paper_id
stringlengths 9
16
| version
stringclasses 26
values | yymm
stringclasses 311
values | created
timestamp[s] | title
stringlengths 6
335
| secondary_subfield
sequencelengths 1
8
| abstract
stringlengths 25
3.93k
| primary_subfield
stringclasses 124
values | field
stringclasses 20
values | fulltext
stringlengths 0
2.84M
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1608.03465 | 1 | 1608 | 2016-08-05T20:43:21 | The Future of Data Analysis in the Neurosciences | [
"q-bio.NC",
"stat.ML"
] | Neuroscience is undergoing faster changes than ever before. Over 100 years our field qualitatively described and invasively manipulated single or few organisms to gain anatomical, physiological, and pharmacological insights. In the last 10 years neuroscience spawned quantitative big-sample datasets on microanatomy, synaptic connections, optogenetic brain-behavior assays, and high-level cognition. While growing data availability and information granularity have been amply discussed, we direct attention to a routinely neglected question: How will the unprecedented data richness shape data analysis practices? Statistical reasoning is becoming more central to distill neurobiological knowledge from healthy and pathological brain recordings. We believe that large-scale data analysis will use more models that are non-parametric, generative, mixing frequentist and Bayesian aspects, and grounded in different statistical inferences. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Review Manuscript
The Future of Data Analysis in the Neurosciences
Danilo Bzdok1,2,3,4,* and B. T. Thomas Yeo5,6,7,8,9
1 Department of Psychiatry, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, RWTH Aachen University, 52072 Aachen, Germany
2 JARA-BRAIN, Jülich-Aachen Research Alliance, Germany
3 IRTG2150 - International Research Training Group
4 Parietal team, INRIA, Neurospin, bat 145, CEA Saclay, 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France
5 Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, National University of Singapore, Singapore 119077
6 Clinical Imaging Research Centre, National University of Singapore, Singapore 117599
7 Singapore Institute for Neurotechnology, National University of Singapore, Singapore 117456
8 Memory Networks Programme, National University of Singapore, Singapore 119077
9 Martinos Center for Biomedical Imaging, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Charlestown, MA
02129, USA
Running title: From "Big-Data" To "Big-Analysis"
Keywords: systems biology, epistemology, hypothesis testing, high-dimensional statistics,
machine learning, sample complexity
* Correspondence: [email protected] (D. Bzdok)
Prof. Dr. Dr. Danilo Bzdok
Department of Psychiatry, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics
Pauwelsstrasse 30
52074 Aachen
Germany
phone: +49 241 8085729
1
Abstract
Neuroscience is undergoing faster changes than ever before. Over 100 years our field
qualitatively described and invasively manipulated single or few organisms to gain
anatomical, physiological, and pharmacological insights. In the last 10 years neuroscience
spawned quantitative big-sample datasets on microanatomy, synaptic connections,
optogenetic brain-behavior assays, and high-level cognition. While growing data availability
and information granularity have been amply discussed, we direct attention to a routinely
neglected question: How will the unprecedented data richness shape data analysis
practices? Statistical reasoning is becoming more central to distill neurobiological knowledge
from healthy and pathological brain recordings. We believe that large-scale data analysis will
use more models that are non-parametric, generative, mixing frequentist and Bayesian
aspects, and grounded in different statistical inferences.
2
Introduction
During most of neuroscience history, new insights were "inferred" with little or no reliance
on statistics. Qualitative, often anecdotal reports have documented impairments after brain
lesion [1], microscopical inspection of stained tissue [2], electrical stimulation during
neurosurgery [3], targeted pharmacological intervention [4], and brain connections using
neuron-transportable dyes [5]. Connectivity analysis by axonal tracing studies in monkeys
exemplifies biologically justified "inference" with many discoveries since the 60s [6]. A
colored tracer substance is injected in vivo into source region A, uptaken by local neuronal
receptors, and automatically transported in axons to target region B. This observation in a
single monkey allows extrapolating a monosynaptical connection between region A and B to
the entire monkey species [7]. Instead, later brain-imaging technology propelled the data-
intensive characterization of the mammalian brain and today readily quantifies axonal
connections, myeloarchitectonic distributions, cytoarchitectonic borders, neurotransmitter
receptors, and oscillatory coupling [8-11]. Following many new opportunities to generate
digitized brain data, uncertainties about neurobiological phenomena henceforth required
assessment in the statistical arena.
In the quantitative sciences, the invention and application of statistical tools has always been
dictated by changing contexts and domain questions [12]. As this appears to be less
appreciated in current neuroscience, the present paper reviews how "optimal" statistical
choices are likely to change due to the progressively increasing granularity of digitized brain
data. Massive data collection is a game changer in neuroscience [9, 13], and many other
public and scientific areas [14-16]. There is an always-bigger interest in and pressure for data
sharing, open access, and building "big-data" repositories [8, 17, 18]. For instance, UK
Biobank is a longitudinal population study dedicated to the genetic and environmental
influence on mental and other disorders. 500,000 enrolled volunteers undergo an impressive
battery of clinical diagnostics from brain scans to bone density with a >25 year follow-up.
Targeted reanalysis of such national and international data collections will soon become the
new normal in neuroscience and medicine. Statistical scalability to high-dimensional data
will therefore be inspected from the independent perspectives of i) parametric versus non-
parametric, ii) discriminative versus generative, and iii) frequentist versus Bayesian statistical
models as well as iv) classical hypothesis testing and out-of-sample generalization.
3
Towards adaptive models?
Today, parametric models are still the obvious choice in neuroscience. For instance, many
big-sample studies (i.e., data from hundreds of animals or humans) currently apply the same
parametric models as previous small-sample studies (i.e., a few dozen animals or humans).
However, concentrating on sample size, parametric analyses such as Student's t-test,
ANOVA, and Pearson's linear correlation on brain data from many hundred individuals may
not yield an improved quality of statistical insight on a neurobiological phenomenon that
could not already be achieved with a dozen participants (Box 1). An important caveat relies
in their systematic inability to grow in complexity no matter how much data is collected and
analyzed [19]. In any classification, a linear parametric classifier will always make predictions
based on a linear decision boundary between classes, whereas a non-parametric classifier
can learn a non-linear boundary whose shape grows more complex with more data.
Analogously, parametric independent component analysis (ICA) and principal component
analysis (PCA) require presetting the component number, yet the form and number of
clusters in brain data is not known to neuroscientists. Such finite mixture models may give
way to infinite mixture models that reframe the cluster number as a function of data
availability and hence gradually yield more clusters without bound. Similarly, classical hidden
Markov models may get upgraded to infinite hidden Markov models and we might see more
applications of non-parametric decision trees and nearest neighbors in future neuroscientific
studies. Finally, it is currently debated whether increasingly used "deep" neural network
algorithms with many non-linear hidden layers are more accurately viewed as parametric or
non-parametric.
A crucial statistical property for data-rich neuroscience will be the strength of non-
parametric models to automatically increase the number of model parameters. Many
interesting phenomena in the brain are likely to be very complex. Fortunately, probability
theory recently proposed stochastic processes that instantiate random variables ranging
over unlimited function spaces. Gaussian Processes (GP) are an important non-parametric
example for specifying distributions on unknown functions to place minimal structural
assumptions or constraints on possible interactions [20]. Although GPs instantiate infinite
dimensional objects, indexing a subset of random variables in this infinite collection is
4
ensured to yield multivariate Gaussian distributions. Instead of fitting one parameter to each
variable to predict a behavior or clinical outcome with linear regression, GPs learn a non-
parametric distribution of non-linear functions to explain brain-behavior associations. This is
likely to leverage predictive regression and classification performance in large-sample
studies in neuroscience. For instance, natural scaling to the high-dimensional scenario was
demonstrated by a GP regression model that explained 70% of known missing heritable
variability in yeast phenotypes [21]. Such emergent insight from complex non-additive
interactions between gene loci is difficult to infer by genome-wide association studies
(GWAS) that use parametric models to explain small fractions of total heritable variation.
Unfortunately, the computational cost of parametric alternatives scales exponentially with
interaction order and the necessary correction for the multiple tested hypotheses becomes
challenging.
inference on behavioral
As another non-parametric family, kernel-based models can provide statistical advantages by
mapping brain variables to a latent variable space [22]. Kernels promise effective modality
fusion to incorporate heterogeneous sources given that, mathematically, kernel addition
equates with concatenation of variable spaces. Such genuine multi-modal analysis can
perform conjoint
indices, brain connectivity and function
phenotypes. Non-parametric prediction in classification and regression is thus performed
based on dot products on the vectors of the inner product space without requiring an explicit
mapping from the actual brain variables (i.e., "kernel trick"). In this virtual variable space the
added dimensions enable linear separability of complex neurobiological effects that are not
linearly separable in the original variables. Kernelization of statistical estimators inherits
enriched transformation of the input data that only grow linearly in dimension with
increasing sample size. Such purposeful increase of input dimensionality and model
complexity is useful for small to intermediate, but probably not extremely large datasets
because the kernel matrix can grow to terabytes scales. Disadvantages of kernels include the
inability to assess contributions of individual variables and to distinguish informative and
noise variables. Finally, kernel-based statistics relate to psychology in that learning pairwise
similarity measures between environmental stimuli is an aspect of intelligent behavior.
Radial basis kernels were argued to offer psychological and neurobiological plausibility as
computational model for human decision-making [23].
5
In sum, neurobiology is high-dimensional in nature and thus difficult to understand for
human intuition. By expressing brain phenomena in some finite-dimensional space,
parametric models are more interpretable, easier to implement, and faster to estimate. They
are often the best choice in data scarcity, yet they are further away from neurobiological
ground truth. Exclusive reliance on parametric analysis of brain recordings may keep
neuroscientists from extracting structured knowledge on emergence properties that can only
be grasped in data richness [15, 19, 24]. Even if more complex models do not always result in
greater insight [25], non-parametric approaches are naturally prepared to capture complex
relationships. This is because the complexity of statistical structure and hence extracted
neurobiological insight grow boundlessly with the amount of fitted data [19, 26]. This is likely
to be important for modern neuroscience and personalized medicine.
Towards models that incorporate biological structure?
The fact that more interpretable models typically require more data samples explains why,
in neuroscience, the less data-hungry discriminative models have been ubiquitious in small-
sample studies, while the popularity of more interpretable generative models is steadily
increasing with recent data availability (Box 2). For instance, hidden Markov models have
recently been applied to high-dimensional temporal data of magnetencephalographic
recordings [27]. These generative models simultaneously inferred the spatial topography of
the major brain networks subserving environment responses and their cross-talk dynamics
without anatomical assumptions. The model-immanent estimation of the joint distributions
between the voxel inputs has identified 100-200ms windows of coherent spatiotemporally
states and their exact functional coupling occurring faster than previously thought (i.e., both
are hidden variables). As another example, neuroscientists often conceptualize behavioral
tasks as recruiting multiple neural processes supported by multiple brain regions. This
century-old notion [28] was lacking a formal mathematical model. The conceptual premise
was recently encoded with a generative model [29]. Applying the model to 10,449
experiments across 83 behavioral tasks revealed heterogeneity in the degree of functional
specialization within association cortices to execute diverse tasks by flexible brain regions
integration across specialized networks [29, 30]. As a clinical example, dynamic causal
modeling for model-induced variable spaces and ensuing group classification by learning
6
algorithms were combined to infer neurobiologically interpretable manifolds underlying
aphasia [31]. Their model identified the directed interregional connectivity strengths that
distinguish aphasic and neurotypical individuals. This generative modeling approach was
more explanatory than brute-force prediction based on activity extent or linear correlations.
The influence exerted from right planum temporale and right Heschl's gyrus on their left
counterparts turned out as candidate mechanisms underlying communication impairment
and formally discarded other plausible auditory processing schemes. Such generative
approaches may refine diagnosis and treatment of spectrum disorders in neurology and
psychiatry.
Moreover, generative approaches to fitting biological data have successfully reverse-
engineered i) human facial variation related to gender and ethnicity based on genetic
information alone [32], ii) the complexity gradient in the ventral-visual processing hierarchy
which confirmed encoding of low-/mid-/high-level facets in V1, V2, and V4 mostly known
from animals [33], iii) structural content from naturalistic static images by revealing an
explicit inverse mapping between occipital activity and retinotopic stimulation [34], iv) video
scenes from naturalistic movies enabled by revealing importance of separately modeling
slow and fast visual movement [35], and v) brain atlases of semantic specificity from
naturalistic speech reinforcing the intuition that various different semantic features are
widely distributed in the cortex [36]. Finally, it is becoming increasingly clear that neural-
network models constitute a class of computational architectures [37] that lend themselves
particularly well to representation and manifold
learning tasks [38]. In particular,
autoencoders are modern neural-network models that have been formally shown to
generalize commonly employed representation discovery techniques, such as ICA and PCA as
well as clustering models [39, 40]. Autoencoder architectures therefore have the generative
potential to extract local (brain-area-like) and global (brain-network-like) representation to
abandon hand-crafted "feature engineering" made difficult by missing ground truth [41].
Neurobiologically valid representations are revealed as sets of predictive patterns that
together explain psychological tasks and disease processes without being constrained to
functional specialization into distinct regions or functional integration by brain networks.
The predictive validity of the discovered functional compartments thus extends the
interpretational spectrum offered by explained-variance approaches like ICA and PCA.
7
In sum, neuroscientists can afford more generative models as brain data become abundant.
In contrast to discriminative models, their naturally higher interpretability could open the
black box of the neural processing architectures underlying behavior and its disturbances.
Generative models enable more detailed understanding by exposing the low-dimensional
manifolds embedded within high-dimensional brain data. However, "the more detailed and
biologically realistic a model, the greater the challenges of parameter estimation and the
danger of overfitting" [42]. A crucial next step in neuroscience might lie in extracting actual
pathophysiological mechanisms from brain measurements in mental disorders. In contrast,
applying discriminative approaches on patients grouped by the diagnostic manuals DSM or
ICD could recapitulate categories that are neither neurobiologically valid nor clinically
predictive [43]. Finally, discriminative models may be less potent to characterize the neural
mechanisms of information processing up to the ultimate goal of recovering subjective
mental experience from brain recordings [31, 44-46].
Towards integration of traditional modeling regimes?
in neuroscience
After the 19th century was driven by Bayesian and the 20th century by frequentist statistics
[47], one might wonder about their relative contributions in the 21st century. These two
attitudes towards quantitative investigation are the most common distinction in statistics in
general [48] and
in particular [49, 50], yet orthogonal to the
parametric/non-parametric and discriminative/generative perspectives on statistical models
[48]. Overall, the many desirable properties of Bayesian modeling and interpretation are
contrasted by the computationally feasibility of frequentist models in high-dimensional data
(Box 3). In neuroscience the speed-accuracy tradeoff in Bayesian posterior inference has
been advantageously rebalanced using variational Bayes for limited computational budgets
on a number of previous occasions. This includes Bayesian time-series analysis [51], model
selection for group analysis [50] and mixed-effects classification for imbalanced groups [52].
Bayesian inference is an appealing framework by its intimate relationship to properties of
firing in neuronal populations [53] and the learning human mind [44]. Additionally, it is
important for currently increasing efforts in transdiagnostic clinical neuroscience [54] that
Bayesian hierarchical models could elegantly handle class imbalances with very unequal
group sizes. Moreover, inferring hierarchies of statistical relationships, a natural way of
8
inducing parsimony, is difficult or impossible in a frequentist model selection regime and
much more feasible in a Bayesian model averaging regime.
In particular, recent advances in non-parametric Bayesian methods [55] combined with
extensive datasets promise progress in longstanding problems in cognitive and clinical
neuroscience. As a key problem in cognition, neuroscientists have not agreed on a
description system of mental operations (called 'taxonomy' or 'ontology') that would
canonically motivate and operationalize their experiments [56, 57]. As a key problem in
medicine, partly shared neurobiological endophenotypes are today believed to contribute to
the pathophysiology of various neurological and psychiatric diagnoses (called 'nosology')
despite drastically different clinical exophenotypes [31, 43, 58]. As an
interesting
observation, both these neuroscientific challenges can be statistically recast as latent factor
problems [cf. 59]. The same class of statistical models could both identify the unnamed
building blocks underlying human cognition and the unknown neurobiological mechanisms
underlying diverse mental disorders. For instance, hierarchical Bayesian models were
recently borrowed from the topic modeling domain to estimate a latent cognitive ontology
[60] and neurobiological subtypes in Alzheimer's disease [61]. Further, formal posterior
inference in non-parametric Bayesian models could gracefully handle complexity in the brain
by estimating the number of latent factors in cognition and disease using Chinese Restaurant
Processes [62], relative implications of latent causes in neurobiological observations using
Indian Buffet Process [63], as well as induce hierarchies of cognitive primitives and disease
endophenotypes using Hierarchical Dirichlet Processes [64]. Cluster detection in the non-
parametric Bayesian regime exchanges the neurobiologically implausible winner-takes-all
property of traditional clustering by allowing each observation to participate in all clusters.
Crucially, the non-parametric aspect of these Dirichlet Process models allows the number of
inferred clusters to grow organically with increasing sample size.
In sum, the scalability of model estimation in the data-rich scenario is calibrated between
frequentist numerical optimization and Bayesian numerical integration. Ingredients from
both statistical regimes can be advantageously combined by adjusting the modeling goal [65,
chapter 5, 66]. Many frequentist methods reliant on gradient-based optimization can be
recast as Bayesian integration problems, for instance using Hamiltonian MCMC methods.
Conversely, integration problems can be turned into optimization problems, for instance
9
using variational Bayes approximations. High-dimensional data have been authoritatively
argued to motivate novel blends between simplier-to-use frequentist and more integrative
Bayesian modeling aspects [47]. Indeed, the continuously increasing number of observations
and number of parameters to estimate have earlier been predicted to complicate logical
consistency in statistical theory [67]. We therefore believe that the recent emergence of
extensive datasets
in neuroscience could analogously prompt emergence of more
frequentist-Bayesian hybrid approaches.
Towards diversification of statistical inference?
Drawing statistical inference on regional brain responses during controlled experiments has
largely hinged on classical null-hypothesis rejection, but is increasingly flanked by out-of-
sample prediction based on cross-validation [68, 69]. Both inferential regimes provide formal
justifications for deriving neurobiological knowledge using mathematical models (Box 4).
Classical inference measures the statistical significance associated with a relationship
between typically few variables given a prespecified model. Generalization inference
assesses the robustness of patterns between typically many variables in the data [70]. One
might think that these differences in deriving formal conclusions on brain recordings are
mostly of technical relevance but there is an often-overlooked misconception that models
with high explanatory power always exhibit high predictive power [71, 72]. A neurobiological
effect assessed to be statistically significant by a p-value may sometimes not yield successful
predictability based on cross-validation, and vice versa. Their theoretical differences are also
practically manifested in the high-dimensional setting where classical inference needs to
address the multiple comparisons problem and generalization inference involves tackling the
curse of dimensionality [73, 74].
Consequently, care needs to be taken when combing both inferential regimes in data
analysis [68, 69]. Say, a neuroscientist wants to predict Alzheimer diagnosis from the
>100,000 brain location per brain scan by sparse L1-penalized logistic regression (i.e.,
classification with minimal necessary variables) using cross-validation but performs
preliminary dimensionality reduction to the most important 10,000 voxels by ANOVA-
mediated variable ranking using classical inference. In this case, it is not permitted to
conduct an ordinary significance test (i.e., classical inference) on the obtained sparse model
10
coefficients (obtained from generalization inference) because it would involve recasting an
originally high-dimensional variable-selection as a univariate setting [75]. The ANOVA test
would ignore the fact that the sparse logistic regression had already reduced the variables to
the most important ones [72]. Very recently proposed methods for so-called post-selection
inference allow replacing naive by selection-adjusted p-values for a set of variables
previously chosen to be meaningful predictors [76]. This and similar clashes between
inferential regimes will probably increase in neuroscientific data analysis.
However, classical inference and generalization inference have also been advantageously
joined towards a same neuroscientific goal. In a first example, cross-validated classification
algorithms estimated the relative contribution of all macroscopical brain networks in a
battery of psychological tasks, while ANOVA was used to find smaller subsets of most
important networks for each task [45]. In a second example, Latent Dirichlet Allocation [77]
was used to find a nested hierarchy of volume atrophy endophenotypes in Alzheimer's
disease, while these were cross-validated by distinct trajectories in memory and executive
function decline using classical hypothesis testing [61]. More generally, a neurobiological
question, such as "Are region A and B significantly connected?", can also be cross-validated
by an independent method that can make the same observation, such as significant
structural and functional connectivities [78]. The previous two examples performed cross-
validation in a different kind of data, in contrast to the typical practice of performing cross-
validation in unseen data of the same kind. This is important because fMRI, EEG, MEG, fNIRS,
and other neuroscientific methods measure biological phenomena only indirectly. Out-of-
sample generalization to a different modality (e.g., behavior, genetics, microbiomics)
increases confidence that the findings reflect neurobiological reality. Combining different
inferential regimes can therefore corroborate neurobiological findings.
In sum, the leap from quantitative brain measurements to neurobiological knowledge is
secured by statistical inference. There is not one but several different types of inference that
can ask a same question with different mathematical foundations requiring differently
nuanced neuroscientific interpretation. Historically, classical inference was invented for
problems with small samples that can be addressed by plausible, handpicked models with a
small number of parameters [cf. 79]. Some authors therefore emphasize that "one should
never use sum of squared errors, p-values, R2 statistics, or other classical measures of model
11
fit on the training data as evidence of a good model fit in the high-dimensional setting." [80,
p. 247, their emphasis]. P-values and other classical guarantees may lose their ability to
evaluate model fit in high-dimensional data. Instead, out-of-sample generalization by
successful cross-validation to independent data will be increasingly used given natural tuning
to problems with more variables and larger samples [cf. 24]. Envisioning a future of precision
medicine, only cross-validated predictive models can obtain answers from a single data point
[42]. Finally, data richness will increasingly require preliminary dimensionality-reduction and
feature-engineering procedures, including k-means clustering and ICA decomposition, that
do not themselves perform statistical inference. A back and forth between dimensionality-
reducing data transformations, inductive pattern extrapolation and deductive hypothesis
testing of the discovered candidate effects will become valid routines in neuroscience.
Concluding Remarks and Future Perspectives
After astronomy, particle physics, and genetics, massive data is the new reality in
neuroscience and medicine. Rich datasets can extend the spectrum of possible findings and
permissible conclusions about the brain. Yet, the unavoidable impact on data analysis
practices is currently shunned. While sample size and information granularity are increasing
progressively, the prompted shift in statistical choices may be categorical. Neuroscientists
need to extend their modeling instincts towards neurobiological insight with gradually
increasing quality of insight as data accumulate [12] and towards prediction on the single-
individual level [81]. It is difficult to overstate the importance of closing training gaps in next-
generation PhD curricula that will include machine-learning, computer programming,
distributed multi-core processing, and advanced visualization [82].
In a nutshell,
neuroscience is entering the era of large-scale data collection, curation, and collaboration
with a pressing need for statistical models tailored for high-dimensional inference. These will
frequently lie beyond the scope of the statistical repertoire cherished today. Analyzing
extensive multi-modal datasets with inappropriate statistical models would be a waste of
public financial resources and our limited scientific efforts.
12
TEXT BOX 1: Parametric and non-parametric models
This statistical distinction takes place at the equilibrium between imposing specific
assumptions (i.e., parametric) and not assuming a certain functional form (i.e., non-
parametric) to encourage discovery of relevant structure driven by the brain data
themselves [19, 83]. Contrary to common misunderstanding, both classes of quantitative
modeling involve parameters. "Non-parametric" is defined in three different flavors: The
first, perhaps most widespread meaning implies those statistical estimators that do not
make explicit assumptions about the probability distribution (e.g., Gaussian) from which the
data have arisen. As a second, more intuitive explanation, non-parametric models do not
assume that the structure of the statistical model is fixed. The last, most formal definition
emphasizes that the number of model parameters increases explicitly or implicitly with the
number of available data points (e.g., number of brain recordings). In contrast, the number
of model parameters are fixed in parametric models and do not vary with sample size (Fig.
1). In its most extreme manifestation, effectively fitting an arbitrary functional form can
result in non-parametric models larger in memory usage than the actual input data
themselves. Flexible non-parametric models include decision trees like random forests,
nearest-neighbor estimators, kernel support vector machines or kernel principal component
analysis, and hierarchical clustering, as well as bootstrapping and other resampling
procedures. More rigid parametric models include methods from classical statistics based on
maximum likelihood estimation, Gaussian mixture models, support vector machines,
principal component analysis, and k-means clustering, but also modern penalized regression
variants like Lasso, ElasticNet, and RidgeRegression.
It is an advantage of parametric modeling to expresses the data compactly in a few model
parameters, which increases interpretability, requires smaller datasets, has higher statistical
power, and incurs lower computational load. Additionally, if the parametric assumptions
hold "true" in nature, non-parametric approaches can be less powerful than their parametric
counterparts. Although parametric and non-parametric models require assumptions, non-
parametric models have the advantage to be more robust about estimating properties of
still poorly known phenomena in the brain if the modeling assumptions are partly false. Due
to
improper use and
misunderstanding. Most importantly, even if the number of parameters in parametric
robustness, non-parametric methods may prevent
their
13
models can be manually increased, only non-parametric models have an inherent ability to
automatically scale with the complexity of the available data resources.
Figure 1 (in Box 1): Prediction based on parametric versus non-parametric regression
Fitted models that predict the continuous outcome Y based on the observed variables X1 and
X2. Left: Ordinary linear regression finds the best plane to distinguish high and low outcomes
Y. Middle/Right: K-nearest neighbor regression predicts the same outcome Y based on the
K=1 (middle) or K=9 (right) closest data points in the available sample. Parametric linear
regression cannot grow more complex than a stiff plane (or hyperplane when more input
dimensions Xn) as decision boundary, which entails big regions with identical predictions Y.
Non-parametric nearest-neighbor regression can grow from a rough step-function decision
boundary (k=1) to an always-smoother fit (k=9) by incorporating the data in more complex
ways. Non-parametric models therefore outperform parametric alternatives in many data-
rich scenarios. Reused with permission from [80].
TEXT BOX 2: Discriminative and generative models
Discriminative models are common choices when best-possible prediction of neurobiological
phenomena is the primary aim (e.g., based on behavioral phenotype, age, performance or
clinical scores), which does not require recovery of the explicit relationships between input
variables (Fig. 2). Generative models also aim at successful extrapolation of statistical
relationships to new data but simultaneously extract special neurobiological structure from
14
brain data by indirectly inferring the target variable from hidden variables [85]. Typical
discriminative models include linear regression, support vector machines, decision-tree
algorithms, and logistic regression, while generative models include hidden Markov models,
modern neural network algorithms, dictionary learning methods, and many non-parametric
statistical models [77]. As an important advantage in brain science, generative modeling
approaches are more expressive in extracting representations in input data that are
"economical to describe but allow the input to be reconstructed accurately" [86].
More formally, discriminative models focus on a target variable y, whereas generative
models are concerned with the joint distributions between observed and unobserved
variables [84]. Discriminative models find a direct mapping function by predicting a
categorical or continuous target variable y by estimating P(yx) without capturing special
properties in the data x. Generative models estimate relevant properties in the data by
P(yx) from P(xy) and P(y). Generative models can hence produce synthetic, never observed
examples x~ for targets y by sampling from the estimated joint distributions P(x,y). The
strength of generative models to conjointly realize predictive modeling and representation
learning is paid by requiring more input data, more computational resources, and possibly
more model parameters to fit. Consequently, with too few data points available for model
estimation, discriminative models will usually achieve better prediction performance in new
data because generative models suffer from higher model variance. Finally, generative
models make an assumption about the distribution of the input data and their performance
therefore suffers more if this model is inaccurate. Discriminative models are generally more
robust to assumptions about the data-generating process.
Figure 2 (in Box 2): Class-conditional densities can be more complex than class posteriors
15
Generative models (left) estimate P(xy=c) by indirectly fitting mechanisms in data
conditioned on the class c. Discriminative models (right) estimate the posterior probability
P(y=cx) to directly quantify the presence of class c conditioned on the data x without
capturing data mechanisms underlying that class. It is important to note that peaks of the
class-conditional densities P(xy=c) have no impact on the class posteriors P(y=cx). Only
generative models can therefore produce new, unseen examples x~ from the captured input
distributions characteristic for class c. Figure reused with permission from [65].
TEXT BOX 3: Frequentist and Bayesian models
In theory, the frequentist attitude aims at universally acceptable, investigator-independent
conclusions on neurobiological processes by avoiding hand-selected priors on model
parameters. The Bayesian attitude is more transparent in the unavoidable, necessarily
subjective introduction of existing domain knowledge as model priors. Frequentist modeling
achieves best-guess values (often without uncertainty
interval) treating the model
parameters as fixed unknown constants and averaging over input data treated as random.
Instead, ideal Bayesian modeling achieves full posterior distribution estimates (including
intervals) by averaging over the random model parameters rather than the data. Frequentist
approaches typically perform model selection to obtain model parameters by maximum
likelihood estimation using numerical optimization. Bayesian approaches typically perform
model averaging by integrating over model parameters conditioned on prespecified priors
by approximate resampling solutions from Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) variants.
In practice, statistical models span a continuum between the extreme poles of frequentism
and Bayesianism. They exhibit many unexpected similarities [65, 83]. For instance, the
bootstrap is a frequentist method for population-level inference of confidence intervals and
non-parametric null-hypothesis testing [87] that also lends itself to Bayesian interpretations
[70]. Frequentist practitioners are mostly concerned about model overfitting, while Bayesian
practitioners are more concerned about the pertinence and number of domain-informed
priors.
Important for data-intensive brain science, the frequentist-Bayesian tradeoff impacts the
computational budget required for model estimation (Fig. 3). Generally, the more one
16
adheres to frequentist instead of Bayesian ideology, the less computationally expensive and
the less technically involved are the statistical analyses. It is a widespread opinion that
Bayesian models do not scale well to the data-rich setting, although there is little work on
the behavior of Bayesian methods in high dimensions [88, 89]. While the pure frequentist
approach computes maximum likelihood estimation, the pure Bayesian approach achieves
inference by full posterior probability distributions computed by asymptotically exact MCMC.
Given their computational cost, MCMCs have mainly been used for small-scale problems.
The practical applicability of Bayesian methods has been greatly enhanced through the
development of approximate inference algorithms such as variational Bayes and expectation
propagation [90]. Nevertheless, exact MCMC and its accelerated approximate variants tend
to suffer from i) uncertainty when convergence is reached, ii) difficult-to-control "random-
walk" behavior, and iii) limited scaling to the high-dimensional setting [91]. Consequently,
the intractability of Bayesian posterior integrals motivated a rich spectrum of model hybrids
[47]. There is an increasing trend towards incorporating appealing Bayesian aspects into
computationally cheap frequentist approaches [e.g., 92].
Figure 3 (in Box 3): Different shades of Bayesian inference
There is no unique Bayesian formulation to perform statistical inference, but there is a
variety of them. For instance, type-II maximum likelihood or empirical Bayes has genuine
frequentist properties, does not specify a prior distribution before visiting the data, and is
often used in non-Bayesian modeling. Generally, the more integrals to be solved or
approximated, the higher the computational budget needed for model estimation. Reused
with permission from [65].
BOX 4: Null-hypothesis testing and out-of-sample generalization
Statistical inference can be generally defined as the extraction of new knowledge from
17
parameters in mathematical models fitted to data [15]. In classical inference, invented
almost 100 years ago [93], the neuroscientist articulates two mutually exclusive hypotheses
by domain-informed judgment with the agenda to disprove the null hypothesis embraced by
the research community. A p-value is then computed that denotes the conditional
probability of obtaining an equal or more extreme test statistic provided that the null
hypothesis is correct at the conventional significance threshold alpha=0.05 [94]. For
instance, statistical significance of the Student's t-test indicates a difference between two
means with a 5% chance after sampling twice from the same population. Adopting deductive
reasoning and a mostly retrospective viewpoint [95], state-of-the-art hypotheses are
continuously replaced by always more pertinent hypotheses using verification and
falsification in a Darwinian process. The classical framework of null-hypothesis falsification
to infer new knowledge is still the go-to choice in many branches of neuroscience.
Considering the data-rich scenario, it is an important problem that p-values intrinsically
become better (i.e., lower) as the sample size increases [96]. In some fields, it is therefore
now mandatory to report effect sizes in addition or instead of p-values [94].
In contrast, generalization inference emerged much more recently in basic statistics [97] and
tests whether complex patterns extrapolate to independent data using cross-validation.
Formally, this inferential regime is mathematically justified by the so-called Vapnik-
Chervonenkis (VC) dimensions from statistical learning theory, conceptually related to the
degrees of freedom from classical statistics [98]. In generalization inference on high-
dimensional patterns, the VC dimensions formally express the circumstances under which a
class of functions is able to learn from a finite amount of data to successfully predict a given
neurobiological phenomenon in unseen data [99]. Thus, the VC dimensions provide a
probabilistic measure of whether a certain model is able to learn a distinction given a
dataset. This inductive reasoning to learn a general principle from examples adopting a
mostly prospective viewpoint contrasts the deductive, retrospective logic of null-hypothesis
testing. In practice, cross-validation is frequently used to quantify the out-of-sample
performance by an unbiased estimate of a model's capacity to generalize to data samples
acquired in the future [100]. Model assessment is done by training on a bigger subset of the
available data (i.e., training set) and subsequently applying the trained model to the smaller
remaining part of data (i.e., test set).
18
References
1.
Harlow, J.M., Passage of an iron rod through the head. Boston Medical and Surgical Journal,
1848. 39(20): p. 389-393.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
Brodmann, K., Vergleichende Lokalisationslehre der Grosshirnrinde. 1909, Leipzig: Barth.
Penfield, W. and P. Perot, The Brain? S record of auditory and visual experience. Brain, 1963.
86(4): p. 595-696.
Clark, W.G., J. Del Giudice, and G.K. Aghajanian, Principles of psychopharmacology: a
textbook for physicians, medical students, and behavioral scientists. 1970: Academic Press
Inc.
Mesulam, M.M., Tetramethyl benzidine for horseradish peroxidase neurohistochemistry: a
non-carcinogenic blue reaction product with superior sensitivity for visualizing neural
afferents and efferents. J Histochem Cytochem, 1978. 26(2): p. 106-17.
Köbbert, C., et al., Current concepts in neuroanatomical tracing. Progress in neurobiology,
2000. 62(4): p. 327-351.
Mesulam, M., The evolving landscape of human cortical connectivity: facts and inferences.
Neuroimage, 2012. 62(4): p. 2182-9.
Frackowiak, R. and H. Markram, The future of human cerebral cartography: a novel approach.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences, 2015.
370(1668): p. 20140171.
Kandel, E.R., et al., Neuroscience thinks big (and collaboratively). Nature Reviews
Neuroscience, 2013. 14(9): p. 659-664.
Amunts, K., et al., BigBrain: an ultrahigh-resolution 3D human brain model. Science, 2013.
340(6139): p. 1472-5.
Van Essen, D.C., et al., The Human Connectome Project: a data acquisition perspective.
Neuroimage, 2012. 62(4): p. 2222-31.
Efron, B. and T. Hastie, Computer-Age Statistical Inference. 2016.
Poldrack, R.A. and K.J. Gorgolewski, Making big data open: data sharing in neuroimaging.
Nat Neurosci, 2014. 17(11): p. 1510-1517.
House of Common, S.a.T., The big data dilemma. 2016, UK: Committee on Applied and
Theoretical Statistics.
Jordan, M.I., et al., Frontiers in Massive Data Analysis. 2013, Washington, D.C.: The National
Academies Press.
Manyika, J., et al., Big data: The next frontier for innovation, competition, and productivity.
Technical report, McKinsey Global Institute, 2011.
Randlett, O., et al., Whole-brain activity mapping onto a zebrafish brain atlas. Nat Meth,
2015. 12(11): p. 1039-1046.
19
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
Lichtman, J.W., H. Pfister, and N. Shavit, The big data challenges of connectomics. Nature
neuroscience, 2014. 17(11): p. 1448-1454.
Ghahramani, Z., Probabilistic machine learning and artificial intelligence. Nature, 2015.
521(7553): p. 452-9.
Rasmussen, C.E., Gaussian processes for machine learning. 2006.
Sharp, K., et al., Explaining Missing Heritability Using Gaussian Process Regression. bioRxiv,
2016: p. 040576.
Hofmann, T., B. Schölkopf, and A.J. Smola, Kernel methods in machine learning. The annals of
statistics, 2008: p. 1171-1220.
Jäkel, F., B. Schölkopf, and F.A. Wichmann, Does cognitive science need kernels? Trends in
cognitive sciences, 2009. 13(9): p. 381-388.
Halevy, A., P. Norvig, and F. Pereira, The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Data. Intelligent
Systems, IEEE, 2009. 24(2): p. 8-12.
Eliasmith, C., et al., A large-scale model of the functioning brain. Science, 2012. 338(6111): p.
1202-1205.
Jordan, M.I. and T.M. Mitchell, Machine learning: Trends, perspectives, and prospects.
Science, 2015. 349(6245): p. 255-260.
Baker, A.P., et al., Fast transient networks in spontaneous human brain activity. Elife, 2014. 3:
p. e01867.
Walton, G.L. and W.E. Paul, Contribution to the study of the cortical sensory areas. Brain,
1901. 24(3): p. 430-452.
Yeo, B.T., et al., Functional Specialization and Flexibility in Human Association Cortex. Cereb
Cortex, 2015. 25(10): p. 3654-72.
Bertolero, M.A., B.T. Yeo, and M. D'Esposito, The modular and integrative functional
architecture of the human brain. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 2015. 112(49): p. E6798-807.
Brodersen, K.H., et al., Generative embedding for model-based classification of fMRI data.
PLoS Comput Biol, 2011. 7(6): p. e1002079.
Claes, P., et al., Modeling 3D facial shape from DNA. PLoS Genet, 2014. 10(3): p. e1004224.
Güçlü, U. and M.A.J. van Gerven, Deep neural networks reveal a gradient in the complexity of
neural representations across the ventral stream. The Journal of Neuroscience, 2015. 35(27):
p. 10005-10014.
Thirion, B., et al., Inverse retinotopy: inferring the visual content of images from brain
activation patterns. Neuroimage, 2006. 33(4): p. 1104-16.
Nishimoto, S., et al., Reconstructing visual experiences from brain activity evoked by natural
movies. Curr Biol, 2011. 21(19): p. 1641-6.
Huth, A.G., et al., Natural speech reveals the semantic maps that tile human cerebral cortex.
Nature, 2016. 532(7600): p. 453-458.
20
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
43.
44.
45.
46.
47.
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
54.
55.
Schmidhuber, J., Deep learning in neural networks: An overview. Neural Networks, 2015. 61:
p. 85-117.
LeCun, Y., Y. Bengio, and G. Hinton, Deep learning. Nature, 2015. 521(7553): p. 436-444.
Baldi, P. and K. Hornik, Neural networks and principal component analysis: Learning from
examples without local minima. Neural networks, 1989. 2(1): p. 53-58.
Le, Q.V., et al. ICA with reconstruction cost for efficient overcomplete feature learning. in
Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems. 2011.
Bzdok, D., et al. Semi-Supervised Factored Logistic Regression for High-Dimensional
Neuroimaging Data. in Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems. 2015.
Stephan, K.E., et al., Translational perspectives for computational neuroimaging. Neuron,
2015. 87(4): p. 716-732.
Hyman, S.E., Can neuroscience be integrated into the DSM-V? Nat Rev Neurosci, 2007. 8(9):
p. 725-32.
Lake, B.M., R. Salakhutdinov, and J.B. Tenenbaum, Human-level concept learning through
probabilistic program induction. Science, 2015. 350(6266): p. 1332 - 1338.
Bzdok, D., et al., Formal models of the network co-occurrence underlying mental operations.
PLoS Comput Biol, 2016: p. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1004994.
Yanga, G.J., et al., Altered global brain signal in schizophrenia. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 2014.
111(20): p. 7438–7443.
Efron, B., Modern science and the Bayesian-frequentist controversy. 2005: Division of
Biostatistics, Stanford University.
Freedman, D., Some issues in the foundation of statistics. Foundations of Science, 1995. 1(1):
p. 19-39.
Friston, K.J., et al., Classical and Bayesian
Neuroimage, 2002. 16(2): p. 484-512.
inference
in neuroimaging: applications.
Stephan, K.E., et al., Bayesian model selection for group studies. Neuroimage, 2009. 46(4): p.
1004-17.
Penny, W., S. Kiebel, and K. Friston, Variational Bayesian inference for fMRI time series.
Neuroimage, 2003. 19(3): p. 727-41.
Brodersen, K.H., et al., Variational Bayesian mixed-effects inference for classification studies.
Neuroimage, 2013. 76: p. 345-61.
Ma, W.J., et al., Bayesian inference with probabilistic population codes. Nature neuroscience,
2006. 9(11): p. 1432-1438.
Goodkind, M., et al., Identification of a Common Neurobiological Substrate for Mental Illness.
JAMA Psychiatry, 2015.
Orbanz, P. and Y.W. Teh, Bayesian nonparametric models, in Encyclopedia of Machine
Learning. 2011, Springer. p. 81-89.
21
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
67.
68.
69.
70.
71.
72.
73.
Barrett, L.F., The Future of Psychology: Connecting Mind to Brain. Perspect Psychol Sci, 2009.
4(4): p. 326-39.
Tenenbaum, J.B., et al., How to grow a mind: Statistics, structure, and abstraction. science,
2011. 331(6022): p. 1279-1285.
Stephan, K.E., et al., Charting the landscape of priority problems in psychiatry, part 2:
pathogenesis and aetiology. The Lancet Psychiatry, 2015.
Poldrack, R.A., et al., Discovering relations between mind, brain, and mental disorders using
topic mapping. PLoS Comput Biol, 2012. 8(10): p. e1002707.
Bertolero, M.A., B.T.T. Yeo, and M. D'Esposito, The modular and integrative functional
architecture of the human brain. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 2015.
Zhang, X., et al., Bayesian model reveals latent atrophy factors with dissociable cognitive
trajectories in Alzheimer's disease.
Kemp, C., et al. Learning systems of concepts with an infinite relational model. in Aaai. 2006.
Ghahramani, Z. and T.L. Griffiths. Infinite latent feature models and the Indian buffet process.
in Advances in neural information processing systems. 2005.
Teh, Y.W., et al., Sharing Clusters Among Related Groups: Hierarchical Dirichlet Processes.
Advances in neural information processing systems, 2005.
Murphy, K.P., Machine learning: a probabilistic perspective. 2012: MIT press.
Gopalan, P.K. and D.M. Blei, Efficient discovery of overlapping communities in massive
networks. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 2013. 110(36): p. 14534–14539.
Efron, B., Controversies in the foundations of statistics. American Mathematical Monthly,
1978: p. 231-246.
Bzdok, D., Classical Statistics and Statistical Learning in Imaging Neuroscience. arXiv preprint
arXiv:1603.01857, 2016.
Yarkoni, T. and J. Westfall, Choosing prediction over explanation in psychology: Lessons from
machine learning. 2016.
Hastie, T., R. Tibshirani, and J. Friedman, The Elements of Statistical Learning. 2001,
Heidelberg, Germany: Springer Series in Statistics.
Lo, A., et al., Why significant variables aren't automatically good predictors. Proc Natl Acad
Sci U S A, 2015. 112(45): p. 13892-7.
Wu, T.T., et al., Genome-wide association analysis by lasso penalized logistic regression.
Bioinformatics, 2009. 25(6): p. 714-721.
Domingos, P., A Few Useful Things to Know about Machine Learning. Communications of the
ACM, 2012. 55(10): p. 78-87.
74.
Friston, K.J., et al., Bayesian decoding of brain images. Neuroimage, 2008. 39(1): p. 181-205.
22
75.
76.
77.
78.
79.
80.
81.
82.
83.
84.
85.
86.
87.
88.
89.
90.
91.
92.
93.
Haufe, S., et al., On the interpretation of weight vectors of linear models in multivariate
neuroimaging. Neuroimage, 2014. 87: p. 96-110.
Taylor, J. and R.J. Tibshirani, Statistical learning and selective inference. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S
A, 2015. 112(25): p. 7629-34.
Teh, Y.W. and M.I. Jordan, Hierarchical Bayesian nonparametric models with applications.
Bayesian nonparametrics, 2010. 1.
Eickhoff, S.B., et al., Connectivity-based parcellation: Critique and implications. Hum Brain
Mapp, 2015.
Wigner, E.P., The unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics in the natural sciences.
Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics, 1960. 13: p. 1-14.
James, G., et al., An introduction to statistical learning. Vol. 112. 2013: Springer.
Roberts, N.J., et al., The predictive capacity of personal genome sequencing. Science
translational medicine, 2012. 4(133): p. 133ra58-133ra58.
Akil, H., et al., Neuroscience Training for the 21st Century. Neuron, 2016. 90(5): p. 917-926.
Bishop, C.M., Pattern Recognition and Machine Learning. 2006, Heidelberg: Springer.
Bishop, C.M. and J. Lasserre, Generative or discriminative? getting the best of both worlds.
Bayesian statistics, 2007. 8: p. 3-24.
Ng, A.Y. and M.I. Jordan, On discriminative vs. generative classifiers: A comparison of logistic
regression and naive bayes. Advances in neural information processing systems, 2002. 14: p.
841.
Hinton, G.E., et al., The "Wake-Sleep" algorithm for unsupervised neural networks. Science,
1995. 268: p. 1158-1161.
Efron, B., Bootstrap methods: another look at the jackknife. The annals of Statistics, 1979: p.
1-26.
Jordan, M.I., A message from the President: The era of big data. ISBA Bulletin, 2011. 18(2): p.
1-3.
Yang, Y., M.J. Wainwright, and M.I. Jordan, On the computational complexity of high-
dimensional Bayesian variable selection. arXiv preprint arXiv:1505.07925, 2015.
Jordan, M.I., et al., An introduction to variational methods for graphical models. Machine
learning, 1999. 37(2): p. 183-233.
MacKay, D.J.C., Information theory, inference and learning algorithms. 2003: Cambridge
university press.
Kingma, D.P., et al. Semi-supervised learning with deep generative models. in Advances in
Neural Information Processing Systems. 2014.
Fisher, R.A. and W.A. Mackenzie, Studies in crop variation. II. The manurial response of
different potato varieties. The Journal of Agricultural Science, 1923. 13(03): p. 311-320.
23
94.
95.
96.
97.
98.
Wasserstein, R.L. and N.A. Lazar, The ASA's statement on p-values: context, process, and
purpose. The American Statistician, 2016(just-accepted): p. 00-00.
Goodman, S.N., Toward evidence-based medical statistics. 1: The P value fallacy. Annals of
internal medicine, 1999. 130(12): p. 995-1004.
Berkson, J., Some difficulties of interpretation encountered in the application of the chi-
square test. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 1938. 33(203): p. 526-536.
Breiman, L. and P. Spector, Submodel selection and evaluation in regression. The X-random
case. International statistical review/revue internationale de Statistique, 1992: p. 291-319.
Abu-Mostafa, Y.S., M. Magdon-Ismail, and H.T. Lin, Learning from data. 2012, California:
AMLBook.
99.
Vapnik, V.N., Statistical Learning Theory. 1989, New York: Wiley-Interscience.
100.
Dwork, C., et al., The reusable holdout: Preserving validity in adaptive data analysis. Science,
2015. 349(6248): p. 636-638.
24
|
1906.07211 | 1 | 1906 | 2019-06-17T18:23:41 | Brain Maturation Study during Adolescence Using Graph Laplacian Learning Based Fourier Transform | [
"q-bio.NC",
"eess.SP"
] | Objective: Longitudinal neuroimaging studies have demonstrated that adolescence is the crucial developmental epoch of continued brain growth and change. A large number of researchers dedicate to uncovering the mechanisms about brain maturity during adolescence. Motivated by both achievement in graph signal processing and recent evidence that some brain areas act as hubs connecting functionally specialized systems, we proposed an approach to detect these regions from spectral analysis perspective. In particular, as human brain undergoes substantial development throughout adolescence, we addressed the challenge by evaluating the functional network difference among age groups from functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) observations. Methods: We treated these observations as graph signals defined on the parcellated functional brain regions and applied graph Laplacian learning based Fourier Transform (GLFT) to transform the original graph signals into frequency domain. Eigen-analysis was conducted afterwards to study the behavior of the corresponding brain regions, which enables the characterization of brain maturation. Result: We first evaluated our method on the synthetic data and further applied the method to resting and task state fMRI imaging data from Philadelphia Neurodevelopmental Cohort (PNC) dataset, comprised of normally developing adolescents from 8 to 22. The model provided a highest accuracy of 95.69% in distinguishing different adolescence stages. Conclusion: We detected 13 hubs from resting state fMRI and 16 hubs from task state fMRI that are highly related to brain maturation process. Significance: The proposed GLFT method is powerful in extracting the brain connectivity patterns and identifying hub regions with a high prediction power | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Brain Maturation Study during Adolescence Using
Graph Laplacian Learning Based Fourier Transform
Junqi Wang, Li Xiao, Tony W. Wilson, Julia M. Stephen, Vince D. Calhoun, Yu-Ping Wang
1
9
1
0
2
n
u
J
7
1
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
1
1
2
7
0
.
6
0
9
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
Abstract -- Objective: Longitudinal neuroimaging studies have
demonstrated that adolescence is the crucial developmental epoch
of continued brain growth and change. A large number of
researchers dedicate to uncovering the mechanisms about brain
maturity during adolescence. Motivated by both achievement in
graph signal processing and recent evidence that some brain
areas act as hubs connecting functionally specialized systems,
we proposed an approach to detect these regions from spectral
analysis perspective. In particular, as human brain undergoes
substantial development throughout adolescence, we addressed
the challenge by evaluating the functional network difference
among age groups from functional magnetic resonance imaging
(fMRI) observations.
Methods: We treated these observations as graph signals
defined on the parcellated functional brain regions and applied
graph Laplacian learning based Fourier Transform (GLFT) to
transform the original graph signals into frequency domain.
Eigen-analysis was conducted afterwards to study the behavior
of the corresponding brain regions, which enables the character-
ization of brain maturation.
Result: We first evaluated our method on the synthetic data
and further applied the method to resting and task state fMRI
imaging data from Philadelphia Neurodevelopmental Cohort
(PNC) dataset, comprised of normally developing adolescents
from 8 to 22. The model provided a highest accuracy of 95.69%
in distinguishing different adolescence stages.
Conclusion: We detected 13 hubs from resting state fMRI and
16 hubs from task state fMRI that are highly related to brain
maturation process.
Significance: The proposed GLFT method is powerful
in
extracting the brain connectivity patterns and identifying hub
regions with a high prediction power.
Index Terms -- brain maturation, GLFT, PNC, fMRI, hubs.
I. INTRODUCTION
A DVANCES in neuroimaging techniques for the study of
human brain have attracted a growing amount of scien-
tific interest in recent years. In particular, functional magnetic
resonance imaging (fMRI) provides a chance to study brain
structure and function through non-invasive measurements
over a time frame of seconds with a spatial resolution of
millimeters. Resting state functional MRI (rs-fMRI), which
measures spontaneous low frequency fluctuations in blood
oxygenation level dependent (BOLD) signal, has attracted
J. Wang, L.Xiao and Y. Wang were with the Department of Biomedical En-
gineering, Tulane University, New Orleans, LA, USA e-mail: [email protected]
V.D Calhoun was with the Department of Electrical and Computer Engi-
neering, The University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, NM, USA and also
with the Mind Research Network, Albuquerque.
J.M. Stephen was with the Mind Research Network, Albuquerque, NM,
USA
T.W Wilson was with the Department of Neurological Sciences, University
of Nebraska Medical Center,Omaha, NE, USA
attention for its ability to measure correlations in neural activ-
ity between distant brain regions [1]. These correlations can
have multiple applications in improving medical diagnostics,
prognostics and further therapeutics. Task state fMRI (tfMRI)
measures the behavior of the brain activity with a range
of motor, sensory, cognitive and emotional process tasks to
explore a core set of functional related brain connectivity and
human function. tfMRI data can also help characterize and
validate the connectivity analyses conducted on structural and
resting-state functional data [2].
It is a common assumption that the brain operates as a set
of distributed sub-networks [3] that co-activate over time. A
significant amount of studies have been conducted to uncover
the mechanisms about changes in brain functional activity
that occur throughout childhood and adolescence [4], [5].
Task state fMRI data have been used to detect the functional
behavioral difference between children and adult brain [6].
Interesting findings have drawn wide concerns about exploring
the core regions with brain development [7]. As the functional
organization of the brain structure is still not fully understood,
there is a growing interest in capturing the structure of the
brain network during early development.
A variety of methods have been proposed to study the
neuroimaging data and one widely used approach is the graph
based one [8], [9]. Within this framework, a complex system is
formulated as a graph or network consisting of a set of nodes
and pairwise relationships between the nodes,
i.e., edges.
Spectral graph theory was introduced to study the proper-
ties of these graphs via the eigen-analysis of the associated
graph matrices: the adjacency matrix, the graph Laplacian and
their variants. These matrices have been well studied as the
representation of graph signals with many applications [10],
which led to the emerging field of graph signal processing [11].
Among these graph signal processing tools, the graph Fourier
transform (GFT) is a powerful one with well-documented
performance in signal denoising [12], mental disease study
[13], and brain network studies [14]. As a generalization of
the Fourier transform, it naturally decomposes a graph signal
into different frequency components with different variabil-
ities. The Laplacian form of the brain connectivity matrix
constructed using Gaussian radial basis function (RBF) kernel
plays a major role in graph Fourier transform. Changes in
the representation matrix lead to variants of GFT such as
alternative graph Fourier transform [11], which used adjacency
matrix as the shift operator and conducted Jordan decompo-
sition accordingly. Generally speaking, learning graph from
data samples is an ill-posed problem. Kernel based methods
exhibit well-demonstrated performance in various nonlinear
learning tasks in machine learning and signal processing, most
of which rely on a preselected kernel presuming task-specific
prior information. However, prior information is usually not
available due to the complexity of the brain. To overcome this
issue, we apply a data-driven graph Laplacian learning frame-
work [15] that can effectively construct a brain connectivity
network. Afterwards, we use the graph Fourier transform to
carry out frequency components partition and further analyze
the mechanisms of brain maturation. The whole process is
called a graph Laplacian learning Fourier transform (GLFT)
to distinguish the graph Laplacian matrix from the one used
in graph Fourier transform.
A similar and well-known method is principal component
analysis (PCA), which has been used to extract intrinsic struc-
ture in the data by eigen analysis of the covariance matrix [16].
Other matrix decomposition methods such as non-negative
matrix factorization [17] are also used to extract multiple
potentially overlapping brain networks by decomposing data
matrices into linear combinations of nonnegative basis func-
tions. A major concern about these methods is the assumption
that the data come from a linear space, which is not always
true in general cases. The limitations of the conventional
signal processing techniques in irregular graph data such as
the lack of a shift-invariance notion have been well discussed
in [12]. Brain networks are invariably complex, which should
be characterized using more sophisticated network methods
[9] and therefore graph signal processing is a right tool.
As stated previously, it would be interesting to construct the
brain network and extract the core regions changing over time
to study the mechanism of brain maturation. In this paper,
we treat brain imaging data as signals defined on the graph,
followed by GLFT process to detect hub regions in a given
frequency range. The model is finally applied on data from the
Philadelphia Neurodevelopmental Cohort (PNC) [18], a large-
scale collaborative study from the dbGap database, in which
volunteers are healthy adolescents of age 8 to 22 years. The
database contains rs-fMRI of nearly 900 subjects and tfMRI
of nearly 700 subjects and over 900 subjects for emotion
identification and working memory task, respectively.
The rest of the paper is organized as follows:
in the
methodology section, we present in detail the way to construct
the brain network and how it is linked to graph signals. We
further introduce the GLFT process and explain how it works
on the graph signals. The model is then evaluated on both
synthetic and real data analysis in the result section, followed
by some discussions and concluding remarks.
II. METHODOLOGY
In this section, we give a detailed explanation for each
step in GLFT process in Fig.1. First, we introduce the no-
tions of brain network and graph signals to represent fMRI
observations. Then, the graph Laplacian matrix is learned as
brain connectivity matrix from fMRI observations. Finally,
we conduct graph Fourier transform and graph filtering to
manipulate the signals into a variety of frequency components.
2
A. Signal and graph concepts
We begin by formulating the framework of describing
signals defined on a graph. A graph G(V, E, W ) with n nodes
includes three components: the vertex set V (V = n), the
edge set E and the weighted adjacency matrix W . In brain
network analysis, nodes are often defined from a given list of
regions of interest (ROI, based on brain atlases [1]), data-
driven clusters (e.g. using independent component analysis
(ICA) [19]) or even voxels; edges are often characterized
by statistical dependencies between pairs of nodes (or, more
generally, groups of nodes) and the weighted adjacency matrix
W represents the affinity between the two nodes. Let us
assume we have m ∈ N subjects. For each subject, we have
BOLD time series of p time points and n ROIs available.
Let W = [Wij] ∈ Rn×n denote the association or similarity
matrix for a subject. A signal x defined on the vertex set of the
graph G is a function from V → R, which is often represented
by a vector in Rn. The i-th element of x represents the real
value assigned to the node i, which reflects the functional
activity of the corresponding brain region.
Apart from W , we introduce the graph Laplacian L as
another important graph associated matrix.
L = D − W,
(1)
where D is referred to degree matrix, which is diagonal with
i-th element on the diagonal being the sum of i-th row in
the weight matrix W . The graph Laplacian L has following
properties: L is a real symmetric matrix and therefore has
a complete set of orthonormal eigenvectors {fi}(i=1,...,n).
If G is connected, the associated eigenvalues are real non-
negative with the unique smallest eigenvalue being zero [10]
0 = λ1 < λ2 ≤ λ3 ≤ ... ≤ λn. By eigendecomposition, the
graph Laplacian L can be rewritten as L = F ΛF T , where Λ
is diagonal with Λii = λi being the i-th eigenvalue of L and
the i-th column of F , fi is the associated eigenvector [13].
To investigate the behavior of the graph signal defined on
the network, we define the smoothness of x with respect to
the Laplacian as
T V (x) := xT Lx =
i,j=1Wij(x(i) − x(j))2,
Σn
(2)
1
2
where x(i) represents the i-th element in x. It reflects the total
variation of the graph signal and has a similar view to optimal
embedding [12], [20]. According to early work by Chung, a
reasonable criterion for a "good" graph map is to minimize
the objective function [10]
Σi,j(x(i) − x(j))2Wij.
(3)
The definition is reasonable because when Wij is large, the
values x(i) and x(j) are expected to be as close as possible,
since the weight matrix is intended to measure the function
connectional similarity between different brain regions. Other-
wise when Wij is small, the contribution of difference between
signal values x(i) and x(j) have little effect on the total
variation. Therefore, we can treat a signal with small total
variation as a smooth signal over the graph while the signals
with large total variations being oscillatory.
3
Fig. 1: Flow diagram of GLFT process for hubs detection. We treat the fMRI observations as graph signals and construct
the connectivity network individually using graph Laplacian learning method. Graph signal was transformed and split into
different frequency components using graph Fourier transform and graph filtering. Finally, we report and visualize the selected
hub regions from the low frequency components.
B. Graph Laplacian learning
First, we represent
the graph signals statistically using
factor analysis model, which can explain observations with
a potentially smaller number of unobserved latent variables.
Specifically, the graph signal can be written as follows [15]:
x = F h + ux + ,
(4)
where x ∈ Rn represents the observed signal, h ∈ Rn
represents the unobserved latent variable, ux ∈ Rn stands for
the mean of x and is the noise term.
The main consideration is the introduction of eigenvector
matrix F as the representation matrix. On one hand,
the
eigenvector matrix of the graph Laplacian is directly related
to the properties of the graph signals by providing a spectral
embedding of the graph vertices. One the other hand, it serves
as basis to represent graph signals in the frequency domain.
Following the similar framework proposed by Dong [15], we
assume that and h follow a multivariate Gaussian distribution
with zero-mean and covariance σIn and Λ† (Λ† is the Moore-
Penrose pseudoinverse of Λ), respectively, i.e.,
∼ N (0, σ
2In)
h ∼ N (0, Λ†).
(5)
(6)
Given the above prior, the energy of the signal is concentrated
mainly on the first few eigen components such that it promotes
the smoothness of the graph signal. With the above assump-
tions, the probability function of the graph signal x is given
as:
x ∼ N (ux, F Λ†F T + σ
2In)).
(7)
We then introduce a maximum a posteriori(MAP) estimation
to estimate h given graph observation x and prior distribution
of h. Specifically, by applying Bayes' rule and assuming
without loss of generality that ux = 0, the MAP estimation
of the latent variable h can be written in the following form
[21]:
hM AP (x) : = arg max
h
= arg max
h
= arg min
h
= arg min
h
= arg min
h
p(hx)
p(xh)p(h)
(− ln pE(x − F h) − ln pH (h))
(− ln e
hT Λh + k(cid:107)x − F h(cid:107)2
2,
−(x−F h)T (x−F h)
σ2
− ln e−hT Λh)
(8)
where pE(x − F h) and pH (h) denote the probability density
function of the noise and the latent variable, respectively.
is the parameter denoting the variance of the noise.
k = σ2
Especially,
the
minimization problem is reduced to:
in a noise free scenario when x = F h,
hT Λh = (F T x)T ΛF T x = xT Lx.
(9)
Thus, it confirms that the proposed model describes the smooth
property of the graph signal x. Similar conclusion can be made
in a noisy setting, where the main component(F h) is smooth
on the graph.
Using a change of variable y = F h, we solve the problem
in (8) with the following objective function [15]:
min
L∈Rn×n,Y ∈Rn×p
α(cid:107)X − Y (cid:107)2
F + tr(Y T LY ) + β(cid:107)L(cid:107)2
F
s.t tr(L) = n,
Lij = Lji ≤ 0, (i (cid:54)= j),
L · 1 = 0,
(10)
where X ∈ Rn×p contains p observations in columns, and
α, β are two positive parameters regulating the tradeoff of the
noise and penalty term. tr(·) and (cid:107) · (cid:107)F denote the trace and
Frobenius norm of a matrix and 0 and 1 represent the constant
zero and one vectors, respectively. The third one(Frobenius
norm of L) in the objective function is the penalty term to
control the off-diagonal elements in L. The trace constraint
serves as a normalization factor to avoid trivial solutions and
the second and third constraints are based on the properties of
the graph Laplacian to ensure the learned L is valid.
Since the optimization problem is not jointly convex, we
adopted an alternating minimization scheme to fix one variable
while solving for the other one at each step, which leads to a
local minimum of the solution. Specifically, we first initialize
Y as the graph signal X and iteratively solve the following
optimization problems:
min
tr(Y T LY ) + β(cid:107)L(cid:107)2
F
L
s.t tr(L) = n,
Lij = Lji ≤ 0, (i (cid:54)= j),
L · 1 = 0,
α(cid:107)X − Y (cid:107)2
F + tr(Y T LY ).
min
Y
(11)
(12)
The problems can be effectively solved with CVX [22].
C. Graph Fourier transform
With the notion of the signal defined on the graph and its
graph Laplacian L, the graph Fourier transform(GFT) of x
with respect to L is defined as
x := F T x.
The inverse GFT of x with respect to L is defined as
x = F x.
(13)
(14)
Note that F is orthonormal, i.e., F T F = I, and the original
signal x can be recovered through inverse GFT of the x. Thus
x and x form a GFT pair.
n
n
There are two explanations linking GFT with conventional
Fourier Transform. Mathematically, if the eigenvectors in F
, ..., e−i 2π(k−1)(n−1)
are of the form of fk = [1, e−i 2π(k−1)
]T ,
the GFT is reduced to conventional
time domain Fourier
transform. Specifically, the eigenvectors of a cycle graph are
of such form [14]. Therefore, conventional Fourier transform
can be viewed as a specific case of GFT. On the other hand,
the eigenvalues of the graph Laplacian play a similar role in
serving as frequency components compared with conventional
Fourier transform. In classical Fourier analysis, the eigenvalues
{2π(k − 1)}(k=1,...,n) carry a specific notion of frequency
[12]: when k approaches one (low frequencies), the associated
4
complex exponential eigenfunctions oscillate slowly, appear-
ing to be smooth, whereas when k is far from one (high
frequencies), the associated eigenfunctions oscillate rapidly.
In the graph setting, eigenvalues λk have the similar notion
of frequency. In fact, we can define the total variation of the
eigenvector fk to measure how much the eigenvector over the
graph:
T V (fk) := f T
k Lfk = f T
k λkfk = λk.
(15)
We can conclude confidentially that when k is close to one,
the eigenvectors fk change slowly over the graph, whereas
when k is far away from one, the eigenvectors vary rapidly.
This is consistent with the conventional Fourier Transform.
D. Graph filtering
Given the above discussion, we are able to manipulate the
transformed signal in the frequency domain by designing fil-
ters to extract information at a range of frequencies. Following
the standard procedure from signal processing, we define a
low-pass filter to keep the transformed signal below a given
threshold; a high-pass filter to represent the high frequency
components; and a band-pass filter to preserve in between.
We begin by splitting the diagonal matrix Λ with λl and λm
being the threshold to separate low and high frequencies.
Λ =diag(λ1, λ2, ..., λl, 0, ..., 0)+
diag(0, ..., 0, λl+1, ..., λm, 0, ..., 0)+
diag(0, ..., 0, λm+1, ..., λn).
(16)
The corresponding graph filter for each frequency range can
be defined as:
Gl = diag(1, 1, ..., 1
, 0, ..., 0)
(cid:124)
(cid:123)(cid:122)
(cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125)
l
(cid:125)
(cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125)
(cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125)
Gm = diag(0, ..., 0
, 1, ..., 1
m−l
Gh = diag(0, ..., 0, 1, ..., 1
n−m
l
).
, 0, ..., 0)
(17)
(18)
(19)
The effect of the filtering on the graph spectral coefficients
is G x. Thus, the graph signal in the frequency domain can
be decomposed into low frequency, intermediate frequency
and high frequency components x = xl + xm + xh. Based
on the definition of the inverse Graph Fourier transform, the
original graph signal can be reconstructed by x = xl+xm+xh
with xl, xm, xh being the inverse signal corresponding to the
specific frequencies.
It has long been understood that the brain combines certain
degree of disorganized behavior with some degree of regularity
to form a high complexity system with order and disorder co-
existing [23]. In our framework, the ordered part corresponds
to low frequency component with small total variation which
is believed to help with the organization of the brain functional
activities and the disorder portion stands for the high frequency
component with high total variation which is more likely to
be the noise. The low variability has proven to be essential in
the analysis of neurological disease and behavior and strong
contribution in learning process [14], [24]. As a consequence,
we put our emphasis on the learning of the low frequency
subspace in the following section.
III. RESULTS
In this section, we first evaluated the performance of the
proposed graph learning method on synthetic data. We further
applied GLFT for real brain imaging data analysis and reported
some interesting findings regarding the brain development
stages during adolescence. Finally, we compared the classifi-
cation results using learned Laplacian matrix as fingerprints
to sperate subjects belonging to different age groups with
those using the original graph Fourier transform and alternative
graph Fourier transform based ones [11], [12]. Fig.1 gives the
summarization and illustration of the main steps involved in
GLFT process to identify hub regions in this work.
A. Synthetic data analysis
the ER model
1) Data preparation: We generated two types of artificial
graphs with 20 vertices that follow the Erdos-Renyi (ER)
model [25] and the Barabasi-Albert (BA) model [26]. Specif-
ically,
in this case generates a graph with
probability 0.2 for each possible edge independently. The BA
model generates a graph by adding new vertices linking with
other existing nodes proportional to the degree distribution,
namely, the probability of the new vertex to an existing node
is the ratio of the degree of that existing node to the sum
of degrees of all
the existing nodes. We consider unitary
weights in this experiment and calculate the ground truth
Laplacian based on (1). For each graph, we generated 100
signals according to (7) with ux = 0 and σ = 0.5.
2) Result and visualization: Given the graph signal x
defined on each graph, we first applied the proposed graph
Laplacian learning method to learn the graph Laplacian matrix.
For comparison, we calculated the graph Laplacian by two
other methods: i) construct the similarity matrix W using
RBF kernel and then calculate L in (1); ii) construct the
similarity matrix W using the Pearson correlation at different
vertices of the signal and then calculate L in (1). To evaluate
the performance of these methods quantitatively, we used
precision, recall and F-measure as the evaluation metrics
statistically. Specifically, the precision measures the percentage
of edges in the learned graph that are present in the ground
truth graph. On the contrary, the recall measures the percentage
of the edges in the ground truth graph that are also in the
learned graph. The F-measure is the harmonic average of the
precision and recall that evaluates the overall performance of
the recovery of the edge set. We repeated the experiment 20
times randomly and the average results are shown in Table.I.
The results demonstrated that the graph Laplacian learning
method outperformed the RBF-kernel and correlation based
ones for all metrics.This implies that the graph Laplacian
learning method is more powerful in extracting significant
patterns in the network.
For clarity, we also visualized the learned graph Laplacian
matrix on both BA and ER graph in Fig.2.
TABLE I: Simulation result
learning method
gl-learning
RBF
correlation
learning method
gl-learning
RBF
correlation
precision
0.9413
0.8217
0.4870
precision
0.6669
0.5161
0.3336
B-A model
E-R model
recall
0.9474
0.9974
0.5211
recall
0.8363
0.7755
0.3423
5
F-measure
0.9132
0.8984
0.5031
F-measure
0.7375
0.6761
0.3378
Fig. 2: The visualization of the learned graph Laplacian
matrix for both E-R and B-A model. The superior part is
the simulation from B-A model and the inferior part is the
E-R model. From left to right is the groundtruth Laplacian
matrix and Laplacian matrix recovered from graph signals
learned by GL-learning method, radial basis function kernel
and correlation matrix.
B. Real data analysis
We further applied the GLFT to real neuroimaging data
analysis. Specifically, we consider fMRI data collected from
Philadelphia Neurodevelopmental Cohort (PNC) [11] to study
the brain maturation process. MRI examinations were con-
ducted on a single 3T Siemens TIM Trio whole-body scanner.
Both resting-state and task-based images were collected us-
ing a single-shot, interleaved multi-slice, gradient-echo, echo
planar imaging sequence.
1) Analysis of resting-state MRI data:
a) Data acquisition and preprocessing: During the
resting-state scan, a fixation cross was displayed as images
were acquired. Subjects were instructed to stay awake, keep
their eyes open, fixate on the displayed crosshair, and remain
still. Total resting state scan duration was 6.2 min [18].
Standard preprocessing steps were applied using SPM12,
including motion correction, spatial normalization to standard
MNI space (adult template) and spatial smoothing with a 3mm
FWHM Gaussian kernel. The influence of motion (6 param-
eters) was further addressed using a regression procedure,
and the functional time series were band-pass filtered using
a 0.01Hz to 0.1Hz frequency range. Finally, we reduced the
dimension of the data using the 264 ROI atlas defined by
Power et al [1] with a sphere radius parameter of 5mm. The
time sequences of all voxels in the same brain region were
averaged so that the data reduced to a 264× p matrix for each
subject with p = 124 denoting the number of time points
for each rs-fMRI scan [27]. We normalized the regional mean
BOLD observation at each time point to maintain consistency
of the total energy to avoid extreme spikes due to head motion
or drift artifacts in fMRI [14]
Since we are interested in brain development as a function
of age, we select a subset of the full dataset based on age in
months. More precisely, each subject whose age is over 18
years is considered to belong to the first class (young adult,
age 18-22.58 years, 119 females out of 198 subjects), while
subjects whose age is under 12 years belong to the second
class (children, age 8.58-12 years, 108 females out of 191
subjects).
b) Result and visualization: We followed the procedures
illustrated in Fig.1 to identify hub regions for each age
group. Specifically, we treated fMRI observations of each time
point on different brain regions as graph signals defined on
the brain network and applied the graph Laplacian learning
algorithm to estimate the graph Laplacian for each subject.
Then we conducted graph Fourier transform and graph filtering
to decompose the graph signal into low, intermediate and
high frequency components. Hu et al [13] found interesting
results by analyzing the magnitude of the eigenvectors corre-
sponding to different cortical regions and showed differences
in Alzheimer's disease. We further improved the model by
taking the projection energy of each projected eigenbasis into
consideration. The spikes of the energy concentration were
considered dominant in the frequency domain, which could
be further mapped back to detect important cortical regions.
Specifically, the inner products on eigenbasis of the signals in
the low frequency domain were calculated. The core regions
were detected whose averaged magnitude of eigenvectors were
two standard deviations higher than mean value [28] with
cutoffs splitting the frequency ranges selected using cross-
validation, i.e, l = 19. We plotted the energy concentration of
the transformed signals as a reason why we put our emphasis
on low frequency part in Fig.3. The plot suggested that the
majority of the information contained in the low frequency
part. We explored group differences in the organization of
the networks at a regional level by statistical testing for a
significant between-group difference in the detected hubs and
reported the result in Table.II and Table.III for children and
young adult group, respectively. Regions with * in the table
have been reported previously and the reference behind the
regions point to the corresponding literature with 10 out of 13
regions in both age stages. We also visualized the locations
of the detected brain regions in Fig.4. When we compare
the difference between age groups, a significant number of
common regions were observed, most of which are listed in the
default mode network (DMN) [29]. This finding verifies our
previous hypothesis that the low frequency segment represents
the ordered regularity part and is consistent with the fact that
DMN is dominant at resting state.
2) Analysis of task-state MRI data:
a) Data acquisition and preprocessing: In our work, we
applied our method on two types of task-state MRI data from
6
Fig. 3: The energy plot of the signal after GLFT process. We
calculate the projection energy for all the subjects. We average
the projection power for all frequency components except for
the first one, which has constant values in its eigenbasis.
We plot the energy map toward frequency components in
an increasing order. The most concentration of the energy
is located in the low frequency components as shown in the
figure.
Fig. 4: The sketch map of the core brain regions coalitions
from the rs-fMRI data. The regions in the left part are detected
from the children group while the regions in the right part from
the young adult group. Most of the regions detected come from
Default Mode Network. The size of the nodes represents the
detection significance of the region. The visualization of the
brain network is by BrainNet Viewer developed by [30].
PNC [37] to understand how brain maturation mediates cog-
nitive development. The task involves emotion identification
and working memory examination and detailed conduction of
the experiments can be found in the paper by Satterthwaite et
al [18].
The emotion identification employs a fast event-related
design with a jittered inter-stimulus interval(ISI). 60 faces in
total were displayed with neutral, happy, sad, angry or fearful
expressions performed by volunteered actors(50% female) in
color photographs. The actors were trained by professional
directors to express a range of facial expressions and a subset
of expressions was kept based on high degree of accurate
identification(80%) by raters. Participants were required to
label the emotion corresponding to the expressions displayed.
Each face was displayed for 5.5 s followed by a variable ISI
from 0.5s to 18.5 s, during which a complex crosshair (that
TABLE II: Cortical hubs estimated from children stage rs-
fMRI
Location
Left Cerebrum, Parietal Lobe, Precuneus* [31]
Left Cerebrum, Limbic Lobe, Cingulate Gyrus
Left Cerebrum, Limbic Lobe, Posterior Cingulate*
[32]
Right Cerebrum, Frontal Lobe, Superior Frontal
Gyrus* [33]
Right Cerebrum, Temporal Lobe, Inferior Temporal
Gyrus* [33]
Right Cerebrum, Temporal Lobe, Middle Temporal
Gyrus* [34]
Left Cerebrum, Temporal Lobe, Middle Temporal
Gyrus* [33]
Right Cerebrum, Occipital Lobe, Cuneus* [24]
Right Cerebrum, Frontal Lobe, Middle Frontal
Gyrus* [33]
Right Cerebrum, Parietal Lobe, Inferior Parietal
Lobule* [35]
Left Cerebrum, Frontal Lobe, Medial Frontal
Gyrus* [36]
Right Cerebrum, Sub-lobar, Extra-Nuclear
Right Cerebrum, Temporal Lobe, Superior
Temporal Gyrus* [33]
Statistic
test(P-value)
2.48e−9
2.10e−13
8.28e−5
8.84e−7
4.73e−10
4.07e−4
1.62e−5
0.53
8.70e−11
0.1398
0.0342
1.67e−14
1.25e−4
TABLE III: Cortical hubs estimated from young adult stage
rs-fMRI
Location
Left Cerebrum, Parietal Lobe, Precuneus* [31]
Left Cerebrum, Limbic Lobe, Cingulate Gyrus
Left Cerebrum, Limbic Lobe, Posterior Cingulate*
[32]
Left Cerebrum, Frontal Lobe, Medial Frontal
Gyrus* [36]
Right Cerebrum, Frontal Lobe, Middle Frontal
Gyrus* [33]
Right Cerebrum, Frontal Lobe, Superior Frontal
Gyrus* [33]
Right Cerebrum, Temporal Lobe, Inferior Temporal
Gyrus* [33]
Right Cerebrum, Temporal Lobe, Middle Temporal
Gyrus* [34]
Left Cerebrum, Temporal Lobe, Middle Temporal
Gyrus* [33]
Right Cerebrum, Occipital Lobe, Cuneus* [24]
Right Cerebrum, Parietal Lobe, Inferior Parietal
Lobule* [35]
Right Cerebrum, Sub-lobar, Extra-Nuclear
Right Cerebrum, Temporal Lobe, Superior
Temporal Gyrus* [33]
Statistic
test(P-value)
2.48e−9
2.10e−13
8.28e−5
0.0342
8.70e−11
8.84e−7
4.73e−10
4.07e−4
1.62e−5
0.53
0.1398
1.67e−14
1.25e−4
matched the faces' perceptual qualities) was displayed. Total
emotion identification task duration was 10.5 min [18].
The working memory studies were performed via a fractal
version of the standard n-back task, which was proved to be a
reliable indicator of the executive system and was able to avoid
lexical processing abilities that evolve during development
[38], [39]. The task was conducted by presenting complex
geometric figures (fractals) for 500 ms, followed by a fixed
ISI of 2500 ms. There are three levels of test in total: 0-back,
1-back and 2-back. In 0-back setting, participants responded
to a specified target fractal; in 1-back setting, participants
responded if the current fractal was identical to the previous
7
Fig. 5: The sketch map of the core brain regions coalitions
identified from the tfMRI data. The superior part (a,b) indi-
cates the network constructed from emotion identification task
while the inferior part (c,d) indicates the working memory task
based network. The regions in left part are identified from
children group and the regions in right part from the young
adult group. The size of the nodes represents the detection
significance of the region.
one; in 2-back setting, participants responded if the current
fractal was identical to the previous two trails. Total working
memory task duration was 11.6 min [18].
The preprocessing steps for task state fMRI data were
similar to that adopted for resting state fMRI data, detailed
in Result section B.1.a. The only differences were at the final
step that the time sequences reduced to a 264 × p matrix for
every subject with p = 210 and p = 231 denoting the number
of time points for emotion identification and working memory
tasks, respectively, due to the total duration of the MRI scan.
The same manner was adopted to partition the age groups,
with 154 and 204 subjects belonging to the younger group
and 148 and 207 subjects belonging to the older group for
emotion and working memory task, respectively.
b) Result and visualization: Following the same steps
in rs-fMRI study, we display the estimated task related core
regions along brain maturation process in Fig.5 using the
BrainNet Viewer [30]. with thresholds being l = 45 and
l = 40 for working memory task and emotion identification
task, respectively. Different from rs-fMRI study, task-based
age related regions are observed for both emotion and working
memory task such as postcentral parietal gyrus and parahip-
pocampal gyrus (part of cerebral cortex, closely related to
TABLE IV: Cortical hubs estimated from children stage tfMRI
TABLE VI: Result for fMRI data analysis
8
Location
Left Cerebrum, Parietal Lobe, Postcentral Gyrus*
[33]
Right Cerebrum, Frontal Lobe, Medial Frontal
Gyrus* [34] .
Right Cerebrum, Parietal Lobe, Inferior Parietal
Lobule* [35]
Left Cerebrum, Sub-lobar, Insula
Right Cerebrum, Parietal Lobe, Precuneus
Right Cerebrum, Frontal Lobe, Superior Frontal
Gyrus* [33]
Left Cerebrum, Frontal Lobe, Medial Frontal
Gyrus* [36]
Left Cerebrum, Occipital Lobe, Middle Occipital
Gyrus
Left Cerebrum, Limbic Lobe, Parahippocampal
Gyrus* [40]
Right Cerebrum, Temporal Lobe, Middle Temporal
Gyrus* [34]
Left Cerebrum, Temporal Lobe, Middle Temporal
Gyrus* [33]
Statistic
test(P-value)
6.14e−5
2.87e−6
6.52e−5
0.0078
1.55e−5
0.1492
0.0438
0.0826
0.9779
0.0654
1.87e−5
TABLE V: Cortical hubs estimated from young adult stage
tfMRI
Location
Left Cerebrum, Temporal Lobe, Superior Temporal
Gyrus* [33]
Left Cerebrum, Sub-lobar, Insula
Left Cerebrum, Limbic Lobe, Cingulate Gyrus
Right Cerebrum, Frontal Lobe, Medial Frontal
Gyrus* [41]
Left Cerebrum, Frontal Lobe, Medial Frontal
Gyrus* [36]
Left Cerebrum, Temporal Lobe, Middle Temporal
Gyrus* [33]
Left Cerebrum, Parietal Lobe, Precuneus* [31]
Right Cerebrum, Frontal Lobe, Superior Frontal
Gyrus* [33]
Right Cerebrum, Sub-lobar, Extra-Nuclear
Statistic
test(P-value)
0.0015
0.0078
2.65e−4
1.25e−4
0.0272
5.57e−4
0.0044
0.3235
0.5862
hippocampus). The result is within our expectation since it
has been reported that the different activation patterns occur
in different adolescence stages facing the same task [34]. To
exclude unexpected interference, the joint core regions which
play a key role in both cognitive tasks were identified as hubs.
We listed these hubs in Table.IV and Table.V for children and
young adult group, respectively. 8 of the 11 hubs in children
stage and 6 of 9 hubs in young adult stage have been reported
in the literatures [31], [33] -- [36], [40], [41] to be closely related
to the brain maturation.
3) Brain maturation analysis: In this section, we summa-
rize the findings and interpret the results with brain maturation.
We notice that for resting state fMRI data, a series of common
regions are detected for both age groups. These regions
have been identified within the default mode network. Recent
studies report that the same general pattern for the DMN in
adults is also found in children age from 7 to 9 years and
7-12 years [42], [43]. It indicates that the DMN is relatively
stable at stages from childhood to puberty to adulthood. Since
DMN is dominantly active during the rs-fMRI scan periods, it
ACC
SEN
SPE
ACC
SEN
SPE
ACC
SEN
SPE
GLFT
0.9306
0.9295
0.9321
rs-fMRI
RBF
0.8870
0.8945
0.8803
emoid-fMRI
GLFT
0.9569
0.9595
0.9542
GLFT
0.9392
0.9271
0.9514
nback-fMRI
RBF
0.9110
0.9262
0.8963
RBF
0.8856
0.9129
0.8586
Corr
0.9279
0.9242
0.9318
Corr
0.9469
0.9462
0.9475
Corr
0.9417
0.9271
0.9564
Note.In this table, ACC, SEN and SPE are the abbreviations of accuracy,
sensitivity and specificity, respectively.
is reasonable that the detected regions lie mainly in DMN and
similar patterns are observed across age groups. Especially we
find that superior temporal gyrus (STG) is reported in both age
groups, which is commonly believed to be essential during
brain maturation process [44], [45]. In a longitudinal study
conducted by Nitin Gogtay and his colleagues [33], STG is
identified with the most variation and speed of gray matter
loss(brain maturation) during adolescence stage.
lobe,
In tfMRI analysis, the middle temporal gyrus is observed
in the children stage while the superior temporal gyrus is
observed in the order one. Both middle and superior tem-
poral gyrus are thought to be heteromodal association sites
(along with prefrontal and inferior parietal cortices) and are
involved with integration of memory, audiovisual association
and object-recognition functions [33]. The findings on the
temporal cortex is consistent with the report that the superior
temporal cortex, which contains association areas that integrate
information from several sensory modalities, matures last [33].
In parietal
the postcentral gyrus is detected in the
children stage and has been reported to be the beginning part
of the gray matter loss. The inferior parietal cortex has also
been reported to mature during puberty. Neuroimaging studies
demonstrated that the hippocampus has significant activation
during the encoding of faces or pictures in young adults,
but the activation is reduced in older adults [40], [46]. We
also draw the similar conclusion because the hippocampus is
detected only in the children group. The frontal lobes that are
involved in executive function, attention and motor coordina-
tion, are observed for both age groups. For further validation of
the result, we separated the age groups using the learned brain
network via linear SVM (support vector machine) classifier
[47]. We also constructed the brain network using RBF kernel
and correlation matrix to compare the performance. Sensitivity,
specificity and accuracy are used as metrics to evaluate the
performance. Specifically, sensitivity measures the percentage
of children that are correctly identified in the younger group
and the specificity measures the proportion of actual young
adults that are correctly identified in the older group. Accuracy
evaluates the overall performance of the classifier by indicating
the percentage of the correctly identified subjects. 10-fold
cross-validation was carried out to avoid overfitting and we
list the result in the Table.VI.
In general,
the performance of GLFT method is better
than RBF and correlation based one(except for the slightly
worse result compared with correlation in working memory
task). It demonstrates that the proposed method is comparably
powerful in extracting the age-related features. The high accu-
racies in distinguishing age groups also suggest the disparity
of brain maturation stages, which implies the changes and
transformations of the brain network during puberty.
IV. CONCLUSION
We analyzed the brain functional connectivity differences
between children and young adults using GLFT to explore the
mechanisms of brain maturation during adolescence. Specif-
ically, neuroimaging data were parcellated into regions of
interest according to the pre-defined functional atlas [1]. The
fMRI observations were viewed in a graph setting to become
graph signals defined on the vertex set or namely, different
functional brain regions. Given these graph signals, the con-
nectivity matrix of the pairwise regions were estimated via a
graph Laplacian learning algorithm. These signals were fur-
ther transformed into the frequency domain, manipulated into
several frequency ranges, analyzed in the filtered frequency
components, and recovered from each frequency portion us-
ing graph signal processing tool. Compared with the graph
Fourier transform and its variants, the GLFT can facilitate
the extraction of the brain connectivity network directly from
the BOLD observations based on the smoothness conditions
on the graph. In both real and synthetic data analysis, we
show that
the proposed learning method outperforms the
GFT and Alternative GFT based one. Based on PNC dataset
containing both task and task-free fMRI imaging, the core
regions corresponding to the brain development at normally
developing adolescent stage were identified through spectral
analysis of the graph Laplacian eigenfunctions. The findings
in this experiment are consistent with the original hypothesis
from brain network analysis [23]. The hub regions reported are
also consistent with the longitudinal biological experiment on
the dynamic map of gray matter loss(brain maturation) during
puberty [33].
In conclusion, we present a GLFT approach to study the
brain functional difference among adolescent age groups and
demonstrate it on a real
large dataset. The core regions
reported in this paper can serve as biomarkers for brain
maturation at youth stage. We hope this model can find other
applications in neuroimaging.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This work has been supported by NIH (R01 GM109068,
R01 MH104680, R01 MH107354, P20 GM103472, R01
REB020407, 1R01 EB006841) and NSF (#1539067).
REFERENCES
[1] J. D. Power et al., "Functional network organization of the human brain,"
Neuron, vol. 72, no. 4, pp. 665 -- 678, 2011.
9
[2] D. M. Barch et al., "Function in the human connectome: task-fmri and
individual differences in behavior," Neuroimage, vol. 80, pp. 169 -- 189,
2013.
[3] H. Eavani et al., "Identifying sparse connectivity patterns in the brain
using resting-state fmri," Neuroimage, vol. 105, pp. 286 -- 299, 2015.
[4] D. D. Jolles et al., "A comprehensive study of whole-brain functional
connectivity in children and young adults," Cerebral cortex, vol. 21,
no. 2, pp. 385 -- 391, 2010.
[5] D. A. Fair et al., "Functional brain networks develop from a local to
distributed organization," PLoS computational biology, vol. 5, no. 5, p.
e1000381, 2009.
[6] A. M. Passarotti et al., "The development of face and location process-
ing: An fmri study," Developmental Science, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 100 -- 117,
2003.
[7] S. K. Holland et al., "Normal fmri brain activation patterns in children
performing a verb generation task," Neuroimage, vol. 14, no. 4, pp.
837 -- 843, 2001.
[8] E. Bullmore and O. Sporns, "Complex brain networks: graph theoretical
analysis of structural and functional systems," Nature Reviews Neuro-
science, vol. 10, no. 3, p. 186, 2009.
[9] M. Rubinov and O. Sporns, "Complex network measures of brain
connectivity: uses and interpretations," Neuroimage, vol. 52, no. 3, pp.
1059 -- 1069, 2010.
[10] F. R. Chung, Spectral graph theory. American Mathematical Soc.,
1997, no. 92.
[11] A. Sandryhaila and J. M. Moura, "Discrete signal processing on graphs,"
IEEE transactions on signal processing, vol. 61, no. 7, pp. 1644 -- 1656,
2013.
[12] D. I. Shuman et al., "The emerging field of signal processing on graphs:
Extending high-dimensional data analysis to networks and other irregular
domains," IEEE Signal Processing Magazine, vol. 30, no. 3, pp. 83 -- 98,
2013.
[13] C. Hu et al., "Matched signal detection on graphs: Theory and appli-
cation to brain network classification," in International Conference on
Information Processing in Medical Imaging. Springer, 2013, pp. 1 -- 12.
[14] W. Huang et al., "Graph frequency analysis of brain signals," IEEE
journal of selected topics in signal processing, vol. 10, no. 7, pp. 1189 --
1203, 2016.
[15] X. Dong et al., "Learning laplacian matrix in smooth graph signal
representations," IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing, vol. 64,
no. 23, pp. 6160 -- 6173, 2016.
[16] H. Abdi and L. J. Williams, "Principal component analysis," Wiley
interdisciplinary reviews: computational statistics, vol. 2, no. 4, pp. 433 --
459, 2010.
[17] A. Anderson et al., "Non-negative matrix factorization of multimodal
mri, fmri and phenotypic data reveals differential changes in default
mode subnetworks in adhd," NeuroImage, vol. 102, pp. 207 -- 219, 2014.
[18] T. D. Satterthwaite et al., "Neuroimaging of the philadelphia neurode-
velopmental cohort," Neuroimage, vol. 86, pp. 544 -- 553, 2014.
[19] E. A. Allen et al., "A baseline for the multivariate comparison of resting-
state networks," Frontiers in systems neuroscience, vol. 5, p. 2, 2011.
[20] M. Belkin and P. Niyogi, "Laplacian eigenmaps for dimensionality
reduction and data representation," Neural computation, vol. 15, no. 6,
pp. 1373 -- 1396, 2003.
[21] R. Gribonval, "Should penalized least squares regression be interpreted
as maximum a posteriori estimation?" IEEE Transactions on Signal
Processing, vol. 59, no. 5, pp. 2405 -- 2410, 2011.
[22] M. Grant et al., "Cvx: Matlab software for disciplined convex pro-
gramming (2008)," Web page and software available at http://stanford.
edu/ boyd/cvx, 2015.
[23] O. Sporns, Networks of the Brain. MIT press, 2010.
[24] D. D. Garrett et al., "The modulation of bold variability between
cognitive states varies by age and processing speed," Cerebral Cortex,
vol. 23, no. 3, pp. 684 -- 693, 2012.
[25] P. Erdos and A. R´enyi, "On the evolution of random graphs," Publ.
Math. Inst. Hung. Acad. Sci, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 17 -- 60, 1960.
[26] A.-L. Barab´asi and R. Albert, "Emergence of scaling in random net-
works," science, vol. 286, no. 5439, pp. 509 -- 512, 1999.
[27] P. Zille et al., "Fused estimation of sparse connectivity patterns from
rest fmriapplication to comparison of children and adult brains," IEEE
transactions on medical imaging, vol. 37, no. 10, pp. 2165 -- 2175, 2018.
[28] D. S. Bassett et al., "Hierarchical organization of human cortical
networks in health and schizophrenia," Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 28,
no. 37, pp. 9239 -- 9248, 2008.
[29] R. Buckner et al., "The brains default network: anatomy, function, and
relevance to disease ann ny acad sci 2008; 1124: 1-38."
10
[30] M. Xia et al., "Brainnet viewer: a network visualization tool for human
brain connectomics," PloS one, vol. 8, no. 7, p. e68910, 2013.
[31] C. L. Grady et al., "Age-related changes in brain activity across the
adult lifespan," Journal of cognitive neuroscience, vol. 18, no. 2, pp.
227 -- 241, 2006.
[32] H. Reyngoudt et al., "Age-related differences in metabolites in the
posterior cingulate cortex and hippocampus of normal ageing brain: a
1h-mrs study," European journal of radiology, vol. 81, no. 3, pp. e223 --
e231, 2012.
[33] N. Gogtay et al., "Dynamic mapping of human cortical development
during childhood through early adulthood," Proceedings of the National
academy of Sciences of the United States of America, vol. 101, no. 21,
pp. 8174 -- 8179, 2004.
[34] T. Iidaka et al., "Age-related differences in the medial temporal lobe
responses to emotional faces as revealed by fmri," Hippocampus, vol. 12,
no. 3, pp. 352 -- 362, 2002.
[35] J. G. Chi et al., "Gyral development of the human brain," Annals of
neurology, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 86 -- 93, 1977.
[36] K. Rubia et al., "Functional frontalisation with age: mapping neu-
rodevelopmental trajectories with fmri," Neuroscience & Biobehavioral
Reviews, vol. 24, no. 1, pp. 13 -- 19, 2000.
[37] T. D. Satterthwaite et al., "The philadelphia neurodevelopmental cohort:
a publicly available resource for the study of normal and abnormal brain
development in youth," Neuroimage, vol. 124, pp. 1115 -- 1119, 2016.
[38] T. T. Brown et al., "Developmental changes in human cerebral functional
organization for word generation," Cerebral Cortex, vol. 15, no. 3, pp.
275 -- 290, 2004.
[39] B. L. Schlaggar et al., "Functional neuroanatomical differences between
adults and school-age children in the processing of single words,"
Science, vol. 296, no. 5572, pp. 1476 -- 1479, 2002.
[40] C. L. Grady et al., "Age-related reductions in human recognition
memory due to impaired encoding," Science, vol. 269, no. 5221, pp.
218 -- 221, 1995.
[41] P. Shaw et al., "Intellectual ability and cortical development in children
and adolescents," Nature, vol. 440, no. 7084, p. 676, 2006.
[42] M. E. Thomason et al., "Default-mode function and task-induced
deactivation have overlapping brain substrates in children," Neuroimage,
vol. 41, no. 4, pp. 1493 -- 1503, 2008.
[43] K. Supekar et al., "Development of functional and structural connectivity
within the default mode network in young children," Neuroimage,
vol. 52, no. 1, pp. 290 -- 301, 2010.
[44] M. E. Raichle, "The brain's default mode network," Annual review of
neuroscience, vol. 38, pp. 433 -- 447, 2015.
[45] M. E. Raichle et al., "A default mode of brain function," Proceedings
of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 98, no. 2, pp. 676 -- 682, 2001.
[46] C. L. Grady et al., "The effects of age on the neural correlates of episodic
encoding," Cerebral Cortex, vol. 9, no. 8, pp. 805 -- 814, 1999.
[47] B. Scholkopf and A. J. Smola, Learning with kernels: support vector
machines, regularization, optimization, and beyond. MIT press, 2002.
|
1706.01757 | 2 | 1706 | 2017-09-16T10:37:24 | Visual pathways from the perspective of cost functions and multi-task deep neural networks | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Vision research has been shaped by the seminal insight that we can understand the higher-tier visual cortex from the perspective of multiple functional pathways with different goals. In this paper, we try to give a computational account of the functional organization of this system by reasoning from the perspective of multi-task deep neural networks. Machine learning has shown that tasks become easier to solve when they are decomposed into subtasks with their own cost function. We hypothesize that the visual system optimizes multiple cost functions of unrelated tasks and this causes the emergence of a ventral pathway dedicated to vision for perception, and a dorsal pathway dedicated to vision for action. To evaluate the functional organization in multi-task deep neural networks, we propose a method that measures the contribution of a unit towards each task, applying it to two networks that have been trained on either two related or two unrelated tasks, using an identical stimulus set. Results show that the network trained on the unrelated tasks shows a decreasing degree of feature representation sharing towards higher-tier layers while the network trained on related tasks uniformly shows high degree of sharing. We conjecture that the method we propose can be used to analyze the anatomical and functional organization of the visual system and beyond. We predict that the degree to which tasks are related is a good descriptor of the degree to which they share downstream cortical-units. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Visual pathways from the perspective of cost functions and multi-task deep
neural networks
H.Steven Scholte1,2,∗ Max M. Losch1,2,3,∗ Kandan Ramakrishnan3
Edward H.F. de Haan1,2 Sander M. Bohte4
∗ Shared first author
1Department of Psychology, University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands
2Amsterdam Brain and Cognition, University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands
3Informatics Institute, University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands
4Machine Learning Group, CWI, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
{h.s.scholte, m.m.losch, k.ramakrishnan, e.h.f.dehaan}@uva.nl, [email protected]
Abstract
Vision research has been shaped by the seminal insight
that we can understand the higher-tier visual cortex from
the perspective of multiple functional pathways with differ-
ent goals. In this paper, we try to give a computational ac-
count of the functional organization of this system by rea-
soning from the perspective of multi-task deep neural net-
works. Machine learning has shown that tasks become eas-
ier to solve when they are decomposed into subtasks with
their own cost function. We hypothesize that the visual sys-
tem optimizes multiple cost functions of unrelated tasks and
this causes the emergence of a ventral pathway dedicated
to vision for perception, and a dorsal pathway dedicated to
vision for action. To evaluate the functional organization
in multi-task deep neural networks, we propose a method
that measures the contribution of a unit towards each task,
applying it to two networks that have been trained on ei-
ther two related or two unrelated tasks, using an identical
stimulus set. Results show that the network trained on the
unrelated tasks shows a decreasing degree of feature repre-
sentation sharing towards higher-tier layers while the net-
work trained on related tasks uniformly shows high degree
of sharing. We conjecture that the method we propose can
be used to analyze the anatomical and functional organiza-
tion of the visual system and beyond. We predict that the
degree to which tasks are related is a good descriptor of the
degree to which they share downstream cortical-units.
1. Introduction
The visual system is described as consisting of two par-
allel pathways. Research by Gross, Mishkin and colleagues,
integrating insights from lesion (Newcombe, 1969) and
anatomical studies (Schneider, 1969), showed that these
pathways emerge beyond the striate cortex with one in-
volved in the identification of objects projecting ventrally,
and the other involved in localization of objects, project-
ing to the parietal cortex (Gross & Mishkin, 1977; Mishkin,
Ungerleider, & Macko, 1983). From the start of the dual-
pathway theory, multiple pathways were believed to be
computationally efficient (Gross & Mishkin, 1977). Sup-
port for this idea comes from research using artificial net-
works with one hidden layer, showing that location and
identity are better learned when units in the hidden layers
are uniquely assigned to one of these functions (Rueckl,
Cave, & Kosslyn, 1989; Jacobs, Jordan, & Barto, 1991).
In the early nineties, Goodale & Milner argued that, on
the basis of neuropsychological, electrophysiological and
behavioural evidence, these pathways should be understood
as have different goals. The ventral pathway (vision for per-
ception) is involved in computing the transformations nec-
essary for the identification and recognition of objects. The
dorsal pathway (vision for action) is involved in sensorimo-
tor transformations for visually guided actions directed at
these objects (Goodale & Milner, 1992).
It was recently suggested that the brain uses a variety of
cost functions for learning (Marblestone, Wayne, & Kord-
ing, 2016). These cost functions can be highly diverse. The
brain must optimize a wide range of cost functions, such
as keeping body temperature constant or optimizing future
reward from social interactions. High-level cost functions,
by necessity, also shape other cost functions that determine
the organization of perception: a cost function that is being
optimized to minimize hunger affects the visual recognition
cost function as foods have to be recognized. Mechanis-
tically, this could take place directly through, for instance,
a reward modulation of object recognition learning, or indi-
rectly through evolutionary pressure on the cost function as-
sociated with object recognition learning. In this paper, we
try to understand how multiple pathways in the visual cor-
tex might evolve from the perspective of Deep Neural Net-
works (DNNs) (see box 1) and cost functions (see box 2),
and what this implies for how object information is stored
in these networks.
We start with a discussion of the relevance of DNNs
(LeCun, Bengio, & Hinton, 2015; Schmidhuber, 2015) and,
following Marblestone (Marblestone et al., 2016), of cost
functions for understanding the brain in section 2. We ex-
tend our discussion with the importance of optimizing dif-
ferent cost functions simultaneously, presenting a hypothe-
sis on the relationship between relatedness of tasks and the
degree of feature representation sharing.
We test this hypothesis in a computational experiment
with DNNs in section 3 to evaluate how much its feature
representations contribute to each task.
In section 4, we
discuss the degree to which we are able to translate our ex-
perimental findings to the division between the ventral and
dorsal pathway, the multiple functions of the ventral cor-
tex, and the apparent co-occurrence of both distributed and
modular representations related to object recognition.
We finish this paper with a discussion of how this frame-
work can be used experimentally to understand the human
brain while elaborating on the limitations of DNNs and cost
functions. For brevity, we do not consider models of re-
current processing.
2. Multi-task DNNs as models of neural infor-
mation processing in the brain
Artificial neural networks are inspired by computational
principles of biological neuronal networks and are part of
a large class of machine learning models that learn feature
representations from data by optimizing a cost function. In
this section, we discuss why we believe models based on
optimizing cost functions, such as DNNs, are relevant for
understanding brain function.
2.1. Similarities in architecture and behavior be-
tween DNNs and the brain
Alexnet (Krizhevsky, Sutskever, & Hinton, 2012), a
model that is has been used extensively in research relat-
ing DNN's to the brain, consists of 7 layers (see box 1).
The first layer consists of filters with small kernels that are
applied to each position of the input. In the subsequent four
layers this procedure is repeated using the output of the pre-
ceding layer. This results in an increase in receptive field
(RF) size and concurrently an increase in the specificity of
tuning (Zeiler & Fergus, 2014). This increase of receptive
field size and tuning specificity traversing the layers resem-
ble the general architecture of feed-forward visual repre-
sentations in the human brain (Lamme & Roelfsema, 2000;
DiCarlo, Zoccolan, & Rust, 2012).
A number of BOLD-MRI studies have revealed that
the neural activation's in early areas of visual cortex show
the best correspondence with the early layers of DNNs
and that higher-tier cortical areas show the best correspon-
dence with higher-tier DNN layers (Guc¸lu & van Gerven,
2015; Eickenberg, Gramfort, Varoquaux, & Thirion, 2017).
MEG/EEG studies have furthermore shown that early lay-
ers of DNNs have a peak explained variance that is earlier
than higher-tier DNN layers (Cichy, Khosla, Pantazis, Tor-
ralba, & Oliva, 2016; Ramakrishnan, Scholte, Smeulders,
& Ghebreab, 2016). In addition, the DNN model has been
shown to predict neural responses in IT, both from humans
and macaque, much better than any other computational
model (Khaligh-Razavi & Kriegeskorte, 2014; Yamins et
al., 2014).
A number of BOLD-MRI studies have revealed that the
neural activations in early areas of the visual cortex show
the best correspondence with the early layers of DNNs and
that higher-tier cortical areas show the best correspondence
with higher-tier DNN layers (Guc¸lu & van Gerven, 2015;
Eickenberg et al., 2017). MEG/EEG studies have further-
more shown that early layers of DNNs have a peak ex-
plained variance that is earlier than higher-tier DNN layers
(Cichy et al., 2016; Ramakrishnan et al., 2016). In addition,
the DNN model has been shown to predict neural responses
in IT, both from humans and macaque, much better than any
other computational model (Khaligh-Razavi & Kriegesko-
rte, 2014; Yamins et al., 2014).
The correspondence between DNNs and the brain begs
the question of the degree to which DNNs show behavior
similar to humans. Early results indicate that humans and
DNNs have a similar pattern of performance in terms of the
kinds of variation (size, rotation) that make object recog-
nition harder or simpler (Kheradpisheh, Ghodrati, Gan-
jtabesh, & Masquelier, 2016). It has also been shown that
higher-tier layers of DNNs follow human perceptual shape
similarity while the lower-tier layers strictly abide by phys-
ical similarity (Kubilius, Bracci, & Op de Beeck, 2016). On
the other hand, DNNs are, for instance, much more suscep-
tible to the addition of noise to input images than humans
(Jang, McCormack, & Tong, 2017) and the exact degree to
which the behavior of DNNs and humans overlap is cur-
rently a central topic of research.
As others (Kriegeskorte, 2015; Yamins & DiCarlo,
2016), we therefore believe that there is a strong case that
DNNs can serve as a model for information processing in
the brain. From this perspective, using DNNs to understand
the human brain and behavior is similar to using an animal
model. Like any model, it is a far cry from a perfect re-
flection of reality, but it is still useful, with unique possibili-
ties to yield insights in the computations underlying cortical
function.
2.2. Cost functions as a metric to optimize tasks
While deep neural networks offer the representational
power to learn features from data, the actual learning pro-
cess is guided by an objective that quantifies the perfor-
mance of the model for each input-output pair. Common
practice in machine learning is to express such an objec-
tive as a cost function (Domingos, 2012). As Marblestone
and colleagues argue, the human brain can be thought of
implementing something very similar to cost functions to
quantify the collective performance of neurons and conse-
quently to steer the learning of representations in a direction
that improves a global outcome (Marblestone et al., 2016).
2.3. Problem simplification by task decomposition
While humans may act under a grand evolutionary objec-
tive of staying alive long enough to reproduce, we accom-
plish many small-scale objectives along the way, like guid-
ing our arms to our mouth to eat or plan our path through
the city. Each of these smaller objectives can be thought
of as being governed by their own cost functions (see fig-
ure 1). These could be embedded in the brain, either hard
coded into the neural substrate by evolution, by sovereign
decision making, or as part of meta-learning: learning to
learn (Baxter, 1998).
While humans may act under a grand evolutionary objec-
tive of staying alive long enough to reproduce, we accom-
plish many small-scale objectives along the way, like guid-
ing our arms to our mouth to eat or plan our path through the
city. Each of these smaller objectives can be thought of as
being governed by their own cost functions (see figure 1).
These could be embedded in the brain, either hard-coded
into the neural substrate by evolution, by sovereign deci-
sion making, or as part of meta-learning: learning to learn
(Baxter, 1998).
It has been argued that a task becomes easier to solve
if it can be decomposed into simpler tasks (Jacobs et al.,
1991; Sutton, Precup, & Singh, 1999). To support their ar-
gument they state that the simple problem of learning the
absolute value function can be decomposed into learning
two linear functions and a switching function, which leads
to a model with fewer parameters that can be trained faster.
While such a decomposition could be predefined through
the neural substrate, they observe in their experiments that
such a decomposition can naturally arise from competitive
learning, if the same set of parameters are optimized for
multiple tasks. As the decomposition of tasks is underde-
termined, the learner may come up with different decompo-
sitions, each time it is trained.
The notion of decomposition has been frequently used
in machine learning literature on reinforcement learning
(Dietterich, 2000) to increase learning speed and enable the
learning of task-local optima that can be reused to learn a
superordinate goal. Very often it is even impossible to spec-
ify the objective for a complex task so that it is a neces-
sity to decompose it into tractable partial objectives. An
example is the objective of vision. Finding an objective for
such a broad and vague task appears futile so that it is eas-
ier to define a subset of tasks like figure ground segmen-
tation, saliency and boundaries. A noteworthy implemen-
tation of such a decomposition is the recent DNN Uber-
Net (Kokkinos, 2016), which solves 7 vision related tasks
(boundary, surface normals, saliency, semantic segmenta-
tion, semantic boundary and human parts detection) with
a single multi-scale DNN network to reduce the memory
footprint. It can be assumed that such a multi-task train-
ing improves convergence speed and better generalization
to unseen data, something that already has been observed
on other multi-task setups related to speech processing, vi-
sion and maze navigation (Dietterich, Hild, & Bakiri, 1990,
1995; Bilen & Vedaldi, 2016; Mirowski et al., 2016; Caru-
ana, 1998).
3. Functional organization in multi-task DNNs
One hypothesis for the emergence of different functional
pathways in the visual system is that learning and develop-
ment in the cortex is under pressure of multiple cost func-
tions induced by different objectives.
It has been argued
that the brain can recruit local populations of neurons to as-
sign local cost functions that enable fast updating of these
neurons (Marblestone et al., 2016). We explore in this sec-
tion the ramifications of multiple cost functions acting on
the same neurons by translating the problem to instances of
multi-task DNNs sharing the same parameters. By observ-
ing the contributions each feature representation in a DNN
has to each task, we will draw conclusions about the func-
tional separation we observe in the visual cortex in section
4.
3.1. Hypothesis
Given two cost functions that optimized two related
tasks, which both put pressure on the same set of parame-
ters, we conjecture that the parameters learned will be gen-
eral enough to be used for both tasks (see figure 2B). In con-
trast, we speculate that, when the tasks are unrelated, two
subsets of parameters will emerge during learning that each
lie within their task-respective feature domain (see figure
2C). Because the amount of feature representation sharing
is determined by the relation between tasks, and ultimately
by the statistics of the credit assignments, we predict an up-
per to lower tier gradient of feature representation sharing
with the least sharing in higher tier layers.
Box 1 Deep Neural Networks
Artificial neural networks refer to a large class of models loosely inspired by the way brain solves problems with a
large number of interconnected units (neurons). The basic computation of a neural network unit is a weighted sum of
incoming inputs followed by an activation function i.e a static non-linearity (Rumelhart, McClelland, Group, & Others,
1988).
Composing a network of many of these basic computational units in more than 3 layers results in what is usually
referred to as deep neural network (DNN). While the exact architecture of a DNN varies across applications, the one
we are focusing on is the convolutional DNN, specifically designed for inputs with high spatially-local correlation like
natural images. Convolution is hereby the process of applying a filter to each position in the image. In the first layer,
these filters are able to detect for instance edges and very simple shapes, but composing a hierarchy of these filters
allows for great compositional power to express complex features and is an important reason DNNs have proven to be
so successful.
As determining these filters by hand is practically impossible DNNs are trained by backpropagation (LeCun et al., 1989),
a standard machine learning optimization method based on gradient descent. Given a cost function that determines for
an input and an expected output a single error value, backpropagation allows to assign a credit to each single unit in the
network to specify how much it contributed to the error.
Recent state-of-the-art neural networks have increased depth, ranging from 16 (Simonyan & Zisserman, 2014) to 152
(He, Zhang, Ren, & Sun, 2015) layers (combined with some architectural advances). While the brain is clearly not
shallow, its depth is limited to substantially fewer computational layers considering feed-forward processing (Lamme
& Roelfsema, 2000). However, it has not yet been investigated how the layers of a very deep neural network map to the
human brain.
Figure Box.1. Essential architecture of DNN AlexNet and filter visualization. AlexNet consists of 5 convolutional layers repre-
sented by boxes and 3 fully connected layers of which the last is the output layer with 1000 units. The number of filters in a layer as
well as the filter dimension is noted under each box. Below are selected filters visualized to show the increasing complexity of features
they represent (adopted from Zeiler et al 2014).
Box 2 Cost Functions
A cost function maps a set of observable variables to a real value representing the 'loss of the system. Optimization then
aims to minimize this loss, for instance by changing tunable parameters θ in the system. While a cost function is defined
as the composition of mathematical operations, e.g. mean squared error, we expand the definition here to include the
set of observed variables. This allows us to regard two cost functions composed of the same mathematical operations as
distinct when the set of observed targets, in order to solve two different objectives, is different.
For a predictive brain in a moving organism, the system tries to optimize actions, and sequences thereof that minimize
one or more cost functions; these actions in turn are specified by a plethora of parameters, like synaptic efficacies and
hormone levels. It is these parameters that are adjusted to change the actions that the system takes in a given environment
to decrease the cost.
Mathematically, we can specify the collective sensory input into the brain at any point in time as S, and the joint output
of muscle tensions as O. A cost function maps the outputs O into a value, f (O), that is minimized by adjusting the
parameters θ: learning. Multiple cost functions arise naturally when different measured quantities are to be optimized:
if t = fthirst(O, Θ) corresponds to the degree of thirst, and the system also has to optimize financial welfare d =
ff w(O, Θ), the system has to find the optimum values of theta that maximize both functions. We can jointly optimize
these two cost functions by specifying a single combined cost function: G = ff w(O, θ) + λfthirst(O, θ), where λ is
a weight that measures the relative importance of the two cost functions. Such joint cost functions can be learned with
a single network, where the degree to which shared representations (in the form of shared learned features) help or hurt
with the optimization task is variable (Caruana, 1998). The shape of the cost has likely evolved such that they help make
most sense of our environment (Marblestone et al., 2016): a loss may measure the absolute deviation from some target
value, or the square of this difference, or any other mapping.
(cid:7578)1(cid:7578)2(cid:7578)3(cid:7578)4(cid:7578)596112563843842563333409640961000 Top-5-error
Subordinate-level
Ordinate-level/Text
recognition
recognition
Figure 1. Hierarchy of tasks related to the objectives the brain
has to accomplish. To make the evolutionary goal of Life
tractable, the brain must be able to decompose it into manageable
subtasks (blue and yellow arcs). All tasks and their cost functions
effectively act on the same set of parameters (gray semicircle),
while there may be differing degree of influence.
3.2. Training models for multiple tasks
We test this hypothesis on feature representation sharing
with DNNs trained for two tasks simultaneously. We con-
struct two example setups involving a pair of related tasks
(which we call RelNN), namely the simultaneous classifica-
tion of ordinate and subordinate categories of objects in im-
ages, and a pair of unrelated tasks (which we call UnrelNN)
namely the classification of objects and text labels in im-
ages (see figure 3). As the relatedness of tasks is not clearly
defined and an open problem (Caruana, 1998; Zhang & Ye-
ung, 2014), the tasks were selected based on the assumption
that text recognition in UnrelNN is mostly independent of
object recognition while in contrast ordinate level classifi-
cation in RelNN is highly dependent on the feature repre-
sentations formed for subordinate level classification.
Chance
RelNN
UnrelNN
97.9%
14.0%
15.2%
66.7%
2.9%
4.9%
Table 1. Classification errors. Comparison of the error rates of
RelNN and UnrelNN on a validation set of 11,800 images. The
Top-5-error is defined as the correct prediction not being under
the 5 most likely predictions. Both models were trained for 90
epochs until convergence with Nesterov accelerated gradient de-
scent (Nesterov, 1983) with momentum of 0.9, starting with a
learning rate of 0.01 and decreasing it every 30 epochs by a factor
of 10.
representation has to both tasks. Our method is inspired
by the attribute contribution decomposition by (Robnik-
Sikonja & Kononenko, 2008) which has recently been used
to visualize the inner workings of deep convolutional net-
works (Zintgraf, Cohen, Adel, & Welling, 2017). The
method is used to marginalize out features in the input im-
age in the shape of small image patches, to observe the im-
pact on the classification. In comparison, our method con-
siders feature representations instead of features as we are
not interested in the contribution of particular feature in-
stances. The interested reader is referred to appendix A for
the definition and derivation of the task contribution.
3.2.1 Training setup
3.2.3 Results
Both setups were implemented by training a version of
AlexNet (Krizhevsky et al., 2012) on approximately half a
million images from the ImageNet database (Russakovsky
et al., 2015) each 1. To optimize the models for two tasks
simultaneously, the output layer of AlexNet was split into
two independent layers. Both models were trained on an
identical set of images consisting of 15 ordinate classes fur-
ther divided into 234 subordinate classes, each image aug-
mented with an overlay of 3 letter labels from 15 different
classes (see figure 3a). The overlays were randomly scaled,
colored and positioned while ensuring that the text is con-
tained within the image boundaries. Furthermore to enable
the networks to classify two tasks at once, the output layer
was split in two independent layers (see figure 3b) for which
each had its own softmax activation. For classification per-
formance results see table 1.
3.2.2 Measuring feature representation contribution
To determine the degree of feature representation sharing in
a neural network we measure the contribution each feature
1The code, data and pretrained models are available here:
https://github.com/mlosch/FeatureSharing
We visualize the layer-wise task contributions by unrolling
the feature representations of a layer on a rectangle and col-
oring each resulting cell by the composition of its contri-
bution. Blue is used as indicator for the subordinate-level
recognition task and yellow as indicator for the text- and
basic-level-recognition task respectively. Equal contribu-
tion to both tasks results in grayish to white tones while
little contribution to either task causes dark to black tones
(see figure 4 for the color coding). A high degree of feature
representation sharing would hereby generate cells colored
in the range from black and gray to white, while low degree
of sharing would result in more pronounced and clearly dis-
tinguishable colors of yellow and blue.
The two visualizations in figure 4 show a substantial dif-
ference in feature representation contribution as the repre-
sentations in layer 2 to 5 of the RelNN contribute to both
tasks much more equally than the representations of the
UnrelNN. This is in line with our expectation depicted in
figure 2 and our choice of setups. Contrary to our predic-
tion, the degree of feature representation sharing in layer
1 of the UnrelNN is lower than expected; this can be ex-
plained by assuming that text recognition is mostly indepen-
dent of all features but horizontal and vertical lines. Note
𝜃LifeVisionActionMovementplanning Figure 2. Task relatedness and feature representation sharing in deep neural networks. Given a multi-layered neural network with
a set of feature representations θ (indicated by cells) that optimize differently related tasks, we conjecture that the degree to which repre-
sentations can be shared is dependent on the generalizability, which reduces with the depth of the network for single modality inputs. The
generalizability is indicated by the strength of the color. Gray tones indicate high generalizability, while strong colors indicate features
that are tuned to one respective cost function. A - Initial, untrained network configuration with 5 layers for a single modality input x.
Cost functions fA and fB have direct access to their respective parameters θA and θB. B - Two strongly related tasks inducing features
that are generalizable to both tasks. Little function-specificity identifiable. C - Two largely unrelated tasks. While early simple features
representations can be shared, intermediate and higher level representations are likely to be exclusive to their respective cost function due
to their task-specificity.
representation sharing in the RelNN consistent with the
idea that relatedness between tasks and therefore cost func-
tions strongly influences the degree of feature representa-
tion sharing across layers. More importantly, these results
demonstrate that these types of ideas can be translated, us-
ing the right image data-sets and task-labels, into quantifi-
able predictions on the degree of feature sharing that might
be observed in the brain.
4. Implications of models optimized for multi-
ple tasks for understanding the visual sys-
tem
In section 3 we presented an example in which the degree
to which feature representations can be shared in a neu-
ral network depended on the relatedness of the tasks they
are optimized for. In a neural population under pressure of
the optimization for two unrelated tasks and the pressure
to optimize the length of neuronal wiring (Chklovskii &
Koulakov, 2004), a spatial segregation is likely to occur, re-
sulting in anatomically and functionally separate pathways.
In this section we consider to what degree we can under-
stand the organization of the visual system from the per-
spective of a DNN that has been trained on multiple tasks
and discuss three hypotheses derived from the simulations.
4.1. The visual system optimizes two cost functions
of unrelated tasks
The early visual cortex has neurons that respond to prop-
erties such as orientation, wavelength, contrast, disparity
and movement direction that are relevant for a broad range
(a)
(b)
Figure 3. Multi-Task-Learning setup. (a) Two example images
and their corresponding classification for our example setups of
related and unrelated tasks. (b) To classify an input into two cat-
egories from different domains using AlexNet, the output layer is
split in two where each split has its own softmax activation layer.
also that most of the representations in the fully connected
layers in both setups have only little contribution. This
might seem counter-intuitive at first sight but is an effect of
the abundance of representations coupled with the training
scheme involving dropout. Dropout significantly reduces
co-dependencies between units (Dahl, Sainath, & Hinton,
2013) resulting in only small changes in classification prob-
ability after marginalizing out a single representation.
We also observe that there is a dominance of blue cells
expressing low contribution to the text- and basic-level-
recognition task but high contribution to the subordinate-
level-recognition task. We conjecture that this is because
the subordinate-level-recognition task uses a larger fraction
of units to distinguish between 200 classes.
Comparing the layers of both networks, it becomes ev-
ident that there generally is a higher degree of feature
(cid:7578)A(cid:7578)B(cid:6916)A ((cid:6933) ; (cid:7578),(cid:7578)A)(cid:6916)B ((cid:6933) ; (cid:7578),(cid:7578)B)(cid:6933)Features(cid:7578)1Features(cid:7578)2Features(cid:7578)3Features(cid:7578)4TrainingReorganization(cid:7578)A(cid:7578)B(cid:7578)A4(cid:7578)B4(cid:7578)A3(cid:7578)B3(cid:7578)A2(cid:7578)B2Shared features(cid:7578)1Features(cid:7578)1Features(cid:7578)2Features(cid:7578)3Features(cid:7578)4(cid:7578)A(cid:7578)B(cid:6916)A ((cid:6933) ; (cid:7578),(cid:7578)A)(cid:6916)B ((cid:6933) ; (cid:7578),(cid:7578)B)(cid:6933)ABC(cid:7578)A(cid:7578)B(cid:6916)A ((cid:6933) ; (cid:7578),(cid:7578)A)(cid:6916)B ((cid:6933) ; (cid:7578),(cid:7578)B)(cid:6933)Features(cid:7578)1Features(cid:7578)2Features(cid:7578)3Features(cid:7578)4TrainingReorganization(cid:7578)A(cid:7578)BShared features(cid:7578)1Shared features(cid:7578)2Shared features(cid:7578)3Shared features(cid:7578)4GoldfinchBirdElectric GuitarString Instrument(cid:6916)A(cid:6916)B(cid:6916)A(cid:6916)BText & Object recognitionBasic- & Subordinate object recognitionUnrelated TaskRelated TaskGoldfinchLipElectric GuitarElk(cid:6916)A(cid:6916)B(cid:6916)A(cid:6916)BRelatedUnrelatedFully connected Layer 7Output(cid:6916)A(x)(cid:6916)B(x) Figure 4. Composition of feature representation contribution in DNNs to dual task. (Best viewed in color) Each cell represents a
feature representation in a neural network and its contribution. Task description and color coding of the contributions are displayed in
the top left corner of each visualization. The cells are ordered by contribution magnitude of the yellow task so that the first cell in each
layer displays the representation that contributes the least. (a) Contributions to RelNN, subordinate- and ordinate-level-recognition. (b)
Contributions to UnrelNN, subordinate-level- and text-recognition.
Contribution to Subordinate-levelDepth96 Features25638438425640964096Contribution to Basic-levelContribution to Subordinate-levelDepth96 Features25638438425640964096Contribution to Text-recognition of visual tasks (Wandell, 1995). Moving upwards from
early cortex we see a gradual increase in the tuning speci-
ficity of neurons resulting in the dorsal and ventral pathways
that have, as has become clear the last 25 years, unrelated
goals (Goodale & Milner, 1992). The dorsal pathway ren-
ders the representation of objects invariant to eye-centered
transformations in a range of reference frames to allow ef-
ficient motor planning and control (Kakei, 1999), while the
ventral pathway harbors object-centered, transformation in-
variant features (Leibo, Liao, Anselmi, & Poggio, 2015;
Higgins et al., 2016) to allow efficient object recognition.
These observations concur well with the predictions and
experimental results we made about feature representation
sharing in DNNs. Given that the two tasks, vision for recog-
nition and vision for action, are mostly unrelated we can un-
derstand the gradual emergence of functional and anatomi-
cal separation between these systems from this perspective.
Nonetheless, we note that the functional units of the
pathways beyond the occipital lobe are not entirely sep-
arated and cross-talk does exist between these pathways
(McIntosh & Schenk, 2009; Farivar, 2009; de Haan &
Cowey, 2011; van Polanen & Davare, 2015): a phenomenon
we also observed in our experiment in section 3.
In the
UnrelNN, there are feature representations that contribute
to both tasks throughout all layers of the network. Conse-
quently the brain might trade off contribution and wiring
length so that neurons that contribute little are tolerable to
have long wiring to the functional epicentre.
As a whole the existence of two pathways guided by two
cost functions of unrelated tasks might be seen as an illus-
tration of the efficient decomposition of the overall vision
function.
4.2. The visual pathways contain further task de-
compositions each with their own cost func-
tions
We further generalize our perspective on cost function
optimization of the visual system via the general observa-
tion made from machine learning that a complex task be-
comes simpler to solve if it is decomposed into simpler
smaller tasks (see section 2.3). Given that the tasks we as-
sign to the visual pathways are rather complex and vague we
conjecture that there might be a broad range of cost func-
tions active in the pathway regions to optimally decompose
the task of vision resulting in a schematic similar to figure
5.
The ventral and dorsal pathways are each involved in a
multitude of tasks serving the overall goals of vision for
perception and vision for action. Examples of subordinate
tasks for vision for action are localization, distance, rela-
tive position, position in egocentric space and motion and
these interact with the goals that are part of vision for ac-
tion: pointing, grasping, self-termination movements, sac-
cades and smooth pursuit (de Haan & Cowey, 2011). Sub-
ordinate tasks for vision for perception include contour inte-
gration, processing of surface properties, shape discrimina-
tion, surface depth and surface segmentation. These in turn
interact with executing the goals that are part of vision for
perception: categorization and identification of object but
also scene understanding (Groen, Silson, & Baker, 2017).
Reasoning from this framework we can also understand
the existence of multiple processing streams within the dual
pathways. For instance, within ventral cortex there ap-
pears to be a pathway for object recognition and a path-
way for scene perception. The object recognition path-
way consists of areas like V4 which responds to simple
geometric shapes and the anterior part of inferior temporal
(aIT) that is sensitive for complete objects (Kravitz, Saleem,
Baker, Ungerleider, & Mishkin, 2013). The scene recogni-
tion pathway contains areas such as the occipital place area
(OPA), involved in the analyses of local scene elements and
the parahippocampal place area (PPA) which responds to
configurations of these elements (Kamps, Julian, Kubilius,
Kanwisher, & Dilks, 2016). The tasks of scene and ob-
ject perception are closely related; scenes consist of objects.
However, scene perception involves relating the positions of
multiple objects to each other, scene gist and navigability
(Groen et al., 2017). From our framework we would pre-
dict that an area like OPA is mainly involved in the task of
scene perception but has RFs that are also used for object
perception and the opposite pattern for V4. Crucially, we
believe this framework can be used to generate quantitative
predictions for this amount of sharing.
4.3. Distributed versus modal representations
How information is represented is one of the major ques-
tions in cognitive neuroscience. When considering object
based representations both distributed (Haxby et al., 2001;
Avidan & Behrmann, 2009) and module-based represen-
tations (Cohen, Dehaene, Naccache, Leh´ericy, & others,
2000; Kanwisher, 2000; Puce, Allison, Gore, & McCarthy,
1995) have been observed.
Module-based representations, and theories stressing
their importance, point to the existence of distinct cortical
modules specialized for the recognition of particular classes
such as words, faces and body parts. These modules encom-
pass different cortical areas and, in case of the fusiform face
area and visual word form area, even similar areas but in dif-
ferent hemispheres (Plaut & Behrmann, 2011). Conversely,
distributed theories of object recognition point to the pos-
sibility to decode information from a multitude of classes
from the patterns of activity present in a range of cortical
regions (Haxby et al., 2001; Avidan & Behrmann, 2009).
If we consider feature representations in the early and
intermediate layers of the UnrelNN (figure 4) as a reason-
able approximation of representations in early / intermedi-
Figure 5. How functional pathways in the visual system could be associated with cost functions. (Vision for perception pathway in
blue, vision for action pathway in yellow). Within the pathways are streams that develop under guidance from cost functions which are a
direct decomposition of the pathways cost function. Feature representations that are learned for one task can still be used by units in the
other pathway (crosstalk arrows). Both pathways share the same input units that either develop through the relation between tasks and/or
evolutionary or developmental learning.
ate visual areas, we note that most units are being shared
by both streams. However, some units contribute more to
one than the other task and are spatially intermingled at
the same time. An external observer, analyzing the activ-
ity of these representations under stimulation with pattern
analysis would conclude that information from both tasks is
present, and conclude that a distributed code is present. If
the same observer would investigate the representations at
the top of the stream the observer would conclude that there
is an area dedicated to the analysis of text and another to the
analysis of the subordinate task.
Translated to the visual system this would mean that dis-
tributed representations should be observed in areas such
as posterior inferior temporal (pIT), OPA and V4 because
these units are activated by multiple tasks but with a differ-
ent weighting. Vice versa, at the top of a pathway or stream
the network would show a strong module based pattern of
activation. In sum, multi-task DNNs provide a framework
in which we can potentially understand that both modal and
distributed representations can be observed experimentally
but suggest that the patterns of activity should be interpreted
as emerging from the network as a whole.
5. Discussion
Following Marblestone and colleagues (Marblestone et
al., 2016), and the strength of the similarities between
DNNs and the visual brain, we hypothesize that cost func-
tions, associated with different tasks, are a major driving
force for the emergence of different pathways.
A central insight from machine learning is that functions
become easier to learn when they are decomposed as a set of
unrelated subtasks. As a whole, the existence of two path-
ways guided by two cost functions of unrelated tasks might
be seen as an illustration of the efficient decomposition of
the overall vision function (Sutton et al., 1999). Observing
that DNNs decompose a problem in multiple steps, with the
earlier layers related to the input and later layers related to
outputs demanded for the task, we hypothesized that the de-
gree of feature representation sharing between tasks, will be
determined by the relatedness of the tasks with an upper-to-
lower tier gradient.
On this basis, we performed simulations that confirm that
units in a DNN show a strong degree of sharing when tasks
are strongly related and a separation between units when
tasks are unrelated. The degree to which this framework
will be useful depends on the degree to which understand-
ing elements of brain function using DNNs is valid which
is discussed in section 5.1 and 5.2. Subsequently, we will
argue that having multiple pathways within a multi-task net-
work might also help explaining catastrophic forgetting, the
phenomenon that an old task is overwritten by learning a
new task (section 5.3). Next, we will discuss the vision for
perception and vision for action framework (section 5.4),
and finally we discuss the possibilities of using multi-task
for further understanding the brain and ways in which our
current analysis approach can be extended (section 5.5).
5.1. The biological realism of machine learning
mechanisms
While there has been much progress in the field of Deep
Learning, it remains a question how and if the weights of
neurons are updated in learning under the supervision of
cost functions in the brain, that is, what the actual learning
rules of the brain are.
DNNs are trained using back-propagation, an algorithm
believed to miss a basis in biology (Crick, 1989; Stork,
Shared features for vision taskse.g. Gabor filtersPointingRelative positionsGrasping...Surface segmentationShape discriminationContour integration...fVisionfVision for actionfVision for perceptionDorsal pathwayVentral pathwaySpatial proximityShared features for "vision for action" taskse.g. eye centered transformationsShared features for "vision for perception" taskse.g. object centered transformationsCrosstalkfi+1fi+2fi+...fi+nfj+1fj+2fj+...fj+k 1989). Some of the criticisms include the use in backpropa-
gation of symmetrical weight for the forward inference and
backward error propagation phase, the relative paucity of
supervised signals and the clear and strong unsupervised
basis of much learning. Recent research has shown that
the symmetrical weight requirement is not a specific re-
quirement (Lillicrap, Cownden, Tweed, & Akerman, 2016).
Roelfsema & Van Ooyen already showed in (Roelfsema &
van Ooyen, 2005) that a activation feedback combined with
a broadly distributed, dopamine-like error-difference signal
can on average learn error-backpropagation in a reinforce-
ment learning setting. Alternative learning schemes, like
Equilibrium Propagation (Scellier & Bengio, 2017) have
also been shown to approximate error-backpropagation
while effectively implementing basic STDP rules.
Alternatively, effective deep neural networks could be
learned through combination of efficient unsupervised dis-
covery of structure and reinforcement learning. Recent
work on predictive coding suggests this might indeed be
feasible (Whittington & Bogacz, 2017). Still, the learning
rules that underpin deep learning in biological systems are
very much an open issue.
5.2. Cost functions as the main driver of functional
organization
Reviewing literature on the computational perspective
for functional regions in the visual system, we conclude
that each region might be ultimately traced back to being
under the influence of some cost function that the brain op-
timizes and its interplay or competition for neurons (Jacobs
et al., 1991) with other cost functions resulting in differ-
ent degrees of feature representation sharing. The domain-
specific regions in the ventral stream for example may be
caused by a cost function defined to optimize for invari-
ance towards class-specific transformations (Leibo et al.,
2015), of which the Fusiform Face Area could additionally
be bootstrapped from a rudimentary objective, hard coded
by genetics, to detect the pattern of two dots over a line
(McKone, Crookes, Jeffery, & Dilks, 2012; Marblestone et
al., 2016). Finally, as we argued in section 4, the functional
separation of the ventral and dorsal pathway can be associ-
ated with two cost functions as well. We emphasize that the
precise implementation of these cost functions is unknown
and note the concept of the task "vision for recognition" and
"vision for action" is merely a summary of all the subordi-
nate tasks that these two tasks have been decomposed into,
as argued in section 2.3 and the cost function box.
Reviewing literature on the computational perspective
for functional regions in the visual system, we conclude
that each region might be ultimately traced back to being
under the influence of some cost function that the brain op-
timizes and its interplay or competition for neurons (Jacobs
et al., 1991) with other cost functions resulting in differ-
ent degrees of feature representation sharing. The domain-
specific regions in the ventral stream for example may be
caused by a cost function defined to optimize for invari-
ance towards class-specific transformations (Leibo et al.,
2015), of which the Fusiform Face Area could additionally
be bootstrapped from a rudimentary objective, hard coded
by genetics, to detect the pattern of two dots over a line be-
ing the basic constellation of a face (McKone et al., 2012;
Marblestone et al., 2016). Finally, as we argued in section 4,
the functional separation of the ventral and dorsal pathway
can be associated with two cost functions as well. We em-
phasize that the precise implementation of these cost func-
tions is unknown and note the concept of the task vision for
recognition and vision for action is merely a summary of all
the subordinate tasks that these two tasks have been decom-
posed into, as argued in section 2.3 and the cost function
box.
5.3. Multiple pathways as a solution for catas-
trophic forgetting
While joint cost functions can be learned when the quan-
tities needed by the cost functions are all present at the same
time, most animals are continually learning and different as-
pects of cost functions are present at different times. Then,
it is well known that standard neural networks have great
difficulty learning a new task without forgetting an old task,
so-called catastrophic forgetting. Effectively, when train-
ing the network for the new task, the parameters that are
important for the old task are changed as well, with neg-
ative results. While very low learning rates, in combina-
tion with an alternating learning scheme, can mitigate this
problem to some degree, this is costly in terms of learn-
ing time. For essentially unmixed outputs, like controlling
body temperature and optimizing financial welfare, an easy
solution is to avoid shared parameters, resulting in sepa-
rate neural networks, or streams. Similarly, various prop-
erties can be derived from a single stream, like visual as-
pects (depth, figure-ground separation, segmentation), from
an object recognition stream, where each aspect substream
is learned via a separate cost function. For tasks sharing
outputs, and thus having overlap over different tasks, ev-
idence increasingly suggests that the brain selectively pro-
tects synapses for modification by new tasks, effectively un-
sharing these parameters between tasks (Kirkpatrick et al.,
2016).
5.4. What and where vs. vision for action and per-
ception
Goodale & Milner argued that the concept of a what and
where pathway should be replaced by the idea that there are
two pathways with different computational goals, vision for
perception and vision for action, summarized as a what and
how pathway (Goodale & Milner, 1992). Insights from the
last 25 years of research in vision science have shown that
the original idea of a what and where pathway lack explana-
tory power. It is clear that RFs in inferior temporal cortex
are large when objects are presented on a blank background
(Gross, Desimone, Albright, & Schwartz, 1985). However,
these become substantially smaller and thereby implicitly
contain positional information, when measured against a
natural scene background (Rolls, Aggelopoulos, & Zheng,
2003). Interestingly, studies on DNNs have shown that ap-
proximate object localization can be inferred from a CNN
trained on only classification, although the spatial extend of
an object cannot not be estimated (Oquab, Bottou, Laptev,
& Sivic, 2015).
With regards to the dorsal pathways it has been observed
that there are cells relating to gripping an object that are spe-
cific for object-classes (Brochier & Umilt`a, 2007) showing
that this pathway contains, in addition to positional infor-
mation, categorical information. These observations are in
direct opposition to one of the central assumptions, a strong
separation between identity and location processing, of the
what and where hypothesis. It is now abundantly clear that
the move from what and where pathway to what and how
pathways and moving from input to function fits particu-
larly well with vision as a multi-task DNN.
5.5. Future research
Originally DNNs were criticised for being black boxes,
and using DNNs to understand the brain would equate to
replacing one black box with another. Recent years have
shown a rapid increase in our understanding of what makes
a DNN work (LeCun et al., 2015; Simonyan & Zisserman,
2014; Zeiler & Fergus, 2014) and how to visualize the fea-
tures (Zintgraf et al., 2017; Zhou, Khosla, Lapedriza, Oliva,
& Torralba, 2014; Zeiler & Fergus, 2014) that give DNNs
its power.
These developments illustrate that DNNs are rapidly be-
coming more gray boxes, and are therefore a promising av-
enue into increasing our understanding of the architecture
and computations used by the visual system and brain.
We therefore believe it is sensible to investigate to which
degree multi-task DNNs, trained using the same input, will
allow us to understand the functional organisation of the vi-
sual system. Using the analytical framework introduced in
section 3, we can generate a fingerprint for each of the lay-
ers in a network based on the degree of feature representa-
tion sharing. This can be subsequently related to the activa-
tion patterns, evoked by different tasks observed within dif-
ferent cortical areas. Alternatively it is possible to compare
representational dissimilarity matrices (Kriegeskorte, Mur,
& Bandettini, 2008) obtained from single and multitask-
DNNs and determine which better explain RDMs obtained
from cortical areas.
An open question remains how subtasks and their
are
functions
learned from overall
associated cost
goals/general cost functions, both in machine learning
(Lakshminarayanan, Krishnamurthy, Kumar, & Ravindran,
2016) and in neuroscience (Marblestone et al., 2016;
Botvinick, Niv, & Barto, 2009).
Acknowledgements
MML is supported by a grant from the ABC, KR is sup-
ported by a grant from COMMIT and EHFdH by an ERC
(339374 - FAB4V).
References
Avidan, G., & Behrmann, M.
(2009, 14 July). Func-
tional MRI reveals compromised neural integrity of
the face processing network in congenital prosopag-
nosia. Curr. Biol., 19(13), 1146–1150.
Baxter, J. (1998). Theoretical models of learning to learn.
In Learning to learn (pp. 71–94).
Bilen, H., & Vedaldi, A. (2016). Integrated perception with
recurrent multi-task neural networks. In D. D. Lee,
M. Sugiyama, U. V. Luxburg, I. Guyon, & R. Gar-
nett (Eds.), Advances in neural information process-
ing systems 29 (pp. 235–243). Curran Associates,
Inc.
Botvinick, M. M., Niv, Y., & Barto, A. C. (2009, Decem-
ber). Hierarchically organized behavior and its neu-
ral foundations: a reinforcement learning perspective.
Cognition, 113(3), 262–280.
Brochier, T., & Umilt`a, M. A. (2007, December). Cortical
control of grasp in non-human primates. Curr. Opin.
Neurobiol., 17(6), 637–643.
Caruana, R.
(1998). Multitask learning.
In S. Thrun
& L. Pratt (Eds.), Learning to learn (pp. 95–133).
Springer US.
Chklovskii, D. B., & Koulakov, A. A.
(2004). Maps in
the brain: what can we learn from them? Annu. Rev.
Neurosci., 27, 369–392.
Cichy, R. M., Khosla, A., Pantazis, D., Torralba, A., &
Oliva, A. (2016, 10 June). Comparison of deep neu-
ral networks to spatio-temporal cortical dynamics of
human visual object recognition reveals hierarchical
correspondence. Sci. Rep., 6, 27755.
Cohen, L., Dehaene, S., Naccache, L., Leh´ericy, S., & oth-
(2000). The visual word form area. Brain,
ers.
123(2), 291–307.
Crick, F. (1989, 12 January). The recent excitement about
neural networks. Nature, 337(6203), 129–132.
Dahl, G. E., Sainath, T. N., & Hinton, G. E. (2013). Improv-
ing deep neural networks for LVCSR using rectified
linear units and dropout. In 2013 IEEE international
conference on acoustics, speech and signal process-
ing.
de Haan, E. H. F., & Cowey, A. (2011, October). On the
usefulness of 'what' and 'where' pathways in vision.
Trends Cogn. Sci., 15(10), 460–466.
DiCarlo, J. J., Zoccolan, D., & Rust, N. C. (2012, 9 Febru-
ary). How does the brain solve visual object recogni-
tion? Neuron, 73(3), 415–434.
Dietterich, T. G. (2000). Hierarchical reinforcement learn-
ing with the MAXQ value function decomposition. J.
Artif. Intell. Res., 13, 227–303.
Dietterich, T. G., Hild, H., & Bakiri, G. (1990). A compar-
ative study of ID3 and backpropagation for english
Text-to-Speech mapping. In Machine learning pro-
ceedings 1990 (pp. 24–31).
Dietterich, T. G., Hild, H., & Bakiri, G. (1995). A compar-
ison of ID3 and backpropagation for english text-to-
speech mapping. Mach. Learn., 18(1), 51–80.
Domingos, P. (2012, October). A few useful things to know
about machine learning. Commun. ACM, 55(10), 78–
87.
Eickenberg, M., Gramfort, A., Varoquaux, G., & Thirion, B.
(2017, 15 May). Seeing it all: Convolutional network
layers map the function of the human visual system.
Neuroimage, 152, 184–194.
Farivar, R. (2009, October). Dorsal-ventral integration in
object recognition. Brain Res. Rev., 61(2), 144–153.
Goodale, M. A., & Milner, A. D. (1992, January). Separate
visual pathways for perception and action. Trends
Neurosci., 15(1), 20–25.
Groen, I. I. A., Silson, E. H., & Baker, C. I. (2017). Con-
tributions of low-and high-level properties to neu-
ral processing of visual scenes in the human brain.
Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B Biol. Sci., 372(1714),
20160102.
(1985).
Gross, C. G., Desimone, R., Albright, T. D., & Schwartz,
Inferior temporal cortex and pattern
E. L.
recognition.
In C. Chagas, R. Gattass, & C. Gross
(Eds.), Pattern recognition mechanisms (pp. 179–
201). Springer-Verlag.
Gross, C. G., & Mishkin, M.
(1977). The neural basis
of stimulus equivalence across retinal translation. In
S. Harnad, R. W. Doty, L. Goldstein, J. Jaynes, &
G. Krauthamer (Eds.), Lateralization in the nervous
system (pp. 109–122). Academic Press.
Guc¸lu, U., & van Gerven, M. A. J. (2015, 8 July). Deep
neural networks reveal a gradient in the complexity
of neural representations across the ventral stream. J.
Neurosci., 35(27), 10005–10014.
Haxby, J. V., Gobbini, M. I., Furey, M. L., Ishai, A.,
Schouten, J. L., & Pietrini, P.
(2001, 28 Septem-
ber). Distributed and overlapping representations of
faces and objects in ventral temporal cortex. Science,
293(5539), 2425–2430.
He, K., Zhang, X., Ren, S., & Sun, J.
(2015). Delving
deep into rectifiers: Surpassing human-level perfor-
mance on imagenet classification. In Proceedings of
the IEEE international conference on computer vi-
sion (pp. 1026–1034).
Higgins, I., Matthey, L., Glorot, X., Pal, A., Uria, B., Blun-
dell, C., . . . Lerchner, A. (2016, 17 June). Early vi-
sual concept learning with unsupervised deep learn-
ing.
Jacobs, R. A., Jordan, M. I., & Barto, A. G. (1991). Task de-
composition through competition in a modular con-
nectionist architecture: The what and where vision
tasks. Cogn. Sci., 15(2), 219–250.
Jang, H., McCormack, D., & Tong, F. (2017). Evaluating
the robustness of object recognition to visual noise in
In Journal of
humans and convolutional networks.
vision.
Kakei, S. (1999). Muscle and movement representations in
the primary motor cortex. Science, 285(5436), 2136–
2139.
Kamps, F. S., Julian, J. B., Kubilius, J., Kanwisher, N., &
Dilks, D. D. (2016, 15 May). The occipital place area
represents the local elements of scenes. Neuroimage,
132, 417–424.
Kanwisher, N. (2000, August). Domain specificity in face
perception. Nat. Neurosci., 3(8), 759–763.
Khaligh-Razavi, S.-M., & Kriegeskorte, N.
(2014,
6 November). Deep supervised, but not unsupervised,
models may explain IT cortical representation. PLoS
Comput. Biol., 10(11), e1003915.
