GPT-4, in complex games, yet the recently released
Llama-3-70b-Instruct makes up for this shortcoming. In addition,
code-pretraining greatly benefits strategic reasoning, while advanced reasoning
methods such as Chain-of-Thought (CoT) and Tree-of-Thought (ToT) do not always
help. We further characterize the game-theoretic properties of LLMs, such as
equilibrium and Pareto Efficiency in repeated games. Detailed error profiles
are provided for a better understanding of LLMs' behavior. We hope our research
provides standardized protocols and serves as a foundation to spur further
explorations in the strategic reasoning of LLMs. | [
-0.3938387334346771,
-0.89295494556427,
1.023330569267273,
0.339811235666275,
-0.043759241700172424,
0.433217316865921,
-0.46602046489715576,
-0.34621772170066833,
-0.02708066999912262,
0.31784045696258545,
-0.6530382037162781,
-0.6837594509124756,
-0.3997332751750946,
-0.21134494245052338,
-0.07962293922901154,
0.7304520606994629,
-0.0783654972910881,
0.0031468539964407682,
-0.4154208302497864,
-0.07199475169181824,
-0.5481564998626709,
-0.6784365177154541,
-0.6599339246749878,
-0.6249580979347229,
0.14885249733924866,
0.5070065259933472,
0.7937532067298889,
0.5433279871940613,
0.7180566191673279,
0.39548155665397644,
-0.07056082040071487,
-0.05759632587432861,
-0.8241129517555237,
0.3706696033477783,
-0.5326252579689026,
-0.7364547252655029,
-0.3485817611217499,
0.11630319803953171,
0.3706824779510498,
0.31458309292793274,
-0.5286492705345154,
0.17699044942855835,
0.043965891003608704,
0.3874858021736145,
-0.49397513270378113,
0.3502500653266907,
-0.6895769238471985,
0.2186138927936554,
-0.2825954556465149,
-0.2448846846818924,
-0.3980829119682312,
-0.2949168086051941,
0.0949065238237381,
-0.856590747833252,
-0.1517239809036255,
0.11584378033876419,
0.8311812877655029,
0.1509401500225067,
0.028895307332277298,
-0.546252429485321,
-0.8262092471122742,
0.7015301585197449,
-0.5196915864944458,
0.16774100065231323,
-0.024223854765295982,
0.6078222990036011,
-0.5172116756439209,
-0.6230556964874268,
-0.38669589161872864,
-0.5034290552139282,
0.17473025619983673,
0.4976119101047516,
-0.402192622423172,
0.30171796679496765,
0.4927773177623749,
0.04576651751995087,
-0.5223198533058167,
0.15619821846485138,
-0.056353989988565445,
0.1542130708694458,
0.6197183728218079,
0.35042881965637207,
0.2491832673549652,
0.01456457655876875,
-0.5244465470314026,
0.05196177586913109,
-0.6782343983650208,
0.014885511249303818,
0.3482603132724762,
-0.3255990743637085,
0.14331291615962982,
0.4899793863296509,
-0.05927233397960663,
0.3255748748779297,
0.07774166762828827,
-0.26636356115341187,
-0.2941242456436157,
-0.2202824354171753,
-0.1451951414346695,
-0.05073960870504379,
0.6979508996009827,
0.42644867300987244,
0.34124383330345154,
-0.432327538728714,
-0.1058373898267746,
0.37571877241134644,
0.027172107249498367,
-0.4230676591396332,
-0.3275817036628723,
0.22192561626434326,
-0.42370709776878357,
-0.22264079749584198,
-0.2595515549182892,
-0.9175426959991455,
-0.40549442172050476,
-0.06363038718700409,
0.3610696494579315,
-0.311745822429657,
0.02591334842145443,
0.30808642506599426,
-0.5000974535942078,
0.3927983045578003,
0.1732555627822876,
-0.70616614818573,
0.41718849539756775,
0.9029762148857117,
0.647877037525177,
-0.2836616635322571,
-0.3349350690841675,
-0.39437392354011536,
0.4123096466064453,
-0.328888863325119,
0.9939941167831421,
-0.5781347751617432,
-0.5313360691070557,
-0.35189545154571533,
-0.48785078525543213,
0.11204785108566284,
-0.8279376029968262,
0.800309956073761,
-0.4513251781463623,
-0.09135955572128296,
-0.5090800523757935,
-0.5393077731132507,
0.1609765887260437,
0.6392898559570312,
-0.4633576571941376,
0.8171991109848022,
-0.3613194227218628,
-0.4770461320877075,
0.37327754497528076,
-0.6962933540344238,
-0.43050897121429443,
0.4003901183605194,
-0.4057564437389374,
0.09866394102573395,
0.19192172586917877,
-0.04825897142291069,
0.08186092227697372,
-0.6458351016044617,
0.4871877431869507,
-0.6275030374526978,
-0.5387362241744995,
0.2960628271102905,
-0.30107560753822327,
0.8146457076072693,
0.08076582849025726,
-0.6591554880142212,
0.32550880312919617,
-0.3519810438156128,
0.47240298986434937,
0.3837731182575226,
-0.4277109205722809,
0.06421178579330444,
0.7405194044113159,
-0.6180610656738281,
0.37898939847946167,
0.10653345286846161,
-0.19746768474578857,
0.22010537981987,
-0.12892629206180573,
0.5863282680511475,
0.9106521010398865,
-0.21015959978103638,
0.2234482616186142,
-0.2873472571372986,
0.618879497051239,
-0.4505928158760071,
0.3731743097305298,
0.5462170839309692,
-0.43557217717170715,
-0.7533823251724243,
-0.242086261510849,
0.2326970249414444,
1.0025420188903809,
-0.9165772199630737,
0.297775536775589,
-0.44034644961357117,
-0.6085731983184814,
0.02712702751159668,
-0.012039032764732838,
0.2782776355743408,
0.179967001080513,
0.056669287383556366,
-0.17658810317516327,
-0.5597888231277466,
-0.7123932838439941,
-0.30129724740982056,
-0.35579001903533936,
0.2083996832370758,
0.5764267444610596,
0.5405282974243164,
-0.06674352288246155,
0.6041990518569946,
-0.3346623182296753,
-0.10339558869600296,
-0.644016444683075,
-0.08691123127937317,
0.14171835780143738,
0.20471441745758057,
0.2836839556694031,
-0.08095338195562363,
-0.091715008020401,
-0.13098487257957458,
-0.9746747016906738,
-0.16581155359745026,
-0.22564846277236938,
-0.43866488337516785,
-0.1901429295539856,
0.5654054284095764,
-0.8165488243103027,
0.3475460708141327,
0.4718533754348755,
-0.2913980185985565,
0.7579261064529419,
-0.30423033237457275,
-0.0715029165148735,
-0.25264668464660645,
-0.013815443962812424,
-0.22446610033512115,
0.05160033330321312,
-0.4000593423843384,
0.5705637335777283,
-0.5670738220214844,
0.09352872520685196,
0.02123270183801651,
0.45581814646720886,
-0.45681121945381165,
-0.31501495838165283,
-0.06553574651479721,
0.669096052646637,
-0.13420873880386353,
0.33779868483543396,
0.28342923521995544,
0.740765392780304,
0.3385416865348816,
-0.4624958038330078,
0.7909246683120728,
0.025016888976097107,
-0.5940712690353394,
0.6488252878189087,
-0.7284494042396545,
0.03331385552883148,
0.14052914083003998,
0.3454746901988983,
-0.8951252102851868,
0.14577680826187134,
0.3740350008010864,
-0.21582099795341492,
-0.19486026465892792,
0.019689152017235756,
-0.6519051194190979,
-0.45362159609794617,
-0.22486884891986847,
0.07527079433202744,
0.46140748262405396,
-0.4517172873020172,
0.5952980518341064,
0.3455961346626282,
-0.004285705275833607,
-0.5318687558174133,
-0.6799429059028625,
0.2421031892299652,
-0.3690466284751892,
-0.5932213068008423,
0.2474701702594757,
-0.18266284465789795,
-0.5566349625587463,
0.04400845617055893,
-0.2924982011318207,
0.09937296062707901,
0.3382760286331177,
0.026363585144281387,
0.24520370364189148,
-0.24312430620193481,
-0.09649252146482468,
-0.27559712529182434,
-0.08388008922338486,
0.5355914235115051,
-0.319935142993927,
0.3439144492149353,
-0.46784690022468567,
-0.5223108530044556,
0.26364681124687195,
0.1898583173751831,
0.12625102698802948,
-0.12302358448505402,
0.3941720724105835,
0.2242521345615387,
-0.012083220295608044,
-0.42021870613098145,
-0.6249021291732788,
0.0166726466268301,
-0.48184502124786377,
0.4358617663383484,
-0.473895788192749,
-0.7893140912055969,
0.7278991937637329,
-0.3849748373031616,
-0.08877857029438019,
0.44100117683410645,
0.5252817273139954,
-0.2570938169956207,
0.9225817322731018,
0.15640005469322205,
0.1600181758403778,
0.05207749456167221,
-0.08949842303991318,
0.11782370507717133,
-0.5008067488670349,
-0.4459610879421234,
-0.28848928213119507,
-0.6293255090713501,
-0.5554074048995972,
-0.5439898371696472,
0.3149071931838989,
0.2131483405828476,
-0.4894542396068573,
-0.0868983343243599,
-0.23719486594200134,
1.0639395713806152,
0.5878235101699829,
0.1773223876953125,
0.28648602962493896,
-0.1604941189289093,
-0.5474098920822144,
-0.03585265949368477,
-1.0612916946411133,
-0.45577821135520935,
0.9231777787208557,
0.18077155947685242,
0.6563143134117126,
0.4246878921985626,
0.7059227824211121,
0.1525770127773285,
0.2801375985145569,
-0.7338589429855347,
0.9949899315834045,
0.1188083067536354,
-0.8839578032493591,
-0.248372882604599,
-0.6349723935127258,
-0.741136908531189,
0.12903781235218048,
-0.3057125210762024,
-0.8355224132537842,
0.055726390331983566,
-0.07538890093564987,
-0.43350493907928467,
0.4798765480518341,
-0.45840370655059814,
0.9882725477218628,
-0.8191463947296143,
-0.6563311815261841,
-0.4053973853588104,
-0.43807801604270935,
0.6749728322029114,
0.30729034543037415,
0.13692855834960938,
-0.05046052113175392,
-0.12648586928844452,
0.4776875376701355,
-0.09599754214286804,
0.5488158464431763,
0.015363998711109161,
0.04146455600857735,
0.4525678753852844,
0.5021255612373352,
0.48861992359161377,
0.12634910643100739,
0.1775112897157669,
0.07738400250673294,
0.05096050724387169,
-0.27334311604499817,
-0.646315336227417,
0.7563925981521606,
-0.6701940298080444,
-1.0322173833847046,
-0.7416969537734985,
-0.4484536647796631,
-0.5769240856170654,
0.06052813678979874,
0.2333342432975769,
-0.03333795443177223,
-0.5824661254882812,
0.07781964540481567,
0.7191486954689026,
-0.3236981928348541,
0.13283534348011017,
0.2508310079574585,
-0.1908475160598755,
-0.2561427354812622,
0.953355073928833,
-0.06298402696847916,
0.2796693742275238,
0.12821756303310394,
0.15472103655338287,
-0.28468701243400574,
-0.7352991700172424,
-0.118744857609272,
0.052486781030893326,
-0.9886852502822876,
-0.061798907816410065,
0.07293038070201874,
-0.24272532761096954,
0.4904932379722595,
-0.15531834959983826,
0.02381005324423313,
-0.3161299526691437,
0.09667441993951797,
-0.222086101770401,
-0.19627754390239716,
0.911106288433075,
-0.3237014710903168,
0.3314040005207062,
-0.3429199159145355,
0.14014987647533417,
0.293718159198761,
0.6319117546081543,
0.07294054329395294,
-0.17397752404212952,
0.20671702921390533,
-0.2036495953798294,
-0.2296927273273468,
-0.9624674916267395,
-0.08828376978635788,
-0.15130195021629333,
0.9814528822898865,
0.3740193843841553,
-0.34071075916290283,
0.7956712245941162,
-0.5075020790100098,
0.6247799396514893,
-0.025946516543626785,
-1.1399303674697876,
0.27486464381217957,
-0.44624099135398865,
0.12483088672161102,
0.5541313886642456,
0.12008068710565567,
-0.3168680965900421,
-0.10476846992969513,
-0.8106212019920349,
-0.4571080803871155,
0.6855098009109497,
0.12258280813694,
-0.33320754766464233,
-0.20745855569839478,
0.2892530560493469,
-0.337921679019928,
0.1874990463256836,
-0.641855001449585,
-0.20600341260433197,
0.15329770743846893,
0.14992466568946838,
-0.028076037764549255,
-0.33159691095352173,
-0.2984117865562439,
-0.2431599646806717,
0.5375575423240662,
0.19802387058734894,
0.37530094385147095,
-0.08895863592624664,
0.042951155453920364,
0.11492729187011719,
0.42884185910224915,
0.6422203183174133,
0.7359948754310608,
-0.14293767511844635,
0.0813836008310318,
0.37742987275123596,
-0.10833757370710373,
0.3688619136810303,
0.1082204058766365,
-0.08441178500652313,
-0.245031476020813,
0.488007515668869,
0.5253127217292786,
0.3756057024002075,
-1.0760242938995361,
0.3018324375152588,
0.03936421498656273,
-0.3728479743003845,
-0.04782998934388161,
0.11875775456428528,
0.30841901898384094,
0.5814188122749329,
-0.049272432923316956,
0.0226468276232481,
0.14558163285255432,
-0.8144845366477966,
0.010109659284353256,
0.8593104481697083,
0.06011887639760971,
-0.04643682390451431,
0.610612690448761,
0.27582061290740967,
0.056767597794532776,
0.5117910504341125,
-0.6696428060531616,
-0.7548608183860779,
0.5662508606910706,
0.4784505367279053,
0.655479371547699,
0.11318264156579971,
0.3449101746082306,
0.11826883256435394,
0.5321357846260071,
-0.2532701790332794,
0.4255824685096741,
0.026619112119078636,
-0.6061394214630127,
-0.5867316722869873,
-0.1078941598534584,
-0.6520247459411621,
0.09397478401660919,
-0.2426377534866333,
-0.15752814710140228,
-0.9565690755844116,
-0.5289074182510376,
-0.2806338965892792,
0.2016848772764206,
-0.6498837471008301,
-0.2690071761608124,
0.4111289083957672,
0.8711944818496704,
-0.3140181303024292,
0.32943588495254517,
0.4930651783943176,
-0.18242201209068298,
-0.6762728691101074,
-0.15586353838443756,
0.19749955832958221,
-0.8296270966529846,
0.8752966523170471,
-0.3974478244781494,
-0.30068930983543396,
-0.12658736109733582,
-0.6438853740692139,
-0.7973815202713013,
1.107878565788269,
0.6162872910499573,
-0.6898111701011658,
-0.31101083755493164,
0.24543696641921997,
0.45032015442848206,
-0.15575137734413147,
0.43793678283691406,
0.8737828731536865,
0.6825351119041443,
0.22255559265613556,
-0.7184689044952393,
0.02529941126704216,
-0.017988063395023346,
-0.23846890032291412,
-0.0036098002456128597,
-0.7397928833961487,
0.5271888971328735,
-0.42270684242248535,
-0.4342765808105469,
0.10077665001153946,
0.47214674949645996,
0.6800215244293213,
-0.0064508868381381035,
0.20929861068725586,
0.7783421277999878,
0.835838794708252,
-0.5620901584625244,
0.9624709486961365,
-0.20411811769008636,
0.17102302610874176,
1.0401095151901245,
-0.5880962610244751,
0.8310865759849548,
0.1146906390786171,
-0.2140653431415558,
0.7404412031173706,
0.388490229845047,
-0.13665108382701874,
0.2575114965438843,
0.7526062726974487,
-0.08757679164409637,
-0.6625822186470032,
0.03422994539141655,
-0.1541467308998108,
0.5491989850997925,
0.5870718955993652,
0.0322783887386322,
-0.527584969997406,
-0.45913732051849365,
0.10793532431125641,
0.0213349349796772,
-0.26610690355300903,
0.6099900603294373,
-0.060357626527547836,
-0.6668900847434998,
0.2902734875679016,
0.04668635502457619,
0.5060716271400452,
-0.6941876411437988,
0.13927975296974182,
-0.22321954369544983,
0.43951037526130676,
-0.0411948636174202,
-1.068723440170288,
-0.01357719860970974,
0.20008538663387299,
0.20802928507328033,
0.046158984303474426,
0.7250788807868958,
-0.023481903597712517,
-0.2919256389141083,
0.4765155017375946,
0.9090977311134338,
0.005102706607431173,
-0.030864687636494637,
-1.1598122119903564,
0.5030986666679382,
-0.17300423979759216,
-0.14203347265720367,
0.29292070865631104,
0.6709516644477844,
0.03429412096738815,
0.7957845330238342,
0.4822017550468445,
0.28657886385917664,
-0.09438234567642212,
-0.14387847483158112,
0.6686550974845886,
-0.7442763447761536,
-0.3827745020389557,
-1.0674711465835571,
-0.173846036195755,
-0.25339508056640625,
-0.17042842507362366,
0.7626495957374573,
0.5631508231163025,
0.7509405016899109,
0.12654060125350952,
0.8298869132995605,
0.01322909351438284,
-0.13971661031246185,
-0.5360502600669861,
0.47979050874710083,
-0.0476938933134079,
0.4064381420612335,
-0.03283865749835968,
-0.8193917870521545,
-0.06363878399133682,
0.5397820472717285,
-0.7554672360420227,
0.04718286171555519,
0.6827151775360107,
0.3300577402114868,
-0.013757560402154922,
-0.0012458419660106301,
0.14467206597328186,
0.12720887362957,
0.3894849419593811,
1.2444082498550415,
1.2405555248260498,
0.13719938695430756,
0.8081281185150146,
-0.02348584122955799,
-0.34868529438972473,
0.03777751326560974,
-1.049851655960083,
-1.1583343744277954,
-0.007388738915324211,
-0.08018071949481964,
-0.4162657558917999,
0.41127318143844604,
0.7288303971290588,
0.2909896969795227,
-0.44969871640205383,
-0.6852235198020935,
-0.13645848631858826,
0.30722230672836304,
-0.3314340114593506,
-0.22979407012462616,
0.07322301715612411,
-0.2397657036781311,
-0.2012990117073059,
0.40704286098480225,
0.35641878843307495,
-0.15878178179264069,
-0.17706355452537537,
-0.08187444508075714,
-0.1662445068359375,
0.5351278781890869,
0.6685802936553955,
0.4561329782009125,
-0.9241984486579895,
-0.22267253696918488,
0.1168208122253418,
-0.00590229406952858,
0.013662214390933514,
0.7528917193412781,
-0.7121937274932861,
0.22719062864780426,
0.43764618039131165,
0.5500476360321045,
0.22350677847862244,
0.027767429128289223,
0.47264647483825684,
-0.16634437441825867,
-0.04418075457215309,
0.38230210542678833,
0.32174694538116455,
-0.10650573670864105,
0.051070138812065125,
0.6844423413276672,
0.39393946528434753,
-0.5179566740989685,
-0.5760542750358582,
0.3152797222137451,
-0.7655110359191895,
-0.3039533495903015,
1.1830263137817383,
-0.07838389277458191,
-0.03820709139108658,
0.20796701312065125,
-0.1428169459104538,
-0.19069883227348328,
-0.17114822566509247,
0.5200726985931396,
1.2481298446655273,
-0.20114952325820923,
0.047313619405031204,
-0.7683265805244446,
0.6608796715736389,
0.3468788266181946,
-0.9830650091171265,
0.14736072719097137,
0.6142674088478088,
0.11982488632202148,
0.10414821654558182,
0.4659177362918854,
0.1186947226524353,
0.4122623801231384,
0.3228844106197357,
-0.17659331858158112,
-0.12194610387086868,
-0.2389037013053894,
0.01660788059234619,
0.226973757147789,
0.15915842354297638,
0.22515732049942017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12343v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12343v4 | Emulated Disalignment: Safety Alignment for Large Language Models May Backfire! | 2024-02-19T18:16:51 | 2024-06-06T12:54:48 | Zhanhui Zhou, Jie Liu, Zhichen Dong, Jiaheng Liu, Chao Yang, Wanli Ouyang, Yu Qiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) undergo safety alignment to ensure safe
conversations with humans. However, this paper introduces a training-free
attack method capable of reversing safety alignment, converting the outcomes of
stronger alignment into greater potential for harm by accessing only LLM output
token distributions. Specifically, our method achieves this reversal by
contrasting the output token distribution of a safety-aligned language model
(e.g., Llama-2-chat) against its pre-trained version (e.g., Llama-2), so that
the token predictions are shifted towards the opposite direction of safety
alignment. We name this method emulated disalignment (ED) because sampling from
this contrastive distribution provably emulates the result of fine-tuning to
minimize a safety reward. Our experiments with ED across three evaluation
datasets and four model families (Llama-1, Llama-2, Mistral, and Alpaca) show
that ED doubles the harmfulness of pre-trained models and outperforms strong
baselines, achieving the highest harmful rates in 43 out of 48 evaluation
subsets by a large margin. Eventually, given ED's reliance on language model
output token distributions, which particularly compromises open-source models,
our findings highlight the need to reassess the open accessibility of language
models, even if they have been safety-aligned. Code is available at
https://github.com/ZHZisZZ/emulated-disalignment. | [
0.0848921462893486,
-0.6678106188774109,
0.3539228141307831,
0.0481480211019516,
-0.4645960032939911,
0.31015393137931824,
-0.1546170562505722,
-0.37662243843078613,
0.16615618765354156,
0.47000789642333984,
-0.4819789528846741,
-0.6291589736938477,
-0.7960749864578247,
-0.21844416856765747,
-0.7182063460350037,
1.0995086431503296,
0.026647377759218216,
-0.12751813232898712,
0.07372088730335236,
-0.11077041923999786,
-0.33709782361984253,
-0.6288731694221497,
-0.5865662097930908,
-0.26806721091270447,
0.37560349702835083,
0.13541080057621002,
0.8019325733184814,
0.9007445573806763,
0.7047491669654846,
0.3775370419025421,
-0.24294929206371307,
-0.5432184338569641,
-0.8097904920578003,
0.004041619598865509,
-0.15847331285476685,
-0.44484618306159973,
-0.6380791664123535,
0.037140801548957825,
0.5467100143432617,
0.6422827243804932,
-0.41874024271965027,
0.11593003571033478,
0.3216248154640198,
0.39069339632987976,
-0.8153662085533142,
-0.15804338455200195,
-0.9689844846725464,
-0.05386015772819519,
-0.1477360874414444,
-0.055140867829322815,
-0.6877561807632446,
-0.44422048330307007,
-0.1420574188232422,
-0.4428747594356537,
-0.19737520813941956,
0.10384911298751831,
0.7441121935844421,
0.5512621402740479,
-0.33327290415763855,
-0.21042931079864502,
-0.5838645696640015,
1.0077050924301147,
-0.7527433633804321,
0.4686921536922455,
0.21542362868785858,
0.40681949257850647,
-0.2951301038265228,
-0.4573471248149872,
-0.6232606768608093,
-0.0029723886400461197,
-0.10435272008180618,
-0.08959181606769562,
-0.3798525333404541,
0.1783299595117569,
0.0509529635310173,
0.04222379997372627,
-0.26378360390663147,
0.6443265676498413,
-0.34958764910697937,
-0.1910843551158905,
0.569748044013977,
0.1893557757139206,
0.3585904538631439,
0.1497054249048233,
-0.6205857396125793,
-0.23633600771427155,
-1.0762603282928467,
-0.12982673943042755,
0.5937163233757019,
0.2709479331970215,
-0.2956651747226715,
0.6322173476219177,
-0.07161406427621841,
0.5288759469985962,
0.31986933946609497,
-0.26158589124679565,
0.4162318706512451,
-0.3090900182723999,
-0.40083980560302734,
0.2910913825035095,
0.7330447435379028,
0.7358729243278503,
0.04126816242933273,
-0.04372384771704674,
-0.28348273038864136,
0.061365820467472076,
0.2946458160877228,
-0.7149680256843567,
-0.018368801102042198,
0.3337923586368561,
-0.3123573064804077,
-0.784339189529419,
-0.2847859561443329,
-0.9201321005821228,
-0.5450266003608704,
-0.10509610921144485,
0.3170120120048523,
-0.2669827938079834,
-0.35718294978141785,
0.04276184365153313,
0.07805117964744568,
0.28193801641464233,
0.20590484142303467,
-1.1107292175292969,
0.20685890316963196,
1.0308932065963745,
0.7045354247093201,
0.12129273265600204,
-0.4538167119026184,
-0.6313828229904175,
0.32762423157691956,
-0.3478411138057709,
0.306138813495636,
-0.7495361566543579,
-0.18100859224796295,
-0.025036297738552094,
-0.10981710255146027,
0.00798919890075922,
-0.28327181935310364,
0.3491118848323822,
-0.5264455676078796,
-0.05061274766921997,
0.049539126455783844,
-0.16821178793907166,
-0.08515626192092896,
0.3506227135658264,
-0.459371417760849,
0.5984458327293396,
-0.21948829293251038,
-1.1241624355316162,
0.30323171615600586,
-0.36300894618034363,
-0.12025976181030273,
-0.6400236487388611,
-0.1814093440771103,
-0.5764039158821106,
0.06178570166230202,
0.33256182074546814,
0.233985036611557,
-0.03807961568236351,
0.2546508312225342,
-0.544891893863678,
-0.48258620500564575,
0.3051510453224182,
-0.6651017665863037,
1.0789836645126343,
0.2216673642396927,
-0.4890996813774109,
0.1642080694437027,
-0.690253734588623,
-0.08196359127759933,
0.17194394767284393,
-0.17717917263507843,
-0.7583994269371033,
0.12256911396980286,
-0.3570745289325714,
0.14251232147216797,
0.2010631561279297,
-0.7062239646911621,
0.1212577223777771,
-0.7124397158622742,
0.27111300826072693,
1.1003267765045166,
-0.13492824137210846,
0.5424088835716248,
-0.25326603651046753,
0.4095427989959717,
0.19628597795963287,
0.553233802318573,
0.17266662418842316,
-0.1866888850927353,
-0.5429524779319763,
-0.49980074167251587,
0.3288852870464325,
0.5116357803344727,
-0.5928381085395813,
0.46683692932128906,
-0.40387752652168274,
-0.4905385971069336,
-0.9121716022491455,
-0.03201349824666977,
0.7200374007225037,
0.3647405207157135,
0.20138899981975555,
-0.28050535917282104,
-0.4943448603153229,
-0.8650308847427368,
-0.2017829269170761,
-0.44686758518218994,
0.14852924644947052,
-0.283498078584671,
0.2592620253562927,
-0.3223552405834198,
0.603159487247467,
-0.4153992235660553,
0.07848962396383286,
0.07322174310684204,
-0.016665568575263023,
-0.11188703030347824,
0.6249443292617798,
0.6327804327011108,
-0.4571969509124756,
-0.12221376597881317,
-0.07484464347362518,
-0.5197096467018127,
-0.3295036554336548,
-0.1995398849248886,
-0.4274364709854126,
0.15717557072639465,
0.5717023611068726,
-0.15530189871788025,
0.5861057043075562,
0.857640266418457,
-0.14892318844795227,
0.20165611803531647,
0.09148816764354706,
0.22594411671161652,
-1.16655695438385,
0.06534580141305923,
-0.4086739420890808,
-0.04272938519716263,
-0.7346611618995667,
0.3128150403499603,
0.08955053240060806,
0.06491533666849136,
-0.6467331051826477,
0.30523598194122314,
-0.38361817598342896,
-0.0979025587439537,
-0.23631295561790466,
0.21531268954277039,
-0.1330147683620453,
0.28653720021247864,
-0.23168949782848358,
0.5670427083969116,
0.42766624689102173,
-0.4080585539340973,
0.005058016628026962,
0.47466811537742615,
-0.18761125206947327,
0.5032862424850464,
-0.571868360042572,
0.3975161910057068,
-0.25982263684272766,
0.14995180070400238,
-1.1586761474609375,
-0.019870609045028687,
0.5227970480918884,
-0.28842493891716003,
0.48462557792663574,
-0.2227345108985901,
-0.11989732086658478,
-0.03220878541469574,
-0.6811767220497131,
0.5842628479003906,
0.6363105773925781,
-0.9254943132400513,
0.2060105800628662,
0.5360065698623657,
-0.26435238122940063,
-1.2878857851028442,
-0.8372365236282349,
-0.02407381869852543,
-0.49010127782821655,
-0.3594755232334137,
0.14423932135105133,
0.10658541321754456,
-0.5443165898323059,
-0.14541733264923096,
0.08000900596380234,
0.09087695926427841,
0.4929182231426239,
0.4192598760128021,
0.2535831332206726,
0.1280355304479599,
-0.0028484556823968887,
0.4784429371356964,
-0.1751043200492859,
-0.08765491098165512,
0.19049113988876343,
0.6212359070777893,
0.2751305103302002,
-0.8657208681106567,
-0.4781048595905304,
0.35768982768058777,
0.5764139294624329,
-0.21278879046440125,
0.8601298928260803,
0.06928633153438568,
-0.5004454255104065,
0.17068719863891602,
-0.32233941555023193,
-0.32441583275794983,
-0.5724608302116394,
0.5452697277069092,
-0.06937815248966217,
-0.6330567598342896,
0.3065565526485443,
-0.032116860151290894,
0.7332538962364197,
0.24689790606498718,
0.5072290301322937,
0.04141102731227875,
1.1534085273742676,
0.7088372111320496,
-0.20853856205940247,
0.48080727458000183,
0.27225854992866516,
0.3069094717502594,
-0.7684854865074158,
-0.09186497330665588,
-0.639349639415741,
-0.5061340928077698,
-0.5149127840995789,
-0.29890725016593933,
0.12351655215024948,
0.33632466197013855,
-0.40683311223983765,
0.26720795035362244,
-0.5046378374099731,
0.5978541970252991,
0.19546276330947876,
-0.006189379841089249,
0.3652649521827698,
0.15173722803592682,
-0.1518314778804779,
-0.10370268672704697,
-0.3654979169368744,
-0.6256863474845886,
1.267641305923462,
0.5449848175048828,
0.990395724773407,
0.3228805363178253,
1.2591277360916138,
-0.11830033361911774,
0.7607312798500061,
-0.4939101040363312,
0.5084015727043152,
-0.026429619640111923,
-0.45430684089660645,
-0.2933627665042877,
-0.2980750501155853,
-0.875720202922821,
0.1988641619682312,
-0.11698292940855026,
-0.8906021118164062,
0.12911182641983032,
0.28523313999176025,
-0.3490449786186218,
0.4597148597240448,
-0.759031355381012,
0.5822869539260864,
-0.39659231901168823,
-0.05765542760491371,
-0.35438868403434753,
-0.5962857604026794,
0.5566916465759277,
-0.42341670393943787,
0.4951114058494568,
-0.021717211231589317,
-0.0722019150853157,
0.6448853611946106,
-0.35623547434806824,
1.2991002798080444,
-0.17752914130687714,
-0.370800644159317,
0.1401520073413849,
0.26240575313568115,
0.6728406548500061,
-0.2938731014728546,
-0.19558990001678467,
0.33527258038520813,
0.037045106291770935,
-0.38287633657455444,
-0.5116411447525024,
0.8712287545204163,
-0.7779126763343811,
-1.0084011554718018,
-0.3250465393066406,
-0.2771490812301636,
0.07431722432374954,
0.09046807885169983,
0.05433852598071098,
0.2362709939479828,
-0.34241732954978943,
-0.04858171567320824,
0.057328879833221436,
-0.5120365023612976,
0.4986889660358429,
0.3957326114177704,
-0.48644718527793884,
-0.48203426599502563,
0.7635269165039062,
0.00018108330550603569,
0.7327979207038879,
0.3152095675468445,
0.06397499889135361,
-0.36893415451049805,
-0.7932059168815613,
-0.5417225360870361,
0.06940906494855881,
-0.8414446711540222,
-0.20513826608657837,
-0.40702879428863525,
-0.0533028170466423,
-0.42735740542411804,
-0.3912283182144165,
-0.4320926070213318,
-0.5384447574615479,
-0.07263962179422379,
-0.5162330865859985,
0.2889218330383301,
0.7484972476959229,
-0.2558451294898987,
0.2846245765686035,
-0.7232284545898438,
-0.21145625412464142,
0.08312801271677017,
0.3875744342803955,
0.044827938079833984,
-0.5639309883117676,
0.11016268283128738,
0.2152564376592636,
-0.3962862491607666,
-0.9363458752632141,
0.23258253931999207,
-0.0811278447508812,
0.478485107421875,
0.612361490726471,
0.32252779603004456,
0.6428095698356628,
-0.6215720772743225,
0.540336012840271,
0.6130845546722412,
-0.8970849514007568,
0.26687848567962646,
-0.04220157861709595,
-0.19445575773715973,
0.6821693778038025,
0.25407350063323975,
-0.452865868806839,
-0.5851745009422302,
-0.44454923272132874,
-0.8678975701332092,
0.46688714623451233,
0.13212472200393677,
0.3450275659561157,
-0.22670577466487885,
0.1903821974992752,
0.28504568338394165,
0.13843466341495514,
-0.5890041589736938,
-0.14780820906162262,
-0.247991144657135,
-0.5808495283126831,
-0.024934589862823486,
-0.33042746782302856,
-0.44245004653930664,
-0.06736826151609421,
0.5855122804641724,
0.008684991858899593,
0.26788049936294556,
-0.10964372009038925,
-0.1097196638584137,
-0.13944803178310394,
0.4850355088710785,
0.5586450099945068,
0.3777097463607788,
-0.09355101734399796,
0.42768776416778564,
0.2739378809928894,
-0.4967338740825653,
0.5348361730575562,
0.08236516267061234,
-0.22161297500133514,
-0.33673733472824097,
0.1544853299856186,
0.5576004981994629,
0.4040324091911316,
-0.5532920360565186,
0.5572274923324585,
0.07720911502838135,
0.04584495723247528,
-0.03380807116627693,
0.05185426026582718,
0.012550867162644863,
0.2723732888698578,
-0.1105489656329155,
-0.14023390412330627,
-0.10917530953884125,
-0.4504358768463135,
0.27725106477737427,
0.4654095470905304,
-0.403868168592453,
-0.4289475083351135,
0.7451171875,
0.3540516197681427,
-0.40565726161003113,
0.5356665253639221,
-0.006070184521377087,
-0.39651960134506226,
0.5564488172531128,
0.698922336101532,
0.9262866377830505,
-0.3963509798049927,
0.0834944024682045,
0.34583452343940735,
0.648876965045929,
0.11433432996273041,
0.08757825195789337,
0.3678396940231323,
-0.7707524299621582,
-0.33455023169517517,
-0.559825599193573,
-0.27026766538619995,
-0.07200634479522705,
-0.7006041407585144,
0.1474916934967041,
-0.6532483696937561,
-0.13206379115581512,
-0.19165484607219696,
-0.5440902709960938,
-0.4057334065437317,
-0.12245917320251465,
0.11262255162000656,
0.7420796751976013,
-0.9150694012641907,
0.7863819003105164,
0.4570349156856537,
-0.20788778364658356,
-0.5486307740211487,
0.40316879749298096,
0.2578601539134979,
-0.9103974103927612,
0.4457717537879944,
0.14295171201229095,
-0.19778455793857574,
0.081674724817276,
-0.6233419179916382,
-0.9142865538597107,
1.1746807098388672,
0.6482017040252686,
-1.0866903066635132,
0.07939103990793228,
0.22804589569568634,
0.41009968519210815,
-0.10335607826709747,
0.0785955861210823,
0.63828045129776,
0.21407073736190796,
-0.18637004494667053,
-1.095459222793579,
0.2823420763015747,
0.10546883195638657,
-0.24062363803386688,
0.48224937915802,
-0.725878894329071,
0.6681813597679138,
-0.44099026918411255,
-0.5057526230812073,
0.09016473591327667,
0.4017879068851471,
0.464040070772171,
0.2509855628013611,
0.7277073264122009,
0.6573089957237244,
0.7836589813232422,
0.011385377496480942,
0.9149829149246216,
-0.2049066126346588,
0.28631386160850525,
1.0918132066726685,
-0.42714923620224,
1.1278190612792969,
0.9420284032821655,
-0.011465870775282383,
0.1805485635995865,
0.3471619784832001,
0.5292012095451355,
0.898324191570282,
0.25104206800460815,
-0.14460216462612152,
0.03859410434961319,
0.09567903727293015,
-0.4390171468257904,
0.41753023862838745,
0.17365770041942596,
-0.5078399777412415,
-0.3208542466163635,
-0.18051409721374512,
0.14601173996925354,
0.08247508108615875,
-0.2060597538948059,
0.7915195822715759,
0.05430924519896507,
-0.37405452132225037,
0.9429055452346802,
0.04657678306102753,
0.7460969686508179,
-0.2734360098838806,
0.027415284886956215,
-0.19216009974479675,
0.31091099977493286,
-0.12217064201831818,
-0.6995251178741455,
0.6209849119186401,
0.20973724126815796,
0.23513855040073395,
0.005962788593024015,
0.3835190534591675,
-0.43795260787010193,
-0.38173696398735046,
0.5380353927612305,
0.20654642581939697,
0.10542234033346176,
0.4601488411426544,
-0.6370424628257751,
0.35583898425102234,
0.19450566172599792,
-0.39513126015663147,
0.644608736038208,
0.2295687347650528,
-0.13750919699668884,
0.4846893846988678,
0.4720785617828369,
-0.1991267204284668,
0.2419872134923935,
-0.031560301780700684,
1.0248771905899048,
-0.4428347051143646,
-0.46108999848365784,
-1.1192567348480225,
0.39355045557022095,
-0.06241106986999512,
-0.11396915465593338,
0.44344937801361084,
0.28361764550209045,
0.9411693215370178,
0.15779896080493927,
0.728313148021698,
0.15049953758716583,
0.2738296389579773,
-0.5951089859008789,
0.9033892154693604,
-0.46164456009864807,
0.45904192328453064,
-0.5237655639648438,
-0.5661666393280029,
-0.3070436418056488,
0.43588748574256897,
-0.5236018300056458,
-0.3541729748249054,
0.4860035479068756,
1.0673061609268188,
-0.11349119991064072,
-0.12511251866817474,
0.3840502202510834,
0.3370932936668396,
0.47652915120124817,
0.4766850769519806,
1.0300830602645874,
-0.3027462661266327,
0.6157153248786926,
-0.4601544141769409,
-0.3990907669067383,
-0.18879739940166473,
-1.067826747894287,
-0.8791261911392212,
-0.3758060038089752,
-0.316543310880661,
-0.35368672013282776,
0.34991878271102905,
1.0290852785110474,
0.26788705587387085,
-0.8034445643424988,
0.18992730975151062,
0.20733006298542023,
0.06343104690313339,
-0.2465432733297348,
-0.06631529331207275,
0.3378567397594452,
0.06847251206636429,
-0.7854911684989929,
0.3930298089981079,
0.1527397334575653,
0.304004430770874,
-0.16215164959430695,
-0.11116788536310196,
0.07866476476192474,
0.17143431305885315,
0.23453325033187866,
0.16705134510993958,
-0.7291795015335083,
-0.8436019420623779,
-0.21092559397220612,
-0.27391180396080017,
-0.018265146762132645,
0.4368124008178711,
-0.31007468700408936,
0.3602861166000366,
0.3731193542480469,
0.8381637930870056,
-0.19219942390918732,
0.13052654266357422,
0.6289050579071045,
-0.8960322737693787,
0.6501711010932922,
0.003605046309530735,
0.4236888587474823,
0.2791077196598053,
-0.4752911329269409,
0.34984177350997925,
-0.259473979473114,
-0.3440300524234772,
-1.200637936592102,
0.4185900390148163,
-0.6152551174163818,
-0.12148821353912354,
1.1501052379608154,
-0.17352540791034698,
-0.41882163286209106,
-0.11606389284133911,
-0.3381848931312561,
0.38456785678863525,
-0.24840794503688812,
1.1240413188934326,
0.4765663146972656,
0.44466280937194824,
0.05158567056059837,
-0.18327194452285767,
0.2789500057697296,
0.4564512372016907,
-0.672794759273529,
0.4518682062625885,
0.3840269446372986,
0.47583135962486267,
0.009228088892996311,
0.6298465728759766,
-0.37303680181503296,
0.07541858404874802,
0.05256655812263489,
0.2808460295200348,
-0.039550770074129105,
-0.23463667929172516,
-0.6796166896820068,
0.003441942622885108,
0.36095213890075684,
-0.5277560353279114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12332v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12332v1 | Triple-Encoders: Representations That Fire Together, Wire Together | 2024-02-19T18:06:02 | 2024-02-19T18:06:02 | Justus-Jonas Erker, Florian Mai, Nils Reimers, Gerasimos Spanakis, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Search-based dialog models typically re-encode the dialog history at every
turn, incurring high cost. Curved Contrastive Learning, a representation
learning method that encodes relative distances between utterances into the
embedding space via a bi-encoder, has recently shown promising results for
dialog modeling at far superior efficiency. While high efficiency is achieved
through independently encoding utterances, this ignores the importance of
contextualization. To overcome this issue, this study introduces
triple-encoders, which efficiently compute distributed utterance mixtures from
these independently encoded utterances through a novel hebbian inspired
co-occurrence learning objective without using any weights. Empirically, we
find that triple-encoders lead to a substantial improvement over bi-encoders,
and even to better zero-shot generalization than single-vector representation
models without requiring re-encoding. Our code/model is publicly available. | [
-0.18781587481498718,
-0.3748247027397156,
0.510651707649231,
-0.04311243072152138,
-0.08935828506946564,
0.2854306995868683,
0.0228167362511158,
-0.3254544138908386,
0.04829246923327446,
0.5286910533905029,
-0.5454585552215576,
-0.6955143809318542,
-0.331949919462204,
0.04670843482017517,
-0.0473778061568737,
0.8343601226806641,
0.02793215960264206,
0.227054163813591,
0.017574556171894073,
-0.23514942824840546,
-0.34807130694389343,
-0.45577511191368103,
-0.589989960193634,
-0.6104353070259094,
0.4361150860786438,
0.15059328079223633,
0.6044614315032959,
0.4609206020832062,
0.391226589679718,
0.31721392273902893,
0.10455245524644852,
0.20678673684597015,
-0.6188957691192627,
0.017265815287828445,
0.43858855962753296,
-0.5058655142784119,
0.008625845424830914,
-0.07330814003944397,
0.4316651225090027,
1.0813206434249878,
-0.5022189617156982,
-0.3565690815448761,
0.17767424881458282,
0.5563227534294128,
-0.44960370659828186,
0.2745222747325897,
-0.5148292183876038,
0.17591989040374756,
0.24109914898872375,
-0.3296085596084595,
-0.46669328212738037,
-0.5992600917816162,
0.4163748025894165,
-0.7707401514053345,
0.5490717887878418,
0.18040360510349274,
0.7288519144058228,
0.05759171023964882,
-0.5044413805007935,
-0.64951491355896,
-0.5825800895690918,
0.6858580112457275,
-0.5591980814933777,
0.5186997056007385,
-0.0009736398351378739,
0.2619018852710724,
-0.1896914839744568,
-0.5044113397598267,
-0.5368629693984985,
0.1259942501783371,
-0.12383156269788742,
0.30066657066345215,
-0.11419139057397842,
0.3480776846408844,
-0.13108189404010773,
0.7040697932243347,
-0.42728477716445923,
-0.029596030712127686,
-0.6637276411056519,
-0.007197939325124025,
0.3270401954650879,
0.3035707175731659,
0.09456674754619598,
-0.1376917064189911,
-0.23954840004444122,
-0.1488931030035019,
-0.5132438540458679,
-0.12408097833395004,
0.45443224906921387,
0.387651264667511,
-0.36126580834388733,
0.2826550006866455,
-0.007369589526206255,
0.6626057624816895,
0.5083532333374023,
0.16160711646080017,
0.35038915276527405,
-0.15959903597831726,
-0.16912247240543365,
0.0968940407037735,
0.8220322132110596,
0.24546103179454803,
-0.19645604491233826,
-0.19158519804477692,
0.03354315087199211,
-0.097519651055336,
0.30026113986968994,
-0.9050502777099609,
-0.2228696048259735,
0.18289527297019958,
-0.4013642966747284,
-0.03739422559738159,
0.16241484880447388,
-0.6945449709892273,
-0.35775667428970337,
-0.1394163966178894,
0.3672950565814972,
-0.641839861869812,
-0.10246989130973816,
0.3881460130214691,
-0.258620023727417,
0.06992380321025848,
0.2823216915130615,
-0.9610045552253723,
0.32502859830856323,
0.6317283511161804,
0.8252031803131104,
-0.08712393045425415,
-0.13008449971675873,
-0.4670346677303314,
0.2325754165649414,
-0.3676910698413849,
0.5200579762458801,
-0.8393608927726746,
-0.5281469225883484,
0.07103368639945984,
-0.36156538128852844,
0.06009596586227417,
-0.7273944616317749,
0.31693944334983826,
-0.7047180533409119,
0.4881908595561981,
-0.15690632164478302,
-0.6533176302909851,
-0.6250771880149841,
-0.12185946106910706,
-0.6970900893211365,
0.8548828959465027,
0.11462661623954773,
-0.5654683709144592,
0.574907660484314,
-0.5780024528503418,
-0.20514605939388275,
0.27493542432785034,
-0.3927861154079437,
-0.534928023815155,
0.24351927638053894,
0.3424150049686432,
0.4866690933704376,
-0.13086335361003876,
0.23774142563343048,
-0.4551510810852051,
-0.6917501091957092,
-0.19879268109798431,
-0.3827873170375824,
0.6930097937583923,
0.09996320307254791,
-0.2645290791988373,
0.17980560660362244,
-0.6323691010475159,
-0.3560176193714142,
-0.00511383730918169,
-0.4856422245502472,
-0.3659795820713043,
-0.2721707820892334,
-0.3199369013309479,
-0.010612793266773224,
-0.00884659867733717,
-0.5786452293395996,
-0.11933191120624542,
-0.5220677852630615,
0.12412063032388687,
0.6831403374671936,
0.053890161216259,
0.530580997467041,
-0.2421821504831314,
0.12584277987480164,
0.3884511888027191,
-0.237282395362854,
-0.29655638337135315,
-0.2004166543483734,
-0.8838003277778625,
-0.5799873471260071,
-0.17586030066013336,
0.3226754367351532,
-0.9832234382629395,
0.5775545835494995,
-0.18992125988006592,
-0.13327935338020325,
-0.5366762280464172,
0.057052988559007645,
0.21301700174808502,
0.32284313440322876,
0.25056028366088867,
-0.11294098198413849,
-0.5139502882957458,
-0.6642105579376221,
-0.2594466507434845,
-0.01354864239692688,
-0.25012266635894775,
0.40241101384162903,
0.37627139687538147,
-0.1616508960723877,
0.7598925232887268,
-0.5892086029052734,
-0.029559925198554993,
-0.33415812253952026,
0.4704039692878723,
0.24156515300273895,
0.30460405349731445,
0.35287874937057495,
-0.6727954745292664,
-0.6158176064491272,
0.13888773322105408,
-1.0623626708984375,
0.07517147809267044,
-0.05039279907941818,
0.10399041324853897,
0.23556089401245117,
0.48444822430610657,
-0.3535064458847046,
0.4434090852737427,
0.6580576300621033,
-0.14814576506614685,
0.027667595073580742,
-0.28071022033691406,
0.16955731809139252,
-1.1596723794937134,
-0.4181675314903259,
-0.0038887239061295986,
-0.12608113884925842,
-0.7439098358154297,
-0.21184220910072327,
-0.10216591507196426,
-0.37630367279052734,
-0.2738589644432068,
0.32788416743278503,
-0.7074429988861084,
-0.11769671738147736,
-0.06760723888874054,
0.17546553909778595,
0.16582661867141724,
1.0532771348953247,
0.14937935769557953,
0.825830340385437,
0.7072775959968567,
-0.6851765513420105,
0.47829028964042664,
0.26232337951660156,
-0.2399221658706665,
0.7910528779029846,
-0.5742854475975037,
0.2570765018463135,
-0.4476928412914276,
0.455074280500412,
-0.786525309085846,
-0.4807194769382477,
0.2288484424352646,
-0.2558201253414154,
0.10048844665288925,
0.027341557666659355,
-0.05584303289651871,
-0.4717985689640045,
-0.3127627372741699,
0.3517841398715973,
0.43633317947387695,
-1.1139702796936035,
0.8106594681739807,
0.08736614882946014,
-0.06006865203380585,
-0.4113248884677887,
-0.42051607370376587,
-0.26930543780326843,
-0.28188347816467285,
-0.6288807392120361,
0.22310370206832886,
0.08219105750322342,
-0.004590775351971388,
-0.06563779711723328,
-0.3648756742477417,
0.007562893442809582,
-0.18751679360866547,
0.3286304473876953,
0.1413009613752365,
-0.019258644431829453,
0.10296827554702759,
-0.1603236198425293,
0.05624473839998245,
-0.15396037697792053,
-0.3742367923259735,
0.7493547797203064,
-0.31056371331214905,
-0.6551586389541626,
-0.8703874945640564,
0.7931699156761169,
0.25209882855415344,
0.1904730200767517,
0.7175683975219727,
0.6737825870513916,
-0.29808157682418823,
0.0021496100816875696,
-0.6737274527549744,
-0.2686561942100525,
-0.5716632604598999,
0.3899350166320801,
-0.5019843578338623,
-1.2594093084335327,
0.5030826330184937,
-0.08338949084281921,
0.11036469787359238,
0.12229258567094803,
0.40109381079673767,
-0.19117721915245056,
0.8830077052116394,
0.5523315072059631,
0.32952889800071716,
0.6863887310028076,
-0.17406001687049866,
0.38052529096603394,
-0.6292158365249634,
-0.5284816026687622,
-0.2849288284778595,
0.10716862976551056,
-0.6222947835922241,
-0.41128653287887573,
0.7326674461364746,
-0.013191320933401585,
-0.27089110016822815,
0.2436157763004303,
-0.22572457790374756,
0.43078529834747314,
0.7086414098739624,
0.4499867260456085,
0.09037532657384872,
0.26345953345298767,
-0.1202368214726448,
0.06376241892576218,
-0.7180157899856567,
-0.2868759036064148,
0.8768755793571472,
0.25135287642478943,
0.7962570786476135,
0.29509931802749634,
1.2418240308761597,
0.1814558058977127,
-0.06476937979459763,
-0.820930540561676,
0.36741143465042114,
-0.12153754383325577,
-0.29458075761795044,
-0.09708628803491592,
-0.6235413551330566,
-0.9398726224899292,
0.4587610065937042,
-0.08397695422172546,
-0.67182856798172,
0.41631028056144714,
-0.0031310277990996838,
-0.6243162751197815,
0.4133201837539673,
-0.8022037148475647,
0.6011282801628113,
-0.08800967037677765,
-0.47979864478111267,
-0.29190748929977417,
-0.427916944026947,
0.1317129284143448,
0.19237403571605682,
-0.019093498587608337,
0.049723636358976364,
0.3086698651313782,
0.683216392993927,
-0.4086449146270752,
0.8997828364372253,
-0.2959236800670624,
0.0419205017387867,
0.3604523241519928,
0.01744796335697174,
0.44200772047042847,
-0.02227393537759781,
-0.14996689558029175,
0.43394020199775696,
-0.3779591917991638,
-0.6068173050880432,
-0.6537855863571167,
0.3836495280265808,
-0.8447839021682739,
-0.6272022724151611,
-0.2939966320991516,
-0.5505505800247192,
-0.19625172019004822,
0.10765421390533447,
0.19304566085338593,
0.747036337852478,
-0.36794593930244446,
0.3210337460041046,
0.6466217041015625,
-0.2462097704410553,
0.6651023626327515,
0.07501102983951569,
0.014318615198135376,
-0.6871808171272278,
0.7729455828666687,
-0.3431953191757202,
0.361002653837204,
0.2599567472934723,
-0.020776323974132538,
-0.01963239535689354,
-0.40150368213653564,
-0.2806112766265869,
0.25758451223373413,
-0.7751296758651733,
-0.07538241147994995,
-0.9563702940940857,
-0.16339115798473358,
-0.21517039835453033,
-0.7453840970993042,
-0.316977322101593,
0.09035751223564148,
-0.6320136785507202,
-0.1675412356853485,
0.08969983458518982,
0.9867066144943237,
-0.34841591119766235,
0.7044389843940735,
-0.7379501461982727,
0.5520472526550293,
0.7070353031158447,
0.47607287764549255,
-0.06623709946870804,
-0.3421884775161743,
-0.34364861249923706,
0.10831496864557266,
-0.2989526689052582,
-0.6294870972633362,
0.6794801354408264,
0.14956125617027283,
0.5772345662117004,
0.36354193091392517,
-0.10944889485836029,
0.7536307573318481,
-0.4205010235309601,
0.8285229206085205,
0.6712532043457031,
-1.0437496900558472,
0.038298334926366806,
-0.5143458843231201,
0.3313343822956085,
0.6242237687110901,
0.4481073021888733,
-0.49811628460884094,
-0.02928982861340046,
-0.42307141423225403,
-0.6062142252922058,
0.9178479313850403,
0.16708137094974518,
0.17134571075439453,
-0.012076142244040966,
0.2373410314321518,
0.5853896737098694,
0.048039305955171585,
-0.5289490222930908,
-0.004133710637688637,
-0.5889415144920349,
-0.5281044840812683,
0.25216642022132874,
-0.399209201335907,
-0.18569029867649078,
-0.009802263230085373,
0.48509880900382996,
-0.3292073905467987,
0.507788360118866,
0.050310589373111725,
-0.05593031272292137,
0.14296984672546387,
0.4189644455909729,
0.3984488844871521,
0.19991354644298553,
-0.5138199329376221,
0.14900407195091248,
0.09120814502239227,
-0.4150441884994507,
0.022591350600123405,
0.12132003903388977,
0.17890015244483948,
0.08713223040103912,
0.12527327239513397,
1.3624547719955444,
0.16731667518615723,
-0.1284627616405487,
0.5034991502761841,
-0.11830464005470276,
-0.16178888082504272,
-0.2642230987548828,
-0.11113077402114868,
-0.018118690699338913,
0.41929566860198975,
0.5316219925880432,
0.07589463144540787,
0.4599936604499817,
-0.6440767645835876,
0.17073680460453033,
0.3809897005558014,
-0.5515591502189636,
-0.2892410457134247,
0.39288148283958435,
0.7545782327651978,
-0.29436424374580383,
0.6069631576538086,
-0.22534619271755219,
-0.5341130495071411,
0.2414286732673645,
0.5482575297355652,
1.0793867111206055,
-0.07519315928220749,
0.22073759138584137,
0.40813347697257996,
-0.09328842908143997,
-0.05012596771121025,
0.16102084517478943,
-0.35606998205184937,
-0.9103190898895264,
0.10807020217180252,
-0.4324883818626404,
-0.6428793668746948,
-0.23954139649868011,
-0.8667251467704773,
0.26787540316581726,
-0.4119901955127716,
0.11989504843950272,
-0.22505521774291992,
-0.16728965938091278,
-0.7553895115852356,
-0.1711677461862564,
0.30093204975128174,
0.309901624917984,
-0.6610088348388672,
0.36442598700523376,
0.10871318727731705,
-0.18002404272556305,
-0.49264925718307495,
0.2548251450061798,
0.10059810429811478,
-0.8024978041648865,
0.6029666662216187,
0.6582439541816711,
-0.4715975821018219,
-0.056353773921728134,
-0.5121797323226929,
-0.7129543423652649,
1.120356559753418,
0.20187240839004517,
-0.7322505712509155,
-0.18942669034004211,
0.13859759271144867,
0.3822624087333679,
-0.5982574820518494,
0.44817376136779785,
0.5776252746582031,
-0.08561930060386658,
0.46110522747039795,
-0.7661256790161133,
-0.18239831924438477,
-0.04685565456748009,
0.2391781210899353,
-0.04851676523685455,
-0.7295008301734924,
0.853030264377594,
-0.17346537113189697,
-0.5084770321846008,
-0.22266100347042084,
0.9461086392402649,
0.44801586866378784,
0.2942473292350769,
0.1893320083618164,
0.35889968276023865,
0.8392444252967834,
-0.2354559749364853,
0.8920602202415466,
-0.05792710930109024,
0.3410812020301819,
1.2494877576828003,
-0.5943511128425598,
0.4290012717247009,
0.4169818162918091,
0.04884748533368111,
0.8554251790046692,
0.38473382592201233,
0.19561220705509186,
0.7353866100311279,
0.012074875645339489,
-0.6793841123580933,
-0.3048523962497711,
0.09945102035999298,
-0.11678953468799591,
0.5689980387687683,
0.5732507109642029,
-0.08962550759315491,
-0.364603191614151,
0.09331439435482025,
-0.013503232039511204,
0.07994875311851501,
-0.24478422105312347,
1.1384509801864624,
-0.021657241508364677,
-0.407457560300827,
0.8241888284683228,
-0.331088125705719,
1.1765058040618896,
-0.35786738991737366,
-0.27161505818367004,
-0.2674058675765991,
0.1619955152273178,
-0.21261605620384216,
-0.5185156464576721,
0.30231162905693054,
-0.2925630807876587,
0.019918352365493774,
-0.16194316744804382,
0.3975486159324646,
-0.669739305973053,
-0.2990228831768036,
0.26524171233177185,
0.2180900126695633,
0.013063796795904636,
0.22208309173583984,
-0.3603130877017975,
0.16387329995632172,
0.03329548239707947,
-0.08013380318880081,
-0.2208017259836197,
0.45567893981933594,
0.14332467317581177,
0.5185691118240356,
0.34323379397392273,
-0.3583567440509796,
0.2772912085056305,
0.23532161116600037,
0.7712564468383789,
-0.8953405022621155,
-0.6084858179092407,
-0.5532036423683167,
0.39498013257980347,
-0.3214835524559021,
0.31398600339889526,
0.5100704431533813,
0.40977275371551514,
0.8481784462928772,
0.016369687393307686,
1.0537676811218262,
0.2087244838476181,
0.42153802514076233,
-0.5083745718002319,
0.3669653832912445,
-0.38207992911338806,
0.2682499289512634,
0.013279496692121029,
-0.6622827053070068,
-0.5151136517524719,
0.6144633293151855,
-0.3047288954257965,
0.2683417499065399,
0.7203213572502136,
0.8332324028015137,
-0.07982584089040756,
0.5181668400764465,
0.5002606511116028,
-0.0901232361793518,
0.43101468682289124,
0.6283231377601624,
0.7672803401947021,
-0.5529620051383972,
0.5340521931648254,
-0.149113729596138,
-0.09658109396696091,
-0.4823610186576843,
-0.532477855682373,
-1.2837661504745483,
-0.5207698941230774,
-0.08323781937360764,
-0.16618704795837402,
0.1265561729669571,
1.2043604850769043,
0.8230651617050171,
-0.8298407196998596,
-0.39850714802742004,
-0.3221161663532257,
0.00738523667678237,
-0.06620503216981888,
-0.20137928426265717,
0.29576778411865234,
-0.321643203496933,
-0.896443247795105,
0.47542428970336914,
0.4434618353843689,
0.07091741263866425,
-0.13273096084594727,
-0.24339331686496735,
-0.17863963544368744,
0.33076000213623047,
0.564079225063324,
0.10007433593273163,
-0.8238269686698914,
-0.5271093249320984,
-0.20354622602462769,
-0.21001677215099335,
0.42502641677856445,
0.749165952205658,
-0.7741376161575317,
0.537804365158081,
0.41266530752182007,
0.6715384721755981,
0.8159893751144409,
-0.09772686660289764,
0.7629938721656799,
-0.8278448581695557,
0.3020878732204437,
-0.013390985317528248,
0.3029879927635193,
0.7819426655769348,
-0.37072351574897766,
0.33197468519210815,
0.2999825179576874,
-0.262285053730011,
-0.5470263361930847,
0.4301612973213196,
-1.0085813999176025,
-0.08496405929327011,
1.0010387897491455,
-0.20614847540855408,
-0.22688592970371246,
-0.3396137058734894,
-0.17390868067741394,
0.4222097098827362,
-0.7373348474502563,
0.5913063883781433,
0.3534733057022095,
-0.4422934651374817,
-0.2910439372062683,
-0.10094263404607773,
0.26520204544067383,
0.2117258906364441,
-0.7701317667961121,
-0.0432073175907135,
0.9116662740707397,
0.29253503680229187,
0.26334846019744873,
0.5143572688102722,
-0.01164542231708765,
0.0879414975643158,
0.5090731382369995,
0.3811534345149994,
-0.13114632666110992,
-0.3772370517253876,
-0.626820981502533,
0.5092195868492126,
-0.49557289481163025,
-0.24618664383888245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12329v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12329v1 | Query-Based Adversarial Prompt Generation | 2024-02-19T18:01:36 | 2024-02-19T18:01:36 | Jonathan Hayase, Ema Borevkovic, Nicholas Carlini, Florian Tramèr, Milad Nasr | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Recent work has shown it is possible to construct adversarial examples that
cause an aligned language model to emit harmful strings or perform harmful
behavior. Existing attacks work either in the white-box setting (with full
access to the model weights), or through transferability: the phenomenon that
adversarial examples crafted on one model often remain effective on other
models. We improve on prior work with a query-based attack that leverages API
access to a remote language model to construct adversarial examples that cause
the model to emit harmful strings with (much) higher probability than with
transfer-only attacks. We validate our attack on GPT-3.5 and OpenAI's safety
classifier; we can cause GPT-3.5 to emit harmful strings that current transfer
attacks fail at, and we can evade the safety classifier with nearly 100%
probability. | [
-0.06800753623247147,
-1.1719967126846313,
0.37204670906066895,
-0.31059715151786804,
0.03681417927145958,
-0.16559375822544098,
0.1278858780860901,
-0.5872182250022888,
-0.08173469454050064,
0.6907414793968201,
-0.5558373332023621,
-0.23617719113826752,
-0.5421446561813354,
-0.13021473586559296,
-0.5524701476097107,
1.1878770589828491,
0.3239942789077759,
-0.1439671665430069,
0.18882595002651215,
0.10322190076112747,
-0.43079888820648193,
-0.6539233326911926,
-1.0661076307296753,
0.2256542593240738,
0.6157257556915283,
0.034962888807058334,
0.9797820448875427,
0.251239150762558,
0.5127745270729065,
0.2869774103164673,
0.031135449185967445,
-0.15459050238132477,
-0.45971712470054626,
0.3546193838119507,
-0.22891837358474731,
-0.8687632083892822,
-0.23802076280117035,
-0.027487637475132942,
0.1510644555091858,
0.3266195058822632,
-0.005508937407284975,
-0.10115092247724533,
-0.19938649237155914,
0.4531308710575104,
-0.6371120810508728,
-0.15964196622371674,
-1.1274336576461792,
-0.1478157639503479,
-0.20538777112960815,
-0.12087827175855637,
-0.7026782631874084,
-0.6162024140357971,
0.08018970489501953,
-0.6628912091255188,
0.24948282539844513,
0.05271552875638008,
0.882817268371582,
0.21554051339626312,
-0.5504704713821411,
-0.5229192972183228,
-0.49914106726646423,
0.4119078814983368,
-0.528794527053833,
-0.20310509204864502,
0.497000128030777,
0.6309090852737427,
-0.42232775688171387,
-0.7999369502067566,
-0.34214508533477783,
-0.43270519375801086,
-0.03833991289138794,
-0.04466754570603371,
-0.6661252975463867,
-0.010486236773431301,
0.4603748619556427,
0.027587875723838806,
-0.7662147879600525,
-0.042660582810640335,
-0.5201368927955627,
-0.22125446796417236,
0.5595722198486328,
-0.04086203873157501,
0.7095174789428711,
-0.22645221650600433,
-0.48665961623191833,
-0.24852275848388672,
-1.0950117111206055,
-0.047288041561841965,
0.696452796459198,
0.47117435932159424,
0.18613572418689728,
0.3925448954105377,
0.05083568021655083,
0.9293420910835266,
0.0046864100731909275,
0.4195001423358917,
-0.42317458987236023,
-0.3213634490966797,
-0.06444942206144333,
0.17761659622192383,
1.0881271362304688,
0.29845932126045227,
0.24741072952747345,
-0.1233971118927002,
-0.08994852751493454,
-0.07738711684942245,
0.5692080855369568,
-0.736398458480835,
-0.5032544732093811,
0.08084011822938919,
-0.18894250690937042,
-0.6993922591209412,
0.13193659484386444,
-0.7598814964294434,
-0.7328848242759705,
0.21895068883895874,
0.4472648799419403,
-0.5689477324485779,
-0.036790650337934494,
-0.19334828853607178,
-0.14983728528022766,
0.04100217670202255,
0.1677638441324234,
-0.754160463809967,
0.09118073433637619,
0.562038779258728,
0.5978543758392334,
-0.104566790163517,
-0.14755477011203766,
-0.7552587985992432,
0.16426022350788116,
-0.17059706151485443,
0.6054666638374329,
-0.3458997905254364,
-0.567256510257721,
0.08167901635169983,
0.10868269205093384,
-0.14521673321723938,
-0.34264859557151794,
0.4951375722885132,
-0.9272235035896301,
0.5442376732826233,
-0.39474478363990784,
-0.2548867166042328,
-0.3207613229751587,
0.15364916622638702,
-0.6877773404121399,
0.5374860167503357,
0.14474667608737946,
-0.7191808223724365,
0.11381521075963974,
-0.8024756908416748,
-0.6760239005088806,
0.060664087533950806,
0.1412169486284256,
-0.24412693083286285,
-0.0719258114695549,
0.23814022541046143,
0.1396005004644394,
-0.08832216262817383,
-0.09634596854448318,
-0.4992600977420807,
-0.3121158480644226,
0.4181530773639679,
-0.7075259685516357,
1.2977901697158813,
0.5794051885604858,
-0.4106171429157257,
0.2379521280527115,
-0.5513406991958618,
0.024053191766142845,
0.34498992562294006,
0.04815247654914856,
-0.5658363103866577,
-0.2903504967689514,
-0.36703428626060486,
0.08740655332803726,
0.22649915516376495,
-0.4517269432544708,
0.3501741588115692,
-0.4285399615764618,
0.38168057799339294,
0.7670089602470398,
0.37031567096710205,
0.192671537399292,
-0.2350969910621643,
0.8360435962677002,
-0.2471739500761032,
0.31740283966064453,
0.049327701330184937,
-0.6157785058021545,
-0.2445107251405716,
0.005430232733488083,
0.10094591230154037,
0.8178446888923645,
-1.1573923826217651,
0.1851845234632492,
0.020249536260962486,
-0.5715438723564148,
-0.3346981108188629,
-0.10016153007745743,
0.4579697847366333,
0.60250324010849,
0.21523134410381317,
0.2898499667644501,
-0.21220307052135468,
-0.6134626269340515,
-0.46776214241981506,
-0.4524843394756317,
-0.02048422396183014,
0.46109744906425476,
0.346952348947525,
0.18951308727264404,
0.4349094331264496,
-0.8300086855888367,
0.19294913113117218,
0.028312543407082558,
0.1623559445142746,
0.14672887325286865,
0.4878256022930145,
0.8688074946403503,
-0.8744983673095703,
-0.4359816312789917,
-0.2050471156835556,
-0.7474740147590637,
-0.06750790774822235,
-0.18711620569229126,
-0.4417007267475128,
0.027212249115109444,
0.49825990200042725,
-0.6123793721199036,
0.3352649211883545,
0.25463294982910156,
-0.5764021873474121,
0.553704559803009,
-0.10747029632329941,
0.4267578423023224,
-1.2901581525802612,
-0.04269970580935478,
-0.07122454792261124,
-0.21487151086330414,
-0.7851054072380066,
0.543403685092926,
0.10315387696027756,
-0.5636054873466492,
-0.9061641097068787,
0.39446237683296204,
-0.03838841989636421,
0.2213570922613144,
-0.25203946232795715,
0.12847353518009186,
0.03562997654080391,
0.28241676092147827,
-0.44220849871635437,
1.1055024862289429,
0.6608385443687439,
-0.7091202735900879,
0.7338442206382751,
0.1484629362821579,
-0.02135591395199299,
0.7172825932502747,
-0.7980868220329285,
0.13694800436496735,
0.0695318952202797,
0.17308388650417328,
-1.0009040832519531,
-0.205948606133461,
0.6968273520469666,
-0.6963261961936951,
0.5305723547935486,
-0.3250574469566345,
-0.2438717931509018,
-0.30657121539115906,
-0.3461569845676422,
0.3615424335002899,
0.5820322632789612,
-0.7638885974884033,
0.09429654479026794,
0.13065998256206512,
-0.23947393894195557,
-0.6507163643836975,
-0.6434569358825684,
0.22747939825057983,
-0.4605688154697418,
-0.6878915429115295,
0.05081811919808388,
0.08028075844049454,
-0.06551342457532883,
0.07319291681051254,
0.15366363525390625,
0.12284568697214127,
0.5978407859802246,
0.06362584978342056,
0.37914955615997314,
-0.26378804445266724,
-0.28897908329963684,
-0.14338363707065582,
0.2620096206665039,
0.4047360122203827,
-0.26897820830345154,
0.3388235569000244,
-0.08847375959157944,
-0.8174956440925598,
-0.562829852104187,
0.41088584065437317,
0.6896636486053467,
-0.169154092669487,
0.7115766406059265,
0.4143464267253876,
-0.3759549856185913,
-0.10518791526556015,
-0.010112246498465538,
-0.19380967319011688,
-0.49907639622688293,
0.44905900955200195,
-0.32903018593788147,
-0.5874338150024414,
0.46603643894195557,
0.2771115303039551,
-0.03355066850781441,
0.43959712982177734,
0.09993646293878555,
0.22187022864818573,
1.4261528253555298,
0.11014833301305771,
-0.17997229099273682,
0.7292959094047546,
-0.06474427133798599,
0.05707445740699768,
-0.6511257290840149,
-0.018251940608024597,
-0.7444944977760315,
0.06948471814393997,
-0.8312673568725586,
0.06580424308776855,
0.3080807626247406,
0.21709901094436646,
-0.3716318607330322,
0.557127058506012,
-0.5586071610450745,
0.3996026813983917,
0.8145051002502441,
0.20298464596271515,
-0.2084529846906662,
0.10626871138811111,
-0.1105448305606842,
0.2292180061340332,
-0.5642139315605164,
-0.31942689418792725,
1.1776518821716309,
0.042658817023038864,
0.9397118091583252,
0.5627870559692383,
0.3725110590457916,
0.5124292373657227,
0.34911873936653137,
-0.3705037832260132,
0.5655296444892883,
-0.2482401579618454,
-0.7852948307991028,
-0.2015153020620346,
-0.6076824069023132,
-1.1962896585464478,
0.14933915436267853,
0.09318266063928604,
-1.0014424324035645,
-0.15978498756885529,
0.16478978097438812,
-0.3485340178012848,
0.5913637280464172,
-1.0010920763015747,
0.8267621397972107,
-0.4350435435771942,
-0.41319653391838074,
0.2972603142261505,
-0.560426652431488,
0.719108521938324,
-0.019448740407824516,
0.025817451998591423,
0.2362896353006363,
0.3278679847717285,
0.39103689789772034,
-0.40094244480133057,
0.8186602592468262,
-0.5192117691040039,
-0.19418120384216309,
0.46805402636528015,
0.364597350358963,
0.8217239379882812,
0.0853293314576149,
-0.24958942830562592,
-0.23811979591846466,
-0.132846862077713,
-0.4984678030014038,
-0.8310878276824951,
0.7375001907348633,
-0.5649910569190979,
-0.9663061499595642,
-0.4087185859680176,
-0.3012537658214569,
-0.05073091387748718,
0.2092577964067459,
0.41555413603782654,
0.4252678453922272,
-0.12680566310882568,
0.06538131833076477,
0.6117175817489624,
-0.5559632182121277,
0.2993730306625366,
0.44494548439979553,
-0.1439436376094818,
-0.3148523271083832,
1.28130304813385,
-0.21998465061187744,
0.5659144520759583,
0.3141769468784332,
0.1386762410402298,
-0.4679253101348877,
-0.5795389413833618,
-0.6581982374191284,
-0.13158106803894043,
-0.6796591877937317,
-0.39001545310020447,
-0.29868900775909424,
-0.1855965256690979,
-0.6968298554420471,
-0.11750542372465134,
0.07741671800613403,
-0.5167642831802368,
-0.29047891497612,
-0.05193925276398659,
0.5402774214744568,
0.8146116733551025,
0.16534076631069183,
0.4145447015762329,
-0.8257485032081604,
0.1390388160943985,
0.47977614402770996,
0.07638021558523178,
-0.09982678294181824,
-0.4428631067276001,
0.21384823322296143,
0.24088770151138306,
-0.5800692439079285,
-1.2212395668029785,
0.23370565474033356,
-0.13068895041942596,
0.5451025366783142,
0.512313187122345,
0.4976285398006439,
0.2629694640636444,
-0.16549070179462433,
1.2294660806655884,
0.13899612426757812,
-0.6196463704109192,
0.8583628535270691,
-0.5970865488052368,
0.2083437442779541,
0.4618038237094879,
0.3915186822414398,
-0.25733861327171326,
-0.7526158690452576,
-0.827687680721283,
-0.6515223979949951,
0.8442695140838623,
0.3149803578853607,
0.03401054069399834,
-0.21586008369922638,
0.273202121257782,
0.0455043651163578,
0.05963537096977234,
-0.5709382891654968,
-0.5413368344306946,
-0.35300227999687195,
-0.06688492000102997,
0.1931775063276291,
-0.01793820597231388,
-0.24379491806030273,
0.3102070689201355,
0.8581960201263428,
-0.052794262766838074,
0.19177298247814178,
0.005246622022241354,
-0.0017882672837004066,
0.1200210377573967,
0.30373889207839966,
0.6792548298835754,
0.23640507459640503,
-0.11403465270996094,
0.19546812772750854,
0.01644332893192768,
-0.4030102789402008,
0.16910438239574432,
0.5214142203330994,
-0.6581313014030457,
-0.36700668931007385,
0.16247917711734772,
0.7842609286308289,
-0.18907515704631805,
-0.3019948899745941,
0.6201993823051453,
-0.5064124464988708,
0.033892955631017685,
0.05931119993329048,
0.31843966245651245,
-0.2154804915189743,
-0.10536811500787735,
0.26273098587989807,
0.3263232707977295,
0.26568618416786194,
-0.5271070003509521,
0.29174134135246277,
0.8481338620185852,
-0.6121737360954285,
-0.34971606731414795,
0.9594109654426575,
0.2337685227394104,
-0.3385337293148041,
0.426950067281723,
-0.3315563499927521,
-0.7236915230751038,
0.7521193623542786,
0.7868698239326477,
0.8225196003913879,
-0.40898486971855164,
0.236472025513649,
0.21568842232227325,
0.3652009665966034,
0.2009030431509018,
0.23532222211360931,
0.039117421954870224,
-0.297079861164093,
-0.06557754427194595,
-0.23766426742076874,
-0.48115864396095276,
0.375811368227005,
-0.7301649451255798,
0.04453757777810097,
-0.36580121517181396,
-0.09506102651357651,
-0.037587374448776245,
-0.22603993117809296,
-0.3345772325992584,
0.16583290696144104,
-0.031177595257759094,
0.5619838833808899,
-0.7182193398475647,
0.43258583545684814,
0.8979177474975586,
-0.4937216341495514,
-0.6859897971153259,
0.09055972099304199,
0.1076168492436409,
-0.8811734318733215,
0.42215391993522644,
-0.020207272842526436,
-0.03252479061484337,
-0.25471410155296326,
-0.5920515060424805,
-0.7671663761138916,
0.7976562976837158,
0.423954039812088,
-0.05505533888936043,
-0.07821375876665115,
-0.016191959381103516,
0.3623259961605072,
0.021388806402683258,
0.22490732371807098,
0.2549627721309662,
0.23800607025623322,
0.08882850408554077,
-0.46710991859436035,
0.5708112120628357,
-0.12471404671669006,
-0.251753032207489,
0.30469876527786255,
-0.47873011231422424,
0.7846705913543701,
-0.2006496638059616,
-0.40393877029418945,
0.14174054563045502,
0.619845449924469,
0.13421086966991425,
0.21513162553310394,
0.3986968994140625,
0.40390267968177795,
0.9961836934089661,
-0.15553176403045654,
1.4979299306869507,
-0.4577597677707672,
-0.04187960922718048,
0.9841787815093994,
-0.17931032180786133,
0.5521597266197205,
0.21261604130268097,
-0.2649746835231781,
0.19098304212093353,
0.5253333449363708,
-0.08418414741754532,
0.6326212286949158,
0.33620718121528625,
-0.48737072944641113,
0.1751278042793274,
-0.24685245752334595,
-0.6146283149719238,
0.24260656535625458,
0.3644636869430542,
-0.24762658774852753,
-0.2798931300640106,
0.25211551785469055,
0.2800142168998718,
0.08132689446210861,
-0.32142505049705505,
0.6985347867012024,
-0.14811144769191742,
-0.9719028472900391,
0.6662463545799255,
-0.13230520486831665,
0.6789929270744324,
-0.7490053772926331,
0.11174989491701126,
-0.0626557469367981,
0.06521641463041306,
-0.008593282662332058,
-0.6282879710197449,
0.2826019823551178,
0.08485303074121475,
0.08821669965982437,
-0.039077144116163254,
0.904163658618927,
-0.19641347229480743,
-0.3314864933490753,
-0.07076157629489899,
0.31887325644493103,
0.14351192116737366,
-0.07820932567119598,
-0.7525206208229065,
-0.43535152077674866,
0.32561829686164856,
-0.22768352925777435,
0.5411349534988403,
0.4791446030139923,
-0.05116109922528267,
0.5962756276130676,
0.8279519081115723,
0.37577053904533386,
0.14234356582164764,
0.14541929960250854,
0.7396469116210938,
-0.454411119222641,
-0.4975246489048004,
-0.8420527577400208,
0.010596141219139099,
-0.20232445001602173,
-0.1266317367553711,
0.8833544850349426,
0.340669184923172,
0.6929770112037659,
0.02649095095694065,
1.0748015642166138,
-0.12125029414892197,
0.3451679050922394,
-0.5922735333442688,
0.9866076111793518,
-0.4302695691585541,
0.5042418837547302,
-0.30299392342567444,
-0.40965673327445984,
-0.19143657386302948,
0.1398557871580124,
-0.39034202694892883,
0.058343518525362015,
0.7650777697563171,
0.8767156600952148,
0.11198267340660095,
0.23289410769939423,
0.15644149482250214,
0.04211565852165222,
0.7670122981071472,
0.7233936786651611,
1.000543475151062,
-0.5536426901817322,
1.0179648399353027,
-0.12051630020141602,
-0.12603871524333954,
-0.08010640740394592,
-0.904312789440155,
-0.8360831141471863,
-0.29928386211395264,
-0.289725661277771,
-0.7799506783485413,
0.3570960462093353,
0.42883047461509705,
0.5514808297157288,
-0.825556218624115,
0.25450456142425537,
-0.28510814905166626,
0.39279118180274963,
0.037822794169187546,
-0.34295105934143066,
0.5828704237937927,
-0.23080681264400482,
-0.6088332533836365,
0.5058509707450867,
-0.34481263160705566,
0.41339054703712463,
-0.1267087757587433,
0.2570447623729706,
-0.07728362828493118,
-0.020956149324774742,
0.2635306119918823,
0.6340841054916382,
-0.5593577027320862,
-0.48154976963996887,
-0.09253192692995071,
-0.2803237736225128,
-0.37825217843055725,
0.586970865726471,
-0.4909469187259674,
0.30867451429367065,
0.5032637119293213,
0.9069177508354187,
-0.08296061307191849,
0.3158969581127167,
0.8112480640411377,
-0.8591061234474182,
-0.03514629974961281,
0.15962480008602142,
0.35188400745391846,
0.37204989790916443,
-0.8209975361824036,
0.28233543038368225,
0.1635396033525467,
-0.47458192706108093,
-0.7836156487464905,
0.5214468836784363,
-0.7478240132331848,
-0.5417987704277039,
1.2116390466690063,
-0.4417901933193207,
-0.4433456361293793,
0.010525163263082504,
-0.35353758931159973,
0.21539215743541718,
-0.6636713147163391,
0.6866793036460876,
0.5236068964004517,
-0.27408984303474426,
0.3572376072406769,
-0.53204745054245,
0.7578540444374084,
0.3581094443798065,
-0.9497511386871338,
0.12286641448736191,
0.3745674192905426,
0.2102721929550171,
0.20440451800823212,
0.13599766790866852,
-0.22199015319347382,
0.48278093338012695,
0.15307432413101196,
-0.4773887097835541,
-0.4437754452228546,
-0.04558277130126953,
-0.3889389932155609,
0.5110709071159363,
0.0714559480547905,
-0.5013507008552551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12327v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12327v2 | Shall We Team Up: Exploring Spontaneous Cooperation of Competing LLM Agents | 2024-02-19T18:00:53 | 2024-07-02T17:56:09 | Zengqing Wu, Run Peng, Shuyuan Zheng, Qianying Liu, Xu Han, Brian Inhyuk Kwon, Makoto Onizuka, Shaojie Tang, Chuan Xiao | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.MA, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | Large Language Models (LLMs) have increasingly been utilized in social
simulations, where they are often guided by carefully crafted instructions to
stably exhibit human-like behaviors during simulations. Nevertheless, we doubt
the necessity of shaping agents' behaviors for accurate social simulations.
Instead, this paper emphasizes the importance of spontaneous phenomena, wherein
agents deeply engage in contexts and make adaptive decisions without explicit
directions. We explored spontaneous cooperation across three competitive
scenarios and successfully simulated the gradual emergence of cooperation,
findings that align closely with human behavioral data. This approach not only
aids the computational social science community in bridging the gap between
simulations and real-world dynamics but also offers the AI community a novel
method to assess LLMs' capability of deliberate reasoning. | [
-0.2912639081478119,
-0.8376968502998352,
0.7892892956733704,
0.6115334033966064,
-0.030224457383155823,
0.5929058194160461,
-0.3466038703918457,
-0.5797405242919922,
0.43304625153541565,
0.2658652663230896,
-0.7791119813919067,
0.03831515461206436,
-0.2131798267364502,
0.28496265411376953,
-0.07126486301422119,
0.364874929189682,
0.21972844004631042,
0.13569612801074982,
-0.364234060049057,
-0.06580616533756256,
-0.5441513657569885,
-0.6368891000747681,
-0.9310245513916016,
-0.6568478941917419,
0.6654532551765442,
0.5258930921554565,
0.7040231227874756,
0.11187613010406494,
0.2512354552745819,
0.5713338851928711,
0.11666245758533478,
0.39323893189430237,
-0.6236150860786438,
0.5727099776268005,
-0.231694296002388,
-0.5440685153007507,
-0.32251232862472534,
0.4361862540245056,
0.5734416842460632,
0.7816393971443176,
-0.34395259618759155,
-0.27540990710258484,
0.1258801966905594,
0.426866352558136,
-0.0013329207431524992,
0.15554645657539368,
-0.8154767751693726,
0.09443212300539017,
-0.008719578385353088,
-0.2001684606075287,
-0.21680136024951935,
-0.2670307457447052,
0.18607202172279358,
-0.6789321303367615,
0.1875396966934204,
0.3109915852546692,
0.5890193581581116,
0.0857238620519638,
-0.35340625047683716,
-0.23360292613506317,
-0.936733067035675,
0.616675853729248,
-0.3188304603099823,
-0.04648381844162941,
0.31715118885040283,
0.28585708141326904,
-0.9072641134262085,
-0.8347324132919312,
-0.8389309048652649,
-0.4541257321834564,
0.27804434299468994,
0.328061044216156,
0.05017167329788208,
-0.008836778812110424,
-0.04100043326616287,
-0.0877593383193016,
-0.3419205844402313,
0.2773781418800354,
-0.23917312920093536,
-0.09389390796422958,
1.0114246606826782,
0.4602227807044983,
0.4467034935951233,
0.46096163988113403,
-0.4518502652645111,
0.052307963371276855,
-0.3367463946342468,
0.11481370776891708,
0.06087259203195572,
0.33815470337867737,
-0.3303746283054352,
0.5672754049301147,
0.06468208134174347,
0.3749263882637024,
0.23833394050598145,
0.2734321653842926,
-0.21708059310913086,
-0.45184510946273804,
-0.3762848675251007,
0.06591667979955673,
0.7773576378822327,
0.5481612086296082,
0.29975324869155884,
-0.4198862910270691,
-0.18487314879894257,
0.4020436406135559,
0.20729634165763855,
-0.20063531398773193,
0.024709518998861313,
0.02332357130944729,
-0.21152548491954803,
-0.5669054388999939,
-0.046415604650974274,
-0.5552608966827393,
-0.4461187422275543,
-0.4079042077064514,
0.3937903046607971,
0.06213346868753433,
-0.3065469563007355,
-0.09404006600379944,
-0.35381171107292175,
0.34269654750823975,
0.6206609010696411,
-0.5529836416244507,
0.5098803639411926,
0.8073722720146179,
0.8022810816764832,
-0.19120964407920837,
-0.8429241180419922,
-0.4359253942966461,
0.1097574457526207,
-0.5818328261375427,
0.7504775524139404,
-0.23163862526416779,
-0.5642264485359192,
-0.0896090716123581,
-0.07650730758905411,
-0.06617693603038788,
-0.27541399002075195,
0.2719460427761078,
-0.5928764343261719,
-0.04767056554555893,
-0.6546632647514343,
-0.559382438659668,
0.25139695405960083,
0.40670961141586304,
-0.641273021697998,
0.7728382349014282,
-0.021035565063357353,
-0.5392888784408569,
0.5279040336608887,
-0.4663471579551697,
-0.3583325743675232,
0.46364331245422363,
-0.3846932351589203,
0.061941422522068024,
-0.0009707212448120117,
-0.3901272416114807,
0.5016845464706421,
-0.2051859200000763,
0.21809569001197815,
-0.6823347806930542,
-0.36790481209754944,
0.850568950176239,
-0.11015824228525162,
0.7888603210449219,
0.0838952511548996,
-0.17119967937469482,
0.31858715415000916,
0.01026742160320282,
-0.2798370122909546,
0.28447794914245605,
-0.06381908804178238,
-0.29715317487716675,
0.2327001541852951,
-0.32416000962257385,
0.36555540561676025,
0.16978363692760468,
-0.17122866213321686,
0.6187137365341187,
-0.18258854746818542,
0.45759159326553345,
1.0907655954360962,
0.18321079015731812,
0.8779141306877136,
-0.8382633924484253,
0.5075908899307251,
-0.3497862219810486,
0.21053478121757507,
0.4429799020290375,
-0.7453100085258484,
-0.5974275469779968,
-0.1708552986383438,
-0.07654976844787598,
0.4946982264518738,
-0.8969195485115051,
0.15616318583488464,
0.03948543220758438,
-0.3732089102268219,
-0.07194685190916061,
0.08999881893396378,
0.050358254462480545,
0.12021379172801971,
-0.11406393349170685,
-0.21615061163902283,
-0.6693763732910156,
-0.3748059868812561,
-0.11511056125164032,
-0.24562673270702362,
0.07024717330932617,
0.47292622923851013,
0.24477005004882812,
-0.2793818712234497,
1.0059926509857178,
-0.010117970407009125,
-0.25676339864730835,
-0.6862725615501404,
0.21798844635486603,
-0.0050188591703772545,
0.3565513789653778,
0.5020079612731934,
-0.713081419467926,
-0.5372792482376099,
-0.09811607003211975,
-1.0101245641708374,
0.042204536497592926,
-0.26721060276031494,
-0.35233673453330994,
0.2987552285194397,
0.6753690242767334,
-0.5538941621780396,
0.14874474704265594,
0.709644615650177,
-0.6199321746826172,
0.5572454333305359,
-0.3555437922477722,
0.2621350884437561,
-0.9848648905754089,
-0.4120304584503174,
-0.09027738124132156,
-0.15589185059070587,
-0.7122744917869568,
-0.07209593057632446,
-0.4540110230445862,
0.18155308067798615,
-0.2620850205421448,
0.6467300653457642,
-0.7457120418548584,
-0.1321972906589508,
-0.15646398067474365,
0.40261951088905334,
-0.33942002058029175,
0.13564372062683105,
0.05984775349497795,
0.7426127195358276,
0.6623023748397827,
-0.5952016115188599,
0.6129717826843262,
-0.11063794046640396,
-0.09123839437961578,
0.40160709619522095,
-0.6272759437561035,
0.26963454484939575,
0.15227891504764557,
0.6082871556282043,
-0.814698338508606,
-0.6953011751174927,
0.1707811951637268,
-0.48296040296554565,
0.04118656367063522,
0.06148483604192734,
-0.7220538258552551,
-0.3692914545536041,
-0.2764240503311157,
0.3696571886539459,
0.465770959854126,
-0.19617609679698944,
0.6218063235282898,
0.5988842844963074,
-0.016342666000127792,
-0.18032468855381012,
-0.5777943730354309,
0.2836419641971588,
-0.25746971368789673,
-0.9440822601318359,
0.3364335894584656,
-0.3099331259727478,
-0.868829071521759,
-0.06412076950073242,
0.20068761706352234,
-0.16219936311244965,
0.2734680771827698,
0.44757503271102905,
0.4377760887145996,
0.09889867156744003,
-0.26063627004623413,
-0.1529621183872223,
0.311749666929245,
0.028923485428094864,
-0.07402745634317398,
0.6343666315078735,
-0.07441440224647522,
-0.14706549048423767,
-0.2975955605506897,
0.25408846139907837,
0.5934792757034302,
0.2522704005241394,
0.9825038909912109,
0.18725116550922394,
-0.37527331709861755,
-0.3581840395927429,
-0.5822036266326904,
-0.23271870613098145,
-0.5983200669288635,
-0.053846586495637894,
-0.027885401621460915,
-1.0804437398910522,
0.8128153085708618,
-0.07698007673025131,
-0.03854961320757866,
-0.2677006721496582,
0.6169775128364563,
-0.3151018023490906,
0.9143410921096802,
0.6765261292457581,
-0.2605969309806824,
0.15867497026920319,
0.24279341101646423,
-0.11917240917682648,
-0.3367437720298767,
-0.45312827825546265,
-0.3517278730869293,
-0.3621017038822174,
-0.5998131632804871,
-0.8423720598220825,
0.4978371560573578,
0.1724957823753357,
0.08440227806568146,
0.11214220523834229,
-0.11187247186899185,
0.7264001965522766,
0.1542186737060547,
0.06317503750324249,
0.09135890752077103,
-0.2721864581108093,
-0.23212489485740662,
-0.028310149908065796,
-0.8942064046859741,
-0.1875791847705841,
0.6290479898452759,
-0.09761307388544083,
0.4214647710323334,
0.16667288541793823,
0.8282700777053833,
0.549945056438446,
0.5789849162101746,
-0.5733955502510071,
0.8556127548217773,
0.5126598477363586,
-0.4870293140411377,
-0.44624853134155273,
-0.42741528153419495,
-1.388322114944458,
0.08480489253997803,
-0.546442449092865,
-0.7295225262641907,
-0.08961750566959381,
-0.10896263271570206,
-0.37735700607299805,
0.1541975736618042,
-0.4261866509914398,
0.4971640706062317,
-0.1453210413455963,
-0.6031097173690796,
-0.36107614636421204,
-0.6086891889572144,
0.6269999742507935,
-0.02440328523516655,
0.5731238126754761,
-0.07756417989730835,
-0.2081640213727951,
0.4751006066799164,
-0.17439094185829163,
0.9804971814155579,
0.16670666635036469,
-0.06879398226737976,
0.43310731649398804,
0.4636649191379547,
0.611749529838562,
0.2893331050872803,
-0.12321312725543976,
-0.06744103878736496,
-0.4054524302482605,
-0.49467262625694275,
-0.5207735896110535,
0.7971891164779663,
-0.7757278680801392,
-0.6103242635726929,
-0.5567494034767151,
-0.5147519111633301,
-0.15101143717765808,
-0.05615842342376709,
0.023660022765398026,
0.11630092561244965,
-0.6353535056114197,
-0.13880710303783417,
0.49742254614830017,
0.0642038881778717,
0.614826500415802,
0.5712941884994507,
-0.2971944212913513,
-0.2489643543958664,
0.740744948387146,
-0.13300107419490814,
0.30658039450645447,
-0.13971588015556335,
0.100592240691185,
-0.034839726984500885,
-0.32359814643859863,
0.05617733672261238,
0.2721171975135803,
-0.2800564169883728,
-0.0463411770761013,
-0.23430629074573517,
0.06709903478622437,
-0.4252021908760071,
-0.7295843958854675,
-0.1699598878622055,
-0.08915028721094131,
-0.08048687130212784,
0.03085392713546753,
0.1239720955491066,
1.070749044418335,
-0.43172264099121094,
-0.08693715929985046,
-0.9062457084655762,
0.019392812624573708,
0.6300172805786133,
-0.009406992234289646,
0.07283834367990494,
-0.15225757658481598,
0.05337899923324585,
-0.025303050875663757,
0.14577704668045044,
-1.1484671831130981,
0.4027807116508484,
-0.16079886257648468,
0.8760219812393188,
0.14732494950294495,
0.15670569241046906,
0.4322901666164398,
-0.31340599060058594,
0.9173585772514343,
0.04274284839630127,
-0.8151400685310364,
0.3409992456436157,
-0.732852578163147,
0.0009280852973461151,
0.4319530129432678,
0.4222021996974945,
-0.48935794830322266,
-0.3575803339481354,
-0.6797636151313782,
-0.7154728770256042,
0.6694397926330566,
0.521401584148407,
0.054928530007600784,
0.010630381293594837,
0.4052155017852783,
-0.35387665033340454,
-0.15408670902252197,
-0.579292893409729,
-0.14854121208190918,
0.5072989463806152,
0.3242754340171814,
-0.1546664535999298,
0.08090423047542572,
-0.5758843421936035,
-0.22562308609485626,
0.2186090499162674,
0.13079014420509338,
0.15323741734027863,
0.28284573554992676,
0.04163357615470886,
-0.5033020973205566,
-0.11294953525066376,
0.7632670402526855,
0.3523610234260559,
0.15324077010154724,
0.04394948482513428,
0.46275442838668823,
-0.2046775072813034,
0.21573416888713837,
-0.19959072768688202,
0.3552643060684204,
-0.3815426826477051,
0.4328910708427429,
0.2002125233411789,
0.31243231892585754,
-0.6398011445999146,
0.5075480937957764,
-0.6136781573295593,
-0.4742067754268646,
-0.4475221633911133,
0.18657450377941132,
0.3831385374069214,
0.6972185373306274,
0.4368848204612732,
0.25375184416770935,
-0.3089117109775543,
-0.9227834939956665,
0.40214091539382935,
0.5291224718093872,
-0.08053021132946014,
-0.5442436337471008,
0.2761789560317993,
0.6121739745140076,
-0.7684066891670227,
0.47389721870422363,
-0.7033231258392334,
-0.7825266122817993,
0.8613463640213013,
0.3093831241130829,
0.8001095056533813,
-0.20367836952209473,
0.10845156013965607,
0.06482870876789093,
0.3145538866519928,
-0.4511066973209381,
-0.01029878854751587,
-0.26027750968933105,
-1.104409098625183,
-0.3859913945198059,
-0.44710421562194824,
-0.6299003958702087,
-0.18912377953529358,
-0.2820163369178772,
0.22088393568992615,
-0.4949952960014343,
-0.03012942709028721,
-0.20044001936912537,
0.25724896788597107,
-0.6370277404785156,
-0.33735209703445435,
0.380617618560791,
0.7319504022598267,
-0.8001168966293335,
1.0361768007278442,
0.7064031362533569,
-0.23530980944633484,
-1.0612167119979858,
0.07701200246810913,
0.21999004483222961,
-0.6312662959098816,
0.7028312683105469,
-0.02660120092332363,
-0.28026872873306274,
0.06291420012712479,
-1.0679551362991333,
-0.5316272974014282,
1.357772946357727,
-0.004970291163772345,
-0.5684313178062439,
-0.13107344508171082,
-0.14142177999019623,
0.3961038291454315,
-0.3463952839374542,
-0.03851800411939621,
0.3684306740760803,
0.44963914155960083,
0.2216111421585083,
-1.0794165134429932,
0.3274593949317932,
-0.22315993905067444,
-0.23759035766124725,
-0.16421301662921906,
-1.0104782581329346,
0.8297930955886841,
-0.32762113213539124,
-0.13641619682312012,
0.18018043041229248,
0.8414517641067505,
0.6621080040931702,
0.5472615957260132,
0.6428225636482239,
0.11857511848211288,
0.7297922968864441,
0.12295038998126984,
0.7106977701187134,
-0.040545281022787094,
0.22290053963661194,
0.7858763337135315,
-1.0484734773635864,
0.42304396629333496,
0.3454928398132324,
-0.29131120443344116,
0.34291595220565796,
0.4966687262058258,
0.0943002849817276,
0.03018082305788994,
0.24509510397911072,
-0.6745603680610657,
-0.7103350162506104,
-0.07902485132217407,
-0.1110026016831398,
0.49741634726524353,
0.5197206735610962,
0.22793006896972656,
0.0007927805418148637,
-0.27198299765586853,
-0.13777805864810944,
0.2665857672691345,
-0.19600193202495575,
0.7250477075576782,
0.2000666856765747,
-0.9117724299430847,
0.0004311800003051758,
-0.2901252806186676,
0.9774280786514282,
-0.3791520297527313,
-0.10976585000753403,
-0.3863339424133301,
-0.06586722284555435,
-0.07722393423318863,
-0.6678359508514404,
0.048930492252111435,
-0.16395513713359833,
0.05286207050085068,
-0.09128658473491669,
0.7237553596496582,
-0.31918615102767944,
-0.12232325971126556,
0.5874252915382385,
0.5997864007949829,
0.04136442393064499,
0.2665531039237976,
-0.7104992866516113,
0.2322317659854889,
-0.33748775720596313,
-0.13098669052124023,
0.7418145537376404,
0.7489870190620422,
-0.08660083264112473,
0.7462680339813232,
0.9414394497871399,
0.1580771952867508,
0.0021137550938874483,
0.03167954832315445,
1.026276707649231,
-0.5448833703994751,
-0.39244621992111206,
-0.9433406591415405,
0.32177573442459106,
-0.38880664110183716,
0.06529700756072998,
0.8038854598999023,
0.13085904717445374,
0.6246311068534851,
0.2703413665294647,
0.5524948835372925,
-0.10470448434352875,
0.024089308455586433,
-0.3413628041744232,
0.8547559976577759,
-0.4551249146461487,
0.2492433488368988,
-0.24708981812000275,
-0.6951753497123718,
-0.2632104754447937,
0.3963242173194885,
0.21850168704986572,
-0.022676873952150345,
0.43008214235305786,
0.8062773942947388,
0.21667809784412384,
-0.0018523186445236206,
0.4878891110420227,
0.16824236512184143,
0.12922419607639313,
0.4352788031101227,
1.331555962562561,
0.24649016559123993,
0.30220165848731995,
-0.014398062601685524,
-0.5273705720901489,
-0.1468534767627716,
-0.9581254124641418,
-1.04355788230896,
-0.3772960305213928,
-0.08829929679632187,
-0.5346369743347168,
0.1180795431137085,
1.555449366569519,
0.4865090250968933,
-0.19498448073863983,
-0.6424748301506042,
-0.3615683913230896,
0.2288595736026764,
-0.07565108686685562,
-0.28024017810821533,
-0.5021109580993652,
-0.45724502205848694,
-0.6227930784225464,
0.8099197149276733,
0.1740986853837967,
0.25987184047698975,
-0.3247717022895813,
-0.4882170557975769,
-0.3204936385154724,
0.48625892400741577,
0.449314683675766,
0.5469408631324768,
-0.41551461815834045,
0.08082865178585052,
0.13176849484443665,
-0.38096049427986145,
-0.4125240445137024,
1.1154873371124268,
-0.7051599621772766,
0.1178780347108841,
0.5919672846794128,
0.23456330597400665,
0.20210805535316467,
-0.12704937160015106,
0.9832941293716431,
-0.6156840920448303,
0.4183630347251892,
0.3937951922416687,
0.19654721021652222,
0.09052027016878128,
-0.24098265171051025,
0.40420371294021606,
0.5306405425071716,
-1.0062339305877686,
-1.0754799842834473,
0.03773687407374382,
-1.1440635919570923,
-0.2886795997619629,
1.1504695415496826,
-0.3073979914188385,
-0.23623427748680115,
-0.28335151076316833,
-0.12649452686309814,
0.45338916778564453,
-0.5670822858810425,
0.9322970509529114,
0.73816978931427,
-0.5282565951347351,
0.11448788642883301,
-0.394733726978302,
0.5897723436355591,
0.31200629472732544,
-0.6408306360244751,
-0.15365388989448547,
0.3800996243953705,
0.017919126898050308,
-0.007412952836602926,
0.9620545506477356,
0.5755443572998047,
0.18512313067913055,
0.10534278303384781,
-0.4003419876098633,
0.18197514116764069,
-0.2731257379055023,
-0.2877553105354309,
-0.1419965624809265,
0.4161815643310547,
0.3563334345817566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12326v1 | LLM Agents for Psychology: A Study on Gamified Assessments | 2024-02-19T18:00:30 | 2024-02-19T18:00:30 | Qisen Yang, Zekun Wang, Honghui Chen, Shenzhi Wang, Yifan Pu, Xin Gao, Wenhao Huang, Shiji Song, Gao Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG, cs.MA | Psychological measurement is essential for mental health, self-understanding,
and personal development. Traditional methods, such as self-report scales and
psychologist interviews, often face challenges with engagement and
accessibility. While game-based and LLM-based tools have been explored to
improve user interest and automate assessment, they struggle to balance
engagement with generalizability. In this work, we propose PsychoGAT
(Psychological Game AgenTs) to achieve a generic gamification of psychological
assessment. The main insight is that powerful LLMs can function both as adept
psychologists and innovative game designers. By incorporating LLM agents into
designated roles and carefully managing their interactions, PsychoGAT can
transform any standardized scales into personalized and engaging interactive
fiction games. To validate the proposed method, we conduct psychometric
evaluations to assess its effectiveness and employ human evaluators to examine
the generated content across various psychological constructs, including
depression, cognitive distortions, and personality traits. Results demonstrate
that PsychoGAT serves as an effective assessment tool, achieving statistically
significant excellence in psychometric metrics such as reliability, convergent
validity, and discriminant validity. Moreover, human evaluations confirm
PsychoGAT's enhancements in content coherence, interactivity, interest,
immersion, and satisfaction. | [
-0.6522185802459717,
-0.7586725354194641,
0.7607553005218506,
0.7389428615570068,
0.026448316872119904,
0.6078019142150879,
-0.28503960371017456,
-0.26913830637931824,
0.40481656789779663,
-0.005885764956474304,
-0.811623752117157,
-0.37130507826805115,
-0.26770055294036865,
0.20375820994377136,
0.07057994604110718,
0.9643293023109436,
0.011995446868240833,
0.16089250147342682,
-0.5530768632888794,
0.09006743133068085,
-0.48011112213134766,
-0.48453840613365173,
-0.5335697531700134,
-0.8355229496955872,
0.6452926993370056,
0.004621561616659164,
0.7525914311408997,
0.03152259439229965,
0.6557936668395996,
0.25513094663619995,
0.20902201533317566,
0.31884220242500305,
-0.6480740904808044,
0.23384220898151398,
-0.38907554745674133,
-0.4918515086174011,
-0.65121990442276,
0.4205077588558197,
-0.07102574408054352,
0.03030768409371376,
-0.4353751242160797,
0.5481611490249634,
0.04278438165783882,
0.10588507354259491,
-0.6219692230224609,
0.1350623220205307,
0.21989597380161285,
0.30228886008262634,
0.31027135252952576,
-0.3793163299560547,
-0.22160476446151733,
-0.7009524703025818,
-0.3314622938632965,
-0.5300383567810059,
0.1302458792924881,
-0.17961835861206055,
0.6008572578430176,
0.10817690193653107,
-0.2463098168373108,
-0.5174357891082764,
-0.9943898916244507,
0.4823514521121979,
-0.4827311933040619,
-0.1361628919839859,
0.4888327419757843,
0.38851943612098694,
-0.3764510154724121,
-0.2537730038166046,
-0.40869975090026855,
-0.5344599485397339,
0.11026515811681747,
0.5090683698654175,
-0.2104903608560562,
0.2731792628765106,
0.05652890354394913,
0.3846357762813568,
-0.5564157962799072,
0.169138565659523,
-0.07079549878835678,
-0.2584306299686432,
1.218332052230835,
0.8903625011444092,
0.5413222908973694,
0.23042014241218567,
-0.264741450548172,
0.17320072650909424,
-0.24385739862918854,
0.21669593453407288,
0.47079160809516907,
-0.17144468426704407,
-0.24242885410785675,
0.41557180881500244,
-0.06435544043779373,
0.21180057525634766,
0.5052598118782043,
-0.510563313961029,
0.11776178330183029,
-0.12976548075675964,
-0.024842791259288788,
-0.2837021052837372,
0.8318684101104736,
0.7319738864898682,
0.15354880690574646,
-0.3835597038269043,
-0.13845127820968628,
0.4406495988368988,
0.5302198529243469,
-0.6639087796211243,
-0.4827687740325928,
0.6808843016624451,
-0.3037395775318146,
-0.4760415852069855,
-0.14687791466712952,
-0.9889875054359436,
-0.8223161697387695,
-0.1257951259613037,
0.4734397530555725,
-0.30713334679603577,
-0.24789007008075714,
0.13256891071796417,
-0.08267832547426224,
0.333975613117218,
0.4659903943538666,
-0.9941660165786743,
0.24623452126979828,
0.6491937041282654,
0.8666405081748962,
-0.34392839670181274,
-0.28053322434425354,
-0.20866887271404266,
-0.118953637778759,
-0.5943935513496399,
0.9039789438247681,
-0.269241064786911,
-0.6295536756515503,
-0.01388811320066452,
-0.3351219892501831,
0.43889960646629333,
-0.4405897855758667,
0.13511057198047638,
-0.0677490308880806,
0.2604026198387146,
-0.13722838461399078,
-0.36264345049858093,
-0.14323210716247559,
0.7345825433731079,
-0.13583678007125854,
1.0217753648757935,
0.3837209641933441,
0.0702509805560112,
0.4567887783050537,
-0.7945626378059387,
-0.1443241834640503,
0.5475732088088989,
-0.22022180259227753,
0.10758931934833527,
0.6048316359519958,
0.09510903805494308,
0.3252517282962799,
-0.3938373029232025,
0.09437596052885056,
-0.39741384983062744,
-0.8315425515174866,
0.617084264755249,
-0.1350673884153366,
0.777604341506958,
0.20740556716918945,
-0.23758526146411896,
0.18079042434692383,
-0.47518986463546753,
0.33016470074653625,
-0.020995670929551125,
-0.27383941411972046,
-0.06015770509839058,
0.024452554062008858,
-0.05759868398308754,
0.3349214196205139,
0.10250723361968994,
-0.5092864036560059,
0.32923418283462524,
0.11249502003192902,
0.010294719599187374,
0.7994102239608765,
0.2825770676136017,
0.2738901972770691,
-0.46548953652381897,
1.2897422313690186,
-0.5679954290390015,
0.4496017098426819,
0.4949328303337097,
-0.5698410272598267,
-0.3002719283103943,
-0.9622378945350647,
0.07776513695716858,
0.6244249939918518,
-0.3062184453010559,
0.901025652885437,
0.0339030958712101,
-1.012070655822754,
-0.4010801315307617,
0.22797557711601257,
0.1358283907175064,
0.209762305021286,
-0.18135660886764526,
-0.6932217478752136,
-0.307878315448761,
-0.23414984345436096,
-0.17345190048217773,
-0.39723387360572815,
-0.4840354919433594,
0.18679659068584442,
0.3803262412548065,
-0.5495632290840149,
1.0120186805725098,
-0.442209392786026,
-0.6461251378059387,
-0.12419961392879486,
0.4501902163028717,
0.12261074781417847,
0.06352302432060242,
0.5429147481918335,
-0.3122352957725525,
-0.29512181878089905,
-0.2411486804485321,
-1.280782699584961,
-0.48138490319252014,
-0.27070966362953186,
0.020751066505908966,
-0.6000560522079468,
0.02277674339711666,
-0.5075446963310242,
0.3841520845890045,
0.31445878744125366,
-0.5706914067268372,
0.9658477306365967,
-0.39032772183418274,
0.3832412660121918,
-0.09307245910167694,
-0.20577093958854675,
-0.028835412114858627,
-0.20560356974601746,
-0.6750957369804382,
0.4852393865585327,
-0.0917348563671112,
-0.13624288141727448,
-0.3936867117881775,
0.5738252401351929,
-0.3873039484024048,
0.21653108298778534,
-0.3353886008262634,
0.26729780435562134,
-0.16266562044620514,
0.5513190031051636,
-0.281980961561203,
0.7748265266418457,
0.47101855278015137,
-0.6042671203613281,
0.8377854228019714,
0.2088679075241089,
-0.20859676599502563,
1.1391966342926025,
-0.4115120470523834,
0.3711710572242737,
-0.05586167797446251,
0.1674305945634842,
-1.0494393110275269,
0.022269466891884804,
0.5589565634727478,
-0.6812663078308105,
-0.41728901863098145,
0.616019606590271,
-0.6098900437355042,
-0.3689878582954407,
-0.5685277581214905,
-0.05822678282856941,
0.7078951001167297,
-0.19731058180332184,
0.904365599155426,
0.23206186294555664,
-0.04778299853205681,
-0.10098619014024734,
-0.6613810062408447,
0.24314408004283905,
-0.649935245513916,
-0.39672550559043884,
-0.08836637437343597,
-0.38900840282440186,
-0.34367355704307556,
-0.2192370444536209,
0.09439994394779205,
0.10091055929660797,
0.17684487998485565,
0.45222747325897217,
0.28179609775543213,
0.00580791337415576,
0.1765621453523636,
-0.3290553390979767,
-0.11192809045314789,
0.6413062810897827,
0.463175892829895,
0.6346919536590576,
-0.3168802261352539,
-0.23251135647296906,
-0.18846239149570465,
0.22965393960475922,
0.32621753215789795,
-0.3137829303741455,
0.22033844888210297,
1.1403439044952393,
-0.2875054180622101,
0.06806893646717072,
-0.7112250328063965,
0.03272236883640289,
-0.480585515499115,
0.29224929213523865,
-0.4196047782897949,
-0.7715479135513306,
0.809787929058075,
-0.20648667216300964,
-0.11580485105514526,
-0.15830446779727936,
1.0646284818649292,
-0.3676513433456421,
1.2433463335037231,
0.3733704090118408,
-0.020723378285765648,
0.09204614907503128,
-0.00965769961476326,
0.37680524587631226,
-0.8744145631790161,
-0.3259098529815674,
-0.10833289474248886,
-0.7129731178283691,
-0.3504224419593811,
-0.3458101749420166,
0.30773529410362244,
-0.17823097109794617,
-0.41297632455825806,
-0.3623604476451874,
-0.6310323476791382,
0.39524826407432556,
0.21652568876743317,
0.34838664531707764,
0.36615532636642456,
0.011991248466074467,
-0.09277674555778503,
-0.30915266275405884,
0.039849717170000076,
-0.48055022954940796,
1.014175534248352,
0.25584402680397034,
1.1271716356277466,
0.41666868329048157,
1.0574244260787964,
0.8863579034805298,
0.9037889838218689,
-1.029025912284851,
0.6150273084640503,
0.558168351650238,
-0.8901516199111938,
-0.2568720579147339,
-0.12138114869594574,
-0.5828564167022705,
0.39753368496894836,
-0.2239546924829483,
-1.3322781324386597,
0.3251694142818451,
-0.29806527495384216,
-0.6457634568214417,
-0.08417665958404541,
-0.5452804565429688,
0.3495023846626282,
-0.6464065313339233,
-0.5322375297546387,
-0.31587377190589905,
-0.1186424046754837,
0.44571971893310547,
-0.16669973731040955,
0.06335843354463577,
-0.3842388391494751,
-0.3148488998413086,
0.6109382510185242,
-0.10826452821493149,
0.4534602165222168,
-0.2851009964942932,
-0.27242550253868103,
0.3406084179878235,
0.6166526079177856,
0.056668687611818314,
0.42296022176742554,
0.027126874774694443,
-0.04591171443462372,
0.09170923382043839,
-0.34309640526771545,
-1.2325035333633423,
0.26928025484085083,
-0.8586530685424805,
-0.7760992646217346,
-0.8223300576210022,
-0.822538435459137,
-0.5854259729385376,
-0.0772828534245491,
-0.056391630321741104,
-0.1842830926179886,
-0.621895968914032,
-0.11976293474435806,
0.2861258387565613,
-0.061203956604003906,
-0.03290925547480583,
0.6398452520370483,
-0.6174278855323792,
-0.45045796036720276,
0.8643742203712463,
-0.40697741508483887,
0.00231372588314116,
-0.11931824684143066,
0.2578287422657013,
-0.3123740255832672,
-0.20118308067321777,
0.13701096177101135,
0.17059525847434998,
-0.40941011905670166,
0.005093082785606384,
-0.012001206167042255,
0.14214545488357544,
-0.24005408585071564,
-0.3621630370616913,
0.12254707515239716,
0.25606536865234375,
-0.12055972218513489,
-0.44266998767852783,
0.18805845081806183,
0.7620673179626465,
-0.6495967507362366,
0.5466022491455078,
-0.21001961827278137,
0.35029861330986023,
0.1980176866054535,
0.15256290137767792,
0.09596699476242065,
-0.20348943769931793,
0.010995868593454361,
-0.020163720473647118,
-0.6374546885490417,
-0.9907385110855103,
0.4342058300971985,
0.060488756746053696,
0.394172728061676,
0.8466594815254211,
-0.23030255734920502,
0.7872603535652161,
-0.08408714085817337,
0.9778234958648682,
0.4835872948169708,
-0.7282339930534363,
0.20356318354606628,
-0.42106080055236816,
0.12382762134075165,
0.6655746102333069,
0.47961801290512085,
-0.6567262411117554,
-0.46502935886383057,
-0.3805737793445587,
-0.24508263170719147,
0.42635321617126465,
-0.030795292928814888,
0.30981096625328064,
-0.04834188148379326,
0.36764687299728394,
0.02020968124270439,
0.2747252881526947,
-0.501196563243866,
-0.3092953562736511,
0.14977577328681946,
-0.1860683560371399,
-0.6512264609336853,
-0.23382733762264252,
-0.3202984035015106,
-0.33521297574043274,
0.3762756586074829,
0.1436551958322525,
0.6916217803955078,
0.17921306192874908,
0.012349297292530537,
-0.03556787967681885,
0.2691640853881836,
0.3653644323348999,
0.8476063013076782,
-0.6807366609573364,
0.05020156130194664,
0.04183714836835861,
-0.8095259666442871,
1.1787123680114746,
-0.1495189219713211,
0.0034128434490412474,
-0.2869708836078644,
0.07543708384037018,
-0.07486999779939651,
-0.2470434457063675,
-0.8487144112586975,
0.33859628438949585,
-0.31463271379470825,
-0.29375889897346497,
-0.2277894914150238,
0.3233156204223633,
0.14489001035690308,
0.4936582148075104,
0.32820260524749756,
-0.376921683549881,
0.20149822533130646,
-0.7734658122062683,
0.13115529716014862,
0.1850474774837494,
-0.4959432780742645,
-0.14778360724449158,
0.5465975999832153,
0.1208483874797821,
-0.8483660221099854,
0.6651752591133118,
-0.6957976818084717,
-0.22900515794754028,
0.48899054527282715,
0.45355862379074097,
0.9976099729537964,
-0.29662761092185974,
0.9885750412940979,
-0.07195045053958893,
0.4584790766239166,
0.1051185131072998,
0.513325035572052,
-0.03879258781671524,
-0.6418599486351013,
-0.06180277094244957,
-0.23574621975421906,
-0.6625367999076843,
0.2274412363767624,
-0.5926114320755005,
-0.06497673690319061,
-0.7423127889633179,
-0.679133951663971,
-0.5705010294914246,
0.42888322472572327,
-0.8219850659370422,
0.3519056737422943,
0.20963986217975616,
0.5461027026176453,
-0.9389667510986328,
0.10247070342302322,
0.8141003847122192,
-0.7815985679626465,
-0.5745898485183716,
-0.2914315164089203,
0.17565815150737762,
-0.7071717381477356,
0.22371545433998108,
-0.16985014081001282,
-0.08517272025346756,
-0.2592022716999054,
-0.5198169946670532,
-0.43008363246917725,
1.0970598459243774,
0.39869874715805054,
0.01176636666059494,
-0.26542729139328003,
0.26229631900787354,
1.149202823638916,
-0.4810561537742615,
0.8068253993988037,
0.46915701031684875,
0.5043359398841858,
-0.28759801387786865,
-0.3147810697555542,
0.1636851280927658,
-0.23131096363067627,
0.033257149159908295,
-0.3162446916103363,
-0.7245712280273438,
0.5201485753059387,
-0.1639404296875,
-0.05031890049576759,
0.2790057063102722,
0.8724457025527954,
0.6780146956443787,
0.3201565444469452,
0.2437087893486023,
0.20474277436733246,
0.924095869064331,
-0.04263189435005188,
0.8575333952903748,
-0.017261888831853867,
0.5942864418029785,
0.9217289686203003,
-0.5300043821334839,
0.3134594261646271,
0.48734521865844727,
-0.49436599016189575,
0.6054732203483582,
0.9928951859474182,
-0.5002573728561401,
0.4652097523212433,
0.8357890248298645,
-0.36651375889778137,
-0.38062047958374023,
-0.14682075381278992,
-0.01584620401263237,
0.5102460384368896,
0.5141152739524841,
-0.030799541622400284,
-0.35710757970809937,
0.2632986009120941,
-0.03447550907731056,
0.18304744362831116,
-0.25137415528297424,
0.16418902575969696,
0.08300633728504181,
-0.48313984274864197,
0.2199985533952713,
0.01949404366314411,
0.79891437292099,
-0.7929762601852417,
0.2569732964038849,
-0.6017835736274719,
0.30242404341697693,
-0.2784225642681122,
-0.568526029586792,
-0.3417520523071289,
0.10298755019903183,
0.35976603627204895,
-0.12298385798931122,
0.8328285217285156,
-0.024591445922851562,
-0.43317702412605286,
0.33840861916542053,
0.9482631683349609,
0.36920270323753357,
-0.09413088858127594,
-0.6799653172492981,
-0.10020174831151962,
-0.37525373697280884,
-0.17870664596557617,
0.5284826159477234,
0.14773954451084137,
0.26143503189086914,
1.0341458320617676,
0.33332476019859314,
0.5163033604621887,
-0.19077906012535095,
-0.12286287546157837,
0.05748780071735382,
-0.5581886768341064,
-0.7683417201042175,
-0.8865252137184143,
0.17500104010105133,
0.11293955892324448,
-0.5223371386528015,
0.945743203163147,
0.41001030802726746,
0.2754715383052826,
-0.3071817457675934,
0.666721761226654,
-0.1576257348060608,
-0.14521384239196777,
0.02922775410115719,
0.8847958445549011,
-0.456730455160141,
-0.35735827684402466,
-0.29054707288742065,
-1.0188555717468262,
-0.2761462926864624,
0.7150020599365234,
-0.37371423840522766,
0.07524498552083969,
0.5279234647750854,
0.6951839327812195,
0.22189538180828094,
-0.12660743296146393,
0.5096550583839417,
-0.23492293059825897,
0.678718626499176,
0.7671838998794556,
1.356337308883667,
-0.10244468599557877,
0.1396462470293045,
-0.15590651333332062,
-0.6368725895881653,
-0.056202471256256104,
-0.6198119521141052,
-1.1690781116485596,
-0.2903195917606354,
-0.4155083894729614,
-0.3814392685890198,
0.2039707750082016,
0.8528521060943604,
0.35124635696411133,
-0.23485834896564484,
-0.7517422437667847,
0.49465593695640564,
-0.11876572668552399,
-0.7005720734596252,
-0.336372047662735,
0.08190634846687317,
-0.12899592518806458,
-0.39204174280166626,
0.0881340280175209,
0.26154568791389465,
-0.4207293689250946,
-0.846375584602356,
-0.2500748932361603,
-0.1874932050704956,
0.4231719970703125,
0.5178393125534058,
0.23037700355052948,
-0.694976270198822,
-0.4504299461841583,
-0.007682338356971741,
-0.2880608141422272,
-0.017322594299912453,
0.7203016877174377,
-0.6614269614219666,
0.6048721671104431,
0.44118595123291016,
0.41466280817985535,
0.21718406677246094,
0.26644954085350037,
0.7419742345809937,
-0.10299710929393768,
-0.05473173037171364,
0.23093898594379425,
-0.03110566735267639,
-0.04826580360531807,
-0.6468154788017273,
0.8746136426925659,
0.0014461408136412501,
-0.563041627407074,
-0.8477005362510681,
-0.12962111830711365,
-0.951555609703064,
0.3730645477771759,
0.976365864276886,
-0.4121228754520416,
-0.13197292387485504,
0.046445026993751526,
-0.35917091369628906,
-0.12591737508773804,
-0.3331207036972046,
1.0990979671478271,
1.1285772323608398,
-0.7877830862998962,
-0.13518399000167847,
-0.37232860922813416,
0.3041045069694519,
0.302939236164093,
-0.8325681686401367,
-0.5360755920410156,
0.4371429979801178,
0.2896958887577057,
0.3391977548599243,
0.8791600465774536,
-0.09161883592605591,
0.49373000860214233,
-0.02302788756787777,
0.39824968576431274,
-0.1364241987466812,
0.17239437997341156,
-0.501120388507843,
0.14699019491672516,
-0.02407238818705082,
-0.12239865958690643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15401v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15401v2 | Large Language Model for Mental Health: A Systematic Review | 2024-02-19T17:58:41 | 2024-05-29T21:55:17 | Zhijun Guo, Alvina Lai, Johan Hilge Thygesen, Joseph Farrington, Thomas Keen, Kezhi Li | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have attracted significant attention for
potential applications in digital health, while their application in mental
health is subject to ongoing debate. This systematic review aims to evaluate
the usage of LLMs in mental health, focusing on their strengths and limitations
in early screening, digital interventions, and clinical applications. Adhering
to PRISMA guidelines, we searched PubMed, IEEE Xplore, Scopus, and the JMIR
using keywords: 'mental health OR mental illness OR mental disorder OR
psychiatry' AND 'large language models'. We included articles published between
January 1, 2017, and December 31, 2023, excluding non-English articles. 30
articles were evaluated, which included research on mental illness and suicidal
ideation detection through text (n=12), usage of LLMs for mental health
conversational agents (CAs) (n=5), and other applications and evaluations of
LLMs in mental health (n=13). LLMs exhibit substantial effectiveness in
detecting mental health issues and providing accessible, de-stigmatized eHealth
services. However, the current risks associated with the clinical use might
surpass their benefits. The study identifies several significant issues: the
lack of multilingual datasets annotated by experts, concerns about the accuracy
and reliability of the content generated, challenges in interpretability due to
the 'black box' nature of LLMs, and persistent ethical dilemmas. These include
the lack of a clear ethical framework, concerns about data privacy, and the
potential for over-reliance on LLMs by both therapists and patients, which
could compromise traditional medical practice. Despite these issues, the rapid
development of LLMs underscores their potential as new clinical aids,
emphasizing the need for continued research and development in this area. | [
-0.2539989650249481,
-0.6880477666854858,
1.069656252861023,
0.3209000527858734,
-0.23607470095157623,
-0.11119381338357925,
-0.42477327585220337,
-0.6528950929641724,
0.3653387129306793,
0.5479629635810852,
-0.47317439317703247,
-0.6206046938896179,
-0.9829192161560059,
0.3461001515388489,
-0.5392553210258484,
0.7745958566665649,
-0.1742546260356903,
0.5905301570892334,
0.21658651530742645,
0.07094097882509232,
-0.36458390951156616,
-0.614946186542511,
-0.7209431529045105,
-0.42623013257980347,
0.7704702615737915,
0.12530656158924103,
0.6737773418426514,
-0.02877146005630493,
0.8090150356292725,
0.24700917303562164,
-0.3746946156024933,
0.06813684105873108,
-0.5242734551429749,
0.2053215652704239,
-0.1251523643732071,
-0.3197092115879059,
-0.7338024973869324,
-0.14964129030704498,
0.5068919062614441,
0.7338012456893921,
-0.36637890338897705,
0.2667470872402191,
-0.0677892193198204,
0.6268506050109863,
-0.4366210401058197,
-0.03654922917485237,
-0.22131934762001038,
0.25567924976348877,
-0.2771698236465454,
0.05971121788024902,
-0.2040480375289917,
-0.2849786579608917,
0.07117811590433121,
-0.35108837485313416,
-0.3188791573047638,
-0.12167070806026459,
0.24168594181537628,
0.1343395859003067,
-0.6086211204528809,
-0.2915832996368408,
-0.9590018391609192,
0.556976318359375,
-0.9504237174987793,
0.41050267219543457,
0.33839619159698486,
0.26470446586608887,
-0.3325407803058624,
-0.47999390959739685,
-0.5489082336425781,
-0.15231163799762726,
0.053408216685056686,
0.06764519959688187,
-0.32683995366096497,
0.28043925762176514,
0.5925650000572205,
0.4205780029296875,
-0.6281830668449402,
0.24048180878162384,
-0.5221560001373291,
-0.1066867932677269,
0.7658967971801758,
0.5366386771202087,
0.4804235100746155,
-0.07259654253721237,
0.09465163201093674,
0.2380966991186142,
-0.7043532133102417,
-0.18988166749477386,
0.13552024960517883,
0.02970465086400509,
-0.1418306678533554,
1.0902103185653687,
-0.04568156599998474,
0.4070156216621399,
-0.19604159891605377,
-0.7098124623298645,
0.12078789621591568,
-0.21462030708789825,
-0.20952977240085602,
0.044109147042036057,
0.8446965217590332,
0.6458949446678162,
0.14618366956710815,
-0.059849176555871964,
-0.18364232778549194,
0.02564937062561512,
0.3281921446323395,
-0.8511188626289368,
0.11888217180967331,
0.6209209561347961,
-0.5717273950576782,
0.2520395815372467,
-0.20609702169895172,
-0.43371573090553284,
-0.595984935760498,
-0.304149329662323,
-0.03658648207783699,
-0.3410082757472992,
-0.34612470865249634,
0.5028313398361206,
0.03231498971581459,
0.06394673138856888,
0.3123933970928192,
-0.5346710085868835,
0.2678617238998413,
0.8001096844673157,
0.9283362030982971,
-0.24104061722755432,
-0.12041687965393066,
0.15370555222034454,
0.0294229406863451,
-0.5871400833129883,
0.6278740167617798,
-0.24632054567337036,
-0.48531585931777954,
0.32624635100364685,
0.2095378190279007,
0.013733448460698128,
-0.535424530506134,
0.5660900473594666,
-0.16816134750843048,
0.12551507353782654,
-0.40857237577438354,
-0.3568170368671417,
0.04479432851076126,
0.11045493185520172,
-0.6170269846916199,
0.4721115529537201,
-0.0833868682384491,
-0.8804254531860352,
0.16955694556236267,
-0.40837401151657104,
-0.4259447753429413,
0.134174183011055,
-0.12457071244716644,
-0.2163810133934021,
0.24473051726818085,
0.10124864429235458,
0.4604349136352539,
-0.585261881351471,
0.6006724834442139,
-0.6700165867805481,
-0.515842080116272,
0.4784635901451111,
-0.2383207380771637,
0.8043056130409241,
0.3743366599082947,
-0.1933351308107376,
0.19855712354183197,
-0.4523622393608093,
-0.1875692456960678,
0.2569243907928467,
-0.09610826522111893,
-0.4672210216522217,
0.10064830631017685,
0.30060258507728577,
0.37629464268684387,
0.12009374052286148,
-0.5907123684883118,
-0.05140005052089691,
-0.3902546167373657,
0.48500189185142517,
0.4109652042388916,
0.2813084125518799,
-0.004667498171329498,
-0.5299029350280762,
0.5892855525016785,
-0.19356827437877655,
0.5085833072662354,
0.0023534775245934725,
-0.5846589803695679,
-0.23946896195411682,
-0.6147414445877075,
-0.026653477922081947,
0.5293851494789124,
-0.479417622089386,
0.6356932520866394,
-0.16844050586223602,
-0.5170924663543701,
-0.49456119537353516,
0.01928955875337124,
0.08899018913507462,
0.020107321441173553,
0.037640079855918884,
-0.3220996856689453,
-0.28554922342300415,
-1.0503380298614502,
0.008424799889326096,
-0.14600148797035217,
-0.11691063642501831,
0.31327536702156067,
0.6267775297164917,
-0.9937919974327087,
0.5455403327941895,
-0.2656736671924591,
-0.413750022649765,
-0.32143059372901917,
-0.09522777050733566,
0.04837827384471893,
-0.12040828168392181,
0.1973903924226761,
-0.39035022258758545,
-0.34196069836616516,
-0.1443922221660614,
-0.9516568779945374,
-0.3406673073768616,
0.12643001973628998,
0.14005182683467865,
-0.1331678181886673,
0.10242857784032822,
-0.8217255473136902,
0.019103454425930977,
0.6750309467315674,
-0.07625093311071396,
0.3680564761161804,
-0.07500942796468735,
0.07106231153011322,
-0.7936756014823914,
0.13442718982696533,
0.2943304777145386,
-0.011971726082265377,
-0.508757472038269,
-0.07394107431173325,
-0.08322539180517197,
-0.2882396876811981,
-0.2870407998561859,
0.39847490191459656,
-0.3224162757396698,
0.24251863360404968,
-0.4837937653064728,
0.3148375153541565,
-0.23866111040115356,
-0.10763347893953323,
-0.1691390722990036,
0.5765897631645203,
0.31065833568573,
-0.1970272958278656,
0.490354061126709,
0.10921045392751694,
-0.45229196548461914,
0.8220287561416626,
-0.5649406313896179,
-0.0365900844335556,
-0.14517129957675934,
0.5903924107551575,
-0.7200355529785156,
-0.2503306567668915,
0.2266942411661148,
-0.1259613335132599,
0.2966615855693817,
0.483386754989624,
-0.6691146492958069,
-0.5665578842163086,
-0.395587682723999,
0.3814801573753357,
0.16282649338245392,
0.0463220551609993,
0.010175449773669243,
0.9297930598258972,
-0.6589944958686829,
-0.2648875117301941,
-0.5392425656318665,
0.4644930958747864,
-0.33456122875213623,
-0.5221337676048279,
0.18898586928844452,
-0.054018933326005936,
-0.6100520491600037,
-0.19346334040164948,
-0.03214292973279953,
0.03425297513604164,
0.16663114726543427,
0.10948573052883148,
0.17031778395175934,
0.025947637856006622,
0.37519556283950806,
-0.07951658219099045,
0.0019044154323637486,
0.4073566198348999,
0.18839292228221893,
0.44646257162094116,
0.06460320949554443,
-0.5569150447845459,
-0.48497211933135986,
0.7976220846176147,
0.6044990420341492,
0.05910945683717728,
0.6158369183540344,
0.47523391246795654,
-0.6077207922935486,
-0.11001661419868469,
-0.6878367066383362,
-0.2739209234714508,
-0.29149022698402405,
0.5382121205329895,
0.06008952856063843,
-1.0419306755065918,
0.2851525843143463,
-0.07385960966348648,
-0.08285665512084961,
0.38967928290367126,
0.8325435519218445,
-0.21447844803333282,
1.1665034294128418,
0.5320674777030945,
-0.12841328978538513,
0.3443439304828644,
-0.07347145676612854,
0.7596628665924072,
-0.9644359946250916,
-0.21405594050884247,
-0.3100241720676422,
-0.200967937707901,
-0.6756478548049927,
-0.3000793755054474,
0.48704659938812256,
-0.17230309545993805,
-0.38495972752571106,
-0.26549673080444336,
-0.3750215172767639,
-0.16106058657169342,
-0.1403515636920929,
0.3990553021430969,
0.5400165319442749,
-0.1462009698152542,
-0.05664397031068802,
-0.49305692315101624,
-0.4447174072265625,
-0.7418898940086365,
1.322993278503418,
0.6900946497917175,
1.2085034847259521,
0.14780639111995697,
0.4929671883583069,
0.3705000877380371,
0.6199344396591187,
-0.9601788520812988,
0.5086889863014221,
-0.005494852550327778,
-0.7820739150047302,
-0.35936102271080017,
-0.3619978725910187,
-0.9411477446556091,
0.21510758996009827,
-0.17946550250053406,
-1.0270127058029175,
-0.014656087383627892,
-0.2816386818885803,
-0.28952884674072266,
0.2166588008403778,
-0.4059928357601166,
0.4281712770462036,
-0.7158179879188538,
-0.2355145812034607,
-0.4115917384624481,
-0.431884765625,
0.8456323742866516,
-0.5829417109489441,
0.45407575368881226,
-0.2917923331260681,
-0.05399376153945923,
0.87928706407547,
-0.2676296532154083,
0.7314260005950928,
0.2549079656600952,
-0.5735673904418945,
-0.03887735307216644,
-0.2099464237689972,
0.21013996005058289,
0.3144049048423767,
0.12317916005849838,
0.32451435923576355,
0.36109912395477295,
-0.06669876724481583,
-0.4673772156238556,
0.732385516166687,
-0.6321148872375488,
-0.9868804216384888,
-0.7421365976333618,
-0.42821383476257324,
-0.3751722276210785,
0.2793956995010376,
0.029641244560480118,
0.14707086980342865,
-0.32726699113845825,
0.12889258563518524,
0.5386763215065002,
-0.459537148475647,
-0.22537322342395782,
0.629158616065979,
-0.5820236802101135,
-0.5753518342971802,
0.5038905739784241,
0.21602416038513184,
0.039727140218019485,
-0.08841457217931747,
0.04966298118233681,
-0.28686267137527466,
-0.8088342547416687,
0.02400418370962143,
0.6873825192451477,
-0.4361884891986847,
0.2315622866153717,
-0.5391324758529663,
-0.504870593547821,
-0.41152703762054443,
0.10101587325334549,
-0.3503096401691437,
0.12796235084533691,
-0.002971757436171174,
0.01675787940621376,
0.20869237184524536,
1.0070728063583374,
0.18512435257434845,
0.24882178008556366,
-0.6485215425491333,
0.3851858675479889,
-0.025520900264382362,
0.5536024570465088,
0.07055584341287613,
-0.21398277580738068,
-0.2258485108613968,
0.03360265865921974,
-0.31487786769866943,
-1.0485531091690063,
0.3587659001350403,
-0.25251373648643494,
0.6259860992431641,
0.5958963632583618,
0.12305738776922226,
0.6559533476829529,
-0.4527773857116699,
0.6163907647132874,
0.4480302929878235,
-0.570096492767334,
0.43886446952819824,
-0.4217507839202881,
0.45250359177589417,
0.49768033623695374,
0.8426114320755005,
-1.0741240978240967,
-0.37143826484680176,
-0.3318813145160675,
-0.9952643513679504,
0.46032941341400146,
0.18608178198337555,
0.039026498794555664,
-0.14217104017734528,
0.1887129843235016,
-0.15230399370193481,
0.2348390370607376,
-0.6143932342529297,
-0.40929701924324036,
0.5105499625205994,
-0.1577918529510498,
-0.3274160921573639,
-0.5484961271286011,
-0.5096456408500671,
-0.11087702214717865,
0.6065757870674133,
0.04183583706617355,
0.4598838686943054,
0.4374658465385437,
-0.05091862380504608,
-0.3746036887168884,
0.48597434163093567,
0.31293365359306335,
0.7251172661781311,
-0.3626123070716858,
0.028234370052814484,
0.13453909754753113,
-0.6637665629386902,
0.3956283926963806,
0.2622607350349426,
-0.220105841755867,
-0.017954625189304352,
0.2889745831489563,
0.37619978189468384,
0.3680364191532135,
-1.0398547649383545,
0.4531061053276062,
-0.07091441750526428,
-0.1618030071258545,
-0.4777635633945465,
-0.26812079548835754,
0.19313117861747742,
0.5663776993751526,
0.05456126853823662,
-0.47119778394699097,
0.26224201917648315,
-0.5482704043388367,
-0.11580867320299149,
0.6616517901420593,
-0.21527840197086334,
-0.23107868432998657,
0.08253432810306549,
0.04006289318203926,
-0.5216513276100159,
0.4251706600189209,
0.027687886729836464,
-0.153231680393219,
0.13169080018997192,
0.5429853796958923,
0.6595262885093689,
-0.12811079621315002,
0.14911580085754395,
0.07462439686059952,
0.654489278793335,
-0.39224326610565186,
0.37297651171684265,
0.4155050814151764,
-0.48928895592689514,
-0.2578986883163452,
-0.34603551030158997,
-0.6142380237579346,
0.6458758115768433,
-0.35200729966163635,
0.26705655455589294,
-0.4568387269973755,
-0.8443450927734375,
-0.16967284679412842,
0.06433817744255066,
-0.5280463695526123,
-0.10815192759037018,
0.6433364748954773,
0.8314411640167236,
-0.6315475106239319,
0.5999335050582886,
0.7283810377120972,
-0.07556112110614777,
-0.3113552927970886,
0.07181791216135025,
0.4335404336452484,
-0.254271000623703,
0.04090261831879616,
0.1922721266746521,
-0.025362325832247734,
-0.3963387906551361,
-0.35625651478767395,
-1.0252050161361694,
1.1050313711166382,
0.5558291673660278,
-0.7469536662101746,
-0.3530961871147156,
0.2659206688404083,
0.7122194766998291,
-0.41756340861320496,
0.4079588055610657,
0.5077816247940063,
0.5568612813949585,
-0.06229746714234352,
-1.000808596611023,
0.02672402746975422,
-0.23575419187545776,
0.25263911485671997,
-0.058143775910139084,
-0.6689958572387695,
0.5461243987083435,
-0.14077845215797424,
-0.5135493278503418,
0.05587983876466751,
0.10226356983184814,
0.5165059566497803,
0.24811114370822906,
0.15137912333011627,
0.5484192967414856,
0.773479700088501,
0.18452371656894684,
0.9924911856651306,
-0.2748276889324188,
0.35843876004219055,
0.8644258975982666,
-0.9049530029296875,
0.8479489088058472,
0.34873002767562866,
-0.4329592287540436,
0.09118813276290894,
0.7157393097877502,
0.08152160793542862,
0.1726648509502411,
0.34830546379089355,
-0.27604496479034424,
-0.1769145280122757,
-0.22069694101810455,
-0.42096635699272156,
0.08020972460508347,
0.6819373965263367,
-0.44467484951019287,
-0.11348865926265717,
0.11856178194284439,
0.1486799269914627,
0.011005432344973087,
-0.10130704194307327,
0.5643738508224487,
0.71201092004776,
-0.2679949998855591,
0.4640049636363983,
0.26454460620880127,
0.5794153809547424,
-0.7571587562561035,
0.19867557287216187,
-0.007888048887252808,
0.09113945811986923,
-0.2954781651496887,
-0.6185097098350525,
0.4129578471183777,
0.2004314363002777,
0.053365789353847504,
-0.18040309846401215,
0.722355842590332,
-0.05869606137275696,
-0.7283905744552612,
0.6913124918937683,
0.7163926959037781,
0.14464275538921356,
-0.11943617463111877,
-0.6967609524726868,
0.15267430245876312,
-0.4616571366786957,
-0.4733085036277771,
0.5160356760025024,
0.3219071328639984,
-0.25462016463279724,
0.6817620992660522,
0.6312276721000671,
0.6385964155197144,
-0.24988748133182526,
0.15565553307533264,
0.6637961864471436,
-0.9364786744117737,
-0.03235093876719475,
-0.7834569811820984,
0.07756564766168594,
0.016902392730116844,
-0.2836989462375641,
0.7861379384994507,
0.37490928173065186,
0.6117222905158997,
0.2217567265033722,
0.7192806005477905,
0.3197746276855469,
0.2894396483898163,
-0.267436683177948,
0.830682635307312,
-0.5870659947395325,
0.22548428177833557,
-0.2373984456062317,
-0.943979024887085,
-0.4791586399078369,
0.5882604122161865,
-0.6807273030281067,
0.04891706258058548,
0.968940794467926,
0.6681717038154602,
0.27460551261901855,
0.12465278059244156,
0.3998803198337555,
0.4938032329082489,
0.2901877164840698,
0.5532774329185486,
0.9310190677642822,
-0.09657730162143707,
-0.16975334286689758,
-0.19771865010261536,
-0.27373093366622925,
-0.2252839356660843,
-0.5709570646286011,
-0.9167921543121338,
-0.37145814299583435,
-0.14506886899471283,
-0.16427774727344513,
0.13422377407550812,
1.1183886528015137,
0.4759359061717987,
-0.5542562007904053,
-0.40425100922584534,
0.507568359375,
0.2556932270526886,
-0.1316007524728775,
-0.13866405189037323,
-0.07121710479259491,
0.1041686087846756,
-0.36102262139320374,
0.15490677952766418,
0.5930835008621216,
-0.13960394263267517,
-0.7186276912689209,
0.09744467586278915,
-0.1749005913734436,
-0.031158294528722763,
0.85307377576828,
-0.004772776737809181,
-1.037505865097046,
0.19506077468395233,
-0.061256423592567444,
-0.6263251900672913,
-0.1812916100025177,
0.8928560018539429,
-0.10247177630662918,
0.16412879526615143,
0.37008073925971985,
0.48930656909942627,
0.3757425546646118,
-0.4589213728904724,
0.552635908126831,
0.4250083267688751,
-0.12498152256011963,
0.3810078501701355,
0.7747116684913635,
0.2703896462917328,
-0.3900696635246277,
0.18243210017681122,
0.16752217710018158,
-0.3730727732181549,
-0.7532655596733093,
0.07759572565555573,
-0.9878516793251038,
-0.18473246693611145,
1.3496893644332886,
-0.017106546089053154,
-0.2999464273452759,
-0.32491907477378845,
-0.49907824397087097,
0.02822299115359783,
-0.35150426626205444,
1.0281118154525757,
0.7801927924156189,
0.0534946545958519,
-0.10451483726501465,
-0.9957167506217957,
0.14575186371803284,
0.051630567759275436,
-0.737823486328125,
0.015495727770030499,
0.5203098654747009,
0.1709400862455368,
-0.09781020879745483,
0.9061289429664612,
-0.5401067733764648,
0.14107587933540344,
-0.5217366218566895,
0.17457275092601776,
0.26649025082588196,
-0.09499898552894592,
-0.7240175008773804,
-0.10842414945363998,
0.3146745264530182,
0.7810688614845276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12317v1 | ARKS: Active Retrieval in Knowledge Soup for Code Generation | 2024-02-19T17:37:28 | 2024-02-19T17:37:28 | Hongjin Su, Shuyang Jiang, Yuhang Lai, Haoyuan Wu, Boao Shi, Che Liu, Qian Liu, Tao Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently the retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) paradigm has raised much
attention for its potential in incorporating external knowledge into large
language models (LLMs) without further training. While widely explored in
natural language applications, its utilization in code generation remains
under-explored. In this paper, we introduce Active Retrieval in Knowledge Soup
(ARKS), an advanced strategy for generalizing large language models for code.
In contrast to relying on a single source, we construct a knowledge soup
integrating web search, documentation, execution feedback, and evolved code
snippets. We employ an active retrieval strategy that iteratively refines the
query and updates the knowledge soup. To assess the performance of ARKS, we
compile a new benchmark comprising realistic coding problems associated with
frequently updated libraries and long-tail programming languages. Experimental
results on ChatGPT and CodeLlama demonstrate a substantial improvement in the
average execution accuracy of ARKS on LLMs. The analysis confirms the
effectiveness of our proposed knowledge soup and active retrieval strategies,
offering rich insights into the construction of effective retrieval-augmented
code generation (RACG) pipelines. Our model, code, and data are available at
https://arks-codegen.github.io. | [
-0.06872665882110596,
-0.8135970830917358,
0.25897216796875,
0.15216967463493347,
-0.2505270540714264,
0.2505590319633484,
-0.5085144639015198,
-0.43666887283325195,
0.11344832181930542,
0.570404589176178,
0.06933782249689102,
-0.6625877022743225,
-0.29289907217025757,
0.16451546549797058,
-0.6222959160804749,
0.6247257590293884,
-0.11396098136901855,
-0.05016950145363808,
-0.041779350489377975,
-0.10950737446546555,
-0.1735084503889084,
-0.14008009433746338,
-0.33097079396247864,
0.11213063448667526,
0.4413333833217621,
0.42435505986213684,
0.5543361306190491,
0.9138896465301514,
0.5722748041152954,
0.28403130173683167,
-0.09096427261829376,
0.24218210577964783,
-0.4219224154949188,
0.822486937046051,
-0.093903087079525,
-0.5361281037330627,
-0.0759592056274414,
-0.3270031213760376,
0.7317802906036377,
0.4486245810985565,
-0.40857791900634766,
0.345001757144928,
-0.17465569078922272,
0.6810569167137146,
-0.9362848401069641,
0.1525942087173462,
-0.8269426226615906,
0.1337474137544632,
-0.216219961643219,
-0.32639676332473755,
-0.45780423283576965,
-0.40865522623062134,
-0.02828088216483593,
-0.20691096782684326,
0.333269327878952,
0.370073527097702,
0.3730267882347107,
0.20892244577407837,
-0.3268618583679199,
-0.5656686425209045,
-0.6357972621917725,
0.8325457572937012,
-0.697953999042511,
0.4115311801433563,
0.3926679193973541,
0.30637165904045105,
-0.2215265929698944,
-1.072021484375,
-0.5557215809822083,
-0.3739302158355713,
0.23896902799606323,
-0.10253582149744034,
-0.3637539744377136,
-0.17337669432163239,
0.33158475160598755,
0.8303306698799133,
-0.26545941829681396,
-0.24858620762825012,
-0.3406623899936676,
-0.11475560814142227,
0.4946700930595398,
-0.07626938819885254,
0.46400895714759827,
-0.1783134788274765,
-0.44726666808128357,
-0.05541997402906418,
-1.0562880039215088,
-0.08771611750125885,
0.31764936447143555,
0.47875726222991943,
0.1275152862071991,
0.8084136843681335,
-0.09787318110466003,
0.9135638475418091,
-0.3208475708961487,
0.2159961611032486,
0.23614706099033356,
-0.18734054267406464,
0.1292966902256012,
-0.06663767248392105,
0.7420099973678589,
0.0053606824949383736,
-0.04056582227349281,
-0.36285778880119324,
-0.6927299499511719,
-0.09738415479660034,
0.6122940182685852,
-0.5820456147193909,
-0.15822111070156097,
0.009918172843754292,
-0.32378390431404114,
-0.4775761365890503,
-0.07630560547113419,
-0.6098731160163879,
-0.4826373755931854,
0.09307961910963058,
0.3266488015651703,
-0.4196222722530365,
-0.3737049400806427,
-0.08502090722322464,
-0.4261131286621094,
0.3100350499153137,
0.03662605583667755,
-0.4300931692123413,
0.1732204407453537,
0.48222431540489197,
0.9019306302070618,
-0.1893562525510788,
-0.04263288900256157,
-0.782123327255249,
0.34002718329429626,
-0.5430870056152344,
0.858688235282898,
-0.6698604226112366,
-0.16674156486988068,
0.171781986951828,
-0.3652436137199402,
0.18363730609416962,
-0.694625735282898,
0.12252070754766464,
-0.9003254175186157,
-0.19318115711212158,
-0.06520946323871613,
-0.5155247449874878,
-0.015796802937984467,
0.3422575294971466,
-0.8418793082237244,
0.9722492098808289,
0.3383735716342926,
-0.7112608551979065,
0.03390497714281082,
-0.6059166193008423,
-0.6573227643966675,
0.24896812438964844,
-0.32550838589668274,
-0.31759199500083923,
0.029376329854130745,
-0.056538574397563934,
0.34979334473609924,
-0.4674031734466553,
-0.021116670221090317,
-0.20504571497440338,
-0.4811673164367676,
0.0325438417494297,
-0.049507688730955124,
0.3026971220970154,
0.5581409335136414,
-0.4015684127807617,
-0.02316368743777275,
-0.5030511617660522,
0.20603512227535248,
0.2508792579174042,
-0.7830630540847778,
-0.3173963725566864,
0.25441470742225647,
-0.3257768750190735,
-0.2607238292694092,
0.23536212742328644,
-0.41433075070381165,
0.5411158204078674,
-0.12333584576845169,
0.35905665159225464,
0.5031729340553284,
0.14279034733772278,
0.6269786357879639,
-0.20803244411945343,
0.6192154884338379,
-0.1998385339975357,
-0.07280734181404114,
-0.3935815989971161,
-0.46888041496276855,
-0.5643103122711182,
-0.12593437731266022,
0.36646655201911926,
0.4095228910446167,
-1.0186797380447388,
0.05377940461039543,
-0.18952718377113342,
-0.3690979480743408,
-0.5872375965118408,
0.5297298431396484,
0.5916212797164917,
0.2580307424068451,
0.49459293484687805,
-0.32039570808410645,
-0.6081662178039551,
-0.7012728452682495,
-0.5186053514480591,
-0.08261610567569733,
-0.17002876102924347,
0.38549038767814636,
0.10737870633602142,
-0.2820442318916321,
0.8412094712257385,
-0.532850444316864,
0.032325372099876404,
-0.5956822633743286,
0.16190674901008606,
0.1286052018404007,
0.397220253944397,
0.3747333884239197,
-0.9232773184776306,
-0.43795689940452576,
-0.023031312972307205,
-0.5528784990310669,
0.004513895139098167,
0.4148561656475067,
0.018979957327246666,
0.07919992506504059,
0.42860183119773865,
-0.4344608187675476,
0.2180688977241516,
0.6104933619499207,
-0.3003036081790924,
0.5530474185943604,
0.038681093603372574,
0.12995892763137817,
-0.9283135533332825,
0.4027077853679657,
-0.209251269698143,
-0.2012772560119629,
-0.39699310064315796,
0.7506860494613647,
0.2987273037433624,
-0.2545168399810791,
-0.32900285720825195,
0.6182878613471985,
-0.9294933080673218,
-0.28089579939842224,
-0.10071874409914017,
-0.017339099198579788,
-0.14045682549476624,
0.32084712386131287,
-0.06932190805673599,
1.0699524879455566,
0.6444334983825684,
-0.729218602180481,
0.7470798492431641,
-0.006467332132160664,
-0.6873605847358704,
-0.2637198567390442,
-0.5090632438659668,
0.40815970301628113,
0.13248227536678314,
0.14212924242019653,
-0.585850715637207,
0.006797292735427618,
0.10434361547231674,
-0.3552917540073395,
0.5306868553161621,
-0.6731958985328674,
-0.5598633885383606,
-0.3038873076438904,
-0.21547260880470276,
0.4098077416419983,
0.7113572359085083,
-0.3874320983886719,
0.5785322189331055,
0.5098119974136353,
-0.12195513397455215,
-0.7778576612472534,
-0.44864994287490845,
0.13501977920532227,
0.09964321553707123,
-0.42983150482177734,
0.08415351063013077,
0.09179912507534027,
-0.48973315954208374,
0.13302594423294067,
-0.4704561233520508,
-0.023815279826521873,
-0.07436887174844742,
-0.2791674733161926,
-0.05440297722816467,
-0.46118733286857605,
-0.08051741868257523,
-0.1823902726173401,
0.051326069980859756,
-0.10841570049524307,
-0.21593689918518066,
0.6728323698043823,
-0.1780383139848709,
-0.4677574336528778,
0.21450486779212952,
0.21292425692081451,
0.4715089201927185,
-0.6198939085006714,
0.5735107064247131,
0.37906068563461304,
-0.10264487564563751,
-0.6102178692817688,
-0.7378307580947876,
-0.11677022278308868,
-0.4621070325374603,
0.28593844175338745,
-0.15079359710216522,
-0.5498371720314026,
0.6342215538024902,
-0.28073060512542725,
0.2538256347179413,
0.18414722383022308,
0.24747605621814728,
0.0705622136592865,
1.039949655532837,
0.486202597618103,
0.011703137308359146,
0.5968912243843079,
-0.6704302430152893,
0.10295385867357254,
-0.9571954607963562,
-0.20820346474647522,
-0.658496618270874,
-0.2270231992006302,
-0.2713332176208496,
-0.9338756799697876,
0.1377914845943451,
0.36428701877593994,
-0.09684779495000839,
0.42917120456695557,
-0.41144296526908875,
0.4919956922531128,
0.5980827212333679,
0.15195654332637787,
0.3527275025844574,
-0.13693682849407196,
-0.2554250955581665,
0.4594227075576782,
-1.0066725015640259,
-0.2539099454879761,
1.1494027376174927,
0.08699537813663483,
0.974129319190979,
0.3128683567047119,
0.6343731880187988,
0.5660427808761597,
0.27597522735595703,
-0.7005476355552673,
0.5003713965415955,
0.05983734875917435,
-0.4455043375492096,
-0.29574525356292725,
-0.9312519431114197,
-1.042317509651184,
0.06398481130599976,
-0.12415941804647446,
-0.14173442125320435,
-0.12306110560894012,
0.2582336962223053,
-0.2293277233839035,
0.46843022108078003,
-0.7986687421798706,
0.633003830909729,
-0.2521926462650299,
-0.47808101773262024,
-0.3378990590572357,
-0.43333661556243896,
0.1725405901670456,
0.19098599255084991,
0.29415372014045715,
0.18179520964622498,
-0.14190860092639923,
0.5328623056411743,
-0.21997074782848358,
0.46695655584335327,
-0.22709278762340546,
-0.20332199335098267,
0.601049542427063,
0.3550192713737488,
0.8811917901039124,
0.031118856742978096,
-0.36209818720817566,
-0.045072488486766815,
-0.35184118151664734,
-0.4903978705406189,
-0.6496135592460632,
0.7979461550712585,
-0.46410635113716125,
-0.6114805340766907,
-0.3122573792934418,
-0.4664117693901062,
-0.13194409012794495,
0.5458778738975525,
-0.05519120767712593,
0.7223501205444336,
0.14082024991512299,
0.49867868423461914,
0.8809966444969177,
-0.4139834940433502,
0.21347163617610931,
0.7146015763282776,
-0.3123294711112976,
-0.20751217007637024,
0.8312041759490967,
-0.03971094638109207,
0.1776646226644516,
0.3125161826610565,
0.12753376364707947,
-0.09377194195985794,
-0.8453291058540344,
-0.6138874292373657,
0.05239170789718628,
-0.5198423266410828,
-0.7966495156288147,
-0.4474404752254486,
-0.1775471717119217,
-0.5441042184829712,
0.06596509367227554,
-0.5467211008071899,
-0.3174465596675873,
0.1436690241098404,
0.045729704201221466,
0.5264922976493835,
1.0509847402572632,
0.10000298917293549,
-0.27464091777801514,
-0.9961988925933838,
0.6500533223152161,
0.2476896047592163,
0.8137795925140381,
0.15546122193336487,
-0.22856585681438446,
-0.37544140219688416,
0.2713443636894226,
-0.24817194044589996,
-1.000980257987976,
0.2375527024269104,
0.15294183790683746,
0.780817985534668,
0.37783896923065186,
0.47715136408805847,
0.6101369857788086,
-0.49451154470443726,
0.6543585658073425,
0.017615698277950287,
-0.6784675121307373,
0.6589668989181519,
-0.4134182333946228,
0.37767940759658813,
0.29422062635421753,
0.07903128862380981,
-0.47514423727989197,
-0.673731803894043,
-0.4456023573875427,
-1.3242193460464478,
0.6496478319168091,
0.32760006189346313,
0.2416161596775055,
-0.4357629716396332,
0.43087491393089294,
-0.13407334685325623,
0.2564217448234558,
-0.3708781599998474,
-0.2699131667613983,
0.03926119953393936,
0.020055314525961876,
0.3796074390411377,
-0.2671217620372772,
-0.1434633731842041,
-0.02655426226556301,
0.642883837223053,
-0.0628976970911026,
0.3889034688472748,
-0.032195158302783966,
-0.29431384801864624,
-0.5069732666015625,
0.11917383223772049,
0.09481412917375565,
0.6633210778236389,
-0.13125090301036835,
0.3007288873195648,
0.05103547126054764,
-0.5185895562171936,
-0.34920474886894226,
-0.13661882281303406,
-0.05378256365656853,
-0.04721524193882942,
0.44987940788269043,
0.5204369425773621,
0.655523419380188,
-0.9725818634033203,
0.6458970904350281,
-0.06322964280843735,
0.31146201491355896,
-0.3342013657093048,
0.4817262589931488,
-0.036994144320487976,
0.31659767031669617,
0.9142598509788513,
0.12089890241622925,
0.07216965407133102,
-0.8935633897781372,
0.42057737708091736,
0.4247269332408905,
-0.1377582848072052,
-0.05457549914717674,
0.2929058372974396,
0.3519476652145386,
-0.4927786588668823,
0.9914916157722473,
-0.2668916583061218,
-0.5555018782615662,
0.5222549438476562,
0.7878919243812561,
0.6608943939208984,
-0.23099109530448914,
-0.15361084043979645,
0.30850234627723694,
-0.05512753129005432,
-0.3631422221660614,
0.3400716781616211,
-0.47940897941589355,
-0.6879411339759827,
-0.4403650462627411,
-0.765394389629364,
-0.32991597056388855,
-0.1080896407365799,
-0.8281806111335754,
0.39975234866142273,
-0.2329942286014557,
0.09552372246980667,
-0.563943088054657,
0.09363410621881485,
-0.5597183704376221,
-0.23995472490787506,
0.0005816928460262716,
1.272156000137329,
-0.4006422758102417,
0.6861059665679932,
0.9946562647819519,
-0.4524803161621094,
-0.7404410243034363,
-0.030552813783288002,
-0.41203129291534424,
-0.9157400131225586,
0.1935831606388092,
-0.15422095358371735,
-0.019569097086787224,
0.2783152163028717,
-0.7449876666069031,
-1.031906247138977,
1.1792112588882446,
0.2715492248535156,
-0.4454311728477478,
-0.22670277953147888,
-0.3250392973423004,
0.40120258927345276,
-0.15018251538276672,
0.13667744398117065,
0.16073808073997498,
0.3846897780895233,
0.31532061100006104,
-0.7724758982658386,
-0.07159443944692612,
-0.5950911045074463,
-0.06034749001264572,
0.4338536858558655,
-0.4336790442466736,
0.4299347996711731,
-0.5580261945724487,
-0.3004433214664459,
0.07840332388877869,
0.6167738437652588,
0.48578041791915894,
0.12806522846221924,
0.370138943195343,
0.5804517269134521,
0.48961973190307617,
0.10670778155326843,
1.1962591409683228,
-0.6794303059577942,
0.2595662772655487,
0.7619240880012512,
0.009422382339835167,
1.0327231884002686,
0.4196777045726776,
-0.10925176739692688,
0.5885084867477417,
0.07193528115749359,
-0.02579360641539097,
0.5594664216041565,
0.29715704917907715,
-0.23152993619441986,
-0.18672171235084534,
0.2842877209186554,
-0.5079023838043213,
0.30177241563796997,
0.3552314341068268,
-0.4449794292449951,
-0.22755815088748932,
-0.19115059077739716,
-0.03330758586525917,
0.06647265702486038,
-0.2659285366535187,
0.9122211933135986,
0.06957506388425827,
-0.7131696939468384,
0.5982608795166016,
0.013074214570224285,
0.5396060347557068,
-0.8276113271713257,
-0.4833967685699463,
-0.2986884117126465,
0.11959271132946014,
-0.0921073630452156,
-0.8077316284179688,
0.1905413717031479,
0.3227357566356659,
-0.059956684708595276,
-0.3781033754348755,
0.5849420428276062,
-0.4482736885547638,
-0.18155936896800995,
0.1750020980834961,
0.41058823466300964,
0.05281674861907959,
-0.08452403545379639,
-0.585004985332489,
0.14162082970142365,
0.0009005321189761162,
-0.5180736184120178,
0.3983977735042572,
0.6287612318992615,
0.16842859983444214,
0.9586974382400513,
0.7613246440887451,
0.430177241563797,
0.20084893703460693,
-0.06783387809991837,
1.0302871465682983,
-0.7023150324821472,
-0.40303120017051697,
-0.38865530490875244,
0.18487660586833954,
0.10232693701982498,
0.026098432019352913,
0.9199188947677612,
0.8954119682312012,
0.665371835231781,
-0.01926717907190323,
0.8345925807952881,
-0.4802291989326477,
0.5846020579338074,
-0.443013995885849,
0.8357087969779968,
-0.383537232875824,
0.740397036075592,
-0.234122171998024,
-1.1666134595870972,
-0.21742798388004303,
0.7763701677322388,
-0.1035013496875763,
-0.026695510372519493,
0.49601396918296814,
0.732221245765686,
-0.09348687529563904,
-0.18514692783355713,
-0.0077570048160851,
0.34388336539268494,
0.1370672732591629,
0.08342182636260986,
0.9027676582336426,
-0.2987688481807709,
0.7605128884315491,
-0.31255003809928894,
-0.16349489986896515,
-0.17179980874061584,
-0.7775163054466248,
-0.45699894428253174,
-0.5820843577384949,
-0.07351712137460709,
-0.36809924244880676,
0.358083039522171,
0.8599956631660461,
0.40364211797714233,
-0.6255748271942139,
-0.18819813430309296,
-0.11243262141942978,
0.35858914256095886,
-0.3474076986312866,
-0.1963292509317398,
0.19409061968326569,
-0.7568651437759399,
-0.5181049704551697,
0.6325604915618896,
0.00871299672871828,
-0.19639268517494202,
-0.24083375930786133,
-0.14756466448307037,
-0.1808481216430664,
-0.17995186150074005,
0.43966662883758545,
0.4159461259841919,
-0.31952914595603943,
-0.06861694902181625,
0.2752871811389923,
-0.028201546519994736,
-0.12675221264362335,
1.1543970108032227,
-0.9667025208473206,
0.4576144814491272,
0.5464375615119934,
0.4390133321285248,
0.37832239270210266,
0.11524119973182678,
0.8921800851821899,
-0.8324074745178223,
-0.055569734424352646,
0.6707668900489807,
0.32057711482048035,
0.32107117772102356,
-0.17225366830825806,
0.5076351165771484,
0.03764212876558304,
-0.43330591917037964,
-1.1436432600021362,
0.24761873483657837,
-0.5364161729812622,
-0.3693571388721466,
1.705256700515747,
-0.1842339038848877,
-0.3330846428871155,
-0.26862776279449463,
0.10934282094240189,
0.4193597137928009,
-0.47487130761146545,
1.0228172540664673,
0.11720890551805496,
0.08114269375801086,
-0.18456494808197021,
-0.4054965674877167,
0.5776355862617493,
-0.09105238318443298,
-0.309395432472229,
0.3734029233455658,
0.5383877158164978,
0.35323646664619446,
0.1817893385887146,
0.42277804017066956,
-0.2553998827934265,
0.38625770807266235,
0.04842321574687958,
0.400336891412735,
-0.31157186627388,
-0.3440440595149994,
0.06715349107980728,
0.24651357531547546,
0.30107051134109497,
0.09274791926145554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12309v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12309v1 | TILP: Differentiable Learning of Temporal Logical Rules on Knowledge Graphs | 2024-02-19T17:30:44 | 2024-02-19T17:30:44 | Siheng Xiong, Yuan Yang, Faramarz Fekri, James Clayton Kerce | cs.CL | cs.CL | Compared with static knowledge graphs, temporal knowledge graphs (tKG), which
can capture the evolution and change of information over time, are more
realistic and general. However, due to the complexity that the notion of time
introduces to the learning of the rules, an accurate graph reasoning, e.g.,
predicting new links between entities, is still a difficult problem. In this
paper, we propose TILP, a differentiable framework for temporal logical rules
learning. By designing a constrained random walk mechanism and the introduction
of temporal operators, we ensure the efficiency of our model. We present
temporal features modeling in tKG, e.g., recurrence, temporal order, interval
between pair of relations, and duration, and incorporate it into our learning
process. We compare TILP with state-of-the-art methods on two benchmark
datasets. We show that our proposed framework can improve upon the performance
of baseline methods while providing interpretable results. In particular, we
consider various scenarios in which training samples are limited, data is
biased, and the time range between training and inference are different. In all
these cases, TILP works much better than the state-of-the-art methods. | [
0.13458694517612457,
-0.6975087523460388,
0.7780689001083374,
-0.02004057914018631,
-0.38153284788131714,
-0.009063418954610825,
-0.04974190145730972,
-0.605625569820404,
-0.014333476312458515,
0.0907319039106369,
-0.8499734997749329,
-0.7478647828102112,
-0.5363985300064087,
-0.040299784392118454,
-0.029360098764300346,
0.48606741428375244,
-0.0835629552602768,
-0.1500043123960495,
0.171129047870636,
-0.27531537413597107,
-0.4873960018157959,
0.10430261492729187,
-0.7253767848014832,
-0.7676671743392944,
0.5074241161346436,
0.1010613963007927,
0.4862547516822815,
0.9717928767204285,
-0.06647171080112457,
0.23651880025863647,
0.0851973444223404,
0.2119368314743042,
-0.1681382805109024,
0.03216313570737839,
-0.38505178689956665,
-0.49111253023147583,
-0.41003888845443726,
0.19123391807079315,
0.4187534749507904,
0.9080222845077515,
-0.3669600188732147,
0.12118974328041077,
-0.36009687185287476,
0.6763250231742859,
-0.35747459530830383,
0.8151125311851501,
-0.29409876465797424,
0.7431551218032837,
-0.22522543370723724,
-0.6404790878295898,
-0.4084153175354004,
-0.8187137246131897,
0.19167736172676086,
-0.9981133937835693,
-0.024036763235926628,
0.18884800374507904,
0.8447064757347107,
0.34430572390556335,
-0.5583780407905579,
0.04756404832005501,
-0.5603804588317871,
0.6669737100601196,
-0.6644339561462402,
0.9516052007675171,
0.11031163483858109,
0.8639402985572815,
-0.10391046106815338,
-1.0551053285598755,
-0.4538142681121826,
-0.21052998304367065,
0.08045343309640884,
-0.18535596132278442,
0.02432553470134735,
-0.22488166391849518,
0.5758751034736633,
-0.07779081165790558,
-0.23260077834129333,
-0.013898423872888088,
-0.11459778249263763,
0.10537324100732803,
0.3634824752807617,
0.18950633704662323,
0.11282185465097427,
-0.2165771722793579,
-0.42938995361328125,
-0.04815003275871277,
-0.5478522181510925,
0.05860363692045212,
0.17439787089824677,
0.34173935651779175,
-0.2201562225818634,
0.49149227142333984,
-0.47135427594184875,
0.6894509792327881,
0.1847798228263855,
-0.5939510464668274,
0.40478262305259705,
0.17000648379325867,
-0.2488776594400406,
-0.14427921175956726,
0.19230124354362488,
0.44847649335861206,
0.5464203953742981,
-0.5180204510688782,
-0.07999037206172943,
-0.005435888655483723,
-0.17587098479270935,
-0.6463427543640137,
-0.21447445452213287,
0.06932023912668228,
-0.6102559566497803,
-0.38465583324432373,
-0.35293179750442505,
-0.4734678566455841,
-0.13812366127967834,
-0.7451853156089783,
0.0994286835193634,
-0.92725670337677,
-0.2611386775970459,
0.23700958490371704,
-0.305441677570343,
0.12867221236228943,
0.6758956909179688,
-0.4300682842731476,
0.3034164011478424,
0.6335015892982483,
0.6369040608406067,
0.15357938408851624,
-0.3516666889190674,
-0.7214202880859375,
0.3211783468723297,
-0.43884068727493286,
0.5571079850196838,
-0.9112955331802368,
-0.06842555850744247,
-0.16651001572608948,
-0.36721688508987427,
-0.29688912630081177,
-0.21752341091632843,
0.2558785080909729,
-0.9033888578414917,
0.4642794728279114,
-0.38636043667793274,
-0.7133914232254028,
-0.3170873820781708,
0.2674790620803833,
-0.36167535185813904,
0.606823742389679,
0.3563846945762634,
-1.009271264076233,
1.0584996938705444,
-0.5862794518470764,
-0.505486011505127,
0.047578759491443634,
-0.19637861847877502,
-0.13443228602409363,
-0.33563053607940674,
0.18045839667320251,
0.397938996553421,
-0.16628512740135193,
0.29747986793518066,
-0.789090096950531,
0.23826003074645996,
0.02725077047944069,
-0.04387572780251503,
1.0312354564666748,
0.6223559975624084,
0.0026032987516373396,
-0.10660654306411743,
-0.929079532623291,
0.3102327287197113,
0.18330439925193787,
-0.47632333636283875,
-0.09863568842411041,
0.4863390028476715,
-0.22968704998493195,
0.44468411803245544,
-0.13684432208538055,
-0.5581459403038025,
0.43205541372299194,
0.04628521203994751,
0.612741231918335,
0.7662085890769958,
0.3990750014781952,
0.22071947157382965,
-0.62702876329422,
0.2724795639514923,
0.04993993416428566,
0.2188037782907486,
0.4678363800048828,
-0.2424144744873047,
-0.18473507463932037,
-0.14393648505210876,
0.4266979396343231,
0.5839741826057434,
-0.7828830480575562,
0.15477171540260315,
-0.3715270459651947,
-0.18118993937969208,
0.2864830493927002,
-0.12625837326049805,
0.15400710701942444,
0.9288781881332397,
0.4223126471042633,
-0.35151490569114685,
-0.5181317329406738,
-0.18813812732696533,
-0.2361447662115097,
-0.465906023979187,
-0.25519120693206787,
0.44234147667884827,
0.053973980247974396,
-0.280195027589798,
1.0134705305099487,
-0.6217835545539856,
-0.09321225434541702,
-0.2373657524585724,
0.14983594417572021,
0.03847963735461235,
0.1890794336795807,
0.6240084171295166,
-0.7722300291061401,
-0.1717126965522766,
-0.22298362851142883,
-0.9054617285728455,
-0.29982826113700867,
-0.07067552953958511,
0.20055124163627625,
0.02514679916203022,
0.7122176885604858,
-0.5962948799133301,
0.37781980633735657,
-0.1729770302772522,
-0.39548882842063904,
0.4298489987850189,
-0.06355730444192886,
0.21408264338970184,
-0.7838537096977234,
-0.215347021818161,
0.11209268122911453,
-0.5317915081977844,
-0.3063186705112457,
-0.13767531514167786,
-0.12639421224594116,
-0.19342060387134552,
-0.4142691493034363,
0.4855058193206787,
-0.03252081573009491,
0.04707903042435646,
0.2859399616718292,
0.15290167927742004,
-0.2522183656692505,
0.7000774145126343,
0.26114243268966675,
-0.12808796763420105,
0.3007186949253082,
-0.8240066766738892,
0.2507206201553345,
0.19647251069545746,
-0.3931035101413727,
0.5975566506385803,
-0.38289472460746765,
-0.07524919509887695,
-0.05453215166926384,
0.23632782697677612,
-0.3599153757095337,
-0.2171814888715744,
0.3409906327724457,
-0.3895413279533386,
0.6744375228881836,
-0.6469252109527588,
-0.5617815256118774,
-0.15427754819393158,
0.0481964647769928,
0.10525194555521011,
0.575802743434906,
-0.5249053835868835,
0.9103482961654663,
0.10788331925868988,
0.3537631332874298,
-0.46861210465431213,
-0.45631006360054016,
-0.3047359883785248,
-0.3514138460159302,
-0.7248246073722839,
0.2307555228471756,
0.27782633900642395,
-0.4849828779697418,
0.2414921075105667,
-0.6868394613265991,
-0.0166472177952528,
0.07854175567626953,
0.1683570295572281,
-0.17869384586811066,
-0.14338210225105286,
0.45709165930747986,
-0.10220775753259659,
-0.364871621131897,
0.015589246526360512,
-0.9149761199951172,
0.44430139660835266,
-0.036537136882543564,
-0.41011375188827515,
-0.40153759717941284,
-0.15047897398471832,
0.238251194357872,
-0.02556386962532997,
0.4567285478115082,
0.544125497341156,
-0.44278380274772644,
-0.586304247379303,
-0.2527358829975128,
0.014544043689966202,
-0.4625312387943268,
0.06027856096625328,
-0.4621957838535309,
-0.5241047143936157,
0.1928901970386505,
-0.3809373378753662,
0.2186003476381302,
0.5008163452148438,
0.06191537156701088,
-0.26852574944496155,
0.4606093168258667,
0.9148056507110596,
0.15824225544929504,
0.748649001121521,
-0.05247535929083824,
-0.15745306015014648,
-0.2702672779560089,
-0.5485466718673706,
-0.19308124482631683,
-0.22184021770954132,
-0.7614369988441467,
-0.34444814920425415,
0.19525806605815887,
0.44031989574432373,
-0.6943215727806091,
0.2272675335407257,
0.029487958177924156,
0.25329944491386414,
0.34950777888298035,
0.43131861090660095,
0.3810998201370239,
0.012646002694964409,
-0.6095014214515686,
-0.04256721958518028,
-1.0785448551177979,
-0.23720350861549377,
0.9873993992805481,
0.29699352383613586,
0.849080502986908,
0.01877056248486042,
0.7632516622543335,
0.6877867579460144,
0.0333385169506073,
-0.2225656360387802,
0.6094396710395813,
0.01043299213051796,
-0.22090047597885132,
-0.3028853237628937,
-0.7504509091377258,
-0.6229019165039062,
-0.3044789731502533,
-0.2242487370967865,
-0.9834234714508057,
0.3804454207420349,
0.28645652532577515,
0.10150668770074844,
0.8183189034461975,
-0.8281247615814209,
0.4500837028026581,
-0.2089553028345108,
-0.2782456576824188,
-0.2623828947544098,
-0.8139076828956604,
0.08917597681283951,
0.1826665997505188,
-0.0338924340903759,
-0.4228730797767639,
0.08609647303819656,
0.7029903531074524,
-0.548623263835907,
0.9164906740188599,
-0.4767290949821472,
0.4181266725063324,
0.23596814274787903,
0.40438538789749146,
0.4608278274536133,
0.30603688955307007,
0.12227825820446014,
0.02971058152616024,
0.16260133683681488,
-0.4750845730304718,
-0.5663507580757141,
0.2685054540634155,
-0.7072702050209045,
-0.47125303745269775,
-0.368303507566452,
-0.5550189018249512,
-0.48556384444236755,
0.4032694101333618,
-0.011639243923127651,
0.49783986806869507,
0.0981520339846611,
-0.045315008610486984,
0.6834306120872498,
-0.08542990684509277,
0.48362451791763306,
0.508246660232544,
-0.27397966384887695,
-0.05799850448966026,
0.6502307057380676,
0.19125154614448547,
0.3382297158241272,
1.0563478469848633,
0.38330045342445374,
-0.400393009185791,
-0.4120177626609802,
0.155072882771492,
0.18551144003868103,
-0.9294888973236084,
-0.0437040813267231,
-0.6078510284423828,
-0.11644987761974335,
-0.41942712664604187,
0.018524961546063423,
-0.12414879351854324,
-1.1970231533050537,
0.004392311442643404,
-0.19963769614696503,
0.6117343902587891,
0.4109373688697815,
-0.47113069891929626,
-0.2581728994846344,
-0.39942169189453125,
0.5211346745491028,
0.5773084163665771,
0.6082298755645752,
-0.03152962774038315,
-0.16674929857254028,
0.3039367198944092,
-0.21317315101623535,
-0.18931584060192108,
-0.7206628918647766,
0.04484044387936592,
0.19529561698436737,
0.6245620250701904,
0.7140862941741943,
0.22013124823570251,
0.5028359889984131,
-0.6713926196098328,
0.13848534226417542,
0.043387271463871,
-0.7045095562934875,
0.4215256869792938,
-0.44021880626678467,
0.012693289667367935,
0.13681571185588837,
0.47369763255119324,
-0.7944322228431702,
0.16559910774230957,
-0.9051831364631653,
-0.4070661664009094,
0.5617528557777405,
0.1754794716835022,
-0.6815311312675476,
0.07310421764850616,
0.40424877405166626,
0.04958758503198624,
0.3594099283218384,
-0.5338590145111084,
-0.050419606268405914,
-0.3822363018989563,
0.06862793117761612,
0.25929775834083557,
0.007073486223816872,
-0.22017231583595276,
0.09461769461631775,
0.3718116879463196,
-0.010880905203521252,
0.41423964500427246,
0.09492295980453491,
-0.17823055386543274,
-0.12823820114135742,
0.4748069643974304,
-0.0013123350217938423,
1.075337529182434,
-0.5990846753120422,
-0.01807909831404686,
0.347105473279953,
-0.12410558015108109,
-0.07044696807861328,
0.30895620584487915,
-0.11035498231649399,
-0.23395413160324097,
0.7953927516937256,
0.33175209164619446,
-0.01692306250333786,
-0.28458502888679504,
0.10212855041027069,
0.21797800064086914,
-0.15563681721687317,
-0.08004482835531235,
0.3430292308330536,
0.0005061978008598089,
0.762567400932312,
0.13621914386749268,
0.18926620483398438,
-0.3273073136806488,
-0.4292158782482147,
0.42305782437324524,
-0.2260962277650833,
-0.37406235933303833,
-0.1558280736207962,
0.7758193016052246,
-0.030630966648459435,
-0.5225508213043213,
0.7032122611999512,
-0.4008958637714386,
-0.4341301918029785,
0.4871104061603546,
0.24003931879997253,
0.7304038405418396,
0.16860494017601013,
0.23610632121562958,
0.15640266239643097,
0.3420490622520447,
0.18265090882778168,
0.355242520570755,
-0.47575733065605164,
-0.752457320690155,
-0.37127819657325745,
-0.44698333740234375,
-0.28561800718307495,
-0.12408701330423355,
-0.407754510641098,
0.12037144601345062,
-0.8068134188652039,
-0.07410774379968643,
0.024142414331436157,
0.34930822253227234,
-0.9685357809066772,
0.32326266169548035,
-0.18745461106300354,
1.4100708961486816,
-0.9269828796386719,
0.8949891328811646,
0.3342295289039612,
-0.5054901242256165,
-0.7904368042945862,
-0.12546831369400024,
0.23958978056907654,
-0.8155480027198792,
0.8433523774147034,
-0.19340452551841736,
-0.09447439759969711,
-0.28138038516044617,
-0.5472955107688904,
-0.44077175855636597,
1.2893263101577759,
0.19926656782627106,
-0.5588239431381226,
-0.370348185300827,
0.007094866596162319,
0.4942742586135864,
-0.4531812071800232,
-0.1241694912314415,
0.40670058131217957,
0.36496037244796753,
-0.012615103274583817,
-0.44705337285995483,
0.16878339648246765,
-0.09630703926086426,
-0.16184376180171967,
0.20230638980865479,
-0.6487910747528076,
0.6914168000221252,
-0.552354633808136,
-0.43368321657180786,
-0.41012001037597656,
0.578303337097168,
0.37557268142700195,
0.6805486679077148,
0.6732382774353027,
0.8589215874671936,
0.9038594365119934,
-0.14917930960655212,
1.110086441040039,
-0.03547678142786026,
0.18187275528907776,
1.339874267578125,
-0.2586142420768738,
0.38925862312316895,
0.29952511191368103,
-0.3819505274295807,
0.6874063014984131,
0.8030734062194824,
0.08298303931951523,
0.7177452445030212,
0.08969695121049881,
0.03130076825618744,
-0.6530051827430725,
0.18769791722297668,
-0.4335591495037079,
-0.21556389331817627,
0.2709544897079468,
-0.06778820604085922,
-0.6916172504425049,
-0.2923637628555298,
-0.0212288498878479,
0.040073212236166,
-0.2071792185306549,
0.3800073266029358,
0.15530569851398468,
-0.0663737878203392,
0.06198148801922798,
0.24552273750305176,
-0.04373132809996605,
-0.7703210115432739,
-0.2669678330421448,
-0.1744338572025299,
0.14872774481773376,
-0.24919946491718292,
-0.6459212899208069,
-0.004359448328614235,
-0.2785019874572754,
-0.2304488569498062,
-0.36020779609680176,
0.49786055088043213,
0.010496534407138824,
-0.12283273786306381,
0.3431704342365265,
0.4706282615661621,
-0.1404426395893097,
0.6397071480751038,
-0.8050997853279114,
-0.5397874116897583,
0.050279222428798676,
-0.0843854770064354,
0.08792302757501602,
1.0742708444595337,
-0.39583778381347656,
1.244167447090149,
0.5552235841751099,
0.07915814965963364,
0.25157636404037476,
0.06139638274908066,
0.8111846446990967,
-0.6058605909347534,
-0.5160535573959351,
-0.30461961030960083,
0.11859387904405594,
-0.01453383732587099,
-0.2655799984931946,
0.5283616185188293,
0.1899779736995697,
1.1644586324691772,
0.25927457213401794,
0.44713249802589417,
-0.5253311395645142,
0.7276946902275085,
-1.0826432704925537,
0.36002594232559204,
-0.3161223232746124,
0.760949969291687,
-0.1383482664823532,
-0.6606689095497131,
-0.1136932298541069,
0.2783578634262085,
-0.6328437924385071,
0.2746717631816864,
0.8343814611434937,
0.2874228358268738,
-0.40266290307044983,
0.1228199377655983,
-0.02435149997472763,
0.13723191618919373,
0.4993947446346283,
0.8198378682136536,
0.6450873613357544,
-0.012760289013385773,
0.45110535621643066,
-0.5123011469841003,
-0.04603416472673416,
0.12770694494247437,
-1.341591238975525,
-0.8760756850242615,
-0.5077990293502808,
-0.4184820055961609,
-0.39072689414024353,
0.287973016500473,
1.2215036153793335,
0.8167595863342285,
-0.5357576012611389,
0.016497453674674034,
-0.1728293001651764,
0.5807638168334961,
-0.5488376617431641,
-0.212860569357872,
0.5675830245018005,
-0.4437216818332672,
-0.12870676815509796,
0.25148239731788635,
0.054312609136104584,
0.027713775634765625,
0.4723200798034668,
-0.19558613002300262,
-0.3474752902984619,
-0.23001283407211304,
0.3870069682598114,
0.6895670294761658,
-0.21509936451911926,
-0.6788296103477478,
-0.2838408350944519,
0.3551030158996582,
0.12126628309488297,
1.0015623569488525,
-0.7450044751167297,
0.556661069393158,
0.621139407157898,
0.3745347857475281,
1.0360316038131714,
-0.28427019715309143,
0.4583527445793152,
-0.8695567846298218,
0.10638447850942612,
0.22659194469451904,
0.48023486137390137,
0.036568500101566315,
0.024108152836561203,
0.7804561853408813,
0.7440818548202515,
-0.2401684671640396,
-0.407970130443573,
0.5150406360626221,
-0.9950469136238098,
-0.4254676401615143,
1.0105929374694824,
-0.16889774799346924,
-0.13941706717014313,
-0.27270543575286865,
0.5834682583808899,
0.5142883062362671,
-0.3638761639595032,
0.8682082891464233,
0.2718765139579773,
-0.3739336133003235,
0.00851709395647049,
-0.5225112438201904,
0.6017597913742065,
-0.2934408187866211,
-0.7139021754264832,
-0.1983959972858429,
0.5372406244277954,
0.9035295844078064,
-0.06380345672369003,
0.5241235494613647,
-0.2422182261943817,
0.34227439761161804,
0.2809951901435852,
-0.4807356595993042,
-0.556320309638977,
-0.6470084190368652,
0.2875383198261261,
0.26347023248672485,
-0.018932297825813293,
-0.07086274772882462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12298v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12298v1 | Is Open-Source There Yet? A Comparative Study on Commercial and Open-Source LLMs in Their Ability to Label Chest X-Ray Reports | 2024-02-19T17:23:10 | 2024-02-19T17:23:10 | Felix J. Dorfner, Liv Jürgensen, Leonhard Donle, Fares Al Mohamad, Tobias R. Bodenmann, Mason C. Cleveland, Felix Busch, Lisa C. Adams, James Sato, Thomas Schultz, Albert E. Kim, Jameson Merkow, Keno K. Bressem, Christopher P. Bridge | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Introduction: With the rapid advances in large language models (LLMs), there
have been numerous new open source as well as commercial models. While recent
publications have explored GPT-4 in its application to extracting information
of interest from radiology reports, there has not been a real-world comparison
of GPT-4 to different leading open-source models.
Materials and Methods: Two different and independent datasets were used. The
first dataset consists of 540 chest x-ray reports that were created at the
Massachusetts General Hospital between July 2019 and July 2021. The second
dataset consists of 500 chest x-ray reports from the ImaGenome dataset. We then
compared the commercial models GPT-3.5 Turbo and GPT-4 from OpenAI to the
open-source models Mistral-7B, Mixtral-8x7B, Llama2-13B, Llama2-70B,
QWEN1.5-72B and CheXbert and CheXpert-labeler in their ability to accurately
label the presence of multiple findings in x-ray text reports using different
prompting techniques.
Results: On the ImaGenome dataset, the best performing open-source model was
Llama2-70B with micro F1-scores of 0.972 and 0.970 for zero- and few-shot
prompts, respectively. GPT-4 achieved micro F1-scores of 0.975 and 0.984,
respectively. On the institutional dataset, the best performing open-source
model was QWEN1.5-72B with micro F1-scores of 0.952 and 0.965 for zero- and
few-shot prompting, respectively. GPT-4 achieved micro F1-scores of 0.975 and
0.973, respectively.
Conclusion: In this paper, we show that while GPT-4 is superior to
open-source models in zero-shot report labeling, the implementation of few-shot
prompting can bring open-source models on par with GPT-4. This shows that
open-source models could be a performant and privacy preserving alternative to
GPT-4 for the task of radiology report classification. | [
-0.035947997123003006,
-0.20735076069831848,
0.9663217067718506,
-0.1527881920337677,
-0.33409106731414795,
-0.28327110409736633,
-0.037882011383771896,
-0.8357365727424622,
-0.11180442571640015,
0.36327189207077026,
-0.17156335711479187,
-0.8400910496711731,
-0.7719964981079102,
0.16729597747325897,
-0.29526758193969727,
1.021690011024475,
-0.21587924659252167,
0.20799730718135834,
0.019572971388697624,
-0.2454095184803009,
-0.23546889424324036,
-0.4298490285873413,
-0.5203951001167297,
-0.309173583984375,
0.5256028175354004,
0.03196112811565399,
0.8695992827415466,
0.6947107315063477,
0.7930673360824585,
0.2361859381198883,
-0.056356031447649,
-0.41926151514053345,
-0.2454097867012024,
-0.21154361963272095,
-0.1621621698141098,
-0.44218310713768005,
-0.5149811506271362,
0.36323094367980957,
0.5560411810874939,
0.08571472018957138,
0.160304993391037,
0.061020128428936005,
-0.22215542197227478,
0.5560320019721985,
-0.5057660937309265,
0.26545828580856323,
-0.1005065068602562,
0.13232076168060303,
-0.2629256844520569,
-0.15034614503383636,
-0.4331742525100708,
-0.5875966548919678,
0.37823235988616943,
-0.6137403845787048,
0.07548810541629791,
-0.02421921119093895,
0.9844799041748047,
0.05237426981329918,
-0.15192659199237823,
-0.6795802712440491,
-0.6051369905471802,
0.6771429181098938,
-0.7850025296211243,
0.477839857339859,
0.2769128978252411,
0.4504169821739197,
0.5332072973251343,
-1.0223374366760254,
-0.002687718253582716,
-0.42577508091926575,
-0.09698188304901123,
0.3971922695636749,
-0.792961835861206,
-0.008126786909997463,
0.04430300369858742,
0.5709239840507507,
-0.799542248249054,
0.3738167881965637,
-0.600313127040863,
-0.15202666819095612,
0.2680400609970093,
0.06844998151063919,
0.10513217747211456,
-0.1404052972793579,
-0.7776216864585876,
0.03633716702461243,
-0.9475796222686768,
-0.39954543113708496,
-0.12597821652889252,
0.13477756083011627,
-0.1620030552148819,
0.7037228941917419,
-0.29212939739227295,
0.5901655554771423,
-0.21847844123840332,
-0.29083213210105896,
0.4474191665649414,
-0.43078523874282837,
-0.4740155339241028,
0.3877323567867279,
0.9028379321098328,
0.26653817296028137,
-0.007800867781043053,
-0.011108539998531342,
-0.14646239578723907,
0.13284023106098175,
-0.13888145983219147,
-0.6792131066322327,
-0.23957830667495728,
0.20992785692214966,
-0.6922125816345215,
-0.6388084292411804,
0.0691799446940422,
-0.3480062782764435,
-0.4149046242237091,
-0.012538019567728043,
0.6630314588546753,
-0.3159988224506378,
-0.1295706331729889,
-0.0036248313263058662,
-0.025593629106879234,
0.1812765896320343,
0.42490267753601074,
-0.26551496982574463,
0.17915181815624237,
0.48269835114479065,
1.3582854270935059,
0.06707537174224854,
-0.010211644694209099,
-0.556532621383667,
0.106781005859375,
-0.3969684839248657,
1.0219095945358276,
-0.45069795846939087,
-0.475334495306015,
-0.15580399334430695,
-0.04784382879734039,
0.1023968756198883,
-0.6756296753883362,
0.4708913564682007,
-0.47768744826316833,
0.3036983907222748,
-0.29300743341445923,
-0.41647371649742126,
-0.1029292643070221,
0.35354262590408325,
-0.8345857858657837,
0.6305018663406372,
0.43467485904693604,
-0.689529538154602,
0.28184831142425537,
-0.4680740535259247,
0.16933411359786987,
0.15580037236213684,
-0.4904973804950714,
-0.5141028165817261,
0.019486073404550552,
0.22154642641544342,
0.2784609794616699,
-0.5687346458435059,
0.02286304347217083,
-0.08359219878911972,
-0.1996999979019165,
0.432941198348999,
-0.2924664616584778,
0.7727160453796387,
0.3288792669773102,
-0.3755825459957123,
0.09386931359767914,
-0.6161482334136963,
0.11921799927949905,
0.14465738832950592,
-0.33517882227897644,
-0.22148950397968292,
-0.395240843296051,
-0.45557117462158203,
0.4879050850868225,
-0.20502550899982452,
-0.9021717309951782,
0.01881524547934532,
-0.11576665937900543,
0.13705284893512726,
0.6703906059265137,
-0.027646774426102638,
0.0008566832984797657,
-0.6085329651832581,
0.9487961530685425,
0.05363955348730087,
0.15066979825496674,
-0.26702451705932617,
-0.8337824940681458,
-0.17832070589065552,
-0.5838147401809692,
0.3758561909198761,
0.5682224631309509,
-0.45439571142196655,
-0.16299785673618317,
-0.04704726114869118,
-0.5693776607513428,
-0.7961151003837585,
-0.21740838885307312,
0.7046085000038147,
0.7613930106163025,
0.2877500057220459,
-0.28352147340774536,
-0.308682918548584,
-0.9125901460647583,
-0.21022841334342957,
-0.11426270008087158,
-0.1709960252046585,
0.36466872692108154,
0.10397180169820786,
0.04367397353053093,
0.6070797443389893,
-0.8437244296073914,
-0.6538498997688293,
-0.01084639597684145,
0.22352950274944305,
0.2795214056968689,
-0.021332992240786552,
0.5723273158073425,
-0.21862980723381042,
-0.6837818026542664,
0.18944963812828064,
-1.080916404724121,
-0.27420830726623535,
0.38941481709480286,
0.16350413858890533,
0.4247541129589081,
0.4872366487979889,
-0.3911767899990082,
0.6292390823364258,
0.7447348237037659,
-0.0693933442234993,
0.5027074217796326,
-0.17875342071056366,
0.30867624282836914,
-0.7382831573486328,
0.06656806170940399,
0.30209434032440186,
-0.28711721301078796,
-0.6880391240119934,
-0.08733198046684265,
0.19823679327964783,
-0.32429373264312744,
-0.8760563731193542,
0.5951768755912781,
-0.7202730774879456,
-0.07799159735441208,
-0.24011923372745514,
0.05954257398843765,
-0.018206294625997543,
0.017926236614584923,
0.3153679072856903,
0.5175358057022095,
0.565017580986023,
-0.22713077068328857,
0.1296711266040802,
0.2292456179857254,
-0.6219931244850159,
0.3969920873641968,
-0.8172813057899475,
0.17427557706832886,
0.015115036629140377,
0.361788809299469,
-0.9269421696662903,
-0.03148762881755829,
0.5286571979522705,
-0.33456742763519287,
0.2209969460964203,
-0.23218148946762085,
-0.3963836133480072,
-0.5267634391784668,
-0.4803996682167053,
0.35655421018600464,
0.6915786266326904,
-0.4834285080432892,
0.11114772409200668,
-0.04811648651957512,
-0.38674184679985046,
-0.3246927261352539,
-0.9063591957092285,
-0.17662638425827026,
0.19132237136363983,
-0.5976161956787109,
0.19091998040676117,
-0.18669675290584564,
-0.24367131292819977,
0.3790280818939209,
-0.19697394967079163,
-0.20929859578609467,
-0.4477936029434204,
0.24202871322631836,
0.4239877760410309,
-0.4610874354839325,
-0.109774149954319,
-0.3191072642803192,
-0.4367693364620209,
-0.03189973905682564,
-0.35538235306739807,
0.03787216544151306,
-0.3863498568534851,
-0.38917016983032227,
-0.5045338273048401,
0.2307586520910263,
0.20998713374137878,
-0.11020459979772568,
0.47323134541511536,
0.5035781860351562,
-0.24819202721118927,
0.286171555519104,
-0.4441920518875122,
0.10439786314964294,
-0.4206845760345459,
0.08981367200613022,
-0.20247958600521088,
-1.0494028329849243,
0.20049557089805603,
0.14015686511993408,
-0.09789014607667923,
0.4130285084247589,
0.7733253240585327,
0.08010246604681015,
0.8071536421775818,
0.4071823060512543,
0.10072942823171616,
0.08042729645967484,
-0.12830102443695068,
0.28940698504447937,
-0.6456487774848938,
-0.16451554000377655,
-0.6605664491653442,
-0.03934936970472336,
-0.5983626246452332,
-0.3981133997440338,
0.8068287968635559,
-0.37903428077697754,
0.026832060888409615,
-0.2710088789463043,
-0.8105002045631409,
0.6413049697875977,
0.31496286392211914,
0.23506700992584229,
0.6974753141403198,
0.05494621396064758,
0.2891577184200287,
-0.0005104078445583582,
-0.6604120135307312,
-0.4299749433994293,
1.2821316719055176,
0.38842135667800903,
0.731096625328064,
0.23298975825309753,
0.8469181060791016,
0.11781974881887436,
0.6498981714248657,
-0.7431207895278931,
0.33114826679229736,
-0.3388907313346863,
-0.8519285917282104,
-0.0836082473397255,
-0.21629859507083893,
-1.1342957019805908,
0.2679453194141388,
0.06905949115753174,
-0.5980473160743713,
0.15218384563922882,
0.03664593771100044,
-0.5064202547073364,
0.3917251527309418,
-0.6421467065811157,
0.5457425713539124,
-0.245781809091568,
-0.21506065130233765,
0.3040378987789154,
-0.5871337652206421,
0.7383547425270081,
-0.33683228492736816,
0.4559992253780365,
-0.3105961084365845,
-0.2616631090641022,
0.631022036075592,
-0.6315528154373169,
0.8792685270309448,
-0.19391362369060516,
-0.3753851354122162,
0.5541231632232666,
-0.04537089914083481,
0.2853670120239258,
-0.1395641267299652,
-0.1074552983045578,
0.4469446837902069,
0.09932509064674377,
-0.0979914739727974,
-0.2692407965660095,
0.9976066946983337,
-0.9672523736953735,
-0.47613465785980225,
-0.8892186284065247,
-0.3394985795021057,
0.16317927837371826,
0.4443638324737549,
0.6435420513153076,
0.8626090884208679,
-0.08776143193244934,
0.025607893243432045,
0.6412485241889954,
-0.4425729811191559,
0.16308757662773132,
0.8290096521377563,
-0.15199939906597137,
-0.6973683834075928,
0.8056352734565735,
0.5721220374107361,
0.355671226978302,
0.40396299958229065,
0.691154956817627,
-0.23114262521266937,
-0.5392066240310669,
-0.21988078951835632,
0.5628267526626587,
-0.8724275827407837,
-0.44429898262023926,
-0.5151671767234802,
-0.29697278141975403,
-0.3862279951572418,
-0.3095070421695709,
-0.24538907408714294,
-0.37163645029067993,
-0.10781361162662506,
-0.16785486042499542,
0.38691428303718567,
1.2062022686004639,
-0.22110974788665771,
0.11622466146945953,
-0.9450049996376038,
0.1890127807855606,
0.08488977700471878,
0.611499011516571,
-0.14207415282726288,
-0.39146512746810913,
-0.2701374590396881,
-0.34242701530456543,
-0.2712828516960144,
-1.0716561079025269,
0.31406447291374207,
-0.20085614919662476,
0.5100979804992676,
0.18494075536727905,
0.04949161037802696,
0.18502898514270782,
-0.2574564516544342,
0.9193034768104553,
0.30623942613601685,
-0.8489676117897034,
0.6590725183486938,
-0.5561748147010803,
0.6668961048126221,
0.24077345430850983,
0.8548769354820251,
-0.2042999416589737,
-0.3910832703113556,
-0.6822647452354431,
-0.7498805522918701,
1.0450375080108643,
0.2009383738040924,
-0.5236246585845947,
-0.15428587794303894,
0.1416558474302292,
0.3776805102825165,
0.14592254161834717,
-0.8666921854019165,
-0.023538270965218544,
-0.20999133586883545,
-0.07580098509788513,
-0.10428486764431,
-0.28851187229156494,
-0.2591349184513092,
-0.006681540980935097,
0.6202399134635925,
0.02373490110039711,
0.5915025472640991,
0.4631894528865814,
-0.011733212508261204,
-0.12301433831453323,
0.3730473220348358,
0.6204657554626465,
0.7548301815986633,
-0.5010022521018982,
0.24635101854801178,
-0.28880077600479126,
-0.38362687826156616,
0.3775128424167633,
0.08552008867263794,
-0.17203688621520996,
0.21937696635723114,
0.3671967089176178,
0.6682782173156738,
0.2265556901693344,
-0.28582173585891724,
0.656740665435791,
-0.0326351597905159,
-0.8069228529930115,
-0.20432503521442413,
-0.19222567975521088,
0.07493310421705246,
0.30625542998313904,
-0.0939289852976799,
-0.1660412847995758,
0.08702881634235382,
-0.42057889699935913,
0.0047136456705629826,
0.09841854125261307,
-0.5874569416046143,
-0.31771454215049744,
0.8455597162246704,
-0.07582999020814896,
0.05509096011519432,
0.7125310301780701,
0.026579290628433228,
0.17208577692508698,
0.4448833167552948,
0.5838826894760132,
0.8785946369171143,
-0.44447094202041626,
0.4294862151145935,
0.4641484022140503,
0.41884756088256836,
-0.059486791491508484,
0.3160652816295624,
0.21693019568920135,
-0.367342472076416,
-0.26817435026168823,
-0.08440391719341278,
-0.6020427942276001,
0.3723753094673157,
-0.7666614651679993,
0.2222064733505249,
-0.6609176993370056,
-0.1860182285308838,
0.16817474365234375,
-0.23952245712280273,
-0.6401940584182739,
0.2984190285205841,
0.2775983512401581,
0.9792280197143555,
-0.7970864176750183,
0.8280715942382812,
0.6616343855857849,
-0.6820843815803528,
-0.8136772513389587,
-0.31205353140830994,
0.5537226796150208,
-0.8034960031509399,
0.5154897570610046,
0.2149103581905365,
0.02798299305140972,
-0.0527321919798851,
-0.4563896358013153,
-1.0964006185531616,
1.4226924180984497,
0.21406571567058563,
-0.447016179561615,
0.06275052577257156,
0.11285743862390518,
0.4112798273563385,
-0.15309277176856995,
0.48742249608039856,
0.5100942850112915,
0.48874431848526,
0.19047261774539948,
-0.9900689125061035,
0.26458993554115295,
-0.08269958198070526,
-0.2569308876991272,
0.2979285418987274,
-0.7791138887405396,
0.8379737138748169,
-0.17499031126499176,
-0.16857124865055084,
0.2157779335975647,
0.283894807100296,
0.5018885135650635,
0.6826462745666504,
0.10044699907302856,
0.5825902819633484,
0.7200244665145874,
-0.08823354542255402,
1.4312803745269775,
0.050530318170785904,
0.14525055885314941,
0.9722190499305725,
-0.5187686681747437,
0.6882498264312744,
-0.027098773047327995,
-0.09435329586267471,
0.4561944901943207,
0.4286191463470459,
-0.11362985521554947,
0.5244786143302917,
-0.037614814937114716,
-0.2994168996810913,
0.2679119408130646,
0.010405024513602257,
-0.653709352016449,
0.17136074602603912,
0.1273820847272873,
-0.5302197933197021,
-0.3616570830345154,
0.023216689005494118,
0.3325589895248413,
-0.46768155694007874,
-0.2935975193977356,
0.8402643799781799,
0.23661278188228607,
-0.4763861298561096,
0.7967343926429749,
-0.11096140742301941,
0.4084390103816986,
-0.9603139758110046,
0.2710931897163391,
-0.137419193983078,
0.25837770104408264,
-0.4806854724884033,
-0.9160100817680359,
0.34839415550231934,
0.24530915915966034,
-0.15957821905612946,
-0.0525486133992672,
0.7578492164611816,
-0.22577868402004242,
-0.27331995964050293,
0.21328607201576233,
0.5003622770309448,
0.4454774260520935,
0.04299484193325043,
-0.5391107797622681,
0.4479864537715912,
0.11033972352743149,
-0.2816051244735718,
0.6442880034446716,
0.18897265195846558,
-0.15834400057792664,
0.3624608814716339,
0.3312632739543915,
0.19516949355602264,
0.047791995108127594,
0.008214033208787441,
0.9230020046234131,
-0.635463297367096,
-0.3613198697566986,
-0.5145217180252075,
0.3544585108757019,
0.26501673460006714,
-0.1767655313014984,
0.7400922775268555,
0.568020224571228,
0.7769949436187744,
-0.12657535076141357,
1.1060020923614502,
0.2132670283317566,
0.4826679825782776,
-0.7137038707733154,
0.3307284414768219,
-0.3314540684223175,
0.324795126914978,
-0.3585756719112396,
-0.7657503485679626,
-0.5783397555351257,
0.30065393447875977,
-0.43479958176612854,
0.07474808394908905,
1.0470850467681885,
0.8682247400283813,
-0.1292532980442047,
0.1482527256011963,
0.34517747163772583,
0.3656681180000305,
0.48529016971588135,
0.4761275053024292,
0.8443071246147156,
-0.21505135297775269,
0.8244043588638306,
-0.3517104387283325,
-0.7144292593002319,
-0.04711879417300224,
-0.891776978969574,
-0.6110013723373413,
-0.2322934865951538,
-0.7373850345611572,
-0.3965674042701721,
0.15957802534103394,
0.446990430355072,
0.5669164061546326,
-0.4804936647415161,
-0.025957150384783745,
0.4028068780899048,
-0.29278048872947693,
-0.22823433578014374,
-0.14618852734565735,
0.490431547164917,
-0.054522931575775146,
-0.34679627418518066,
0.5274211764335632,
0.531347930431366,
0.14162114262580872,
-0.04336683452129364,
-0.08366061747074127,
-0.08420930057764053,
0.12120094150304794,
0.6930261850357056,
0.405099093914032,
-0.7591379880905151,
0.011533770710229874,
-0.09293118119239807,
-0.08976307511329651,
0.34120267629623413,
0.815369725227356,
-0.8047292232513428,
0.686779797077179,
0.5206661224365234,
0.2541320323944092,
0.5921093821525574,
-0.14914703369140625,
0.25294479727745056,
-0.5852392315864563,
-0.07897218316793442,
0.07449828833341599,
0.1870133876800537,
0.21693114936351776,
-0.4224020838737488,
0.689470648765564,
0.10408965498209,
-0.9030013680458069,
-0.6528732776641846,
0.08159942179918289,
-0.8980711698532104,
-0.4848593473434448,
1.0572973489761353,
-0.2482070028781891,
-0.2623380720615387,
-0.016905266791582108,
-0.2389606088399887,
0.03473949059844017,
-0.30312901735305786,
0.2757405638694763,
0.46347957849502563,
-0.4792782664299011,
-0.3755340278148651,
-0.6911832690238953,
0.23637856543064117,
0.04799987003207207,
-0.7274929285049438,
-0.27201011776924133,
0.5734109878540039,
0.48016491532325745,
0.07229356467723846,
1.3104820251464844,
-0.7093923687934875,
0.44083642959594727,
-0.0011611536610871553,
-0.01566639356315136,
-0.48521631956100464,
-0.146993488073349,
-0.741631805896759,
0.2781064510345459,
0.34590864181518555,
-0.3071768283843994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12291v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12291v1 | KARL: Knowledge-Aware Retrieval and Representations aid Retention and Learning in Students | 2024-02-19T17:05:29 | 2024-02-19T17:05:29 | Matthew Shu, Nishant Balepur, Shi Feng, Jordan Boyd-Graber | cs.CL | cs.CL | Flashcard schedulers are tools that rely on 1) student models to predict the
flashcards a student knows; and 2) teaching policies to schedule cards based on
these predictions. Existing student models, however, only use flashcard-level
features, like the student's past responses, ignoring the semantic ties of
flashcards. Deep Knowledge Tracing (DKT) models can capture semantic relations
with language models, but are inefficient, lack content-rich datasets for
evaluation, and require robust teaching policies. To address these issues, we
design KARL, a DKT-inspired student model that uses retrieval and BERT
embeddings for efficient and accurate student recall predictions. To test KARL,
we collect a new dataset of diverse study history on trivia questions. KARL
bests existing student models in AUC and calibration error. Finally, we propose
a novel teaching policy that exploits the predictive power of DKT models to
deploy KARL online. Based on 27 learners and 32 6-day study trajectories, KARL
shows the ability to enhance medium-term educational learning, proving its
efficacy for scheduling. | [
-0.07760576158761978,
-0.6554772853851318,
0.7778289318084717,
-0.14101055264472961,
-0.044331349432468414,
0.32339704036712646,
-0.00029861342045478523,
-0.1754344403743744,
0.09416445344686508,
0.46722328662872314,
-0.3644088804721832,
-0.6682303547859192,
-0.17022740840911865,
-0.22542963922023773,
-0.4950657784938812,
1.0627421140670776,
0.015563998371362686,
0.009851166978478432,
-0.3935096263885498,
0.125572070479393,
-0.6142696738243103,
-0.23435881733894348,
-0.43996092677116394,
-0.524152934551239,
0.572053074836731,
0.41241952776908875,
0.6998911499977112,
0.7250514626502991,
0.1546075940132141,
0.07687903940677643,
-0.08920962363481522,
-0.15383613109588623,
-0.5461605191230774,
-0.015171217732131481,
-0.15867403149604797,
-0.5571601986885071,
-0.43948209285736084,
-0.2789030969142914,
0.8694193959236145,
0.9145429730415344,
-0.43443599343299866,
0.0909232497215271,
0.020754221826791763,
0.4877961277961731,
-0.542214035987854,
0.1739778071641922,
-0.4088166356086731,
0.055709108710289,
0.11021143198013306,
-0.08454140275716782,
-0.5007743239402771,
-0.9306894540786743,
0.7443104982376099,
-0.8798482418060303,
0.24250510334968567,
-0.16487368941307068,
0.3997866213321686,
0.04250694438815117,
-0.5505457520484924,
-0.26908618211746216,
-0.8130179047584534,
0.7846038341522217,
-0.5808685421943665,
0.5412482619285583,
0.4884955585002899,
0.6900649070739746,
0.16563940048217773,
-0.6481313109397888,
-0.5793970823287964,
-0.07124870270490646,
-0.17543892562389374,
0.12491247802972794,
0.19901128113269806,
0.01498828548938036,
0.23904046416282654,
-0.045968540012836456,
-0.5219320058822632,
-0.03441651538014412,
-0.5237376689910889,
-0.17784294486045837,
0.4358091950416565,
0.4917968511581421,
-0.026276063174009323,
0.053300801664590836,
-0.6372530460357666,
-0.1540864259004593,
-0.7865275144577026,
-0.15701405704021454,
0.43053963780403137,
0.2018367350101471,
0.23431408405303955,
0.2441708743572235,
0.011808236129581928,
0.8416405320167542,
-0.22822289168834686,
-0.2213660627603531,
-0.23112176358699799,
-0.1835334300994873,
0.07858719676733017,
0.29623231291770935,
-0.09988970309495926,
0.06381262093782425,
0.2537516951560974,
-0.2589848041534424,
-0.07998189330101013,
-0.10640190541744232,
0.3020603060722351,
-0.7185290455818176,
-0.7184054255485535,
-0.07087192684412003,
-0.22004836797714233,
-0.051052458584308624,
-0.03203226625919342,
-0.8865112662315369,
-0.34276390075683594,
-0.48511749505996704,
0.9412476420402527,
-0.6878020763397217,
-0.2560727596282959,
0.19152960181236267,
-0.19471591711044312,
0.15976226329803467,
0.604518711566925,
-0.760657787322998,
0.20014530420303345,
0.6314193606376648,
0.3378383219242096,
-0.09465067088603973,
-0.2650042176246643,
-0.19332586228847504,
0.4864250123500824,
-0.3443438708782196,
0.48745548725128174,
-0.7853050231933594,
-0.32710832357406616,
0.4725842773914337,
-0.29526811838150024,
-0.04863329604268074,
-0.31042301654815674,
-0.0105142742395401,
-0.7357662916183472,
0.2554592490196228,
-0.5530248880386353,
-1.173357367515564,
-0.4705088436603546,
0.11185217648744583,
-0.6889591217041016,
0.9416657090187073,
0.20199783146381378,
-0.30705806612968445,
0.47547540068626404,
-0.27951735258102417,
-0.44389253854751587,
0.35956791043281555,
-0.15499715507030487,
-0.22410684823989868,
-0.21001392602920532,
-0.14085331559181213,
0.6682588458061218,
0.07287633419036865,
0.6621219515800476,
-0.3176664113998413,
-0.6246647834777832,
-0.021482426673173904,
-0.06531678885221481,
0.7377324104309082,
0.08593427389860153,
-0.19811664521694183,
-0.11540365219116211,
-0.8455671668052673,
-0.06497755646705627,
0.05155123770236969,
-0.6704007983207703,
-0.7069292068481445,
0.10504820942878723,
0.01846698857843876,
-0.07018059492111206,
0.10681718587875366,
-0.5422004461288452,
0.3760069012641907,
0.04731638357043266,
0.07903879880905151,
0.911600649356842,
-0.005877434276044369,
0.5209034085273743,
-0.4587104022502899,
0.5550912022590637,
-0.13100802898406982,
0.01826946809887886,
-0.35286998748779297,
-0.22218725085258484,
-0.7723122239112854,
0.10462114214897156,
0.08562559634447098,
0.3355233371257782,
-0.6829971075057983,
0.04796735197305679,
-0.3139364421367645,
-0.5441157221794128,
-0.46802905201911926,
0.2674201428890228,
0.492368221282959,
0.5292463898658752,
0.4536451995372772,
-0.019256478175520897,
-0.235818549990654,
-0.6048705577850342,
-0.12709780037403107,
0.11117076128721237,
0.17363014817237854,
0.42168721556663513,
0.5084826350212097,
0.027316126972436905,
1.083327054977417,
-0.682216227054596,
-0.26233798265457153,
-0.5431069135665894,
0.024444112554192543,
0.022065626457333565,
0.5353267192840576,
0.6376601457595825,
-0.5869229435920715,
-0.6893670558929443,
-0.3634756803512573,
-0.5901304483413696,
0.37467527389526367,
-0.24117527902126312,
-0.0169066209346056,
0.4529288113117218,
0.19947387278079987,
-0.13388869166374207,
0.5349075794219971,
-0.17925463616847992,
-0.7532075643539429,
0.3244963586330414,
-0.22323845326900482,
-0.22297847270965576,
-0.7314395904541016,
0.015989016741514206,
-0.38873904943466187,
-0.16189445555210114,
-0.48197007179260254,
-0.5018953084945679,
0.2005458027124405,
-0.2558022141456604,
-0.41944873332977295,
0.7106931209564209,
-0.16388195753097534,
-0.1863238364458084,
-0.0070107607170939445,
0.06695140898227692,
0.1809055507183075,
0.36648890376091003,
0.032330408692359924,
0.5462266206741333,
0.5019114017486572,
-0.9411638975143433,
0.04541415721178055,
0.3474719822406769,
-0.48515287041664124,
0.8836699724197388,
-0.4450390934944153,
0.08583123236894608,
-0.27380090951919556,
0.2704203724861145,
-0.9224740266799927,
0.02775183878839016,
-0.23631209135055542,
-0.1657041311264038,
0.5845531821250916,
-0.1766899824142456,
-0.4766407608985901,
-0.2791542410850525,
-0.059895627200603485,
0.3578989505767822,
0.7850115895271301,
-0.9722914695739746,
0.8126960396766663,
0.24234500527381897,
0.1624041497707367,
-0.6287533044815063,
-0.12190733850002289,
-0.4729393720626831,
-0.2679547369480133,
-0.27316391468048096,
0.22702611982822418,
-0.12896335124969482,
-0.05597173050045967,
0.3683578073978424,
-0.28037187457084656,
-0.20507249236106873,
0.18916310369968414,
-0.06333905458450317,
0.48982471227645874,
-0.07714074850082397,
0.6442379951477051,
0.01316931564360857,
-0.02517322637140751,
0.10734158009290695,
-0.6098005771636963,
0.45167076587677,
0.11231686919927597,
-0.15161825716495514,
-0.4441658556461334,
0.29293709993362427,
0.27960315346717834,
0.12946230173110962,
0.4433780014514923,
0.8356179594993591,
-0.32420283555984497,
-0.6171627044677734,
-0.8329552412033081,
-0.6475682258605957,
-0.452984482049942,
0.27983132004737854,
-0.02604166604578495,
-0.92609041929245,
0.4831676483154297,
0.05757387354969978,
0.20194780826568604,
0.25090813636779785,
-0.08602555096149445,
-0.43423038721084595,
0.6171739101409912,
0.8823667764663696,
0.2211305797100067,
0.45832133293151855,
-0.4684503376483917,
-0.03012484312057495,
-0.563029408454895,
-0.5169624090194702,
-0.04498816281557083,
-0.3259638845920563,
-0.13554759323596954,
0.025606559589505196,
0.188393697142601,
-0.08858375996351242,
-0.5078731775283813,
0.31912922859191895,
-0.4080713987350464,
0.5544582009315491,
0.8807919025421143,
0.11662063747644424,
0.027088817209005356,
-0.1698458194732666,
-0.169931098818779,
-0.048593923449516296,
-0.982585608959198,
-0.40426555275917053,
1.431755542755127,
0.11302518099546432,
0.8746363520622253,
0.02164464071393013,
0.9159591197967529,
0.3096575438976288,
0.060173701494932175,
-0.3011592626571655,
0.7353381514549255,
0.06961724162101746,
-1.0438944101333618,
-0.36660853028297424,
-0.3244791328907013,
-0.8033924698829651,
-0.10546702891588211,
-0.22161619365215302,
-0.7030522227287292,
0.10878488421440125,
0.35938549041748047,
-0.7877401113510132,
0.5563714504241943,
-0.5581299662590027,
0.8317760825157166,
-0.29010218381881714,
-0.7324210405349731,
-0.6075912117958069,
-0.6995935440063477,
0.0743272602558136,
-0.05722625181078911,
-0.18563425540924072,
-0.2505478858947754,
0.2948329448699951,
1.144120216369629,
-0.18575812876224518,
1.2013545036315918,
-0.39658623933792114,
0.16186563670635223,
0.674357533454895,
0.459423303604126,
0.39739713072776794,
-0.019519856199622154,
0.14013518393039703,
-0.31820499897003174,
0.42649003863334656,
-0.43530741333961487,
-0.7212366461753845,
0.6775298118591309,
-0.4785228371620178,
-0.5576809048652649,
-0.5064008831977844,
-0.629178524017334,
-0.019252749159932137,
0.14885751903057098,
-0.2870385944843292,
0.5391367673873901,
-0.07087067514657974,
0.13713078200817108,
1.0143241882324219,
-0.2789369225502014,
0.6558476686477661,
0.8281466960906982,
-0.2854228615760803,
-0.16410700976848602,
1.3424476385116577,
0.4996047019958496,
0.27550143003463745,
0.4277729094028473,
0.357418954372406,
-0.36625075340270996,
-0.1284303516149521,
-0.1353525072336197,
0.2456739842891693,
-1.067469835281372,
-0.17019236087799072,
-0.5233033895492554,
0.08018403500318527,
-0.5228714346885681,
-0.5968812108039856,
-0.3445042371749878,
-0.6296082139015198,
-0.4170287847518921,
-0.30728235840797424,
0.5067702531814575,
1.075174331665039,
-0.10008182376623154,
0.39106637239456177,
-0.43172818422317505,
-0.2301134169101715,
0.7237512469291687,
0.5467342734336853,
0.423799604177475,
-0.35976943373680115,
-0.1181369423866272,
-0.3664747476577759,
-0.38075149059295654,
-0.7008479237556458,
0.3105449676513672,
0.20224256813526154,
0.6445756554603577,
0.41976025700569153,
0.21535144746303558,
0.47466471791267395,
-0.1984153836965561,
0.5132591724395752,
-0.11770819127559662,
-0.7293246984481812,
0.7307600378990173,
-0.4773792326450348,
0.13822463154792786,
0.5276821255683899,
0.5483410358428955,
-0.3238580822944641,
-0.025628404691815376,
-0.878284752368927,
-0.8445764780044556,
0.6694897413253784,
-0.3508659303188324,
0.23886501789093018,
0.08954136073589325,
0.48309820890426636,
0.5126103162765503,
0.34003928303718567,
-0.35068389773368835,
-0.22152718901634216,
-0.29407021403312683,
-0.28287550806999207,
-0.1200343668460846,
-0.7586908936500549,
0.008561206981539726,
-0.4662684202194214,
0.5725078582763672,
0.023109430447220802,
0.23114129900932312,
0.12744249403476715,
0.016134943813085556,
0.2934938669204712,
0.2660748362541199,
0.5416846871376038,
1.0138764381408691,
-0.5517215728759766,
0.19114947319030762,
0.1892952024936676,
-0.5619619488716125,
-0.08029361069202423,
0.022739021107554436,
-0.46567267179489136,
0.17529311776161194,
0.243351012468338,
0.3917173147201538,
0.7635261416435242,
-0.5823957324028015,
0.3216801583766937,
0.3590097427368164,
0.007403079885989428,
-0.8527417778968811,
0.22527508437633514,
-0.009912828914821148,
0.29214781522750854,
0.4388381242752075,
-0.4659593105316162,
-0.0017023407854139805,
-0.4771558344364166,
0.5491241216659546,
0.14571444690227509,
-0.5088849663734436,
-0.38289013504981995,
0.7308842539787292,
0.1699669510126114,
-0.24705612659454346,
0.8222730159759521,
-0.10891061276197433,
-0.6406751871109009,
0.6661748290061951,
0.8213594555854797,
0.48903000354766846,
-0.35654446482658386,
0.4827330708503723,
0.6832868456840515,
0.02010386250913143,
-0.22090275585651398,
0.5682371258735657,
-0.30637243390083313,
-0.3077324628829956,
0.059623729437589645,
-0.5311391949653625,
-0.4520616829395294,
-0.3851637840270996,
-0.7854852676391602,
0.10706177353858948,
-0.48667657375335693,
-0.07647831737995148,
-0.2533523440361023,
0.22867707908153534,
-0.9831246137619019,
-0.004649320617318153,
-0.0014997739344835281,
0.8276587724685669,
-0.8255158066749573,
1.1134566068649292,
0.48491254448890686,
-0.3245009779930115,
-0.8122853636741638,
-0.4444672167301178,
0.006682687439024448,
-0.7989214658737183,
0.7072815895080566,
0.13131682574748993,
0.44471925497055054,
0.3576219975948334,
-0.3991679549217224,
-0.9708791971206665,
1.5485163927078247,
0.21908646821975708,
-0.4091622233390808,
-0.10420800000429153,
-0.08698483556509018,
0.28859490156173706,
-0.3979841470718384,
0.10627596825361252,
0.5627522468566895,
0.37952691316604614,
0.37710803747177124,
-0.6030229330062866,
0.0006754288915544748,
0.3550626337528229,
-0.27534720301628113,
0.13110151886940002,
-0.3125833570957184,
0.8195698857307434,
-0.63688725233078,
-0.2359386682510376,
-0.42188405990600586,
0.5318730473518372,
-0.018015336245298386,
0.7036268711090088,
0.1164245530962944,
0.7174156308174133,
0.9918006658554077,
-0.14952664077281952,
1.0961114168167114,
0.0025629031006246805,
0.25689780712127686,
1.2870032787322998,
-0.12841594219207764,
0.732020914554596,
0.4043242335319519,
-0.03651425987482071,
0.5474949479103088,
0.33975890278816223,
-0.2747504711151123,
0.8141521215438843,
0.1502818763256073,
-0.212254136800766,
-0.5728670954704285,
-0.21944551169872284,
-0.37275832891464233,
0.25058218836784363,
0.32869794964790344,
-0.27214542031288147,
-0.42406022548675537,
0.12371207773685455,
0.28644880652427673,
0.1728990375995636,
-0.474720299243927,
0.5981596112251282,
-0.1153845563530922,
-0.7740281224250793,
0.2818819284439087,
-0.6978246569633484,
0.29783761501312256,
-0.5665594935417175,
-0.32015010714530945,
-0.2847796082496643,
0.5856116414070129,
0.05673416331410408,
-0.7906537055969238,
0.02366335317492485,
-0.64094477891922,
0.14919379353523254,
-0.3046129047870636,
0.4947441518306732,
-0.782784104347229,
-0.5317789912223816,
0.29452621936798096,
0.3378503620624542,
0.026733148843050003,
0.5078447461128235,
-0.3230709731578827,
-0.07180190086364746,
-0.07548688352108002,
0.02730627730488777,
0.3068041503429413,
0.06850779801607132,
0.17775149643421173,
0.9458841681480408,
0.31984177231788635,
-0.19591957330703735,
0.2747364342212677,
-0.12954922020435333,
0.6276735067367554,
-0.6081312298774719,
-0.3679240047931671,
-0.7161242365837097,
0.41477084159851074,
0.07723803073167801,
-0.28580960631370544,
0.8473107218742371,
0.6548401713371277,
1.0230849981307983,
-0.08852599561214447,
0.6436042189598083,
0.2714919447898865,
0.5814018845558167,
-0.3250036835670471,
0.9267147183418274,
-0.3748414218425751,
0.2626054584980011,
-0.20499946177005768,
-0.7264849543571472,
-0.039675384759902954,
0.7052948474884033,
-0.23358510434627533,
-0.0995224341750145,
0.5462658405303955,
0.17229898273944855,
0.13998855650424957,
0.14388248324394226,
0.2250644862651825,
-0.15511159598827362,
0.360675185918808,
0.8287469148635864,
0.6397563219070435,
-0.154697984457016,
0.5727130174636841,
-0.6171376705169678,
0.007817881181836128,
-0.3303077518939972,
-0.62965989112854,
-1.2575958967208862,
-0.8363790512084961,
-0.4486045241355896,
-0.21644900739192963,
0.30133095383644104,
0.6685259342193604,
0.4755874574184418,
-0.5650343298912048,
-0.22474882006645203,
0.19155378639698029,
0.5720348954200745,
-0.2610006034374237,
-0.24280275404453278,
0.8269649147987366,
-0.3735843598842621,
-0.2926531732082367,
0.16231897473335266,
-0.20023471117019653,
0.5083796381950378,
-0.1976928561925888,
0.034150414168834686,
-0.2184259444475174,
-0.07093966007232666,
0.506860613822937,
0.2705346643924713,
-0.5848677158355713,
-0.5022790431976318,
0.3679831326007843,
0.023401882499456406,
-0.3512561619281769,
0.7803801894187927,
-1.0794531106948853,
0.7596628665924072,
0.41696426272392273,
0.6352453827857971,
0.5715675950050354,
-0.14227820932865143,
0.5814542770385742,
-0.3664838969707489,
-0.25289034843444824,
0.6612173914909363,
0.13575959205627441,
0.1278788149356842,
-0.29900842905044556,
0.5165759325027466,
0.27961552143096924,
-0.47946470975875854,
-0.942609429359436,
0.11641601473093033,
-0.865895688533783,
-0.22468918561935425,
1.0285818576812744,
-0.20916831493377686,
-0.05018831416964531,
-0.4086046516895294,
0.2892070710659027,
0.05454877018928528,
-0.3706275224685669,
1.089468002319336,
0.6581708192825317,
-0.01104005053639412,
0.1215692013502121,
-0.9172912240028381,
0.6401588320732117,
0.32995671033859253,
-0.212424173951149,
0.16076286137104034,
0.3838202953338623,
0.47297099232673645,
0.1384040117263794,
0.6318623423576355,
0.20653711259365082,
0.2825886607170105,
-0.05738373473286629,
-0.09271465241909027,
-0.30289262533187866,
-0.8455798029899597,
0.031137924641370773,
0.2292003482580185,
-0.3763592541217804,
-0.13368956744670868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12282v1 | Ontology Enhanced Claim Detection | 2024-02-19T16:50:58 | 2024-02-19T16:50:58 | Zehra Melce Hüsünbeyi, Tatjana Scheffler | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose an ontology enhanced model for sentence based claim detection. We
fused ontology embeddings from a knowledge base with BERT sentence embeddings
to perform claim detection for the ClaimBuster and the NewsClaims datasets. Our
ontology enhanced approach showed the best results with these small-sized
unbalanced datasets, compared to other statistical and neural machine learning
models. The experiments demonstrate that adding domain specific features
(either trained word embeddings or knowledge graph metadata) can improve
traditional ML methods. In addition, adding domain knowledge in the form of
ontology embeddings helps avoid the bias encountered in neural network based
models, for example the pure BERT model bias towards larger classes in our
small corpus. | [
-0.09072160720825195,
-0.5721555352210999,
0.5178916454315186,
0.061261098831892014,
0.26531341671943665,
-0.08269943296909332,
-0.009695508517324924,
-0.5991982817649841,
0.45902860164642334,
0.9493168592453003,
-0.3520287573337555,
-0.2537040114402771,
-0.6883576512336731,
-0.06290961802005768,
-0.3410407304763794,
1.0242984294891357,
0.2760053277015686,
0.1043897345662117,
-0.38062119483947754,
0.057597313076257706,
-0.4499969482421875,
-0.3722403347492218,
-0.2219984084367752,
-0.5561078786849976,
0.2285756766796112,
0.341417133808136,
0.7856729626655579,
0.18282610177993774,
0.5610539317131042,
0.21528127789497375,
0.010228455998003483,
0.26156187057495117,
-0.01784955896437168,
-0.007188199553638697,
-0.18298448622226715,
-0.8080732822418213,
-0.613048255443573,
-0.1385626196861267,
0.5351312160491943,
0.6126464009284973,
-0.21282249689102173,
0.11970788240432739,
-0.04103570803999901,
0.3238665461540222,
-0.6886605024337769,
0.17577704787254333,
-0.9210187792778015,
0.32550162076950073,
-0.09178207069635391,
-0.2782727777957916,
-0.5016757249832153,
-0.35824814438819885,
0.634829580783844,
-0.5224749445915222,
0.2571053206920624,
0.18415336310863495,
0.9913216233253479,
0.10872340202331543,
-0.503531813621521,
-0.4195590019226074,
-0.13110530376434326,
0.8821290135383606,
-0.6959823369979858,
0.19374971091747284,
0.3213293254375458,
0.22379501163959503,
-0.0897730216383934,
-0.9554591178894043,
-0.8438658714294434,
-0.3470936417579651,
-0.33348074555397034,
0.23261727392673492,
-0.5379169583320618,
0.20627473294734955,
0.17820654809474945,
0.2432679533958435,
-0.4227065145969391,
0.24538546800613403,
0.15810061991214752,
-0.6922436952590942,
0.494586318731308,
-0.025017552077770233,
0.387177050113678,
-0.7004940509796143,
-0.6715927124023438,
-0.07410448044538498,
-0.714694082736969,
-0.1456267237663269,
0.33847638964653015,
0.5849847197532654,
0.21828842163085938,
0.7269089221954346,
0.018808137625455856,
0.8760159611701965,
-0.15676267445087433,
-0.09772290289402008,
0.19030579924583435,
-0.11690612137317657,
-0.2570657730102539,
0.4645569324493408,
0.33465835452079773,
0.23506541550159454,
0.1582399606704712,
-0.3100971281528473,
-0.3180719316005707,
0.23841355741024017,
0.2481670081615448,
-0.5010465383529663,
-0.16308394074440002,
0.1822866052389145,
-0.7766659259796143,
-0.5109030604362488,
0.12669704854488373,
-0.5214946269989014,
-0.8114331364631653,
-0.061771780252456665,
0.7101027965545654,
-0.5450465083122253,
-0.2690455913543701,
0.2343246191740036,
-0.565750002861023,
0.14996488392353058,
0.1500156968832016,
-0.586388885974884,
0.30340269207954407,
0.5885975956916809,
0.5774141550064087,
0.26421165466308594,
0.19933021068572998,
-0.4574885368347168,
0.3384486138820648,
-0.01791882887482643,
1.1369119882583618,
-0.5945722460746765,
0.1441318541765213,
0.48373180627822876,
-0.18925753235816956,
-0.02384156733751297,
-0.5891702771186829,
0.951970636844635,
-0.8131274580955505,
0.43998757004737854,
-0.36245855689048767,
-1.1194453239440918,
-0.3042601943016052,
0.5796459913253784,
-0.7506905794143677,
0.8651196360588074,
0.16565904021263123,
-0.8805222511291504,
0.7910946607589722,
-1.088301181793213,
-0.3725728988647461,
0.2156742364168167,
-0.03638870641589165,
-0.45795485377311707,
0.07354942709207535,
-0.0886455774307251,
0.41242632269859314,
-0.14374494552612305,
0.27996826171875,
-0.19799114763736725,
0.27993378043174744,
0.3220159411430359,
-0.14577268064022064,
1.0095183849334717,
0.3065737187862396,
-0.07148438692092896,
-0.15357482433319092,
-0.888382613658905,
0.30846574902534485,
0.11015995591878891,
-0.4736121892929077,
-0.6373790502548218,
0.06442783027887344,
0.19799864292144775,
0.09949702024459839,
0.3391810953617096,
-1.1164343357086182,
0.2548210322856903,
-0.47546613216400146,
0.33478647470474243,
0.49987468123435974,
-0.31232160329818726,
0.04105004295706749,
-0.30464306473731995,
0.22612392902374268,
0.0076929135248064995,
-0.26154935359954834,
-0.01977677270770073,
-0.43287938833236694,
-0.8480640649795532,
-0.3105892837047577,
0.9075123071670532,
0.8118642568588257,
-0.6872175335884094,
0.9963438510894775,
-0.4358021318912506,
0.14553003013134003,
-0.6242274045944214,
0.07775003463029861,
0.18037481606006622,
0.5265237092971802,
0.4291188716888428,
-0.30152201652526855,
-0.9017483592033386,
-0.829952597618103,
-0.49108824133872986,
-0.140500009059906,
-0.34503763914108276,
0.13784301280975342,
0.3666532635688782,
-0.24700644612312317,
1.5941901206970215,
-0.7441497445106506,
-0.9627202749252319,
-0.3496067523956299,
0.1887420266866684,
-0.13874460756778717,
0.14510083198547363,
0.6750842928886414,
-1.0180264711380005,
-0.29803264141082764,
-0.1807200014591217,
-0.8378616571426392,
-0.34913232922554016,
-0.06260061264038086,
0.09444672614336014,
0.34703487157821655,
0.08801795542240143,
-0.6174442172050476,
0.4682406187057495,
0.24618445336818695,
-0.8136923909187317,
0.17929387092590332,
-0.1452198475599289,
-0.24943383038043976,
-1.1092536449432373,
-0.3151472806930542,
-0.05862349644303322,
-0.6107933521270752,
-0.5737062692642212,
-0.2009996920824051,
0.15764190256595612,
0.15095536410808563,
-0.09290236234664917,
0.13733740150928497,
-0.4290461838245392,
-0.12049205601215363,
-0.6171388030052185,
0.37614527344703674,
0.31640276312828064,
0.010797743685543537,
0.12244290858507156,
0.16535373032093048,
0.506958544254303,
-0.4877685010433197,
0.5067541599273682,
0.8330410122871399,
-0.4555830657482147,
0.4737147092819214,
-0.5597106218338013,
-0.2016279548406601,
-0.005897267255932093,
0.3456297516822815,
-1.1643710136413574,
-0.05751065909862518,
-0.07213813811540604,
-0.664007306098938,
0.19052866101264954,
0.16841790080070496,
-0.8774738311767578,
-0.5828337669372559,
-0.27609407901763916,
-0.5070219039916992,
0.3884269893169403,
-0.9533956050872803,
0.8452528119087219,
0.4497964084148407,
-0.1755346655845642,
-0.44549691677093506,
-1.1731935739517212,
0.5012235045433044,
-0.05939521640539169,
-0.8676256537437439,
0.6578080058097839,
0.6084962487220764,
-0.17619258165359497,
0.42685332894325256,
0.17418180406093597,
-0.1801329255104065,
-0.05468002334237099,
-0.01916952058672905,
0.338081955909729,
-0.34651774168014526,
0.6459943652153015,
0.04029649496078491,
-0.021234964951872826,
0.10812776535749435,
-0.577056348323822,
0.4777887165546417,
-0.028142165392637253,
-0.12347166985273361,
-0.41657865047454834,
0.41520214080810547,
-0.04897892102599144,
-0.038616638630628586,
1.0911117792129517,
0.4926376938819885,
-0.42356717586517334,
-0.15081104636192322,
-0.6215565800666809,
-0.18431922793388367,
-0.4388805329799652,
0.228906512260437,
-0.1430588811635971,
-1.0428431034088135,
0.4093599021434784,
-0.2053324580192566,
0.12735001742839813,
0.7579914927482605,
0.5086014866828918,
-0.10521119832992554,
0.8818811178207397,
0.9186619520187378,
0.02847777120769024,
0.4381961524486542,
-0.18521057069301605,
0.4103201925754547,
-0.4251364767551422,
-0.10958636552095413,
-0.38593238592147827,
-0.1618713140487671,
-0.52176833152771,
-0.08148577809333801,
0.1342092603445053,
-0.16589465737342834,
0.0650818943977356,
0.5254520177841187,
-0.5085904598236084,
0.05798592045903206,
0.5389816761016846,
0.2730564475059509,
0.5562713146209717,
0.17016847431659698,
-0.08474340289831161,
-0.03351558744907379,
-0.8531176447868347,
-0.6406912803649902,
1.2105205059051514,
0.3216313421726227,
0.6073006987571716,
0.399199903011322,
0.3403353989124298,
0.9880056977272034,
0.35512009263038635,
-0.7916064262390137,
0.40463849902153015,
-0.16250985860824585,
-0.9291436076164246,
-0.11715540289878845,
-0.39817482233047485,
-0.897305428981781,
0.24723920226097107,
-0.630044162273407,
-0.6331861615180969,
0.23540854454040527,
0.2780957818031311,
-0.5696911215782166,
0.382355272769928,
-0.7520853877067566,
0.5346068143844604,
-0.05307551100850105,
0.10605710744857788,
-0.30609482526779175,
-0.7081974744796753,
0.1595456302165985,
0.002687418833374977,
-0.2607562243938446,
0.06473371386528015,
0.01288745366036892,
0.9476439952850342,
-0.8346495628356934,
1.236440896987915,
-0.38982993364334106,
-0.33406364917755127,
0.7013850212097168,
-0.39606964588165283,
0.6268583536148071,
-0.17673082649707794,
-0.040552347898483276,
-0.11111702769994736,
-0.09677904099225998,
-0.42935803532600403,
-0.5207985043525696,
0.3251760005950928,
-0.500799298286438,
-0.38940081000328064,
-0.38197046518325806,
-0.6422967314720154,
-0.32606062293052673,
0.13008451461791992,
0.29132136702537537,
0.2467661052942276,
-0.1951417624950409,
0.14520063996315002,
0.757945716381073,
-0.31966760754585266,
0.37543773651123047,
0.800805389881134,
-0.06663807481527328,
-0.11032824963331223,
0.7344077825546265,
0.33678433299064636,
0.20753397047519684,
0.5577164888381958,
0.30490168929100037,
-0.37522441148757935,
-0.17386305332183838,
-0.07813268154859543,
-0.3493225574493408,
-0.6761425137519836,
-0.6465196013450623,
-1.208433985710144,
-0.1486620306968689,
-0.9792364835739136,
0.21547773480415344,
-0.2853268086910248,
-0.8867703080177307,
0.23667562007904053,
-0.24404840171337128,
0.7816272974014282,
0.4778794050216675,
-0.10674254596233368,
0.6305103898048401,
-0.9356310963630676,
0.317756325006485,
0.2849541902542114,
0.19036710262298584,
-0.09733299165964127,
-0.6990817189216614,
-0.07381186634302139,
-0.14655499160289764,
-0.5585592985153198,
-0.47545933723449707,
0.2555827498435974,
0.3811708390712738,
0.5616697072982788,
0.7488440275192261,
0.31969115138053894,
0.20755799114704132,
-0.46686452627182007,
0.6487088799476624,
0.2916927933692932,
-0.9756485223770142,
0.8152515292167664,
-0.023670712485909462,
-0.4406333267688751,
0.20001475512981415,
0.36841198801994324,
-0.27188920974731445,
-0.1530885398387909,
-0.8399810791015625,
-0.5113147497177124,
0.4467628598213196,
0.15056811273097992,
0.3038981854915619,
0.1205422580242157,
0.1763463318347931,
0.12371507287025452,
0.17008967697620392,
-0.8757579326629639,
-0.118472158908844,
-0.008307967334985733,
-0.34004077315330505,
0.6141229271888733,
-0.48816192150115967,
-0.2868020832538605,
0.0033210546243935823,
0.42676544189453125,
-0.21101000905036926,
0.458355188369751,
0.2965179681777954,
-0.38770630955696106,
0.15783102810382843,
0.41571760177612305,
0.10660330951213837,
0.42461106181144714,
-0.16657330095767975,
0.007312565576285124,
0.24186880886554718,
-0.3676191568374634,
-0.22653482854366302,
0.40714728832244873,
-0.15087059140205383,
0.22782033681869507,
0.6740454435348511,
0.7361461520195007,
-0.06159956380724907,
-0.8279435634613037,
0.7549468278884888,
0.19672463834285736,
-0.1818731278181076,
-0.4533727169036865,
-0.044115204364061356,
-0.2196645587682724,
0.2801153063774109,
0.428130179643631,
0.20355723798274994,
0.39217883348464966,
-0.6275126338005066,
0.46159827709198,
0.3760150372982025,
-0.4900785982608795,
-0.0363883338868618,
0.41465651988983154,
0.14981535077095032,
0.03725408390164375,
0.28283342719078064,
0.00847355742007494,
-0.9665688872337341,
0.5375449061393738,
0.7378892302513123,
0.42579036951065063,
-0.05535617098212242,
0.25200095772743225,
-0.23512400686740875,
0.36030521988868713,
-0.01848975569009781,
0.4109884798526764,
0.030132589861750603,
-1.352059245109558,
-0.34255465865135193,
-0.3271377384662628,
-0.42358750104904175,
-0.25275832414627075,
-0.765486478805542,
0.14327387511730194,
-0.20752693712711334,
-0.35895150899887085,
0.23121853172779083,
0.14078082144260406,
-0.4412066638469696,
0.3153582811355591,
0.2295716255903244,
1.0729029178619385,
-1.0278136730194092,
0.8346408605575562,
0.7923116683959961,
-0.4093051254749298,
-0.5942304730415344,
0.14499448239803314,
0.01988971047103405,
-0.9743430018424988,
1.0665161609649658,
0.11121083796024323,
0.1438814252614975,
-0.11477744579315186,
-0.5731769800186157,
-0.5759492516517639,
0.9471748471260071,
0.4502982497215271,
-0.18530982732772827,
0.050721004605293274,
0.19308951497077942,
0.45242419838905334,
-0.504717230796814,
0.04120641574263573,
0.436542809009552,
0.5175855755805969,
-0.03974080830812454,
-0.7402639985084534,
0.1416795402765274,
0.14566487073898315,
0.041789066046476364,
0.14104817807674408,
-0.6242764592170715,
0.7722814679145813,
-0.20291456580162048,
-0.05097544938325882,
0.08021242171525955,
1.0756417512893677,
-0.002327905735000968,
0.24749495089054108,
0.6714617013931274,
0.949367880821228,
1.1049995422363281,
-0.02435576729476452,
1.2546133995056152,
0.07389184832572937,
0.6338780522346497,
1.0874642133712769,
-0.5853936672210693,
0.7903461456298828,
0.16153043508529663,
-0.227819561958313,
0.7692887187004089,
0.41451701521873474,
-0.35874176025390625,
0.6451930999755859,
0.3579581677913666,
-0.32571151852607727,
-0.3635508120059967,
-0.6424621343612671,
-0.4248402714729309,
0.7312554717063904,
0.4093549847602844,
-0.6257280111312866,
-0.2863365113735199,
0.35516586899757385,
-0.03561294823884964,
0.14115116000175476,
-0.35906291007995605,
0.6884055137634277,
0.003715785685926676,
-0.4192449450492859,
0.04164277762174606,
0.06816312670707703,
0.9475914835929871,
-0.5841919183731079,
-0.07781338691711426,
0.30927252769470215,
0.524276614189148,
-0.4489153027534485,
-0.7844648957252502,
0.3438419997692108,
0.0102767338976264,
-0.41292157769203186,
-0.2740715742111206,
1.3777326345443726,
-0.43978211283683777,
-0.5217471122741699,
0.5426985621452332,
0.3375939428806305,
-0.10403045266866684,
-0.09388845413923264,
-0.5195647478103638,
-0.5166558623313904,
-0.20423854887485504,
-0.25413402915000916,
0.13915342092514038,
0.670927882194519,
-0.0027184667997062206,
0.5949932932853699,
0.4354068338871002,
0.008527846075594425,
0.04177410528063774,
0.2379470020532608,
0.9744663238525391,
-0.5728217363357544,
-0.7323870062828064,
-0.6055837869644165,
0.1717626452445984,
-0.5798933506011963,
-0.022919483482837677,
0.8891271948814392,
0.6136607527732849,
0.4904273450374603,
-0.024594886228442192,
1.1184148788452148,
-0.5019174218177795,
0.9540640711784363,
-0.7196906208992004,
0.869149386882782,
-0.4318940341472626,
0.09281109273433685,
-0.18893155455589294,
-0.5730554461479187,
-0.3738562762737274,
0.6158555150032043,
-0.22023457288742065,
-0.07658679783344269,
0.510147213935852,
0.5171187520027161,
0.17247655987739563,
0.39863842725753784,
0.37155696749687195,
0.1301025003194809,
0.07846130430698395,
0.4299861192703247,
0.86753249168396,
-0.5836076140403748,
0.6646096706390381,
0.3598098158836365,
-0.33686351776123047,
-0.3554403781890869,
-1.0024280548095703,
-0.9211587905883789,
-0.02405500039458275,
-0.4922305643558502,
-0.7231253385543823,
-0.182859867811203,
0.7427417635917664,
0.580481231212616,
-1.1412047147750854,
0.3133615255355835,
0.053222186863422394,
-0.09721212834119797,
0.04836426302790642,
-0.31331667304039,
0.31269147992134094,
-0.49065226316452026,
-0.2857401371002197,
0.11008747667074203,
0.05485965684056282,
-0.18203124403953552,
0.00877218134701252,
0.26788994669914246,
-0.4703517258167267,
0.18927858769893646,
0.8051843643188477,
-0.02136078104376793,
-0.555972158908844,
-0.48464298248291016,
-0.15202634036540985,
-0.16279302537441254,
-0.03096383810043335,
0.9368840456008911,
-0.815751850605011,
0.2586144208908081,
0.5195991396903992,
0.9204723238945007,
0.0738343596458435,
-0.12055917084217072,
0.6030399799346924,
-0.9773051738739014,
0.22066712379455566,
0.13209733366966248,
0.5983456373214722,
0.19404007494449615,
-0.6827595233917236,
0.5448447465896606,
0.2782754600048065,
-0.19622837007045746,
-0.6996473670005798,
0.09702550619840622,
-0.8856489658355713,
-0.28983157873153687,
0.6981008052825928,
-0.4477110207080841,
-0.01632549613714218,
-0.2846895158290863,
-0.02548818103969097,
0.22814540565013885,
-0.24588961899280548,
0.8039458990097046,
0.8623654246330261,
-0.21535815298557281,
0.3155035078525543,
-0.5015596747398376,
0.3145062029361725,
0.6900646090507507,
-0.7390585541725159,
-0.06361247599124908,
0.37914523482322693,
0.24239563941955566,
0.6710226535797119,
0.332028865814209,
-0.13987690210342407,
0.06517326086759567,
0.09123914688825607,
0.41786491870880127,
0.10232783854007721,
-0.04958465322852135,
-0.04739941656589508,
0.262848824262619,
-0.3439549505710602,
-0.35992133617401123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12280v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12280v1 | Adaptive Skeleton Graph Decoding | 2024-02-19T16:47:04 | 2024-02-19T16:47:04 | Shuowei Jin, Yongji Wu, Haizhong Zheng, Qingzhao Zhang, Matthew Lentz, Z. Morley Mao, Atul Prakash, Feng Qian, Danyang Zhuo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have seen significant adoption for natural
language tasks, owing their success to massive numbers of model parameters
(e.g., 70B+); however, LLM inference incurs significant computation and memory
costs. Recent approaches propose parallel decoding strategies, such as
Skeleton-of-Thought (SoT), to improve performance by breaking prompts down into
sub-problems that can be decoded in parallel; however, they often suffer from
reduced response quality. Our key insight is that we can request additional
information, specifically dependencies and difficulty, when generating the
sub-problems to improve both response quality and performance. In this paper,
we propose Skeleton Graph Decoding (SGD), which uses dependencies exposed
between sub-problems to support information forwarding between dependent
sub-problems for improved quality while exposing parallelization opportunities
for decoding independent sub-problems. Additionally, we leverage difficulty
estimates for each sub-problem to select an appropriately-sized model,
improving performance without significantly reducing quality. Compared to
standard autoregressive generation and SoT, SGD achieves a 1.69x speedup while
improving quality by up to 51%. | [
-0.0840110033750534,
-0.49216940999031067,
0.38421252369880676,
0.5525242686271667,
-0.6669809818267822,
0.38525959849357605,
-0.057997312396764755,
-0.5904061794281006,
0.43635496497154236,
0.5538290739059448,
-0.5026960372924805,
-0.5311275720596313,
-0.7022846937179565,
0.37076491117477417,
-0.0017002328531816602,
0.846077561378479,
-0.20393584668636322,
0.3122309744358063,
-0.10815798491239548,
-0.18412555754184723,
-0.5995103716850281,
-0.4372689127922058,
-1.028347373008728,
-0.33867397904396057,
0.5051342248916626,
0.0856628343462944,
0.5875836610794067,
1.090428113937378,
0.4217272400856018,
0.2674787938594818,
-0.07519497722387314,
0.14681175351142883,
-0.6921432614326477,
0.14289291203022003,
-0.4241759777069092,
-0.5594521760940552,
-0.6599397659301758,
-0.41054821014404297,
0.5694471597671509,
0.8541741967201233,
-0.10273706167936325,
-0.023698652163147926,
0.13083751499652863,
0.9227356910705566,
-0.4121452569961548,
0.8822847604751587,
-0.5372859835624695,
-0.18991497159004211,
-0.07623257488012314,
-0.22167344391345978,
-0.36427006125450134,
-0.159637913107872,
0.08843106031417847,
-0.5932021141052246,
0.26811084151268005,
0.01252905186265707,
0.5034320950508118,
0.4965086877346039,
0.022162793204188347,
-0.5987492203712463,
-0.3276524543762207,
0.40749192237854004,
-0.6732676029205322,
0.4957585036754608,
0.44864118099212646,
0.0060472190380096436,
-0.4085397720336914,
-0.7504668235778809,
-0.26080000400543213,
0.1560060977935791,
-0.014160984195768833,
0.14974215626716614,
-0.2874978184700012,
0.25853100419044495,
0.14131830632686615,
0.30240732431411743,
-0.5153272747993469,
0.04151526838541031,
-0.1652357280254364,
-0.3650921583175659,
0.6423386931419373,
0.4198671281337738,
0.3649623692035675,
-0.37578538060188293,
0.10358066111803055,
-0.3728516399860382,
-0.4539009928703308,
0.14540976285934448,
0.47659826278686523,
0.552375078201294,
0.0037041925825178623,
0.44640663266181946,
-0.4254719018936157,
0.7211927175521851,
0.15712401270866394,
-0.2433609813451767,
0.22250117361545563,
-0.40175679326057434,
-0.09454432129859924,
0.16351978480815887,
0.3985084593296051,
0.2815220355987549,
0.2527047395706177,
-0.2970430850982666,
-0.172531396150589,
0.3269808888435364,
0.06453975290060043,
-0.8214964270591736,
-0.7486920356750488,
0.23170015215873718,
-0.5491601228713989,
0.29486584663391113,
-0.452927827835083,
-0.8348157405853271,
-0.3605938255786896,
-0.13880838453769684,
0.1683608442544937,
-0.6308894157409668,
-0.324086457490921,
0.587910532951355,
-0.16889245808124542,
-0.23026451468467712,
0.3936019539833069,
-0.9448021054267883,
0.34243857860565186,
0.40141886472702026,
0.8467774987220764,
-0.1987241953611374,
-0.16722917556762695,
-0.619915246963501,
0.18634742498397827,
-0.18632374703884125,
0.8179000616073608,
-0.5022715926170349,
-0.2051103413105011,
-0.594836950302124,
-0.013598849065601826,
-0.23252065479755402,
-0.5156100988388062,
0.39539092779159546,
-0.44534438848495483,
-0.4391903877258301,
-0.33145469427108765,
-0.4142661392688751,
-0.1546923965215683,
0.15345053374767303,
-0.7909417748451233,
0.7224096655845642,
0.32227182388305664,
-1.1113839149475098,
0.040388040244579315,
-0.2852953374385834,
-0.6567531228065491,
-0.02541007101535797,
-0.12713417410850525,
0.004629144910722971,
0.34456706047058105,
0.7230318784713745,
0.5430468320846558,
-0.43399688601493835,
-0.013326335698366165,
-0.2767530381679535,
-0.07943148165941238,
-0.43997523188591003,
-0.20237132906913757,
0.5312737226486206,
0.09249213337898254,
-0.17869515717029572,
0.0760837271809578,
-1.0405353307724,
0.06278572976589203,
0.42347201704978943,
-0.6502082943916321,
-0.3550947904586792,
0.14760135114192963,
-0.3567306101322174,
-0.1520385891199112,
0.09628821164369583,
-0.43606334924697876,
0.08860018849372864,
-0.6810578107833862,
0.3941989541053772,
0.8911172151565552,
-0.17128926515579224,
0.249635249376297,
-0.1770518273115158,
0.4976138770580292,
-0.0008727640379220247,
-0.33408409357070923,
-0.2025417536497116,
-0.3781619071960449,
-0.7096160054206848,
-0.3634190261363983,
0.44263166189193726,
0.3731083869934082,
-1.2814908027648926,
0.07148149609565735,
-0.41543272137641907,
-0.2968485653400421,
-0.6895298361778259,
0.26895707845687866,
0.528719961643219,
0.42362311482429504,
0.5457808375358582,
-0.5468582510948181,
-0.5645163059234619,
-0.4716327488422394,
-0.2484835833311081,
-0.42562592029571533,
-0.014179568737745285,
0.4616653025150299,
0.0499887615442276,
0.03814326599240303,
0.783372700214386,
-0.5275577902793884,
-0.07167396694421768,
-0.4985324442386627,
0.10302184522151947,
0.33712664246559143,
0.4817742109298706,
0.4863681495189667,
-0.4328656792640686,
-0.6132246255874634,
-0.15367144346237183,
-0.6127477884292603,
-0.14360973238945007,
0.14939554035663605,
-0.028233811259269714,
0.182830810546875,
0.40095624327659607,
-0.8757591843605042,
0.27754703164100647,
0.6404278874397278,
-0.05132263898849487,
0.39451366662979126,
-0.35772472620010376,
-0.15220744907855988,
-1.115395188331604,
-0.24301904439926147,
-0.1259225308895111,
-0.20432867109775543,
-0.31823834776878357,
0.16797752678394318,
-0.06624094396829605,
0.16224181652069092,
0.012438518926501274,
0.3290429413318634,
-0.7742106914520264,
-0.23541204631328583,
-0.33371594548225403,
0.058471765369176865,
-0.030714815482497215,
0.35899150371551514,
0.0661129429936409,
0.6723815202713013,
0.734978199005127,
-0.47526004910469055,
0.5251805186271667,
0.014778069220483303,
-0.1636480838060379,
0.42935463786125183,
-0.563575804233551,
0.36087560653686523,
-0.5947709083557129,
0.7047147750854492,
-1.1636600494384766,
-0.4846324026584625,
0.251345157623291,
-0.2529717981815338,
0.36538276076316833,
-0.4426654577255249,
-0.5502345561981201,
-0.47382596135139465,
-0.17631883919239044,
0.6379380822181702,
0.3838455080986023,
-0.8088670969009399,
0.8141278028488159,
0.29312828183174133,
-0.37414076924324036,
-0.6242244839668274,
-0.4639050364494324,
0.046071067452430725,
0.18960489332675934,
-0.8895366191864014,
0.17445969581604004,
-0.12235420942306519,
0.11470586061477661,
0.13902316987514496,
-0.4853838384151459,
0.16226370632648468,
-0.21014973521232605,
0.0713714063167572,
-0.2832912504673004,
-0.4544411301612854,
0.056383777409791946,
0.09391660988330841,
-0.4842720329761505,
0.07815716415643692,
-0.6333920359611511,
0.9647213220596313,
0.32898420095443726,
-0.3322819769382477,
-0.4383077919483185,
0.3084748685359955,
0.5089954733848572,
-0.1966487169265747,
0.5266708135604858,
0.47344934940338135,
-0.4353645443916321,
-0.31983569264411926,
-0.3572198450565338,
-0.14217424392700195,
-0.4726073145866394,
0.5411405563354492,
-0.5730889439582825,
-0.7429404854774475,
0.7211924195289612,
-0.10656566917896271,
-0.2730594575405121,
0.21617870032787323,
0.46920961141586304,
0.10543853044509888,
1.2745097875595093,
0.47033509612083435,
-0.304108589887619,
0.1717677265405655,
-0.2929975092411041,
0.15591031312942505,
-0.6811109185218811,
-0.20372873544692993,
-0.49513867497444153,
-0.3160400688648224,
-0.30626943707466125,
-0.5494720935821533,
0.10131797194480896,
0.5068003535270691,
0.15253648161888123,
0.45086389780044556,
-0.4001232087612152,
0.45468202233314514,
0.19035160541534424,
0.4829709231853485,
0.3387696146965027,
0.10924699157476425,
-0.21825112402439117,
-0.013345548883080482,
-1.0556050539016724,
-0.1081177294254303,
0.9496728181838989,
0.3264321982860565,
1.2637033462524414,
0.09574143588542938,
0.5660902261734009,
0.023496000096201897,
0.31523188948631287,
-0.6667339205741882,
0.5356000065803528,
-0.485289603471756,
-0.17745906114578247,
-0.18875762820243835,
-0.6587874293327332,
-1.0060937404632568,
0.2193555384874344,
0.05663538724184036,
-0.8989606499671936,
0.07957111299037933,
0.3759065866470337,
-0.3032132685184479,
0.2840416431427002,
-0.6024715900421143,
0.4820600152015686,
0.14420565962791443,
-0.06458371877670288,
-0.23364202678203583,
-0.5852526426315308,
0.14564961194992065,
0.04341387003660202,
0.026125041767954826,
-0.1366102248430252,
0.23554229736328125,
0.6576470136642456,
-0.29351651668548584,
0.8838346600532532,
-0.22679853439331055,
-0.14026100933551788,
0.1135961264371872,
0.052775684744119644,
1.1340142488479614,
0.247852623462677,
-0.30593568086624146,
-0.18081946671009064,
-0.0885368138551712,
-0.5862699747085571,
-0.6529048085212708,
0.6803266406059265,
-0.6916642785072327,
-0.7630524039268494,
-0.07988471537828445,
-1.066087245941162,
-0.3517685830593109,
0.21641215682029724,
0.3527754545211792,
0.5559597015380859,
0.28140944242477417,
0.11388890445232391,
0.553078830242157,
-0.11617573350667953,
0.5451346039772034,
0.26748040318489075,
-0.020084215328097343,
-0.5521886348724365,
1.0407390594482422,
0.33256351947784424,
0.30462682247161865,
0.2129601240158081,
0.021988213062286377,
-0.48524564504623413,
-1.1977486610412598,
-0.7197195291519165,
0.2772483229637146,
-0.9544550180435181,
-0.46619829535484314,
-1.054595708847046,
-0.1312803030014038,
-0.4853569269180298,
0.08371283113956451,
-0.4913412034511566,
-0.1556917279958725,
-0.4615335464477539,
-0.05530809983611107,
0.40443217754364014,
0.671007513999939,
0.08392215520143509,
0.36221033334732056,
-0.8326563835144043,
0.5271477103233337,
0.16451455652713776,
0.4639356732368469,
0.24727876484394073,
-0.2571639120578766,
-0.20320194959640503,
0.07487311214208603,
0.2348068207502365,
-0.7189956307411194,
0.34510353207588196,
-0.1859310418367386,
0.5155799388885498,
-0.02898765169084072,
0.4490232765674591,
0.8264367580413818,
-0.4458514153957367,
0.40522119402885437,
0.22025854885578156,
-0.8639413714408875,
0.11639174818992615,
-0.2568499743938446,
0.3421036899089813,
0.3187064826488495,
0.3264913260936737,
-0.060477979481220245,
-0.31540727615356445,
-0.28638148307800293,
-0.8950868248939514,
1.0220143795013428,
0.1776706427335739,
0.271099716424942,
-0.16369733214378357,
0.6500914692878723,
-0.009182059206068516,
-0.12070543318986893,
-0.55349200963974,
-0.0025925172958523035,
-0.3275350034236908,
-0.48552727699279785,
-0.12038591504096985,
-0.24281932413578033,
0.129756361246109,
-0.18802253901958466,
0.32692164182662964,
-0.4567846953868866,
0.1570250689983368,
0.2915211319923401,
-0.26040250062942505,
-0.30276501178741455,
-0.03032304160296917,
0.2969297766685486,
0.6614199280738831,
-0.18679547309875488,
0.31425225734710693,
0.3439509868621826,
-0.6093435287475586,
0.18030959367752075,
0.14416122436523438,
0.34677231311798096,
-0.10016105324029922,
0.4916493892669678,
0.8872637748718262,
-0.12452830374240875,
-0.5225064158439636,
0.1979508101940155,
-0.04447845369577408,
0.05382813513278961,
0.4321323335170746,
0.22647885978221893,
0.4758336544036865,
0.5737291574478149,
0.42243385314941406,
-0.08832378685474396,
-0.051141176372766495,
-0.3477103114128113,
0.09722950309515,
0.24499177932739258,
-0.24034835398197174,
-0.4373483657836914,
0.5537474751472473,
0.1489204615354538,
-0.3549247086048126,
0.5024092197418213,
-0.1812635362148285,
-0.4477473795413971,
0.7070285677909851,
1.0095999240875244,
0.6018456816673279,
-0.2304040640592575,
0.10537165403366089,
0.23441995680332184,
0.25408995151519775,
-0.3267630338668823,
0.5470584630966187,
0.1994381994009018,
-0.7114790081977844,
-0.78202885389328,
-0.7756621837615967,
-0.11718598753213882,
0.12950871884822845,
-0.6599462628364563,
-0.16442862153053284,
-0.7666917443275452,
-0.056704286485910416,
-0.0015144700882956386,
-0.14590033888816833,
-0.44672664999961853,
0.289880633354187,
-0.3747006952762604,
0.9792746901512146,
-0.45837095379829407,
0.8597954511642456,
0.612212061882019,
-0.09396626800298691,
-0.9370962381362915,
0.2771318554878235,
-0.2868582606315613,
-0.7529199719429016,
0.5908071994781494,
0.10054893046617508,
-0.4599374532699585,
0.5262869000434875,
-0.23623685538768768,
-1.0973715782165527,
0.9911438226699829,
1.024947166442871,
-0.33227401971817017,
-0.05163104087114334,
0.06723828613758087,
0.7119597792625427,
-0.6583430767059326,
0.021915659308433533,
0.5726826786994934,
0.2565166652202606,
0.10734488815069199,
-0.8773823380470276,
0.43905264139175415,
-0.15416431427001953,
0.24367974698543549,
0.18359743058681488,
-0.5997624397277832,
1.0536589622497559,
-0.19499875605106354,
-0.603658139705658,
0.19538460671901703,
0.5743821263313293,
0.15866900980472565,
0.33430400490760803,
0.543459415435791,
0.4476451873779297,
0.5624081492424011,
0.09000597149133682,
1.0992655754089355,
-0.4100848436355591,
0.25821399688720703,
1.1113756895065308,
-0.09440791606903076,
0.6845232844352722,
0.30496352910995483,
-0.19849151372909546,
0.2322893589735031,
0.8543187975883484,
0.533566951751709,
0.5483996868133545,
0.4814978539943695,
-0.07573797553777695,
-0.3854124844074249,
-0.13068464398384094,
-0.46882811188697815,
0.4088050425052643,
0.4798468053340912,
-0.30425068736076355,
-0.5768776535987854,
0.08131136745214462,
-0.1522853821516037,
0.14921356737613678,
-0.30778783559799194,
0.6556344032287598,
-0.1951790601015091,
-0.5227431654930115,
0.758918821811676,
0.10719092190265656,
0.46547383069992065,
-0.4584347903728485,
-0.16082367300987244,
-0.4217306971549988,
0.12871968746185303,
-0.14606332778930664,
-0.5863494277000427,
0.12280117720365524,
-0.2839130461215973,
-0.5739037394523621,
0.03433740884065628,
0.7196319699287415,
-0.27350232005119324,
-0.3807564973831177,
0.7515559792518616,
0.414156049489975,
0.16690394282341003,
-0.10605623573064804,
-0.6424458026885986,
0.3339707553386688,
-0.04250040650367737,
-0.18244527280330658,
0.3959445357322693,
0.4640793204307556,
-0.09492809325456619,
0.7281527519226074,
0.7963246703147888,
-0.06781626492738724,
0.13124120235443115,
-0.12259670346975327,
1.3250732421875,
-0.4088638126850128,
-0.6506744623184204,
-0.7419310808181763,
0.1238521859049797,
0.07815005630254745,
-0.028151992708444595,
0.6252596378326416,
0.25243625044822693,
0.9614490866661072,
0.015459082089364529,
0.6117123961448669,
0.1271982192993164,
0.3891575336456299,
-0.9386383891105652,
0.5097405910491943,
-0.2894991338253021,
0.5586293935775757,
-0.34069621562957764,
-0.9977525472640991,
-0.2708892822265625,
0.5137893557548523,
-0.023088620975613594,
-0.020058883354067802,
0.6145936846733093,
0.7856393456459045,
-0.20656003057956696,
0.11347433924674988,
0.10292980074882507,
0.3215925693511963,
0.26195308566093445,
0.6285077929496765,
0.5461503267288208,
-0.21519222855567932,
0.665230929851532,
-0.07423331588506699,
-0.14865025877952576,
-0.08341892808675766,
-0.7378782033920288,
-1.0430047512054443,
-0.2900570034980774,
-0.1411553919315338,
-0.720039427280426,
0.28281834721565247,
0.9434277415275574,
0.6917039155960083,
-0.8124796748161316,
-0.13439035415649414,
-0.3210819661617279,
0.24237507581710815,
-0.10764992982149124,
-0.15478011965751648,
0.7102256417274475,
-0.46252498030662537,
-0.7804163694381714,
0.5274128913879395,
0.5051349401473999,
0.03930041566491127,
-0.07641401141881943,
-0.34036386013031006,
-0.03882294148206711,
0.21402958035469055,
0.49077972769737244,
0.23306266963481903,
-0.6383504867553711,
-0.5756775736808777,
-0.07606346905231476,
-0.07125245034694672,
0.1924852877855301,
0.9809327721595764,
-0.7066309452056885,
0.5838434100151062,
0.7602446675300598,
0.9847869873046875,
0.7601416707038879,
0.040498532354831696,
0.5357082486152649,
-0.669494092464447,
0.14373864233493805,
0.08393768221139908,
0.31492429971694946,
0.2927128076553345,
-0.47212809324264526,
0.5495989322662354,
0.539043128490448,
0.05560682341456413,
-0.8186647295951843,
0.3992152512073517,
-0.755875825881958,
-0.3476128876209259,
0.927208423614502,
-0.6278631687164307,
-0.2735386788845062,
-0.49843478202819824,
-0.29560205340385437,
0.2855689227581024,
-0.26773983240127563,
0.6121742129325867,
0.6506726145744324,
-0.4594569206237793,
-0.3630421757698059,
-0.17411725223064423,
0.4562235176563263,
0.4790234863758087,
-0.7621429562568665,
0.35726606845855713,
0.3678290843963623,
0.27235326170921326,
0.1857311874628067,
0.8698776364326477,
0.11700008809566498,
0.13414832949638367,
0.3881596624851227,
-0.3497287929058075,
-0.07026217132806778,
-0.4262983202934265,
-0.11944341659545898,
0.4223245084285736,
-0.12629978358745575,
-0.03413067385554314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12279v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12279v2 | Key ingredients for effective zero-shot cross-lingual knowledge transfer in generative tasks | 2024-02-19T16:43:57 | 2024-04-22T17:32:00 | Nadezhda Chirkova, Vassilina Nikoulina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Zero-shot cross-lingual knowledge transfer enables a multilingual pretrained
language model, finetuned on a task in one language, make predictions for this
task in other languages. While being broadly studied for natural language
understanding tasks, the described setting is understudied for generation.
Previous works notice a frequent problem of generation in a wrong language and
propose approaches to address it, usually using mT5 as a backbone model. In
this work we compare various approaches proposed from the literature in unified
settings, also including alternative backbone models, namely mBART and
NLLB-200. We first underline the importance of tuning learning rate used for
finetuning, which helps to substantially alleviate the problem of generation in
the wrong language. Then, we show that with careful learning rate tuning, the
simple full finetuning of the model acts as a very strong baseline and
alternative approaches bring only marginal improvements. Finally, we find that
mBART performs similarly to mT5 of the same size, and NLLB-200 can be
competitive in some cases. Our final zero-shot models reach the performance of
the approach based on data translation which is usually considered as an upper
baseline for zero-shot cross-lingual transfer in generation. | [
-0.41594406962394714,
-0.5638545155525208,
0.42492860555648804,
0.13349181413650513,
-0.26651161909103394,
0.07885751873254776,
-0.13649684190750122,
-0.5351928472518921,
-0.3445996642112732,
0.4151248335838318,
-0.4946381747722626,
-0.2834642827510834,
-0.4440097212791443,
0.06920527666807175,
-0.38705480098724365,
1.1137999296188354,
-0.16574332118034363,
0.12512563169002533,
-0.059014707803726196,
-0.2734088599681854,
-0.710997998714447,
-0.44324010610580444,
-0.7456003427505493,
-0.7673715353012085,
0.5816633701324463,
0.5270674824714661,
0.3513675332069397,
0.38611963391304016,
0.3865337073802948,
0.11145325005054474,
0.1550380289554596,
-0.18026120960712433,
-0.6694286465644836,
-0.12435393035411835,
-0.4885511100292206,
-0.5770782828330994,
-0.45891276001930237,
-0.13217595219612122,
0.32229042053222656,
1.0756309032440186,
-0.06712159514427185,
0.20778709650039673,
0.1742997169494629,
0.562716007232666,
-0.6445501446723938,
0.018215740099549294,
-0.7608173489570618,
0.39306777715682983,
-0.1685427725315094,
-0.3500916659832001,
-0.5700007677078247,
-0.01481546275317669,
-0.08742056787014008,
-0.7807366847991943,
0.5741251111030579,
-0.028116848319768906,
0.9131543040275574,
-0.05394810065627098,
-0.5904954671859741,
-0.019428588449954987,
-0.8858668208122253,
0.9505273699760437,
-0.5759362578392029,
0.552151083946228,
0.33809709548950195,
0.42947521805763245,
0.12398429214954376,
-0.4049331843852997,
-0.5480920672416687,
-0.13856257498264313,
0.039899930357933044,
0.37970227003097534,
-0.28116852045059204,
0.00020156906975898892,
0.1454983502626419,
0.3037826418876648,
-0.6343250274658203,
0.3079565465450287,
-0.5111568570137024,
0.005773909855633974,
0.3887411952018738,
0.11239438503980637,
0.30982705950737,
-0.4409131109714508,
-0.5243407487869263,
0.019789373502135277,
-0.9171600341796875,
0.003878298681229353,
0.24282890558242798,
0.486306756734848,
-0.13111473619937897,
0.48616233468055725,
-0.4925287961959839,
1.0407499074935913,
0.4016185998916626,
0.013221606612205505,
0.020855100825428963,
-0.7059178948402405,
-0.4348786175251007,
0.03155365586280823,
0.5882865190505981,
0.28018245100975037,
0.5491845011711121,
-0.5770662426948547,
0.0132075734436512,
0.003561126533895731,
0.3523200452327728,
-0.7690778374671936,
-0.18758834898471832,
-0.037405792623758316,
-0.05136622115969658,
-0.28912442922592163,
-0.17184171080589294,
-0.44801658391952515,
0.10773251950740814,
-0.5612348318099976,
0.7178320288658142,
-0.8176547288894653,
-0.2261892855167389,
0.12870028614997864,
-0.0705612301826477,
0.5420427918434143,
0.38783830404281616,
-1.1402531862258911,
-0.07114429771900177,
0.3902800977230072,
0.5689677596092224,
-0.06309140473604202,
-0.40306544303894043,
-0.4336705803871155,
0.31838324666023254,
-0.5975507497787476,
0.8016838431358337,
-0.04353814572095871,
-0.27976253628730774,
-0.2763720452785492,
-0.06993138790130615,
-0.4243300259113312,
-0.35975196957588196,
0.4369935095310211,
-0.2843732535839081,
0.5362668037414551,
-0.4202577769756317,
-0.35008278489112854,
-0.3886133134365082,
0.21739447116851807,
-0.3437771201133728,
0.7399146556854248,
0.34200772643089294,
-0.7363607883453369,
0.666531503200531,
-0.7638676762580872,
-0.745764434337616,
0.09596388041973114,
0.11779218912124634,
-0.07074079662561417,
0.22787532210350037,
0.31791889667510986,
0.7409908771514893,
-0.1458730399608612,
0.2675936222076416,
-0.18301714956760406,
-0.28084519505500793,
-0.0731038898229599,
-0.5368590950965881,
0.9958780407905579,
0.3198529779911041,
-0.4706510007381439,
-0.26931434869766235,
-0.9225253462791443,
0.015424148179590702,
0.20936289429664612,
-0.2885134816169739,
-0.32801133394241333,
-0.5416542887687683,
-0.0178439412266016,
0.28760039806365967,
-0.16431082785129547,
-0.6205644607543945,
0.03151070699095726,
-0.3314577043056488,
0.0791192427277565,
0.4806002378463745,
0.012118736281991005,
0.6479259133338928,
-0.3516252934932709,
0.5898638963699341,
0.2259739190340042,
0.0034494127612560987,
-0.24275530874729156,
-0.15332898497581482,
-0.9656870365142822,
0.04995232820510864,
0.5347791910171509,
0.5991358757019043,
-1.2834522724151611,
-0.07267987728118896,
-0.34206321835517883,
-0.3840687870979309,
-0.8804203271865845,
0.2970415949821472,
0.6128830313682556,
0.7601794004440308,
0.5359256863594055,
-0.3905853033065796,
-0.4250873327255249,
-0.6598082184791565,
-0.28314924240112305,
0.09068833291530609,
-0.14168988168239594,
-0.07476364821195602,
0.2367786318063736,
0.214735209941864,
0.7832797765731812,
-0.15183323621749878,
-0.31036823987960815,
-0.6114753484725952,
0.6887580156326294,
-0.015170714817941189,
0.6042773127555847,
0.9297122955322266,
-0.4910042881965637,
-0.8175014853477478,
0.5373222231864929,
-0.8915231823921204,
-0.06374599784612656,
-0.31242796778678894,
-0.21344134211540222,
0.4277629256248474,
0.18177613615989685,
-0.5031577348709106,
0.24425706267356873,
0.6287596821784973,
-0.06947055459022522,
0.3164183497428894,
-0.10993662476539612,
0.27482813596725464,
-1.2931870222091675,
0.2501969337463379,
-0.07986088842153549,
-0.33732879161834717,
-1.13817298412323,
0.13767878711223602,
0.16042859852313995,
-0.009106320329010487,
-0.7377101182937622,
0.5148992538452148,
-0.6517184972763062,
0.04369950667023659,
-0.1559973657131195,
0.21567939221858978,
0.08997317403554916,
0.6276900172233582,
0.09151611477136612,
0.6224305033683777,
0.5657164454460144,
-0.5239041447639465,
0.2240464836359024,
0.0375232920050621,
-0.3603696823120117,
1.0869522094726562,
-0.451158344745636,
0.14439591765403748,
-0.22101657092571259,
-0.09954747557640076,
-0.8156995177268982,
0.10526980459690094,
0.25596967339515686,
-0.6107650995254517,
0.6497510075569153,
-0.19102860987186432,
-0.19684657454490662,
-0.11106362193822861,
0.0002655377902556211,
0.34058669209480286,
0.525996744632721,
-0.44524461030960083,
0.2635757029056549,
-0.27040937542915344,
-0.12528598308563232,
-0.7584666013717651,
-0.8666610717773438,
0.12231968343257904,
-0.21769991517066956,
-0.4558408558368683,
0.27253225445747375,
0.05781202390789986,
0.09609438478946686,
0.01926279254257679,
-0.0643736943602562,
0.020117992535233498,
0.03799113258719444,
-0.08465668559074402,
0.22374817728996277,
-0.43288132548332214,
-0.21924768388271332,
-0.04526962339878082,
-0.2955663800239563,
-0.3626307249069214,
-0.30332279205322266,
0.2954229414463043,
0.22422127425670624,
-0.31929659843444824,
-0.22966569662094116,
0.22529008984565735,
0.5674777626991272,
-0.17064107954502106,
0.7687724828720093,
0.9276426434516907,
-0.01733275130391121,
-0.17015564441680908,
-0.4829462170600891,
0.03616611659526825,
-0.3380139470100403,
0.14247509837150574,
-0.6400560140609741,
-0.6806814074516296,
0.40777698159217834,
0.10385875403881073,
0.1920013427734375,
0.5699136853218079,
0.4801445007324219,
-0.15265418589115143,
0.8770418763160706,
1.0147944688796997,
-0.06511791795492172,
0.4413957893848419,
-0.2870882749557495,
0.29223206639289856,
-0.8710170984268188,
-0.13808976113796234,
-0.4058583676815033,
-0.1047271266579628,
-0.19920675456523895,
-0.36982461810112,
0.08157400041818619,
0.4516519606113434,
-0.0036895177327096462,
0.8054882884025574,
-0.03751493990421295,
0.23034358024597168,
0.5586295127868652,
-0.26845648884773254,
0.5066399574279785,
0.1932671070098877,
-0.5327053070068359,
0.04356684535741806,
-1.2849667072296143,
-0.042836710810661316,
1.145745038986206,
-0.05870234966278076,
0.7177724242210388,
0.1289197951555252,
0.5501515865325928,
-0.1701534241437912,
0.452299028635025,
-0.5076166987419128,
0.31806597113609314,
-0.3069496750831604,
-0.7446449398994446,
-0.3073832094669342,
-0.6482587456703186,
-1.124435305595398,
0.43608197569847107,
-0.20378747582435608,
-0.5270913243293762,
0.16632795333862305,
0.11607213318347931,
-0.4336155354976654,
0.4600067436695099,
-0.7442154884338379,
1.006808876991272,
-0.25998684763908386,
-0.3234870731830597,
0.03504006937146187,
-0.6744227409362793,
0.5422530770301819,
-0.25905749201774597,
0.15665243566036224,
-0.14161881804466248,
0.6575163006782532,
0.3280962109565735,
0.022270578891038895,
0.7240892648696899,
-0.15865908563137054,
-0.20831625163555145,
0.06335851550102234,
0.2190094292163849,
0.18113839626312256,
-0.46780383586883545,
0.004030230455100536,
0.20841491222381592,
-0.015284652821719646,
-0.4782763719558716,
-0.6058659553527832,
0.41916197538375854,
-0.6850515604019165,
-0.42393574118614197,
-0.06209974363446236,
-0.7525161504745483,
-0.202535018324852,
0.1474892497062683,
0.5962111949920654,
0.4672168493270874,
-0.28715965151786804,
0.38293731212615967,
0.4502097964286804,
-0.13937130570411682,
0.4141370952129364,
0.7299409508705139,
-0.18876239657402039,
-0.004835250321775675,
0.9808042049407959,
0.43396008014678955,
0.773112416267395,
0.6280260682106018,
-0.12814752757549286,
-0.10348636656999588,
-0.43029794096946716,
-0.9404160976409912,
-0.000931746035348624,
-0.5925572514533997,
-0.38458460569381714,
-0.5915333032608032,
-0.241251140832901,
-0.6386369466781616,
-0.4104141891002655,
-0.3790038228034973,
-0.565069854259491,
-0.3318997621536255,
-0.3158988952636719,
0.18544746935367584,
0.34466931223869324,
-0.3846619427204132,
0.248677596449852,
-0.7437061071395874,
0.6028001308441162,
0.20202428102493286,
0.08965364843606949,
0.12025928497314453,
-0.7426030039787292,
-0.3388303518295288,
0.16910910606384277,
-0.3009486198425293,
-0.7635534405708313,
0.3091433048248291,
0.20855441689491272,
0.7726377844810486,
0.38499772548675537,
0.1466885656118393,
1.008291244506836,
-0.41152700781822205,
0.5593429803848267,
0.4827112853527069,
-0.9234245419502258,
0.3523547947406769,
-0.3164758086204529,
0.6224772334098816,
0.5352761745452881,
0.594828724861145,
-0.7791258692741394,
-0.46851468086242676,
-0.5663811564445496,
-0.6944179534912109,
0.7405800819396973,
0.27456358075141907,
0.039802223443984985,
0.2805902361869812,
0.024840593338012695,
0.3726542890071869,
0.08124595135450363,
-0.9289031028747559,
0.06087109446525574,
-0.38402149081230164,
-0.053532518446445465,
-0.27714669704437256,
0.12218422442674637,
0.03426797688007355,
-0.34701669216156006,
0.549247682094574,
-0.21208031475543976,
0.1282772719860077,
0.08588076382875443,
-0.38993164896965027,
-0.44519051909446716,
0.534574031829834,
0.5317972302436829,
0.6951367259025574,
-0.1927780658006668,
0.14867419004440308,
0.46919378638267517,
-0.18101876974105835,
0.2651461064815521,
-0.03996063768863678,
-0.4638890027999878,
-0.019307361915707588,
0.4769555330276489,
1.1179399490356445,
0.40648961067199707,
-0.114600270986557,
0.3159356415271759,
0.31556078791618347,
-0.45114266872406006,
0.18082310259342194,
0.11488321423530579,
0.06046026572585106,
-0.052274566143751144,
0.17547239363193512,
0.03474085032939911,
-0.07050006091594696,
-0.750880777835846,
0.04850040376186371,
0.4301168620586395,
-0.448518306016922,
-0.5641869902610779,
0.7133731842041016,
0.12123890966176987,
0.11970297992229462,
0.6435724496841431,
-0.22959917783737183,
-0.3108203113079071,
0.4293801188468933,
0.7715257406234741,
0.7055696845054626,
-0.43996289372444153,
0.45966851711273193,
0.34480610489845276,
0.3420172929763794,
0.1487751007080078,
0.015997610986232758,
-0.407540500164032,
-0.9226295948028564,
-0.7610251903533936,
-0.7879549264907837,
-0.2790561318397522,
-0.028309324756264687,
-0.8061680197715759,
0.04466724395751953,
0.026204902678728104,
0.027102166786789894,
0.08437177538871765,
-0.04730682447552681,
-0.8923521637916565,
0.15811969339847565,
0.08674917370080948,
0.6027024984359741,
-0.8736617565155029,
1.1086703538894653,
0.6271144151687622,
-0.6676797270774841,
-0.8426118493080139,
-0.2706661522388458,
-0.13745614886283875,
-0.891274631023407,
0.7415056824684143,
-0.25191938877105713,
-0.13523410260677338,
0.22392721474170685,
-0.15402935445308685,
-0.6232617497444153,
1.2235537767410278,
0.5360184907913208,
-0.37555935978889465,
-0.1294700801372528,
0.4439963102340698,
0.5135220885276794,
-0.16223149001598358,
-0.029950624331831932,
0.46368321776390076,
0.4580305218696594,
0.5556786060333252,
-1.144400954246521,
-0.10679030418395996,
0.08464990556240082,
0.06337454169988632,
0.23008383810520172,
-0.43554452061653137,
0.837750256061554,
-0.2509380280971527,
-0.4258657693862915,
0.09505393356084824,
0.40931519865989685,
0.03725859895348549,
0.3327840566635132,
0.12251096218824387,
0.7109813094139099,
0.24839714169502258,
0.036941979080438614,
0.9903294444084167,
-0.28083541989326477,
0.3823230266571045,
0.9055335521697998,
-0.3312491476535797,
0.7927544116973877,
0.5364338755607605,
-0.06391091644763947,
0.3069680631160736,
0.34269794821739197,
0.01251905132085085,
0.5783612132072449,
-0.051880113780498505,
-0.1396835595369339,
-0.09777958691120148,
-0.14646176993846893,
-0.39263826608657837,
0.46223410964012146,
0.057924844324588776,
-0.09688573330640793,
-0.5786565542221069,
0.3725818991661072,
0.2728427052497864,
-0.20349149405956268,
-0.37231940031051636,
0.7824949026107788,
0.22823874652385712,
-0.7887023687362671,
0.8577342629432678,
0.09854307025671005,
0.6175307631492615,
-0.5825896859169006,
0.022796252742409706,
-0.5226916074752808,
0.13506777584552765,
-0.09178976714611053,
-0.6726372838020325,
0.40703919529914856,
0.11934143304824829,
-0.09604871273040771,
-0.5620830655097961,
0.8993703722953796,
-0.6784224510192871,
-0.5748376846313477,
0.3071082830429077,
0.8194713592529297,
0.0715077593922615,
0.05016694590449333,
-0.5629399418830872,
-0.47139972448349,
0.1391599327325821,
-0.03714212775230408,
0.5875954627990723,
0.6696615815162659,
-0.0030678603798151016,
0.3586015999317169,
0.7658782005310059,
0.11647965013980865,
0.2687329351902008,
0.11969859153032303,
0.37911495566368103,
-0.6106090545654297,
-0.13577596843242645,
-0.5297219753265381,
0.49344924092292786,
0.25112485885620117,
-0.16074076294898987,
1.006742000579834,
0.23695598542690277,
1.248169183731079,
-0.2264566868543625,
0.6668992042541504,
-0.040086157619953156,
0.2756578326225281,
-0.6730186343193054,
0.7794838547706604,
-0.6328287124633789,
-0.27110329270362854,
-0.30290380120277405,
-0.9426560997962952,
-0.49362456798553467,
0.5234610438346863,
-0.21713826060295105,
0.07136642932891846,
0.6763790249824524,
0.5087124109268188,
-0.3770221471786499,
-0.2679097056388855,
0.8858730792999268,
0.17323754727840424,
-0.017974354326725006,
0.8198099136352539,
0.7147449254989624,
-0.42419520020484924,
0.6115617752075195,
-0.3939218819141388,
0.12445801496505737,
-0.12584739923477173,
-0.8802818059921265,
-0.7880701422691345,
-0.39434894919395447,
-0.16829659044742584,
0.1936744898557663,
0.265206515789032,
0.39377105236053467,
0.9129830598831177,
-0.7481909394264221,
-0.389201819896698,
-0.14958073198795319,
-0.1149878054857254,
-0.4164580702781677,
-0.23533806204795837,
0.09496468305587769,
-0.5335205793380737,
-0.5956531167030334,
0.3349871039390564,
0.3369617164134979,
0.18394437432289124,
-0.26137274503707886,
0.026246657595038414,
-0.232289120554924,
0.09861933439970016,
0.8937828540802002,
0.5068482756614685,
-0.6640450954437256,
-0.40745022892951965,
0.07747942209243774,
-0.07460864633321762,
0.10739820450544357,
0.7542568445205688,
-0.795121431350708,
0.39623725414276123,
0.5187293291091919,
0.6028019189834595,
0.706330418586731,
0.10226104408502579,
0.8365401029586792,
-0.8315985202789307,
0.11129610240459442,
-0.1702144742012024,
0.20207609236240387,
0.5245014429092407,
-0.2212437242269516,
0.6562609076499939,
0.33396798372268677,
-0.26469165086746216,
-0.6101039052009583,
0.20961591601371765,
-0.8874571919441223,
-0.3592509627342224,
0.9013057947158813,
-0.25877904891967773,
-0.023554615676403046,
-0.21322928369045258,
-0.11026766896247864,
0.5148226022720337,
0.1756315678358078,
0.5760838389396667,
0.6584072709083557,
-0.24070997536182404,
-0.3476356267929077,
-0.8796901106834412,
0.2604455053806305,
0.8063876628875732,
-0.732751190662384,
-0.07619167864322662,
0.2879595458507538,
0.3560243248939514,
0.12073369324207306,
0.5966622233390808,
-0.08495739102363586,
0.1826619952917099,
0.10552971065044403,
0.27140843868255615,
-0.0302861537784338,
-0.5554897785186768,
-0.3303314745426178,
0.2497514933347702,
0.03193879872560501,
-0.09743748605251312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12275v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12275v2 | WorldCoder, a Model-Based LLM Agent: Building World Models by Writing Code and Interacting with the Environment | 2024-02-19T16:39:18 | 2024-05-26T04:24:04 | Hao Tang, Darren Key, Kevin Ellis | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We give a model-based agent that builds a Python program representing its
knowledge of the world based on its interactions with the environment. The
world model tries to explain its interactions, while also being optimistic
about what reward it can achieve. We define this optimism as a logical
constraint between a program and a planner. We study our agent on gridworlds,
and on task planning, finding our approach is more sample-efficient compared to
deep RL, more compute-efficient compared to ReAct-style agents, and that it can
transfer its knowledge across environments by editing its code. | [
-0.31545814871788025,
-0.5987991094589233,
0.3998185098171234,
0.12620612978935242,
0.23826885223388672,
0.057467058300971985,
0.16467317938804626,
-0.5499133467674255,
-0.05099157616496086,
0.4989874064922333,
-0.6204950213432312,
-0.38851794600486755,
-0.334553986787796,
-0.0067940279841423035,
0.003991656005382538,
0.8281958699226379,
-0.006096356548368931,
-0.2862398326396942,
-0.4396243095397949,
0.25620853900909424,
-0.08098291605710983,
-0.6961552500724792,
-0.409332811832428,
-0.8918002247810364,
0.47513285279273987,
0.20431555807590485,
0.9662727117538452,
0.628258466720581,
0.566299319267273,
0.33964619040489197,
-0.14971716701984406,
0.2007572203874588,
-0.47675955295562744,
0.39119288325309753,
-0.28804484009742737,
-0.6106377243995667,
-0.33460015058517456,
-0.10312233120203018,
-0.10657524317502975,
0.05107986181974411,
-0.08087042719125748,
0.17391295731067657,
-0.17293906211853027,
0.3637908101081848,
-0.6996950507164001,
0.5396641492843628,
-0.4331474006175995,
0.5003681182861328,
0.5281348824501038,
-0.33389154076576233,
-0.23625093698501587,
-0.25708380341529846,
-0.3705364167690277,
-0.7499708533287048,
0.03528808057308197,
0.03752918913960457,
0.5766541361808777,
0.5538247227668762,
-0.5209901332855225,
-0.26985278725624084,
-1.0892672538757324,
0.5855661034584045,
-0.5362080335617065,
0.24869434535503387,
0.10034766793251038,
0.3787936568260193,
-0.5671526193618774,
-0.6594762802124023,
-0.7198941111564636,
-0.09391596913337708,
0.12894710898399353,
0.07113991677761078,
-0.03616104647517204,
0.19221587479114532,
0.5603386759757996,
0.14265649020671844,
-0.34331074357032776,
-0.12259183824062347,
-0.393355131149292,
-0.36964306235313416,
0.8138586282730103,
0.5826808214187622,
0.4799405634403229,
-0.18418832123279572,
-0.26391902565956116,
0.0397803969681263,
-0.6242330074310303,
0.27568694949150085,
0.2727581262588501,
0.2584967315196991,
-0.08532403409481049,
0.8118597865104675,
-0.22788771986961365,
0.8066287040710449,
-0.2983577251434326,
-0.7052586078643799,
-0.18077567219734192,
0.08023726940155029,
0.015204010531306267,
-0.011970617808401585,
0.31835177540779114,
0.7190847992897034,
0.16242754459381104,
-0.30662283301353455,
-0.763942301273346,
0.3946700096130371,
0.46264174580574036,
-0.8388874530792236,
-0.1590958833694458,
0.30416572093963623,
-0.6408219337463379,
-0.4279341995716095,
0.07847980409860611,
-0.3780210316181183,
-0.5590576529502869,
-0.2883448898792267,
0.2821508049964905,
-0.13233721256256104,
-0.11798735707998276,
-0.07620697468519211,
-0.3989974856376648,
0.33310970664024353,
0.36888107657432556,
-0.4988304078578949,
0.34152472019195557,
0.995132327079773,
0.8660350441932678,
0.11321405321359634,
-0.5617946982383728,
-0.37137091159820557,
0.2371010035276413,
-0.4290215075016022,
0.9551976919174194,
-0.4491174817085266,
-0.6022369265556335,
0.04014468193054199,
-0.13550643622875214,
0.24251869320869446,
-0.3043535649776459,
0.1265658736228943,
-0.739646315574646,
-0.2871537208557129,
-0.11656884104013443,
-0.7147481441497803,
-0.18159174919128418,
0.5709693431854248,
-0.7683572769165039,
0.9566208720207214,
0.3080452084541321,
-0.5867497324943542,
0.3600645363330841,
-0.7089285850524902,
-0.18041470646858215,
0.04529045149683952,
0.1374787539243698,
0.008431973867118359,
0.04074462503194809,
0.06378229707479477,
0.5277109146118164,
-0.07776506245136261,
0.19300881028175354,
-0.2309599667787552,
-0.6722424030303955,
0.48467695713043213,
0.07520507276058197,
0.4522808790206909,
0.7043628692626953,
-0.006423918064683676,
0.11267739534378052,
-0.7436209321022034,
0.3274068534374237,
-0.027214176952838898,
-0.6246551275253296,
-0.08044517040252686,
0.3629002571105957,
0.060351595282554626,
0.45047837495803833,
0.3111916482448578,
-0.7283113598823547,
0.5630029439926147,
-0.30865418910980225,
0.6178192496299744,
0.5839957594871521,
0.1854497790336609,
0.4712403416633606,
-0.8498327136039734,
0.8312371373176575,
-0.2919851541519165,
0.07338796555995941,
-0.0763234943151474,
-0.47540467977523804,
-0.7390495538711548,
-0.07605612277984619,
-0.1754845529794693,
0.7427891492843628,
-0.6195611953735352,
0.12130063027143478,
-0.2987748980522156,
-0.6730995774269104,
-0.23326453566551208,
0.16963115334510803,
0.3116552531719208,
0.04602736607193947,
-0.014072444289922714,
0.22846993803977966,
-0.9495450854301453,
-0.7464501261711121,
-0.11366445571184158,
-0.12460807710886002,
0.43614068627357483,
0.18747469782829285,
0.9180030822753906,
-0.44159844517707825,
1.2015786170959473,
-0.5896482467651367,
0.11017763614654541,
-0.7682390809059143,
-0.42260414361953735,
0.46765562891960144,
0.5179767608642578,
0.10621440410614014,
-0.8542791604995728,
-0.7061566710472107,
0.09936423599720001,
-0.9151219129562378,
0.17571136355400085,
-0.09794238954782486,
-0.13242676854133606,
0.0939689427614212,
0.6102190017700195,
-0.9135131239891052,
0.6190711259841919,
0.37294888496398926,
-0.3653251528739929,
0.5725095272064209,
-0.4189033806324005,
0.05125968158245087,
-0.9699908494949341,
-0.0966576635837555,
-0.12916120886802673,
-0.3422990143299103,
-0.7674127221107483,
0.47289618849754333,
-0.05288411304354668,
-0.38423842191696167,
-0.6004886031150818,
0.7268612384796143,
-0.5171525478363037,
-0.2241562455892563,
-0.47550496459007263,
-0.23510797321796417,
-0.00036260305205360055,
0.4842679798603058,
0.06434246152639389,
1.0411313772201538,
0.5134214758872986,
-0.9233974814414978,
0.7230216860771179,
0.3500082194805145,
-0.41073569655418396,
0.4035412073135376,
-0.6029999852180481,
0.4227719306945801,
-0.185594841837883,
0.20374760031700134,
-0.4227370619773865,
-0.24452964961528778,
0.11024267226457596,
-0.2767498195171356,
-0.07316716760396957,
-0.3295042812824249,
-0.5473150610923767,
-0.644679605960846,
-0.016872072592377663,
-0.010479501448571682,
0.6648446321487427,
-0.6524158120155334,
0.5307760834693909,
0.4372939467430115,
0.26117318868637085,
-0.44187960028648376,
-0.8436835408210754,
0.1790970414876938,
-0.11240150034427643,
-0.5910866260528564,
0.3689214289188385,
-0.08727279305458069,
-0.8330170512199402,
0.24767740070819855,
-0.09262201189994812,
-0.18256624042987823,
0.1499110758304596,
0.6230547428131104,
0.1794714629650116,
-0.07968207448720932,
-0.12559156119823456,
-0.340345561504364,
-0.2133411020040512,
0.26006653904914856,
-0.3496880531311035,
0.44985949993133545,
-0.13600946962833405,
-0.29857906699180603,
-0.3408908545970917,
0.22390833497047424,
0.5795120000839233,
-0.02347818948328495,
0.6270198225975037,
-0.046759504824876785,
-0.38174957036972046,
-0.6577754020690918,
-0.16717444360256195,
0.3159204125404358,
-0.548197865486145,
0.437909871339798,
-0.8136622309684753,
-0.665805995464325,
0.7624934315681458,
0.012155008502304554,
-0.07188276946544647,
0.18003004789352417,
0.5412061810493469,
0.1408136934041977,
0.9076557159423828,
0.8940423130989075,
-0.1217794269323349,
0.24833330512046814,
-0.490404337644577,
0.14298729598522186,
-0.876155436038971,
-0.4476565420627594,
-0.23844489455223083,
-0.3457643687725067,
-0.32546642422676086,
-0.685039222240448,
0.1214064359664917,
-0.10078396648168564,
-0.6176854968070984,
0.3180350959300995,
-0.8500153422355652,
0.6977260112762451,
0.6706064343452454,
0.03750883415341377,
0.17896609008312225,
-0.316066175699234,
0.044082656502723694,
0.12058858573436737,
-0.8777697682380676,
-0.6627689003944397,
1.1164439916610718,
0.043985024094581604,
1.2989497184753418,
0.11798880249261856,
0.9920784831047058,
0.6088907122612,
0.2247438281774521,
-0.750979483127594,
0.6729210615158081,
0.5869610905647278,
-0.6590408086776733,
-0.07626552879810333,
-0.06885842978954315,
-0.9047853350639343,
0.5270254015922546,
-0.15536515414714813,
-0.8478768467903137,
-0.06301884353160858,
0.17468270659446716,
-0.28153282403945923,
0.6778650283813477,
-0.37234067916870117,
0.7605952620506287,
-0.1770150363445282,
-0.3608425557613373,
-0.14171989262104034,
-0.3139292299747467,
0.18274474143981934,
0.39674538373947144,
0.2910846769809723,
-0.11986783146858215,
-0.25066033005714417,
0.2757647633552551,
-0.6720204949378967,
0.6843584775924683,
-0.3506469428539276,
-0.20341484248638153,
0.7225155234336853,
0.4023747146129608,
0.8374431133270264,
-0.013544844463467598,
-0.3067515194416046,
-0.2712223529815674,
0.020863225683569908,
-0.25259584188461304,
-0.6223850846290588,
0.5906163454055786,
-1.0572376251220703,
-0.6951785683631897,
-0.5404780507087708,
-1.058258056640625,
0.11332666873931885,
0.045063745230436325,
0.15334643423557281,
0.37248408794403076,
-0.6562706232070923,
-0.28608790040016174,
0.40349528193473816,
-0.2912711501121521,
0.4915734529495239,
0.39847826957702637,
-0.6112557649612427,
-0.16107983887195587,
0.9554682970046997,
0.00697368523105979,
0.10162149369716644,
0.5937867760658264,
-0.11060461401939392,
-0.024378139525651932,
-0.3258211314678192,
-0.0810718983411789,
-0.2709837257862091,
-1.0460633039474487,
-0.3075564503669739,
-0.6527376770973206,
-0.572603702545166,
-0.2917802035808563,
-0.5654646158218384,
-0.2754206657409668,
-0.295543372631073,
0.031153511255979538,
-0.04453577101230621,
0.43792420625686646,
1.2298998832702637,
-0.20147064328193665,
0.3480713367462158,
-0.7513456344604492,
0.2518194317817688,
0.3434276282787323,
0.08309769630432129,
-0.14254185557365417,
-0.08677415549755096,
-0.4740365147590637,
0.0026125090662389994,
-0.3197897672653198,
-0.7182106971740723,
0.8139163851737976,
0.2680247128009796,
0.866863489151001,
0.09346611797809601,
0.09117399901151657,
0.5926390886306763,
-0.29256027936935425,
0.8541849255561829,
-0.15220852196216583,
-0.9397981762886047,
0.6488504409790039,
-0.17221689224243164,
0.3286866545677185,
0.016294250264763832,
-0.15252713859081268,
-0.7760483026504517,
-0.5899884104728699,
-0.5732638239860535,
-0.364656001329422,
0.8555635809898376,
0.027941426262259483,
0.1430894136428833,
0.16511861979961395,
0.6745814085006714,
0.01283054519444704,
0.15678523480892181,
-0.9229262471199036,
-0.1461147516965866,
-0.4492594003677368,
-0.0010337561834603548,
-0.25397399067878723,
-0.3503282964229584,
-0.1686875969171524,
-0.11872278153896332,
0.5412057638168335,
-0.3004712164402008,
0.58066725730896,
0.3701673150062561,
-0.6059972047805786,
0.006960587110370398,
0.47266072034835815,
0.43875008821487427,
0.5953945517539978,
-0.2203035205602646,
0.4012739658355713,
0.08865620940923691,
-0.27688339352607727,
0.6647891998291016,
-0.0857294425368309,
-0.3026556372642517,
-0.49317947030067444,
0.5292516946792603,
0.7494980692863464,
-0.20152270793914795,
-0.832427442073822,
0.36258256435394287,
0.09907346218824387,
-0.3902606666088104,
-0.35016629099845886,
0.6176957488059998,
0.25680264830589294,
0.6486431956291199,
0.1090879887342453,
0.23424862325191498,
0.17516811192035675,
-0.4024924635887146,
0.09552392363548279,
0.2439844161272049,
-0.44074901938438416,
-0.33096638321876526,
0.7925342321395874,
0.23134684562683105,
-0.7268757224082947,
0.8218063116073608,
-0.536198079586029,
-0.8788212537765503,
1.2719885110855103,
1.1313408613204956,
0.6697271466255188,
0.2701331675052643,
0.21677185595035553,
0.3111945688724518,
0.4114497900009155,
-0.05534503981471062,
0.8397034406661987,
0.040672723203897476,
-1.0624444484710693,
-0.47259798645973206,
-0.4908330738544464,
-0.5209150910377502,
-0.319112092256546,
-0.5363675951957703,
-0.15877021849155426,
-0.6598439812660217,
-0.142092764377594,
-0.4134517014026642,
0.04140349105000496,
-0.8240708708763123,
0.141386479139328,
0.2886606454849243,
1.0332456827163696,
-0.5828965306282043,
0.9597298502922058,
1.170140266418457,
-0.22255925834178925,
-0.7470242977142334,
-0.2078234702348709,
0.23071779310703278,
-0.9921035766601562,
1.0581837892532349,
0.45331358909606934,
-0.04258018359541893,
0.008410555310547352,
-0.7395259737968445,
-1.2571617364883423,
1.2377451658248901,
0.2060680240392685,
-0.3820796012878418,
0.17452968657016754,
-0.05911194160580635,
0.6353114247322083,
-0.7276220917701721,
0.0059495544992387295,
0.2100573182106018,
0.4458097517490387,
-0.2155742645263672,
-0.5886563658714294,
0.16660571098327637,
-0.7958409190177917,
0.48921728134155273,
0.23014791309833527,
-0.6644915342330933,
0.9230212569236755,
-0.7526633739471436,
-0.09087955951690674,
0.14777572453022003,
0.7825981378555298,
0.16460713744163513,
0.180139422416687,
0.3205857276916504,
0.554957389831543,
0.6952638626098633,
0.16106893122196198,
1.3560454845428467,
-0.8872936964035034,
0.48861727118492126,
0.8600450754165649,
-0.4246997833251953,
0.4936549663543701,
0.33179232478141785,
-0.3230794072151184,
0.6494083404541016,
0.6532184481620789,
-0.18317434191703796,
0.620629608631134,
0.24364764988422394,
-0.2617763578891754,
-0.5139752626419067,
-0.09837208688259125,
-0.08694057166576385,
0.35039517283439636,
0.21782469749450684,
0.1853502243757248,
-0.035258419811725616,
0.11465251445770264,
-0.3445049226284027,
0.062121596187353134,
-0.5206850171089172,
0.6494387984275818,
0.1110413670539856,
-0.7919817566871643,
0.2229200005531311,
-0.005382636561989784,
0.643527626991272,
-0.4210962653160095,
-0.1517421454191208,
-0.09711730480194092,
0.5192750096321106,
-0.37623846530914307,
-0.7448893189430237,
0.41422924399375916,
-0.13390278816223145,
-0.22584904730319977,
-0.28537461161613464,
0.9876064658164978,
-0.12545989453792572,
-0.28896862268447876,
0.1891993135213852,
0.5791658759117126,
0.1953989863395691,
0.050366781651973724,
-0.8759161829948425,
0.10933107882738113,
-0.01772874779999256,
-0.427347332239151,
0.22968509793281555,
0.3853439390659332,
0.1402091085910797,
1.3954969644546509,
0.5739784240722656,
0.14737892150878906,
-0.006921019405126572,
-0.3101459741592407,
0.8473791480064392,
-1.073451280593872,
-0.789981484413147,
-0.7785447239875793,
0.4062007963657379,
0.08815141022205353,
-0.1556379199028015,
0.755496621131897,
0.8549720048904419,
0.554616391658783,
-0.06681537628173828,
1.1899336576461792,
-0.46193739771842957,
0.08977223187685013,
-0.37590840458869934,
0.40862029790878296,
-0.4735780954360962,
0.26033374667167664,
0.07178032398223877,
-1.0638878345489502,
-0.1600492000579834,
0.8338382840156555,
0.037444598972797394,
-0.23219168186187744,
0.5939054489135742,
1.2513951063156128,
0.1456155776977539,
-0.19435176253318787,
0.3954601287841797,
-0.010171306319534779,
0.4641566574573517,
0.7142970561981201,
1.3883585929870605,
-0.12339290976524353,
0.4634599983692169,
-0.4312850534915924,
0.058414846658706665,
0.023467550054192543,
-0.6311942934989929,
-0.896440863609314,
-0.09483035653829575,
-0.20429126918315887,
-0.652558445930481,
0.23347873985767365,
1.1802518367767334,
0.6158839464187622,
-0.4730512201786041,
-0.5445497632026672,
-0.1681809425354004,
0.43868833780288696,
-0.4004477858543396,
-0.14678888022899628,
-0.053704071789979935,
-0.43629392981529236,
-0.7115161418914795,
0.4068075120449066,
0.20447027683258057,
0.04725194349884987,
-0.4821838438510895,
-0.6767627000808716,
0.19355925917625427,
0.09041028469800949,
0.4471758008003235,
0.4251563549041748,
-0.6252873539924622,
-0.27750205993652344,
-0.12977460026741028,
-0.4937853217124939,
0.0965990424156189,
0.8671838045120239,
-0.7531139850616455,
0.3925931751728058,
0.3313431143760681,
0.269441694021225,
0.5736778378486633,
-0.18846595287322998,
0.8462002873420715,
-0.24075596034526825,
0.5264034271240234,
0.052076756954193115,
0.3009844720363617,
0.2430320531129837,
-0.6829113960266113,
0.6720287203788757,
0.11368115991353989,
-0.9103941917419434,
-0.4956832826137543,
0.21282558143138885,
-0.7673065662384033,
-0.5261156558990479,
1.3693889379501343,
-0.19744592905044556,
-0.4346652626991272,
-0.19751548767089844,
-0.25840112566947937,
-0.07935211807489395,
-0.45624226331710815,
0.418258398771286,
0.3794460892677307,
-0.5267453193664551,
-0.01714705489575863,
-0.5711323618888855,
0.4491676688194275,
-0.33594146370887756,
-0.7494279742240906,
-0.24141518771648407,
0.5984566807746887,
0.35961446166038513,
-0.004565785638988018,
0.9761629104614258,
0.46980416774749756,
0.2670041024684906,
0.7551620006561279,
0.7870345711708069,
-0.4792291224002838,
-0.1394224613904953,
-0.0360378623008728,
0.2173805683851242,
0.3860471546649933,
0.05485931783914566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12424v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12424v4 | Tables as Texts or Images: Evaluating the Table Reasoning Ability of LLMs and MLLMs | 2024-02-19T16:34:50 | 2024-06-06T03:02:25 | Naihao Deng, Zhenjie Sun, Ruiqi He, Aman Sikka, Yulong Chen, Lin Ma, Yue Zhang, Rada Mihalcea | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | In this paper, we investigate the effectiveness of various LLMs in
interpreting tabular data through different prompting strategies and data
formats. Our analyses extend across six benchmarks for table-related tasks such
as question-answering and fact-checking. We introduce for the first time the
assessment of LLMs' performance on image-based table representations.
Specifically, we compare five text-based and three image-based table
representations, demonstrating the role of representation and prompting on LLM
performance. Our study provides insights into the effective use of LLMs on
table-related tasks. | [
-0.2658611834049225,
-0.9977365136146545,
0.9287935495376587,
0.2060825675725937,
-0.39825451374053955,
-0.007037690840661526,
0.14001330733299255,
-0.41838178038597107,
-0.15841060876846313,
0.5840138792991638,
-0.48373228311538696,
-0.7788315415382385,
-0.44462132453918457,
0.3683643937110901,
-0.6981266140937805,
0.702095091342926,
-0.3166569769382477,
0.4226657748222351,
-0.9255236983299255,
-0.094866082072258,
-0.7141223549842834,
-0.31143319606781006,
-0.5644482374191284,
-0.6558195948600769,
0.8534553647041321,
0.6992208361625671,
0.8326752185821533,
0.7590029239654541,
0.7166386842727661,
0.20606806874275208,
0.18184322118759155,
0.22442354261875153,
-0.2004263699054718,
0.2895963788032532,
0.09799075871706009,
-0.7632455229759216,
-0.26284217834472656,
0.1256372034549713,
0.5306269526481628,
0.4573739767074585,
-0.06271248310804367,
0.3530154824256897,
0.1292303055524826,
1.1868557929992676,
-0.3068172335624695,
0.428440660238266,
-0.6759781837463379,
0.4799288511276245,
-0.0865604355931282,
-0.4219202399253845,
-0.7605705261230469,
-0.6733565926551819,
-0.013331453315913677,
-0.5091557502746582,
-0.10800512880086899,
0.43193694949150085,
0.5297184586524963,
0.23785342276096344,
-0.4867619574069977,
-0.7702434659004211,
-0.6195128560066223,
0.4790419042110443,
-0.33194077014923096,
0.6353002190589905,
0.22041386365890503,
0.348254919052124,
-0.3050101399421692,
-1.014897108078003,
-0.6274576187133789,
-0.667985737323761,
-0.33148863911628723,
0.09521999210119247,
-0.024225521832704544,
-0.13761170208454132,
0.6980579495429993,
0.2760244905948639,
-0.7239802479743958,
0.04071079194545746,
-0.1344393491744995,
-0.030279245227575302,
0.38268768787384033,
0.4058224558830261,
0.4420526325702667,
-0.06648746877908707,
-0.509848952293396,
-0.0959482491016388,
-0.8157374858856201,
0.12759332358837128,
0.007860517129302025,
0.02083025500178337,
-0.03742659091949463,
0.8794127702713013,
0.056710708886384964,
1.0305025577545166,
-0.4256646931171417,
-0.2295602411031723,
-0.17999327182769775,
-0.14254841208457947,
-0.39546409249305725,
-0.08626803010702133,
0.4662878215312958,
0.6439802646636963,
0.25102418661117554,
-0.1933298110961914,
-0.21634520590305328,
0.28083425760269165,
0.13109654188156128,
-0.24872846901416779,
0.04830664023756981,
0.04672059044241905,
-0.650661826133728,
-0.08185425400733948,
-0.038762643933296204,
-0.92253577709198,
-0.7694564461708069,
-0.46605584025382996,
0.6786379218101501,
-0.20124785602092743,
0.3151071071624756,
-0.22471027076244354,
-0.30666735768318176,
0.4392797350883484,
0.6301883459091187,
-0.6195542216300964,
0.43039798736572266,
0.3705788254737854,
0.7223125100135803,
-0.5819031000137329,
-0.06977713108062744,
-0.38292479515075684,
0.27808505296707153,
-0.6644816398620605,
1.126763105392456,
-0.37115633487701416,
-0.5234689116477966,
0.21370728313922882,
-0.14204396307468414,
-0.04584179073572159,
-0.8212063312530518,
0.7032906413078308,
-0.4735356271266937,
-0.0030897643882781267,
-0.8417729139328003,
-0.7025416493415833,
-0.25768381357192993,
0.5223142504692078,
-1.1629351377487183,
1.0638229846954346,
-0.050048746168613434,
-0.4272637665271759,
0.8410927057266235,
-0.8759850859642029,
-0.450274795293808,
-0.055632710456848145,
-0.5620598793029785,
-0.45937880873680115,
-0.2018224000930786,
0.4135538935661316,
0.7366895079612732,
-0.3670850694179535,
-0.05187580734491348,
-0.01657669059932232,
-0.5156958103179932,
0.7255393266677856,
-0.35825830698013306,
0.20984002947807312,
0.1540001779794693,
-0.21066328883171082,
0.16656993329524994,
-0.43658047914505005,
0.02174040488898754,
0.1702108383178711,
-0.6512183547019958,
0.23708924651145935,
0.3568077087402344,
-0.19085818529129028,
-0.07711161673069,
-0.023479340597987175,
-0.129286989569664,
0.27495113015174866,
0.27883490920066833,
0.14081716537475586,
0.32623031735420227,
-0.018380852416157722,
0.2697347104549408,
-0.6111900210380554,
0.2529483735561371,
0.1964062601327896,
-0.11998414993286133,
-0.10677757859230042,
-0.5709960460662842,
-0.7731390595436096,
0.12480375915765762,
0.2492893785238266,
0.7209354639053345,
-1.1898289918899536,
-0.22702479362487793,
-0.0714765340089798,
-0.581157922744751,
-0.006727855186909437,
0.19566288590431213,
0.33584368228912354,
0.8083688616752625,
0.4470921456813812,
-0.02788507752120495,
-0.36370038986206055,
-0.8615196347236633,
-0.5373750925064087,
-0.19980618357658386,
0.07602271437644958,
0.38169142603874207,
0.6048384308815002,
0.225357323884964,
0.6320709586143494,
-0.19051024317741394,
-0.21822373569011688,
-0.5133235454559326,
0.2507516145706177,
0.252976655960083,
0.36727777123451233,
0.4215616285800934,
-0.5566287636756897,
-0.6585384011268616,
-0.0895862877368927,
-1.0858896970748901,
0.01667778752744198,
-0.30507391691207886,
0.10251449793577194,
0.5920473337173462,
0.5718560814857483,
-0.5641067624092102,
0.8347979187965393,
0.009731206111609936,
-0.5340268015861511,
0.5871894955635071,
-0.09958944469690323,
0.4945026934146881,
-0.1769300252199173,
0.0804540365934372,
0.12277337908744812,
-0.2753605246543884,
-0.7690653204917908,
-0.3246447741985321,
0.21564312279224396,
-0.17262762784957886,
-0.4681154787540436,
0.4933631122112274,
-0.8917939066886902,
-0.6471502184867859,
0.08392346650362015,
0.1785016655921936,
0.032135721296072006,
0.2758294939994812,
0.07893440127372742,
0.9804466962814331,
0.4248799979686737,
-0.5285244584083557,
0.3920697867870331,
0.1387772560119629,
-0.7630612254142761,
0.7506163120269775,
-0.5725617408752441,
0.17967680096626282,
-0.2967199981212616,
0.07265084981918335,
-1.2421787977218628,
0.06143096834421158,
0.44819703698158264,
-0.08161941170692444,
0.46222302317619324,
0.14616337418556213,
-0.6490116119384766,
-0.5797774195671082,
-0.360851913690567,
-0.311428964138031,
0.5081977844238281,
-0.4879706799983978,
0.6994658708572388,
0.050224605947732925,
0.0795755609869957,
-0.7933049201965332,
-0.8055157661437988,
0.24454209208488464,
-0.38013768196105957,
-0.3826662302017212,
0.3479696214199066,
0.15760834515094757,
-0.4856635630130768,
0.22568254172801971,
-0.27478858828544617,
0.008475092239677906,
-0.11274693161249161,
0.2937247157096863,
0.4044644832611084,
-0.1296926736831665,
0.0004271967918612063,
-0.22775886952877045,
0.05327403545379639,
0.22459621727466583,
0.25132590532302856,
0.31665274500846863,
-0.15006275475025177,
-0.49367237091064453,
-0.5528364181518555,
0.13591241836547852,
0.3276696503162384,
0.2979578971862793,
0.7134835720062256,
0.4973505437374115,
-0.17908993363380432,
0.03661024942994118,
-0.8251126408576965,
-0.17655996978282928,
-0.4228796064853668,
0.1102457121014595,
-0.4014407992362976,
-0.5044706463813782,
0.7627542614936829,
-0.05421700328588486,
0.22209343314170837,
0.22894912958145142,
0.48113685846328735,
-0.6703308820724487,
0.7920476794242859,
-0.02077312581241131,
0.23726008832454681,
0.2655879855155945,
-0.3094874918460846,
-0.1785658597946167,
-0.5465306639671326,
-0.680252730846405,
-0.7059140205383301,
-0.6340423226356506,
-0.3058457374572754,
-0.5072532296180725,
0.41407451033592224,
-0.12088888883590698,
-0.14450183510780334,
-0.051568154245615005,
-0.49253690242767334,
0.6651050448417664,
0.4677084684371948,
0.45276138186454773,
0.5740563273429871,
0.14080722630023956,
-0.1042630597949028,
-0.1183350533246994,
-0.7560594081878662,
-0.883837103843689,
0.8837679028511047,
0.31359830498695374,
1.0979588031768799,
-0.2848796844482422,
0.30595213174819946,
0.6246387958526611,
0.7071815729141235,
-0.8059208393096924,
0.9058219790458679,
-0.1356576830148697,
-0.5931337475776672,
-0.5136250853538513,
-0.34169381856918335,
-0.9819461107254028,
0.287423312664032,
-0.4416802227497101,
-0.8340010643005371,
-0.1016351655125618,
0.11502140015363693,
0.06627747416496277,
0.38490384817123413,
-0.767155647277832,
0.9738894701004028,
-0.5129941701889038,
-0.34508371353149414,
-0.02966686524450779,
-0.2628239393234253,
0.21156568825244904,
0.3975682258605957,
0.10420919954776764,
-0.20058730244636536,
-0.364031583070755,
0.9064137935638428,
0.030499326065182686,
0.7174416184425354,
-0.30804306268692017,
0.19813470542430878,
0.5226389169692993,
0.2438054233789444,
0.45862269401550293,
-0.11317551881074905,
-0.30871573090553284,
-0.044430673122406006,
0.20408837497234344,
-0.1420278400182724,
-1.0786473751068115,
0.35564589500427246,
-0.36413347721099854,
-0.8388227224349976,
-0.28275492787361145,
-0.7310193777084351,
-0.422015517950058,
-0.07561255991458893,
0.01866915263235569,
0.48623260855674744,
-0.004750004503875971,
0.3046407103538513,
0.45757171511650085,
-0.18619216978549957,
0.3818371295928955,
0.33033642172813416,
-0.3843308389186859,
-0.17382961511611938,
0.6582637429237366,
0.511911153793335,
-0.08014439046382904,
0.4487539529800415,
0.03678686171770096,
-0.8151331543922424,
-0.7988526821136475,
-0.6498529314994812,
0.010996486060321331,
-1.0854947566986084,
-0.223113015294075,
-0.15924815833568573,
-0.02522682212293148,
0.19936130940914154,
-0.089584119617939,
0.3538582921028137,
-0.40960246324539185,
-0.5367941856384277,
-0.14578209817409515,
0.3412647247314453,
0.9684818983078003,
0.33761560916900635,
0.19981183111667633,
-0.5688285827636719,
0.2779231071472168,
0.4955675005912781,
0.44465988874435425,
0.08732359856367111,
-0.17422854900360107,
0.12449672073125839,
-0.3953538239002228,
-0.3315284848213196,
-1.500796914100647,
0.10060080885887146,
-0.0966433584690094,
1.102887511253357,
0.19197826087474823,
-0.307587593793869,
0.5470362305641174,
-0.5187217593193054,
0.9140341877937317,
0.24794788658618927,
-0.7775337100028992,
0.5514525175094604,
0.011594624258577824,
0.10585899651050568,
0.3936136066913605,
0.6284173130989075,
-0.29985013604164124,
-0.19527395069599152,
-0.19004954397678375,
-0.29593634605407715,
0.4642147123813629,
0.1294667273759842,
-0.12986265122890472,
0.2982514500617981,
0.622520923614502,
0.14437918365001678,
0.2527052164077759,
-1.045522689819336,
-0.3930476903915405,
0.02492598071694374,
-0.18318353593349457,
0.20426872372627258,
-0.5867168307304382,
-0.03560999408364296,
-0.35622137784957886,
0.24447870254516602,
0.013551760464906693,
0.45248788595199585,
0.39958319067955017,
-0.29175207018852234,
0.08280279487371445,
0.38383737206459045,
0.6418506503105164,
0.8038658499717712,
0.011471436358988285,
0.3780451714992523,
0.5749263763427734,
-0.3280714452266693,
0.22341486811637878,
-0.20868556201457977,
-0.08287706226110458,
0.22720938920974731,
0.4187236428260803,
0.7973191738128662,
0.11805973201990128,
-0.5602573156356812,
-0.029117615893483162,
-0.1425752341747284,
-0.36566802859306335,
0.06274092197418213,
0.2648487091064453,
0.256026029586792,
0.12317958474159241,
0.4522002637386322,
-0.6202014684677124,
0.18449611961841583,
-0.8975849151611328,
0.25007036328315735,
0.5654833912849426,
-0.38730934262275696,
0.31869783997535706,
0.4334423840045929,
-0.03181985393166542,
-0.43530064821243286,
0.4847015142440796,
0.028831718489527702,
-0.23013034462928772,
0.8439502120018005,
0.5482046604156494,
0.13557328283786774,
0.0029626686591655016,
0.28516092896461487,
0.21042753756046295,
0.4801619052886963,
0.11027863621711731,
0.9053557515144348,
-0.09614582359790802,
-0.5796135663986206,
-0.16323067247867584,
-0.10543493926525116,
-0.7211500406265259,
0.27625221014022827,
-0.5086548328399658,
0.13627636432647705,
-0.3764461576938629,
-0.39294928312301636,
0.3278350532054901,
0.06932999193668365,
-0.7582178711891174,
0.19191327691078186,
-0.03775379806756973,
1.1083492040634155,
-0.5201299786567688,
0.39553746581077576,
0.8622344732284546,
-0.27020731568336487,
-0.8679024577140808,
-0.512873113155365,
0.003165682777762413,
-0.8799003958702087,
0.8762326836585999,
0.09812215715646744,
0.3643992841243744,
-0.17630839347839355,
-0.7590774893760681,
-0.5141420364379883,
1.2471904754638672,
0.4761640131473541,
-0.5364729762077332,
0.1153457835316658,
0.70069420337677,
0.447986900806427,
-0.30282557010650635,
0.3600129187107086,
0.8535088300704956,
0.9324403405189514,
0.2237912118434906,
-0.5627029538154602,
0.17874497175216675,
0.08314984291791916,
-0.10625099390745163,
-0.0274087805300951,
-0.01779010333120823,
0.5107570290565491,
-0.18015022575855255,
-0.33724603056907654,
-0.19559045135974884,
0.5576506853103638,
0.4372698664665222,
0.757526159286499,
0.6265407800674438,
0.4340556561946869,
0.7086923718452454,
-0.5995355844497681,
0.9550830721855164,
0.1563313603401184,
-0.12003228813409805,
0.7917629480361938,
-0.45861580967903137,
0.7618823051452637,
0.6510717868804932,
-0.4132704436779022,
0.6802965402603149,
0.6418784856796265,
-0.39572280645370483,
0.19856929779052734,
0.34762823581695557,
0.05126028507947922,
-0.016281794756650925,
-0.19714979827404022,
-0.28063860535621643,
0.20959515869617462,
0.8137469291687012,
-0.48272356390953064,
-0.46442556381225586,
-0.18458415567874908,
-0.26034030318260193,
0.17609459161758423,
-0.5568687915802002,
0.8240318894386292,
0.12166612595319748,
-0.5806843638420105,
0.2714281678199768,
-0.37494730949401855,
0.17374378442764282,
-0.13956838846206665,
-0.5128755569458008,
-0.10879610478878021,
-0.5237165689468384,
-0.41781044006347656,
-1.5509581565856934,
0.34641969203948975,
0.12564906477928162,
0.07364359498023987,
-0.33812326192855835,
1.2402743101119995,
-0.31574660539627075,
-0.2854369878768921,
-0.07521840184926987,
0.931948721408844,
0.38398879766464233,
0.24219153821468353,
-0.9614708423614502,
0.3541789948940277,
-0.09925477206707001,
-0.3758678436279297,
0.042330097407102585,
0.3090325593948364,
-0.0596347339451313,
0.8290079236030579,
0.5026747584342957,
-0.046418413519859314,
-0.10808572173118591,
0.21904350817203522,
0.6660709381103516,
-0.8000063896179199,
-0.10084090381860733,
-1.1072137355804443,
0.4998134672641754,
-0.09161991626024246,
0.13062873482704163,
0.6622856259346008,
0.5718019008636475,
0.22319577634334564,
-0.4170152246952057,
0.3061704933643341,
0.1798953264951706,
0.397927463054657,
-0.9371351599693298,
0.744848906993866,
-0.38778749108314514,
0.08788615465164185,
-0.3087785542011261,
-0.8998742699623108,
-0.32776474952697754,
0.6741161346435547,
-0.6672824621200562,
-0.0008408646681345999,
0.8414533734321594,
0.6112412810325623,
0.40347158908843994,
0.22365376353263855,
0.4684070348739624,
-0.18405480682849884,
0.039129551500082016,
0.2407522201538086,
1.3846880197525024,
-0.08717532455921173,
0.6597065329551697,
-0.09301035106182098,
0.10955329984426498,
-0.10683001577854156,
-1.0830624103546143,
-1.1724791526794434,
-0.514814019203186,
-0.20846132934093475,
-0.23010319471359253,
-0.051770903170108795,
0.4580244719982147,
0.43613243103027344,
-0.5098671913146973,
-0.408917635679245,
-0.00082575244596228,
0.6710824370384216,
-0.052403829991817474,
-0.23843595385551453,
0.4226720929145813,
-0.21084743738174438,
-0.20142926275730133,
0.08339709043502808,
0.3618546724319458,
0.4792101979255676,
-0.2507234215736389,
0.06645841151475906,
-0.07815904170274734,
-0.0185446348041296,
0.67190021276474,
0.0038866191171109676,
-0.6786919832229614,
-0.04814323037862778,
0.1315133422613144,
-0.28917768597602844,
0.39443618059158325,
0.9041724801063538,
-0.7422678470611572,
0.1363237500190735,
0.5180826783180237,
0.46110084652900696,
0.6105982661247253,
0.03047829493880272,
0.1684209555387497,
-0.39695626497268677,
-0.060128241777420044,
0.35237857699394226,
0.46797406673431396,
0.333429217338562,
-0.40956684947013855,
0.7931185960769653,
0.016797473654150963,
-0.5822950005531311,
-0.8264741897583008,
-0.1660480499267578,
-1.0214591026306152,
-0.20753222703933716,
0.9211491346359253,
-0.0038751112297177315,
-0.42389145493507385,
-0.2041628509759903,
-0.36060383915901184,
0.20073774456977844,
-0.2854526937007904,
0.8148593902587891,
0.8166472911834717,
-0.5774494409561157,
-0.5323046445846558,
-0.8666996359825134,
0.6680032014846802,
0.2980639338493347,
-1.3677217960357666,
-0.1576114147901535,
0.5407918095588684,
-0.06971368938684464,
0.1584792584180832,
0.6328647136688232,
-0.25753453373908997,
0.3850485384464264,
-0.00650229724124074,
-0.21117688715457916,
-0.13241097331047058,
-0.38371625542640686,
0.00697717722505331,
0.09370557963848114,
0.17058062553405762,
0.11424170434474945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12267v1 | High-quality Data-to-Text Generation for Severely Under-Resourced Languages with Out-of-the-box Large Language Models | 2024-02-19T16:29:40 | 2024-02-19T16:29:40 | Michela Lorandi, Anya Belz | cs.CL | cs.CL | The performance of NLP methods for severely under-resourced languages cannot
currently hope to match the state of the art in NLP methods for well resourced
languages. We explore the extent to which pretrained large language models
(LLMs) can bridge this gap, via the example of data-to-text generation for
Irish, Welsh, Breton and Maltese. We test LLMs on these under-resourced
languages and English, in a range of scenarios. We find that LLMs easily set
the state of the art for the under-resourced languages by substantial margins,
as measured by both automatic and human evaluations. For all our languages,
human evaluation shows on-a-par performance with humans for our best systems,
but BLEU scores collapse compared to English, casting doubt on the metric's
suitability for evaluating non-task-specific systems. Overall, our results
demonstrate the great potential of LLMs to bridge the performance gap for
under-resourced languages. | [
-0.2970081567764282,
-0.3768378794193268,
0.573129415512085,
0.2804964482784271,
-0.3196868300437927,
0.25323763489723206,
-0.6982863545417786,
-0.48236528038978577,
0.029179910197854042,
0.8251366019248962,
-0.4389406740665436,
-0.3248010277748108,
-0.5523484349250793,
0.4453645646572113,
-0.3944261372089386,
0.9088758230209351,
-0.052091777324676514,
0.018200768157839775,
-0.3370557129383087,
0.006694796495139599,
-0.36882299184799194,
-0.7623193860054016,
-0.5479639172554016,
-0.5384294390678406,
0.4149254858493805,
0.3322417736053467,
0.7051547765731812,
0.4832223951816559,
0.5592383742332458,
0.2811557948589325,
-0.07651253789663315,
0.40429699420928955,
-0.66822749376297,
0.03833717107772827,
-0.3220311999320984,
-0.2420796900987625,
-0.5371595621109009,
-0.02726231887936592,
0.6250627040863037,
0.9443125128746033,
-0.11508875340223312,
0.14560027420520782,
0.36776068806648254,
0.7249460220336914,
-0.4721461832523346,
0.028617126867175102,
-0.8408735990524292,
-0.06313931196928024,
-0.45583969354629517,
-0.311577707529068,
-0.46783584356307983,
-0.1943177878856659,
-0.14430737495422363,
-0.3817388415336609,
0.24836145341396332,
0.11621864885091782,
0.661246657371521,
0.3270459473133087,
-0.2693461775779724,
-0.3880237340927124,
-0.9197185039520264,
0.8553861379623413,
-0.802466094493866,
0.4777490794658661,
0.47966063022613525,
-0.03902275487780571,
-0.3940579295158386,
-0.7110949754714966,
-0.45240554213523865,
-0.4436146020889282,
-0.12228645384311676,
0.06507695466279984,
-0.1671755164861679,
-0.06748882681131363,
0.3431101143360138,
0.4668978750705719,
-0.6175209879875183,
0.5103636384010315,
-0.34217432141304016,
0.1407611221075058,
0.8716886043548584,
0.08610900491476059,
0.17570191621780396,
-0.19187520444393158,
-0.11865647882223129,
0.00535189313814044,
-0.9947859048843384,
-0.160902738571167,
0.5350592732429504,
0.6713632345199585,
0.017613695934414864,
0.7104765772819519,
0.0797886922955513,
0.6586557626724243,
-0.052606966346502304,
-0.004907774273306131,
0.09823562204837799,
-0.28419506549835205,
-0.2501939535140991,
-0.026018312200903893,
1.0246015787124634,
0.19883742928504944,
0.49668699502944946,
-0.3472369909286499,
-0.5491836071014404,
0.15729062259197235,
0.15704800188541412,
-0.6591683030128479,
-0.09632060676813126,
-0.0835888683795929,
-0.19238899648189545,
-0.027247242629528046,
-0.3529509902000427,
-0.6406463980674744,
-0.20436608791351318,
-0.06676800549030304,
0.3190516233444214,
-0.0006855072570033371,
-0.3706173598766327,
0.33630287647247314,
0.18665222823619843,
-0.15364590287208557,
0.06673573702573776,
-1.0492887496948242,
0.4565545916557312,
0.34968435764312744,
0.6003322005271912,
-0.308890163898468,
-0.18388104438781738,
-0.3252143859863281,
0.0766603872179985,
-0.6447905898094177,
0.517896831035614,
-0.42777717113494873,
-0.47813573479652405,
0.1637943685054779,
-0.06045100465416908,
0.03636657074093819,
-0.7822610139846802,
0.5485441088676453,
-0.5124664902687073,
0.21068251132965088,
-0.19633181393146515,
-0.547153115272522,
0.33874577283859253,
0.06338562816381454,
-0.7935774326324463,
1.175905466079712,
0.268883615732193,
-0.7127648591995239,
0.3326466679573059,
-0.5097138285636902,
-0.6399422287940979,
0.31382161378860474,
-0.07009188085794449,
-0.10912430286407471,
0.4098796844482422,
0.17754973471164703,
0.6884336471557617,
-0.7910138964653015,
0.35777872800827026,
-0.05301492288708687,
-0.2734072208404541,
0.17151996493339539,
-0.6156554818153381,
0.5602865815162659,
0.18464121222496033,
-0.19492553174495697,
-0.3473518192768097,
-0.7607963681221008,
0.3380151093006134,
0.2063838243484497,
-0.6702888607978821,
-0.22524917125701904,
0.01098113413900137,
0.34994998574256897,
0.42544081807136536,
0.24498774111270905,
-0.5596732497215271,
0.04264327138662338,
-0.5492264032363892,
0.6322829127311707,
0.38589978218078613,
-0.5489749312400818,
0.23174794018268585,
-0.15877769887447357,
0.6046077013015747,
-0.2335262894630432,
-0.262268990278244,
-0.07629598677158356,
-0.26093342900276184,
-0.7847595810890198,
-0.01323600672185421,
0.5196939706802368,
0.6130877733230591,
-0.843275249004364,
0.6062437295913696,
-0.21921059489250183,
-0.4179387092590332,
-0.6909289956092834,
0.5830628275871277,
0.5847228765487671,
0.31541723012924194,
0.4034631848335266,
-0.524398148059845,
-0.40531012415885925,
-0.7275217175483704,
-0.045476678758859634,
-0.346915066242218,
-0.268832266330719,
0.2839981019496918,
0.36992231011390686,
-0.367386132478714,
0.7253944873809814,
-0.17631536722183228,
-0.05007215216755867,
-0.5760115385055542,
-0.04425087571144104,
0.15081976354122162,
0.5132743716239929,
0.25496456027030945,
-0.5571019053459167,
-0.23029504716396332,
0.09574391692876816,
-0.43736299872398376,
-0.3389623165130615,
0.10291324555873871,
0.045544903725385666,
0.43847617506980896,
0.6881359815597534,
-0.520246684551239,
0.12082923203706741,
0.9078361392021179,
-0.16632984578609467,
0.539071798324585,
-0.4399828612804413,
0.09379351139068604,
-1.1262632608413696,
0.1296169012784958,
0.021876009181141853,
-0.2724124789237976,
-0.3962368965148926,
-0.18348917365074158,
-0.06042669713497162,
-0.3390062153339386,
-0.4559963047504425,
0.7776103019714355,
-0.44093674421310425,
-0.27623528242111206,
-0.19112344086170197,
0.08583203703165054,
-0.00926816277205944,
0.0866951197385788,
0.2537960112094879,
0.7501980066299438,
0.262186199426651,
-0.4291349947452545,
0.4352266490459442,
0.14235596358776093,
-0.49448397755622864,
0.33871373534202576,
-0.6319434642791748,
0.00006407630280591547,
0.07517934590578079,
0.2325230985879898,
-0.7913048267364502,
-0.3571442663669586,
-0.36309975385665894,
-0.20919737219810486,
0.5274927020072937,
-0.1411786675453186,
-0.5857455730438232,
-0.48862630128860474,
0.17407658696174622,
0.5783936977386475,
0.5708959102630615,
-0.6245998740196228,
0.13212399184703827,
0.2553572356700897,
-0.4232676029205322,
-0.42415574193000793,
-0.9351436495780945,
0.32884255051612854,
-0.24615980684757233,
-0.6891314387321472,
0.298233300447464,
0.0332346186041832,
-0.20590004324913025,
-0.1241103857755661,
0.28477269411087036,
-0.2316880077123642,
0.12996281683444977,
-0.022531358525156975,
0.1021420806646347,
-0.475960373878479,
0.23238827288150787,
-0.2810024321079254,
-0.11642167717218399,
-0.003511085407808423,
-0.3499637544155121,
0.6922777891159058,
0.01718338578939438,
-0.4518476724624634,
-0.27708035707473755,
0.45997822284698486,
0.398216187953949,
-0.36602240800857544,
0.5900989174842834,
0.2855055332183838,
-0.3327036201953888,
-0.36554327607154846,
-0.6285995841026306,
-0.036518972367048264,
-0.4878549873828888,
0.45359471440315247,
-0.13973137736320496,
-0.9485424160957336,
0.33383509516716003,
-0.29574766755104065,
0.03434759005904198,
0.5600377321243286,
0.588827908039093,
-0.30490684509277344,
0.8295885324478149,
0.814140260219574,
0.03523295000195503,
0.20562992990016937,
-0.15407738089561462,
0.15596319735050201,
-0.5677804350852966,
0.07731465995311737,
-0.6962623596191406,
-0.09819051623344421,
-1.0036126375198364,
-0.37272635102272034,
0.11587680876255035,
0.32550153136253357,
-0.09273747354745865,
0.19309403002262115,
-0.13218264281749725,
0.6100636720657349,
0.5362549424171448,
-0.0804871991276741,
0.23951077461242676,
0.013474828563630581,
0.055566370487213135,
-0.08687134832143784,
-1.0544426441192627,
-0.8897265791893005,
1.2180707454681396,
0.08045827597379684,
0.9091909527778625,
-0.21578994393348694,
0.7620161175727844,
0.22642433643341064,
0.15442170202732086,
-0.4962398111820221,
0.3682560920715332,
-0.6994568109512329,
-0.4894355833530426,
-0.4337296485900879,
-0.6304590702056885,
-1.1048872470855713,
-0.15950556099414825,
-0.3380487561225891,
-0.47576770186424255,
-0.12635838985443115,
0.3210126757621765,
-0.42412620782852173,
0.3432893455028534,
-0.7080392837524414,
0.80641770362854,
-0.49243125319480896,
-0.436874657869339,
-0.11908658593893051,
-0.3877546489238739,
0.36074182391166687,
-0.5154318809509277,
0.3028607964515686,
0.023329542949795723,
0.18412275612354279,
0.7869550585746765,
-0.3586570918560028,
0.6666433811187744,
0.12861639261245728,
-0.2869882881641388,
0.07436604797840118,
-0.06433169543743134,
0.3192083239555359,
-0.04360409453511238,
-0.22904428839683533,
0.22496114671230316,
-0.26783865690231323,
-0.568759560585022,
-0.41903552412986755,
0.6965036392211914,
-0.5748580098152161,
-0.4708836078643799,
-0.06822330504655838,
-0.4933856427669525,
-0.389619916677475,
0.09930554777383804,
0.3939775824546814,
0.5478264093399048,
-0.2819177508354187,
0.11614682525396347,
0.6119214296340942,
-0.5427795052528381,
0.5650464296340942,
0.4123101234436035,
-0.07457070052623749,
-0.24419783055782318,
0.7192268967628479,
0.2597895860671997,
0.4684721827507019,
0.12852226197719574,
0.08784159272909164,
-0.4356880486011505,
-0.6959744691848755,
-0.727353572845459,
0.23349331319332123,
-0.2518673837184906,
-0.16559502482414246,
-0.27375757694244385,
-0.3267168700695038,
-0.1935662180185318,
-0.46953505277633667,
-0.6641846299171448,
-0.38410353660583496,
-0.24365898966789246,
0.049994733184576035,
0.01994640938937664,
1.0482559204101562,
-0.1330655813217163,
0.48021191358566284,
-0.8610329031944275,
0.2704950273036957,
0.32257509231567383,
0.3855000138282776,
-0.08415510505437851,
-0.48038893938064575,
-0.4186319410800934,
-0.0063012223690748215,
-0.2537451982498169,
-0.4371262192726135,
0.42185071110725403,
0.13176892697811127,
0.40407776832580566,
0.10757116973400116,
0.13086000084877014,
0.4740947484970093,
-0.7791842818260193,
0.7605863213539124,
0.28305739164352417,
-0.7397416234016418,
0.369550496339798,
-0.25073572993278503,
0.20350781083106995,
0.36564046144485474,
0.3803546726703644,
-0.5857191681861877,
-0.5580695867538452,
-0.5768187642097473,
-1.030174970626831,
0.7323846220970154,
0.2213592529296875,
0.3208446204662323,
-0.07228535413742065,
0.26932406425476074,
0.1772177368402481,
0.2723146677017212,
-0.7693985104560852,
0.08864319324493408,
0.10085384547710419,
-0.20673660933971405,
-0.5999365448951721,
-0.3422450125217438,
0.08067545294761658,
0.042374905198812485,
0.636959969997406,
0.05951721593737602,
-0.024339696392416954,
-0.04549065977334976,
-0.13823865354061127,
-0.3630536198616028,
0.38391250371932983,
0.38496509194374084,
0.9741800427436829,
-0.13094158470630646,
-0.016405750066041946,
0.2536162734031677,
-0.4594854712486267,
0.40896934270858765,
0.14032703638076782,
0.022099779918789864,
-0.14786049723625183,
0.7628216743469238,
0.7659417390823364,
0.06708995997905731,
-0.6202638149261475,
0.457843154668808,
-0.14521923661231995,
0.058376505970954895,
-0.0606449730694294,
0.17658227682113647,
0.21304337680339813,
0.22307747602462769,
0.40196749567985535,
-0.13483797013759613,
-0.4885404706001282,
-0.5505642890930176,
0.15399514138698578,
0.5016916990280151,
-0.1350187361240387,
-0.27002477645874023,
0.5287147760391235,
0.5928615927696228,
-0.4941771626472473,
0.6368560194969177,
-0.18892396986484528,
-0.4041050970554352,
0.46662265062332153,
0.6751682162284851,
0.6237919926643372,
-0.2809986174106598,
0.12040083855390549,
0.106228306889534,
0.5735698938369751,
-0.32917076349258423,
0.36448296904563904,
0.1253589391708374,
-0.7796858549118042,
-0.9045819044113159,
-0.9072080850601196,
-0.25880447030067444,
0.4809877574443817,
-0.6125975251197815,
0.1698104590177536,
-0.24908779561519623,
-0.33740416169166565,
-0.13266603648662567,
0.33017948269844055,
-0.9372150301933289,
0.4354304075241089,
0.2699747085571289,
0.8632247447967529,
-1.1493864059448242,
0.7360602021217346,
0.6016055941581726,
0.010749484412372112,
-0.6779187321662903,
-0.04155702888965607,
-0.49139195680618286,
-0.651283860206604,
0.7013118267059326,
-0.03216071426868439,
-0.16244925558567047,
0.2092158943414688,
-0.33749350905418396,
-0.7376611232757568,
0.6202446818351746,
0.8366997241973877,
-0.8296036124229431,
-0.13518954813480377,
0.4756719470024109,
0.7384276390075684,
-0.18834419548511505,
0.30645856261253357,
0.6635458469390869,
0.3492303490638733,
-0.1010032445192337,
-1.229261040687561,
-0.24328680336475372,
0.03276589885354042,
-0.008877216838300228,
0.311668336391449,
-0.5818225741386414,
0.5483542084693909,
-0.1390099823474884,
-0.26104971766471863,
-0.021293850615620613,
0.5103803873062134,
0.11030931770801544,
0.12628816068172455,
0.41196414828300476,
0.7259235978126526,
0.7651857733726501,
-0.04858057200908661,
1.0609718561172485,
-0.22774720191955566,
0.05992676317691803,
0.91957026720047,
-0.4639792740345001,
0.9674850106239319,
0.32912713289260864,
-0.25492605566978455,
0.06373509019613266,
0.4576791822910309,
0.3393092155456543,
0.24625365436077118,
0.45352739095687866,
-0.14897464215755463,
-0.5815736055374146,
-0.22416436672210693,
-0.33464711904525757,
0.5511002540588379,
0.33140406012535095,
-0.2291553020477295,
-0.2283826619386673,
0.007661424111574888,
-0.11250327527523041,
0.31899401545524597,
-0.47628238797187805,
0.7376614809036255,
0.12530185282230377,
-0.5257923603057861,
0.9367251992225647,
-0.052700936794281006,
0.8454649448394775,
-0.5252198576927185,
0.19166529178619385,
-0.2870670557022095,
-0.03758034482598305,
-0.30724480748176575,
-0.7604515552520752,
0.14303924143314362,
0.46125683188438416,
-0.28668835759162903,
-0.5498753786087036,
0.4641576409339905,
-0.6756858229637146,
-0.8081910610198975,
0.6060300469398499,
0.786656379699707,
0.2993262708187103,
0.1882418990135193,
-0.4069463610649109,
-0.045751702040433884,
-0.09313665330410004,
-0.2813643515110016,
0.37498781085014343,
0.6419494152069092,
-0.04525906965136528,
0.5814944505691528,
0.5051133036613464,
0.5861181020736694,
0.11212074756622314,
-0.04718225076794624,
0.8109835386276245,
-0.6723482012748718,
-0.1933363974094391,
-0.851097822189331,
0.23604288697242737,
0.22295568883419037,
-0.4685439169406891,
0.47544434666633606,
0.6244235038757324,
1.225142478942871,
0.09559489041566849,
0.7706252932548523,
0.2192360907793045,
0.6229040622711182,
-0.7712265849113464,
0.8988901376724243,
-0.7036375999450684,
0.10923151671886444,
-0.37133675813674927,
-1.1001067161560059,
-0.09109587967395782,
0.34498003125190735,
-0.09834779798984528,
-0.005881076212972403,
0.5856329202651978,
0.7042061686515808,
-0.18165473639965057,
-0.30780908465385437,
0.6358223557472229,
0.22772204875946045,
0.15234322845935822,
0.658715009689331,
1.0139302015304565,
-0.09701674431562424,
0.4866969883441925,
-0.0005335678579285741,
-0.02542368695139885,
0.07095327973365784,
-0.9621008634567261,
-0.9004024863243103,
-0.5129032731056213,
-0.05311441421508789,
-0.19866566359996796,
0.10300257802009583,
0.8933417797088623,
0.6303614377975464,
-0.7076629996299744,
-0.5244570970535278,
0.0739416629076004,
-0.17143312096595764,
0.28343114256858826,
-0.09131572395563126,
0.28314706683158875,
-0.44701331853866577,
-0.6958276629447937,
0.6003029942512512,
0.11843720078468323,
0.1501864492893219,
-0.4447494447231293,
-0.18383446335792542,
0.11094003170728683,
0.10050050169229507,
0.5683350563049316,
0.22238323092460632,
-0.5360835790634155,
0.16396282613277435,
-0.2712664008140564,
-0.30416417121887207,
0.021498754620552063,
0.8253135085105896,
-0.8632674217224121,
0.09708286821842194,
0.24225381016731262,
0.8764693737030029,
0.46474120020866394,
-0.047825656831264496,
0.8034406304359436,
-0.9762122631072998,
0.21242853999137878,
0.42790666222572327,
0.28136691451072693,
0.6990613341331482,
-0.09619908034801483,
0.3274948298931122,
0.0023332720156759024,
-0.6185007095336914,
-1.048877239227295,
0.21973034739494324,
-0.456967294216156,
-0.03667820990085602,
1.0945544242858887,
-0.1913168877363205,
-0.05530274286866188,
-0.02633870393037796,
0.04188087210059166,
0.2310606986284256,
-0.17394471168518066,
0.7919998168945312,
0.835574746131897,
0.18552087247371674,
0.13912375271320343,
-0.7464960217475891,
0.7794328927993774,
0.4289686977863312,
-0.8883522152900696,
0.46050360798835754,
0.41806483268737793,
-0.13581731915473938,
0.09859781712293625,
0.675027072429657,
0.08233825862407684,
0.10205602645874023,
-0.2859760820865631,
0.06748302280902863,
0.11234895139932632,
-0.4357318580150604,
-0.24370869994163513,
-0.1287788301706314,
0.33666449785232544,
0.30267050862312317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12264v1 | Uncertainty quantification in fine-tuned LLMs using LoRA ensembles | 2024-02-19T16:26:00 | 2024-02-19T16:26:00 | Oleksandr Balabanov, Hampus Linander | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | Fine-tuning large language models can improve task specific performance,
although a general understanding of what the fine-tuned model has learned,
forgotten and how to trust its predictions is still missing. We derive
principled uncertainty quantification for fine-tuned LLMs with posterior
approximations using computationally efficient low-rank adaptation ensembles.
We analyze three common multiple-choice datasets using low-rank adaptation
ensembles based on Mistral-7b, and draw quantitative and qualitative
conclusions on their perceived complexity and model efficacy on the different
target domains during and after fine-tuning. In particular, backed by the
numerical experiments, we hypothesise about signals from entropic uncertainty
measures for data domains that are inherently difficult for a given
architecture to learn. | [
-0.4195261001586914,
-0.9683201313018799,
0.5663995146751404,
0.07962411642074585,
-0.08896631002426147,
0.05830537527799606,
-0.4024569094181061,
-0.40812745690345764,
-0.18341514468193054,
0.22876547276973724,
-0.49301645159721375,
-0.4639117419719696,
-0.7309041023254395,
0.07064075767993927,
-0.3087542653083801,
0.6334109902381897,
-0.0578017421066761,
-0.07008957862854004,
-0.08972413837909698,
-0.11435505002737045,
-0.23922966420650482,
-0.12460564821958542,
-0.62941575050354,
-0.20178210735321045,
0.5719206929206848,
0.4761072099208832,
0.6941167116165161,
0.3597490191459656,
0.5384504199028015,
0.244332954287529,
-0.15123683214187622,
0.4393632113933563,
-0.578422486782074,
-0.028183819726109505,
-0.2935657799243927,
-0.7264729738235474,
-0.5493136048316956,
-0.32061484456062317,
0.6287602782249451,
0.8755589723587036,
-0.25120776891708374,
0.492533802986145,
0.3695754408836365,
0.6579693555831909,
-1.0900543928146362,
0.00811783131211996,
-0.9806511998176575,
-0.04955299571156502,
-0.005591182503849268,
-0.22419485449790955,
-0.26687443256378174,
-0.2250736653804779,
0.07025305181741714,
-0.871036171913147,
-0.020789097994565964,
0.14799626171588898,
0.4834669530391693,
0.8156997561454773,
-0.29310840368270874,
-0.12178453803062439,
-0.8978931307792664,
0.8575612902641296,
-0.7286854982376099,
0.3018214702606201,
0.6671230792999268,
0.1907426416873932,
-0.3399209678173065,
-0.4230930209159851,
-0.16334453225135803,
0.19540230929851532,
0.3308033347129822,
0.09548486769199371,
-0.2850118577480316,
0.23271964490413666,
0.1400892585515976,
0.22635890543460846,
-0.2131672501564026,
0.5875593423843384,
-0.37237146496772766,
-0.16630715131759644,
0.48116037249565125,
0.03849765285849571,
-0.212357297539711,
0.14747558534145355,
-0.15647491812705994,
-0.04852294921875,
-0.6378215551376343,
0.15760572254657745,
0.44059690833091736,
0.3119596242904663,
-0.2955682575702667,
0.45432204008102417,
-0.36831003427505493,
0.998137354850769,
0.3669619858264923,
-0.18808402121067047,
-0.0396617166697979,
0.06932755559682846,
-0.5084310173988342,
-0.12740372121334076,
0.4619823694229126,
0.04397987574338913,
0.3354749381542206,
-0.13688801229000092,
-0.19445033371448517,
-0.10428060591220856,
0.19123776257038116,
-0.46013787388801575,
0.04532262310385704,
0.3823353946208954,
-0.22930563986301422,
-0.2249322235584259,
-0.1028575748205185,
-0.4058073163032532,
-0.4307240843772888,
-0.48529019951820374,
0.8479086756706238,
-0.4696252644062042,
0.11743896454572678,
0.36073824763298035,
0.0008961725980043411,
0.2997634708881378,
0.6721148490905762,
-0.7802125811576843,
0.44019195437431335,
0.7030659914016724,
0.5757962465286255,
-0.4638316333293915,
-0.4039701819419861,
-0.3343210816383362,
0.12304694205522537,
-0.5576980113983154,
0.6087800860404968,
-0.4907502830028534,
-0.2925250232219696,
-0.2121429145336151,
-0.11957667768001556,
-0.4453466832637787,
-0.6529086232185364,
0.5860153436660767,
-0.5504980683326721,
-0.2845129370689392,
-0.05909102037549019,
-0.5262176990509033,
-0.07243871688842773,
0.06958727538585663,
-0.5864212512969971,
0.9007148146629333,
0.26641973853111267,
-0.6507146954536438,
0.3168385624885559,
-0.20521150529384613,
-0.30138543248176575,
-0.32273006439208984,
0.07725553214550018,
-0.2787139415740967,
0.7184448838233948,
0.25812289118766785,
0.539360761642456,
-0.41949230432510376,
-0.13482071459293365,
-0.6591766476631165,
-0.5124717950820923,
0.5142438411712646,
-0.6610751748085022,
0.3040349781513214,
0.3669242262840271,
0.091619111597538,
-0.05147148668766022,
-0.8542115092277527,
0.16787199676036835,
-0.3618200719356537,
-0.4469762444496155,
-0.35600101947784424,
0.0253138430416584,
-0.3110419511795044,
-0.15601123869419098,
0.4448830187320709,
-0.08629096299409866,
0.1371414214372635,
-0.3391163647174835,
0.5874704122543335,
0.9573086500167847,
0.20357100665569305,
0.5539899468421936,
-0.4243326187133789,
0.4940333664417267,
0.06833597272634506,
0.04413541778922081,
0.39382028579711914,
-0.2939716577529907,
-0.845399796962738,
-0.25800856947898865,
0.4236903786659241,
0.42853376269340515,
-0.6392449736595154,
0.2931778132915497,
-0.35327643156051636,
-0.6267333030700684,
-0.5906240940093994,
0.19642390310764313,
0.18372781574726105,
0.1627928614616394,
0.27525636553764343,
-0.032168321311473846,
-0.034414589405059814,
-0.7574975490570068,
-0.25820857286453247,
-0.1323719173669815,
-0.02928118221461773,
0.27004873752593994,
0.5643753409385681,
-0.17693760991096497,
0.6929644346237183,
-0.3765853941440582,
-0.015153837390244007,
0.24649329483509064,
0.12193881720304489,
0.165258526802063,
0.4843520224094391,
0.3012098968029022,
-0.5877091288566589,
-0.29846853017807007,
0.06151250749826431,
-0.42103689908981323,
0.09447676688432693,
0.002961245831102133,
-0.13150615990161896,
0.10781151056289673,
0.4906552731990814,
-0.5049862265586853,
0.197470024228096,
0.7089572548866272,
0.1557675004005432,
0.3881418704986572,
-0.47662147879600525,
0.17425671219825745,
-0.8853104710578918,
-0.19627083837985992,
-0.017735494300723076,
-0.10052469372749329,
-0.4543798863887787,
0.0379653237760067,
0.05115118250250816,
0.1816258430480957,
-0.3826278746128082,
0.40859436988830566,
-0.3139879107475281,
-0.2932080924510956,
-0.1461140513420105,
0.07529926300048828,
-0.2638542354106903,
0.5642812848091125,
-0.04631418362259865,
0.735883355140686,
0.7599272131919861,
-0.8777047395706177,
-0.10269105434417725,
-0.1384311020374298,
-0.6564605832099915,
0.7831405997276306,
-0.6208063364028931,
-0.023011887446045876,
-0.0870341882109642,
-0.13411015272140503,
-0.883174479007721,
-0.5310055613517761,
0.010566569864749908,
-0.3769368529319763,
0.2966737747192383,
-0.2578323185443878,
-0.23921538889408112,
-0.026077179238200188,
-0.0798833891749382,
0.49606117606163025,
0.38935738801956177,
-0.28153306245803833,
0.40829551219940186,
0.2460508793592453,
-0.053676918148994446,
-0.4704601764678955,
-0.6864288449287415,
-0.4370098412036896,
-0.463625431060791,
-0.2748900055885315,
0.3243866264820099,
-0.04772984981536865,
-0.32321518659591675,
-0.41548436880111694,
-0.43536266684532166,
-0.21087925136089325,
0.6031306982040405,
0.467314213514328,
-0.21270617842674255,
-0.1469597965478897,
0.21747753024101257,
0.39281418919563293,
0.155502587556839,
-0.09272647649049759,
-0.24251985549926758,
0.32591918110847473,
-0.2622334957122803,
-0.8323307633399963,
-0.07623081654310226,
-0.25385648012161255,
0.6390499472618103,
-0.040922604501247406,
0.4698295295238495,
0.72599858045578,
-0.6381693482398987,
-0.5210368633270264,
-0.34674859046936035,
-0.13604295253753662,
-0.48068857192993164,
0.2983350455760956,
-0.45923852920532227,
-0.9452688097953796,
0.7543467283248901,
-0.28331258893013,
-0.2557491064071655,
0.5518240332603455,
0.5858289003372192,
-0.3231082260608673,
0.734095573425293,
0.43242397904396057,
-0.1974141001701355,
0.21577762067317963,
-0.040233463048934937,
-0.14307314157485962,
-0.7469935417175293,
0.12032971531152725,
-0.6189102530479431,
-0.5992382168769836,
-0.9407667517662048,
-0.5201667547225952,
0.6150238513946533,
0.44634297490119934,
-0.5135964155197144,
0.011390464380383492,
-0.2925918698310852,
0.21108734607696533,
0.6551262736320496,
0.4807405173778534,
0.3990800976753235,
0.16334453225135803,
0.29893994331359863,
0.1444227546453476,
-0.706023097038269,
-0.20245373249053955,
1.031704306602478,
0.3628690540790558,
1.272737741470337,
0.2644314467906952,
0.6261699199676514,
0.3201271891593933,
-0.15667252242565155,
-0.7449966073036194,
0.07617181539535522,
-0.1125192791223526,
-0.340638130903244,
-0.6171336770057678,
-0.40033936500549316,
-1.0458441972732544,
0.23835596442222595,
-0.2884604036808014,
-0.9320400953292847,
0.5389865040779114,
0.30841633677482605,
-0.9057649374008179,
0.03251110762357712,
-0.5280501246452332,
0.43984565138816833,
-0.1588306725025177,
-0.28952130675315857,
-0.2688697278499603,
-0.528028130531311,
0.24718205630779266,
-0.4355448782444,
0.43888193368911743,
-0.1919519156217575,
-0.07359176129102707,
0.7072399258613586,
-0.08417325466871262,
1.0011850595474243,
0.03087020106613636,
-0.3966328203678131,
0.24193115532398224,
0.28298524022102356,
0.6301817297935486,
0.20666813850402832,
-0.35211220383644104,
0.12049011141061783,
0.31053417921066284,
-0.34982550144195557,
-0.604518473148346,
0.7560181021690369,
-0.9409788846969604,
-0.5446813702583313,
-0.06753526628017426,
-0.5029075741767883,
-0.6563168168067932,
0.028256647288799286,
0.5253340601921082,
0.15675179660320282,
-0.12979109585285187,
0.4038371443748474,
0.806799054145813,
-0.1357734054327011,
0.29376229643821716,
0.371263325214386,
0.26466524600982666,
-0.17738285660743713,
0.8684066534042358,
0.2614133656024933,
0.5006906390190125,
0.5831425189971924,
-0.048891227692365646,
0.14450548589229584,
-0.8587625622749329,
-0.19558750092983246,
-0.17991313338279724,
-0.5082276463508606,
-0.2585791051387787,
-0.05382301285862923,
-0.1009034588932991,
-0.2292112410068512,
-0.2109142392873764,
-0.42610323429107666,
-0.6081579327583313,
-0.7217388153076172,
-0.07999052852392197,
0.4355001449584961,
0.5836525559425354,
-0.1112464889883995,
0.6437032222747803,
-0.46394217014312744,
0.3300914168357849,
0.2649998664855957,
0.3522171080112457,
-0.2239844799041748,
-1.043508768081665,
-0.32546454668045044,
0.4595811069011688,
-0.05003136396408081,
-0.5698857307434082,
0.23806212842464447,
0.6517734527587891,
0.618050754070282,
0.34936174750328064,
0.23924335837364197,
0.7025279402732849,
-0.2007361352443695,
0.5224210619926453,
-0.3470925986766815,
-0.855790913105011,
0.475442111492157,
-0.3939770460128784,
0.25887826085090637,
0.5639618039131165,
0.24086348712444305,
0.0894041433930397,
-0.13568109273910522,
-0.4746271073818207,
-0.5277673602104187,
0.32546621561050415,
0.08495175838470459,
-0.012439010664820671,
0.3751640319824219,
0.6469519734382629,
0.035583626478910446,
0.250160813331604,
-0.26172131299972534,
-0.2181941717863083,
0.22284561395645142,
-0.29233312606811523,
-0.3805290162563324,
-0.08758927881717682,
-0.1718607097864151,
-0.2408367246389389,
0.36967533826828003,
-0.4087681174278259,
0.32343047857284546,
-0.018216541036963463,
-0.26613569259643555,
-0.260723739862442,
0.3819446563720703,
0.6823878288269043,
0.6980248093605042,
-0.3860512971878052,
0.23103682696819305,
0.6461076736450195,
-0.22455060482025146,
0.09022767096757889,
-0.028005326166749,
0.007308322004973888,
-0.42723381519317627,
0.5597113370895386,
0.9710163474082947,
0.47486355900764465,
-0.4565543830394745,
0.25132277607917786,
0.24307659268379211,
-0.23198416829109192,
-0.25461649894714355,
0.3810831308364868,
0.021231776103377342,
0.3456486165523529,
0.30612456798553467,
0.4316554665565491,
0.20754995942115784,
-0.2791145145893097,
-0.14260606467723846,
0.5261449813842773,
-0.5642878413200378,
-0.3114566206932068,
0.44976234436035156,
-0.09702374041080475,
0.0940699577331543,
0.12484142929315567,
0.1439872533082962,
-0.044714536517858505,
0.6312786936759949,
0.3304438292980194,
0.5179876685142517,
-0.07382305711507797,
0.04907028377056122,
0.06781452149152756,
0.4307458698749542,
-0.3486502766609192,
0.3175393342971802,
-0.06438504904508591,
-0.9486197233200073,
-0.35640260577201843,
-0.8586946725845337,
-0.5549909472465515,
-0.07693920284509659,
-1.0079678297042847,
0.09083374589681625,
-0.40661337971687317,
-0.38416948914527893,
-0.09061969816684723,
-0.18531057238578796,
-0.7713979482650757,
0.23927007615566254,
-0.03051988035440445,
1.0039180517196655,
-0.7179067134857178,
0.7465470433235168,
0.4535602927207947,
0.09405988454818726,
-0.6349064707756042,
-0.124858558177948,
-0.21677058935165405,
-1.0055159330368042,
0.3376976549625397,
-0.477907657623291,
-0.40762054920196533,
0.21124863624572754,
-0.7938446998596191,
-1.175058364868164,
1.2116870880126953,
0.651726484298706,
-0.5273778438568115,
0.03138190880417824,
0.1932039111852646,
0.5154581665992737,
-0.06520441174507141,
-0.1404748558998108,
0.7052079439163208,
0.4231063425540924,
-0.06267683207988739,
-1.0415927171707153,
-0.3103388845920563,
0.23677466809749603,
-0.11302737891674042,
-0.04135441407561302,
-0.6375729441642761,
0.9361361861228943,
-0.3155505359172821,
-0.023976417258381844,
0.17011015117168427,
0.5827001929283142,
0.16536934673786163,
0.1773720383644104,
0.3666433095932007,
0.4558761417865753,
1.0518699884414673,
-0.0815616026520729,
0.8556928038597107,
-0.4739016592502594,
0.44032999873161316,
1.3319289684295654,
-0.059291284531354904,
1.1164826154708862,
0.589038610458374,
-0.3337556719779968,
0.17023348808288574,
1.0586473941802979,
0.24865959584712982,
0.5039231181144714,
0.39237844944000244,
-0.05866210535168648,
-0.5975024700164795,
0.07607412338256836,
-0.3820367157459259,
0.5498130321502686,
0.930273175239563,
-0.20800259709358215,
0.0903574749827385,
-0.010786356404423714,
-0.39548438787460327,
-0.17022903263568878,
-0.595887303352356,
0.8461466431617737,
0.31673845648765564,
-0.5788288116455078,
0.8742214441299438,
0.08363756537437439,
0.6490206718444824,
-0.3909226059913635,
0.36895114183425903,
-0.08048936724662781,
0.1773475855588913,
-0.17714674770832062,
-0.5686177611351013,
-0.11159583926200867,
-0.4973776042461395,
-0.05648353695869446,
0.20834410190582275,
0.7593197822570801,
-0.31910181045532227,
-0.5735070109367371,
-0.04585755616426468,
0.7612311840057373,
0.03622477501630783,
-0.3342891037464142,
-0.37989678978919983,
0.13430030643939972,
-0.18838906288146973,
-0.3585050702095032,
0.3759058117866516,
0.6563082337379456,
-0.11140306293964386,
0.950760006904602,
0.284067839384079,
0.18015454709529877,
0.11817371100187302,
-0.1972774863243103,
0.4328218102455139,
-0.23448379337787628,
-0.025463290512561798,
-0.751998782157898,
0.02475317381322384,
0.37935391068458557,
-0.5449556112289429,
0.568372368812561,
0.17043651640415192,
0.8947537541389465,
-0.2747501730918884,
0.818329393863678,
0.3583480417728424,
0.3973809480667114,
-0.8912209272384644,
0.535040557384491,
-0.5963231325149536,
0.3011308014392853,
-0.13045842945575714,
-0.806476354598999,
-0.22859817743301392,
0.6155996918678284,
-0.22621479630470276,
0.09517349302768707,
0.3407090902328491,
0.8355156183242798,
-0.27065175771713257,
-0.14781835675239563,
0.5594930052757263,
0.2785949110984802,
-0.3296204209327698,
0.659661591053009,
0.6804249882698059,
-0.5117460489273071,
0.10737982392311096,
-0.2649155557155609,
-0.07386929541826248,
-0.27751877903938293,
-0.7519082427024841,
-0.5964799523353577,
-0.5675885677337646,
-0.2954164743423462,
-0.16738291084766388,
0.09769195318222046,
0.8409735560417175,
0.7421192526817322,
-0.9269832968711853,
-0.1598987877368927,
-0.047517549246549606,
0.31044167280197144,
-0.26789340376853943,
-0.07070406526327133,
0.42880403995513916,
-0.15548236668109894,
-0.7318111062049866,
0.288648396730423,
0.008836407214403152,
0.25111111998558044,
-0.09830974787473679,
-0.21846766769886017,
0.17102597653865814,
0.24452908337116241,
0.5237603187561035,
0.24368909001350403,
-0.8140975832939148,
-0.4866909682750702,
-0.09623125195503235,
-0.14134258031845093,
-0.28211650252342224,
0.44356825947761536,
-0.43354225158691406,
0.045213889330625534,
0.32411977648735046,
0.60398930311203,
0.42894086241722107,
0.14765971899032593,
0.49562790989875793,
-0.6714933514595032,
-0.03845854848623276,
-0.10809718817472458,
0.4376460015773773,
0.04895344376564026,
-0.22026598453521729,
0.529818058013916,
-0.048960644751787186,
-0.5521711111068726,
-0.7358424663543701,
0.11621194332838058,
-1.0965536832809448,
-0.4004223346710205,
1.3462246656417847,
-0.07259313762187958,
-0.2304854542016983,
-0.016301121562719345,
-0.04615580663084984,
-0.01590144820511341,
-0.3206648528575897,
0.6796284914016724,
0.6276046633720398,
-0.05077574402093887,
-0.04266807436943054,
-0.5433400869369507,
0.7000768184661865,
0.3525390326976776,
-0.721960186958313,
-0.0003947298100683838,
0.37088698148727417,
0.21138428151607513,
0.01647007279098034,
0.17980122566223145,
0.3478020429611206,
0.16745495796203613,
-0.23913514614105225,
-0.302238404750824,
0.2707726061344147,
-0.239276722073555,
-0.43285706639289856,
0.25208330154418945,
0.5944680571556091,
-0.05836102366447449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12423v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12423v2 | On the Semantic Latent Space of Diffusion-Based Text-to-Speech Models | 2024-02-19T16:22:21 | 2024-06-04T11:03:57 | Miri Varshavsky-Hassid, Roy Hirsch, Regev Cohen, Tomer Golany, Daniel Freedman, Ehud Rivlin | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | The incorporation of Denoising Diffusion Models (DDMs) in the Text-to-Speech
(TTS) domain is rising, providing great value in synthesizing high quality
speech. Although they exhibit impressive audio quality, the extent of their
semantic capabilities is unknown, and controlling their synthesized speech's
vocal properties remains a challenge. Inspired by recent advances in image
synthesis, we explore the latent space of frozen TTS models, which is composed
of the latent bottleneck activations of the DDM's denoiser. We identify that
this space contains rich semantic information, and outline several novel
methods for finding semantic directions within it, both supervised and
unsupervised. We then demonstrate how these enable off-the-shelf audio editing,
without any further training, architectural changes or data requirements. We
present evidence of the semantic and acoustic qualities of the edited audio,
and provide supplemental samples:
https://latent-analysis-grad-tts.github.io/speech-samples/. | [
-0.4680165946483612,
-0.9953663945198059,
0.7164159417152405,
-0.06920907646417618,
-0.16314101219177246,
0.21680065989494324,
0.05179116129875183,
-0.02281128242611885,
0.16811127960681915,
0.6365768909454346,
-0.689276933670044,
-0.7390195727348328,
-0.7809871435165405,
-0.28640657663345337,
-0.6591229438781738,
0.7861983776092529,
0.14528435468673706,
-0.010980592109262943,
-0.12499129772186279,
0.05635853484272957,
-0.4052913784980774,
-0.2436598688364029,
-0.4313639998435974,
0.09940247237682343,
0.33500897884368896,
0.0441775918006897,
0.9916588664054871,
0.5926645398139954,
-0.007478071842342615,
0.3089870512485504,
-0.7096699476242065,
-0.20422521233558655,
-0.28494179248809814,
0.28564611077308655,
-0.08246321231126785,
-0.16135190427303314,
-0.746736466884613,
0.3131777048110962,
0.877544641494751,
1.0708667039871216,
-0.22507794201374054,
-0.339964896440506,
-0.16083361208438873,
0.5771629810333252,
-0.36035430431365967,
-0.16738516092300415,
-0.8628936409950256,
0.1619442254304886,
-0.1174783930182457,
-0.04499214142560959,
-0.25056877732276917,
-0.10829989612102509,
0.5414671897888184,
-0.7417884469032288,
0.4825386703014374,
-0.473704993724823,
0.5852705836296082,
0.618400514125824,
-0.375698059797287,
-0.21748150885105133,
-0.8572466373443604,
0.7213163375854492,
-0.5035785436630249,
0.7720164656639099,
0.3338162899017334,
0.04483524709939957,
-0.45178544521331787,
-0.8043745756149292,
-0.555931806564331,
0.23158013820648193,
0.26331016421318054,
0.27068644762039185,
-0.49659493565559387,
0.06385143846273422,
-0.11994735896587372,
0.19011546671390533,
-0.3642904460430145,
0.17032290995121002,
-0.2508813142776489,
-0.2009909749031067,
0.3321709632873535,
0.024832837283611298,
0.501462459564209,
-0.03429808095097542,
-0.142209991812706,
0.06947898864746094,
-0.5609995126724243,
-0.3753335475921631,
0.24928145110607147,
0.2333393692970276,
-0.15168042480945587,
0.7366814017295837,
-0.01151073258370161,
0.915601372718811,
-0.11522713303565979,
-0.057242125272750854,
0.09905201941728592,
-0.2606982886791229,
-0.110826276242733,
0.10223756730556488,
0.39543768763542175,
0.3459392786026001,
-0.36898067593574524,
-0.5056039094924927,
-0.3530139923095703,
0.1991099864244461,
0.1601237654685974,
-0.5835461616516113,
-0.2831512987613678,
0.2126130908727646,
-0.30420365929603577,
-0.09193674474954605,
-0.30897438526153564,
-0.6655149459838867,
-0.20741620659828186,
-0.3370407819747925,
0.37542590498924255,
-0.2521941065788269,
-0.42610475420951843,
0.10452854633331299,
-0.7006023526191711,
-0.03362629935145378,
0.5053215026855469,
-0.6576005220413208,
0.4190370738506317,
0.4149940311908722,
0.9728900790214539,
-0.29281502962112427,
0.0118936225771904,
-0.41137102246284485,
0.32763049006462097,
-0.8605970144271851,
0.822663426399231,
-0.5588282346725464,
-0.6576604843139648,
-0.2747250497341156,
-0.30735915899276733,
0.09592153877019882,
-0.6866351366043091,
0.17719446122646332,
-0.8324943780899048,
0.31431126594543457,
0.12565386295318604,
-0.7303399443626404,
-0.008289753459393978,
-0.40832963585853577,
-0.7305307984352112,
0.9182474613189697,
0.19665341079235077,
-0.5012528896331787,
0.367160826921463,
-0.695896327495575,
-0.2922889292240143,
-0.1979145109653473,
0.00472769420593977,
-0.28489863872528076,
0.2948780357837677,
0.08442017436027527,
0.5025606155395508,
-0.13924112915992737,
0.3798920810222626,
-0.11500690132379532,
-0.004073815885931253,
0.4930585026741028,
-0.5199556350708008,
0.3862598240375519,
0.41924357414245605,
-0.09665358811616898,
0.05934692174196243,
-0.9359778761863708,
-0.18131105601787567,
-0.012351833283901215,
-0.17068399488925934,
-0.45548731088638306,
0.030685964971780777,
0.09697035700082779,
0.04723389446735382,
-0.02478606253862381,
-0.3853464424610138,
-0.06795080751180649,
-0.5293459892272949,
0.7853002548217773,
0.4651956856250763,
0.20446324348449707,
0.8072255849838257,
-0.18845923244953156,
0.3805590867996216,
0.1431441754102707,
-0.20439478754997253,
0.030860651284456253,
-0.7608785629272461,
-0.3454442620277405,
-0.4877146780490875,
0.2905885577201843,
0.38115304708480835,
-0.7213162779808044,
0.4752396047115326,
-0.03692900389432907,
-0.6051930785179138,
-0.3730727434158325,
-0.02057061530649662,
-0.0695023387670517,
0.5488433241844177,
0.35722994804382324,
-0.2220933586359024,
-0.060280222445726395,
-0.4988577365875244,
0.01566210575401783,
0.10116640478372574,
-0.24095147848129272,
0.18013505637645721,
0.16602975130081177,
-0.3487839996814728,
1.3613697290420532,
-0.6097503304481506,
-0.24171599745750427,
0.20232389867305756,
0.16291241347789764,
-0.01485625933855772,
0.6442461013793945,
0.4590778648853302,
-0.981722354888916,
-0.0056939502246677876,
-0.4792202413082123,
-0.42827391624450684,
-0.3915597200393677,
0.0548204630613327,
-0.10752903670072556,
0.020900508388876915,
0.7702387571334839,
-0.7831434011459351,
0.6216132640838623,
0.6431752443313599,
-0.48543307185173035,
0.26334476470947266,
-0.3502141237258911,
0.0979728177189827,
-0.9235572218894958,
-0.15357762575149536,
-0.16939543187618256,
-0.06715279072523117,
-0.8175548911094666,
-0.3801405727863312,
-0.4618900418281555,
-0.26553040742874146,
-0.5280613899230957,
0.5002052187919617,
-0.43807148933410645,
-0.3613201379776001,
-0.31046271324157715,
0.7506608963012695,
0.10732630640268326,
0.15586167573928833,
0.3051251769065857,
0.810198962688446,
0.5970540046691895,
-0.6257163882255554,
0.14795371890068054,
0.46800315380096436,
-0.31061798334121704,
0.5748803615570068,
-0.6693568825721741,
0.15625500679016113,
-0.15443874895572662,
0.2250807285308838,
-1.3997584581375122,
0.0168941468000412,
-0.018125589936971664,
-0.39495956897735596,
0.28913354873657227,
-0.485807329416275,
-0.4551975727081299,
0.2597261965274811,
0.10507979243993759,
0.5416002869606018,
0.6432250738143921,
-0.4168311357498169,
0.5832173824310303,
0.8347548842430115,
-0.4872983396053314,
-0.23894314467906952,
-0.7006861567497253,
0.2145700305700302,
-0.35709071159362793,
-0.6919910311698914,
0.7543085813522339,
-0.14761072397232056,
-0.37268882989883423,
0.3552902042865753,
-0.03113512136042118,
-0.5931441783905029,
0.12846598029136658,
0.24166616797447205,
0.18861912190914154,
-0.1182020828127861,
0.15709824860095978,
0.5798439979553223,
-0.2384076714515686,
-0.11528684943914413,
-0.6761810779571533,
0.11696568876504898,
0.3708426058292389,
0.03561723604798317,
-0.35007497668266296,
0.3694896996021271,
0.6639397740364075,
0.14015667140483856,
0.4223618507385254,
0.3536769151687622,
-0.35862672328948975,
-0.1654575616121292,
-0.3460457921028137,
-0.09265540540218353,
-0.41069748997688293,
0.3328700065612793,
-0.29682299494743347,
-1.0892103910446167,
0.5594997406005859,
-0.3226191997528076,
-0.14672201871871948,
0.5652250051498413,
0.4072521924972534,
0.010800291784107685,
0.8398892879486084,
0.5333492159843445,
0.5317477583885193,
0.5819417238235474,
-0.4450170397758484,
-0.12343860417604446,
-0.8694044947624207,
-0.15047627687454224,
-0.6779505610466003,
0.15315383672714233,
-0.5849080681800842,
-0.9005314111709595,
0.5005208849906921,
0.040906473994255066,
0.07409797608852386,
0.011884890496730804,
-0.5531237721443176,
0.21309460699558258,
0.2549332082271576,
-0.05184192955493927,
0.1066378802061081,
0.1282687783241272,
-0.32373857498168945,
-0.39793992042541504,
-0.9093184471130371,
-0.44247105717658997,
0.652449905872345,
0.39647603034973145,
0.6692880988121033,
0.16309206187725067,
0.3278048038482666,
0.3574908971786499,
-0.3498211205005646,
-0.6141581535339355,
0.547296941280365,
-0.4938299059867859,
-0.40214312076568604,
-0.5107746720314026,
-0.3875095546245575,
-0.9412809610366821,
0.2585979402065277,
-0.26176005601882935,
-0.5521078109741211,
0.16928450763225555,
-0.003465126035735011,
-0.1957836151123047,
0.3411078155040741,
-0.6226789951324463,
0.7504283785820007,
0.29757872223854065,
-0.38476431369781494,
-0.36423078179359436,
-0.5893661379814148,
-0.20615309476852417,
-0.1524335741996765,
0.30779287219047546,
-0.1918436884880066,
-0.3800804316997528,
1.071799397468567,
-0.5854485630989075,
0.8183060884475708,
-0.4967389404773712,
-0.3930928111076355,
0.4585474133491516,
0.2944682240486145,
0.01653887890279293,
0.03623205050826073,
0.18956038355827332,
0.3942891061306,
0.061081450432538986,
-0.1798355132341385,
-0.7170491814613342,
0.7229081988334656,
-0.7345083951950073,
-0.5121463537216187,
-0.018776917830109596,
-0.430459588766098,
-0.39691123366355896,
0.22233378887176514,
0.2110585868358612,
0.6137911081314087,
-0.3658837378025055,
-0.06306419521570206,
0.8844271898269653,
-0.5099763870239258,
0.3619798421859741,
0.37398719787597656,
-0.04402134194970131,
-0.4808860123157501,
0.6051780581474304,
0.31855693459510803,
0.26902809739112854,
0.4187115430831909,
0.42641302943229675,
-0.5847252011299133,
-0.7445909976959229,
-0.5944938063621521,
0.12588417530059814,
-0.884568989276886,
0.10358286648988724,
-0.7648447751998901,
-0.2664422392845154,
-0.41383349895477295,
-0.28961971402168274,
-0.8166961073875427,
-0.839942991733551,
-0.7283222675323486,
0.07135529816150665,
0.5499680042266846,
0.8242071866989136,
-0.20359493792057037,
0.4964696168899536,
-0.7861961722373962,
0.48632004857063293,
0.2808745503425598,
0.41971829533576965,
-0.003973825369030237,
-0.6860889196395874,
-0.033805008977651596,
0.02912307344377041,
0.06601469218730927,
-0.8426918387413025,
0.3611483871936798,
0.015518954023718834,
0.4543050527572632,
-0.03791128471493721,
-0.1427910178899765,
0.6465992331504822,
-0.5477710962295532,
1.1730223894119263,
0.1530061960220337,
-1.0997827053070068,
0.593734085559845,
-0.2825283706188202,
0.36760473251342773,
-0.08785343915224075,
0.13426941633224487,
-0.2780746519565582,
-0.6964831948280334,
-0.7583290934562683,
-0.8944317102432251,
0.40537407994270325,
0.36096855998039246,
0.26818498969078064,
0.08741222321987152,
0.520007312297821,
0.07718892395496368,
0.3157883286476135,
-0.22870343923568726,
-0.21929116547107697,
-0.43461933732032776,
-0.04361690208315849,
0.007774286437779665,
-0.4126838743686676,
0.04997335374355316,
-0.06439922004938126,
0.4674334228038788,
0.2489084154367447,
0.3102688491344452,
0.3787270784378052,
0.1152300089597702,
-0.05333926901221275,
0.3557659089565277,
0.5741980075836182,
0.4437321424484253,
-0.04325392469763756,
0.17553237080574036,
0.0059120869264006615,
-0.587089478969574,
0.28774595260620117,
-0.04203413799405098,
-0.27328386902809143,
0.31010952591896057,
0.17231710255146027,
0.8178126811981201,
0.12126529216766357,
-0.34601259231567383,
0.4444112479686737,
-0.14410178363323212,
-0.19443216919898987,
-0.30047643184661865,
0.10426460206508636,
0.04694577306509018,
0.1988266259431839,
0.27319735288619995,
0.15260197222232819,
0.29885321855545044,
-0.08478538691997528,
0.284507691860199,
0.5191285610198975,
-0.585388720035553,
-0.3615022301673889,
0.9112898707389832,
0.025401931256055832,
-0.12702307105064392,
0.5498388409614563,
0.0936850905418396,
-0.1396561861038208,
0.21962760388851166,
0.24602067470550537,
0.998345136642456,
-0.06519275903701782,
0.11337006092071533,
-0.1273236870765686,
-0.03032142110168934,
0.22077599167823792,
0.016400109976530075,
-0.22568580508232117,
-0.7454338073730469,
-0.5730180144309998,
-0.4739430546760559,
-0.17599992454051971,
-0.020938316360116005,
-0.3486824631690979,
0.2010127604007721,
-0.3399580717086792,
-0.4787253141403198,
0.35010355710983276,
-0.5044924020767212,
-0.29557478427886963,
0.40174973011016846,
-0.19885776937007904,
0.697360634803772,
-0.585395872592926,
0.6702867746353149,
0.41970473527908325,
0.02543320693075657,
-0.5916135907173157,
0.021915804594755173,
-0.04840490221977234,
-0.31599968671798706,
0.7360817193984985,
-0.44491103291511536,
-0.41799038648605347,
0.1888551115989685,
-0.3730248212814331,
-0.8145877718925476,
0.716189444065094,
0.3248206079006195,
-0.2594621181488037,
-0.08343803882598877,
0.052446238696575165,
0.6892540454864502,
-0.2555922567844391,
-0.005534517113119364,
0.43167176842689514,
0.12642312049865723,
0.5405852198600769,
-0.5904786586761475,
-0.26953694224357605,
-0.018828479573130608,
0.2752825617790222,
0.06302695721387863,
-0.1117531880736351,
0.7094578146934509,
-0.18132109940052032,
-0.16491274535655975,
0.13042648136615753,
0.4988659918308258,
-0.11830158531665802,
0.3024800419807434,
0.5906032919883728,
0.6016519665718079,
0.4033600986003876,
-0.17278797924518585,
0.6014338135719299,
-0.16205933690071106,
0.019492290914058685,
0.8647884130477905,
-0.11260378360748291,
0.7827615737915039,
0.5092137455940247,
-0.014433127827942371,
0.5406887531280518,
0.4982447624206543,
0.17525102198123932,
0.838131308555603,
0.0853724479675293,
-0.298681378364563,
-0.10599366575479507,
-0.1415424942970276,
-0.2227238416671753,
0.5538133978843689,
0.663453221321106,
-0.13470645248889923,
-0.016615375876426697,
0.1203901395201683,
0.02908516488969326,
0.17004236578941345,
0.04226510599255562,
1.1192944049835205,
-0.07882042974233627,
-0.33553189039230347,
0.5329833030700684,
0.020245330408215523,
0.3984874188899994,
-0.48144111037254333,
-0.239471435546875,
-0.03226622939109802,
-0.31957438588142395,
-0.06563200056552887,
-0.9354095458984375,
0.6736310720443726,
-0.02763773873448372,
-0.257172167301178,
-0.2656327486038208,
0.6119881272315979,
-0.3768560588359833,
-0.11671813577413559,
0.4009113013744354,
0.5947728753089905,
0.21848464012145996,
0.14832918345928192,
-0.47375962138175964,
0.07926110178232193,
-0.3926089406013489,
-0.1678084135055542,
0.12638844549655914,
0.6675117015838623,
0.0915374606847763,
0.3581595718860626,
0.6580002307891846,
0.42378154397010803,
0.05035819113254547,
0.0999184250831604,
0.7155110836029053,
-0.6432396173477173,
-0.8331670165061951,
-0.5854843258857727,
0.4567042887210846,
0.26433631777763367,
-0.140176922082901,
0.5073035955429077,
0.48203548789024353,
0.7859017848968506,
-0.06405472010374069,
0.7438881993293762,
0.13971666991710663,
0.6595878005027771,
-0.9761778116226196,
0.7744846940040588,
-0.6850054264068604,
0.4061695337295532,
-0.7535837292671204,
-0.713789165019989,
-0.37673884630203247,
0.5291367769241333,
-0.1555446833372116,
0.03830841928720474,
0.34051021933555603,
0.9777652621269226,
0.008873682469129562,
-0.0778895691037178,
0.6615949273109436,
0.2852379381656647,
0.22415995597839355,
0.10055452585220337,
1.1976656913757324,
-0.3264479339122772,
0.3649939298629761,
-0.048567503690719604,
-0.31372135877609253,
0.2530703842639923,
-0.957726240158081,
-0.5939245223999023,
-0.9811331629753113,
-0.7735857963562012,
-0.38532671332359314,
-0.054170574992895126,
0.3679574131965637,
0.8581244945526123,
-0.30230817198753357,
-0.20551393926143646,
-0.30651700496673584,
0.3679670989513397,
-0.037127651274204254,
-0.15181590616703033,
0.4291916489601135,
-0.022934120148420334,
-0.7005231380462646,
0.5932317972183228,
0.5297344326972961,
0.7292639017105103,
-0.1536194533109665,
0.042657144367694855,
0.13452407717704773,
0.20167914032936096,
0.6159965991973877,
-0.237929567694664,
-0.8430007100105286,
0.014357329346239567,
-0.01724417880177498,
-0.006157491356134415,
0.016466913744807243,
0.794220507144928,
-0.7393766045570374,
0.697586178779602,
0.37625935673713684,
0.44996944069862366,
0.5270436406135559,
-0.378569096326828,
0.4290226697921753,
-0.7720133066177368,
0.4947469234466553,
0.1782202422618866,
0.10435447096824646,
0.40493252873420715,
-0.11958792805671692,
0.2058975100517273,
0.5433383584022522,
-0.4100414216518402,
-0.6352503299713135,
-0.02913825586438179,
-0.9407235383987427,
-0.6180760860443115,
1.067423701286316,
0.05563008040189743,
-0.09635842591524124,
-0.25086915493011475,
-0.17531222105026245,
0.5234788656234741,
-0.3298368752002716,
0.6140032410621643,
0.5758318901062012,
-0.050298698246479034,
-0.014242252334952354,
-0.5169369578361511,
0.7226393222808838,
0.2452087104320526,
-0.4537774324417114,
0.17784027755260468,
0.9181892275810242,
0.3500180244445801,
0.20739498734474182,
0.6265156269073486,
-0.34548747539520264,
0.2069902867078781,
0.30226942896842957,
-0.2882929742336273,
0.2536527216434479,
-0.3732312321662903,
-0.4743744730949402,
0.0703992247581482,
0.1272437572479248,
-0.02042851597070694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12261v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12261v3 | NEO-BENCH: Evaluating Robustness of Large Language Models with Neologisms | 2024-02-19T16:19:15 | 2024-06-05T17:12:23 | Jonathan Zheng, Alan Ritter, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) degrades from the temporal
drift between data used for model training and newer text seen during
inference. One understudied avenue of language change causing data drift is the
emergence of neologisms -- new word forms -- over time. We create a diverse
resource of recent English neologisms by using several popular collection
methods. We analyze temporal drift using neologisms by comparing sentences
containing new words with near-identical sentences that replace neologisms with
existing substitute words. Model performance is nearly halved in machine
translation when a single neologism is introduced in a sentence. Motivated by
these results, we construct a benchmark to evaluate LLMs' ability to generalize
to neologisms with various natural language understanding tasks and model
perplexity. Models with later knowledge cutoff dates yield lower perplexities
and perform better in downstream tasks. LLMs are also affected differently
based on the linguistic origins of words, indicating that neologisms are
complex for static LLMs to address. We will release our benchmark and code for
reproducing our experiments. | [
-0.18009451031684875,
-0.9030874967575073,
0.6281363368034363,
0.08793061226606369,
-0.2905530035495758,
0.2021951973438263,
-0.31754863262176514,
-0.4775369465351105,
0.08533243089914322,
0.37661877274513245,
-0.6463395953178406,
-0.35068488121032715,
-0.45078203082084656,
0.2590063810348511,
-0.5969355702400208,
0.6684832572937012,
0.020578045397996902,
0.03034478984773159,
-0.3383283019065857,
-0.22292158007621765,
-0.051675889641046524,
-0.3669756352901459,
-0.3459989130496979,
-0.5486015677452087,
0.20429173111915588,
-0.12425494939088821,
0.8372041583061218,
0.7917647361755371,
0.46523773670196533,
0.3091925084590912,
-0.4018319845199585,
0.030096638947725296,
-0.4673120677471161,
0.2787947654724121,
-0.35122159123420715,
-0.6575404405593872,
-0.4896082580089569,
0.019232090562582016,
0.8222215175628662,
0.8828935623168945,
-0.09431713074445724,
0.09021536260843277,
-0.17502568662166595,
0.275714248418808,
-0.6940215229988098,
-0.05661081150174141,
-0.9071794748306274,
-0.2408875823020935,
-0.267871618270874,
-0.0415913350880146,
-0.2433241903781891,
-0.3328988254070282,
0.06673324108123779,
-0.589125394821167,
0.341063529253006,
-0.21460597217082977,
0.8549697399139404,
0.32628417015075684,
0.01766059547662735,
-0.20232604444026947,
-0.5998786091804504,
0.8348641395568848,
-0.9177107214927673,
0.44034314155578613,
0.30656176805496216,
0.3893745541572571,
-0.09994243085384369,
-0.7743405103683472,
-0.4757949411869049,
-0.49020981788635254,
0.17754916846752167,
-0.09196292608976364,
-0.16807429492473602,
-0.43103304505348206,
0.3457562029361725,
0.23729151487350464,
-0.5906352996826172,
0.32911989092826843,
0.325775146484375,
-0.10763360559940338,
0.4571399986743927,
0.35258543491363525,
-0.08841612935066223,
-0.27351856231689453,
-0.2916359007358551,
-0.282116174697876,
-0.8386138677597046,
-0.3292771279811859,
0.38375645875930786,
0.2946661710739136,
-0.04414987936615944,
0.1828712671995163,
-0.26113608479499817,
0.6100497245788574,
-0.28855952620506287,
-0.2654675543308258,
0.3725284934043884,
-0.4231739938259125,
-0.07309727370738983,
-0.27385103702545166,
0.7194541692733765,
0.4164521396160126,
0.18237698078155518,
-0.381041556596756,
-0.30587777495384216,
0.30476242303848267,
-0.049715325236320496,
-0.7726137042045593,
0.044751714915037155,
-0.030813027173280716,
-0.34910470247268677,
-0.20885872840881348,
-0.31268370151519775,
-0.6410263180732727,
-0.5590816140174866,
-0.20629140734672546,
0.10086289048194885,
-0.425732284784317,
-0.28544744849205017,
0.09365207701921463,
-0.2043820023536682,
-0.07776028662919998,
0.2346535325050354,
-0.5574965476989746,
0.6438629031181335,
0.8569211959838867,
0.7731360793113708,
-0.04940463975071907,
-0.2638868987560272,
-0.4930742681026459,
0.05781277269124985,
-0.4574621915817261,
0.7657617926597595,
-0.5486564636230469,
-0.3044481873512268,
0.11108564585447311,
0.030954424291849136,
-0.036505766212940216,
-0.8687838912010193,
0.2796154320240021,
-0.4342666268348694,
0.19975261390209198,
-0.0865887999534607,
-0.5728963613510132,
0.16489927470684052,
0.45404404401779175,
-0.4247519373893738,
0.8305651545524597,
0.11006993055343628,
-0.62894606590271,
0.40020230412483215,
-0.2948310971260071,
-0.16745296120643616,
0.20818506181240082,
-0.05583569407463074,
-0.04255104809999466,
0.27616819739341736,
-0.05284865200519562,
0.21824710071086884,
-0.49648788571357727,
0.21535909175872803,
-0.6549304127693176,
-0.18854697048664093,
0.5195567011833191,
-0.3270092308521271,
0.6188204288482666,
0.09728172421455383,
-0.27615538239479065,
-0.25652050971984863,
-0.7395840287208557,
0.08013585209846497,
0.21544300019741058,
-0.09454113245010376,
-0.5829117894172668,
0.36767885088920593,
0.17711582779884338,
0.2084803730249405,
0.2721061408519745,
-0.33768635988235474,
0.23289775848388672,
-0.4752468168735504,
0.5642008781433105,
0.708009660243988,
-0.15487326681613922,
0.11194900423288345,
-0.388747900724411,
0.603061318397522,
-0.22892433404922485,
0.13181723654270172,
0.06897476315498352,
-0.15608477592468262,
-0.4517923593521118,
-0.0037803668528795242,
0.4278944730758667,
0.5736600756645203,
-0.4765726923942566,
0.15363815426826477,
-0.5885049700737,
-0.4486728310585022,
-0.2789091467857361,
0.32109344005584717,
0.27143803238868713,
0.25119855999946594,
0.2568850517272949,
-0.6187951564788818,
-0.3215055763721466,
-0.9974367022514343,
-0.4153166711330414,
-0.12117133289575577,
-0.04375945031642914,
0.22907522320747375,
0.42096617817878723,
-0.6113560199737549,
0.6360700130462646,
-0.16743561625480652,
0.2693648338317871,
-0.16364972293376923,
0.2637016177177429,
0.2542770206928253,
0.1475154608488083,
0.5663275718688965,
-0.36733758449554443,
-0.1609201729297638,
-0.005268905311822891,
-0.48424670100212097,
-0.3031822741031647,
-0.018783777952194214,
0.11488626152276993,
0.3478250503540039,
0.7147454619407654,
-0.6128285527229309,
0.22550097107887268,
0.6623555421829224,
-0.27300333976745605,
0.5716408491134644,
0.15993420779705048,
-0.38831469416618347,
-1.2189315557479858,
0.19596852362155914,
-0.1807970553636551,
-0.30510464310646057,
-0.3222421109676361,
-0.08789078146219254,
0.003127348842099309,
0.16848139464855194,
-0.30647292733192444,
0.6478864550590515,
-0.4550880789756775,
-0.24764496088027954,
-0.32503145933151245,
0.5975542664527893,
-0.1896238923072815,
-0.2776820659637451,
0.010256685316562653,
0.3511677086353302,
0.34392014145851135,
-0.6372742056846619,
0.2388705015182495,
0.06363959610462189,
-0.5170128345489502,
0.45806652307510376,
-0.4169958531856537,
0.21345508098602295,
-0.06299110502004623,
0.10390554368495941,
-0.6823638677597046,
-0.031238382682204247,
-0.18530111014842987,
-0.3254656195640564,
0.5738723874092102,
-0.18061260879039764,
-0.535640299320221,
-0.12355706095695496,
-0.2179684191942215,
0.13021035492420197,
0.3900224268436432,
-0.14323274791240692,
0.3106725215911865,
0.20027990639209747,
-0.14295455813407898,
-0.7462353110313416,
-0.6826679110527039,
0.3156779706478119,
-0.1373327523469925,
-0.46514537930488586,
0.36219626665115356,
-0.05042571946978569,
-0.6930050849914551,
0.2921696603298187,
-0.3387604057788849,
0.0936564952135086,
0.5233840346336365,
-0.046710655093193054,
0.017430933192372322,
-0.19785970449447632,
0.21054093539714813,
-0.17075511813163757,
-0.0890517607331276,
0.270854651927948,
-0.12762002646923065,
0.9347524642944336,
-0.03887961059808731,
-0.07277671247720718,
-0.28638315200805664,
0.12423823773860931,
0.7196347713470459,
-0.007343868725001812,
0.6852045655250549,
0.5970660448074341,
-0.28708717226982117,
-0.2853374183177948,
-0.5395435690879822,
-0.31523287296295166,
-0.42795267701148987,
0.5700968503952026,
-0.26563042402267456,
-0.6927823424339294,
0.5668700933456421,
-0.226068377494812,
0.20331349968910217,
0.574658215045929,
0.4753361642360687,
0.07966387271881104,
0.7936297059059143,
0.46571996808052063,
-0.047738924622535706,
0.48785439133644104,
-0.31022730469703674,
-0.04293544590473175,
-0.8822095394134521,
-0.06467898190021515,
-0.5588414669036865,
-0.2952366769313812,
-0.7618204951286316,
-0.4056609570980072,
-0.03338921442627907,
-0.00493075093254447,
0.08017470687627792,
0.3657459616661072,
-0.030351806432008743,
0.2630821168422699,
0.3059332072734833,
-0.25664591789245605,
0.30960920453071594,
-0.030896171927452087,
-0.17065732181072235,
-0.08779098838567734,
-0.7238197922706604,
-0.6068071126937866,
1.189191222190857,
0.24862301349639893,
0.9835543632507324,
0.2419077455997467,
0.5821908116340637,
0.10028620809316635,
0.5133630037307739,
-0.6326993107795715,
0.6211668848991394,
-0.20337343215942383,
-0.6991714239120483,
0.08265120536088943,
-0.6424316167831421,
-0.9530068635940552,
0.02767917886376381,
-0.2801942527294159,
-0.7912165522575378,
0.018074601888656616,
-0.041564736515283585,
0.0005320605123415589,
0.11542554944753647,
-0.3662818968296051,
0.9623467922210693,
-0.4462131857872009,
-0.5997292995452881,
-0.4528858959674835,
-0.5419976711273193,
0.36778005957603455,
-0.014909675344824791,
0.3502221405506134,
-0.34040316939353943,
-0.4400927424430847,
0.6946231126785278,
-0.38595664501190186,
0.7071027159690857,
0.01959351822733879,
0.003915333189070225,
-0.004200577270239592,
0.3772217333316803,
0.3400692045688629,
0.30071982741355896,
-0.0694628357887268,
-0.02540586143732071,
0.20064063370227814,
-0.38295772671699524,
-0.5277993083000183,
0.8223205804824829,
-0.6571321487426758,
-0.3978189527988434,
-0.45459914207458496,
-0.7325884699821472,
-0.5025696158409119,
0.2802399694919586,
0.33032509684562683,
0.488918662071228,
-0.5076287388801575,
0.16055291891098022,
0.5454984903335571,
-0.01819472201168537,
0.6142611503601074,
0.703312873840332,
-0.4422181248664856,
-0.4188785254955292,
0.6001891493797302,
0.12966419756412506,
0.5663943290710449,
0.40015682578086853,
0.34818416833877563,
-0.419442355632782,
-0.8777493238449097,
-0.1380208283662796,
0.40221548080444336,
-0.44221383333206177,
0.029308656230568886,
-0.46401703357696533,
0.12960216403007507,
-0.5314526557922363,
0.05106749385595322,
-0.5418606400489807,
-0.551048994064331,
0.007712928578257561,
0.21524420380592346,
0.22790560126304626,
0.76554936170578,
-0.05841951444745064,
0.20706439018249512,
-0.6717470288276672,
0.10657408833503723,
0.26945072412490845,
0.1531757265329361,
-0.42846184968948364,
-0.7720184326171875,
-0.2027634233236313,
-0.16164785623550415,
-0.1294897198677063,
-0.8729929327964783,
0.28843021392822266,
0.2729959487915039,
0.673216700553894,
0.5186350345611572,
-0.2817777991294861,
0.43460389971733093,
-0.3178424537181854,
0.643153965473175,
-0.00042115096584893763,
-0.9521028399467468,
0.4583432674407959,
-0.560555100440979,
0.6588132977485657,
0.5916631817817688,
0.4529843330383301,
-0.8034851551055908,
-0.2946328818798065,
-0.8593751192092896,
-0.8653069138526917,
0.3809870481491089,
-0.14350441098213196,
0.0910135880112648,
-0.09635372459888458,
0.3018023371696472,
0.10926315933465958,
0.3857569098472595,
-0.5372689366340637,
-0.0003375335072632879,
0.03181753307580948,
0.02153564989566803,
-0.5364388227462769,
-0.2442229837179184,
-0.22991321980953217,
-0.06862123310565948,
0.6215555667877197,
-0.2997552156448364,
-0.015399058349430561,
-0.0635298416018486,
-0.3114522695541382,
-0.0604279451072216,
0.31138861179351807,
0.5331371426582336,
0.9895556569099426,
-0.38605475425720215,
0.19331535696983337,
0.36394932866096497,
-0.4904310405254364,
-0.033149540424346924,
0.4010680913925171,
-0.29365795850753784,
0.30434805154800415,
0.6481271386146545,
0.6282695531845093,
0.24963189661502838,
-0.7901797890663147,
0.15599247813224792,
-0.161371648311615,
-0.06951519846916199,
-0.2364480197429657,
0.008860220201313496,
0.386762797832489,
0.018576595932245255,
0.052326008677482605,
0.09289953112602234,
-0.12006208300590515,
-0.9459697008132935,
0.11187177151441574,
0.5733428001403809,
-0.223482146859169,
-0.43371033668518066,
0.40213459730148315,
-0.06417249888181686,
-0.24436156451702118,
0.5845058560371399,
-0.3637959063053131,
-0.5075651407241821,
0.2846134603023529,
0.6173239350318909,
0.8189964294433594,
-0.4385697841644287,
0.09105589240789413,
0.1788761466741562,
0.6018292903900146,
-0.12724412977695465,
0.10997555404901505,
0.25123876333236694,
-0.6153207421302795,
-0.6471002101898193,
-0.6153888702392578,
-0.5183289051055908,
0.4268609583377838,
-0.6056541800498962,
0.028960032388567924,
-0.6381427645683289,
-0.509418249130249,
-0.11826422810554504,
0.07442556321620941,
-0.5113975405693054,
-0.04262503981590271,
0.2942759394645691,
1.1258708238601685,
-0.9675285816192627,
0.522104799747467,
0.9208377599716187,
0.1107332780957222,
-0.30553221702575684,
-0.04688884690403938,
0.13480883836746216,
-0.6454578042030334,
0.38512122631073,
0.10771548002958298,
-0.14553454518318176,
-0.366599977016449,
-0.4587746560573578,
-0.9972791075706482,
0.8765178322792053,
0.5822330713272095,
-0.6306483745574951,
-0.011006426066160202,
0.10231318324804306,
0.5931344032287598,
-0.19845028221607208,
0.30197325348854065,
0.6991565823554993,
0.333499550819397,
-0.12057624012231827,
-0.8870749473571777,
-0.023545721545815468,
-0.26841601729393005,
-0.057877738028764725,
0.47815024852752686,
-0.511145293712616,
0.8959413766860962,
0.17126628756523132,
-0.3014407157897949,
0.27181941270828247,
0.2227209359407425,
-0.07479578256607056,
0.40028876066207886,
0.5481583476066589,
1.0085980892181396,
0.8029618263244629,
-0.1822933703660965,
1.1058558225631714,
-0.1755577176809311,
0.22590212523937225,
1.2162588834762573,
-0.30874374508857727,
1.000369906425476,
0.39359158277511597,
-0.2787122428417206,
0.7606866955757141,
0.44213175773620605,
0.19284948706626892,
0.3418770432472229,
0.44170188903808594,
-0.07060487568378448,
-0.4491916596889496,
-0.2613644301891327,
-0.4465131163597107,
0.44699880480766296,
0.5445466637611389,
-0.3160730004310608,
-0.40649935603141785,
-0.41465315222740173,
0.2653605043888092,
0.06266912817955017,
-0.11417056620121002,
0.5954701900482178,
0.1753435730934143,
-0.7040157318115234,
0.8491629958152771,
-0.1381181925535202,
0.4642292559146881,
-0.7035546898841858,
0.4069020450115204,
-0.32943546772003174,
0.46284326910972595,
-0.08263383060693741,
-0.32503101229667664,
0.27240273356437683,
0.05464952811598778,
-0.09712614864110947,
-0.059501662850379944,
0.4357633888721466,
-0.13643047213554382,
-0.502878725528717,
0.3285112679004669,
0.683860719203949,
0.20057067275047302,
0.01388037484139204,
-0.8067439198493958,
0.24431420862674713,
-0.3203384578227997,
-0.15689337253570557,
0.42216718196868896,
0.3354814946651459,
-0.05046006664633751,
0.6621782183647156,
0.4652148187160492,
0.11880243569612503,
0.15471602976322174,
0.17528145015239716,
0.7277994155883789,
-0.7297446131706238,
-0.1406625211238861,
-0.796314001083374,
0.08285635709762573,
-0.27735891938209534,
-0.6458539366722107,
0.7629678845405579,
0.567115306854248,
0.7363734245300293,
0.232071191072464,
0.5655142664909363,
-0.09239193052053452,
0.570891261100769,
-0.6282117962837219,
0.46553194522857666,
-0.6870542764663696,
0.2674121558666229,
-0.2986762821674347,
-1.1433097124099731,
-0.14605341851711273,
0.40749114751815796,
-0.5229282975196838,
-0.011527672410011292,
0.987086296081543,
0.7769741415977478,
-0.02090001292526722,
-0.19704321026802063,
0.10004172474145889,
0.404106467962265,
0.11663152277469635,
0.602640688419342,
1.206010341644287,
-0.30349814891815186,
0.2957846522331238,
-0.3528355360031128,
-0.24866658449172974,
-0.35142016410827637,
-1.0204893350601196,
-0.8867941498756409,
-0.24693524837493896,
-0.4241035282611847,
-0.4303281307220459,
0.17484433948993683,
0.5910057425498962,
0.5892298817634583,
-0.6651175022125244,
-0.3954313397407532,
-0.1939426213502884,
-0.043692611157894135,
-0.3548565208911896,
-0.1787005066871643,
0.14360803365707397,
-0.48938727378845215,
-0.6323087215423584,
0.7610804438591003,
-0.10787142068147659,
-0.03274751827120781,
-0.3441058397293091,
0.057403482496738434,
-0.2619735300540924,
-0.011483832262456417,
0.4447312653064728,
0.2567834258079529,
-0.5126486420631409,
-0.10252843052148819,
0.30965656042099,
0.033989317715168,
-0.23748813569545746,
0.7034181356430054,
-0.729189395904541,
0.4477839171886444,
0.56197190284729,
0.497004896402359,
0.6239142417907715,
-0.053119298070669174,
0.4932153522968292,
-0.33562371134757996,
0.11834823340177536,
0.574030876159668,
0.3325793147087097,
0.5973016619682312,
0.3318467438220978,
0.4901547431945801,
0.6016899347305298,
-0.4212872087955475,
-1.006295084953308,
0.37095773220062256,
-0.7768092751502991,
-0.41964682936668396,
1.092045783996582,
0.1658296436071396,
-0.4478434920310974,
0.036401309072971344,
0.4632062613964081,
0.020054632797837257,
-0.02569231204688549,
0.6259656548500061,
0.7995683550834656,
0.1073562279343605,
0.07372156530618668,
-0.6299872994422913,
0.48158082365989685,
0.7785014510154724,
-0.6756917238235474,
0.23246702551841736,
0.6171543002128601,
0.4448111057281494,
0.4743020832538605,
0.204236701130867,
-0.1558915078639984,
0.3420420289039612,
0.16276521980762482,
-0.10803442448377609,
0.08548907190561295,
-0.16013893485069275,
-0.34699997305870056,
0.01732085831463337,
0.41935500502586365,
0.07930759340524673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12255v1 | Shallow Synthesis of Knowledge in GPT-Generated Texts: A Case Study in Automatic Related Work Composition | 2024-02-19T16:14:04 | 2024-02-19T16:14:04 | Anna Martin-Boyle, Aahan Tyagi, Marti A. Hearst, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Numerous AI-assisted scholarly applications have been developed to aid
different stages of the research process. We present an analysis of AI-assisted
scholarly writing generated with ScholaCite, a tool we built that is designed
for organizing literature and composing Related Work sections for academic
papers. Our evaluation method focuses on the analysis of citation graphs to
assess the structural complexity and inter-connectedness of citations in texts
and involves a three-way comparison between (1) original human-written texts,
(2) purely GPT-generated texts, and (3) human-AI collaborative texts. We find
that GPT-4 can generate reasonable coarse-grained citation groupings to support
human users in brainstorming, but fails to perform detailed synthesis of
related works without human intervention. We suggest that future writing
assistant tools should not be used to draft text independently of the human
author. | [
-0.06575032323598862,
-0.6379784345626831,
0.8097852468490601,
0.13187135756015778,
0.014493278227746487,
0.24200339615345,
0.01909620873630047,
-0.7472178936004639,
0.32104384899139404,
0.17787763476371765,
-0.41872262954711914,
-0.4651910960674286,
-0.19710183143615723,
0.3765873908996582,
-0.4329235255718231,
1.3972197771072388,
-0.33636409044265747,
-0.09969952702522278,
-0.6069677472114563,
-0.008111566305160522,
-0.247250497341156,
-0.23324283957481384,
-0.4931127727031708,
-0.2132175862789154,
0.5498340725898743,
0.06399054080247879,
0.40540316700935364,
0.5022408366203308,
0.8505325317382812,
0.43810632824897766,
0.25458618998527527,
0.27366772294044495,
-0.2600800395011902,
0.48270517587661743,
-0.34429439902305603,
-0.06543999910354614,
-0.7023608088493347,
0.1748901605606079,
0.4063267111778259,
0.6848059892654419,
0.44028106331825256,
0.19398006796836853,
0.28014326095581055,
0.7814151048660278,
-0.49224570393562317,
0.23440907895565033,
-0.6692636609077454,
-0.0019425476202741265,
-0.3192547857761383,
-0.23426346480846405,
-0.18501709401607513,
-0.5272005200386047,
0.354024738073349,
-0.6719830632209778,
0.4891115725040436,
0.12615950405597687,
0.5985594391822815,
0.35129284858703613,
0.10587616264820099,
-0.9196210503578186,
-0.8000208139419556,
0.49636536836624146,
-0.482573539018631,
-0.3088315427303314,
0.2997307777404785,
-0.028662871569395065,
0.011933982372283936,
-1.0971230268478394,
-0.5442044138908386,
-0.29991593956947327,
-0.28880369663238525,
0.3822398781776428,
-0.1582985371351242,
0.19884461164474487,
-0.02143184095621109,
0.34492993354797363,
-0.8847309947013855,
-0.4113919734954834,
-0.6784173846244812,
-0.3772483468055725,
0.7664097547531128,
0.24412044882774353,
0.4516092538833618,
-0.23185782134532928,
-0.05993444100022316,
0.16836561262607574,
-0.5082913637161255,
-0.5328186750411987,
0.44513270258903503,
0.14228878915309906,
0.4514620304107666,
0.8663856387138367,
-0.029167985543608665,
0.4149474799633026,
-0.05001811683177948,
0.03021834045648575,
0.08130176365375519,
-0.5549262762069702,
-0.2839745283126831,
0.0770898312330246,
1.0315974950790405,
0.23941893875598907,
0.2555675506591797,
-0.4720531404018402,
-0.08685825020074844,
0.1604326367378235,
0.3080703318119049,
-0.5506638884544373,
-0.3926539421081543,
0.1585274338722229,
-0.2595859467983246,
-0.3784658908843994,
0.007420409005135298,
-0.10780706256628036,
-0.39645880460739136,
-0.3347717523574829,
0.2708456516265869,
-0.2500290274620056,
0.14776065945625305,
-0.3711232841014862,
-0.29894664883613586,
-0.5243071913719177,
0.23436325788497925,
-0.6400866508483887,
0.19419363141059875,
0.24796321988105774,
0.9072842001914978,
-0.4248517155647278,
-0.7441462874412537,
-0.18798063695430756,
0.6499271988868713,
-0.13121800124645233,
0.847343385219574,
-0.22517910599708557,
-0.5382074117660522,
-0.053582243621349335,
-0.2886113226413727,
-0.10225429385900497,
-0.25623607635498047,
0.46068888902664185,
-0.3727845549583435,
0.4491563141345978,
-0.21620586514472961,
-0.5421826243400574,
0.062200963497161865,
0.07634001970291138,
-0.6855108141899109,
1.0443822145462036,
0.4158133268356323,
-1.2385575771331787,
0.45974209904670715,
-0.7496475577354431,
-0.6149320602416992,
0.1836014837026596,
-0.3724811375141144,
-0.1435183435678482,
0.002361232414841652,
0.008734792470932007,
0.4639344811439514,
-0.31175559759140015,
0.26727983355522156,
-0.12750713527202606,
-0.59839928150177,
0.07630305737257004,
-0.052893925458192825,
0.6116965413093567,
0.19856292009353638,
-0.5304887294769287,
0.4194568693637848,
-0.6287001967430115,
-0.14697158336639404,
-0.15257853269577026,
-0.25362175703048706,
-0.5137297511100769,
-0.1541844606399536,
0.12401638925075531,
-0.01386088877916336,
0.33831822872161865,
-0.27850884199142456,
0.4793128967285156,
-0.13340561091899872,
0.5351623892784119,
0.7306872606277466,
0.21985389292240143,
0.675720751285553,
-0.2722562551498413,
0.4659057557582855,
-0.5422309041023254,
-0.07025957852602005,
0.12972095608711243,
-0.3633422553539276,
-0.6154689192771912,
-0.15029512345790863,
0.38787922263145447,
0.4507197141647339,
-1.0746370553970337,
0.2702552080154419,
-0.3380242884159088,
-0.5515012741088867,
-0.24462781846523285,
0.05879456549882889,
0.33529919385910034,
0.3649000823497772,
0.39585986733436584,
-0.2727431356906891,
-0.4586387276649475,
-0.9158543348312378,
-0.5092930793762207,
-0.4415810704231262,
-0.09392015635967255,
0.16139928996562958,
0.6200832724571228,
-0.20374318957328796,
0.8773053288459778,
-0.5378991961479187,
-0.5690342783927917,
-0.07449258863925934,
0.47595903277397156,
-0.4006446599960327,
0.4947986602783203,
0.5385449528694153,
-0.2022935450077057,
-0.8343605399131775,
0.09073130041360855,
-1.0977283716201782,
-0.11095533519983292,
-0.30836743116378784,
-0.2747616767883301,
0.11335878819227219,
0.8536862134933472,
-0.6736630797386169,
0.4882357716560364,
0.10745447874069214,
-0.0918208435177803,
0.5573893189430237,
-0.2456122636795044,
0.11845719814300537,
-0.6766492128372192,
0.4695006310939789,
-0.25030943751335144,
0.3034040331840515,
-0.4067816138267517,
0.08906672894954681,
-0.378737211227417,
-0.06314246356487274,
0.068377785384655,
0.3666553199291229,
-0.6948117017745972,
-0.16212181746959686,
-0.29390400648117065,
0.34712469577789307,
-0.04995216801762581,
0.45141690969467163,
-0.010668493807315826,
0.9298985600471497,
0.055656641721725464,
-0.12719343602657318,
-0.11213798075914383,
0.08344930410385132,
-0.1817196011543274,
0.5091714859008789,
-0.8634951710700989,
0.45656564831733704,
0.1475355327129364,
0.29221150279045105,
-0.7357895374298096,
-0.5367962718009949,
0.3315349817276001,
-0.2194424420595169,
0.0851936861872673,
-0.13090050220489502,
-0.603882908821106,
-0.25674229860305786,
-0.38830262422561646,
0.5393679738044739,
0.03781944513320923,
0.2739092707633972,
0.7857184410095215,
0.1390666961669922,
-0.8198822736740112,
-0.27047544717788696,
-0.7638339400291443,
0.17806831002235413,
-0.10978677123785019,
-0.7368513345718384,
0.6341860890388489,
-0.24679850041866302,
-0.4670439064502716,
0.36511799693107605,
0.31950417160987854,
-0.10878144204616547,
-0.22172945737838745,
0.37234511971473694,
0.2762601673603058,
0.08720741420984268,
0.09562989324331284,
0.48621678352355957,
0.1487913578748703,
0.037200964987277985,
-0.2198968231678009,
0.10417254269123077,
-0.28202497959136963,
-0.45489874482154846,
-0.3575977385044098,
0.5043549537658691,
0.639826774597168,
0.05531108006834984,
0.24005773663520813,
0.8295490741729736,
-0.025037556886672974,
0.09119463711977005,
-0.30707255005836487,
-0.09473708271980286,
-0.4303622841835022,
0.07768672704696655,
-0.1491086483001709,
-0.7975730299949646,
0.5248531699180603,
0.22581113874912262,
0.22805079817771912,
0.7711973190307617,
0.41766712069511414,
-0.15967650711536407,
0.6710915565490723,
0.3000251054763794,
-0.11607712507247925,
0.3393729329109192,
-0.23409460484981537,
0.10329470038414001,
-0.7034373879432678,
-0.09980255365371704,
-0.6378588676452637,
-0.2590083181858063,
-0.5984011888504028,
-0.14678660035133362,
0.5101460218429565,
-0.14595383405685425,
-0.203041210770607,
0.1604798436164856,
-0.9545544981956482,
0.353936105966568,
0.7754603624343872,
-0.14166121184825897,
0.4659731984138489,
0.22194626927375793,
0.02372266724705696,
-0.19040845334529877,
-0.6122578978538513,
-0.5119668245315552,
1.0518136024475098,
-0.17376980185508728,
0.3577454686164856,
-0.22645607590675354,
1.0002803802490234,
0.680122971534729,
0.5949353575706482,
-0.6178059577941895,
0.45617958903312683,
0.11616992950439453,
-0.5549131035804749,
-0.5186673998832703,
-0.19218862056732178,
-0.8106120228767395,
0.18614459037780762,
-0.16492407023906708,
-0.46549272537231445,
0.05044620484113693,
-0.02821074239909649,
-0.12839767336845398,
-0.10672421008348465,
-0.7199572324752808,
0.42497217655181885,
0.011530330404639244,
-0.6672475337982178,
-0.014920608140528202,
-0.6290789842605591,
0.16750475764274597,
0.061089638620615005,
0.20784613490104675,
0.370382159948349,
0.2926484942436218,
0.9145559072494507,
-0.46951955556869507,
0.6318725943565369,
-0.15408402681350708,
-0.03413475304841995,
0.8260126113891602,
0.3200156092643738,
0.6145594716072083,
-0.032310355454683304,
-0.24749866127967834,
-0.20725248754024506,
-0.2180187702178955,
-0.4116405248641968,
-0.39639273285865784,
0.9100125432014465,
-0.584033727645874,
-0.5165553689002991,
-0.6355401873588562,
-0.9227126240730286,
-0.09916852414608002,
0.5521366000175476,
0.49450305104255676,
0.30361872911453247,
-0.25507357716560364,
-0.0882892981171608,
-0.05108943581581116,
0.3752249777317047,
0.4588758945465088,
-0.14773787558078766,
0.07592814415693283,
-0.6238449811935425,
1.073867917060852,
0.28527331352233887,
-0.158858060836792,
-0.12207985669374466,
-0.09555728733539581,
0.07614791393280029,
-0.992980420589447,
-0.6605029702186584,
0.29258668422698975,
-0.7286344766616821,
0.012144501321017742,
-0.44523924589157104,
-0.14570939540863037,
-0.3089537024497986,
-0.48091548681259155,
-0.016304612159729004,
-0.517228901386261,
-0.4135703146457672,
-0.04680660367012024,
-0.029104020446538925,
1.2139952182769775,
-0.012927046045660973,
-0.053920336067676544,
-0.6962254643440247,
-0.16622182726860046,
0.3120226263999939,
-0.1410597711801529,
0.1508028209209442,
0.1269822120666504,
-0.47721606492996216,
-0.2284509837627411,
-0.33063405752182007,
-0.5945417284965515,
0.08318587392568588,
0.04780203104019165,
0.2981777489185333,
0.10003475099802017,
-0.03829323872923851,
0.5240709185600281,
-0.5135302543640137,
1.085394263267517,
0.02594822458922863,
-0.9202471375465393,
0.3770309388637543,
-0.6839861273765564,
0.23215606808662415,
1.117483139038086,
0.4130813181400299,
0.07493408024311066,
-0.6454275250434875,
-0.7098392844200134,
-1.0660297870635986,
0.3029162287712097,
0.7434386610984802,
-0.13797466456890106,
0.045562028884887695,
0.35449767112731934,
0.17374193668365479,
0.2739191949367523,
-0.8149723410606384,
-0.03220811486244202,
-0.14885874092578888,
-0.3286498188972473,
0.3199516534805298,
-0.11441609263420105,
-0.35919949412345886,
-0.07009243220090866,
0.612895131111145,
-0.17254117131233215,
0.18904255330562592,
0.46134406328201294,
-0.23253172636032104,
0.08651480078697205,
-0.0745578333735466,
0.6548386216163635,
0.9036113023757935,
-0.12247616797685623,
0.16648879647254944,
-0.21937504410743713,
-0.6140640377998352,
-0.21363364160060883,
0.27099117636680603,
-0.5607430338859558,
-0.031031345948576927,
1.0006142854690552,
0.27500680088996887,
-0.1688331812620163,
-0.31086093187332153,
0.25061437487602234,
-0.08857180923223495,
-0.6205419301986694,
-0.17609544098377228,
0.18148359656333923,
0.08237534016370773,
0.16512137651443481,
0.43809774518013,
0.39020586013793945,
0.6526951193809509,
-0.5175743699073792,
-0.2729627788066864,
0.2813079357147217,
-0.5688493847846985,
-0.38022565841674805,
0.4775823950767517,
0.2340935468673706,
-0.08764027804136276,
0.5011538863182068,
-0.36142727732658386,
-0.2847820520401001,
0.16174963116645813,
0.2271551787853241,
0.963922381401062,
0.1361500769853592,
0.22394104301929474,
0.06432727724313736,
0.2682901620864868,
0.2648209035396576,
0.1621209979057312,
-0.21216587722301483,
-0.10952898859977722,
-0.36835139989852905,
-0.4256012439727783,
-0.13978494703769684,
-0.022145992144942284,
-0.47867950797080994,
-0.2385171353816986,
-0.2876296639442444,
-0.1697077602148056,
0.24899029731750488,
0.008271765895187855,
-0.5028875470161438,
0.028610333800315857,
-0.7531722187995911,
0.23258773982524872,
-0.8974756002426147,
0.4794211983680725,
0.9147888422012329,
-0.7815534472465515,
-0.6658416390419006,
0.17950071394443512,
-0.20774833858013153,
-0.24473462998867035,
0.5486428141593933,
-0.2128845751285553,
-0.432923287153244,
-0.011476878076791763,
-0.5048471689224243,
-0.47434404492378235,
1.2894915342330933,
0.12531796097755432,
-0.04139290004968643,
-0.3295918405056,
0.011107658967375755,
0.9578750133514404,
-0.20109528303146362,
0.2820369303226471,
0.2223479449748993,
0.6146851181983948,
0.0024188575334846973,
-0.8742848038673401,
0.2662314474582672,
-0.5326080322265625,
-0.09093555063009262,
-0.23033249378204346,
-0.4447473883628845,
0.9352946877479553,
0.1759166717529297,
-0.23724491894245148,
0.327426940202713,
0.7296808958053589,
0.10522015392780304,
0.48832839727401733,
0.27192869782447815,
-0.0459737591445446,
0.8771899342536926,
0.21211232244968414,
0.9007343649864197,
-0.2036660611629486,
0.0865219384431839,
1.2697322368621826,
-0.4223387837409973,
0.3669629693031311,
0.6873559951782227,
-0.2474164366722107,
0.8569427132606506,
0.40706315636634827,
0.11287345737218857,
0.441253125667572,
0.1567373424768448,
-0.3328348696231842,
0.1889571100473404,
-0.0991978868842125,
-0.6480220556259155,
0.23952730000019073,
0.15395502746105194,
-0.6800531148910522,
0.13077613711357117,
-0.2584301233291626,
0.07318016141653061,
0.18298447132110596,
0.15515729784965515,
0.9163431525230408,
-0.10753091424703598,
-0.903069257736206,
0.3246246576309204,
-0.10340391844511032,
0.24217377603054047,
-0.25197216868400574,
-0.017585400491952896,
-0.2066650390625,
-0.07399646937847137,
-0.416197806596756,
-0.6982467770576477,
0.4409745931625366,
-0.05858606845140457,
-0.343779981136322,
0.03604932874441147,
0.8397407531738281,
-0.30391725897789,
-0.4001927673816681,
-0.16965942084789276,
0.7882042527198792,
0.27471724152565,
-0.11780815571546555,
-0.5482601523399353,
0.025661740452051163,
-0.019996672868728638,
-0.3084544539451599,
0.19280488789081573,
0.5253231525421143,
-0.34184253215789795,
0.35099440813064575,
0.701657772064209,
0.07924287021160126,
-0.35185015201568604,
0.2369699329137802,
0.9736676216125488,
-0.34380286931991577,
-0.4055914580821991,
-0.7184081077575684,
0.3982313573360443,
-0.3152807056903839,
-0.28576430678367615,
0.9843586683273315,
0.5345913767814636,
0.5895489454269409,
-0.3570157587528229,
1.3566060066223145,
-0.3329000771045685,
0.12653285264968872,
-0.38753366470336914,
0.8700816035270691,
-0.3795912563800812,
0.20782095193862915,
-0.894856333732605,
-1.0528301000595093,
-0.4367402195930481,
0.5296970009803772,
-0.2948670983314514,
0.13658694922924042,
1.0131964683532715,
0.46504920721054077,
0.00004987205829820596,
0.18917402625083923,
-0.21240349113941193,
-0.14598993957042694,
0.2912038564682007,
0.038570668548345566,
0.6867212653160095,
-0.20826299488544464,
0.6031498312950134,
-0.0421861931681633,
-0.16227814555168152,
-0.19302427768707275,
-0.9120884537696838,
-1.0946869850158691,
-0.7772484421730042,
-0.07214108854532242,
-0.3803279399871826,
0.06751351803541183,
0.4944026470184326,
0.3584958612918854,
-0.5717688798904419,
-0.13267207145690918,
-0.5345304012298584,
-0.04535358399152756,
-0.07651842385530472,
-0.19928260147571564,
0.9894253611564636,
-0.13580206036567688,
-0.6788498163223267,
0.4005199074745178,
0.2930922508239746,
0.02988387644290924,
-0.6418665051460266,
0.03467541188001633,
-0.10150282829999924,
-0.0058457376435399055,
0.6059781312942505,
-0.06702637672424316,
-0.4002132713794708,
-0.21713370084762573,
0.061184514313936234,
-0.15473251044750214,
-0.36215949058532715,
1.184138536453247,
-0.48099496960639954,
0.37229275703430176,
0.7683472037315369,
0.3666366636753082,
0.7102956771850586,
-0.02039838396012783,
0.5954886674880981,
-0.5156081318855286,
-0.008593762293457985,
0.2680080533027649,
0.19253642857074738,
0.4621218740940094,
-0.38069844245910645,
0.794482409954071,
0.3933916985988617,
-0.8541598916053772,
-0.6660535931587219,
-0.029707444831728935,
-0.8267097473144531,
-0.4528796076774597,
0.8010790348052979,
-0.21845519542694092,
-0.1028393805027008,
-0.39926084876060486,
-0.5820730328559875,
0.25970178842544556,
-0.2930268347263336,
1.0106407403945923,
0.7335417866706848,
-0.6142185926437378,
0.6926572918891907,
-0.21031470596790314,
0.7556242942810059,
0.1406691074371338,
-0.9074030518531799,
-0.06303828209638596,
0.7842239141464233,
0.08931006491184235,
0.6151090264320374,
0.9850133061408997,
0.05583522096276283,
0.2362436056137085,
0.30080389976501465,
0.04035068675875664,
-0.34283557534217834,
-0.37455546855926514,
0.4312639832496643,
0.49919790029525757,
0.23065492510795593,
0.5014218688011169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12249v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12249v1 | Analysis of Levenshtein Transformer's Decoder and Its Variants | 2024-02-19T16:05:28 | 2024-02-19T16:05:28 | Ruiyang Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Levenshtein transformer (LevT) is a non-autoregressive machine translation
model with high decoding efficiency and comparable translation quality in terms
of bleu score, due to its parallel decoding and iterative refinement procedure.