Kheradpisheh, S. R., Ghodrati, M., Ganjtabesh, M., &
Masquelier, T. (2016, 21 April). Humans and deep
networks largely agree on which kinds of variation
make object recognition harder.
Kirkpatrick, J., Pascanu, R., Rabinowitz, N., Veness, J.,
Desjardins, G., Rusu, A. A., . . . Hadsell, R. (2016,
2 December). Overcoming catastrophic forgetting in
neural networks.
Kokkinos, I.
(2016, 7 September). UberNet: Training
a 'universal' convolutional neural network for low-
, mid-, and High-Level vision using diverse datasets
and limited memory.
Kravitz, D. J., Saleem, K. S., Baker, C. I., Ungerleider,
L. G., & Mishkin, M. (2013, January). The ventral
visual pathway: an expanded neural framework for
the processing of object quality. Trends Cogn. Sci.,
17(1), 26–49.
Kriegeskorte, N.
(2015). Deep neural networks: A new
framework for modeling biological vision and brain
information processing. Annual Review of Vision Sci-
ence, 1(1), 417–446.
Kriegeskorte, N., Mur, M., & Bandettini, P.
(2008,
24 November). Representational similarity analysis
- connecting the branches of systems neuroscience.
Front. Syst. Neurosci., 2, 4.
Krizhevsky, A., Sutskever, I., & Hinton, G. E. (2012). Im-
ageNet classification with deep convolutional neural
networks. In F. Pereira, C. J. C. Burges, L. Bottou, &
K. Q. Weinberger (Eds.), Advances in neural infor-
mation processing systems 25 (pp. 1097–1105). Cur-
ran Associates, Inc.
Kubilius, J., Bracci, S., & Op de Beeck, H. P. (2016, April).
Deep neural networks as a computational model for
human shape sensitivity. PLoS Comput. Biol., 12(4),
e1004896.
Lakshminarayanan, A., Krishnamurthy, R., Kumar, P., &
Ravindran, B.
(2016). Option discovery in hierar-
chical reinforcement learning using Spatio-Temporal
clustering. arXiv preprint arXiv:1605. 05359.
Lamme, V. A., & Roelfsema, P. R. (2000, November). The
distinct modes of vision offered by feedforward and
recurrent processing. Trends Neurosci., 23(11), 571–
579.
LeCun, Y., Bengio, Y., & Hinton, G. (2015, 28 May). Deep
learning. Nature, 521(7553), 436–444.
LeCun, Y., Boser, B., Denker, J. S., Henderson, D., Howard,
R. E., Hubbard, W., & Jackel, L. D. (1989). Back-
propagation applied to handwritten zip code recogni-
tion. Neural Comput., 1(4), 541–551.
Leibo, J. Z., Liao, Q., Anselmi, F., & Poggio, T. (2015, Oc-
tober). The invariance hypothesis implies Domain-
Specific regions in visual cortex. PLoS Comput. Biol.,
11(10), e1004390.
Lillicrap, T. P., Cownden, D., Tweed, D. B., & Akerman,
C. J. (2016, 8 November). Random synaptic feed-
back weights support error backpropagation for deep
learning. Nat. Commun., 7, 13276.
Marblestone, A. H., Wayne, G., & Kording, K. P. (2016,
14 September). Toward an integration of deep learn-
ing and neuroscience. Front. Comput. Neurosci., 10,
94.
McIntosh, R. D., & Schenk, T.
(2009, May). Two vi-
sual streams for perception and action: current trends.
Neuropsychologia, 47(6), 1391–1396.
McKone, E., Crookes, K., Jeffery, L., & Dilks, D. D.
(2012). A critical review of the development of face
recognition: Experience is less important than previ-
ously believed. Cogn. Neuropsychol., 29(1-2), 174–
212.
Mirowski, P., Pascanu, R., Viola, F., Soyer, H., Ballard,
A. J., Banino, A., . . . Hadsell, R. (2016, 11 Novem-
ber). Learning to navigate in complex environments.
Mishkin, M., Ungerleider, L. G., & Macko, K. A. (1983).
Object vision and spatial vision: two cortical path-
ways. Trends Neurosci., 6, 414–417.
Nesterov, Y. (1983). A method of solving a convex pro-
gramming problem with convergence rate O (1/k2).
Soviet Mathematics Doklady, 27(2).
Newcombe, F. (1969). Missile wounds of the brain: A study
of psychological deficits. Oxford University Press,
London.
Oquab, M., Bottou, L., Laptev, I., & Sivic, J. (2015). Is ob-
ject localization for free? - weakly-supervised learn-
ing with convolutional neural networks. In IEEE con-
ference on computer vision and pattern recognition
(pp. 685–694). IEEE.
Plaut, D. C., & Behrmann, M.
(2011, May). Comple-
mentary neural representations for faces and words:
a computational exploration. Cogn. Neuropsychol.,
28(3-4), 251–275.
Puce, A., Allison, T., Gore, J. C., & McCarthy, G. (1995,
September). Face-sensitive regions in human extras-
triate cortex studied by functional MRI. J. Neuro-
physiol., 74(3), 1192–1199.
Ramakrishnan, K., Scholte, H. S., Smeulders, A., & Ghe-
breab, S.
(2016, 31 August). Mapping human vi-
sual representations by deep neural networks. J. Vis.,
16(12), 373–373.
Robnik-Sikonja, M., & Kononenko, I. (2008). Explaining
classifications for individual instances. IEEE Trans.
Knowl. Data Eng., 20(5), 589–600.
Roelfsema, P. R., & van Ooyen, A.
(2005, October).
Attention-gated reinforcement learning of internal
representations for classification. Neural Comput.,
17(10), 2176–2214.
Rolls, E. T., Aggelopoulos, N. C., & Zheng, F. (2003, 1 Jan-
uary). The receptive fields of inferior temporal cortex
neurons in natural scenes. J. Neurosci., 23(1), 339–
348.
Rueckl, J. G., Cave, K. R., & Kosslyn, S. M. (1989). Why
are "what" and "where" processed by separate corti-
cal visual systems? a computational investigation. J.
Cogn. Neurosci., 1(2), 171–186.
Rumelhart, D. E., McClelland, J. L., Group, P. R., & Oth-
ers. (1988). Parallel distributed processing (Vol. 1).
IEEE.
Russakovsky, O., Deng, J., Su, H., Krause, J., Satheesh, S.,
Ma, S., . . . Fei-Fei, L.
Ima-
geNet large scale visual recognition challenge. Int. J.
Comput. Vis., 115(3), 211–252.
(2015, 1 December).
Scellier, B., & Bengio, Y. (2017, 4 May). Equilibrium prop-
agation: Bridging the gap between Energy-Based
models and backpropagation. Front. Comput. Neu-
rosci., 11, 24.
Schmidhuber, J. (2015, January). Deep learning in neural
networks: an overview. Neural Netw., 61, 85–117.
Schneider, G. E. (1969, 28 February). Two visual systems.
Science, 163(3870), 895–902.
Simonyan, K., & Zisserman, A. (2014, 4 September). Very
deep convolutional networks for Large-Scale image
Sutton, R. S., Precup, D., & Singh, S.
Stork. (1989). Is backpropagation biologically plausible?
In International joint conference on neural networks.
(1999). Between
MDPs and semi-MDPs: A framework for temporal
abstraction in reinforcement learning. Artif. Intell.,
112(1–2), 181–211.
van Polanen, V., & Davare, M. (2015, December). Inter-
actions between dorsal and ventral streams for con-
trolling skilled grasp. Neuropsychologia, 79(Pt B),
186–191.
Wandell, B. A. (1995). Foundations of vision. Sunderland:
Sinauer Associates.
Whittington, J. C. R., & Bogacz, R. (2017, May). An ap-
proximation of the error backpropagation algorithm
in a predictive coding network with local hebbian
synaptic plasticity. Neural Comput., 29(5), 1229–
1262.
Yamins, D. L. K., & DiCarlo, J. J. (2016, March). Using
goal-driven deep learning models to understand sen-
sory cortex. Nat. Neurosci., 19(3), 356–365.
Yamins, D. L. K., Hong, H., Cadieu, C. F., Solomon,
E. A., Seibert, D., & DiCarlo, J. J. (2014, 10 June).
Performance-optimized hierarchical models predict
neural responses in higher visual cortex. Proc. Natl.
Acad. Sci. U. S. A., 111(23), 8619–8624.
recognition.
Zeiler, M. D., & Fergus, R.
(2014, 6 September). Vi-
sualizing and understanding convolutional networks.
In D. Fleet, T. Pajdla, B. Schiele, & T. Tuytelaars
(Eds.), Computer vision – ECCV 2014 (pp. 818–833).
Springer International Publishing.
Zhang, Y., & Yeung, D.-Y.
(2014). A regularization
approach to learning task relationships in multitask
learning. ACM Trans. Knowl. Discov. Data, 8(3), 1–
31.
Zhou, B., Khosla, A., Lapedriza, A., Oliva, A., & Torralba,
A. (2014, 22 December). Object detectors emerge in
deep scene CNNs.
Zintgraf, L. M., Cohen, T. S., Adel, T., & Welling, M.
(2017, February). Visualizing Deep Neural Network
Decisions: Prediction Difference Analysis. ArXiv e-
prints.
A. Measuring parameter contribution
A.1. Marginalization of parameters
(cid:88)
In models that are able to handle the lack of informa-
tion about a particular representation like in naıve Bayesian
classifiers, the contribution can be measured by marking the
representation as unknown. Typically though, neural net-
works are not able to handle missing information and setting
the parameters of a representation to zero will still result in
interpretable information for subsequent layers. While re-
moving a feature representation and retraining the network
would alleviate this issue, quantifying the contribution of
thousands of representations this way is generally unfeasi-
ble. Instead we make use of the models classification proba-
bilities given by the softmax activation output which allows
us to estimate the classification probability while lacking a
representation by marginalizing it out via standard method
from statistics. Marginalization effectively computes the
weighted average of the classification probabilities after the
representation has been replaced with random values sam-
pled from an appropriate distribution. See equation 1 for
the mathematical definition used for our evaluation.
p(yx, Θ\θ) =
p(yx, Θ)p(θ)
(1)
θ
p(yx, Θ) defines here the probability of input x belonging
to class y and p(yx, Θ\θ) the probability if θ is unknown.
Note that a feature representation is represented by its pa-
rameters θ, which in turn consists classically of a weight w
and a potential bias b in a neural network setting. Θ de-
fines then the set of all parameters such that θ ∈ Θ. Each
classification probability is eventually weighted by the prior
probability of the sample θ expressing the likelihood the pa-
rameter in question takes value θ. We used 100 samples in
our experiments to approximate the contribution.
A.1.1 Derivation
Given a parametric model like a DNN that is described by
its parameters Θ, we can express the probability of input
x belonging to class y as p(yx, Θ), where the probabili-
ties are given by the softmax output layer. To measure the
contribution of a feature generated by parameter θ ∈ Θ,
we are interested in what the probability is when θ is miss-
ing or unknown. By assuming that the input is indepen-
dent of the parameters as well as the parameters are inde-
pendent of each other, such that p(x, Θ) = p(x)p(Θ) and
p(Θ) = p(Θ\θ)p(θ) and by treating the parameters as ran-
dom variables we can marginalize out θ as follows.
(cid:82)
(cid:82)
(cid:82)
θ p(y, x, Θ)dθ
θ p(x, Θ)dθ
θ p(yx, Θ)p(x, Θ\θ)p(θ)dθ
(cid:90)
p(x, Θ\θ)(cid:82)
θ p(θ)dθ
p(yx, Θ)p(θ)dθ
θ
p(yx, Θ\θ) =
=
=
(2)
(3)
(4)
(cid:88)
As the integral over all possible values of θ is intractable for
DNN-like structures, we instead approximate the probabil-
ity by sampling from θ a finite number of times. We can
now express the upper equation with a sum over all samples
of θ.
p(yx, Θ\θ) =
p(yx, Θ)p(θ)
(5)
θ
To sample from θ, we assume that the values are normal
distributed with uniform variance and mean centered at the
learned weight w and bias b:
θ ∼ N (µ = w, Σ = I),N (µ = b, Σ = I) (6)
so that p(θ) = pN (w,I)(w) · pN (b,I)(b)
(7)
A.2. Generalizing contributions from classes to
tasks
As proposed by (Robnik-Sikonja & Kononenko, 2008),
we use the weighted evidence (W E) to measure the con-
tribution of parameter towards class probability p(yx, Θ)
(see equation A.6) instead of taking the difference of prob-
abilities directly. W Eθ(yx, Θ) gives us a positive value
indicating θ adds evidence for class y for input x, while a
negative value adds evidence against class y and zero if θ
has no contribution at all. To eventually determine the con-
tribution towards a class independent of the input we calcu-
late the arithmetic mean of the absolute weighted evidence
over more than 500 input samples (see equation 10) from
the test set.
odds(z) =
p(z)
1 − p(z)
W Eθ(yx, Θ) = log2(odds(yx, Θ))
− log2(odds(yx, Θ\θ))
W Eθ(yxj, Θ)
Cθ(yΘ) =
n(cid:88)
1
n
j=1
(8)
(9)
(10)
We finally measure the contribution to a task t by selecting
the contributions Cθ(yΘ) that satisfy y = ytrue which are
the class predictions that are correct. Furthermore filtering
out predictions that had been incorrectly inferred from the
network, we can increase certainty that the inputs used to
evaluate the contributions lead to high probability for the
correct class and low everywhere else. We further gener-
alize the contribution of θ to task t by averaging over the
contributions to each class yk within task t (see equation
11).
1
K
T Cθ(tΘ) =
Cθ(ykΘ)
t ∈ T asks, K ∈ outputst
K(cid:88)
k=1
(11)
|
1703.05917 | 3 | 1703 | 2017-08-07T21:59:34 | Autocatalytic networks in cognition and the origin of culture | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | It has been proposed that cultural evolution was made possible by a cognitive transition brought about by onset of the capacity for self-triggered recall and rehearsal. Here we develop a novel idea that models of collectively autocatalytic networks, developed for understanding the origin and organization of life, may also help explain the origin of the kind of cognitive structure that makes cultural evolution possible. In our setting, mental representations (for example, memories, concepts, ideas) play the role of 'molecules', and 'reactions' involve the evoking of one representation by another through remindings, associations, and stimuli. In the 'episodic mind', representations are so coarse-grained (encode too few properties) that such reactions are catalyzed only by external stimuli. As cranial capacity increased, representations became more fine-grained (encoded more features), allowing them to act as catalysts, leading to streams of thought. At this point, the mind could combine representations and adapt them to specific needs and situations, and thereby contribute to cultural evolution. In this paper, we propose and study a simple and explicit cognitive model that gives rise naturally to autocatylatic networks, and thereby provides a possible mechanism for the transition from a pre-cultural episodic mind to a mimetic mind. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Autocatalytic networks in cognition and the origin of
culture
Liane Gabora and Mike Steel
Abstract
It has been proposed that cultural evolution was made possible by a cogni-
tive transition brought about by onset of the capacity for self-triggered recall
and rehearsal. Here we develop a novel idea that models of collectively auto-
catalytic networks, developed for understanding the origin and organization
of life, may also help explain the origin of the kind of cognitive structure
that makes cultural evolution possible. In this setting, mental representa-
tions (for example, memories, concepts, ideas) play the role of 'molecules',
and 'reactions' involve the evoking of one representation by another through
remindings and associations. In the 'episodic mind', representations are so
coarse-grained (encode too few properties) that such reactions must be 'cat-
alyzed' by external stimuli. As cranial capacity increased, representations
became more fine-grained (encoded more features), which facilitated recur-
sive catalysis and culminated in free-association and streams of thought. At
this point, the mind could combine representations and adapt them to spe-
cific needs and situations, and thereby contribute to cultural evolution. In
this paper, we propose and study a simple and explicit cognitive model that
gives rise naturally to autocatylatic networks, and thereby provides a possible
mechanism for the transition from a pre-cultural episodic mind to a mimetic
mind.
Affiliations: [LG] Department of Psychology, University of British Colombia,
Okanagan Campus, Kelowna BC, Canada;
[MS] Biomathematics Resarch Centre, University of Canterbury, Christchurch,
New Zealand (corresponding author).
Email: [email protected], [email protected]
Keywords: autocatalytic network, conceptual closure, episodic, mimetic, rep-
resentational redescription, stream of thought
Preprint submitted to Elsevier
today
1. Introduction
We are surrounded by evidence of a cultural evolution process that is
cumulative (new ideas build on old ones), and open-ended (there is no a
priori limit on the generation of novelty). By 'culture' we refer to extra-
somatic adaptations -- including behavior and technology -- that are socially
rather than sexually transmitted.
In order to contribute in a meaningful
and reliable way to cultural evolution, one must be able to develop and re-
fine ideas by thinking them through (i.e., engage in a stream of abstract
thought). Since the capacity for a stream of thought is not specific to a par-
ticular domain of knowledge or cognitive process, the origins of this capacity
are not straightforwardly traced to a particular area or even neural circuit
of the brain. We could possess all the relevant neuroscientific data, as well
as the relevant archaeological and anthropological data, yet still not under-
stand how the human mind became able to evolve culture. Data alone are
insufficient to explain this; what is needed here is a theory.
Once humans could engage in abstract thought, we could combine con-
cepts, draw analogies, look at situations from different perspectives, modify
plans according to unforeseen circumstances, and adapt ideas to new con-
ditions, tastes, and desires.
In other words, abstract thought enabled us
to modify mental representations in light of one another, and thereby 're-
shape' our web of understandings as a whole. However, to engage in abstract
thought requires that these representations be within reach of one another
(i.e., they must already be somehow related to one another in our mind).
Thus, in attempting to formally model the conditions for the emergence of
cultural evolution, we are faced with the problem of explaining how a com-
plex system composed of mutually dependent parts could come into existence.
Which came first: the associative links between mental representations (i.e.,
the 'tracks' that a 'train of thought' runs on)? Or did trains of thought
cement the connections from one rung (i.e., one mental representation) to
the next? We have a 'chicken and egg problem'. In short, the answer to the
question of how we arrived at the capacity for a stream of thought is related
to the question of how we acquired an integrated web of understandings, and
how this came about is not straightforward.
Theories of how life began also face a 'chicken and egg' problem as to
how a self-replicating structure composed of mutually dependent parts could
come into existence. The improbability that such a structure could come
about spontaneously has led to widespread support for the hypothesis that
2
the earliest forms of life were autocatalytic molecular networks that evolved
in a relatively haphazard manner without an explicit self-assembly code,
through a non-Darwinian process involving self-organization and horizontal
(lateral) transfer of innovation protocols (Farmer et al., 1986; Gabora, 2006;
Kauffman, 1993; New and Pohorille, 2000; Segre, 2000; Vetsigian et al., 2006;
Wachtershauser, 1997). Kauffman (1993) showed that when polymers inter-
act, their diversity increases, and so does the probability that some subset
of the total reaches a critical point where there is a catalytic pathway to ev-
ery member, a state Kauffman referred to as autocatalytic closure. Although
the term 'closure' has several different meanings in mathematics, and it is
sometimes used to mean a condition that bounds or limits the set, Kauffman
(following in the footsteps of Erdos and R´enyi (1960)) used the term to ex-
press the property that the set surpassed a threshold density of connectedness
by way of catalysis events. Thus, many closed sets within a system can exist,
and they can become larger by combining together or through the introduc-
tion of new items. Kauffman showed that autocatalytic sets emerge for a
wide range of hypothetical chemistries (i.e., different collections of catalytic
molecules).
This paper explores the feasibility of adapting a generalized autocatalytic
approach to model the emergence of the kind of cognitive structure necessary
for complex culture. In other words, we draw upon a body of work developed
to model the origin of life to model the transition to the kind of cognitive
structure responsible for the origins of cultural evolution. While this paper is
not the first to broaden the concept of 'catalysis' and apply it in a cognitive
context (see, for example, Gabora (1998, 2013); Cabell and Valsiner (2014)),
here we build on these efforts to develop a more formal model that allows for
analysis and predictions.
1.1. Comparison of origins of biological and cultural evolution
Although the origin of the kind of chemical structure necessary for biolog-
ical evolution, and the origin of the kind of cognitive structure necessary for
cultural evolution would appear superficially to be two very different prob-
lems, at a formal, algorithmic level they share a common deep structure.
They both involves processes in which elements interact, generally referred
to as reactions, resulting in element transformation. In the case of the be-
ginnings of biological evolution and the origin of life (OOL), the elements
are catalytic molecules. In the case of the beginnings of cultural evolution
and the origin of complex cognition (OOC), the elements participating in
3
'reactions' are thoughts, memories, concepts, ideas, and chunks of knowledge
encoded in memory which are referred to collectively as mental representa-
tions, or MRs. We use the term mental representation in what philosophers
refer to as the 'weak sense', in that we do not aim to provide a theory of
consciousness. In this paper, the term 'reaction' will be used to refer to the
process in which two or more MRs interact and at least one of them changes
as a result. Although this paper does not delve into the mechanisms un-
derlying this cognitive form of reactivity, we believe it arises due to overlap
of receptive fields in distributed, content-addressable representations, as dis-
cussed in detail elsewhere (Gabora (2002b, 2010, 2018b); Gabora and Ranjan
(2013)). The term 'reactant' will be used to refer to the MRs participating
in such a reaction.
It is useful to distinguish between externally-driven and internally-driven
reactions. In the OOC case, we use the term learning to refer to the cognitive
process of revising a MR on the basis of new external input from the environ-
ment. We use the term reflection to refer to a cognitive process of revising a
MR on the basis of internal input from the mind. The mapping of the basic
elements of OOL scenario to the OOC scenario is summarized in Table 1. In
both the OOL and the OOC, certain elements, referred to as catalysts, speed
up or help certain reactions along. In the OOL these elements are catalytic
molecules, and in the OOC they are catalytic MRs.
Component
Food set
Reactants
Products
Reactions
Catalysts
Autocatalytic sets
OOL
original polymers
polymers
polymers
ligation and cleavage
polymers
chemical RAFs
OOC
innate concepts
mental representations
mental representations
learning and reflection
stimuli and catalytic mental representations
cognitive RAFs
Table 1. Comparison of the basic components of the two evolutionary pro-
cesses that we propose are productively understood in terms of autocatalyic
models. OOL refers to 'origin of life' and OOC refers to 'origin of culture'.
Despite these similarities between the OOL and OOC scenarios, there are
some important differences, which present interesting challenges. For exam-
ple, in the OOC scenario, externally registered stimuli are held in working
memory, whereas there is no similar bottleneck in the OOL. Such differences
4
pose interesting theoretical challenges which are addressed in this paper.
1.2. Structure of paper
This paper sketches out the beginnings of a formal model of how the
mind could have developed the kind of integrated structure that enables
self-triggered recall and abstract thought, drawing upon a formal framework
developed for the formal description of autocatalytic networks. The paper
begins with a bare minimum of background material from psychology, an-
thropology, and archaeology concerning the uniqueness of human cognition
and our ability to evolve complex, cumulatively creative culture. Next, we
provide the mathematical definitions of the basic concepts of our model, fol-
lowed by the model itself. We then investigate the predictions of this model,
in particular the factors that play an important role in the emergence of a
kind of cognitive structure that is able to participate in cultural evolution,
which we propose owes to the fact that is, in a fundamental sense, autocat-
alytic. Finally, we conclude with some caveats and limitations, as well as
unanswered questions and possibilities for future research.
2. Background from cognitive anthropology: A transition in cog-
nitive functioning
We now summarize briefly the archaeological evidence that the origin of
culture did reflect a transition to a different kind of cognitive functioning
(see Mithen (1998); Gabora and Smith (2017); Penn et al. (2008); Chomsky
(2012); Donald (1991)). There is no consensus as to why Homo erectus
crossed the threshold to the capacity for cumulative cultural evolution, but
the cranial capacity of Homo erectus was approximately 1,000 cc -- about
25% larger than that of Homo habilis (Aiello, 1996). Although simple stone
(and some bone and antler) implements can be found in the archaeological
record dating back to as long ago as 3.3 million years ago (Harmand et al.,
2015), it is not until over a million years later that Homo constructed tools
that were intentionally symmetrical (Lepre et al., 2011) and required multiple
production steps and varied raw materials (Haidle, 2009). By this time they
were transporting tool stone over greater distances than their predecessors
(Moutsou, 2014), and they had acquired the ability to use and control fire
(Goren-Inbar et al., 2004), had crossed stretches of open water up to 20
km (Gibbons, 1998), ranged as far north as latitude 52 (Parfitt et al., 2010),
revisited campsites possibly for seasons at a time, sometimes building shelters
5
(Mania and Mania, 2005), and ranked moderately high among predators
(Plummer, 2004). Thus, cumulative cultural evolution is believed to have
originated approximately two million years ago, following the appearance of
Homo erectus (Mithen, 1998).
It has been proposed that the increase in brain size enabled a transition
to a fundamentally different kind of cognitive architecture (Donald, 1991).1
Donald (1991) refers to the cognition of Homo habilis as an episodic mode
of cognitive functioning because it was limited to the 'here and now' of the
present moment. He proposed that the enlarged cranial capacity enabled
the hominin mind to undergo a transition to a new mode of cognitive func-
tioning made possible by the onset of what he calls a self-triggered recall and
rehearsal loop, which we abbreviate STR. STR enabled hominins to voluntar-
ily retrieve stored memories independent of environmental cues (sometimes
referred to as 'autocuing') and engage in pantomime, re-enactive play, and,
importantly, representational redescription, which involves embellishing and
revising thoughts and ideas as they are reflected upon from different per-
spectives. Donald referred to this as the mimetic mind because it could act
out or 'mime' events that occurred in the past or that could occur in the fu-
ture, thereby not only temporarily escaping the present but, through mime
or gesture, communicating the escape to others. STR also enabled attention
to be directed away from the external world toward ones' internal represen-
tations, which paved the way for abstract thought.
It enabled systematic
evaluation and improvement of thoughts and motor acts by adapting them
to new situations, resulting in voluntary rehearsal and refinement of skills
and artifacts.
Donald's concept of STR bears some resemblance to the suggestion by
Hauser et al. (2002) that what distinguishes human cognition from that of
other species is the capacity for recursion (Corballis, 2011), as well as the
concepts of relational reinterpretation by Penn et al. (2008) and of 'merge'
by Chomsky (2012) (for an overview, see (Gabora, 2018a)). What these
theories have in common is that they focus not on abilities in a particular
domain (such as social or technical abilities) but on a cognitive trait that
cuts across domains. STR enabled not just the redescription and thereby
refinement of previous representations but the sequential chaining of them,
and in a way that, through autocuing, could build upon past representations.
1For related proposals see (Gabora, 1998; Mithen, 1998; Penn et al., 2008).
6
However, STR requires that concepts and ideas be accessible to one another
(i.e., that they collectively constitute an integrated structure). How did such
a structure emerge?
3. Earlier approaches
We now briefly review the earlier work upon which this paper builds.
Inspired by Stuart Kauffman's (Kauffman, 1986, 1993) models of the emer-
gence of the earliest kind of living structure (sometimes called a protocell)
through autocatalytic closure of a set of catalytic polymers, Gabora (1998,
2000, 2001) proposed that the cognitive analog of the protocell is an indi-
vidual's integrated web of knowledge, beliefs, and so forth, that constitute
an internal model of the world, or worldview. In Kauffman's OOL model,
each polymer, composed of up to a maximum of M monomers, is assigned a
low a priori probability P of catalyzing each ligation (joining) and cleavage
(cutting) reaction. In the cognitive scenario, the analog of the set of poly-
mers is the set of MRs (i.e., mental representations in working or long-term
memory). The cognitive analog of M (the maximum polymer length) is the
maximum number of properties of a MR, and the analog of P , the proba-
bility of catalysis, is the probability that one representation brings about a
reminding or associative recall of another.
It was proposed that, as exposure to similar items or events causes the
formation of abstract concepts that connect these instances (for example, it
is recognized that experiences of specific rocks are instances of the concept
ROCK), a critical 'percolation threshold' is eventually reached because the
number of ways of forging associations amongst items in memory increases
faster than the number of items in memory. Following Kauffman's use of the
term 'autocatalytic closure' in early biochemistry, the analogous state in cog-
nition was referred to as conceptual closure (Gabora, 2000), a term we will
use later in this paper, with a precise definition. In this way, the assemblage
of human worldviews changes over time not because some of them replicate
in their entirety at the expense of others (for example, by natural selection)
but through piecemeal mutual interaction and self-organized transformation.
Artifacts, rituals, and other elements of culture reflect the states of the world-
views that generate them. Interactions amongst items in memory increases
their joint complexity, eventually transforming them into a conceptual net-
work, which continually revises itself as new inputs are incorporated. This
7
enables the creative connecting and refining of concepts and ideas necessary
for the individual to participate in the evolution of cultural novelty.
Kauffman found that, the lower the value of P , the greater M has to be
(and vice versa) in order for autocatalytic closure to be achieved. In other
words, there is a transition from a subcritical process to a critical process
which depends sensitively on these parameters. Similarly, there is a trade-off
between (the analogues of) these parameters in conceptual closure. In the
cognitive scenario, if the probability of associative recall is low, a network
is subcritical: the worldview is expected to be stable but to have difficulty
incorporating new information. Conversely, if the probability of associative
recall is high, the network is super-critical: the worldview is expected to
incorporate new information readily, but be at risk of destabilization (i.e.,
everything seems reminiscent of everything).
In the next few sections, we take these ideas in a new direction, and
provide for a more explicit mathematical framework. We stress once again
that in the terms autocatalytic closure and conceptual closure, the word
'closure' is not a condition that requires the set of items to be bounded or
unable to grow larger. Rather it expresses a property that that the set is
sufficiently connected together by catalysis events. In this way, many closed
sets within a system can exist and they can become larger by combining
together or by the introduction of new items.
4. Background from Theoretical Work on Autocatalytic Sets
As noted, the role of autocatalytic networks in OOL was introduced by
Kauffman (1993, 1986) in a pioneering approach to explain how complex
biochemistry might have arisen from primitive chemistry, based on reactions
that combine polymers. The notion of self-sustaining autocatalytic sets was
developed further (mathematically) as RAF-theory (here, RAF= Reflexively-
autocatalytic and F-generated set, reviewed in Hordijk and Steel (2016)).
Formally, a catalytic reaction system (CRS) is a tuple Q = (X,R, C, F )
consisting of a set X of molecule types, a set R of reactions, a catalysis set
C indicating which molecule types catalyze which reactions, and a subset F
of X called the food set. A Reflexively Autocatalytic and F-generated (RAF)
set for Q is a non-empty subset R(cid:48) ⊆ R of reactions which is:
1. Reflexively Autocatalytic: each reaction r ∈ R(cid:48) is catalyzed by at least
one molecule type that is either a product of R(cid:48) or is present in the
food set F ; and
8
2. F-generated: all reactants in R(cid:48) can be created from the food set F
using a series of reactions only from R(cid:48) itself.
In words, a RAF set is a subset of reactions that is both self-sustaining (i.e.,
every molecule involved in a reaction can be generated from the food set F by
a sequence of reactions within the subset) and collectively autocatalytic (i.e.,
every reaction is catalyzed by a molecule generated by the subset or the food
set). Such a set is a basic requirement for all living systems. Kauffman (1993)
first demonstrated this in a simple binary polymer model, the emergence of
such a RAF occurs when the complexity of the polymers reaches a certain
threshold. This has been further formalized and analyzed (mathematically
and using simulations) and with applications to real biochemical systems
(Hordijk et al. (2010, 2011), Hordijk and Steel (2004, 2012, 2016), Mossel
and Steel (2005)). RAF theory has proven useful for identifying how such
transitions might occur, and at what parameter values.
Our approach here is to apply the theory of RAFs in a form that is maxi-
mally abstract, and show how this can be used to address the question of how
a mind that is more or less a brittle, un-creative stimulus -- response machine
could transform into a mind capable of viewing situations from different per-
spectives, combining information from seemingly unrelated sources to solve
problems, and adapting responses in contextually appropriate ways. We will
start with this generic form of the model and examine how this might occur.
We will see that as we incorporate aspects unique to the OOC scenario, the
situation becomes more complex but the RAF approach can still effectively
model it.
In short, although results concerning the emergence of RAFs in chemical
networks cannot be applied directly to the question of how human cognition
evolved, related mathematical techniques can be, as we show after introduc-
ing some further background material and definitions.
5. A simple cognitive model based on reactions and catalysis
At a top level, our highly simplified cognitive model can be viewed as a
continuous-time, stochastic process involving three sets. As mentioned in
the introduction, we use the term mental representation, abbreviated MR, to
refer collectively to items in memory (either working memory or long-term
memory), as well as percepts, concepts, thoughts, and ideas, as well as more
9
complex mental structures such as schemas. For simplicity, we view a MR
to be an ensemble of a collection of hierarchically organized properties.
• St denotes the set of stimuli at time t registered by the senses (i.e.,
percepts that arise from sensory experiences). We can take t = 0 to be
the time of conception of the individual.
• Lt denotes the set of items encoded in long-term memory. This includes
the set I of any innate knowledge with which the individual comes into
the world.
• Mt denotes the set of items encoded in working memory and/or long-
term memory at time t (and so I ⊆ M0).2 Each element of m in Mt is
associated with a set of properties, denoted P (m), and we let m be the
number of those properties. Items in long-term memory encode largely
static 'invariances' of the world, while the items in working memory
often reflect variances from this static model.
• wt denotes the mental representation of a particular instant of expe-
It is
rience at time t. We will call wt the attended item at time t.
whatever is in the 'spotlight' of attention at time t.
• Wt denotes items in working memory. It consists of wt as well as any
other similar or recently-attended items that are still accessible. It is
a very small subset of Mt, of size in the order of 1 to ∼ 103. Thus,
wt ∈ Wt ⊂ Mt.
There is a straightforward way to define what 'associated' means here (in
the definition of Mt), based on a natural partial order on the set of mental
items. For two mental items m and m(cid:48) let us write m (cid:22) m(cid:48) if the properties
comprising m are a subset of the properties comprising m(cid:48). This partial order
allows us to capture the notion of an item m generalizing more particular
instances m1, m2, . . . , mk if m (cid:22) mi for each i (for example, m has precisely
the properties shared by each of m1, . . . , mk). The items m and m(cid:48) are said
be members of a concept if (though, not if and only if), on the basis of one or
more shared properties, there exists a representation of an abstract category
or prototype of which both are instances. For example, if m = a smooth
2Not to be confused with M from Section 3.
10
STONE, and m(cid:48) = a rough STONE, then m(cid:48)(cid:48) = STONE is a lower bound
(under (cid:22)) to both of them.3
More generally, the partial order also allows for associations amongst
items. We will say that m and m(cid:48) are associable if there is some property
they share, i.e., there exists m(cid:48)(cid:48) with m(cid:48)(cid:48) (cid:22) m and m(cid:48)(cid:48) (cid:22) m(cid:48). Note that
the properties associated with a mental representation are not fixed but can
be biased by context or by mode of thought (i.e., convergent/analytic ver-
sus divergent/associative) (Veloz et al. (2011); Sowden et al. (2015); Gabora
(2018b)). The fact that they share a particular property need never have
been explicitly noted by the individual. For example, even if an individual
has never consciously noticed that wood and rock share the property 'hard',
they are nevertheless implicitly associable. We will say that m and m(cid:48) are
associated if the fact that they share this property has been explicitly per-
ceived and encoded in memory. For example, if an individual noticed that
wood and rock share the property 'hard', they would be associated.
The reason we stress the distinction between associable and associated
is that explicit recognition of previously unrecognized shared properties is
central to the creative processes that fuel cultural evolution. For example, one
might consciously recognize that wood and rock share the property 'hard'.
If one had previously carved something durable out of wood, this would be a
first step toward recognizing that a durable object might also be carved out
of stone.
5.1. Forging of cognitive structure
There are several sources of cognitive structure. One is innate structure
in the form of instincts, fixed action patterns, and so forth. A second is
structure on the basis of aspects of the MR perceived at the time of initial
encoding, such as on the basis of properties shared by the MR and other
previously encoded MRs. A third is structure on the basis of aspects of
the MR perceived after the time of encoding, such as occurs during mind
wandering, contemplation, reflection from different perspectives, or creative
thought.
As mentioned, the term catalysis refers to one MR evoking another, as
in a stream of thought. A MR that was present at time t plays the role of
3Note that there are other ways that mental representations can be associated with
each other (beyond sharing properties), such as via classical conditioning (for example, if
a bell always goes right before food appears).
11
(and is referred to as) the reactant, whereas a MR that is present at time
t + δ is referred to as the product. Catalysis may be precipitated by an ex-
ternal stimulus -- as when something in the environment triggers a particular
thought -- or by another MR -- as when the shift from one thought to an-
other is triggered by looking at it from (one's internal representation of) the
perspective of someone else. A stimulus or MR that precipitates cognitive
catalysis is referred to as a catalyst. We write the 'reaction' x → z or x
y−→ z,
where x is a reactant and y is a catalyst.
In biochemistry, the distinction between reactant and catalyst is that
the reactant is transformed (and therefore replaced by its product) in the
reaction. The catalyst simply enables this to occur, without being itself
used up in the reaction. In cognition, however, both the reactant and the
catalyst may be affected by the reaction. For example, if x is the MR of
a piece of wood, and y is the MR of an event in which the wood is dented
by a falling rock, this may change the individual's conception of both wood
(i.e., it is now dented) and rock (i.e., it is capable of denting wood).
In
the cognitive scenario, the distinction between reactant and catalyst is the
following: the reactant is the MR that is generally (though not always) the
focus of attention, whereas the catalyst is a stimulus or another MR that
allows the reactant to give rise to a new MR as the next focus of attention.
5.2. Modeling the episodic mind
We posit that the dynamics of an episodic mind can be modeled by
the following three processes. Note that in writing +δ, we allow either a
continuous-time process or a finely-discretized (i.e., nearly continuous time)
process.
Encoding in memory: An item in Wt can be encoded to long-term
memory m in Lt+δ. We denote encoding by writing w ; m. and for
an attended item w, we write w ; m. Note that w may or may not
remain in Wt+δ when encoded to long-term memory.
Shift in attention: Attention may shift from one thought or stimulus
w in Wt to another w(cid:48) in Wt+δ. After attention shifts away from a
particular item w, it persists for some time in Wt, and during this time
it is still readily accessible. Once it is no longer present in working
memory, it is denoted w (cid:55)→ ∅. Note, however, that it meanwhile may
12
have been encoded in long-term memory. w(cid:48) may either come from
working memory (in which case, we denote this shift in attention by
writing w (cid:55)→ w and w(cid:48)
(cid:55)→ w(cid:48)) or it may be a new item generated by
one of the following processes.
Updating by stimuli: Without entering a detailed discussion on the
nature of awareness and perception, (in order to keep the focus on the
forest rather than the trees), we use the term updating by stimulus to
refer to a stimulus-driven change in what is paid attention to, whether
it be social in nature (such as a smile, gesture, or speech), or nonsocial
(such as a change in the weather). Note that we are not using the
term 'learning' for this purpose because learning could imply that the
change is encoded to long-term memory; what we are referring to here
is any attended stimulus change, no matter how trivial, whether or not
it is ever consolidated to long-term memory.
We say that the subject of attention, w, shifts to w(cid:48) ∈ Wt+δ, due to
catalysis by a stimulus s in St; in other words:
w s−→ w(cid:48) and w (cid:55)→ w.
A concrete example of updating by stimuli is given in the lower part of
Fig. 1.
Sometimes the new content of working memory is not an external stim-
ulus s ∈ St, but a mental representation m ∈ Mt that was evoked by
the stimulus because they are associated. This association may either
have been hardwired or learned. For now, we will not concern ourselves
with exactly how the stimulus affects the content of working memory,
or the role of long-term memory (as well as goals, attitudes, motives,
and so forth) on this process; what we focus on is the fact that the
content of working memory has changed. Note that, in a society of
interacting individuals, the expression, through speech or action, of an
item m ∈ Mt in one individual's mind can be regarded as a stimulus
s for another individual, thereby provide a social learning 'reaction' in
that individual.
13
5.3. Modeling the mimetic mind
So far we have considered cognitive processes that occur in the episodic
mind, which carries out appropriate responses to stimuli, but these responses
are fixed. We now consider an additional process that is a distinguishing
feature of the mimetic mind, which as mentioned earlier was physically larger
than the episodic mind, and which Donald (1991) posited was capable of self-
triggered recall and rehearsal.
Cognitive updating: In the process of reflecting upon, or thinking
about an attended item w ∈ Wt, we think about it in a new way or
consider it appears from a different context or from another person's
perspective, which we denote as m ∈ Mt. We say that w ∈ Wt is
catalyzed by an item m ∈ Mt. This 'reaction' updates the subject of
thought, which is now denoted w(cid:48) ∈ Wt+δ. We will refer to a single step
such as this type of reflection process as cognitive updating and denote
it by writing:
w m−→ w(cid:48), and w (cid:55)→ w.
As an example, suppose you are thinking about a dog (this is w) and
you wonder what your mother would think of it (thus, m is your
mother's perspective, which plays the role of catalyst). Then w(cid:48) is
a new opinion of the dog that incorporates your mother's perspective.
This example involves representational re-description, i.e., the modifi-
cation or redescription of a MR of a dog.
Abstract thought can also involve the chaining, or sequencing, of multi-
ple MRs -- such as representations for simple, single-step actions -- into
a more complex MR that involves multiple steps. It occasionally re-
sults in concept combination: the merger of two concepts into a more
complex concept.
Another example of representational re-description is illustrated by the
top dashed arrow in Fig. 1. Again, in order not to lose sight of the forest for
the trees, we omit details of how causal relationships arise in cognition, an
active area of research in psychology and artificial intelligence largely carried
out using Bayesian statistical models (Goodman et al., 2011; Tenenbaum
et al., 2011).
14
Figure 1: The lower two reactions (green circles) correspond to 'updating by stimulus' (i.e.,
w s−→ w(cid:48) where, for example, w = (wood is sappy), s = (burning well), and w(cid:48)=(sappy
wood burns well)). This kind of reaction is possible in either an episodic or mimetic mind.
However, in the representational re-description reaction at the top of the figure (blue
circle), a MR undergoes change in the absence of a stimulus; it is instead catalyzed by
another MR. Representational re-description is the outcome of self-triggered recall, which
is believed to be a distinguishing feature of a mimetic mind (Donald, 1991).
Note that the key difference between this process and updating due to
stimulus is the nature of the catalyst: here it is internal -- i.e., an item in
Mt -- rather than external -- i.e., a stimulus in St.
In order to revise one's
understanding of something, it was no longer necessary for something to
happen in the physical world; this new understanding could arise due to
'putting 2 and 2 together', or making more integrated use of thoughts and
ideas encoded in memory.
Notice also that there are various ways to model the fraction of men-
tal representations that are close enough to the current subject of thought
to generate a retrieval or reminding event. Under a binomial distribution,
very few items are highly similar to any given item m, a great many are of
intermediate similarity to m, and very few are extremely different from m.
This distribution widens as we allow for abstract categories, of which specific
15
Wood is sappy Burning well Sappy wood burns well Wood is not sappy Burning poorly Low-sap wood burns poorly Sap helps the wood to burn well instances are members (Gabora, 1998).
6. Dynamics of cognition under the model
A Cognitive Catalytic Process (CCP) is a sequence of attended items
C = wt(1), wt(2), . . . , wt(k),
(where wt(i) ∈ Wt(i), and where the t(i) values are increasing) with the prop-
erty that each item wt(i) after the first is generated from an earlier one by a
cognitive updating reaction. In words, a CCP is a stream of thoughts, each
of which builds on an earlier one, via its connection to (catalysis by) an item
in long-term or working memory. Newly generated MRs may subsequently
be encoded in long-term memory and thus are available to catalyze further
cognitive catalytic processes. We note that CCPs take shape in conjunction
with drives and goals (though the details of how this works is beyond the
scope of the current paper). Fig. 2 provides a simple schematic example to
illustrate the distinction between processes where CCPs are absent (i) and
where they are present (ii).
We suggest that by providing a mechanism whereby ideas can be com-
bined, developed, enhanced, integrated with existing knowledge, and made
available for further such processes, the emergences of CCPs can allow the
development of a mimetic mind from a simpler episodic mind, regarded as
a key step in the origin of cultural evolution. The encoding of MRs aris-
ing from CCPs in long-term memory can then leads to a more integrated
cognitive network ('conceptual closure') which we describe in Section 7.1.
We now describe some generic features of the dynamics of CCPs and
their emergence in the transition from an episodic to a mimetic mind. We
focus on the impact of two parameters: the richness of MRs (i.e., the detail
with which items in memory are encoded) parameterized by the maximum
number N of properties of MRs, and their reactivity (i.e., the extent to which
features in a mental item trigger associations with other items), denoted P .
Here N and P can be viewed as the analogues of the maximum polymer
length M and the catalyzation probability P (respectively) in Kauffman's
OOL model from Section 3. We will also describe how CCPs correspond
to the autocatalytic network concepts of RAFs and CAFs that have been
developed in origin-of-life research (Section 7).
We begin by noting that whether or not a given MR in Mt catalyzes a
given cognitive updating reaction depends on numerous factors, such as how
16
Figure 2: In this figure, the attended item in Wt is shown in solid green lines, with other
items in Wt as thin orange lines; × denotes that the item is no longer present in working
memory. (i) Item updating due to stimulus (the four reactions, with catalysis indicated by
dotted arrows) together with encoding (an item from Wt is cemented in Lt) is denoted by
wiggly arrows). These do not allow for a cognitive catalytic processes (CCP) to form. (ii)
The additional ability of items in Mt to catalyze cognitive updating from Lt (the lower
dotted arrow) and from within Wt (the two uppermost dotted arrows). This leads to the
formation of a CCP of size four. The disconnect in the solid green path near the top is an
instance of a shift in attention to an item in working memory.
closely associated the items are in terms of shared properties, what stimuli
are present, and what other MRs are active in working memory. The rate
at which an item m ∈ Mt catalyzes an attended item w in Wt will be higher
the more properties the two items share.
Rather than trying to model the impact of increasing N directly on the
emergence of CCPs, we consider the simpler case of increasing the average
rate λ at which items in Wt and Lt catalyze cognitive updating reactions (the
rates within these two classes may differ, so λ should be viewed as a scaling
factor for both rates). Note that λ is an function of both P and N .
We are particularly interested in understanding how the formation and
persistence of CCPs depends on this catalysis rate λ and a possible transition
that occurs when this catalysis rate increases, which could provide a feasible
explanation for the transition from an episodic to a mimetic mind. The fol-
lowing broad predictions, which can be easily derived in overly-simplified
models (using techniques familiar from branching processes and random
17
s(cid:48)(cid:48)s(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48)ss(cid:48)timetLtWtSt(i)timetLtWtSt(ii)sm graph theory), are generic properties that would be expected to hold in more
specialized models.
1. When λ is below a critical value, the dynamics of wt, Wt, and Mt are
essentially determined by the external stimuli St. This situation is
characteristic of an episodic mind. If CCPs form at all, they do not
persist, and therefore have negligible impact on the structure of the
whole. Thus, items in memory remain essentially disconnected; they
are activated in response to particular stimuli or situations, and evoke
appropriate responses, but do not transform into an architecture that
is continually revising its own structure by way of streams of thought.
2. As λ increases towards a critical threshold, CCPs begin to form, and
their size increases. This threshold depends on a sensitive interplay
between P and Lt, such that when long-term memory is denser, lower
values of P suffice.
3. The emergence of CCPs causes Mt to grow at a faster rate than it would
otherwise by generating a stream of thought that need not be related
to current stimuli. Such streams of thought may be encoded in Mt
thereby providing a richer array of catalysts in Lt for future cognitive
updating reactions (and thereby CCPs) and so generating a positive
feedback process. This situation is characteristic of the mimetic mind.
7. Cognitive RAFs: The mind as an autocatalytic network
The model that we have described can be viewed as an instance of an
autocatalytic set in an abstract reactive network, as described in Section
4, in which the transition from episodic to mimetic mind corresponds to
the emergence of an RAF set. To describe this more formally, consider the
myriad of ways that Mt could develop from M0 (at conception) to its state
at some particular time t. More precisely, for a fixed time t > 0, consider the
following catalytic reaction system Q = (X,R, C, F ), where:
t(cid:48)≤t St(cid:48)(cid:1) ∪ M0 (this is what the external environment
t(cid:48)≤t Mt(cid:48)(cid:1) ∪ Ft (this is the set of all mental representations that
have been present in the mind from conception up to some time t,
together with Ft).
• F = Ft = (cid:0)(cid:83)
• X =(cid:0)(cid:83)
provides (stimuli);
18
• R is the set of all the updating reactions that can potentially take place
from conception up to time t;
• C is all the catalysis assignments that are potentially possible.
R and C are not prescribed in advance. Because C includes remindings and
associations on the basis of, not just a single shared property, but also on
the basis of multiple shared properties, MRs can develop in a potentially
unlimited number of directions through interactions with other MRs. Never-
theless, it makes perfect mathematical sense to talk about R and C as sets.
The justification of the following result is provided in the Appendix, in which
we assume that t is large enough that updating reactions have commenced,
and that the rate at which stimuli occur is bounded.
Proposition 1. Q contains a RAF that increases in size with t (namely
the set of updating reactions that actually do occur between time 0 and t).
Moreover, while λ is below a critical threshold, CCPs in this RAF are short
and few in number, but when λ exceeds this threshold, CCPs become more
frequent, persistent and complex.
We will refer to the particular RAF described in Proposition 1 as the cognitive
RAF. It has, in fact, the stronger property of being a CAF, as defined in
Mossel and Steel (2005). The significance of a transition from linear to super-
linear growth in Proposition 1 is in providing a mechanism for generating
densely linked connections in the mimetic mind. This is described in more
detail in the next section.
This formal connection between the RAF structure of (i) our simple model
of the mind and (ii) a model that has been used to understand the transition
to self-sustaining autocatalytic life in biochemistry, may be helpful in subse-
quent work. This is because efficient (polynomial-time) algorithms exist for
detecting RAFs (and CAFs) in catalytic reaction systems in general, and for
studying their organisation and structure. (For further details, see Hordijk
and Steel (2016) and the references therein).
7.1. Cognitive RAFs and conceptual closure
Our simple model provides a mechanism by which items involved in the
cognitive RAF (reactants, products, and catalysts) and in the sequences
(streams of thought) that form CCPs present in this cognitive RAF can
give rise (via the encoding process) to increasingly interlinked associations
19
between mental representations in long-term memory. Formally, we say that
a set C of items in Lt (i.e., long-term memory) is a conceptually closed set
if, for any two items mi, mj in C, there is a possible sequence of cognitive
updating reactions that (if activated) can relate mi to mj, and such that each
reaction in that sequence has a catalyst that is also an item in C. In this
definition, saying that the sequence of reactions relates mi to mj means that
for each reaction in the sequence, the reactant and product are associated
(here 'associated' is as defined in the paragraphs before Section 5.1).
As N increases in the transition from episodic mind to mimetic mind, Lt
begins to increase more rapidly (via Proposition 1) and P becomes tuned
to match N such that reminding events are neither too frequent, such that
the network is super-critical (an 'everything reminds you of everything' sit-
uation), nor too infrequent, such that the network is subcritical (a 'nothing
reminds you of anything' situation), as discussed in Section 3. Thus, concep-
tually closed sets of increasing size and complexity can form.
8. Conclusions
We suggest that it was not a change to any particular brain area that
enabled the threshold to cumulative cultural evolution to be crossed, but
a change to how the brain functions as a whole, and this change can be
articulated using a mathematical model.
It has been proposed that cultural evolution was made possible by a cog-
nitive transition brought about by onset of the capacity for self-triggered
recall and rehearsal. However, self-triggered recall requires that concepts
and ideas be accessible to one another (i.e., that they collectively constitute
an integrated structure). We suggest that, much as models of self-sustaining,
autocatalytic networks have been useful for understanding how the the origin
of life, and thus biological evolution, could have come about, they are also
useful for understanding how the the origin of the kind of cognitive structure
that makes cultural evolution possible could have come about. Mental repre-
sentations (such as memories, concepts, and schemas) play the role of 'reac-
tants' and 'catalysts', and relationships amongst them (such as associations,
remindings, and causal relationships) are the 'reactions'. In the pre-cultural
'episodic' mind, such reactions are catalyzed only by external stimuli. As
cranial capacity increases, representations become richer (more features or
properties are encoded), and thus reactions become more plentiful, leading
to streams of thought. Streams of thought cause the reaction network to
20
become even denser. Eventually, it becomes almost inevitable that a per-
colation threshold is surpassed, and collectively the representations form an
integrated autocatalytic set. At this point, the mind can combine represen-
tations and adapt them to specific needs and situations, and thereby become
a contributor to culture. We posit that an interacting population of such
minds is capable of cumulatively creative cultural evolution.
Our model provides a means of differentiating between the episodic mind
of Homo habilis, the mimetic mind of Homo erectus, and the mind of a
young child. The proposed similarities and differences amongst them are
summarized in Table 2.
Variable Variable
(Symbol)
Homo
habilis
Homo
erectus
N
X
P
λ
Wt
Lt
Mt
C
CCP s
(In Words)
MR richness
Set of existing MRs
Reactivity
Catalysis rate
Working memory
Long-term memory
Memory (Wt and/or Lt)
Streams of thought
Conceptual Closure
High
Large
Larger
Larger
Low
Large
Fixed
Small
Small
Small Much larger
Small Much larger
Absent
Absent
Present
Present
Tuned to N Tuned to N
Young
Child
High
Small
Small
Small
Small
Small
Absent
Absent
Table 2. Summary comparison of the episodic mind of Homo habilis, the
mimetic mind of Homo erectus, and the mind of a young child.
We suggest that in the mind of a developing child, MRs are sufficiently
rich, and the catalysis rate is sufficiently high, but memory is not yet packed
densely with enough MRs for CCPs to occur. As more MRs are encoded in
long-term memory, the effective rate of cognitive updating increases as items
get encoded into long-term memory (the more items there, the more likely
one is to catalyze a cognitive updating reaction). This, in turn, increases
working memory, which also eventually increases the rate of cognitive up-
dating reactions from within working memory.4 In short, while the OOC is
4This is supported by findings that measures of performance on tests of working memory
increase continuously between early childhood and adolescence (Gathercole et al., (2004).
21
attributed to an increase in N and corresponding fine-tuning of P , in the
developmental transition of a young child to a contributing member of cul-
ture, N and P are sufficiently high but X is not sufficiently dense for the
formation of CCPs.
While our model is individual-based, it also allows for societal interactions
and development. More precisely, if we have a collection of minds (society),
then an item m ∈ Mt in one individual can (through speech, gesture, or ac-
tion) be regarded as a stimulus s for another individual, and thereby provide
an 'updating by stimuli' reaction in that individual. Thus the collection of
minds (together with other stimuli from the environment) provides a higher-
level network structure.
There are several caveats and limitations to this work. Firstly, we have
not dealt with the problems that have arisen in psychology and artificial
intelligence in trying to deal with mental representations, reasoning and in-
ference, creativity, and language understanding. These challenges are not
the subject of this paper. Nevertheless, we believe that by introducing an
architecture conducive to self-organized emergent cognitive complexity, the
proposed framework has the potential to facilitate such efforts.
Also, in this paper we have not provided a mechanism that accounts for
awareness, though one of us has proposed such a mechanism elsewhere (Gab-
ora (2002a)). Nor have we provided a mechanism for subconscious processing
within working memory, although one of us has published on this extensively
elsewhere (Gabora (2002b, 2010, 2018b); Gabora and Ranjan (2013)). In a
subsequent paper, we will aim to show how implicit processing fit into this
model.
Indeed, the model proposed here is quite general and schematic. To
make it precise enough to allow a detailed mathematical analysis requires
specifying a large number of assumptions and parameter choices, estimated
from empirical studies. Since the goal of the present paper is merely to show
that, for a range of reasonable values, the kind of cognitive reorganization
that we propose made cultural evolution possible is likely to occur, and leads
to testable predictions. Rather than exploring any particular choice here -- a
topic that we wish to pursue in future work -- our approach is to consider
generic properties of the simple and general model described.
Other fruitful arenas for future research would be to more fully explore
how transitions in the network structure map onto cognitive developmental
stages, or how different ways of achieving a closure structure map onto per-
sonality differences. We might speculatively suggest that the fact that there
22
are different ways of satisfying the criterion (for example, very high reactivity
with a medium number of episodes, versus a very high number of episodes
and medium reactivity) could form the basis of fascinating personality test.
A person with high reactivity might be likely to understand things in terms
of analogies and metaphors and make decisions in a context-dependent way,
whereas a person with a high number of episodes would be more likely to
understand things in terms of their large repertoire of cultural teachings and
make decisions according to how its been done in the past as opposed to
taking context-specific factors into account.
We conclude by suggesting that the common mathematical approach of
two superficially different evolution processes (the origin of life and the origin
of culture) depends on a certain kind of deep abstract structure, which has
also recently been identified in other fields, such a ecology (Gatti et al., 2017)
and economics (Hordijk, 2013). This may prove useful for studying emergent
processes in other fields.
9. Acknowledgments
We thank an anonymous reviewer for a number of helpful comments and
suggestions. This work was supported by a grant (62R06523) from the Nat-
ural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada.
References
References
Aiello, L.C., 1996. Hominine pre-adaptations for language and cognition, in:
Mellars, P., Gibson, K. (Eds.), Modeling the early human mind. McDonald
Institute Monographs, Cambridge, UK, pp. 89 -- 99.
Cabell, K.R., Valsiner, J., 2014. The catalyzing mind: Beyond models of
causality. Annals of Theoretical Psychology 11, Springer.
Chomsky, N., 2012. The science of language. Cambridge University Press.
Corballis, M.C., 2011. The recursive mind: the origins of human language,
thought and civilization. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
Donald, M., 1991. Origins of the modern mind: Three stages in the evolution
of culture and cognition. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
23
Erdos, P., R´enyi, A., 1960. On the evolution of random graphs. Publications
of the Mathematical Institute of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences 5,
17 -- 61.
Farmer, J.D., Kauffman, S.A., Packard, N.H., 1986. Autocatalytic replication
of polymers. Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena 22, 50 -- 67.
Gabora, L., 1998. Autocatalytic closure in a cognitive system: A tentative
scenario for the origin of culture. Psycoloquy 9, 67 [adap -- org/9901002].
Gabora, L., 2000. Conceptual closure: How memories are woven into an
interconnected worldview., in: Van de Vijver, G., Chandler, J. (Eds.),
Closure: Emergent Organizations and their Dynamics. Annals of the New
York Academy of Sciences. 901, pp. 42 -- 53.
Gabora, L., 2001. Cognitive mechanisms underlying the origin and evolution
of culture. Doctoral dissertation. Free University of Brussels, Belgium.
Gabora, L., 2002a. Amplifying phenomenal information: Toward a funda-
mental theory of consciousness. Journal of Consciousness Studies 9, 3 -- 29.
Gabora, L., 2002b. Cognitive mechanisms underlying the creative process.,
in: T., H., Kavanagh, T. (Eds.), Proceedings of the Fourth International
Conference on Creativity and Cognition. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp.
126 -- 133.
Gabora, L., 2006. Self-other organization: Why early life did not evolve
through natural selection. Journal of Theoretical Biology 241, 443 -- 450.
Gabora, L., 2010. Revenge of the 'neurds': Characterizing creative thought
in terms of the structure and dynamics of human memory. 22 , 1 -- 13.
Gabora, L., 2013. An evolutionary framework for culture: Selectionism versus
communal exchange. Physics of Life Reviews 10, 117 -- 145.
Gabora, L., 2018a. The creative process of cultural evolution, in: Leung, A.
(Ed.), Handbook of Culture and creativity: Basic processes and applied
innovations. Oxford University Press.
Gabora, L., 2018b. How insight emerges in distributed, content-addressable
memory, in: Vartanian, O., Jung, J. (Eds.), The Cambridge Handbook of
the Neuroscience of Creativity. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
24
Gabora, L., Ranjan, A., 2013. How insight emerges in distributed, content-
addressable memory, in: Bristol, A., Vartanian, O., Kaufman, J. (Eds.),
The neuroscience of creativity. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 19 -- 43.
Gabora, L., Smith, L., 2017. Two cognitive transitions underlying the ca-
pacity for cultural evolution. (submitted.).
Gathercole, S.E., Pickering, S.J., Ambridge, B., Wearing, H., (2004. The
structure of working memory from 4 to 15 years of age. Developmental
Psychology 40, 177 -- 190. Doi:10.1037/0012-1649.40.2.177. PMID 14979759.
Gatti, R.C., Hordijk, W., Kauffman, S., 2017. Biodiversity is autocatalytic.
Ecological modelling 346, 70 -- 76.
Gibbons, A., 1998. Ancient island tools suggest Homo erectus was a seafarer.
Science 297, 1635 -- 1637.
Goodman, N.D., Ullmand, T.D., Tenenbaum, J.B., 2011. Learning a theory
of causality. Psychological review 118, 110.
Goren-Inbar, N., Alperson, N., Kiselv, M.E., Simchoni, O., Melamed, Y.,
Ben-Nun, A., Werker, E., 2004. Evidence of hominin control of fire at
Gesher Benot Ya'aqov, Israel. Science 304, 725 -- 727.
Haidle, M.N., 2009. How to think a simple spear,
in: deBaune, S.A.,
Coolidge, F.L., Wynn, T. (Eds.), Cognitive archaeology and human evo-
lution. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 57 -- 73.
Harmand, S., Lewis, J.E., Feibel, C.S., Lepre, C.J., Prat, S., Lenoble, A.,
Boes, X., Quinn, R.L., Brenet, M., Arroyo, A., Taylor, N., Cl´ement, S.,
Daver, G., Brugal, J.P., Leakey, L., Mortlock, R.A., Wright, J.D., Loko-
rodi, S., Kirwa, C., Kent, D.V., Roche, H., 2015. 3.3-million-year-old stone
tools from Lomekwi 3, West Turkana, Kenya. Nature 521, 310 -- 315.
Hauser, M.D., Chomsky, N., Fitch, W.T., 2002. The faculty of language:
What is it, who has it and how did it evolve? Science 298, 1569 -- 1579.
Hordijk, W., 2013. From the origin of life to the economy. BioScience 63,
877 -- 881.
Hordijk, W., Hein, J., Steel, M., 2010. Autocatalytic sets and the origin of
life. Entropy 12, 1733 -- 1742.
25
Hordijk, W., Kauffman, S.A., Steel, M., 2011. Required levels of catalysis
for emergence of autocatalytic sets in models of chemical reaction systems.
International Journal of Molecular Sciences 12, 3085 -- 3101.
Hordijk, W., Steel, M., 2004. Detecting autocatalytic, self-sustaining sets in
chemical reaction systems. Journal of Theoretical Biology 227, 451 -- 461.
Hordijk, W., Steel, M., 2012. Predicting template-based catalysis rates in
a simple catalytic reaction model. Journal of Theoretical Biology 295,
132 -- 138.
Hordijk, W., Steel, M., 2016. Chasing the tail: The emergence of autocat-
alytic networks. Biosystems 152, 1 -- 10.
Kauffman, S.A., 1986. Autocatalytic sets of proteins. Journal of Thoeretical
Biology 119, 1 -- 24.
Kauffman, S.A., 1993. The origins of order. Oxford University Press.
Lepre, C.J., Roche, H., Kent, D.V., Harmand, S., Quinn, R.L., Brugal, J.P.,
Texier, P.J., Lenoble, A., Feibel, C.S., 2011. An earlier origin for the
Acheulian. Nature 477, 82 -- 85.
Mania, D., Mania, U., 2005. The natural and socio-cultural environment of
Homo erectus at Bilzingsleben, Germany, in: Gamble, C. (Ed.), The Indi-
vidual Hominid in context: Archaeological investigations of Lower and
Middle Palaeolithic landscapes,
locales, and artefacts. Routledge, New
York, pp. 98 -- 114.
Mithen, S., 1998. Creativity in human evolution and prehistory. Routledge,
London, UK.
Mossel, E., Steel, M., 2005. Random biochemical networks and the proba-
bility of self-sustaining autocatalysis. Journal of Theoretical Biology 233,
327 -- 336.
Moutsou, T., 2014. The obsidian evidence for the scale of social life during the
Palaeolithic. British Archaeological Reports International Series #2613,
Oxford.
New, M.H., Pohorille, A., 2000. An inherited efficiencies model of non-
genomic evolution. Simulation Practice Theory 8, 99 -- 108.
26
Parfitt, S., Ashton, N.M., Lewis, S.G., Abel, R.L., Coope, G.R., Field, M.H.,
Gale, R., Hoare, P.G., Larkin, N.R., Lewis, M.D., Karloukivski, V., Maher,
B.A., Peglar, S.M., Preece, R.C., Whittaker, J.F., Stringer, C.B., 2010.
Early Pleistocene human occupation at the edge of the boreal zone in
northwest Europe. Nature 466, 229 -- 233.
Penn, D., Holyoak, K., Povinelli, D., 2008. Darwin's mistake: Explaining
the discontinuity between human and nonhuman minds. Behavioral and
Brain Sciences 31, 109 -- 178.
Plummer, T., 2004. Flaked stones and old bones: Biological and cultural
evolution at the dawn of technology. Yearbook of Physical Anthropology
47, 118 -- 164.
Segre, D., 2000. Compositional genomes: Prebiotic information transfer in
mutually catalytic noncovalent assemblies. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences USA 97, 4112 -- 4117.
Sowden, P., Pringle, A., Gabora, L., 2015. The shifting sands of creative
thinking: Connections to dual process theory. Thinking & Reasoning 21,
40 -- 60.
Tenenbaum, J.B., Kemp, C., Griffiths, T.L., Goodman, N.D., 2011. How
to grow a mind: statistics, structure and abstraction. Science 331 (6022),
1279 -- 1285.
Veloz, T., Gabora, L., Eyjolfson, M., Aerts, D., 2011. Toward a formal
model of the shifting relationship between concepts and contexts in differ-
ent modes of thought, in: Song, D., Melucci, M., Frommholz, I., Zhang, P.,
Wang, L., Arafat, S. (Eds.), Lecture Notes in Computer Science 7052: Pro-
ceedings of the Fifth International Symposium on Quantum Interaction.
Springer, Berlin, pp. 25 -- 34.
Vetsigian, K., Woese, C., Goldenfeld, N., 2006. Collective evolution and the
genetic code. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 103,
10696 -- 10701.
Wachtershauser, G., 1997. The origin of life and its methodological challenge.
Journal of Theoretical Biology 187, 483 -- 494.
27
10. Appendix: Justification of Proposition 1
Let Rt be the set of actual updating reactions that occur in Wt up to
time t (as noted, we assume that t is large enough so this set is nonempty),
and let r1, r2, . . . , rk be a list of the sequence of these reactions in the order
they occur. The reactant of each reaction ri in Rt is either an element of
M0 (which is a subset of F ) or another attended item that is the product
of an earlier reaction rj (where j < i) in the sequence (this holds even in
the presence of attention shifts). Moreover, each reaction in Rt is catalysed
either by an stimulus (which is an element of F ) or by the product of an
earlier reaction rj (where j < i) in the sequence. Thus, Rt satisfies the
required properties to be a CAF (constructively autocatalytic F-generated
set) as defined in Mossel and Steel (2005), and so is a RAF.
For the second part of Proposition 1, if λ is sufficiently small then the
rate of cognitive updating reactions will be less than the rate µ at which
items in working memory become no longer present in this set. By standard
(birth-death process) arguments, it follows that a sequence of consecutive
cognitive updating reactions (as in Fig. 2(ii)) will eventually die out, and
as λ declines further the frequency of such sequences of length greater than
1 tends to zero. However, as, λ grows beyond the rate at which cognitive
updating reactions exceeds µ, sequences of consecutive cognitive updating
reactions become increasingly frequent, and of greater duration and size.
28
|
1702.06405 | 1 | 1702 | 2017-02-21T14:36:17 | Interactive Web Application for Exploring Matrices of Neural Connectivity | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | We present here a browser-based application for visualizing patterns of connectivity in 3D stacked data matrices with large numbers of pairwise relations. Visualizing a connectivity matrix, looking for trends and patterns, and dynamically manipulating these values is a challenge for scientists from diverse fields, including neuroscience and genomics. In particular, high-dimensional neural data include those acquired via electroencephalography (EEG), electrocorticography (ECoG), magnetoencephalography (MEG), and functional MRI. Neural connectivity data contains multivariate attributes for each edge between different brain regions, which motivated our lightweight, open source, easy-to-use visualization tool for the exploration of these connectivity matrices to highlight connections of interest. Here we present a client-side, mobile-compatible visualization tool written entirely in HTML5/JavaScript that allows in-browser manipulation of user-defined files for exploration of brain connectivity. Visualizations can highlight different aspects of the data simultaneously across different dimensions. Input files are in JSON format, and custom Python scripts have been written to parse MATLAB or Python data files into JSON-loadable format. We demonstrate the analysis of connectivity data acquired via human ECoG recordings as a domain-specific implementation of our application. We envision applications for this interactive tool in fields seeking to visualize pairwise connectivity. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Interactive Web Application for Exploring Matrices of Neural
Connectivity
David J. Caldwell†, Student Member, IEEE, Jing Wu†, Student Member, IEEE, Kaitlyn Casimo,
Jeffrey G. Ojemann, Rajesh P.N. Rao, Member, IEEE
via
files
(ECoG),
acquired
electroencephalography
Abstract- We present here a browser-based application for
visualizing patterns of connectivity in 3D stacked data matrices
with
large numbers of pairwise relations. Visualizing a
connectivity matrix, looking for trends and patterns, and
dynamically manipulating these values is a challenge for
scientists from diverse fields, including neuroscience and
genomics. In particular, high-dimensional neural data include
those
(EEG),
electrocorticography
magnetoencephalography
(MEG), and functional MRI. Neural connectivity data contains
multivariate attributes for each edge between different brain
regions, which motivated our lightweight, open source, easy-to-
use visualization tool for the exploration of these connectivity
matrices to highlight connections of interest. Here we present a
client-side, mobile-compatible visualization tool written entirely
in HTML5/JavaScript that allows in-browser manipulation of
user-defined
for exploration of brain connectivity.
Visualizations can highlight different aspects of the data
simultaneously across different dimensions. Input files are in
JSON format, and custom Python scripts have been written to
parse MATLAB or Python data files into JSON-loadable
format. We demonstrate the analysis of connectivity data
acquired via human ECoG recordings as a domain-specific
implementation of our application. We envision applications for
this interactive tool in fields seeking to visualize pairwise
connectivity.
I. INTRODUCTION
In this paper, we present an interactive exploration tool
specifically tailored to visualize large numbers of pairwise
neural connectivity dynamics. We further demonstrate the
utility of this tool for analyzing pairwise connections across
† These authors contributed equally
*Research supported by grants from NSF EEC-1028725, NINDS
5R01NS065186, the UW Big Data for Genomics and Neuroscience
(BDGN) T32 Training Grant, and the WRF Fund for Innovation in
Neuroengineering.
D.J Caldwell is with the department of Bioengineering, University of
Washington, Seattle, WA 98105 USA, and the Center for Sensorimotor
Neural
e-mail:
[email protected]).
206-685-3301;
Engineering
(CSNE).
(phone:
J. Wu is with the department of Bioengineering, University of
Washington, Seattle, WA 98105 USA, and the CSNE. (phone: 206-685-
3301; e-mail: [email protected]).
K. Casimo is with the Graduate Program in Neuroscience, University of
(e-mail:
Washington, Seattle, WA 98105 USA, and
[email protected])
the CSNE
J.G. Ojemann is with the department of Neurological Surgery,
University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98105 USA, and the CSNE. (e-
mail: [email protected]).
R.P.N. Rao is with the department of Computer Science, University of
the CSNE. (e-mail:
Washington, Seattle, WA 98105 USA, and
[email protected]).
various regions of the brain based on electrocorticography
(ECoG) data.
Interpreting neural connectivity is a challenging problem
because cortical connectivity visualizations are largely
exploratory and require the encoding of many multivariate
attributes that exist for each pairwise edge, as each edge can
be its own high-dimensional correlation matrix. These
multiple metrics for each connection require an investment
of user time to navigate and interpret. Unlike social networks
or aggregate flow for which directed graphs are often
designed, neural connectivity is highly nonstationary through
time, and the set of descriptive statistics change rapidly. This
adds many potential encoding dimensions
for any
visualization tool, leading to a critical need for user
interactivity to explore data and formulate appropriate
questions. Fig. 1 highlights sources of data, and potential
dimensions along which a user may seek to subselect and
visualize the data.
Figure 1. a) Sources of ECoG signals, which can be generalized to any
spatially specific measurement of correlation. From these time series traces,
researchers calculate matrices of connectivity values. b) Connectivity
matrices often exist for various frequency bands of interest, and c) are often
complex valued. d) Various dimensions of matrix selection.
Our dataset explorations emphasize the use of the tool to
analyze pairwise connectivity
in ECoG datasets. The
utilization of our tool demonstrates a unique opportunity to
apply
interactive visualization
techniques, such as chord diagrams, dynamic querying and
selection, and interactivity, to exploratory neuroscience.
existing
extend
and
II. RELATED WORK AND MOTIVATION
Visualizing neural connectivity is a significant problem
in the field of neuroscience. Examples of current tools to
address this problem can be found in a centralized repository
named "The Neuroimaging Informatics Tools and Resources
Clearinghouse" (NITRC) [1] founded by the National
Institutes of Health (NIH), which hosts hundreds of tools
(mostly for MRI data) for the analysis and visualization of
Neuroimaging data. A subset of tools for MEG and ECoG
data are available as MATLAB plugins, which require
package download, a MATLAB license, and a user interface
with a powerful but complicated software suite. We propose
instead an open source, browser-based visualization toolkit.
in
leads
to occlusions
Other past visualization techniques include rendering
each anatomical location on a virtual cortex. However, this
approach often
the resulting
visualization due to the sheer number of overlapping
connection pairs. Additional techniques include static graphs
of frequency dependent functional connectivity through
undirected graphs based on fMRI data [2]. Of note is the
labeling of various anatomic locations in free space, with a
web of connections. While this common visualization
demonstrates connectivity between numerous nodes and
captures the connectivity of the system, we sought a more
intuitive way to represent connectivity.
in
A review of various methods [3] demonstrates different
approaches used
the past for demonstrating both
functional connectivity (correlations in activity between
various regions) and anatomic connectivity (fiber tract
density between regions). Visualization strategies range from
literal demonstration of the brain's anatomical structure, to
more abstract visualizations depicting the brain with nodes
and edges. We sought for our application a simple,
uncluttered
interface highlighting connectivity patterns
without requiring rotation to visualize obscured regions.
Other recent advances in visualization of neural data
include the folding of time curves to visualize patterns of
temporal activation [4] and stacking of adjacency matrices
representing temporal snapshots to visualize changes in
networks over time [5]. While these tools offer great
flexibility and exploratory depth in dealing with time series
data, we desired a simpler, more lightweight approach to
visualize connectivity matrices which were constant across a
time period. We wished to implement strategies similar to
the interactive pruning [5] and rapid exploratory nature of
the above tools. We also desired a tool agnostic to the
underlying data matrix, enabling the use of whichever
connectivity value the researcher desires.
III. METHODS AND IMPLEMENTATION
A. Visualization Architecture
Our visualization architecture, with corresponding static
screenshot, is shown in the schematic in Fig. 2a. A
correlation matrix (3D matrix of connectivity strengths at
various sensor locations and frequency ranges) is loaded into
a client-side JavaScript-enabled page in a desktop or mobile
browser via drag and drop or a browsing menu. The
correlation matrices, nested arrays in JavaScript Object
Notation (JSON) format, are loaded using HTML5 standards
compatible file handing routines. These datasets can be
generated by the end-user, by conversion from either a
Python numpy data file or a MATLAB data file, using our
included Python script. These two data formats represent the
vast majority of pairwise connectivity data in neuroscience.
The basis upon which our visualization builds upon is the
d3.js [6] implementation of Krzywinski's "circos" [7], which
we chose as a visualization technique for representing
pairwise
connections with minimal occlusion. Our
implementation can handle non-symmetric connectivity
matrices, where there is directional connectivity strengths
between nodes. For additional visualization dimensions, we
simultaneously plot dynamic bar charts between pairs of
electrodes across frequency bands, as well as a global
histogram that demonstrates the average strength across all
frequencies for all nodes. For the implementation to be
functionally usable, the interface must be extended with
interactivity that is rapid and responsive when selecting and
visualizing more information about pairwise connections.
The user selects a frequency range of interest, a statistical
measure of interest (absolute value or magnitude and phase
information, if both are present), the inclusion or exclusion
of self-connections, and then presses the "re-slice matrix and
render" button to submit the query and update the chord
diagram (Fig. 2b). This uses the JavaScript math.js library to
subselect and compute an average matrix slice across the
selected
frequencies. The browser-based controls use
JavaScript d3.js and jQuery controller frameworks to create
cross-platform,
responsive controls. The user-selected
threshold cutoff value dynamically prunes connections above
or below the selected strength from the diagram in real time.
A callback with active tweening of the arc and chord shapes
with d3 transitions conveys a smooth but rapid transition
between rendered frames (Fig. 3a).
Figure 2. a) Schematic overview of the approach to data visualization. b)
Example screenshot from the visualization highlighting the use of
subselection, thresholding, dynamic bar graph generation, and hover
feature.
As the color representation of nominal categories is
extremely important [8] and spatial information must be
accurately conveyed, we tailored a CIE L*a*b colorscale that
fades in two directions, as well as an L*c*h colorscale that
transitions in color unidirectionally (Fig. 3b). In this way, the
two CIE L*a*b colors correspond to spatial locations on our
ECoG grid. For datasets where spatial ordering is not as
clear,
the L*c*h unidirectional colorscale emphasizes
separability of nodes. Additional color files can be supplied
by the user to tailor the data conveyed by color.
B. User Interactions
Once the chord diagram is set up for visualization, the
user hovers over a node or a chord to display connection
strengths for that node, or between the two nodes specified
by a given chord. An additional user option for coloring via
mean phase angle of the connection uses a divergent color
palette
to show
differences between positive and negative phase angles in
complex data.
from ColorBrewer
(colorbrewer.org)
Upon clicking a chord, a bar graph dynamically updates
to display connection strengths across frequencies for the
two nodes of interest (Fig. 2b). By hovering over any bar in
the chart, the connectivity strength for that frequency will be
displayed. These features were implemented using the
"hover" and "on click" functionalities from JS and d3 (Fig.
3c, 3d). By revealing the connection strengths across all
frequencies, the user gains additional insight into the
topology of connectivity for two regions without losing the
global connectivity pattern provided by the chord diagram.
their data, allowing
For any selected set of frequencies, a histogram displays
all channel-by-channel connectivity values in a given
frequency range (Fig. 3b). Using interactive JS functionality,
users input a desired bin size to visualize different binnings
of
fine
visualizations. By the combination of dynamic features, and
three separate visualization strategies (chord diagram, bar
chart, and histogram), for the data, users can interpret their
datasets in a multifaceted manner without any software
downloads or programming.
rapid coarse and
for
Figure 3. a) Example screenshot illustrating rapid fade and tween pruning
using a single slider to select for maximally salient chords and remove
occlusion. Note that regions with similar colors convey a local group of
intra-region connections while dissimilar colors convey longer distance,
crosscortical connections. The user then has the option to color the chord
diagram based off anatomic locations from a file (if present), or in a
constant luminance scheme based off sequential order. b) A modified
L*a*b colorspace controlled for luminance for coloring arcs representing
spatial locations around the chord diagram to give the user rapid
assessment of sensor proximity. Hover-over functionality for both c) the bar
chart and d) chord diagram.
C. Sample analysis data
All provided datasets were acquired with written
informed consent through a protocol approved by the
University of Washington Institutional Review Board. Our
sample data sets are human ECoG datasets acquired during a
resting state, where the subject was not actively engaged in
any task. Data were processed for connectivity metrics [9].
IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The screenshot in Fig. 2b illustrates our visualization
tool. We use this tool to explore connectivity matrices of
differing values, including phase locking value (PLV) [9],
phase slope index (PSI), correlation, and coherence, as well
as intraclass correlation (ICC) of these measures over time
[10]. Of note is the ability of the application to handle
different statistical measures of connectivity, highlighting its
extensibility to other data types and data sets. Of note is that
our example involves symmetric connectivity, but our
application can handle non-symmetric matrices. In this
instance, the chord would be thicker near the node with the
greater value for the asymmetric matrix. This is useful when
looking at connections that are stronger in one causal
direction than another.
One particular application highlights (Fig. 4) the use of
our tool to explore ICC over three sessions of PLV in the
high gamma band (HG, 70-200 Hz in ECoG) between
various regions of the cortex across 9 subjects. PLV
describes the consistency of a phase difference between two
signals throughout time, while ICC is an ANOVA-based
metric for the evaluation of the stability of connections over
time across multiple individuals. The stationarity of brain
signals is a topic of research interest in assessing the function
and structure of cortical networks. HG signals in ECoG are
known to be associated with local synchronous neural
activity [11]. We use our application to first prune high
gamma (70-200 Hz in frequency) ICC values to a low ICC
value range (Fig. 4a), revealing widespread unstable
connections between regions. Although difficult to currently
interpret, this visualization allows us to further analyze these
highly unstable regions. Further exploration of high ICC
values demonstrates fewer, more local stable connections
over time (Fig. 4b). An example chord of interest illustrates
the high ICC between Brodmann areas regions 4 and 34,
representing a highly stable connection between motor and
entorhinal cortex. Entorhinal cortex is associated with spatial
processing [12], positing interesting questions to explore as
to why this region might have stable connections with motor
cortex. This finding highlights the use of our tool to explore
novel connectivity patterns uniquely available from human
electrophysiological recordings.
A different data set explored by our research group
assesses the spatial representation of connections across the
cortex. Using PLV as a metric, we first subselect and
visualize connectivity related to the beta band (13-30 Hz,
Fig. 5a) and PLV between 0.65 and 1. After switching to
high frequency (high gamma) PLV and thresholding for the
same values (Fig. 5b), we observe a different pattern of
connectivity. This emphasizes the utility of our tool as an
exploratory form of analysis to inform further inquiries.
Figure 4. ICC values in the high gamma (70-200 Hz in ECoG) range for
nine subjects. a) Low thresholded values, illustrating many long-range
unstable connections. b) High thresholded values, illustrating fewer, mostly
local, stable connections. We highlight the connection between Brodmann
areas 4 and 34, motor cortex and entorhinal cortex, respectively.
Our results for test matrices of size 65x64x64 and
5x64x64 reveal re-rendering and math.js processing
within 500 ms to a second depending on the user's' machine.
Code profiling revealed the bottlenecks to be in the
math.js processing and computations on matrices, so in
the event of matrices orders of magnitude larger than our
current ones, we may need
to consider alternative
approaches. Since the visualization tool does not require any
additional software packages, this is a significant advantage
over existing tools that may require MATLAB or other
software on the end user's computer.
In conclusion, we demonstrate a browser-based, open
source, easy to use application to quickly visualize, prune,
reslice and explore complex data matrices encoding
relationships between pairwise nodes.
Figure 5. PLV values for a single subject. a) Beta Band (13-30 Hz)
displaying local, looping connections. b) High gamma, 70-200 Hz),
displaying a different pattern of connectivity.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors acknowledge Dr. Emily Fox, Dr. Nick Foti,
and Dr. Jeffrey Heer for conversation and feedback. The
authors would also like to thank all the patients who
willingly contributed to the data presented in this paper.
DISCLAIMER
The views expressed are solely those of the authors and
do not reflect the views of the National Institutes of Health
or the National Science Foundation.
SOFTWARE LINKS
Overview - http://uwgridlab.github.io/Affinity/
Software - http://uwgridlab.github.io/Affinity/main.html
REFERENCES
[1] "NITRC: Human Imaging Database (HID): Tool/Resource Info."
[Online]. Available: https://www.nitrc.org/projects/hid/.
[2] R. Salvador, J. Suckling, C. Schwarzbauer, and E. Bullmore,
"Undirected graphs of frequency-dependent functional connectivity in
whole brain networks.," Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. Biol. Sci.,
vol. 360, no. 1457, pp. 937–946, 2005.
[3] B. Alper, B. Bach, N. Henry Riche, T. Isenberg, and J.-D. Fekete,
"Weighted graph comparison techniques for brain connectivity
analysis," Proc. SIGCHI Conf. Hum. Factors Comput. Syst. - CHI
'13, p. 483, 2013.
[4] B. Bach et al., "Time Curves : Folding Time to Visualize Patterns of
Temporal Evolution in Data To cite this version : Time Curves :
Folding Time to Visualize Patterns of Temporal Evolution in Data,"
2015.
[5] B. Bach, N. Henry-Riche, T. Dwyer, T. Madhyastha, J.-D. Fekete, and
T. Grabowski, "Small MultiPiles: Piling Time to Explore Temporal
Patterns in Dynamic Networks," Comput. Graph. Forum, vol. 34, no.
3, pp. 31–40, 2015.
[6] M. Bostock, V. Ogievetsky, and J. Heer, "D³ Data-Driven
Documents," IEEE Trans. Vis. Comput. Graph., vol. 17, no. 12, pp.
2301–2309, Dec. 2011.
[7] M. Krzywinski et al., "Circos: An information aesthetic for
comparative genomics," Genome Res., vol. 19, no. 9, pp. 1639–1645,
2009.
[8] J. Heer and M. Bostock, "Crowdsourcing Graphical Perception: Using
Mechanical Turk to Assess Visualization Design," Proc. 28th Annu.
Chi Conf. Hum. Factors Comput. Syst., pp. 203–212, 2010.
[9] K. Casimo et al., "Regional Patterns of Cortical Phase Synchrony in
the Resting State," Brain Connect., vol. 6, no. 6, pp. 470-481, Jul.
2016.
[10] K. O. McGraw and S. P. Wong, "Forming inferences about some
intraclass correlations coefficients," Psychol. Methods, vol. 1, no. 1,
pp. 30–46, 1996.
[11] S. Ray, N. E. Crone, E. Niebur, P. J. Franaszczuk, and S. S. Hsiao,
"Neural Correlates of High-Gamma Oscillations (60-200 Hz) in
Macaque Local Field Potentials and Their Potential Implications in
Electrocorticography," J. Neurosci., vol. 28, no. 45, pp. 11526–
11536, Nov. 2008.
[12] J. J. Knierim, J. P. Neunuebel, and S. S. Deshmukh, "Functional
correlates of the lateral and medial entorhinal cortex : objects , path
integration and local – global reference frames," Philos. Trans. R.
Soc., vol. 369, no. 1635, 2014.
|
1508.04751 | 5 | 1508 | 2016-03-24T15:10:45 | On Contextuality in Behavioral Data | [
"q-bio.NC",
"quant-ph"
] | Dzhafarov, Zhang, and Kujala (Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. A 374, 20150099) reviewed several behavioral data sets imitating the formal design of the quantum-mechanical contextuality experiments. The conclusion was that none of these data sets exhibited contextuality if understood in the generalized sense proposed in Dzhafarov, Kujala, and Larsson (Found. Phys. 7, 762-782, 2015), while the traditional definition of contextuality does not apply to these data because they violate the condition of consistent connectedness (also known as marginal selectivity, no-signaling condition, no-disturbance principle, etc.). In this paper we clarify the relationship between (in)consistent connectedness and (non)contextuality, as well as between the traditional and extended definitions of (non)contextuality, using as an example the Clauser-Horn-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequalities originally designed for detecting contextuality in entangled particles. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
On Contextuality in Behavioral Data
Ehtibar N. Dzhafarov1, Janne V. Kujala2, Víctor H. Cervantes1, Ru Zhang1,
and Matt Jones3
1Purdue University, [email protected]
2University of Jyväskylä, [email protected]
3University of Colorado, [email protected]
Abstract
Dzhafarov, Zhang, and Kujala (Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. A 374,
20150099) reviewed several behavioral data sets imitating the formal de-
sign of the quantum-mechanical contextuality experiments. The con-
clusion was that none of these data sets exhibited contextuality if un-
derstood in the generalized sense proposed in Dzhafarov, Kujala, and
Larsson (Found. Phys. 7, 762-782, 2015), while the traditional defini-
tion of contextuality does not apply to these data because they violate
the condition of consistent connectedness (also known as marginal se-
lectivity, no-signaling condition, no-disturbance principle, etc.).
In this
paper we clarify the relationship between (in)consistent connectedness
and (non)contextuality, as well as between the traditional and extended
definitions of (non)contextuality, using as an example the Clauser-Horn-
Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequalities originally designed for detecting con-
textuality in entangled particles.
1 Introduction
This paper is based on two talks given at the conference Quantum Theory: From
Foundations to Technologies organized by Andrei Khrennikov at the Linnaeus
University in Växjö, Sweden. The content of these talks has been to a large
extent published elsewhere [1–5], and the present paper focuses on one specific
aspect of these talks: the relationship between (in)consistent connectedness and
(non)contextuality. This focus was prompted by a recent extensive exchange
of personal communications involving a few of our colleagues and related to
a new experiment announced by Aerts and Sozzo [6]. The issue in question
is by no means new:
it was in fact raised and discussed in Ref. [7], using as
an example an experiment by Aerts, Gabora, and Sozzo [8]. Later, this issue
has become a central one in the development of our approach to contextuality,
called Contextuality-by-Default (CbD) [1–5,9–12]. It has become clear from the
1
2
discussion in question, however, that there are still serious disagreements about
this issue. The aim of this paper is to offer a resolution for these disagreements
and to dispel possible conceptual confusions.
Although prompted by a discussion of Ref. [6], this paper is not meant to
be a critique of that or any particular paper. We use the experiment presented
in Ref. [6] and the paradigm in which it was conducted only as an example,
one providing an opportunity to demonstrate the workings of our theory of
contextuality and to make our points. We would like therefore to play down the
critical aspects of this paper.
2 A list of important terms and notation conven-
tions
Special terms used in this paper are rigorously defined and every notation con-
vention is stipulated. The reader may, however, find it useful to consult the
following list from time to time to recall a term or to more easily find where it
is systematically discussed.
Measurements (random variables). The generic notation for random vari-
q, interpreted as the measurement of property q in context c. If c can
ables is Rc
be c1, . . . , cm and q can be q1, . . . , qn, then instead of Rcj
i (see
Section 3).
qi we write Rj
In the "Alice-Bob" variant of cyclic-4 systems (Sections 3 and 8), we re-
q for the measurements by A-B notation, with the
place the general notation Rc
following table of correspondences:
A11 B11 A12 B12 A21 B21 A22 B22
3 R3
R1
2 R3
3 R2
1 R1
2 R4
1 R4
4 R2
.
(1)
4
The logic of these correspondences is explained in Section 8, (25) and (26).
In a set of measurements: a subset of all Rc
Bunches and connections.
q
with the same c and different qs forms a bunch of measurements representing
context c; a subset of all Rc
q with the same q and different cs forms a connection
of measurements representing property q (Section 3).
Consistent connectedness. Some connections have a certain property, (2),
that makes them consistent; and a system of measurements with all its con-
nections consistent is consistently connected. (See Sections 3 and 5.) The term
is close to such terms as no-signaling, no-disturbance, etc., but void of their
physical connotations.
(Non)contextuality of a consis-
Contextual and noncontextual systems.
tently connected system of measurements is defined in Section 6, Definition 6.4.
3
The general definition of (non)contextuality, for arbitrary systems, is given in
Section 7, Definition 7.1.
Couplings: S-notation and T -notation. The notion of (non)contextuality
is based on the notion of a (probabilistic) coupling. Definition 6.1 defines the
couplings for cyclic-4 systems, and the subsequent remarks explain how the
definition applies to arbitrarily-connected systems of random variables.
When a coupling is constructed for all measurements in a cyclic-4 system,
q in this system we denote its counterpart in the coupling by Sc
q
then for each Rc
(Definition 6.1).
When a coupling is constructed for only a part of a cyclic-4 system, specif-
forming a connection, then the
ically for pairs of the measurements Rc
corresponding elements of the coupling are denoted T c
(Definition 6.2).
q, Rc′
q
q , T c′
q
3 Systems of measurements
Of the two concepts characterizing a system of measurements, (in)consistent
connectedness and (non)contextuality, the former is about distributions of the
measurements of one and the same property in different contexts, whereas the
latter is about the (im)possibility of imposing certain joint distributions on all
the measurements, for all properties and all contexts involved.
q and Rc′
Let a property q be measured in contexts c and c′. These measurements
q . The property q may be a spin in a given particle
can be denoted Rc
along a given axis, and the contexts c and c′ may be defined by what other spins
(say, in other particles) are measured together with this one. Outside physics,
the property q may be a question, and the contexts c and c′ may be defined by
whether this question was asked first or following another question. Examples
can be easily multiplied, within physics and without. The measurements Rc
q
and Rc′
q are two different random variables, and their distributions can be the
same or different. If they are the same, we write
Rc
q ∼ Rc′
q ,
(2)
and if this distributional equality holds for any q and any contexts c, c′ in which q
is measured, we say that the system of measurements is consistently connected.
This term derives from the term connection that we use to denote a set of
all measurements of a given property in all contexts in which it is measured.
For instance, if property q is measured in three contexts, c, c′, c′′, and in no
q, Rc′
q , Rc′′
q o is the connection for q. Consistent
other contexts, then the set nRc
connectedness is known under many different names: no-signaling condition [13],
marginal selectivity [9, 14, 15], no-disturbance principle [16], etc. (see Ref. [17]
for a few other terms).
Contextuality is about all measurements Rc
q composing a system. Such a
system can always be viewed as a set of bunches, where a bunch is defined
as the set of all measurements made within a given context. For instance,
let q, q′, q′′ be measured in a context c (e.g., q, q′, q′′ are three spins measured
simultaneously, or three questions asked of one and the same person), and let
4
no other properties be measured in that context. Then the set (cid:8)Rc
the bunch (of measurements) representing the context c. The random variables
within a bunch are jointly distributed, which means that they can be viewed as
a single ("vector-valued") random variable.
q′′(cid:9) is
q′ , Rc
q, Rc
Assuming the numbers of the properties and the contexts are finite, one can
present the system of measurements in the form of a matrix, in which rows cor-
respond to the properties {q1, . . . , qn} and columns to the contexts {c1, . . . , cm},
and each cell (i, j) is filled with the measurement Rj
i if qi is measured in context
cj (and is left empty otherwise).
...
Rj
i
...
connection for qi
(3)
· · ·
· · ·
bunch representing cj
The random variables in any row of this matrix form a connection for the cor-
responding property, and those in any column form a bunch representing the
corresponding context.
We will focus in this paper on a special system of measurements, a cyclic sys-
tem of rank 4 [1,4,5], or cyclic-4 system for short. Its best known implementation
is the "Alice-Bob" version of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-Bohm system (EPR-
B, where B can also stand for Bell). This system has been prominently studied
in relation to contextuality since John Bell's pioneering work [18, 19], although
the conceptual framework used in quantum physics (entanglement, nonlocality)
initially did not include contextuality explicitly. Outside quantum physics the
term "nonlocality" rarely makes sense, and "entanglement", if it does make sense
(even if only metaphorical), can always be taken as a possible "explanation" for
contextuality, if observed. We will return to the EPR-B implementation of the
cyclic-4 system in Section 8.
The system in question can be presented in the format of the matrix (3) as
follows:
1
1
c1
q1 R1
q2 R1
q3
q4
c2
·
2 R2
· R2
·
c3
c4
· R4
·
·
3 R3
·
· R3
4 R4
3
4
2
(4)
We will change the notation later, in Section 8, to conform with the traditional
interpretation of the properties and contexts involved, e.g., in a pair of two
entangled particles. For now, one can think of any four properties measured
in any four contexts so that (a) each context contains two properties measured
together; (b) each property is measured in two different contexts; (c) no two
contexts share more than one property; and (d) each measurement is a binary
random variable, with values ±1.
5
4 Traditional understanding of contextuality in
cyclic-4 systems
The traditional understanding of contextuality in the cyclic-4 paradigm can be
presented as follows. Let us assume the measurements Rc
q of any property
q in the contexts c, c′ in which it is measured to be in fact one and the same
random variable, R∗
q. This assumption can be referred to as that of context-
irrelevance, and in many traditional treatments it is made implicitly, by the
virtue of indexing the measurements by the properties being measured but not
by the contexts. The assumption implies that our matrix (4) can be written as
q, Rc′
1
c1
q1 R∗
q2 R∗
q3
q4
c2
·
2 R∗
· R∗
·
c3
c4
· R∗
·
·
3 R∗
·
4 R∗
· R∗
2
1
4
3
(5)
immediately and trivially implying consistent connectedness: e.g., R∗
together with R∗
measured together with R∗
by the same symbol R∗
distribution.
1 measured
2 in context c1 is precisely the same random variable as R∗
4 in context c4 (otherwise they could not be denoted
1); and, of course, a fixed random variable has a fixed
1
It is easy to show that if random variables are understood within the frame-
work of the classical, Kolmogorovian probability theory (KPT), then the four
4} in system (5) possess a joint distribution. In-
random variables {R∗
deed, the random variables (R∗
2) in context c1 are jointly distributed, which
means that they are two measurable functions defined on the same probability
space S,
2, R∗
1, R∗
3, R∗
1, R∗
R∗
1 : S → {−1, +1} , R∗
2 : S → {−1, +1} .
(6)
[More precisely, S is a set in a probability space (S, Σ, µ), where Σ is a sigma-
algebra (set of events) on S and µ some probability measure. A function X :
S → {−1, +1} is measurable (and therefore X is a random variable) if the set
of values mapped into +1 is an event (i.e., it belongs to Σ, and therefore has
a well-defined probability value). We conveniently confuse the set S with the
probability space containing S.]
The random variables (R∗
4) in context c4 are also jointly distributed,
4 are measurable functions on the same probability space. This
1 in the contexts c1
whence R∗
must be the same space S as above because the variable R∗
and c4 is the same. Hence
1, R∗
1, R∗
R∗
4 : S → {−1, +1} .
(7)
Finally, in context c2, the random variables (R∗
we conclude that
2, R∗
3) are jointly distributed, and
R∗
3 : S → {−1, +1} .
(8)
6
As a result, all four random variables in (4) are measurable functions defined
on the same probability space, i.e., they are jointly distributed.
[There is a naive way of arriving at the same conclusion, by assuming that
in the KPT any set of random variables is jointly distributed. This view is
untenable [9, 11].]
1, R∗
3, R∗
2, R∗
2, R∗
Now, the joint distribution of {R∗
4} is unobservable, because
3} or
no two measurements made in two different contexts (such as {R∗
4}), "co-occur" in any empirical meaning of "co-occurrence". One can
{R∗
only observe (i.e., estimate from observed frequencies of co-occurrences) the
distributions of four specific subsets of {R∗
4}, the pairs of random
variables forming the columns of matrix (5). We have the following theorem
about these pairs that was first proved, mutatis mutandis, in Ref. [20]. In its
formulation, h·i denotes expected value, and the maximum is taken over all
combinations of + and − signs replacing ± so that the number of the − signs
is odd (1 or 3).
2, R∗
1, R∗
3, R∗
1, R∗
Theorem 4.1. In any system described by (5),
(± hR∗
1R∗
2i ± hR∗
2R∗
3i ± hR∗
3R∗
4i ± hR∗
4R∗
1i) ≤ 2.
(9)
max
odd number
of − 's
3, R∗
2, R∗
1, R∗
2, R∗
The inequality (9) is usually presented as a necessary condition for the ex-
4}, implying that (9) can be
istence of a joint distribution of {R∗
1, R∗
4} do not have a joint distribution and we
violated, in which case {R∗
3, R∗
say that the cyclic-4 system is contextual. This understanding, however, lacks
logical rigor. If the left-hand side of (9) can be computed at all, then the ex-
1i in it are well-defined, whence each of the
pected products hR∗
1R∗
1) has a well-defined joint distribution.
corresponding pairs (R∗
But then, as we have seen, the entire set {R∗
4} has to have a joint
distribution too, and then, by Theorem 4.1, (9) must hold. It simply cannot be
violated.
2i , . . . , hR∗
1, R∗
2) , . . . , (R∗
4, R∗
1, R∗
3, R∗
2, R∗
4R∗
Put differently but equivalently, if {R∗
4} do not possess a joint
2, R∗
1) forming
distribution, then at least two of the four pairs (R∗
2) , . . . , (R∗
columns of matrix (5) do not have joint distributions (because a global joint
distribution follows from any three of these pairs being jointly distributed). But
if this is the case, the left-hand side of (9) simply cannot be computed.
3, R∗
1, R∗
1, R∗
4, R∗
5 Consistent connectedness and contextuality in
traditional understanding
One can be easily confused by the reasoning above, because it may seem that
it is trivial to construct a system (5) in which all four expected products
1i are well-defined while (9) is violated (and it is routinely
hR∗
claimed that quantum mechanics predicts such situations and experiments con-
firm these predictions). This seemingly trivial possibility, however, is merely
2i , . . . , hR∗
1R∗
4R∗
7
Table 1: Example in which the left-hand side of (9) is seemingly well-defined
and exceeds 2. Since this is mathematically impossible, there should be a hidden
assumption here that is false.
R∗
1
R∗
3
+1
−1
+1
−1
R∗
2
+1 −1
0
1/2
0
1/2
1/2
1/2
+1 −1
0
1/2
0
1/2
1/2
1/2
1/2
1/2
1/2
1/2
R∗
4
+1 −1
0
1/2
0
1/2
1/2
1/2
+1 −1
0
1/2
0
1/2
1/2
1/2
1/2
1/2
1/2
1/2
+1
−1
+1
−1
an illusion, because such a construction would be one of a mathematically self-
contradictory system. One example is given by the four distributions in Table 1,
where entries within the 2 × 2 interiors are joint probabilities, while the margins
show marginal probabilities. The expected products here are
hR∗
1R∗
1i = 1,
2i = hR∗
2R∗
3i = − hR∗
3R∗
4i = hR∗
4R∗
and the left-hand side of (9) is 4, violating the inequality. As this system is
mathematically impossible, we must have made an assumption that this con-
tradiction demonstrates to be false.
1 are R∗
1 are R∗
What might this assumption be? Can it be that R∗
2 are not jointly
distributed, or that they are not well-defined random variables? The answer
is clearly negative: R∗
2 are observed empirically and jointly. The same
reasoning applies to the remaining three pairs: in each pair the two random vari-
ables are well-defined and jointly distributed. The only possible error therefore
is in the identity of these random variables across different contexts: we have
assumed, e.g., that R∗
2 is the same random variable
4. It must be wrong to label the measurements
as R∗
by the measured properties only, ignoring the contexts.
3 measured together with R∗
3 measured together with R∗
This means that a correct initial representation of the system would be as
in Table 2, with the random variables contextually labeled, so that the pairs
of measurements forming different bunches do not overlap. If one makes the
assumption that, for any property q and any two contexts c, c′, the measure-
ments Rc
q, then this
assumption is rejected by reductio ad absurdum: if it were correct, (9) would
have to hold, and it does not.
q in this matrix are "one and the same variable" R∗
q and Rc′
Below we will present a rigorous way of formulating the hypothesis that
random variables measuring the same property in different contexts are (in
some sense) "the same". We already have, however, sufficient clarity about
this hypothesis to address the often misunderstood question of the relationship,
within the framework of this hypothesis, between the concepts of consistent
connectedness and contextuality.
8
Table 2: Example of Table 1 without the assumption of context-irrelevance:
the identity of measurements (random variables) depends not only on what is
measured but also on the context in which it is measured.
R1
1
R2
3
+1
−1
+1
−1
R1
2
+1 −1
0
1/2
0
1/2
1/2
1/2
+1 −1
0
1/2
0
1/2
1/2
1/2
R2
2
1/2
1/2
1/2
1/2
+1
−1
+1
−1
R4
4
+1 −1
0
1/2
0
1/2
1/2
1/2
+1 −1
0
1/2
0
1/2
1/2
1/2
R3
4
1/2
1/2
1/2
1/2
R4
1
R3
3
It is clear that the assumption of consistent connectedness can be formulated
and, in special cases, even justified without assuming context-irrelevance. Its
formulation for the cyclic-4 system presented in the form (4) is
R4
R2
1 ∼ R1
3 ∼ R3
1, R1
3, R3
2 ∼ R2
2,
4 ∼ R4
4.
(10)
Such a hypothesis can often be entertained without assuming that the identi-
cally distributed random variables are "the same". For instance, in the classical
entanglement paradigm for two electrons, property 1 corresponds to Alice's
choice of a certain axis in her particle, and the context c1 is defined by Bob's
simultaneously choosing axis 2 in his particle, while the context c4 is defined
by Bob's simultaneously choosing axis 4 (on labeling Alice's two axes 1,3, and
Bob's two axes 2,4). If the two particles are space-like separated, one should
assume that Bob's settings cannot influence Alice's measurements, which im-
1. No physical
plies the distribution of R1
principle prevents one, however, from viewing R1
1 as different random
variables with one and the same distribution. We have seen already that one's
denying this view leads to a mathematical contradiction.
1 is the same as the distribution of R4
1 and R4
The expected products in (9) also can be written without regard to the
2R∗
3i
context-irrelevance hypothesis. One can replace hR∗
1R∗
1R1
2i with (cid:10)R1
3(cid:11), etc. to obtain the following analogue of inequality (9):
1(cid:11)(cid:1) ≤ 2.
3(cid:11) ±(cid:10)R3
2(cid:11) ±(cid:10)R2
4(cid:11) ±(cid:10)R4
(cid:0)±(cid:10)R1
2R2
1R1
3R3
4R4
2(cid:11), hR∗
2R2
with (cid:10)R2
max
odd number
of − 's
(11)
Using this formulation, Theorem 4.1 can be understood as stating that (11) holds
under the context-irrelevance hypothesis. If this hypothesis does not hold, (11)
does not have to be satisfied and therefore cannot be derived as a theorem. One
can always check whether it holds or not, but the outcome has no known to
us interpretation if Rc
q are not assumed always to be the same. Now,
q and Rc′
9
the context-irrelevance hypothesis simply cannot be entertained if consistent
connectedness is violated: "one and the same" random variable cannot have two
different distributions. There is therefore no reason for checking the inequality
(11) if (10) does not hold.
The only exception can be made in an imaginary situation wherein the con-
sistency of connectedness is not known (e.g., it is not established in a statistically
reliable way), but one knows (in a statistically reliable way) that the inequality
(11) is violated. In this case one can reject the context-irrelevance hypothesis by
the following reasoning: (i) if the system is consistently connected, then the hy-
pothesis of context-irrelevance leads to (11), which is rejected; (ii) if the system
is not consistently connected, the hypothesis of context-irrelevance is rejected
as well; (iii) hence this hypothesis is rejected.
6 Traditional understanding of contextuality trans-
lated into the CbD language
q and Rc′
q (c 6= c′) are a priori different
In accordance with the CbD approach, Rc
random variables, and since they are never observed "together" (in any empiri-
cally grounded sense of this word), they do not posses a joint distribution. The
conceptual coherence and advantages offered by this understanding of random
variables recorded in different contexts has been discussed in Refs. [1,11,21]. In
the framework of KPT this means that Rc
q are functions defined on two
different probability spaces:
q and Rc′
Rc
q : Sc → {−1, +1} , Rc′
q : Sc′ → {−1, +1} .
(12)
It is therefore impossible to hypothesize that Rc
"the same". Nor is it possible to treat these Rc
equal to each other",
q and Rc′
q (c 6= c′) are in fact
q as "different but always
q and Rc′
PrhRc
q = Rc′
q i = 1,
(13)
since this statement also implies a joint distribution of (cid:16)Rc
into Sc = Sc′.
q, Rc′
q (cid:17), translating
To formulate the analogue of the context-irrelevance hypothesis within the
framework of CbD one has to use the foundational notion of a (probabilistic)
coupling.
Definition 6.1. A coupling for the cyclic-4 system (4) is a set of eight jointly
distributed random variables
such that
1 , S 1
(cid:0)S 1
2(cid:1) ∼ (cid:0)R1
4(cid:1) ∼ (cid:0)R3
1 , S 1
3 , S 3
(cid:0)S 1
(cid:0)S 3
1, R1
3, R3
2(cid:1) ,
4(cid:1) ,
2 , S 2
4 , S 4
(cid:0)S 2
(cid:0)S 4
2 , S 2
2, S 2
3 , S 3
3 , S 3
4 , S 4
4 , S 4
1(cid:1)
3(cid:1) ∼ (cid:0)R2
1(cid:1) ∼ (cid:0)R4
2, R2
4, R4
3(cid:1) ,
1(cid:1) .
(14)
(15)
10
In other words, the bunches of the system are distributed as the correspond-
ing marginals of the coupling. A system has generally an infinity of couplings.
The notion of a coupling is not confined to cyclic-4 systems. It applies to any
system of random variables, the idea being that (a) the coupling is a set of jointly
distributed random variables in a one-to-one correspondence with the variables
constituting the system being coupled; and (b) the observable parts of this
system are distributed in the same way as the corresponding marginals (subsets,
or subcouplings) of the coupling. In particular, the system being coupled can be
a connection of the cyclic-4 system.
Recall that the connection for property q is the set of all random variables
In the cyclic-4 system the connection for
measuring q in different contexts.
1, R4
1(cid:9), for property 2 it is (cid:8)R1
matrix (4). Each of these connections taken in isolation has its couplings.
property 1 is (cid:8)R1
Definition 6.2. A pair of jointly distributed random variables nT c
coupling of a connection nRc
2(cid:9), etc., along the rows of the
q o is a
q , T c′
q, Rc′
2, R2
q o in a cyclic-4 system if
q ∼ Rc
T c
q,
q ∼ Rc′
T c′
q .
(16)
q , T c′
The coupling nT c
attain equal values, PrhT c
q o is called maximal if the probability with which T c
q , T c′
q o.
q i, is maximal among all couplings ofnRc
q, Rc′
Another way of stating the second part of the definition is that PrhT c
q i
q = T c′
q , which are
is as large as it is allowed to be by the distributions of T c
fixed by (16). The following theorem says that this concept is well-defined.
q and T c′
q = T c′
q
Theorem 6.3 (Refs. [1, 5]). A maximal coupling nT c
nRc
q o of a connection
q o in a cyclic-4 system exists and its distribution is unique: it is defined
q , T c′
q, Rc′
by (16) and
or equivalently,
DT c
q T c′
q E = 1 −(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:10)T c
q i = 1 −(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
PrhT c
q E(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
= 1 −(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:10)Rc
q(cid:11) −DT c′
q = 1(cid:3) − PrhRc′
Pr(cid:2)Rc
q E(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
q(cid:11) −DRc′
q = 1i(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
q = T c′
.
,
(17)
(18)
The notion of a maximal coupling and the existence part of the theorem
above can be generalized to arbitrary systems [2, 5, 21], but in this paper we
focus on the cyclic-4 systems only.
It is easy to see that if a cyclic-4 system is consistently connected, i.e., if
q(cid:11) = DRc′
(cid:10)Rc
connection nRc
q E for all q, c, c′, then in a maximal coupling nT c
q, Rc′
q E = 1, or equivalently,
q o we have DT c
q T c′
PrhT c
q = T c′
q i = 1.
q , T c′
q o of any
(19)
11
In other words, in a maximal coupling the measurements in a connection are
modeled as being essentially "the same". This simple observation allows us to
make use of the notion of maximal couplings in the following rigorous version
of the traditional understanding of contextuality.
Definition 6.4. A consistently connected cyclic-4 system (4) is noncontextual
if it has a coupling (14) in which (cid:0)S 1
mal couplings for the corresponding connections(cid:0)R1
1(cid:1) ,(cid:0)S 1
i.e., if
1 , S 4
2 , S 2
2(cid:1) ,(cid:0)S 2
1, R4
3 , S 3
3(cid:1) ,(cid:0)S 3
2, R2
4 , S 4
4(cid:1) are maxi-
2(cid:1) ,(cid:0)R2
3(cid:1) ,(cid:0)R3
3, R3
4, R4
4(cid:1),
1(cid:1) ,(cid:0)R1
2(cid:3) = 1,
4(cid:3) = 1.
1 = S 4
3 = S 3
Pr(cid:2)S 1
Pr(cid:2)S 2
1(cid:3) = 1, Pr(cid:2)S 1
3(cid:3) = 1, Pr(cid:2)S 3
2 = S 2
4 = S 4
If such a coupling does not exist, the system is contextual.
(20)
This definition allows one to preserve the spirit of the traditional understand-
q are always "the same") while
ing (the context-irrelevance hypothesis: Rc
q are not only different,
adhering to the logic of the CbD approach: Rc
they are not even stochastically interrelated. From this point of view, the follow-
ing theorem, first proved mutatis mutandis by Fine in Refs [22,23], summarizes
the traditional analysis of contextuality for the cyclic-4 systems.
q and Rc′
q and Rc′
Theorem 6.5. A consistently connected cyclic-4 system (4) is noncontextual
(by Definition 6.4) if and only if (11) is satisfied.
This is a special case of the theorem 7.2 below, which in turn is a special
case of a theorem proved in Ref. [4] (see also Refs. [1, 2, 5, 21]) that applies to a
broad class of cyclic systems, of which cyclic-4 ones are a special case.
7 A general definition and criterion of contextu-
ality in the CbD framework
The fact that we relate Definition 6.4 to the notion of maximal couplings for
connections reflects the intuition we are guided by and suggests a natural way
of generalizing contextuality beyond consistently connected systems.
The intuition in question can be explicated as follows. For an inconsistently
connected system, we interpret the non-coincidence of the distributions of Rc
q
and Rc′
q as evidence that changes in context, c → c′, "directly" influence the mea-
surement of q. For instance, in the Alice-Bob entanglement paradigm, if the two
measurements are time-like separated, Alice's choice of the spin axis can influ-
ence Bob's measurement along a given axis. This is referred to as "signaling".
It is also possible that a Charlie who receives information from both Alice and
Bob and records both their settings and their measurement results makes sys-
tematic errors in recording Bob's results depending on Alice's settings. This is
referred to as "context-dependent biases". Whatever the cause, when we model
these "direct" influences by a coupling nT c
q , T c′
q o of nRc
q, Rc′
q o, we translate the
differences in distributions into differences in values: as c changes into c′, the
q changes into a corresponding value of T c′
q . In a maximal coupling
value of T c
we do this in the maximally conservative way: the values of T c
q remain
the same as often as it is allowed by their individual distributions (in particular,
they remain always the same if the distributions are the same). Modeling by
q and T c′
12
such a coupling is always possible if nRc
q, Rc′
q o is coupled in isolation. Now, if
this is also possible for all the connections taken together, within the framework
of an overall coupling of the entire system, we can say that direct influences are
sufficient to account for the system. If, however, this is not possible, then the
maximal couplings for different connections are not mutually compatible: we
interpret this as evidence that we need more than direct influences to account
for the system. This "more" is what we call contextuality, as distinct from direct
influences.
The generalization of Definition 6.4 to arbitrary systems of measurement
therefore is straightforward: one can simply drop the qualification "consistently
connected" and use the general form of Theorem 6.3.
Definition 7.1. A cyclic-4 system (4) is noncontextual if it has a coupling (14)
3 , S 3
2 , S 2
1 , S 4
1, R4
in which (cid:0)S 1
3(cid:1) ,(cid:0)S 3
2(cid:1) ,(cid:0)S 2
corresponding connections (cid:0)R1
1(cid:1) ,(cid:0)R1
1(cid:3) = 1 −(cid:12)(cid:12)Pr(cid:2)R1
2(cid:3) = 1 −(cid:12)(cid:12)Pr(cid:2)R1
3(cid:3) = 1 −(cid:12)(cid:12)Pr(cid:2)R2
4(cid:3) = 1 −(cid:12)(cid:12)Pr(cid:2)R3
1(cid:1) ,(cid:0)S 1
Pr(cid:2)S 1
Pr(cid:2)S 1
Pr(cid:2)S 2
Pr(cid:2)S 3
1 = S 4
2 = S 2
3 = S 3
4 = S 4
4 , S 4
2, R2
3, R3
4, R4
4(cid:1), i.e., if
4(cid:1) are maximal couplings for the
2(cid:1) ,(cid:0)R2
1 = 1(cid:3) − Pr(cid:2)R4
2 = 1(cid:3) − Pr(cid:2)R2
3 = 1(cid:3) − Pr(cid:2)R3
4 = 1(cid:3) − Pr(cid:2)R4
3(cid:1) ,(cid:0)R3
1 = 1(cid:3)(cid:12)(cid:12) ,
2 = 1(cid:3)(cid:12)(cid:12) ,
3 = 1(cid:3)(cid:12)(cid:12) ,
4 = 1(cid:3)(cid:12)(cid:12) .
(21)
This is arguably the most conservative generalization of Definition 6.4, but
it is sufficient to deal with all conceivable cyclic-4 systems. The correspondingly
generalized version of Theorem 6.5 is as follows [1, 4, 5, 12].
Theorem 7.2. A cyclic-4 system (4) is noncontextual if and only if
CHSH − ICC ≤ 2,
(cid:0)±(cid:10)R1
1R1
2R2
2(cid:11) ±(cid:10)R2
3R3
3(cid:11) ±(cid:10)R3
4(cid:11) ±(cid:10)R4
4R4
(22)
(23)
1(cid:11)(cid:1) ,
where
CHSH =
max
odd number
of − 's
and
ICC = (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:10)R1
1(cid:11) −(cid:10)R4
1(cid:11)(cid:12)(cid:12) +(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:10)R1
2(cid:11) −(cid:10)R2
2(cid:11)(cid:12)(cid:12) +(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:10)R2
3(cid:11) −(cid:10)R3
3(cid:11)(cid:12)(cid:12) +(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:10)R3
4(cid:11) −(cid:10)R4
4(cid:11)(cid:12)(cid:12) . (24)
The abbreviations in this theorem are as follows. CHSH is the left-hand side
expression in the classical CHSH inequality (11), named so after the authors of
Ref. [20]. ICC is a measure of inconsistency of the connectedness [1, 5, 12]: if it
is zero, then the criterion (22) reduces to the CHSH inequality (11), and the
theorem above reduces to Theorem 6.5.
13
Table 3: An inconsistently connected cyclic-4 system. In accordance with the
general Definition 7.1, the system is contextual if and only if p is not 0 or
1.
In accordance with the narrow (traditional) Definition 6.4, the notion of
contextuality is not applicable unless p = 1/2; in all other cases the criterion
(11) is not derivable and the value of CHSH is not interpretable.
R1
1
+1
−1
R2
3
+1
−1
R1
2
+1 −1
0
1/2
0
1/2
1/2
1/2
+1 −1
0
1/2
0
1/2
1/2
1/2
R2
2
1/2
1/2
1/2
1/2
R4
4
+1
−1
+1
−1
+1 −1
0
1/2
0
1/2
1/2
1/2
−1
+1
0
p
0
p
1 − p
1 − p
R3
4
1/2
1/2
R4
1
p
1 − p
R3
3
To illustrate the computations, consider the modification of the example of
Table 2 in Table 3. The value of CHSH in the system is 4, the same maximal
possible value as in Table 2. But
ICC = (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:10)R2
3(cid:11) −(cid:10)R3
3(cid:11)(cid:12)(cid:12) +(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:10)R3
4(cid:11) −(cid:10)R4
4(cid:11)(cid:12)(cid:12) = 4p − 2 ,
whence
CHSH − ICC = 4 − 4p − 2 = (cid:26) 4 (1 − p) + 2
4p + 2
if p ≥ 1/2,
if p < 1/2.
The system is noncontextual by the criterion (22) only if p = 0 or p = 1; for
other values the difference exceeds 2.
One can see in (22) an algebraic realization of the intuition described above,
of direct influences being or not being sufficient to account for the system. The
direct influences are represented by the term ICC while CHSH − 2 can be viewed
as the total of the dependence of measurements on contexts. If ICC is not large
enough, it does not exceed CHSH − 2, and in this sense it is "insufficient" to
explain the total of the context-dependence. The difference is the "unexplained"
context-dependence that we view as true contextuality.
For the arguments in favor of generalizing the definition of contextuality to
inconsistently connected systems, see Refs. [1, 5, 21]. Let us emphasize here a
pragmatic argument. Since one cannot prove a null hypothesis, dealing with ex-
perimental results one can never be certain that consistent connectedness holds.
If one confines one's definition of contextuality to the latter case (Definition 6.4),
one's determination that a system is contextual would always be "suspended"
and could be easily invalidated if with a larger sample size a small inconsistency
were detected. Moreover, small inconsistencies should be expected in virtually
all real experiments, as one can never be rid of all systematic sources of error
14
or make them perfectly counterbalanced. None of this poses a problem for Def-
inition 7.1: small values of ICC, unless CHSH is very close to 2, will not change
one's determination that a system is or is not contextual.
8 The "Alice-Bob" EPR-B version of the cyclic-4
system
The contextuality analysis of a cyclic-4 system does not depend on what pre-
cisely the properties {q1, q2, q3, q4} are, nor on what the contexts {c1, c2, c3, c4}
are. All that matters is that each context involves two properties measured
"together", no two contexts share more than one property, each property is mea-
sured in precisely two different contexts, and each measurement has two possible
values.
The importance of the cyclic-4 systems, however, is primarily related to the
entanglement paradigm in quantum mechanics: two particles created in a sin-
gular state move away from each other, reaching simultaneously two observers,
one of them Alice and another Bob; Alice chooses one of two fixed axes and mea-
sures her particle's spin along it; Bob does the same with his particle. Assuming
the two particles are spin-1/2 ones, the outcomes are binary random variables.
Alice's two fixed axes can be denoted a1 = q1 and a2 = q3, and Bob's axes can
be denoted b1 = q2 and b2 = q4. The contexts then can be identified by the
pairs of axes simultaneously chosen by Alice and Bob:
c1 = {q1, q2} = {a1, b1} ,
c3 = {q3, q4} = {a2, b2} ,
c2 = {q2, q3} = {b1, a2} ,
c4 = {q4, q1} = {b2, a1} .
(25)
We can now simplify notation for the measurements by denoting Alice's
measurements by A and Bob's by B. We will use two subscripts of which
(note the asymmetry) the first one refers to Alice's choice of one of her two
axes, and the second one refers to Bob's choice of one of his two axes. This
notation ensures that Aij and Bij (and only these, identically subscripted pairs)
are jointly distributed. Random variable Aij is interpreted as the outcome of
measuring property ai in the context of being measured together with property
bj (whether or not the distribution of Aij depends on j); Bij is the outcome of
measuring property bj in the context of being measured together with property
ai (whether or not the distribution of Bij depends on i).
The correspondence between the general Rc
q notation and the special Aij-Bij
notation is as follows:
a1
R1
R2
R3
R4
1 = R{a1,b1}
2 = R{a2,b1}
3 = R{a2,b2}
4 = R{a1,b2}
a2
b1
b2
b1
= A11, R1
= B21, R2
= A22, R3
= B12, R4
2 = R{a1,b1}
3 = R{a2,b1}
4 = R{a2,b2}
1 = R{a1,b2}
a1
a2
b2
= B11,
= A21,
= B22,
= A12.
(26)
The entanglement paradigm serves as a template for other applications, with
very different meanings of the properties a, b (see Ref. [3] for examples in psy-
15
Table 4: The properties and their measurements in the EPR-B-like system used
in Ref. [6]. In each trial a human respondent is asked to choose "wind directions"
along a pair of spatial orientations in the Rose of the Winds. Each pair consists
of one cardinal orientation (a1 or a2) and one intercardinal orientation (b1 or
b2). For instance, the respondent can be given (a2, b1), in which case her pos-
sible choices would be "East and Northeast", "East and Southwest", "West and
Northeast", and "West and Southwest", corresponding to four possible values of
(A21, B21).
Properties, q
Measurements
Context
(Rose of the Winds)
(Choices of direction)
(Options for other direction)
North-South (a1)
East-West (a2)
Northeast-Southwest (b1)
Northwest-Southeast (b2)
A1j = +1 = North
A1j = −1 = South
A2j = +1 = East
A2j = −1 = West
Bi1 = +1 = Northeast
Bi1 = −1 = Southwest
Bi2 = +1 = Southeast
Bi2 = −1 = Northwest
measured together with bj
(j = 1, 2)
measured together with ai
(i = 1, 2)
chology). In this paper we will use as an example the experiment by Aerts and
Sozzo [6], where a and b are cardinal and intercardinal orientations chosen in the
Rose of the Winds, and the measurements are choices (by human respondents)
of one of two possible wind directions along each of these orientations, as shown
in Table 4.
The results of this experiment (see Table 5) yield the following computations:
whence
CHSH = 2.47, ICC = 0.71,
CHSH − ICC = 1.76 < 2.
We conclude that the data exhibit no contextuality in the sense of Definition
7.1.
9 Methodological Remarks
One may, of course, reject the generalized Definition 7.1 and stick with the tradi-
tional understanding (Definition 6.4), but the latter applies only to consistently
connected systems of measurements, whereas the inconsistency of the connect-
edness in the data of Ref. [6] is clearly present in spite of the small sample size
used (p < 0.03 for the difference between hB11i and hB21i). As explained in
Section 5, in this case no inequality can be derived for CHSH (except for the
trivial CHSH ≤ 4), and no interpretation is known for whether CHSH exceeds
or does not exceed any value below 4.
The authors of Ref. [6] are aware of the difficulties caused by inconsistent
connectedness in judging violations of the CHSH inequality (see Ref. [7]), so
16
Table 5: The results of the experiment reported in Ref. [6]. All probability
estimates are computed from polling 85 people, treating them as 85 realizations
of one and the same pair of random variables in each of the four contexts.
A11
A21
+1
−1
+1
−1
B11
+1
0.13
0.25
0.38
+1
0.13
0.42
0.55
−1
0.55
0.07
0.62
−1
0.38
0.07
0.45
B21
0.68
0.32
0.51
0.49
+1
−1
+1
−1
B12
+1
0.47
0.06
0.53
+1
0.09
0.38
0.47
−1
0.12
0.35
0.47
−1
0.44
0.09
0.53
B22
0.59
0.41
0.53
0.47
A12
A22
they propose a computational modification of their data that makes all marginal
distributions uniform. They justify this procedure by an isotropy argument, ac-
cording to which any direction in the Rose of the Winds plane could be taken
to play the role of the vector North, with all other directions rotated to pre-
serve their angles with respect to this new North. Using this argument, Aerts
and Sozzo average the observed probabilities in such a way that all marginal
probabilities become 1/2 while the value of CHSH does not change.
An isotropy argument, however, as any other symmetry argument, only
makes sense if formulated as invariance of a relevant feature (in our case, mea-
surement) with respect to certain changes. To give a trivial example, the length
of a segment in the Euclidean plane is invariant with respect to its rotations.
Therefore one can average the length measurements of a radius at different ori-
entations, and this averaging would only improve statistical reliability of the
measurements rather than change the true measured value. By contrast, we see
in Table 5 that the measurements Aij and Bij are not invariant with respect to
rotations: e.g., Pr [A11 = −1, B11 = 1] is different from Pr [B21 = −1, A21 = 1],
although the ordered pair of the orientations in the second case, (b1, a2), is a
rotated by π/4 copy of the orientation pair in the first case, (a1, b1). Even
more obvious: Pr [A11 = 1, B11 = 1] is not the same as Pr [A11 = −1, B11 = −1]
although they pertain to orientation pairs rotated by π with respect to each
other.
The latter example is important for the computational modification of the
data used in Ref. [6]. This procedure achieves uniform marginals while retaining
the value of CHSH precisely because it considers the jointly-opposite outcomes
(Aij = x, Bij = y) and (Aij = −x, Bij = −y) ,
(27)
with x, y ∈ {−1, +1}, to be "equivalent". The probability of each of them is
therefore replaced with their average:
Pr [Aij = x, Bij = y] + Pr [Aij = −x, Bij = −y]
2
.
(28)
Let us denote by A∗
distributions. Due to the symmetry,
ij and B∗
ij the new random variables with these symmetrized
17
ij(cid:11) = Pr(cid:2)A∗
(cid:10)A∗
ij(cid:11) = Pr(cid:2)B∗
(cid:10)B∗
(cid:10)A∗
ij B∗
Pr(cid:2)A∗
ij = +1(cid:3) − Pr(cid:2)A∗
ij = +1(cid:3) − Pr(cid:2)B∗
ij(cid:11) = 2 Pr(cid:2)A∗
ij = B∗
ij = B∗
ij = −1(cid:3) = 0,
ij = −1(cid:3) = 0.
ij(cid:3) − 1,
ij(cid:3) = Pr [Aij = Bij] ,
(29)
(30)
(31)
At the same time,
and since it follows from (28) that
the value of CHSH remains intact.
This averaging procedure has been described in the quantum physics liter-
ature by Masanes, Acin, and Gisin [24]; it is the first part of their "depolariza-
tion" procedure. There, however, it is meant to be a data generation or data
doctoring procedure (not a data analysis one), involving either direct signaling
between Alice or Bob, or a third party, Charley, who receives from Alice and
from Bob their settings and their measurement results, flips a fair coin, and
multiplies these measurement results (always both of them) by +1 or −1 ac-
cordingly. Since this averaging procedure is universal (applicable to all EPR-B
systems without exception), if taken as a data analysis procedure it amounts to
ignoring the marginal probabilities altogether and simply defining contextuality
(or entanglement) as any violation of the CHSH inequality.
One might ask: why not adopt this approach? It is definitely simpler than
the approach advocated by us, which involves (a) labeling the measurements
contextually, (b) determining subsystems of measurements that are stochasti-
cally unrelated to each other, (c) defining contextuality in terms of the (non)existence
of a coupling for these subsystems with certain constraints imposed on the con-
nections (measurements of the same properties in different contexts); and (d) de-
riving CHSH inequalities or their generalizations as theorems [1,2,4,5,9–11,21].
The answer to the question is that adopting the definition in question, in
addition to being arbitrary, would make construction of contextual systems
child's play: the contextual system will become ubiquitous and obvious, includ-
ing systems in classical mechanics and human behavior that no one normally
would think of as contextual. Moreover, with the definition in question one
would have to forget about the "quantum" motivation for seeking contextuality,
because these contextual systems in classical mechanics and human behavior
would violate Tsirelson (or Cirel'son) bounds [25,26] as easily as they would the
CHSH ones.
10 Contextuality as child's play
We will consider just one example, with multiple possible implementations. Ta-
ble 6 represents the probabilities of [Aij = x, Bij = y] in a hypothetical EPR-
B-type system (i, j ∈ {1, 2}, x, y ∈ {−1, +1}). Here,
CHSH = 4,
18
Table 6: A deterministic system that is (as any other deterministic system)
noncontextual by Definition 7.1 but is "maximally contextual" if one ignores
marginal probabilities (or, equivalently, averages over jointly-opposite out-
comes).
A11
A21
+1
−1
+1
−1
B11
+1 −1
0
1
0
0
1
0
+1 −1
0
1
0
0
1
0
B21
1
0
1
0
+1
−1
+1
−1
B12
+1 −1
0
1
0
0
1
0
+1 −1
0
0
0
1
1
0
B22
1
0
0
1
A12
A22
the algebraically maximal possible value for CHSH. The system is, however,
noncontextual by Definition 7.1 and Theorem 7.2: ICC in it equals the value of
hA21i − hA22i = 2, whence
CHSH − ICC = 2
In fact, any deterministic system (one in which all probabilities are 0 or 1) is
noncontextual. A simple way of demonstrating this is as follows: a deterministic
system has a single coupling, and its subcouplings corresponding to connections
(each of which is deterministic) are their only couplings, hence maximal ones.
However, if in Table 6 one decides to ignore marginal probabilities, the sys-
tem is maximally contextual (and in fact more contextual than allowed by quan-
tum mechanics).
It is trivial to find or construct a system described by Table 6. To begin with
conceptual combinations, consider, e.g., the experiment in which the properties
a, b and measurements A, B are identified as shown in Table 7. Such an exper-
iment would yield Table 6 unless the participants choose to deliberately give
wrong responses. There is, in fact, nothing wrong in considering the conceptual
inferences like "Green Triangle is Green" and "Green Triangle is Triangular" as
examples of contextuality or "(super-quantum) entanglement," but this looks to
us as making the concept of contextuality too trivial to be of interest.
Another example of "conceptual entanglement" involves creation of new con-
cepts in children by means of teaching them a simple nonsense verse:
Pips and Nips are Zops, not Zogs.
Pops and Nops aren't Zops nor Zogs.
Pips and Nops are Gots, not Gons.
Pops and Nips aren't Gots nor Gons.
Children who learned this piece of poetry by heart (or are allowed to look at
it while responding) would confidently respond to the questions like "Are Pips
Zops?" and "Are Pops Gots?" The resulting table of the probabilities for them
19
Table 7: A trivial system described by Table 6 if people are instructed to choose
correct responses.
In the context (a1, b1) the choice is among the sentences:
"Green Triangle is Green", "Green Triangle is Red", "Yellow Circle is Green",
and "Yellow Circle is Red".
In the context (a1, b2) the choice is among the
sentences: "Green Triangle is Triangular", "Green Triangle is Square", "Yellow
Circle is Triangular", and "Yellow Circle is Square". In the context (a2, b1) the
choice is among the sentences: "Green Circle is Green", "Green Circle is Red",
"Yellow Triangle is Green", and "Yellow Triangle is Red". In the context (a2, b2),
the choice is among the sentences: "Green Circle is Triangular", "Green Circle
is Square", "Yellow Triangle is Triangular", and "Yellow Triangle is Square".
Properties
(choices between)
Green Triangle and Yellow Circle (a1)
Green Circle and Yellow Triangle (a2)
Green and Red (b1)
Triangular and Square (b2)
Measurements
(choices)
A1j = +1 = Green Triangle
A1j = −1 = Yellow Circle
A2j = +1 = Green Circle
A2j = −1 = Yellow Triangle
Bi1 = +1 = Green
Bi1 = −1 = Red
Bi2 = +1 = Triangular
Bi2 = −1 = Square
Context
together with bj
(j = 1, 2)
together with ai
(j = 1, 2)
will be the same as in Table 6, on denoting the conditions and outcomes as in
Table 8.
Finally, here is a scenario of creating Table 6 in a purely classical physical
situation. There is a gadget "Alice" that responds to inputs i, j ∈ {1, 2} by
computing A = min (1, 2i + 2j − 5), and a gadget "Bob" that outputs 1 no
matter what. This example is essentially identical to one given by Filk in Figure
3 of Ref. [27]. No physicist, as it seems to us, would call the system consisting
of these two gadgets entangled or contextual.
It is simply that both inputs
influence one of the outputs (Alice's), resulting in the observed inconsistent
connectedness.
Table 8: A trivial system described by Table 6 if people are instructed to choose
correct responses given by the nonsense verse about Pips, Nips, etc.
Properties
(choices between)
Measurements
(choices)
Pip and Pop (a1)
Nip and Nop (a2)
Zop and Zog (b1)
Got and Gon (b2)
A1j = +1 = Pip
A1j = −1 = Pop
A2j = +1 = Nip
A2j = −1 = Nop
Bi1 = +1 = Zop
Bi1 = −1 = Zog
Bi2 = +1 = Got
Bi2 = −1 = Gon
Context
together with bj
(j = 1, 2)
together with ai
(i = 1, 2)
20
11 Conclusion
Inconsistent connectedness is almost a universal rule in behavioral and social
data (e.g., it is very plausible that the task of choosing between the North and
South winds affects the probabilities with which one, in the same trial, chooses
between the Northeast and Southwest winds). It is therefore a sound scientific
strategy to make inconsistent connectedness part of one's theory of contextu-
ality.
Inconsistent connectedness means that the measurement of a property
is directly influenced by the measurement of other properties, and this may or
may not be sufficient to account for a system's behavior. For instance, in the
experiment described in Ref. [28] we find violations of consistent connectedness
due to context-dependent biases in measurements, but the detailed analysis pre-
sented in Ref. [5] shows that contextuality, in the sense of Definition 7.1, is still
prominently present in these data. By contrast, the system in Table 6 is non-
contextual by Definition 7.1, which means that the direct influences it entails
are sufficient to explain its behavior (no contextuality exists "on top of" these
input-output relations). The same conclusion applies to the many different ex-
periments analyzed in Ref. [3] and to the experiment reported in Ref. [6]. We
have argued that the justification proposed in the latter for averaging across
different contexts is not tenable, and the reason it works as desired is that it
is equivalent to ignoring marginal probabilities altogether. The consequence of
such ignoring, in addition to being ad hoc, is that contextuality becomes trivial
and uninteresting.
We make no claim, however, that contextuality, in the sense of our definition,
cannot be found in behavioral data: we merely say that we have not found it
yet. We also acknowledge that there may be viable alternatives to our Definition
7.1 that also take into account inconsistent connectedness in a different way.
Finally, we would like to refer the reader to the concluding part of Ref. [3]
to emphasize that absence of contextuality in behavioral and social systems
does not mean that quantum formalisms are not applicable to them. The so-
called QQ equality, in our opinion the most impressive outcome of quantum
cognition research to date [29, 30], provides a clear illustration of how absence
of contextuality can in fact be precisely a prediction derived from quantum
theory.
Acknowledgments
This research has been supported by NSF grant SES-1155956, AFOSR grant
FA9550-14-1-0318, A. von Humboldt Foundation, and by the J. William Ful-
bright Grant from Fulbright Colombia.
References
[1] Dzhafarov EN, Kujala JV, Larsson J-Å. 2015 Contextuality in three
762–782.
types of quantum-mechanical
systems. Found. Phys. 7,
21
(doi:10.1007/s10701-015-9882-9)
[2] Dzhafarov EN, Kujala JV, Cervantes VH. 2016 Contextuality-by-Default:
A brief overview of ideas, concepts, and terminology. Lect. Notes Comput.
Sc. 9535, 12–23.
[3] Dzhafarov EN, Zhang R, Kujala JV. 2015 Is there contextuality in be-
havioral and social systems? Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 374, 20150099
(doi:10.1098/rsta.2015.0099).
[4] Kujala JV, Dzhafarov EN. 2015 Proof of a conjecture on contextuality in
cyclic systems with binary variables. arXiv:1503.02181.
[5] Kujala JV, Dzhafarov EN, Larsson J-Å. 2015 Necessary and suf-
for maximal noncontextuality in a broad class
150401.
ficient
of quantum mechanical
(doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.115.150401)
systems. Phys. Rev. Lett. 115,
conditions
[6] Aerts D, Sozzo S. 2015 Spin and wind directions: Identifying entanglement
in nature and cognition. arXiv:1508.00434v2.
[7] Dzhafarov EN, Kujala, JV. 2014 Selective influences, marginal se-
lectivity, and Bell/CHSH inequalities. Top. Cogn. Sci. 6, 121–128.
(doi:10.1111/tops.12060)
[8] Aerts D, Gabora L, Sozzo S. 2013 Concepts and their dynamics: A
quantum-theoretic modeling of human thought. Top. Cogn. Sci. 5, 737–
772. (doi:10.1111/tops.12042)
[9] Dzhafarov EN, Kujala JV. 2014 A qualified Kolmogorovian account
of probabilistic contextuality. Lect. Notes Comput. Sc. 8369, 201–212.
(doi:10.1007/978-3-642-54943-4_18)
[10] Dzhafarov EN, Kujala JV. 2014 Embedding quantum into classi-
e92818.
cal: Contextualization vs conditionalization. PLoS One 9,
(doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0092818)
[11] Dzhafarov EN, Kujala JV. 2014 Contextuality is about identity of
(doi:10.1088/0031-
random variables. Phys. Scripta T163, 014009.
8949/2014/T163/014009)
[12] Kujala
JV, Dzhafarov EN.
2015. Probabilistic Contextuality in
EPR/Bohm-type systems with signaling allowed. In Contextuality from
Quantum Physics to Psychology (eds EN Dzhafarov, JS Jordan, R Zhang,
VH Cervantes), pp. 287-308, New Jersey:World Scientific Press.
[13] Popescu S, Rohrlich D. 1994 Quantum nonlocality as an axiom. Found.
Phys. 24, 379–385. (doi:10.1007/BF02058098)
22
[14] Dzhafarov EN, Kujala JV. 2012 Quantum entanglement and the issue of
selective influences in psychology: An overview. Lect. Notes Comput. Sc.
7620, 184–195. (doi:10.1007/978-3-642-35659-9_17)
[15] Townsend JT, Schweickert R. 1989 Toward the trichotomy method of reac-
tion times: Laying the foundation of stochastic mental networks. J. Math.
Psychol. 33, 309–327. (doi:10.1016/0022-2496(89)90013-8)
[16] Ramanathan R, Soeda A, Kurzynski P, Kasznlikowski D. 2012 Generalized
Monogamy of Contextual Inequalities from the No-Disturbance Principle.
Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 050404. (doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.109.050404)
[17] Cereceda J. 2000 Quantum mechanical probabilities and general proba-
bilistic constraints for Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-Bohm experiments. Found.
Phys. Lett. 13, 427–442. (doi:10.1023/A:1007828731477)
[18] Bell JS. 1964 On the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox. Physics 1, 195–
200.
[19] Bell JS. 1966 On the problem of hidden variables in quantum mechanics.
Rev. Mod. Phys. 38, 447–453. (doi:10.1103/RevModPhys.38.447)
[20] Clauser JF, Horne MA, Shimony A, Holt RA. 1969 Proposed experi-
ment to test local hidden-variable theories. Phys. Rev. Lett. 23, 880–884.
(doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.23.880)
[21] Dzhafarov EN, Kujala JV. 2015 Conversations on contextuality. In Con-
textuality from Quantum Physics to Psychology (eds EN Dzhafarov, JS
Jordan, R Zhang, VH Cervantes), pp. 1-22, New Jersey: World Scientific
Press.
[22] Fine A. 1982 Hidden variables, joint probability, and the Bell inequalities.
Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 291–295. (doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.48.291)
[23] Fine A. 1982 Joint distributions, quantum correlations, and commuting
observables. J. Math. Phys. 23, 1306–1310. (doi:10.1063/1.525514)
[24] Masanes Ll, Acin A, Gisin N. 2006 General properties of nonsignaling the-
ories. Phys. Rev. A 73, 012112. (doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.73.012112)
[25] Cirel'son BS. 1980 Quantum generalizations of Bell's inequality. Lett. Math.
Phys. 4, 93–100.
[26] Landau LJ. 1987 On the violation of Bell's inequality in quantum theory.
Phys. Lett. A 120, 54–56. (doi:10.1016/0375-9601(87)90075-2)
[27] Filk T. 2015. It is the theory which decides what we can observe. In Con-
textuality from Quantum Physics to Psychology (eds EN Dzhafarov, JS
Jordan, R Zhang, VH Cervantes), pp. 77-92, New Jersey:World Scientific
Press.
23
[28] Lapkiewicz R , Li P , Schaeff C, Langford NK, Ramelow S, Wieśniak M,
Zeilinger A. 2011 Experimental non-classicality of an indivisible quantum
system. Nature 474, 490–493. (doi:10.1038/nature10119)
[29] Wang Z, Solloway T, Shiffrin RM, Busemeyer JR. 2014 Context effects
produced by question orders reveal quantum nature of human judgments.
P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 111, 9431–9436. (doi:10.1073/pnas.1407756111)
[30] Wang Z, Busemeyer JR. 2013 A quantum question order model supported
by empirical tests of an a priori and precise prediction. Top. Cogn. Sci. 5,
689–710. (doi:10.1111/tops.12040)
|
1007.5471 | 1 | 1007 | 2010-07-30T15:09:12 | A big-world network in ASD: Dynamical connectivity analysis reflects a deficit in long-range connections and an excess of short-range connections | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Over the last years, increasing evidence has fuelled the hypothesis that Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is a condition of altered brain functional connectivity. The great majority of these empirical studies rely on functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) which has a relatively poor temporal resolution. Only a handful of studies have examined networks emerging from dynamic coherence at the millisecond resolution and there are no investigations of coherence at the lowest frequencies in the power spectrum - which has recently been shown to reflect long-range cortico-cortical connections. Here we used electroencephalography (EEG) to assess dynamic brain connectivity in ASD focusing in the low-frequency (delta) range. We found that connectivity patterns were distinct in ASD and control populations and reflected a double dissociation: ASD subjects lacked long-range connections, with a most prominent deficit in fronto-occipital connections. Conversely, individuals with ASD showed increased short-range connections in lateral-frontal electrodes. This effect between categories showed a consistent parametric dependency: as ASD severity increased, short-range coherence was more pronounced and long-range coherence decreased. Theoretical arguments have been proposed arguing that distinct patterns of connectivity may result in networks with different efficiency in transmission of information. We show that the networks in ASD subjects have less Clustering coefficient, greater Characteristic Path Length than controls -indicating that the topology of the network departs from small-world behaviour- and greater modularity. Together these results show that delta-band coherence reveal qualitative and quantitative aspects associated with ASD pathology. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | A big-world network in ASD: Dynamical connectivity analysis
reflects a deficit in long-range connections and an excess of short-
range connections.
Pablo Barttfeld1,2, Bruno Wicker 1,3, Sebastián Cukier1,2, Silvana Navarta1 , Sergio Lew4
and Mariano Sigman1
1Integrative Neuroscience Laboratory, Physics Department, University of Buenos Aires.