Are there any deficiencies of its translations and what improvements could be
made? In this report, we focus on LevT's decoder and analyse the decoding
results length, subword generation, and deletion module's capability. We hope
to identify weaknesses of the decoder for future improvements.
We also compare translations of the original LevT, knowledge-distilled LevT,
LevT with translation memory, and the KD-LevT with translation memory to see
how KD and translation memory can help. | [
-0.3898836374282837,
-0.6300374269485474,
-0.05943918973207474,
-0.1313685029745102,
-0.24786965548992157,
0.08217839151620865,
0.05658045411109924,
-0.48018428683280945,
-0.055949047207832336,
0.15416136384010315,
-0.26124995946884155,
-0.032324038445949554,
-0.8151246905326843,
0.46721240878105164,
-0.8265097737312317,
1.1107796430587769,
-0.1884184032678604,
0.21316787600517273,
0.3387376666069031,
-0.11044599115848541,
-0.6553945541381836,
-0.13060982525348663,
-0.5975604057312012,
-0.2094781994819641,
0.36263421177864075,
0.3757961392402649,
0.6462405323982239,
0.496550053358078,
0.8330326080322266,
0.2585624158382416,
-0.06688732653856277,
-0.4213557243347168,
-0.6434750556945801,
0.03704293817281723,
-0.23303593695163727,
-0.40225207805633545,
-0.6254610419273376,
-0.25444716215133667,
0.8592622876167297,
0.35938701033592224,
-0.20283131301403046,
0.13871750235557556,
0.03434478119015694,
1.0003294944763184,
-0.24304085969924927,
-0.14999043941497803,
-0.5576105117797852,
0.2110666185617447,
-0.23485080897808075,
-0.10641642659902573,
-0.46821850538253784,
-0.22445426881313324,
0.10383331775665283,
0.1073259562253952,
0.8155837059020996,
0.30776143074035645,
0.8066831827163696,
0.49627548456192017,
-0.6362400650978088,
0.00594334676861763,
-0.7550309896469116,
0.7600622177124023,
-0.8693057298660278,
0.769834041595459,
0.09169444441795349,
0.6771160364151001,
-0.1023024320602417,
-0.48459339141845703,
-0.6396404504776001,
-0.12731516361236572,
-0.34169742465019226,
0.20239543914794922,
-0.05404939502477646,
-0.012561757117509842,
0.2796883285045624,
1.1636266708374023,
-1.0271157026290894,
0.03968515247106552,
-0.4428577125072479,
-0.08338096737861633,
0.489883691072464,
0.18787814676761627,
0.3134390413761139,
-0.39429545402526855,
-0.24058404564857483,
-0.14783194661140442,
-0.5322819948196411,
-0.14497922360897064,
0.369700163602829,
-0.20200257003307343,
0.03414127230644226,
0.807593047618866,
-0.4044022262096405,
0.3956858813762665,
0.1765315681695938,
0.2930736243724823,
0.3215939402580261,
-0.2726992070674896,
-0.4517044723033905,
0.05045897886157036,
0.4809962809085846,
0.30796438455581665,
0.052947357296943665,
-0.2815185785293579,
-0.6981845498085022,
-0.2343127280473709,
0.3297989070415497,
-0.8301630020141602,
-0.4613400995731354,
0.22566966712474823,
-0.972922146320343,
-0.1361500769853592,
0.06945321708917618,
-0.7588889002799988,
-0.04531720280647278,
0.22102905809879303,
0.41081804037094116,
-0.7537362575531006,
-0.4171483516693115,
0.11039800941944122,
-0.47473499178886414,
0.4911535680294037,
0.08060727268457413,
-0.9244199991226196,
0.3289439082145691,
0.08087199181318283,
0.4673968255519867,
-0.474001407623291,
-0.37241026759147644,
-0.3452906608581543,
-0.17131945490837097,
-0.20068304240703583,
0.6392013430595398,
-0.11288541555404663,
-0.5262711644172668,
-0.1669478565454483,
0.37704673409461975,
-0.2391941398382187,
-0.5172926783561707,
0.3647569715976715,
-0.814175546169281,
0.04650642350316048,
-0.486846923828125,
-0.7967939972877502,
-0.4456563889980316,
0.14063014090061188,
-0.9987590312957764,
0.6846705079078674,
0.4514075219631195,
-0.8184051513671875,
0.26154080033302307,
-0.6482337713241577,
-0.6364032030105591,
0.24932262301445007,
0.22948551177978516,
-0.3755676746368408,
0.4633520841598511,
0.11328476667404175,
-0.05699753761291504,
-0.28972920775413513,
0.041816942393779755,
0.5220575332641602,
-0.4484257698059082,
0.2686026096343994,
-0.6788201928138733,
0.3518209755420685,
0.17624972760677338,
-0.4487329423427582,
-0.038137130439281464,
-0.843005895614624,
-0.12583327293395996,
0.34008553624153137,
-0.6562581658363342,
0.36831745505332947,
0.1182570680975914,
0.4363185167312622,
-0.06721504777669907,
0.41284874081611633,
-0.7588043212890625,
0.06661857664585114,
-0.4050312042236328,
0.22258174419403076,
0.6040678024291992,
-0.00803721509873867,
0.35182496905326843,
-0.4721793532371521,
0.5215640068054199,
0.22946012020111084,
0.2791557013988495,
-0.1750592440366745,
-0.6685261130332947,
-0.8196021318435669,
0.23958058655261993,
0.6383140683174133,
0.6308206915855408,
-0.8075137734413147,
0.17889495193958282,
-0.2694620192050934,
-0.2625390291213989,
-0.48688092827796936,
-0.047379620373249054,
0.4232138991355896,
0.4366195499897003,
0.7274996042251587,
-0.3040771186351776,
-0.3036445081233978,
-1.2052520513534546,
-0.48804792761802673,
0.17965827882289886,
0.16191673278808594,
-0.31415775418281555,
0.5846002101898193,
-0.3448464572429657,
0.39389634132385254,
-0.12445960938930511,
-0.039401665329933167,
-0.40816548466682434,
0.10639659315347672,
0.04530346766114235,
0.6224057674407959,
0.3715149760246277,
-0.9132183194160461,
-0.7972078919410706,
0.2987687885761261,
-0.34695902466773987,
0.1536557823419571,
0.10888101905584335,
0.2749980390071869,
0.540115237236023,
0.25512444972991943,
-0.6010045409202576,
0.8855600953102112,
0.5726468563079834,
-0.29933473467826843,
0.7135752439498901,
-0.29826274514198303,
0.5853447914123535,
-0.8723085522651672,
0.042598336935043335,
-0.3503884971141815,
-0.3747381269931793,
-0.4830714762210846,
0.06200595945119858,
0.26667797565460205,
0.03646078705787659,
-0.1659349799156189,
0.11652753502130508,
-0.3656269311904907,
-0.10285632312297821,
-0.18017646670341492,
-0.13876911997795105,
-0.2024969607591629,
0.2242395132780075,
-0.10435082763433456,
0.8228549957275391,
0.26117396354675293,
-0.2758926451206207,
0.5938625335693359,
0.3280610740184784,
-0.420225590467453,
0.46647879481315613,
-0.7062200903892517,
0.12430144101381302,
-0.1785849630832672,
0.03430427238345146,
-1.0432335138320923,
-0.15911652147769928,
-0.04064872860908508,
-0.3906131386756897,
0.5966538786888123,
0.018249064683914185,
-0.6711960434913635,
-0.43791696429252625,
-0.16388817131519318,
0.7222597002983093,
0.8177415132522583,
-0.35191673040390015,
0.13127222657203674,
-0.20598062872886658,
0.13236232101917267,
-0.6936631202697754,
-0.8791955709457397,
0.033792559057474136,
0.055595122277736664,
-0.20956330001354218,
0.2694539427757263,
-0.2376585751771927,
0.2957479655742645,
0.38052108883857727,
-0.4239805340766907,
0.055636752396821976,
-0.33241868019104004,
-0.22176243364810944,
-0.0750250592827797,
-0.4903546869754791,
-0.0997534841299057,
0.15138272941112518,
-0.3891851007938385,
-0.20562328398227692,
-0.05564076825976372,
0.49458047747612,
-0.3283250331878662,
-0.41721048951148987,
-0.5652424097061157,
0.6135072708129883,
0.5865835547447205,
-0.26352658867836,
0.5474576950073242,
0.6875470280647278,
-0.16824863851070404,
-0.1556212157011032,
-0.5750325322151184,
-0.07649540901184082,
-0.48104771971702576,
0.4373704791069031,
-0.5374212265014648,
-0.6545422673225403,
0.5542898178100586,
0.16107037663459778,
-0.19718848168849945,
0.7086148262023926,
0.46147212386131287,
0.026685034856200218,
0.8278582692146301,
0.6555246710777283,
0.13471044600009918,
0.23618996143341064,
-0.2713161110877991,
0.5046767592430115,
-0.8614020347595215,
-0.1378554105758667,
-0.1584443747997284,
-0.6807025671005249,
-0.8312917351722717,
-0.02338731847703457,
-0.028958147391676903,
0.07205487042665482,
0.010752726346254349,
0.6557337641716003,
-0.5020743608474731,
0.5135453939437866,
0.47241640090942383,
-0.18508946895599365,
0.2962004542350769,
-0.20809593796730042,
0.0798335075378418,
0.053875114768743515,
-0.5860992670059204,
-0.29320308566093445,
0.9768914580345154,
0.39283496141433716,
0.6383078098297119,
0.1834714263677597,
0.6037525534629822,
0.27528661489486694,
0.04489710554480553,
-0.7459814548492432,
0.3904831111431122,
-0.37835773825645447,
-0.6437295079231262,
-0.334651380777359,
-0.5009941458702087,
-0.8690699338912964,
-0.0653722882270813,
0.01255305390805006,
-0.5708860754966736,
0.28345534205436707,
0.1302758753299713,
0.18734604120254517,
0.5670814514160156,
-0.7648792862892151,
1.1082340478897095,
-0.015117749571800232,
0.3851209580898285,
-0.22714395821094513,
-0.5795890092849731,
0.29798388481140137,
-0.10718591511249542,
-0.16816416382789612,
0.19376328587532043,
0.23940713703632355,
0.4549524784088135,
-0.28879618644714355,
0.35264965891838074,
0.04254831373691559,
-0.25020676851272583,
0.021287325769662857,
0.35932567715644836,
0.33254075050354004,
-0.1858062893152237,
-0.22299166023731232,
0.2443692982196808,
0.36379846930503845,
-0.6314422488212585,
-0.5400616526603699,
0.4970491826534271,
-0.56154465675354,
-0.5406799912452698,
-0.16247788071632385,
-0.713411271572113,
0.01463350746780634,
0.44055867195129395,
0.8062333464622498,
0.5768380761146545,
-0.3728209435939789,
0.10979005694389343,
0.654636561870575,
-0.4665275812149048,
0.601108193397522,
0.40975743532180786,
-0.23292790353298187,
-0.35527995228767395,
0.8652293682098389,
0.16657553613185883,
0.3986593186855316,
0.6546571850776672,
0.1986387073993683,
-0.3319482207298279,
-0.809685468673706,
-0.4886075556278229,
0.02925688773393631,
-0.8930959701538086,
-0.3371518850326538,
-0.2259051501750946,
-0.3928942084312439,
-0.4265460669994354,
0.1827753186225891,
-0.4883231818675995,
-0.3782970905303955,
0.35299524664878845,
-0.06271245330572128,
0.3379316031932831,
1.2128713130950928,
0.024731934070587158,
0.37668856978416443,
-0.9382520318031311,
0.6533209681510925,
0.27791517972946167,
0.44352173805236816,
0.007407601922750473,
-0.48277637362480164,
-0.37428390979766846,
-0.07328299432992935,
-0.2035277783870697,
-1.1478641033172607,
0.27042558789253235,
-0.08290582150220871,
0.41452014446258545,
0.02255389094352722,
-0.043564509600400925,
0.2595006823539734,
-0.6864708662033081,
0.9363793730735779,
0.09106891602277756,
-0.9875973463058472,
0.4146342873573303,
-0.19849711656570435,
0.4441854953765869,
0.2508377134799957,
0.08720988780260086,
-0.555178701877594,
-0.23772995173931122,
-0.551434338092804,
-0.44997888803482056,
0.5914661288261414,
0.3612695336341858,
-0.10328374803066254,
-0.13256117701530457,
0.4852031469345093,
0.4250822365283966,
0.1621169149875641,
-0.5212166905403137,
-0.385555237531662,
-0.457887202501297,
-0.19543656706809998,
-0.2276279330253601,
-0.451702743768692,
0.3644999861717224,
-0.4494478106498718,
0.5763992667198181,
0.333306223154068,
0.3676118552684784,
0.34011977910995483,
-0.41379934549331665,
-0.3862569332122803,
0.37398311495780945,
0.36494436860084534,
0.3815719783306122,
-0.18834815919399261,
0.29304665327072144,
0.4200267791748047,
-0.618986189365387,
0.08338613063097,
-0.18373124301433563,
0.006855091545730829,
0.07635383307933807,
0.22932472825050354,
0.543549656867981,
-0.21489137411117554,
-0.4218737781047821,
0.5953348278999329,
-0.23321469128131866,
-0.14465120434761047,
0.1706686019897461,
-0.12932878732681274,
0.01284017227590084,
0.27916955947875977,
0.3217468559741974,
0.1642129272222519,
0.4440123438835144,
-0.35781145095825195,
0.37836387753486633,
0.18871282041072845,
-0.24642784893512726,
-0.3729635775089264,
0.4733164608478546,
-0.000690062646754086,
-0.6374027132987976,
0.794268786907196,
-0.5709857940673828,
-0.6334164142608643,
0.5812134742736816,
0.7441027164459229,
0.9543181657791138,
-0.7774753570556641,
0.12276463955640793,
0.15966510772705078,
0.592617928981781,
-0.19758480787277222,
0.3528265357017517,
-0.030196022242307663,
-0.5010174512863159,
-0.48830968141555786,
-0.7450306415557861,
-0.044045768678188324,
0.23961442708969116,
-0.821715772151947,
0.17871560156345367,
-0.011277019046247005,
0.03895650431513786,
-0.280771404504776,
-0.1257086843252182,
-0.6577300429344177,
0.29078909754753113,
-0.33591943979263306,
0.9861664175987244,
-0.47349023818969727,
1.1293394565582275,
0.6663061380386353,
-0.3144735097885132,
-0.6015005111694336,
0.36880236864089966,
-0.35913899540901184,
-0.61954265832901,
0.8500959277153015,
0.07178615778684616,
-0.13735529780387878,
0.29323694109916687,
-0.10066678375005722,
-0.5760360956192017,
0.8358019590377808,
0.19602718949317932,
-0.6918990015983582,
-0.062469907104969025,
0.4099343717098236,
0.4753977954387665,
0.17158962786197662,
0.011452672071754932,
0.7900779247283936,
0.5585114359855652,
-0.3607703745365143,
-1.4038604497909546,
0.3018750846385956,
-0.40354305505752563,
0.38863155245780945,
0.37389931082725525,
-0.4687964618206024,
0.8498620986938477,
0.1359693706035614,
-0.45134857296943665,
0.3513573706150055,
0.24950724840164185,
-0.6250419616699219,
-0.026414604857563972,
0.11976106464862823,
0.7821692824363708,
0.30130234360694885,
0.11506164073944092,
1.189467430114746,
-0.20583973824977875,
0.5813199877738953,
0.6503216624259949,
0.2225572019815445,
0.8762214779853821,
0.39363911747932434,
-0.19182096421718597,
0.5049206018447876,
0.3537351191043854,
-0.16854117810726166,
0.5567678213119507,
0.15600907802581787,
0.03358501195907593,
0.01726367697119713,
0.5911701321601868,
-0.42622166872024536,
0.2207799106836319,
0.14697128534317017,
-0.1648002415895462,
-0.46545204520225525,
0.14968018233776093,
-0.6765212416648865,
-0.05166475847363472,
0.029311910271644592,
0.6439819931983948,
0.15190455317497253,
-0.33648329973220825,
0.8932721018791199,
0.10867295414209366,
0.5228761434555054,
-0.16957254707813263,
-0.09813812375068665,
-0.2900282144546509,
0.263742595911026,
-0.32133427262306213,
-0.7534213066101074,
0.6821982264518738,
-0.30442312359809875,
-0.3017062246799469,
-0.05718093737959862,
0.6010099053382874,
-0.3301694691181183,
-0.18444828689098358,
0.28096452355384827,
0.4551951289176941,
0.34323787689208984,
0.060459431260824203,
-0.6868341565132141,
0.07637087255716324,
-0.07477181404829025,
-0.3629540503025055,
0.08805955201387405,
0.5156329274177551,
0.2908618152141571,
0.38018494844436646,
0.1910528689622879,
0.012144128791987896,
0.36827802658081055,
0.05266286060214043,
0.463875412940979,
-0.91334468126297,
-0.14387764036655426,
-0.7498835325241089,
0.4757311940193176,
0.06064358353614807,
-0.15930543839931488,
0.9459874629974365,
0.6683294177055359,
0.6629149913787842,
-0.4519057869911194,
0.6316342949867249,
-0.20811204612255096,
0.3083863854408264,
-0.45234519243240356,
0.7048735618591309,
-0.4951378107070923,
0.05046309530735016,
0.015207565389573574,
-1.1850918531417847,
-0.05080312117934227,
0.5646989941596985,
-0.21539272367954254,
-0.03739329054951668,
1.2760686874389648,
0.6031203269958496,
-0.15799857676029205,
0.24440045654773712,
0.47541430592536926,
0.23375998437404633,
0.23399841785430908,
0.5635768175125122,
0.9185479283332825,
-1.0643786191940308,
0.5194671750068665,
-0.09705173969268799,
-0.011064453050494194,
-0.24937236309051514,
-0.6565636396408081,
-0.8330771923065186,
-0.7128915190696716,
-0.3310839533805847,
-0.23246443271636963,
-0.09120329469442368,
0.13844166696071625,
0.3789728283882141,
-0.9784956574440002,
-0.12396291643381119,
-0.5366499423980713,
0.2252153605222702,
-0.3372633159160614,
-0.2753988206386566,
0.36036473512649536,
-0.5773947238922119,
-0.6829164624214172,
0.49064409732818604,
0.2889343500137329,
0.37404513359069824,
-0.13355141878128052,
-0.07342787086963654,
0.11274538189172745,
0.002613217104226351,
0.4994278848171234,
0.18618926405906677,
-0.5897442102432251,
-0.5398356914520264,
0.2124810665845871,
0.10725511610507965,
0.3339459002017975,
0.8497002720832825,
-0.37400293350219727,
0.1973751187324524,
0.8927221894264221,
0.6581147313117981,
0.6514505743980408,
-0.1719331443309784,
0.6263983249664307,
-0.3997008800506592,
-0.13518808782100677,
0.010473170317709446,
0.44150713086128235,
0.2245030701160431,
-0.41950416564941406,
0.043849874287843704,
0.246515691280365,
-0.8152586817741394,
-0.6172563433647156,
0.49783405661582947,
-0.9547343254089355,
-0.4104018807411194,
1.1066282987594604,
0.11773096770048141,
-0.3121311068534851,
-0.26716455817222595,
-0.275855153799057,
0.43886566162109375,
-0.030658746138215065,
0.6593197584152222,
0.6369159817695618,
-0.06951301544904709,
-0.33722129464149475,
-0.8350943326950073,
0.5820304751396179,
0.4296764135360718,
-0.3440145254135132,
0.06283717602491379,
0.11250773072242737,
0.683807373046875,
0.20607154071331024,
0.31774958968162537,
-0.47477078437805176,
0.3806576430797577,
0.29682600498199463,
0.043728332966566086,
0.17520780861377716,
-0.10994718223810196,
-0.44922393560409546,
-0.0974297747015953,
0.06276637315750122,
-0.26831963658332825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14848v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14848v1 | Same Task, More Tokens: the Impact of Input Length on the Reasoning Performance of Large Language Models | 2024-02-19T16:04:53 | 2024-02-19T16:04:53 | Mosh Levy, Alon Jacoby, Yoav Goldberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper explores the impact of extending input lengths on the capabilities
of Large Language Models (LLMs). Despite LLMs advancements in recent times,
their performance consistency across different input lengths is not well
understood. We investigate this aspect by introducing a novel QA reasoning
framework, specifically designed to assess the impact of input length. We
isolate the effect of input length using multiple versions of the same sample,
each being extended with padding of different lengths, types and locations. Our
findings show a notable degradation in LLMs' reasoning performance at much
shorter input lengths than their technical maximum. We show that the
degradation trend appears in every version of our dataset, although at
different intensities. Additionally, our study reveals that traditional
perplexity metrics do not correlate with performance of LLMs' in long input
reasoning tasks. We analyse our results and identify failure modes that can
serve as useful guides for future research, potentially informing strategies to
address the limitations observed in LLMs. | [
-0.39206430315971375,
-0.7934795618057251,
1.151286244392395,
0.21044529974460602,
-0.23945468664169312,
0.18273311853408813,
-0.29673856496810913,
-0.6403570175170898,
0.09262773394584656,
0.4341626763343811,
-0.42544877529144287,
-0.2526816129684448,
-0.829355776309967,
0.46123161911964417,
-0.3927857279777527,
0.6125516295433044,
-0.13158850371837616,
-0.10086727887392044,
-0.4472070336341858,
-0.29821401834487915,
-0.5691571235656738,
-0.7488855719566345,
-0.5949265956878662,
-0.32960572838783264,
0.7772461175918579,
0.4134806990623474,
0.8398127555847168,
0.5363881587982178,
0.6625801920890808,
0.2845935523509979,
-0.4641917049884796,
0.27532798051834106,
-0.35830381512641907,
0.16659937798976898,
-0.1483144462108612,
-0.6808876991271973,
-0.3459532856941223,
-0.34004923701286316,
1.0862188339233398,
0.8313271999359131,
0.23573631048202515,
0.07977841049432755,
0.08168177306652069,
0.3782343864440918,
-0.5760887265205383,
-0.02883042022585869,
-0.3771044909954071,
-0.0324297733604908,
-0.18306130170822144,
-0.04968291521072388,
-0.3965679109096527,
0.06414162367582321,
-0.00015520672604907304,
-0.43404096364974976,
-0.3026457130908966,
-0.1563701331615448,
0.601958692073822,
0.14284686744213104,
-0.40592673420906067,
-0.13209208846092224,
-0.8208156228065491,
0.7541537284851074,
-0.980247974395752,
0.4425230622291565,
0.1539154201745987,
0.11870857328176498,
-0.3354276120662689,
-0.5995606184005737,
-0.8524035811424255,
-0.36148861050605774,
-0.08013281971216202,
-0.48413485288619995,
0.012826002202928066,
0.17654255032539368,
0.6121463775634766,
0.10196393728256226,
-0.48565906286239624,
0.39866411685943604,
-0.4272710084915161,
-0.0009410888305865228,
0.5582041144371033,
0.2963324785232544,
0.17926211655139923,
-0.08896417915821075,
-0.152862548828125,
-0.01178289670497179,
-0.9341342449188232,
0.2880353331565857,
0.4087413549423218,
0.19499999284744263,
0.0960959866642952,
0.6375327110290527,
-0.3619425594806671,
0.6238783597946167,
-0.22194135189056396,
-0.3423781991004944,
0.20240694284439087,
-0.40199732780456543,
-0.10722257941961288,
-0.300302118062973,
0.7034912705421448,
0.03293713182210922,
-0.12553706765174866,
-0.06243418529629707,
-0.29489246010780334,
-0.2552136182785034,
-0.17367589473724365,
-0.6184864044189453,
0.25781553983688354,
0.25490492582321167,
-0.266567200422287,
0.14295074343681335,
-0.01978292502462864,
-0.33232325315475464,
-0.5941099524497986,
-0.20998436212539673,
0.38935524225234985,
-0.34856876730918884,
-0.12310405820608139,
0.29359325766563416,
-0.13359087705612183,
0.3502964675426483,
0.14420820772647858,
-0.7193546891212463,
0.35186877846717834,
1.169501543045044,
0.834597647190094,
-0.39261308312416077,
-0.5117396116256714,
-0.6064232587814331,
-0.20675252377986908,
-0.3045731484889984,
0.6207321882247925,
-0.8636391162872314,
-0.49266356229782104,
0.010047485120594501,
0.09287072718143463,
-0.038953203707933426,
-0.6717355251312256,
0.6208599209785461,
-0.569912850856781,
-0.020643820986151695,
-0.4310009181499481,
-0.5433176755905151,
-0.051940444856882095,
0.14531733095645905,
-0.697729766368866,
0.8045741319656372,
0.10658363997936249,
-0.5583685040473938,
0.42431071400642395,
-0.7101550698280334,
-0.7395109534263611,
0.16625365614891052,
-0.2765977680683136,
-0.34291595220565796,
0.35741302371025085,
-0.015185515396296978,
0.3124040365219116,
-0.4530598521232605,
0.38367152214050293,
-0.6644330024719238,
-0.6838558316230774,
0.6142683029174805,
-0.5762506723403931,
0.7813668847084045,
0.04817141592502594,
-0.2431618869304657,
0.2520502805709839,
-0.9809221029281616,
-0.06000271439552307,
0.01906530186533928,
-0.6072410941123962,
-0.020068639889359474,
-0.0021433874499052763,
-0.1728106141090393,
0.41989728808403015,
0.2932281196117401,
-0.7818419337272644,
0.21827469766139984,
-0.3610926568508148,
0.7006900906562805,
0.7265232801437378,
-0.21661972999572754,
0.2675732672214508,
-0.4070742428302765,
0.8071590662002563,
-0.08301184326410294,
0.22545109689235687,
-0.19576887786388397,
-0.23801936209201813,
-0.6547088027000427,
-0.28397896885871887,
0.4082586169242859,
0.43088003993034363,
-0.6629559993743896,
0.35757383704185486,
-0.5329336524009705,
-0.2530553936958313,
-0.14671841263771057,
0.17257322371006012,
0.41730430722236633,
0.09696142375469208,
0.17860715091228485,
-0.41187968850135803,
-0.6210815906524658,
-0.9801493287086487,
-0.29828375577926636,
-0.30235567688941956,
-0.18260912597179413,
0.1376989483833313,
0.634849488735199,
-0.2418583333492279,
0.8520969748497009,
-0.2791772186756134,
0.11895223706960678,
-0.46019837260246277,
-0.30124732851982117,
0.25352609157562256,
0.48800718784332275,
0.3044379651546478,
-0.2384679913520813,
0.036063309758901596,
-0.14895407855510712,
-0.41970524191856384,
0.031324319541454315,
-0.18534564971923828,
0.090680330991745,
0.27928176522254944,
0.47532981634140015,
-0.9077754616737366,
0.3896048367023468,
0.6258863210678101,
-0.5054059028625488,
1.0455060005187988,
-0.029590412974357605,
0.0007114771869964898,
-0.7693705558776855,
-0.18742701411247253,
-0.017717888578772545,
-0.07528603076934814,
-0.356995552778244,
0.19616807997226715,
-0.12145454436540604,
-0.029518218711018562,
-0.3209819197654724,
0.7496321201324463,
-0.2483544796705246,
-0.24599683284759521,
-0.25766998529434204,
0.07890326529741287,
0.28612807393074036,
0.44512778520584106,
-0.2672700583934784,
0.8498244881629944,
0.37550461292266846,
-0.3991246521472931,
0.5135931372642517,
0.009565114043653011,
-0.4847337603569031,
0.3953707814216614,
-0.8911808729171753,
0.11563567817211151,
0.14052388072013855,
0.3096841275691986,
-1.012498378753662,
-0.07051718235015869,
-0.06340177357196808,
-0.5662063360214233,
0.3024176359176636,
0.18137313425540924,
-0.878678560256958,
-0.33268243074417114,
-0.3081323504447937,
0.6259190440177917,
0.4795447885990143,
-0.5849407911300659,
0.6593815684318542,
-0.052111949771642685,
-0.18886181712150574,
-0.504449725151062,
-0.6537724137306213,
0.2628779709339142,
-0.37975814938545227,
-0.8399060964584351,
0.0027975577395409346,
-0.02576080895960331,
-0.3514663875102997,
-0.11817401647567749,
-0.1573311984539032,
-0.06393126398324966,
0.39330676198005676,
0.3121410012245178,
0.1372845321893692,
-0.4203023314476013,
0.4462328553199768,
0.1158640906214714,
0.25090292096138,
0.416738897562027,
-0.18448977172374725,
0.6323558688163757,
-0.04270818084478378,
-0.6206416487693787,
-0.6827123761177063,
0.5112411975860596,
0.7114289999008179,
-0.23781748116016388,
1.0253889560699463,
0.15237097442150116,
-0.15023291110992432,
-0.1835823804140091,
-0.6096165180206299,
-0.20158471167087555,
-0.5131042003631592,
0.6881511807441711,
-0.7993829846382141,
-1.2279514074325562,
0.7654765844345093,
-0.042273931205272675,
0.027622291818261147,
0.49560412764549255,
0.3477736711502075,
-0.023635493591427803,
1.022141456604004,
0.6698228120803833,
0.008567089214920998,
0.3626479208469391,
0.004572695586830378,
0.3867211937904358,
-0.9445751309394836,
-0.3022679090499878,
-0.4775036871433258,
-0.18611939251422882,
-0.32105499505996704,
-0.65920490026474,
0.06586632877588272,
0.07799021899700165,
-0.34083136916160583,
-0.025784911587834358,
-0.052024852484464645,
0.4571908712387085,
0.3574814200401306,
-0.09785743802785873,
0.338452011346817,
-0.19032025337219238,
-0.15903452038764954,
0.33813396096229553,
-0.7349061369895935,
-0.5631819367408752,
1.0736870765686035,
0.6371386647224426,
0.5160582661628723,
0.13154663145542145,
0.5609875321388245,
0.06057057902216911,
-0.09257218986749649,
-0.7197439074516296,
0.586452066898346,
-0.057685162872076035,
-0.36271727085113525,
-0.6642557382583618,
-0.45249009132385254,
-1.0066919326782227,
0.1362227201461792,
0.07174350321292877,
-0.8114466667175293,
0.21137568354606628,
-0.10782764106988907,
-0.41902589797973633,
0.32849791646003723,
-0.39950448274612427,
0.6126948595046997,
-0.28547000885009766,
-0.3377441167831421,
-0.1384982317686081,
-0.3575884997844696,
0.36871621012687683,
-0.019861450418829918,
0.18552225828170776,
-0.00876852497458458,
-0.003918678034096956,
0.9144981503486633,
-0.671107828617096,
0.6781730651855469,
0.08019525557756424,
-0.38329005241394043,
0.21039405465126038,
-0.08468380570411682,
0.4590294361114502,
0.13886751234531403,
-0.1194787472486496,
0.175982266664505,
0.2294570654630661,
-0.6200100779533386,
-0.8652259111404419,
0.8237747550010681,
-0.6220117211341858,
-1.012837290763855,
-0.14311784505844116,
-0.7141481041908264,
-0.6675068140029907,
0.08013013005256653,
-0.051093894988298416,
0.5385461449623108,
0.16189870238304138,
0.3827454149723053,
0.7159188985824585,
-0.25094249844551086,
0.3544195294380188,
0.25961410999298096,
-0.36911237239837646,
-0.13581570982933044,
0.7079610824584961,
0.2526933252811432,
0.4791439175605774,
0.14881779253482819,
0.022706300020217896,
-0.3792303502559662,
-0.8145955801010132,
-0.4108365774154663,
0.36087581515312195,
-0.9314351677894592,
0.12177800387144089,
-0.542051374912262,
-0.13557498157024384,
-0.5582895874977112,
0.03457130491733551,
-0.2175576090812683,
-0.5813209414482117,
-0.3583829998970032,
-0.2604166865348816,
0.2656184732913971,
0.7696015238761902,
0.09141421318054199,
0.2410164624452591,
-0.7224043011665344,
-0.0010588557925075293,
0.2704393267631531,
0.7556997537612915,
0.18541677296161652,
-0.9312268495559692,
-0.15278930962085724,
-0.1890925168991089,
-0.05682661384344101,
-0.6771258115768433,
-0.06646515429019928,
-0.14809690415859222,
0.6237724423408508,
0.3277810215950012,
-0.24832087755203247,
0.5318877100944519,
-0.31409284472465515,
0.8697780966758728,
0.3330792784690857,
-0.96208655834198,
0.04671551659703255,
-0.21240636706352234,
0.816604495048523,
0.39409443736076355,
0.17396783828735352,
-0.6441572308540344,
-0.32929906249046326,
-0.4535635709762573,
-0.7726097702980042,
0.3433714509010315,
-0.09102106839418411,
0.28329363465309143,
0.005821669474244118,
0.4548094868659973,
0.24669748544692993,
-0.23507268726825714,
-0.40897059440612793,
-0.06240016967058182,
0.38683316111564636,
-0.021048422902822495,
-0.13676247000694275,
-0.7116938829421997,
-0.06569275259971619,
-0.3873922526836395,
0.6425034999847412,
-0.169463112950325,
0.06283193826675415,
0.06553198397159576,
-0.0936262458562851,
0.2707766890525818,
0.4532036781311035,
0.7504370212554932,
1.2006419897079468,
0.34753674268722534,
0.10940596461296082,
0.5225929021835327,
-0.04093734547495842,
0.11179901659488678,
0.07596399635076523,
0.06809690594673157,
0.015585269778966904,
0.7103567719459534,
0.9913862347602844,
-0.012518304400146008,
-1.1144791841506958,
0.40597841143608093,
-0.040958721190690994,
-0.39400461316108704,
-0.402714341878891,
0.005340204108506441,
0.31934595108032227,
0.3780295252799988,
0.3788386881351471,
-0.24759235978126526,
0.07733385264873505,
-0.6950917840003967,
0.18025042116641998,
0.424432635307312,
-0.4245666563510895,
-0.21463577449321747,
0.23230358958244324,
0.06455370783805847,
-0.42821234464645386,
0.48199182748794556,
-0.2974420487880707,
-0.48766806721687317,
0.8697043061256409,
0.4609123766422272,
0.6709765791893005,
0.11565689742565155,
0.0475449413061142,
0.09112625569105148,
0.33103811740875244,
-0.09234727919101715,
0.31728923320770264,
0.0477101095020771,
-0.5135145783424377,
-0.9238125681877136,
-0.7176873683929443,
-0.25051334500312805,
0.3082444667816162,
-0.40716132521629333,
0.17922092974185944,
-0.6882231831550598,
-0.1738106608390808,
-0.20840178430080414,
0.023032447323203087,
-0.6239932179450989,
0.029971979558467865,
0.22348523139953613,
0.8364401459693909,
-0.6606332659721375,
0.5146211385726929,
0.6172021627426147,
-0.22524628043174744,
-0.9582995176315308,
-0.12889619171619415,
-0.12158246338367462,
-0.554213285446167,
0.7754994630813599,
0.1383453607559204,
-0.27831798791885376,
-0.6132528185844421,
-0.35423895716667175,
-1.1320160627365112,
0.7469625473022461,
0.33060774207115173,
-0.7360420823097229,
-0.15285877883434296,
0.5566527843475342,
0.6544547080993652,
-0.36041802167892456,
0.060202766209840775,
0.9322888255119324,
0.366629034280777,
0.03995516523718834,
-1.3404326438903809,
0.22285300493240356,
-0.09600913524627686,
0.08216352015733719,
0.038852546364068985,
-0.6116677522659302,
0.8160263895988464,
-0.32957303524017334,
-0.24353177845478058,
0.29750898480415344,
0.5414246916770935,
0.41502895951271057,
0.16231557726860046,
0.3890063166618347,
0.6864807605743408,
0.7201951146125793,
-0.013629457913339138,
1.131765604019165,
-0.055917687714099884,
0.15453873574733734,
1.2214897871017456,
-0.338006854057312,
0.8784100413322449,
0.37832775712013245,
-0.40130162239074707,
0.6904762983322144,
0.43447747826576233,
0.1196262538433075,
-0.10390757769346237,
0.7081988453865051,
-0.23438717424869537,
-0.39335915446281433,
-0.12050845474004745,
-0.20572979748249054,
0.5038332939147949,
0.3271128237247467,
-0.37598520517349243,
0.11379163712263107,
0.3121761679649353,
0.09749840945005417,
0.11842282116413116,
-0.19868731498718262,
0.6419579982757568,
0.11089828610420227,
-0.6569867730140686,
0.779977560043335,
0.07132190465927124,
0.6877034306526184,
-0.20924682915210724,
0.021566836163401604,
-0.21812155842781067,
0.07960356771945953,
-0.2372761070728302,
-0.7207158207893372,
0.15551987290382385,
-0.2183154970407486,
-0.2458547204732895,
0.1442701369524002,
0.5081496238708496,
-0.040683336555957794,
-0.5181357860565186,
0.32012566924095154,
0.49220171570777893,
0.0656203031539917,
-0.02527209185063839,
-0.41340962052345276,
0.5762864351272583,
-0.22575734555721283,
-0.2931203246116638,
0.4458846151828766,
0.5667844414710999,
-0.22867166996002197,
0.8864515423774719,
0.4730589985847473,
0.007804215885698795,
0.20615901052951813,
0.02880115434527397,
0.9227971434593201,
-0.7084479928016663,
-0.2354302853345871,
-0.9656880497932434,
0.18014222383499146,
-0.15256577730178833,
-0.4468175172805786,
0.5951566100120544,
0.5865713357925415,
0.8608565926551819,
0.2589913606643677,
0.8269041776657104,
0.23708920180797577,
0.4915563762187958,
-0.45698240399360657,
0.3591831922531128,
-0.5176833271980286,
0.6754806041717529,
0.06993559747934341,
-0.742662787437439,
-0.25031065940856934,
0.11166229844093323,
-0.5231616497039795,
0.07587910443544388,
0.9999120235443115,
0.6262879371643066,
0.3279830515384674,
-0.08793815225362778,
0.4752517342567444,
0.21737496554851532,
0.5016456842422485,
0.7489898204803467,
1.054883360862732,
0.04096309840679169,
0.588378369808197,
-0.08788929879665375,
-0.01411121990531683,
-0.16345800459384918,
-0.4713688790798187,
-0.8438053727149963,
-0.6257230043411255,
-0.22403420507907867,
-0.35801106691360474,
0.1336667239665985,
0.6338207721710205,
0.46434974670410156,
-0.6334434747695923,
-0.10309116542339325,
0.14235709607601166,
0.34445205330848694,
-0.021792007610201836,
-0.2588280737400055,
0.37845319509506226,
-0.34318023920059204,
-0.5657190084457397,
0.26941341161727905,
0.3693300485610962,
-0.3490743637084961,
-0.5426316261291504,
-0.06254228949546814,
-0.20594929158687592,
0.29838821291923523,
0.8620485067367554,
0.42811107635498047,
-1.142011284828186,
-0.6287168860435486,
0.05804707482457161,
0.0010321445297449827,
0.03289179131388664,
0.8436357378959656,
-0.7962907552719116,
0.23114733397960663,
0.5729107856750488,
0.9812788963317871,
0.11160412430763245,
-0.2860417366027832,
0.6010044813156128,
-0.5111805200576782,
-0.18245358765125275,
0.29351353645324707,
0.5497763156890869,
0.2527874708175659,
-0.2617577314376831,
0.1593012809753418,
0.1178589016199112,
-0.4788875877857208,
-1.0024409294128418,
0.4543403387069702,
-0.8639941215515137,
-0.5946345925331116,
1.523396372795105,
-0.3906855881214142,
-0.11543358862400055,
-0.12977834045886993,
-0.1251671463251114,
0.03498566523194313,
-0.30173248052597046,
0.7923570871353149,
1.0004937648773193,
-0.27668309211730957,
-0.2895950675010681,
-0.28585875034332275,
0.2974552810192108,
0.841861367225647,
-0.7004086375236511,
0.15368041396141052,
0.5461028218269348,
0.3917793929576874,
0.2496158480644226,
0.45277318358421326,
-0.15471449494361877,
0.4916696548461914,
0.12006818503141403,
-0.3465557098388672,
-0.1008429005742073,
-0.2565637230873108,
-0.5959341526031494,
0.40130940079689026,
0.5799263715744019,
0.16123434901237488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12243v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12243v4 | Understanding the Effects of Noise in Text-to-SQL: An Examination of the BIRD-Bench Benchmark | 2024-02-19T15:58:15 | 2024-03-25T19:48:16 | Niklas Wretblad, Fredrik Gordh Riseby, Rahul Biswas, Amin Ahmadi, Oskar Holmström | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text-to-SQL, which involves translating natural language into Structured
Query Language (SQL), is crucial for enabling broad access to structured
databases without expert knowledge. However, designing models for such tasks is
challenging due to numerous factors, including the presence of 'noise,' such as
ambiguous questions and syntactical errors. This study provides an in-depth
analysis of the distribution and types of noise in the widely used BIRD-Bench
benchmark and the impact of noise on models. While BIRD-Bench was created to
model dirty and noisy database values, it was not created to contain noise and
errors in the questions and gold queries. We found that noise in questions and
gold queries are prevalent in the dataset, with varying amounts across domains,
and with an uneven distribution between noise types. The presence of incorrect
gold SQL queries, which then generate incorrect gold answers, has a significant
impact on the benchmark's reliability. Surprisingly, when evaluating models on
corrected SQL queries, zero-shot baselines surpassed the performance of
state-of-the-art prompting methods. We conclude that informative noise labels
and reliable benchmarks are crucial to developing new Text-to-SQL methods that
can handle varying types of noise. All datasets, annotations, and code are
available at
https://github.com/niklaswretblad/the-effects-of-noise-in-text-to-SQL. | [
0.018833868205547333,
-1.1867460012435913,
0.38974887132644653,
0.4638267755508423,
-0.3446976840496063,
-0.5175700187683105,
-0.07075638324022293,
-0.8464447259902954,
-0.4020387530326843,
0.7008331418037415,
-0.6833662390708923,
-0.5525397658348083,
-0.33153200149536133,
0.37412992119789124,
-0.9742183089256287,
1.084925651550293,
0.31788596510887146,
0.021482031792402267,
-0.19903801381587982,
0.046103864908218384,
-0.3924928307533264,
-0.6060196757316589,
-0.23924322426319122,
0.06974732875823975,
0.3192290663719177,
-0.2779915928840637,
0.631085216999054,
0.5715354084968567,
0.6754657030105591,
0.07619573175907135,
-0.376572847366333,
0.16856688261032104,
-0.4166276156902313,
0.29942676424980164,
-0.2221602499485016,
-0.4302048087120056,
-0.2093726545572281,
-0.2514677047729492,
0.5139986872673035,
0.9800373911857605,
-0.16625776886940002,
0.14900904893875122,
0.05484867841005325,
0.8672000169754028,
-0.7226214408874512,
0.6033793687820435,
-0.8856680393218994,
0.10574956983327866,
-0.6882611513137817,
-0.248462975025177,
-0.3631259500980377,
-0.0960763469338417,
-0.19791138172149658,
-0.6112536191940308,
0.15610088407993317,
0.1391567885875702,
0.8346374034881592,
0.42494675517082214,
-0.4024178087711334,
-0.32599103450775146,
-0.9475407600402832,
0.7282222509384155,
-0.6035819053649902,
0.2565261125564575,
0.4458374083042145,
0.14245298504829407,
-0.3412307798862457,
-0.5067892074584961,
-0.23333506286144257,
0.16415263712406158,
-0.1845567226409912,
0.03989694267511368,
0.10621228069067001,
-0.0075475857593119144,
0.3919162154197693,
0.48111096024513245,
-0.4949101507663727,
-0.23683659732341766,
-0.24304479360580444,
0.2643164396286011,
0.6807392239570618,
-0.003950994927436113,
0.03201867267489433,
0.045024573802948,
0.2176615297794342,
0.0005929043982177973,
-0.35668548941612244,
0.020619114860892296,
0.43036597967147827,
0.8998520970344543,
0.07277252525091171,
0.3820345401763916,
-0.3829084634780884,
1.3400319814682007,
-0.18149781227111816,
0.15378104150295258,
0.11992237716913223,
-0.6930661797523499,
-0.20054303109645844,
0.07221852988004684,
0.7179805636405945,
0.11901934444904327,
0.3772963285446167,
-0.46349939703941345,
-0.21182654798030853,
-0.22560636699199677,
0.22740601003170013,
-0.7425075769424438,
-0.22248105704784393,
0.35004207491874695,
-0.49221405386924744,
-0.5408275723457336,
-0.0137736015021801,
-0.6902010440826416,
-0.6350488662719727,
-0.09136752784252167,
0.5616408586502075,
-0.14120817184448242,
-0.6026202440261841,
0.17090772092342377,
-0.29967203736305237,
-0.022057825699448586,
0.27063843607902527,
-0.8567190170288086,
0.6352983713150024,
0.6764580607414246,
0.42998483777046204,
0.03961825743317604,
-0.04474590718746185,
-0.4219236969947815,
0.2501050531864166,
-0.5470840334892273,
1.158803105354309,
-0.5252312421798706,
-0.5360148549079895,
0.10400845110416412,
-0.08253783732652664,
-0.4165832996368408,
-0.8979971408843994,
0.7718732357025146,
-0.2575029134750366,
0.0880478024482727,
-0.6173014640808105,
-0.4637035131454468,
-0.03585514426231384,
0.05460860952734947,
-0.6444036364555359,
1.2456899881362915,
0.21716047823429108,
-0.8055758476257324,
0.5259233713150024,
-0.7429885268211365,
-0.7269372344017029,
-0.1255139857530594,
-0.36345553398132324,
-0.5414746403694153,
0.25943565368652344,
0.11538466811180115,
0.0371006578207016,
-0.3208158016204834,
-0.025961143895983696,
-0.13092973828315735,
-0.8021883964538574,
0.521272599697113,
-0.11299920082092285,
0.6928707957267761,
0.12694677710533142,
-0.3251986503601074,
-0.371893048286438,
-0.9795820116996765,
0.06471095234155655,
0.08924297988414764,
-0.08166081458330154,
-0.22240914404392242,
0.36089026927948,
0.08904969692230225,
0.013356203213334084,
-0.22930948436260223,
-0.15140517055988312,
-0.2920380234718323,
-0.4033717215061188,
0.2942177653312683,
0.14866168797016144,
0.5244883894920349,
-0.019808325916528702,
-0.4594360291957855,
0.11462806165218353,
0.4747501015663147,
0.3147638142108917,
0.01821932941675186,
-0.472001314163208,
-0.2103251814842224,
0.05240003392100334,
0.16430234909057617,
0.3609559237957001,
0.05918934568762779,
-0.09167976677417755,
0.1315108984708786,
-0.20505136251449585,
-0.3122711181640625,
0.2660616636276245,
0.11606356501579285,
0.6947243213653564,
0.3999841511249542,
-0.10097741335630417,
-0.47045812010765076,
-0.6489041447639465,
-0.8932134509086609,
-0.41275477409362793,
0.2428044229745865,
0.4603171944618225,
0.34802183508872986,
0.11382877081632614,
0.847200870513916,
-0.08592601120471954,
-0.4923805892467499,
0.35958126187324524,
0.2852742671966553,
0.17501947283744812,
0.36458620429039,
0.5401394367218018,
-0.7087001204490662,
-0.41944199800491333,
-0.29374992847442627,
-0.664252519607544,
-0.25939783453941345,
-0.1533883512020111,
-0.09256679564714432,
0.36313682794570923,
0.573051393032074,
-0.567561686038971,
0.591884195804596,
0.259033739566803,
-0.030173948034644127,
0.8334676027297974,
0.23975205421447754,
0.0355830043554306,
-0.698966383934021,
0.3400668799877167,
-0.013280997052788734,
0.289495050907135,
-0.3501488268375397,
-0.3226335644721985,
-0.04958281293511391,
-0.20728491246700287,
-0.05409559980034828,
0.016921652480959892,
-0.6102599501609802,
-0.2568241059780121,
0.05371062830090523,
0.07364880293607712,
0.14544065296649933,
0.0016440836479887366,
0.029378782957792282,
1.078590750694275,
0.4989748001098633,
-0.6541072726249695,
-0.2561958134174347,
0.3485192656517029,
-0.38302555680274963,
0.8579858541488647,
-0.7249006032943726,
-0.20535694062709808,
-0.08444486558437347,
0.1057080626487732,
-1.0827274322509766,
-0.12613578140735626,
0.12317943572998047,
-0.33308881521224976,
0.2130042463541031,
-0.34906986355781555,
-0.8205996155738831,
-0.026782935485243797,
-0.010131566785275936,
0.15115562081336975,
0.25189393758773804,
-0.2780247628688812,
-0.05009893327951431,
0.2610604763031006,
-0.04351424425840378,
-0.5019279718399048,
-0.9734527468681335,
0.27177804708480835,
0.08546125888824463,
-0.525138795375824,
0.2555601894855499,
0.03350327908992767,
-0.5240540504455566,
0.07875730842351913,
-0.2550106346607208,
-0.6020022034645081,
0.017979657277464867,
0.3366440236568451,
-0.0838502049446106,
-0.3359263241291046,
0.5742914080619812,
-0.11800408363342285,
0.2674673795700073,
0.49551376700401306,
-0.1861366331577301,
0.08951413631439209,
-0.23838002979755402,
-0.2886732816696167,
-0.45112279057502747,
0.40705522894859314,
0.39159250259399414,
-0.4099118113517761,
0.8915711641311646,
0.39039376378059387,
-0.09933172911405563,
-0.36431291699409485,
-0.3087136745452881,
-0.27509960532188416,
-0.38164839148521423,
0.5227860808372498,
-0.2509050965309143,
-0.09375845640897751,
0.3703579604625702,
-0.24379272758960724,
0.25889256596565247,
0.6983308792114258,
0.030657196417450905,
-0.47903695702552795,
1.067067265510559,
0.42461106181144714,
0.40332871675491333,
0.569405734539032,
0.10148470103740692,
0.0698828175663948,
-0.5481171011924744,
-0.23562945425510406,
-1.0984333753585815,
0.08491896092891693,
-0.3553004860877991,
-0.3690173923969269,
-0.023816049098968506,
0.07916679978370667,
-0.32046961784362793,
-0.07800465077161789,
-0.7071390748023987,
0.4315139055252075,
0.0411531962454319,
-0.04002239927649498,
0.587123453617096,
0.40446528792381287,
0.21971549093723297,
-0.2966378331184387,
-0.6298074722290039,
-0.12484833598136902,
1.0345966815948486,
-0.29791060090065,
0.7882463932037354,
0.15190191566944122,
0.5868996381759644,
0.31549039483070374,
-0.05731581896543503,
-0.3281363248825073,
0.27461153268814087,
-0.3515684902667999,
-0.8716191649436951,
-0.19137993454933167,
-0.4786421060562134,
-1.0490962266921997,
0.051829997450113297,
-0.4146603047847748,
-0.7709919214248657,
0.2528913915157318,
-0.0030212977435439825,
-0.14537763595581055,
0.22241103649139404,
-0.5630112290382385,
0.9523337483406067,
-0.06882711499929428,
-0.5707724690437317,
0.08674314618110657,
-0.6715340614318848,
0.46878892183303833,
-0.21606555581092834,
0.5279436707496643,
-0.06344220787286758,
0.08289177715778351,
0.7069483995437622,
-0.558843731880188,
0.8563393354415894,
-0.06869709491729736,
-0.03933098912239075,
0.44893506169319153,
0.1043647825717926,
0.7906794548034668,
-0.32796141505241394,
-0.6548378467559814,
0.23256178200244904,
0.4248213469982147,
-0.27283787727355957,
-0.4801733195781708,
0.3963537812232971,
-0.9021860957145691,
-0.2215016484260559,
-0.4051259160041809,
-0.6963921189308167,
-0.25913649797439575,
0.08583192527294159,
0.142557755112648,
0.5475358366966248,
-0.03791124373674393,
0.3550395369529724,
0.6888031959533691,
-0.04248511418700218,
0.175942525267601,
0.7569279670715332,
-0.2124880850315094,
0.11531505733728409,
0.7536121010780334,
0.6794347763061523,
0.02665821649134159,
0.24436166882514954,
-0.024900663644075394,
-0.6728231310844421,
-0.7619931697845459,
-0.15788567066192627,
0.29958200454711914,
-0.5926611423492432,
0.03961701691150665,
-0.8012439608573914,
-0.38794243335723877,
-0.290469765663147,
0.22420062124729156,
-0.33935898542404175,
-0.5454580187797546,
-0.640495777130127,
0.1526726335287094,
0.4849279522895813,
0.7630681991577148,
0.21419788897037506,
0.22199204564094543,
-0.5219601988792419,
-0.01258306298404932,
0.04018119350075722,
0.6691438555717468,
-0.15997208654880524,
-0.4420807957649231,
-0.22650036215782166,
-0.13551007211208344,
0.0784088522195816,
-1.1375290155410767,
-0.0015935928095132113,
0.6306609511375427,
0.49177518486976624,
-0.0007885212544351816,
0.6445268392562866,
0.8850540518760681,
0.0035087938886135817,
0.8724648356437683,
-0.24526478350162506,
-0.599380373954773,
0.6697660088539124,
-0.6776109933853149,
0.20835809409618378,
0.8863088488578796,
-0.26004326343536377,
-0.29844722151756287,
-0.5453625917434692,
-0.659744918346405,
-0.6885136961936951,
0.658477246761322,
0.4029131531715393,
-0.2357049286365509,
-0.15925952792167664,
0.5939337015151978,
0.003067441051825881,
0.42541006207466125,
-0.6018218398094177,
-0.1534135937690735,
-0.20800809562206268,
0.10076795518398285,
0.160479336977005,
-0.2253451645374298,
-0.19270533323287964,
-0.08529048413038254,
0.5337508916854858,
0.10425971448421478,
0.13563552498817444,
0.17207017540931702,
-0.27557137608528137,
-0.4437122344970703,
0.3697684705257416,
0.6135711073875427,
0.5427225232124329,
-0.6524948477745056,
0.021029695868492126,
-0.11048076301813126,
-0.3456094264984131,
-0.3860189616680145,
0.3028642535209656,
-0.27740171551704407,
0.38829338550567627,
0.002917093923315406,
0.39065271615982056,
0.1713734120130539,
-0.5735147595405579,
0.364060640335083,
-0.16645961999893188,
-0.36003851890563965,
-0.17240950465202332,
0.059234749525785446,
0.13087022304534912,
-0.27955910563468933,
0.38002365827560425,
0.4203583002090454,
0.2980669438838959,
-0.4460142254829407,
0.12449857592582703,
0.3866826891899109,
-0.6477096676826477,
-0.2048506736755371,
0.864129900932312,
0.36722394824028015,
-0.3600238561630249,
0.6766115427017212,
-0.060947250574827194,
0.07821818441152573,
0.51950603723526,
0.6325129270553589,
0.5329917669296265,
0.301156222820282,
0.24615490436553955,
0.3449343144893646,
0.6016753911972046,
-0.1553964465856552,
0.5508723855018616,
-0.07693310081958771,
-0.12710386514663696,
-0.362846702337265,
-0.5895606279373169,
-0.5210340023040771,
0.07967875152826309,
-0.9280022382736206,
-0.1208396852016449,
-0.40459755063056946,
-0.3384605050086975,
0.16999280452728271,
0.24957212805747986,
-0.33567163348197937,
0.1274484395980835,
-0.335978627204895,
0.7783650159835815,
-0.8499980568885803,
0.49108177423477173,
0.6285241842269897,
-0.4115433990955353,
-0.6589797735214233,
0.023562710732221603,
0.17191079258918762,
-0.42355117201805115,
0.4138464331626892,
0.01624346524477005,
0.17209962010383606,
-0.13467220962047577,
-0.46209219098091125,
-0.602537214756012,
0.5480690598487854,
0.3319219648838043,
-0.46848300099372864,
0.46844473481178284,
0.68302983045578,
0.6496442556381226,
0.006806905847042799,
0.23257403075695038,
0.599636435508728,
0.578136682510376,
0.054685089737176895,
-0.7686730027198792,
0.045187994837760925,
-0.252810001373291,
-0.12631534039974213,
0.27352339029312134,
-0.7264254093170166,
1.041612148284912,
-0.12897475063800812,
-0.22140470147132874,
-0.07109877467155457,
0.26113131642341614,
0.10762540251016617,
0.27328595519065857,
0.4021458029747009,
0.12310712039470673,
0.9930667877197266,
-0.16974182426929474,
0.9479126930236816,
-0.46785810589790344,
0.10897358506917953,
1.2860267162322998,
-0.603690505027771,
1.0361273288726807,
0.5371629595756531,
-0.4626498222351074,
0.4473167955875397,
0.6414210796356201,
-0.09889689087867737,
0.18395908176898956,
0.3542339503765106,
-0.3259211480617523,
-0.1219072937965393,
-0.4013032913208008,
-0.8926418423652649,
0.05694892257452011,
0.5222486257553101,
-0.2947610020637512,
-0.5233637690544128,
-0.6273350119590759,
-0.3602222800254822,
0.12572337687015533,
0.08668573945760727,
0.8973548412322998,
-0.06689304113388062,
-0.3945200443267822,
0.502743124961853,
-0.30434662103652954,
0.3108171224594116,
-0.6442933082580566,
0.06627820432186127,
-0.22234177589416504,
0.21778139472007751,
-0.48988601565361023,
-0.6788323521614075,
0.7970800399780273,
-0.16815441846847534,
-0.43353894352912903,
0.0019282173598185182,
0.6419878602027893,
-0.4705623984336853,
-0.5937244296073914,
-0.02237900160253048,
0.44685742259025574,
0.5391591787338257,
-0.6877012252807617,
-0.9219241738319397,
0.35650500655174255,
-0.22365731000900269,
-0.10435067117214203,
0.5293946266174316,
0.5612472295761108,
0.03250781446695328,
0.23131316900253296,
0.7589776515960693,
0.1431676745414734,
0.09567944705486298,
0.3138884902000427,
0.5017472505569458,
-0.5303782820701599,
-0.3926250636577606,
-0.5468829274177551,
0.2512894570827484,
-0.20576122403144836,
-0.17667096853256226,
0.8020012378692627,
0.8031783699989319,
0.22191567718982697,
-0.029079115018248558,
0.5978827476501465,
0.2883140444755554,
0.6491168141365051,
-0.08969628065824509,
1.022386908531189,
-0.6770786046981812,
0.5805689692497253,
-0.4719981551170349,
-0.7888286709785461,
-0.33156201243400574,
0.4077610969543457,
-0.03362571820616722,
0.13016584515571594,
0.7370749711990356,
1.1365532875061035,
0.35095149278640747,
0.42270326614379883,
0.33623191714286804,
0.445240318775177,
0.1756560355424881,
0.06966935843229294,
0.6861765384674072,
-0.8499619960784912,
1.3015375137329102,
-0.20516075193881989,
0.23278120160102844,
-0.3321749269962311,
-0.7025140523910522,
-0.6044650077819824,
-0.4027613699436188,
-0.8182775974273682,
-0.6063538789749146,
0.600473165512085,
0.32849398255348206,
0.8171008825302124,
-0.8077174425125122,
-0.513023853302002,
-0.3233707845211029,
0.06108143925666809,
-0.7958478331565857,
-0.2890816330909729,
0.4693149924278259,
-0.6556857824325562,
-0.37848588824272156,
0.19082215428352356,
0.2211240977048874,
0.15057800710201263,
0.2834237515926361,
0.26264455914497375,
-0.23248977959156036,
0.2814009487628937,
0.45564886927604675,
0.5260618925094604,
-0.3897133469581604,
0.17905350029468536,
-0.054404038935899734,
-0.3208475708961487,
-0.019224321469664574,
0.4462483525276184,
-0.729207456111908,
0.5274415016174316,
0.23328529298305511,
0.3293721377849579,
0.7362437844276428,
0.1428339034318924,
0.44825252890586853,
-1.0063347816467285,
0.21655292809009552,
0.06071152910590172,
-0.20302264392375946,
0.21515505015850067,
-0.5450319647789001,
0.6587671041488647,
0.45676711201667786,
-0.3984226584434509,
-1.2285722494125366,
-0.2819213271141052,
-0.8849016427993774,
-0.3951578438282013,
1.056053638458252,
0.32699888944625854,
-0.42278245091438293,
-0.5761310458183289,
-0.10800407826900482,
-0.054325126111507416,
-0.30740323662757874,
0.8873408436775208,
0.7925934791564941,
-0.25998905301094055,
-0.3369625210762024,
-0.6501297354698181,
0.8597142100334167,
0.4498292803764343,
-0.8332110047340393,
0.5001292824745178,
0.35677051544189453,
0.268080472946167,
-0.2520149350166321,
0.62690269947052,
-0.45293793082237244,
0.28696098923683167,
0.5473103523254395,
-0.2951561510562897,
-0.20505961775779724,
0.1423409879207611,
-0.1184123307466507,
0.2624730169773102,
0.07739734649658203,
0.014995456673204899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12234v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12234v1 | Task-Oriented Dialogue with In-Context Learning | 2024-02-19T15:43:35 | 2024-02-19T15:43:35 | Tom Bocklisch, Thomas Werkmeister, Daksh Varshneya, Alan Nichol | cs.CL | cs.CL | We describe a system for building task-oriented dialogue systems combining
the in-context learning abilities of large language models (LLMs) with the
deterministic execution of business logic. LLMs are used to translate between
the surface form of the conversation and a domain-specific language (DSL) which
is used to progress the business logic. We compare our approach to the
intent-based NLU approach predominantly used in industry today. Our experiments
show that developing chatbots with our system requires significantly less
effort than established approaches, that these chatbots can successfully
navigate complex dialogues which are extremely challenging for NLU-based
systems, and that our system has desirable properties for scaling task-oriented
dialogue systems to a large number of tasks. We make our implementation
available for use and further study. | [
-0.02604593336582184,
-1.0058788061141968,
0.6655765771865845,
0.26978880167007446,
-0.01649131439626217,
0.19789037108421326,
-0.21997316181659698,
-0.3768964409828186,
-0.13305318355560303,
0.8350131511688232,
-0.7713172435760498,
-0.4264585077762604,
-0.31004756689071655,
-0.014379121363162994,
-0.17830346524715424,
0.8995468616485596,
0.25213873386383057,
0.1159466803073883,
-0.23661747574806213,
0.06016487255692482,
-0.7742316126823425,
-0.6521722078323364,
-1.0117268562316895,
-0.5156204104423523,
0.10554489493370056,
0.3237725496292114,
0.45796599984169006,
0.10189934819936752,
0.2806347608566284,
0.3814161717891693,
0.04771393910050392,
0.12057634443044662,
-0.4627539813518524,
0.5413872003555298,
-0.376211017370224,
-0.665139377117157,
-0.4530135989189148,
-0.3469158709049225,
0.27645742893218994,
0.9401588439941406,
-0.23280221223831177,
0.04438863694667816,
0.08816734701395035,
0.5344770550727844,
-0.3211779296398163,
0.589368999004364,
-0.5790697932243347,
0.06243951618671417,
0.17723670601844788,
-0.22226008772850037,
-0.7581403255462646,
-0.06571851670742035,
0.37933608889579773,
-0.3753392696380615,
-0.42461541295051575,
0.14563626050949097,
0.2857709527015686,
0.2128314971923828,
-0.40382686257362366,
-0.5233101844787598,
-1.0375381708145142,
1.1780190467834473,
-0.7703146934509277,
0.41279634833335876,
0.14899225533008575,
0.3654455542564392,
-0.5343747735023499,
-0.5975408554077148,
-0.3914746344089508,
-0.29430675506591797,
0.004304889589548111,
0.0759153813123703,
-0.11400753259658813,
0.1965176910161972,
0.3464362323284149,
0.11441824585199356,
-0.3171951472759247,
0.027609217911958694,
-0.11547240614891052,
0.23825772106647491,
0.580507755279541,
0.5375799536705017,
0.12038891762495041,
0.048911720514297485,
-0.4732317328453064,
0.3499540388584137,
-0.6893352270126343,
0.12365308403968811,
0.07376831769943237,
0.6089105606079102,
0.1376330405473709,
0.3721500039100647,
-0.36399760842323303,
0.9474058747291565,
0.07821796089410782,
-0.5398120284080505,
-0.09397528320550919,
-0.18620461225509644,
-0.5981307029724121,
0.08725370466709137,
0.6895937323570251,
0.232048898935318,
-0.08537377417087555,
-0.10803870111703873,
-0.38400909304618835,
-0.03914026543498039,
0.33215248584747314,
-0.6119126081466675,
0.18545086681842804,
0.3896389901638031,
-0.4788750112056732,
-0.12485900521278381,
-0.49722811579704285,
-0.15693342685699463,
-0.18826277554035187,
-0.619339108467102,
0.43497079610824585,
-0.38436099886894226,
-0.04734063893556595,
0.11109024286270142,
-0.018821213394403458,
0.23463617265224457,
0.776811420917511,
-0.7279732823371887,
0.5997410416603088,
0.8033507466316223,
0.5426061749458313,
-0.22517026960849762,
0.09246934950351715,
-0.5843009948730469,
0.37284454703330994,
-0.36765438318252563,
0.41578924655914307,
-0.6289323568344116,
-0.43476399779319763,
-0.012149599380791187,
-0.14531874656677246,
-0.02638544887304306,
-0.6157654523849487,
0.43205589056015015,
-0.6300750374794006,
0.2760562300682068,
0.12677983939647675,
-0.6984877586364746,
-0.39084410667419434,
0.39099830389022827,
-0.2445700764656067,
0.7067116498947144,
0.1573258340358734,
-0.26318687200546265,
0.12114468216896057,
-1.0713869333267212,
-0.5840531587600708,
0.49434465169906616,
-0.3212837874889374,
0.09334469586610794,
-0.120768703520298,
-0.10278574377298355,
0.6397987008094788,
-0.46651941537857056,
0.39661461114883423,
0.03653079643845558,
-0.3382134735584259,
0.35437142848968506,
-0.42607998847961426,
0.9900554418563843,
0.3390561044216156,
-0.6565180420875549,
0.15364710986614227,
-0.43982720375061035,
-0.02529943361878395,
0.04586140438914299,
-0.38499781489372253,
-0.1855245679616928,
0.4331003725528717,
-0.03288445249199867,
0.25576478242874146,
0.39346930384635925,
-0.5598589181900024,
0.1399894803762436,
-0.3816702663898468,
0.4501500427722931,
0.5777745246887207,
-0.2693055272102356,
0.40536513924598694,
-0.2765616178512573,
0.4077838659286499,
0.1255003958940506,
0.2080141305923462,
-0.2456703633069992,
-0.5283564329147339,
-0.9431700110435486,
-0.20753461122512817,
-0.2720881700515747,
0.8494715690612793,
-0.7505236864089966,
0.5221900939941406,
-0.12199439108371735,
-0.2633345127105713,
0.0404510498046875,
0.18593132495880127,
0.4344516098499298,
0.5476282238960266,
0.1275036484003067,
-0.4266366958618164,
-0.2266780287027359,
-0.7292178273200989,
-0.02136114612221718,
-0.19315892457962036,
-0.14587758481502533,
0.6339020729064941,
0.1783536970615387,
-0.3089295029640198,
0.9899013042449951,
-0.44798851013183594,
-0.378317266702652,
-0.8111180067062378,
-0.1593465805053711,
0.4899274408817291,
0.4004169702529907,
0.20913422107696533,
-0.8298643231391907,
-0.6570736169815063,
0.15426364541053772,
-0.8081746697425842,
0.1250835657119751,
-0.05578790232539177,
-0.13449783623218536,
0.6194292902946472,
0.7186592221260071,
-0.652877151966095,
0.4760948419570923,
0.37792548537254333,
-0.1057821661233902,
0.3926101326942444,
0.0019324367167428136,
0.07583484053611755,
-1.0935144424438477,
-0.04506245255470276,
0.008792625740170479,
-0.47928228974342346,
-0.9877136945724487,
-0.2620563507080078,
-0.30349430441856384,
-0.265571266412735,
-0.614654541015625,
0.3675291836261749,
-0.0911896675825119,
-0.19945712387561798,
-0.34570401906967163,
0.33410853147506714,
-0.12712590396404266,
0.9270811676979065,
0.282432496547699,
0.5370984077453613,
0.453934907913208,
-0.898297905921936,
0.44290652871131897,
0.48176783323287964,
-0.45805907249450684,
0.9976301789283752,
-0.5482523441314697,
0.06926251947879791,
0.10925333946943283,
0.5046798586845398,
-0.6776124238967896,
-0.016093233600258827,
0.2724965512752533,
-0.17499274015426636,
0.19615218043327332,
-0.1998366415500641,
-0.3168761432170868,
-0.11534462869167328,
0.433744341135025,
0.096242256462574,
0.42968082427978516,
-0.3515690267086029,
0.6464511156082153,
0.4761195480823517,
-0.5233679413795471,
-0.5260392427444458,
-0.47133782505989075,
0.212528258562088,
-0.17724496126174927,
-0.48049309849739075,
0.16551685333251953,
-0.08209266513586044,
-0.47884002327919006,
-0.2525491416454315,
-0.08694209158420563,
-0.15341666340827942,
0.19528792798519135,
0.3021838665008545,
0.2968846559524536,
-0.14107444882392883,
0.13028421998023987,
-0.11260894685983658,
0.07132486253976822,
0.23785309493541718,
-0.7244971990585327,
0.6651586294174194,
-0.22322127223014832,
-0.5041856169700623,
-0.7287627458572388,
0.554291844367981,
0.6506982445716858,
0.034941013902425766,
0.43733543157577515,
0.05731171742081642,
-0.30356690287590027,
-0.4298253655433655,
-0.43832477927207947,
-0.09460648894309998,
-0.5303165316581726,
0.43861180543899536,
-0.48411932587623596,
-1.007959008216858,
0.23116543889045715,
-0.3315357267856598,
0.45383045077323914,
0.27342453598976135,
0.7674311399459839,
-0.3402438163757324,
0.9690520763397217,
0.827398955821991,
0.04465256258845329,
0.7827902436256409,
-0.13430067896842957,
0.5165696144104004,
-0.7495397329330444,
-0.2702706754207611,
-0.2871982157230377,
-0.3458894193172455,
-0.21307237446308136,
-0.40836307406425476,
0.24816669523715973,
-0.11018820852041245,
-0.390723317861557,
0.5741583704948425,
-0.21858374774456024,
0.24908524751663208,
0.755744218826294,
0.12368401885032654,
0.4935234487056732,
-0.22623777389526367,
0.06984595954418182,
0.19336235523223877,
-0.7585805058479309,
-0.6741458773612976,
0.9019389152526855,
0.2610524892807007,
0.846737802028656,
0.3103756904602051,
0.5316298604011536,
0.18317657709121704,
0.34222832322120667,
-1.0593829154968262,
0.8028885722160339,
-0.10946501046419144,
-0.5823437571525574,
-0.6708016395568848,
-0.42239850759506226,
-0.8399690985679626,
0.018666263669729233,
0.019011860713362694,
-1.0812231302261353,
-0.14048469066619873,
-0.11954905837774277,
-0.28317826986312866,
0.3038829267024994,
-0.6888703107833862,
0.7914302349090576,
-0.36664676666259766,
-0.1582740992307663,
-0.46680477261543274,
-0.708784282207489,
0.11049027740955353,
0.020132457837462425,
0.06762991100549698,
-0.2396746128797531,
0.16104626655578613,
0.5521988272666931,
-0.4140962064266205,
1.1302305459976196,
-0.24709245562553406,
-0.38079309463500977,
0.39872732758522034,
0.12486626952886581,
0.39049333333969116,
0.0033575904089957476,
0.08016245812177658,
-0.10721661895513535,
-0.19272059202194214,
-0.2208452671766281,
-0.8740962147712708,
0.4657997786998749,
-0.4214369058609009,
-0.8834609985351562,
-0.17187383770942688,
-0.9517202973365784,
-0.3901837170124054,
0.13856008648872375,
-0.31341689825057983,
0.6793140769004822,
-0.3497263193130493,
0.2740729749202728,
0.7290533185005188,
-0.20206321775913239,
0.4208754003047943,
0.5881249308586121,
-0.23700961470603943,
0.025438955053687096,
0.6943057179450989,
-0.18498924374580383,
0.5770948529243469,
0.7574594020843506,
-0.11864715814590454,
-0.2352740466594696,
-0.3974109888076782,
-0.4592393636703491,
-0.13477525115013123,
-0.7500120997428894,
-0.2838887572288513,
-0.7622559070587158,
-0.2980021834373474,
-0.21670745313167572,
-0.2796870470046997,
-0.3328096866607666,
-0.356999933719635,
-0.10719191282987595,
0.3134462833404541,
0.3071199357509613,
0.8679482340812683,
0.5646249055862427,
0.3697965741157532,
-0.8266797661781311,
0.04659685492515564,
0.48052388429641724,
0.3233780562877655,
-0.17666614055633545,
-0.45040184259414673,
-0.37290874123573303,
0.1663818061351776,
-0.5774298906326294,
-0.5253613591194153,
0.3873592019081116,
0.10398795455694199,
0.7882586121559143,
0.461722195148468,
0.17183952033519745,
0.46377113461494446,
-0.5516669154167175,
0.808245062828064,
0.25585678219795227,
-1.122951865196228,
0.7259654402732849,
-0.41906553506851196,
0.28464779257774353,
0.464078813791275,
0.4721698760986328,
-0.6867446303367615,
-0.6220375895500183,
-0.4992508292198181,
-0.6265086531639099,
0.9085441827774048,
-0.005252039059996605,
0.24759574234485626,
-0.034512512385845184,
0.1238587349653244,
0.03942134603857994,
0.3519761562347412,
-0.39683929085731506,
-0.24824583530426025,
0.14920656383037567,
-0.330875039100647,
-0.13894441723823547,
0.05775114521384239,
-0.32050222158432007,
0.01659071445465088,
0.6396352052688599,
-0.34610721468925476,
0.4200991690158844,
0.13740023970603943,
-0.3867191672325134,
0.23137035965919495,
0.4224347174167633,
0.5614060759544373,
0.7288209199905396,
-0.15747590363025665,
-0.282441109418869,
0.14776915311813354,
-0.27201762795448303,
0.17013287544250488,
-0.2051856815814972,
0.06648936867713928,
-0.19485929608345032,
-0.1807248890399933,
0.9630225896835327,
0.3979948163032532,
-1.1252121925354004,
0.5179690718650818,
-0.03609250858426094,
-0.16261251270771027,
-0.3463491201400757,
0.233087420463562,
0.18599361181259155,
0.7309367656707764,
0.4422891139984131,
-0.054556477814912796,
0.23201128840446472,
-0.8012734651565552,
0.14969079196453094,
0.5107290148735046,
-0.6501106023788452,
0.052405185997486115,
0.46153122186660767,
0.5736329555511475,
-0.6967393159866333,
0.5802813768386841,
-0.22983606159687042,
-0.5399386882781982,
0.5229369401931763,
0.8527312278747559,
0.9665721654891968,
-0.05661409720778465,
0.18133190274238586,
0.005878170486539602,
-0.014298433437943459,
-0.029940420761704445,
0.25174686312675476,
-0.38389232754707336,
-0.6954232454299927,
-0.7488172054290771,
-0.5336430072784424,
-0.992522656917572,
0.02129056118428707,
-0.3156140148639679,
0.14589597284793854,
-0.43860766291618347,
-0.12472932785749435,
-0.2610469460487366,
0.015790769830346107,
-0.6200207471847534,
0.22948797047138214,
0.09030453115701675,
0.748518168926239,
-0.5007233619689941,
0.8414112329483032,
0.6854667663574219,
-0.0007392132538370788,
-0.4537813067436218,
-0.1639171987771988,
-0.06491262465715408,
-0.3801320493221283,
1.1745153665542603,
0.17320431768894196,
-0.40664342045783997,
-0.0068453229032456875,
-0.3713368773460388,
-0.7122126817703247,
1.1535283327102661,
0.16140949726104736,
-0.5983571410179138,
0.07810632139444351,
0.09920380264520645,
0.4264615476131439,
-0.7116138935089111,
0.07812261581420898,
0.4545633792877197,
-0.01201359461992979,
0.07275301218032837,
-1.1080024242401123,
0.05643108859658241,
-0.08215354382991791,
-0.044676899909973145,
0.13094213604927063,
-0.5994959473609924,
0.4653586745262146,
-0.0057593584060668945,
-0.2652920186519623,
-0.08434275537729263,
0.7584393620491028,
0.13172438740730286,
0.3432871997356415,
0.6762784123420715,
0.2980600893497467,
0.5925097465515137,
-0.025280043482780457,
0.5715755820274353,
-0.3907466232776642,
0.14836138486862183,
1.2328295707702637,
-0.5233905911445618,
0.9489328265190125,
0.37474751472473145,
-0.21690793335437775,
0.6868605017662048,
0.16524523496627808,
0.4018416702747345,
0.242753803730011,
0.24190190434455872,
-0.5150312781333923,
-0.2717397212982178,
-0.22921080887317657,
0.31922024488449097,
0.5336884260177612,
0.927423357963562,
-0.05047226697206497,
-0.02024213969707489,
0.10810154676437378,
-0.1548817753791809,
-0.05956657603383064,
-0.24926918745040894,
1.0492990016937256,
0.23029100894927979,
-0.707889974117279,
0.3626479208469391,
-0.2069191038608551,
0.6911960244178772,
-0.5779727101325989,
0.08330875635147095,
-0.044572483748197556,
0.1383362114429474,
-0.021105382591485977,
-0.6396106481552124,
0.413889080286026,
-0.014769676141440868,
-0.01570926047861576,
-0.472953200340271,
0.5854747295379639,
-0.5505427122116089,
-0.20430625975131989,
0.2706376910209656,
0.6202378273010254,
0.23066863417625427,
0.07505946606397629,
-0.670878529548645,
-0.08463425934314728,
-0.10968364030122757,
-0.2412850707769394,
0.21929971873760223,
0.39122605323791504,
-0.17474719882011414,
1.0962834358215332,
0.4296305477619171,
-0.3818449378013611,
-0.21667559444904327,
0.0606868602335453,
0.6097842454910278,
-0.636549174785614,
-0.5120552778244019,
-0.49317240715026855,
0.42741820216178894,
-0.20752547681331635,
0.08451684564352036,
0.7241707444190979,
0.5839856266975403,
1.0238068103790283,
0.019932949915528297,
0.9766205549240112,
-0.1900273710489273,
0.458481103181839,
-0.4338925778865814,
0.43368470668792725,
-0.39056697487831116,
0.21287396550178528,
-0.295680433511734,
-0.9493692517280579,
-0.2172495573759079,
0.685415506362915,
-0.25877395272254944,
-0.11837927252054214,
0.7480419874191284,
0.680436909198761,
0.0328000970184803,
0.10992409288883209,
0.5762521624565125,
-0.007437715772539377,
0.41210389137268066,
0.7373479008674622,
0.8966312408447266,
-0.24293842911720276,
0.5015665292739868,
-0.0736161321401596,
-0.3950693607330322,
-0.4119279384613037,
-0.6060136556625366,
-0.9165967106819153,
-0.7460951805114746,
-0.4622820317745209,
-0.17063549160957336,
0.023087922483682632,
1.1273456811904907,
0.7039065361022949,
-0.6439148783683777,
-0.833895742893219,
-0.09585519134998322,
0.10491921007633209,
-0.4818238317966461,
-0.2311309427022934,
-0.01624397374689579,
-0.8774377703666687,
-1.16653311252594,
0.7347171902656555,
0.7337631583213806,
-0.18947525322437286,
-0.2655746042728424,
-0.12383552640676498,
-0.059155531227588654,
0.32736650109291077,
1.0913840532302856,
0.1940852403640747,
-0.7659735679626465,
-0.1218382865190506,
0.02964867278933525,
-0.23729507625102997,
0.09973129630088806,
0.8700885772705078,
-0.6625561714172363,
0.3877522945404053,
0.4244360625743866,
0.7867100238800049,
0.4685496687889099,
-0.2775164246559143,
0.8462960124015808,
-0.48482784628868103,
0.13989755511283875,
0.24450184404850006,
0.2174316793680191,
0.15244160592556,
-0.25277143716812134,
0.34710222482681274,
0.04042576998472214,
-0.6350375413894653,
-0.475119948387146,
0.722671627998352,
-1.1990700960159302,
-0.3121911585330963,
0.9888523817062378,
-0.19923369586467743,
-0.09020890295505524,
-0.5781604647636414,
-0.3262071907520294,
0.09304123371839523,
-0.4690793752670288,
0.40192413330078125,
0.4106135666370392,
-0.41132450103759766,
0.1724042445421219,
-0.784164309501648,
0.46583226323127747,
0.32205966114997864,
-0.8638904094696045,
0.14043618738651276,
0.36095529794692993,
0.10817208886146545,
0.22457799315452576,
0.9323862195014954,
-0.022771265357732773,
0.07781225442886353,
-0.21597199141979218,
0.02580871433019638,
0.3515482246875763,
-0.34958699345588684,
-0.025760071352124214,
-0.020409485325217247,
-0.07733070850372314,
-0.0151900053024292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12233v1 | Empirical Study on Updating Key-Value Memories in Transformer Feed-forward Layers | 2024-02-19T15:42:54 | 2024-02-19T15:42:54 | Zihan Qiu, Zeyu Huang, Youcheng Huang, Jie Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The feed-forward networks (FFNs) in transformers are recognized as a group of
key-value neural memories to restore abstract high-level knowledge. In this
work, we conduct an empirical ablation study on updating keys (the 1st layer in
the FFNs layer) or values (the 2nd layer in the FFNs layer). We compare those
two methods in various knowledge editing and fine-tuning tasks of large
language models to draw insights to understand FFNs further. Code is available
at $\href{https://github.com/qiuzh20/Tuning-keys-v.s.-values}{this\,repo}$. | [
-0.2313508838415146,
-0.6419054269790649,
0.2723982632160187,
0.09292556345462799,
0.1002284362912178,
0.016385026276111603,
-0.2682833969593048,
-0.29818975925445557,
-0.25623902678489685,
0.859023928642273,
-0.5968589186668396,
-0.06702741980552673,
-0.3871319591999054,
-0.04635487124323845,
-0.6524415612220764,
0.9795835614204407,
0.15685446560382843,
-0.046454884111881256,
-0.04246518760919571,
-0.13488943874835968,
-0.3596142828464508,
-0.2141508311033249,
-1.2000563144683838,
-0.5650730133056641,
0.5934938788414001,
0.23627117276191711,
0.9822595119476318,
0.9907886981964111,
0.7555301189422607,
0.40140771865844727,
-0.5490618348121643,
-0.174868643283844,
-0.428324818611145,
0.24021539092063904,
-0.42551189661026,
-0.41870927810668945,
-0.293699711561203,
-0.1783341020345688,
0.6555412411689758,
0.7589040398597717,
0.09677321463823318,
0.055263809859752655,
-0.1016424372792244,
0.9936546683311462,
-0.5081320405006409,
0.18939359486103058,
-0.7357928156852722,
0.14133290946483612,
-0.004862270783632994,
-0.23355340957641602,
-0.6116030812263489,
-0.387054979801178,
0.2867089509963989,
-0.430406391620636,
0.5095117092132568,
-0.07367412745952606,
0.9713274836540222,
0.5214601159095764,
-0.2874152958393097,
-0.20095330476760864,
-1.008748173713684,
0.5891269445419312,
-0.5723227858543396,
0.6973502039909363,
0.23964978754520416,
0.19334518909454346,
0.061382751911878586,
-0.8739747405052185,
-0.5242937803268433,
0.14210925996303558,
-0.3260771930217743,
0.07097680866718292,
-0.13748688995838165,
0.11080798506736755,
0.471600204706192,
0.7314872145652771,
-0.007927479222416878,
0.058412227779626846,
-0.7927013635635376,
-0.12943634390830994,
0.4746699333190918,
0.13119341433048248,
0.10322058945894241,
0.08353716135025024,
-0.23768994212150574,
-0.5605856776237488,
-0.7803377509117126,
0.17454646527767181,
0.30165931582450867,
0.24260810017585754,
0.10593394935131073,
0.422375351190567,
-0.3034886121749878,
0.7046982049942017,
0.29639071226119995,
0.08386565744876862,
0.38372698426246643,
-0.44011566042900085,
-0.5356319546699524,
0.02709139697253704,
0.5756692886352539,
0.31969380378723145,
0.3407868444919586,
-0.6101765632629395,
-0.3395412266254425,
-0.2837006151676178,
0.5804586410522461,
-0.730379045009613,
-0.42866572737693787,
-0.07077239453792572,
-0.6498345732688904,
-0.749323308467865,
-0.102425716817379,
-0.4978169798851013,
-0.35727477073669434,
-0.2597685158252716,
0.7242639660835266,
-0.5582188367843628,
-0.294196218252182,
0.03830360621213913,
-0.5409970283508301,
0.5452479124069214,
0.26527974009513855,
-1.1995441913604736,
0.22270315885543823,
0.7747158408164978,
0.6191004514694214,
0.2643653154373169,
-0.5372899770736694,
0.011704204604029655,
-0.20717386901378632,
-0.23889896273612976,
0.8214763402938843,
-0.4045640528202057,
-0.2712704837322235,
-0.1831122785806656,
0.13519792258739471,
-0.07051751762628555,
-0.7292420268058777,
0.48332688212394714,
-1.2422813177108765,
0.0026998003013432026,
-0.7147927284240723,
-0.5521669387817383,
-0.2530441880226135,
0.023074913769960403,
-0.8928559422492981,
1.050685167312622,
0.3957758843898773,
-0.379157692193985,
0.3636377155780792,
-0.5940120220184326,
-0.543298065662384,
-0.32562804222106934,
0.23365935683250427,
-0.4107140302658081,
0.28331267833709717,
0.02162150666117668,
0.40139517188072205,
-0.15335848927497864,
0.0801888033747673,
0.04381650686264038,
-0.1526196002960205,
0.6746575832366943,
-0.613632082939148,
0.7053417563438416,
0.2579643726348877,
-0.15407267212867737,
0.16452619433403015,
-0.7321229577064514,
-0.21732968091964722,
0.04150864854454994,
-0.14786551892757416,
-0.22211414575576782,
0.0882500410079956,
-0.42903465032577515,
0.5424498319625854,
-0.09199085086584091,
-0.530977725982666,
0.16083437204360962,
-0.5903338193893433,
0.7028377652168274,
0.90743488073349,
0.3799663484096527,
0.6735199093818665,
-0.53855299949646,
0.12677815556526184,
0.38128000497817993,
0.1623552292585373,
-0.7431169152259827,
-0.39193207025527954,
-0.8648453950881958,
0.40509283542633057,
0.5333303213119507,
0.3914165794849396,
-0.55588299036026,
0.27885133028030396,
-0.21910643577575684,
-0.4367663264274597,
-0.7498093247413635,
0.015024441294372082,
0.2290421426296234,
0.937675952911377,
0.5454291105270386,
0.08972372859716415,
-0.2194814831018448,
-1.0348531007766724,
-0.22158128023147583,
-0.07527945190668106,
-0.24554035067558289,
0.3115697503089905,
0.4497474431991577,
-0.10916715860366821,
0.8673391342163086,
-0.47256335616111755,
-0.3099871277809143,
0.28163793683052063,
0.060184743255376816,
0.0966816395521164,
0.5207217931747437,
0.3872673809528351,
-0.720720648765564,
-0.3915143609046936,
0.1970309317111969,
-0.5152762532234192,
-0.0024312559980899096,
-0.45436355471611023,
-0.18926988542079926,
0.02740967646241188,
0.5375840663909912,
-0.34725573658943176,
0.22133812308311462,
0.4093872308731079,
-0.3755415976047516,
0.2594474256038666,
-0.09312812238931656,
0.45246678590774536,
-0.8760483860969543,
0.03698918968439102,
-0.16857104003429413,
-0.013805410824716091,
-0.8214407563209534,
0.04035764932632446,
0.24332541227340698,
0.03717045858502388,
-0.549595057964325,
0.46216028928756714,
-0.22635799646377563,
-0.1919737160205841,
-0.3537682890892029,
-0.16174469888210297,
0.2170208990573883,
0.6955341696739197,
0.013194392435252666,
0.9966869354248047,
0.461168110370636,
-0.542971670627594,
0.39823466539382935,
0.33606624603271484,
-0.316582053899765,
0.2594299614429474,
-0.7028016448020935,
0.16703824698925018,
-0.17613762617111206,
-0.15441545844078064,
-1.066272258758545,
-0.00617592828348279,
0.16594365239143372,
-0.46551990509033203,
0.296123743057251,
-0.058175522834062576,
-0.23472566902637482,
-0.0857761949300766,
-0.12391681969165802,
0.2828095257282257,
0.6322557926177979,
-0.6157853603363037,
0.6548646688461304,
0.3119068145751953,
-0.07065749168395996,
-0.6348094940185547,
-0.7340776324272156,
-0.19940151274204254,
0.13872356712818146,
-0.8624036908149719,
0.5745792984962463,
0.1835545301437378,
-0.33492255210876465,
0.3509667217731476,
-0.210880309343338,
-0.02367917262017727,
0.19775432348251343,
0.10994268953800201,
-0.02959500625729561,
-0.5436640381813049,
0.22329218685626984,
0.4257839620113373,
-0.2667142152786255,
0.28367891907691956,
-0.270082026720047,
0.40569210052490234,
-0.3631925880908966,
-0.16965320706367493,
-0.17733098566532135,
0.06499527394771576,
0.6202138066291809,
-0.22790363430976868,
1.006286382675171,
0.40830153226852417,
-0.4414212703704834,
-0.22403694689273834,
-0.6536921262741089,
-0.4123128056526184,
-0.593069851398468,
0.15258726477622986,
-0.3753975033760071,
-0.9493025541305542,
0.879174530506134,
-0.2291700839996338,
0.0975189357995987,
0.8490298390388489,
0.5332995057106018,
-0.2711021304130554,
0.7086847424507141,
0.34837910532951355,
-0.1428014487028122,
0.3712952435016632,
-0.406249463558197,
0.05278001353144646,
-1.044811725616455,
-0.24899370968341827,
-0.6541150212287903,
-0.6015564799308777,
-0.1315452605485916,
-0.2661516070365906,
0.10330430418252945,
0.24488678574562073,
-0.25819772481918335,
0.3181338906288147,
-0.5128676295280457,
0.7583780288696289,
0.40528610348701477,
0.23283147811889648,
0.20456171035766602,
-0.25433987379074097,
-0.06963507831096649,
0.18563629686832428,
-0.4240216016769409,
-0.1004607155919075,
0.9644144773483276,
0.5395432114601135,
0.6793777942657471,
-0.2071642130613327,
0.2138012796640396,
0.2943383753299713,
0.3264366686344147,
-0.8332617282867432,
0.32503625750541687,
-0.1309470236301422,
-0.7881816029548645,
-0.6074362397193909,
-0.34310677647590637,
-0.630958080291748,
0.2062440663576126,
-0.26639869809150696,
-0.4236908555030823,
0.3133527338504791,
0.39902356266975403,
-0.5342455506324768,
0.6105591654777527,
-0.6207572221755981,
0.8571997284889221,
-0.1330500692129135,
-0.2401564121246338,
-0.11901678889989853,
-0.7793676853179932,
0.1211991161108017,
-0.007690247148275375,
-0.10919906198978424,
0.3604506850242615,
0.21524636447429657,
0.7454601526260376,
-0.2540333569049835,
0.6591955423355103,
-0.1113167256116867,
-0.2343180626630783,
0.17710591852664948,
-0.1664842814207077,
0.5095489025115967,
-0.03963169455528259,
-0.332374632358551,
0.20230165123939514,
-0.314507395029068,
0.00024038930132519454,
-0.8317452073097229,
0.575576663017273,
-0.952582836151123,
-0.4216579496860504,
-0.2203770875930786,
-0.4239770770072937,
-0.024915972724556923,
0.30663251876831055,
0.22402143478393555,
0.5686936974525452,
-0.07628582417964935,
0.5959613919258118,
1.1506754159927368,
-0.2783434987068176,
0.33404964208602905,
0.38531529903411865,
-0.08239641785621643,
-0.21085253357887268,
0.6122907996177673,
0.21653394401073456,
0.34005656838417053,
0.7490904331207275,
0.2599670886993408,
-0.13260987401008606,
-0.6823017001152039,
-0.5088998079299927,
0.085474893450737,
-0.7453973889350891,
-0.41170525550842285,
-0.8685318231582642,
-0.7688319683074951,
-0.4100872874259949,
-0.3635941743850708,
-0.6673249006271362,
-0.46813979744911194,
-0.1999720185995102,
-0.2556731700897217,
0.6454004645347595,
0.6281425952911377,
-0.0012301316019147635,
0.6686773300170898,
-1.0061768293380737,
0.43639466166496277,
0.3155357241630554,
0.8021456599235535,
0.2822551429271698,
-0.6329329013824463,
-0.6863109469413757,
0.30919334292411804,
-0.2329409420490265,
-0.9694640636444092,
0.16026562452316284,
0.12867605686187744,
0.4926186203956604,
0.43906232714653015,
-0.19229228794574738,
0.5652512907981873,
-0.512844443321228,
0.7666978240013123,
-0.3358358144760132,
-1.1209657192230225,
0.43590304255485535,
-0.23711542785167694,
0.4117797315120697,
0.7554398775100708,
0.06277937442064285,
-0.8946038484573364,
-0.16807404160499573,
-0.5397177934646606,
-0.7183220386505127,
1.0474514961242676,
0.13957975804805756,
0.1583510786294937,
0.21216481924057007,
0.7689160108566284,
-0.03560807555913925,
0.16290684044361115,
-0.40856847167015076,
-0.5253804922103882,
-0.32707563042640686,
-0.044709112495183945,
0.01964130811393261,
-0.14470013976097107,
-0.0014289610553532839,
-0.4705577790737152,
0.7098278403282166,
0.07918785512447357,
0.7048880457878113,
0.022748654708266258,
-0.32153818011283875,
-0.40015774965286255,
0.2609602212905884,
0.8374529480934143,
0.45291006565093994,
-0.3532162308692932,
-0.047792356461286545,
0.4010367691516876,
-0.5253472924232483,
0.08411486446857452,
-0.25264495611190796,
-0.3707754909992218,
-0.38738933205604553,
0.28425538539886475,
1.3672791719436646,
0.45995885133743286,
-0.06345170736312866,
0.38144370913505554,
-0.11606115102767944,
-0.582334578037262,
-0.29023370146751404,
0.30026891827583313,
0.23789866268634796,
0.35610395669937134,
0.388350248336792,
0.8124647736549377,
0.05723490193486214,
-0.4619198441505432,
0.3462161421775818,
0.19146983325481415,
-0.5150614380836487,
-0.5758875012397766,
0.6131910681724548,
0.08293114602565765,
-0.5307005643844604,
0.9995800256729126,
0.14104624092578888,
-0.6301419734954834,
0.5594943165779114,
0.5819632411003113,
0.9927645325660706,
-0.2835986316204071,
0.16922661662101746,
0.254080206155777,
0.5598491430282593,
-0.1031196117401123,
0.05696119740605354,
-0.16288958489894867,
-1.2034751176834106,
-0.6322267651557922,
-0.5591341853141785,
-0.49516624212265015,
0.23668915033340454,
-0.7167143225669861,
0.14078009128570557,
-0.23753111064434052,
0.04808361083269119,
0.3270445168018341,
-0.23638640344142914,
-0.7786774635314941,
0.3808886706829071,
-0.10850026458501816,
1.120547890663147,
-0.9635207056999207,
1.0536364316940308,
0.5681038498878479,
-0.15425001084804535,
-0.9397656321525574,
-0.19313344359397888,
-0.13785919547080994,
-0.6795102953910828,
0.6804848909378052,
-0.22910231351852417,
0.015091423876583576,
0.2154601663351059,
-0.13241910934448242,
-1.0670443773269653,
1.2210577726364136,
-0.02748899534344673,
-0.3103548586368561,
-0.3230765759944916,
0.47540539503097534,
0.7317847013473511,
-0.0889388844370842,
0.286689817905426,
0.7401782870292664,
0.6652791500091553,
0.1345590204000473,
-0.49009159207344055,
-0.10494942963123322,
-0.4567410349845886,
-0.042627930641174316,
0.5860932469367981,
-0.7067188024520874,
1.0196468830108643,
0.027628712356090546,
-0.16544519364833832,
-0.37273159623146057,
0.7655462026596069,
-0.41883522272109985,
-0.024669775739312172,
0.6018087267875671,
0.671329140663147,
0.5159679651260376,
-0.36577335000038147,
0.6904994249343872,
-0.5663324594497681,
0.187481090426445,
0.8223856687545776,
-0.2749130427837372,
0.5694782137870789,
0.4171200096607208,
-0.05783761292695999,
0.2866557240486145,
0.20541420578956604,
-0.3226807415485382,
0.7248888611793518,
-0.10039528459310532,
0.06827760487794876,
0.17110861837863922,
0.4407510459423065,
-0.42725419998168945,
0.3910680413246155,
0.4455382525920868,
-0.7936109304428101,
-0.03213771432638168,
0.20789161324501038,
0.12965048849582672,
-0.26589980721473694,
-0.2385794222354889,
1.1167351007461548,
-0.0383206270635128,
-0.7613036036491394,
0.22897425293922424,
0.17922775447368622,
0.485149085521698,
-0.4619966447353363,
0.1271790713071823,
-0.2057778537273407,
0.4213516116142273,
-0.11420600116252899,
-1.0376776456832886,
0.8478150367736816,
-0.15561412274837494,
-0.44528207182884216,
-0.6000892519950867,
1.0868406295776367,
-0.3621293902397156,
-0.34079238772392273,
0.20693771541118622,
0.28757408261299133,
-0.466791033744812,
-0.04289252683520317,
-0.5737847685813904,
0.07206479460000992,
-0.07372891902923584,
-0.6302471160888672,
0.3052135705947876,
0.3654906451702118,
0.2962692975997925,
0.4149269461631775,
0.6181883215904236,
0.1303614377975464,
0.19877031445503235,
0.08623465150594711,
1.0078498125076294,
-0.8413774371147156,
-0.30429792404174805,
-0.8575307130813599,
0.7300136685371399,
0.004765696357935667,
-0.5179120302200317,
0.6496103405952454,
0.5403149127960205,
1.1889898777008057,
-0.2963601052761078,
0.6298233270645142,
0.20579220354557037,
0.43220311403274536,
-0.6269779801368713,
0.9962912201881409,
-0.23851698637008667,
0.285368412733078,
-0.31409159302711487,
-0.8091037273406982,
-0.2734679877758026,
0.6231318712234497,
-0.08420605212450027,
-0.1953376680612564,
0.6156539916992188,
0.9306720495223999,
0.017980175092816353,
0.5127178430557251,
0.19295653700828552,
0.4279557168483734,
0.19128721952438354,
0.1822812408208847,
0.89731764793396,
-0.9096693992614746,
0.2895714044570923,
-0.9704767465591431,
-0.04402526840567589,
0.05237305164337158,
-0.6791849732398987,
-0.5870108604431152,
-0.7812997102737427,
-0.3069743514060974,
-0.3163672387599945,
0.046788740903139114,
0.6105955839157104,
0.4155831038951874,
-0.889354944229126,
-0.11846135556697845,
-0.013556808233261108,
0.17620255053043365,
-0.7512902617454529,
-0.23427753150463104,
0.2756570875644684,
-0.36000120639801025,
-0.2950213849544525,
0.3425137996673584,
0.25427520275115967,
-0.23853617906570435,
-0.1516929268836975,
0.04839292913675308,
-0.04015873745083809,
0.277691513299942,
0.6782823204994202,
0.15066219866275787,
-0.2912370264530182,
-0.5600793361663818,
0.6528998017311096,
-0.030917678028345108,
0.1987462043762207,
0.9771840572357178,
-0.8873030543327332,
0.20293308794498444,
0.9289559721946716,
0.77534019947052,
0.473951131105423,
-0.06308688968420029,
0.511911153793335,
-0.8008699417114258,
-0.14267531037330627,
0.05744378641247749,
0.3423786759376526,
0.11518647521734238,
-0.4838135540485382,
0.2991611659526825,
0.028716973960399628,
-0.9277299046516418,
-0.7194519639015198,
0.03928894177079201,
-1.0202380418777466,
-0.13456688821315765,
0.8775200247764587,
0.0031088530085980892,
-0.3749336898326874,
0.01864074356853962,
-0.11238094419240952,
0.4894349277019501,
-0.13980735838413239,
0.707432210445404,
0.6283648610115051,
0.10355885326862335,
-0.37662917375564575,
-0.1585121601819992,
0.8104835152626038,
0.13896511495113373,
-0.4894300103187561,
0.14270921051502228,
0.22763408720493317,
0.08723068982362747,
0.29326191544532776,
0.47381699085235596,
-0.22491128742694855,
0.2720305323600769,
0.03908952698111534,
-0.20210319757461548,
-0.397315114736557,
-0.4964364469051361,
-0.5745992064476013,
0.2500072121620178,
-0.14197015762329102,
0.13035684823989868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12226v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12226v3 | AnyGPT: Unified Multimodal LLM with Discrete Sequence Modeling | 2024-02-19T15:33:10 | 2024-03-07T06:31:46 | Jun Zhan, Junqi Dai, Jiasheng Ye, Yunhua Zhou, Dong Zhang, Zhigeng Liu, Xin Zhang, Ruibin Yuan, Ge Zhang, Linyang Li, Hang Yan, Jie Fu, Tao Gui, Tianxiang Sun, Yugang Jiang, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | We introduce AnyGPT, an any-to-any multimodal language model that utilizes
discrete representations for the unified processing of various modalities,
including speech, text, images, and music. AnyGPT can be trained stably without
any alterations to the current large language model (LLM) architecture or
training paradigms. Instead, it relies exclusively on data-level preprocessing,
facilitating the seamless integration of new modalities into LLMs, akin to the
incorporation of new languages. We build a multimodal text-centric dataset for
multimodal alignment pre-training. Utilizing generative models, we synthesize
the first large-scale any-to-any multimodal instruction dataset. It consists of
108k samples of multi-turn conversations that intricately interweave various
modalities, thus equipping the model to handle arbitrary combinations of
multimodal inputs and outputs. Experimental results demonstrate that AnyGPT is
capable of facilitating any-to-any multimodal conversation while achieving
performance comparable to specialized models across all modalities, proving
that discrete representations can effectively and conveniently unify multiple
modalities within a language model. Demos are shown in
https://junzhan2000.github.io/AnyGPT.github.io/ | [
-0.18556401133537292,
-0.8190914988517761,
0.675123929977417,
0.058443404734134674,
-0.21228718757629395,
-0.21333163976669312,
-0.2927623689174652,
-0.10196717828512192,
0.02511187270283699,
0.4481240510940552,
-0.7527023553848267,
-0.7119714021682739,
-0.24122865498065948,
-0.17181654274463654,
-0.6011592745780945,
1.1240803003311157,
0.18344679474830627,
0.30163663625717163,
-0.058643799275159836,
-0.01215438824146986,
-0.39189934730529785,
-0.534636914730072,
-0.5065643787384033,
-0.2503853440284729,
0.5978097319602966,
0.32915547490119934,
0.6743349432945251,
0.9119206070899963,
0.2280270755290985,
0.32956403493881226,
0.3692082464694977,
-0.12183010578155518,
-0.3145380914211273,
0.21363629400730133,
-0.04399116337299347,
-0.13367630541324615,
-0.5821052193641663,
-0.07457294315099716,
0.9413376450538635,
0.57224440574646,
-0.36909061670303345,
0.04119656980037689,
-0.3930554986000061,
0.3002597391605377,
-0.43068793416023254,
0.1167900338768959,
-0.5899882316589355,
0.15604057908058167,
-0.4450986087322235,
-0.13039004802703857,
-0.5251765847206116,
-0.24408787488937378,
0.15430836379528046,
-0.4599015414714813,
-0.08185942471027374,
-0.15114031732082367,
0.3160676062107086,
0.21870891749858856,
-0.6902047395706177,
0.03130413964390755,
-0.6324425935745239,
0.5154920220375061,
-0.49993056058883667,
0.8023591637611389,
-0.04509466513991356,
0.1830107718706131,
0.04481188580393791,
-0.9475307464599609,
-0.8266322612762451,
-0.28986939787864685,
0.17081671953201294,
0.1916516274213791,
0.07853581756353378,
0.3769317865371704,
0.13038991391658783,
0.2945159077644348,
-1.0519014596939087,
0.012163308449089527,
0.042833734303712845,
0.07551786303520203,
0.357418030500412,
0.2558991611003876,
0.5297826528549194,
-0.295293390750885,
-0.6692131757736206,
-0.24079781770706177,
-0.607960045337677,
-0.07073353976011276,
-0.054800428450107574,
0.2574548125267029,
-0.30796003341674805,
0.6980881690979004,
0.19066664576530457,
0.9073044657707214,
-0.19118966162204742,
-0.34201180934906006,
-0.12559065222740173,
-0.41652581095695496,
-0.4629982113838196,
0.04092518612742424,
1.080553412437439,
-0.16871406137943268,
0.16475000977516174,
-0.19777034223079681,
-0.06647367030382156,
0.24136890470981598,
0.34985992312431335,
-0.650653600692749,
-0.5630163550376892,
-0.18702316284179688,
-0.3130890130996704,
-0.06648893654346466,
0.10807932913303375,
-0.6910480856895447,
-0.3305160701274872,
-0.3486955761909485,
0.35175296664237976,
-0.61330246925354,
-0.22971785068511963,
0.16752062737941742,
0.34624940156936646,
0.25950396060943604,
0.21980249881744385,
-1.1048558950424194,
0.07156287878751755,
0.3750373125076294,
0.447860449552536,
-0.16755452752113342,
-0.5888081192970276,
-0.11474967002868652,
0.2540585398674011,
-0.22686512768268585,
0.9857650995254517,
-0.8388384580612183,
-0.5012123584747314,
-0.04124728590250015,
-0.2654849588871002,
-0.5473363995552063,
0.14656388759613037,
0.537653386592865,
-0.4831576645374298,
0.20476941764354706,
0.05489885061979294,
-0.47522157430648804,
-0.25449037551879883,
0.2653469741344452,
-0.5234130024909973,
0.6243585348129272,
-0.07919321209192276,
-0.544452965259552,
-0.07035359740257263,
-1.033420443534851,
-0.3387954831123352,
-0.06611669808626175,
-0.7135015726089478,
-0.28926488757133484,
-0.036578238010406494,
0.15210218727588654,
0.3268890082836151,
-0.4448428750038147,
0.15899839997291565,
-0.2888699769973755,
-0.03259529173374176,
0.4242565631866455,
-1.0462294816970825,
0.44180455803871155,
0.1197376698255539,
-0.0979403629899025,
0.2991178333759308,
-0.8171544671058655,
0.16031195223331451,
0.006979730911552906,
-0.4401092529296875,
0.27055951952934265,
-0.07997287809848785,
0.5742949843406677,
0.39310866594314575,
0.18827782571315765,
-0.6421935558319092,
0.610511064529419,
0.3138686716556549,
0.5871360898017883,
0.9180415272712708,
-0.25224849581718445,
0.7319573760032654,
-0.39486372470855713,
0.5904941558837891,
-0.30858689546585083,
0.278758704662323,
-0.9080785512924194,
-0.4732549488544464,
-0.6255578398704529,
-0.5817586183547974,
0.6343218088150024,
0.6347558498382568,
-0.8518146276473999,
0.14145641028881073,
-0.7822352647781372,
-0.14298087358474731,
-0.418517529964447,
-0.05698380246758461,
0.44342896342277527,
0.36511117219924927,
0.0013219427783042192,
-0.6458507776260376,
-0.6936460733413696,
-0.5216215252876282,
0.28778207302093506,
-0.17812134325504303,
0.0742516741156578,
0.0004439829208422452,
0.23506727814674377,
-0.27852505445480347,
1.0861774682998657,
-0.21112319827079773,
-0.23285025358200073,
-0.14783194661140442,
0.33944928646087646,
-0.17028355598449707,
0.57551109790802,
0.20105156302452087,
-0.962323784828186,
-0.4917677044868469,
0.039737164974212646,
-0.7778140902519226,
0.1458176225423813,
-0.2856921851634979,
0.013012846931815147,
0.24805128574371338,
0.396765798330307,
-0.8927050232887268,
0.23218004405498505,
0.8536863327026367,
-0.2512425184249878,
0.4808971583843231,
-0.06777527183294296,
0.28883618116378784,
-1.1992154121398926,
0.05371250584721565,
-0.36325520277023315,
-0.4047378897666931,
-0.7400192618370056,
-0.13920240104198456,
0.0838257446885109,
-0.5189392566680908,
-0.5743032693862915,
0.37102222442626953,
-0.3172125220298767,
-0.15924616158008575,
0.13312825560569763,
0.1691965013742447,
-0.16473929584026337,
0.580542266368866,
0.1786796748638153,
0.8110345005989075,
0.7453395128250122,
-0.19774721562862396,
0.5211779475212097,
0.4228770136833191,
-0.40116187930107117,
0.7131581902503967,
-0.325052410364151,
0.4122808873653412,
-0.14534087479114532,
0.43702858686447144,
-1.2380338907241821,
-0.42777371406555176,
0.1083744540810585,
-0.5344065427780151,
0.4660378098487854,
-0.2186635136604309,
-0.5573382377624512,
0.09538783133029938,
-0.17073281109333038,
0.5693375468254089,
0.3367919325828552,
-0.5856242775917053,
0.9265516400337219,
0.06336919963359833,
-0.3233341574668884,
-0.3911908268928528,
-0.605475127696991,
0.08247993886470795,
0.04245562106370926,
-0.7834151387214661,
0.3833082616329193,
-0.3422633409500122,
0.39613601565361023,
0.06686999648809433,
-0.23293718695640564,
-0.230143204331398,
-0.4934535622596741,
0.3199314773082733,
0.3891723155975342,
-0.22453604638576508,
0.2640792429447174,
-0.31369030475616455,
-0.23338879644870758,
-0.25573286414146423,
-0.5254879593849182,
0.7606911063194275,
-0.1304096132516861,
-0.7568233013153076,
-0.4183136820793152,
0.3983577489852905,
0.6877962350845337,
-0.3743392825126648,
0.1601143181324005,
0.7923195362091064,
0.08707073330879211,
0.03835355117917061,
-0.5760745406150818,
0.03801233693957329,
-0.4580552577972412,
0.44005683064460754,
-0.47248053550720215,
-1.1249101161956787,
0.23668107390403748,
0.047408170998096466,
-0.07513967156410217,
-0.07622824609279633,
0.40393751859664917,
-0.023243216797709465,
1.396842122077942,
0.7586414217948914,
-0.22182564437389374,
0.880065381526947,
-0.07706861943006516,
0.2754136323928833,
-0.5802193880081177,
-0.22459524869918823,
-0.12026054412126541,
-0.18511901795864105,
-0.6606709361076355,
-0.4926101267337799,
0.47574108839035034,
-0.14821018278598785,
-0.4819895029067993,
0.3125753104686737,
-0.29561713337898254,
0.6160531640052795,
0.4566895663738251,
0.05722960829734802,
0.4086180031299591,
0.02088901586830616,
-0.09474311023950577,
-0.000010269204722135328,
-0.8989778161048889,
-0.2995617091655731,
1.1510229110717773,
0.01672566868364811,
1.1244086027145386,
0.1414347141981125,
0.4761160612106323,
0.18765133619308472,
0.40670475363731384,
-0.6690059900283813,
0.6487884521484375,
-0.25660353899002075,
-0.5431361794471741,
-0.2876461148262024,
-0.5417380928993225,
-0.7632512450218201,
0.33766818046569824,
-0.26383909583091736,
-0.7623049020767212,
-0.039889201521873474,
-0.08947791904211044,
-0.3997232913970947,
0.5811797976493835,
-0.5818380117416382,
1.1835402250289917,
-0.34184351563453674,
0.09577781707048416,
0.25862228870391846,
-0.735888659954071,
0.45739102363586426,
0.0034276749938726425,
0.04830748960375786,
-0.0223713181912899,
-0.014627465046942234,
0.339282363653183,
0.11028426140546799,
0.9528347253799438,
0.45930638909339905,
-0.30551666021347046,
0.053022727370262146,
0.22835402190685272,
0.30336374044418335,
0.20912012457847595,
0.21981552243232727,
-0.020429959520697594,
0.01088313665241003,
-0.40796083211898804,
-0.6913750171661377,
0.7532687187194824,
-0.6399409770965576,
-0.20032626390457153,
-0.3474818766117096,
-0.8566853404045105,
-0.08394955843687057,
0.2066497802734375,
0.2826407551765442,
0.6870812773704529,
-0.33600980043411255,
0.07938654720783234,
0.8222407698631287,
0.019512897357344627,
0.5733532905578613,
0.7514153718948364,
-0.2334301620721817,
-0.5813443660736084,
1.0700007677078247,
-0.18021610379219055,
0.16080711781978607,
0.7086909413337708,
-0.17827413976192474,
-0.49436914920806885,
-0.1896539181470871,
-0.6571930646896362,
0.06044112518429756,
-0.8228755593299866,
-0.2123710811138153,
-0.5426036715507507,
-0.12103313207626343,
-0.5287691354751587,
-0.06411178410053253,
-0.6780800223350525,
-0.4948694705963135,
-0.022114384919404984,
0.06875588744878769,
0.23835529386997223,
0.7686610817909241,
-0.15079765021800995,
0.4659774601459503,
-0.9251397252082825,
0.3059113919734955,
0.8539558053016663,
0.3293907046318054,
-0.30066317319869995,
-0.5174152851104736,
0.1676701307296753,
0.06097474321722984,
-0.6830341815948486,
-0.7869225740432739,
0.255479097366333,
0.3638365566730499,
0.2643110156059265,
0.702828049659729,
-0.3488595485687256,
0.7565158605575562,
-0.7843917608261108,
0.9682592153549194,
0.5190302133560181,
-1.103170394897461,
0.21869142353534698,
-0.5971831679344177,
0.3696531653404236,
0.2498677521944046,
0.41567933559417725,
-0.9001977443695068,
0.244672030210495,
-0.4987381398677826,
-0.507659375667572,
0.7429242134094238,
0.03861692175269127,
0.22018298506736755,
-0.07390640676021576,
0.032919421792030334,
-0.1184624508023262,
0.3319121301174164,
-1.028773307800293,
-0.342342346906662,
-0.32474949955940247,
-0.2126457244157791,
-0.22341673076152802,
-0.10356973111629486,
-0.047614142298698425,
-0.23609744012355804,
0.2139187902212143,
0.035259559750556946,
0.6491326093673706,
-0.16770149767398834,
-0.19607138633728027,
0.006663828622549772,
0.619495153427124,
0.8201547265052795,
0.6522208452224731,
-0.14897529780864716,
0.31324976682662964,
-0.06338623911142349,
-0.22492660582065582,
0.26753440499305725,
0.21391773223876953,
0.02750615030527115,
-0.01643112115561962,
0.25062212347984314,
0.9063987135887146,
0.5200162529945374,
-0.6882753372192383,
0.5540290474891663,
-0.061119336634874344,
-0.17075730860233307,
-0.22817209362983704,
-0.26288527250289917,
-0.17704255878925323,
0.2931422293186188,
-0.019679924473166466,
0.1636059284210205,
-0.004914079327136278,
-0.6516832709312439,
0.3480432331562042,
0.22624963521957397,
-0.5164413452148438,
-0.5658658146858215,
0.7438401579856873,
-0.018598899245262146,
-0.1368464082479477,
0.8134337663650513,
-0.12331858277320862,
-0.44413962960243225,
0.10745541006326675,
0.6402897834777832,
0.8510302901268005,
-0.5631886124610901,
0.4567992091178894,
-0.0999285951256752,
0.15705740451812744,
-0.052889250218868256,
0.21073298156261444,
-0.285601943731308,
-0.866072416305542,
-0.761650800704956,
-0.5150976777076721,
-0.4770755171775818,
0.19087094068527222,
-0.4190177321434021,
-0.09903447329998016,
-0.2066073715686798,
0.0056511759757995605,
-0.12433911114931107,
-0.6565426588058472,
-0.39981701970100403,
0.1356719434261322,
0.3880978524684906,
0.5578995943069458,
-0.8711100816726685,
1.2071453332901,
1.023943305015564,
-0.6122109889984131,
-0.6597385406494141,
-0.22120997309684753,
0.1969483345746994,
-0.8198485374450684,
0.5981875658035278,
-0.10981273651123047,
0.07635795325040817,
0.2328425645828247,
-0.5326592922210693,
-0.8269773721694946,
1.0722103118896484,
0.628371000289917,
-0.24403135478496552,
-0.20510318875312805,
0.46619564294815063,
0.16146089136600494,
-0.48213642835617065,
0.267128050327301,
0.6434090733528137,
0.455249160528183,
0.28195875883102417,
-0.8622498512268066,
-0.22035002708435059,
-0.35496753454208374,
0.47205209732055664,
0.3955921232700348,
-0.3748858571052551,
1.08254873752594,
0.05750104784965515,
-0.3672233521938324,
0.3360777497291565,
0.43995022773742676,
0.06253070384263992,
-0.10267861187458038,
0.28514334559440613,
0.8451913595199585,
0.37376001477241516,
-0.22095023095607758,
1.2493542432785034,
-0.28102123737335205,
0.21883632242679596,
1.1463279724121094,
-0.13306821882724762,
0.8010705709457397,
0.34166255593299866,
-0.07260426878929138,
0.27025043964385986,
0.4849224388599396,
0.19526825845241547,
0.6230157613754272,
0.03392192721366882,
-0.8085429668426514,
-0.477462500333786,
-0.18448026478290558,
-0.40627747774124146,
0.7069838047027588,
0.20489118993282318,
-0.18037836253643036,
-0.4621116816997528,
0.2532593011856079,
-0.12007099390029907,
-0.03554912284016609,
-0.17768119275569916,
0.8205093741416931,
-0.010335247032344341,
-0.46504247188568115,
0.7230650782585144,
0.07891490310430527,
0.7913114428520203,
-0.9721252918243408,
-0.13607415556907654,
-0.25588753819465637,
-0.023603923618793488,
-0.09439674019813538,
-0.5097689032554626,
-0.06182471290230751,
-0.08752807974815369,
-0.3599499464035034,
-0.5332656502723694,
0.46224507689476013,
-0.9488139748573303,
-0.18899637460708618,
-0.026886552572250366,
0.3230418562889099,
0.05862199142575264,
-0.22665709257125854,
-0.7614187002182007,
0.20189999043941498,
0.03429573401808739,
-0.1874944567680359,
0.5711906552314758,
0.5210968852043152,
0.001185799017548561,
0.6529683470726013,
0.6938958168029785,
-0.16354511678218842,
0.31702956557273865,
0.22168618440628052,
0.9701768755912781,
-0.5089366436004639,
-0.19688282907009125,
-0.8136979341506958,
0.6314876079559326,
0.41002973914146423,
-0.21574713289737701,
0.7742570638656616,
0.3055756688117981,
1.0562938451766968,
-0.22235864400863647,
0.816937267780304,
-0.231902077794075,
-0.07472150027751923,
-0.6725601553916931,
0.5500301718711853,
-0.3414458632469177,
0.08024279028177261,
-0.22662217915058136,
-1.0897506475448608,
-0.23453828692436218,
0.83056640625,
-0.17290371656417847,
0.2695818543434143,
0.7582255005836487,
0.8399263620376587,
-0.2840624451637268,
0.3430336117744446,
0.6796197891235352,
0.08013621717691422,
0.2833687365055084,
0.5891695618629456,
0.9460280537605286,
-0.3410509526729584,
0.8481546640396118,
-0.21799780428409576,
-0.16327857971191406,
0.3081910014152527,
-0.9963608384132385,
-0.771388828754425,
-0.5563316345214844,
0.02653108909726143,
0.12157642096281052,
0.08953941613435745,
1.1054048538208008,
0.8209183216094971,
-0.5870103240013123,
-0.4537886679172516,
-0.10070188343524933,
-0.14414983987808228,
0.019064679741859436,
-0.1552646905183792,
0.2592070400714874,
-0.5001848936080933,
-0.7155801057815552,
0.6714255809783936,
0.409474641084671,
0.1412210762500763,
-0.1098114475607872,
-0.0017814282327890396,
-0.2395130693912506,
-0.0738389864563942,
0.8869431614875793,
0.4526703357696533,
-0.4994083642959595,
-0.08163920044898987,
-0.029557323083281517,
0.025809243321418762,
0.18877986073493958,
1.0281873941421509,
-0.23777414858341217,
0.7118116021156311,
0.3598603308200836,
0.7325655221939087,
0.6648500561714172,
0.004879997577518225,
0.5967974662780762,
-1.0920330286026,
0.17067936062812805,
0.08802976459264755,
0.18891160190105438,
0.3342683017253876,
0.25477784872055054,
0.3662237823009491,
0.10120794177055359,
-0.623564600944519,
-0.6095441579818726,
0.5197430849075317,
-1.1381938457489014,
-0.06607576459646225,
1.0174250602722168,
-0.18175269663333893,
0.01859782263636589,
0.07590915262699127,
-0.34762680530548096,
0.24985218048095703,
-0.46750161051750183,
0.6446291208267212,
0.35285815596580505,
-0.15805011987686157,
-0.6957964301109314,
-0.5455542206764221,
0.37912440299987793,
0.43509137630462646,
-0.7374101877212524,
-0.12437290698289871,
0.4139055609703064,
0.21412543952465057,
0.10654781758785248,
0.8883901834487915,
-0.3072964549064636,
0.38743895292282104,
-0.16061055660247803,
0.5033950805664062,
-0.17690874636173248,
-0.39248713850975037,
-0.511667788028717,
-0.0005181302549317479,
-0.19659069180488586,
-0.23060473799705505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12222v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12222v1 | CovRL: Fuzzing JavaScript Engines with Coverage-Guided Reinforcement Learning for LLM-based Mutation | 2024-02-19T15:30:40 | 2024-02-19T15:30:40 | Jueon Eom, Seyeon Jeong, Taekyoung Kwon | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SE, D.4.6; I.2.5; D.2.4 | Fuzzing is an effective bug-finding technique but it struggles with complex
systems like JavaScript engines that demand precise grammatical input.
Recently, researchers have adopted language models for context-aware mutation
in fuzzing to address this problem. However, existing techniques are limited in
utilizing coverage guidance for fuzzing, which is rather performed in a
black-box manner. This paper presents a novel technique called CovRL
(Coverage-guided Reinforcement Learning) that combines Large Language Models
(LLMs) with reinforcement learning from coverage feedback. Our fuzzer,
CovRL-Fuzz, integrates coverage feedback directly into the LLM by leveraging
the Term Frequency-Inverse Document Frequency (TF-IDF) method to construct a
weighted coverage map. This map is key in calculating the fuzzing reward, which
is then applied to the LLM-based mutator through reinforcement learning.
CovRL-Fuzz, through this approach, enables the generation of test cases that
are more likely to discover new coverage areas, thus improving vulnerability
detection while minimizing syntax and semantic errors, all without needing
extra post-processing. Our evaluation results indicate that CovRL-Fuzz
outperforms the state-of-the-art fuzzers in terms of code coverage and
bug-finding capabilities: CovRL-Fuzz identified 48 real-world security-related
bugs in the latest JavaScript engines, including 39 previously unknown
vulnerabilities and 11 CVEs. | [
-0.44949477910995483,
-1.0681272745132446,
0.14581872522830963,
0.3524000346660614,
0.16646459698677063,
0.48747360706329346,
-0.09148300439119339,
-0.005334271118044853,
0.21554724872112274,
0.48381465673446655,
-0.891671895980835,
-0.7651404142379761,
-0.21690580248832703,
-0.2431657612323761,
-0.5386245250701904,
1.0412734746932983,
-0.0013022099155932665,
-0.301482617855072,
-0.35192418098449707,
0.23308846354484558,
-0.38146406412124634,
-0.5018752217292786,
-0.36217212677001953,
-0.17646408081054688,
0.5360226035118103,
0.6279295682907104,
0.48928266763687134,
-0.009341937489807606,
0.5704001188278198,
0.26685285568237305,
0.019085807725787163,
0.26080992817878723,
-0.6886200308799744,
0.007746862713247538,
0.07375427335500717,
-0.5323805809020996,
-0.10552053153514862,
-0.49378031492233276,
0.1876857578754425,
0.28293484449386597,
-0.4661796987056732,
-0.09328554570674896,
-0.489885151386261,
0.35054469108581543,
-0.7890806794166565,
-0.02779047004878521,
-0.6344736814498901,
0.14264418184757233,
-0.013110163621604443,
-0.39745864272117615,
-0.8674249649047852,
-0.14326372742652893,
-0.24906718730926514,
-0.6807541847229004,
0.32686498761177063,
0.353285014629364,
0.6451138854026794,
0.47139567136764526,
-0.4149612486362457,
-0.07040946930646896,
-0.7132859826087952,
0.6655096411705017,
-0.38035696744918823,
0.26873779296875,
0.30510884523391724,
0.454994261264801,
-0.8164273500442505,
-0.4951488971710205,
-0.5358926653862,
-0.42479437589645386,
0.13397997617721558,
0.17876654863357544,
-0.20911309123039246,
0.02573345974087715,
0.2568482756614685,
0.23506587743759155,
-0.7729843258857727,
0.03722698241472244,
-0.23429447412490845,
-0.5414829850196838,
0.7983542680740356,
-0.026378484442830086,
0.3445814251899719,
0.23035143315792084,
-0.5888115167617798,
-0.1576794534921646,
-0.6729309558868408,
0.30228927731513977,
0.3892924189567566,
-0.17139975726604462,
-0.005162583664059639,
0.21074266731739044,
-0.27880406379699707,
0.8716965913772583,
-0.055610109120607376,
0.08615491539239883,
0.20284992456436157,
-0.09967544674873352,
-0.3425509035587311,
-0.12121419608592987,
0.4862808883190155,
-0.10059088468551636,
0.058123499155044556,
-0.3880593180656433,
-0.2770238220691681,
-0.044186532497406006,
0.5228257179260254,
-0.4952608644962311,
-0.3026502728462219,
0.2556348145008087,
0.28627386689186096,
-0.5778273344039917,
0.2663852274417877,
-0.765714168548584,
-0.26445841789245605,
0.32234737277030945,
0.4804398715496063,
-0.3491694927215576,
-0.28024718165397644,
0.3139919936656952,
-0.5648046731948853,
0.25655344128608704,
0.2669614851474762,
-0.7557753324508667,
0.22692863643169403,
0.6779810786247253,
0.6480460166931152,
-0.18057408928871155,
-0.1802579164505005,
-0.9431752562522888,
0.2289985567331314,
-0.21628057956695557,
0.7925788760185242,
-0.359536737203598,
-0.5219754576683044,
0.06505290418863297,
-0.13463738560676575,
0.09091617166996002,
-0.4005974233150482,
-0.08950340747833252,
-0.7200201749801636,
0.11110615730285645,
0.012241446413099766,
-0.45469430088996887,
-0.11115115135908127,
0.5516873002052307,
-0.7213823199272156,
1.1094987392425537,
0.31822097301483154,
-0.4652344584465027,
0.08049696683883667,
-0.6299167275428772,
-0.5754169225692749,
0.1531924307346344,
-0.027459818869829178,
-0.9725686311721802,
-0.09443448483943939,
0.20237179100513458,
0.25313690304756165,
0.05064941942691803,
0.10891932249069214,
-0.6186748743057251,
-0.7281340956687927,
0.5040369629859924,
-0.17740055918693542,
0.5347216129302979,
-0.10736511647701263,
-0.5028943419456482,
0.5361868739128113,
-0.4728035628795624,
0.07274708151817322,
0.0644763931632042,
-0.11044307798147202,
-0.1323174238204956,
-0.08733798563480377,
0.0646996945142746,
0.11469989269971848,
-0.19405597448349,
-0.47149211168289185,
0.32746216654777527,
-0.6586030721664429,
0.14385738968849182,
0.558984100818634,
0.38176801800727844,
0.28677400946617126,
-0.626297652721405,
0.8520150780677795,
-0.2119663804769516,
0.29911911487579346,
-0.3442195653915405,
-0.18319480121135712,
-0.8828860521316528,
-0.5167677998542786,
0.050742533057928085,
0.4923054873943329,
-0.881024956703186,
0.36025646328926086,
-0.1743897944688797,
-0.7015448212623596,
-0.3251776099205017,
0.008880900219082832,
0.5807578563690186,
0.1483466774225235,
0.47927263379096985,
-0.1121857762336731,
-0.364439994096756,
-0.5747852325439453,
-0.13825058937072754,
-0.06071479246020317,
0.21331076323986053,
0.2936614453792572,
0.6949620842933655,
-0.18708333373069763,
0.7708681225776672,
-0.6431079506874084,
-0.2245209515094757,
-0.24170412123203278,
0.06857918202877045,
-0.26688167452812195,
0.19819454848766327,
0.4198879599571228,
-0.7464921474456787,
-0.231876939535141,
0.05613737925887108,
-0.09967350959777832,
-0.15331821143627167,
-0.07924891263246536,
-0.06384626030921936,
0.39396148920059204,
0.6762492060661316,
0.012901048175990582,
0.5102792382240295,
0.8011132478713989,
-0.49468255043029785,
0.48264750838279724,
-0.11693935841321945,
0.133816659450531,
-0.7280478477478027,
-0.06966160237789154,
-0.3484099507331848,
-0.7229154706001282,
-0.3719450533390045,
0.5310975909233093,
0.042933110147714615,
0.10122964531183243,
-0.6491929888725281,
0.5403731465339661,
-0.24489861726760864,
0.06705425679683685,
-0.10705339163541794,
-0.23411013185977936,
0.10529791563749313,
0.7555552124977112,
-0.4454672038555145,
0.8512920141220093,
0.20426365733146667,
-0.4818084239959717,
0.7597729563713074,
-0.1705242097377777,
-0.19056816399097443,
0.2471732646226883,
-0.35970538854599,
0.22158902883529663,
0.2047048807144165,
0.4556522071361542,
-0.9625864624977112,
-0.2485974133014679,
0.15060284733772278,
-0.32927799224853516,
0.12142027169466019,
-0.2116599678993225,
-0.5301878452301025,
-0.470615953207016,
-0.3171764016151428,
0.16026759147644043,
0.6712433695793152,
-0.6011409163475037,
0.11847677081823349,
0.3497615158557892,
0.13325363397598267,
-0.4693734049797058,
-0.6001206636428833,
-0.3103892207145691,
-0.05400129035115242,
-0.765063464641571,
0.4628889262676239,
-0.3404553234577179,
-0.047738026827573776,
-0.15015633404254913,
-0.24627262353897095,
-0.27820244431495667,
0.6213281750679016,
0.39161840081214905,
-0.06720922887325287,
0.02928360551595688,
0.3004646301269531,
0.06961983442306519,
-0.02236079052090645,
0.04183939844369888,
-0.29116854071617126,
0.8320445418357849,
-0.38429081439971924,
-0.829775333404541,
-0.01945894956588745,
0.1642996072769165,
0.4209810495376587,
-0.5448622703552246,
0.27231594920158386,
0.6887200474739075,
-0.11186873912811279,
-0.8422467112541199,
-0.42458269000053406,
-0.048551056534051895,
-0.46098294854164124,
0.38232487440109253,
-0.20220528542995453,
-1.050427794456482,
0.4513978362083435,
-0.1982841193675995,
-0.28105971217155457,
0.38882550597190857,
0.6446069478988647,
-0.19468441605567932,
0.6311231255531311,
0.6103731989860535,
0.008780360221862793,
0.6885355114936829,
-0.590222179889679,
-0.125512033700943,
-0.2944251596927643,
-0.4821992516517639,
-0.27693748474121094,
-0.31115296483039856,
-0.2386748194694519,
-0.5759561061859131,
0.4760431945323944,
-0.1388418823480606,
0.055650074034929276,
0.10368236154317856,
-0.2667359709739685,
0.6500436067581177,
0.5084202289581299,
0.21017992496490479,
0.2546826899051666,
0.0297157671302557,
-0.4491073787212372,
0.4038665294647217,
-0.5810285806655884,
0.31131312251091003,
0.7414665222167969,
0.10632961243391037,
0.8697205781936646,
0.30044281482696533,
0.9344057440757751,
0.49087563157081604,
0.3228018581867218,
-0.6575316786766052,
0.32334664463996887,
0.23871301114559174,
-0.5903438925743103,
-0.4496517479419708,
-0.2938354015350342,
-0.9575880765914917,
0.24952471256256104,
-0.032693050801754,
-0.3509635627269745,
-0.24534659087657928,
0.3577997088432312,
-0.3338210880756378,
0.21859286725521088,
-0.6573485136032104,
0.8779115080833435,
-0.20312853157520294,
-0.4601059854030609,
-0.47778236865997314,
-0.33318591117858887,
0.3583770990371704,
0.07457960397005081,
0.2588593661785126,
0.038702018558979034,
0.09682268649339676,
0.2582373321056366,
-0.6739128232002258,
0.572329580783844,
-0.2476784735918045,
-0.13120236992835999,
0.17275549471378326,
0.2735792100429535,
0.6094430088996887,
0.3559907376766205,
0.01226609293371439,
-0.18745099008083344,
0.15814915299415588,
-0.5662550926208496,
-0.8354729413986206,
0.5663564801216125,
-0.3835272192955017,
-0.5910763144493103,
-0.7282877564430237,
-0.6066439151763916,
-0.08449061214923859,
0.1979074627161026,
0.00015948731743264943,
0.27956438064575195,
-0.5092760920524597,
0.30063101649284363,
0.8400797247886658,
-0.3194287121295929,
0.41519203782081604,
0.8500434160232544,
-0.6661117076873779,
-0.18993906676769257,
0.8659252524375916,
-0.184869647026062,
0.3833930492401123,
0.6380307674407959,
-0.006104852072894573,
0.24511468410491943,
-0.5602688789367676,
-0.40181949734687805,
-0.24428431689739227,
-0.26890936493873596,
-0.39148208498954773,
-0.449304461479187,
-0.3523305654525757,
-0.04388413205742836,
-0.37267279624938965,
-0.2106158584356308,
-0.013319319114089012,
0.11851371824741364,
0.010675574652850628,
0.6472296714782715,
0.38870641589164734,
0.44766339659690857,
0.48240384459495544,
-0.3522596061229706,
0.23998260498046875,
-0.011098022572696209,
0.39981144666671753,
-0.42623648047447205,
-0.2696055769920349,
-0.3312571048736572,
0.14161480963230133,
-0.42340219020843506,
-0.9022250771522522,
0.6184768080711365,
-0.14237064123153687,
0.3569371700286865,
-0.24272704124450684,
0.11376561969518661,
0.7094687819480896,
-0.2281339019536972,
0.5333670377731323,
-0.056454528123140335,
-0.8302167654037476,
0.49815598130226135,
-0.35907870531082153,
0.4615768492221832,
0.3595059812068939,
-0.12664224207401276,
-0.7092054486274719,
-0.8104941248893738,
-0.7677204012870789,
-0.8263838887214661,
0.44691890478134155,
0.04886885732412338,
0.004307481925934553,
0.07691152393817902,
0.14639133214950562,
0.09125171601772308,
0.17508402466773987,
-0.5351461172103882,
-0.08715154975652695,
-0.00655214861035347,
-0.23470991849899292,
-0.06115998327732086,
-0.028428249061107635,
-0.1038714051246643,
-0.2600109279155731,
0.7537470459938049,
-0.1967628449201584,
0.36270514130592346,
0.25267279148101807,
-0.6165220737457275,
-0.09626450389623642,
0.5008684396743774,
0.7947277426719666,
0.10172288119792938,
-0.42242732644081116,
0.0864471048116684,
0.33297908306121826,
-0.2794550061225891,
0.18587684631347656,
-0.006615359801799059,
-0.27546456456184387,
-0.08094606548547745,
0.2883989214897156,
0.8288455605506897,
0.4729853868484497,
-0.8551279902458191,
0.9234402775764465,
-0.20560374855995178,
-0.18317684531211853,
-0.6165179014205933,
0.7463568449020386,
-0.010432964190840721,
0.10417509824037552,
0.11825593560934067,
0.1372477263212204,
0.12344445288181305,
-0.31435173749923706,
0.5289678573608398,
0.6378787159919739,
-0.6142500638961792,
-0.15797129273414612,
0.26361164450645447,
0.2963170111179352,
-0.36207637190818787,
0.5087283253669739,
-0.5302991271018982,
-0.5486339926719666,
1.0291943550109863,
0.6680401563644409,
0.7320912480354309,
-0.0952075943350792,
0.3150516450405121,
-0.11810116469860077,
0.3995456397533417,
0.06919452548027039,
0.4572513699531555,
-0.03147679939866066,
-0.32404088973999023,
-0.36490777134895325,
-0.40193989872932434,
-0.5064793825149536,
0.04121922701597214,
-0.45908698439598083,
0.5692600011825562,
-0.4812591075897217,
0.3203205466270447,
-0.09525734931230545,
0.012885593809187412,
-0.7667426466941833,
0.09039557725191116,
-0.0832841545343399,
1.0452263355255127,
-0.5747193098068237,
0.8999366164207458,
0.36366143822669983,
-0.42242270708084106,
-0.6127147078514099,
0.2053009271621704,
0.12824423611164093,
-0.7054909467697144,
0.168728768825531,
0.29542306065559387,
-0.2408544272184372,
0.4039113521575928,
-0.4111296236515045,
-0.853386402130127,
1.2337092161178589,
0.5176803469657898,
-0.6242008209228516,
0.22906748950481415,
-0.1999623030424118,
0.602879524230957,
-0.11021630465984344,
0.4772908389568329,
0.06828629225492477,
0.36851412057876587,
0.2192518264055252,
-0.5567805171012878,
-0.1226762980222702,
-0.23603862524032593,
-0.32893234491348267,
0.4191444218158722,
-0.8071123361587524,
0.12414885312318802,
-0.3765437602996826,
0.06882121413946152,
-0.08887626975774765,
0.4113529920578003,
0.06186012551188469,
0.5339922904968262,
0.48128941655158997,
0.5325557589530945,
0.8053163886070251,
-0.17552416026592255,
1.507527470588684,
0.04601287841796875,
0.4602121412754059,
0.9197962284088135,
-0.06184186041355133,
0.8646745085716248,
0.3060576319694519,
-0.015487434342503548,
0.8810098767280579,
0.34155452251434326,
-0.3425700068473816,
0.5299729108810425,
0.7142912745475769,
-0.24306122958660126,
-0.17304092645645142,
0.02246236428618431,
-0.18321596086025238,
0.3942990303039551,
0.26975834369659424,
0.060497406870126724,
0.015115509741008282,
0.12432461231946945,
0.08809898793697357,
-0.029736939817667007,
-0.1802237331867218,
0.8202988505363464,
-0.26985296607017517,
-0.7763605713844299,
0.6227251291275024,
0.21624350547790527,
0.6260009407997131,
-0.6578211188316345,
0.10253331810235977,
-0.27944156527519226,
0.16753913462162018,
-0.22663342952728271,
-0.49909013509750366,
0.5530067682266235,
-0.1946416050195694,
-0.20354120433330536,
-0.255770742893219,
0.7004379630088806,
-0.5109012722969055,
-0.30942225456237793,
0.40415939688682556,
-0.0071146017871797085,
-0.20282773673534393,
-0.1951432228088379,
-0.2045896053314209,
0.22274747490882874,
-0.004789396654814482,
-0.31031692028045654,
0.133321613073349,
-0.04036872833967209,
-0.1877255141735077,
0.8400124311447144,
0.7788374423980713,
-0.0727248266339302,
0.2639820873737335,
0.048369430005550385,
0.787787139415741,
-0.6661019325256348,
-0.5745551586151123,
-0.8964023590087891,
0.5942664742469788,
-0.0619511678814888,
0.11119081825017929,
0.6903947591781616,
0.6152719259262085,
1.0788270235061646,
-0.15888085961341858,
0.8578168153762817,
0.10894173383712769,
0.0777936726808548,
-0.538650393486023,
0.6685407757759094,
-0.47419512271881104,
0.2236332893371582,
0.001984434435144067,
-0.27786046266555786,
-0.6685678958892822,
0.30189985036849976,
-0.324696809053421,
0.0010616087820380926,
0.6645354628562927,
1.2079682350158691,
-0.06783916056156158,
-0.3683790862560272,
0.42267534136772156,
0.2640424072742462,
0.6354174017906189,
0.8119284510612488,
0.7137516140937805,
-0.3004191517829895,
0.6427999138832092,
-0.1041085422039032,
-0.19959762692451477,
-0.6975250840187073,
-0.6611100435256958,
-0.8850558400154114,
-0.3443658947944641,
-0.21040883660316467,
-0.5460668206214905,
0.3714202642440796,
0.8075290322303772,
0.7680195569992065,
-0.700020432472229,
0.07774492353200912,
-0.3596184253692627,
0.5480964779853821,
-0.4023441672325134,
-0.20382677018642426,
-0.12181071192026138,
-0.4444994628429413,
-0.3885245621204376,
0.5508168339729309,
0.6378235220909119,
-0.17373384535312653,
-0.4634726345539093,
-0.3255997598171234,
-0.07500991970300674,
0.19207173585891724,
0.19611017405986786,
0.3916216194629669,
-0.727459728717804,
-0.2495701164007187,
0.08411361277103424,
-0.2216864973306656,
-0.1725306361913681,
0.7512364387512207,
-0.9297905564308167,
0.7012432813644409,
0.47888222336769104,
0.7142335176467896,
0.7593875527381897,
-0.359378844499588,
0.5840154886245728,
-1.1328777074813843,
0.23793406784534454,
0.07912192493677139,
0.06760693341493607,
0.10176662355661392,
-0.44305843114852905,
0.2582281529903412,
0.3583424985408783,
-0.3424893915653229,
-0.9162237644195557,
0.5703795552253723,
-1.0175458192825317,
-0.2000972330570221,
1.3096357583999634,
0.015661802142858505,
-0.3779359459877014,
-0.06666067242622375,
-0.36056220531463623,
0.23662754893302917,
-0.3289443254470825,
0.8135175108909607,
0.6337735652923584,
0.2122432142496109,
-0.16105520725250244,
-0.17653541266918182,
0.596218466758728,
0.4106948673725128,
-1.0577665567398071,
-0.3006783127784729,
0.2674359977245331,
0.4747205078601837,
-0.07996644824743271,
0.4137449860572815,
0.02859797328710556,
0.6694625020027161,
-0.1737726777791977,
0.3707614541053772,
-0.5766372680664062,
-0.3711617887020111,
-0.45941081643104553,
0.20644237101078033,
0.004679822828620672,
0.0421605110168457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12219v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12219v2 | Reformatted Alignment | 2024-02-19T15:21:58 | 2024-04-17T15:03:19 | Run-Ze Fan, Xuefeng Li, Haoyang Zou, Junlong Li, Shwai He, Ethan Chern, Jiewen Hu, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The quality of finetuning data is crucial for aligning large language models
(LLMs) with human values. Current methods to improve data quality are either
labor-intensive or prone to factual errors caused by LLM hallucinations. This
paper explores elevating the quality of existing instruction data to better
align with human values, introducing a simple and effective approach named
ReAlign, which reformats the responses of instruction data into a format that
better aligns with pre-established criteria and the collated evidence. This
approach minimizes human annotation, hallucination, and the difficulty in
scaling, remaining orthogonal to existing alignment techniques. Experimentally,
ReAlign significantly boosts the general alignment ability, math reasoning,
factuality, and readability of the LLMs.
Encouragingly, without introducing any additional data or advanced training
techniques, and merely by reformatting the response, LLaMA-2-13B's mathematical
reasoning ability on GSM8K can be improved from 46.77% to 56.63% in accuracy.
Additionally, a mere 5% of ReAlign data yields a 67% boost in general alignment
ability measured by the Alpaca dataset. This work highlights the need for
further research into the science and mechanistic interpretability of LLMs. We
have made the associated code and data publicly accessible to support future
studies at https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/ReAlign. | [
-0.2130916267633438,
-0.6509371399879456,
0.35935911536216736,
-0.06288900226354599,
-0.18308214843273163,
0.1793973743915558,
-0.31924891471862793,
-0.5966256856918335,
0.2758929431438446,
0.3167021572589874,
-0.5568100810050964,
-0.46011099219322205,
-0.4416515529155731,
-0.08156395703554153,
-0.230963334441185,
0.7985017895698547,
-0.11428259313106537,
0.07872632145881653,
-0.16916531324386597,
-0.29532089829444885,
-0.575016438961029,
-0.4047940969467163,
-0.3767188489437103,
-0.406617671251297,
0.4638785719871521,
0.7510294318199158,
1.2057340145111084,
1.1954807043075562,
0.6856587529182434,
0.23296748101711273,
0.12354312837123871,
0.497246652841568,
-0.702838122844696,
-0.03749282658100128,
-0.1300126612186432,
-0.618868887424469,
-0.5383294820785522,
0.22941088676452637,
0.5712997317314148,
0.6125885248184204,
-0.5189522504806519,
0.3524572551250458,
0.0018436146201565862,
0.7943870425224304,
-0.36565789580345154,
0.07217542082071304,
-0.5295001268386841,
-0.1478917896747589,
-0.11759166419506073,
-0.093651682138443,
-0.3963155746459961,
-0.8088776469230652,
-0.18492473661899567,
-0.8468778133392334,
0.03609730675816536,
0.2336457371711731,
1.4334917068481445,
0.5500943660736084,
-0.04199657961726189,
-0.43055444955825806,
-0.7479446530342102,
0.9060105681419373,
-0.8340965509414673,
0.6334205269813538,
0.3381592929363251,
0.507948100566864,
-0.43197566270828247,
-0.5122145414352417,
-0.8098521828651428,
-0.07175139337778091,
-0.11130271852016449,
0.16390015184879303,
0.17081204056739807,
-0.22134585678577423,
0.004793148022145033,
0.4265686273574829,
-0.6173943877220154,
0.3959674537181854,
-0.5519970655441284,
-0.28899309039115906,
0.6639480590820312,
0.3144071400165558,
0.4574389159679413,
0.27319636940956116,
-0.2159425914287567,
-0.45171070098876953,
-0.9679322242736816,
0.15512341260910034,
0.7320000529289246,
0.35524871945381165,
-0.03903041034936905,
0.6716829538345337,
-0.09709449857473373,
0.7921901941299438,
0.16711360216140747,
-0.5239089131355286,
0.1343199461698532,
-0.34844425320625305,
-0.26872357726097107,
0.42035752534866333,
0.5290393829345703,
0.4553731381893158,
0.17959463596343994,
-0.1221531555056572,
-0.2768475115299225,
0.026155659928917885,
0.625025749206543,
-0.8343505263328552,
-0.06638806313276291,
0.22886952757835388,
-0.4658340513706207,
-0.25574687123298645,
0.29294630885124207,
-0.6504773497581482,
-0.13413111865520477,
-1.013554334640503,
0.40336623787879944,
-0.31182119250297546,
-0.0398312546312809,
0.3568672835826874,
0.5054603219032288,
0.5885774493217468,
0.3580631911754608,
-1.1513277292251587,
0.32725027203559875,
1.1738053560256958,
0.6637960076332092,
0.11910934746265411,
-0.2783052325248718,
-0.3154269754886627,
-0.039321932941675186,
-0.7012282609939575,
0.6945046186447144,
-0.4777972996234894,
0.056638285517692566,
-0.11381068080663681,
0.09172939509153366,
0.031538043171167374,
-0.7327364087104797,
0.7538031339645386,
-0.5670973062515259,
0.4362967014312744,
-0.36386623978614807,
-0.47980427742004395,
-0.13351590931415558,
0.25897693634033203,
-0.6747382879257202,
0.9118418097496033,
0.14257076382637024,
-0.3942944407463074,
0.10383060574531555,
-0.25388798117637634,
-0.22182349860668182,
-0.41963908076286316,
-0.2881214916706085,
-0.7726960182189941,
0.060352835804224014,
0.19628795981407166,
0.24574734270572662,
-0.20694893598556519,
0.5110788941383362,
-0.029635384678840637,
-0.644687831401825,
0.4844836890697479,
-0.47368890047073364,
0.6180142164230347,
0.34102970361709595,
-0.17612694203853607,
0.07093621045351028,
-0.8704034686088562,
0.10001832991838455,
0.18201936781406403,
-0.3921484649181366,
0.039629604667425156,
-0.02289305441081524,
-0.5231415629386902,
0.14003217220306396,
0.17650404572486877,
-0.4012976586818695,
0.49917542934417725,
-0.6066805124282837,
0.1836737096309662,
0.749732494354248,
-0.4529911279678345,
0.6701762676239014,
-0.4571389853954315,
0.4619583785533905,
-0.18879404664039612,
0.18361355364322662,
0.0958806574344635,
-0.3615328371524811,
-0.800622284412384,
-0.26593297719955444,
0.4833361804485321,
0.6343263983726501,
-0.33932074904441833,
0.6139754056930542,
-0.5274195075035095,
-0.5275601148605347,
-1.2604165077209473,
0.16511817276477814,
0.46192076802253723,
0.7563526630401611,
0.5230405926704407,
-0.19521811604499817,
-0.5401832461357117,
-0.9304808378219604,
0.07207388430833817,
-0.029922975227236748,
-0.20699533820152283,
-0.08276722580194473,
0.07070194184780121,
-0.4428851902484894,
0.7886066436767578,
-0.6426036357879639,
-0.20293286442756653,
0.055176787078380585,
0.09328003227710724,
0.1346377432346344,
0.5734302401542664,
0.2194218933582306,
-0.29515212774276733,
-0.024716755375266075,
-0.0012070814846083522,
-0.6038755774497986,
-0.26141196489334106,
-0.35579487681388855,
-0.6000058650970459,
-0.05384590104222298,
0.3077249526977539,
-0.4223920702934265,
0.19184203445911407,
0.520397424697876,
-0.15317247807979584,
0.6997933983802795,
-0.05509117245674133,
0.2630659341812134,
-0.9585410356521606,
-0.18587346374988556,
-0.1784338355064392,
-0.011995038948953152,
-0.559665858745575,
-0.039733659476041794,
0.21282872557640076,
0.041915636509656906,
-0.18097417056560516,
0.3180583119392395,
-0.46556568145751953,
-0.12825942039489746,
-0.27936863899230957,
0.1401941031217575,
0.18339186906814575,
0.23409304022789001,
-0.22162017226219177,
1.176406741142273,
-0.07250925898551941,
-0.34613028168678284,
0.37396523356437683,
0.3546293079853058,
-0.4869200587272644,
0.4415440857410431,
-0.4790477454662323,
0.00828242115676403,
-0.21122997999191284,
0.14144732058048248,
-0.9637514352798462,
-0.4867979884147644,
0.37044021487236023,
-0.3593037724494934,
0.5159989595413208,
0.16897127032279968,
-0.1852872520685196,
-0.01946091093122959,
-0.37141531705856323,
0.36233580112457275,
0.49646449089050293,
-0.8025808930397034,
0.40057259798049927,
0.23553290963172913,
-0.10681398957967758,
-0.7297253012657166,
-0.5136579275131226,
0.15981628000736237,
-0.23527292907238007,
-0.7040367126464844,
0.47278112173080444,
0.1696949452161789,
-0.23627062141895294,
-0.17892354726791382,
-0.31178537011146545,
0.058473147451877594,
0.035432763397693634,
0.08280867338180542,
0.4633714258670807,
-0.5351132750511169,
0.0777927115559578,
0.08678191900253296,
-0.3987445533275604,
-0.053454626351594925,
0.01593267358839512,
0.5372688174247742,
-0.07656979560852051,
-0.4142566919326782,
-0.9428189992904663,
-0.12513968348503113,
0.4422905445098877,
-0.18980595469474792,
0.833344042301178,
0.42698192596435547,
-0.4257490932941437,
0.09445395320653915,
-0.5312921404838562,
-0.29877969622612,
-0.4666995108127594,
0.1563900113105774,
-0.25809094309806824,
-0.576493501663208,
0.47301822900772095,
-0.02072984352707863,
0.2890002727508545,
0.13699059188365936,
0.35198095440864563,
-0.24511952698230743,
0.9065688848495483,
0.4811868369579315,
0.07144010066986084,
0.3478044271469116,
-0.07979805022478104,
0.6223543286323547,
-0.8709656000137329,
-0.47980666160583496,
-0.6186310052871704,
-0.6000162363052368,
-0.3450027406215668,
-0.3363032639026642,
-0.2418525218963623,
0.2631274163722992,
-0.3367554843425751,
0.471134752035141,
-0.8103671073913574,
0.5857160091400146,
0.3252352774143219,
0.219265416264534,
0.21150627732276917,
0.11603342741727829,
0.25936126708984375,
-0.31656497716903687,
-0.31788280606269836,
-1.257508397102356,
0.9728168845176697,
0.583099365234375,
1.1076219081878662,
0.30472472310066223,
0.6256541609764099,
-0.14685997366905212,
0.4897429347038269,
-0.8623032569885254,
0.36133667826652527,
0.028009414672851562,
-0.1496535986661911,
-0.3305036723613739,
-0.2994295358657837,
-0.8751557469367981,
0.18260017037391663,
-0.2712828814983368,
-0.5007798671722412,
0.12999264895915985,
0.23788030445575714,
-0.6028489470481873,
0.04763534665107727,
-0.889348566532135,
0.6976791620254517,
-0.5085945129394531,
-0.27545052766799927,
0.010225352831184864,
-0.6370797753334045,
0.46493595838546753,
-0.11187876015901566,
0.30617278814315796,
-0.22203300893306732,
0.0011164649622514844,
0.9213775396347046,
-0.502716600894928,
0.7644301056861877,
0.14416883885860443,
-0.6295965909957886,
0.23783330619335175,
0.03795270249247551,
0.5241521000862122,
-0.10932844877243042,
-0.08914535492658615,
-0.04821084812283516,
0.003901510266587138,
-0.4345538318157196,
-0.8460238575935364,
0.8144710063934326,
-0.9327267408370972,
-0.705675482749939,
-0.12127737700939178,
-0.6207188367843628,
-0.13801881670951843,
-0.150716632604599,
-0.11636906862258911,
0.3997076153755188,
0.024665003642439842,
0.01084761880338192,
0.7366822957992554,
-0.050750043243169785,
-0.06069936603307724,
0.22395731508731842,
-0.01639210432767868,
-0.5594791173934937,
1.2792844772338867,
0.40873685479164124,
0.4137142300605774,
0.2122913897037506,
0.1864529848098755,
-0.3805435597896576,
-0.3247791528701782,
-0.7169700860977173,
0.32843202352523804,
-0.6357764601707458,
-0.41568103432655334,
-0.2564326822757721,
-0.08885519951581955,
-0.34614989161491394,
-0.3573659658432007,
-0.5236214399337769,
-0.638733983039856,
-0.5594428181648254,
-0.3137454390525818,
0.09157553315162659,
0.5005517601966858,
0.18525244295597076,
0.6394873261451721,
-0.6245115399360657,
0.4098875820636749,
0.3106584846973419,
0.3257375955581665,
-0.029794687405228615,
-0.9116480350494385,
-0.17245842516422272,
0.4084816873073578,
-0.3901239037513733,
-0.6617234349250793,
0.232940673828125,
0.09904489666223526,
0.4174331724643707,
0.652703046798706,
-0.18497197329998016,
1.173535704612732,
-0.3923985958099365,
0.5369381308555603,
0.09099742770195007,
-0.6887465119361877,
0.20171572268009186,
0.14229829609394073,
-0.07848335057497025,
0.6543793678283691,
0.28707432746887207,
-0.46410492062568665,
-0.17123496532440186,
-0.5155338644981384,
-0.5601509809494019,
0.5754981637001038,
0.06054331362247467,
0.09864263981580734,
0.3705962002277374,
0.6575123071670532,
0.2776802182197571,
-0.10272988677024841,
-0.2064983993768692,
0.03939906507730484,
-0.4059405028820038,
-0.9954383373260498,
0.298161119222641,
-0.29580384492874146,
-0.32168570160865784,
-0.32886847853660583,
0.7608779668807983,
-0.10959386080503464,
0.14468130469322205,
-0.07796620577573776,
-0.04136735200881958,
-0.09026877582073212,
0.34633493423461914,
1.0075918436050415,
0.9577152729034424,
-0.04854952543973923,
0.36994680762290955,
0.09978528320789337,
-0.6554162502288818,
0.4880467653274536,
-0.15487278997898102,
-0.21211141347885132,
-0.3418270945549011,
0.5603293180465698,
0.5118697881698608,
0.0646439716219902,
-0.6057226657867432,
0.24854274094104767,
-0.018616942688822746,
-0.06696745753288269,
0.19919347763061523,
0.35131654143333435,
0.18306483328342438,
0.03486671298742294,
0.17493148148059845,
-0.22369319200515747,
-0.26450231671333313,
-0.5250157117843628,
0.1134549230337143,
0.23756487667560577,
-0.21671932935714722,
-0.4417879283428192,
0.5700754523277283,
0.13084013760089874,
-0.4466027319431305,
0.7847567796707153,
-0.1703789383172989,
-0.30520185828208923,
0.7425084710121155,
0.8577031493186951,
0.2795059382915497,
-0.31948715448379517,
0.027972977608442307,
0.5370813012123108,
0.4279420077800751,
-0.4022810459136963,
0.19404542446136475,
0.28582483530044556,
-0.8447242975234985,
-0.6030167937278748,
-0.5925436615943909,
-0.47111764550209045,
0.043813884258270264,
-0.688930094242096,
0.2642458975315094,
-0.46019765734672546,
0.08189009130001068,
-0.16460593044757843,
0.09216335415840149,
-0.21440330147743225,
0.44589197635650635,
0.002314163837581873,
0.5855076909065247,
-0.9657700657844543,
0.7831084132194519,
0.521011233329773,
-0.40961915254592896,
-1.04045569896698,
-0.10772416740655899,
0.024539494886994362,
-1.106134295463562,
0.3757579028606415,
0.25798898935317993,
-0.17622776329517365,
0.03243538737297058,
-0.7183595299720764,
-0.8962284326553345,
1.145266056060791,
0.5661497116088867,
-0.9903745651245117,
0.1467127948999405,
0.2556443214416504,
0.5018420219421387,
-0.3346058130264282,
0.07936245203018188,
0.888995349407196,
0.5373930335044861,
0.08036787807941437,
-0.5335691571235657,
0.2175857573747635,
0.11047950387001038,
-0.09857110679149628,
0.34597352147102356,
-0.5543687343597412,
0.2804919183254242,
-0.3486471176147461,
-0.4481929540634155,
0.01463557593524456,
0.9862034320831299,
0.3203620910644531,
0.15871696174144745,
0.10323674231767654,
0.8848195672035217,
1.215241551399231,
-0.3891183137893677,
0.4965522885322571,
-0.15158291161060333,
0.11159959435462952,
1.1478034257888794,
-0.19085031747817993,
0.7976582646369934,
0.6098978519439697,
-0.2703501284122467,
0.40076401829719543,
0.693537175655365,
0.06487501412630081,
0.33246511220932007,
0.3380694091320038,
-0.13906548917293549,
-0.19594648480415344,
-0.00983711238950491,
-0.21791529655456543,
0.3834608495235443,
0.33095136284828186,
0.14404328167438507,
-0.05949806049466133,
-0.1719786524772644,
0.2922455370426178,
0.5284733772277832,
0.026144834235310555,
0.7388293743133545,
-0.09792761504650116,
-0.6014216542243958,
0.8808217644691467,
0.05044747516512871,
0.6832966208457947,
-0.2894667387008667,
-0.2434316724538803,
-0.42232850193977356,
0.0951247364282608,
-0.6177103519439697,
-0.921783983707428,
0.5614667534828186,
-0.09308400750160217,
-0.18186770379543304,
-0.08867865055799484,
0.3405757248401642,
-0.6092550158500671,
-0.4000725746154785,
-0.2530401945114136,
-0.014810184016823769,
0.2258530706167221,
0.38590896129608154,
-0.6097217202186584,
0.4686833322048187,
0.09408115595579147,
-0.017006278038024902,
0.3083597421646118,
0.23893335461616516,
-0.2710201144218445,
0.7048786878585815,
0.7768968939781189,
0.06988687813282013,
0.04024164751172066,
0.12105797976255417,
0.7648437023162842,
-0.7143006920814514,
0.042520731687545776,
-0.8873892426490784,
0.3625548779964447,
0.01729007251560688,
-0.2769470512866974,
0.3330044746398926,
0.6694549918174744,
0.9224494695663452,
0.13625994324684143,
0.20800313353538513,
0.35051295161247253,
0.3429689109325409,
-0.7157272696495056,
0.6206177473068237,
-0.21365709602832794,
0.30131295323371887,
0.22728031873703003,
-0.7943431735038757,
-0.4251493215560913,
0.8311265707015991,
-0.3301542103290558,
-0.41560909152030945,
0.43067315220832825,
1.2306392192840576,
-0.2738483250141144,
-0.07492305338382721,
0.11380579322576523,
-0.06671664118766785,
0.5626936554908752,
0.21321339905261993,
0.7922542095184326,
-0.675460934638977,
0.4983396828174591,
-0.29547855257987976,
-0.2734818160533905,
-0.22277918457984924,
-0.6423095464706421,
-0.4213506281375885,
-0.287449449300766,
-0.33282941579818726,
-0.3668445944786072,
0.04261656105518341,
1.0844875574111938,
0.37175992131233215,
-0.8234522342681885,
-0.15206246078014374,
0.15057700872421265,
0.23837074637413025,
-0.3473028242588043,
-0.18231642246246338,
0.5949417352676392,
-0.4155198633670807,
-0.6312239766120911,
0.3853779435157776,
0.22607964277267456,
0.3491773009300232,
-0.060801755636930466,
-0.3301512598991394,
0.017684541642665863,
0.2349947839975357,
0.42371994256973267,
0.3856167495250702,
-0.8427761197090149,
-0.41809093952178955,
0.08667290955781937,
-0.5077064037322998,
0.34838441014289856,
0.4276556372642517,
-0.44192633032798767,
0.27619507908821106,
0.43379566073417664,
0.9365137815475464,
-0.140730619430542,
0.6270105838775635,
0.4746309816837311,
-0.3509595990180969,
0.0809718444943428,
0.023018071427941322,
0.16970257461071014,
0.5113839507102966,
-0.47344669699668884,
0.5094322562217712,
-0.15461024641990662,
-0.7093108296394348,
-0.8777145147323608,
0.08244533836841583,
-0.9702237844467163,
-0.025253089144825935,
0.7818909883499146,
0.08756562322378159,
-0.4235999286174774,
0.030480533838272095,
-0.7002648115158081,
0.42446744441986084,
-0.25567030906677246,
1.2303377389907837,
0.6614315509796143,
-0.11650028079748154,
0.07557771354913712,
-0.4722561538219452,
0.36886587738990784,
0.4847879409790039,
-1.0741651058197021,
0.15571436285972595,
0.5046323537826538,
0.12273453921079636,
0.13654965162277222,
0.2046801745891571,
-0.24887436628341675,
0.14799916744232178,
-0.30659356713294983,
0.22953619062900543,
-0.145083948969841,
-0.37766411900520325,
-0.2662687301635742,
-0.07831058651208878,
0.20556151866912842,
-0.3144887387752533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12212v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12212v1 | Polarization of Autonomous Generative AI Agents Under Echo Chambers | 2024-02-19T15:14:15 | 2024-02-19T15:14:15 | Masaya Ohagi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online social networks often create echo chambers where people only hear
opinions reinforcing their beliefs. An echo chamber often generates
polarization, leading to conflicts caused by people with radical opinions, such
as the January 6, 2021, attack on the US Capitol. The echo chamber has been
viewed as a human-specific problem, but this implicit assumption is becoming
less reasonable as large language models, such as ChatGPT, acquire social
abilities. In response to this situation, we investigated the potential for
polarization to occur among a group of autonomous AI agents based on generative
language models in an echo chamber environment. We had AI agents discuss
specific topics and analyzed how the group's opinions changed as the discussion
progressed. As a result, we found that the group of agents based on ChatGPT
tended to become polarized in echo chamber environments. The analysis of
opinion transitions shows that this result is caused by ChatGPT's high prompt
understanding ability to update its opinion by considering its own and
surrounding agents' opinions. We conducted additional experiments to
investigate under what specific conditions AI agents tended to polarize. As a
result, we identified factors that strongly influence polarization, such as the
agent's persona. These factors should be monitored to prevent the polarization
of AI agents. | [
-0.7261354923248291,
-0.911842405796051,
0.6398528218269348,
-0.016629062592983246,
-0.20310844480991364,
0.35806751251220703,
-0.1573420614004135,
-0.23562580347061157,
0.1663305014371872,
0.4221230447292328,
-0.4524444341659546,
-0.2960074543952942,
-0.6697229146957397,
0.03782239928841591,
-0.4433552324771881,
1.3260570764541626,
0.41889089345932007,
0.12506894767284393,
-0.004802047275006771,
-0.24740102887153625,
-0.3395635485649109,
-0.9000751972198486,
-0.9930844902992249,
-0.4482381045818329,
0.48785901069641113,
0.045202020555734634,
1.0204505920410156,
0.26878803968429565,
0.5267915725708008,
0.3845710754394531,
-0.04121012985706329,
-0.40416374802589417,
-0.33816611766815186,
0.06827782839536667,
0.00824078917503357,
-0.6219453811645508,
-0.5540452599525452,
0.14623801410198212,
0.43219250440597534,
0.32573384046554565,
-0.24059508740901947,
-0.18836849927902222,
0.20896555483341217,
0.6819881796836853,
0.07887201756238937,
0.5210082530975342,
-0.6272512078285217,
-0.0029167591128498316,
0.01595856435596943,
-0.24935922026634216,
-0.35382336378097534,
-0.3293110430240631,
0.09471170604228973,
-0.44424188137054443,
0.6157383918762207,
-0.12772278487682343,
0.6248137950897217,
0.48395588994026184,
-0.40605151653289795,
-0.2116263508796692,
-0.9398191571235657,
0.5187773108482361,
-0.5331422090530396,
0.03580562770366669,
0.22861318290233612,
0.1819901466369629,
-0.12489728629589081,
-0.2908506393432617,
-0.7262279391288757,
-0.22125735878944397,
0.166865274310112,
0.31073835492134094,
-0.6666597127914429,
0.3284020721912384,
0.07197313755750656,
0.09020253270864487,
-0.5071436762809753,
-0.19254553318023682,
-0.25533726811408997,
0.09275694191455841,
0.7076129913330078,
0.1312965303659439,
0.5840991139411926,
-0.22756798565387726,
-0.32239678502082825,
-0.40438786149024963,
-0.4119158387184143,
0.12249976396560669,
0.622627854347229,
0.23262783885002136,
-0.18913857638835907,
0.5647821426391602,
-0.07570557296276093,
0.23562757670879364,
0.510857880115509,
0.492150217294693,
0.14254988729953766,
-0.2551301121711731,
-0.11712265759706497,
0.10345573723316193,
1.0155528783798218,
0.39599645137786865,
0.2634245455265045,
0.004176381975412369,
-0.189315527677536,
0.07751293480396271,
0.5875600576400757,
-0.6277854442596436,
-0.09729990363121033,
0.5382584929466248,
-0.5960692167282104,
-0.5847833752632141,
0.20016147196292877,
-0.7942522764205933,
-0.9495910406112671,
-0.25039389729499817,
0.3242349922657013,
-0.08105013519525528,
-0.43800634145736694,
-0.2788459062576294,
-0.3352561891078949,
0.4448704421520233,
0.2594181299209595,
-0.5505092740058899,
0.1793806552886963,
0.8522576689720154,
0.8241474628448486,
0.026313673704862595,
-0.36038991808891296,
-0.2665855586528778,
-0.2881835401058197,
-0.2745664119720459,
1.0356855392456055,
-0.32011744379997253,
-0.44715163111686707,
-0.09177733212709427,
-0.09389747679233551,
-0.05530906841158867,
-0.5470770001411438,
0.09329644590616226,
-0.7529875636100769,
0.24599212408065796,
-0.18695493042469025,
-0.29667264223098755,
-0.13332408666610718,
0.3042716979980469,
-0.34456029534339905,
0.125936821103096,
-0.13063597679138184,
-0.7498480677604675,
0.210137739777565,
-0.6022511124610901,
-0.32491856813430786,
0.19292311370372772,
-0.5727174282073975,
-0.5891929864883423,
0.02271214872598648,
0.26525816321372986,
0.4547000229358673,
-0.10790865123271942,
0.17886200547218323,
-0.20542658865451813,
0.008973412215709686,
0.50132817029953,
-0.479480504989624,
1.0366261005401611,
-0.03836163878440857,
-0.8452074527740479,
0.6122164130210876,
-0.1509062647819519,
-0.19424374401569366,
0.21611431241035461,
-0.013310287147760391,
0.0901326984167099,
0.5036150813102722,
-0.1909162551164627,
-0.07707005739212036,
0.08827530592679977,
-0.3882144093513489,
0.20861110091209412,
-0.322651743888855,
0.3633327782154083,
1.1513816118240356,
0.519812285900116,
0.5152841806411743,
-0.6007421016693115,
0.7468384504318237,
0.12327683717012405,
0.556236207485199,
0.26061221957206726,
-1.0772970914840698,
-0.9351558089256287,
-0.11266828328371048,
-0.5314589142799377,
0.5828817486763,
-0.6846845149993896,
0.5508443117141724,
-0.03053286112844944,
-0.525444746017456,
-0.6192330718040466,
-0.06694856286048889,
0.009767362847924232,
0.09300429373979568,
0.34526482224464417,
-0.16389398276805878,
-0.10206521302461624,
-0.8644559383392334,
-0.19531287252902985,
-0.7020242214202881,
-0.0015719921793788671,
0.4851358234882355,
0.09634743630886078,
-0.6014355421066284,
1.028490662574768,
-0.22435316443443298,
-0.4805612564086914,
-0.5424337983131409,
0.6582304835319519,
0.17071139812469482,
0.20924606919288635,
0.3578692078590393,
-0.8402113914489746,
-0.7115129232406616,
0.2068631947040558,
-0.7817501425743103,
-0.01881839893758297,
-0.38198167085647583,
0.09391860663890839,
0.20460394024848938,
0.3924103081226349,
-0.7109763622283936,
0.4869881868362427,
0.5593740344047546,
-0.23327434062957764,
0.36533448100090027,
0.03712930530309677,
0.2747219204902649,
-1.0581008195877075,
-0.30919864773750305,
-0.23764798045158386,
-0.009666714817285538,
-0.7653306722640991,
-0.1505526751279831,
-0.5338774919509888,
-0.24203093349933624,
-0.17003308236598969,
0.12013688683509827,
-0.25226280093193054,
0.16369740664958954,
-0.5515448451042175,
0.1762361377477646,
-0.17066511511802673,
0.3958200216293335,
0.07760480791330338,
0.7115551233291626,
0.6550999283790588,
-0.11764562129974365,
0.48713114857673645,
0.18767479062080383,
-0.1395687758922577,
0.3239457905292511,
-0.7712047100067139,
0.49279722571372986,
-0.3965606391429901,
0.3965045213699341,
-0.8614410161972046,
-0.1982569694519043,
0.4565628468990326,
-0.6371530294418335,
-0.08908876776695251,
-0.2846023738384247,
-0.14251267910003662,
0.17024563252925873,
-0.25559285283088684,
0.4109947681427002,
0.5718532800674438,
-0.31585413217544556,
0.8699593544006348,
0.46013548970222473,
-0.372873455286026,
-0.38326549530029297,
-0.2924087345600128,
0.2726544737815857,
-0.2061278373003006,
-0.548273503780365,
-0.16491231322288513,
-0.05558596923947334,
-0.766663134098053,
0.11534330248832703,
0.5508229732513428,
0.14599408209323883,
0.003838596399873495,
0.46602338552474976,
0.18396690487861633,
-0.19833402335643768,
-0.02070426195859909,
-0.164199098944664,
-0.11956949532032013,
0.4510142505168915,
0.021026385948061943,
0.8669254779815674,
-0.6000717282295227,
-0.5563962459564209,
-0.7794180512428284,
0.5024828910827637,
1.0455093383789062,
-0.2181917279958725,
1.0860384702682495,
0.45685920119285583,
-0.02972823567688465,
-0.23029109835624695,
-0.5749757885932922,
-0.5416238307952881,
-0.46472489833831787,
0.4544751048088074,
0.1319051831960678,
-0.4671589732170105,
0.7567937970161438,
0.47143298387527466,
0.05227376148104668,
0.3724084794521332,
0.9602648615837097,
-0.21537114679813385,
1.4724639654159546,
0.32490089535713196,
-0.4471423029899597,
0.6915976405143738,
-0.21643966436386108,
0.46131476759910583,
-0.7214840650558472,
-0.08528319746255875,
-0.45631200075149536,
-0.05863551050424576,
-0.8386114239692688,
-0.39877787232398987,
0.5573075413703918,
-0.45387065410614014,
0.04136085510253906,
-0.01871553063392639,
-0.7041957974433899,
0.2572808861732483,
0.40168774127960205,
0.20405665040016174,
0.03697327524423599,
-0.07772056758403778,
0.5724667906761169,
0.47834140062332153,
-0.6321502923965454,
-0.42839929461479187,
1.1256778240203857,
0.38786548376083374,
0.5415407419204712,
0.21187691390514374,
0.6257879137992859,
0.6550323367118835,
0.7394869923591614,
-0.8804446458816528,
0.5097107291221619,
0.2670373022556305,
-0.58502596616745,
-0.46566709876060486,
-0.3995979428291321,
-1.2245396375656128,
0.23407655954360962,
-0.10677193850278854,
-0.2867158055305481,
0.324510782957077,
-0.041953206062316895,
-0.15793682634830475,
0.2002965807914734,
-0.6076731085777283,
0.6566705107688904,
-0.15265697240829468,
0.06837493926286697,
-0.6195626854896545,
-0.46413296461105347,
-0.127607062458992,
0.0964706763625145,
0.19449158012866974,
-0.16352598369121552,
0.3786586821079254,
0.5847312808036804,
-0.32284101843833923,
1.2433708906173706,
-0.3479805588722229,
0.1522253006696701,
0.6893190741539001,
-0.07606314867734909,
0.6040335297584534,
0.10102083534002304,
0.053627222776412964,
0.443405419588089,
-0.40547993779182434,
-0.44248849153518677,
-0.5813318490982056,
0.4342074692249298,
-1.4804317951202393,
-1.0011029243469238,
-0.6001057624816895,
-0.33685407042503357,
0.14365074038505554,
-0.08995306491851807,
0.5570797324180603,
0.2991534173488617,
-0.36435389518737793,
0.18035756051540375,
0.44074898958206177,
-0.0928243026137352,
0.40021902322769165,
0.28374049067497253,
0.03740259259939194,
-0.48078224062919617,
0.8883941173553467,
0.18706724047660828,
0.42786628007888794,
-0.0809292197227478,
0.3567301332950592,
0.07468611747026443,
-0.44483476877212524,
-0.36120349168777466,
0.07329486310482025,
-0.5434958338737488,
-0.05257323011755943,
-0.6706483960151672,
-0.3410428464412689,
-0.5897200703620911,
-0.2486318051815033,
-0.386569619178772,
0.005439849570393562,
-0.26714420318603516,
-0.026249416172504425,
0.06093524768948555,
1.0754048824310303,
0.1589888036251068,
0.37356722354888916,
-0.5112277269363403,
0.06428011506795883,
0.676009476184845,
-0.07988569140434265,
0.04609650745987892,
-0.3963685631752014,
-0.018070662394165993,
0.04327867180109024,
-0.33280858397483826,
-1.1771206855773926,
0.2449343055486679,
-0.11123156547546387,
0.5579959154129028,
0.8328143954277039,
0.26099932193756104,
-0.005076689645648003,
-0.14734794199466705,
0.8163081407546997,
-0.11035429686307907,
-0.665109395980835,
0.49407607316970825,
-0.7844337821006775,
0.3333446979522705,
0.2584647834300995,
0.13852903246879578,
-0.4770086109638214,
-0.9558790922164917,
-0.9516125321388245,
-0.582489550113678,
0.4825412631034851,
0.46411603689193726,
0.28555527329444885,
-0.14075900614261627,
0.11161000281572342,
-0.05144013091921806,
0.3552897870540619,
-0.9115674495697021,
-0.14480775594711304,
-0.5198795795440674,
-0.10446230322122574,
-0.21289215981960297,
-0.04429718106985092,
-0.5089481472969055,
0.00687368493527174,
0.5512152314186096,
-0.08753787726163864,
0.5110436081886292,
0.19211754202842712,
0.35837700963020325,
-0.2133101373910904,
0.4167355000972748,
0.487778902053833,
0.36200737953186035,
-0.18599902093410492,
0.12805455923080444,
-0.08017585426568985,
-0.4117183983325958,
0.15294747054576874,
-0.02609885111451149,
-0.4142090976238251,
-0.26593369245529175,
0.5826839804649353,
0.6535244584083557,
-0.6079347729682922,
-0.46131521463394165,
0.9580512046813965,
-0.2664858102798462,
0.1937434822320938,
-0.6881895065307617,
0.09343598037958145,
-0.25055715441703796,
0.5327388048171997,
0.3610377907752991,
0.5145028233528137,
0.0933501198887825,
-0.8537387251853943,
-0.08827952295541763,
0.9696870446205139,
-0.4931439161300659,
-0.6983206272125244,
0.4372590482234955,
0.3255713880062103,
-0.6404948234558105,
0.7973531484603882,
-0.3358030319213867,
-0.9179668426513672,
0.8747802376747131,
0.25744006037712097,
1.5064828395843506,
-0.39818158745765686,
0.46532920002937317,
0.04737916588783264,
0.693271815776825,
0.3921276032924652,
-0.15080896019935608,
-0.2885007858276367,
-1.168869972229004,
0.15590447187423706,
-0.24719785153865814,
-0.5972661972045898,
-0.023215822875499725,
-0.7043024301528931,
0.03781815245747566,
-0.748009443283081,
-0.6775315999984741,
-0.3397587835788727,
-0.2579106092453003,
-0.5167038440704346,
-0.057108424603939056,
0.25065889954566956,
-0.19181515276432037,
-1.054736852645874,
0.39092308282852173,
0.8163701891899109,
-0.3662145137786865,
-0.4093683362007141,
0.5265131592750549,
0.15354858338832855,
-0.6632792949676514,
0.33641791343688965,
-0.023810820654034615,
-0.32376188039779663,
-0.10158541798591614,
-0.5743147730827332,
-0.6810652017593384,
0.8290908932685852,
0.04330098628997803,
-0.10869640111923218,
0.37702634930610657,
0.4179099500179291,
0.9815866351127625,
-0.4464297592639923,
0.15569524466991425,
0.358783096075058,
0.3741777241230011,
-0.38062044978141785,
-0.6392361521720886,
-0.1649530678987503,
-0.3128512501716614,
-0.4260841906070709,
-0.016893187537789345,
-1.1830416917800903,
1.015394926071167,
-0.07959102094173431,
-0.37882199883461,
-0.361593633890152,
0.44512292742729187,
-0.07139032334089279,
0.4279434084892273,
0.7049708962440491,
0.1748502254486084,
0.5094203352928162,
0.09132708609104156,
1.0009219646453857,
-0.3503338694572449,
0.2197577953338623,
0.6610895395278931,
-0.24447879195213318,
0.7787392735481262,
0.39324694871902466,
0.032723817974328995,
0.5906682014465332,
0.13178019225597382,
0.009517069905996323,
0.3176463842391968,
-0.1681910902261734,
-0.6629189252853394,
-0.2388611137866974,
-0.24011865258216858,
-0.3487417697906494,
0.42994236946105957,
0.156228706240654,
-0.1613321453332901,
0.21317338943481445,
0.3387114405632019,
0.05989415571093559,
-0.18197320401668549,
-0.12443902343511581,
1.2225165367126465,
-0.1311396211385727,
-0.7211033701896667,
0.12499888986349106,
-0.12476500123739243,
0.07333602011203766,
-0.2556276321411133,
0.243779256939888,
-0.25001177191734314,
0.07209107279777527,
-0.2120657116174698,
-0.6200180649757385,
0.1887742131948471,
-0.040979769080877304,
-0.30770254135131836,
-0.38410624861717224,
0.28388547897338867,
-0.10379461199045181,
-0.3963932394981384,
0.5760497450828552,
0.550470232963562,
0.05159139260649681,
-0.43911212682724,
-0.7109596133232117,
0.08366778492927551,
0.1453973799943924,
-0.5356686115264893,
0.43340936303138733,
0.16341964900493622,
-0.047342896461486816,
0.657016396522522,
0.683500349521637,
0.1996518224477768,
0.09707523882389069,
0.2758297026157379,
1.1100205183029175,
-0.22048990428447723,
-0.44242823123931885,
-0.8161402344703674,
0.36488717794418335,
-0.17719626426696777,
-0.02643551304936409,
0.5815340876579285,
0.3001564145088196,
0.47183898091316223,
0.050074562430381775,
1.007878303527832,
-0.18504290282726288,
0.27377045154571533,
-0.2080717831850052,
1.1255335807800293,
-0.3598102033138275,
0.360131174325943,
-0.16325567662715912,
-0.9542470574378967,
0.07232213020324707,
0.5902236104011536,
-0.4788895845413208,
0.09500818699598312,
0.5329922437667847,
0.9648197293281555,
0.4157976806163788,
0.07553983479738235,
0.16073374450206757,
0.6570291519165039,
0.7485909461975098,
0.06062716990709305,
1.0329982042312622,
-0.0883328840136528,
0.5440105199813843,
-0.3186291456222534,
-0.6258912682533264,
-0.17376106977462769,
-0.3309165835380554,
-1.2546526193618774,
-0.7790144085884094,
-0.5185865759849548,
-0.33846524357795715,
-0.05079428106546402,
0.9231039881706238,
0.50846266746521,
-0.8678112626075745,
-0.29451921582221985,
-0.27229824662208557,
0.17783522605895996,
-0.12646865844726562,
-0.34905141592025757,
0.3158954381942749,
-0.3129974603652954,
-0.6898735165596008,
0.42142558097839355,
0.32454660534858704,
0.042971421033144,
-0.5462945699691772,
0.2034294605255127,
0.2163725346326828,
0.4849646985530853,
0.36517074704170227,
0.3000739812850952,
-0.820960283279419,
-0.5386332869529724,
-0.1133173406124115,
-0.1809128075838089,
0.2351728081703186,
0.7532523274421692,
-0.6167237758636475,
0.538970947265625,
0.5161222815513611,
0.44043639302253723,
0.03023793175816536,
0.645828902721405,
0.6469564437866211,
-0.28614723682403564,
0.25358864665031433,
0.6271376013755798,
0.021424997597932816,
0.1328517645597458,
-0.6939046382904053,
0.04888143017888069,
0.2886049151420593,
-1.0047152042388916,
-0.582225501537323,
0.12555940449237823,
-0.9445493221282959,
0.04544675722718239,
1.0197738409042358,
0.08848383277654648,
0.009966699406504631,
-0.2617129385471344,
-0.36952802538871765,
0.22365617752075195,
-0.6125340461730957,
1.438554286956787,
0.6691128015518188,
-0.6962164044380188,
-0.1703394502401352,
-0.35638320446014404,
0.5151491165161133,
0.5771633982658386,
-0.9947665929794312,
0.055839307606220245,
0.2074011117219925,
-0.10666944086551666,
0.25034329295158386,
0.6703738570213318,
0.12874452769756317,
0.2513372600078583,
0.10018842667341232,
0.047839999198913574,
0.29738134145736694,
-0.2988928258419037,
-0.48288634419441223,
0.43550315499305725,
0.11469098925590515,
-0.04598028212785721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12204v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12204v1 | Enhancing Multilingual Capabilities of Large Language Models through Self-Distillation from Resource-Rich Languages | 2024-02-19T15:07:32 | 2024-02-19T15:07:32 | Yuanchi Zhang, Yile Wang, Zijun Liu, Shuo Wang, Xiaolong Wang, Peng Li, Maosong Sun, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) have been pre-trained on multilingual
corpora, their performance still lags behind in most languages compared to a
few resource-rich languages. One common approach to mitigate this issue is to
translate training data from resource-rich languages into other languages and
then continue training. However, using the data obtained solely relying on
translation while ignoring the original capabilities of LLMs across languages
is not always effective, which we show will limit the performance of
cross-lingual knowledge transfer. In this work, we propose SDRRL, a method
based on Self-Distillation from Resource-Rich Languages that effectively
improve multilingual performance by leveraging the internal capabilities of
LLMs on resource-rich languages. We evaluate on different LLMs (LLaMA-2 and
SeaLLM) and source languages across various comprehension and generation tasks,
experimental results demonstrate that SDRRL can significantly enhance
multilingual capabilities while minimizing the impact on original performance
in resource-rich languages. | [
-0.43350550532341003,
-0.40885475277900696,
0.49320027232170105,
0.34080618619918823,
-0.44750404357910156,
0.5429619550704956,
-0.5860025882720947,
-0.48262810707092285,
0.14890660345554352,
0.5849190354347229,
-0.4321054220199585,
-0.09649493545293808,
-0.5256837606430054,
0.4570125937461853,
0.04750680550932884,
1.2924524545669556,
-0.08321096748113632,
0.21723519265651703,
-0.1383153349161148,
-0.3485294580459595,
-0.351078063249588,
-0.6166144609451294,
-0.3526811897754669,
-0.36941835284233093,
0.6695603728294373,
0.3380337953567505,
0.30749547481536865,
0.6022242903709412,
0.5010058283805847,
0.29491496086120605,
-0.08183814585208893,
0.3424525856971741,
-0.6635035872459412,
0.2238685041666031,
-0.4784102141857147,
-0.42266643047332764,
-0.2293287217617035,
-0.32180488109588623,
0.8808304071426392,
0.560810923576355,
-0.1875552088022232,
0.36679938435554504,
0.4004085659980774,
0.74027419090271,
-0.5985889434814453,
0.2819693684577942,
-0.6023266315460205,
0.020107483491301537,
-0.2747746706008911,
-0.225661039352417,
-0.28675389289855957,
-0.1178167387843132,
-0.12310639768838882,
-0.3965216875076294,
0.17220360040664673,
-0.16867277026176453,
0.2521405518054962,
0.45958712697029114,
-0.14698046445846558,
-0.22324813902378082,
-0.7359451651573181,
0.9577308893203735,
-0.7574461102485657,
0.6768814921379089,
0.3722814619541168,
0.25296562910079956,
0.26978984475135803,
-0.5416457056999207,
-0.4753907322883606,
-0.2166430801153183,
-0.2452293038368225,
-0.13210012018680573,
-0.0046052648685872555,
-0.27421367168426514,
0.22773562371730804,
0.08552499860525131,
-0.3930050730705261,
0.2747346758842468,
-0.6695528626441956,
-0.17247307300567627,
0.6831710338592529,
-0.08184254169464111,
0.08661817759275436,
-0.10819989442825317,
-0.4392941892147064,
-0.2526297867298126,
-0.7288194298744202,
-0.11185405403375626,
0.1556326299905777,
0.7125065326690674,
-0.0864432230591774,
0.5468471646308899,
-0.02638905495405197,
0.46769046783447266,
-0.16503283381462097,
-0.6088632345199585,
0.32680219411849976,
-0.6495620012283325,
-0.06945732235908508,
0.22534891963005066,
0.6568295359611511,
-0.04474543780088425,
0.24559564888477325,
-0.1805286556482315,
-0.2841561734676361,
-0.34140557050704956,
-0.23903854191303253,
-0.8624945282936096,
-0.159323588013649,
0.0600363165140152,
-0.3312743008136749,
0.1218988224864006,
-0.5077275633811951,
-0.7962966561317444,
-0.2713831961154938,
-0.4939477741718292,
0.08198351413011551,
-0.31320711970329285,
-0.7265965938568115,
-0.04887991398572922,
-0.053650613874197006,
-0.15697044134140015,
0.12665559351444244,
-0.9997228384017944,
-0.056037042289972305,
0.2838822305202484,
0.9002019166946411,
-0.2987041473388672,
-0.5742860436439514,
-0.5937695503234863,
0.448684960603714,
-0.23637571930885315,
0.6400134563446045,
-0.2973090410232544,
-0.36364278197288513,
-0.12976188957691193,
-0.15076841413974762,
-0.005577614530920982,
-0.6992464065551758,
0.21546722948551178,
-0.5102218985557556,
-0.24008949100971222,
-0.5082420706748962,
-0.1788351684808731,
0.04360612854361534,
0.13001509010791779,
-0.7753868699073792,
1.0153030157089233,
-0.04055885598063469,
-0.6845155954360962,
0.26182475686073303,
-0.5616108179092407,
-0.6192658543586731,
0.09332051128149033,
-0.18938490748405457,
-0.04420119896531105,
0.1553795486688614,
0.3234162926673889,
0.4789678156375885,
-0.26047223806381226,
0.19939261674880981,
-0.34233713150024414,
0.06712152808904648,
0.23152635991573334,
-0.4659019410610199,
0.6875901818275452,
0.539007842540741,
-0.015239282511174679,
-0.12182595580816269,
-0.7526218891143799,
0.2055174857378006,
0.16553084552288055,
-0.5685204267501831,
-0.5608888268470764,
-0.4321548640727997,
0.0423511303961277,
0.5005667805671692,
0.504536509513855,
-0.4298451244831085,
0.17233477532863617,
-0.09060616791248322,
0.30883488059043884,
0.7530932426452637,
-0.40232187509536743,
0.48398417234420776,
-0.10177463293075562,
0.6429938077926636,
0.04525573551654816,
-0.1665521264076233,
-0.12616340816020966,
-0.05596962198615074,
-0.7641379833221436,
-0.638733446598053,
0.3337997496128082,
0.43528518080711365,
-1.0653859376907349,
0.06836172193288803,
-0.3575429618358612,
-0.334615558385849,
-0.9007711410522461,
0.8688273429870605,
0.38102033734321594,
0.3084620535373688,
0.5802753567695618,
-0.06880946457386017,
-0.6001176834106445,
-0.7869094014167786,
-0.08459099382162094,
-0.21699167788028717,
0.21657688915729523,
-0.0012332123005762696,
0.2318560928106308,
-0.1024855375289917,
0.8334583044052124,
-0.29735803604125977,
-0.4599321782588959,
-0.7899914979934692,
0.010058857500553131,
0.18986643850803375,
0.3661893904209137,
0.5470067858695984,
-0.6205998063087463,
-0.7490146160125732,
0.2314092367887497,
-0.7275028228759766,
-0.31974196434020996,
-0.10604306310415268,
0.03603019937872887,
0.4376000165939331,
0.562618613243103,
-0.2153354436159134,
-0.07079654932022095,
0.8779235482215881,
-0.019809411838650703,
0.5535986423492432,
-0.5901244282722473,
-0.006990854628384113,
-0.9199312925338745,
0.18058131635189056,
-0.04625683277845383,
-0.1326904445886612,
-0.6379669904708862,
0.08966164290904999,
0.18342795968055725,
0.051492851227521896,
-0.579733669757843,
0.8361557722091675,
-0.7395999431610107,
-0.21995031833648682,
-0.36809515953063965,
0.08546308428049088,
0.09332553297281265,
0.341970831155777,
0.27787208557128906,
0.800099790096283,
0.3567220866680145,
-0.5086565017700195,
0.25891852378845215,
0.1704547256231308,
-0.34713804721832275,
0.4752489924430847,
-0.3925723731517792,
-0.13411405682563782,
-0.24072983860969543,
-0.023284059017896652,
-0.7928364872932434,
0.09596060961484909,
-0.1582205891609192,
0.0797782689332962,
0.5698040127754211,
-0.3710666596889496,
-0.4283907413482666,
-0.21580453217029572,
0.07039405405521393,
0.43294835090637207,
0.3366004526615143,
-0.7801706790924072,
0.5390222668647766,
0.12658025324344635,
-0.36717653274536133,
-0.7981563806533813,
-1.0941276550292969,
0.060989584773778915,
-0.44371265172958374,
-0.5047245025634766,
0.06593664735555649,
-0.2713528275489807,
-0.29317668080329895,
-0.16750779747962952,
0.10255858302116394,
-0.1616661250591278,
0.05957955867052078,
-0.26820775866508484,
0.27899664640426636,
-0.09521985799074173,
0.3190831243991852,
0.05134696885943413,
-0.03422421216964722,
-0.18641549348831177,
-0.1513441950082779,
0.613007128238678,
-0.05426012724637985,
-0.4724079370498657,
-0.3628198802471161,
0.3735716640949249,
0.6325351595878601,
-0.6534875631332397,
0.8084402680397034,
0.7854073643684387,
0.16274887323379517,
-0.5351653099060059,
-0.8245499134063721,
-0.20773161947727203,
-0.48567482829093933,
0.48805779218673706,
-0.6300186514854431,
-0.9198797345161438,
0.5929175019264221,
-0.15586571395397186,
0.010756568983197212,
0.27886223793029785,
0.6695763468742371,
0.046278394758701324,
0.6677642464637756,
0.7703734636306763,
-0.294494092464447,
0.5184701085090637,
-0.31617555022239685,
0.16963934898376465,
-0.8815308809280396,
-0.15103895962238312,
-0.422627717256546,
-0.08479723334312439,
-0.4924917221069336,
-0.7020035982131958,
0.26739707589149475,
0.3051033914089203,
0.07276272773742676,
0.3072861135005951,
-0.22316356003284454,
0.3893144130706787,
0.4366426467895508,
-0.18709464371204376,
0.6233839392662048,
0.33823278546333313,
-0.30986687541007996,
-0.18669402599334717,
-0.9432747960090637,
-0.31424546241760254,
1.0332282781600952,
0.4245270788669586,
1.0171232223510742,
0.1974778026342392,
0.9535600543022156,
0.19212695956230164,
0.2671729624271393,
-0.360174298286438,
0.3425571918487549,
-0.3662366569042206,
-0.42128413915634155,
-0.4871934950351715,
-0.670871913433075,
-0.5739082098007202,
0.6548922657966614,
-0.0700172483921051,
-0.24693487584590912,
0.08311358094215393,
-0.0480429083108902,
-0.27404531836509705,
0.38721829652786255,
-0.5843793153762817,
0.6496598720550537,
-0.7760397791862488,
-0.6301244497299194,
-0.27320942282676697,
-0.2039637565612793,
0.263593465089798,
-0.5397903323173523,
0.49923622608184814,
-0.2712554633617401,
0.020358571782708168,
0.5132012963294983,
-0.14270375669002533,
0.7845551371574402,
-0.13068681955337524,
-0.5885652899742126,
0.25042325258255005,
0.1230422630906105,
0.5508821606636047,
0.09440535306930542,
-0.18150544166564941,
0.4676629900932312,
0.00834066141396761,
-0.2916441261768341,
-0.5406566858291626,
0.7226774096488953,
-0.7498815059661865,
-0.6049429774284363,
-0.20338179171085358,
-0.6336460709571838,
-0.16773642599582672,
0.21235322952270508,
-0.045045893639326096,
0.1329750269651413,
-0.07662798464298248,
0.09816493839025497,
0.43294814229011536,
-0.15807555615901947,
0.7765118479728699,
0.8654189705848694,
-0.2734210789203644,
-0.3966916501522064,
0.9592897295951843,
0.3584604263305664,
0.5012738108634949,
0.21748919785022736,
0.24034906923770905,
-0.828265905380249,
-0.6154592633247375,
-0.7613576650619507,
0.4847719669342041,
-0.7923927307128906,
-0.21948747336864471,
-0.6680297255516052,
-0.17807963490486145,
-0.4631713926792145,
-0.002878273604437709,
-0.6340567469596863,
-0.4126940071582794,
-0.3350766897201538,
0.014933940954506397,
0.2421252727508545,
0.5832067728042603,
-0.6058805584907532,
-0.023020632565021515,
-0.9900339245796204,
0.2514825761318207,
0.25306203961372375,
0.37872079014778137,
0.15757843852043152,
-0.6795966625213623,
-0.49741294980049133,
0.23336099088191986,
0.011965018697082996,
-0.3168286681175232,
0.7035738229751587,
0.4046368896961212,
0.8656359910964966,
0.19887949526309967,
0.15631172060966492,
0.9776915311813354,
-0.516703188419342,
0.44947028160095215,
0.44341427087783813,
-0.7467223405838013,
0.3550131916999817,
-0.049943435937166214,
0.29109886288642883,
0.5195578932762146,
0.4495801627635956,
-0.5456326603889465,
-0.39606866240501404,
-0.1375613510608673,
-0.5475988984107971,
0.6692473292350769,
-0.026952771469950676,
0.06225476413965225,
0.03062664344906807,
0.08372654020786285,
0.19216375052928925,
0.11580902338027954,
-0.9015306234359741,
-0.017824403941631317,
-0.24484698474407196,
0.013632928021252155,
-0.34911710023880005,
-0.3367512822151184,
-0.1356092393398285,
-0.09738575667142868,
0.5119292736053467,
-0.3929682970046997,
-0.3626388907432556,
0.23805436491966248,
-0.3502150774002075,
-0.054766684770584106,
0.3238637447357178,
0.3686910569667816,
0.9158614873886108,
0.0863921195268631,
0.3279572129249573,
0.48939943313598633,
-0.24805861711502075,
0.3293857276439667,
0.05106120929121971,
0.26029595732688904,
-0.2413913607597351,
0.49996763467788696,
0.6211118698120117,
0.06988474726676941,
-0.7890757918357849,
0.09325762093067169,
0.05674850195646286,
0.12864629924297333,
0.021580154076218605,
0.016315340995788574,
0.19998984038829803,
0.6570025682449341,
0.4796639680862427,
-0.3289131820201874,
-0.16238799691200256,
-0.4778801202774048,
0.13529489934444427,
0.35905715823173523,
0.08855685591697693,
-0.16448333859443665,
0.5203424692153931,
0.11222797632217407,
0.18127655982971191,
0.5976263880729675,
-0.0496002659201622,
-0.35294049978256226,
0.31795385479927063,
0.8973677754402161,
0.56893390417099,
-0.4916746914386749,
0.1952461153268814,
0.5693594217300415,
0.2776075303554535,
-0.30749645829200745,
0.12457317113876343,
-0.18502703309059143,
-0.7679911851882935,
-0.8269402980804443,
-0.9596598148345947,
-0.043528370559215546,
0.07621464878320694,
-0.6220899820327759,
0.10567449778318405,
-0.18153057992458344,
-0.11193974316120148,
-0.16106531023979187,
0.07826488465070724,
-0.7319760322570801,
-0.1123451367020607,
0.3385419249534607,
0.7563860416412354,
-0.8852359652519226,
1.1910929679870605,
0.3827093243598938,
-0.4311579167842865,
-0.4767098128795624,
-0.40123632550239563,
-0.3802933692932129,
-0.7820017337799072,
1.2324270009994507,
-0.1734023094177246,
-0.15531346201896667,
-0.08832364529371262,
-0.0710320845246315,
-1.1072601079940796,
1.057713270187378,
0.6748048663139343,
-0.8398180603981018,
0.12226401269435883,
0.6285425424575806,
0.6751044392585754,
-0.3010137379169464,
0.09393803030252457,
0.5070161819458008,
0.48912397027015686,
0.1494365781545639,
-1.254866123199463,
-0.0721808522939682,
0.013553907163441181,
0.2926945388317108,
-0.08525753766298294,
-0.6982052326202393,
0.7971426248550415,
-0.4733630418777466,
-0.2622182369232178,
-0.19833256304264069,
0.7468290328979492,
0.43707191944122314,
-0.06429750472307205,
0.40602776408195496,
0.4895836114883423,
0.8427128791809082,
0.2877417504787445,
0.7015340328216553,
-0.4620455801486969,
0.32599279284477234,
1.4031827449798584,
-0.6096900701522827,
0.9264234900474548,
0.6563976407051086,
-0.10009981691837311,
0.2152620255947113,
0.19557695090770721,
-0.006816258653998375,
0.7965092658996582,
0.06717521697282791,
-0.42505910992622375,
-0.40970978140830994,
-0.35019442439079285,
-0.4950380027294159,
0.7215949892997742,
0.24150246381759644,
-0.33659565448760986,
-0.4784449636936188,
0.2597652077674866,
-0.0911613330245018,
0.13176396489143372,
-0.2463754266500473,
0.7416173219680786,
0.11996928602457047,
-0.6146513819694519,
0.9480330944061279,
-0.08815169334411621,
0.7580994367599487,
-0.764484703540802,
-0.08086976408958435,
-0.4335772395133972,
0.30355119705200195,
-0.04488009214401245,
-0.8017809391021729,
0.35129058361053467,
0.14733624458312988,
-0.2301405817270279,
-0.6107136011123657,
0.6691610217094421,
-0.8782939910888672,
-0.630283772945404,
0.7298560738563538,
0.9843130111694336,
0.1982302963733673,
0.19796162843704224,
-0.6075124144554138,
0.21510927379131317,
0.15377476811408997,
0.060974884778261185,
0.6137425899505615,
0.5972162485122681,
0.1721680611371994,
0.8889254331588745,
0.9419189095497131,
0.4221797585487366,
0.12311463057994843,
0.0581999272108078,
0.9180136322975159,
-0.38346466422080994,
-0.4977743327617645,
-0.9605838060379028,
0.3072957992553711,
-0.00330002186819911,
-0.05372348800301552,
0.9193524718284607,
0.5179877281188965,
1.1019366979599,
-0.05499178171157837,
1.0383256673812866,
-0.04612521827220917,
0.4313231408596039,
-0.5289344787597656,
0.9972182512283325,
-0.6383015513420105,
0.35199427604675293,
0.04126327484846115,
-0.9584304094314575,
-0.00442548468708992,
0.5596336722373962,
-0.09709290415048599,
-0.008151747286319733,
0.4856722056865692,
0.6870999336242676,
-0.03816825523972511,
-0.36217278242111206,
0.6450369954109192,
0.1830829381942749,
0.40398046374320984,
0.29748594760894775,
0.7589375972747803,
0.12869828939437866,
0.6104245781898499,
-0.45460543036460876,
-0.12537607550621033,
0.009379545226693153,
-0.9976779222488403,
-1.0753713846206665,
-0.6056463718414307,
-0.12476447224617004,
-0.185576394200325,
-0.07226705551147461,
0.7909226417541504,
0.6000357866287231,
-0.6141130328178406,
-0.5288534164428711,
0.37207135558128357,
0.10012788325548172,
-0.06292318552732468,
-0.11344756931066513,
0.30982014536857605,
-0.7159725427627563,
-0.6380497217178345,
0.7182716727256775,
0.1400860846042633,
0.11971882730722427,
-0.8244971036911011,
-0.17011475563049316,
-0.18184421956539154,
-0.22305597364902496,
0.7177482843399048,
0.3168947100639343,
-0.5986206531524658,
0.014714066870510578,
-0.20023776590824127,
-0.09740064293146133,
0.0223228856921196,
0.7938562631607056,
-0.7016739249229431,
0.6026338338851929,
0.37167888879776,
0.6145815253257751,
0.4339171051979065,
-0.22624781727790833,
0.46572497487068176,
-0.837151288986206,
0.2971791923046112,
0.015288607217371464,
0.44082513451576233,
0.6166859865188599,
-0.21280606091022491,
0.5626123547554016,
-0.006505734287202358,
-0.38505175709724426,
-0.76518714427948,
0.011395714245736599,
-0.5624613761901855,
-0.5288524031639099,
1.3815531730651855,
-0.30596402287483215,
-0.10153313726186752,
-0.09927920997142792,
-0.06244295462965965,
0.3035300374031067,
-0.2595459520816803,
0.7297988533973694,
0.5366917252540588,
0.10951989144086838,
-0.23988986015319824,
-0.5716158151626587,
0.5612674355506897,
0.18139679729938507,
-0.7129033207893372,
0.49483585357666016,
0.2901671230792999,
0.5073061585426331,
0.26143231987953186,
0.6406839489936829,
-0.05148207023739815,
-0.05095604062080383,
-0.22728589177131653,
0.203578382730484,
-0.2546694874763489,
-0.5377303957939148,
-0.3651373088359833,
0.025027329102158546,
0.10946636646986008,
0.218482106924057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12198v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12198v1 | Zero shot VLMs for hate meme detection: Are we there yet? | 2024-02-19T15:03:04 | 2024-02-19T15:03:04 | Naquee Rizwan, Paramananda Bhaskar, Mithun Das, Swadhin Satyaprakash Majhi, Punyajoy Saha, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Multimedia content on social media is rapidly evolving, with memes gaining
prominence as a distinctive form. Unfortunately, some malicious users exploit
memes to target individuals or vulnerable communities, making it imperative to
identify and address such instances of hateful memes. Extensive research has
been conducted to address this issue by developing hate meme detection models.
However, a notable limitation of traditional machine/deep learning models is
the requirement for labeled datasets for accurate classification. Recently, the
research community has witnessed the emergence of several visual language
models that have exhibited outstanding performance across various tasks. In
this study, we aim to investigate the efficacy of these visual language models
in handling intricate tasks such as hate meme detection. We use various prompt
settings to focus on zero-shot classification of hateful/harmful memes. Through
our analysis, we observe that large VLMs are still vulnerable for zero-shot
hate meme detection. | [
-0.4403586685657501,
-0.8504916429519653,
0.4324672818183899,
0.05447535589337349,
-0.37214040756225586,
0.19910626113414764,
0.15099148452281952,
-0.4205223619937897,
0.16562841832637787,
0.3891809284687042,
-0.7759808301925659,
-0.5715385675430298,
-0.7456112504005432,
0.09638220816850662,
-0.6486436724662781,
0.7311217784881592,
0.1971215009689331,
-0.16635346412658691,
-0.09326150268316269,
-0.48878854513168335,
-0.5973369479179382,
-0.6323262453079224,
-0.6055235862731934,
0.08320708572864532,
0.9761348962783813,
0.444995641708374,
0.4441009759902954,
0.5106499791145325,
0.5288786888122559,
0.2488361895084381,
0.15290787816047668,
-0.2638998329639435,
-0.5710209608078003,
0.4651440680027008,
-0.2335793673992157,
-0.2926715910434723,
-0.0270353052765131,
0.056028030812740326,
0.3415554165840149,
0.2509728670120239,
0.1454751342535019,
0.3704160749912262,
-0.31783026456832886,
0.1874210238456726,
-0.8283314108848572,
-0.3717704117298126,
-0.9048128724098206,
0.2880729138851166,
-0.39131221175193787,
-0.22972366213798523,
-0.43372994661331177,
-0.061741914600133896,
0.05489351227879524,
-0.12477627396583557,
0.06008068099617958,
-0.013843473047018051,
0.6199366450309753,
0.13147616386413574,
-0.30591240525245667,
-0.24004100263118744,
-0.7329753637313843,
1.2263717651367188,
-0.9143247008323669,
0.2267039716243744,
-0.03993969038128853,
0.4751713275909424,
0.03125937655568123,
-0.2827432155609131,
-0.7318386435508728,
-0.25835487246513367,
0.3355953097343445,
-0.08845692873001099,
-0.8931480646133423,
-0.2803981304168701,
0.3894394040107727,
0.02696690894663334,
-0.8713018298149109,
0.7103094458580017,
-0.5178501009941101,
-0.27797064185142517,
0.4804137647151947,
0.5535517930984497,
0.5546686053276062,
-0.3411509692668915,
-0.5866591334342957,
0.10611151903867722,
-0.44978392124176025,
-0.13680399954319,
0.18744701147079468,
0.22467593848705292,
0.03019195795059204,
0.8253485560417175,
-0.3001187741756439,
0.9952037334442139,
-0.33750489354133606,
-0.19407354295253754,
0.0075934710912406445,
0.08881942927837372,
-0.485721617937088,
-0.193034827709198,
0.8765645027160645,
0.571988046169281,
0.5526857376098633,
0.043028172105550766,
-0.1038912907242775,
0.4480750858783722,
0.5424429774284363,
-1.008034348487854,
0.06862610578536987,
-0.03827599436044693,
-0.2989566922187805,
-0.7361869812011719,
-0.4478878080844879,
-0.6176512241363525,
-0.573844313621521,
-0.18747515976428986,
0.4414689540863037,
-0.2779511511325836,
-0.26197928190231323,
-0.14307208359241486,
-0.28884193301200867,
0.24558353424072266,
0.7185488939285278,
-0.47815820574760437,
-0.04483836144208908,
0.2732386589050293,
0.7792637944221497,
-0.08992860466241837,
-0.07139144092798233,
-0.5652011632919312,
-0.08776727318763733,
-0.4125247895717621,
0.812644898891449,
-0.6143295764923096,
-0.014706355519592762,
0.21842323243618011,
-0.028387587517499924,
0.11455431580543518,
-0.39778295159339905,
0.5115447640419006,
-0.5486010909080505,
0.03324046730995178,
-0.32390180230140686,
-0.5493481159210205,
-0.34269559383392334,
0.5975531339645386,
-0.4521491229534149,
0.33801308274269104,
0.35904210805892944,
-0.5984432697296143,
0.471212774515152,
-0.46510735154151917,
-0.2708549499511719,
0.34443631768226624,
-0.2490638792514801,
-0.6591112017631531,
0.21353912353515625,
-0.36584293842315674,
0.9280604124069214,
-0.03242771700024605,
-0.18875502049922943,
-0.9699707627296448,
-0.1949751228094101,
0.1814591884613037,
-0.593012809753418,
0.8393256068229675,
0.5242542028427124,
-0.418686181306839,
0.2643827497959137,
-0.5892104506492615,
-0.2167653888463974,
0.4741363823413849,
0.03281071037054062,
-0.581890881061554,
-0.30125826597213745,
0.11954189091920853,
0.6236335635185242,
-0.14890408515930176,
-0.8071500062942505,
0.16816945374011993,
0.3348104655742645,
0.16252543032169342,
0.9065280556678772,
-0.1499023288488388,
0.255487322807312,
0.05137027055025101,
0.7135056257247925,
0.2582739591598511,
0.39483270049095154,
0.016800396144390106,
-0.5770379304885864,
-0.5896763801574707,
-0.24691839516162872,
-0.23990969359874725,
0.48720428347587585,
-0.97339928150177,
0.054111167788505554,
0.13675858080387115,
-0.5254973769187927,
-0.25721707940101624,
0.203163281083107,
0.2755998373031616,
0.5741428136825562,
0.492603063583374,
-0.26533371210098267,
-0.6394864320755005,
-0.9436498284339905,
-0.0908549353480339,
-0.10835974663496017,
-0.0879567489027977,
0.40160804986953735,
0.32939037680625916,
-0.3339647054672241,
0.5480049252510071,
-0.3481411933898926,
-0.3566865622997284,
-0.21483184397220612,
0.2676546275615692,
0.020101012662053108,
0.06935286521911621,
1.143180012702942,
-0.5988189578056335,
-0.6433858275413513,
-0.3856077790260315,
-1.1508750915527344,
-0.4397289454936981,
-0.010211139917373657,
0.2416844218969345,
0.2065654993057251,
0.4349309802055359,
-0.009579190984368324,
0.5900964736938477,
0.5510425567626953,
-0.584044873714447,
0.6685741543769836,
0.3707667887210846,
0.364666223526001,
-0.5008179545402527,
-0.3112662732601166,
0.30732306838035583,
-0.506515383720398,
-0.9380717873573303,
-0.24870836734771729,
-0.159002885222435,
-0.030930425971746445,
-0.8680905103683472,
0.522066056728363,
-0.32902997732162476,
0.09368370473384857,
-0.41740384697914124,
-0.128352552652359,
-0.42151501774787903,
0.35633668303489685,
-0.034259289503097534,
0.32805564999580383,
0.723089873790741,
-0.5062224268913269,
0.317839652299881,
-0.08288716524839401,
-0.22872959077358246,
0.9048839211463928,
-0.41401758790016174,
-0.0716012641787529,
-0.33098965883255005,
-0.2759782075881958,
-0.8692629933357239,
0.060103725641965866,
0.8267612457275391,
-0.487920880317688,
0.3771761953830719,
-0.1325901448726654,
-0.2743270695209503,
-0.622860312461853,
-0.43124860525131226,
0.48052024841308594,
0.5585969686508179,
-0.2643336057662964,
0.11375703662633896,
0.20854441821575165,
0.20241490006446838,
-0.7408835291862488,
-0.5039170980453491,
0.16981202363967896,
-0.35456961393356323,
-0.36853551864624023,
-0.343612939119339,
-0.1771073192358017,
-0.28327450156211853,
0.09242022782564163,
0.010126407258212566,
-0.09678689390420914,
0.13996316492557526,
0.44843167066574097,
0.08359669893980026,
-0.44182005524635315,
-0.13588455319404602,
-0.300448477268219,
-0.12394200265407562,
-0.3637015223503113,
-0.0835663452744484,
0.5433381795883179,
-0.02589145116508007,
-0.5411911606788635,
-0.28000426292419434,
0.4246983826160431,
1.04377281665802,
-0.1566491723060608,
0.8483903408050537,
0.7450771927833557,
-0.3504442870616913,
-0.3553302586078644,
-0.7058653831481934,
0.10268394649028778,
-0.4567078948020935,
0.31685301661491394,
-0.11846613883972168,
-1.3734546899795532,
0.38752761483192444,
0.3036811351776123,
-0.026649953797459602,
0.44872501492500305,
0.578294038772583,
-0.2697352468967438,
0.7900501489639282,
0.6483024954795837,
-0.29702338576316833,
0.6645421385765076,
-0.1425935924053192,
0.22451885044574738,
-0.316898912191391,
-0.0075790127739310265,
-0.38618209958076477,
-0.3668837547302246,
-0.17507429420948029,
-0.6545970439910889,
0.2789655327796936,
0.047404926270246506,
-0.042176105082035065,
0.4224369525909424,
-0.5466983318328857,
0.27391523122787476,
0.32128167152404785,
-0.0431353822350502,
-0.08627749234437943,
0.34136462211608887,
0.2693387269973755,
-0.36860546469688416,
-0.5573604106903076,
-0.24924929440021515,
1.0377854108810425,
0.35890263319015503,
0.8016005158424377,
0.053934577852487564,
0.29151472449302673,
0.8425689339637756,
0.47877007722854614,
-0.7384209036827087,
0.5706727504730225,
-0.32724156975746155,
-0.550457239151001,
-0.4787273108959198,
-0.08753704279661179,
-0.8817617893218994,
-0.01853330247104168,
-0.20644892752170563,
-0.6794097423553467,
-0.09564975649118423,
0.14577093720436096,
-0.09079748392105103,
0.6432673335075378,
-0.20891030132770538,
1.1353734731674194,
-0.21017800271511078,
-0.21112319827079773,
-0.269559770822525,
-0.3987109065055847,
0.3268812298774719,
0.0022347436752170324,
0.15306168794631958,
-0.4831525981426239,
0.15093062818050385,
0.5631412267684937,
-0.3126718997955322,
0.971415638923645,
-0.39224258065223694,
0.07401110231876373,
0.6556481719017029,
0.3359571695327759,
0.025915812700986862,
-0.5666138529777527,
-0.00015771180915180594,
0.4676854908466339,
-0.420534610748291,
-0.744044303894043,
-0.5124770998954773,
0.7325924634933472,
-0.2973586618900299,
-0.3274042308330536,
-0.3971911370754242,
-0.13338139653205872,
0.24237380921840668,
0.22593086957931519,
0.12754276394844055,
0.39101654291152954,
-0.2289423644542694,
0.2610081732273102,
0.7186826467514038,
-0.3663557469844818,
0.5104756355285645,
0.803412675857544,
-0.4218604266643524,
-0.061615318059921265,
1.2443459033966064,
0.5514945983886719,
0.19558829069137573,
0.19002842903137207,
-0.13102294504642487,
-0.04468372091650963,
-0.8971554040908813,
-0.7166618704795837,
-0.04151752218604088,
-0.5596573948860168,
-0.37626051902770996,
-0.7521371245384216,
-0.18583671748638153,
-0.2912779152393341,
-0.3854057490825653,
-0.2107766568660736,
-0.1560165137052536,
-0.3446626663208008,
-0.1108943372964859,
0.349862664937973,
1.0040907859802246,
-0.043171226978302,
0.26869308948516846,
-0.7201107144355774,
0.40460720658302307,
0.4501354992389679,
0.47322261333465576,
0.15532593429088593,
-0.7354757785797119,
-0.21922558546066284,
-0.1333366483449936,
-0.20809873938560486,
-1.1599950790405273,
0.3779750168323517,
-0.20075906813144684,
0.5030234456062317,
0.6255553960800171,
0.07261105626821518,
0.4869800806045532,
-0.5253766775131226,
0.7718760967254639,
0.41870343685150146,
-0.5236912965774536,
0.5222523808479309,
-0.450421541929245,
0.13556842505931854,
0.27303946018218994,
0.6413064002990723,
-0.6133992075920105,
-0.5616335272789001,
-0.5849468111991882,
-0.324503630399704,
0.37931057810783386,
0.23705048859119415,
0.4949464797973633,
-0.20722422003746033,
0.16102725267410278,
0.0676041767001152,
0.3380686938762665,
-0.8526307940483093,
-0.4482233226299286,
-0.2666163146495819,
0.1397618055343628,
0.09262919425964355,
-0.7946555018424988,
0.35883015394210815,
-0.3243783116340637,
0.44705089926719666,
0.0776536613702774,
-0.0879475325345993,
-0.03941631689667702,
-0.2310018241405487,
-0.46987849473953247,
0.2354612946510315,
0.6904967427253723,
0.431695818901062,
-0.269349068403244,
0.2294798195362091,
0.04052434861660004,
-0.20048147439956665,
0.2774818241596222,
-0.4890837073326111,
-0.5105728507041931,
0.31881237030029297,
0.3692343831062317,
0.8701339364051819,
0.08217019587755203,
-0.7915878891944885,
0.8487482070922852,
-0.03018324263393879,
-0.17996928095817566,
-0.39682435989379883,
0.04799164459109306,
-0.23552870750427246,
0.23711438477039337,
0.14313122630119324,
0.10507618635892868,
0.20350462198257446,
-0.4820510745048523,
0.5206805467605591,
0.7231617569923401,
-0.7923961877822876,
-0.43334561586380005,
0.7139251828193665,
-0.06306478381156921,
-0.29422223567962646,
0.3707202970981598,
-0.2961413264274597,
-0.6258343458175659,
0.587365984916687,
0.4442204236984253,
0.8745344877243042,
-0.5247961282730103,
0.5714234113693237,
0.38046595454216003,
0.4903102517127991,
0.5033037066459656,
0.03121430054306984,
0.0884234681725502,
-0.7232218384742737,
-0.08488380163908005,
-1.0223883390426636,
-0.24679015576839447,
0.6168977618217468,
-0.2800118625164032,
0.5240293145179749,
-0.6353719830513,
0.12989898025989532,
0.40327712893486023,
-0.44071900844573975,
-0.7135072946548462,
0.41058918833732605,
0.7338300943374634,
0.7074509263038635,
-1.1924091577529907,
0.5402169823646545,
0.4924217462539673,
-0.628035306930542,
-0.5264632701873779,
-0.4998572766780853,
0.35825303196907043,
-0.8258882761001587,
0.41613709926605225,
0.300542414188385,
0.06189887970685959,
-0.06501159071922302,
-1.03231942653656,
-0.4239291250705719,
0.6096630692481995,
0.3088042736053467,
-0.5184428691864014,
0.4113924503326416,
0.13418763875961304,
0.7365877628326416,
-0.4883945882320404,
0.08928340673446655,
0.1094544529914856,
0.3094937801361084,
0.34067589044570923,
-0.49568939208984375,
-0.07737970352172852,
-0.16266758739948273,
-0.262427419424057,
0.12276920676231384,
-0.3786405622959137,
0.9714017510414124,
-0.15408773720264435,
0.04331459105014801,
-0.2626483738422394,
0.51829594373703,
-0.002547463169321418,
0.6357264518737793,
0.7166454792022705,
0.5760560035705566,
0.1470819115638733,
0.4605485200881958,
0.8942910432815552,
0.5139106512069702,
0.2280423939228058,
0.8944664001464844,
-0.10692402720451355,
0.7162819504737854,
0.3399762213230133,
-0.17278075218200684,
0.4712633788585663,
0.44982412457466125,
-0.5582602620124817,
0.30825483798980713,
0.4449220299720764,
-0.525467574596405,
-0.5704199075698853,
-0.541335940361023,
-0.10165228694677353,
0.4099327325820923,
0.336977481842041,
-0.4120030999183655,
-0.543854832649231,
0.34463539719581604,
0.32153794169425964,
0.1510002613067627,
-0.5541382431983948,
0.7293859720230103,
-0.015735862776637077,
-0.031664952635765076,
0.816303551197052,
-0.17155732214450836,
0.8319395184516907,
-0.5440836548805237,
-0.07813594490289688,
0.09119248390197754,
-0.13709433376789093,
-0.3293437361717224,
-0.7756224870681763,
0.40648260712623596,
0.349704772233963,
-0.41936060786247253,
-0.007415127474814653,
1.19748854637146,
-0.3910590708255768,
-0.5299310088157654,
0.6749598383903503,
0.5604001879692078,
0.35493654012680054,
-0.33445265889167786,
-0.7457761168479919,
0.17587773501873016,
0.22118037939071655,
-0.2612728178501129,
0.4694012403488159,
0.3370746076107025,
-0.30820050835609436,
0.7344948053359985,
0.6284191608428955,
-0.20548787713050842,
0.541767418384552,
0.36230340600013733,
0.7287535667419434,
-0.6887967586517334,
0.09032553434371948,
-1.255474328994751,
0.6035942435264587,
-0.2489859014749527,
0.16752615571022034,
0.986701250076294,
0.3160398602485657,
0.8280970454216003,
-0.4206845462322235,
0.9075117111206055,
-0.10911814123392105,
0.5564031004905701,
0.117091104388237,
0.7110579609870911,
-0.9650223851203918,
-0.12646688520908356,
-0.44092464447021484,
-0.6797661185264587,
-0.6564461588859558,
0.1330409049987793,
-0.20797835290431976,
-0.2857109010219574,
0.10594558715820312,
0.5958862900733948,
-0.11504705995321274,
-0.37612584233283997,
0.9938144683837891,
0.3727191984653473,
0.5340067148208618,
0.32757481932640076,
0.8925082683563232,
-0.22823494672775269,
0.5830380916595459,
-0.48842301964759827,
-0.30071085691452026,
-0.5404089689254761,
-0.8850594162940979,
-1.1393659114837646,
-0.33049774169921875,
-0.36249664425849915,
-0.19757279753684998,
-0.04591888561844826,
0.5492081046104431,
0.49457675218582153,
-1.0095603466033936,
0.05036027729511261,
0.16345156729221344,
0.33627966046333313,
0.2562776505947113,
-0.19751235842704773,
-0.14469240605831146,
-0.14515160024166107,
-0.4322837293148041,
0.28449535369873047,
0.8305375576019287,
0.2302280068397522,
-0.280860036611557,
0.01877398043870926,
-0.3301176428794861,
0.24544046819210052,
0.941545844078064,
0.6248969435691833,
-0.7976067662239075,
-0.47668343782424927,
0.06400124728679657,
-0.305101215839386,
-0.1259716898202896,
0.6063045859336853,
-0.6086827516555786,
0.5397910475730896,
0.3929542303085327,
0.5399250984191895,
0.15118299424648285,
-0.09258526563644409,
0.21730473637580872,
-0.5733526945114136,
0.23098842799663544,
0.33421561121940613,
0.2216300219297409,
0.34532612562179565,
-0.1906459480524063,
0.5897808074951172,
0.5699477195739746,
-0.3016273081302643,
-1.0072948932647705,
0.16416694223880768,
-1.1601322889328003,
-0.4387073516845703,
0.8832743763923645,
-0.0011243001790717244,
-0.25923338532447815,
-0.20089633762836456,
-0.19462376832962036,
0.15522131323814392,
-0.2521621286869049,
0.5830962657928467,
0.4582067131996155,
-0.04058891907334328,
-0.3464571535587311,
-0.7187208533287048,
0.24700221419334412,
0.5066100358963013,
-0.479665607213974,
-0.20647048950195312,
0.6371936798095703,
0.40458646416664124,
0.27638885378837585,
0.7858202457427979,
0.20960167050361633,
0.42257219552993774,
-0.1278434842824936,
0.2734566032886505,
-0.10233937203884125,
-0.41775912046432495,
-0.43983152508735657,
0.39791804552078247,
-0.06971532851457596,
-0.35267746448516846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12195v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12195v2 | Browse and Concentrate: Comprehending Multimodal Content via prior-LLM Context Fusion | 2024-02-19T14:59:07 | 2024-06-08T03:04:30 | Ziyue Wang, Chi Chen, Yiqi Zhu, Fuwen Luo, Peng Li, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Maosong Sun, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the bloom of Large Language Models (LLMs), Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) that incorporate LLMs with pre-trained vision models have
recently demonstrated impressive performance across diverse vision-language
tasks. However, they fall short to comprehend context involving multiple
images. A primary reason for this shortcoming is that the visual features for
each images are encoded individually by frozen encoders before feeding into the
LLM backbone, lacking awareness of other images and the multimodal
instructions. We term this issue as prior-LLM modality isolation and propose a
two phase paradigm, browse-and-concentrate, to enable in-depth multimodal
context fusion prior to feeding the features into LLMs. This paradigm initially
"browses" through the inputs for essential insights, and then revisits the
inputs to "concentrate" on crucial details, guided by these insights, to
achieve a more comprehensive understanding of the multimodal inputs.
Additionally, we develop training strategies specifically to enhance the
understanding of multi-image inputs. Our method markedly boosts the performance
on 7 multi-image scenarios, contributing to increments on average accuracy by
2.13% and 7.60% against strong MLLMs baselines with 3B and 11B LLMs,
respectively. | [
-0.6235098242759705,
-0.7184427380561829,
0.8318760991096497,
0.24755264818668365,
-0.43977847695350647,
-0.07212655246257782,
-0.1165364682674408,
-0.3674211800098419,
0.10044664144515991,
0.5582555532455444,
-0.5937707424163818,
-0.3279118537902832,
-0.6531391143798828,
0.07287590205669403,
-0.23917388916015625,
0.38496869802474976,
-0.20719066262245178,
0.23443320393562317,
-0.6185051798820496,
-0.11378432810306549,
-0.7042030096054077,
-0.2786930203437805,
-0.45492348074913025,
-0.21746088564395905,
0.5468289256095886,
0.18170206248760223,
0.2857412099838257,
0.3468165397644043,
0.5095009207725525,
0.3410629332065582,
-0.07098059356212616,
0.5349048972129822,
-0.5909339189529419,
0.39770522713661194,
-0.21267811954021454,
-0.558963418006897,
-0.023293133825063705,
-0.0636138916015625,
0.7446427345275879,
0.5870798826217651,
0.20818541944026947,
-0.20789146423339844,
0.2981932461261749,
0.5963738560676575,
-1.1942602396011353,
-0.0010341490851715207,
-0.6151217222213745,
0.006011880934238434,
-0.19850358366966248,
-0.3057776391506195,
-0.6109374761581421,
0.3226519823074341,
0.42334944009780884,
-0.8298419117927551,
0.18511001765727997,
-0.03550875559449196,
0.8767603635787964,
0.42643308639526367,
-0.6697191596031189,
0.1510317176580429,
-0.4822806119918823,
0.8483445048332214,
-0.17623575031757355,
0.6662050485610962,
0.5432149767875671,
0.19979746639728546,
0.1425512433052063,
-0.874546229839325,
-0.6000941395759583,
0.06466905772686005,
-0.18695130944252014,
0.3701907694339752,
0.008097360841929913,
0.027774028480052948,
0.14953908324241638,
0.31731703877449036,
-0.4541036784648895,
-0.08966110646724701,
-0.2820762097835541,
-0.2957356572151184,
0.17735080420970917,
0.21281443536281586,
0.19740672409534454,
-0.09516815096139908,
-0.5691137909889221,
-0.21130098402500153,
-0.6928943395614624,
0.05460410565137863,
-0.42417585849761963,
-0.1440621167421341,
-0.03359992057085037,
0.5898796319961548,
-0.22502750158309937,
0.6158777475357056,
0.33428001403808594,
-0.6884331703186035,
0.28843191266059875,
-0.678527295589447,
-0.477517306804657,
-0.3241610527038574,
0.46128931641578674,
0.353934645652771,
-0.12565653026103973,
-0.1451655924320221,
-0.16233645379543304,
0.09252790361642838,
0.3375508487224579,
-0.7913147807121277,
-0.1002359539270401,
0.229750394821167,
-0.7218306064605713,
0.010757384821772575,
-0.146286278963089,
-0.5579481720924377,
-0.5421187281608582,
-0.4543597400188446,
0.5652896761894226,
-0.3696308732032776,
-0.26877838373184204,
-0.07637456804513931,
-0.19525201618671417,
0.3860780894756317,
0.5440741181373596,
-0.701702356338501,
-0.0005364136886782944,
0.3558044135570526,
0.9616663455963135,
-0.4809064567089081,
-0.5453785061836243,
-0.6174703240394592,
0.6300368905067444,
-0.11788062006235123,
0.8745777606964111,
-0.6088979840278625,
-0.3724856674671173,
0.28117799758911133,
0.29552730917930603,
-0.43504032492637634,
-0.5541257858276367,
0.22056463360786438,
-0.8380945920944214,
0.24935343861579895,
-0.21718080341815948,
-0.3986521065235138,
-0.6620187759399414,
0.4613945484161377,
-0.57856285572052,
0.6337113380432129,
0.00985837820917368,
-0.7533097863197327,
0.5581422448158264,
-0.3513237237930298,
-0.5500630736351013,
-0.0411570705473423,
-0.21697744727134705,
0.06509674340486526,
0.09413495659828186,
0.5348033308982849,
0.5417858362197876,
-0.05222149193286896,
0.17494146525859833,
-0.5126246809959412,
-0.17650477588176727,
0.22831325232982635,
-0.35214149951934814,
0.41068241000175476,
0.09515808522701263,
-0.20638471841812134,
0.4075705111026764,
-0.348545640707016,
-0.16786210238933563,
0.017177149653434753,
-0.34188637137413025,
-0.27114808559417725,
0.050279516726732254,
0.050367798656225204,
0.3110165596008301,
0.18091677129268646,
-0.19727295637130737,
-0.10653939843177795,
-0.30774161219596863,
0.44866883754730225,
0.6045109033584595,
-0.1477707475423813,
0.8261098861694336,
-0.2180602252483368,
0.5397297143936157,
0.40265002846717834,
0.12360727041959763,
-0.9147439002990723,
-0.20872317254543304,
-0.9180658459663391,
-0.4906021058559418,
0.021974390372633934,
0.6811796426773071,
-1.1487221717834473,
0.01304271724075079,
-0.18931737542152405,
0.04973848909139633,
-0.425629198551178,
0.38371923565864563,
0.4785161018371582,
0.5100036263465881,
0.46127238869667053,
-0.6128627061843872,
-0.2633036971092224,
-1.137162446975708,
0.34445711970329285,
0.32658588886260986,
-0.13870969414710999,
0.45024779438972473,
0.2938055396080017,
-0.3671383559703827,
0.8581658601760864,
-0.4987078607082367,
-0.6308248043060303,
-0.33020633459091187,
-0.12296020239591599,
-0.08149118721485138,
0.517886221408844,
0.3098073899745941,
-1.072199821472168,
-0.5289189219474792,
-0.178237646818161,
-0.7529089450836182,
0.28571900725364685,
-0.07801369577646255,
-0.2627321779727936,
0.14147573709487915,
0.6661134958267212,
-0.5778754353523254,
0.3941591680049896,
0.44596749544143677,
-0.08988971263170242,
0.3081631660461426,
-0.06672943383455276,
0.27260342240333557,
-1.0617344379425049,
0.06841598451137543,
0.0897892490029335,
-0.20947574079036713,
-0.6212103366851807,
0.12217845767736435,
0.23009243607521057,
-0.12890537083148956,
-0.6883732676506042,
0.47676920890808105,
-0.7899196147918701,
0.06111174449324608,
-0.3283036947250366,
0.2688335180282593,
0.5061818957328796,
0.4946328401565552,
0.370076984167099,
0.7695716023445129,
0.9546880722045898,
-0.536969780921936,
-0.045086439698934555,
0.28463882207870483,
-0.30513349175453186,
0.60768723487854,
-0.48658958077430725,
0.18026018142700195,
-0.2641110420227051,
0.36559465527534485,
-1.19483482837677,
-0.5081177949905396,
0.23103338479995728,
-0.0033562148455530405,
0.6993287205696106,
-0.27160656452178955,
-0.333834171295166,
-0.09954030066728592,
-0.3435957729816437,
0.7538694739341736,
0.3602246642112732,
-0.4898509979248047,
0.9758033752441406,
0.500873863697052,
-0.22870579361915588,
-0.5664495825767517,
-0.6847315430641174,
-0.00019624062406364828,
-0.16205886006355286,
-0.9567276835441589,
0.5015457272529602,
-0.0974375307559967,
-0.11800318956375122,
-0.07569459825754166,
0.02452518790960312,
-0.3081204891204834,
-0.0911576971411705,
0.2854994535446167,
0.23449039459228516,
-0.2774465084075928,
-0.06409970670938492,
0.062335021793842316,
0.006743894424289465,
-0.1914655566215515,
-0.16107358038425446,
0.5853240489959717,
0.08848761022090912,
-0.5294942855834961,
-0.5377978086471558,
0.5828065872192383,
0.588699996471405,
-0.38694339990615845,
0.46028125286102295,
0.9392678141593933,
-0.025686750188469887,
0.24225488305091858,
-0.8672013282775879,
-0.3559423089027405,
-0.5187095403671265,
0.41071709990501404,
-0.47732260823249817,
-1.0537809133529663,
0.27647241950035095,
-0.07320726662874222,
-0.10912664979696274,
0.1067248284816742,
0.48824724555015564,
-0.3196297883987427,
1.1176332235336304,
0.9609213471412659,
0.09991461783647537,
0.7432981133460999,
-0.24662691354751587,
-0.01796756312251091,
-1.182738184928894,
-0.5602350234985352,
0.14330840110778809,
-0.36736226081848145,
-0.06647907197475433,
-0.6940774917602539,
0.5139513611793518,
0.3015374541282654,
0.31053051352500916,
-0.21559923887252808,
-0.20904073119163513,
0.6310375928878784,
0.6957336664199829,
0.46954384446144104,
0.07262716442346573,
0.13233670592308044,
-0.3657519817352295,
-0.08664627373218536,
-0.62907475233078,
-0.11586327105760574,
0.9999017119407654,
0.19105088710784912,
0.6612251400947571,
-0.0033505908213555813,
0.44393718242645264,
-0.10183275490999222,
0.11822394281625748,
-0.8964381814002991,
0.4552586078643799,
-0.16242548823356628,
-0.5233202576637268,
-0.04423484578728676,
0.09963508695363998,
-0.9714573621749878,
0.8189651370048523,
-0.3320826292037964,
-0.670880913734436,
0.3619414269924164,
0.25375181436538696,
-0.31045740842819214,
-0.08477162569761276,
-0.7692187428474426,
0.9775425791740417,
-0.10977009683847427,
-0.7397571206092834,
-0.47235172986984253,
-0.847278892993927,
0.7440697550773621,
0.04324039816856384,
0.277058482170105,
0.010176003910601139,
-0.19499263167381287,
0.3345015347003937,
-0.04131561517715454,
0.9892646670341492,
0.05116996541619301,
-0.015275860205292702,
0.07077233493328094,
0.20235484838485718,
0.12202055752277374,
0.016535446047782898,
0.6234487295150757,
-0.03364655002951622,
0.06100944057106972,
-0.3044660985469818,
-0.38211876153945923,
0.47727158665657043,
-0.44589558243751526,
-0.6906984448432922,
-0.1446269452571869,
-0.5619181990623474,
-0.28400373458862305,
0.37459638714790344,
0.28335440158843994,
0.8756176233291626,
0.062132127583026886,
0.3830811679363251,
0.957963228225708,
-0.012542246840894222,
0.5553439259529114,
0.4485224485397339,
-0.32463768124580383,
-0.7542556524276733,
0.8159039616584778,
-0.2646419405937195,
0.3275097906589508,
0.5608593821525574,
-0.1662847399711609,
-0.42031407356262207,
-0.7454972267150879,
-0.3237355351448059,
0.2414582073688507,
-0.9964784979820251,
-0.05194533243775368,
-0.8103252053260803,
0.07556889951229095,
-0.5046654343605042,
-0.36201879382133484,
0.10039796680212021,
0.10432130843400955,
-0.5396126508712769,
0.43556392192840576,
-0.1906019002199173,
0.47739148139953613,
-0.012917516753077507,
0.4322702884674072,
-1.0150030851364136,
0.5957134962081909,
0.4461328089237213,
0.033243682235479355,
0.019069025292992592,
-0.43245401978492737,
-0.3366093039512634,
-0.15888334810733795,
-0.4372100532054901,
-0.8682610392570496,
0.30852973461151123,
0.35166653990745544,
0.76800137758255,
0.841705322265625,
-0.35314053297042847,
0.870401918888092,
-0.42040884494781494,
0.8661580085754395,
0.4881068766117096,
-0.7022866606712341,
0.5869600176811218,
-0.15748928487300873,
0.7468007802963257,
0.6422936320304871,
0.46347013115882874,
-0.4030585289001465,
-0.33781686425209045,
-0.14119070768356323,
-0.9344030022621155,
0.8190937638282776,
-0.18099230527877808,
-0.10204135626554489,
-0.00724200950935483,
0.06906897574663162,
-0.006155795883387327,
0.18396496772766113,
-0.7607524394989014,
-0.08913063257932663,
-0.22254173457622528,
0.04051033407449722,
-0.28583577275276184,
-0.6549327969551086,
-0.4065832197666168,
-0.23293353617191315,
0.3198275864124298,
-0.20583264529705048,
-0.06698624044656754,
0.35596367716789246,
-0.7087955474853516,
0.1479872614145279,
-0.022671004757285118,
0.704866886138916,
0.8159387707710266,
0.0006702321115881205,
0.4920993745326996,
0.03300989046692848,
-0.5999675393104553,
0.018802953884005547,
-0.060856614261865616,
-0.24669131636619568,
-0.2113935649394989,
0.47008955478668213,
0.7127650380134583,
0.4522385597229004,
-0.7329619526863098,
0.5441187620162964,
-0.055702999234199524,
-0.15844327211380005,
-0.03584790602326393,
-0.10916236788034439,
0.00939695630222559,
0.4156010150909424,
0.25422996282577515,
0.25148263573646545,
0.25957155227661133,
-0.42909425497055054,
0.2262134999036789,
0.5192340016365051,
-0.27917540073394775,
-0.207642063498497,
0.5164548754692078,
0.3915075957775116,
0.34951332211494446,
0.5451126098632812,
0.0412532277405262,
-0.504207968711853,
0.314224511384964,
0.5879732966423035,
0.9829530715942383,
0.21264173090457916,
-0.029503140598535538,
0.196177676320076,
0.1561013013124466,
-0.0821438729763031,
0.14839069545269012,
-0.3878302574157715,
-0.9849487543106079,
-0.7890520095825195,
-0.5813509821891785,
-0.15006005764007568,
0.10102500766515732,
-0.5776593685150146,
0.03813061863183975,
-0.1826622486114502,
-0.13277019560337067,
-0.14842216670513153,
-0.3344862461090088,
-0.7061581015586853,
-0.017979595810174942,
0.3957756459712982,
0.6969032883644104,
-0.5823237299919128,
0.8940622806549072,
0.6998587846755981,
-0.4069575369358063,
-0.587505042552948,
0.09238096326589584,
0.18594101071357727,
-0.8860574960708618,
0.8176230788230896,
0.5257191061973572,
-0.2847748398780823,
-0.009815727360546589,
-0.3968565762042999,
-0.9836611151695251,
1.1189419031143188,
0.10523009300231934,
-0.4730254113674164,
0.14723064005374908,
-0.38154491782188416,
-0.02040359005331993,
-0.4315935969352722,
0.25672537088394165,
0.4523954689502716,
0.4818803369998932,
0.35137447714805603,
-0.8551428318023682,
-0.0065855407156050205,
-0.1406080722808838,
0.08246178179979324,
0.1557435840368271,
-0.530346691608429,
0.6991328597068787,
-0.1847735196352005,
-0.5004310607910156,
-0.11805044114589691,
0.43280720710754395,
0.0915343388915062,
0.38963133096694946,
0.6206274032592773,
0.6475446820259094,
0.4267898201942444,
0.07657832652330399,
0.9629335403442383,
-0.253246545791626,
-0.08878348022699356,
1.0671939849853516,
-0.4147575795650482,
0.9339391589164734,
0.6173428893089294,
0.07427775114774704,
0.17491279542446136,
0.7471909523010254,
0.06819573044776917,
1.0631219148635864,
-0.35959625244140625,
-0.4302627146244049,
-0.647854745388031,
-0.37253859639167786,
-0.4215116798877716,
0.563132107257843,
0.3939798176288605,
-0.32975566387176514,
-0.2344902902841568,
0.4262799024581909,
-0.25773245096206665,
-0.1661037653684616,
-0.42070120573043823,
1.0358387231826782,
0.1536322832107544,
-0.7217476963996887,
0.6079531908035278,
-0.2672693133354187,
0.7864181399345398,
-0.6760916113853455,
0.06700929254293442,
-0.17515495419502258,
0.037215206772089005,
-0.13285547494888306,
-0.7053827047348022,
0.1090116873383522,
-0.4269842505455017,
-0.4376853406429291,
-0.4113978445529938,
0.9067874550819397,
-0.6195349097251892,
-0.2542576789855957,
0.2320520430803299,
0.6657320261001587,
0.10644485056400299,
-0.29163888096809387,
-0.5049824118614197,
0.27423977851867676,
-0.008919569663703442,
-0.09612841159105301,
0.49838539958000183,
0.24137115478515625,
0.2118208259344101,
0.6727134585380554,
0.7058178782463074,
-0.22459428012371063,
0.054117392748594284,
0.2753957211971283,
1.1331226825714111,
-0.4325101971626282,
-0.35149088501930237,
-0.8927076458930969,
0.44584164023399353,
0.03997061774134636,
-0.21137642860412598,
0.5945723652839661,
0.47378289699554443,
0.9416545033454895,
-0.21091514825820923,
0.5554376244544983,
0.03457765281200409,
0.11222915351390839,
-0.9560772776603699,
0.5076081156730652,
-0.9472061395645142,
-0.16528217494487762,
0.027473177760839462,
-0.8833027482032776,
-0.28146591782569885,
0.395021915435791,
-0.19269956648349762,
-0.3019036054611206,
1.0533115863800049,
0.7926792502403259,
-0.10008877515792847,
-0.31544744968414307,
0.5077604055404663,
0.008810955099761486,
0.11377767473459244,
0.46476343274116516,
1.147373080253601,
0.11748841404914856,
0.6429430842399597,
-0.4603174924850464,
-0.17847402393817902,
-0.33544042706489563,
-0.684974193572998,
-1.0094232559204102,
-0.520864725112915,
-0.1287037432193756,
-0.1396947056055069,
-0.325526624917984,
0.45458313822746277,
1.1370797157287598,
-0.6083245277404785,
-0.07212594896554947,
0.21954812109470367,
0.11235176026821136,
-0.14499223232269287,
-0.21494802832603455,
0.21767865121364594,
-0.6127683520317078,
-0.768993616104126,
0.7674739360809326,
0.7246190309524536,
0.1152416244149208,
-0.5581508874893188,
0.08666336536407471,
-0.21200378239154816,
-0.26933011412620544,
1.0210283994674683,
-0.04259289801120758,
-1.0478743314743042,
-0.003897822694852948,
0.1289960741996765,
-0.09487145394086838,
0.29023921489715576,
1.0763229131698608,
-0.8636319041252136,
0.6495497226715088,
0.4858419597148895,
0.48933476209640503,
0.8264086842536926,
0.03696262091398239,
0.5286059379577637,
-0.468598335981369,
0.5550668835639954,
0.1114741712808609,
0.6781064867973328,
0.2752141058444977,
-0.10730268061161041,
0.17941252887248993,
0.25436025857925415,
-0.29455527663230896,
-0.5502170920372009,
0.4944487512111664,
-1.4228330850601196,
-0.6227591633796692,
1.033504843711853,
-0.18951447308063507,
-0.20514528453350067,
-0.2958579659461975,
-0.3874121308326721,
-0.12621648609638214,
-0.1935565322637558,
0.5108868479728699,
0.6001091599464417,
-0.01180983055382967,
-0.5681352615356445,
-0.44345298409461975,
0.32099995017051697,
0.5354770421981812,
-0.5639238357543945,
-0.360462486743927,
0.8645236492156982,
0.12538790702819824,
0.2423035204410553,
0.6719287037849426,
0.012595652602612972,
0.30274367332458496,
0.15155437588691711,
-0.19974590837955475,
-0.08183920383453369,
-0.5935086607933044,
-0.2241068184375763,
0.5619320273399353,
-0.06006799265742302,
-0.37967759370803833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12193v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12193v2 | A Chinese Dataset for Evaluating the Safeguards in Large Language Models | 2024-02-19T14:56:18 | 2024-05-26T17:15:44 | Yuxia Wang, Zenan Zhai, Haonan Li, Xudong Han, Lizhi Lin, Zhenxuan Zhang, Jingru Zhao, Preslav Nakov, Timothy Baldwin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many studies have demonstrated that large language models (LLMs) can produce
harmful responses, exposing users to unexpected risks when LLMs are deployed.
Previous studies have proposed comprehensive taxonomies of the risks posed by
LLMs, as well as corresponding prompts that can be used to examine the safety
mechanisms of LLMs. However, the focus has been almost exclusively on English,
and little has been explored for other languages. Here we aim to bridge this
gap. We first introduce a dataset for the safety evaluation of Chinese LLMs,
and then extend it to two other scenarios that can be used to better identify
false negative and false positive examples in terms of risky prompt rejections.
We further present a set of fine-grained safety assessment criteria for each
risk type, facilitating both manual annotation and automatic evaluation in
terms of LLM response harmfulness. Our experiments on five LLMs show that
region-specific risks are the prevalent type of risk, presenting the major
issue with all Chinese LLMs we experimented with. Our data is available at
https://github.com/Libr-AI/do-not-answer. Warning: this paper contains example
data that may be offensive, harmful, or biased. | [
0.09213777631521225,
-0.8548737168312073,
0.376364141702652,
0.23860172927379608,
-0.09107612818479538,
-0.2973312437534332,
-0.21759678423404694,
-0.6007570624351501,
-0.3463783860206604,
0.5602248311042786,
-0.30344250798225403,
-0.5304369926452637,
-0.4650919735431671,
0.01814647577702999,
-0.43069955706596375,
1.0184177160263062,
-0.01323188841342926,
0.11780264973640442,
0.18437258899211884,
0.16651812195777893,
-0.6449418067932129,
-0.6444088816642761,
-0.8809007406234741,
-0.08861898630857468,
0.7504244446754456,
0.24649466574192047,
0.6775081157684326,
0.48887720704078674,
0.675602376461029,
0.19097629189491272,
-0.09578125178813934,
0.02794644609093666,
-0.3075668513774872,
-0.06613387912511826,
-0.07941681891679764,
-0.35864633321762085,
-0.4365037679672241,
-0.10059282183647156,
0.6208104491233826,
0.6362137794494629,
-0.02178841643035412,
0.10681600868701935,
0.15643656253814697,
0.29878172278404236,
-0.5761433243751526,
0.09227614104747772,
-0.7087294459342957,
0.18243460357189178,
-0.33909159898757935,
-0.14768725633621216,
-0.6385115385055542,
-0.6570096611976624,
0.24782031774520874,
-0.2055622637271881,
-0.38449010252952576,
0.1895272582769394,
0.8008671402931213,
-0.11809144169092178,
-0.677632749080658,
-0.30602386593818665,
-0.5011394023895264,
0.8053457140922546,
-0.7254500389099121,
-0.10147832334041595,
0.48043709993362427,
0.44570764899253845,
-0.28649336099624634,
-0.2433885782957077,
-0.39495760202407837,
-0.43255096673965454,
-0.2013111412525177,
-0.015107210725545883,
-0.057960715144872665,
0.10851976275444031,
0.24319101870059967,
0.25334298610687256,
-0.8416178226470947,
0.5923412442207336,
-0.22929725050926208,
-0.5681054592132568,
1.021977424621582,
0.48488160967826843,
0.8501153588294983,
-0.27033531665802,
-0.44548115134239197,
-0.23786230385303497,
-1.4027416706085205,
0.1485094130039215,
0.47246047854423523,
0.6771888732910156,
-0.3215256333351135,
0.42718368768692017,
0.17432217299938202,
0.5190953016281128,
-0.4575468599796295,
-0.20144082605838776,
0.24563010036945343,
-0.4516010880470276,
-0.15152885019779205,
0.10090211778879166,
1.0643757581710815,
0.6455825567245483,
0.4416969418525696,
-0.03456275910139084,
-0.4055498242378235,
-0.23127712309360504,
-0.1264113336801529,
-0.7254400849342346,
0.050163283944129944,
0.33971941471099854,
-0.4080575108528137,
-0.3084491491317749,
0.11975914239883423,
-0.6932358741760254,
-0.7107048630714417,
0.19825701415538788,
0.4126231074333191,
-0.295136958360672,
-0.21515528857707977,
0.1587812453508377,
0.1847534328699112,
0.5887752175331116,
0.051886722445487976,
-0.6595103144645691,
0.009749574586749077,
0.6121072173118591,
0.6783202290534973,
-0.30427905917167664,
-0.2824335992336273,
-0.5828121304512024,
0.10160055011510849,
-0.6559081077575684,
0.6148720383644104,
-0.17588944733142853,
-0.5634140968322754,
0.5075277090072632,
0.3187253773212433,
0.18207499384880066,
-0.5366016626358032,
0.9016974568367004,
-0.3389601409435272,
0.12632109224796295,
-0.4297889769077301,
-0.20864342153072357,
-0.25349941849708557,
0.3607787489891052,
-0.6777490973472595,
0.5828506350517273,
-0.288085013628006,
-0.9197961688041687,
0.3006986379623413,
-0.2897990942001343,
-0.9009337425231934,
-0.01733993925154209,
-0.1248910203576088,
-0.47127699851989746,
-0.3252745270729065,
-0.08476611971855164,
0.5724541544914246,
-0.41626664996147156,
0.3672880530357361,
-0.539096474647522,
-0.2808258831501007,
0.3218516707420349,
-0.858194887638092,
1.131611943244934,
0.34831541776657104,
-0.04101654142141342,
0.36215656995773315,
-0.4776400923728943,
-0.07268374413251877,
0.3087681531906128,
-0.30576804280281067,
-0.628136932849884,
-0.05849166586995125,
0.12221875041723251,
0.4868209660053253,
0.3568362891674042,
-0.45615553855895996,
-0.16282884776592255,
-0.4124133288860321,
0.3778513967990875,
0.7678017616271973,
0.1310657262802124,
0.08817309886217117,
-0.48095789551734924,
0.3228107988834381,
0.13595269620418549,
0.365793377161026,
-0.23289410769939423,
-0.19231218099594116,
-0.5598648190498352,
0.10754042863845825,
0.0061778537929058075,
0.8515382409095764,
-0.9474595189094543,
0.5923413038253784,
-0.11918871849775314,
-0.5854278206825256,
-0.053430184721946716,
-0.0211227647960186,
0.6482505202293396,
0.26524147391319275,
-0.07201596349477768,
0.07165198028087616,
-0.3214026093482971,
-0.9793637990951538,
-0.11047743260860443,
-0.5748307108879089,
-0.11486378312110901,
0.3821733891963959,
0.3242366313934326,
-0.13831540942192078,
0.44619038701057434,
-0.42735329270362854,
-0.06938525289297104,
-0.21302156150341034,
-0.16678182780742645,
0.1430327594280243,
0.462372750043869,
0.7741127610206604,
-0.6576656103134155,
-0.4162910282611847,
-0.010410956107079983,
-0.8541082143783569,
-0.179550439119339,
-0.27571821212768555,
-0.1462518274784088,
0.30005455017089844,
0.37693583965301514,
-0.5412890315055847,
0.13929837942123413,
0.5892412066459656,
-0.16670475900173187,
0.6981946229934692,
0.027063315734267235,
-0.026778629049658775,
-1.1385772228240967,
0.24209930002689362,
0.18807417154312134,
0.09450597316026688,
-0.8012539148330688,
0.19286073744297028,
0.19202950596809387,
0.019078616052865982,
-0.9327380061149597,
0.7187537550926208,
-0.2000323385000229,
0.1524355411529541,
-0.11975707858800888,
0.21213588118553162,
-0.12843546271324158,
0.017219074070453644,
0.14670883119106293,
0.7809821963310242,
0.6701956391334534,
-0.7817879319190979,
0.3398880660533905,
0.2532811760902405,
-0.5077154636383057,
0.10140757262706757,
-0.6929649114608765,
0.032165512442588806,
0.052908141165971756,
0.0672847107052803,
-0.7488779425621033,
-0.3273804187774658,
0.3292704224586487,
-0.19660139083862305,
0.27148714661598206,
0.06199967861175537,
-0.5577181577682495,
-0.47439271211624146,
-0.6799651980400085,
0.22764301300048828,
0.3522019684314728,
-0.5477269291877747,
0.057943254709243774,
0.6610031127929688,
-0.3781541883945465,
-0.8177372813224792,
-0.9258162975311279,
0.22446869313716888,
-0.7043492794036865,
-0.5375037789344788,
-0.1659005582332611,
-0.20369373261928558,
-0.4489578306674957,
-0.2193581610918045,
0.15632499754428864,
-0.1190907210111618,
0.6541563272476196,
0.2524529993534088,
0.5695197582244873,
-0.0007374576525762677,
0.1375349760055542,
-0.10816924273967743,
-0.03171242028474808,
0.32848992943763733,
0.18590691685676575,
0.4385533332824707,
-0.04055563732981682,
-0.36046895384788513,
-0.23780211806297302,
0.2340659499168396,
0.2083897441625595,
-0.07298341393470764,
0.6802029013633728,
0.25660035014152527,
-0.7081863284111023,
-0.25398221611976624,
-0.14412592351436615,
-0.11687445640563965,
-0.5239701867103577,
0.5194050669670105,
-0.0352945551276207,
-0.7102441191673279,
0.5250743627548218,
0.3190425634384155,
0.4616967439651489,
0.35888922214508057,
0.667860209941864,
0.09473398327827454,
0.8730655312538147,
0.479781836271286,
-0.6134595274925232,
0.29360857605934143,
0.27038055658340454,
0.3445630371570587,
-0.3045571446418762,
-0.13535460829734802,
-0.6161754727363586,
0.2915485203266144,
-0.7465961575508118,
-0.1245952621102333,
0.48599591851234436,
-0.2597621977329254,
-0.4612535536289215,
0.3780933916568756,
-0.021870678290724754,
0.4243043065071106,
0.17826707661151886,
-0.11661208420991898,
0.27869561314582825,
-0.15173448622226715,
0.012960197404026985,
0.1306331902742386,
-0.5536381602287292,
-0.7970729470252991,
0.8240845203399658,
0.6338915228843689,
1.3244951963424683,
0.2986288368701935,
0.39273133873939514,
0.26168322563171387,
0.39564967155456543,
-0.8136391639709473,
0.6335268616676331,
-0.29713174700737,
-0.8259852528572083,
-0.44124746322631836,
-0.5702301859855652,
-0.9970810413360596,
0.05566488206386566,
-0.21213054656982422,
-0.6784875392913818,
-0.2914395034313202,
-0.04035693779587746,
-0.6519023776054382,
0.22744528949260712,
-0.6086494326591492,
0.570865273475647,
-0.7115728259086609,
-0.13305659592151642,
0.18424813449382782,
-0.6150282621383667,
0.8489363193511963,
-0.5015024542808533,
0.2839205861091614,
-0.1391490399837494,
0.20125293731689453,
0.5388229489326477,
0.0422261506319046,
1.0186516046524048,
0.030026428401470184,
-0.6192019581794739,
0.4227489233016968,
0.22910204529762268,
0.3884386420249939,
0.03700684756040573,
-0.3690745532512665,
0.20540815591812134,
0.1439533680677414,
-0.20368443429470062,
-0.19671641290187836,
0.8287275433540344,
-0.6609522700309753,
-0.7805615067481995,
-0.4363479018211365,
-0.5855342745780945,
-0.1882070004940033,
0.45049402117729187,
0.17697401344776154,
0.2071293592453003,
-0.2578909695148468,
0.11116897314786911,
0.5728219151496887,
-1.0552750825881958,
0.5621231198310852,
0.7754729390144348,
-0.2718394100666046,
-0.00984750036150217,
0.9544590711593628,
0.22447098791599274,
0.3856099843978882,
0.23067565262317657,
0.3223862648010254,
-0.3666832149028778,
-0.6782613396644592,
-0.37662267684936523,
0.023530520498752594,
-0.8195184469223022,
-0.16496068239212036,
-0.18800942599773407,
-0.5640352368354797,
-0.364964097738266,
0.11999112367630005,
-0.03678138181567192,
0.07047954946756363,
-0.0419897623360157,
-0.4265609085559845,
0.07800310850143433,
0.6325053572654724,
-0.0032342823687940836,
0.04321905970573425,
-1.0699667930603027,
-0.11440794914960861,
0.15068656206130981,
0.3528801202774048,
0.08367060124874115,
-0.43555736541748047,
-0.2539389133453369,
-0.05839868634939194,
-0.13542820513248444,
-0.5688438415527344,
0.421140193939209,
-0.08276732265949249,
0.9117330312728882,
0.5889939069747925,
0.663880467414856,
0.21992862224578857,
-0.6195102334022522,
0.9883497357368469,
-0.006598203908652067,
-0.644176185131073,
0.4316033124923706,
-0.5290828347206116,
-0.19155524671077728,
0.35928860306739807,
0.5937832593917847,
-0.8191904425621033,
-0.16383087635040283,
-0.1385626345872879,
-0.9539766907691956,
0.4607686996459961,
-0.11565634608268738,
0.4847396910190582,
-0.21568414568901062,
0.22375567257404327,
0.13478030264377594,
-0.12410815805196762,
-1.0087987184524536,
-0.339426726102829,
0.2946731448173523,
-0.05458306893706322,
-0.11475100368261337,
-0.4187912940979004,
-0.3548918664455414,
0.3535875380039215,
0.7859733700752258,
-0.08206507563591003,
-0.1660657823085785,
-0.0008224712801165879,
-0.11693691462278366,
-0.1930742859840393,
0.42373985052108765,
0.47053563594818115,
0.16914211213588715,
-0.0012040415313094854,
0.28690093755722046,
0.45775777101516724,
-0.3973686397075653,
0.2172810584306717,
-0.011684892699122429,
-0.34148404002189636,
-0.3886397182941437,
0.6598725914955139,
0.5288333296775818,
-0.18791629374027252,
-0.9346701502799988,
0.5349810123443604,
-0.115638367831707,
0.09806406497955322,
-0.5054033398628235,
0.03360164165496826,
-0.13216876983642578,
-0.25480490922927856,
0.11816398054361343,
-0.5172478556632996,
0.18636086583137512,
-0.5330526828765869,
0.3007982671260834,
0.5642312169075012,
-0.3391156792640686,
-0.34089353680610657,
0.3307929039001465,
0.4590769410133362,
-0.11294087767601013,
0.32231080532073975,
-0.029252735897898674,
-0.4996929466724396,
0.6287928223609924,
0.4023577570915222,
0.8550357818603516,
-0.2534961402416229,
0.07273375242948532,
0.3856404721736908,
0.7587363123893738,
0.0804852768778801,
0.36971473693847656,
0.7102370858192444,
-0.8588488698005676,
-0.20854642987251282,
-0.30120623111724854,
-0.4549620747566223,
0.5991344451904297,
-0.5171324610710144,
0.3577788472175598,
-0.6785222887992859,
-0.0759376585483551,
-0.33163395524024963,
0.02679888717830181,
-0.18584054708480835,
0.0906461700797081,
0.6379333138465881,
1.011136770248413,
-1.1977976560592651,
0.7668569087982178,
0.5228741765022278,
-0.3094102144241333,
-0.8943520784378052,
0.31125739216804504,
0.23213568329811096,
-0.8361729979515076,
0.5068172216415405,
0.3631865382194519,
-0.06533285230398178,
-0.6492142081260681,
-0.40663397312164307,
-0.6346114277839661,
0.9521719813346863,
0.45448341965675354,
-0.8288113474845886,
0.14536553621292114,
0.46684741973876953,
0.4627322852611542,
0.0854625552892685,
0.10589563846588135,
0.6623926758766174,
0.48597031831741333,
-0.31171876192092896,
-1.0340105295181274,
0.27202996611595154,
-0.09375918656587601,
-0.04527163505554199,
-0.13444356620311737,
-0.9547455906867981,
0.8969264030456543,
-0.22738675773143768,
-0.5180919170379639,
0.22221694886684418,
0.26547563076019287,
0.4154130816459656,
0.31068676710128784,
0.5780275464057922,
0.06563811004161835,
0.6737334728240967,
-0.09664390236139297,
1.308398723602295,
-0.3489263951778412,
0.1300542801618576,
0.9383547306060791,
-0.5497439503669739,
0.78973388671875,
0.16781973838806152,
-0.12210125476121902,
-0.02346235141158104,
0.8781231045722961,
0.06699314713478088,
0.2929234802722931,
0.35969844460487366,
-0.20697684586048126,
-0.2732726037502289,
-0.487581729888916,
-0.20523804426193237,
0.2803202271461487,
0.41421064734458923,
-0.2659570574760437,
-0.23072607815265656,
-0.05852974206209183,
0.22960412502288818,
-0.044612105935811996,
-0.36591169238090515,
0.5643011331558228,
0.36508363485336304,
-0.4823274314403534,
0.4119001626968384,
0.0032467059791088104,
0.745547890663147,
-0.575727105140686,
0.029846517369151115,
-0.31366831064224243,
0.05514897406101227,
-0.24715197086334229,
-1.2214741706848145,
0.25790777802467346,
0.1511603146791458,
0.1696864813566208,
0.18435831367969513,
0.7761189341545105,
-0.4329192340373993,
-0.36005762219429016,
0.4517335295677185,
0.323220431804657,
0.16805711388587952,
0.3108997046947479,
-0.617396354675293,
0.07502514123916626,
-0.12423822283744812,
-0.3215751051902771,
0.4592093527317047,
0.38219958543777466,
-0.6319840550422668,
1.0247682332992554,
0.5094608664512634,
0.09690529108047485,
-0.15385037660598755,
0.19854359328746796,
0.7435352206230164,
-0.6224034428596497,
-0.31431350111961365,
-1.0023022890090942,
0.2155434936285019,
0.1294780671596527,
-0.13083001971244812,
0.9874067306518555,
0.3377026319503784,
0.6149185299873352,
0.08456346392631531,
1.094252347946167,
0.08326257020235062,
0.31954482197761536,
-0.6924937963485718,
1.0760083198547363,
-0.40573522448539734,
0.5263185501098633,
-0.39076536893844604,
-0.5820005536079407,
-0.6145447492599487,
0.30112406611442566,
-0.494937002658844,
-0.04728683456778526,
0.4007473587989807,
0.8537440299987793,
0.5121342539787292,
-0.1673814207315445,
0.6193330883979797,
0.40864434838294983,
0.6878972053527832,
0.841386616230011,
1.1479979753494263,
-0.3187227249145508,
0.6376755833625793,
-0.2548674941062927,
-0.04577562212944031,
-0.07837476581335068,
-1.1416651010513306,
-1.1007261276245117,
-0.35777461528778076,
-0.11398100852966309,
-0.3921421468257904,
0.04672776907682419,
0.9594838619232178,
0.456582635641098,
-1.1015117168426514,
-0.22691646218299866,
0.49594512581825256,
0.16130317747592926,
0.2891274094581604,
-0.17202460765838623,
0.5809338092803955,
-0.11826514452695847,
-0.6890602111816406,
0.2738856077194214,
0.12505009770393372,
0.32303586602211,
-0.4043876826763153,
-0.01996660605072975,
0.18368376791477203,
0.10547004640102386,
0.6497577428817749,
0.3059469759464264,
-0.6124017238616943,
-0.7968540191650391,
-0.11862428486347198,
-0.5028408765792847,
-0.41621890664100647,
0.38506606221199036,
-0.03372512012720108,
0.022241108119487762,
0.5325385332107544,
0.8130560517311096,
-0.4392361640930176,
-0.3253308832645416,
0.6863106489181519,
-0.5387834906578064,
0.2642342448234558,
0.12872691452503204,
0.6741674542427063,
0.4464988708496094,
-0.6484167575836182,
0.420188844203949,
-0.17361916601657867,
-0.46007177233695984,
-0.8965197205543518,
0.2929166257381439,
-0.8601022958755493,
-0.2637203633785248,
1.5281460285186768,
-0.5497230887413025,
-0.15387918055057526,
-0.20903107523918152,
-0.3781573176383972,
0.10010261833667755,
-0.19827285408973694,
0.8799781203269958,
0.8217318058013916,
0.26537638902664185,
0.02342444285750389,
-0.691525936126709,
0.5276241302490234,
0.24070750176906586,
-0.9583778381347656,
0.5604670643806458,
0.4660552442073822,
0.4957207143306732,
-0.02628251351416111,
0.22668366134166718,
-0.291742742061615,
0.3129385709762573,
-0.24018387496471405,
-0.08676576614379883,
0.07071173191070557,
-0.3563776910305023,
-0.6238102912902832,
-0.18269051611423492,
0.4335646331310272,
0.046994876116514206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14846v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14846v3 | Stick to Your Role! Context-dependence and Stability of Personal Value Expression in Large Language Models | 2024-02-19T14:53:01 | 2024-04-30T07:09:22 | Grgur Kovač, Rémy Portelas, Masataka Sawayama, Peter Ford Dominey, Pierre-Yves Oudeyer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T07, I.2.7 | The standard way to study Large Language Models (LLMs) with benchmarks or
psychology questionnaires is to provide many different queries from similar
minimal contexts (e.g. multiple choice questions). However, due to LLMs' highly
context-dependent nature, conclusions from such minimal-context evaluations may
be little informative about the model's behavior in deployment (where it will
be exposed to many new contexts). We argue that context-dependence
(specifically, value stability) should be studied a specific property of LLMs
and used as another dimension of LLM comparison (alongside others such as
cognitive abilities, knowledge, or model size). We present a case-study on the
stability of value expression over different contexts (simulated conversations
on different topics) as measured using a standard psychology questionnaire
(PVQ) and on behavioral downstream tasks. Reusing methods from psychology, we
study Rank-order stability on the population (interpersonal) level, and
Ipsative stability on the individual (intrapersonal) level. We consider two
settings (with and without instructing LLMs to simulate particular personas),
two simulated populations, and three downstream tasks. We observe consistent
trends in the stability of models and model families - Mixtral, Mistral,
GPT-3.5 and Qwen families are more stable than LLaMa-2 and Phi. The consistency
of these trends implies that some models exhibit higher value-stability than
others, and that value stability can be estimated with the set of introduced
methodological tools. When instructed to simulate particular personas, LLMs
exhibit low Rank-Order stability, which further diminishes with conversation
length. This highlights the need for future research on LLMs that coherently
simulate different personas. This paper provides a foundational step in that
direction, and, to our knowledge, it is the first study of value stability in
LLMs. | [
-0.5671635270118713,
-0.7302538156509399,
0.48827943205833435,
0.384765088558197,
0.12004844844341278,
-0.053169313818216324,
-0.2344696968793869,
-0.3307017982006073,
0.16431987285614014,
0.5982906222343445,
-0.2940119206905365,
-0.08675111830234528,
-0.7022743225097656,
0.010560075752437115,
-0.09219279885292053,
0.8567274808883667,
0.3219341039657593,
0.018387319520115852,
-0.6932130455970764,
-0.5085484385490417,
-0.6445152759552002,
-1.1093502044677734,
-0.6716752052307129,
-0.1794833391904831,
0.6584993600845337,
0.23942837119102478,
0.5216646194458008,
0.24943001568317413,
0.37843382358551025,
0.30270928144454956,
-0.25988444685935974,
-0.3284328281879425,
-0.8538267016410828,
0.6092430353164673,
-0.09254612773656845,
-0.34424495697021484,
-0.4202735722064972,
0.17796887457370758,
0.5503267645835876,
0.7735800743103027,
-0.2557241916656494,
0.14823250472545624,
0.1333950310945511,
0.3291894495487213,
-0.6425341963768005,
0.1819154918193817,
-0.5766266584396362,
-0.5103101134300232,
-0.12991179525852203,
-0.15822328627109528,
-0.4538739323616028,
-0.10676787048578262,
0.29689261317253113,
0.006193657871335745,
-0.3466826379299164,
-0.16525226831436157,
0.841645359992981,
0.15656466782093048,
-0.6761797666549683,
0.00029849770362488925,
-0.7092278599739075,
0.8210619688034058,
-0.49536412954330444,
0.16693028807640076,
0.5065622925758362,
0.2575152516365051,
-0.16283459961414337,
-0.4667551517486572,
-0.398681104183197,
-0.344801127910614,
-0.12757638096809387,
0.19474898278713226,
0.16317875683307648,
0.015085908584296703,
0.23630592226982117,
0.06997708976268768,
0.18187201023101807,
0.3572709858417511,
-0.4154278635978699,
0.0010628250893205404,
0.5551314353942871,
0.3234933316707611,
0.05574525520205498,
-0.05956439673900604,
-0.3067704141139984,
-0.16367922723293304,
-1.0594898462295532,
0.40917012095451355,
0.021424589678645134,
0.1568104326725006,
-0.047279126942157745,
0.5878435969352722,
-0.10880854725837708,
0.19820931553840637,
0.35917556285858154,
-0.5398953557014465,
-0.1506996899843216,
-0.027325838804244995,
0.012669761665165424,
-0.03196059912443161,
0.5266827940940857,
0.4927125871181488,
0.20984004437923431,
0.04862533137202263,
-0.11532570421695709,
-0.06536570191383362,
0.3406572639942169,
-0.902867317199707,
0.21646425127983093,
0.15919451415538788,
-0.4709721803665161,
-0.19894744455814362,
-0.12188609689474106,
-0.5114820599555969,
-0.39720618724823,
-0.09547549486160278,
0.3100951015949249,
-0.03294089436531067,
-0.21005162596702576,
-0.34153085947036743,
0.44629260897636414,
0.31542959809303284,
0.4749491810798645,
-1.1291598081588745,
0.5524563193321228,
0.5496115684509277,
0.7419917583465576,
-0.33713963627815247,
-0.5099733471870422,
-0.8560723066329956,
0.051256269216537476,
-0.22901590168476105,
0.5403842329978943,
-0.4305863678455353,
-0.591712236404419,
0.03478957340121269,
0.05089152231812477,
-0.11520963162183762,
-0.6552984118461609,
0.27190208435058594,
-0.5387897491455078,
0.28662893176078796,
-0.5628488063812256,
-0.5458092093467712,
0.19888941943645477,
0.30001184344291687,
-0.4461982250213623,
0.8681022524833679,
0.18840214610099792,
-0.6338446140289307,
0.4343816041946411,
-0.4959537982940674,
-0.2848826050758362,
-0.05037856847047806,
-0.4622962772846222,
-0.14938975870609283,
0.19638237357139587,
-0.32759538292884827,
0.4992712140083313,
-0.2756473124027252,
0.13084420561790466,
-0.5671902894973755,
-0.3737805187702179,
0.5181423425674438,
-0.3322637379169464,
0.8033304810523987,
-0.1264430731534958,
-0.17398090660572052,
0.06637713313102722,
-0.526517391204834,
-0.018859218806028366,
-0.13649673759937286,
-0.490753173828125,
-0.4178287982940674,
0.3004470765590668,
-0.1159517839550972,
0.6898296475410461,
0.11767323315143585,
-0.49027082324028015,
0.18898673355579376,
-0.2230454385280609,
0.3524821996688843,
0.8494642376899719,
0.3055879473686218,
0.26664698123931885,
-0.3571856617927551,
0.6191702485084534,
0.09782920777797699,
-0.12385306507349014,
0.005798756144940853,
-0.49207016825675964,
-0.5397577881813049,
-0.18984226882457733,
0.15254050493240356,
0.44993463158607483,
0.00639793137088418,
0.2267739623785019,
-0.4088071286678314,
-0.12854254245758057,
-0.27196136116981506,
-0.046943653374910355,
0.27428558468818665,
0.49968773126602173,
0.10858506709337234,
-0.2584843337535858,
-0.24789853394031525,
-0.9086004495620728,
0.008094887249171734,
-0.43018820881843567,
0.04951079934835434,
0.24978692829608917,
0.5617986917495728,
-0.27086275815963745,
1.2097429037094116,
-0.3365732431411743,
-0.13542461395263672,
-0.2514307200908661,
0.08143536001443863,
-0.09467747062444687,
0.34286391735076904,
0.5429632663726807,
-0.8143898248672485,
-0.3932400345802307,
-0.20191368460655212,
-0.5047900080680847,
-0.23940211534500122,
-0.01074572280049324,
-0.1499045044183731,
0.46628227829933167,
0.3533381521701813,
-0.4797782897949219,
0.22656062245368958,
0.9661101698875427,
-0.5210936069488525,
0.441123366355896,
-0.12160911411046982,
-0.02675323188304901,
-1.1500880718231201,
0.15214554965496063,
0.06316542625427246,
-0.26257675886154175,
-0.7389444708824158,
-0.16204789280891418,
-0.08436468988656998,
0.1425657570362091,
-0.2773987352848053,
0.624194860458374,
-0.07689294964075089,
-0.12181270867586136,
-0.24252957105636597,
-0.033543169498443604,
-0.1002637967467308,
0.1934628188610077,
0.17342889308929443,
0.8987928628921509,
0.3003518879413605,
-0.7179842591285706,
-0.08639450371265411,
0.42226994037628174,
-0.18148638308048248,
0.7007787823677063,
-0.7470401525497437,
0.11190178990364075,
0.03170608729124069,
0.09430915117263794,
-0.8475794792175293,
-0.2810462713241577,
0.14769481122493744,
-0.18598903715610504,
0.17915299534797668,
-0.22117732465267181,
-0.46900495886802673,
0.3189948797225952,
-0.02923278696835041,
0.24133539199829102,
0.7007784247398376,
-0.3703289031982422,
0.3768594563007355,
0.727375328540802,
-0.3586871027946472,
-0.39822906255722046,
-0.4999742805957794,
-0.008658111095428467,
-0.47337058186531067,
-0.7487277984619141,
0.369790643453598,
-0.24674122035503387,
-0.7483704686164856,
-0.19664952158927917,
-0.28285712003707886,
-0.3365718424320221,
0.274742066860199,
0.5759158730506897,
0.15834744274616241,
0.04183802008628845,
0.11921843141317368,
0.11500141024589539,
-0.049725063145160675,
0.1629491001367569,
0.2697423994541168,
0.38432806730270386,
-0.4117119610309601,
-0.12352156639099121,
0.05300217866897583,
0.3244865834712982,
0.8284003138542175,
-0.16384315490722656,
1.1141443252563477,
0.1402013748884201,
-0.1698645055294037,
0.17446739971637726,
-0.6352264881134033,
-0.2105097770690918,
-0.49279043078422546,
0.19285719096660614,
-0.4916702210903168,
-1.2263591289520264,
0.7695348858833313,
-0.1268547624349594,
0.03415355086326599,
0.21364301443099976,
0.756460964679718,
-0.332161545753479,
0.9184390306472778,
0.8147993683815002,
0.0680166482925415,
0.2565819025039673,
0.09994927048683167,
0.13836660981178284,
-0.8855965733528137,
-0.08549462258815765,
-0.1469285637140274,
-0.17404396831989288,
-0.6487457156181335,
-0.19180305302143097,
0.6028839945793152,
0.15582136809825897,
-0.2709008753299713,
-0.15555070340633392,
-0.044725582003593445,
0.2741158604621887,
0.15797758102416992,
-0.18702615797519684,
0.25528275966644287,
-0.3154923915863037,
0.1886933594942093,
-0.1483372449874878,
-0.486837238073349,
-0.7057512998580933,
0.8374789953231812,
0.3444017767906189,
0.7564552426338196,
0.2561732828617096,
0.6036436557769775,
0.09029895067214966,
0.5582882165908813,
-0.6942087411880493,
0.6330627202987671,
-0.012951855547726154,
-0.5912708640098572,
-0.44413381814956665,
-0.3592066168785095,
-1.01930570602417,
0.4378049373626709,
-0.05823130160570145,
-1.0209723711013794,
0.2432093471288681,
0.14411887526512146,
-0.36577191948890686,
-0.3859196603298187,
-0.4960857927799225,
1.044578194618225,
-0.4165407121181488,
-0.5415427684783936,
-0.09171715378761292,
-0.7684744000434875,
0.3516387641429901,
-0.006858694367110729,
0.05952773243188858,
-0.30470210313796997,
-0.16767540574073792,
0.4912807047367096,
-0.44424086809158325,
0.977681577205658,
-0.06991863250732422,
-0.3129459023475647,
0.11954296380281448,
0.09055157005786896,
0.2185654491186142,
0.27888432145118713,
-0.22947539389133453,
0.004828875418752432,
0.5429949760437012,
-0.3158451318740845,
-0.6230223178863525,
0.8852056860923767,
-0.819647490978241,
-0.8895928263664246,
-0.5330525636672974,
-0.3619479537010193,
-0.27795329689979553,
0.2770666182041168,
0.2257523238658905,
0.30401360988616943,
-0.4051975905895233,
0.5789332985877991,
0.7043001055717468,
-0.075804203748703,
0.35654592514038086,
0.3179716467857361,
-0.37598472833633423,
-0.2926480174064636,
0.5073753595352173,
0.5341132879257202,
0.7515430450439453,
0.2602672576904297,
0.2817656695842743,
-0.1695883721113205,
-0.18547064065933228,
-0.08087529242038727,
0.08310072869062424,
-0.7439090013504028,
0.10718043893575668,
-0.30807408690452576,
-0.08030793815851212,
-0.24822354316711426,
-0.13293571770191193,
-0.4780339002609253,
-0.1928311437368393,
0.05205117166042328,
0.06637336313724518,
0.12590129673480988,
0.615345299243927,
0.3711518347263336,
0.16673873364925385,
-0.5424100160598755,
0.03493190184235573,
0.43392542004585266,
0.3068547546863556,
-0.32061314582824707,
-0.35479405522346497,
-0.3388756215572357,
-0.09633044898509979,
-0.26200294494628906,
-0.9061782956123352,
0.26158618927001953,
0.11557170003652573,
0.6390025019645691,
0.520776093006134,
0.20681875944137573,
0.5893958806991577,
-0.13527192175388336,
0.9236814975738525,
-0.087397001683712,
-1.161094307899475,
0.2621113061904907,
-0.6523337364196777,
0.2775163948535919,
0.7617450952529907,
0.17203788459300995,
-0.8986528515815735,
-0.26152923703193665,
-0.5077613592147827,
-0.834929347038269,
0.7266503572463989,
0.1723650097846985,
0.33984193205833435,
-0.09067762643098831,
0.5774295926094055,
-0.08041932433843613,
0.3947512209415436,
-0.920871913433075,
-0.23970113694667816,
-0.12199222296476364,
0.09926049411296844,
0.11234557628631592,
-0.543663501739502,
-0.40270230174064636,
-0.3576175272464752,
0.32997575402259827,
-0.2844059467315674,
0.3014138340950012,
-0.06511636823415756,
-0.0044173295609653,
0.08138685673475266,
0.07318519055843353,
0.6823814511299133,
0.9400591850280762,
-0.29032212495803833,
0.18956731259822845,
0.46060436964035034,
-0.27288374304771423,
0.29769381880760193,
-0.4044418931007385,
-0.07767676562070847,
-0.3878333270549774,
0.07519856095314026,
0.6498816013336182,
0.6051873564720154,
-0.8255285620689392,
0.6810210347175598,
-0.060423120856285095,
0.01742224395275116,
-0.5715680122375488,
-0.0066063422709703445,
0.3780430257320404,
0.03489398583769798,
-0.013385911472141743,
-0.07536845654249191,
-0.36255234479904175,
-0.8509069681167603,
0.03280146047472954,
0.47089704871177673,
-0.09476516395807266,
-0.23464740812778473,
0.642461895942688,
0.1832031011581421,
-0.12819088995456696,
0.5982425212860107,
-0.16416631639003754,
-0.2509395182132721,
0.4782419502735138,
0.6126960515975952,
0.8478126525878906,
-0.19906625151634216,
0.12347862869501114,
-0.07750211656093597,
0.09017175436019897,
-0.2755242884159088,
0.14026160538196564,
0.1167823076248169,
-0.8793621063232422,
-0.28215253353118896,
-0.4846874177455902,
-0.6506898999214172,
0.2128952294588089,
-0.7730081081390381,
0.20895841717720032,
-0.6475520133972168,
-0.3613838255405426,
-0.5131440162658691,
0.017576664686203003,
-0.2824360132217407,
0.07783807069063187,
0.1171487495303154,
0.4845128357410431,
-0.6390542387962341,
1.0668221712112427,
0.6241446733474731,
-0.2425202578306198,
-0.4603908658027649,
0.4616846442222595,
-0.05135597661137581,
-0.39516568183898926,
0.9936999082565308,
0.3127609193325043,
-0.3944449722766876,
-0.15426309406757355,
-0.35155120491981506,
-1.2271677255630493,
1.2952208518981934,
0.5213050842285156,
-0.26858747005462646,
0.1402459293603897,
-0.05724993348121643,
0.7382199764251709,
-0.7519614696502686,
0.1036299616098404,
0.49800485372543335,
0.4360651671886444,
0.11872866004705429,
-0.9102156758308411,
0.034370534121990204,
-0.16762320697307587,
0.27513283491134644,
-0.01271733921021223,
-1.1107300519943237,
0.8238061666488647,
0.05908900871872902,
-0.07993242144584656,
0.21294507384300232,
0.3901160955429077,
0.44575637578964233,
0.05403660610318184,
0.4605049192905426,
0.22118477523326874,
0.632531464099884,
0.004893484991043806,
1.0615079402923584,
-0.6809362173080444,
0.3348608911037445,
0.9864012002944946,
-0.4457685947418213,
1.083189606666565,
0.6084579825401306,
0.028395796194672585,
0.42515894770622253,
0.5466822981834412,
-0.04091294854879379,
0.2709776759147644,
0.1595717817544937,
-0.23583269119262695,
-0.2783811092376709,
0.14155665040016174,
-0.12848301231861115,
0.6052898168563843,
0.3583734333515167,
-0.3280177414417267,
0.20839063823223114,
-0.18046687543392181,
0.2199542373418808,
-0.14942215383052826,
-0.03533531352877617,
0.5038430094718933,
0.22763307392597198,
-0.7484011054039001,
0.6139008402824402,
0.0021995396818965673,
0.3463234603404999,
-0.7464343905448914,
0.2652384340763092,
-0.19879260659217834,
0.08109231293201447,
-0.1487320065498352,
-0.5887331366539001,
0.27098673582077026,
-0.08932936936616898,
-0.26164835691452026,
-0.6261525750160217,
0.5534822344779968,
-0.3161499798297882,
-0.29561254382133484,
0.4429747760295868,
0.645853579044342,
0.08451061695814133,
0.14629217982292175,
-0.2908068597316742,
0.33123958110809326,
-0.5289989709854126,
-0.5977534651756287,
0.8664267659187317,
0.2313888818025589,
-0.20930516719818115,
0.6775823831558228,
0.16220661997795105,
0.02872326411306858,
0.16470582783222198,
-0.06704289466142654,
0.7232052683830261,
-0.5560288429260254,
-0.29161450266838074,
-0.8774653077125549,
0.6542447209358215,
-0.11433662474155426,
-0.7085968255996704,
0.9631345868110657,
0.2818896174430847,
0.806109607219696,
0.18568523228168488,
0.7557593584060669,
-0.1858712136745453,
0.08212704956531525,
-0.4266221821308136,
0.722626805305481,
-0.3834023177623749,
0.5589175820350647,
-0.2592003643512726,
-0.928920567035675,
-0.09722138196229935,
0.5891162753105164,
-0.5381556749343872,
0.19803792238235474,
0.6095045208930969,
0.5629067420959473,
0.223247691988945,
-0.315936803817749,
0.48046809434890747,
0.37528905272483826,
0.5409441590309143,
0.10862098634243011,
0.8362529873847961,
0.13006457686424255,
0.29363811016082764,
-0.42217740416526794,
-0.19822347164154053,
-0.32709717750549316,
-0.8747321367263794,
-0.8525388836860657,
-0.6124135255813599,
-0.4365612268447876,
-0.39397040009498596,
-0.047349367290735245,
1.0354626178741455,
0.8526137471199036,
-0.49172496795654297,
-0.6430809497833252,
0.004502991214394569,
0.0050058625638484955,
-0.3206596374511719,
-0.22676067054271698,
0.03666350618004799,
-0.39031827449798584,
-0.6305148005485535,
0.329555869102478,
0.4778498709201813,
-0.08696901798248291,
-0.49735990166664124,
-0.1752825230360031,
0.03083270974457264,
0.20607008039951324,
0.874018669128418,
0.4120016098022461,
-0.737852931022644,
-0.5152179002761841,
-0.027315830811858177,
-0.11311421543359756,
0.3038851320743561,
0.7136369943618774,
-0.696575939655304,
0.293139785528183,
0.356953889131546,
0.5894157886505127,
0.4030243754386902,
0.3195042908191681,
0.6756088733673096,
-0.6286944150924683,
-0.10837382823228836,
0.1620113104581833,
0.3415464162826538,
0.16055412590503693,
-0.4172993302345276,
0.26531827449798584,
0.259358286857605,
-0.8451849818229675,
-0.7864506840705872,
0.5489576458930969,
-1.0437511205673218,
-0.03308822587132454,
1.2970176935195923,
-0.21656695008277893,
0.0713525339961052,
0.007493995130062103,
-0.2245379239320755,
-0.15984903275966644,
-0.44575411081314087,
1.048163890838623,
0.8320260047912598,
-0.6599498391151428,
-0.4113357663154602,
-0.5072811841964722,
0.38537847995758057,
0.49621185660362244,
-0.7179574370384216,
0.12421449273824692,
0.5006060600280762,
0.43588751554489136,
0.21173095703125,
0.8011268377304077,
-0.05202217027544975,
-0.08779575675725937,
-0.1252623051404953,
-0.3896297216415405,
0.221316859126091,
-0.22840307652950287,
-0.4839741885662079,
0.42562946677207947,
0.46804654598236084,
0.05619366094470024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12189v1 | Amplifying Training Data Exposure through Fine-Tuning with Pseudo-Labeled Memberships | 2024-02-19T14:52:50 | 2024-02-19T14:52:50 | Myung Gyo Oh, Hong Eun Ahn, Leo Hyun Park, Taekyoung Kwon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG, I.2.7; K.6.5 | Neural language models (LMs) are vulnerable to training data extraction
attacks due to data memorization. This paper introduces a novel attack scenario
wherein an attacker adversarially fine-tunes pre-trained LMs to amplify the
exposure of the original training data. This strategy differs from prior
studies by aiming to intensify the LM's retention of its pre-training dataset.
To achieve this, the attacker needs to collect generated texts that are closely
aligned with the pre-training data. However, without knowledge of the actual
dataset, quantifying the amount of pre-training data within generated texts is
challenging. To address this, we propose the use of pseudo-labels for these
generated texts, leveraging membership approximations indicated by
machine-generated probabilities from the target LM. We subsequently fine-tune
the LM to favor generations with higher likelihoods of originating from the
pre-training data, based on their membership probabilities. Our empirical
findings indicate a remarkable outcome: LMs with over 1B parameters exhibit a
four to eight-fold increase in training data exposure. We discuss potential
mitigations and suggest future research directions. | [
-0.3741707503795624,
-0.676213264465332,
0.16807863116264343,
-0.4785674512386322,
-0.35919833183288574,
-0.03808671236038208,
-0.2460443675518036,
-0.42829495668411255,
0.08265350759029388,
0.46479618549346924,
-0.5078400373458862,
-0.19320495426654816,
-0.6326649188995361,
-0.1736876219511032,
-0.4658088684082031,
1.2373126745224,
0.5244185328483582,
-0.1697510927915573,
-0.038203395903110504,
-0.026396481320261955,
-0.3680184781551361,
-0.9834495186805725,
-0.4067595899105072,
-0.18990583717823029,
0.728870689868927,
0.23467133939266205,
0.861122727394104,
0.7269009947776794,
0.19554702937602997,
0.30943912267684937,
0.08696232736110687,
0.14921927452087402,
-0.7704442739486694,
-0.06846024096012115,
0.04926304519176483,
-0.8285956978797913,
-0.3662143051624298,
0.06875661760568619,
0.7790185213088989,
0.6731352806091309,
0.16476702690124512,
0.08399317413568497,
0.02298368327319622,
0.5821075439453125,
-0.6310902833938599,
-0.2876090705394745,
-1.262853741645813,
0.038583751767873764,
-0.3828478753566742,
-0.4915195405483246,
-0.5001225471496582,
-0.14990663528442383,
0.1139523833990097,
-0.3914192318916321,
0.20160776376724243,
-0.07054179161787033,
0.9255385994911194,
0.21525155007839203,
0.01825897768139839,
-0.24945972859859467,
-0.7302548885345459,
0.6159025430679321,
-0.7962822914123535,
0.27558714151382446,
0.5961750745773315,
0.16507300734519958,
-0.31581783294677734,
-0.7933428883552551,
-0.4979921281337738,
-0.1554848849773407,
-0.18999062478542328,
-0.1600576937198639,
-0.1499510556459427,
0.07691145688295364,
0.2830118238925934,
0.4459865987300873,
-0.4604068994522095,
0.4172080457210541,
-0.456233412027359,
-0.2894209027290344,
0.5254943370819092,
0.05777634307742119,
0.5009439587593079,
0.17590464651584625,
-0.21782755851745605,
-0.14759907126426697,
-0.9135395884513855,
-0.09618016332387924,
0.8053112626075745,
0.48898202180862427,
0.0728788748383522,
0.5656518340110779,
0.09649395942687988,
1.002065658569336,
0.019370360299944878,
0.2120356261730194,
0.13380122184753418,
-0.366083562374115,
-0.2677355408668518,
0.27360981702804565,
0.8200388550758362,
0.11510627716779709,
0.45629993081092834,
-0.3293101489543915,
-0.2611841857433319,
-0.03227052837610245,
0.5929229259490967,
-0.8933321833610535,
-0.6722791194915771,
-0.03484639897942543,
-0.331266850233078,
-0.5950531363487244,
0.006771468557417393,
-0.7194699048995972,
-0.3017726540565491,
-0.2530892789363861,
0.6893677115440369,
-0.39652368426322937,
-0.13091523945331573,
-0.040467310696840286,
-0.031167976558208466,
-0.05789710953831673,
-0.3037470281124115,
-0.8991302847862244,
-0.03012496419250965,
0.44302254915237427,
0.6167888641357422,
0.20864903926849365,
-0.10780636966228485,
-0.3572731018066406,
0.039126913994550705,
-0.4392368197441101,
0.3132942020893097,
-0.4733172059059143,
-0.2626655697822571,
-0.05433937907218933,
-0.27124953269958496,
-0.17909537255764008,
-0.5701819062232971,
0.2940622866153717,
-0.8610153794288635,
0.16248181462287903,
0.10797454416751862,
-0.6798229217529297,
0.36301469802856445,
0.33962002396583557,
-0.6189978718757629,
0.8460623621940613,
0.14835521578788757,
-0.7707902789115906,
0.27664193511009216,
-0.3053376078605652,
-0.31945639848709106,
-0.029027575626969337,
-0.0528906024992466,
-0.8300804495811462,
0.24429866671562195,
0.13540305197238922,
0.37299844622612,
0.11456677317619324,
0.0035604515578597784,
-0.37690532207489014,
-0.29857033491134644,
0.6505987644195557,
-0.5193619132041931,
0.6082460284233093,
0.22029247879981995,
-0.15287667512893677,
0.11852971464395523,
-1.0395087003707886,
0.347873330116272,
0.10439250618219376,
-0.2524934411048889,
-0.7244464159011841,
0.04801586642861366,
-0.46630555391311646,
0.3270106613636017,
0.13583046197891235,
-0.19749000668525696,
0.19324274361133575,
-0.9417886137962341,
0.2561148703098297,
0.7411516904830933,
0.2563691735267639,
0.5047578811645508,
-0.17822417616844177,
0.44267144799232483,
-0.10758227854967117,
0.11557181924581528,
-0.22018291056156158,
-0.08882170170545578,
-0.695965051651001,
-0.3631111681461334,
0.5731918811798096,
0.20279835164546967,
-0.952656090259552,
0.624068558216095,
-0.34343624114990234,
-0.7774470448493958,
-0.5761157870292664,
0.26111918687820435,
0.5199406147003174,
0.5960612893104553,
0.5368321537971497,
-0.0739268958568573,
-0.7182281613349915,
-0.9203903675079346,
-0.5584086775779724,
-0.17438571155071259,
-0.2226075679063797,
0.30507877469062805,
0.15394726395606995,
-0.13701876997947693,
0.9783431887626648,
-0.5834357738494873,
-0.37627384066581726,
-0.2126532644033432,
0.13324390351772308,
0.17330218851566315,
0.5734803080558777,
0.7333546280860901,
-0.63326495885849,
-0.344598650932312,
-0.1994662582874298,
-0.4921531677246094,
-0.03887411579489708,
-0.44712069630622864,
-0.020738694816827774,
-0.27013006806373596,
0.7000780701637268,
-0.21969468891620636,
0.4462767541408539,
0.4296642243862152,
-0.061490193009376526,
0.4531126320362091,
-0.22154968976974487,
-0.34032881259918213,
-1.0612345933914185,
-0.02652818150818348,
-0.12935040891170502,
-0.1174587681889534,
-0.995739758014679,
0.053994059562683105,
0.15220195055007935,
-0.0994110181927681,
-0.45412519574165344,
0.2226221263408661,
-0.5651096105575562,
0.1596074253320694,
-0.3996756374835968,
-0.17504924535751343,
-0.314601331949234,
0.3517466187477112,
-0.15366651117801666,
0.8265868425369263,
0.6164147257804871,
-0.7452970147132874,
-0.0640590712428093,
0.13251730799674988,
-0.3540450632572174,
0.11197302490472794,
-0.5480773448944092,
0.4775228798389435,
-0.05783700570464134,
0.1062278300523758,
-0.7676310539245605,
-0.09794062376022339,
0.27977466583251953,
-0.6712799072265625,
0.656595766544342,
-0.3638272285461426,
-0.4750806391239166,
-0.24153269827365875,
-0.21190865337848663,
0.43105244636535645,
0.3592537045478821,
-0.5448383092880249,
0.24415762722492218,
0.5359207391738892,
0.12987467646598816,
-0.6044819951057434,
-0.6818296313285828,
0.33969494700431824,
-0.46957260370254517,
-0.1331876963376999,
0.3004893362522125,
-0.020440462976694107,
0.18623554706573486,
-0.22510682046413422,
-0.05072026699781418,
0.0298421923071146,
0.4504256844520569,
0.11714866012334824,
0.19848091900348663,
-0.2014223337173462,
-0.007428640034049749,
-0.13931764662265778,
-0.07869578152894974,
0.24664466083049774,
-0.4139247536659241,
0.648525595664978,
0.059252504259347916,
-0.11018075793981552,
-0.3275417685508728,
0.003649727674201131,
0.2384999692440033,
-0.3090214431285858,
1.1250429153442383,
0.30706048011779785,
-0.44572320580482483,
-0.510517418384552,
-0.0024725596886128187,
-0.48537570238113403,
-0.5539948344230652,
0.7363962531089783,
-0.37519413232803345,
-0.5720347166061401,
0.34319832921028137,
-0.08951256424188614,
-0.004063143394887447,
0.2044362723827362,
0.5049939155578613,
-0.34233391284942627,
0.998891294002533,
0.5121772289276123,
-0.37667620182037354,
0.6852377653121948,
-0.25638148188591003,
0.25282764434814453,
-0.5510546565055847,
-0.16284537315368652,
-0.581381618976593,
-0.553523600101471,
-0.36812251806259155,
-0.11512427031993866,
0.14151352643966675,
0.4115157127380371,
0.1831178367137909,
0.5906235575675964,
-0.48817622661590576,
0.5598905086517334,
0.4452981948852539,
0.20646512508392334,
-0.25861236453056335,
0.0549963116645813,
0.08237463980913162,
-0.12948884069919586,
-0.9000452160835266,
-0.3498718738555908,
1.3471271991729736,
0.39900222420692444,
0.553928017616272,
0.09841252118349075,
0.7786529660224915,
0.23301327228546143,
0.4348767399787903,
-0.6316614747047424,
0.4864329993724823,
-0.047302357852458954,
-0.6358367800712585,
-0.1470123678445816,
-0.7373363971710205,
-1.0708824396133423,
-0.003537744050845504,
-0.4336904287338257,
-0.8175544142723083,
0.32513296604156494,
0.4656302332878113,
-0.267638623714447,
0.30306392908096313,
-0.7166529893875122,
0.7663361430168152,
-0.3780500888824463,
-0.14845946431159973,
0.06756199896335602,
-0.8359155058860779,
0.38918739557266235,
-0.5261811017990112,
0.18972228467464447,
0.2835995554924011,
0.23375143110752106,
0.8318738341331482,
-0.5539602041244507,
1.0322265625,
-0.26225537061691284,
-0.06480977684259415,
0.21928249299526215,
-0.03913058713078499,
0.6150403022766113,
-0.13767051696777344,
-0.05970879644155502,
0.09765087813138962,
-0.24059586226940155,
-0.274830162525177,
-0.5991930961608887,
0.6014223098754883,
-0.8681541681289673,
-0.4911485016345978,
-0.25338655710220337,
-0.46351930499076843,
-0.5022148489952087,
0.34092599153518677,
0.45393016934394836,
0.41859614849090576,
-0.13443762063980103,
0.358970046043396,
0.6254358291625977,
-0.18422497808933258,
0.4371277689933777,
0.323471337556839,
0.09102237969636917,
-0.509198009967804,
1.4584304094314575,
0.2800508439540863,
0.6530812978744507,
0.13656745851039886,
0.08225889503955841,
-0.29234248399734497,
-0.9906080961227417,
-0.3503986597061157,
-0.06041434779763222,
-0.5196978449821472,
-0.36539608240127563,
-0.5651123523712158,
-0.37531623244285583,
-0.1405366212129593,
0.23733849823474884,
-0.29129135608673096,
-0.3338281512260437,
-0.7103468179702759,
-0.2333415001630783,
0.06937212496995926,
0.16019009053707123,
0.0984659418463707,
0.9170597195625305,
-0.8913934230804443,
0.36014610528945923,
0.16945567727088928,
0.273306667804718,
-0.1481999307870865,
-0.8014053702354431,
-0.4853920042514801,
0.23588542640209198,
-0.10438627749681473,
-1.1088364124298096,
0.4205990433692932,
0.6221317052841187,
0.5563448667526245,
0.5460571646690369,
0.16371223330497742,
0.7848063707351685,
-0.5474068522453308,
0.5783320069313049,
0.15665780007839203,
-0.5514461994171143,
0.45058873295783997,
-0.3027358651161194,
0.06974542886018753,
0.7809281945228577,
0.3437507450580597,
-0.057298384606838226,
-0.48467016220092773,
-0.7915038466453552,
-0.9728142023086548,
0.9873694777488708,
0.34870246052742004,
0.5635015368461609,
0.0404883474111557,
0.5934715867042542,
-0.2110784351825714,
0.17150522768497467,
-0.7632460594177246,
-0.6701734662055969,
-0.36707639694213867,
-0.33903899788856506,
-0.12087316066026688,
-0.3056349754333496,
-0.040181342512369156,
-0.18939828872680664,
0.6777839064598083,
-0.040272608399391174,
-0.05385212600231171,
-0.13493934273719788,
-0.34188008308410645,
0.08072898536920547,
0.1064796969294548,
0.501230001449585,
0.4844079613685608,
-0.13620972633361816,
0.36968374252319336,
-0.0038709540385752916,
-0.5586901307106018,
0.0878889411687851,
0.1877683848142624,
-0.4016988277435303,
0.056121740490198135,
0.4078526794910431,
0.8330517411231995,
0.15061388909816742,
-0.41204774379730225,
0.2937392592430115,
-0.11497558653354645,
-0.10764019936323166,
-0.11338142305612564,
0.2919676899909973,
0.05230800434947014,
-0.16489645838737488,
0.4122428297996521,
0.2817457318305969,
-0.13151560723781586,
-0.5482379794120789,
0.7043723464012146,
0.5466910600662231,
-0.564828634262085,
-0.5230029821395874,
0.6152166128158569,
-0.12991632521152496,
-0.4694303274154663,
0.43665197491645813,
0.21303020417690277,
-0.7049645185470581,
0.5056296586990356,
0.7188272476196289,
0.5497596263885498,
-0.4844840466976166,
-0.0760352686047554,
0.40722325444221497,
0.5567644238471985,
0.21216152608394623,
-0.2484988272190094,
0.03726925700902939,
-0.7533190846443176,
-0.05554865300655365,
-0.6831075549125671,
0.17856745421886444,
0.6170014142990112,
-0.7348839044570923,
0.17431771755218506,
-0.5934293866157532,
-0.2587130665779114,
0.2102339267730713,
-0.3049550950527191,
-0.38244134187698364,
0.6196485161781311,
0.22771722078323364,
0.5034461617469788,
-0.8403925895690918,
1.1740427017211914,
0.39830324053764343,
-0.27859872579574585,
-0.7967326641082764,
0.10132580250501633,
-0.20630903542041779,
-0.6938996315002441,
0.3966979682445526,
0.04627605155110359,
0.21191993355751038,
0.1962762475013733,
-0.33325010538101196,
-0.6160659193992615,
0.3643024265766144,
0.6022616028785706,
-0.7202081680297852,
-0.027702245861291885,
0.5302690863609314,
0.6993786692619324,
0.03246122971177101,
-0.02022663503885269,
0.7492853999137878,
0.2564418613910675,
-0.2595843970775604,
-0.4233679175376892,
-0.21653532981872559,
-0.2832586169242859,
-0.2851989269256592,
0.2651556134223938,
-0.0847424790263176,
0.5998747944831848,
0.007846253924071789,
-0.1908619999885559,
-0.10361278057098389,
0.8113107085227966,
0.09748547524213791,
0.08745638281106949,
0.7294779419898987,
0.3962669372558594,
0.6818415522575378,
0.03223932161927223,
1.02816903591156,
-0.23038367927074432,
0.080646812915802,
1.5676168203353882,
0.22075019776821136,
0.5724661946296692,
0.5786389708518982,
-0.011082310229539871,
-0.04697709530591965,
0.683586061000824,
-0.01764741539955139,
0.7814859747886658,
0.5371108651161194,
-0.2149098962545395,
-0.17063255608081818,
0.08765086531639099,
-0.5327724814414978,
0.32455676794052124,
0.5467674136161804,
-0.779063880443573,
-0.04567084088921547,
-0.0651785135269165,
-0.02557753399014473,
0.21022090315818787,
-0.35444480180740356,
1.1559209823608398,
0.2096855193376541,
-0.44574105739593506,
0.766669511795044,
0.08349078893661499,
0.3976931571960449,
-0.823911190032959,
0.10388895124197006,
-0.034698497503995895,
0.3277387320995331,
-0.28078606724739075,
-0.40626272559165955,
0.34976670145988464,
-0.01071560475975275,
-0.08110959082841873,
-0.07398679107427597,
0.8491048216819763,
-0.6360861659049988,
-0.5108562111854553,
0.15270446240901947,
0.04236597567796707,
0.025188438594341278,
-0.12202296406030655,
-0.655276894569397,
-0.09748309850692749,
0.19806089997291565,
-0.36258864402770996,
0.7859919667243958,
0.275281697511673,
-0.011426816694438457,
0.3319767713546753,
0.9141671657562256,
0.4046526849269867,
0.4352526366710663,
0.04849955067038536,
1.2018988132476807,
-0.13979150354862213,
-0.34353652596473694,
-1.223894715309143,
0.2988485097885132,
-0.15386974811553955,
-0.3893331289291382,
0.7623050212860107,
0.602651834487915,
0.8526540994644165,
-0.10062523931264877,
0.6288084387779236,
0.21137233078479767,
0.21103963255882263,
-0.530474066734314,
1.1601896286010742,
-0.5175898671150208,
0.4828311502933502,
-0.3295411765575409,
-0.8529428243637085,
-0.3865039050579071,
0.313317209482193,
-0.339493066072464,
0.013749988749623299,
0.15627379715442657,
1.0343891382217407,
-0.14580334722995758,
-0.19731177389621735,
0.4345856010913849,
0.27156925201416016,
0.4580968916416168,
0.3922700583934784,
0.8308694362640381,
-0.42991527915000916,
0.7286038398742676,
-0.2508658170700073,
-0.09682700037956238,
-0.0006149603868834674,
-0.7352434992790222,
-1.2131255865097046,
-0.3795487582683563,
-0.2089744359254837,
-0.264614462852478,
0.08597273379564285,
0.47035980224609375,
0.7514432072639465,
-0.8945774435997009,
0.3607727289199829,
-0.13637562096118927,
-0.20179806649684906,
0.0883387103676796,
-0.18460704386234283,
0.5432008504867554,
-0.3903433382511139,
-0.46687453985214233,
0.7553507685661316,
-0.20817600190639496,
0.15471181273460388,
-0.021808182820677757,
-0.033495593816041946,
-0.17871135473251343,
0.15539678931236267,
0.12425380945205688,
0.43775543570518494,
-0.2613678574562073,
-0.2949989438056946,
-0.2955351769924164,
-0.08613473176956177,
0.016708100214600563,
0.8431714177131653,
-0.7251890301704407,
0.592024028301239,
0.30622121691703796,
0.9909713864326477,
0.30783259868621826,
0.12266363203525543,
0.7002004981040955,
-1.4479113817214966,
0.3047234117984772,
0.4182475507259369,
0.21590615808963776,
0.18099629878997803,
-0.530212938785553,
0.08930022269487381,
0.028081532567739487,
-0.135112926363945,
-1.2709662914276123,
0.16220872104167938,
-0.5117034912109375,
-0.4690140187740326,
0.7007585167884827,
-0.303438276052475,
-0.18388378620147705,
-0.1734372079372406,
-0.09092593938112259,
0.4435999393463135,
0.15668043494224548,
0.7963930368423462,
0.34221765398979187,
0.40746867656707764,
-0.025822505354881287,
-0.36031007766723633,
0.8298943042755127,
0.6212225556373596,
-0.8356040120124817,
0.19125376641750336,
0.28811532258987427,
0.2101077139377594,
0.09241835027933121,
0.37449535727500916,
-0.16888642311096191,
0.05432244390249252,
-0.2194427102804184,
-0.18870623409748077,
-0.40448445081710815,
-0.4992991089820862,
-0.35232052206993103,
0.27940231561660767,
0.006456774193793535,
-0.35630810260772705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12177v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12177v4 | Mafin: Enhancing Black-Box Embeddings with Model Augmented Fine-Tuning | 2024-02-19T14:33:24 | 2024-03-12T16:04:23 | Mingtian Zhang, Shawn Lan, Peter Hayes, David Barber | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) has emerged as an effective solution for
mitigating hallucinations in Large Language Models (LLMs). The retrieval stage
in RAG typically involves a pre-trained embedding model, which converts queries
and passages into vectors to capture their semantics. However, a standard
pre-trained embedding model may exhibit sub-optimal performance when applied to
specific domain knowledge, necessitating fine-tuning. This paper addresses
scenarios where the embeddings are only available from a black-box model. We
introduce Model augmented fine-tuning (Mafin) -- a novel approach for
fine-tuning a black-box embedding model by augmenting it with a trainable
embedding model. Our results demonstrate that Mafin significantly enhances the
performance of the black-box embeddings by only requiring the training of a
small augmented model. We validate the effectiveness of our method on both
labeled and unlabeled datasets, illustrating its broad applicability and
efficiency. | [
-0.7868673801422119,
-1.0405585765838623,
0.36587944626808167,
-0.3792279064655304,
-0.5025632381439209,
0.18105395138263702,
-0.18826377391815186,
-0.4084734320640564,
0.1717837154865265,
0.7978247404098511,
-0.2069496512413025,
-0.35508793592453003,
-0.6855599284172058,
-0.05948364734649658,
-0.0981823205947876,
0.9028979539871216,
0.1766008734703064,
-0.15631891787052155,
-0.1251286119222641,
-0.1463133841753006,
-0.5890399813652039,
-0.5524646639823914,
-0.6230974197387695,
-0.3803843557834625,
0.25396454334259033,
0.3975306451320648,
0.8443974852561951,
0.8140407204627991,
0.301196426153183,
0.1704055219888687,
-0.06079929322004318,
0.952867865562439,
-0.7973108887672424,
0.13223303854465485,
-0.41152340173721313,
-0.2963072955608368,
-0.4993375837802887,
-0.08952879160642624,
0.46543240547180176,
0.5690125823020935,
-0.17620114982128143,
0.29522982239723206,
0.03669562190771103,
0.4342727065086365,
-1.069623589515686,
-0.04744185134768486,
-0.9588097333908081,
0.12288022041320801,
-0.038412705063819885,
-0.5023984909057617,
-0.2951348125934601,
0.040872830897569656,
-0.1692177951335907,
-0.6625299453735352,
0.28831836581230164,
0.556290328502655,
0.7859869003295898,
0.516114354133606,
-0.3736833930015564,
-0.07867559045553207,
-0.6505496501922607,
0.7976575493812561,
-0.684958815574646,
0.6084193587303162,
0.6113920211791992,
0.35275182127952576,
-0.30572620034217834,
-0.35739174485206604,
-0.4732586145401001,
-0.1465308666229248,
-0.0734645277261734,
-0.34808313846588135,
-0.049130942672491074,
0.08875338733196259,
0.2870638072490692,
0.5918602347373962,
-0.05244598537683487,
0.008103354834020138,
-0.29385778307914734,
-0.17385652661323547,
0.5759866833686829,
0.020150624215602875,
0.06908359378576279,
-0.12723039090633392,
-0.16228847205638885,
-0.16032811999320984,
-0.7287158966064453,
-0.30838829278945923,
0.2694036066532135,
0.6110836267471313,
0.24343368411064148,
0.9454528093338013,
-0.12480582296848297,
0.8238064050674438,
0.23122669756412506,
-0.0355805829167366,
0.1347796618938446,
-0.040856845676898956,
-0.38640469312667847,
0.0643344521522522,
0.28097015619277954,
0.2574251890182495,
0.271013468503952,
-0.26497265696525574,
-0.6689308881759644,
0.13262778520584106,
0.5842359066009521,
-0.717144250869751,
-0.24422472715377808,
-0.053758710622787476,
-0.2046111822128296,
-0.32112258672714233,
0.0941038429737091,
-0.720345675945282,
-0.4893035888671875,
-0.42895275354385376,
0.7959643602371216,
-0.1847313940525055,
-0.3446745276451111,
0.435342401266098,
-0.10873743146657944,
0.1620877981185913,
0.1301870048046112,
-0.8359206914901733,
0.26304107904434204,
1.0359405279159546,
0.6622747182846069,
0.02110682800412178,
0.03185007721185684,
-1.057602882385254,
0.3751384913921356,
-0.5806813836097717,
0.7682173848152161,
-1.01497220993042,
-0.42231300473213196,
0.06000089272856712,
-0.011066182516515255,
0.08908465504646301,
-0.7048315405845642,
0.41053876280784607,
-0.5330052375793457,
-0.28757530450820923,
0.062024664133787155,
-0.5905950665473938,
-0.1996416449546814,
0.28494611382484436,
-0.5187044739723206,
1.0848432779312134,
0.03370067477226257,
-0.4869934022426605,
0.22232328355312347,
-0.4677661657333374,
-0.42948514223098755,
-0.11688343435525894,
-0.0889371857047081,
-0.7035015225410461,
0.5323392748832703,
0.48769739270210266,
0.779470682144165,
-0.22496594488620758,
0.09758821874856949,
-0.5432486534118652,
-0.5653076171875,
0.043385300785303116,
-0.12885405123233795,
0.09483402222394943,
0.293877512216568,
-0.23074255883693695,
-0.25604432821273804,
-0.9719796776771545,
-0.12331653386354446,
-0.027259116992354393,
-0.12302114814519882,
-0.7744224667549133,
-0.175608292222023,
-0.2961258590221405,
0.03576139733195305,
0.15232700109481812,
-0.49311456084251404,
0.22774386405944824,
-0.6282157301902771,
0.19288402795791626,
0.6442294120788574,
0.30758145451545715,
0.5853160619735718,
-0.4272092878818512,
0.5958879590034485,
-0.03851399943232536,
-0.051625922322273254,
-0.08132348209619522,
-0.24678534269332886,
-0.9201841354370117,
-0.2763676643371582,
0.5855657458305359,
0.3632137179374695,
-0.7782208919525146,
0.21734192967414856,
-0.026203341782093048,
-0.2687408924102783,
-1.0826220512390137,
0.29538482427597046,
0.5394393801689148,
0.32988297939300537,
0.47655460238456726,
-0.17357470095157623,
-0.3814341425895691,
-1.0070619583129883,
-0.16954739391803741,
0.5507612228393555,
0.13311098515987396,
0.6545030474662781,
0.4265979528427124,
-0.46473971009254456,
0.4832349717617035,
-0.6697784662246704,
-0.3667741119861603,
0.15884080529212952,
0.15297865867614746,
-0.10357718169689178,
0.6719166040420532,
0.3276768624782562,
-0.7225604057312012,
-0.24895566701889038,
0.23846693336963654,
-0.3819240629673004,
0.04287354275584221,
0.14121031761169434,
-0.5290969014167786,
0.051773834973573685,
0.6607645153999329,
-0.19853487610816956,
0.5137374997138977,
0.50658118724823,
-0.4130100607872009,
0.3649585545063019,
-0.42710140347480774,
0.1936739981174469,
-0.97885662317276,
0.02638169750571251,
-0.23267079889774323,
-0.5697612166404724,
-0.39994439482688904,
0.27634140849113464,
0.1461847871541977,
-0.2762993276119232,
-0.332235723733902,
0.7921645641326904,
-0.5991997718811035,
-0.09254555404186249,
-0.5398373603820801,
0.0784953385591507,
0.0994783341884613,
0.5233091711997986,
-0.2862895131111145,
1.0937780141830444,
0.30035948753356934,
-0.8733108043670654,
-0.10143439471721649,
0.4217093884944916,
-0.34136849641799927,
0.495680034160614,
-0.630283772945404,
0.3541843295097351,
-0.16830052435398102,
-0.43089553713798523,
-0.7103100419044495,
-0.033608634024858475,
0.18181255459785461,
-0.2514877915382385,
0.6114254593849182,
-0.43292850255966187,
-0.46848994493484497,
-0.06608202308416367,
-0.2821294665336609,
0.40174317359924316,
0.42468783259391785,
-0.7349703311920166,
0.5710274577140808,
0.6671138405799866,
0.09470194578170776,
-0.661827027797699,
-0.5063944458961487,
-0.14995737373828888,
-0.06680016219615936,
-0.1926986128091812,
0.34348130226135254,
0.056992821395397186,
0.008237357251346111,
0.06558835506439209,
-0.1230345368385315,
0.25067824125289917,
0.23730924725532532,
0.12600350379943848,
-0.023054422810673714,
-0.23375822603702545,
0.1983606219291687,
0.4278755486011505,
-0.20093397796154022,
-0.3497520685195923,
-0.2826088070869446,
0.43108347058296204,
0.09124770760536194,
-0.2893693149089813,
0.1487688571214676,
0.36830639839172363,
0.3366073668003082,
-0.7915474772453308,
0.8775174617767334,
0.5961402058601379,
-0.5447893738746643,
-0.6411249041557312,
-0.7525923252105713,
-0.2877250909805298,
-0.5040157437324524,
0.16587957739830017,
-0.63877934217453,
-1.232861876487732,
0.39520201086997986,
-0.4649200141429901,
-0.06149248778820038,
0.28628984093666077,
0.4044078290462494,
0.0978827178478241,
1.3493332862854004,
0.9728014469146729,
0.27594900131225586,
0.5324956178665161,
-0.4346920847892761,
0.15461227297782898,
-1.2426837682724,
-0.08725843578577042,
-0.41803646087646484,
-0.27619388699531555,
-0.5104857683181763,
-0.5490891933441162,
0.3403744101524353,
0.29805639386177063,
-0.3891681134700775,
-0.07185610383749008,
-0.6769712567329407,
0.6585373878479004,
0.42712488770484924,
0.25030630826950073,
0.30918699502944946,
0.1617973893880844,
-0.40382280945777893,
0.15240859985351562,
-0.7863032221794128,
-0.5238687992095947,
1.1965378522872925,
0.23259471356868744,
0.6038051843643188,
-0.00033309304853901267,
0.6061305999755859,
0.3823678493499756,
0.16039548814296722,
-0.6430721879005432,
0.3436436951160431,
-0.3165106475353241,
-0.6460705399513245,
-0.18280364573001862,
-0.35526955127716064,
-1.0777536630630493,
0.4563640356063843,
-0.7762385606765747,
-0.49034225940704346,
0.48041096329689026,
0.3317011296749115,
-0.522429347038269,
0.46750667691230774,
-0.6063628196716309,
0.7868115901947021,
0.07358115911483765,
-0.3672531247138977,
-0.31104421615600586,
-0.043155182152986526,
0.48722636699676514,
-0.2916807234287262,
0.17830199003219604,
-0.2587936818599701,
-0.1690700501203537,
0.531252920627594,
-0.42076465487480164,
0.6240397095680237,
-0.1814655065536499,
-0.12304629385471344,
-0.039540134370326996,
0.266641229391098,
0.7156296968460083,
0.17538119852542877,
-0.12528933584690094,
-0.1632898896932602,
-0.0013606937136501074,
-0.5550369024276733,
-0.828652560710907,
0.7584230303764343,
-0.6979250907897949,
-0.8379737138748169,
-0.1930747926235199,
-0.5215042233467102,
-0.4707064628601074,
0.23493649065494537,
-0.18255440890789032,
0.6199325323104858,
-0.03163992241024971,
0.30680060386657715,
0.9242262244224548,
-0.28037044405937195,
-0.10600493848323822,
0.44478461146354675,
-0.3653522729873657,
-0.5750810503959656,
1.0319204330444336,
0.12194152176380157,
0.12190798670053482,
0.381285697221756,
0.04933302477002144,
-0.12953625619411469,
-0.8020206689834595,
-0.2793566584587097,
0.46553218364715576,
-0.5025054812431335,
-0.569108247756958,
-0.6581407785415649,
-0.10542500764131546,
-0.21619895100593567,
-0.16242104768753052,
-0.5204293131828308,
-0.4525211453437805,
-0.4622831642627716,
-0.1640951931476593,
0.537276566028595,
0.7982557415962219,
-0.13819119334220886,
0.344271719455719,
-0.6741873025894165,
0.5823575258255005,
0.3540279269218445,
0.7973801493644714,
0.21107208728790283,
-0.6668172478675842,
-0.5933860540390015,
0.3167782723903656,
-0.2087966352701187,
-0.4878957271575928,
0.483540803194046,
0.34213557839393616,
0.5572470426559448,
0.28331729769706726,
0.20466084778308868,
0.9789325594902039,
-0.6642465591430664,
0.4067362844944,
-0.35665300488471985,
-0.7299241423606873,
0.6054705381393433,
-0.37431037425994873,
0.03108828328549862,
0.5703908801078796,
0.21043752133846283,
-0.02114207297563553,
-0.44926902651786804,
-0.6087967157363892,
-0.583586573600769,
0.36364850401878357,
-0.13270002603530884,
0.22163072228431702,
0.008460002951323986,
0.678870677947998,
0.23620247840881348,
0.4107903242111206,
-0.12697668373584747,
-0.2579711377620697,
-0.01548180915415287,
0.028549540787935257,
-0.5663416981697083,
-0.5162525773048401,
-0.19194357097148895,
-0.4743165373802185,
0.7186275124549866,
-0.09469104558229446,
0.3348221182823181,
0.01880800910294056,
-0.3057458698749542,
-0.28562429547309875,
0.08327393978834152,
0.6425277590751648,
0.5728694796562195,
-0.43254274129867554,
0.27489033341407776,
0.22496184706687927,
-0.27909335494041443,
0.06871537119150162,
0.2827703654766083,
-0.17175346612930298,
-0.06530960649251938,
-0.07281960546970367,
1.062591314315796,
0.6934608221054077,
-0.41696783900260925,
0.16166354715824127,
0.146589457988739,
-0.06334136426448822,
-0.011253958567976952,
0.3616931736469269,
-0.24046282470226288,
0.5070279836654663,
0.3341604769229889,
0.1179860308766365,
0.20231546461582184,
-0.4209637939929962,
0.39976468682289124,
0.7044078707695007,
-0.1607077270746231,
0.026130402460694313,
0.7652223706245422,
-0.022833241149783134,
-0.42198464274406433,
0.28783655166625977,
-0.32860812544822693,
-0.3879861533641815,
0.16209706664085388,
0.6860280632972717,
0.6508612632751465,
-0.05793871730566025,
0.06370268762111664,
0.23650579154491425,
0.3059733510017395,
-0.13378669321537018,
0.26385483145713806,
-0.056317318230867386,
-0.7809869050979614,
-0.4727201461791992,
-0.9429800510406494,
-0.4136846661567688,
0.09461156278848648,
-0.7207201719284058,
0.2871708273887634,
-0.4976296126842499,
-0.24440886080265045,
-0.03803058713674545,
0.38956746459007263,
-0.7789345383644104,
0.14357686042785645,
-0.0018168981187045574,
0.8274679183959961,
-0.6196272969245911,
0.7318530678749084,
0.7347077131271362,
-0.22400659322738647,
-0.6761429309844971,
-0.3692016303539276,
-0.4516333341598511,
-0.7478022575378418,
0.030215393751859665,
-0.1526244878768921,
-0.1159885972738266,
0.4370298981666565,
-0.513992190361023,
-0.827885091304779,
0.9693779349327087,
0.5002443790435791,
-0.6069620251655579,
0.27334508299827576,
-0.10090680420398712,
0.44830045104026794,
-0.622805118560791,
-0.06319865584373474,
0.6437076926231384,
0.3653582036495209,
-0.04761096462607384,
-0.7405430674552917,
0.02480302006006241,
-0.31635019183158875,
0.13374796509742737,
0.47455015778541565,
-0.36597147583961487,
0.6224649548530579,
-0.06761571019887924,
-0.21039733290672302,
-0.13945400714874268,
0.6752466559410095,
0.3829374611377716,
0.2271137833595276,
0.4272370934486389,
0.7159891128540039,
1.0225493907928467,
0.1495601087808609,
1.2975565195083618,
-0.36077529191970825,
0.17474710941314697,
1.0070066452026367,
0.13678085803985596,
1.1963529586791992,
0.3206856846809387,
0.18663646280765533,
0.10310384631156921,
0.4591027498245239,
-0.10352379828691483,
0.702338695526123,
-0.02576933056116104,
-0.028795519843697548,
-0.5600899457931519,
-0.15203239023685455,
-0.4834098517894745,
0.3257139325141907,
0.6557452082633972,
-0.24019074440002441,
0.05596018582582474,
0.48633986711502075,
-0.13422904908657074,
0.2829064130783081,
-0.5888320207595825,
0.8209311962127686,
0.235609233379364,
-0.5030480027198792,
1.0634640455245972,
0.11690916121006012,
0.8760979771614075,
-0.20807914435863495,
-0.2345045655965805,
-0.20538370311260223,
0.21893246471881866,
-0.04104474186897278,
-0.3635602593421936,
0.3026152551174164,
-0.22126230597496033,
-0.19311903417110443,
0.05819867551326752,
0.9334139227867126,
-0.7057207226753235,
-0.645505428314209,
0.18936169147491455,
0.6315522789955139,
-0.02504175342619419,
-0.09203182905912399,
-0.6546059250831604,
0.09650614857673645,
-0.14109687507152557,
-0.047455355525016785,
0.4285871088504791,
0.6173830628395081,
0.12585332989692688,
0.6829388737678528,
0.8954806327819824,
0.30215078592300415,
0.11882111430168152,
-0.11659568548202515,
0.980588436126709,
-0.6296040415763855,
-0.31874722242355347,
-0.5786898136138916,
0.3272079825401306,
0.039853472262620926,
-0.10901486128568649,
0.6754981279373169,
0.5113889575004578,
0.8242659568786621,
-0.14812910556793213,
0.5473125576972961,
0.5448970198631287,
0.7967700958251953,
-0.5940903425216675,
0.8128361105918884,
-1.0090383291244507,
0.2669481635093689,
-0.19678276777267456,
-0.9861484169960022,
-0.38634243607521057,
0.7446028590202332,
-0.35574138164520264,
-0.08353656530380249,
0.17372143268585205,
1.2389339208602905,
-0.5643521547317505,
-0.23007646203041077,
0.6570094227790833,
0.176370769739151,
0.11922543495893478,
0.29116490483283997,
0.667218029499054,
-0.4636573791503906,
0.32604655623435974,
-0.2964703142642975,
-0.039196811616420746,
-0.40715986490249634,
-0.772871732711792,
-1.221992015838623,
-0.5622429847717285,
-0.23822766542434692,
-0.2332594394683838,
0.39817726612091064,
0.8771970868110657,
0.7036069631576538,
-0.891412615776062,
0.09795142710208893,
0.392900675535202,
0.2193189561367035,
-0.12324575334787369,
-0.138252854347229,
0.26859599351882935,
-0.4077933728694916,
-0.7076573371887207,
0.3887353241443634,
0.11859389394521713,
0.25981613993644714,
-0.278993159532547,
-0.04791204631328583,
-0.3784453272819519,
0.3785930871963501,
0.7122315764427185,
0.19601117074489594,
-0.443899005651474,
-0.3939500153064728,
-0.1930876076221466,
0.04908093065023422,
-0.0008183251484297216,
0.6585286855697632,
-0.8593767881393433,
0.5971184968948364,
0.1688235104084015,
1.0276376008987427,
0.7241023182868958,
0.18244504928588867,
0.898145854473114,
-0.958713948726654,
0.3835879862308502,
0.13356901705265045,
0.2771301567554474,
0.40086841583251953,
-0.46353229880332947,
0.5163536667823792,
-0.2291135936975479,
-0.49587318301200867,
-1.2373048067092896,
-0.0017754518194124103,
-0.646884024143219,
-0.31969529390335083,
1.1004897356033325,
0.2715701758861542,
-0.28344017267227173,
-0.15200582146644592,
-0.3231314718723297,
0.31411978602409363,
-0.3213775157928467,
0.7523856163024902,
0.5134463906288147,
0.2460578978061676,
-0.3953680694103241,
-0.8259945511817932,
0.7743898630142212,
0.40805119276046753,
-0.35237425565719604,
-0.039784498512744904,
0.3500664234161377,
0.0019462046911939979,
0.03340843692421913,
0.1644013673067093,
0.040831323713064194,
0.17334116995334625,
-0.136363223195076,
-0.18851159512996674,
-0.7102278470993042,
-0.378948837518692,
-0.3948289752006531,
0.2212509661912918,
0.18534305691719055,
-0.2500646710395813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12174v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12174v2 | BIDER: Bridging Knowledge Inconsistency for Efficient Retrieval-Augmented LLMs via Key Supporting Evidence | 2024-02-19T14:28:31 | 2024-05-30T11:26:58 | Jiajie Jin, Yutao Zhu, Yujia Zhou, Zhicheng Dou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated efficacy
in knowledge-intensive tasks such as open-domain QA, addressing inherent
challenges in knowledge update and factual inadequacy. However, inconsistencies
between retrieval knowledge and the necessary knowledge for LLMs, leading to a
decline in LLM's answer quality. This paper introduces BIDER, an approach that
refines retrieval documents into Key Supporting Evidence (KSE) through
knowledge synthesis, supervised fine-tuning (SFT), and preference alignment. We
train BIDER by learning from crafting KSE, while maximizing its output to align
with LLM's information acquisition preferences through reinforcement learning.
Evaluations across five datasets show BIDER boosts LLMs' answer quality by 7%
while reducing input content length in retrieval documents by 80%,
outperforming existing methods. The proposed KSE simulation effectively equips
LLMs with essential information for accurate question answering. | [
-0.23191174864768982,
-0.5192922949790955,
0.9181112051010132,
-0.32467523217201233,
-0.19314785301685333,
0.176921546459198,
0.06905978173017502,
-0.12488231062889099,
0.07262657582759857,
0.480974406003952,
-0.3612043559551239,
-0.41567352414131165,
-0.6969879865646362,
-0.16946345567703247,
0.050787873566150665,
0.9521835446357727,
-0.23493435978889465,
0.18282562494277954,
-0.6160512566566467,
-0.21604569256305695,
-0.3253100514411926,
-0.19169066846370697,
-0.7004267573356628,
-0.35829055309295654,
0.5583106875419617,
0.6588848233222961,
0.5647307634353638,
0.3827870190143585,
0.4883507788181305,
0.1920347362756729,
0.037166446447372437,
0.5768816471099854,
-0.5483161211013794,
0.38044655323028564,
-0.5296697020530701,
-0.6764930486679077,
-0.43796399235725403,
-0.04107551649212837,
0.34027233719825745,
0.4867822825908661,
-0.15046557784080505,
0.1445085108280182,
-0.04891541972756386,
0.7450087070465088,
-0.8537713885307312,
0.1514265537261963,
-0.8451738953590393,
-0.2884228527545929,
0.04143669456243515,
-0.17617526650428772,
-0.4307138919830322,
-0.33903610706329346,
0.36961740255355835,
-0.7694511413574219,
0.35744619369506836,
-0.023979688063263893,
0.9318562150001526,
0.5496987104415894,
-0.5819901823997498,
-0.4324689209461212,
-0.5815184116363525,
0.493708997964859,
-1.0012513399124146,
0.46535125374794006,
0.2291615605354309,
0.36642539501190186,
-0.22553898394107819,
-0.5773110389709473,
-0.6553655862808228,
-0.09283189475536346,
-0.08993612974882126,
0.4097347557544708,
0.29536741971969604,
0.3029147684574127,
0.12854577600955963,
0.18580034375190735,
-0.3211921751499176,
-0.1899113804101944,
-0.27430182695388794,
-0.2109403908252716,
0.515940248966217,
-0.14607200026512146,
0.04358578100800514,
-0.24701201915740967,
-0.3450518846511841,
-0.3548349440097809,
-0.8179584741592407,
0.2782551050186157,
0.24251636862754822,
0.1067110076546669,
0.35464879870414734,
0.7075567245483398,
-0.2517792582511902,
0.5062553882598877,
0.348639577627182,
-0.16154508292675018,
-0.028568683192133904,
-0.11985575407743454,
-0.1648765504360199,
0.16987650096416473,
0.46247613430023193,
0.33604198694229126,
-0.21245214343070984,
-0.35755470395088196,
-0.24819208681583405,
-0.2561858296394348,
0.36292287707328796,
-0.8866392374038696,
-0.16823694109916687,
0.3713570535182953,
-0.12467854470014572,
-0.12177138030529022,
0.01019330881536007,
-0.4761350154876709,
-0.43425309658050537,
-0.23482559621334076,
0.6924988031387329,
-0.5440487861633301,
0.025116296485066414,
0.14259374141693115,
-0.20374731719493866,
0.43539518117904663,
0.5347161293029785,
-0.5227178335189819,
0.1965876966714859,
0.551826536655426,
0.341839462518692,
-0.1245049461722374,
-0.011451508849859238,
-0.8354542851448059,
0.35944023728370667,
-0.36279430985450745,
0.9710814952850342,
-0.5422998070716858,
-0.26274192333221436,
-0.05621058866381645,
0.08624851703643799,
-0.08539298921823502,
-0.6288426518440247,
0.7298061847686768,
-1.1741061210632324,
0.5068219900131226,
-0.4374864101409912,
-0.900626003742218,
-0.1623750627040863,
0.5092825889587402,
-0.7023307085037231,
0.8616476058959961,
0.1370537281036377,
-0.6693686842918396,
0.4685000777244568,
-0.4939267337322235,
-0.24520979821681976,
0.050345174968242645,
-0.1907188445329666,
-0.3534137010574341,
0.18411417305469513,
0.2762031555175781,
0.15283390879631042,
-0.14448164403438568,
0.4125747084617615,
-0.17545169591903687,
-0.40233102440834045,
0.11355147510766983,
-0.22938528656959534,
0.20584920048713684,
0.05302244424819946,
0.025667399168014526,
0.008282236754894257,
-0.6909225583076477,
-0.1721477061510086,
0.07337847352027893,
-0.7371220588684082,
-0.3899330198764801,
0.27002957463264465,
-0.32871735095977783,
0.22177866101264954,
0.4770874083042145,
-0.762224555015564,
0.1246059238910675,
-0.6086235642433167,
0.038268618285655975,
0.6814723610877991,
0.2240632176399231,
0.5644418001174927,
-0.6425467729568481,
0.535046398639679,
0.25898003578186035,
0.0001115751510951668,
0.06292904168367386,
-0.13384874165058136,
-0.8225721716880798,
0.09491564333438873,
0.5041275024414062,
0.5338379740715027,
-1.1401804685592651,
-0.13503585755825043,
-0.49613210558891296,
-0.1515398770570755,
-0.9476078152656555,
0.2044975906610489,
0.3208066523075104,
0.5934054255485535,
0.46926525235176086,
-0.11530213057994843,
-0.6056637763977051,
-0.8510119915008545,
-0.3919472396373749,
-0.3419627547264099,
-0.11823272705078125,
0.6098392009735107,
0.18864649534225464,
-0.06867775321006775,
1.0447182655334473,
-0.32782548666000366,
-0.15186968445777893,
0.0987023189663887,
-0.06362242251634598,
0.21093200147151947,
0.312002032995224,
0.06988696753978729,
-0.745863139629364,
-0.2867162525653839,
-0.12306377291679382,
-0.5552771091461182,
0.051739323884248734,
-0.05488039180636406,
-0.20268669724464417,
0.30892419815063477,
0.48049798607826233,
-0.6018173694610596,
0.007353263441473246,
0.16214917600154877,
-0.06976239383220673,
0.40157991647720337,
-0.2269153743982315,
0.3584100902080536,
-1.1773936748504639,
-0.03171321004629135,
-0.20144818723201752,
-0.24535208940505981,
-0.3484589755535126,
0.06937587261199951,
0.17155511677265167,
0.135581836104393,
-0.25415873527526855,
0.6251826882362366,
-0.2563161849975586,
0.24952241778373718,
-0.3131301999092102,
0.5807945132255554,
0.2309987097978592,
0.31192412972450256,
0.04918188601732254,
1.1153960227966309,
-0.1283506602048874,
-0.46177107095718384,
0.30455923080444336,
0.45985788106918335,
-0.2407751828432083,
0.5981898903846741,
-0.7225526571273804,
0.15103478729724884,
-0.336978942155838,
-0.10256276279687881,
-1.0264276266098022,
-0.3345648944377899,
-0.043171536177396774,
-0.5087119936943054,
0.44259512424468994,
-0.5855029225349426,
-0.4374609887599945,
-0.110786072909832,
-0.33008360862731934,
0.3003769814968109,
0.44639959931373596,
-0.564683198928833,
0.7666184306144714,
0.2704370617866516,
-0.26009586453437805,
-0.6427093744277954,
-0.009715733118355274,
-0.06285736709833145,
0.06201380863785744,
-0.640878438949585,
0.46574801206588745,
-0.0547030009329319,
0.004778972361236811,
0.12619635462760925,
-0.5647770762443542,
-0.03593771159648895,
0.06215931102633476,
-0.07292104512453079,
0.34057846665382385,
-0.24995312094688416,
0.4662236273288727,
0.25575047731399536,
-0.005990280769765377,
0.2069154530763626,
-0.28609946370124817,
0.14570128917694092,
0.17724724113941193,
-0.5770501494407654,
0.11486414819955826,
0.06490195542573929,
0.6959653496742249,
-0.10928256064653397,
0.6655784845352173,
0.3139949142932892,
-0.17636004090309143,
-0.024407435208559036,
-0.8620708584785461,
-0.3170868158340454,
-0.40019726753234863,
0.23973122239112854,
-0.5213059782981873,
-1.101824164390564,
0.36580607295036316,
-0.4007188677787781,
0.19869662821292877,
0.31640419363975525,
0.07148867845535278,
-0.36410340666770935,
1.104143500328064,
0.3997064530849457,
0.0978965237736702,
0.29547515511512756,
-0.00474773533642292,
0.34439438581466675,
-1.0965237617492676,
-0.3897583782672882,
-0.20147590339183807,
-0.1937144696712494,
-0.525446891784668,
-0.511215329170227,
0.6488131284713745,
0.28768524527549744,
-0.3368159830570221,
-0.000060357422626111656,
-0.1764402836561203,
0.43756893277168274,
0.6787580847740173,
0.4401206076145172,
0.3032841980457306,
-0.16849420964717865,
-0.27381014823913574,
0.07014276087284088,
-0.841118335723877,
-0.5150346159934998,
1.1677066087722778,
0.02071351930499077,
0.7096970081329346,
0.1508534699678421,
0.6332368850708008,
0.20830047130584717,
0.11302259564399719,
-0.7282522320747375,
0.37923523783683777,
0.15383759140968323,
-0.5616976022720337,
-0.2975013256072998,
-0.34624743461608887,
-0.5996012091636658,
0.1950613260269165,
-0.20066513121128082,
-0.1549222618341446,
0.0988006666302681,
0.1355721801519394,
-0.3179466128349304,
0.1530509889125824,
-0.47667115926742554,
0.7657049894332886,
-0.08457506448030472,
-0.668663501739502,
-0.2991636395454407,
-0.6614960432052612,
0.35040491819381714,
0.0933007225394249,
-0.010485555045306683,
0.07106013596057892,
-0.14121778309345245,
0.7885974049568176,
-0.40644580125808716,
0.5820745825767517,
-0.3651997745037079,
-0.2577395737171173,
0.13486072421073914,
0.1904955357313156,
0.9329717755317688,
0.2341376543045044,
-0.1550954282283783,
-0.677267849445343,
0.17608396708965302,
-0.6810433864593506,
-0.8348680138587952,
0.6062765717506409,
-0.7365651726722717,
-0.9771513938903809,
-0.2936685383319855,
-0.6635473370552063,
-0.6422428488731384,
0.055023420602083206,
-0.000635878590401262,
0.25819846987724304,
-0.18785803020000458,
0.14303478598594666,
1.2266302108764648,
-0.05717150866985321,
-0.06484176963567734,
0.8122313022613525,
0.12666188180446625,
-0.659985363483429,
0.804739773273468,
0.052487559616565704,
0.15096396207809448,
0.5985405445098877,
0.0005940085393376648,
-0.4772239625453949,
-0.6803173422813416,
-0.4523560404777527,
0.39053139090538025,
-0.6881977319717407,
-0.39425382018089294,
-0.5614905953407288,
-0.4069896936416626,
-0.3234066963195801,
-0.05965249240398407,
-0.21065764129161835,
-0.45685508847236633,
-0.0839504674077034,
-0.2900262475013733,
0.3474968373775482,
0.5515742897987366,
0.054207175970077515,
0.20189225673675537,
-0.8132601380348206,
0.21867218613624573,
0.7018037438392639,
0.3795616626739502,
-0.16539373993873596,
-0.6810290217399597,
-0.33368924260139465,
0.2700513005256653,
-0.2771763503551483,
-0.7558882236480713,
-0.09284429252147675,
0.07833845168352127,
0.6598556637763977,
0.2859690189361572,
0.416583389043808,
0.5920630097389221,
-0.31095820665359497,
0.7521209120750427,
-0.19400468468666077,
-0.7413975596427917,
0.8228915333747864,
-0.22526755928993225,
0.15373681485652924,
0.8086989521980286,
0.3650049865245819,
-0.4637630879878998,
-0.3821799159049988,
-0.7019961476325989,
-0.9001168608665466,
0.608079195022583,
-0.10632085800170898,
-0.04373897984623909,
-0.18179558217525482,
0.5071210861206055,
0.06702952086925507,
0.40919002890586853,
-0.3904702663421631,
0.03604807332158089,
-0.06507665663957596,
-0.40886300802230835,
0.24955907464027405,
-0.6121189594268799,
-0.15526404976844788,
-0.061511654406785965,
1.2047932147979736,
-0.37738409638404846,
-0.057378653436899185,
0.48524990677833557,
-0.4612921178340912,
-0.009970512241125107,
0.4454805254936218,
0.40106216073036194,
0.6383717060089111,
-0.4471418559551239,
0.31910839676856995,
0.35148870944976807,
-0.2512667775154114,
0.1889321357011795,
0.14303326606750488,
-0.36079761385917664,
-0.17305314540863037,
0.19791847467422485,
0.6832190752029419,
0.25964081287384033,
-0.8400987982749939,
0.6960577368736267,
0.07327768206596375,
-0.23914863169193268,
-0.011879452504217625,
0.1691359132528305,
0.2058248668909073,
0.3433007597923279,
0.3181910216808319,
0.01791091449558735,
0.18151609599590302,
-0.13470809161663055,
0.16233336925506592,
0.5309478640556335,
-0.5814399123191833,
-0.05638320744037628,
0.592698335647583,
0.22370362281799316,
0.05604373663663864,
0.5481981635093689,
-0.20420603454113007,
-0.49211496114730835,
0.29302623867988586,
0.33762606978416443,
0.45654892921447754,
-0.1843252032995224,
0.22531549632549286,
0.338634729385376,
0.18909572064876556,
0.0013652064371854067,
0.322747141122818,
-0.274377703666687,
-0.7829380631446838,
-0.615419864654541,
-0.5389091968536377,
-0.6923403739929199,
0.04889446869492531,
-0.7465407848358154,
0.03628583997488022,
-0.20291925966739655,
0.19116224348545074,
-0.431908518075943,
0.2040913999080658,
-0.6086718440055847,
0.052634283900260925,
-0.1728208214044571,
1.048608422279358,
-0.6310674548149109,
0.6680899262428284,
0.9426711201667786,
-0.5860067009925842,
-0.7032767534255981,
0.008137108758091927,
-0.36582648754119873,
-0.7940399050712585,
0.5815241932868958,
-0.32582396268844604,
-0.17795689404010773,
0.14193016290664673,
-0.6939271688461304,
-0.7546394467353821,
1.2134371995925903,
0.3498457372188568,
-0.3544226586818695,
-0.20338988304138184,
0.05910386145114899,
0.260917991399765,
-0.07809845358133316,
0.4454437494277954,
0.49519434571266174,
0.3560961186885834,
0.44122549891471863,
-0.5845413208007812,
0.08128883689641953,
-0.2597280740737915,
0.07748576253652573,
0.16405527293682098,
-0.6292619109153748,
0.23575638234615326,
-0.29474955797195435,
-0.2111024558544159,
-0.11161977052688599,
0.6977671384811401,
0.5796616077423096,
0.2480422854423523,
0.3388039469718933,
0.7361204028129578,
0.9583318829536438,
0.05721521005034447,
0.5970597267150879,
-0.32774579524993896,
0.1425614356994629,
1.3401193618774414,
-0.435970276594162,
0.9533729553222656,
0.6887269616127014,
-0.24612653255462646,
0.6903653144836426,
0.5268847346305847,
0.27820125222206116,
0.6598458290100098,
0.01234872080385685,
-0.5575600862503052,
-0.6034294962882996,
-0.21180161833763123,
-0.17220549285411835,
0.24609796702861786,
0.21220041811466217,
-0.1202704980969429,
-0.3871002197265625,
-0.050498779863119125,
0.012140989303588867,
0.1244860589504242,
-0.05324530601501465,
1.1551005840301514,
-0.16468876600265503,
-0.8312972784042358,
0.500791609287262,
-0.20622791349887848,
0.42097213864326477,
-0.44941815733909607,
-0.20083405077457428,
-0.4042263925075531,
0.16463690996170044,
-0.06389706581830978,
-0.8322663307189941,
0.01683630421757698,
-0.2619505226612091,
-0.6513454914093018,
-0.009685240685939789,
0.8073608875274658,
-0.539110004901886,
-0.2715364396572113,
0.11383195221424103,
0.7378188967704773,
-0.14297102391719818,
-0.1520576775074005,
-0.3248244822025299,
-0.3354473412036896,
-0.02222605235874653,
-0.143016055226326,
0.3893575966358185,
0.6924348473548889,
0.21028612554073334,
0.6378653645515442,
0.7133744955062866,
0.11641848832368851,
0.04127096012234688,
-0.03319280594587326,
1.0612664222717285,
-0.41662102937698364,
-0.12513047456741333,
-0.5164082050323486,
0.431100457906723,
-0.37588804960250854,
0.18962471187114716,
0.6475947499275208,
0.77447509765625,
0.9310117363929749,
-0.02785206213593483,
0.8947134613990784,
0.14211063086986542,
0.6902646422386169,
-0.6122534871101379,
0.6181182265281677,
-0.42329514026641846,
0.47547078132629395,
0.1979827731847763,
-0.5529226064682007,
0.11501114070415497,
0.4005275368690491,
-0.38844969868659973,
-0.23616845905780792,
0.5587650537490845,
0.8266376852989197,
-0.19787228107452393,
-0.16049699485301971,
0.22093547880649567,
0.2901552617549896,
0.39292845129966736,
0.7917559742927551,
0.777260422706604,
-0.8344559669494629,
0.7113727331161499,
-0.05461929365992546,
-0.09333795309066772,
-0.25744882225990295,
-0.6756226420402527,
-0.7223230004310608,
-0.6275297403335571,
-0.364836186170578,
-0.44592350721359253,
0.38094988465309143,
0.9052891135215759,
0.5982723832130432,
-0.9581195712089539,
-0.011584552936255932,
-0.05568002909421921,
0.5006195902824402,
-0.026161378249526024,
-0.2209872305393219,
0.32935813069343567,
-0.795957088470459,
-0.4187502861022949,
0.5016536712646484,
0.0963682010769844,
0.03126726299524307,
0.1259855329990387,
-0.14738604426383972,
-0.23683662712574005,
0.3038941025733948,
0.5910035967826843,
0.07934828847646713,
-0.7265561819076538,
-0.33828943967819214,
0.19728991389274597,
-0.06177764758467674,
0.15285305678844452,
0.6306254863739014,
-1.1484533548355103,
0.5594502687454224,
0.6123234629631042,
0.9423091411590576,
0.5670387744903564,
0.17497804760932922,
0.6274851560592651,
-0.6475703716278076,
-0.46509674191474915,
0.2076806277036667,
0.29888105392456055,
0.256246954202652,
-0.3293723464012146,
0.3771074414253235,
0.17451481521129608,
-0.7024810910224915,
-0.6186201572418213,
0.21380512416362762,
-0.9389457106590271,
-0.3037397265434265,
0.9010168313980103,
-0.11025455594062805,
-0.33541932702064514,
-0.11270660161972046,
-0.3030162453651428,
0.3213382065296173,
-0.34177109599113464,
0.9441425800323486,
0.8293876051902771,
0.08910281211137772,
-0.3517809808254242,
-0.4034630060195923,
0.6056815981864929,
0.28112345933914185,
-0.6855401992797852,
0.03323135897517204,
0.5425344109535217,
0.5825177431106567,
0.10985089838504791,
0.5039607286453247,
-0.09103912115097046,
0.49358922243118286,
-0.3149307668209076,
0.11675792187452316,
-0.16472139954566956,
-0.12958508729934692,
0.02173912338912487,
0.29404985904693604,
0.5281020402908325,
-0.2139909416437149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12168v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12168v3 | Defending Against Weight-Poisoning Backdoor Attacks for Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning | 2024-02-19T14:22:54 | 2024-03-29T12:12:30 | Shuai Zhao, Leilei Gan, Luu Anh Tuan, Jie Fu, Lingjuan Lyu, Meihuizi Jia, Jinming Wen | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recently, various parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) strategies for
application to language models have been proposed and successfully implemented.
However, this raises the question of whether PEFT, which only updates a limited
set of model parameters, constitutes security vulnerabilities when confronted
with weight-poisoning backdoor attacks. In this study, we show that PEFT is
more susceptible to weight-poisoning backdoor attacks compared to the
full-parameter fine-tuning method, with pre-defined triggers remaining
exploitable and pre-defined targets maintaining high confidence, even after
fine-tuning. Motivated by this insight, we developed a Poisoned Sample
Identification Module (PSIM) leveraging PEFT, which identifies poisoned samples
through confidence, providing robust defense against weight-poisoning backdoor
attacks. Specifically, we leverage PEFT to train the PSIM with randomly reset
sample labels. During the inference process, extreme confidence serves as an
indicator for poisoned samples, while others are clean. We conduct experiments
on text classification tasks, five fine-tuning strategies, and three
weight-poisoning backdoor attack methods. Experiments show near 100% success
rates for weight-poisoning backdoor attacks when utilizing PEFT. Furthermore,
our defensive approach exhibits overall competitive performance in mitigating
weight-poisoning backdoor attacks. | [
0.018791936337947845,
-0.530786395072937,
0.4776209890842438,
-0.08812688291072845,
-0.06772751361131668,
-0.015338384546339512,
-0.21214605867862701,
-0.11932998895645142,
-0.5075517892837524,
0.6779251098632812,
-0.3066554069519043,
-0.6515101790428162,
-0.6031204462051392,
-0.08008132874965668,
-0.4856358468532562,
1.2949073314666748,
0.0898125171661377,
-0.11353729665279388,
0.32561033964157104,
0.13417497277259827,
-0.5014530420303345,
-0.7243362069129944,
-0.9483540654182434,
-0.19894656538963318,
0.790826678276062,
0.3330352306365967,
0.5921437740325928,
0.21094588935375214,
0.21808214485645294,
0.1961793750524521,
0.12603162229061127,
-0.1989286094903946,
-0.49505385756492615,
0.11826226860284805,
-0.5638348460197449,
-0.755818784236908,
-0.36859267950057983,
0.12409009039402008,
0.37412935495376587,
0.10760445147752762,
-0.17578409612178802,
0.16029322147369385,
0.16637656092643738,
0.7070479393005371,
-1.1383585929870605,
-0.29755231738090515,
-1.1015660762786865,
0.13328513503074646,
-0.3149462938308716,
-0.5473819375038147,
-0.8503614068031311,
0.14535394310951233,
-0.3179207742214203,
-0.24461029469966888,
0.0589321069419384,
0.24253694713115692,
0.9094036221504211,
0.21653445065021515,
-0.21535885334014893,
0.18369866907596588,
-0.44668805599212646,
0.7444480657577515,
-0.7734628915786743,
0.4453962445259094,
0.4487985074520111,
0.22229695320129395,
-0.3736213445663452,
-0.4055866599082947,
-0.17322580516338348,
-0.13042570650577545,
0.01200416311621666,
-0.0014423643006011844,
-0.25629520416259766,
0.20200641453266144,
0.2650059461593628,
0.09608989208936691,
-0.7338809370994568,
0.24245621263980865,
-0.1225196048617363,
-0.4657866358757019,
0.7599100470542908,
0.19212132692337036,
0.35953518748283386,
0.025780165567994118,
-0.3285401165485382,
-0.3346613347530365,
-0.8629074096679688,
-0.0790390893816948,
0.8961443305015564,
0.5027171969413757,
-0.017976945266127586,
0.3724362254142761,
-0.1324334591627121,
0.6344295144081116,
0.23444589972496033,
0.20861294865608215,
0.008690746501088142,
0.013879361562430859,
-0.3479929268360138,
0.24546363949775696,
0.7828835844993591,
0.4145401418209076,
0.4364519715309143,
-0.23623009026050568,
-0.36707940697669983,
-0.4090220034122467,
0.4326353967189789,
-1.0630899667739868,
-0.6120558977127075,
0.577008843421936,
-0.39045217633247375,
-0.634052038192749,
0.1079801395535469,
-0.829271674156189,
-0.33696290850639343,
0.6273306608200073,
1.1110365390777588,
-0.6814890503883362,
-0.17643891274929047,
0.16756601631641388,
-0.48507848381996155,
0.3306671380996704,
0.2543430030345917,
-1.030815601348877,
0.4118932783603668,
1.10006582736969,
0.7216591835021973,
-0.21367350220680237,
-0.3287287652492523,
-0.9737192392349243,
0.2575596570968628,
-0.38019123673439026,
0.5031358003616333,
-0.5171493291854858,
-0.22384919226169586,
-0.2415531426668167,
0.15854839980602264,
0.046123016625642776,
-0.5080344080924988,
0.44036927819252014,
-0.5529247522354126,
0.08532136678695679,
-0.2572381794452667,
-0.23856057226657867,
0.04434351623058319,
0.44213661551475525,
-0.41685739159584045,
0.8816499710083008,
-0.1701342761516571,
-1.0038248300552368,
0.3990548551082611,
0.13793306052684784,
-0.5451919436454773,
-0.00006310013850452378,
0.08109297603368759,
-0.599768340587616,
0.22874514758586884,
0.042745962738990784,
0.6016992330551147,
0.21449972689151764,
-0.26124608516693115,
-0.41204071044921875,
-0.47418755292892456,
0.0893913209438324,
-0.487406849861145,
0.6355026364326477,
0.27170899510383606,
-0.026796627789735794,
-0.002668000292032957,
-0.6938524842262268,
0.06362287700176239,
0.1477910578250885,
-0.4763142764568329,
-0.6578311324119568,
0.16078250110149384,
-0.08408822119235992,
-0.008891829289495945,
0.21050630509853363,
-0.7868871688842773,
0.051171090453863144,
-0.8147816061973572,
0.28495141863822937,
0.8361549973487854,
0.3072485029697418,
0.2666948437690735,
-0.4306817948818207,
0.2666216194629669,
0.003511368529871106,
0.28247374296188354,
-0.25170665979385376,
-0.45672324299812317,
-0.11306089162826538,
-0.2646137773990631,
0.42673736810684204,
0.7205495238304138,
-0.2704583704471588,
0.5801461338996887,
0.05384582281112671,
-0.7830276489257812,
0.006192311178892851,
0.061629053205251694,
0.5549204349517822,
0.5120954513549805,
0.3552817404270172,
0.0189377274364233,
-0.06397394090890884,
-0.6798200607299805,
-1.081681251525879,
-0.13476048409938812,
-0.4465694725513458,
0.28756454586982727,
0.6124792695045471,
0.14740683138370514,
0.5994871854782104,
-0.6257635951042175,
-0.19451181590557098,
0.12855808436870575,
-0.003163493936881423,
0.09599929302930832,
0.7655128240585327,
0.7016644477844238,
-0.6258947849273682,
-0.5258005857467651,
-0.1529553234577179,
-0.018117956817150116,
-0.25383269786834717,
-0.19247180223464966,
-0.14198291301727295,
-0.09270673990249634,
0.3443049192428589,
-0.21855710446834564,
0.244558647274971,
0.4638959765434265,
-0.3365633487701416,
0.4542330205440521,
-0.22739221155643463,
0.045403167605400085,
-0.9613538980484009,
-0.0663251206278801,
0.053502775728702545,
-0.12426074594259262,
-0.6028016805648804,
0.3883335590362549,
0.46132901310920715,
-0.40536609292030334,
-0.49425408244132996,
0.7093912959098816,
0.021968098357319832,
0.4467483162879944,
-0.06972559541463852,
-0.39967766404151917,
0.14993569254875183,
0.6183308362960815,
-0.28475499153137207,
0.596569836139679,
0.5920451283454895,
-0.32289960980415344,
0.15340614318847656,
-0.2761172652244568,
0.12966066598892212,
0.6517555117607117,
-0.5817911624908447,
0.19305802881717682,
0.22062474489212036,
0.17999431490898132,
-1.1811636686325073,
-0.1717442125082016,
0.5187220573425293,
-0.4569143056869507,
0.6406614780426025,
-0.5226836204528809,
-0.6362294554710388,
-0.025379464030265808,
-0.6435538530349731,
0.17545907199382782,
0.41523921489715576,
-0.49437838792800903,
0.7752655148506165,
-0.17673122882843018,
-0.048022352159023285,
-0.5357035994529724,
-0.779896080493927,
-0.08004293590784073,
-0.3782784044742584,
-0.35544106364250183,
0.3262294828891754,
-0.12502515316009521,
-0.07438310235738754,
-0.3847026228904724,
-0.545401394367218,
-0.02034919522702694,
0.5254360437393188,
0.2022092491388321,
-0.3000187277793884,
0.17810110747814178,
0.04134014993906021,
0.4565044045448303,
-0.10019475221633911,
0.08419081568717957,
-0.41391482949256897,
0.5752291083335876,
0.1309269815683365,
-0.4217127561569214,
-0.610460638999939,
0.4806581735610962,
0.4553777575492859,
-0.32213711738586426,
0.7688945531845093,
0.37234485149383545,
-0.5172455906867981,
-0.3636176288127899,
-0.4725774824619293,
-0.4814292788505554,
-0.5211893320083618,
0.43233180046081543,
-0.5781402587890625,
-0.37585246562957764,
0.4642806351184845,
-0.003097166772931814,
0.1713828444480896,
0.28015565872192383,
0.47172296047210693,
0.00845820177346468,
1.2733343839645386,
0.613282322883606,
-0.1295987218618393,
0.37969332933425903,
0.2526054084300995,
-0.2131374478340149,
-0.6490341424942017,
-0.08345042914152145,
-0.7421533465385437,
-0.39527735114097595,
-0.31731611490249634,
0.3287076950073242,
0.23220017552375793,
0.005886996630579233,
-0.5192089080810547,
0.31356608867645264,
-0.5362944602966309,
0.5259281396865845,
0.3742046356201172,
0.3321181535720825,
0.34947991371154785,
0.014731606468558311,
-0.3076077997684479,
0.07911284267902374,
-0.41469433903694153,
-0.23936931788921356,
1.3649606704711914,
0.3782981336116791,
1.2282546758651733,
-0.05765363946557045,
0.9360657930374146,
0.18471559882164001,
0.04240494221448898,
-0.6052860021591187,
0.41118019819259644,
-0.10725751519203186,
-0.7997450828552246,
-0.14224006235599518,
-0.4598008394241333,
-0.8390219211578369,
0.105523020029068,
-0.13848240673542023,
-0.9294209480285645,
0.16701149940490723,
0.42114537954330444,
-0.61859530210495,
0.4371490180492401,
-0.9289246201515198,
0.8396300673484802,
-0.35026007890701294,
-0.24548467993736267,
-0.23528076708316803,
-0.46910789608955383,
0.19202445447444916,
-0.6770790219306946,
-0.10826877504587173,
-0.14321687817573547,
-0.17705334722995758,
0.7788563370704651,
-0.6321524977684021,
0.7772064208984375,
-0.2464405596256256,
-0.5073682069778442,
-0.30453771352767944,
0.3514704704284668,
0.6133437752723694,
0.3930332064628601,
-0.3262466490268707,
0.3262133300304413,
0.4168150722980499,
-0.5274884104728699,
-0.4654035270214081,
0.5595653653144836,
-0.5245500802993774,
-0.8426912426948547,
-0.45144423842430115,
-0.23732095956802368,
-0.32954925298690796,
0.38251644372940063,
0.6890921592712402,
0.20001013576984406,
0.3179751932621002,
0.17841346561908722,
0.7862157821655273,
-0.6159483790397644,
0.3259284496307373,
0.74001145362854,
0.13926781713962555,
-0.2019302099943161,
0.8345611095428467,
0.1850433051586151,
0.5240240097045898,
0.7281039953231812,
0.616839587688446,
0.3589875400066376,
-0.6947904229164124,
-0.2110985368490219,
-0.013452399522066116,
-0.12608680129051208,
-0.5460984110832214,
-0.537756621837616,
-0.22587142884731293,
-0.35180041193962097,
-0.058188650757074356,
-0.5252160429954529,
0.030724305659532547,
0.014209113083779812,
0.13687847554683685,
0.6240432858467102,
0.029028186574578285,
0.0756751224398613,
0.49923163652420044,
-0.7328165173530579,
0.12207910418510437,
0.47396498918533325,
0.42776384949684143,
0.02950616553425789,
-0.587452232837677,
-0.21528252959251404,
-0.04726953059434891,
-0.2854330837726593,
-1.3407223224639893,
0.33396995067596436,
0.279815137386322,
0.35869723558425903,
0.4092603921890259,
0.39681804180145264,
0.3031262457370758,
-0.6846411824226379,
0.6818875074386597,
-0.1655554175376892,
-0.8992996215820312,
0.6528775095939636,
-0.3342898190021515,
0.24134944379329681,
0.5481359958648682,
0.2642589807510376,
-0.5409461855888367,
-0.6209913492202759,
-0.4117523431777954,
-0.8122411966323853,
0.4913868308067322,
-0.006022718735039234,
0.430281400680542,
0.26986581087112427,
0.5565497875213623,
0.19489166140556335,
0.3807562291622162,
-0.32512637972831726,
0.030574582517147064,
-0.1539228856563568,
-0.2034667432308197,
0.16483701765537262,
-0.2215126007795334,
-0.21563906967639923,
-0.19148994982242584,
0.6124788522720337,
-0.038274407386779785,
-0.19583450257778168,
0.05995313823223114,
-0.021210718899965286,
-0.3299875855445862,
0.3465041220188141,
0.22990338504314423,
0.21740037202835083,
-0.29111772775650024,
0.3280949294567108,
0.388051301240921,
-0.7419348359107971,
0.04261140525341034,
0.2662822902202606,
-0.08896679431200027,
-0.4820592403411865,
0.26335975527763367,
0.1769724041223526,
0.23655177652835846,
-0.7635936141014099,
0.6064584255218506,
-0.16570188105106354,
-0.14524583518505096,
0.007367840502411127,
0.5443302392959595,
-0.28759729862213135,
0.1521240770816803,
0.7811365723609924,
-0.0319676399230957,
-0.03621833398938179,
-0.5735684037208557,
0.2472306489944458,
0.7431077361106873,
-0.3094588816165924,
-0.2907651364803314,
0.5535803437232971,
0.034856799989938736,
-0.4368830621242523,
0.27830758690834045,
0.15720321238040924,
-0.570597231388092,
0.41162851452827454,
0.35906848311424255,
0.7409622669219971,
-0.5503147840499878,
-0.3066781759262085,
-0.07599139958620071,
0.644791305065155,
0.055971600115299225,
0.39989760518074036,
-0.2067718505859375,
-0.7457805275917053,
0.03136379271745682,
-0.7845335006713867,
-0.27771759033203125,
0.30308544635772705,
-0.5160195827484131,
0.2397676706314087,
-0.9564836025238037,
0.055101435631513596,
-0.13246510922908783,
0.08714780956506729,
-0.07944844663143158,
0.17912153899669647,
0.07957664877176285,
1.105143427848816,
-1.0559488534927368,
0.751937747001648,
0.352690190076828,
-0.14975537359714508,
-1.030113697052002,
0.5164629817008972,
0.11717653274536133,
-0.569542646408081,
0.3387117087841034,
0.01619018241763115,
-0.0012510862434282899,
0.16185471415519714,
-0.7531349658966064,
-0.6606553196907043,
0.6027827262878418,
0.4578850567340851,
-0.46888938546180725,
-0.07548292726278305,
-0.3278125524520874,
0.3048783242702484,
0.3692333698272705,
-0.35057181119918823,
0.4570913016796112,
0.5902144312858582,
-0.2199743688106537,
-0.772731363773346,
0.3374651372432709,
-0.14244210720062256,
-0.3616732060909271,
0.38530433177948,
-0.7892200350761414,
0.8906066417694092,
0.1403965801000595,
-0.1820298433303833,
0.1909990906715393,
0.34208226203918457,
0.3462439179420471,
0.20148660242557526,
0.5407736301422119,
0.7906715869903564,
0.5300959944725037,
-0.10087356716394424,
0.6364240646362305,
-0.29482170939445496,
0.11747706681489944,
1.1504815816879272,
-0.4461766481399536,
1.0537351369857788,
0.29603055119514465,
0.12526781857013702,
0.38904938101768494,
0.5650202631950378,
-0.6225683689117432,
0.5673776865005493,
0.20439493656158447,
0.027534078806638718,
-0.25023093819618225,
0.4579985439777374,
-0.44972068071365356,
0.42399299144744873,
0.40349388122558594,
-0.47302788496017456,
-0.34770333766937256,
0.26985931396484375,
0.4642282724380493,
0.03424825519323349,
-0.5425088405609131,
0.6361678242683411,
0.13639451563358307,
-0.49256187677383423,
0.5418189167976379,
0.24369929730892181,
0.7769208550453186,
-0.6794220209121704,
0.20844389498233795,
0.044190414249897,
0.3087565004825592,
-0.4157152473926544,
-0.715901255607605,
0.18466371297836304,
0.033176861703395844,
0.12167452275753021,
-0.18246148526668549,
0.9005886912345886,
-0.19932742416858673,
-0.06836697459220886,
0.11901971697807312,
-0.09862266480922699,
-0.11888743191957474,
-0.7692606449127197,
-0.6315522789955139,
0.0393475741147995,
-0.4395127296447754,
-0.45421645045280457,
0.5477038621902466,
0.2928737699985504,
0.10616108030080795,
0.4945595860481262,
0.6069943308830261,
0.4253854751586914,
-0.08863747119903564,
-0.21353808045387268,
0.7028183937072754,
-0.35373955965042114,
-0.639694094657898,
-1.1993814706802368,
0.18726877868175507,
-0.07114044576883316,
-0.048052266240119934,
1.032782793045044,
0.6652691960334778,
0.8774237632751465,
0.1173306405544281,
0.5356931090354919,
0.283137708902359,
0.23838621377944946,
-0.5233938097953796,
1.3022431135177612,
-0.7373313903808594,
0.1193842887878418,
-0.535392165184021,
-0.4112434685230255,
-0.25667113065719604,
0.09677887707948685,
-0.3880419433116913,
0.13341151177883148,
0.5550072193145752,
0.9208781719207764,
0.006272752769291401,
-0.23786556720733643,
0.24702128767967224,
0.4173664450645447,
0.3071434795856476,
0.6828820109367371,
0.4145680069923401,
-0.3936953544616699,
0.7842779755592346,
-0.19809161126613617,
-0.355632483959198,
-0.2559637427330017,
-0.8986364603042603,
-1.045669436454773,
-0.33677589893341064,
-0.20062069594860077,
-0.5791352391242981,
0.3630369007587433,
0.508730411529541,
0.8996025919914246,
-0.9023512601852417,
0.28711119294166565,
0.09463677555322647,
0.11355660110712051,
-0.4758712649345398,
-0.21800197660923004,
0.08093587309122086,
-0.15273071825504303,
-0.48104244470596313,
0.2242869734764099,
0.48182806372642517,
-0.20407326519489288,
-0.2538168132305145,
0.21952089667320251,
0.05658053234219551,
0.4112907350063324,
0.09748481959104538,
0.5686401724815369,
-0.4064086377620697,
-0.6177130937576294,
-0.4188254177570343,
-0.16864360868930817,
-0.19072622060775757,
0.5565577149391174,
-0.7341022491455078,
0.2108050435781479,
0.6771568059921265,
0.6547525525093079,
0.16974101960659027,
-0.017796112224459648,
0.7806681394577026,
-1.174302339553833,
0.16961930692195892,
0.26217901706695557,
0.2661099433898926,
0.064476378262043,
-0.8423797488212585,
-0.02629110775887966,
0.1834215223789215,
-0.32772576808929443,
-1.0837931632995605,
0.39920592308044434,
-0.7004048824310303,
-0.6920313835144043,
0.9691306352615356,
-0.044017594307661057,
-0.4807020425796509,
0.0008221542811952531,
-0.13899226486682892,
0.104532390832901,
-0.43431809544563293,
0.8289027214050293,
0.641832172870636,
0.24582043290138245,
-0.06833542138338089,
-0.18189220130443573,
0.6422050595283508,
0.38162949681282043,
-0.6407750248908997,
0.17112299799919128,
-0.0761919915676117,
0.7150409817695618,
0.05275942385196686,
0.04550333693623543,
-0.24478471279144287,
0.3028147220611572,
-0.20870286226272583,
-0.4213966727256775,
0.02700594812631607,
-0.4193669557571411,
-0.459637314081192,
0.48869484663009644,
-0.06461795419454575,
-0.08174449950456619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12151v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12151v2 | Transformer-based Causal Language Models Perform Clustering | 2024-02-19T14:02:31 | 2024-03-03T20:06:24 | Xinbo Wu, Lav R. Varshney | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Even though large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
capability in solving various natural language tasks, the capability of an LLM
to follow human instructions is still a concern. Recent works have shown great
improvements in the instruction-following capability via additional training
for instruction-following tasks. However, the mechanisms responsible for
effective instruction-following capabilities remain inadequately understood.