2Fundación para la Lucha contra las Enfermedades Neurológicas de la Infancia, Buenos
Aires.
3Mediterranean Institute of Cognitive Neurosciences, Centre National de la Recherche
Scientifique, Université de la Méditerranée, 31 Chemin Joseph Aiguier, 13402
Marseille Cedex 20, France.
4Instituto de Ingeniería Biomédica, Facultad de Ingeniería, Universidad of Buenos Aires
Corresponding author: Pablo Barttfeld
Integrative Neuroscience Laboratory, Physics Department, University of Buenos Aires,
Buenos Aires, Argentina.
e-mail:[email protected]
Abstract
Over the last years, increasing evidence has fuelled the hypothesis that Autism
Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is a condition of altered brain functional connectivity. The
great majority of these empirical studies rely on functional magnetic resonance imaging
(fMRI) which has a relatively poor temporal resolution. Only a handful of studies have
examined networks emerging from dynamic coherence at the millisecond resolution and
there are no investigations of coherence at the lowest frequencies in the power spectrum
– which has recently been shown to reflect long-range cortico-cortical connections.
Here we used electroencephalography (EEG) to assess dynamic brain connectivity in
ASD focusing in the low-frequency (delta) range. We found that connectivity patterns
were distinct in ASD and control populations and reflected a double dissociation: ASD
subjects lacked long-range connections, with a most prominent deficit in fronto-
occipital connections. Conversely, individuals with ASD showed increased short-range
connections in lateral-frontal electrodes. This effect between categories showed a
consistent parametric dependency: as ASD severity increased, short-range coherence
was more pronounced and long-range coherence decreased. Theoretical arguments have
been proposed arguing that distinct patterns of connectivity may result in networks with
different efficiency in transmission of information. We show that the networks in ASD
subjects have less Clustering coefficient, greater Characteristic Path Length than
controls -indicating that the topology of the network departs from small-world
behaviour- and greater modularity. Together these results show that delta-band
coherence reveal qualitative and quantitative aspects associated with ASD pathology.
Running title: Functional EEG connectivity in Autism.
Keywords: Functional connectivity - delta band EEG – resting state - small world
metrics - Autism Spectrum Disorders.
1. Introduction
Autism or Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is a neurodevelopmental disorder
characterized by a triad of impairments in social interaction, communication, and
behavioural flexibility (APA, 2000). There is increasing evidence that ASD could be a
condition of altered brain connectivity (Belmonte et al., 2004; Courchesne & Pierce,
2005; Just, Cherkassky, Keller, Kana, & Minshew, 2007; Just, Cherkassky, Keller, &
Minshew, 2004; Markram, Rinaldi, & Markram, 2007; Wicker, 2008). Anatomical
studies showed that individuals with ASD have smaller and more densely packed
columns of neuronal cells (Casanova & Trippe, 2009; Casanova et al., 2006; Hughes,
2007). Structural MRI studies have reported a reduced corpus callosum (Alexander et
al., 2007; Egaas, Courchesne, & Saitoh, 1995) and abnormal anatomy and connections
of the limbic–striatal social brain system in ASD (McAlonan et al., 2005). fMRI studies
also yielded evidence of altered connectivity: connectivity within the frontal lobe seems
differently organized, and areas such as prefrontal cortex, precuneus/posterior cingulate
cortex and superior temporal sulcus, appear to be poorly connected (Just, Cherkassky,
Keller, Kana, & Minshew, 2007; Just, Cherkassky, Keller, & Minshew, 2004; Kana,
2006; Kleinhans et al., 2008; Koshino et al., 2005; Mason, Williams, Kana, Minshew, &
Just, 2008; Welchew et al., 2005; Wicker, 2008). Recent fMRI studies have moved
away from the social and cognitive deficit models and looked at the functional
connectivity between areas of the so-called default mode network (DMN), i.e. networks
that become activated at rest (Gusnard & Raichle, 2001; Raichle, 2009) Results
revealed decreased connectivity between
the medial prefrontal cortex and
precuneus/posterior cingulate cortex (Cherkassky, 2006; Di Martino et al., 2009; Weng,
2010). The great majority of the evidence signalling functional connectivity as a key
aspect of ASD was obtained using fMRI. There are only a handful of studies assessing
ASD brain connectivity using the other canonical tool to study connectivity,
electroencephalography (EEG). Abnormal gamma activity has been reported in autistic
children, interpreted as supporting hypotheses of abnormal connectivity (Brown,
Gruber, Boucher, Rippon, & Brock, 2005). Murias et al. (2007) and Coben et al. (2008)
measured connectivity more directly using EEG coherence and reported evidence of
both under- and over-connectivities in different frequency bands in ASD populations.
Understanding the patterns of connectivity in low frequencies - the delta band - remains
unexplored.
Over the last years, analysis of coherence at low-frequencies has gained great interest.
Long-range intra-cortical and feedback cortico-cortical connections, specifically those
connections thought to be altered in ASD, contribute directly and significantly to the
slow cortical potentials of the EEG (He & Raichle, 2009; He, Snyder, Zempel, Smyth,
& Raichle, 2008). Also, the power coherence in low-frequency bands, particularly in the
delta band correlates with the resting-state fMRI signal. (He, Snyder, Zempel, Smyth, &
Raichle, 2008; Lu, 2007). Together, these results suggest that connectivity in the lower
bands might specifically reflect the alterations of long range connectivity thought to
play a key role in ASD.
Based on this hypothesis, we investigated whether functional brain networks in EEG are
abnormally organized in the delta band in ASD. We will show that control subjects have
stronger long fronto-occipital connections, and weaker lateral frontal connections and
these differences are good predictors of ASD severity. Interestingly, the specificity of
the connections is modulated by ASD severity (and not simply the amount of
connections): short connections correlate positively with ASD (stronger connections
relating to more severe ASD) whereas long connections correlate negatively with ASD
(weaker connections relating to more severe ASD). When inspecting the impact of this
connectivity pattern on the global organization of functional network using graph theory
measures we observed that ASD present longer Characteristic Path Length (L), smaller
Clustering Coefficient (C) and higher modularity index (MI), resulting in a less efficient
brain network (Latora & Marchiori, 2001).
2. Material and Methods.
2.1 Participants
Two groups took part in this study. The ASD group included 10 adults with
high-functioning autism or Asperger’s syndrome (9 men and 1 women; mean age =
23.8, std = 7.6, Table 1). The individuals with ASD were provisionally accepted into the
study if they had received a diagnosis of infantile autism or Asperger’s syndrome from
a child psychiatrist, developmental pediatrician, or licensed clinical psychologist.
Actual participation required that this diagnosis had been recently confirmed, with each
subject having met the criteria for ASD within the past 3 years on the basis of the
revised fourth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Condition
(APA, 2000) and on the score on the Autistic Diagnostic Observation Schedule-Generic
(Lord et al., 2000). IQs were measured with the third edition of the Wechsler Adult
Intelligence Scale and ranged from 85 to 125 (mean=101.7, SD=14.97). At the time of
testing, no ASD subject had known associated medical condition. As their mean IQ
score was within the normal range, the ASD participants were individually matched to a
group of 10 typically developing individuals on the basis of sex and chronological age.
The participants in the control group (9 men, 1 women, mean age = 25.3, std = 6.54)
were all volunteers and were free of psychiatric condition at the time of testing.
Exec
IQ
Sex Diagnosis Verbal
IQ
Total
IQ
Age
Total
7
15
12
13
9
12
15
11
12
16
F
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
32
26
22
17
17
30
38
24
16
16
99
90
85
120
85
125
121
98
95
99
Asperger 116
HFA
98
96
HFA
111
HFA
Asperger
88
114
HFA
111
HFA
HFA
104
99
HFA
HFA
94
78
80
74
127
83
130
131
89
89
105
Table 1. Details of ASD subjects: age, diagnosis, IQ and ADOS scores.
2.2 EEG recordings.
EEG were recorded with a Biosemi Active-two 128 channels equipment, at a rate of 512
Hz. 7-minute temporal signals were recorded during an eyes-closed resting while
subjects sat on a reclining chair in a sound attenuated room with a dim light. Digital,
zero-phase shift filtering of the EEG temporal signals in the delta band (0.5-3.5Hz) was
done performed offline in order to compute the correltion matrices. Correlations
between all pair wise combinations of EEG channels were computed for all subjects
with the Synchronisation Likelihood (SL) method (Stam & van Dijk, 2002). All
parameters were set as described in detail in (Montez, Linkenkaer-Hansen, van Dijk, &
ADOS
Soc. Int.
4
5
9
8
7
8
9
6
9
10
Comm.
3
10
3
5
2
4
6
5
3
6
Stam, 2006). This resulted in a 128x128 symmetrical matrix for each subject, where
each entry in the matrix represents the SL between the corresponding pair of electrodes.
All subsequent analysis and statistics were performed from these SL matrices.
2.3 Graph Theory metrics.
The connectivity matrix defines a weighted graph where each electrode corresponds to a
node and the weight of each link is determined by the SL of the electrode pair. To
calculate network measures, SL matrices were converted to binary undirected matrices
by applying a threshold T. We explored a broad range of values of 0.01< T < 0.2, with
increments of 0.0005 and repeated the full analysis for each value of T. After
transforming the SL-matrix to a binary undirected graph, we measured the Clustering
Coefficient C, the Characteristic Path Length L and Modularity Index MI using the BCT
toolbox (Rubinov & Sporns, 2009). For statistical comparisons of graph based metrics,
we performed ANOVAs with group (control or ASD) and threshold (binned in 8) as
independent factors. Errors were calculated using bootstrap (Efron & Tibshirani, 1994),
which were used to explore statistical differences for all individual thresholds. The
bootstrap probability was also calculated, by resampling 2000 times each metric for
both groups, and calculating the percentage of times the mean metric of a group was
larger than the mean metric of the other group. Network visualizations were performed
using the Pajek software package (Batagelj & Mrvar, 1998) using a Kamada-Kawai
layout algorithm (Kamada & Kawai, 1989).
3. Results
For each participant in this study, we calculated the Synchronization Likelihood (SL)
across all pairs of channels (see methods and Montez et al., 2006 for details). SL
provides a measure of temporal coherence between two temporal signals. This measure
is more sensitive than simply a linear-correlation because: 1) it does not assume
linearity in the coherence and 2) it is sensitive to phase-shifted coherent frequency
bands which may result in a null linear correlation. This analysis collapsed the
stationary EEG data of each participant, band passed in the delta range to a 128x128
synchronization matrix (henceforth referred as SL-matrix). The element (i,j) of the
matrix provides a measure of the temporal similarity at low frequencies of electrodes i
and j during eyes-closed stationary EEG, which we refer as functional connectivity. In
what follows, we analyse statistical differences in functional connectivity for ASD and
control population.
To calculate significant differences in SL patterns across groups, we conducted a paired
t-test with the SL value for each pair of channels (Figure 1b). A positive t-value
indicates that SL increased in control compared to ASD population. Conversely, a
negative t-value indicates that SL is greater in ASD than in the control population. The
distribution of t-values (Figure 1d) was significantly shifted towards positive values
(mean= 0.57; std= 1,11; t-test: p=0, CImin= 0.55; CImax=0.58) indicating that the
global trend was that SL was greater in the control population. Our interest was to
understand the topography of the tails of this distribution, i.e. which pairs of electrodes
had a greater difference in SL between ASD and control population. For this, we simply
determined an arbitrary cut-off at t = 2 (Figures 1b and 1d) and considered the resulting
matrix with values 1, 0 or -1 depending on whether t > 2, 2>t > -2 or -2 > t (Figure 1f).
This cut-off is certainly arbitrary but none of the results discussed in what follows
depend on this choice (see Supplementary Figure 1 for a progression of the correlation
topographies for varying thresholds). To further constrain the number of comparisons
and generate a relatively sparse pattern of connections amenable to visualize its
topography, we applied a mask, considering only pairs of electrodes with SL values
exceeding a threshold of 0.03 (Figures 1c and 1e). The topographic projections of
connections whose strength increased (red) or decreased (blue) in ASD compared to
control participants (Figure 1h) showed a very consistent pattern. Connections which
were stronger in the control group were localized in the frontal lobe and extended over
the midline to the occipital cortex. They also included long-range connections
connecting these regions. On the contrary, connections which were stronger in the ASD
group were very focal and largely localized to the lateral frontal electrodes. These
observations did not change qualitatively when changing the thresholds of the binary
difference matrix or the activation mask (Supplementary Figure 1).
Figure 1. Differences in connectivity between ASD and Control groups. a) SL-matrix, averaged for all
participants in this study. b) t-values of the SL difference between ASD and controls for each pair of
channels. A red (blue) colour in the matrix indicates that SL is increased (decreased) in control compared
to ASD population. c) Proportion of links in the SL-matrix remaining after appliance of different SL-
value filters. The red line shows the threshold chosen for the analysis. d) Distribution of t-values. Red
lines indicate the thresholds chosen for the analysis. e) Binary matrix showing links exceeding the SL
threshold. f) Resulting matrix of thresholding the t-value matrix of fig 1b. Values are 1, 0 or -1. g)
Combination of both filters gives the matrix valued in 1 and -1 for those links surpassing both filters. h)
Topography of the links exceeding the threshold: Blue lines show connections significantly higher in
controls, red lines show connections significantly higher in ASD.
To further quantify these observations, and to explore in a statistical manner whether
fronto-occipital interactions are greater in control group and lateral-frontal interactions
in the ASD group, we defined four different regions: Mid Frontal, Frontal Right Frontal
Left and Occipital (Figure 2a). We then measured global connectivity across regions
(including the connectivity of a region with itself), performing a t-test comparing the SL
value of the weighted SL-matrix for all pairs of electrodes of the corresponding regions.
This analysis revealed that local connections in Mid Frontal decrease in ASD compared
to controls (t-test: t(1,9)=3.02; p=0.01), as well as the long connections between Mid
Frontal and Occipital (t-test: t(1,9)=2.21; p=0.05) (Figure 2b).
Figure 2. SL averaged across different regions. a) Scheme of the four regions defined for this analysis. b)
SL connections for all pair or regions (connections are symmetric son only the upper-diagonal triangular
matrix is shown). Comparisson within the diagonal show within region connections. Local connections in
mid frontal and long connections between mid frontal and occipital are diminished in ASD compared to
controls. Local connections in both Lateral Frontal areas are enhanced in ASD.
On the contrary, local connections in both Lateral Frontal areas are enhanced in ASD,
being significant only in the Frontal Left (t-test: t(1,9)=-2.35; p<0.05), not in the Frontal
Right (t-test: t(1,9)=- 0.82; p>0.1). All other combinations of regions (Figure 2b)
showed no statistical diferences.
The previous analysis showed consistent and topographically organized differences in
SL between ASD and control groups, suggesting that a distinct pattern of dynamical
connectivity may be related to the physiopathology of ASD. A more severe test to this
hypothesis involves examining progressive changes in connectivity with a continuous
progression of ASD. To examine whether the observed difference in connectivity
progressed with ASD severity, we measured the correlations between ADOS score –
which indexes ASD severity and varied from 7 to 16 within our population- with SL-
connectivity of each pair of electrodes. Figure 3a shows two representative examples of
SL pairs with a negative (blue) and a positive (red) correlation with ADOS score. The
topographical distribution of the correlation of ADOS within the ASD population
followed the same pattern than the difference between ASD and control groups: medial
electrodes are negatively correlated with ADOS (and hence their SL is greater with
decreasing levels of ASD and progressing to control population). On the contrary,
lateral electrodes, predominantly for short local connections have SL values which
increase with ADOS score. Note that also coherently with the group analysis; the global
trend is that negative correlations (blue edges, Figure 3b) are more prominent indicating
that, on average, SL connectivity increases with decreasing levels of ASD. To test
quantitatively the hypothesis that short-range connections are overweighed in ASD and
long-range connections are scanter, we measured the distribution of correlation
coefficients for all pairs of electrodes at any given length 1 (Figure 3c). Positive
correlations (SL increases with ADOS score) were very significant only within a very
short range. On the contrary negative correlations (SL increases with decreasing ADOS
score) were broadly distributed and extended over distant pairs of electrodes (Figure
3c). This scaling effect becomes clearer in a more quantitative manner when
considering the mean value of positive and negative correlations averaged across all
pairs at a fixed distance (Figure 3d). These results confirm our findings based on group
analysis: ASD connectivity is overall of shorter range and dominantly localized to
lateral region of the brain, with a deficit of medial occipito-frontal connections.
1
Here we considered the planar distance between pairs of electrodes. This is only an
approximation as interactions reflect coherent sources in a 3D volume. For the purpose of this analysis,
were we merely want to explore broad scaling properties, this approximation seems adequate. Analyzing
distributions considering spherical distances yielded virtually the same result.
Figure 3. Relation between SL and ADOS. a) Representative links showing a positive and a negative
relation between SL and ADOS. b) Topographic projection of the coefficients of the regression, at two
different thresholds. Blue lines show negative coefficients (negative relation between SL and ASD
severity) and red lines show positive coefficients (positive relation between SL and ASD severity) c)
Histograms of coefficients as a function of distance between electrodes. The fraction of positive
coefficients decays monotonically as the distance increases. Negative coefficients distribution is more
homogeneous and remains significant at longer distances. d) Mean value of correlation coefficients as a
function of distance. For short distances, correlations are on average positive, indicating that short range
connections increase with ADOS. At long distances, correlations are on average negative indicating that
long range connections decrease with ADOS
Our results indicate reliable differences in the connectivity pattern of ASD and control
groups. We next investigated whether these differences resulted in network topologies
which may have consequences in properties of information flow in the ASD and control
group. Using the Kamada Kawai algorithm (Kamada & Kawai, 1989), we embedded the
ASD and control networks, showing the 1000 strongest connections, in the two-
dimensional plane (Figure 4a; visualizations of the networks at fixed threshold gave
qualitatively the same results, see Supplementary Figure 2). By simple inspection, it is
evident that the networks are qualitatively different. Control network presents a central
core of nodes –composed mainly by Mid-Frontal and Occipital electrodes, considering
the regions defined in Figure 2a. The ASD network is homogeneously connected, has a
larger diameter and appears to be more modular and less clustered.
To quantify these observations we used four canonical graph theory metrics: Degree
(K), Characteristic Path Length (L), Clustering Coefficient (C) and Modularity Index
(MI). The degree (K) of the network, which constitutes its simplest statistical indicator,
simply measures the average number of neighbours of each node (Figures 4b and 4c).
As expected, K diminished as the threshold increases, disconnecting nodes and
diminishing the size of the network. To investigate the effect of ASD on K, we
submitted the K values to an ANOVA with group (control or ASD) and T (binned in 8)
as independent factors. Results revealed a significant effect of group (F(1,1)=14.48;
p<0,01) as well as for threshold (F(1,7)=662; p<0,01), and a significant interaction
between both factors (F(1,1)=12.15; p<0,01). This shows that K was higher for the ASD
group and that this effect is not invariant for all thresholds (Figure 4b). To further
quantify where the differences between groups are located, we conducted a bootstrap
analysis to compare K at every threshold. We found that for an intermediate range of T
values (0.034-0.093), the degree was significantly higher in controls than in ASD, the
most significant difference found for T = 0.056 (bootstrap test, P<0.01). At this
threshold, we explored the topography of K for both groups. The scalp in Figure 4c
shows the difference between scalps of both groups (Control – ASD). As with our
previous findings, while the main finding is that K increases for Controls compared to
ASD on average, it displays a rich topographical distribution with areas showing larger
K and areas showing smaller K than ASD: Control group shows larger K than ASD in
the Mid Frontal and Occipital areas, and smaller K in the lateral Midline, a distribution
consistent with the observed pattern in figures 1 and 2 (green dots mark electrodes
where Kcontrol > KASD,; pink dots mark electrodes where KASD > Kcontrol, p<0.01).
Figure 4. Topology. of ASD and control functional connectivity networks: a) minimal energy plots of the
average networks for both groups. Colors represents the four electrode groups defined in figure 2. b)
Average degree as a function of threshold. Control group shows higher degree than ASD. b) topographic
map of the degree at threshold = 0.056. Green dots indicate electrodes where Kcontrol > KASD. Pink dots
indicate electrodes where KASD > Kcontrol , P<0.01) d) Characteristic path length (L) as a function of
threshold. Control group shows lower L than ASD. e) Clustering Coefficient (C) as a function of
threshold. Control group shows higher C than ASD. f) Modularity as a function of threshold. ASD group
shows higher modularity than Controls.
To quantify the notion of homogeneity we measured the distribution of K at different
nodes (simply comparing the max and min K, a standard deviation of the distribution
yielded the same results). Variations in K were less pronounced in ASD networks. At a
fixed threshold the relation min(K) / max(K) for a given subject is larger in ASD than in
Controls (mean controls = 0.02; mean ASD = 0.05; t(1,9): 2.39; p<0.05) demonstrating
a more homogeneously connected network in ASD.
The overall dependence of the Characteristic Path Length with T also followed a well
known behaviour (Figure 4d). As T increases, less edges remain and hence L increases.
For very high values of T, the graph disconnects in several components, only short-
range links remaining and hence L starts decreasing. To investigate the effect of ASD
on Characteristic Path Length, we submitted L to an ANOVA with group (control or
ASD) and T (binned in 8) as independent factors. Results revealed a significant effect of
group (F(1,1)=8.56; p<0,05) as well as for threshold (F(1,7)=186; p<0,01), and a
significant interaction between both factors (F(1,1)=4.91; p<0,01), showing that L was
higher for the ASD group (Figure 4d). To further quantify at which thresholds
differences between groups were significant, we conducted a bootstrap analysis to
compare L at every threshold. At intermediate range of values of T (0.042-0.073), L is
significantly larger for the ASD group, the most significant difference found at T =
0.056 (bootstrap test, p< 0.01).
We performed the same analysis to examine whether Clustering coefficient of ASD and
Control networks differed (Figure 4e). We submitted C to an ANOVA with group
(control or ASD) and T (binned in 8). Results revealed a significant effect of group
(F(1,1)=120.23; p<0,01) as well as for threshold (F(1,7)=295; p<0,01), and a non
significant interaction between both factors (F(1,1)=1.88; p>0.05), showing that the C
was higher for the ASD group (Figure 4e). Posthoc bootstrap analysis comparing L at
every threshold showed that, at intermediate range of values of T (0.017-0.044), C is
significantly larger for the control group; the most significant difference is found for T
= 0.032 (bootstrap test, p < 0.01).
Much effort has been devoted to the study of statistical indicators of networks,
particularly the Characteristic Path Length and the Clustering Coefficient. An
ubiquitous present topological network usually referred as small-world, which has a
relatively short (compared to random networks) Characteristic Path Length and high
Clustering Coefficient has been shown to be optimal for information transfer and
storage (Sporns & Zwi, 2004). Our combined findings (increased L and decreased C in
ASD compared to control networks) indicate that the ASD network topology is
consistently farther from being a small world than control network.
A direct consequence of the lack of long-range connections found in ASD is that
cortical areas may become relatively isolated from each other, resulting in turn in a
more modular organization (Galvao et al., 2010; Gallos, Song, Havlin, & Makse, 2007).
To assess this in a quantitative manner, we estimated the Modulation Index (MI) that
estimates the tendency of a network to split into modules. The dependence of MI with T
follows a trend similar to L (Figure 4f): as T increases, less edges remain and MI (and
the number of actual modules) increases. To investigate the effect of ASD on MI, we
submitted this data to an ANOVA with group (control or ASD) and T (binned in 8) as
independent factors. Results revealed a significant effect of group (F(1,1)=40.76;
p<0,01) as well as for threshold (F(1,7)=220; p<0,01), and a significant interaction
between both factors (F(1,1)=18.64; p<0,01), showing that the MI was higher for the
ASD group (Figure 4f). To further quantify where the differences between groups are
located, we conducted a bootstrap analysis to compare MI at every threshold. We found
that for a very wide range of values of T (0.005-0.14), MI is significantly larger for the
ASD group, the most significant difference found at T = 0.065 (bootstrap test, P < 0.01)
4. Discussion
The main purpose of this study was to characterize and compare resting state functional
brain networks in ASD and a neurotypical subjects. We studied networks derived from
stationary EEG data filtered at the delta band which has been shown to covary with
BOLD fluctuations in the resting state (He & Raichle, 2009; He, Snyder, Zempel,
Smyth, & Raichle, 2008). We observed reliable and consistent differences in the
connectivity patterns of both groups. ASD subjects showed a lack of long-range, fronto-
frontal and fronto occipital connections, and an enhancement of local, lateral frontal
connections. While the spatial resolution of EEG is limited, the topographical analysis
reported here can only be understood as referring to broad cortical regions. With this
caveat and note of caution, our results are consistent with fMRI data showing
diminished or lack of diminished connectivity in the midline, more specifically between
the medial prefrontal cortex and precuneus (Courchesne & Pierce, 2005; Hughes, 2007;
Kana, 2006; Weng, 2010). Similarly, our observation of increased connectivity in
prefronto-lateral nodes might be related with a lack of inhibition in dorsolateral
Prefrontal cortex and altered connectivity of the Anterior Insula, (Di Martino et al.,
2009; Kennedy, Redcay, & Courchesne, 2006; Weng, 2010).
Beyond broad group differences, our observation of a coherent
topographic
representation in a parametric measure of ASD determined by the ADOS score is
indicative of a gradual change of network properties with increasing severity of the
syndrome. Our results also revealed global trends related to proximity of correlations
and ASD: for increased ASD severity, local connections increased monotonically and
long range connections decreased. This global trend is also inline with fMRI results
relating the severity of ASD and fMRI correlation (Di Martino et al., 2009; Kennedy,
Redcay, & Courchesne, 2006; Weng, 2010).
While connectivity by itself conveys an interesting and informative measure, its main
relevance lies in the implications that it has for global function (information transfer,
functional specificity) of the network. Recent mathematical efforts have established
connecting bridges between connectivity measures and functional properties of the
emergent network (Barabasi, 2009; Galvao et al., 2010; Gallos, Song, Havlin, & Makse,
2007; Sporns & Zwi, 2004). Networks which establish an optimal balance between
local specialization and global integration -displaying the highest “complexity” (Sporns
& Zwi, 2004)- have characteristic small-world properties. Hence, our findings suggest
that the ASD functional networks – at least as revealed by low frequency connectivity –
may result in a less efficient and optimal scaffold for information processing and
storage.
Cortico-cortical connections can be roughly classified in two main groups (Schroeder &
Lakatos, 2009; Sporns & Zwi, 2004): local connections linking neurons in the same
cortical area (critical in generating functional specificity i.e., information) and long-
distance connections between neurons of different cortical regions, that ensure that
distant cortical sites can interact rapidly to generate dynamical patterns of temporal
correlations, allowing the integration of different sources of information into coherent
behavioural and cognitive states (Bressler, 1995; Friston, 2002; Nicoll, Larkman, &
Blakemore, 1993; Sporns & Zwi, 2004). The differences we found in this study suggest
that this compromise is unbalanced in ASD. The reduced long range connections may
provide a physiological measure for the lack of proper integration of information
observed in ASD (Frith, 1989). In this sense, the organization of the whole brain
networks might be related with the known differences in information processing
between typical and ASD individuals.
A ubiquitous aspect of brain function is its modular organization, with a large number
of processors (neurons, columns or entire areas) working in parallel. The workspace
theory argues that a distributed set of neurons with long axons provides a transient
global “broadcasting” system enabling communication between arbitrary and otherwise
not directly connected brain processors (Baars, 1988; Baars, 2005; Dehaene &
Naccache, 2001; Frith, 1989). While at this stage merely speculative and requiring
further investigation, these findings suggest that ASD individuals may have an atypical
workspace system, revealed in enhanced local connectivity, a more homogeneous
network lacking hubs and central nodes, and a more modular organization. While the
workspace system conveys brain function with a flexible communication protocol this
comes at a cost: it is slow and intrinsically serial (Pashler & O'Brien, 1993; Sergent,
Baillet, & Dehaene, 2005; Sigman & Dehaene, 2008; Zylberberg, Fernandez Slezak,
Roelfsema, Dehaene, & Sigman, 2010). Hence, a functional manifestation of the ASD
network might be to favour more parallel processing of information – being the cost of
this enhancement the lack of behavioural flexibility, core symptom of individuals with
ASD- an idea that resonates with the well known skills and handicaps of individuals
with ASD, such as a detailed perception at the expense of a poorer integration into a big
picture and, in rare cases, extraordinary performances in tasks such as the numerosity
skill or calendar computation -typical of many autistic savants (Dakin & Frith, 2005;
Mottron, Dawson, Soulieres, Hubert, & Burack, 2006; Thioux, Stark, Klaiman, &
Schultz, 2006). If this speculations were true, ASD symptoms, its enhancements and
handicaps, could be the symptoms of the lack of a proper workspace system. Future
work should clarify whether the similitude observed in ASD we point here -more
parallel processing/less behavioural flexibility on the one hand; more parallel low
frequency EEG network/lack of a marked central core in the low frequency EEG
network on the other - are indeed related.
Acknowledgements
MS and PB are supported by the Human Frontiers Science Program. BW is supported
by the CNRS. The authors want to thank Iñaki Landerreche for providing help with the
code to calculate SL.
References
Alexander, A. L., Lee, J. E., Lazar, M., Boudos, R., DuBray, M. B., Oakes, T. R., et al.
(2007). Diffusion
tensor
imaging of
the corpus callosum
in Autism.
Neuroimage, 34(1), 61-73.
APA. (2000). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition,
Text Revision. Washinton DC: American Psychiatric Association.
Baars, B. (1988). A cognitive theory of consciousness. New York: Cambridge
University Press.
Baars, B. J. (2005). Global workspace theory of consciousness: toward a cognitive
neuroscience of human experience. Prog Brain Res, 150, 45-53.
Barabasi, A. L. (2009). Scale-free networks: a decade and beyond. Science, 325(5939),
412-413.
Batagelj, J. V., & Mrvar, A. (1998). Pajek – A Program for Large Network Analysis.
Connections, 21(2), 47-57.
Belmonte, M. K., Allen, G., Beckel-Mitchener, A., Boulanger, L. M., Carper, R. A., &
Webb, S. J. (2004). Autism and abnormal development of brain connectivity. J
Neurosci, 24(42), 9228-9231.
Bressler, S. L. (1995). Large-scale cortical networks and cognition. Brain Res Brain Res
Rev, 20(3), 288-304.
Brown, C., Gruber, T., Boucher, J., Rippon, G., & Brock, J. (2005). Gamma
abnormalities during perception of illusory figures in autism. Cortex, 41(3), 364-
376.
Casanova, M., & Trippe, J. (2009). Radial cytoarchitecture and patterns of cortical
connectivity in autism. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci, 364(1522), 1433-
1436.
Casanova, M. F., van Kooten, I. A. J., Switala, A. E., van Engeland, H., Heinsen, H.,
Steinbusch, H. W. M., et al. (2006). Minicolumnar abnormalities in autism. Acta
Neuropathologica, 112, 287–303.
Cherkassky, V. L., Kana, R.K , Keller, T.A, Just, M. A. (2006). Functional connectivity
in a baseline resting-state network in autism. Neuroreport, 17(6), 1687-1690.
Coben, R., Clarke, A. R., Hudspeth, W., & Barry, R. J. (2008). EEG power and
coherence in autistic spectrum disorder. Clin Neurophysiol, 119(5), 1002-1009.
Courchesne, E., & Pierce, K. (2005). Why the frontal cortex in autism might be talking
only to itself: local over-connectivity but long-distance disconnection. Curr
Opin Neurobiol, 15(2), 225-230.
Dakin, S., & Frith, U. (2005). Vagaries of visual perception in autism. Neuron, 48(3),
497-507.
Dehaene, S., & Naccache, L. (2001). Towards a cognitive neuroscience of
consciousness: basic evidence and a workspace framework. Cognition, 79(1-2),
1-37.
Di Martino, A., Shehzad, Z., Kelly, C., Roy, A. K., Gee, D. G., Uddin, L. Q., et al.
(2009). Relationship between cingulo-insular functional connectivity and
autistic traits in neurotypical adults. Am J Psychiatry, 166(8), 891-899.
Efron, B., & Tibshirani, R. J. (1994). An Introduction to the Bootstrap. New York:
Chapman and Hall.
Egaas, B., Courchesne, E., & Saitoh, O. (1995). Reduced size of corpus callosum in
autism. Arch Neurol, 52(8), 794-801.
Friston, K. (2002). Beyond phrenology: what can neuroimaging tell us about distributed
circuitry? Annu Rev Neurosci, 25, 221-250.
Frith, U. (1989). Autism: explaining the enigma. Oxford, U.K.: Basil Blackwell.
Gallos, L. K., Song, C., Havlin, S., & Makse, H. A. (2007). Scaling theory of transport
in complex biological networks. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 104(19), 7746-7751.
Galvao, V., Miranda, J. G., Andrade, R. F., Andrade, J. S., Jr., Gallos, L. K., & Makse,
H. A. (2010). Modularity map of the network of human cell differentiation. Proc
Natl Acad Sci U S A, 107(13), 5750-5755.
Gusnard, D. A., & Raichle, M. E. (2001). Searching for a baseline: functional imaging
and the resting human brain. Nat Rev Neurosci, 2(10), 685-694.
He, B. J., & Raichle, M. E. (2009). The fMRI signal, slow cortical potential and
consciousness. Trends Cogn Sci, 13(7), 302-309.
He, B. J., Snyder, A. Z., Zempel, J. M., Smyth, M. D., & Raichle, M. E. (2008).
Electrophysiological correlates of the brain's intrinsic large-scale functional
architecture. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 105(41), 16039-16044.
Hughes, J. R. (2007). Autism: The first firm finding = underconnectivity? Epilepsy and
Behavior, 11, 20-24.
Just, M. A., Cherkassky, V. L., Keller, T. A., Kana, R. K., & Minshew, N. J. (2007).
Functional and Anatomical Cortical Underconnectivity in Autism: Evidence
from an fMRI Study of an Executive Function Task and Corpus Callosum
Morphometry. Cerebral Cortex, 17, 951--961.
Just, M. A., Cherkassky, V. L., Keller, T. A., & Minshew, N. J. (2004). Cortical
activation and synchronization during sentence comprehension in high-
functioning autism: evidence of underconnectivity. Brain, 127(Pt 8), 1811-1821.
Kamada, T., & Kawai, S. (1989). An algorithm for drawing general undirected graphs.
Information Processing Letters, 31, 7-15.
Kana, R. K., Keller, T.A. Cherkassky, V. L. Minshew, N.J., Just, M. A. (2006).
Sentence comprehension in autism: thinking in pictures with decreased
functional connectivity. Brain, 129(9), 484-2493.
Kennedy, D. P., Redcay, E., & Courchesne, E. (2006). Failing to deactivate: resting
functional abnormalities in autism. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 103(21), 8275-
8280.
Kleinhans, N. M., Richards, T., Sterling, L., Stegbauer, K. C., Mahurin, R., Johnson, L.
C., et al. (2008). Abnormal functional connectivity in autism spectrum disorders
during face processing. Brain, 131(Pt 4), 1000-1012.
Koshino, H., Carpenter, P. A., Minshew, N. J., Cherkassky, V. L., Keller, T. A., & Just,
M. A. (2005). Functional connectivity in an fMRI working memory task in high-
functioning autism. Neuroimage, 24(3), 810-821.
Latora, V., & Marchiori, M. (2001). Efficient behavior of small-world networks. Phys
Rev Lett, 87(19), 198701.
Lord, C., Risi, S., Lambrecht, L., Cook, E. H., Jr., Leventhal, B. L., DiLavore, P. C., et
al. (2000). The autism diagnostic observation schedule-generic: a standard
measure of social and communication deficits associated with the spectrum of
autism. J Autism Dev Disord, 30(3), 205-223.
Lu, H., Zuo, Y. Gu, H., Waltz, J. A. Zhan, W. Scholl, C.A. Rea, W. Yang. (2007).
Synchronized delta oscillations correlate with the resting-state functional MRI
signal. Proceeedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 104(46), 18265–
18269
Markram, H., Rinaldi, T., & Markram, K. (2007). The intense world syndrome--an
alternative hypothesis for autism. Front Neurosci, 1(1), 77-96.
Mason, R. A., Williams, D. L., Kana, R. K., Minshew, N., & Just, M. A. (2008). Theory
of Mind disruption and recruitment of the right hemisphere during narrative
comprehension in autism. Neuropsychologia, 46(1), 269-280.
McAlonan, G. M., Cheung, V., Cheung, C., Suckling, J., Lam, G. Y., Tai, K. S., et al.
(2005). Mapping the brain in autism. A voxel-based MRI study of volumetric
differences and intercorrelations in autism. Brain, 128(Pt 2), 268-276.
Montez, T., Linkenkaer-Hansen, K., van Dijk, B. W., & Stam, C. J. (2006).
Synchronization likelihood with explicit time-frequency priors. Neuroimage,
33(4), 1117-1125.
Mottron, L., Dawson, M., Soulieres, I., Hubert, B., & Burack, J. (2006). Enhanced
perceptual functioning in autism: an update, and eight principles of autistic
perception. J Autism Dev Disord, 36(1), 27-43.
Murias, M., Webb, S. J., Greenson, J, Dawson, G. (2008). Resting state cortical
connectivity reflected in EEG coherence in individuals with autism. Biological
Psychiatry, 62(3), 270–273.
Nicoll, A., Larkman, A., & Blakemore, C. (1993). Modulation of EPSP shape and
efficacy by intrinsic membrane conductances in rat neocortical pyramidal
neurons in vitro. J Physiol, 468, 693-710.
Pashler, H., & O'Brien, S. (1993). Dual-task interference and the cerebral hemispheres.
J Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perform, 19(2), 315-330.
Raichle, M. E. (2009). A paradigm shift in functional brain imaging. J Neurosci, 29(41),
12729-12734.
Rubinov, M., & Sporns, O. (2009). Complex network measures of brain connectivity:
Uses and interpretations. Neuroimage.
Schroeder, C. E., & Lakatos, P. (2009). Low-frequency neuronal oscillations as
instruments of sensory selection. Trends Neurosci, 32(1), 9-18.
Sergent, C., Baillet, S., & Dehaene, S. (2005). Timing of the brain events underlying
access to consciousness during the attentional blink. Nat Neurosci, 8(10), 1391-
1400.
Sigman, M., & Dehaene, S. (2008). Brain mechanisms of serial and parallel processing
during dual-task performance. J Neurosci, 28(30), 7585-7598.
Sporns, O., & Zwi, J. D. (2004). The small world of the cerebral cortex.
Neuroinformatics, 2(2), 145-162.
Stam, C. J., & van Dijk, B. W. (2002). Synchronization likelihood: an unbiased measure
of generalized synchronization in multivariate data ses. Physica D, 163(3), 236-
251.
Thioux, M., Stark, D. E., Klaiman, C., & Schultz, R. T. (2006). The day of the week
when you were born in 700 ms: calendar computation in an Autistic savant. J
Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perform, 32(5), 1155-1168.
Welchew, D. E., Ashwin, C., Berkouk, K., Salvador, R., Suckling, J., Baron-Cohen, S.,
et al. (2005). Functional disconnectivity of the medial temporal lobe in
Asperger's syndrome. Biol Psychiatry, 57(9), 991-998.
Weng, S. J., Wiggins, J. L Peltier S. J Carrasco, M Risi, S, Lord, C Monk, C.S. (2010).
Alterations of resting state functional connectivity in the default network in
adolescents with autism spectrum disorders. Brain Research, 1313, 202-214.
Wicker, B., Fonlupt, P.,Hubert, B., Tardif, C., Gepner, B., Deruelle, C. (2008).
Abnormal cerebral effective connectivity during explicit emotional processing in
adults with autism spectrum disorder. Social Cognitive and Affective
Neuroscience, 3(2), 135-143.
Wilson, T. W., Rojas, C.D Reite, M.L, Teale, P. D. Rogers, S.J. (2007). Children and
Adolescents with Autism Exhibit Reduced MEG Steady-State Gamma
Responses. Biological Psychiatry, 62, 192-197.
Zylberberg, A., Fernandez Slezak, D., Roelfsema, P. R., Dehaene, S., & Sigman, M.
(2010). The brain's router: a cortical network model of serial processing in the
primate brain. PLoS Comput Biol, 6(4), e1000765.
Supplementary Figure 1. Pairs of electrodes displaying differences in connectivity between ASD and
control groups at several thresholds.. Blue lines: conections weaker in ASD than in controls. Red lines:
connections stronger in ASD than in controls. a) Different values for the filter of T values (SL-value
=0.03). b) Different values for the filter of SL-value (t-value =2).
Supplementary Figure 2. Visualization of ASD and control networks for a fixed threshold of 0.05. The
topography of the networks is qualitatively equal to the topography when the degree is fixed.
|
1611.09245 | 1 | 1611 | 2016-11-17T14:25:45 | Evolving Network Model that Almost Regenerates Epileptic Data | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | In many realistic networks, the edges representing the interactions between the nodes are time-varying. There is growing evidence that the complex network that models the dynamics of the human brain has time-varying interconnections, i.e., the network is evolving. Based on this evidence, we construct a patient and data specific evolving network model (comprising discrete-time dynamical systems) in which epileptic seizures or their terminations in the brain are also determined by the nature of the time-varying interconnections between the nodes. A novel and unique feature of our methodology is that the evolving network model remembers the data from which it was conceived from, in the sense that it evolves to almost regenerate the patient data even upon presenting an arbitrary initial condition to it. We illustrate a potential utility of our methodology by constructing an evolving network from clinical data that aids in identifying an approximate seizure focus -- nodes in such a theoretically determined seizure focus are outgoing hubs that apparently act as spreaders of seizures. We also point out the efficacy of removal of such spreaders in limiting seizures. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Evolving Network Model that Almost Regenerates
Epileptic Data
G. Manjunath
Department of Mathematics, Rhodes University, South Africa
Email: {m.gandhi}@ru.ac.za
Abstract
In many realistic networks, the edges representing the interactions between the
nodes are time-varying. There is growing evidence that the complex network that
models the dynamics of the human brain has time-varying interconnections, i.e., the
network is evolving. Based on this evidence, we construct a patient and data specific
evolving network model (comprising discrete-time dynamical systems) in which epilep-
tic seizures or their terminations in the brain are also determined by the nature of the
time-varying interconnections between the nodes. A novel and unique feature of our
methodology is that the evolving network model remembers the data from which it was
conceived from, in the sense that it evolves to almost regenerate the patient data even
upon presenting an arbitrary initial condition to it. We illustrate a potential utility
of our methodology by constructing an evolving network from clinical data that aids
in identifying an approximate seizure focus -- nodes in such a theoretically determined
seizure focus are outgoing hubs that apparently act as spreaders of seizures. We also
point out the efficacy of removal of such spreaders in limiting seizures.
Keywords: Mathematical modeling, time-varying network, state forgetting
property, focal epilepsy, discrete-time dynamical system, nonautonomous dy-
namical system
1
1
Introduction
Increasingly, many complex systems are being modeled as networks since the framework of
nodes representing the basic elements of the system and the interconnections of the network
representing the interaction between the elements fits well for a theoretical study. When the
complex systems are large-dimensional dynamical systems, the network framework comprises
many interacting subsystems of smaller dimension each of which constitutes a node. As a
particular example, the whole or a portion of the entire neuronal activity in the human
brain can be regarded as the consequential dynamics of interacting subsystems, where the
dynamics of a subsystem is generated by a group of neurons. The enormously interconnected
subsystems in the brain generate a wide variety of dynamical patterns, synchronised activities
and rhythms.
Epilepsy is a disorder that affects the nerve cell activity which in turn intermittently
causes seizures. During such seizures, patients could experience abnormal sensations includ-
ing loss of consciousness. Clinical and theoretical research have shown that underpinning the
cause of this disorder has not proved to be easy, in particular the predicament of resolving
the question as to whether the disorder manifests due to the nature of the interconnections
in the brain or the pathologicity of a portion of the brain tissue itself remains.
Since epilepsy is one of the most common neurological disorders with an estimate of
more than 50 million individuals being affected [26], there is a strong need both for curative
treatment and as well for the analysis of the underlying structure and dynamics that could
bring about seizures.
In this paper, our attention is on focal epilepsy where the origin
of the seizures are circumscribed to certain regions of the brain called the seizure focus
[4, 3, 7, 19, 27, 32, 36], and the aim of this paper is to foster theoretical investigation into
the connection strengths of the underlying nodes in such a seizure focus in comparison to
the other nodes in the network.
Different models have been proposed to understand different aspects of focal epilepsy
[1, 13, 38]. Mathematically speaking, dynamical system models of focal epilepsy studied
in the literature are mainly of two broad categories: (i). Models that consider noise to be
2
inducing seizures in a node [15, 31, 34] (ii). Models that consider seizures to be caused or
terminated by a bifurcation, a change in the intrinsic feature of the (autonomous) dynamics
at the node [5, 24, 28].
While modeling the neuronal activity of the human brain, there are far too many nu-
merous parameters which also dynamically evolve on separate spaces and scales, and it is
unrealistic to observe or encapsulate all these aspects in a static network or an autonomous
dynamical system (see Appendix A). Since the brain evolution does not depend on its own
internal states as it responds to external stimuli and the interconnections in the brain are
likely to change in response to stimuli, the human brain can be safely said to be a nonau-
tonomous system and in the language of network dynamics, this is effectively an evolving
network (see Section 2).
Besides evidence that network connections play a role in initiating seizures (e.g., [2, 4,
20, 32]), some authors also provide evidence that stronger interconnections play a role in
epileptic seizures (e.g., [11, 25]). Also, a commonly found feature of biological systems is
adaptation: an increase in exogenous disturbance beyond a threshold activates a change
in the physiological or biochemical state, succeeded by an adaptation of the system that
facilitates the gradual relaxation of these states toward a basal, pre-disturbance level. Based
on all these, we present a novel phenomenological model where seizures could be activated
in a node, if certain interconnections change to have larger weights resulting in a larger
exogenous drive or disturbance or energy transmitted from other nodes into it, and upon
experiencing seizure, adjustment of interconnections takes place eventually to subside the
seizures. Since the interconnections are allowed to change, the model dynamics emerges from
an evolving network.
In this paper, we propose a patient and data-specific, macroscopic, functional network
model that can act as a "surrogate" representation of the electroencephalography (EEG)
or electrocorticography (ECoG) time-series. The network model is new in the sense that it
satisfies the following simultaneously: the network connections are directed and weighted;
the network connections are time-varying; there is a discrete-time dynamical system at each
3
node whose dynamics is constantly influenced by the rest of the network's structure and
dynamics; the ability of the network to generate a time-series that sharply resembles the
original data is based on a notion of robustness of the dynamics of the network to its initial
conditions what we call as the "state-forgetting" property.
The essence of the state-forgetting property, roughly put is that the current state of the
brain does not have an " distinct imprint" of the brain's past right since from its "genesis"
or "origin" (rigorous definitions are provided later in the paper). Effectively, this means that
the brain tends to forget its past history as time progresses. Such a notion has been adapted
from the previously proposed notions for studying static (artificial neural) networks with
an exogenous input in the field of machine learning viz., echo state property [12, 22], liquid
state machines, [21], backpropagation-decorrelation learning,[33] and others. However, the
network model that we represent is very different from that of the artificial neural networks
and moreover the nodes in our model correspond to different regions of the brain.
Our methodology is as follows: We present an evolving network model which exhibits
state-forgetting property for all possible inter-connections, and a particular sequence of inter-
connection strengths (matrices) is determined from a given EEG/ECoG time-series so that
the model can almost regenerate the time-series. The weights of the interconnections are
chosen from a set of possibilities based on a heuristic algorithm that infers a causal relation-
ship between nodes -- a (directed) synchrony measure between two nodes i and j represents
the conductance (ease at which energy flows) from node j into node i, and weight of the
connection from node j into node i has some degree of proportionality with the synchrony
measure.
The state forgetting property ensures the synthesized evolving network has in some sense
captured the original time series as an "attractor" (see [23] and Proposition C.1), and hence
the network acts as surrogate representation of the original time series. In other words, since
any initial condition presented to a state-forgetting network has no effect on its asymptotic
dynamics, and that the asymptotic dynamics resembles the time-series, we assume that the
evolving network model has captured the essence of the time-series data.
4
To indicate the potential utilities of the model, we analyse the constructed evolving net-
work from a patient's clinical data. By comparing the relative strength of the interconnec-
tions, we identify nodes that are outgoing hubs of the network as a theoretically determined
seizure focus. The nodes in such a focus have a strong location-wise correlation with the
set of nodes in a clinically determined seizure focus. We also, discuss the efficacy of surgical
removal of the determined focus in subsiding seizures.
The remainder of the paper is organised as follows. We introduce the notion of state-
forgetting evolving networks in Section 2; formal definitions are made in Appendix B. In
Section 3, we present the evolving network model in detail and state a result concerning
the state-forgetting property; the complete mathematical proof of this result is presented in
Appendix C. In Section 4, we present a method to obtain the weight matrices to obtain a
time-varying network from a clinical time series. In Section 5, we present some results on
the network inference followed by a brief discussion and conclusion in Section 6.
2 Evolving networks that are state-forgetting
The aim of this section is to give an intuitive description of the state forgetting property
of evolving networks; the formal and rigorous definitions of this property are found in Ap-
pendix B. We employ discrete-time systems [6] since they are more amenable to computer
simulations as the computed orbits or solutions unlike in the case of differential equations
do not depend on numerical methods for computing the solutions and their related accu-
racy. Also, discrete-time systems can exhibit complex dynamical behaviour (e.g., [6]) even
in one-dimension whereas a continuous time-system needs a dimension of at least three.
Using Fig. 1, we present a less formal and simplistic description of an evolving network
with three nodes i = 1, 2, 3. Let W (n) be a 3 × 3 matrix defined for each integer n with
Wij(n) being the strength of the incoming connection from node j to node i; here Wij(n)
is the element in the ith row and jth column of W (n). There is a discrete-time dynamical
system at each node in the evolving network represented in Fig. 1, and the ith node dynamics
5
is given by
(cid:0)x1(n), x2(n), x3(n), Wi1(n), Wi2(n), Wi3(n)(cid:1),
xi(n + 1) = hi
where hi is some function (not dependent on n) that calculates xi(n + 1) using information
from the dynamical state in the three nodes at time n and the respective incoming strengths
into node i. By specifying h1, h2 and h3 together with the sequence of weight matrices W (n),
the evolving network is specified completely. By denoting x(n) := (x1(n), x2(n), x3(n)), we
can represent the evolving network dynamics also as a nonautonomous system x(n + 1) =
gn(x(n)), where the variation of gn with n represents the inherent plasticity of the system
(change in W (n) above). We can also allow gn's to represent external stimuli to the network
and other obfuscated factors.
Figure 1: A schematic of an evolving network with three nodes and the plot of the time
series x1(n) from Node 1
Since an evolving network is essentially a nonautonomous system, we recall some relevant
results of a nonautonomous system. Of interest to us is the notion of an entire-solution of a
nonautonomous system. An entire solution (or orbit) of a nonautonomous system {gn} is a
6
sequence {ϑn} that satisfies ϑn+1 = gn(ϑn) for all n ∈ Z. It is possible to show under natural
conditions that there exist at least one entire solution [22]. In the particular case, where
the evolving network has a unique entire solution, we say that the network (or the nonau-
tonomous system) has the state-forgetting property (formally defined in Definition B.2).
Now, we comment on the rather intriguing consequence of an evolving network {gn}
having multiple entire-solutions. Suppose {ϑn} and {θn} are two distinct entire-solutions of
a nonautonomous dynamical system, then for some time n = n0, we have ϑn0 (cid:54)= θn0 i.e, the
system could have evolved into two possible states at time n0. Since ϑn0 = gn0−1(ϑn0−1) and
θn0 = gn0−1(θn0−1), it is necessary to have ϑn0−1 (cid:54)= θn0−1. Similarly, ϑn0−1 (cid:54)= θn0−1 would
necessitate ϑn0−2 (cid:54)= θn0−2 and so on. Thus, in general, at any time-instant n0, ϑn0 (cid:54)= θn0
implies that there are two entire-solutions that have had distinct infinitely long pasts. In
other words, the dynamics of such systems with distinct entire-solutions "depends" not only
on the inherent plasticity or the exogenous stimuli represented by the maps {gn}, the distinct
solutions carry a distinct and non-vanishing imprint of their past.
From the arguments in the preceding paragraph, for nonautonomous systems like the
human brain, having more than one entire solution translates to saying that the current
state of the brain is not just the result of the changing interconnections in the brain or
the exogenous input but to also say that its past states have a non-vanishing effect on the
asymptotic dynamics.
Since it is hard to envisage or believe that seizures in current time had something to do
with the state of the brain right from its "genesis" (genesis is used as a metaphor to refer
to the earliest factual time instant from which the current brain state has evolved from, and
this time could be matter of debate), we assume the more plausible -- seizures at a certain
time are a consequence of how the network structure has evolved/changed till that time or
a result of a stream of exogenous inputs to the brain, but certainly not a consequence of the
state at which the brain was in during its genesis. This also forms the basis for employing
echo-state networks in artificial neural network training and machine learning[12, 22].
Whenever a nonautonomous system (technically, defined on a compact state space) has
7
the state-forgetting property, it also has state-space contraction towards its entire-solution in
the backward direction (see Proposition C.1). In fact, a stronger result [23] holds: if {xn} is
the unique entire solution, then for every y0 ∈ X the successive iterates yn+1 = gn(xn) would
satisfy yn−xn → 0 as n → ∞. In other words, {xn} "attracts" all other state-space iterates
towards it (component-wise) as time tends to infinity. This convergence due to the attractor
property of the state-forgetting property is what makes our evolving network model generate
a time-series that actually sharply resembles (mathematically, converges to) the data from
which the network was conceived. Further discussion on attractivity is beyond the scope of
this paper. The larger point is that for an evolving network to be of utility as a surrogate
representation of the time-series data, we need the state-forgetting property.
3 Model
Before, we actually describe the evolving network model in (6), we list and describe its
features: (i).
The evolving network model has N -nodes for all time. (ii).
Placed
at each node is a certain bi-parametric one-dimensional discrete-time dynamical system
which is autonomous when there are no incoming connections from other nodes to it, and
nonautonomous otherwise. We refer to the dynamics of the system at a node, as the dynamics
of the node or nodal dynamics. (iii). Among the two parameters that specify this one-
dimensional dynamical system is a stability parameter. The nodal dynamics in autonomous
mode has a globally stable fixed point at 0 whenever the stability parameter is in a certain
range (stable-regime); a globally stable fixed point attracts all solutions, i.e, the time series
values measured in the node are close to 0 and tend towards to it. (iv). When the stability
parameter is chosen not to lie in the stable regime, the autonomous nodal dynamics can
render a range of different behaviours including oscillatory behavior, complex behavior like
chaos [6] depending upon the value of the stability parameter. (v). When the nodal
dynamics is nonautonomous, the dynamics of the node is perturbed at each time-instant
from the dynamical states of other nodes. We call the net perturbation from other nodes
8
as the drive to the node under consideration. The exogenous drive from other nodes has
its signature on the nodal dynamics, and if sufficiently strong, is also capable of setting the
nodal dynamics far away from the fixed point 0. (vi). We term a seizure in the node to be
a dynamical excursion away from the fixed point, and that the seizures in a node are brought
about (and terminated) in two distinct scenarios: (via). changing the stability parameter
of the node in the autonomous mode of operation (vib). by the nature of the exogenous
drive from the other nodes in the network in the nonautonomous mode. (vii).
In this
paper, we consider the case of nodal dynamics slipping into seizures as in scenario (vib)
above, i.e, we consider each node to have its stability parameter to lie in the stable regime,
and the exogenous drive to cause seizures. The drive is time-varying on two accounts: first,
being a function of the states of the other nodes it is time-varying as other nodes have a
dynamical system and not static; second, the drive is time-varying since it is a function of
the interconnection strengths of the nodes.
Our model is also motivated on the lines of previous research [14, 30, 35, 37] showing that
the hyper-interconnected regions in the brain are prone to seizures (see Section 3). Hence,
we expect the drive to an individual node is likely to be having large magnitude if it has
large weighted incoming connections.
To describe a family of evolving networks (as in Definition B.1), we first sketchily de-
scribe the nonautonomous dynamics at each node i (the map hi described in Section 2 or in
+
net drive from
from all other
nodes j (cid:54)= i
fa,b(xi(n)), the
update at the
ith node
,
(1)
Definition B.1) via the update equation:
=
xi(n + 1), state
of node at
time n + 1
saturation
function
where the various entities are listed and briefly explained:
• The iteration of the map fa,b on an initial condition gives the autonomous dynamics of
the node. Some Neuron models like that of Fitzhugh-Nagumo (e.g., [9, 29]) permit an
individual neuron to have a regenerative self-excitation via a feedback term. Based on
9
this principle, we consider a highly simplistic discrete time model of the node dynamics
where feedback from the node dynamics can cause self-excitation, and set
fa,b(x) := a x3 − b x,
(2)
where parameters 0 < a < 1 and 0 < b < 3 (for a graph of fa,b, see Fig. 2(a)). Expla-
nation on how a parameter can cause self-excitation dynamics is made in Section 3.1.
• Adopting the principle that the individual drive from a connecting node has a larger
magnitude if the incoming connection weight and the magnitude of the state value of
the connecting node are together larger, we set the total sum of the drives from the
other (N − 1) nodes into the node i to be =
log
φ(Wij(n)) · (d + xj(n))
,
(3)
(cid:16)
− (cid:88)
j(cid:54)=i
(cid:17)
where Wij(n) is the weight of the incoming connection from the jth node to the ith
node; d > 0 is an offset parameter to enable a positive argument for the log function;
φ : [0,∞) → [0,∞) is an increasing function and is defined by
√
log(1+(cid:63)).
e
φ((cid:63)) :=
1
d
(4)
The function φ although increasing, has a monotonically decreasing slope (see Fig. 2(c)).
The net effect of the function φ can be thought of as the node's mechanism to have
a relatively stronger inhibition to a stronger incoming connection -- node's internal
mechanism to resist seizures by inhibiting stronger exogenous drive. Lastly, the nega-
tive sign in (3) is only for mathematical convenience and has no physical significance.
When the drive is zero, the dynamics of the node i is in autonomous mode.
• The saturation function henceforth would be the mapping σ : R → R which is linear
in a certain adjustable range, and its slope becomes zero asymptotically (see Fig. 2(b))
10
defined by:
σ(y) =
y
: y ∈ [−p, p]
1
r log( 1
− 1
r log( 1
r + (y − p)) + k
r − (y + p)) − k : y < p,
: y > p
(5)
where p > 0 and σ is the identify function on [−p, p]; r > 1 determines the asymptotic
rate at which the slope of σ decreases and k = p − 1
r ). (see Fig. 2(b)); σ is linear
in the region (−p, p) with a slope 1, and the slope of σ(y) approaches 0 as y → ∞
r log( 1
monotonically according to
1
1+r(y−p).
Putting together the above into (1), the update equation at the ith node is modeled by:
(cid:18)
fa,b(xi(n)) − (cid:88)
(cid:16)
(cid:19)
φ(cid:0)Wij(n)(cid:1) · (d + xj(n))
.
log
j(cid:54)=i
xi(n + 1) = σ
(6)
Note that in the model in (6), the weights Wij(n) are unspecified, but they actually
can be solved for given a ECoG/EEG time-series {xn} (topic of Section 4). In Section 3.1
and 3.2, we describe the dynamics of a node when it operates in autonomous node and in
the nonautonomous mode. In Section 3.3, we state sufficient conditions on the parameters
a,b and d, to ensure state-forgetting property of any evolving network arising out of (6).
However, to understand the model, a few remarks are in order concerning the role of the
offset parameter d and the saturation function σ in (6):
(cid:17)
11
(cid:16)
From (3), it follows that the individual drive from the node j into node i, at time n is given
by uij(n) := − log
a smaller weight Wij(n) should ensure smaller individual drive from node j, i.e., we must
. To make the role of the weights meaningful,
φ(Wij(n)) · (d + xj(n))
have uij(n) close to zero whenever Wij(n) is close to zero. We note that this would be the
case whenever the offset parameter d is sufficiently large. To observe this, we remark on
the behavior of uij(n) as the weight Wij(n) gets close to zero. By definition of φ in (4),
when Wij(n) is close to zero, it follows that φ(Wij(n)) is close to 1
to 1
d, uij(n) is close to log( d+xj (n)
d
Section 4), and hence if d is much larger than xj(n), then d+xj (n)
d
d. When φ(Wij(n)) is close
). For practical purposes we restrict xi(n) ∈ [−1, 1] (see
is close to 1, and log( d+xj (n)
)
d
is close to zero, and thus uij(n) is very close to zero. However, it is also to be noted that if
d is made unreasonably large, the signature of xj(n) on uij(n) gets weaker, so d is chosen in
an appropriate range, although with a large value. Physiologically, the parameter d has no
direct relation, but serves as a mathematical plug to overcome the difficulty in modeling the
drive directly from the dynamical states of a connecting node that take both positive and
negative values. The offset d has another role: its value could determine the state-forgetting
property of an evolving network (see Theorem 3.3.1).
The particular choice of the saturation function σ is not critical to the model; for the
convenience of mathematical proofs, we need σ to be differentiable and unbounded and hence
its form. On the other hand, for practical reasons, choosing such a σ, helps in the simulation
stage to troubleshoot if each of the parameters a,b and d are chosen in an appropriate range
lest the network lose the state-forgetting property. While the network does not have the
state-forgetting property, the dynamics can be unbounded in the absence of a saturation
function since the range of fa,b is unbounded and the numerical values on a computer could
indicate an error.
3.1 Isolated node-dynamics
We present a short summary of the dynamics of the family of maps fa,b described in (2).
The detailed analysis of this family of maps is not the subject matter of this paper, and the
discussion here is only intended to convey the point that the dynamics of fab adds notable
features to the evolving network model. Recall that the parameters a, b are restricted to
0 < a < 1 and 0 < b ≤ 3. With b ≤ 3, it can be easily verified that there is an invariant
closed interval J symmetrically extending on either side of the real number 0 given by
(cid:3), i.e., fa,b(J) = J. The dynamics of fa,b on J is relevant to us
since the dynamics outside J escapes to ±∞. With a fixed, and increasing b through 0 to
(cid:113) b
J := (cid:2) − 2
3a ,
2
(cid:113) b
3a
3, the dynamics of this family of maps on J takes a route to chaos qualitatively similar to
the variation in b from 0 to 4 in the well studied logistic family of maps L(x) = bx(1 − x)
12
(a) fa,b with a = 0.01 and b = 0.9
(b) σ with p = 5 and r = 5
(c) φ with d = 500
Figure 2: Graphs of fa,b, σ and φ
on [0, 1] (for e.g., [6]). Elaborating this further, when 0 < b < 1, the fixed point is globally
stable, in the sense that every orbit asymptotically approaches the fixed point as n tends to
∞; when b = 1, the fixed point loses stability and undergoes a period doubling bifurcation.
As b is increased beyond 2, period doubling cascades occur alike in the logistic family of
maps [6], and eventually there is a transition to chaos. Thus each node has the potential
to have self-excitatory dynamics (oscillate or exhibit complicated behaviour) if the stability
parameter for the node b is set between 1 < b ≤ 3.
3.2 Driven node-dynamics
Adding a time varying drive u(n) to the update equation of fa,b by
13
−15−10−5051015−15−10−5051015−15−10−5051015−15−10−5051015024681000.0020.0040.0060.0080.01 xi(n + 1) = a (xi(n))3 − bxi(n) − u(n),
makes the mapping xi(n) (cid:55)→ xi(n + 1) depend on n, and clearly the graph of such a mapping
at any n is a vertically shifted version of the graph of Fig. 2(a) with the shift determined by
u(n). Since, we expect u(n) to be changing with every n, the stable fixed point dynamics
is not a feature of nonautonomous dynamics. As mentioned above, increasing b beyond 1,
makes the dynamics move away from the fixed point at 0. We make use of the fact that to
move the nonautonomous dynamics away from the fixed point, it is not necessarily required to
increase b beyond 1, but a sufficiently strong drive is capable of moving the dynamics. Also,
some background observations and computer simulations suggest that larger the magnitude
of drive, further away is the likelihood of the dynamics away from 0.
3.3 Is the evolving network state-forgetting?
Having made some points on the nodal dynamics, we now state a result on the evolving
network. Next, we state a theorem which says that when d is sufficiently large, then any
evolving network obtained from (5) is state-forgetting. The complete proof of this result is
provided in Appendix C.
Theorem 3.3.1 Fix non-zero, positive reals a, b, λ such that the following hold
b < λ < 1 & a <
λ + b
3
.
Also, fix a saturation function σ as in Equation (5) with p > 1, and a time series {x(n) =
(x1(n), . . . , xN (n))} such that xi(n) ∈ [−1, +1] for all 1 ≤ i ≤ N and all n ∈ Z. There exists
a real number D > 0 such that for all d > D, if (6) holds for all 1 ≤ i ≤ N and n ∈ Z for
some {W (n)} ⊂ RN×N , then the resultant evolving network is state-forgetting.
14
4 Heuristic algorithm: directed weights from EEG/ECoG
time-series
Henceforth, for ease of jargon we call the ith component of a N -dimensional time series data
{x(n)}, i.e., {xi(n)} the data in the ith channel. Given {x(n)}, we present a method for
solving the weights Wij(n) in(6) based on inferring a causal relationship between the nodes,
which we call a synchrony measure.
To explain the methodology of solving weights from (6), we rewrite (6) by rearranging as
log(φ(Wij(n))(d + xj(n))) = a (xi(n))3 − b xi(n) − σ−1(cid:0)xi(n + 1)(cid:1),
(7)
(cid:88)
j(cid:54)=i
where σ−1 is the inverse of the saturation function σ. Clearly, given a N -dimensional time-
series {x(n)} of EEG or ECoG clinical data, and having fixed a, b in the model, the right
hand side of (7) can be computed easily for each n from the ith channel data. Let ri(n)
denote the right hand side term in (7).
For a fixed i, we have a single equation
(cid:88)
j(cid:54)=i
log(φ(Wij(n))(d + xj(n))) = ri(n),
(8)
where there are N − 1 unknown quantities (Wij(n)) as j is varied from 1 to N with j (cid:54)= i.
Hence, multiple solutions of Wij(n) could exist since we have more unknowns than equations.
We regard seizure spread in the network due to sustained energy transmitted from a node
that is seizing to the ones which is not. With this principle, we hypothesize Wij(n) to be
an increasing parametric function of a certain synchrony measure ρij(n) between the two
distinct nodes i and j. Physiologically, the synchrony measure between two nodes i and j
represents the ease at which energy dissipates (a measure of conductance) from node j into
node i, and hence is directed -- nodes i and j could have different interconnections, and energy
dissipation between nodes is not symmetric. To get a measure of such conductance, we let
the synchrony measure ρij(n) depend on (i) a sustained influence from node j into node i
measured by a leaky integrator placed between the two nodes (ii) the similarity between the
average amplitude or power in the two channels up to time n.
15
The algorithm for computation of directed synchrony ρij(n) between two channels is
described in Section 4.1. We now explain the idea/reasoning behind some of the steps of the
algorithm. The discussion can be read in conjunction with the various steps of the algorithm.
The very first step of the algorithm involves normalisation of the amplitude of data for
setting the amplitude of the time-series in any channel lies between [−1, 1] (see (S1) of
Section 4.1).
In a succeeding stage of the algorithm, we compute the average power at each instant in
a window of length τ in each channel (see definition of Pi(n) in (S6) of Section 4.1). It turns
out that the time interval in which there is sustained influence of one node on the other by
the synchrony measure is determined by τ . We comment on the choice of τ in Section 5.1
The directed synchrony ρij(n) depends on the product of two factors (see (S7) of Sec-
tion 4.1). One of the factors is the similarity between the powers in the ith and jth channels
which we quantify by a similarity index (1 − Pi(n) − Pj(n)). Note that due to normal-
isation in (S1), the average power Pi(n) in any window is between 0 and 1, and hence
0 ≤ (1 − Pi(n) − Pj(n)) ≤ 1, and the similarity index attains 1 if and only if Pi(n) and
Pj(n) are identical.
The other factor that contributes to ρij(n) is Qij(n), the output of a (directed) nonlinear
leaky integrator placed between two distinct nodes and whose states are evaluated recur-
sively (for details see (S8) to (S12) of Section 4.1)). The purpose of such a leaky integrator
is to model the sustained influence of the signal strength in the node j on node i -- the
word sustained points to the fact that the integrator leaks, and unless the influence is not
sustained over a period of time, the influence diminishes. Any such leaky integrator in (S11)
of Section 4.1 is a nonautonomous dynamical system in its own right, and hence its future
states are obtained by iteration on the current state. In essence, a leaky integrator sums up
(or integrates) its previous state with what is fed to it typically as an input, but also leaks a
small fraction of the sum while integrating. Here, we set the leaky integrator dynamics for
16
the connection from node j to i as
Qij(n + 1)), state
of leaky integrator
at time n + 1
=
leaky
integrating
function
+
¯¯Pj(n), cumulative
average-fractional
power at time n
Qij(n), state of
leaky integrator
at time n
,
where the cumulative average power ¯¯Pj(n) in the jth channel is calculated as in (S9) of the
algorithm. This cumulative average fractional power is determined by first calculating the
fractional power in the jth channel (see (S8) of the algorithm). The cumulative average of
this fractional power is calculated as in (S9) of the algorithm; this cumulative average is
calculated iteratively using the elementary idea: to calculate the average of a collection of
M numbers (s1, . . . , sM ), if the average of M − 1 numbers is given to be AM−1, then the
average of M numbers AM can be updated by AM = (M − 1)AM−1 + sM .
Once the synchrony ρij(n) from the time series from the algorithm in Section 4.1 is
computed, then for convenience, we proceed to deduce the intermediate quantity Vij(n) :=
φ(Wij(n)) from which the actual weight Wij(n) can be readily obtained (see (11)).
We hypothesise Vij(n) to be an increasing parametric function of ρij(n) and is in the form
Vij(n) =
eαi(n)·ρij (n),
1
d
(9)
where the parameter αi(n) can be solved as explained below. Substituting Vij(n) = 1
d eαi(n)·ρij (n)
in Eq. (8), we have the following straightforward deduction to get an expression for αi(n):
(cid:88)
j(cid:54)=i
log
(cid:19)(cid:19)
(cid:18) d + xj(n)
(cid:18)(cid:0)eαi(n)·ρij (n)(cid:1) ·
(cid:88)
αi(n) · ρij(n) = ri(n) −(cid:88)
ri(n) −(cid:80)
(cid:80)
= ri(n),
αi(n) =
j(cid:54)=i
j(cid:54)=i
d
(cid:19)
,
(cid:18)d + xj(n)
(cid:17)
(cid:16) d+xj (n)
d
log
j(cid:54)=i log
j(cid:54)=i ρij(n)
d
.
(10)
Once Vij(n) is found, the weight Wij(n) can be easily found since φ is invertible. From
17
(4), we get
Wij(n) = elog2(d·Vij (n)) − 1.
(11)
4.1 Algorithm to find the synchrony ρij(n)
The algorithm is described in the following ordered steps (S1) to (S12).
(S1). Normalize or scale the time-series data {x(n)}, by dividing each component in each
(xj(n)) so that upon normalisation the time-series satisfies: (i) every
channel by max
j,n
value of the time series in each channel lies between [−1, 1] (ii) the maximum of absolute
value of the normalised time-series {x(n)} (retaining the same notation as the original
time-series) is 1, i.e., max
j,n
(xj(n)) = 1.
(S2). Fix the parameters a, b and d of the network, and a large positive integer τ .
It
is suggestive that the parameters a and b are chosen to satisfy 0.001 ≤ a ≤ 0.01,
1/3 ≤ b < 1 and 5000 ≤ τ ≤ 10000. Once these values are fixed, (by Theorem 3.3.1)
the value of the parameter d determines the state-forgetting property of the evolving
network. The state-forgetting property can be cross-verified after simulations (see
Figure 3); the minimum value of d required increases with the number of nodes in the
network. For instance, in our simulation results in Section 5, with N = 48, the value of
d = 500 is found to be sufficient for the network to satisfy the state-forgetting property
when a = 0.01, b = 0.9 and τ = 5000.
(S3). For all time n < τ , initialise the cumulative average power in each of the jth channel
to be ¯¯Pj(n) = 0.
(S4). At time n = τ , initialize, the leaky integrator state Qij(n) a random number (0, 1) for
all i = 1, . . . , N .
(S5). Set a counter to an initial state, count = 0 (to aid a calculation in (S9)).
(S6). Obtain the average power in every channel j of the time series at the time instant n
18
using the data in the window [xj(n − τ ), . . . , xj(n)] as Pj(n) :=
τ + 1
(Note: Clearly, since the data is normalized in (S1), max(Pj(n)) = 1)
1
τ(cid:88)
k=0
xj(n − k)2.
(S7). Define the directed synchrony ρij(n) := Qij(n) · (1 − Pi(n) − Pj(n)) for all i, j run-
ning from 1, . . . , N with i (cid:54)= j.
(S8). Find the fraction of the power in each channel j, using ¯Pj(n) :=
(cid:80)N
Pj(n)
k=1 Pk(n)
.
(S9). For each j, compute the cumulative average ¯¯Pj(n) of the fractional power from ¯¯Pj(n−1)
and ¯Pj(n) using ¯¯Pj(n) :=
count · ¯¯Pj(n − 1) + ¯Pj(n)
.
(count + 1)
(S10). Denote t := Qij(n) + ¯¯Pj(n), the quantity that is to be fed into the leaky integrator to
obtain its next state.
(S11). The tanh function when shifted up and to the right is a positive increasing map on R
with a large slope in a very short interval; we use such a function to update the leaky
integrator state according to Qij(n + 1) :=
1
2
tanh
+ 1
.
4t − 8
5
(cid:18)
(cid:18)
(cid:19)
(cid:19)
(S12). If ρij(n + 1) needs to be computed, set n = n + 1; count = count + 1, and return to
(S6). (cid:4)
We recapitulate from Section 2, that only a state-forgetting network can attract all other
iterates towards a unique entire solution. As a numerical verification of this, in Section 5 we
show the ability of the evolving network model to generate a time series from an arbitrary
initial condition that begins to resemble the original one in a very few time steps.
5 Network Inference & Potential Utility
We infer cortical connectivity from a 58 year old male patient diagnosed at Mayo Clinic. The
patient had intractable focal seizures (seizures that fail to come under control due to treat-
ment) with secondary generalization (seizures that start in one area and then spread to both
sides of the brain). The patient underwent surgical treatment and pre-surgical evaluations
19
were performed using a combination of history, physical exam, neuroimaging, and electro-
graphic recordings. For delineating the epileptogenic tissues, electrocorticography (ECoG)
recording was performed at a sampling frequency of 500 Hz for four days continuously with
grid, strip, and depth electrodes implanted intracranially on the frontal, temporal and inter-
hemispheric cortical regions. A total of nine seizures were captured during the recording
period and complete seizure freedom was achieved (ILAE class I) following the resection of
pathological tissues in the left medial frontal lobe and medial temporal structures. All record-
ings were performed conforming to the ethical guidelines and under the protocols monitored
by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) according to National Institutes of Health (NIH)
guidelines. The clinical data and ECoG recordings for this patient are publicly available on
the IEEG portal (https://www.ieeg.org) with dataset ID 'Study 038'.
In our analysis, we consider only the electrodes in the (8 × 6) grid placed on the frontal
lobe where both the seizure onset and its spread were captured. The electrodes which
circumscribed the epileptogenic tissues are shaded in black on the schematic shown in Fig.
3(a). A small segment of ECoG recording is sufficient to demonstrate the efficacy of our
modelling framework. Therefore, we select an ECoG segment comprising of both pre-ictal
and ictal activities to explore how the network evolves during seizures. We remove the noise
artefacts and the power-line interference from the raw ECoG signals by applying a bandpass
filter between 1 − 70Hz and a notch filter at 60Hz. The ECoG signals from a few exemplary
electrodes (labeled with a prefix LG) are shown in Fig. 3(b).
Next, we infer an evolving network synthesized from the ECoG data. We consider the
cortical area under each ECoG electrode as a network node and apply algorithm detailed in
Section 4.1 to get the directed and weighted edges or interconnections between the nodes
so that (6) is satisfied. In particular with parameters a = 1, b = 0.9, d = 500, τ = 5000
we apply the algorithm to obtain the weights of the interconnections between the nodes at
each time sample of the data. To cross validate that the weights obtained eventually render
a state-forgetting evolving network, we adopt the following procedure. With an arbitrary
initial condition x(n0) and the obtained weights at time n0, we use (6) to obtain x(n0 + 1).
20
Repeating this, we obtain x(n0 + 2), x(n0 + 3) and so on. The time-series in a few channels
obtained from this procedure is shown in Fig. 3(d). Apparently, the time-series in Fig. 3(b)
and Fig. 3(d) are similar. Actually, the similarity is true barring a few hundred samples
at the beginning (see Fig. 3(c)). This convergence of the model output from an arbitrary
initial condition to the given time-series verifies state-forgetting property and validates our
modelling framework for the study of network evolution during seizure onset and seizures.
As a passing remark to the reader, the model's ability to sharply reconstruct the given
data as indicated in Fig. 3(c) (plots of the first 2000 samples of an ECoG channel data,
corresponding model output and their difference) is robust even for a different choice of
parameters in the algorithm. In fact, Theorem 3.3.1 tells us that such a reconstruction is
possible as long as the parameters are in a certain range.
With an objective of identifying the nodes crucial for the seizure genesis, we study the
network properties before and after the seizure onset. Consequently, we divide the ECoG
recordings into two segments: pre-ictal (before seizure onset) and ictal (after seizure onset).
For each segment of this data, we compute an ensemble average of node strengths as
(cid:16)
(cid:17)
explained next. It may be recalled from Section 3 that the drive from node j to i at time
n is given by uij(n) := − log
. For each node i, we compute its
uij(n),
mean incoming drive strength of node over a time period T as
where N is the number of nodes, and T is the number of sample points in T . In a similar
φ(Wij(n)) · (d + xj(n))
(cid:88)
N(cid:88)
N − 1
1
T
1
n∈T
j=1,j(cid:54)=i
(cid:88)
N(cid:88)
vein, we compute the mean outgoing drive strength of node i over a time period T as
1
T
n∈T
Figure 4 shows the mean incoming and outgoing node strengths for each node during the
uji(n).
N − 1
j=1,j(cid:54)=i
1
pre-ictal and ictal periods. Fig. 4 (a) indicates a strong correlation of the mean incoming
node strengths with the clinical seizure onset zone or seizure focus (depicted by the electrodes
shaded in black) during the pre-ictal period, while Fig. 4 (b) indicates a more uniform spread
of mean incoming node strengths across all nodes during the ictal period. The correlation of
the mean incoming node strengths with the clinical seizure onset zone during the pre-ictal
21
Figure 3: Model simulations and sharp reconstruction of ECoG recordings (a)
shows the placement of electrodes in (8 × 6) grid on the brain schematic of a patient --
electrodes within clinical onset zone are shaded in black; (b) shows the time series of ECoG
recordings from a few exemplary electrodes (channels) labeled with a prefix LG; (d) shows
the model generated time-series with an arbitrary initial condition in those channels shown
in (b); (c) zooms on one of the channels in (d) and over the first 2000 samples to indicate
the convergence of the model output to the ECoG recording from the model.
period can be understood as that the external drives from other nodes play a supportive role
in initiating seizures (a hypothesis of our model as well). Since during the ictal period all
channels seem to have similar average power due to seizures, all nodes are likely to receive a
similar quantum of external drive. Hence, the mean incoming drive strength appears to be
uniform.
22
814148a) Seizure Focus01020304050Time (s)LG46LG43LG40LG37LG34LG31LG28LG25LG22LG19LG16LG13LG10LG7LG4LG1Seizure Onsetb) Clinical ECoG Recordingsc) Sharp Reconstructiond) Model Output01020304050Time (s)LG46LG43LG40LG37LG34LG31LG28LG25LG22LG19LG16LG13LG10LG7LG4LG1-0.200.2-0.200.2Model OutputClinical Recording -0.200.2(clinical -- model) In contrast, Fig. 4 (c, d) shows that the distinctively higher mean outgoing node strength
(during both ictal and pre-ictal period) is much strongly "correlated" with the clinical seizure
onset zone than that shown by the corresponding mean incoming node strengths. Therefore,
from Fig. 4 (c, d), it is evident that the nodes whose node strengths are shown as columns
in red (i.e., nodes 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 18, 19, 20, 27, 28, 29, 35) are the outgoing hubs. We refer to
this set of nodes as the theoretical seizure onset zone.
Incidentally in this experiment there are 12 nodes in the theoretical seizure onset zone,
similar in cardinality to the set of the nodes at the site of clinical resection ( i.e., nodes
(9, 10, 11, 12, 17, 18, 19, 20, 25, 26, 27, 28)). We refer to the nodes at the site of clinical resec-
tion as the clinical seizure onset zone. It is evident that the theoretical seizure onset zone
and the clinical seizure onset zone point to very similar regions in the brain. Thus, the model
has the potential utility of identifying an approximate seizure focus zone prior to surgery by
analysing some pre-ictal and ictal data.
Although the theoretical and clinical onset zones differ slightly, from a theoretical stand-
point of view, we can hypothesise the outcome of the surgical removal of these two zones
and compare these outcomes if we have a suitable objective measure. To explain this, let R
be the indices of the subset of the nodes that are omitted from a network of N nodes in a
simulation experiment, i.e, the nodes in R are made non-functional by setting Wij(n) = 0
for all n if either i or j belongs to R. Using such modified weight matrices in (6) we can
obtain a time-series {y(n)} of the depleted network can be calculated by starting with any
initial condition that satisfies yi(n0) = 0 whenever i ∈ R. In other words, the signal has
to have zero amplitude in all the channels corresponding to the nodes in R since they are
assumed to not participate in the network dynamics.
We quantify the efficacy of the removal of the nodes that belong to R by calculating the
ratio of the average power in those channels outside R prior to removal of nodes and after
it by:
Poriginal =
1
T
where T denotes the number of samples over a time-interval T and R denotes the cardi-
(cid:33)
(cid:88)
j∈R
1
N − R
(xj(n))2
,
(cid:32)
(cid:88)
n∈T
23
nality of the set R. Similarly the average power in the signal generated from the depleted
network can be calculated by Pdepleted =
1
T
1
N − R
(yj(n))2
, and we calcu-
(cid:32)
(cid:88)
n∈T
(cid:33)
(cid:88)
j∈R
late the efficacy of removing the nodes R by the ratio G(R) = Poriginal/Pdepleted.
We tabulate the values of G(R) below, where R is determined by the following choices:
(i) the clinical seizure onset zone (ii) theoretical seizure onset zone (outgoing hubs) (iii) an
arbitrary set of 12 nodes (iv) 12 nodes randomly drawn (average of G(R) is tabulated in this
case). Now, we discuss the potential application of the model in a clinical study when surgery
is part of the treatment. The aim of a clinical surgery would be to a minimise the removal
of tissue from the brain along with subsiding seizures post surgery. In our study above, the
removal of a set of nodes R from the evolving network is intended to simulate a surgical
removal of the tissue beneath the nodes in R. A time series {y(n)} from the depleted network
is intended to simulate the resultant clinical ECoG time series observed after surgery, and
the quantity G(R) is meant to measure the efficacy of the surgery. Thus prior to an actual
surgery, the theoretical efficacy of surgical removal of nodes can be studied by using the
corresponding depleted network. From the tabulated values of G(R), we observe that the
removal of nodes from the outgoing hubs that form the theoretical onset zone maximises the
efficacy of a surgery when (the tissue beneath) a set with 12 nodes is assumed to be removed
in each simulation. In fact the large value of G(R) obtained after the removal of the nodes
in the theoretical onset zone translates to complete subsiding of seizures in the resultant
time-series (not shown here) generated from the depleted network. When a small subset of
the outgoing hubs were retained in the network, G(R) was still observed to be smaller and
the seizures continued to persist from the resultant time-series (not shown here) generated
from the depleted networks. From this ability of outgoing hubs to subside seizures in the
rest of the network upon their omission, we also refer the outgoing hubs to as spreaders. For
a reader interested in finding an optimal set of nodes for subsiding seizures, we note that
one does not have to necessarily aim to get a very large value of G(R), but any G(R) that
yields a seizure free time-series is adequate.
24
Onset zone
R =
Clinical
(9, 10, 11, 12, 17, 18, 19, 20, 25, 26, 27, 28)
Theoretical
(9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 18, 19, 20, 27, 28, 29, 35)
Random
(6, 7, 11, 13, 24, 25, 34, 38, 40, 43, 45, 48)
20 sets of Random each trial (not listed here) has 12 nodes
G(R)
7.20
27.24
1.51
1.69
We remark that in our simulations, the mean incoming (outgoing) node strengths and
the mean incoming (outgoing) weights of a node exhibit similar variation across nodes, but
we employ the former as it accounts for more accurate interaction between two nodes since
it subsumes both the effect of the weight of the interconnection and the signal strength of
the node that connects.
5.1 Practical issues and modifications
The parameter τ determines the length of the windows in which average powers are compared
(in the algorithm in Section 4.1) while computing the synchrony measure. Since the power
during the inter-ictal period (period between two distinct seizures) is negligible in all channels
and seizures are relatively short epochs, if τ is made extremely large then the synchrony
measures would not show distinct variation across nodes, and we could end up with no
useful network information as the weights lose physical significance. It is required to set τ in
a range so that some noticeable pre-ictal activity or larger power in the data that typically
occurs (e.g.,[16]) just prior to seizures is captured in the synchrony measure. In this paper,
we set τ = 5000 so that with a sampling rate of 500 Hz we use about 10 seconds of data
for such a power comparison. However, it turns out that the mean node strengths show
similar variation even if τ is increased in a range of up to 15000, but a large τ increases
computational complexity.
In conventional machine learning problems, complicated models are avoided fearing an
over-fitted model. An over-fitted network model is usually a static network with a very large
number of nodes and it tends to model the random noise or anomalies in the data rather
25
than the underlying relationship. We evaluate the sensitivity of the weight computation
algorithm or the model by analysing the change in computed weights with additive artefact
noise to the data; we use weights rather than node strengths since we are analysing the
model sensitivity and not evaluating a seizure focus. By adding realizations of zero mean
iid noise having uniform distribution to the above analysed patient's clinical ECoG data
(taking values in [−1, 1]), we plot in Fig. 5(a) and Fig. 5(b) the normalised average incoming
and outgoing connections for different noise variances -- the average weights are normalised
to have a maximum average value of 1 for the purpose of comparison across different noise
variances. The pattern in the variation of the average weights has many similar features
even when the noise variance is high (fourth panel in Fig. 5(a) and Fig. 5(b)). With such
a high variance of noise, we observe from Fig. 5(b) that all the nodes in the theoretically
determined focus are still outgoing hubs. Similar robustness of the pattern in normalised
weights were observed when the data was quantised or when the parameters (a, b and d) in
our algorithm were varied.
Lastly, we remark that the model is flexible to changes and can be modified to work as
long as the state-forgetting property is satisfied. In particular, the dynamical system at each
node in (2) and inferring causality in the Algorithm in 4.1 can be made more sophisticated
or changed to be based on a deeper or alternate physiological understanding of how epileptic
seizures are generated.
6 Conclusions
In this paper, we have presented a modeling approach to transform data into an evolving
network that has the state forgetting property or robustness to initial conditions. Although,
this principle of transformation can be applied to data originating from any source, the
particular evolving network model concerned an epileptic network. Although time-series
can be modeled with reasonable accuracy by static networks of very large dimension such as
recurrent neural networks, the individual nodes in such case have no physical significance and
26
they do not correspond to the regions in the brain. The interconnection-strengths between
the nodes were solved via a causal relationship inferred from the sustained power similarity
between two nodes.
Since the model can produce a sharp reconstruction of the time-series, there is flexibility
to study the interconnections in the evolving network in conjunction with the value of the
time series at any time point, or over a time-interval. We have observed from modeling
clinical data of an epileptic patient that certain nodes turn into outgoing hubs during the
pre-ictal period and persist through the ictal period. These outgoing hubs also have a
location in the brain similar to that of the clinically identified seizure onset zone (seizure
focus). This hints that the (pathological) seizure causing areas in the brain could be having
strong outgoing connections during seizure onset and during seizures.
Further, to quantify the influence of such outgoing hubs on the network dynamics, we have
presented a result quantifying the theoretical efficacy of removal of such nodes in subsiding
seizures. Of course, the result is based on data of a single patient, but then a comprehen-
sive study of the effect of a removal of any node in an evolving network has to be backed
up with a justification -- since altering even a single interconnection could alter the entire
network dynamics, a reliable model should show small changes in the network dynamics for
small changes in the weights.
In a sequel paper, we present a mathematical justification
for inferring network information from a depleted network where we establish that changing
the interconnections results in a continuous change in the time series whenever the evolving
network is state-forgetting. Such a result is needed to justify a more detailed study of the
theoretical efficacy of removal of nodes. In fact, it is possible to prove a very strong result
showing that the effect of the removal of a node can be studied reliably if and only if a
'nontrivial' evolving network has state-forgetting property.
27
Acknowledgments
The author would like to thank Nishant Sinha at Nanyang Technological University for as-
sistance in presenting plots in Section 5 and some discussions there in. The author thanks
the team of the IEEG portal (https://www.ieeg.org) for providing access to the ECoG data.
Access to the image(s) and/or data was supported by Award number U24NS06930 from the
U.S. National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke. The content of this publica-
tion/presentation is solely the responsibility of the author, and does not necessarily represent
the official views of the U.S. National Institute for Neurological Disorders and Stroke or the
U.S. National Institutes of Health. The author thanks an anonymous referee for pointing
out several typographical errors.
References
References
[1] Benjamin, O., Fitzgerald, T., Ashwin, P., Tsaneva-Atanasova, K., Chowdhury, F.,
Richardson, M. P., and Terry, J. R. (2012). A phenomenological model of seizure ini-
tiation suggests network structure may explain seizure frequency in idiopathic generalised
epilepsy. J Math Neurosci, 2(1):1.
[2] Bertram, E. H., Mangan, P., Fountain, N., Rempe, D., et al. (1998). Functional anatomy
of limbic epilepsy: a proposal for central synchronization of a diffusely hyperexcitable
network. Epilepsy research, 32(1):194 -- 205.
[3] Bonilha, L., Nesland, T., Martz, G. U., Joseph, J. E., Spampinato, M. V., Edwards,
J. C., and Tabesh, A. (2012). Medial temporal lobe epilepsy is associated with neuronal
fibre loss and paradoxical increase in structural connectivity of limbic structures. Journal
of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, pages jnnp -- 2012.
28
[4] Bragin, A., Wilson, C., and Engel, J. (2000). Chronic epileptogenesis requires develop-
ment of a network of pathologically interconnected neuron clusters: a hypothesis. Epilep-
sia, 41(s6):S144 -- S152.
[5] Breakspear, M., Roberts, J., Terry, J. R., Rodrigues, S., Mahant, N., and Robinson, P.
(2006). A unifying explanation of primary generalized seizures through nonlinear brain
modeling and bifurcation analysis. Cerebral Cortex, 16(9):1296 -- 1313.
[6] Devaney, R. L. (1989). An introduction to chaotic dynamical systems. Addison-Wesley.
[7] Diessen, E., Diederen, S. J., Braun, K. P., Jansen, F. E., and Stam, C. J. (2013). Func-
tional and structural brain networks in epilepsy: what have we learned?
Epilepsia,
54(11):1855 -- 1865.
[8] Elaydi, S. (2005). An introduction to difference equations. Springer Science & Business
Media.
[9] FitzHugh, R. (1969). Mathematical models of excitation and propagation in nerve. In
Biological engineering, pages 1 -- 85. McGraw-Hill, New York.
[10] Furi, M. and Martelli, M. (1991). On the mean value theorem, inequality, and inclusion.
American Mathematical Monthly, pages 840 -- 846.
[11] Hutchings, F., Han, C. E., Keller, S. S., Weber, B., Taylor, P. N., and Kaiser, M. (2015).
Predicting surgery targets in temporal lobe epilepsy through structural connectome based
simulations. PLoS Comput Biol, 11(12):e1004642.
[12] Jaeger, H. (2001). The echo state approach to analysing and training recurrent neural
networks-with an erratum note. Bonn, Germany: German National Research Center for
Information Technology GMD Technical Report, 148:34.
[13] Jansen, B. H. and Rit, V. G. (1995). Electroencephalogram and visual evoked potential
generation in a mathematical model of coupled cortical columns. Biological cybernetics,
73(4):357 -- 366.
29
[14] Jirsa, V. K., Stacey, W. C., Quilichini, P. P., Ivanov, A. I., and Bernard, C. (2014). On
the nature of seizure dynamics. Brain, 137(8):2210 -- 2230.
[15] Kalitzin, S. N., Velis, D. N., and da Silva, F. H. L. (2010). Stimulation-based anticipation
and control of state transitions in the epileptic brain. Epilepsy & Behavior, 17(3):310 -- 323.
[16] Khosravani, H., Mehrotra, N., Rigby, M., Hader, W. J., Pinnegar, C. R., Pillay, N.,
Wiebe, S., and Federico, P. (2009). Spatial localization and time-dependant changes of
electrographic high frequency oscillations in human temporal lobe epilepsy. Epilepsia,
50(4):605 -- 616.
[17] Kloeden, P., Potzsche, C., and Rasmussen, M. (2013). Discrete-time nonautonomous
dynamical systems.
In Stability and bifurcation theory for non-autonomous differential
equations, pages 35 -- 102. Springer.
[18] Kloeden, P. E. and Rasmussen, M. (2011). Nonautonomous dynamical systems. Number
176. American Mathematical Soc., Providence.
[19] Kramer, M. A. and Cash, S. S. (2012). Epilepsy as a disorder of cortical network
organization. The Neuroscientist, 18(4):360 -- 372.
[20] Lemieux, L., Daunizeau, J., and Walker, M. C. (2011). Concepts of connectivity and
human epileptic activity. Frontiers in systems neuroscience, 5:1 -- 13.
[21] Maass, W., Natschlager, T., and Markram, H. (2002). Real-time computing without
stable states: A new framework for neural computation based on perturbations. Neural
computation, 14(11):2531 -- 2560.
[22] Manjunath, G. and Jaeger, H. (2013). Echo state property linked to an input: Exploring
a fundamental characteristic of recurrent neural networks. Neural computation, 25(3):671 --
696.
[23] Manjunath, G. and Jaeger, H. (2014). The dynamics of random difference equations is
remodeled by closed relations. SIAM Journal on Mathematical Analysis, 46(1):459 -- 483.
30
[24] Marten, F., Rodrigues, S., Suffczynski, P., Richardson, M. P., and Terry, J. R. (2009).
Derivation and analysis of an ordinary differential equation mean-field model for studying
clinically recorded epilepsy dynamics. Physical Review E, 79(2):021911.
[25] Morgan, R. J. and Soltesz, I. (2008). Nonrandom connectivity of the epileptic dentate
gyrus predicts a major role for neuronal hubs in seizures. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences, 105(16):6179 -- 6184.
[26] Ngugi, A. K., Bottomley, C., Kleinschmidt, I., Sander, J. W., and Newton, C. R.
(2010). Estimation of the burden of active and life-time epilepsy: a meta-analytic ap-
proach. Epilepsia, 51(5):883 -- 890.
[27] Richardson, M. P. (2012). Large scale brain models of epilepsy: dynamics meets con-
nectomics. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, 83(12):1238 -- 1248.
[28] Robinson, P., Rennie, C., and Rowe, D. (2002). Dynamics of large-scale brain activity
in normal arousal states and epileptic seizures. Physical Review E, 65(4):041924.
[29] Rocsoreanu, C., Georgescu, A., and Giurgiteanu, N. (2012). The FitzHugh-Nagumo
model: bifurcation and dynamics, volume 10. Springer Science & Business Media.
[30] Schmidt, H., Petkov, G., Richardson, M. P., and Terry, J. R. (2014). Dynamics on
networks: the role of local dynamics and global networks on the emergence of hypersyn-
chronous neural activity. PLoS Comput Biol, 10(11):e1003947.
[31] Silva, F. H., Blanes, W., Kalitzin, S. N., Parra, J., Suffczynski, P., and Velis, D. N.
(2003). Dynamical diseases of brain systems: different routes to epileptic seizures. Biomed-
ical Engineering, IEEE Transactions on, 50(5):540 -- 548.
[32] Spencer, S. S. (2002). Neural networks in human epilepsy: evidence of and implications
for treatment. Epilepsia, 43(3):219 -- 227.
31
[33] Steil, J. J. (2004). Backpropagation-decorrelation: online recurrent learning with o
(n) complexity. In Neural Networks, 2004. Proceedings. 2004 IEEE International Joint
Conference on, volume 2, pages 843 -- 848. IEEE.
[34] Suffczynski, P., Kalitzin, S., and Da Silva, F. L. (2004). Dynamics of non-convulsive
epileptic phenomena modeled by a bistable neuronal network. Neuroscience, 126(2):467 --
484.
[35] Taylor, P. N., Goodfellow, M., Wang, Y., and Baier, G. (2013). Towards a large-scale
model of patient-specific epileptic spike-wave discharges. Biological cybernetics, 107(1):83 --
94.
[36] Terry, J. R., Benjamin, O., and Richardson, M. P. (2012). Seizure generation: the role
of nodes and networks. Epilepsia, 53(9):e166 -- e169.
[37] Wendling, F., Bartolomei, F., Bellanger, J., and Chauvel, P. (2002). Epileptic fast
activity can be explained by a model of impaired gabaergic dendritic inhibition. European
Journal of Neuroscience, 15(9):1499 -- 1508.
[38] Wendling, F., Hernandez, A., Bellanger, J.-J., Chauvel, P., and Bartolomei, F. (2005).
Interictal to ictal transition in human temporal lobe epilepsy: insights from a computa-
tional model of intracerebral eeg. Journal of Clinical Neurophysiology, 22(5):343.
A Appendix: Autonomous vs. Nonautonomous Dy-
namics
When interconnections change with time in a network of dynamical systems, the overall
dynamics of the entire network is nonautonomous -- autonomous dynamics is rendered when
systems evolve according to a rule fixed for all time, and when it is not fixed (here, due
to the time-varying interconnections), nonautonomous dynamics emerges (see Section 2 for
definitions). The evolution of an autonomous system depends on only the initial condition
32
presented to it, whereas in a nonautonomous system the evolution depends both on the
initial condition and the time at which it is presented. The evolution of an autonomous
system in discrete-time can be described by an update equation xn+1 = f (xn), where f is
a function governing the rule for evolution. The evolution of a nonautonomous system can
be described by an update equation xn+1 = fn(xn), where a family of maps {fn} govern the
rule of evolution.
We explain the advantage of considering a nonautonomous model. Consider a two-
dimensional autonomous dynamical system which updates its dynamics according to the
rule (xn+1, yn+1) = (f (xn, yn), g(xn, yn)) (f and g are any functions whose domain and range
are R2 and R) to generate a 2-dimensional time series {(xn, yn)}. Suppose in reality, only the
first coordinate or dimension of the time series, i.e, {xn} is observable. Then, in general it is
not possible to model the time-series {xn} as the dynamics of a one-dimensional dynamical
system, in other words it is not possible to find a function (map) h so that xn+1 = h(xn)
holds for all n since xn+1 inherently depends on yn. However, it is possible to find a nonau-
tonomous system, i.e., a family of maps {hn} so that xn+1 = hn(xn). In general, whenever
we are unable to completely observe all the variables from a dynamical system (including
nonautonomous systems) it is possible to synthesise a nonautonomous system that models
the observed variables. In real world systems, the non-autonomous system can account for
obfuscated factors such as the unfeasibility of observing all variables, exogenous influence
etc. by subsuming their net-effect by a collection or family of maps that vary with time.
B Appendix: Formal Definition of State Forgetting
Property
Mathematically, viewing an evolving network as a static network being acted upon by an
exogenous stimulus that influences the network connections at each time step gives us the
advantage of employing the formal framework of the echo-state static networks theory in
machine learning [12, 22]. We recall some notions [12, 22] and adapt to our setup. We begin
33
now with a formal description.
Here, and throughout, only the Euclidean distance is employed as a metric/distance on
any two elements of Rd. Also I represents a nondegenerate compact interval of R, and I N
denotes the N -times product (I × ··· × I).
Following [22, 23] and several others (e.g., [8, 17, 18]), we define a discrete-time nonau-
tonomous system on a metric space X as a sequence of maps {gn}, where each gn : X → X
is a continuous map. Any sequence {xn} ⊂ X that satisfies xn+1 = gn(xn) for all n ∈ Z is
called an entire-solution of {gn}. For the discussion in this paper it is sufficient to consider
an evolving network with each of the nodes having a one-dimensional dynamical system on
an interval I, i.e., for an isolated node, there is some function mapping I to I as it is an
autonomous system. We formally define an evolving network below:
Definition B.1 Let I be a compact interval of R, and let N ≥ 1 be an integer. Suppose a
function G has a real-valued N × N matrix W (n), and a value in I N as its arguments and
maps it to a value in I N for each n ∈ Z, i.e., G : RN×N × I N → I N is such that
(i) G is continuous and
(ii) G is defined by a set of N (continuous) coordinate maps hi : I N × RN → I such that
hi : (xi(n), W¯i(n)) (cid:55)→ xi(n + 1), where W¯i(n) ∈ RN represents the ith row of a matrix
W (n), and xi(n) the ith component of x(n + 1); here hi generates the node dynamics
at the ith node,
then such a map G is called a family of evolving network.
If in particular, a bi-infinite
sequence of matrices {W (n)} ⊂ RN×N is fixed, then the sequence of mappings gW (n)(·) :=
G(W (n),·) is referred to as an evolving network.
Clearly, any evolving network gW (n)(·) := G(W (n),·) is also a nonautonomous system {gn}
on I N if we set gn := gW (n) for all n. We call W (n) the connectivity weight matrix or just
the weight matrix.
We next define the state-forgetting property of a family of evolving networks and also for
a particular evolving network.
34
Definition B.2 Let G : RN×N×I N → I N be a family of evolving networks. If for each choice
of {W (n)}, the evolving network gW (n)(·) := G(W (n),·) has exactly one entire-solution, then
the family of evolving networks G is said to be state-forgetting. In particular, for any fixed
{W (n)}, the corresponding evolving network (or the nonautonomous system) {g(W (n),·)}
is said to be state-forgetting if it has exactly one entire-solution.
C Appendix: Proof of State Forgetting Property
We first recall some preliminaries and known results that help us in presenting the proof of
Theorem 3.3.1.
It is convenient to have the following alternate representation of a nonautonomous system.
Let Z2≥ the collection of all integer tuples (n, m) so that n ≥ m, i.e., Z2≥ := {(n, m) : n, m ∈
Z & n ≥ m}. Given a nonautonomous system {gn} on X, it is convenient (see [22]) to
denote the nonautonomous system through a function φ : Z2≥ × X → X called a process
on X that satisfies: φ(m, m, x) := x and φ(n, m, x) := gn−1 ◦ ··· ◦ gm(x). We say φ has the
state-forgetting property if {gn} has the state-forgetting property.
The following Lemma is reproduced from [22, Lemma 2.2].
Lemma C.1 Let ϕ be a process on a compact metric space X metrized by dX. Suppose
that, for all n ∈ Z, there exists a sequence of positive reals {δj}∞
j=1 converging to 0 such that
dX(ϕ(n, n− j, x), ϕ(n, n− j, y)) ≤ δj dX(x, y) for all x, y ∈ X and for all j ∈ N. Then φ has
the state-forgetting property, i.e., there is exactly one entire solution of the process ϕ.
The essence of the following result is that if φ has the state-forgetting property then all
initial conditions converge to the unique entire-solution in Proposition C.1. For a detailed
explanation see [23] and references therein.
Proposition C.1 Let ϕ be a process on a compact metric space X metrized by dX. Suppose
{ϑn} is the unique entire-solution of ϕ, then limj→∞ dX(ϕ(n, n − j, x), ϕ(n, n − j, ϑn)) = 0
for all x and n.
35
We repeatedly use the following standard inequalities involving the infinity norm and
N(cid:107)x(cid:107)∞ for all x ∈ RN ; when A ∈ RN×N ,
spectral norm: (cid:107)x(cid:107)∞ ≤ (cid:107)x(cid:107)2 and (cid:107)x(cid:107)2 ≤ √
(cid:107)A(cid:107)2 ≤ √
N(cid:107)A(cid:107)∞.
A generalization of the mean-value theorem in one-dimensional calculus to higher dimen-
sions results in the following mean-value inequality (e.g., [10]). This result can be stated as:
if ϕ : V → Rn is a C 1-function where V is an open subset of Rn then for any x, y ∈ V
(cid:107)ϕ(x) − ϕ(y)(cid:107)2 ≤ sup{(cid:107)ϕ
(cid:48)
(z)(cid:107)2 : z ∈ V } · (cid:107)x − y(cid:107)2,
(C-12)
(z)x(cid:107)2 : (cid:107)x(cid:107)2 = 1) is the induced norm
where (cid:107) · (cid:107)2 is the L2-norm, and (cid:107)ϕ
of the Jacobian of ϕ(·) at the point z.
(cid:48)
(z)(cid:107)2 := sup((cid:107)ϕ
(cid:48)
To simplify the notations in the proof of Theorem 3.3.1, whenever y = (y1, . . . , yN ), we
adopt the notation log(y) := (log(y1), log(y2), . . . , log(yN ))T and
σ(y) := (σ(y1), σ(y2), . . . , σ(yN ))T, where log(y) and σ(y) are column vectors and the super-
script (·)T represents the transpose of the vector (·).
Proof of Theorem 3.3.1. Fix a {W (n)} ⊂ RN×N that satisfies (6) for all 1 ≤ i ≤ N
and n ∈ Z. Let {V (n)} be defined by Vij(n) = φ(Wij(n)), where φ is as in (4). Since fixing a
{W (n)} or a {V (n)} (Vij(n) related to Wij(n) by (4)) amounts to fixing an evolving network,
we have fixed a nonautonomous system.
In the notion of a process, the evolving network update obtained by varying i from 1 to
N in (6) can be represented at time n by
ϕ(n, n − 1, y) = σ
(cid:18)
(cid:19)
Fa,b(y) − Ln−1(y)
,
where y ∈ [−1, 1]N , Fa,b(y1, . . . , yN ) := (fa,b(y1), . . . , fa,b(yN )) and Ln−1(y) :=
log (V (n − 1) · (d + y)), with (d + y) as the column vector (d + y1, . . . , d + yN ). Since the
function σ in (5), ensures (cid:107)σ(y1) − σ(z1)(cid:107) ≤ (cid:107)y1 − z1(cid:107), we have
(C-13)
Since the choice of {W (n)} was made arbitrarily, if we show that ϕ has exactly one-entire
(cid:107)σ(y) − σ(z)(cid:107)∞ ≤ (cid:107)y − z(cid:107)∞ for all y, z ∈ RN .
solution then we would have shown that the evolving network is state-forgetting by Def-
36
inition B.2. Since φ is a process on [−1, 1]N , a compact subset of RN , we make use of
Lemma C.1 to show ϕ has exactly one-entire solution. We employ the metric induced by
the norm (cid:107) · (cid:107)∞ for getting an inequality of the form in Lemma C.1.
Let δ be any real number in (λ, 1). We first aim to show that there exists a D (that
depends on δ) such that for all d > D, the following inequality is satisfied.
(C-14)
(cid:107)ϕ(n, n − 1, y) − ϕ(n, n − 1, z)(cid:107)∞ ≤ δ(cid:107)y − z(cid:107)∞ for all y, z,∈ [−1, 1]N .
For convenience, we let (cid:98)ϕ(n, n− 1, y) := Fa,b(y)− Ln−1(y). Then, clearly ϕ(n, n− 1, y) =
σ ◦(cid:98)ϕ(n, n − 1, y). If (cid:107)(cid:98)ϕ(n, n − 1, y) −(cid:98)ϕ(n, n − 1, z)(cid:107)∞ ≤ δ(cid:107)y − z(cid:107)∞ for all y, z,∈ [−1, 1]N
We next proceed to prove (cid:107)(cid:98)ϕ(n, n − 1, y) −(cid:98)ϕ(n, n − 1, z)(cid:107)∞ ≤ δ(cid:107)y − z(cid:107)∞ for all y, z,∈
[−1, 1]N . Recall that (cid:98)ϕ(n, n − 1, y) = (Fa,b(y) − Ln−1(z)). We first consider the first term
and (C-13) holds, then (C-14) holds.
on the right hand side, i.e., Fa,b(y) and prove an upper bound for (cid:107)Fa,b(y) − Fa,b(z)(cid:107)∞ using
the mean value theorem.
Since fa,b is differentiable and has a continuous derivative, by applying the mean value
theorem on the domain [−1, 1] we infer:
fa,b(yi) − fa,b(zi) ≤ sup
s∈(−1,1)
( f(cid:48)
a,b(s) ) · yi − zi
for all yi, zi ∈ [−1, 1]
(C-15)
by hypotheses, a < λ+b
3 and 0 < b < λ < 1. If s ∈ (−1, 1), it is straightforward to deduce
3 ⇐⇒ 3as2 < λ + b for all s ∈ (−1, 1) ⇐⇒
the following equivalent statements: a < λ+b
−λ + b < 3as2 < λ + b for all s ∈ (−1, 1) (since b < λ) ⇐⇒ −λ < 3as2 − b < λ for all
s ∈ (−1, 1) ⇐⇒ f(cid:48)
a,b(s) < λ for all s ∈ (−1, 1) since the derivative f
a,b(s) = 3as2 − b.
(cid:48)
(cid:48)
Since f
a,b is continuous, f(cid:48)
a,b(s) < λ for all s ∈ (−1, 1) implies f(cid:48)
a,b(s) ≤ λ for all
s ∈ [−1, 1]. Using this in (C-15), it follows that
fa,b(yi) − fa,b(zi) ≤ λ yi − zi
for all yi, zi ∈ [−1, 1].
(C-16)
37
Now,
(cid:107)Fa,b(y) − Fa,b(z)(cid:107)∞
=
max
1≤i≤N
( fa,b(yi) − fa,b(zi) ) ,
(C-16)≤
=
λ yi − zi ,
max
1≤i≤N
λ (cid:107)y − z(cid:107)∞.
(C-17)
Let > 0 be such that δ = λ + . Since Ln−1(y) = log(V (n− 1)· (d + y)), the Jacobian L
(cid:48)
n−1
evaluated at y is a diagonal matrix and the ith diagonal element of this matrix is found to
be
∂
∂yi
(cid:32)(cid:88)
j(cid:54)=i
(cid:33)
(cid:88)
j(cid:54)=i
log(Vij(n − 1)(d + yj))
=
1
(d + yj)
.
(C-18)
The following deductions give an upper bound for (cid:107)Ln−1(y) − Ln−1(z)(cid:107)∞:
(cid:107)Ln−1(y) − Ln−1(z)(cid:107)∞
≤
(C-12)≤
≤
(cid:107)Ln−1(y) − Ln−1(z)(cid:107)2,
sup
s∈int(I N )
√
(cid:107)L
(cid:48)
n−1(s)(cid:107)2(cid:107)y − z(cid:107)2,
√
(cid:107)L
N (cid:107)y − z(cid:107)∞,
N sup
s∈int(I N )
(cid:32)(cid:88)
(cid:48)
n−1(s)(cid:107)∞
(cid:33)
1
(C-18)≤
≤
(cid:107)y − z(cid:107)∞,
N max
1≤i≤N
(cid:107)y − z(cid:107)∞ (for all d sufficiently large).
d + sj
j(cid:54)=i
Using (C-17) and (C-19) together, we get (cid:107)(cid:98)ϕ(n, n− 1, y)−(cid:98)ϕ(n, n− 1, z)(cid:107)∞ ≤ (λ + )(cid:107)y −
(C-19)
z(cid:107)∞ = (cid:107)y − z(cid:107)∞ for all y, z,∈ [−1, 1]N .
Finally, (C-13) and (C-19) yields the desired bound in (C-14). Applying (C-14) itera-
tively, we get for any j ≥ 1, (cid:107)ϕ(n, n − j, y) − ϕ(n, n − j, z)(cid:107)∞ ≤ δj(cid:107)y − z(cid:107)∞. Denoting
δj := δj in the inequality in the statement of Lemma C.1 it follows that there is exactly one
entire-solution for ϕ. This proves the theorem.
38
Figure 4:
Illustration of the variation in the mean incoming and outgoing node strengths
across nodes during the pre-ictal and ictal period (the word 'mean' is omitted in the labels
only for a shortage of space). Nodes shaded in black are from the clinically delineated seizure
focus and are also depicted by asterisks on the corresponding columns in the bar plots. Nodes
whose node strengths are shown as columns in red correspond to the theoretical seizure focus
identified from the model simulations. The color code on the brain schematic at the nodes
is for convenient viewing and indicates the corresponding relative node strength in the bar
plot, but only approximately
39
b)c)d)a)************************************************ (a) Average incoming weights
(b) Average outgoing weights
Figure 5: Nodes Vs. Normalised average incoming/outgoing weights (graph connected by a
line) computed with/without additive uniform iid noise; Without noise in Panel 1; Panel 2,
3, 4 use respectively uniformly distributed noise in [−0.1, 0.1], [−0.25, 0.25] and [−0.5, +0.5].
40
5101520253035404500.515101520253035404500.515101520253035404500.515101520253035404500.515101520253035404500.515101520253035404500.515101520253035404500.515101520253035404500.51 |
1907.03612 | 2 | 1907 | 2019-10-21T14:31:20 | Discovering the Computational Relevance of Brain Network Organization | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Understanding neurocognitive computations will require not just localizing cognitive information distributed throughout the brain but also determining how that information got there. We review recent advances in linking empirical and simulated brain network organization with cognitive information processing. Building on these advances, we offer a new framework for understanding the role of connectivity in cognition - network coding (encoding/decoding) models. These models utilize connectivity to specify the transfer of information via neural activity flow processes, successfully predicting the formation of cognitive representations in empirical neural data. The success of these models supports the possibility that localized neural functions mechanistically emerge (are computed) from distributed activity flow processes that are specified primarily by connectivity patterns. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Discovering the Computational Relevance of Brain Network Organization
Takuya Ito, Luke Hearne, Ravi Mill, Carrisa Cocuzza, Michael W. Cole*
Center for Molecular and Behavioral Neuroscience, Rutgers University, Newark, NJ, 07102,
USA
*Correspondence: [email protected] (M.W. Cole).
Keywords: connectivity; machine learning; representations; neural encoding/decoding;
connectome; neural networks; artificial intelligence
Abstract
Understanding neurocognitive computations will require not just localizing cognitive
information distributed throughout the brain but also determining how that information got
there. We review recent advances in linking empirical and simulated brain network
organization with cognitive information processing. Building on these advances, we offer a
new framework for understanding the role of connectivity in cognition -- network coding
(encoding/decoding) models. These models utilize connectivity to specify the transfer of
information via neural activity flow processes, successfully predicting the formation of
cognitive representations in empirical neural data. The success of these models supports the
possibility that localized neural functions mechanistically emerge (are computed) from
distributed activity flow processes that are specified primarily by connectivity patterns.
Highlights
• Recent results suggest that localized functions in brain areas are specified primarily by
their distributed global connectivity patterns
• Recent approaches go beyond stimulus/task brain mapping (and encoding/decoding) to
characterize the role of brain connectivity in neural information processing
• We introduce network coding models as a framework encompassing neural network
models optimized for task performance and those optimized for biological realism
• Biological and task performance constraints are complementary for aiding the search for
accurate models of empirical brain function
• The activity flow algorithm is a core computational mechanism underlying network
coding models, linking brain activity and connectivity in a biologically-plausible
mechanistic framework
1
Placing Brain Network Organization Within A Computational Framework
A central goal of neuroscience is to understand how neural entities (such as brain
regions) interact to compute cognitive functions. Historically, cognitive neuroscientists have
tried to understand neural systems by mapping cognitive processes to neural entities.
However, a comprehensive functional map of neural entities would still be insufficient to
explain how cognition emerges through the collective interaction among these components.
What could facilitate such mechanistic inferences? To answer this question, cognitive
neuroscientists have begun to incorporate descriptions of brain network architecture (i.e. how
neural entities are connected to each other) with these functional maps. Indeed, recent
theoretical work suggests that mechanistic understanding of a brain system depends on
characterizing the causal relationships between the system's components [1 -- 3]. This is
analogous to how we understand other mechanical systems; for example, understanding how
a car moves upon pressing its accelerator requires knowledge of the causal relationships
between the system's components (e.g., the pedal, the transmission, the engine, and the
wheels). Similarly, mapping brain network connectivity allows
for a mechanistic
understanding by revealing the causal relations among neural components.
Facilitating this effort, recent advances in network neuroscience (see Glossary) are
providing ever more detailed descriptions of brain network architecture [4]. Yet these
descriptions have so far provided only limited insights into the neural computations underlying
cognitive functions. Simultaneously, connectionist artificial neural network research has
revealed the theoretical importance of network connectivity in computing cognitive functions
(Box 1). Yet it remains unclear whether these theoretical insights emerging primarily from
simulations apply to empirical neural computations. Thus, connectionism has provided an
abundance of theoretical insights with limited translation to empirical evidence, while
empirical neuroscience now has an abundance of empirical observations with limited
theoretical insights. We propose that combining connectionist theory with empirical brain
connectivity data will advance understanding of the computational and cognitive relevance of
brain network organization.
We begin by discussing efforts to model neural computations using empirical brain
connectivity. We then draw on conceptual insights from the connectionist literature -- including
from recent research involving "deep" neural network architectures -- to help identify the
computational and cognitive relevance of the distributed neural processes reported in recent
empirical studies. Here we focus on a subset of studies that have successfully linked
2
distributed brain connectivity with neurocognitive computations. This research is framed in a
new data analytic perspective -- network coding models -- that suggests a way toward
unifying empirical brain network analysis with a rich theoretical connectionist foundation.
From Mapping Localized Functions to Building Network Coding Models
Network coding models facilitate understanding of the function of localized neural
entities (such as brain regions) by clarifying how they send and receive information:
connectivity. This also has the advantage of clarifying the role of each brain connection in
computing cognitive functions. In contrast to network coding models, cognitive neuroscience
has primarily mapped tasks and stimuli to activity in neurons and neural populations --
function-structure mappings (Figure 1A) [5]. Some examples of this general strategy
include spike rate changes in single- or multi-unit recordings [6], general linear modeling with
functional MRI (fMRI) [7], and event-related potentials with electroencephalography [8]. This
strategy has been tremendously useful for characterizing the functions of spatially localized
neural populations [9].
3
Figure 1 -- What would it take to understand a neural population's function? A) The standard
approach in neuroscience, identifying associations between cognitive variables and brain responses. This
has led to sophisticated encoding (predicting neural activity from cognitive variables) and decoding
(predicting cognitive variables from neural activity) models. Arrow darkness indicates strength of
association between each cognitive variable and neural activity in Region X. Even with accurate
associations it remains unclear how such selectivity arises in Region X. B) Knowing the set of
connections to and from Region X provides additional mechanistic knowledge, yet it remains unclear what
Region X represents or does in terms of information processing. Arrows indicate direction of causal
inference (effective connectivity), but less detailed connectivity information (e.g., structural or functional
connectivity) can also be useful. Arrow darkness indicates strength of connectivity between regions. C)
We suggest that combining cognitive variables with connectivity in a single "network coding" model can
allow for a more complete mechanistic understanding of a region's function. Connectivity can act as an
encoding model for Region X, predicting its activity based on activity elsewhere in the brain. It can also
act as a decoding model for Region X, predicting how Region X's activity influences other regions and
ultimately behavior.
Encoding and Decoding: Predictive Approaches for Mapping Localized Functions
More recent methods have used a predictive framework to allow for more complex
function-structure mappings. By predicting independent data, these approaches avoid
overestimation of effects from increased model complexity (e.g., overfitting to noise), while
providing more robust function-structure mappings [10,11]. It is commonly underappreciated
how problematic overfitting is in standard data analysis approaches (e.g., general linear
models or event-related potentials) that do not test for generalization in independent data
using cross-validation [10,11]. Among these predictive approaches, an encoding model
uses the task/stimulus condition to predict neural activity [12 -- 14]. In contrast, a decoding
model supports the opposite inference, using activity in a neural population to predict the
task/stimulus condition [12 -- 14]. These predictive models facilitate interpretation of neural
activity in terms of task-related information content, which is an important step towards
understanding the brain as an information processing system [15,16]. Notably, we have
conceptualized network coding models within the framework of encoding and decoding
models, since they inherit many of the benefits of encoding and decoding models while
incorporating connectivity as a mechanistic constraint (as illustrated in Figure 1).
The Role of Connectivity in Functional Localization
Despite the utility of these approaches, a comprehensive function-structure mapping
would not provide insight into how local functionality is specified mechanistically. As an
example of mechanistic understanding, consider work in visual neuroscience suggesting that
receptive field properties in V1 can be explained by connectivity patterns with the lateral
4
geniculate nucleus [17]. More recent work has extended this insight to suggest that localized
functionality in visual cortex might result from intrinsic connectivity architecture [18,19], with
one study indicating that face and word selectivity in visual areas emerge from connectivity
and specific computational processes [20].
Thus, one possibility to gain mechanistic insight is to map relationships between
neural entities -- connectivity mapping -- based on the well-supported hypothesis that
cognitive/behavioral functionality emerges due to neural interactions [21 -- 24] (Figure 1B).
Conceptually, this goal is similar to constructing a causal map among the functional
components of a car (e.g., pedal -> engine -> transmission -> wheels). Various approaches
to estimating connectivity could potentially be useful here, such as resting-state functional
connectivity [25 -- 27], task-state functional connectivity [28 -- 34], or structural connectivity
[35,36]. However, connectivity mapping can only facilitate mechanistic understanding to the
extent that it can provide insight into the causal relations among neural entities [1,3].
Nonetheless, progress can likely be made even with limited causal inferences (e.g.,
structural/anatomical connectivity indicating possible rather than actual causal influence) by
constraining the likelihood of possible causal models [1]. However, similar to the limitations
of function-structure mappings, a complete connectivity map of neural populations (i.e., a
connectome) would still not explain the emergence of any cognitive/behavioral functionality
in a neural population [3,37]. Critically, unlike function-structure mappings, a connectivity
mapping has no reference to cognitive/behavioral functionality. Without grounding in
cognitive/behavioral functionality, a connectivity mapping merely describes potential routes
of signaling among localized neural populations with no reference to the relevant
cognitive/behavioral information content.
Therefore, we propose the importance of combining function-structure mapping and
connectivity mapping to understand how function emerges from network connectivity in the
form of network coding models (Figure 1C). The use of network coding models will facilitate
a shift from purely functional models towards mechanistic models of brain function [15]. In the
following section, we provide theoretical and empirical support for brain network organization
as the basis for cognitive computations, highlighting converging ideas from network
neuroscience and connectionist theory. We review instances of empirical studies that have
bridged this gap, demonstrating how connectionist principles can be evaluated in models
estimated from empirical neural data. We will conclude with a detailed description of network
coding models (foreshadowed in Figure 1C) as a particularly useful approach to
5
characterizing the role of brain connectivity patterns in cognitive computations. Ultimately, we
expect these emerging areas of research to unify the major theoretical perspectives and
methodological approaches in neuroscience: localized functions and information (reflected in
task-evoked neural activity), and network neuroscience.
Brain Network Organization Shapes Cognitive Computations
Connectionist Architectures and Cognitive Computations
Decades of neuroscience have focused on function-structure mapping. Why might
incorporating brain network connectivity (and, by extension, network coding models) address
this strategy's limitations? Evidence from multiple sources suggests connectivity can provide
a mechanistic explanation of how function emerges in neural networks (Box 1). First, decades
of "connectionist" work with artificial neural network models have demonstrated the
plausibility of distributed connectivity-based processes driving various complex cognitive
functions [38 -- 41]. Second, the standard model of neuroscience, as proposed by Ramón y
Cajal [42] and solidified by Hodgkin and Huxley [43] and others [17], provides a prominent
role for connectivity among discrete neural units in determining localized functionality. Third,
there is increasing empirical evidence that the fundamental unit of functionality in the brain is
not single neurons but rather populations of neurons [44 -- 46].
In particular, neural network models have primarily utilized inter-unit connectivity to
define the architecture for cognitive computations [47 -- 49] (Figure 2A). This includes recently
developed deep neural networks that improve model performance by including additional
neural units with structured connectivity as "hidden" layers between input and output
[47,49,50]. Thus, decades of modeling work demonstrates that connectivity architectures can
support dozens (or hundreds) of complex cognitive processes, with more recent deep
learning work indicating that additional performance gains are possible through refinement of
connectivity architecture.
6
Figure 2 -- Activity flow as a linking principle between connectivity and activity. A) Most neural
network simulations use an algorithm to compute activity at each node at each time point. Briefly, each
network node's activity (𝑎) at the next time point is computed as the connectivity-weighted sum across
the activity levels of all other nodes (the propagation rule), which is then passed through a function (𝒇)
(the activation rule) [51]. Figure adapted from [52]. B) Inspired by connectionist principles, the activity flow
mapping algorithm implements basic neural network computations using empirical data, and
accommodates limitations in empirical neural measures (such as limited fMRI spatio-temporal resolution).
C) Simulations of fMRI data demonstrated that accurate activity flow mapping predictions depend on
strong inter-unit connectivity (global coupling) relative to recurrent local connectivity. D) Activity flow-
based predictions of task-evoked activity levels for a reasoning task (and many other tasks) were highly
accurate, suggesting that empirical fMRI-based functional connectivity estimates are likely informative
regarding the specification of localized functionality throughout the brain. Panels B-D adapted with
permission from [53]. E) A modification of activity flow mapping to estimate information transfers,
assessing whether decodable information in a source brain region can be preserved in a downstream
target brain region. Panel E adapted with permission from [54].
7
These considerations support the conclusion that the brain's network organization is
a major contributor to the computational architecture underlying its functionality, leading to a
more focused question: how much function (in terms of both neural activity variance and
cognitive/behavioral variance) can connectivity patterns explain? This is an important
question since there are various alternatives to distributed connectivity in determining the
functionality of single neurons and neural populations. For instance, relevant local neural
population properties include population firing thresholds [43,55], neuron types [56,57],
excitatory-inhibitory balance [58,59], local glial cell properties [60], and local recurrent
connectivity [61,62]. Also highly relevant are neurotransmitter types (including large-scale
neuromodulatory effects) [63,64] as well as systemic delivery of neuromodulators (e.g.,
hormones) [65].
Testing Connectionist Principles in Empirical Data
One way to evaluate the relative contribution of local versus distributed factors in
determining the functionality of neural populations is to test the plausibility of each in
computational models. We recently built on the fundamental algorithm underlying most
computational simulations of large-scale neural processing -- activity flow (Figure 2A) -- to
develop a procedure for testing local vs. distributed contributions to functionality [53,54,66]
(Figure 2B). Activity flow is the movement of neural activity (e.g., spike rates or fMRI signal
amplitudes in biological contexts) between neural entities. Quantitatively, the activity flow
approach involves simulating a single neural network computation (e.g., a forward iteration in
a feedforward neural network): 𝑎#=𝑓(∑ 𝑎(𝑤#(
), where a unit 𝑎#'s activity is a linear
combination of all other units activity (∑ 𝑎(
) weighted by their connectivity (𝑤#() to 𝑎# before
(∈+
passing through a transfer function 𝑓, such as a sigmoid. Within the connectionism
(∈+
framework, this formalization is a combination of the propagation and activation rules [51].
Other names given to more specific instantiations of this algorithm (e.g., with a particular form
of nonlinearity) include the McCulloch-Pitts neuron [55], the perceptron [67], the divisive
normalization model of neural activity [68], adaptive linear element [69], and spreading
activation [70]. Critically, this algorithm was adapted for use with empirical data (e.g., fMRI
activity and functional connectivity estimates) to parameterize empirically-derived models that
make quantitative predictions of the spread of estimated activity over brain network
connections (Figure 2B).
8
In neural network simulations we found that activity flow mapping was only effective
in network architectures with relatively large effects of distributed (relative to recurrent/local)
connectivity (Figure 2C). This is consistent with previous findings, where large effects of inter-
regional synaptic coupling (relative to local coupling) were important for predicting functional
from structural connectivity [71]. Thus, when we applied this approach successfully in
empirical fMRI data across a variety of diverse tasks (see Figure 2D for an example) we were
able to conclude that distributed connectivity plays a substantial role in determining localized
functionality [76]. This is highly compatible with the notion that each localized population has
a "connectivity fingerprint" that largely determines its functionality [72,73]. These results are
also in line with the observation that large-scale propagation of neural activity in animal
models tends to conform to large-scale anatomical connectivity patterns [74].
Other studies have further demonstrated the role of brain connectivity in mediating
distributed neural activity. One study found that decodable cognitive information transfer
between pairs of brain regions can be mediated via activity flow processes [54]. This
illustrated that information in a source brain region can be sent (encoded) through network
connectivity to be received (decoded) by a target brain region (Figure 2E). In another study,
we found that the task activations of healthy older adults can be transformed into
dysfunctional task activations of unhealthy older adults via the latter's connectivity patterns
[66]. This was accomplished by estimating activity flow through disrupted intrinsic functional
networks of subjects at increased risk for developing Alzheimer's disease. This suggests that
changes in brain network organization underlie "unhealthy" cognitive computations [66].
Using Connectionist Models to Understand Empirical Data
A general principle of connectionist theory is that the ability of a neural network model
to perform an experimental task is dependent upon its connectivity patterns [46]. This
suggests an alternative approach to study the importance of connectivity in producing
cognitive computations: training an artificial neural network model to perform an experimental
cognitive task. Despite the connectivity patterns of these models being specified more by task
training than biological constraints, many of these models are able to accurately predict
empirical neural responses [40,41,46,75]. Moreover, both biological and artificial systems can
be characterized by the same computational mechanism: activity flow processes (Figure 2A)
[52]. This again supports the conclusion that connectivity patterns -- even those derived
9
primarily from task training constraints -- are central to neural computations underlying
cognitive processing.
Despite these promising results, much work remains to determine the role of the
brain's network architecture in influencing cognitive functionality. For instance, the particular
cognitive tasks used are only a small sample of the wide array of tasks humans are capable
of [76,77]. Thus, much work remains to verify the role of connectivity patterns in determining
the computations across diverse tasks and stimuli. Notably, understanding how many
different tasks can be encoded through distributed network processes will likely facilitate the
design of generalized models of cognition that can adaptively perform novel tasks [13,76,77].
Additionally, it will be important to assess how activity flow computations are altered across
different levels of functional organization, from finer-grained activity and connectivity patterns
to large-scale functional brain regions and networks. Finally, it will be important to determine
the role of features other than connectivity -- such as local activation functions (incorporating
nonlinearities, such as compressive summation in visual cortex) [78,79] and operating
timescales/dynamics [71,80] -- in specifying the neural computations that facilitate cognitive
processes.
Additional Approaches for Mapping Cognitive Function with Connectivity
Given the strong evidence that connectivity is central to neural computation, any
methods that link cognitive function with connectivity are likely to provide useful theoretical
insight. In this section we focus on efforts that characterize information in distributed
networks, as well as efforts that quantify how cognitive information representations
quantitatively change between brain areas. In the subsequent section we will focus on
network coding models, which provide a mechanistic characterization of information
processing, due to the incorporation of connectivity estimates as constraints. For instance,
there have been significant advances in characterizing how the synchronization of neural time
series during tasks -- task-state functional connectivity -- relates to ongoing cognitive
processes. While links between resting-state functional connectivity and cognitive ability
(estimated via individual difference correlations) have been widely reported [21,22,81 -- 83],
changes to the underlying functional network organization from resting state to task state can
shed light on how those network changes contribute to task-related cognitive processes
[30,34].
10
Recent work has shown that the functional network organization during resting and
task states are highly similar [29,31], with the functional network organization at rest
accounting for up to 80% of the variance in whole-brain network organization during tasks.
However, studies have reported systematic task-related changes in functional network
organization that reflect ongoing cognitive processes [28,33,84]. Moreover, transient changes
in task-state functional connectivity have been shown to predict task performance [84]. Thus,
measures of task-state functional connectivity can provide insight into which brain region
interactions are involved in a cognitive process.
Despite the insights offered by standard task-state functional connectivity analyses,
correlation-based measures of the BOLD signal between pairs of regions limit the
identification of what kind of information is transmitted between brain regions and how this
information might be transmitted. Several recent approaches have gone beyond standard
functional connectivity measures, providing multivariate measures of temporal and spatial
dependence between brain areas [85]. For example, one study measured the time-varying
information content (i.e., decodability) during task states, and correlated the informational
time series with other brain regions [86]. This technique goes beyond asking whether two
brain regions are synchronized and addresses whether pairs of regions contain task-related
information at the same time.
Other approaches estimate the neural transformation of cognitive representations
between brain regions, clarifying the mathematical relationship between distinct units. One
approach maps spatial activation patterns between brain areas using a nonlinear
transformation, capturing the optimal or "normative" computational transformation required to
project one brain region's information into another brain region's geometry [87]. Another
similar approach estimated the optimal linear transformation required to project activation
patterns in early visual cortex to regions further along the ventral visual stream, such as the
fusiform face complex [88]. By identifying a simple linear transformation, the authors were
able to investigate the computational properties of the linear transformation matrix, such as
whether the mapping projected to a lower dimensional space (e.g., information compression)
as the information was mapped from early visual areas to the fusiform face complex. Thus,
by characterizing the representational mappings between brain regions during cognitive
tasks, these studies go beyond what standard task-state functional connectivity approaches
offer to characterize inter-unit computational relationships. However, such models fail to
11
constrain their predictions with separate estimates of brain connectivity; a key aspect of
network coding models.
Network Coding Models: Computing Cognitive Information in Neural Networks
We and others have made the case that a particularly powerful framework for
characterizing the functionality of brain regions is to use encoding and decoding models [12 --
14]. However, most uses of encoding and decoding models are designed to characterize
information of interest to the experimenter, and are inconsistent with how neural entities likely
encode and decode task information biophysically [89,90]. An example of this are function-
structure mappings that map high-level, human annotated information (such as semantic
information) onto brain activity [91]. Though these data-driven functional models can be
useful, neural entities likely encode and decode complex task features through network
connectivity, rather than the direct task stimulus-to-neural response associations composing
traditional encoding and decoding models (Figure 3A). The absence of mechanistic
constraints (such as network connectivity) in these models limit the causal relevance of
experimenter-extracted neural representations [89,90].
12
Figure 3. From experimenter-based encoding/decoding models to network coding models. A)
Traditional encoding models impose experimenter-based stimulus constraints to measure neural
responses. These measures represent the degree to which a neural entity responds to different task
features. Despite the simplicity of these models, the neural responses predicted by these encoding
models may not reflect how the brain actually responds to the task information. Instead, these models
focus on whether the experimenter can map task information onto neural responses, rather than how a
neural entity actually encodes task information through its network connectivity [89]. B) Network coding
models (see Figures 1 and 2) utilize mechanistic constraints (e.g., brain network connectivity) to
investigate how a neural entity's connections might drive its task-related response. The first approach is
to estimate connectivity directly, and then predict (via activity flow estimation) neural responses in a
downstream neural entity to characterize how those responses likely emerge from activity flow processes
via connectivity. C) The second, more top-down approach (see Figure 4) uses behavior or task
performance to learn the network connectivity patterns necessary to encode task representations
(through learning algorithms). These artificial neural networks implicitly model activity flow processes to
implement the neural computations underlying cognitive task functions. When provided with sufficient
biological constraints (e.g., the visual system's "deep" network architecture), these models can be directly
compared to empirical data, producing unique insight into the network principles that are instrumental to
performing cognitive processes (which include cognitive encoding and decoding) [41,46,48].
A potential solution to this problem is to incorporate network connectivity estimates in
conjunction with traditional encoding and decoding models -- a network coding model (Figures
13
1C, 3B, and 3C). Figure 3 formalizes the distinction between standard encoding/decoding
models and network coding models. The latter approach would add mechanistic constraints
-- brain network connectivity -- to encoding and decoding models. Constraining models via
connectivity, as performed in activity flow mapping (Figure 2), enables a stronger mechanistic
interpretation of how neural entities receive (encode) and send (decode) information within
the brain. Additionally, this approach explicitly implements activity flow processes in empirical
data (Figure 2A). This increases the biological relevance of these models by simulating the
physical process by which neural signals are relayed through network connectivity [53,54,66].
Ultimately, this framework strengthens causal inferences made about the transmission of task
information within the brain, beyond traditional descriptive statistics [3,54].
link between
Network coding models provide a biologically plausible
encoding/decoding models and connectionist theory when studying the propagation of activity
during cognitive tasks. Several recent methods have applied this general framework. The first
is to incorporate estimates of functional connectivity directly with traditional, experimenter-
based encoding and decoding models (Figure 3B) [54]. This approach tests whether
decodable information in one brain area can be re-encoded through connectivity patterns and
decoded in a downstream target brain area, providing a biophysically plausible model of
information transfer. We recently demonstrated that task information in a set of brain regions
could be used to predict the same task features in downstream regions through activity flow
processes using functional connectivity estimated using resting-state fMRI (Figure 2E) [54].
These findings illustrate that task information in a brain area not only can be
encoded/decoded by the experimenter, but is also used by other brain areas through
distributed network connectivity.
The second approach uses structured connectionist models (neural network
models with architectural constraints) to study the emergence of localized functionality from
connectivity (Figure 3C). Recent technological advances in the training of structured
connectionist models, such as biologically-inspired deep neural networks and recurrent
neural networks, have enabled the study of the encoding and decoding of cognitive
information via activity flow through optimized connectivity architectures. For example, a
recent study showed that a recurrent neural network was able to represent an array of
different inputs, such as different task states and stimuli (encoding), and map those inputs to
different motor outputs (decoding) for accurate task performance [41]. Importantly, the task
features/stimuli that this neural network encoded (its inputs) were qualitatively different from
14
the features that it decoded (motor outputs), offering insight into how information might be
transformed across neural entities via network connectivity [49]. Thus, while traditional
experimenter-based encoding and decoding models typically address what a neural entity
might be encoding and decoding, network coding models can also address how that
information might be computed and/or subsequently processed.
Although unconstrained/unstructured neural network models are universal function
approximators [92], employing biological priors in neural network models can aid in producing
mechanistic models of neural computations (Figure 3C) [93]. Such constraints (model
assumptions) are essential to discovering the model features that are involved in the neural
computations underlying cognitive functions. For instance, connectivity architecture and task
performance constraints were implemented to demonstrate how images can be encoded and
decoded to identify objects in neural network models in both human [50] (Figure 4) and non-
human primates [47,48]. These types of models map visual images onto specific object codes
via a nonlinear computation mediated by connectivity (Figure 4A). While any neural network
model can be theoretically trained to accurately perform this computation, Wen and
colleagues demonstrated that when adding biological constraints into this neural network
(e.g., number of layers and number of units per layer to match those of the ventral visual
stream) the network exhibited similar neuronal responses to empirical fMRI data obtained in
humans (Figure 4B) [50]. Moreover, they identified a face-selective unit in their model and
showed that its activity was highly correlated with the fusiform face area in empirical fMRI
data when dynamic naturalistic stimuli was shown to both human and model (Figure 4C). This
suggests that like the brain, localized functionality can emerge in neural network models even
when primarily optimized for task performance. Critically, incorporating realistic biological
constraints can improve the fidelity with which artificial neural networks mimic the brain in
representing cognitive information.
15
Figure 4. Leveraging neural network models to explain empirical neural data in the visual system.
A) When appropriately constrained with biological and structural priors, artificial neural networks can be
used to model empirical neural data [50]. Wen and colleagues compared representations in a brain-
inspired neural network to representations found in empirical fMRI data during presentation of the same
naturalistic stimuli (movies). B) Stimulus activations in different layers of the deep convolutional neural
network corresponded to different brain areas in the visual system. For example, brain areas in earlier
visual processing areas (e.g., V1 and V2) contained representations more similar to representations in
earlier layers in the artificial neural network. C) The activation time series of face-selective areas in fMRI
data and the face-selective unit in the artificial neural network had highly similar and comparable time
series during presentation of the dynamic naturalistic stimuli. Figures adapted with permission from [50].
Network coding models can therefore provide directly testable hypotheses in empirical
data. For example, if a neural network model contains enough biological constraints, a
mapping between the network model and empirical neural data can be made (Figure 3C). In
a recent study, a biologically-constrained artificial neural network of the ventral visual stream
provided insight into how to control and activate targeted neural populations in area V4 [75].
By dissecting the receptive fields of specific units in their biologically-constrained artificial
16
neural network model, the authors generated novel visual stimuli that could theoretically
target a subset of biological units in the primate V4. Indeed, the authors showed that these
stimuli could activate and control corresponding neural populations empirically in the primate
brain, uncovering the receptive fields (and localized function) of those biological units through
model analysis. This approach provides a powerful framework to test how localized
functionality emerges from network organization in both artificial and biophysical neural
networks. We suggest that including additional biological constraints, such as empirically-
derived connectivity estimates, would likely lend additional mechanistic insight into how
neural information processing is carried out in the brain [15].
Concluding Remarks
The recent proliferation of large neural data sets with rich task features has created a
wealth of opportunities in functional brain mapping. However, data-driven approaches to
mapping task features to neural responses largely disregard the biological mechanisms of
neural information processing: distributed cognitive processing through brain network
connectivity. Since the early days of connectionism, the functionality of neural entities has
long been hypothesized to be embedded in its patterns of network connectivity [51,72,73].
Here we propose the incorporation of brain network connectivity as a biological constraint
underlying the emergence of localized functionality and distributed cognitive processing.
Though mounting evidence suggests that connectivity undoubtedly plays a role in
cognition, the precise contribution of distributed versus local processing remains an open
question (see Outstanding Questions). Several advances are needed to answer this question.
First, it will be important to advance current connectivity estimates, given that current methods
may only indicate associational (and not causal) relations [3,94]. Second, it will be important
to integrate additional biological properties that shape local processing properties (such as
nonlinear transfer functions) and incorporate them into network coding models [20]. Lastly, it
will be important to evaluate how these principles might generalize across levels of
organization and spatial scales using the wide variety of data types available to
neuroscientists. Such insight can provide more mechanistic insight into how local functionality
emerges from the interplay between distributed (e.g., connectivity) and local (e.g., nonlinear)
processes. Taken together, we can begin to reconstruct how the collective interaction of
functionally-specific localized processes work together to compute diverse cognitive
functions.
17
Box 1. The evolution of connectionism in relation to neuroscience
Despite the biological and neural origins of connectionism [38,55,67,69], there are stark
differences in current connectionist (deep learning) and neuroscientific research. One of
the most influential advances in connectionism was the discovery of backpropagation, an
algorithm that enabled the training of multilayer artificial neural networks. Pioneered by Paul
Werbos in 1974 and popularized by other connectionist researchers [51,69,95],
backpropagation provided researchers with the tools to train networks to perform
increasingly complex tasks. This discovery strongly influenced the direction of connectionist
research away from its neurobiological roots and towards the development of learning
algorithms. Until recently, the development of these learning algorithms has been the
primary focus of many connectionist and deep learning researchers.
Despite this focus on learning algorithms, learning in artificial systems is in many ways
incomparable to learning in biological systems. One reason for this is the biological
implausibility of the backpropagation learning algorithm, though biologically-plausible
equivalents exist [96]. A more fundamental reason is that biological systems are born with
inductive biases (i.e., innate structure) that shape how they interact with their environments
early in life [93,97]. A recent opinion paper argued that the inductive biases afforded to a
biological system are the result of learning during evolution (rather than within a single
lifespan), and is likely embedded in an organism's DNA [97]. Thus, learning in artificial
systems is more appropriately compared to learning on evolutionary timescales (which
often takes place outside the context of neuroscience research), since artificial neural
networks are typically "born" with a blank slate.
The network coding model approach advocated here is consistent with recent work focused
on
to understand
neurocomputational principles. Such biologically-based inductive biases, such as the
incorporation of highly structured network architectures, have been especially useful in
understanding core object recognition in the ventral visual stream [47,48,50,75,98]. Other
inductive biases, such as the incorporation of cortical heterogeneity and local biophysical
into neural network models
integrating
inductive biases
18
properties, have been especially useful in characterizing simulated large-scale network
dynamics [62,99 -- 101]. Here we focus primarily on the incorporation of empirical brain
network architecture
to predictive
(encoding/decoding) brain models. We expect insights from these network coding models
to positively impact both neuroscience and connectionist research.
to provide principled
inductive biases
Glossary
Activity flow: A fundamental computation (see Figure 2A) describing the movement of
activity between neural units as a function of their connectivity (e.g., propagating spikes over
axons in the brain). This is equivalent to the activation and propagation rules used in
connectionist research.
Connectionist/Connectionism: A subfield within cognitive science that focuses on
implementing cognitive and mental phenomena computationally through artificial neural
networks.