Here, we introduce a simplified instruction-following task and use synthetic
datasets to analyze a Transformer-based causal language model. Our findings
suggest that the model learns task-specific information by clustering data
within its hidden space, with this clustering process evolving dynamically
during learning. We also demonstrate how this phenomenon assists the model in
handling unseen instances, and validate our results in a more realistic
setting. Furthermore, we present inspired applications regarding pre-training
and alignment. | [
0.0858931690454483,
-0.7549160122871399,
0.7299786806106567,
0.10514796525239944,
0.060071006417274475,
0.07794796675443649,
-0.23270493745803833,
-0.1676476150751114,
-0.05722036585211754,
0.5699380040168762,
-0.8996054530143738,
-0.5035896897315979,
-0.8082481026649475,
-0.01907828077673912,
-0.7441580891609192,
0.9699965119361877,
0.12296318262815475,
-0.2402563840150833,
-0.25675952434539795,
0.12182261049747467,
-0.9617201089859009,
-0.22069843113422394,
-0.45349159836769104,
-0.3574804961681366,
0.8244078159332275,
0.5455580353736877,
0.5569048523902893,
1.0195387601852417,
0.5454233884811401,
0.2988463044166565,
0.1862894743680954,
-0.09283827990293503,
-0.6745866537094116,
0.04749568551778793,
-0.04404161125421524,
-0.8792272806167603,
-0.0702442079782486,
-0.13302354514598846,
1.014850378036499,
1.053978443145752,
-0.1589861363172531,
-0.016691824421286583,
0.17275694012641907,
0.3944275975227356,
-0.3180137872695923,
0.4682338237762451,
-0.6204126477241516,
-0.108423613011837,
0.037948090583086014,
0.006062871310859919,
-0.7402430772781372,
-0.3299166262149811,
0.28985410928726196,
-0.5903099179267883,
0.6384866833686829,
0.12811514735221863,
0.5169287323951721,
0.5030943155288696,
-0.42618024349212646,
-0.3379260003566742,
-0.987140953540802,
0.6991848349571228,
-0.5451546907424927,
0.5146791338920593,
0.33628296852111816,
0.4894700050354004,
-0.23948927223682404,
-0.7986794710159302,
-0.6090640425682068,
-0.2075955718755722,
-0.5913703441619873,
0.0005711389239877462,
-0.3453255891799927,
-0.2832328975200653,
0.24041341245174408,
-0.1512451022863388,
-0.48889434337615967,
0.3761535584926605,
-0.5158082842826843,
0.3236047029495239,
0.19747333228588104,
0.2830337882041931,
0.40317854285240173,
0.04328714683651924,
-0.22244793176651,
-0.31599918007850647,
-0.9337384700775146,
0.07755814492702484,
0.11189877241849899,
0.4779856503009796,
-0.30637845396995544,
0.4733121991157532,
0.0436396524310112,
0.7604150772094727,
0.2670065462589264,
0.09746719896793365,
0.03760860115289688,
0.004519099369645119,
-0.14926832914352417,
0.10180382430553436,
0.378580242395401,
-0.16730333864688873,
-0.060025494545698166,
-0.46845826506614685,
0.054700177162885666,
0.1762726604938507,
0.7258508205413818,
-0.550273597240448,
-0.29377514123916626,
-0.192262664437294,
-0.280438631772995,
-0.33388766646385193,
0.3094247281551361,
-0.4528528153896332,
-0.2248479723930359,
-0.592485249042511,
0.38470518589019775,
-0.3972203731536865,
0.05607312172651291,
-0.10891103744506836,
0.148911252617836,
0.3437367081642151,
0.1097138524055481,
-0.9296945929527283,
0.5084689855575562,
0.8520151972770691,
0.44320249557495117,
-0.5803937315940857,
-0.4435249865055084,
-0.5526469945907593,
0.38945963978767395,
-0.36227887868881226,
0.8695338368415833,
-0.9420125484466553,
-0.3727823793888092,
0.0024062928277999163,
0.591905415058136,
-0.5062811970710754,
-0.4986325800418854,
0.3596281111240387,
-0.6190715432167053,
0.2502672076225281,
-0.3238285183906555,
-0.6443633437156677,
-0.38529664278030396,
-0.20322422683238983,
-0.7512645125389099,
0.887141764163971,
-0.07972803711891174,
-0.5865218639373779,
0.353281706571579,
-0.3842763304710388,
-0.565472424030304,
0.011219561100006104,
-0.3167109787464142,
-0.46022576093673706,
0.415313720703125,
0.01970915123820305,
0.49773529171943665,
-0.17035937309265137,
0.5362327694892883,
-0.10005243867635727,
-0.5883704423904419,
0.10531216859817505,
-0.4954853057861328,
0.47431090474128723,
-0.45586371421813965,
-0.7155195474624634,
0.3367060124874115,
-0.9357346296310425,
-0.5337408781051636,
0.08592426776885986,
-0.048588573932647705,
-0.45464712381362915,
0.47434771060943604,
-0.5566558241844177,
0.07081523537635803,
0.0026412757579237223,
-0.36911916732788086,
0.17717859148979187,
-0.08977984637022018,
-0.030416909605264664,
0.8184393644332886,
0.003467814065515995,
0.5668001770973206,
-0.05801193416118622,
0.5048888921737671,
0.0038569066673517227,
0.034581735730171204,
-0.3754067122936249,
-0.4232426881790161,
-1.0686925649642944,
0.100998155772686,
-0.1846417337656021,
0.663657546043396,
-0.6334161758422852,
0.5169206261634827,
-0.3899705111980438,
-0.6487552523612976,
-0.2828562557697296,
-0.06422947347164154,
0.2861911356449127,
0.7761825919151306,
0.5658895969390869,
0.19716869294643402,
-0.3030749261379242,
-0.8811777830123901,
-0.1290961354970932,
0.06559579074382782,
0.016794946044683456,
0.17249208688735962,
0.22565175592899323,
-0.5554761290550232,
0.8584821224212646,
-0.8928039073944092,
-0.09202080219984055,
-0.3074280321598053,
0.12472837418317795,
0.37237221002578735,
0.5716791152954102,
0.2646254897117615,
-0.6378240585327148,
-0.4304180145263672,
0.12572352588176727,
-0.8048098087310791,
-0.32562315464019775,
-0.3231038749217987,
-0.1850944608449936,
-0.05601166933774948,
0.9835308194160461,
-0.47134074568748474,
0.5519813895225525,
0.5834527611732483,
-0.33498215675354004,
0.5163969397544861,
-0.22182628512382507,
-0.05709110200405121,
-0.9114206433296204,
0.05388585478067398,
0.0017731423722580075,
0.0016148294089362025,
-0.912973165512085,
-0.03965311869978905,
0.13712142407894135,
-0.03913063183426857,
-0.20801828801631927,
0.42744967341423035,
-0.5275518894195557,
-0.010372988879680634,
-0.6451318860054016,
-0.08841036260128021,
-0.3847114145755768,
0.670978844165802,
0.34437766671180725,
0.5893878936767578,
0.7908414006233215,
-0.6074910163879395,
0.025083810091018677,
0.2020336389541626,
0.05084715411067009,
0.3281596302986145,
-0.7023453116416931,
0.031255241483449936,
-0.3584023118019104,
0.04030710458755493,
-0.9610713720321655,
-0.1847236007452011,
-0.03927288204431534,
0.03617836907505989,
0.5380988121032715,
-0.012609078548848629,
-0.5721007585525513,
-0.48069140315055847,
0.23070919513702393,
0.27309077978134155,
0.7181949615478516,
-0.5947993993759155,
0.7348909974098206,
0.17478519678115845,
-0.1534595787525177,
-0.30158641934394836,
-0.4443100690841675,
-0.2688223421573639,
-0.3035019338130951,
-0.17459741234779358,
0.31021392345428467,
0.16359961032867432,
0.05655691772699356,
0.1612405925989151,
-0.21585392951965332,
-0.009407352656126022,
-0.057945579290390015,
0.5809531211853027,
0.38263562321662903,
-0.07943087071180344,
0.229944109916687,
0.2452314794063568,
-0.297556072473526,
0.1437433958053589,
-0.3131435811519623,
0.3588520288467407,
0.024394702166318893,
-0.5461606383323669,
-0.5362861752510071,
0.2752985656261444,
0.2282429337501526,
-0.01227292139083147,
1.043437123298645,
0.5681468844413757,
-0.29620954394340515,
-0.4120009243488312,
-0.45189863443374634,
-0.6009331941604614,
-0.5389511585235596,
0.3755337595939636,
-0.009437713772058487,
-1.2375307083129883,
0.4512121379375458,
-0.05372758209705353,
0.1632431149482727,
0.420187771320343,
0.3478085994720459,
-0.2969381511211395,
0.8355307579040527,
1.0836420059204102,
-0.047913625836372375,
0.5792329907417297,
0.08591127395629883,
0.35260307788848877,
-0.5548914074897766,
-0.3496372401714325,
-0.48827117681503296,
-0.2679721713066101,
-0.8161060214042664,
-0.6339911222457886,
0.4998247027397156,
0.08093610405921936,
-0.16665028035640717,
0.8022558689117432,
-0.30142366886138916,
0.42413392663002014,
0.6991257667541504,
0.20581290125846863,
0.13787192106246948,
-0.013568015769124031,
-0.011394000612199306,
0.07845741510391235,
-0.9911704659461975,
-0.2935366630554199,
0.6436155438423157,
0.18163956701755524,
0.9307350516319275,
-0.1130317747592926,
0.4787728786468506,
0.20928694307804108,
0.6651222109794617,
-0.36995410919189453,
0.6042026281356812,
-0.3449094891548157,
-0.1331155002117157,
-0.3088543117046356,
-0.49300017952919006,
-1.2662220001220703,
0.15245585143566132,
-0.20393049716949463,
-0.7783750295639038,
-0.04496598243713379,
0.20574045181274414,
0.01762535609304905,
0.2223053127527237,
-0.7268585562705994,
0.8035001754760742,
0.04898649826645851,
-0.2365494966506958,
-0.37654024362564087,
-0.7777925133705139,
0.09933483600616455,
-0.35482361912727356,
0.21235816180706024,
0.25383874773979187,
0.2802354693412781,
0.6412637233734131,
-0.18246382474899292,
1.4234333038330078,
-0.04142085090279579,
-0.11292263865470886,
0.39510488510131836,
0.11229240149259567,
0.6487147212028503,
-0.41730523109436035,
0.3300599455833435,
-0.10379243642091751,
-0.5004845261573792,
-0.3124946653842926,
-0.9050571918487549,
0.7281249761581421,
-0.4917922616004944,
-0.9789471626281738,
-0.026582859456539154,
-0.5915700197219849,
-0.27773135900497437,
0.3817059099674225,
0.044289566576480865,
0.3956095576286316,
-0.09654413163661957,
0.2413422167301178,
0.6895632743835449,
-0.34107476472854614,
0.5747679471969604,
0.6996990442276001,
0.04372792690992355,
0.1614769548177719,
0.8228096961975098,
-0.022829683497548103,
0.19725589454174042,
0.7128890156745911,
0.3348231315612793,
-0.23365920782089233,
-0.17539067566394806,
-0.1421336531639099,
0.5403532385826111,
-0.5309113264083862,
-0.025768762454390526,
-0.649554967880249,
-0.06590214371681213,
-0.2800609767436981,
-0.32937055826187134,
-0.14956295490264893,
-0.13282015919685364,
-0.4455440044403076,
-0.40895867347717285,
0.08739754557609558,
0.9878988265991211,
0.329448938369751,
0.6606550812721252,
-1.0010803937911987,
0.061996039003133774,
0.4864236116409302,
0.3716718554496765,
0.34744614362716675,
-0.5235168933868408,
-0.30893996357917786,
-0.22495901584625244,
-0.1443607658147812,
-0.8895230889320374,
0.21936024725437164,
0.008963960222899914,
0.7491159439086914,
0.36958497762680054,
-0.2871432900428772,
0.6137151718139648,
-1.0346819162368774,
0.49743589758872986,
0.023380622267723083,
-0.725653350353241,
0.5936339497566223,
-0.41224998235702515,
0.567419707775116,
0.2439199686050415,
0.5202034711837769,
-0.45032998919487,
-0.5816470980644226,
-0.5620363354682922,
-0.44313710927963257,
0.7666980028152466,
0.1952618956565857,
0.1430986225605011,
-0.1620635837316513,
0.42997366189956665,
0.14947839081287384,
0.11771445721387863,
-0.7674880623817444,
-0.20677924156188965,
0.20018529891967773,
-0.21308284997940063,
-0.21331176161766052,
-0.038933828473091125,
0.14574779570102692,
-0.24366292357444763,
0.5745381116867065,
-0.10327840596437454,
0.32114559412002563,
-0.23795731365680695,
-0.10238096117973328,
-0.028737006708979607,
-0.02364790439605713,
0.5340266227722168,
0.3273046016693115,
0.2952076196670532,
0.20716258883476257,
0.16387854516506195,
-0.4213489592075348,
0.07443563640117645,
0.15793508291244507,
-0.2639766335487366,
-0.1747237592935562,
0.7255303263664246,
0.9937286972999573,
0.7018665671348572,
-0.6617807149887085,
0.37944114208221436,
0.11776239424943924,
0.19082173705101013,
-0.2578904628753662,
0.42106208205223083,
0.2222091108560562,
0.4019933342933655,
0.5074449181556702,
0.018987318500876427,
0.010019474662840366,
-0.41503041982650757,
0.47181904315948486,
0.22509333491325378,
-0.7109960913658142,
-0.6978167295455933,
0.6640335917472839,
-0.17316637933254242,
-0.2767449617385864,
0.5646363496780396,
0.11641150712966919,
-0.46737906336784363,
0.6488670706748962,
0.8504434823989868,
0.6837968826293945,
-0.5703624486923218,
0.2186068594455719,
0.14411702752113342,
0.407423734664917,
-0.21923837065696716,
-0.16822662949562073,
-0.10158809274435043,
-0.5516376495361328,
-0.4816010296344757,
-0.4450228810310364,
-0.08305945247411728,
-0.3300289511680603,
-0.7520673274993896,
0.26950374245643616,
0.011613426730036736,
0.2012757956981659,
-0.18717746436595917,
-0.5577830076217651,
-0.818267822265625,
0.21999862790107727,
-0.08827561885118484,
0.5659763813018799,
-1.0274730920791626,
0.9335422515869141,
0.4146338105201721,
-0.01992957852780819,
-1.0217249393463135,
0.1441388875246048,
-0.0787937194108963,
-0.8283425569534302,
0.6222442388534546,
0.3978121280670166,
-0.09106458723545074,
0.14051952958106995,
-0.43282175064086914,
-0.9926535487174988,
1.0756837129592896,
0.19778011739253998,
-0.6894734501838684,
-0.21748962998390198,
0.24786385893821716,
0.7404559850692749,
-0.37570375204086304,
-0.14068418741226196,
0.642448902130127,
0.17123614251613617,
0.08846902847290039,
-0.3611806333065033,
0.14987634122371674,
-0.012197080999612808,
-0.22742289304733276,
0.3052155375480652,
-0.4068681597709656,
0.5768134593963623,
-0.15189489722251892,
-0.3328007757663727,
-0.25208941102027893,
0.6911201477050781,
0.02389737404882908,
0.04652725160121918,
0.42573657631874084,
0.5146191716194153,
0.6404052376747131,
0.07500872015953064,
1.138798713684082,
-0.09707672894001007,
0.18919917941093445,
1.37089204788208,
-0.2561124265193939,
0.8204418420791626,
0.30205804109573364,
-0.004189683124423027,
1.0088796615600586,
0.06710494309663773,
-0.1506059616804123,
0.6296685934066772,
0.05744186416268349,
-0.11917299777269363,
-0.0154721075668931,
0.09424683451652527,
0.12566913664340973,
0.3047195374965668,
0.3590873181819916,
-0.46284669637680054,
-0.2726055681705475,
-0.02965681627392769,
-0.07740699499845505,
0.026219315826892853,
-0.2835903763771057,
0.8037713170051575,
0.024983972311019897,
-0.7984681725502014,
0.19079285860061646,
-0.20641638338565826,
0.25426164269447327,
-0.5266209244728088,
-0.3140001595020294,
-0.09043635427951813,
-0.02653910219669342,
-0.06530505418777466,
-0.5503510236740112,
0.4703376293182373,
0.013039801269769669,
-0.33731380105018616,
-0.17050360143184662,
0.6842203140258789,
-0.4913012683391571,
-0.8020754456520081,
0.36983874440193176,
0.573460042476654,
-0.15457461774349213,
0.23112665116786957,
-0.21789433062076569,
-0.029390640556812286,
-0.04706953465938568,
-0.15688566863536835,
0.3016350567340851,
0.3264895975589752,
-0.4704959988594055,
0.6663745045661926,
0.6248251795768738,
-0.14211846888065338,
0.38647255301475525,
0.31685805320739746,
0.7915535569190979,
-0.6345672011375427,
-0.6796262264251709,
-0.8603255748748779,
0.389656662940979,
0.08282164484262466,
0.20969918370246887,
0.7977492213249207,
0.29157376289367676,
0.751972496509552,
-0.23582758009433746,
0.5181589126586914,
0.17038394510746002,
0.622890055179596,
-0.46886447072029114,
0.5251600742340088,
-0.1337757259607315,
0.3208202123641968,
-0.2949941158294678,
-1.0506993532180786,
-0.4751964211463928,
0.4277079999446869,
-0.5012564659118652,
-0.12346898764371872,
0.844708263874054,
0.6981695294380188,
-0.22454172372817993,
0.21082250773906708,
0.24963484704494476,
0.3516596257686615,
0.3671249747276306,
0.29466700553894043,
0.6337481141090393,
-0.0456557497382164,
0.23173478245735168,
0.014770236797630787,
-0.39411571621894836,
0.1513018012046814,
-0.7861320376396179,
-1.1021023988723755,
-0.7368623614311218,
-0.07334289699792862,
0.032718926668167114,
-0.11633516848087311,
0.6515509486198425,
0.7519985437393188,
-0.8213542103767395,
-0.24506907165050507,
-0.6302395462989807,
0.02455694042146206,
-0.43016135692596436,
-0.24951335787773132,
0.5644019246101379,
-0.43064314126968384,
-0.49301278591156006,
0.5606266856193542,
0.15613485872745514,
0.09805907309055328,
-0.05730891227722168,
0.2900172770023346,
0.01988978683948517,
0.0718262568116188,
0.656065821647644,
0.16016420722007751,
-0.5743238925933838,
-0.5149300694465637,
0.3245687782764435,
0.07010220736265182,
-0.07591164112091064,
1.1261862516403198,
-0.8913714289665222,
0.23124796152114868,
0.12936794757843018,
0.8609343767166138,
0.5936621427536011,
0.032778169959783554,
0.5979127287864685,
-0.7337449789047241,
-0.00431481096893549,
-0.006825055927038193,
0.21977095305919647,
0.1666327267885208,
-0.4716348350048065,
0.28932705521583557,
0.29135623574256897,
-0.38695695996284485,
-0.5468035340309143,
0.15439210832118988,
-0.8123905062675476,
-0.29155826568603516,
0.8878151178359985,
-0.08992160111665726,
-0.18209417164325714,
0.1851484328508377,
0.07618042826652527,
0.4407612383365631,
-0.12563693523406982,
0.9340546131134033,
0.42063403129577637,
-0.3593769371509552,
-0.3576667606830597,
-0.3556655943393707,
0.265752375125885,
0.30612194538116455,
-1.0587215423583984,
0.10508575290441513,
0.42195427417755127,
0.2151171863079071,
0.13312473893165588,
0.23611469566822052,
0.02844334952533245,
0.03722861409187317,
-0.15131983160972595,
-0.3408704102039337,
0.24929307401180267,
-0.771489679813385,
-0.3968409299850464,
0.2237362116575241,
-0.3674176037311554,
0.05821941792964935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12150v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12150v1 | Your Large Language Model is Secretly a Fairness Proponent and You Should Prompt it Like One | 2024-02-19T14:02:22 | 2024-02-19T14:02:22 | Tianlin Li, Xiaoyu Zhang, Chao Du, Tianyu Pang, Qian Liu, Qing Guo, Chao Shen, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2; J.4 | The widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) underscores the
urgent need to ensure their fairness. However, LLMs frequently present dominant
viewpoints while ignoring alternative perspectives from minority parties,
resulting in potential biases. We hypothesize that these fairness-violating
behaviors occur because LLMs express their viewpoints using a human personality
that represents the majority of training data. In response to this, we validate
that prompting LLMs with specific roles can allow LLMs to express diverse
viewpoints. Building on this insight and observation, we develop FairThinking,
a pipeline designed to automatically generate roles that enable LLMs to
articulate diverse perspectives for fair expressions. To evaluate FairThinking,
we create a dataset with a thousand items covering three fairness-related
topics and conduct experiments on GPT-3.5, GPT-4, Llama2, and Mistral to
demonstrate its superior performance. | [
-0.422941118478775,
-0.3128319978713989,
0.8552660942077637,
0.23928368091583252,
-0.1378282755613327,
-0.12128326296806335,
-0.11679114401340485,
-0.2656536400318146,
-0.13646066188812256,
0.5153009295463562,
-0.4452337622642517,
-0.07988578826189041,
-0.8322691917419434,
0.046041570603847504,
-0.35314157605171204,
1.2097655534744263,
0.2511514723300934,
0.43779370188713074,
-0.007412523962557316,
-0.12120615690946579,
-0.6714483499526978,
-0.4569781720638275,
-0.7859668135643005,
-0.685774028301239,
0.7909029126167297,
0.4080978035926819,
0.726486086845398,
0.6404474377632141,
0.13527974486351013,
0.2880842387676239,
-0.13923722505569458,
-0.30151617527008057,
-0.4878217875957489,
0.11949004977941513,
-0.40815243124961853,
-0.9518771767616272,
-0.48040971159935,
0.3399892747402191,
0.7252551913261414,
0.8663303256034851,
-0.3692154288291931,
0.19316346943378448,
0.10912922769784927,
0.6764654517173767,
-0.5915605425834656,
0.036880794912576675,
-0.9756909608840942,
0.40826964378356934,
-0.5010113716125488,
0.12688468396663666,
-0.34496185183525085,
-0.4566391110420227,
0.05595555528998375,
-0.23105908930301666,
0.2757677733898163,
0.009970176964998245,
0.5474459528923035,
0.09156032651662827,
-0.49099791049957275,
0.038692813366651535,
-0.3156490921974182,
0.921889066696167,
-0.7823406457901001,
0.2275048941373825,
0.26817119121551514,
0.5070714950561523,
-0.14499743282794952,
-0.4172604978084564,
-0.9577195048332214,
0.021983010694384575,
0.014842885546386242,
-0.07865381985902786,
0.012297998182475567,
0.13770611584186554,
0.5452594757080078,
0.405368834733963,
-0.4850037693977356,
0.46150943636894226,
-0.21536047756671906,
-0.26370617747306824,
0.4969342052936554,
0.2234472781419754,
-0.037077754735946655,
-0.30291593074798584,
-0.08607039600610733,
0.1026374101638794,
-0.7533389925956726,
0.31174468994140625,
0.7750684022903442,
0.274278849363327,
-0.13986371457576752,
0.6141524910926819,
-0.15293988585472107,
0.5178812146186829,
0.1926620453596115,
0.1855918914079666,
0.19630630314350128,
0.26650089025497437,
-0.4376298189163208,
0.11855640262365341,
0.5545676946640015,
0.6567258238792419,
0.4634232521057129,
-0.11420458555221558,
-0.3847840428352356,
0.12826333940029144,
0.1926070600748062,
-0.7464846968650818,
0.0873870700597763,
0.2627299726009369,
-0.668601393699646,
-0.5149155259132385,
-0.03842932730913162,
-0.6229763627052307,
-0.9816321730613708,
-0.5332143306732178,
0.2847232222557068,
0.12715764343738556,
-0.37484097480773926,
0.21884630620479584,
-0.19161860644817352,
0.40107542276382446,
0.4534022808074951,
-0.9960968494415283,
0.14206917583942413,
0.8939809799194336,
0.4110337793827057,
-0.2538136839866638,
-0.26099878549575806,
-1.0403950214385986,
0.13273154199123383,
-0.23461569845676422,
0.578350841999054,
-0.6370476484298706,
-0.3294867277145386,
-0.12595194578170776,
0.07888099551200867,
0.20545694231987,
-0.6121279001235962,
0.5757570266723633,
-0.4849247336387634,
0.5476204752922058,
-0.6856867671012878,
-0.5177964568138123,
0.07645252346992493,
0.4492984116077423,
-0.6349595189094543,
0.4317155182361603,
-0.02433215267956257,
-1.0101898908615112,
0.6677074432373047,
-0.7546851634979248,
-0.2307351678609848,
0.02625095471739769,
-0.6472665071487427,
-0.29621854424476624,
0.338055819272995,
0.1887395977973938,
0.462742418050766,
-0.07787644863128662,
0.6963756680488586,
-0.4826960563659668,
-0.29253074526786804,
0.46822038292884827,
-0.6829830408096313,
0.9288482666015625,
0.3244073987007141,
-0.39195215702056885,
0.012980623170733452,
-0.2763556241989136,
-0.10622166842222214,
0.06212076544761658,
-0.352933794260025,
-0.009642647579312325,
-0.05771463364362717,
-0.09958787262439728,
0.4608408510684967,
-0.0877678170800209,
-0.4958399534225464,
0.05137861892580986,
-0.5630849003791809,
0.29138410091400146,
1.3724128007888794,
-0.4715104103088379,
0.7121334075927734,
-0.5319652557373047,
0.4452928304672241,
0.10408756881952286,
0.08831898868083954,
0.24874641001224518,
-0.4943661391735077,
-0.6036032438278198,
-0.1568589210510254,
0.145936980843544,
0.49450236558914185,
-0.48343613743782043,
0.17866049706935883,
-0.18758843839168549,
-0.02241618186235428,
-0.7076954245567322,
0.10192669928073883,
0.049015652388334274,
0.5238637924194336,
-0.003626288613304496,
-0.3759872317314148,
-0.6034627556800842,
-1.3075952529907227,
-0.6555167436599731,
-0.03817526623606682,
-0.16083268821239471,
0.21698178350925446,
0.257904976606369,
0.0021213807631284,
1.1431419849395752,
-0.09892039000988007,
-0.16722416877746582,
-0.35124707221984863,
-0.12642081081867218,
0.3942461609840393,
0.35751771926879883,
0.6082412004470825,
-0.907016932964325,
-0.2605401873588562,
-0.3607163429260254,
-0.7357457280158997,
-0.3176805377006531,
0.09465739876031876,
-0.10517500340938568,
0.11785853654146194,
0.4184281826019287,
-0.5623826384544373,
0.3062218129634857,
0.54177325963974,
-0.3795263171195984,
0.3268977403640747,
0.21202433109283447,
0.1570521742105484,
-0.9482138156890869,
0.03331276401877403,
-0.14017009735107422,
-0.44533756375312805,
-0.26141542196273804,
-0.0055753374472260475,
-0.30239126086235046,
0.10050266981124878,
-0.6106395721435547,
0.693912923336029,
-0.12511828541755676,
-0.14330410957336426,
-0.350364625453949,
0.15655721724033356,
-0.019473908469080925,
0.15035639703273773,
-0.23142652213573456,
0.4055316150188446,
0.6305239200592041,
-0.3816186785697937,
0.15550735592842102,
-0.10211413353681564,
-0.21626092493534088,
0.8467917442321777,
-0.5201848149299622,
0.06479734927415848,
-0.6443607211112976,
0.6190065741539001,
-0.7178054451942444,
-0.23099060356616974,
0.23446853458881378,
-0.18287062644958496,
-0.05751911178231239,
-0.4415813088417053,
-0.5198567509651184,
-0.25786879658699036,
-0.327186644077301,
0.38588663935661316,
0.4550379514694214,
-0.5536422729492188,
0.6898947358131409,
0.679969072341919,
-0.2320868968963623,
-0.9206525683403015,
-0.8889843821525574,
0.17512449622154236,
-0.5610949397087097,
-0.5447185635566711,
0.26617854833602905,
-0.23320862650871277,
-0.5157373547554016,
-0.17755979299545288,
-0.07139842212200165,
0.19382666051387787,
0.2725578546524048,
0.2626393735408783,
0.10819781571626663,
0.07127305120229721,
-0.12386764585971832,
0.06694527715444565,
-0.02717452310025692,
0.1294758915901184,
-0.23090508580207825,
0.5202077627182007,
-0.09348957985639572,
-0.48701125383377075,
-0.36821192502975464,
0.3684796690940857,
0.33320721983909607,
-0.09245175868272781,
0.4750092029571533,
0.6305769681930542,
-0.3827819228172302,
-0.3523334860801697,
-0.6528872847557068,
-0.2126099318265915,
-0.5366864204406738,
0.34474819898605347,
-0.11251501739025116,
-1.218727946281433,
0.4941290020942688,
0.3054037094116211,
0.5091646313667297,
0.1091826781630516,
0.7378496527671814,
0.00025893241399899125,
1.2291593551635742,
0.6729016304016113,
-0.05982150509953499,
0.4491124451160431,
0.059732355177402496,
0.3200567066669464,
-0.4902200698852539,
-0.18002508580684662,
-0.4853741526603699,
-0.5677422285079956,
-0.7569050192832947,
-0.477634996175766,
0.08913872390985489,
-0.04059198126196861,
-0.405115008354187,
-0.331127792596817,
-0.3826140761375427,
0.8053048849105835,
0.36218470335006714,
-0.15696942806243896,
0.3897273540496826,
0.07621734589338303,
-0.06316497176885605,
-0.23172537982463837,
-0.4467361569404602,
-0.7832939624786377,
1.0773969888687134,
0.519736111164093,
0.7189965844154358,
0.3046393096446991,
0.6866982579231262,
0.37013697624206543,
0.7251932621002197,
-0.7125140428543091,
0.6128677725791931,
-0.31092336773872375,
-0.8278910517692566,
-0.017414484173059464,
-0.5337628722190857,
-0.7236828804016113,
0.4435255825519562,
-0.007368908729404211,
-0.6417821645736694,
0.06109416484832764,
0.3392565846443176,
-0.11819279938936234,
0.431987464427948,
-0.7150432467460632,
0.6957308053970337,
-0.021116936579346657,
-0.24654003977775574,
-0.3669738173484802,
-0.6201830506324768,
0.49028638005256653,
0.05297541990876198,
0.42218226194381714,
-0.30234453082084656,
0.07928330451250076,
0.6448430418968201,
-0.0900244489312172,
0.9851554036140442,
-0.6317296624183655,
-0.3914293348789215,
0.04437130689620972,
0.32297563552856445,
0.19429868459701538,
0.38416826725006104,
-0.525726854801178,
0.04822539538145065,
-0.33766040205955505,
-0.4585999846458435,
-0.4462442994117737,
0.8019217848777771,
-0.5668506622314453,
-0.877532958984375,
-0.5414171814918518,
-0.553255558013916,
-0.3526637554168701,
0.11641178280115128,
0.18121060729026794,
-0.0569177009165287,
-0.16653157770633698,
0.09707776457071304,
0.6263155341148376,
-0.13705895841121674,
0.4495863616466522,
0.3786467909812927,
-0.3900674283504486,
0.19810181856155396,
0.5420133471488953,
-0.03710446134209633,
0.2730695307254791,
0.026356946676969528,
0.22532659769058228,
-0.31576868891716003,
-0.5118123888969421,
-0.38178059458732605,
0.03829670324921608,
-0.6755049824714661,
-0.12009705603122711,
-0.7190878987312317,
-0.07187473028898239,
-0.32799458503723145,
-0.11852194368839264,
-0.2241622805595398,
-0.4293798804283142,
0.17099997401237488,
-0.19760969281196594,
0.05748596042394638,
0.7114055752754211,
-0.28584086894989014,
0.3309139013290405,
-0.4227893054485321,
0.3051934540271759,
0.7197375297546387,
0.6066668033599854,
0.29349061846733093,
-0.6246366500854492,
0.10379699617624283,
0.1459551602602005,
-0.5531643033027649,
-0.340863436460495,
-0.05769640579819679,
-0.12307160347700119,
0.9375123977661133,
0.3074009120464325,
-0.29832348227500916,
0.2473321259021759,
-0.8199223875999451,
0.7840853929519653,
0.2347794622182846,
-1.0192970037460327,
0.4425811767578125,
-0.32725754380226135,
-0.0433981753885746,
0.3805875778198242,
0.14811831712722778,
-0.6588825583457947,
-0.753178060054779,
-0.5221507549285889,
-0.5515838265419006,
0.7951523065567017,
0.18716394901275635,
0.32227495312690735,
-0.007646400947123766,
0.13096675276756287,
0.3713592290878296,
0.4741697311401367,
-1.244482398033142,
-0.10564635694026947,
-0.33149537444114685,
-0.24380137026309967,
0.1096997782588005,
0.05114473029971123,
-0.3965749144554138,
0.04820391163229942,
0.2202168107032776,
-0.16694219410419464,
0.050885558128356934,
-0.014589516445994377,
-0.056714728474617004,
-0.1458699107170105,
0.5994331240653992,
0.2136126458644867,
0.6810081005096436,
0.044999148696660995,
0.296139121055603,
0.11886654049158096,
-0.27154549956321716,
0.015361127443611622,
0.04050692170858383,
0.0266021229326725,
-0.22444620728492737,
0.04769358038902283,
0.5731611251831055,
-0.3473372459411621,
-0.5997950434684753,
0.7375620007514954,
-0.24438245594501495,
-0.05337882786989212,
-0.035560671240091324,
0.3447522222995758,
0.2268914133310318,
0.45316678285598755,
0.26902809739112854,
0.13345807790756226,
0.23587244749069214,
-0.7078248262405396,
0.06500706821680069,
0.470057874917984,
-0.1757534295320511,
-0.20193631947040558,
0.7481409907341003,
0.2127574235200882,
-0.17611083388328552,
0.3983479142189026,
-0.2949853241443634,
-0.5286905765533447,
0.5901252627372742,
0.17206649482250214,
0.6729320883750916,
-0.027598930522799492,
0.07051631063222885,
-0.10132037103176117,
0.23892217874526978,
-0.27694857120513916,
0.22353467345237732,
0.307304710149765,
-0.8418118953704834,
-0.6127541661262512,
-0.6892209053039551,
-0.2335951179265976,
0.1151377335190773,
-0.3727411925792694,
0.4409090578556061,
-0.4758007526397705,
-0.23198212683200836,
0.009710793383419514,
-0.16790665686130524,
-0.9560477137565613,
0.04543716087937355,
0.5800026655197144,
0.7485186457633972,
-0.9058468341827393,
0.6360342502593994,
0.4014054834842682,
-0.20853011310100555,
-0.7457531094551086,
0.18141068518161774,
0.22151263058185577,
-0.9075940251350403,
0.7419320940971375,
0.2828175127506256,
0.07259432971477509,
-0.2474767416715622,
-0.8212761282920837,
-0.1092664822936058,
0.927827775478363,
0.7896187901496887,
-0.7383444905281067,
-0.2537568211555481,
0.2834469676017761,
0.224182590842247,
-0.4865914583206177,
0.09522762149572372,
0.26705652475357056,
0.4895588159561157,
-0.22648438811302185,
-1.0734803676605225,
0.12410325556993484,
0.0519230030477047,
-0.02586323581635952,
-0.28698956966400146,
-0.5677040815353394,
1.075247883796692,
-0.2988995909690857,
0.10028740763664246,
-0.1292881965637207,
0.3846380412578583,
0.6579090356826782,
0.41932278871536255,
0.9860994815826416,
0.5341378450393677,
0.9035749435424805,
0.05685871094465256,
0.9247554540634155,
0.35640180110931396,
0.036884188652038574,
1.0889679193496704,
-0.619965136051178,
0.37030214071273804,
0.5956283807754517,
0.0046846382319927216,
0.43161386251449585,
0.4295831620693207,
-0.045172784477472305,
0.4018653333187103,
0.6379306316375732,
-0.30367645621299744,
-0.4061218500137329,
-0.2537247836589813,
-0.4277755618095398,
0.46021291613578796,
0.1266442835330963,
-0.2857629060745239,
-0.36144307255744934,
0.12259169667959213,
0.14839227497577667,
0.35077574849128723,
-0.45655807852745056,
0.3918713629245758,
0.41364526748657227,
-0.5822649002075195,
0.008217201568186283,
0.2206277996301651,
1.0128173828125,
-0.2783636748790741,
-0.04842821881175041,
-0.26122546195983887,
0.04935844615101814,
-0.33672481775283813,
-1.2483049631118774,
0.1132209300994873,
0.18031570315361023,
-0.36404672265052795,
-0.48212292790412903,
0.3168542981147766,
-0.20422795414924622,
-0.24038346111774445,
0.2854713201522827,
0.740847110748291,
0.03335981070995331,
0.05258877947926521,
-0.6945502758026123,
0.10059590637683868,
0.12546958029270172,
-0.1287955939769745,
0.5164250731468201,
0.8240041136741638,
-0.305732399225235,
0.6024837493896484,
0.5336204171180725,
0.19636431336402893,
-0.17026327550411224,
0.5226075053215027,
0.8365543484687805,
-0.619365394115448,
-0.7191046476364136,
-0.961673378944397,
0.7245981097221375,
-0.3063998520374298,
-0.06820208579301834,
0.431741327047348,
0.5228199362754822,
0.8406631350517273,
0.21950706839561462,
0.9079747796058655,
-0.11345036327838898,
0.5143452882766724,
-0.4655282199382782,
0.9608303904533386,
-0.5212900638580322,
0.5320488810539246,
-0.24724790453910828,
-0.8819431662559509,
-0.0685507133603096,
0.6032112836837769,
-0.35156628489494324,
0.34963545203208923,
0.23771578073501587,
0.8031629323959351,
-0.20960772037506104,
0.2164766639471054,
0.13427484035491943,
0.3705749213695526,
0.8045141696929932,
0.589261531829834,
1.0650960206985474,
-0.029464155435562134,
0.492874413728714,
0.3174374997615814,
-0.2367876172065735,
-0.03932096064090729,
-1.2807594537734985,
-0.948057234287262,
-0.18689000606536865,
0.03557535633444786,
-0.5479317307472229,
-0.08250734955072403,
1.0288442373275757,
0.7218143343925476,
-0.5222674012184143,
-0.3084152638912201,
0.02348063699901104,
0.31717389822006226,
0.3812890350818634,
-0.26797106862068176,
-0.1158837154507637,
-0.16614671051502228,
-0.7249311208724976,
-0.046982187777757645,
-0.09306961297988892,
-0.11532024294137955,
-0.34192290902137756,
-0.06636815518140793,
0.2046724110841751,
-0.10422442108392715,
0.6237456798553467,
-0.12154969573020935,
-0.6504689455032349,
-0.43402159214019775,
-0.24478527903556824,
-0.30284804105758667,
-0.017312413081526756,
0.866278886795044,
-0.8540825247764587,
0.16358080506324768,
0.319655179977417,
0.6275841593742371,
0.05247596651315689,
-0.39841824769973755,
0.8185404539108276,
-0.655482828617096,
0.2666129469871521,
0.5831013917922974,
0.35586240887641907,
0.578654408454895,
-0.27920103073120117,
0.24027258157730103,
0.22600817680358887,
-0.5639925599098206,
-1.0467637777328491,
0.4259880483150482,
-0.8489930033683777,
-0.27238497138023376,
0.869185209274292,
0.22680343687534332,
-0.035715553909540176,
0.022658025845885277,
-0.29558897018432617,
0.035993173718452454,
-0.6744901537895203,
0.9320196509361267,
0.7850608229637146,
-0.11132466048002243,
0.044809285551309586,
-0.7697192430496216,
0.6142160892486572,
0.5840065479278564,
-0.6931963562965393,
0.1875002086162567,
0.4299762547016144,
0.594149112701416,
-0.28161388635635376,
0.9186707735061646,
-0.3744180500507355,
0.20488356053829193,
-0.5642017126083374,
-0.2148306518793106,
0.29332104325294495,
0.11990024894475937,
-0.376598060131073,
0.1006941944360733,
0.3335128724575043,
0.28721821308135986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14845v1 | Purifying Large Language Models by Ensembling a Small Language Model | 2024-02-19T14:00:39 | 2024-02-19T14:00:39 | Tianlin Li, Qian Liu, Tianyu Pang, Chao Du, Qing Guo, Yang Liu, Min Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2 | The emerging success of large language models (LLMs) heavily relies on
collecting abundant training data from external (untrusted) sources. Despite
substantial efforts devoted to data cleaning and curation, well-constructed
LLMs have been reported to suffer from copyright infringement, data poisoning,
and/or privacy violations, which would impede practical deployment of LLMs. In
this study, we propose a simple and easily implementable method for purifying
LLMs from the negative effects caused by uncurated data, namely, through
ensembling LLMs with benign and small language models (SLMs). Aside from
theoretical guarantees, we perform comprehensive experiments to empirically
confirm the efficacy of ensembling LLMs with SLMs, which can effectively
preserve the performance of LLMs while mitigating issues such as copyright
infringement, data poisoning, and privacy violations. | [
-0.22950193285942078,
-0.7943061590194702,
0.6840054988861084,
-0.24470378458499908,
-0.4989137053489685,
0.049435731023550034,
-0.5604498386383057,
-0.4193006753921509,
0.12770263850688934,
1.0649231672286987,
-0.14360743761062622,
-0.3140869438648224,
-0.49940669536590576,
-0.1270531266927719,
-0.7072639465332031,
0.9604294896125793,
0.17928992211818695,
0.01033172570168972,
-0.31950902938842773,
0.11776559054851532,
-0.28473371267318726,
-0.4453396201133728,
-0.6663994193077087,
-0.5644951462745667,
0.2285938262939453,
0.5461276173591614,
0.580580472946167,
0.8157629370689392,
0.3209146559238434,
0.2951984405517578,
-0.379111111164093,
0.3976666331291199,
-0.8325200080871582,
0.12585805356502533,
-0.3409166932106018,
-0.6520305871963501,
-0.13944706320762634,
0.0018345846328884363,
0.7558131814002991,
0.6602880358695984,
-0.231362447142601,
0.27788469195365906,
0.5304142236709595,
0.589738130569458,
-0.6753649711608887,
-0.20391538739204407,
-0.9506542682647705,
-0.14843040704727173,
-0.49648013710975647,
-0.2629636824131012,
-0.8248237371444702,
-0.4645492434501648,
-0.3847121000289917,
-0.191334068775177,
0.08338623493909836,
0.10381985455751419,
0.7414873242378235,
0.2925623953342438,
-0.19694945216178894,
-0.1213194876909256,
-0.9617286324501038,
1.0425904989242554,
-1.1942023038864136,
0.35703733563423157,
0.4894648492336273,
0.16088560223579407,
-0.2762928903102875,
-0.4827161431312561,
-0.4895520806312561,
-0.12173930555582047,
-0.1683930605649948,
-0.3093951642513275,
-0.18668557703495026,
-0.10928384214639664,
0.291015088558197,
0.2566240131855011,
-0.5138947367668152,
0.42089077830314636,
-0.4280339479446411,
-0.23896200954914093,
0.7376213073730469,
0.17078913748264313,
0.26581576466560364,
-0.060576241463422775,
-0.22801943123340607,
0.24094462394714355,
-1.4389981031417847,
-0.16520068049430847,
0.6705453395843506,
0.5633125901222229,
0.20863528549671173,
0.9068800210952759,
-0.07354403287172318,
0.574077308177948,
-0.023456614464521408,
-0.28769978880882263,
0.00028759113047271967,
-0.17651714384555817,
-0.394111305475235,
0.015453959815204144,
0.6136879324913025,
-0.03498781844973564,
0.3421618342399597,
-0.41996508836746216,
-0.41261810064315796,
-0.07352201640605927,
0.28099358081817627,
-0.8447285294532776,
-0.1898416429758072,
0.4103815257549286,
-0.525897204875946,
-0.3176043927669525,
-0.24480684101581573,
-0.8325745463371277,
-0.7693054676055908,
-0.5540755391120911,
0.4236343801021576,
-0.1326626092195511,
-0.19731256365776062,
0.2087482362985611,
0.12231051921844482,
-0.06692549586296082,
0.2710523307323456,
-0.7454508543014526,
0.25994381308555603,
0.968211829662323,
0.6836576461791992,
-0.09703019261360168,
0.10451693087816238,
-0.7038958072662354,
0.4402216672897339,
-0.20051728188991547,
0.5852766036987305,
-0.5214848518371582,
-0.3551441431045532,
0.16181610524654388,
0.0638069361448288,
0.24215573072433472,
-1.0070689916610718,
0.4374023973941803,
-0.6590190529823303,
-0.06346652656793594,
0.152499258518219,
-0.7392833828926086,
-0.03188184276223183,
0.39115986227989197,
-0.7466710805892944,
0.5539705157279968,
-0.41284850239753723,
-0.7509031891822815,
-0.17016293108463287,
-0.12369736284017563,
-0.4591316878795624,
0.015822868794202805,
-0.034733038395643234,
-0.4831690788269043,
0.33773741126060486,
0.029439348727464676,
0.46574702858924866,
-0.293505996465683,
0.3625926673412323,
-0.5806916952133179,
-0.3423568904399872,
0.34161677956581116,
-0.4420732259750366,
1.0387403964996338,
0.39779749512672424,
0.006240454036742449,
-0.002705484628677368,
-0.7163931131362915,
-0.027099523693323135,
0.1791200041770935,
-0.47696977853775024,
-0.7983248829841614,
0.2132129669189453,
-0.241818368434906,
0.10934764891862869,
0.34845590591430664,
-0.7393223643302917,
0.07528339326381683,
-0.6583409309387207,
0.4799838066101074,
0.7641779184341431,
0.0863896831870079,
0.7390099167823792,
-0.30056002736091614,
0.4296245872974396,
0.13333359360694885,
0.190921351313591,
0.19835874438285828,
-0.4954341650009155,
-0.833534300327301,
-0.2516886591911316,
0.125258207321167,
0.22526751458644867,
-0.8293015360832214,
0.2221013307571411,
-0.43883997201919556,
-0.5852878093719482,
-0.5324445962905884,
0.46535730361938477,
0.31034258008003235,
0.43731486797332764,
0.12746717035770416,
-0.07181009650230408,
-0.4150606095790863,
-0.998609185218811,
-0.47563520073890686,
-0.009791177697479725,
-0.05556198209524155,
0.20589682459831238,
0.5211393237113953,
-0.3149867653846741,
0.9770626425743103,
-0.44988128542900085,
-0.3014243245124817,
-0.1448434591293335,
-0.14186955988407135,
0.12187772989273071,
0.7229697704315186,
0.1715632975101471,
-0.40439704060554504,
-0.3671320676803589,
-0.21126291155815125,
-0.4557643532752991,
-0.19504481554031372,
0.14927883446216583,
-0.05579560995101929,
0.02146795392036438,
0.6767591238021851,
-0.6034733057022095,
0.35058125853538513,
0.3866916000843048,
-0.12508870661258698,
0.5749121904373169,
-0.11934266239404678,
-0.07848364114761353,
-0.7505868673324585,
0.12903207540512085,
-0.11765076965093613,
-0.4653882086277008,
-0.812534749507904,
0.46698108315467834,
0.13081501424312592,
-0.2797304093837738,
-0.7665907740592957,
0.752165675163269,
-0.3382710814476013,
0.27692726254463196,
-0.4253685176372528,
0.11867132782936096,
0.12467976659536362,
0.1540268212556839,
-0.030550241470336914,
0.33394232392311096,
0.23324157297611237,
-0.5727093815803528,
0.09646379202604294,
0.039655305445194244,
-0.40480390191078186,
0.30558666586875916,
-0.4439810514450073,
0.20944419503211975,
-0.3101588189601898,
-0.05540992319583893,
-0.8738234639167786,
-0.02867261879146099,
0.233719140291214,
-0.05611850321292877,
0.5184569358825684,
-0.5127875208854675,
-0.803699254989624,
-0.09287369251251221,
-0.2770080864429474,
0.3809782862663269,
0.6500776410102844,
-0.9012608528137207,
0.4262946844100952,
0.6984140872955322,
-0.12887197732925415,
-0.4078509509563446,
-0.9095653891563416,
0.06929360330104828,
-0.7862980365753174,
-0.5325669646263123,
0.039723899215459824,
-0.003311674576252699,
-0.3584311604499817,
-0.020899102091789246,
0.025849778205156326,
-0.08251119405031204,
0.24728350341320038,
0.2757861018180847,
0.18444791436195374,
0.020616482943296432,
0.006684329826384783,
-0.11725891381502151,
-0.07840894907712936,
0.06050679087638855,
-0.017967717722058296,
0.7035225629806519,
0.08531930297613144,
-0.49785029888153076,
-0.047910384833812714,
0.29309794306755066,
0.4411555230617523,
-0.3380856215953827,
0.79841148853302,
-0.0033367020078003407,
-0.7383534908294678,
-0.5245817303657532,
-0.726161539554596,
-0.35478806495666504,
-0.5522288084030151,
0.13050496578216553,
0.03925022855401039,
-0.9020090103149414,
0.4887482225894928,
-0.1949649304151535,
0.23191078007221222,
0.10730191320180893,
0.40081965923309326,
-0.1119789257645607,
1.030136227607727,
0.4816499352455139,
-0.23922301828861237,
0.35676586627960205,
-0.12101911753416061,
0.5186749696731567,
-0.7682278156280518,
-0.17236945033073425,
-0.7479614615440369,
-0.43190425634384155,
-0.4258557856082916,
-0.40906983613967896,
0.11187222599983215,
0.20605997741222382,
-0.4840952157974243,
0.28946760296821594,
-0.3646523058414459,
0.7503478527069092,
0.45302578806877136,
0.2135736644268036,
0.7570614814758301,
0.15289638936519623,
0.07109943777322769,
-0.1957687884569168,
-0.4345732033252716,
-0.838428258895874,
1.0298625230789185,
0.551814079284668,
1.3856806755065918,
0.2085442841053009,
1.172000765800476,
-0.1800079196691513,
0.49688586592674255,
-0.6265363693237305,
0.7486886382102966,
-0.4545970559120178,
-0.67432701587677,
-0.3039536476135254,
-0.47994738817214966,
-0.9166547060012817,
0.20185482501983643,
0.003540592035278678,
-0.9168241620063782,
0.22259892523288727,
0.15260718762874603,
-0.2937188744544983,
0.5142139196395874,
-0.7022801041603088,
0.7147918939590454,
-0.12189053744077682,
-0.5843908190727234,
-0.39166009426116943,
-0.20995517075061798,
0.8402489423751831,
-0.4863232970237732,
0.5401524305343628,
-0.12090147286653519,
-0.025603797286748886,
0.6825148463249207,
-0.6195349097251892,
0.9645554423332214,
-0.31373047828674316,
-0.4521733820438385,
0.2963506877422333,
0.5484064817428589,
0.741620659828186,
0.015500984154641628,
-0.014230805449187756,
0.1366719752550125,
-0.012707924470305443,
-0.03237944468855858,
-0.5660069584846497,
0.9180087447166443,
-0.47083380818367004,
-0.7817203998565674,
-0.10508141666650772,
-0.39601054787635803,
-0.18496188521385193,
0.33577612042427063,
0.04449239745736122,
0.177638441324234,
0.10151781886816025,
0.27275824546813965,
0.7853362560272217,
-0.3268411159515381,
0.46524590253829956,
0.89452064037323,
-0.4478395879268646,
0.0005400073132477701,
1.1459287405014038,
0.06043117493391037,
0.33492574095726013,
0.1154017224907875,
0.2561650276184082,
-0.32752615213394165,
-0.8841646909713745,
-0.1418030709028244,
0.4329216778278351,
-0.6173346042633057,
-0.3832278549671173,
-0.3638453781604767,
-0.23235680162906647,
-0.19667915999889374,
0.06951399892568588,
-0.697181224822998,
-0.28187501430511475,
-0.36099061369895935,
0.27656349539756775,
0.09917306154966354,
0.5863597393035889,
0.001697783125564456,
0.3690655529499054,
-0.9069114327430725,
0.1737583577632904,
0.0726868212223053,
0.4945552945137024,
0.11621662229299545,
-0.8712945580482483,
-0.3333534598350525,
0.40737074613571167,
-0.22566714882850647,
-0.5474509596824646,
0.6533659100532532,
0.16470417380332947,
0.39840346574783325,
0.6194056272506714,
0.033992912620306015,
0.8168675899505615,
-0.825661301612854,
0.6790525317192078,
-0.02880510315299034,
-0.7535824775695801,
0.6375046372413635,
-0.13759659230709076,
0.036280557513237,
0.5355455279350281,
0.10185246914625168,
-0.49094992876052856,
-0.8325625658035278,
-0.4585537314414978,
-0.8910452127456665,
0.6506369709968567,
0.0003274114860687405,
0.1751818209886551,
-0.010320986621081829,
0.2794245779514313,
-0.013972458429634571,
0.24741359055042267,
-0.6721622943878174,
-0.07726826518774033,
0.18189097940921783,
-0.21317829191684723,
-0.26522383093833923,
-0.2621525824069977,
-0.38220053911209106,
-0.018516968935728073,
1.0318496227264404,
0.3191457688808441,
-0.05379856750369072,
-0.4565317630767822,
-0.49744513630867004,
-0.09347502887248993,
0.41099345684051514,
0.22506465017795563,
0.10031478852033615,
-0.0361885204911232,
0.5646178722381592,
-0.19484350085258484,
-0.26406410336494446,
0.4337579905986786,
-0.18597412109375,
-0.5077593326568604,
-0.2656514346599579,
0.06552312523126602,
0.03706580400466919,
0.29081425070762634,
-0.9782949686050415,
0.4560350179672241,
0.05629132315516472,
0.3317246735095978,
-0.22922345995903015,
0.12740707397460938,
0.43678387999534607,
0.15611311793327332,
-0.06418056041002274,
-0.05531906709074974,
0.07315337657928467,
-0.4427890479564667,
0.24221494793891907,
0.5796339511871338,
0.09716996550559998,
-0.09007179737091064,
0.6412562727928162,
0.12655657529830933,
-0.09478647261857986,
0.6718831062316895,
-0.1627172976732254,
-0.2448110431432724,
0.3028676509857178,
0.7278061509132385,
0.6464404463768005,
-0.2699964642524719,
-0.0467965230345726,
0.27737706899642944,
0.5218154788017273,
-0.5419074296951294,
0.08520463854074478,
0.2655922770500183,
-0.9980457425117493,
-0.4586620628833771,
-0.716178834438324,
-0.1916881948709488,
0.4857286810874939,
-0.5809530019760132,
0.026466824114322662,
-0.4219149351119995,
-0.07343080639839172,
-0.19973519444465637,
-0.02251088060438633,
-0.7005359530448914,
-0.008800551295280457,
0.45743268728256226,
0.8783554434776306,
-1.0238229036331177,
0.9617048501968384,
0.4465695917606354,
-0.3611951470375061,
-0.8521592020988464,
-0.276030570268631,
0.14383016526699066,
-0.7856046557426453,
0.5152204632759094,
0.052571993321180344,
0.02165747620165348,
-0.008010484278202057,
-0.7040901184082031,
-0.9400261640548706,
0.5134583115577698,
0.7679851651191711,
-0.859359085559845,
0.1065884679555893,
0.5042865872383118,
0.43768632411956787,
0.06981027871370316,
-0.22468918561935425,
0.8315689563751221,
0.4061051607131958,
-0.28114309906959534,
-0.6096208095550537,
0.24847640097141266,
-0.33684638142585754,
-0.06307771056890488,
0.2064802646636963,
-0.4716566801071167,
0.6147114634513855,
0.0067594014108181,
-0.4474113881587982,
0.17862756550312042,
0.3733728229999542,
0.3901948630809784,
-0.00014898877998348325,
0.5387532711029053,
0.7245120406150818,
0.8872959017753601,
-0.08989818394184113,
0.6873555183410645,
-0.23370417952537537,
0.4108161926269531,
1.4314624071121216,
-0.5322644114494324,
0.9829832911491394,
0.7232187390327454,
0.01848476193845272,
0.08295250684022903,
0.4604002833366394,
-0.023173745721578598,
0.7275399565696716,
0.36158159375190735,
-0.3511301875114441,
-0.2670089602470398,
-0.1793590486049652,
-0.1318448930978775,
0.4748058021068573,
0.41093340516090393,
-0.2696709632873535,
-0.44520553946495056,
0.22816799581050873,
0.09387046843767166,
0.13933230936527252,
-0.37318655848503113,
0.6381782293319702,
0.2863934338092804,
-0.6334156394004822,
0.4704301357269287,
0.2233743816614151,
0.8280702829360962,
-0.28511497378349304,
0.20139238238334656,
-0.17483358085155487,
0.40615081787109375,
-0.4385825991630554,
-0.8002493977546692,
0.46736955642700195,
0.208354651927948,
0.007561295758932829,
-0.33098113536834717,
1.0253924131393433,
-0.8358181715011597,
-0.27072998881340027,
0.3357425332069397,
0.5367094278335571,
0.366067111492157,
-0.08748339861631393,
-0.19219885766506195,
0.1986176073551178,
-0.0017273499397560954,
-0.25960174202919006,
0.5394001603126526,
0.16094902157783508,
0.08469805121421814,
0.8201733231544495,
0.6316384673118591,
0.47686654329299927,
0.04244198650121689,
0.11271373927593231,
0.8819781541824341,
-0.4264349043369293,
-0.4067622721195221,
-1.1235581636428833,
0.5218863487243652,
0.04102003946900368,
0.29466816782951355,
0.9063626527786255,
0.82903653383255,
0.9003987312316895,
-0.1046920046210289,
0.6740533113479614,
0.3200218677520752,
0.5679787397384644,
-0.4449102580547333,
1.0365887880325317,
-0.5779592394828796,
0.7419995069503784,
-0.02728024497628212,
-0.8034259080886841,
-0.25417619943618774,
0.4340577721595764,
-0.28406834602355957,
-0.1626533418893814,
0.31957197189331055,
1.092349886894226,
-0.20803888142108917,
0.11848475784063339,
0.34068211913108826,
0.46312376856803894,
0.6762619614601135,
0.5228356122970581,
0.9365442395210266,
0.015534302219748497,
0.3985406160354614,
-0.5676853656768799,
-0.09797166287899017,
-0.1455526351928711,
-0.9279902577400208,
-0.9308469891548157,
-0.19864614307880402,
-0.22935405373573303,
-0.44565337896347046,
-0.13120020925998688,
0.6593602895736694,
0.5129138827323914,
-0.8241303563117981,
-0.12416784465312958,
0.15671558678150177,
0.24272362887859344,
0.06391939520835876,
-0.18462510406970978,
0.21920844912528992,
-0.1495678424835205,
-0.8196547627449036,
0.5407742261886597,
0.022811539471149445,
0.12513969838619232,
-0.4609520137310028,
-0.0796019658446312,
0.17122353613376617,
0.18965524435043335,
0.5920796394348145,
0.2608337700366974,
-0.7737117409706116,
-0.5210500955581665,
-0.42889344692230225,
-0.25513848662376404,
-0.22552478313446045,
0.7845389246940613,
-0.688737690448761,
0.4432193636894226,
0.4753299951553345,
0.7612351775169373,
0.3811720907688141,
-0.04896235093474388,
0.40685978531837463,
-0.98650723695755,
0.1501428186893463,
0.2943345606327057,
0.6372262239456177,
0.32852163910865784,
-0.3571537435054779,
0.4152243733406067,
-0.08084911108016968,
-0.6131225228309631,
-1.2901030778884888,
0.12420903146266937,
-0.675449788570404,
-0.3339819610118866,
1.4550169706344604,
-0.1910330206155777,
-0.1546182632446289,
-0.1392824649810791,
0.07285679876804352,
0.23390227556228638,
-0.10133640468120575,
0.8328747749328613,
0.5774791836738586,
0.25585466623306274,
0.2694830596446991,
-0.549220085144043,
0.34263497591018677,
0.16557425260543823,
-0.8896075487136841,
0.3815518915653229,
0.4927753806114197,
0.5991557836532593,
-0.1053893119096756,
0.4828971028327942,
-0.45244595408439636,
-0.16179019212722778,
-0.26055026054382324,
-0.20055872201919556,
-0.1947319358587265,
-0.28143924474716187,
-0.6276384592056274,
0.13725578784942627,
0.03425157070159912,
0.05464620888233185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12147v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12147v3 | Surprising Efficacy of Fine-Tuned Transformers for Fact-Checking over Larger Language Models | 2024-02-19T14:00:35 | 2024-04-30T08:56:18 | Vinay Setty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we explore the challenges associated with establishing an
end-to-end fact-checking pipeline in a real-world context, covering over 90
languages. Our real-world experimental benchmarks demonstrate that fine-tuning
Transformer models specifically for fact-checking tasks, such as claim
detection and veracity prediction, provide superior performance over large
language models (LLMs) like GPT-4, GPT-3.5-Turbo, and Mistral-7b. However, we
illustrate that LLMs excel in generative tasks such as question decomposition
for evidence retrieval. Through extensive evaluation, we show the efficacy of
fine-tuned models for fact-checking in a multilingual setting and complex
claims that include numerical quantities. | [
-0.5029720067977905,
-0.7554183602333069,
0.8844845294952393,
-0.050509992986917496,
-0.16611944139003754,
0.019718360155820847,
-0.33914127945899963,
-0.5074089169502258,
-0.39896300435066223,
0.49624279141426086,
-0.351300984621048,
-0.3608178496360779,
-0.9299159049987793,
0.30905869603157043,
-0.7043445706367493,
1.1919702291488647,
-0.10442352294921875,
-0.17881830036640167,
-0.062202051281929016,
-0.11658147722482681,
-0.08894365280866623,
-0.42022761702537537,
-0.452730655670166,
-0.5141799449920654,
0.361556738615036,
0.37862318754196167,
0.8739416003227234,
0.3994106948375702,
0.59346604347229,
0.3226444721221924,
-0.16520565748214722,
0.6894772052764893,
-0.354836642742157,
0.044589001685380936,
-0.4376666843891144,
-0.8025903105735779,
-0.12300116568803787,
0.07874936610460281,
0.4332491457462311,
0.21722088754177094,
-0.1577187180519104,
0.41499394178390503,
-0.2858225703239441,
0.3727596700191498,
-0.6979538202285767,
0.5025746822357178,
-0.8588974475860596,
-0.020476464182138443,
-0.09858690947294235,
0.02249983698129654,
-0.6177393198013306,
-0.5135854482650757,
0.09327348321676254,
-0.2826312780380249,
0.7133747935295105,
0.17576348781585693,
1.2739442586898804,
0.521396815776825,
-0.6204221844673157,
-0.30289384722709656,
-0.9694303870201111,
0.5490593910217285,
-0.612838625907898,
0.6482735872268677,
0.27398839592933655,
0.4617033898830414,
-0.01067262515425682,
-0.8162564039230347,
-0.7948616743087769,
-0.12717977166175842,
-0.41549691557884216,
0.08962895721197128,
-0.3280443847179413,
0.09133300930261612,
0.5747817158699036,
0.4219495952129364,
-0.4055579900741577,
0.12784403562545776,
-0.2896447777748108,
-0.4798889756202698,
0.37126854062080383,
0.021317370235919952,
0.09634707123041153,
-0.23179270327091217,
0.0009935415582731366,
0.06353641301393509,
-0.8787996172904968,
-0.061595357954502106,
0.2611227035522461,
0.218685582280159,
-0.1037612035870552,
0.6323516368865967,
-0.45421141386032104,
0.693525493144989,
0.03527750447392464,
-0.11507901549339294,
-0.24344219267368317,
-0.4949095845222473,
-0.21004286408424377,
-0.07285350561141968,
0.5636852979660034,
0.22158898413181305,
0.23129858076572418,
-0.41988348960876465,
-0.3294479250907898,
0.2631740868091583,
0.11723895370960236,
-1.0517929792404175,
-0.09719259291887283,
0.1443934440612793,
-0.12604211270809174,
-0.1431414783000946,
0.047032374888658524,
-0.38027700781822205,
-0.34192872047424316,
-0.44568464159965515,
0.5368189811706543,
-0.2628224790096283,
-0.13764941692352295,
0.4400493800640106,
-0.03181205317378044,
0.3051265776157379,
0.3085072636604309,
-0.7407343983650208,
-0.08384409546852112,
0.9944961667060852,
0.8118728995323181,
0.18437516689300537,
-0.08166032284498215,
-0.8589745759963989,
-0.19453895092010498,
-0.40345388650894165,
1.0558024644851685,
-0.5515481233596802,
0.19345079362392426,
0.13757608830928802,
0.2581586241722107,
-0.02392180822789669,
-0.540429413318634,
1.1713342666625977,
-0.7300629019737244,
0.12177377939224243,
-0.4921635091304779,
-0.5594469308853149,
-0.17165593802928925,
0.6419569849967957,
-0.707144021987915,
0.8173485994338989,
0.02307734452188015,
-0.6839278340339661,
0.5448625683784485,
-0.3983948826789856,
-0.5918001532554626,
-0.19308950006961823,
-0.08009838312864304,
-0.6835446357727051,
0.33095163106918335,
0.129480242729187,
0.58453768491745,
-0.6962839365005493,
0.658085286617279,
0.024949481710791588,
-0.1739208847284317,
0.24376577138900757,
-0.7140771150588989,
0.4881556034088135,
0.20356899499893188,
-0.4230479896068573,
0.03868471086025238,
-0.8042479157447815,
-0.3390516936779022,
-0.1780208945274353,
-0.424911230802536,
-0.03761889040470123,
0.12701137363910675,
-0.16044458746910095,
0.23700982332229614,
0.1329929083585739,
-0.8965153694152832,
0.1557837873697281,
-0.1870606690645218,
0.4158954322338104,
0.2774803042411804,
-0.30959373712539673,
-0.14670026302337646,
-0.3652191162109375,
0.28334784507751465,
0.1057811975479126,
0.054529160261154175,
-0.32075369358062744,
-0.34814193844795227,
-1.1858500242233276,
-0.19000206887722015,
0.6694456338882446,
0.5608318448066711,
-0.792309045791626,
0.34222498536109924,
-0.4088161289691925,
-0.6303076148033142,
-0.607872486114502,
-0.23062990605831146,
0.35355672240257263,
0.5195125341415405,
0.42221948504447937,
0.20049655437469482,
-0.4440700113773346,
-1.0950204133987427,
-0.5014442801475525,
-0.2100631594657898,
-0.08378790318965912,
-0.0630752295255661,
0.5501869320869446,
-0.13468553125858307,
1.014807105064392,
-0.5934748649597168,
-0.1180066168308258,
-0.08719776570796967,
0.3215702772140503,
0.33158546686172485,
0.044385313987731934,
0.41060298681259155,
-0.8467919230461121,
-0.482412189245224,
0.32747164368629456,
-0.660362184047699,
0.02669755183160305,
-0.30406272411346436,
0.28668278455734253,
0.18366557359695435,
0.44268977642059326,
-1.1763910055160522,
0.15030361711978912,
0.471361368894577,
-0.4369620680809021,
0.7037924528121948,
-0.2690017819404602,
0.39267635345458984,
-0.7480871081352234,
-0.06269572675228119,
0.1984405815601349,
-0.5685939788818359,
-0.5723787546157837,
0.2407539039850235,
0.3970097005367279,
0.20728699862957,
-0.4234590530395508,
0.10488297790288925,
-0.22799289226531982,
0.19110052287578583,
-0.13512730598449707,
-0.1944662183523178,
-0.1474980115890503,
0.2256052941083908,
-0.09185820072889328,
0.8645814657211304,
0.5678313374519348,
-0.6523230075836182,
0.30291426181793213,
0.13783623278141022,
-0.7015905976295471,
0.4925958216190338,
-0.6432309150695801,
-0.21818280220031738,
-0.25430893898010254,
0.18217507004737854,
-0.8187596201896667,
-0.3340897858142853,
-0.3482520580291748,
-0.11866281181573868,
0.3433460593223572,
-0.48427075147628784,
-0.8323469758033752,
-0.2442832589149475,
-0.03311905264854431,
-0.0016549854772165418,
0.5225673913955688,
-0.8143439888954163,
0.8213599324226379,
0.17710915207862854,
-0.027703268453478813,
-0.5975052118301392,
-0.437193900346756,
0.225505530834198,
-0.1806563138961792,
-0.5870200395584106,
0.20857496559619904,
0.29766449332237244,
-0.3743756115436554,
-0.27967527508735657,
-0.27803441882133484,
0.08007916808128357,
0.0842345729470253,
-0.06862235814332962,
0.04320196807384491,
-0.25086185336112976,
0.047141119837760925,
0.12786747515201569,
-0.24115820229053497,
0.1663554608821869,
-0.13795895874500275,
0.2739671766757965,
-0.2868409752845764,
-0.7285787463188171,
-0.13633982837200165,
0.011444620788097382,
0.9748340249061584,
-0.36941903829574585,
0.7741724252700806,
0.8687647581100464,
-0.33851900696754456,
-0.15662820637226105,
-1.1001113653182983,
-0.25723081827163696,
-0.43601226806640625,
0.42890167236328125,
-0.3503568470478058,
-1.139203667640686,
0.5972043871879578,
-0.40614262223243713,
0.3120255172252655,
0.6910220980644226,
0.6802626252174377,
0.17836645245552063,
1.0395019054412842,
0.5315843820571899,
0.01817629486322403,
0.028905928134918213,
-0.11925671994686127,
0.6658358573913574,
-0.4589366614818573,
-0.1892353594303131,
-0.7716639041900635,
-0.0063377548940479755,
-0.7023594379425049,
-0.5026443004608154,
0.5799587368965149,
-0.11293968558311462,
-0.19697439670562744,
0.38048848509788513,
-0.21106979250907898,
0.6764353513717651,
0.2574024200439453,
0.0622519925236702,
0.7834358811378479,
-0.10321271419525146,
0.06318635493516922,
0.04812903702259064,
-0.601712167263031,
-0.47208651900291443,
0.7860916256904602,
0.425810843706131,
0.6775492429733276,
0.31875815987586975,
0.09016630798578262,
0.2603641152381897,
0.47411251068115234,
-0.8156516551971436,
0.2709820866584778,
-0.3433970808982849,
-0.7147320508956909,
-0.2857816815376282,
-0.34018078446388245,
-0.5492580533027649,
0.5129397511482239,
-0.26375052332878113,
-0.2727046608924866,
0.16708220541477203,
0.2057604044675827,
-0.4288536012172699,
0.5299350023269653,
-0.6924758553504944,
0.521203875541687,
-0.1351190060377121,
-0.3714151978492737,
-0.4601466655731201,
-0.4130863547325134,
0.5564807653427124,
-0.19297188520431519,
0.22870327532291412,
-0.18265873193740845,
0.3856728672981262,
0.2430599331855774,
-0.45251229405403137,
0.815234363079071,
-0.00027923411107622087,
-0.517583429813385,
0.2923196852207184,
0.20137734711170197,
0.9782862663269043,
0.3272888958454132,
-0.09225821495056152,
0.2121206521987915,
0.00524609349668026,
-0.0013664041180163622,
-0.6238873600959778,
0.4126574397087097,
-0.584440290927887,
-0.8427005410194397,
-0.3487912714481354,
-0.43680301308631897,
-0.2578030228614807,
0.2494274526834488,
0.4309890568256378,
0.6440644264221191,
-0.12196337431669235,
0.5492612719535828,
1.094827651977539,
-0.06686179339885712,
0.3195275366306305,
1.044702410697937,
0.07890208810567856,
0.1744416058063507,
0.9084728360176086,
0.18522347509860992,
0.23032958805561066,
0.5770695209503174,
0.17658467590808868,
-0.3759194016456604,
-0.6306661367416382,
-0.6479163765907288,
0.16569195687770844,
-0.6569471955299377,
-0.4881596863269806,
-0.895679771900177,
-0.28104615211486816,
-0.0987364873290062,
0.30256015062332153,
-0.7618787288665771,
-0.4114127457141876,
0.20891879498958588,
-0.17397157847881317,
0.3778631389141083,
0.848803699016571,
0.03756320849061012,
0.04031066223978996,
-0.7448554635047913,
0.6743544340133667,
0.4768884479999542,
0.6858677864074707,
-0.36697712540626526,
-0.6989215016365051,
-0.3794107437133789,
0.07916046679019928,
-0.32846391201019287,
-0.3579083979129791,
0.04518313705921173,
0.24026204645633698,
0.3275350332260132,
0.18277260661125183,
0.13968919217586517,
0.4702187180519104,
-0.6291255950927734,
0.6545639634132385,
-0.16091981530189514,
-0.827141284942627,
0.16442613303661346,
-0.20674560964107513,
0.10065750032663345,
0.2924260199069977,
0.38629886507987976,
-0.5617811679840088,
-0.4852921962738037,
-0.45795881748199463,
-0.49403849244117737,
0.5590345859527588,
0.3260245621204376,
0.05077511444687843,
-0.026490768417716026,
0.41166892647743225,
0.24950391054153442,
0.07414339482784271,
-0.4559119939804077,
-0.23740339279174805,
-0.0721193253993988,
-0.11336690932512283,
-0.004934834316372871,
-0.3697947859764099,
-0.2332087606191635,
-0.2585254907608032,
0.7429211735725403,
-0.4960351586341858,
-0.026684002950787544,
0.34706640243530273,
-0.30157315731048584,
-0.09477928280830383,
0.7593810558319092,
0.6973125338554382,
0.6156439185142517,
0.04775545746088028,
0.42349448800086975,
0.4455784857273102,
-0.364204466342926,
0.12891744077205658,
0.16039425134658813,
-0.44081753492355347,
0.18112389743328094,
0.35107144713401794,
0.7907067537307739,
0.29759809374809265,
-0.5148385167121887,
0.4015527665615082,
-0.23244398832321167,
-0.2636619210243225,
-0.06677189469337463,
0.11472700536251068,
0.09458265453577042,
0.26711082458496094,
0.3131493330001831,
0.23046183586120605,
0.13483116030693054,
-0.553431510925293,
0.30981072783470154,
0.5795983672142029,
-0.1966780722141266,
-0.48292675614356995,
0.5872387886047363,
-0.04002031683921814,
0.08534134924411774,
0.4963380694389343,
-0.3610456585884094,
-0.8685631155967712,
0.5661396980285645,
0.4505484104156494,
0.665494441986084,
0.008698483929038048,
0.21320100128650665,
0.4053530991077423,
0.6967767477035522,
-0.5368717908859253,
0.011019989848136902,
0.09565010666847229,
-0.7990269660949707,
-0.8971066474914551,
-0.5935308933258057,
-0.5914789438247681,
0.17992448806762695,
-0.4151885211467743,
0.44128772616386414,
-0.06931551545858383,
-0.0553131029009819,
0.12831982970237732,
-0.17643745243549347,
-0.8957302570343018,
0.25520962476730347,
0.03916361927986145,
0.8890060186386108,
-0.9825683236122131,
0.6432200074195862,
0.46777647733688354,
-0.08242814242839813,
-0.7165571451187134,
-0.0565529502928257,
-0.1148153692483902,
-0.5885151028633118,
0.5828816294670105,
0.007045922335237265,
-0.30260229110717773,
-0.10022958368062973,
-0.6025805473327637,
-0.9069204926490784,
0.8610593676567078,
0.9113662838935852,
-0.7592868804931641,
0.11774378269910812,
0.3424031138420105,
0.7619113922119141,
0.09906088560819626,
0.41779378056526184,
0.9505439400672913,
0.5924996137619019,
0.02047145739197731,
-1.2551125288009644,
0.05007593333721161,
0.08721888065338135,
-0.5104689002037048,
0.31980815529823303,
-0.9141743779182434,
0.8441046476364136,
-0.24637560546398163,
-0.20733660459518433,
-0.279565691947937,
0.8305881023406982,
0.09255558252334595,
0.0397321991622448,
0.5930135250091553,
0.5395552515983582,
0.7778701782226562,
-0.44168734550476074,
1.0865834951400757,
-0.45348942279815674,
0.7724868655204773,
0.8826728463172913,
-0.15409305691719055,
0.4979971945285797,
0.10623408854007721,
-0.23919576406478882,
0.5308059453964233,
0.40505701303482056,
-0.2011292427778244,
0.15306726098060608,
-0.08595455437898636,
-0.18269076943397522,
-0.680492103099823,
-0.4106018841266632,
-0.12261886894702911,
0.5399191379547119,
0.47461479902267456,
0.011846113950014114,
-0.4730095863342285,
-0.3904416561126709,
0.16313017904758453,
-0.0757371038198471,
0.005626834463328123,
0.5255084037780762,
-0.1632452756166458,
-1.0834749937057495,
0.6050548553466797,
0.1549587845802307,
0.7106185555458069,
-0.4606047570705414,
-0.13489505648612976,
-0.06577448546886444,
0.2725437581539154,
-0.41970619559288025,
-0.9188669323921204,
0.3316185772418976,
0.252249151468277,
-0.284298300743103,
-0.02783205173909664,
0.7987747192382812,
-0.5277978181838989,
-0.3658216595649719,
-0.096468985080719,
0.45276546478271484,
-0.31082218885421753,
-0.3979843258857727,
-0.2838175594806671,
0.05602671578526497,
-0.008435473777353764,
-0.30997151136398315,
0.09934324026107788,
0.546931266784668,
-0.21036165952682495,
0.8516412973403931,
0.5215796828269958,
-0.14001421630382538,
-0.166600301861763,
0.3126533329486847,
0.6137253046035767,
-0.3668600916862488,
-0.30792495608329773,
-0.9733567833900452,
0.4688742756843567,
0.017915578559041023,
-0.014657549560070038,
0.8121443390846252,
0.7687983512878418,
0.7787030935287476,
-0.12140873819589615,
0.9209104776382446,
-0.08940289169549942,
0.3784140944480896,
-0.5515803098678589,
0.6910998821258545,
-0.16020365059375763,
0.1021914854645729,
0.04254940524697304,
-0.7183168530464172,
-0.3827767074108124,
0.37743479013442993,
-0.11444669961929321,
-0.18337449431419373,
0.6919965744018555,
0.7981352210044861,
-0.35362520813941956,
0.22678814828395844,
0.4311070740222931,
0.4203032851219177,
0.6386469006538391,
0.2236424684524536,
0.8104788661003113,
-0.5668285489082336,
0.5162525177001953,
-0.14250726997852325,
-0.024321509525179863,
-0.08364497125148773,
-1.048915982246399,
-1.0113962888717651,
-0.4906955063343048,
-0.423875093460083,
-0.40024277567863464,
-0.3821987211704254,
0.7062525153160095,
0.7111610174179077,
-1.1059086322784424,
0.26533567905426025,
-0.03515055775642395,
0.24419954419136047,
0.040023285895586014,
-0.13489817082881927,
0.33493828773498535,
-0.41744929552078247,
-0.5995014309883118,
0.25557824969291687,
0.21577291190624237,
-0.23797720670700073,
-0.3246583640575409,
0.16002875566482544,
0.053478121757507324,
0.14094948768615723,
0.8848845958709717,
0.06018727645277977,
-0.8975959420204163,
-0.6242729425430298,
0.02269444614648819,
0.034254856407642365,
-0.12350650131702423,
1.1934536695480347,
-0.6270711421966553,
0.3225187361240387,
0.5231801867485046,
0.8033114671707153,
0.6443904042243958,
0.03207150474190712,
0.4862408936023712,
-0.6502767205238342,
-0.18715800344944,
-0.18265610933303833,
0.6705299019813538,
0.5160321593284607,
-0.3825819194316864,
0.5858278870582581,
0.16076388955116272,
-0.5687928795814514,
-0.8185091018676758,
0.37897878885269165,
-0.5757539868354797,
-0.004314938094466925,
1.0626341104507446,
-0.043540872633457184,
0.12777602672576904,
-0.40291628241539,
-0.0770096555352211,
0.4522765874862671,
-0.03444240987300873,
1.0222125053405762,
0.9330769777297974,
0.05570090562105179,
0.020345980301499367,
-0.6469216346740723,
0.7375191450119019,
0.5266204476356506,
-0.6582785844802856,
0.5212996006011963,
0.3414420783519745,
0.4085363447666168,
0.4004264175891876,
-0.08419448882341385,
-0.10142447799444199,
0.2298620492219925,
-0.2556315064430237,
-0.18598614633083344,
-0.11159636080265045,
-0.38467273116111755,
-0.109734445810318,
0.236545130610466,
0.1464192420244217,
0.40610769391059875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12146v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12146v3 | Enabling Weak LLMs to Judge Response Reliability via Meta Ranking | 2024-02-19T13:57:55 | 2024-05-31T03:25:42 | Zijun Liu, Boqun Kou, Peng Li, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Despite the strong performance of large language models (LLMs) across a wide
range of tasks, they still have reliability issues. Previous studies indicate
that strong LLMs like GPT-4-turbo excel in evaluating the reliability of
responses from LLMs, but face efficiency and local deployment issues. Thus, to
enable weak LLMs to effectively assess the reliability of LLM responses, we
propose a novel cross-query-comparison-based method called $\textit{Meta
Ranking}$ (MR). Unlike previous few-shot methods that solely based on
in-context learning capabilities in LLMs, MR assesses reliability by pairwisely
ranking the target query-response pair with multiple reference query-response
pairs. We found that MR is highly effective in error detection for LLM
responses, where weak LLMs, such as Phi-2, could surpass strong baselines like
GPT-3.5-turbo, requiring only five reference samples and significantly
improving efficiency. We further demonstrate that MR can enhance strong LLMs'
performance in two practical applications: model cascading and instruction
tuning. In model cascading, we combine open- and closed-source LLMs to achieve
performance comparable to GPT-4-turbo with lower costs. In instruction tuning,
we use MR for iterative training data filtering, significantly reducing data
processing time and enabling LLaMA-7B and Phi-2 to surpass Alpaca-13B with
fewer training tokens. These results underscore the high potential of MR in
both efficiency and effectiveness. | [
-0.3832935690879822,
-0.6465327143669128,
0.5931375026702881,
0.2476252168416977,
-0.3518303334712982,
0.24444355070590973,
-0.38160550594329834,
-0.34039241075515747,
0.15326720476150513,
0.20541943609714508,
-0.29927054047584534,
-0.6067003607749939,
-0.7583795189857483,
0.2373494803905487,
-0.16199228167533875,
1.04556405544281,
0.1673174500465393,
0.25469350814819336,
-0.3751564919948578,
-0.39676544070243835,
-0.5673990249633789,
-0.27176403999328613,
-0.6122466921806335,
-0.3423944115638733,
0.600797712802887,
0.5013631582260132,
0.7181986570358276,
0.3402875065803528,
0.8100095391273499,
0.32430997490882874,
-0.031541354954242706,
0.23857305943965912,
-0.5793272852897644,
0.033100150525569916,
-0.32460036873817444,
-0.47412049770355225,
-0.8471367955207825,
-0.05587974563241005,
0.5515575408935547,
0.5415844321250916,
-0.1790088266134262,
0.20380668342113495,
0.44014912843704224,
0.44383496046066284,
-0.8964881300926208,
0.05285635590553284,
-0.9214460849761963,
-0.17924843728542328,
-0.38122621178627014,
-0.4185609817504883,
-0.41883420944213867,
-0.4042031764984131,
-0.1584077775478363,
-0.13283926248550415,
0.1838051676750183,
-0.00005901517943129875,
0.46501046419143677,
0.292867511510849,
-0.3120623826980591,
-0.16033628582954407,
-0.6834897398948669,
0.8607062697410583,
-0.8998597264289856,
0.4295596778392792,
0.5947425961494446,
0.42563754320144653,
-0.16216106712818146,
-0.6509095430374146,
-0.3662075996398926,
-0.16183622181415558,
-0.08931451290845871,
0.2653210759162903,
0.06884369254112244,
-0.004321932327002287,
0.08800098299980164,
0.3035160005092621,
-0.7609971165657043,
0.05654387176036835,
-0.1907559335231781,
-0.2755124866962433,
0.2466222643852234,
0.261781245470047,
0.08550260961055756,
-0.09301675856113434,
-0.24295097589492798,
-0.008472012355923653,
-0.8683236837387085,
-0.18086883425712585,
0.18379609286785126,
0.5239726305007935,
0.15441618859767914,
0.6017810106277466,
-0.10391606390476227,
0.6525719165802002,
0.0969824269413948,
-0.42213088274002075,
0.31649771332740784,
-0.4646906852722168,
-0.25407546758651733,
-0.2536756694316864,
0.8020033836364746,
0.15718279778957367,
-0.02036404237151146,
-0.24353305995464325,
-0.34312641620635986,
-0.20731373131275177,
0.25654706358909607,
-0.7005607485771179,
0.09289421141147614,
-0.02161065675318241,
-0.3834947347640991,
-0.08954232186079025,
0.026549560949206352,
-0.716768741607666,
-0.1080707460641861,
0.06463067978620529,
0.5932003855705261,
-0.16670046746730804,
-0.09703177213668823,
-0.08620814234018326,
0.1856744885444641,
0.15981091558933258,
0.01831457018852234,
-0.9474717378616333,
0.2013198584318161,
0.6797370910644531,
0.867263674736023,
-0.1418238878250122,
-0.46106845140457153,
-0.8121264576911926,
0.1163019984960556,
-0.1970156878232956,
0.823772132396698,
-0.7105937600135803,
-0.35536569356918335,
-0.1536686271429062,
0.021559929475188255,
-0.18027456104755402,
-0.7451104521751404,
0.7546433806419373,
-0.5467521548271179,
0.0905819907784462,
-0.32706862688064575,
-0.22565338015556335,
0.11844948679208755,
0.435287743806839,
-0.5513224005699158,
1.1242878437042236,
0.11828477680683136,
-0.9606659412384033,
0.28063079714775085,
-0.14924034476280212,
-0.5755009055137634,
-0.16497395932674408,
-0.10371661186218262,
-0.6792014837265015,
0.10728480666875839,
0.24223089218139648,
0.4116588234901428,
-0.5125171542167664,
-0.05007459595799446,
-0.7644729018211365,
-0.7430935502052307,
-0.164798766374588,
-0.46991753578186035,
0.3642875850200653,
-0.09330630302429199,
-0.557532012462616,
0.010584725998342037,
-0.6617125868797302,
0.29165807366371155,
0.05754813179373741,
-0.6718698740005493,
-0.3699021637439728,
0.08583822101354599,
-0.4027981460094452,
0.12861628830432892,
0.15030962228775024,
-0.24025197327136993,
0.07330174744129181,
-0.39357730746269226,
0.19621407985687256,
0.5431742072105408,
-0.12363644689321518,
0.3565656840801239,
-0.08389078825712204,
0.5307143926620483,
-0.24069549143314362,
0.1989753544330597,
0.022781752049922943,
-0.513072669506073,
-0.7521084547042847,
-0.21902798116207123,
0.31461867690086365,
0.5770456790924072,
-0.7752470374107361,
0.44173765182495117,
-0.43733394145965576,
-0.42437443137168884,
-0.4990706741809845,
0.4318045973777771,
0.5608900785446167,
0.7151374816894531,
0.703537106513977,
-0.19476407766342163,
-0.4781827926635742,
-0.8233652114868164,
-0.27583274245262146,
-0.3512659966945648,
-0.05817738175392151,
0.4138798713684082,
0.4078804552555084,
-0.2447885125875473,
0.7422964572906494,
-0.26279836893081665,
-0.06302091479301453,
-0.3904563784599304,
0.21391603350639343,
0.2279110997915268,
0.10289622843265533,
0.4244990348815918,
-0.3540976047515869,
-0.3745228052139282,
-0.26739415526390076,
-0.6017257571220398,
-0.21116691827774048,
0.4598119556903839,
-0.022426970303058624,
0.1562839299440384,
0.09783037006855011,
-0.4951309561729431,
0.3751375079154968,
0.5890510678291321,
-0.06873513013124466,
0.31098952889442444,
-0.00044870961573906243,
0.33200275897979736,
-0.917427659034729,
0.14381182193756104,
-0.27368077635765076,
-0.3422071635723114,
-0.14271853864192963,
-0.11544525623321533,
0.1465476006269455,
0.08839873969554901,
-0.3980547785758972,
0.30889490246772766,
-0.3044697940349579,
-0.46564993262290955,
-0.534005343914032,
-0.011866956017911434,
-0.152220219373703,
0.3793480098247528,
-0.0409194678068161,
0.8610367774963379,
0.22499065101146698,
-0.4557490050792694,
0.23475034534931183,
0.04047521576285362,
-0.11129451543092728,
0.6772592663764954,
-0.8076184988021851,
0.30528101325035095,
0.16148126125335693,
0.4895855486392975,
-0.9356451034545898,
-0.015916205942630768,
0.15176235139369965,
-0.3326818645000458,
0.32555028796195984,
-0.4463973641395569,
-0.4692925810813904,
-0.38937246799468994,
-0.5115898251533508,
0.5152316093444824,
0.20718424022197723,
-0.6017678380012512,
0.5586095452308655,
-0.012721349485218525,
-0.13795392215251923,
-0.9114199876785278,
-0.6988005638122559,
0.09641733020544052,
-0.051797252148389816,
-0.5839616060256958,
0.19970859587192535,
-0.11369409412145615,
0.07459084689617157,
0.05243782326579094,
-0.34321293234825134,
0.08872038871049881,
0.1552201360464096,
0.05244597792625427,
0.11301752924919128,
-0.2668686807155609,
0.06253854185342789,
-0.06013137102127075,
-0.3006872534751892,
-0.07164984196424484,
-0.13211588561534882,
0.4007556140422821,
-0.20966912806034088,
-0.6325360536575317,
0.013543807901442051,
0.05383443459868431,
0.7884731292724609,
-0.29679402709007263,
0.7585523128509521,
0.663294792175293,
-0.1479644477367401,
-0.34665486216545105,
-0.4906467795372009,
-0.3552177846431732,
-0.4614158570766449,
0.20977170765399933,
-0.3453618884086609,
-0.8013669848442078,
0.2828432321548462,
-0.00983472727239132,
-0.05746109411120415,
0.37807023525238037,
0.583648681640625,
-0.08461634069681168,
0.8910598158836365,
0.48392558097839355,
-0.37554696202278137,
0.24647046625614166,
-0.09977857768535614,
0.09436200559139252,
-0.7063050866127014,
-0.24988162517547607,
-0.6249361634254456,
-0.41944727301597595,
-0.4868749678134918,
-0.4634911119937897,
0.6432070136070251,
0.06523320823907852,
-0.2611040771007538,
0.253222793340683,
-0.24847093224525452,
0.6632968187332153,
0.4363027513027191,
0.2632571756839752,
0.4742666184902191,
-0.13612864911556244,
-0.33345136046409607,
0.053440310060977936,
-0.626041829586029,
-0.4622967541217804,
1.2631226778030396,
0.2600499391555786,
0.9952952265739441,
0.17694708704948425,
0.5792398452758789,
0.08607056736946106,
0.4382922053337097,
-0.604648232460022,
0.6002007126808167,
-0.12610962986946106,
-0.4469274878501892,
-0.24932193756103516,
-0.7280765175819397,
-0.695803701877594,
0.310308575630188,
-0.18383190035820007,
-0.2110128551721573,
-0.1377428025007248,
0.06200769171118736,
-0.2648233473300934,
0.3758177161216736,
-0.4240638017654419,
0.6940985918045044,
-0.5105628371238708,
-0.6928731799125671,
-0.24362432956695557,
-0.6070590615272522,
0.6257324814796448,
-0.08236104995012283,
-0.06654725223779678,
-0.10646022111177444,
-0.16404694318771362,
0.4711448848247528,
-0.5955231785774231,
0.756668210029602,
-0.017880357801914215,
-0.027187654748558998,
0.17001661658287048,
-0.06841307878494263,
0.5868051648139954,
0.18901631236076355,
-0.28419360518455505,
0.16700708866119385,
-0.35826951265335083,
-0.48264482617378235,
-0.890038251876831,
0.9794837832450867,
-0.5278409719467163,
-0.4603242874145508,
-0.4076545536518097,
-0.1905204802751541,
-0.5474100708961487,
0.13934221863746643,
0.2798357903957367,
0.24616344273090363,
0.021971235051751137,
0.4027360677719116,
0.6239011883735657,
-0.1280682533979416,
0.4564407765865326,
0.7424730658531189,
-0.01825793646275997,
-0.6841611266136169,
0.7591359615325928,
0.13066036999225616,
0.22913271188735962,
0.44806066155433655,
0.1789764165878296,
-0.40287691354751587,
-0.7313921451568604,
-0.40187209844589233,
0.2037155032157898,
-0.6574928760528564,
-0.584673285484314,
-0.40319496393203735,
-0.19819730520248413,
-0.17179100215435028,
0.224501833319664,
-0.598392128944397,
-0.26606810092926025,
0.02429385855793953,
-0.1810348778963089,
0.06386484205722809,
0.636359691619873,
0.002861040411517024,
0.0694439634680748,
-0.7231097221374512,
0.26426637172698975,
0.5644081830978394,
0.5969422459602356,
-0.022125383839011192,
-0.5996169447898865,
-0.42697274684906006,
-0.16732627153396606,
-0.5290489196777344,
-0.7349891662597656,
-0.05434070900082588,
0.2252005636692047,
0.7312435507774353,
0.24763110280036926,
-0.10785066336393356,
0.707944929599762,
-0.4666421711444855,
0.6367506980895996,
-0.23369373381137848,
-0.8921239376068115,
0.7023413777351379,
-0.2837616801261902,
0.2658236026763916,
0.8110818862915039,
0.41335511207580566,
0.06843335181474686,
-0.5172444581985474,
-0.3518807590007782,
-0.9055589437484741,
0.5235533714294434,
0.25223779678344727,
-0.041367869824171066,
-0.08189937472343445,
0.517185389995575,
-0.06948348134756088,
0.14122143387794495,
-0.6081863045692444,
-0.28504008054733276,
-0.26313045620918274,
-0.1039818599820137,
-0.17753441631793976,
-0.24652637541294098,
-0.038045793771743774,
-0.21375583112239838,
0.7078200578689575,
-0.3462370038032532,
0.22211603820323944,
-0.08589502424001694,
-0.1727415770292282,
-0.1460026353597641,
0.3325115144252777,
0.6538891196250916,
0.7506958842277527,
-0.44216957688331604,
0.4575304388999939,
0.5415453910827637,
-0.3832259476184845,
0.2043227255344391,
-0.118867427110672,
0.07056693732738495,
0.01894373446702957,
0.6500152349472046,
0.5158881545066833,
0.6153711676597595,
-0.31996509432792664,
0.5641278028488159,
-0.06429507583379745,
0.1845078021287918,
0.31347331404685974,
0.05619555711746216,
0.19063222408294678,
0.172285258769989,
0.3673560917377472,
-0.047078054398298264,
0.15045976638793945,
-0.5743188858032227,
0.33908626437187195,
0.6524390578269958,
-0.003808829002082348,
-0.3862602114677429,
0.5142466425895691,
0.39557868242263794,
-0.07207454741001129,
0.501010000705719,
-0.1831246316432953,
-0.5557530522346497,
0.457550972700119,
0.6623238921165466,
0.829748809337616,
-0.4063066840171814,
0.022381536662578583,
0.5028679966926575,
0.5616481304168701,
-0.2918296158313751,
0.28849539160728455,
-0.09970851242542267,
-0.46075883507728577,
-0.4157654941082001,
-0.5486355423927307,
-0.7427048683166504,
0.28818899393081665,
-0.522634744644165,
0.30302315950393677,
-0.5419934391975403,
-0.33936992287635803,
-0.5650930404663086,
0.09096816182136536,
-0.5443620085716248,
0.24633334577083588,
-0.00661518843844533,
0.8287249803543091,
-0.8496279120445251,
0.7120752930641174,
0.6282745599746704,
-0.44200173020362854,
-0.7038753628730774,
0.2550305426120758,
0.028475843369960785,
-0.7243642807006836,
0.5396037697792053,
0.07750705629587173,
-0.4978587031364441,
-0.3411056101322174,
-0.2911020815372467,
-0.8876786231994629,
1.3286455869674683,
0.6709541082382202,
-0.6432918906211853,
0.2806502878665924,
0.210378497838974,
0.4691815972328186,
-0.14929325878620148,
0.8894398808479309,
0.5814310312271118,
0.5170089602470398,
0.31210649013519287,
-1.1236003637313843,
0.09378495067358017,
-0.013503371737897396,
-0.169094055891037,
0.21319591999053955,
-0.9054352045059204,
0.48038312792778015,
-0.19898276031017303,
-0.025994516909122467,
-0.10587064921855927,
0.6414596438407898,
0.42820650339126587,
0.5932243466377258,
0.48032256960868835,
0.800735354423523,
0.7995368838310242,
-0.04786650463938713,
0.8695463538169861,
-0.33355847001075745,
0.38103142380714417,
1.2689871788024902,
-0.331493616104126,
1.157683253288269,
0.16374796628952026,
-0.175315722823143,
0.5519134998321533,
0.545209527015686,
0.18179918825626373,
0.6065887808799744,
0.028470998629927635,
-0.23889684677124023,
-0.3567422330379486,
0.18473339080810547,
-0.43932196497917175,
0.47385168075561523,
0.08598466962575912,
-0.3594370186328888,
-0.41665393114089966,
-0.12685315310955048,
-0.03786405548453331,
-0.2920911908149719,
-0.19997438788414001,
0.5531098246574402,
0.2574503719806671,
-0.5454122424125671,
0.7943955659866333,
0.11020522564649582,
0.7063074111938477,
-0.6572913527488708,
0.04929041862487793,
-0.6329438090324402,
0.2179916501045227,
-0.43933624029159546,
-0.6223465800285339,
0.48355552554130554,
0.1602410525083542,
-0.3938816785812378,
0.06520109623670578,
0.8483521342277527,
-0.3020787537097931,
-0.4911656379699707,
0.47549673914909363,
0.5817146301269531,
0.07189150154590607,
0.030000785365700722,
-0.6956539750099182,
0.3641732931137085,
-0.4195951819419861,
-0.3772256672382355,
0.4901156723499298,
0.201481431722641,
0.004259246867150068,
0.8291932940483093,
0.38934633135795593,
0.0869927778840065,
-0.08345046639442444,
0.0753902941942215,
0.798294723033905,
-0.5780067443847656,
-0.006072131916880608,
-0.9493380784988403,
0.26784515380859375,
0.19218158721923828,
-0.13996991515159607,
0.7623599767684937,
0.633572518825531,
0.6961851716041565,
0.2967996299266815,
0.8073465824127197,
0.2022572159767151,
0.4154631197452545,
-0.5877697467803955,
0.5219352841377258,
-0.5213744640350342,
0.7508150935173035,
-0.18103010952472687,
-1.1752753257751465,
-0.3198106586933136,
0.39778685569763184,
-0.4614160358905792,
0.44660744071006775,
0.7581255435943604,
0.885185956954956,
-0.4783059358596802,
-0.31700754165649414,
0.31663715839385986,
0.17437060177326202,
0.1760488748550415,
0.7227545976638794,
0.7605114579200745,
-0.32064270973205566,
0.9837900996208191,
-0.03964545205235481,
-0.2495974749326706,
-0.258105993270874,
-0.894607663154602,
-0.967125654220581,
-0.08962016552686691,
-0.02011856622993946,
-0.47899651527404785,
0.19186775386333466,
0.7045958638191223,
0.8737438321113586,
-0.6560516953468323,
-0.048152998089790344,
0.1532318890094757,
0.42987751960754395,
-0.11999378353357315,
-0.19626261293888092,
0.33530640602111816,
-0.6647621393203735,
-0.6202018857002258,
0.8581283688545227,
0.3770976960659027,
-0.17552584409713745,
-0.41203686594963074,
-0.23964273929595947,
0.1556715965270996,
0.1724861115217209,
0.496825248003006,
0.20924179255962372,
-0.5032407641410828,
-0.1969335824251175,
-0.07277218252420425,
-0.25016161799430847,
0.04890710487961769,
0.8341397643089294,
-0.7779927253723145,
0.13259583711624146,
0.6308130025863647,
0.8036487102508545,
0.3455379605293274,
0.090455561876297,
0.4685693383216858,
-0.6983214020729065,
-0.3191918134689331,
0.285593181848526,
0.3519152104854584,
0.47951096296310425,
-0.1279406100511551,
0.745520830154419,
0.4069785475730896,
-0.6853997111320496,
-0.7371233701705933,
0.01841905526816845,
-0.8126325607299805,
-0.041160713881254196,
1.1670782566070557,
-0.27334725856781006,
0.0008950935443863273,
-0.022794529795646667,
0.12122482806444168,
0.03199412673711777,
-0.25938934087753296,
0.8143793344497681,
0.6084791421890259,
-0.17650863528251648,
-0.13374093174934387,
-0.4725038409233093,
0.3073066473007202,
0.5721794962882996,
-0.8905439376831055,
-0.15181633830070496,
0.1425020694732666,
0.6365801095962524,
-0.009328098967671394,
0.6349734663963318,
-0.12103794515132904,
0.1849033087491989,
-0.3040373623371124,
-0.3096421957015991,
-0.11983469128608704,
-0.4734788239002228,
-0.2920435070991516,
0.3452732563018799,
0.145210400223732,
-0.2520233392715454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12121v1 | Evaluating Image Review Ability of Vision Language Models | 2024-02-19T13:16:10 | 2024-02-19T13:16:10 | Shigeki Saito, Kazuki Hayashi, Yusuke Ide, Yusuke Sakai, Kazuma Onishi, Toma Suzuki, Seiji Gobara, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Katsuhiko Hayashi, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.MM | Large-scale vision language models (LVLMs) are language models that are
capable of processing images and text inputs by a single model. This paper
explores the use of LVLMs to generate review texts for images. The ability of
LVLMs to review images is not fully understood, highlighting the need for a
methodical evaluation of their review abilities. Unlike image captions, review
texts can be written from various perspectives such as image composition and
exposure. This diversity of review perspectives makes it difficult to uniquely
determine a single correct review for an image. To address this challenge, we
introduce an evaluation method based on rank correlation analysis, in which
review texts are ranked by humans and LVLMs, then, measures the correlation
between these rankings. We further validate this approach by creating a
benchmark dataset aimed at assessing the image review ability of recent LVLMs.
Our experiments with the dataset reveal that LVLMs, particularly those with
proven superiority in other evaluative contexts, excel at distinguishing
between high-quality and substandard image reviews. | [
-0.38104429841041565,
-0.3128162622451782,
0.45569688081741333,
0.18118537962436676,
-0.558831512928009,
0.07988070696592331,
-0.10070081055164337,
-0.6204729080200195,
-0.1019257977604866,
0.7561541795730591,
0.08996077626943588,
-0.6171305775642395,
-0.4236941933631897,
0.12348715960979462,
-0.7078198194503784,
0.992608368396759,
-0.020654883235692978,
0.3057881295681,
-0.5461639165878296,
-0.3555082380771637,
-0.560060441493988,
-0.33771634101867676,
-0.500143826007843,
-0.07379329204559326,
0.5771864056587219,
-0.2055605798959732,
0.8496255278587341,
0.13432173430919647,
1.3511099815368652,
0.2979110777378082,
-0.24648012220859528,
0.4738200306892395,
-0.63870769739151,
0.082744300365448,
0.054924555122852325,
-0.1175108477473259,
-0.38151776790618896,
-0.053248874843120575,
0.9516736268997192,
0.46475037932395935,
0.13898591697216034,
0.32662349939346313,
0.08446485549211502,
1.0933107137680054,
-0.6442398428916931,
0.1083231121301651,
-0.6545274257659912,
0.20122428238391876,
-0.005045259837061167,
-0.3046928346157074,
-0.5171580910682678,
-0.5269243717193604,
0.2572598457336426,
-0.265937477350235,
-0.032164398580789566,
0.24723055958747864,
0.8439128994941711,
0.1746491640806198,
-0.06299532949924469,
-0.1487978994846344,
-0.6092224717140198,
0.8042075037956238,
-0.6245455145835876,
0.474452942609787,
0.2115325927734375,
0.41769710183143616,
0.1266314536333084,
-0.5226906538009644,
-0.46455076336860657,
-0.42373448610305786,
-0.23551493883132935,
0.3091672956943512,
-0.021866802126169205,
-0.24892032146453857,
0.07651284337043762,
0.47549575567245483,
-0.3488406836986542,
0.11610078811645508,
-0.539275050163269,
-0.04427511617541313,
0.7741820216178894,
0.3057189881801605,
0.14472413063049316,
-0.23529407382011414,
-0.5397372245788574,
-0.45975878834724426,
-0.46867260336875916,
0.4743369221687317,
0.1425970494747162,
-0.11369822919368744,
0.23348961770534515,
0.6167444586753845,
-0.182401642203331,
1.005957007408142,
-0.33340802788734436,
-0.5120811462402344,
0.2858346104621887,
-0.431123822927475,
-0.4468768835067749,
-0.469209760427475,
0.9732481837272644,
1.131961464881897,
0.1678398996591568,
0.048613835126161575,
-0.6192554831504822,
-0.05904385820031166,
0.37229281663894653,
-0.7264924049377441,
0.1650945544242859,
0.19585217535495758,
-1.0006611347198486,
-0.7710426449775696,
0.20294028520584106,
-0.8931447863578796,
-0.8011247515678406,
-0.17731916904449463,
0.5806375741958618,
-0.1117900088429451,
0.047337014228105545,
0.011940629221498966,
-0.14770324528217316,
0.22749552130699158,
0.4259897470474243,
-0.4562614858150482,
0.1037149578332901,
0.40342751145362854,
0.6539181470870972,
-0.5697308778762817,
-0.506747841835022,
-0.5077280402183533,
-0.4034730792045593,
-0.6890983581542969,
1.0441172122955322,
-0.3804282546043396,
-0.4774543046951294,
0.2557445466518402,
-0.21992148458957672,
0.14016343653202057,
-0.6583477258682251,
0.4962853789329529,
-0.7437258958816528,
-0.07655461132526398,
-0.012316754087805748,
-0.3768550455570221,
0.028293687850236893,
0.28333359956741333,
-0.7901456356048584,
0.9822092056274414,
0.01312216091901064,
-0.9203582406044006,
0.5866125226020813,
-0.24328996241092682,
-0.2808707654476166,
0.3218381106853485,
-0.3248847723007202,
-0.8562479615211487,
0.20901800692081451,
0.48508739471435547,
0.5530388355255127,
-0.4261399507522583,
0.20032478868961334,
-0.12802961468696594,
-0.48735421895980835,
0.4688700735569,
-0.15629291534423828,
0.4441012144088745,
0.09422943741083145,
0.03966214135289192,
0.41012752056121826,
-0.7025717496871948,
0.18064886331558228,
0.09557189047336578,
-0.2668486535549164,
-0.5753975510597229,
0.26555201411247253,
-0.03189669921994209,
-0.13797634840011597,
0.21133632957935333,
-0.3345736265182495,
0.011420666240155697,
-0.03399667516350746,
0.054509520530700684,
0.574652373790741,
0.11810965090990067,
0.2938856780529022,
-0.2015438973903656,
0.25121015310287476,
-0.036291785538196564,
0.5831928253173828,
-0.3992457687854767,
-0.6673482060432434,
-0.9356529712677002,
0.0058763944543898106,
0.09866481274366379,
0.35451459884643555,
-0.9213507771492004,
0.28968775272369385,
-0.4472922682762146,
-0.739310622215271,
-0.6759403944015503,
0.30202868580818176,
0.8228529095649719,
0.2875092923641205,
0.33693742752075195,
-0.7863379716873169,
-0.2537539005279541,
-1.0332181453704834,
-0.15147234499454498,
-0.3720742166042328,
0.1019422858953476,
0.4956994950771332,
0.424023300409317,
-0.025948384776711464,
0.6645689010620117,
-0.339327871799469,
-0.5304164886474609,
0.023290032520890236,
0.055525775998830795,
0.07121434062719345,
0.10400441288948059,
0.5044475793838501,
-0.7738732099533081,
-0.3291330337524414,
0.22060100734233856,
-1.003978967666626,
0.04956657811999321,
-0.04136067256331444,
0.017714371904730797,
0.2910816967487335,
0.5378298759460449,
-0.0017500694375485182,
0.6342569589614868,
0.6702880859375,
-0.24435408413410187,
0.5465901494026184,
-0.32672619819641113,
0.5937414765357971,
-0.4282640814781189,
-0.0026713130064308643,
0.18562771379947662,
-0.13936373591423035,
-0.4079815149307251,
0.37744104862213135,
0.07545678317546844,
-0.008484386838972569,
-0.41295912861824036,
0.3473672866821289,
-0.4573926031589508,
-0.5837121605873108,
-0.05616283789277077,
0.06312711536884308,
0.07925782352685928,
0.07408640533685684,
0.30956652760505676,
0.5305865406990051,
0.6116726398468018,
-0.34303534030914307,
0.5306708216667175,
0.14557257294654846,
-1.0581821203231812,
0.7356593608856201,
-0.6155836582183838,
-0.015122713521122932,
-0.25785186886787415,
-0.020530033856630325,
-1.1404476165771484,
0.05840904638171196,
-0.22240707278251648,
-0.18627972900867462,
-0.04108308255672455,
0.10016998648643494,
-0.45844629406929016,
-0.586769163608551,
-0.2949400544166565,
0.26144471764564514,
0.7147020697593689,
-0.5698944926261902,
0.28368261456489563,
0.44220367074012756,
0.10732221603393555,
-0.5419021844863892,
-0.4205337464809418,
0.1566886454820633,
0.07757864147424698,
-0.5205573439598083,
-0.04709314554929733,
-0.026769232004880905,
-0.5235023498535156,
0.016835961490869522,
0.22134627401828766,
-0.026546137407422066,
-0.27283939719200134,
0.25273218750953674,
0.43246516585350037,
-0.057644858956336975,
-0.04696327820420265,
-0.5547462701797485,
0.15340834856033325,
-0.2044479101896286,
0.10285039246082306,
0.19436651468276978,
-0.39436236023902893,
-0.3268802762031555,
-0.28050750494003296,
0.039072804152965546,
0.7873445749282837,
-0.46259260177612305,
0.29308682680130005,
0.5495818853378296,
0.0822090432047844,
-0.16691291332244873,
-0.7778887748718262,
0.040362872183322906,
-0.35739925503730774,
0.5062242746353149,
-0.23964866995811462,
-0.539196789264679,
0.34337571263313293,
0.5076795816421509,
0.14738185703754425,
0.35176077485084534,
0.6253871917724609,
-0.3893674910068512,
0.7903061509132385,
0.48546677827835083,
0.13589179515838623,
0.5241373777389526,
-0.09022892266511917,
0.20802704989910126,
-0.8868483304977417,
-0.3708272874355316,
-0.2004910707473755,
-0.2575482726097107,
-0.3557868003845215,
-0.7078439593315125,
0.5474277138710022,
-0.1885164976119995,
0.15072889626026154,
0.12122318148612976,
-0.6912090182304382,
0.729779839515686,
0.44963905215263367,
0.3006431758403778,
0.46766436100006104,
0.3179175555706024,
-0.12518881261348724,
-0.04393641650676727,
-0.26039668917655945,
-0.5391987562179565,
1.1064597368240356,
0.49647217988967896,
0.9116086363792419,
-0.2987520396709442,
0.4220872223377228,
0.40705016255378723,
0.425169438123703,
-0.8178026080131531,
0.8052617311477661,
-0.4954203963279724,
-0.1540083885192871,
-0.45168328285217285,
-0.10297811031341553,
-0.7236676216125488,
0.5550867319107056,
-0.571699321269989,
-0.44799771904945374,
0.03149886801838875,
-0.10870678722858429,
-0.11493543535470963,
0.374345600605011,
-0.3808746039867401,
0.6307346224784851,
-0.3937778174877167,
-0.4800877571105957,
-0.21756592392921448,
-0.5488259196281433,
0.5660855770111084,
-0.28045105934143066,
0.3054153621196747,
0.12248366326093674,
0.19636468589305878,
0.8028364181518555,
-0.26571303606033325,
0.7041292190551758,
0.17908073961734772,
-0.2417934238910675,
0.44875144958496094,
0.20002080500125885,
0.010568800382316113,
-0.20248381793498993,
0.02812322974205017,
0.3691742718219757,
0.12433694303035736,
0.015913208946585655,
-0.5409800410270691,
0.5918814539909363,
-0.7686156034469604,
-0.3652326166629791,
-0.33257976174354553,
-0.3893645107746124,
-0.18984581530094147,
0.11336543411016464,
0.0786757692694664,
0.4815126061439514,
-0.06955403089523315,
0.3968188166618347,
0.31816911697387695,
-0.42809826135635376,
0.4493468701839447,
0.472842812538147,
-0.8985656499862671,
-0.5712383985519409,
0.9167886972427368,
-0.004773250315338373,
0.298050194978714,
0.35380375385284424,
0.1856582909822464,
-0.11936091631650925,
-0.7247646450996399,
-0.42659732699394226,
-0.025188392028212547,
-1.0567137002944946,
-0.14712019264698029,
-0.30098214745521545,
-0.45580369234085083,
-0.020106932148337364,
0.05024519935250282,
-0.3932492434978485,
0.046537090092897415,
0.2534236013889313,
0.3898530602455139,
-0.046703238040208817,
1.1018917560577393,
0.4750044643878937,
-0.04891559109091759,
-0.6053646206855774,
0.4345109164714813,
0.5893396139144897,
0.47949445247650146,
0.1906462460756302,
-0.3868742287158966,
-0.2288714051246643,
-0.4241493046283722,
-0.23521773517131805,
-0.6732786893844604,
0.43141061067581177,
-0.11447162181138992,
0.6791075468063354,
0.2893493175506592,
-0.24915435910224915,
0.621403694152832,
-0.5712475776672363,
1.1240683794021606,
0.34721270203590393,
-0.674913227558136,
0.469871461391449,
-0.06459709256887436,
0.15180842578411102,
0.33391040563583374,
-0.03155803680419922,
-0.24785494804382324,
-0.6253266930580139,
-0.29174530506134033,
-0.6631207466125488,
0.1836111843585968,
0.4855688512325287,
-0.09004215896129608,
0.32312852144241333,
0.06660544872283936,
-0.07349805533885956,
0.275043249130249,
-0.9137625694274902,
-0.04922940954566002,
-0.21835453808307648,
0.21725299954414368,
-0.20843321084976196,
-0.43997424840927124,
-0.27433425188064575,
-0.2532021105289459,
0.3582003712654114,
0.0226319320499897,
0.11672165244817734,
0.3410550057888031,
-0.1316782832145691,
-0.19111160933971405,
0.10715262591838837,
0.6075461506843567,
0.7977567911148071,
-0.38157063722610474,
0.1553395837545395,
-0.02859792672097683,
-0.516262948513031,
-0.07779494673013687,
-0.5511388182640076,
-0.34078460931777954,
0.1229202076792717,
0.6188378930091858,
0.8764224648475647,
0.08086229860782623,
-0.6723448038101196,
0.8028032183647156,
-0.3775951862335205,
-0.17549081146717072,
-0.05162370577454567,
-0.17004971206188202,
-0.1891777217388153,
0.02601766586303711,
0.33574000000953674,
0.24491624534130096,
0.17100036144256592,
-0.3153854012489319,
0.08203154057264328,
0.6005392074584961,
-0.4228600561618805,
0.08905567228794098,
0.31912532448768616,
0.35378411412239075,
-0.22662167251110077,
0.5182559490203857,
0.16290594637393951,
-0.40358301997184753,
0.7944793105125427,
0.23934930562973022,
0.7187835574150085,
0.07494542747735977,
0.17876224219799042,
0.6476207971572876,
0.5293782353401184,
-0.06805772334337234,
0.07757418602705002,
0.21076437830924988,
-0.768225908279419,
-0.2980954945087433,
-0.9287582039833069,
-0.6061804890632629,
0.2250194251537323,
-0.6766538023948669,
0.3618694543838501,
-0.32207241654396057,
-0.18482428789138794,
0.15459305047988892,
-0.43750327825546265,
-0.6966009736061096,
0.5175254940986633,
0.3398873209953308,
0.5940611958503723,
-0.8540335297584534,
0.6223230957984924,
0.622791588306427,
-0.6053935885429382,
-0.5208832025527954,
-0.027273669838905334,
-0.3310939073562622,
-0.9866337776184082,
1.1309962272644043,
0.19978821277618408,
-0.3207959234714508,
-0.3061034679412842,
-0.554088830947876,
-0.5671831369400024,
0.919003963470459,
-0.23920443654060364,
-0.5478618144989014,
0.31494036316871643,
-0.0959642082452774,
1.0113133192062378,
-0.6023514270782471,
0.3694992959499359,
0.346419095993042,
0.26215142011642456,
0.1652289777994156,
-1.1046874523162842,
-0.30394992232322693,
-0.25423967838287354,
0.42661914229393005,
-0.22100061178207397,
-0.6168672442436218,
0.7807598114013672,
-0.4021874666213989,
-0.1151546984910965,
0.31004589796066284,
0.38760119676589966,
0.30208081007003784,
0.15299418568611145,
0.7298957705497742,
0.3598580062389374,
0.37974560260772705,
0.042861055582761765,
1.383250117301941,
-0.19519269466400146,
0.5092425346374512,
0.8261193633079529,
-0.4156183898448944,
1.467387318611145,
0.6488887071609497,
-0.3199208974838257,
0.5408020615577698,
0.3649578392505646,
-0.42513319849967957,
0.6316460967063904,
0.23745647072792053,
0.10494183748960495,
-0.38751935958862305,
-0.16623474657535553,
-0.2069934457540512,
0.4139336347579956,
0.03932510316371918,
-0.7357543110847473,
0.011029830202460289,
-0.00039169672527350485,
-0.6835392713546753,
0.17291440069675446,
-0.6717720031738281,
0.9109576940536499,
-0.034163910895586014,
-1.0085256099700928,
0.7025775909423828,
-0.3355756402015686,
0.47120577096939087,
-0.23594804108142853,
-0.056526560336351395,
-0.017923908308148384,
0.2264602929353714,
-0.35025742650032043,
-1.4374231100082397,
0.05310818925499916,
0.15397155284881592,
-0.1535540521144867,
-0.2392905354499817,
0.7196176648139954,
-0.20115675032138824,
-0.7676268219947815,
0.38965916633605957,
0.406586617231369,
0.4274331331253052,
0.4044191539287567,
-0.5152648091316223,
0.37771156430244446,
-0.05954912677407265,
-0.10012667626142502,
0.17972058057785034,
-0.25476518273353577,
-0.2859302759170532,
0.6679897904396057,
0.6519508957862854,
0.3128020167350769,
-0.065413698554039,
0.4211254417896271,
0.6647207736968994,
-0.3936759829521179,
-0.4046515226364136,
-0.7426757216453552,
0.5675172805786133,
-0.3046620488166809,
-0.2656586468219757,
0.6447248458862305,
0.5102910399436951,
0.6818117499351501,
-0.3918151557445526,
0.7479292750358582,
0.2111060619354248,
0.35063061118125916,
-0.6460397243499756,
0.8278318047523499,
-0.6871234178543091,
0.30658242106437683,
-0.4293863773345947,
-0.962464451789856,
-0.6549012064933777,
0.9265025854110718,
-0.35801172256469727,
-0.10662999749183655,
0.9318163990974426,
0.749504566192627,
0.19448132812976837,
-0.20775346457958221,
0.8133563995361328,
0.18349778652191162,
0.2121160924434662,
0.40975135564804077,
1.0859692096710205,
-0.5654328465461731,
0.5761682987213135,
-0.20503419637680054,
-0.15439444780349731,
-0.1938590705394745,
-1.2210018634796143,
-1.2862926721572876,
-0.6518750190734863,
-0.2867513597011566,
-0.5796433687210083,
-0.012758822180330753,
0.2911907732486725,
0.6015530824661255,
-0.7152782082557678,
-0.3509514629840851,
0.22469203174114227,
0.0935993641614914,
-0.26200374960899353,
-0.1555054485797882,
0.5750258564949036,
-0.31799575686454773,
-0.7283297181129456,
0.019199363887310028,
0.5611061453819275,
0.013111788779497147,
-0.8500576019287109,
-0.13749763369560242,
0.40606576204299927,
-0.07253177464008331,
0.7325166463851929,
-0.14819687604904175,
-1.0674769878387451,
-0.10833215713500977,
-0.20819668471813202,
-0.4722515046596527,
0.10328695178031921,
0.6671005487442017,
-0.6507512927055359,
1.0112756490707397,
0.6741223931312561,
0.4166766405105591,
0.18698008358478546,
-0.12284335494041443,
0.24431294202804565,
-0.44032832980155945,
0.025905460119247437,
0.022879863157868385,
0.6284029483795166,
0.5500180721282959,
-0.02686549350619316,
0.4954777956008911,
0.10561966896057129,
-0.7463542819023132,
-0.874341607093811,
0.007925250567495823,
-1.3448470830917358,
-0.02308070845901966,
1.4431264400482178,
-0.17941920459270477,
-0.413883239030838,
0.3582923710346222,
-0.5474303364753723,
-0.40127676725387573,
-0.017279891297221184,
0.7408424615859985,
0.7449849247932434,
0.10244514793157578,
-0.3671993017196655,
-0.44429486989974976,
0.4173806607723236,
0.20029409229755402,
-0.8507375121116638,
-0.14074259996414185,
0.40787240862846375,
0.288114994764328,
0.45200538635253906,
0.5590176582336426,
-0.45642805099487305,
0.42497721314430237,
-0.17947980761528015,
0.17032675445079803,
0.09298893809318542,
-0.13598157465457916,
-0.3973424732685089,
0.3302256464958191,
0.19841860234737396,
-0.1277269870042801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12102v1 | Is It a Free Lunch for Removing Outliers during Pretraining? | 2024-02-19T12:45:52 | 2024-02-19T12:45:52 | Baohao Liao, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the growing size of large language models, the role of quantization
becomes increasingly significant. However, outliers present in weights or
activations notably influence the performance of quantized models. Recently,
\citet{qtransformer} introduced a novel softmax function aimed at pretraining
models in an outlier-free manner, thereby enhancing their suitability for
quantization. Interestingly, we observed that such an approach leads to
performance degradation in full precision. Building on this insight, we enhance
the method by ensuring its normalization is invariant to sequence length, a
crucial factor for bridging the gap between pretraining and fine-tuning.
Moreover, this improved method also facilitates successful pretraining of
causal language models. | [
0.0527002215385437,
-0.6223016381263733,
0.4036221206188202,
-0.0028023775666952133,
-0.4261420667171478,
-0.28357386589050293,
-0.2545522451400757,
0.06937726587057114,
-0.12367769330739975,
0.3681359887123108,
-0.38594764471054077,
-0.18105533719062805,
-0.7158486247062683,
-0.2088712751865387,
-0.574368417263031,
1.2850408554077148,
0.05618960037827492,
0.22936798632144928,
-0.3483472466468811,
-0.2855537533760071,
-0.3204002380371094,
-0.3441527187824249,
-0.6876330375671387,
-0.13880321383476257,
0.47995465993881226,
0.42424944043159485,
0.8831907510757446,
0.8184250593185425,
0.16716618835926056,
0.2991194725036621,
0.003168209921568632,
-0.2211609184741974,
-0.5314769744873047,
0.17792727053165436,
0.24565958976745605,
-0.9022632241249084,
-0.386406809091568,
0.02004552073776722,
1.0713273286819458,
0.7639231085777283,
-0.19589345157146454,
0.13980405032634735,
0.41714027523994446,
0.8327518105506897,
-0.742292046546936,
-0.02698133885860443,
-0.24442780017852783,
-0.0050322068855166435,
-0.6129692196846008,
-0.1246948391199112,
-0.3310167193412781,
-0.6580535173416138,
-0.0707608312368393,
-0.7812985777854919,
0.3403192162513733,
-0.3040219843387604,
0.9248910546302795,
0.4619584381580353,
-0.4895058572292328,
0.271191269159317,
-0.7443098425865173,
0.7522991299629211,
-0.6709842681884766,
0.36335405707359314,
0.28491201996803284,
0.25419631600379944,
-0.16679303348064423,
-0.7713013887405396,
-0.49361005425453186,
0.23628704249858856,
-0.06713217496871948,
-0.26617535948753357,
-0.16813157498836517,
0.16559143364429474,
0.3660367727279663,
0.48134559392929077,
-0.872482419013977,
0.12396371364593506,
-0.3568030595779419,
-0.11366389691829681,
0.5166748762130737,
-0.10290700197219849,
0.2642829120159149,
0.2800925672054291,
0.022802293300628662,
-0.1908417046070099,
-0.9204164147377014,
0.26026079058647156,
0.39744460582733154,
0.1996629536151886,
0.21204784512519836,
0.24741514027118683,
-0.22513052821159363,
0.4976711571216583,
-0.18178969621658325,
0.15953329205513,
0.2764885723590851,
-0.22763970494270325,
-0.25055429339408875,
0.012094758450984955,
0.5467232465744019,
0.06599094718694687,
0.8267173171043396,
-0.26564136147499084,
-0.3846251666545868,
-0.31338489055633545,
-0.13263574242591858,
-1.0817863941192627,
-0.4201997220516205,
0.0398872047662735,
-0.44189345836639404,
0.004681886173784733,
0.03200709819793701,
-0.24693767726421356,
-0.18352214992046356,
-0.11741622537374496,
0.8844372630119324,
-0.4438880980014801,
-0.30564120411872864,
0.19587312638759613,
-0.29898083209991455,
-0.03853346034884453,
-0.08736727386713028,
-0.8474954962730408,
0.44925040006637573,
0.535197913646698,
0.7690936923027039,
0.37538468837738037,
-0.14028728008270264,
-0.965117335319519,
0.19733558595180511,
-0.2858763039112091,
0.5454981327056885,
-0.36469924449920654,
-0.34660398960113525,
-0.21094270050525665,
0.1454971879720688,
-0.17548255622386932,
-0.7270038723945618,
0.24416205286979675,
-0.7279894948005676,
0.07562528550624847,
-0.28114619851112366,
-0.789434015750885,
-0.23034189641475677,
-0.0653771460056305,
-0.6801096200942993,
0.7588405013084412,
0.41468489170074463,
-0.3851466476917267,
0.5621674656867981,
-0.5809455513954163,
-0.4266890585422516,
0.25309908390045166,
0.22914008796215057,
-0.5943722724914551,
0.3379403352737427,
0.24145889282226562,
0.09620458632707596,
-0.2379593551158905,
0.37477385997772217,
-0.16960804164409637,
-0.7741841077804565,
0.30782178044319153,
-0.3012444078922272,
0.938216507434845,
0.09412414580583572,
-0.43335050344467163,
0.5214971303939819,
-0.8839846253395081,
0.430291086435318,
0.046014364808797836,
-0.12830471992492676,
-0.616570770740509,
-0.16078400611877441,
-0.24723300337791443,
0.1657560020685196,
-0.13288874924182892,
-0.2085319459438324,
0.11096612364053726,
-0.7478615045547485,
0.42353135347366333,
0.9717629551887512,
0.05533391609787941,
0.6983283758163452,
-0.14304272830486298,
0.7122284770011902,
0.4288833737373352,
0.42569756507873535,
-0.3066769540309906,
-0.11769749224185944,
-0.9127793908119202,
-0.545212984085083,
0.7665511965751648,
0.6229817271232605,
-0.6045100688934326,
0.4703095853328705,
-0.12832148373126984,
-0.4434998333454132,
-0.417729914188385,
0.4275006353855133,
0.4509533941745758,
0.35519787669181824,
0.5937073230743408,
-0.3440576493740082,
-0.4585134983062744,
-0.7565355896949768,
-0.7077140212059021,
0.5876822471618652,
-0.2181238979101181,
-0.5595526695251465,
0.25467994809150696,
-0.2567410171031952,
1.105921983718872,
-0.4093227982521057,
-0.17245960235595703,
-0.1571582406759262,
0.12578262388706207,
0.35925182700157166,
1.0114625692367554,
0.5880605578422546,
-0.7179625034332275,
-0.5110439658164978,
-0.623533308506012,
-0.3372751474380493,
0.08076990395784378,
0.2870372533798218,
-0.32844242453575134,
-0.11325626075267792,
0.655493438243866,
-0.6030712127685547,
0.6479116678237915,
0.27035143971443176,
-0.30020418763160706,
0.42054739594459534,
-0.06172648072242737,
-0.09413852542638779,
-0.8023264408111572,
0.08642411977052689,
0.015197801403701305,
-0.2935928404331207,
-0.7413597106933594,
-0.19000732898712158,
0.2431441992521286,
-0.09570705145597458,
-0.3196226954460144,
0.45707011222839355,
-0.3555985689163208,
0.20639635622501373,
0.017392173409461975,
-0.1403934806585312,
-0.04303540289402008,
0.22792105376720428,
-0.3329423666000366,
0.7452833652496338,
0.6004019975662231,
-0.7214462757110596,
-0.012371237389743328,
-0.07415717840194702,
-0.3372446894645691,
0.21699590981006622,
-0.837565004825592,
-0.01376728992909193,
-0.3387327194213867,
0.11595012247562408,
-0.8812502026557922,
0.1437322348356247,
0.170453280210495,
-0.17820221185684204,
0.30934786796569824,
-0.17225386202335358,
-0.5693972706794739,
-0.08492898941040039,
-0.4810919761657715,
0.9076986908912659,
0.4919523298740387,
-0.36839067935943604,
0.130268394947052,
0.033556174486875534,
-0.024541106075048447,
-0.4206991195678711,
-0.3012292683124542,
-0.5788248777389526,
-0.39879006147384644,
-0.48041462898254395,
-0.005262524820864201,
-0.3620222508907318,
-0.001450028852559626,
-0.05387970432639122,
-0.10843044519424438,
-0.3817691206932068,
0.34224405884742737,
0.14708653092384338,
0.010314952582120895,
-0.36405616998672485,
0.31863102316856384,
0.1800013780593872,
-0.38936901092529297,
-0.06824058294296265,
-0.409430593252182,
0.45262569189071655,
-0.07975012809038162,
0.08348967880010605,
-0.3269825577735901,
0.27642759680747986,
0.34898728132247925,
-0.5743632912635803,
0.8810142278671265,
0.7888311147689819,
-0.42588087916374207,
-0.08327911049127579,
-0.22954247891902924,
-0.4223988652229309,
-0.5634913444519043,
0.35782909393310547,
-0.17893964052200317,
-0.9870707988739014,
0.2725657820701599,
-0.05275021120905876,
-0.28504112362861633,
0.3412240445613861,
-0.020445290952920914,
0.35409775376319885,
1.4206514358520508,
1.0321794748306274,
0.13035444915294647,
0.7249934077262878,
-0.38741016387939453,
0.46290692687034607,
-0.6931406259536743,
0.03849417716264725,
-0.44166430830955505,
-0.3172743022441864,
-0.532342255115509,
-0.1638672947883606,
0.5099168419837952,
0.4106309413909912,
-0.42463552951812744,
0.09983360022306442,
-0.1705392748117447,
0.911397397518158,
0.7064783573150635,
0.022765474393963814,
-0.027660707011818886,
-0.09067614376544952,
0.08885535597801208,
-0.15748561918735504,
-0.6879710555076599,
-0.08850979804992676,
1.0715279579162598,
0.009314765222370625,
0.5674641132354736,
0.05330703780055046,
0.6991801261901855,
-0.06816935539245605,
0.48149463534355164,
-0.6101126074790955,
0.3777444660663605,
-0.2335391342639923,
-0.5840144753456116,
-0.7215734720230103,
-0.775555431842804,
-1.0162880420684814,
0.09096571058034897,
-0.12246416509151459,
-0.6880001425743103,
0.11528021097183228,
0.46567967534065247,
-0.8711737394332886,
0.13644179701805115,
-0.9556222558021545,
1.361962080001831,
-0.14346542954444885,
-0.37185296416282654,
-0.13290178775787354,
-0.6256427764892578,
0.3650631904602051,
0.05290258675813675,
0.29994434118270874,
-0.14695914089679718,
0.18912367522716522,
0.9775468111038208,
-0.7455052733421326,
0.5150828957557678,
-0.4669446051120758,
0.1407613754272461,
0.0687059685587883,
0.19318228960037231,
0.2706981897354126,
0.0912640243768692,
0.15320375561714172,
-0.06307752430438995,
0.21633702516555786,
-0.8532857298851013,
-0.7841227650642395,
0.2950007915496826,
-0.6212442517280579,
-0.541300356388092,
-0.22168557345867157,
-0.3686244487762451,
-0.4411643445491791,
0.5422028303146362,
0.570979118347168,
0.6261627078056335,
-0.09427228569984436,
0.3538376986980438,
0.6670756340026855,
-0.07641156017780304,
0.6743143796920776,
0.4399568438529968,
0.21342720091342926,
-0.3371295630931854,
0.9733173847198486,
0.3899429440498352,
0.06646958738565445,
0.4004904329776764,
0.2638187110424042,
-0.31668978929519653,
-0.428535133600235,
-0.09319495409727097,
0.24803000688552856,
-0.5246340036392212,
-0.4796682894229889,
-0.3839349150657654,
-0.3091634213924408,
-0.7580267786979675,
-0.08241020888090134,
-0.39557504653930664,
-0.6358039975166321,
-0.37205687165260315,
-0.07144489139318466,
0.1292388141155243,
0.33448219299316406,
-0.15643244981765747,
0.7701160907745361,
-1.1533842086791992,
-0.0475500114262104,
0.4898395836353302,
0.36793088912963867,
-0.014572900719940662,
-0.5951348543167114,
-0.7458922266960144,
0.0062149083241820335,
-0.35603079199790955,
-0.6427269577980042,
0.5104809403419495,
0.6969002485275269,
0.3791806697845459,
0.70707768201828,
-0.053252995014190674,
0.8543094396591187,
-0.2868702709674835,
0.549566388130188,
0.2615186870098114,
-1.3410956859588623,
0.5179731845855713,
0.05597463995218277,
0.4991456866264343,
0.4491539001464844,
0.7236687541007996,
-0.5838416814804077,
-0.22713209688663483,
-0.6927039623260498,
-1.1604795455932617,
0.3948730528354645,
-0.26338809728622437,
0.07103516906499863,
0.02331976406276226,
0.5606254935264587,
0.13970278203487396,
0.4663791358470917,
-0.7006772756576538,
-0.1762065440416336,
-0.29597508907318115,
-0.22490905225276947,
-0.7139133214950562,
-0.6083841323852539,
0.04140947386622429,
-0.6689411401748657,
0.6733370423316956,
-0.24839147925376892,
-0.12542489171028137,
-0.17849017679691315,
-0.669198215007782,
-0.42537567019462585,
0.22569409012794495,
0.5299404263496399,
0.8130677938461304,
-0.07692484557628632,
0.1492483764886856,
0.035420116037130356,
-0.334576815366745,
0.26149076223373413,
0.1602059304714203,
-0.14631283283233643,
-0.29129940271377563,
0.29258713126182556,
0.6057778000831604,
0.5318651795387268,
-0.7240933179855347,
0.8550000190734863,
-0.14000505208969116,
0.05110544338822365,
-0.180341899394989,
0.24563688039779663,
-0.3684120774269104,
0.2799699604511261,
0.34867945313453674,
0.006788375787436962,
0.23241132497787476,
-0.38071760535240173,
0.2710064649581909,
0.21276357769966125,
-0.475796639919281,
-0.6166735291481018,
0.7383275032043457,
-0.06270230561494827,
-0.062188003212213516,
0.9554606080055237,
-0.3383544087409973,
-0.5636552572250366,
0.32612478733062744,
0.6539970636367798,
0.8437159061431885,
-0.5539848208427429,
0.1253596544265747,
0.4311753809452057,
0.17707522213459015,
-0.15286441147327423,
-0.031362537294626236,
-0.18763253092765808,
-0.7591744661331177,
-0.53089439868927,
-0.5083615779876709,
0.12512287497520447,
0.006104477681219578,
-0.7822251319885254,
0.17766869068145752,
-0.3811302185058594,
-0.03273158520460129,
-0.18065574765205383,
-0.11245794594287872,
-0.6110440492630005,
0.4856555759906769,
-0.05358951911330223,
0.6713029742240906,
-0.9491142630577087,
1.1000494956970215,
0.45787936449050903,
-0.25943461060523987,
-0.9453963041305542,
-0.06344172358512878,
-0.2280268520116806,
-0.45781210064888,
0.6078898906707764,
0.24516408145427704,
0.2027103453874588,
0.3019394278526306,
-0.5064886808395386,
-0.9247924089431763,
0.7263931035995483,
0.750410795211792,
-0.5341548919677734,
-0.14541278779506683,
0.07593967020511627,
0.19278529286384583,
0.1753515750169754,
0.34258365631103516,
0.8691746592521667,
0.2835359573364258,
-0.27347978949546814,
-0.686357855796814,
0.24490632116794586,
-0.3833121657371521,
0.07989578694105148,
0.5221594572067261,
-0.5622201561927795,
1.2114427089691162,
-0.17869944870471954,
-0.16989827156066895,
0.0389312244951725,
0.6328158974647522,
-0.14327561855316162,
0.11572694033384323,
0.7036030292510986,
0.6299762725830078,
0.9736614227294922,
-0.09559659659862518,
0.6609004139900208,
-0.17304514348506927,
0.19544708728790283,
0.8873191475868225,
-0.004246114287525415,
0.5057299137115479,
0.41428038477897644,
-0.029547713696956635,
0.4193691611289978,
0.4946664273738861,
0.3896890878677368,
0.7513218522071838,
0.4903225600719452,
-0.24108748137950897,
-0.3517639935016632,
0.34477800130844116,
-0.5721966028213501,
0.3205682933330536,
0.1839866042137146,
-0.04990581050515175,
-0.3194705843925476,
0.10379289835691452,
0.27257952094078064,
-0.0894189178943634,
-0.3195842206478119,
0.49990391731262207,
0.046752579510211945,
-0.5033993721008301,
0.7073009014129639,
-0.05259209871292114,
0.6886425018310547,
-0.7167626023292542,
0.10493570566177368,
-0.3447447717189789,
0.4562457501888275,
-0.13613781332969666,
-0.16165439784526825,
0.3645050823688507,
-0.43985214829444885,
-0.1870909035205841,
-0.3200329840183258,
0.48110508918762207,
-0.5361997485160828,
-0.0589786134660244,
0.0850268229842186,
0.5858965516090393,
-0.026093078777194023,
-0.4863527715206146,
-0.4123550355434418,
-0.19710470736026764,
-0.14901907742023468,
-0.3316742479801178,
0.5166222453117371,
0.5678715109825134,
-0.23059605062007904,
0.44082799553871155,
0.6779868006706238,
-0.08939335495233536,
0.1993623822927475,
0.07021601498126984,
0.8985613584518433,
-0.764420747756958,
-0.7942898869514465,
-1.0369740724563599,
0.5546072721481323,
0.058380212634801865,
-0.5378326177597046,
0.7867263555526733,
0.8141546845436096,
0.8781009316444397,
-0.19579000771045685,
0.2174864560365677,
0.2945157587528229,
0.3556489050388336,
-0.4612891376018524,
0.8270171284675598,
-0.6486853957176208,
-0.007248717360198498,
-0.2717725336551666,
-0.8169459700584412,
-0.47942909598350525,
0.46254801750183105,
-0.4155513644218445,
0.09269049018621445,
0.6487988233566284,
0.9637619853019714,
0.05090362951159477,
-0.09128022193908691,
0.46520665287971497,
0.10657940059900284,
0.4190475046634674,
0.4931112825870514,
0.7660103440284729,
-0.5255407691001892,
0.6314110159873962,
-0.3899109661579132,
-0.4677864611148834,
-0.27176937460899353,
-0.8461247086524963,
-0.49330514669418335,
-0.7171832323074341,
-0.42466387152671814,
-0.29346299171447754,
0.27091607451438904,
0.7195349335670471,
1.015541672706604,
-0.8347694873809814,
-0.25766611099243164,
-0.015137855894863605,
0.24197712540626526,
-0.42466843128204346,
-0.23766742646694183,
0.17843276262283325,
-0.6180663108825684,
-0.4112526774406433,
0.2729834318161011,
0.1483190953731537,
0.27071285247802734,
0.29753226041793823,
-0.08138303458690643,
0.04326436668634415,
0.19436366856098175,
0.5193498730659485,
0.515970766544342,
0.13300779461860657,
-0.29470428824424744,
-0.23289991915225983,
0.21525613963603973,
0.093653105199337,
1.1885197162628174,
-0.8294557332992554,
0.14685609936714172,
0.21934235095977783,
0.2306152731180191,
0.6031856536865234,
-0.06498159468173981,
0.6114934682846069,
-1.1141157150268555,
0.7631271481513977,
0.18732450902462006,
0.08537159860134125,
0.2525344491004944,
-0.3616790771484375,
0.2976406514644623,
0.44528111815452576,
-0.6418898105621338,
-1.1097748279571533,
-0.030057040974497795,
-0.3954671621322632,
-0.10953621566295624,
0.7630906105041504,
-0.04422881826758385,
-0.5265805125236511,
0.1752285212278366,
0.14052443206310272,
0.6623181104660034,
-0.11927726119756699,
0.5380679368972778,
0.28925570845603943,
0.028439836576581,
-0.26646217703819275,
-0.33016449213027954,
0.8709475994110107,
0.5970238447189331,
-0.5496381521224976,
-0.17429204285144806,
0.14517825841903687,
0.5495090484619141,
-0.15097446739673615,
0.7418734431266785,
-0.1316026747226715,
0.46488288044929504,
-0.19630658626556396,
-0.04600052535533905,
0.11339719593524933,
-0.28505373001098633,
-0.46200838685035706,
0.06109455227851868,
0.32437729835510254,
-0.36151909828186035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12100v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12100v1 | Groot: Adversarial Testing for Generative Text-to-Image Models with Tree-based Semantic Transformation | 2024-02-19T12:31:56 | 2024-02-19T12:31:56 | Yi Liu, Guowei Yang, Gelei Deng, Feiyue Chen, Yuqi Chen, Ling Shi, Tianwei Zhang, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.SE | With the prevalence of text-to-image generative models, their safety becomes
a critical concern. adversarial testing techniques have been developed to probe
whether such models can be prompted to produce Not-Safe-For-Work (NSFW)
content. However, existing solutions face several challenges, including low
success rate and inefficiency. We introduce Groot, the first automated
framework leveraging tree-based semantic transformation for adversarial testing
of text-to-image models. Groot employs semantic decomposition and sensitive
element drowning strategies in conjunction with LLMs to systematically refine
adversarial prompts. Our comprehensive evaluation confirms the efficacy of
Groot, which not only exceeds the performance of current state-of-the-art
approaches but also achieves a remarkable success rate (93.66%) on leading
text-to-image models such as DALL-E 3 and Midjourney. | [
-0.3695697784423828,
-1.2782059907913208,
0.30724775791168213,
-0.06870818883180618,
-0.40075623989105225,
0.008727088570594788,
0.24512581527233124,
-0.4719448983669281,
-0.08127927780151367,
0.4810228645801544,
-0.5703497529029846,
-0.6453192830085754,
-0.84068763256073,
0.00018641422502696514,
-0.9667990207672119,
1.052776575088501,
-0.06324132531881332,
-0.33975499868392944,
-0.28823593258857727,
-0.09850431233644485,
-0.2963610291481018,
-0.08076747506856918,
-0.6168224811553955,
0.055190593004226685,
0.47327524423599243,
0.10708939284086227,
1.1527040004730225,
0.4672451913356781,
0.8149755001068115,
0.23322813212871552,
-0.1080622673034668,
0.029195493087172508,
-0.41968628764152527,
0.3303648829460144,
-0.21799272298812866,
-0.34176546335220337,
-0.1518249660730362,
0.025257742032408714,
0.3598038852214813,
0.2884116470813751,
-0.012220563367009163,
-0.022183774039149284,
-0.13221260905265808,
0.6715744137763977,
-0.7233769297599792,
-0.013268430717289448,
-1.0217169523239136,
0.06448665261268616,
-0.20589907467365265,
-0.2495822161436081,
-0.716908872127533,
-0.46244698762893677,
-0.37086454033851624,
-0.8615692853927612,
0.6444405317306519,
0.2535818815231323,
1.0868281126022339,
0.4043892025947571,
-0.634968101978302,
-0.3055150806903839,
-0.4460560977458954,
0.4510209262371063,
-0.3295169174671173,
0.2335776537656784,
0.19618107378482819,
0.47113415598869324,
-0.5556957125663757,
-0.953812301158905,
-0.5983867645263672,
-0.44255489110946655,
-0.0905737653374672,
0.048747748136520386,
-0.2909352481365204,
0.17018401622772217,
0.08303434401750565,
0.29782921075820923,
-0.8031180500984192,
-0.11473651230335236,
0.03298047184944153,
-0.13933584094047546,
0.5761594176292419,
0.028416885063052177,
0.8776631355285645,
0.11956262588500977,
-0.6169912219047546,
-0.7177106738090515,
-0.7537298798561096,
-0.12441502511501312,
0.4243398904800415,
0.2413957118988037,
0.3128761053085327,
0.7403527498245239,
0.05768463760614395,
0.3717617988586426,
0.02833501249551773,
-0.07007890939712524,
0.029431678354740143,
0.004718415439128876,
-0.2845250070095062,
-0.07494129985570908,
0.7216789126396179,
0.48896145820617676,
0.0398634672164917,
-0.24337007105350494,
-0.3772891163825989,
0.7038030624389648,
0.29502907395362854,
-0.7678084373474121,
-0.4081966280937195,
-0.020139163359999657,
-0.23282527923583984,
-0.7718936204910278,
-0.2719663977622986,
-0.9909170866012573,
-0.7949175834655762,
0.30947408080101013,
0.4303770065307617,
-0.61130690574646,
-0.10892974585294724,
0.20312847197055817,
-0.3517457842826843,
0.3425286114215851,
0.5071057081222534,
-0.8198660612106323,
0.07524231821298599,
0.6066563129425049,
0.7095752954483032,
-0.17173928022384644,
-0.42921262979507446,
-0.6925233006477356,
0.18752332031726837,
-0.6970582604408264,
0.8524800539016724,
-0.3355027437210083,
-0.6491579413414001,
0.0476524718105793,
0.3503596782684326,
-0.2920788824558258,
-0.22973351180553436,
0.5137962698936462,
-0.7147880792617798,
0.2514907717704773,
-0.03334084898233414,
-0.29469117522239685,
-0.29950618743896484,
0.5833555459976196,
-0.6327273845672607,
0.893731415271759,
0.2400815337896347,
-1.0388747453689575,
0.32098400592803955,
-0.8868246078491211,
-0.8733603358268738,
0.07435298711061478,
-0.17318232357501984,
-0.5204722881317139,
-0.1771409809589386,
0.4319065809249878,
0.45924490690231323,
-0.46221065521240234,
0.19734233617782593,
-0.4625222384929657,
-0.272603303194046,
-0.21045438945293427,
-0.45205453038215637,
0.8410045504570007,
0.06085249409079552,
-0.5019178986549377,
0.15523375570774078,
-0.37858375906944275,
0.026047008112072945,
0.8918616771697998,
0.07075808197259903,
-0.3990207016468048,
-0.18026535212993622,
0.009961051866412163,
-0.04850548133254051,
-0.0977788046002388,
-0.49215129017829895,
0.2349083423614502,
-0.2607306241989136,
0.2947228252887726,
0.6772329211235046,
0.06932024657726288,
0.3454791009426117,
-0.3947707712650299,
0.7892575263977051,
-0.3048718571662903,
0.27409279346466064,
-0.3680914640426636,
-0.727056086063385,
-0.49917393922805786,
-0.20301221311092377,
0.043914709240198135,
0.6246862411499023,
-1.2040846347808838,
0.17279665172100067,
-0.2544742524623871,
-0.6236030459403992,
-0.1661565601825714,
-0.23983922600746155,
0.3525366187095642,
0.6050017476081848,
0.37328219413757324,
-0.31150466203689575,
0.15587499737739563,
-0.6713861227035522,
-0.21014493703842163,
-0.5770476460456848,
0.06381843239068985,
0.1449504792690277,
0.694750189781189,
-0.5316697359085083,
0.5914307236671448,
-0.3347313106060028,
-0.24180875718593597,
0.006799893919378519,
0.3267366290092468,
-0.31685471534729004,
0.3557147979736328,
0.827266275882721,
-0.9654824733734131,
-0.35571709275245667,
0.0352945402264595,
-0.6066973209381104,
0.08709992468357086,
-0.20216549932956696,
-0.15236380696296692,
0.3554570972919464,
0.5170676708221436,
-0.8290810585021973,
0.6361247301101685,
0.6186789274215698,
-0.5910255312919617,
0.6678761839866638,
-0.24900344014167786,
0.47822582721710205,
-0.5915243029594421,
0.23229622840881348,
-0.2407228946685791,
-0.3715590834617615,
-0.3142980933189392,
0.8015061616897583,
0.26888546347618103,
-0.3723057508468628,
-0.5659047365188599,
0.6004781126976013,
-0.2906441390514374,
-0.08588436990976334,
-0.07999730110168457,
-0.07478947192430496,
0.2029581218957901,
0.23097479343414307,
-0.3679574728012085,
0.9017125964164734,
0.6211257576942444,
-0.5701844692230225,
0.4712468981742859,
0.5054618120193481,
-0.017353715375065804,
0.683560311794281,
-0.7147838473320007,
0.43983349204063416,
-0.23789826035499573,
0.24358588457107544,
-1.0810737609863281,
-0.3689299523830414,
0.416638046503067,
-0.556959331035614,
0.36161378026008606,
-0.2999909818172455,
-0.6813417077064514,
-0.28549298644065857,
-0.3899387717247009,
0.13919129967689514,
0.7033652067184448,
-0.7429167032241821,
0.6778289079666138,
0.30684205889701843,
-0.18817104399204254,
-0.43635690212249756,
-0.6972836852073669,
0.31465277075767517,
-0.3771326541900635,
-1.0132383108139038,
0.4874573349952698,
0.052087292075157166,
-0.020409420132637024,
0.13095898926258087,
0.17648473381996155,
-0.009942587465047836,
0.30873817205429077,
0.2390134036540985,
0.3100823760032654,
0.16038066148757935,
0.014390526339411736,
-0.02832244336605072,
-0.31898003816604614,
0.10147599130868912,
-0.07240662723779678,
0.32587310671806335,
-0.15465885400772095,
-0.8590015769004822,
0.02504519373178482,
0.37378349900245667,
0.8907043933868408,
-0.30427736043930054,
0.3053581416606903,
0.7743315100669861,
-0.391094446182251,
-0.15090394020080566,
-0.18789227306842804,
-0.03866443783044815,
-0.5050100088119507,
0.5314359664916992,
-0.10792165994644165,
-0.48607373237609863,
0.3261035084724426,
-0.1925009787082672,
0.08070211112499237,
0.586500883102417,
0.2748950123786926,
0.08304884284734726,
1.1807801723480225,
0.5525431632995605,
-0.013843796215951443,
0.31971031427383423,
-0.275699645280838,
0.08428428322076797,
-0.3873542845249176,
-0.14108207821846008,
-0.3634810447692871,
-0.011640605516731739,
-0.40165987610816956,
-0.385636568069458,
0.5627355575561523,
-0.251473069190979,
-0.3204052746295929,
0.3089790642261505,
-0.6236542463302612,
0.5649345517158508,
0.46149715781211853,
0.030008025467395782,
0.14468872547149658,
-0.012165611609816551,
-0.18526403605937958,
0.2015015184879303,
-0.4889552593231201,
-0.4470914602279663,
0.8370225429534912,
0.43890416622161865,
1.0732475519180298,
-0.008279560133814812,
0.32525113224983215,
0.4758613109588623,
0.4013638496398926,
-0.7635062336921692,
0.844931960105896,
-0.40024498105049133,
-0.6268669962882996,
-0.49791720509529114,
-0.1006336510181427,
-0.945564866065979,
0.2900083065032959,
-0.06056557968258858,
-0.3742676377296448,
-0.07728154212236404,
0.05735153704881668,
0.10308261215686798,
0.543416440486908,
-0.6783923506736755,
0.9328336119651794,
-0.3359619379043579,
-0.26392996311187744,
0.0008574399398639798,
-0.7687912583351135,
0.6204105615615845,
-0.007168984040617943,
0.1086447611451149,
-0.22690702974796295,
0.04091989994049072,
0.574907660484314,
-0.2568962872028351,
0.6442767381668091,
-0.4614126682281494,
-0.02124103158712387,
0.26124098896980286,
0.5152484178543091,
1.181397795677185,
-0.05594958737492561,
0.30612409114837646,
-0.13100290298461914,
-0.10932151973247528,
-0.33457261323928833,
-0.6996887922286987,
0.5398274064064026,
-0.5593721866607666,
-0.5691503286361694,
-0.5104378461837769,
-0.5196356177330017,
-0.23563270270824432,
0.2699245512485504,
0.2575623691082001,
0.09593913704156876,
-0.22932572662830353,
0.11203933507204056,
0.8100879192352295,
-0.3227722942829132,
0.2867894470691681,
0.20934294164180756,
-0.48577797412872314,
-0.45369264483451843,
0.7789625525474548,
-0.37479203939437866,
0.4034648835659027,
0.013251992873847485,
0.11289923638105392,
-0.5641611218452454,
-0.8048198819160461,
-0.748625636100769,
-0.13710182905197144,
-1.1280453205108643,
-0.2541743516921997,
-0.5743706822395325,
-0.06166987866163254,
-0.4297660291194916,
-0.45838817954063416,
-0.392707496881485,
-0.19385972619056702,
-0.2650482654571533,
0.016505394130945206,
0.3847685754299164,
0.5326918959617615,
0.388531893491745,
0.056220367550849915,
-0.6292352676391602,
0.5300297141075134,
0.5873542428016663,
-0.03960670158267021,
-0.3927372097969055,
-0.5273044109344482,
0.4524178206920624,
-0.1220969706773758,
-0.46007293462753296,
-0.8117131590843201,
0.4984678626060486,
0.229557067155838,
0.3817305266857147,
0.16370631754398346,
0.4187024235725403,
0.6177836656570435,
-0.3606641888618469,
0.8719772696495056,
0.30020493268966675,
-0.7338072657585144,
0.6407164335250854,
-0.6134543418884277,
-0.18506543338298798,
0.41239500045776367,
0.17947369813919067,
-0.43693283200263977,
-0.42611807584762573,
-0.8197311758995056,
-1.0710123777389526,
0.1049247682094574,
0.31344497203826904,
0.14669856429100037,
0.05829142779111862,
0.0945344865322113,
0.13268056511878967,
0.0014275290304794908,
-0.37127670645713806,
-0.1210530698299408,
-0.2837144136428833,
-0.022630682215094566,
-0.15055406093597412,
-0.04862659424543381,
-0.2946145534515381,
0.09267891198396683,
0.6995427012443542,
-0.3778778910636902,
0.3343086540699005,
0.31637728214263916,
-0.19911617040634155,
-0.19217991828918457,
0.12964680790901184,
0.37334340810775757,
0.10010962188243866,
-0.09183492511510849,
0.3173512816429138,
0.08837816119194031,
-0.49641963839530945,
0.4923154413700104,
0.3573312759399414,
-0.30837032198905945,
0.017095070332288742,
0.4627573490142822,
0.6493356227874756,
-0.15893201529979706,
-0.5042822957038879,
0.8036413192749023,
-0.30568575859069824,
-0.2859010696411133,
-0.15719301998615265,
0.2146121859550476,
-0.2667674124240875,
-0.09741933643817902,
0.36856380105018616,
0.2492089718580246,
0.1399303674697876,
-0.4028368294239044,
0.4054686427116394,
0.586037278175354,
-0.3157489001750946,
-0.13036030530929565,
0.9869657754898071,
0.1790093630552292,
0.054802071303129196,
0.3934863805770874,
-0.6147507429122925,
-0.483847975730896,
0.8652899861335754,
0.6431803107261658,
1.164036512374878,
-0.17201799154281616,
0.4789036810398102,
-0.017078110948204994,
0.5945128202438354,
-0.03200331702828407,
0.023503733798861504,
0.43729251623153687,
-0.5542311072349548,
-0.03095081076025963,
-0.10165829956531525,
-0.5459986329078674,
0.08875761181116104,
-0.4593942165374756,
0.3485630750656128,
-0.4689698815345764,
0.018017515540122986,
-0.04910812899470329,
-0.29808077216148376,
-0.35027867555618286,
0.4467078149318695,
-0.09028589725494385,
0.8289492130279541,
-1.074323296546936,
0.5415039658546448,
1.0016810894012451,
-0.15078842639923096,
-0.32178783416748047,
0.18585652112960815,
0.14784173667430878,
-1.1957550048828125,
0.4444482624530792,
0.2967354655265808,
-0.10681532323360443,
0.18330208957195282,
-0.6849450469017029,
-0.5806008577346802,
1.3253501653671265,
0.8277461528778076,
-0.22237832844257355,
-0.010856668464839458,
0.04727904498577118,
0.22575128078460693,
-0.11245817691087723,
0.20515358448028564,
0.21663379669189453,
0.528761088848114,
0.5733982920646667,
-0.47609058022499084,
0.26353344321250916,
-0.43406444787979126,
0.22151465713977814,
0.3191964328289032,
-0.34556886553764343,
0.7008208632469177,
-0.4138387441635132,
-0.7024194002151489,
-0.039008256047964096,
0.39304500818252563,
0.29812300205230713,
0.4462539553642273,
0.9337170124053955,
0.7688692212104797,
0.8012978434562683,
-0.1282137781381607,
1.286198616027832,
-0.31603917479515076,
0.4415215849876404,
0.7721132040023804,
-0.34004777669906616,
0.49353349208831787,
0.37232381105422974,
-0.14286349713802338,
0.24504604935646057,
0.682304322719574,
0.05908938869833946,
0.7801344394683838,
0.07559768855571747,
-0.14402543008327484,
-0.26866579055786133,
-0.2550658583641052,
-0.4876292645931244,
0.08825662732124329,
0.2971007525920868,
-0.25118204951286316,
-0.531467616558075,
0.1823774129152298,
0.005376489367336035,
0.04139046370983124,
-0.08252856880426407,
0.514456033706665,
-0.27838608622550964,
-0.40230944752693176,
0.6691497564315796,
0.038726337254047394,
0.4757322669029236,
-0.4986852705478668,
-0.07350122183561325,
-0.1343456506729126,
0.06746088713407516,
0.003112364560365677,
-0.7913391590118408,
0.4272136390209198,
-0.0668700635433197,
0.2185102254152298,
-0.15778714418411255,
1.3281257152557373,
-0.1504533290863037,
-0.4393950402736664,
0.3366985023021698,
0.08247264474630356,
-0.11388615518808365,
-0.35942691564559937,
-0.8620673418045044,
-0.1076597273349762,
-0.17378129065036774,
-0.32534730434417725,
0.33519449830055237,
0.3829766809940338,
-0.040256571024656296,
0.9365617036819458,
0.7771517634391785,
-0.29265835881233215,
0.00002281430715811439,
-0.15485721826553345,
0.9767004251480103,
-0.5473167300224304,
-0.7029810547828674,
-0.7401785850524902,
0.5866981148719788,
0.16734974086284637,
-0.14147479832172394,
0.5919094681739807,
0.2559933066368103,
0.6469113230705261,
-0.16937853395938873,
1.0680627822875977,
-0.18459340929985046,
0.033491626381874084,
-0.6623390913009644,
0.7544723749160767,
-0.5113462805747986,
-0.0730484277009964,
-0.26459816098213196,
-0.3955616056919098,
-0.4701636731624603,
0.23184195160865784,
-0.08830060809850693,
-0.07119058072566986,
0.9260327219963074,
0.9962328672409058,
-0.03611218184232712,
0.12870708107948303,
0.5514556169509888,
-0.1963634043931961,
0.6827392578125,
0.6317448616027832,
0.969817042350769,
-0.6207128763198853,
0.701862096786499,
-0.23438192903995514,
-0.23413914442062378,
-0.23209086060523987,
-1.165469765663147,
-0.8767111301422119,
-0.5092277526855469,
-0.6081364750862122,
-0.4598851799964905,
0.35846206545829773,
0.41087043285369873,
0.5844409465789795,
-0.5202773213386536,
0.6588484644889832,
-0.6398102641105652,
0.041299931704998016,
-0.11206427216529846,
-0.20069363713264465,
0.4386569857597351,
-0.4220477044582367,
-0.4564548134803772,
0.31089603900909424,
0.249635711312294,
0.5854336619377136,
-0.2592417895793915,
-0.06698549538850784,
0.21260729432106018,
-0.1523115634918213,
0.2797488272190094,
0.212798610329628,
-0.585563063621521,
-0.3556167483329773,
-0.016296587884426117,
-0.24180690944194794,
-0.09533272683620453,
0.4719180464744568,
-0.5409728288650513,
0.5540185570716858,
0.5726156234741211,
0.9566298127174377,
0.21541336178779602,
0.05718040466308594,
0.3068538308143616,
-0.594186007976532,
0.1573837697505951,
0.27143746614456177,
0.3529849946498871,
0.4273991584777832,
-0.6434316039085388,
0.6956354975700378,
0.5892019271850586,
-0.5880936980247498,
-0.8408697247505188,
0.224779412150383,
-0.682243824005127,
-0.13014385104179382,
1.3710633516311646,
-0.3997284471988678,
-0.378214955329895,
0.08888265490531921,
-0.30644550919532776,
0.1453617364168167,
-0.11963912099599838,
0.8243765234947205,
0.37388235330581665,
0.25208383798599243,
-0.030678248032927513,
-0.4941610097885132,
0.2992207109928131,
0.2962993085384369,
-0.9369112253189087,
0.12548017501831055,
0.16161036491394043,
0.17038442194461823,
0.18427345156669617,
0.4743778705596924,
-0.29549887776374817,
0.369739294052124,
0.29896730184555054,
0.08768351376056671,
-0.3372286856174469,
-0.3834898769855499,
-0.24505206942558289,
0.20291565358638763,
0.09539936482906342,
-0.5672677755355835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12091v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12091v1 | Do Large Language Models Understand Logic or Just Mimick Context? | 2024-02-19T12:12:35 | 2024-02-19T12:12:35 | Junbing Yan, Chengyu Wang, Jun Huang, Wei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Over the past few years, the abilities of large language models (LLMs) have
received extensive attention, which have performed exceptionally well in
complicated scenarios such as logical reasoning and symbolic inference. A
significant factor contributing to this progress is the benefit of in-context
learning and few-shot prompting. However, the reasons behind the success of
such models using contextual reasoning have not been fully explored. Do LLMs
have understand logical rules to draw inferences, or do they ``guess'' the
answers by learning a type of probabilistic mapping through context? This paper
investigates the reasoning capabilities of LLMs on two logical reasoning
datasets by using counterfactual methods to replace context text and modify
logical concepts. Based on our analysis, it is found that LLMs do not truly
understand logical rules; rather, in-context learning has simply enhanced the
likelihood of these models arriving at the correct answers. If one alters
certain words in the context text or changes the concepts of logical terms, the
outputs of LLMs can be significantly disrupted, leading to counter-intuitive
responses. This work provides critical insights into the limitations of LLMs,
underscoring the need for more robust mechanisms to ensure reliable logical
reasoning in LLMs. | [
-0.3002271354198456,
-1.192376732826233,
1.1247570514678955,
-0.27057209610939026,
-0.3042796552181244,
-0.3279813826084137,
-0.12660379707813263,
-0.43105456233024597,
-0.1859041005373001,
0.655873715877533,
-0.7865936756134033,
-0.1467175930738449,
-0.49608558416366577,
0.1612323373556137,
-0.39260274171829224,
0.7042913436889648,
-0.0005946408491581678,
0.09401042014360428,
-0.26140880584716797,
-0.14240720868110657,
-0.6454497575759888,
-0.6629828214645386,
-0.35912078619003296,
-0.6588217616081238,
0.2730298340320587,
0.24956153333187103,
0.7125654816627502,
0.4367949664592743,
0.15215319395065308,
0.342189222574234,
-0.053024161607027054,
0.08772248774766922,
-0.47161898016929626,
0.1237981989979744,
-0.5502243041992188,
-0.6796640753746033,
-0.24938587844371796,
0.02238794043660164,
0.5974419713020325,
0.8395252823829651,
0.03993748128414154,
0.02928350679576397,
-0.09215134382247925,
0.3606099784374237,
-0.5431117415428162,
0.2879480719566345,
-1.0578502416610718,
-0.0759768933057785,
-0.017160218209028244,
-0.3229028880596161,
-0.5758092403411865,
0.06768226623535156,
0.3151245713233948,
-0.5830259919166565,
-0.17114539444446564,
0.1254914253950119,
0.444203644990921,
0.29706916213035583,
-0.6388033628463745,
-0.3136754631996155,
-0.6227779388427734,
0.9834446310997009,
-0.8008381128311157,
0.2007313221693039,
0.22990934550762177,
0.4172716438770294,
-0.5344651341438293,
-0.43177706003189087,
-0.793441116809845,
-0.13042289018630981,
-0.3748205304145813,
-0.11308871954679489,
-0.12413214892148972,
-0.17206116020679474,
0.691672682762146,
-0.1379765272140503,
-0.4880027770996094,
0.0823315978050232,
-0.051593951880931854,
0.0003032185777556151,
0.39048275351524353,
0.22777339816093445,
0.3756316006183624,
-0.09223733842372894,
-0.4497164189815521,
0.0422828309237957,
-1.1295961141586304,
-0.08893095701932907,
-0.12675841152668,
0.1709846556186676,
0.04994887858629227,
0.5624241828918457,
-0.05925705283880234,
1.0929148197174072,
-0.25361910462379456,
-0.2721027433872223,
-0.08798161894083023,
-0.21623815596103668,
-0.5867053270339966,
0.06693198531866074,
0.48312273621559143,
0.26489192247390747,
0.7912095189094543,
0.0016350166406482458,
-0.34830930829048157,
0.10626087337732315,
-0.02683393284678459,
-0.5711618065834045,
0.08880700916051865,
0.18870289623737335,
-0.3547331690788269,
0.07062651962041855,
-0.02508476935327053,
-0.19546346366405487,
-0.34831589460372925,
-0.6079875230789185,
0.6743209958076477,
-0.4251421093940735,
-0.17654818296432495,
0.2834688723087311,
-0.1546241194009781,
0.41160401701927185,
0.7118150591850281,
-0.5028862953186035,
0.06375490128993988,
0.7436901330947876,
0.4214384853839874,
0.15853317081928253,
-0.25663071870803833,
-0.6493964195251465,
0.1455184817314148,
-0.6412740349769592,
0.8293672204017639,
-0.7522251009941101,
-0.21381142735481262,
-0.05817999318242073,
0.03405353054404259,
-0.2399948388338089,
-0.7214539051055908,
0.20775479078292847,
-0.7682538032531738,
0.11670627444982529,
-0.6755287647247314,
-0.7155797481536865,
-0.40899765491485596,
0.3390016257762909,
-0.4074556529521942,
0.38923802971839905,
-0.10921715199947357,
-0.7160141468048096,
0.4325869679450989,
-0.2562817335128784,
-0.43001288175582886,
0.02139546535909176,
-0.23300939798355103,
0.06810197979211807,
0.242935910820961,
0.17082244157791138,
0.5283249020576477,
-0.3523710370063782,
0.4333594739437103,
-0.47689422965049744,
-0.5432141423225403,
0.6633301377296448,
-0.40666431188583374,
0.8903324007987976,
0.1414308249950409,
-0.32040202617645264,
0.07136239856481552,
-0.5105251669883728,
-0.1417553573846817,
0.24856723845005035,
-0.045234449207782745,
-0.40502822399139404,
0.26717251539230347,
-0.18416322767734528,
0.6246541142463684,
-0.1526014357805252,
-0.31792452931404114,
0.1376548558473587,
-0.37245261669158936,
0.5604100227355957,
0.7016211152076721,
-0.09553655236959457,
0.43933290243148804,
-0.4331555962562561,
0.33513912558555603,
0.15515248477458954,
-0.32406970858573914,
-0.4174446165561676,
-0.4371629059314728,
-0.532850444316864,
-0.24089504778385162,
-0.05646331235766411,
0.7079750895500183,
-0.8519079089164734,
0.16713900864124298,
-0.14122986793518066,
-0.18093888461589813,
-0.0741901621222496,
0.2579673230648041,
0.30125632882118225,
0.9728046655654907,
0.4968019127845764,
0.17917752265930176,
-0.5082385540008545,
-0.8143407702445984,
-0.5365882515907288,
-0.1442219316959381,
-0.04376489296555519,
0.3238303065299988,
0.7576143145561218,
-0.25257521867752075,
1.0289891958236694,
-0.28694620728492737,
-0.13807974755764008,
-0.5965585112571716,
-0.13207697868347168,
0.26729616522789,
0.24652709066867828,
0.6244518160820007,
-0.698857307434082,
-0.16335929930210114,
-0.32851022481918335,
-0.9228014349937439,
-0.443320631980896,
-0.3670940101146698,
0.2168772667646408,
0.3521319031715393,
0.8604367971420288,
-0.7640484571456909,
0.44904330372810364,
0.39377784729003906,
-0.37382104992866516,
0.5658614039421082,
-0.08046077191829681,
-0.029255548492074013,
-0.5744343400001526,
-0.13448284566402435,
-0.06265754252672195,
-0.3875519633293152,
-0.6702917814254761,
0.09161578863859177,
-0.07504145801067352,
0.2044883519411087,
-0.6302242875099182,
0.9055786728858948,
-0.30032485723495483,
-0.14208638668060303,
-0.36237630248069763,
0.40972670912742615,
-0.04739951342344284,
0.2637067437171936,
0.4022827744483948,
0.5493296384811401,
0.5371055603027344,
-0.5979018211364746,
0.3223038613796234,
-0.010992893017828465,
-0.5995641946792603,
0.6734919548034668,
-0.6963315010070801,
-0.13519608974456787,
-0.2952856421470642,
0.7642006874084473,
-0.9982497096061707,
-0.25200849771499634,
0.23936621844768524,
-0.1375291794538498,
0.021526260301470757,
-0.09927412867546082,
-0.6904961466789246,
-0.02911616675555706,
0.10376360267400742,
0.25099197030067444,
0.5384194850921631,
-0.6740373373031616,
0.6665933728218079,
0.12208189815282822,
0.18534600734710693,
-0.4291036128997803,
-0.9005770087242126,
0.02797779068350792,
-0.34573596715927124,
-0.4678255319595337,
-0.11516730487346649,
0.03536372631788254,
-0.8904631733894348,
-0.11534922569990158,
-0.14192111790180206,
0.19900955259799957,
0.19184459745883942,
0.21024084091186523,
0.24599674344062805,
-0.2351323813199997,
0.2607254981994629,
-0.16472479701042175,
-0.08757885545492172,
0.3177514672279358,
-0.3462689518928528,
0.3448128402233124,
-0.09886182844638824,
-0.5033604502677917,
-0.40616533160209656,
0.11876898258924484,
0.5101033449172974,
-0.1038525253534317,
1.0690891742706299,
0.1467140018939972,
-0.45029130578041077,
-0.4334307014942169,
-0.5353096723556519,
-0.4319384694099426,
-0.4076043963432312,
0.11420278996229172,
-0.7405149936676025,
-0.8923211097717285,
0.5953577160835266,
-0.1520361602306366,
-0.13769759237766266,
0.4953683018684387,
0.6069697737693787,
-0.24650274217128754,
0.8666061162948608,
0.06593894213438034,
0.27563920617103577,
0.13548524677753448,
0.07097580283880234,
0.19863882660865784,
-0.5288417935371399,
-0.15686148405075073,
-0.37219923734664917,
-0.10735075175762177,
-0.5641303658485413,
-0.42223766446113586,
0.2350572943687439,
0.08015899360179901,
-0.37552136182785034,
0.17811088263988495,
0.10615918040275574,
0.5356746315956116,
0.3860085606575012,
0.09004652500152588,
0.33392027020454407,
-0.12798255681991577,
-0.19627724587917328,
0.08836765587329865,
-0.7555939555168152,
-0.5986319184303284,
0.7969621419906616,
0.2579437792301178,
0.9737412929534912,
0.25277063250541687,
0.291065514087677,
-0.08685167878866196,
0.26325199007987976,
-0.7940757274627686,
0.818085253238678,
0.013644300401210785,
-0.7221493721008301,
-0.22812595963478088,
-0.4263714849948883,
-0.6106802821159363,
0.5023142099380493,
-0.39112263917922974,
-0.7782611846923828,
0.05431891605257988,
0.3003305196762085,
-0.06972609460353851,
0.4873374104499817,
-0.6082881689071655,
0.8008387684822083,
-0.12681074440479279,
-0.3355053961277008,
-0.30411258339881897,
-0.6628978252410889,
0.45917144417762756,
-0.308792382478714,
0.4168412387371063,
0.13860052824020386,
0.14858588576316833,
0.4420534670352936,
-0.37444978952407837,
1.004473090171814,
-0.1266804337501526,
-0.36220523715019226,
0.45427292585372925,
0.5423384308815002,
0.4949423670768738,
-0.00006454707181546837,
-0.1024165078997612,
0.01979040913283825,
0.057615119963884354,
-0.39347514510154724,
-0.7787674069404602,
0.7085033059120178,
-0.3828483819961548,
-1.0099531412124634,
-0.4205314815044403,
-0.6766839623451233,
-0.3304615318775177,
0.10299566388130188,
0.07160992175340652,
0.5263568758964539,
-0.009225411340594292,
0.3106154501438141,
0.7978323101997375,
-0.4835444688796997,
0.32771947979927063,
0.5177431106567383,
-0.1740269660949707,
0.2690376341342926,
0.4086671471595764,
0.20991648733615875,
0.5024358630180359,
0.4802272617816925,
0.33792009949684143,
-0.3424828052520752,
-0.17392845451831818,
-0.3870013952255249,
0.1969527006149292,
-1.0356836318969727,
0.17825883626937866,
-0.5120601654052734,
-0.0658363550901413,
-0.20040321350097656,
-0.3036627471446991,
0.0323336087167263,
-0.326675683259964,
-0.17088885605335236,
-0.17089278995990753,
0.04833792522549629,
0.7661616206169128,
0.07609228044748306,
0.18919330835342407,
-0.5823593139648438,
0.350273460149765,
0.5484404563903809,
-0.10262659937143326,
0.11537085473537445,
-0.7828934192657471,
0.2707827091217041,
0.046609409153461456,
0.16663779318332672,
-1.037785291671753,
0.179095059633255,
-0.0030241007916629314,
0.5981228947639465,
0.4159906208515167,
-0.02759336121380329,
0.6325379610061646,
-0.7240442633628845,
0.5822930932044983,
-0.1497475653886795,
-0.9631009697914124,
0.5715023875236511,
-0.428348571062088,
0.6097704768180847,
0.11562052369117737,
0.2949097752571106,
-0.368348628282547,
-0.221662238240242,
-0.40185222029685974,
-0.29911139607429504,
0.6025573015213013,
-0.1493772268295288,
0.26903828978538513,
-0.08140600472688675,
0.38309770822525024,
0.032928843051195145,
0.14014044404029846,
-0.6839749813079834,
0.03000975400209427,
-0.10302591323852539,
-0.09327040612697601,
-0.24692831933498383,
-0.2921927571296692,
-0.18746109306812286,
-0.20450221002101898,
0.5116873979568481,
-0.2194705307483673,
-0.08157232403755188,
0.1146451011300087,
-0.4234774112701416,
-0.12462001293897629,
0.5103269219398499,
0.8000062704086304,
1.077033519744873,
-0.18046835064888,
0.42449694871902466,
0.3496314287185669,
0.10486136376857758,
0.049630675464868546,
-0.19579093158245087,
-0.19687697291374207,
-0.25341323018074036,
0.9192367196083069,
0.7405417561531067,
0.18806932866573334,
-1.0464588403701782,
0.4315147399902344,
0.16767241060733795,
-0.18708761036396027,
-0.2560931444168091,
0.2827167510986328,
0.19666047394275665,
0.2718387544155121,
0.31648531556129456,
-0.09198347479104996,
-0.08115844428539276,
-1.0103284120559692,
0.09818130731582642,
0.7309597134590149,
-0.1579916775226593,
-0.22854109108448029,
0.5817193388938904,
-0.27000775933265686,
-0.06895793229341507,
0.5799024105072021,
0.046411026269197464,
-0.7135787010192871,
0.678472101688385,
0.8683045506477356,
0.41320717334747314,
0.03193557634949684,
-0.04997921362519264,
0.17384891211986542,
0.39448773860931396,
-0.21723634004592896,
0.12288293242454529,
0.03271043300628662,
-1.1065477132797241,
-0.584030032157898,
-0.38452109694480896,
-0.40472254157066345,
0.338247686624527,
-0.21005895733833313,
0.09807562828063965,
-0.4349447786808014,
0.13933241367340088,
-0.1856161653995514,
-0.2778160274028778,
-0.7409781813621521,
0.5585008859634399,
0.13584710657596588,
1.0924431085586548,
-1.0649560689926147,
0.8681651949882507,
0.8073078989982605,
-0.20459602773189545,
-0.6702096462249756,
0.030728504061698914,
0.36967113614082336,
-0.7786398530006409,
1.0136774778366089,
0.23015253245830536,
-0.33077800273895264,
-0.2511005699634552,
-0.7521011233329773,
-0.5134494304656982,
0.6491226553916931,
0.42736244201660156,
-0.6264649629592896,
0.2681668996810913,
0.07978136837482452,
0.5492725968360901,
-0.49022188782691956,
0.23159915208816528,
0.5437753796577454,
0.5594527721405029,
0.23550035059452057,
-0.7898641228675842,
0.3136632442474365,
0.25926464796066284,
-0.1701950877904892,
-0.20531991124153137,
-0.3498504161834717,
0.781495988368988,
-0.3633265197277069,
0.01162087731063366,
-0.22204725444316864,
0.39475467801094055,
0.5856234431266785,
0.2358679622411728,
0.6407033205032349,
0.6299974918365479,
0.4178984463214874,
-0.09438785910606384,
1.1509547233581543,
-0.06489689648151398,
0.06214125081896782,
1.2676819562911987,
-0.5499365329742432,
0.8995593786239624,
0.5428472757339478,
0.12486164271831512,
0.7102121710777283,
0.48455217480659485,
0.23214606940746307,
0.318143755197525,
0.19158156216144562,
-0.1462095081806183,
-0.8517683744430542,
-0.0151675408706069,
-0.07161988317966461,
0.5982033014297485,
0.5934783220291138,
-0.2461465448141098,
-0.2326936423778534,
-0.10915164649486542,
0.06475046277046204,
0.2257859706878662,
-0.22357000410556793,
0.6349056959152222,
0.38210612535476685,
-0.8178308606147766,
0.4594748616218567,
0.006808382458984852,
0.3339734673500061,
-0.462340384721756,
-0.11026941984891891,
-0.10784920305013657,
0.2085702270269394,
-0.17393328249454498,
-0.869159996509552,
0.35131263732910156,
-0.15228019654750824,
-0.006542574614286423,
-0.282100111246109,
0.7401483058929443,
-0.25655972957611084,
-0.24781274795532227,
0.44456595182418823,
0.6829477548599243,
0.04938243329524994,
0.027404380962252617,
-0.5889134407043457,
0.06939122080802917,
-0.3290773928165436,
-0.3959192633628845,
0.28965631127357483,
0.6252886056900024,
-0.3583119511604309,
0.8648512363433838,
0.5353379249572754,
0.09057486802339554,
-0.2519192099571228,
0.12381076067686081,
0.642199695110321,
-0.5315830111503601,
-0.2655937969684601,
-1.1641732454299927,
0.2489987462759018,
0.20882898569107056,
0.13376648724079132,
0.743025541305542,
0.11861054599285126,
0.9628170728683472,
-0.1876390129327774,
0.6470274329185486,
0.22152079641819,
0.33973437547683716,
-0.811100423336029,
0.42672815918922424,
-0.7641313076019287,
0.4683648943901062,
-0.2686041593551636,
-0.822708010673523,
-0.36285120248794556,
0.7941319346427917,
-0.7535543441772461,
0.1859438419342041,
0.6537647247314453,
0.7426974177360535,
-0.20617051422595978,
-0.12499874085187912,
0.4539143443107605,
0.5126774311065674,
0.24443498253822327,
0.6780553460121155,
0.8691725730895996,
-0.06678422540426254,
0.21385113894939423,
0.29766425490379333,
-0.23691032826900482,
-0.09635844826698303,
-1.0217314958572388,
-1.1219679117202759,
-0.3627571165561676,
-0.12959013879299164,
-0.22708982229232788,
-0.0011682376498356462,
0.8713838458061218,
0.5637102723121643,
-0.9180416464805603,
-0.037285465747117996,
-0.14814132452011108,
0.3872039020061493,
-0.00937788188457489,
-0.2128438502550125,
0.24351133406162262,
-0.3145163655281067,
-0.45174774527549744,
0.48877644538879395,
0.3745879828929901,
-0.10220371186733246,
-0.10204267501831055,
-0.0009385959128849208,
-0.4042512774467468,
0.5567396283149719,
0.7102628350257874,
0.1684248298406601,
-1.0237598419189453,
-0.3560023903846741,
-0.10705891251564026,
-0.07003120332956314,
-0.2504293620586395,
0.661078155040741,
-1.111376404762268,
0.32706418633461,
0.7983720302581787,
0.5594214200973511,
0.08420084416866302,
0.02473735250532627,
0.4424456059932709,
-0.3291434645652771,
0.22337888181209564,
-0.2061774879693985,
0.6439321041107178,
0.29480481147766113,
-0.032850395888090134,
0.33981969952583313,
0.46756798028945923,
-0.3659804165363312,
-0.6592376232147217,
0.519631028175354,
-0.6200776100158691,
-0.8891952037811279,
1.2915641069412231,
-0.08645685762166977,
-0.15549884736537933,
-0.10823626816272736,
-0.10398582369089127,
0.00794085394591093,
0.15766002237796783,
0.4405476450920105,
0.834232747554779,
-0.20384566485881805,
-0.2818564772605896,
-0.8455424308776855,
0.3518938422203064,
0.6118103265762329,
-0.6964778900146484,
-0.13547027111053467,
0.6457230448722839,
0.5080025792121887,
-0.13196875154972076,
0.5860194563865662,
0.08755453675985336,
0.15764498710632324,
-0.2897307276725769,
-0.6189036965370178,
0.2350100576877594,
-0.35289624333381653,
-0.31594228744506836,
0.06249994784593582,
0.0015302887186408043,
0.3577645719051361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12080v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12080v1 | Can LLMs Compute with Reasons? | 2024-02-19T12:04:25 | 2024-02-19T12:04:25 | Harshit Sandilya, Peehu Raj, Jainit Sushil Bafna, Srija Mukhopadhyay, Shivansh Sharma, Ellwil Sharma, Arastu Sharma, Neeta Trivedi, Manish Shrivastava, Rajesh Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | Large language models (LLMs) often struggle with complex mathematical tasks,
prone to "hallucinating" incorrect answers due to their reliance on statistical
patterns. This limitation is further amplified in average Small LangSLMs with
limited context and training data. To address this challenge, we propose an
"Inductive Learning" approach utilizing a distributed network of SLMs. This
network leverages error-based learning and hint incorporation to refine the
reasoning capabilities of SLMs. Our goal is to provide a framework that
empowers SLMs to approach the level of logic-based applications achieved by
high-parameter models, potentially benefiting any language model. Ultimately,
this novel concept paves the way for bridging the logical gap between humans
and LLMs across various fields. | [
-0.21699710190296173,
-0.5644043684005737,
0.8726990818977356,
0.2593744099140167,
0.005484078079462051,
-0.0003119270841125399,
-0.45063117146492004,
-0.09882109612226486,
0.14349399507045746,
0.4657359719276428,
-0.8440198302268982,
-0.4912039637565613,
-0.47091972827911377,
0.19426760077476501,
-0.4322410225868225,
0.7160365581512451,
0.0799512267112732,
0.30226436257362366,
-0.6343841552734375,
-0.06340859830379486,
-0.39902356266975403,
-0.38812822103500366,
-0.8507564067840576,
-0.6633868217468262,
0.6526002287864685,
0.5125430822372437,
0.5953132510185242,
0.3580348789691925,
0.4970826804637909,
0.306639164686203,
0.2757898271083832,
0.7228506207466125,
-0.17088650166988373,
0.4944191575050354,
-0.4527730643749237,
-0.982912003993988,
-0.05194162577390671,
-0.12610246241092682,
0.49819156527519226,
1.0920814275741577,
-0.27699214220046997,
0.10163690149784088,
-0.05900728330016136,
0.7795743942260742,
-0.4917635917663574,
0.23132842779159546,
-0.8547608256340027,
0.10055588185787201,
-0.06204802915453911,
-0.4292994737625122,
-0.7816586494445801,
-0.46632859110832214,
-0.11257512122392654,
-0.5856510996818542,
0.3307192027568817,
-0.10398586839437485,
0.6610419154167175,
0.48555102944374084,
-0.06010293960571289,
-0.6065106987953186,
-0.7446564435958862,
0.6703975796699524,
-0.6988640427589417,
0.2463173270225525,
0.3124969005584717,
0.3518679440021515,
-0.38728031516075134,
-0.5420728921890259,
-0.41047078371047974,
0.005700377281755209,
-0.18191762268543243,
-0.10870550572872162,
0.16187651455402374,
-0.0022288996260613203,
0.5003430843353271,
-0.12423966825008392,
-0.34771183133125305,
0.23356670141220093,
-0.21672527492046356,
0.06637295335531235,
0.6770631074905396,
0.3551139831542969,
0.3639441132545471,
0.07865491509437561,
-0.07219460606575012,
0.19344426691532135,
-0.9621112942695618,
-0.08801186084747314,
0.11881183087825775,
0.7209806442260742,
0.05300498008728027,
0.6345692873001099,
-0.1690356582403183,
0.6675771474838257,
-0.10359985381364822,
-0.2758287191390991,
0.04643554985523224,
0.1863217055797577,
-0.39794492721557617,
0.22107422351837158,
0.6403639316558838,
0.052026621997356415,
0.1506391167640686,
-0.26893123984336853,
-0.5852421522140503,
0.12726299464702606,
-0.12095078080892563,
-0.6729051470756531,
-0.18804803490638733,
0.15463203191757202,
-0.18894478678703308,
-0.1551155298948288,
-0.1546991914510727,
-0.4643084406852722,
-0.8609718680381775,
-0.642633318901062,
0.48975569009780884,
-0.22952382266521454,
-0.3658725917339325,
0.3382119834423065,
0.009687613695859909,
-0.02072998881340027,
0.7346689105033875,
-0.7944919466972351,
0.45062917470932007,
0.7644618153572083,
0.8367586135864258,
-0.1677873134613037,
-0.35062503814697266,
-0.6314398646354675,
-0.11684942245483398,
-0.5988255739212036,
0.6045762300491333,
-0.4327734112739563,
-0.055994730442762375,
0.0288431067019701,
-0.12446407228708267,
-0.20143699645996094,
-0.942855954170227,
0.4135245680809021,
-0.6325550675392151,
-0.03209801763296127,
-0.42683595418930054,
-0.6210147738456726,
-0.03856101632118225,
0.133863627910614,
-0.6919093132019043,
0.8490716814994812,
-0.01932433992624283,
-0.6316571831703186,
0.12483909726142883,
-0.6330701112747192,
-0.5781776905059814,
0.2634393572807312,
-0.6114192008972168,
-0.24168507754802704,
0.3022727072238922,
0.032054100185632706,
0.6869680285453796,
-0.657203197479248,
0.4265219569206238,
-0.3076833188533783,
-0.2912002503871918,
0.47936582565307617,
-0.25944074988365173,
0.9990123510360718,
0.3347971439361572,
-0.4278157353401184,
0.2189486026763916,
-0.7394555807113647,
0.016345705837011337,
0.4207281768321991,
-0.3793063759803772,
-0.45248469710350037,
0.3549055755138397,
-0.621166467666626,
0.34002721309661865,
0.10878967493772507,
-0.36553752422332764,
0.07491801679134369,
-0.36697548627853394,
0.4438062012195587,
0.8146607875823975,
-0.3158346116542816,
0.40900254249572754,
-0.3264238238334656,
0.5415726900100708,
0.20614710450172424,
-0.26505041122436523,
-0.09905790537595749,
-0.2748323082923889,
-1.1926791667938232,
-0.1805301010608673,
-0.11528342217206955,
0.5306013226509094,
-0.8201212882995605,
0.20392301678657532,
-0.11159726977348328,
-0.20644071698188782,
-0.4999573826789856,
0.42915078997612,
0.09965815395116806,
0.388430655002594,
0.2483585923910141,
0.24642962217330933,
-0.6241196393966675,
-0.48447054624557495,
-0.049811530858278275,
0.06225009635090828,
0.0062336390838027,
0.42612865567207336,
0.35367125272750854,
-0.25318437814712524,
0.9534845352172852,
-0.21190664172172546,
-0.0887896940112114,
-0.4838629364967346,
-0.17452947795391083,
0.34118080139160156,
0.24177253246307373,
0.13448098301887512,
-0.5671752095222473,
-0.28780174255371094,
0.11080578714609146,
-1.1604779958724976,
-0.24638278782367706,
-0.28541409969329834,
-0.09669685363769531,
0.1508403718471527,
0.7685751914978027,
-0.9726375341415405,
0.359582781791687,
0.23795481026172638,
-0.16021203994750977,
0.6799603700637817,
-0.15993525087833405,
-0.4095209538936615,
-0.8356859087944031,
-0.46494317054748535,
0.09463024884462357,
-0.17889560759067535,
-0.3653704822063446,
0.09038350731134415,
-0.11252705752849579,
-0.15918175876140594,
-0.21666957437992096,
0.35721316933631897,
-0.39453762769699097,
-0.3651604950428009,
-0.28633353114128113,
0.34631434082984924,
0.06726619601249695,
0.21547092497348785,
-0.06771348416805267,
0.623677670955658,
0.7515624165534973,
-0.8353064656257629,
0.8277642130851746,
-0.14778821170330048,
-0.2761209309101105,
0.5588414072990417,
-0.71680748462677,
-0.16714522242546082,
-0.3569777309894562,
0.08220238983631134,
-0.7570748329162598,
-0.3059455156326294,
0.04400118440389633,
-0.47183385491371155,
0.10380317270755768,
0.1702885776758194,
-0.72459477186203,
-0.13017398118972778,
0.2151227742433548,
0.2057344615459442,
0.29476413130760193,
-0.9617363810539246,
0.72248774766922,
0.19271360337734222,
0.11150030046701431,
-0.34790512919425964,
-0.5847516655921936,
0.02501741796731949,
-0.3054245114326477,
-0.6770171523094177,
0.008985863998532295,
0.03487836942076683,
-0.7300917506217957,
-0.007267857436090708,
0.24938146770000458,
0.23871144652366638,
0.31958916783332825,
0.45587050914764404,
0.1958855241537094,
-0.25593215227127075,
0.7561867833137512,
-0.14078980684280396,
0.07013978064060211,
0.4608626961708069,
-0.5273227691650391,
0.6140241622924805,
-0.2398342341184616,
-0.6792733669281006,
-0.3284546732902527,
0.3485974073410034,
0.6921367049217224,
-0.38607820868492126,
0.7105841040611267,
0.1714431196451187,
-0.6410583853721619,
-1.0996594429016113,
-0.40655598044395447,
-0.4902169704437256,
-0.521263837814331,
0.24766142666339874,
-0.4497259259223938,
-0.9891983866691589,
0.6142438054084778,
-0.3739754259586334,
-0.14760644733905792,
0.24642181396484375,
0.6859898567199707,
-0.06198545917868614,
1.1004152297973633,
0.3481194078922272,
0.09529069811105728,
0.06200222671031952,
-0.07102879881858826,
0.31209102272987366,
-0.48323431611061096,
-0.4176425337791443,
-0.5179142355918884,
-0.16618035733699799,
-0.4745290279388428,
-0.5074346661567688,
0.19185124337673187,
0.2045540064573288,
-0.4789264500141144,
-0.0726444274187088,
-0.5026739835739136,
0.45983296632766724,
0.42742082476615906,
0.2447405308485031,
0.19332562386989594,
0.14776523411273956,
-0.6104772686958313,
0.0097971735522151,
-0.8199315071105957,
-0.20401696860790253,
0.7565550208091736,
0.4467897117137909,
1.1970698833465576,
0.19186389446258545,
0.7824888229370117,
0.07487986236810684,
0.2913607060909271,
-0.9274634122848511,
0.7378084659576416,
0.02317657694220543,
-0.45061981678009033,
-0.3574830889701843,
-0.6423583030700684,
-0.7190783023834229,
0.11318185925483704,
-0.026819121092557907,
-0.6587694883346558,
-0.023734645918011665,
-0.1577783226966858,
-0.16672855615615845,
0.4495602548122406,
-0.6093842387199402,
0.5192136168479919,
-0.37208831310272217,
-0.38874801993370056,
-0.12587830424308777,
-0.42198190093040466,
0.4352458417415619,
0.15618334710597992,
0.3931249678134918,
-0.28900447487831116,
0.2134299874305725,
0.5778223872184753,
-0.7140535712242126,
1.102429747581482,
-0.2234063297510147,
-0.06184890866279602,
0.4658164978027344,
0.20022761821746826,
0.677106499671936,
0.11203094571828842,
-0.16206224262714386,
-0.269980788230896,
-0.5113253593444824,
-0.21444779634475708,
-0.9016715288162231,
0.8408625721931458,
-0.8387370109558105,
-0.6321836113929749,
-0.3187415897846222,
-0.7267851233482361,
-0.2240632176399231,
0.06781083345413208,
0.09967751801013947,
0.5013241767883301,
0.5312291383743286,
0.02928074635565281,
1.0323289632797241,
-0.09293778985738754,
0.48625051975250244,
0.3697414696216583,
-0.46238332986831665,
-0.0757354199886322,
0.8539588451385498,
-0.04935859888792038,
0.3903438150882721,
0.2342752367258072,
0.2845951318740845,
-0.28646835684776306,
-0.5625403523445129,
-0.2617452144622803,
0.4520033299922943,
-1.2847552299499512,
-0.20271795988082886,
-0.3616475760936737,
-0.3841513991355896,
-0.20530322194099426,
-0.20781035721302032,
-0.3072589039802551,
-0.23319174349308014,
-0.6255797147750854,
-0.35853832960128784,
0.5294966101646423,
0.9342188239097595,
0.07101806253194809,
0.1321815401315689,
-0.42864707112312317,
-0.07919961959123611,
0.3514609634876251,
0.40675678849220276,
0.18822917342185974,
-0.3851495087146759,
-0.3117125332355499,
-0.052086081355810165,
0.1469680815935135,
-0.673976480960846,
0.41627293825149536,
0.2181551605463028,
0.6914989352226257,
0.2367718368768692,
0.2226438969373703,
0.5548744797706604,
-0.4793005585670471,
0.3977341055870056,
0.3999386429786682,
-0.8611128330230713,
0.6500899195671082,
-0.16675087809562683,
0.08538005501031876,
0.4104991555213928,
0.5175500512123108,
-0.39966434240341187,
-0.3143933117389679,
-0.3871101140975952,
-0.5758461356163025,
0.4641433358192444,
-0.22489936649799347,
-0.06100522726774216,
-0.24096500873565674,
0.6841278076171875,
-0.14361150562763214,
0.053552430123090744,
-0.7944933176040649,
-0.2497124820947647,
0.02558206394314766,
-0.33238378167152405,
0.11592116206884384,
0.052227966487407684,
-0.3770327568054199,
-0.37388962507247925,
0.6216587424278259,
-0.4721268117427826,
0.16654923558235168,
0.23362772166728973,
-0.2741398811340332,
-0.17216311395168304,
0.16093052923679352,
0.7098833918571472,
1.0200146436691284,
0.12258149683475494,
0.6363409757614136,
0.13014502823352814,
-0.025079233571887016,
0.19604818522930145,
-0.15225690603256226,
-0.2410559058189392,
0.15681272745132446,
0.19961895048618317,
0.8647258281707764,
-0.09164590388536453,
-0.8803208470344543,
0.44446954131126404,
-0.17289525270462036,
-0.162105992436409,
-0.43448778986930847,
0.07823533564805984,
0.46579641103744507,
0.33957841992378235,
0.5248454809188843,
0.035885777324438095,
-0.15660999715328217,
-0.3327690362930298,
0.38799241185188293,
0.645131528377533,
-0.5075271725654602,
-0.1451939195394516,
0.44701316952705383,
0.09964501857757568,
-0.42687323689460754,
0.5791632533073425,
-0.5953899621963501,
-0.6006525754928589,
0.7570808529853821,
0.8932178020477295,
0.7049275040626526,
-0.1165279969573021,
0.311466246843338,
0.3798583447933197,
0.39052820205688477,
-0.20975066721439362,
0.1754518300294876,
0.13683372735977173,
-1.119341492652893,
-0.6791117787361145,
-0.6875377297401428,
-0.35972580313682556,
0.010693957097828388,
-0.4275072515010834,
0.3218255639076233,
-0.9416049718856812,
0.07745083421468735,
-0.09301333874464035,
-0.16287869215011597,
-0.5580426454544067,
0.35081443190574646,
0.2198808193206787,
0.7094378471374512,
-0.852824866771698,
0.8955078125,
0.6793981194496155,
-0.3604496419429779,
-1.13090980052948,
-0.48178067803382874,
-0.04441084340214729,
-0.8706251978874207,
1.2040278911590576,
0.31122517585754395,
-0.3218195140361786,
-0.013331768102943897,
-0.7183555960655212,
-0.6871786117553711,
1.068862795829773,
0.5145493745803833,
-0.6380353569984436,
-0.03449885547161102,
0.27613359689712524,
0.17896591126918793,
-0.7924867868423462,
0.19310948252677917,
0.5717729926109314,
0.05806432664394379,
0.2646901309490204,
-0.6062221527099609,
0.29309627413749695,
-0.07221586257219315,
-0.10248181968927383,
0.2381899356842041,
-0.34201931953430176,
1.1780933141708374,
-0.4733850359916687,
-0.2004140466451645,
-0.39992275834083557,
0.6106077432632446,
0.5753850936889648,
0.39159896969795227,
0.4239383935928345,
0.8335892558097839,
1.24048912525177,
-0.04785989597439766,
0.758468508720398,
-0.030520346015691757,
0.4853448271751404,
1.2284221649169922,
-0.5577774047851562,
0.6549891233444214,
0.3933238387107849,
-0.25863373279571533,
0.6666731834411621,
0.5662120580673218,
0.3396763801574707,
0.30708757042884827,
0.5832477807998657,
-0.7329267859458923,
-0.5014168620109558,
-0.20269033312797546,
-0.05812996253371239,
0.1220858246088028,
0.9510217308998108,
-0.30220887064933777,
-0.45248040556907654,
0.07055418938398361,
0.038699835538864136,
0.3111344873905182,
-0.6630593538284302,
0.5801583528518677,
0.2954319715499878,
-0.5590625405311584,
0.5902413725852966,
-0.043103933334350586,
0.6599859595298767,
-0.48118218779563904,
-0.050436485558748245,
-0.04234379157423973,
0.3892151415348053,
-0.6408258080482483,
-0.43510547280311584,
0.2658597528934479,
-0.30390655994415283,
-0.18971896171569824,
-0.002238753717392683,
0.8713708519935608,
-0.3972185552120209,
-0.6508001089096069,
0.35979509353637695,
0.5307018756866455,
0.03705649822950363,
0.06783460080623627,
-0.584348201751709,
0.11284840106964111,
-0.14264173805713654,
0.14675770699977875,
0.3332120478153229,
0.7550475597381592,
-0.0875270739197731,
0.9755405187606812,
0.703813374042511,
0.2547934055328369,
0.30888670682907104,
0.3957900106906891,
0.8220909833908081,
-0.5645576119422913,
-0.2653140723705292,
-1.1426470279693604,
0.27140191197395325,
-0.029422268271446228,
0.009690266102552414,
0.8495151996612549,
0.3155638575553894,
0.8289188146591187,
0.18087518215179443,
1.0110762119293213,
0.20925359427928925,
0.6426217555999756,
-0.6461650133132935,
0.5313674211502075,
-0.5426363945007324,
0.6053650379180908,
0.16142654418945312,
-0.5510406494140625,
-0.5560070872306824,
0.8170596957206726,
-0.277447909116745,
-0.16393692791461945,
0.7983489632606506,
0.7308102250099182,
0.26345449686050415,
0.03465411812067032,
0.3349529504776001,
0.026864226907491684,
0.5176481008529663,
0.6315569281578064,
0.9390812516212463,
-0.03746241331100464,
0.20268963277339935,
-0.2775813341140747,
-0.2129814773797989,
-0.2922254800796509,
-0.8774198293685913,
-1.1156315803527832,
-0.4323329031467438,
-0.30786412954330444,
-0.6116264462471008,
-0.1475299596786499,
1.33298921585083,
0.5144578218460083,
-0.7766189575195312,
-0.508006751537323,
-0.6067332029342651,
0.5530821681022644,
-0.07448992133140564,
-0.2557741403579712,
0.17581652104854584,
-1.0149497985839844,
-0.35751914978027344,
0.4073633849620819,
0.3136977553367615,
-0.16386675834655762,
-0.6420039534568787,
-0.3076508939266205,
-0.0875144898891449,
0.16872616112232208,
0.6487274765968323,
0.21706527471542358,
-0.6509846448898315,
-0.10639221966266632,
0.13344374299049377,
-0.34689560532569885,
-0.04083426296710968,
0.9448437690734863,
-0.812642514705658,
0.3766033947467804,
0.4281172454357147,
1.169613242149353,
0.29836544394493103,
-0.27025705575942993,
0.3410381078720093,
-0.7324603796005249,
0.19655679166316986,
0.3243890702724457,
0.4449477195739746,
0.6227231621742249,
-0.4745858311653137,
0.3346620500087738,
0.4907439649105072,
-0.6860548853874207,
-0.8584733605384827,
0.4139389395713806,
-0.6998357772827148,
-0.26617273688316345,
1.2234660387039185,
-0.16966880857944489,
-0.21615613996982574,
-0.012111802585422993,
0.23460574448108673,
0.0027332990430295467,
-0.14802196621894836,
0.516413688659668,
0.6815087199211121,
-0.20560744404792786,
-0.450347900390625,
-0.783029317855835,
0.5429932475090027,
0.4169571101665497,
-0.9041815996170044,
0.10962259769439697,
0.42767655849456787,
0.2685028612613678,
0.23152725398540497,
0.570684552192688,
0.09478816390037537,
0.2084699422121048,
-0.27429813146591187,
0.09138619899749756,
0.06893806904554367,
-0.6231221556663513,
-0.3638473153114319,
0.14522135257720947,
0.4142051339149475,
0.07015717774629593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12079v1 | LVCHAT: Facilitating Long Video Comprehension | 2024-02-19T11:59:14 | 2024-02-19T11:59:14 | Yu Wang, Zeyuan Zhang, Julian McAuley, Zexue He | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Enabling large language models (LLMs) to read videos is vital for multimodal
LLMs. Existing works show promise on short videos whereas long video (longer
than e.g.~1 minute) comprehension remains challenging. The major problem lies
in the over-compression of videos, i.e., the encoded video representations are
not enough to represent the whole video. To address this issue, we propose Long
Video Chat (LVChat), where Frame-Scalable Encoding (FSE) is introduced to
dynamically adjust the number of embeddings in alignment with the duration of
the video to ensure long videos are not overly compressed into a few
embeddings. To deal with long videos whose length is beyond videos seen during
training, we propose Interleaved Frame Encoding (IFE), repeating positional
embedding and interleaving multiple groups of videos to enable long video
input, avoiding performance degradation due to overly long videos. Experimental
results show that LVChat significantly outperforms existing methods by up to
27\% in accuracy on long-video QA datasets and long-video captioning
benchmarks. Our code is published at https://github.com/wangyu-ustc/LVChat. | [
-0.3886038064956665,
-0.9622539281845093,
0.5881072282791138,
0.5894711017608643,
-0.6515177488327026,
0.4885560870170593,
-0.512573778629303,
-0.34625938534736633,
0.4733050465583801,
0.30082905292510986,
-0.675404965877533,
-0.240228533744812,
-0.566298246383667,
-0.156534805893898,
-0.5235207676887512,
0.5219180583953857,
-0.04607938975095749,
0.07058349996805191,
-0.39349082112312317,
-0.32008615136146545,
-0.5392048358917236,
-0.4006313383579254,
-0.34524771571159363,
0.04115186259150505,
0.39056745171546936,
0.6062920689582825,
0.762769341468811,
0.5028402209281921,
0.5771546363830566,
0.3194432854652405,
0.023900415748357773,
0.3446188271045685,
-0.5757806897163391,
0.3271874785423279,
0.13112770020961761,
-0.4517817199230194,
-0.3739895224571228,
-0.5107119679450989,
0.9820452332496643,
0.3030543327331543,
-0.1091335266828537,
0.34470415115356445,
0.02864071913063526,
0.7199972867965698,
-0.6413408517837524,
0.405286580324173,
-0.39986351132392883,
0.089898481965065,
-0.13729655742645264,
-0.5196607112884521,
-0.3655017912387848,
0.0642898678779602,
-0.16221731901168823,
-0.5857959985733032,
-0.18187052011489868,
0.17222177982330322,
0.3646780848503113,
0.703104555606842,
-0.3432311415672302,
-0.05880174785852432,
-0.5887489318847656,
0.6856209635734558,
-0.5521283149719238,
0.6834945678710938,
0.585378885269165,
0.5892961621284485,
-0.1223527118563652,
-0.4940359592437744,
-0.8689137697219849,
-0.25223690271377563,
0.24551934003829956,
0.053518038243055344,
-0.229740709066391,
0.28198301792144775,
0.5171865224838257,
0.4960184097290039,
-0.4802702069282532,
0.4196925759315491,
-0.38868263363838196,
-0.12165006995201111,
0.3652734160423279,
0.13403616845607758,
0.2501599192619324,
-0.25855228304862976,
-0.3574432134628296,
-0.1739576905965805,
-0.3315388858318329,
0.44935113191604614,
0.21760492026805878,
0.03977397829294205,
-0.13998126983642578,
0.7009207010269165,
-0.5572453141212463,
0.5639033913612366,
-0.056052953004837036,
-0.4130938649177551,
0.2632363438606262,
-0.041969940066337585,
-0.6749963164329529,
-0.0017861730884760618,
0.5463930368423462,
0.6301369667053223,
0.100039042532444,
0.16112029552459717,
0.11436448246240616,
0.20720508694648743,
0.01975356973707676,
-0.9323651790618896,
0.021866964176297188,
0.4349513053894043,
-0.33615949749946594,
-0.16688968241214752,
0.014804516918957233,
-1.0072057247161865,
-0.3743468225002289,
-0.3328939974308014,
0.43242499232292175,
-0.294113427400589,
-0.16686762869358063,
0.22056694328784943,
0.02365051582455635,
0.6090871095657349,
0.30988064408302307,
-0.937519371509552,
0.33819010853767395,
0.5558808445930481,
0.8335734605789185,
-0.24484708905220032,
-0.41707083582878113,
-1.0382376909255981,
0.08381470292806625,
-0.14022383093833923,
0.40140560269355774,
-0.4167109429836273,
-0.12587465345859528,
0.30696383118629456,
0.3037254810333252,
0.5099586844444275,
-0.0362226776778698,
0.2971464693546295,
-0.631283700466156,
0.06398550420999527,
-0.08666592091321945,
-0.6167566180229187,
-0.09416785836219788,
0.46113279461860657,
-0.5250759124755859,
0.7598918676376343,
-0.1922179013490677,
-0.6289390921592712,
0.2765790820121765,
-0.4965935945510864,
-0.13803552091121674,
0.04225161299109459,
-0.3621968924999237,
-0.33731669187545776,
-0.04702134057879448,
0.695993959903717,
0.8184006214141846,
-0.14298655092716217,
0.32694268226623535,
-0.3499044179916382,
-0.41606077551841736,
0.2489689290523529,
-0.7989284992218018,
0.23618336021900177,
0.13633127510547638,
-0.09498629719018936,
0.4125250577926636,
-0.5181171298027039,
0.036776795983314514,
-0.11382081359624863,
-0.12116922438144684,
0.029282398521900177,
-0.011224023997783661,
-0.20151054859161377,
-0.055639561265707016,
-0.13655398786067963,
-0.5903050303459167,
0.234204962849617,
-0.11579455435276031,
0.9851404428482056,
0.7837114334106445,
-0.24695292115211487,
0.5374778509140015,
-0.0643046498298645,
0.7918973565101624,
-0.14895644783973694,
0.3196277618408203,
-0.5489891171455383,
-0.1736050844192505,
-0.6810430288314819,
-0.34322914481163025,
-0.15006303787231445,
0.4356082081794739,
-1.2709537744522095,
-0.03584762290120125,
-0.5751217007637024,
-0.3327063322067261,
-0.4925323724746704,
0.26372775435447693,
0.19051165878772736,
0.08968424797058105,
0.48571091890335083,
-0.25039899349212646,
-0.31707102060317993,
-0.7419217228889465,
0.25831684470176697,
-0.09998852014541626,
-0.09558400511741638,
0.11303199827671051,
0.4749029874801636,
-0.37097638845443726,
0.8140752911567688,
-0.5336134433746338,
-0.2446809560060501,
-0.19140581786632538,
-0.34366002678871155,
0.10024527460336685,
0.12660066783428192,
0.4007563889026642,
-0.6556009650230408,
-0.43832823634147644,
-0.23385173082351685,
-0.6315529942512512,
0.4888163208961487,
-0.25431081652641296,
0.019760990515351295,
0.12025284022092819,
1.0229684114456177,
-0.483551025390625,
0.4010002911090851,
1.0480871200561523,
0.05064370855689049,
0.3555102050304413,
-0.40579545497894287,
0.4467194378376007,
-0.9918294548988342,
-0.5177923440933228,
-0.2371566891670227,
-0.7457723617553711,
-0.2743716239929199,
0.18150480091571808,
0.21191315352916718,
-0.4493091106414795,
-0.7889153361320496,
0.22880715131759644,
-0.524664044380188,
-0.16265030205249786,
-0.22090956568717957,
0.34578344225883484,
-0.04614512622356415,
0.7947272062301636,
0.07670727372169495,
0.9025325179100037,
0.7412816286087036,
-0.4944641888141632,
0.8358571529388428,
0.31748518347740173,
-0.6091529726982117,
0.6057893633842468,
-0.5984062552452087,
-0.017128614708781242,
-0.29088354110717773,
0.6615516543388367,
-0.8841253519058228,
-0.7063463926315308,
0.06467723846435547,
-0.5465670228004456,
0.35889115929603577,
-0.0839250385761261,
-0.17367075383663177,
-0.3764491379261017,
-0.637701690196991,
0.667905867099762,
0.5045295357704163,
-0.9994252920150757,
0.3519258499145508,
0.39390331506729126,
0.0027550950180739164,
-0.8436103463172913,
-0.783864438533783,
0.23567096889019012,
-0.4424471855163574,
-0.8774015307426453,
0.37812539935112,
-0.3410481810569763,
0.06676650792360306,
-0.3243557810783386,
-0.12044209241867065,
-0.2220027893781662,
-0.49247831106185913,
0.43753737211227417,
-0.04279564693570137,
-0.2808423936367035,
0.5120894908905029,
0.0270707905292511,
-0.0013933181762695312,
-0.03823859244585037,
-0.011684280820190907,
0.48240354657173157,
-0.2234421670436859,
-0.4773741662502289,
-0.559575617313385,
0.6834183931350708,
0.7725900411605835,
-0.16606836020946503,
0.6239039897918701,
0.7504668235778809,
-0.13236917555332184,
-0.41831353306770325,
-0.6156026721000671,
-0.1492026448249817,
-0.5397961735725403,
0.7182034850120544,
-0.23705311119556427,
-1.4197903871536255,
0.29289743304252625,
0.17109033465385437,
-0.13914355635643005,
-0.12614132463932037,
0.4165577292442322,
-0.5832830667495728,
0.5378639698028564,
0.7357854247093201,
-0.21000857651233673,
0.7620773315429688,
-0.09536134451627731,
0.11986976861953735,
-0.5138181447982788,
-0.09145183861255646,
0.08385486155748367,
-0.2492421418428421,
-0.5658324956893921,
-1.0680416822433472,
0.37454551458358765,
-0.06665337085723877,
-0.19077160954475403,
0.173859104514122,
-0.2631094455718994,
0.8638558387756348,
0.3737998604774475,
0.30363786220550537,
0.11578904837369919,
-0.050792016088962555,
0.6929412484169006,
-0.2693106532096863,
-0.5200454592704773,
-0.08516957610845566,
0.47451987862586975,
0.8789213299751282,
1.024803638458252,
0.34951165318489075,
0.3592973053455353,
0.4200502634048462,
-0.4247910678386688,
-1.0970414876937866,
0.7772371172904968,
-0.10884550958871841,
-0.12353914231061935,
-0.5471909642219543,
-0.12126346677541733,
-0.8187636137008667,
-0.04032989218831062,
-0.04604057967662811,
-0.4478605389595032,
-0.1334618479013443,
0.23524683713912964,
-0.4838356673717499,
0.48282355070114136,
-0.3152465224266052,
0.5088737607002258,
-0.3097648620605469,
-0.4313276410102844,
-0.5549731850624084,
-0.8127239942550659,
0.5448475480079651,
0.18357570469379425,
0.32661429047584534,
0.04263068735599518,
0.039442844688892365,
0.7466509342193604,
-0.5235519409179688,
0.8376129269599915,
0.004845993593335152,
0.02985856868326664,
0.43181681632995605,
-0.00003672787352115847,
0.3221319317817688,
0.5059318542480469,
0.5179589986801147,
-0.0749698132276535,
0.23338887095451355,
-0.5491307973861694,
-0.7588145732879639,
0.484403520822525,
-0.6750214695930481,
-0.7028504014015198,
-0.3847458064556122,
-0.3776609003543854,
-0.29263055324554443,
-0.2292269617319107,
-0.058309901505708694,
0.4671877920627594,
0.10462048649787903,
0.862260103225708,
0.912456214427948,
-0.5282524824142456,
0.7010220289230347,
-0.018042992800474167,
-0.458163857460022,
-0.6039389371871948,
0.829928457736969,
-0.4409652054309845,
0.6189854145050049,
0.6195089221000671,
-0.09323783963918686,
-0.10861367732286453,
-0.4029238820075989,
-0.4118620455265045,
0.06740673631429672,
-0.9871184229850769,
-0.3195444643497467,
-0.26441916823387146,
-0.25215697288513184,
-0.2253098338842392,
-0.1640104204416275,
-0.4685826599597931,
-0.1993769258260727,
-0.18389657139778137,
-0.34180182218551636,
0.645008385181427,
0.24746587872505188,
-0.018097959458827972,
0.6623983383178711,
-1.0237419605255127,
0.5895984768867493,
0.7694899439811707,
0.4143686890602112,
-0.20331332087516785,
-0.846483588218689,
-0.2571740448474884,
-0.13505451381206512,
-0.059128619730472565,
-0.7301247715950012,
0.24977387487888336,
0.17867621779441833,
0.3523108959197998,
0.28996071219444275,
-0.093824103474617,
1.1048625707626343,
-0.40016525983810425,
0.92293381690979,
0.4581454396247864,
-1.0285578966140747,
0.37460634112358093,
-0.4326648414134979,
0.3456226587295532,
0.49650368094444275,
0.3263663351535797,
-0.7337466478347778,
0.03980347886681557,
-0.016515135765075684,
-0.7159729599952698,
0.3021903932094574,
0.20908871293067932,
0.5351499915122986,
0.14024582505226135,
0.1578904390335083,
0.09053979814052582,
0.007464825641363859,
-0.7960864901542664,
0.16828598082065582,
-0.4376550614833832,
0.028319304808974266,
-0.08029284328222275,
-0.5487897396087646,
0.13443827629089355,
-0.2489306628704071,
0.5528277158737183,
-0.3053823709487915,
0.2964402437210083,
0.267564982175827,
-0.39219745993614197,
0.07079660147428513,
0.3829156756401062,
0.7642238140106201,
0.5997956991195679,
-0.23646074533462524,
-0.10067705810070038,
0.44239217042922974,
-0.4873614013195038,
0.0671813040971756,
-0.41641485691070557,
0.5935357213020325,
-0.2060733288526535,
0.5634650588035583,
0.993499755859375,
0.22588084638118744,
-0.8859316110610962,
0.6556499004364014,
-0.21156875789165497,
-0.207044780254364,
-0.5550982356071472,
-0.14957788586616516,
-0.016025273129343987,
0.5549411177635193,
0.0359019860625267,
-0.4576066732406616,
-0.25067636370658875,
-0.81849604845047,
0.30620813369750977,
0.2847532331943512,
-0.32061681151390076,
-0.047037895768880844,
0.6110115051269531,
0.4053191542625427,
-0.4333646893501282,
0.8198810815811157,
-0.03439771384000778,
-0.4236626625061035,
0.2415226697921753,
0.12093651294708252,
0.4855330288410187,
-0.027676057070493698,
0.21983572840690613,
0.44376519322395325,
0.19147498905658722,
-0.24015676975250244,
0.10707587003707886,
-0.46582701802253723,
-0.3465491533279419,
-0.9730947017669678,
-0.5902866125106812,
-0.5807721018791199,
0.057610202580690384,
-0.7679154872894287,
0.5378512740135193,
-0.1208028569817543,
0.044024478644132614,
-0.40587618947029114,
-0.23691526055335999,
-0.5502109527587891,
0.06947394460439682,
0.5050487518310547,
0.9063854217529297,
-0.5918452739715576,
1.1424946784973145,
-0.05083092674612999,
-0.42560669779777527,
-0.6145191192626953,
-0.18526595830917358,
-0.2731616795063019,
-0.9658393859863281,
0.39362800121307373,
0.15351201593875885,
-0.09987238794565201,
-0.40754932165145874,
-0.6718241572380066,
-0.7600806951522827,
1.2473056316375732,
0.1909884661436081,
-1.214182734489441,
-0.3419901132583618,
0.2829229533672333,
0.3031238913536072,
-0.05492144823074341,
0.07119215279817581,
0.36389920115470886,
0.16387954354286194,
0.21726354956626892,
-1.005884051322937,
-0.26901450753211975,
0.031243344768881798,
-0.33086705207824707,
0.05354926735162735,
-0.7590799927711487,
0.45806241035461426,
-0.24574075639247894,
0.17440544068813324,
0.0870758518576622,
1.0810997486114502,
0.23279178142547607,
0.31497707962989807,
0.7528619170188904,
0.1339356154203415,
0.6303529143333435,
0.3315417468547821,
0.6900156140327454,
0.05092170462012291,
0.13340824842453003,
1.4340788125991821,
0.3234240710735321,
1.0648458003997803,
0.8363820910453796,
-0.2884105443954468,
0.32921695709228516,
0.6615443825721741,
0.12147900462150574,
0.36492016911506653,
0.29177042841911316,
-0.09676717221736908,
-0.5683001279830933,
0.20994922518730164,
-0.3703809678554535,
0.7120292782783508,
0.5093967914581299,
-0.17783212661743164,
0.138422429561615,
0.5212370753288269,
-0.22024784982204437,
0.17758361995220184,
-0.459171861410141,
0.44275420904159546,
0.29699617624282837,
-0.5919899344444275,
0.47695475816726685,
-0.42781922221183777,
0.955697774887085,
-0.6782121658325195,
0.02104753628373146,
-0.11084798723459244,
0.08784133195877075,
-0.20369945466518402,
-1.1532260179519653,
0.21627762913703918,
0.04756766930222511,
-0.06406598538160324,
-0.29417380690574646,
0.4076877236366272,
-0.5837224721908569,
-0.30685922503471375,
0.32905715703964233,
0.2598811686038971,
0.2878175675868988,
-0.0875520408153534,
-0.31104642152786255,
0.5218228697776794,
0.0863468125462532,
-0.12864497303962708,
0.40426674485206604,
0.23319275677204132,
-0.2534523606300354,
0.7855467796325684,
0.4102666676044464,
-0.23234044015407562,
-0.03487752750515938,
0.21859408915042877,
0.8178135752677917,
-0.7090913653373718,
-0.5783340930938721,
-0.9842514395713806,
0.6001726984977722,
-0.012560609728097916,
0.011551662348210812,
0.5636412501335144,
0.13377924263477325,
0.735037624835968,
-0.0010028043761849403,
0.3309582471847534,
0.1833210438489914,
0.06227078661322594,
-0.780511736869812,
0.35772842168807983,
-0.6043795347213745,
0.11922036856412888,
-0.1976950764656067,
-0.810806930065155,
-0.3117303252220154,
0.3111220598220825,
0.08187995105981827,
-0.48500198125839233,
0.6508992314338684,
0.6275209188461304,
-0.2877650558948517,
0.045218680053949356,
0.6722297072410583,
0.2421981692314148,
0.7944177985191345,
0.6958908438682556,
1.0535916090011597,
-0.31581008434295654,
0.8979939222335815,
-0.23154553771018982,
-0.0960724875330925,
-0.14940692484378815,
-1.1202995777130127,
-1.0827796459197998,
-0.7787531018257141,
-0.20182932913303375,
-0.09970086812973022,
0.010377091355621815,
0.8931524157524109,
0.7872580289840698,
-0.28436771035194397,
-0.1321641504764557,
0.2839255630970001,
-0.10736369341611862,
0.08583904057741165,
-0.12742109596729279,
0.34754690527915955,
-0.06028998643159866,
-0.6889441013336182,
0.6284137964248657,
0.3005952835083008,
-0.16580989956855774,
-0.5649271011352539,
-0.15237899124622345,
0.16484515368938446,
-0.00009011336078401655,
1.037894606590271,
0.3811315894126892,
-0.8023590445518494,
-0.66975998878479,
0.09897806495428085,
0.24855512380599976,
0.27499309182167053,
0.730449378490448,
-0.6898782253265381,
0.6101986169815063,
0.6216105818748474,
0.7827460169792175,
0.8536966443061829,
-0.06459391862154007,
0.3354666829109192,
-0.7694231867790222,
0.44362205266952515,
0.140518456697464,
0.518578290939331,
0.35063180327415466,
-0.1894047111272812,
0.4023638367652893,
-0.28488028049468994,
-0.8560189604759216,
-1.105918049812317,
0.10501649230718613,
-1.6694324016571045,
-0.2831171751022339,
1.2638245820999146,
-0.027919750660657883,
-0.3109564781188965,
0.20448961853981018,
-0.35458871722221375,
0.18443763256072998,
-0.3916516602039337,
0.6062518358230591,
0.6895999908447266,
-0.05282076075673103,
-0.5221480131149292,
-0.8066061735153198,
0.36815619468688965,
0.3070397675037384,
-0.7337039709091187,
0.1832726150751114,
0.3286912143230438,
0.18021583557128906,
-0.13861189782619476,
0.746880054473877,
0.37186771631240845,
0.531940221786499,
-0.1357135772705078,
-0.3493685722351074,
-0.14073100686073303,
-0.33116641640663147,
-0.27708879113197327,
0.038749583065509796,
-0.11984767764806747,
-0.546316921710968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12071v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12071v2 | EmoBench: Evaluating the Emotional Intelligence of Large Language Models | 2024-02-19T11:48:09 | 2024-06-07T07:43:45 | Sahand Sabour, Siyang Liu, Zheyuan Zhang, June M. Liu, Jinfeng Zhou, Alvionna S. Sunaryo, Juanzi Li, Tatia M. C. Lee, Rada Mihalcea, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have highlighted the need for
robust, comprehensive, and challenging benchmarks. Yet, research on evaluating
their Emotional Intelligence (EI) is considerably limited. Existing benchmarks
have two major shortcomings: first, they mainly focus on emotion recognition,
neglecting essential EI capabilities such as emotion regulation and thought
facilitation through emotion understanding; second, they are primarily
constructed from existing datasets, which include frequent patterns, explicit
information, and annotation errors, leading to unreliable evaluation. We
propose EmoBench, a benchmark that draws upon established psychological
theories and proposes a comprehensive definition for machine EI, including
Emotional Understanding and Emotional Application. EmoBench includes a set of
400 hand-crafted questions in English and Chinese, which are meticulously
designed to require thorough reasoning and understanding. Our findings reveal a
considerable gap between the EI of existing LLMs and the average human,
highlighting a promising direction for future research. Our code and data are
publicly available at https://github.com/Sahandfer/EmoBench. | [
-0.3624767065048218,
-0.7592397928237915,
0.44231802225112915,
0.37022411823272705,
0.08466069400310516,
-0.06635196506977081,
-0.4646434485912323,
-0.5064736604690552,
0.06074727699160576,
-0.015095232054591179,
-0.683847963809967,
-0.3703373372554779,
-0.3386263847351074,
0.25558656454086304,
-0.2857706844806671,
0.5476062297821045,
-0.015793172642588615,
-0.269654244184494,
0.028701769188046455,
-0.27894774079322815,
0.03610934317111969,
-0.6367295384407043,
-0.4223501980304718,
-0.45897582173347473,
0.5943153500556946,
0.4156530797481537,
0.31227195262908936,
0.3723914921283722,
0.3359425961971283,
0.2636067569255829,
-0.08879546076059341,
0.106783427298069,
-0.6359794735908508,
0.2215508073568344,
0.16453193128108978,
-0.5170519351959229,
-0.4741901755332947,
-0.0020735193975269794,
0.36170271039009094,
0.5423119068145752,
-0.27631285786628723,
0.28464365005493164,
-0.014831078238785267,
0.8069409728050232,
-0.8854153752326965,
-0.0834348127245903,
-0.2734077572822571,
0.3675130307674408,
-0.15761718153953552,
-0.009150000289082527,
-0.4649496376514435,
-0.49097031354904175,
0.04426056519150734,
-0.40869852900505066,
-0.2769022285938263,
0.46798208355903625,
0.670754075050354,
0.38915878534317017,
-0.41871359944343567,
-0.3694366216659546,
-0.3308190703392029,
0.6301017999649048,
-0.6046739220619202,
0.5816056728363037,
0.38265201449394226,
0.06672168523073196,
0.1883503794670105,
-0.45862433314323425,
-0.2792932391166687,
-0.3034602701663971,
0.15145689249038696,
0.35081472992897034,
-0.6227377653121948,
-0.0067567299120128155,
0.46576735377311707,
0.1301611363887787,
-0.6969980001449585,
0.2826825678348541,
-0.08854428678750992,
0.27555927634239197,
0.5450891256332397,
0.43701761960983276,
0.12222765386104584,
0.0036161092575639486,
0.018747111782431602,
-0.01058043073862791,
-0.49467575550079346,
0.22579894959926605,
0.3450911343097687,
-0.10421635210514069,
-0.0355137437582016,
0.5755012631416321,
-0.27627745270729065,
0.302030473947525,
0.21940302848815918,
0.3600357174873352,
0.47307997941970825,
0.2882363498210907,
-0.2919856607913971,
-0.010544268414378166,
0.566621720790863,
0.5101132392883301,
0.2745911777019501,
-0.23909635841846466,
-0.20998188853263855,
-0.2724856734275818,
0.1596067249774933,
-1.0189688205718994,
-0.09858284145593643,
0.664124608039856,
-0.5133148431777954,
-0.06405341625213623,
0.0038054909091442823,
-1.017179012298584,
-0.5713902711868286,
-0.11015629023313522,
0.18639101088047028,
-0.5741204619407654,
-0.3772328197956085,
-0.1547062247991562,
0.00989637803286314,
0.3749309778213501,
0.15055759251117706,
-0.8986908197402954,
0.1201409175992012,
1.099583387374878,
0.781929612159729,
0.35104960203170776,
-0.4403916001319885,
-0.2482575923204422,
-0.012365961447358131,
-0.39233139157295227,
0.7412377595901489,
-0.687343955039978,
-0.13932520151138306,
0.29880207777023315,
-0.1028110533952713,
-0.05016058310866356,
-0.5129718780517578,
0.7559089660644531,
-0.16976208984851837,
-0.2842424809932709,
-0.26503443717956543,
-0.6668282151222229,
-0.44939935207366943,
0.4426187574863434,
-0.5669193267822266,
1.2339311838150024,
-0.061794213950634,
-0.5784673690795898,
0.12453582137823105,
-0.4741050601005554,
-0.4254704713821411,
-0.1138802021741867,
0.0750654861330986,
-0.09175137430429459,
0.6180610656738281,
0.2576848864555359,
0.5310160517692566,
-0.6806445717811584,
0.21615730226039886,
-0.809372067451477,
-0.34689033031463623,
0.6209647059440613,
-0.2330428957939148,
0.7152596116065979,
0.19422246515750885,
-0.4381157457828522,
-0.2752353250980377,
-0.6435276865959167,
0.34997794032096863,
0.019347166642546654,
0.0015524367336183786,
-0.388010174036026,
-0.05570114403963089,
0.04312203824520111,
0.14883773028850555,
0.32257014513015747,
-0.532723069190979,
-0.18546055257320404,
-0.22966012358665466,
0.3671571910381317,
0.9171726703643799,
-0.44162020087242126,
0.17477798461914062,
-0.288187712430954,
0.4915466904640198,
-0.5771820545196533,
0.12589406967163086,
-0.18087178468704224,
-0.06395597010850906,
-0.958177387714386,
-0.44524821639060974,
0.03291873261332512,
0.4698600172996521,
0.0067634922452270985,
0.5862182974815369,
-0.0867019072175026,
-1.0528450012207031,
-0.7947641015052795,
0.12199561297893524,
0.3922862112522125,
-0.008475301787257195,
-0.0447533018887043,
0.07224883139133453,
-0.5246242880821228,
-0.8826024532318115,
-0.5036770105361938,
-0.18038798868656158,
-0.2874668836593628,
0.6249023079872131,
0.6187753677368164,
-0.24935461580753326,
0.6399396061897278,
-0.2581334412097931,
0.055019840598106384,
-0.20089556276798248,
0.4179248809814453,
0.11648479849100113,
0.19084076583385468,
0.4266655147075653,
-0.45591527223587036,
-0.2504250705242157,
0.06192771717905998,
-0.9420326352119446,
-0.6062905192375183,
0.19304686784744263,
-0.331179141998291,
-0.0031051128171384335,
0.41810014843940735,
-0.30636194348335266,
0.1007138267159462,
0.6201770305633545,
-0.28404486179351807,
0.2755908668041229,
0.003945576027035713,
0.4377554655075073,
-0.6218770742416382,
0.5073737502098083,
0.09610234946012497,
0.12679478526115417,
-0.6497689485549927,
-0.05354198068380356,
0.24213925004005432,
-0.2390916496515274,
-0.2886987328529358,
0.45943742990493774,
-0.41403353214263916,
-0.12210152298212051,
-0.07019510865211487,
0.31252044439315796,
-0.06230931356549263,
0.4565281569957733,
-0.3744036555290222,
0.13493458926677704,
0.16444702446460724,
-0.3816794157028198,
0.6290373206138611,
0.0432126447558403,
-0.33558762073516846,
0.991043746471405,
-0.7052739262580872,
0.432904452085495,
0.01576862670481205,
0.049940697848796844,
-0.636902928352356,
-0.24536320567131042,
-0.0071786572225391865,
-0.39944732189178467,
0.18739773333072662,
0.3374747037887573,
-0.4833321273326874,
-0.4168592095375061,
-0.43599095940589905,
0.18084555864334106,
0.6187828183174133,
-0.6290808916091919,
1.0707848072052002,
0.4584202766418457,
-0.32023829221725464,
-0.44419798254966736,
-0.5380247831344604,
-0.044044576585292816,
-0.1720828264951706,
-0.6096950769424438,
0.1151944175362587,
-0.09147138893604279,
-0.42378395795822144,
0.1284647434949875,
0.07138071954250336,
-0.17347130179405212,
0.4551423490047455,
0.46254080533981323,
-0.2594812512397766,
-0.1259019523859024,
0.4389028251171112,
-0.034702710807323456,
-0.00038692279485985637,
0.26901161670684814,
0.4363510012626648,
0.3724870979785919,
-0.6080021262168884,
-0.40517571568489075,
-0.2948938012123108,
0.31447842717170715,
0.6466911435127258,
-0.3163861334323883,
0.5703694224357605,
0.6528804898262024,
-0.6900362372398376,
-0.45839160680770874,
-0.6931277513504028,
-0.05005894973874092,
-0.42485469579696655,
0.8621219396591187,
-0.5008059740066528,
-0.870796263217926,
0.5227892398834229,
-0.402241975069046,
0.18491888046264648,
0.14784909784793854,
0.7161887884140015,
-0.30021682381629944,
1.1403175592422485,
0.5896958112716675,
0.07587966322898865,
0.3615491986274719,
0.1996425986289978,
0.2941432297229767,
-1.0487481355667114,
-0.29305770993232727,
-0.6986396312713623,
-0.46327531337738037,
-0.27419134974479675,
-0.20319469273090363,
-0.10859851539134979,
-0.05885839834809303,
-0.7473165392875671,
-0.1271027773618698,
-0.159908264875412,
0.25099849700927734,
0.31519636511802673,
0.12889552116394043,
-0.09888304024934769,
-0.30350735783576965,
-0.03630021587014198,
-0.2064971625804901,
-0.4425516426563263,
-0.6331828236579895,
0.8823152184486389,
0.5054436922073364,
0.9140751361846924,
0.17988382279872894,
0.4536684453487396,
0.1836448311805725,
0.7473294138908386,
-0.7128658890724182,
0.5781548023223877,
-0.007773782592266798,
-0.7284501194953918,
-0.09833356738090515,
-0.33194324374198914,
-0.6280583739280701,
0.34362509846687317,
-0.13527946174144745,
-1.0119868516921997,
0.02185095101594925,
0.006006239913403988,
-0.22235436737537384,
0.15393923223018646,
-0.6570155024528503,
0.8934186100959778,
-0.8449108004570007,
-0.42110201716423035,
-0.48943737149238586,
-0.25439199805259705,
0.2707352042198181,
-0.4059111773967743,
0.17397816479206085,
-0.705366849899292,
-0.24691708385944366,
1.0127981901168823,
-0.11997605860233307,
0.7283602952957153,
0.04072599112987518,
0.07635480910539627,
0.03623056784272194,
0.05684845522046089,
0.2323002964258194,
-0.2834107279777527,
-0.652348518371582,
0.03189585730433464,
-0.25008872151374817,
-0.2885655462741852,
-0.7150938510894775,
0.457526296377182,
-0.6462023258209229,
-0.5445457696914673,
-0.4341762661933899,
-0.344430536031723,
-0.2164631187915802,
-0.1150251179933548,
-0.10088453441858292,
0.14562925696372986,
-0.5965715050697327,
0.5680218935012817,
0.13033707439899445,
-0.43215253949165344,
0.12203063815832138,
0.7829471826553345,
-0.21852830052375793,
-0.48255017399787903,
0.7282934784889221,
0.07247452437877655,
-0.08247268199920654,
0.2790030241012573,
0.13265755772590637,
-0.25970470905303955,
0.0985412672162056,
-0.20255790650844574,
0.26221004128456116,
-0.8119984865188599,
0.04099256917834282,
-0.5586559176445007,
0.14969852566719055,
-0.10262523591518402,
-0.42544153332710266,
-0.553688645362854,
0.006886095739901066,
-0.12770682573318481,
-0.26004162430763245,
0.48192042112350464,
0.8614624738693237,
-0.1876116693019867,
-0.12417078763246536,
-0.8158152103424072,
-0.22032102942466736,
0.1486552655696869,
0.2522561252117157,
0.48150625824928284,
-0.6642524003982544,
-0.545122504234314,
-0.1203409880399704,
-0.3500535190105438,
-0.9919753670692444,
0.5980521440505981,
0.49221768975257874,
0.6618865728378296,
0.8110920190811157,
0.37868210673332214,
0.7242136597633362,
-0.4839845597743988,
0.3156396746635437,
0.04778515174984932,
-1.3524388074874878,
0.5671200156211853,
0.02000328339636326,
0.028096871450543404,
0.5005602240562439,
0.5051314830780029,
-0.7928710579872131,
-0.42714717984199524,
-0.37640076875686646,
-0.8678795099258423,
0.5127933621406555,
0.06550439447164536,
-0.08011927455663681,
0.19903649389743805,
0.14374107122421265,
0.033151596784591675,
0.1929120123386383,
-0.5061402320861816,
-0.08931578695774078,
0.13151001930236816,
-0.5953835844993591,
-0.07323107123374939,
-0.2544931173324585,
0.005728616379201412,
-0.18079426884651184,
0.516611635684967,
0.04729616641998291,
0.34344297647476196,
0.05588819459080696,
-0.28917059302330017,
-0.21110209822654724,
0.39395958185195923,
0.04256635531783104,
0.3418096601963043,
-0.4246087372303009,
0.09422063082456589,
0.5077365040779114,
-0.11284574121236801,
0.30876386165618896,
0.18319010734558105,
0.12866568565368652,
-0.3296002447605133,
0.31536105275154114,
0.6792404651641846,
0.5329452157020569,
-1.188263177871704,
0.2554417550563812,
-0.0045155733823776245,
0.0025083383079618216,
-0.426358163356781,
-0.2423492968082428,
0.17464111745357513,
0.6351435780525208,
0.43113890290260315,
-0.358662486076355,
0.11091534048318863,
-0.547002911567688,
0.05376264825463295,
0.07592575997114182,
-0.5522836446762085,
-0.6054078936576843,
0.3383307456970215,
0.6110588312149048,
-0.3504480719566345,
0.9026921391487122,
-0.0978766456246376,
-0.9600411057472229,
0.7746158838272095,
0.4431666135787964,
1.1526726484298706,
-0.34781673550605774,
-0.07374497503042221,
0.4060947000980377,
0.7877455949783325,
0.11041661351919174,
0.40862205624580383,
0.24524734914302826,
-0.6312158107757568,
-0.05667194351553917,
-0.4006781578063965,
-0.789705216884613,
-0.16767476499080658,
-0.727806806564331,
0.13937966525554657,
-0.45647212862968445,
-0.28491315245628357,
-0.32597166299819946,
0.06400542706251144,
-0.9069136381149292,
0.16109474003314972,
0.5252757668495178,
0.7473270893096924,
-1.0044548511505127,
0.30581462383270264,
0.8512165546417236,
-0.10356150567531586,
-0.715655505657196,
-0.1440129578113556,
0.18202896416187286,
-0.6731687188148499,
0.6576592326164246,
0.8561881184577942,
-0.03344332054257393,
-0.04548129066824913,
-0.23625685274600983,
-0.5968335270881653,
0.9186269044876099,
0.32998353242874146,
-0.4986465871334076,
0.2651488482952118,
-0.26963722705841064,
0.5219475626945496,
-0.5631979703903198,
0.9964060187339783,
0.7329433560371399,
0.6306201815605164,
-0.45394212007522583,
-0.6592432260513306,
0.1618800312280655,
-0.7832251787185669,
-0.3431706130504608,
0.13083547353744507,
-1.0007685422897339,
0.8338260054588318,
-0.3156542181968689,
-0.2831917703151703,
0.056428421288728714,
0.48637887835502625,
0.21943381428718567,
0.4999220669269562,
0.3883596956729889,
0.8848674297332764,
1.0791294574737549,
-0.26036614179611206,
0.8305016756057739,
-0.44844284653663635,
0.4329913556575775,
0.7298761010169983,
-0.8383376002311707,
1.2822798490524292,
0.1092299148440361,
-0.1997067630290985,
0.26711660623550415,
0.8337005376815796,
-0.2001248151063919,
0.17228391766548157,
0.2941645681858063,
-0.07176776975393295,
-0.3556000888347626,
-0.3492400050163269,
-0.3312869668006897,
0.48716312646865845,
0.5524758696556091,
-0.30633366107940674,
0.24929659068584442,
0.052985381335020065,
0.06958209723234177,
-0.23152437806129456,
-0.1961023509502411,
0.47882381081581116,
0.22893263399600983,
-0.3963042199611664,
0.42499589920043945,
-0.15504127740859985,
0.6016045212745667,
-0.2802101671695709,
0.2888634502887726,
-0.231668159365654,
0.40450519323349,
-0.19355817139148712,
-0.6993237137794495,
-0.06886719167232513,
0.5857358574867249,
0.2479030042886734,
0.017682913690805435,
0.31702521443367004,
-0.11755366623401642,
-0.40029376745224,
0.695290207862854,
0.6583519577980042,
0.32683345675468445,
0.08281400799751282,
-0.7772930860519409,
0.2527656853199005,
-0.02410714514553547,
-0.7039300203323364,
0.0644034594297409,
0.9406631588935852,
0.6260337829589844,
0.9038151502609253,
0.352066308259964,
-0.20862847566604614,
-0.004432424437254667,
0.0768011063337326,
0.6704499125480652,
-0.9381130337715149,
-0.371823787689209,
-0.9624278545379639,
0.28532761335372925,
-0.15074847638607025,
-0.5849704146385193,
0.6748442053794861,
0.4401859939098358,
0.5244688987731934,
0.17672263085842133,
0.6980748772621155,
-0.1806851029396057,
0.444282591342926,
-0.09568055719137192,
0.7136180400848389,
-0.9171174168586731,
-0.1819753497838974,
-0.4160977303981781,
-0.8645321726799011,
-0.12170110642910004,
0.8585350513458252,
-0.47963857650756836,
0.15455278754234314,
0.8032875061035156,
0.7728039026260376,
0.28107360005378723,
0.2988013029098511,
0.5368061065673828,
0.4686492681503296,
0.16065391898155212,
1.0241833925247192,
1.2584879398345947,
-0.1848871409893036,
0.5185835957527161,
-0.3263168931007385,
-0.4305417835712433,
-0.6648986339569092,
-0.9206671118736267,
-1.0016781091690063,
-0.22333675622940063,
-0.22224968671798706,
-0.07253638654947281,
0.19793958961963654,
1.283181071281433,
0.48099949955940247,
-0.5564579367637634,
-0.3224567770957947,
0.327789843082428,
-0.19061245024204254,
-0.20699448883533478,
-0.09611836075782776,
0.3237031400203705,
-0.034308187663555145,
-0.8209287524223328,
-0.025386624038219452,
0.5069852471351624,
-0.2347700148820877,
-0.08664056658744812,
-0.27995380759239197,
0.09162735193967819,
0.31377676129341125,
0.46253305673599243,
0.3698333501815796,
-0.7248967289924622,
-0.1341128647327423,
0.2714807391166687,
-0.25971850752830505,
-0.19334577023983002,
0.6026402711868286,
-0.1451396495103836,
0.4652373492717743,
0.40708667039871216,
0.8473180532455444,
0.16475293040275574,
-0.12096288800239563,
0.6935100555419922,
-0.1850183606147766,
0.1624293029308319,
0.4100918769836426,
0.6537114977836609,
0.2934046983718872,
0.00135290517937392,
0.7039535641670227,
-0.21006597578525543,
-0.6968153715133667,
-0.9846944808959961,
-0.011207341216504574,
-0.6455697417259216,
0.0032762906048446894,
0.8970713019371033,
-0.5430054068565369,
-0.5023428797721863,
0.12803266942501068,
-0.16510459780693054,
0.31084075570106506,
-0.5679227113723755,
0.7002706527709961,
0.8034550547599792,
-0.14626270532608032,
-0.4807118773460388,
-0.5355063676834106,
-0.02859589084982872,
0.8698403835296631,
-0.8752173781394958,
0.35611391067504883,
0.4071061313152313,
-0.26346954703330994,
-0.13719096779823303,
0.28426530957221985,
0.27199259400367737,
0.32593807578086853,
0.14455898106098175,
0.433450847864151,
0.1590123176574707,
-0.11564946174621582,
-0.3929153382778168,
0.21300174295902252,
0.14989709854125977,
0.27236706018447876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12065v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12065v2 | WKVQuant: Quantizing Weight and Key/Value Cache for Large Language Models Gains More | 2024-02-19T11:33:21 | 2024-02-20T08:48:24 | Yuxuan Yue, Zhihang Yuan, Haojie Duanmu, Sifan Zhou, Jianlong Wu, Liqiang Nie | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) face significant deployment challenges due to
their substantial memory requirements and the computational demands of
auto-regressive text generation process. This paper addresses these challenges
by focusing on the quantization of LLMs, a technique that reduces memory
consumption by converting model parameters and activations into low-bit
integers. We critically analyze the existing quantization approaches,
identifying their limitations in balancing the accuracy and efficiency of the
quantized LLMs. To advance beyond these limitations, we propose WKVQuant, a PTQ
framework especially designed for quantizing weights and the key/value (KV)
cache of LLMs. Specifically, we incorporates past-only quantization to improve
the computation of attention. Additionally, we introduce two-dimensional
quantization strategy to handle the distribution of KV cache, along with a
cross-block reconstruction regularization for parameter optimization.
Experiments show that WKVQuant achieves almost comparable memory savings to
weight-activation quantization, while also approaching the performance of
weight-only quantization. | [
-0.06215449795126915,
-0.4301626980304718,
0.4951431155204773,
0.1977563202381134,
-0.47560107707977295,
0.019719673320651054,
-0.15705035626888275,
-0.033116184175014496,
-0.22886821627616882,
0.4247184693813324,
-0.23113659024238586,
-0.40095430612564087,
-0.5139217972755432,
-0.30731913447380066,
-0.2497047781944275,
0.6436825394630432,
-0.011336668394505978,
0.030341750010848045,
-0.506783664226532,
-0.1546856015920639,
-0.3505280315876007,
-0.5805933475494385,
-0.7006208300590515,
-0.22647543251514435,
0.4325798451900482,
0.1951562464237213,
0.7010927200317383,
0.573429524898529,
0.32601305842399597,
0.22485962510108948,
-0.04635694995522499,
-0.29531630873680115,
-0.5570769309997559,
0.4281911849975586,
0.24643445014953613,
-0.6220652461051941,
-0.40232473611831665,
-0.2802771329879761,
0.7963188886642456,
0.6164280772209167,
-0.2419307380914688,
0.2739235460758209,
-0.21955618262290955,
0.9885682463645935,
-1.2105247974395752,
0.19246406853199005,
-0.4698309302330017,
0.12725955247879028,
-0.13455823063850403,
-0.03087041899561882,
-0.25508633255958557,
-0.36941346526145935,
0.20588237047195435,
-0.5805404782295227,
-0.09773822873830795,
-0.10917370766401291,
0.5284938812255859,
0.4933488368988037,
-0.6026222109794617,
0.10089025646448135,
-0.7403995394706726,
1.0451172590255737,
-0.9739335775375366,
0.6529360413551331,
0.5061625242233276,
0.002524860668927431,
0.02350841648876667,
-0.7410345673561096,
-0.41445192694664,
-0.19508805871009827,
0.4418797791004181,
0.10784374922513962,
-0.16134320199489594,
0.11385621875524521,
0.2605537176132202,
0.4221753180027008,
-0.6298658847808838,
-0.09797404706478119,
-0.17722809314727783,
-0.2883540093898773,
0.3745483160018921,
0.142618790268898,
-0.17631535232067108,
-0.005883757956326008,
-0.07951747626066208,
-0.39493492245674133,
-0.8379005789756775,
0.1690206676721573,
0.3206120729446411,
-0.04980781301856041,
0.21364419162273407,
0.6438860297203064,
-0.5509938597679138,
0.5848591923713684,
0.0537012442946434,
-0.3347072899341583,
-0.010927476920187473,
-0.21217027306556702,
-0.3556385338306427,
0.05268065631389618,
0.8547303676605225,
0.20631839334964752,
0.1906006634235382,
-0.10072186589241028,
-0.18002179265022278,
-0.15937086939811707,
0.17154061794281006,
-1.2024903297424316,
-0.45794621109962463,
0.2545526921749115,
-0.5700070858001709,
-0.29285305738449097,
-0.38391807675361633,
-0.35995784401893616,
-0.15484872460365295,
-0.14631031453609467,
0.5520899891853333,
-0.4628443121910095,
-0.2768407464027405,
0.17443467676639557,
-0.03707147762179375,
0.15334737300872803,
0.275939017534256,
-0.7404693961143494,
0.08729801326990128,
0.5439790487289429,
0.627661943435669,
0.045210354030132294,
0.17267361283302307,
-0.5356349349021912,
0.22013550996780396,
-0.3517265319824219,
0.39215293526649475,
-0.3756875991821289,
-0.2774654030799866,
-0.0009402667637914419,
-0.28843873739242554,
0.43357598781585693,
-0.2900354266166687,
0.31470558047294617,
-0.8680163621902466,
-0.07947035133838654,
-0.4423532783985138,
-0.49222680926322937,
0.05456066131591797,
0.2019936591386795,
-0.8023748397827148,
1.2267621755599976,
0.1896941363811493,
-0.7420700192451477,
0.20998059213161469,
-0.051188092678785324,
-0.4945313036441803,
0.1846439093351364,
0.2147270143032074,
-0.5845901966094971,
0.5317952632904053,
0.008433008566498756,
0.19974473118782043,
-0.5027430057525635,
0.1306595802307129,
-0.2857138514518738,
-0.311277836561203,
0.23907515406608582,
-0.5849339962005615,
0.5455821752548218,
0.2886413335800171,
-0.1365661919116974,
-0.1044296994805336,
-0.7861237525939941,
0.3509068191051483,
0.16172392666339874,
-0.42012956738471985,
-0.7670356631278992,
0.3135729134082794,
-0.1341884881258011,
0.15650798380374908,
0.5199078321456909,
-0.3045651912689209,
0.3416789174079895,
-0.473367303609848,
0.5938816666603088,
0.4828238785266876,
-0.06407521665096283,
0.5286621451377869,
0.011686176992952824,
0.5759173631668091,
-0.006671286653727293,
0.2180316001176834,
-0.0954967811703682,
-0.35995492339134216,
-0.8923384547233582,
-0.19761349260807037,
0.46632131934165955,
0.36304381489753723,
-0.8094697594642639,
0.2731356620788574,
-0.4491601884365082,
-0.308113694190979,
-0.5367564558982849,
-0.07077771425247192,
0.5068018436431885,
0.1635386347770691,
0.07832233607769012,
-0.21484273672103882,
-0.40091750025749207,
-0.8430526256561279,
-0.07244925200939178,
-0.41822418570518494,
-0.20474104583263397,
0.13271917402744293,
0.2104647308588028,
0.06518009305000305,
1.0115854740142822,
-0.5102631449699402,
0.07338128238916397,
0.17534057796001434,
0.37104591727256775,
-0.21265850961208344,
0.4309055507183075,
0.047361429780721664,
-0.8490371704101562,
-0.6285803914070129,
-0.06889944523572922,
-0.15669526159763336,
-0.33523282408714294,
0.15939952433109283,
0.005281312856823206,
0.3655085563659668,
0.5640382170677185,
-0.6970880627632141,
0.3011295795440674,
0.709322988986969,
0.015025709755718708,
0.44421300292015076,
-0.1462995409965515,
0.13972586393356323,
-1.0562857389450073,
0.23140613734722137,
-0.29320910573005676,
-0.42573463916778564,
-0.3145498037338257,
-0.09068979322910309,
0.4042397141456604,
-0.09627664089202881,
-0.44868335127830505,
0.5404741764068604,
-0.35863131284713745,
-0.1294415444135666,
-0.35332387685775757,
0.0852397233247757,
0.23874343931674957,
0.4604048728942871,
-0.09351517260074615,
0.7220911979675293,
0.2656742036342621,
-0.5028871893882751,
0.5214994549751282,
-0.07213868945837021,
-0.13673143088817596,
0.6934608221054077,
-0.5772261023521423,
0.0854806900024414,
-0.14656662940979004,
0.19516901671886444,
-1.0786964893341064,
0.208674818277359,
-0.05825674161314964,
-0.37690269947052,
0.28406810760498047,
-0.43156179785728455,
-0.8563600182533264,
-0.3050616681575775,
-0.5540090799331665,
0.8578425645828247,
0.6802698969841003,
-0.14389576017856598,
0.3423210680484772,
0.3205093443393707,
-0.10015104711055756,
-0.4737218916416168,
-0.5386093258857727,
-0.012433917261660099,
-0.1415654420852661,
-0.48835909366607666,
0.36526116728782654,
-0.10668991506099701,
-0.13433174788951874,
0.08772385120391846,
-0.31258171796798706,
-0.09678640961647034,
-0.056818731129169464,
0.030936207622289658,
-0.043098971247673035,
-0.3072836995124817,
0.47401294112205505,
0.15996114909648895,
-0.2319761961698532,
0.03517899662256241,
-0.8680185079574585,
0.5846408605575562,
-0.0582050159573555,
-0.22000521421432495,
-0.1891866773366928,
0.3769235908985138,
0.631110429763794,
-0.5134090185165405,
0.6931361556053162,
0.6454757452011108,
-0.3606216311454773,
-0.08319873362779617,
-0.6409682631492615,
0.027988389134407043,
-0.47617682814598083,
0.6638339757919312,
-0.36473849415779114,
-1.1243808269500732,
0.4185839295387268,
-0.17867448925971985,
-0.09319280087947845,
0.4060477018356323,
0.9263532757759094,
-0.04626177251338959,
1.2840512990951538,
0.5449817776679993,
-0.14083245396614075,
0.49308446049690247,
-0.10767125338315964,
0.31089645624160767,
-0.8985528945922852,
-0.03437700867652893,
-0.39919230341911316,
-0.2688475549221039,
-0.4721534550189972,
-0.5265958905220032,
0.4327505826950073,
0.38838958740234375,
-0.24219335615634918,
0.09078377485275269,
-0.3929955065250397,
0.3784118592739105,
0.4934782385826111,
-0.16821493208408356,
0.35735389590263367,
-0.035659536719322205,
-0.04046342894434929,
-0.3094389736652374,
-0.6100702285766602,
-0.08896361291408539,
1.1605089902877808,
0.21767853200435638,
0.9901854991912842,
0.10556977242231369,
0.3779142498970032,
0.12342311441898346,
0.23874105513095856,
-1.1010619401931763,
0.41172337532043457,
-0.1754535585641861,
-0.2609086036682129,
-0.5401043891906738,
-0.731120765209198,
-0.8596625328063965,
0.4103944003582001,
0.061584439128637314,
-0.5627155303955078,
-0.04809493198990822,
0.2048066109418869,
-0.434839129447937,
0.10346584022045135,
-0.6351786255836487,
0.8821490406990051,
-0.13519391417503357,
-0.3121689558029175,
-0.2825089693069458,
-0.4983941316604614,
0.4805201292037964,
-0.19307398796081543,
-0.071881502866745,
-0.04720800742506981,
-0.3853091597557068,
0.6778200268745422,
-0.5483963489532471,
0.7191258072853088,
-0.09879416227340698,
-0.5344765782356262,
0.2414388209581375,
0.13429296016693115,
0.937828779220581,
0.09654296934604645,
0.23773284256458282,
-0.18032997846603394,
0.3005150258541107,
-0.4368508458137512,
-0.5615372657775879,
0.7903534173965454,
-0.6710714101791382,
-0.36549293994903564,
-0.22012309730052948,
-0.8106133341789246,
-0.3876326084136963,
0.20498062670230865,
0.1408235728740692,
0.2509911060333252,
-0.0382123664021492,
0.38875487446784973,
1.1520265340805054,
-0.30183708667755127,
0.4142594039440155,
0.5905928015708923,
0.09706182777881622,
-0.5967737436294556,
0.9152774810791016,
0.17683133482933044,
0.5573845505714417,
0.7862746715545654,
0.3500240445137024,
-0.27835339307785034,
-0.5179448127746582,
0.007247273810207844,
0.18222084641456604,
-0.7078763246536255,
-0.5443403720855713,
-0.7342149019241333,
-0.1587066352367401,
-0.47640472650527954,
0.2267218828201294,
-0.8220142126083374,
-0.8327925205230713,
-0.13153398036956787,
0.3146905303001404,
0.5008877515792847,
0.09441723674535751,
0.0987425222992897,
0.5573282241821289,
-0.8742102384567261,
0.28760257363319397,
0.5560973882675171,
0.25448185205459595,
0.21099399030208588,
-0.38251885771751404,
-0.7145548462867737,
0.036007367074489594,
-0.4061414897441864,
-0.5407649874687195,
0.5042731761932373,
0.16450084745883942,
0.049894705414772034,
0.3056373596191406,
0.33227020502090454,
0.7234761118888855,
-0.5307137370109558,
0.6465067267417908,
-0.005689927842468023,
-1.0943607091903687,
0.2584759294986725,
-0.0677303597331047,
0.6879094839096069,
0.45248523354530334,
0.23473848402500153,
-0.8240495920181274,
-0.4142017662525177,
-0.5226495862007141,
-1.1409494876861572,
0.5109338164329529,
0.191002756357193,
0.12212231755256653,
0.1824537068605423,
0.5350069403648376,
-0.39771950244903564,
0.4553307890892029,
-0.7427466511726379,
-0.13028788566589355,
-0.13336098194122314,
-0.38163238763809204,
0.3208756148815155,
-0.45776063203811646,
0.16793951392173767,
-0.015928413718938828,
0.603828489780426,
-0.18528251349925995,
0.1645750105381012,
-0.014506232924759388,
-0.3172937035560608,
-0.4083079397678375,
0.19532838463783264,
0.6265133023262024,
0.45585402846336365,
-0.1454097479581833,
0.20830506086349487,
0.16241666674613953,
-0.6282956600189209,
0.1660218983888626,
-0.11043905466794968,
-0.17099754512310028,
-0.2572758197784424,
0.16887755692005157,
0.6680267453193665,
0.35443469882011414,
-0.7643227577209473,
0.6939479112625122,
-0.11655716598033905,
-0.07532700896263123,
-0.20054876804351807,
-0.15986497700214386,
0.2425183355808258,
0.38249868154525757,
0.48885679244995117,
-0.49458879232406616,
0.06700772047042847,
-0.12643253803253174,
0.14696581661701202,
0.7711538672447205,
-0.2523464560508728,
-0.3672480881214142,
0.6475808024406433,
0.02409548871219158,
-0.03486495465040207,
0.616396427154541,
-0.17377182841300964,
-0.5246173143386841,
0.5481516122817993,
0.3782452940940857,
0.9771630167961121,
-0.341277152299881,
-0.02473464421927929,
0.3022620379924774,
0.313191294670105,
-0.14456172287464142,
0.31004956364631653,
-0.27581164240837097,
-0.4672289490699768,
-0.9016864895820618,
-0.7086257338523865,
-0.23473700881004333,
0.34298527240753174,
-0.6260712742805481,
0.03145281597971916,
-0.2542972266674042,
-0.348103404045105,
-0.4431733787059784,
0.1968383938074112,
-0.38341420888900757,
0.11890644580125809,
0.17176195979118347,
0.5175837278366089,
-0.5878540277481079,
1.2243653535842896,
0.2592661380767822,
-0.01986866630613804,
-0.47347384691238403,
-0.002623244421556592,
-0.2873168885707855,
-0.6961395740509033,
0.7898321151733398,
-0.2769767940044403,
0.20417550206184387,
0.4159447252750397,
-0.47810521721839905,
-1.151917815208435,
1.1113983392715454,
0.29453131556510925,
-0.7463045716285706,
-0.08048554509878159,
0.30336299538612366,
0.3965720534324646,
0.15284287929534912,
-0.022847026586532593,
0.4285111129283905,
0.4509427547454834,
0.2867453694343567,
-0.8022404313087463,
0.11784372478723526,
0.031517285853624344,
0.4537486732006073,
0.6603015065193176,
-0.7240942716598511,
0.8801459074020386,
0.04328138753771782,
-0.20242473483085632,
0.2121170163154602,
0.6635167598724365,
0.3253591060638428,
-0.2715919017791748,
0.33710718154907227,
0.8873661160469055,
0.46860039234161377,
0.05904817581176758,
0.9625133872032166,
-0.33062633872032166,
0.5362419486045837,
0.7535769939422607,
-0.30828312039375305,
0.9093638062477112,
0.7106304168701172,
-0.47556689381599426,
-0.08465025573968887,
0.5260569453239441,
0.15569503605365753,
0.7258692383766174,
0.5249059200286865,
-0.36366578936576843,
-0.25068727135658264,
0.028723785653710365,
-0.23208239674568176,
0.0008473070920445025,
0.2498149275779724,
0.04322608932852745,
-0.11180076003074646,
0.12548084557056427,
0.00984202791005373,
-0.5768557190895081,
-0.23652711510658264,
0.6744159460067749,
0.2209911048412323,
-0.5050632953643799,
0.7873550057411194,
0.21730898320674896,
0.46068239212036133,
-0.7425788044929504,
0.0644216313958168,
-0.19060739874839783,
0.2889269292354584,
0.12767931818962097,
-0.2895660996437073,
0.02140706405043602,
-0.2943888306617737,
-0.4146895110607147,
-0.32656168937683105,
0.4104037880897522,
-0.6927127838134766,
-0.605685293674469,
-0.1283850371837616,
0.29774561524391174,
-0.22325710952281952,
-0.43982285261154175,
-0.42993319034576416,
0.25144898891448975,
-0.16351787745952606,
-0.5212076902389526,
0.5558420419692993,
0.9335472583770752,
-0.3272930681705475,
0.759369969367981,
0.6277801394462585,
0.23299627006053925,
0.2536032199859619,
-0.000017506736185168847,
0.7527179718017578,
-0.6045781373977661,
-0.4008607268333435,
-0.8423903584480286,
0.41806402802467346,
0.41259288787841797,
-0.15735375881195068,
0.5994908213615417,
0.620526134967804,
0.5838780403137207,
0.0355546697974205,
0.6629218459129333,
0.0806160718202591,
0.027582647278904915,
-0.6738842725753784,
0.7566383481025696,
-0.6550256609916687,
0.17158785462379456,
-0.12409587949514389,
-0.9684279561042786,
-0.2646350562572479,
0.5952639579772949,
0.0002240468456875533,
-0.05219535529613495,
0.7650294303894043,
0.5589851140975952,
0.17029348015785217,
-0.5467554330825806,
0.48920953273773193,
0.24578578770160675,
0.43577009439468384,
0.8511773347854614,
0.8130238652229309,
-0.6580659747123718,
0.8282860517501831,
-0.23312507569789886,
-0.15878620743751526,
-0.24963977932929993,
-1.0154637098312378,
-0.7208237051963806,
-0.7012820243835449,
-0.4898376762866974,
-0.2392343282699585,
-0.019518841058015823,
0.5224645733833313,
0.8585151433944702,
-0.5533779859542847,
-0.26412394642829895,
-0.17028509080410004,
0.010368216782808304,
0.015360766090452671,
-0.25955820083618164,
0.5600404739379883,
-0.4400809407234192,
-0.6854342818260193,
0.06364447623491287,
0.3829152584075928,
0.1395200490951538,
-0.6283038854598999,
-0.19718500971794128,
0.21460509300231934,
0.179905965924263,
0.8381984829902649,
0.1830630600452423,
-0.6311931014060974,
-0.03300844505429268,
0.06950247287750244,
-0.36049529910087585,
-0.015753572806715965,
1.0528334379196167,
-0.941253125667572,
0.40526968240737915,
0.7251308560371399,
0.7140958905220032,
0.8543869256973267,
-0.17203764617443085,
0.7039305567741394,
-0.851999044418335,
0.4097873568534851,
0.4581897556781769,
0.03498381748795509,
0.22328299283981323,
-0.2617233991622925,
0.052046921104192734,
0.2583277225494385,
-0.4949173629283905,
-0.8723963499069214,
0.20550499856472015,
-0.849265456199646,
-0.2523477077484131,
1.0510101318359375,
0.10150493681430817,
-0.37433651089668274,
0.05501537024974823,
-0.025415237993001938,
0.17302611470222473,
-0.4038602113723755,
0.7131885290145874,
0.8602666258811951,
0.3159931004047394,
-0.5901201963424683,
-0.7169607281684875,
0.655433714389801,
0.5041027069091797,
-0.5907207727432251,
0.2646030783653259,
0.4241301715373993,
0.0758582353591919,
-0.09363607317209244,
0.5683914422988892,
-0.18607263267040253,
0.17632639408111572,
-0.22308248281478882,
0.3284291625022888,
0.09897313266992569,
0.03639693558216095,
-0.2247055172920227,
-0.06725156307220459,
0.19856669008731842,
-0.018626028671860695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12061v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12061v2 | All Language Models Large and Small | 2024-02-19T11:28:20 | 2024-06-05T15:08:28 | Zhixun Chen, Yali Du, David Mguni | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Many leading language models (LMs) use high-intensity computational resources
both during training and execution. This poses the challenge of lowering
resource costs for deployment and faster execution of decision-making tasks
among others. We introduce a novel plug-and-play LM framework named Language
Optimising Network Distribution (LONDI) framework. LONDI learns to selectively
employ large LMs only where complex decision-making and reasoning are required
while using low-resource LMs (i.e. LMs require less GPU usage, but may not be
able to solve the problem alone) everywhere else. LONDI consists of a system of
two (off-)policy networks, an LM, a large LM (LLM), and a reinforcement
learning module that uses switching controls to quickly learn which system
states to call the LLM. We then introduce a variant of LONDI that maintains
budget constraints on LLM calls and hence its resource usage. Theoretically, we
prove LONDI learns the subset of system states to activate the LLM required to
solve the task. We then prove that LONDI converges to optimal solutions while
also preserving budgetary constraints on LLM calls almost surely enabling it to
solve various tasks while significantly lowering computational costs. We test
LONDI's performance in a range of tasks in ScienceWorld and BabyAI-Text and
demonstrate that LONDI can solve tasks only solvable by resource-intensive LLMs
while reducing GPU usage by up to 30%. | [
-0.42378056049346924,
-0.6864511370658875,
0.4131503105163574,
0.43178489804267883,
0.027143988758325577,
-0.03273828700184822,
-0.39417168498039246,
-0.1288418471813202,
0.19919948279857635,
0.8357650637626648,
-0.5709501504898071,
-0.16591353714466095,
-0.19126178324222565,
-0.07489559054374695,
-0.24746619164943695,
0.8222935795783997,
0.02099638618528843,
-0.26952388882637024,
-0.09478304535150528,
-0.16899248957633972,
-0.0952439084649086,
-0.08682812750339508,
-1.1495869159698486,
-0.6359851956367493,
0.6620863676071167,
0.22346356511116028,
0.7592538595199585,
0.7554929852485657,
0.45267412066459656,
0.29487907886505127,
-0.42347222566604614,
0.4701477289199829,
-0.7037186026573181,
-0.22078001499176025,
-0.3579707741737366,
-0.5822758078575134,
-0.21895095705986023,
-0.30407559871673584,
0.6212766766548157,
0.7071771025657654,
-0.6005250811576843,
0.06521252542734146,
-0.1180391013622284,
0.7128965258598328,
-0.9291549324989319,
0.20981194078922272,
-0.5874600410461426,
0.1955799162387848,
-0.05938726291060448,
-0.03673999011516571,
-0.6588119864463806,
-0.07222477346658707,
-0.05459956079721451,
-0.673389196395874,
-0.1508636474609375,
0.09124169498682022,
0.7424682974815369,
0.45429015159606934,
-0.2424190491437912,
-0.1791679412126541,
-0.8740102648735046,
0.8075416684150696,
-0.4285801947116852,
0.18953952193260193,
0.14402203261852264,
0.2632995843887329,
-0.12137430161237717,
-0.4879986047744751,
-0.5673500299453735,
0.01902877911925316,
0.05606614425778389,
-0.020904971286654472,
-0.3208431005477905,
0.07240424305200577,
0.2653564214706421,
0.11810231953859329,
-0.34665611386299133,
0.4343529939651489,
-0.3357752561569214,
0.06081359088420868,
0.3752996325492859,
0.1774490773677826,
0.0965830534696579,
-0.12417400628328323,
-0.32194405794143677,
0.026259416714310646,
-0.8853617906570435,
-0.044900018721818924,
0.26114797592163086,
0.5242632031440735,
-0.11498723179101944,
0.3414786756038666,
0.13110247254371643,
0.6421731114387512,
-0.31273403763771057,
-0.446677029132843,
0.18131807446479797,
0.03677381947636604,
-0.5413978695869446,
-0.08477029949426651,
1.0060991048812866,
-0.19399620592594147,
0.08784788101911545,
0.14518015086650848,
-0.3054763078689575,
-0.023156745359301567,
0.0856608971953392,
-0.6595683097839355,
-0.000987323233857751,
-0.052501317113637924,
-0.2998834252357483,
-0.5137797594070435,
-0.7031832337379456,
-0.5545070171356201,
-0.5092918276786804,
-0.043964684009552,
0.29590949416160583,
-0.21870122849941254,
-0.35656553506851196,
0.17694206535816193,
0.23810029029846191,
-0.08740835636854172,
0.18435686826705933,
-0.9881801009178162,
0.5141726732254028,
0.5445384979248047,
0.9928520321846008,
-0.308685839176178,
-0.18502561748027802,
-0.6156379580497742,
0.11878380179405212,
-0.5075007081031799,
0.567939043045044,
-0.20134581625461578,
-0.45299166440963745,
0.0012490764493122697,
0.0669410452246666,
-0.12492246925830841,
-0.6819033026695251,
0.09429238736629486,
-0.6424084305763245,
0.042242344468832016,
-0.13616123795509338,
-0.16842350363731384,
0.19042490422725677,
0.08027102053165436,
-0.8948782086372375,
0.8879424333572388,
0.19805774092674255,
-0.6237924695014954,
0.09867947548627853,
-0.9665547013282776,
-0.5376536846160889,
-0.08360739797353745,
-0.08909241855144501,
-0.43760257959365845,
-0.18735088407993317,
-0.12636303901672363,
0.25891318917274475,
-0.5572146773338318,
0.048260439187288284,
-0.21382078528404236,
-0.253346711397171,
0.02750280871987343,
-0.35508960485458374,
0.8780496716499329,
0.46705806255340576,
-0.4300265908241272,
0.12698622047901154,
-0.5712100863456726,
0.011195157654583454,
0.3429298400878906,
-0.6458152532577515,
-0.11439065635204315,
0.2716946601867676,
0.07911406457424164,
0.07173556834459305,
0.12765666842460632,
-0.3411109149456024,
0.28067201375961304,
-0.48914143443107605,
0.7362720370292664,
0.772132396697998,
-0.28987476229667664,
0.7880386710166931,
-0.015178539790213108,
0.631238579750061,
-0.05250873416662216,
0.28737857937812805,
0.15616026520729065,
-0.3168310225009918,
-0.8449868559837341,
-0.3553808927536011,
0.12363279610872269,
0.7232222557067871,
-0.8981385827064514,
-0.004088841378688812,
-0.060868021100759506,
-0.2176135629415512,
-0.36997538805007935,
0.40328314900398254,
0.4878523647785187,
0.14987531304359436,
0.11956918984651566,
0.0776456743478775,
-0.38604411482810974,
-0.997929573059082,
0.2883705496788025,
-0.3141200840473175,
0.33688294887542725,
0.5484396815299988,
0.3810798227787018,
-0.24079062044620514,
0.9350534081459045,
-0.7206289172172546,
-0.21722713112831116,
-0.6760502457618713,
-0.2560310363769531,
0.44927290081977844,
0.10820610821247101,
0.45696553587913513,
-0.7668437957763672,
-0.37456977367401123,
0.2865074872970581,
-0.5474944114685059,
-0.1856539100408554,
-0.10818509012460709,
-0.08414296060800552,
0.543468713760376,
0.5087600350379944,
-0.6242580413818359,
0.08631764352321625,
0.7209223508834839,
-0.10172736644744873,
0.5114498138427734,
-0.43397587537765503,
-0.5022546052932739,
-0.9831735491752625,
0.07530317455530167,
-0.1773432344198227,
-0.2377728521823883,
-0.31222817301750183,
0.24226683378219604,
-0.1401163935661316,
-0.43980497121810913,
-0.5420405864715576,
0.6228650808334351,
-0.3160721957683563,
-0.19030208885669708,
-0.14299096167087555,
0.3343357741832733,
0.18814800679683685,
0.5767605900764465,
-0.1072637140750885,
0.9419533014297485,
0.30074745416641235,
-0.6560794115066528,
0.4494217038154602,
0.09981989115476608,
-0.38161444664001465,
0.27418190240859985,
-0.5551920533180237,
-0.34009304642677307,
-0.15677082538604736,
0.11613196134567261,
-0.5121408104896545,
0.01673245243728161,
0.07563085854053497,
0.23852664232254028,
0.13843631744384766,
0.0041536069475114346,
-0.47099289298057556,
-0.27924421429634094,
0.18292643129825592,
0.1784803569316864,
0.688184380531311,
-0.7137935757637024,
0.5390216112136841,
0.495831161737442,
0.21726292371749878,
-0.7033064961433411,
-0.7724125385284424,
-0.16236896812915802,
-0.18453778326511383,
-0.3638114631175995,
0.2545699179172516,
-0.10838142037391663,
-0.35860171914100647,
0.14262966811656952,
0.2249235212802887,
-0.08555516600608826,
0.22303898632526398,
0.09667619317770004,
0.07902351021766663,
-0.2904388904571533,
0.31643396615982056,
-0.3215079605579376,
-0.02710200846195221,
0.07995052635669708,
-0.560699462890625,
0.6402541399002075,
-0.20233741402626038,
-0.5022770762443542,
-0.06598930060863495,
0.2141389548778534,
0.42713385820388794,
-0.09967188537120819,
0.9148091077804565,
0.5487390756607056,
-0.047284599393606186,
-0.8247520327568054,
-0.22376221418380737,
0.13767458498477936,
-0.49711498618125916,
0.6970465183258057,
-0.28944265842437744,
-0.6980176568031311,
0.3497081995010376,
-0.1754741221666336,
0.2583722472190857,
0.1560533344745636,
0.46760469675064087,
-0.01945810765028,
0.8287043571472168,
0.7121385931968689,
-0.424140989780426,
0.6153246164321899,
-0.5945949554443359,
0.5117465853691101,
-0.5435263514518738,
0.028174251317977905,
-0.21967312693595886,
-0.25513213872909546,
-0.7097706198692322,
-0.6345784068107605,
0.411894291639328,
0.1758405566215515,
-0.41471001505851746,
0.20957261323928833,
-0.4552886188030243,
0.8785815238952637,
0.4869591295719147,
0.08807826787233353,
0.13238760828971863,
0.19495262205600739,
-0.2408999502658844,
0.2910376191139221,
-1.134250521659851,
-0.20630037784576416,
0.7279099822044373,
0.2721174359321594,
0.7404084801673889,
0.4251958727836609,
0.7155670523643494,
0.2156887948513031,
0.2968813180923462,
-0.7790369987487793,
0.7227272391319275,
-0.40069854259490967,
-0.44893327355384827,
-0.535433292388916,
-0.82879638671875,
-0.8985897898674011,
0.17285789549350739,
-0.1633143275976181,
-0.6184098124504089,
-0.06526839733123779,
0.20159399509429932,
-0.3794806897640228,
0.7619261741638184,
-0.6213063597679138,
0.6351422071456909,
-0.11455266922712326,
-0.5906690359115601,
-0.32567471265792847,
-0.07972550392150879,
0.35525432229042053,
-0.047894928604364395,
0.5075975060462952,
-0.0504131056368351,
-0.1472192406654358,
0.5374090671539307,
-0.45881325006484985,
0.7524932622909546,
-0.12187059968709946,
-0.22020676732063293,
0.39270734786987305,
0.15501663088798523,
0.5732547640800476,
-0.018708446994423866,
-0.1516079157590866,
-0.25248509645462036,
-0.30612912774086,
-0.4627758860588074,
-0.6249023079872131,
0.9318180680274963,
-1.0697015523910522,
-0.4814588725566864,
-0.15234020352363586,
-0.36784645915031433,
-0.10511213541030884,
0.14720559120178223,
0.1574721783399582,
0.4014352262020111,
-0.2950983941555023,
-0.03460560739040375,
1.0324658155441284,
-0.4817403256893158,
0.615959644317627,
0.3767527639865875,
-0.6160879135131836,
-0.34942156076431274,
1.0744047164916992,
-0.03819507360458374,
0.6844130158424377,
0.4888487160205841,
0.3213145136833191,
-0.045281097292900085,
-0.2672075927257538,
-0.5021528005599976,
0.2971411347389221,
-0.9204325079917908,
0.04723235219717026,
-0.4952094256877899,
-0.47204160690307617,
0.10548704117536545,
-0.15339402854442596,
-0.6108946800231934,
-0.29684701561927795,
-0.2695613205432892,
0.03360975161194801,
0.2593469023704529,
0.7922304272651672,
-0.18680638074874878,
0.6150444149971008,
-0.16289682686328888,
0.0415339395403862,
0.3577169179916382,
0.490285187959671,
-0.005377833265811205,
-0.12442385405302048,
-0.453472763299942,
-0.1783948689699173,
-0.2998979985713959,
-0.45209354162216187,
0.37114471197128296,
0.291224867105484,
0.27449512481689453,
0.5858587622642517,
-0.12453364580869675,
0.46789222955703735,
-0.5558254718780518,
0.6506288051605225,
0.3957551419734955,
-0.7658048868179321,
0.32829001545906067,
-0.39360305666923523,
0.3416385054588318,
0.2078544944524765,
0.16718409955501556,
-0.4327591061592102,
0.13575097918510437,
-0.4763142764568329,
-0.8360281586647034,
0.862375020980835,
0.09322729706764221,
-0.05353850871324539,
-0.14208343625068665,
0.05098036304116249,
-0.3031308948993683,
0.08732351660728455,
-0.7683656215667725,
-0.22844481468200684,
0.22960682213306427,
-0.016476519405841827,
-0.2440025955438614,
-0.08936768770217896,
-0.23652000725269318,
0.07546471059322357,
0.8602086305618286,
-0.313019335269928,
0.31884071230888367,
-0.24440757930278778,
0.04081041365861893,
0.021237531676888466,
0.25390008091926575,
0.5857928991317749,
0.541923999786377,
0.01555756013840437,
0.07579491287469864,
0.2988061308860779,
-0.18314339220523834,
0.23995757102966309,
-0.35747143626213074,
-0.35043618083000183,
0.0680835172533989,
0.2511923611164093,
1.2226150035858154,
0.44271591305732727,
-0.8592104315757751,
0.4113762676715851,
0.07026468217372894,
-0.19828233122825623,
-0.4079151153564453,
0.3548634350299835,
0.5492538809776306,
0.3674006164073944,
-0.059372782707214355,
0.13998332619667053,
-0.2413714975118637,
-0.39267852902412415,
-0.2552438974380493,
0.4246634244918823,
-0.2288282811641693,
-0.015930963680148125,
0.304605633020401,
0.2534944713115692,
-0.5079950094223022,
0.5207179188728333,
-0.4794485569000244,
-0.42897024750709534,
0.7277030348777771,
0.6878622770309448,
0.5980373024940491,
0.059291526675224304,
0.57940673828125,
0.044273655861616135,
0.2555820047855377,
-0.33958253264427185,
0.40615683794021606,
-0.002094476018100977,
-0.8459742665290833,
-0.6050562858581543,
-0.7597425580024719,
-0.5188823938369751,
0.19263599812984467,
-0.3965495824813843,
0.3129776418209076,
-0.7728578448295593,
-0.21511287987232208,
-0.1704455018043518,
-0.03803171217441559,
-0.6496607065200806,
-0.06315542012453079,
0.192459836602211,
0.8972035050392151,
-0.7312948107719421,
0.7427962422370911,
0.4695679545402527,
-0.12863272428512573,
-0.8528316020965576,
-0.4954170286655426,
0.00144601846113801,
-0.8278318047523499,
1.0053908824920654,
-0.2485739290714264,
-0.2540256381034851,
0.03203394636511803,
-0.31411921977996826,
-1.0316407680511475,
0.925164520740509,
0.57514888048172,
-0.6098994016647339,
-0.16368785500526428,
0.2168629914522171,
0.35237449407577515,
-0.3786652386188507,
0.2836951017379761,
0.4745551347732544,
0.23737001419067383,
0.07462023943662643,
-0.9836557507514954,
-0.24739426374435425,
-0.11857747286558151,
0.09308963268995285,
0.5884300470352173,
-0.8088932633399963,
1.0337027311325073,
-0.3842332065105438,
-0.23020106554031372,
-0.1883479356765747,
0.3168857991695404,
0.41154471039772034,
0.10352262109518051,
0.7221890687942505,
0.5883852243423462,
0.7480531334877014,
0.06228271871805191,
0.8749040365219116,
-0.2107793241739273,
0.3829331398010254,
0.8505869507789612,
-0.45182350277900696,
1.0113357305526733,
0.5565513372421265,
-0.41362616419792175,
0.5616544485092163,
0.49379387497901917,
0.30132603645324707,
0.5874156951904297,
0.5472672581672668,
-0.39775606989860535,
-0.22530823945999146,
-0.2811012864112854,
-0.06240605190396309,
0.29774680733680725,
0.37864211201667786,
-0.2711799740791321,
-0.17641940712928772,
0.20719285309314728,
0.1480693370103836,
-0.02434099093079567,
-0.35707563161849976,
0.6929423809051514,
0.19596076011657715,
-0.558158814907074,
0.9085490703582764,
-0.01557327900081873,
0.4395444691181183,
-0.747314453125,
0.305801123380661,
-0.31200823187828064,
0.6307187676429749,
-0.18806906044483185,
-0.4715392291545868,
0.21323701739311218,
-0.1717248111963272,
-0.4159563481807709,
-0.3636421263217926,
0.3379533290863037,
-0.2938540577888489,
-0.3746083974838257,
0.6160698533058167,
0.38134393095970154,
0.03432324156165123,
0.31352728605270386,
-0.5681793689727783,
0.20166268944740295,
0.026999978348612785,
-0.3967560827732086,
0.4885968863964081,
0.5201660990715027,
-0.09377177804708481,
1.0500004291534424,
0.6004286408424377,
0.6894749402999878,
-0.15238209068775177,
0.08507849276065826,
0.9254258871078491,
-0.3500286042690277,
-0.8157005310058594,
-0.7618445158004761,
-0.043585482984781265,
-0.23725995421409607,
-0.20268785953521729,
0.2341708242893219,
0.29957857728004456,
0.6687698364257812,
0.07640448957681656,
0.9118646383285522,
0.005464114248752594,
0.10030093789100647,
-0.6594883799552917,
0.6427342295646667,
-0.6297887563705444,
0.5064542889595032,
-0.02687191218137741,
-0.909451961517334,
-0.00015322367835324258,
0.5980808734893799,
-0.30465173721313477,
-0.25169822573661804,
0.8195792436599731,
0.8604364395141602,
-0.2764948904514313,
-0.004877022001892328,
0.4055599868297577,
0.08192607760429382,
0.3066268265247345,
0.7252687811851501,
0.5368829369544983,
-0.08165459334850311,
0.6065083146095276,
-0.20318295061588287,
-0.22638505697250366,
-0.2464025914669037,
-0.8221503496170044,
-0.8890687823295593,
-0.42156121134757996,
-0.20373831689357758,
-0.41452398896217346,
0.29438483715057373,
1.1499820947647095,
0.8803785443305969,
-0.668432891368866,
-0.6501713991165161,
-0.16897377371788025,
0.31428900361061096,
-0.19278323650360107,
-0.2090899795293808,
0.259794682264328,
-0.44429415464401245,
-0.3921370804309845,
0.4273424446582794,
0.3110331594944,
-0.39279627799987793,
-0.6854652166366577,
-0.3569755554199219,
-0.1901017278432846,
0.17773014307022095,
0.6570794582366943,
0.3537144958972931,
-0.5268886089324951,
0.08747724443674088,
-0.057893697172403336,
-0.32526832818984985,
-0.10753133893013,
0.7745744585990906,
-0.6852871775627136,
0.0861702412366867,
0.3708646595478058,
0.8974748849868774,
0.5490164160728455,
-0.47848042845726013,
0.38496026396751404,
-0.7332200407981873,
0.3170062005519867,
0.07830727100372314,
0.4159088432788849,
0.17712745070457458,
-0.13857348263263702,
0.4587439298629761,
0.2323816865682602,
-0.5446224808692932,
-0.8580648303031921,
0.6216006875038147,
-0.5897559523582458,
-0.43226298689842224,
1.245908498764038,
-0.10004378110170364,
-0.5993272066116333,
0.1447153240442276,
-0.03553585708141327,
-0.12139036506414413,
-0.3435913920402527,
0.5362544059753418,
0.372749924659729,
0.04307973384857178,
-0.29285430908203125,
-0.5705925226211548,
0.5709806680679321,
0.4826158881187439,
-0.7109569907188416,
-0.0037347599864006042,
0.11692365258932114,
0.2057938277721405,
0.37794744968414307,
0.622357964515686,
0.4708303213119507,
-0.08036722242832184,
-0.11883018910884857,
0.09510182589292526,
-0.13804695010185242,
-0.34692415595054626,
0.0010102808009833097,
0.2252029925584793,
0.04019443690776825,
0.06774614006280899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12058v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12058v1 | Scaffolding Coordinates to Promote Vision-Language Coordination in Large Multi-Modal Models | 2024-02-19T11:23:53 | 2024-02-19T11:23:53 | Xuanyu Lei, Zonghan Yang, Xinrui Chen, Peng Li, Yang Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | State-of-the-art Large Multi-Modal Models (LMMs) have demonstrated
exceptional capabilities in vision-language tasks. Despite their advanced
functionalities, the performances of LMMs are still limited in challenging
scenarios that require complex reasoning with multiple levels of visual
information. Existing prompting techniques for LMMs focus on either improving
textual reasoning or leveraging tools for image preprocessing, lacking a simple
and general visual prompting scheme to promote vision-language coordination in
LMMs. In this work, we propose Scaffold prompting that scaffolds coordinates to
promote vision-language coordination. Specifically, Scaffold overlays a dot
matrix within the image as visual information anchors and leverages
multi-dimensional coordinates as textual positional references. Extensive
experiments on a wide range of challenging vision-language tasks demonstrate
the superiority of Scaffold over GPT-4V with the textual CoT prompting. Our
code is released in https://github.com/leixy20/Scaffold. | [
-0.19158363342285156,
-0.7886068224906921,
0.9643086791038513,
0.37977537512779236,
-0.5079775452613831,
-0.25567880272865295,
-0.13446849584579468,
-0.08552349358797073,
0.22413557767868042,
0.20747865736484528,
-0.5182300209999084,
-0.6801892518997192,
-0.40093085169792175,
-0.027622807770967484,
-0.199960395693779,
0.7205528020858765,
-0.22170338034629822,
0.2783282697200775,
-0.5056222677230835,
-0.13596315681934357,
-0.4841840863227844,
-0.35267895460128784,
-0.25780701637268066,
-0.17640627920627594,
1.0541510581970215,
0.5595230460166931,
0.6214135885238647,
0.692716658115387,
0.2651582360267639,
0.3419760465621948,
0.21404597163200378,
0.3101321756839752,
-0.07534515112638474,
0.6341950297355652,
-0.1880808025598526,
-0.437528133392334,
-0.4019251763820648,
-0.17180387675762177,
0.6667765974998474,
0.7319263219833374,
-0.28067803382873535,
0.17340189218521118,
0.11385489255189896,
0.7456826567649841,
-0.7948718070983887,
0.39068132638931274,
-0.3920511305332184,
-0.23649387061595917,
-0.2697954773902893,
-0.5581294894218445,
-0.37664616107940674,
-0.28151842951774597,
0.10558868944644928,
-0.7200011014938354,
-0.05812736973166466,
-0.008174045011401176,
0.8294957876205444,
0.3079962730407715,
-0.44883063435554504,
-0.03194661810994148,
-0.23161722719669342,
0.5829579830169678,
-0.16371209919452667,
0.5951699614524841,
0.5854551792144775,
0.4085312485694885,
-0.07813846319913864,
-0.5250060558319092,
-0.5253039002418518,
-0.16031698882579803,
0.21903474628925323,
0.21007202565670013,
0.08452912420034409,
0.15737086534500122,
0.42810121178627014,
-0.321578711271286,
-0.4465014338493347,
-0.07591550052165985,
-0.6337715983390808,
-0.07473937422037125,
0.12333230674266815,
0.03722887858748436,
0.12758779525756836,
-0.05548437312245369,
-0.8604949116706848,
-0.2449730634689331,
-0.8190798759460449,
0.27368155121803284,
0.20676003396511078,
0.33467528223991394,
-0.24555470049381256,
0.768034040927887,
-0.3771442174911499,
0.9941026568412781,
0.2440960705280304,
-0.04970363527536392,
0.4002818167209625,
-0.37184709310531616,
-0.27210551500320435,
-0.13827094435691833,
0.3980121910572052,
0.9431276321411133,
0.27746355533599854,
0.2635354995727539,
-0.09322311729192734,
0.3188629150390625,
0.2671293020248413,
-0.6982640624046326,
-0.2604658305644989,
0.2007836252450943,
-0.4142133593559265,
0.006113843992352486,
-0.2482302486896515,
-0.6239640712738037,
-0.435905784368515,
-0.6097679734230042,
0.7018296122550964,
-0.6325949430465698,
0.07418099045753479,
0.37110328674316406,
-0.19476744532585144,
0.36807671189308167,
0.7278652787208557,
-0.8687712550163269,
-0.4499574601650238,
0.20507723093032837,
0.6294763088226318,
-0.11957462131977081,
-0.5472022891044617,
-0.6812778115272522,
0.6883450150489807,
-0.30134251713752747,
1.0053679943084717,
-0.4799324572086334,
-0.057754721492528915,
0.1865486353635788,
0.12711651623249054,
-0.32411640882492065,
0.10133111476898193,
0.2919541597366333,
-0.30096399784088135,
0.3683593273162842,
-0.5947428941726685,
0.016741162165999413,
-0.22102248668670654,
0.5638170838356018,
-0.576860785484314,
0.8798296451568604,
-0.13919763267040253,
-0.6593648791313171,
0.43445903062820435,
-0.5201242566108704,
-0.266735702753067,
0.05905495211482048,
-0.6267051696777344,
-0.23582147061824799,
-0.04535417631268501,
0.5267319679260254,
0.478301078081131,
-0.09448599070310593,
0.12056898325681686,
-0.1915382742881775,
-0.25551968812942505,
0.005370332859456539,
-0.24774158000946045,
0.30157992243766785,
0.0767999142408371,
-0.12564067542552948,
0.5222172737121582,
-0.4282064139842987,
-0.012868770398199558,
0.10652942210435867,
-0.2988640069961548,
-0.21408911049365997,
0.04801252856850624,
-0.25887399911880493,
0.30803969502449036,
0.3501850366592407,
-0.07313986122608185,
0.4935401380062103,
0.06982991844415665,
0.054359957575798035,
0.8117331862449646,
-0.11005400121212006,
0.7143060564994812,
-0.10570719093084335,
0.6819552779197693,
-0.04533056169748306,
0.26896753907203674,
-0.7906838059425354,
-0.6535802483558655,
-0.8315533399581909,
-0.3336843252182007,
-0.1263137310743332,
0.4271443784236908,
-1.553585171699524,
-0.16888687014579773,
-0.2687106728553772,
-0.22873516380786896,
-0.035842932760715485,
-0.048662763088941574,
0.5924455523490906,
0.4884682297706604,
0.40274909138679504,
-0.24841149151325226,
-0.25850149989128113,
-0.993980884552002,
0.14915962517261505,
-0.17151109874248505,
-0.04653901979327202,
0.014943975955247879,
0.27129262685775757,
0.18597380816936493,
0.7270681262016296,
-0.30006179213523865,
-0.36628079414367676,
-0.06319703161716461,
0.05850644037127495,
0.034237515181303024,
0.4017833471298218,
0.759272038936615,
-0.7911196351051331,
-0.23408809304237366,
-0.11373193562030792,
-0.8359477519989014,
-0.33549025654792786,
-0.04097074642777443,
-0.2739067077636719,
0.31423911452293396,
0.9759974479675293,
-0.8686922192573547,
0.5782214999198914,
0.7457301616668701,
-0.32829520106315613,
0.8520728945732117,
-0.28874504566192627,
0.4624978303909302,
-1.0195714235305786,
0.21586069464683533,
-0.34546297788619995,
0.04461747780442238,
-0.6166423559188843,
0.1560615450143814,
0.21440644562244415,
-0.026148056611418724,
-0.5707030296325684,
0.1547781527042389,
-0.6272890567779541,
0.06933809071779251,
-0.014575137756764889,
0.2625575065612793,
0.34781819581985474,
0.6245628595352173,
-0.049941278994083405,
0.700893223285675,
0.8684871196746826,
-0.3191241919994354,
0.29217565059661865,
0.25120770931243896,
-0.21298491954803467,
1.1630972623825073,
-0.710412859916687,
-0.12524627149105072,
-0.29768362641334534,
0.4223073422908783,
-0.9912266731262207,
-0.46026846766471863,
0.30704233050346375,
-0.21839205920696259,
0.22283482551574707,
-0.36033621430397034,
-0.3777773976325989,
-0.2706295847892761,
-0.4479229152202606,
0.7436250448226929,
-0.1901244968175888,
-0.46030697226524353,
0.7717325687408447,
0.1471519023180008,
-0.09773685038089752,
-0.5720195174217224,
-0.6443430185317993,
0.07095462083816528,
-0.06773924082517624,
-0.6836926937103271,
0.2247604876756668,
-0.2533939480781555,
0.14756570756435394,
-0.3282794654369354,
-0.09312139451503754,
0.06761352717876434,
-0.4382742643356323,
0.523206353187561,
0.5112345218658447,
-0.1747279018163681,
0.25118640065193176,
-0.04379653185606003,
-0.3797738552093506,
-0.10152440518140793,
-0.4264833927154541,
0.5684041976928711,
-0.1382523626089096,
-0.8276251554489136,
-0.43536654114723206,
0.5004271864891052,
0.7948481440544128,
-0.43798238039016724,
0.469392329454422,
0.3023073673248291,
-0.18377159535884857,
0.07200751453638077,
-0.5847668647766113,
-0.24531863629817963,
-0.5040634870529175,
0.15054528415203094,
-0.6150376200675964,
-0.7464238405227661,
0.13513116538524628,
-0.13264328241348267,
-0.30343520641326904,
-0.2321578860282898,
0.6108288764953613,
-0.26114368438720703,
1.2974371910095215,
0.5047914981842041,
0.33259767293930054,
0.7541258931159973,
-0.164680615067482,
0.12089506536722183,
-0.5686801671981812,
-0.39356550574302673,
-0.2806817293167114,
-0.24345286190509796,
0.21092478930950165,
-1.0659950971603394,
0.7281234860420227,
0.16786669194698334,
-0.15892228484153748,
0.3563758134841919,
-0.3231009542942047,
0.6638436317443848,
0.490744411945343,
0.26515093445777893,
0.023541223257780075,
0.3296394348144531,
-0.8734093308448792,
0.05676613375544548,
-0.9496511220932007,
-0.24329961836338043,
0.46573156118392944,
0.20243513584136963,
0.693069577217102,
-0.2787679135799408,
0.27653768658638,
-0.3613228499889374,
-0.2587617337703705,
-0.5782022476196289,
0.723352313041687,
0.20787128806114197,
-0.31114697456359863,
-0.17238740622997284,
0.17814692854881287,
-0.9369143843650818,
0.23029141128063202,
-0.6044741868972778,
-0.8245740532875061,
0.4871557056903839,
0.3515573740005493,
-0.3959302008152008,
0.1170525774359703,
-0.8125638961791992,
0.7531260848045349,
-0.12634479999542236,
-0.5127667784690857,
-0.28753072023391724,
-0.743314266204834,
0.06045376881957054,
0.14741292595863342,
0.3419158458709717,
0.030568888410925865,
-0.14628809690475464,
0.0699702650308609,
-0.2465372532606125,
0.9860953688621521,
-0.1071419045329094,
-0.2816993296146393,
0.04299576207995415,
0.26088598370552063,
0.5706070065498352,
-0.3424769639968872,
-0.10005516558885574,
0.09616032987833023,
-0.023614663630723953,
-0.2855958640575409,
-0.516835629940033,
0.6724804639816284,
-0.12096676230430603,
-0.5752507448196411,
-0.2707348167896271,
-0.6973933577537537,
-0.019715404137969017,
0.3149467408657074,
0.25184133648872375,
0.5460933446884155,
0.31046828627586365,
0.5035215616226196,
0.23893442749977112,
-0.0434034988284111,
0.4475403130054474,
0.3204365670681,
-0.48912447690963745,
-0.4493975043296814,
0.7636492252349854,
0.061179019510746,
0.5789052844047546,
0.03945524990558624,
-0.09629680216312408,
-0.21172450482845306,
-0.478135883808136,
-0.7902968525886536,
0.06345409154891968,
-0.9130961298942566,
-0.4210303723812103,
-0.2512318193912506,
0.0936141312122345,
-0.05439028888940811,
-0.5632080435752869,
-0.2179134339094162,
-0.5092334747314453,
0.2907813787460327,
-0.17072857916355133,
0.34024837613105774,
0.48250308632850647,
-0.04456678777933121,
0.3821832537651062,
-0.5303879380226135,
0.5256888270378113,
0.4349336326122284,
0.5222564935684204,
-0.2761593163013458,
0.12454507499933243,
-0.49166715145111084,
0.08992860466241837,
-0.06933119148015976,
-0.8683774471282959,
-0.1534043401479721,
0.012418843805789948,
0.46916717290878296,
0.5136920809745789,
-0.06800568103790283,
0.8960473537445068,
-0.7607082724571228,
0.8598612546920776,
0.6147539615631104,
-0.7422024011611938,
0.7692426443099976,
-0.7529645562171936,
0.5751616954803467,
0.41363388299942017,
0.16099022328853607,
-0.17867819964885712,
-0.4193398058414459,
-0.16179344058036804,
-0.9771772027015686,
0.5852961540222168,
0.24986664950847626,
-0.2828892767429352,
-0.03208782151341438,
0.13845378160476685,
-0.2593560814857483,
0.2292523980140686,
-0.5726949572563171,
-0.040461279451847076,
-0.2103782445192337,
-0.038357026875019073,
0.3255367875099182,
-0.2233927696943283,
-0.5813097357749939,
-0.151371568441391,
0.11957848072052002,
-0.6584981679916382,
-0.03726101294159889,
0.25832247734069824,
-0.16137582063674927,
-0.3360149562358856,
-0.1494530588388443,
0.6517056822776794,
0.8430763483047485,
0.27174094319343567,
0.34424909949302673,
0.2941744923591614,
-0.2695550322532654,
-0.10413262248039246,
0.0573665052652359,
-0.3954918086528778,
-0.2399093061685562,
0.20479369163513184,
0.7829342484474182,
0.5226146578788757,
-0.2505510449409485,
0.821073591709137,
-0.00817161425948143,
-0.3284569978713989,
0.12340184301137924,
-0.028619004413485527,
0.10909224301576614,
0.5987462401390076,
0.3961716592311859,
0.15305563807487488,
-0.3376780152320862,
-0.1904321163892746,
0.2077297866344452,
0.4453580975532532,
-0.27536675333976746,
-0.2836143672466278,
0.7729390859603882,
0.14142628014087677,
-0.09272681921720505,
0.018931103870272636,
0.30588021874427795,
-0.6171846389770508,
0.25415170192718506,
0.45388147234916687,
0.4535256326198578,
-0.5295959115028381,
0.3181721866130829,
0.3750995099544525,
0.1512928009033203,
-0.13100665807724,
0.5890123248100281,
-0.4051702618598938,
-0.43894410133361816,
-0.5217850208282471,
-0.4532558023929596,
-0.2799304127693176,
-0.4974040985107422,
-0.26933491230010986,
0.6681941747665405,
-0.38850459456443787,
-0.0686967596411705,
-0.24466238915920258,
-0.6725443005561829,
-0.5292275547981262,
0.23225539922714233,
0.43197378516197205,
0.8656519651412964,
-0.5620778203010559,
1.0506279468536377,
0.7822495102882385,
-0.6345988512039185,
-0.8515721559524536,
-0.08515103906393051,
0.2981557250022888,
-0.9000349640846252,
0.49493440985679626,
0.39316022396087646,
-0.6635934710502625,
-0.08011268079280853,
-0.755430281162262,
-0.8076531291007996,
1.317908525466919,
0.5511624813079834,
-0.19148845970630646,
-0.12057743221521378,
0.17015181481838226,
0.22880695760250092,
-0.3484309911727905,
0.010480502620339394,
0.017704373225569725,
0.6643011569976807,
0.3244688808917999,
-0.9091266989707947,
0.18395055830478668,
-0.3558051884174347,
-0.09939809143543243,
0.025777507573366165,
-0.35736340284347534,
0.7249449491500854,
-0.4180099666118622,
-0.3542875051498413,
0.2323734611272812,
0.33754682540893555,
0.6727457642555237,
0.26021692156791687,
1.0191389322280884,
0.31409239768981934,
0.42072224617004395,
-0.14865230023860931,
0.6716285943984985,
-0.569352924823761,
-0.11984716355800629,
0.9599324464797974,
-0.12427318096160889,
0.9359504580497742,
0.9009460806846619,
0.29440179467201233,
0.7962742447853088,
0.26181361079216003,
0.23445454239845276,
0.3397563397884369,
-0.26213163137435913,
-0.164678156375885,
-0.5381997227668762,
-0.39902958273887634,
-0.5515725612640381,
0.525976836681366,
0.5940231680870056,
-0.12814165651798248,
-0.514779806137085,
0.05311685428023338,
-0.16641348600387573,
0.0697326585650444,
-0.06260461360216141,
0.37645336985588074,
0.1302349716424942,
-0.8412349820137024,
0.5687946081161499,
-0.5541447401046753,
0.06552691012620926,
-0.8528338074684143,
-0.24995869398117065,
0.1421700417995453,
0.09996123611927032,
-0.09486721456050873,
-0.9613549113273621,
-0.0016999966464936733,
-0.39567744731903076,
-0.2631830871105194,
-0.6810086965560913,
0.643735408782959,
-0.940097451210022,
-0.11508208513259888,
0.47449633479118347,
0.5145392417907715,
-0.08843334019184113,
-0.09541428834199905,
-0.5254352688789368,
0.31202834844589233,
-0.18831855058670044,
-0.2753402888774872,
0.18497294187545776,
0.6471094489097595,
-0.5094503164291382,
0.7855959534645081,
1.218843698501587,
-0.17203471064567566,
-0.16071239113807678,
0.5069268941879272,
1.1428029537200928,
-0.5206208825111389,
-0.6765636205673218,
-0.6007143259048462,
0.8036268949508667,
-0.031459130346775055,
-0.16597165167331696,
0.738896906375885,
0.25921908020973206,
0.3994981050491333,
-0.19820243120193481,
0.19187365472316742,
0.0544460229575634,
-0.004598578903824091,
-0.7884131073951721,
0.623602569103241,
-0.6485286951065063,
0.138133704662323,
-0.36057162284851074,
-1.037074089050293,
-0.8360105752944946,
0.6744805574417114,
-0.183126762509346,
-0.20633907616138458,
0.8100835680961609,
1.0970678329467773,
-0.07747434824705124,
-0.28053930401802063,
0.4196585416793823,
0.11465699970722198,
0.1898433119058609,
0.43844300508499146,
0.9239174723625183,
0.018779318779706955,
0.6864087581634521,
-0.0020945859141647816,
-0.3176027536392212,
-0.353551983833313,
-1.3011913299560547,
-0.8832131028175354,
-0.8320968747138977,
0.037956174463033676,
-0.34331876039505005,
0.181392639875412,
0.8402461409568787,
0.802131712436676,
-0.5045902132987976,
-0.10591627657413483,
0.044182613492012024,
0.030380424112081528,
-0.1078893393278122,
-0.06205587461590767,
0.4383019208908081,
-0.3471689820289612,
-0.5393560528755188,
0.6429805159568787,
0.7446579933166504,
0.14228534698486328,
-0.2611922323703766,
-0.11049051582813263,
-0.5186757445335388,
-0.04572143033146858,
0.745537519454956,
0.15826907753944397,
-0.6796514391899109,
-0.6070963144302368,
0.10518667846918106,
-0.2856748402118683,
-0.08168753981590271,
0.8478326201438904,
-0.9320593476295471,
0.8453590273857117,
0.8034276962280273,
-0.05978726968169212,
0.44355401396751404,
0.14436790347099304,
0.9832502603530884,
-0.8449579477310181,
0.5247971415519714,
-0.2643376290798187,
0.7104484438896179,
0.3121640980243683,
-0.028107017278671265,
0.3890703320503235,
0.012360656633973122,
-0.5259173512458801,
-0.5175191164016724,
0.5519553422927856,
-1.1197161674499512,
-0.1195618212223053,
1.0704967975616455,
-0.010512602515518665,
-0.3934269845485687,
-0.16477756202220917,
-0.8839724063873291,
0.06740359961986542,
-0.18533934652805328,
0.5345966815948486,
0.4875042140483856,
0.06034909188747406,
-0.34007081389427185,
-0.4740683436393738,
0.5917719602584839,
0.6025980114936829,
-0.4459512233734131,
0.0647321343421936,
0.7688521146774292,
-0.1851886659860611,
0.2871434688568115,
0.5912940502166748,
-0.05881170555949211,
0.708562433719635,
-0.21158656477928162,
0.157024085521698,
-0.19880948960781097,
-0.7397843599319458,
-0.2463912069797516,
0.08768767863512039,
-0.3560236990451813,
-0.46611055731773376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12055v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12055v2 | Are LLM-based Evaluators Confusing NLG Quality Criteria? | 2024-02-19T11:19:02 | 2024-06-28T14:53:35 | Xinyu Hu, Mingqi Gao, Sen Hu, Yang Zhang, Yicheng Chen, Teng Xu, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Some prior work has shown that LLMs perform well in NLG evaluation for
different tasks. However, we discover that LLMs seem to confuse different
evaluation criteria, which reduces their reliability. For further verification,
we first consider avoiding issues of inconsistent conceptualization and vague
expression in existing NLG quality criteria themselves. So we summarize a clear
hierarchical classification system for 11 common aspects with corresponding
different criteria from previous studies involved. Inspired by behavioral
testing, we elaborately design 18 types of aspect-targeted perturbation attacks
for fine-grained analysis of the evaluation behaviors of different LLMs. We
also conduct human annotations beyond the guidance of the classification system
to validate the impact of the perturbations. Our experimental results reveal
confusion issues inherent in LLMs, as well as other noteworthy phenomena, and
necessitate further research and improvements for LLM-based evaluation. | [
-0.3729270398616791,
-1.0972554683685303,
0.60741126537323,
0.5044761896133423,
-0.2800920903682709,
0.16499322652816772,
0.00798660609871149,
-0.7885498404502869,
-0.018114246428012848,
0.47935280203819275,
-0.47330164909362793,
-0.5330284237861633,
-0.9354959726333618,
0.31350913643836975,
-0.5238715410232544,
1.2914206981658936,
-0.1537025421857834,
0.17000479996204376,
-0.39532190561294556,
-0.2688024342060089,
-0.3870449960231781,
-0.6743309497833252,
-0.8214605450630188,
-0.8162745833396912,
0.7060678005218506,
0.029659610241651535,
0.8725533485412598,
0.2317492663860321,
0.9049402475357056,
0.23726573586463928,
-0.5751585364341736,
0.24405227601528168,
-0.2961687445640564,
-0.19165557622909546,
-0.14254359900951385,
-0.5041571855545044,
-0.9694518446922302,
0.22075660526752472,
0.21046268939971924,
0.8639917969703674,
-0.17342673242092133,
0.36560869216918945,
0.503659188747406,
0.6537705063819885,
-0.5583575367927551,
-0.13775040209293365,
-0.4918723702430725,
0.4686695337295532,
-0.06789615750312805,
-0.4350801706314087,
-0.30640628933906555,
-0.1293119192123413,
-0.010249614715576172,
-0.26997020840644836,
0.2199283242225647,
0.17252418398857117,
0.8847569823265076,
0.5152444243431091,
-0.21498703956604004,
-0.26838964223861694,
-0.7602957487106323,
0.7374858260154724,
-0.7646329402923584,
0.3295086920261383,
0.5318701863288879,
0.18119773268699646,
-0.390108197927475,
-0.39477062225341797,
-0.24197961390018463,
-0.3183194398880005,
-0.28286269307136536,
0.12073276191949844,
-0.25055402517318726,
0.5858338475227356,
0.4256604313850403,
0.548190176486969,
-0.47445568442344666,
0.5120629072189331,
-0.1126108467578888,
-0.35598140954971313,
0.6743793487548828,
0.35695207118988037,
-0.049418237060308456,
-0.6114169359207153,
-0.5766816735267639,
0.1771063208580017,
-0.8996198177337646,
0.33149656653404236,
0.6322765946388245,
0.0787230134010315,
-0.04683740437030792,
0.627498984336853,
-0.23099450767040253,
0.7409877777099609,
0.5282881259918213,
-0.26665201783180237,
0.10065998882055283,
-0.3766213655471802,
-0.4427492320537567,
-0.07464056462049484,
0.8179641366004944,
0.5330796241760254,
-0.30114367604255676,
-0.31397661566734314,
-0.5682743787765503,
-0.2832581102848053,
0.6319409012794495,
-0.36063048243522644,
-0.030354438349604607,
0.4837839603424072,
-0.5849577784538269,
-0.4946521520614624,
0.02580440230667591,
-0.5139943361282349,
-0.5139733552932739,
-0.3839801549911499,
0.659815788269043,
-0.24745579063892365,
0.12295827269554138,
0.2570832371711731,
0.061840590089559555,
0.16862353682518005,
0.504270076751709,
-0.6630802750587463,
0.3463924527168274,
0.9513997435569763,
0.4257868230342865,
-0.5021072626113892,
-0.3848319351673126,
-0.44622603058815,
-0.3190927505493164,
-0.2632650136947632,
0.7982705235481262,
-0.52494877576828,
-0.3970966041088104,
-0.23137545585632324,
-0.2995520234107971,
0.20410875976085663,
-0.7357719540596008,
0.5992581248283386,
-0.5464811325073242,
0.37879663705825806,
-0.42844995856285095,
-0.4540952444076538,
-0.3417861759662628,
0.5986289978027344,
-0.42477843165397644,
0.9977315664291382,
0.2222270965576172,
-0.7413126230239868,
0.6835139393806458,
-0.465079128742218,
-0.2036990374326706,
0.08990009874105453,
-0.1933358758687973,
-0.284422904253006,
0.3683101236820221,
0.020046327263116837,
0.4651843309402466,
-0.20165720582008362,
0.2066047340631485,
-0.07964939624071121,
-0.6542285680770874,
0.4103218615055084,
-0.5930260419845581,
0.5058184862136841,
0.13396653532981873,
-0.24458889663219452,
0.3661346733570099,
-0.9885563850402832,
0.16473549604415894,
-0.3154809772968292,
-0.6006953716278076,
-0.16755947470664978,
0.18165454268455505,
-0.13434264063835144,
-0.024500539526343346,
0.4175262451171875,
-0.32860150933265686,
0.2244134545326233,
-0.1891487091779709,
0.17171691358089447,
0.6562891602516174,
0.17442530393600464,
0.32612091302871704,
-0.5566064119338989,
0.6368442177772522,
-0.09484978020191193,
0.553974449634552,
0.3504028022289276,
-0.42080822587013245,
-0.9640281796455383,
0.053728554397821426,
0.283254474401474,
0.5269260406494141,
-0.6076071858406067,
0.9678565859794617,
0.24494631588459015,
-0.4522891938686371,
-0.33098292350769043,
0.13518337905406952,
0.5515606999397278,
0.19791510701179504,
0.47316038608551025,
-0.39597606658935547,
-0.41122081875801086,
-0.6420705914497375,
-0.3404548466205597,
-0.522331178188324,
-0.06490448117256165,
0.08962331712245941,
0.3509223759174347,
-0.2104727029800415,
0.824887752532959,
0.030805503949522972,
-0.28525668382644653,
-0.2863118648529053,
0.17431727051734924,
0.2481280416250229,
0.2662622034549713,
0.6028150320053101,
-0.39496034383773804,
-0.04073954373598099,
-0.056545890867710114,
-0.5853738188743591,
-0.42894428968429565,
-0.2781212031841278,
0.07352835685014725,
-0.004171065520495176,
0.6047477722167969,
-0.22987708449363708,
0.4444202184677124,
0.7301812171936035,
-0.2420606166124344,
0.8199336528778076,
-0.0022180431988090277,
0.3305652141571045,
-0.3731505870819092,
-0.34389227628707886,
0.08200625330209732,
-0.168411523103714,
-0.5554744601249695,
0.27765974402427673,
-0.2282440960407257,
0.49532192945480347,
-0.6448525786399841,
0.36549872159957886,
-0.061310309916734695,
-0.022372694686055183,
-0.34464746713638306,
-0.12371283769607544,
0.23027409613132477,
0.506592333316803,
-0.5942546725273132,
0.39195361733436584,
0.4618379771709442,
-0.7666777968406677,
0.35026565194129944,
-0.16872437298297882,
-0.1072922945022583,
0.8411336541175842,
-0.6936824321746826,
0.3390793800354004,
-0.053822532296180725,
0.20001418888568878,
-0.8347440361976624,
-0.11568952351808548,
0.627940833568573,
-0.342619389295578,
0.3744610548019409,
-0.2342929095029831,
-0.6232579946517944,
-0.0019072559662163258,
-0.43101295828819275,
0.37621134519577026,
0.3429284691810608,
-0.5570567846298218,
0.5788564682006836,
-0.185772106051445,
0.39569297432899475,
-0.5688880681991577,
-0.714825451374054,
-0.03732115030288696,
-0.6004924774169922,
-0.5160090327262878,
0.32799360156059265,
0.07923460751771927,
-0.3255797028541565,
0.05105118453502655,
-0.6055610775947571,
0.11305645853281021,
0.38099682331085205,
0.3540530502796173,
0.10706225782632828,
-0.02398574724793434,
-0.2493308186531067,
-0.09287533164024353,
0.07551358640193939,
0.3016960620880127,
0.07799233496189117,
0.37089356780052185,
-0.14153021574020386,
-0.8963704109191895,
-0.42419466376304626,
-0.05925896391272545,
0.178084596991539,
0.1243402510881424,
0.13866955041885376,
0.7901182770729065,
-0.216166689991951,
-0.007689100690186024,
-0.6743476390838623,
-0.018693719059228897,
-0.5257632732391357,
0.5364131927490234,
-0.35038280487060547,
-1.0104314088821411,
0.7385569214820862,
0.16846251487731934,
0.19033150374889374,
0.49961185455322266,
0.14274722337722778,
-0.5539290308952332,
0.8593520522117615,
0.4973600208759308,
0.3241288363933563,
0.28778842091560364,
0.018789231777191162,
0.2647583484649658,
-1.2625068426132202,
-0.3306007385253906,
-0.48872607946395874,
-0.6741150617599487,
-0.7770932912826538,
-0.28172755241394043,
0.28864240646362305,
0.7214871644973755,
-0.100969098508358,
0.21189332008361816,
-0.5584167242050171,
0.5340219736099243,
-0.08216649293899536,
0.16615134477615356,
0.3823027014732361,
0.009229878894984722,
-0.161799818277359,
-0.056971870362758636,
-0.5575007200241089,
-0.8459268808364868,
1.0426336526870728,
0.6152072548866272,
1.0531245470046997,
0.18991367518901825,
0.7893233299255371,
0.4762735962867737,
0.4280548393726349,
-1.0698024034500122,
0.6941262483596802,
-0.29419058561325073,
-0.4386258125305176,
-0.26292920112609863,
-0.49201324582099915,
-1.0854017734527588,
0.41959577798843384,
-0.1799929141998291,
-0.9932955503463745,
0.07229501754045486,
0.04848116636276245,
-0.5284883379936218,
0.2762335538864136,
-0.49230432510375977,
0.6059866547584534,
-0.6246004104614258,
-0.043133318424224854,
-0.11154165863990784,
-0.16564607620239258,
0.42972293496131897,
-0.15723897516727448,
0.09048301726579666,
-0.4012024998664856,
0.0788249745965004,
0.7812373638153076,
-0.417019784450531,
0.8410799503326416,
-0.02857971377670765,
-0.19354937970638275,
0.207136332988739,
0.22014345228672028,
0.17795491218566895,
0.12003421038389206,
-0.05045255273580551,
0.6340140104293823,
-0.11866133660078049,
-0.24044933915138245,
-0.8964623808860779,
0.41944679617881775,
-0.7254698276519775,
-1.0629174709320068,
-0.5202140212059021,
-0.14651936292648315,
-0.43462899327278137,
-0.1376282423734665,
0.3928165137767792,
0.1438629925251007,
-0.033601224422454834,
0.15674349665641785,
0.46118640899658203,
-0.27517154812812805,
0.19968588650226593,
0.42849692702293396,
-0.4947572946548462,
-0.14544770121574402,
0.7215574383735657,
-0.040168456733226776,
0.48329031467437744,
0.16017195582389832,
0.10298269987106323,
-0.016075214371085167,
-1.144296646118164,
-0.12101130932569504,
-0.010485602542757988,
-0.7111733555793762,
-0.11632347106933594,
-0.06202905252575874,
-0.4767508804798126,
0.1946841925382614,
0.08100695163011551,
-0.16628916561603546,
-0.07798043638467789,
-0.4264683723449707,
-0.05786086991429329,
0.13018453121185303,
1.0057823657989502,
0.18523341417312622,
0.47552430629730225,
-0.7250208258628845,
0.2533566653728485,
0.25676852464675903,
0.6190540194511414,
-0.05790037289261818,
-0.8388893604278564,
-0.10408174246549606,
-0.23957067728042603,
-0.6010933518409729,
-0.8598178029060364,
-0.29075783491134644,
-0.025853849947452545,
0.8152387142181396,
0.5693795680999756,
-0.2532361149787903,
0.6922733187675476,
-0.36696428060531616,
1.0335009098052979,
0.21937094628810883,
-0.9320704936981201,
0.35920196771621704,
-0.0379294790327549,
0.1020844355225563,
0.4856593608856201,
0.22479939460754395,
-0.5590560436248779,
-0.6958826780319214,
-0.5878669023513794,
-0.8491472005844116,
0.7083220481872559,
0.24088416993618011,
-0.014582385309040546,
0.07110579311847687,
0.7196168303489685,
0.308506041765213,
-0.04124259576201439,
-0.6447650790214539,
-0.4631778597831726,
-0.11272221803665161,
0.24673961102962494,
0.31738707423210144,
-0.37884584069252014,
-0.2717163562774658,
-0.1146870031952858,
0.2665071487426758,
-0.014420349150896072,
0.07550521194934845,
0.2463364154100418,
-0.0447794646024704,
-0.13950325548648834,
0.4549104869365692,
0.48017290234565735,
0.8082942366600037,
-0.3418140113353729,
0.20366144180297852,
0.42727959156036377,
-0.3953101933002472,
0.31011494994163513,
-0.07860834896564484,
-0.10988350212574005,
0.016479922458529472,
0.49928656220436096,
0.8771135807037354,
0.2711564004421234,
-0.1620393544435501,
0.2538849115371704,
-0.1729639321565628,
-0.33165067434310913,
-0.046594683080911636,
0.44109341502189636,
-0.28585299849510193,
0.29797372221946716,
0.45058611035346985,
0.3151187002658844,
0.22357459366321564,
-0.372433066368103,
-0.03647971525788307,
0.47655853629112244,
-0.4753076732158661,
-0.3773137032985687,
0.46032479405403137,
0.2122863531112671,
-0.5408697724342346,
0.20222942531108856,
-0.5575639605522156,
-0.41906487941741943,
0.5268324017524719,
0.008287591859698296,
0.9517822265625,
-0.0044989753514528275,
0.033798884600400925,
0.08117996156215668,
0.5936728715896606,
-0.019619673490524292,
0.28231796622276306,
0.13284370303153992,
-0.7114220857620239,
-0.7713441252708435,
-0.8559271693229675,
-0.7716790437698364,
0.5000866651535034,
-0.7674081325531006,
0.17831969261169434,
-0.7185566425323486,
-0.5212619304656982,
-0.0005558874108828604,
-0.05236232280731201,
-0.7326066493988037,
0.26123857498168945,
0.23224100470542908,
0.5237987637519836,
-0.5713465809822083,
0.410976380109787,
0.9123079180717468,
-0.20892629027366638,
-0.7153938412666321,
0.2191956341266632,
0.024530131369829178,
-0.5904939770698547,
0.6825793385505676,
-0.13346992433071136,
-0.1024562194943428,
-0.6762769222259521,
-0.3991619348526001,
-0.8975762724876404,
0.7828797698020935,
0.051653169095516205,
-0.48973578214645386,
-0.12937919795513153,
0.3529616594314575,
0.7706456780433655,
-0.040233347564935684,
0.31985893845558167,
0.7468114495277405,
0.643306314945221,
-0.01975497230887413,
-1.301766037940979,
-0.0053119719959795475,
0.1578114777803421,
-0.03795815259218216,
0.09457402676343918,
-0.6310262680053711,
0.6520867347717285,
-0.003470699768513441,
-0.20831531286239624,
-0.017794683575630188,
0.5422985553741455,
0.4662768840789795,
0.3906973898410797,
0.6036452651023865,
0.5106502771377563,
0.6640873551368713,
-0.45095714926719666,
1.0733962059020996,
-0.08304119855165482,
0.44636642932891846,
1.0922702550888062,
-0.13034923374652863,
0.6707980632781982,
0.4871922433376312,
-0.6653594374656677,
0.17558957636356354,
0.9441028833389282,
-0.13413064181804657,
0.021455109119415283,
0.40654757618904114,
0.10283143818378448,
-0.04032524302601814,
0.14399272203445435,
-0.18425296247005463,
0.6430476307868958,
0.46819621324539185,
0.004376627039164305,
-0.32788020372390747,
-0.3266105353832245,
-0.20523601770401,
-0.17473748326301575,
-0.3830326199531555,
0.6148616075515747,
0.10252124071121216,
-0.4971739649772644,
0.6300733685493469,
0.33171606063842773,
1.1680070161819458,
-0.4867950975894928,
0.16438797116279602,
-0.39169445633888245,
-0.2957054674625397,
-0.966965913772583,
-0.9220470786094666,
0.5037906169891357,
0.08897654712200165,
0.03772857412695885,
-0.4271804988384247,
0.5777158737182617,
-0.07812879979610443,
-0.19136951863765717,
0.21487919986248016,
0.58354651927948,
0.3819168210029602,
-0.0855119451880455,
-0.7362911701202393,
0.18465842306613922,
0.0634535625576973,
-0.26939037442207336,
0.43370646238327026,
0.4094131588935852,
-0.05180811509490013,
0.3429458439350128,
0.5003150105476379,
0.17850732803344727,
0.14129994809627533,
0.37201642990112305,
0.385021448135376,
-0.6965258717536926,
-0.01482191402465105,
-1.027145504951477,
0.2509271204471588,
0.26025688648223877,
-0.4702550768852234,
0.8724258542060852,
0.23758526146411896,
0.8922074437141418,
0.3352343440055847,
0.38351166248321533,
0.23385244607925415,
0.08221028000116348,
-0.8599145412445068,
0.7138494253158569,
-0.6019085049629211,
0.7581918239593506,
-0.24897754192352295,
-1.2507655620574951,
-0.23574823141098022,
0.46012717485427856,
-0.12443672120571136,
0.4223015010356903,
0.9298722743988037,
0.37689507007598877,
0.12036437541246414,
-0.08855053782463074,
0.5279558897018433,
0.1554195135831833,
0.5453921556472778,
0.44067850708961487,
1.2707980871200562,
-0.4696042835712433,
0.36595970392227173,
-0.24807608127593994,
-0.018093079328536987,
-0.32678139209747314,
-0.9225072264671326,
-0.762205958366394,
-0.19984859228134155,
-0.7711201310157776,
-0.43697482347488403,
-0.11045964062213898,
0.9163271188735962,
0.6341190338134766,
-0.6374342441558838,
-0.07662419974803925,
0.05826445668935776,
0.33384257555007935,
-0.16407880187034607,
-0.2971969544887543,
0.126381516456604,
-0.42912253737449646,
-0.5718516111373901,
0.3637040853500366,
0.422056645154953,
0.10750875622034073,
-0.6530795097351074,
-0.08254242688417435,
0.38489264249801636,
0.04953218251466751,
0.6097798943519592,
-0.030594415962696075,
-1.2883615493774414,
-0.685832679271698,
-0.2426023781299591,
-0.24800115823745728,
0.17181816697120667,
0.6952908635139465,
-0.6414591073989868,
0.04840541258454323,
0.405070424079895,
0.5793572068214417,
-0.046370964497327805,
0.11449739336967468,
0.027989182621240616,
-0.8420352935791016,
-0.201645627617836,
0.2765580117702484,
0.36556869745254517,
0.25977587699890137,
-0.6444137096405029,
0.35647618770599365,
-0.08891177177429199,
-0.649683952331543,
-0.7227199077606201,
0.28142133355140686,
-1.1950576305389404,
-0.09393269568681717,
1.502537727355957,
-0.09097246080636978,
-0.09549372643232346,
-0.15160074830055237,
-0.09070096909999847,
-0.18536074459552765,
-0.17516334354877472,
1.0793554782867432,
1.0729485750198364,
-0.8384345769882202,
0.15422195196151733,
-0.40062278509140015,
0.692104697227478,
0.6066678762435913,
-0.871694028377533,
-0.36072254180908203,
0.2647688090801239,
0.3599281311035156,
0.433632493019104,
0.261043906211853,
-0.23964905738830566,
0.43421557545661926,
-0.4177125096321106,
-0.02874714322388172,
0.1032639741897583,
-0.1498481035232544,
-0.6449152231216431,
0.22317597270011902,
0.5859582424163818,
-0.00460455846041441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12052v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12052v3 | Small Models, Big Insights: Leveraging Slim Proxy Models To Decide When and What to Retrieve for LLMs | 2024-02-19T11:11:08 | 2024-05-30T12:03:51 | Jiejun Tan, Zhicheng Dou, Yutao Zhu, Peidong Guo, Kun Fang, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The integration of large language models (LLMs) and search engines represents
a significant evolution in knowledge acquisition methodologies. However,
determining the knowledge that an LLM already possesses and the knowledge that
requires the help of a search engine remains an unresolved issue. Most existing
methods solve this problem through the results of preliminary answers or
reasoning done by the LLM itself, but this incurs excessively high
computational costs. This paper introduces a novel collaborative approach,
namely SlimPLM, that detects missing knowledge in LLMs with a slim proxy model,
to enhance the LLM's knowledge acquisition process. We employ a proxy model
which has far fewer parameters, and take its answers as heuristic answers.
Heuristic answers are then utilized to predict the knowledge required to answer
the user question, as well as the known and unknown knowledge within the LLM.
We only conduct retrieval for the missing knowledge in questions that the LLM
does not know. Extensive experimental results on five datasets with two LLMs
demonstrate a notable improvement in the end-to-end performance of LLMs in
question-answering tasks, achieving or surpassing current state-of-the-art
models with lower LLM inference costs. | [
-0.5093223452568054,
-0.43246835470199585,
1.2745728492736816,
-0.2837360203266144,
-0.08084489405155182,
0.2271965742111206,
-0.0894717276096344,
-0.31390610337257385,
0.49424171447753906,
0.5605974793434143,
-0.7594817280769348,
-0.39290955662727356,
-0.6504269242286682,
-0.040638767182826996,
-0.0875851958990097,
0.6310564279556274,
0.3192560076713562,
0.09923383593559265,
-0.5791127681732178,
0.049483541399240494,
-0.24529163539409637,
-0.13334231078624725,
-0.6292924880981445,
-0.19389089941978455,
0.5137932300567627,
0.6130093336105347,
0.7209786772727966,
0.7616435885429382,
0.3860391676425934,
0.2815970778465271,
-0.36300262808799744,
0.635027289390564,
-0.5967204570770264,
-0.1595413088798523,
-0.6124985218048096,
-0.8555516004562378,
-0.4311883747577667,
0.013303964398801327,
0.24746806919574738,
1.1883362531661987,
-0.1941716969013214,
0.3593595623970032,
0.008973522111773491,
0.5582443475723267,
-0.7802658081054688,
0.2342417687177658,
-0.7605912089347839,
-0.13511502742767334,
-0.19017045199871063,
0.04163854941725731,
-0.22733928263187408,
-0.3428170382976532,
0.3223934471607208,
-0.7566748261451721,
0.2927301526069641,
0.12429779767990112,
0.4942760169506073,
0.34130197763442993,
-0.3779313266277313,
-0.5297914147377014,
-0.343707799911499,
0.805013120174408,
-0.7775838971138,
0.5630810856819153,
0.3626681864261627,
0.1548060178756714,
-0.5505021810531616,
-0.8045424818992615,
-0.6382575035095215,
0.12544551491737366,
-0.07945597916841507,
0.24020516872406006,
0.09013382345438004,
-0.10794274508953094,
0.00048163498286157846,
0.3386247158050537,
-0.4516716003417969,
0.14069059491157532,
-0.5896949768066406,
-0.3863431215286255,
0.605352520942688,
0.2236337661743164,
0.23654864728450775,
-0.29971417784690857,
-0.1768742799758911,
0.159257173538208,
-0.7065739631652832,
-0.2254474014043808,
0.24252870678901672,
0.3598402142524719,
-0.17916364967823029,
0.5636276602745056,
-0.22556884586811066,
0.528593897819519,
0.06108248978853226,
-0.39210471510887146,
0.06961273401975632,
-0.22332032024860382,
0.018548600375652313,
-0.08966490626335144,
0.6493584513664246,
0.019690977409482002,
0.22844748198986053,
-0.2606823742389679,
-0.1672150194644928,
-0.38188284635543823,
-0.07719528675079346,
-0.6487059593200684,
-0.38493722677230835,
0.07895852625370026,
-0.4092128574848175,
0.21966321766376495,
-0.037421949207782745,
-0.8085877895355225,
-0.7535132169723511,
-0.2457427680492401,
0.47878125309944153,
-0.17220653593540192,
-0.24313612282276154,
0.2175094336271286,
-0.48903384804725647,
0.1094575822353363,
0.6295425295829773,
-0.6044816970825195,
0.5305157899856567,
0.9221978783607483,
0.909122109413147,
-0.28836560249328613,
-0.09546881914138794,
-0.7685025930404663,
0.3631006181240082,
-0.16516819596290588,
0.6766442656517029,
-0.35267794132232666,
-0.3431603014469147,
-0.04317581281065941,
0.07862825691699982,
-0.09780614823102951,
-0.6831727027893066,
0.2999686300754547,
-0.7806413769721985,
0.5720037221908569,
-0.28967776894569397,
-0.9582482576370239,
-0.1907956451177597,
0.18024012446403503,
-0.75553959608078,
0.6417520046234131,
0.0005818877834826708,
-0.6686161756515503,
0.10689686983823776,
-0.37427711486816406,
-0.16080370545387268,
0.3901800811290741,
-0.1809561401605606,
-0.04380128160119057,
0.5285068154335022,
0.38144251704216003,
0.5473328232765198,
-0.5529439449310303,
-0.05129325017333031,
-0.6043416261672974,
-0.3763434588909149,
0.09225241839885712,
0.06988847255706787,
0.7642983198165894,
0.19910921156406403,
0.0654371827840805,
-0.38258394598960876,
-0.6465351581573486,
0.09446483105421066,
0.36421722173690796,
-0.3430059552192688,
-0.6570058465003967,
0.14715223014354706,
-0.6889157295227051,
0.17272831499576569,
0.6463059186935425,
-0.48160549998283386,
0.15689578652381897,
-0.6016853451728821,
0.1892983317375183,
0.6719992160797119,
0.2210700511932373,
0.6332712769508362,
-0.15897120535373688,
0.4293663799762726,
-0.06983344256877899,
0.12309403717517853,
-0.036990437656641006,
-0.5965772867202759,
-0.861445963382721,
-0.34151148796081543,
0.3200008273124695,
0.4086797833442688,
-0.8973276615142822,
0.121123768389225,
-0.3203614056110382,
-0.3199656307697296,
-0.6602949500083923,
0.6868409514427185,
0.09755443036556244,
0.39061376452445984,
0.27963465452194214,
-0.29635927081108093,
-0.40214747190475464,
-0.8164151906967163,
-0.23153060674667358,
-0.42012932896614075,
-0.36692315340042114,
0.5508165955543518,
0.5199301242828369,
-0.2722434103488922,
1.0072373151779175,
-0.9974235892295837,
-0.3562805950641632,
-0.43951791524887085,
-0.1518900990486145,
0.3569653034210205,
0.028078993782401085,
0.19585895538330078,
-0.7660005688667297,
-0.33948299288749695,
-0.0785803273320198,
-0.7176797389984131,
-0.23461052775382996,
0.22406905889511108,
-0.03282831236720085,
-0.31334856152534485,
0.4879736602306366,
-0.7463487982749939,
-0.008010733872652054,
0.539232611656189,
0.08959179371595383,
0.26231053471565247,
-0.13501542806625366,
-0.3573046028614044,
-1.1081953048706055,
-0.09273044019937515,
0.00026631512446329,
-0.4389890730381012,
-0.38608407974243164,
0.1881345808506012,
0.2130572646856308,
0.133745938539505,
-0.4277118444442749,
0.9449200630187988,
-0.6917822360992432,
-0.1356772929430008,
-0.22185054421424866,
0.7667660117149353,
0.015697194263339043,
0.42234620451927185,
0.10966364294290543,
0.8748763799667358,
0.16209574043750763,
-0.5371204614639282,
0.21546155214309692,
0.20686347782611847,
-0.11021027714014053,
0.4584338963031769,
-0.46083372831344604,
0.3529929220676422,
-0.13162705302238464,
-0.06852257996797562,
-0.987276017665863,
-0.565621554851532,
-0.13640551269054413,
-0.35979723930358887,
-0.004244140349328518,
-0.3858610987663269,
-0.702466607093811,
-0.6199957132339478,
-0.3355715274810791,
0.004715545568615198,
0.5843938589096069,
-0.7289952039718628,
0.7246461510658264,
0.7523478865623474,
-0.4074789881706238,
-0.2167261838912964,
-0.2557547390460968,
-0.10186059772968292,
-0.09757333248853683,
-0.6378230452537537,
0.0037318437825888395,
-0.16578051447868347,
-0.38681885600090027,
-0.09828449040651321,
-0.41854551434516907,
-0.26115846633911133,
0.18947315216064453,
0.03156966716051102,
0.20313037931919098,
-0.24848023056983948,
0.12948782742023468,
0.0903933048248291,
0.15649142861366272,
0.15615475177764893,
-0.4641793370246887,
0.4707002639770508,
0.11464156955480576,
-0.27136585116386414,
-0.17989379167556763,
0.05435976758599281,
0.7078816890716553,
-0.11651016771793365,
0.8323778510093689,
0.3301498293876648,
-0.3479161560535431,
-0.6093368530273438,
-0.9356008768081665,
-0.48572269082069397,
-0.5323567390441895,
0.15480254590511322,
-0.19223135709762573,
-0.9308940768241882,
0.645241379737854,
-0.6123677492141724,
-0.2282208502292633,
0.22662341594696045,
0.48777908086776733,
-0.1383924037218094,
1.086473822593689,
1.0658905506134033,
-0.1566002070903778,
0.21737726032733917,
-0.14136463403701782,
0.07967124134302139,
-0.7545259594917297,
-0.45626571774482727,
-0.4270564019680023,
-0.04229012131690979,
-0.49280574917793274,
-0.4292319416999817,
0.5299803614616394,
0.1856144219636917,
0.12298090010881424,
0.044056545943021774,
0.007065740879625082,
0.5919185876846313,
0.6512040495872498,
0.34069719910621643,
0.584692120552063,
-0.1593390554189682,
-0.4572478234767914,
-0.04601166397333145,
-0.8876252770423889,
-0.25525084137916565,
0.9955905079841614,
0.2476600855588913,
0.6548118591308594,
0.30240440368652344,
0.7445300221443176,
0.1305377334356308,
0.21207143366336823,
-0.9295233488082886,
0.7486863136291504,
-0.11387312412261963,
-0.49104657769203186,
-0.08843236416578293,
-0.6640146970748901,
-0.6659491062164307,
0.39035314321517944,
0.1834925413131714,
-0.8016245365142822,
0.1321389526128769,
-0.051601581275463104,
-0.4221945106983185,
0.212217316031456,
-0.8262459635734558,
0.5076823830604553,
-0.2748815715312958,
-0.7348445653915405,
-0.07313425838947296,
-0.5428414940834045,
0.5441381335258484,
-0.5110472440719604,
0.4088701903820038,
0.0652155801653862,
-0.5199252367019653,
0.8936823010444641,
-0.6173961162567139,
0.8545427918434143,
-0.11653365194797516,
-0.0869399756193161,
0.2564599812030792,
0.2571013867855072,
0.6803318858146667,
0.1587119847536087,
-0.1593918800354004,
0.03983914852142334,
-0.08080994337797165,
-0.2911539375782013,
-0.6491480469703674,
0.770719051361084,
-0.7462629675865173,
-0.8891469836235046,
-0.18193002045154572,
-0.5814769268035889,
-0.5460364818572998,
0.2736208736896515,
-0.11650525778532028,
-0.20021143555641174,
0.14107219874858856,
-0.0767846405506134,
0.9885896444320679,
-0.2517872154712677,
0.3257668614387512,
1.0101500749588013,
-0.20558448135852814,
-0.33628028631210327,
0.6947299838066101,
-0.0032367308158427477,
0.28160980343818665,
0.10455775260925293,
0.3580152094364166,
-0.34553009271621704,
-0.5492157340049744,
-0.2109997421503067,
0.843490719795227,
-0.5980222225189209,
-0.2425687164068222,
-0.6789910793304443,
-0.17844076454639435,
-0.29981356859207153,
0.08447521179914474,
-0.4858994483947754,
-0.3380904793739319,
-0.37650609016418457,
0.0007358043803833425,
0.12192562222480774,
0.7103724479675293,
-0.2101997286081314,
0.5388343334197998,
-0.9477956295013428,
0.06363452225923538,
0.49984559416770935,
0.04750121012330055,
0.05828392878174782,
-0.4724288880825043,
-0.3296089768409729,
0.0837683454155922,
-0.174924835562706,
-0.9845806360244751,
0.5285758376121521,
-0.04295656830072403,
0.7106176614761353,
0.3943437933921814,
-0.06428532302379608,
0.9239414930343628,
-0.363144189119339,
0.7415291666984558,
0.033476874232292175,
-0.850733757019043,
0.6112791895866394,
-0.330613911151886,
0.3777768611907959,
0.6053164005279541,
0.7936257123947144,
-0.36536872386932373,
-0.26354745030403137,
-0.6764400005340576,
-0.5624639391899109,
0.6293314099311829,
-0.194626122713089,
-0.16773639619350433,
0.06379356235265732,
0.6317956447601318,
0.11654587835073471,
0.6092139482498169,
-0.28155866265296936,
0.07544125616550446,
0.6021902561187744,
-0.2838934361934662,
0.08332572132349014,
-0.19353142380714417,
-0.03474678471684456,
-0.17262613773345947,
0.5190435647964478,
-0.4104277789592743,
0.004339868202805519,
-0.07053687423467636,
-0.31061145663261414,
-0.09998925030231476,
0.04819447174668312,
0.02873976342380047,
0.693999171257019,
-0.16737672686576843,
0.2610017955303192,
0.32095324993133545,
-0.4821164011955261,
-0.3120966851711273,
-0.025565896183252335,
0.014809316024184227,
-0.08958087861537933,
0.3754563331604004,
0.17772994935512543,
0.11959821730852127,
-0.9088488221168518,
0.8067854642868042,
0.002507877303287387,
-0.07445528358221054,
-0.30743172764778137,
0.26634615659713745,
0.3553411662578583,
0.5677943825721741,
0.4184061884880066,
-0.2861974835395813,
0.15352661907672882,
-0.5349742770195007,
0.2661171555519104,
0.5785530209541321,
-0.18769873678684235,
-0.4278068542480469,
0.5765944719314575,
0.08045168220996857,
-0.15590804815292358,
0.7369856834411621,
-0.2535347640514374,
-0.700038731098175,
0.4743780791759491,
0.48223504424095154,
0.4925014078617096,
-0.19712595641613007,
0.31378763914108276,
-0.05040394142270088,
0.2814326286315918,
-0.3679969906806946,
0.42488229274749756,
-0.07077968865633011,
-0.6573693156242371,
-0.524720311164856,
-0.6049562096595764,
-0.6260575652122498,
0.47666093707084656,
-0.4918288290500641,
0.16099780797958374,
-0.46011704206466675,
0.15852180123329163,
-0.10599339753389359,
0.45573359727859497,
-0.8669723272323608,
-0.0725574940443039,
0.0599929504096508,
1.035103440284729,
-0.8538729548454285,
0.6286206245422363,
0.6420682668685913,
-0.4792272746562958,
-0.8568885326385498,
0.18353012204170227,
0.4463646113872528,
-1.0652557611465454,
0.7489829063415527,
-0.1300402730703354,
-0.06320668756961823,
0.10624286532402039,
-0.7678727507591248,
-1.011812686920166,
1.1194754838943481,
0.4871635437011719,
-0.7467278242111206,
-0.13143756985664368,
0.16849227249622345,
0.5398612022399902,
-0.18202756345272064,
0.2094305008649826,
0.5626010894775391,
0.27283740043640137,
0.35649070143699646,
-1.0354501008987427,
-0.025589367374777794,
0.14542606472969055,
-0.3480623662471771,
0.17823533713817596,
-0.7980716824531555,
0.9558145403862,
-0.4087996184825897,
-0.2246212661266327,
0.25550588965415955,
0.5732333064079285,
0.24918308854103088,
0.4548563063144684,
0.3156132102012634,
0.46681103110313416,
1.351386308670044,
0.24983857572078705,
0.8985963463783264,
-0.1893262267112732,
0.2667323648929596,
1.213194727897644,
-0.44072335958480835,
1.0094882249832153,
0.5167214870452881,
-0.05426899343729019,
0.2912694215774536,
0.4619462490081787,
0.188456192612648,
0.6617682576179504,
0.11157513409852982,
-0.27996712923049927,
-0.5180056095123291,
-0.30199331045150757,
0.053678881376981735,
0.3407728374004364,
0.7359659075737,
-0.22993479669094086,
-0.2928313612937927,
-0.04214844852685928,
0.29206785559654236,
0.03700973466038704,
-0.5370113849639893,
0.9939176440238953,
0.36385172605514526,
-0.5270521640777588,
0.09021368622779846,
-0.06155622750520706,
0.5397895574569702,
-0.5053660273551941,
0.06273911148309708,
-0.7509196996688843,
0.45481064915657043,
-0.12668348848819733,
-0.636896550655365,
-0.086543969810009,
-0.27991509437561035,
-0.20155425369739532,
0.015519868582487106,
0.8639069199562073,
-0.3130669891834259,
-0.4574185609817505,
0.39847472310066223,
1.4654686450958252,
0.1547049880027771,
-0.11872434616088867,
-0.43030980229377747,
-0.1037345603108406,
-0.09100551903247833,
0.07318849861621857,
0.360395610332489,
0.6839268803596497,
0.033214882016181946,
0.856169581413269,
0.6061260104179382,
0.48753300309181213,
0.23794089257717133,
-0.18215587735176086,
0.9637806415557861,
-0.3550897538661957,
-0.47770509123802185,
-0.7559877038002014,
0.11106691509485245,
-0.3446090817451477,
0.1561029851436615,
1.0363816022872925,
0.6667090058326721,
0.8905654549598694,
0.11299441754817963,
0.791041374206543,
0.2916754484176636,
0.7597516179084778,
-0.49672508239746094,
0.6111159324645996,
-0.9156014919281006,
0.6268683671951294,
-0.13893577456474304,
-0.7307432293891907,
-0.12403611093759537,
0.3742375075817108,
-0.5262195467948914,
-0.11670393496751785,
0.6391996145248413,
0.9449663758277893,
-0.4731288552284241,
0.10525870323181152,
0.23899292945861816,
0.2517244517803192,
0.2272893339395523,
0.6852314472198486,
0.9796719551086426,
-0.09737668931484222,
0.4176943302154541,
-0.18536238372325897,
-0.1667308658361435,
-0.06400872021913528,
-0.605131208896637,
-1.1218535900115967,
-0.3952094316482544,
-0.17296528816223145,
-0.0635865181684494,
0.24113893508911133,
0.7816693186759949,
0.716611385345459,
-0.49689680337905884,
-0.33268752694129944,
0.08833806216716766,
0.5496500134468079,
0.08603272587060928,
-0.23061415553092957,
0.3270127475261688,
-0.3551042675971985,
-0.7150332927703857,
0.575741171836853,
0.1328132301568985,
-0.15295633673667908,
-0.36065223813056946,
-0.06506884098052979,
-0.16368110477924347,
0.3178344666957855,
0.4021744728088379,
0.22506636381149292,
-0.4857654869556427,
-0.08071120828390121,
0.08254006505012512,
0.08103370666503906,
-0.22928433120250702,
0.7703992128372192,
-1.048629641532898,
0.1763065606355667,
0.5762043595314026,
0.8528352975845337,
0.5531042814254761,
-0.11894450336694717,
0.4782628118991852,
-0.9501726031303406,
0.014074613340198994,
0.011425557546317577,
0.42736005783081055,
0.25689661502838135,
-0.38498133420944214,
0.6249854564666748,
0.4481528699398041,
-0.35425612330436707,
-0.7507374882698059,
-0.01538920309394598,
-0.7178077697753906,
-0.5477278828620911,
1.0438319444656372,
-0.13887746632099152,
-0.3723777234554291,
-0.15617509186267853,
0.06008186191320419,
-0.09907719492912292,
-0.38852640986442566,
0.7585071921348572,
0.5222963094711304,
0.0042200577445328236,
-0.2598731815814972,
-0.7697349786758423,
0.25623220205307007,
0.24781587719917297,
-0.7643110156059265,
-0.22282825410366058,
0.6501232385635376,
0.6022800803184509,
0.3802747428417206,
0.3454340100288391,
0.12924739718437195,
0.11733729392290115,
-0.23182161152362823,
-0.4202967584133148,
-0.12146903574466705,
-0.31649258732795715,
-0.03067193739116192,
0.6058424115180969,
-0.004284295253455639,
0.023104730993509293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12048v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12048v1 | Model Tailor: Mitigating Catastrophic Forgetting in Multi-modal Large Language Models | 2024-02-19T11:02:05 | 2024-02-19T11:02:05 | Didi Zhu, Zhongyi Sun, Zexi Li, Tao Shen, Ke Yan, Shouhong Ding, Kun Kuang, Chao Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Catastrophic forgetting emerges as a critical challenge when fine-tuning
multi-modal large language models (MLLMs), where improving performance on
unseen tasks often leads to a significant performance drop on the original
tasks. This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of catastrophic forgetting
in MLLMs and introduces a post-training adjustment method called Model Tailor.
Our method primarily preserves the pre-trained parameters while replacing a
small number ($\leq$ 10\%) of fine-tuned parameters, maintaining $\sim$ 99\%
effectiveness on original tasks versus pre-training, and achieving $\sim$ 97\%
on new tasks compared to standard fine-tuning. Specifically, we derive a sparse
mask to identify the "model patch", based on a fusion strategy that integrates
salience and sensitivity analysis. Subsequently, a compensation mechanism is
introduced to "decorate the patch", enhancing the model's performance on both
target and original tasks. Additionally, our method is adaptable to multi-task
scenarios. Through extensive experiments on InstructBLIP and LLaVA-1.5 in both
image captioning and visual question answering tasks, our approach demonstrates
significant task adaptability while preserving inherent pre-trained
capabilities. | [
-0.45592230558395386,
-0.6650696992874146,
0.26242437958717346,
0.14878863096237183,
-0.19981911778450012,
-0.07226769626140594,
-0.19836784899234772,
-0.0058743637055158615,
0.022969093173742294,
0.6696804761886597,
-0.9230070114135742,
-0.059130795300006866,
-0.4318697452545166,
-0.17494720220565796,
0.14491252601146698,
0.9678462743759155,
-0.09283668547868729,
0.03187742456793785,
-0.40683475136756897,
-0.3344815969467163,
-0.9192473292350769,
-0.38172513246536255,
-0.7963644862174988,
-0.07782979309558868,
0.6283316016197205,
0.4086793065071106,
0.3182065784931183,
0.3820768892765045,
0.4654594361782074,
0.2793646454811096,
-0.14146509766578674,
0.4782741963863373,
-0.8592724800109863,
0.0802873969078064,
-0.33755433559417725,
-0.4643453061580658,
-0.6200132966041565,
-0.14945156872272491,
0.8509209156036377,
0.5415523648262024,
-0.19474591314792633,
0.4367499351501465,
0.23893973231315613,
0.6813740134239197,
-1.0309224128723145,
-0.17551395297050476,
-0.9483209848403931,
-0.10109785944223404,
-0.12301938980817795,
-0.32097452878952026,
-0.5771468877792358,
0.1917663961648941,
-0.1711219847202301,
-0.54173743724823,
0.37001872062683105,
0.12800736725330353,
0.5622648596763611,
0.4635442793369293,
-0.0023776404559612274,
0.13565491139888763,
-0.7490751147270203,
0.9236443638801575,
-0.8826469779014587,
0.392624169588089,
0.548213005065918,
0.26761701703071594,
-0.19159351289272308,
-0.4446790814399719,
-0.32371464371681213,
-0.1997440904378891,
0.1285303831100464,
0.03854656592011452,
-0.06419425457715988,
-0.14731387794017792,
0.4151398241519928,
0.2307349145412445,
-0.608387291431427,
0.21955426037311554,
-0.2480570524930954,
-0.4244983494281769,
0.4270424246788025,
0.27445927262306213,
0.2023879587650299,
0.1440601944923401,
-0.10392438620328903,
0.046209633350372314,
-0.72588050365448,
-0.09976352751255035,
0.14390721917152405,
0.28815531730651855,
0.05778753384947777,
0.3457848131656647,
-0.11220906674861908,
0.8794896006584167,
-0.03877374529838562,
-0.29876160621643066,
-0.03677305206656456,
-0.3700873553752899,
-0.30486196279525757,
-0.45171666145324707,
0.4245314598083496,
0.2916765809059143,
0.2760597765445709,
-0.04058501869440079,
-0.37764495611190796,
-0.292052686214447,
0.48056671023368835,
-0.5064562559127808,
-0.5274756550788879,
-0.07139474153518677,
-0.4012112319469452,
-0.0003884645411744714,
-0.32259732484817505,
-0.5084877014160156,
-0.4700433313846588,
-0.3724210858345032,
0.7411988973617554,
-0.37068215012550354,
-0.235753133893013,
0.19001716375350952,
0.023399563506245613,
-0.1430671066045761,
0.35492515563964844,
-0.8593611121177673,
-0.08324635028839111,
0.22417251765727997,
0.8410266041755676,
0.08049872517585754,
-0.7332944869995117,
-0.643839418888092,
0.4110134541988373,
-0.23424816131591797,
0.9711097478866577,
-0.4427359700202942,
-0.11563056707382202,
-0.06291943788528442,
0.041056837886571884,
-0.5495469570159912,
-0.47589850425720215,
0.3826257586479187,
-0.3876809775829315,
0.13960771262645721,
-0.404593825340271,
-0.4201870858669281,
-0.1166912168264389,
0.5336377024650574,
-0.6959324479103088,
0.719460666179657,
0.11779594421386719,
-0.8092634081840515,
0.2842518091201782,
-0.53246009349823,
-0.28631454706192017,
-0.30535921454429626,
0.4697611629962921,
-0.8438843488693237,
0.314339280128479,
0.4667809009552002,
0.4370993673801422,
-0.23661841452121735,
0.04434971138834953,
-0.7048858404159546,
-0.46858248114585876,
0.2254132181406021,
-0.37721195816993713,
0.43984663486480713,
-0.1596604436635971,
0.02125784382224083,
0.4919450283050537,
-0.7344486117362976,
-0.018149588257074356,
0.15768462419509888,
-0.2716364860534668,
-0.3758902847766876,
0.03531833738088608,
0.26016712188720703,
0.3317124545574188,
0.18498292565345764,
-0.2106727659702301,
0.1917961984872818,
-0.3516356945037842,
0.7061675190925598,
0.9792900681495667,
0.15151801705360413,
0.3821030259132385,
-0.7406066656112671,
0.508241593837738,
-0.0062631880864501,
0.45862850546836853,
-0.655461847782135,
-0.015916481614112854,
-0.9467161297798157,
-0.4975753128528595,
0.15236559510231018,
0.3314113914966583,
-0.5732154846191406,
0.1725115180015564,
-0.04696832224726677,
-0.6397984027862549,
-0.47953927516937256,
0.12054777145385742,
0.43974775075912476,
0.5005576610565186,
0.4394519329071045,
-0.35279950499534607,
-0.6482975482940674,
-0.9639286398887634,
-0.3539290130138397,
0.06087571382522583,
-0.08392369002103806,
0.28476482629776,
0.4156743884086609,
-0.3293919861316681,
0.5396856069564819,
-0.44331708550453186,
-0.6153331995010376,
-0.19327013194561005,
-0.12078807502985,
-0.08740683645009995,
0.7054733633995056,
0.4849961996078491,
-0.6237062811851501,
-0.1970718950033188,
-0.22837431728839874,
-0.327146977186203,
0.046367645263671875,
-0.4410136044025421,
-0.09206142276525497,
0.3761390447616577,
0.6286250352859497,
-0.529297411441803,
0.2120533138513565,
0.36889830231666565,
-0.25339752435684204,
0.8371903896331787,
-0.5234077572822571,
0.1796213537454605,
-1.069893717765808,
0.34134387969970703,
-0.20825424790382385,
-0.14074420928955078,
-0.4782317876815796,
0.2395140677690506,
0.2742638885974884,
0.016584495082497597,
-0.32911035418510437,
0.5445479154586792,
-0.48208120465278625,
0.19439680874347687,
-0.33498066663742065,
-0.238280788064003,
-0.06971960514783859,
0.5984393954277039,
-0.43971681594848633,
0.6529926061630249,
0.5926356315612793,
-0.4677836000919342,
0.05483757704496384,
0.2423190325498581,
-0.055934906005859375,
0.622162938117981,
-0.4153658449649811,
0.2894645929336548,
-0.3732718825340271,
0.20425018668174744,
-1.157365322113037,
-0.33315664529800415,
0.22489047050476074,
-0.13926038146018982,
0.39994892477989197,
-0.12799791991710663,
-0.3866328001022339,
-0.43940240144729614,
-0.352239727973938,
0.45913711190223694,
0.27298247814178467,
-0.14092719554901123,
0.7282966375350952,
0.25945720076560974,
-0.35953786969184875,
-0.30037885904312134,
-0.29273170232772827,
0.14943340420722961,
-0.40784528851509094,
-0.27828919887542725,
0.1960659772157669,
-0.5375597476959229,
0.26743167638778687,
-0.2885187268257141,
-0.13262827694416046,
-0.30798304080963135,
0.21354788541793823,
0.07961097359657288,
0.29234299063682556,
-0.3091113269329071,
0.13239817321300507,
0.1499648541212082,
-0.16733914613723755,
-0.22132447361946106,
-0.22369596362113953,
0.6887280344963074,
0.012876949273049831,
-0.5248445272445679,
-0.2845902740955353,
0.41545987129211426,
1.0478869676589966,
-0.5934121608734131,
0.7180469036102295,
0.6645408272743225,
-0.5064902305603027,
-0.08788327872753143,
-0.997186005115509,
-0.24730180203914642,
-0.4064662456512451,
0.7926123142242432,
-0.20922359824180603,
-0.8894301056861877,
0.7063825726509094,
0.005081153009086847,
0.18229971826076508,
0.2887336015701294,
0.6382598876953125,
-0.14668725430965424,
0.9289037585258484,
0.9397031664848328,
-0.30822572112083435,
0.5504051446914673,
0.13420164585113525,
0.07825219631195068,
-0.9179133772850037,
-0.15498895943164825,
-0.2568559944629669,
-0.35556527972221375,
0.0011077140225097537,
-0.4168497323989868,
0.3027850389480591,
0.29360663890838623,
-0.4076481759548187,
0.2763768136501312,
-0.3123611509799957,
0.48571905493736267,
0.6598171591758728,
0.42625999450683594,
0.13273102045059204,
-0.26826193928718567,
0.2533396780490875,
-0.31214556097984314,
-0.9825729727745056,
-0.18780383467674255,
0.9908174872398376,
0.14824452996253967,
0.5587390065193176,
-0.050678376108407974,
0.38611000776290894,
0.09265449643135071,
0.33276158571243286,
-0.4206182062625885,
0.3681515157222748,
-0.09890446811914444,
-0.33786439895629883,
-0.40101170539855957,
-0.2280658632516861,
-0.5838105082511902,
0.1443672776222229,
-0.39244508743286133,
-0.6754633188247681,
-0.11379969120025635,
0.6956632137298584,
-0.539429783821106,
0.36089175939559937,
-0.7029536366462708,
1.0299322605133057,
0.006956445053219795,
-0.26697617769241333,
-0.42696258425712585,
-0.37999796867370605,
0.47792041301727295,
-0.49361997842788696,
0.12028691917657852,
-0.10456184297800064,
0.12351026386022568,
0.6434699892997742,
0.10830123722553253,
0.984548032283783,
-0.13097602128982544,
0.15929102897644043,
-0.14401531219482422,
0.21417707204818726,
0.6163263916969299,
-0.17942962050437927,
-0.017428474500775337,
-0.13526573777198792,
0.11060550808906555,
-0.6495447754859924,
-0.49597516655921936,
0.6400244235992432,
-0.2929039001464844,
-0.5710753798484802,
0.05760367959737778,
-1.1264055967330933,
-0.4568915367126465,
0.34809547662734985,
0.29611676931381226,
0.33248257637023926,
-0.16001494228839874,
0.04501928389072418,
0.8621477484703064,
-0.3667079210281372,
0.6119655966758728,
0.6546062231063843,
0.05705930292606354,
-0.5330270528793335,
0.9561487436294556,
0.16104140877723694,
0.3794412910938263,
0.1870596557855606,
0.13142728805541992,
0.04180101677775383,
-0.7290311455726624,
-0.4419352412223816,
0.2830006778240204,
-0.5092393159866333,
-0.4423268437385559,
-0.5194622278213501,
-0.15189334750175476,
-0.34187018871307373,
-0.34728315472602844,
-0.5349302887916565,
-0.12249075621366501,
-0.41565608978271484,
0.3296690583229065,
0.17459224164485931,
0.42903685569763184,
0.08937422931194305,
0.28970736265182495,
-0.8004077076911926,
0.18865929543972015,
0.22980664670467377,
0.4650322198867798,
0.19129152595996857,
-0.9371070861816406,
-0.37172791361808777,
0.056209370493888855,
-0.33062905073165894,
-0.48119980096817017,
0.21051937341690063,
0.5889363288879395,
0.5476307272911072,
0.23347771167755127,
0.056734904646873474,
1.0104597806930542,
-0.69161057472229,
0.5514606833457947,
0.2422109991312027,
-0.7401915192604065,
0.6256065368652344,
-0.4829995632171631,
0.7825185656547546,
0.35951894521713257,
0.06891601532697678,
-0.4921603500843048,
-0.5398401618003845,
-0.4963594079017639,
-0.8575019240379333,
0.5671752691268921,
-0.14643846452236176,
0.29843488335609436,
0.28032177686691284,
0.4593857526779175,
0.04371342808008194,
-0.01428980566561222,
-0.6542617082595825,
-0.12248332798480988,
0.027397962287068367,
0.04391423985362053,
-0.2532193958759308,
-0.6510543823242188,
-0.21357952058315277,
-0.36833035945892334,
0.7032186388969421,
-0.2087525874376297,
-0.014275792054831982,
-0.050628677010536194,
-0.3972472846508026,
-0.14314186573028564,
0.044973503798246384,
1.2352371215820312,
1.0405641794204712,
0.048212967813014984,
-0.038876552134752274,
0.5647127032279968,
-0.2805978059768677,
-0.11121834069490433,
0.07046707719564438,
-0.010086014866828918,
-0.18756717443466187,
0.7025206685066223,
0.9382937550544739,
0.6350910067558289,
-0.7738469839096069,
0.3760242164134979,
0.15575112402439117,
0.018668660894036293,
-0.12919844686985016,
0.11032119393348694,
0.1412678211927414,
0.3083403408527374,
0.19840888679027557,
0.6287192106246948,
-0.07662155479192734,
-0.3079881966114044,
0.4236331880092621,
0.4387321174144745,
-0.533687949180603,
-0.31812185049057007,
0.8032786846160889,
-0.23448622226715088,
-0.5041854977607727,
0.47328945994377136,
0.3072035312652588,
-0.4901733994483948,
0.3776439428329468,
0.8066084980964661,
0.711911141872406,
-0.6137151122093201,
0.06497398018836975,
0.45553645491600037,
0.4632706046104431,
-0.2766436040401459,
-0.07275134325027466,
0.08227075636386871,
-0.4228065013885498,
-0.5627760887145996,
-0.6253101229667664,
-0.018787192180752754,
0.17445725202560425,
-0.7587361335754395,
0.20246875286102295,
-0.5351508855819702,
0.08366943895816803,
-0.11385621875524521,
-0.5937908291816711,
-0.6107357740402222,
0.18450239300727844,
0.007254625204950571,
0.9491822123527527,
-1.0426197052001953,
0.6224647164344788,
0.6523535251617432,
-0.4193632900714874,
-0.6409598588943481,
0.07999997586011887,
-0.009342892095446587,
-0.8317908048629761,
-0.015521923080086708,
0.03361564874649048,
0.22205643355846405,
0.10824684798717499,
-0.26568031311035156,
-0.985932469367981,
0.8494912385940552,
0.7774802446365356,
-0.596200704574585,
-0.03867871314287186,
-0.13725468516349792,
0.4120253920555115,
-0.13547423481941223,
0.12571416795253754,
0.5895326733589172,
0.32782188057899475,
0.11099965125322342,
-1.2447986602783203,
0.020018618553876877,
-0.11893924325704575,
0.03508752956986427,
0.2450864613056183,
-0.5643552541732788,
0.6954212784767151,
-0.396657794713974,
0.21420495212078094,
0.19929338991641998,
0.23242798447608948,
0.2540335953235626,
0.20578956604003906,
0.5464206337928772,
0.5538370013237,
0.7563372850418091,
0.24344748258590698,
0.8309402465820312,
0.06631223112344742,
0.4934842586517334,
1.3538918495178223,
0.048092521727085114,
0.9257964491844177,
0.6119495034217834,
0.004530542995780706,
-0.02142762765288353,
0.7341660857200623,
0.033153604716062546,
0.6937187314033508,
0.08409110456705093,
-0.14830613136291504,
-0.6215080618858337,
-0.017255309969186783,
-0.2931760847568512,
0.4207087755203247,
0.12573175132274628,
-0.2874681055545807,
-0.17828597128391266,
0.4866625964641571,
-0.03706992417573929,
0.04264575615525246,
-0.5848463177680969,
0.8863422870635986,
-0.03888939321041107,
-0.6537324786186218,
0.8255098462104797,
-0.17837132513523102,
0.36129307746887207,
-0.6462562084197998,
0.028981713578104973,
-0.29383477568626404,
0.4224878251552582,
0.07568160444498062,
-0.2237791270017624,
0.4923212230205536,
-0.41543760895729065,
-0.6975212097167969,
-0.09039568156003952,
0.5181612968444824,
-0.6140314340591431,
-0.7498722076416016,
-0.06819042563438416,
0.14851050078868866,
-0.3650989234447479,
-0.4880927503108978,
-0.767867386341095,
0.3670922815799713,
0.09739521145820618,
-0.15862593054771423,
0.4576692581176758,
0.18753492832183838,
-0.21706320345401764,
0.895466148853302,
0.5396652221679688,
-0.007492842618376017,
-0.026135576888918877,
0.08480342477560043,
1.020716667175293,
-0.45028579235076904,
-0.4468194544315338,
-0.9639321565628052,
0.8656346797943115,
-0.029860807582736015,
-0.4662880301475525,
0.6803804636001587,
0.383231520652771,
0.7171430587768555,
-0.451803058385849,
0.563587486743927,
0.17897993326187134,
0.43945783376693726,
-0.5905439853668213,
1.069454550743103,
-0.6669780015945435,
0.17214342951774597,
-0.4814824163913727,
-1.0479655265808105,
-0.8052449822425842,
0.41537877917289734,
-0.12497090548276901,
-0.14822155237197876,
0.5468460917472839,
1.1091808080673218,
-0.2586829662322998,
-0.4737141728401184,
0.5392828583717346,
0.24619826674461365,
0.14253443479537964,
0.7989243268966675,
0.6477852463722229,
-0.4203668534755707,
0.48036694526672363,
-0.006237974390387535,
-0.31534504890441895,
-0.2585051655769348,
-0.7973926067352295,
-0.9946567416191101,
-0.819045901298523,
-0.3967096209526062,
-0.1891644299030304,
0.15354417264461517,
0.5494265556335449,
0.8622730374336243,
-0.8317739963531494,
0.26783499121665955,
0.1909390538930893,
0.021163692697882652,
-0.3252011835575104,
-0.08772315084934235,
0.4518609344959259,
-0.46427232027053833,
-0.4553820788860321,
0.218796044588089,
0.5692794322967529,
-0.07434776425361633,
-0.2237502485513687,
0.008078431710600853,
-0.053754229098558426,
0.04122497886419296,
0.6356462240219116,
0.3227992653846741,
-0.9378257393836975,
-0.4942946135997772,
-0.07639866322278976,
0.1979505717754364,
-0.1289006471633911,
0.9162135720252991,
-0.5366077423095703,
0.6690440773963928,
-0.023374667391180992,
0.7366632223129272,
0.32134076952934265,
-0.34923726320266724,
0.6676903367042542,
-0.6936699748039246,
0.39312034845352173,
0.2334672063589096,
0.4858456254005432,
0.4447537064552307,
-0.22182238101959229,
-0.021153083071112633,
0.20110370218753815,
-0.5327046513557434,
-1.0764617919921875,
0.34085798263549805,
-0.8778098821640015,
-0.3033220171928406,
0.7143742442131042,
-0.17849622666835785,
0.1139383390545845,
-0.11471644788980484,
-0.5563967227935791,
0.026701796799898148,
0.2788793742656708,
1.148024559020996,
0.7037665843963623,
0.23172126710414886,
-0.5745841264724731,
-0.37383684515953064,
0.3937462568283081,
0.6570978164672852,
-0.46837887167930603,
0.3432130217552185,
0.5335764288902283,
0.47810089588165283,
-0.21211880445480347,
0.6394200325012207,
0.1641116738319397,
0.5146586298942566,
-0.16205884516239166,
0.009492580778896809,
-0.29383522272109985,
-0.3814537525177002,
-0.2593832314014435,
0.2412586808204651,
0.1857403665781021,
-0.0926605612039566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12046v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12046v1 | Citation Amnesia: NLP and Other Academic Fields Are in a Citation Age Recession | 2024-02-19T10:59:29 | 2024-02-19T10:59:29 | Jan Philip Wahle, Terry Ruas, Mohamed Abdalla, Bela Gipp, Saif M. Mohammad | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL | This study examines the tendency to cite older work across 20 fields of study
over 43 years (1980--2023). We put NLP's propensity to cite older work in the
context of these 20 other fields to analyze whether NLP shows similar temporal
citation patterns to these other fields over time or whether differences can be
observed. Our analysis, based on a dataset of approximately 240 million papers,
reveals a broader scientific trend: many fields have markedly declined in
citing older works (e.g., psychology, computer science). We term this decline a
'citation age recession', analogous to how economists define periods of reduced
economic activity. The trend is strongest in NLP and ML research (-12.8% and
-5.5% in citation age from previous peaks). Our results suggest that citing
more recent works is not directly driven by the growth in publication rates
(-3.4% across fields; -5.2% in humanities; -5.5% in formal sciences) -- even
when controlling for an increase in the volume of papers. Our findings raise
questions about the scientific community's engagement with past literature,
particularly for NLP, and the potential consequences of neglecting older but
relevant research. The data and a demo showcasing our results are publicly
available. | [
-0.4533917009830475,
-0.36868688464164734,
0.6698817014694214,
0.4459092319011688,
0.06346799433231354,
-0.10426091402769089,
0.24350446462631226,
-0.8456288576126099,
0.3094375729560852,
0.23717057704925537,
-0.24821916222572327,
-0.24944829940795898,
-0.5540502667427063,
0.4988076984882355,
-0.12280527502298355,
0.957234799861908,
0.29282742738723755,
-0.0832531675696373,
-0.4476560354232788,
-0.20852850377559662,
-0.417901873588562,
-0.5450496673583984,
-0.8327182531356812,
-0.45675957202911377,
0.7598880529403687,
-0.14293453097343445,
0.4680315852165222,
0.31206101179122925,
0.6044957041740417,
0.1541362702846527,
-0.6745060086250305,
-0.1342611312866211,
-0.4991382658481598,
0.3154250681400299,
-0.4092167913913727,
-0.3908239006996155,
-0.5748476982116699,
-0.18964159488677979,
0.6143826246261597,
1.0463896989822388,
0.28776776790618896,
0.1210634782910347,
-0.21643808484077454,
1.263298511505127,
-0.8734285831451416,
-0.006130595691502094,
-0.773678183555603,
-0.06386300921440125,
-0.34012696146965027,
-0.7103620171546936,
-0.6616935729980469,
-0.48216286301612854,
0.22865590453147888,
-0.3939857482910156,
0.38979458808898926,
0.20196539163589478,
0.6061646342277527,
0.01283558551222086,
-0.11537458747625351,
-0.14370504021644592,
-0.7116504311561584,
0.7907001376152039,
-0.5249848961830139,
0.10094455629587173,
0.5846102833747864,
0.041080351918935776,
0.06834463030099869,
-0.9370037317276001,
-0.20452675223350525,
0.04711442068219185,
0.014186123386025429,
0.0736236572265625,
-0.5820705890655518,
-0.4852067232131958,
0.35822275280952454,
0.17909733951091766,
-0.6183214783668518,
-0.07732707262039185,
-0.9172943234443665,
-0.06182452663779259,
0.19810280203819275,
0.06093687191605568,
0.08527371287345886,
-0.09325602650642395,
-0.5607408881187439,
0.26803064346313477,
-1.0525401830673218,
-0.2543097734451294,
0.09195105731487274,
0.023122960701584816,
0.5789504647254944,
0.6226263642311096,
0.06325540691614151,
0.2959083020687103,
-0.08042041212320328,
0.34905314445495605,
0.3290848731994629,
-0.39528438448905945,
-0.2181193232536316,
0.1175108402967453,
0.6154312491416931,
0.49906569719314575,
0.23314806818962097,
-0.32139286398887634,
0.3077065646648407,
-0.34112000465393066,
0.24213482439517975,
-0.5317592620849609,
-0.2539227604866028,
-0.11840928345918655,
-0.6127110719680786,
0.19286206364631653,
0.014754817821085453,
-0.7990414500236511,
-0.5571972727775574,
0.0522279217839241,
-0.0732346624135971,
-0.5665667057037354,
-0.1771935075521469,
-0.019815165549516678,
-0.6687428951263428,
-0.005932212807238102,
0.07042688876390457,
-0.7406545877456665,
0.08137962967157364,
0.5519065856933594,
1.2050025463104248,
-0.09432206302881241,
-0.46826767921447754,
0.02459551766514778,
0.11256133764982224,
-0.3420760929584503,
0.8250089883804321,
-0.6901455521583557,
-0.6081535220146179,
0.022556982934474945,
0.10343366861343384,
-0.2859427034854889,
-0.6147468686103821,
0.46127843856811523,
-0.75472092628479,
0.19181793928146362,
-0.3292404115200043,
-0.22481387853622437,
-0.15066806972026825,
-0.04458107426762581,
-0.7494661808013916,
0.9111523032188416,
0.21591246128082275,
-0.996845006942749,
0.738939642906189,
-0.45450353622436523,
0.019103890284895897,
-0.13460665941238403,
0.11097530275583267,
-0.5532522797584534,
0.13077516853809357,
0.005755103193223476,
0.03969572111964226,
-0.31323137879371643,
0.306956946849823,
-0.6467510461807251,
-0.37655866146087646,
0.19203999638557434,
-0.352702796459198,
1.3097561597824097,
0.4045969247817993,
-0.06501630693674088,
-0.465873658657074,
-0.8323841691017151,
-0.15460504591464996,
-0.17368580400943756,
-0.0655144602060318,
-0.9538305997848511,
0.12482845783233643,
-0.19262832403182983,
0.16100388765335083,
0.06452013552188873,
-0.563044548034668,
0.41548940539360046,
-0.38859057426452637,
0.6642405390739441,
0.1437983214855194,
0.5310114026069641,
0.5307213664054871,
-0.7033288478851318,
0.5516056418418884,
-0.11382998526096344,
-0.1020393967628479,
-0.22981928288936615,
-0.7016574740409851,
-0.40272653102874756,
0.135501429438591,
-0.16001193225383759,
0.2487589567899704,
-0.23273371160030365,
0.10696055740118027,
-0.36578911542892456,
-0.3701585531234741,
-0.1701297014951706,
-0.01355281937867403,
-0.1935807466506958,
0.6304466128349304,
0.7833302021026611,
-0.1698721945285797,
-0.8610906004905701,
-0.685521125793457,
-0.6325887441635132,
-0.6019631028175354,
-0.2369319349527359,
0.2502214312553406,
0.6011631488800049,
-0.08566369116306305,
1.0043858289718628,
-0.20990560948848724,
-0.4564493000507355,
0.32507750391960144,
0.7276642918586731,
0.07222600281238556,
0.5526283383369446,
0.8062763810157776,
-0.7184829115867615,
-0.06829904019832611,
-0.37501198053359985,
-0.49941784143447876,
-0.19661039113998413,
-0.30661559104919434,
0.09105773270130157,
0.4675731658935547,
0.789512038230896,
-0.46299612522125244,
0.3210451304912567,
0.06802988797426224,
-0.6615394949913025,
0.5815958380699158,
0.05234929546713829,
-0.06524474918842316,
-0.27536964416503906,
0.7330716252326965,
-0.21949702501296997,
0.3770621716976166,
-0.0906582698225975,
-0.5271188020706177,
-0.0465276800096035,
-0.24653953313827515,
-0.027492349967360497,
0.1834435760974884,
-0.8273160457611084,
0.06558524817228317,
-0.22669298946857452,
-0.07973097264766693,
0.2447894811630249,
-0.18116481602191925,
0.1413835883140564,
0.5883983969688416,
0.3308331072330475,
-0.4397396743297577,
-0.23889371752738953,
-0.10322288423776627,
-0.22859513759613037,
0.4910584092140198,
-0.5632405877113342,
0.13864238560199738,
-0.4087259769439697,
0.3524370789527893,
-0.699928879737854,
0.40654152631759644,
-0.24875886738300323,
-0.3493327498435974,
0.08765754848718643,
-0.12632738053798676,
-0.08803246170282364,
-0.34920448064804077,
-0.43383628129959106,
0.37056899070739746,
0.22600704431533813,
0.03841825947165489,
0.5578137040138245,
-0.04772500693798065,
-0.8271774649620056,
-0.8669068217277527,
-0.7015164494514465,
0.10808441787958145,
-0.41991126537323,
-0.5460063219070435,
0.6225801110267639,
0.06797736138105392,
-0.6647898554801941,
0.32669922709465027,
-0.2667786180973053,
-0.1391630470752716,
0.2752707600593567,
0.25547048449516296,
0.2531719505786896,
-0.5061361193656921,
0.15764428675174713,
-0.03890686854720116,
-0.010044089518487453,
0.3800346553325653,
-0.3373037576675415,
0.5965057015419006,
-0.2540019750595093,
-0.008513703010976315,
0.07401428371667862,
0.5226256251335144,
0.6157335042953491,
-0.13173671066761017,
0.8902559280395508,
0.3419627845287323,
-0.12920071184635162,
0.22024299204349518,
-0.4426760971546173,
0.04180040955543518,
-0.321180135011673,
0.15658313035964966,
0.12225141376256943,
-0.62725430727005,
0.3958958685398102,
-0.02262638695538044,
0.24183343350887299,
0.8601610660552979,
0.30035385489463806,
-0.20156347751617432,
0.38928109407424927,
0.598487913608551,
-0.04743000864982605,
0.568503201007843,
-0.28706324100494385,
0.17560921609401703,
-0.7864852547645569,
-0.4834279417991638,
-0.8467839956283569,
-0.3439810872077942,
-0.29274484515190125,
-0.36100634932518005,
0.05357567220926285,
0.42349496483802795,
-0.17723716795444489,
0.11726759374141693,
-0.4535965323448181,
0.47373735904693604,
0.48449134826660156,
-0.2717449963092804,
0.61170893907547,
-0.2661314606666565,
0.39931172132492065,
-0.26309508085250854,
-0.4522292912006378,
-0.45982056856155396,
0.9907987117767334,
0.23839688301086426,
0.45859500765800476,
0.1798064410686493,
0.7184291481971741,
0.4939168691635132,
0.48949506878852844,
-0.5894016027450562,
0.16954746842384338,
0.24295192956924438,
-0.8098121881484985,
-0.4163516163825989,
-0.25239014625549316,
-1.3796498775482178,
0.07513239234685898,
-0.18332083523273468,
-0.665304958820343,
0.9188628792762756,
0.03619028255343437,
-0.3024002015590668,
0.03093935176730156,
-0.28776881098747253,
0.49403494596481323,
0.29619115591049194,
-0.34861448407173157,
-0.07300464063882828,
-0.7939609885215759,
0.5497398376464844,
0.07353422790765762,
0.3058667778968811,
-0.19271959364414215,
0.18920040130615234,
0.921725869178772,
-0.23202882707118988,
0.58323734998703,
-0.2962348163127899,
0.27138808369636536,
0.36037570238113403,
0.19076091051101685,
0.3757588863372803,
0.12696616351604462,
-0.1813296377658844,
-0.2592170238494873,
0.39174678921699524,
-0.5175259113311768,
-0.2667801082134247,
0.8560020327568054,
-0.33728209137916565,
-0.3927553594112396,
-0.9256899356842041,
-0.6001877188682556,
-0.10267068445682526,
0.1961221992969513,
0.36441221833229065,
0.05554195120930672,
-0.29430466890335083,
0.6087509989738464,
0.5365606546401978,
-0.1151994988322258,
0.7550382018089294,
0.5195140838623047,
-0.28084099292755127,
-0.3385513722896576,
0.6927258968353271,
0.3900456428527832,
0.21045838296413422,
0.17952916026115417,
0.07636140286922455,
0.011495806276798248,
-0.6624466776847839,
-0.00016102891822811216,
0.36667731404304504,
-0.503662645816803,
-0.21641910076141357,
-0.9109510183334351,
0.2128966599702835,
-0.715997040271759,
-0.14526090025901794,
-0.026629377156496048,
-0.6085934638977051,
-0.48931777477264404,
0.10521295666694641,
0.4247293770313263,
0.24743284285068512,
-0.013344737701117992,
-0.15354277193546295,
-0.41476455330848694,
-0.08242177218198776,
0.1208517849445343,
0.041335221379995346,
0.15346913039684296,
-0.3641435205936432,
-0.09746234118938446,
-0.542291522026062,
-0.3617348074913025,
-0.8767697215080261,
0.5699364542961121,
0.6249294877052307,
0.2775484323501587,
0.49917158484458923,
0.07619832456111908,
0.5803120136260986,
-0.5326584577560425,
0.9131348729133606,
0.10948780179023743,
-0.45880240201950073,
0.19020414352416992,
-0.3709966838359833,
0.5950264930725098,
0.9350330829620361,
0.9228803515434265,
-0.4939686059951782,
-0.369848370552063,
-0.9691281318664551,
-1.4907560348510742,
0.21737271547317505,
-0.23485296964645386,
-0.06646472215652466,
-0.16948463022708893,
0.1494656205177307,
0.23353078961372375,
0.00003573150388547219,
-0.7480522394180298,
-0.5088930130004883,
-0.20154044032096863,
0.32533928751945496,
0.28681492805480957,
-0.43658697605133057,
-0.15982145071029663,
-0.17373879253864288,
0.49985870718955994,
0.1689511090517044,
0.43029752373695374,
0.47978675365448,
-0.09094583243131638,
0.00984852947294712,
0.3143492043018341,
0.737888753414154,
1.3312443494796753,
-0.44775521755218506,
0.5539336800575256,
-0.2576628625392914,
-0.5587871074676514,
-0.17398478090763092,
0.23109430074691772,
-0.5465301871299744,
0.32749781012535095,
0.45323246717453003,
0.3982183039188385,
0.30957239866256714,
-0.466562956571579,
0.15029796957969666,
0.47452113032341003,
-0.18666934967041016,
-0.7292829751968384,
-0.3044539988040924,
0.17787398397922516,
0.13851705193519592,
1.0534664392471313,
0.4411654472351074,
0.31944867968559265,
-0.9689257740974426,
0.1438499540090561,
0.2577224671840668,
-0.33550894260406494,
-0.25586700439453125,
0.8657060265541077,
-0.22016361355781555,
-0.030303707346320152,
0.25711581110954285,
0.07892550528049469,
-0.049021489918231964,
0.5028787851333618,
0.8256233334541321,
0.6144096255302429,
0.24624425172805786,
0.22044895589351654,
0.41414856910705566,
0.3720274269580841,
-0.276615172624588,
0.10574938356876373,
0.16005180776119232,
-0.10116815567016602,
-0.4434794783592224,
-0.678429126739502,
-0.023079441860318184,
0.36587291955947876,
-0.7814327478408813,
-0.028558922931551933,
-0.18997034430503845,
-0.6552914381027222,
0.17509014904499054,
-0.1749848574399948,
-0.6964904069900513,
0.0540362149477005,
-0.16106407344341278,
0.7787272930145264,
-1.0014538764953613,
0.534905731678009,
0.418937623500824,
-0.6027495861053467,
0.29620078206062317,
-0.3404439687728882,
0.09755601733922958,
-0.4484993815422058,
1.0089527368545532,
-0.03100823052227497,
-0.26239755749702454,
-0.029934372752904892,
-0.48249390721321106,
-1.1417211294174194,
1.1627169847488403,
-0.017863502725958824,
-0.48777392506599426,
-0.3619851768016815,
-0.5244090557098389,
0.7579831480979919,
-0.27151888608932495,
0.01373316254466772,
0.49830541014671326,
0.5014190673828125,
-0.15418986976146698,
-0.6240202188491821,
-0.049030374735593796,
-0.38059839606285095,
-0.18312858045101166,
0.38230016827583313,
-0.45357319712638855,
0.8931840658187866,
-0.28472650051116943,
-0.5233309268951416,
0.22242122888565063,
1.0031087398529053,
0.29533836245536804,
1.0915111303329468,
0.24650901556015015,
0.2083224356174469,
0.78443443775177,
0.058864396065473557,
0.6577872037887573,
0.05803043395280838,
0.05536375194787979,
1.0406663417816162,
-0.12318692356348038,
0.8711272478103638,
1.076000690460205,
-0.3187731206417084,
0.7457066178321838,
0.10447467118501663,
-0.3265446424484253,
0.4985044300556183,
0.027280064299702644,
-0.11625264585018158,
0.18833792209625244,
-0.04509073123335838,
-0.7735511064529419,
-0.08389993757009506,
0.22352099418640137,
-1.1459075212478638,
-0.16467797756195068,
0.09135020524263382,
0.5280656814575195,
0.13139575719833374,
-0.19031062722206116,
0.4271164536476135,
0.25545641779899597,
-0.6444555521011353,
0.5998929738998413,
-0.42354169487953186,
0.4777767062187195,
-0.47079890966415405,
0.15969131886959076,
-0.24413339793682098,
-0.1365702748298645,
-0.1952056735754013,
-0.42247581481933594,
0.6523991823196411,
0.08854862302541733,
-0.6333603858947754,
-0.15098293125629425,
0.5226352214813232,
-0.22285987436771393,
-0.3119335472583771,
0.1344609409570694,
0.6268765926361084,
0.4234292209148407,
0.1030125692486763,
-0.2424006313085556,
-0.032023996114730835,
-0.26218605041503906,
-0.3633061945438385,
0.5485284924507141,
0.7634024620056152,
-0.07717383652925491,
0.5828090906143188,
0.24490442872047424,
0.4063014090061188,
0.22120167315006256,
0.0590846948325634,
0.5139074325561523,
-0.8787449598312378,
0.1984999030828476,
-0.8451058268547058,
0.06455762684345245,
-0.3785717189311981,
-0.8694527745246887,
0.989185631275177,
0.6412133574485779,
0.6326536536216736,
-0.056877732276916504,
0.5925476551055908,
-0.3828260004520416,
0.385672926902771,
-0.5479528903961182,
0.6391612887382507,
-0.35113832354545593,
0.35835692286491394,
-0.3599461019039154,
-0.8209620118141174,
-0.5743204355239868,
0.44344261288642883,
-0.4060834050178528,
0.13745655119419098,
0.9739933013916016,
0.15619473159313202,
0.4053652882575989,
0.18501271307468414,
-0.08733943849802017,
0.07379467785358429,
0.1446874737739563,
0.03975379094481468,
0.5751535296440125,
0.08078035712242126,
0.6108021140098572,
-0.3478667140007019,
0.06671799719333649,
-0.4897598922252655,
-1.0348211526870728,
-0.45510393381118774,
-0.588252604007721,
-0.3640945255756378,
-0.42749452590942383,
0.10907354950904846,
0.33992651104927063,
-0.1355178952217102,
-0.7247053384780884,
0.31959259510040283,
-0.1102982610464096,
-0.07970474660396576,
-0.954375684261322,
-0.33362215757369995,
0.6993746161460876,
-0.321961373090744,
-0.6271759867668152,
0.45740848779678345,
0.20995193719863892,
-0.0787665992975235,
-0.2541608214378357,
0.4954681992530823,
-0.4567352831363678,
-0.10044875741004944,
0.6234327554702759,
0.8390347957611084,
-0.5294804573059082,
-0.14128993451595306,
0.5535217523574829,
0.014872324652969837,
0.164581760764122,
1.2898483276367188,
-0.8923207521438599,
0.4100745916366577,
0.7792419195175171,
0.24449867010116577,
0.606231689453125,
0.20914612710475922,
0.5381418466567993,
-0.3215474784374237,
-0.1310817152261734,
0.8337972164154053,
0.4293302595615387,
0.3717578053474426,
0.11798924952745438,
0.5730493664741516,
0.6059385538101196,
-0.9553090333938599,
-1.1501456499099731,
-0.0992710217833519,
-0.8115187883377075,
-0.59071946144104,
0.49973490834236145,
-0.09358207136392593,
-0.15750348567962646,
-0.8712087273597717,
0.08596108108758926,
-0.11725334823131561,
-0.37736600637435913,
1.3067611455917358,
0.8682337403297424,
-0.3915479779243469,
-0.2362729012966156,
-0.496412456035614,
0.6197329163551331,
0.6644067764282227,
-0.24838976562023163,
0.369217187166214,
0.6290618777275085,
-0.062466736882925034,
0.7011235356330872,
0.6526510715484619,
-0.43869686126708984,
0.3233183026313782,
0.3077126145362854,
-0.23769481480121613,
-0.052544888108968735,
-0.46746447682380676,
0.03727457672357559,
0.6200946569442749,
0.26879575848579407,
0.6181372404098511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12038v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12038v3 | Self-AMPLIFY: Improving Small Language Models with Self Post Hoc Explanations | 2024-02-19T10:47:09 | 2024-06-17T08:52:29 | Milan Bhan, Jean-Noel Vittaut, Nicolas Chesneau, Marie-Jeanne Lesot | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Incorporating natural language rationales in the prompt and In-Context
Learning (ICL) have led to a significant improvement of Large Language Models
(LLMs) performance. However, generating high-quality rationales require
human-annotation or the use of auxiliary proxy models. In this work, we propose
Self-AMPLIFY to automatically generate rationales from post hoc explanation
methods applied to Small Language Models (SLMs) to improve their own
performance. Self-AMPLIFY is a 3-step method that targets samples, generates
rationales and builds a final prompt to leverage ICL. Self-AMPLIFY performance
is evaluated on four SLMs and five datasets requiring strong reasoning
abilities. Self-AMPLIFY achieves good results against competitors, leading to
strong accuracy improvement. Self-AMPLIFY is the first method to apply post hoc
explanation methods to autoregressive language models to generate rationales to
improve their own performance in a fully automated manner. | [
-0.5783311724662781,
-0.7431364059448242,
0.6087645292282104,
0.34931111335754395,
-0.24691495299339294,
-0.29910963773727417,
-0.2487751841545105,
-0.12168567627668381,
-0.0690494030714035,
0.5091449618339539,
-0.5827277898788452,
-0.23444849252700806,
-0.17465545237064362,
0.41047537326812744,
-0.2935834527015686,
0.769756555557251,
0.12446706742048264,
0.23744842410087585,
-0.20822837948799133,
-0.08663608878850937,
-0.43968406319618225,
-0.44866663217544556,
-0.5860287547111511,
-0.3733576834201813,
0.3512446880340576,
0.6396287083625793,
0.3701016902923584,
0.8729134202003479,
0.18977341055870056,
0.3172634243965149,
0.23193950951099396,
0.2919940948486328,
-0.16111412644386292,
0.2838762402534485,
-0.27306097745895386,
0.0007661464624106884,
-0.32636764645576477,
-0.008063497953116894,
0.6648887395858765,
0.6578684449195862,
-0.12961775064468384,
0.37293174862861633,
0.11054126918315887,
0.4465674161911011,
-0.3123573362827301,
-0.20547866821289062,
-0.5374717712402344,
-0.3453928828239441,
0.07773932814598083,
-0.3978559970855713,
-0.4955926537513733,
-0.2564718425273895,
-0.07653703540563583,
-0.3416414260864258,
0.23630191385746002,
0.39250272512435913,
0.4436669945716858,
0.3933810591697693,
-0.32687467336654663,
-0.27900999784469604,
-0.7427303791046143,
0.7865750789642334,
-1.0714352130889893,
0.2589496076107025,
0.37600305676460266,
0.41581639647483826,
-0.2325523942708969,
-0.7951217889785767,
-0.5943114161491394,
-0.1954449862241745,
-0.4116010069847107,
-0.324867308139801,
0.1300625503063202,
0.2073548138141632,
0.43026068806648254,
0.4781706929206848,
-0.468769371509552,
-0.03237323835492134,
-0.33800679445266724,
-0.27062615752220154,
0.9096716642379761,
0.01418315526098013,
0.24189268052577972,
-0.3726378083229065,
-0.2777499854564667,
-0.0495307594537735,
-0.8934534192085266,
-0.06650512665510178,
0.1387598216533661,
0.2947731018066406,
0.2105780839920044,
0.5614011287689209,
-0.24122542142868042,
0.6973821520805359,
0.4190668761730194,
-0.1970294564962387,
-0.003622962161898613,
-0.38541051745414734,
-0.435314804315567,
0.31725141406059265,
0.6479052305221558,
-0.11597204953432083,
-0.1294681280851364,
0.10505653917789459,
-0.3105173408985138,
-0.13342225551605225,
0.074666827917099,
-0.8003948330879211,
-0.3107243776321411,
0.3218986988067627,
-0.3748009502887726,
-0.08626286685466766,
-0.3931489586830139,
-0.7030778527259827,
-0.04683254286646843,
-0.5039004683494568,
0.8455247282981873,
-0.1861700713634491,
-0.038135990500450134,
0.18809562921524048,
0.15496249496936798,
0.009399551898241043,
0.33887046575546265,
-0.9447423219680786,
0.14037197828292847,
0.3028146028518677,
0.6863518953323364,
0.007700291462242603,
-0.4541456699371338,
-0.7693701982498169,
0.28472158312797546,
-0.40270474553108215,
0.9628667235374451,
-0.10845310240983963,
-0.3978630006313324,
-0.12203774601221085,
-0.05640086531639099,
0.1562136560678482,
-0.4134233593940735,
0.6269281506538391,
-0.2644270360469818,
0.49819204211235046,
-0.3153628408908844,
-0.6886533498764038,
0.0768285021185875,
-0.030417807400226593,
-0.4062572717666626,
1.0324499607086182,
-0.031193282455205917,
-0.4270675778388977,
0.10651282966136932,
-0.8679563403129578,
-0.5147371292114258,
0.20027312636375427,
0.0009563102503307164,
-0.13443836569786072,
0.20754410326480865,
0.6627477407455444,
0.3543333411216736,
-0.17812924087047577,
0.2614339292049408,
-0.13530774414539337,
-0.1756436675786972,
-0.0008502849377691746,
-0.3712943494319916,
0.5911941528320312,
0.27739256620407104,
-0.4534638226032257,
0.4271864891052246,
-0.6186619997024536,
-0.01944444142282009,
0.07005070894956589,
-0.18216758966445923,
-0.2733944356441498,
-0.13269449770450592,
-0.6601239442825317,
0.43921899795532227,
0.10264581441879272,
-0.2619346082210541,
-0.004608886316418648,
-0.7637568712234497,
0.24357642233371735,
0.74442058801651,
0.14774805307388306,
0.6778948307037354,
-0.14960618317127228,
0.5824164748191833,
-0.07895705103874207,
0.08342860639095306,
-0.6664361357688904,
-0.34788769483566284,
-0.7224653363227844,
-0.27037402987480164,
0.0996098592877388,
0.02844403125345707,
-0.7314608097076416,
0.16875794529914856,
0.06854984164237976,
-0.3327449858188629,
-0.7282381057739258,
0.35476240515708923,
0.1846240907907486,
1.0102249383926392,
0.7008209824562073,
0.30097854137420654,
-0.6892405152320862,
-0.9828891754150391,
-0.6243457198143005,
-0.20623210072517395,
-0.029978156089782715,
0.25300997495651245,
0.3401012122631073,
-0.25649696588516235,
1.0428751707077026,
-0.11114411801099777,
-0.1750687211751938,
-0.3376888930797577,
0.6091840267181396,
0.0014591572107747197,
0.5871667265892029,
0.251071035861969,
-0.34515711665153503,
-0.42779242992401123,
-0.3085842728614807,
-0.5746821761131287,
-0.6013967990875244,
-0.1633012294769287,
-0.09757271409034729,
0.13511349260807037,
0.5821890234947205,
-0.4464535713195801,
0.3436245620250702,
0.49323272705078125,
-0.45010632276535034,
0.7425142526626587,
-0.3017388880252838,
0.2687896192073822,
-0.5139561295509338,
-0.10272747278213501,
-0.050215404480695724,
-0.3753848373889923,
-0.5188373923301697,
-0.15156127512454987,
0.0632854625582695,
-0.21535243093967438,
-0.3075096905231476,
0.871780514717102,
-0.6401258111000061,
-0.11178162693977356,
-0.5769671201705933,
0.4643986225128174,
0.11625733226537704,
0.3200550973415375,
-0.07459854334592819,
0.9902342557907104,
0.5169587135314941,
-0.7685925364494324,
0.14286726713180542,
0.07564866542816162,
0.04305324703454971,
0.22591540217399597,
-0.7605526447296143,
-0.021844210103154182,
-0.1795610785484314,
0.2682356834411621,
-1.2609938383102417,
-0.5518989562988281,
0.12661528587341309,
-0.22205160558223724,
0.011883096769452095,
-0.16154561936855316,
-0.31109389662742615,
-0.6405640244483948,
0.051027219742536545,
0.42167726159095764,
0.5782479643821716,
-1.2027214765548706,
0.6951161026954651,
0.31021296977996826,
-0.12873215973377228,
-0.13312768936157227,
-0.5551652312278748,
-0.05459309369325638,
-0.3638856112957001,
-0.680570125579834,
0.12398310005664825,
-0.4852425754070282,
-0.37098389863967896,
-0.32988297939300537,
-0.007785195019096136,
0.156808540225029,
-0.0032164589501917362,
0.08919449150562286,
0.08092399686574936,
-0.2823178768157959,
0.714674711227417,
0.31496334075927734,
-0.13003364205360413,
0.284186452627182,
-0.4595591425895691,
0.2814750373363495,
-0.307073712348938,
-0.39072728157043457,
-0.5137863755226135,
0.3219885528087616,
0.2621431350708008,
-0.15145859122276306,
0.5579665899276733,
0.36539125442504883,
-0.23976637423038483,
-0.44665613770484924,
-0.730533242225647,
-0.8481422662734985,
-0.5391297936439514,
-0.2941048741340637,
-0.46438783407211304,
-0.9741955399513245,
0.32091042399406433,
-0.28715065121650696,
-0.057084761559963226,
0.7451379895210266,
0.5831251740455627,
-0.052529700100421906,
1.5279003381729126,
0.1668313890695572,
0.35668686032295227,
0.21586637198925018,
0.09400279819965363,
0.28061750531196594,
-0.6482508182525635,
-0.02168893814086914,
-0.5099080801010132,
0.10313030332326889,
-0.09217476844787598,
-0.44101956486701965,
0.09099768847227097,
0.24602121114730835,
-0.05176765099167824,
0.2384006232023239,
-0.660219132900238,
0.49220648407936096,
0.45526668429374695,
-0.3326876759529114,
0.3389785885810852,
0.04926932603120804,
-0.24545057117938995,
-0.22759829461574554,
-0.8049948811531067,
-0.6357925534248352,
0.7611927390098572,
0.4338548183441162,
0.8161334991455078,
-0.0013892739079892635,
0.8074581623077393,
0.29395028948783875,
0.5810540914535522,
-0.5770860314369202,
0.49049174785614014,
0.38670381903648376,
-0.7129992246627808,
-0.6505323052406311,
-0.42569446563720703,
-0.6436915397644043,
0.3169320523738861,
-0.014665927737951279,
-0.5377230048179626,
0.2044098824262619,
0.7440257668495178,
-0.3963243067264557,
-0.20964747667312622,
-0.9096549153327942,
0.9467054009437561,
-0.31616678833961487,
-0.472625732421875,
-0.22912919521331787,
-0.3323349356651306,
0.5259125828742981,
0.0012808488681912422,
0.4899372160434723,
-0.13112974166870117,
0.05447471886873245,
0.5354758501052856,
-0.6272672414779663,
0.6428146958351135,
-0.22406907379627228,
-0.140587717294693,
0.49832043051719666,
0.22932592034339905,
0.8173139095306396,
0.24359175562858582,
-0.26862961053848267,
-0.07943733036518097,
-0.2778533101081848,
-0.3471216559410095,
-0.7773318886756897,
0.8850786089897156,
-0.36214184761047363,
-1.0108410120010376,
-0.06967594474554062,
-0.3087843358516693,
-0.12347825616598129,
0.13788560032844543,
0.2049238234758377,
0.5706000924110413,
0.19687137007713318,
0.11967532336711884,
0.5639632344245911,
-0.05922940373420715,
0.691505491733551,
0.5715138912200928,
-0.4508931040763855,
-0.4908895492553711,
0.6060882806777954,
0.09989221394062042,
0.3168385922908783,
-0.2103770226240158,
0.5970191955566406,
-0.7885317206382751,
-0.4823119342327118,
-0.6495276689529419,
0.4016074240207672,
-0.9417903423309326,
-0.1591472178697586,
-0.7971028685569763,
0.02032584510743618,
-0.7656862735748291,
-0.1878044456243515,
-0.34958189725875854,
-0.5399309992790222,
-0.3687435984611511,
-0.08028043061494827,
0.2784885764122009,
0.7196316123008728,
-0.5208712816238403,
0.5305286049842834,
-0.39210978150367737,
0.4042101800441742,
0.6777905225753784,
0.12104243785142899,
-0.024887481704354286,
-0.8592424392700195,
-0.4651678502559662,
0.1000458151102066,
-0.006622160319238901,
-1.0673048496246338,
0.6493051052093506,
0.31274545192718506,
0.7233641743659973,
0.15402555465698242,
0.2608366310596466,
1.097415566444397,
-0.4323332905769348,
0.8494041562080383,
0.08730883151292801,
-1.3955620527267456,
1.0713417530059814,
-0.28870266675949097,
0.3763106167316437,
0.4037708640098572,
0.3466631770133972,
-0.11802814155817032,
-0.4141116440296173,
-0.8287371397018433,
-0.8211309313774109,
0.6907385587692261,
0.2776065170764923,
-0.18395762145519257,
-0.26260313391685486,
0.5224517583847046,
-0.08524692803621292,
0.08128465712070465,
-0.9357663989067078,
-0.21042418479919434,
-0.5113198161125183,
-0.2275332808494568,
-0.12058740854263306,
-0.49437421560287476,
-0.2052004486322403,
-0.37470024824142456,
1.1185585260391235,
-0.6127116084098816,
0.024082865566015244,
0.6645448207855225,
-0.23908931016921997,
-0.4846402108669281,
0.12521657347679138,
0.5600613355636597,
0.6909827589988708,
0.16846054792404175,
0.39155077934265137,
0.5130941867828369,
0.2827063500881195,
0.2010183334350586,
0.08036961406469345,
-0.005950593855232,
0.11287006735801697,
0.30580395460128784,
0.5765023231506348,
0.17894788086414337,
-0.6419752240180969,
0.4736737012863159,
-0.30214181542396545,
0.03922662138938904,
-0.29365241527557373,
0.1634625792503357,
0.06482519209384918,
0.13870610296726227,
0.551507830619812,
-0.24658825993537903,
0.4277147650718689,
-0.2964327931404114,
0.39801692962646484,
0.3727547228336334,
-0.04319305345416069,
-0.18989896774291992,
0.6741534471511841,
0.1841258853673935,
-0.5171154737472534,
0.13325698673725128,
-0.3135834038257599,
-0.26021742820739746,
0.28840115666389465,
0.8710523843765259,
0.7284546494483948,
-0.7155534625053406,
0.22516484558582306,
0.8300228118896484,
0.2044043242931366,
-0.26854193210601807,
0.0372898131608963,
-0.4009394943714142,
-0.3492169976234436,
-0.7893665432929993,
-0.6806824207305908,
-0.16142310202121735,
0.12201950699090958,
-0.3969421684741974,
0.23543605208396912,
-0.3313586711883545,
0.07962042093276978,
0.05886780470609665,
-0.09115592390298843,
-0.27486637234687805,
0.44827860593795776,
-0.05560285970568657,
0.7292419672012329,
-0.8220041394233704,
0.8470607995986938,
0.49075210094451904,
-0.30061593651771545,
-1.0789717435836792,
-0.0008282461785711348,
-0.18471617996692657,
-0.5214083194732666,
0.8173589110374451,
0.18034130334854126,
-0.2758365273475647,
0.31620773673057556,
-0.6743983626365662,
-1.0225027799606323,
0.9001513123512268,
0.3454301655292511,
-0.55729740858078,
0.3122160732746124,
-0.10744829475879669,
0.616884708404541,
-0.8371827602386475,
0.29311516880989075,
0.49239176511764526,
0.5228287577629089,
0.15903986990451813,
-0.520065426826477,
0.1405528336763382,
0.03332686424255371,
-0.00952827651053667,
-0.10478419810533524,
-0.08248525112867355,
0.5887606143951416,
-0.23698924481868744,
-0.3392777144908905,
-0.01230439729988575,
0.9773963689804077,
0.46467071771621704,
0.269212543964386,
0.6255188584327698,
0.25016865134239197,
0.6594254374504089,
0.021668901666998863,
0.941670835018158,
-0.5232574343681335,
0.4498006999492645,
1.4607731103897095,
0.030857199802994728,
0.6600738763809204,
0.6012395620346069,
0.29423797130584717,
0.6862552165985107,
0.6786555647850037,
0.27427902817726135,
0.32388758659362793,
-0.018979836255311966,
-0.43336647748947144,
-0.7027694582939148,
-0.011189845390617847,
-0.23225842416286469,
0.22058667242527008,
0.43373364210128784,
-0.5939593315124512,
-0.243418887257576,
0.3318992555141449,
-0.2747959792613983,
0.10034088045358658,
-0.29590871930122375,
0.7770459055900574,
0.09960200637578964,
-1.1246263980865479,
0.5185540318489075,
-0.10490383207798004,
0.08891257643699646,
-0.42972081899642944,
0.01812281645834446,
-0.21690621972084045,
0.07267216593027115,
-0.15374161303043365,
-0.4865541458129883,
0.4971606135368347,
-0.3277643918991089,
-0.11175242811441422,
-0.48670661449432373,
1.0807323455810547,
-0.6476055979728699,
-0.3391043245792389,
0.43656158447265625,
0.4067372977733612,
0.28379184007644653,
-0.055244337767362595,
-0.7363601326942444,
-0.11763796210289001,
-0.017143575474619865,
-0.3587004840373993,
-0.0168687142431736,
0.5124446749687195,
0.13510896265506744,
0.7837445139884949,
0.8739917278289795,
0.05982498452067375,
0.11971651017665863,
0.19892242550849915,
0.8195914626121521,
-0.5362298488616943,
-0.5549073219299316,
-1.016777753829956,
0.657669723033905,
-0.11502039432525635,
-0.12110528349876404,
1.2395848035812378,
0.28132104873657227,
0.49000775814056396,
-0.14960798621177673,
0.5735852122306824,
0.23849786818027496,
0.8012754321098328,
-0.38673728704452515,
0.30716922879219055,
-0.7553660273551941,
0.5612143278121948,
-0.018989307805895805,
-0.5549853444099426,
-0.17125535011291504,
0.7350031137466431,
-0.5791732668876648,
0.04486461356282234,
0.6204693913459778,
0.918655514717102,
0.06717148423194885,
0.01560808252543211,
0.5292648673057556,
0.4340895116329193,
0.271345853805542,
-0.2918816804885864,
0.8668422698974609,
-0.24739126861095428,
0.4549785256385803,
-0.47981807589530945,
-0.1400570124387741,
-0.3281351625919342,
-0.9662808179855347,
-1.1436865329742432,
-0.48623496294021606,
-0.4722771644592285,
-0.4321359694004059,
-0.09763925522565842,
0.9553461074829102,
1.038985013961792,
-0.7169806361198425,
-0.20398284494876862,
-0.40873628854751587,
0.24344587326049805,
-0.09940584748983383,
-0.3007358908653259,
0.23122155666351318,
-0.9045252799987793,
-0.48307207226753235,
0.849626362323761,
0.47412246465682983,
0.17917625606060028,
-0.7062376737594604,
-0.4022608995437622,
-0.12256040424108505,
0.44303038716316223,
0.7018603086471558,
0.39522650837898254,
-0.9676322937011719,
-0.3016333281993866,
-0.18082551658153534,
-0.08978984504938126,
0.12194334715604782,
0.8948096632957458,
-1.1021533012390137,
0.5573005080223083,
0.4523680508136749,
0.25181493163108826,
0.3684965670108795,
0.34445685148239136,
0.6700133681297302,
-0.7625955939292908,
-0.09195683151483536,
0.20965160429477692,
0.46644943952560425,
0.48030123114585876,
-0.5223901271820068,
0.3531631529331207,
0.11102765053510666,
-0.8858709931373596,
-0.8389378190040588,
0.23041954636573792,
-0.4309747517108917,
-0.33428266644477844,
1.1414726972579956,
-0.1702916920185089,
-0.31975218653678894,
-0.2583814263343811,
-0.31291475892066956,
0.12970905005931854,
-0.2783832252025604,
0.8093428611755371,
0.37019801139831543,
-0.302146315574646,
-0.5452611446380615,
-0.20271943509578705,
0.9506858587265015,
0.43404823541641235,
-0.984815239906311,
0.20082411170005798,
0.6279895901679993,
0.11620382219552994,
0.2050757110118866,
0.6079800128936768,
0.036690376698970795,
0.29061299562454224,
-0.10319165140390396,
0.03832678869366646,
0.0524863563477993,
-0.47888925671577454,
-0.5726170539855957,
0.18884187936782837,
0.17160621285438538,
0.2684837281703949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12036v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12036v2 | Language Model Adaptation to Specialized Domains through Selective Masking based on Genre and Topical Characteristics | 2024-02-19T10:43:27 | 2024-02-26T16:47:36 | Anas Belfathi, Ygor Gallina, Nicolas Hernandez, Richard Dufour, Laura Monceaux | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in pre-trained language modeling have facilitated significant
progress across various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. Word masking
during model training constitutes a pivotal component of language modeling in
architectures like BERT. However, the prevalent method of word masking relies
on random selection, potentially disregarding domain-specific linguistic
attributes. In this article, we introduce an innovative masking approach
leveraging genre and topicality information to tailor language models to
specialized domains. Our method incorporates a ranking process that prioritizes
words based on their significance, subsequently guiding the masking procedure.