Connectivity mapping: The quantification of the relationship between two or more neural
entities (e.g., brain regions) using either statistical dependencies of the neural time series
(functional connectivity) or estimates of structural/anatomical pathways
(structural
connectivity).
Connectome: A complete connectivity map of all units in a neural system.
Constraint: A limitation placed on a model in an optimization context. We focus primarily on
empirical constraints, especially biological constraints such as brain network organization.
We also focus on task performance constraints, which are typically emphasized in
connectionist modeling.
Decoding model: A statistical model that predicts a task stimulus or condition as a function
of a set of neural responses.
Deep neural network models: Neural network models with more than one hidden layer,
which have been shown to boost task performance in many cases relative to traditional neural
network models.
Encoding model: A statistical model that predicts a neural response as a function of a task
stimulus or condition.
Experimenter-based encoding/decoding models: In contrast to network coding models,
encoding/decoding models that focus on how the experimenter encodes/decodes information
from a neural entity, rather than how other neural entities in the brain encode/decode that
information.
19
Function-structure mapping: The association between a particular neural entity and its
functionality, such as what task stimuli a neural entity activates or responds to.
Network coding models: Models of brain function that simulate encoding and decoding
processes through network connectivity (typically via the activity flow algorithm) to predict
empirical brain activity.
Network neuroscience: A subfield of neuroscience concerned with understanding the
network principles of neural phenomena by exploiting tools from network science.
Neural network models: Computational models consisting of a network of interconnected
units that are optimized to match biological features (biological constraints) and task
performance (normative task performance constraints) to varying extents.
Recurrent neural network model: Neural network models that feedforward through time,
rather than through different spatial layers. Recurrent connections indicate directed
connections to other units within the network that propagate activity through time.
Structured connectionist models: Neural network models with built-in architectures (i.e.,
innate structure), such as many deep neural networks with a fixed number of layers.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank Ruben Sanchez-Romero for assistance with preparing this
article. The authors acknowledge the support of the US National Institutes of Health under
awards R01 AG055556 and R01 MH109520, and the Behavioral and Neural Sciences
Graduate Program at Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey. The content is solely the
responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of any of
the funding agencies.
20
References
1 Reid, A.T. et al. (In Press) Advancing functional connectivity research from association to
causation. Nat. Neurosci.
2 Craver, C. (2007) Explaining the brain, Oxford University Press.
3 Mill, R.D. et al. (2017) From connectome to cognition: The search for mechanism in
human functional brain networks. NeuroImage DOI: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.01.060
4 Bassett, D.S. and Sporns, O. (2017) Network neuroscience. Nat. Neurosci. 20, 353
5 Henson, R. (2005) What can functional neuroimaging tell the experimental psychologist?
Q. J. Exp. Psychol. Sect. A 58, 193 -- 233
6 Wallis, J.D. (2018) Decoding Cognitive Processes from Neural Ensembles. Trends Cogn.
Sci. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tics.2018.09.002
7 Poldrack, R.A. et al. (2011) Handbook of functional MRI data analysis, Cambridge
8 Luck, S.J. (2014) An introduction to the event-related potential technique, MIT press.
9 Genon, S. et al. (2018) How to Characterize the Function of a Brain Region. Trends Cogn.
University Press.
Sci. 22, 350 -- 364
10 Kriegeskorte, N. et al. (2009) Circular analysis in systems neuroscience: the dangers of
double dipping. Nat. Neurosci. 12, 535 -- 540
11 Varoquaux, G. and Poldrack, R.A. (2019) Predictive models avoid excessive reductionism
in cognitive neuroimaging. Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 55, 1 -- 6
12 Gallant, J. et al. (2010) System identification, encoding models, and decoding models, a
powerful new approach to fMRI research. Underst. Vis. Popul. Codes
13 Naselaris, T. et al. (2011) Encoding and decoding in fMRI. NeuroImage 56, 400 -- 410
14 Kriegeskorte, N. and Douglas, P.K. (2018) Interpreting Encoding and Decoding Models.
ArXiv181200278 Q-Bio at <http://arxiv.org/abs/1812.00278>
15 Kay, K.N. (2018) Principles for models of neural information processing. NeuroImage 180,
16 Kriegeskorte, N. and Douglas, P.K. (2018) Cognitive computational neuroscience. Nat.
101 -- 109
Neurosci. 21, 1148 -- 1160
17 Hubel, D.H. and Wiesel, T.N. (1962) Receptive fields, binocular interaction and functional
architecture in the cat's visual cortex. J. Physiol. 160, 106 -- 154
18 Haak, K.V. et al. (2013) Connective field modeling. NeuroImage 66, 376 -- 384
19 Arcaro, M.J. et al. (2015) Widespread correlation patterns of fMRI signal across visual
cortex reflect eccentricity organization. eLife 4,
20 Kay, K. and Yeatman, J. (2016) Bottom-up and top-down computations in high-level visual
cortex. bioRxiv DOI: 10.1101/053595
21 Cole, M.W. et al. (2012) Global connectivity of prefrontal cortex predicts cognitive control
and intelligence. J. Neurosci. Off. J. Soc. Neurosci. 32, 8988 -- 99
22 Finn, E.S. et al. (2015) Functional connectome fingerprinting: identifying individuals using
patterns of brain connectivity. Nat. Neurosci. 18, 1664 -- 1671
23 Smith, S.M. et al. (2015) A positive-negative mode of population covariation links brain
connectivity, demographics and behavior. Nat. Neurosci. 18, 1 -- 7
24 Li, J. et al. (2019) Global signal regression strengthens association between resting-state
functional connectivity and behavior. NeuroImage 196, 126 -- 141
25 Biswal, B. et al. (1995) Functional connectivity in the motor cortex of resting human brain
using echo-planar MRI. Magn. Reson. Med. 34, 537 -- 541
26 Power, J.D. et al. (2011) Functional Network Organization of the Human Brain. Neuron
21
72, 665 -- 678
27 Yeo, B.T. et al. (2011) The organization of the human cerebral cortex estimated by
intrinsic functional connectivity. J. Neurophysiol. 106, 1125 -- 1165
28 Cole, M.W. et al. (2013) Multi-task connectivity reveals flexible hubs for adaptive task
29 Cole, M.W. et al. (2014) Intrinsic and task-evoked network architectures of the human
control. Nat. Neurosci. 16, 1348 -- 1355
brain. Neuron 83, 238 -- 251
30 Cole, M.W. et al. (2019) Task activations produce spurious but systematic inflation of task
functional connectivity estimates. NeuroImage 189, 1 -- 18
31 Krienen, F.M. et al. (2014) Reconfigurable task-dependent functional coupling modes
cluster around a core functional architecture. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 369,
20130526 -- 20130526
32 Hearne, L. et al. (2015) Interactions between default mode and control networks as a
function of increasing cognitive reasoning complexity. Hum. Brain Mapp. 36, 2719 -- 2731
33 Hearne, L.J. et al. (2017) Reconfiguration of Brain Network Architectures between
Resting-State and Complexity-Dependent Cognitive Reasoning. J. Neurosci. 37, 8399 --
8411
34 Ito, T. et al. (2019) Task-evoked activity quenches neural correlations and variability in
large-scale brain systems. bioRxiv DOI: 10.1101/560730
35 Honey, C.J. et al. (2007) Network structure of cerebral cortex shapes functional
connectivity on multiple time scales. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 104, 10240 -- 5
36 Hagmann, P. et al. (2008) Mapping the structural core of human cerebral cortex. PLoS
Biol. 6, 1479 -- 1493
Methods 10, 483 -- 490
37 Bargmann, C.I. and Marder, E. (2013) From the connectome to brain function. Nat.
38 Rumelhart, D.E. and Mcclelland, J.L. (1986) Parallel distributed processing: explorations
at
Foundations.
cognition.
Volume
1.
the microstructure
in
<https://www.osti.gov/biblio/5838709>
of
39 Cohen, J.D. et al. (1990) On the control of automatic processes: a parallel distributed
processing account of the Stroop effect. Psychol. Rev. 97, 332 -- 61
40 Mante, V. et al. (2013) Context-dependent computation by recurrent dynamics in
prefrontal cortex. Nature 503, 78 -- 84
41 Yang, G.R. et al. (2019) Task representations in neural networks trained to perform many
cognitive tasks. Nat. Neurosci. DOI: 10.1038/s41593-018-0310-2
42 Ramón y Cajal, S. (1888) Estructura de los centros nerviosos de las aves,
43 Hodgkin, A.L. and Huxley, A.F. (1952) A quantitative description of membrane current
and its application to conduction and excitation in nerve. J. Physiol. 117, 500 -- 44
44 Rigotti, M. et al. (2013) The importance of mixed selectivity in complex cognitive tasks.
Nature 497, 585 -- 90
Opin. Neurobiol. 55, 103 -- 111
45 Saxena, S. and Cunningham, J.P. (2019) Towards the neural population doctrine. Curr.
46 Williamson, R.C. et al. (2019) Bridging large-scale neuronal recordings and large-scale
network models using dimensionality reduction. Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 55, 40 -- 47
47 Khaligh-Razavi, S.M. and Kriegeskorte, N. (2014) Deep Supervised, but Not
Unsupervised, Models May Explain IT Cortical Representation. PLoS Comput. Biol. 10,
48 Yamins, D.L.K. et al. (2014) Performance-optimized hierarchical models predict neural
responses in higher visual cortex. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 111, 8619 -- 8624
49 Yamins, D.L.K. and DiCarlo, J.J. (2016) Using goal-driven deep learning models to
understand sensory cortex. Nat. Neurosci. 19, 356
22
50 Wen, H. et al. (2018) Neural Encoding and Decoding with Deep Learning for Dynamic
Natural Vision. Cereb. Cortex 28, 4136 -- 4160
51 Rumelhart, D.E. et al. (1986) A general framework for parallel distributed processing.
Parallel Distrib. Process. Explor. Microstruct. Cogn. 1, 45 -- 76
52 McClelland, J.L. and Rogers, T.T. (2003) The parallel distributed processing approach to
semantic cognition. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 4, 310 -- 322
53 Cole, M.W. et al. (2016) Activity flow over resting-state networks shapes cognitive task
activations. Nat. Neurosci. DOI: 10.1038/nn.4406
54 Ito, T. et al. (2017) Cognitive task information is transferred between brain regions via
resting-state network topology. Nat. Commun. 8,
55 McCulloch, W.S. and Pitts, W. (1943) A logical calculus of the ideas immanent in nervous
activity. Bull. Math. Biophys. 5, 115 -- 133
56 Markram, H. et al. (2004) Interneurons of the neocortical inhibitory system. Nat. Rev.
Neurosci. 5, 793
57 Gouwens, N.W. et al. (2019) Classification of electrophysiological and morphological
neuron types in the mouse visual cortex. Nat. Neurosci. DOI: 10.1038/s41593-019-0417-
0
58 Barral, J. and Reyes, A.D. (2016) Synaptic scaling rule preserves excitatory -- inhibitory
balance and salient neuronal network dynamics. Nat. Neurosci. DOI: 10.1038/nn.4415
59 Hennequin, G. et al. (2017) Inhibitory Plasticity: Balance, Control, and Codependence.
Annu. Rev. Neurosci. 40, 557 -- 579
60 De Pittà, M. and Berry, H. (2019) Computational Glioscience, Springer.
61 Demirtaş, M. et al. (2019) Hierarchical Heterogeneity across Human Cortex Shapes
Large-Scale Neural Dynamics. Neuron DOI: 10.1016/j.neuron.2019.01.017
62 Wang, P. et al. (2019) Inversion of a large-scale circuit model reveals a cortical hierarchy
in the dynamic resting human brain. Sci. Adv. 5, eaat7854
63 Servan-Schreiber, D. et al. (1990) A network model of catecholamine effects: gain, signal-
to-noise ratio, and behavior. Science 249, 892 -- 895
64 Shine, J.M. (2019) Neuromodulatory Influences on Integration and Segregation in the
Brain. Trends Cogn. Sci. 0,
65 Izquierdo, I. and Medina, J.H. (1997) The biochemistry of memory formation and its
regulation by hormones and neuromodulators. Psychobiology 25, 1 -- 9
66 Mill, R.D. et al. (2019) Predicting dysfunctional age-related task activations from resting-
state network alterations. bioRxiv DOI: 10.1101/678086
67 Rosenblatt, F. (1958) The perceptron: A probabilistic model for information storage and
organization in the brain. Psychol. Rev. 65, 386 -- 408
68 Carandini, M. and Heeger, D.J. (2012) Normalization as a canonical neural computation.
Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 13, 51 -- 62
69 Widrow, B. and Lehr, M.A. (1990) 30 Years of Adaptive Neural Networks: Perceptron,
Madaline, and Backpropagation. Proc. IEEE 78, 1415 -- 1442
70 Collins, A.M. and Loftus, E.F. (1975) A spreading-activation theory of semantic
processing. Psychol. Rev. 82, 407
71 Deco, G. et al. (2013) Resting-state functional connectivity emerges from structurally and
dynamically shaped slow linear fluctuations. J. Neurosci. Off. J. Soc. Neurosci. 33,
11239 -- 52
72 Passingham, R.E. et al. (2002) The anatomical basis of functional localization in the
73 Mars, R.B. et al. (2018) Connectivity Fingerprints: From Areal Descriptions to Abstract
cortex. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 3, 606 -- 616
Spaces. Trends Cogn. Sci. 22, 1026 -- 1037
23
74 Kotter, R. and Sommer, F.T. (2000) Global relationship between anatomical connectivity
and activity propagation in the cerebral cortex. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. Biol. Sci.
355, 127 -- 134
75 Bashivan, P. et al. (2019) Neural population control via deep image synthesis. Science
364, eaav9436
76 Cole, M.W. et al. (2013) Rapid instructed task learning: A new window into the human
brain's unique capacity for flexible cognitive control. Cogn. Affect. Behav. Neurosci. 13,
1 -- 22
77 Yang, G.R. et al. (2019) How to study the neural mechanisms of multiple tasks. Curr.
78 Reynolds, J.H. and Heeger, D.J. (2009) The normalization model of attention. Neuron 61,
79 Kay, K.N. et al. (2013) Compressive spatial summation in human visual cortex. J.
Opin. Behav. Sci. 29, 134 -- 143
168 -- 185
Neurophysiol. 110, 481 -- 494
Neurosci. 17, 1661 -- 1663
80 Murray, J.D. et al. (2014) A hierarchy of intrinsic timescales across primate cortex. Nat.
81 Schultz, D.H. and Cole, M.W. (2016) Higher Intelligence Is Associated with Less Task-
Related Brain Network Reconfiguration. J. Neurosci. 36, 8551 -- 8561
82 Gratton, C. et al. (2018) Functional Brain Networks Are Dominated by Stable Group and
Individual Factors, Not Cognitive or Daily Variation. Neuron 98, 439 -- 452.e5
83 Kashyap, R. et al. (2019) Individual-specific fMRI-Subspaces improve functional
connectivity prediction of behavior. NeuroImage 189, 804 -- 812
84 Sadaghiani, S. et al. (2015) Ongoing dynamics in large-scale functional connectivity
predict perception. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 112, 8463 -- 8468
85 Anzellotti, S. and Coutanche, M.N. (2017) Beyond Functional Connectivity : Investigating
Networks of Multivariate Representations. Trends Cogn. Sci. xx, 1 -- 12
86 Coutanche, M.N. and Thompson-Schill, S.L. (2013) Informational connectivity: identifying
synchronized discriminability of multi-voxel patterns across the brain. Front. Hum.
Neurosci. 7, 15
87 Anzellotti, S. et al. (2016) Measuring and Modeling Transformations of Information
Between Brain Regions with fMRI. bioRxiv DOI: 10.1101/074856
88 Basti, A. et al. (2019) Analysing linear multivariate pattern transformations in
neuroimaging data. bioRxiv DOI: 10.1101/497180
89 De-Wit, L. et al. (2016) Is neuroimaging measuring information in the brain? Psychon.
Bull. Rev. DOI: 10.3758/s13423-016-1002-0
90 Brette, R. (2018) Is coding a relevant metaphor for the brain? bioRxiv DOI:
10.1101/168237
91 Huth, A.G. et al. (2016) Natural speech reveals the semantic maps that tile human
cerebral cortex. Nature 532, 453 -- 458
92 Hartman, E.J. et al. (1990) Layered Neural Networks with Gaussian Hidden Units as
Universal Approximations. Neural Comput. 2, 210 -- 215
93 Sinz, F.H. et al. (2019) Engineering a Less Artificial Intelligence. Neuron 103, 967 -- 979
94 Power, J.D. et al. (2012) Spurious but systematic correlations in functional connectivity
MRI networks arise from subject motion. NeuroImage 59, 2142 -- 2154
95 Werbos, P. (1974) Beyond Regression:" New Tools for Prediction and Analysis in the
Behavioral Sciences. Ph Diss. Harv. Univ.
96 O'Reilly, R.C. (1996) Biologically plausible error-driven learning using local activation
differences: The generalized recirculation algorithm. Neural Comput. 8, 895 -- 938
97 Zador, A.M. (2019) A critique of pure learning and what artificial neural networks can learn
24
bioRxiv DOI: 10.1101/553255
101 Demirtas, M. et al. (2018) Hierarchical heterogeneity across human cortex shapes
large-scale neural dynamics. bioRxiv DOI: 10.1101/341966
from animal brains. Nat. Commun. 10, 1 -- 7
98 Kar, K. et al. (2019) Evidence that recurrent circuits are critical to the ventral stream's
execution of core object recognition behavior. Nat. Neurosci. 22, 974 -- 983
99 Singh, M.F. et al. (2019) Individualized Dynamic Brain Models: Estimation and Validation
with Resting-State fMRI. bioRxiv DOI: 10.1101/678243
100 Seeliger, K. et al. (2019) Neural System Identification with Neural Information Flow.
25
|
1911.08584 | 1 | 1911 | 2019-11-15T18:32:42 | Neocortical plasticity: an unsupervised cake but no free lunch | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cs.AI",
"cs.LG",
"cs.NE"
] | The fields of artificial intelligence and neuroscience have a long history of fertile bi-directional interactions. On the one hand, important inspiration for the development of artificial intelligence systems has come from the study of natural systems of intelligence, the mammalian neocortex in particular. On the other, important inspiration for models and theories of the brain have emerged from artificial intelligence research. A central question at the intersection of these two areas is concerned with the processes by which neocortex learns, and the extent to which they are analogous to the back-propagation training algorithm of deep networks. Matching the data efficiency, transfer and generalization properties of neocortical learning remains an area of active research in the field of deep learning. Recent advances in our understanding of neuronal, synaptic and dendritic physiology of the neocortex suggest new approaches for unsupervised representation learning, perhaps through a new class of objective functions, which could act alongside or in lieu of back-propagation. Such local learning rules have implicit rather than explicit objectives with respect to the training data, facilitating domain adaptation and generalization. Incorporating them into deep networks for representation learning could better leverage unlabelled datasets to offer significant improvements in data efficiency of downstream supervised readout learning, and reduce susceptibility to adversarial perturbations, at the cost of a more restricted domain of applicability. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Neocortical plasticity: an unsupervised cake but no
free lunch
Eilif B. Muller*
Philippe Beaudoin
Element AI
6650 Saint-Urbain #500
Montreal, QC H2S 3G9
Canada
*Correspondence to:
[email protected]
Abstract
The fields of artificial intelligence and neuroscience have a long history of fertile bi-
directional interactions. On the one hand, important inspiration for the development
of artificial intelligence systems has come from the study of natural systems of
intelligence, the mammalian neocortex in particular. On the other, important
inspiration for models and theories of the brain have emerged from artificial
intelligence research. A central question at the intersection of these two areas is
concerned with the processes by which neocortex learns, and the extent to which
they are analogous to the back-propagation training algorithm of deep networks.
Matching the data efficiency, transfer and generalization properties of neocortical
learning remains an area of active research in the field of deep learning. Recent
advances in our understanding of neuronal, synaptic and dendritic physiology of
the neocortex suggest new approaches for unsupervised representation learning,
perhaps through a new class of objective functions, which could act alongside or in
lieu of back-propagation. Such local learning rules have implicit rather than explicit
objectives with respect to the training data, facilitating domain adaptation and
generalization. Incorporating them into deep networks for representation learning
could better leverage unlabelled datasets to offer significant improvements in data
efficiency of downstream supervised readout learning, and reduce susceptibility to
adversarial perturbations, at the cost of a more restricted domain of applicability.
Unsupervised neocortex
The neocortex is the canonically 6-layered sheet of cells forming the grey matter surface of the
mammalian cerebrum. It is composed of a densely interconnected network of sub-regions responsible
for learning sensory processing, speech and language, motor planning and many of the higher
cognitive processes associated with rational thought. The human neocortex contains an estimated 100
trillion synapses, the points of communication between neurons which undergo persistent changes
in strength and topology as a function of signals local to the synapse and a complex biochemical
program (Holtmaat and Svoboda, 2009). These processes, broadly known as synaptic plasticity, are
thought to be the basis of learning and memory in the brain.
An important task of synaptic plasticity in sensory neocortical areas is to learn disentangled invariant
representations (DiCarlo et al., 2012). For example, the ventral stream of primate visual cortex,
Preprint. Under review.
the collection of areas responsible for visual object recognition, computes hierarchically organized
representations much like state-of-the art convolutional neural networks (CNNs) optimized for the
task (Yamins et al., 2014).
While there are impressive similarities in the learned representations between the ventral stream and
CNNs, there are important differences in how those representations are learned. While CNNs are
trained in a supervised manner using a gradient descent optimization algorithm with an explicit global
objective on large labelled datasets, the ventral stream learns from a much larger dataset (visual
experience) but with only very sparse labelling. The latter property of cortical learning is attractive to
emulate in CNNs, and more broadly across deep learning models. Attractive, not only because of the
ability to make use of unlabelled data during learning, but also because it will impart the models with
superior generalization and transfer properties, as discussed below.
The monkey's paw effect: the problem with specifying what without
specifying how
A well known and often encountered pitfall of numerical optimization algorithms for high dimensional
problems, such as evolutionary algorithms, simulated annealing and also gradient descent, is that they
regularly yield solutions matching what your objective specifies to the letter, but far from how you
intended (Lehman et al., 2018).
The short story "The Monkey's Paw" by W. W. Jacobs provides a compelling metaphor. In that
story, the new owner of a magical mummified monkey's paw of Indian origin is granted three wishes.
The owner first wishes for $200, and his wish is eventually granted to the penny, but with the grave
side effect that it is granted through a goodwill payment from his son's employer in response to his
untimely death in a terrible machinery accident (Jacobs and Parker, 1910).
The Monkey's Paw effect is also applicable to gradient descent-based optimization of deep neural
nets. The relative data-hungriness of current supervised learning strategies, and the use of data
augmentation to improve generalization reflect the precarious position we are in of needing to
micromanage the learning processes.
Adversarial examples (Moosavi-Dezfooli et al., 2016) are evidence that the monkey's paw effect
none-the-less persists. It is temping to continue with the current paradigm and re-inject adversarial
examples back into the learning data stream. Extrapolating, this goes in the direction of specifying the
negative space of the objective, all those things the optimization should not do to solve the problem,
which is potentially infinite, and rather risky in production environments like self-driving cars.
Adversarial examples represent an opportunity to address the issue in a more fundamental way
(Yamins and DiCarlo, 2016). It has been argued by Bengio (2012) that if we could design deep
learning systems with the explicit objective of "disentangling the underlying factors of variation" in
an unsupervised manner, then there is much to be gained for generalization and transfer.
Such an approach offers a promising solution to the Monkey's Paw effect, as there is an explicit
objective of learning good representations, from which generalization and transfer follow by defini-
tion.1 One small challenge remains: how to express the objective of learning good representations?
If we restrict ourselves to the subset of all possible inputs for which the neocortex learns good
representations, the local processes of synaptic plasticity may provide valuable clues.
Neocortical plasticity
The neocognitron model (Fukushima, 1980), the original CNN architecture, learned visual features
through self-organization using local rules. Since its conception, our understanding of the neocortex
and its neurons and synapses has progressed considerably.
Recent insights into the local plasticity rules for learning in the neocortex offer new inspiration
for deep representation learning paradigms that learn "disentangled representations" from large
unlabelled datasets in an unsupervised manner. A selection of recent insights into the systems of
plasticity of the neocortex is shown in Fig. 1. A new dendrite-centric view of synaptic plasticity is
1For some input spaces, such as white noise, a good representation may be undefined.
2
Figure 1: A selection of recent insights into the dendritic mechanisms of plasticity of the neo-
cortex. (A) Concurrent activation of > 10 nearby synapses in pyramidal neuron dendrites (red)
triggers NMDA plateau potentials in dendrites (left). (B) Calcium drives synaptic plasticity. Synapses
are bi-stable, and can be added or removed in the weak state (above). NMDA plateau potentials
drive potentiation of synapses through their associated large calcium currents. (source: Graupner
and Brunel (2010)) (C): Clusters of co-coding synapses are captured through these mechanisms. (D)
Co-coding neurons form small cliques, reinforced through cluster capture. These cliques activate
Martinotti cells which block further capture, implementing opposing competition. (E) Neocortical
areas are organized in a hierarchy with top-down input arriving in layer 1 (the top-most layer) at the
apical tufts of pyramidal dendrites, and at layer 6 and lower layer 5. (F). Temporal association of
top-down and bottom-up drives cliques and plasticity.
emerging with the discovery of the NMDA spike, a non-linear mechanism hypothesized to associate
co-activated synapses through potentiation or structural changes driven by the resulting calcium
currents (Schiller et al., 2000; Graupner and Brunel, 2010; Holtmaat and Svoboda, 2009) (Fig. 1A-B).
Such associations, in the form of co-coding clusters of synapses, have recently been experimentally
observed using optical techniques (Wilson et al., 2016) (Fig. 1C). Moreover neurons in the neocortex
are known to form small cliques of all-to-all connected neurons which drive co-coding (Reimann et al.,
2017), a process that would be self-reinforced through dendritic clustering by NMDA spikes (Fig. 1D).
Martinotti neurons, which are activated by such cliques of pyramidal neurons, and subsequently
inhibit pyramidal dendrites (Silberberg and Markram, 2007) provide well-timed inhibition to block
further NMDA spikes (Doron et al., 2017), and put a limit on the maximal pyramidal clique size, but
also suppress activation of competing cliques (e.g. Winner-take-all (WTA) dynamics). Together, such
plasticity mechanisms appear to form basic building blocks for representation learning in the feed-
forward pathway of the neocortex using local learning rules. While long known competitive strategies
for unsupervised representation learning indeed rely on WTA dynamics (Fukushima, 1980; Rumelhart
and Zipser, 1985), deep learning approaches incorporating these increasingly apparent dendritic
dimensions of learning processes have yet to be proposed (Poirazi and Mel, 2001; Kastellakis et al.,
2015).
Unlike CNNs, the neocortex also has a prominent feedback pathway down the hierarchy, whereby top-
down input from upper layers innervate the apical tufts of pyramidal cells in layer 1 of a given cortical
3
region (Felleman and Van, 1991). Associations between top-down and feed-forward (bottom-up)
activation are known to trigger dendritic calcium spikes and dendritic bursting (Larkum et al., 1999),
which again specifically activates the WTA dynamics of the Martinotti neurons (Murayama et al.,
2009), but disinhibitory VIP neurons can also modulate their impact (Karnani et al., 2016). These
feed-back pathways have been proposed to implement predictive coding (Rao and Ballard, 1999),
and error back-propagation for supervised learning algorithms (Guerguiev et al., 2017; Sacramento
et al., 2018). While their importance for rapid object recognition has been recently demonstrated,
their computational role remained inconclusive (Kar et al., 2019).
Cake but no free lunch
With the demonstrated applicability of supervised learning for a broad range of problems and data
distributions, and an ever expanding toolbox of optimized software libraries, it is unlikely that
supervised learning, back-propagation and gradient descent will be dethroned as the work horses of
AI for many years to come.
Nonetheless, as applications of deep networks are moving into regions where sparse data, general-
ization and transfer are increasingly important, unsupervised approaches designed with the explicit
goal of learning good representations from mere observation may find an important place in the AI
ecosystem.
Quoting Yann LeCun2
"If intelligence is a cake, the bulk of the cake is unsupervised learning, the icing
on the cake is supervised learning, and the cherry on the cake is reinforcement
learning."
A promising strategy would be to assume learning with sparse labels, overcoming adversarial
examples, transfer learning, and few-shot learning together as the success criteria for the further
development of the powerful unsupervised approaches we seek.
Recent advances in our understanding of the processes of neocortical plasticity may well offer useful
inspiration, but let's close with some words of moderation. Biology's solutions also show us there
will be no free lunch, i.e. neocortical unsupervised learning algorithms will be less general than
supervised learning by gradient descent. Neocortex relies on structure at specific spatial and temporal
scales in its input streams to learn representations. Evolution has had millions of years to configure
the sensory organs to provide signals to the neocortex in ways that it can make sense of them, and
that serve the animal's ecological niche. We should not expect, for example, cortical unsupervised
learning algorithms to cluster frozen white noise images. A neocortical solution requires a neocortical
problem (e.g. from the so-called "Brain set" (Richards et al., 2019)), so if we are to successfully take
inspiration from it, we must also work within its limitations.
Acknowledgments
Thanks to Giuseppe Chindemi, Perouz Taslakian, Pau Rodriguez, Isabeau Prémont-Schwarz, Hector
Palacios Verdes, Pierre-André Noël, Nicolas Chapados, Blake Richards, and Guillaume Lajoie for
helpful discussions.
References
Bengio, Y. (2012). Deep learning of representations for unsupervised and transfer learning. In
Proceedings of ICML workshop on unsupervised and transfer learning, pages 17 -- 36.
DiCarlo, J. J., Zoccolan, D., and Rust, N. C. (2012). How does the brain solve visual object
recognition? Neuron, 73(3):415 -- 434.
Doron, M., Chindemi, G., Muller, E., Markram, H., and Segev, I. (2017). Timed synaptic inhibition
shapes nmda spikes, influencing local dendritic processing and global i/o properties of cortical
neurons. Cell reports, 21(6):1550 -- 1561.
2https://medium.com/syncedreview/yann-lecun-cake-analogy-2-0-a361da560dae
4
Felleman, D. J. and Van, D. E. (1991). Distributed hierarchical processing in the primate cerebral
cortex. Cerebral cortex (New York, NY: 1991), 1(1):1 -- 47.
Fukushima, K. (1980). Neocognitron: A self-organizing neural network model for a mechanism of
pattern recognition unaffected by shift in position. Biological cybernetics, 36(4):193 -- 202.
Graupner, M. and Brunel, N. (2010). Mechanisms of induction and maintenance of spike-timing
dependent plasticity in biophysical synapse models. Frontiers in computational neuroscience,
4:136.
Guerguiev, J., Lillicrap, T. P., and Richards, B. A. (2017). Towards deep learning with segregated
dendrites. ELife, 6:e22901.
Holtmaat, A. and Svoboda, K. (2009). Experience-dependent structural synaptic plasticity in the
mammalian brain. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 10(9):647.
Jacobs, W. W. and Parker, L. N. (1910). The monkey's paw: A Story in Three Scenes. Samuel French,
Inc.
Kar, K., Kubilius, J., Schmidt, K., Issa, E. B., and DiCarlo, J. J. (2019). Evidence that recurrent
circuits are critical to the ventral stream's execution of core object recognition behavior. Nature
neuroscience, 22(6):974.
Karnani, M. M., Jackson, J., Ayzenshtat, I., Tucciarone, J., Manoocheri, K., Snider, W. G., and Yuste,
R. (2016). Cooperative subnetworks of molecularly similar interneurons in mouse neocortex.
Neuron, 90(1):86 -- 100.
Kastellakis, G., Cai, D. J., Mednick, S. C., Silva, A. J., and Poirazi, P. (2015). Synaptic clustering
within dendrites: an emerging theory of memory formation. Progress in neurobiology, 126:19 -- 35.
Larkum, M. E., Zhu, J. J., and Sakmann, B. (1999). A new cellular mechanism for coupling inputs
arriving at different cortical layers. Nature, 398(6725):338.
Lehman, J., Clune, J., Misevic, D., Adami, C., Altenberg, L., Beaulieu, J., Bentley, P. J., Bernard, S.,
Beslon, G., Bryson, D. M., et al. (2018). The surprising creativity of digital evolution: A collection
of anecdotes from the evolutionary computation and artificial life research communities. arXiv
preprint arXiv:1803.03453.
Moosavi-Dezfooli, S.-M., Fawzi, A., and Frossard, P. (2016). Deepfool: a simple and accurate
method to fool deep neural networks. In Proceedings of the IEEE conference on computer vision
and pattern recognition, pages 2574 -- 2582.
Murayama, M., Pérez-Garci, E., Nevian, T., Bock, T., Senn, W., and Larkum, M. E. (2009). Dendritic
encoding of sensory stimuli controlled by deep cortical interneurons. Nature, 457(7233):1137.
Poirazi, P. and Mel, B. W. (2001). Impact of active dendrites and structural plasticity on the memory
capacity of neural tissue. Neuron, 29(3):779 -- 796.
Rao, R. P. and Ballard, D. H. (1999). Predictive coding in the visual cortex: a functional interpretation
of some extra-classical receptive-field effects. Nature neuroscience, 2(1):79.
Reimann, M. W., Nolte, M., Scolamiero, M., Turner, K., Perin, R., Chindemi, G., Dłotko, P., Levi, R.,
Hess, K., and Markram, H. (2017). Cliques of neurons bound into cavities provide a missing link
between structure and function. Frontiers in computational neuroscience, 11:48.
Richards, B. A., Lillicrap, T. P., Beaudoin, P., Bengio, Y., Bogacz, R., Christensen, A., Clopath, C.,
Ponte Costa, R., De Berker, A., Ganguli, S., Gillon, C. J., Hafner, D., Kepecs, A., Kriegeskorte,
N., Latham, P., Lindsay, G. W., Miller, K. D., Naud, R., Pack, C. C., Poirazi, P., Roelfsema, P.,
Sacramento, J., Saxe, A., Scellier, B., Schapiro, A. C., Senn, W., Wayne, G., Yamins, D., Zenke, F.,
Zylberberg, J., Therien, D., and Kording, K. P. (2019). A deep learning framework for neuroscience.
Nature Neuroscience, 22:1761 -- 1770.
Rumelhart, D. E. and Zipser, D. (1985). Feature discovery by competitive learning. Cognitive science,
9(1):75 -- 112.
5
Sacramento, J., Costa, R. P., Bengio, Y., and Senn, W. (2018). Dendritic cortical microcircuits
In Advances in Neural Information Processing
approximate the backpropagation algorithm.
Systems, pages 8721 -- 8732.
Schiller, J., Major, G., Koester, H. J., and Schiller, Y. (2000). Nmda spikes in basal dendrites of
cortical pyramidal neurons. Nature, 404(6775):285.
Silberberg, G. and Markram, H. (2007). Disynaptic inhibition between neocortical pyramidal cells
mediated by martinotti cells. Neuron, 53(5):735 -- 746.
Wilson, D. E., Whitney, D. E., Scholl, B., and Fitzpatrick, D. (2016). Orientation selectivity and the
functional clustering of synaptic inputs in primary visual cortex. Nature neuroscience, 19(8):1003.
Yamins, D. L. and DiCarlo, J. J. (2016). Using goal-driven deep learning models to understand
sensory cortex. Nature neuroscience, 19(3):356.
Yamins, D. L., Hong, H., Cadieu, C. F., Solomon, E. A., Seibert, D., and DiCarlo, J. J. (2014).
Performance-optimized hierarchical models predict neural responses in higher visual cortex.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111(23):8619 -- 8624.
6
|
1707.02365 | 3 | 1707 | 2018-04-12T16:14:19 | The quest for identifiability in human functional connectomes | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | The evaluation of the individual 'fingerprint' of a human functional connectome (FC) is becoming a promising avenue for neuroscientific research, due to its enormous potential inherent to drawing single subject inferences from functional connectivity profiles. Here we show that the individual fingerprint of a human functional connectome can be maximized from a reconstruction procedure based on group-wise decomposition in a finite number of brain connectivity modes. We use data from the Human Connectome Project to demonstrate that the optimal reconstruction of the individual FCs through connectivity eigenmodes maximizes subject identifiability across resting-state and all seven tasks evaluated. The identifiability of the optimally reconstructed individual connectivity profiles increases both at the global and edgewise level, also when the reconstruction is imposed on additional functional data of the subjects. Furthermore, reconstructed FC data provide more robust associations with task-behavioral measurements. Finally, we extend this approach to also map the most task-sensitive functional connections. Results show that is possible to maximize individual fingerprinting in the functional connectivity domain regardless of the task, a crucial next step in the area of brain connectivity towards individualized connectomics. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | The quest for identifiability in human functional connectomes
Enrico Amico1,2 and Joaquín Goñi 1,2,3,*
1 School of Industrial Engineering, Purdue University, West-Lafayette, IN, USA
2 Purdue Institute for Integrative Neuroscience, Purdue University, West-Lafayette, IN, USA
3 Weldon School of Biomedical Engineering, Purdue University, West-Lafayette, IN, USA
* Correspondence: [email protected]
Keywords: functional connectome, individual fingerprint, human brain, brain
networks, brain connectivity
Abstract
The evaluation of the individual "fingerprint" of a human functional connectome (FC) is
becoming a promising avenue for neuroscientific research, due to its enormous potential
inherent to drawing single subject inferences from functional connectivity profiles. Here we
show that the individual fingerprint of a human functional connectome can be maximized from
a reconstruction procedure based on group-wise decomposition in a finite number of brain
connectivity modes. We use data from the Human Connectome Project to demonstrate that
the optimal reconstruction of the individual FCs through connectivity eigenmodes maximizes
subject identifiability across resting-state and all seven tasks evaluated. The identifiability of
the optimally reconstructed individual connectivity profiles increases both at the global and
edgewise level, also when the reconstruction is imposed on additional functional data of the
subjects. Furthermore, reconstructed FC data provide more robust associations with task-
behavioral measurements. Finally, we extend this approach to also map the most task-
sensitive functional connections. Results show that is possible to maximize individual
fingerprinting in the functional connectivity domain regardless of the task, a crucial next step
in the area of brain connectivity towards individualized connectomics.
Introduction
The explosion of publicly available neuroimaging datasets in the last years have provided an
ideal benchmark for mapping functional and structural connections in the human brain. At the
same time, quantitative analysis of connectivity patterns based on network science have
become more commonly used to study the brain as a network 1, giving rise to the area of
research so called Brain Connectomics 2,3. The analyses of functional and structural brain
connectivity patterns have allowed researchers to make inferences on the different
organization of brain networks in clinical and healthy populations, and to identify changes in
these cohorts, usually by testing differences across groups 4,5. Until recently, brain
connectivity studies have generally overlooked the existing connectivity heterogeneity within
each group, for several reasons. The group average procedure eases comparisons between
different populations and has the benefit of providing more representative connectivity
1
patterns. However, this comes at the cost of ignoring the potentially precious information
provided by subject level, i.e. individual , connectomes.
Recent work on fMRI 6–9 and EEG fingerprinting 10 has paved the way to the new promising
avenue of detecting individual differences through brain connectivity features. They showed
that the individual functional connectivity (FC) profiles estimated from functional resonance
magnetic imaging (fMRI) data can be seen as a "fingerprint" of the subject, which indeed may
be used to identify a given individual in a set of functional connectivity profiles from a
population.
The capacity of functional connectivity profiles to identify subjects goes along with the concept
of reproducibility of test-retest experiments 6. The rationale behind is that the higher the
accuracy of the functional connectivity on each fMRI session and subject, the better will be
the identifiability of individual subjects. Several aspects may have an impact on the quality,
and hence on the identifiability of the data. This includes the characteristics of the fMRI
sequence (such as its spatial and temporal resolution 11), the processing of the fMRI data
(including how to handle head motion and other artifacts 12,13 and the statistical approach used
to obtain pairwise region-to-region functional connectivity from voxel-level time-series 4,14. All
the aspects listed above refer to efforts on increasing the reliability of functional connectivity
on individual fMRI sessions 9,13,15. Indeed, all of them could be applied by acquiring just one
fMRI session of one subject. In the lack of gold-standards in brain connectivity, it is important
to investigate the reliability of connectome fingerprinting 7,9,15 by procedures that gradually
assess the data from common connectivity patterns present along the cohort to individual
connectivity patterns.
The assessment of individual fingerprinting based on functional connectivity could be
presented as a decomposition methodology. In this case, one could think of an approach that
obtains common connectivity patterns highly present in the cohort, individual patterns present
in certain subjects, and even in only certain individual sessions. Such a framework would
allow us to decipher between what connectivity patterns are common in a cohort (human
brain functional traits), what connectivity traits are unique of different individuals (inter-subject
variability) and what are session-dependent (within-subject variability) or beyond, i.e. spurious
patterns from the standpoint of individual fingerprinting. Interestingly, this conceptual
framework would allow for individual reconstruction of functional connectomes based on a
subset of the aforementioned traits.
Here we propose a group-level framework to assess and maximize the individual
fingerprinting of functional connectomes based on a principal component analysis (PCA)
decomposition and subsequent individual reconstruction. We show that the uniqueness of
each individual connectivity profile can be reconstructed through an optimal finite linear
combination of orthogonal principal components (or eigenmodes) in the connectivity domain,
hence here denominated brain connectivity modes. These connectivity modes improve the
identification of each individual's functional architecture both at the whole-brain and local sub-
network level. We evaluate this methodology on 100 unrelated subjects of the Human
Connectome Project (HCP), for test-retest data including resting-state and 7 different task-
fMRI (see Methods).
The impact of the decomposition into connectivity modes and subsequent reconstruction of
FC patterns is assessed in different scenarios. For all 7 fMRI tasks and resting-state, we find
2
the existence of optimal reconstructions that maximize identifiability of functional
connectomes. At those optimal solutions, edgewise identifiability as measured by intra-class-
correlation is largely enhanced. The possible influence of motion (absolute frame
displacement per session) in identifiability is assessed and found to be significant for all fMRI
tasks but not for resting-state. We propose a generalization of this framework for cross-
sectional data based on splitting the fMRI time-series into two halves and evaluate it on all
four resting-state sessions. We assess the impact of different lengths of fMRI runs on
identifiability. We also find that optimal PCA reconstruction leads to more robust associations
to task-related behavioral measurements across visits (test-retest). Finally, we map task-
specific functional edges as measured by intra-class correlation and identify which within and
between functional networks (FNs) are the most task-specific.
We conclude by discussing the interpretation of the concept of brain connectivity modes, or
eigenmodes in the functional connectivity domain. We make considerations on possible
driving factors (mainly motion and task performance) that may limit the maximization of
identifiability. Finally, we discuss the limitations of our study and future work and potential
applications of this methodology.
Materials and Methods
Dataset. The fMRI and behavioral dataset used in this work is from the Human Connectome
Project (HCP, http://www.humanconnectome.org/), Release Q3.
Data availability. The dataset analyzed during the current study, i.e. the Human Connectome
Project, Release Q3, is
available in the Human Connectome Project repository
(http://www.humanconnectome.org/). The processed functional connectomes obtained from
this data and used for the current study are available from the corresponding author on
reasonable request. Below follows the full description of the acquisition protocol and
processing steps.
tasks were
HCP data. We assessed the 100 unrelated subjects (54 females, 46 males, mean age = 29.1
± 3.7 years) as provided at the HCP 900 subjects data release 16,17. This subset of subjects
provided by HCP ensures that they are not family relatives. This criterion was crucial to
exclude the need of family-structure co-variables in our analyses as well as possible
identifiability confounds. Per HCP protocol, all subjects gave written informed consent to the
Human Connectome Project consortium. The fMRI resting-state runs (HCP filenames:
rfMRI_REST1 and rfMRI_REST2) were acquired in separate sessions on two different days,
with two different acquisitions (left to right or LR and right to left or RL) per day 18,19. The seven
fMRI
relational
(tfMRI_RELATIONAL), social (tfMRI_SOCIAL), working memory (tfMRI_WM), motor
(tfMRI_MOTOR), language (tfMRI_LANGUAGE, including both a story-listening and
arithmetic task) and emotion (tfMRI_EMOTION). The working memory, gambling and motor
task were acquired on the first day, and the other tasks were acquired on the second day 17,20.
The HCP scanning protocol was approved by the local Institutional Review Board at
Washington University in St. Louis. All experiments were performed in accordance with
relevant guidelines and regulations. For all sessions, data from both the left-right (LR) and
right-left (RL) phase-encoding runs were used to calculate connectivity matrices. Data
acquisitions for each subject and for each task were tagged as test and retest (also referred
(tfMRI_GAMBLING),
gambling
the
following:
3
as visits). In order to avoid confounds between test-retest and phase encoding, runs were
evenly distributed on test-retest along the subjects. Hence, for half of the subjects LR was
used as test and RL as retest and for the other half RL was used as test and LR as retest.
This operation was done for all 7 fMRI tasks. For the case of resting-state, this procedure was
done for both REST1 and REST2 separately. Full details on the HCP dataset have been
published previously 17–19.
Brain atlas. We employed a cortical parcellation into 360 brain regions as recently proposed
by Glasser et al. 21. For completeness, 14 sub-cortical regions were added, as provided by the
HCP release (filename "Atlas_ROI2.nii.gz"). To do so, this file was converted from NIFTI to
18,22
CIFTI
(http://www.humanconnectome.org/software/connectome-workbench.html, command -cifti-
create-label)
the HCP workbench
software
by
using
format
HCP preprocessing: functional data. The HCP functional preprocessing pipeline 18,19was
used for the employed dataset. This pipeline included artifact removal, motion correction and
registration to standard space. Full details on the pipeline can be found in 18,19. The main steps
were: spatial ("minimal") pre-processing, in both volumetric and grayordinate forms (i.e.,
where brain locations are stored as surface vertices 19); weak highpass temporal filtering (>
2000s full width at half maximum) applied to both forms, achieving slow drift removal.
MELODIC ICA 23 applied to volumetric data; artifact components identified using FIX 24.
Artifacts and motion-related time courses were regressed out (i.e. the 6 rigid-body parameter
time-series, their backwards-looking temporal derivatives, plus all 12 resulting regressors
squared) of both volumetric and grayordinate data 19.
For the resting-state fMRI data, we also added the following steps: global gray matter signal
was regressed out of the voxel time courses 13; a bandpass first-order Butterworth filter in
forward and reverse directions [0.001 Hz, 0.08 Hz] 13 was applied (Matlab functions butter and
filtfilt); the voxel time courses were z-scored and then averaged per brain region, excluding
outlier time points outside of 3 standard deviation from the mean, using the workbench
software 22 ( workbench command -cifti-parcellate ). For task fMRI data, we applied the same
above mentioned steps except the bandpass filter, since it is still unclear the connection
between different tasks and optimal frequency ranges 25.
Pearson correlation coefficients between pairs of nodal time courses were calculated
(MATLAB command corr), resulting in a symmetric connectivity matrix for each fMRI session
of each subject. Functional connectivity matrices were kept in its signed weighted form, hence
neither thresholded nor binarized. Finally, the resulting individual functional connectivity
matrices were ordered (rows and columns) according to 7 functional cortical sub-networks
(FNs) as proposed by Yeo and colleagues 26. For completeness, an 8th sub-network including
the 14 HCP sub-cortical regions was added (as analogously done in recent paper 27).
PCA reconstruction of the individual connectivity profiles
Principal component analysis (PCA) is a statistical procedure 28that transforms a set of
observations of possibly correlated variables into a set of values of linearly uncorrelated
4
variables called principal components (or sometimes, principal modes of variation), ranked in
descending order of explained variance of the initial data. PCA has been widely used for
exploratory analysis of the underlying structure of data in many areas of science, from pattern
recognition in genetics 29 , to denoising and compression in image processing 30, and recently
to dynamic functional connectivity patterns 31.
In this study we explored the use of PCA (MATLAB command pca) in the connectivity domain
for improving the individual fingerprint in functional connectomes from a group-level
perspective. The procedure starts by matching the number of principal components included
with the number of functional connectomes of the dataset. By definition, this PCA-based
decomposition accounts for 100% of the variance in the data. As mentioned above,
components are ranked according to explained variance in descending order. The next step
consists of the reconstruction of the individual functional connectomes as a function of the
number of components included (see methodological scheme at Fig. 1). The rationale behind
this analysis is that high-variance components might carry cohort-level functional connectivity
information, whereas lower-variance components might carry subject-level functional
connectivity information and, finally, lowest-variance components might carry noisy or
artifactual connectivity information. By doing this iterative fine-grained exploration of number
of components used, we are able to identify in a data-driven fashion what are the boundaries
for group-level, individual-level, and artifactual-level components. That is, once extracted the
main connectivity-based principal components (PCs), each individual connectivity profile is
reconstructed based on its mean and the linear combination of the chosen PCs (see Fig. 1).
For 16 fMRI sessions (REST1 and 7 fMRI-tasks, with test-retest for each), we explored the
property of individual fingerprinting for different levels of reconstruction based on the number
of ranked components used. We kept the 2 additional fMRI runs from REST2 as validation
set. In the next section we will define the function employed for evaluating the level of
individual fingerprint at any reconstruction level.
Figure 1. Workflow scheme of the group-level principal component analysis (PCA) reconstruction
procedure of individual functional connectomes (FC). The upper triangular of each functional connectivity
matrix (two FCs per subject, test-retest) is vectorized and added to a matrix where columns are sessions and
rows are their vectorized functional connectivity patterns. Data are first centered: this is obtained by subtracting
5
the mean µk from each column (where k goes from 1 to N subjects). Second, the PCA algorithm extracts the M
principal components (i.e. the functional connectivity modes) associated to the whole population and their
relative weights across subjects. The M orthogonal connectivity modes are then used to reconstruct back the FC
of each subject (µk
is added back to the data). Colorbars indicate positive (yellow) to negative (blue) connectivity
values: Pearson's correlation coefficient in the case of individual FC matrices (left and right sides of scheme),
and unitless connectivity weights in the case of PCA FC-modes. For ease of visualization, the FC-modes
colorbar ranges from 5th to 95th percentile of the distribution of values.
Differential identifiability quality function
The maximization of a functional connectome fingerprint relies on the assumption that the
connectivity profiles should be, overall, more similar between visits or sessions of the same
subject than between different subjects. Finn et al. 6 showed that, to a great extent, it is
possible to robustly identify the functional connectome of a subject "target" from a sample
database of FCs, simply by computing the spatial (Pearson) correlation of the target FC
against the database ones. For identification, they used a set of connectivity matrices from
one session for the database and connectivity matrices from a second session acquired on a
different day as the target set. Then, given a query connectivity matrix from the target set,
they computed the correlations between this matrix and all the connectivity matrices in the
database. Finally, for each query, the predicted identity was picked as the one with the highest
correlation coefficient, and assigned a score of 1 if the predicted identity matched the true
identity, and a score of 0 otherwise. The success rate of this identification procedure was
above 90% for resting-state sessions, and ranged between 54% and 87% when including
task-task and task-rest sessions 6.
In order to evaluate our framework and the identifiability capability as a continuum, we
generalized the above mentioned binary score system 6 to a more continuous score on the
level of individual fingerprinting present on a set of test-retest functional connectomes. Hence
we introduce the concept of "level of identifiability" on a set of functional connectomes.
Let A be the "identifiability matrix", i.e. the matrix of correlations (square, non symmetric)
between the subjects' FCs test and retest. The dimension of A is N2, where N is the number of
subjects in the database. Let Iself=<aii> represent the average of the main diagonal elements
of A, which consist of the Pearson correlation values between visits of same subjects: from
now on, we will refer to this quantity as self-identifiability or I self. Similarly, let Iothers=<aij> define
the average of the off-diagonal elements of matrix A, i.e. the correlation between visits of
different subjects. Then we define the differential identifiability (Idiff) of the population as the
difference between both terms:
I diff = ( I self − I others) ∗ 100 ,
i≠ j
(1)
which quantifies the difference between the average within-subject FCs similarity and the
average between-subjects FCs similarity.
The higher the value of Idiff, the higher the individual fingerprint overall along the population.
By defining Idiff, the optimization problem of differential identifiability is then reduced to
maximizing Idiff. This consists of exploring within a range of number of components (M), and
of finding the optimal number of components, m*, in the PCA decomposition that provides the
maximum value of Idiff, namely Idiff*, for which:
6
I diff * = arg max
m ∈ M
I diff (m)
(2)
Influence of the number of fMRI volumes on identifiability
The effect of scan duration on individual measurements of functional connectivity has been
well documented 15,32–34 and might be considered as a potential confound for the identifiability
analysis presented here. We assessed, for REST1, the impact of the number of fMRI volumes
in the PCA reconstruction and subsequent identifiability. To do so, we tested on shortening the
session to different session-lengths corresponding to the following numbers of fMRI volumes:
5, 10, 25, 50, 100 and up to 1,200 in steps of 100. For each number of fMRI volumes, a full
exploration of PCA reconstruction was run in order to obtain optimal number of components
and subsequent identifiability score. This allowed us to assess the impact of PCA optimal
reconstruction on different number of fMRI volumes.
Edgewise subject identifiability and edgewise task identifiability
The function defined earlier provides a way to quantify the differential identifiability at a whole-
network level. We also quantified the edgewise subject identifiability by using intraclass
correlation 35,36(ICC). ICC is a widely used measure in statistics, normally to assess the
percent of agreement between units (or ratings/scores) of different groups (or raters/judges)
37. It describes how strongly units in the same group resemble each other. The stronger the
agreement, the higher its ICC value. We used ICC to quantify to which extent the connectivity
value of an edge (functional connectivity value between two brain regions) could separate
within and between subjects. In other words, the higher the ICC, the higher the identifiability
of the connectivity edge.
Following the same rationale, one can also compute edgewise ICC when tasks are "raters"
and "scores" are given by subjects. In this case, the higher the ICC, the more separable the
different tasks across subjects and consequently the higher the task identifiability of the
connectivity edge.
Influence of motion regressors on self identifiability
Finally, we tested if optimal self identifiability (i.e. same subject's FC similarity) after PCA
reconstruction was linked to motion estimators. HCP data collection provides an estimate of
average absolute
file name
"Movement_AbsoluteRMS_mean.txt") and frame-to-frame displacement (file name
"Movement_RelativeRMS_mean.txt") for each run and fMRI session. We evaluated linear
and log10-linear trends between self identifiability values after reconstruction and subject's
motion displacement values (maximum between the two runs).
displacement
frame,
from
(i.e.
initial
Robustness in the association of functional connectivity with task-related scores
before and after optimal PCA reconstruction.
7
the
time and performance accuracy across
For each task fMRI session (test and retest, for both original and reconstructed functional
connectomes), we computed the corresponding association matrices with the average
response
task (file pattern
{TASK_name}_stats.txt). To do so, the edgewise (across subjects) Pearson's correlation
between functional connectivity and the task feature was computed, producing a square
correlation matrix of the same size of an FC matrix. Correlations in association matrices
denote the correlation between functional connectivity values between two regions across
subjects and a task feature (in our case, response time and accuracy) Note that we excluded
the MOTOR task (information was not available) and we only computed average response
time in those tasks where accuracy was not clearly defined (i.e. SOCIAL and GAMBLING
tasks). For each task-measurement, this produced four association matrices (based on
original and reconstructed FC test, based on original and reconstructed FC retest). Each
association matrix was filtered based on two steps. First, only significant correlations were
kept (p<0.01) and second, only the functional associations forming the giant component were
kept (as analogously done in Network Based Statistics or NBS, 38). We measure the
robustness of the filtered association matrices by obtaining their intersection between test and
retest, for the original and the reconstructed data. After this procedure, level of robust
associations is measured by the remaining number of functional edges, and of nodes. We
also tested the significance of these numbers over null distributions created by randomly
shuffling the task-measures 1,000 times, and computing the same two quantities ( i.e. the
overlapping number of nodes and number of edges of the giant component across the two
visits). This procedure is similar to the random shuffling of group-membership done in NBS 38.
Influence of PCA reconstruction on functional connectome-based predictive modeling
Next, we evaluated the predictability of fluid intelligence (gF, mean = 16.2 ± 4.6) based on
resting-state, as analogously done by Finn et al. 6. We used connectome-based predictive
modeling (CPM, 39) to assess whether the predictability of fluid intelligence increases after
optimal PCA reconstruction. CPM takes as input data connectivity matrices (FC here) and a
vector of behavioral measures (gF here). Validation of predictability was based on leave-one-
out cross-validation 6. Iteratively, edges of all subjects except one are associated to the
behavioral measure using Pearson's correlation. Significant edges (p<0.01) with positive
correlation with behavior are then summed into a single subject value (strength). A linear
predictive model is then fitted to predict behavior (dependent variable) from strength values
(independent variable). Finally, the strength of the subject left out is used on the linear model
to obtain the corresponding predicted behavioral score 6,39.
We used REST1-AVG (i.e. average FCs from runs 1 and 2 of day 1) to test gF predictability
before and after optimal PCA reconstruction. Edges with positive significant correlations with
gF (p<0.01) were first selected. Significant edges were sorted based on their correlation with
gF, weighted by their corresponding intraclass correlation (see Figure 3B1). Including ICC
ensures the use of edges with a high individual fingerprint and hence allows for a better
generalization of the predictive model. Finally, we built a predictive model in an additive
fashion, by adding the most important 5, 10 up to the best 100 edges in steps of 5. At every
step, gF predictability (i.e. the correlation between predicted and observed gF values) was
computed before and after reconstruction.
8
Results
The dataset used for this study consisted of functional data from the 100 unrelated subjects
in the Q3 release of the HCP 16,17. For each subject, we estimated 18 functional connectivity
matrices: 4 corresponding to resting-state ( conventionally named REST1 test-retest and
REST2 test-retest, see Methods), 14 corresponding to each of the 7 tasks (test-retest, where
{TASK_NAME}_LR and {TASK_NAME}_RL are evenly distributed; see Methods). The
multimodal parcellation used here, as proposed by Glasser et al. 21, includes 360 cortical brain
regions. We added 14 subcortical regions, hence producing functional connectome matrices
(square, symmetric) of 374 x 374 (see Methods for details).
For each task (including resting-state), individual functional connectomes (including two visits,
test-retest, per subject) were reconstructed based on PCA by iteratively including different
number of components. This procedure can be summarized as follows (Fig. 1): first, the
upper triangular part of each individual functional connectivity matrix was vectorized and
added to a matrix where columns are the subjects and rows are their full connectivity pattern;
second, the PCA algorithm extracted the principal components (PCs) associated to the whole
population; third, these components were projected back in the individual subjects' space,
leading to a "reconstructed" version of each original connectivity profiles (Fig. 1).
From the test-retest pool of 100 unrelated subjects (total of 200 FC matrices per task and 200
per resting-state, for this experiment only the REST1 test-retest FCs were considered), a
bootstrap technique was used to accurately estimate I diff for each value m of number of
components, m={2,5,10:10:160}. This was meant to avoid results driven by a small subset of
the population. To do so, 100 random samples comprising the test-retest pairs of 80 subjects
(total of 160 FC matrices) were performed for each value of m.
9
Figure 2. Percent difference of the differential identifiability (Idiff) as a function of the number of PCA
components used for reconstruction in resting-state and 7 fMRI tasks. Plots show, for each task, the
differential identifiability as a function of the number of PCA components used for reconstruction (evaluated at 2,
5, and 10 to 160 components in steps of 10). Red line denotes I diff for the original FCs, whereas blue line with
circles denotes the identifiability for reconstructed FCs based on the different number of components sampled.
For each subplot, the optimal number of components that maximizes I diff (m*) and the corresponding explained
variance (R2) are shown. The PCA reconstruction was tested on the resting state (REST) and 7 different task
sessions provided by the HCP data (EMOTION, GAMBLING, LANGUAGE, MOTOR, RELATIONAL, SOCIAL,
WORKING MEMORY, see Methods for details). To test the stability of the method, Idiff was evaluated over 100
different runs. At each run, 80 subjects were randomly sampled from the HCP data pool of 100 unrelated
subjects, 2 sessions for a total of 160 FCs at every run). The standard deviation of I diff (not shown in the plots)
across runs was always lower than 0.8 %, for all the sessions considered, for original and reconstructed data.
FC differential identifiability increases at optimal PCA reconstruction
For each number m of components retained for reconstruction, we tested the differential
identifiability (Idiff) (see Methods) of the reconstructed connectomes with respect to the
original ones, based on the following assumption: the connectivity profiles should be, overall,
more similar between visits of the same subjects than between different subjects. For
simplicity, in the main text we will show results for resting-state (REST) and for the MOTOR
task . Results for all the other six tasks are shown in Fig. S1 and Fig. S2. For all seven tasks
and for resting-state, the PCA reconstructed functional connectomes outperformed the
original ones in terms of Idiff for a wide range of m (Fig. 2, Fig. S1 and Fig. S2). Each condition
shows a slightly different optimal m* for maximizing I diff (e.g. m*=80 PCs for resting-state,
m*=70 for the MOTOR task, Fig. 2). For all cases, the variance of the functional data kept in
the reconstruction was between 72% and 89%. We also compared original and optimally
reconstructed FC data by using identification rate (as proposed by 6). As shown in Fig. S4, we
10
found that identification rate was higher after optimal reconstruction for all fMRI tasks and for
resting-state. When assessing identifiability rates on REST1-AVG (two-runs of day 1) and
REST2-AVG (two-runs of day 2), even higher rates were obtained at the optimal PCA
reconstruction. In particular, when REST1-AVG was the target, identifiability rate increased
from 94% to 98%, whereas when REST2-AVG was the target it increased from 93% to 97%.
By definition, Idiff optimization is constrained to the availability of test-retest fMRI sessions,
which is not common in many acquired fMRI experiments, especially in cross-sectional
assessments of clinical populations. To cover the necessity of assessing individual
fingerprinting in these scenarios, we computed "two-halves" individual FCs by splitting each of
the 4 resting state sessions in two parts (~600 fMRI volumes each). We then evaluated I diff
before and after reconstruction, with "test-retest" sessions now being the first and the second
part of the same fMRI acquisition. Again, the PCA reconstructed functional connectomes keep
outperforming the original ones for a wide range of m (see Fig. S3). We next explored further
properties of the optimal PCA reconstruction for REST and the MOTOR task.
Figure 3. Evaluation and validation of PCA reconstruction on resting-state functional connectomes
(FCs) at the optimal point (m* = 80). The resting FCs of 80 subjects were reconstructed by using group-level
PCA. The optimal number of PCA components was 80 (see Fig. 2). Results shown correspond to a single run.
The PCA reconstruction was first evaluated on the REST1 (test and retest, training set, left panel). The FC-
modes extracted from the training set were then used to reconstruct two different resting state sessions, namely
11
REST2 test and retest (here used as a test set, right panel). A1-A2) From left to right: the group averaged FC of
the original data; the group averaged FC of the reconstructed data; the scatter plot edge by edge of the
reconstructed group averaged FC (y axis) vs original group averaged FC (x axis). B1-B2) From left to right: the
intra-class correlation (ICC), computed over each FC edge, for the original data; the edgewise ICC for the
reconstructed data; the scatter plot edge by edge of the reconstructed ICC values (y axis) vs original ICC values
(x axis). The inset reports the percentage of edges where ICC increased after reconstruction (black dots on top
of the red dashed line) from those that did not (black dots below of the red line). C1-C2) From left to right:
Identifiability matrix (i.e. Pearson's correlation coefficient between functional profiles across subjects and
sessions, see Methods) of the original data; identifiability matrix of the reconstructed data; violin plot of the "self
identifiability" (i.e. the main diagonal of the identifiability matrix) distribution across the 80 subjects, for original
(Orig, red) and reconstructed (Recon, blue). The solid black lines depict the mean value of the distribution; the
dashed black lines the 5 and 95 percentiles. Note that, as specified by the inset, the self identifiability of each
subject always improves after PCA reconstruction, both for the training and test set.
Reconstructed Functional connectomes: resting state
For the REST data, we tested the goodness of this method at the optimal PCA reconstruction
point with respect to the original FCs in three different ways: 1) by comparing the group
average functional connectomes before and after optimal PCA reconstruction; 2) by
computing the edgewise intraclass correlation (ICC, i.e. how good a single edge can separate
different subjects, see Methods), before and after optimal PCA reconstruction; 3) by
evaluating Idiff (as described in Methods), before and after optimal PCA reconstruction.
The 4 resting-state fMRI acquisitions per HCP subject available allowed us to perform
evaluation and validation of our methodology as follows: the optimal PCA reconstruction was
first evaluated on the "training set" consisting of REST 1 (Fig. 3, left panel), at the optimal
number of 80 PCA components (as depicted in Fig. 2). The 80 FC-modes extracted from the
training set were then used as the "orthogonal connectivity basis" through which reconstruct
the two other FCs of the same subjects, i.e REST2 (Fig. 3, right panel).
Both for training and validation sets, the optimal PCA reconstruction preserves the main
characteristics of the functional connectomes (the group averaged functional connectomes
before and after reconstruction are almost identical, Fig. 3 A1, A2). Nonetheless, the
edgewise ICC largely increase after optimal reconstruction for almost all edges (99%), both in
the training and test cases (Fig. 3 B1, B2). In accordance with results shown in Fig.2, the self
identifiability of the subjects' FCs after reconstruction increases on all subjects (Fig. 3 C1,
C2).
Reconstructed Functional connectomes: motor task
Evaluation of the proposed methodology was also performed for all seven tasks available in
the HCP dataset. We show as example results for the MOTOR task at the optimal
reconstruction (m*= 70, Fig. 4). Also, Fig. S2 summarizes results for all the other tasks. Even
in this case the reconstructed group average FC resembles the original one almost perfectly
(Fig. 3A); edgewise ICC improves after optimal reconstruction on 96% of the functional edges
(Fig. 3B); self identifiability increases after reconstruction on all subjects (Fig. 3C), with some
subjects showing a larger increase than others (as shown by the violin plot distributions of self
identifiability after reconstruction, Fig. 3C).
12
Figure 4. Evaluation of optimal PCA reconstruction (m* = 70) on motor task-based functional
connectomes (FCs) . The motor task-based FCs of 80 subjects were reconstructed at the optimal number of
PCA components (i.e. 70, see Fig.2), for 1 single run. The PCA reconstruction was evaluated on the using the
two runs available per subject. A1) From left to right: the group averaged FC of the original data; the group
averaged FC of the reconstructed data; the scatter plot edge by edge of the reconstructed group averaged FC (y
axis) vs original group averaged FC (x axis). B1) From left to right: the intra-class correlation (ICC), computed
over each FC edge, for the original data; the edgewise ICC for the reconstructed data; the scatter plot edge by
edge of the reconstructed ICC values (y axis) vs original ICC values(x axis). The inset reports the percentage of
edges where ICC increased after reconstruction (black dots on top of the red dashed line) from those that did not
(black dots below of the red line). C1) From left to right: Identifiability matrix (i.e. the Pearson's correlation
between functional profiles between subjects and sessions, see Methods) of the original data; identifiability
matrix of the reconstructed data; violin plot of the "self identifiability"(i.e. the main diagonal of the identifiability
matrix) distribution across the 80 subjects, for original (Orig, red) and reconstructed (Recon, blue). The solid
black lines depict the mean value of the distribution; the dashed black lines the 5 and 95 percentiles. Note that
self identifiability of each subject always improves after PCA reconstruction.
Effect of the number of time frames on differential identifiability
Next, we evaluated the impact of the length of the fMRI session on the reconstruction of
functional connectomes. We estimated the trend of the differential identifiability on the REST1
session, when including different number of fMRI volumes in the FC estimation, and
compared the curve obtained after PCA reconstruction to the one obtained from the original
13
data (see Fig. 5). Results from this analysis can be interpreted in two ways: the PCA optimal
reconstruction always improves identifiability with respect to the original FC data. Remarkably,
the level of identifiability obtained originally by using the whole length of REST1 is
outperformed in the reconstructed data when only using 200 fMRI volumes (Fig. 5).
Figure 5. Optimal differential identifiability (Idiff) as a function of the number of fMRI volumes used for
reconstruction on REST1. Bottom: plot shows the optimal average Idiff across 100 runs (similarly to Fig. 2 and
Fig. S3, see Methods for details), as a function of the number of fMRI volumes (frames) used for FC evaluation
and subsequent reconstruction. Values tested are: 5, 10, 25, 50 frames, and from 100 to 1,200 frames in steps
of 100. Red line with circles denotes the average I diff for the original FCs (standard deviation across runs were
always < 0.4 % and are not shown in the plot), whereas blue line with circles denotes the identifiability for
reconstructed FCs based on the different number of fMRI volumes retained (blue vertical bars indicate standard
deviation across runs). Top: insets show the Idiff curves (blue line, reconstructed Idiff; red line, original Idiff; same as
Fig.2 and S3) per optimal number of PCA components (evaluated at 2, 5, and 10 to 160 components in steps of
10) for three different choices of number of fMRI frames retained (50, 500 and 1,000 fMRI volumes respectively).
The three vertical dashed black lines in bottom plot show the correspondent optimal I diff value for each of three
insets on top.
PCA reconstruction improves robustness and reproducibility of associations with
behavior
An important question regarding this approach is to what extent it increases the association of
the reconstructed connectomes with behavior and/or task performance. Ideally, improving the
identifiability of functional connectomes should increase the robustness and reproducibility of
the associations with behaviour. That is, if a functional connectivity subsystem is associated
14
with task performance in one experiment (test), one would expect it to be connected to it in a
repetition of the experiment (retest).
FC ORIGINAL
FC PCA RECONSTRUCTED
test ∩ retest
test ∩ retest
test ∩ retest
test ∩ retest
Task Name
Perf. Score
# edges (prctile) # nodes (prctile)
# edges (prctile) # nodes (prctile)
Emotion
Emotion
Gambling
Language
Language
Relational
Relational
Social
Accuracy
4 (66%)
Response Time
24 (96%)
Response Time
Accuracy
Response Time
Accuracy
6 (32%)
2 (32%)
10 (71%)
24 (92%)
Response Time
114 (99%)
Response Time
0 (%)
W. Memory
Accuracy
W. Memory
Response Time
28 (94%)
18 (85%)
4 (68%)
17 (95%)
5 (32%)
2 (32%)
8 (66%)
20 (94%)
48 (99%)
0 (%)
26 (96%)
13 (81%)
0 (0%)
96 (98%)
8 (26%)
26 (98%)
26 (83%)
110 (98%)
304 (99%)
6 (47%)
80 (98%)
36 (88%)
0 (0%)
47 (98%)
6 (24%)
21 (98%)
20 (82%)
75 (99%)
99 (99%)
6 (51%)
58 (99%)
31 (91%)
Table 1. Robustness in the association of functional connectivity with task-related scores before and
after optimal reconstruction. For each task, score and visit (test and retest), an association matrix correlating
the scores with all pairwise functional vectors is computed. Values are thresholded by statistical significance
(p<0.01) and the giant component of the thresholded association matrix is obtained. Finally, the intersection of
the giant components of test and retest is obtained and considered a robust association. Each row of the table
indicates the resulting robust association in terms of number of functional edges, number of nodes involved. This
procedure is repeated with the original FC data and with the optimally PCA reconstructed data. Percentile values
between parenthesis account for respective null models where the performance score is randomly shuffled (each
distribution is built upon 1,000 repetitions). Note how, with the exception of EMOTION with accuracy, the
reconstructed connectomes outperform the original ones across all tasks and scores.
Briefly, for each task-measurement, association matrices were obtained, filtered by
significance and by giant component. We measured the robustness of the filtered association
matrices by obtaining their intersection between both visits for the original and for the
reconstructed data. Robustness is measured by the remaining number of functional edges,
and of nodes. We also tested the significance of these numbers over null distributions (see
Methods for details). Results per task-measurement for original and reconstructed FC data
are reported in Table 1. Apart from one exception (EMOTION, accuracy), the optimally
reconstructed connectomes outperformed the original ones for robust associations across all
tasks in having more functional edges, more nodes (or brain regions) and in being in higher
percentiles with respect to their null models. Overall, these results indicate that PCA optimal
reconstruction displays more robust associations to task-related measurements across visits.
PCA reconstruction improves connectome-based predictive modeling of behavior
We assessed the impact of this approach on predictive modeling from FCs to behavior. Based
on connectome-based predictive modeling (CPM, 39), we tested fluid intelligence (gF)
predictability on REST1-AVG (see Methods for details), as analogously done by Finn et al. 6.
15
Fig. 6 shows predictability of gF for up to the top 100 most relevant edges (added iteratively),
sorted by correlation with gF (weighted by ICC) , for original and reconstructed connectomes.
Note how PCA reconstructed connectomes outperform the original in gF predictability at every
step of the curve (Fig. 6).
Figure 6: Predictive modeling of fluid intelligence before and after optimal PCA reconstruction. A)
predictability level of fluid intelligence (gF) from resting state FCs when selected up to the top 100 most
predictive edges. Blue curve represents the prediction obtained from reconstructed FCs (RECON), whereas red
curve is from original data (ORIG). B) Scatter plots of optimal predictions found. Top: observed versus predicted
gF values for RECON (blue circles, r=0.72); bottom: observed versus predicted gF values for ORIG (bottom, red
triangles, r=0.61).
Self identifiability in tasks correlates with motion displacement
Further inspection of self identifiability of subjects reveals differences, mainly between resting-
state and the fMRI tasks. The violin plot distributions of self identifiability values after
reconstruction for resting are unimodal, whereas task sessions display bimodal and
sometimes even trimodal shapes (Fig. 3C, Fig. S2). This suggests that subject's identifiability
might relate to the goodness of his test-retest FCs. That is, if one or more of the individual
sessions is highly compromised or corrupted (due to motion or other factors), it might become
very challenging to improve the similarity between the FCs of the same subject. Indeed, self
identifiability values after reconstruction for the task sessions negatively correlate with the
mean absolute motion displacement from the first fMRI frame (AbsoluteRMS, see Methods),
particularly with the maximum AbsoluteRMS between the two sessions (Fig. S5). That is, the
higher the presence of motion in at least one the sessions of the subject, the lower the subject
identifiability. Notably, the log-linear trend between identifiability and AbsoluteRMS is evident
across all the different tasks, but it is not present for the resting-state session (Fig. S5).
Moreover, no significant correlation between self identifiability and task response time nor
16
between identifiability and task accuracy (see Methods) was observed for any task (results
not shown).
Reconstructed Functional connectomes: edgewise subject/task identifiability
Finally, we tested the edgewise identifiability properties of the optimally reconstructed
functional connectomes, on all subjects and tasks, in two different ways. One, by computing
the edgewise subject identifiability over all tasks (i.e., intraclass correlation across subjects,
see Methods). In other words, identifying which specific set of functional connections can
separate between subjects regardless the tasks (resting state included). The other, by
computing the edgewise task identifiability over all subjects (i.e. intraclass correlation across
tasks, see Methods); that is, which specific functional connections can separate between
tasks (resting state included) regardless which subjects are performing them (see Methods).
Interestingly, there are sub-networks that are associated to subject and task identifiability
more than others, both in terms of within- and between- FNs (Fig. 7). Particularly, edges
involving connectivity within the visual and dorsal attentional networks, as well as edges
between those two networks, appear among the top 5 sub-networks highly implicated in task
identifiability (Fig. 7 D,E,F). The fronto-parietal and DMN networks and its between-network
connectivity with the attentional networks is highly involved in subject identifiability (Fig. 7
A,B,C). Both Subject ICC and Task ICC results were consistent and qualitatively similar
before and after optimal PCA reconstruction (results not shown for original FC data).
17
Figure 7. Intra-class correlation (ICC) analysis of subject identifiability and task identifiability. A-D)
Edgewise ICC for identifiability. Figure shows functional connections for which ICC values were significantly
higher (> 95th percentile of the distribution). The brain regions are ordered according to Yeo's (Yeo et al., 2011)
functional resting state networks (FNs): Visual (VIS), Somato-Motor (SM), Dorsal Attention (DA), Ventral
Attention (VA), Limbic system (L), Fronto-Parietal (FP), Default Mode Network (DMN), and subcortical regions
(SUBC). The colored dots depict ICC value across subjects in different within FNs networks; gray dots indicate
significant ICC edges between FNs. The most prominent networks for subject's identifiability (6A) appear to be:
FP, DMN and the interaction FP-DMN and with the attentional networks. For task identifiability (6B): VIS, and the
interaction VIS-DA; DA, SM and the VA. B-E) Violin plot of edgewise ICC for the top 5 FNs. The edgewise
ICC distribution per within or between FNs interaction, for the five with the highest ICC value for identifiability.
Each different color indicates a different within FN (as in 6A-D), while the gray indicates ICC values between
functional networks. The solid black lines depict the mean value of the distribution; the dashed black lines the 5
and 95 percentiles; the solid red line indicates the whole-brain mean ICC value. C-F) Brain render of ICC
subject identifiability as nodal density per region. The strength per brain region computed as sum of edges
above the 95 percentile threshold divided by the total number of edges per region gives an assessment of the
overall prominence of each brain region for subject's and task identifiability. Note how, the occipital lobe is
prominent in both task and subject identifiability, while frontal areas show higher nodal density for subject's ICC,
as opposed to dorsal areas in task ICC.
Discussion
The neuroscientific community is advancing towards the era of large public data repositories
(such as the Human Connectome Project 16, or the 1,000 Functional Connectomes Project 40,
the era of reproducibility of brain data and neuroscientific results 41, and the exciting avenue of
linking large-scale brain connectivity profiles to single subject's genetic 42, clinical,
demographical and behavioral features 5,39. In this respect, improving the reliability and
robustness of individual fingerprinting in the connectivity domain (both functional and
structural) is a crucial next step in the area of brain connectomics.
We here presented a framework that addresses this point from a cohort-level perspective. We
used principal component analysis to decompose and optimally reconstruct functional
connectomes obtained from the 100 unrelated subjects cohort (two sessions, test-retest) from
the HCP benchmark, both in resting state and all seven fMRI-tasks. Results indicate that this
method improves, on a data-driven fashion, both the global and the local (edgewise)
individual fingerprint (as measured by identifiability) of the functional connectivity profiles,
independently from the acquired task.
PCA is a method commonly used to provide a simpler representation of the data at hand, by
compressing most of the variance of the data in a reduced number of orthogonal components,
or eigenvectors. For instance, in face recognition problems, the retained eigenvectors
("eigenfaces") are used to denoise the initial images and improve the identification of the face
in the image 43. Similarly, we here mapped and ranked the principal connectivity modes from a
set of functional connectomes. Hence, by maximizing differential identifiability, the
reconstructed functional connectomes provided a denoised or more accurate version of the
original ones.
The simplicity of the approach allowed us to test the optimal number of eigenmodes or
components to retain for an optimal differential identifiability of the functional connectomes
(Fig. 2) across different tasks. Also, when splitting the resting-state time-series into two
halves, each resting state run shows a similar optimal m* (m*=80 PCs for split data, Fig. S3;
18
m*=80 for full data, Fig. 2). Also, resting-state is the session which shows greater
improvement after optimal PCA reconstruction (Fig. 3) in terms of edgewise ICC and self
identifiability. Moreover, the improvement in the individual identification was also substantial
for all the task sessions (Fig. 4 and Fig. S2). Despite subtle differences between Idiff and
identification rate as proposed by 6, results suggest that maximizing Idiff leads to an increased
identification rate for all tasks and resting-state sessions (Fig. S4).
Furthermore, in order to evaluate how differences in the number of fMRI volumes acquired
relates to identifiability, we tested the optimal identifiability for REST1 before and after
reconstruction when changing the number of frames available in the evaluation of functional
connectomes (Fig. 5). This result is noteworthy for two reasons. First, it shows that differential
identifiability after reconstruction always improves, also with low number of frames (Fig. 5).
Second, and more importantly, the identifiability rate obtained from the original data using the
whole resting-state acquisition (1,200 volumes) is achieved after optimal PCA reconstruction
when only considering 200 frames of the same acquisition. Indeed, given the asymptotic
behavior of the identifiability on the original data, values near 18% or above seem almost
unreachable for any acquisition length without the optimal reconstruction. This striking result
suggests that the proposed method may have an impact in helping reducing and optimizing
the duration and design of fMRI protocols, procedures and costs. Further research could
refine the assessment of trends and relations between acquisition length and identifiability.
Another crucial issue worth to tackle here was related to the association of the reconstructed
patterns with behavioral scores of the subjects. Indeed, a method with the aim of improving
identifiability needs to be tested on the association with cognitive-behavioral scores. Ideally, if
two functional connectomes of a same subject have better identifiability after reconstruction
across fMRI runs, one would expect to observe or detect more robust and stable associations
with behavior across the two visits. Motivated by this hypothesis, we tested whether the
functional connectomes obtained after PCA decomposition increases the robustness and
reproducibility of their association with behavioral scores, here identified as average response
time and average task accuracy (see Table 1 and Methods). With a single exception, the
results confirm the hypothesis that this method contributes to obtaining stronger, more reliable
and more robust associations with behavioral scores across runs. We also tested whether this
method could improve the prediction of individual behaviour from functional connectomes. As
a test-bed, we used fluid intelligence to show that the resting state reconstructed
connectomes outperform the original ones in the prediction of fluid intelligence (Fig. 6),
showing evidence of the potential of this approach for associations between brain connectivity
and behavior. Altogether, these findings suggest that this method provides a step forward
towards reproducibility and robustness in brain connectomics as well as for linking
connectivity profiles to cognitive "ground-truth" or behavioral scores.
We found head motion (as measured by absolute frame displacement, see Methods) to be
significantly associated with differential identifiability (negatively correlated) for all tasks and,
interestingly, in a minor way for resting-state (Fig. S5). This might lead to two main
considerations. One, that in resting state the principal components discarded may be
successfully carrying most of the motion-induced artifacts left over in the functional
connectome domain. The second, that motion during resting-state sessions might be more
homogeneous between subjects or better isolated in the discarded components (ranked by
explained variance, see discussion on limitations below) than when the subject is cognitively
19
engaged in a task that include time-controlled events and interactions. Ultimately, the more
brain connectivity modes retained, the more fine-grained information (i.e. variance explained)
is kept in the functional connectomes after optimal reconstruction. However, this comes at the
risk of carrying over session-specific and/or motion-induced connectivity artifacts, not
beneficial for identifiability.
We extended the question to whether it is possible to identify a subject or a task performed
based solely on characteristic functional connectivity patterns. Our results based on
intraclass correlation show some functional networks (FNs) specialization, being some FNs
more involved in edgewise task-identifiability and others in subject-identifiability (Fig. 7). This
is in line with recent studies reporting that individual differences in many tasks can be stable
trait markers 44,45, as well as that individual fingerprint is not homogeneous across FNs 6,45. We
extend these questions on individual fingerprinting by showing here that identifiability across
individuals and across tasks might overlap. Indeed, we found prominent FNs-based
connections sensitive to both subjects and tasks being performed (Fig. 7).
This study has some limitations. The optimal number of components is dataset dependent
(e.g., size of the cohort, heterogeneity within the cohort, acquisition and processing
characteristics) and cannot be easily extrapolated from one dataset to another one. Also,
here we are selecting the principal brain modes based on the ranking by variance explained
(as it is the normal procedure in PCA). Different selection of the optimal subset of PCs should
be explored (i.e by using simulated annealing 46).
This work adds up to the emerging new field of features extraction in brain connectomics
(independent subsystem detection through independent component analysis 27,47;
dimensionality reduction and connectome denoising through PCA here), that can contribute to
the association of neuroimaging data with clinical/genetic biomarkers, as well as to the
exploration of the underlying latent structures and factors present in the connectome
architecture of the human brain. Future studies should explore more advanced models of
features extraction as well as the connections of these denoised connectivity profiles with
behavior/performance/cognition. For instance, on cross-sectional studies one could try to find
optimal number of components that allows for mapping demographics or cognitive
performance variables. Another exciting avenue of further investigation relates to the
predictability of new (healthy or clinical) functional connectivity profiles, once given the
connectivity modes obtained from a "benchmark" cohort. Future work should also explore,
with more advanced approaches such as machine learning techniques, up to what extent on
the reconstructed connectomes it is possible to identify a subject with higher accuracy than
using original FC. Other interesting avenues also involve the application of this methodology
to structural connectivity patterns, and the dependence of the reconstruction on aging through
longitudinal analyses.
Individual fingerprinting within the functional connectivity domain is a critical attribute for
further research on brain connectomics. Here, we used data from the Human Connectome
Project to demonstrate that the optimal reconstruction of the individual FCs through
connectivity eigenmodes maximizes subject identifiability across resting-state and all seven
tasks evaluated. The subject identifiability of the reconstructed individual connectivity profiles
increased both at the global and edgewise level, also when the reconstruction was imposed
on additional sessions of the subjects. We extended this approach to also map the most task-
sensitive functional connections. Results showed that is possible to maximize individual
20
fingerprinting in the functional connectivity domain regardless of the task, a crucial next step
in the area of brain connectivity towards individualized connectomics.
Acknowledgments
Data were provided [in part] by the Human Connectome Project, WU-Minn Consortium
(Principal Investigators: David Van Essen and Kamil Ugurbil; 1U54MH091657) funded by the
16 NIH Institutes and Centers that support the NIH Blueprint for Neuroscience Research; and
by the McDonnell Center for Systems Neuroscience at Washington University. This work was
partially supported by NIH R01EB022574,by NIH R01MH108467, and by the Indiana Clinical
and Translational Sciences Institute (UL1TR001108) from the NIH, National Center for
Advancing Translational Sciences, Clinical and Translational Sciences Award. We would like
to thank Dr. Olaf Sporns, Dr. Alex Fornito, Dr. Gesualdo Scutari and Dr. Mario Dzemidzic for
insightful discussions.
Author contributions
E.A and J.G conceptualized the study, processed the MRI data, designed the framework and
performed the analyses, interpreted the results and wrote the manuscript.
Declaration of interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
REFERENCES
1. Bullmore, E. & Sporns, O. Complex brain networks: graph theoretical analysis of structural and
functional systems. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 10, 186–198 (2009).
2. Sporns, O. The human connectome: a complex network. Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 1224, 109–125
(2011).
3. Fornito, A., Zalesky, A. & Bullmore, E. Fundamentals of Brain Network Analysis. (Academic
Press, 2016).
4. van den Heuvel, M. P. & Hulshoff Pol, H. E. Exploring the brain network: A review on resting-state
fMRI functional connectivity. Eur. Neuropsychopharmacol. 20, 519–534 (2010).
21
5. Fornito, A., Zalesky, A. & Breakspear, M. The connectomics of brain disorders. Nat. Rev. Neurosci.
16, 159–172 (2015).
6. Finn, E. S. et al. Functional connectome fingerprinting: identifying individuals using patterns of
brain connectivity. Nat. Neurosci. 18, 1664–1671 (2015).
7. Kaufmann, T. et al. Delayed stabilization and individualization in connectome development are
related to psychiatric disorders. Nat. Neurosci. 20, nn.4511 (2017).
8. Miranda-Dominguez, O. et al. Connectotyping: Model Based Fingerprinting of the Functional
Connectome. PLOS ONE 9, e111048 (2014).
9. Noble, S. et al. Influences on the Test–Retest Reliability of Functional Connectivity MRI and its
Relationship with Behavioral Utility. Cereb. Cortex 27, 5415–5429 (2017).
10. Fraschini, M., Hillebrand, A., Demuru, M., Didaci, L. & Marcialis, G. L. An EEG-Based Biometric
System Using Eigenvector Centrality in Resting State Brain Networks. IEEE Signal Process. Lett.
22, 666–670 (2015).
11. Fox, M. D. & Raichle, M. E. Spontaneous fluctuations in brain activity observed with functional
magnetic resonance imaging. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 8, 700–711 (2007).
12. Power, J. D., Barnes, K. A., Snyder, A. Z., Schlaggar, B. L. & Petersen, S. E. Spurious but
systematic correlations in functional connectivity MRI networks arise from subject motion.
NeuroImage 59, 2142–2154 (2012).
13. Power, J. D. et al. Methods to detect, characterize, and remove motion artifact in resting state
fMRI. NeuroImage 84, 320–341 (2014).
14. Friston, K. J. Functional and Effective Connectivity: A Review. Brain Connect. 1, 13–36 (2011).
15. Finn, E. S. et al. Can brain state be manipulated to emphasize individual differences in functional
connectivity? NeuroImage 160, 140–151 (2017).
16. Van Essen, D. C. et al. The WU-Minn Human Connectome Project: An overview. NeuroImage 80,
62–79 (2013).
17. Van Essen, D. C. et al. The Human Connectome Project: a data acquisition perspective.
NeuroImage 62, 2222–2231 (2012).
22
18. Glasser, M. F. et al. The minimal preprocessing pipelines for the Human Connectome Project.
NeuroImage 80, 105–124 (2013).
19. Smith, S. M. et al. Resting-state fMRI in the Human Connectome Project. NeuroImage 80, 144–
168 (2013).
20. Barch, D. M. et al. Function in the human connectome: Task-fMRI and individual differences in
behavior. NeuroImage 80, 169–189 (2013).
21. Glasser, M. F. et al. A multi-modal parcellation of human cerebral cortex. Nature 536, 171–178
(2016).
22. Marcus, D. et al. Informatics and Data Mining Tools and Strategies for the Human Connectome
Project. Front. Neuroinformatics 5, (2011).
23. Jenkinson, M., Beckmann, C. F., Behrens, T. E. J., Woolrich, M. W. & Smith, S. M. FSL.
NeuroImage 62, 782–790 (2012).
24. Salimi-Khorshidi, G. et al. Automatic denoising of functional MRI data: Combining independent
component analysis and hierarchical fusion of classifiers. NeuroImage 90, 449–468 (2014).
25. Cole, M. W., Bassett, D. S., Power, J. D., Braver, T. S. & Petersen, S. E. Intrinsic and Task-Evoked
Network Architectures of the Human Brain. Neuron 83, 238–251 (2014).
26. Yeo, B. T. T. et al. The organization of the human cerebral cortex estimated by intrinsic functional
connectivity. J. Neurophysiol. 106, 1125–1165 (2011).
27. Amico, E. et al. Mapping the functional connectome traits of levels of consciousness. NeuroImage
148, 201–211 (2017).
28. Jolliffe, I. Principal Component Analysis. in Wiley StatsRef: Statistics Reference Online (John
Wiley & Sons, Ltd, 2014). doi:10.1002/9781118445112.stat06472
29. Price, A. L. et al. Principal components analysis corrects for stratification in genome-wide
association studies. Nat. Genet. 38, 904–909 (2006).
30. Zhang, L., Dong, W., Zhang, D. & Shi, G. Two-stage image denoising by principal component
analysis with local pixel grouping. Pattern Recognit. 43, 1531–1549 (2010).
23
31. Leonardi, N. et al. Principal components of functional connectivity: A new approach to study
dynamic brain connectivity during rest. NeuroImage 83, 937–950 (2013).
32. Birn, R. M. et al. The effect of scan length on the reliability of resting-state fMRI connectivity
estimates. NeuroImage 83, 550–558 (2013).
33. Laumann, T. O. et al. Functional System and Areal Organization of a Highly Sampled Individual
Human Brain. Neuron 87, 657–670 (2015).
34. Shah, L. M., Cramer, J. A., Ferguson, M. A., Birn, R. M. & Anderson, J. S. Reliability and
reproducibility of individual differences in functional connectivity acquired during task and resting
state. Brain Behav. 6, n/a-n/a (2016).
35. McGraw, K. O. & P, S. Forming inferences about some intraclass correlation coefficients. Psychol.
Methods 1, 30–46 (1996).
36. Bartko, J. J. The Intraclass Correlation Coefficient as a Measure of Reliability. Psychol. Rep. 19, 3–
11 (1966).
37. Shrout, P. E. & Fleiss, J. L. Intraclass correlations: Uses in assessing rater reliability. Psychol. Bull.
86, 420–428 (1979).
38. Zalesky, A., Fornito, A. & Bullmore, E. T. Network-based statistic: Identifying differences in brain
networks. NeuroImage 53, 1197–1207 (2010).
39. Shen, X. et al. Using connectome-based predictive modeling to predict individual behavior from
brain connectivity. Nat. Protoc. 12, 506–518 (2017).
40. Mennes, M., Biswal, B. B., Castellanos, F. X. & Milham, M. P. Making data sharing work: The
FCP/INDI experience. NeuroImage 82, 683–691 (2013).
41. Nichols, T. E. et al. Best practices in data analysis and sharing in neuroimaging using MRI. Nat.
Neurosci. 20, 299–303 (2017).
42. Thompson, P. M., Ge, T., Glahn, D. C., Jahanshad, N. & Nichols, T. E. Genetics of the connectome.
NeuroImage 80, 475–488 (2013).
24
43. Zhao, W., Chellappa, R. & Krishnaswamy, A. Discriminant analysis of principal components for
face recognition. in Proceedings Third IEEE International Conference on Automatic Face and
Gesture Recognition 336–341 (1998). doi:10.1109/AFGR.1998.670971
44. Tavor, I. et al. Task-free MRI predicts individual differences in brain activity during task
performance. Science 352, 216–220 (2016).
45. Peña-Gómez, C., Avena-Koenigsberger, A., Sepulcre, J. & Sporns, O. Spatiotemporal Network
Markers of Individual Variability in the Human Functional Connectome. Cereb. Cortex 1–13
doi:10.1093/cercor/bhx170
46. Hwang, C.-R. Simulated annealing: Theory and applications. Acta Appl. Math. 12, 108–111 (1988).
47. Kessler, D., Angstadt, M. & Sripada, C. Growth Charting of Brain Connectivity Networks and the
Identification of Attention Impairment in Youth. JAMA Psychiatry 73, 481–489 (2016).
25
The quest for identifiability in human functional connectomes
Enrico Amico1,2 and Joaquín Goñi 1,2,3,*
1 School of Industrial Engineering, Purdue University, West-Lafayette, IN, USA
2 Purdue Institute for Integrative Neuroscience, Purdue University, West-Lafayette, IN, USA
3 Weldon School of Biomedical Engineering, Purdue University, West-Lafayette, IN, USA
Supplementary Information
Figure S1. Explained variance and differential identifiability (I diff) across sessions. Left: the variance
explained (R-square) of the original data from the PCA reconstruction, for different number of PCA components
employed. Each session is plotted with a different color. Right: violin plots show the distribution of the FC
individual identifiability (see Methods) across subjects, for each fMRI session (each one has a distinct color),
before and after PCA reconstruction. The solid black lines of the violins depict the mean value of the distribution.
The asterisk indicates the individual identifiability distributions after reconstruction. Note how the PCA
reconstruction always improves the individual identifiability.
Figure S2. Summary of results on ICC and self-identifiability (I self) for the six fMRI tasks not shown in the
main text. Left: the scatter plot edge by edge of the reconstructed ICC values (y axis) vs original ICC values(x
axis). The inset reports the percentage of edges where ICC increased after reconstruction (top of the red
dashed line) from those that did not (low of the red line). Right: violin plot of the "self identifiability" (i.e., the main
diagonal of the identifiability matrix, see Methods) distribution across the 80 subjects, for original (ORIG, red)
and reconstructed (RECON, blue). The solid black lines depict the mean value of the distribution; the dashed
black lines the 5 and 95 percentiles. The inset specifies the percentage of subjects whose identifiability has
improved after PCA reconstruction.
Figure S3. Percent difference of the differential identifiability (Idiff) as a function of the number of PCA
components used for reconstruction in split resting-state sessions. Plots show, for each split resting state
sessions (test = first 600 fMRI frames, retest = second 600 fMRI frames, see Methods for details), I diff as a
function of the number of PCA components used for reconstruction (evaluated at 2, 5, and 10 to 160
components in steps of 10). Red line denotes I diff for the original FCs, whereas blue line with circles denotes the
identifiability for reconstructed FCs based on the different number of components sampled. For each subplot, the
optimal number of components that maximizes differential identifiability (m*) and the corresponding explained
variance (R2) are shown. To test the stability of the method, I diff was evaluated over 100 different runs. At each
run, 80 subjects were randomly sampled from the HCP resting-state data pool of 100 unrelated subjects, 4
sessions (REST1_LR, REST1_RL, REST2_LR and REST2_RL) for a total of 160 FCs at every run. The
standard deviation of Idiff (not shown in the plots) across runs was always lower then 0.9 %, for all the sessions
considered, for both original and reconstructed data.
Figure S4: Identifiability rates for all possible combinations of test-retest (within the same sequence and
between different sequences), before and after PCA reconstruction. Note that identifiability rates in the main
diagonal (i.e. test-retest from the same sequence) were the average of test-retest and retest-test rates. Also, for
main diagonal values, the optimal number of PCA components m* was based on the findings of Fig. 2. For off
diagonal values, where FCs come from different tasks (T i,Tj), optimal reconstruction on the mixed data matrix
was defined as m*mixed = max(m*Ti , m*Tj).
EMOTION GAMBLING
LANGUAGE
MOTOR
RELATIONAL
REST
SOCIAL
WORKING
MEMORY
Abs_RMS - μ ± σ
0.36 ± 0.39 0.39 ± 0.44
0.44 ± 0.45
0.49 ± 0.33
0.43 ± 0.46
0.82 ± 0.44
0.37 ± 0.32
0.56 ± 0.52
RT (ms) - μ ± σ
798 ± 143
418 ± 116
359 ± 350
ACC (%) μ ± σ
98 ± 4
n.a.
88 ± 9
n.a.
n.a.
1762 ± 327
76 ± 14
n.a
n.a.
1103 ± 358
884 ± 149
n.a
86 ± 10
Table S1: The summary statistic (mean and standard deviation across the 100 unrelated subjects) for the motion
and behavioral variables employed in Fig.S5 and Table1, respectively, for each of the fMRI task and resting-
state. In order from top to bottom row: absolute frame displacement (Abs_RMS, unitless); task response time
(RT, milliseconds); task accuracy (ACC, percentage).
Figure S5. Log-linear trend evaluation between self identifiability (I self) and mean absolute frame
displacement. Plot shows, for each resting-state and task session, the scatter plot between individual self
identifiability (see Methods for details) values after reconstruction (y-axis) and the log 10 of the maximum value
( across the two sessions) of the average absolute frame displacement (ABS_RMS, x-axis). Solid lines show the
linear fit of the scatter plots, and the insets report Pearson's correlation coefficient (r) between these two
variables, with the associated significance (p-value). Note how there is a significant negative correlation
(p<0.001) between increases in self identifiability and ABS_RMS across all tasks. No significant linear trend is
present for the REST acquisition.
|
1109.2556 | 1 | 1109 | 2011-09-12T18:18:34 | Intermittent synchronization in a network of bursting neurons | [
"q-bio.NC",
"nlin.CD"
] | Synchronized oscillations in networks of inhibitory and excitatory coupled bursting neurons are common in a variety of neural systems from central pattern generators to human brain circuits. One example of the latter is the subcortical network of the basal ganglia, formed by excitatory and inhibitory bursters of the subthalamic nucleus and globus pallidus, involved in motor control and affected in Parkinson's disease. Recent experiments have demonstrated the intermittent nature of the phase-locking of neural activity in this network. Here we explore one potential mechanism to explain the intermittent phase-locking in a network. We simplify the network to obtain a model of two inhibitory coupled elements and explore its dynamics. We used geometric analysis and singular perturbation methods for dynamical systems to reduce the full model to a simpler set of equations. Mathematical analysis was completed using three slow variables with two different time scales. Intermittently synchronous oscillations are generated by overlapped spiking which crucially depends on the geometry of the slow phase plane and the interplay between slow variables as well as the strength of synapses. Two slow variables are responsible for the generation of activity patterns with overlapped spiking and the other slower variable enhances the robustness of an irregular and intermittent activity pattern. While the analyzed network and the explored mechanism of intermittent synchrony appear to be quite generic, the results of this analysis can be used to trace particular values of biophysical parameters (synaptic strength and parameters of calcium dynamics), which are known to be impacted in Parkinson's disease. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Intermittent synchronization in a network of bursting neurons
Choongseok Park1 (박중석), Leonid L. Rubchinsky1,2
1 Department of Mathematical Sciences and Center for Mathematical Biosciences, Indiana University
Purdue University Indianapolis, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA
2 Stark Neurosciences Research Institute, Indiana University School of Medicine, Indianapolis, IN 46202,
USA
Abstract
Synchronized oscillations in networks of inhibitory and excitatory coupled bursting neurons are
common in a variety of neural systems from central pattern generators to human brain circuits.
One example of the latter is the subcortical network of the basal ganglia, formed by excitatory
and inhibitory bursters of the subthalamic nucleus and globus pallidus, involved in motor control
and affected in Parkinson’s disease. Recent experiments have demonstrated the intermittent
nature of the phase-locking of neural activity in this network. Here we explore one potential
mechanism to explain the intermittent phase-locking in a network. We simplify the network to
obtain a model of two inhibitory coupled elements and explore its dynamics. We used geometric
analysis and singular perturbation methods for dynamical systems to reduce the full model to a
simpler set of equations. Mathematical analysis was completed using three slow variables with
two different time scales. Intermittently synchronous oscillations are generated by overlapped
spiking which crucially depends on the geometry of the slow phase plane and the interplay
between slow variables as well as the strength of synapses. Two slow variables are responsible
for the generation of activity patterns with overlapped spiking and the other slower variable
enhances the robustness of an irregular and intermittent activity pattern. While the analyzed
network and the explored mechanism of intermittent synchrony appear to be quite generic, the
results of this analysis can be used to trace particular values of biophysical parameters (synaptic
strength and parameters of calcium dynamics), which are known to be impacted in Parkinson’s
disease.
Synchronized neural oscillations are widespread phenomena with a variety of functional
implications and have been observed in many neural systems. In particular, synchronized
oscillations of bursting neurons are related to motor symptoms of Parkinson’s disease.
Recent experiments revealed intermittent characteristic of this synchronized activity,
which may have functional importance. This manuscript explores potential mechanisms
underlying this intermittent synchronization. We reduced large network model [1] to a
simpler model of two coupled bursting neurons and used fast/slow analysis to explore the
mechanisms of intermittent synchronization. Intermittently synchronous oscillations are
generated by overlapped spiking which crucially depends on the geometry of slow phase
1
plane and the interaction between slow variables as well as the strength of coupling
between bursting cells.
1. Introduction
Synchronized oscillations across various brain areas have been extensively studied because of
their functional significance for perceptive and cognitive processing [2,3,4] and for movement
preparation and execution [5,6,7]. Thus it is natural that disorganization of this oscillatory
activity (including pathologically strong or pathologically weak synchronization of oscillations)
may contribute to a variety of neurological and psychiatric disorders [8,9]. In particular,
hypokinetic motor symptoms of Parkinson’s disease such as slowness and rigidity of voluntary
movements are closely related to synchronized oscillatory neuronal activity in the beta frequency
band, loosely speaking, 10-30 Hz [10,11,12]. This kind of synchronization is intermittent and
has a specific temporal patterning [13].
Earlier modeling and experimental studies investigated the role of two brain nuclei – external
globus pallidus (GPe) and subthalamic nucleus (STN) in the support of this oscillatory
synchronized dynamics in Parkinson’s disease. In particular, synchronized oscillations have been
suggested to result from rhythmic sequences of recurrent excitation and inhibition in pallido-
subthalamic networks [14,15]. While the role of other structures in the generation of these
synchronized oscillations cannot be ruled out, our own modeling work suggested that the
characteristic temporal structure of oscillatory activity in the beta-band may be due to intrinsic
properties of the STN-GPe network itself and showed that the corresponding parameter region
resides between synchronized and nonsynchronized oscillatory dynamics [1].
The transient nature of neural dynamics should not be surprising [16,17]. However, although
many network architectures and their activity patterns have been extensively studied, biological
and dynamical mechanisms underlying synchrony with irregular desynchronizing events (like
those described in [13]) are not fully understood. In the current study, we investigated one
possible generic mechanism underlying this intermittent synchrony in networks of inhibitory and
excitatory bursting neurons. We reduced the excitatory-inhibitory network formed by STN and
GPe to a simple network consisting of two inhibitory cells with self-inhibition. The resulting
simple model is not able to fully capture all the details of the complex network activity patterns
shown in experimental recordings [13] and previous modeling work [1]. However, it captures
important characteristics of intermittent synchrony and provides insights into potential dynamical
and biological mechanisms and their dependence on parameters.
We used geometric dynamical systems and singular perturbation methods to reduce the full
model to a simpler set of equations. This approach simplifies the analysis of the dynamics and
investigation of the underlying mechanisms. Mathematical analysis was completed using three
slow variables with two different time scales. We show how two slow variables are responsible
for the competition between two cells by studying the geometry of slow phase plane. This
competition is responsible for the generation of overlapped spiking. The slowest variable, on the
2
other hand, broadens the range of synaptic strength, over which irregular and intermittent activity
patterns occur. The results in this study describe how the properties of the cells and strength of
synaptic connections interact to generate intermittent synchrony and may be used to relate the
model parameter relationship to the properties of real systems.
In Section 2, a conductance-based model of the STN cell and network architecture is introduced.
In Section 3, we study various activity patterns focusing on the intermittent phase-locking due to
overlapped spiking of neurons. In Section 4, we provide a geometric analysis of intermittent
synchronization using fast/slow analysis. Overlapped spiking and regular bursting solutions are
subjected to the analysis based on the geometry of a two-dimensional bifurcation diagram.
2. Neural Model and Network Architecture
Experimental results and previous modeling studies have suggested that the STN-GPe network
within the basal ganglia may form a key network and their interactions play a crucial role in the
pathophysiology of Parkinson’s disease [14,15]. In the reciprocally connected STN-GPe network,
the excitatory input from STN to GPe is relatively sparse whereas the inhibitory input from GPe
to STN is relatively dense [18]. The GPe cell also gets an external inhibitory input from striatum.
Previous modeling works [1,19,20] considered a network consisting of 10 STN cells and 10 GPe
cells where STN cell sends an excitatory input to a GPe cell and GPe cell sends an inhibitory
input to nearby STN cells (Fig.1A). Such networks are able to produce realistically rich patterns
of activity. In this study, we will start with this network architecture and reduce it to a simpler
one as follows.
The aforementioned modeling studies have shown that a transition from an irregular,
uncorrelated regime (presumably close to the normal state) to a regular, synchronized regime
(presumably extreme pathology) in STN-GPe network can be accomplished in a biologically
realistic manner by controlling two dopamine-dependent parameters, more hyperpolarizing
current input to GPe and stronger inhibitory synaptic connection from GPe to STN. Under more
hyperpolarizing current, the model GPe cell becomes less active and spontaneous activity is
substantially reduced. Thus, as we approach a synchronized regime through intermittent
synchrony, the GPe cell tends to relay the excitation from the STN cell faithfully due to its
reduced spontaneous firings. For simplicity of analysis, we assume that the GPe cell acts as a
simple relay cell and reduce the whole network to a network of STN cells. Under this assumption,
activity of the STN cell is instantaneously delivered to a GPe cell and that GPe cell faithfully
reproduces STN cell activity, hence the STN cell and the GPe cell, which gets an excitatory input
from that STN cell, are merged together. Thus although real STN cells are excitatory, the
resulting network consists of cells with inhibitory connections. In particular, the reciprocal
inhibition from a GPe cell to an STN cell becomes self-inhibition. Therefore, we considered a
network consisting of two inhibitory cells with reciprocal inhibition as well as self-inhibition
(Fig. 1B). We assumed that the strength of self-inhibition is 30% of the reciprocal synaptic
strength unless specified otherwise.
3
I
Ca
presyn
(1)
syn
app
We employ the conductance-based single compartment model of STN cells used in [1,19,20],
which consists of membrane potential (V), three gating variables for ionic currents (n, h and r),
2Ca +
, and synaptic variable (s). The equations are
intracellular concentration of
+
I
−
=
(2)
(3)
(4)
−
I
AHP
n h r
,
,
−
−
t = − −
−
I
I
d
I
I
C dV
I
·
/
Na
Ca
T
K
L
τ
φ
=
−
x
V
x
x V
dx dt
(
) for
(
(
) /
/
)
∞
x
x
−
ε=
−
−
k Ca
I
d Ca dt
I
[
])
(
[
] /
Ca
T
−
−
−
=
β
θ
α
H V
s
s
ds dt
(
/
)
)(1
∞
g
=
=
−
−
−
=
g m V h V V
g n V V
I
I
g V
V
I
)
are leak, fast potassium and
3 (
)
,
4 (
,
) (
(
)
∞
K
K
K
Na
Na
Na
L
L
L
2 ( r )(V −VCa ) and
= gT a∞
=
−
sodium currents, respectively. IT
3 (V )b∞
g s V V V
I
are two
2 (
)
)(
∞
Ca
Ca
Ca
=
+
−
I
g
Ca
Ca
k
V V
is an afterhyperpolarization current.
calcium currents and
([
] / ([
]
))(
)
K
AHP
AHP
1
− ∑
=
s
I
g V V
m∞ , a∞ , and s∞ are instantaneous voltage-dependent gating variables.
)
(
syn
j
syn
syn
j
is synaptic current where summation is over s-variables from all neurons projecting to a given
+
−
− Θ
σ
V
neuron. Sigmoidal function H ∞ is given by 1 / (1 exp[ (
) /
])
H
H
. The parameters are the
g
g
Tg changed from 0.5 to 0.6.
same as in [20] with the minor exception of
In the later part of this study, we will focus on the dynamics of three slow variables (the gating
variable r of TI , total synaptic input σ, and the calcium concentration [Ca]) with their time
+
g
s
s
where s1 is the
scales. The total synaptic input for cell 1, say σ1, is defined as
(0.3
)
2
1
syn
synaptic variable of self-inhibition and s2 is the synaptic variable for synapse from the other cell.
φ for r in Eq. (2) is 49.2 over most of voltage range, 1/β for s in Eq.
Vτ
The time constant
(
) /
r
r
(4) is 25, and 1/ε for [Ca] in Eq.(3) is 2667 while membrane potential V rises and falls within
few milliseconds when a cell fires. We have two slow variables σ and r, and another extremely
slow variable [Ca].
This model was integrated using XPPAUT. Customized MATLAB codes were used for time-
series analysis which is described in more detail in [13,21]. Delays due to conductance, synapses
and cell dynamics may influence the intermittent synchronization properties observed in
experimental data. However, this simple network is able to generate patterns, which are
qualitatively similar to those observed in experimental data. Since we are interested in the
generic mechanism underlying such activity patterns, this network architecture is justified for our
study.
The resulting network appears to be relatively typical for neural systems. Its mutually inhibitory
organization makes it prone to the generation of rhythms, which makes it somewhat similar to
central pattern generator (CPG) networks.
4
3. Synchronous activity patterns in the network
3.1 Synchronous activity in dependence on the coupling strength
syng
We chose
(inhibitory synaptic strength) as a varying parameter (it is one of the parameters,
expected to increase as the dopamine disappears in Parkinson’s disease [22,23,24,25]) and first
syng
consider activity patterns over various
values. Without self-coupling, we observed out-of-
phase bursting solutions (phases of bursting in neurons are shifted by π) for sufficiently large
syng
values due to the post-inhibitory rebound burst of STN cell [20]. With self-coupling, we
also observe out-of-phase bursting solutions where the number of spikes within a burst of the
syng
out-of-phase solution increases monotonically as
increases. But, there are also intervals of
parameters, which correspond to transitions from one out-of-phase solution to another. Over such
intervals, activity patterns demonstrate a mixture of the two nearby solutions. The lengths of
syng
such intervals become shorter as
increases.
Note that while [20] studied similar models, it looked at extremes: clustered regime in the strong
coupling case and irregular regime in the weak coupling case. This study looks at the
intermediate case, when the coupling is intermediate and the dynamics is neither perfectly
clustered nor irregular. Not only this dynamics is more complex, it is also more realistic, as we
show below. The present study outlines a scenario for a realistically complex dynamics,
advancing us beyond well-studied cases of weak and strong coupling.
To characterize the dynamics of the network, we consider the correlation between activities of
the two cells in a large range of coupling strength. First, we computed coherence in the
frequency domain using membrane potentials. We downsampled 10s-long voltage data to 1 kHz
and divided it into 8 sections with 50% overlap. A Welch’s averaged, modified periodogram
method was used to compute the coherence estimate over frequencies. Fig. 2A shows the
coherence values averaged over [0,100] Hz (black) and [10, 30] Hz (gray) frequency bands. We
syng
observe an overall increase of average coherence in both cases as
increases because network
activity patterns are controlled by stronger inhibitory connection.
This network can generate complex activity patterns over a significant interval of parameter
syng
values due to reciprocal inhibitory input. One example is for
around 0.9 (see Fig. 2A), where
the average coherence over 10-30Hz frequency band shows a dip. Interestingly, solutions over
this interval demonstrate substantial power in 10-30 Hz frequency band. Fig. 2C illustrates
syng = 0.9. This solution “lies between” 2-spike and 3-spike out-of-phase
activity patterns when
bursting solutions and shows alternation of bursts, the number of spikes within each cycle tends
to change irregularly. To quantify this imperfect synchrony, we computed the degree of phase-
locking between two cells using the synchronization index γ. We first band-pass filtered the
signal within 10-30 Hz band and constructed phase variables using Hilbert transform. The
5
=
(
t
k
)
2
γ
N
, where
φ is the difference of
j
synchronization index is defined as
1
k
e φ
i
∑
j
N
= − +
j k N
1
phases and N is the number of data points over a window of some fixed length. We used 1s long
non-overlapping windows and averaged the resulting synchronization indices to get an averaged
syng
synchronization index. Fig. 2B shows the averaged synchronization index over some
values
and different self-coupling strengths. When the self-coupling strength is 30%, we have 1 or 2-
syng
spike (3-spike) out-of-phase bursting solution for
smaller than 0.9 (greater than 0.93). Over
syng
values, we have relatively strong phase locking between the two cells.
these two ranges of
syng
is between 0.9 and 0.92, where an irregular
This secure phase locking is reduced when
sequence of burstings with overlapped spikes dominates. Different values of self-coupling
syng
syng
preserve this characteristic feature of phase-locking over a range of
values while the
value which shows the most significant drop of phase-locking decreases as the strength of self-
coupling increases.
3.2 Irregular Dynamics
Now let us explore whether the activity pattern shown in Fig. 2B is really chaotic. To do it
numerically we compute maximal Lyapunov exponents (MLEs); in general, a positive maximal
Lyapunov exponent indicates exponential growth of small perturbations and chaotic dynamics if
the solutions are bounded. Instead of using whole time series, we may use one-dimensional map
data obtained through Poincare section. We chose the gating variable r of TI (Eq. (1)) in one of
the cells for Lyapunov exponent computation. TI is essential for the generation of a rebound
burst after removal of prolonged hyperpolarization, which, in turn, is important for generating
irregular activity patterns. We recorded values of r of STN 1 whenever it is released from
inhibition to get { nr }. We say that STN 1 is released from inhibition when total synaptic input σ1
of STN 1 begins to decrease after STN 2 fires its last spike of a burst. Fig. 3A shows return maps,
≤ 0.89 or
≥ 0.93,
1nr + vs. nr , for several different
syng
syng
syng
values from 0.86 through 0.96. For
syng = 0.86
the return map has only one single point; black square (circle, triangle, diamond) for
+ = line implies
r
r
(0.88, 0.94, 0.96, respectively). A single point (a tight cluster of points) on
1n
n
an almost regular and periodic solution. In this case the black square and circle are 2-spike
bursting solutions, the triangle and diamond are 3-spike bursting solutions. Between these two
syng =0.9 (Fig. 3B) and 0.92 (Fig. 3A, gray
cases, we have more complicated return maps when
dots). The complex appearance of the return map in Fig. 3B may suggest chaotic dynamics. And
syng = 0.9, hence activity patterns are
indeed, the maximal Lyapunov exponent is 0.5292 when
syng = 0.92 case (Fig. 3A) also has positive maximal Lyapunov exponent 0.3613.
really irregular.
syng
values from 0.894 to 0.924. The
Fig. 3C shows the maximal Lyapunov exponents over other
syng
and are relatively
values of maximal Lyapunov exponents show complex dependence on
6
syng
large for
between 0.9 and 0.91. Maximal Lyapunov exponents were computed with
TISEAN package [26].
3.3 Escaping and intermittent phase synchronization
The characteristic irregular sequence of burstings shown in Fig. 2B may be attributed to the
competition between the two cells, which is evidenced by frequent occurrences of overlapped
spikes. This kind of spike overlapping can be characterized as ‘escape’ [27]. The observed
variability of number of spikes associated with an escape mechanism is responsible for the
reduction of the phase-locking strength. Fig. 4A shows an example of ‘escape’ in detail when
syng = 0.9. Two voltage profiles are shown in upper panel where gray trace is escaping from
inhibition of the other cell and the corresponding phase variables are shown in bottom panel. We
can see that overlapped spikes cause distortions of the phase relationship between the two cells
through delay and/or advance of phase propagations, which would be almost constant in case of
regular bursting solutions. The competition of the two cells through escaping redefines the
relationship between them. The accumulated effect of this competition is shown in Fig. 4B
through the first-return map for the phase difference. We recorded the phases of cell 1 whenever
the phase of cell 2 passes upward through some fixed value. In this figure, we set the check point
as -3 for cell 2 and collected { iφ} for cell 1. { iφ} was shifted so that the mean is
and then
1iφ+ vs.
iφ.
we plotted
In Fig. 4B, one big cluster in the first quadrant corresponds to the synchronized activity patterns
between two cells, while two big branches in the second and fourth quadrants correspond to
desynchronized activity. Deviation from the cluster is mostly due to the frequent occurrence of
overlapped spikes and is characterized by a quick return to the cluster (Fig. 4C). Similar first-
return maps for the phase difference and relatively short duration of desynchronizing events was
also observed in experimental data in parkinsonian patients [13] and in the model of the large
basal ganglia network [1].
Although the origin and the underlying mechanisms of this spike overlapping and resulting
intermittent synchronization will be discussed in the next part of this paper, one heuristic
explanation can be given. Irregular and frequent occurrence of overlapping is due to the specific
nature of the given solution itself; in the parameter space it is situated in between two stable
solution regimes. The solution tends to be either in 2-spike or 3-spike bursting modes but this
tendency for stability is frequently destroyed by other destabilizing factors. We would like to
stress that this activity pattern is robust in numerical simulations with weak additive Gaussian
white noise, which suggests that this mechanism of activity pattern may be of experimental
relevance.
7
4. Geometric analysis of intermittent synchronization
4.1 Slow phase plane construction via fast/slow analysis
In this section, we will investigate how frequent occurrences of overlapped spiking, which result
in characteristic irregular sequence of burstings and intermittent phase synchronization, depend
on the strength of synaptic connection, intrinsic properties of the cells and the interplay between
syng =
slow variables. We will use geometric methods and begin by considering a STN cell when
0.9 (intermittent phase-locking case illustrated in Figs. 3 and 4). The voltage profile is shown in
the upper panel of Fig. 5A and the lower panel shows three other variables, the gating variable r
of TI , the total synaptic input σ, and the calcium concentration [Ca]. Total synaptic input σ is
the sum of inhibitory input from the other cell and self-inhibition.
Due to the slowest time scale of [Ca], we may consider it as a constant and proceed with
fast/slow analysis. It seems, however, that [Ca] plays an important role in the generation of
irregular sequence of burstings with overlapped spiking. We inspected activity patterns under
constant [Ca] ranged from 0.66 to 0.70 and found that they tend to be periodic. These periodic
solutions are not like simple out-of-phase 2-spike or 3-spike solutions but more complicated
patterns with escaping. For example, when [Ca] =0.67 and
syng
= 0.9, one period of activity
patterns consists of 1) 3-spikes burst beginning with escaping, 2) one alternation of bursts each
consisting of 3-spikes and 3) 3-spikes burst ending with escaping. In some case, we have
chaotic-like activity patterns also. The activity patterns when [Ca] = 0.68 and
syng
=0.9 provides
one example. In this case, long repetition of periodic patterns stated above is interrupted by
syng
intermittent occurrences of other types of long burst alternation. For other values of
,
syng
values over which chaotic
however, periodic patterns appear again. As a result, the range of
patterns appear is significantly reduced. In other words, the occurrence of irregular patterns
shows sensitivity to [Ca] values. Hence we include [Ca] in our fast/slow analysis.
To begin fast/slow analysis, we first regard [Ca] as a constant ([Ca] = 0.7 in the following
analysis unless mentioned otherwise), while σ and r are slow variables. Then we can explore the
bifurcation diagram of the fast subsystem with parameters σ and r. We first fix r and consider σ
to be a bifurcation parameter. Fig. 5B shows the resulting bifurcation diagram when r = 1. We
have Z-shaped curve of fixed points. For larger values of σ, there are three fixed points; the
lower fixed point is stable, the middle is a saddle, and the upper is unstable. As σ decreases,
lower stable and middle saddle fixed points merge at a saddle-node bifurcation (labeled SN).
There is also a subcritical Hopf bifurcation point on the upper branch and fixed points become
stable once passed this point (thick black). A branch of the unstable periodic orbit (thin gray)
which becomes to be stable (thick black) emanates from the Hopf bifurcation point and becomes
a saddle-node homoclinic orbit when σ = σSN. In fact, this bifurcation structure persists for each r
on [0, 1].
We trace the saddle-node bifurcation point (SN) in the bifurcation diagram as r varies to get a
two dimensional bifurcation diagram which is shown in Fig. 6A. We call the resulting curve Σ-
8
curve (gray curve in the (σ, r) plane at Fig. 6A). The fast subsystem shows sustained spiking in
the region left to Σ (spiking region) and quiescence in the region right Σ (silent region). Note that
if r is sufficiently small, then we cannot get an oscillatory solution. Fig. 6A also shows frequency
curves (dependence of frequency of spikes on the total synaptic input σ for different values of r)
in the spiking region. Fig. 6B provides another view of these curves. There is a band-like region
of lower frequency along Σ, visible in the frequency curve when r = 0.25. This band is more
prominent along the lower part of Σ and this will play an important role in the generation of
overlapped spiking.
4.2. Regular out-of-phase bursting solutions in the phase plane of slow
variables and linear stability under constant calcium level
Fig. 7 shows the two parameter bifurcation diagram with the projection of regular 2-spike out-of-
syng = 0.86. Without loss of generality, let’s assume that active cell
phase bursting solution when
is cell 2 and silent cell is cell 1. We will follow trajectories of both cells from the moment when
cell 2 fires its second spike. Upper filled circle in Fig. 7 denotes (σ1, 1r ) of cell 1 and lower filled
circle denotes (σ2, 2r ) of cell 2 at this moment.
First note that synaptic variable s of a cell rises once membrane potential rises, passes certain
threshold ( gθ ), and stays above it; s decreases otherwise (Eq. 4). More precisely, if membrane
α α β+
, and if it is less than gθ , then s
gθ , then s quickly approaches
/ (
)
potential is larger than
slowly approaches 0 (Eq. 4). Hence s repeats ups and downs when a cell fires a series of action
potentials, while it decreases monotonically when a cell is silent. We also note that total synaptic
input σ is a weighted sum of synaptic variables multiplied by synaptic strength. For example, σ1
syng
(0.3* s1+ s2). Therefore, even though a cell is in active phase, corresponding total synaptic
=
input σ shows wiggles with reduced amplitude due to self-inhibition (Fig. 5A).
Now let’s return to the trajectories in Fig. 7. When cell 2 fires its second spike, s2 approaches
α α β+
quickly but s1 is small (around 0.1) and keeps decreasing, hence the increment of σ1
/ (
)
α α β+
α α β+
syng
syng
is near
/ (
)
while the increment of σ2 is near 30% of
/ (
)
. Due to this
large increment in σ1, (σ1, 1r ) is shifted to the silent phase (open circle) while (σ2, 2r ) is slightly
gθ , both s1 and s2 begin to decrease
shifted to the right. Once membrane potential drops below
and so do both σ1 and σ2 .
To understand dynamics of r when cell 2 fires its second spike, we need to consider the
governing equation of r (Eq. 2). For the clarity of explanation, we rewrite it here:
−
r V
dr
r
(
)
=
φ
∞
τ
r
V
dt
)
(
r
9
Vτ
φ . For example,
The dynamics of r is driven by two factors:
r V∞
(
)
and the time constant
(
) /
r
r
0V . Then r approaches
r V∞
suppose that membrane potential V is fixed at some value
over
0(
)
φ. The
Vτ
r V∞
time. How fast or slowly r approaches
0(
)
is determined by the time constant
0(
) /
r
r
Vτ
φ is
r V∞
smaller the time constant is, the faster r approaches
0(
)
. As was stated before,
(
) /
r
r
49.2 over reasonable range of voltage V. Thus, the dynamics of r is mainly driven by the values
r V∞
r V∞
is close to zero if membrane potential V is sufficiently large and is
of
(
)
. Value of
(
)
close to one for sufficiently small values of V. There is a monotonic transition between these two
states over intermediate values of V. When a cell fires an action potential, membrane potential
goes through three stages: 1) fast up and down of voltage, 2) afterhyperpolarization period, and
r V∞
3) recovery period. Accordingly,
(
)
takes small values close to zero during up/down strokes,
large values close to one during afterhyperpolarization period, and then intermediate values over
recovery period. This explains the behavior of 2r in Fig.7, where 2r decreases initially, increases
for a while, and then decreases again. The dynamics of 1r is more simple. When cell 2 fires its
second spike, 1r first increases due to the hyperpolarization caused by inhibitory input from cell
2 and then decreases as the inhibition wears off.
Let us consider how far 1r can go under hyperpolarization. It is an important issue in the current
study because larger value of r may result in longer duration of post-inhibitory rebound burst
[20,28] when a cell is released from inhibition and enters spiking region (Fig. 8). The increment
of 1r under hyperpolarization depends on the following two factors: degree of hyperpolarization
and duration of hyperpolarization. Degree of hyperpolarization is a function of synaptic strength
syng
syng
determines how much the membrane potential V can be lowered by
(
) because
r V∞
inhibitory input from the other cell. Admitting that the dynamics of r is driven by
and
(
)
controls the maximum level that r
takes values close to 1 over sufficiently small V,
r V∞
syng
(
)
may reach during hyperpolarization. In other words, the degree of hyperpolarization which is
controls the maximum level of 1r . On the other hand. if the duration of
syng
modulated by
hyperpolarization is not sufficient, then 1r may not reach the maximum set up by
syng
.
After some time past Σ in the (σ, r) plane, cell 1 finally fires its first spike (upper square, Fig.7).
We denote the time needed for cell 1 to fire its first spike after it is released from inhibition
(from upper open circle to upper square in Fig. 7) by 1T . It is not clear here whether cell 2 were
able to fire another spike or not if it were not interrupted by cell 1. If cell 2 were able to fire
another spike, then the inter-spike interval between its second and third spikes should be greater
than 1T of cell 1. If not, then cell 2 would get a chance to fire its third spike and cell 1 be
inhibited again. In fact, the lower frequency band along Σ make this scenario possible because
cell 2 traverses near the lower frequency band along Σ after its second spike and this results in
longer inter-spike interval between second and third spikes of cell 2. It is also possible that cell 2
simply leaves the active region after its second spike.
10
Once cell 1 fires its first spike, due to the self-inhibition, (σ1, r1) is also pushed to the right very
quickly and then begins to move to the left slowly to enter the spiking region again to fire its
next spike, while (σ2, r2) traverses mostly silent region. Because the inter-spike interval between
first and second spikes of cell 1is smaller than the time needed for cell 2 to enter the spiking
region and fire its first spike, cell 1 fires its second spike. This comprises the half cycle of the
regular 2-spike bursting solution in the (σ, r) plane of slow variables.
To get some insight into the stability of 2-spike regular out-of-phase bursting solution, we
simplify the dynamics of r by averaging its governing equation. Recall that overall level of r is
increasing in silent region and decreasing in spiking region although it shows up and down
Sr∞ ( Ar∞ ) be the averaged value of
r V∞
fluctuations. Let
over silent (active) phase in the
(
)
governing equation of r (Eq. 2). Here we say that a cell is in the silent phase if it is in the silent
region (right of the Σ ) and is in the active phase if it is in the spiking region. We also assume
r Vτ is almost constant over a physiologically relevant
r Vτ is constant, say
rτ , because
that
(
)
(
)
=
∞ −
k φ τ=
range of V. Then the averaged equation is given by
r
k
r
r
and r∞ is
where
(
'
)
/r
r
=
−
+
e−
for some initial condition r0. In this
either Sr∞ or Ar∞ with general solution
r
r
r
r
0(
)
kt
∞
∞
averaged framework r is monotonically increasing (decreasing) over silent (active) phase.
IT as the time from the point when silent cell is released from inhibition to the point
We define
when (σ, r) reaches Σ and enters spiking region. We also define AT as the time from Σ to its
second spike. As compared to 1T and
2T in Fig. 7,
IT is smaller than 1T and AT is bigger than
We may assume that silent cell fires its first spike when (σ, r) reaches Σ and enters spiking
IT for silent cell to enter spiking region and fire its first spike.
region as in [20]. Now, it takes
Then silent cell becomes active cell and it takes AT to fire its second spike. After its second spike,
IT in the spiking region before it gets inhibition from the other cell. Now
active cell spends
active cell becomes silent cell and it spends AT until it is released from inhibition.
IT and AT are functions of the values of (σ, r) when silent cell is released from inhibition (e.g. at
α α β+
/ (
)
the open circle in Fig. 7). Recall that synaptic variable of active cell approaches
quickly when it fires its second spike while synaptic variable of silent cell is small and keeps
decreasing. Near the regular 2-spike out-of-phase solution, the values of synaptic variable of
active cell are similar in magnitude. In addition, synaptic variable of silent cell is multiplied by
0.3* syng
syng
where
is 0.86. Thus σ of silent cell when it is released from inhibition is dominated
g α α β+
. In fact it takes almost identical values with negligible differences near the
)
/ (
by
syn
regular 2-spike out-of-phase solution. By letting σ being fixed when silent cell is released from
IT and AT as functions of r.
inhibition, we may regard
We will now trace values of r when silent cell is released from inhibition and construct a map for
it. If fixed point of this map is stable, then we may conclude that 2-spike regular out-of-phase
ur be the value of r when silent cell is released from
bursting solution is also stable. Let *
2T .
11
lr the value of r when active cell fires its second spike. Now we trace 1r from
inhibition and *
ur along the simplified trajectory of regular 2-spike bursting solution. When cell 1 fires its first
*
=
+
−
e−
ur
spike, 1r is given by
r
r
r
r
. In the active region, it fires its second spike after
*(
)
kT
S
S
)
(
1
I
*
∞
∞
1
−
+
=
e −
+
until it gets inhibition. At this time, 1r is
r
r
AT r
IT r
r
r
k
T
T
and spends
.
( u
( u
* )
* )
)
1(
(
)
A
A
2
I
A
∞
∞
1
1
=
+
−
e−
r
r
r
r
ur , where
IT , 1r becomes *
(
)
. Combining these three equations, we
After
IkT
S
u
S
2
∞
∞
*
1
have an implicit equation for *
ur
=
r
u
*
+
−
C C e
3
2
−
1
kT
A
e
−
+
C e
1
+
−
k T T
2 (
A
I
)
k T
(
I
+
2
T
A
)
(5)
−
−
∞=
−
∞=
−
∞=
e−
Sr
e
C
r
C
Sr
e
C
)IkT
(1
where
1r ( 0
2r ) be a value
. Now let
)AkT
(1
, and
)
(1
,
A
0
3
1
2
of 1r ( 2r ) near *
lr ) when cell 2 fires its second spike and we trace them in the slow phase
ur ( *
IT and AT are functions of
1r during the first half cycle. After
IT r
plane. Note that
, we have
1(
)
0
0
+
ATT
I
−
k
(
)
+
+
(
(
r
0
u
r
0
l
−
−
r
S
∞
r
A
∞
e
)
e
)
−
kT
I
−
kT
I
let
=
⎞
⎟
⎠
⎛
⎜
⎝
r
1
u
r
1
l
⎞
⎟
⎠
(6)
⎛
⎜
⎝
r
0
u
r
0
l
⎞
⎟
⎠
(cid:54)
r
S
∞
r
A
∞
⎛
⎜
⎝
Again, after
AT r
1(
0
)
, we have
⎛
⎜
⎝
r
1
u
r
1
l
⎞
⎟
⎠
(cid:54)
r
A
∞
r
S
∞
⎛
⎜
⎝
+
+
r
{
S
∞
r
{
A
∞
+
+
(
(
r
0
u
r
0
l
−
−
r
S
∞
r
A
∞
e
)
e
)
−
kT
I
−
kT
I
−
−
r
A
∞
r
S
∞
e
}
e
}
−
kT
A
−
k
T
A
let
=
⎞
⎟
⎠
⎛
⎜
⎝
r
2
u
r
2
l
⎞
⎟
⎠
(7)
We let
F x
( )
1
F x y
( ,
2
=
+
+
r
r
(
{
A
S
∞
∞
=
+
+
r
r
)
{
A
S
∞
∞
x
(
−
y
r e
)
S
∞
−
r
)
A
∞
kT
A
x
( )
−
kT
I
x
( )
−
kT
I
e
−
x
( )
−
r
e
}
A
∞
−
r
e
}
S
∞
(8)
−
kT
A
x
( )
Then Eq. (7) becomes
⎛
⎜
⎝
r
2
u
r
2
l
⎞ =
⎟
⎠
⎛
⎜
⎝
F r
(
0
u
1
F r
,
(
0
u
2
)
r
0
l
⎞
⎟
⎠
)
Similarly, over the remaining half cycle,
(9)
⎛
⎜
⎝
2
r
l
r
2
u
⎞
⎟
⎠
(cid:54)
⎛
⎜
⎝
F r
(
l
1
F r
,
(
2
l
2
2
)
r
2
u
⎞
⎟
⎠
)
=
⎛
⎜
⎝
0
r
F F r
))
,
(
(
0
l
u
1
2
r F r
F F r
),
(
(
,
(
0
0
0
l
u
u
1
2
2
⎞
⎟
⎠
))
(10)
where
IT and AT are functions of
lr .
2
Combining these, we have the following map
12
⎛
⎜
⎝
r
0
u
r
0
l
⎞
⎟
⎠
(cid:54)
⎛
⎜
⎝
r
F F r
r F
(
(
,
),
(
0
0
0
u
u
l
2
2
1
F F r
r
))
(
,
(
0
0
l
u
1
2
))
⎞
⎟
⎠
(11)
ur , *
lr ), we have the following Jacobian matrix
If we linearize this map at ( *
∂
∂
2
F
F
⎤
⎡
2
2
⎥
⎢
∂
∂
x
y
⎢
⎥
∂
∂
F
F
⎥
⎢
1
1
⎢
⎥
∂
∂
x
x
⎣
⎦
(12)
where
∂
F
1
∂
x
∂
F
1
∂
y
∂
F
2
∂
x
∂
F
2
∂
y
=
S
(
r
∞
−
r
∞
A
)
e
−
kT
A
(
u
r
*
)
−
(
kT r
(
u
'
A
*
)
)
+
e
−
k T
(
A
(
u
r
*
+
)
T
I
(
u
r
*
))
+
(
r
u
*
−
S
r
∞
)
e
−
k T
(
A
(
r
u
*
+
)
T
I
(
u
r
*
))
−
(
k T r
(
(
u
'
I
*
)
+
T r
(
u
'
A
*
)
))
=
0
=
A
(
r
∞
−
S
r
∞
)
e
−
kT
A
(
u
r
*
)
−
(
kT r
(
u
'
A
*
)
)
+
(
r
l
*
−
r
∞
A
)
e
−
k T
(
(
u
r
*
+
)
T
I
(
u
r
*
A
))
−
(
k
T
(
'
I
(
r
u
*
)
+
T
'
A
(
r
u
*
)))
=
e
−
k T
(
A
(
u
r
*
+
)
T
I
(
u
r
*
))
(13)
IT =
ur =
Ar∞ =
Sr∞ =
lr =
In the current example, we have
, *
, *
and
13
,
,
0.3106
0.39
0.45
0.6606
AdT dr r = −
IdT dr r = −
AT =
u
u
41
. Using these values,
27
)
/
/
(
)
16
and
(
. Numerically computed
*
*
we found the eigenvalues of linearized map as 0.142 and 0.099, which implies that 2-spike
solution is stable.
4.3. Dependence of number of spikes in a burst on the slow variables r and
[Ca]
To analyze the dynamics that underlies the irregular sequence of burstings with overlapped
spiking, we first checked how many spikes a cell is able to fire when it is released from
inhibition and inter-spike intervals between these spikes. If a cell fires a series of action
potentials after release from inhibition , a cell is said to have post-inhibitory rebound (PIR) burst
property and STN cell has this property [28]. Duration of PIR burst, patterns of action potentials
within PIR burst, and, in turn, number of spikes per burst depend on intrinsic properties of cell
and network.
13
First, we note that T-type current is responsible for a PIR property of STN cell. In terms of slow
variables, PIR property depends on gating variable r of T-type current, which determines the
level of availability of T-type current. In the plane of slow variables (σ, r), larger value of r
means the possibility of longer stay in spiking region when a cell is released from inhibition,
hence a larger number of spikes within a burst is implicated.
To have larger r, sufficient level and duration of hyperpolarization are required. As was
explained above, the maximal level r can reach under inhibition is governed by (
. If a cell is
r V∞
)
sufficiently hyperpolarized (hence the overall level of membrane potential during inhibition is
sufficiently low), then
becomes close to one. Recall that degree of hyperpolarization is
r V∞
(
)
= . In fact,
modulated by syng
syng
. Thus, if
is sufficiently large, then we may assume that
r V∞
(
) 1
syng
this was assumed and used in the analysis of cluster solution in [20]. Over the range of
r V∞
values considered in the current study, however, we have only intermediate level of
(
)
. For
Sr∞ was 0.6606 when
syng = 0.86 as we saw in previous section.
example,
r V∞
syng
To reach the maximum level set up by
, a cell also needs to be
(
)
, say averaged
inhibited sufficiently long by a sequence of action potentials with short inter-spike intervals. The
requirement of sufficiently long inhibition is obvious because it takes some time for r to
r V∞
converge to the averaged
(
)
due to the slow time scale of the process. On the other hand,
firing rate of action potentials within a PIR burst should be sufficiently high. If the inter-spike
interval between inhibitory inputs is large, then cell may be depolarized and r begins to decrease.
This may result in the lowering of overall level of r even though a cell gets sufficiently long
syng
hyperpolarization. For example, in the previous section the maximum level set up by
is
Sr∞ =
ur =
while the level of r when a cell is released from inhibition is *
and the
0.45
0.6606
following maximum value of r is 0.521 (Fig. 7). This may be due to the insufficient duration of
inhibition (just 2 spikes) and relatively larger inter-spike intervals.
Second, decay rates of r and σ and their ratio also play an important role in the generation of
spikes within PIR burst because trajectory of (σ, r) in the slow phase plane is modulated by them
after release from inhibition. For example, suppose that σ decays fast and r decays slowly. Then,
(σ, r) moves leftward almost horizontally in the slow phase plane. Hence it quickly passes
through the low frequency band along with Σ, approaches the high frequency region and spends
most of its time there. Thus we expect larger number of spikes per burst. On the other hand, if
the decay rate of r is much faster than that of σ, then (σ, r) moves leftward almost vertically. In
this case, (σ, r) would enter the spiking region, traverse the band of low frequencies and then exit
without spikes or with just one spike. The ‘worst’ scenario is that (σ, r) is even not able to enter
the spiking region.
Third, the number of spikes within PIR burst is also limited by self-inhibition because (σ, r) in
the slow phase plane is pushed to the right when a cell fires. This would result in longer inter-
spike intervals due to the geometry of frequency curves over the slow phase plane (Fig. 6). In
14
syng
, self-inhibition would force the trajectory of (σ, r) to stay
addition, under current values of
mostly in the band of low frequencies. In some cases, (σ, r) even has to re-enter the spiking
region as seen in Figure 7. Therefore, we would expect not a large number of spikes but 2- or 3-
spikes solutions with long inter-spike intervals.
Fig. 8A illustrates how the number of spikes changes with r at the moment that a cell is released
from inhibition. In this figure, [Ca] is fixed at 0.7. Recall that σ for cell 1 is given by
+
where s1 is its own the synaptic variable and s2 is the synaptic variable of cell 2.
g
s
s
(0.3
)
syn
1
2
Upon firing of cell 2, s2 approaches a value near 1 while s1 is about 0.1. In this example, σ1
approaches 0.927. Hence, we chose 0.927 as an initial condition for σ and the corresponding
vertical line in the slow phase plane is plotted at Fig. 8A. Due to the existence of low frequency
region along Σ, a cell doesn’t fire immediately once past Σ. As expected, number of spikes
increases from 2 to 4 as r increases. In each case, after the last spike, the trajectories traverse the
low frequency band and leave the spiking region without additional spike.
Fig. 8B plots inter-spike intervals of trajectories shown in Fig. 8A. As before, we let 1T be the
time from the moment that a silent cell is released from inhibition to the point that it fires its first
2T as the first inter-spike interval, 3T the second,
4T the third, and so on. As
spike. We define
kT k =
is a function of (σ0, 0r ) at the moment a cell is released
implicated in Fig. 8A,
(
1, 2, 3, ...)
from inhibition. Since σ0 takes almost fixed values under fixed synaptic strength (for example,
kT k =
kT k =
σ ≈ 0.927 when
syng = 0.9),
is mainly a function of 0r . In general,
(
1, 2, 3, ...)
(
1, 2, 3, ...)
decreases as 0r increases because a trajectory in the (σ, r) plane, originating at larger 0r , gets
more chances to traverse higher frequency region, that is, upper left corner of the (σ, r) plane. In
kT k =
addition,
, especially 1T , tends to be leveled off for sufficiently large 0r . This
(
1, 2, 3, ...)
happens because of the geometries of Σ curve and spiking region, especially the low frequency
band along Σ. Σ curve is almost vertical (Fig. 8A) and the frequency curves are almost identical
(Fig. 6) for sufficiently large values of r. Thus, trajectories in the (σ, r) plane, originating at
sufficiently large 0r , pass through qualitatively similar spiking region and their corresponding
kT k =
becomes similar.
(
1, 2, 3, ...)
We now check the effect of calcium concentration on Σ (Fig. 8C). As calcium concentration
increases from 0.4 to 0.8, Σ moves leftward. Fig. 8C also presents values of r and σ when a cell
fires its first spike after release from inhibition. These values also transition to the left along with
their corresponding Σ curves. For lower calcium levels, Σ curves don’t cross the x-axis. In this
low [Ca] case, once a cell is released from inhibition, a trajectory in the (σ, r) plane converges to
the origin and the corresponding cell activity pattern is continuous firing with very low
frequency. On the other hand, Σ crosses the y-axis for larger calcium levels as shown in Fig. 8A.
In this case, a trajectory in the (σ, r) plane eventually escape the spiking region and cell stops
firing. Now consider a trajectory that begins at (σ0, 0r ) when a cell is released from inhibition.
Because the path of this trajectory is determined by (σ0, 0r ), increase of [Ca] does not change this
trajectory but shift the spiking region to the left in the (σ, r) plane. As a result, this trajectory
15
kT k =
becomes closer to the low frequency band left to Σ curve and we can expect that
(
1, 2, 3, ...)
increases as [Ca] increases (Fig. 9C). Fig. 8B also shows
kT curves (dotted lines) when [Ca] is
not a constant but a dynamic variable. Changes in
kT curves are not significant because the
magnitude of [Ca] fluctuations is small.
4.4 The ‘escape’ mechanism and overlapped spiking
Now we consider the mechanism underlying escape in detail using slow variables, especially r
and [Ca]. Fig. 9 demonstrates one example of escaping for
syng = 0.9. In this example, active cell
(gray) fires three spikes and Fig. 9A shows only last two spikes. When active cell fires its last
spike, silent cell (black) also fires. Fig. 9B shows the corresponding trajectories in the slow phase
plane of (σ, r). Black dots denote time t = 0ms and squares t = 40ms in Fig. 9A. Small increment
of σ of active cell in the middle of trajectory followed by large increment at the end of trajectory
means that active cell first fired its last spike and then was inhibited by silent cell. Although
active cell first fired and thus the silent cell got inhibition, silent cell was also able to fire because
the membrane potential of silent cell crossed the spike threshold when it was inhibited (Fig. 9A).
kT of active cell for some k and 1T of silent cell.
We may interpret this as the competition between
kT of active
Whenever active cell fires, silent cell seeks a chance to enter the spiking region. If
cell becomes comparable to 1T of silent cell, the possibility of escaping arises. The example
shown in Fig. 2B illustrates the competition between 3T of active cell and 1T of silent cell, which
facilitates the generation of escape. We note that a stable 3-spike bursting solution satisfies the
following condition
(14)
<
T
3
T
1
<
T
4
that is, before active cell fires its 4th spike, silent cell enters the bursting region and fires. Here 3T
4T are inter-spike intervals of active cell and 1T is of silent cell. In the bursting solution,
and
kT ’s because the values of σ, r, and [Ca] when silent
however, there is no distinction between
kT ’s. This relationship
cell is lastly released from inhibition are fixed and these values determine
syng = 0.94 and 0.96. Similarly, we have
between kT ’s is satisfied for
T
2
<
T
1
<
T
3
(15)
syng = 0.86 and 0.88 over which stable 2-spike bursting solutions exist. In escaping case, for
for
some reason, these relationships between kT ’s are disrupted due to the comparability between 1T
and 3T .
16
Fig. 9C shows curves of 1T and 3T when
syng = 0.9 and [Ca] = 0.66 (black) and 0.7 (gray). Here
[Ca] is not a constant but a variable and the above values are initial values of [Ca] when silent
fr to be the value of 0r such that if 0r =
fr , then
cell is lastly released from inhibition. We define
T=
fr is a function of [Ca] and Fig.
and if 0r < fr ( 0r > fr ), then 1T < 3T ( 1T > 3T ). Naturally,
T
1
3
syng = 0.9, numerically computed
fr exists [Ca] = 0.66 and 0.7. When
fr is
9C demonstrates that
0.474 (0.476, 0.480, 0.483, resp.) when [Ca] is 0.64 (0.66, 0.68, 0.70, resp.).
fr increases as [Ca]
increases.
fr values (middle gray lines with star marks) over a range of [Ca]
Figure 10 shows
and syng
fr show monotonic increase as [Ca] increases.
values. Except for smaller values of
,
syng
fr values form a band from the upper-left corner to the lower-right corner, which
These
separates 2-spike and 3-spike regular bursting solutions. Figure 10 also shows numerically
calculated *r values of 2-spike (lower left four circles) and 3-spike (upper right four squares)
regular bursting solutions. These two groups of
fr values are extrapolated respectively using
syng
quadratic polynomials to the
values of interest, from 0.9 to 0.92. The resulting extrapolated
*r values are also plotted in the same figure.
fr values for
Figure 10 demonstrates the proximity between extrapolated *r values and
from
syng
0.9 to 0.92, over which escaping activity patterns are prominent. Especially the extrapolated
syng
values of *r fall within the band when
is 0.91. We cannot use this result directly because
fr values were obtained from the comparison between inter-spike intervals of the same cell while
we need to compare 3T of active cell and 1T of silent cell. However, the closeness of
fr and *r
may suggest a heuristic explanation on the mechanism underlying escaping. A trajectory starting
at some initial conditions near those of 2-spike bursting solution tends to approach the regular
bursting solution after some time. While doing so, due to the proximity between *r and
fr , 1T of
silent cell becomes comparable to 3T of active cell, which renders the possibility of escaping.
Once escaping happens, both cells fall into 3-spike bursting regime. However, due to the
instability of 3-spike bursting solution, both cells are pushed into2-spike bursting solution
regime again and this process repeated.
Now we look at escaping more closely in the (r, [Ca]) plane. Figure 11A shows the trajectories
of active cell and silent cell from the time when the active cell is released from inhibition to
escaping in the (r, [Ca]) plane. Triangles denote starting points of trajectories. At the first star,
silent cell fires its last spike and active cell is released from inhibition. For the active cell, these
values of r and [Ca] determine inter-spike intervals, which will be compared to 1T of silent cell.
Whenever the active cell fires, 1T is determined by r and [Ca] values of the active cell at that
17
moment. At the moment of the second spike of the active cell, the trajectory of the silent cell lies
close to the open square, the extrapolated 2-spike bursting solution point. As shown in this figure,
the trajectories tend to approach the extrapolated 2-spike bursting solution point. Figure 11B
illustrates how the closeness of the square to the right vertical line causes escaping. As expected
in Fig. 11A, 3T value of the active cell is close to 1T value of silent cell, which facilitates
escaping.
In summary, escaping may result from the closeness between *r and
fr . In (r, [Ca]) plane, each
trajectory approaches the extrapolated values of r and [Ca] in regular 2-spike bursting solution
over time. Due to the proximity of *r and
fr , 1T becomes comparable to 3T and this provides
good ingredient for escaping. Once escaping occurs, σ values of both cells reach larger values
due to the combinations of self-inhibition and inhibition from other cell (Fig. 9B). Because of
this increased amount of σ, it requires longer time for the escaping cell to enter the spiking
region to fire an additional spike. This extended depolarizing period results in a larger value of r
and may enable the escaping cell to fire additional two spikes depending on the availability of T-
type current. If the escaping cell fires additional two spikes, then the other cell would fire three
spikes when it is released due to the extended duration of inhibition. Hence we have 3-spike
alternating bursting patterns. In (r, [Ca]) plane, this means that (r, [Ca]) of silent cell when it is
T>
fr line where 1
T
released from inhibition lies on the right side of
. But after some time, due
3
to the insufficient hyperpolarization, trajectories of two cells come back into 2-spike region and
this process repeats.
While the results in this section may provide a scenario for switching between 2- and 3- spike
burstings with escaping, as stated in Section 4.1, numerical study shows that the slow fluctuation
of [Ca] appears to be responsible for the irregularity of the generation of escaping. Because the
possibility of escaping is very sensitive to the relative timing of the suppressed and active cells,
small differences of [Ca] may determine whether the suppressed cell can escape or not. Further
studies may be needed to explain how the slow fluctuations of [Ca] enhance the robustness of the
irregularity of the activity patterns over the synaptic strength.
5. Discussion
In the present work, we considered a reciprocally connected inhibitory network with self-
inhibition consisting of two cells. There are intervals of coupling parameters over which activity
patterns exhibit an irregular bursting sequence. This characteristic irregular bursting sequence
may be attributed to the frequent occurrence of overlapped spiking (‘escape’) due to the
competition of the two cells. We show that the irregularity of overlapping and the resulting
variability in the number of spikes within a burst significantly reduces the degree of a phase-
locking between the two cells. In this case, the fine temporal structure of phase-locking between
two cells is characterized by intermittent occurrences of relatively short deviations from the
phase-locked state, which is similar to what was observed in experimental data in the brains of
parkinsonian patients [13].
18
To investigate the mechanism underlying this intermittent occurrence of escaping and the
resulting bursting patterns, we considered the dynamics of slow variables and used geometric
methods for analysis. For the fast/slow analysis, we chose three slow variables, the gating
variable r of T-type current, the total synaptic input σ, and calcium concentration [Ca]. We
constructed a two-dimensional bifurcation diagram using r and σ for constant [Ca] to find the Σ-
curve, which divides the slow phase plane into silent and sustained spiking regions. Slow
variation of [Ca] moves this curve horizontally. The sustained spiking region is roughly divided
into two sub-regions according to frequencies, a low frequency band along Σ and a high
frequency region. Since the activity patterns of the cells can be qualitatively described on the
slow phase plane (σ, r) along the trajectory of the system, the geometry of the slow phase plane
including the Σ-curve is an important determiner of the dynamics.
Our results demonstrate that an irregular sequence of burstings results from the complex
interplay between network architecture, decay rates of the synaptic variable and the gating
variable of T- type current, and other intrinsic properties of cells which are responsible for the
geometry of the slow phase plane, especially structure of Σ and low frequency band along it.
Overlapped spiking, the main cause of the irregular sequence of burstings, is the result of
competition between two cells; the suppressed cell may enter the bursting region while the active
cell fires additional spike. In more technical terms, in the system considered in this study, this
overlapped spiking happens due to the competition between 1T of silent cell and
3T of active cell,
where the former is the time from the moment when the suppressed cell is released from
inhibition to its first spike and the latter is the time between second and third spikes. Over the
stable bursting solution regime, the value of r when a cell is released from inhibition, say 0r ,
converges to a stable fixed point *r (Eq. (5)), and there is a fixed relationship between interspike
2T < 1T < 3T for 2-spike solution and 3T < 1T < 4T for 3-spike solution. As
intervals. For example,
syng
increases from 2-spike bursting regime to 3-spike bursting regime, *r increases to approach
fr where 1T equals 3T . Due to this proximity, 0r approaches
fr during the repeated burstings. As
a result, 1T of silent cell and
3T of active cell become comparable. In the 2-spike bursting region,
this proximity also allows a cell to fire an additional spike so that the other cell may be pushed
fr acts as a driving force
into the 3-spike bursting region. In summary, the closeness of *r ’s and
which pushes the solution from 3-spike bursting region into 2-spike region and vice versa. While
the switching between 2- and 3-spike burstings with escaping results from the proximity of *r
fr , the robustness of irregularity in overlapping of spikes seems to come from the slow
and
fluctuation of [Ca] . This may be due to the fact that the possibility of escaping depends on the
small difference between the phases of two cells. Although the amount of change of [Ca] is
small, its effect is significant for the described activity patterns to be robust as to the synaptic
strength, the dopamine-dependent variable.
fr depends on several factors. An appropriate level of the synaptic
This proximity of *r and
pushes r high enough under inhibition. Comparable decay rates of the
syng
coupling strength
synaptic variable σ and the gating variable r along with the self-inhibition architecture and the
19
bending part of Σ let the system stay mostly in the low frequency region in the plane of the slow
variables (σ, r).
Current study is partially based on results of previous studies of STN-GPe network [20,29], in
which sufficiently strong or weak coupling strengths made a rather complete mathematical
analysis possible. In the current study,the intermediate level of synaptic strength along with self-
coupling network architecture makes activity patterns more realistic, however the dynamics and
its analysis is much more complex. It would be desirable to obtain one or two dimensional maps
to explain the existence of chaotic behavior or the route to chaos as some physiologically
relevant parameters change as in [20,29]. However, the chaotic dynamics observed in this study
shows sensitivity to the small difference between values of slow variables, hence analysis using
averaged equations doesn’t work. To trace the trajectories because is challenging due to the
following limitations: intermediate level of synaptic strength, the geometry and low frequency
band of Σ curve, and network architecture with self-inhibition. Instead, the present study outlines
a scenario for a realistically complex dynamics, advancing us beyond the extreme cases of weak
and strong coupling studied earlier.
The considered mechanism of generation of intermittent synchronous patterns requires some
tuning of the parameters of neurons and synapses, which leads to the appropriate timing of spikes.
Thus the question of the overall robustness of this mechanism remains open. However, in
numerical experiments this tuning does not appear to be very fine and allows for some variation
of the parameters characterizing the timings of synapses and ionic channels. Moreover, real
living neuronal networks with larger numbers of neurons and some degree of inhomogeneity
may loosen the requirements for tuning as the variation of parameters in the network may make
the necessary similarity of the time-scales easier to achieve. In addition, robustness to noise
further supports the robustness and generic nature of the considered phenomenon.
This suggests that the considered mechanism is relevant to the experimentally observed cases of
intermittent dynamics. As we described in the Introduction, transient nature of dynamics in
neural systems may be quite general in the nervous system [16,17]. In particular the networks of
the basal ganglia, which inspired the model considered here, exhibit intermittent phase locking,
similar to that considered here [13]. Our recent modeling studies of larger and more realistic
networks showed that the parameter region for realistic intermittent synchrony is located in the
boundary between synchronized (presumably extreme pathological) and nonsynchronized
(presumably normal) dynamics. It was conjectured there that closeness to the synchrony regime
would yield easy formation and dissociation of synchronized neuronal assemblies [1]. The
present study provides one possible generic mechanism for irregular escaping events which
could be responsible for intermittent disruptions of phase-locking between two cells.
This modeling also gives consistent results in that dopamine-dependent synaptic coupling
syng
strength
controls various activity patterns and the transitions between them. As we showed
above, an intermediate level of synaptic strength is crucial in the generation of overlapped
spiking in conjunction with the geometry of Σ. Under the loss of dopamine, STN cell becomes
sensitive to the inputs from GPe [22,23,24,25]. Hence the loss of dopaminergic cells in
syng
Parkinson’s disease may result in an increase of sensitivity of the STN cell and of
. These
20
syng
experimental results are consistent with our current study: up to some level of
the network
exhibits low-correlation activity patterns which correspond to the normal state of the basal
syng
ganglia. But for intermediate value of
the network shows more synchronized activity, which
is interrupted by desynchronized events such as overlapped spiking. This fits very well with the
comparison of the larger model network with experimental data [1], which suggests that
parkinsonian state is characterized by intermediate (rather than large) values of synaptic
strength syng
and other related parameters.
The mutual inhibition of bursting neurons (direct or through excitatory cells) in our network may
be a fairly generic cellular and network set-up. Thus we think that the considered mechanisms of
intermittent phase-locking have implications for neural systems beyond the basal ganglia,
including subcortical areas or, possibly, central pattern generators.
Acknowledgements
We thank Dr. R.M. Worth for his comments on the manuscript.
This study was supported by NIH grant R01NS067200 (NSF/NIH CRCNS program).
References
1.
Park, C., R. Worth, and L.L. Rubchinsky, Neural Dynamics in Parkinsonian Brain: The Boundary
Between Synchronized and Nonsynchronized Dynamics. Physical Review E, 2011. 83(4): p.
042901.
Engel, A.K., P. Fries, and W. Singer, Dynamic predictions: oscillations and synchrony in top-down
processing. Nat Rev Neurosci, 2001. 2(10): p. 704-16.
Varela, F., et al., The brainweb: phase synchronization and large-scale integration. Nat Rev
Neurosci, 2001. 2(4): p. 229-39.
Buzsaki, G. and A. Draguhn, Neuronal oscillations in cortical networks. Science, 2004. 304(5679):
p. 1926-9.
Baker, S.N., et al., The role of synchrony and oscillations in the motor output. Exp Brain Res, 1999.
128(1-2): p. 109-17.
Sanes, J.N. and J.P. Donoghue, Oscillations in local field potentials of the primate motor cortex
during voluntary movement. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 1993. 90(10): p. 4470-4.
Murthy, V.N. and E.E. Fetz, Oscillatory activity in sensorimotor cortex of awake monkeys:
synchronization of local field potentials and relation to behavior. J Neurophysiol, 1996. 76(6): p.
3949-67.
Schnitzler, A. and J. Gross, Normal and pathological oscillatory communication in the brain. Nat
Rev Neurosci, 2005. 6(4): p. 285-96.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
21
Uhlhaas, P.J. and W. Singer, Neural synchrony in brain disorders: relevance for cognitive
dysfunctions and pathophysiology. Neuron, 2006. 52(1): p. 155-68.
Brown, P., Abnormal oscillatory synchronisation in the motor system leads to impaired
movement. Curr Opin Neurobiol, 2007. 17(6): p. 656-64.
Hutchison, W.D., et al., Neuronal oscillations in the basal ganglia and movement disorders:
evidence from whole animal and human recordings. J Neurosci, 2004. 24(42): p. 9240-3.
Hammond, C., H. Bergman, and P. Brown, Pathological synchronization in Parkinson's disease:
networks, models and treatments. Trends Neurosci, 2007. 30(7): p. 357-64.
Park, C., R.M. Worth, and L.L. Rubchinsky, Fine temporal structure of beta oscillations
synchronization in subthalamic nucleus in Parkinson's disease. J Neurophysiol, 2010. 103(5): p.
2707-16.
Bevan, M.D., et al., Move to the rhythm: oscillations in the subthalamic nucleus-external globus
pallidus network. Trends Neurosci, 2002. 25(10): p. 525-31.
Mallet, N., et al., Parkinsonian beta oscillations in the external globus pallidus and their
relationship with subthalamic nucleus activity. J Neurosci, 2008. 28(52): p. 14245-58.
Rabinovich, M., R. Huerta, and G. Laurent, Neuroscience. Transient dynamics for neural
processing. Science, 2008. 321(5885): p. 48-50.
Nowotny, T., R. Huerta, and M.I. Rabinovich, Neuronal synchrony: peculiarity and generality.
Chaos, 2008. 18(3): p. 037119.
Parent, A., et al., Organization of the basal ganglia: the importance of axonal collateralization.
Trends Neurosci, 2000. 23(10 Suppl): p. S20-7.
Terman, D., et al., Activity patterns in a model for the subthalamopallidal network of the basal
ganglia. J Neurosci, 2002. 22(7): p. 2963-76.
Best, J., et al., Transitions between irregular and rhythmic firing patterns in excitatory-inhibitory
neuronal networks. J Comput Neurosci, 2007. 23(2): p. 217-35.
Ahn, S., C. Park, and L.L. Rubchinsky, Detecting the temporal structure of intermittent phase
locking. Physical Review E, in press.
Floran, B., et al., Dopamine D4 receptors inhibit depolarization-induced [3H]GABA release in the
rat subthalamic nucleus. Eur J Pharmacol, 2004. 498(1-3): p. 97-102.
Cragg, S.J., et al., Synaptic release of dopamine in the subthalamic nucleus. Eur J Neurosci, 2004.
20(7): p. 1788-802.
Shen, K.Z. and S.W. Johnson, Dopamine depletion alters responses to glutamate and GABA in the
rat subthalamic nucleus. Neuroreport, 2005. 16(2): p. 171-4.
Baufreton, J. and M.D. Bevan, D2-like dopamine receptor-mediated modulation of activity-
dependent plasticity at GABAergic synapses in the subthalamic nucleus. J Physiol, 2008. 586(8): p.
2121-42.
Hegger, R., H. Kantz, and T. Schreiber, Practical implementation of nonlinear time series
methods: The TISEAN package. Chaos, 1999. 9(2): p. 413-435.
Wang, X.J. and J. Rinzel, Alternating and Synchronous Rhythms in Reciprocally Inhibitory Model
Neurons. Neural Computation, 1992. 4(1): p. 84-97.
Bevan, M.D., et al., Regulation of the timing and pattern of action potential generation in rat
subthalamic neurons in vitro by GABA-A IPSPs. J Neurophysiol, 2002. 87(3): p. 1348-62.
Park, C. and D. Terman, Irregular behavior in an excitatory-inhibitory neuronal network. Chaos,
2010. 20(2): p. 023122.
22
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
Figures
Figure1. Network architecture. (A) Reciprocally connected large STN-GPe network. Arrow
indicates excitatory connection and circle indicates inhibitory connection. (B) Reduced network
of two inhibitory cells with self-inhibition.
Figure 2. (A) Averaged coherence over 0-100 Hz band (black) and 10-30 Hz band (gray)
between voltages of two cells. Coupling strength syng
varies from 0.1 to 2 with 0.1 stepsize. (B)
Phase-locking index γ in dependence on
syng
. Different lines denote different strength of self-
coupling; default value is 30% (black solid) and two other strengths, 25% (dotted) and 35%
(gray) are also shown for comparison. (C) Activity patterns with irregular sequence of burstings
with overlapped spikes when
syng = 0.9.
Figure 3. Return map
1nr + vs. nr for different values of the synaptic strength parameter
syng
(A)
syng
presents five different values of
: 0.86(square), 0.88(circle), 0.94(triangle), 0.96(diamond)
syng = 0.9. (C) Maximal
and 0.92(gray dots). (B) More complex dynamics observed for
Lyapunov exponents (MLEs) over a range of refined syng
values between 0.9 and 0.92. When
syng
syng
lies between 0.9 and 0.91, MLE values are significant as compared to other range of
syng
values, chaotic activity patterns may be robust.
values. Over this range of
Figure 4. Irregular partially-synchronous dynamics of reduced model when
syng = 0.9. (A) An
example of escaping. Upper panel shows voltage profiles and lower panel shows corresponding
1iφ+ vs.
iφ. (C) Histrogram of durations of
phases for two neurons. (B) Return map for phases
desynchronization events. Black bars come from experimental data [13].
Figure 5. (A) STN cell activity patterns when
syng = 0.9. Upper panel shows voltage profile and
lower panel shows slow variables r (black solid), σ (lower gray solid), and [Ca] (black dotted).
Refer to Eqs. (2)-(4). The time course of [Ca] is also plotted with the scale on the right vertical
axis (upper gray solid). (B) Bifurcation diagram of the fast subsystem for r = 1 and [Ca] = 0.7.
There is a saddle-node bifurcation point (SN) at σ = σSN and also a subcritical Hopf bifurcation
point on the upper branch where an unstable periodic orbit begins to be turning to a stable
periodic orbit. This stable periodic orbit becomes a saddle-node homoclinic orbit when σ = σSN.
Stable (unstable) fixed points and limit cycles are in thick black (thin gray).
23
Figure 6. The frequency of firing in dependence on the slow variables σ and r. (A) Σ-curve (gray
line in the (σ, r) plane) divides the space of the slow variables (σ, r) into silent and sustained
spiking regions. Over the sustained spiking region, the curves of frequencies are plotted for
various r (0.25, 0.3, 0.35, 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9 and 1, left to right). (B) Another view of
frequency curves from the part (A). For larger values of r, the frequency of the periodic solution
decreases almost linearly as σ decreases and then sharply decreases near Σ. For r ≥ 0.5, the
frequency curves are almost identical.
Figure 7. Two-parameter bifurcation diagram with projection of 2-spike out-of-phase bursting
solution. The close-to-vertical curve in the middle of the figure is the Σ-curve shown in Fig. 6
when [Ca] = 0.7. The moment when active cell fires its last spike is denoted by lower circle and
upper circle denotes (σ, r) of silent cell at that moment. Open circle denotes the moment that
silent cell is released from inhibition. The moment when the silent cell fires its first spike is
denoted by upper square and lower square denotes (σ, r) of active cell at that moment. 1T is the
time needed for silent cell to fire its first spike after it is released from inhibition (from open
2T is inter-spike interval between first and second spike. Black line
circle to upper square) and
is the trajectory of active cell from its first spike until the moment that it gets inhibition to leave
the spiking region. The counterpart of silent cell is denoted by gray trajectory.
Figure 8. Spike firing for different values of r and [Ca]. (A) The number of spikes that a cell
fires depends on the level of r when the cell is released from inhibition. The vertical line (σ =
0.927) is divided into three intervals according to number of spikes, 2, 3, and 4. Boundaries
between these intervals are marked by two dots (r = 0.45 and 0.58). Three exemplary cases for
each number of spikes are presented for r is 0.4 (2 spikes, dotted), 0.5 (3 spikes, black solid), and
2T (left gray solid), 3T (right gray
0.6 (4 spikes, gray solid). (B) Plot of 1T (left black solid),
4T (right black solid) as a function of r. The dotted lines are
kT curves for k = 1,2,3
solid) and
and 4 when [Ca] is slow variable. (C) Σ-curves for several [Ca] levels from 0.4 to 0.8 with
stepsize 0.1 (left to right). Values of r and σ are also plotted when a cell fires its first spike for
various initial values of r, from 0.35 to 0.7 with the stepsize 0.05 (from bottom to top). Synaptic
syng = 0.9.
strength
Figure 9. An example of ‘escaping’ for
syng = 0.9; one cell fires three spikes and during the
firing of its last spike, the other cell also fires. (A) Voltage traces of both cells (only last two
spikes are shown in this figure, black line is escaping cell). (B) The corresponding trajectory in
the phase space of slow variables. Black dots (squares) correspond to time t = 0 (t = 40 ) in part
(A). (C) 1T (solid) and 3T (dotted) curves as a function of r when [Ca] is variable. Initial
conditions for [Ca] are 0.66 (black) and 0.7 (gray).
24
Figure 10. *r and
fr values for the range of
syng
and different values of [Ca]. The lower four
circles and upper four squares are numerically computed *r ’s for 2-spike and 3-spike regular
bursting solutions. The middle three circles and squares are obtained by quadratic extrapolation.
fr ’s for different [Ca] levels are also shown (gray stars and lines, [Ca]
Numerically computed
level increases from 0.6, bottom on the right ,to 0.7, top on the right, with the stepsize of 0.02).
Figure 11. Escaping revisited. (A) An escaping example in the (r, [Ca]) plane. Close to vertical
lines divide the plane according to the number of spikes when a cell is released from inhibition
(Fig. 8). Left to the dotted line is 1-spike region and right 2-spike region. Similarly, right to the
fr in the 3-spike region. Four circles
dashed line is 3-spike region. Solid line is the line of
between middle and right vertical lines denote the values of r and [Ca] when silent cell is lastly
values are from 0.86 to
inhibited in a regular 2-spike bursting solution. From bottom to top,
syng
0.89. Square at the top of this array of circles denotes the extrapolated values of r and [Ca] when
is 0.9. Lower trajectory is active cell and upper trajectory is silent cell and triangles denote
syng
starting points of each trajectory. Stars denote the moments when cells get inhibition either from
kT curves using the calcium level when
itself or from other cell. (B) Three gray solid lines are
the active cell is lastly inhibited. Dots on these curves denote 2T and 3T of active cell computed
from the value of r when the active cell is released. Black curve is 1T of silent cell when it gets
second inhibition and square denotes actual 1T value at that moment.
25
Figure 1
26
Figure 2
27
Figure 3
28
Figure 4
29
Figure 5
30
Figure 6
31
Figure 7
32
Figure 8
33
Figure 9
34
Figure 10
35
Figure 11
36
|
0905.3887 | 2 | 0905 | 2010-03-08T16:41:07 | Mesoscopic organization reveals the constraints governing C. elegans nervous system | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cond-mat.dis-nn",
"physics.bio-ph"
] | One of the biggest challenges in biology is to understand how activity at the cellular level of neurons, as a result of their mutual interactions, leads to the observed behavior of an organism responding to a variety of environmental stimuli. Investigating the intermediate or mesoscopic level of organization in the nervous system is a vital step towards understanding how the integration of micro-level dynamics results in macro-level functioning. In this paper, we have considered the somatic nervous system of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans, for which the entire neuronal connectivity diagram is known. We focus on the organization of the system into modules, i.e., neuronal groups having relatively higher connection density compared to that of the overall network. We show that this mesoscopic feature cannot be explained exclusively in terms of considerations, such as optimizing for resource constraints (viz., total wiring cost) and communication efficiency (i.e., network path length). Comparison with other complex networks designed for efficient transport (of signals or resources) implies that neuronal networks form a distinct class. This suggests that the principal function of the network, viz., processing of sensory information resulting in appropriate motor response, may be playing a vital role in determining the connection topology. Using modular spectral analysis, we make explicit the intimate relation between function and structure in the nervous system. This is further brought out by identifying functionally critical neurons purely on the basis of patterns of intra- and inter-modular connections. Our study reveals how the design of the nervous system reflects several constraints, including its key functional role as a processor of information. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Mesoscopic organization reveals the constraints governing Caenorhabditis elegans
nervous system
The Institute of Mathematical Sciences, C.I.T. Campus, Taramani, Chennai - 600 113 India
Raj Kumar Pan∗ and Sitabhra Sinha†
Nivedita Chatterjee‡
Vision Research Foundation, Sankara Nethralaya, 18 College Road, Chennai - 600 006 India
(Dated: November 21, 2018)
One of the biggest challenges in biology is to understand how activity at the cellular level of
neurons, as a result of their mutual interactions, leads to the observed behavior of an organism
responding to a variety of environmental stimuli. Investigating the intermediate or mesoscopic level
of organization in the nervous system is a vital step towards understanding how the integration
of micro-level dynamics results in macro-level functioning. The coordination of many different co-
occurring processes at this level underlies the command and control of overall network activity. In
this paper, we have considered the somatic nervous system of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans,
for which the entire neuronal connectivity diagram is known. We focus on the organization of the
system into modules, i.e., neuronal groups having relatively higher connection density compared to
that of the overall network. We show that this mesoscopic feature cannot be explained exclusively
in terms of considerations such as, optimizing for resource constraints (viz., total wiring cost) and
communication efficiency (i.e., network path length). Even including information about the genetic
relatedness of the cells cannot account for the observed modular structure. Comparison with other
complex networks designed for efficient transport (of signals or resources) implies that neuronal
networks form a distinct class. This suggests that the principal function of the network, viz.,
processing of sensory information resulting in appropriate motor response, may be playing a vital
role in determining the connection topology. Using modular spectral analysis we make explicit the
intimate relation between function and structure in the nervous system. This is further brought out
by identifying functionally critical neurons purely on the basis of patterns of intra- and inter-modular
connections. Our study reveals how the design of the nervous system reflects several constraints,
including its key functional role as a processor of information.
I. AUTHOR SUMMARY
Why are brains wired in the manner that is observed in
nature? To address this, we analyze the structure of the
Caenorhabditis elegans neuronal network at an interme-
diate level of its organization into groups of densely con-
nected neurons. These structural units, called modules,
are composed of multiple neuronal types which rules out
the possibility that this is a straightforward partition of
the network into sensory and motor regions. Nor do they
have a simple anatomical interpretation (e.g., in terms of
ganglia). We investigate the possibility that this mod-
ular structure developed through an evolutionary drive
to optimize a nervous system subject to different con-
straints. We show that neither wiring cost minimization
nor maximization of communication efficiency are ade-
quate in explaining the observed patterns in the network
topology. The distinction with other complex networks
designed for efficient signal propagation (such as the In-
ternet) suggests that the neuronal network's key func-
tional requirement of information processing may play a
crucial role in determining its overall structure. Analyz-
∗Electronic address: [email protected]
†Electronic address: [email protected]
‡Electronic address: [email protected]
ing the network organization at the mesoscopic level also
allows us to identify neurons belonging to known func-
tional circuits and predict those that may play a vital
part in some as yet undetermined function.
II.
INTRODUCTION
The relatively simple nervous systems of invertebrate
organisms provide vital insights into how nerve cells inte-
grate sensory information from the environment, result-
ing in a coordinated response. Analysing the intermedi-
ate or mesoscopic level of organization in such systems
is a crucial step in understanding how micro-level ac-
tivity of single neurons and their interactions eventually
result in macro-level behavior of the organism [1]. The
nematode Caenorhabditis elegans is a model organism on
which such an analysis can be performed, as its entire
neuronal wiring layout has been completely mapped [2].
This information enables one to trace in full the course of
activity along the neuronal network, from sensory stim-
ulation to motor response [3]. We study its somatic ner-
vous system, comprising 282 neurons that control all ac-
tivity except the pharyngeal movements. This can lead to
an understanding of the command and control processes
occurring at the mesoscopic level that produce specific
functional responses, including avoidance behavior and
movement along a chemical gradient. The neuron loca-
tions as well as their connections being completely de-
termined by the genetic program, are invariant across
individual organisms [3]. Further, unlike in higher or-
ganisms, the connections do not change with time in the
adult nematode [4]. In combination with the possibility
of experimenting on the role of single neurons in differ-
ent functional modalities, these invariances allow one to
uniquely identify the important neurons in the system
having specific behavioral tasks.
The recent developments in the theory of complex
graphs has made available many analytical tools for
studying biological networks [5, 6]. The initial emphasis
was on developing gross macroscopic descriptions of such
systems using measures such as average path length be-
tween nodes of the network, the clustering among nodes
and the degree sequences (the number of links per node).
However, such global characterizations of systems ignore
significant local variations in the connection topology
that are often functionally important. Therefore, investi-
gating the network at a mesoscopic level which consider
the broad patterns in the inhomogeneous distribution of
connections, may reveal vital clues about the working of
an organism that could be hidden in a global analysis.
Further, these large-scale features help in understanding
how coordination and integration occurs across different
parts of the system, in contrast to a study of microscopic
patterns comprising only a few neurons, e.g., motifs [7].
The existence of modules, marked by the occurrence of
groups of densely connected nodes with relatively fewer
connections between these groups [8], provides a natu-
ral meso-level description of many complex systems [9].
In biological networks, such modular organization has
been observed across many length scales, from the intra-
cellular protein-protein interaction system [10, 11] to
food webs comprising various species populations [12].
The relation between certain modules and specific func-
tions, e.g., in metabolic networks [13], helps us to un-
derstand how different functions are coordinated in the
integral performance of complex biological networks.
Modular organization in the brains of different species
have been observed, both in functional networks derived
from EEG/MEG and fMRI experiments and in struc-
tural networks obtained from tracing anatomical connec-
tions [14]. Functionally defined networks are constructed
by considering brain areas, comprising a large number of
localized neuronal groups, which are linked if they are
simultaneously active. Such systems have been shown to
be modular for both human [15, 16] and non-human [17]
subjects. Tract-tracing studies in the brains of cat [18]
and macaque [19] have also revealed a modular layout in
the structural inter-connections between different corti-
cal areas. However, as neurons are the essential build-
ing blocks of the nervous system, ideally one would like
to explore the network of interconnections between these
most basic elements. In the extremely complicated mam-
malian brains, it is so far only possible to analyze such
networks for extremely limited regions that do not give a
picture of how the system behaves as a whole [20]. The
2
relative simplicity of the nervous system of C. elegans al-
lows a detailed analysis of the network, defined in terms
of both electrical (gap junctional) and chemical (synap-
tic) connections between the neurons (Fig. 1).
Head
IN
Anterior (G1)
Dorsal (G2)
Lateral (G3)
Ventral (G4)
Retrovesicular (G5)
SCC
98% nodes
99% links
OUT
Lumbar (G9)
Dorsorectal (G8)
Posterolateral (G6)
A
Tail
Ventral Cord (G10)
C
Pre−anal (G7)
n
o
i
l
g
n
a
G
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
B
10
n
o
i
l
g
n
a
G
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
1 2
3
5 6 7 8 9
4
Ganglion
10
1 2
3
5 6 7 8 9
4
Ganglion
10
FIG. 1: Neuronal position and connectivity in the so-
matic nervous system of the nematode C. elegans in-
dicating the different ganglia. (a) Schematic diagram of
C. elegans, indicating the different ganglia. (Inset) Schematic
representation of connectivity between the neurons, parti-
tioned into a strongly connected component (SCC), an in-
component (IN), and an out-component (OUT). A directed
path exists from any neuron in IN to any neuron in OUT
through neurons in SCC, all of whose members can be reached
from each other. The large SCC suggests that it is possible
to transfer signals between almost all neurons of the network.
The IN and OUT components have only 1.5% and 0.5%, re-
spectively, of the 279 connected neurons in the somatic ner-
vous system. (b, c) The connectivity matrix corresponding to
the (b) Synaptic and (c) Gap-junctional connections between
the somatic system neurons. In all figures, the partition sym-
bols correspond to (G1) Anterior, (G2) Dorsal, (G3) Lateral,
(G4) Ventral, (G5) Retrovesicular, (G6) Posterolateral, (G7)
Preanal, (G8) Dorsorectal and (G9) Lumbar ganglion, and
(G10) the Ventral cord.
The ubiquity of modularity in brain networks leads to
the obvious question about how to explain the evolution
of such a structural organization [21]. One possible rea-
son for the existence of modular architecture is that it
may result in low average path length (which is associ-
ated with high efficiency of signal communication) and
high clustering (that allows local segregation of informa-
tion processing) in networks [22]. An alternative possibil-
ity is that segregation of neurons into spatially localized
communities minimizes the total cost associated with the
wiring length (the physical distance spanned by connec-
tions between neurons). This cost arises from resources
associated with factors such as wiring volume as well as
metabolism required for maintenance and propagation of
signals across long distances [23]. Developmental con-
straints, such as the lineage relations between different
neurons may also play an important role in determining
the connection topology of the neuronal network [24]. In
addition, the existence of empirically determined circuits
responsible for specific functions (such as, movement as-
sociated with exploratory behavior, egg laying, etc.) in
the C. elegans nervous system, raises the intriguing pos-
sibility that structurally defined modules are associated
with definite functional roles [25]. The invariant neuronal
connectivity profile of C. elegans allows us to explore the
contributions of the above mentioned structural, develop-
mental and functional constraints in governing the meso-
scopic organization of the nervous system.
In this paper, we begin our analysis of the organi-
zation of the C. elegans nervous system by identifying
structurally defined modules in the network of neurons
linked by synapses and gap-junctions. Next, we inves-
tigate whether the observed modular structure can be
explained by using arguments based on universal prin-
ciples. Such criteria, which include minimizing the cost
associated with neuronal connections [23, 26] and their
genetic encoding [27], or, decreasing the signal propaga-
tion path [28, 29], have recently been proposed to explain
observed patterns of neuronal position and connectivity.
Complementing the above studies, we seek to understand
the factors determining the topological arrangement of
the nervous system, given the physical locations of the
neurons. We determine the role of physical proximity
between a pair of neurons in deciding the connection
structure, by investigating the correlation between their
spatial positions and their modular membership. We also
compare these modules with the existing classification of
the nematode nervous system into several ganglia, as the
latter have been differentiated in terms of anatomical lo-
calization of their constituent neurons. Results from the
above analysis suggests that resource constraints such as
wiring cost cannot be the sole deciding factor governing
the observed meso-level organization. We also show that
the modules cannot be only a result of the common lin-
eage of their member nodes.
It is natural to expect that the structure of the nervous
system is optimized to rapidly process signals from the
environment so that the organism can take appropriate
action for its survival [30]. By looking at the deviation
between the actual network and a system optimized for
maximal communication efficiency in conjunction with
minimum wiring cost, we infer the existence of additional
functional constraints possibly related to processing of in-
formation (i.e., other than rapid signal transmission). In-
formation processing refers to the transformation of sig-
nals [31], such as selective suppression of activation in
specific pathways, which allows different sensory stimuli
to initiate response in distinct sets of motor neurons. Ab-
sence of such transformations would result in non-specific
arousal of a large number of connected neurons, and will
not achieve the high level of control and coordination
necessary for performing a variety of specific functional
3
tasks. This is also related to the observation of rela-
tively high clustering in C. elegans neuronal network as
compared to other information networks (e.g., electronic
logic circuits [32]). Previous investigation of the role of
clustering in the performance of neural network models in
associative recall of stored patterns, has shown that lower
clustering exhibits much better performance [33]. It has
also been shown that the clustering in C. elegans neuronal
network is higher than that in degree-conserved random-
ized networks having the same wiring cost [28]. There-
fore, the presence of enhanced clustering in a system that
has evolved under intense competition for survival may
imply it plays a key role in processing information.
This brings us to the possibility that the observed dis-
tribution of neurons among modules is closely related
to the behavioral requirements of the organism. For this
purpose, we investigate the relation between the modules
and the different functional circuits governing specific be-
havioral aspects of C. elegans. We identify the functional
importance of certain key neurons by observing their rel-
ative connectivity within their module as compared to
that with neurons belonging to other modules. By look-
ing at the correlation between local and global connectiv-
ity profiles of individual neurons, we observe that the ne-
matode nervous system is different from systems designed
for rapid signal transfer, including other information net-
works occurring in the technological domain, such as the
Internet. Further, in contrast to previous observations on
the similarity between biological signalling networks hav-
ing different origins [34, 35], we find that the C. elegans
neuronal network has properties distinct from at least
one other biological network involved in signalling, the
protein interaction network (viz., in terms of the assor-
tativity and the role-to-role connectivity profile) [36, 37].
Thus, the analysis of the network at the mesoscopic
level provides an appropriate framework for identifying
the roles that different classes of constraints (develop-
mental, structural and functional) play in determining
the organization of a nervous system.
It allows us to
infer the existence of criteria related to processing of in-
formation governing the observed modular architecture
in C. elegans neuronal inter-connections. It also provides
the means for identifying neurons having key roles in the
behavioral performance of the organism exclusively from
anatomical information about their structural connectiv-
ity. Our results can help experimentalists in focusing
their attention to a select group of neurons which may
play a vital part in as yet undetermined functions.
III. RESULTS
A. Modular structure of the C.elegans somatic
nervous system
We begin our study of the mesoscopic organization of
the network by focusing on identifying its modular ar-
rangement. In order to determine the community struc-
ture of the C. elegans neuronal network, we perform an
optimal partitioning of the system into modules, that cor-
responds to the maximum value of modularity parameter,
Q (see Methods for details on modularity measure Q and
the algorithm used for modularity determination). We
have considered different cases corresponding to the dif-
ferent types of neuronal connections (viz., gap junctions
and synapses) and the nature of such connections (i.e.,
unweighted or weighted by the number of connections be-
tween a given pair). While the gap junctional network is
undirected, the directional nature of signal propagation
through a synapse implies that the synaptic network is
directed. For each network, we have obtained using the
spectral method, the maximum modularity QM and the
corresponding number of partitions (Table I). Note that,
the number of modules and their composition is depen-
dent on the type of connections we consider.
As we want to consider all connections in our study,
we have also worked with an aggregate network that in-
cludes synapses as well as gap junctions. Throughout
this paper, we have reported results for this weighted
combined network, unless stated otherwise (see Text S1
for the analysis of the network of synaptic connections).
The link weights in the combined network correspond to
the total number of synaptic and gap junctional connec-
tions from one neuron to another. The high value of
QM and dense inter-connectivity within modules (Fig. 2,
a) suggest that the network has a modular organization
(Table S1). We further validate our results by calculat-
ing the modularity of randomized versions of the network
where the degree of each node is kept fixed (see Methods
for the network randomization procedure). The average
modularity of these randomized networks is considerably
lower than that of the empirical network. We examine
the robustness of the modular partitioning with respect
to the method used for detecting communities by using
another module determination algorithm [38]. However,
this produces a lower value for Q(= 0.434) compared to
the spectral method. The three modules identified us-
ing this alternative method have a substantial overlap
(normalized mutual information I = 0.496) with the six
modules obtained using the spectral method. It suggests
that the alternative algorithm yields a coarser-grained
picture of the network communities that are considered
in the rest of the paper.
The modules do not have a simple relation with the
anatomical layout of the worm. In particular, they are
not a result of a simple division of the nervous system
into groups responsible for receiving sensory input, and
other groups involved in motor output. In Fig. 2 (b), we
have analyzed the composition of the different modules in
terms of distinct neuron types (viz. sensory, motor and
inter-neurons). None of the modules are exclusively com-
posed of a single type of neuron, although motor neurons
do tend to dominate one module.
A
VI
V
l
s
e
u
d
o
M
IV
III
II
I
0.45
B
Sensory
Motor
Inter
Others
0.4
0.35
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
y
t
i
s
n
e
D
n
o
i
t
c
e
n
n
o
C
I
II
III
IV
Modules
V
VI
I
II
III
IV
Modules
V
VI
4
1
s
n
o
r
u
e
n
f
o
n
o
i
t
c
a
r
F
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
FIG. 2: Modular interconnectivity and decomposition
according to neuron type.
(a) Matrix representing the
average connection density between neurons occurring within
modules and those in different modules. The figure indicates
that neurons within a module are densely interconnected com-
pared to the overall connectivity in the network.
(b) The
modules are decomposed according to the different neuron
types comprising them. The figure shows that the modules
are not simply composed of a single type of neuron.
B. Modules and spatial localization
To understand why modular structures occur in the
neuronal network, we first consider the relation between
the optimal partitions and the spatial localization of neu-
rons in each module. This can tell us whether constraints
related to the physical nearness between neurons, such as
minimization of the wiring length, dictate the topologi-
cal organization of the network. Wiring cost has already
been shown to be the decisive factor governing neuron po-
sitions in the body of C. elegans [23, 26]. Thus, a plausi-
ble hypothesis is that, if most neuronal connections occur
within a group of neurons which are physically adjacent
to each other, then the wiring cost will be significantly
decreased.
In terms of connectivity, this will be mani-
fested as a modular organization of the network, where
each module will mostly comprise neurons in close phys-
ical proximity.
Fig. 3 indicates the spatial location of the cell body
for each neuron on the nematode body (along the longi-
tudinal axis), segregated according to their membership
in different modules. We see that a large fraction of the
neurons belonging to the same module do indeed have
their cell bodies close to each other. A one-way ANOVA
test, comparing the positions of the neurons in the dif-
ferent modules with the null hypothesis that they are
drawn from the same population, shows that it can be
rejected at confidence level of 99.9%. However, the large
standard deviations for the distribution of positions of
the module components reveal that none of the modules
are spatially localized at any specific region on the ne-
matode body axis. A more detailed multiple comparison
procedure carried out for every pair of modules shows the
absence of statistically significant spatial separation for
the module pairs (I, III), (I, V), (II, VI), (III, IV), (III,
V), (III, VI) and (IV, VI). The lack of significant dis-
tinction between the modules in terms of their physical
5
TABLE I: Modularity of the C. elegans neuronal network.
Network
Un weighted
Weighted
Qg QM mM I
Qrand
M
mrand
M
Qg QM mM I
Qrand
M
mrand
M
Gap Jn
0.207 0.630 11 0.326 0.467 ± 0.010 10.5 ± 2.2 0.170 0.657 15 0.347 0.519 ± 0.022 12.5 ± 3.9
Synaptic
0.149 0.349
Combined 0.169 0.378
2
3
0.257 0.192 ± 0.013 3.6 ± 0.7 0.211 0.472
0.306 0.156 ± 0.012 3.2 ± 0.7 0.203 0.491
4
6
0.314 0.307 ± 0.018 5.6 ± 1.4
0.376 0.258 ± 0.015 4.9 ± 1.5
The modularity of the network is measured using the parameter Q, which requires a knowledge of the partitions or
communities which divide the network. We obtain the modularity measure, Qg, on assuming the communities to correspond
to the ganglia. Its positive values indicate that neurons in the same ganglion have high density of inter-connections. We have
also obtained Q by determining the modules of the network using a spectral method, the corresponding values being indicated
by QM . The relatively high values of QM compared to Qg, indicates that the ganglia do not match with this optimal
partitioning of the network. The measures, Qg and QM , as well as the number of modules, nM , have been obtained for both
unweighted and weighted networks consisting of either gap junctions or synapses or both. We calculate the overlap between
the ganglionic and the optimal partition of the network using the normalized mutual information index, I. For the case of
perfect match between the two, the index, I = 1, whereas if they are independent of each other, I = 0. The measured values
of I indicate that the overlap between the different modules and the anatomically defined ganglia is not high. The modular
nature of the somatic nervous system is emphasised by comparing the empirical network with networks obtained by
randomizing the connections, keeping the degree of each neuron fixed. The mean and standard deviation of the modularity
Qrand
M are shown for both weighted and unweighted networks, and for the
different types of connections. For all cases, the randomized networks show a significantly lower modularity than the
empirical network.
M and the corresponding number of partitions mrand
l
s
e
u
d
o
M
VI
V
IV
III
II
I
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
Neuron Positions
0.8
1
FIG. 3: Neuronal layout of the worm indicating cell
body positions of each neuron. The position of neuronal
cell bodies along the longitudinal axis of the C. elegans body
plan is shown, with the vertical offset and color indicating
the module to which a neuron belongs. The mean and stan-
dard deviation of neuronal positions for each module is also
indicated, suggesting relative absence of spatial localization
in the modules.
location weighs against the hypothesis of wiring length
minimization being the dominant factor governing the
connectivity.
The above conclusion is further supported by analysing
the connectivity pattern of the different ganglia of the
nematode nervous system. The nine anatomically de-
fined ganglia (G1: Anterior, G2: Dorsal, G3: Lateral,
G4: Ventral, G5: Retrovesicular, G6: Posterolateral, G7:
Preanal, G8: Dorsorectal and G9: Lumbar), in addition
to the ventral cord (G10), are defined in terms of physi-
cal proximity of their component neurons. Thus, a lower
total connection length between neurons would result in
the ganglia having a relatively higher density of connec-
tions between their constituent neurons. This would im-
ply that the existence of ganglia imposes a modular struc-
ture in the connection topology. To examine how well the
ganglionic arrangement explains the observed modularity
of the neuronal network, we have measured the modular-
ity value Qg where the network communities correspond
to the different ganglia. Although the non-zero value
of Qg indicates that the connection density between the
neurons in a ganglion is higher than that for the overall
network, it is not as high as the maximum possible value
of Q (= QM , obtained for the optimal partitioning) as
seen from Table I. To measure the overlap between the
modules obtained by optimal partitioning of the network
and the ganglia, we calculate the normalized mutual in-
formation index, I (see Methods). In the case of perfect
match between the two, I = 1, while, if there is no over-
lap, I = 0. The low values for I given in Table I suggest
that the composition of the different ganglia is quite dis-
tinct from that of the modules. The overlap between the
modules and the ganglia is shown explicitly in Fig. 4 (a),
indicating that most ganglia are composed of neurons
belonging to many different modules.
This distribution of the neurons of each ganglion into
the m different modules of the optimal partition allows
us to define a modular decomposition spectrum for the
different ganglia. It gives us a metric for inter-ganglionic
distance in a m-dimensional "modular" space. Thus, in
this abstract space, two ganglia are close to each other if
they have similar spectral profiles. Their distance in this
"modular" space (Fig. 4, b) are then compared to their
physical distance, as measured in terms of the average
separation between the cell bodies of all pairs of neu-
rons i and j, belonging to different ganglia (Fig. 4, c).
The comparison of the two distance matrices shows that
there are indeed certain similarities between these two
different concepts of closeness between the ganglia. For
example, the five ganglia located in the head (G1-G5)
1
0.5
0
n
o
i
t
c
a
r
F
p
a
l
r
e
v
O
I
II
III
Modules
IV
V
VI
4
3
2
1
6
5
Ganglion
10
9
8
7
A
B
10
n
o
i
l
g
n
a
G
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
C
10
n
o
i
l
g
n
a
G
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
1 2
3
1 2
3
10
10
1.2
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
4
5 6 7 8 9
Ganglion
4
5 6 7 8 9
Ganglion
e
c
n
a
t
s
D
i
l
r
a
u
d
o
M
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
e
c
n
a
t
s
D
i
l
r
a
u
d
o
M
i
e
c
n
a
t
s
D
n
a
e
d
i
l
c
u
E
G7 G8 G9 G6 G10 G1 G2 G3 G4 G5
i
e
c
n
a
t
s
D
n
a
e
d
i
l
c
u
E
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
FIG. 4: Modular decomposition of neurons in differ-
ent ganglia. (a) Neurons belonging to different ganglia are
decomposed according to their modular membership. The
height of each bar in the histogram corresponds to the over-
lap between the ganglia and the modules, calculated as the
fraction of neurons that are common to a particular ganglion
and a specific module. (b) The matrix representing the aver-
age modular distance between the different ganglia, as calcu-
lated from the modular decomposition spectrum of each gan-
glion. The corresponding dendrogram indicates the closeness
between different ganglia in the abstract 6-dimensional "mod-
ular" space. (c) The matrix of physical distances between the
ganglia is shown for comparison with (b), calculated as the
average distance between neurons belonging to the different
ganglia. The corresponding dendrogram indicates the close-
ness between ganglia according to the geographical nearness
of their constituent neurons in the nematode body. The dif-
ference indicates that the ganglia which are geographically
close may not be neighbors in terms of their modular spectra.
G6 G9 G7 G5 G10 G8 G1 G2 G4 G3
C. Modules and cell lineage
6
Ganglia which are close to each other in physical space
may not be neighbors in terms of their modular spec-
tra. For instance, G5 which is located in the head, is
closer in "modular" space to the ganglion G8 located in
the tail. On computing the correlation coefficient be-
tween the two trees by considering the distances between
every pair of ganglia (measured as the path length be-
tween the pair in the dendrogram), we obtain r = 0.516
(p < 0.0003). This value is substantially lower than 1,
the value expected had the two dendrograms been identi-
cal. It reiterates our previous conclusion that wiring cost
minimization, which is related to the physical distance
between neurons, is not a dominant factor governing the
organization of C. elegans somatic nervous system.
As developmental processes are believed to play a crit-
ical role in determining the structure of the nervous sys-
tem, we also consider the alternative hypothesis that the
structural modules reflect a clustering of neurons that
are related in terms of their lineage. Lineage of a cell
is the pattern of successive cellular divisions that occur
during its development. This is invariant in C. elegans,
allowing one to trace the individual developmental his-
tory of each cell in order to identify the cell-autonomous
mechanisms and inter-cellular interactions that define its
fate [3]. We investigate whether a relation exists between
the modular structure and the sequence of cell divisions
that occur during development, by measuring the aver-
age relatedness between neurons occurring in the same
module and comparing with that for neurons occurring
in different modules.
VI
V
IV
III
II
l
s
e
u
d
o
M
I
I
17.5
17
16.5
16
15.5
II
III IV
Modules
V
VI
i
e
c
n
a
t
s
D
e
g
a
e
n
L
i
cluster together, as do the three located towards the tail
(G7-G9). This similarity can be quantified by comput-
ing the correlation between these two distance measures
(i.e., Euclidean and modular), r = 0.564 (p < 0.0001).
Our observation is in accord with previous reports which
use the notion of wiring cost for explaining (to a cer-
tain extent) the observed relative positions of the gan-
glia [39]. However, when we consider the correspond-
ing dendrograms that indicate the relative proximity of
the different ganglia in physical space and in "modular"
space, we observe significant differences between the two.
FIG. 5: Lineage distance between modules. The ma-
trix representing the average lineage distance between neurons
occurring within the same module and those belonging to dif-
ferent modules. The figure indicates that neurons occurring
in the same module have only a slightly lower lineage distance
as compared to that between neurons occurring in different
modules.
Fig. 5 indicates that it is difficult to distinguish the
modules in terms of the lineage of the neurons com-
prising them.
Indeed, even coarse distinctions such as
AB and non-AB lineage neurons are not apparent from
the modular division. A one-way ANOVA test, with the
null hypothesis that the average lineage distance between
neurons within the same module and that between neu-
rons belonging to different modules are obtained from
the same distribution, shows that it cannot be rejected
at confidence level of 99%. We next analyse each pair
of modules using a multiple comparison procedure for
the intra-modular and inter-modular lineage distances of
their constituent neurons. This reveals that the neurons
belonging to modules III and VI have within-module lin-
eage distance distribution that is statistically indistin-
guishable from the distribution of their lineage distance
with neurons belonging to any of the other modules.
Thus, for at least two of the modules, one cannot seg-
regate them in terms of cell lineage. The detailed view
of the relatedness between each pair of neurons shown
in Fig. S1 indicates that, while in each module there
are subgroups of closely related neurons, different sub-
groups within the same module may be very far from
each other in the lineage tree. Conversely, neurons oc-
curring in different modules can have small distance be-
tween each other in terms of lineage. This observation is
supported by the low correlation r = 0.076 (p < 0.0001)
between the physical and lineage distances of neurons.
The fact that C. elegans neurons are largely non-clonally
derived from many different parent cells [40] may partly
explain this lack of correlation between lineage and mod-
ules. The above results indicate that developmental con-
straints arising from common ancestry are not exclusively
responsible for the observed connection structure of the
C. elegans neuronal network.
D. Optimizing between wiring cost and
communication efficiency
Low Efficiency
Low wiring cost
High Efficiency
High wiring cost
7
E
E
E
E
y
y
y
y
c
c
c
c
n
n
n
n
e
e
e
e
i
i
i
i
c
c
c
c
ffi
ffi
ffi
ffi
E
E
E
E
0.41
0.41
0.39
0.39
0.37
0.37
0.35
0.35
CW
DW
Emp
(CW)
Emp
(DW)
200
200
400
400
600
600
800
800
Wiring cost
Wiring cost
Wiring cost
Wiring cost
FIG. 6: Trade-off between wiring cost and communi-
cation efficiency in the network. The variation of com-
munication efficiency, E, as a function of the wiring cost, de-
fined using either the "dedicated-wire" model (DW) or the
"common-wire" model (CW), in the ensemble of random net-
works with degree sequence identical to the C. elegans neu-
ronal network. The trend indicates a trade-off between in-
creasing communication efficiency and decreasing wiring cost.
The corresponding values for the empirical network are indi-
cated by crosses for both DW and CW. The schematic figures
shown above the main panel indicate the type of networks
obtained in the limiting cases when only one of the two con-
straints are satisfied. In both curves, error bars indicate the
standard deviations calculated for 103 random realizations.
We observe that the empirical network is suboptimal in terms
of wiring cost and communication efficiency, suggesting the
presence of other constraints governing the network organiza-
tion.
In the previous section, we have shown that neither
wiring cost minimization nor lineage considerations can
by themselves determine the connection topology of the
network.
In order to ascertain the possible nature of
the additional constraints that gives rise to the observed
mesoscopic structure, we now investigate global proper-
ties of the neuronal network. A possible governing factor
for network organization is that, rather than decreasing
the total wiring length or the average physical distance
between connected neurons, the network minimizes the
path length for information transfer. This can be mea-
sured by the number of links that must be traversed to go
from one neuron to another using the shortest route [29].
We consider this possibility by measuring the communi-
cation efficiency of the network, using the harmonic aver-
age path length between all pairs of neurons (see Meth-
ods).
It is evident that increasing the efficiency requires
topological long-range connections, which however in-
creases the wiring cost of the network (Fig. 6 top). There-
fore, it is natural to expect that the system would try to
optimize between these two constraints. Thus, we com-
pare the performance of the network as a rapid signal
propagation system against the resource cost for the re-
quired number of connections. This cost is measured as
the Euclidean length between the cell bodies of all con-
nected pairs of neurons, corresponding to the "dedicated-
wire" model of Ref. [23]. It has been shown that the posi-
tions of the subset of sensory and motor neurons directly
connected to sensory organs and muscles, respectively,
can be determined quite accurately by minimizing their
total wiring cost [26]. As our focus is on the connection
structure of the neuronal network, we keep the neuron
positions invariant. By randomizing the network, keep-
ing the degree of each node unchanged, we can construct
a system with a specific wiring cost. We then measure its
communication efficiency. Fig. 6 reproduces the expected
result that, decreasing the wiring cost of the network
causes a decline in its performance in terms of its abil-
ity to propagate signals rapidly. However, it is surprising
that the empirical network has a wiring cost much higher
than that of the corresponding randomized network hav-
ing the same communication efficiency. To see whether
this could be an artifact of the measure used to calculate
wiring cost, we have considered an alternative method
for quantifying it.
Most of the neurons in C. elegans have at most one or
two extended processes, on which all the synapses and
gap junctions with other neurons are made. Thus the
"dedicated-wire" definition of wiring cost that sums Eu-
clidean distances between every connected neuronal pair
may be a gross over-estimate of the actual usage of re-
sources used in wiring. Instead, we can use a "common-
wire" model to define the wiring cost for connecting to
a specific neuron. This is measured by the Euclidean
distance between the neuron's cell body and that of the
farthest neuron (along the longitudinal axis) it is con-
nected to. The simple one-dimensional simplification of
the C. elegans body that we have assumed here ignores
distance along the transverse plane. Thus, this mea-
sure is actually an under-estimate of the actual wiring
cost, and should provide an insightful comparison with
the above measure obtained from the "dedicated-wire"
model. Fig. 6 (inset) shows that wiring cost increases
with communication efficiency for the randomized net-
works, which is qualitatively similar to the relation ob-
tained using the preceding definition for wiring cost. In
this case also, we find that the empirical C. elegans net-
work has a much lower efficiency in comparison with an
equivalent randomized network having the same wiring
cost. Thus, as this observation is independent of these
two definitions of wiring cost, it suggests the presence of
other constraints that force the neuronal network to have
a higher wiring cost or lower efficiency than we would
have expected. These constraints are possibly related to
information processing, which is the principal function of
the nervous system.
E.
Information processing is a distinctive feature of
the C. elegans neuronal network
To explore further the possibility that the additional
constraints governing the topological structure of C. ele-
gans nervous system may be related to information pro-
cessing, we investigate how this functional requirement
could be responsible for differentiating the system from
other complex networks for which communication effi-
ciency is of paramount importance. Rapid communica-
tion of information between different neurons is certainly
an important performance criterion. However, the neu-
ronal network has properties quite distinct from that of
(say) the Internet or the airline transportation network,
which are systems designed for maximum transportation
efficiency of signals or physical resources.
For this purpose, we look at the overall network de-
sign by decomposing the system into (i) a strongly con-
nected component (SCC), within which it is possible to
visit any node from any other node using directed links,
(ii) an inward component (IN) and (iii) an outward com-
10000
8000
6000
4000
2000
〉
C
B
〈
0
0
25
80
60
40
20
〉
n
n
k
〈
50
100
Average Degree, 〈 k 〉
75
125
0
0
25
50
100
Average Degree, 〈 k 〉
75
8
125
FIG. 7: Betweenness centrality and the average near-
est neighbor degree as a function of the total degree of
network. (a) The average betweenness centrality, hBCi, and
(b) the average nearest neighbor degree, hknni of each node as
a function of its total degree, hki = hkin + kouti. Betweenness
centrality is a measure of how frequently a particular node is
used when a signal is being sent between any pair of nodes
in the network using the shortest path. In case of the Inter-
net, BC of nodes increases with its degree which is sought
to be linked with its information transport property. In C.
elegans, although BC increases with degree, this increase is
not significant when compared to the randomized version of
the network.
In the case of the relation between the aver-
age connectivity of nearest neighbors of a node with its total
degree k, we note that for both the Internet and protein in-
teraction network, knn decreases with k as a power law. This
means that low connectivity nodes have high degree nodes as
their neighbors and vice-versa. However, in the case of C.
elegans, this relation is not very apparent and insignificant
in comparison with the randomized version of the network.
In both figures, error bars indicate the standard deviations
calculated for 103 random realizations. These results suggest
that the C.elegans network forms a class distinct from the
class of networks optimized only for signal propagation.
ponent (OUT), consisting of nodes from which the SCC
can be visited or which can be visited from the SCC,
respectively, but not vice versa. In addition, there can
be disconnected components, i.e., nodes which cannot be
visited from SCC nor can any visits be made to SCC from
there (Fig. 1). A comparison of the C. elegans neuronal
network with a similar decomposition of the WWW [41]
reveals that, while in the latter the different components
are approximately of equal size (WWW: SCC ∼ 56 mil-
lion pages, while IN, OUT consist of ∼ 43 million pages
each), the SCC of the nervous system comprises almost
the entire network (SCC has 274 neurons, IN has 4 neu-
rons and OUT has 1 neuron). Thus, any node can, in
principle, affect any other node in the nervous system,
suggesting the importance of feedback control for infor-
mation processing.
Next, we consider the relation between two fundamen-
tal properties of the network: the degree of nodes and
their betweenness centrality (BC), which characterizes the
importance of a node in information propagation over
the network (see Methods). We observe that for both
the C. elegans neuronal network and its randomized ver-
sions, the degree of a node and its BC are strongly cor-
related, i.e., highly connected nodes are also the most
central (Fig. 7, left). This is similar to what has been
observed in the Internet [42], where the highest degree
nodes are also those with the highest betweenness [43],
but in sharp contrast to the airport transportation net-
work, where non-hub nodes (low degree) may have very
large BC [44].
However, the C. elegans neuronal network differs from
other networks whose primary function is to allow sig-
nal propagation between nodes (viz., the Internet and
the protein interaction network (PIN)), in terms of the
variation of the degree of a node with the average degree
of its neighboring nodes, hknni. While in the Internet
and PIN, hknni decays as a power law with node de-
gree, in the neuronal network, this dependence is very
weak (Fig 7, right), especially when contrasted with the
randomized ensemble. This implies that the C. elegans
nervous system does not have multiple star-like subnet-
works as seen in the Internet and PIN [37]. Further, it is
different from the airline transportation network, where
the high degree nodes are closely connected among them-
selves showing an assortative behavior [45]. In fact, com-
putation of the assortativity coefficient r = −0.093 in-
dicates that the network is disassortative (as previously
stated in Refs. [46, 47]), although comparison with that
of the degree-conserved randomized ensemble (rrand =
−0.078 ± 0.011) indicates that this is predominantly a
result of the degree sequence. Another important distin-
guishing characteristic of the C. elegans network is that
the distributions of link weight and degree do not appear
to be scale-free, or even having a long tail (Fig. S2), unlike
systems such as the Internet and the airline transporta-
tion network [45, 48]. Thus, our study shows that there
are additional constraints governing the nervous system
connection topology in C. elegans, which are unrelated to
wiring cost, lineage or communication efficiency. As the
principal function of the system is to process information,
the above results suggest it is this functional requirement
that provides the additional constraints leading to the ob-
served organization of the nematode neuronal network.
F. Modules and functional circuits
In order to understand the nature of functional consid-
erations that may govern the network organization, we
focus on the overlap of several previously identified func-
tional circuits of C. elegans with the structurally identi-
fied modules. Functional circuits are a subset of neurons
which are believed to play a vital role in performing a
function, and are distinguished by observing abnormal
behavior of the organism when they are individually re-
moved (e.g., by laser ablation).
In biological systems,
it has been observed that members of structurally de-
fined communities are often functionally related (e.g., in
the intra-cellular protein interaction network [13] and the
network of cortical areas in the brain [49, 50]). Here, we
investigate the possibility of a similar correlation between
9
the anatomical modules of C. elegans and its functional
circuits. We consider the functional circuits for (F1)
mechanosensation [51 -- 53], (F2) egg laying [54, 55], (F3)
thermotaxis [56], (F4) chemosensation [57], (F5) feed-
ing [2, 51, 58], (F6) exploration [2, 51, 58] and (F7) tap
withdrawal [52, 59] (Table S2).
1
0.5
0
n
o
i
t
c
a
r
F
p
a
l
r
e
v
O
e
c
n
a
t
s
D
i
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
I
II
III
IV
Modules
V
VI
3
2
1
7
6
5
4
Functional Circuit
F4 F5 F6 F2 F1 F3 F7
FIG. 8: Modular decomposition of neurons in dif-
ferent functional circuits. Neurons belonging to different
functional circuits are decomposed according to their modular
membership. The height of each bar in the histogram corre-
sponds to the overlap between the modules and functional
circuits (F1) mechanosensation, (F2) egg laying, (F3) ther-
motaxis, (F4) chemosensation, (F5) feeding, (F6) exploration
and (F7) tap withdrawal. The overlap is measured in terms
of the fraction of neurons common to a particular functional
circuit and a specific module. The corresponding dendrogram
represents the closeness between different functional circuits
in the abstract 6-dimensional "modular" space.
Fig. 8 shows the modular decomposition of each func-
tional circuit, indicating their overlap with the modules.
The corresponding dendrogram clusters the circuits in
terms of the similarity in their modular spectra. We note
that the circuits for chemosensation, feeding and explo-
ration are clustered together. This is consistent with the
fact that most of the neurons belonging to the feeding
and exploration circuits are involved in chemosensation.
A surprising observation is that although F6 is a subset
of F4, it is actually closer to F5 in "modular" space (dis-
tance = 0.18) than to F4 (distance = 0.26), despite the
feeding and exploration circuits not having any neuron in
common. This close relation between F5 and F6 in mod-
ular space is suggestive of a relation between modularity
and functionality, as it is known from experiments that
there is a strong connection between their corresponding
functions. The feeding behavior of C.elegans is known to
be regulated in a context-dependent manner by its chem-
ical milieu. It integrates external signals [60], such as the
availability of food, and nutritional status of the animal,
to direct an appropriate response [61]. An example is
the avoidance of high CO2 concentrations by satiated
animals [62]. Further, the mode of locomotion of the
organism is also determined by the quality of food [63].
Another important observation made from the modular
decomposition is the proximity of the functional circuit
F2 to the group (F4,F5,F6). This is significant in light of
experimental observations that presence of food detected
through chemosensory neurons modulates the egg-laying
rate in C. elegans [53, 64]. The above results indicate
that the relation between the functional circuits, which
are essential for the survival of the organism, are reflected
in the modular organization of the nematode nervous sys-
tem.
nodes have higher participation coefficient, with a large
majority being satellite connectors (R3). More interest-
ing is the fact that, the empirical neural network does not
possess any neuron having the global roles played by R4
and R7, whereas these regions may be populated in ran-
domized networks. This implies that modular identity in
the C. elegans neuronal network is very pronounced.
10
G. Functional roles of different neurons
Having looked at the functional circuits and the rela-
tions between them in the previous section, we now in-
vestigate the importance of individual neurons in terms
of their connectivity. This is revealed by a comparison
between the localization of their connections within their
own community and their global connectivity profile over
the entire network. In order to do this, we focus on (i)
the degree of a node within its module, z, that indicates
the number of connections a node has to other members
of its module, and (ii) its participation coefficient, P ,
which measures how dispersed the connections of a node
are among the different modules [37].
A node having low within-module degree is called a
non-hub (z < 0.7) which can be further classified ac-
cording to their fraction of connections with other mod-
ules. Following Ref. [37], these are classified as (R1)
ultra-peripheral nodes (P ≤ 0.05), having connections
only within their module, (R2) peripheral nodes (0.05 <
P ≤ 0.62), which have a majority of their links within
their module, (R3) satellite connectors (0.62 < P ≤ 0.8),
with many links connecting nodes outside their modules,
and (R4) kinless nodes (P > 0.8), which form links uni-
formly across the network. Hubs, i.e., nodes having rel-
atively large number of connections within their module
(z ≥ 0.7), are also divided according to their participa-
tion coefficient into (R5) provincial hubs (P ≤ 0.3), with
most connections within their module, (R6) connector
hubs (0.3 < P ≤ 0.75), with a significant fraction of links
distributed among many modules, and (R7) global hubs
(P > 0.75), which connect homogeneously to all mod-
ules. This classification allows us to distinguish nodes
according to their different roles as brought out by their
intra-modular and inter-modular connectivity patterns
(Table S3).
We will now use the above methodology on the C. el-
egans network in order to identify neurons that play a
vital role in coordinating activity through sharing infor-
mation (either locally within their community or globally
over the entire network). Fig. 9 shows the comparison
between the empirical network and a corresponding ran-
domized network (obtained by keeping the degree of each
node fixed). Results for a randomized ensemble, com-
paring the number of neurons in each role against that
for the empirical network, are given in Table S4. We
immediately notice that the randomized networks have
relatively very few nodes having the roles R1 and R5, in-
dicating that the modular nature of the original network
has been lost. In fact, in the randomized system, most
z
e
e
r
g
e
d
l
e
u
d
o
m
n
−
h
i
t
i
W
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
−1
−2
0
AVAL
AVAR
RIAL
RIAR
z
e
e
r
g
e
d
PVCR
PVCL
AVDR
AVKL
AVBR
AVBL
AVDL
AVER
AVEL
SMBVL
l
e
u
d
o
m
n
−
h
i
t
i
W
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
PVCR
AVAR
AVBL
AVAL
AVBR
PVCL
RIAR
AVDL
AVER
AVDR
RIAL
AVKL
AVEL
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Participation Coefficient P
−1
−2
0
1
SMBVL
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Participation Coefficient P
1
FIG. 9: The role of individual neurons according to
their intra- and inter-modular connectivity. (a) The
within module degree z-score of each neuron in the empirical
neuronal network is shown against the corresponding partici-
pation coefficient P . The within module degree measures the
connectivity of a node to other nodes within its own module,
while the participation coefficient measures its connectivity
with neurons in the entire network. (b) The corresponding
result for a randomized version of the C. elegans network
where the degree of each neuron is kept unchanged is also
shown. Neurons belonging to the different regions in the P −z
space are categorised as: (gray) "ultraperipheral nodes," i.e.,
nodes with all their links within their module, (blue) "pe-
ripheral nodes," i.e., nodes with most links within their mod-
ule, (pink) "nonhub connector nodes," i.e., nodes with many
links to other modules, (green) "nonhub kinless nodes," i.e.,
nodes with links homogeneously distributed among all mod-
ules, (yellow) "provincial hubs," i.e., hub nodes with the vast
majority of links within their module, (red) "connector hubs,"
i.e., hubs with many links to most of the other modules, and
(white) "global hubs," i.e., hubs with links homogeneously
distributed among all modules. The neurons occurring as con-
nector hubs are identified in the figure. Most of these neurons
occur in different functional circuits indicating the close rela-
tion between functional importance and connectivity pattern
of individual neurons.
In addition, the neurons AVKL and
SMBVL which are predicted to be functionally important are
separately marked.
It is possible that, neurons having the role of provin-
cial hubs may be involved in local coordination of neural
activity, while, the connector hubs may be responsible
for integration of local excitations to produce a coher-
ent response of the entire system. This hypothesis is
supported by noting that all command interneurons (of
the class AVA, AVB, AVD, AVE, PVC), which control
forward and backward locomotion of the worm by reg-
ulating motor output, play the role of connector hubs.
In fact, out of the 23 neurons in the class R6, 20 are
known to belong to different functional circuits. Among
the rest, although DVA does not belong to any of the
known circuits, it has recently been identified as being
involved in mechanosensory response and in its absence,
the frequency and magnitude of the tap-induced reversal,
as well as the acceleration magnitude, is diminished [59].
The two remaining neurons, AVKL and SMBVL, have
not been implicated so far in any known functional cir-
cuit. However, their occurrence in this class suggests
that they may be important for some, as yet unknown,
function. This is a potentially interesting prediction that
may be verified in the laboratory.
The significance of these results is underlined by a com-
parison with the randomized network. For instance, in
the random realization shown in Fig. 9 (b), of the 49
neurons playing the role of connector or global hubs,
less than half (viz., 23) actually belong to any of the
known functional circuits. The appearance of most of the
command interneurons in the high-z region of both the
empirical and randomized networks indicates that their
high overall degree is responsible for their observed role
of "connecting hubs".
We now turn to the 28 neurons which play the role of
provincial hubs. Half of all the inhibitory D-class mo-
torneurons (viz., DD1-DD3 and VD1-VD6) are found to
belong to this class. This is significant as these neurons
have already been implicated in the ability of the worm
to initiate backward motion. While they also contribute
to forward locomotion, previous experiments have shown
that they are not essential [65]. This fits with our hy-
pothesis that, R5 neurons are important for local coor-
dination but may not be crucial for the global integra-
tion of activity. A pair of excitatory B-class motorneu-
rons that sustain coordinated forward locomotion in the
worm also appear as provincial hubs. Of the remaining
R5 neurons, 9 have been previously identified as belong-
ing to various functional circuits. It will be interesting
to verify the functional relevance of the remaining 8 neu-
rons (OLLL/R, RMDVL/R, SMDVR, RIH, RMDDL/R)
in the laboratory. Thus, overall, we find a very good cor-
relation between the connectivity pattern and the func-
tional importance of different neurons.
Analysis of neurons having different roles in terms of
their membership in the different ganglia (Fig. S3) indi-
cates that the lateral ganglion provides the majority of
neurons acting as connector hubs (R6). This is consis-
tent with an earlier study where this ganglion was found
to be the principal highway for information flowing be-
tween neurons responsible for receiving sensory stimuli
and those involved in motor response [66]. To check the
significance of the above result, we observe the member-
ship of the set of connector hubs in the corresponding
randomized network (Fig. S3). While this also shows
many neurons from the lateral ganglion, unlike in the
empirical network it has significant representation from
other ganglia too (e.g., the retrovesicular ganglion).
We have also carried out an analysis of the frequency
of links between neurons having different roles, relative
to the randomized network (Fig. S4). This allows us
to compare the C. elegans neuronal network with other
11
networks involved in (a) transportation and (b) informa-
tion propagation.
It has been shown that networks of
class (b) shows significant under-representation of links
between R1-R1, R5-R6 and R6-R6, whereas networks
of class (a) exhibit over-representation of all three [37].
These patterns have been related to the occurrence of
stringy periphery in class (a) and multi-star structures
in class (b) [37]. In the case of C. elegans, R1-R1 does
seem to be over-represented. However, R6-R6 shows very
little over-representation, while both R5-R6 and R6-R5
show slight under-representation. This difference in the
role-to-role connectivity pattern for the nematode ner-
vous system with the networks in the above-mentioned
two classes suggests that its structure is not exclusively
characterized by either a stringy periphery or multiple
stars. This assumes significance in light of recent work
distinguishing information (or signalling) networks, such
as the Internet and protein interactome, on the one hand,
and transportation networks, such as metabolic and air-
port networks, on the other, into two classes [37]. Our
results suggest that neuronal networks which have to pro-
cess information, in addition to transferring signals, may
constitute a different category from either of the above
classes.
IV. DISCUSSION
In this paper, we have carried out a detailed analysis
of the mesoscopic structure in the connection topology of
the C. elegans neuronal network. Inferring the organizing
principles underlying the network may give us an under-
standing of the way in which an organism makes sense of
the external world. We have focused primarily on the ex-
istence of modules, i.e., groups of neurons having higher
connection density among themselves than with neurons
in other groups. The presence of such mesoscopic orga-
nization naturally prompts us to ask the reasons behind
the evolution of these features in the network.
In lower invertebrates like nematodes, the genome is
the dominant factor which governs the development of
the organism, including its nervous system. The neu-
ronal network structure is formed early in the life-cycle
of the organism, when most of the cells and their con-
nections are configured permanently. Although external
cues may play a role, the relative absence of individual
variations in the network organization makes C. elegans
an ideal system for studying how the system has evolved
to optimize for various constraints, such as minimizing
resource use and maximizing performance.
There have been recent attempts at explaining neu-
ronal position and structural layout of the network by
using static constraints, such as wiring economy and com-
munication path minimization. Although we find that
membership of neurons in specific modules are corre-
lated with their physical nearness, the empirical network
is sub-optimal in terms of both the above-mentioned con-
straints. By comparing the system with other complex
networks that have been either designed or have evolved
for rapid transportation while being subject to wiring
economy, we find that the C. elegans nervous system
stands apart as a distinct class. This suggests that the
principal function of neuronal networks, viz., the pro-
cessing of information, distinguishes it from the other
networks considered, and plays a vital role in govern-
ing its arrangement. Considering the importance of this
constraint in ensuring the survival of an organism, it is
natural that this should be key to the organizing princi-
ples underlying the design of the network. The intimate
relation between function and structure of the nervous
system is further brought out by our use of structural
analysis to distinguish neurons that are critical for the
survival of the organism. In addition to identifying neu-
rons that have been already empirically implicated in
different functions (which serve as a verification of our
method), we also predict several neurons which can be
potentially crucial for certain, as yet unidentified, func-
tions.
Biological systems are distinguished by the occurrence
of discrete entities with a distinct function, which are
often termed as functional modules [9]. For several net-
works that occur in the biological context (such as that of
protein interactions), the components of structural mod-
ules are seen to be functionally related. This suggests
that modules provide a framework for relating meso-
scopic patterns in the connection topology to subsystems
responsible for specific functions. Although there is no
unique correspondence between the structural modules of
C. elegans and the known functional circuits [67], we use
the overlap of the circuits with the modular membership
of their constituent neurons to discover correlations be-
tween them. Our results reveal non-trivial association be-
tween circuits whose corresponding functions are closely
connected, even when they do not share any common
neurons. As such relations could not have been revealed
by a micro-scale study which focuses on individual neu-
rons and their connections, this result highlights one of
the significant advantages of investigating the network at
the mesoscopic level.
When we compare the nervous system of C. elegans
with the brains of higher organisms, we observe the mod-
ular organization of the latter to be more prominent [68].
For example, the network of cortical areas in the cat
and macaque brains exhibit distinct modules [22, 69],
with each module being identified with specific func-
tions [49, 50]. A possible reason for the relatively weak
modular structure in the nematode could be due to the
existence of extended processes for the neurons of C. ele-
gans. Many of these span almost the entire body length,
an effect that is enhanced by the approximately linear
nature of the nematode body plan. As a result, con-
nections are not constrained by the physical distance
between soma of the neurons, as is mostly the case in
mammalian brains. It is apparent that such constraints
on the geographical distance spanned by links between
nodes (viz., cost of wiring length) can give rise to cluster-
12
ing of connections among physically adjacent elements.
In addition, the small nervous system of C. elegans, com-
prising only 302 neurons, lacks redundancy. Therefore,
individual neurons may often have to perform a set of
tasks which in higher organisms are performed by sev-
eral different neurons. Thus, functional modularity is
less prominent in the nematode, as some neurons belong
to multiple behavioral circuits.
Another principal distinction between the C. elegans
nervous system and the brains of higher organisms such
as human beings, is the relative high connectivity in the
former (the connection density being C ∼ 0.1). By
contrast, the connectance for human brain is around
10−6 [70], which leads us to the question of how com-
munication efficiency can remain high in such a sparsely
connected network. It is possible that the more intricate
hierarchical and modular structures seen in the brains
of higher organisms is a response to the above problem.
The fact that the rate at which the number of neurons
N increase across species, is not matched by a corre-
sponding increase in the number of links (which increases
slower than N 2) implies the existence of constraints on
the latter, which is a resource cost in addition to the ear-
lier mentioned cost of wiring length. Note that, in the
present work we have focused on a single level of mod-
ular decomposition of the nematode neuronal network.
It is possible that the system may have multiple levels
of hierarchically arranged inter-nested modules [15, 71].
Investigating the existence of such organization in the
C. elegans nervous system is a potential topic for future
exploration.
Networks provide the scaffolding for the computational
architectures that mediate cognitive functions. The pat-
tern of connections of a neuron (or a neuronal cluster)
defines its functionality not just locally but also as an
integrated part of the nervous system. This is because
neurocognitive networks across the evolutionary tree con-
sist of interconnected clusters of neurons that are simul-
taneously activated for generating a single or a series of
cognitive outputs. However, while some of the neurons
(or clusters of neurons) are essential for the relevant out-
come, others are ancillary. Thus, they work in a collab-
orative mode but are not interchangeable, each display-
ing relative specializations for separate behavioral com-
ponents. Since the most prominent neuronal pathways
are those that interconnect components of functional cir-
cuits, our analysis validates the intrinsic connection be-
tween network structure and the functions of the ner-
vous system. The concept that behavioral consequences
of damaging a region of the brain will reflect the disrup-
tion of the underlying network architecture may be in-
tuitive but is particularly important when one considers
brain dysfunction through neurodegeneration [72], where
atrophy is seen to propagate preferentially through net-
works of functionally related neurons [73]. While the idea
that damage in one part of the brain can affect other ar-
eas connected to that region is not new, our work on
the mesoscopic network organization may be extended
to look at disease progression through the network, be-
yond the current focus on the pathology within individual
cells.
We obtain this using a generalization of the spectral
method [75, 76]. We first define a modularity matrix
B,
13
V. MATERIALS AND METHODS
Connectivity Data: We have used information
about the network connectivity, positions of neurons and
the lineage distance between cells for the C. elegans ner-
vous system, from the database published in Ref. [23] and
available from the online Atlas of C. elegans anatomy
(www.wormatlas.org). This is an updated and revised
version of the wiring data originally published in Ref. [2].
The connectivity between neurons and the positions of
the neuron cell bodies along the longitudinal axis of the
worm is reconstructed based on serial section electromi-
crography. Note that, the new database adds or updates
about 3000 connections to the previous version. The lin-
eage data indicates the relatedness between every pair of
neurons in terms of distances in the embryonic and post-
embryonic lineage trees. This is measured by identifying
the last common progenitor cells of the two neurons, and
then counting the number of cell divisions from this com-
mon ancestor. Each cell division adds a single unit to the
total lineage distance, with the initial division from the
common progenitor counted only once.
Modularity (Q): To decompose a given network into
modules (where a module or community is defined as a
subnetwork having a higher density of connections rela-
tive to the entire network) we use a method introduced
in Ref. [74]. We compute a quantitative measure of mod-
ularity, Q, for a given partitioning of the network into
several communities,
Q ≡
1
2LXi,j (cid:20)Aij −
kikj
2L (cid:21) δcicj .
(1)
Here, A is the adjacency matrix (Aij is 1, if neurons i,
j are connected, and 0, otherwise). The degree of each
node i is given by ki =Pj=1 Aij . L is the total number
of links in the network, δ is the Kronecker delta (δij = 1,
if i = j, and 0, otherwise), and ci is the label of the
community to which vertex i is assigned. In the case of
directed and weighted network, the above measure can
be generalized as
QW ≡
1
LW Xi,j "Wij −
j
sin
i sout
LW # δcicj ,
(2)
where, LW = Pi,j Wij is the sum of weights of all links
i =Pj Wji,
in the network (Wij is the weight of the link from neuron
j to neuron i), and the weighted in-degree and out-degree
of node i are given by sin
respectively.
i =Pj Wij and sout
The optimal partitioning of the network is the one
which maximizes the modularity measure Q (or QW ).
Bij = Wij −
j
i sout
sin
LW .
(3)
To split the network into modules, the eigenvectors cor-
responding to the largest positive eigenvalue of the sym-
metric matrix (B + BT) is calculated and the commu-
nities are assigned based on the sign of the elements of
the eigenvector. This divides the network into two parts,
which is refined further by exchanging the module mem-
bership of each node in turn if it results in an increase in
the modularity. The process is then repeated by splitting
each of the two divisions into further subdivisions. This
recursive bisection of the network is carried out until no
further increase of Q is possible.
Modular spectra: We analyze different neuronal
groups, defined in terms of functions, anatomy (e.g., gan-
glia), etc., by proposing a decomposition in terms of the
overlap of their constituent neurons with the different
modules. Let the set of all neurons be optimally parti-
tioned into m modules. We then define an overlap ma-
trix, O, where the rows correspond to the different neu-
ronal groups, and the columns correspond to the different
modules. An element of this overlap matrix, Oij , is the
number of neurons in group i that are from the module
j. Then, the decomposition of the i-th group in the ab-
stract m-dimensional basis space formed by the modules
is { Oi1
k=1Oik is the to-
Ni
tal number of neurons in the i-th group. The distance
between two groups i and k in this "modular" space is
defined as
}, where Ni = Σm
, . . . , Oim
Ni
, Oi2
Ni
dmodular
ij
=vuutXk (cid:20) Oik
Ni
−
Ojk
Nj (cid:21)2
.
(4)
Thus, this measure can be used as a metric for closeness
between different neuronal groups.
Decomposition of the network into SCC, IN and
OUT components: In order to determine the Strongly
Connected Component (SCC) of the network, we first
calculate the graph distance matrix containing the short-
est directed path between every pair of nodes in the net-
work. A finite path length from neuron i to neuron j indi-
cates the existence of a connected path from one neuron
to the other. By grouping together all nodes which have
finite path length with all other members of the group, we
determine the SCC. In general, one can use Tarjan's algo-
rithm for SCC determination [77]. Next, we identify all
neurons not belonging to SCC but which can be reached
via a directed path starting from a node in SCC. This
constitutes the OUT component of the network. Simi-
larly, the group of neurons which do not belong to SCC
but which have finite directed path length to a member
of SCC, constitutes the set of IN neurons.
Betweenness centrality (BC): To measure the im-
portance of a node in facilitating communication across
a network, we consider how frequently a node is used to
convey information from any part of the network to any
other part using the shortest available path. The be-
tweenness centrality of a node i is defined as the fraction
of shortest paths between the pairs of all other nodes in
the network that pass through i [78]. If the total number
of shortest paths between nodes j and k is σjk, of which
σjk(i) paths pass through node i, then the betweenness
centrality of node i is
CB(i) = Xj→k
σjk(i)
σjk
.
(5)
Communication Efficiency (E): To measure the
speed of information transfer over the network, one can
define the efficiency εij of communication between ver-
tices i and j to be inversely proportional to the shortest
graph distance εij = 1/dij∀i, j. Therefore, the efficiency
of communication across the whole network is
E(G) = ℓ−1 =
1
1
2 N (N − 1)Xi>j
1
dij
.
(6)
This is the harmonic mean of graph distances between
all pairs, which does not diverge even when the network
is disconnected [79].
Network Randomization: An ensemble of random-
ized versions of the empirical network is constructed
keeping the in-degree and out-degree of each node un-
changed. Each such network is created by rewiring ran-
domly selected pairs of directed edges, i → j and k → l,
such that, in the randomized network, the corresponding
directed edges are i → l and k → j. However, if these
new links already exist in the empirical network, this step
is aborted and a new pair of edges are chosen in order to
prevent the occurrence of multiple edges [36]. The above
procedure is repeated 5 × 106 times for a single realiza-
tion of the randomized network. In order to compare the
properties of the empirical network with its randomized
version, an ensemble of 103 realizations is considered.
Determining the intra- and inter-modular role
of a neuron: The role played by each neuron in terms of
its connectivity within its own module and in the entire
network is determined according to two properties [44]:
(i) the relative within module degree, z, and (ii) the par-
ticipation coefficient, P .
The z-score of the within module degree distinguishes
nodes that are hubs of their communities from those that
are non-hubs. It is defined as
ci − hκj
κi
ciij∈ci
ci)2ij∈ci − hκj
ci i2
j∈ci
,
(7)
zi =
qh(κj
where κi
c is the number of links of node i to other nodes
in its community c and h· · · ij∈c are taken over all nodes
in module c. The within-community degree z-score mea-
sures how well-connected node i is to other nodes in the
community.
14
The nodes are also distinguished based on their con-
nectivity profile over the entire network, in particular,
their connections to nodes in other communities. Two
nodes with same within module degree z-score can play
different roles, if one of them has significantly higher
inter-modular connections compared to the other. This
is measured by the participation coefficient Pi of node i,
defined as
m
c
Pi = 1 −
where κi
,
(8)
ki(cid:19)2
Xc=1(cid:18) κi
in its community c and ki =Pc κi
c is the number of links from node i to other nodes
c is the total degree of
node i. Therefore, the participation coefficient of a node
is close to 1, if its links are uniformly distributed among
all the communities, and is 0, if all its links are within
its own community.
Normalized mutual information (I): To measure
the overlap of the membership of nodes in a ganglion with
their membership in a specific module, we use the nor-
malized mutual information measure [80, 81]. First, we
define a overlap matrix, O, where the rows correspond to
the different ganglia, and the columns correspond to the
modules obtained by optimal partitioning of the network.
An element of this overlap matrix, Oij, is the number of
neurons in the ganglion i that appear in the module j.
An information-theoretic measure of similarity between
the partitions can then be defined as
I =
i=1PmB
−2PmA
i=1 Oi. log(Oi./O) +PmB
PmA
j=1 Oij log(Oij O/Oi.O.j)
j=1 O.j log(O.j/O)
,
(9)
where mA and mB are the numbers of ganglia and mod-
ules respectively. The sum over row i of matrix Oij is
denoted by Oi. and the sum over column j is denoted
by O.j. If the modules are identical to the ganglia, then
I takes its maximum value of 1. On the other hand, if
the modular partitioning is independent of the division
of the network into ganglia, I ∼ 0.
VI. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We would like to thank R. Anishetty, S. Koushika and
V. Sreenivasan for helpful comments and discussion.
VII. SUPPORTING INFORMATION
Figure S1. Matrix representing the relatedness of
neurons in the somatic nervous system of C. elegans as
measured in terms of their lineage distance. The neu-
rons are arranged according to the modules they belong
to. The module boundaries are indicated in the figure.
Within each module, neurons that are close in terms of
lineage are placed in adjacent positions. The figure shows
that closely related neurons may occur in different mod-
ules, while those in the same module may be far apart in
15
terms of lineage distance. This indicates that there is no
simple relation between relatedness of neurons in terms
of lineage and their modular membership.
Figure S2. Cumulative distributions of the strength
and (inset) degree for the (a) gap-junctional, (b) synaptic
and (c) combined networks. The gap-junctional network
is undirected and the strength of a node is defined as
si = Pj Wij , where Wij is the number of gap junctions
i =Pj Wji,
i = Pj Wij, respectively. For directed networks,
between neurons i and j. On the other hand, the synaptic
and combined networks are directed and the inward- and
outward-strength of a node are defined as sin
and sout
Wij represents the number of connections from neuron j
to i. The figures indicate that scale-free behavior of the
distributions is seen only for the gap-junctional network.
The other two networks exhibit exponentially decaying
nature for both the degree and the strength distributions.
Figure S3. The intra- and inter-modular connectivity
of individual neurons in the C. elegans somatic nervous
systems, color-coded to represent the different ganglia in
which each occurs. (a) The within module degree z-score
of each neuron in the empirical neuronal network is shown
against the corresponding participation coefficient P . (b)
The corresponding result for a randomized version of the
C. elegans network where the degree of each neuron is
kept unchanged. The lateral ganglion is seen to occupy
a prominent position in the system, coordinating the in-
formation flow between the neuronal groups responsible
for receiving sensory stimuli and those controlling motor
activity. On the other hand, the randomized network
shows similar prominence for several other ganglia.
Table S1. The classification of neurons according to
their membership in the 6 modules obtained by optimal
partitioning of the combined synaptic-gap junctional net-
work of the C. elegans somatic nervous system.
Table S2. The neuronal composition of different func-
tional circuits in the C. elegans somatic nervous system.
Table S3. The classification of neurons in the C. el-
egans somatic nervous system, according to their role in
intra- and inter-modular connectivity.
Text S1. Analysis of the C. elegans network of synap-
tic connections.
[1] G. Tononi, O. Sporns, and G. Edelman, Proc. Natl. Acad.
[18] J. W. Scannell, C. Blakemore, and M. P. Young, Journal
Sci. U.S.A. 91, 5033 (1994).
of Neuroscience 15, 1463 (1995).
[2] J. G. White, E. Southgate, J. N. Thomson, and S. Bren-
ner, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B 314, 1 (1986).
[19] M. Young, Proc. R. Soc. B 252, 13 (1993).
[20] M. D. Humphries, K. Gurney, and T. J. Prescott, Proc.
[3] D. L. Riddle, T. Blumenthal, B. J. Meyer, and J. R.
Priess, eds., Celegans II (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
Press, New York, 1993).
R. Soc. B 273, 503 (2006).
[21] R. K. Pan and S. Sinha, Phys. Rev. E 76, 045103 (2007).
[22] R. K. Pan and S. Sinha, Europhys. Lett. 85, 68006
[4] R. Schnabel, Seminars in Cell & Developmental Biology
(2009).
8, 341 (1997).
[5] M. E. J. Newman, SIAM Review 45, 167 (2003).
[6] R. Albert and A.-L. Barab´asi, Rev. Mod. Phys. 74, 47
(2002).
[7] M. Reigl, U. Alon, and D. B. Chklovskii, BMC Biology
2, 25 (2004).
[23] B. L. Chen, D. H. Hall, and D. B. Chklovskii, Proc. Natl.
Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 103, 4723 (2006).
[24] U. Deppe, E. Schierenberg, T. Cole, C. Krieg, D. Schmitt,
B. Yoder, and G. V. Ehrenstein, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.
U.S.A. 75, 376 (1978).
[25] A. Arenas, A. Fernandez, and S. Gomez, Lecture Notes
[8] M. Girvan and M. E. J. Newman, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.
In Computer Science 5151, 9 (2008).
U.S.A. 99, 7821 (2002).
[26] A. Perez-Escudero and G. G. de Polavieja, Proc. Natl.
[9] L. H. Hartwell, J. J. Hopfield, S. Leibler, and A. W.
Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 104, 17180 (2007).
Murray, Nature 402, C47 (1999).
[27] S. Itzkovitz, L. Baruch, E. Shapiro, and E. Segal, Proc.
[10] B. Schwikowski, P. Uetz, and S. Fields, Nature Biotech-
Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 105, 9278 (2008).
nology 18, 1257 (2000).
[28] Y.-Y. Ahn, H. Jeong, and B. J. Kim, Physica A 367, 531
[11] A. W. Rives and T. Galitski, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.
(2006).
U.S.A. 100, 1128 (2003).
[29] M. Kaiser and C. Hilgetag, PLoS Computational Biology
[12] A. E. Krause, K. A. Frank, D. M. Mason, R. U. Ulanow-
2 (2006).
icz, and W. W. Taylor, Nature 426, 282 (2003).
[30] N. Brenner, W. Bialek, and R. de Ruyter van Steveninck,
[13] R. Guimera and L. A. N. Amaral, Nature 433, 895
Neuron 26, 695 (2000).
(2005).
[14] E. Bullmore and O. Sporns, Nature Reviews Neuro-
[31] U. Alon, Nature Reviews Genetics 8, 450 (2007).
[32] R. F. Cancho, C. Janssen, and R. V. Sole, Phys. Rev. E
science 10, 186 (2009).
64, 046119 (2001).
[15] L. Ferrarini, I. Veer, E. Baerends, M. van Tol, R. Renken,
N. van der Wee, D. Veltman, A. Aleman, F. Zit-
man, B. Penninx,
et al., Human Brain Mapping
doi:10.1002/hbm.20663 (2008).
[33] B. J. Kim, Phys. Rev. E 69, 045101 (2004).
[34] R. Milo, S. Itzkovitz, N. Kashtan, R. Levitt, S. Shen-Orr,
I. Ayzenshtat, M. Sheffer, and U. Alon, Science 303, 1538
(2004).
[16] D. Meunier, S. Achard, A. Morcom, and E. Bullmore,
[35] K. Klemm and S. Bornholdt, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.
Neuroimage 44, 715 (2009).
U.S.A. 102, 18414 (2005).
[17] A. Schwarz, A. Gozzi, and A. Bifone, Magnetic Reso-
nance Imaging 26, 914 (2008).
[36] S. Maslov and K. Sneppen, Science 296, 910 (2002).
[37] R. Guimera, M. Sales-Pardo, and L. A. Amaral, Nature
16
Physics 3, 63 (2007).
[60] S. A. Daniels, M. Ailion, J. H. Thomas, and P. Sengupta,
[38] V. Blondel, J. Guillaume, R. Lambiotte, and E. Lefebvre,
Genetics 156, 123 (2008).
J. Stat. Mech P10008 (2008).
[39] C. Cherniak, Journal of Neuroscience 14, 2418 (1994).
[40] O. Hobert, Specification of the nervous system (Worm-
[61] C. J. Franks, L. Holden-Dye, K. Bull, S. Luedtke, and
R. J. Walker, Invert Neurosci. 6, 105 (2006).
[62] A. J. Bretscher, K. E. Busch, and M. de Bono, Proc.
Book, ed. The C. elegans Research Community, 2005).
Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 105, 8044 (2008).
[41] A. Broder, R. Kumar, F. Maghoul, P. Raghavan, S. Ra-
jagopalan, R. Stata, A. Tomkins, and J. Wiener, Com-
puter Networks 33, 309 (2000).
[63] B. B. Shtonda and L. Avery, J Exp Biol. 209, 89 (2006).
[64] E. R. Sawin, R. Ranganathan, and H. R. Horvitz, Neuron
26, 619 (2000).
[42] A. Vazquez, R. Pastor-Satorras, and A. Vespignani,
[65] S. L. McIntire, E. Jorgensen, J. Kaplan, and H. R.
Phys. Rev. E 65, 066130 (2002).
Horvitz, Nature 364, 337 (1993).
[43] K.-I. Goh, E. Oh, B. Kahng, and D. Kim, Phys. Rev. E
[66] N. Chatterjee and S. Sinha, Progress in Brain Research
67, 017101 (2003).
168, 145 (2007).
[44] R. Guimera, S. Mossa, A. Turtschi, and L. Amaral, Proc.
[67] A. Arenas, A. Diaz-Guilera, J. Kurths, Y. Moreno, and
Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 102, 7794 (2005).
C. Zhou, Phys. Rep. 469, 93 (2008).
[45] A. Barrat, M. Barthelemy, R. Pastor-Satorras, and
A. Vespignani, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 101, 3747
(2004).
[46] M. E. J. Newman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 208701 (2002).
[47] M. E. J. Newman, Phys. Rev. E 67, 026126 (2003).
[48] R. Pastor-Satorras, A. V´azquez, and A. Vespignani,
Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 258701 (2001).
[49] C. C. Hilgetag, G. A. P. C. Burns, M. A. O'Neill, J. W.
Scannell, and M. P. Young, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B 355,
91 (2000).
[50] D. S. Bassett and E. Bullmore, Neuroscientist 12, 512
(2006).
[68] M. Muller-Linow, C. C. Hilgetag, and M. T. Hutt, PLoS
Computational Biology 4, e1000190 (2008).
[69] C. Zhou, L. Zemanov´a, G. Zamora, C. C. Hilgetag, and
J. Kurths, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 238103 (pages 4) (2006).
[70] G. M. Shepherd, ed., The Synaptic Organization of the
Brain (Oxford University Press, New York, 1998), 4th
ed.
[71] M. Sales-Pardo, R. Guimera, A. A. Moreira, and L. A. N.
Amaral, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 104, 15224 (2007).
[72] B. Horwitz, A. R. McIntosh, J. V. Haxby, M. Furey, J. A.
Salerno, M. B. Schapiro, S. I. Rapoport, and C. L. Grady,
Neuroreport 6, 2287 (1995).
[51] M. Chalfie, J. E. Sulston, J. G. White, E. Southgate, J. N.
[73] W. W. Seeley, R. K. Crawford, J. Zhou, B. L. Miller, and
Thomson, and S. Brenner, J Neurosci. 5, 956 (1985).
M. D. Greicius, Neuron 16, 42 (2009).
[52] S. R. Wicks and C. H. Rankin, J Comp Physiol [A] 179,
675 (1996).
[74] M. E. J. Newman, Eur. Phys. J. B 38, 321 (2004).
[75] E. A. Leicht and M. E. J. Newman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100,
[53] E. R. Sawin, Ph.D. thesis, Massachusetts Institute of
118703 (2008).
Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts (1996).
[76] M. E. J. Newman, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 103,
[54] L. E. Waggoner, G. T. Zhou, R. W. Schafer, and W. R.
8577 (2006).
Schafer, Neuron 21, 203 (1998).
[55] I. A. Bany, M. Q. Dong, and M. R. Koelle, J Neurosci
23, 8060 (2003).
[56] I. Mori and Y. Ohshima, Nature 376, 344 (1995).
[57] E. R. Troemel, B. E. Kimmel, and C. I. Bargmann, Cell
91, 161 (1997).
[58] J. M. Gray, J. J. Hill, and C. I. Bargmann, Proc. Natl.
Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 102, 3184 (2005).
[77] R. Tarjan, SIAM Journal on Computing 1, 146 (1972).
[78] L. C. Freeman, Sociometry 40, 35 (1977).
[79] V. Latora and M. Marchiori, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 198701
(2001).
[80] L. Kuncheva and S. Hadjitodorov, in 2004 IEEE Inter-
national Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics
(2004), vol. 2, pp. 1214 -- 1219.
[81] L. Danon, A. Diaz-Guilera, J. Duch, and A. Arenas, J.
[59] S. R. Wicks and C. H. Rankin, Journal of Neuroscience
Stat. Mech. p. P09008 (2005).
15, 2434 (1995).
|
1903.05979 | 2 | 1903 | 2019-03-27T18:31:13 | The Frequent Complete Subgraphs in the Human Connectome | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | While it is still not possible to describe the neural-level connections of the human brain, we can map the human connectome with several hundred vertices, by the application of diffusion-MRI based techniques. In these graphs, the nodes correspond to anatomically identified gray matter areas of the brain, while the edges correspond to the axonal fibers, connecting these areas. In our previous contributions, we have described numerous graph-theoretical phenomena of the human connectomes. Here we map the frequent complete subgraphs of the human brain networks: in these subgraphs, every pair of vertices is connected by an edge. We also examine sex differences in the results. The mapping of the frequent subgraphs gives robust substructures in the graph: if a subgraph is present in the 80% of the graphs, then, most probably, it could not be an artifact of the measurement or the data processing workflow. We list here the frequent complete subgraphs of the human braingraphs of 414 subjects, each with 463 nodes, with a frequency threshold of 80%, and identify 812 complete subgraphs, which are more frequent in male and 224 complete subgraphs, which are more frequent in female connectomes. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
The Frequent Complete Subgraphs in the Human Connectome
M´at´e Fellnera, B´alint Vargaa, Vince Grolmusza,b,∗
aPIT Bioinformatics Group, Eotvos University, H-1117 Budapest, Hungary
bUratim Ltd., H-1118 Budapest, Hungary
Abstract
While it is still not possible to describe the neural-level connections of the human brain, we can
map the human connectome with several hundred vertices, by the application of diffusion-MRI
based techniques. In these graphs, the nodes correspond to anatomically identified gray matter
areas of the brain, while the edges correspond to the axonal fibers, connecting these areas. In our
previous contributions, we have described numerous graph-theoretical phenomena of the human
connectomes. Here we map the frequent complete subgraphs of the human brain networks:
in
these subgraphs, every pair of vertices is connected by an edge. We also examine sex differences
in the results. The mapping of the frequent subgraphs gives robust substructures in the graph: if
a subgraph is present in the 80% of the graphs, then, most probably, it could not be an artifact of
the measurement or the data processing workflow. We list here the frequent complete subgraphs
of the human braingraphs of 414 subjects, each with 463 nodes, with a frequency threshold of
80%, and identify 812 complete subgraphs, which are more frequent in male and 224 complete
subgraphs, which are more frequent in female connectomes.
Introduction
Diffusion MRI-based macroscopic mapping of the connections of the human brain is a tech-
nology that was developed in the last 15 years [1, 2, 3, 4]. Applying the method, we are able to
construct braingraphs, or connectomes, from the diffusion MRI images [1, 5, 6]: the vertices of
the graph are anatomically labeled areas of the gray matter (called "Regions of Interests", ROIs),
and two such ROIs are connected by an edge, if a complex workflow, involving either determin-
istic or probabilistic tractography, finds axonal fibers between the two ROIs. Therefore, one can
construct graphs, with up to 1015 nodes and several thousand edges, from the MR image of each
subject.
The analysis of these graphs is a fast-developing and an important area today: these con-
nections form the "hardware" of all brain functions on a macroscopic level [2, 3, 4]. Naturally,
it would be exciting to map the neuronal scale human connectome, too: here the nodes were
the individual neurons, and two nodes (or neurons), say X and Y, would be connected by a di-
rected edge, say (X, Y ), if the axon of X were connected to a dendrite of Y . Unfortunately, to
date, the neural-level connectome of only one adult organism is described: that of the nematode
Caenorhabditis elegans with 302 neurons, in the year 1986 [7]. In larval state, two more neuronal
level connectomes are published: the larva of the fruitfly Drosophila melanogaster [8], and the
tadpole larva of the Ciona intestinalis [9]. Despite of some exciting, very recent developments
[10], the complete connectome of the adult Drosophila melanogaster with 100,000 neurons, is not
∗Corresponding author
Email addresses: [email protected] (M´at´e Fellner), [email protected] (B´alint Varga),
[email protected] (Vince Grolmusz)
1
determined yet. Humans have 80 billion neurons in their brains. Therefore, the mapping and the
analysis of the neuronal scale human connectome is out of our reach today.
There are numerous results published for the analysis of the diffusion MRI-computed hu-
man connectomes, e.g., [1, 2, 3, 4]. Our research group has also contributed some more graph-
theoretically oriented analytical methods, like the comparison of the deep graph theoretical pa-
rameters of male and female connectomes [11, 12, 13], the parameterizable human consensus
connectome [14, 15], the description of the individual variability in the connections of the major
lobes [16], the discovery of the Consensus Connectome Dynamics [17, 18, 19, 20] the description
of the frequent subgraphs of the human brain [21], and the Frequent Neighborhood Mapping of
the human hippocampus [22].
The reasons of our graph-theoretical approach are listed as follows:
(i) Graph theory has a long history of great successes, starting with the paper of Leonhard
Euler in 1741 on Konigsberg's bridges [23].
(ii) "Pure mathematical" graph theory and its applications in computer engineering reached an
exceptionally high level of development in the late XXth and in the early XXIst century, just
mentioning three famous examples: the Strong Perfect Graph Theorem [24], Szemer´edi's
Regularity Lemma [25], and the intricate parallel algorithms for multiprocessor routing in
[26].
(iii) Graph theoretical definitions and notations are well-developed, clear, and usually catch the
deep and most relevant properties of the networks examined.
Frequent edges and subgraphs: a robust analysis
The data acquisition and processing workflow, whose results are the braingraphs or structural
connectomes, has numerous delicate steps. Naturally, errors may occur in MRI recordings and
processing, as well as in segmentation, parcellation, tractography and graph computation steps
[1, 27, 28]. When we have hundreds of high-quality MR images, we can analyze the frequently
appearing graph edges or subgraphs, in order to derive robust, reproducible results, appearing
in high fraction of the brains imaged. By analyzing only the frequently appearing structural
elements, the great majority of data acquisition and processing errors will be filtered out.
Our first effort for describing frequent edges in human connectome was the construction of
the Budapest Reference Connectome Server [14, 15], in which the user can select the frequency
threshold k% of the edges, and the resulting consensus connectome contains only those edges,
which are present in at least k% of the subjects. The generated consensus connectome can be
both visualized and downloaded at the site https://pitgroup.org/connectome/.
The frequent, connected subgraphs of at most 6 edges are mapped in the human connectome
in [21]. The frequencies were compared between female and male connectomes, and strong sex
differences were identified: there are connected subgraphs, which are significantly more frequent
in males than in females, and there are a higher number of connected graphs that are more
frequent in females than in males.
The direct connections of important brain areas are of special interest: correlations between
the present or missing connections and psychological tests results or biological parameters may
enlighten the fine structure-function relations of our brain. For error-correction reasons, the
frequent neighbors of the relevant brain areas form the robust objects of study: small errors in
the data processing workflow will most probably have no effects on the frequent connections. In
our work [22], we have introduced the method of the Frequent Neighborhood Mapping, which
describes the frequent neighbor sets of the given nodes of the braingraph.
In [22], we have
demonstrated the method by mapping the frequent neighborhoods of the human hippocampus:
one of the most deeply studied part of the brain. We have mapped the frequent neighbor sets
2
of the hippocampus, and we have found sex differences in the frequent neighbor sets: males
have much more frequent neighbor sets of the hippocampus than the females; therefore, the
neighborhoods of the men's hippocampi are more regular, with less variability than those of
women. This observation is in line with the results of [11, 12, 13], where we have shown that the
female connectomes are better expander graphs than the braingraphs of men.
In the present contribution, we are mapping the frequent complete graphs of the human
connectome, based on the large dataset of the Human Connectome Project [29]. Our dataset
contains the braingraphs of 414 subjects. A recently appeared work [30] deals with complete
subgraphs in braingraphs of 8 subjects, each with 83 nodes. Our results are derived from 414
braingraphs, each of 463 nodes. Therefore, we are able to find frequent structures, i.e., frequent
complete subgraphs in our dataset of 414 graphs (while it is not feasible to derive frequent
structures from 8 graphs).
Here we intend to clarify some graph theoretical terms. A complete graph on v vertices
(cid:1) = v(v−1)/2 vertex-pairs: that is, in a complete
2
Cliques vs. complete subgraphs
contains (undirected) edges, connecting all the(cid:0)v
graph, each pair of vertices are connected by an edge.
If we have a graph G on n vertices, we can look for the complete subgraphs H of G: all the
vertices and the edges of H need to be vertices and edges of G (i.e., H is a subgraph of G), and,
moreover, H needs to be a complete graph.
The complete subgraph of the maximum vertex-number of G is called a clique. The clique
number of graph G, ω(G), is the number of vertices in the largest complete subgraph of G.
Computing the clique number ω(G) is a well-known hard problem: it is NP-hard [31], that is, it
is not probable that one could find a fast (i.e., polynomial-time) algorithm for computing ω(G).
Moreover, in general, not only the exact value of ω(G) is hard to compute, but it is also very
difficult to approximate, even roughly [32]. In special cases, however, when the number of the
vertices is only several hundred, and the graph is not too dense, that is, it has not too many edges,
then all the frequently appearing complete subgraphs can be computed relatively quickly by the
apriori algorithm [33, 34]. The computational details are given in the Materials and Methods
section.
Our goal in the present contribution is to map the frequently appearing complete subgraphs in
human connectomes. We need to make clear that our analysis is done on 463-vertex braingraphs.
Therefore, if a complete subgraph is found, it does not imply the neuronal level existence of
complete subgraphs. It implies, however, that the macroscopic ROIs, corresponding to the vertices
of the complete graphs discovered, are connected densely to each another, probably even on the
neuronal level.
In the literature one may find numerous references to the "rich club property" of some networks,
related to the braingraph [35, 36]. Here we prefer using classical graph theoretical terms instead
of this "rich club property", consequently, we intend to map those densely connected subgraphs
of the human connectomes, which form complete graphs, and appear in at least the 80% of the
all braingraphs considered.
Discussion and Results
First we review the frequent complete subgraphs of the human braingraph, next we analyze
the significant differences in their frequencies in males and in females.
3
Frequent complete subgraphs of the human connectome
Supporting Table S1 contains the complete subgraphs of the human connectomes appearing in
at least 80% of the graphs of the 414 subjects examined. In each row, the vertices of the complete
subgraphs are listed, together with their frequencies of appearance. Note, that the vertices of a
complete graph uniquely determine its edges. The list is redundant in the following sense: if a
k-vertex complete graph has frequency at least 80%, then all of its complete subgraphs are also
listed. We find that this redundancy helps in the analysis of the results, as it will be clear from
what follows.
We would like to emphasize the following very simple, but powerful fact: If a given subgraph
U has a frequency, say (cid:96)%, then all subgraphs of U has frequency at least (cid:96)%. This is the central
point in the apriori algorithm [33, 34], and it was noted and applied in [21, 22].
The ROIs
in Table S1 carry the names of
the resolution-250 parcellation labels
(where the number 250 refers to the approximate number of vertices in each hemisphere;
the graphs of
just 250), based on the Lau-
sanne 2008 brain atlas [37] and computed by using FreeSurfer [38] and CMTK [39, 5],
given at https://github.com/LTS5/cmp_nipype/blob/master/cmtklib/data/parcellation/
lausanne2008/ParcellationLausanne2008.xls. The "lh" and the "rh" prefixes abbreviate the
"left-hemisphere" and "right-hemisphere" terms of localizations.
resolution-250 contain 465 vertices, not
Complete subgraphs appearing in each subject
Here we list the maximal complete subgraphs from supporting Table S1, which are present in
all of the braingraphs, and contains at least three nodes:
L1: (Left-Caudate)(Left-Pallidum)(Left-Putamen)(Left-Thalamus-Proper),
L2: (Left-Hippocampus)(Left-Putamen)(Left-Thalamus-Proper),
L3: (Left-Putamen)(Left-Thalamus-Proper)(lh.insula 1)
R1: (Right-Caudate)(Right-Pallidum)(Right-Putamen)(Right-Thalamus-Proper)
R2: (Right-Hippocampus)(Right-Putamen)(Right-Thalamus-Proper)
R3: (Right-Putamen)(Right-Thalamus-Proper)(rh.insula 2)
R4: (rh.superiorfrontal 7)(rh.superiorfrontal 8)(rh.superiorfrontal 9)
Note that L1 and L2 correspond to R1 and R2, and L3 almost corresponds to R3. Complete
graph R4 has no correspondence in the left hemisphere (which are present in each subject), but
in the left hemisphere, the superiorfrontal regions are also connected densely, as one can verify
easily from Table S1.
We believe that the connections between the above-listed areas are very strong in each subject:
so strong that they are not affected by measurement errors and individual variability.
The largest frequent complete subgraphs
The largest complete subgraphs, which are present in at least the 80% of the subjects, have
seven vertices, and they are located in the left hemisphere. The first one connects the left putamen
with six vertices in the left frontal lobe (B1), the second one connects the left caudate and the
left putamen ROIs to five left frontal areas (B2):
B1:
(lh.lateralorbitofrontal 6)
(lh.parstriangularis 3) (lh.rostralmiddlefrontal 12) (lh.rostralmiddlefrontal 9)
(lh.lateralorbitofrontal 7)
(lh.lateralorbitofrontal 4)
(Left-Putamen)
B2:
(lh.rostralanteriorcingulate 1) (lh.rostralmiddlefrontal 12) (lh.rostralmiddlefrontal 9)
(lh.lateralorbitofrontal 7)
(Left-Putamen)
(Left-Caudate)
(lh.medialorbitofrontal 2)
There are 48 different 6-vertex complete subgraphs, which are present in at least 80% of the connec-
tomes. Only 6 of these are situated in the right hemisphere, the other 42 are in the left hemisphere.
4
Hippocampus
Amygdala
Thalamus-Proper
Putamen
Pallidum
Left Right
247
187
66
99
175
265
673
1041
149
123
Table 1: The number of appearances of the hippocampus, the amygdala, the thalamus-proper, the putamen and
the pallidum in the frequent complete subgraphs, with a frequency threshold of 80%, in each hemisphere. The
right hippocampus and the right amygdala are present in much more complete subgraphs than the left ones; the
left thalamus-proper, the left putamen and the left pallidum are present in much more complete subgraphs than
the right ones.
Complete subgraphs across the hemispheres
Since the neural fiber tracts, connecting the two hemispheres of the brain, are very dense in the corpus
callosum, their tractography in the diffusion MR images is difficult since the fiber-crossings cannot always
be tracked reliably [40, 41].
We have found only relatively few frequent complete subgraphs of the human connectome, which have
nodes from both hemispheres. Here we list those, which are present in more than 80% of the braingraphs
studied; therefore, they are most probably not false positives. Again, we are listing only the maximal
complete subgraphs for clarity. We note that most ROIs in the list are the parts of the striatum: each
complete subgraph contains either a caudate nucleus or a nucleus accumbens of either the right- or the
left hemisphere:
A1: (Left-Accumbens-area)(Left-Caudate)(Left-Thalamus-Proper)(Right-Caudate)
A2: (Left-Accumbens-area)(Left-Caudate)(Right-Caudate)(lh.rostralanteriorcingulate 1)
A3: (Left-Accumbens-area)(Left-Thalamus-Proper)(Right-Thalamus-Proper)
A4: (Left-Caudate)(Left-Thalamus-Proper)(Right-Caudate)(Right-Thalamus-Proper)
A5: (Left-Caudate)(Right-Caudate)(lh.caudalanteriorcingulate 1)(lh.caudalanteriorcingulate 2)
A6: (Left-Caudate)(Right-Caudate)(lh.caudalanteriorcingulate 1)(lh.rostralanteriorcingulate 1)
A7: (Left-Caudate)(Right-Caudate)(rh.caudalanteriorcingulate 1)
A8: (Left-Caudate)(Right-Caudate)(rh.rostralanteriorcingulate 2)
A9: (Left-Thalamus-Proper)(Right-Accumbens-area)(Right-Thalamus-Proper)
Counts of the hippocampus, thalamus, putamen, pallidum and the amygdala in the frequent com-
plete subgraphs
In this section we count the appearances of certain ROIs in the frequent complete subgraphs, with
a frequency threshold of 80%. Our results show that there are considerable differences between the
hemispheres in these numbers: The right hippocampus and the right amygdala are present in much more
complete subgraphs than the left ones; the left thalamus-proper, the left putamen and the left pallidum
are present in much more complete subgraphs than the right ones (Table 1).
Sex differences
Mapping sex differences in the human connectome is a hot and fast-developing area of research. In
our earlier works we have shown - first in the literature - that in numerous well-defined graph theoretical
parameters, women have "better connected" braingraphs than men [11, 12, 13]. In the work [21] we have
mapped the frequent subgraphs of the human brain of at most 6 vertices, and have found sex differences:
there are numerous frequent connected subgraphs, which are more frequent in men than in women, and,
similarly, which are more frequent in men than in women. In the study of [22], we have mapped the
neighbor-sets of the human hippocampus and found also significant sex differences in these sets.
Here we compare the frequencies of the complete subgraphs of the connectomes of men and women.
We have found significant differences in the frequencies of some complete subgraphs, with the advantage
at men and women, too.
5
We have found much more complete subgraphs with significantly higher frequency in men than in
women. More exactly, Supporting Table S2 lists 224 complete subgraphs, with significantly higher fre-
quency in females than in males, while Table S3 lists 812 complete subgraphs, where their frequencies in
males were higher than in females (with p=0.01, and the inclusion threshold was a minimum 80% for the
larger frequency).
This observation, in a sense, shows that men's connectomes show less inter-personal variability in
complete subgraphs than those of women. This observation is in contrast with our findings in [21], where
we have shown that women have much more 6-vertex frequent subgraphs than men: but in [21] we
required connectedness, and not completeness.
Figure 1: A complete subgraph with four vertices, which is present in all 414 human connectomes examined. The
vertices of the depicted subgraph are Right-Caudate, Right-Pallidum, Right-Putamen, Right-Thalamus-Proper.
The supporting Table S1 contains all the complete subgraphs with frequency of at least 80%, Table S2 contains
the complete subgraphs, where the frequency of their appearance in females is significantly higher (p=0.01) than
in males; Table S3 contains those, where the frequency is significantly higher in males than in females. The
supporting tables are available at http://uratim.com/cliques/tables.zip.
Materials and Methods
The Data Source and the Graph Computation
The data source of the present study is the website of the Human Connectome Project at the address
http://www.humanconnectome.org/documentation/S500 [29]. The dataset contains the HARDI MRI
data of healthy human young adults between the ages of 22 and 35 years.
The CMTK toolkit [5], together with the FreeSurfer tool and the MRtrix tractography process-
In the MRtrix tool, we have applied ran-
[42] were applied in the graph generation.
ing tool
6
domized seeding and deterministic streamline method, with 1 million streamlines. We have stud-
ied here graphs with 463-vertex resolution. The parcellation data is given in the CMTK nypipe
GitHub repository https://github.com/LTS5/cmp_nipype/blob/master/cmtklib/data/parcellation/
lausanne2008/ParcellationLausanne2008.xls.
Further particularities of the graph processing workflow are described in [6], where the http://
braingraph.org repository is also given. The braingraphs, analyzed here, can be accessed at the https:
//braingraph.org/cms/download-pit-group-connectomes/ site, choosing the "Full set, 413 brains, 1
million streamlines" option.
The Algorithm
In general, in a graph G, finding the size of the largest complete subgraph, called the clique-number,
it is NP-hard [31]. Naturally, finding the largest complete
and denoted by ω(G), is a hard problem:
subgraph itself cannot be easier than finding its size ω(G); therefore, it is also hard.
Finding the largest complete subgraphs in sparse graphs (i.e., graphs with relatively few edges, com-
pared to the number of its vertices) is usually not a very difficult task, since in these graphs, regularly,
there are not too many large complete subgraphs. Finding only the frequently appearing complete sub-
graphs further simplifies the computational tasks, and we can apply an algorithm, which resembles in
many points to the apriori algorithm for finding frequent item sets [34, 33], and this algorithm is very
fast in the practice.
Now we describe the algorithm: A frequent complete subgraph is characterized by the list of its
vertices and the set of its edges. At the beginning, for an (undirected) edge (vi, vj), let these two lists be
given as ([vi, vj],{(vi, vj)}), where i < j.
In general, the vertices of the complete subgraphs are listed in the increasing order of their indices,
and the vertices of each edge are listed also in the increasing order of its indices; otherwise, the particular
order of the edges is indifferent, since they are elements of an unordered set, and they are stored also as
a set.
Now we describe the generating, "apriori" step. Let
L1 = ([v1, v2, ..., vk],{(v1, v2), (v1, v3), ...(vk−1, vk)})
and
L2 = ([u1, u2, ..., uk],{(u1, u2), (u1, u3), ...(uk−1, uk)})
If the first k − 1 vertices of L1 and L2 are the same,
be two frequent complete subgraphs of size k.
and the last ones differ, we will consider generating a new, k + 1-vertex complete graph, as follows:
if
v1 = u1, v2 = u2, ...vk−1 = uk−1 and vk (cid:54)= uk, then, by the notation vk+1 = uk, we verify the suitable
frequency of the complete graph L = ([v1, v2, ...vk, vk+1],{(v1, v2), (v1, v3), ...(vk, vk+1)}).
It is easy to see that in the edge list only the last one, (vk, vk+1) is new, all the others are already the
edges of the frequent subgraphs L1 or L2.
In generating L one needs to make sure that the vertices in the vertex-list are ordered by their indices,
and that the frequency of L is above the inclusion threshold.
The apriori generating step is correct, since if L is frequent, then both L1 and L2 were frequent.
Additionally, every k + 1-vertex complete graph is generated only once, since the vertices are in increasing
order: (v1, v2, . . . , vk+1) can be generated only from (v1, ...vk) and (v1, ...vk−1, vk+1).
Statistical Notes
The frequent complete subgraphs were chosen in the following way:
First, the subjects were partitioned into two disjoint sets, by the parity of their ID number's second
digit from the right. Next, in both sets, the complete graphs with the minimum frequency of 80% were
identified, as it was described in the previous section. Only those complete subgraphs were retained,
which have had a minimum frequency of 80% in both sets under consideration. Then the frequency of
these subgraphs were re-calculated for the whole dataset: these frequencies are given in the supplementary
tables.
In the computation of sex differences, we have applied χ2 tests to identify significant differences in
the frequencies of the complete subgraphs. Our null hypothesis was that the frequencies are the same
7
in males and females, and we refute this hypothesis with p=0.01. The secondary statistical errors were
handled by Holm-Bonferroni corrections [43]. The un-corrected and the corrected p values are listed in
supplementary Tables S2 and S3.
Conclusions
By an apriori-like algorithm, we have mapped the frequent (>80%) complete subgraphs of 414 sub-
jects, each with 463 vertices. The largest frequent complete subgraph has 7 vertices. Most of the largest
frequent subgraphs are located in the left hemisphere. We have also identified the frequent complete
subgraphs, containing vertices from both hemispheres, and identified complete subgraphs with significant
frequency-differences between the sexes. We have found that men have much more frequent complete
subgraphs than women: this result contrasts our earlier finding [11], where we have shown that women
have much better connectivity-related parameters in their connectomes than men in a following sense:
while women have better connected braingraphs than men (as it is very precisely described in [11]), the
dense subgraphs of men show less inter-individual variability than in women.
Data availability
The data source of this work is published at the Human Connectome Project's website at http://www.
humanconnectome.org/documentation/S500 [29]. The parcellation data, containing the anatomically
labeled ROIs, is listed in the CMTK nypipe GitHub repository https://github.com/LTS5/cmp_nipype/
blob/master/cmtklib/data/parcellation/lausanne2008/ParcellationLausanne2008.xls.
The braingraphs, computed by us, can be accessed at the https://braingraph.org/cms/
download-pit-group-connectomes/ site, by choosing the "Full set, 413 brains, 1 million streamlines"
option. Here we have used exclusively the 463-node graphs.
The Supplementary Tables are available on-line at the address http://uratim.com/cliques/tables.
zip. Table S1 contains the list of all the complete subgraphs of 414 human connectomes with a minimum
frequency of 80%. Table S2 contains the complete subgraphs, where the frequency of their appearance
in females is significantly higher (p=0.01) than in males; Table S3 contains those, where the frequency is
significantly higher in males than in females. In both Tables S2 and S3 a frequency cut-off 80% is applied
to the larger frequency of the appearance in the sexes: only those significant differences are listed, where
the larger of the frequencies of males and females are at least 80%.
Acknowledgments
Data were provided in part by the Human Connectome Project, WU-Minn Consortium (Principal
Investigators: David Van Essen and Kamil Ugurbil; 1U54MH091657) funded by the 16 NIH Institutes
and Centers that support the NIH Blueprint for Neuroscience Research; and by the McDonnell Center for
Systems Neuroscience at Washington University. VG and BV were partially supported by the VEKOP-
2.3.2-16-2017-00014 program, supported by the European Union and the State of Hungary, co-financed
by the European Regional Development Fund, VG and MF by the NKFI-126472 and NKFI-127909 grants
of the National Research, Development and Innovation Office of Hungary. BV and MF was supported
in part by the EFOP-3.6.3-VEKOP-16-2017-00002 grant, supported by the European Union, co-financed
by the European Social Fund.
Conflict of Interest: The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Author Contribution
MF analyzed braingraphs and developed statistical and graph theoretical tools, BV constructed the
image processing system and computed the braingraphs, VG has initiated the study, analyzed data and
wrote the paper.
8
References
[1] Patric Hagmann, Patricia E. Grant, and Damien A. Fair. MR connectomics: a conceptual framework
for studying the developing brain. Front Syst Neurosci, 6:43, 2012. doi: 10.3389/fnsys.2012.00043.
URL http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fnsys.2012.00043.
[2] H Sebastian Seung. Reading the book of memory:
sparse sampling versus dense mapping of
connectomes. Neuron, 62(1):17 -- 29, Apr 2009. doi: 10.1016/j.neuron.2009.03.020. URL http:
//dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2009.03.020.
[3] Olaf Sporns, Giulio Tononi, and Rolf Kotter. The human connectome: A structural description of
the human brain. PLoS Comput Biol, 1(4):e42, Sep 2005. doi: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.0010042. URL
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.0010042.
[4] Jeff W. Lichtman, Jean Livet, and Joshua R. Sanes. A technicolour approach to the connectome.
Nat Rev Neurosci, 9(6):417 -- 422, Jun 2008. doi: 10.1038/nrn2391. URL http://dx.doi.org/10.
1038/nrn2391.
[5] Alessandro Daducci, Stephan Gerhard, Alessandra Griffa, Alia Lemkaddem, Leila Cammoun, Xavier
Gigandet, Reto Meuli, Patric Hagmann, and Jean-Philippe Thiran. The connectome mapper: an
open-source processing pipeline to map connectomes with MRI. PLoS One, 7(12):e48121, 2012. doi:
10.1371/journal.pone.0048121. URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0048121.
[6] Csaba Kerepesi, Balazs Szalkai, Balint Varga, and Vince Grolmusz. The braingraph. org database
of high resolution structural connectomes and the brain graph tools. Cognitive Neurodynamics, 11
(5):483 -- 486, 2017.
[7] JG White, E Southgate, JN Thomson, and S Brenner. The structure of the nervous system of the
nematode caenorhabditis elegans: the mind of a worm. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond, 314:1 -- 340, 1986.
[8] Tomoko Ohyama, Casey M Schneider-Mizell, Richard D Fetter, Javier Valdes Aleman, Romain
Franconville, Marta Rivera-Alba, Brett D Mensh, Kristin M Branson, Julie H Simpson, James W
Truman, Albert Cardona, and Marta Zlatic. A multilevel multimodal circuit enhances action selec-
tion in Drosophila. Nature, 520:633 -- 639, April 2015. ISSN 1476-4687. doi: 10.1038/nature14297.
[9] Kerrianne Ryan, Zhiyuan Lu, and Ian A Meinertzhagen. The CNS connectome of a tadpole larva
of Cona intestinalis (L.) highlights sidedness in the brain of a chordate sibling. eLife, 5, December
2016. ISSN 2050-084X. doi: 10.7554/eLife.16962.
[10] Zhihao Zheng, J Scott Lauritzen, Eric Perlman, Camenzind G Robinson, Matthew Nichols, Daniel
Milkie, Omar Torrens, John Price, Corey B Fisher, Nadiya Sharifi, Steven A Calle-Schuler, Lucia
Kmecova, Iqbal J Ali, Bill Karsh, Eric T Trautman, John A Bogovic, Philipp Hanslovsky, Gregory
S X E Jefferis, Michael Kazhdan, Khaled Khairy, Stephan Saalfeld, Richard D Fetter, and Davi D
Bock. A complete electron microscopy volume of the brain of adult drosophila melanogaster. Cell,
174:730 -- 743.e22, July 2018. ISSN 1097-4172. doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2018.06.019.
[11] Bal´azs Szalkai, B´alint Varga, and Vince Grolmusz. Graph theoretical analysis reveals: Women's
brains are better connected than men's. PLoS One, 10(7):e0130045, 2015. doi: 10.1371/journal.
pone.0130045. URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0130045.
[12] Bal´azs Szalkai, B´alint Varga, and Vince Grolmusz. The graph of our mind.
arXiv preprint
arXiv:1603.00904, 2016.
[13] Bal´azs Szalkai, B´alint Varga, and Vince Grolmusz. Brain size bias-compensated graph-theoretical
parameters are also better in women's connectomes. Brain Imaging and Behavior, 2017. doi: 10.
1007/s11682-017-9720-0. URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11682-017-9720-0. Also in arXiv
preprint arXiv:1512.01156.
9
[14] Bal´azs Szalkai, Csaba Kerepesi, B´alint Varga, and Vince Grolmusz. The Budapest Reference Con-
nectome Server v2. 0. Neuroscience Letters, 595:60 -- 62, 2015.
[15] Balazs Szalkai, Csaba Kerepesi, Balint Varga, and Vince Grolmusz. Parameterizable consen-
sus connectomes from the Human Connectome Project: The Budapest Reference Connectome
Server v3.0. Cognitive Neurodynamics, 11(1):113 -- 116, feb 2017. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/
s11571-016-9407-z.
[16] Csaba Kerepesi, Bal´azs Szalkai, B´alint Varga, and Vince Grolmusz. Comparative connectomics:
Mapping the inter-individual variability of connections within the regions of the human brain. Neu-
roscience Letters, 662(1):17 -- 21, 2018. doi: 10.1016/j.neulet.2017.10.003.
[17] Csaba Kerepesi, Balazs Szalkai, Balint Varga, and Vince Grolmusz. How to direct the edges of the
connectomes: Dynamics of the consensus connectomes and the development of the connections in the
human brain. PLOS One, 11(6):e0158680, June 2016. URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.
pone.0158680.
[18] Csaba Kerepesi, Balint Varga, Balazs Szalkai, and Vince Grolmusz. The dorsal striatum and the
dynamics of the consensus connectomes in the frontal lobe of the human brain. Neuroscience Letters,
673:51 -- 55, 2018. doi: 10.1016/j.neulet.2018.02.052.
[19] Balazs Szalkai, Csaba Kerepesi, Balint Varga, and Vince Grolmusz. High-resolution directed human
connectomes and the consensus connectome dynamics. arXiv, 1609.09036, September 2016.
[20] Bal´azs Szalkai, B´alint Varga, and Vince Grolmusz. The robustness and the doubly-preferential
attachment simulation of the consensus connectome dynamics of the human brain. Scientific Reports,
7(16118), 2017. doi: 10.1038/s41598-017-16326-0.
[21] Mate Fellner, Balint Varga, and Vince Grolmusz. The frequent subgraphs of the connectome of the
human brain. arXiv preprint arXiv:1711.11314, 2017.
[22] Mate Fellner, Balint Varga, and Vince Grolmusz. The frequent network neighborhood mapping of
the human hippocampus shows much more frequent neighbor sets in males than in females. arXiv
preprint arXiv:1811.07423, 2018.
[23] Leonhard Euler. Solutio problematis ad geometriam situs pertinentis. Commentarii Academiae
Scientarum Imperialis Petropolitanae, 8(1):128 -- 140, 1741. URL http://eulerarchive.maa.org/
/docs/originals/E053.pdf.
[24] Maria Chudnovsky, Neil Robertson, Paul Seymour, and Robin Thomas. The strong perfect graph
theorem.
[25] Endre Szemeredi. Regular Partitions of Graphs. In Colloq. Internat. CNRS, Univ. Orsay, Orsay,
1976, volume 260. CNRS, 1975.
[26] F Thomson Leighton. Introduction to parallel algorithms and architectures: Arrays, trees, hypercubes.
Elsevier, 1992. ISBN 9781483221151.
[27] Saad Jbabdi and Heidi Johansen-Berg. Tractography: where do we go from here? Brain Connect,
1(3):169 -- 183, 2011. doi: 10.1089/brain.2011.0033. URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1089/brain.2011.
0033.
[28] J-F. Mangin, P. Fillard, Y. Cointepas, D. Le Bihan, V. Frouin, and C. Poupon. Toward global
tractography. Neuroimage, 80:290 -- 296, Oct 2013. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.04.009. URL
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.04.009.
10
[29] Jennifer A. McNab, Brian L. Edlow, Thomas Witzel, Susie Y. Huang, Himanshu Bhat, Keith
Heberlein, Thorsten Feiweier, Kecheng Liu, Boris Keil, Julien Cohen-Adad, M Dylan Tisdall, Re-
becca D. Folkerth, Hannah C. Kinney, and Lawrence L. Wald. The Human Connectome Project
and beyond: initial applications of 300 mT/m gradients. Neuroimage, 80:234 -- 245, Oct 2013. doi:
10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.05.074. URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.05.074.
[30] Ann E Sizemore, Chad Giusti, Ari Kahn, Jean M Vettel, Richard F Betzel, and Danielle S Bassett.
Cliques and cavities in the human connectome. Journal of Computational Neuroscience, 44(1):
115 -- 145, 2018.
[31] Michael R. Garey and David S. Johnson. Computers and Intractability: A Guide to the Theory of
NP-Completeness. W.H. Freeman, 1979.
[32] Johan Hastad. Clique is hard to approximate within n1-epsilon.
In 37th Annual Symposium on
Foundations of Computer Science, FOCS '96, Burlington, Vermont, USA, 14-16 October, 1996,
pages 627 -- 636. IEEE Computer Society, 1996. doi: 10.1109/SFCS.1996.548522.
[33] Rakesh Agrawal, Tomasz Imielinski, and Arun N. Swami. Mining association rules between sets of
items in large databases. In Peter Buneman and Sushil Jajodia, editors, Proceedings of the 1993
ACM SIGMOD International Conference on Management of Data, Washington, D.C., May 26-28,
1993, pages 207 -- 216. ACM Press, 1993.
[34] Rakesh Agrawal and Ramakrishnan Srikant. Fast algorithms for mining association rules in large
databases. In Jorge B. Bocca, Matthias Jarke, and Carlo Zaniolo, editors, Proc. of the 20th Interna-
tional Conference on Very Large Data Bases (VLDB '94),, volume 1215, pages 487 -- 499. Kaufmann
Publishers Inc.
1994.
"
[35] Gareth Ball, Paul Aljabar, Sally Zebari, Nora Tusor, Tomoki Arichi, Nazakat Merchant, Emma C.
Robinson, Enitan Ogundipe, Daniel Rueckert, A David Edwards, and Serena J. Counsell. Rich-club
organization of the newborn human brain. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 111(20):7456 -- 7461, May 2014.
doi: 10.1073/pnas.1324118111. URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1324118111.
[36] Martijn P. van den Heuvel and Olaf Sporns. Rich-club organization of the human connectome.
J Neurosci, 31(44):15775 -- 15786, Nov 2011. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.3539-11.2011. URL http:
//dx.doi.org/10.1523/JNEUROSCI.3539-11.2011.
[37] Patric Hagmann, Leila Cammoun, Xavier Gigandet, Reto Meuli, Christopher J. Honey, Van J.
Wedeen, and Olaf Sporns. Mapping the structural core of human cerebral cortex. PLoS Biol, 6(7):
e159, Jul 2008. doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.0060159. URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.
pbio.0060159.
[38] Bruce Fischl. Freesurfer. Neuroimage, 62(2):774 -- 781, 2012.
[39] Stephan Gerhard, Alessandro Daducci, Alia Lemkaddem, Reto Meuli, Jean-Philippe Thiran, and
Patric Hagmann. The connectome viewer toolkit: an open source framework to manage, analyze,
and visualize connectomes. Front Neuroinform, 5:3, 2011. doi: 10.3389/fninf.2011.00003. URL
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fninf.2011.00003.
[40] W Reginold, J Itorralba, A C Luedke, J Fernandez-Ruiz, J Reginold, O Islam, and A Garcia.
Tractography at 3t mri of corpus callosum tracts crossing white matter hyperintensities. AJNR.
American journal of neuroradiology, 37:1617 -- 1622, September 2016. ISSN 1936-959X. doi: 10.3174/
ajnr.A4788.
[41] Sabine Hofer and Jens Frahm. Topography of the human corpus callosum revisited -- comprehensive
fiber tractography using diffusion tensor magnetic resonance imaging. NeuroImage, 32:989 -- 994,
September 2006. ISSN 1053-8119. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2006.05.044.
[42] J Tournier, Fernando Calamante, Alan Connelly, et al. Mrtrix: diffusion tractography in crossing
fiber regions. International Journal of Imaging Systems and Technology, 22(1):53 -- 66, 2012.
11
[43] Sture Holm. A simple sequentially rejective multiple test procedure. Scandinavian Journal of Statis-
tics, pages 65 -- 70, 1979.
12
|
1708.08133 | 1 | 1708 | 2017-08-27T20:27:01 | Methods for applying the Neural Engineering Framework to neuromorphic hardware | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cs.AI",
"eess.SY",
"math.DS"
] | We review our current software tools and theoretical methods for applying the Neural Engineering Framework to state-of-the-art neuromorphic hardware. These methods can be used to implement linear and nonlinear dynamical systems that exploit axonal transmission time-delays, and to fully account for nonideal mixed-analog-digital synapses that exhibit higher-order dynamics with heterogeneous time-constants. This summarizes earlier versions of these methods that have been discussed in a more biological context (Voelker & Eliasmith, 2017) or regarding a specific neuromorphic architecture (Voelker et al., 2017). | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Methods for applying the Neural Engineering
Framework to neuromorphic hardware
Aaron R. Voelker and Chris Eliasmith
Centre for Theoretical Neuroscience, University of Waterloo
July 7, 2021
Abstract
We review our current software tools and theoretical methods for apply-
ing the Neural Engineering Framework to state-of-the-art neuromorphic hard-
ware. These methods can be used to implement linear and nonlinear dynami-
cal systems that exploit axonal transmission time-delays, and to fully account
for nonideal mixed-analog-digital synapses that exhibit higher-order dynamics
with heterogeneous time-constants. This summarizes earlier versions of these
methods that have been discussed in a more biological context (Voelker & Elia-
smith, 2017) or regarding a specific neuromorphic architecture (Voelker et
al., 2017).
1
Introduction
This report is motivated by the recent influx of neuromorphic computing architec-
tures including SpiNNaker [1], Neurogrid [2], Brainstorm [3], IBM's TrueNorth [4],
BrainScaleS [5], and ROLLS [6], among others. These are massively-parallel, low-
power, analog, and/or digital systems (often a mix of the two) that are designed
to simulate large-scale artificial neural networks rivalling the scale and complexity
of real biological systems. Despite growing excitement, we believe that methods to
fully unlock the computational power of neuromorphic hardware are lacking. This is
primarily due to a theoretical gap between our traditional, discrete, von Neumann-
like understanding of conventional algorithms and the continuous spike-based signal
processing of real brains that is often emulated in silicon [7].
We use the term "neural compiler" to refer loosely to any systematic method of
converting an algorithm, expressed in some high-level mathematical language, into
synaptic connection weights between populations of spiking neurons [8]. To fully
leverage neuromorphic hardware for real-world applications, we require neural com-
pilers that can account for the effects of spiking neuron models and mixed-analog-
digital synapse models, and, perhaps more importantly, exploit these details in useful
ways when possible. There exist various approaches to neural engineering, includ-
ing those by Den`eve et al. [9, 10] and Memmesheimer et al. [11]. However, the
Neural Engineering Framework (NEF; [12, 13]) stands apart in terms of software
implementation (Nengo; [8, 14, 15, 16]), large-scale cognitive modeling [17, 18], and
neuromorphic applications [1, 2, 3, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23]. Competing methods consis-
tently exclude important details, such as refractory periods and membrane voltage
leaks, from their networks [9, 11]. The NEF, on the other hand, embraces biological
complexity whenever it proves computationally useful [24] and/or improves contact
1
with neuroscience literature [25]. This approach to biological modeling directly mir-
rors a similar need to account for the details in neuromorphic hardware when building
neural networks [19, 20, 26].
Nevertheless, there are many open problems in optimizing the NEF for state-
of-the-art neuromorphics. In particular, we have been working to account for more
detailed dynamics in heterogeneous models of the post-synaptic current (PSC) in-
duced by each spike, as well as delays in spike propagation [24, 26, 27, 28]. The
purpose of this report is to summarize our methods, both theoretical and practical,
that have progressed in this direction. There are similar challenges in extending the
NEF to account for multi-compartment neuron models [25, 29], conductance-based
synapses [30], and to minimize the total number of spikes [7] -- but these topics will
not be addressed in this report.
The remainder of this report assumes that the reader is already comfortable with
Nengo and the NEF in the context of engineering dynamical systems (i.e., "Princi-
ple III"). A technical yet accessible overview of the NEF can be found in [31], and a
tutorial for Nengo (version 2) can be found in [15].
2 Accounting for Synaptic Dynamics
This section provides a theoretical account of the effect of higher-order linear synapse
models on the dynamics of the network, by summarizing the extensions from [24]
and [26]. This yields two novel proofs of Principle III from the NEF, and generalizes
the principle to include more detailed synapses, including those modeling axonal
transmission delays.
2.1 Linear systems
Here we focus our attention on linear time-invariant (LTI) systems:
x(t) = Ax(t) + Bu(t)
y(t) = Cx(t) + Du(t)
(1)
where the time-varying vector x(t) represents the system state, y(t) the output, u(t)
the input, and the time-invariant "state-space" matrices (A, B, C, D) fully determine
the system's dynamics. We will omit the variable t when not needed.
Principle III from the NEF states that in order to train the recurrent connection
weights to implement (1) -- using a continuous-time lowpass filter h(t) = (1/τ )e−t/τ
to model the PSC -- we use Principle II to train the decoders for the recurrent trans-
formation (τ A + I)x, input transformation τ Bu, output transformation Cx, and
passthrough transformation Du [13, pp. 221 -- 225]. This drives the recurrent synapses
with the signal τ x + x so that their output is the signal x, in effect transforming
the synapses into perfect integrators with respect to x. The vector x is then repre-
sented by the population of neurons via Principle I. Thus, this provides a systematic
approach for training a recurrent neural network to implement any linear dynamical
system. Now we show that this approach generalizes to other synaptic models.
For these purposes, the transfer function is a more useful description of the LTI
system than (1). The transfer function is defined as the ratio of Y (s) to U (s), given
by the Laplace transforms of y(t) and u(t) respectively. The variable s denotes a
complex value in the frequency domain, while t is non-negative in the time domain.
2
The transfer function is related to (1) by the following:
F (s) =
Y (s)
U (s)
= C(sI − A)−1B + D.
(2)
The transfer function F (s) can be converted into the state-space model (A, B, C, D)
if and only if it can be written as a proper ratio of finite polynomials in s. The ratio
is proper when the degree of the numerator does not exceed that of the denominator.
In this case, the output will not depend on future input, and so the system is 'causal'.
The order of the denominator corresponds to the dimensionality of x, and therefore
must be finite. Both of these conditions can be interpreted as physically realistic
constraints where time may only progress forward, and neural resources are finite.
Continuous Identity In order to account for the introduction of a synaptic filter
h(t), we replace the integrator s−1 in (2) with H(s), where H(s) = L {h(t)}. This
new system has the transfer function C(H(s)−1I − A)−1B + D = F (H(s)−1). To
compensate for this change in dynamics, we must invert the change-of-variables s ↔
H(s)−1. This means finding the required F H (s) such that F H (H(s)−1) is equal to
the desired transfer function, F (s). We highlight this as the following identity:
F H(cid:18) 1
H(s)(cid:19) = F (s).