Experiments conducted using continual pre-training within the legal domain have
underscored the efficacy of our approach on the LegalGLUE benchmark in the
English language. Pre-trained language models and code are freely available for
use. | [
-0.4432433545589447,
-0.6960790157318115,
0.38406771421432495,
0.32378777861595154,
-0.5645084977149963,
0.328017920255661,
-0.2458646297454834,
-0.45775654911994934,
0.4033370316028595,
0.9787646532058716,
-0.3574991226196289,
-0.7439074516296387,
-0.8772452473640442,
-0.31987759470939636,
-0.27655789256095886,
1.095655083656311,
0.2765941917896271,
-0.07815293222665787,
-0.2077254354953766,
-0.2917770445346832,
-0.6084723472595215,
-0.9067659974098206,
-0.604325532913208,
-0.26243075728416443,
0.2299644649028778,
-0.18481358885765076,
0.4932834208011627,
0.43953657150268555,
0.5558112859725952,
0.2583017349243164,
0.1458907425403595,
-0.12825751304626465,
-0.4278452694416046,
0.14513789117336273,
-0.416561484336853,
-0.5341605544090271,
-0.4185589551925659,
0.17099769413471222,
0.5322736501693726,
0.6415706872940063,
-0.27277514338493347,
0.004919430706650019,
-0.29800641536712646,
0.44200366735458374,
-0.6026387810707092,
-0.26377958059310913,
-1.2244752645492554,
0.09059450775384903,
-0.5294200778007507,
-0.2890988290309906,
-0.38981640338897705,
-0.10590445250272751,
0.21367821097373962,
-0.5584221482276917,
0.4875984191894531,
0.1730988770723343,
0.9693247079849243,
0.12121134996414185,
-0.017756791785359383,
-0.11540215462446213,
-0.7563941478729248,
0.6382726430892944,
-0.6986116766929626,
0.35946670174598694,
0.5270400047302246,
0.3217827081680298,
0.12069129198789597,
-0.9566448330879211,
-0.2823653221130371,
-0.3723267614841461,
0.04948240891098976,
0.03188799321651459,
-0.1626468300819397,
0.13869096338748932,
-0.01794629916548729,
0.09619662165641785,
-0.5107242465019226,
0.130263552069664,
-0.2530193328857422,
-0.2804548740386963,
0.570955753326416,
-0.3019336760044098,
0.42875444889068604,
0.24231138825416565,
-0.39898574352264404,
0.09774935990571976,
-0.7092452645301819,
0.060565125197172165,
0.33601367473602295,
0.30782637000083923,
0.4440442621707916,
0.2217683494091034,
-0.11311115324497223,
0.6969832181930542,
0.029016297310590744,
-0.13507291674613953,
0.1213471069931984,
0.1621205359697342,
-0.34664738178253174,
0.011737908236682415,
0.2645566463470459,
0.009180576540529728,
0.2274319976568222,
-0.38416820764541626,
-0.5413780808448792,
-0.07545125484466553,
0.7761827111244202,
-0.5868325233459473,
-0.25857776403427124,
0.11029200255870819,
-0.2613731026649475,
-0.24483709037303925,
0.01303823385387659,
-0.3808085024356842,
-0.32011452317237854,
-0.3255631625652313,
0.6214441657066345,
-0.21612471342086792,
-0.1443592756986618,
0.40447506308555603,
-0.0328449010848999,
-0.15151430666446686,
0.2673598527908325,
-0.889365553855896,
0.5726847648620605,
0.7579215168952942,
0.5224634408950806,
-0.46839383244514465,
-0.04339132085442543,
-0.45172321796417236,
0.24942725896835327,
-0.29778727889060974,
0.8730345368385315,
-1.053931474685669,
-0.12466142326593399,
0.11941290646791458,
-0.02839653193950653,
-0.21310004591941833,
-0.7374053001403809,
0.4181058704853058,
-1.0740362405776978,
-0.0671592652797699,
0.2014024257659912,
-0.38884052634239197,
-0.35613521933555603,
0.06053725257515907,
-0.5028941631317139,
0.9000245928764343,
0.23868334293365479,
-0.5287074446678162,
0.7057161927223206,
-0.4966205954551697,
-0.42208167910575867,
0.4441385269165039,
0.06701803207397461,
-0.5205857157707214,
0.12033822387456894,
0.21325933933258057,
0.3727315068244934,
0.09183920174837112,
0.5702998042106628,
-0.1591891497373581,
-0.22152745723724365,
0.18286840617656708,
0.09723863750696182,
0.673816442489624,
0.27124476432800293,
-0.3210310935974121,
0.4363718032836914,
-0.6637358665466309,
-0.04947875067591667,
-0.059244684875011444,
-0.04937246814370155,
-0.6021364331245422,
0.04807686433196068,
0.1491529643535614,
0.26603350043296814,
0.05652473866939545,
-0.29090264439582825,
-0.06974464654922485,
-0.43867817521095276,
0.27942898869514465,
0.6367467045783997,
0.07685970515012741,
0.5501851439476013,
-0.3485845625400543,
0.9119722247123718,
0.08948677033185959,
-0.09411989897489548,
0.30608949065208435,
-0.650189220905304,
-0.7677603960037231,
-0.5903688669204712,
0.8043447732925415,
0.7084716558456421,
-0.6113085746765137,
0.5013332962989807,
-0.30395424365997314,
-0.4731670618057251,
-0.6796364784240723,
0.04199860990047455,
0.25058022141456604,
0.047203078866004944,
0.23925144970417023,
-0.9231154918670654,
-0.5032161474227905,
-0.9250169396400452,
-0.416598916053772,
0.11307795345783234,
-0.27180129289627075,
0.28679266571998596,
0.31043541431427,
-0.22117936611175537,
1.0905979871749878,
-0.5418886542320251,
-0.6023091673851013,
-0.34595125913619995,
0.39247024059295654,
0.06105770170688629,
0.42687833309173584,
0.9639685153961182,
-0.7933179140090942,
-0.5069025158882141,
-0.13027308881282806,
-0.12297877669334412,
-0.4227532744407654,
-0.1591164916753769,
-0.26268354058265686,
-0.024239588528871536,
0.5897846221923828,
-0.2812979519367218,
0.25792181491851807,
0.2826472818851471,
-0.07159028947353363,
0.510879397392273,
-0.20034192502498627,
0.02799890749156475,
-0.6642746925354004,
0.032063618302345276,
-0.029907558113336563,
-0.7184105515480042,
-0.8785439729690552,
0.47591397166252136,
-0.37549227476119995,
-0.17474660277366638,
-0.46926388144493103,
0.6163960695266724,
-0.4638240337371826,
0.022628754377365112,
-0.3988601267337799,
0.06850515305995941,
-0.029320180416107178,
0.4778830409049988,
0.5309504866600037,
0.6204319596290588,
0.7520917654037476,
-0.6173185110092163,
-0.08477079123258591,
-0.04991724714636803,
-0.5533034205436707,
0.22650499641895294,
-0.4483262002468109,
0.34446990489959717,
-0.12503179907798767,
0.049378350377082825,
-0.633500337600708,
0.07917077094316483,
0.2102309614419937,
-0.10492264479398727,
0.549289345741272,
-0.3519684374332428,
-0.2631421983242035,
-0.234203040599823,
-0.1314319223165512,
0.4322296679019928,
0.6314639449119568,
-0.03759458661079407,
0.4538869857788086,
0.8770748376846313,
-0.5063591003417969,
-0.4709850549697876,
-0.3720725476741791,
0.23681595921516418,
-0.4319474399089813,
-0.36515727639198303,
0.7928658723831177,
-0.0938708707690239,
-0.059521161019802094,
-0.08148469030857086,
-0.012301298789680004,
-0.6150732636451721,
0.33154532313346863,
0.028795583173632622,
-0.07069461792707443,
-0.38287296891212463,
0.025449085980653763,
0.024043399840593338,
0.07977425307035446,
0.023700373247265816,
-0.40111756324768066,
0.5441939830780029,
0.15808835625648499,
-0.1412949115037918,
0.2081281691789627,
0.42241278290748596,
0.24418282508850098,
-0.5773038864135742,
0.6701753735542297,
0.5245128870010376,
-0.485307514667511,
-0.7225613594055176,
-0.6565864086151123,
-0.1199592724442482,
-0.5055868029594421,
0.509861171245575,
-0.4250059723854065,
-1.0813945531845093,
0.5364223718643188,
-0.009377297013998032,
-0.07884460687637329,
0.3311014175415039,
0.571454644203186,
0.1985483020544052,
0.6468778848648071,
1.140689492225647,
-0.07291753590106964,
0.6346179246902466,
0.31029197573661804,
0.5903818607330322,
-0.4364400804042816,
0.06870760023593903,
-0.4512631595134735,
-0.05984066426753998,
-0.4774603247642517,
-0.655151903629303,
0.2434355467557907,
0.16001710295677185,
0.16951964795589447,
0.48089560866355896,
-0.686658501625061,
0.5564489960670471,
0.6193942427635193,
0.12151122093200684,
0.07383628189563751,
0.3568236231803894,
-0.015243113972246647,
-0.22725550830364227,
-0.6215880513191223,
-0.5578280091285706,
1.0156573057174683,
0.3689865469932556,
0.39683425426483154,
-0.024615855887532234,
0.7199627161026001,
0.522091269493103,
0.67447429895401,
-0.5456154346466064,
0.5715361833572388,
-0.45839983224868774,
-0.8814630508422852,
-0.38314270973205566,
0.06585026532411575,
-0.9547539353370667,
0.4317834973335266,
-0.3650802969932556,
-0.9182764887809753,
0.1849275827407837,
-0.16327491402626038,
-0.5024994611740112,
0.18195906281471252,
-0.3197411596775055,
0.6136215925216675,
0.1946837157011032,
-0.059927575290203094,
-0.30213209986686707,
-0.6065608263015747,
0.34091559052467346,
-0.6095983982086182,
0.4002588391304016,
-0.31325259804725647,
0.14796039462089539,
0.9039639234542847,
-0.03896008059382439,
0.8593263030052185,
-0.15402598679065704,
0.06648934632539749,
0.31274378299713135,
0.15972104668617249,
0.06972727924585342,
0.03936522826552391,
-0.016028687357902527,
0.17800574004650116,
-0.01082072127610445,
-0.36925601959228516,
-0.3888208270072937,
0.4392869472503662,
-0.543764054775238,
-1.0873432159423828,
-0.38348662853240967,
-0.5107072591781616,
-0.3292538821697235,
0.3638407289981842,
0.11039154976606369,
0.1804661750793457,
-0.3253892958164215,
0.02821209467947483,
0.8868056535720825,
-0.26428118348121643,
0.24725115299224854,
0.7267326712608337,
-0.28168386220932007,
-0.16999511420726776,
1.0058211088180542,
0.22986803948879242,
0.09988005459308624,
0.5174834132194519,
0.050059664994478226,
-0.09406786412000656,
-1.0146489143371582,
-0.09644874930381775,
0.21723268926143646,
-0.8471384644508362,
-0.06580118089914322,
-0.9235305786132812,
-0.5898728370666504,
-0.5626784563064575,
-0.29447662830352783,
-0.06605435162782669,
-0.4233313500881195,
-0.10145356506109238,
-0.011167858727276325,
0.03917935490608215,
0.7072814702987671,
0.27619031071662903,
0.20672845840454102,
-0.7189167141914368,
0.4479573667049408,
0.5164206624031067,
0.4533117115497589,
-0.3692325949668884,
-0.8357467651367188,
-0.14734716713428497,
-0.2149355411529541,
-0.21499356627464294,
-0.591198742389679,
0.43956923484802246,
0.5495302677154541,
0.8313102126121521,
0.22352385520935059,
0.09644593298435211,
0.3087192177772522,
-0.9587752223014832,
0.8448383212089539,
-0.0961797907948494,
-1.0225416421890259,
0.690495491027832,
-0.3760858476161957,
-0.003323107725009322,
0.5996220707893372,
0.3321719765663147,
-0.41148364543914795,
-0.8989420533180237,
-0.5953200459480286,
-1.002747654914856,
0.5459769368171692,
0.12450236082077026,
0.48131871223449707,
0.08389068394899368,
0.2774066627025604,
0.32094743847846985,
0.45504507422447205,
-1.145174503326416,
0.03824011608958244,
-0.13534535467624664,
0.059586551040410995,
0.06370490044355392,
-0.3932347595691681,
-0.36149862408638,
-0.1914038509130478,
0.6434632539749146,
0.10058265924453735,
0.2775944173336029,
-0.04457587003707886,
-0.5756329894065857,
0.2284761667251587,
0.26429036259651184,
0.9638969898223877,
0.8847187161445618,
-0.28795796632766724,
-0.005135487765073776,
-0.14899349212646484,
-0.7110628485679626,
0.09085646271705627,
-0.020699268206954002,
-0.08693023771047592,
0.3513942360877991,
0.43569719791412354,
0.7478739619255066,
0.16642005741596222,
-0.4768674075603485,
0.6528261303901672,
0.2922344505786896,
-0.1670946478843689,
-0.01924961246550083,
0.23075547814369202,
-0.05923276022076607,
-0.10312846302986145,
0.3119250237941742,
0.19651035964488983,
0.2528049051761627,
-0.4745437502861023,
0.4830605089664459,
0.35057929158210754,
-0.28482016921043396,
-0.2651648223400116,
0.751842737197876,
0.19588884711265564,
-0.37370434403419495,
0.11981348693370819,
-0.1653863936662674,
-0.6489437818527222,
0.679853618144989,
0.6396862268447876,
1.0956546068191528,
-0.40302228927612305,
0.31473544239997864,
0.13063058257102966,
0.3423948585987091,
0.04820971563458443,
-0.044164158403873444,
0.1337701976299286,
-0.7946243286132812,
-0.28643426299095154,
-0.9051458835601807,
-0.1981644183397293,
0.16048890352249146,
-0.6000774502754211,
0.19164271652698517,
-0.7153186798095703,
-0.30525830388069153,
0.13748429715633392,
-0.32883647084236145,
-0.6728139519691467,
0.5403710007667542,
0.37471380829811096,
0.8894739151000977,
-1.0208182334899902,
1.1924047470092773,
0.7533566951751709,
-0.13187436759471893,
-0.2564474940299988,
0.19140298664569855,
-0.39989736676216125,
-0.8736948370933533,
0.9111526012420654,
0.11439186334609985,
-0.14891228079795837,
0.024696076288819313,
-0.4083578884601593,
-0.8257788419723511,
0.5647220611572266,
0.28035983443260193,
-0.37214162945747375,
0.1983378380537033,
0.2780579626560211,
0.7294698357582092,
-0.7944192886352539,
-0.056956373155117035,
0.5566295385360718,
0.17006532847881317,
-0.13087667524814606,
-0.749165415763855,
0.04599187523126602,
-0.2697252631187439,
0.27915534377098083,
-0.021922387182712555,
-0.22324635088443756,
0.5122406482696533,
0.21258848905563354,
-0.19395482540130615,
-0.22639165818691254,
0.5356353521347046,
0.244139164686203,
0.16959470510482788,
0.6234843730926514,
0.48120516538619995,
0.6899927854537964,
-0.06094012036919594,
0.7285960912704468,
-0.32322269678115845,
0.16185933351516724,
0.9888544678688049,
-0.48824799060821533,
0.845592200756073,
0.23645727336406708,
-0.3407140076160431,
0.6542956829071045,
0.7040536999702454,
-0.014931697398424149,
1.0233279466629028,
0.5973937511444092,
-0.3223397433757782,
-0.3800102770328522,
-0.20591284334659576,
-0.36687609553337097,
0.41010576486587524,
0.4085704982280731,
-0.15551576018333435,
0.03412863612174988,
0.20522113144397736,
-0.177283376455307,
0.253644734621048,
-0.3288091719150543,
0.7528743147850037,
0.1594618409872055,
-0.666390597820282,
0.3925720453262329,
0.3307516574859619,
0.7245628833770752,
-0.8242161870002747,
0.06725523620843887,
-0.1551954746246338,
-0.270435631275177,
0.027663694694638252,
-0.3899939954280853,
0.3482937216758728,
-0.1766745150089264,
-0.33422598242759705,
-0.5419796109199524,
0.8745690584182739,
-0.574277937412262,
-0.5282729268074036,
0.2657053768634796,
0.22948212921619415,
0.1578291952610016,
-0.18826600909233093,
-0.6439611315727234,
-0.1730777621269226,
-0.3622712194919586,
-0.16342943906784058,
0.629294216632843,
0.4223755896091461,
-0.44856777787208557,
0.6190751194953918,
0.583037257194519,
0.22287623584270477,
0.24538210034370422,
0.4663204252719879,
0.8560081124305725,
-0.4824240207672119,
-0.9810915589332581,
-0.41064226627349854,
0.5028689503669739,
-0.07197356224060059,
-0.16365866363048553,
0.35798728466033936,
0.25500181317329407,
0.7664811015129089,
-0.4187438488006592,
0.5675384402275085,
0.1257277876138687,
0.3812326490879059,
-0.754455029964447,
1.070833683013916,
-0.3938593864440918,
0.43571117520332336,
-0.283370703458786,
-1.1348117589950562,
-0.5778301358222961,
0.5555833578109741,
-0.2860557436943054,
0.13718028366565704,
0.7286202311515808,
0.8141124844551086,
-0.19239190220832825,
-0.46157190203666687,
0.7367714047431946,
-0.036918312311172485,
0.22064557671546936,
0.1998690962791443,
0.35726404190063477,
-0.015101240016520023,
-0.00029089945019222796,
-0.10679567605257034,
-0.253544420003891,
-0.2769092321395874,
-1.0007154941558838,
-1.0750869512557983,
-0.6189821362495422,
-0.5538425445556641,
-0.0506482757627964,
0.16391479969024658,
0.6051439046859741,
1.1305394172668457,
-1.1974726915359497,
-0.020413996651768684,
0.1562930941581726,
-0.003863070858642459,
-0.292474627494812,
-0.2264401912689209,
0.23435553908348083,
-0.5878717303276062,
-0.4793088138103485,
0.3779471814632416,
0.3489835858345032,
-0.1221710592508316,
-0.06505873799324036,
0.3501408100128174,
-0.1958225518465042,
0.46025362610816956,
0.5880579948425293,
-0.036714714020490646,
-0.9836760759353638,
-0.4655386209487915,
-0.2957775592803955,
-0.13417910039424896,
0.14333757758140564,
1.250601887702942,
-0.5644522905349731,
0.5360145568847656,
0.17862339317798615,
0.7623737454414368,
0.30113327503204346,
-0.14479632675647736,
0.7590367197990417,
-1.088335394859314,
0.4539601504802704,
0.5839661955833435,
0.17213338613510132,
0.20023183524608612,
-0.5045557022094727,
0.47731831669807434,
0.33941134810447693,
-0.34293943643569946,
-0.8859139680862427,
0.17734479904174805,
-0.8091605305671692,
-0.6192923784255981,
0.9145689606666565,
-0.40419790148735046,
-0.018049847334623337,
-0.39495038986206055,
-0.06980644911527634,
-0.06422697752714157,
-0.04085639491677284,
0.9407414793968201,
0.9944872260093689,
0.3750319182872772,
-0.1686895489692688,
-0.7426760196685791,
0.720222532749176,
0.5528110861778259,
-0.6463796496391296,
-0.28157830238342285,
-0.0340629518032074,
0.5365941524505615,
0.0762045606970787,
0.9040442705154419,
-0.007907300256192684,
0.18627439439296722,
-0.22190314531326294,
0.13893207907676697,
0.22993414103984833,
-0.4782475233078003,
-0.3923131823539734,
0.32167884707450867,
0.2745407223701477,
-0.0615399032831192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12030v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12030v2 | Towards Cross-Tokenizer Distillation: the Universal Logit Distillation Loss for LLMs | 2024-02-19T10:37:29 | 2024-02-20T14:46:03 | Nicolas Boizard, Kevin El Haddad, Céline Hudelot, Pierre Colombo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deploying large language models (LLMs) of several billion parameters can be
impractical in most industrial use cases due to constraints such as cost,
latency limitations, and hardware accessibility. Knowledge distillation (KD)
offers a solution by compressing knowledge from resource-intensive large models
to smaller ones. Various strategies exist, some relying on the text generated
by the teacher model and optionally utilizing his logits to enhance learning.
However, these methods based on logits often require both teacher and student
models to share the same tokenizer, limiting their applicability across
different LLM families. In this paper, we introduce Universal Logit
Distillation (ULD) loss, grounded in optimal transport, to address this
limitation. Our experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of ULD loss
in enabling distillation across models with different architectures and
tokenizers, paving the way to a more widespread use of distillation techniques. | [
-0.0544387586414814,
-0.3411961793899536,
0.8998410701751709,
0.05944822356104851,
-0.5448194742202759,
0.1969662755727768,
-0.10718713700771332,
-0.14234879612922668,
-0.13439054787158966,
0.28304895758628845,
-0.08354395627975464,
-0.28714877367019653,
-0.5878526568412781,
-0.16430270671844482,
-0.5582830309867859,
1.0037782192230225,
-0.3009299039840698,
0.25465497374534607,
-0.4701094627380371,
-0.19466382265090942,
-0.6485726237297058,
-0.9737868905067444,
-0.6941399574279785,
-0.6680075526237488,
0.5328083038330078,
0.20469006896018982,
0.3695966899394989,
0.35008183121681213,
0.22008126974105835,
0.16511164605617523,
-0.4041588306427002,
-0.1561574935913086,
-0.4500744044780731,
0.017663339152932167,
-0.3598339557647705,
-0.9621908664703369,
-0.027880892157554626,
-0.17132948338985443,
0.5602227449417114,
0.8844298124313354,
-0.27919402718544006,
0.11277267336845398,
0.34553423523902893,
0.7021567821502686,
-0.7139863967895508,
-0.1722448766231537,
-0.7751187086105347,
0.3300873339176178,
-0.043661706149578094,
-0.13942191004753113,
-0.44911104440689087,
-0.12498265504837036,
0.008771798573434353,
-0.31632715463638306,
0.12724518775939941,
0.22024677693843842,
0.6492157578468323,
0.30085834860801697,
-0.8382353782653809,
-0.22168999910354614,
-1.0356204509735107,
0.709780216217041,
-0.7233021855354309,
0.5810467600822449,
-0.04444633051753044,
0.39558473229408264,
-0.07417720556259155,
-0.7247716188430786,
-0.4115416407585144,
0.16390296816825867,
-0.23339974880218506,
-0.07128151506185532,
-0.33959218859672546,
0.23519670963287354,
-0.2144092321395874,
0.19474686682224274,
-0.251050740480423,
0.253936767578125,
-0.37666112184524536,
-0.1613011658191681,
0.24791763722896576,
0.3161652386188507,
0.03301478177309036,
0.09349564462900162,
-0.5572997331619263,
-0.010896255262196064,
-0.8819582462310791,
-0.07454334199428558,
0.2881407141685486,
0.09329544752836227,
0.2791779339313507,
0.3253641724586487,
0.008259231224656105,
0.5254817008972168,
-0.05285080149769783,
-0.24463948607444763,
-0.26290184259414673,
-0.48586568236351013,
-0.35706761479377747,
0.3248288035392761,
0.72016441822052,
0.3751106262207031,
0.003477168269455433,
-0.22632041573524475,
-0.29024747014045715,
-0.29579514265060425,
-0.2025829553604126,
-1.0097352266311646,
-0.3057190179824829,
-0.0731964036822319,
-0.4072169065475464,
-0.36973556876182556,
-0.14284691214561462,
-0.4668329060077667,
-0.35724326968193054,
-0.2503100633621216,
0.5678094029426575,
-0.023623069748282433,
-0.2580220103263855,
0.12920932471752167,
-0.497043639421463,
-0.02403273433446884,
0.00005407940625445917,
-1.1813795566558838,
0.3229631781578064,
0.45009928941726685,
1.1139174699783325,
-0.30512988567352295,
-0.014806875959038734,
-0.18458010256290436,
0.5443498492240906,
-0.19137650728225708,
0.5330970883369446,
-0.3328120708465576,
-0.7301964163780212,
-0.41068944334983826,
-0.21338438987731934,
-0.034233514219522476,
-0.7785338759422302,
0.5402166247367859,
-0.3879458010196686,
-0.05065850540995598,
-0.23137697577476501,
-0.7765948176383972,
-0.29260075092315674,
-0.1446933001279831,
-0.5107220411300659,
0.8787903785705566,
0.049153443425893784,
-0.7026484608650208,
0.5438714027404785,
-0.5093467831611633,
-0.4404170513153076,
-0.11789561808109283,
-0.2744695842266083,
-0.3131202459335327,
0.6252706050872803,
0.09481615573167801,
0.7661646604537964,
-0.4215681552886963,
0.6294650435447693,
-0.21520859003067017,
-0.14889438450336456,
-0.08375368267297745,
-0.8823645114898682,
0.9002164602279663,
0.26666197180747986,
-0.2977580726146698,
-0.11545826494693756,
-0.726912796497345,
-0.34715738892555237,
0.0009204795933328569,
-0.6388823986053467,
-0.954216480255127,
-0.1736065298318863,
0.37397366762161255,
-0.058423977345228195,
0.1244763731956482,
-0.640354573726654,
0.33560997247695923,
0.10387194156646729,
0.6090835928916931,
1.1191030740737915,
-0.1558089554309845,
0.5196271538734436,
-0.21426130831241608,
0.4839445948600769,
0.24746525287628174,
0.3005744218826294,
0.11985955387353897,
-0.3236185908317566,
-0.7980185747146606,
-0.21416808664798737,
0.3393097519874573,
0.3280216455459595,
-0.4197115898132324,
0.19345028698444366,
-0.3276682496070862,
-0.485734224319458,
-0.3872138559818268,
0.2474384605884552,
0.09193217009305954,
0.5251372456550598,
0.05912451073527336,
0.033352650701999664,
-0.7518764734268188,
-0.7510588765144348,
-0.14970816671848297,
-0.3832094073295593,
-0.003801463870331645,
0.05624651908874512,
0.3265087604522705,
-0.1766810268163681,
0.9825894236564636,
-0.4536156952381134,
-0.4942646622657776,
-0.48087847232818604,
-0.165866419672966,
0.21329031884670258,
0.44300150871276855,
0.5915715098381042,
-0.7439618110656738,
-0.7431696057319641,
0.37618759274482727,
-0.614937961101532,
-0.13091686367988586,
-0.2416670322418213,
-0.15455390512943268,
0.259657621383667,
0.6327410340309143,
-0.6641176342964172,
0.48734357953071594,
0.8128306269645691,
-0.44750311970710754,
0.46553748846054077,
-0.2554042339324951,
0.026945464313030243,
-1.2506464719772339,
0.12455830723047256,
-0.4065404236316681,
-0.33145853877067566,
-0.5044899582862854,
-0.1193157210946083,
-0.19412726163864136,
-0.07986199855804443,
-0.4920179545879364,
0.6497591137886047,
-0.29818153381347656,
0.024209337309002876,
-0.16854827105998993,
0.008208392187952995,
0.4194822907447815,
0.20301014184951782,
-0.0712021216750145,
0.7165216207504272,
0.45875516533851624,
-0.5098654627799988,
0.6413365006446838,
-0.010686449706554413,
-0.2363058179616928,
0.6944020986557007,
-0.7654355764389038,
-0.1525869071483612,
-0.048912547528743744,
0.4256194233894348,
-1.1924586296081543,
0.296599805355072,
0.010801471769809723,
-0.12807610630989075,
0.2775692939758301,
-0.17045378684997559,
-0.47689953446388245,
-0.20312675833702087,
-0.07474926859140396,
0.4144849181175232,
0.8277310729026794,
-0.8310938477516174,
0.9919514060020447,
0.08641993254423141,
0.13110114634037018,
-0.43157389760017395,
-0.9201900362968445,
0.3010939061641693,
-0.702769935131073,
-0.6259931325912476,
0.16612297296524048,
-0.2403092235326767,
-0.08599599450826645,
0.22499315440654755,
-0.5505366921424866,
-0.10811308026313782,
0.17271104454994202,
0.2824888527393341,
0.3387274444103241,
-0.11677437275648117,
0.35132649540901184,
0.31277987360954285,
-0.060188744217157364,
0.0613522082567215,
-0.7278755307197571,
0.5777087807655334,
0.2646794319152832,
-0.4539419114589691,
-0.7209396958351135,
0.3056894838809967,
0.6294383406639099,
0.24989354610443115,
0.9427617788314819,
0.5219041109085083,
-0.021205324679613113,
-0.187498539686203,
-0.7151103019714355,
-0.07307037711143494,
-0.5245711803436279,
0.44720226526260376,
-0.6569297313690186,
-0.864401638507843,
0.5566604733467102,
-0.4162222445011139,
0.08304804563522339,
0.21495716273784637,
0.35100311040878296,
-0.06360436975955963,
0.8597328662872314,
0.9539077281951904,
-0.5513936877250671,
0.24940846860408783,
-0.26267796754837036,
0.5056065320968628,
-0.6786295771598816,
-0.41593804955482483,
-0.6664790511131287,
-0.4178868532180786,
-0.10445348173379898,
-0.2420676201581955,
0.4028152823448181,
0.34515345096588135,
0.04543137922883034,
0.21204933524131775,
-0.4558562636375427,
0.7944005131721497,
0.798071026802063,
-0.20634928345680237,
0.8637392520904541,
0.18107952177524567,
-0.588729739189148,
0.20708715915679932,
-1.2712959051132202,
-0.48711884021759033,
1.269023060798645,
0.3275865614414215,
1.0019283294677734,
-0.14643116295337677,
1.191148042678833,
0.17820896208286285,
0.3010014295578003,
-0.6830229163169861,
0.5819242596626282,
-0.17791345715522766,
-0.8316420912742615,
-0.4204270839691162,
-0.5275647640228271,
-0.752669632434845,
0.4344697594642639,
0.1918049454689026,
-0.44507768750190735,
0.1793373078107834,
0.18925443291664124,
-0.2016887068748474,
1.075308084487915,
-0.787520706653595,
0.8642145395278931,
-0.1803182065486908,
0.06175411865115166,
-0.25072914361953735,
-0.38778144121170044,
0.4256146252155304,
-0.26264363527297974,
0.4346528947353363,
0.031774044036865234,
-0.11490320414304733,
0.6997337937355042,
-0.7269687056541443,
0.8350135087966919,
-0.2814028263092041,
-0.3972732126712799,
0.31159403920173645,
0.07343021780252457,
0.39480844140052795,
-0.22367791831493378,
0.13569775223731995,
0.27626630663871765,
0.2200353592634201,
-0.35242336988449097,
-0.8208092451095581,
0.7817056775093079,
-0.7545859813690186,
-0.7478381395339966,
-0.13588343560695648,
-0.28668665885925293,
0.13657213747501373,
0.10093015432357788,
0.2702743411064148,
0.15194816887378693,
-0.17400123178958893,
0.12716205418109894,
0.6639143824577332,
0.04030054807662964,
0.7123187184333801,
0.3610077202320099,
-0.3152901530265808,
-0.09502597153186798,
0.8989466428756714,
0.10451829433441162,
0.5357216596603394,
0.3711797893047333,
0.4783543050289154,
-0.4289887547492981,
-0.7543288469314575,
-0.5360345840454102,
0.059478044509887695,
-1.1884633302688599,
-0.12123458832502365,
-0.44934794306755066,
-0.13160531222820282,
-0.30730557441711426,
-0.29678672552108765,
-0.39609819650650024,
-0.5186012387275696,
-0.5273194313049316,
-0.4066554605960846,
0.3005158007144928,
0.8053487539291382,
-0.3670380115509033,
0.3523375689983368,
-0.8763943910598755,
0.0033640337642282248,
0.5156285166740417,
0.29116401076316833,
0.34952256083488464,
-0.6712625622749329,
-0.2836284935474396,
0.034516341984272,
-0.22150766849517822,
-0.5401629209518433,
0.04949047043919563,
0.4414685070514679,
0.5920194983482361,
0.5161649584770203,
0.2753388583660126,
0.872329831123352,
-0.6231685280799866,
0.6252646446228027,
0.625153660774231,
-1.0614895820617676,
0.28166463971138,
0.15040840208530426,
0.24011771380901337,
0.47975069284439087,
0.6571488976478577,
-0.7812352180480957,
-0.4153003990650177,
-0.30877557396888733,
-1.0551706552505493,
0.2483331859111786,
-0.0012417719699442387,
0.45351698994636536,
0.31818994879722595,
0.206919863820076,
0.3354053497314453,
0.04547114297747612,
-0.8886464834213257,
-0.3406549394130707,
0.060819707810878754,
-0.3514000177383423,
-0.10972899943590164,
-0.11125244200229645,
-0.03196648508310318,
-0.3979507386684418,
0.925481379032135,
0.355351060628891,
-0.32728275656700134,
0.13487648963928223,
-0.0256025567650795,
0.09878991544246674,
0.3350880742073059,
0.09172073751688004,
0.4859338402748108,
0.03704587370157242,
0.4831676185131073,
0.18218225240707397,
-0.5088592171669006,
0.8378003835678101,
-0.2984883189201355,
-0.31510356068611145,
0.332934707403183,
0.017276376485824585,
0.9265009164810181,
-0.011966903693974018,
-0.6816412806510925,
0.32314425706863403,
-0.12913502752780914,
-0.31878364086151123,
-0.057199764996767044,
0.11336521059274673,
0.38032588362693787,
0.45321446657180786,
0.576323390007019,
-0.006039730738848448,
0.20197877287864685,
-0.5092962980270386,
0.05025425925850868,
0.3655998408794403,
-0.42841655015945435,
-0.07991237193346024,
1.1168451309204102,
0.4035384953022003,
-0.14249464869499207,
0.40261319279670715,
-0.016359418630599976,
-0.2785223424434662,
0.3066515326499939,
0.3804682493209839,
0.9813649654388428,
-0.21162500977516174,
0.09562171250581741,
0.03649430349469185,
0.2733563482761383,
-0.19353824853897095,
-0.31790608167648315,
-0.15337811410427094,
-0.5297428965568542,
-0.2580164670944214,
-0.7425384521484375,
-0.200819194316864,
-0.06277205049991608,
-0.3822787404060364,
0.18229807913303375,
-0.41768190264701843,
-0.24053184688091278,
-0.10998298227787018,
-0.427980899810791,
-0.5319147706031799,
-0.2685917019844055,
-0.002816353226080537,
0.6520097851753235,
-1.051881194114685,
0.8895111083984375,
0.5292173624038696,
-0.2862742841243744,
-0.8422989845275879,
-0.31304582953453064,
-0.0853428989648819,
-0.5020938515663147,
1.1281256675720215,
-0.08205854892730713,
-0.002128089312463999,
0.09844375401735306,
-0.33559781312942505,
-0.5160029530525208,
1.3404109477996826,
0.40640565752983093,
-1.002146601676941,
-0.22803236544132233,
0.5550088882446289,
0.16708914935588837,
-0.12297683954238892,
0.026683559641242027,
0.6572725772857666,
0.380228728055954,
0.2386225461959839,
-1.1741702556610107,
0.20472507178783417,
0.11837013065814972,
0.3021864593029022,
0.26003605127334595,
-0.7422412633895874,
0.7703295350074768,
-0.10409755259752274,
-0.25110509991645813,
-0.1257825493812561,
0.47334185242652893,
0.04652323201298714,
0.38017451763153076,
0.5409731864929199,
0.7301790714263916,
0.5675534009933472,
0.13958406448364258,
0.5738239884376526,
-0.1550314873456955,
0.33669331669807434,
0.987987220287323,
-0.19438692927360535,
0.6811314225196838,
1.0557212829589844,
-0.4038768410682678,
0.2378033846616745,
0.3505621552467346,
0.17068488895893097,
0.5893117189407349,
0.5843539237976074,
-0.6794676780700684,
-0.09197817742824554,
-0.20541362464427948,
-0.19880566000938416,
0.21669204533100128,
-0.04121960699558258,
-0.12302917242050171,
-0.3839392364025116,
0.40991735458374023,
0.22599507868289948,
0.0006187352701090276,
-0.19098161160945892,
0.653135359287262,
0.150514617562294,
-0.22999653220176697,
0.9112209677696228,
-0.08366315811872482,
0.9125658869743347,
-0.5295186638832092,
0.15319128334522247,
-0.5217860341072083,
0.14714640378952026,
-0.08285033702850342,
-0.2767956256866455,
0.3303038477897644,
-0.14274811744689941,
-0.09628492593765259,
-0.3501793444156647,
0.5198904871940613,
-0.6003419160842896,
-0.6183918118476868,
0.3965110182762146,
0.2894209027290344,
0.30696216225624084,
-0.009852822870016098,
-0.18387958407402039,
0.17717933654785156,
0.22479552030563354,
-0.19612954556941986,
0.5334399938583374,
0.6498185396194458,
0.18354520201683044,
0.9277804493904114,
0.4587222635746002,
0.13083477318286896,
0.32847902178764343,
-0.05191740021109581,
1.0852333307266235,
-0.3386031687259674,
-0.3061101734638214,
-1.147887110710144,
0.5302181243896484,
0.08105245977640152,
0.016680974513292313,
0.8172048926353455,
0.6805554628372192,
1.003355622291565,
-0.0910327136516571,
1.082909107208252,
0.015154303051531315,
0.16584445536136627,
-0.5983716249465942,
0.8624582886695862,
-0.6999726295471191,
0.5438355207443237,
-0.22248363494873047,
-1.183209776878357,
-0.12406989932060242,
0.3673407733440399,
0.3381153345108032,
-0.2674218714237213,
0.7635108232498169,
0.4510852098464966,
-0.1893436163663864,
-0.30488863587379456,
0.6718180775642395,
0.008915677666664124,
0.6080018281936646,
0.7839696407318115,
0.6638075709342957,
-0.4372900426387787,
0.8356226682662964,
-0.2252262532711029,
-0.025724653154611588,
-0.31053584814071655,
-0.9042063355445862,
-1.2426371574401855,
-0.6050059199333191,
-0.30745837092399597,
0.02439774200320244,
0.2734031081199646,
0.6514442563056946,
0.7022733688354492,
-0.5858389139175415,
-0.5497734546661377,
-0.2817646861076355,
0.26897749304771423,
0.20461530983448029,
-0.1769970953464508,
0.3296985924243927,
-0.2940298914909363,
-0.7427673935890198,
0.08764200657606125,
0.13833817839622498,
0.48763903975486755,
-0.4968315660953522,
-0.03811212629079819,
-0.10467472672462463,
0.09773945063352585,
0.5147588849067688,
-0.06810852140188217,
-0.6040168404579163,
-0.2365758717060089,
-0.20430269837379456,
0.22916002571582794,
-0.10161099582910538,
1.0246398448944092,
-0.7627922892570496,
0.25638705492019653,
0.46249401569366455,
0.7822314500808716,
0.5118811130523682,
-0.28218168020248413,
0.5712927579879761,
-0.7464190125465393,
0.30130642652511597,
0.0824388712644577,
0.2949964106082916,
0.06931643187999725,
-0.27643314003944397,
0.4119971692562103,
0.48694315552711487,
-0.598619282245636,
-0.9651541113853455,
0.08221614360809326,
-0.5668542385101318,
-0.546306848526001,
1.0253870487213135,
-0.38738682866096497,
-0.0155590008944273,
-0.1582099050283432,
-0.38090643286705017,
0.16005362570285797,
-0.36346006393432617,
0.7307575345039368,
0.9052234292030334,
-0.0030561296734958887,
-0.12055755406618118,
-0.4478452205657959,
0.3882178068161011,
0.5618867874145508,
-0.5464758276939392,
0.2856626808643341,
0.3112858533859253,
0.48302653431892395,
-0.11082233488559723,
0.6180423498153687,
0.13474665582180023,
-0.3673907220363617,
0.03710132837295532,
0.1829390823841095,
-0.10618056356906891,
-0.4389570653438568,
-0.24082902073860168,
-0.10266511887311935,
0.20386169850826263,
-0.20434437692165375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12026v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12026v3 | Acquiring Clean Language Models from Backdoor Poisoned Datasets by Downscaling Frequency Space | 2024-02-19T10:34:48 | 2024-06-02T10:28:13 | Zongru Wu, Zhuosheng Zhang, Pengzhou Cheng, Gongshen Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR | Despite the notable success of language models (LMs) in various natural
language processing (NLP) tasks, the reliability of LMs is susceptible to
backdoor attacks. Prior research attempts to mitigate backdoor learning while
training the LMs on the poisoned dataset, yet struggles against complex
backdoor attacks in real-world scenarios. In this paper, we investigate the
learning mechanisms of backdoor LMs in the frequency space by Fourier analysis.
Our findings indicate that the backdoor mapping presented on the poisoned
datasets exhibits a more discernible inclination towards lower frequency
compared to clean mapping, resulting in the faster convergence of backdoor
mapping. To alleviate this dilemma, we propose Multi-Scale Low-Rank Adaptation
(MuScleLoRA), which deploys multiple radial scalings in the frequency space
with low-rank adaptation to the target model and further aligns the gradients
when updating parameters. Through downscaling in the frequency space,
MuScleLoRA encourages the model to prioritize the learning of relatively
high-frequency clean mapping, consequently mitigating backdoor learning.
Experimental results demonstrate that MuScleLoRA outperforms baselines
significantly. Notably, MuScleLoRA reduces the average success rate of diverse
backdoor attacks to below 15\% across multiple datasets and generalizes to
various backbone LMs, including BERT, RoBERTa, GPT2-XL, and Llama2. The codes
are publicly available at https://github.com/ZrW00/MuScleLoRA. | [
-0.3064526319503784,
-0.4535144567489624,
0.23845252394676208,
0.015493424609303474,
0.1444612294435501,
-0.13023212552070618,
-0.5017589330673218,
-0.17571382224559784,
-0.21878588199615479,
0.5757207274436951,
-0.4368158280849457,
-0.7913634777069092,
-0.48901212215423584,
-0.10988357663154602,
-0.20430727303028107,
1.0587794780731201,
0.41847360134124756,
0.09363463521003723,
0.5271428227424622,
-0.22995729744434357,
-0.7810143828392029,
-0.5660646557807922,
-0.6081041693687439,
-0.31251028180122375,
0.6386725306510925,
0.5184751152992249,
0.8285265564918518,
0.22021810710430145,
0.326787531375885,
0.29648256301879883,
0.15701864659786224,
-0.2775724530220032,
-0.9018807411193848,
0.2671249806880951,
-0.3338148891925812,
-0.5015636682510376,
-0.39576929807662964,
0.010502059943974018,
0.4792868196964264,
0.4491748511791229,
-0.41844117641448975,
0.37051209807395935,
-0.12528462707996368,
0.8095297813415527,
-0.6629403233528137,
0.056585147976875305,
-1.006345510482788,
0.02913891151547432,
-0.2744814455509186,
-0.26337680220603943,
-0.5972829461097717,
-0.20497027039527893,
-0.36228615045547485,
-0.43643996119499207,
0.016199296340346336,
0.15827716886997223,
0.6097151637077332,
0.26837876439094543,
-0.21402142941951752,
0.009404984302818775,
-0.6295745372772217,
0.6822643280029297,
-0.8207699656486511,
0.8136123418807983,
0.3779420554637909,
0.4397868514060974,
-0.5202081203460693,
-0.390288770198822,
-0.40752580761909485,
-0.2479768842458725,
0.01659344509243965,
-0.12583570182323456,
-0.26072996854782104,
-0.09092891961336136,
0.2999132573604584,
0.10795188695192337,
-0.7628406286239624,
0.3752669394016266,
-0.6685926914215088,
-0.14720883965492249,
0.5257793068885803,
-0.10412278026342392,
0.36657020449638367,
-0.16626328229904175,
-0.192264586687088,
-0.5115095973014832,
-0.9082574248313904,
0.020451214164495468,
0.3919821083545685,
0.7269081473350525,
-0.33194026350975037,
0.1785546839237213,
0.10798995941877365,
0.5014341473579407,
-0.00786648876965046,
-0.15891703963279724,
0.38880252838134766,
-0.12093088775873184,
-0.2946707010269165,
0.20678727328777313,
0.4267127811908722,
-0.006953694391995668,
0.47757747769355774,
-0.20907534658908844,
-0.2801356315612793,
-0.2646237313747406,
0.5647003650665283,
-0.8071311712265015,
-0.22634148597717285,
0.5014935731887817,
-0.4996097981929779,
-0.19360317289829254,
-0.2527889311313629,
-1.0647101402282715,
-0.4288620352745056,
-0.007765441667288542,
0.6087503433227539,
-0.40719902515411377,
-0.2354336380958557,
0.11938174068927765,
-0.24969114363193512,
0.22527804970741272,
0.23302294313907623,
-1.0659407377243042,
0.5224327445030212,
0.78174889087677,
0.7772515416145325,
0.140655979514122,
-0.16739241778850555,
-0.6351487636566162,
-0.03275177627801895,
-0.33695563673973083,
0.2749423384666443,
-0.4582294523715973,
-0.23252667486667633,
-0.19325414299964905,
-0.11669757217168808,
-0.36592087149620056,
-0.6356538534164429,
0.09327830374240875,
-0.9630054235458374,
0.10027133673429489,
0.11847888678312302,
0.08126895129680634,
-0.6061409115791321,
0.11828447878360748,
-0.7507531642913818,
0.9970749020576477,
0.13844531774520874,
-0.53655606508255,
0.2069852352142334,
-0.3858940899372101,
-0.2846219539642334,
-0.27672266960144043,
0.18399782478809357,
-0.5037049055099487,
0.35677632689476013,
0.07505375891923904,
0.4625173807144165,
-0.011523702181875706,
0.004585143644362688,
-0.685602068901062,
-0.4740254878997803,
0.3412175178527832,
-0.3368809223175049,
0.7967842817306519,
0.3328592777252197,
-0.2200949639081955,
0.14613984525203705,
-0.8495526313781738,
0.0014730652328580618,
-0.11939849704504013,
-0.27480924129486084,
-0.49195748567581177,
-0.023292575031518936,
-0.014608354307711124,
0.5231660008430481,
-0.32776740193367004,
-0.32597818970680237,
0.12714388966560364,
-0.7606127262115479,
0.03824024647474289,
0.7449038624763489,
0.1649799644947052,
0.3346465826034546,
-0.49676668643951416,
0.3184177577495575,
-0.268128901720047,
0.11648859083652496,
-0.059413716197013855,
-0.45086202025413513,
-0.3669838309288025,
-0.46521639823913574,
0.15623638033866882,
0.5594683885574341,
-0.49453940987586975,
0.29901185631752014,
-0.6581458449363708,
-0.754838228225708,
-0.28984153270721436,
0.33627772331237793,
0.4988766014575958,
0.370665967464447,
0.6503670811653137,
-0.39668217301368713,
-0.1128685399889946,
-0.5574143528938293,
-0.40856173634529114,
0.06148253008723259,
-0.2697141766548157,
0.17064465582370758,
0.7532755732536316,
-0.0726025402545929,
0.7004351019859314,
-0.38169628381729126,
-0.7833746671676636,
-0.08034314960241318,
-0.0409063845872879,
0.4722837507724762,
0.45093584060668945,
0.6884586215019226,
-0.6803880333900452,
-0.3397008776664734,
-0.10326115041971207,
-0.36384469270706177,
-0.09625264257192612,
-0.10235048830509186,
0.1098163053393364,
-0.006193382665514946,
0.40401604771614075,
-0.10264942049980164,
0.3007632791996002,
1.0345135927200317,
-0.05405464395880699,
0.1471537947654724,
-0.07786915451288223,
0.09867411106824875,
-1.0565690994262695,
0.19711855053901672,
0.12094037979841232,
-0.1418459713459015,
-1.066740870475769,
0.33631259202957153,
0.08274360746145248,
-0.3859823942184448,
-0.5048069953918457,
0.4879935383796692,
-0.2278328239917755,
-0.23549483716487885,
-0.003995311912149191,
0.13964438438415527,
-0.22177226841449738,
1.1236010789871216,
-0.23284165561199188,
0.6493045091629028,
0.21720759570598602,
-0.31750231981277466,
0.10267598181962967,
0.10638425499200821,
0.1432528793811798,
0.25081494450569153,
-0.320295512676239,
0.21235278248786926,
0.09460337460041046,
0.3058066666126251,
-1.0914983749389648,
-0.10885890573263168,
0.6057159900665283,
-0.39912357926368713,
0.602459192276001,
-0.46762529015541077,
-0.33206403255462646,
0.031200310215353966,
-0.7564743757247925,
0.4030620753765106,
0.5698434710502625,
-0.5456017255783081,
0.6107385158538818,
0.384884238243103,
-0.20735187828540802,
-0.39256981015205383,
-0.4782380759716034,
-0.12320315092802048,
-0.190656840801239,
-0.536685049533844,
-0.06515605747699738,
0.21415938436985016,
-0.3245304822921753,
-0.4701426923274994,
-0.2599470615386963,
-0.080074243247509,
0.5442909002304077,
0.4992193281650543,
-0.04573860391974449,
-0.30052557587623596,
0.4372892677783966,
-0.09905406087636948,
0.051612574607133865,
-0.07038833200931549,
-0.29644665122032166,
0.7562034726142883,
-0.1575932800769806,
-0.3540930449962616,
-0.47822150588035583,
0.058981239795684814,
0.5310624837875366,
-0.12799978256225586,
0.7906951308250427,
0.3510461747646332,
-0.3389582931995392,
-0.447385311126709,
-0.24059802293777466,
-0.55232834815979,
-0.5668519735336304,
0.42410731315612793,
-0.31371545791625977,
-0.5748029947280884,
0.5458386540412903,
-0.13258369266986847,
-0.0029041862580925226,
0.3244129717350006,
0.5820965766906738,
0.1288776695728302,
0.44197583198547363,
0.5779294371604919,
-0.24016019701957703,
0.4532782733440399,
-0.09132878482341766,
0.09484272450208664,
-0.7239475250244141,
0.02402600832283497,
-0.7708012461662292,
-0.3815082311630249,
-0.7117713093757629,
-0.2660762369632721,
0.5616737604141235,
-0.06329822540283203,
-0.43417003750801086,
0.2152082622051239,
-0.2022010236978531,
0.1033233255147934,
0.35148119926452637,
0.1871856302022934,
0.3377237319946289,
0.25865495204925537,
0.12584605813026428,
0.06094904616475105,
-0.7416408658027649,
-0.06168455258011818,
1.2214009761810303,
0.705464243888855,
0.9109721183776855,
0.3737576901912689,
0.7965325117111206,
0.3751843273639679,
0.6923273801803589,
-0.5528236627578735,
0.256366491317749,
-0.35006338357925415,
-0.7543883919715881,
-0.5638477802276611,
-0.3574475944042206,
-0.9242530465126038,
0.6315661072731018,
-0.2531001567840576,
-0.9604988694190979,
0.4859716296195984,
0.15066148340702057,
-0.4441799819469452,
0.3063088655471802,
-0.6178844571113586,
0.7508403062820435,
-0.04484066367149353,
-0.1836753785610199,
-0.3910053074359894,
-0.6182157397270203,
0.6260521411895752,
-0.6972637176513672,
0.6447522640228271,
-0.21224455535411835,
0.22508099675178528,
0.7770273685455322,
-0.29097434878349304,
1.0906630754470825,
-0.3100373148918152,
-0.6617757081985474,
-0.3525691330432892,
0.17666873335838318,
0.3484859764575958,
0.08070758730173111,
-0.19521674513816833,
0.7102850675582886,
-0.07489055395126343,
-0.31266510486602783,
-0.5405066013336182,
0.34554368257522583,
-0.6516388654708862,
-0.7162250876426697,
-0.3881036937236786,
-0.3788343071937561,
-0.40762099623680115,
0.15120817720890045,
0.01829906553030014,
0.4799037575721741,
0.23520585894584656,
0.2857312262058258,
0.5885313749313354,
-0.3828365206718445,
0.37829700112342834,
0.6216184496879578,
-0.14594727754592896,
-0.40517479181289673,
0.9640605449676514,
0.006547645665705204,
0.3947620391845703,
0.4227583408355713,
0.1902649700641632,
-0.0064040799625217915,
-0.7463216185569763,
-0.28725025057792664,
0.22248616814613342,
-0.609463632106781,
-0.4587538540363312,
-0.2810731828212738,
-0.13208486139774323,
-0.548607349395752,
-0.035809226334095,
-0.42411258816719055,
-0.26873600482940674,
-0.05297939106822014,
0.2182501256465912,
0.44028931856155396,
0.4232536554336548,
-0.2022404819726944,
0.5412658452987671,
-0.9786285758018494,
0.5500709414482117,
0.15089358389377594,
0.21251939237117767,
0.1993427872657776,
-0.7852314710617065,
-0.32037585973739624,
0.1271129697561264,
-0.10394658893346786,
-1.194433331489563,
0.7210524678230286,
0.36164388060569763,
0.35380008816719055,
0.12939736247062683,
0.06770366430282593,
0.3914410471916199,
-0.4527530074119568,
0.3961234390735626,
0.007655788213014603,
-0.9620482921600342,
0.31681615114212036,
-0.41488686203956604,
0.18212904036045074,
0.5575112104415894,
0.2357683628797531,
-0.8919190764427185,
-0.7167754769325256,
-0.10088863968849182,
-0.8825406432151794,
0.8372162580490112,
0.017483774572610855,
0.22728778421878815,
0.5379876494407654,
0.3035132586956024,
0.09632615745067596,
0.28995105624198914,
-0.7138619422912598,
-0.10647442191839218,
-0.41580817103385925,
-0.32172492146492004,
-0.20736423134803772,
-0.05675822123885155,
-0.44166290760040283,
0.045596376061439514,
0.7174862027168274,
-0.3380048871040344,
0.0001237895485246554,
-0.1522645205259323,
-0.4014956057071686,
-0.09903333336114883,
0.6375364065170288,
0.7360305190086365,
0.380650132894516,
-0.28846073150634766,
0.08260494470596313,
0.4466295540332794,
-0.7555259466171265,
0.2305840104818344,
0.1956101804971695,
0.07843849062919617,
-0.4016280770301819,
0.6892532706260681,
0.33822283148765564,
0.656257152557373,
-0.3962119519710541,
0.49222609400749207,
0.031947240233421326,
0.13654620945453644,
0.024193082004785538,
0.3897246718406677,
-0.21498313546180725,
0.3105502426624298,
0.6624845266342163,
0.044695932418107986,
-0.1787295639514923,
-0.5078245401382446,
0.4535519778728485,
0.30448511242866516,
-0.25822100043296814,
-0.4322310984134674,
0.41673544049263,
0.11668750643730164,
-0.23246464133262634,
0.7194800972938538,
0.1394701898097992,
-0.585542619228363,
0.39418351650238037,
0.41495949029922485,
0.8506882190704346,
-0.3983128070831299,
0.03881903365254402,
0.1048850566148758,
0.5039308667182922,
0.10826122760772705,
0.3085235059261322,
-0.06017475947737694,
-0.8417432308197021,
-0.09563077986240387,
-0.7495200037956238,
-0.0374377965927124,
0.0669376328587532,
-0.5775492191314697,
-0.03875832259654999,
-0.5841673612594604,
0.0350855253636837,
-0.15964022278785706,
0.21286554634571075,
-0.2667349874973297,
0.03494926914572716,
0.23505529761314392,
1.0162246227264404,
-1.1420854330062866,
1.1628201007843018,
-0.05555281788110733,
-0.43462154269218445,
-0.9989668726921082,
0.34519219398498535,
0.23462867736816406,
-0.9681333303451538,
1.0103263854980469,
-0.030811674892902374,
-0.20374451577663422,
0.2332460582256317,
-0.24401342868804932,
-0.9404937028884888,
0.8050652742385864,
0.2797187566757202,
-0.4871346354484558,
0.05595358833670616,
-0.11925441026687622,
0.6622170805931091,
0.05825933814048767,
-0.20415760576725006,
0.3943327069282532,
0.6125094294548035,
-0.21469587087631226,
-1.0047874450683594,
0.4046855866909027,
0.007176985498517752,
-0.04401802271604538,
0.19776800274848938,
-0.5907660126686096,
0.9491784572601318,
-0.13384369015693665,
-0.3756779432296753,
0.014787094667553902,
0.43478772044181824,
0.3857002854347229,
0.24244153499603271,
0.3836682140827179,
0.4673294723033905,
0.5578135251998901,
-0.04850758612155914,
0.8060391545295715,
-0.23970335721969604,
0.35685715079307556,
1.1156667470932007,
-0.4205225110054016,
0.9596283435821533,
0.36076754331588745,
-0.015817774459719658,
0.6011140942573547,
0.4123023748397827,
-0.5257428884506226,
0.5644495487213135,
0.4240807592868805,
0.28846222162246704,
0.07539766281843185,
0.4054050147533417,
-0.5920446515083313,
0.6393285989761353,
0.5123441219329834,
-0.157444566488266,
-0.5869017243385315,
0.3180631101131439,
0.27122631669044495,
0.04993939772248268,
-0.4184601604938507,
0.6420255899429321,
0.14355352520942688,
-0.38741132616996765,
0.9050105214118958,
0.19922102987766266,
0.5228241682052612,
-0.6787972450256348,
-0.0747348740696907,
-0.3169916272163391,
0.22769539058208466,
-0.23755818605422974,
-0.19225087761878967,
0.10139276087284088,
-0.3257614076137543,
0.010716005228459835,
-0.3383786976337433,
0.6656097173690796,
-0.47249674797058105,
-0.11790963262319565,
0.3662126958370209,
0.2536334991455078,
-0.0418202169239521,
-0.05802616477012634,
-0.5106950402259827,
0.21877585351467133,
-0.32402393221855164,
-0.4384731948375702,
0.5789932012557983,
0.011973990127444267,
-0.2304438054561615,
0.7472959756851196,
0.8864598870277405,
0.36258020997047424,
0.1846415251493454,
-0.03769739344716072,
0.9601165056228638,
-0.5333075523376465,
-0.3780588209629059,
-0.706562876701355,
0.04481786489486694,
0.21084846556186676,
0.06961284577846527,
1.0086696147918701,
0.4283158481121063,
0.799148440361023,
-0.08455973863601685,
0.2677045166492462,
0.4526825547218323,
0.24215996265411377,
-0.8100650310516357,
1.0804879665374756,
-0.563267171382904,
0.5318542122840881,
-0.07244738936424255,
-0.47687438130378723,
-0.4548480212688446,
0.23702643811702728,
-0.30887481570243835,
0.2233457714319229,
0.5300069451332092,
1.1455402374267578,
-0.05672258138656616,
-0.11177118122577667,
0.3535323739051819,
0.4838688373565674,
0.39595526456832886,
0.6111832857131958,
0.42724087834358215,
-0.37545090913772583,
0.3713263273239136,
-0.08206257969141006,
-0.17771483957767487,
-0.3509035110473633,
-0.5410915017127991,
-0.8747950792312622,
-0.32474610209465027,
0.04814408719539642,
-0.4652043282985687,
0.3284159302711487,
0.6856500506401062,
0.7953323125839233,
-1.0161930322647095,
-0.28515657782554626,
0.4073065519332886,
0.4796656668186188,
-0.40569719672203064,
-0.2264661341905594,
0.3776529133319855,
-0.5517411828041077,
-0.4453437626361847,
0.46509408950805664,
0.37647607922554016,
-0.2674696445465088,
-0.2947273850440979,
-0.003988569136708975,
-0.1721494048833847,
0.12124425917863846,
0.18462632596492767,
0.5939182639122009,
-0.43584758043289185,
-0.5133646130561829,
-0.4000695049762726,
-0.3124774396419525,
0.0618094876408577,
0.7916037440299988,
-0.8797914385795593,
0.08718486875295639,
0.5291674137115479,
0.38255953788757324,
0.10615331679582596,
-0.2078925520181656,
0.6191497445106506,
-1.1434816122055054,
0.21305744349956512,
0.05691468343138695,
0.11629290133714676,
0.10431164503097534,
-0.34437859058380127,
0.39345598220825195,
0.22886137664318085,
-0.179158017039299,
-1.0114262104034424,
0.16145917773246765,
-0.7510954737663269,
-0.802297055721283,
1.3255555629730225,
0.014515946619212627,
-0.348722368478775,
-0.40685826539993286,
0.06016874313354492,
0.1745530068874359,
-0.37291765213012695,
0.961264431476593,
0.36049509048461914,
0.1873505860567093,
0.14235885441303253,
-0.46620458364486694,
0.760674774646759,
0.06288696825504303,
-0.7537299990653992,
0.19452887773513794,
0.327499121427536,
0.4489184319972992,
0.23160378634929657,
0.45099547505378723,
-0.06158509850502014,
0.3430766761302948,
-0.09927424043416977,
-0.13277556002140045,
-0.1287832409143448,
-0.461351215839386,
-0.9156644344329834,
0.7418771982192993,
-0.1424121856689453,
-0.06422354280948639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12025v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12025v2 | Speech Translation with Speech Foundation Models and Large Language Models: What is There and What is Missing? | 2024-02-19T10:34:13 | 2024-05-17T14:46:32 | Marco Gaido, Sara Papi, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli | cs.CL | cs.CL | The field of natural language processing (NLP) has recently witnessed a
transformative shift with the emergence of foundation models, particularly
Large Language Models (LLMs) that have revolutionized text-based NLP. This
paradigm has extended to other modalities, including speech, where researchers
are actively exploring the combination of Speech Foundation Models (SFMs) and
LLMs into single, unified models capable of addressing multimodal tasks. Among
such tasks, this paper focuses on speech-to-text translation (ST). By examining
the published papers on the topic, we propose a unified view of the
architectural solutions and training strategies presented so far, highlighting
similarities and differences among them. Based on this examination, we not only
organize the lessons learned but also show how diverse settings and evaluation
approaches hinder the identification of the best-performing solution for each
architectural building block and training choice. Lastly, we outline
recommendations for future works on the topic aimed at better understanding the
strengths and weaknesses of the SFM+LLM solutions for ST. | [
-0.3856927752494812,
-0.8048946261405945,
0.4213887155056,
0.3590569496154785,
-0.3788721263408661,
0.28120964765548706,
-0.22206826508045197,
-0.6549175977706909,
0.041993845254182816,
0.6333245635032654,
-0.28872594237327576,
-0.275770902633667,
-0.8464219570159912,
0.17040131986141205,
-0.8391172289848328,
0.9011021256446838,
-0.14436641335487366,
0.3253467082977295,
-0.4070000648498535,
-0.04358752816915512,
-0.5875333547592163,
-0.461057186126709,
-0.5509976148605347,
-0.3987029194831848,
0.08607160300016403,
0.007319326046854258,
0.5311656594276428,
0.7434135675430298,
0.5277705788612366,
0.2546406686306,
-0.42487072944641113,
-0.09060007333755493,
-0.2164251059293747,
-0.08389011770486832,
-0.08678992092609406,
-0.10839477181434631,
-0.44567111134529114,
-0.15481382608413696,
0.9698749780654907,
1.0599414110183716,
-0.04053608328104019,
0.146463543176651,
0.16660934686660767,
0.7110670804977417,
-0.2324153631925583,
-0.04265308007597923,
-0.479968786239624,
0.33486849069595337,
-0.10331334918737411,
-0.2605602443218231,
-0.4723827838897705,
-0.093536876142025,
0.25704747438430786,
0.0040001170709729195,
0.14307920634746552,
-0.21923087537288666,
0.355448842048645,
0.4607481062412262,
-0.7293145060539246,
-0.3622480034828186,
-1.1335841417312622,
0.7459985613822937,
-0.7824718952178955,
0.653477132320404,
-0.03299807757139206,
0.21180561184883118,
-0.38744646310806274,
-0.7027536630630493,
-0.19063334167003632,
-0.24717247486114502,
0.14734908938407898,
-0.11236881464719772,
-0.30729547142982483,
0.13225002586841583,
-0.07539603859186172,
0.41711723804473877,
-0.6262992024421692,
0.18459726870059967,
-0.3135302662849426,
-0.04001357778906822,
0.6075581312179565,
-0.036616601049900055,
0.2509535551071167,
-0.14926974475383759,
-0.6177554130554199,
-0.028942521661520004,
-0.7279699444770813,
0.07651056349277496,
-0.09284620732069016,
0.52618807554245,
-0.2599763572216034,
0.49551302194595337,
0.0809779018163681,
0.8606953620910645,
-0.2744845449924469,
-0.28951218724250793,
0.30143117904663086,
-0.45795324444770813,
-0.49397507309913635,
0.0751400887966156,
0.7029811143875122,
-0.20571069419384003,
0.20523713529109955,
-0.3403457701206207,
-0.21132223308086395,
-0.12027838826179504,
0.2570880651473999,
-0.4308268129825592,
0.23293830454349518,
0.020245401188731194,
-0.3740808963775635,
-0.2658199667930603,
-0.30269211530685425,
-0.7056394219398499,
-0.11608453094959259,
-0.49037814140319824,
0.07440777122974396,
-0.07953833788633347,
-0.3822656273841858,
0.2352200746536255,
-0.03788405656814575,
0.37404340505599976,
0.27873465418815613,
-0.9816430807113647,
0.3742395043373108,
0.7806347608566284,
0.7461228370666504,
-0.5002390146255493,
-0.11807083338499069,
-0.5205931663513184,
0.0701499804854393,
-0.5835421085357666,
0.7674827575683594,
-0.4031064212322235,
-0.5924117565155029,
0.12068600952625275,
-0.299089640378952,
-0.1541866511106491,
-0.4060373604297638,
0.7393878698348999,
-0.15615925192832947,
0.26084408164024353,
-0.14630909264087677,
-0.36677786707878113,
-0.0043857465498149395,
0.0881674662232399,
-0.48993706703186035,
0.9934963583946228,
-0.11425964534282684,
-0.45347461104393005,
-0.061527837067842484,
-0.5950013995170593,
-0.703079342842102,
-0.04713951051235199,
-0.2460487335920334,
-0.039310209453105927,
0.6321251392364502,
0.12081371992826462,
0.5585857629776001,
-0.5037708282470703,
0.47093719244003296,
0.011570113711059093,
-0.2276344895362854,
0.12900827825069427,
-0.4890699088573456,
0.6124996542930603,
0.14638862013816833,
-0.27852579951286316,
0.29805341362953186,
-0.7735720872879028,
-0.085373155772686,
0.12011796236038208,
-0.6263716220855713,
-0.1186152994632721,
0.14488041400909424,
0.35975420475006104,
0.474010705947876,
0.09835640341043472,
-0.23963160812854767,
-0.20086738467216492,
-0.5223882794380188,
0.8528051376342773,
0.649767279624939,
-0.3332351744174957,
0.6999921202659607,
-0.10478620231151581,
0.39704185724258423,
-0.07412838190793991,
-0.09150929003953934,
0.038884151726961136,
-0.4957239627838135,
-0.5538977980613708,
-0.07816793024539948,
0.15428148210048676,
0.376945823431015,
-0.5216004848480225,
0.1541484296321869,
-0.4551865756511688,
-0.5061993598937988,
-0.5864320993423462,
0.05546455457806587,
0.3009217381477356,
0.5311006307601929,
0.4986433684825897,
-0.1714315563440323,
-0.520073413848877,
-0.8733530640602112,
-0.28984197974205017,
-0.050113704055547714,
0.17510558664798737,
0.032078955322504044,
0.5810420513153076,
-0.3110765218734741,
0.7438147068023682,
0.03511669859290123,
-0.29991796612739563,
-0.4019187092781067,
0.005748842842876911,
-0.009077413007616997,
0.42565029859542847,
0.6424090266227722,
-1.0902005434036255,
-0.33154812455177307,
-0.004239381290972233,
-0.44540607929229736,
0.07016675174236298,
-0.031048744916915894,
0.3680267930030823,
0.2070738971233368,
0.5809352993965149,
-0.6779217720031738,
0.28316420316696167,
0.864355742931366,
0.06308736652135849,
0.7419978976249695,
0.03371075913310051,
0.06297791004180908,
-1.344124674797058,
0.20523931086063385,
-0.056294530630111694,
-0.3050000071525574,
-1.033382773399353,
0.14265553653240204,
-0.23741735517978668,
-0.3431822657585144,
-0.510699450969696,
0.6414287090301514,
-0.36920684576034546,
-0.6482767462730408,
-0.32171252369880676,
0.342769593000412,
-0.05235319212079048,
0.4834270179271698,
0.16411389410495758,
0.8032668232917786,
0.30081233382225037,
-0.5530933737754822,
0.44809848070144653,
0.47222888469696045,
-0.2964821755886078,
0.5543022155761719,
-0.6918547749519348,
0.2574423849582672,
-0.08800207823514938,
0.35745593905448914,
-1.043042540550232,
-0.20741240680217743,
0.14394338428974152,
-0.4398478865623474,
0.3315964639186859,
-0.028047697618603706,
-0.3552229404449463,
-0.36606118083000183,
-0.11073055118322372,
0.1993715614080429,
0.18997910618782043,
-0.3567894995212555,
0.7729350328445435,
0.4263259470462799,
-0.42029905319213867,
-0.6594782471656799,
-0.9168978929519653,
0.5283457040786743,
-0.12182754278182983,
-0.7057675719261169,
0.5461679697036743,
-0.18388226628303528,
-0.23374296724796295,
-0.05028052628040314,
-0.34206247329711914,
-0.258192241191864,
0.2768242359161377,
0.15375284850597382,
0.10998021811246872,
-0.594244122505188,
0.11991717666387558,
-0.011113209649920464,
-0.1664348691701889,
0.01614772155880928,
-0.23147623240947723,
0.45862144231796265,
-0.32712721824645996,
-0.28318163752555847,
-0.3017149269580841,
0.7140973806381226,
0.7188119888305664,
-0.48001915216445923,
0.518678605556488,
0.5051968693733215,
-0.4014301300048828,
-0.14090578258037567,
-0.3671410083770752,
0.09760577976703644,
-0.3476434648036957,
0.6210773587226868,
-0.38936910033226013,
-1.0771585702896118,
0.2102486789226532,
-0.2103147953748703,
0.35997727513313293,
0.3852716088294983,
0.5489333271980286,
-0.14313016831874847,
0.9909331202507019,
0.78964763879776,
-0.15815065801143646,
0.5919827818870544,
0.15486255288124084,
0.28063637018203735,
-0.8407303690910339,
-0.21922902762889862,
-0.8638817071914673,
-0.3336128890514374,
-0.2195313274860382,
-0.3130820691585541,
0.1713208258152008,
0.1321508139371872,
0.16555631160736084,
0.5392532348632812,
-0.43065035343170166,
0.10092995315790176,
0.23015975952148438,
-0.4579216539859772,
0.4735065996646881,
0.2578880488872528,
0.05978310480713844,
-0.06677251309156418,
-0.7000283598899841,
-0.5058151483535767,
0.7863330245018005,
0.4355353116989136,
0.35298314690589905,
0.050626758486032486,
0.40859392285346985,
0.10603626072406769,
0.21523158252239227,
-0.7981862425804138,
0.6291000843048096,
-0.5389718413352966,
-0.47390294075012207,
-0.21449026465415955,
-0.5484105348587036,
-0.739660918712616,
0.6319342255592346,
-0.4111478924751282,
-0.37626534700393677,
0.15579324960708618,
-0.08316358923912048,
-0.11534681916236877,
0.1781018227338791,
-0.45696160197257996,
1.0413999557495117,
-0.6385535001754761,
0.07999755442142487,
-0.2794255018234253,
-0.6008492708206177,
0.25233644247055054,
-0.12789388000965118,
0.47773006558418274,
0.02097470685839653,
0.14542457461357117,
0.5105306506156921,
0.1697726994752884,
0.6875066757202148,
0.09832703322172165,
-0.2595907747745514,
-0.098049096763134,
-0.23861445486545563,
0.3783230781555176,
-0.46207326650619507,
0.039292365312576294,
0.21869292855262756,
0.0403849333524704,
-0.19516080617904663,
-0.29757794737815857,
0.5464848875999451,
-0.6151769161224365,
-0.4497322142124176,
-0.28713247179985046,
-0.4948907792568207,
-0.4818212687969208,
0.2362307459115982,
0.12150608003139496,
0.4940561354160309,
-0.6984542012214661,
0.7027485966682434,
0.80423504114151,
-0.09803406149148941,
0.4813431203365326,
0.3834773004055023,
-0.19836652278900146,
-0.39585256576538086,
0.35747331380844116,
-0.0734391063451767,
0.3338186740875244,
0.5645753741264343,
0.17582319676876068,
-0.38479095697402954,
-0.9592078924179077,
-0.6856366395950317,
0.21010097861289978,
-0.6392472982406616,
0.09715569764375687,
-0.651746392250061,
-0.32849568128585815,
-0.7210084795951843,
-0.22474685311317444,
-0.5515475869178772,
-0.275674432516098,
-0.5375732779502869,
-0.22006168961524963,
-0.22135597467422485,
0.6315882205963135,
0.13685575127601624,
0.2362048327922821,
-0.8577634692192078,
0.3775058686733246,
0.3287888467311859,
0.060366980731487274,
-0.008385937660932541,
-0.7066028118133545,
-0.3414541184902191,
0.22456064820289612,
-0.1306743025779724,
-0.8395106196403503,
0.21273939311504364,
0.34655627608299255,
0.5850626826286316,
0.054683882743120193,
-0.30987539887428284,
0.7087484002113342,
-0.6740473508834839,
0.7485749125480652,
0.2969776690006256,
-0.8465139269828796,
0.5003560185432434,
-0.21672849357128143,
0.06458058208227158,
0.3573262095451355,
0.1422594040632248,
-0.7874223589897156,
-0.1397131234407425,
-0.4002631902694702,
-0.8902602791786194,
0.40912652015686035,
-0.035637129098176956,
0.3476494550704956,
0.20386067032814026,
0.18765108287334442,
-0.19854776561260223,
0.5685566663742065,
-0.8577533960342407,
-0.02874004654586315,
-0.07867829501628876,
-0.16573816537857056,
-0.2916080355644226,
-0.15804918110370636,
-0.3422798216342926,
0.026484819129109383,
0.4378957450389862,
-0.0015502885216847062,
0.20828746259212494,
-0.07553926110267639,
-0.2783889174461365,
-0.2471264898777008,
0.5861354470252991,
0.824774444103241,
0.5596454739570618,
0.029125340282917023,
-0.009350067935883999,
-0.08799143880605698,
-0.14004844427108765,
0.08724755793809891,
0.15621398389339447,
-0.13296931982040405,
0.2021138221025467,
0.6139878630638123,
1.085951328277588,
0.7944705486297607,
-0.6112143993377686,
0.5288557410240173,
0.23811811208724976,
-0.27557647228240967,
-0.24489101767539978,
0.04989730939269066,
0.30027085542678833,
0.19808001816272736,
0.4062047302722931,
0.4338880181312561,
-0.1033359244465828,
-0.7393617630004883,
0.07510677725076675,
0.5318469405174255,
-0.4425961673259735,
-0.36301738023757935,
0.6646049618721008,
0.4373839795589447,
-0.5760155320167542,
0.3031021058559418,
0.42373764514923096,
-0.317227840423584,
0.4257238507270813,
0.7534001469612122,
1.116473913192749,
-0.2691865563392639,
0.4314190149307251,
-0.13241170346736908,
0.42628583312034607,
-0.42114192247390747,
-0.13476544618606567,
-0.08095405250787735,
-0.6251031756401062,
-0.6503520607948303,
-0.8004329204559326,
-0.32941433787345886,
0.15508688986301422,
-0.6271204352378845,
-0.08189265429973602,
-0.3038393259048462,
-0.00461842305958271,
-0.033965665847063065,
-0.20396558940410614,
-0.4924347996711731,
0.12722836434841156,
0.21549925208091736,
1.0859003067016602,
-0.9184945821762085,
0.862206757068634,
0.9201778173446655,
-0.22431597113609314,
-0.5243691802024841,
-0.3051654100418091,
-0.05557386949658394,
-0.48822808265686035,
0.4172018766403198,
-0.16859683394432068,
-0.31022191047668457,
0.16348309814929962,
-0.3331395387649536,
-0.7488016486167908,
0.8155947923660278,
0.6687955260276794,
-0.36528703570365906,
-0.4237597584724426,
0.519559383392334,
0.8637495636940002,
-0.6206195950508118,
-0.5291837453842163,
0.40375471115112305,
0.35091426968574524,
0.2450770139694214,
-1.020678162574768,
-0.3738054931163788,
0.02072909288108349,
0.2427106350660324,
0.18201389908790588,
-0.28365999460220337,
0.5871463418006897,
0.05621149390935898,
-0.30347031354904175,
0.0868043601512909,
0.5505802035331726,
0.0444653294980526,
0.24856022000312805,
0.21864742040634155,
0.47549542784690857,
0.38408851623535156,
-0.14045961201190948,
0.8271191716194153,
-0.00007766952330712229,
0.024352658540010452,
1.0555410385131836,
-0.2234799563884735,
1.3685858249664307,
0.7013146281242371,
-0.1775234341621399,
0.23173333704471588,
0.5752162337303162,
0.2102697789669037,
0.4440377652645111,
-0.0870424136519432,
-0.13105511665344238,
-0.2162618339061737,
-0.04638433828949928,
-0.6487452387809753,
0.5695722103118896,
0.3294697701931,
-0.3030782639980316,
-0.3099854588508606,
0.2012689858675003,
-0.3380246162414551,
0.28667470812797546,
-0.3405739963054657,
0.8188492655754089,
0.5219427943229675,
-0.4697395861148834,
0.3810614347457886,
0.25572556257247925,
0.5931357741355896,
-0.8454846143722534,
0.18091458082199097,
-0.25999823212623596,
-0.14708057045936584,
-0.11116795986890793,
-0.5295528173446655,
0.5984766483306885,
0.056913819164037704,
-0.30720755457878113,
-0.8121031522750854,
0.6623581051826477,
-0.5431898236274719,
-0.27745911478996277,
0.5324761271476746,
0.5861575603485107,
0.058705613017082214,
-0.08135560154914856,
-0.8399434685707092,
0.21194912493228912,
0.07275582104921341,
-0.10231304168701172,
0.46943947672843933,
0.24385124444961548,
0.07770462334156036,
0.6874440312385559,
0.8462597131729126,
0.2158675491809845,
0.1277533769607544,
-0.14253273606300354,
0.5835824012756348,
-0.5721848607063293,
-0.48607832193374634,
-0.7339584231376648,
0.5541532635688782,
0.23123548924922943,
-0.39632099866867065,
0.5730295181274414,
0.4762212634086609,
0.7484989762306213,
-0.07063675671815872,
0.5787880420684814,
0.23432524502277374,
0.34021422266960144,
-0.4955874979496002,
0.38825222849845886,
-0.6119775772094727,
0.1770462691783905,
-0.3873170018196106,
-1.246071219444275,
-0.23418767750263214,
0.6176048517227173,
-0.04713572561740875,
-0.21508194506168365,
0.5368200540542603,
0.352642297744751,
0.04960879683494568,
0.16989468038082123,
0.2839953899383545,
0.22966131567955017,
0.3919272720813751,
0.4905942678451538,
0.6604142189025879,
-0.5067498683929443,
0.6451823711395264,
0.2377961277961731,
-0.11162251234054565,
-0.42147883772850037,
-0.9729076027870178,
-0.5229506492614746,
-0.6416783332824707,
-0.1684967577457428,
-0.06275172531604767,
-0.03494011610746384,
0.876550555229187,
0.6427597403526306,
-0.7619415521621704,
-0.4258551597595215,
-0.07045447826385498,
0.2746720314025879,
-0.3953894376754761,
-0.10360277444124222,
0.22110334038734436,
-0.019146133214235306,
-0.5974206924438477,
0.9906205534934998,
0.5378612279891968,
0.2248348742723465,
-0.3303164541721344,
-0.08222386986017227,
-0.20587597787380219,
0.07870393246412277,
0.7276620268821716,
0.48554521799087524,
-0.7627867460250854,
-0.2230534851551056,
-0.06763289868831635,
-0.23395730555057526,
0.20892634987831116,
0.7403811812400818,
-0.427527517080307,
0.24784398078918457,
0.5843122601509094,
1.1882975101470947,
0.5149148106575012,
-0.2566506862640381,
0.6518985629081726,
-0.9215407371520996,
0.15432685613632202,
0.31402429938316345,
0.2647693157196045,
0.5361078381538391,
0.17669999599456787,
0.47582048177719116,
0.34319278597831726,
-0.4132481813430786,
-1.1435694694519043,
0.422687292098999,
-0.8430342674255371,
-0.3017697334289551,
0.9460984468460083,
0.20114298164844513,
0.02314833179116249,
-0.05208359286189079,
0.110356405377388,
0.009172813035547733,
0.024516792967915535,
0.6085148453712463,
0.9437698721885681,
0.0040895226411521435,
-0.2827607989311218,
-0.7584624886512756,
0.47024857997894287,
0.37112516164779663,
-0.7894173264503479,
0.011441100388765335,
0.5629316568374634,
0.17087163031101227,
0.36481714248657227,
0.7291128635406494,
-0.1286327838897705,
0.08915655314922333,
-0.27659133076667786,
-0.23886848986148834,
-0.036432743072509766,
-0.47086045145988464,
-0.5313470363616943,
0.22435981035232544,
0.016775595024228096,
0.003074659500271082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12022v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12022v1 | Distilling Large Language Models for Text-Attributed Graph Learning | 2024-02-19T10:31:53 | 2024-02-19T10:31:53 | Bo Pan, Zheng Zhang, Yifei Zhang, Yuntong Hu, Liang Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Text-Attributed Graphs (TAGs) are graphs of connected textual documents.
Graph models can efficiently learn TAGs, but their training heavily relies on
human-annotated labels, which are scarce or even unavailable in many
applications. Large language models (LLMs) have recently demonstrated
remarkable capabilities in few-shot and zero-shot TAG learning, but they suffer
from scalability, cost, and privacy issues. Therefore, in this work, we focus
on synergizing LLMs and graph models with their complementary strengths by
distilling the power of LLMs to a local graph model on TAG learning. To address
the inherent gaps between LLMs (generative models for texts) and graph models
(discriminative models for graphs), we propose first to let LLMs teach an
interpreter with rich textual rationale and then let a student model mimic the
interpreter's reasoning without LLMs' textual rationale. Extensive experiments
validate the efficacy of our proposed framework. | [
0.033053215593099594,
-0.5733680129051208,
0.7058426737785339,
-0.1578940749168396,
-0.43345075845718384,
0.5552141666412354,
-0.3697248697280884,
-0.5108445286750793,
0.10982276499271393,
0.5637296438217163,
-0.3407323658466339,
-0.6356515884399414,
-0.5981807112693787,
0.2392258495092392,
-0.21982868015766144,
1.0383108854293823,
-0.1571069359779358,
0.0296044759452343,
-0.2812458276748657,
-0.14124193787574768,
-0.33881694078445435,
-0.44084736704826355,
-0.5113564729690552,
-0.7030309438705444,
0.7360210418701172,
0.16554082930088043,
0.4212220311164856,
0.7619034051895142,
0.1291407197713852,
0.3241885304450989,
0.013038049452006817,
0.3370445668697357,
-0.5213015079498291,
0.18030473589897156,
-0.3387266993522644,
-0.6000111699104309,
-0.4319300353527069,
0.08600970357656479,
0.8612969517707825,
0.9642003178596497,
0.09298555552959442,
0.02450345642864704,
0.002071492839604616,
0.30511924624443054,
-0.314514696598053,
0.407917857170105,
-1.0176085233688354,
-0.3493613600730896,
-0.12187075614929199,
0.08525066822767258,
-1.000952959060669,
-0.2722319960594177,
0.056280717253685,
-0.6735320687294006,
0.1524563431739807,
0.04487348347902298,
0.8991946578025818,
0.1844768226146698,
-0.6102291345596313,
-0.23232139647006989,
-0.6138349771499634,
0.8035690784454346,
-0.519822359085083,
0.198148712515831,
0.4893052875995636,
0.22559252381324768,
-0.10152571648359299,
-0.9972139000892639,
-0.5068417191505432,
-0.1976989209651947,
-0.2648179233074188,
-0.11139730364084244,
-0.31629031896591187,
0.0421903133392334,
0.31468942761421204,
0.205458864569664,
-0.44140926003456116,
0.47790923714637756,
-0.042043887078762054,
-0.07376717031002045,
0.4877946078777313,
0.017096025869250298,
0.2560121715068817,
-0.339053750038147,
-0.5013986229896545,
0.05518864840269089,
-0.7471192479133606,
-0.38051506876945496,
0.3266355097293854,
0.5303394794464111,
0.07665201276540756,
0.5002556443214417,
0.14095932245254517,
0.9139442443847656,
-0.18160632252693176,
-0.34657442569732666,
0.31288498640060425,
-0.05270984396338463,
-0.17662665247917175,
-0.14096184074878693,
0.8932456970214844,
0.01026354543864727,
0.4118088185787201,
-0.49858716130256653,
-0.09739284217357635,
0.21172665059566498,
-0.19388531148433685,
-0.8869605660438538,
-0.4228889048099518,
-0.04735133424401283,
-0.1999383568763733,
-0.09196358174085617,
-0.26801198720932007,
-0.4521784484386444,
-0.4983503222465515,
-0.39389273524284363,
0.2902483344078064,
-0.5680350065231323,
-0.30244728922843933,
0.01103541161864996,
-0.30301111936569214,
-0.03828364610671997,
0.23515799641609192,
-0.7547962665557861,
0.19441892206668854,
0.6405724287033081,
0.9263763427734375,
0.025682948529720306,
-0.43755677342414856,
-0.4654754400253296,
0.45239609479904175,
-0.11126752942800522,
0.684176504611969,
-0.7689803242683411,
-0.3144305348396301,
-0.15419521927833557,
0.05551344156265259,
-0.11677117645740509,
-0.3758232891559601,
0.4163213074207306,
-0.4821624159812927,
-0.07219739258289337,
-0.13523578643798828,
-0.783278226852417,
-0.17057523131370544,
0.16507922112941742,
-0.7809558510780334,
0.9074509739875793,
0.31375786662101746,
-0.9397179484367371,
0.2375498116016388,
-0.2112855762243271,
-0.7631763219833374,
0.321050226688385,
-0.12277280539274216,
-0.35846641659736633,
-0.0434085875749588,
0.26713743805885315,
0.6239306926727295,
-0.3462187647819519,
0.38650110363960266,
-0.40066057443618774,
-0.21241401135921478,
0.1890241801738739,
-0.3108370006084442,
0.8552832007408142,
0.16181054711341858,
0.05997775122523308,
0.044438496232032776,
-0.7969392538070679,
-0.13782797753810883,
0.40893059968948364,
-0.2766735553741455,
-0.7065579295158386,
0.1468733251094818,
-0.24855230748653412,
0.09079762548208237,
0.1560606211423874,
-0.5778084397315979,
0.44861066341400146,
-0.6009471416473389,
0.8288841843605042,
0.7301655411720276,
-0.19071772694587708,
0.614169716835022,
-0.1978980004787445,
0.4460509121417999,
-0.2554723918437958,
-0.4437228739261627,
-0.45684540271759033,
-0.28830787539482117,
-0.569290280342102,
-0.7963891625404358,
0.38713550567626953,
0.17916615307331085,
-1.039368748664856,
0.3797326683998108,
-0.4645174741744995,
-0.614047646522522,
-0.418363094329834,
0.27826663851737976,
0.2315675914287567,
0.6398729681968689,
0.16629937291145325,
-0.1725849062204361,
-0.4281920790672302,
-0.4569230079650879,
-0.31188902258872986,
-0.30375343561172485,
0.02619084343314171,
0.3168562650680542,
0.4515642821788788,
-0.11979201436042786,
1.160069465637207,
-0.6720054149627686,
-0.4394652545452118,
-0.6754509806632996,
0.13998614251613617,
0.0380328968167305,
0.2055634707212448,
0.7082949876785278,
-0.583895742893219,
-0.7332756519317627,
0.0765068531036377,
-0.6428743004798889,
-0.18252579867839813,
0.023945361375808716,
-0.13479836285114288,
0.15729299187660217,
0.43932995200157166,
-0.6761716604232788,
0.16141237318515778,
0.5076271891593933,
-0.08839866518974304,
0.28034278750419617,
-0.13882073760032654,
-0.47489407658576965,
-1.304402470588684,
-0.017957502976059914,
0.24107597768306732,
-0.570634126663208,
-0.4095950126647949,
0.09691475331783295,
-0.12699638307094574,
-0.22320657968521118,
-0.1496952921152115,
0.6487860083580017,
-0.6679258346557617,
-0.00008295705629279837,
-0.3402191698551178,
0.44100460410118103,
0.3354351222515106,
0.44328734278678894,
0.09984763711690903,
0.4103308320045471,
0.6532291173934937,
-0.22094625234603882,
0.487220823764801,
0.10564127564430237,
-0.21973004937171936,
0.4650931656360626,
-0.5877915024757385,
0.13297566771507263,
-0.3549089729785919,
0.7193886637687683,
-1.088252305984497,
-0.31170350313186646,
0.007738327607512474,
-0.33475759625434875,
0.5388036966323853,
-0.5193013548851013,
-0.7145847082138062,
-0.3888881504535675,
-0.1529858559370041,
0.35432636737823486,
0.5605512261390686,
-0.7672065496444702,
0.8443199396133423,
0.4540427327156067,
-0.0662553459405899,
-0.46529242396354675,
-0.511186957359314,
0.12435687333345413,
-0.1051139160990715,
-0.4645635485649109,
0.2580382525920868,
0.18299023807048798,
-0.043044690042734146,
0.14377811551094055,
0.10460475087165833,
-0.15184436738491058,
0.27893927693367004,
0.26831281185150146,
0.4055887460708618,
-0.039936844259500504,
0.5380403399467468,
-0.055462636053562164,
-0.27293652296066284,
-0.18051283061504364,
-0.6245822310447693,
0.71026611328125,
0.010051621124148369,
-0.2873452305793762,
-0.209659606218338,
0.2265540063381195,
0.3508418798446655,
-0.6861820220947266,
0.9090452194213867,
0.468144953250885,
-0.39685365557670593,
-0.6255212426185608,
-0.09415023028850555,
-0.03737827017903328,
-0.46243566274642944,
0.5234496593475342,
-0.27694588899612427,
-1.076792597770691,
0.4671882390975952,
-0.413811057806015,
-0.10665537416934967,
0.35560184717178345,
0.6984294056892395,
-0.041836872696876526,
0.9938170909881592,
0.5852963924407959,
-0.2556624710559845,
0.6396971344947815,
-0.3714241683483124,
0.32848799228668213,
-0.6010891199111938,
-0.05641033500432968,
-0.62883061170578,
-0.17429497838020325,
-0.518588662147522,
-0.4176439940929413,
0.03941827639937401,
0.15137314796447754,
-0.2094649225473404,
0.3587091267108917,
-0.44356438517570496,
0.916609525680542,
0.3339114785194397,
0.06490227580070496,
0.3978428244590759,
0.15872366726398468,
-0.10339884459972382,
0.08213750272989273,
-0.6194107532501221,
-0.5475407242774963,
1.0836800336837769,
0.42443764209747314,
1.056470513343811,
0.04415321722626686,
0.8544639945030212,
-0.14605776965618134,
0.666620135307312,
-0.9107994437217712,
0.5243512392044067,
-0.3451991081237793,
-0.5692358613014221,
-0.17493446171283722,
-0.6935036778450012,
-1.0138118267059326,
0.37518227100372314,
-0.0520872063934803,
-1.0036053657531738,
-0.2667037844657898,
0.1523459553718567,
0.10823921859264374,
0.5156948566436768,
-0.9456056952476501,
0.9692541360855103,
-0.02838427759706974,
-0.23189745843410492,
0.06900397688150406,
-0.49238553643226624,
0.27872487902641296,
-0.1652321219444275,
0.3480220437049866,
-0.27340933680534363,
0.18507020175457,
0.4838508367538452,
-0.3760252594947815,
1.2959084510803223,
-0.046717531979084015,
-0.1828036904335022,
0.5027710795402527,
0.22797295451164246,
0.7566859722137451,
-0.12336476892232895,
-0.017844973132014275,
0.031092248857021332,
-0.26390108466148376,
-0.288554847240448,
-0.39483439922332764,
0.7487408518791199,
-0.6768783330917358,
-0.4105292856693268,
-0.2881059944629669,
-0.6655116677284241,
-0.11717111617326736,
0.4123932123184204,
0.12913309037685394,
0.5360212922096252,
-0.05953548103570938,
-0.017949970439076424,
0.38109225034713745,
-0.03130513057112694,
0.3426940143108368,
0.3492622375488281,
-0.4128337502479553,
-0.2977622449398041,
1.1845228672027588,
0.18426966667175293,
0.5818262696266174,
0.34802281856536865,
0.23265743255615234,
-0.28138524293899536,
-0.38259977102279663,
-0.16995082795619965,
0.6909085512161255,
-1.0795022249221802,
-0.3250580132007599,
-0.586363673210144,
-0.10105148702859879,
-0.3604864776134491,
-0.11426674574613571,
-0.1518426537513733,
-0.472159743309021,
-0.5406518578529358,
-0.2867506742477417,
0.41475167870521545,
0.683077871799469,
0.15242284536361694,
0.5197383761405945,
-0.5884842276573181,
0.25640374422073364,
0.11996324360370636,
0.33620011806488037,
0.24417012929916382,
-0.44836777448654175,
-0.17023569345474243,
-0.04590227082371712,
-0.348840594291687,
-0.8148722052574158,
0.3781466484069824,
0.3155917823314667,
0.40522316098213196,
0.18399961292743683,
0.18999391794204712,
0.48282840847969055,
-0.665277361869812,
0.496297687292099,
0.2910689413547516,
-1.073935627937317,
0.3398391306400299,
-0.3483788073062897,
-0.09808036684989929,
0.23169675469398499,
0.5919798612594604,
-0.37173038721084595,
-0.6435737013816833,
-0.43284815549850464,
-0.8689513802528381,
0.691167950630188,
-0.06549976766109467,
0.27861663699150085,
-0.21898037195205688,
0.3620033264160156,
0.051543161273002625,
0.052572544664144516,
-1.25481116771698,
-0.16760574281215668,
-0.17513689398765564,
-0.5866352319717407,
-0.23005184531211853,
0.006632000673562288,
-0.052652034908533096,
-0.3753012418746948,
0.5734314322471619,
-0.4788662791252136,
-0.27019912004470825,
-0.0685122162103653,
-0.37782320380210876,
0.012280418537557125,
0.16866086423397064,
-0.056683458387851715,
0.6514133810997009,
0.01375949289649725,
0.659958004951477,
0.0557844303548336,
-0.17635411024093628,
0.14434564113616943,
0.16132129728794098,
-0.1467423439025879,
0.053168561309576035,
0.6054337620735168,
0.8408191204071045,
0.009232335723936558,
-0.5877299308776855,
0.5609322190284729,
0.18166381120681763,
-0.036138225346803665,
0.12593655288219452,
-0.11412966251373291,
0.4941401183605194,
0.11529721319675446,
0.1550714075565338,
-0.3027638792991638,
-0.30651137232780457,
-0.4937482476234436,
0.09259803593158722,
0.5078624486923218,
-0.2627667784690857,
-0.3768274486064911,
0.5994513630867004,
0.2599010765552521,
-0.27386751770973206,
0.4265637993812561,
-0.3789811432361603,
-0.7446261644363403,
0.4992017149925232,
0.953518807888031,
0.7204671502113342,
-0.12534253299236298,
0.45640692114830017,
0.3812420070171356,
0.31451481580734253,
0.029871784150600433,
-0.21446576714515686,
0.0001361290633212775,
-0.7186516523361206,
-0.7093594670295715,
-0.6128499507904053,
-0.2122226059436798,
-0.15159930288791656,
-0.4077913165092468,
0.3399506211280823,
-0.3775244355201721,
-0.26816707849502563,
0.5180060863494873,
-0.07396408915519714,
-0.39629030227661133,
-0.10243197530508041,
0.18220360577106476,
0.6294133067131042,
-1.0358752012252808,
1.1670396327972412,
0.5566720962524414,
-0.5792864561080933,
-1.0362862348556519,
-0.11973220854997635,
-0.35071346163749695,
-0.8637101650238037,
0.8509528040885925,
0.25975391268730164,
-0.009751970879733562,
0.4297280013561249,
-0.7151062488555908,
-0.5868716239929199,
1.0287333726882935,
0.807909369468689,
-0.5430127382278442,
-0.16907022893428802,
0.10734859853982925,
0.537574052810669,
-0.4120655059814453,
0.13780845701694489,
0.39702051877975464,
0.05022904649376869,
0.3647327423095703,
-0.8009015321731567,
0.05814974009990692,
0.31344014406204224,
0.0031506626401096582,
0.43221044540405273,
-0.6090788841247559,
1.0670706033706665,
-0.23511523008346558,
-0.47270089387893677,
-0.06472073495388031,
0.44998234510421753,
-0.01761596091091633,
0.1631496101617813,
0.33064284920692444,
0.6667884588241577,
1.0059436559677124,
-0.0437740720808506,
1.0230860710144043,
-0.12302136421203613,
0.7435153722763062,
1.378699541091919,
-0.7232078909873962,
0.7943987250328064,
0.3437957167625427,
-0.0889056846499443,
0.7767524719238281,
0.38916343450546265,
-0.007428391836583614,
0.26268547773361206,
0.2556145191192627,
-0.3781597912311554,
-0.5548970699310303,
-0.3524932563304901,
-0.03712256997823715,
0.37593507766723633,
0.1775737851858139,
-0.4940836727619171,
-0.6115434169769287,
-0.09244894981384277,
0.19670747220516205,
0.30483996868133545,
-0.23517972230911255,
0.7555228471755981,
0.2927563488483429,
-0.46727168560028076,
0.5577495694160461,
0.17928937077522278,
0.23774360120296478,
-0.5819247961044312,
-0.004454063717275858,
0.04661779850721359,
0.3276718258857727,
-0.1806698888540268,
-0.7213063836097717,
0.08163903653621674,
0.23254188895225525,
-0.176541268825531,
-0.21210941672325134,
0.8878450393676758,
-0.5793014168739319,
-0.5772899389266968,
0.42213085293769836,
0.31488779187202454,
0.012245242483913898,
0.23099979758262634,
-0.38394895195961,
-0.017640916630625725,
-0.1211857795715332,
0.012945626862347126,
0.3096669316291809,
0.5834178328514099,
-0.017994431778788567,
0.7734357118606567,
0.5936965346336365,
0.028903212398290634,
-0.08058766275644302,
0.2803729176521301,
1.1581244468688965,
-0.4277071952819824,
-0.40576159954071045,
-1.2389531135559082,
0.3381447494029999,
-0.17213116586208344,
0.1803121715784073,
0.9309319257736206,
0.4956134259700775,
0.8592586517333984,
0.2347227782011032,
0.8286322951316833,
0.10845500975847244,
0.3656400144100189,
-0.4444029927253723,
0.6938573122024536,
-0.39898985624313354,
0.16087248921394348,
-0.3801359534263611,
-0.9012373685836792,
-0.34974610805511475,
0.6999155282974243,
-0.31388208270072937,
-0.03602822124958038,
0.5750887989997864,
0.3894936740398407,
0.07818039506673813,
-0.19953718781471252,
0.1707378476858139,
0.32604819536209106,
0.5191882848739624,
0.7722293138504028,
0.9306374788284302,
-0.15966114401817322,
0.4176896810531616,
0.14417359232902527,
-0.2745211720466614,
0.02998272329568863,
-1.1315345764160156,
-1.4051244258880615,
-0.5051689147949219,
-0.3620014786720276,
-0.4613647758960724,
-0.5081941485404968,
0.8535045981407166,
0.5154892206192017,
-0.24651987850666046,
-0.05857783555984497,
-0.1134469136595726,
0.46272212266921997,
0.19613946974277496,
-0.14573031663894653,
0.3420535624027252,
-0.30918997526168823,
-0.7143833637237549,
0.015403250232338905,
0.2735568881034851,
0.16561390459537506,
-0.26395905017852783,
-0.08395237475633621,
-0.16411429643630981,
0.17814971506595612,
0.5811582207679749,
0.09465067088603973,
-0.7092400789260864,
-0.39594972133636475,
-0.18987983465194702,
-0.2535199820995331,
0.11358463019132614,
0.7256656289100647,
-0.8210879564285278,
0.5087637901306152,
0.35356536507606506,
0.5747037529945374,
0.6357589960098267,
-0.022298825904726982,
0.3217259645462036,
-1.1477538347244263,
0.4225674271583557,
0.19994370639324188,
0.5356274247169495,
0.43776223063468933,
0.035856787115335464,
0.3295556306838989,
0.4681083559989929,
-0.3742358386516571,
-1.256395936012268,
0.5930966138839722,
-0.8989188075065613,
-0.46799442172050476,
1.221070408821106,
-0.5999479293823242,
-0.2552904784679413,
0.10673414170742035,
-0.2700938880443573,
0.39239078760147095,
-0.006506358273327351,
0.24639661610126495,
0.6811467409133911,
0.3602907955646515,
0.05617471784353256,
-0.054805416613817215,
0.22135362029075623,
-0.07020362466573715,
-0.7118769884109497,
0.5069183707237244,
0.5835102796554565,
0.36418765783309937,
0.08337585628032684,
0.685387909412384,
0.18314097821712494,
-0.25735801458358765,
0.012550650164484978,
0.07274632900953293,
-0.24448300898075104,
-0.37328818440437317,
-0.20230267941951752,
0.11030979454517365,
0.41078120470046997,
0.10492361336946487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12011v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12011v3 | A Systematic Comparison of Contextualized Word Embeddings for Lexical Semantic Change | 2024-02-19T10:04:59 | 2024-03-08T14:50:40 | Francesco Periti, Nina Tahmasebi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Contextualized embeddings are the preferred tool for modeling Lexical
Semantic Change (LSC). Current evaluations typically focus on a specific task
known as Graded Change Detection (GCD). However, performance comparison across
work are often misleading due to their reliance on diverse settings. In this
paper, we evaluate state-of-the-art models and approaches for GCD under equal
conditions. We further break the LSC problem into Word-in-Context (WiC) and
Word Sense Induction (WSI) tasks, and compare models across these different
levels. Our evaluation is performed across different languages on eight
available benchmarks for LSC, and shows that (i) APD outperforms other
approaches for GCD; (ii) XL-LEXEME outperforms other contextualized models for
WiC, WSI, and GCD, while being comparable to GPT-4; (iii) there is a clear need
for improving the modeling of word meanings, as well as focus on how, when, and
why these meanings change, rather than solely focusing on the extent of
semantic change. | [
-0.20691922307014465,
-0.6245787143707275,
0.7277845740318298,
-0.029128391295671463,
-0.2568683624267578,
-0.26766932010650635,
-0.3859187662601471,
-0.46266070008277893,
-0.03841005638241768,
0.04991629347205162,
-0.39410141110420227,
-0.7380778789520264,
-0.8241742253303528,
0.1705550253391266,
-0.469196617603302,
0.6771525740623474,
-0.4659324884414673,
0.23076468706130981,
-0.13994118571281433,
-0.40596890449523926,
-0.7637456655502319,
-0.1902204304933548,
-0.35911670327186584,
-0.3963123559951782,
0.38130590319633484,
-0.008319678716361523,
0.8235064148902893,
0.349899023771286,
0.4665343463420868,
0.26320281624794006,
-0.5195203423500061,
0.12094531953334808,
-0.10793405026197433,
0.11590921133756638,
-0.4781133830547333,
-0.1545102894306183,
-0.17897844314575195,
0.19885830581188202,
0.48272162675857544,
0.9595844149589539,
-0.3958137333393097,
-0.0033769775182008743,
0.03433948755264282,
0.4030541181564331,
-1.1231096982955933,
0.3052537739276886,
-0.816550612449646,
0.13452430069446564,
0.07727659493684769,
0.09080947190523148,
-0.3802223801612854,
-0.16729441285133362,
0.10937807708978653,
-0.7726976275444031,
0.10005677491426468,
-0.07836773246526718,
0.6529843211174011,
0.2666708528995514,
-0.39801985025405884,
-0.7029218077659607,
-0.43930426239967346,
0.7039812207221985,
-0.7508443593978882,
0.8437700867652893,
0.22646982967853546,
0.16392016410827637,
-0.038218434900045395,
-0.7194510102272034,
-0.609049916267395,
-0.4664500951766968,
0.06555387377738953,
0.3830706775188446,
-0.15982644259929657,
-0.04447343200445175,
0.300850510597229,
0.33355712890625,
-0.12014991790056229,
0.1177678257226944,
-0.0906987115740776,
-0.14894598722457886,
0.2990204989910126,
0.18660709261894226,
0.34877344965934753,
-0.1690259426832199,
-0.352904736995697,
-0.41320160031318665,
-0.6461302638053894,
0.1475185602903366,
-0.030726570636034012,
0.21130679547786713,
-0.07757788151502609,
0.5234605669975281,
-0.3554580807685852,
0.7650901079177856,
0.049228403717279434,
-0.23795640468597412,
0.278474360704422,
-0.595170795917511,
-0.30897870659828186,
0.18905693292617798,
0.05735952779650688,
0.602776825428009,
0.163974329829216,
-0.3070215582847595,
-0.43345046043395996,
0.7666061520576477,
0.06348808109760284,
-0.6572301983833313,
0.055022358894348145,
-0.04341157153248787,
-0.3806515038013458,
-0.11581463366746902,
0.050504136830568314,
-0.148838073015213,
-0.46399790048599243,
-0.6924777626991272,
0.3076768219470978,
-0.6112012267112732,
-0.18897251784801483,
0.3579084575176239,
-0.3603948652744293,
0.3598726987838745,
0.6360906362533569,
-0.7308576703071594,
0.2491084188222885,
0.7637518644332886,
0.822078287601471,
-0.4410640299320221,
-0.22373908758163452,
-0.26022711396217346,
0.00003998163447249681,
-0.7576420903205872,
0.817692756652832,
-0.8025813698768616,
-0.4095451831817627,
0.2812260091304779,
0.0777142122387886,
-0.2777995765209198,
-0.6500061750411987,
0.38394007086753845,
-0.5124949812889099,
0.09606204926967621,
-0.6303631663322449,
-0.9043177366256714,
0.15340636670589447,
0.4523388147354126,
-0.4369482696056366,
1.097880244255066,
0.2809198200702667,
-1.034559965133667,
0.9715693593025208,
-0.7184965014457703,
-0.07417701184749603,
0.0227041095495224,
0.139903724193573,
-0.0049735442735254765,
0.4552168846130371,
0.2157776802778244,
0.1768580973148346,
0.18272490799427032,
0.3594186007976532,
-0.158196359872818,
-0.5773053765296936,
0.1506783813238144,
-0.04741790518164635,
0.4033167362213135,
0.2902728021144867,
-0.3821939527988434,
0.1218772605061531,
-0.5211184620857239,
0.019494257867336273,
-0.11297252774238586,
-0.21771404147148132,
-0.8061479330062866,
0.2604748010635376,
-0.10304040461778641,
0.2617419958114624,
0.11223362386226654,
-0.8806926012039185,
0.09775058925151825,
-0.2734934389591217,
0.5088448524475098,
0.6958400011062622,
-0.228504478931427,
0.560675859451294,
-0.0687231495976448,
0.14850452542304993,
0.38666221499443054,
0.14343330264091492,
-0.171260803937912,
-0.5407332181930542,
-0.49699994921684265,
-0.08821435272693634,
0.4242573082447052,
0.34410959482192993,
-0.7316873073577881,
0.2483910620212555,
-0.25139954686164856,
-0.2943418323993683,
-0.3975367546081543,
-0.15005141496658325,
0.17472489178180695,
0.4027253985404968,
0.6999103426933289,
-0.4456525146961212,
0.04206472262740135,
-0.600315511226654,
-0.5462198257446289,
-0.005496553611010313,
-0.11374656111001968,
0.10636026412248611,
0.5228273868560791,
-0.4154658913612366,
1.0227375030517578,
-0.4310508370399475,
-0.2321772426366806,
-0.1341804563999176,
0.04020356386899948,
-0.15497322380542755,
0.210836261510849,
0.3195517063140869,
-0.5749876499176025,
-0.19036300480365753,
0.06888556480407715,
-0.5497905015945435,
-0.21845802664756775,
0.060366902500391006,
0.04508179798722267,
0.16580316424369812,
0.8136196732521057,
-0.22834210097789764,
0.8550341725349426,
0.5934575200080872,
-0.7169790267944336,
0.43765655159950256,
-0.27774420380592346,
0.19073639810085297,
-0.780559241771698,
-0.27968916296958923,
-0.06414063274860382,
-0.08538567274808884,
-0.6521291136741638,
0.3064277470111847,
0.6055029034614563,
0.08722828328609467,
-0.6597962379455566,
0.5819381475448608,
-0.37639448046684265,
-0.3525262773036957,
-0.1085948497056961,
0.49977439641952515,
-0.05061246454715729,
0.20904070138931274,
0.11637243628501892,
0.6868353486061096,
0.3208138346672058,
-0.560352087020874,
0.05164787545800209,
0.14772929251194,
-0.8236211538314819,
0.5006564855575562,
-0.5535473227500916,
-0.02117127552628517,
-0.16560664772987366,
0.42165350914001465,
-0.7961700558662415,
0.18156754970550537,
0.09417854994535446,
-0.1489514261484146,
0.06617087870836258,
0.2632884085178375,
-0.5989638566970825,
-0.151800274848938,
-0.32417985796928406,
0.5563670992851257,
0.2625020444393158,
-0.8246948719024658,
0.2783055305480957,
0.01509418897330761,
0.1221727505326271,
-0.19028884172439575,
-0.6562477946281433,
0.10839521139860153,
-0.16336777806282043,
-0.6131486892700195,
0.9765084385871887,
-0.07000108808279037,
-0.528907060623169,
0.24493204057216644,
-0.1642245650291443,
0.13912971317768097,
0.14953076839447021,
-0.030847106128931046,
-0.07234536111354828,
-0.02600068226456642,
0.3733663856983185,
0.21269679069519043,
-0.0361739806830883,
-0.191885307431221,
-0.18421171605587006,
0.40842634439468384,
-0.14227959513664246,
-0.43303826451301575,
-0.35046544671058655,
0.30493810772895813,
0.31919553875923157,
-0.2712160348892212,
0.8302599191665649,
0.7163211107254028,
-0.47268491983413696,
-0.08669223636388779,
-0.4920157194137573,
-0.15645726025104523,
-0.38433268666267395,
0.36496230959892273,
-0.29200759530067444,
-0.9567623138427734,
0.4666222631931305,
-0.2059134691953659,
0.02114040218293667,
0.29184091091156006,
0.5776272416114807,
0.2181205302476883,
1.1019097566604614,
0.7143897414207458,
0.2175453007221222,
0.6779347062110901,
-0.01433700229972601,
0.2915586233139038,
-1.1810792684555054,
-0.08264372497797012,
-0.2651820778846741,
-0.19913940131664276,
-0.6710635423660278,
-0.471666157245636,
0.48317694664001465,
0.1962609589099884,
-0.11904499679803848,
0.23449544608592987,
-0.40556320548057556,
0.2155231386423111,
0.042895931750535965,
-0.035358916968107224,
0.3045399785041809,
-0.05385322868824005,
-0.48474815487861633,
-0.0948144868016243,
-0.4633742868900299,
-0.41577717661857605,
0.9122441411018372,
0.21737511456012726,
0.675239086151123,
0.2556226849555969,
0.5555073618888855,
0.34698668122291565,
0.7172945141792297,
-0.8907397389411926,
0.4728780686855316,
-0.184645876288414,
-0.10238564759492874,
-0.28957808017730713,
-0.04594863951206207,
-0.9267816543579102,
0.7915090918540955,
-0.11806339025497437,
-0.7060593962669373,
0.2372330129146576,
-0.13813528418540955,
0.07464396953582764,
0.49084410071372986,
-0.707433819770813,
0.7880059480667114,
0.2988815903663635,
-0.13710923492908478,
-0.4346136450767517,
-0.07631586492061615,
0.1266838163137436,
0.10107538849115372,
0.31288594007492065,
-0.24742986261844635,
-0.2283172309398651,
0.6574686169624329,
-0.6042149662971497,
0.5261613130569458,
-0.4653797447681427,
-0.48089471459388733,
0.24938002228736877,
0.08890122920274734,
0.43530070781707764,
-0.054923318326473236,
-0.2184617668390274,
0.17678789794445038,
0.27352920174598694,
-0.27379149198532104,
-0.5619825720787048,
0.7085953950881958,
-0.555633008480072,
-0.5402597188949585,
-0.35786888003349304,
-0.6375685334205627,
-0.2314162254333496,
-0.23508520424365997,
0.18496179580688477,
0.6933994889259338,
-0.3022094964981079,
-0.04859089478850365,
0.26166123151779175,
-0.35158923268318176,
0.5497615337371826,
0.37759900093078613,
-0.08662375062704086,
0.07764969766139984,
0.39433637261390686,
0.14694662392139435,
0.46988800168037415,
0.045601192861795425,
0.3922620713710785,
-0.2940867841243744,
-0.3332826495170593,
-0.24836745858192444,
0.07411780953407288,
-0.9766627550125122,
0.033934835344552994,
-0.33844611048698425,
0.1989860236644745,
-0.5701968669891357,
-0.49921637773513794,
-0.23388554155826569,
-0.15106931328773499,
0.06544271856546402,
-0.05093184486031532,
0.2542833983898163,
0.8865962624549866,
-0.10856803506612778,
-0.025121480226516724,
-0.20557455718517303,
0.07728066295385361,
0.2344202995300293,
0.2858227491378784,
-0.08485262095928192,
-0.5031133890151978,
-0.10501742362976074,
0.09700668603181839,
-0.3430182635784149,
-1.0229870080947876,
0.32926785945892334,
0.29835522174835205,
0.44183021783828735,
0.34380942583084106,
-0.049580395221710205,
0.6147237420082092,
-0.5739624500274658,
0.9717490673065186,
0.25316399335861206,
-1.2786179780960083,
0.551361620426178,
0.018223175778985023,
0.6766487956047058,
0.3649316728115082,
0.11186350882053375,
-0.9770918488502502,
-0.3553307354450226,
-0.4032304584980011,
-0.6735705137252808,
0.3687079846858978,
-0.12687447667121887,
0.12914495170116425,
-0.38740456104278564,
0.24476005136966705,
0.06385928392410278,
-0.007448744494467974,
-0.5022898316383362,
0.22478380799293518,
-0.3025408983230591,
-0.11473356187343597,
-0.006543364841490984,
-0.14748097956180573,
0.101217120885849,
-0.37203043699264526,
0.20846550166606903,
-0.2548844814300537,
0.24446268379688263,
0.5296591520309448,
-0.6126646995544434,
0.2011754810810089,
0.5252259969711304,
0.5924768447875977,
0.8117821216583252,
-0.06561361998319626,
0.22232858836650848,
0.6580431461334229,
-0.37434837222099304,
-0.11613570153713226,
-0.30945512652397156,
-0.25077319145202637,
0.20054754614830017,
0.6283106207847595,
0.853801965713501,
0.763371467590332,
-0.4449393153190613,
0.633140504360199,
-0.07167856395244598,
-0.2147323042154312,
-0.16144759953022003,
-0.11917704343795776,
0.06819169968366623,
-0.08533644676208496,
0.0013372546527534723,
-0.03718046844005585,
0.1790887713432312,
-0.6744269132614136,
-0.06095058470964432,
0.3654995858669281,
-0.6658372282981873,
-0.3001621663570404,
0.2896825075149536,
-0.1889907270669937,
0.11149023473262787,
0.5140916705131531,
-0.47606921195983887,
-0.5248396992683411,
0.5159426927566528,
0.6971040964126587,
0.5790677666664124,
-0.36583206057548523,
0.20617394149303436,
0.4021545946598053,
0.1273183971643448,
-0.10316193848848343,
-0.060737378895282745,
-0.45783475041389465,
-1.1985430717468262,
-0.22728681564331055,
-0.5366697907447815,
-0.470750093460083,
-0.2034132331609726,
-0.9043790102005005,
0.2383614331483841,
-0.3459654748439789,
-0.16822820901870728,
-0.03766530379652977,
-0.2468436360359192,
-0.9313536882400513,
0.16069957613945007,
0.2509199380874634,
1.0443472862243652,
-0.8735830187797546,
0.8658121824264526,
0.8402047753334045,
0.045639898627996445,
-0.6623489856719971,
0.21979595720767975,
-0.034357327967882156,
-0.6881095170974731,
0.7392765283584595,
0.2766313850879669,
-0.15172359347343445,
-0.20927047729492188,
-0.45532700419425964,
-0.758848249912262,
1.3492112159729004,
-0.15948769450187683,
-0.42761772871017456,
0.185085728764534,
0.0056629423052072525,
0.6339513063430786,
-0.5094226002693176,
0.37209683656692505,
0.7898722290992737,
0.5589773058891296,
-0.07229769229888916,
-0.773855984210968,
-0.052622102200984955,
0.04327232390642166,
0.4310041666030884,
0.11084321141242981,
-0.1027783751487732,
1.0373950004577637,
-0.05097261071205139,
-0.6837753057479858,
-0.030355023220181465,
0.5118419528007507,
0.2652498185634613,
0.27901214361190796,
0.8787484765052795,
0.7942735552787781,
0.6601102948188782,
-0.36658188700675964,
1.2232463359832764,
-0.48502761125564575,
0.4497428238391876,
0.7541868090629578,
-0.5726632475852966,
0.9634616374969482,
0.3638107180595398,
-0.16538317501544952,
0.7345921397209167,
0.6851232051849365,
0.3209291696548462,
0.8565061688423157,
0.3727743625640869,
-0.22749318182468414,
-0.24517062306404114,
-0.2853306829929352,
-0.5563284158706665,
0.3860452473163605,
0.6539047956466675,
-0.11697071045637131,
-0.6288731694221497,
0.08252492547035217,
0.16265685856342316,
0.21726444363594055,
-0.5733984708786011,
0.7372056245803833,
0.0895964577794075,
-0.7855716943740845,
0.5812731385231018,
0.5011417865753174,
0.9848700761795044,
-0.48381394147872925,
0.2643031179904938,
-0.3806473910808563,
0.30515041947364807,
-0.03607102483510971,
-0.5616899132728577,
0.352139949798584,
-0.051073428243398666,
-0.012722654268145561,
-0.23829640448093414,
0.773003101348877,
-0.46880918741226196,
-0.47300243377685547,
0.8276476860046387,
0.38037383556365967,
-0.23843300342559814,
0.000783750438131392,
-0.7123494148254395,
0.32264959812164307,
-0.3645888566970825,
-0.06366937607526779,
0.38787245750427246,
0.28089913725852966,
-0.5517340898513794,
0.32847651839256287,
0.5830535292625427,
0.07751204073429108,
0.1340942531824112,
0.5426547527313232,
0.7806649208068848,
-0.5558778047561646,
-0.6512212753295898,
-0.4468592703342438,
0.16810105741024017,
0.03348004072904587,
-0.5339957475662231,
0.4694264829158783,
-0.022431835532188416,
1.0166932344436646,
-0.04476913437247276,
0.41435614228248596,
0.13488858938217163,
0.17123186588287354,
-0.7474824786186218,
0.268270343542099,
-0.6838821172714233,
0.06997977197170258,
-0.5793076157569885,
-1.0474224090576172,
-0.3039517104625702,
0.6892114281654358,
-0.4673895239830017,
-0.06522843986749649,
1.1993346214294434,
0.8373656272888184,
-0.028485629707574844,
0.22309529781341553,
0.44922199845314026,
0.10629995912313461,
0.26263123750686646,
0.47626641392707825,
0.9762887954711914,
-0.373531311750412,
-0.13183778524398804,
-0.10214832425117493,
-0.302525132894516,
0.012059512548148632,
-0.9911061525344849,
-0.512053906917572,
-0.7878270149230957,
-0.6039546728134155,
-0.14235904812812805,
0.2057795524597168,
0.7278406620025635,
0.440286248922348,
-0.8354530930519104,
0.06206320598721504,
-0.1009964793920517,
-0.007978479377925396,
-0.5138214230537415,
-0.16845542192459106,
0.4666634798049927,
-0.5752245783805847,
-0.6361536383628845,
0.6517166495323181,
0.3001798093318939,
-0.3890823721885681,
-0.1971297264099121,
-0.02215699478983879,
0.07494732737541199,
0.23297560214996338,
0.9609946012496948,
-0.18391095101833344,
-1.1741455793380737,
-0.7986221313476562,
-0.23588816821575165,
-0.1996322125196457,
-0.140735924243927,
0.896312415599823,
-0.8406951427459717,
0.3261777460575104,
0.46609070897102356,
0.40653637051582336,
0.3940943777561188,
-0.1504746675491333,
0.14717254042625427,
-0.4520799517631531,
0.2621404528617859,
-0.33965086936950684,
0.6878134608268738,
0.503746509552002,
0.024947479367256165,
0.6320970058441162,
0.3070526421070099,
-0.21853403747081757,
-0.6668140888214111,
0.3136163353919983,
-0.7211731672286987,
-0.48852968215942383,
1.3409305810928345,
-0.11261104047298431,
-0.04914591833949089,
0.0268313717097044,
0.008786767721176147,
0.09044381231069565,
-0.12130142003297806,
0.5662080645561218,
0.7864382266998291,
0.08541170507669449,
0.27632731199264526,
-0.40033701062202454,
0.482716828584671,
0.5265528559684753,
-0.5514917373657227,
-0.21212004125118256,
0.4063152074813843,
0.40076279640197754,
0.1063712015748024,
0.44198328256607056,
-0.38011229038238525,
0.10953693836927414,
-0.1832991987466812,
0.12229182571172714,
0.09319280833005905,
-0.14273250102996826,
-0.4063614308834076,
-0.045454755425453186,
-0.05967753008008003,
0.06297101080417633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12419v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12419v1 | EBFT: Effective and Block-Wise Fine-Tuning for Sparse LLMs | 2024-02-19T09:55:32 | 2024-02-19T09:55:32 | Song Guo, Fan Wu, Lei Zhang, Xiawu Zheng, Shengchuan Zhang, Fei Chao, Yiyu Shi, Rongrong Ji | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Existing methods for fine-tuning sparse LLMs often suffer from
resource-intensive requirements and high retraining costs. Additionally, many
fine-tuning methods often rely on approximations or heuristic optimization
strategies, which may lead to suboptimal solutions. To address these issues, we
propose an efficient and fast framework for fine-tuning sparse LLMs based on
minimizing reconstruction error. Our approach involves sampling a small dataset
for calibration and utilizing backpropagation to iteratively optimize
block-wise reconstruction error, on a block-by-block basis, aiming for optimal
solutions. Extensive experiments on various benchmarks consistently demonstrate
the superiority of our method over other baselines. For instance, on the
Wikitext2 dataset with LlamaV1-7B at 70% sparsity, our proposed EBFT achieves a
perplexity of 16.88, surpassing the state-of-the-art DSnoT with a perplexity of
75.14. Moreover, with a structured sparsity ratio of 26\%, EBFT achieves a
perplexity of 16.27, outperforming LoRA (perplexity 16.44). Furthermore, the
fine-tuning process of EBFT for LlamaV1-7B only takes approximately 30 minutes,
and the entire framework can be executed on a single 16GB GPU. The source code
is available at https://github.com/sunggo/EBFT. | [
-0.5604568123817444,
-1.0243512392044067,
0.33959758281707764,
0.2970329225063324,
-0.6502369046211243,
0.05769135430455208,
-0.19113174080848694,
-0.16009892523288727,
0.34165704250335693,
0.19376394152641296,
-0.9682802557945251,
-0.15735630691051483,
-0.4710802733898163,
0.01975979097187519,
-0.2367068976163864,
0.8414925336837769,
-0.10403510183095932,
-0.13648882508277893,
0.226236030459404,
0.01481582596898079,
-0.461119681596756,
0.19486400485038757,
-0.7212467789649963,
-0.2494579255580902,
0.5782052278518677,
0.4969455599784851,
0.3015604615211487,
0.7806938886642456,
0.3334069550037384,
0.27250009775161743,
-0.18947432935237885,
0.6472232341766357,
-1.2129735946655273,
-0.06516443192958832,
-0.14122048020362854,
0.08912325650453568,
-0.2701936662197113,
-0.6043222546577454,
0.4743649959564209,
0.6584491729736328,
-0.44175079464912415,
0.2941574454307556,
0.2279682457447052,
0.8893844485282898,
-0.5018376708030701,
-0.10164907574653625,
-0.8385358452796936,
-0.12147469073534012,
0.06276688724756241,
-0.5930129885673523,
0.08019648492336273,
-0.32974153757095337,
-0.20228268206119537,
-0.8592966198921204,
0.5454962849617004,
0.4820239543914795,
0.9056789875030518,
0.937993049621582,
-0.015784326940774918,
0.3515267074108124,
-0.24287474155426025,
0.6567438244819641,
-0.33250692486763,
0.3480978012084961,
0.34359490871429443,
0.18289385735988617,
-0.40790247917175293,
-0.5316208004951477,
-0.10306110978126526,
0.21159067749977112,
0.11362600326538086,
0.09627219289541245,
-0.1661534607410431,
0.32226231694221497,
0.4179527163505554,
0.3451424539089203,
-0.6678946018218994,
0.21388041973114014,
-0.1499917358160019,
-0.38701462745666504,
0.2896878719329834,
0.24247244000434875,
-0.4856150150299072,
-0.014699469320476055,
-0.4456454813480377,
0.2475103735923767,
-0.8939245939254761,
-0.30852991342544556,
0.39351218938827515,
0.31636255979537964,
-0.005373372696340084,
0.3795090615749359,
-0.37031126022338867,
1.0725921392440796,
0.4577828347682953,
-0.24064867198467255,
-0.01784181222319603,
-0.3703422546386719,
-0.5063469409942627,
0.036274611949920654,
0.16286127269268036,
0.3182229697704315,
0.04518163576722145,
0.014730822294950485,
-0.5562624931335449,
-0.1584528237581253,
0.17983250319957733,
-1.1111406087875366,
-0.3167227804660797,
0.15215744078159332,
-0.22158965468406677,
-0.1798924058675766,
-0.31382206082344055,
-0.6553540825843811,
-0.34807226061820984,
-0.41470134258270264,
0.7366620898246765,
-0.2408958524465561,
-0.005496918223798275,
0.29756230115890503,
0.2189699113368988,
0.16170231997966766,
0.7223936915397644,
-1.0026187896728516,
0.43497514724731445,
0.7590963840484619,
0.856235682964325,
-0.06458819657564163,
-0.10291490703821182,
-0.7872166037559509,
-0.04920840635895729,
-0.33994126319885254,
0.9423971772193909,
0.2707976698875427,
-0.23821769654750824,
-0.3927880525588989,
-0.040437258780002594,
0.019465729594230652,
-0.6261943578720093,
0.27243077754974365,
-0.21064159274101257,
-0.6942845582962036,
-0.11712317913770676,
-0.3293244540691376,
-0.15856778621673584,
0.36612531542778015,
-0.5446584224700928,
0.9819610714912415,
0.3335641026496887,
-0.37939774990081787,
0.2799294590950012,
-0.022674918174743652,
-0.42891138792037964,
-0.1752738207578659,
0.08449950814247131,
-0.6230362057685852,
0.3612200915813446,
0.3003578186035156,
0.4599091112613678,
-0.43923714756965637,
0.09321439266204834,
-0.2979908287525177,
-0.9803892970085144,
-0.13621185719966888,
-0.4386615455150604,
0.2695996165275574,
0.2089887112379074,
-0.34060171246528625,
0.017425894737243652,
-1.0716670751571655,
0.12525856494903564,
-0.003147813957184553,
-0.36654067039489746,
-0.08580541610717773,
-0.3330278992652893,
0.2550881505012512,
-0.347859650850296,
0.08719654381275177,
-0.5358378887176514,
0.15091373026371002,
-0.5114036202430725,
0.36795729398727417,
1.1102772951126099,
-0.004685576073825359,
0.05804278701543808,
-0.6806305646896362,
0.19544604420661926,
-0.49256569147109985,
0.04834844172000885,
-0.021854693070054054,
-0.24445562064647675,
-0.6617385745048523,
-0.9158260822296143,
0.27191779017448425,
0.3747880160808563,
-0.2980978488922119,
0.47516340017318726,
-0.17030586302280426,
-0.2502101957798004,
-0.587647020816803,
0.36654505133628845,
0.3766358196735382,
0.5828078985214233,
0.4510221481323242,
-0.2032560408115387,
-0.6328431963920593,
-0.7896644473075867,
-0.025947535410523415,
0.16706636548042297,
0.2667197287082672,
0.503401517868042,
0.4817558825016022,
-0.10612305998802185,
0.5185156464576721,
-0.5867645144462585,
-0.39796820282936096,
0.17221781611442566,
-0.04854196682572365,
0.3295402526855469,
0.6998196244239807,
0.16034668684005737,
-0.5438309907913208,
-0.3651904761791229,
-0.034190259873867035,
-0.17525604367256165,
-0.36041292548179626,
-0.12941253185272217,
-0.2463717758655548,
0.11430982500314713,
0.290802001953125,
-0.290397584438324,
0.43767881393432617,
0.43447861075401306,
-0.06957309693098068,
0.2437911033630371,
-0.3681955337524414,
0.1371680349111557,
-1.0066992044448853,
-0.022180356085300446,
-0.14073900878429413,
-0.626492440700531,
-0.1176254153251648,
-0.0879797711968422,
0.06829420477151871,
0.2014445811510086,
-0.22803129255771637,
0.28844863176345825,
-0.4169924557209015,
-0.21893100440502167,
-0.29470503330230713,
-0.06362614035606384,
-0.005797242280095816,
0.6340937614440918,
-0.2755686640739441,
0.5113980174064636,
0.16207699477672577,
-0.23304975032806396,
0.5398580431938171,
0.09282451868057251,
-0.33857017755508423,
0.7878788709640503,
-0.6258687973022461,
0.1467587947845459,
-0.19364629685878754,
0.10032390803098679,
-1.0820765495300293,
-0.2721692621707916,
0.20609717071056366,
-0.22711396217346191,
0.8374107480049133,
-0.4268732964992523,
-0.40241187810897827,
0.0057858857326209545,
-0.38695693016052246,
0.441774845123291,
0.42393383383750916,
-0.7795013785362244,
0.4332975149154663,
0.13902372121810913,
0.04514855146408081,
-0.7651311159133911,
-0.6373375654220581,
-0.39298808574676514,
-0.026133019477128983,
-0.5642544627189636,
0.3411780893802643,
-0.19079165160655975,
0.12535922229290009,
-0.004557518288493156,
-0.6166958212852478,
-0.11574672907590866,
0.2423378825187683,
0.30310899019241333,
-0.032306719571352005,
-0.012380829080939293,
-0.2493966519832611,
0.35722681879997253,
-0.26785406470298767,
-0.6461975574493408,
-0.33697575330734253,
0.4516153931617737,
-0.32469430565834045,
-0.5298842787742615,
-0.2971091568470001,
0.11712635308504105,
0.04445028677582741,
0.32507553696632385,
0.33894118666648865,
0.6112199425697327,
-0.6934618949890137,
-0.4907180070877075,
-0.8095756769180298,
-0.20876936614513397,
-0.4596436321735382,
0.7754484415054321,
-0.4283434748649597,
-0.8820340037345886,
0.38367751240730286,
-0.2211805284023285,
-0.03999544680118561,
-0.015352335758507252,
0.6469270586967468,
-0.2891903221607208,
0.5851136445999146,
0.649197518825531,
0.058477066457271576,
0.42043960094451904,
-0.4791429340839386,
-0.15415680408477783,
-0.787161648273468,
-0.10520778596401215,
-0.37311503291130066,
-0.6194132566452026,
-0.3319288492202759,
-0.47167497873306274,
0.26452815532684326,
0.21117334067821503,
-0.45334258675575256,
0.3332814872264862,
-0.47883865237236023,
0.690870463848114,
0.25781479477882385,
0.42556512355804443,
0.2768735885620117,
0.3793502151966095,
0.06949275732040405,
-0.11723539978265762,
-0.8199931383132935,
0.0013403575867414474,
0.8239825367927551,
0.036812618374824524,
1.2138171195983887,
-0.11505894362926483,
0.9108597040176392,
-0.06877487152814865,
0.17005369067192078,
-0.7374081611633301,
0.332678884267807,
0.03813575208187103,
-0.4787599444389343,
-0.3784465193748474,
-0.5321157574653625,
-0.8080189228057861,
0.4796462953090668,
-0.1573515683412552,
-0.5470454692840576,
0.24768343567848206,
0.6005677580833435,
-0.631752610206604,
0.354931503534317,
-0.6034014225006104,
0.6538617610931396,
0.009680399671196938,
-0.794901967048645,
-0.5225598812103271,
-0.5710976719856262,
0.19936013221740723,
-0.5151417851448059,
0.09074320644140244,
-0.37526553869247437,
-0.29563000798225403,
0.17075777053833008,
-0.5890771746635437,
0.6926304697990417,
-0.2051597386598587,
0.044740237295627594,
0.020965103060007095,
0.18869100511074066,
0.6422539949417114,
0.23031552135944366,
0.09651049971580505,
-0.02334040403366089,
0.14457418024539948,
-0.5189688205718994,
-0.40647780895233154,
0.9942890405654907,
-0.6721426248550415,
-0.3282023072242737,
-0.2155337631702423,
-0.7358872890472412,
-0.230818971991539,
0.13301917910575867,
0.12232847511768341,
0.5438759922981262,
-0.16245557367801666,
0.19771191477775574,
0.8327402472496033,
-0.08027822524309158,
0.12800249457359314,
0.470094233751297,
0.24541784822940826,
-0.5768100023269653,
1.3117015361785889,
0.06674907356500626,
0.17231106758117676,
0.5517643094062805,
-0.01615574210882187,
-0.15294115245342255,
-0.9019721746444702,
-0.6856241822242737,
0.38604670763015747,
-0.4604938328266144,
-0.8192533254623413,
-0.00042963100713677704,
0.20977434515953064,
0.019175732508301735,
-0.39324048161506653,
-0.5620388388633728,
-0.530125081539154,
-0.3813905417919159,
-0.08957436680793762,
0.4198078215122223,
0.5761922001838684,
-0.5285921096801758,
0.3848988115787506,
-0.44782498478889465,
0.4475354552268982,
0.07162079960107803,
0.6121863722801208,
-0.2501380741596222,
-0.7154421806335449,
-0.31474268436431885,
-0.12524005770683289,
-0.19534385204315186,
-0.4675116539001465,
0.3577747344970703,
0.462473601102829,
0.32433921098709106,
0.12927131354808807,
-0.14727994799613953,
1.3995814323425293,
-0.3188389241695404,
0.16940131783485413,
0.026899054646492004,
-0.662101686000824,
0.38593506813049316,
-0.18646317720413208,
-0.07879271358251572,
0.7148166298866272,
-0.06300143897533417,
-0.02624121680855751,
0.012310299091041088,
-0.3426366150379181,
-0.9254583716392517,
0.7074455618858337,
-0.02571546845138073,
-0.3181197941303253,
0.468824177980423,
0.6051515936851501,
0.3210539221763611,
0.289397656917572,
-0.23970207571983337,
-0.248369500041008,
-0.3067893981933594,
-0.34267690777778625,
-0.036877259612083435,
-0.13812674582004547,
-0.3242156207561493,
-0.2845662832260132,
0.8644097447395325,
-0.5276283621788025,
0.19495561718940735,
0.26566922664642334,
-0.4557011127471924,
-0.6254361271858215,
-0.1768009066581726,
0.6239470839500427,
0.510293185710907,
-0.5006081461906433,
-0.026409855112433434,
0.4440421164035797,
-0.4186801612377167,
0.2771904766559601,
0.5419597029685974,
-0.3226729929447174,
-0.35540664196014404,
-0.07415261119604111,
0.8432040214538574,
0.5643959045410156,
-0.4593549072742462,
0.45838692784309387,
-0.009156676009297371,
-0.31878310441970825,
-0.06660305708646774,
-0.2659738063812256,
-0.06848923861980438,
0.5095140337944031,
0.3134039044380188,
0.3346119225025177,
0.02265007048845291,
0.11261659115552902,
0.13169638812541962,
0.4840664267539978,
0.16112254559993744,
-0.1929292529821396,
0.5559589266777039,
0.028881516307592392,
0.13973760604858398,
0.38704466819763184,
0.027801141142845154,
-0.0327928364276886,
0.5238638520240784,
0.5854358673095703,
0.6460504531860352,
0.11690493673086166,
-0.18768250942230225,
0.5079716444015503,
0.519320011138916,
-0.16221968829631805,
0.4166203439235687,
-0.22191978991031647,
-0.5700660943984985,
-0.7440446019172668,
-0.8910011649131775,
-0.24141131341457367,
-0.024287624284625053,
-0.4492016136646271,
0.27018481492996216,
-0.787784993648529,
0.20333494246006012,
-0.4661686420440674,
0.21778613328933716,
-0.6018083691596985,
0.158527672290802,
0.030235381796956062,
0.9855820536613464,
-0.38217371702194214,
0.6992351412773132,
0.40317463874816895,
-0.07780615985393524,
-0.8927803039550781,
-0.3965766727924347,
0.07065382599830627,
-1.0865960121154785,
0.1488119214773178,
0.004258890636265278,
-0.32808491587638855,
0.587961733341217,
-0.49560317397117615,
-0.9204833507537842,
1.276206612586975,
0.6880469918251038,
-1.0131986141204834,
0.09627912938594818,
-0.36871567368507385,
0.20369504392147064,
0.039737503975629807,
-0.034506749361753464,
0.6644855737686157,
0.5157465934753418,
0.15631909668445587,
-0.9939938187599182,
0.27134719491004944,
0.11230102181434631,
0.20592288672924042,
0.2939288318157196,
-0.890857994556427,
0.333179771900177,
-0.4738953113555908,
-0.06657344847917557,
0.6190131902694702,
0.4923968017101288,
0.34603360295295715,
0.07299461960792542,
0.6055797338485718,
0.8997301459312439,
0.827407717704773,
-0.44859156012535095,
0.7246984243392944,
-0.36196351051330566,
0.6086459755897522,
0.7223184108734131,
0.15806913375854492,
0.4216557443141937,
0.7934155464172363,
-0.05104094743728638,
-0.10971587151288986,
1.0714519023895264,
-0.12630876898765564,
0.9183152318000793,
0.5835772752761841,
-0.13000084459781647,
-0.3724479377269745,
0.1541142612695694,
-0.32809683680534363,
0.036977071315050125,
0.48475244641304016,
0.20777609944343567,
-0.32531169056892395,
-0.1278490424156189,
-0.3645658493041992,
-0.27277010679244995,
-0.6938316822052002,
0.5803285241127014,
0.15868687629699707,
-0.4128263592720032,
1.0243711471557617,
-0.0534418448805809,
0.8215623497962952,
-0.6048399806022644,
-0.0997239202260971,
-0.500003457069397,
0.413999080657959,
-0.4995505213737488,
-0.20249786972999573,
0.13541269302368164,
-0.2709299325942993,
0.11964275687932968,
-0.1996898651123047,
0.854524552822113,
-0.38170701265335083,
-0.05180904641747475,
0.0046877614222466946,
0.5261229276657104,
0.19351530075073242,
-0.059179872274398804,
-0.5931147336959839,
0.41986793279647827,
0.1511375904083252,
-0.5263856053352356,
0.4345035254955292,
0.27833205461502075,
0.29560959339141846,
0.5644264817237854,
0.5451561212539673,
0.3918428421020508,
0.15034925937652588,
-0.051536399871110916,
0.9704933762550354,
-0.45608654618263245,
-0.17798617482185364,
-0.543746829032898,
0.32035791873931885,
0.2727436423301697,
-0.2579502761363983,
0.24490748345851898,
0.6480536460876465,
0.9110081791877747,
0.0971805527806282,
0.49359965324401855,
-0.09599773585796356,
0.5287895202636719,
-0.6085869073867798,
0.44250354170799255,
-0.8061646819114685,
0.3306215703487396,
-0.22793641686439514,
-0.8950576186180115,
-0.40066584944725037,
1.1052042245864868,
0.3448362648487091,
0.027961857616901398,
0.46893131732940674,
1.414749026298523,
-0.21124137938022614,
-0.05064989626407623,
0.5395401120185852,
0.2581559121608734,
-0.0916425958275795,
0.761341392993927,
0.7426354885101318,
-0.5380375385284424,
0.7343012690544128,
-0.4136348366737366,
-0.4521482586860657,
-0.3710836172103882,
-0.8185136914253235,
-0.5069289207458496,
-0.26700159907341003,
-0.25770556926727295,
-0.3951551616191864,
0.4015117883682251,
1.2424592971801758,
0.8058760166168213,
-0.6930407285690308,
0.026621555909514427,
-0.1464310884475708,
0.2108294665813446,
-0.3501942455768585,
-0.10489600151777267,
0.29710111021995544,
-0.18549314141273499,
-0.715975821018219,
0.47208476066589355,
0.23828715085983276,
0.08148643374443054,
-0.15203703939914703,
-0.20507153868675232,
0.09757471084594727,
-0.12392916530370712,
0.41189998388290405,
0.3977130949497223,
-0.5542660355567932,
-0.4061264991760254,
-0.13301798701286316,
-0.021709393709897995,
0.013736732304096222,
0.7569231986999512,
-0.777365505695343,
0.38187718391418457,
0.3259044587612152,
0.9080066680908203,
1.077304720878601,
0.02338510751724243,
0.17257428169250488,
-0.9200262427330017,
0.22037172317504883,
0.19246746599674225,
0.5176513195037842,
0.4356154799461365,
-0.24329957365989685,
0.7040164470672607,
0.6009697318077087,
-0.616672694683075,
-1.109792709350586,
0.12478183954954147,
-1.2613917589187622,
-0.09593569487333298,
1.072053074836731,
-0.06348244845867157,
-0.2184714674949646,
-0.1574307084083557,
-0.5273512601852417,
0.19987988471984863,
-0.39492055773735046,
0.6201099753379822,
0.17325520515441895,
-0.27357301115989685,
-0.11483076959848404,
-0.41083067655563354,
0.40423324704170227,
0.4070166349411011,
-0.45464280247688293,
-0.034380827099084854,
0.6728295087814331,
0.6704340577125549,
-0.44664767384529114,
0.7775232791900635,
0.16373364627361298,
0.4682989716529846,
-0.024046175181865692,
-0.24780011177062988,
-0.5407910943031311,
-0.24174782633781433,
-0.44018715620040894,
0.003959219437092543,
-0.011006162501871586,
0.0007002764032222331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11997v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11997v1 | Remember This Event That Year? Assessing Temporal Information and Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2024-02-19T09:43:03 | 2024-02-19T09:43:03 | Himanshu Beniwal, Kowsik Nandagopan D, Mayank Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly becoming ubiquitous, yet their
ability to reason about and retain temporal information remains limited. This
hinders their application in real-world scenarios where understanding the
sequential nature of events is crucial. This paper experiments with
state-of-the-art models on a novel, large-scale temporal dataset,
\textbf{TempUN}, to reveal significant limitations in temporal retention and
reasoning abilities. Interestingly, closed-source models indicate knowledge
gaps more frequently, potentially suggesting a trade-off between uncertainty
awareness and incorrect responses. Further, exploring various fine-tuning
approaches yielded no major performance improvements. The associated dataset
and code are available at the following URL
(https://github.com/lingoiitgn/TempUN). | [
-0.19554337859153748,
-0.6409724950790405,
1.0103293657302856,
0.02164686843752861,
-0.19770018756389618,
-0.19839611649513245,
-0.3209016025066376,
-0.5282336473464966,
-0.2660106420516968,
0.03322204202413559,
-0.6479238271713257,
-0.26561012864112854,
-0.3187931478023529,
-0.1585731953382492,
-0.4031284749507904,
0.5915159583091736,
-0.1536475569009781,
-0.3319351375102997,
-0.014719394966959953,
-0.23442307114601135,
-0.31152695417404175,
-0.7197071313858032,
-0.807765007019043,
-0.5405418276786804,
0.6979631781578064,
0.5229383111000061,
0.5536016821861267,
0.3706595003604889,
0.42290017008781433,
0.14276601374149323,
-0.2164412885904312,
0.1251508891582489,
-0.562567949295044,
0.06701367348432541,
-0.4248420000076294,
-0.2095852941274643,
-0.44809800386428833,
-0.045651212334632874,
1.1126668453216553,
0.7070233821868896,
-0.15490855276584625,
0.26722952723503113,
-0.2804568111896515,
0.2956730127334595,
-0.8664478063583374,
0.12965278327465057,
-0.883999228477478,
-0.0028049449902027845,
-0.33215266466140747,
-0.3696519136428833,
-0.429433137178421,
-0.24278675019741058,
0.19980685412883759,
-0.4502770006656647,
0.030135657638311386,
0.09627948701381683,
1.0644681453704834,
0.22845497727394104,
-0.30827611684799194,
0.08756161481142044,
-1.040817141532898,
0.8377742171287537,
-0.9531291723251343,
0.5183162093162537,
0.5890747308731079,
0.3038577139377594,
-0.19741855561733246,
-0.7236481308937073,
-0.6401042342185974,
-0.2547490894794464,
0.28981295228004456,
-0.06910273432731628,
0.06362904608249664,
-0.34693092107772827,
0.4454691708087921,
0.1805114597082138,
-0.4631805121898651,
0.283091276884079,
-0.26963821053504944,
-0.08085697144269943,
0.3730262815952301,
0.48165494203567505,
0.17403265833854675,
-0.0774984061717987,
-0.2230387181043625,
0.03171604871749878,
-0.7980802655220032,
-0.07722202688455582,
0.2934701144695282,
0.02549789473414421,
0.06298694014549255,
0.7140089869499207,
-0.1590694636106491,
0.5021649599075317,
-0.2155621349811554,
0.10352970659732819,
-0.032046929001808167,
-0.27743321657180786,
-0.24524115025997162,
0.004669888876378536,
0.5254026055335999,
0.3922777473926544,
0.49417898058891296,
-0.3871595561504364,
-0.04012785106897354,
-0.13049958646297455,
0.04223909229040146,
-0.7527255415916443,
-0.1609489768743515,
0.32797694206237793,
-0.14184004068374634,
0.10075867176055908,
0.08761922270059586,
-0.585781991481781,
-0.23456689715385437,
-0.1666741967201233,
0.24939917027950287,
-0.5534316301345825,
-0.3018520772457123,
0.28903907537460327,
-0.18114160001277924,
0.23916293680667877,
0.3079051375389099,
-0.4750158488750458,
-0.14249831438064575,
0.8969606161117554,
0.8573455810546875,
-0.20093931257724762,
-0.5438748598098755,
-0.41422945261001587,
0.34652867913246155,
-0.47458916902542114,
0.6945750117301941,
-0.7258949875831604,
-0.19116050004959106,
-0.2539023458957672,
0.03591044992208481,
-0.14720964431762695,
-0.4650174081325531,
0.35481125116348267,
-0.7861440181732178,
0.13144735991954803,
-0.2539450228214264,
-0.5604328513145447,
0.08198076486587524,
0.1603555679321289,
-0.6129180192947388,
0.945349395275116,
-0.060453832149505615,
-0.8576498031616211,
0.4330873191356659,
-0.08301153779029846,
-0.16173920035362244,
-0.10341338813304901,
-0.1800469309091568,
-0.44028329849243164,
0.20293481647968292,
-0.04850231111049652,
0.28279995918273926,
-0.1718614399433136,
0.537026584148407,
-0.5846233367919922,
-0.5043611526489258,
0.546340823173523,
-0.3107101023197174,
0.5741333365440369,
0.24448971450328827,
0.029024319723248482,
0.005282704718410969,
-0.7911198139190674,
-0.24436865746974945,
0.38394245505332947,
-0.3853127062320709,
-0.4198669493198395,
0.2965376377105713,
-0.08798157423734665,
0.12192004173994064,
0.4420449137687683,
-0.42299890518188477,
0.2929091453552246,
-0.2303740382194519,
0.6457061171531677,
0.7459198236465454,
0.3064199388027191,
0.423838347196579,
-0.5829952359199524,
0.30284443497657776,
0.29876941442489624,
0.16356441378593445,
-0.39896902441978455,
-0.21935409307479858,
-0.7110147476196289,
0.30057013034820557,
0.049362581223249435,
0.6361130475997925,
-0.5516645908355713,
0.15984325110912323,
-0.5143957138061523,
-0.29534631967544556,
0.12864041328430176,
-0.11498549580574036,
-0.08410748839378357,
0.5137172937393188,
0.036250289529561996,
0.04388294368982315,
-0.636137068271637,
-0.8264089822769165,
-0.19367912411689758,
-0.47114917635917664,
-0.1376575529575348,
0.09463303536176682,
0.5120879411697388,
-0.043925441801548004,
0.8342545628547668,
-0.2590714395046234,
0.14172856509685516,
-0.1100843995809555,
0.051389388740062714,
0.1651482731103897,
0.3569413125514984,
0.47243598103523254,
-0.39597541093826294,
0.2929426431655884,
-0.13758598268032074,
-0.7890458703041077,
-0.09783978015184402,
-0.3520045876502991,
0.04684925451874733,
0.35927408933639526,
0.6235371232032776,
-0.469308078289032,
0.4767915904521942,
0.3258918523788452,
-0.608244001865387,
0.5320166945457458,
-0.2363334447145462,
0.2099309265613556,
-0.8305844664573669,
0.1978624314069748,
-0.08058536052703857,
-0.11080566048622131,
-0.5004489421844482,
-0.07208238542079926,
0.2776091992855072,
-0.010698026046156883,
-0.4918162524700165,
0.8519389033317566,
-0.41832271218299866,
0.11130207777023315,
-0.24262163043022156,
0.027239618822932243,
-0.1847241073846817,
0.31941190361976624,
0.08869063854217529,
0.5850042700767517,
0.23520895838737488,
-0.7570262551307678,
0.08696410804986954,
-0.0262648556381464,
-0.7325222492218018,
0.41756731271743774,
-0.43648889660835266,
0.36527562141418457,
-0.21550682187080383,
-0.03020665980875492,
-0.678497314453125,
-0.47055190801620483,
0.06439252197742462,
-0.38543975353240967,
0.4489913880825043,
-0.20526601374149323,
-0.7880004048347473,
-0.3342926800251007,
-0.12085854262113571,
0.4614512622356415,
0.39826515316963196,
-0.40283867716789246,
0.6998350620269775,
0.2810971736907959,
-0.2841951251029968,
-0.4314216077327728,
-0.7494567632675171,
0.1978183090686798,
-0.3799188435077667,
-0.4216749370098114,
-0.10601543635129929,
-0.0662635862827301,
-0.6021342277526855,
0.0936056524515152,
-0.49413010478019714,
-0.024269400164484978,
0.21093323826789856,
0.196747288107872,
0.31268057227134705,
-0.2853907644748688,
0.4448775053024292,
-0.18530084192752838,
0.08082633465528488,
0.13784195482730865,
-0.42319256067276,
0.4825189709663391,
-0.24419674277305603,
-0.4657009541988373,
-0.4499214291572571,
0.1296916902065277,
0.6408116817474365,
0.12603113055229187,
1.0195376873016357,
0.2706884741783142,
-0.7825672626495361,
-0.07370404154062271,
-0.9115733504295349,
-0.193809375166893,
-0.39033305644989014,
0.43291130661964417,
-0.2525976598262787,
-0.9662652015686035,
0.6337850093841553,
0.0778503492474556,
0.19866354763507843,
0.4176313281059265,
0.3775135576725006,
-0.19788068532943726,
0.516266942024231,
0.09306521713733673,
-0.0374133475124836,
0.6815829873085022,
0.04910990223288536,
0.09882794320583344,
-0.7113014459609985,
-0.4187605679035187,
-0.37851953506469727,
-0.27951744198799133,
-0.13218724727630615,
-0.2720296084880829,
0.2767946422100067,
0.09842242300510406,
-0.6927423477172852,
-0.12098023295402527,
0.16189439594745636,
0.5012516975402832,
0.27958235144615173,
0.1838342845439911,
0.4756215810775757,
-0.13080430030822754,
0.19832921028137207,
-0.10061183571815491,
-0.9127662777900696,
-0.5817288160324097,
0.7819880247116089,
0.34568724036216736,
0.7602988481521606,
-0.05831867828965187,
0.20928075909614563,
0.08834321796894073,
-0.013058026321232319,
-0.4663531482219696,
0.7711133360862732,
0.1680021435022354,
-0.5904102325439453,
-0.5400393009185791,
-0.7531125545501709,
-1.0471433401107788,
-0.16114577651023865,
-0.1539309322834015,
-0.9545183777809143,
0.2537626624107361,
0.019167516380548477,
-0.3715548515319824,
0.7109528183937073,
-0.6129921674728394,
0.5192626118659973,
-0.11247823387384415,
-0.3734174966812134,
-0.2213171273469925,
-0.3258541226387024,
0.3242983818054199,
-0.324593186378479,
0.28080326318740845,
-0.5631552934646606,
-0.2119176834821701,
0.8425979018211365,
-0.183237224817276,
0.7691265344619751,
0.055730871856212616,
0.03797588124871254,
0.33643925189971924,
0.3917677700519562,
0.5225002765655518,
0.16409121453762054,
-0.3094883859157562,
0.1299479752779007,
0.2758919894695282,
-0.5761615037918091,
-0.4852849245071411,
0.9535722732543945,
-0.5301343202590942,
-0.7287930250167847,
-0.5062925219535828,
-0.6337106227874756,
-0.3470118045806885,
0.05760035663843155,
0.09598405659198761,
0.5330971479415894,
-0.3017771542072296,
0.1657596081495285,
0.7556357383728027,
-0.40125998854637146,
0.5493430495262146,
0.7113739252090454,
-0.1972726583480835,
-0.11183347553014755,
0.5639228820800781,
0.3722468912601471,
0.23379826545715332,
0.3117448091506958,
0.33582720160484314,
0.03463825210928917,
-0.5618357062339783,
-0.1392328441143036,
0.4650764763355255,
-0.6354588866233826,
-0.047735944390296936,
-0.5751796960830688,
-0.1869632452726364,
-0.3097246289253235,
0.13422517478466034,
-0.19048582017421722,
-0.8341939449310303,
-0.34695565700531006,
-0.21359962224960327,
0.45189905166625977,
0.6176952719688416,
0.049867864698171616,
0.21671520173549652,
-0.7023424506187439,
0.15601332485675812,
0.05786324664950371,
0.49040400981903076,
0.3545055687427521,
-0.6572113037109375,
-0.2704404592514038,
-0.24446704983711243,
0.14763925969600677,
-0.9959933161735535,
0.09908076375722885,
0.2037343829870224,
0.6220047473907471,
0.3025657534599304,
0.20805111527442932,
0.4855065941810608,
-0.43970930576324463,
0.843940794467926,
-0.10638605058193207,
-0.6858869194984436,
0.855545699596405,
-0.4767608940601349,
1.088474988937378,
0.2570326030254364,
0.28871551156044006,
-0.5323241949081421,
-0.4677346646785736,
-0.7823765873908997,
-0.9988762736320496,
0.8340470194816589,
0.06171029061079025,
-0.30694612860679626,
0.005637912079691887,
0.6420283317565918,
-0.043628837913274765,
-0.08046536892652512,
-0.2933046221733093,
-0.005569444969296455,
0.1873929500579834,
0.03509796783328056,
-0.1414104551076889,
-0.557650089263916,
0.07465042918920517,
-0.12588249146938324,
0.5942217707633972,
0.19590893387794495,
-0.0173251461237669,
0.179814875125885,
-0.01848980039358139,
-0.12927626073360443,
0.4397084414958954,
0.5644073486328125,
1.0688860416412354,
-0.38775092363357544,
0.2797011137008667,
0.7437646389007568,
-0.38263770937919617,
-0.09302186965942383,
0.1185089498758316,
-0.2339295744895935,
-0.19837012887001038,
0.6345013380050659,
0.6609497666358948,
0.40278956294059753,
-0.8150503635406494,
0.11324257403612137,
-0.07492697238922119,
0.14311262965202332,
-0.6781280040740967,
0.007511741016060114,
0.2794758379459381,
0.4193574786186218,
0.4014264941215515,
-0.2751816511154175,
-0.18037745356559753,
-0.8204673528671265,
0.036966536194086075,
0.08801934123039246,
-0.1996026635169983,
-0.3391569256782532,
0.6603333950042725,
-0.29014694690704346,
-0.06431551277637482,
0.8911759257316589,
0.03399326652288437,
-0.41447049379348755,
0.6082972288131714,
0.21567875146865845,
0.6131395101547241,
-0.25140029191970825,
-0.346556156873703,
0.5594763159751892,
0.5432775020599365,
-0.30859026312828064,
0.4263351559638977,
0.08200147747993469,
-0.6344737410545349,
-0.5074930191040039,
-0.40682142972946167,
-0.3841484487056732,
0.37878307700157166,
-0.5470345616340637,
0.05469036474823952,
-0.5717279314994812,
-0.5740782618522644,
-0.2514856159687042,
-0.09859355539083481,
-0.8448988199234009,
-0.07532148063182831,
0.14722687005996704,
1.2279819250106812,
-0.6777869462966919,
0.920211136341095,
0.5746152400970459,
-0.24857133626937866,
-0.40959304571151733,
-0.0033032118808478117,
0.04140248894691467,
-0.59906405210495,
0.49352583289146423,
-0.20668284595012665,
-0.05879838019609451,
-0.3881623148918152,
-0.4959900379180908,
-0.7651429176330566,
1.0703667402267456,
0.24172726273536682,
-0.9349879622459412,
-0.4315382242202759,
-0.005654658190906048,
0.44858279824256897,
-0.07471752911806107,
0.058046855032444,
0.9009350538253784,
0.56711345911026,
0.2879953682422638,
-1.1178385019302368,
-0.07336953282356262,
-0.1416604220867157,
-0.09549185633659363,
0.3669489920139313,
-0.643734872341156,
0.5584040880203247,
-0.44552770256996155,
-0.6677113175392151,
0.08664976805448532,
0.8146314024925232,
0.2698999345302582,
0.8060093522071838,
0.3951234221458435,
0.704627275466919,
0.947690486907959,
-0.36556607484817505,
1.1485651731491089,
0.13012777268886566,
0.02980385161936283,
1.5693800449371338,
-0.3195473849773407,
0.9369590878486633,
0.39444079995155334,
0.14741815626621246,
0.09673602133989334,
0.6869461536407471,
0.14392058551311493,
0.22531022131443024,
0.034538112580776215,
-0.2723276615142822,
-0.5987713932991028,
0.024124491959810257,
-0.3852190673351288,
0.0012925652554258704,
0.6657117605209351,
-0.02760343998670578,
-0.22816230356693268,
0.022315738722682,
0.19009405374526978,
-0.14586468040943146,
-0.3719773292541504,
0.6087439656257629,
0.2539672255516052,
-0.4857730567455292,
0.2657780051231384,
-0.30577728152275085,
0.24492309987545013,
-0.5860722661018372,
0.23228327929973602,
-0.24006491899490356,
0.3719867169857025,
-0.0034255424980074167,
-1.0656925439834595,
0.49129387736320496,
0.10227559506893158,
-0.05795908346772194,
-0.008803710341453552,
0.5313597917556763,
-0.24662820994853973,
-0.5560797452926636,
0.23242206871509552,
0.5159831047058105,
0.24102988839149475,
0.017693201079964638,
-0.29492881894111633,
0.5307124853134155,
-0.32945796847343445,
-0.39006954431533813,
0.20490555465221405,
0.9926839470863342,
-0.14921525120735168,
0.9921903610229492,
0.13536956906318665,
0.4003450572490692,
0.0807337686419487,
0.24285167455673218,
0.5349501371383667,
-0.9966124892234802,
-0.18715204298496246,
-0.9322748780250549,
-0.04348263144493103,
0.03792724758386612,
-0.3323827385902405,
0.7115382552146912,
0.7250579595565796,
0.9300982356071472,
0.18952509760856628,
0.5599556565284729,
0.35461416840553284,
0.5678946375846863,
-0.7131353616714478,
0.3983117341995239,
-0.5447206497192383,
0.3639937937259674,
0.16345109045505524,
-0.6157587170600891,
-0.21193450689315796,
0.24110153317451477,
-0.5162310004234314,
0.035037457942962646,
0.7168603539466858,
0.4882339537143707,
-0.07268458604812622,
0.12408635765314102,
0.3997710645198822,
0.43832430243492126,
0.1817210465669632,
1.0641772747039795,
1.4712063074111938,
-0.08180546015501022,
0.4788135886192322,
-0.10040698945522308,
-0.17550645768642426,
-0.33889782428741455,
-1.1069812774658203,
-1.096400499343872,
-0.8920886516571045,
-0.4507530629634857,
-0.45850127935409546,
0.4583779275417328,
0.981693685054779,
0.5240386128425598,
-0.8305587768554688,
-0.07668136805295944,
0.4516347348690033,
-0.10007224977016449,
0.11785466969013214,
-0.1616637408733368,
0.28221815824508667,
-0.09432458877563477,
-0.5283867120742798,
0.43470895290374756,
0.23321522772312164,
0.2906411588191986,
0.06188253313302994,
0.1868923157453537,
-0.1997484564781189,
0.20313000679016113,
0.4911805987358093,
0.4897976219654083,
-0.715313732624054,
-0.4877701699733734,
0.05055109038949013,
0.033577319234609604,
-0.05910927429795265,
0.975315272808075,
-0.6995753645896912,
0.28634315729141235,
0.634200930595398,
0.3991680145263672,
0.715822160243988,
-0.22215652465820312,
0.5457582473754883,
-0.3352503776550293,
0.11493203043937683,
0.25851181149482727,
0.7209874391555786,
0.32427072525024414,
-0.30944275856018066,
0.4835594594478607,
0.07599906623363495,
-0.6607192754745483,
-0.8206996321678162,
0.24674125015735626,
-1.1785966157913208,
-0.5524695515632629,
1.2306394577026367,
0.10838726907968521,
-0.09973493963479996,
-0.1558389514684677,
0.05778372660279274,
0.33569279313087463,
-0.37491196393966675,
0.8817322850227356,
1.1827056407928467,
0.028578320518136024,
-0.3707233965396881,
-0.7786915898323059,
0.18782295286655426,
0.15446488559246063,
-0.5750607848167419,
0.14417718350887299,
0.6197656989097595,
0.4216112494468689,
-0.08706524223089218,
0.4441773593425751,
-0.10429179668426514,
0.26357871294021606,
-0.08374150842428207,
-0.40525466203689575,
-0.23728016018867493,
-0.6555269360542297,
-0.362945020198822,
0.16646546125411987,
0.2210497111082077,
0.17560236155986786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14843v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14843v1 | Text Diffusion with Reinforced Conditioning | 2024-02-19T09:24:02 | 2024-02-19T09:24:02 | Yuxuan Liu, Tianchi Yang, Shaohan Huang, Zihan Zhang, Haizhen Huang, Furu Wei, Weiwei Deng, Feng Sun, Qi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Diffusion models have demonstrated exceptional capability in generating
high-quality images, videos, and audio. Due to their adaptiveness in iterative
refinement, they provide a strong potential for achieving better
non-autoregressive sequence generation. However, existing text diffusion models
still fall short in their performance due to a challenge in handling the
discreteness of language. This paper thoroughly analyzes text diffusion models
and uncovers two significant limitations: degradation of self-conditioning
during training and misalignment between training and sampling. Motivated by
our findings, we propose a novel Text Diffusion model called TREC, which
mitigates the degradation with Reinforced Conditioning and the misalignment by
Time-Aware Variance Scaling. Our extensive experiments demonstrate the
competitiveness of TREC against autoregressive, non-autoregressive, and
diffusion baselines. Moreover, qualitative analysis shows its advanced ability
to fully utilize the diffusion process in refining samples. | [
-0.4369581639766693,
-1.0375010967254639,
0.43251925706863403,
0.37895306944847107,
-0.11972072720527649,
0.2902965545654297,
-0.024073995649814606,
-0.14027062058448792,
-0.08859739452600479,
0.23597782850265503,
-0.4640991687774658,
-0.402092844247818,
-0.7355131506919861,
0.177116259932518,
-0.8742969632148743,
1.0772360563278198,
-0.1891099512577057,
-0.17143256962299347,
-0.04723573103547096,
-0.4684637486934662,
-0.5702014565467834,
-0.14389437437057495,
-0.9217186570167542,
-0.5331259965896606,
0.031938336789608,
0.2737894654273987,
0.4956211447715759,
0.5809962749481201,
0.16633665561676025,
0.26066482067108154,
-0.10614609718322754,
-0.05611942708492279,
-0.45637616515159607,
0.34275883436203003,
-0.2672004997730255,
0.07450036704540253,
-0.0986197292804718,
-0.07981834560632706,
0.965715765953064,
0.6036993861198425,
-0.5127330422401428,
-0.24174682796001434,
0.17780856788158417,
0.8215304613113403,
-0.5449519753456116,
-0.537954568862915,
-0.37968406081199646,
0.1174299418926239,
-0.07560605555772781,
-0.13968005776405334,
-0.576545238494873,
-0.3385966122150421,
0.16892723739147186,
-0.5748381018638611,
0.7967186570167542,
-0.027991509065032005,
0.6843743324279785,
0.3726019561290741,
-0.5260487198829651,
-0.11920370906591415,
-0.934904158115387,
0.7466811537742615,
-0.5514856576919556,
0.2948739528656006,
0.3756776452064514,
0.08623071014881134,
0.10688493400812149,
-0.6340290904045105,
-0.608138918876648,
-0.046387773007154465,
0.34133589267730713,
0.12621016800403595,
-0.126482293009758,
-0.15838153660297394,
-0.04300776496529579,
0.38250866532325745,
-0.7037814855575562,
0.06200720742344856,
-0.1544119417667389,
0.11967457830905914,
0.31119194626808167,
0.12263736873865128,
0.2786596417427063,
-0.03461401164531708,
-0.5351935625076294,
-0.1529718041419983,
-0.27156415581703186,
-0.19917288422584534,
0.3661535680294037,
-0.12183624505996704,
-0.061090126633644104,
0.26836439967155457,
0.06560839712619781,
0.4391660690307617,
0.3785940408706665,
0.022836074233055115,
0.17537616193294525,
-0.3151315450668335,
-0.28245991468429565,
-0.005117674358189106,
0.8789623379707336,
0.09127994626760483,
0.1557134985923767,
-0.08878796547651291,
-0.2724590301513672,
-0.12583403289318085,
0.547316312789917,
-0.695730447769165,
-0.2804432809352875,
0.05613170191645622,
-0.6128503680229187,
-0.2805090844631195,
-0.34989088773727417,
-0.912915050983429,
-0.0637832060456276,
0.1523059606552124,
0.34768572449684143,
-0.5676007270812988,
-0.4562174081802368,
0.2544134557247162,
-0.3282358944416046,
-0.2075534462928772,
0.11631249636411667,
-0.9629546999931335,
0.4287315607070923,
0.11247672885656357,
1.2011597156524658,
-0.4707012474536896,
0.02808382548391819,
-0.015871088951826096,
0.18964485824108124,
-0.39655470848083496,
1.0438472032546997,
-0.5621040463447571,
-0.8740269541740417,
-0.008261580020189285,
-0.14130885899066925,
-0.10068565607070923,
-0.494416207075119,
0.447815865278244,
-0.5092787742614746,
0.17245422303676605,
0.24732236564159393,
-0.4022599160671234,
0.11550810933113098,
0.08451557159423828,
-0.9324185252189636,
1.3660354614257812,
0.24597524106502533,
-0.9270270466804504,
0.2290414571762085,
-0.4274240732192993,
-0.6682177186012268,
-0.2500579357147217,
0.31068482995033264,
-0.7856627702713013,
0.1072874441742897,
0.08393093943595886,
0.23474489152431488,
-0.1339808851480484,
0.46826767921447754,
-0.5037247538566589,
-0.15457022190093994,
0.3310205042362213,
-0.7010955810546875,
0.1927836537361145,
0.5555886626243591,
-0.2257082760334015,
-0.3712003231048584,
-0.6816060543060303,
-0.25677719712257385,
-0.14704309403896332,
-0.4453739523887634,
-0.5152175426483154,
0.04298057034611702,
0.1283845454454422,
0.32091808319091797,
-0.24594920873641968,
-0.3290988504886627,
0.2441689819097519,
-0.3740667998790741,
0.6279467940330505,
0.7004284858703613,
0.39098384976387024,
0.9078121781349182,
-0.34160560369491577,
0.5891486406326294,
0.1611255407333374,
0.032103125005960464,
-0.05961340293288231,
-0.2791699469089508,
-0.7839155793190002,
0.0003884565958287567,
0.4005764126777649,
0.39827239513397217,
-1.1825755834579468,
-0.04118403419852257,
-0.19091182947158813,
-0.3479177951812744,
-0.4280335605144501,
-0.013986560516059399,
0.3255099952220917,
0.5955875515937805,
0.6164501309394836,
-0.4349786043167114,
-0.2831166386604309,
-0.8207478523254395,
-0.3301108479499817,
0.13110612332820892,
0.08070321381092072,
-0.09062224626541138,
0.46866294741630554,
-0.23868116736412048,
0.8304010629653931,
-0.2610938847064972,
-0.10202735662460327,
-0.21408705413341522,
0.8474158644676208,
-0.15095075964927673,
0.8431815505027771,
0.5441222190856934,
-0.7500461339950562,
-0.4843744933605194,
-0.3505101501941681,
-0.11726860702037811,
-0.32785359025001526,
-0.48956099152565,
-0.2397177368402481,
0.41036444902420044,
0.5282394289970398,
-0.2211935967206955,
0.6203688979148865,
0.6865943670272827,
-0.3104599714279175,
0.3911200761795044,
-0.3842397630214691,
0.4157814383506775,
-1.0605359077453613,
0.01523401215672493,
0.6722922325134277,
-0.4728003442287445,
-0.5451189875602722,
-0.493865966796875,
-0.028181113302707672,
-0.014588287100195885,
-0.21796204149723053,
0.6711302399635315,
-0.2223503142595291,
0.2958780527114868,
-0.460053950548172,
0.2091001570224762,
0.16529777646064758,
0.3608180582523346,
0.38165247440338135,
0.8099390268325806,
0.18183672428131104,
-1.0717289447784424,
-0.2149847447872162,
0.17647871375083923,
-0.23561103641986847,
0.9064837694168091,
-0.7118502259254456,
-0.11888047307729721,
-0.21524286270141602,
0.324280321598053,
-1.331382393836975,
0.09666542708873749,
0.02706894837319851,
-0.4883624017238617,
0.7314375042915344,
0.10454803705215454,
-0.2819744944572449,
-0.3436998724937439,
-0.11386356502771378,
0.8647528290748596,
0.48313021659851074,
-0.34023064374923706,
0.45289942622184753,
0.10548091679811478,
-0.13320621848106384,
-0.6323230266571045,
-1.1043506860733032,
-0.10166719555854797,
-0.17079617083072662,
-0.4038669168949127,
0.6661584377288818,
-0.33316853642463684,
-0.05969463661313057,
-0.042131975293159485,
-0.2754898965358734,
-0.428201824426651,
-0.024812445044517517,
0.07746005803346634,
-0.10946548730134964,
0.18626552820205688,
0.54139643907547,
0.17629866302013397,
-0.1091427430510521,
-0.27356967329978943,
-0.6375083327293396,
0.3017455041408539,
0.3751535415649414,
-0.15831603109836578,
-0.5149198770523071,
0.5508809685707092,
0.38682612776756287,
0.10119263827800751,
0.7711476683616638,
0.5507674217224121,
-0.1447865515947342,
-0.34394916892051697,
-0.7024364471435547,
0.18405640125274658,
-0.4830399453639984,
0.2256532907485962,
-0.27762359380722046,
-0.7997865080833435,
0.19689546525478363,
-0.13923422992229462,
-0.054471563547849655,
0.6850057244300842,
0.5726578235626221,
-0.3599115312099457,
0.9383332133293152,
0.8017277717590332,
0.19570758938789368,
0.7793453931808472,
-0.2942979037761688,
-0.019297363236546516,
-0.6556075215339661,
-0.2230343371629715,
-0.8138354420661926,
-0.39923685789108276,
-0.5662404894828796,
-0.4498502016067505,
0.10280540585517883,
-0.30188196897506714,
-0.3820476830005646,
0.24198085069656372,
-0.5515888333320618,
0.32908305525779724,
0.4724617302417755,
0.06914947181940079,
0.38245993852615356,
0.03753478452563286,
-0.4226115047931671,
-0.07899416238069534,
-0.6646111011505127,
-0.46263259649276733,
0.6212198734283447,
0.47838500142097473,
0.9801344871520996,
0.008888517506420612,
0.49904417991638184,
0.8721804022789001,
0.3161645531654358,
-0.3885049819946289,
0.17692475020885468,
-0.282550185918808,
-0.6304997205734253,
-0.263347327709198,
-0.6117151975631714,
-0.9482877850532532,
-0.08163616806268692,
-0.10872431844472885,
-0.3075905740261078,
0.367824912071228,
0.1316968947649002,
-0.16457699239253998,
0.3970308005809784,
-0.5935667157173157,
0.7492288947105408,
0.2080937623977661,
-0.4936322867870331,
-0.2933448851108551,
-0.4337030351161957,
0.30098024010658264,
-0.18306821584701538,
0.41709572076797485,
0.0939684584736824,
-0.09574154019355774,
0.6242760419845581,
-0.4068383276462555,
0.5341920852661133,
-0.12109741568565369,
-0.11330700665712357,
0.4700033664703369,
0.5822029709815979,
0.2216852754354477,
0.001938121858984232,
-0.08974775671958923,
-0.4029046893119812,
-0.048391956835985184,
-0.630591094493866,
-0.5450044870376587,
0.623790979385376,
-0.6393457651138306,
-0.3573629856109619,
-0.3223055899143219,
-0.23179471492767334,
-0.21358034014701843,
-0.04678673669695854,
0.6516610980033875,
0.3000883162021637,
-0.4976349174976349,
0.11592990905046463,
1.054320216178894,
-0.28115928173065186,
0.9683386087417603,
0.4952656924724579,
0.27462849020957947,
-0.5992275476455688,
0.7125906944274902,
-0.009467238560318947,
0.5794559717178345,
0.4524288475513458,
0.0005895006470382214,
-0.5344210267066956,
-0.7240826487541199,
-0.05460153892636299,
0.2590217888355255,
-0.5269149541854858,
-0.19763517379760742,
-0.7491635084152222,
-0.09244728833436966,
-0.4654654562473297,
-0.1820811629295349,
-0.4762190580368042,
-0.6602948904037476,
-0.6083736419677734,
-0.22003620862960815,
0.12300585955381393,
0.8324456214904785,
-0.02448873221874237,
0.7430180311203003,
-0.7315101027488708,
0.3706084191799164,
0.14381267130374908,
0.5537319183349609,
0.09762914478778839,
-0.8821915984153748,
-0.43491309881210327,
-0.2504303455352783,
-0.5534626841545105,
-0.8846872448921204,
0.6459085941314697,
0.25669562816619873,
0.37343308329582214,
0.3035792410373688,
0.004527560900896788,
0.512451171875,
-0.48834705352783203,
0.9124385714530945,
0.2937871813774109,
-1.0681843757629395,
0.4364854395389557,
-0.20690058171749115,
0.546061098575592,
0.5634526014328003,
0.4003645181655884,
-0.6503970623016357,
-0.47971639037132263,
-0.7929940819740295,
-0.7675492763519287,
0.3800813555717468,
0.3613273501396179,
0.14488884806632996,
-0.29491496086120605,
0.5455731749534607,
0.020044056698679924,
0.11293860524892807,
-1.0637586116790771,
0.015092868357896805,
-0.6209310293197632,
-0.34311631321907043,
0.13352303206920624,
-0.47522175312042236,
0.21482908725738525,
0.06389863789081573,
0.9967682361602783,
0.10574054718017578,
0.16619034111499786,
0.47231248021125793,
-0.25206536054611206,
-0.005112909246236086,
0.1907832771539688,
0.5889941453933716,
-0.0855570137500763,
0.29942142963409424,
0.06892204284667969,
0.12466773390769958,
-0.526619017124176,
0.5641126036643982,
-0.21267755329608917,
-0.11993588507175446,
0.10835807770490646,
0.30640947818756104,
0.6581867337226868,
0.15519964694976807,
-0.26223108172416687,
0.4197312891483307,
-0.2041025012731552,
-0.49810120463371277,
0.05539028346538544,
-0.03113400936126709,
-0.20036327838897705,
0.13273781538009644,
0.43749260902404785,
0.2853373885154724,
0.2793685793876648,
-0.07102669030427933,
0.3505532443523407,
0.24451373517513275,
-0.40759971737861633,
-0.08260215073823929,
0.887229859828949,
0.3762722909450531,
-0.21459367871284485,
0.6465157270431519,
-0.11866804212331772,
-0.17668572068214417,
0.5602984428405762,
0.5208866596221924,
0.9339452385902405,
-0.45219162106513977,
0.5041782855987549,
0.5170250535011292,
0.29302260279655457,
-0.6129133701324463,
-0.16409818828105927,
-0.41708657145500183,
-0.390277624130249,
-0.3061580955982208,
-0.45847851037979126,
-0.020066319033503532,
-0.3023613393306732,
-0.5097768306732178,
0.03380371630191803,
-0.41674309968948364,
-0.7497248649597168,
-0.3888324797153473,
-0.17237944900989532,
-0.5058944225311279,
0.41217273473739624,
-0.09881816059350967,
1.0486571788787842,
-0.8466849327087402,
0.9399096965789795,
0.1323586404323578,
-0.30478137731552124,
-0.48787227272987366,
0.1227228194475174,
-0.35073912143707275,
-0.362976610660553,
0.5212175846099854,
-0.1147860512137413,
-0.17886993288993835,
-0.0015696421032771468,
-0.48061177134513855,
-0.678077220916748,
0.8779605031013489,
-0.006966172251850367,
-0.35606393218040466,
-0.3393084704875946,
-0.016765723004937172,
0.7318118810653687,
-0.21986591815948486,
0.2556391954421997,
0.6808139681816101,
0.4377567768096924,
0.46078070998191833,
-0.594523012638092,
-0.1733207106590271,
-0.25065016746520996,
0.544426441192627,
0.156866192817688,
-0.8328697681427002,
0.6355165839195251,
0.08824437111616135,
-0.5428364872932434,
0.2892158031463623,
0.7094094753265381,
-0.1919594258069992,
0.28608912229537964,
0.3636537194252014,
0.9118079543113708,
0.48020145297050476,
-0.12934985756874084,
0.9133657813072205,
0.05083547532558441,
0.4157397449016571,
1.086085557937622,
-0.013623365201056004,
0.5846851468086243,
0.3038707971572876,
0.003646594937890768,
1.0092227458953857,
0.8643474578857422,
0.10185971111059189,
0.7347069382667542,
0.023159360513091087,
-0.34877315163612366,
-0.16017979383468628,
-0.014816628769040108,
-0.19979490339756012,
0.04200415313243866,
0.3735194504261017,
-0.49740123748779297,
-0.1875981092453003,
0.27322062849998474,
-0.3155686557292938,
0.34613871574401855,
-0.16656941175460815,
0.6258140802383423,
-0.027189401909708977,
-0.8960264325141907,
0.5402072668075562,
0.16120363771915436,
0.7309868335723877,
-0.44658809900283813,
0.1948121190071106,
-0.5050029754638672,
-0.023454241454601288,
-0.1736278086900711,
-0.7967144250869751,
0.5103519558906555,
-0.10109799355268478,
-0.38018539547920227,
-0.6506009101867676,
0.5412769317626953,
-0.6090555191040039,
-0.12555062770843506,
0.13249751925468445,
0.27832308411598206,
-0.19391800463199615,
0.10364662855863571,
-0.5899952054023743,
-0.12001876533031464,
-0.12128481268882751,
-0.4163821041584015,
0.0683244988322258,
0.8413311243057251,
0.21395906805992126,
0.9299891591072083,
0.22822058200836182,
-0.008716583251953125,
0.05363846942782402,
0.15623340010643005,
0.395579069852829,
-0.6451724171638489,
-0.49578770995140076,
-0.9927608370780945,
0.5155314803123474,
0.00579460896551609,
-0.15438848733901978,
0.5291322469711304,
0.35252928733825684,
0.46506640315055847,
-0.05601595342159271,
0.6930041313171387,
0.33948302268981934,
0.4074723720550537,
-0.6180768609046936,
0.5498296618461609,
-0.549735426902771,
0.280291348695755,
-0.3027680516242981,
-0.5879154801368713,
-0.10719963908195496,
0.5019630193710327,
-0.1100996658205986,
0.3484703004360199,
0.9608097672462463,
0.39560458064079285,
0.0827215388417244,
-0.0783582329750061,
0.13825060427188873,
0.1032632365822792,
0.45429784059524536,
0.6767987608909607,
0.7219597697257996,
-0.376972496509552,
0.8329469561576843,
0.05868378281593323,
-0.020652692764997482,
-0.044934600591659546,
-0.9563683271408081,
-0.9352095723152161,
-0.8606109023094177,
-0.5827280879020691,
-0.573990523815155,
-0.059804901480674744,
0.4272383153438568,
0.9344830513000488,
-0.3987124264240265,
-0.004041826818138361,
-0.4581202268600464,
0.2297145426273346,
-0.05241600424051285,
-0.2910214364528656,
0.038760002702474594,
-0.42405083775520325,
-0.8594948649406433,
0.0497114360332489,
0.29434674978256226,
0.9300636053085327,
-0.379930317401886,
0.17436325550079346,
-0.38488131761550903,
0.3375839293003082,
0.25004690885543823,
0.36884841322898865,
-0.2404644936323166,
-0.04787575080990791,
-0.1025891974568367,
-0.34867092967033386,
0.30367785692214966,
1.1463747024536133,
-1.0364292860031128,
0.5721728801727295,
0.5133140683174133,
0.5114986896514893,
0.8602722883224487,
0.20285770297050476,
0.6924541592597961,
-1.0847278833389282,
0.1512255221605301,
0.2873572111129761,
0.15060696005821228,
0.3310995399951935,
-0.2979608476161957,
0.39502182602882385,
0.37843066453933716,
-0.7205049991607666,
-0.5466560125350952,
0.1622932106256485,
-0.6767786145210266,
-0.6707932353019714,
1.0524734258651733,
0.16663455963134766,
-0.16913673281669617,
-0.26232847571372986,
-0.10740746557712555,
0.5481895208358765,
-0.556262195110321,
0.9610777497291565,
1.176988959312439,
0.04545683041214943,
-0.25780460238456726,
-0.37365996837615967,
0.589178204536438,
0.4622199535369873,
-0.5926901698112488,
-0.05017848312854767,
0.4390425384044647,
0.3814534842967987,
-0.06855183839797974,
0.8375442624092102,
-0.09029929339885712,
0.09892620146274567,
0.03591601923108101,
-0.09806306660175323,
0.25864142179489136,
-0.4743293523788452,
-0.528588056564331,
0.17763759195804596,
-0.03242850676178932,
-0.06542804092168808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11975v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11975v2 | Compress to Impress: Unleashing the Potential of Compressive Memory in Real-World Long-Term Conversations | 2024-02-19T09:19:50 | 2024-07-01T09:38:06 | Nuo Chen, Hongguang Li, Juhua Huang, Baoyuan Wang, Jia Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing retrieval-based methods have made significant strides in maintaining
long-term conversations. However, these approaches face challenges in memory
database management and accurate memory retrieval, hindering their efficacy in
dynamic, real-world interactions. This study introduces a novel framework,
COmpressive Memory-Enhanced Dialogue sYstems (COMEDY), which eschews
traditional retrieval modules and memory databases. Instead, COMEDY adopts a
"One-for-All" approach, utilizing a single language model to manage memory
generation, compression, and response generation. Central to this framework is
the concept of compressive memory, which intergrates session-specific
summaries, user-bot dynamics, and past events into a concise memory format. To
support COMEDY, we curated a large-scale Chinese instruction-tuning dataset,
Dolphin, derived from real user-chatbot interactions. Comparative evaluations
demonstrate COMEDY's superiority over traditional retrieval-based methods in
producing more nuanced and human-like conversational experiences. Our codes are
available at https://github.com/nuochenpku/COMEDY. | [
-0.2858440577983856,
-1.026324987411499,
0.27615877985954285,
0.3793349862098694,
-0.41075244545936584,
0.08509884774684906,
-0.6288496255874634,
-0.26535600423812866,
0.6751745343208313,
0.2937251925468445,
-0.5327389240264893,
-0.12313509732484818,
-0.17572008073329926,
-0.15035110712051392,
-0.3407222330570221,
0.5956405997276306,
0.6199325323104858,
-0.37823033332824707,
-0.13073554635047913,
-0.24241453409194946,
-0.6277899742126465,
-0.7923608422279358,
-0.839868426322937,
-0.18266034126281738,
0.4475604295730591,
0.4511019289493561,
1.0498664379119873,
0.32430538535118103,
0.2869148552417755,
0.24217674136161804,
0.05216414853930473,
0.25385376811027527,
-0.8798313736915588,
0.22930988669395447,
0.08834287524223328,
-0.27271610498428345,
-0.34869664907455444,
-0.36624816060066223,
0.44627365469932556,
0.7182427048683167,
-0.6512474417686462,
-0.3223464787006378,
0.19519101083278656,
0.5223298072814941,
-0.8682904243469238,
0.20633040368556976,
-0.490863174200058,
0.3269505798816681,
0.23446336388587952,
-0.5464840531349182,
-0.7383801937103271,
-0.3295234441757202,
-0.09039300680160522,
-0.6319124102592468,
-0.21299952268600464,
-0.01556011289358139,
0.8018426299095154,
0.36307263374328613,
0.08168520033359528,
-0.3484535813331604,
-0.7019253373146057,
0.6789396405220032,
-0.5754392743110657,
0.05917247757315636,
0.2245350331068039,
0.3194696605205536,
-0.3479035198688507,
-0.7069039940834045,
-0.489511102437973,
-0.15422916412353516,
0.07741930335760117,
0.355607271194458,
-0.13203296065330505,
0.16221514344215393,
0.1971447467803955,
0.3913319706916809,
-0.5185232162475586,
-0.10746071487665176,
-0.11929056793451309,
0.019121918827295303,
0.3600951135158539,
0.11805842071771622,
0.5100047588348389,
-0.2785112261772156,
-0.1646539717912674,
-0.1353798657655716,
-0.4779646396636963,
-0.1686539202928543,
0.17127706110477448,
0.29367420077323914,
-0.03714531660079956,
0.09539338201284409,
-0.24894815683364868,
0.44167962670326233,
-0.1058172956109047,
0.00389310484752059,
-0.15335401892662048,
0.009119566529989243,
-0.2762867212295532,
0.2022072672843933,
0.9358121752738953,
0.39316967129707336,
0.3919866979122162,
-0.20329347252845764,
0.1470755934715271,
-0.2611265778541565,
0.3126794993877411,
-0.7534896731376648,
-0.5583387613296509,
0.06505030393600464,
-0.4893524646759033,
-0.24821974337100983,
0.16432474553585052,
-0.7986425757408142,
-0.3377961814403534,
0.12553003430366516,
0.504649817943573,
-0.6431819796562195,
-0.21901994943618774,
0.3318789303302765,
-0.45915067195892334,
-0.16361309587955475,
0.45775002241134644,
-0.659547746181488,
0.5856907367706299,
0.6545876264572144,
0.8152095675468445,
0.009921073913574219,
0.06419962644577026,
-0.8277701735496521,
0.28789496421813965,
-0.2339351326227188,
0.7308886647224426,
-0.6785501837730408,
-0.2427247017621994,
0.16938887536525726,
-0.19494324922561646,
0.1852700412273407,
-0.8937576413154602,
0.6412594318389893,
-0.19683216512203217,
0.2562802731990814,
0.11400705575942993,
-0.3410155773162842,
0.09343782067298889,
0.2588483691215515,
-0.6059314608573914,
0.8888062834739685,
0.06706403195858002,
-0.43518704175949097,
-0.1209111288189888,
-0.3091304898262024,
-0.5721783638000488,
0.12593062222003937,
-0.2691075801849365,
-0.04189058393239975,
0.31720247864723206,
0.18380360305309296,
0.35227739810943604,
-0.37392765283584595,
0.388859361410141,
-0.372043251991272,
-0.9273365139961243,
0.40295958518981934,
-0.7775142788887024,
0.39889511466026306,
0.3307841122150421,
0.07545893639326096,
-0.4248653054237366,
-0.6649484038352966,
0.13955549895763397,
0.10752684623003006,
-0.49142077565193176,
-0.2723478674888611,
0.14664100110530853,
-0.32943615317344666,
0.18629638850688934,
0.16813303530216217,
-0.3981655240058899,
0.11569322645664215,
-0.5154332518577576,
0.5942755341529846,
0.46775487065315247,
-0.036419522017240524,
-0.005782345775514841,
-0.4733178913593292,
0.3953654170036316,
0.1540413349866867,
0.26788821816444397,
-0.8301650285720825,
-0.20346969366073608,
-0.8798984885215759,
-0.03139349818229675,
-0.039932701736688614,
0.7062692046165466,
-0.7940949201583862,
0.4937736690044403,
-0.6163368225097656,
-0.15818095207214355,
-0.2224823236465454,
-0.06510917842388153,
0.2569486200809479,
0.2886425256729126,
0.35131481289863586,
-0.703503429889679,
-0.49812594056129456,
-0.5929836630821228,
-0.10862153768539429,
-0.29924365878105164,
-0.19516421854496002,
0.6621811389923096,
-0.32388731837272644,
0.6073764562606812,
0.5754181146621704,
-0.6063203811645508,
-0.037626758217811584,
-0.4348357319831848,
0.02549363300204277,
0.3468019366264343,
0.4797370731830597,
0.15232887864112854,
-0.5287197828292847,
-0.4354609549045563,
-0.5266300439834595,
-0.6398895382881165,
0.13694453239440918,
-0.4669297933578491,
0.0676569938659668,
0.184871643781662,
0.41675809025764465,
-0.8012309670448303,
0.457309752702713,
0.17770566046237946,
0.07395027577877045,
0.5512549877166748,
-0.3653368353843689,
0.3555225133895874,
-0.9565719366073608,
-0.037535008043050766,
-0.30984535813331604,
-0.3240604102611542,
-0.3558887839317322,
-0.029752325266599655,
-0.10465668886899948,
-0.4662012755870819,
-0.47837886214256287,
0.49222275614738464,
-0.3694416284561157,
0.024581147357821465,
-0.2204395979642868,
0.42389175295829773,
-0.01717579923570156,
0.6582265496253967,
0.00751920323818922,
0.6493383646011353,
0.49437829852104187,
-0.6243312358856201,
0.473215788602829,
0.25854626297950745,
-0.3840183615684509,
0.6289185285568237,
-0.5857277512550354,
0.4036140739917755,
0.09288286417722702,
0.46985310316085815,
-1.0445139408111572,
-0.33908164501190186,
0.24260979890823364,
-0.4709939658641815,
0.5169470310211182,
-0.14947089552879333,
-0.802008867263794,
-0.39723989367485046,
-0.4200144112110138,
0.03581246733665466,
0.7814075946807861,
-0.5668372511863708,
0.3348691165447235,
0.19696561992168427,
-0.5480046272277832,
-0.6245228052139282,
-0.5996865034103394,
0.6587116122245789,
-0.37411004304885864,
-0.5391555428504944,
0.3088351786136627,
-0.3029651641845703,
0.039897289127111435,
-0.23923322558403015,
-0.10154540836811066,
-0.20948541164398193,
0.1252278983592987,
0.05625293031334877,
0.07509694248437881,
-0.29386642575263977,
0.25818535685539246,
0.06287547200918198,
0.10977312922477722,
-0.15967513620853424,
-0.03650657460093498,
0.9339442253112793,
0.3299531638622284,
-0.202133446931839,
-0.7417984008789062,
0.4565921723842621,
0.2410024255514145,
0.40268775820732117,
0.5386415719985962,
0.29911863803863525,
-0.10124475508928299,
-0.19864441454410553,
-0.5309656262397766,
-0.263338565826416,
-0.5446955561637878,
0.45611321926116943,
-0.3356417417526245,
-0.7129910588264465,
0.27872949838638306,
-0.44749876856803894,
-0.3274290859699249,
-0.1169256865978241,
0.12568841874599457,
-0.24105985462665558,
0.927189290523529,
0.4540940821170807,
-0.1576036959886551,
0.6250880360603333,
0.1309358775615692,
0.2713398039340973,
-0.693341851234436,
0.1832135170698166,
-0.2815953493118286,
-0.518737256526947,
-0.12910591065883636,
-0.4184422791004181,
0.2254648655653,
0.14152538776397705,
-0.35094916820526123,
0.33067044615745544,
-0.5073601603507996,
0.6710245013237,
0.3181396424770355,
0.26071932911872864,
0.12110274285078049,
0.15793320536613464,
0.09135988354682922,
-0.06623853743076324,
-0.8930106163024902,
-0.35206103324890137,
0.512734055519104,
0.13617444038391113,
1.0814963579177856,
0.25999557971954346,
0.6779249906539917,
0.32624515891075134,
-0.14418919384479523,
-0.6838663220405579,
0.8754720091819763,
-0.44941097497940063,
-0.04925255477428436,
-0.07460083067417145,
-0.5763282775878906,
-1.0315680503845215,
-0.1869642734527588,
0.09209001064300537,
-1.1928646564483643,
-0.08226362615823746,
0.03747514262795448,
-0.7603816390037537,
0.12537778913974762,
-0.507102906703949,
0.5881619453430176,
-0.094788558781147,
-0.6488445401191711,
-0.66566002368927,
-0.7397508025169373,
0.308523029088974,
0.31978005170822144,
0.07372485101222992,
0.01777035929262638,
0.2380753755569458,
0.4676830470561981,
-0.16798776388168335,
0.9460974335670471,
-0.02369806356728077,
0.18940316140651703,
0.29548147320747375,
0.36406630277633667,
0.3122372031211853,
0.12168239057064056,
-0.24183081090450287,
-0.1298515796661377,
0.09376887232065201,
-0.30045610666275024,
-1.078185796737671,
0.7701940536499023,
-0.5300548076629639,
-0.7248038649559021,
-0.0882803425192833,
-0.6832111477851868,
-0.14383898675441742,
-0.16669799387454987,
-0.17006205022335052,
0.7137600779533386,
-0.396397203207016,
0.3931601345539093,
0.5334821939468384,
-0.8577844500541687,
0.4944583475589752,
0.3356151580810547,
-0.10121071338653564,
-0.5882382392883301,
1.0486433506011963,
0.07082436233758926,
0.39741095900535583,
0.4478762149810791,
0.1882304847240448,
-0.0578889399766922,
0.15455681085586548,
-0.28202033042907715,
0.12077070772647858,
-0.7647061347961426,
-0.26600563526153564,
-0.6568694710731506,
-0.3024446964263916,
-0.519094705581665,
-0.09207633882761002,
-0.33077511191368103,
-0.9566607475280762,
-0.15567797422409058,
0.1841031163930893,
0.06036379933357239,
0.42407968640327454,
-0.13630571961402893,
0.2906263470649719,
-0.8896445035934448,
0.27202683687210083,
-0.016105160117149353,
0.20637081563472748,
0.20695292949676514,
-0.5339931845664978,
-0.32701754570007324,
-0.03703400865197182,
-0.7100251913070679,
-0.7185230851173401,
0.6691095232963562,
0.7621247172355652,
0.4154496192932129,
0.5218769311904907,
0.4125341475009918,
1.1083861589431763,
-0.31032252311706543,
0.9610311388969421,
0.29359203577041626,
-0.5877749919891357,
0.7405872941017151,
0.06599355489015579,
0.23690955340862274,
0.3746866285800934,
0.08063129335641861,
-0.6924031972885132,
-0.43455204367637634,
-0.8638755083084106,
-0.8246283531188965,
0.7932183742523193,
0.012070761993527412,
0.7794473171234131,
-0.39455142617225647,
0.629615306854248,
0.04372552037239075,
0.23783402144908905,
-0.3095199167728424,
-0.22142037749290466,
-0.1031874492764473,
-0.34542596340179443,
0.010231174528598785,
-0.23732078075408936,
-0.12030687928199768,
-0.1075260117650032,
0.29840266704559326,
-0.17492081224918365,
0.5863710641860962,
0.10331370681524277,
0.04202207922935486,
0.04883129894733429,
0.4278687834739685,
0.5130758285522461,
0.14322182536125183,
-0.3481953740119934,
0.25943899154663086,
-0.009144226089119911,
-0.33409547805786133,
-0.0519871786236763,
0.04920763894915581,
0.17121215164661407,
0.025244377553462982,
-0.05621581897139549,
0.8204888701438904,
0.5981666445732117,
-0.9828819036483765,
0.40380528569221497,
-0.2764742076396942,
0.32435739040374756,
-0.36245638132095337,
0.5433821082115173,
0.017838750034570694,
0.034738101065158844,
0.3787062168121338,
-0.18614046275615692,
0.22967000305652618,
-1.0891785621643066,
0.4151935577392578,
0.2576066255569458,
-0.585217297077179,
-0.22413191199302673,
0.39700600504875183,
0.27004119753837585,
-0.4321885108947754,
0.9060463905334473,
-0.1735641062259674,
-0.43350863456726074,
0.4149101674556732,
0.8619332313537598,
0.6181172132492065,
0.019502058625221252,
0.1996498554944992,
0.6287694573402405,
-0.17884543538093567,
-0.2506762444972992,
0.33721020817756653,
-0.5352003574371338,
-0.5771123766899109,
-0.4508608281612396,
-0.2746823728084564,
-0.5228137969970703,
0.01039083767682314,
-0.7137072086334229,
0.2724952697753906,
-0.5085561275482178,
-0.0584540069103241,
-0.5725997686386108,
0.12226246297359467,
-0.12958969175815582,
0.09578032046556473,
0.33828672766685486,
1.0608370304107666,
-0.3225352466106415,
0.9624811410903931,
0.28452056646347046,
-0.39109161496162415,
-0.6478174328804016,
0.12148699164390564,
-0.2056031972169876,
-0.769570529460907,
0.47196924686431885,
0.3732885718345642,
0.11317835003137589,
0.03583601117134094,
-0.6366819143295288,
-0.4243038594722748,
0.9342361688613892,
0.6934247016906738,
-0.40994593501091003,
-0.11008496582508087,
0.14352107048034668,
0.41513708233833313,
-0.22789199650287628,
0.4926803410053253,
0.4688602089881897,
0.07343816757202148,
0.4566769301891327,
-0.9896559119224548,
0.10193496942520142,
-0.2945793867111206,
-0.34369784593582153,
0.05112572759389877,
-1.1036059856414795,
0.3294999301433563,
-0.29473045468330383,
-0.5063594579696655,
0.29886069893836975,
0.7877830266952515,
0.3831537961959839,
0.2558668553829193,
0.2833287715911865,
0.6866101622581482,
0.8439232110977173,
-0.06763026863336563,
0.9950747489929199,
-0.4935373067855835,
0.0624198280274868,
1.5311601161956787,
-0.30602967739105225,
0.9738956093788147,
0.36271345615386963,
-0.0013124288525432348,
0.6147763133049011,
0.31512975692749023,
0.29384875297546387,
0.46738073229789734,
0.330128937959671,
-0.23968034982681274,
-0.4385453760623932,
-0.3008025288581848,
-0.05029842630028725,
0.08001797646284103,
0.6162502765655518,
-0.0005115119274705648,
-0.08205889165401459,
-0.06067649647593498,
-0.019101794809103012,
0.0961238443851471,
0.12670853734016418,
0.8995934128761292,
0.40173470973968506,
-0.8147972226142883,
0.7409027218818665,
-0.5206389427185059,
0.8103018403053284,
-0.452174574136734,
-0.3045012354850769,
-0.4408574104309082,
0.10551204532384872,
0.12959261238574982,
-0.8822326064109802,
0.20324017107486725,
-0.17396460473537445,
0.3686639070510864,
-0.08743027597665787,
0.8612546324729919,
-0.406817227602005,
-0.028972355648875237,
0.20091724395751953,
0.2555854022502899,
0.610317051410675,
-0.10581488907337189,
-0.8230026960372925,
0.4157963693141937,
-0.265348345041275,
-0.12829527258872986,
0.40972912311553955,
0.6588952541351318,
0.3841122090816498,
0.9976281523704529,
0.2063474953174591,
0.11555908620357513,
-0.16742192208766937,
0.27793464064598083,
0.7494633197784424,
-0.8817784786224365,
-0.5023833513259888,
-0.7391590476036072,
0.26558393239974976,
-0.3964124917984009,
0.009964266791939735,
0.4508378803730011,
0.7137207984924316,
0.26288115978240967,
0.1743364781141281,
0.6886335015296936,
-0.1430860310792923,
0.40875566005706787,
-0.40640929341316223,
0.6265682578086853,
-0.58890300989151,
0.3042784333229065,
-0.16534638404846191,
-0.5485002398490906,
-0.2480866014957428,
0.6551199555397034,
0.17968669533729553,
-0.06187635287642479,
0.541357696056366,
0.8031390905380249,
-0.24820424616336823,
0.06046626344323158,
0.8502491116523743,
0.3318901062011719,
0.3317554295063019,
1.0215996503829956,
1.086166501045227,
-0.44470497965812683,
0.9092282652854919,
-0.15186147391796112,
-0.010554568842053413,
-0.3047275245189667,
-0.742205023765564,
-0.5288936495780945,
-0.3975227177143097,
-0.4808642566204071,
-0.3746248781681061,
0.2612147331237793,
0.9628797173500061,
0.7064931392669678,
-0.34313979744911194,
-0.2978236675262451,
0.13196153938770294,
-0.0999809205532074,
-0.242955282330513,
-0.293483167886734,
0.2875955402851105,
-0.6437755227088928,
-0.8387883305549622,
0.5584270358085632,
0.7561054825782776,
-0.252862811088562,
-0.13424152135849,
-0.15267153084278107,
0.19972926378250122,
0.5120615363121033,
0.4989725351333618,
0.43908393383026123,
-0.4197089970111847,
-0.37836748361587524,
-0.05857807770371437,
-0.10960054397583008,
0.4556286931037903,
0.6278091073036194,
-1.1162469387054443,
0.438498318195343,
0.33887287974357605,
0.3387598395347595,
0.1758168786764145,
0.08099376410245895,
0.7823701500892639,
-0.7549506425857544,
0.4173000156879425,
0.11703875660896301,
0.282910019159317,
0.3883030116558075,
-0.3940899968147278,
0.5173999071121216,
0.17778898775577545,
-0.6554513573646545,
-0.9097647070884705,
0.05925176665186882,
-1.185158371925354,
-0.4072195589542389,
0.9078853726387024,
-0.48368966579437256,
-0.24791169166564941,
-0.16431647539138794,
-0.3687155544757843,
0.2973771393299103,
-0.6229106187820435,
1.1538974046707153,
0.728805422782898,
-0.34749603271484375,
-0.505142092704773,
-0.496815949678421,
0.30327174067497253,
0.5331316590309143,
-0.6292099952697754,
0.2712406814098358,
0.5888242721557617,
-0.09562068432569504,
0.20795927941799164,
0.7608024477958679,
-0.02305557206273079,
0.43581050634384155,
0.010552231222391129,
-0.12864996492862701,
0.2753422260284424,
-0.2715313136577606,
-0.047957103699445724,
0.507231593132019,
-0.1100689172744751,
0.16957151889801025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11968v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11968v2 | What Do Dialect Speakers Want? A Survey of Attitudes Towards Language Technology for German Dialects | 2024-02-19T09:15:28 | 2024-06-07T13:05:01 | Verena Blaschke, Christoph Purschke, Hinrich Schütze, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural language processing (NLP) has largely focused on modelling
standardized languages. More recently, attention has increasingly shifted to
local, non-standardized languages and dialects. However, the relevant speaker
populations' needs and wishes with respect to NLP tools are largely unknown. In
this paper, we focus on dialects and regional languages related to German -- a
group of varieties that is heterogeneous in terms of prestige and
standardization. We survey speakers of these varieties (N=327) and present
their opinions on hypothetical language technologies for their dialects.