(3)
Then the state-space model (AH , BH , CH , DH ) satisfying (2) with respect to F H (s)
will implement the desired dynamics (1) given h(t).
Discrete Identity For the discrete (i.e., digital synapse) case, we begin with F (z)
and H(z) expressed as digital systems. The form of H(z) is usually determined by
the hardware, and F (z) is usually found by a zero-order hold (ZOH) discretization
of F (s) using the simulation time-step (dt), resulting in the discrete LTI system:
x[t + dt] = ¯Ax[t] + ¯Bu[t]
y[t] = ¯Cx[t] + ¯Du[t].
Here, we have the same relationship as (2),
F (z) =
Y (z)
U (z)
= ¯C(zI − ¯A)−1 ¯B + ¯D.
(4)
(5)
Therefore, the previous discussion applies, and we must find an F H (z) that satisfies:
F H(cid:18) 1
H(z)(cid:19) = F (z).
(6)
Then the state-space model ( ¯AH , ¯BH , ¯CH , ¯DH ) satisfying (5) with respect to F H (z)
will implement the desired dynamics (4) given h[t]. In either case, the general prob-
lem reduces to solving this change-of-variables problem for various synaptic models.
We now provide a number of results. More detailed derivations are available in [24].
Continuous Lowpass Synapse Replacing the integrator s−1 with the standard
continuous-time lowpass filter, so that H(s) = 1
τ s+1 :
F H (τ s + 1) = F (s) ⇐⇒ F H (s) = C(sI − (τ A + I))−1(τ B) + D
(7)
which rederives the standard form of Principle III from the NEF [13].
3
Discrete Lowpass Synapse Replacing the integrator with a discrete-time lowpass
filter H(z) = 1−a
z−a in the z-domain with time-step dt, where a = e−
τ :
dt
F H(cid:18) z − a
1 − a(cid:19) = F (z) ⇐⇒ F H (z) = ¯C(cid:18)zI −
1
1 − a
( ¯A − aI)(cid:19)−1(cid:18) 1
1 − a
¯B(cid:19) + ¯D.
(8)
Therefore, ¯AH = 1
¯B, ¯CH = ¯C, and ¯DH = ¯D. This map-
ping can dramatically improve the accuracy of Principle III in digital simulations
(e.g., when using a desktop computer) [24].
1−a ( ¯A − aI), ¯BH = 1
1−a
Delayed Continuous Lowpass Synapse Replacing the integrator with a con-
tinuous lowpass filter containing a pure time-delay of length λ, so that H(s) = e−λs
τ s+1 :
F H(cid:18) τ s + 1
e−λs (cid:19) = F (s) ⇐⇒ F H (s) = F(cid:18) 1
λ
W0(ds) −
1
τ(cid:19) ,
(9)
λ
where d = λ
τ and W0(xex) = x is the principal branch of the Lambert-W func-
τ e
tion [32].1 This synapse model can be used to model axonal transmission time-delays
due to the finite-velocity propagation of action potentials, or to model feedback de-
lays within a broader control-theoretic context. To demonstrate the case where a
pure time-delay of length θ is the desired transfer function (F (s) = e−θs), we let
c = e
λ to obtain the required transfer function:
τ and r = θ
θ
ds (cid:19)r
F H (s) = c(cid:18) W0(ds)
= cr
∞
Xi=0
(i + r)i−1
i!
(−ds)i.
(10)
We then numerically find the Pad´e approximants of the latter Taylor series. More
details and validation may be found in [24] and [27].
General Case Finally, we consider any linear synapse model of the form:
H(s) =
,
(11)
1
i=0 cisi
Pk
for some polynomial coefficients (ci) of arbitrary degree k. To the best of our knowl-
edge, this class includes the majority of linear synapse models used in the literature.
For synapses containing a polynomial numerator with degree q > 1 (e.g., considering
the Taylor series expansion of the box filter ǫ−1(1 − e−ǫs)s−1), we take its [0, q]-Pad´e
approximants to transform the synapse into this form within some radius of conver-
gence.2 To map F (s) onto (11), we begin by defining our solution to F H (s) in the
form of its state-space model:
CH = C,
DH = D,
(12)
ciAi,
k
AH =
Xi=0
BH =
Xj=0
k−1
sj
k
Xi=j+1
ciAi−j−1
B,
4
1This assumes that η < π and λRe [s] + λ
2This is equivalent to the approach taken in [26, equations (9)-(11)].
τ > −η cot η, where η := λIm [s] [24].
which we claim satisfies (3). To validate this claim, we assert the following algebraic
relationship (proven in [24]):
H(s)−1I − AH =
k
Xi=0
ci(cid:0)siI − Ai(cid:1) =
sj
k−1
Xj=0
k
Xi=j+1
ciAi−j−1
(sI − A).
We now verify that (12) satisfies (3):
F H (H(s)−1) = CH (H(s)−1I − AH )−1BH + DH
= C(H(s)−1I − AH )−1
= C(sI − A)−1B + D = F (s).
k−1
Xj=0
sj
k
Xi=j+1
ciAi−j−1
B + D
Since sj is the jth-order differential operator, this form of BH states that we must
supply the jth-order input derivatives u(j), for all j = 1 . . . k − 1. To be more precise,
let us first define BH
j
state-space model must implement the input transformation as a linear combination
j u(j). However, if the required derivatives are not
included in the neural representation, then it is natural to use a ZOH method by
assuming u(j) = 0, for all j = 1 . . . k − 1:
:= (cid:16)Pk
of input derivatives, Pk−1
i=j+1 ciAi−j−1(cid:17) B. Then (12) states that the ideal
j=0 BH
BH = k
Xi=1
ciAi−1! B,
(13)
with AH , CH , and DH as in (12). This is now an equivalent model to (12) assuming
ZOH, and in the form of the standard state-space model (1).
The same derivation also applies to the discrete-time domain, with respect to the
discrete synapse (corresponding to some implementation in digital hardware):
Here, the only real difference (apart from notation) is the discrete version of (13):
These mappings are made available by ss2sim and LinearNetwork in nengolib 0.4.0 [28].
Additional details may again be found in [24].
2.2 Nonlinear systems
Here we derive two theorems for nonlinear systems, by taking a different perspective
that is consistent with §2.1. This generalizes the approach taken in [26], which con-
sidered the special case of a pulse-extended (i.e., time-delayed) double-exponential.
We wish to implement some desired nonlinear dynamical system,
x(t) = f (x, u),
(16)
5
H(z) =
1
.
i=0 ¯cizi
Pk
¯ci ¯Ai−j−1
¯B.
k
Xi=j+1
¯BH =
k−1
Xj=0
(14)
(15)
using (11) as the synaptic filter h(t). Letting w(t) = f h(x, u) for some recurrent
function f h and observing that x(t) = (w ∗ h)(t), we may express these dynamics in
the Laplace domain:
⇐⇒
⇐⇒
X(s)
W(s)
=
1
i=0 cisi
Pk
W(s) = X(s)
w(t) =
k
Xi=0
cix(i)
cisi =
k
Xi=0
k
Xi=0
ci(cid:2)siX(s)(cid:3)
since s is the differential operator. This proves the following theorem:
Theorem 1. Let the function computed along the recurrent connection be:
f h(x, u) =
cix(i)
k
Xi=0
(17)
where x(i) denotes the ith time-derivative of x(t), and ci are given by (11). Then the
resulting dynamical system is precisely (16).
For the discrete case, we begin with some desired nonlinear dynamics expressed
over discrete time-steps:
x[t + dt] = ¯f (x, u),
using (14) as the synaptic filter h[t], followed by an analogous theorem:
Theorem 2. Let the function computed along the recurrent connection be:
¯f h(x, u) =
¯cix[i]
k
Xi=0
(18)
(19)
where x[i] denotes the ith discrete forwards time-shift of x, and ¯ci are given by (14).
Then the resulting dynamical system is precisely (18).
The proof for the discrete case is nearly identical. For sake of completeness, let
w[t] = ¯f h(x, u) for some recurrent function ¯f h and observe that x[t] = (w ∗ h)[t]:
⇐⇒
⇐⇒
X(z)
W(z)
=
1
i=0 ¯cizi
Pk
W(z) = X(z)
w[t] =
k
Xi=0
¯cix[i]
¯cizi =
k
Xi=0
k
Xi=0
¯ci(cid:2)ziX(z)(cid:3)
since z is the forwards time-shift operator.
6
Continuous Lowpass Synapse For standard Principle III, we have H(s) = 1
=⇒ k = 1, c0 = 1 and c1 = τ ,
τ s+1
=⇒ f h(x, u) = c0x(0) + c1x(1) = x + τ x = τ f (x, u) + x.
(20)
Note that (20) is consistent with (7) and with Principle III from the NEF.
Discrete Lowpass Synapse For the discrete case of Principle III, we have H(z) =
1−a
z−a , where a = e−dt/τ =⇒ k = 1, ¯c0 = −a(1 − a)−1, ¯c1 = (1 − a)−1,
=⇒ ¯f h(x, u) = ¯c0x[0] + ¯c1x[1] = (1 − a)−1( ¯f (x, u) − ax).
(21)
Note that (21) is consistent with (8).
Continuous Double Exponential Synapse For the double exponential synapse:
H(s) =
1
(τ1s + 1)(τ2s + 1)
=
1
τ1τ2s2 + (τ1 + τ2)s + 1
(22)
=⇒ f h(x, u) = x + (τ1 + τ2) x + τ1τ2 x
= x + (τ1 + τ2)f (x, u) + τ1τ2(cid:18) ∂f (x, u)
∂x
· f (x, u) +
∂f (x, u)
∂u
· u(cid:19) .
(23)
In the linear case, this simplifies to:
f h(x, u) =(cid:0)τ1τ2A2 + (τ1 + τ2)A + I(cid:1) x + (τ1 + τ2 + τ1τ2A) Bu + τ1τ2B u.
Linear Systems As in §2.1, Theorems 1 and 2 require that we differentiate the
desired dynamical system. For the case of nonlinear systems, this means determining
the (possibly higher-order) Jacobian(s) of f , as shown in (23). For the special case of
LTI systems, we can determine this analytically to obtain a closed-form expression.
By induction it can be shown that:
x(i) = Aix +
i−1
Xj=0
Ai−j−1Bu(j).
Then by expanding and rewriting the summations:
f h(x, u) =
k
k
=
cix(i)
Xi=0
ci
Xi=0
Aix +
ciAi!
= k
Xi=0
{z
}
Recurrent
Matrix
x +
i−1
Xj=0
Xj=0
k−1
k
Ai−j−1Bu(j)
ciAi−j−1
Xi=j+1
B
{z
}
Input Matrices
7
u(j).
(24)
The discrete case is identical:
¯ci ¯Ai!
¯f h(x, u) = k
Xi=0
}
{z
Recurrent
Matrix
x +
k−1
Xj=0
k
Xi=j+1
¯ci ¯Ai−j−1
¯B
}
{z
Input Matrices
u[j].
(25)
This gives a matrix form for any LTI system with a kth order synapse, provided we
can determine u(j) or u[j] for 0 ≤ j ≤ k − 1. Again, (24) is consistent with (12) and
(13), as is (25) with (15).
3 Accounting for Synaptic Heterogeneity
We now show how §2 can be applied to train efficient networks where the ith neuron
has a distinct synaptic filter hi(t), given by:
Hi(s) =
.
(26)
1
j=0 cij sj
Pki
This network architecture can be modeled in Nengo using nengolib 0.4.0 [28]. This
is particularly useful for applications to neuromorphic hardware, where transistor
mismatch can change the effective time-constant(s) of each synapse. To this end, we
abstract the approach taken in [26]. We show this specifically for Theorem 1, but
this naturally applies to all methods in this report.
Recalling the intuition behind Principle III, our approach is to separately drive
each synapse hi with the required signal f hi(x, u) such that each PSC becomes the
desired representation x. Thus, the connection weights to the ith neuron should
be determined by solving the decoder optimization problems for f hi(x, u) using the
methods of §2 with respect to the synapse model hi. This can be repeated for each
synapse to obtain a full set of connection weights. While correct in theory, this
approach displays two shortcomings in practice: (1) we must solve n optimization
problems, where n is the number of post-synaptic neurons, and (2) there are O(n2)
weights, which eliminates the space and time efficiency of using factorized weight
matrices [1].
We can solve both issues simultaneously by taking advantage of the linear struc-
ture within f hi that is shared between all hi. Considering Theorem 1, we need to
drive the ith synapse with the function:
f hi(x, u) =
cij x(j).
ki
Xj=0
Let dj be the set of decoders optimized to approximate x(j), for all j = 0 . . . k, where
k = maxi ki. By linearity, the optimal decoders used to represent each f hi(x, u) may
be decomposed as:
df hi =
cij dj.
ki
Xj=0
Next, we express our estimate of each variable x(j) using the same activity vector a:
x(j) =(cid:10)a, dj(cid:11) .
8
Now, putting this all together, we obtain:
Da, df hiE =
ki
Xj=0
cij(cid:10)a, dj(cid:11) =
ki
Xj=0
cij x(j) ≈ f hi(x, u).
(27)
Therefore, we only need to solve k + 1 optimization problems, decode the "matrix
representation"(cid:2)x(0), x(1), . . . , x(k)(cid:3), and then linearly combine these k + 1 different
decodings as shown in (27) -- using the matrix of coefficients cij -- to determine the
input to each synapse. This approach reclaims the advantages of using factorized
connection weight matrices, at the expense of a factor O(k) increase in space and
time efficiency.
4 Discussion
We have reviewed three major extensions to the NEF that appear in recent publi-
cations. These methods can be used to implement linear and nonlinear systems in
spiking neurons recurrently coupled with heterogeneous higher-order mixed-analog-
digital synapses. This provides us with the ability to implement NEF networks in
state-of-the-art neuromorphics while accounting for, and sometimes even exploiting,
their nonideal nature.
While the linear and nonlinear methods can both be used to harness pure spike
time-delays (due to axonal transmission) by modeling them in the synapse, the lin-
ear approach provides greater flexibility. Both extensions can first transform the
time-delay into the standard form of (11) via Pad´e approximants, which maintains
the same internal representation x as the desired dynamics (within some radius of
convergence). But the linear extension also allows the representation to change, since
it is only concerned with maintaining the overall input-output transfer function re-
lation. In particular, we derived an analytic solution using the Lambert-W function,
which allows the neural representation x, and even its dimensionality, to change ac-
cording to the expansion of some Taylor series. The linear case is also much simpler
to analyze in terms of the network-level transfer function that results from substi-
tuting one synapse model for another. For all other results that we have shown, the
linear extension is consistent with the nonlinear extension, as they both maintain
the desired representation by fully accounting for the dynamics in the synapse.
Acknowledgements
We thank Wilten Nicola for inspiring our derivation in §2.2 with his own phase-
space derivation of Principle III using double exponential synapses for autonomous
systems (unpublished). We also thank Kwabena Boahen and Terrence C. Stewart
for providing the idea used in §3 to separately drive each hi, and for improving this
report through many helpful discussions.
9
References
[1] A. Mundy, J. Knight, T. C. Stewart, and S. Furber, "An efficient SpiNNaker implementation
of the Neural Engineering Framework," in The 2015 International Joint Conference on Neural
Networks (IJCNN), pp. 1 -- 8, IEEE, 2015.
[2] S. Choudhary, S. Sloan, S. Fok, A. Neckar, E. Trautmann, P. Gao, T. Stewart, C. Eliasmith,
and K. Boahen, "Silicon neurons that compute," in International Conference on Artificial
Neural Networks (ICANN), pp. 121 -- 128, Springer, 2012.
[3] "Projects
-
The
neuromorphics
project
-
Stanford
University."
http://brainstorm.stanford.edu/projects/ . Accessed: 2017-08-12.
[4] P. A. Merolla, J. V. Arthur, R. Alvarez-Icaza, A. S. Cassidy, J. Sawada, F. Akopyan, B. L.
Jackson, N. Imam, C. Guo, Y. Nakamura, et al., "A million spiking-neuron integrated circuit
with a scalable communication network and interface," Science, vol. 345, no. 6197, pp. 668 -- 673,
2014.
[5] J. Schemmel, D. Briiderle, A. Griibl, M. Hock, K. Meier, and S. Millner, "A wafer-scale neuro-
morphic hardware system for large-scale neural modeling," in IEEE International Symposium
on Circuits and systems (ISCAS), pp. 1947 -- 1950, IEEE, 2010.
[6] N. Qiao, H. Mostafa, F. Corradi, M. Osswald, F. Stefanini, D. Sumislawska, and G. Indiveri,
"A reconfigurable on-line learning spiking neuromorphic processor comprising 256 neurons and
128k synapses," Frontiers in neuroscience, vol. 9, 2015.
[7] K. Boahen, "A neuromorph's prospectus," Computing in Science & Engineering, vol. 19, no. 2,
pp. 14 -- 28, 2017.
[8] T. Bekolay, J. Bergstra, E. Hunsberger, T. DeWolf, T. C. Stewart, D. Rasmussen, X. Choo,
A. R. Voelker, and C. Eliasmith, "Nengo: A Python tool for building large-scale functional
brain models," Frontiers in Neuroinformatics, vol. 7, no. 48, 2014.
[9] M. Boerlin, C. K. Machens, and S. Den`eve, "Predictive coding of dynamical variables in
balanced spiking networks," PLoS Comput Biol, vol. 9, no. 11, p. e1003258, 2013.
[10] M. A. Schwemmer, A. L. Fairhall, S. Den`eve, and E. T. Shea-Brown, "Constructing precisely
computing networks with biophysical spiking neurons," The Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 35,
no. 28, pp. 10112 -- 10134, 2015.
[11] D. Thalmeier, M. Uhlmann, H. J. Kappen, and R.-M. Memmesheimer, "Learning universal
computations with spikes," PLoS Comput Biol, vol. 12, no. 6, p. e1004895, 2016.
[12] C. Eliasmith and C. H. Anderson, "Developing and applying a toolkit from a general neuro-
computational framework," Neurocomputing, vol. 26, pp. 1013 -- 1018, 1999.
[13] C. Eliasmith and C. H. Anderson, Neural engineering: Computation, representation, and
dynamics in neurobiological systems. MIT press, 2003.
[14] T. C. Stewart, B. Tripp, and C. Eliasmith, "Python scripting in the Nengo simulator," Frontiers
in Neuroinformatics, vol. 3, 2009.
[15] S. Sharma, S. Aubin, and C. Eliasmith, "Large-scale cognitive model design using the Nengo
neural simulator," Biologically Inspired Cognitive Architectures, 2016.
[16] J. Gosmann and C. Eliasmith, "Automatic optimization of the computation graph in the Nengo
neural network simulator," Frontiers in Neuroinformatics, vol. 11, p. 33, 2017.
[17] C. Eliasmith, T. C. Stewart, X. Choo, T. Bekolay, T. DeWolf, Y. Tang, and D. Rasmussen, "A
large-scale model of the functioning brain," science, vol. 338, no. 6111, pp. 1202 -- 1205, 2012.
[18] C. Eliasmith, How to build a brain: A neural architecture for biological cognition. Oxford
University Press, 2013.
[19] J. Dethier, P. Nuyujukian, C. Eliasmith, T. C. Stewart, S. A. Elasaad, K. V. Shenoy, and K. A.
Boahen, "A brain-machine interface operating with a real-time spiking neural network control
algorithm," in Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems (NIPS), pp. 2213 -- 2221,
2011.
10
[20] F. Corradi, C. Eliasmith, and G. Indiveri, "Mapping arbitrary mathematical functions and
dynamical systems to neuromorphic VLSI circuits for spike-based neural computation," in
IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems (ISCAS), (Melbourne), 2014.
[21] J. Knight, A. R. Voelker, A. Mundy, C. Eliasmith, and S. Furber, "Efficient SpiNNaker simu-
lation of a heteroassociative memory using the Neural Engineering Framework," in The 2016
International Joint Conference on Neural Networks (IJCNN), IEEE, 07 2016.
[22] M. Berzish, C. Eliasmith, and B. Tripp, "Real-time FPGA simulation of surrogate models of
large spiking networks," in International Conference on Artificial Neural Networks (ICANN),
2016.
[23] A. Mundy, Real time Spaun on SpiNNaker. PhD thesis, University of Manchester, 2016.
[24] A. R. Voelker and C. Eliasmith, "Improving spiking dynamical networks: Accurate delays,
higher-order synapses, and time cells," (under review), 2017.
[25] C. Eliasmith, J. Gosmann, and X.-F. Choo, "BioSpaun: A large-scale behaving brain model
with complex neurons," ArXiv, 2016.
[26] A. R. Voelker, B. V. Benjamin, T. C. Stewart, K. Boahen, and C. Eliasmith, "Extending the
Neural Engineering Framework for nonideal silicon synapses," in IEEE International Sympo-
sium on Circuits and Systems (ISCAS), (Baltimore, MD), IEEE, 05 2017.
[27] A. R. Voelker and C. Eliasmith, "Methods and systems for implementing dynamic neural
networks," (patent pending), 07 2016.
[28] "Nengolib -- Additional extensions and tools for modelling dynamical systems in Nengo."
https://github.com/arvoelke/nengolib/. Accessed: 2017-08-12.
[29] P. Duggins, "Incorporating biologically realistic neuron models into the NEF," Master's thesis,
University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, 2017.
[30] A. Stockel, "Point neurons with conductance-based synapses in the Neural Engineering Frame-
work," tech. rep., Centre for Theoretical Neuroscience, Waterloo, ON, 2017.
[31] T. C. Stewart, "A technical overview of the Neural Engineering Framework," tech. rep., Centre
for Theoretical Neuroscience, Waterloo, ON, 2012.
[32] R. M. Corless, G. H. Gonnet, D. E. Hare, D. J. Jeffrey, and D. E. Knuth, "On the Lambert
W function," Advances in Computational mathematics, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 329 -- 359, 1996.
11
|
1701.04893 | 1 | 1701 | 2017-01-17T22:40:59 | Grid cells show field-to-field variability and this explains the aperiodic response of inhibitory interneurons | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Research on network mechanisms and coding properties of grid cells assume that the firing rate of a grid cell in each of its fields is the same. Furthermore, proposed network models predict spatial regularities in the firing of inhibitory interneurons that are inconsistent with experimental data. In this paper, by analyzing the response of grid cells recorded from rats during free navigation, we first show that there are strong variations in the mean firing rate of the fields of individual grid cells and thus show that the data is inconsistent with the theoretical models that predict similar peak magnitudes. We then build a two population excitatory-inhibitory network model in which sparse spatially selective input to the excitatory cells, presumed to arise from e.g. salient external stimuli, hippocampus or a combination of both, leads to the variability in the firing field amplitudes of grid cells. We show that, when combined with appropriate connectivity between the excitatory and inhibitory neurons, the variability in the firing field amplitudes of grid cells results in inhibitory neurons that do not exhibit regular spatial firing, consistent with experimental data. Finally, we show that even if the spatial positions of the fields are maintained, variations in the firing rates of the fields of grid cells are enough to cause remapping of hippocampal cells. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Grid cells show field-to-field variability and this explains the aperiodic
response of inhibitory interneurons
Benjamin Dunn1†*, Daniel Wennberg1,2†, Ziwei Huang1,3, Yasser Roudi1,4
1 Kavli Institute for Systems Neuroscience / Centre for Neural Computation, NTNU, 7030 Trondheim,
Norway
2 Department of Applied Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, California 94305, USA
3 Werner Reichardt Centre for Integrative Neuroscience, University of Tubingen, D-72076 Tubingen,
Germany
4 Simons Center for Systems Biology, Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, New Jersey 08540, USA
†These authors contributed equally to this work.
* [email protected]
Abstract
Research on network mechanisms and coding properties of grid cells assume that the firing rate of a grid cell
in each of its fields is the same. Furthermore, proposed network models predict spatial regularities in the
firing of inhibitory interneurons that are inconsistent with experimental data. In this paper, by analyzing the
response of grid cells recorded from rats during free navigation, we first show that there are strong variations
in the mean firing rate of the fields of individual grid cells and thus show that the data is inconsistent with
the theoretical models that predict similar peak magnitudes. We then build a two population
excitatory-inhibitory network model in which sparse spatially selective input to the excitatory cells,
presumed to arise from e.g. salient external stimuli, hippocampus or a combination of both, leads to the
variability in the firing field amplitudes of grid cells. We show that, when combined with appropriate
connectivity between the excitatory and inhibitory neurons, the variability in the firing field amplitudes of
grid cells results in inhibitory neurons that do not exhibit regular spatial firing, consistent with experimental
data. Finally, we show that even if the spatial positions of the fields are maintained, variations in the firing
rates of the fields of grid cells are enough to cause remapping of hippocampal cells.
1 Introduction
Grid cells in the medial entorhinal cortex (MEC) of mammals are selectively active in positions that together
form a hexagonal pattern tessellating the space in which an animal moves [1]. These cells, along with other
cells in the MEC that code for various spatial quantities, e.g. speed [2], head direction [3, 4], borders [5], as
well as hippocampal place cells [6, 7], are believed to form the neural basis of spatial navigation in mammals.
Over the past decade, a great deal of knowledge has been collected about the properties of grid cells, thereby
gaining better insight into the neural mechanisms involved in spatial navigation [8].
Since the discovery of grid cells, a significant amount of work has been devoted to building models for
explaining the underlying neural basis of the spatial selectivity of grid cells [9–21]. Among these studies,
network models based on the concept of continuous attractor dynamics explain the hexagonal firing of grid
cells by proposing the generation of a hexagonal pattern of activity on a two dimensional neural array, which
is then moved with the animal using velocity input. These continuous attractor models as well as studies on
the coding of position by grid cells [22–26] assume or predict that the different firing fields of a grid cell are
periodic replicas of one another, and that the mean firing rate, or amplitude, of the firing fields are similar.
In this paper, by analyzing 373 experimentally recorded grid cells, we first demonstrate that, contrary to
the predictions and assumptions in previous work, there is significant field-to-field variability in the response
of grid cells, indicating that individual fields of a cell enjoy a significant degree of independence even though
1
they are laid out on a periodic lattice. We then show that the variability in the fields is instrumental in
answering one of the problems of existing implementations of continuous attractor models of grid cells: that
contrary to experimental findings, they predict regular firing for inhibitory interneurons [27]. Finally, by
considering a feedforward network in which summation of grid cell activity of various scales leads to spatially
localized activity akin to that of hippocampus place cells, we show that changing the relative amplitude of
the fields of grid cells, while maintaining the spatial relationship between the firing of the cells, leads to
global remapping, as has been observed in a recent experimental study by Kanter et al. [28].
Continuous attractor models mainly consider a single population of grid cells, and the role of inhibitory
neurons is included in the effective interaction between the neurons in this single population [9–12, 29]. Those
cases which do consider separate excitatory and inhibitory populations [13–15] rely on connectivity rules
which result in inhibitory interneurons with grid- or "antigrid"-like spatial tuning. This was shown to not
hold true in experimental recordings from the interneurons in the MEC, which did show spatial selectivity
but little or no spatial periodicity in the firing patterns of the interneurons [27]. Our analysis of a network of
inhibitory and excitatory neurons shows that field-to-field variability together with sparse connectivity
between inhibitory and excitatory neurons can explain this experimental finding. Grid cells in the network
simulations that we report here express a hexagonal firing pattern through the interacting effect of recurrent
connectivity and sparse spatially selective input: some of the neurons are activated by place-like input when
the animal visits a certain position, and these neurons activate other cells that should be active at the
position via effective inhibitory interactions. The model is thus different from existing continuous attractor
models in that the generation of grid activity does not require moving a hexagonal pattern of activity on the
network by integrating velocity [9].
2 Results
2.1 Recorded grid cells show field-to-field variability
We analyzed grid cells recorded from rats with multisite (hyperdrive) implants, reported in Stensola et al. [30].
The cells were recorded from the MEC while the animals explored 1 or 1.5 m square, open-field environments.
Analysis was performed per grid cell module. As in [30], modules were identified according to the firing field
spacing, orientation and deformation relative to a perfect hexagonal pattern. In total, we analyzed recordings
from 373 cells distributed among 13 modules and five rats (see sections 5.1-5.12 for details).
Firing fields were detected in grid cell rate maps via watershed segmentation (see section 5.13 for details).
We defined the amplitude of a firing field as the ratio of the number of spikes recorded to the time spent
within a circular region enclosing the field.
Although grid cell rate maps often show clear field-to-field variations, as can be seen in figure 1 a, it is
not obvious whether this variability is mainly induced by some combination of temporal fluctuations in the
cell response, stochastic spiking dynamics, and the non-uniform occupancy typically obtained in open-field
experiments, or if it is a stable property of the spatial tuning of the cell. We performed a careful statistical
analysis to assess the degree of inherent variability in the firing rate of the fields, by measuring the mean
firing rate within each firing field, both over the whole experiment and in the first and second halves of the
experiment separately. These data are compared, on a cell-by-cell basis, against a synthetic population
derived from a spatial tuning profile with identical firing fields, but having the same spacing and spatial
phase as the corresponding real cell. Synthetic spike trains were generated from this tuning profile using the
real trajectory and assuming Poisson spiking with spatially modulated rate (full details of the procedure is
given in section 5.14.) An example of how a real cell and synthetic spikes compare is shown in figure 1 b.
The figure demonstrates that, when compared to the synthetic spikes, the real cell shows considerably more
variation in firing rate from one field to another, and these variations can be substantially larger than the
variation from the first to the second half of the experiment. This indicates that field-to-field variations are
stable and cannot be explained by occupancy and fluctuations alone.
To make this observation quantitative, we also computed the coefficient of variation c of the amplitudes of
each cell, and 1000 synthetically generated spike trains per real cell (see Eq. 25 in section 5.15). Figure 2 a
shows the measured coefficient of variation of all cells in one module, scattered against the corresponding
mean (cid:104)c(cid:105)sim computed from synthetic spikes, and compared directly to a single synthetic spike train
2
Fig 2. Firing field amplitude variability. a:
Blue circles show the field amplitude coefficient of
variation of each cell in a module, scattered against
the mean coefficient of variation from the 1000
synthetic spike trains corresponding to that cell. Red
squares show the same quantity for one particular
synthetic spike train per real cell. b: Between-field
coefficient of variability scattered against within-field
coefficient of variability from the same real cells and
synthetic spikes as in a. Variabilities are computed
from field amplitudes measured in the first and
second halves of the experimental sessions separately.
For each cell, we only included the amplitudes of
firing fields that were detected in both the real cell
rate map and all corresponding synthetic rate maps.
If less than 3 such fields were found, the cell was
discarded. The enlarged, filled markers in a and b
correspond to the cell (yellow circle) and synthetic
spikes (green square) shown in figure 1.
Fig 1. Example grid cell rate map and firing
field amplitudes, with simulated counterpart.
a: A typical grid cell rate map with detected firing
fields circled and numbered. The grid score (gs) and
field amplitude coefficient of variation (c) are quoted
below the rate map. b: The amplitude of each field
in a, normalized to the mean amplitude of all fields
from the same rate map, is shown (gray wide bars in
the background) together with the amplitudes
measured in only the first and second halves of the
session (red and light blue bars in the foreground).
On top of this, markers and error bars visualize the
distribution of normalized amplitudes from 1000
synthetic spike trains, with the black diamond
showing the mean amplitude, the small black
whiskers showing the central 95 % of the full-length
amplitudes (to be compared with the gray wide bars),
and the large purple whiskers showing the central
95 % of the half-length amplitudes (to be compared
with the red and light blue narrow bars). For each
cell and synthetic spike train, amplitudes are
normalized to the mean of the full-length amplitudes
from that cell or spike train when creating this plot.
c-d: Equivalent to a-b, but using synthetic spikes
generated from the real animal trajectory and a
tuning profile consisting of identical firing fields.
Another 1000 synthetic spike trains like this were
used to generate the error bars in b and c, and to
perform the statistical analysis of the variability.
3
a1234567gs=0.82, c=0.60c1234567gs=1.25, c=0.11024Rate /Hz012r/rb1234567Field012r/rdRat: 13855, Cell: 20091024 0950 T1C100.9›cfisim00.9ca01.4cW01.4cBbRat: 13855, Module: 1 realization per real cell. The figure clearly shows that the amplitudes of real cells vary much more than those
of the synthetic spike trains.
While this comparison gives a first indication of the degree of variation in grid cell field amplitudes, it
does not take into account the possibility that the measured field amplitudes in a finite-time experiment may
be affected by factors not accounted for by the synthetic spike trains, such as the simultaneous encoding of
other kinds of information in the grid cell (i.e. head direction), as well as non-Poisson and possibly temporally
varying spiking statistics. We therefore considered data from the first and second halves of the experiments
separately, and asked whether amplitude variation between fields exceeded what would be expected based on
the variability over time of the amplitudes of the same cell. Figure 2 b shows the between-field coefficient of
variability cB scattered against the within-field coefficient cW for each cell in a module, as well as for a single
synthetic spike train per real cell. The coefficients cB and cW are computed from between-field and
within-field variabilities, quantities that are standard in one-way ANOVA (see section 5.15 for details).
Hence, a cB that is significantly greater than cW indicates that we see more variation between the field
amplitudes than what would be expected based on the temporal fluctuations we observe. From the figure we
see that this is the case for a large fraction of the real cells, but certainly not all. On the other hand, all the
simulated cells have cB and cW of comparable magnitudes and somewhat smaller than the typical values for
the real cells. Figure 1 b shows what this can look like in terms of actual field amplitudes: the difference
between the first and second half is quite large for certain firing fields when compared to the synthetic data,
but still much smaller than the variation between different fields in the real data.
To condense this notion into a single number, we computed the F -statistic F = c2
W . We used the 1000
synthetic spike trains to generate a cell-specific null distribution for the F -statistic, which was then used to
compute a p-value by ranking the real F -statistic against this distribution. Note that although we once again
invoke the synthetic data here, we only compare between-field variabilities to within-field variabilities from
the same spike train, such that the effects of factors not accounted for in the synthetic spike generation
should cancel out to a first approximation. Thus we expect that, regardless of additional factors affecting the
between-field variation, each generated distribution for the F -statistic will predict with reasonable accuracy
the outcome for a real cell with this particular trajectory, firing field locations, and mean firing rate,
assuming that the firing fields are identical in terms of the strength of the underlying spatial tuning. This
assumption could be rejected with p < 0.05 for 24 of the 86 cells in the module shown in figure 2, and 129 of
the 373 cells in total.
B/c2
The fact that only a little more than a third of the cells have a statistically significant between-field to
within-field variability ratio reflects a continuum in the cell population, from cells where this ratio is of order
unity to cells to cells with very large field amplitude variations. This property is also clearly visible in figure
2. However, the number of statistically significant cases greatly exceeds the chance level (i.e. 5 % of the
population). By interpreting rejection or not of the null hypothesis as a Bernoulli trial with success
probability 0.05, the number of rejections in a population of cells should follow a binomial distribution under
the null-hypothesis, and thus we can define an aggregate p-value ptot for the number of rejections in the
population. For the module shown in figure 1, this comes out to ptot = 3.5 · 10−12, and for all cells in the
data set we find ptot = 7.5 · 10−71. This leads us to conclude that the discrete translational symmetry of the
grid cell network with respect to physical space is broken not only by geometrical distortions of the lattice
due to the environment [31], but also in terms of the firing field strength at each site.
Supplementary figure 4 contains figures similar to figure 2 for all modules in the data set, containing
between 2 and 93 cells after discarding cells for which fewer than three firing fields were detected. On
average, about 35 % of the cells in a module show statistically significant amplitude variations. We find
ptot < 0.05 for 9 of the 13 modules, and ptot < 0.005 for 8 of these.
2.2 Basic aspects of the recurrent excitatory-inhibitory models
Networks models of grid cells based on continuous attractor dynamics and integration of velocity involve two
key steps. The first one is to generate a translationally periodic pattern of activity in a network of neurons,
and the second is to translate this pattern along with the animal movement using speed and head direction
input [9]. The fact that the fields of a single grid cell appear due to the translation of a regular pattern,
guarantees that in these models each firing field of any given grid cell is the same as another field of the same
cell. The analysis in the previous section thus demonstrates that this simple mechanism cannot be the whole
4
story and other mechanisms are in play to generate the field-to-field variations in the firing rates of a grid cell.
As described in the Introduction, recent experimental evidence also shows that inhibitory neurons in the
MEC do not exhibit spatially periodic firing [27], as predicted by existing continuous attractor models. In
this section we consider a two population network of excitatory and inhibitory neurons and show that, with
appropriate connectivity, field-to-field variability can lead to irregular firing, and that this comes at the cost
of the ability to integrate velocity properly.
We consider a simple two-population models of the form [32]:
+ si = g(cid:0)(cid:88)
+ ua = g(cid:0)(cid:88)
b
τ
τ
dsi
dt
dua
dt
(cid:1)
(cid:1)
Jibub + Iit
Kajsj
j
+ ,
+ ,
(1)
(2)
where si and ua represent the firing rates of the excitatory neuron (grid cell) i and inhibitory neuron
(interneuron) a, respectively. (··· )+ is the threshold-linear function, which outputs zero if its argument if
equal to or less than zero and is a linear function for positive arguments. g is the single neuron gain, τ the
neuronal time constant, Jib and Kaj the connectivity from interneurons to grid cells and grid cells to
interneurons, and Iit the external input.
We consider different forms of external input Iit during the simulations reported below. Classically in
continuous attractor networks of grid cells, one considers a velocity dependent of the typical form
Iit = I v
it ≡ constant + α × speed(t) cos(θt − θi) ,
(3)
where the superscript v emphasizes the velocity dependence of the input, speed(t) and θt are the
time-varying speed and direction of the animal as it moves around, α the velocity modulation and θi the
preferred direction of neuron i, patterned as in Burak and Fiete [11] to (0, π/4, π/2, 3π/4).
However, as noted in the Introduction, with pure velocity input we cannot see any variability in the firing
field amplitudes of grid cells: even if the connectivity is heterogeneous such that in the stationary pattern the
peak activity at some positions in the network ends up being different from another one, the translation of
the pattern will lead the fields of each grid cell to have exactly the same amplitudes, with the heterogeneity
only causing the rates being different from one cell to another, and not different within one cell. We therefore
consider the case in which the hexagonal firing pattern and the variability in the fields of one cell arise from
a different type of input to the excitatory neurons in the model, the place-like input, that could originate
from a combination of sensory input as well as the hippocampus or other areas with spatially selective
neurons projecting to the MEC. Assuming a population of place-like neurons whose rates are denoted Pj(t),
we take the input to be of the form
Iit = I p
it ≡ constant +
HijPj(t) ,
j
(4)
(cid:88)
where the superscript p indicates the place-like selectivity of the cells contributing to this type of input, and
Hij are weights that connect the place-like neurons to the excitatory grid cell population. The weights are
chosen from place-like inputs that are active at hexagonally arranged fields in the environment. The
amplitude of these Hij are drawn from a Gaussian distribution of mean µ = 0.5 and standard deviation σ
with negative values set to zero, as suggested in [33]. We also dilute the input by setting a fraction, fd, of
these connections to zero, allowing us to study not only the effect of variability in the amplitude of the
place-like input but also the sparsity of the input. In what follows, we will study the effect of σ and fd on
the quality of the grid cells generated by the model as well as the field-to-field variability. But before doing
that, we discuss in the next section two ways of wiring up the neurons in the model, namely the choices for J
and K in Eq. 2.
Examples of networks with inputs of the form in equation 3 and 4 can be seen in accompanying videos 1
and 2.
2.3 Two ways of generating the connectivity matrices
Having described the types of input to the network that we consider, in this section we detail two ways of
designing the connectivity pattern between neurons in the model. To do so, we first note that as dua/dt → 0,
5
we have ua = g(cid:80)
We can therefore approximate the term(cid:80)
connectivity between the excitatory neurons:
j Kajsj, since Kaj is non-negative and g(·)+ is a zero-threshold linear activation function.
bj JibKbjsj, to end up with the following effective
b Jibub ≈ g(cid:80)
(cid:88)
Wij = g
JibKbj .
b
As a simple effective connectivity, similar to that used in the literature [11, 12], we let
Wij = W0Θ(Rmax − dij)Θ(dij − Rmin) ,
(5)
where Θ(·) is the Heaviside step function, Rmax the outer ring of the radial extent of the connectivity, Rmin
the inner ring, W0 the strength of the inhibitory connections and dij the Euclidean distance between cells i
and j.
For the simulations reported below, where the external input includes the velocity terms the Euclidean
distance, dij is biased in the preferred direction θi of the grid cell [11],
ij = (xi − xj − l cos(θi))2 + (yi − yj − l sin(θi))2, with xi ∈ [1, Nx], yi ∈ [1, N y] representing the position of
d2
neuron i in a two dimensional Nx × Ny neural sheet with periodic boundary conditions and spatial offset l.
Each grid cell in the model is therefore connected with other neurons within a radius between Rmin and
Rmax, forming an inhibitory ring connectivity. For simulations where place-like input is used, no bias exists
in the connectivity.
Our two network architectures now amount to the different ways of choosing the connectivity matrices J
and K to obtain the prescribed effective connectivity W. In principle, this problem is under-constrained and
has an infinite number of solutions. Conveniently, it has been shown that grid cells in superficial layers of
MEC are primarily connected through inhibition [12, 13], making the matrix Wij strictly non-positive while
also justifying the lack of direct connectivity between the excitatory neurons si. Furthermore, by Dale's law,
Kib is strictly non-negative and Jaj is non-positive, hence we rewrite the factorization problem as
(−W) = g(−J)K, where all three matrices are non-negative.
We considered two possible ways of generating the connectivity. First, we initialized both −J and K to
random numbers drawn from a uniform distribution on [0, 0.1] and solved for these iteratively using methods
for factorizing non-negative matrices (NMF) [34, 35]. NMF is an iterative method that converges to a local
(cid:113)(cid:80)
(cid:0)Wij −(cid:80)
(cid:1)2
minimum of the cost function
minimum is not necessarily the global minimum, so different initializations may result in different
connectivity patterns. We refer to this approach as the fully factorized model. For the second approach,
which we label the partially factorized model, we set the connections to the interneurons K to sparse (10 %)
random excitatory connectivity, and solved for J only using NMF.
(see section 5.16-5.17 for additional details). This
k JikKkj
ij
Figure 3 shows examples of the connectivities that we find with these two approaches. As can be seen in
figure 3 a,b,c, both approaches manage to reasonably approximate the desired effective connectivity. In the
case of the fully factorized model, this resulted in interneurons that receive inputs from grid cells of similar
spatial phase (figure 3 d) or receive input from grid cells of surrounding spatial phases (figure 3 e). These
interneurons will exhibit grid-like or anti-grid like firing correspondingly, similar to those in [13] and [14].
These grid-like and anti-grid-like interneurons then project back to the surrounding (figure 3 h) and center
(figure 3 i), respectively. The resulting connectivity for the partially factorized model (figure 3 c) also
manages to approximate the desired connectivity, but typically requires many more interneurons than the
fully factorized model, e.g. in the example shown it required 5 times more interneurons than excitatory
neurons. This can be attributed to the fact that in the fully factorized model both inhibitory-to-excitatory
connections and excitatory-to-inhibitory connections can be adjusted to achieve the desired connectivity
while in the partially factorized one only the former are allowed to be adjusted. In the partially factorized
model, the inhibitory neurons obviously receive random input from the grid cells (figure 3 f,j) while
projecting back in a non-random but not obviously structured manner (figure 3 g,k). Consistent with this
connectivity scheme, Buetfering et al., 2014, found that grid cells of all phases functionally project to local
interneurons [27].
Using these two approaches we were able to construct different models with variable numbers of
interneurons while maintaining the same effective weight matrix Wij between the grid cells. Additional
details on the construction of the grid cell model can be found in 5.16.
6
Fig 3. Approximate connectivity using non-negative matrix factorization (a) The desired
effective connectivity matrix between grid cells, Wij in Eq. 5, with σ, fd and offset, l, equal to zero. (b) the
resulting effective connectivity for the fully factorized model, with 200 interneurons and 896 excitatory cells
and (c) for the partially factorized model, with 896 excitatory and 4480 inhibitory cells. (d,h) Examples of
the connections from the 32 × 28 excitatory cells arranged on a two dimensional lattice to two example
interneurons in the fully factorized model and (e,i) the corresponding inhibitory-to-excitatory connectivity
from the same interneurons to the excitatory neurons. In each of the examples the aptitude of the
connections are normalized to the peak value of the coupling matrix with excitatory couplings colored red
and inhibitory blue. In d,e,h,i the excitatory cells are arranged according to spatial phase. The interneuron
in d receives input from excitatory cells with similar phase but and inhibits a number of excitatory cells e.
Since this inhibitory neuron is activated by grid cells with similar phase, it is going to exhibit gird-like firing.
The opposite is true for the example inhibitory neuron h,i which will show anti-grid-like tuning. f,g,j,k Same
as d,e,h,i but for the partially factorized model.
2.4 Response of models to velocity modulated and place-like inputs
We subjected both models to input of the form shown in Eq. 4, following an experimentally recorded
trajectory of an animal exploring a square open-field environment. In both models, we could change the
degree of firing field amplitude variance in the excitatory grid cells by changing the dilution fd of the
place-like input as well as the standard deviation σ of the truncated Gaussian distribution from which the
connections Hij in Eq. 4 are drawn. The fields of a grid cell that were not directly excited by place-like input
added further variations in the field-to-field difference of the cell: a field not driven by place-like input would
be activated only through the interaction between the external excitatory drive that all neurons receive (i.e.
the constant term in Eq. 4) and the pattern forming effective inhibitory connectivity, leading to a lower firing
rate compared to fields driven by place-like input.
In figure 4, we show how the firing properties of the cells change as we vary σ with fixed fd = 0.2 for both
fully factorized and partially factorized models, by showing rate maps and cross-correlograms of selected cells.
7
abcdefghijk Fig 4. Rate maps and autocorrelograms of simulated neurons. Rate maps and autocorrelograms of
one excitatory and one inhibitory neuron from each of several model simulations with different parameters.
The top two rows show excitatory neurons (grid cells), with grid score (gs) and field amplitude coefficient of
variation (c) quoted between the rate map (above) and autocorrelogram (below). The bottom two rows show
inhibitory neurons (interneurons), listing grid score (gs) and sparsity (sp). The four left columns are taken
from runs of the fully factorized model with different values of place-like input connection strengths σ, and
the four right columns from similar runs of the partially factorized model with dilution fd = 0.2.
Complementing the observations in figure 5, we see that inhibitory neurons in fully factorized models have a
high degree of periodicity regardless of the connectivity variance, while interneurons in the partially
factorized model lose their periodicity as the grid cell amplitude variability increases. Note that inhibitory
neurons in the fully factorized model need not have isolated firing fields even though they are periodic; see
Supplementary figure 6 for several counterexamples.
As can be seen, in the fully factorized model, the excitatory neurons but not the inhibitory neurons become
more irregular as σ is increased. This is, however, not the case for the partially factorized model. In this
model, both inhibitory and excitatory neurons become more irregular as σ is increased.
In figure 5, we show the trends exemplified in figure 4 at the population level. As can be seen in figure 5
a-b, the grid score for the excitatory neurons but not the inhibitory neurons drop as σ is increased in the
fully factorized model. In fact, there is no value of σ where, in this model, we can see grid cells with grid
score similar to the real data and irregular inhibitory neurons (see also figure 4). This is, however, not the
case for the partially factorized model. In this model, the grid score for both inhibitory and excitatory
neurons drop by increasing σ. In fact, for the parameters we chose already at σ close to zero and dilution
level fd = 0.2, we can have interneurons with irregular firing (figure 4) while having excitatory neurons with
realistic grid score. As we show in figure 5 c, the irregularity in the fields can also be increased by keeping σ
at zero and simply varying the dilution fd of the place-like input.
The grid score on its own suffers from the fact that it can be low due to field strength variations even if
the pattern is regular (see also figure 4). We therefore also analyzed our results using a modified score which
is a linear sum of the grid score as well as the spatial sparsity of the firing, which we will denote the
combined score (see section 5.5 for further details). For grid cells most of the firing is confined to isolated
fields, so taking into account the spatial sparsity helps separate such cells from e.g. interneurons, which may
exhibit some degree of periodicity but often fire all over space. As can be seen in figure 5 d-f, in the fully
factorized model both grid cells and interneurons maintain high scores, while the interneurons of the partially
factorized model have substantially lower scores. Inspection of the firing rate maps of individual cells (see
Supplementary figure 6 for more examples) clearly substantiates the conclusion from this figure that in the
8
gs=1.22, c=0.09σ=0.0Grid cellsgs=1.11, c=0.61σ=0.4gs=0.86, c=1.10σ=0.8Fully factorizedgs=0.82, c=1.24σ=1.2gs=0.30, c=0.40σ=0.0gs=0.76, c=0.89σ=0.1gs=0.03, c=2.34σ=0.2Partially factorizedgs=0.12, c=2.49σ=0.3gs=0.93, sp=0.64Interneuronsgs=0.90, sp=0.26gs=0.51, sp=0.40gs=0.75, sp=0.42gs=0.71, sp=0.00gs=0.27, sp=0.00gs=0.53, sp=0.01gs=0.36, sp=0.02 Fig 5. Connectivity variance and the resulting selectivity of excitatory and inhibitory
neurons. a-b: Mean and standard deviation of the grid score of excitatory grid cells (blue) and inhibitory
interneurons (green) from several model simulations, plotted against the standard deviation in the place-like
input connection strengths, σ. For comparison, the same quantities for real grid cells are shown in gray. c:
Same as b but keeping σ fixed and varying the dilution fraction fd of non-zero couplings randomly removed.
d-f: Mean and standard deviation of the combined score of grid cells and interneurons from model
simulations, and real grid cells. g-i: Mean and standard deviation of the firing field amplitude coefficient of
variation c of excitatory grid cells from model simulations, and real grid cells. a,d,g: Fully factorized model.
Grid scores and combined scores of interneurons remain high and similar to real grid cells for all connectivity
variances, reflecting their periodic and relatively sparse firing in this model. Grid scores of grid cells decrease
with increasing input variance, but only due to increasing field amplitude variation, not geometric distortions
of the firing pattern (see figure 4). b,e,h: Partially factorized model with fd = 0.2. Grid scores of model grid
cells are similar to real data for zero input variance, and decrease with increasing input variance. In this
model, grid scores of interneurons also decrease as σ is increased, reflecting their waning periodicity (see
figure 4). Due to their non-sparse firing, interneurons are clearly separated from grid cells by the combined
score. c,f,i: Partially factorized model with σ = 0. Without dilution (fd = 0), both the interneurons and grid
cells are predictably periodic with little field-to-field variations. By diluting the projections from the
place-like input, the field amplitudes of the grid cells become increasingly variable, while the grid and
combined scores of the interneurons decrease as in b,e,h.
fully factorized model, increasing the variance of the input does yield variable field amplitudes in the grid cell
but the inhibitory neurons maintain a high degree of regularity and sparsity, while for the partially factorized
model, the inhibitory neurons have non-sparse firing, and also lose their regularity when the variance of the
9
00.30.60.91.2grid scoreaFully factorizedbPartially factorizedc00.51.01.52.02.5combined scoredefreal exc.model exc.model inh.012345σ00.51.01.52.0cg00.20.40.60.81.0σh00.10.20.30.40.5fdi input to the excitatory neurons increases. Note that, as shown in figure 5 g-i, in both networks the
coefficient of variation in the field-to-field firing in the excitatory neurons can be reached at small values of σ
and fd, but as described above, it is the behavior of the inhibitory neurons that sets the two architectures
apart from each other.
2.5 Integrating velocity
After establishing that with the place-like input both the fully factorized and the partially factorized models
generate grid cells, we wondered whether these two architectures can also generate grid cells using only
velocity-head directional input (Eq. 3). While the fully factorized model managed to generate hexagonal grid
cells only using input of the form of Eq. 3, the partially factorized model failed to do so, e.g. figure 6.
Testing various configurations with up to 20 times more interneurons than grid cells we were unable to find a
configuration that could accurately integrate the velocity and generate grid cells in the partially factorized
model. As can be seen in figure 6 (right), with a ratio of interneurons to grid cells that is completely
biologically implausible, the model was only able to produce random, unreliable firing fields when attempting
to integrate over velocity for ten minutes. At the same time, the fully-factorized model performed beyond
expectations: with as little as 200 interneurons (comprising approximately 5 % of the network) and 64 × 56
grid cells, the model could accurately path integrate over 10 minutes of tracked position data (figure 6, left).
Fig 6. Top left: Rate map of a simulated grid cell arising from stable path integration of velocity input in
the fully factorized model. Bottom left: Rate map of a simulated interneuron during the same simulation run.
Top right: Rate map of a simulated would-be grid cell that fails to develop a grid pattern because path
integration is too unstable. Bottom Right: Rate map of an interneuron during the same simulation run. No
discernible grid-like structure was observed after a ten minute session.
To understand why the two models performed so differently under path integration, we considered the
issue of drift [36]. Since even minute levels of randomness in connectivity is known to cause drift, drift is a
likely candidate for the failure of the partially factorized model for generating grid cells by integrating
velocity because of the presence of random sparse connectivity in this network. For each drift simulation the
pattern was initialized randomly, with the external drive It set to a constant value, allowing the network to
converge to a static pattern. Once formed, the pattern was shifted randomly around the neural sheet. In an
idealized continuous attractor, the shifted pattern should stay in place indefinitely due to the translational
invariance property [36], but any inhomogeneity in the networks, makes the pattern prone to drifting. We
measured the drift as the average distance traveled from 200 shifted locations during 100 time steps, allowing
us to estimate the average drift velocity during the first second after shifting the pattern (see figure 7).
For the fully factorized models, the resulting drift decreased exponentially with the number of
interneurons included in the model (see figure 7) while the partially-factorized model decayed significantly
10
gs=1.27, sp=0.67gs=0.06, sp=0.09gs=1.07, sp=0.13gs=0.16, sp=0.00 more slowly, requiring several orders of magnitude more interneurons to achieve a similar degree of stability.
Fig 7. Stable continuous attractor dynamics. Mean and standard deviation of the measured drift
speed (y-axis), defined as (displacement on neural sheet/(time step · length of neural sheet). The drift speed
is plotted against the ratio of the number of interneurons to the number of grid cells (x-axis) for various
configurations of both the fully (F) and partially (P) factorized model. The legend shows the size Nx × Ny of
the neural sheet.
3 Field variability and remapping
The fact that the firing rate of individual fields of a cell may shows strong and robust variations may have
multiple implications. One is that it will increase the information that the firing of each individual cell
carries about the position of the animal: if all fields are identical, it is impossible to distinguish between
different sites by observing the firing of the cell, and this ambiguity could be reduced by introducing varying
field amplitudes. This could have implications for theories on how grid cell parameters are chosen for
optimally encoding space [37, 38].
In addition, variability among firing fields suggest the possibility of an additional role for grid cells in
distinguishing between different environments, i.e. encoding contextual information. Previous work assuming
equal firing amplitudes [39] confirm the high spatial information content of grid cells while suggesting that
they provide almost no contextual information (that is, they cannot be used to discriminate between
environments). Interestingly, a recent study by Kanter et al. [28] shows that with a chemogenetic
manipulation of the mouse MEC, random shifts in the firing amplitudes of the individual grid fields can be
induced without changing the positions of fields. This observation can be exploited in a simple feedforward
model in which the output of grid cells with different spacings are summed and thresholded by cells in the
hippocampus, such that the hippocampal cells obtain spatial tuning [22]. With identical fields, the only way
to obtain remapping in the place cells is to change the relative spatial phase of different grid cells. With
non-identical fields, however, changing the relative amplitude of different fields can cause remapping to occur,
as shown in figure 8. The statistical analysis and theoretical model presented here, together with this recent
experimental finding, thus suggests an expanded role for grid cells, not only integrating over velocity output,
but over spatial and contextual cues more generally.
4 Summary and Discussion
In this paper we established that the firing fields of real grid cells are not simple translations of one another,
but that their amplitudes can in fact vary significantly. These variations are stable and reproducible, and are
not merely a consequence of experiments with finite duration and imperfect, non-uniform sampling of the
environment, or temporal fluctuations in the spiking of the neuron.
11
10 1100101# interneurons/# grid cells10 310 210 1drift speed16×13 F32×28 F64×55 F32×28 P Fig 8. Rate-remapping of grid cells sufficient to globally remap a place cell. a-c: Example
simulated grid cells from 3 modules with imposed field-to-field variability. d: A place cell with only input
from grid cells of the type in a-c (25 from each of the 3 modules) and a constant external input. e-g: Same
cells as in b but with different field amplitudes. This manipulation has been accomplished chemogenetically
in rats [28]. Here the peak rates of the fields were sampled from a Gaussian distribution with a mean of 1
and standard deviation of 0.3. h: The same place cell as in d but with the input grid cells rate-remapped (as
shown in e-g). Thus with the same connections and constant external input a place cell can globally remap
with just a rate-remapping of the grid cells. Here the grid cell selectivity was simulated with Gaussian bumps
centered on the vertices of a hexagonal lattice while the firing rate of the place cell is determined by the
input with a logistic activation function.
To consider the consequences of this variability in firing field amplitudes within the context of the
continuous attractor model, we devised two recurrent network models of grid cells, explicitly including both
excitatory and inhibitory populations, and using patterned (fully factorized) or random (partially factorized)
connectivity from grid cells to interneurons, respectively. We considered these networks operating under
three different conditions: only receiving input from place-like input, only receiving a velocity dependent
signal, or receiving only a constant input which we used for studying the drift. While the components
necessary for the velocity input are found locally in the MEC [2, 4], the MEC has also been shown to receive
extensive input from the hippocampus as well as other areas with discrete spatial selectivity such as the
postrhinal cortex [40, 41]. Indeed, even during hippocampal inactivation, in which grid cells loose their
periodic selectivity, stable discrete spatial selectivity in the form of single fields as well as increased
directional selectivity has been demonstrated in grid cells [42].
We found that the fully factorized model could generate stable grid cells by only integrating velocity
input and employing only a very small population of interneurons, e.g. approximately 5 % of the size of the
excitatory population. In this condition, the grid cells did not show noticeable firing field amplitude
variability. By adding a place-like signal via random connectivity to the excitatory cells, we obtained grid
cells that exhibited amplitude variability in their fields, similar to what we established to occur in the real
data. The degree of this variability could be controlled by diluting the spatial input to the grid cells or
adjusting the variance of the strength of the connections from the place-like input.
Regardless of the type of input, the interneurons in the fully factorized models demonstrated periodic
spatial coding with high grid scores, albeit with different kinds of firing patterns such as the "anti-grid"
pattern. Interestingly, the interneurons maintained high grid scores and relatively low field-to-field variability
while grid cells became more variable with increasingly variable input connections. This may indicate that
the input connection strengths to an interneuron are distributed quite uniformly among grid cells with
similar spatial phases in this model, such that the field-to-field variations of single grid cells often cancel
approximately when summing over several cells of the same phase.
With only velocity input, the partially factorized model failed to generate the periodic firing pattern
12
abcdefgh associated with grid cells. When replacing velocity input with a place-like input, however, the excitatory
neurons acquired grid cell firing with realistically varying firing field amplitudes, but with amplitude variance
increasing significantly faster than in the fully factorized model as a function of the variance of the place-like
input connection strengths. The interneurons in this model, lacking the patterned input connectivity
required to maintain their firing patterns while grid field amplitudes fluctuate, were strongly impacted by the
variance of the connections from the place selective cells, and lost their periodicity as the variance increased.
In order to understand why this network failed to generate grid cells with only velocity input, we
evaluated the attractor drift in the models, and observed that while there was a rapid exponential decrease in
drift with the number of interneurons in the fully factorized models, even with a moderate number of
interneurons (figure 7), the decrease was much slower and did not reach the same levels even at an order of
magnitude more interneurons in the partially factorized model.
We interpret these results by proposing two possible scenarios for the underlying network that generated
grid cells. Since both models are able to generate grid cells firing patterns in excitatory neurons with the
field amplitude variability found in experimental data, both can be used as models for the generation of grid
cells. However, they are distinguished by their predictions for the firing patterns of interneurons and their
response to different types of input, and may thus differ in their compatibility with experimental data as we
discuss further below.
The selectivity of interneurons in the partially factorized model (figure 4, right) resembled the selectivity
of the majority of recorded local interneurons in Buetfering et al. [27]. However, the model required place
selective input in order to generate grid cells, a prediction consistent with developmental data showing that
place cell selectivity appears before grid cells [43].
The fully factorized model (figure 4, left), managed to generate grid cells with only velocity input, and
firing field amplitude variations could be observed in the network when place-like input was added. However,
this model also generated periodic spatial selectivity in the interneurons. Although the majority of the
interneurons recorded in Buetfering et al. [27] did not show periodic firing, a few of them still did, which is
consistent with the fact that the fully factorized model can generate the hexagonal pattern of the grid cells
by integrating velocity input using a very small number of interneurons compared to the total size of the
network. An interesting experimental proposal is therefore to investigate how many of the interneurons in
the MEC are actually involved in generating grid cells, e.g. by looking at the fraction of interneurons that
project back to grid cells, and seeing if these are among the few interneurons that show periodic firing, or by
optogenetically manipulating a fraction of interneurons and seeing how it affects the grid cells' periodic firing.
It should be mentioned that the use of place-like input in generating grid cells is not an entirely new idea.
The so-called adaptation model originally developed by Kropff and Treves [21], and related models [44, 45],
consider the entorhinal network not as a fixed code with discrete translation symmetry built for path
integration, but one that learns and adapts to different environments. In these models, external spatially
modulated input provides an important role in the formation and maintenance of the grid pattern. Here, we
have not discussed mechanisms through which the place-like input connectivity to the grid network may be
formed through development or synaptic plasticity while the animal navigates a new environment. However,
mechanisms such as those proposed by Kropff and Treves [21] might admit the establishment of proper
place-like connectivity to the grid cells. Furthermore, though it has yet to be studied, it seems plausible that
incorporating the observed field amplitude variability within such a framework may also be achieved by
assuming that the spatial input can vary on a time scale that is faster than the learning of the connectivity
required for the pattern to form.
The model presented here shares the much of the benefits of the adaptation model, such as stability to
the types quenched noise [36, 46] that plague models based on integrating velocity while still uses attractor
dynamics enabling, for example, firing fields to appear for cells where external spatial input was removed or
not provided. It is still an open question, however, what mechanisms for path integration could exist that are
consistent with emerging properties, such as variability among grid cell firing fields.
13
5 Materials and Methods
5.1 Data
The 373 identified cells used in this analysis were selected from recordings of rats 13855, 13960, 14147, 15314,
and 15708 in Stensola et al. [30], and details about the data acquisition can be found in that reference. These
rats had multisite (hyperdrive) tetrode implants, and the recordings were carried out in square open-field
environments of either 100 × 100 cm (rat 13855) or 150 × 150 cm (others).
5.2 Position filtering
The position time series, which were recorded at sampling rate 25 Hz, were smoothed to reduce jitter using a
low-pass Hann window FIR filter with design cutoff frequency 2.0 Hz and kernel support of 13 taps, or
approximately 0.5 s.
For each sample, the filter kernel was renormalized to compensate for missing samples within the kernel
duration. In practice, this is accomplished by applying the filter to the original sequence but with missing
samples replaced by zeros, and then to an indicator sequence with a value of 1 at every valid sample and 0 at
every missing sample. The elementwise ratio of these two sequences is the final filtered sequence. This
approach automatically interpolates across gaps shorter than the kernel duration, and is the simplest
example of normalized convolution [47].
All experiments provided two sequences of position samples, corresponding to LEDs located in slightly
different positions on the animal. The animal position was taken to be the mean of the two (filtered)
sequences.
The speed at each sample was computed as the average speed over the surrounding 13 samples, by
dividing the trajectory length with the elapsed time within this window. This was used to apply a speed
filter: only samples where the speed exceeded 5 cm/s were kept.
5.3 Rate maps
Spike locations ξj = (ξj, χj) at spike times τj were found by linearly interpolating the position time series
(ti, xi, yi) at the spike times. The spatial firing rate at location x = (x, y) was defined as the ratio of kernel
density estimates of the spatial spike frequency and the occupancy,
f (x) =
,
(6)
where the sums are taken over the spikes and position samples, respectively. Here,
∆ti = (ti+1 − ti−1)/2 ≈ 1/Fs, where Fs = 25 Hz is the target sampling frequency. A triweight kernel was
used,
K1(x ξ) =
4
9πσ2
, (cid:107)x − ξ(cid:107) < 3σ ,
(7)
(cid:80)
(cid:80)
j K1(x ξj)
i ∆tiK1(x xi)
(cid:21)3
(cid:20)
1 − (cid:107)x − ξ(cid:107)2
9σ2
(cid:80)
(cid:80)
i ri∆tiK1(x xi)
i ∆tiK1(x xi)
with bandwidth σ = 4.2 cm for 150 cm environments and σ = 2.8 cm for 100 cm environments.
The triweight kernel has compact support, so we avoid the infinite extrapolation entailed by a Gaussian.
It is also a smooth, bell-shaped bump, that eliminates some problems that in our experience tend to show up
when using finite kernels that go non-smoothly to zero (such as the uniform or Epanechnikov kernels), in
particular that the ratios of such KDEs tend to blow up along the edges of the support.
Model simulations returned a continuous firing rate rather than discrete spikes, providing a combined
position-rate time series (ti, xi, yi, ri). Rate maps were created by considering each rate sample as a
fractional spike and otherwise proceeding as with spike trains,
f (x) =
.
(8)
All rate maps were discretized for further analysis by sampling f (x) on a uniform square grid with bin
centers xij. We write fij = f (xij). Unless otherwise stated, a 50 × 50-bin grid was used.
14
5.4 Correlograms
Spatial rate correlograms were computed from discretized rate maps using a Pearson product-moment
correlation coefficient of overlapping regions of the rate maps at all integer-bin spatial lags. The cross
correlogram ρ of rate maps f and g can be expressed as:
(cid:0)fkl − f(cid:1) (gk+i,l+j − g)
(cid:80)
(cid:113)(cid:80)
(cid:0)fkl − f(cid:1)2(cid:80)
kl
kl (gk+i,l+j − g)2
ρij =
kl
.
(9)
All sums were taken over the overlapping region of the rate maps at the given lag i, j. A single global mean
ij fij/N was used at all lags (here N is the number of bins in fij, usually 50 × 50 = 2500).
f =(cid:80)
5.5 Scores and selection
The grid score of a cell was computed from its spatial rate autocorrelogram by considering the angular
Pearson autocorrelation of the autocorrelogram at lags of 30◦, 60◦, 90◦, 120◦, 150◦, as well as ±3◦ and ±6◦
offsets from these angles. Only bins closer to the center than a radius u were included in the angular
autocorrelations, and the grid score at a particular u was defined as the difference between the average of the
maximum correlations around 60◦ and 120◦ lags and the average of the minimum correlations around the
30◦, 90◦ and 150◦ lags:
Grid score(u) =
1
2
− 1
3
(cid:2) max{acorr(u) at 60◦ ± (0◦, 3◦, 6◦)} +
max{acorr(u) at 120◦ ± (0◦, 3◦, 6◦)}(cid:3)
(cid:2) min{acorr(u) at 30◦ ± (0◦, 3◦, 6◦)} +
min{acorr(u) at 150◦ ± (0◦, 3◦, 6◦)}(cid:3) .
min{acorr(u) at 90◦ ± (0◦, 3◦, 6◦)} +
(10)
The final grid score of the cell was defined as the maximum of Grid score(u) over values of u ranging from
four bin widths (i.e. u = 12 cm for 50 × 50 bins in a 150 cm box) to the full width of the experimental
environment (half the width of the autocorrelogram), computed at intervals of one bin width.
We also calculated the spatial sparsity score defined by Buetfering et al. [27] (adapted from Skaggs et
al. [48]) to quantify the degree of spatial tuning in the rate map:
Sparsity score = 1 −
,
(11)
(cid:0)f(cid:1)2
f 2
where f denotes the firing rate of the cell and the bars indicate an occupancy weighted spatial mean, i.e. a
mean where each bin is weighted by the value of the occupancy map in that bin. The occupancy map is the
denominator in equation 6.
The selection of cells for further analysis was done using a combination of these scores:
Combined score = 1.2 · Grid score + 1.55 · Sparsity score .
(12)
Only cells for which the combined score exceeded 1.0 were included in the further analysis. The purpose of
this selection was to only include cells for which it was possible to make out clear and distinct firing fields in
the spatial rate maps (quantified by the sparsity score) and for which these fields were laid out in a grid-like
pattern (quantified by the grid score). The form of the combined score allows for an additive tradeoff
between the two properties, while rejecting cells for which both scores are low. The exact weights were
determined by looking for an appropriate cutoff line through grid score-sparsity space (see Supplementary
figure 1) that separated cells that were subjectively deemed too noisy or disordered from the others.
In order to exclude suspected multiple recordings of the same cell, an additional selection filter was
applied. For each pair of cells recorded from the same animal, one cell was excluded if the following criteria
were satisfied:
15
1. The cells were recorded on the same tetrode.
2. The cells were either
• recorded closer in depth than 75 µm (for datasets where tetrode depth estimates for each session
were available), or
• recorded closer in time than nine days (for other datasets).
3. The Pearson correlation of the cell rate maps at zero spatial lag exceeded 0.8.
Note that the issue of possible repeats in these datasets was also addressed in the original
reference [30, Supplementary Materials and Methods], and we have only used data that was kept at that time.
5.6 Lattice vectors
The spatial rate autocorrelograms were separated into segments associated with different peaks using a
watershed algorithm. The algorithm is seeded with all the local maxima in the correlograms, and works by
interpreting the negative of the correlogram as a topographical map and virtually "flooding" the image from
imaginary water sources at the seeds. Thus each source is assigned a basin, separated from neighboring
basins along the watershed lines where water from different sources meet as the water level is increased.
Segmentation was only applied to regions of the correlogram exceeding a correlation threshold ρmin, where we
used ρmin = 0.1 as a default value and made adjustments for certain cells in order to properly separate the
central peak and the inner ring of six peaks around it. We always discarded all segments associated with a
seed in an edge bin of the correlogram, but only after performing the segmentation with such seeds included.
The exact location of a peak was defined as the center of mass of the associated segment of the
correlogram.
The inner six peaks provide three vectors that would ideally correspond to primitive lattice vectors of the
grid pattern of the cell. (Due to the inversion symmetry of the autocorrelogram, there are only three unique
vectors up to a trivial sign difference.) However, while a lattice can be defined by any two of the vectors
extracted from the autocorrelogram, the third vector will in general not conform exactly to the same lattice.
Therefore, we derived a projection from the peak vectors to a corresponding set of consistent lattice vectors.
Let pi, i = 1, 2, 3 be three unique peak vectors from the autocorrelogram, numbered in successive order
around the origin. In addition, let ai be a set of vectors that define a consistent lattice and are closely
approximated by the pi. In order to define a lattice, the ai must satisfy
a2 = a1 + a3 .
(13)
The vector a2 must then be close to both p2 and p1 + p3, so we postulate that it should be expressible as a
weighted average of the two: a2 = (µp2 + p1 + p3)/(µ + 1). Extending this reasoning to a1 and a3, we arrive
at the transformation
with
P =
This transformation is by construction equivalent to the identity whenever the pi already satisfy 13. To
guarantee that the ai always define a consistent lattice, it is therefore sufficient to require that P is a
projection matrix, i.e. P 2 = P . This gives the unique solution µ = 2. The effect of this projection is shown
in Supplementary figure 2.
16
a1
a2
a3
= P
µ
1
−1
1
µ + 1
p1
,
p2
p3
1 −1
1
µ
1
µ
.
(14)
(15)
In practice, we found it more convenient to work with all six peaks in the inner ring in the
autocorrelogram. The projection derived above is straightforward to extend to that case, and the result is
=
a1
a2
a3
a4
a5
a6
1
6
1 −1 −2 −1
2
1
1 −1 −2 −1
1
2
−1
1 −1 −2
1
2
−2 −1
1 −1
2
1
−1 −2 −1
1
2
1
1 −1 −2 −1
1
2
,
p1
p2
p3
p4
p5
p6
where the vectors are numbered in successive order around the origin.
In the following, we write the Cartesian components of ai as (ax,i, ay,i).
5.7 Deformation ellipse
To quantify the deformation of the grid cell firing pattern from a perfect triangular lattice, and also to define
the spacing of the grid pattern, we fitted an ellipse through the endpoints of the lattice vectors ai. This
fitting problem has an exact solution, which we derive here.
A general conic section can be written as an implicit quadratic equation in two variables:
Ax2 + 2Bxy + Cy2 + 2Dx + 2Ey + F = 0 .
Scaling the six parameters A, B, C, D, E, F by a common factor will not change the conic, leaving five
degrees of freedom for size, shape and orientation. The conic will be an ellipse if B2 − AC < 0.
For N points (xi, yi), i = 1, . . . , N , we define the N × 6 design matrix M as
x2
1
...
2x1y1
...
y2
1
...
M =
2x1
2y1
1
...
...
...
N 2xN yN y2
x2
N 2xN 2yN 1
The conic section with parameter vector θ = (A, B, C, D, E, F )T passes through all the points if M θ = 0.
When M has rank 5, and hence a one-dimensional null space, this equation uniquely determines θ up to a
scaling factor, and hence there is a unique conic section passing through all N points. In this case the system
can be solved via singular value decomposition of M – the right-singular vector corresponding to the
vanishing singular value is the parameter vector θ.
If we construct M from the lattice vectors ai = (ax,i, ay,i), and use the fact that ai+3 = −ai, i = 1, 2, 3
(assuming cyclically wrapping indices), we can write
(16)
(17)
(18)
which is row equivalent to
Here,
A =
B =
C =
M(cid:48) =
x,1
a2
x,2
a2
x,3
a2
2ax,1
0
2ax,2
2ax,3
0
0
0
0
0
M =
B + C
A −B + C
(cid:18)A
(cid:18)A
C
0 −B
(cid:19)
(cid:19)
,
.
y,1
y,2
y,3
,
2ax,1ay,1 a2
2ax,2ay,2 a2
2ax,3ay,3 a2
2ay,1
2ay,2
2ay,3
1
1
1
.
0
0
0
17
,
(19)
(20)
(21)
Provided that a1, a2 and a3 are not all parallel, we see that rank B = 2. As long as none of them are
parallel, we also find that A is full-rank (the easiest way to see this is to divide row i in A by a2
x,i, and
consider the linear independence of the resulting rows). Hence, rank [A C] = 3, and thus rank M = 5. This
is exactly the condition required to solve exactly for the conic section passing through the lattice vector
endpoints. Note that this derivation only relies on inversion symmetry among the ai, so the conic can just as
easily be fitted through the unprojected peak vectors pi
1.
We have not shown that the fitted conic will be an ellipse, but the inversion symmetry among the ai rules
out the possibility of obtaining a parabola, and a hyperbola will not be obtained from points that are
vertices of a convex polygon. Both these properties should always be satisfied for the inner ring of peaks in a
grid cell autocorrelograms.
From the analytic geometry parametrization θ = (A, B, C, D, E, F )T , one can derive the equivalent
canonical parameters (xc, yc, a, b, θ) of the ellipse (see e.g. [49]). Here, (xc, yc) are the coordinates of the
center of the ellipse, a and b are the lengths of the semi-major and semi-minor axes, and θ ∈ [−π/2, π/2) is
the angle between the major axis of the ellipse and the coordinate x-axis. Defining the translated and
rotated coordinates
x(cid:48) = (x − xc) cos θ + (y − yc) sin θ ,
y(cid:48) = −(x − xc) sin θ + (y − yc) cos θ ,
x(cid:48)2
a2 +
y(cid:48)2
b2 = 1 .
(22)
(23)
the ellipse satisfies
5.8 Grid spacing
√
We defined the grid spacing λ of a cell as the geometric mean of the lengths of the semiaxes of the
deformation ellipse, λ =
it is therefore preserved under any area-preserving deformation of the grid pattern, such as the shearing
described in Stensola et al. [50].
ab. Thus defined, λ is the radius of a circle with the same area as the ellipse, and
An ellipse fitted through a ring of grid cell autocorrelogram peaks, and a circle with the same area, are
shown in Supplementary figure 3.
5.9 Grid cell feature space
We defined a space of grid cell features in which Euclidean distance was used as a proxy for the similarity of
the cells' firing patterns. The feature vector of a cell can be written as
X = (wλ log λ, ax,1, ay,1, ax,2, ay,2, ax,3, ay,3)T .
(24)
Here, we define ax,i = ax,i/λ, and similarly for ay,i. These are dimensionless versions of the grid lattice
vectors, and characterize the orientation and deformation of the grid pattern independently of the spacing.
This way, the grid pattern shape and size are decoupled in feature space, and their relative importance is
tuned by the weight wλ. The grid spacing λ only enters through its logarithm, so that all differences and
distances in feature space are dimensionless and independent of the measurement units used
(log λ2 − log λ1 = log λ2/λ1).
5.10 Module clustering
Modules were identified by detecting clusters in the grid cell feature space using the mean-shift clustering
algorithm [51]. The algorithm works by randomly choosing a candidate centroid, and iteratively updating it
until convergence by replacing it with the centroid of all points within distance h. This is repeated for a
number of different starting locations, and after eliminating near-duplicates, each resulting centroid
1What we have shown here is really that six points with inversion symmetry through a common center, or equivalently, a
center and three peripheral points, uniquely define a conic section, as long as the points lie on three different rays through the
center.
18
corresponds to a cluster in the dataset. A sample which was only visited by (i.e. within distance h of)
centroid trajectories that converged to the same final centroid is taken to be part of the corresponding
cluster, while remaining points are declared outliers. The algorithm takes a single parameter h, the
bandwidth, and determines the number of clusters automatically.
We discarded outliers and clusters with less than five cells, and accepted the remaining clusters as grid
cell modules. Using the feature space weight wλ = 3.3 and the mean shift bandwidth to h = 0.35, we
reproduced the modules from Stensola et al. [30] in all animals2.
In order to assert the stability of the clusters, the clustering was repeated 10 times on each dataset. The
clustering was identical in all 10 runs on all datasets when using the mentioned parameters.
5.11 Average firing field shape
We used a small region around the central peak in the autocorrelogram as as a model for the shape and size
of a typical firing field of the cell. We defined this region using a separate correlation threshold ρfield, and
modeled the firing field shape as a 2D Gaussian bump with variance Σ2 = −A/2π log(ρfield), where A is the
area of the region around the central peak where autocorrelation exceeds ρf f . This definition is designed to
match the value of the Gaussian at distance R =(cid:112)A/π from the origin, relative to the peak value, to the
correlation threshold ρfield, i.e.
e−R2/2Σ2
= ρfield .
We used the threshold ρfield = 0.55 for all cells. We defined the radius of the average firing field as uf = 1.6Σ.
5.12 Idealized spatial tuning profile
We derived an idealized spatial tuning profile from a grid cell by tessellating space with the lattice defined by
the primitive lattice vectors ai, and placing a circular Gaussian bump with variance Σ2 at each node. The
lattice was translated to the location that maximized the zero-lag cross correlation between the rate map of
the actual cell and the idealized profile, and scaled to have the same mean firing rate as the recorded cell.
The tuning profile is meant to represent an idealization of the spatial tuning of the real grid cell, with the
same lattice parameters, spatial phase, firing field size and mean firing rate, but with firing fields that are
identical.
5.13 Firing field detection
Firing field centers were detected in grid cell rate maps using the same watershed segmentation algorithm
used to detect peaks in the autocorrelograms (see section 5.6). The detection was performed on rate maps
created with 1.5 times the bandwidth of the ordinary rate maps, i.e. σ = 6.3 cm for 150 cm environments
and σ = 4.2 cm for 100 cm environments. Segmentation was applied only to regions of these rate maps where
the firing rate exceeded the 25th percentile of the distribution of rates in the rate map.
Candidate firing fields were defined as circular regions of radius uf around the detected firing field
centers. The amplitude r of a field was defined as the number of spikes recorded within this field region,
divided by the time spent there.
A final filtering step to distinguish true firing fields from possible noise blobs was performed by
comparing the candidate fields to the firing fields in the idealized spatial tuning profile derived from the rate
map, using the same radius uf for the idealized and candidate fields. We computed the overlap fraction q of
each pair of a candidate and an idealized field, defined as the ratio of the overlapping area of the fields to the
field area πu2
f . Pairs with q > 0.25 were sorted by the product rq, where r is the amplitude of the candidate
field, and unique pairs were kept starting from the top of this list. Thus false positives among detected fields
were eliminated, and each detected field was associated with an idealized counterpart.
For rate maps created from sampled spikes, firing fields were detected in the exact same way, using the
same idealized fields as for the corresponding real rate map (i.e. no new idealized spatial tuning profile was
created for the synthetic rate map). Corresponding fields in the real and synthetic rate maps were identified
2By this we mean that we found the same number of modules, with approximately the same average grid parameters, in all
animals. Since we have filtered out a number of cells in previous steps, and our clustering algorithm generates outliers, the
allocation of cells to modules was not identical.
19
by association with the same idealized field, and only fields detected in both the real rate map and all
synthetic rate maps from the same cell were used further analysis.
For rate maps created from model simulations, no lattice parameters were extracted from the
autocorrelogram and no idealized tuning profile was created. Hence, candidate fields were used directly
without any filtering. This is unproblematic, since model cell rate maps are not noisy.
Supplementary figure 5 shows the detected firing fields and corresponding amplitudes for a selection of
real grid cells and an accompanying synthetic rate map per real cell.
5.14 Sampled spike trains
We used the idealized spatial tuning to sample spike trains corresponding to this spatial tuning and the real
animal trajectory, assuming Poisson spiking statistics and no covariates except spatial location. To this end,
the real trajectory of the rat was divided into ∆t = 5 ms bins, and the target firing rate fi at in bin i,
centered on time ti, was found by evaluating the tuning profile at the corresponding location (xi, yi). In each
bin, a Bernoulli trial was performed with success probability fi∆t, and if successful a spike was placed at ti.
Rate maps were computed from these spike trains in the same way as for real cells.
5.15 Statistical analysis of firing field amplitudes
Only cells for which 3 or more fields were detected (counting only fields detected in the real rate map and all
synthetic rate maps derived from it) were used in the statistical analysis of firing field amplitudes. We
computed the sample coefficient of variation of the amplitudes of a cell as
Here, k is the number of fields, ri, i = 1, . . . , k are the amplitudes of the fields, and r =(cid:80)
i=1
c =
=
k − 1
amplitude. The usual sample variance is given by s2.
i ri/k is the mean
To compare the temporal stability of the field amplitudes with the field-to-field variations, we extracted
firing field amplitudes using only data from the first and second halves of the experiment, respectively (using
the same fields as for the full-length data). We denote these amplitudes as rij, where the index i runs over
the k firing fields and j runs over the partitions 1, 2. First, we define the following sample means:
(cid:118)(cid:117)(cid:117)(cid:116) 1
s
r
1
r
k(cid:88)
(cid:0)ri − r(cid:1)2
.
and the within-field variability as
s2
W =
1
k − 1
(cid:34)(cid:32) k(cid:88)
2(cid:88)
j=1
i=1
(cid:33)
(cid:35)
.
− k (r·j − r··)2
(rij − ri·)2
The second term in equation 30 is a repeated-measures correction included to remove contributions to the
within-field variability due to a coherent shift in amplitudes between the two halves of the experiment. We
do this because we are only interested in capturing random within-field fluctuations that may explain the
20
The between-field variability is defined as,
r·· =
(ri1 + ri2) ,
ri· =
r·j =
1
2
1
k
k(cid:88)
k(cid:88)
i=1
1
2k
rij ,
(ri1 + ri2) .
i=1
k(cid:88)
i=1
s2
B =
1
k − 1
2 (ri· − r··)2 ,
(25)
(26)
(27)
(28)
(29)
(30)
measured between-field variability, not coherent variations that would not contribute to this and may even be
due to experimental artifacts such as as the cell not being detected by the tetrode for parts of the
experiment. We compensate by subtracting n − 1 from the degrees of freedom of the estimator (i.e. dividing
by (k − 1)(2 − 1) = k − 1 instead of k(2 − 1) = k), such that s2
W remains unbiased.
A key point here is that if all the rij are independent and identically distributed, both s2
B and s2
W are
unbiased estimators of the variance of this distribution. Hence, if s2
W , this may
indicate that there is a component of variability between the field amplitudes that cannot be explained by
fluctuations that affect between- and within-field variabilities alike. This is made quantitative via the
F -statistic,
B is significantly larger than s2
F =
,
(31)
s2
B
s2
W
which may be familiar from one-way ANOVA. For each cell, we computed a p-value based on this statistic by
ranking it against the same statistic computed from the 1000 simulated spike trains associated with the cell.
(Notably, we did not use critical values of the F -distribution to get the p-values, as this would be entail
unjustified normality assumptions)
We also define dimensionless coefficients of variability, useful for plotting and comparison:
cB =
cW =
sB
r··
sW
r··
,
.
The F -statistic can be expressed in terms of these quantities:
F =
c2
B
c2
W
.
(32)
(33)
5.16 Two population continuous attractor network model
To investigate the firing properties of interneurons in the two population model with place-like external
input, we constructed networks consisting of 32 × 28 grid cells and 200 interneurons for the fully factorized
model, and 4480 interneurons for the partially factorized model. The activity was translated during
exploration via place-like input from 180 × 180 units each encoding one unique position of the environment
and projecting to a single grid cell. The values of the non-zero connections from the place-like neurons was
drawn from a Gaussian distribution with mean 0.5, truncated at 0.0. The values for the standard deviation
ranged from σ = 0 to σ = 5 for the fully factorized model, and σ = 0 to σ = 1 for the partially factorized
model. The path of the animal in the simulation was taken from two adjacent 10 minute recordings and
resampled into 10 ms bins.
In the models to check the drift of the network, we used 16 × 13, 32 × 28 and 64 × 55 grid cells in the fully
factorized case and 32 × 28 for the partially factorized model. The number of interneurons was chosen as a
fraction of the total grid cell population. In each of these, the neurons were assumed to lie on a twisted
torus [29] with connectivity as described in the main text and Rmin = 0.5 × Ny and Rmax = Ny. The other
parameters were chosen as τ = 10 ms, constant = 0.1, W0 = 0.1 and l = 0.
For the path integration model we went with a four bump model with 64 × 56 grid cells, 200 interneurons,
Rmin = 15, Rmax = 20, τ = 10 ms, l = 4, α = 0.0075, constant = 0.1 and W0 = −0.05. As mentioned above,
no place-like input were used for error correction during path integration. A 10 minute recording of the
animal was resampled into 10ms bins and used to insure that the statistics of the movement were consistent
with those of an actual animal.
5.17 NMF
The matrices J and K were first set to small random values and the updated iteratively according to the
multiplicative learning rules
K = K × (JT W)/(JT JK)
J = J × (WKT )/(JKKT )
(34)
(35)
21
where the signs × and / represent element-wise multiplication and division, respectively. The above
equations are iterated until convergence, i.e. the change in the value of the cost function
(cid:0)Wij −(cid:80)
(cid:1)2
(cid:113)(cid:80)
ij
k JikKkj
is below 0.0001.
Acknowledgments
We thank Hanne and Tor Stensola as well as Edvard and May-Britt Moser for making the data available. We
are also grateful to Edvard Moser for his comments on this work, and also Trygve Solstad for discussions at
the early stages of this project. This work was supported by the Kavli Foundation, Norwegian Research
Council (Centre of Excellence Scheme), and a Starr Foundation fellowship at the Simons Center for Systems
Biology, IAS to YR.
References
1. Torkel Hafting, Marianne Fyhn, Sturla Molden, May-Britt Moser, and Edvard I Moser. Microstructure
of a spatial map in the entorhinal cortex. Nature, 436(7052):801–806, 2005.
2. Emilio Kropff, James E Carmichael, May-Britt Moser, and Edvard I Moser. Speed cells in the medial
entorhinal cortex. Nature, 2015.
3. Jeffrey S Taube, Robert U Muller, and James B Ranck. Head-direction cells recorded from the
postsubiculum in freely moving rats. i. description and quantitative analysis. The Journal of
neuroscience, 10(2):420–435, 1990.
4. Francesca Sargolini, Marianne Fyhn, Torkel Hafting, Bruce L McNaughton, Menno P Witter,
May-Britt Moser, and Edvard I Moser. Conjunctive representation of position, direction, and velocity
in entorhinal cortex. Science, 312(5774):758–762, 2006.
5. Trygve Solstad, Charlotte N Boccara, Emilio Kropff, May-Britt Moser, and Edvard I Moser.
Representation of geometric borders in the entorhinal cortex. Science, 322(5909):1865–1868, 2008.
6. John O'Keefe and Jonathan Dostrovsky. The hippocampus as a spatial map. preliminary evidence
from unit activity in the freely-moving rat. Brain research, 34(1):171–175, 1971.
7. John O'Keefe. Place units in the hippocampus of the freely moving rat. Experimental neurology,
51(1):78–109, 1976.
8. David C Rowland, Yasser Roudi, May-Britt Moser, and Edvard I Moser. Ten years of grid cells.
Annual review of neuroscience, (0), 2016.
9. Bruce L McNaughton, Francesco P Battaglia, Ole Jensen, Edvard I Moser, and May-Britt Moser.
Path integration and the neural basis of the 'cognitive map'. Nature Reviews Neuroscience,
7(8):663–678, 2006.
10. Mark C Fuhs and David S Touretzky. A spin glass model of path integration in rat medial entorhinal
cortex. The Journal of Neuroscience, 26(16):4266–4276, 2006.
11. Yoram Burak and Ila R Fiete. Accurate path integration in continuous attractor network models of
grid cells. PLoS Comput Biol, 5(2):e1000291, 2009.
12. Jonathan J Couey, Aree Witoelar, Sheng-Jia Zhang, Kang Zheng, Jing Ye, Benjamin Dunn, Rafal
Czajkowski, May-Britt Moser, Edvard I Moser, Yasser Roudi, et al. Recurrent inhibitory circuitry as a
mechanism for grid formation. Nature neuroscience, 16(3):318–324, 2013.
13. Hugh Pastoll, Lukas Solanka, Mark CW van Rossum, and Matthew F Nolan. Feedback inhibition
enables theta-nested gamma oscillations and grid firing fields. Neuron, 77(1):141–154, 2013.
22
14. John Widloski and Ila R Fiete. A model of grid cell development through spatial exploration and spike
time-dependent plasticity. Neuron, 83(2):481–495, 2014.
15. Lukas Solanka, Mark CW van Rossum, and Matthew F Nolan. Noise promotes independent control of
gamma oscillations and grid firing within recurrent attractor networks. Elife, 4:e06444, 2015.
16. Neil Burgess, Caswell Barry, and John O'Keefe. An oscillatory interference model of grid cell firing.
Hippocampus, 17(9):801–812, 2007.
17. Michael E Hasselmo, Lisa M Giocomo, and Eric A Zilli. Grid cell firing may arise from interference of
theta frequency membrane potential oscillations in single neurons. Hippocampus, 17(12):1252–1271,
2007.
18. Hugh T Blair, Adam C Welday, and Kechen Zhang. Scale-invariant memory representations emerge
from moire interference between grid fields that produce theta oscillations: a computational model.
The Journal of neuroscience, 27(12):3211–3229, 2007.
19. Daniel Bush and Neil Burgess. A hybrid oscillatory interference/continuous attractor network model
of grid cell firing. The Journal of Neuroscience, 34(14):5065–5079, 2014.
20. Himanshu Mhatre, Anatoli Gorchetchnikov, and Stephen Grossberg. Grid cell hexagonal patterns
formed by fast self-organized learning within entorhinal cortex. Hippocampus, 22(2):320–334, 2012.
21. Emilio Kropff and Alessandro Treves. The emergence of grid cells: Intelligent design or just
adaptation? Hippocampus, 18(12):1256–1269, 2008.
22. Trygve Solstad, Edvard I Moser, and Gaute T Einevoll. From grid cells to place cells: a mathematical
model. Hippocampus, 16(12):1026–1031, 2006.
23. Edmund T Rolls, Simon M Stringer, and Thomas Elliot. Entorhinal cortex grid cells can map to
hippocampal place cells by competitive learning. Network: Computation in Neural Systems,
17(4):447–465, 2006.
24. Ila R Fiete, Yoram Burak, and Ted Brookings. What grid cells convey about rat location. The Journal
of Neuroscience, 28(27):6858–6871, 2008.
25. Sameet Sreenivasan and Ila Fiete. Grid cells generate an analog error-correcting code for singularly
precise neural computation. Nature neuroscience, 14(10):1330–1337, 2011.
26. Alexander Mathis, Andreas VM Herz, and Martin B Stemmler. Resolution of nested neuronal
representations can be exponential in the number of neurons. Physical review letters, 109(1):018103,
2012.
27. Christina Buetfering, Kevin Allen, and Hannah Monyer. Parvalbumin interneurons provide grid
cell-driven recurrent inhibition in the medial entorhinal cortex. Nature neuroscience, 17(5):710–718,
2014.
28. Benjamin R Kanter, Christine M Lykken, Daniel Avesar, Aldis Weible, Jasmine Dickinson, Benjamin
Dunn, Nils Z Borgesius, Yasser Roudi, and Clifford G Kentros. Transgenic depolarization of medial
entorhinal cortex layer ii neurons reveals a potential novel mechanism of the grid-to-place cell
transformation. submitted, 2016.
29. Alexis Guanella, Daniel Kiper, and Paul Verschure. A model of grid cells based on a twisted torus
topology. International journal of neural systems, 17(04):231–240, 2007.
30. Hanne Stensola, Tor Stensola, Trygve Solstad, Kristian Frøland, May-Britt Moser, and Edvard I
Moser. The entorhinal grid map is discretized. Nature, 492(7427):72–78, 2012.
31. Julija Krupic, Marius Bauza, Stephen Burton, Caswell Barry, and John O'Keefe. Grid cell symmetry
is shaped by environmental geometry. Nature, 518(7538):232–235, feb 2015.
23
32. Hugh R Wilson and Jack D Cowan. Excitatory and inhibitory interactions in localized populations of
model neurons. Biophysical journal, 12(1):1, 1972.
33. Nicolas Brunel, Vincent Hakim, Philippe Isope, Jean-Pierre Nadal, and Boris Barbour. Optimal
information storage and the distribution of synaptic weights: perceptron versus purkinje cell. Neuron,
43(5):745–757, 2004.
34. Daniel D Lee and H Sebastian Seung. Learning the parts of objects by non-negative matrix
factorization. Nature, 401(6755):788–791, 1999.
35. Pentti Paatero and Unto Tapper. Positive matrix factorization: A non-negative factor model with
optimal utilization of error estimates of data values. Environmetrics, 5(2):111–126, 1994.
36. Kechen Zhang. Representation of spatial orientation by the intrinsic dynamics of the head-direction
cell ensemble: a theory. The Journal of Neuroscience, 16(6):2112–2126, 1996.
37. Alexander Mathis, Andreas VM Herz, and Martin Stemmler. Optimal population codes for space: grid
cells outperform place cells. Neural computation, 24(9):2280–2317, 2012.
38. Xue-Xin Wei, Jason Prentice, and Vijay Balasubramanian. A principle of economy predicts the
functional architecture of grid cells. Elife, 4:e08362, 2015.
39. Federico Stella, Erika Cerasti, Bailu Si, Karel Jezek, and Alessandro Treves. Self-organization of
multiple spatial and context memories in the hippocampus. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews,
36(7):1609–1625, 2012.
40. Marianne Fyhn, Sturla Molden, Menno P Witter, Edvard I Moser, and May-Britt Moser. Spatial
representation in the entorhinal cortex. Science, 305(5688):1258–1264, 2004.
41. Rebecca D Burwell and D M Hafeman. Positional firing properties of postrhinal cortex neurons.
Neuroscience, 119(2):577–588, 2003.
42. Tora Bonnevie, Benjamin Dunn, Marianne Fyhn, Torkel Hafting, Dori Derdikman, John L Kubie,
Yasser Roudi, Edvard I Moser, and May-Britt Moser. Grid cells require excitatory drive from the
hippocampus. Nature neuroscience, 16(3):309–317, 2013.
43. Rosamund F Langston, James A Ainge, Jonathan J Couey, Cathrin B Canto, Tale L Bjerknes,
Menno P Witter, Edvard I Moser, and May-Britt Moser. Development of the spatial representation
system in the rat. Science, 328(5985):1576–1580, 2010.
44. Lu´ısa Castro and Paulo Aguiar. A feedforward model for the formation of a grid field where spatial
information is provided solely from place cells. Biological cybernetics, 108(2):133–143, 2014.
45. Andrey Stepanyuk. Self-organization of grid fields under supervision of place cells in a neuron model
with associative plasticity. Biologically Inspired Cognitive Architectures, 13:48–62, 2015.
46. Misha Tsodyks and Terrence Sejnowski. Associative memory and hippocampal place cells.
International journal of neural systems, 6:81–86, 1995.
47. Hans Knutsson and Carl-Fredrik Westin. Normalized and differential convolution. In Computer Vision
and Pattern Recognition, 1993. Proceedings CVPR 1993., 1993 IEEE Computer Society Conference on,
pages 515–523. IEEE Comput. Soc. Press, 1993.
48. William E Skaggs, Bruce L McNaughton, Matthew A Wilson, and Carol A Barnes. Theta phase
precession in hippocampal neuronal populations and the compression of temporal sequences.
Hippocampus, 6:149–172, 1996.
49. Eric W. Weisstein. Ellipse, from mathworld–a wolfram web resource.
http://mathworld.wolfram.com/Ellipse.html. Accessed: 2016-03-07.
24
50. Tor Stensola, Hanne Stensola, May-Britt Moser, and Edvard I. Moser. Shearing-induced asymmetry in
entorhinal grid cells. Nature, 518(7538):207–212, 2015.
51. Dorin Comaniciu and Peter Meer. Mean shift: A robust approach toward feature space analysis. IEEE
Transactions on pattern analysis and machine intelligence, 24(5):603–619, 2002.
25
Supplementary Figures
Supplementary fig 1. Grid score–sparsity filtering. a: All available cells scattered in sparsity–grid score
space. The combined score cutoff defined in the Materials and Methods section is drawn with a black line: only
cells above/to the right of the line were kept. The discarded cells tend to have noisy ratemaps, where firing
fields and a clear triangular lattice may be difficult to make out. b: Ratemap and autocorrelogram of the cell
with lowest combined score. This cell is also marked with a red dot in a. The grid score (gs) and sparsity (sp) of
the cell are quoted below the ratemap.
26
01sparsity01grid scoreags=0.38bCell:20091203 1029 T1C3Rat: 1385501sparsity01grid scoreags=0.15bCell:20100225 1741 T10C3Rat: 1396001sparsity01grid scoreags=0.43bCell:20100315 1549 T4C8Rat: 1414701sparsity01grid scoreags=0.43bCell:20101005 1350 T1C2Rat: 1531401sparsity01grid scoreags=0.26bCell:20110330 1526 T3C3Rat: 15708 Supplementary fig 2. Projection from peaks
to lattice vectors. a: A typical grid cell
autocorrelogram with three detected peakcenters
drawn as vectors p1, p2, p3 from the origin. The purple
vectors demonstrate that p1 + p3 (cid:54)= p2. b: The same
autocorrelogram, but now with vectors a1, a2, a3 that
are related to p1, p2, p3 by the lattice projection
derived in the Materials and Methods section. These
vectors satisfy a1 + a3 = a2, and hence they define a
consistent lattice.
Supplementary fig 3. Deformation ellipse and
spacing of a grid pattern The ellipse (green curve)
has been fitted through a ring of autocorrelogram
lattice points (blue dots) taken from the
autocorrelogram. The semiaxes are labeled a and b. A
circle with the same area as the ellipse is plotted
concentrically (red dashed curve). The radius of this
circle, λ =
ab, defines the grid spacing.
√
Supplementary fig 4. Firing field amplitude variability. a: Blue circles show the field amplitude
coefficient of variation of each cell in a module, scattered against the mean coefficient of variation from the 1000
sampled spike trains corresponding to that cell. Red squares show the same quantity for one particular sampled
spike train per real cell. b: Between-field coefficient of variability scattered against within-field coefficient of
variability from the same real cells and synthetic spikes as in a. Variabilities are computed from field amplitudes
measured in the first and second halves of the experimental sessions separately.
27
p1p2p3aa1a2a3bλab00.8›cfisim00.8ca01.2cW01.2cBbRat: 13960, Module: 101›cfisim01ca01.4cW01.4cBbRat: 13960, Module: 201›cfisim01ca01.4cW01.4cBbRat: 13960, Module: 301.4›cfisim01.4ca02cW02cBbRat: 14147, Module: 101.2›cfisim01.2ca01.6cW01.6cBbRat: 14147, Module: 200.3›cfisim00.3ca00.5cW00.5cBbRat: 14147, Module: 300.9›cfisim00.9ca01.4cW01.4cBbRat: 15314, Module: 100.4›cfisim00.4ca00.6cW00.6cBbRat: 15314, Module: 200.7›cfisim00.7ca00.9cW00.9cBbRat: 15708, Module: 100.7›cfisim00.7ca01cW01cBbRat: 15708, Module: 200.3›cfisim00.3ca00.4cW00.4cBbRat: 15708, Module: 300.3›cfisim00.3ca00.5cW00.5cBbRat: 15708, Module: 4 Supplementary fig 5. Example grid cell ratemaps and firing field amplitudes, with simulated
counterparts. The cells used in this figure are a subset of the cells constituting the respective modules
(approx. every 13th cell in each module). a: Grid cell rate map with detected firing fields circled and numbered.
The grid score (gs), sparsity (sp) and field amplitude coefficient of variation (c) are quoted below the rate map.
b: The normalized amplitude of each field in a is shown (gray wide bars in the background) together with the
amplitudes measured in only the first and second halves of the session (red and light blue bars in the
foreground). On top of this, markers and error bars visualize the distribution of normalized amplitudes from
1000 synthetic spike trains, with the black diamond showing the mean amplitude, the small black whiskers
showing the central 95 % of the full-length amplitudes (to be compared with the gray wide bars), and the large
purple whiskers showing the central 95 % of the half-length amplitudes (to be compared with the red and light
blue narrow bars). For each cell and synthetic spike train, amplitudes are normalized to the mean of the
full-length amplitudes from that cell or spike train when creating this plot. c-d: Equivalent to a-b, but using
sampled spikes generated from the real animal trajectory and a tuning profile consisting of identical firing fields.
Another 1000 synthetic spike trains like this were used to generate the error bars in b and c, and to perform the
statistical analysis of the variability.
28
a1234567gs=0.54, c=0.46c1234567gs=1.04, c=0.2307.4Rate /Hz012r/rb1234567Field012r/rdRat: 13855, Cell: 20091019 0848 T1C7a12456gs=0.71, c=0.27c12456gs=0.96, c=0.08016Rate /Hz012r/rb12456Field012r/rdRat: 13855, Cell: 20091123 1720 T1C5a123456710gs=0.72, c=0.30c123456710gs=1.19, c=0.08035Rate /Hz012r/rb123456710Field012r/rdRat: 13855, Cell: 20091024 0950 T1C2a123456714gs=0.85, c=0.44c123456714gs=1.24, c=0.11022Rate /Hz0123r/rb123456714Field0123r/rdRat: 13855, Cell: 20091019 0848 T5C2a12345611gs=0.74, c=0.31c12345611gs=1.19, c=0.2505.4Rate /Hz012r/rb12345611Field012r/rdRat: 13855, Cell: 20091020 1709 T1C1a12356712gs=0.92, c=0.35c12356712gs=1.28, c=0.1709.5Rate /Hz012r/rb12356712Field012r/rdRat: 13855, Cell: 20091029 1031 T2C3a123456716gs=0.85, c=0.49c123456716gs=1.25, c=0.13020Rate /Hz012r/rb123456716Field012r/rdRat: 13855, Cell: 20091124 1700 T2C4a1256710gs=0.81, c=0.39c1256710gs=1.02, c=0.07015Rate /Hz012r/rb1256710Field012r/rdRat: 13960, Cell: 20100123 1849 T5C16a123567gs=1.12, c=0.34c123567gs=1.21, c=0.08020Rate /Hz012r/rb123567Field012r/rdRat: 13960, Cell: 20100219 1807 T5C2a123gs=0.66, c=0.41c123gs=1.03, c=0.03015Rate /Hz012r/rb123Field012r/rdRat: 13960, Cell: 20100216 1709 T5C3a156gs=0.84, c=0.32c156gs=1.12, c=0.06022Rate /Hz012r/rb156Field012r/rdRat: 13960, Cell: 20100222 1930 T5C1a123467913gs=0.90, c=0.69c123467913gs=1.23, c=0.2209.5Rate /Hz012r/rb123467913Field012r/rdRat: 14147, Cell: 20100322 1714 T3C4a12345611gs=0.79, c=0.19c12345611gs=0.90, c=0.08030Rate /Hz012r/rb12345611Field012r/rdRat: 14147, Cell: 20100627 1500 T2C7a1234567gs=0.73, c=0.26c1234567gs=1.08, c=0.09020Rate /Hz012r/rb1234567Field012r/rdRat: 14147, Cell: 20100301 1649 T4C2a1234567gs=0.91, c=0.62c1234567gs=1.16, c=0.04036Rate /Hz012r/rb1234567Field012r/rdRat: 14147, Cell: 20100510 1650 T3C5a1234567gs=0.59, c=0.62c1234567gs=1.02, c=0.10012Rate /Hz012r/rb1234567Field012r/rdRat: 14147, Cell: 20100608 1113 T3C3 Supplementary fig 5. Continued.
29
a1256gs=0.64, c=0.33c1256gs=0.82, c=0.04018Rate /Hz012r/rb1256Field012r/rdRat: 14147, Cell: 20100225 1631 T2C8a1234gs=0.92, c=0.42c1234gs=1.11, c=0.09018Rate /Hz012r/rb1234Field012r/rdRat: 14147, Cell: 20100622 1604 T2C1a1256gs=0.82, c=0.70c1256gs=0.77, c=0.13013Rate /Hz012r/rb1256Field012r/rdRat: 14147, Cell: 20100622 1604 T2C2a134gs=1.07, c=0.20c134gs=1.24, c=0.09039Rate /Hz012r/rb134Field012r/rdRat: 14147, Cell: 20100510 1650 T7C8a1567gs=0.91, c=0.70c1567gs=1.06, c=0.1307.9Rate /Hz012r/rb1567Field012r/rdRat: 15314, Cell: 20101005 1350 T5C1a123467gs=0.76, c=0.46c123467gs=0.75, c=0.09016Rate /Hz012r/rb123467Field012r/rdRat: 15314, Cell: 20101015 1326 T3C2a1345gs=0.48, c=0.30c1345gs=1.06, c=0.0708.5Rate /Hz012r/rb1345Field012r/rdRat: 15314, Cell: 20101005 1350 T1C3a12467gs=0.99, c=0.14c12467gs=1.01, c=0.08035Rate /Hz012r/rb12467Field012r/rdRat: 15314, Cell: 20100927 1502 T1C3a1267gs=0.93, c=0.29c1267gs=0.99, c=0.09011Rate /Hz012r/rb1267Field012r/rdRat: 15314, Cell: 20101029 1902 T2C3a123457gs=0.41, c=0.36c123457gs=0.88, c=0.13014Rate /Hz012r/rb123457Field012r/rdRat: 15314, Cell: 20101005 1350 T1C4a12467gs=0.67, c=0.18c12467gs=0.73, c=0.13012Rate /Hz012r/rb12467Field012r/rdRat: 15314, Cell: 20101027 1745 T9C5a12567gs=0.56, c=0.17c12567gs=0.64, c=0.11027Rate /Hz012r/rb12567Field012r/rdRat: 15314, Cell: 20100924 1600 T5C1a123gs=0.82, c=0.16c123gs=1.05, c=0.05019Rate /Hz012r/rb123Field012r/rdRat: 15314, Cell: 20101013 1251 T10C3a12345678141719gs=0.87, c=0.26c12345678141719gs=1.10, c=0.16011Rate /Hz012r/rb12345678141719Field012r/rdRat: 15708, Cell: 20110330 1526 T4C3a1234567121314gs=0.79, c=0.25c1234567121314gs=1.03, c=0.2007.9Rate /Hz012r/rb1234567121314Field012r/rdRat: 15708, Cell: 20110412 1741 T4C8a12345678101113gs=0.90, c=0.31c12345678101113gs=1.13, c=0.11041Rate /Hz012r/rb12345678101113Field012r/rdRat: 15708, Cell: 20110418 1609 T4C1a123456791011gs=0.45, c=0.42c123456791011gs=0.93, c=0.22011Rate /Hz012r/rb123456791011Field012r/rdRat: 15708, Cell: 20110330 1526 T5C2a145610gs=0.92, c=0.50c145610gs=1.27, c=0.18012Rate /Hz012r/rb145610Field012r/rdRat: 15708, Cell: 20110329 1558 T2C4a134gs=0.80, c=0.15c134gs=1.03, c=0.09023Rate /Hz012r/rb134Field012r/rdRat: 15708, Cell: 20110330 1526 T1C6a134gs=1.06, c=0.38c134gs=1.29, c=0.13040Rate /Hz012r/rb134Field012r/rdRat: 15708, Cell: 20110414 1354 T3C3 Fully factorized, σ = 0.0
Fully factorized, σ = 0.4
Fully factorized, σ = 0.8
Fully factorized, σ = 1.2
Supplementary fig 6. Additional examples of rate maps from the model simulation runs used in figure 4. In
each frame, the two top rows are excitatory neurons (grid cells) and the two bottom rows are inhibitory neurons
(interneurons).
30
gs=1.14, c=0.12gs=1.13, c=0.18gs=1.01, c=0.12gs=1.09, c=0.09gs=1.05, c=0.10gs=1.08, c=0.20gs=1.10, c=0.09gs=1.04, c=0.05gs=1.00, c=0.07gs=1.04, c=0.10gs=0.45, sp=0.33gs=0.86, sp=0.50gs=1.02, sp=0.63gs=1.19, sp=0.61gs=0.99, sp=0.59gs=0.43, sp=0.37gs=0.96, sp=0.21gs=0.78, sp=0.26gs=0.54, sp=0.50gs=0.82, sp=0.24gs=0.97, c=0.58gs=0.89, c=0.79gs=1.10, c=0.29gs=0.81, c=0.96gs=0.99, c=0.84gs=0.96, c=0.55gs=1.04, c=0.50gs=0.98, c=0.70gs=1.14, c=0.46gs=0.83, c=0.92gs=0.45, sp=0.33gs=0.84, sp=0.49gs=1.02, sp=0.63gs=1.20, sp=0.60gs=1.01, sp=0.59gs=0.41, sp=0.36gs=1.00, sp=0.21gs=0.77, sp=0.26gs=0.56, sp=0.50gs=0.85, sp=0.24gs=1.02, c=0.75gs=0.68, c=1.19gs=0.41, c=1.14gs=0.62, c=1.07gs=0.89, c=0.58gs=0.75, c=0.84gs=1.15, c=0.73gs=0.64, c=1.16gs=0.70, c=0.90gs=0.71, c=1.15gs=0.45, sp=0.33gs=0.81, sp=0.50gs=1.02, sp=0.64gs=1.17, sp=0.60gs=0.90, sp=0.60gs=0.37, sp=0.38gs=0.98, sp=0.22gs=0.79, sp=0.26gs=0.57, sp=0.51gs=0.87, sp=0.25gs=0.63, c=1.72gs=0.66, c=1.20gs=0.94, c=1.20gs=0.05, c=2.71gs=0.48, c=1.28gs=1.08, c=0.79gs=0.48, c=1.88gs=0.98, c=0.74gs=0.35, c=1.52gs=0.31, c=1.91gs=0.45, sp=0.32gs=0.81, sp=0.51gs=0.97, sp=0.64gs=1.18, sp=0.63gs=0.94, sp=0.60gs=0.45, sp=0.36gs=0.94, sp=0.22gs=0.82, sp=0.26gs=0.49, sp=0.50gs=0.83, sp=0.25 Partially factorized, σ = 0.0
Partially factorized, σ = 0.1
Partially factorized, σ = 0.2
Partially factorized, σ = 0.3
Supplementary fig 6. Continued.
31
gs=0.68, c=0.40gs=0.74, c=0.61gs=0.20, c=0.39gs=0.57, c=0.41gs=0.14, c=0.41gs=0.10, c=0.51gs=0.50, c=0.64gs=0.51, c=0.55gs=0.39, c=0.64gs=0.42, c=0.55gs=0.99, sp=0.00gs=0.29, sp=0.00gs=0.26, sp=0.00gs=0.66, sp=0.00gs=0.16, sp=0.00gs=0.01, sp=0.00gs=0.13, sp=0.00gs=0.16, sp=0.00gs=0.47, sp=0.00gs=0.04, sp=0.00gs=0.60, c=1.52gs=0.19, c=1.06gs=0.73, c=1.20gs=0.78, c=0.78gs=0.95, c=0.69gs=0.87, c=0.87gs=0.35, c=1.08gs=0.33, c=1.24gs=0.51, c=1.32gs=0.96, c=0.73gs=0.29, sp=0.01gs=0.38, sp=0.01gs=0.70, sp=0.01gs=0.51, sp=0.01gs=0.59, sp=0.01gs=0.80, sp=0.01gs=0.80, sp=0.01gs=0.83, sp=0.01gs=0.18, sp=0.00gs=0.20, sp=0.01gs=1.06, c=1.57gs=0.14, c=1.24gs=0.23, c=2.01gs=0.43, c=1.05gs=0.69, c=1.49gs=0.55, c=1.23gs=0.16, c=1.94gs=0.19, c=1.47gs=0.08, c=2.33gs=0.20, c=1.27gs=0.38, sp=0.01gs=0.44, sp=0.01gs=0.51, sp=0.02gs=0.15, sp=0.01gs=0.18, sp=0.01gs=0.12, sp=0.02gs=0.29, sp=0.01gs=0.26, sp=0.01gs=0.45, sp=0.01gs=0.44, sp=0.02gs=0.41, c=1.32gs=0.03, c=1.50gs=0.28, c=2.73gs= 0.03, c=1.91gs=0.21, c=1.50gs= 0.00, c=3.81gs=0.21, c=1.96gs=0.31, c=1.07gs=0.05, c=1.36gs=0.46, c=1.49gs=0.49, sp=0.01gs=0.24, sp=0.02gs=0.07, sp=0.02gs=0.05, sp=0.02gs=0.64, sp=0.01gs=0.02, sp=0.02gs=0.09, sp=0.02gs=0.40, sp=0.02gs=0.02, sp=0.02gs= 0.01, sp=0.02 Supplementary fig 7. Ratemaps of all 200 excitatory neurons (grid cells) in a run of the partially factorized
model with zero connectivity variance (σ = 0) and dilution fraction fd = 0.5. Grid score (gs) and field
amplitude coefficient of variation (c) quoted beneath each ratemap. The ratemaps are sorted by grid score, in
decreasing order.
32
gs=1.03, c=0.05gs=0.93, c=0.46gs=0.90, c=0.46gs=0.88, c=0.07gs=0.87, c=0.49gs=0.87, c=0.56gs=0.86, c=0.40gs=0.82, c=0.68gs=0.81, c=0.74gs=0.76, c=0.57gs=0.76, c=0.70gs=0.76, c=0.41gs=0.75, c=0.67gs=0.74, c=0.51gs=0.74, c=0.56gs=0.74, c=0.87gs=0.74, c=0.55gs=0.72, c=0.56gs=0.71, c=0.75gs=0.70, c=0.68gs=0.70, c=0.57gs=0.69, c=0.67gs=0.68, c=0.74gs=0.66, c=0.41gs=0.66, c=0.67gs=0.66, c=0.83gs=0.66, c=0.62gs=0.66, c=0.53gs=0.65, c=0.69gs=0.65, c=0.77gs=0.64, c=0.81gs=0.64, c=0.44gs=0.63, c=0.61gs=0.61, c=0.39gs=0.61, c=0.78gs=0.60, c=0.77gs=0.59, c=0.52gs=0.58, c=0.60gs=0.58, c=0.67gs=0.58, c=0.51gs=0.58, c=0.78gs=0.58, c=0.83gs=0.57, c=0.82gs=0.57, c=0.68gs=0.57, c=0.78gs=0.57, c=0.68gs=0.57, c=0.73gs=0.57, c=0.85gs=0.56, c=0.83gs=0.56, c=0.69gs=0.56, c=0.59gs=0.55, c=0.88gs=0.55, c=0.91gs=0.54, c=0.55gs=0.53, c=0.67gs=0.53, c=0.88gs=0.53, c=0.99gs=0.53, c=0.81gs=0.53, c=0.46gs=0.53, c=0.79gs=0.52, c=0.84gs=0.52, c=0.62gs=0.51, c=0.76gs=0.51, c=0.99gs=0.51, c=0.70gs=0.51, c=0.76gs=0.51, c=0.77gs=0.51, c=0.73gs=0.50, c=0.75gs=0.50, c=0.72gs=0.50, c=0.81gs=0.49, c=0.83gs=0.49, c=0.54gs=0.48, c=0.08gs=0.48, c=0.54gs=0.48, c=0.94gs=0.47, c=0.66gs=0.47, c=0.65gs=0.47, c=0.76gs=0.47, c=0.75gs=0.46, c=0.78gs=0.46, c=0.82gs=0.46, c=0.87gs=0.46, c=0.75gs=0.45, c=0.75gs=0.45, c=0.77gs=0.45, c=0.76gs=0.45, c=0.75gs=0.44, c=0.53gs=0.44, c=0.59gs=0.44, c=0.70gs=0.43, c=0.65gs=0.42, c=0.55gs=0.42, c=0.76gs=0.41, c=0.96gs=0.41, c=0.96gs=0.41, c=0.93gs=0.41, c=0.80gs=0.41, c=0.70gs=0.41, c=0.88gs=0.41, c=0.65gs=0.40, c=0.88gs=0.40, c=0.87gs=0.40, c=0.78gs=0.40, c=0.65gs=0.40, c=0.06gs=0.39, c=0.61gs=0.38, c=0.91gs=0.38, c=0.79gs=0.38, c=0.82gs=0.37, c=0.54gs=0.36, c=0.88gs=0.36, c=0.11gs=0.36, c=0.95gs=0.36, c=0.81gs=0.35, c=0.82gs=0.34, c=0.68gs=0.33, c=0.96gs=0.33, c=0.66gs=0.32, c=0.78 Supplementary fig 7. Continued.
33
gs=0.32, c=0.78gs=0.32, c=0.86gs=0.32, c=0.74gs=0.31, c=0.95gs=0.31, c=0.95gs=0.31, c=0.76gs=0.31, c=1.04gs=0.31, c=0.88gs=0.31, c=0.95gs=0.30, c=0.90gs=0.30, c=0.86gs=0.30, c=0.66gs=0.29, c=0.89gs=0.29, c=0.80gs=0.29, c=0.85gs=0.29, c=0.79gs=0.29, c=1.06gs=0.29, c=0.82gs=0.29, c=0.92gs=0.28, c=0.95gs=0.27, c=0.89gs=0.26, c=0.78gs=0.26, c=0.79gs=0.26, c=0.76gs=0.26, c=0.80gs=0.25, c=0.87gs=0.25, c=1.01gs=0.24, c=0.70gs=0.24, c=1.00gs=0.23, c=0.85gs=0.23, c=0.70gs=0.23, c=0.81gs=0.22, c=0.81gs=0.22, c=0.98gs=0.21, c=1.02gs=0.21, c=0.92gs=0.21, c=0.92gs=0.20, c=0.88gs=0.20, c=0.92gs=0.20, c=0.78gs=0.19, c=0.74gs=0.19, c=0.92gs=0.18, c=0.93gs=0.17, c=0.89gs=0.17, c=0.94gs=0.17, c=0.96gs=0.17, c=0.90gs=0.16, c=0.78gs=0.16, c=0.96gs=0.16, c=1.04gs=0.16, c=0.92gs=0.16, c=0.91gs=0.15, c=0.64gs=0.15, c=0.91gs=0.15, c=0.90gs=0.15, c=0.88gs=0.15, c=0.85gs=0.14, c=1.00gs=0.14, c=0.99gs=0.14, c=0.86gs=0.14, c=0.82gs=0.13, c=0.90gs=0.13, c=0.79gs=0.12, c=0.70gs=0.11, c=1.04gs=0.11, c=0.85gs=0.11, c=0.96gs=0.11, c=0.76gs=0.10, c=0.82gs=0.10, c=0.89gs=0.10, c=0.90gs=0.09, c=0.88gs=0.09, c=0.93gs=0.09, c=0.94gs=0.08, c=0.92gs=0.06, c=0.98gs=0.06, c=0.89gs=0.03, c=0.92gs=0.01, c=0.95gs= 0.00, c=0.86 |
1907.08549 | 2 | 1907 | 2019-12-04T20:43:41 | Universality and individuality in neural dynamics across large populations of recurrent networks | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cs.NE"
] | Task-based modeling with recurrent neural networks (RNNs) has emerged as a popular way to infer the computational function of different brain regions. These models are quantitatively assessed by comparing the low-dimensional neural representations of the model with the brain, for example using canonical correlation analysis (CCA). However, the nature of the detailed neurobiological inferences one can draw from such efforts remains elusive. For example, to what extent does training neural networks to solve common tasks uniquely determine the network dynamics, independent of modeling architectural choices? Or alternatively, are the learned dynamics highly sensitive to different model choices? Knowing the answer to these questions has strong implications for whether and how we should use task-based RNN modeling to understand brain dynamics. To address these foundational questions, we study populations of thousands of networks, with commonly used RNN architectures, trained to solve neuroscientifically motivated tasks and characterize their nonlinear dynamics. We find the geometry of the RNN representations can be highly sensitive to different network architectures, yielding a cautionary tale for measures of similarity that rely representational geometry, such as CCA. Moreover, we find that while the geometry of neural dynamics can vary greatly across architectures, the underlying computational scaffold---the topological structure of fixed points, transitions between them, limit cycles, and linearized dynamics---often appears universal across all architectures. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Universality and individuality in neural dynamics
across large populations of recurrent networks
Niru Maheswaranathan∗
Google Brain, Google Inc.
Mountain View, CA
[email protected]
Alex H. Williams∗
Stanford University
Stanford, CA
[email protected]
Matthew D. Golub
Stanford University
Stanford, CA
[email protected]
Surya Ganguli
Stanford University and Google Brain
Stanford, CA and Mountain View, CA
[email protected]
David Sussillo†
Google Brain, Google Inc.
Mountain View, CA
[email protected]
Abstract
Task-based modeling with recurrent neural networks (RNNs) has emerged as a
popular way to infer the computational function of different brain regions. These
models are quantitatively assessed by comparing the low-dimensional neural rep-
resentations of the model with the brain, for example using canonical correlation
analysis (CCA). However, the nature of the detailed neurobiological inferences
one can draw from such efforts remains elusive. For example, to what extent does
training neural networks to solve common tasks uniquely determine the network
dynamics, independent of modeling architectural choices? Or alternatively, are
the learned dynamics highly sensitive to different model choices? Knowing the
answer to these questions has strong implications for whether and how we should
use task-based RNN modeling to understand brain dynamics. To address these
foundational questions, we study populations of thousands of networks, with com-
monly used RNN architectures, trained to solve neuroscientifically motivated tasks
and characterize their nonlinear dynamics. We find the geometry of the RNN
representations can be highly sensitive to different network architectures, yielding
a cautionary tale for measures of similarity that rely on representational geometry,
such as CCA. Moreover, we find that while the geometry of neural dynamics
can vary greatly across architectures, the underlying computational scaffold -- the
topological structure of fixed points, transitions between them, limit cycles, and
linearized dynamics -- often appears universal across all architectures.
1
Introduction
The computational neuroscience community is increasingly relying on deep learning both to directly
model large-scale neural recordings [1, 2, 3] as well to train neural networks on computational tasks
and compare the internal dynamics of such trained networks to measured neural recordings [4, 5, 6, 7,
8, 9]. For example, several recent studies have reported similarities between the internal represen-
tations of biological and artificial networks [5, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16]. These representational
similarities are quite striking since artificial neural networks clearly differ in many ways from their
much more biophysically complex natural counterparts. How then, should we scientifically interpret
∗Equal contribution.
†Corresponding author.
33rd Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS 2019), Vancouver, Canada.
the striking representational similarity of biological and artificial networks, despite their vast disparity
in biophysical and architectural mechanisms?
A fundamental impediment to achieving any such clear scientific interpretation lies in the fact that
infinitely many model networks may be consistent with any particular computational task or neural
recording. Indeed, many modern applications of deep learning utilize a wide variety of recurrent
neural network (RNN) architectures [17, 18, 19, 20], initialization strategies [21] and regularization
terms [22, 23]. Moreover, new architectures continually emerge through large-scale automated
searches [24, 25, 26]. This dizzying set of modelling degrees of freedom in deep learning raises
fundamental questions about how the degree of match between dynamical properties of biological
and artificial networks varies across different modelling choices used to generate RNNs.
For example, do certain properties of RNN dynamics vary widely across individual architectures?
If so, then a high degree of match between these properties measured in both an artificial RNN
and a biological circuit might yield insights into the architecture underlying the biological circuit's
dynamics, as well as rule out other potential architectures. Alternatively, are other properties of RNN
dynamics universal across many architectural classes and other modelling degrees of freedom? If
so, such properties are interesting neural invariants determined primarily by the task, and we should
naturally expect them to recur not only across diverse classes of artificial RNNs, but also in relevant
brain circuits that solve the same task. The existence of such universal properties would then provide
a satisfying explanation of certain aspects of the match in internal representations between biological
and artificial RNNs, despite many disparities in their underlying mechanisms.
Interestingly, such universal properties can also break the vast design space of RNNs into different
universality classes, with these universal dynamical properties being constant within classes, and
varying only between classes. This offers the possibility of theoretically calculating or understanding
such universal properties by analyzing the simplest network within each universality class3. Thus
a foundational question in the theory of RNNs, as well as in their application to neuroscientific
modelling, lies in ascertaining which aspects of RNN dynamics vary across different architectural
choices, and which aspects -- if any -- are universal across such choices.
Theoretical clarity on the nature of individuality and universality in nonlinear RNN dynamics is
largely lacking4, with some exceptions [29, 30, 31, 32]. Therefore, with the above neuroscientific
and theoretical motivations in mind, we initiate an extensive numerical study of the variations in
RNN dynamics across thousands of RNNs with varying modelling choices. We focus on canonical
neuroscientifically motivated tasks that exemplify basic elements of neural computation, including
the storage and maintenance of multiple discrete memories, the production of oscillatory motor-like
dynamics, and contextual integration in the face of noisy evidence [33, 4].
To compare internal representations across networks, we focused on comparing the geometry of
neural dynamics using common network similarity measures such as singular vector canonical
correlation analysis (SVCCA) [34] and centered kernel alignment (CKA) [35]. We also used tools
from dynamical systems analysis to extract more topological aspects of neural dynamics, including
fixed points, limit cycles, and transition pathways between them, as well as the linearized dynamics
around fixed points [33]. We focused on these approaches because comparisons between artificial
and biological network dynamics at the level of geometry, and topology and linearized dynamics, are
often employed in computational neuroscience.
Using these tools, we find that different RNN architectures trained on the same task exhibit both
universal and individualistic dynamical properties. In particular, we find that the geometry of neural
representations varies considerably across RNNs with different nonlinearities. We also find surprising
dissociations between dynamical similarity and functional similarity, whereby trained and untrained
architectures of a given type can be more similar to each other than trained architectures of different
types. This yields a cautionary tale for using SVCCA or CKA to compare neural geometry, as
these similarity metrics may be more sensitive to particular modeling choices than to overall task
performance. Finally, we find considerably more universality across architectures in the topological
3This situation is akin to that in equilibrium statistical mechanics in which physical materials as disparate
as water and ferromagnets have identical critical exponents at second order phase transitions, by virtue of the
fact that they fall within the same universality class [27]. Moreover, these universal critical exponents can be
computed theoretically in the simplest model within this class: the Ising model.
4Although Feigenbaum's analysis [28] of period doubling in certain 1D maps might be viewed as an analysis
of 1D RNNs.
2
structure of fixed points, limit cycles, and specific properties of the linearized dynamics about fixed
points. Thus overall, our numerical study provides a much needed foundation for understanding
universality and individuality in network dynamics across various RNN models, a question that is
both of intrinsic theoretical interest, and of importance in neuroscientific applications.
2 Methods
2.1 Model Architectures and Training Procedure
We define an RNN by an update rule, ht = F (ht−1, xt), where F denotes some nonlinear function
of the network state vector ht−1 ∈ RN and the network input xt ∈ RM . Here, t is an integer index
denoting discrete time steps. Given an initial state, h0, and a stream of T inputs, x1, x2, . . ., xT , the
RNN states are recursively computed, h1, h2, . . ., hT . The model predictions are based on a linear
readout of these state vector representations of the input stream. We studied 4 RNN architectures, the
vanilla RNN (Vanilla), the Update-Gate RNN (UGRNN; [20]), the Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU; [18]),
and the Long-Short-Term-Memory (LSTM; [17]). The equations for these RNNs can be found in
Appendix A. For each RNN architecture we modified the (non-gate) point-wise activation function to
be either rectified linear (relu) or hyperbolic tangent (tanh). The point-wise activation for the gating
units is kept as a sigmoid.
We trained networks for every combination of the following parameters: RNN architecture (Vanilla,
UGRNN, LSTM, GRU), activation (relu, tanh), number of units/neurons (64, 128, 256), and L2
regularization (1e-5, 1e-4, 1e-3, 1e-2). This yielded 4×2×3×4 = 96 unique configurations. For each
one of these configurations, we performed a separate random hyperparameter search over gradient
clipping values [22] (logarithmically spaced from 0.1 to 10) and the learning rate schedule parameters.
The learning rate schedule is an exponentially decaying schedule parameterized by the initial rate
(with search range from 1e-5 to 0.1), decay rate (0.1 to 0.9), and momentum (0 to 1). All networks
were trained using stochastic gradient descent with momentum [36, 37] for 20,000 iterations with
a batch size of 64. For each network configuration, we selected the best hyperparameters using a
validation set. We additionally trained each of these configurations with 30 random seeds, yielding
2,880 total networks for analysis for each task. All networks achieve low error; histograms of the
final loss values achieved by all networks are available in Appendix C.
2.2 Tasks
We used three canonical tasks that have been previously studied in the neuroscience literature:
K-bit flip-flop Following [33], RNNs were provided K inputs taking discrete values in
{−1, 0, +1}. The RNN has K outputs, each of which is trained to remember the last non-zero
input on its corresponding input. Here we set K = 3, so e.g. output 2 remembers the last non-zero
state of input 2 (+1 or -1), but ignores inputs 1 and 3. We set the number of time steps, T , to 100, and
the flip probability (the probability of any input flipping on a particular time step) to 5%.
Frequency-cued sine wave Following [33], RNNs received a static input, x ∼ Uniform(0, 1), and
were trained to produce a unit amplitude sine wave, sin(2πωt), whose frequency is proportional to
the input: ω = 0.04x + 0.01. We set T = 500 and dt = 0.01 (5 simulated seconds total).
Context-dependent integration (CDI) Following previous work [4], RNNs were provided with
K static context inputs and K time-varying white noise input streams. On each trial, all but one
context input was zero, thus forming a one-hot encoding indicating which noisy input stream of
length T should be integrated. The white noise input was sampled from N (µ, 1) at each time step,
with µ sampled uniformly between -1 and 1 and kept static across time for each trial. RNNs were
trained to report the cumulative sum of the cued white-noise input stream across time. Here, we set
K = 2 and T = 30.
3
2.3 Assessing model similarity
The central questions we examined were: how similar are the representations and dynamics of
different RNNs trained on the same task? To address this, we use approaches that highlight different
but sometimes overlapping aspects of RNN function:
SVCCA and CKA to assess representational geometry We quantified similarity at the level of
representational geometry [38]. In essence, this means quantifying whether the responses of two
RNNs to the same inputs are well-aligned by some kind of linear transformation.
We focused on singular vector canonical correlations analysis (SVCCA; [34]), which has found
traction in both neuroscience [12] and machine learning communities [39, 15]. SVCCA compares
representations in two steps. First, each representation is projected onto their top principal components
to remove the effect of noisy (low variance) directions. Typically, the number of components is
chosen to retain ~95% of the variance in the representation. Then, canonical correlation analysis
(CCA) is performed to find a linear transformation that maximally correlates the two representations.
This yields R correlation coefficients, 1 ≥ ρ1 ≥ . . . ≥ ρR ≥ 0, providing a means to compare the
two datasets, typically by averaging or summing the coefficients (see Appendix D for further details).
In addition to SVCCA, we explored a related metric, centered kernel alignment (CKA; [35]). CKA
is related to SVCCA in that it also suppresses low variance directions, however CKA weights the
components proportional to the singular value (as opposed to removing some completely). We
found that using SVCCA and CKA yielded similar results for the purposes of determining whether
representations cluster by architecture or activation function so we present SVCCA results in the
main text but provide a comparison with CKA in Appendix E.
1, h∗
i ≈ F (h∗
2, ...} of an RNN such that h∗
Fixed point topology to assess computation An alternative perspective to representational geom-
etry for understanding computation in RNNs is dynamics. We studied RNN dynamics by reducing
their nonlinear dynamics to linear approximations. Briefly, this approach starts by optimizing to find
the fixed points {h∗
i , x∗). We use the term fixed point to
also include approximate fixed points, which are not truly fixed but are nevertheless very slow on the
time scale of the task.
We set the input (x∗) to be static when finding fixed points. These inputs can be thought of as
specifying different task conditions. In particular, the static command frequency in the sine wave task
and the hot-one context signal in the CDI task are examples of such condition specifying inputs. Note
however, that dimensions of x that are time-varying are set to 0 in x∗. In particular, the dimensions
of the input that represent the input pulses in the 3-bit memory task and the white noise input streams
in the CDI task are set to 0 in x∗.
Numerical procedures for identifying fixed points are discussed in [33, 40]. Around each fixed point,
the local behavior of the system can be approximated by a reduced system with linear dynamics:
ht ≈ h∗ + J(h∗, x∗) (ht−1 − h∗) ,
where Jij(h∗, x∗) = ∂Fi(h∗,x∗)
denotes the Jacobian of the RNN update rule. We studied these
linearized systems using the eigenvector decomposition for non-normal matrices (see Appendix B
for the eigenvector decomposition). In this analysis, both the topology of the fixed points and the
linearizations around those fixed points become objects of interest.
∂h∗
j
Visualizing similarity with multi-dimensional scaling For each analysis, we computed network
similarity between all pairs of network configurations for a given task, yielding a large (dis-)similarity
matrix for each task (for example, we show this distance matrix for the flip-flop task in Fig. 1c). To
visualize the structure in these matrices, we used multi-dimensional scaling (MDS) [41] to generate
a 2D projection which we used for visualization (Fig. 1d and f, Fig. 2c and e, Fig. 3c and d). For
visualization purposes, we separate plots colored by RNN architecture (for a fixed nonlinearity, tanh)
and nonlinearity (for a fixed architecture, Vanilla).
3 Results
The major contributions in this paper are as follows. First, we carefully train and tune large populations
of RNNs trained on several canonical tasks relating to discrete memory [33], pattern generation [33],
4
Figure 1: 3-bit discrete memory. a) Inputs (black) of -1 or 1 come in at random times while the corresponding
output (dashed red) has to remember the last non-zero state of the input (either +1 or -1). b) Example PCA
trajectories of dynamics for an example architecture and activation function. c) Dynamics across networks
are compared via SVCCA and given a distance (one minus the average correlation coefficient), yielding a
network-network distance matrix. d) This distance matrix is used to create a 2D embedding via multidimensional
scaling (MDS) of all networks, showing clustering based on RNN architecture (left) and activation function
(right). e) Topological analysis of a network using fixed points. First, the fixed points of a network's dynamics
are found, and their linear stability is assessed (left, black dots - stable fixed points, red - one unstable dimension,
green - 2 unstable dimensions, blue - 3 unstable dimensions. By studying heteroclinic and homoclinic orbits, the
fixed point structure is translated to a graph representation (right). f) This graph representation is then compared
across networks, creating another network-network distance matrix. The distance matrix is used to embed the
network comparisons into 2D space using MDS, showing that the topological representation of a network using
fixed point structure is more similar across architectures (left) and activation functions (right) than the geometry
of the network is (layout as in 1d).
and analog memory and integration [4]. Then, we show that representational geometry is sensitive
to model architecture (Figs. 1-3). Next, we show all RNN architectures, including complex, gated
architectures (e.g. LSTM and GRU) converge to qualitatively similar dynamical solutions, as
quantified by the topology of fixed points and corresponding linearized dynamics (Figs. 1-3). Finally,
we highlight a case where SVCCA is not necessarily indicative of functional similarity (Fig. 4).
3.1
3-bit discrete memory
We trained RNNs to store and report three discrete binary inputs (Fig. 1a). In Fig. 1b, we use a simple
"probe input" consisting of a series of random inputs to highlight the network structure. Across all
network architectures the resulting trajectories roughly trace out the corners of a three-dimensional
cube. While these example trajectories look qualitatively similar across architectures, SVCCA
revealed systematic differences. This is visible in the raw SVCCA distance matrix (Fig. 1c), as well
as in low-dimensional linear embeddings achieved by applying multi-dimensional scaling (MDS)
(Fig. 1d) created using the SVCCA distance matrix.
To study the dynamics of these networks, we ran an optimization procedure [40] to numerically
identify fixed points for each trained network (see Methods). A representative network is shown in
Fig. 1e (left). The network solves the task by encoding all 23 possible outputs as 8 stable fixed points.
Furthermore, there are saddle points with one, two, or three unstable dimensions (see caption), which
route the network activity towards the appropriate stable fixed point for a given input.
We devised an automated procedure to quantify the computational logic of the fixed point structure
in Fig. 1e that effectively ignored the precise details in the transient dynamics and overall geometry
of the 3D cube evident in the PCA trajectories. Specifically, we distilled the dynamical trajectories
into a directed graph, with nodes representing fixed points, and weighted edges representing the
probability of moving from one fixed point to another when starting the initial state a small distance
5
(a)Flip-floptaskschematicgraphrepresentationPCAtrajectories(f)NetworksimilarityusingfixedpointtopologyMDStanhreluUGRNNVanillaGRULSTM(d)NetworksimilarityusingSVCCAMDS(b)PCATrajectoriesPC#1PC#2PC#3(c)SVCCADistances(e)Fixedpointtopology Figure 2: Sine wave generation. a) Schematic showing conversion of static input specifying a command
frequency, ω, for the sine wave output sin(2πωt). b) PCA plots showing trajectories using many evenly divided
command frequencies delivered one at a time (blue: smallest ω, yellow: largest ω). c) MDS plots based on
SVCCA network-network distances, layout as in Fig. 1d. d) Left, fixed points (colored circles, with color
indicating ω, one fixed point per command frequency) showing a single fixed point in the middle of each
oscillatory trajectory. Right, the complex eigenvalues of all the linearized systems, one per fixed point, overlayed
on top of each other, with primary oscillatory eigenvalues colored as in panel b. e) MDS network-network
distances based on fixed point topology, assessing systematic differences in the topology of the input-dependent
fixed points (layout as in Fig. 1d). f) Summary analysis showing the frequency of the oscillatory mode in the
linearized system vs. command frequency for different architectures (left) and activations (right). Solid line and
shaded patch show the mean ± standard error over networks trained with different random seeds. Small, though
systematic, variations exist in the frequency of each oscillatory mode.
away from the first fixed point. We did this 100 times for each fixed point, yielding a probability
of transitioning from one fixed point to another. As expected, stable fixed points have no outgoing
edges, and only have a self-loop. All unstable fixed points had two or more outgoing edges, which are
directed at nearby stable fixed points. We constructed a fixed point graph for each network and used
the Euclidean distance between the graph connectivity matrices to quantify dis-similarity5. These
heteroclinic orbits are shown in Fig. 1e, light black trajectories from one fixed point to another. Using
this topological measure of RNN similarity, we find that all architectures converge to very similar
solutions as shown by an MDS embedding of the fixed point graph (Fig. 1f).
3.2 Sine wave generation
We trained RNNs to convert a static input into a sine wave, e.g. convert the command frequency ω
to sin(2πωt) (Fig. 2a). Fig. 2b shows low-dimensional trajectories in trained networks across all
architectures and nonlinearities (LSTM with ReLU did not train effectively, so we excluded it). Each
5While determining whether two graphs are isomorphic is a challenging problem in general, we circumvented
this issue by lexographically ordering the fixed points based on the RNN readout. Networks with different
numbers of fixed points than the modal number were discarded (less than 10% of the population).
6
(b)ExamplePCAtrajectoriestanhreluVanillaUGRNNGRUPC#1PC#3PC#2LSTM(c)NetworksimilarityviaSVCCAMDS(e)NetworksimilarityviafixedpointtopologyMDS(d)Fixedpointlinearizationanalysis(examplenetwork)(f)Linearizationsummary135Inputfrequency(Hz)(a)SinewavetaskschematicTime(s)TargetsUGRNNVanillaGRULSTMtanhreluUGRNNVanillaGRULSTMtanhrelu135135LSTMUGRNNGRUVanilla135tanhreluInputfreq.,ω(Hz)Inputfrequency,ω(Hz)Linearfreq.(Hz)0.00.51.0()0.50.00.5() trajectory is colored by the input frequency. Furthermore, all trajectories followed a similar pattern:
oscillations occur in a roughly 2D subspace (circular trajectories), with separate circles for each
frequency input separated by a third dimension. We then performed an analogous series of analyses
to those used in the previous task. In particular, we computed the SVCCA distances (raw distances
not shown) and used those to create an embedding of the network activity (Fig. 2c) as a function of
either RNN architecture or activation. These SVCCA MDS summaries show systematic differences
in the representations across both architecture and activation.
Moving to the analysis of dynamics, we found for each input frequency a single input-dependent
fixed point (Fig. 2d, left). We studied the linearized dynamics around each fixed point and found a
single pair of imaginary eigenvalues, representing a mildly unstable oscillatory mode whose complex
angle aligned well with the input frequency (Fig. 2d, right). We compared the frequency of the linear
model to the input frequency and found generally good alignment. We averaged the linear frequency
across all networks within architecture or activation and found small, but systematic differences
(Fig. 2f). Embeddings of the topological structure of the input-dependent fixed points did not reveal
any structure that systematically varied by architecture or activation (Fig. 2e).
3.3 Context-dependent integration (analog memory)
We trained an RNN to contextually integrate one of two white noise input streams, while ignoring
the other (Fig. 3a). We then studied the network representations by delivering a set of probe inputs
(Fig. 3a). The 3D PCA plots are shown in Fig. 3b, showing obvious differences in representational
geometry as a function of architecture and activation. The MDS summary plot of the SVCCA
distances of the representations is shown in Fig. 3c, again showing systematic clustering as a function
of architecture (left) and activation (right). We also analyzed the topology of the fixed points (black
dots in Fig. 3b) to assess how well the fixed points approximated a line attractor. We quantified this
by generating a graph with edges between fixed points that were nearest neighbors. This resulted in a
graph for each line attractor in each context, which we then compared using Euclidean distance and
embedded in a 2D space using MDS (Fig. 3d). The MDS summary plot did not cluster strongly by
architecture, but did cluster based on activation.
We then studied the linearized dynamics around each fixed point (Fig. 3e,f). We focused on a single
context, and studied how a unit magnitude relevant input (as opposed to the input that should be
contextually ignored) was integrated by the linear system around the nearest fixed point. This was
previously studied in depth in [4]. Here we were interested in differences in integration strategy as a
function of architecture. We found similar results to [4] for the vanilla RNN, which integrated the
input using a single linear mode with an eigenvalue of 1, with input coming in on the associated
left eigenvector and represented on the associated right eigenvector. Examination of all linearized
dynamics averaged over all fixed points within the context showed that different architectures had
a similar strategy, except that the gated architectures had many more eigenvalues near 1 (Fig. 3e)
and thus used a high-dimensional strategy to accomplish the same goal as the vanilla RNN does in 1
dimension. We further studied the dimensionality by systematically zeroing out eigenvalues from
smallest to largest to discover how many linear modes were necessary to integrate a unit magnitude
input, compared to the full linear approximation (Fig. 3f). These results show that all of the networks
and architectures use essentially the same integration strategy, but systematically vary by architecture
in terms of the number of modes they employ. To a lesser degree they also vary some in the amount
the higher order terms contribute to the solution, as shown by the differences away from an integral
of 1 for a unit magnitude input, for the full linearized system with no modes zeroed out (analogous to
Fig. 2f).
Finally, to highlight the difficulty of using CCA-based techniques to compare representational
geometry in simple tasks, we used the inputs of the context-dependent integrator task to drive both
trained and untrained vanilla RNNs (Fig. 4). We found that the average canonical correlation between
trained and untrained networks can be larger than between trained RNNs with different nonlinearities.
The summary MDS plot across many RNNs shows that the two clusters of untrained and trained relu
networks are closer together than the two clusters of trained tanh networks Fig. 4b.
7
Figure 3: Context-Dependent Integration. a) One of two streams of white-noise input (blue or red) is contextually
selected by a one-hot static context input to be integrated as output of the network, while the other is ignored
(blue or red). b) The trained networks were studied with probe inputs (panel inset in a), probes from blue to
red show probe input). For this and subsequent panels, only one context is shown for clarity. Shown in b are
the PCA plots of RNN hidden states when driven by probe inputs (blue to red). The fixed points (black dots)
show approximate line attractors for all RNN architectures and nonlinearities. c) MDS embedding of SVCCA
network-network distances comparing representations based on architecture (left) and activation (right), layout
as in Fig. 1d. d) Using the same method to assess the topology of the fixed points as used in the sine-wave
example to study the topology of the input-dependent fixed points, we embedded the network-network distances
using the topological structure of the line attractor (colored based on architectures (left) and activation (right),
layout as in Fig. 1d). e) Average sorted eigenvalues as a function architecture. Solid line and shaded patch show
mean ± standard error over networks trained with different random seeds. f) Output of the network when probed
with a unit magnitude input using the linearized dynamics, averaged over all fixed points on the line attractor,
as a function of architecture and number of linear modes retained. In order to study the the dimensionality of
the solution to integration, we systematically removed the modes with smallest eigenvalues one at a time, and
recomputed the prediction of the new linear system for the unit magnitude input. These plots indicate that the
vanilla RNN (blue) uses a single mode to perform the integration, while the gated architectures distribute this
across a larger number of linear modes.
4 Related Work
Researchers are beginning to study both empirically and theoretically how deep networks may show
universal properties. For example, [32] proved that representational geometry is a universal property
amongst all trained deep linear networks that solve a task optimally, with smallest norm weights.
Also, [42, 43] studied how expressive capacity increases with network depth and width. Work in
RNNs is far more preliminary, though it is well known that RNNs are universal approximators
of dynamical systems [44]. More recently, the per-parameter capacity of RNNs was found to be
remarkably similar across various RNN architectures [20]. The authors of [45] studied all the possible
topological arrangements of fixed points in a 2D continuous-time GRU, conjecturing that dynamical
configurations such as line or ring attractors that require an infinite number of fixed points can only
be created in approximation, even in GRUs with more than two dimensions.
8
UGRNNVanillaGRULSTMtanhreluUGRNNVanillaGRULSTMtanhrelu(a)ContextdependentintegrationtaskContext(redorblue)Probe(singlecontext)(b)ExamplePCAtrajectories(singlecontext)(c)NetworksimilarityusingSVCCAMDS(d)NetworksimilarityusingfixedpointtopologyMDStanhVanillaUGRNNGRULSTMreluContextSignalInputsOutputs(a)(c)LinearprojectionsofCCAsimilarities(b)tanhReLUUntrainedTrainedVanillaRNNsPCAprojectionsofRNNactivityuntrainedReLUtrainedReLUuntrainedtanhtrainedtanhtanhRNNs(trained)VanillaLSTMGRUUGRNNPC1PC2ProbeinputsforRNNintegrationtask.0.720.810.80112801VanillaLSTMGRUUGRNNPC#1PC#2112801VanillaGRUUGRNNLSTM1128tanhreluλEigenmode(e)AverageeigenvaluemagnitudeNumberofkepteigenmodes(f)Linearizedpredictionsforaunitinput Figure 4: An example where SVCCA yields a stronger correlation between untrained networks and trained
networks than between trained networks with different nonlinearities. a) An example (single context shown)
of the representation of the probe inputs (blue through red) for four networks: two trained, and two untrained
with tanh and ReLU nonlinearities. In this case the untrained tanh and ReLU networks have a higher correlation
to the trained tanh network than the trained tanh network does to the trained ReLU network. b) MDS plot
of SVCCA-based distances for many trained and untrained networks, showing that trained and untrained relu
networks are more similar to each other on average than to tanh networks.
Understanding biological neural systems in terms of artificial dynamical systems has a rich tradition
[46, 47, 48, 49]. Researchers have attempted to understand optimized neural networks with nonlinear
dynamical systems techniques [33, 50] and to compare those artificial networks to biological circuits
[4, 12, 51, 52, 53, 13, 14].
Previous work has studied vanilla RNNs in similar settings [33, 4, 54], but has not systematically
surveyed the variability in network dynamics across commonly used RNN architectures, such as
LSTMs [17] or GRUs [18], nor quantified variations in dynamical solutions over architecture and
nonlinearity, although [16] considers many issues concerning how RNNs may hold memory. Finally,
there has been a recent line of work comparing artificial network representations to neural data [1, 2,
3, 10, 11, 12]. Investigators have been studying ways to improve the utility of CCA-based comparison
methods [34, 55], as well as comparing CCA to other methods [35].
5 Discussion
In this work we empirically study aspects of individuality and universality in recurrent networks.
We find individuality in that representational geometry of RNNs varies significantly as a function
of architecture and activation function (Fig. 1d, 2c, 3c). We also see hints of universality: the fixed
point topologies show far less variation across networks than the representations do (Fig. 1f, 2e, 3d).
Linear analyses also showed similar solutions, e.g. essentially linear oscillations for the sine wave
task (Fig. 2f) and linear integration in the CDI task (Fig. 3f). However, linear analyses also showed
variation across architectures in the dimensionality of the solution to integration (Fig. 3e).
While the linear analyses showed common computational strategies across all architectures (such
as a slightly unstable oscillation in the linearized system around each fixed point), we did see small
systematic differences that clustered by architecture (such as the difference between input frequency
and frequency of oscillatory mode in the linearized system). This indicates that another aspect of
individuality appears to be the degree to which higher order terms contribute to the total solution.
The fixed point analysis discussed here has one major limitation, namely that the number of fixed
points must be the same across networks that are being compared. For the three tasks studied here,
we found that the vast majority of trained networks did indeed have the same number of fixed points
for each task. However, an important direction for future work is extending the analysis to be more
robust with respect to differing numbers of fixed points.
In summary, we hope this empirical study begins a larger effort to characterize methods for comparing
RNN dynamics, building a foundation for future connections of biological circuits and artificial
neural networks.
9
(a)tanhReLUUntrainedTrainedPC1PC20.720.810.80VanillaRNNsuntrainedReLUtrainedReLUuntrainedtanhtrainedtanh(b)PC#1PC#2 Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank Jeffrey Pennington, Maithra Raghu, Jascha Sohl-Dickstein, and Larry
Abbott for helpful feedback and discussions. MDG was supported by the Stanford Neurosciences
Institute, the Office of Naval Research Grant #N00014-18-1-2158.
References
[1] Lane McIntosh, Niru Maheswaranathan, Aran Nayebi, Surya Ganguli, and Stephen Baccus.
"Deep Learning Models of the Retinal Response to Natural Scenes". In: Advances in Neural
Information Processing Systems 29. Ed. by D. D. Lee, M. Sugiyama, U. V. Luxburg, I. Guyon,
and R. Garnett. Curran Associates, Inc., 2016, pp. 1369 -- 1377. URL: http://papers.nips.
cc/paper/6388-deep-learning-models-of-the-retinal-response-to-natural-
scenes.pdf.
[2] Niru Maheswaranathan, Lane T McIntosh, David B Kastner, Josh Melander, Luke Brezovec,
Aran Nayebi, Julia Wang, Surya Ganguli, and Stephen A Baccus. "Deep learning models reveal
internal structure and diverse computations in the retina under natural scenes". In: bioRxiv
(2018), p. 340943.
[3] Chethan Pandarinath, Daniel J O'Shea, Jasmine Collins, Rafal Jozefowicz, Sergey D Stavisky,
Jonathan C Kao, Eric M Trautmann, Matthew T Kaufman, Stephen I Ryu, Leigh R Hochberg,
Jaimie M Henderson, Krishna V Shenoy, L F Abbott, and David Sussillo. "Inferring single-
trial neural population dynamics using sequential auto-encoders". In: Nature Methods 15.10
(2018), pp. 805 -- 815. ISSN: 1548-7105. DOI: 10.1038/s41592-018-0109-9. URL: https:
//doi.org/10.1038/s41592-018-0109-9.
[4] Valerio Mante, David Sussillo, Krishna V. Shenoy, and William T. Newsome. "Context-
dependent computation by recurrent dynamics in prefrontal cortex". In: Nature 503 (2013).
Article, p. 78.
[5] Alexander J E Kell, Daniel L K Yamins, Erica N Shook, Sam V Norman-Haignere, and Josh
H McDermott. "A Task-Optimized Neural Network Replicates Human Auditory Behavior,
Predicts Brain Responses, and Reveals a Cortical Processing Hierarchy". In: Neuron 98.3
(May 2018), 630 -- 644.e16. ISSN: 0896-6273. DOI: 10.1016/j.neuron.2018.03.044. URL:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2018.03.044.
[6] Rishi Rajalingham, Elias B. Issa, Pouya Bashivan, Kohitij Kar, Kailyn Schmidt, and James J.
DiCarlo. "Large-Scale, High-Resolution Comparison of the Core Visual Object Recognition
Behavior of Humans, Monkeys, and State-of-the-Art Deep Artificial Neural Networks". In:
Journal of Neuroscience 38.33 (2018), pp. 7255 -- 7269. ISSN: 0270-6474. DOI: 10.1523/
JNEUROSCI.0388- 18.2018. eprint: http://www.jneurosci.org/content/38/33/
7255.full.pdf. URL: http://www.jneurosci.org/content/38/33/7255.
[7] Christopher J Cueva and Xue-Xin Wei. "Emergence of grid-like representations by training
recurrent neural networks to perform spatial localization". In: arXiv preprint arXiv:1803.07770
(2018).
[8] Andrea Banino, Caswell Barry, Benigno Uria, Charles Blundell, Timothy Lillicrap, Piotr
Mirowski, Alexander Pritzel, Martin J Chadwick, Thomas Degris, Joseph Modayil, et al.
"Vector-based navigation using grid-like representations in artificial agents". In: Nature
557.7705 (2018), p. 429.
[9] Stefano Recanatesi, Matthew Farrell, Guillaume Lajoie, Sophie Deneve, Mattia Rigotti, and
Eric Shea-Brown. "Predictive learning extracts latent space representations from sensory
observations". In: bioRxiv (2019). DOI: 10.1101/471987. eprint: https://www.biorxiv.
org/content/early/2019/07/13/471987.full.pdf. URL: https://www.biorxiv.
org/content/early/2019/07/13/471987.
[10] Daniel L. K. Yamins, Ha Hong, Charles F. Cadieu, Ethan A. Solomon, Darren Seibert, and
James J. DiCarlo. "Performance-optimized hierarchical models predict neural responses in
higher visual cortex". In: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 111.23 (2014),
pp. 8619 -- 8624. ISSN: 0027-8424. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1403112111.
10
[11] Seyed-Mahdi Khaligh-Razavi and Nikolaus Kriegeskorte. "Deep Supervised, but Not Unsu-
pervised, Models May Explain IT Cortical Representation". In: PLOS Computational Biology
10.11 (Nov. 2014), pp. 1 -- 29. DOI: 10 . 1371 / journal . pcbi . 1003915. URL: https :
//doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1003915.
[12] David Sussillo, Mark M Churchland, Matthew T Kaufman, and Krishna V Shenoy. "A neural
network that finds a naturalistic solution for the production of muscle activity". In: Nature
neuroscience 18.7 (2015), p. 1025.
[13] Evan D Remington, Devika Narain, Eghbal A Hosseini, and Mehrdad Jazayeri. "Flexible
Sensorimotor Computations through Rapid Reconfiguration of Cortical Dynamics". In: Neuron
98.5 (2018), 1005 -- 1019.e5. ISSN: 0896-6273. DOI: 10.1016/j.neuron.2018.05.020.
Jing Wang, Devika Narain, Eghbal A Hosseini, and Mehrdad Jazayeri. "Flexible timing by
temporal scaling of cortical responses". In: Nature neuroscience 21.1 (2018), p. 102.
[14]
[15] David GT Barrett, Ari S Morcos, and Jakob H Macke. "Analyzing biological and artificial neu-
ral networks: challenges with opportunities for synergy?" In: Current Opinion in Neurobiology
55 (2019). Machine Learning, Big Data, and Neuroscience, pp. 55 -- 64. ISSN: 0959-4388.
[16] A Emin Orhan and Wei Ji Ma. "A diverse range of factors affect the nature of neural represen-
tations underlying short-term memory". In: Nature Neuroscience 22.2 (2019), pp. 275 -- 283.
ISSN: 1546-1726. DOI: 10.1038/s41593- 018- 0314- y. URL: https://doi.org/10.
1038/s41593-018-0314-y.
[17] Sepp Hochreiter and Jürgen Schmidhuber. "Long short-term memory". In: Neural computation
9.8 (1997), pp. 1735 -- 1780.
[18] Kyunghyun Cho, Bart van Merrienboer, Caglar Gulcehre, Fethi Bougares, Holger Schwenk,
and Yoshua Bengio. "Learning Phrase Representations using RNN Encoder-Decoder for
Statistical Machine Translation". In: Proc. Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural
Language Processing. Unknown, Unknown Region, 2014.
[19] Scott Wisdom, Thomas Powers, John Hershey, Jonathan Le Roux, and Les Atlas. "Full-
Capacity Unitary Recurrent Neural Networks". In: Advances in Neural Information Processing
Systems 29. Ed. by D. D. Lee, M. Sugiyama, U. V. Luxburg, I. Guyon, and R. Garnett. 2016,
pp. 4880 -- 4888.
Jasmine Collins, Jascha Sohl-Dickstein, and David Sussillo. "Capacity and Trainability in
Recurrent Neural Networks". In: ICLR. 2017.
[20]
[21] Quoc V. Le, Navdeep Jaitly, and Geoffrey E. Hinton. A Simple Way to Initialize Recurrent
Networks of Rectified Linear Units. 2015. eprint: arXiv:1504.00941.
[22] Razvan Pascanu, Tomas Mikolov, and Yoshua Bengio. "On the Difficulty of Training Recurrent
Neural Networks". In: Proceedings of the 30th International Conference on International
Conference on Machine Learning - Volume 28. ICML'13. Atlanta, GA, USA, 2013, pp. III-
1310 -- III-1318.
[23] Stephen Merity, Nitish Shirish Keskar, and Richard Socher. "Regularizing and Optimizing
LSTM Language Models". In: ICLR. 2018.
[24] Barret Zoph and Quoc V. Le. "Neural Architecture Search with Reinforcement Learning". In:
2017.
[25] Hieu Pham, Melody Y. Guan, Barret Zoph, Quoc V. Le, and Jeff Dean. "Efficient Neural
Architecture Search via Parameter Sharing". In: ICML. 2018.
[26] Liang-chieh Chen, Maxwell Collins, Yukun Zhu, George Papandreou, Barret Zoph, Florian
Schroff, Hartwig Adam, and Jonathon Shlens. "Searching for Efficient Multi-Scale Architec-
tures for Dense Image Prediction". In: 2018. URL: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1809.04184.
pdf.
[27] Harry Eugene Stanley. Introduction to Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena. en. Oxford
University Press, 1971.
[28] Mitchell J Feigenbaum. "Universal behavior in nonlinear systems". In: Universality in Chaos,
2nd edition. Routledge, 2017, pp. 49 -- 50.
[29] Alexander Rivkind and Omri Barak. "Local dynamics in trained recurrent neural networks".
In: Physical review letters 118.25 (2017), p. 258101.
[30] Francesca Mastrogiuseppe and Srdjan Ostojic. "Linking connectivity, dynamics, and computa-
tions in low-rank recurrent neural networks". In: Neuron 99.3 (2018), pp. 609 -- 623.
11
[31] Francesca Mastrogiuseppe and Srdjan Ostojic. "A Geometrical Analysis of Global Stability in
Trained Feedback Networks". In: Neural computation 31.6 (2019), pp. 1139 -- 1182.
[32] Andrew M Saxe, James L McClelland, and Surya Ganguli. "A mathematical theory of semantic
development in deep neural networks". In: Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. (May 2019).
[33] David Sussillo and Omri Barak. "Opening the Black Box: Low-Dimensional Dynamics in
High-Dimensional Recurrent Neural Networks". In: Neural Computation 25.3 (2013), pp. 626 --
649. DOI: 10.1162/NECO_a_00409.
[34] Maithra Raghu, Justin Gilmer, Jason Yosinski, and Jascha Sohl-Dickstein. "SVCCA: Singular
Vector Canonical Correlation Analysis for Deep Learning Dynamics and Interpretability".
In: Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 30. Ed. by I. Guyon, U. V. Luxburg,
S. Bengio, H. Wallach, R. Fergus, S. Vishwanathan, and R. Garnett. Curran Associates, Inc.,
2017, pp. 6076 -- 6085.
[35] Simon Kornblith, Mohammad Norouzi, Honglak Lee, and Geoffrey Hinton. "Similarity of
Neural Network Representations Revisited". In: arXiv preprint arXiv:1905.00414 (2019).
[36] Boris T Polyak. "Some methods of speeding up the convergence of iteration methods". In:
USSR Computational Mathematics and Mathematical Physics 4.5 (1964), pp. 1 -- 17.
Ilya Sutskever, James Martens, George Dahl, and Geoffrey Hinton. "On the importance of
initialization and momentum in deep learning". In: International conference on machine
learning. 2013, pp. 1139 -- 1147.
[37]
[38] Nikolaus Kriegeskorte and Rogier A. Kievit. "Representational geometry: integrating cognition,
computation, and the brain". In: Trends in Cognitive Sciences 17.8 (2013), pp. 401 -- 412. ISSN:
1364-6613.
[39] Saskia E. J. de Vries, Jerome Lecoq, Michael A. Buice, Peter A. Groblewski, Gabriel K. Ocker,
Michael Oliver, David Feng, Nicholas Cain, Peter Ledochowitsch, Daniel Millman, et al. "A
large-scale, standardized physiological survey reveals higher order coding throughout the
mouse visual cortex". In: bioRxiv (2018). DOI: 10.1101/359513.
[40] Matthew Golub and David Sussillo. "FixedPointFinder: A Tensorflow toolbox for identifying
and characterizing fixed points in recurrent neural networks". In: Journal of Open Source
Software 3.31 (Nov. 2018), p. 1003. DOI: 10.21105/joss.01003. URL: https://doi.
org/10.21105/joss.01003.
Ingwer Borg and Patrick Groenen. "Modern multidimensional scaling: Theory and applica-
tions". In: Journal of Educational Measurement 40.3 (2003), pp. 277 -- 280.
[41]
[42] Ben Poole, Subhaneil Lahiri, Maithra Raghu, Jascha Sohl-Dickstein, and Surya Ganguli.
"Exponential expressivity in deep neural networks through transient chaos". In: Advances in
neural information processing systems. 2016, pp. 3360 -- 3368.
[43] Maithra Raghu, Ben Poole, Jon Kleinberg, Surya Ganguli, and Jascha Sohl Dickstein. "On
the expressive power of deep neural networks". In: Proceedings of the 34th International
Conference on Machine Learning-Volume 70. JMLR. org. 2017, pp. 2847 -- 2854.
[44] Kenji Doya. "Universality of fully connected recurrent neural networks". In: Dept. of Biology,
UCSD, Tech. Rep (1993).
Ian D. Jordan, Piotr Aleksander Sokol, and Il Memming Park. "Gated recurrent units viewed
through the lens of continuous time dynamical systems". In: CoRR abs/1906.01005 (2019).
arXiv: 1906.01005. URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/1906.01005.
[45]
[46] Alain Destexhe and Terrence J Sejnowski. "The Wilson -- Cowan model, 36 years later". In:
Biological cybernetics 101.1 (2009), pp. 1 -- 2.
John J Hopfield. "Neural networks and physical systems with emergent collective computa-
tional abilities". In: Proceedings of the national academy of sciences 79.8 (1982), pp. 2554 --
2558.
[47]
[48] Haim Sompolinsky, Andrea Crisanti, and Hans-Jurgen Sommers. "Chaos in random neural
networks". In: Physical review letters 61.3 (1988), p. 259.
[49] H. S. Seung. "How the brain keeps the eyes still". In: Proceedings of the National Academy
of Sciences 93.23 (1996), pp. 13339 -- 13344. ISSN: 0027-8424. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.93.23.
13339.
[50] Omri Barak, David Sussillo, Ranulfo Romo, Misha Tsodyks, and LF Abbott. "From fixed
points to chaos: three models of delayed discrimination". In: Progress in neurobiology 103
(2013), pp. 214 -- 222.
12
[51] David Sussillo. "Neural circuits as computational dynamical systems". In: Current opinion in
neurobiology 25 (2014), pp. 156 -- 163.
[52] Kanaka Rajan, Christopher D Harvey, and David W Tank. "Recurrent network models of
sequence generation and memory". In: Neuron 90.1 (2016), pp. 128 -- 142.
[53] Omri Barak. "Recurrent neural networks as versatile tools of neuroscience research". In:
Current opinion in neurobiology 46 (2017), pp. 1 -- 6.
[54] Guangyu Robert Yang, Madhura R Joglekar, H Francis Song, William T Newsome, and
Xiao-Jing Wang. "Task representations in neural networks trained to perform many cognitive
tasks". In: Nature neuroscience 22.2 (2019), p. 297.
[55] Ari Morcos, Maithra Raghu, and Samy Bengio. "Insights on representational similarity in
neural networks with canonical correlation". In: Advances in Neural Information Processing
Systems. 2018, pp. 5727 -- 5736.
Ingmar Kanitscheider and Ila Fiete. "Training recurrent networks to generate hypotheses
about how the brain solves hard navigation problems". In: Advances in Neural Information
Processing Systems 30. Ed. by I. Guyon, U. V. Luxburg, S. Bengio, H. Wallach, R. Fergus,
S. Vishwanathan, and R. Garnett. Curran Associates, Inc., 2017, pp. 4529 -- 4538.
[56]
[57] Harold Hotelling. "Relations between two sets of variates". In: Breakthroughs in statistics.
Springer, 1992, pp. 162 -- 190.
13
A RNN Architectures
We examined four RNN architectures that exemplify various degrees of complexity and sophistication.
Vanilla RNNs have been historically favored by computational neuroscientists [4, 13], while LSTM
and GRU networks have been favored by machine learning practitioners due to performance advan-
tages [20]. However, neuroscientists are beginning to utilize gated RNNs as they progress to studying
more complex phenomena [56]. Thus, it is of great interest to determine whether similar mechanisms
arise across this range of model architectures, or if different models give rise to distinct dynamics and
scientific conclusions. These are architectures are summarized below, with W and b respectively
representing trainable weight matrices and bias parameters. All other vectors (c, g, r, i, f) represent
intermediate quantities; σ() represents a pointwise sigmoid nonlinearity; and f () is either the ReLU
or tanh nonlineary.
Vanilla RNN
ht = f (Whhht−1 + Whxxt + bh)
Update-Gate RNN (UGRNN; [20])
ht = g · ht−1 + (1 − g) · c
c = f (Wchht−1 + Wcxxt + bc)
g = σ(Wghht−1 + Wgxxt + bg + bf g)
Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU; [18])
ht = g · ht−1 + (1 − g) · c
Long-Short-Term-Memory (LSTM; [17])
ct(cid:101)ht
ht =
c = f (Wch(r · ht−1) + Wcxxt + bc)
g = σ(Wghht−1 + Wgxxt + bg + bf g)
r = σ(Wrhht−1 + Wrxxt + br)
(cid:101)ht = f (ct) · σ(Whhh + Whxx + bh)
ct = ft · ct−1 + i · σ(Wch(cid:101)ht−1 + Wcxx + bc)
i = σ(Wihh + Wixx + bi)
f = σ(Wfhh + Wfxx + bf + bf g)
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
B Non-normal linear dynamical systems analysis
We studied the linearized systems, e.g. ∂F (h∗,x∗)i
normal matrices, dropping the dependence on h∗ and x∗ for clarity
∂h∗
j
using the eigenvector decomposition for non-
N(cid:88)
J = RΛL =
λara(cid:96)T
a ,
(5)
a=1
where L = R−1, the columns of R (denoted ra) contain the right eigenvectors of Jrec, the rows of L
a ) contain the left eigenvectors of Jrec, and Λ is a diagonal matrix containing complex-
(denoted (cid:96)T
valued eigenvalues, λ1 > λ2 > . . . > λN , which are sorted based on their magnitude. Note in
particular there is no requirement that RTR = I, leading to potentially sophisticated locally linear
dynamics.
C Network performance
Below, we include a plot of the final performance of all networks retained for analysis in this paper.
All networks achieve low error for their respective tasks.
14
Figure 5: Histogram of final performance (mean squared error) across all networks used for the analyses in this
paper.
D SVCCA
The input to SVCCA [34] are two matrices, H1 ∈ RP×N1 and H2 ∈ RP×N2, which hold the state
vector representations of two RNNs over P test inputs. Here, N1 and N2 denote the number of
neurons in each RNN (in general N1 (cid:54)= N2). First, the singular value decomposition (SVD) is
computed for each matrix: H1 = U1S1VT
2 . Then, these decompositions are
truncated by taking the top R singular vectors. The value of R is a user-defined hyperparameter.
Let (cid:101)V1 ∈ RR×N1 and (cid:101)V2 ∈ RR×N2 denote the truncated right singular vectors. Finally, canonical
correlations analysis (CCA; [57]) is performed to quantify the similarity of (cid:101)V1 and (cid:101)V2.
1 and H2 = U2S2VT
E Centered kernel alignment (CKA)
Centered kernel alignment (CKA; [35]) is a measure of similarity between representations that is
invariant to orthogonal transformation and isotropic scaling, but unlike SVCCA, is not invariant to
invertible linear transformations. It defines a similarity between two representations X ∈ Rm×nx
and Y ∈ Rm×ny where m is the number of examples, and nx and ny are the number of units in the
representations for X and Y , respectively. The measure can be computed (for a linear kernel, see
[35] for details) as:
CKA(X, Y ) =
(cid:107)X T Y (cid:107)2
(cid:107)X T X(cid:107)F(cid:107)Y T Y (cid:107)F
F
Below, we compare representations using both singular vector canonical correlation analysis (SVCCA)
and centered kernel alignment (CKA). Each figure shows comparisons for each of the three studied
tasks. Within each figure, the first row shows the full pairwise distance matrix using either SVCCA
(left column) or CKA (right column). The next two rows show embeddings of a subset of these
pairwise distances in 2D using multi-dimensional scaling, highlighting differences by architecture
(middle row) or activation (bottom row). The key takeaway is that both SVCCA and CKA show
differences between network representations that cluster based on RNN architectures.
15
Figure 6: Comparing SVCCA and CKA for the flip flop task. See Appendix E for description of the panels.
16
Figure 7: Comparing SVCCA and CKA for the sinewave task. See Appendix E for description of the panels.
17
Figure 8: Comparing SVCCA and CKA for the context dependent integration task. See Appendix E for
description of the panels.
18
|
1710.05945 | 1 | 1710 | 2017-10-16T18:10:44 | Rats optimally accumulate and discount evidence in a dynamic environment | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | How choices are made within noisy environments is a central question in the neuroscience of decision making. Previous work has characterized temporal accumulation of evidence for decision-making in static environments. However, real-world decision-making involves environments with statistics that change over time. This requires discounting old evidence that may no longer inform the current state of the world. Here we designed a rat behavioral task with a dynamic environment, to probe whether rodents can optimally discount evidence by adapting the timescale over which they accumulate it. Extending existing results about optimal inference in a dynamic environment, we show that the optimal timescale for evidence discounting depends on both the stimulus statistics and noise in sensory processing. We found that when both of these components were taken into account, rats accumulated and temporally discounted evidence almost optimally. Furthermore, we found that by changing the dynamics of the environment, experimenters could control the rats' accumulation timescale, switching them from accumulating over short timescales to accumulating over long timescales and back. The theoretical framework also makes quantitative predictions regarding the timing of changes of mind in the dynamic environment. This study establishes a quantitative behavioral framework to control and investigate neural mechanisms underlying the adaptive nature of evidence accumulation timescales and changes of mind. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Rats optimally accumulate and discount evidence in a dy-
namic environment
Alex T Piet1, Ahmed El Hady1,3,∗, Carlos D Brody1,2,3,∗
1. Princeton Neuroscience Institute, Princeton University, Princeton, United States.
2. Department of Molecular Biology, Princeton University, Princeton, United States.
3. Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Princeton University, Princeton, United States.
*correspondence should be addressed to Ahmed El Hady ([email protected]) or Carlos D Brody
([email protected])
Abstract
How choices are made within noisy environments is a central question in the neuroscience of decision
making. Previous work has characterized temporal accumulation of evidence for decision-making in
static environments. However, real-world decision-making involves environments with statistics that
change over time. This requires discounting old evidence that may no longer inform the current state
of the world. Here we designed a rat behavioral task with a dynamic environment, to probe whether
rodents can optimally discount evidence by adapting the timescale over which they accumulate it. Ex-
tending existing results about optimal inference in a dynamic environment, we show that the optimal
timescale for evidence discounting depends on both the stimulus statistics and noise in sensory pro-
cessing. We found that when both of these components were taken into account, rats accumulated
and temporally discounted evidence almost optimally. Furthermore, we found that by changing the
dynamics of the environment, experimenters could control the rats' accumulation timescale, switching
them from accumulating over short timescales to accumulating over long timescales and back. The
theoretical framework also makes quantitative predictions regarding the timing of changes of mind in
the dynamic environment. This study establishes a quantitative behavioral framework to control and
investigate neural mechanisms underlying the adaptive nature of evidence accumulation timescales and
changes of mind.
7
1
0
2
t
c
O
6
1
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
5
4
9
5
0
.
0
1
7
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
1
Introduction
Decision making refers to the cognitive and neural mechanisms underlying processes that generate
choices. In our daily life, the processes of decision making are ubiquitous. Decision making has been a
major focus in the neuroscience community because it bridges sensory, motor, and executive functions.
A well characterized decision making paradigm is that of "evidence accumulation" or "evidence integra-
tion" referring to the process by which the subject gradually processes evidence for or against different
choices until making a well defined choice. Evidence accumulation is thought to underlie many different
types of decisions from perceptual decisions (Brunton et al., 2013), to social decisions (Krajbich et al.,
2015), and to value based decisions (Basten et al., 2010).
Most behavioral studies to date have focused on evidence accumulation in stationary environments.
In the case of stationary environments, the normative behavioral strategy used is perfect integration
(Bogacz et al., 2006), which refers to equal weighting of all incoming evidence across time. However,
real world environments are complex and change over time.
In this case, a strategy based on per-
fect integration will be suboptimal due to the changing statistics of the environment. Crucially, in
a dynamic environment older observations may no longer reflect the current state of the world, and
an observer needs to modify their inference processes to discount older evidence. Previous studies
have demonstrated that humans can modify the timescales of evidence integration, adopting "leaky"
integration when beneficial (Ossmy et al., 2013; Glaze et al., 2015). This observation opens many
questions related to why and how subjects might alter their integration timescales. To answer "why"
or normative questions, one would ideally like to develop a model that can be directly compared to the
standard evidence accumulation models used in the decision making literature. Two recent studies have
developed this connection to drift-diffusion models, and examined evidence accumulation in dynamic
environments either in humans (Glaze et al., 2015; Gold and Stocker, 2017) or in ideal observer models
(Veliz-Cuba et al., 2016). Animal models of behavior facilitate investigation of "how" or mechanistic
questions, by allowing measurement and perturbation of neural circuits. Here, we demonstrate that rats
are capable of adopting the optimal integration timescale predicted by the recently developed modeling
framework (Veliz-Cuba et al., 2016), and we furthermore show that they can dynamically modulate
their integration timescale according to changing environmental statistics.
In the present study, we extend a previously published pulse-based accumulation of evidence task
the "Poisson clicks task" (Brunton et al., 2013; Erlich et al., 2015; Hanks et al., 2015) to a dynamic
environment. We refer to our task as the "Dynamic clicks task". We extend results from the literature
(Veliz-Cuba et al., 2016) to develop the optimal inference process for our task. The ideal observer
is closely related to the "drift-diffusion model" used widely in the decision making literature (Bogacz
2
et al., 2006; Ratcliff and McKoon, 2008). The primary difference is that, in addition to integrating
sensory evidence, the ideal observer discounts accumulated evidence at a rate proportional to the
volatility of the environment, and the reliability of each evidence pulse. The reliability of each pulse
is determined by the stimulus statistics (e.g., the pulse rates), as well as noise in the subject's sensory
transduction process. While the exact origin of sensory noise is unclear, quantitative modeling can
separate sensory noise from other types of noise (Brunton et al., 2013). Here, we use sensory noise to
refer to noise that scales with the amount of evidence. The role of sensory noise in decision making
processes is a relatively unexplored area. Studies in the literature are beginning to document under
what circumstances subjects modify their behavior based on noise in the sensory evidence (Gureckis
and Love, 2009; Zylberberg et al., 2016).
Using high-throughput behavioral training, we trained rats to perform this task. With a combina-
tion of quantitative methods, we find that rats' adaptation to the dynamic environment is such that
they adopt the optimal timescale for evidence accumulation. Our findings establish rats as an adequate
animal model for evidence accumulation in a dynamic environment. Training rodents on state of the art
cognitive tasks opens up the opportunity to understand the neuronal mechanisms underlying complex
behavior. Rodents can be trained in a high throughput manner, are amenable to genetic manipulation,
are accessible to electrophysiological and optogenetic manipulations, and a large number of experimen-
tal subjects can be used. Finally, the dynamic clicks task opens up the opportunity to study the neural
underpinnings of evidence integration in a dynamic environment as this task gives the experimentalist
a unique quantitative handle over the integration timescale of the animals.
Results
A dynamic decision making task
We developed a decision making task that requires accumulating noisy evidence in order to infer a state
that is hidden, and dynamic. Rats were trained to infer, at any moment during the course of a trial,
which of two states the environment was in at that moment. These could be either a state in which
randomly-timed auditory clicks were played from a left-speaker at a high rate and right speaker clicks
were played at a low rate, or its inverse (low rate on the left, high rate on the right). In more detail,
in each trial of our task, we first illuminate a center light inside an automated operant chamber, to
indicate that the rat may start the trial by nose-poking into the center port. Once the rat enters the
center port, auditory clicks play from speakers positioned on the left and right sides of the rat. The
auditory clicks are generated from independent Poisson processes. Importantly, the left and right side
Poisson rate parameters are dependent on a hidden state that changes dynamically during the course
3
Figure 1: Dynamic Clicks Task structure and example trial. (A) Schematic of task events and
timing. A center light illuminates indicating the rat may initiate a trial by poking its nose into a
center port. Auditory clicks are generated from state-dependent Poisson processes (the two states are
schematized by light green and light blue backgrounds) and played concurrently from left and right
speakers. The hidden state toggles between two states according to a telegraph process with hazard
rate h. When the auditory clicks end, and the center light turns off, the rats must infer which of the
two states the trial ended in and report their decision by poking into one of two reward ports. Trials
have random durations so the rat must be prepared to answer at all time points. (B) An example
trial illustrates features of the task. The hidden state transitions randomly, and the auditory clicks are
generated accordingly. The optimal inference process (black line; see text for its derivation) accumulates
clicks, and discounts accumulated evidence proportionally to the volatility of the environment and click
statistics. For the optimal process, a choice is generated at the end of the trial according to whether
the optimal inference variable is above or below 0.
4
Variable stimulus durationrat "fixates" in centerState changeshazard rate "h"State 1 - Go Right2 Hz / 38 Hz2 1State 2 - Go Left 38 Hz / 2 Hzr / r1 2leftrightrat infers final statePoisson clicksPoisson clicksCenter LEDNose in center portNose in side portWater valvePoisson clicks playL/R responseAstate211accumulatedevidence "a"00.20.40.60.81-505inferred state changenonlineardiscountingRLgo rightgo leftBr / rtimevariable stimulus duration(0.5 - 2 s) of each trial. This is in sharp contrast to previous studies where the Poisson click rates are constant
for the duration of each trial (Brunton et al., 2013; Erlich et al., 2015; Hanks et al., 2015). Within
each trial, the dynamic environment is in one of two hidden states S1, and S2, each of which has an
associated left and right click generation rate (S1: rates r1
L and r1
R, respectively; S2: rates r2
L and r2
R).
In this study S1 and S2 were symmetric (r1
R = r2
L = high rate r1 and r2
R = r1
L = low rate r2). Each
trial starts with equal probability in one of the two states, and switches stochastically between them at
a fixed "hazard rate" h. On each time step, the switch probability is given by h∆t, (with ∆t kept small
enough that h∆t << 1). At the end of the stimulus period, the auditory clicks end, and the center
light turns off, indicating the rat must make a left or right choice by entering one of the side reward
ports. The rat is rewarded with a water drop for correctly inferring the hidden state at the end of the
stimulus period (if S1, go right; if S2, go left). The stimulus period duration is variable on each trial
(0.5 − 2 seconds), so the rat must be prepared to infer the current hidden state at all times. Figure
1 shows a schematic of task events, as well as an example trial. Rats trained every day, performing
150-1000 self-paced trials per day.
Optimal inference in a dynamic environment
Here we derive the optimal procedure for inferring the hidden state. Optimality, in this setting, refers
to reward maximizing. Given that each trial's duration is imposed by the experimenter and thus fixed
to the rat, maximizing reward is equivalent to maximizing accuracy (Bogacz et al., 2006). We build on
results from Veliz-Cuba et al. 2016, but a basic outline is repeated here for continuity. Mathematical
details can be found in the supplementary materials.
Before diving into the derivation, it is worth building some intuition. Because the hidden state is
dynamic, auditory clicks heard at the start of the trial are unlikely to be informative of the current
state. However, because state transitions are hidden, an observer doesn't know how far back in time
observations are still informative of the current state. Our derivation derives the optimal weighting of
older evidence. We first consider observations in discrete timesteps of short duration ∆t. Within each
timestep, a momentary evidence sample is generated. This sample is either a click on the left, a click
on the right, no clicks, or a click on both sides (we will consider ∆t small enough that r1∆t << 1 and
r2∆t << 1 so that multiple clicks are not generated within one timestep).
Following Veliz-Cuba et al. 2016, the probability of being in State 1 at time t, given all observed
samples up to time t:
P(cid:0)S11...t
(cid:1) ∝ P (tS1)(cid:0)(1 − h∆t) P(cid:0)S11...t−1
(cid:1) + h∆tP(cid:0)S21...t−1
(cid:1)(cid:1) .
(1)
5
We can interpret this equation as the probability of being in State 1 given all observed evidence up
to time t (P(cid:0)S11...t
the probability of remaining in the same state from the last time step ((1 − h∆t) P(cid:0)S11...t−1
the probability of changing states after the last time step (h∆tP(cid:0)S21...t−1
(cid:1)) is proportional to the probability of observing the evidence sample at time t
(cid:1)) and
given State 1 (P (tS1)) times the independent probability that we were in State 1 given evidence from
timesteps 1 . . . t − 1 (P (S11...t−1)). This second term is decomposed into two terms which depend on
(cid:1)).
Combining the probability of each state into a ratio, we can write the posterior probability ratio
(Rt) of the current state given all previous evidence samples 1...t:
Rt =
P (S11...t)
P (S21...t)
P (tS1)
P (tS2)
=
(cid:18) (1 − h∆t) Rt−1 + h∆t
(h∆t) Rt−1 + 1 − h∆t
(cid:19)
.
(2)
Observe that in a static environment (h = 0), the term on the far right simplifies to Rt−1 and (2) becomes
the statistical test known as the Sequential Probability Ratio Test (SPRT) (Wald, 1945; Barnard, 1946;
Bogacz et al., 2006). A recent study demonstrated that monkeys could accurately perform a literal
instantiation of the SPRT (Kira et al., 2015). When h (cid:54)= 0, the more complicated expression reflects the
fact that previous evidence samples might no longer be informative of the current state, in a manner
proportional to the environmental volatility h.
In order to compare (2) to standard decision making models like the drift-diffusion model (DDM)
we will transform the expression into a differential equation. We can accomplish this by taking the
logarithm of (2), then substituting a = log (R), and finally taking the limit of ∆t goes to 0 (See
Veliz-Cuba et al. 2016 and supplementary materials for details):
(cid:19)
(cid:18) P (tS1)
P (tS2)
− 2h sinh (a) dt.
(3)
(cid:16)
da = log
(cid:16) P (S11...t)
(cid:17)(cid:17)
(cid:16) P (tS1)
P (S21...t)
(cid:17)
This differential equation describes the evolution of the log-probability ratio of being in each of the
two hidden states
a = log
: a > 0 indicates more evidence for S1, while a < 0 indicates
more evidence for S2. Momentary evidence samples t are incorporated into the log-probability ratio
). The previously accumulated evidence is forgotten by a
through the evidence term (log
nonlinear discounting term (−2h sinh (a)) (See Fig 2C). The evidence discounting reduces the effect of
P (tS2)
older evidence, weighting recent evidence more. This discounting reflects the fact that older evidence
may no longer be informative of the current state of the environment. In a static environment (h = 0),
the discounting term is eliminated, and the ideal observer perfectly integrates the momentary evidence
samples. In analysis of the static decision making models, the evidence term is commonly approximated
by its expectation (drift) and variance (diffusion), transforming (3) into the Drift-Diffusion Model
6
(DDM) for decision making (Bogacz et al., 2006).
From this point on our derivation departs from existing results in the literature. In order to develop a
deeper understanding of the optimal inference on our task, we will evaluate the evidence term. Because
of the discrete nature of the Poisson evidence, this term can be precisely evaluated for each evidence
sample in a way that is not possible in other decision making tasks.
In a small sample window of
duration ∆t, the probability of a Poisson event is r∆t, where r is the parameter of the Poisson process
(provided r∆t << 1). In our task a momentary sample t is the result of two independent Poisson
processes and can take on four possible values: a click on both sides, a click on the right, a click on the
left, or no clicks. Evaluating the evidence term for these four conditions:
A click on both sides
P (tS1)
P (tS2)
log
= log
P(cid:0)click-RS1(cid:1) P(cid:0)click-LS1(cid:1)
P (click-RS2) P (click-LS2)
= log
(r1∆t) (r2∆t)
(r2∆t) (r1∆t)
= 0.
(4)
No clicks
P (tS1)
P (tS2)
log
= log
P(cid:0)no-click-RS1(cid:1) P(cid:0)no-click-LS1(cid:1)
P (no-click-RS2) P (no-click-LS2)
= log
(1 − r1∆t)(1 − r2∆t)
(1 − r2∆t)(1 − r1∆t)
= 0.
(5)
A click on the right
P (tS1)
P (tS2)
log
= log
P(cid:0)click-RS1(cid:1) P(cid:0)no-click-LS1(cid:1)
P (click-RS2) P (no-click-LS2)
= log
(r1∆t)(1 − r2∆t)
(r2∆t)(1 − r1∆t)
≡ +κ (r1, r2) .
(6)
A click on the left
P (tS1)
P (tS2)
log
= log
P(cid:0)no-click-RS1(cid:1) P(cid:0)click-LS1(cid:1)
P (no-click-RS2) P (click-LS2)
= log
(1 − r1∆t)(r2∆t)
(1 − r2∆t)(r1∆t)
≡ −κ (r1, r2) .
(7)
We define the function κ(r1, r2) to be the increase in the log-probability ratio from the arrival of a
single click on the right, given click rates r1, r2. The function κ tells us how reliably each click indicates
the hidden state. This is easily seen when letting ∆t → 0, so κ → log r1
. If the click rates r1 and r2
r2
are very similar (so κ is small) then we expect many distractor clicks (clicks from the smaller click rate
that do not indicate the correct state), so an individual click tells us little about the underlying state.
On the other hand, if the click rates are very different (so κ is large) then we expect very few distractor
clicks, so an individual click very reliably informs the current state. In the limit of one of the click rates
going to zero: κ → ∞, and a single click tells us the current state with absolute certainty. In our task,
the two click rates r1 and r2 always sum to 40 hz. Figure 2A shows κ as a function of the click rates.
7
Re-writing the log-evidence term in (3) in terms of κ and using δL/R,t to represent the left/right
click times, we can summarize across all four conditions:
da = κ (r1, r2) (δR,t − δL,t) − 2h sinh(a)dt.
(8)
We can then rescale equation (8) by κ, let a = log(R)
κ
, to put our evidence accumulation equation in
units of clicks:
da = δR,t − δL,t − 2h
κ
sinh(κa)dt.
(9)
Here δL/R,t are trains of delta functions at the times of the left and right clicks. Equation (9) has
a simple interpretation, sensory clicks are integrated (δR,t − δL,t), while accumulated evidence is dis-
counted (- 2h
κ sinh(κa)) proportionally to the volatility of the environment (h), and the reliability of
each click (κ). This interpretation also allows for a simple assay of behavior: do rats adopt the optimal
discounting timescale? We will present two quantitative methods for measuring the rats discounting
timescales. However, before examining rat behavior, we need to examine the impact of sensory noise
on optimal behavior.
Sensory noise decreases click reliability
The function κ (r1, r2) tells us how reliably each click indicates the underlying state as a function of
the click generation rates r1 and r2. The computation above of κ assumes that each click is detected
and correctly localized as either a left or right click with perfect accuracy. Previous studies using
pulse-based evidence demonstrate that rats have significant sensory noise (Brunton et al., 2013; Scott
et al., 2015). The term sensory noise in the context of these studies refers to sources of errors that scale
with the number of pulses of evidence. Sensory noise was measured by fitting parametric models that
included a parameter for how much uncertainty in the accumulation variable was increased due to each
pulse of evidence. The exact biological origin of this noise remains unclear. It could arise from sensory
processing errors, or from disruption of coding in the putative integration circuit at the moment of
pulse arrival. Regardless of its origins, sensory noise is a significant component of rodent behavior.
We will now show that sensory noise decreases how reliably each click indicates the underlying state.
While sensory noise can be modeled in many ways, primarily the mislocalization of clicks changes the
click reliability. We analyze the cases of Gaussian noise on the click amplitudes and missing clicks,
and provide a general argument for mislocalization in the supplementary materials. Mislocalization
refers to how often clicks are incorrectly localized to the other speaker (hearing a click from the left and
8
Figure 2: Optimal discounting rates depends on click reliability and can be well-
approximated by linear discounting (A) The reliability κ of each click depends on the Poisson
click rates r1 and r2. If the click rates are very similar, each click is not very informative about the
underlying state. Black dot shows the rates used in the study. (B) The reliability of each click also
depends on how consistently each click can be correctly localized to the side that generated it. At 50%
mislocalization each click contains no information about the current state, so κ = 0. The light pink
dot is the average level of sensory noise reported in Brunton 2013. The grey dot is half of the sensory
noise in Brunton 2013. (C) Discounting functions for the three sensory noise levels in B (same colors).
Increasing sensory noise causes the discounting functions to weaken. Horizontal lines show average
clks/sec in each of the two states. (D) Histogram of changes of mind produced by the optimal inference
equation. Timing is relative to the last change in the hidden state. (Black) Inference without sensory
noise, (pink) inference with average rat level of sensory noise. (E) The optimal nonlinear discounting
function can be approximated by a linear discounting function. If the linear discounting function is
tuned appropriately, accuracy is close to the full nonlinear function. (F) Comparison between optimal
nonlinear discounting function (blue) and the best linear approximation (black), in terms of average
accuracy for different noise levels. The best linear approximation is effectively equivalent. Arrow indi-
cates parameter values used in panel D. (G) The best linear discounting rate λ as a function of sensory
noise. Increasing sensory noise decreases the discounting rate. The best linear function is found nu-
merically on a set of 30k trials, which produces some variability for different noise levels. Pink dot
indicates average rat sensory noise.
9
-4-202-4Accumulation value, a (clks)-50050Evidence discounting (clks/s)01020304050Linear discounting ( )6065707580Accuracy %Enonlinear theorylinear agent2025303540Larger click rate0123456Click reliability (K)ACState 1 click rateState 2 click rate00.51Click mislocalization probability, n-4-2024Click reliability (K)Baverage ratsensory noiseno sensory noise00.10.20.30.4Clickmislocalizationprobability,n051015202530Optimal linear discounting ( )00.10.20.30.4Click mislocalization probability, n020406080100Accuracy %Fnonlinear theorybest linear agentDGClick ReliabilityOptimal InferenceLinear Approx.00.10.20.30.4Time from generative state change (s)05101520% of changes of mindDTheory Summary( )best linearaccumulationdiscounting assigning it to the right). For intuition, consider that if a rat could never tell whether a click was played
from the right or left then each click would never indicate any information about the underlying state.
We can again evaluate the log-evidence term, this time including the probability of click mislocalization
(n):
A click on the right
(r1∆t)(1 − n)(1 − r2∆t) + (1 − r1∆t)(r2∆t)(n)
(r2∆t)(1 − n)(1 − r1∆t) + (1 − r2∆t)(r1∆t)(n)
log
= +κ (r1, r2, n) .
(10)
A click on the left
(r2∆t)(1 − n)(1 − r1∆t) + (1 − r2∆t)(r1∆t)(n)
(r1∆t)(1 − n)(1 − r2∆t) + (1 − r1∆t)(r2∆t)(n)
log
= −κ (r1, r2, n) .
(11)
The terms for no clicks, or clicks on both sides evaluate to 0. As in the case with no sensory noise, the
log-evidence is either 0, or has value κ. We can simplify the expression for κ by letting ∆t → 0:
κ(r1, r2, n) = log
r1(1 − n) + r2n
r2(1 − n) + r1n
.
(12)
Sensory noise decreases how reliably each click informs the underlying state in the trial, increasing n
decreases κ. If n = 0, we recover the original κ derived without noise. If n = 0.5, then each click is
essential heard on a random side, and therefore contains no information so kappa = 0. If n = 1, then
we simply flip the sign of all clicks.
Previous studies using the same auditory clicks have shown that rats have significant sensory noise.
Figure 2B shows κ against n, and highlights the average sensory noise, and corresponding κ, found in
a previous study (Brunton et al., 2013).
Lower click reliability requires longer integration timescales
The discounting term of equation (9) has κ in the denominator as well as the argument of the sinh term.
As a result, it is not clear how decreasing the click reliability κ changes the behavior of the optimal
inference agent. To gain insight, consider that if evidence is very reliable, accurate decisions can be
made by only using a few clicks from a small time window. However, if evidence is unreliable, a longer
time window must be used to average out unreliable clicks. This intuition is confirmed by plotting
the discounting function for a variety of evidence reliability values (Figure 2C). Decreasing reliability
weakens the evidence discounting term creating longer integration timescales. See the supplementary
materials for more details.
10
Evidence discounting leads to changes of mind
The optimal inference equation attempts to predict the hidden state. As the hidden state dynamically
transitions, we expect the inference process to track, albeit imperfectly, the dynamic transitions. From
the perspective of a subject this dynamic tracking leads to changes of mind in the upcoming choice.
Through the optimal inference process we can predict the timing of changes of mind by looking for
times when the sign of the inference process changes (sign(a)). The presence of sensory noise slows the
integration timescale, and thus slows the timing of changes of mind. Figure 2D shows the predicting
timing of changes of mind with and without sensory noise.
Linear approximation to nonlinear discounting function is very accurate
The full nonlinear discounting function (− 2h
κ sinh (κa)), is complicated. In order to aid our analysis of
rat behavior, we will consider a linear approximation to the discounting function (−λa), where λ gives
the discounting rate. There are many possible linear approximations with different slopes. A linear
approximation using the slope of sinh at the origin will fail to capture the strong discounting farther
from the origin. We found the best linear approximation numerically.
Figure 2E shows, for a particular noise level and click rates, the accuracy of a range of linear
discounting agents against the full nonlinear agent. If λ is tuned correctly, the linear agent accuracy
is very close to the full nonlinear function. We find this to be true across a wide range of noise values
(Figure 2F). While the optimal linear strength at each noise level changes (Figure 2G), the accuracy is
always very close to that of the full nonlinear theory. It is important to note that a linear approximation
in general will not always be close in accuracy to the full nonlinear theory, but for our specific click
rate parameters it is an accurate approximation. See Veliz-Cuba et al. 2016 for examples of evidence
statistics for which the linear approximation does not fit as well.
Given that a linear discounting function matches the accuracy of the full nonlinear model, we will
analyze rat evidence discounting behavior by looking for the appropriate discounting rate or equivalently
the appropriate integration timescale. Specifically, we will compare the rat behavior to this linear
discounting equation:
da = δR,t − δL,t − λadt,
(13)
where λ is the discounting rate and 1
λ is the integration timescale. We did not examine whether rats
demonstrate nonlinear evidence discounting because the linear approximation in our task is effectively
indistinguishable from the full nonlinear theory.
11
Figure 3: Rats discount evidence. (A) Reverse correlation curves for an example rat reveals how
clicks at each time point influence the rat's decision. (B) Reverse correlation curves for 14 rats. Error
bars are omitted for clarity. (C) Reverse correlation curves for a range of simulated linear discounting
agents. Black to white lines indicate increasing discounting rates (λ). Only the reverse correlation curve
for the right choice are shown for clarity. Each curve was fit with an exponential function (example
red). The fit parameters are used in part D. (D) Exponential fit to each discounting agent recovers the
generative linear discounting rate. Example in part C show with red dot.
Psychophysical reverse correlation reveals the integration timescale
Psychophysical reverse correlation is a commonly used statistical method to find what aspects of a
behavioral stimulus influence a subject's choice. Here we use reverse correlation to find the integration
timescale used by the rats. We then normalized the reverse correlation curve to have an area under
the curve equal to one. This step lets the curves be interpreted in units of effective weight at each
time point. A flat reverse correlation curve indicates even weighting of evidence across all time points.
Previous studies in a static environment find rats with flat reverse correlation curves (Brunton et al.,
2013; Hanks et al., 2015; Erlich et al., 2015). Figure 3A shows the reverse correlation for an example
rat in a dynamic environment. The stimulus earlier in the trial is weighted less than the stimulus at
the end of the trial indicating evidence discounting. Figure 3B shows the mean reverse correlations
12
-0.5-0.4-0.3-0.2-0.1time from end of trial (s)-8-6-4-202468relative weight-0.5-0.4-0.3-0.2-0.1time from end of trial (s)0510152025relative weight-0.5-0.4-0.3-0.2-0.1time from end of trial (s)-8-6-4-202468relative weight0 25exponential fitACDBRat H033right choiceleft choice14 ratssimulationsimulation Figure 4: Rats optimally discount evidence. (A) Example reverse correlation curve for one rat,
and the reverse correlation curve from the optimal inference agent with the average rat sensory noise.
The optimal inference agent was simulated on the same trials the rat performed. (B) Quantification
of discounting timescales. When factoring average sensory noise, the rats adopt the optimal timescale.
The variability in optimal discounting rates is a result of measuring the reverse correlation curves on a
different set of trials each rat actually performed.
for all rats in the study. Figure 3C shows the reverse correlation curves from a family of linear dis-
counting agents (da = δR − δL − λadt), with λ ranging from 0 to 30. The curves were generated from
a synthetic dataset of 20,000 trials. The weaker the discounting rate, the flatter the reverse correla-
tion curves. To quantify the discounting timescale from the reverse correlation curves, an exponential
function ebt was fit to each curve. The parameter b reliably recovers the discounting rate λ (Figure 3D).
Rats adapt to the optimal timescale
To compare each rat's evidence discounting timescale to the optimal inference equation, we simulated
the optimal inference agent on the trials each rat experienced. We then computed the reverse correlation
curves for both the rats and the optimal agent (Figure 4A). To quantitatively compare timescales, we
then fit an exponential function to each of the reverse correlation curves. Rat behavior was compared
with two optimal agents. The first optimal agent assumes no sensory noise; while the second agent uses
the optimal timescale given the average level of sensory noise across rats reported in Brunton et al. 2013
(Figure 4B). When the average level of sensory noise is taken into account, the rats match the optimal
timescale. The reverse correlation analysis shows that rats are close to optimal given the average level
of sensory noise in a separate cohort of rats.
A quantitative behavioral model captures rat behavior
In order to extend our analysis to examine individual variations in noise level and integration timescales,
we fit a behavioral accumulation of evidence model from the literature to each rat (Brunton et al., 2013;
13
-0.5-0.4-0.3-0.2-0.1time from end of trial (s)-8-6-4-202468relative weightABRat H033rat right choicerat left choiceoptimal given avg. noiseOptimal given no noise (n = 0)Optimal givenavg. noise (n = .35) Hanks et al., 2015; Erlich et al., 2015). This model generates a moment-by-moment estimate of a latent
accumulation variable. The dynamical equations for the model are given by:
da = (δR,t · ηR · C − δL,t · ηL · C) dt − λadt + σadW,
dC
dt
+ (φ − 1) C (δR,t + δL, t) .
1 − C
τφ
=
(14)
(15)
At each moment in a trial, the model generates a distribution of possible accumulation values P (at, δR, δL).
In addition to the click integration and linear discounting that was present in our normative theory,
this model also parameterizes many possible sources of noise. Each click has multiplicative Gaussian
sensory noise, ηL/R = N(cid:0)1, σ2
s
(cid:1). In addition to the sensory noise, each click is also filtered through
an adaptation process, C. The adaptation process is parameterized by the adaptation strength φ, and
a adaptation time constant τφ. If φ > 1 the model has facilitation of sequential clicks, and if φ < 1
the model has depression of sequential clicks. The accumulation variable a also undergoes constant
additive Gaussian noise σa. Finally, the initial distribution of a has some initial variance given by σi.
See Brunton et al. 2013 for details on the development and evaluation of this model. One major modi-
fication to the model from previous studies is the removal of the sticky bounds B, which are especially
detrimental to subject performance given the dynamic nature of the task. This model is a powerful tool
for the description of behavior on this task because of its flexibility at characterizing many different
behavioral strategies (Brunton et al., 2013; Hanks et al., 2015; Erlich et al., 2015).
The model was fit to individual rats by maximizing the likelihood of observing the rat's choice
on each trial. To evaluate the model, we can compare the reverse correlation curves from the model
and subject. Figure 5A shows the comparison for an example rat, showing that the model captures
the timescale of evidence discounting seen by the reverse correlation analysis. See the supplemental
materials for residual error plots for each rat.
In order to analyze the model fits we can examine the best fit parameters for each rat, and compare
them to rats trained on the static version of the task (from Brunton et al. 2013). The evidence dis-
counting strength parameter λ shows a striking difference between the two rat populations (Figure 5B).
In the static task, the rats have small discounting rates indicating an integration timescale comparable
to the longest trial the rats experienced (Brunton et al., 2013; Hanks et al., 2015; Erlich et al., 2015).
In the dynamic task, the rats have strong evidence discounting, consistent with the reverse correlation
analysis. See the supplemental materials for a comparison of other model parameters.
To assess whether rats individually calibrate their discounting timescales to their level of sensory
noise, we estimate the sensory noise level from the model parameters. We estimated the click mislo-
calization probability by taking the average level of adaptation, and the Gaussian distributed sensory
14
Figure 5: Quantitative model captures rat behavior, and shows optimal discounting (A)
Example reverse correlation curves generated by the quantitative model compared with a rat's behavior.
(B) Best fitting discounting rates for rats trained on the dynamic task (orange), and for rats trained in a
static environment (blue, data and fits from Brunton, 2013 ). (C) Each rat's noise level and discounting
rate compared to the optimal trade-off. (D) Each rat's evidence discounting parameter compared to
the accuracy maximizing discounting level. (E) The average accuracy for the model fit to each rat's
behavior, and optimized to maximize accuracy.
noise. Figure 5C shows each rat's fit compared to the numerically obtained optimal discounting lev-
els from Figure 2F. The rats appear to have slightly larger discounting rates than predicted by the
normative theory. The deviation from the normative theory may be due to other parameters in the
behavioral model, the fact that we considered only the average level of sensory adaptation, or other
factors. In order to more directly examine whether the rats were adopting the optimal timescale, we
asked whether the rat's discounting rates were constrained by the other model parameters. For each
rat, we took the best fitting model parameters, and froze all parameters except the discounting rate
parameter λ. Then, we found the value of λ that maximized accuracy on the trials each rat performed.
Note this optimization did not ask to maximize the similarity to the rat's behavior. We found that
given the other model parameters, the accuracy maximizing discounting level was very close to the
rat's discounting level (Figure 5D) meaning that different sources of noise parametrized in the model
highly constrain the rats' discounting rates. Further, while the discounting rates changed slightly, the
improvement in total trial accuracy changed even less. For all rats, optimizing the discounting rate
increased the total accuracy of the model by less than 1% (Figure 5E). Taken together these results
suggest that rats discount evidence at the optimal level given several sources of noise.
15
static task(n=19 from Brunton, 2013)dynamic task (n=14)fit to ratoptimized0.650.70.750.80.85Avg. P(hit)00.10.20.30.4rat noise level(n)051015202530discounting rate (clks/s)-0.5-0.4-0.3-0.2-0.1time from end of trial (s)-6-4-20246relative weightoptimal linearmodel fitCDABRat H033model fitrat left choicerat right choiceE Figure 6: Rats adapt to changing environmental conditions. Three rats were moved from a
0.5 hz hazard rate to 0 hz, then back to 0.5 hz. Rats stayed in each environment for multiple daily
training sessions, with a minimum of 25 sessions. (Top) Schematic outlining the experimental design.
(A-C) Reverse correlation curves for an example rat in a (A) 0.5 Hz hazard rate environment before
switching, (B) 0 Hz environment, and (C) 0.5 Hz environment after switching. (D) Quantification of
the integration timescales before, during, and after the switch for all rats.
Individual rats in different environments
Previous studies have demonstrated that rats can optimally integrate evidence in a static environment
(Brunton 2013). Here we have demonstrated that rats can optimally integrate and discount evidence in
a dynamic environment. In order to demonstrate the ability of individual rats to adapt their timescales
in different environments, we moved three rats from a dynamic environment (h = 0.5 Hz) to a static
environment (h = 0 Hz), and then back. The rats trained in each environment for many daily sessions
(minimum 25 sessions). In each environment, we quantified their behavior using reverse correlation
methods. Figure 6A-C show the reverse correlation curves for an example rat as the rat transitioned
between environments with different statistics. Figure 6D shows the integration timescales for each rat
in each environment. Rats rapidly adjusted their timescales when moving into a static environment, a
session-by-session estimate is in the supplementary materials Figure 23. Consistent with our normative
theory, rats in the h = 0.5 Hz environment show discounting rates approximately half the strength of
rats in the h = 1 Hz environment. We find rats can dynamically adjust their integration behavior to
match their environments.
Discussion
We have developed a pulse-based auditory decision making task in a dynamic environment. Using a
high-throughput automated rat training, we trained rats to accumulate and discount evidence in a dy-
16
-0.4-0.3-0.2-0.1-505relative weight-0.4-0.3-0.2-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weight0.500.5Hazard Rate (Hz)012345discounting rate (clks/s)-0.4-0.3-0.2-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightn = 3 rats0 HzHazard Rate 0.5 Hz 0.5 HzABCDtime from end of trial (s)Rat H046Rat H046Rat H046hazard ratepanelABC0.5 Hz0 Hzdaily sessions25+25+25+ namic environment. Extending results from the literature (Veliz-Cuba et al., 2016), we formalized the
optimal behavior on our task, which critically involves discounting evidence on a timescale proportional
to the environmental volatility and the reliability of each click. The reliability of each click depends on
the experimenter imposed click statistics, and each rat's sensory noise. We find that once sensory noise
is taken into account, the rats have timescales consistent with the optimal inference process. We used
quantitative modeling to investigate rat to rat variability, and to predict a moment-by-moment estimate
of the rats' accumulated evidence. Finally, we demonstrated rats can rapidly adjust their discounting
behavior and respectively their integration timescales in response to changing environmental statistics.
Our findings open new questions into complex rodent behavior and the underlying neural mechanisms
of decision making.
Previously accumulation of evidence has been studied in a static stationary environment . These
studies have given behavioral and neural insights into the ability of rats, monkeys, and humans to
optimally accumulate evidence over extended timescales (Brunton et al., 2013; Kira et al., 2015; Pur-
cell et al., 2010; Philiastides et al., 2011; Lee and Cummins, 2004; Kelly and O'Connell, 2013; Gold
and Shadlen, 2001). These studies have showed that rats or primates, like humans, can gradually
accumulate evidence for decision-making, and that their evidence accumulation process timescale is op-
timal. Quantitative modeling revealed that errors originated from sensory noise, not from the evidence
accumulation process. The optimal strategy in the stationary environment is perfect integration. A
natural extension of the static version of the task is a setting in which the environment changes with
some defined statistics and this what we aimed to do in our "dynamic clicks task". In the dynamics
clicks task, the optimal strategy involves discounting evidence at a rate proportional to the volatility
of the environment and the reliability of each evidence pulse. The behavioral quantitative modeling
builds on a study that derived ideal observer models for dynamic environments, including the two-state
environments considered here, and more complex environments (Veliz-Cuba et al., 2016). That study
analyzed the behavior of ideal agents with Gaussian distributed evidence samples. Our work builds
on their derivation of ideal behavior, and extends their analysis to discrete evidence. Importantly, our
analysis allowed us to separate evidence reliability into experimenter imposed stimulus statistics and
sensory noise. Moreover, our findings show that rats discounting rates are optimal only when factoring
in sensory noise. We have also shown that rats can switch back and forth between environments with
different volatilities thus providing for the first time a knob for the experimenter to control the subjects'
integration timescale.
On the other hand, a recent study examined human decision making in a dynamic environment
17
(Glaze et al., 2015). That study found that humans show nonlinear evidence discounting, but their dis-
counting rates did not match with the optimal inference. Incorporating models of human sensory noise
could explain deviations from optimality in their data. We did not examine whether rats demonstrate
nonlinear evidence discounting because the linear approximation in our task is effectively indistinguish-
able from the full nonlinear theory (Figure 2). Other studies in humans have also found that humans
perform leaky integration in dynamic environments (Ossmy et al., 2013).
The behavior presented here is distinct from previous tasks that have investigated decision making
over time. Cisek et al. 2009 developed an evidence accumulation task in which the amount of evidence
changes over the course of the trial. However, in that study the evidence is generated from a stationary
process and the optimal behavior is to perfectly integrate all evidence. This is in contrast to the present
study that examines conditions under which the optimal behavior is to discount old evidence.
In a separate line of work called bandit tasks, the subject gets reward or feedback on a timescale
slower than the dynamics of the environment (Iigaya et al., 2017; Miller et al., 2017). In bandit tasks,
the environment changes slowly with respect to each choice, and subjects get many opportunities for
reward and feedback before the environment changes. In the work presented here, the subjects must
perform inference without feedback while the dynamics of the environment are changing within the
course of one trial. Importantly, in our task the environmental state "resets" after each choice the rat
makes.
The dynamic accumulation of evidence task that we are presenting here should not also be confused
with the conventional change detection tasks, which have only a single change of mind. In our case, we
have many changes of mind that are happening stochastically. See Fig 2 in Veliz-Cuba et al. 2016 for
a detailed discussion on the relationship between these tasks.
It is very important to note that the term "evidence discounting" is different than "temporal
discounting" prominently used in the reinforcement learning literature. Temporal discounting is the
phenomenon in which the subjective value of some reward decreases in magnitude when the given reward
is delayed (Dayan and Abbott, 2005, pg.352). In our case, evidence discounting is the phenomenon in
which an agent discards evidence in order to infer state changes in the environment.
One benefit of rodent studies is the wide range of experimental tools available to investigate the
neural mechanisms underlying behavior. Our task will facilitate the investigation of two neural mech-
anisms. First, due to the dynamic nature of each trial, subject's change their mind often during each
trial allowing experimental measurement of changes of mind within one trial. Further, these changes of
mind are driven by internal estimates of accumulated evidence. Previous studies of rat decision making
have identified a cortical structure, the Frontal Orienting Fields (FOF) as a potential substrate for
18
upcoming choice memory (Erlich et al., 2011; Hanks et al., 2015; Erlich et al., 2015; Kopec et al., 2015;
Piet et al., 2017). Future work could investigate if and how the FOF tracks upcoming choice in a dy-
namic environment during changes of mind. It will also complement already existing neurophysiological
studies of changes of mind (Kiani et al., 2014; Peixoto et al., 2016)
Second, normative behavior in a dynamic environment requires tuning the timescale of evidence in-
tegration to the environmental volatility. There is a large body of experimental and theoretical studies
on neural integrators (Seung, 1996; Goldman, 2009; Aksay et al., 2007; Scott et al., 2017) that inves-
tigates how neural circuits potentially perform integration. Many possible neural circuit mechanisms
have been proposed, from random unstructured networks (Maass et al., 2002; Ganguli et al., 2008),
feed-forward syn-fire chains (Goldman, 2009), and recurrent structured networks of many forms (Seung,
1996; Druckmann and Chklovskii, 2012; Boerlin et al., 2013). The task developed here allows for ex-
perimental control of the putative neural integrator's timescale within the same subject. Measurement
of neural activity in different dynamic environments, and thus different integration timescales, may
shed light into which mechanisms are used in neural circuits for evidence integration. For instance, un-
structured networks, or feed-forward networks may re-tune themselves via adjusting read-out weights.
Networks that integrate via recurrent dynamics; however, would re-tune themselves via changes in those
recurrent dynamics. Alternatively, measurement of neural activity in different dynamic environments
may reveal fundamentally new mechanisms of evidence integration. For instance, Erlich et al. 2015
proposed multiple integration networks with different timescales to account for behavioral changes in
response to prefrontal cortex inactivations. Our task may allow further investigation into the structure
and dynamics of neural integrators.
Methods
Subjects
Animal use procedures were approved by the Princeton University Institutional Animal Care and Use
Committee and carried out in accordance with NIH standards. All subjects were adult male Long
Evans rats (Vendor: Taconic and Harlan, USA) placed on a controlled water schedule to motivate them
to work for a water reward.
Behavioral Training
We trained 14 rats on the dynamic clicks task (Figure 1). Rats went through several stages of an
automated training protocol. In the final stage, each trial began with an LED turning on in the center
nose port indicating to the rats to poke there to initiate a trial. Rats were required to keep their nose
19
in the center port (nose fixation) until the light turned off as a "go" signal. During center fixation,
auditory cues were played indicating the current hidden state. The duration of the fixation period (and
stimulus period) ranged from 0.5 to 2 seconds. After the go signal, rats were rewarded for entering
the side port corresponding to the hidden state at the end of the stimulus period. The hidden state
did not change after the go signal. A correct choice was rewarded with 24 microliters of water; while
an incorrect choice resulted in a punishment noise (spectral noise of 1 kHz for a 0.7 seconds duration).
The rats were put on a controlled water schedule where they receive at least 3% of their weight every
day. Rats trained each day in a training session on average 120 minutes in duration. Training sessions
were included for analysis if the overall accuracy rate exceeded 70%, the center-fixation violation rate
was below 25%, and the rat performed more than 50 trials. In order to prevent the rats from develop-
ing biases towards particular side ports an anti-biasing algorithm detected biases and probabilistically
generated trials with the correct answer on the non-favored side.
Linear discounting agents
To analyze the performance of linear discounting agents at varying levels of noise, we created synthetic
noisy-datasets. For each level of click noise, each click switched sides according to the noise level. On
each of these datasets, we numerically optimized the discounting level that maximized the accuracy of
predicting the hidden state at the end of the trial.
Psychophysical reverse correlation
The computation of the reverse correlation curves was very similar to methods previously reported
(Brunton et al., 2013; Hanks et al., 2015; Erlich et al., 2015). However, one additional step is included
to deal with the hidden state. The first step is to smooth the click trains on each trial with a causal
Gaussian filter (k(t)), this creates one smooth click rate for each trial. The filter had a standard
deviation of 5 msec.
ri(t) = δR,t ∗ k(t) − δL,t ∗ k(t)
(16)
Then, the smooth click rate on each trial was normalized by the expected click rate for that time step,
given the current state of the environment. This gives us the deviation (the excess click rate) from the
expected click rate for each trial.
ei(t) = ri(t) − (cid:104)r(t)Si(t)(cid:105)
(17)
20
Finally, we compute the choice triggered average of the excess click rate by averaging over trials based
on the rat's choice.
excess-rate(tchoice) = (cid:104)e(t)choice(cid:105)
(18)
The excess rate curves were then normalized to integrate to one. This was done to remove distorting
effects of a lapse rate, as well to make the curves more interpretable by putting the units into effective
weight of each click on choice. To quantify the timescale of the reverse correlation curves, we fit an
exponential of the form aebt to each curve. The parameter b is the discounting rate, while 1/b is the
integration timescale.
Behavioral Model
Previous studies using this behavioral accumulation of evidence model (Brunton et al., 2013) have
included sticky bounds which absorb probability mass when the accumulated evidence reaches a certain
threshold. We found this sticky bounds to be detrimental to high performance on our task, so we
removed them. The removal of the sticky bounds facilitates an analytical solution of the model. The
model assumes an initial distribution of accumulation values P (at = 0) = N(cid:0)µ0, σ2
(cid:1). At each moment
i
in the trial, the distribution of accumulation values P (at, δR, δL) is Gaussian distributed with mean
(µ) and variance (σ2) given by:
(δR,s · C (R(s)) − δL,s · C (L(s))) ds
µ(t) = µ0eλt +
µ(t) = µ0eλt +
σ2(t) = σ2
i eλt +
σ2(t) = σ2
i eλt +
eλ(t−R(i))C(R(i)) − #L(cid:88)
(cid:16)
(cid:16)
t(cid:90)
#R(cid:88)
e2λt − 1
(cid:17)
(cid:17)
+
0
e2λt − 1
+
i
eλ(t−L(i))C(L(i))
t(cid:90)
#R(cid:88)
0
i
σ2
a
2λ
σ2
a
2λ
(19)
(20)
(21)
(22)
s (δR,s · C (R(s)) − δL,s · C (L(s))) e2λtds
σ2
s C(R(i))e2λ(t−R(i)) +
σ2
s C(L(i))e2λ(t−L(i))
σ2
i
i
#L(cid:88)
Where #R is the number of right clicks on this trial up to time t, and R(i) is the time of the ith right
click. C(R(i)) tells us the effective adaptation for that clicks. For a detailed discussion of a similar
model, see Feng et al. 2009.
Given a distribution of accumulation values P (at, δR, δL) = N(cid:0)µ(t), σ2(t)(cid:1), and the bias parameter
21
B, we can compute the left and right choice probabilities by:
(cid:18)
1
2
P (go right) =
P (go left) = 1 − P (go right).
1 + erf
(cid:18)− (B − µ(t))
√
σ
2
(cid:19)(cid:19)
,
(23)
(24)
These choice probabilities are then distorted by the lapse rate, which parameterizes how often a rat
makes a random choice:. The model parameters θ were fit to each rat individually by maximizing the
likelihood function:
#trials(cid:89)
i
L =
P (rat's choice on trial iθ, δi
R, δi
L).
(25)
Additionally, a half-gaussian prior was put on the initial noise (σi) and accumulation noise parameters
(σa). Due to the presence of large discounting rates, these parameters are difficult to recover in syn-
thetic datasets. The priors were set to match the respective best fit values from Brunton et al. 2013.
The numerical optimization was performed in MATLAB. To estimate the uncertainty on the parameter
estimates, we used the inverse hessian matrix as a parameter covariance matrix (Daw, 2011). To com-
pute the hessian of the model, we used automatic differentiation to exactly compute the local curvature
(Revels et al., 2016).
Calculating noise level from model parameters
Given the model parameters (σ2
s , φ, and τφ), we computed the average level of sensory adaptation on
each click (cid:104)C(cid:105). Then, we computed what fraction of the probability mass would cross 0 to be registered
as a click on the other side.
(cid:32)
1 + erf
(cid:32) −(cid:104)C(cid:105)(cid:112)2σ2
s(cid:104)C(cid:105)
(cid:33)(cid:33)
.
n =
1
2
(26)
Acknowledgements
We thank all members of the Brody lab for technical assistance, and feedback throughout the project.
We thank Ben Scott, Diksha Gupta, Tim Hanks, and Christine Constantinople for detailed comments
on the manuscript. This work was supported in part by NIH grant 5-R01-MH108358
Author Contributions
22
AP:Task design, rat training, theoretical analysis, quantitative methods development and application.
AE: Task design, rat training, and advised during all aspects of the study. CB: advised during all
aspects of the study
23
Supplementary Materials
The supplementary materials contains extended figures and control analyses for several aspects of the
study:
1. Individual rat behavior and training
2. Optimal inference details and derivation
3. Sensory noise parameterization details and alternatives
4. Psychophysical reverse correlation details
5. Quantitative model details
Individual Rat Behavior
In this section we outline our rat training process, and then provide several model free analyses of
behavior for each rat individually. First, we include the psychometric curve with respect to the total
click difference on each trial. Second, we include the psychometric curve with respect to the optimal
inference process (assuming no sensory noise). Third, the chronometric plot shows rat accuracy with
respect to time since the last hidden state change. Fourth, the chronometric plot with respect to total
trial duration. Fifth, the reverse correlation curves with best fit exponential for each rat.
24
Training procedure details
The training process for the Dynamic Clicks task involves "classical" training during which the rats
learn to associate ports with rewards. The "classical" pipeline is the same as Duan et al. 2015. After
completing classical training, then rats then learn the standard Poisson clicks task as described in
Brunton et al. 2013. Finally, environmental state switching is introduced. The following tables outline
keep changes at each stage in the procedure. Rats typically spend a few days on classical, and about 6
weeks moving through the clicks training.
Classical Training:
Stage Name
1
2
3
learn left poking
learn right poking
learn center poke switching blocks
Dynamic Clicks Training:
Stage Name
1
grow nose in center 1
2 wait for good endpoints
3
grow nose in center 2
4 wait for good endpoints
5
add variable trial length
6 wait for good endpoints
h
0
0
0
0
0
0
γ
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
4
3.5
3.2
3
3
T ∆T
1
1
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
0
0
0
0
0.5
0.5
0.5
1.5
1.5
1.5
1.5
1.5
1.5
1
1
1
1
1
1
step hazard 1
1 Hz
increase variable trial length
add psychometrics 1
add psychometrics 2
add psychometrics 3
add psychometrics 4
7
9
10
11
12
13
14 final
Notes: h is the hazard rate between states. H is introduced in stage 9, increased in stage 10, and
is constant afterwards. Gamma (γ) is the log of the click rates. γ = 5 is the setting for endpoints,
which is extremely easy. T is the maximum duration of the stimulus period. ∆T is the variability in
stimulus period duration. If the trial length (T) is 2 seconds, and ∆T is 0.5, that means trials are 1.5
- 2 seconds in length.
25
Figure 7: Psychometric graph for all rats Each trial performed by the rat was binned by the total
click difference in the trial. The rat's average accuracy in each bin is shown (dots). A four parameter
logistic function is fit to the data with 95% confidence intervals (line).
26
Figure 8: Psychometric graph for all rats Each trial performed by the rat was binned by the total
click difference in the trial. The rat's average accuracy in each bin is shown (dots). A four parameter
logistic function is fit to the data with 95% confidence intervals (line).
27
Figure 9: Psychometric graph for all rats against ideal observer Each trial performed by the
rat was binned by the accumulation value (log-odds) of the ideal observer (ie, no sensory noise). The
rat's average accuracy in each bin is shown (dots). A four parameter logistic function is fit to the data
with 95% confidence intervals (line).
28
Figure 10: Psychometric graph for all rats against ideal observer Each trial performed by the
rat was binned by the accumulation value (log-odds) of the ideal observer (ie, no sensory noise). The
rat's average accuracy in each bin is shown (dots). A four parameter logistic function is fit to the data
with 95% confidence intervals (line).
29
Figure 11: Chronometric graph for all rats Each trial was binned by the amount of time since the
last change in the hidden environmental state. The average accuracy of each bin is shown.
30
Figure 12: Chronometric graph for all rats Each trial was binned by the amount of time since the
last change in the hidden environmental state. The average accuracy of each bin is shown.
31
Figure 13: Chronometric graph for all rats Each trial was binned by the total trial duration.
The average accuracy of each bin is shown. Most trials were drawn from the range (0.5 - 2) seconds;
however, some rats experience a small number of shorter trials, leading to greater uncertainty for those
durations.
32
Figure 14: Chronometric graph for all rats Each trial was binned by the total trial duration.
The average accuracy of each bin is shown. Most trials were drawn from the range (0.5 - 2) seconds;
however, some rats experience a small number of shorter trials, leading to greater uncertainty for those
durations.
33
Figure 15: Reverse Correlation for all rats Reverse Correlation curves for each rat (black), as well
as the best fit exponential discounting function (blue).
34
-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH033-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH037-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH038-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH039-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH040-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH043-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH045-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH058-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH061-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH065-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH066-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH067 Figure 16: Reverse Correlation for all rats Reverse Correlation curves for each rat (black), as well
as the best fit exponential discounting function (blue).
35
-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH083-0.5-0.3-0.1time from end of trial (s)-505relative weightH084 Optimal inference details
Derivation of optimal inference
Here we provide more detail on the derivation from equation (2) to equation (3). This derivation was
developed by Veliz-Cuba et al. 2016, see equations 3.2 and 3.3. However, we do not approximate the
evidence term into its first two moments, instead evaluating the evidence term. For this reason we
report the same derivation but halting at the intermediate step not shown in Veliz-Cuba et al. 2016.
Beginning with the evidence ratio, equation (2) in the present study, and equation 3.2 in Veliz-Cuba
(h∆t) eat−1 + 1 − h∆t
(cid:18) (1 − h∆t) + h∆te−at−1
(cid:18) (1 − h∆t) + h∆te−at−1
(cid:16)
(1 − h∆t) + h∆teat−1
te−at−1 − 1
(cid:19)
(cid:19)
(cid:17)(cid:17) − log
1 + h∆t
(cid:16)
,
,
+ log
+ log
+ log
(cid:16)
1 + h∆t
(cid:16)
(cid:17)(cid:17)
eat−1 − 1
Using the approximation log (1 + a) ≈ a, which is valid when a << 1. Here, h∆t << 1.
e−at−1 − 1
eat−1 − 1
,
(cid:17)
(cid:16)
(cid:16)
+ h∆t
+ h∆t
(cid:16)
(cid:17) − h∆t
(cid:17)
e−at−1 − eat−1
.
et al. 2016.
Rt =
P (S11...t)
P (S21...t)
P (tS1)
P (tS2)
=
(cid:18) (1 − h∆t) Rt−1 + h∆t
(h∆t) Rt−1 + 1 − h∆t
(cid:19)
.
Dividing each side by Rt−1
Rt
Rt−1
=
P (tS1)
P (tS2)
(cid:18) (1 − h∆t) Rt−1 + h∆t
(h∆t) Rt−1 + 1 − h∆t
(cid:19) 1
Rt−i
.
Now, define at = log (Rt), and take the logarithm of both sides:
(cid:19)
(cid:19)
(cid:19)
P (tS2)
(cid:18) P (tS1)
(cid:18) P (tS1)
(cid:18) P (tS1)
P (tS2)
P (tS2)
(cid:19)
(cid:19)
(cid:18) P (tS1)
(cid:18) P (tS1)
P (tS2)
P (tS2)
at − at−1 = log
∆at = log
∆at = log
∆at = log
∆at = log
Using sinh(x) = 1
2 (ex − e−x):
(cid:18) P (tS1)
P (tS2)
∆at = log
(cid:19)
− 2h∆t sinh (at−1) .
36
(27)
(28)
(29)
(30)
(31)
(32)
(33)
(34)
Here, we again use ∆t << 1 to justify replacing at−1 with at on the right hand side. Evaluating the
evidence term as derived in the main text, and rescaling κ:
∆at = δt,R − δt,L − 2h
κ
∆t sinh (κat) .
Taking the limit of ∆t → 0:
dat = δt,R − δt,L − 2h
κ
sinh (κat) dt.
(35)
(36)
Here we are making the assumption that the action of the auditory clicks happen instantaneously with
respect to the accumulation equation.
Decreasing click reliability lengthens integration timescales
We found that plotting the evidence discounting term with less reliable clicks (smaller κ) resulted in a
flatter curve, which corresponds to a longer integration timescale. To see this relationship more clearly
we can expand the discounting function in a taylor series around the origin:
f (x) ≈ f (a) +
f(cid:48)(a)
1!
2h
κ
sinh (κx) ≈ 2h
κ
sinh (0) +
2h
κ
κ
1!
(x − a) +
f(cid:48)(cid:48)(a)
2!
(x − a)2 +
cosh (κ · 0) (x − 0) +
f(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48)(a)
3!
κ2
2!
2h
κ
(x − a)3 + . . .
sinh (κ · 0) (x − 0)2
The even terms drop out, and we collect the odd terms:
sinh (κx) ≈ 2hx +
2h
κ
2hκ2
3!
x3 +
2hκ4
5!
x5 + . . .
(37)
(38)
(39)
We find that κ only appears with even power exponents in odd powers of x. Increasing κ will increase
the strength of the discounting function. Increasing the strength of the discounting function leads to
shorter integration timescales. In short, increasing κ shortens the integration timescale. Decreasing κ
lengthens the integration timescale.
37
Sensory noise parameterization details
The main analysis in the text derives optimal inference given sensory noise that is discrete, clicks are
either localized on one side or the other.
It is easy to imagine many other forms of sensory noise,
including Gaussian fluctuations in the click amplitude, or simply missing clicks. Here we demonstrate
by evaluating the log-evidence term that decreases in click reliability are primarily driven by click
mislocalization, not fluctuations in the perceived amplitude of the clicks, or missed clicks. Finally, we
provide a general argument for why only click mislocalization matters
Click reliability with Gaussian sensory noise
Consider Gaussian noise where the clicks played from the right/left are perceived with amplitude given
by N (±µ, σ2). Here we interpret clicks with positive amplitude as right clicks, and negative amplitude
as left clicks. Note that if σ2 is sufficiently large, clicks will be mislocalized.
To compute the reliability of an individual click with a specific amplitude fluctuation (a), we need
to compute the probability of a click generated on the right being observed with amplitude a: Pr(a), as
well as the probability of a click generated on the left being observed with amplitude a: Pl(a). Formally
we need to integrate the Gaussian probability density function over a small window centered at a.
a+(cid:90)
a+(cid:90)
a−
a−
Pr(a) =
Pl(a) =
κ (r1, r2, Pr, Pl) = log
1√
2πσ2
− (µ−s)2
e
2σ2 ds
2σ2 ds
− (−µ−s)2
e
1√
2πσ2
(r1∆t)Pr(1 − r2∆t) + (1 − r1∆t)(r2∆t)Pl
(r2∆t)Pr(1 − r1∆t) + (1 − r2∆t)(r1∆t)Pl
This expression for κ seems hard to interpret, but notice what happens if Pl = 0.
κ (r1, r2, Pr, 0) = log
(r1∆t)(1 − r2∆t)
(r2∆t)(1 − r1∆t)
= κ(r1, r2).
.
(40)
(41)
(42)
(43)
In this case, Pr drops out entirely, and we get the same value of κ as the no-noise case. This demonstrates
that click mislocalization is necessary for a decrease in click reliability.
Next, we will compare how the Gaussian click reliability scales with the rate of mislocalization. We
generated a dataset of trials where each click had an amplitude drawn from a Gaussian distribution. We
asked what was the accuracy of the nonlinear inference using the Gaussian click reliability derived above,
and what is the discounting rate of the best linear discounting agent? We refer to this as "quenched
38
Figure 17: Three Interpretations of Gaussian noise Numerically optimized discounting rates
for different noise amplitudes.
(Grey dots)
unquenched Gaussian noise of the form in equation (45). The unqueched fluctuations favor a larger
discounting rate.
(Black dots) Discrete noise, same points as Figure 2.
Gaussian noise," the meaning of quenched is explained below. We then considered a second dataset
where the Gaussian amplitudes were thresholded to either be ±1 reflecting whether the amplitude was
above or below 0. We refer to this as "discrete noise." We compute the click mislocalization probability
for corresponding to each Gaussian variance σ2 by:
(cid:18)
(cid:19)(cid:19)
(cid:18)
1√
2σ2
s
(44)
(cid:104)n(µ, σ2)(cid:105) = 1
2
µ + erf
Figure 17 shows the results of the comparison. The discrete noise has a slight decrease in accuracy,
and a slightly smaller discounting rate. The difference is due to clicks that weakly change sign. The
discrete noise doesn't distinguish between small and large amplitude clicks, where the quenched Gaus-
sian noise does. Importantly, in the noise regime we expect the rats, there is no difference between
these interpretations of sensory noise.
Unquenched Gaussian noise in the quantitative model
Gaussian noise subjects the clicks to large amplitude fluctuations in how they are perceived. Our
quantitative model handles these fluctuations slightly differently from the normative theory outlined
in the section above. First, observe that in the optimal inference theory, the evidence reliability term
quenches large amplitude fluctuations. Following the derivation in the section above, κ (r1, r2, Pr, Pl)
is bounded between ±κ (r1, r2), so the evidence added to the accumulation variable after each click is
bounded ("quenched") and not subjected to large amplitude fluctuations.
39
00.10.20.30.4Click mislocalization probability020406080100Accuracy %ABdiscrete noisequenched noiseunquenched noise Second, we asked whether the presence of large amplitude fluctuations of click amplitudes if they are
not quenched, would cause a linear approximation to favor a stronger evidence discounting in order to
damper the fluctuations. Specifically, we asked whether an evidence discounting agent with unquenched
Gaussian noise:
da = (δR,t − δL,t)N (1, σ2) − λadt,
(45)
would maximize accuracy with a larger λ than the same click mislocalization strength implemented as
quenched noise in the normative theory. Quenched noise as properly implemented in the normative
theory would look like:
da = (δR,t − δL,t) κ(cid:0)r1, r2,N (1, σ2)(cid:1) − λadt.
(46)
Figure 17 shows a comparison between quenched and unquenched Gaussian noise. We find no differ-
ence between these interpretations. In panel B, the accuracy of the unquenched Gaussian noise is from
the best linear discounting agent, because we do not have a normative theory for unquenched noise
(precisely what the simulation was asking to compare).
Click reliability with missed clicks
An alternative form of sensory noise might parameterize the probability that a subject just fails to
hear a click at all. Using this framework, we show that missed clicks doesn't change the click reliability
function. Assume a click that is generated is not detected at all with probability m. Then, the click
reliability of a click on the right can be computed as:
(cid:18) r1(1 − m)r2m + r1(1 − m)(1 − r2)
r2(1 − m)r1m + r2(1 − m)(1 − r1)
(cid:19)
(47)
κ(r1, r2, m) = log
We can interpret this expression as the probability of having a click be generated on one side and not
missed and a click generated on the other side and missed, or the probability of a click being generated
on one side and not being missed and no click is generated on the other side. Given that ∆t << 1, we
can remove second order terms in ∆t:
κ(r1, r2, m) = log
(cid:19)
(cid:18) r1(1 − m)
r2(1 − m)
(cid:18) r1
(cid:19)
r2
= log
(48)
We find the click reliability is independent of the probability of missing a click, m.
40
A general argument for click mislocalization
In the previous sections we demonstrated that in the case of missed clicks, or gaussian clicks, mislocal-
ization is necessary for decreasing click reliability. Here we provide a general argument for why that is
true under any form of sensory noise. The auditory evidence takes on two possible values S = {+1,−1}.
Let y be the value of each auditory stimuli after being noisily encoded by the sensory transduction pro-
cess (y = f (S)). If f () maps left and right clicks separately into non-overlapping distributions of click
amplitudes, then an ideal observer can bin y into groups y < 0 and y > 0, and perfectly recover the
original signal S. If f () maps left and right clicks into overlapping distributions, then an observer can-
not bin y to perfectly recover the original signal. If the observer uses the same binary binning scheme
as before, then the error rate in the recovered signal will be equal to the mislocalization rate. Notice
that an observer with perfect knowledge of the distribution of f () can do slightly better by using a
different binning scheme. If the observer recognizes that clicks in the domain where the left and right
distributions overlap are less trustworthy, then the observer can use multiple bins to discount specifi-
cally those clicks near 0. The Gaussian reliability function above κ(r1, r2, Pr, Pl) can be considered an
observer with an infinite number of bins. As seen in figure 17, this strategy slightly improves accuracy
above the two-binning strategy. We thus conclude that click mislocalization is the source of decreasing
click reliability from sensory noise.
41
Psychophysical Reverse Correlation details
Here we present two control analyses on our reverse correlation method. First, we show that our method
is not biased by the presence of a lapse rate, unlike logistic regression. Second, we rule out degenerate
strategies like deciding based on only the last click.
Figure 18: Reverse Correlation timescales are unaffected by lapse rates. Lapse rates are
defined as the percentage of trials where the subject makes a random response. (A) Logistic regression
is strongly biased by the presence of a lapse rate. (B) Psychophysical reverse correlation methods used
in this study are not biased.
42
0% Lapse Rate1% Lapse Rate5% Lapse Rate10% Lapse Rate20% Lapse RateLogistic RegressionReverse Correlation0% Lapse Rate10% Lapse Rate Are the rats really integrating? Ruling out last click strategies
One possible concern is that the rats might be relying on degenerate strategies like choosing based
on the last click they heard. Or that the rat's integration timescale is so short, that their behavior
shouldn't really be considering integration. Figure 19A shows a quasi-fixed point analysis of the optimal
accumulation equation given a noise level. Assuming the environment stays in one state for a long
time, we then replace the evidence term with the expected rate of clicks, and solve for the steady state
accumulation value. We can see that for all noise levels, the fixed point lies above 1 click, so the optimal
behavior necessarily involves integrating clicks. For the average rat noise level, we see integration of
about 5 clicks.
Figure 19B shows the recovered discounting rate from the reverse correlation method against a
simulated discounting agents, similar to Figure 3. Here, we include much stronger discounting agents,
and find the recovered discounting rate asymptotes at just under 36 Hz, which is the expected total
click rate(r1 − r2 ≈ 36). The last click strategy could be considered a discounting agent with an infinite
discounting rate, and would be recovered in our analysis as a discounting rate of about 36. We find our
rats are well away from this limit. Thus we confidently rule out a last click strategy.
Figure 19: Ruling out last click strategies. (A) Quasi fixed points derived from the expected click
rate and evidence discounting functions, assuming a fixed environmental state. For all noise levels, the
fixed point is greater than 1 click. (B) Integration timescales measured from reverse correlation curves.
At large discounting rates, the timescale saturates reflecting the timescale of click generation.
43
00.10.20.30.40.5Click mislocalization probability0246810Fixed point (clks)click statistics limitBAclick integration limit Model details
Figure 20: Best fitting model parameters on static and dynamic tasks. The best fitting
parameters and their standard errors are shown for each rat in the current study, compared to each rat
from Brunton et al. 2013. Each parameter plot has the rats sorted independently by parameter value,
rows across panels do not indicate the same rat.
44
static task(n=19 from Brunton, 2013)dynamic task (n=14)A0102030saRatsB0510ssRatsC0102030siRatsD00.51phiRatsE00.20.40.6tauRatsF-1-0.500.51biasRatsG00.20.4lapseRatsH 4
1
0
.
0
±
3
0
t
.
p
5
o
−
λ
9
7
0
0
.
0
±
2
9
.
5
−
1
9
0
.
0
±
3
1
.
5
−
2
2
0
0
.
0
±
4
9
.
5
−
9
7
0
.
0
±
3
5
.
5
−
3
1
.
0
±
6
5
.
4
−
8
1
.
0
±
7
2
.
5
−
2
4
.
0
±
7
8
.
4
−
6
2
0
0
.
0
±
5
7
.
4
−
4
5
0
0
.
0
±
7
3
.
5
−
1
8
0
.
0
±
5
0
.
6
−
5
2
0
.
0
±
7
8
.
4
−
7
2
.
0
±
8
5
.
5
−
2
1
.
0
±
7
1
.
5
−
2
4
0
.
0
±
6
−
e
1
.
1
0
2
0
.
0
±
9
−
e
6
.
3
5
2
0
.
0
±
7
9
0
.
0
4
1
.
0
±
7
9
0
.
0
9
2
0
.
0
±
7
−
e
9
.
1
8
9
0
0
.
0
±
7
3
.
0
6
3
0
.
0
±
1
3
.
0
3
6
0
.
0
±
7
−
e
4
6
.
1
9
6
0
.
0
±
8
−
e
9
0
.
4
7
8
0
.
0
±
6
−
e
1
5
3
0
.
0
±
7
−
e
8
.
3
7
4
0
.
0
±
7
−
e
3
.
3
5
7
0
.
0
±
7
−
e
5
.
9
2
6
0
.
0
±
7
−
e
3
.
2
e
s
p
a
L
4
1
0
.
0
±
5
2
0
.
0
−
2
7
0
0
.
0
±
0
3
0
.
0
9
3
0
.
0
±
1
2
.
0
−
0
2
.
0
±
1
9
.
0
−
2
1
0
.
0
±
3
7
0
.
0
−
9
7
0
.
0
±
7
6
.
0
−
3
2
0
.
0
±
5
1
.
0
−
6
2
0
.
0
±
3
5
0
.
0
1
1
.
0
±
0
2
.
0
−
s
a
i
B
3
3
0
.
0
±
9
8
0
.
0
−
2
2
0
.
0
±
2
1
.
0
−
7
7
0
.
0
±
2
1
0
0
.
0
−
8
3
0
.
0
±
3
5
0
.
0
−
7
3
0
.
0
±
9
2
.
0
−
4
−
e
7
.
1
±
4
−
e
2
.
1
3
7
0
0
.
0
±
3
5
0
.
0
8
1
0
.
0
±
2
1
.
0
φ
τ
2
4
0
0
.
0
±
3
8
0
0
.
0
4
3
0
0
.
0
±
5
3
0
.
0
0
1
0
.
0
±
8
4
0
.
0
2
3
0
.
0
±
2
1
.
0
0
4
0
0
.
0
±
9
1
0
.
0
9
1
0
.
0
±
7
6
0
.
0
9
1
0
.
0
±
4
8
0
.
0
6
2
0
.
0
±
5
9
0
.
0
3
1
0
.
0
±
5
4
0
.
0
4
5
0
0
.
0
±
9
2
0
.
0
0
±
0
1
.
0
5
4
0
.
0
±
5
4
.
0
2
3
0
.
0
±
7
3
.
0
9
7
.
0
±
0
2
.
1
φ
2
4
.
0
±
4
−
e
3
.
5
7
4
0
.
0
±
5
7
0
.
0
9
2
0
.
0
±
2
0
.
1
9
8
0
.
0
±
4
−
e
8
.
4
8
9
0
.
0
±
2
4
.
0
9
8
0
.
0
±
1
3
.
0
4
1
.
0
±
4
6
0
.
0
3
6
0
.
0
±
0
6
.
0
5
6
0
.
0
±
2
2
.
0
4
1
.
0
±
0
3
.
0
7
8
.
1
±
6
7
0
0
.
0
7
8
.
1
±
0
6
0
.
0
7
8
.
1
±
2
5
0
.
0
7
8
.
1
±
2
7
0
.
0
7
8
.
1
±
2
5
0
.
0
7
8
.
1
±
8
2
0
.
0
6
8
.
1
±
1
7
.
0
2i
σ
7
8
.
1
±
5
6
0
0
.
0
7
8
.
1
±
8
3
0
.
0
1
7
.
1
±
2
5
.
0
4
8
.
1
±
0
4
.
0
7
8
.
1
±
8
2
0
.
0
7
8
.
1
±
5
−
e
4
6
.
6
9
7
.
0
±
5
4
.
6
6
2
.
0
±
9
1
.
2
9
9
.
0
±
6
.
1
1
6
9
.
4
±
2
5
.
1
1
2a
σ
0
4
.
0
±
6
3
.
4
7
4
.
1
±
1
6
.
7
3
2
.
0
±
9
0
.
1
4
8
.
0
±
2
8
.
4
7
9
.
1
±
9
5
.
6
9
4
.
1
±
1
9
.
7
1
6
.
0
±
9
8
.
4
9
4
.
0
±
0
4
.
2
5
9
.
1
±
0
9
.
7
2
1
.
1
±
5
3
.
6
6
7
.
2
±
9
7
.
1
4
4
.
0
±
1
4
.
0
9
9
.
4
±
4
−
e
2
1
1
.
5
±
4
4
.
0
5
4
.
1
±
0
3
.
2
3
.
5
±
4
0
.
1
2s
σ
2
9
.
2
±
5
−
e
9
5
.
3
7
3
.
2
±
9
2
0
0
.
0
9
9
.
4
±
5
−
e
3
5
.
1
8
6
.
2
±
5
−
e
9
.
5
1
2
.
4
±
5
−
e
5
.
3
5
7
.
4
±
4
3
0
0
.
0
0
±
5
−
e
9
.
3
8
7
.
3
±
9
6
.
4
2
9
0
.
0
±
9
3
.
6
−
3
6
0
.
0
±
3
3
.
4
−
9
9
0
.
0
±
4
6
.
6
−
0
3
.
0
±
4
9
.
4
−
7
0
.
0
±
9
0
.
5
−
9
1
.
0
±
8
9
.
4
−
3
1
.
0
±
1
1
.
5
−
5
1
.
0
±
5
1
.
5
−
5
1
.
0
±
2
1
.
5
−
0
2
.
0
±
7
5
.
6
−
9
8
0
.
0
±
3
1
.
5
−
3
2
.
0
±
8
1
.
9
−
2
2
.
0
±
5
3
.
5
−
4
1
0
.
0
±
6
5
.
5
−
λ
3
3
0
H
7
3
0
H
8
3
0
H
9
3
0
H
0
4
0
H
3
4
0
H
5
4
0
H
8
5
0
H
1
6
0
H
5
6
0
H
6
6
0
H
7
6
0
H
3
8
0
H
4
8
0
H
t
a
r
45
.
r
e
t
e
m
a
r
a
p
h
c
a
e
r
o
f
r
o
r
r
e
d
r
a
d
n
a
t
s
e
h
t
d
n
a
s
r
e
t
e
m
a
r
a
p
d
o
o
h
i
l
e
k
i
l
m
u
m
i
x
a
M
:
1
e
l
b
a
T
3
0
1
.
0
±
7
1
0
.
0
1
9
.
1
±
4
−
e
2
0
.
1
Figure 21: Model Residual error against time The model fits short and long trials equally well.
46
H033H037H038H039H040H043H045H058H061 Figure 22: Model Residual error against time The model fits short and long trials equally well.
47
H065H066H067H083H084 Figure 23: Rats adjust their integration timescales quickly to new environments Evidence
discounting rates estimated in blocks of 4 sessions for each rat in figure 6D. Session 1 is the first session
in the 0Hz environment. Each rat is then moved back to 0.5 Hz. Dashed lines show the evidence
discounting rates estimated over all sessions of the same hazard rate. Variability across blocks of
session is due to low trial count.
48
050100150Session #-1012345discounting (clks/s)0204060Session #-1012345discounting (clks/s)0204060Session #-1012345discounting (clks/s)H036H045H046ABCSwitch to 0 HzSwitch back to 0.5 Hz References
Aksay, E., Olasagasti, I., Mensh, B. D., Baker, R., Goldman, M. S., and Tank, D. W. (2007). Functional dissection of
circuitry in a neural integrator. Nat Neurosci, 10(4):494–504. 17369822[pmid].
Barnard, G. A. (1946). Sequential tests in industrial statistics. Supplement to the Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,
8(1):1–26.
Basten, U., Biele, G., Heekeren, H. R., and Fiebach, C. J. (2010). How the brain integrates costs and benefits during
decision making. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 107(50):21767–21772.
Boerlin, M., Machens, C. K., and Denve, S. (2013). Predictive coding of dynamical variables in balanced spiking networks.
PLOS Computational Biology, 9(11):1–16.
Bogacz, R., Brown, E., Moehlis, J., Holmes, P., and Cohen, J. D. (2006). The physics of optimal decision making: a
formal analysis of models of performance in two-alternative forced-choice tasks. Psychol Rev, 113(4):700–765.
Brunton, B. W., Botvinick, M. M., and Brody, C. D. (2013). Rats and humans can optimally accumulate evidence for
decision-making. Science, 340(6128):95–98.
Cisek, P., Puskas, G. A., and El-Murr, S. (2009). Decisions in changing conditions: The urgency-gating model. Journal
of Neuroscience, 29(37):11560–11571.
Daw, N. (2011). Trial-by-trial data analysis using computational models. Oxford University Press.
Dayan, P. and Abbott, L. F. (2005). Theoretical Neuroscience: Computational and Mathematical Modeling of Neural
Systems. The MIT Press.
Druckmann, S. and Chklovskii, D. (2012). Neuronal circuits underlying persistent representations despite time varying
activity. Current Biology, 22(22):2095 – 2103.
Duan, C. A., Erlich, J. C., and Brody, C. D. (2015). Requirement of prefrontal and midbrain regions for rapid executive
control of behavior in the rat. Neuron, 86(6):1491 – 1503.
Erlich, J. C., Bialek, M., and Brody, C. D. (2011). A cortical substrate for memory-guided orienting in the rat. Neuron,
72(2):330–343.
Erlich, J. C., Brunton, B. W., Duan, C. A., Hanks, T. D., and Brody, C. D. (2015). Distinct effects of prefrontal and
parietal cortex inactivations on an accumulation of evidence task in the rat. eLife, 4:e05457.
Feng, S., Holmes, P., Rorie, A., and Newsome, W. T. (2009). Can monkeys choose optimally when faced with noisy stimuli
and unequal rewards? PLOS Computational Biology, 5(2):1–15.
Ganguli, S., Huh, D., and Sompolinsky, H. (2008). Memory traces in dynamical systems. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences, 105(48):18970–18975.
Glaze, C. M., Kable, J. W., and Gold, J. I. (2015). Normative evidence accumulation in unpredictable environments.
eLife, 4:e08825.
Gold, J. I. and Shadlen, M. N. (2001). Neural computations that underlie decisions about sensory stimuli. Trends in
cognitive sciences, 5(1):10–16.
49
Gold, J. I. and Stocker, A. A. (2017). Visual decision-making in an uncertain and dynamic world. Annual Review of
Vision Science, 3(1):null. PMID: 28715956.
Goldman, M. S. (2009). Memory without feedback in a neural network. Neuron, 61(4):621–634.
Gureckis, T. M. and Love, B. C. (2009). Learning in noise: Dynamic decision-making in a variable environment. Journal
of Mathematical Psychology, 53(3):180 – 193. Special Issue: Dynamic Decision Making.
Hanks, T. D., Kopec, C. D., Brunton, B. W., Duan, C. A., Erlich, J. C., and Brody, C. D. (2015). Distinct relationships
of parietal and prefrontal cortices to evidence accumulation. Nature, 520(7546):220–223. Letter.
Iigaya, K., Ahmadian, Y., Sugrue, L., Corrado, G., Loewenstein, Y., Newsome, W. T., and Fusi, S. (2017). Learning fast
and slow: Deviations from the matching law can reflect an optimal strategy under uncertainty. bioRxiv.
Kelly, S. P. and O'Connell, R. G. (2013). Internal and external influences on the rate of sensory evidence accumulation in
the human brain. Journal of Neuroscience, 33(50):19434–19441.
Kiani, R., Cueva, C., Reppas, J., and Newsome, W. (2014). Dynamics of neural population responses in prefrontal cortex
indicate changes of mind on single trials. Current Biology, 24(13):1542 – 1547.
Kira, S., Yang, T., and Shadlen, M. (2015). A neural implementation of walds sequential probability ratio test. Neuron,
85(4):861 – 873.
Kopec, C., Erlich, J., Brunton, B., Deisseroth, K., and Brody, C. (2015). Cortical and subcortical contributions to
short-term memory for orienting movements. Neuron, 88(2):367 – 377.
Krajbich, I., Hare, T., Bartling, B., Morishima, Y., and Fehr, E. (2015). A common mechanism underlying food choice
and social decisions. PLOS Computational Biology, 11(10):1–24.
Lee, M. D. and Cummins, T. D. (2004). Evidence accumulation in decision making: Unifying the take the best and the
rational models. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 11(2):343–352.
Maass, W., Natschlger, T., and Markram, H. (2002). Real-time computing without stable states: A new framework for
neural computation based on perturbations. Neural Computation, 14(11):2531–2560.
Miller, K. J., Botvinick, M. M., and Brody, C. D. (2017). Dorsal hippocampus contributes to model-based planning. Nat
Neurosci, advance online publication. Article.
Ossmy, O., Moran, R., Pfeffer, T., Tsetsos, K., Usher, M., and Donner, T. (2013). The timescale of perceptual evidence
integration can be adapted to the environment. Current Biology, 23(11):981 – 986.
Peixoto, D., Kiani, R., Nuyujukian, P., Chandrasekaran, C., Brown, R., Fong, S., Shenoy, K., and Newsome, W. (2016).
Real-time decoding of a decision variable during a perceptual discrimination task. In Proceedings of Society for Neuro-
science Annual Conference 2016.
Philiastides, M. G., Auksztulewicz, R., Heekeren, H. R., and Blankenburg, F. (2011). Causal role of dorsolateral prefrontal
cortex in human perceptual decision making. Current biology, 21(11):980–983.
Piet, A., Erlich, J., Kopec, C., and Brody, C. D. (2017). Rat prefrontal cortex inactivations are explained by bistable
attractor dynamics. Neural Computation.
50
Purcell, B. A., Heitz, R. P., Cohen, J. Y., Schall, J. D., Logan, G. D., and Palmeri, T. J. (2010). Neurally constrained
modeling of perceptual decision making. Psychological review, 117(4):1113.
Ratcliff, R. and McKoon, G. (2008). The diffusion decision model: Theory and data for two-choice decision tasks. Neural
Computation, 20(4):873–922. PMID: 18085991.
Revels, J., Lubin, M., and Papamarkou, T. (2016).
Forward-mode automatic differentiation in julia. CoRR,
abs/1607.07892.
Scott, B. B., Constantinople, C. M., Akrami, A., Hanks, T. D., Brody, C. D., and Tank, D. W. (2017). Fronto-parietal
cortical circuits encode accumulated evidence with a diversity of timescales. Neuron, 95(2):385–398.e5.
Scott, B. B., Constantinople, C. M., Erlich, J. C., Tank, D. W., and Brody, C. D. (2015). Sources of noise during
accumulation of evidence in unrestrained and voluntarily head-restrained rats. eLife, 4:e11308.
Seung, H. (1996). How the brain keeps the eyesstill. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 93(23):13339–13344.
Veliz-Cuba, A., Kilpatrick, Z. P., and Josic, K. (2016). Stochastic models of evidence accumulation in changing environ-
ments. SIAM Review.
Wald, A. (1945). Sequential tests of statistical hypotheses. Ann. Math. Statist., 16(2):117–186.
Zylberberg, A., Fetsch, C. R., and Shadlen, M. N. (2016). The influence of evidence volatility on choice, reaction time
and confidence in a perceptual decision. eLife, 5:e17688.
51
|
1509.04304 | 2 | 1509 | 2015-12-23T16:48:00 | Large-scale signatures of unconsciousness are consistent with a departure from critical dynamics | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Loss of cortical integration and changes in the dynamics of electrophysiological brain signals characterize the transition from wakefulness towards unconsciousness. The common mechanism underlying these observations remains unknown. In this study we arrive at a basic model, which explains these empirical observations based on the theory of phase transitions in complex systems. We studied the link between spatial and temporal correlations of large-scale brain activity recorded with functional magnetic resonance imaging during wakefulness, propofol-induced sedation and loss of consciousness, as well as during the subsequent recovery. We observed that during unconsciousness activity in frontal and thalamic regions exhibited a reduction of long-range temporal correlations and a departure of functional connectivity from the underlying anatomical constraints. These changes in dynamics and anatomy-function coupling were correlated across participants, suggesting that temporal complexity and an efficient exploration of anatomical connectivity are inter-related phenomena. A model of a system exhibiting a phase transition reproduced our findings, as well as the diminished sensitivity of the cortex to external perturbations during unconsciousness. This theoretical framework unifies different empirical observations about brain activity during unconsciousness and predicts that the principles we identified are universal and independent of the causes behind loss of awareness. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Large-scale signatures of unconsciousness are consistent
with a departure from critical dynamics
Enzo Tagliazucchi1,2*, Dante R. Chialvo3*, Michael Siniatchkin1, Enrico Amico4, Jean-Francois
Brichant4, Vincent Bonhomme4, Quentin Noirhomme4, Helmut Laufs2,5*, Steven Laureys4*
* These authors contributed equally to this work
1 Institute for Medical Psychology, Christian Albrechts University Kiel, 24105 Kiel, Germany.
2 Department of Neurology and Brain Imaging Center, Goethe University Frankfurt am Main.
Frankfurt am Main, 60528 Frankfurt am Main, Germany.
3 Comision Nacional de Investigaciones Cientificas y Tecnologicas (CONICET), Argentina.
4 Coma Science Group, GIGA Research and Cyclotron Research Center, University and
University Hospital of Liège, Liège, Belgium.
5 Department of Neurology, Christian Albrechts University Kiel, 24104 Kiel, Germany.
Contact information:
Enzo Tagliazucchi
Institute for Medical Psychology, UKSH
Arnold-Heller-Strasse 3
24105 Kiel
Germany
Tel: 0157 - 81976950
[email protected]
1"
ABSTRACT
Loss of cortical integration and changes in the dynamics of electrophysiological brain signals
characterize the transition from wakefulness towards unconsciousness. In this study we arrive
at a basic model explaining these observations based on the theory of phase transitions in
complex systems. We studied the link between spatial and temporal correlations of large-
scale brain activity recorded with fMRI during wakefulness, propofol-induced sedation and
loss of consciousness, and during the subsequent recovery. We observed that during
unconsciousness activity in fronto-thalamic regions exhibited a reduction of long-range
temporal correlations and a departure of functional connectivity from anatomical constraints.
A model of a system exhibiting a phase transition reproduced our findings, as well as the
diminished sensitivity of the cortex to external perturbations during unconsciousness. This
framework unifies different observations about brain activity during unconsciousness and
predicts that the principles we identified are universal and independent from its causes.
KEYWORDS: Consciousness; anesthesia; complex systems; phase transitions; fMRI.
2"
1. INTRODUCTION
Anesthetic drugs transiently impair awareness and thus offer a unique opportunity to
investigate the neural correlates of conscious wakefulness. In contrast to other reversible
unconscious states (such as sleep), anesthetics simultaneously reduce arousal and
awareness and – except in the rare event of intra-operative awareness – result in a brain
state incompatible with conscious content (Alkire et al. 2008). Studies of the transition from
wakefulness to loss of consciousness induced by propofol (a presumed GABA agonist
anesthetic agent) consistently report decreased cortical integration (Alkire et al. 2008; Lee et
al. 2009; Boveroux et al. 2010; Schrouff et al. 2011; Monti et al. 2013; Amico et al., 2014) and
changes in the dynamics of electrophysiological brain signals, such as delta (1 - 4 Hz) and
gamma oscillations (30 - 70 Hz) (Murphy et al. 2011; Boly et al. 2012). Despite many
experimental reports at different temporal and spatial scales, the precise mechanisms
underlying propofol-induced unconsciousness remain poorly understood. The need for a
mechanistic understanding of this phenomenon is non-trivial, since it could contribute to
unraveling how consciousness is constructed and preserved by the brain.
During conscious wakefulness the cortex spontaneously generates a flurry of ever changing
activity (Chialvo 2010; Raichle 2011; Sporns 2011). In the temporal domain, this activity is
characterized by long-range temporal correlations, meaning that signal fluctuations at the
present time influence dynamics up to several minutes in the future (Maxim et al. 2005; He
2011). Lacking any distinctive scale (scale-free), these temporal correlations can be
characterized by the computation of scaling exponents, such as the Hurst exponent
(Tagliazucchi et al. 2013a). In the spatial domain, these fluctuations are coordinated across
networks of regions commonly co-activated during stimulation and cognitive performance,
termed resting state networks (RSN) (Beckmann et al. 2005; Smith et al. 2009). While
functional connectivity can transiently dissociate from inter-areal anatomical connections
(Liegeois et al. 2015), brain activity correlations computed over extended periods of time
seems to be partially explained by the underlying anatomy (Hagmann et al. 2008;
Hermundstad et al. 2013; Greicius et al. 2009; Wang et al. 2013). This suggests that
spontaneous brain activity can be understood as an ever-transient (or metastable) exploration
of the wide repertoire of paths offered by the underlying structural connectivity, the extent of
such exploration potentially depending on the brain state, with variable repertoires
corresponding to different degrees of awareness.
Here we put forward an interpretation of propofol-induced loss of consciousness in analogy to
the dynamics and connectivity of fluctuations seen on a diversity of complex systems
exhibiting different phases. As a system explores the space of possible configurations, its
spatio-temporal correlations behave in characteristic ways. In particular, the dynamical
changes underlying different degrees of awareness could be analogous to the qualitative
3"
from
is manifest as
increased
long-range
temporal autocorrelation (i.e.
changes observed in the dynamics of complex systems when they move away from a phase
transition (Werner 2013). Experimental evidence gathered
functional magnetic
resonance imaging (fMRI) data supports the view that during conscious wakefulness the
human brain operates near the critical point of such a transition (Chialvo 2010; Tagliazucchi
et al., 2012). A robust feature of the critical state is the phenomenon of critical slowing down,
which
temporal
correlations) of fluctuations throughout the system (Werner 2007; Chialvo 2010; Kelso 2012).
Far from the critical transition, the variables describing the system are very stable. As a
consequence, any perturbation from equilibrium is dissipated quickly (i.e. dynamics rapidly
returns to equilibrium). Conversely, near the transition the effects of any disturbance last
longer, thus it is that the dynamics slow down. Since far from the transition the system is
stuck into a stable state, its dynamics cannot explore the wider repertoire allowed by
structural constraints. The opposite occurs near the phase transition at which the system can
switch between a large number of locally stable or metastable states (Werner 2007), and fully
explore its structural connectivity (Stam et al., 2014; Deco et al., 2014). Thus, if
unconsciousness results in a departure from critical dynamics, we expect to see these two
inter-related signatures: 1) Loss of temporal correlations in brain activity time series and 2) a
less complete exploration of the activity patterns allowed by the underlying structural
connectivity.
Previous experimental results are consistent with a loss of critical slowing down in large-scale
brain activity during unconsciousness. For instance, magnetic and electric perturbation of the
cortex during different states of consciousness elicits equally different responses: conscious
wakefulness is characterized by prolonged and spatiotemporally correlated responses
(disturbances last longer), whereas unconsciousness is characterized by a smaller repertoire
of rapidly vanishing and spatially localized responses (Massimini et al. 2005; Ferrarelli et al.
2010; Casali et al. 2013; Pigorini et al. 2014). The response to endogenous fluctuations
during deep sleep is also rapidly vanishing, resulting in the loss of temporal long-range
correlations (Tagliazucchi et al. 2013a). Finally, spontaneous electrophysiological activity
recorded during unconsciousness presents increased stability (Solovey et al. 2015). A
mechanistic account of the action of propofol on large-scale brain activity should provide a
unified explanation for these seemingly different experimental results.
To propose such an explanation, we studied fMRI data acquired during wakefulness,
propofol-induced sedation and loss of consciousness, as well as during the subsequent
recovery of awareness. We evaluated the presence of two large-scale signatures of a
departure from the critical point of a phase transition: loss of long-range temporal correlations
and the uncoupling of functional and anatomical connectivity (Stam et al., 2014; Deco et al.,
2014), measured using diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) and diffusion spectrum imaging (DSI).
4"
Finally, we developed a conceptual model presenting a phase transition to assist in the
mechanistic interpretation of the experimental results.
2. METHODS
Experimental design and participants
Participants were scanned with fMRI during wakefulness (W), propofol sedation (S), propofol-
induced loss of consciousness (LOC) and finally during the recovery of wakefulness (R).
Sedation corresponded to Ramsay level 3 (Ramsay et al. 1974). Loss of consciousness
corresponded to Ramsay levels 5-6 (subjects did not exhibit responses to verbal instructions).
Recovery corresponded to Ramsay level 2.
Twenty healthy right-handed volunteers aged between 18 and 31 years (22.4± 2.4 years)
were initially included in the study. Following Monti et al (2013), subjects with head
displacements exceeding 3 mm during any of the four conditions were discarded from the
analysis, resulting in a final set of 12 participants. For all conditions, the resulting average
head movement amplitudes did not exceed 1 mm (wakefulness: 0.38 mm, sedation: 0.25 mm,
loss of consciousness: 0.17, recovery: 0.36 mm). No significant effect of condition on head
displacement was found (!!,!!= 2.63, p=0.062). As noted by Monti et al., this is a conservative
approach to limit the impact of head movement. Other methods, such as scan nulling (Power
et al. 2014), could affect the estimation of blood-oxygen level dependent (BOLD) signal
spectral power and long-range temporal correlations and therefore were not applied. As an
additional control, the presence of significant residual correlations between absolute and
relative head movement time series and voxel-wise BOLD time series was evaluated after
data pre-processing, with no significant residual correlations being detected.
Details on fMRI, DTI and DSI data acquisition and preprocessing are provided in the
Supplementary Methods.
Estimation of long-range temporal dependencies
DFA (Kantelhardt et al. 2001) was applied to study the temporal correlations of BOLD
fluctuations. This method was developed to obtain estimates of long-range temporal
dependence in time series, while accounting for the possibility of non-stationarities. In the
Supplementary Methods we provide a formal definition of the procedure followed in the DFA
algorithm. Briefly, time series were first de-trended by subtracting the mean and the
cumulative sum was then computed. Afterwards, the signal was divided into non-overlapping
windows and the intensity of the fluctuations was computed by averaging the standard
deviation of the signal across all windows (de-trended within each window). This procedure
5"
was repeated for different window sizes and the slope of the standard deviation of the
fluctuations vs. the window size (“fluctuation function”, in logarithmic scale) was identified with
the Hurst exponent (H). Based on the value of H, three qualitatively different scenarios can be
distinguished: long-range temporal correlations (slow decay of the autocorrelation function)
with 0.5 < H < 1, uncorrelated temporal activity (exponential decay of the autocorrelation
function) with H = 0.5 and long-range anti-correlations (switching between high and low
values in consecutive time steps) with 0 < H < 0.5.
We applied DFA to the first 150 volumes of the BOLD time series of every voxel for each
subject and condition, obtaining spatial maps of H values. To compute H, windows of length
10, 15, 25 and 30 volumes were used, as the logarithmic plot of the fluctuation function
showed linear behavior within this range. We also estimated H in the frequency domain
following a wavelet-based method. The steps followed for the wavelet estimation of H are
extensively presented and discussed in the Supplementary Methods.
Functional network construction
We constructed functional networks by extracting average BOLD signals from all regions of
interest and computing the linear correlation between all pairs of signals, resulting in the
correlation matrix C!".
C!" were thresholded to yield binary adjacency matrices A!" such that A!"=1 if C!"≥ρ and
A!"=0 otherwise. The parameter ρ was chosen to fix the ratio of the connections in the
arise because the means of the respective C!" are different (and therefore the number of non-
zeros entries in A!") and not because connections are topologically re-organized across
network (
) to the total possible number of connections (termed link density). It is
important to fix the link density when comparing networks since otherwise differences could
For comparison with the underlying anatomical connectivity networks, the correlation matrices
A!"
!!!
conditions.
We performed all analyses for a range of link densities between 0.01 and 0.3 in steps of 0.01.
When comparing functional networks with their anatomical counterparts, the chosen link
density ranges always included the link density of the DTI and DSI anatomical networks.
Similarity between functional and anatomical connectivity neighborhoods
We defined the connectivity neighborhood of node i as n!=A!" (i.e. the i-th column of the
adjacency matrix for a fixed local link density). According to this definition, the j-th entry of n!
is 1 if nodes i and j share a direct connection in the network, and it is zero otherwise. We
6"
obtained the connectivity neighborhood of all nodes in the anatomical and functional networks
across all conditions and participants, as well as for a range of local link densities. To
estimate the similarity between the anatomical and functional connectivity neighborhoods of
each node we computed the Hamming distance between the anatomical and functional
versions of vectors n! (normalized by their total length). The Hamming distance is defined as
the number of symbol substitutions (in this case 0 or 1) needed to transform one sequence
into another and vice-versa, and in this case it is equal to twice the number of connections
that must be re-wired to turn the functional connectivity neighbor into the anatomical
connectivity neighbor.
Fluctuations in functional connectivity and repertoire of functional networks
We investigated if the fluctuations in the transient connectivity within the frontal executive
control RSN were more widespread during wakefulness vs. propofol-induced
unconsciousness by computing the average functional connectivity of all nodes in the RSN
over short non-overlapping windows of different durations. Afterwards, we computed the
variance of the time series of dynamical functional connectivity fluctuations.
We investigated the repertoire of functional networks explored over time by means of a new
methodology (see Fig. S7 of the Supplemental Information for a schematic). We first
computed the connectivity matrices of all nodes within the executive control RSN (Fig. S7A)
over non-overlapping segments of 20 volumes. After thresholding at a given link density
(ranging from 0.01 to 0.4) this defined a series of binary networks explored over time (Fig.
S7B). Afterwards, we computed the average correlation between the adjacency matrices of all
these binary networks (Fig. S7C). If the repertoire of explored networks is very constrained
this average correlation is high (i.e. all transient networks are very similar). On the other hand,
if the system explores a wide range of different transient networks, this average correlation is
lower. We termed this index transient network similarity (TNS) index.
Computational model
The computational model is based on the previous work of Haimovici et al. 2013 (see also a
posteriori similar formulation by Stam et al. 2014). It consists of an underlying anatomical
network of connections (DSI network) and rules for the transition between three states:
inactive, active and refractory. The rules for the transitions at the i-th node are as follows,
W!">T
.
!!!"!!"#$%&
Inactive to active: either spontaneously with a probability of 10-3 or if
1)
2) Active to refractory always occurs.
3) Refractory to inactive with a probability of 10-1.
7"
These rules were used to simulate time series that were subsequently binarized by setting the
active state to 1 and the other two to 0, and convolved with the standard hemodynamic
response function mimicking the brain neurometabolic coupling. As shown in Haimovici et al.
2013, a second order phase transition exists at TC ≈ 0.05. At this point, activity becomes self-
sustained, spatial and temporal correlations are maximized and an optimal agreement with
the empirical fMRI data is obtained (including an approximate reproduction of the major RSN
reported in the work of Beckmann et al. 2005).
3. RESULTS
We first obtained Hurst exponent and the low-frequency (0.01 - 0.1 Hz) power for each
participant and condition (W, S, LOC and R). Also, we investigated the same metrics in a
phantom made of water (see Figure S1 of the Supplementary Figures).
The anatomical distribution of Hurst values and low frequency power reflected the division of
cortical anatomy into grey and white matter and cerebrospinal fluid. BOLD signals from grey
matter voxels were characterized by long-range temporal correlations (H > 0.65) whereas
white matter and cerebrospinal fluid voxels generally presented relatively weaker temporal
correlations and 0.01-0.1 Hz frequency power (Fig. 1A). A shift towards reduced H and low-
frequency power can be observed in the LOC condition (third row). We computed the global
Hurst exponent and low-frequency power values (averaged across all grey matter voxels) and
observed reduced values for the LOC condition relative to W (Fig. 1B). We also observed
reduced values of the metrics in the frequency domain for R relative to W, suggesting that the
recovery from propofol-induced loss of consciousness might not have been complete.
Histograms for H and low-frequency power are shown in Fig. S1 (Supplementary Figures). H
values peaked at around 0.5 (corresponding to temporally uncorrelated dynamics) for the
water phantom and at H > 0.5 for grey matter brain voxels, i.e. as opposed to brain dynamics,
those of the water phantom were temporally uncorrelated.
We conducted voxel-wise statistical tests to assess the effect of the condition on H and low-
frequency power (Fig. 2). We observed a significant effect of the condition (W, S, LOC and R)
on H (both DFA and wavelet-estimated) and 0.01-0.1 Hz power. This was observed in in a set
of regions comprising the thalamus, the ventromedial and orbitofrontal cortices, the frontal
and rolandic operculi, the superior and medial frontal gyri and the anterior cingulate and
bilateral insular cortices. Post-hoc t-tests between W and all other conditions revealed
significant decreases only for the comparison vs. LOC. Similar results can also be observed
in the first-order autoregressive coefficient of BOLD signals (Fig. S2, Supplementary Figures).
Statistical parametric maps are presented in Fig. 2A (bottom panel). Fig. 2B shows a ranking
of the top ten automated anatomical labeling (AAL) atlas (Tzourio-Mazoyer et al. 2002)
8"
regions based on the statistical significance of the contrast W vs. LOC. The extent of the
overlap between the three different metrics is shown in Fig. 2C as a joint rendering of
differences in H (both DFA and wavelet-estimated) and 0.01-0.1 Hz power. No significant
differences were observed in terms of the goodness of fit (!!) of the DFA fluctuation function.
functional and anatomical connectivity networks
The covariance between the statistical significance maps derived from all three metrics is
shown in Fig. S3 (Supplementary Figures).
We then studied the coupling between anatomical and functional connectivity. At first, we
restricted both
to a sub-network
encompassing the executive control network reported in Beckmann et al. 2005, since this
RSN overlapped with the regions where we found a breakdown of long-range temporal
correlations during LOC (see Fig. S4 of the Supplementary Figures). For both DTI and DSI
anatomical connectivity networks and almost all link densities we observed decreased
similarity between anatomical and functional connectivity networks during LOC relative to W
(Fig. 3A).
Afterwards, we studied the local similarity between the anatomical and functional first
neighbors of all individual nodes in whole-brain networks. The network nodes associated with
decreased anatomical-functional coupling during LOC relative to W are shown in Fig. 3B.
Differences encompassed the thalamus, as well as the medial prefrontal cortex, anterior
cingulate cortex, frontal and rolandic operculi and the bilateral insular cortex. A ranking of AAL
regions by their percentage of nodes with significant differences is presented in Fig. 3C. The
robustness of the results with respect to the two anatomical connectivity networks is manifest
in the joint rendering of the nodes presenting significant differences (Fig. 3D). Similar results
were obtained using partial correlations instead of linear correlations (see Fig. S6 of the
Supplementary Figures).
As discussed in the introduction, we hypothesized that during LOC the de-correlation of
temporal dynamics should be seen together with a less thorough exploration of the repertoire
of possible states allowed by anatomical constraints. To address this possibility, we
investigated whether changes in H and low-frequency power during LOC were correlated with
the degree of anatomy-function coupling. We computed the average anatomy-function
Hamming distance within the significant regions in Fig. 3B (bottom panel) as a function of the
link density, as well as the average H (DFA and wavelet-estimated) and 0.01-0.1 Hz
frequency power in the same regions. This was performed for each participant in the LOC
condition. We then computed the correlation coefficients and associated p-values between H,
low frequency power and the mean Hamming distance as a function of the link density.
Results are shown in Fig. 4A (note that this correlation is against structural-functional network
distance, not similarity). For both anatomical connectivity networks and almost all link
densities, a significant negative correlation between H and the mean Hamming distance was
9"
found. Correlations involving low frequency power were also negative but in most cases
slightly above the threshold of statistical significance. Negative correlations imply that the
stronger the de-correlation in temporal dynamics, the stronger the uncoupling between
anatomical and functional connectivity. Fig. 4B shows example scatterplots obtained at the
reference link density of 0.15.
We then investigated the variability of functional connectivity over time to determine if
unconsciousness was characterized by diminished fluctuations in dynamic connectivity, as
predicted by a departure from criticality (see Haimovici et al., 2013). Results presented in Fig.
5A reveal that the variance of functional connectivity fluctuations (over a wide range of
window sizes) were diminished during propofol-induced loss of consciousness. Furthermore,
a wider range (repertoire) of functional networks was explored during conscious wakefulness
compared to unconsciousness (Fig. 5B), as quantified by the TNS index computed using
windows of 20 volumes.
To further gauge the significance of our observations we introduced a simple dynamical
model to evaluate which qualitative aspects of the propagation of information in anatomical
networks were more relevant to replicate our empirical observations. The model allows three
possible states for each node in the DSI network. The possible node states and transitions
between them are illustrated in Fig. S5 of the Supplementary Figures.
The threshold in the model controls the propensity of excitations to propagate throughout the
anatomical network. Values higher than the critical threshold of TC ≈ 0.05 difficult the
critical point exists at TC ≈ 0.05, marked by self-sustained activity allowing the reproduction of
propagation of activity, which eventually dies out. On the other hand, lower thresholds result
in self-sustained activity. Very low values result in the extreme of many nodes becoming
rapidly activated and then transitioning towards the refractory (“hyperpolarized”) state. A
many features of large-scale brain activity, such as long-range temporal correlations in space
and time and the emergence of coordinated structures strongly resembling RSN (Haimovici et
al. 2014). The critical point corresponds to a second order phase transition, characterized by
maximal variability in the intrinsic dynamics of the system, critical slowing down and an
optimal exploration of the repertoire of metastable state (i.e. states in which the system
transiently resides). Examples of the temporal dynamics during the sub-, super-, and critical
regimes are shown in Fig. S5 of the Supplementary Figures.
We found that the similarity between functional and structural connectivity was maximal near
the critical point. This was evident from computing the correlation between functional and
anatomical adjacency matrices at each threshold value (Fig. 6A, left) or by computing the
Hamming distance between the binarized functional and anatomical connectivities of each
node (Fig. 6A, right). The frequency at which activations occurred correlated negatively with
10"
the threshold. As shown in Fig. 6B (left), low values facilitated the propagation of activity and
induced higher activation rates while higher thresholds caused the opposite effect by
hindering the propagation of activity. In the super-critical (T > TC) regime, the frequency of
activations also correlated negatively with the anatomical-functional distance (Fig. 6B, right).
The same result was observed for the Hurst exponent of the average activity generated by
the model. Both are consistent with the changes observed under propofol: the higher the
uncoupling between anatomical and functional connectivity, the faster and less temporally
correlated the dynamics of the system.
The critical slowing down observed when dynamics are close to the phase transition
maximizes the response of the model to external perturbations. We studied the average
response of the system to a sudden excitation of 60% of the nodes. This computation is of
interest to evaluate which phases of the model better correspond to the diminished response
to magnetic perturbations of cortical activity observed during loss of consciousness. In Fig. 7
(left) we show the average time course after a perturbation (computed over 100 simulations)
both for TC ≈ 0.05 and for TC < T = 0.01. The response in the critical case was characterized
by a sustained oscillation, with temporally persistent activity observed after the perturbation.
On the other hand, the perturbation in the super-critical case induced a transient response
rapidly giving way to a baseline of uncorrelated oscillations. We measured the decay of the
variance in the activity over short temporal windows of 20 time steps. The activity decay after
the perturbations is shown in Fig. 7 (center) for all thresholds. By measuring the time elapsed
until a level of low variance (10-5) was crossed, we estimated the time necessary for the
activity to decay to its baseline. The decay time peaked near the critical point and quickly
decreased both in the super- and sub- critical cases (Fig. 7, right).
4. DISCUSSION
We studied how propofol-induced loss of consciousness affected the temporal dynamics of
BOLD signals and how the changes in large-scale dynamics were related to the exploration of
the underlying anatomical connectivity. Loss of consciousness was paralleled by a shift
towards faster and temporally uncorrelated BOLD signals in the frontal lobe, the salience
network and the thalamus. Within the same regions, functional connectivity departed from the
underlying anatomical constraints; this departure covaried with loss of long-range temporal
correlations.
An interpretation for our results is given in Fig. 8. We show a schematic depiction of an
elementary system composed of interacting units, the state of the system being symbolized
by the position of a particle within a potential landscape with several local equilibria (potential
wells). In reality, this potential would span a high-dimensional space, with the state vector
describing a multitude of independent variables characterizing the system at each time point.
11"
However, we adopt this simplified schematic for illustration purposes. Far from the critical
point of a phase transition (left panel), the system is more stable and the local minima are
deeper; in consequence any external perturbation or internal fluctuation rapidly vanishes and
the particle returns quickly to the same local equilibrium. For the same reason, the dynamics
of the system do not allow the exploration of all possibilities offered by the structural
connectivity and thus functional correlations reflect only a portion of the anatomical
connections. Near the phase transition (right panel) the landscape becomes shallower, the
stability decreases and perturbations can induce a more widespread exploration of the
potential landscape (see also Fig. 5), resulting in more sustained changes. As the system
explores the neighborhood of different local equilibria (or metastable states) spatial
correlations better reproduce its structural connectivity. Our observations of large-scale fMRI
dynamics and connectivity during loss of consciousness can be interpreted as a departure
from a critical state (near the transition) towards more stable fluctuations (far from the
transition).
Our model also allowed us to simulate the effect of perturbations near and far from its phase
transition and thus to connect two robust but seemingly unrelated findings characterizing
states of reduced awareness: loss of temporal complexity (i.e. long-range temporal
correlations [Tagliazucchi et al. 2013a]) and rapidly vanishing responses to direct magnetic
and electric stimulation of the cortex (Massimini et al. 2005; Ferrarelli et al. 2010; Casali et al.
2013; Pigorini et al. 2015). Within our framework, both arise as a result of increased stability,
with endogenous as well as exogenous fluctuations failing to displace the system between
different metastable states.
The mechanisms by which propofol could result in dynamics compatible with a departure from
a phase transition deserve further investigation. Most likely, these consist of alterations in the
properties of individual units (neurons or groups of neurons) translating into dramatically
different collective behaviors. For instance, our model suggests that facilitated spreading of
activity results in a state of global hyperpolarization (see Fig. S5) impairing the propagation of
external perturbations throughout the system. A possible correlate of this facilitated spreading
is the increased power in the gamma frequency band observed during propofol-induced
unconsciousness (Murphy et al. 2011; Boly et al. 2012), which is also a main driver of BOLD
activity fluctuations (Nir et al. 2007).
Contemporary theories postulate that consciousness is an emergent phenomenon of physical
processes in the brain. The explanation of subjective experiences from the objective
observation of these processes has remained elusive to neuroscience. However, it is possible
to ask what features of brain activity are compatible with the rich subjective phenomenology
of consciousness. An aspect common to different theories is that consciousness can be
associated to a state of high neural complexity (Tononi et al., 1994; Tononi and Edelman,
12"
1998). This can be understood as a state between the extremes of very high differentiation
without information integration (the dynamics of each unit in the system become independent,
like in a “disordered” or “random” system at the super-critical state) and very low
differentiation (the system presents few possible states, as in an “ordered” or “regular” sub-
critical system). At the - between ordered and disordered - critical state, dynamics are both
integrated (the units of the system present long-range correlations both in time and space)
and segregated (the system allows the exploration of a large number of possible metastable
states), suggesting this is the state that could maximize the standard definition of neural
complexity. Future work will need to formally address a possible equivalence between metrics
of neural complexity and metrics of criticality (i.e. order parameters).
Our research provides evidence that the “baseline” state of wakeful rest presents critical
dynamics and that unconscious brain states depart from this kind of dynamics. Thus, we
identify critical dynamics with the state of consciousness. Since the possibility of having
conscious, reportable content (“I see X, hear Y, feel Z”) is in general conditional to being in a
conscious state; critical dynamics could also be a necessary requirement for conscious
content to emerge. This is supported by the observation of comparable neural complexity at
rest and during conscious information access (Burguess et al., 2003). Furthermore, the role
critical dynamics play in conscious information access could be related to the observation that
at criticality the response of the system to external stimuli is maximized (see Fig. 7). Since
conscious perception requires the engagement of a distributed set of neurons (dynamical
core; Tononi and Edelman, 1998, as well as in the concept of the global workspace; Dehaene
and Naccache, 2001), a prerequisite is a high sensitivity to incoming stimuli (high
susceptibility). Conversely, at the sub- or super-critical states, sensory stimulation results in a
local and transient perturbation failing to propagate to more widespread networks related to
conscious perception.
At other spatial and temporal scales, evidence for an association between consciousness and
critical dynamics has been obtained in the context of deep sleep (Priesemann et al. 2013),
anesthesia (Alonso et al. 2014; Scott et al. 2014) and epileptic seizures (Meisel et al. 2012).
Here we introduced the coupling between anatomical and functional connectivity as a
signature of the critical state, which is particularly fit for fMRI recordings since both can be
measured at the same spatial resolution using this technique. Propofol-induced loss of
consciousness resulted in diminished anatomical-functional coupling, interpreted here as a
departure from the critical regime characteristic of conscious wakeful rest (Tagliazucchi et al
2012, Expert et al. 2010). Changes in function-anatomy uncoupling can be understood in
terms of the emergence of long-range correlations at criticality. The term “long-range” must be
treated with caution when discussing the human brain, since regions far away in Euclidean
space may be close together in a topological sense (i.e. directly connected anatomically).
Thus, we did not expect to see a breakdown of long-range functional connectivity as a
13"
function of Euclidean distance following the departure from criticality, but a separation from
the structural connectivity backbone instead.
Recent work on anesthetized primates (Barttfeld et al. 2015A) found that transient patterns of
functional connectivity strongly resembling the anatomical constraints were more frequent
during loss of consciousness relative to wakefulness, which appears to contradict our results.
However, two important differences must be taken into account. First, we found diminished
anatomy-function coupling over extended periods of time, which is related to the average of
the functional connectivity states visited over time (as an analogy, mapping the average route
traced by cars in a city throughout a entire day, as opposed to taking instantaneous
snapshots). Second, the effect we report was regionally localized to a set of frontal regions
and the thalamus, as opposed to the global effect reported in Barttfeld et al. 2015A. This last
distinction is very important since the richness of anatomical connectivity varies throughout
the brain, from the regular structure of the cerebellum and primary cortices to the highly
complex, variable and phylogenetically advanced frontal and parietal associative cortices
(Kaas et al. 2013; Rilling et al. 2014). Indeed, we observed that the functional exploration of
fronto-thalamic anatomical connectivity was hindered under propofol, highlighting
its
importance for the maintenance of conscious awareness. We note that decreased similarity
between anatomical and functional connectivity could also result from the selective
enhancement of functional connections that are not associated with structural links (as an
analogy, cars taking “shortcuts” across regions not directly connected by roads). This
possibility is ruled out by the breakdown of within- and between-network functional
connectivity observed during propofol-induced unconsciousness (Boveroux et al. 2010).
We also studied the dynamics of BOLD signals, which have received comparatively less
attention in the context of anesthesia than electrophysiological recordings. We observed a
departure from slow and temporally correlated dynamics in frontal regions and in the
thalamus. These areas strongly overlap with those where decreased metabolism under
anesthesia was reported (Alkire et al. 1997; Kaisti et al. 2002; Laitio et al. 2007; Bonhomme
et al. 2008). Breakdown of long-range temporal correlations was also reported in other
unconscious brain states such as deep non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep (Tagliazucchi
et al. 2013a). This led us to hypothesize that long-range temporal correlations of spontaneous
activity fluctuations are a primary characteristic of brain activity during conscious wakeful rest.
Phenomenologically, the subjective feeling of continuity during conscious wakefulness
(“stream of consciousness”, as famously phrased by William James [James, 1980]) cannot be
supported by short-range temporal correlations as exhibited, for example, in Markovian
dynamics (when the state of the system depends only on the immediately previous state).
The short-term persistence of conscious information is impossible under these dynamics
unless structural changes occur, which likely belong to a completely different temporal scale
(Bullmore and Sporns 2009).
14"
respiration
functional responses during propofol-induced
The main limitation of our manuscript arises from the indirect nature of fMRI recordings and
the possibility of propofol influencing other physiological variables that are not directly related
to the level of consciousness. Experimental evidence shows that the effects of propofol on
arterial blood pressure and cerebral blood flow are small (Fiset et al., 2005; Liu et al., 2013;
Veselis et al., 2005; Johnston et al., 2003), ruling out confounds related to pressure-
dependent changes in BOLD signals. As discussed by Hudetz and colleagues (Hudetz et al.,
2015), confounds due to alterations in neurovascular coupling are also unlikely given the
preservation of
loss of consciousness
(Franceschini et al., 2010). Experiments measuring cardiac and
rates
simultaneously with fMRI during propofol-induced loss of consciousness did not find a
significant difference vs. conscious wakefulness (e.g. Schröter et al., 2012). Another
possibility is that our results reflect the concentration of propofol in blood but not the
responsiveness of the participants (Barttfeld et al., 2015B). One argument against our results
reflecting the increasing concentration of propofol in blood is the fact that we did not observe
any significant effects under propofol-induced sedation
(a state characterized by
responsiveness in spite of non-zero propofol plasma concentration). Our results were specific
to unconsciousness, as determined by the onset of state of unresponsiveness (Ramsay et
al., 1974).
In summary, we achieved an empirical characterization of large-scale brain activity during
propofol-induced unconsciousness in terms of inter-related changes in spatial and temporal
correlations. In analogy to other complex systems undergoing phase transitions, the dynamics
became temporally uncorrelated during unconsciousness and failed to efficiently explore the
underlying structural connections. Since the proposed interpretation is based on general
principles of complex systems, further research should reveal the universality of our findings
across other brain states of diminished awareness, as well as investigate their applicability for
the objective assessment of levels of consciousness.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This work was funded by the Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung (grant 01 EV
0703) and the LOEWE Neuronale Koordination Forschungsschwerpunkt Frankfurt (NeFF).