Although attitudes vary among subgroups of our respondents, we find that
respondents are especially in favour of potential NLP tools that work with
dialectal input (especially audio input) such as virtual assistants, and less
so for applications that produce dialectal output such as machine translation
or spellcheckers. | [
-1.0435186624526978,
-0.703554630279541,
0.5611987709999084,
0.24314765632152557,
-0.04984385147690773,
-0.2627178430557251,
-0.3607831299304962,
-0.5250166058540344,
0.709923505783081,
0.6312073469161987,
-0.338339626789093,
-0.27550041675567627,
-0.3563099801540375,
0.2113122045993805,
-0.5575911998748779,
0.6212794184684753,
0.4160904288291931,
-0.06955868005752563,
0.00987014826387167,
0.028650417923927307,
-0.3453504145145416,
-0.9222590923309326,
-0.5426051616668701,
-0.5140202641487122,
0.6074460744857788,
0.5945427417755127,
1.0633822679519653,
0.2729948163032532,
0.16176651418209076,
0.4153635501861572,
-0.21783031523227692,
-0.4938306510448456,
0.2711392939090729,
0.19920894503593445,
-0.24995148181915283,
-0.3371354937553406,
-0.6959558129310608,
0.04396761953830719,
0.3054562509059906,
1.0188781023025513,
0.014061790890991688,
0.07944300025701523,
-0.281239777803421,
0.6860467195510864,
-0.1719183772802353,
0.09535116702318192,
-0.3421285152435303,
0.38216888904571533,
-0.4484841227531433,
-0.10465489327907562,
-0.20048826932907104,
-0.566819429397583,
0.17211969196796417,
-0.3530932068824768,
0.5130600333213806,
-0.06443791091442108,
0.9873321652412415,
-0.0965833067893982,
-0.7532528042793274,
-0.08283933252096176,
-0.9515122175216675,
0.5486121773719788,
-0.8736985921859741,
0.6856182813644409,
0.6236579418182373,
0.41142433881759644,
0.08490193635225296,
-0.5750499963760376,
-0.5072398781776428,
-0.22342213988304138,
-0.14329072833061218,
0.1512659192085266,
-0.22838512063026428,
0.254980206489563,
0.11310546845197678,
0.5539699196815491,
-0.5358825922012329,
0.44722941517829895,
0.021107420325279236,
0.10795347392559052,
0.5044105052947998,
-0.19061633944511414,
0.11089091002941132,
-0.1805494725704193,
0.30028748512268066,
0.048792459070682526,
-0.20581448078155518,
-0.02675740234553814,
0.5860173106193542,
0.5081700086593628,
-0.06623945385217667,
0.5052229166030884,
-0.532391369342804,
1.1468759775161743,
0.3275696337223053,
0.05995564162731171,
0.42909157276153564,
-0.17541302740573883,
-0.05375528335571289,
-0.09661390632390976,
0.3710345923900604,
0.2124139666557312,
0.49124231934547424,
-0.30949121713638306,
-0.49687814712524414,
-0.34853342175483704,
0.27684733271598816,
-0.3519126772880554,
-0.16913753747940063,
0.44189080595970154,
-0.24963253736495972,
0.05882536992430687,
0.07078400999307632,
-0.989368736743927,
-0.2428443878889084,
-0.417468786239624,
0.16729971766471863,
-0.4134496748447418,
-0.564826488494873,
0.34369030594825745,
-0.7171231508255005,
0.10396668314933777,
0.3870581388473511,
-1.4674779176712036,
0.32644087076187134,
0.6408441662788391,
0.5816042423248291,
0.0016617742367088795,
0.06568702310323715,
-0.20478737354278564,
-0.26584699749946594,
-0.2849818170070648,
0.914097011089325,
-0.4842384457588196,
-0.7761110067367554,
0.4120892286300659,
-0.011756522580981255,
0.10336978733539581,
-0.7449798583984375,
0.3729283809661865,
-0.6100839376449585,
0.6609857082366943,
-0.33888813853263855,
-0.32687878608703613,
0.016563689336180687,
0.13159963488578796,
-0.6734949946403503,
0.8738471269607544,
0.213975191116333,
-0.5063589215278625,
0.5950661897659302,
-0.5309794545173645,
-0.680269181728363,
0.3034936487674713,
0.0023321176413446665,
0.23822341859340668,
0.4300306439399719,
0.051522716879844666,
0.35653162002563477,
-0.12282732129096985,
0.2834472954273224,
-0.3511069416999817,
-0.08941306173801422,
0.22126656770706177,
-0.3832513093948364,
0.4949897527694702,
0.42344608902931213,
-0.42650067806243896,
-0.2104238122701645,
-0.5955079793930054,
0.3440690338611603,
-0.16230742633342743,
-0.21777671575546265,
-0.279619038105011,
0.21172817051410675,
0.30203646421432495,
0.4646741449832916,
0.3228825032711029,
-0.657968282699585,
-0.07932215929031372,
-0.5828863382339478,
0.07068028301000595,
0.8541699647903442,
-0.2219649702310562,
0.7141884565353394,
-0.23048865795135498,
0.5181116461753845,
-0.08893799781799316,
0.053974926471710205,
0.3805379569530487,
-0.5580284595489502,
-1.0094321966171265,
-0.07524049282073975,
0.46289876103401184,
0.3550712466239929,
-0.6248563528060913,
0.7434833645820618,
-0.2199275940656662,
-0.6910845637321472,
-0.27013149857521057,
-0.08794880658388138,
0.03775760158896446,
0.4056548774242401,
-0.023471806198358536,
-0.4595072865486145,
-0.35027480125427246,
-1.2635219097137451,
-0.05378936603665352,
-0.45508259534835815,
-0.38621142506599426,
0.3931877315044403,
-0.07725948840379715,
-0.06359395384788513,
1.2422451972961426,
-0.30068257451057434,
-0.05026702582836151,
-0.4478840231895447,
-0.005744414869695902,
0.2603400945663452,
0.06970253586769104,
0.9350245594978333,
-1.0632582902908325,
-0.5437051653862,
0.48451000452041626,
-0.6587110757827759,
-0.4289332628250122,
0.35650134086608887,
0.4425821900367737,
0.558571994304657,
0.31626611948013306,
-0.2773241102695465,
-0.09808952361345291,
0.758027195930481,
-0.03768499940633774,
0.38533729314804077,
-0.009600978344678879,
0.2200806736946106,
-0.8037521839141846,
0.052963610738515854,
0.38202372193336487,
-0.1574629694223404,
-1.014214038848877,
0.09648700058460236,
-0.4212269186973572,
-0.06846155971288681,
-0.34579023718833923,
0.6640397906303406,
-0.11286193877458572,
-0.35464051365852356,
-0.1809133142232895,
0.201707661151886,
-0.045993249863386154,
0.09144850820302963,
0.7631127834320068,
0.722449779510498,
0.17801332473754883,
-0.5629603862762451,
0.44816654920578003,
-0.058745380491018295,
-0.14005395770072937,
0.524568498134613,
-0.6129863858222961,
0.35659417510032654,
0.06622113287448883,
-0.09081102162599564,
-0.47195205092430115,
-0.5014634132385254,
-0.20522907376289368,
-0.592231273651123,
0.11206213384866714,
0.004973142873495817,
-0.4088784158229828,
-0.3014783561229706,
0.14746129512786865,
-0.2526528835296631,
0.6813802123069763,
-0.20642182230949402,
0.5233259797096252,
0.560470461845398,
-0.6142880320549011,
-0.17397041618824005,
-0.9052313566207886,
0.19399882853031158,
-0.3165847957134247,
-0.7042474150657654,
-0.02147097699344158,
0.3237384855747223,
-0.7215554118156433,
0.0688151866197586,
0.034413691610097885,
-0.4517175853252411,
-0.015227166935801506,
0.14678610861301422,
-0.05022791773080826,
-0.497952938079834,
0.04962947964668274,
-0.049215901643037796,
-0.24963907897472382,
-0.2432468831539154,
-0.4331950843334198,
0.831534743309021,
-0.4544315040111542,
-0.37610524892807007,
-0.043426599353551865,
0.8072174787521362,
0.22366197407245636,
0.03637928143143654,
0.31287050247192383,
0.49707335233688354,
-0.011581292375922203,
-0.14310401678085327,
-0.6763002872467041,
-0.2834414541721344,
-0.554965615272522,
0.5071932077407837,
-0.516944944858551,
-1.1649807691574097,
0.18194837868213654,
-0.09328632801771164,
0.039978284388780594,
0.4048856198787689,
0.7485494017601013,
-0.4565972685813904,
0.6720438003540039,
0.7461454272270203,
-0.28822869062423706,
0.545137345790863,
0.32742854952812195,
0.4136017858982086,
0.18518896400928497,
0.2035292536020279,
-1.0393234491348267,
-0.04717770591378212,
-0.6711103916168213,
0.1106574758887291,
0.4830889105796814,
-0.3289523124694824,
0.05775909498333931,
0.5387932658195496,
-0.23890690505504608,
-0.0538882240653038,
1.0886131525039673,
-0.25037673115730286,
0.21300823986530304,
0.0628398209810257,
0.2213500589132309,
-0.17882443964481354,
-0.7871257662773132,
-0.6580497026443481,
0.4037542939186096,
0.19190053641796112,
0.3590313792228699,
0.11547467857599258,
0.9225664734840393,
0.5979800224304199,
-0.45717719197273254,
-0.8726564049720764,
0.6463951468467712,
-0.2533820867538452,
-0.7983464002609253,
-0.3587203919887543,
-0.14947205781936646,
-0.8543024659156799,
0.10704907774925232,
0.05060483142733574,
-0.7419925928115845,
0.3913673162460327,
0.43466609716415405,
0.10816925019025803,
0.4602508842945099,
-0.873984158039093,
0.7676942944526672,
-0.02453349158167839,
0.2937270700931549,
-0.2674390971660614,
-0.7899695634841919,
-0.0038862985093146563,
-0.1837848573923111,
0.3739401400089264,
0.058510672301054,
0.26819878816604614,
0.15342944860458374,
-0.2618100941181183,
0.593146026134491,
-0.22575105726718903,
-0.15877537429332733,
0.10604476928710938,
0.029492314904928207,
0.03135156258940697,
-0.37557828426361084,
-0.5195493102073669,
0.4551423490047455,
0.3093410134315491,
-0.42149287462234497,
-0.38103559613227844,
0.4000537693500519,
-0.6499890685081482,
-1.0961235761642456,
-0.5354509949684143,
-0.3748146891593933,
-0.6067668795585632,
0.1092585101723671,
0.32911011576652527,
0.35317808389663696,
-0.4850848913192749,
-0.014051114208996296,
0.4305647611618042,
-0.16137970983982086,
0.43837541341781616,
0.2715499699115753,
-0.4344301223754883,
0.19018582999706268,
1.0082770586013794,
0.2716559171676636,
0.7887680530548096,
0.09598571807146072,
-0.01702778786420822,
-0.03792664781212807,
-0.3631259500980377,
-0.7190189957618713,
0.0776163637638092,
-0.6174874305725098,
0.5849131345748901,
-0.4814448952674866,
-0.3142428696155548,
-0.7060171365737915,
-0.42984190583229065,
-0.3207285404205322,
-0.7763971090316772,
-0.056950539350509644,
-0.14657041430473328,
0.1295499950647354,
0.7864739894866943,
-0.21843773126602173,
0.2703574001789093,
-0.6298338174819946,
0.25976118445396423,
0.3768500089645386,
0.18592405319213867,
-0.5807263851165771,
-0.5373730659484863,
-0.0760306641459465,
-0.011603632010519505,
0.09562718123197556,
-0.6175982356071472,
0.45470306277275085,
0.10760832577943802,
0.3843217194080353,
0.36184605956077576,
0.0661839172244072,
0.18999208509922028,
-0.40679994225502014,
1.0747264623641968,
-0.1727571040391922,
-0.7864267230033875,
0.31117546558380127,
-0.3209463357925415,
0.2200155109167099,
0.39043310284614563,
0.10538242757320404,
-1.360646367073059,
-0.5468195080757141,
-0.585207998752594,
-0.6143620014190674,
0.8339576125144958,
-0.28595900535583496,
0.5581527352333069,
0.1044904887676239,
-0.17572952806949615,
0.1972135454416275,
0.5260813236236572,
-0.48152267932891846,
-0.12396058440208435,
-0.39731258153915405,
0.2161695659160614,
-0.1841474324464798,
-0.06954052299261093,
-0.16457770764827728,
-0.00041693192906677723,
0.5567757487297058,
0.03136751055717468,
0.3548162281513214,
-0.1424872875213623,
0.4349639117717743,
0.10869963467121124,
0.8850072026252747,
0.027913061901926994,
0.2825458347797394,
-0.36926817893981934,
0.29731714725494385,
-0.06423451006412506,
-0.2419712245464325,
0.3837890326976776,
0.0473562553524971,
-0.680246889591217,
0.6297224164009094,
0.08687983453273773,
0.6405218243598938,
-0.45525577664375305,
-0.2891807556152344,
0.2657092213630676,
0.2785598039627075,
-0.12679454684257507,
-0.3951806128025055,
-0.011856716126203537,
0.28397634625434875,
-0.17414048314094543,
-0.03281809389591217,
0.2743018567562103,
0.31834590435028076,
-0.6696452498435974,
-0.039109859615564346,
0.3538353145122528,
-0.7159963846206665,
-0.5739848017692566,
0.17011837661266327,
0.33107003569602966,
-0.6188291311264038,
0.39044973254203796,
-0.3430512249469757,
-0.26853013038635254,
0.4400421380996704,
0.4891955554485321,
1.0354533195495605,
-0.06235133484005928,
0.6417322158813477,
-0.09371224045753479,
0.23931394517421722,
0.33172333240509033,
0.16961753368377686,
-0.06949391216039658,
-0.8908182978630066,
0.1813630312681198,
-0.6518182158470154,
-0.6156198382377625,
-0.31192973256111145,
-0.48847687244415283,
0.4340533912181854,
-0.3796648383140564,
-0.6489306092262268,
-0.09440342336893082,
-0.7101649045944214,
-0.479342520236969,
0.1977091282606125,
0.1866442710161209,
0.9423514604568481,
-0.91219162940979,
1.1199071407318115,
0.8557832837104797,
-0.1274973303079605,
-0.30654099583625793,
0.18346433341503143,
0.26085883378982544,
-0.46223002672195435,
0.5955125689506531,
-0.3785679042339325,
-0.15472328662872314,
-0.12895607948303223,
-0.18559414148330688,
-0.5788975954055786,
0.13779723644256592,
0.32627469301223755,
-0.2692953944206238,
-0.2783221900463104,
0.6119740009307861,
0.6441104412078857,
0.22033855319023132,
-0.007904352620244026,
0.7441090941429138,
0.7032442092895508,
-0.2390465885400772,
-1.1814839839935303,
-0.7017952799797058,
-0.3984925150871277,
0.040698014199733734,
0.3124058246612549,
-0.6263028383255005,
0.6985700130462646,
0.3832698166370392,
-0.0349605455994606,
-0.14798367023468018,
0.40922001004219055,
-0.1819513589143753,
0.29318591952323914,
0.5279167890548706,
0.09456462413072586,
0.22006256878376007,
-0.2955131232738495,
1.1300795078277588,
-0.2794497311115265,
-0.24046814441680908,
0.9272245764732361,
-0.47521984577178955,
0.6428353190422058,
0.6125853657722473,
-0.3507169187068939,
0.4019051492214203,
0.6493716239929199,
0.30539417266845703,
0.3918765187263489,
-0.10817091912031174,
-0.5042195320129395,
-0.3333103060722351,
-0.3899867832660675,
-0.3878072202205658,
0.49260714650154114,
0.2217288613319397,
-0.022797290235757828,
-0.19661490619182587,
-0.07235398143529892,
0.2164287567138672,
0.21290025115013123,
0.09745053201913834,
0.7411631941795349,
0.033961620181798935,
-0.6933789849281311,
0.1174839586019516,
0.3356291949748993,
0.6569228768348694,
-0.9702000617980957,
0.4032655954360962,
-0.252627968788147,
-0.07764583826065063,
-0.1883276402950287,
-0.8607008457183838,
0.3093712627887726,
-0.10164927691221237,
-0.19189560413360596,
-0.3055572807788849,
0.6547277569770813,
-0.08121175318956375,
-0.2483639121055603,
0.22452399134635925,
0.8285507559776306,
0.3613557815551758,
-0.15960875153541565,
-0.2903071939945221,
-0.466739684343338,
0.08565287292003632,
-0.32839086651802063,
0.39004960656166077,
0.47104784846305847,
-0.17141804099082947,
0.4654240310192108,
0.22000780701637268,
0.4207290709018707,
0.18200793862342834,
0.1406286060810089,
0.6968068480491638,
-0.49368318915367126,
-0.18945743143558502,
-0.42368578910827637,
0.22867225110530853,
-0.008415532298386097,
-0.5851571559906006,
1.1763341426849365,
0.43911415338516235,
0.9455581903457642,
-0.16401714086532593,
1.0210729837417603,
-0.5350183248519897,
0.3845635652542114,
-0.23582443594932556,
0.2567456066608429,
-0.5171732902526855,
-0.2171313613653183,
-0.5113070607185364,
-0.8401860594749451,
0.09397412091493607,
0.240229532122612,
-0.27094078063964844,
0.14125418663024902,
0.4395885765552521,
0.6448497772216797,
-0.10236725956201553,
0.6139507293701172,
0.5848901271820068,
-0.08770470321178436,
0.1160159781575203,
0.1529160439968109,
0.48345619440078735,
0.2684357464313507,
-0.07588963955640793,
-0.5856668949127197,
-0.13999541103839874,
0.06833236664533615,
-0.5456804037094116,
-0.3050117790699005,
-0.7976722121238708,
0.047912873327732086,
-0.29292207956314087,
-0.004946084227412939,
0.8865779042243958,
0.5647812485694885,
-1.0184673070907593,
-0.7143834233283997,
0.20805777609348297,
-0.16473963856697083,
-0.08191376179456711,
-0.24348728358745575,
-0.22349359095096588,
-0.5941676497459412,
-1.1115955114364624,
0.35647961497306824,
0.4636646807193756,
0.03853940963745117,
-0.2908988893032074,
0.10591597855091095,
-0.04605570062994957,
0.08082671463489532,
0.4802808165550232,
0.6187241673469543,
-0.8212336897850037,
-0.5471857190132141,
0.256693035364151,
-0.25143516063690186,
0.21855250000953674,
0.6676822900772095,
-0.6005407571792603,
0.5801479816436768,
0.28223350644111633,
0.3149036169052124,
0.48662927746772766,
-0.04728398844599724,
0.7818357348442078,
-0.679844319820404,
0.6502346992492676,
0.49027493596076965,
0.404911607503891,
0.22673262655735016,
0.0194858405739069,
0.42386138439178467,
0.4062669277191162,
-0.6397613286972046,
-0.3914654552936554,
0.37105515599250793,
-0.8047084212303162,
-0.2510603368282318,
1.305342674255371,
0.027170561254024506,
0.03463535010814667,
-0.4677598476409912,
-0.23523111641407013,
-0.18928387761116028,
-0.4533611834049225,
0.32349681854248047,
0.9225149750709534,
-0.08491994440555573,
0.11509774625301361,
-0.8234850764274597,
0.3009392023086548,
0.5510194897651672,
-0.6245785355567932,
-0.13891415297985077,
0.8539811968803406,
-0.08483118563890457,
0.2697255611419678,
0.9469148516654968,
-0.04945606738328934,
0.1225232258439064,
0.31076347827911377,
0.23334616422653198,
0.36758953332901,
-0.2021128088235855,
-0.5309468507766724,
0.35014277696609497,
0.377765417098999,
0.03382761403918266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13284v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13284v2 | Structure Guided Large Language Model for SQL Generation | 2024-02-19T09:07:59 | 2024-03-27T14:30:44 | Qinggang Zhang, Junnan Dong, Hao Chen, Wentao Li, Feiran Huang, Xiao Huang | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL | Generating accurate Structured Querying Language (SQL) is a long-standing
problem, especially in matching users' semantic queries with structured
databases and then generating structured SQL. Existing models typically input
queries and database schemas into the LLM and rely on the LLM to perform
semantic-structure matching and generate structured SQL. However, such
solutions overlook the structural information within user queries and
databases, which can be utilized to enhance the generation of structured SQL.
This oversight can lead to inaccurate or unexecutable SQL generation. To fully
exploit the structure, we propose a structure-to-SQL framework, which leverages
the inherent structure information to improve the SQL generation of LLMs.
Specifically, we introduce our Structure Guided SQL~(SGU-SQL) generation model.
SGU-SQL first links user queries and databases in a structure-enhanced manner.
It then decomposes complicated linked structures with grammar trees to guide
the LLM to generate the SQL step by step. Extensive experiments on two
benchmark datasets illustrate that SGU-SQL can outperform sixteen SQL
generation baselines. | [
0.19486822187900543,
-0.9958615899085999,
0.6784895062446594,
0.1637742966413498,
-0.2452857494354248,
-0.07303395867347717,
0.05803203210234642,
-0.29271838068962097,
0.20189498364925385,
0.8334261178970337,
-0.7513197660446167,
-0.7475560903549194,
0.05408768728375435,
0.029016511514782906,
-0.46279171109199524,
0.7811574935913086,
0.4775177836418152,
0.19869138300418854,
-0.17368629574775696,
0.19387252628803253,
-0.36323094367980957,
-0.7492071986198425,
-0.506145179271698,
-0.06981362402439117,
0.3544534742832184,
0.26664936542510986,
0.6600002646446228,
0.9078105688095093,
0.2576579749584198,
0.20144438743591309,
-0.35742679238319397,
0.22333134710788727,
-0.7227667570114136,
0.42643409967422485,
-0.16154108941555023,
-0.6079517006874084,
-0.7460176348686218,
-0.5984636545181274,
0.8085795640945435,
1.0768640041351318,
-0.4746250808238983,
0.12348003685474396,
0.010185642167925835,
0.9402171969413757,
-0.27289697527885437,
0.36183249950408936,
-1.025312066078186,
-0.024128906428813934,
-0.49561819434165955,
-0.3003276586532593,
-0.5386607646942139,
-0.39576420187950134,
-0.5689824223518372,
-0.30239787697792053,
0.3506767749786377,
0.3786831498146057,
0.5639600157737732,
0.15720683336257935,
-0.6377846002578735,
-0.2570135295391083,
-0.6209309697151184,
0.32723116874694824,
-0.6949176788330078,
0.47825929522514343,
0.1396600902080536,
0.3679018020629883,
-0.9542198777198792,
-0.5437994599342346,
-0.22560515999794006,
-0.5182558298110962,
-0.2179802805185318,
-0.16125519573688507,
0.399705171585083,
0.18123194575309753,
0.41539278626441956,
0.39782413840293884,
-0.764153778553009,
0.05278778448700905,
-0.3725394010543823,
0.07335847616195679,
0.7822977304458618,
0.35758689045906067,
0.27562621235847473,
-0.5246511101722717,
-0.3151725232601166,
0.23735153675079346,
-1.4060308933258057,
-0.2681799829006195,
0.4501303732395172,
0.765378475189209,
0.4870358109474182,
0.9959774613380432,
-0.39527440071105957,
1.0063591003417969,
0.08464014530181885,
0.16600564122200012,
-0.13058459758758545,
-0.5812817215919495,
-0.29539796710014343,
0.22559240460395813,
0.685454785823822,
0.24577611684799194,
0.1260230541229248,
-0.09072259068489075,
-0.28755608201026917,
0.055401310324668884,
0.07302337139844894,
-1.0039854049682617,
-0.3004091680049896,
0.29365184903144836,
-0.27318835258483887,
-0.37695640325546265,
-0.0815856084227562,
-0.4138498306274414,
-0.34014731645584106,
0.052359890192747116,
-0.08483172953128815,
-0.3332165777683258,
-0.3619121313095093,
-0.20344044268131256,
0.08143714815378189,
0.39335712790489197,
0.029616380110383034,
-0.9269816279411316,
0.33477890491485596,
0.5597500205039978,
0.5717741847038269,
-0.30094391107559204,
0.11327449232339859,
-0.7695618867874146,
0.7876375913619995,
-0.4747813940048218,
0.6768213510513306,
-0.5760722160339355,
-0.643301248550415,
-0.09826012700796127,
-0.10481778532266617,
0.18898069858551025,
-0.5983866453170776,
0.35598814487457275,
-0.3866135776042938,
0.3774007260799408,
-0.3086246848106384,
-0.8028564453125,
0.3275885283946991,
0.03099958226084709,
-0.6397005319595337,
1.1587350368499756,
0.19165566563606262,
-0.3350059986114502,
0.6009111404418945,
-0.6517590284347534,
-0.7200995683670044,
0.47874170541763306,
-0.6319762468338013,
-0.4765188694000244,
0.40711694955825806,
0.2313467264175415,
0.4926057755947113,
-0.36797547340393066,
0.5755103230476379,
-0.2704538106918335,
-0.3002586364746094,
-0.2764493525028229,
0.1825650930404663,
0.7288079261779785,
0.23758433759212494,
-0.029197515919804573,
0.30129384994506836,
-1.0763922929763794,
0.20686151087284088,
0.4200271964073181,
-0.6372385025024414,
-0.10975773632526398,
0.3065791428089142,
-0.056575994938611984,
0.08363715559244156,
0.05213053524494171,
-0.447122186422348,
0.2402665615081787,
-0.7736983299255371,
0.5420820713043213,
0.4794270694255829,
0.060204122215509415,
0.49801507592201233,
0.21940472722053528,
0.38877153396606445,
0.146505206823349,
-0.028072480112314224,
-0.3437061905860901,
-0.29751721024513245,
-0.36480772495269775,
0.06416598707437515,
-0.08886400610208511,
0.39953312277793884,
-0.43005821108818054,
0.5316882729530334,
-0.1643189638853073,
-0.34490442276000977,
0.0872858315706253,
0.20562008023262024,
0.30136972665786743,
0.5614997148513794,
0.23602963984012604,
-0.23896217346191406,
-0.534049928188324,
-0.7353730797767639,
-0.5071336627006531,
-0.3529568612575531,
-0.16002152860164642,
0.6406907439231873,
0.20692378282546997,
0.18260031938552856,
0.7001819014549255,
-0.7913921475410461,
-0.36744892597198486,
-0.2775198817253113,
-0.42020487785339355,
0.2838377058506012,
0.4677639305591583,
0.422656774520874,
-0.5665428638458252,
-0.34124794602394104,
0.13308772444725037,
-0.7309686541557312,
0.059329766780138016,
0.0259333997964859,
-0.30372071266174316,
0.37439417839050293,
0.7258036136627197,
-0.7157290577888489,
0.09322081506252289,
0.10051510483026505,
-0.5556787848472595,
0.5777941942214966,
-0.0379452258348465,
-0.24205850064754486,
-1.5025657415390015,
0.015657585114240646,
-0.22899062931537628,
-0.24372096359729767,
-0.45050331950187683,
0.2893850803375244,
0.06945905834436417,
-0.48640671372413635,
-0.18032488226890564,
0.24526089429855347,
-0.8477732539176941,
-0.4105575680732727,
0.08238884806632996,
-0.00256362440995872,
0.0006069822702556849,
0.33216047286987305,
-0.06535904109477997,
0.7857440114021301,
0.43164339661598206,
-0.5015972852706909,
0.3510878384113312,
0.2992895543575287,
-0.3954814672470093,
0.7155156135559082,
-0.8320813179016113,
0.11130319535732269,
-0.05347457155585289,
0.27438777685165405,
-0.9507008790969849,
-0.721160352230072,
-0.0666579157114029,
-0.24362923204898834,
0.4606100916862488,
-0.4480363130569458,
-0.3954388201236725,
-0.3134981393814087,
-0.0007610117318108678,
0.05925222113728523,
0.3259618580341339,
-0.5128268599510193,
0.6972679495811462,
0.25954312086105347,
-0.17492933571338654,
-0.5498489737510681,
-0.726593554019928,
0.2849625051021576,
-0.1350809782743454,
-0.951557993888855,
0.5041969418525696,
0.14361906051635742,
-0.07553680986166,
0.0666448101401329,
-0.21478863060474396,
-0.11254636943340302,
0.052580706775188446,
0.25329747796058655,
0.29864436388015747,
-0.6831850409507751,
0.14238956570625305,
0.15940532088279724,
0.33658647537231445,
0.19193756580352783,
-0.3950038552284241,
0.5854401588439941,
-0.0529562272131443,
-0.3814055621623993,
-0.07157240808010101,
0.4883149266242981,
0.2860673666000366,
-0.30071184039115906,
0.7601999640464783,
0.0977153480052948,
-0.17873349785804749,
-0.5681132674217224,
-0.3829682767391205,
-0.3272697925567627,
-0.43860164284706116,
0.8013224005699158,
-0.6988630294799805,
-0.8228535652160645,
0.37192395329475403,
-0.20981889963150024,
0.07078016549348831,
0.4813114106655121,
0.49833840131759644,
-0.09212445467710495,
1.2298692464828491,
0.6030019521713257,
0.38880017399787903,
0.5862339735031128,
0.207396000623703,
0.08348259329795837,
-0.47022607922554016,
-0.39559465646743774,
-0.6073926687240601,
0.04009125009179115,
-0.31180906295776367,
-0.259794145822525,
0.07466171681880951,
0.37543973326683044,
-0.26956942677497864,
0.4334760308265686,
-0.6514912247657776,
0.7525340914726257,
0.22763603925704956,
-0.0549430288374424,
0.43230772018432617,
0.3993772864341736,
-0.16148222982883453,
0.19274869561195374,
-0.8116636872291565,
-0.25799328088760376,
0.9901341199874878,
-0.15552671253681183,
0.9049406051635742,
0.19820134341716766,
0.9008362889289856,
0.07140713930130005,
0.05212579667568207,
-0.6486243605613708,
0.8204001784324646,
-0.12163794785737991,
-0.6511098742485046,
-0.2740291655063629,
-0.8050884008407593,
-0.7763573527336121,
0.14830411970615387,
-0.13238267600536346,
-0.42579519748687744,
0.013439774513244629,
0.3338834047317505,
-0.02633695863187313,
0.05292399972677231,
-0.8966091275215149,
0.8108316659927368,
-0.3495948910713196,
-0.45053961873054504,
-0.047404780983924866,
-0.5386627316474915,
0.6228971481323242,
-0.002532549435272813,
-0.1414705067873001,
0.04267285764217377,
0.26186320185661316,
0.33210697770118713,
-0.6723780035972595,
0.7370272874832153,
-0.33274272084236145,
-0.08161206543445587,
0.20358256995677948,
0.3059501349925995,
0.7207444310188293,
-0.06538953632116318,
-0.3309883773326874,
-0.03941720724105835,
-0.11295872181653976,
-0.39621514081954956,
-0.5398193001747131,
0.8505483269691467,
-0.1233338788151741,
-0.8933860063552856,
-0.1509070098400116,
-0.5066230297088623,
-0.08835437148809433,
0.22664090991020203,
0.043298810720443726,
0.3279033303260803,
-0.44907325506210327,
0.21651707589626312,
0.402457594871521,
-0.018194355070590973,
-0.03375113010406494,
0.2933891713619232,
-0.4382331073284149,
-0.06161254644393921,
0.5981835722923279,
0.04621697962284088,
0.282261461019516,
0.3065774738788605,
0.06676546484231949,
-0.5798749327659607,
-0.7080175876617432,
-0.7154818773269653,
0.36910203099250793,
-0.4580294191837311,
-0.3005349636077881,
-0.37353137135505676,
-0.2005366086959839,
-0.40805408358573914,
0.013376050628721714,
-0.18362867832183838,
-0.6543293595314026,
-0.011545199900865555,
-0.24570557475090027,
0.18006828427314758,
0.9548285007476807,
0.5529536008834839,
0.32117533683776855,
-0.6187165379524231,
0.08862613141536713,
-0.031199751421809196,
0.3363626301288605,
-0.3370370864868164,
-0.10120409727096558,
0.08047995716333389,
-0.22960685193538666,
-0.07388445734977722,
-1.0858285427093506,
0.15540549159049988,
0.5634384751319885,
0.5107086300849915,
0.13832387328147888,
-0.0987328439950943,
0.7269555926322937,
-0.7528007626533508,
0.8918468952178955,
0.14429545402526855,
-0.7255346775054932,
1.1923068761825562,
-0.3270663022994995,
0.004115636460483074,
0.2552392780780792,
0.027774572372436523,
0.05699713155627251,
-0.3519692122936249,
-0.3030129373073578,
-0.9262341856956482,
0.7375097870826721,
0.2647351920604706,
-0.003569262567907572,
-0.18936297297477722,
0.7439636588096619,
-0.12387033551931381,
0.18613697588443756,
-0.8688382506370544,
0.06440317630767822,
-0.09409964084625244,
-0.17667943239212036,
0.27578452229499817,
-0.38797369599342346,
-0.12272574752569199,
0.022435104474425316,
0.48929962515830994,
-0.36081042885780334,
-0.16912896931171417,
-0.016955673694610596,
-0.15541847050189972,
-0.25105300545692444,
0.3514825105667114,
0.17090436816215515,
0.7679105401039124,
-0.2786960303783417,
-0.16510483622550964,
-0.06778012216091156,
-0.2190253883600235,
-0.15667575597763062,
0.10085244476795197,
-0.45800459384918213,
-0.06719816476106644,
-0.10292307287454605,
0.7308812141418457,
-0.13851892948150635,
-0.547431230545044,
0.2182336449623108,
0.05635775625705719,
-0.13122157752513885,
-0.18125738203525543,
0.3800433576107025,
0.46104708313941956,
0.16130533814430237,
0.3078092932701111,
-0.3612399101257324,
0.13649921119213104,
-0.6711350083351135,
0.17039506137371063,
0.8230640292167664,
-0.1623692661523819,
-0.15707260370254517,
1.0285990238189697,
0.243048757314682,
-0.41168323159217834,
0.7393482327461243,
0.03161448612809181,
-0.198172464966774,
0.3895181119441986,
0.9581875205039978,
0.5730530619621277,
-0.4832450747489929,
0.014521707780659199,
0.5581350922584534,
0.28654247522354126,
-0.06361474096775055,
0.6838480234146118,
-0.1373278796672821,
-0.3437424302101135,
-0.5707201957702637,
-0.983533501625061,
-0.1192261278629303,
-0.14869841933250427,
-0.5247987508773804,
0.31114235520362854,
-0.4286060929298401,
0.042895570397377014,
-0.10920340567827225,
-0.04282551258802414,
-0.1952085793018341,
0.14439429342746735,
-0.10766206681728363,
0.8061837553977966,
-0.7045663595199585,
1.0458353757858276,
0.6492406725883484,
-0.5411231517791748,
-0.9328738451004028,
-0.29703107476234436,
-0.11935832351446152,
-0.6866797208786011,
0.6787257194519043,
0.03480861708521843,
-0.22665449976921082,
0.028895391151309013,
-0.5754798054695129,
-0.6958534717559814,
1.152718186378479,
0.6779402494430542,
-0.7406420707702637,
-0.3873072862625122,
0.3843528628349304,
0.5222125053405762,
-0.6450640559196472,
-0.2552627921104431,
0.5178014039993286,
0.05490905046463013,
0.5073429942131042,
-0.3297554850578308,
0.37949880957603455,
-0.10564768314361572,
0.2389058917760849,
0.5026142597198486,
-0.19165067374706268,
0.6263672709465027,
-0.450050950050354,
-0.4779543876647949,
0.048852503299713135,
0.7760987281799316,
0.5360651016235352,
0.06485256552696228,
0.48112326860427856,
0.3323042392730713,
0.8698474764823914,
-0.118338443338871,
1.0401513576507568,
-0.39941439032554626,
0.0018457286059856415,
1.2941923141479492,
-0.6817870736122131,
1.0394706726074219,
0.3385827839374542,
-0.14167547225952148,
0.5282666087150574,
0.46045196056365967,
-0.07652459293603897,
0.10741505026817322,
0.2663786709308624,
-0.0058133951388299465,
-0.32266655564308167,
-0.12906983494758606,
-0.5445482730865479,
0.3208300471305847,
0.6287335753440857,
-0.54985111951828,
-0.22204627096652985,
-0.7808358073234558,
-0.09863794595003128,
0.22139643132686615,
-0.2218899428844452,
0.8076638579368591,
0.11654893308877945,
-0.5076054334640503,
0.5792509913444519,
-0.01896035112440586,
0.08830137550830841,
-0.8657416105270386,
-0.10126189142465591,
-0.5090882182121277,
-0.06758183240890503,
-0.4799298644065857,
-0.7320152521133423,
0.4943472146987915,
-0.08066761493682861,
-0.10954010486602783,
0.003984785173088312,
1.04389226436615,
-0.7168476581573486,
-0.5818871259689331,
0.16858458518981934,
0.6640047430992126,
0.3161287009716034,
-0.29089120030403137,
-0.5373311042785645,
-0.22714458405971527,
0.04844994843006134,
-0.33084896206855774,
0.344260573387146,
0.43418824672698975,
-0.27847403287887573,
0.35321083664894104,
0.9045334458351135,
0.24581435322761536,
0.1752711832523346,
0.2705010175704956,
0.9088632464408875,
-0.9033249616622925,
-0.5562018156051636,
-0.9015660285949707,
0.11294068396091461,
-0.4038745164871216,
-0.04989318177103996,
0.7036367654800415,
0.8973647356033325,
0.5858801603317261,
-0.06741814315319061,
0.269433856010437,
-0.04623328149318695,
0.2121366709470749,
-0.6532395482063293,
0.7402710914611816,
-0.7852796912193298,
0.4669121503829956,
-0.1391366422176361,
-1.533453345298767,
-0.41947701573371887,
0.36905840039253235,
0.14192618429660797,
0.08634969592094421,
0.5063726902008057,
1.1955528259277344,
0.102859728038311,
-0.04527606442570686,
0.44054868817329407,
0.6148805618286133,
0.44901877641677856,
0.5114685297012329,
0.7572516202926636,
-0.11547943949699402,
0.7737252712249756,
0.3018246591091156,
-0.03089749440550804,
-0.19647541642189026,
-0.7885376214981079,
-0.8445568084716797,
-0.3692793846130371,
0.002404408995062113,
-0.5559736490249634,
0.18027327954769135,
0.640112578868866,
0.70833420753479,
-0.7714208364486694,
-0.5098091959953308,
-0.5268701910972595,
0.05649475008249283,
-0.004109442699700594,
-0.2287604659795761,
0.4816230833530426,
-0.44822296500205994,
-0.5457805395126343,
0.9200767874717712,
0.5270954370498657,
-0.18629473447799683,
-0.40348973870277405,
0.07086581736803055,
-0.0622379407286644,
0.08041469007730484,
0.8069890141487122,
0.13652895390987396,
-0.6558298468589783,
0.029169410467147827,
0.08864101022481918,
-0.29896336793899536,
0.17056934535503387,
0.7055497169494629,
-0.6223360300064087,
0.10733404755592346,
0.48200392723083496,
0.5339623689651489,
0.7168036699295044,
0.17827768623828888,
0.8611966371536255,
-1.168099045753479,
-0.17908449470996857,
0.1545562446117401,
0.4960397183895111,
0.4154784083366394,
-0.7889987826347351,
0.8416018486022949,
0.17310424149036407,
-0.4368802607059479,
-0.9547803997993469,
0.7703006863594055,
-1.0331320762634277,
-0.37999245524406433,
1.1326791048049927,
0.2157014161348343,
-0.568787157535553,
0.005353468935936689,
-0.10990434139966965,
-0.08812779188156128,
-0.2981724441051483,
0.3526788651943207,
0.35001131892204285,
-0.17688338458538055,
0.1813684105873108,
-0.0574045367538929,
0.6346095204353333,
0.45819970965385437,
-0.9286195635795593,
0.38744744658470154,
1.1051133871078491,
0.37978604435920715,
-0.10152977705001831,
0.6300004720687866,
-0.3935311436653137,
0.010466515086591244,
0.1841340959072113,
-0.11753075569868088,
-0.21989306807518005,
-0.38136258721351624,
-0.06941059231758118,
0.5400878190994263,
0.10741803050041199,
0.23513072729110718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11960v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11960v1 | DB-LLM: Accurate Dual-Binarization for Efficient LLMs | 2024-02-19T09:04:30 | 2024-02-19T09:04:30 | Hong Chen, Chengtao Lv, Liang Ding, Haotong Qin, Xiabin Zhou, Yifu Ding, Xuebo Liu, Min Zhang, Jinyang Guo, Xianglong Liu, Dacheng Tao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced the field of natural
language processing, while the expensive memory and computation consumption
impede their practical deployment. Quantization emerges as one of the most
effective methods for improving the computational efficiency of LLMs. However,
existing ultra-low-bit quantization always causes severe accuracy drops. In
this paper, we empirically relieve the micro and macro characteristics of
ultra-low bit quantization and present a novel Dual-Binarization method for
LLMs, namely DB-LLM. For the micro-level, we take both the accuracy advantage
of 2-bit-width and the efficiency advantage of binarization into account,
introducing Flexible Dual Binarization (FDB). By splitting 2-bit quantized
weights into two independent sets of binaries, FDB ensures the accuracy of
representations and introduces flexibility, utilizing the efficient bitwise
operations of binarization while retaining the inherent high sparsity of
ultra-low bit quantization. For the macro-level, we find the distortion that
exists in the prediction of LLM after quantization, which is specified as the
deviations related to the ambiguity of samples. We propose the Deviation-Aware
Distillation (DAD) method, enabling the model to focus differently on various
samples. Comprehensive experiments show that our DB-LLM not only significantly
surpasses the current State-of-The-Art (SoTA) in ultra-low bit quantization
(eg, perplexity decreased from 9.64 to 7.23), but also achieves an additional
20\% reduction in computational consumption compared to the SOTA method under
the same bit-width. Our code will be released soon. | [
-0.40118208527565,
-1.1349753141403198,
0.4148690700531006,
0.2063213288784027,
-0.6844564080238342,
0.19591417908668518,
-0.29654642939567566,
-0.39169344305992126,
0.07909651845693588,
0.44916027784347534,
-0.5051846504211426,
-0.48015129566192627,
-0.5312740802764893,
0.20339754223823547,
-0.10046985745429993,
0.4854738712310791,
0.18491385877132416,
0.3148859739303589,
-0.005502788815647364,
-0.019825758412480354,
-0.21197211742401123,
-0.5812837481498718,
-0.5709134936332703,
-0.008043513633310795,
0.2613693177700043,
0.2597692608833313,
0.6388204097747803,
0.5594817996025085,
0.47694259881973267,
0.22853045165538788,
-0.5776909589767456,
0.21383389830589294,
-0.3592088520526886,
0.06240908056497574,
0.1313628852367401,
-0.7075208425521851,
-0.48409661650657654,
-0.303573876619339,
0.8662570714950562,
0.6433873176574707,
-0.3580058217048645,
-0.06132956221699715,
0.09126091748476028,
0.9727039933204651,
-0.3634912967681885,
0.11721187829971313,
-0.641532301902771,
-0.003588894149288535,
-0.3098987638950348,
0.07393907755613327,
-0.16096268594264984,
-0.3212662637233734,
-0.2803955376148224,
-0.2634768784046173,
0.14900335669517517,
-0.027681101113557816,
0.4934406280517578,
0.4719151258468628,
-0.5393385291099548,
-0.1674451380968094,
-0.9469047784805298,
0.802407443523407,
-0.8048000931739807,
0.5487952828407288,
0.1653348207473755,
0.3289969861507416,
-0.1693299263715744,
-0.41803285479545593,
-0.5614372491836548,
0.03315417468547821,
0.2858630418777466,
-0.10646478831768036,
-0.20267514884471893,
0.050282835960388184,
0.05325230211019516,
0.5551398992538452,
-0.1822851151227951,
0.28228089213371277,
-0.19598335027694702,
-0.13202448189258575,
0.47678467631340027,
0.18408262729644775,
-0.23068486154079437,
-0.06188635155558586,
-0.4687480926513672,
0.09384121745824814,
-0.8130561113357544,
-0.0833323523402214,
0.49587172269821167,
0.28064271807670593,
0.012006806209683418,
0.5206697583198547,
0.009322570636868477,
0.43366020917892456,
0.19072914123535156,
-0.1706388145685196,
-0.10706698149442673,
-0.5569154620170593,
-0.36080265045166016,
0.04601744934916496,
0.8216961026191711,
0.2337867021560669,
-0.002163529396057129,
0.17162905633449554,
-0.2505924701690674,
-0.015071392990648746,
-0.07027225941419601,
-1.2086697816848755,
-0.131470188498497,
0.24276219308376312,
-0.2562081515789032,
-0.32203689217567444,
-0.27863258123397827,
-0.9065387845039368,
-0.6048756241798401,
-0.1550579071044922,
0.20020882785320282,
-0.6946585774421692,
-0.3569745719432831,
0.09695153683423996,
0.29509449005126953,
-0.14101774990558624,
0.20435099303722382,
-1.054466962814331,
0.2688104808330536,
0.7226783037185669,
0.7831944823265076,
0.17475423216819763,
0.32603690028190613,
-0.45299065113067627,
0.1966741532087326,
-0.4384613335132599,
0.6807400584220886,
-0.23930062353610992,
-0.3627520799636841,
-0.4132802486419678,
-0.5859840512275696,
0.3712235391139984,
-0.8594932556152344,
0.4389113485813141,
-0.5950612425804138,
-0.2542533576488495,
-0.012888636440038681,
-0.49654653668403625,
-0.1932082176208496,
-0.03245239704847336,
-0.7887704372406006,
0.9794443249702454,
0.1113809123635292,
-0.6554535031318665,
0.34127387404441833,
-0.3356057405471802,
-0.1841767132282257,
-0.06405827403068542,
-0.19630871713161469,
-0.5914166569709778,
0.43632158637046814,
0.18859636783599854,
0.25759437680244446,
-0.5176372528076172,
0.37423253059387207,
-0.387333482503891,
-0.5543199181556702,
0.4450518488883972,
-0.9464862942695618,
0.9277330636978149,
0.00386426760815084,
-0.21017101407051086,
-0.07975103706121445,
-0.8527067303657532,
-0.0017389525892212987,
0.034761134535074234,
-0.54827880859375,
-0.4995386302471161,
-0.04024510458111763,
-0.19376356899738312,
0.03410232067108154,
0.3150663673877716,
-0.3826604187488556,
0.18273542821407318,
-0.6834714412689209,
0.29887011647224426,
0.8100239038467407,
-0.1390020102262497,
0.3947535455226898,
0.07934528589248657,
0.32267338037490845,
0.1446460336446762,
0.05052188038825989,
0.29611557722091675,
-0.2971935570240021,
-0.5119628310203552,
-0.820774257183075,
0.7992902994155884,
0.5309717059135437,
-0.46849292516708374,
0.9368038773536682,
-0.2548618018627167,
-0.22836434841156006,
-0.5498345494270325,
0.21791160106658936,
0.3218546211719513,
0.18659110367298126,
0.19634918868541718,
-0.34876275062561035,
-0.5934473276138306,
-0.7169131636619568,
-0.10671143233776093,
-0.0026299795135855675,
-0.19545391201972961,
0.11379639059305191,
0.17728954553604126,
-0.4036289155483246,
0.9240702986717224,
-0.3363293707370758,
-0.29222139716148376,
-0.2678251564502716,
0.12894250452518463,
0.2691877782344818,
0.17955493927001953,
0.35869234800338745,
-0.6767610311508179,
-0.705356240272522,
-0.16331392526626587,
-0.34145841002464294,
-0.2947549819946289,
0.17193078994750977,
-0.13138733804225922,
0.813775360584259,
0.15569894015789032,
-0.43195268511772156,
0.4657069146633148,
0.6694749593734741,
-0.4106907248497009,
0.6315854787826538,
-0.27875369787216187,
-0.09193476289510727,
-1.0233674049377441,
-0.1315125823020935,
-0.15804935991764069,
-0.4821323752403259,
-0.5748451352119446,
-0.2259841412305832,
0.36928820610046387,
0.4308558404445648,
-0.22976481914520264,
0.20465798676013947,
-0.5909810066223145,
0.006587275769561529,
-0.23757511377334595,
0.07455242425203323,
0.0015422053402289748,
0.38606324791908264,
-0.10786734521389008,
0.6584205627441406,
0.5204418301582336,
-0.4682079255580902,
0.5880700349807739,
-0.13301806151866913,
-0.41741836071014404,
0.7931257486343384,
-0.302382230758667,
0.017048895359039307,
-0.09730963408946991,
0.12072470039129257,
-0.937588632106781,
0.3475398123264313,
0.1767473667860031,
-0.255459725856781,
0.6932584047317505,
-0.26393547654151917,
-0.6302412152290344,
-0.13948577642440796,
-0.630663275718689,
0.019885554909706116,
0.5463924407958984,
-0.4957936406135559,
0.5557342171669006,
0.2796038091182709,
-0.13318343460559845,
-0.6234025359153748,
-0.8552002310752869,
-0.02992537058889866,
-0.3850163519382477,
-0.5843998193740845,
0.3035474419593811,
-0.36800965666770935,
-0.3627583384513855,
-0.03611934185028076,
-0.6027342677116394,
-0.26323747634887695,
0.07537446916103363,
-0.049378424882888794,
0.34552839398384094,
-0.20823971927165985,
0.03276902064681053,
0.3037445545196533,
-0.23926982283592224,
0.02191573567688465,
-0.3164484202861786,
0.6078338623046875,
-0.2915000021457672,
0.13926038146018982,
-0.3708401918411255,
0.2742515206336975,
0.2433067262172699,
0.11332671344280243,
0.9179173111915588,
0.6482133269309998,
-0.38214585185050964,
-0.28769150376319885,
-0.49127495288848877,
-0.11451247334480286,
-0.4826192557811737,
0.4193704128265381,
-0.5914006233215332,
-0.8636051416397095,
0.38399896025657654,
-0.19350916147232056,
-0.09778599441051483,
0.16413567960262299,
0.5654375553131104,
-0.25057926774024963,
0.7476849555969238,
0.6412845253944397,
0.14610646665096283,
0.3071563243865967,
-0.3048470616340637,
0.48457029461860657,
-0.9600629210472107,
0.020829619839787483,
-0.33554548025131226,
-0.28177931904792786,
-0.38877156376838684,
-0.6860345602035522,
0.3524799644947052,
0.7504462599754333,
0.11945740878582001,
0.04093386232852936,
-0.300957590341568,
0.3800297975540161,
0.5969650745391846,
0.019319474697113037,
0.581961452960968,
0.2453785389661789,
-0.3385525047779083,
-0.2173919826745987,
-0.4197337031364441,
-0.5569254159927368,
1.1094704866409302,
0.2142549604177475,
0.8440700769424438,
0.3785914480686188,
0.6718605756759644,
0.18457333743572235,
0.05783539265394211,
-0.8309323787689209,
0.6052129864692688,
-0.49957379698753357,
-0.5269729495048523,
-0.5515584945678711,
-0.7403544783592224,
-0.7025225162506104,
0.5037323236465454,
-0.2156682014465332,
-0.4314039349555969,
0.04644966498017311,
0.22368304431438446,
-0.4979027807712555,
0.42952921986579895,
-0.6169499158859253,
0.664993405342102,
-0.3365512490272522,
-0.3445960283279419,
-0.30476734042167664,
-0.6563560366630554,
0.42219778895378113,
-0.4324941337108612,
0.2884696125984192,
-0.34998542070388794,
-0.3735547661781311,
0.4198627769947052,
-0.6090154051780701,
0.686942994594574,
-0.22091896831989288,
-0.3653811514377594,
0.2654866874217987,
0.18624815344810486,
0.5139454007148743,
0.27104422450065613,
-0.11566553264856339,
0.5264309048652649,
0.17533206939697266,
-0.12183438241481781,
-0.6466291546821594,
0.4687017500400543,
-0.38676220178604126,
-0.4880727231502533,
-0.28007858991622925,
-0.47241345047950745,
-0.16374632716178894,
0.2318655103445053,
0.04875650629401207,
0.3326600193977356,
-0.15139932930469513,
0.31902027130126953,
0.8784075379371643,
0.0009696328197605908,
0.3518262207508087,
0.7182140946388245,
-0.1921120584011078,
-0.4798363447189331,
0.49084004759788513,
0.14129838347434998,
0.31611138582229614,
0.8019843697547913,
0.4738004207611084,
-0.6173446774482727,
-0.8512812852859497,
-0.6567255854606628,
0.3226625323295593,
-0.4094807505607605,
-0.3632391691207886,
-0.39937418699264526,
0.08462295681238174,
-0.44119641184806824,
0.18090179562568665,
-0.5842025876045227,
-0.6788484454154968,
-0.29164186120033264,
-0.06523356586694717,
0.33975639939308167,
0.27333346009254456,
-0.29695841670036316,
0.2513790428638458,
-0.7130025625228882,
0.4714304804801941,
0.2925044894218445,
0.49407079815864563,
-0.4513964354991913,
-0.5089454650878906,
-0.1921534389257431,
0.3150114119052887,
-0.025588175281882286,
-0.8649824261665344,
0.33787164092063904,
0.12935292720794678,
0.16158463060855865,
0.37239912152290344,
0.07950925081968307,
0.6238990426063538,
-0.37662944197654724,
0.45966798067092896,
0.20427206158638,
-1.0318297147750854,
0.30433189868927,
-0.008961350657045841,
-0.09469258040189743,
0.5404170751571655,
0.09847651422023773,
-0.3195488452911377,
-0.2686915099620819,
-0.2455846518278122,
-0.9039795994758606,
0.8581752181053162,
0.017172032967209816,
-0.03499098867177963,
0.40686681866645813,
0.17156276106834412,
0.16154639422893524,
0.3527035117149353,
-0.6231487393379211,
-0.6291345357894897,
0.09510928392410278,
-0.4410540461540222,
0.12163429707288742,
-0.6753730773925781,
0.10545889288187027,
-0.23104213178157806,
0.787868320941925,
-0.04604509100317955,
0.2315589189529419,
-0.20491063594818115,
-0.08198820799589157,
-0.08400033414363861,
0.4621039628982544,
0.27565664052963257,
0.4227103292942047,
-0.5301612615585327,
0.39513182640075684,
0.26868191361427307,
-0.6778148412704468,
0.3189985156059265,
0.36724230647087097,
-0.25663846731185913,
0.0574728362262249,
-0.19858132302761078,
0.6818951964378357,
0.156400665640831,
-0.7100717425346375,
0.4644128680229187,
-0.18622945249080658,
-0.15535743534564972,
-0.1921331137418747,
0.03551572561264038,
0.5030162930488586,
0.3973047435283661,
0.18769477307796478,
-0.05054668337106705,
0.16963829100131989,
-0.4503762722015381,
-0.13896596431732178,
0.5797600150108337,
-0.0037619394715875387,
-0.1325387954711914,
0.6108156442642212,
0.13724660873413086,
-0.19293786585330963,
0.5487173795700073,
-0.35983219742774963,
-0.2248370498418808,
0.5089651346206665,
0.5682850480079651,
0.7479385733604431,
-0.4293404519557953,
-0.07439626008272171,
0.1118955910205841,
0.27528703212738037,
0.043605562299489975,
0.29813504219055176,
-0.2199002206325531,
-0.7371147871017456,
-0.2084210067987442,
-0.9180750846862793,
-0.3518785536289215,
0.00006924245826667175,
-0.40714231133461,
0.23439064621925354,
-0.3931400775909424,
-0.14288973808288574,
-0.07191548496484756,
0.408606618642807,
-0.2178419828414917,
0.1264263093471527,
0.26192790269851685,
0.6988376379013062,
-0.3063892722129822,
1.1984394788742065,
0.4124317169189453,
0.0015501950401812792,
-0.6590599417686462,
-0.06522973626852036,
-0.004380013793706894,
-0.5264484286308289,
0.24666453897953033,
0.11883801966905594,
-0.3231279253959656,
0.003581365803256631,
-0.0025641347747296095,
-0.7693050503730774,
1.1803369522094727,
0.5067266225814819,
-1.0423998832702637,
0.13547101616859436,
0.41547146439552307,
0.5371021032333374,
0.07137541472911835,
0.1575743556022644,
0.9072766304016113,
0.4791315197944641,
0.16454468667507172,
-0.6581805348396301,
0.08429143577814102,
0.03587118908762932,
0.3850134015083313,
0.5817724466323853,
-0.5667864084243774,
0.5818840265274048,
-0.2815452218055725,
-0.3373895585536957,
0.026725484058260918,
0.598064124584198,
0.34942489862442017,
0.2361462563276291,
0.5259566307067871,
0.41996681690216064,
0.8885303735733032,
-0.19051428139209747,
0.5577751994132996,
-0.1972334086894989,
0.42474430799484253,
0.8093047142028809,
-0.3228626251220703,
0.7980664968490601,
0.6064677238464355,
-0.7222457528114319,
0.4048587679862976,
0.32134202122688293,
0.21811950206756592,
0.5452084541320801,
0.3620079755783081,
-0.5765288472175598,
0.023239564150571823,
0.379698783159256,
-0.050715867429971695,
0.19008992612361908,
0.5238048434257507,
-0.11192531883716583,
0.12354356050491333,
-0.28494229912757874,
0.12898887693881989,
0.020221102982759476,
-0.14126744866371155,
0.6310107707977295,
0.2169020026922226,
-0.1769047975540161,
0.9924100041389465,
0.48204514384269714,
1.2746918201446533,
-0.6891176104545593,
0.29672643542289734,
-0.435437947511673,
0.2819288969039917,
-0.0402463935315609,
-0.5708271265029907,
0.625444769859314,
0.20918095111846924,
-0.24624645709991455,
-0.194440096616745,
0.48154449462890625,
-0.6375645399093628,
-0.6869964003562927,
0.23760119080543518,
0.253264844417572,
0.22250498831272125,
-0.3302851617336273,
-0.5910341143608093,
0.04970941320061684,
0.16020584106445312,
-0.3734912872314453,
0.1912647932767868,
0.6743019223213196,
0.01635206863284111,
0.4654906690120697,
0.38238003849983215,
0.36572179198265076,
0.30942320823669434,
0.12464652955532074,
0.4443805515766144,
-0.7802440524101257,
-0.4525783360004425,
-1.0780664682388306,
0.1696174293756485,
0.009541207924485207,
0.15767045319080353,
0.5387281179428101,
0.7007541060447693,
0.6026984453201294,
0.038425277918577194,
0.5771403312683105,
-0.15838120877742767,
0.6063191890716553,
-0.6724039912223816,
0.462894469499588,
-0.5264431238174438,
0.6597570180892944,
0.05690402537584305,
-0.9250603318214417,
-0.510517418384552,
0.5866081118583679,
-0.06997308880090714,
0.08433867245912552,
0.7462819814682007,
0.9364299178123474,
0.0047814068384468555,
-0.04968539625406265,
0.3620336055755615,
0.31972771883010864,
0.178498312830925,
0.7787254452705383,
0.7287020683288574,
-0.2796989679336548,
0.8322589993476868,
-0.7212872505187988,
-0.34639108180999756,
-0.34401950240135193,
-0.770082950592041,
-0.767177164554596,
-0.16981841623783112,
-0.30783411860466003,
-0.07882633805274963,
0.10823771357536316,
0.6559897065162659,
0.5696216821670532,
-0.5775368809700012,
-0.17592059075832367,
-0.19044610857963562,
0.29144373536109924,
-0.36475905776023865,
-0.23324576020240784,
0.4618694484233856,
0.043984461575746536,
-0.9888125061988831,
0.30071473121643066,
0.540610134601593,
0.23126284778118134,
-0.27882882952690125,
-0.06092904880642891,
-0.004779066890478134,
0.2849389314651489,
0.5657185912132263,
-0.29453492164611816,
-0.6206037402153015,
0.055891577154397964,
-0.2624916732311249,
-0.37257710099220276,
0.37650224566459656,
0.550575852394104,
-0.5438867211341858,
0.287371426820755,
0.39314913749694824,
0.3441593050956726,
0.5664348602294922,
0.1431746482849121,
0.2079533338546753,
-0.8267189264297485,
0.05676707997918129,
0.2666482627391815,
0.16029761731624603,
0.44889870285987854,
-0.4531019330024719,
0.5270944833755493,
0.43264392018318176,
-0.27728670835494995,
-0.7864170670509338,
0.1541314423084259,
-0.9797062277793884,
-0.45361411571502686,
1.0098339319229126,
0.03326130285859108,
-0.21789292991161346,
0.0000839048734633252,
-0.3003773093223572,
0.4272487461566925,
-0.31969913840293884,
0.7672175765037537,
0.5319737195968628,
-0.05606753006577492,
-0.1493723839521408,
-0.3015463948249817,
0.3692150413990021,
0.493678480386734,
-0.6641753911972046,
0.2879757285118103,
0.6791985630989075,
0.4292158782482147,
-0.1963064968585968,
0.6772814989089966,
-0.2772834300994873,
-0.028241613879799843,
0.07041097432374954,
0.155342698097229,
-0.280496209859848,
-0.16102339327335358,
-0.6420974135398865,
-0.048665110021829605,
0.13155709207057953,
-0.03941085934638977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11958v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11958v1 | Automatic Evaluation for Mental Health Counseling using LLMs | 2024-02-19T09:00:10 | 2024-02-19T09:00:10 | Anqi Li, Yu Lu, Nirui Song, Shuai Zhang, Lizhi Ma, Zhenzhong Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL | High-quality psychological counseling is crucial for mental health worldwide,
and timely evaluation is vital for ensuring its effectiveness. However,
obtaining professional evaluation for each counseling session is expensive and
challenging. Existing methods that rely on self or third-party manual reports
to assess the quality of counseling suffer from subjective biases and
limitations of time-consuming.
To address above challenges, this paper proposes an innovative and efficient
automatic approach using large language models (LLMs) to evaluate the working
alliance in counseling conversations. We collected a comprehensive counseling
dataset and conducted multiple third-party evaluations based on therapeutic
relationship theory. Our LLM-based evaluation, combined with our guidelines,
shows high agreement with human evaluations and provides valuable insights into
counseling scripts. This highlights the potential of LLMs as supervisory tools
for psychotherapists. By integrating LLMs into the evaluation process, our
approach offers a cost-effective and dependable means of assessing counseling
quality, enhancing overall effectiveness. | [
-0.29142504930496216,
-0.3816918730735779,
0.8817197680473328,
0.6174749135971069,
-0.3703116178512573,
0.025632981210947037,
-0.3937090039253235,
-0.5394584536552429,
0.08851679414510727,
0.45468461513519287,
-0.6168995499610901,
-0.5120976567268372,
-0.8709573149681091,
0.3161126375198364,
-0.018087781965732574,
0.5938052535057068,
-0.20061802864074707,
0.672419011592865,
-0.2298719435930252,
-0.11127498000860214,
-0.5469520092010498,
-0.22358906269073486,
-0.9592024683952332,
-0.7177281379699707,
0.45440366864204407,
0.13953690230846405,
0.7311687469482422,
0.42146405577659607,
0.7646732330322266,
0.3607199192047119,
-0.06978345662355423,
0.2818590998649597,
-0.54303377866745,
-0.02483241818845272,
-0.24270932376384735,
-0.1754024177789688,
-0.9569041132926941,
0.25774797797203064,
0.5285207629203796,
0.7011879086494446,
-0.4641158878803253,
0.4832371771335602,
0.1569206416606903,
0.5813613533973694,
-0.4358050525188446,
0.18191979825496674,
-0.495391309261322,
0.1921231895685196,
0.36228126287460327,
-0.22905196249485016,
-0.18358531594276428,
-0.5173145532608032,
0.23765802383422852,
-0.1562773883342743,
-0.13440166413784027,
-0.1313820630311966,
0.5143078565597534,
0.2629733979701996,
-0.6722587943077087,
-0.11168733239173889,
-0.7523199319839478,
0.542382001876831,
-0.7406110167503357,
0.5432573556900024,
0.5619403719902039,
0.4079490005970001,
-0.44737616181373596,
-0.46315205097198486,
-0.2923094630241394,
-0.45053526759147644,
-0.2563416361808777,
0.18616002798080444,
-0.39820337295532227,
0.18598346412181854,
0.15718340873718262,
0.4983728229999542,
-0.3131251931190491,
0.19596680998802185,
-0.15373726189136505,
-0.034694328904151917,
0.9017236828804016,
0.6567018032073975,
0.2981508672237396,
0.11130407452583313,
-0.13707774877548218,
0.29250696301460266,
-0.23607926070690155,
-0.25594210624694824,
0.03191669285297394,
-0.06675004214048386,
-0.11810584366321564,
0.5343354344367981,
0.14207638800144196,
0.5157781839370728,
0.17837080359458923,
-0.7141731381416321,
-0.3253341019153595,
-0.12395181506872177,
-0.15919670462608337,
-0.12104598432779312,
0.9515274167060852,
1.0798968076705933,
-0.11632071435451508,
-0.4288412034511566,
-0.17377464473247528,
0.10812710970640182,
0.3359627425670624,
-0.6487902402877808,
-0.023613400757312775,
0.11819429695606232,
-0.6741979122161865,
-0.07913953810930252,
-0.24361038208007812,
-0.8351019024848938,
-0.4151151180267334,
-0.6515882611274719,
0.23080974817276,
-0.28541749715805054,
-0.24025608599185944,
-0.06530261039733887,
0.17134572565555573,
0.1059531718492508,
0.29993966221809387,
-0.45787936449050903,
0.48054563999176025,
0.6313904523849487,
0.9670745730400085,
-0.5147958397865295,
-0.2505587637424469,
-0.6086025834083557,
0.16905447840690613,
-0.3862137496471405,
0.7455875873565674,
-0.4458393454551697,
-0.4976758658885956,
-0.12438930571079254,
0.15886305272579193,
0.022713469341397285,
-0.48379236459732056,
0.5155826807022095,
-0.33034685254096985,
0.261821985244751,
-0.10754141211509705,
-0.7226489186286926,
0.3294341564178467,
0.2733790874481201,
-0.4223737418651581,
0.850355863571167,
0.4288216531276703,
-0.5729360580444336,
0.33560335636138916,
-0.7064850330352783,
-0.23902368545532227,
0.21387706696987152,
0.10749178379774094,
-0.23928973078727722,
-0.04529271647334099,
0.2184182107448578,
0.35310661792755127,
-0.683139979839325,
0.4098328649997711,
-0.5334692001342773,
-0.4247307777404785,
0.352859228849411,
-0.22467130422592163,
0.5631727576255798,
0.03753076121211052,
-0.06771139055490494,
0.4247867166996002,
-0.7455731630325317,
0.08027203381061554,
0.009456622414290905,
-0.3053717315196991,
-0.26213338971138,
-0.24070751667022705,
-0.14281439781188965,
0.18536706268787384,
0.1495712399482727,
-0.43041273951530457,
0.06214108690619469,
-0.43312177062034607,
0.08274630457162857,
0.7584695816040039,
0.449990838766098,
0.10721012949943542,
-0.29141879081726074,
0.8087486624717712,
-0.47518330812454224,
0.4081679582595825,
0.22683817148208618,
-0.2489130049943924,
-0.3886307179927826,
-0.463786244392395,
-0.22105053067207336,
0.4167182743549347,
-0.49236127734184265,
0.9608503580093384,
-0.06424769014120102,
-0.8789786696434021,
-0.4550420641899109,
0.33551961183547974,
0.4116910398006439,
0.493114709854126,
0.2304016500711441,
-0.3523935377597809,
-0.3105117976665497,
-0.6800357103347778,
-0.4963873326778412,
-0.02478930726647377,
-0.07224638760089874,
0.08487340807914734,
0.35680991411209106,
-0.5373668074607849,
0.9611425399780273,
-0.5626198649406433,
-0.2825726866722107,
-0.3261799216270447,
0.01349322497844696,
0.1772630512714386,
0.223133847117424,
0.3587249219417572,
-0.009306933730840683,
-0.5612648129463196,
-0.2953088581562042,
-0.7034733295440674,
-0.45965147018432617,
0.16256080567836761,
-0.5804601907730103,
-0.08627265691757202,
0.19109174609184265,
-0.18372024595737457,
0.1562916785478592,
0.6038145422935486,
-0.5119715332984924,
0.695837140083313,
-0.3102686405181885,
0.035249557346105576,
-0.7908413410186768,
0.006360411643981934,
0.18122482299804688,
-0.3445555865764618,
-0.212803453207016,
-0.3350088596343994,
-0.1883503496646881,
-0.11620137840509415,
-0.2940196692943573,
0.5626599192619324,
-0.40660321712493896,
-0.168633833527565,
-0.23936757445335388,
0.23046088218688965,
-0.12536239624023438,
0.5633831024169922,
-0.36755672097206116,
0.5986459851264954,
0.36473390460014343,
-0.2788827419281006,
0.8812617659568787,
0.2852383852005005,
-0.2271876037120819,
1.1864811182022095,
-0.5444959998130798,
0.124742291867733,
0.27453362941741943,
0.6665686368942261,
-0.5712769627571106,
-0.255301833152771,
0.3021790683269501,
0.183230459690094,
0.020650826394557953,
-0.23251238465309143,
-0.38763001561164856,
-0.3490919768810272,
-0.19393151998519897,
0.10965850204229355,
0.29897361993789673,
-0.47199246287345886,
0.18939612805843353,
0.5037411451339722,
-0.2595762014389038,
-0.21468771994113922,
-0.1019657626748085,
0.3403729498386383,
-0.38559389114379883,
-0.5503684878349304,
0.236898273229599,
0.10771308839321136,
-0.4110446870326996,
0.02158164046704769,
-0.1738147735595703,
-0.011434925720095634,
-0.008976725861430168,
0.41594332456588745,
0.5517466068267822,
0.12514732778072357,
0.00816491711884737,
0.04093679413199425,
-0.4870368540287018,
0.4178386330604553,
-0.23241320252418518,
0.3241444230079651,
-0.5033542513847351,
-0.6618801951408386,
-0.6427919268608093,
0.37386903166770935,
0.6357777714729309,
-0.23652352392673492,
0.6170287728309631,
0.6822024583816528,
-0.40729376673698425,
-0.02410893142223358,
-0.641801118850708,
-0.14319194853305817,
-0.4138018786907196,
0.3409380316734314,
0.1649746149778366,
-0.6598395705223083,
0.1972319483757019,
-0.1721181720495224,
-0.05680996924638748,
0.2581707239151001,
0.6947376728057861,
-0.019306378439068794,
1.2284928560256958,
0.488861083984375,
0.07173851132392883,
0.34430572390556335,
-0.13895368576049805,
0.3195030987262726,
-0.7924439311027527,
-0.05195877328515053,
-0.046047911047935486,
-0.1422996073961258,
-0.27907595038414,
-0.27644017338752747,
0.8448026776313782,
0.011578795500099659,
-0.26669198274612427,
0.13907191157341003,
-0.595361053943634,
0.29014748334884644,
0.004706108942627907,
0.22548618912696838,
0.653113842010498,
-0.2591497302055359,
-0.22364413738250732,
-0.2630256116390228,
-0.3348994553089142,
-0.8691075444221497,
0.8986908793449402,
0.6275185942649841,
0.6892725229263306,
-0.01870599389076233,
0.6476411819458008,
0.2460286021232605,
0.9184547066688538,
-0.9901519417762756,
0.6011634469032288,
0.226058691740036,
-0.23070789873600006,
-0.41059789061546326,
-0.39818572998046875,
-0.8622483611106873,
0.47655364871025085,
-0.23059946298599243,
-1.0259758234024048,
0.024198248982429504,
-0.04666903614997864,
-0.40076175332069397,
0.0892246812582016,
-0.3685157597064972,
0.8170709609985352,
-0.5433465242385864,
-0.27555933594703674,
-0.5016782283782959,
-0.4920394718647003,
0.6281006336212158,
-0.23921336233615875,
0.10858608782291412,
-0.6780682802200317,
-0.013005098327994347,
1.0831260681152344,
-0.5789271593093872,
0.4681493937969208,
-0.1812017410993576,
-0.4642077088356018,
0.000033439977414673194,
0.13026143610477448,
0.2412581890821457,
0.23552745580673218,
-0.19518250226974487,
-0.046631667762994766,
0.6630698442459106,
-0.11622995138168335,
-1.0834506750106812,
0.5542871356010437,
-0.7055212259292603,
-0.3786523938179016,
-0.3179653584957123,
-0.47908341884613037,
-0.8989498019218445,
0.33440855145454407,
0.024122178554534912,
0.44305333495140076,
-0.47437989711761475,
-0.4079342186450958,
-0.06126220524311066,
-0.2729770839214325,
-0.007054299581795931,
0.7549659609794617,
-0.5158012509346008,
-0.7433837056159973,
0.7227628231048584,
-0.0665973424911499,
0.1544181853532791,
-0.4807867705821991,
0.33422136306762695,
-0.3335466682910919,
-0.22172856330871582,
-0.052066244184970856,
0.5835835933685303,
-0.8881244659423828,
-0.2626514732837677,
-0.5544478893280029,
-0.05397225543856621,
-0.18652404844760895,
-0.19572384655475616,
-0.39362743496894836,
-0.06542579084634781,
0.12848816812038422,
-0.18934614956378937,
0.280405193567276,
0.7079099416732788,
-0.1465909630060196,
0.5191008448600769,
-1.0185856819152832,
0.41011878848075867,
0.3441314995288849,
0.7795207500457764,
0.28400298953056335,
-0.14087750017642975,
-0.347462922334671,
-0.06284178048372269,
-0.6217861175537109,
-1.0562998056411743,
0.47553545236587524,
-0.05820966139435768,
0.5480553507804871,
0.5921367406845093,
0.14502398669719696,
0.7960973381996155,
-0.21517854928970337,
0.47243431210517883,
0.3503575325012207,
-0.9234638810157776,
0.3857048451900482,
-0.385897159576416,
-0.019007796421647072,
0.7744376063346863,
0.28154030442237854,
-0.6523521542549133,
-0.43623116612434387,
-0.5040127038955688,
-0.7134933471679688,
0.7364895343780518,
0.023750973865389824,
-0.190480574965477,
0.08908123522996902,
0.2736539840698242,
-0.14395320415496826,
-0.019735271111130714,
-0.48971667885780334,
-0.06490808725357056,
0.26089128851890564,
-0.11610928177833557,
0.17974859476089478,
-0.16988758742809296,
-0.801963746547699,
-0.44658270478248596,
0.6891269683837891,
-0.007165263406932354,
0.5443547368049622,
0.27146854996681213,
0.007727370597422123,
-0.5578069686889648,
0.4107874631881714,
0.16876812279224396,
0.9894515872001648,
-0.2922632694244385,
0.07136602699756622,
0.6417575478553772,
-0.163212388753891,
0.42531219124794006,
0.029655149206519127,
0.7080011367797852,
0.07948094606399536,
0.6464414596557617,
0.4909486174583435,
0.21753449738025665,
-0.580668568611145,
0.6789430379867554,
-0.3643888235092163,
0.010107000358402729,
-0.36989378929138184,
0.12910772860050201,
0.22416383028030396,
0.37757548689842224,
0.07326047122478485,
-0.4059038758277893,
0.06644852459430695,
-0.4320339560508728,
0.2635677754878998,
0.39961525797843933,
-0.6335674524307251,
-0.032227739691734314,
0.1060018464922905,
0.2299404740333557,
-0.5263757109642029,
0.5902538895606995,
-0.019314821809530258,
-0.30295509099960327,
0.5515357851982117,
0.6242377161979675,
0.8758881092071533,
-0.14334215223789215,
-0.01893606223165989,
0.09808695316314697,
0.03332700580358505,
-0.2140250951051712,
0.16408586502075195,
0.10531270503997803,
-0.3472958505153656,
-0.4605711102485657,
-0.759433388710022,
-0.8310340642929077,
0.04500852897763252,
-1.0455193519592285,
0.33035221695899963,
-0.4799264669418335,
-0.4712975323200226,
-0.2965945601463318,
-0.015992460772395134,
-0.7022109031677246,
0.08234886080026627,
0.15074372291564941,
0.8378816246986389,
-0.6438639163970947,
0.6034679412841797,
0.5611412525177002,
-0.00556958606466651,
-0.761321485042572,
0.05605602264404297,
0.16847527027130127,
-0.7497729063034058,
0.15391607582569122,
0.16718792915344238,
-0.5132800936698914,
-0.22107867896556854,
-0.44164004921913147,
-0.7057285308837891,
1.1866998672485352,
0.7464525699615479,
-0.4554447531700134,
-0.15067292749881744,
0.02187919057905674,
0.9798470735549927,
-0.5288468599319458,
0.5127654671669006,
1.0497897863388062,
0.7467247247695923,
-0.0423639677464962,
-1.0862605571746826,
0.23136739432811737,
-0.19239039719104767,
-0.007660218980163336,
-0.018194468691945076,
-0.46735578775405884,
0.027010628953576088,
0.07644054293632507,
-0.23840369284152985,
-0.12572449445724487,
0.4482991099357605,
0.18505457043647766,
0.2823021709918976,
0.6855312585830688,
0.08721690624952316,
0.7810349464416504,
0.28904053568840027,
0.7121336460113525,
-0.6982809901237488,
0.4552423059940338,
1.2873356342315674,
-0.4848695397377014,
0.47366923093795776,
0.19218237698078156,
-0.5889044404029846,
0.39155763387680054,
0.6391684412956238,
-0.5063759684562683,
0.014710131101310253,
0.15953058004379272,
-0.2365066558122635,
-0.2790732979774475,
-0.37782448530197144,
-0.20617415010929108,
0.4099259078502655,
0.40448394417762756,
-0.31160351634025574,
-0.3864130973815918,
-0.021929290145635605,
0.09424574673175812,
0.01635485514998436,
-0.0024357361253350973,
0.8826655149459839,
0.5787748098373413,
-0.8069807291030884,
0.5742815136909485,
0.14895488321781158,
0.26427048444747925,
-0.560854971408844,
-0.00044735026312991977,
-0.07562360912561417,
0.20950797200202942,
-0.5907725095748901,
-0.6455793976783752,
0.6308339834213257,
0.3159693479537964,
0.33645564317703247,
-0.3667522370815277,
0.5556989908218384,
-0.32060694694519043,
-0.6501376628875732,
0.744891345500946,
0.6182976365089417,
0.11091010272502899,
0.15068313479423523,
-0.6498449444770813,
-0.2108781337738037,
-0.6350969076156616,
-0.20580165088176727,
0.38731586933135986,
0.1528826504945755,
0.07864069938659668,
0.6546400189399719,
0.6611897945404053,
0.3502681851387024,
-0.46192795038223267,
-0.014206935651600361,
0.7651346325874329,
-0.5380221605300903,
-0.5125215649604797,
-1.0700634717941284,
0.06326129287481308,
-0.07076326012611389,
-0.13445143401622772,
0.7017547488212585,
0.17173294723033905,
0.1483461707830429,
0.37883710861206055,
0.7091459631919861,
0.37604665756225586,
0.44807958602905273,
-0.2833334505558014,
0.7466715574264526,
-0.42011645436286926,
0.22217631340026855,
-0.5458754897117615,
-0.99972003698349,
-0.3002285659313202,
0.42544928193092346,
-0.5999430418014526,
-0.2106955647468567,
0.8206122517585754,
0.5864444971084595,
-0.03807032108306885,
0.057855237275362015,
0.2193039357662201,
0.1699855923652649,
0.6811130046844482,
0.2859261929988861,
1.0587056875228882,
0.16404591500759125,
0.3783523142337799,
-0.24924899637699127,
-0.39992183446884155,
0.005452100653201342,
-0.9462981224060059,
-0.747958779335022,
-0.17740821838378906,
-0.16863802075386047,
-0.3967577815055847,
-0.09473653137683868,
1.5852464437484741,
0.49425914883613586,
-0.38320696353912354,
-0.5016053318977356,
0.33696675300598145,
0.14997103810310364,
-0.313459575176239,
-0.20629671216011047,
0.4466016888618469,
-0.14013445377349854,
-0.35158804059028625,
0.6020131707191467,
0.5546371340751648,
-0.12019659578800201,
-0.5825632810592651,
-0.15303626656532288,
0.18900297582149506,
0.03248133882880211,
0.4760296046733856,
-0.15600058436393738,
-0.6468491554260254,
0.020987778902053833,
-0.4939309358596802,
-0.31810468435287476,
0.18808677792549133,
0.7988342642784119,
-0.3765254318714142,
0.3324468731880188,
0.12329021096229553,
0.39814332127571106,
0.2545436918735504,
0.08375103771686554,
1.0395355224609375,
-0.058947619050741196,
-0.12392614036798477,
0.283184289932251,
0.46153679490089417,
0.2573886513710022,
-0.5906904339790344,
0.5904778242111206,
-0.01810872182250023,
-0.604149341583252,
-0.9790468215942383,
-0.04184473678469658,
-0.7032389640808105,
0.054343823343515396,
1.0434813499450684,
-0.5870591402053833,
-0.06386986374855042,
-0.267760694026947,
-0.5866010189056396,
0.5304052233695984,
-0.3024037480354309,
0.8867961764335632,
0.67367023229599,
-0.7527920007705688,
0.0886731669306755,
-0.48231545090675354,
0.5423265695571899,
0.3544684946537018,
-0.9259580373764038,
0.06462353467941284,
0.39853954315185547,
0.3734968304634094,
-0.17579792439937592,
0.7245842814445496,
-0.13847129046916962,
0.11060111224651337,
-0.3483216166496277,
-0.05912236124277115,
0.00110567023511976,
0.04833396151661873,
-0.48468464612960815,
-0.12753057479858398,
0.06220889836549759,
0.3693755865097046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11955v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11955v1 | Analysis of Multidomain Abstractive Summarization Using Salience Allocation | 2024-02-19T08:52:12 | 2024-02-19T08:52:12 | Tohida Rehman, Raghubir Bose, Soumik Dey, Samiran Chattopadhyay | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper explores the realm of abstractive text summarization through the
lens of the SEASON (Salience Allocation as Guidance for Abstractive
SummarizatiON) technique, a model designed to enhance summarization by
leveraging salience allocation techniques. The study evaluates SEASON's
efficacy by comparing it with prominent models like BART, PEGASUS, and
ProphetNet, all fine-tuned for various text summarization tasks. The assessment
is conducted using diverse datasets including CNN/Dailymail, SAMSum, and
Financial-news based Event-Driven Trading (EDT), with a specific focus on a
financial dataset containing a substantial volume of news articles from
2020/03/01 to 2021/05/06. This paper employs various evaluation metrics such as
ROUGE, METEOR, BERTScore, and MoverScore to evaluate the performance of these
models fine-tuned for generating abstractive summaries. The analysis of these
metrics offers a thorough insight into the strengths and weaknesses
demonstrated by each model in summarizing news dataset, dialogue dataset and
financial text dataset. The results presented in this paper not only contribute
to the evaluation of the SEASON model's effectiveness but also illuminate the
intricacies of salience allocation techniques across various types of datasets. | [
-0.3199279010295868,
-0.3202078938484192,
0.23834329843521118,
0.42368772625923157,
-0.41189274191856384,
0.0003892483364325017,
-0.10431699454784393,
-0.784317135810852,
0.5973280072212219,
0.1845952272415161,
-0.6047501564025879,
-0.38349562883377075,
-0.5245620608329773,
0.18343085050582886,
-0.6582897305488586,
1.7786809206008911,
0.17595328390598297,
-0.34735146164894104,
-0.416806161403656,
-0.1128891110420227,
-0.2817254960536957,
-0.5244352221488953,
-0.4357399642467499,
-0.04861462116241455,
0.5863119959831238,
0.1685917228460312,
0.35986313223838806,
0.5695950984954834,
0.8555247187614441,
0.3381294012069702,
-0.11972474306821823,
0.1255824863910675,
-0.4368990659713745,
0.26917505264282227,
0.03760487213730812,
-0.012094858102500439,
-0.8632373213768005,
0.01391167938709259,
0.47882863879203796,
0.7002848386764526,
-0.2159641981124878,
0.6087898015975952,
0.009499872103333473,
0.6880404949188232,
-0.6752466559410095,
0.17236994206905365,
-0.6483972072601318,
-0.015065258368849754,
-0.1818130612373352,
-0.5914733409881592,
-0.10251589864492416,
-0.3079110383987427,
0.7479062676429749,
-0.6186754107475281,
0.4881560504436493,
-0.0009496336570009589,
0.6506235599517822,
0.21657446026802063,
-0.48356178402900696,
-0.2757677137851715,
-0.47609177231788635,
1.0350209474563599,
-0.7672660946846008,
-0.18129755556583405,
0.05190505087375641,
0.22875063121318817,
0.48333126306533813,
-0.5828447341918945,
-0.044605810195207596,
-0.0266718827188015,
-0.11730542778968811,
0.472854346036911,
-0.06881742924451828,
-0.13425658643245697,
-0.22257989645004272,
0.3881690800189972,
-0.3768615424633026,
-0.17307941615581512,
-0.564598560333252,
0.13178685307502747,
0.8137949109077454,
0.38661178946495056,
0.09147468954324722,
-0.445712149143219,
-0.4701763093471527,
0.15672054886817932,
-0.2992155849933624,
0.1284654587507248,
0.5339890122413635,
0.5149775147438049,
-0.2797076404094696,
0.4584692120552063,
-0.10348241776227951,
0.5274032354354858,
-0.23257681727409363,
-0.4276207983493805,
0.04362199455499649,
-0.7267020344734192,
0.031649958342313766,
0.20276518166065216,
0.2802461087703705,
1.0742179155349731,
0.11713350564241409,
-0.16314709186553955,
-0.16599632799625397,
-0.37319523096084595,
0.39881694316864014,
-0.8113889098167419,
-0.41420894861221313,
0.3916679918766022,
-0.7031246423721313,
-0.4806901216506958,
0.21497076749801636,
-0.9701013565063477,
-0.3624717891216278,
-0.498771607875824,
-0.029105406254529953,
-0.33180415630340576,
-0.26627206802368164,
-0.1655472368001938,
-0.7190031409263611,
-0.22882579267024994,
0.3450482189655304,
-1.146828055381775,
0.3426516354084015,
0.7007967233657837,
0.9738776087760925,
-0.37718886137008667,
-0.32865238189697266,
0.03119315393269062,
0.33985692262649536,
0.006644158624112606,
0.9760487675666809,
-0.4555591940879822,
-0.1791858971118927,
-0.3955511450767517,
-0.17014658451080322,
-0.5305567979812622,
-0.17028483748435974,
0.1585066169500351,
-0.48913058638572693,
0.06458309292793274,
-0.24595175683498383,
-0.20208314061164856,
-0.5033432245254517,
0.12110162526369095,
-0.7173230051994324,
0.5768340229988098,
0.10301650315523148,
-1.133374810218811,
0.5169814229011536,
-1.1735527515411377,
-0.4733618199825287,
-0.3926672041416168,
0.2962675988674164,
-0.46139127016067505,
0.09724520891904831,
0.1887892633676529,
0.40534868836402893,
-0.09327129274606705,
0.20036272704601288,
0.07853689789772034,
-0.13919787108898163,
0.5072451233863831,
-0.4149908721446991,
0.2981679439544678,
0.2538250982761383,
-0.12002997100353241,
0.29620152711868286,
-0.7302098870277405,
-0.2664344310760498,
-0.027809690684080124,
0.20128677785396576,
-0.7360039353370667,
0.17781731486320496,
0.3252127766609192,
0.12562616169452667,
0.3916521668434143,
-0.15238694846630096,
0.11213964968919754,
-0.578145444393158,
0.30469298362731934,
0.8496589660644531,
0.2692206799983978,
0.37959226965904236,
-0.3940577208995819,
0.8377839922904968,
0.12393879890441895,
0.23632773756980896,
-0.606584370136261,
-0.14566999673843384,
-0.274407297372818,
-0.6073127388954163,
0.4628903567790985,
0.48230138421058655,
-0.3013220429420471,
0.02740619145333767,
-0.2771441638469696,
-0.3130277693271637,
-0.3087579309940338,
-0.39552590250968933,
0.21812666952610016,
0.4105488359928131,
0.43538615107536316,
-0.3599109649658203,
-0.518997848033905,
-1.1245166063308716,
-0.03315623477101326,
0.23378564417362213,
0.2835112512111664,
0.06756804138422012,
0.4823710024356842,
0.30303555727005005,
0.9546496868133545,
-0.7010375261306763,
0.07451152056455612,
-0.45514005422592163,
0.36520248651504517,
0.2326577603816986,
0.2729855477809906,
1.1103625297546387,
-0.7377590537071228,
-0.20733307301998138,
-0.034458111971616745,
-0.7474866509437561,
-0.20029717683792114,
-0.2522352337837219,
0.00016171984316315502,
0.10348988324403763,
-0.1009276807308197,
-0.1445159614086151,
0.6062865853309631,
0.5128517150878906,
-0.647081732749939,
0.6395158171653748,
-0.028453031554818153,
0.391588032245636,
-1.0540046691894531,
0.39227020740509033,
0.3763502240180969,
-0.3148520886898041,
-0.5394936800003052,
0.2215842306613922,
-0.3494325876235962,
0.1554977297782898,
-0.08136331290006638,
0.3018563985824585,
-0.45503494143486023,
-0.2455930858850479,
-0.617615818977356,
0.16348734498023987,
0.018326090648770332,
0.34487634897232056,
-0.08632805198431015,
0.8951455950737,
0.25263768434524536,
-0.8060848712921143,
0.15602481365203857,
0.007000204641371965,
-0.16323477029800415,
0.3604777753353119,
-0.7310423851013184,
-0.5626748204231262,
-0.5029594898223877,
0.13665147125720978,
-1.0791082382202148,
-0.13368339836597443,
0.3989713191986084,
-0.22943967580795288,
-0.17044638097286224,
0.1185794249176979,
-0.005331561900675297,
0.009433504194021225,
-0.7476824522018433,
0.6510916352272034,
0.13083821535110474,
-0.23667480051517487,
0.44464072585105896,
0.3140203654766083,
-0.9981200098991394,
-0.7853521704673767,
-0.2958814203739166,
0.013197721913456917,
-0.6197694540023804,
-0.23668769001960754,
0.4181787669658661,
0.0942700058221817,
-0.4391365945339203,
0.1220766007900238,
-0.21336263418197632,
0.07209379971027374,
0.3615033030509949,
0.24173450469970703,
0.513495922088623,
0.10496789962053299,
-0.3014015257358551,
0.33154433965682983,
-0.3832363486289978,
0.04569651558995247,
-0.20664267241954803,
0.2820066213607788,
0.14135406911373138,
-0.28535300493240356,
-0.4550113081932068,
0.41553860902786255,
0.5071517825126648,
-0.22632233798503876,
0.8376481533050537,
0.18130233883857727,
0.0016503059305250645,
0.18672889471054077,
-0.20082078874111176,
-0.2566763162612915,
-0.3412435054779053,
0.5657534599304199,
-0.07275278121232986,
-0.4242793023586273,
0.8985845446586609,
0.14337939023971558,
0.6202589869499207,
0.8160598278045654,
0.20088417828083038,
0.1574859917163849,
0.8281388282775879,
0.6746746301651001,
-0.08574351668357849,
0.3536561131477356,
-0.3583822548389435,
0.1902712881565094,
-0.7411377429962158,
-0.32236039638519287,
-0.47527873516082764,
-0.5989111065864563,
-0.35440465807914734,
0.06376296281814575,
0.5347737073898315,
-0.2808653712272644,
0.07052990794181824,
0.08193448930978775,
-0.4556151330471039,
0.5292161703109741,
0.46837112307548523,
-0.036186106503009796,
0.7029789090156555,
0.14337216317653656,
0.1850319355726242,
-0.2987947463989258,
-0.686445951461792,
-0.5981490015983582,
1.1882843971252441,
0.3853031098842621,
0.48927542567253113,
0.2548297941684723,
0.3565428555011749,
0.4085142910480499,
0.42533764243125916,
-0.6705952286720276,
0.29982373118400574,
-0.31208592653274536,
-0.19038598239421844,
-0.34315046668052673,
-0.350742369890213,
-0.8526459336280823,
0.553547739982605,
-0.0668940469622612,
-0.6438539028167725,
0.3348487615585327,
-0.04294027015566826,
-0.6014326214790344,
0.10643931478261948,
-0.48080992698669434,
0.5681090354919434,
-0.01530557218939066,
-0.19161240756511688,
-0.3591455817222595,
-0.5639458894729614,
0.6947658061981201,
-0.13355925679206848,
0.2868882119655609,
-0.24325446784496307,
-0.07500960677862167,
0.8943002223968506,
-0.2630651891231537,
0.8891521096229553,
-0.025138244032859802,
-0.2669295370578766,
-0.027754181995987892,
-0.3863019347190857,
0.03573030233383179,
0.3631526529788971,
-0.17190176248550415,
-0.0035671249497681856,
0.3865550458431244,
-0.5349966883659363,
-0.3900145888328552,
0.5720483064651489,
-0.6437784433364868,
-0.28537634015083313,
-0.8351640105247498,
-0.9344528317451477,
0.10627620667219162,
-0.16217315196990967,
0.15403981506824493,
0.7829993367195129,
-0.2353907823562622,
-0.077836774289608,
0.22450488805770874,
-0.05716659873723984,
0.849795401096344,
0.38259369134902954,
-0.3055278956890106,
-0.47170642018318176,
0.974828839302063,
0.11346083134412766,
0.18386563658714294,
0.20550546050071716,
-0.10598577558994293,
-0.2555873692035675,
-0.6446649432182312,
-0.381535142660141,
-0.13083583116531372,
-0.49530869722366333,
-0.2859649360179901,
-0.7725127339363098,
-0.2136208415031433,
-0.3273577392101288,
-0.169524148106575,
-0.254578173160553,
-0.8015738725662231,
0.0005256563890725374,
-0.16376270353794098,
0.5751060843467712,
0.5411443114280701,
0.16408021748065948,
0.3729608952999115,
-0.6773042678833008,
0.313027024269104,
0.08955278992652893,
-0.013164693489670753,
0.4773114323616028,
-0.4785901606082916,
-0.5856149792671204,
0.0493931919336319,
-0.5019770264625549,
-0.7592971324920654,
0.6535166501998901,
0.09224554151296616,
0.39392977952957153,
0.7129151225090027,
0.09137444943189621,
0.7036671042442322,
-0.22909514605998993,
0.9793509244918823,
0.2665715217590332,
-0.864722490310669,
0.2597527503967285,
-0.5356810092926025,
0.496025413274765,
0.6842408180236816,
0.243062362074852,
-0.4474349617958069,
-0.8251979351043701,
-0.616782546043396,
-1.4219934940338135,
0.7536606788635254,
0.23510198295116425,
0.1542963683605194,
0.033466290682554245,
0.40681707859039307,
0.561512291431427,
0.7961516380310059,
-0.6163115501403809,
-0.4351038336753845,
-0.3889997899532318,
-0.2016495317220688,
0.09773734956979752,
-0.3449164628982544,
-0.2947409451007843,
-0.3804666996002197,
0.56708824634552,
-0.07368701696395874,
0.14998933672904968,
0.07123198360204697,
0.09666664898395538,
0.141055628657341,
0.17531728744506836,
0.8230836391448975,
1.366760492324829,
-0.3335930109024048,
-0.12990304827690125,
-0.03187332674860954,
-0.5257394909858704,
-0.18016865849494934,
0.5462179183959961,
-0.333344429731369,
0.13930237293243408,
0.6772885918617249,
0.6190657019615173,
0.4703150689601898,
-0.6701372861862183,
0.5126404166221619,
-0.007657620590180159,
-0.13946805894374847,
-0.35852310061454773,
-0.0634264349937439,
-0.34846922755241394,
0.2498973309993744,
0.8109701871871948,
0.3563885986804962,
0.7780798673629761,
-0.387343168258667,
-0.04949361830949783,
0.36036819219589233,
0.003574465634301305,
-0.4993237257003784,
0.8084537982940674,
0.2189202457666397,
0.6604154109954834,
0.37670135498046875,
0.03233934938907623,
-0.41628628969192505,
1.0082861185073853,
0.4197388291358948,
0.8997640609741211,
-0.23975740373134613,
0.31066012382507324,
0.2186778485774994,
0.19723039865493774,
0.10120195150375366,
0.2506171762943268,
0.19949029386043549,
-0.42923209071159363,
-0.7421114444732666,
-0.4488055109977722,
-0.2865844964981079,
-0.1650589406490326,
-0.8059844374656677,
-0.16023631393909454,
-0.11079274863004684,
-0.28059715032577515,
0.41362202167510986,
-0.2419554889202118,
-0.25471770763397217,
-0.0076831793412566185,
-0.4246949851512909,
0.6965588331222534,
-0.8916590213775635,
-0.03504182770848274,
0.9308912754058838,
-0.37812554836273193,
-0.1805519461631775,
0.25636813044548035,
0.05391920730471611,
-0.3578035831451416,
0.6010083556175232,
0.09084606170654297,
0.013275811448693275,
-0.08408332616090775,
-0.22672803699970245,
-0.7014898657798767,
1.2534841299057007,
-0.029569735750555992,
-0.19622904062271118,
0.2534511089324951,
-0.3418329954147339,
0.4364328682422638,
-0.4533552825450897,
0.48819321393966675,
0.5847406983375549,
0.5870100259780884,
0.2417912632226944,
-1.041991114616394,
-0.20433256030082703,
-0.40315183997154236,
0.03252842649817467,
0.30016863346099854,
-0.7978845238685608,
0.8029569387435913,
-0.3427743911743164,
-0.07149224728345871,
0.12424670904874802,
0.8956984877586365,
0.3604169189929962,
0.9349024891853333,
0.31780749559402466,
0.22248539328575134,
0.6305063366889954,
0.009485766291618347,
1.1774297952651978,
-0.5080653429031372,
0.2961364686489105,
0.789188802242279,
-0.042347200214862823,
0.546380341053009,
0.6166155934333801,
-0.1843835413455963,
0.327547550201416,
0.525593638420105,
0.07015968859195709,
0.932845950126648,
0.17270927131175995,
-0.466517835855484,
0.2840050756931305,
-0.3831048607826233,
-0.6081714630126953,
0.48263001441955566,
0.050631456077098846,
-0.362091064453125,
-0.41317835450172424,
0.024524115025997162,
0.05309419333934784,
0.09816700965166092,
-0.44743260741233826,
0.9936813116073608,
-0.03701615333557129,
-0.6375406384468079,
-0.01959633082151413,
0.4864942133426666,
0.694985032081604,
-0.5789104104042053,
0.0441695936024189,
-0.3070240616798401,
-0.17024728655815125,
-0.23704320192337036,
-0.33055537939071655,
0.5430454015731812,
0.17978176474571228,
-0.44210878014564514,
-0.14718782901763916,
0.49201011657714844,
-0.45891571044921875,
-0.6235334277153015,
-0.21205244958400726,
0.5206400752067566,
-0.01613793335855007,
0.1447051614522934,
-0.43549224734306335,
-0.3684152662754059,
-0.18628492951393127,
-0.22949433326721191,
0.42360392212867737,
0.4597334563732147,
0.0108173917979002,
0.5525941252708435,
0.5708755254745483,
0.2171378880739212,
-0.31632182002067566,
0.2892560660839081,
0.8169886469841003,
-0.7730015516281128,
-0.845610499382019,
-1.0548487901687622,
0.6353779435157776,
-0.3016318678855896,
-0.34104737639427185,
1.0793627500534058,
0.84767085313797,
0.04747378081083298,
-0.3064679801464081,
1.0119818449020386,
0.08824191242456436,
0.40466874837875366,
-0.6390882730484009,
0.458434522151947,
-0.36936917901039124,
0.4813994765281677,
-0.5990576148033142,
-0.8870768547058105,
-0.15249833464622498,
0.49019336700439453,
-0.44967466592788696,
0.14720043540000916,
0.7161423563957214,
0.3206232190132141,
-0.10542207211256027,
0.48217839002609253,
-0.2690235674381256,
-0.2528857886791229,
-0.09789934009313583,
0.18023011088371277,
0.7511166334152222,
-0.22086918354034424,
0.026848573237657547,
-0.2542547881603241,
-0.3253927230834961,
-0.44221463799476624,
-1.1045762300491333,
-0.800520122051239,
-0.657882571220398,
-0.47181466221809387,
-0.002309831790626049,
0.38936692476272583,
1.0649292469024658,
0.5069801211357117,
-0.8180413842201233,
-0.2547245919704437,
0.41473767161369324,
0.04735318943858147,
-0.7228946685791016,
-0.30936485528945923,
0.6608042120933533,
-0.3384595215320587,
-0.9688329100608826,
0.051743920892477036,
0.46936869621276855,
0.12318827956914902,
-0.15866313874721527,
0.44261395931243896,
-0.022893443703651428,
-0.059209756553173065,
0.8740261793136597,
-0.0389912985265255,
-0.3577265441417694,
0.10926082730293274,
-0.027431190013885498,
0.15442748367786407,
-0.40183591842651367,
0.9695653915405273,
-0.3178307116031647,
0.021908948197960854,
0.3576267957687378,
0.46758291125297546,
0.10757990926504135,
0.7691229581832886,
0.6868657469749451,
-0.8889066576957703,
0.28668951988220215,
-0.1430332064628601,
0.026514502242207527,
-0.021479055285453796,
-0.48664888739585876,
0.39236295223236084,
0.08774831891059875,
-0.3986266851425171,
-0.545936644077301,
-0.3166039288043976,
-0.928161084651947,
-0.5228949785232544,
0.7765117287635803,
0.24472805857658386,
0.07642021775245667,
-0.19551461935043335,
-0.1523679941892624,
-0.11259140819311142,
-0.6516774892807007,
1.3151984214782715,
0.8679566979408264,
-0.35448047518730164,
-0.26815271377563477,
-1.0409011840820312,
0.47499313950538635,
0.2843470573425293,
-0.8411145210266113,
0.15461161732673645,
0.7066134214401245,
0.03876696899533272,
0.11020184308290482,
0.5039845108985901,
-0.1357065886259079,
0.20400013029575348,
-0.352696031332016,
0.008190198801457882,
-0.33319950103759766,
-0.5662643909454346,
-0.14247095584869385,
0.34696531295776367,
-0.12778659164905548,
-0.22409047186374664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11943v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11943v2 | LEMMA: Towards LVLM-Enhanced Multimodal Misinformation Detection with External Knowledge Augmentation | 2024-02-19T08:32:27 | 2024-06-20T20:20:30 | Keyang Xuan, Li Yi, Fan Yang, Ruochen Wu, Yi R. Fung, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rise of multimodal misinformation on social platforms poses significant
challenges for individuals and societies. Its increased credibility and broader
impact compared to textual misinformation make detection complex, requiring
robust reasoning across diverse media types and profound knowledge for accurate
verification. The emergence of Large Vision Language Model (LVLM) offers a
potential solution to this problem. Leveraging their proficiency in processing
visual and textual information, LVLM demonstrates promising capabilities in
recognizing complex information and exhibiting strong reasoning skills. In this
paper, we first investigate the potential of LVLM on multimodal misinformation
detection. We find that even though LVLM has a superior performance compared to
LLMs, its profound reasoning may present limited power with a lack of evidence.
Based on these observations, we propose LEMMA: LVLM-Enhanced Multimodal
Misinformation Detection with External Knowledge Augmentation. LEMMA leverages
LVLM intuition and reasoning capabilities while augmenting them with external
knowledge to enhance the accuracy of misinformation detection. Our method
improves the accuracy over the top baseline LVLM by 7% and 13% on Twitter and
Fakeddit datasets respectively. | [
-0.33934125304222107,
-0.743013858795166,
0.6929736733436584,
0.021528733894228935,
-0.26064276695251465,
0.03467131778597832,
-0.22388403117656708,
-0.7192615270614624,
0.07401397824287415,
0.4265156090259552,
-0.43532609939575195,
-0.4216902554035187,
-0.5444872975349426,
-0.12183037400245667,
-0.2405126392841339,
0.45076674222946167,
0.22369609773159027,
0.0697399452328682,
-0.3671090006828308,
-0.20975147187709808,
-0.2911408543586731,
-0.4168905019760132,
-0.3068002164363861,
0.04085277393460274,
0.7005042433738708,
0.3540196418762207,
0.3799625635147095,
0.2130688577890396,
0.4648996591567993,
0.3116894066333771,
0.07684217393398285,
0.9584379196166992,
-0.411761611700058,
0.3378485143184662,
-0.06356845796108246,
-0.4995640218257904,
-0.08125608414411545,
-0.3361145555973053,
0.7504009008407593,
0.042894262820482254,
-0.07290758192539215,
0.07833188027143478,
-0.04355459660291672,
0.67850261926651,
-0.8154019713401794,
0.08647306263446808,
-0.9420074224472046,
-0.14101585745811462,
-0.16896246373653412,
-0.37376901507377625,
-0.5791579484939575,
0.05050979182124138,
-0.22880341112613678,
-0.48906955122947693,
-0.09887909144163132,
0.09913312643766403,
0.6656261682510376,
0.31176748871803284,
-0.412847101688385,
-0.19051699340343475,
-0.6337360143661499,
0.6600280404090881,
-0.6113656759262085,
0.8199941515922546,
0.272190123796463,
0.46233299374580383,
0.20420998334884644,
-0.7540138363838196,
-0.8708889484405518,
-0.1741267740726471,
0.023394789546728134,
0.0516100712120533,
-0.3472866117954254,
-0.18168888986110687,
0.46049609780311584,
0.016923483461141586,
-0.408051997423172,
0.07486764341592789,
-0.40664732456207275,
-0.5262333154678345,
0.2697344124317169,
-0.08992868661880493,
0.19712182879447937,
-0.1651618480682373,
-0.5105200409889221,
0.02021379955112934,
-0.5444197058677673,
0.03183145448565483,
0.25777050852775574,
0.19192008674144745,
-0.16503052413463593,
0.7131815552711487,
-0.1905464231967926,
0.573026716709137,
-0.08481235802173615,
-0.5862504243850708,
0.5771636366844177,
-0.5923172831535339,
-0.39876148104667664,
-0.0036850094329565763,
0.6275519132614136,
0.7496058940887451,
0.22302541136741638,
0.23689016699790955,
-0.2606276273727417,
0.10855436325073242,
0.007297048810869455,
-0.6202558279037476,
0.10377143323421478,
0.06843485683202744,
-0.610609769821167,
0.005354164633899927,
-0.03164173662662506,
-0.7338800430297852,
-0.9969775080680847,
-0.36522823572158813,
0.47037312388420105,
-0.592211127281189,
-0.3852027952671051,
-0.054070599377155304,
-0.31613144278526306,
0.14103776216506958,
0.8696361780166626,
-0.368606299161911,
-0.5760855674743652,
0.4993986189365387,
0.7839524149894714,
0.012193541042506695,
-0.022413725033402443,
-0.768776535987854,
0.2481652945280075,
-0.12753134965896606,
0.9128259420394897,
-0.5370784401893616,
0.10383067280054092,
0.24027112126350403,
0.06470853090286255,
0.04663942754268646,
-0.3623504638671875,
0.5082381367683411,
-0.4794865846633911,
0.08420547097921371,
-0.40466490387916565,
-0.40007272362709045,
-0.28930237889289856,
0.5527679920196533,
-0.5857557058334351,
0.7328264713287354,
-0.12904705107212067,
-0.9182968735694885,
0.621372401714325,
-0.4215995669364929,
-0.27675506472587585,
0.16707879304885864,
-0.20427517592906952,
-0.347953736782074,
-0.17384734749794006,
0.5487613677978516,
0.5956271290779114,
-0.06276815384626389,
0.11369286477565765,
-0.5569410920143127,
-0.0679674744606018,
0.35728099942207336,
-0.8094332218170166,
0.589987576007843,
0.2023322433233261,
-0.13281205296516418,
0.2710253894329071,
-0.7012537717819214,
-0.2039133459329605,
-0.09798163920640945,
-0.40416985750198364,
-0.7050095200538635,
-0.022010257467627525,
-0.12361226230859756,
0.23002347350120544,
0.29748329520225525,
-0.4989202320575714,
0.2315758913755417,
-0.029249954968690872,
0.03724571689963341,
0.7714605927467346,
-0.04590911790728569,
0.38775545358657837,
-0.09321238845586777,
0.04692910984158516,
0.3834877014160156,
0.4902617633342743,
-0.4053475856781006,
-0.5760276913642883,
-0.8115611672401428,
-0.4478622078895569,
-0.05826154351234436,
0.5890665650367737,
-1.4834872484207153,
0.03353115916252136,
-0.2026887834072113,
-0.2465495467185974,
-0.653386652469635,
0.4833917021751404,
0.0557982362806797,
0.4549639821052551,
0.5233265161514282,
0.15935449302196503,
-0.7950137853622437,
-1.0222307443618774,
-0.4995443522930145,
0.004968428052961826,
0.20518851280212402,
0.19775573909282684,
0.4660817086696625,
-0.526167094707489,
0.7778550386428833,
-0.09417782723903656,
-0.5414618849754333,
-0.3860121965408325,
-0.17173032462596893,
0.16370730102062225,
0.07951485365629196,
0.46427685022354126,
-1.2040303945541382,
-0.45577725768089294,
0.2390095591545105,
-0.9276202321052551,
-0.023357443511486053,
-0.15652203559875488,
0.15857046842575073,
0.4713743031024933,
0.573894739151001,
-0.5983176231384277,
0.41342422366142273,
0.43813246488571167,
-0.28869521617889404,
0.40515419840812683,
-0.23753060400485992,
0.3611718416213989,
-0.8977864384651184,
-0.35779714584350586,
0.39788317680358887,
-0.5028244853019714,
-0.6408700346946716,
-0.07958797365427017,
0.37057316303253174,
0.5829278826713562,
-0.5985714197158813,
0.3873624801635742,
-0.6048469543457031,
-0.034175798296928406,
-0.1703723818063736,
0.2622894048690796,
-0.10728439688682556,
0.19350291788578033,
-0.12645184993743896,
0.4985986053943634,
0.5373083353042603,
-0.5602366328239441,
0.7221895456314087,
-0.20458818972110748,
-0.623014509677887,
0.647640585899353,
-0.17990441620349884,
-0.3446657955646515,
-0.4238002896308899,
0.2150866687297821,
-0.9237090349197388,
-0.14400723576545715,
0.48540401458740234,
-0.49907246232032776,
0.1426529586315155,
-0.09749248623847961,
-0.8429039120674133,
-0.4346218705177307,
-0.41386905312538147,
0.13460901379585266,
0.4241975247859955,
-0.6909769177436829,
0.8491888642311096,
0.30922114849090576,
0.29759660363197327,
-0.7375439405441284,
-0.7408025860786438,
-0.007261072751134634,
-0.18417857587337494,
-0.8658117055892944,
-0.10331760346889496,
-0.16965393722057343,
-0.5665522813796997,
-0.07598993182182312,
0.015860863029956818,
0.1185133308172226,
-0.3861379325389862,
0.168864443898201,
0.19650521874427795,
-0.3628532588481903,
0.4514739215373993,
-0.26138970255851746,
0.10397153347730637,
-0.3643788993358612,
-0.2345057725906372,
0.4416448771953583,
-0.2098708152770996,
-0.5980508923530579,
-0.490805983543396,
0.0328681543469429,
0.8099687695503235,
-0.1255943477153778,
0.914807915687561,
1.2263946533203125,
-0.40864917635917664,
-0.1774354726076126,
-1.0011138916015625,
-0.10845721513032913,
-0.4558611214160919,
0.39216554164886475,
-0.08059275150299072,
-0.7483991384506226,
0.2584547698497772,
0.13732533156871796,
-0.19100143015384674,
0.5694991946220398,
0.6112626791000366,
-0.08500437438488007,
0.8664093613624573,
0.6008610725402832,
0.12208631634712219,
0.5595347881317139,
-0.22260691225528717,
0.15684275329113007,
-0.623772382736206,
-0.4963603615760803,
0.003720003180205822,
-0.12467929720878601,
-0.27309224009513855,
-0.9520033597946167,
0.43407824635505676,
-0.08383201062679291,
0.06578949093818665,
-0.10631075501441956,
-0.31465423107147217,
0.3592710793018341,
0.49427950382232666,
0.3497410714626312,
0.5757340788841248,
0.18167737126350403,
-0.16976507008075714,
-0.24824240803718567,
-0.7240273952484131,
-0.07576341181993484,
0.7975151538848877,
0.6457625031471252,
0.8803778290748596,
0.18938452005386353,
0.04754374176263809,
0.5773597955703735,
0.3966124355792999,
-0.5987837910652161,
0.45284709334373474,
-0.0643465518951416,
-0.33064037561416626,
-0.24117539823055267,
-0.33026108145713806,
-0.308271199464798,
0.6527126431465149,
-0.5730423331260681,
-0.5899234414100647,
0.2512337267398834,
0.13114875555038452,
-0.07796092331409454,
0.5561566352844238,
-0.7269551157951355,
0.42915332317352295,
-0.3946600556373596,
-0.48414793610572815,
-0.36773741245269775,
-0.5446280241012573,
0.6509697437286377,
-0.1251085251569748,
0.7150638103485107,
-0.08405842632055283,
-0.17532943189144135,
0.41147080063819885,
-0.13924640417099,
1.1519981622695923,
-0.2982235252857208,
-0.4428415298461914,
0.29043683409690857,
-0.209395170211792,
0.6583632826805115,
0.07179633527994156,
0.22120638191699982,
0.0847281664609909,
-0.4422777593135834,
-0.03949863836169243,
-0.45571157336235046,
0.6965274214744568,
-0.31598961353302,
-0.4292767643928528,
-0.33231106400489807,
-0.7089064717292786,
-0.15914243459701538,
0.10117275267839432,
0.19859948754310608,
0.4319864511489868,
0.308922678232193,
0.6840863227844238,
0.7959975600242615,
-0.33941128849983215,
0.5255692601203918,
0.6085546016693115,
-0.40668758749961853,
-0.3630632162094116,
0.9260168671607971,
0.12247764319181442,
0.2849796712398529,
0.6139732003211975,
0.16943207383155823,
-0.4005546569824219,
-0.3918769657611847,
-0.5048094987869263,
0.19318857789039612,
-1.265726089477539,
-0.26702356338500977,
-0.7955909371376038,
-0.21977190673351288,
-0.38903072476387024,
0.14023807644844055,
-0.23101726174354553,
-0.07239717990159988,
-0.0728181004524231,
0.12139015644788742,
0.42386654019355774,
0.5340880155563354,
-0.2923523187637329,
0.15370824933052063,
-0.8504650592803955,
0.5986317992210388,
0.3813937306404114,
0.03152185305953026,
-0.0860658586025238,
-0.47342297434806824,
-0.32574549317359924,
0.4548354148864746,
-0.08595772087574005,
-0.7502949833869934,
0.4235052466392517,
0.08002471178770065,
0.8732094168663025,
0.6467486023902893,
-0.20677310228347778,
0.6629669666290283,
-0.21402283012866974,
0.7451151609420776,
0.48755693435668945,
-0.6354978084564209,
0.412506639957428,
-0.22025033831596375,
0.152016744017601,
0.09431750327348709,
0.31887468695640564,
-0.48919522762298584,
-0.35147690773010254,
-0.3030908405780792,
-0.6448156237602234,
0.3218473792076111,
-0.0669887438416481,
-0.001986860763281584,
0.267692506313324,
-0.13236220180988312,
0.1978069543838501,
0.3128839135169983,
-1.2785245180130005,
-0.24091924726963043,
-0.13451185822486877,
-0.1726740300655365,
-0.004795743152499199,
-0.41397708654403687,
0.02351418323814869,
-0.40668514370918274,
0.6013808846473694,
-0.18993030488491058,
0.1610320657491684,
0.26844313740730286,
-0.4897822141647339,
-0.02446720562875271,
0.16147075593471527,
0.9799379706382751,
0.7634357213973999,
0.07241524010896683,
0.25240233540534973,
0.21266743540763855,
-0.3882587254047394,
-0.27184367179870605,
-0.2000267654657364,
-0.09905880689620972,
0.11384760588407516,
0.7487009167671204,
0.7811699509620667,
-0.030116645619273186,
-0.7811561822891235,
0.7797396779060364,
-0.0014619975117966533,
-0.3212527930736542,
-0.29204708337783813,
-0.09662095457315445,
0.1398409903049469,
0.7650971412658691,
0.7526044249534607,
0.3857114911079407,
-0.08865676820278168,
-0.5749803781509399,
0.1551123410463333,
0.7247375249862671,
-0.38619205355644226,
0.030384259298443794,
0.33014801144599915,
0.18180295825004578,
-0.00020679953740909696,
0.057202987372875214,
-0.0307439174503088,
-0.5823471546173096,
0.3365604281425476,
0.31979477405548096,
0.3478187024593353,
-0.2524174749851227,
0.13099822402000427,
0.11908574402332306,
0.7785250544548035,
-0.12754686176776886,
0.1561894714832306,
-0.11748415976762772,
-0.9942473769187927,
-0.5012363195419312,
-0.5868671536445618,
0.02186400815844536,
0.42373126745224,
0.06719465553760529,
0.33539077639579773,
-0.23854874074459076,
0.042232710868120193,
0.00016743133892305195,
-0.5906840562820435,
-0.5912278890609741,
0.1267525553703308,
0.4503181576728821,
0.8850452303886414,
-0.618939220905304,
0.7374144196510315,
0.3046500086784363,
-0.4370943605899811,
-0.3265284299850464,
0.18163567781448364,
0.12397730350494385,
-1.025917410850525,
0.9975358247756958,
0.3372971713542938,
-0.16628628969192505,
-0.3454589545726776,
-0.6774012446403503,
-0.6610116958618164,
1.0588369369506836,
0.33716216683387756,
-0.9181244373321533,
0.1384974718093872,
0.01324698980897665,
0.3738280236721039,
-0.6186438798904419,
0.13041073083877563,
-0.012105163186788559,
0.8082411289215088,
0.2535378932952881,
-0.9190171360969543,
-0.2306186854839325,
-0.06508278101682663,
-0.2792697548866272,
0.0604521781206131,
-0.36288636922836304,
0.9598070979118347,
-0.33784374594688416,
-0.12062487006187439,
-0.35394346714019775,
0.5558484196662903,
-0.0880238488316536,
0.696264922618866,
0.7186671495437622,
0.33454829454421997,
0.8205649256706238,
0.09538451582193375,
1.0248719453811646,
-0.038302741944789886,
0.2031247764825821,
0.8383917808532715,
-0.17171841859817505,
0.7911243438720703,
0.6059362292289734,
0.16049620509147644,
0.5431063175201416,
0.4083320200443268,
0.0419541671872139,
0.5284985899925232,
-0.15781989693641663,
-0.34698259830474854,
-0.6562447547912598,
-0.11404768377542496,
-0.5793074369430542,
0.43377986550331116,
0.7184324860572815,
-0.6242987513542175,
-0.1427011936903,
0.47727057337760925,
-0.340119868516922,
0.005343510769307613,
-0.7506235837936401,
0.6508956551551819,
-0.002962604397907853,
-0.2911090552806854,
0.6480847001075745,
-0.17607133090496063,
1.0425198078155518,
-0.5224942564964294,
-0.06907029449939728,
0.21216776967048645,
0.437871515750885,
-0.2918032109737396,
-0.8606941103935242,
0.14589709043502808,
-0.15997600555419922,
-0.15293759107589722,
-0.1823256015777588,
1.4392828941345215,
-0.6994060277938843,
-0.5014607310295105,
0.47476786375045776,
0.814222514629364,
-0.23523211479187012,
-0.2761770188808441,
-0.5219669342041016,
0.12930549681186676,
0.2199777364730835,
0.011264960281550884,
0.049282997846603394,
0.49782803654670715,
-0.06457574665546417,
0.9774895906448364,
0.95665442943573,
-0.017634907737374306,
0.08420276641845703,
0.2981705069541931,
0.915522038936615,
-0.29248476028442383,
-0.5339128971099854,
-1.2085052728652954,
0.5617350339889526,
-0.545819103717804,
0.18351809680461884,
1.0133599042892456,
0.3864825367927551,
0.6738275289535522,
-0.270324170589447,
1.0806447267532349,
0.1508604735136032,
0.5736601948738098,
-0.7760241627693176,
0.5825594067573547,
-0.9480782747268677,
0.33589786291122437,
-0.19722220301628113,
-0.7805891036987305,
-0.3890894949436188,
0.5464669466018677,
-0.26736536622047424,
-0.08882774412631989,
0.714277982711792,
0.7629886269569397,
-0.19376762211322784,
-0.1968546211719513,
0.6871410012245178,
0.48497524857521057,
0.17986468970775604,
0.39744970202445984,
1.1675069332122803,
-0.12884803116321564,
0.674461841583252,
0.05106298625469208,
-0.026295935735106468,
-0.6239575743675232,
-0.9107133746147156,
-1.104856252670288,
-0.6956144571304321,
0.0007634714129380882,
-0.4880293905735016,
0.043621718883514404,
0.7917192578315735,
0.5995550155639648,
-0.33415675163269043,
0.3340222239494324,
0.2758931517601013,
0.4392249584197998,
0.05843080207705498,
-0.2628575563430786,
-0.03368860483169556,
-0.023039506748318672,
-0.31299206614494324,
0.43012410402297974,
0.5318183302879333,
0.03654630482196808,
-0.47784098982810974,
-0.2513501048088074,
-0.43421608209609985,
0.08602174371480942,
1.027601718902588,
0.012541120871901512,
-1.0293859243392944,
-0.35728970170021057,
-0.10186221450567245,
-0.16271090507507324,
0.1503027230501175,
0.7080593705177307,
-0.7766522765159607,
0.5282162427902222,
0.46083468198776245,
0.5331504940986633,
0.38869428634643555,
-0.08171474188566208,
0.1352495700120926,
-0.8368101716041565,
0.31295648217201233,
-0.11361120641231537,
0.6079599261283875,
0.655911386013031,
-0.41342294216156006,
0.22857287526130676,
0.6345813274383545,
-0.1547096073627472,
-0.8151952028274536,
0.2729196846485138,
-1.0768589973449707,
-0.37086206674575806,
1.532389521598816,
0.25346097350120544,
-0.32405778765678406,
-0.26849207282066345,
-0.5863783359527588,
0.04574204608798027,
-0.5622571110725403,
0.4332970678806305,
0.5164832472801208,
0.12313912808895111,
-0.5511658191680908,
-0.7965578436851501,
0.43439286947250366,
-0.1569022536277771,
-0.9084692001342773,
-0.045071374624967575,
0.6006524562835693,
0.2332133650779724,
0.47616249322891235,
0.6651474237442017,
0.2951696813106537,
0.4913802742958069,
0.007711133919656277,
-0.002609885996207595,
-0.4013665020465851,
-0.2722105383872986,
0.042708493769168854,
0.3322684168815613,
-0.4095284640789032,
-0.2136908322572708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11941v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11941v3 | CoCo-Agent: A Comprehensive Cognitive MLLM Agent for Smartphone GUI Automation | 2024-02-19T08:29:03 | 2024-06-02T13:25:05 | Xinbei Ma, Zhuosheng Zhang, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have shown remarkable potential as
human-like autonomous language agents to interact with real-world environments,
especially for graphical user interface (GUI) automation. However, those GUI
agents require comprehensive cognition ability including exhaustive perception
and reliable action response. We propose a Comprehensive Cognitive LLM Agent,
CoCo-Agent, with two novel approaches, comprehensive environment perception
(CEP) and conditional action prediction (CAP), to systematically improve the
GUI automation performance. First, CEP facilitates the GUI perception through
different aspects and granularity, including screenshots and complementary
detailed layouts for the visual channel and historical actions for the textual
channel. Second, CAP decomposes the action prediction into sub-problems: action
type prediction and action target conditioned on the action type. With our
technical design, our agent achieves new state-of-the-art performance on AITW
and META-GUI benchmarks, showing promising abilities in realistic scenarios.
Code is available at https://github.com/xbmxb/CoCo-Agent. | [
-0.4388541281223297,
-1.1390454769134521,
0.5714877247810364,
0.4411628544330597,
0.21121591329574585,
0.25860121846199036,
-0.4277987480163574,
-0.5488703846931458,
0.17301838099956512,
0.6396445631980896,
-0.436716765165329,
-0.6088693737983704,
-0.3196672797203064,
-0.15952478349208832,
-0.21945104002952576,
0.5957379341125488,
0.06435481458902359,
-0.44836559891700745,
-0.38310885429382324,
0.04799911379814148,
-0.5915699601173401,
-0.2838558852672577,
-0.8001388907432556,
-0.3339264988899231,
0.6914207935333252,
0.4922123849391937,
0.7519745230674744,
-0.08835889399051666,
0.214241161942482,
0.45770299434661865,
0.4834125339984894,
0.24530565738677979,
-0.17277884483337402,
0.2677863538265228,
-0.08734315633773804,
-0.3054829239845276,
-0.8762415051460266,
-0.20689891278743744,
0.05943814665079117,
-0.01184843759983778,
-0.09726832807064056,
-0.1350587159395218,
0.24325548112392426,
0.5252765417098999,
-0.8114544749259949,
0.6162478923797607,
-0.5333254337310791,
-0.036519791930913925,
0.3075733482837677,
0.011126001365482807,
-0.543728768825531,
0.06633470207452774,
-0.10438364744186401,
-0.9540663361549377,
-0.14804136753082275,
0.09586215764284134,
0.4459846019744873,
0.3567548096179962,
-0.4952780604362488,
-0.07861480861902237,
-0.6321792602539062,
0.7952990531921387,
-0.37797629833221436,
0.3286025822162628,
0.4445343613624573,
0.4739997386932373,
-0.1881929636001587,
-0.8080462217330933,
-0.5981003642082214,
-0.5650284886360168,
0.023256586864590645,
0.34167593717575073,
-0.1062108725309372,
0.38939258456230164,
0.33097386360168457,
-0.006574066821485758,
-0.7385103106498718,
0.01538543775677681,
-0.00773787684738636,
-0.5383865237236023,
0.710798978805542,
0.3650393784046173,
0.6639522314071655,
0.14471127092838287,
-0.3783288896083832,
0.15874440968036652,
-0.21794676780700684,
0.4050568640232086,
-0.1960240602493286,
0.09989166259765625,
-0.32385164499282837,
0.5576825737953186,
-0.5601427555084229,
0.7862933278083801,
-0.2505847215652466,
-0.366998553276062,
0.056348271667957306,
-0.3262612223625183,
-0.5128272175788879,
0.08290988206863403,
0.9552608728408813,
0.40675634145736694,
0.41951504349708557,
-0.16866064071655273,
-0.09388219565153122,
0.25354093313217163,
0.408633291721344,
-0.3924349248409271,
-0.45782366394996643,
0.5582714676856995,
-0.07766705751419067,
-0.21574871242046356,
-0.12236467748880386,
-0.5027285814285278,
-0.4233877658843994,
-0.5298721790313721,
0.041197407990694046,
-0.397701233625412,
-0.2432774305343628,
-0.04620426148176193,
0.11834875494241714,
0.2972685694694519,
0.7083399891853333,
-0.7011131048202515,
0.3435313403606415,
0.3952282965183258,
0.6757265329360962,
-0.5154223442077637,
-0.2699747383594513,
-0.546289324760437,
0.33920183777809143,
-0.23638665676116943,
0.9042035341262817,
-0.5948169827461243,
-0.3611947298049927,
-0.16132302582263947,
-0.09966529160737991,
-0.3644917905330658,
-0.1737387627363205,
0.6863350868225098,
-0.4943922162055969,
-0.25480929017066956,
-0.013444598764181137,
-0.06495045870542526,
-0.3419327437877655,
0.6150704026222229,
-0.7955058217048645,
0.8178436160087585,
0.2293863445520401,
-0.6103250980377197,
0.4059259295463562,
-0.9029660820960999,
-0.5387114882469177,
0.04906472563743591,
-0.03300425782799721,
-0.261374831199646,
-0.2174580693244934,
0.4513172209262848,
0.4700051546096802,
0.05527108907699585,
0.16769301891326904,
-0.7660993337631226,
-0.33542224764823914,
0.3745419681072235,
-0.5947805643081665,
0.7327898740768433,
0.23339664936065674,
-0.3813477158546448,
0.38408806920051575,
-0.48532772064208984,
0.46359795331954956,
-0.18860794603824615,
-0.10269059985876083,
0.050703104585409164,
-0.14653699100017548,
0.33938321471214294,
0.5565221905708313,
0.39593029022216797,
-0.563788890838623,
0.331438273191452,
0.03768640384078026,
0.1284606009721756,
0.5955721139907837,
-0.15914598107337952,
0.5963383913040161,
-0.17802847921848297,
0.6181139945983887,
-0.18839262425899506,
0.5319758653640747,
-0.17360389232635498,
-0.701797366142273,
-0.6879028677940369,
-0.6965351700782776,
-0.019436093047261238,
0.8343465924263,
-0.8254743218421936,
0.4264640808105469,
-0.23179727792739868,
-0.31172817945480347,
0.10291042178869247,
0.27875271439552307,
0.28493061661720276,
0.31300532817840576,
0.16966736316680908,
-0.19201166927814484,
-0.5500262379646301,
-0.7568561434745789,
-0.10308775305747986,
-0.1657276153564453,
-0.009167036041617393,
0.44506457448005676,
0.20479600131511688,
-0.7396279573440552,
1.3408046960830688,
-0.42836183309555054,
-0.5069145560264587,
-0.3942291736602783,
-0.039967380464076996,
-0.015249897725880146,
0.2458217591047287,
0.3862324059009552,
-0.9173430800437927,
-0.6902786493301392,
0.46950337290763855,
-0.9205067157745361,
0.018962373957037926,
-0.12508302927017212,
-0.085601806640625,
0.2676449120044708,
0.4445580542087555,
-0.7771997451782227,
0.7686386704444885,
0.5654783844947815,
0.009317097254097462,
0.6064916849136353,
-0.25045761466026306,
0.046376436948776245,
-0.7904618382453918,
0.09867412596940994,
0.02553004026412964,
-0.41165679693222046,
-0.5560657978057861,
-0.03720913827419281,
0.31609490513801575,
-0.21351206302642822,
-0.5471422076225281,
0.8118521571159363,
-0.3281385600566864,
-0.2595091164112091,
-0.5516256093978882,
-0.028513407334685326,
-0.0571150928735733,
0.9607275724411011,
0.27206891775131226,
0.8149845004081726,
0.6275794506072998,
-1.001103162765503,
0.5820870399475098,
-0.018853848800063133,
-0.2663252353668213,
0.41071444749832153,
-0.5173839926719666,
-0.11412380635738373,
0.23518496751785278,
0.6790102124214172,
-0.870637834072113,
-0.39045023918151855,
0.16669318079948425,
-0.3358387053012848,
0.08821456134319305,
0.2226913571357727,
-0.4333660304546356,
-0.4881609380245209,
-0.3513525128364563,
0.26823562383651733,
0.28239554166793823,
-0.13822101056575775,
1.0531340837478638,
0.328784704208374,
-0.23160043358802795,
-0.6386250257492065,
-0.5356523394584656,
0.36225688457489014,
0.03870347887277603,
-0.5204724073410034,
0.14823324978351593,
-0.0694243311882019,
-0.2915850579738617,
-0.4028758108615875,
0.018725818023085594,
-0.021722372621297836,
0.21407009661197662,
0.6990883350372314,
0.24248647689819336,
0.14955517649650574,
-0.20841915905475616,
0.16175363957881927,
-0.22598697245121002,
0.015535471960902214,
-0.22259347140789032,
0.4783076345920563,
-0.22198152542114258,
-0.36430054903030396,
-0.565604567527771,
-0.007927853614091873,
0.8641130328178406,
-0.2842191755771637,
0.06201053038239479,
0.8508688807487488,
-0.18876275420188904,
-0.061197735369205475,
-0.4585331082344055,
0.018367353826761246,
-0.5377964973449707,
0.25320911407470703,
-0.6493110060691833,
-0.27136096358299255,
0.39867866039276123,
-0.11096920073032379,
0.22758804261684418,
-0.0022782133892178535,
0.7345389127731323,
-0.21370546519756317,
1.207358956336975,
0.4935290515422821,
-0.3636760115623474,
0.6936636567115784,
-0.501133918762207,
0.04683135449886322,
-1.0141788721084595,
-0.25492674112319946,
-0.10908812284469604,
-0.12173116952180862,
-0.34225475788116455,
-0.37388384342193604,
0.529955267906189,
-0.13993090391159058,
-0.4860348701477051,
0.33533748984336853,
-0.1780034452676773,
0.1686391681432724,
0.510589599609375,
0.3354603052139282,
0.3614627718925476,
0.10889041423797607,
-0.37835609912872314,
0.33698558807373047,
-0.6845318078994751,
-0.6255776286125183,
1.0498104095458984,
0.07326363027095795,
0.8176340460777283,
0.0027372916229069233,
0.25988486409187317,
0.6270048022270203,
0.5804771184921265,
-0.72383713722229,
0.6632212400436401,
0.3982934057712555,
-0.48376303911209106,
-0.4565895199775696,
0.035270653665065765,
-1.0138005018234253,
0.348650187253952,
-0.20363812148571014,
-1.051363468170166,
-0.08269483596086502,
0.14650915563106537,
-0.2325144112110138,
0.015311772003769875,
-0.6749878525733948,
0.8354654908180237,
-0.4388178288936615,
-0.5999296307563782,
-0.2813952565193176,
-0.45287030935287476,
0.6155852675437927,
0.004060089122503996,
0.30058982968330383,
-0.19666288793087006,
-0.33624494075775146,
0.048189327120780945,
-0.19602225720882416,
0.8908439874649048,
-0.027684686705470085,
-0.26646214723587036,
0.5164059400558472,
0.2937093675136566,
0.6447446942329407,
0.33810558915138245,
-0.0828118845820427,
-0.007470106240361929,
-0.2831883430480957,
-0.590299129486084,
-0.8223173022270203,
0.862919807434082,
-0.648595929145813,
-0.43229857087135315,
-0.36111781001091003,
-0.5832720398902893,
-0.4693787395954132,
0.16623280942440033,
0.2174169272184372,
0.31262773275375366,
-0.5538601279258728,
-0.16175781190395355,
0.38215935230255127,
-0.25942903757095337,
0.6790858507156372,
0.4814600944519043,
-0.495695561170578,
-0.3822501301765442,
0.8809110522270203,
-0.3418390154838562,
0.06832273304462433,
0.602661669254303,
-0.3809199631214142,
-0.47649306058883667,
-0.31991395354270935,
-0.5749679207801819,
-0.23852349817752838,
-0.3175446391105652,
-0.11346102505922318,
-0.9260466694831848,
-0.05871869996190071,
-0.35760849714279175,
-0.38880935311317444,
-0.05157237499952316,
-0.19729265570640564,
-0.201003760099411,
0.04529254510998726,
0.1185859888792038,
0.26901891827583313,
0.252175897359848,
0.2248847484588623,
-0.5292912721633911,
0.6467924118041992,
0.5446411967277527,
0.005580613389611244,
0.02223735675215721,
-0.0010375275742262602,
-0.10487711429595947,
0.33911317586898804,
-0.7048630118370056,
-0.4328663647174835,
0.36892837285995483,
0.1986106038093567,
0.4566664397716522,
0.7188263535499573,
0.2883836328983307,
0.6076276302337646,
-0.1604851335287094,
0.7263703942298889,
0.39911144971847534,
-0.7141621112823486,
0.4847339391708374,
-0.4694596230983734,
0.5145886540412903,
0.3162042498588562,
-0.13524533808231354,
-0.41542765498161316,
-0.7920475006103516,
-0.47290295362472534,
-0.4621420204639435,
0.5215273499488831,
0.4177713990211487,
0.040873706340789795,
0.2508695721626282,
-0.11825406551361084,
-0.05781415477395058,
0.023476291447877884,
-0.64475017786026,
0.0909305065870285,
-0.21914151310920715,
-0.0557682067155838,
-0.33665531873703003,
0.1590447574853897,
0.16250360012054443,
-0.19449304044246674,
0.5013399720191956,
-0.551708459854126,
0.38154616951942444,
0.18147477507591248,
-0.5705190300941467,
0.19303059577941895,
0.20817884802818298,
0.692791223526001,
0.5764365792274475,
-0.04648671671748161,
-0.09958086907863617,
0.3396534323692322,
-0.5953219532966614,
0.19345051050186157,
-0.30659905076026917,
0.04914753511548042,
-0.2747202217578888,
0.5265128016471863,
0.5583309531211853,
0.3355438709259033,
-0.9538906216621399,
0.4603028893470764,
-0.1570277363061905,
0.09634517133235931,
-0.6630746722221375,
0.45959609746932983,
-0.05260780081152916,
0.15431776642799377,
0.2194461077451706,
0.1286756694316864,
0.3526748716831207,
-0.6410983800888062,
0.26145675778388977,
0.38176560401916504,
-0.5253915190696716,
-0.2161993682384491,
0.7303702235221863,
0.4070473611354828,
-0.05880605801939964,
0.6702344417572021,
-0.07972677797079086,
-0.5603244304656982,
0.9649472236633301,
0.40271687507629395,
0.8838247060775757,
-0.10627555847167969,
0.4109542667865753,
0.2845534682273865,
0.13724713027477264,
0.25224652886390686,
0.257013201713562,
-0.47158384323120117,
-0.639409601688385,
-0.3872833549976349,
-0.2916581928730011,
-0.37541449069976807,
-0.31482502818107605,
-0.4171171188354492,
0.34175240993499756,
-0.44906631112098694,
-0.3892741799354553,
-0.1939888596534729,
0.1786062866449356,
-0.8146092891693115,
0.5294092297554016,
0.16543862223625183,
0.8459320664405823,
-0.3151301145553589,
1.281276822090149,
0.520444393157959,
-0.2841237783432007,
-0.40310946106910706,
-0.06979234516620636,
-0.11568243056535721,
-0.6358293890953064,
0.497526079416275,
0.1903095692396164,
-0.2526368498802185,
-0.3041408658027649,
-0.2991091310977936,
-0.6215127110481262,
1.329925298690796,
0.31987637281417847,
-0.8726653456687927,
0.09946975111961365,
0.10969730466604233,
0.42272278666496277,
-0.37785202264785767,
0.7468101978302002,
0.5567886829376221,
0.7555497884750366,
-0.18651364743709564,
-1.0256415605545044,
0.05083531141281128,
-0.17720650136470795,
0.19040875136852264,
-0.027583463117480278,
-0.6985986828804016,
0.4492139220237732,
-0.4902890920639038,
-0.005833257921040058,
0.3046838045120239,
0.6301583647727966,
0.34914687275886536,
0.9228530526161194,
0.4129055142402649,
0.26095184683799744,
0.6501787900924683,
0.07428722083568573,
1.2855393886566162,
-0.5273177623748779,
0.17123419046401978,
0.9054698348045349,
-0.5554060339927673,
0.6710729002952576,
0.1083284243941307,
-0.13563981652259827,
0.6105586886405945,
0.7900052666664124,
0.49869582056999207,
0.46474355459213257,
-0.11111672967672348,
-0.5034711956977844,
-0.33552294969558716,
0.10126781463623047,
-0.05721646547317505,
0.5269215703010559,
0.7064969539642334,
-0.10158485174179077,
0.07137426733970642,
0.5663020014762878,
-0.22807404398918152,
-0.08745025843381882,
-0.523481011390686,
0.8177340030670166,
0.0916876494884491,
-0.7708348035812378,
0.5027382969856262,
-0.003958581015467644,
0.6349714994430542,
-0.6109381318092346,
0.06500804424285889,
-0.15413179993629456,
0.16425666213035583,
-0.35920250415802,
-0.6022577881813049,
-0.016161160543560982,
-0.23642194271087646,
0.06542620807886124,
0.04977157711982727,
0.9814342856407166,
-0.17875097692012787,
-0.3421485424041748,
0.31265512108802795,
0.22637011110782623,
0.02398274466395378,
-0.5557147264480591,
-1.0695881843566895,
0.23775099217891693,
-0.07147791981697083,
-0.13928408920764923,
0.21919962763786316,
0.12057086080312729,
-0.5561299920082092,
1.2288143634796143,
0.7413811683654785,
-0.3319932818412781,
-0.10703080147504807,
-0.29017937183380127,
0.8037030696868896,
-0.5900360345840454,
-0.5184522271156311,
-0.6750327348709106,
0.4631160795688629,
-0.3196640908718109,
-0.21965089440345764,
0.6116520166397095,
0.864148736000061,
0.3735450804233551,
-0.13461890816688538,
1.0674784183502197,
-0.05291200801730156,
-0.24589519202709198,
-0.47130101919174194,
0.49089866876602173,
-0.3730049729347229,
0.13134342432022095,
-0.4097411334514618,
-1.1026785373687744,
-0.2688577473163605,
0.3738485276699066,
-0.3541388511657715,
0.18681392073631287,
0.657492458820343,
0.8758808374404907,
-0.37122973799705505,
-0.09766028821468353,
0.7831841111183167,
0.003020194824784994,
0.3400997519493103,
0.7681295275688171,
0.6100157499313354,
-0.23647437989711761,
0.5798037052154541,
-0.09730244427919388,
-0.18388278782367706,
-0.5087979435920715,
-0.5246214270591736,
-0.8021900653839111,
-0.5305203795433044,
-0.30427315831184387,
-0.19676975905895233,
-0.06324934214353561,
0.7555840611457825,
0.9176007509231567,
-0.6548842191696167,
-0.14640599489212036,
-0.32433080673217773,
0.32555606961250305,
-0.5466883778572083,
-0.2434217780828476,
0.13995592296123505,
-0.3945033848285675,
-0.8820412158966064,
0.26880526542663574,
0.5377844572067261,
-0.1291530877351761,
-0.2695327699184418,
-0.44458699226379395,
0.2958434224128723,
0.18923333287239075,
1.0779789686203003,
0.6256526708602905,
-1.021188735961914,
0.020873339846730232,
-0.1418841928243637,
-0.4486848711967468,
-0.12484654039144516,
1.011256456375122,
-1.0202492475509644,
0.5524115562438965,
0.199887216091156,
0.20193569362163544,
0.6922000646591187,
-0.018180282786488533,
0.7789337038993835,
-0.28773602843284607,
0.3538478910923004,
0.19201725721359253,
0.3755653202533722,
-0.058242350816726685,
-0.4088958501815796,
0.43166130781173706,
-0.18261197209358215,
-0.2676713168621063,
-0.45716214179992676,
0.4564052224159241,
-1.516783595085144,
-0.34987571835517883,
1.2011386156082153,
-0.1812654584646225,
-0.45864346623420715,
-0.5004754066467285,
-0.8872343897819519,
-0.13013063371181488,
-0.7102069854736328,
0.5663811564445496,
0.28235185146331787,
-0.37569281458854675,
-0.42285919189453125,
-0.4547438323497772,
0.3376820385456085,
0.11362273246049881,
-1.040392518043518,
0.02350916899740696,
0.42330724000930786,
0.1185048297047615,
0.011167109943926334,
0.8252367377281189,
0.17745830118656158,
0.5936312079429626,
-0.06633693724870682,
0.2867267429828644,
-0.2062128484249115,
-0.3472483456134796,
0.16975130140781403,
0.052975479513406754,
-0.04693296551704407,
-0.23817966878414154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11934v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11934v1 | Team QUST at SemEval-2024 Task 8: A Comprehensive Study of Monolingual and Multilingual Approaches for Detecting AI-generated Text | 2024-02-19T08:22:51 | 2024-02-19T08:22:51 | Xiaoman Xu, Xiangrun Li, Taihang Wang, Jianxiang Tian, Ye Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents the participation of team QUST in Task 8 SemEval 2024. We
first performed data augmentation and cleaning on the dataset to enhance model
training efficiency and accuracy. In the monolingual task, we evaluated
traditional deep-learning methods, multiscale positive-unlabeled framework
(MPU), fine-tuning, adapters and ensemble methods. Then, we selected the
top-performing models based on their accuracy from the monolingual models and
evaluated them in subtasks A and B. The final model construction employed a
stacking ensemble that combined fine-tuning with MPU. Our system achieved 8th
(scored 8th in terms of accuracy, officially ranked 13th) place in the official
test set in multilingual settings of subtask A. We release our system code
at:https://github.com/warmth27/SemEval2024_QUST | [
-0.31485751271247864,
-0.5558993816375732,
0.37100303173065186,
0.014177784323692322,
-0.37202703952789307,
0.284178763628006,
-0.10655848681926727,
-0.5509599447250366,
-0.10708033293485641,
0.45177924633026123,
-0.4943227767944336,
-0.6147345304489136,
-0.5483684539794922,
0.5144319534301758,
-0.38463306427001953,
1.030312418937683,
0.004947985056787729,
0.1183718591928482,
-0.3756066858768463,
-0.47686484456062317,
-0.3952004015445709,
-0.548557460308075,
-0.9867455959320068,
-0.21981778740882874,
0.4356893002986908,
0.5678471922874451,
0.3576548397541046,
0.32715871930122375,
0.4128260612487793,
0.32493478059768677,
0.15264499187469482,
0.34064632654190063,
-0.27200832962989807,
0.05777555704116821,
-0.2697846293449402,
-0.3568471670150757,
-0.5774643421173096,
-0.07042044401168823,
0.43282389640808105,
0.10861140489578247,
0.134630024433136,
0.2974594831466675,
0.1472490429878235,
0.24883346259593964,
-0.34410515427589417,
0.22163814306259155,
-0.5478625893592834,
-0.03227647393941879,
-0.22246506810188293,
-0.1710248589515686,
-0.43528807163238525,
0.1023915633559227,
-0.04680928215384483,
-0.4392865300178528,
0.1331394612789154,
0.07534291595220566,
0.7680578231811523,
0.46680721640586853,
-0.7196348905563354,
-0.19822704792022705,
-0.39377668499946594,
0.9059867262840271,
-0.851195752620697,
0.38536205887794495,
0.4498266577720642,
-0.006356320809572935,
0.12521381676197052,
-0.5410237908363342,
-0.6295315027236938,
0.04538284242153168,
0.1522054523229599,
0.19310565292835236,
0.015561308711767197,
-0.0526178702712059,
0.16963618993759155,
0.24586573243141174,
-0.7178518772125244,
0.23766382038593292,
-0.4143332839012146,
-0.5005409717559814,
0.8657475113868713,
0.046331968158483505,
0.6016783714294434,
0.07877521961927414,
-0.476164847612381,
0.014475954696536064,
-0.39551860094070435,
0.1099979355931282,
0.3664945363998413,
0.24793079495429993,
-0.13448351621627808,
0.38025593757629395,
-0.23696452379226685,
0.20863847434520721,
0.0006666016997769475,
0.04967733472585678,
0.655304491519928,
-0.8335414528846741,
-0.06591243296861649,
0.22430488467216492,
0.8486790657043457,
0.011181650683283806,
0.13344740867614746,
0.14246219396591187,
-0.3815421164035797,
0.0311116985976696,
0.17935001850128174,
-0.5789305567741394,
-0.3017148971557617,
0.11850390583276749,
-0.30809485912323,
-0.5423955917358398,
-0.21083690226078033,
-0.5292686223983765,
-0.5321312546730042,
-0.3684457540512085,
0.6806244850158691,
-0.5636404752731323,
-0.35129621624946594,
0.08252333104610443,
-0.030562611296772957,
0.0670698955655098,
0.5486767292022705,
-0.5173813700675964,
-0.12776778638362885,
0.5005061030387878,
0.29587018489837646,
-0.2424476146697998,
-0.6359429359436035,
-0.5016767382621765,
-0.21512629091739655,
-0.3190498948097229,
0.9891526699066162,
-0.3041777014732361,
-0.06392568349838257,
-0.3009541630744934,
0.14006030559539795,
0.0008753296569921076,
-0.4595640003681183,
0.9406314492225647,
-0.31476205587387085,
0.4370407164096832,
-0.13497339189052582,
-0.512954592704773,
-0.5108827352523804,
0.5697505474090576,
-0.6929105520248413,
1.2392840385437012,
0.06616152077913284,
-0.7674875259399414,
0.46488580107688904,
-0.5706678628921509,
-0.5569360852241516,
0.519614577293396,
-0.1345498263835907,
-0.6404707431793213,
-0.165411114692688,
0.4696193039417267,
0.38746440410614014,
-0.03462139889597893,
0.10219964385032654,
-0.018420472741127014,
-0.30865687131881714,
-0.1684345006942749,
-0.6466109156608582,
0.85779869556427,
0.1271035373210907,
-0.6257445216178894,
0.3919253945350647,
-0.706305205821991,
-0.013328278437256813,
0.05978648364543915,
-0.41305696964263916,
-0.4199507534503937,
-0.14926087856292725,
0.002344889799132943,
0.1538671851158142,
0.6472824215888977,
-0.6734665036201477,
-0.02458333969116211,
-0.2942520081996918,
0.14907367527484894,
0.7850208878517151,
0.06271132826805115,
0.3994331657886505,
-0.15181864798069,
0.7671011090278625,
0.2550598382949829,
0.10740991681814194,
-0.5509045124053955,
-0.3639852702617645,
-0.9172362685203552,
-0.22404438257217407,
0.49468931555747986,
0.7025150656700134,
-1.1488302946090698,
0.2534857988357544,
-0.13218891620635986,
-0.5062286257743835,
-0.4350599944591522,
-0.06861580908298492,
0.2945045232772827,
0.40637147426605225,
0.32118847966194153,
0.13473211228847504,
-0.674129068851471,
-0.9863708019256592,
-0.18233442306518555,
-0.16696995496749878,
0.36132606863975525,
-0.09214635193347931,
0.7699116468429565,
-0.2614338994026184,
0.28279849886894226,
0.12861038744449615,
0.04097088426351547,
-0.35299769043922424,
0.3003941476345062,
0.14943096041679382,
0.604142963886261,
0.4820520877838135,
-0.9374988079071045,
-0.6203046441078186,
0.231898233294487,
-0.9191750884056091,
-0.008094578050076962,
0.009488405659794807,
-0.04696701094508171,
0.44647854566574097,
0.5197256207466125,
-0.18939334154129028,
0.489227831363678,
0.35113853216171265,
-0.4914016127586365,
0.6479544639587402,
-0.06933461874723434,
0.641135573387146,
-1.3111436367034912,
-0.1745530217885971,
0.010871979407966137,
-0.6654946804046631,
-0.6227267980575562,
0.27873694896698,
0.20093178749084473,
-0.19456112384796143,
-0.4351678192615509,
0.4495805501937866,
-0.39197981357574463,
0.2973940670490265,
-0.2883952856063843,
-0.39330732822418213,
0.1095007136464119,
0.3605988323688507,
-0.15055584907531738,
1.0996869802474976,
0.3921854496002197,
-0.5076438784599304,
0.23781508207321167,
0.06133747845888138,
-0.33642473816871643,
0.548535943031311,
-0.45546385645866394,
0.2178211361169815,
-0.11157810688018799,
-0.18055830895900726,
-0.927791953086853,
-0.008254182524979115,
0.22203050553798676,
-0.8001196384429932,
0.10455328226089478,
0.08021225035190582,
-0.616672694683075,
-0.34982141852378845,
-0.20559194684028625,
0.6404998898506165,
0.298095166683197,
-0.4076516330242157,
0.5204457640647888,
0.7187753915786743,
-0.3983989655971527,
-0.3992786109447479,
-0.4956429898738861,
0.20484738051891327,
-0.42466285824775696,
-0.6980230212211609,
0.06339521706104279,
-0.07452991604804993,
-0.040295086801052094,
-0.24143868684768677,
-0.02590429037809372,
-0.0933898389339447,
0.19738782942295074,
-0.16472914814949036,
0.11160772293806076,
-0.2836000621318817,
0.13788415491580963,
0.1978391706943512,
-0.07744155079126358,
0.00201611896045506,
-0.25638943910598755,
0.5432314276695251,
-0.24860508739948273,
-0.19962793588638306,
-0.4101274907588959,
0.388499915599823,
0.6306191086769104,
-0.6538903117179871,
0.4823262393474579,
0.9983131289482117,
-0.5878500938415527,
-0.2519051730632782,
-0.35090017318725586,
-0.06030910834670067,
-0.452609121799469,
0.46617352962493896,
-0.4256373643875122,
-1.20003080368042,
0.4568135738372803,
0.10230033099651337,
0.0858239158987999,
0.656770646572113,
0.5980511903762817,
-0.11945590376853943,
1.5114428997039795,
0.6901078820228577,
-0.17981752753257751,
0.273472398519516,
-0.17582771182060242,
0.37692493200302124,
-0.49128100275993347,
-0.1399519145488739,
-0.5991747975349426,
-0.1916443407535553,
-0.6880785822868347,
-0.3487405776977539,
0.648520827293396,
-0.16202312707901,
-0.2065782994031906,
0.46648281812667847,
-0.5271052122116089,
0.25707852840423584,
0.6534343361854553,
0.056688129901885986,
0.1638719141483307,
-0.028085777536034584,
-0.11233314871788025,
0.05897011235356331,
-0.5808103680610657,
-0.43640682101249695,
0.9508713483810425,
0.20476360619068146,
0.26422491669654846,
-0.023272426798939705,
0.8250289559364319,
0.625154435634613,
-0.22513504326343536,
-0.5103760361671448,
0.6649789810180664,
-0.11866314709186554,
-0.41549399495124817,
-0.524994432926178,
-0.15772394835948944,
-1.0323772430419922,
0.2526017725467682,
-0.16113123297691345,
-0.5176024436950684,
0.11380929499864578,
0.017517147585749626,
-0.3186863958835602,
0.08554738759994507,
-0.5883491039276123,
1.0484052896499634,
-0.31189587712287903,
-0.27907317876815796,
-0.30808186531066895,
-0.3893778324127197,
0.15570643544197083,
-0.09501877427101135,
0.49907392263412476,
-0.18111592531204224,
-0.054070211946964264,
0.6397409439086914,
-0.18677303194999695,
0.6208696961402893,
-0.10640290379524231,
-0.17572888731956482,
0.41146138310432434,
-0.060734719038009644,
0.5497028827667236,
0.09460976719856262,
-0.32563310861587524,
0.15177391469478607,
0.07378032058477402,
-0.5793534517288208,
-0.19106340408325195,
0.5148870944976807,
-0.5233319401741028,
-0.19594933092594147,
-0.6003578901290894,
-0.5272799730300903,
0.014843672513961792,
0.5596429109573364,
0.4051043391227722,
0.61196368932724,
-0.19655409455299377,
0.2656618654727936,
0.7566043138504028,
-0.34463128447532654,
0.3588956594467163,
0.3993939161300659,
-0.18862266838550568,
-0.3309582769870758,
1.1606992483139038,
-0.10582949966192245,
-0.24258196353912354,
0.3477005958557129,
0.15600043535232544,
-0.2514166235923767,
-0.8447226285934448,
-0.5719555020332336,
-0.1745891124010086,
-0.4467445909976959,
-0.18163423240184784,
-0.6540451049804688,
-0.2953835427761078,
-0.8587357401847839,
0.27631914615631104,
-0.2325441986322403,
-0.17856980860233307,
-0.3472138047218323,
-0.1974947154521942,
-0.004551625344902277,
0.5791046023368835,
0.17484663426876068,
0.07263969630002975,
-1.0428231954574585,
0.022496795281767845,
-0.13722747564315796,
-0.24455589056015015,
-0.3635411858558655,
-0.4911431074142456,
-0.6299048662185669,
0.13751491904258728,
-0.1847681999206543,
-0.5610083937644958,
0.5004412531852722,
0.18150241672992706,
0.6503564715385437,
0.022206472232937813,
0.1450236588716507,
0.2905898094177246,
-0.3996819257736206,
0.8835815787315369,
-0.16889449954032898,
-0.7377573251724243,
0.5645641088485718,
-0.698318362236023,
0.8463669419288635,
0.8644158840179443,
0.23661169409751892,
-0.41012707352638245,
-0.503339409828186,
-0.643993079662323,
-0.7998052835464478,
0.5527042150497437,
0.222584530711174,
0.1584489494562149,
0.08478914946317673,
0.029377460479736328,
0.21040041744709015,
0.4295714199542999,
-0.6818795204162598,
0.0730571523308754,
0.05068863183259964,
-0.5577489137649536,
-0.12355604767799377,
-0.15729855000972748,
0.39845675230026245,
-0.28698500990867615,
0.9515960812568665,
-0.23954007029533386,
0.053069498389959335,
0.10921420156955719,
-0.2678680717945099,
0.2011244297027588,
0.31076258420944214,
0.6792951822280884,
0.5093773007392883,
0.34756070375442505,
0.0911577120423317,
0.34621384739875793,
-0.30019086599349976,
0.004435353446751833,
0.21742042899131775,
-0.38082870841026306,
-0.1325155347585678,
0.6011514067649841,
0.9443013072013855,
0.023317251354455948,
-0.7040549516677856,
0.46552786231040955,
-0.161229208111763,
-0.3174682855606079,
-0.5769137740135193,
-0.09731954336166382,
-0.13603860139846802,
0.3610994219779968,
0.28462889790534973,
0.2427401840686798,
0.6698663234710693,
-0.393669992685318,
0.38096973299980164,
0.23181848227977753,
-0.45611572265625,
-0.5652077198028564,
0.5386266708374023,
0.329120010137558,
-0.29696333408355713,
0.4597383141517639,
-0.7191305160522461,
-1.1022642850875854,
0.8267508745193481,
0.2469681054353714,
0.7281279563903809,
-0.3711588680744171,
0.2324550896883011,
0.5710171461105347,
0.5146461129188538,
0.1490338295698166,
0.6164955496788025,
-0.0032877707853913307,
-0.9432309865951538,
-0.458511084318161,
-0.4686961770057678,
-0.1570068597793579,
0.2754612863063812,
-0.3775235712528229,
0.5018214583396912,
-0.02892165817320347,
-0.011851109564304352,
0.028293531388044357,
0.10220644623041153,
-0.604742169380188,
0.34826162457466125,
0.3447229564189911,
0.7387027740478516,
-0.774932861328125,
0.7719038128852844,
1.1286163330078125,
-0.30628669261932373,
-0.8248332142829895,
-0.20748916268348694,
0.23291265964508057,
-0.5476298928260803,
0.13631297647953033,
0.3404725193977356,
-0.053964026272296906,
0.2207750827074051,
-0.5971881747245789,
-0.7000072002410889,
0.8704671859741211,
0.13668303191661835,
-0.28746363520622253,
0.07879234850406647,
0.11827180534601212,
0.6083514094352722,
-0.18744297325611115,
0.19515854120254517,
0.38510170578956604,
0.5728157162666321,
-0.19390490651130676,
-1.0175213813781738,
-0.269722580909729,
-0.6813220381736755,
-0.44224685430526733,
0.3455600142478943,
-0.7288641929626465,
0.8048301935195923,
0.13041308522224426,
-0.12889781594276428,
0.15268200635910034,
0.8028733134269714,
0.10957033187150955,
0.5017410516738892,
0.7154704332351685,
0.7430723905563354,
0.8302950263023376,
0.09515473991632462,
0.8336437344551086,
-0.2506735920906067,
0.2526693642139435,
1.161879539489746,
-0.31108608841896057,
0.5531653165817261,
0.21410036087036133,
-0.0200290996581316,
0.34274545311927795,
0.8194682598114014,
-0.008493278175592422,
0.33474165201187134,
-0.20403170585632324,
-0.4797854721546173,
-0.5033922791481018,
-0.31310728192329407,
-0.11503371596336365,
0.6788128018379211,
0.2896454632282257,
-0.02793981321156025,
-0.2528633177280426,
0.49778544902801514,
-0.0616261251270771,
0.144558846950531,
-0.3931649327278137,
0.838108241558075,
-0.11617723107337952,
-0.8103316426277161,
0.1740754097700119,
0.04175705090165138,
0.8327970504760742,
-0.21907545626163483,
-0.1688104122877121,
-0.06620543450117111,
0.4027602970600128,
-0.15047377347946167,
-0.6637599468231201,
0.11846457421779633,
-0.10882912576198578,
-0.1288842260837555,
-0.2230692058801651,
1.0400714874267578,
-0.7296399474143982,
-0.8030092120170593,
0.09942139685153961,
0.4095107316970825,
0.21987846493721008,
-0.23730243742465973,
-0.7875869274139404,
-0.03994156792759895,
0.35415059328079224,
-0.015349378809332848,
0.2775300443172455,
0.5934766530990601,
-0.36835843324661255,
0.4074878394603729,
0.551673173904419,
-0.23629750311374664,
0.14321941137313843,
0.14417758584022522,
0.4256882965564728,
-0.21764005720615387,
-0.5459584593772888,
-0.7600201964378357,
0.5696685910224915,
-0.16958485543727875,
-0.43250390887260437,
0.9691328406333923,
0.9356178045272827,
1.0819742679595947,
0.002036534482613206,
0.983756422996521,
0.12200424075126648,
0.7281582355499268,
-0.3335570991039276,
0.728480339050293,
-0.8028922080993652,
0.09099804610013962,
-0.05312960967421532,
-0.6508393883705139,
0.06381005048751831,
0.360975444316864,
-0.04460908845067024,
-0.1573464721441269,
0.7705113291740417,
0.5689318180084229,
-0.019611960276961327,
0.1611746996641159,
0.4015200734138489,
0.020746655762195587,
0.2966620624065399,
0.43906766176223755,
0.763056755065918,
-0.6988002061843872,
0.36989834904670715,
-0.3609350621700287,
-0.04702270030975342,
0.09950633347034454,
-0.6178960800170898,
-0.8681693077087402,
-0.7413497567176819,
-0.47942915558815,
-0.03726828470826149,
0.07009672373533249,
0.7779116034507751,
0.5899278521537781,
-1.0592172145843506,
-0.10002792626619339,
-0.024751702323555946,
0.07804358005523682,
-0.06523063778877258,
-0.2625109553337097,
0.09974107146263123,
-0.36616143584251404,
-1.0220365524291992,
0.6750367283821106,
0.2907675802707672,
-0.1327168047428131,
-0.050512708723545074,
0.05291474238038063,
-0.6606482267379761,
-0.17222703993320465,
0.5964675545692444,
-0.10869815200567245,
-0.25528204441070557,
-0.5018181204795837,
0.1351344883441925,
-0.10504378378391266,
0.07888653874397278,
0.5328008532524109,
-0.5799687504768372,
0.3492610454559326,
0.84814453125,
0.738792359828949,
0.37125736474990845,
0.0831843763589859,
0.638222336769104,
-0.5231889486312866,
0.1595449596643448,
0.5290154814720154,
0.4046882390975952,
0.26701653003692627,
-0.5388614535331726,
0.7434728741645813,
0.18656104803085327,
-0.8428384065628052,
-0.8670534491539001,
-0.05429815128445625,
-0.6493610739707947,
-0.17178472876548767,
0.9158689975738525,
-0.18510079383850098,
-0.3605242669582367,
-0.20545454323291779,
-0.3539699614048004,
0.360416054725647,
-0.4519228935241699,
0.2676461637020111,
0.8447745442390442,
-0.029698161408305168,
-0.4983288645744324,
-0.414919376373291,
0.22481679916381836,
0.46579980850219727,
-1.0748199224472046,
-0.5620265007019043,
0.5056893825531006,
0.141999289393425,
0.1260751485824585,
0.7107428312301636,
0.08658823370933533,
0.4877792000770569,
-0.1579645574092865,
0.39007946848869324,
-0.005938575137406588,
-0.3753955662250519,
-0.4223978519439697,
-0.018554776906967163,
-0.05134899914264679,
-0.16913996636867523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11924v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11924v3 | Evaluating LLMs' Inherent Multi-hop Reasoning Ability | 2024-02-19T08:12:30 | 2024-07-03T15:50:48 | Jian Wu, Linyi Yang, Zhen Wang, Manabu Okumura, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | While Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in question-answering (QA) tasks,
their multi-step reasoning abilities on multiple evidence integration on
Multi-hop QA tasks remain underexplored. LLMs sometimes generate answers that
rely on internal memory rather than reasoning given context, which brings
concerns about the evaluation quality of real reasoning abilities. The
counterfactual QA task can separate internal memory from reasoning abilities,
but focusing solely on final-QA performance without evaluating the multi-step
reasoning process is insufficient for reporting LLMs' real reasoning abilities.
Current Multi-hop QA (MHQA) benchmarks are factual and annotated on open-source
corpora such as Wikipedia, although useful for multi-step reasoning evaluation,
showing limitations due to potential data contamination in LLMs pre-training
stage. To address this issue, we introduce the Inherent Reasoning Evaluation
(IRE) method, a novel evaluation way that jointly evaluates the LLMs'
chain-of-reasoning performance based on the first knowledge-edited
counterfactual multi-hop QA data which involves editing the original Wikipedia
passages, reducing data contamination risks. The IRE comprehensively assesses
reasoning chains through sub-QA and final-QA evaluations. Our comparisons
reveal significant performance gaps for several LLMs between Wikipedia-based
benchmarks and IRE, deeming data contamination issues in existing benchmarks.
We believe that the IRE benchmark will enhance and facilitate trustworthy LLM
evaluations. | [
-0.5877847671508789,
-0.8509347438812256,
0.7789515852928162,
-0.05072558671236038,
-0.2654312252998352,
0.1927795708179474,
0.03800172358751297,
-0.5583629608154297,
-0.0682331845164299,
0.28652071952819824,
-0.613215446472168,
-0.277109831571579,
-0.5825077295303345,
0.07906629145145416,
-0.17381606996059418,
0.6645023822784424,
-0.19601836800575256,
0.14117683470249176,
-0.4681970477104187,
-0.17385084927082062,
-0.4093948006629944,
-0.3626563549041748,
-0.43537676334381104,
-0.25212791562080383,
0.5568113923072815,
0.460417240858078,
0.5246534943580627,
0.4178222417831421,
0.5976648330688477,
0.29936668276786804,
-0.015170690603554249,
0.46310800313949585,
-0.46925652027130127,
0.06239470839500427,
-0.5470008850097656,
-0.4051856994628906,
-0.4169885218143463,
0.20306189358234406,
0.6802326440811157,
0.31638824939727783,
0.13889819383621216,
0.38525816798210144,
-0.14609834551811218,
0.7233319878578186,
-0.7922572493553162,
-0.19300827383995056,
-0.8522108197212219,
-0.17103274166584015,
0.021975118666887283,
-0.2903412878513336,
-0.42325687408447266,
-0.4547026455402374,
0.2306603044271469,
-0.40482497215270996,
-0.34202003479003906,
-0.0036785195115953684,
0.7973755598068237,
0.2707195580005646,
-0.36464551091194153,
-0.3559076189994812,
-0.5456951260566711,
0.5245929956436157,
-0.7743860483169556,
0.40486621856689453,
0.11559236794710159,
0.31390029191970825,
-0.18685370683670044,
-0.5609294772148132,
-0.6890643835067749,
-0.40808409452438354,
0.1369769275188446,
0.025005057454109192,
-0.21736173331737518,
-0.05444139242172241,
0.32767096161842346,
0.23679690062999725,
-0.49832236766815186,
-0.040355831384658813,
-0.21342425048351288,
-0.07260771840810776,
0.470865935087204,
0.015599804930388927,
0.39568451046943665,
-0.07074005156755447,
-0.616866409778595,
-0.07466738671064377,
-0.6332250833511353,
0.09839089214801788,
0.18306778371334076,
-0.03457684442400932,
0.2084505558013916,
0.7231503129005432,
-0.36389774084091187,
0.29371070861816406,
-0.1478545218706131,
-0.281681090593338,
0.3649264872074127,
-0.4195259213447571,
-0.23709557950496674,
-0.23924939334392548,
0.7552533745765686,
0.1627911776304245,
0.45984944701194763,
-0.38214924931526184,
0.005946787539869547,
-0.07357266545295715,
0.362724632024765,
-0.7060946822166443,
0.017185429111123085,
0.3308733403682709,
-0.28919610381126404,
0.08723052591085434,
0.2216261327266693,
-0.7035555243492126,
-0.14870601892471313,
-0.21690843999385834,
0.9173434376716614,
-0.5168449878692627,
-0.17008879780769348,
-0.007314514368772507,
-0.14866966009140015,
0.22912321984767914,
0.2845296263694763,
-0.19546760618686676,
0.17721666395664215,
0.6895166039466858,
0.6468468904495239,
-0.10395250469446182,
-0.6493000984191895,
-0.800609290599823,
0.006511971820145845,
-0.219964861869812,
0.9595134258270264,
-0.5400193333625793,
-0.11438173055648804,
-0.24323627352714539,
-0.10125017911195755,
-0.3620375990867615,
-0.4535074234008789,
0.650407075881958,
-0.8393052220344543,
-0.10789477825164795,
-0.26334139704704285,
-0.7168666124343872,
-0.2850217819213867,
0.44528961181640625,
-0.45862141251564026,
0.9839141368865967,
0.001451085670851171,
-0.9609012603759766,
0.3451234698295593,
-0.6660671234130859,
-0.30306291580200195,
-0.07781824469566345,
-0.05588847026228905,
-0.13544850051403046,
-0.1100352555513382,
0.33734986186027527,
0.10305974632501602,
-0.24308402836322784,
0.27974337339401245,
-0.4087475538253784,
-0.6065698266029358,
0.38061967492103577,
-0.711832582950592,
0.8020955920219421,
0.001909477636218071,
-0.2996510863304138,
0.08518286049365997,
-0.6782420873641968,
0.34394189715385437,
-0.043915458023548126,
-0.38103553652763367,
-0.4190514087677002,
-0.07193256914615631,
-0.6808460354804993,
0.5697340369224548,
0.25375428795814514,
-0.4280577003955841,
0.24039436876773834,
-0.19772908091545105,
-0.04613113030791283,
0.8437426686286926,
0.1872849315404892,
0.10476672649383545,
-0.47304198145866394,
0.4619503319263458,
0.11061815917491913,
0.45536553859710693,
-0.23630750179290771,
-0.6017206907272339,
-0.8326910734176636,
-0.24405984580516815,
0.23022352159023285,
0.8666049838066101,
-0.7584715485572815,
0.371764212846756,
-0.3824070394039154,
-0.7337576746940613,
-0.5234644412994385,
0.29818806052207947,
0.43324124813079834,
0.47939765453338623,
0.5847113728523254,
-0.14387492835521698,
-0.33305060863494873,
-0.7956146001815796,
-0.3929712176322937,
-0.301861435174942,
-0.12317342311143875,
0.3148338794708252,
0.6836657524108887,
-0.34215718507766724,
0.6369562149047852,
-0.10645613074302673,
0.20989039540290833,
0.054015908390283585,
0.2702973186969757,
0.09851542115211487,
0.43145254254341125,
0.06780602782964706,
-0.36808887124061584,
-0.3326619863510132,
-0.2707657217979431,
-0.8402814269065857,
-0.2012186348438263,
-0.20186911523342133,
-0.5917379856109619,
0.009984704665839672,
0.3211594223976135,
-0.8127391338348389,
0.34112557768821716,
0.3244624435901642,
-0.43687883019447327,
0.8274743556976318,
-0.11866119503974915,
0.5743606686592102,
-0.5672099590301514,
-0.05520906299352646,
-0.04882669821381569,
0.15253666043281555,
-0.3123649060726166,
0.16907382011413574,
0.15460439026355743,
0.3507022261619568,
-0.38934245705604553,
0.5379683375358582,
-0.4338787794113159,
-0.2225096970796585,
-0.05491923540830612,
0.3795219659805298,
0.25289615988731384,
0.3284916877746582,
-0.09684298932552338,
0.8467175364494324,
0.5457774996757507,
-0.5416633486747742,
0.2170788198709488,
0.12535212934017181,
-0.39482155442237854,
0.627424418926239,
-0.3925139605998993,
0.38656893372535706,
0.08544722199440002,
0.13805299997329712,
-0.928400456905365,
0.32701990008354187,
0.23574022948741913,
-0.3849559426307678,
0.16245977580547333,
-0.15568342804908752,
-0.5087632536888123,
-0.4276357591152191,
-0.5353438258171082,
0.3356906473636627,
0.14850378036499023,
-0.6466349363327026,
0.6099661588668823,
0.05010783672332764,
0.015116618946194649,
-0.8199047446250916,
-0.39688965678215027,
0.2198116034269333,
-0.24538663029670715,
-0.8681997656822205,
0.0665266141295433,
-0.32442551851272583,
-0.37417954206466675,
0.09164262562990189,
-0.4061315655708313,
-0.12019996345043182,
0.11465181410312653,
-0.050938837230205536,
0.42616257071495056,
-0.38681715726852417,
0.16733260452747345,
0.024417264387011528,
-0.11731497943401337,
0.3150537312030792,
-0.1257997751235962,
0.25354883074760437,
-0.1881541907787323,
-0.7032229900360107,
-0.4190827012062073,
0.09596990793943405,
0.6514067649841309,
-0.34573376178741455,
0.7316224575042725,
0.4278513193130493,
-0.24745847284793854,
-0.10131261497735977,
-0.8267555832862854,
-0.069601871073246,
-0.3780330717563629,
0.24638919532299042,
-0.6426039338111877,
-0.5987964868545532,
0.36007797718048096,
-0.29686489701271057,
0.049513690173625946,
0.5216418504714966,
0.09882325679063797,
-0.24787664413452148,
0.5781830549240112,
0.12758733332157135,
0.16381649672985077,
0.04282490164041519,
-0.1286822259426117,
0.2865549921989441,
-0.9824243783950806,
-0.33446913957595825,
-0.6764602661132812,
0.0030657851602882147,
-0.4744229018688202,
-0.7770410180091858,
0.4413994550704956,
0.5070228576660156,
-0.49516910314559937,
0.00812515988945961,
-0.03334425017237663,
0.5312155485153198,
0.6301501393318176,
0.16237875819206238,
0.6496841311454773,
-0.13858234882354736,
-0.3910331726074219,
0.1840393841266632,
-0.5671163201332092,
-0.797378659248352,
1.2242099046707153,
0.44068387150764465,
0.6383581757545471,
-0.01972183771431446,
0.4483785033226013,
0.3053145706653595,
0.32125556468963623,
-0.5802313685417175,
0.514966607093811,
0.10577452927827835,
-0.547122061252594,
-0.46094444394111633,
-0.5959136486053467,
-0.32767051458358765,
0.5413733124732971,
-0.3329266309738159,
-0.8338867425918579,
-0.09961298108100891,
-0.2078479528427124,
-0.058696769177913666,
0.5709973573684692,
-0.6743220090866089,
0.7545491456985474,
-0.5139662027359009,
-0.3826518952846527,
-0.3083648681640625,
-0.5498607754707336,
0.5720606446266174,
-0.12781117856502533,
0.22912028431892395,
-0.16649740934371948,
0.07344890385866165,
0.6295236349105835,
-0.2437850832939148,
0.3912818729877472,
-0.15182055532932281,
-0.08832960575819016,
0.46081510186195374,
0.19039563834667206,
0.4990212023258209,
0.24060334265232086,
-0.12865881621837616,
0.4993934631347656,
0.10354451090097427,
-0.21977752447128296,
-0.6072710156440735,
0.5881064534187317,
-0.6853677034378052,
-0.6391176581382751,
-0.4279232621192932,
-0.37125957012176514,
-0.7753064632415771,
0.16496191918849945,
0.019287483766674995,
0.20755191147327423,
-0.0827300101518631,
0.03868008032441139,
0.7951788306236267,
-0.4142581522464752,
0.18808656930923462,
0.7326104640960693,
0.08902397006750107,
-0.4200647175312042,
0.5465648770332336,
0.06639634072780609,
0.32335135340690613,
0.4901354908943176,
0.3454507887363434,
-0.528756856918335,
-0.5961700677871704,
-0.6088758111000061,
0.29688313603401184,
-0.9291221499443054,
-0.15224285423755646,
-0.6971545815467834,
-0.433612197637558,
-0.028811858966946602,
0.0745556652545929,
-0.3471057116985321,
-0.17639246582984924,
0.13326118886470795,
-0.07888399064540863,
0.1096283420920372,
0.6148829460144043,
-0.2417759895324707,
-0.008689461275935173,
-0.9057434797286987,
0.7783647179603577,
0.5711875557899475,
0.4970402717590332,
0.1376914232969284,
-0.5109490752220154,
-0.18327975273132324,
0.03118746541440487,
-0.21577253937721252,
-0.8491681218147278,
-0.3328837454319,
-0.08226639777421951,
0.9627291560173035,
0.3108678460121155,
-0.05725228041410446,
0.7432103753089905,
-0.49545615911483765,
0.5260850191116333,
0.08267677575349808,
-1.0025783777236938,
0.5280841588973999,
-0.03967861458659172,
0.24380095303058624,
0.6473803520202637,
0.4151524305343628,
-0.2555590867996216,
-0.46803727746009827,
-0.45794734358787537,
-0.7269159555435181,
0.5028102993965149,
0.09625484049320221,
-0.1697443425655365,
-0.12976637482643127,
0.3126976788043976,
0.09419199824333191,
0.10499148070812225,
-0.731149435043335,
-0.2672346532344818,
-0.053672101348638535,
0.14971581101417542,
0.3148605227470398,
-0.5209671854972839,
0.019276384264230728,
-0.2763723134994507,
0.8641077280044556,
0.002681198064237833,
-0.030217792838811874,
0.2599177658557892,
-0.2988995313644409,
-0.14781776070594788,
0.5182700753211975,
0.26475512981414795,
1.027422308921814,
-0.23427791893482208,
0.184410959482193,
0.2950185239315033,
-0.31816565990448,
0.2416377067565918,
-0.013197147287428379,
-0.12263667583465576,
-0.24257339537143707,
0.5247039198875427,
0.42649784684181213,
0.05315932631492615,
-0.8386923670768738,
0.5502386093139648,
-0.1154501810669899,
-0.008715472184121609,
-0.0673677995800972,
0.22479933500289917,
0.26331639289855957,
0.4555127024650574,
0.5324774980545044,
0.012438285164535046,
0.18665559589862823,
-0.4245491921901703,
0.43929818272590637,
0.4571874141693115,
-0.03083539381623268,
0.06515996903181076,
0.3933749794960022,
-0.04535526782274246,
0.007834373041987419,
0.7643409967422485,
-0.2252255231142044,
-0.38248559832572937,
0.6281334757804871,
0.3086848258972168,
0.852374792098999,
-0.28936952352523804,
0.13296319544315338,
0.48098498582839966,
0.8322330117225647,
0.16031187772750854,
0.31519731879234314,
0.09289027750492096,
-0.7668302655220032,
-0.7527952790260315,
-0.5239300727844238,
-0.39837193489074707,
0.2801956832408905,
-0.4357534348964691,
0.10496404767036438,
-0.14477242529392242,
0.1387808471918106,
-0.2793048024177551,
0.04242869094014168,
-0.6416912078857422,
0.32762381434440613,
0.12190789729356766,
1.2519803047180176,
-0.6651719212532043,
0.7352243065834045,
0.5302519798278809,
-0.42434918880462646,
-0.6439439654350281,
0.2409568727016449,
-0.2332082837820053,
-0.6702917814254761,
0.5495988726615906,
0.2679837942123413,
-0.4567689895629883,
-0.39403361082077026,
-0.30216607451438904,
-0.7224199175834656,
0.962968647480011,
0.49765545129776,
-0.46229615807533264,
0.09508427232503891,
0.12912960350513458,
0.3481169044971466,
-0.22559399902820587,
0.6432046890258789,
0.6091306805610657,
0.615787923336029,
0.10635139048099518,
-0.9562677145004272,
0.020085111260414124,
-0.2466670423746109,
-0.27528297901153564,
-0.1349329650402069,
-0.5758833885192871,
0.6187641620635986,
-0.37653207778930664,
-0.060958076268434525,
-0.20021764934062958,
0.3505975306034088,
0.5996426939964294,
0.36300987005233765,
0.6259933710098267,
0.7873261570930481,
0.817857563495636,
0.07796787470579147,
0.6956480145454407,
-0.226492777466774,
0.12021876871585846,
1.3591279983520508,
-0.34488359093666077,
0.9312113523483276,
0.49978768825531006,
-0.3490605056285858,
0.6139739155769348,
0.38819456100463867,
0.20645363628864288,
0.2962022125720978,
0.36017948389053345,
-0.22482801973819733,
-0.3379402756690979,
0.11436888575553894,
-0.24955376982688904,
0.6610584259033203,
0.2356628030538559,
-0.08295796066522598,
-0.32035115361213684,
-0.27733752131462097,
0.02880914695560932,
-0.02749151550233364,
-0.254218190908432,
0.7183769345283508,
-0.09557471424341202,
-0.7032938599586487,
0.4575789272785187,
-0.1665295511484146,
0.48621490597724915,
-0.5988852381706238,
-0.25296223163604736,
-0.26383140683174133,
-0.18771572411060333,
-0.12485070526599884,
-0.9317771792411804,
0.2526310384273529,
0.23965516686439514,
0.01627967692911625,
0.1425590217113495,
0.6547823548316956,
-0.052703119814395905,
-0.35831841826438904,
0.6276034116744995,
0.9175546169281006,
0.233465313911438,
-0.22451825439929962,
-0.7270572185516357,
-0.1128765419125557,
-0.1959451138973236,
-0.4207926392555237,
0.1847454458475113,
0.6757356524467468,
0.05172261223196983,
0.8859493136405945,
0.6186346411705017,
0.0415375642478466,
0.21428030729293823,
0.2750368118286133,
0.8851208090782166,
-0.6545164585113525,
-0.3172313868999481,
-0.9438096880912781,
0.5518375635147095,
-0.02923482656478882,
-0.15284587442874908,
0.7169844508171082,
0.6049792766571045,
0.7580296397209167,
0.1366836279630661,
0.8126209378242493,
0.07553394138813019,
0.47320204973220825,
-0.6758313775062561,
0.3561805784702301,
-0.4350021481513977,
0.35587185621261597,
-0.4181026518344879,
-0.80301433801651,
0.1704959273338318,
0.5244280099868774,
-0.23067381978034973,
0.06722592562437057,
0.9741073846817017,
0.5065517425537109,
-0.08038581907749176,
0.07248427718877792,
0.3000214695930481,
0.2458900511264801,
0.2070469707250595,
0.7279572486877441,
1.141589641571045,
-0.47108885645866394,
0.60163414478302,
-0.3008982241153717,
-0.3254263401031494,
0.17293977737426758,
-1.0764424800872803,
-0.8314695954322815,
-0.3020345866680145,
-0.3514982759952545,
-0.15725359320640564,
0.01459698099642992,
0.6276544332504272,
0.44847992062568665,
-0.7257879972457886,
0.001893063192255795,
0.08032596856355667,
0.3899747133255005,
-0.38151055574417114,
-0.27078768610954285,
0.36465972661972046,
-0.41162294149398804,
-0.4695635437965393,
0.7351768612861633,
0.4345410168170929,
-0.24365606904029846,
-0.4043935537338257,
-0.09723598510026932,
-0.4701894521713257,
0.22700858116149902,
0.6458005905151367,
-0.0007239904371090233,
-0.6409372091293335,
-0.3486928939819336,
-0.026187464594841003,
0.050795212388038635,
0.18063725531101227,
0.44796130061149597,
-0.7252252697944641,
0.5455806255340576,
0.5178893804550171,
0.791728138923645,
0.3322567045688629,
0.16961073875427246,
0.22339430451393127,
-0.22392190992832184,
-0.27844300866127014,
0.1185334101319313,
0.41291344165802,
0.08312780410051346,
-0.31379401683807373,
0.640023410320282,
0.052575238049030304,
-0.51767897605896,
-0.6661330461502075,
-0.05697127804160118,
-0.7866730093955994,
-0.37266507744789124,
1.124719500541687,
-0.4647802412509918,
0.09217563271522522,
-0.17783883213996887,
0.0440836027264595,
0.30795812606811523,
-0.09000156074762344,
0.7420482039451599,
0.8865405917167664,
-0.27493470907211304,
-0.09565123915672302,
-0.8275880217552185,
0.048228565603494644,
0.06574961543083191,
-1.15896475315094,
-0.13790108263492584,
0.6404980421066284,
0.4372352063655853,
0.08024850487709045,
0.7477247714996338,
-0.3098931312561035,
0.30802682042121887,
0.052815936505794525,
-0.004926272667944431,
-0.03742596507072449,
-0.6316444277763367,
-0.13207745552062988,
0.1937049776315689,
0.2933037579059601,
-0.23210567235946655
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.