We thank Ben Palanca and two anonymous reviewers for valuable comments on this
manuscript, Ed Bullmore and Nicolas Crossley for sharing the DTI data and Patric Hagmann
and Olaf Sporns for sharing the DSI data.
REFERENCES
15"
Alkire, M.T.M., Haier, R.J.P., Shah, N.K.M. & Anderson, C.T.M. 1997 Positron emission tomography
study of regional cerebral metabolism in humans during isoflurane anesthesia. Anesthesiology 86(3),
549-557.
Alkire, M.T., Hudetz, A.G. & Tononi, G. 2008 Consciousness and anesthesia. Science 322(5903), 876-
880.l
Alonso, L.M., Proekt, A., Schwartz, T.H., Pryor, K.O., Cecchi, G.A. & Magnasco, M.O. 2014 Dynamical
criticality during induction of anesthesia in human ECoG recordings. Front. Neural Circuits 8.
Amico, E., Gomez, F., Di Perri, C., Vanhaudenhuyse, A., Lesenfants, D., Boveroux, P., Bonhomme, V.,
Brichant, J.F., Marinazzo, D., Laureys, S. 2014 Posterior cingulate cortex-related co-activation patterns:
a resting state fMRI study in propofol-induced loss of consciousness. Plos ONE, doi:
10.1371/journal.pone.0100012
Barttfeld, P., Uhrig, L., Sitt, J.D., Sigman, M., Jarraya, B. & Dehaene, S. 2015A Signature of
consciousness in the dynamics of resting-state brain activity. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 112(3), 887-
892.
Barttfeld, P., Bekinschtein, T. A., Salles, A., Stamatakis, E. A., Adapa, R., Menon, D. K., Sigman, M.
2015B Factoring the brain signatures of anesthesia concentration and level of arousal across
individuals. NeuroImage: Clinical 9, 385-391.
Beckmann, C.F., DeLuca, M., Devlin, J.T. & Smith, S.M. 2005 Investigations into resting-state
connectivity using independent component analysis. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. B 360(1457), 1001-1013.
Boly, M., Moran, R., Murphy, M., Boveroux, P., Bruno, M.A., Noirhomme, Q., Ledoux, D., Bonhomme,
V., Brichant, J.F., Tononi, G., Laureys, S. & Friston, K. 2012 Connectivity changes underlying spectral
EEG changes during propofol-induced loss of consciousness. J. Neurosci. 32(20), 7082-7090.
Bonhomme, V., Maquet, P., Phillips, C., Plenevaux, A., Hans, P., Luxen, A., Lamy, M. & Laureys, S.
2008 The effect of clonidine
in
volunteers. Anesthesia & Analgesia 106(3), 899-909.
Boveroux, P., Vanhaudenhuyse, A., Bruno, M.A., Noirhomme, Q., Lauwick, S., Luxen, A., Degueldre,
C., Plenevaux, A., Schnakers, C., Phillips, C., Brichant, J., Bonhomme, V., Maquet, P., Greicius, M.,
Laureys, S. & Boly, M. 2010 Breakdown of within-and between-network resting state functional magnetic
resonance imaging connectivity during propofol-induced loss of consciousness. Anesthesiology, 113(5),
1038-1053.
Bullmore, E. & Sporns, O. 2009 Complex brain networks: graph theoretical analysis of structural and
functional systems. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 10(3), 186-198.
Burgess, A. P., Rehman, J., Williams, J. D. 2003 Changes in neural complexity during the perception of
3D images using random dot stereograms. Int J Psychophysiol 48, 35-42.
infusion on distribution of
regional cerebral blood
flow
16"
in cortical effective connectivity during midazolam-induced
Casali, A.G., Gosseries, O., Rosanova, M., Boly, M., Sarasso, S., Casali, K.R., Casarotto, S., Bruno,
M.A., Laureys, S., Tononi, G. & Massimini, M. 2013 A theoretically based index of consciousness
independent of sensory processing and behavior. Sci. Trans. Med. 5(198), 198ra105-198ra105.
Chialvo, D.R. 2010 Emergent complex neural dynamics. Nature Physics 6(10), 744-750.
Deco, G., McIntosh, A.R., Shen, K., Hutchison, R.M., Menon, R.S., Everling, S., Hagmann, P., Jirsa,
V.K. 2014 Identification of optimal structural connectivity using functional connectivity and neural
modeling. J Neurosci 34, 7910-7916.
Dehaene, S. & Naccache, L. 2001 Towards a cognitive neuroscience of consciousness: basic evidence
and a workspace framework. Cognition, 79, 1-37.
Expert, P., Lambiotte, R., Chialvo, D.R., Christensen, K., Jensen, H.J., Sharp, D.J. & Turkheimer, F.
2010 Self-similar correlation function in brain resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging. J.
Roy. Soc. Interface, rsif20100416.
Ferrarelli, F., Massimini, M., Sarasso, S., Casali, A., Riedner, B.A., Angelini, G., Tononi, G. & Pearce,
R.A. 2010 Breakdown
loss of
consciousness. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 107(6), 2681-2686.
Fiset, P., Plourde, G., Backman, S. B. 2005 Brain imaging in research on anesthetic mechanisms:
studies with propofol. Prog Brain Res 150, 245-598.
Franceschini, M. A., Radhakrishnan, H., Thakur, K., Wu, W., Ruvinskaya, S., Carp, S., Boas, D. A. 2010
The effect of different anesthetics on neurovascular coupling. Neuroimage 51, 1367-1377.
Greicius, M.D., Supekar, K., Menon, V. & Dougherty, R.F. 2009 Resting-state functional connectivity
reflects structural connectivity in the default mode network. Cereb. Cortex 19(1), 72-78.
Haimovici, A., Tagliazucchi, E., Balenzuela, P. & Chialvo, D.R. 2013 Brain organization into resting state
networks emerges at criticality on a model of the human connectomes. Phys. Rev. Lett. 110(17),
178101.
He, B.J. 2011 Scale-free properties of the functional magnetic resonance imaging signal during rest and
task. J. Neurosci. 31(39), 13786-13795.
Hermundstad, A.M., Bassett, D.S., Brown, K.S., Aminoff, E.M., Clewett, D., Freeman, S., Frithsen, A.,
Johnson, A., Tipper, C., Miller, M.B., Grafton, S.T. & Carlson, J.M. 2013 Structural foundations of
resting-state and task-based functional connectivity in the human brain. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.
USA 110(15), 6169-6174.
Hudetz, A. G., Liu, X., Pillay, S. 2015 Dynamic repertoire of intrinsic brain states is reduced in propofol-
induced unconsciousness. Brain connectivity 5, 10-22.
17"
Imas, O.A., Ropella, K.M., Ward, B.D., Wood, J.D. & Hudetz, A.G. 2005 Volatile anesthetics disrupt
frontal-posterior recurrent information transfer at gamma frequencies in rat. Neurosci. Lett. 387(3), 145-
150.
James, W. 1890 The Principles of Psychology. ed. George A. Miller, Harvard University Press, 1983
Johnston, A. J., et al. 2003 Effects of propofol on cerebral oxygenation and metabolism after head
injury. Brit J Anaesth 91, 781-786.
Kaas, J.H., Gharbawie, O.A. & Stepniewska, I. 2013 Cortical networks for ethologically relevant
behaviors in primates. Am. J. Primatol. 75(5), 407-414.
Kaisti, K.K., Metsähonkala, L., Teräs, M., Oikonen, V., Aalto, S., Jääskeläinen, S., Hinkka, S. &
Scheinin, H. 2002 Effects of surgical levels of propofol and sevoflurane anesthesia on cerebral blood
flow in healthy subjects studied with positron emission tomography. Anesthesiology 96(6), 1358-1370.
Kantelhardt, J.W., Koscielny-Bunde, E., Rego, H.H., Havlin, S. & Bunde, A. 2001 Detecting long-range
correlations with detrended fluctuation analysis. Physica A 295(3), 441-454.
Kelso, J.S. 2012 Multistability and metastability: understanding dynamic coordination in the brain. Phil.
Trans. Roy. Soc. B 367(1591), 906-918.
Laitio, R.M., Kaisti, K.K., Låangsjö, J.W., Aalto, S., Salmi, E., Maksimow, A., Aantaa, R., Oikonen, V.,
Viljanen, T., Parkkola, R. & Scheinin, H. 2007 Effects of xenon anesthesia on cerebral blood flow in
humans: a positron emission tomography study. Anesthesiology 106(6), 1128-1133.
Lee, U., Mashour, G.A., Kim, S., Noh, G.J. & Choi, B.M. 2009 Propofol induction reduces the capacity
for neural information integration: implications for the mechanism of consciousness and general
anesthesia. Conscious. Cogn. 18(1), 56-64.
Liegeois, R., Ziegler, E., Geurts, P., Gomez, F., Bahri, M.A., Phillips, C., Soddu, A., Vanhaudenhuyse,
A., Laureys, S. & Sepulchre, R. 2014 Cerebral functional connectivity periodically (de) synchronizes with
anatomical constraints. Brain Struct. Func. doi:10.1007/s00429-015-1083-y
Liu, X., Pillay, S., Li, R., Vizuete, J. A., Pechman, K. R., Schmainda, K. M., Hudetz, A. G. 2013
Multiphasic modification of intrinsic functional connectivity of the rat brain during increasing levels of
propofol. Neuroimage 83, 581-592.
Massimini, M., Ferrarelli, F., Huber, R., Esser, S.K., Singh, H. & Tononi, G. 2005 Breakdown of cortical
effective connectivity during sleep. Science 309(5744), 2228-2232.
Maxim, V., Şendur, L., Fadili, J., Suckling, J., Gould, R., Howard, R. & Bullmore, E. 2005 Fractional
Gaussian noise, functional MRI and Alzheimer's disease. Neuroimage 25(1), 141-158.
18"
Meisel, C., Storch, A., Hallmeyer-Elgner, S., Bullmore, E. & Gross, T. 2012 Failure of adaptive self-
organized criticality during epileptic seizure attacks. PLoS Comp. Biol. 8(1), e1002312.
Monti, M.M., Lutkenhoff, E.S., Rubinov, M., Boveroux, P., Vanhaudenhuyse, A., Gosseries, O., Bruno,
M.A., Noirhomme, Q., Boly, M. & Laureys, S. 2013 Dynamic change of global and local information
processing in propofol-induced loss and recovery of consciousness. PLoS Comp. Biol. 9(10), e1003271.
Murphy, M., Bruno, M.A., Riedner, B.A., Boveroux, P., Noirhomme, Q., Landsness, E.C., Brichant, J.F.,
Phillips, C., Massimini, M., Laureys, S., Tononi, G. & Boly, M. 2011 Propofol anesthesia and sleep: a
high-density EEG study. Sleep 34(3), 283.
Pigorini, A., Sarasso, S., Proserpio, P., Szymanski, C., Arnulfo, G., Casarotto, S., Fecchio, M.,
Rosanova, M., Mariotti, M., Lo Russo, G., Palva, J.M., Nobili, L. & Massimini, M. 2015 Bistability breaks-
off deterministic responses to intracortical stimulation during non-REM sleep. NeuroImage 112, 105-
113.
Nir, Y., Fisch, L., Mukamel, R., Gelbard-Sagiv, H., Arieli, A., Fried, I. & Malach, R. 2007 Coupling
between neuronal firing rate, gamma LFP, and BOLD fMRI is related to interneuronal correlations. Curr.
Biol. 17(15), 1275-1285.
Priesemann, V., Valderrama, M., Wibral, M., & Le Van Quyen, M. 2013 Neuronal avalanches differ from
wakefulness to deep sleep–evidence from intracranial depth recordings in humans. PLoS Comp. Biol.
9(3), e1002985.
Power, J.D., Mitra, A., Laumann, T.O., Snyder, A.Z., Schlaggar, B.L. & Petersen, S.E. 2014 Methods to
detect, characterize, and remove motion artifact in resting state fMRI. Neuroimage 84, 320-341.
Raichle, M.E. 2011 The restless brain. Brain Connectivity 1(1):3-12.
Ramsay, M.A., Savege, T.M., Simpson, B.R. & Goodwin, R. 1974 Controlled sedation with alphaxalone-
alphadolone. Br Med J 2, 656–659. doi: 10.1136/bmj.2.5920.656
Rilling, J.K. 2014 Comparative primate neuroimaging: insights into human brain evolution. Trends in
Cognitive Sciences 18(1), 46-55.
Schröter, M. S., et al. (2012). Spatiotemporal reconfiguration of large-scale brain functional networks
during propofol-induced loss of consciousness. J Neurosci 32, 12832-12840.
Schrouff, J., Perlbarg, V., Boly, M., Marrelec, G., Boveroux, P., Vanhaudenhuyse, A., Bruno, M.A.,
Laureys, S., Phillips, C., Pélégrini-Isaac, M., Maquet, P. & Benali, H. 2011 Brain functional integration
decreases during propofol-induced loss of consciousness. Neuroimage 57(1), 198-205.
Scott, G., Fagerholm, E.D., Mutoh, H., Leech, R., Sharp, D.J., Shew, W.L. & Knöpfel, T. 2014 Voltage
imaging of waking mouse cortex reveals emergence of critical neuronal dynamics. J. Neurosci. 34(50),
16611-16620.
19"
Smith, S.M., Fox, P.T., Miller, K.L., Glahn, D.C., Fox, P.M., Mackay, C.E., Filippini, N., Watkins, K.,
Toro, R., Laird, A.R. & Beckmann, C.F. 2009 Correspondence of the brain's functional architecture
during activation and rest. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 106(31), 13040-13045.
Solovey, G., Alonso, L.M., Yanagawa, T., Fujii, N., Magnasco, M.O., Cecchi, G.A. & Proekt, A. 2015
Loss of consciousness is associated with stabilization of cortical activity. J. Neurosci. 35(30), 10866-
10877.
Sporns, O. 2011 The non-random brain: efficiency, economy, and complex dynamics. Front. Comp.
Neurosci. 5.
Seth, A. 2007 Models of consciousness. Scholarpedia 2(1), 1328.
Stam, C.J., van Straaten, E.C.W., Van Dellen, E., Tewarie, P., Gong, G., Hillebrand, A., Meier, J. & Van
Mieghem, P. 2015 The relation between structural and functional connectivity patterns in complex brain
networks. Int. J. Psychophysiol. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2015.02.011
Tagliazucchi, E., Fraiman, D., Balenzuela, P. & Chialvo, D.R. 2012 Criticality in large-scale brain fMRI
dynamics unveiled by a novel point process analysis. Front. Physiol. 61.
Tagliazucchi, E., von Wegner, F., Morzelewski, A., Brodbeck, V., Jahnke, K. & Laufs, H. 2013a
Breakdown of long-range temporal dependence in default mode and attention networks during deep
sleep. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 110(38), 15419-15424.
Tagliazucchi, E. & Chialvo, D.R. 2013b Brain complexity born out of criticality. In “Physics, Computation
and the Mind - Advances and Challenges at Interfaces-". (J. Marro, P. L. Garrido & J. J. Torres, Eds.)
American Institute of Physics Conf. Proc. 1510, 4.
Tononi, G., Sporns, O., Edelman, G. M. 1994 A measure for brain complexity: relating functional
segregation and integration in the nervous system. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91, 5033-5037.
Tononi, G., & Edelman, G. M. 1998. Consciousness and complexity. Science 282, 1846-1851.
Tzourio-Mazoyer, N., Landeau, N., Papathanassiou, B., Crivello, D., Etard, O., Delcroix, N., Mazoyer, B.
Joliot, M. 2002 Automated anatomical labeling of activations in SPM using a macroscopic anatomical
parcellation of the MNI MRI single-subject brain. NeuroImage 15, 273-289.
Veselis, R. A., Feshchenko, V. A., Reinsel, R. A., Beattie, B., Akhurst, T. J. 2005 Propofol and thiopental
do not interfere with regional cerebral blood flow response at sedative concentrations. Anesthesiology
102, 26-34.
Wang, Z., Chen, L.M., Négyessy, L., Friedman, R.M., Mishra, A., Gore, J.C. & Roe, A.W. 2013 The
relationship of anatomical and
in primate
somatosensory cortex. Neuron 78(6), 1116-1126.
to resting-state connectivity
functional connectivity
20"
Werner, G. 2007 Metastability, criticality and phase transitions in brain and its models. Biosystems
90(2), 496-508.
Werner, G. 2013 Consciousness related brain processes viewed in the framework of phase space
dynamics, criticality, and the renormalization group. Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 55, 3-12.
21"
FIGURE CAPTIONS
Figure 1: Anatomical specificity of long-range temporal correlations and low frequency
(0.01-0.1 Hz) fluctuations. (A) Anatomical overlays of the mean Hurst exponent (DFA and
wavelet estimation) and low frequency power for all experimental conditions; long-range
temporal correlations and low frequency fluctuations were predominantly observed in cortical
and sub-cortical grey matter. (B) Differences in global Hurst exponents and low frequency
power relative to the values measured during wakefulness (*p<0.05, Bonferroni corrected for
multiple comparisons).
Figure 2: Breakdown of long-range temporal correlations and reduced low frequency
power fluctuations during propofol-induced loss of consciousness. (A) Top: Main effect
of experimental condition (wakefulness, sedation, loss of consciousness and recovery) on the
Hurst exponent (DFA) and low frequency power. Bottom: Reduced Hurst exponent and low
frequency power during loss of consciousness compared to wakefulness. Both statistical
significance maps were thresholded at p<0.05, FDR-controlled for multiple comparisons. (B)
Regions in the AAL atlas ranked according to their differences between wakefulness and loss
of consciousness. (C) Combined anatomical overlay of the three metrics presented in Panel
A.
Figure 3: Regional dissociation of anatomical and functional connectivity during loss
of consciousness. Results in the left column were obtained using the DTI network with 401
nodes, those in the right column using the DSI network with 998 nodes. (A) Similarity
(correlation coefficient) between anatomical and functional connectivity networks within the
executive control RSN as a function of link density, obtained during wakefulness (blue) and
loss of consciousness (red). (B) Anatomical overlay of regions with significant increases in
anatomical-functional distance during loss of consciousness vs. wakefulness. (C) Ranking of
AAL regions according to the percentage of nodes they contained with significant differences
in anatomical-functional distance. (D) Joint anatomical rendering of results obtained using the
DTI and DSI anatomical connectivity networks.
Figure 4: Changes in long-range temporal correlations and anatomical-functional
coupling are correlated during loss of consciousness. (A) Left: Correlation coefficient
between the Hurst exponent (DFA and wavelet estimation) and low frequency power
averaged over the regions in Fig. 3B, and the average distance between anatomical (DTI)
and functional connectivity; results are shown as a function of the link density. Right: same
computation for the DSI network. (B) Scatter plots of anatomy-function distance vs. H (DFA
and wavelet estimation) for a reference link density of 0.15 (light blue dashed line in panel A).
22"
Figure 5: Unconsciousness increases network stability and decreases the repertoire of
transient network states. (A) The variance of transient average connectivity within the
executive control RSN as a function of non-overlapping window size, for wakefulness and
loss of consciousness. (B) TNS index (computed using non-overlapping windows of 20
volumes) for wakefulness and loss of consciousness.
Figure 6: Dynamics and connectivity of the model. (A) Left: Similarity between anatomical
and functional (i.e. simulated) connectivity as a function of the threshold T. Right: Hamming
distance between anatomical and functional node connectivity neighborhoods (averaged
across all nodes) as a function of T. In both cases, the highest anatomical-functional coupling
is observed close to the critical point (T = TC). (B) Left: Frequency of node activations as a
function of T. Right: Mean anatomical-functional distance as a function of frequency of node
activations and Hurst exponent of average activity of the model. As in the experimental data,
higher frequency of activations and diminished long-range temporal correlations paralleled the
dissociation between anatomical and functional connectivity patterns.
Figure 7: The sensitivity to external perturbations is maximal near the phase transition
of the model. (A) Average time course after a perturbation (activation of 60% of the nodes)
during the critical and supercritical regimes. (B) Decay of activity after a perturbation for a
range of thresholds. (C) Decay time as a function of T. The longest decay times are obtained
when T = TC.
Figure 8: Schematic representation of the dynamics of a system far and near the
critical point of a phase transition. The state of the system at a given time is represented
by the position of the particle on the potential landscape U(x). The system at equilibrium
(green) is perturbed at t0 subsequently relaxing (red, t1→ t2) at different speeds depending on
whether it is far (left) or near (right) a phase transition. Far from the transition (left) the system
is stable and the local minima (equilibrium points) are deep, consequently dynamics are
rapidly restored and the effects of perturbation are short-lasting. Near the phase transition
(right) the landscape of the potential is shallow and consequently the stability of the local
minima decreases, which is reflected in the time domain (middle panels) as a slowing down of
the system response to fluctuations. The change in stability can be also observed spatially
because it affects the exploration of the different metastable states of the system. The graphs
denoted by SC (structural connectivity) represent a portion of the underlying structural
network. The bottom diagram (FC; functional connectivity) denotes the structural paths
traversed during an interval of time. For shallow local minima the structural paths leading from
node A to the rest of the nodes (B, C, D, E) are equally likely, resulting in a complete
exploration of the underlying structural connectivity. On the contrary, far from the transition
(left) the potential barriers separating the nodes are taller, leading to the observation of only a
portion (in this case only one) of all possible paths.
23"
Figure 1
24"
Figure 2
25"
Figure 3
26"
Figure 4
27"
Figure 5
28"
Figure 6
29"
Figure 7
30"
Figure 8
31"
|
1706.00603 | 1 | 1706 | 2017-06-02T09:25:28 | Classification of meaningful and meaningless visual objects: a graph similarity approach | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Cognition involves dynamic reconfiguration of functional brain networks at sub-second time scale. A precise tracking of these reconfigurations to categorize visual objects remains elusive. Here, we use dense electroencephalography (EEG) data recorded during naming meaningful (tools, animals) and scrambled objects from 20 healthy subjects. We combine technique for identifying functional brain networks and recently developed algorithm for estimating networks similarity to discriminate between the two categories. First, we showed that dynamic networks of both categories can be segmented into several brain network states (times windows with consistent brain networks) reflecting sequential information processing from object representation to reaction time. Second, using a network similarity algorithm, results showed high intra-category and very low inter-category values. An average accuracy of 76% was obtained at different brain network states. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Classification of meaningful and meaningless visual
objects: a graph similarity approach
Ahmad Mheich1, Mahmoud Hassan2,3, Fabrice Wendling2,3
1 Télécom SudParis, EPH, Évry, F-91000, France
2INSERM, U1099, Rennes, F-35000, France
3 Université de Rennes 1, LTSI, F-35000, France
Abstract- Cognition involves dynamic reconfiguration of
functional brain networks at sub-second time scale. A precise
tracking of these reconfigurations to categorize visual objects
remains elusive. Here, we use dense electroencephalography
(EEG) data recorded during naming meaningful
(tools,
animals…) and scrambled objects from 20 healthy subjects. We
combine technique for identifying functional brain networks and
recently developed algorithm for estimating networks similarity
to discriminate between the two categories. First, we showed that
dynamic networks of both categories can be segmented into
several brain network states (times windows with consistent
brain networks) reflecting sequential information processing
from object representation to reaction time. Second, using a
network similarity algorithm, results showed high intra-category
and very low inter-category values. An average accuracy of 76%
was obtained at different brain network states.
electroencephalography (EEG, 256 channels) data from
subjects performing a cognitive task corresponds to name two
categories of pictures
(meaningless and meaningful).
Functional brain networks for each object in both categories
were estimated using 'dense-EEG source connectivity' method
[7], [8]. These brain networks were then segmented into brain
network states (BNS) using a k-means clustering method [9].
At each BNS, the similarity between networks were computed
using an algorithm called 'SimNet' [10], [11]. The main
feature of SimNet is the taking into consideration the spatial
location of nodes in order to find the similarity scores between
graphs, a key feature in the brain network analysis context.
The results showed a high performance of the proposed
network similarity-based approach to differentiate between
visual object categories.
Keywords-Dense-EEG source connectivity, Brain networks,
network simialrity
II. MATERIALS AND METHODS
I.
INTRODUCTION
The human brain is a complex network of functionally
interconnected distant brain regions. There is increasing
evidence that the dynamic reconfiguration of this network is a
crucial aspect to understand information processing in the
human brain [1]. Recently, many studies showed that the
dynamic reconfiguration of the brain networks is related to
different brain functions such as learning [2] and disease
progression [3] at different time scales mainly minutes, hours
and days [3]. A precise tracking of these reconfigurations at
sub-second time scale is challenging. One of these fast time
scale cognitive activities is the object recognition and
categorization. This cognitive function occurs in sub-second
time period.
The existed literature related to object categorization is
mainly focused on the time/frequency analysis of the evoked
responses. It was used to differentiate between non-natural vs.
natural [4], [5] made vs. non-made [4] and human vs. non-
human [6] objects. To what extent the semantic category of
the visual
the dynamic
reconfiguration of the functional brain networks is still
unclear.
stimuli can be
related
to
To
tackle
this
issue,
we
collected
dense-
This work was supported by the Rennes University Hospital (COREC Project
named BrainGraph, 2015-17). The work has also received a French
government support granted to the CominLabs excellence laboratory and
managed by the National Research Agency in the "Investing for the Future"
program under reference ANR-10-LABX-07-01. Authors would like to thank
Dufor O. for his help in the data acquisition.
A. Experimental protocol
Twenty healthy volunteers (10 women and 10 men; mean
age, 23 y) with no neurological disease were involved in this
study. 79 meaningful and 40 scrambled pictures were
displayed and the participants were asked to name them. All
pictures were shown as black drawings on a white
background. Errors in naming were removed for the further
analysis and the signals of one participant were eliminated as
data were very noisy. The brain activity was recorded using
dense-EEG, 256 electrodes, system (EGI, Electrical Geodesic
Inc.) with a 1 kHz sampling frequency providing a high
temporal resolution and band-pass filtered between 3 and
45Hz. Each
inspected, and epochs
contaminated by eye blinking, movements or any other
artifacts were rejected and excluded from the analysis
performed using the EEGLAB and Brainstorm open source
toolboxes [12], [13].
trial was visually
B. Functional connectivity analysis
Functional connectivity matrices were estimated using
EEG source connectivity method [8]. Briefly, the method
includes two main steps: i) solving the EEG inverse problem
to reconstruct cortical sources and ii) measuring the functional
connectivity between the reconstructed regional time series.
We used the weighted Minimum Norm Estimate (wMNE) to
reconstruct the cortical sources and the phase locking value
(PLV) method to compute the functional connectivity. This
measure (range between 0 and 1) reflects interactions between
oscillatory signals by quantifying their phase relationships.
The PLVs were estimated at the gamma frequency band (30-
45 Hz). The whole brain was parcellated into a set of 68
regions of interest identified by Desikan atlas [14]. The choice
of wMNE/PLV was supported by two comparative analysis
performed in [7][15].
C. Analysis steps and practical issues
In order to discriminate the brain connectivity networks
related to each category, several steps were performed and
summarized as following:
Step 1 – Brain network states: to track the dynamics
of the brain functional connectivity, we used a
segmentation algorithm that allows decomposing the
cognitive task into brain network states over time. This
algorithm is based on the k-means clustering of the
connectivity matrices, see [11] [12] for detailed
description of the method. The averaged connectivity
matrices over all subjects were first obtained. The
application of
the averaged
connectivity matrix has led to six different functional
connectivity clusters.
the algorithm on
Step 2 - Functional connectivity matrix per picture:
The functional connectivity matrix for each picture was
computed over available trials (in total 119 functional
connectivity matrices were obtianed). These matrices
are segmented into six temporal windows as obtained
in step 1.
Step 3 – Similarity between brain networks: At each
temporal window, the averaged connectivity matrix
over time is computed for all pictures. The similarity
score between all the connectivity networks for all
pictures is computed to get 6 similarity matrices
(119×119). The similarity score is computed using
SimNet algorithm.
Step 4 – Modules in similarity matrices: After
calculating the similarity scores between the functional
brain networks at each window,
the Louvain
modularity maximization method [16] was computed
to every similarity matrix 100 times as the modularity
index Q may vary from run to run, due to heuristic
property of the algorithm. This produces a 119×119
matrix where values represent the probability of each
two networks to be in the same module for all runs. We
used Gephi [17] software to visualize the graph
presentation of the modules, where the nodes represent
the brain connectivity networks of pictures and the
edges represent the similarity score between two brain
connectivity networks of two different pictures.
III. RESULTS
A. Functional connectivity states and networks simialrity
We apply the segmentation algorithm on the averaged
connectivity matrices over all subjects, which led to 6 different
clusters. The first cluster corresponds to the period ranging
from t=0 (onset: presentation of the visual stimulus) to t=80
ms. The second cluster correspond to the period from 81ms to
195 ms. The third cluster from 196 ms to 276 ms, the fourth
cluster correspond to the period from 277 ms to 384 ms, the
fifth cluster correspond to the period from 285 ms to 460 ms
and the sixth cluster from 461 ms to 620 ms. In order to
measure the similarity between the meaningful and the
meaningless pictures, the functional connectivity matrix for
each picture was calculated to get 119 functional connectivity
matrices (79 meaningful and 40 meaningless). SimNet was
then applied between each pair of these networks, leading to a
119 x 119 similarity matrice. In figure 1, we show the results
at the second brain network states (81- 195ms). The rows and
the columns in this matrix represent the functional networks of
the visual objects. Each voxel in this matrix represent a
similarity score between each of two brain networks.
Figure 1: UP: Similarity matrix between brain networks identified from
EEG during the second period (81- 195 ms) obtained from the
segmentation algorithm, where the rows and columns represent the
functional connectivity networks for all pictures (119 pictures). Bottom:
two typical examples with 3D representation for two different similarity
score (high similarity and low similarity) selected from the above
similarity matrices.
Figure 2: Results of application the modularity algorithm to the similarity matrix during the second period of the cognitive response.
In figure 1, we show also two typical examples of brain
networks with high similarity values and low similarity values,
where the node size represents the 'strength' of the network
measure defined as the sum of weights of edges connected to
this node. For instance, a high similarity was measured
between the network obtained between two meaningless
pictures (pictures 84 and 113). In contrast, a low similarity
index was computed between the network obtained between
one meaningful picture and another meaningless picture
(pictures 39 and 81).
B. Meaningful vs. meaningless
Here, we apply the Louvain-algorithm on the similarity matrix
where two main modules were detected. The graphical
representations of these modules are presented in Figure 2
where the orange nodes represent meaningful pictures and the
green nodes represent meaningless pictures. A global accuracy
of 76% was obtained.
IV. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
Understanding the information processing in the human
brain and how the visual object categories are represented in
the brain network is a big challenge. Several studies have
found differences in the activated brain regions specified for
object categories (animals, tools, faces…). Some of these
studies have suggested that each category of objects is
represented in a specific brain region [18]. Other studies
showed that one brain region may represent many categories
[19]. Huth et al. [20] used the brain activity recorded from
subjects when watching natural movies, to study how the
objects and the actions can be categorized in the brain. They
found that the objects categories are regrouped in continuous
semantic space across the brain areas.
In this paper, we present a new approach to differentiate
between the visual object categories in the human brain based
on brain network similarity. We combine both 'dense EEG
source connectivity method' and network similarity algorithm
'SimNet' to investigate the categorization of the human brain
networks. The combination was applied on visual task consist
of naming pictures from two categories (meaningful and
meaningless). To our knowledge, this study constitutes the
first attempt to assess categorization in the human brain from a
network-based approach between meaningful and meaningless
pictures using dense-EEG recordings.
Methodological considerations: first a crucial parameter
must be tuned in SimNet is the radius of the disk used to count
the neighbors of a given node. An increase of the radius R will
automatically lead to an increase of the similarity index
between the two compared graphs. In the application on the
real data, R was chosen as the average distance between all
nodes (R=0.06). Second, it is worth mentioning here that the
similarity scores between brain networks were calculated by
taking the strongest 10% of edges in the connectivity matrices.
Testing other threshold values or other threshold strategies is
necessary to guarantee the robustness of the results. Third, we
considered several values of the resolution parameter γ (used
to compute the modularity) and γ=1 was the good compromise
between number for modules and nodes associated with each
module (as reported also by many studies [21]).
REFERENCES
O. Sporns, Networks of the Brain. MIT press, 2011.
D. S. Bassett, N. F. Wymbs, M. P. Rombach, M. A. Porter, P. J.
Mucha, and S. T. Grafton, "Task-based core-periphery organization
of human brain dynamics," PLoS Comput biol, vol. 9, no. 9, p.
e1003171, 2013.
F. Siebenhühner, S. A. Weiss, R. Coppola, D. R. Weinberger, and
D. S. Bassett, "Intra-and inter-frequency brain network structure in
health and schizophrenia," PLoS One, vol. 8, no. 8, p. e72351, 2013.
L. L. Chao, J. V Haxby, and A. Martin, "Attribute-based neural
substrates in temporal cortex for perceiving and knowing about
objects," Nat. Neurosci., vol. 2, no. 10, pp. 913–919, 1999.
J. V Haxby, E. A. Hoffman, and M. I. Gobbini, "The distributed
human neural system for face perception," Trends Cogn. Sci., vol. 4,
no. 6, pp. 223–233, 2000.
R. M. Cichy, D. Pantazis, and A. Oliva, "Resolving human object
recognition in space and time," Nat. Neurosci., vol. 17, no. 3, pp.
455–462, 2014.
M. Hassan, O. Dufor, I. Merlet, C. Berrou, and F. Wendling, "EEG
source connectivity analysis: from dense array recordings to brain
networks," PLoS One, vol. 9, no. 8, p. e105041, 2014.
M. Hassan, P. Benquet, A. Biraben, C. Berrou, O. Dufor, and F.
Wendling, "Dynamic reorganization of functional brain networks
during picture naming," Cortex, 2015.
A. Mheich, M. Hassan, M. Khalil, C. Berrou, and F. Wendling, "A
new algorithm for spatiotemporal analysis of brain functional
connectivity," J. Neurosci. Methods, 2015.
A. Mheich, M. Hassan, V. Gripon, M. Khalil, C. Berrou, O. Dufor,
and F. Wendling, "A novel algorithm for measuring graph
similarity: application to brain networks," in Neural Engineering
(NER), 2015 7th International IEEE/EMBS Conference on, 2015,
pp. 1068–1071.
A. Mheich, M. Hassan, F. Wendling, M. Khalil, O. Dufor, V.
Gripon, and C. Berrou, "SimNet: A new algorithm for measuring
brain networks similarity," in Advances in Biomedical Engineering
(ICABME), 2015 International Conference on, 2015, pp. 119–122.
[12]
[13]
[14]
[15]
[16]
[17]
[18]
[19]
[20]
[21]
A. Delorme and S. Makeig, "EEGLAB: an open source toolbox for
analysis of single-trial EEG dynamics including independent
component analysis," J. Neurosci. Methods, vol. 134, no. 1, pp. 9–
21, 2004.
F. Tadel, S. Baillet, J. C. Mosher, D. Pantazis, and R. M. Leahy,
"Brainstorm: a user-friendly application for MEG/EEG analysis,"
Comput. Intell. Neurosci., vol. 2011, p. 8, 2011.
R. S. Desikan, F. Ségonne, B. Fischl, B. T. Quinn, B. C. Dickerson,
D. Blacker, R. L. Buckner, A. M. Dale, R. P. Maguire, and B. T.
Hyman, "An automated labeling system for subdividing the human
cerebral cortex on MRI scans into gyral based regions of interest,"
Neuroimage, vol. 31, no. 3, pp. 968–980, 2006.
M. Hassan, I. Merlet, A. Mheich, A. Kabbara, and A. Biraben,
"Identification of interictal epileptic networks from dense-EEG,"
Brain Topogr., 2017.
V. D. Blondel, J.-L. Guillaume, R. Lambiotte, and E. Lefebvre,
"Fast unfolding of communities in large networks," J. Stat. Mech.
Theory Exp., vol. 2008, no. 10, p. P10008, 2008.
M. Bastian, S. Heymann, and M. Jacomy, "Gephi: an open source
software for exploring and manipulating networks," ICWSM, vol. 8,
pp. 361–362, 2009.
G. Avidan, U. Hasson, R. Malach, and M. Behrmann, "Detailed
exploration of face-related processing in congenital prosopagnosia:
2. Functional neuroimaging findings," J. Cogn. Neurosci., vol. 17,
no. 7, pp. 1150–1167, 2005.
T. Konkle and A. Oliva, "A real-world size organization of object
responses in occipitotemporal cortex," Neuron, vol. 74, no. 6, pp.
1114–1124, 2012.
A. G. Huth, S. Nishimoto, A. T. Vu, and J. L. Gallant, "A
continuous semantic space describes the representation of thousands
of object and action categories across the human brain," Neuron,
vol. 76, no. 6, pp. 1210–1224, 2012.
D. S. Bassett, N. F. Wymbs, M. A. Porter, P. J. Mucha, J. M.
Carlson, and S. T. Grafton, "Dynamic reconfiguration of human
brain networks during learning," Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., vol. 108,
no. 18, pp. 7641–7646, 2011.
[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
[6]
[7]
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11]
|
1904.02741 | 3 | 1904 | 2019-11-18T17:28:54 | Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1 | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Previous studies suggested that lateral interactions of V1 cells are responsible, among other visual effects, of bottom-up visual attention (alternatively named visual salience or saliency). Our objective is to mimic these connections with a neurodynamic network of firing-rate neurons in order to predict visual attention. Early visual subcortical processes (i.e. retinal and thalamic) are functionally simulated. An implementation of the cortical magnification function is included to define the retinotopical projections towards V1, processing neuronal activity for each distinct view during scene observation. Novel computational definitions of top-down inhibition (in terms of inhibition of return and selection mechanisms), are also proposed to predict attention in Free-Viewing and Visual Search tasks. Results show that our model outpeforms other biologically-inpired models of saliency prediction while predicting visual saccade sequences with the same model. We also show how temporal and spatial characteristics of inhibition of return can improve prediction of saccades, as well as how distinct search strategies (in terms of feature-selective or category-specific inhibition) can predict attention at distinct image contexts. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a
Neurodynamic Model of V1
David Bergaa,ࢩ, Xavier Otazua,b
aComputer Vision Center, Edifici O, Campus UAB, 08193 Bellaterra (Barcelona), Spain
bUniversitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Edifici Q, Campus UAB, 08193 Bellaterra (Barcelona), Spain
A R T I C L E I N F O
Keywords:
scanpath
saccade
attention
search
firing-rate
V1
A B S T R A C T
Previous studies suggested that lateral interactions of V1 cells are responsible, among
other visual effects, of bottom-up visual attention (alternatively named visual salience
or saliency). Our objective is to mimic these connections with a neurodynamic net-
work of firing-rate neurons in order to predict visual attention. Early visual subcortical
processes (i.e. retinal and thalamic) are functionally simulated. An implementation of
the cortical magnification function is included to define the retinotopical projections to-
wards V1, processing neuronal activity for each distinct view during scene observation.
Novel computational definitions of top-down inhibition (in terms of inhibition of return
and selection mechanisms), are also proposed to predict attention in Free-Viewing and
Visual Search tasks. Results show that our model outpeforms other biologically-inpired
models of saliency prediction while predicting visual saccade sequences with the same
model. We also show how temporal and spatial characteristics of inhibition of return
can improve prediction of saccades, as well as how distinct search strategies (in terms of
feature-selective or category-specific inhibition) can predict attention at distinct image
contexts.
1. Introduction
The human visual system (HVS) structure has evolved in a way to efficiently discriminate redundant
information [1, 2, 3]. In order to filter or select the information to be processed in higher areas of visual pro-
cessing in the brain, the HVS guides eye movements towards regions that appear to be visually conspicuous
or distinct in the scene. This phenomenon was observed during visual search tasks [4, 5], where detecting
early visual features (such as orientation, color or size) was done in parallel (pre-attentively) or required
either a serial "binding" step depending on scene context. Koch & Ullman [6] came up with the hypothe-
sis that neuronal mechanisms involved in selective visual attention generate a unique "master" map from
visual scenes, coined with the term "saliency map". From that, Itti, Koch & Niebur [7] presented a compu-
tational implementation of the aforementioned framework (IKN), inspired by the early mechanisms of the
HVS. It was done by extracting properties of the image as feature maps (using a pyramid of difference-of-
gaussian filters at distinct orientations, color and intensity), obtaining feature-wise conspicuity by comput-
ing center-surround differences as receptive field responses and integrating them on a unique map using
winner-take-all mechanisms. Such framework served as a starting point for saliency modeling [8, 9], which
derived in a myriad of computational models, that differed in their computations but conserved a similar
pipeline. From a biological perspective, further hypotheses suggested that primates' visual system structure
was mainly connected to the efficient coding principle. Later studies considered that maximizing informa-
tion of scenes was the key factor on forming visual feature representations. To test that, Bruce & Tsotsos
[10] implemented a saliency model (AIM) by extracting sparse representations of image statistics (using in-
dependent component analysis). These representations were found to be remarkably similar to cells in V1,
which follow similar spatial properties to Gabor filters [11].
While the current concept of saliency maps is to predict probabilities of specific spatial locations as can-
didates of eye movements, it is also crucial to understand how to predict individual fixations or saccade
sequences (also named "scanpaths"). Scanpath predictions were formerly done through probabilistic mea-
sures of saccade amplitude statistics. These followed a similar heavy-tailed distribution to a Cauchy-Levy
ࢩCorresponding author
[email protected] (D. Berga)
orcid(s): 0000-0001-7543-2770 (D. Berga); 0000-0002-4982-791X (X. Otazu)
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 1 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
(in reference to random walks or "Levy flights", minimizing global uncertainty) [12], with highest proba-
bility of fixations at a low saccade amplitude. This procedure was implemented in Boccignone & Ferraro's
model [13], taking saliency from IKN. Later, LeMeur & Liu [14] proposed a more biologically-plausible ap-
proach, accounting for oculomotor biases and inhibition of return effects. It used a graph-based saliency
model (GBVS, also inspired by IKN) [15], with a higher probability to catch grouped fixations (which tend
to be in stimulus center).
In order to evaluate model predictions with eye movement data, certain patterns underlying human eye
movement behavior need to be accounted for a more detailed description and analysis of visual attention.
These effects are found to be dependent on context, discriminability, temporality, task and memory during
scene viewing and visual search [16, 17]. Attention and spatial selection, therefore, is also dependent on
the neuronal activations from both bottom-up and top-down mechanisms. These processes are known to
compete [18] to form a unique representation, termed priority map [19]. These hypotheses suggest that
attention is separated in distinct stages (pre-attentive as bottom-up and attentive as top-down) and that
contributions towards guiding eye movements are simultaneously affected by distinct mechanisms in the
HVS [20]. This competition for visual priority is biased by a term called relevance (as opposed to saliency),
where top-down attention is driven by task demands, working and semantic memory as well as episodic
memory, emotion and motivation (3 of which seem to be unique for each individual and momentum)[21].
At that end, it is stated [22, 23] that visual selection relies on activations from higher-level layers towards
lower-level receptive fields. Therefore, modelization of attention should consider as well the influences of
task and many other top-down effects.
1.1. Objectives
Initial hypotheses by Li [24, 25] suggested that visual saliency is processed by the lateral interactions
of V1 cells. In their work, pyramidal cells and interneurons in the primary visual cortex (V1, Brodmann
Area 17 or striate cortex) and their horizontal intracortical connections are seen to modulate activity in V1.
Li's neurodynamic model [26] of excitatory and inhibitory firing-rate neurons was able to determine how
contextual influences of visual scenes contribute to the formation of saliency. In this model, interactions be-
tween neurons tuned to specific orientation sensitivities served as predictors of pop-out effects and search
asymmetries [27]. Li's neurodynamic model was later extended by Penacchio et al. [28] proposing the afore-
mentioned lateral interactions to also be responsible for brightness induction mechanisms. By considering
neuron orientation selectivity at distinct spatial scales, this model can act as a contrast enhancement mech-
anism of a particular visual area depending of induced activity from surrounding regions. Latest work
from Berga & Otazu [29] has shown that the same model (without changing its parametrization) is able to
predict saliency using real and synthetic color images. We propose to extend the model providing saliency
computations with foveation, concerning distinct viewpoints during scene observation (mapping retinal
projections towards V1 retinotopy) as a main hypothesis for predicting visual scanpaths. Furthermore, we
also test how the model is able to provide predictions considering recurrent feedback mechanisms of al-
ready visited regions, as well as from visual feature and exemplar search tasks with top-down inhibition
mechanisms.
1.2. A unified model of V1 predicts several perceptual processes
Here we present a novel neurodynamic model of visual attention and we remark its biological plausabil-
ity as being able to simultaneously reproduce other effects such as Brightness Induction [28], Chromatic In-
duction [30] and Visual Discomfort [31] effects in previous work. Brightness and Chromatic induction stand
for the variation of perceived luminance and color of a visual target depending on its luminance and/or
chromatic properties as well as for its surrounding area respectively. Thus, a visual target can be perceived
as being different (contrast) or similar (assimilation) to its physical properties by varying its surrounding
context. With the simulations of our model, the output of V1's neuronal activity (coded as firing-rates dur-
ing several cycles of excitatory-inhibitory V1 interneuron interactions), is used as predictor of induction and
saliency respectively. These responses will act as a contrast enhancement mechanism, which for the case of
saliency, are integrated towards projections in the superior colliculus (SC) for eye movement control. There-
with, our model has also been able to reproduce visual discomfort, as relative contrast energy of particular
region on a scene is found to produce hyperexcitability in V1 [32, 33], one of possible causes of producing
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 2 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
certain conditions such as malaise, nausea or even migraine. Previous neurodynamic [34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39]
and saliency models [8, 9, 40] have been able to predict eye movements. However, most of these models have
been built specifically for visual saliency in a free-viewing task, a characteristic that denies their biological
plausibility for modeling distinct visual processing mechanisms or other visual processes simultaneously.
On behalf of model biological plasusibility on V1 function and its computations, we present a unified model
of lateral connections in V1, able to predict attention (both in free-viewing and visual search) from real and
synthetic color images while mimicking physiological properties of the neural circuitry stated previously.
2. Model
2.1. Retinal and LGN responses
The HVS perceives the light at distinct wavelengths of the visual spectrum and separates them to distinct
channels for further processing in the cortex. First, retinal photoreceptors (or RP, corresponding to rod
and cone cells) are photosensitive to luminance (rhodopsin-pigmented) and color (photopsin-pigmented)
[41, 42]. Mammal cone cells are photosensitive to distinct wavelengths between a range of ß 400 − 700,
corresponding to three cell types, measured to be maximally responsive to Long (L, ࣃ 560nm), Medium
(M, ࣃ 530nm) and Short (S, ࣃ 430nm) wavelengths respectively [43]. RP signals are received by
retinal ganglion cells (or RGC) forming an opponent process [44]. This opponent process allows to model
midget, bistratified and parasol cells as "Red vs Green", "Blue vs Yellow", and "Light vs Dark" channels. In
order to simulate these chromatic and light intensity opponencies using digital images, we transformed the
RGB color space to the CIELAB ( or ࢩࢩࢩ) space (including a gamma correction of =1/2.2), as
exemplified in Fig. 1.
Image
RGB components
L* (M-)
a* (P-)
b* (K-)
Figure 1: Example of CIELAB components of color opponencies given a sample image, corresponding to
ࢩ (Intensity), ࢩ (Red-Green) and ࢩ (Blue-Yellow).
(1)
ࢩ = + + ,
ࢩ = −
ࢩ
ࢩ = + − 2
.
,
ࢩ
The ࢩ, ࢩ and ࢩ channels form a cubic color space [45] with RGB opponencies (+=lighter, −=darker,
+=reddish, −=greenish, +=yellowish and −=blueish).
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 3 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
Later, receptive fields in RGC [44] are activated in a center-surround fashion, receiving ON-OFF re-
sponses, being connected to horizontal (H-cell) and bipolar cell (B-cell) upstream circuitry. B-cells are hy-
perpolarized (OFF) or depolarized (ON) according to RP activity. In conjunction, H-cells send excitatory
(center) and inhibitory feedback (surround) to RP. Midget (R-G), bistratified (B-Y) and parasol (L-D) RGC
signals are sent through the optic nerve towards Parvo-, Konio- and Magno-cellular pathways in LGN re-
spectively.
2.2. V1 Hypercolumnar organization
RGC center-surround responses are sent to LGN and projected to V1 cells. V1's cortical hypercolumns
encode similar features of orientation-selective cells at different spatial frequencies. Simple cells found in V1
receptive fields (RFs) are sensitive to center-surround responses at distinct orientations, whereas complex
cells overlap ON and OFF regions (and can be modeled as a combination of simple cell responses). Parvo-
(P- or ), Konio- (K- or ) and Magno-cellular (M- or ) pathways send signals separately towards distinct
layers of the striate cortex (correspondingly projecting to 4 & 6 from "P-", 2ࢧ3 & 4A from "K-" and 4 &
6 from "M-" cell pathways) for parallel and recurrent processing in V1.
We modeled the input to V1's simple cell responses with a 2D "a-trous" wavelet transform [46]. Discrete
wavelet transforms allow to process signals by extracting information of orientation and scale-dependent
features in the visual space (feature maps), which we used for filtering each of the aforementioed opponen-
cies separately, shown in Fig. 2. Although these computations cannot be considered exact to each separate
process of RGC and LGN, the transform seemingly resembles bottom-up activity projected to V1. The "a-
trous" transform is undecimated and invertible, and allows to perform a transform where its basis functions
remain similar to Gabor filters.
Figure 2: Representation of wavelet coefficients (), in conjunction with the output of "a-trous" wavelet
transform applied to components ( = ࢩ, ࢩ, ࢩ) shown in Fig. 1.
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 4 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
The "a trous" wavelet transform can be defined as:
,Ò = −1 − ,Ò,
, = −1 − ,,
+ ,Ò + ,),
= −1 − (,Ò + , + ,).
, = −1 − (,Ò ࣹ Ò߰
where
(2)
,Ò = −1 ࣹ Ò,
, = −1 ࣹ Ò߰
.
(3)
By transposing the wavelet filter (Ò, expressed in Fig. 2) and dilating it at distinct spatial scales ( =
1...), we can obtain a set of wavelet approximation planes (,), that are combined for calculating wavelet
coefficients (,) at distinct orientation selectivities ( = Ò, , ). From these equations, three orientation
selectivities can be extracted, corresponding to horizontal (Ò ࣃ {0 ± 30180 ± 30}º), vertical ( ࣃ {90 ±
30270 ± 30}º) and diagonal ( ࣃ {45 ± 15135 ± 15225 ± 15315 ± 15}º) angles. For the case of scale
features, sensititivies to size (in degree of visual angle) correspond to 20(−1)ࢧ{}, where "" is the
number of pixels for each degree of visual angle according to experimentation, and 0=8, is the minimum
size of the wavelet filter (Ò0) defining the first the scale frequency sensitivity. Initial 0 = is obtained from
the CIE L*a*b* components and corresponds to the residual plane of the last wavelet component (e.g.
= ). The image inverse (߰
) can be obtained by integrating the wavelet , and residual planes :
ࢣ
߰
=
=1,=Ò,,
, + .
(4)
2.3. Cortical mapping
The human eye is composed by RP but these are not homogeneously or equally distributed along the
retina, contrarily to digital cameras. RP are distributed as a function of eccentricity with respect to the
fovea (or central vision)[47]. Fovea's diameter is known to comprise ß5deg of diameter in the visual field,
extended by the parafovea (ß5-9deg), the perifovea (ß9-17deg) and the macula (ß17deg). Central vision is
known to provide maximal resolution at ß1deg of the fovea, whereas in periphery (ß60-180- deg) there is
lower resolution for the retinotopic positions that are further away from the fovea. These effects are known
to affect color, shape, grouping and motion perception of visual objects (even at few degrees of eccentricity),
making performance on attentional mechanisms eccentricity-dependent [48]. Axons from the nasal retina
project to the contralateral LGN, whereas the ones from the temporal retina are connected with the ipsilateral
LGN. These projections [49] make the left visual field send inputs of the LGN towards the right V1 hemifield
(Fig. 3-Right), similarly for the case of the right visual field to the left hemifield of V1.
(, ) = ( + 0),
(, ) = ( ࢧ) − 0.
(5)
(6)
Figure 3: Left: Examples of applying the cortical magnification function (transforming the visual space
to the cortical space) at distinct views of the image presented in Fig. 1. Right: Illustration of how polar
coordinates (Z-plane) of azimuth = (1, 2, 3, 4, 5) in the left visual field at distinct eccentricities = (, , , )
are transformed to the cortical space (W-plane) in mm (X and Yi axis values). Equations 5 & 6 express the
monopole direct and inverse cortical mapping transformations (parameters set as = 12mm and 0 =
1deg [25, Section 2.3.1]). Illustration sketch was adapted from E.L. Schwartz [50], Biol.Cybernetics 25, p.184.
Copyright (1977) by Springer-Verlag.
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 5 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
We have modeled these projections with a cortical magnification function [50][25, Section 2.3.1] using
128 mm of simulated cortical surface (see an example in Fig. 3-Left). The visual space is transformed to
a cortically-magnified space (with its correspondence of millimeter for each degree of visual angle) with a
logarithmic mapping function. The pixel-wise cartesian visual space is transformed to polar coordinates
in terms of eccentricity and azimuth for a specific foveation instance, then transformed to coordinates in
mm of cortical space. Acknowledging that the visual space for digital images is represented with either
a squared or rectangular shape, we computed the continuation of cortical coordinates by symmetrically
mirroring existing coordinates of the image with their correspondence of visual space outside boundaries
in the cortical space. In that manner, we exclude possible effects of zero-padding over recurrent processing
while preserving 2D shapes for our feature representations. For this case, these effects were minimized
by the inverse and repeating the same process at specific interaction cycles. Schwartz's mapping has been
applied over the wavelet coefficients represented in Fig. 2, as basis functions are convolved in the visual
space, later magnified to the cortical space for representing V1 signals. These signals will serve as input to
excitatory pyramidal cells, projected to their respective iso-orientation domains at distinct RF sizes.
2.4. V1 Neuronal Dynamics
Li's hypotheses suggest that V1 computations are responsible of generating a bottom-up saliency map
[24, 25]. These hypotheses state that intracortical interactions between orientation-selective neurons in V1
are able to explain contextually-dependent perceptual effects present in pre-attentive vision [26, 27, 51, 52,
53, 54], relative to contour integration, visual segmentation, visual search asymmetries, figure-ground and
border effects, among others. Pop-out effects that form the saliency map are believed to be the result of
horizontal connections in V1, that interact with each other locally and reciprocally. These connections are
formed by excitatory cells and inhibitory interneurons [55, 56], processing information from pyramidal
cell signals in layers of V1. Spatial organization of these cells accounts for selectivity in their orientation
columns, their RF size and axonal field localization. The aforementioned interactions between orientation-
selective cells was defined by Li's model [26] of excitatory-inhibitory firing-rate neural dynamics, later ex-
tended by Penacchio et al. [28]. Here, contrast enhancement or suppression in neural responses emerge
from lateral connections as an induction mechanism. Latest implementation done by Berga & Otazu [29]
for saliency prediction used colour images, where chromatic (P-,K-) and luminance (M-) opponent channels
were individually processed in order to compute firing-rate dynamics of each pathway separately. With
cortical magnification, each gaze can significantly vary contextual information and therefore the output of
the model.
Our excitatory-inhibitory model1 is described in Table 1. Horizontal connections (lateral and reciprocal)
are schematized in Fig. 4 and Table 1C, where excitatory cells have self-directed (0) and monosynaptic
connections () between each other, whereas dysynaptically connected through ( ) inhibitory interneu-
rons. Axonal field projections (window) follow a concentric toroid of radius Ɗ = 15 × 2−1 and radial
distance Ɗ (accounting for RF size and radial distance ). Membrane potentials of excitatory ( ij) and
inhibitory ( ij) cells are obtained with partial derivative equations defined in Table 1D, composed by a
chain of functions that consider firing-rates (obtained by piece-wise linear functions and ) and mem-
brane potentials from previous membrane cycles (modulated by , constants), current lateral connection
potentials ( and ) and spread of inhibitory activity within hypercolumns (). Background inputs (
and ) correspond to simulating random noise and divisive normalization signals (i.e. accounting for
local nonorientation-specific cortical normalization and nonlinearities). Top-down inhibitory control mech-
anisms () are further explained in Table 1E and in Section 2.6. See the whole model pipeline in Fig. 6.
1Model implementation in MATLAB: https://github.com/dberga/NSWAM
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 6 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
Figure 4: Left: Representation of cortical hypercolumns with scale and orientation selectivity interactions.
Right: Model's intracortical excitatory-inhibitory interactions, membrane potentials (orange " ij" for excita-
tory and yellow " ij" for inhibitory) and connectivities ("" for monosynaptic excitation and " " for dysy-
naptic inhibition).
Input signals (
), splitted between ON and OFF
components (representing ON and OFF-center cell signals from RGC and LGN) depending on the value
polarity (+ for positive and − for negative coefficient values) from the RF. These signals are processed sep-
arately during 10 ( = 1 membrane time = 10), including a rest interval (using an empty input) of 3
to simulate intervals between each saccade shift. The model output has been computed as the firing-rate
)) during the whole viewing time, corre-
average of the ON and OFF components ((+
sponding to a total of 10 membrane time (being the mean of for a specific range of ).
) have been defined as the wavelet coefficients (
) and (−
;
ࢣ
ࢣ
Į
; =
(+
) +
=1..;=Ò,,
=1..;=Ò,,
Figure 5: Firing rates plotted for 10 membrane time (100 iterations) accounting for neurons (ON+OFF val-
ues) inside a specific region (1st col.). Mean firing rates for all scales (Spatial Frequency Dynamics, 2nd
col.), orientations (Orientation Selectivity Dynamics, 3rd col.), and color channels (Chromatic Opponency
Dynamics, 4th col.).
Combining the output of all components by
(−
) +
,
(7)
we can describe the changes of the model (resulting from the simulated lateral interactions of V1) with
respect the original wavelet coefficients
) will define the saliency map as an average
conspicuity map or feature-wise distinctiveness (RF firing rates across scales and orientations for each path-
way). These changes in firing-rate alternatively define the contrast enhancement seen on the brightness and
chromatic induction cases [28, 30, 31], where the model output is combined with the wavelet coefficients
{(
} instead. The network is in total, composed of 1.18 × 106 neurons (accounting for 3 opponent
channels, both ON/OFF polarities and RF sizes of 128 × 64 × 3×8).
. Our result (
;
)
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 7 of 27
RP/RGCLGN-V1V1SC LIP/FEFDLPFCRP/RGCLGNV1LIPFEFDLPFCSCHF/PHCBottom-upTop-downFeedforwardFeedbackRecurrent10132567841Opponent ProcessDiscrete Wavelet Transform234Cortical Magnification FunctionV1 Lateral Interactions6Inhibition of ReturnTop-down visual selection78Retrieve Memory Representations5Inverse Mapping, IDWT, Eucl. Norm12P-M-K-RGBL*a*b*3ωL*ωa*ωb*Isoθθ45ŜM(ωωsoθ)HF/PHCMAXV(ωi,j)new gaze (ωg)..."Orange pepper""Yelloθw pepper"ωL*^ωa*ωb*^^Firing Rates (ωspikes/s)IiorIC+IVSSearch Target678G(ωMAXV(ωi,j))Excitatory neurons (ωJ)Inhibitory neurons (ωW)COD (h)OSD (P-)SFD (d,P-)............ Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
Table 1: Overview of the model, following Nordlie et. al.'s format [57]. Further explanation for model
variables and parameters is in [28, Supporting Information S1].
Model Summary
Excitatory (), Inhibitory ()
--
Feedforward: one-to-all, Feedback: one-to-all,
Lateral: all-to-all (including self-connections)
Dynamic rate model
--
Piece-wise linear synapse
--
External current in lower () or higher () cortical areas and random noise (0)
Firing-rate ( and )
Elements
Sigmoidal-like neuron
Sigmoidal-like neuron
Source
Target
V1 neuron
Dynamic rate model
Populations
Size
= × × Ǝ × = 64 × 128 × 3 × 8
=
Connectivity
Pattern
Excitatory, toric, all to all, non-plastic
Excitatory, constant 0 = 0.8
Inhibitory, toric, all to all, non-plastic
Inhibitory, toric, all to all, non-plastic
Neuron and Synapse Model
A
Populations
Topology
Connectivity
Neuron model
Channel model
Synapse model
Plasticity
Input
Measurements
B
Name
C
Name
0
D
Name
Type
Synaptic
namics
Membrane
potential
E
Type
Sensory
(bottom-up)
Control
(top-down)
dy-
[,߰߰] = (Ɗ)0.126(−ࢧ)2−2(ࢧ)7−2
ࢧ90
[,߰߰] = (Ɗ)0.14(1 − −0.4(ࢧ)1.5)−(Ɗࢧ(ࢧ4))1.5
ij = − − () − ࢣ
+ 0() + ࢣ
ij = − − () + ࢣ
Ɗ,Ɗࣔ0
ࣔ,߰,߰
ࣔ,߰,߰
(Ɗ, Ɗ)( + Ɗ + Ɗ)
[,߰߰](߰߰) + + 0,
[,߰߰](߰߰) +
Input
Description
Input to excitatory neurons,
Input to inhibitory interneurons, = 1.0 + + +
; =
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
F
Mean Firing-rate of excitatory neurons for =10 membrane time ((=[+,−]
Measurements
)).
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 8 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
Figure 6: Diagram illustrating how visual information is processed by NSWAM-CM, including a brain draw-
ing of each bottom-up and top-down mechanisms and their localization in the cortex (Bottom-Right).
2.5. Projections to the SC
Latest hypotheses about neural correlates of saliency [58, 59] state that the superior colliculus is respon-
sible for encoding visual saliency and to guide eye movements [20, 60]. Acknowledging that the superficial
layers of the SC (sSC) receive inputs from the early stages of visual processing (V1, retina), the SC selects
these as the root of bottom-up activity to be selected in the intermediate and deep layers (iSC, dSC). In
accordance to the previous stated hypotheses [24], saccadic eye movements modulated by saliency there-
fore are computed by V1 activity, whereas recurrent and top-down attention is suggested to be processed
by neural correlates in the parieto-frontal cortex and basal ganglia. All these projections are selected as a
winner-take-all mechanism in SC [24, 25, 27] to a unique map, where retinotopic positions with the highest
activity will be considered as candidates to the corresponding saccade locations. These activations in the
SC are transmitted to guide vertical and horizontal saccade visuomotor nerves [61]. We have defined the
higher active neurons (Equation 12) as the locations for saccades in the visual space (i,j) by decoding the
inverse of the cortical magnification (Equation 6) of their retinotopic position ("" neuron at X,Yi).
(, ) = ( Į) (, ) (, ),
(12)
The behavioral quantity of the unique 2D saliency map has been defined by computing the inverse of
the previous processes using the model output for each pathway separately. Retinotopic positions have
been transformed to coordinates in the visual space using the inverse of the cortical magnification function
(Equation 6). Output signals (V1 sensitivities to orientation and spatial frequencies) are integrated by com-
puting the inverse discrete wavelet transform to obtain unique maps for each channel opponency (Equation
4). A unique representation (Equation 13) of final neuronal responses for each pathway (P-, K- and M- as ࢩ,
ࢩ and ࢩ) is generated with the euclidean norm (adding responses of all channels as in Murray et al.[62]
model). The resulting map is later normalized by the variance (Equation 14) of the firing rate [25, Chap-
ter 5]. This map represents the final saliency map, that describes the probability distribution of fixation
points in certain areas of the image. In addition to this estimation, the saliency map has been convolved
with a gaussian filter simulating a smoothing caused by the deviations of = 1 deg given from eye tracking
experimentation, recommended by LeMeur & Baccino [63].
Ý
Į =
Į;ࢩ + Į;ࢩ + Į;ࢩ,
( Į) =
Į − Į
Į
,
(13)
(14)
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 9 of 27
RP/RGCLGN-V1V1SC LIP/FEFDLPFCRP/RGCLGNV1LIPFEFDLPFCSCHF/PHCBottom-upTop-downFeedforwardFeedbackRecurrent10132567841Opponent ProcessDiscrete Wavelet Transform234Cortical Magnification FunctionV1 Lateral Interactions6Inhibition of ReturnTop-down visual selection78Retrieve Memory Representations5Inverse Mapping, IDWT, Eucl. Norm12P-M-K-RGBL*a*b*3ωL*ωa*ωb*Isoθθ45ŜM(ωωsoθ)HF/PHCMAXV(ωi,j)new gaze (ωg)..."Orange pepper""Yelloθw pepper"ωL*^ωa*ωb*^^Firing Rates (ωspikes/s)IiorIC+IVSSearch Target678G(ωMAXV(ωi,j))Excitatory neurons (ωJ)Inhibitory neurons (ωW)COD (h)OSD (P-)SFD (d,P-)............ Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
2.6. Attention as top-down inhibition
An additional purpose of our work is the modeling of attentional mechanisms beyond pre-attentive
visual selection. Instead of analyzing the scene serially, the visual brain uses a set of attentional biases to
recognize objects, their relationships and their importance with respect to the task, all given in a set of visual
representations. Similarly to the saliency map, the priority map can be interpreted as a unique 2D represen-
tation for eye movement guidance formed in the SC, here including top-down (not guided by the stimulus
itself) and recurrent information as visual relevance. This phenomenon suggests that executive, long-term
and short-term/working memory correlates also direct eye movement control [20, 64]. Previous hypothe-
ses model these properties by forming the priority map through selective tuning [22, 65]. Selective tuning
explains attention mechanisms as a hierarchy of winner-take-all processes. This hypothesis suggests that
top-down attention can be simulated by spatially inhibiting specific layers of processing. Latest hypotheses
[66] confirm that striate cortical activity gain can be modulated by SC responses, with additional modu-
lations arising from pulvinar to extrastriate visual areas. In addition, it has also been stated [67] that V1
influences both saliency and top-down learning during visual detection tasks. By functionally simulating
the aforementioned top-down mechanisms as inhibitory gates of top-down feedback control in our model
[26], we are able to perform task-specific visual selection (VS) and inhibition of return (IoR) mechanisms.
Top-down selection: Goal-directed or memory-guided saccades imply executive control mechanisms that
account for task requirements during stimulus perception. The dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) is
known to be responsible for short-term spatial memory, to retrieve long-term memory signals of object
representations (through projections towards the para- and hippocampal formations) as well as to perform
reflective saccade inhibition, among other functions. These inhibitory signals, later projected to the frontal
eye field (FEF), are able to direct gaze during search and smooth pursuit tasks [64, 68, 69] (also suggested to
be crucial for planning intentional or endogenously-guided saccades), where its signals are sent to the SC.
By feeding our model with inhibitory signals ( shown in Fig. 4 and Table 1E) we can simulate top-down
feedback control mechanisms in V1 (initially proposed by Li [26, Sec. 3.7]). In this case, a new term {}
is added to the top-down inhibition of our V1 cortical signals that will be projected to the SC during each
gaze.
ࢣ
=1
{} = {}
,,,()
(
)ࢧ
, feature-selective ( )
, category-specific ( )
(15)
In this implementation, we can perform distinct search tasks such as feature search (by manually se-
lecting the features, or selecting features with maximal responses, similarly to a boolean selection [23]),
exemplar and categorical object search (by processing the mean of responses Į from wavelet coefficients of
a single or several image samples "N"). These low-level computations would serve as cortical activations to
be stored as weights in our low-level memory representations, that will be used as inhibitory modulation
for the task execution.
Inhibition of Return: During scene viewing, saccadic eye movements show distinct patterns of fixations
[70], directed by exploratory purposes or either towards putting the attentional focus on specific objects in
the scene. For the former case, the HVS needs to ignore already visited regions (triggering anti-saccades
away from these memorized regions, as a consequence of inhibition) during a period of time before gazing
again towards them. This phenomena is named inhibition of return [71], and similarly involves extracting
sensory information and short-term memory during scene perception. As mentioned before, DLPFC is re-
sponsible of memory-guided saccades, and this function might be done in conjunction with the parietal
cortex and the FEF. The parietal areas (LIP and PEF)[64, 68, 72] are known to be responsible of visuospa-
tial integration and preparation of saccade sequences. These areas conjunctively interact with the FEF and
DLPFC for planning these reflexive visually-guided saccades. Acknowledging that LIP receives inputs from
FEF and DLPFC, the role of each cannot be disentangled as a unique functional correlate for the IoR. Fol-
lowing the above, we have modeled return mechanisms as top-down cortical inhibition feedback control
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 10 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
accounting for previously-viewed saccade locations. Thus, we added an inhibition input {} at the start
of each saccade, which will determine our IoR mechanism:
,=0
{} = ( Į) ( (, )) + −1
{},
10Ü
=1
,>0
{} = {}(−1
{})
({})ࢧ.
(16)
This term is modulated with a constant power factor {} and a decay factor {}, which in every cycle
will progressively reduce inhibition. The spatial region of the IoR has been defined as a gaussian function
centered to the previous gaze (g), with a spatial standard deviation {} dependent on a specific spatial
scale and a peak with an amplitude of the maximal RF firing rate of our model's output ( Į). Inhibitory
activity is accumulated to the same map and can be shown how is progressively reduced during viewing
time (Fig. 14). Alternatively illustrated in Itti et al.'s work [7], the IoR can be applied to static saliency models
by substracting the accumulated inhibitory map to the saliency map during each gaze ( Į −
).
{}
3. Materials and Methods
3.1. Procedure
Experimental data has been extracted from eye tracking experimentation. Four datasets were analyzed,
corresponding to 120 real indoor and outdoor images (Toronto [10]), 40 nature scene images (KTH [73]), 100
synthetic image patterns ( 2000 [74]) and 230 psychophysical images (SID4VAM [17, 75]). Generically,
experimentation for these type of datasets [76] capture fixations from about 5 to 55 subjects, looking at a
monitor inside a luminance controlled room while being restrained with a chin rest, located at a relative
distance of 30-40 pixels per degree of visual angle (). The tasks performed mostly consist of freely look-
ing at each image during 5000 ms, looking at the "most salient objects" or searching for specific objects of
interest. We have selected these datasets to evaluate prediction performance at distinct scene contexts. Indi-
cators of psychophysical consistency of the models has been presented, evaluating prediction performance
upon fixation number and feature contrast. Visual search performance has been evaluated by computing
predictions of locating specific objects of interest. For the case of stimuli from real image contexts (Fig. 18)
we have used salient object segmented regions from Toronto's dataset [10], extracted from Li et al. [77]. Fi-
nally, for the case of evaluating fixations performed with synthetic image patterns, we used fixations from
SID4VAM's psychophysical stimuli.
3.2. Model evaluation
Current eye tracking experimentation represent indicators of saliency as the probability of fixations on
certain regions of an image2. Metrics used in saliency benchmarks [40] consider all fixations during viewing
time with same importance, making saliency hypotheses unclear of which computational procedures per-
form best using real image datasets. Previous psychophysical studies [16, 17] revealed that fixations guided
by bottom-up attention are influenced by the type of features that appear in the scene and their relative
feature contrast. From these properties, the order of fixations and the type of task can drive specific eye
movement patterns and center biases, relevant in this case.
The AUC metric (Area Under ROC/Receiver Operant Characteristic) represents a score of a curve com-
prised of true positive values (TP) against false positive (FP) values. The TP are set as human fixations
inside a region of the saliency map, whereas FP are those predicted saliency regions that did not fall on
human fixation instances. For our prediction evaluation we computed the sAUC (shuffled AUC), where
FP are expressed as TP from fixations of other image instances. This metric prioritizes model consistency
and penalizes for prediction biases that appear over eye movement datasets, such as oculomotor and center
biases (not driven by pre-attentional factors). We also calculated the Information Gain (InfoGain) metric
for model evaluation, which compares FP in the probability density distribution of human fixations with
2Code for computing metrics: https://github.com/dberga/saliency
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 11 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
the model prediction, while substracting a baseline distribution of the center bias (all fixations grouped to-
gether in a single map). Saliency metrics, largely explained by Bylinskii et al. [78], usually compare model
predictions with human fixations during the whole viewing time, regardless of fixation order. In our study
is also represented the evolution of prediction scores for each gaze. For the case of scanpaths, we evaluated
saccade sequences by analyzing saccade amplitude (SA) and saccade landing (SL) statistics. These are cal-
culated using euclidean distance between fixation coordinates (distance between saccade length for SA and
distance between locations of saccades for SL).
Initial investigations on visual attention [4, 5] during visual search tasks formulated that reaction times
of finding a target (defined in a region of interest/ROI) among a set of distractors are dependent on set size
as well as target-distractor feature contrast. In order to evaluate performance on visual search, we utilised
two metrics that account for the ground truth mask of specific regions for search and the saliency map (in
this context, it could be considered as a "relevance" map) or predicted saccade coordinates (from locations
with highest neuronal activity). The Saliency Index (SI) [17, 75, 79] calculates the amount of energy of a
saliency map inside a ROI () with respect to the one outside (), calculated as: = ( − )ࢧ. For
the case of saccades in visual search, we considered to calculate the probability of fixations inside the ROI
(PFI).
4. Results
4.1. Results on predicting Saliency
In this section, probability density maps (GT) have been generated using fixation data of all participants
from Toronto, KTH, CAT2000 and SID4VAM eye tracking datasets (model scores and examples in Figs 7-10).
Several saliency predictions have been computed from different biologically-inspired models. Our Neuro-
dynamic Saliency Wavelet Model has been computed without (NSWAM) and with foveation (NSWAM-CM),
as a mean of cortically-mapped saliency computations through a loop of 1, 2, 5 and 10 saccades. The loop
consists on obtaining a saliency map for each view of the scene, and obtaining an unique map for each
saccade instance by computing the mean of all saliency maps.
Based on the shuffled metric scores, traditional saliency models such as AIM overall score higher on real
scene images (Fig. 7), scoring =.663, and =.024. For the case of nature images (Fig.
8), our non-foveated and foveated versions of the model (NSWAM and NSWAM-CM) scored highest on both
metrics ( =.168 and −10=.567). As mentioned before, fixation center biases
are present when the task and/or stimulus do not induce regions that are enough salient to produce bottom-
up saccades. In addition, in real image datasets (Toronto and KTH), not all images contain particularly
salient regions. This is seemingly presented in our models' saliency maps from 1st to 10th fixations (Figs.
7-8, rows 5-8), where salient regions are presented to be less evident across fixation order.
In synthetic image patterns ( 2000 ), both of our model versions outperforms other models
, −=.567. Center biases are present in such dataset (see Fig. 9, "Human Fix." heatmaps),
seemingly reproduced by IKN in the illustration (=-.724). For the case of SID4VAM dataset
(Fig. 10), salient regions are labeled with specific feature type and contrast, and fixation patterns present
lower center biases (due to mainly being based a singleton search type of task with a unique salient target
with random location). Our model presents highest scores on both metrics ( , −2=.622
and −10=-.131).
In Figs. 7-10 are compared the average score per gaze of human fixations and saliency model predictions.
It can be observed that prediction scores for all models decrease as a function of gaze number. Scores of
probability density distributions of human fixations (in comparison to fixation locations) decrease around
10% the sAUC after 10 saccades. This decrease of performance is not reproduced by any of the presented
models, instead, most of them show a flat or slightly increasing slopes for the case of sAUC scores and
logarithmically increasing scores for InfoGain. NSWAM and NSWAM-CM present similar results upon
fixation number.
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 12 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
Model
sAUC InfoGain
Human Fix.
IKN [7]
AIM [10]
NSWAM
NSWAM-CM1
NSWAM-CM2
NSWAM-CM5
NSWAM-CM10
.904
.649
.663*
.631
.636
.644
.650
.655
2.42
-.024*
-.579
-.552
-.818
-.738
-.701
-.692
Figure 7: Results on saliency for Toronto (Bruce & Tsotsos [10]) Eye Tracking Dataset. Left: Saliency metric
scores. Middle: Examples of saliency maps. Right: Shuffled scores per fixation number.
Model
sAUC InfoGain
Human Fix.
IKN [7]
AIM [10]
NSWAM
NSWAM-CM1
NSWAM-CM2
NSWAM-CM5
.822
.551
.552
.565
.564
.566
.566
NSWAM-CM10
.567*
1.41
-.172
-.509
-.168*
-.227
-.213
-.211
-.209
Figure 8: Results on saliency for KTH (Kootra et al'.s [73]) Eye Tracking Dataset. Left: Saliency metric scores.
Middle: Examples of saliency maps. Right: Shuffled scores per fixation number.
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 13 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
Model
sAUC InfoGain
Human Fix.
IKN [7]
AIM [10]
NSWAM
NSWAM-CM1
NSWAM-CM2
NSWAM-CM5
.623
.562
.544
.567*
.561
.563
.565
NSWAM-CM10
.567*
.777
-.724*
-6.49
-1.01
-1.24
-1.14
-1.09
-1.07
Figure 9: Results on saliency for 2000 (Borji & Itti [74]) Dataset. Left: Saliency metric scores.
Middle: Examples of saliency maps. Right: Shuffled scores per fixation number.
Model
sAUC InfoGain
Human Fix.
IKN [7]
AIM [10]
NSWAM
NSWAM-CM1
NSWAM-CM2
NSWAM-CM5
NSWAM-CM10
.860
.608
.557
.622*
.617
.622*
.620
.618
2.80
-.233
-18.2
-.149
-.204
-.164
-.139
-.131*
Figure 10: Results on saliency for SID4VAM (Berga et al. [17]) Eye Tracking Dataset. Left: Saliency metric
scores. Middle: Examples of saliency maps. Right: Shuffled scores per fixation number.
In SID4VAM, stimuli are categorized with specific difficulty (according to the relative target-distractor
feature contrast). With these, we computed the score for each relative contrast instance () in Fig. 11. After
computing every low-level stimulus instance with the presented models and evaluating results with the
same metrics, our saliency model (NSWAM and NSWAM-CM) presents better performance than AIM and
IKN and also increases score at higher feature contrasts.
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 14 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
Figure 11: sAUC and InfoGain scores for each relative target-distractor feature contrast
4.1.1. Discussion
Quantitatively, systematic tendencies in free-viewing (center biases, inter-participant differences, etc.[80])
should not be likely to be considered as indicators of saliency. Although shuffled metrics try to penalize for
these effects, benchmarks do not compensate for these tendencies from model evaluations (these are partic-
ular for each dataset task and stimulus properties). Acknowledging that first saccades determine bottom-up
eye movement guidance [81, 82], it is a phenomenon also present in our experimental data (in terms of the
decrease of performance with respect fixation region probability compared to fixation locations). In that as-
pect, evaluating first fixations with more importance could define new benchmarks for saliency modeling,
similarly with stimuli where feature contrast in salient objects is quantified. Ideal conditions (following the
Weber law) determine that if there is less difficulty for finding the salient region (higher target-distractor
contrast), saliency will be focused on that region. Conversely, fixations would be distributed on the whole
scene if otherwise. Our model presents better performance than other biologically-inspired ones accounting
for these basis.
4.2. Results on predicting scanpaths
Illustration of scanpaths from datasets presented in Section 4.1 were computed with scanpath models
in Fig. 13. Scanpaths are predicted by NSWAM-CM during the first 10 saccades, by selecting maximum
activity of our model for every saccade. We have plotted our model's performance in addition to Boc-
cignone&Ferraro's and LeMeur&Liu's predictions (Fig. 12). Saccade statistics show an initial increment of
saccade amplitude, decreasing as a function of fixation number. Errors of SA and SL (ƊSA and ƊSL) are
calculated as absolute differences between model predictions and human fixations. Values of ƊSL appear
to be lower and similar for all models during initial fixations.
Prediction errors are shown to be sustained or increasing for CLE and NSWAM-CM (maybe due to their
lack of processing higher level features, experimental center biases, etc.). Errors on ƊSA predictions are
lower for LeMeur&Liu's model, retaining similar saccades (except for synthetic images of SID4VAM). Al-
though these errors are representative in terms of saccade sequence, we also computed correlations of mod-
els' SA with GT (SA). In this last case, NSWAM-CM presents most higher correlation values for all datasets
(SA =-.38, =.09; SA =.012, =.96; SA 2000
=.28, =.16; SA4 =.96, =1.26×10−71) than
other models. Most of them seem to accurately predict SA for SID4VAM (which contains mostly visual
search psychophysical image patterns), with SA between .7 and .8. Our scanpath model tend to pre-
dict eye movements with large mean saccade amplitudes {() = 7.8±3.5; () = 13±6.1;
= 15.7±6.7; ()4 = 15.7±6.9 deg}, whereas human fixations combine both short
() 2000
and large saccades {() = 4.6±1; () = 6.7±.5; () 2000
= 5.1±.9; ()4 =
5.8±1.5 deg}. In that aspect, our prediction errors might arise from not correctly predicting focal fixations.
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 15 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
Toronto
KTH
CAT2000
SID4VAM
Figure 12: 1st row: Prediction errors in Saccade Landing (ƊSL) for real indoor/outdoor (Toronto), nature
(KTH) and synthetic (CAT2000 and SID4VAM) image datasets. 2nd row: Prediction errors in Saccade
Amplitude (ƊSA) on same datasets. 3rd row: Correlations of Saccade Amplitude (SA) with respect human
fixations.
"Real"
"Nature"
"Synthetic"
Figure 13: Examples of visual scanpaths for a set of real (1st row, [10]), nature (2nd row,[73]) and synthetic
(3rd row,[17, 74, 75]) images. Model scanpaths correspond to Human Fixations (single sample), CLE [13],
LeMeur, LeMeur , LeMeur [14] and NSWAM-CM (ours).
We simulated the inhibition factor for all datasets by substracting the inhibition factor {} to our mod-
els' saliency maps (NSWAM+IoR). After computing prediction errors in SA and SL for a single sample (Fig.
15-Top), best predictions seem to appear at decay values of {} between .93 and .98, which corresponds
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 16 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
to 1 to 5 saccades (similarly explained by Samuel & Kat [83] and Berga et al. [17], where takes from 300-1600
ms for the duration of the IoR, corresponding to 1 to 5 times the fixation duration). For the case of the {},
lowest prediction error (again, both in SA and SL) is found from 1 to 3 deg (in comparison, LeMeur & Liu [14]
until ({} <1) a single fixation time, decreasing at highest decay {} ࣙ5th saccade. For ƊSL values, er-
parametrized it by default as 2 deg). Results on ƊSA statistics have similar / slightly increasing performance
shown to decrease progressively at highest decay values ({} ࣙ.93). Lastly, when parametrizing the spa-
rors in datasets such as KTH and SID4VAM are decreased at higher decay. For the latter, ƊSA errors are
tial properties of the IoR, saccade prediction performance is highest at lower size (with a near-constant error
in SA and SL increasing about 1 deg for {}=1 to 8 deg on all datasets).
=0
=.5
=.93
=1
=8 deg
Figure 14: Left: Evolution of inhibition factor for 100 mem.time (about 1000 iterations), corresponding ap-
proximately to performing 10 saccades to the model (top). Spatial representation of the IoR with distinct size
(bottom). Right: Examples of scanpaths for different IoR decay factor (top, {}=2 deg, {}={0, .5, .9, 1})
or distinct IoR size (bottom, {}={1, 2, 4, 8} deg,{}=1).
=1 deg
=2 deg
=4 deg
*: Lowest error (ƊSL or ƊSA) at specific parametrization
Figure 15: Statistics of scanpath prediction (ƊSL and ƊSA) by the parametrization of IoR decay ({}) and
IoR size ({}) in a single sample (Top row, from image scanpaths in Fig. 13) and saliency datasets (Bottom
row).
4.2.1. Discussion
Our model predictions on SA correlate better (i.e. obtain higher values) than other scanpath mod-
els (in terms of how SA evolves over fixations), however, prediction errors are higher in both SL and SA.
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 17 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
We believe that these errors are caused by incorrectly predicting locations of fixations, but not for failing
on predictions of the saccade sequence per se. These locations are mainly influenced by systematic tenden-
cies in free-viewing (derived by center biases and/or focal fixations in a particular region of the image).
Cortical magnification mechanisms might be responsible for processing higher saliency at regions outside
the fovea, generating tendencies of uniquely capturing large saccades. These can be solved by processing
high-level feature computations near the fovea, which would increase the probability of fixations at lower
SA. Nonetheless, we have to stress that first fixations are long known for being determinants of bottom-up
attention [17, 81]. Instead, higher inter-participant differences [80] and center biases [84] increase as func-
tions of fixation number, suggested as worse candidates for predicting attention. These parameters appear
to specifically affect each stimuli differently (and accounting that each stimulus may convey specific seman-
tic importance between each contextual element), which may relate to top-down attention but not to the
image characteristics per se. We also want to stress the importance of foveation in our model. This is a
major procedure for determining saccade characteristics (including oculomotor tendencies) and saliency
computations, as it determines current human actions during scene visualization. The decrease of spatial
resolution at increasing eccentricity provides the aforementioned properties, innate in human vision and
invariant to scene semantics.
Adding an IoR mechanism has been seen to affect model activity and therefore scanpath predictions.
In Fig. 14-Left we show how our inhibition factor ({}) decreases over simulation time in relation to the
parametrized decay {}, as well as the projected RF size with respect the gaussian parameter {}. These
variables (decay and size) affect either location of saccades and its sequence, modulating firing rate activity
to already visited locations. It is shown in Fig. 14-Right that the initial saccade is focused on the salient
region and then it spreads to a specific location in the scene, not repeating with higher value of inhibition
decay or field size. In the next section we show how our model can preproduce eye movements beyond
free-viewing tasks by modulating of inhibitory top-down signals.
4.3. Results on feature and exemplar search
We have compared our model predictions with bottom-up only (NSWAM NSWAM-CM) and with top-
down inhibitory modulation (NSWAM+VS NSWAM-CM+VS) for singleton search stimuli (for both real
[10] and synthetic targets [75]). Top-down selection is applied to our low-level feature dimensions (scale,
orientation, channel opponency and its polarity). In VS, inhibition is parametrized considering the feature
with the highest activity inside the stimulus ROI (Equation 15-Top). Besides, inhibitory control in VS has
been set as the mean wavelet coefficients instead (Equation 15-Bottom).
Results of our model predictions with top-down attention (NSWAM+VS NSWAM-CM+VS) present
higher scores for both SI and PFI (Fig. 16) than the case of bottom-up attention only (NWAM NSWAM-CM),
=5.9×10−4, Ɗ()−+
specially for the case of using cortical magnification NSWAM-CM+VS. Here, there is an increase of fixations
inside the ROI: Ɗ( )+ ࣃ1%, Ɗ( )−+ ࣃ10% and Ɗ( ) ࣃ6%, Ɗ( )−+ ࣃ4%
when searching real objects (Fig.16-Top/Right) and Ɗ( )+ ࣃ0%, Ɗ( )−+ ࣃ4% and Ɗ( )+
ࣃ1%, Ɗ( )−+ ࣃ7% when searching synthetic patterns (Fig.16-Top/Left). The SI is also seen to in-
=1.8 × 10−3 and
crease for both types of images, with differences of Ɗ()+
=3.1×
Ɗ()+
10−4, Ɗ()−+
=6×10−4 for psychophysical pat-
tern search (Fig.16-Bottom/Left).
Some object localization examples are shown in Fig. 18, where the relevance maps (NSWAM+VS
maps (NSWAM NSWAM-CM).
NSWAM-CM+VS) seemingly capture the regions inside the ROI/mask compared to the cases of saliency
=7×10−4 for object search (Fig.16-Bottom/Right) and Ɗ()+
=3.8 × 10−4, Ɗ()−+
=1.1×10−3 and Ɗ()+
=1.3×10−5, Ɗ()−+
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 18 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
Synthetic Pattern Search
Object Search
Figure 16: Probability of Fixations Inside the ROI (Bottom row) and statistics of Saliency Index (Top row)
for synthetic image patterns (Left) and salient object detection regions from real image scenes (Right).
In Fig. 19 we illustrated results of PFI and SI in relation to relative target-distractor feature contrast
for cases of Brigthness, Color, Size and Orientation differences. After computing SI for each distinct psy-
chophysical stimuli, we can see in Fig. 17 that our model performs best for searching objects in stimuli
where there are clear differences in brightness, color, size and/or angle, rather than for the case of different
combination of features, specially with heterogeneous, nonlinear or categorical angle configurations.
Figure 17: Performance on visual search evaluated on each distinct low-level feature, stimulus instances are
from SID4VAM's dataset [17, 75].
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 19 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
Image
Mask
NSWAM
(saliency)
NSWAM
+VS
NSWAM
+VS
NSWAM-CM NSWAM-CM NSWAM-CM
(10 sacc.)
+VS
+VS
"Banana"
"Bag"
"Bottle"
"Traffic"
"Lamp"
"Green Ball"
"Person"
"Magazine"
"Tomato"
"Car"
"Telephone"
Figure 18: Search instances with a specific ROI (Mask) based on a category/word exemplar.
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 20 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
NSWAM
NSWAM+VS
NSWAM+VS
NSWAM-CM
NSWAM-CM+VS
NSWAM-CM+VS
NSWAM
NSWAM+VS
NSWAM+VS
NSWAM-CM
NSWAM-CM+VS
NSWAM-CM+VS
NSWAM
NSWAM+VS
NSWAM+VS
NSWAM-CM
NSWAM-CM+VS
NSWAM-CM+VS
NSWAM
NSWAM+VS
NSWAM+VS
NSWAM-CM
NSWAM-CM+VS
NSWAM-CM+VS
Figure 19: Performance on visual search examples with a specific low-level feature contrast (for Brightness,
Color, Size and Orientation). We represented 7 instances ordered by search difficulty of each feature sample.
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 21 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
4.3.1. Discussion
Overall results show that features computed by the top-down approach seemingly performs better in
visual search than saliency, both considering features with maximal cortical activity (VS) and average
statistics of low-level features (VS). Search in both objects and psychophysical image patterns is signifi-
cantly more efficient in SI and PFI when selecting maximal feature activations (VS). Our model is able
to localize objects in real scenes, specially when objects are distinct enough from others (in these low-level
feature computations). However, the model fails when there are sparse regions of the image that interfere
with the selected object (being too salient, such as in Fig. 18-"Telephone") and when characteristics of some
parts of these objects (comprised in the mask) do not significantly pop-out or either coincide with other
non-relevant objects (see Fig. 18-"Car"). This could be improved by computing a higher number of features
[85, 86] (which would represent in more detail each cortical cell sensitivity at higher visual areas of cortex).
We can observe that when using both cortical magnification transform and top-down selection (-CM+VS),
some non-relevant parts of the image are discriminated easier than using top-down selection alone (see
non-relevant artifacts caused by repetitive patterns or wrap-around filtering effects Fig. 19-Bottom). This
suggests that using foveation not only can improve performance on localizing objects (Fig. 16) but also that
provides biologically-plausible perceptual characteristics not considered in most artificial models. Even if
our computations of top-down selection are fed to the model as a constant factor (according to the activity
from exemplars), our model's lateral interactions leverage at each saccade the activity from both bottom-up
and top-down attention.
5. General Discussion
Current implementation of our V1 model is based on Li's excitatory-inhibitory firing rate network [26],
following previous hypotheses of pyramidal and interneuron connectivity for orientation selectivity in V1
[55, 56]. To support and extend this hypothesis, distinct connectivity schemas (following up V1 cell subtype
characterization) [87, 88] could be tested (e.g. adding dysynaptic connections between inhibitory interneu-
rons) to better understand V1 intra-cortical computations. Furthermore, modeling intra-layer interactions
of V1 cells [44] could explain how visual information is parallely processed and integrated by simple and
complex cells [85], how distinct chromatic opponencies (P-,K- and M-) are computed at each layer [89], and
how V1 responses affect SC activity (i.e. from layer 5) [90]. Testing contributions of each of these chromatic
pathways (at distinct single/double opponencies and polarities), as well as distinct fusion mechanisms re-
garding feature integration, would define a more detailed description of how visual features affect saliency
map predictions.
Previous and current scanpath model predictions could be considered to be insufficient due to the scene
complexity and numerous factors (such as the task specificity, scene semantics, etc.) simultaneously in-
volved in saccade programming. These factors increase overall errors on scanpath predictions, as systematic
tendencies increase over time [17, 19, 80, 84], making late saccades difficult to predict. In that aspect, in free-
viewing tasks (when there is no task definition), top-down attention is likely to be dependent on the internal
state of the subject. Further understanding of high level attentional processes have only been approximated
through statistical and optimization techniques uniquely with fixation data (yet participant decisions on
fixations are not accounted and usually have high variability). It has also been later observed that fixations
during free-viewing and visual search have distinct temporal properties. This could explain that saliency
and relevance are elicited differently during viewing time. Latest literature on that aspect, discern two dis-
tinct patterns of fixations (either ambient or focal) where subjects first observe the scene (possibly towards
salient regions), then focus their attention on regions that are relevant to them [70], and these influences are
mainly temporal. Its modelization for eye movements in combination with memory processing is still un-
der discussion. Current return mechanisms have long been computed by inhibiting the regions of previous
fixations (spatially-based), nonetheless, IoR could also have feature-selective properties [91] to consider.
We suggest that not all fixations should have the same importance when evaluating saliency predictions.
Nature and synthetic scene images lack of semantic (man-made) information, which might contribute to
the aforementioned voluntary (top-down guided) eye movements [92]. Acknowledging that objects are
usually composed by the combination of several features (either in shape, color, etc.), we should analyze
if low-level features are sufficient to perform complex categorical search tasks. Extrastriate computations
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 22 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
could allow the usage of object representations at higher-level processing, introducing semantically-relevant
information and several image samples per category. Cortical processing of extrastriate areas (from V2 and
V3) towards temporal (V4 & IT) and dorsal (V5 & MT) pathways [93, Section II][44] could represent cortical
activity at these distinct levels of processing, modeling in more detail the computations within the two-
stream hypothesis (what & where pathways). Color, shape and motion processing in each of these areas
could generate more accurate representations of SC activity [20], producing more complex predictions such
as microsaccadic and smooth pursuit eye movements with dynamic scenes.
6. Future Work
Current and future implementations of the model are able to process dynamic stimuli as to represent
attention using videos. By simulating motion energy from V1 cells and MT direction selective cells [25,
Section 2.3.5], would allow our model to reproduce object motion and flicker mechanisms found in the
HVS. Moreover, foveation through more plausible cortical mapping algorithms [94] could provide better
spatial detail of the cortical field organization of foveal and peripheral retinotopic regions and lateralization,
currently seen to reproduce V1/V2/V3 physiological responses. Adding to that, hypercolumnar feature
computations of geniculocortical pathways could be extended with a higher number of orientation and
scale sensitivities with self-invertible 2D Log-Gabor filters [95]. In that regard, angle configuration pop-
out effects and contour detection computations [96, 97] can be done by changing neuron connectivity and
orientation tuning modulations. Spatiotemporal convolutions shown for center-surround RF [98] could be
integrated for mimicking the dynamics and feature tuning at each pre-cortical pathway.
We aim in future implementations to model the impact of feedback in cortico-cortical interactions with
respect striate and extrastriate areas in the HVS. Some of these regions project directly to SC, including the
intermediate areas (pulvinar and medial dorsal) and basal ganglia [20, 64, 68]. Our current implementation
can be extended with a large scale network of spiking neurons [99, 100], also being able to learn certain
image patterns through spike-timing dependent plasticity (STDP) mechanisms [101]. With such a network,
the same model would be able to perform both psychophysical and electrophysiological evaluations while
providing novel biologically-plausible computations with large scale image datasets.
7. Conclusion
In this study we have presented a biologically-plausible model of visual attention by mimicking visual
mechanisms from retina to V1 using real images. From such, computations at early visual areas of the HVS
(i.e. RP, RGC, LGN and V1) are performed by following physiological and psychophysical characteristics.
Here we state that lateral interactions of V1 cells are able to obtain real scene saliency maps and to predict
locations of visual fixations. We have also proposed novel scanpath computations of scene visualization us-
ing a cortical magnification function. Our model outperforms other biologically inspired saliency models
in saliency predictions (specifically with nature and synthetic images) and has a trend to acquire similar
scanpath prediction performance with respect other artificial models, outperforming them in saccade am-
plitude correlations. The aim of this study, besides from acquiring state-of-the-art results, is to explain how
lateral connections can predict visual fixations and how these can explain the role of V1 in this and other
visual effects. In addition, we formulated projections of recurrent and selective attention using the same
model (simulating frontoparietal top-down inhibition mechanisms). Our implementation of these, included
top-down projections from DLPFC, FEF and LIP (regarding visual selection and inhibition of return mech-
anisms). We have shown how scanpath predictions improve by parametrizing the inhibition of return, with
highest performance at a size of 2 deg and a decay time between 1 and 5 fixations. By processing low-level
feature representations of real images (considering statistics of wavelet coefficients for each object or feature
exemplar) and using them as top-down cues, we have been able to perform feature and object search using
the same computational architecture. Two search strategies are presented, and we show that both the prob-
ability to gaze inside a ROI and the amount of fixations inside that ROI increase with respect saliency. In
previous studies, the same model has been able to reproduce brightness [28] and chromatic [30] induction,
as well as explaining V1 cortical hyperexcitability as a indicator of visual discomfort [31]. With the same
parameters and without any type of training or optimization, NSWAM is also able predict bottom-up and
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 23 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
top-down attention for free-viewing and visual search tasks. Model characteristics has been constrained
(in both architecture and parametrization) with human physiology and visual psychophysics, and can be
considered as a simplified and unified simulation of how low-level visual processes occur in the HVS.
Acknowledgments
This work was funded by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitivity (DPI2017-89867-C2-1-R),
Agencia de Gestió d'Ajuts Universitaris i de Recerca (AGAUR) (2017-SGR-649), and CERCA Programme /
Generalitat de Catalunya.
References
[1] C. E. Shannon. A mathematical theory of communication. Bell System Technical Journal, 27(3):379 -- 423, jul 1948.
[2] H. B. Barlow. Redundancy reduction revisited. Network, 12 3:241 -- 53, 2001.
[3] Li Zhaoping. From the optic tectum to the primary visual cortex: migration through evolution of the saliency map for exogenous
attentional guidance. Current Opinion in Neurobiology, 40:94 -- 102, oct 2016.
[4] Anne M. Treisman and Garry Gelade. A feature-integration theory of attention. Cognitive Psychology, 12(1):97 -- 136, January 1980.
[5] Jeremy M. Wolfe, Kyle R. Cave, and Susan L. Franzel. Guided search: An alternative to the feature integration model for visual
search. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 15(3):419 -- 433, 1989.
[6] Christof Koch and Shimon Ullman. Shifts in selective visual attention: Towards the underlying neural circuitry. In Matters of
[7] L. Itti, C. Koch, and E. Niebur. A model of saliency-based visual attention for rapid scene analysis. IEEE Transactions on Pattern
[8] Ali Borji and Laurent Itti. State-of-the-art in visual attention modeling. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelli-
Intelligence, pages 115 -- 141. Springer Netherlands, 1987.
Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 20(11):1254 -- 1259, 1998.
gence, 35(1):185 -- 207, jan 2013.
[9] Liming Zhang and Weisi Lin. Selective Visual Attention. John Wiley & Sons (Asia) Pte Ltd, mar 2013.
[10] Neil D. B. Bruce and John K. Tsotsos. Saliency based on information maximization.
In Proceedings of the 18th International
Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems, NIPS'05, pages 155 -- 162, Cambridge, MA, USA, 2005. MIT Press.
[11] Bruno A. Olshausen and David J. Field. Emergence of simple-cell receptive field properties by learning a sparse code for natural
images. Nature, 381(6583):607 -- 609, jun 1996.
[12] D. Brockmann. Are human scanpaths levy flights? In 9th International Conference on Artificial Neural Networks: ICANN 99. IEE,
1999.
2015.
[13] Giuseppe Boccignone and Mario Ferraro. Modelling gaze shift as a constrained random walk. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics
and its Applications, 331(1-2):207 -- 218, jan 2004.
[14] Olivier Le Meur and Zhi Liu. Saccadic model of eye movements for free-viewing condition. Vision Research, 116:152 -- 164, nov
[15] Jonathan Harel, Christof Koch, and Pietro Perona. Graph-based visual saliency. Proc. Advances in Neural Information Processing
Systems (NIPS 2007), 19:545 -- 552, 2007.
[16] Neil D.B. Bruce, Calden Wloka, Nick Frosst, Shafin Rahman, and John K. Tsotsos. On computational modeling of visual saliency:
Examining what's right, and what's left. Vision Research, 116:95 -- 112, nov 2015.
[17] David Berga, Xosé R. Fdez-Vidal, Xavier Otazu, Víctor Leborán, and Xosé M. Pardo. Psychophysical evaluation of individual
low-level feature influences on visual attention. Vision Research, 154:60 -- 79, jan 2019.
[18] Robert Desimone and John Duncan. Neural mechanisms of selective visual attention. Annual Review of Neuroscience, 18(1):193 --
[19] Howard E. Egeth and Steven Yantis. VISUAL ATTENTION: Control, representation, and time course. Annual Review of Psychol-
[20] Brian White and Douglas P. Munoz. The Oxford Handbook of Eye Movements. Oxford University Press, aug 2011.
[21] Edmund Rolls. Memory, attention, and decision-making: a unifying computational neuroscience approach. Oxford University Press,
222, mar 1995.
ogy, 48(1):269 -- 297, feb 1997.
Oxford New York, 2008.
[22] John K. Tsotsos, Scan M. Culhane, Winky Yan Kei Wai, Yuzhong Lai, Neal Davis, and Fernando Nuflo. Modeling visual attention
via selective tuning. Artificial Intelligence, 78(1-2):507 -- 545, oct 1995.
[23] Liqiang Huang and Harold Pashler. A boolean map theory of visual attention. Psychological Review, 114(3):599 -- 631, 2007.
[24] Zhaoping Li. A saliency map in primary visual cortex. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 6(1):9 -- 16, jan 2002.
[25] Li Zhaoping. Understanding vision : theory, models, and data. Oxford University Press, Oxford, United Kingdom, 2014.
[26] Zhaoping Li. A neural model of contour integration in the primary visual cortex. Neural Computation, 10(4):903 -- 940, may 1998.
[27] Z. Li. Contextual influences in v1 as a basis for pop out and asymmetry in visual search. Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences, 96(18):10530 -- 10535, aug 1999.
ONE, 8(5):e64086, may 2013.
[28] Olivier Penacchio, Xavier Otazu, and Laura Dempere-Marco. A neurodynamical model of brightness induction in v1. PLoS
[29] David Berga and Xavier Otazu. A neurodynamic model of saliency prediction in v1. arXiv preprint arXiv:1811.06308, 2018.
[30] Xim Cerda and Xavier Otazu. A Multi-Task Neurodynamical Model of Lateral Interactions in V1: Chromatic Induction. 39th
European Conference of Visual Perception, PERCEPTION, 45(2):51, 2016.
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 24 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
[31] Olivier Penacchio, Arnold J. Wilkins, Xavier Otazu, and Julie M. Harris.
Inhibitory function and its contribution to cortical
hyperexcitability and visual discomfort as assessed by a computation model of cortical function. 39th European Conference of
Visual Perception, PERCEPTION, 45(2):51, 2016.
[32] Olivier Penacchio and Arnold J. Wilkins. Visual discomfort and the spatial distribution of fourier energy. Vision Research, 108:1 -- 7,
[33] An T.D. Le, Jasmine Payne, Charlotte Clarke, Murphy A. Kelly, Francesca Prudenziati, Elise Armsby, Olivier Penacchio, and
Arnold J. Wilkins. Discomfort from urban scenes: Metabolic consequences. Landscape and Urban Planning, 160:61 -- 68, apr 2017.
[34] Gustavo Deco and Edmund T. Rolls. A neurodynamical cortical model of visual attention and invariant object recognition. Vision
mar 2015.
Research, 44(6):621 -- 642, mar 2004.
1(4):275 -- 285, oct 2007.
[35] Yuqiao Gu and Hans Liljenström. A neural network model of attention-modulated neurodynamics. Cognitive Neurodynamics,
[36] Sylvain Chevallier, Nicolas Cuperlier, and Philippe Gaussier. Efficient neural models for visual attention. In Computer Vision and
Graphics, pages 257 -- 264. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2010.
[37] Ruben Coen-Cagli, Peter Dayan, and Odelia Schwartz. Cortical surround interactions and perceptual salience via natural scene
statistics. PLoS Computational Biology, 8(3):e1002405, March 2012.
[38] Hung-Cheng Chang, Stephen Grossberg, and Yongqiang Cao. Wheres waldo? how perceptual, cognitive, and emotional brain
processes cooperate during learning to categorize and find desired objects in a cluttered scene. Frontiers in Integrative Neuroscience,
8, jun 2014.
[39] Mateja Marić and Dražen Domijan. A neurodynamic model of feature-based spatial selection. Frontiers in Psychology, 9, mar
2018.
673, may 2014.
[40] Z. Bylinskii, E.M. DeGennaro, R. Rajalingham, H. Ruda, J. Zhang, and J.K. Tsotsos. Towards the quantitative evaluation of visual
attention models. Vision Research, 116:258 -- 268, nov 2015.
[41] Samuel G. Solomon and Peter Lennie. The machinery of colour vision. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 8(4):276 -- 286, apr 2007.
[42] Yasushi Imamoto and Yoshinori Shichida. Cone visual pigments. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA) - Bioenergetics, 1837(5):664 --
[43] Andrew Stockman, Donald I. A. MacLeod, and Nancy E. Johnson. Spectral sensitivities of the human cones. Journal of the Optical
[44] Lawrence C. Sincich and Jonathan C. Horton. THE CIRCUITRY OF v1 AND v2: Integration of color, form, and motion. Annual
Society of America A, 10(12):2491, dec 1993.
Review of Neuroscience, 28(1):303 -- 326, jul 2005.
[45] P Lennie, J Krauskopf, and G Sclar. Chromatic mechanisms in striate cortex of macaque. The Journal of Neuroscience, 10(2):649 -- 669,
feb 1990.
dec 2011.
2007.
[46] M. González-Audícana, X. Otazu, O. Fors, and A. Seco. Comparison between mallat's and the 'à trous' discrete wavelet transform
based algorithms for the fusion of multispectral and panchromatic images. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 26(3):595 -- 614,
feb 2005.
[47] H. Strasburger, I. Rentschler, and M. Juttner. Peripheral vision and pattern recognition: A review. Journal of Vision, 11(5):13 -- 13,
[48] Marisa Carrasco. Covert attention increases contrast sensitivity: psychophysical, neurophysiological and neuroimaging studies.
In Visual Perception - Fundamentals of Vision: Low and Mid-Level Processes in Perception, pages 33 -- 70. Elsevier, 2006.
[49] Brian A. Wandell, Serge O. Dumoulin, and Alyssa A. Brewer. Visual field maps in human cortex. Neuron, 56(2):366 -- 383, oct
[50] E. L. Schwartz. Spatial mapping in the primate sensory projection: Analytic structure and relevance to perception. Biological
Cybernetics, 25(4):181 -- 194, dec 1977.
[51] Zhaoping Li. Pre-attentive segmentation in the primary visual cortex. Spatial Vision, 13(1):25 -- 50, 2000.
[52] Li Zhaoping. V1 mechanisms and some figure -- ground and border effects. Journal of Physiology-Paris, 97(4-6):503 -- 515, jul 2003.
[53] Li Zhaoping and Keith A. May. Psychophysical tests of the hypothesis of a bottom-up saliency map in primary visual cortex.
[54] Li Zhaoping and Li Zhe. Primary visual cortex as a saliency map: A parameter-free prediction and its test by behavioral data.
PLoS Computational Biology, 3(4):e62, 2007.
PLOS Computational Biology, 11(10):e1004375, oct 2015.
[55] Charles D. Gilbert. Horizontal integration and cortical dynamics. Neuron, 9(1):1 -- 13, jul 1992.
[56] Michael Weliky, Karl Kandler, David Fitzpatrick, and Lawrence C. Katz. Patterns of excitation and inhibition evoked by hori-
zontal connections in visual cortex share a common relationship to orientation columns. Neuron, 15(3):541 -- 552, sep 1995.
[57] Eilen Nordlie, Marc-Oliver Gewaltig, and Hans Ekkehard Plesser. Towards reproducible descriptions of neuronal network
models. PLoS Computational Biology, 5(8):e1000456, aug 2009.
[58] Richard Veale, Ziad M. Hafed, and Masatoshi Yoshida. How is visual salience computed in the brain? insights from behaviour,
neurobiology and modelling. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 372(1714):20160113, jan 2017.
[59] Brian J. White, Janis Y. Kan, Ron Levy, Laurent Itti, and Douglas P. Munoz. Superior colliculus encodes visual saliency before
the primary visual cortex. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 114(35):9451 -- 9456, aug 2017.
[60] Peter H. Schiller and Edward J. Tehovnik. Chapter 9 look and see: how the brain moves your eyes about. In Progress in Brain
Research, pages 127 -- 142. Elsevier, 2001.
[61] Anja K.E. Horn and Christopher Adamczyk. Reticular formation. In The Human Nervous System, pages 328 -- 366. Elsevier, 2012.
[62] Naila Murray, Maria Vanrell, Xavier Otazu, and C. Alejandro Parraga. Saliency estimation using a non-parametric low-level
vision model. In CVPR 2011. IEEE, jun 2011.
[63] Olivier LeMeur and Thierry Baccino. Methods for comparing scanpaths and saliency maps: strengths and weaknesses. Behavior
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 25 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
[64] Charles Pierrot-Deseilligny, Dan Milea, and René Müri. Eye movement control by the cerebral cortex. Current Opinion in Neu-
[65] Wloka, Calden; York University, Canada, Kotseruba, Iuliia; York University, Canada, and Tsotsos, John; York University, Canada.
Research Methods, 45(1):251 -- 266, jul 2012.
rology, 17(1):17 -- 25, feb 2004.
A focus on selection for fixation, 2016.
of Neurophysiology, 95(3):1696 -- 1717, mar 2006.
metry. Cognitive Computation, 3(1):223 -- 240, jan 2011.
of Datasets", 2015. arXiv preprint arXiv:1505.03581.
[66] Mehran Ahmadlou, Larry S. Zweifel, and J. Alexander Heimel. Functional modulation of primary visual cortex by the superior
[67] Yin Yan, Li Zhaoping, and Wu Li. Bottom-up saliency and top-down learning in the primary visual cortex of monkeys. Proceed-
colliculus in the mouse. Nature Communications, 9(1), sep 2018.
ings of the National Academy of Sciences, page 201803854, sep 2018.
[68] C. Pierrot-Deseilligny, R.M. Müri, C.J. Ploner, B. Gaymard, and S. Rivaud-Péchoux. Cortical control of ocular saccades in humans:
a model for motricity. In Progress in Brain Research, pages 3 -- 17. Elsevier, 2003.
[69] J.D. Schall. Frontal eye fields. In Encyclopedia of Neuroscience, pages 367 -- 374. Elsevier, 2009.
[70] Michelle L. Eisenberg and Jeffrey M. Zacks. Ambient and focal visual processing of naturalistic activity. Journal of Vision, 16(2):5,
[71] Richard Godijn and Jan Theeuwes. Oculomotor capture and inhibition of return: Evidence for an oculomotor suppression
account of IOR. Psychological Research, 66(4):234 -- 246, nov 2002.
[72] James W. Bisley and Michael E. Goldberg. Neural correlates of attention and distractibility in the lateral intraparietal area. Journal
[73] Gert Kootstra, Bart de Boer, and Lambert R. B. Schomaker. Predicting eye fixations on complex visual stimuli using local sym-
mar 2016.
[74] Ali Borji and Laurent Itti. Cat2000: A large scale fixation dataset for boosting saliency research. CVPR 2015 workshop on "Future
[75] David Berga, Xose R. Fdez-Vidal, Xavier Otazu, and Xose M. Pardo. Sid4vam: A benchmark dataset with synthetic images for
visual attention modeling. In The IEEE International Conference on Computer Vision (ICCV), October 2019.
[76] Stefan Winkler and Ramanathan Subramanian. Overview of eye tracking datasets. In 2013 Fifth International Workshop on Quality
of Multimedia Experience (QoMEX). IEEE, jul 2013.
[77] Yin Li, Xiaodi Hou, Christof Koch, James M. Rehg, and Alan L. Yuille. The secrets of salient object segmentation. In 2014 IEEE
Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. IEEE, jun 2014.
[78] Zoya Bylinskii, Tilke Judd, Aude Oliva, Antonio Torralba, and Fredo Durand. What do different evaluation metrics tell us about
saliency models? IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, pages 1 -- 1, 2018.
[79] M.W. Spratling. Predictive coding as a model of the v1 saliency map hypothesis. Neural Networks, 26:7 -- 28, feb 2012.
[80] Benjamin W. Tatler, Roland J. Baddeley, and Iain D. Gilchrist. Visual correlates of fixation selection: effects of scale and time.
Vision Research, 45(5):643 -- 659, mar 2005.
[81] James R. Antes. The time course of picture viewing. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 103(1):62 -- 70, 1974.
[82] L. Zhaoping. Gaze capture by eye-of-origin singletons: Interdependence with awareness. Journal of Vision, 12(2):17 -- 17, feb 2012.
[83] Arthur G. Samuel and Donna Kat. Inhibition of return: A graphical meta-analysis of its time course and an empirical test of its
temporal and spatial properties. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 10(4):897 -- 906, dec 2003.
[84] Lars O. M. Rothkegel, Hans A. Trukenbrod, Heiko H. Schütt, Felix A. Wichmann, and Ralf Engbert. Temporal evolution of the
central fixation bias in scene viewing. Journal of Vision, 17(13):3, nov 2017.
[85] David A. Mély and Thomas Serre. Towards a theory of computation in the visual cortex. In Computational and Cognitive Neuro-
science of Vision, pages 59 -- 84. Springer Singapore, oct 2016.
[86] David Berga, Calden Wloka, and John K Tsotsos. Modeling task influences for saccade sequence and visual relevance prediction.
Journal of Vision, 19(10):106c, September 2019.
[87] Stephen Grossberg, Jesse Palma, and Massimiliano Versace. Resonant cholinergic dynamics in cognitive and motor decision-
making: Attention, category learning, and choice in neocortex, superior colliculus, and optic tectum. Frontiers in Neuroscience,
9, jan 2016.
[88] Jung H. Lee, Christof Koch, and Stefan Mihalas. A computational analysis of the function of three inhibitory cell types in
contextual visual processing. Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience, 11, apr 2017.
[89] E. N. Johnson, M. J. Hawken, and R. Shapley. The orientation selectivity of color-responsive neurons in macaque v1. Journal of
Neuroscience, 28(32):8096 -- 8106, aug 2008.
[90] Hoang L. Nhan and Edward M. Callaway. Morphology of superior colliculus- and middle temporal area-projecting neurons in
primate primary visual cortex. The Journal of Comparative Neurology, 520(1):52 -- 80, Nov 2011.
[91] Kesong Hu, Junya Zhan, Bingzhao Li, Shuchang He, and Arthur G. Samuel. Multiple cueing dissociates location- and feature-
based repetition effects. Vision Research, 101:73 -- 81, aug 2014.
[92] Alex D. Hwang, Hsueh-Cheng Wang, and Marc Pomplun. Semantic guidance of eye movements in real-world scenes. Vision
Research, 51(10):1192 -- 1205, may 2011.
[93] John Werner and Leo M. Chalupa. The new visual neurosciences. The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 2014.
[94] Mark M. Schira, Christopher W. Tyler, Branka Spehar, and Michael Breakspear. Modeling magnification and anisotropy in the
primate foveal confluence. PLoS Computational Biology, 6(1):e1000651, jan 2010.
[95] Sylvain Fischer, Filip Šroubek, Laurent Perrinet, Rafael Redondo, and Gabriel Cristóbal. Self-invertible 2d log-gabor wavelets.
International Journal of Computer Vision, 75(2):231 -- 246, jan 2007.
[96] Martin A. Asenov. Dynamic model of interactions between orientation selective neurons in primary visual cortex. Master's
thesis, University of Edinburg, Edinburgh, UK, 2016.
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 26 of 27
Modeling Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention with a Neurodynamic Model of V1
[97] Akiyuki Anzai, Xinmiao Peng, and David C Van Essen. Neurons in monkey visual area v2 encode combinations of orientations.
[101] Timothée Masquelier and Simon J Thorpe. Unsupervised learning of visual features through spike timing dependent plasticity.
[98] DC Somers, SB Nelson, and M Sur. An emergent model of orientation selectivity in cat visual cortical simple cells. The Journal
[99] E.M. Izhikevich. Which model to use for cortical spiking neurons? IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks, 15(5):1063 -- 1070, sep
[100] Amirhossein Tavanaei, Masoud Ghodrati, Saeed Reza Kheradpisheh, Timothée Masquelier, and Anthony Maida. Deep learning
Nature Neuroscience, 10(10):1313 -- 1321, sep 2007.
of Neuroscience, 15(8):5448 -- 5465, August 1995.
2004.
in spiking neural networks. Neural Networks, 2018.
PLoS computational biology, 3(2):e31, 2007.
David Berga & Xavier Otazu: Preprint submitted to Elsevier
Page 27 of 27
|
1705.08128 | 1 | 1705 | 2017-05-23T08:45:35 | Quantum probability updating from zero prior (by-passing Cromwell's rule) | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Cromwell's rule (also known as the zero priors paradox) refers to the constraint of classical probability theory that if one assigns a prior probability of 0 or 1 to a hypothesis, then the posterior has to be 0 or 1 as well (this is a straightforward implication of how Bayes's rule works). Relatedly, hypotheses with a very low prior cannot be updated to have a very high posterior without a tremendous amount of new evidence to support them (or to make other possibilities highly improbable). Cromwell's rule appears at odds with our intuition of how humans update probabilities. In this work, we report two simple decision making experiments, which seem to be inconsistent with Cromwell's rule. Quantum probability theory, the rules for how to assign probabilities from the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics, provides an alternative framework for probabilistic inference. An advantage of quantum probability theory is that it is not subject to Cromwell's rule and it can accommodate changes from zero or very small priors to significant posteriors. We outline a model of decision making, based on quantum theory, which can accommodate the changes from priors to posteriors, observed in our experiments. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Quantum probability updating from zero prior (by-passing Cromwell's rule)
Irina Basievaa,b*, Emmanuel Pothosb, Jennifer Truebloodc, Andrei Khrennikova, and Jerome
Busemeyerd
a Linnaeus University, Universitetplatsen 1 351 95 Växjö, Sweden
b Department of Psychology, City University London, UK
c Department of Psychology, Vanderbilt University, USA
d Department of Psychology, Indiana University, USA
Abstract
Cromwell's rule (also known as the zero priors paradox) refers to the constraint of classical probability theory
that if one assigns a prior probability of 0 or 1 to a hypothesis, then the posterior has to be 0 or 1 as well (this is a
straightforward implication of how Bayes's rule works). Relatedly, hypotheses with a very low prior cannot be
updated to have a very high posterior without a tremendous amount of new evidence to support them (or to make
other possibilities highly improbable). Cromwell's rule appears at odds with our intuition of how humans update
probabilities. In this work, we report two simple decision making experiments, which seem to be inconsistent with
Cromwell's rule. Quantum probability theory, the rules for how to assign probabilities from the mathematical
formalism of quantum mechanics, provides an alternative framework for probabilistic inference. An advantage of
quantum probability theory is that it is not subject to Cromwell's rule and it can accommodate changes from zero
or very small priors to significant posteriors. We outline a model of decision making, based on quantum theory,
which can accommodate the changes from priors to posteriors, observed in our experiments.
1. Introduction
Luce is known for many seminal contributions in psychology, yet he still considered the modelling of
uncertainty and vagueness as one of the "unresolved conceptual problems of mathematical psychology"
(the text is part of the title of Luce, 1997). This work considers a fundamental aspect of probabilistic
inference, probability updating.
According to classical probability (CP), our belief in different hypotheses should be updated
using Bayes's law, which states that
.
(1)
Here Hi is a particular hypothesis and D is the observed data. In the set-theoretical paradigm, Eq.
(1) is equivalent to
(1')
The term
is the joint probability of a hypothesis and the data. As can be seen by the above
formula, when holding the data fixed, Bayes rule is just a special case of Luce's choice rule, where
serves as the strength of an alternative. When viewed this way, Bayes rule must satisfy the
choice axiom as well.
There is little doubt that Bayes's law is successful on many occasions, as is evident by the many
CP theory psychological models providing excellent fits (Griffiths et al., 2010; Oaksford & Chater, 2007;
Tenenbaum et al., 2011) and the widespread usage (e.g., in machine learning, management, economics)
of causal reasoning systems based on so-called Bayes Nets.
Bayes rule must satisfy a very important property: when the prior is 0, then regardless of the data
as calculated by Bayes's law, has to be 0 as well.
that we observe, the posterior probability,
* Corresponding author ([email protected])
1
iiijjjpDHpHpHDpDHpH()()()iijjpHDpHDpHD()ipHD()jpHDp(HiD) Likewise, when the prior is 1, the posterior has to be 1 as well. These observations have been called
Cromwell's rule, honoring Oliver Cromwell and his words to the members of the synod of the Church
of Scotland "to think it possible that you may be mistaken" (Carlyle, 1885). The argument goes that
(e.g., if one cares to stay open-minded) one should assign some small possibility to even the most
improbable state of affairs. Otherwise, however much evidence is subsequently accumulated in favor of
the zero-prior possibility, one will be trapped with all-zero posteriors – we call this the zero priors trap.
The trap has roots in the stringent linearity of Bayes's law; updated probabilities are linearly dependent
on the priorsThe main objective of this work is to suggest that the requirement from Bayes's law may
be too stringent, at least in some occasions.
In human decision making, how can the impossible become possible? In this article, we consider
belief updating (in the context of decision making). We discuss a simple experimental paradigm, which
involves the presentation of options for a hypothesis/ problem, some of which are initially impossible/
extremely unlikely. We then create a situation, by providing additional information, which makes some
of these initially impossible options likely. Do participants actually update their beliefs in a way that is
inconsistent with Bayes's law? That is, do participants produce evaluations of posterior probabilities that
exceed the prior probabilities by amounts that go beyond what is allowed by Bayes's law? An interesting
angle to this question concerns creativity, one of the most intriguing features of human cognition. We
do not mean to define or evaluate creativity in this paper. However, whatever creativity is about, it must
also involve a component of eventually recognizing as likely possibilities that had zero or very low
probabilities, to start with. That is, we suggest that, to be "creative", a person has to transcend
Cromwell's rule, in order to assess options, which had been dismissed or not considered before.
We show that there are situations when human decision making is not consistent with Cromwell's
rule. Then we argue that the zero-priors trap can be naturally avoided if one employs quantum probability
theory (QPT), in particular, the QPT rule for updating probabilities, the von Neumann – Lüders' rule.
QPT allows jumps in belief, that is, discontinuous changes in belief states (resulting from
measurements).
We borrow from QPT, initially developed for quantum mechanics, the rules for how to assign
probabilities to events, without any of the physics. QPT is applicable in any situation where there is a
need to formalize uncertainty and, more recently, it has been used to construct cognitive models,
especially in decision making (Pothos & Busemeyer, 2013; Busemeyer & Bruza, 2012; Busemeyer et.
al., 2006; Busemeyer et.al., 2011; Khrennikov, 2003; Haven & Khrennikov, 2012). Such models have
enjoyed good descriptive success, especially for findings which have been paradoxical from a CP
perspective. This is due to the fact that many of such so-called paradoxes, such as order effects
(Trueblood & Busemeyer, 2011), the disjunction effect (Hofstader, 1983; Croson, 1999), and violations
of the law of total probability (Conte et.al., 2007) are conveniently resolved in QPT. It provides an
entirely different (compared to the standard CP one) paradigm for probabilistic inference, where events
and probabilities are represented by vectors in Hilbert space and Hermitian operators. We shall outline
the instruments useful to overcome the zero-priors paradox in the next section. This can also account for
violations of the law of total probability, which has been impressively demonstrated in a number of
experiments (Shafir & Tversky,1992; Tversky & Shafir, 1992; Tversky & Kahneman, 1983; Busemeyer
et.al., 2009). Our goal is to experimentally test the validity of Bayesian updating of zero or extremely
small prior and to apply QPT to the results.
A natural domain to look for a suitable decision making paradigm to test Cromwell's rule is
detective stories, where the criminal turns out to be someone completely unexpected (as in
Dostoyevsky's The Brothers Karamazov, where, in full compliance with CP rules, prior beliefs about
2
the actual criminal were so weak, that his complete confession together with other hard evidence failed
to convince the court) or not even a person (as in Poe's The Murder in the Rue Morgue). In the latter
case, the available prior options do not exhaust the probability space. As briefly noted, a situation when
a previously non-existent option suddenly comes into consideration seems related to creativity. But this
is precisely the problem: some possibilities cannot be, in principle, listed from the very beginning, since
some of them are totally novel and have not been encountered before. For example, it may happen that
the moon contains some minerals that are not present on earth. We are not able to assign even a tiny
probability to such a possibility, in advance.1 Here the classical Bayesian analysis seems simply
inapplicable.
The standard way to deal with such situations in classical probability theory is additive
smoothing, but the problem with it (from the viewpoint of our challenge) is that it is applied a posteriori.
For example, after we discover a new mineral, we reshuffle the prior probabilities adding a "pseudo-
count" to all the priors, so that no option on the (a posteriori!) list has a zero prior. There are other
approaches (Hoppe, 1984), such as the Pólya urn model, directly enforcing increase in probability for a
less probable event each time the more probable event happens. For example, starting with the urn
containing only (or mostly) black balls, we add a white ball each time a black ball is drawn. A variation
most interesting to us considers adding a ball of some new color (instead of white) each time a black
ball is drawn. This is analogous to adding a new option to the list. Still, the question of "creating" the
new colors or new options remains open. The bottom line is that creativity is at odds with the linear
dependence of the posterior on the prior. How fundamental is this feature of Bayesian updating in human
cognition?
The validity of Bayesian updating has been questioned before, for example, by Van Wallendael
and Hastie (Robinson & Hastie, 1985; Van Wallendael, 1989; Van Wallendael & Hastie, 1990) who
noted that, upon receiving information about one hypothesis, people tend to revise only the
corresponding probability and leave their other estimates untouched (so that the total fails to equal one).
Among alternative approaches (in CP), aiming to describe this anomaly, there is Shafer's representation
of belief states (Shafer, 1976) where possible options are grouped (so that one has beliefs about the
groups rather than individual hypotheses). In Section 4 we briefly consider whether this approach is
useful for solving the zero priors paradox. Fundamentally, Shafer's theory of belief functions is
consistent with CP, which makes its application to the present problem limited. In contrast, our main
proposal is that QPT is an appropriate way to generalize CP (and, in particular, allow for nontrivial
updating of zero, or extremely small, priors). Also, approaches beyond CP theory are not necessarily all
quantum, and there are ones that are even more non-classical, compared to QPT. For example, there are
probability models that account for "negative probabilities" regularly encountered both in physics and
cognitive psychology (Acacio de Barros, 2014; Acacio de Barros & Oas, 2014).
In the present paper, we restrict ourselves to a simple experimental setup, where all suspects are
listed beforehand. This allows us a more direct approach and provides for easier analysis. We
demonstrate that the experimental probabilities given by participants in the course of a crime-solving
test strongly violate Bayesian updating. In fact, in 20% of cases participants went from zero prior to high
confidence, in a single step of updating. Such results can be described by QPT.
1 Even if we reserve some portion of our belief to be responsible for all highly improbable possibilities, this does
not help us in creating a new option out of nothing, when we have a set of (not explicitly defined) improbable
possibilities rather than a rigid set of explicit options.
3
2. Principles of Quantum-like Updating
The quantum approach to probability updating involves the formalism of a complex Hilbert space H (for
representing belief states) and the theory of Hermitian operators (for representing observables, including
decision operators).
the norm of
scalar product determines
In QPT, (pure) belief states are represented by normalized vectors in a Hilbert space H (a
complete vector space, where the scalar product between vectors is defined and denoted here as angle
brackets). A
as
ψ=<ψ, ψ>. Vector components are, in general, complex numbers. Given a complex number z=u+iv,
we denote its conjugate as z*, z*=u-iv. The number of vector components is, in general, infinite. Here we
confine ourselves to an m-dimensional Hilbert space, where an orthonormal basis {e1, e2, em} is chosen.
H can then be represented as a Cartesian product Cm, where the scalar product <ψ,>of vectors
*. Operators are
ψ=c1e1+c2e2+…cmem and =k1e1+k2e2+…kmem is then given by c1k1
simply Hermitian matrices. A square matrix A with elements aij is Hermitian if it is equal to its conjugate
transpose, that is aij=aji
any vector ψ on H
*+c2k2
*+…cmkm
*.
Eigenvalues of Hermitian operator are the various possible values that can be obtained with a
measurement. Immediately after a measurement, the state of the system is given by a projection of the
initial state to the eigen-subspace corresponding to the eigenvalue that was obtained, as the result of the
measurement. The latter statement is known as the von-Neumann-Lüders projection postulate.
When observables do not commute, i.e., incompatible observables, the features of quantum
probability updating differ crucially from the well-known features of Bayesian probability updating.
Instead, the von-Neumann-Lüders postulate is used in QPT to update the prior state ψ0 by the means of
projector operator E to a new state:
.
(2)
In classical probability theory there is the set of hypotheses or "states" ={1, 2, …m}, which
are mutually exclusive (only one of them is actually true) and exhaust the whole probability space, so
that the sum of all probabilities (i) is one. More generally, when is not necessarily discrete, one can
speak about a probability density () on rather than discrete probabilities (i).
Constructing a big enough state space is an important first step. From the start, we have to account
even for the most inconceivable possibilities by introducing the corresponding states into consideration
(e.g., that the moon is made of green cheese). In contrast, in the quantum model, see below, we are free
to assign to them zero priors.
For a random variable X taking values from the set {x1, x2, … xn}, one can specify the probability
distribution p(x) for each state . We use two different letters and p to distinguish between probability
distributions for hypotheses and information X. Now, if the random variable X is measured, one can
update the prior probability distribution on the basis of information gained from this concrete result of
measurement, say xi. The classical probability updating gives us (x) according to the Bayes rule
(leaving probabilities 0 and 1 invariant), as:
(xi)= p(xi)()/ p(xi).
(3)
Consider two observables with values 1, 2, …m and X with values x1, x2, … xn. The first
one corresponds to the initial set of hypotheses and the second one to some additional information (which
will be used for probability updating). In QPT, the observables are represented by Hermitian operators,
which we can denote as and X as well, with eigenvalues and x, correspondingly. Then,
and
,
(4)
4
00/EEExXxF where summation is over all possible values or x, and (E) and (Fx) are orthogonal projectors
corresponding to the eigen-subspaces of these operators.
For a particular person, the initial mental representation relevant to a situation is given by a belief
state ψ0 H. Within this state, all subjective probabilities for different states of nature are already
encoded. They can be extracted by performing direct measurements of and taking the square of the
norm of the resulting vector:
(5)
This observation procedure models decision making about prior possibilities of contained in ψ0.2
We want to update the probabilities of on the basis of additional information from measurement
of the X. By using Lüders rule (2), which is the quantum rule for conditional probabilities, we get
.
(6)
The result is not constrained to coincide with Bayesian probability updating. We shall address
the question of when quantum probability updating coincides with classical updating elsewhere.
Let us explore how these ideas apply to a situation, analogous to the one in our empirical
investigation. Suppose that some crime case is under investigation by a police officer. He has the list of
suspects {1, 2, … m}. A "classically thinking commissar" assigns some probabilities that the crime
was done by these suspects, (i), i = 1, 2,… m. Then, in the process of investigation he obtains new
pieces of evidence related to this crime, which are encoded by some number x. For each suspect i he
assigns probability p(xi) that these pieces of evidence given by x can correspond to the case that the
crime was done by suspect i. Finally, he applies Bayes' formula (3) to get the probability (ix) that i
is really responsible for this crime. If some person was not present in the initial list {1, 2, … m}, i.e.,
()=0, the commissar would never get a nontrivial (ix).
A "quantum thinking commissar" prepares the initial belief state ψ0. It can be represented as
superposition of belief states corresponding to the suspects in the initial list:
.
(7)
The state of belief that some person , who was not present in the list {1, 2, … m}, is the
criminal means that information about is not present in the superposition (7). Moreover, this state is
orthogonal to this superposition, since its prior probability is zero. However, the structure of ψ0 may
2 By demanding that each person is able to assign prior probabilities to all possible outcomes (rather than make a
judgement about one particular outcome) we have to assume that, by performing a "prior-measurement", one does not
irrevocably modify the initial belief state ψ0 or at least ψ0 can be perfectly reproduced to be used for further mental
measurements. This may not sound plausible for physics, where the state collapses as the result of the measurement, but in
studying cognition this assumption is natural. In physics there is assumed (at least, theoretically) a preparation procedure
generating an ensemble of systems in the same state. A mental analog of this physical assumption about state preparation is
that the brain, while solving a concrete problem, is able (and meant to) to return to the same belief state, after a judgment.
However, for some mental contexts this assumption may be very restrictive. In principle, it is possible to proceed without it.
But for the traditional Bayesian approach it is really important to start with the assignment of the prior probabilities, since
they are explicitly involved in the update rule (3).
The crucial feature of the quantum scheme is that it is about the updates of states, not probabilities. Once the state
has been updated, we can obtain the posterior probabilities. Therefore, in principle we can proceed without the explicit
assignment of the prior probabilities () given by (5), meaning that the prior measurement of the -observable can be
eliminated from the quantum scheme of probability updating. So, we can start simply with preparation of the initial belief
state ψ0 and its update resulting from gaining information with the aid of the X-observable, see below.
5
2000EE0020xxxEFFxF20,1iiiiicec change
x-evidence.
dramatically
after
the
The new state (after the x-evidence) can have a component not belonging to {1, 2, … m}. In this
case the commissar would assign a nonzero probability (which may be quite substantial) that the person
, which is not among {1,2, … m}, is the criminal.
One can imagine that together with obtaining the x-evidence, the observer (e.g., the commissar)
is changing his own state, in an essentially non-classical manner. If a new option is born from influence
of some new circumstances, the observer may find his horizons essentially widened by these
circumstances, too.
Suppose, the commissar divides his belief among two suspects, so that his quantum belief state
is c1e1+c2e2, where vectors e1 and e2 are orthogonal (meaning that the options are mutually exclusive,
only one or the other is true). In the present belief state, the options are also exhaustive, meaning that
probabilities sum up to one, c12+c22=1. Meanwhile, the actual state space may be three-dimensional,
with basis vectors e1, e2, and e3 (though the commissar is probably not aware of this), but the prior for
e3 is zero. Now, suppose we measure x -evidence, given by projector on the vector
.
Probabilities about x are collected. But also, as a result of this measurement, the state of the commissar
is changed, namely, it is projected on this vector. The component of the basis vector e3 is no longer zero,
and this is how the third option comes into consideration.
3 Experiment Investigation
3.1 Setup
We conducted two experiments to test whether participants' everyday/ intuitive decision making is
consistent with Bayes's law for probability updating. In both cases, we created simple scenarios, based
on a crime mystery. The experiments were matched in much of their detail, so we describe some of the
common elements here. All participants were provided with a main story (approximately 620 words),
which described a couple, John and Jane, their children (Chad and Cheryl) and a number of other
persons, such as friends, John and Jane's gardener etc. The crucial bit of information was that Jane is
fond of her jewelry, which, though valuable, is kept in her bedroom in an unsecured jewelry box.
Participants are told that, on a particular Sunday evening, Jane discovers her jewelry is stolen. They are
then asked to rate the probability that each of the persons introduced in the main story is the culprit. The
persons were described so that some of them were slightly more likely to be guilty than others. However,
in all cases, Chad (Jane's son) and John (Jane's husband) were initially completely beyond suspicion
(this was directly verified in our data). That is, the main story was constructed so that the priors for Chad
and John to be guilty were extremely low or zero.
After participants rated the suspects, they were given further information, which (unsurprisingly
for the reader of this paper) provided a strong motive for stealing the jewels for Chad (in Experiment 1)
and John (in Experiment 2). Participants were asked to rate the possible suspects again.
With this setup, we therefore have a situation such that a hypothesis with an extremely low prior
suddenly acquires a high posterior. However, empirically, it is impossible to establish whether a prior is
exactly zero vs. just extremely low. Therefore, our test of Cromwell's rule has to correspond to a test of
whether probability updating
is consistent with Bayes's
law, 𝑝(𝜃𝑥) =
𝑝(𝑥𝜃)⋅𝑝(𝜃)
𝑝(𝑥)
or
𝑝(𝜃𝑥)
𝑝(𝜃)
=
𝑝(𝑥𝜃)
𝑝(𝑥)
; put differently, according to Bayes's law, the ratio of the likelihoods is constrained by
the ratio of the priors. To empirically test Bayes's law, we needed two kinds of information,
(1) information on whether a suspect is guilty or not a priori and given the motive and (2) information
6
23/2ee on the motive a priori and given that the jewelry was stolen. Theoretically, it would have been ideal to
collect data on all these probabilities within participants. However, asking participants to estimate the
probabilities of conditionals and their corresponding reciprocals would have potentially been very
confusing, so we adopted a between participants design, regarding the estimation of conditionals in the
two directions.
3.2 Experiment 1 – Chad
3.2.1 Participants
We tested 57 participants, all students at the University of California Irvine, who received fixed course
credit for their time.
3.2.2 Materials and procedure
The experiment was designed in Qualtrics and administered online. The experiment lasted for
approximately 20 minutes. All participants received the main story featuring a family of John, Jane and
their two children Chad and Cheryl, their two neighbors Matt and Mary, a cleaner, a gardener, and a
burglar. Following this, there were 10 multiple choice questions (such as whether John has 1, 2, 3, or 4
children), which were meant to examine participants' basic knowledge of the story. The participants
could not continue with the test until they answered all 10 questions right. Regarding safeguards that
participants seriously engaged with the task, additionally, participants then received 6 catch questions
testing probability intuitions as well as the understanding of the main story. Note, both the main story
and all subsequent text that participants were presented with were accessible to participants throughout
the experiment (that is, participants were told that this was not a memory test and they could take notes
or make a copy of any screen). Four of the second group of 6 questions can be called 'easy catch'
questions, and they corresponded to rather a trivial understanding of probability, such as what is the
probability John has a son, when this fact was explicitly stated in the story. Two of these questions can
be called 'hard catch' questions, and tested participants basic probability intuitions, for example,
participants were asked "What is the probability that Mary has two daughters?" (a hard question) about
the neighbor Mary who is known to be a mother of two, but the sex of her children was not explicitly
provided in the main story.
After the catch questions, participants were told that Jane discovered her jewelry was missing,
called the police, etc. Participants were given some facts that made it slightly likely that the cleaner or
the gardener could have stolen the jewelry. Note also that one of the persons introduced in the main story
was a local burglar, designed to be a fairly natural suspect. Following this information, participants were
told to consider how likely all of the persons in the main story were to have stolen the jewelry – there
were in total nine persons and participants were also allowed to enter a probability for 'other persons'.
Note, participants were told to indicate their probability estimates for each suspect on a 0 to 100 scale
and that their probabilities should sum up to 100 (this was checked automatically by the experimental
software).
Following these ratings, the study went differently for two groups of participants. The first group
was provided with a strong motive that Chad stole the jewelry. In brief, they were told that Chad wrecked
a friend's car and needed money to repair it. They were then asked to rate the probability that each person
had stolen the jewelry, as before. This was the last request in the experiment. This condition provided
information for evaluating
, where Je denotes the event Chad stole the jewellery and I denotes
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐽𝑒𝐼)
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐽𝑒)
the information that Chad wrecked the car and needed money to repair it.
7
In the second condition, after the first rating of the people, participants were given information
about what was labeled a 'claim about Chad'. The claim was, basically, that Chad wrecked a friend's
car. Participants were asked to rate the probability of this claim about Chad. In a subsequent screen,
participants were informed that it is known for a fact that the jewelry was stolen by Chad and asked to
update the probability of the claim about Chad. Thus, the second condition provides information that
allows us to compute
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐼𝐽𝑒)
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐼)
. At this point, it should be clear why we opted to adopt a between
participants, rather than a within participants design: for participants who had been asked to estimate
e.g., 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐽𝑒𝐼), it would have been very confusing to subsequently estimate 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐼𝐽𝑒) as well.
Finally, note that all main parts of the text employed in the two conditions are shown in Appendix 1.
3.2.4 Results
In Table 1, we show the probability estimates regarding all people in the story, prior estimates (collected
in both conditions of the experiment) as well as updated ones (collected in the first condition), following
the information about Chad. The prior probability that Chad is guilty, P(Je), was on average 1.5 % the
updated probability P(JeI) was on average 34 %, the prior probability of the claim about Chad, P(I),
was on average 40 % and the conditional probability of the claim about Chad, given that he had stolen
the jewelry, P(IJe), was on average 79 %.
Table 1. Results of Experiment 1 (Chad). Prior and updated (marked in grey) responses for each
suspect. Shown are frequencies and mean probabilities. Standard deviations are given in
parentheses.
0 0.5-10 11-20
21-30 31-40
41-50
51-60
61-70
71-80
81-90
91-100
Frequencies, %
87
87
89
87
76
0
78
80
31
34
51
50
4
10
4
10
15
20
67
76
13
13
11
13
24
27
20
20
40
50
36
40
22
33
24
44
24
30
22
17
0
0
0
0
0
7
2
0
16
13
7
7
14
27
22
23
18
27
4
0
0
0
0
0
0
30
0
0
9
0
4
0
27
23
38
20
18
13
4
0
0
0
0
0
0
7
0
0
2
0
2
3
5
7
5
3
5
4
0
7
0
0
0
0
0
13
0
0
0
0
0
0
20
0
5
0
11
0
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
4
0
2
0
7
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
3
0
0
0
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
7
0
0
2
0
0
0
4
0
0
0
2
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Averaged
probability,
%
0.9 (2.7)
0.9 (2.7)
0.8 (2.5)
1.0 (2.7)
1.5 (3.2)
34 (24)
1.5 (3.5)
1.1 (2.7)
11 (13)
7.8 (12)
5.7 (7.8)
5.1 (7.7)
28 (19)
16 (11)
22 (13)
14 (9.5)
24 (20)
17 (17)
5.1 (11)
3.4 (10)
Suspect
John (prior)
John (updated)
Jane (prior)
Jane (updated)
Chad (prior)
Chad (updated)
Cheryl (prior)
Cheryl (updated)
Matt (prior)
Matt (updated)
Mary (prior)
Mary (updated)
Cleaner (prior)
Cleaner (updated)
Gardener (prior)
Gardener (updated)
Burglar (prior)
Burglar (updated)
Others (prior)
Others (updated)
We seek to test against the null hypothesis that
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐽𝑒𝐼)
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐽𝑒)
=
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐼𝐽𝑒)
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐼)
, as required by Bayes's
law of probability updating. Intuitively, the reason why Bayes's law may be violated in this case is that
we were expecting a huge increase in the probability that Chad is guilty, from the prior estimate P(Je)
to the estimate P(JeI), following the information that Chad had wrecked the car. Note first that given
8
expectations for low (or zero) priors, we computed for each participant either
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐼𝐽𝑒)
depending on condition. Still, one participant produced 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐽𝑒𝐼) = 0 (out of 31) and another
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐼𝐽𝑒) = 0 (out of 26) and these were eliminated from further consideration (their results cannot
be used to evaluate Bayes's law). We used the MATLAB software package to calculate z and p values.
,
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐽𝑒)
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐽𝑒𝐼)
or
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐼)
A non-parametric Mann-Whitney U-test of
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐽𝑒𝐼)
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐽𝑒)
vs.
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐼𝐽𝑒)
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐼)
was found highly significant,
z=4.6, p=5·10-6 (U=120, n1=30, n2=25), allowing us to reject the null hypothesis that these two quantities
are equal. Next, recall, the easy catch questions provided a measure of participants' attention paid to the
story plus some trivial understanding of the probability concept (max possible score 4) and the hard
catch questions a measure of participants' probabilistic intuitions (max possible score 2). We ran the U-
test comparison once more, but excluding all participants with an easy catch score of 2 or less (23
participants were excluded like this); the test was significant again, z=-2.8, p=.006, (U=59, n1=16,
n2=16). Overall, across a number of checks, there was strong evidence that probability updating was not
consistent with Bayes's law.
3.3 Experiment 2 – John
3.3.1 Participants
We tested 58 participants, all students at the University of California Irvine, who received fixed course
credit for their time.
3.3.2 Materials and procedure
Most aspects of this experiment are the same as for Experiment 1 – Experiment 2 was meant to be a
simple replication of Experiment 1. Therefore, we only describe the ways in which Experiment 2 differed
from Experiment 1.
In the first condition, after participants submitted the prior estimates of the probability that each
person stole the jewelry, participants were provided with a strong motive for John. They were told that
John had a severe, secret gambling problem and he owed a lot of money. They were also told that if Jane
were to find out about John's debts, she would likely divorce him. So, this motive was meant to make
John a very likely suspect. The first condition ended as in Experiment 1, with participants being asked
to update the probability that each suspect was guilty, following this new information about John.
In the second condition, following prior evaluation, participants were told about the above 'claim
for John' and were asked to evaluate its probability, P(I). They were then told that the jewelry was
definitely stolen by John and they were asked to rate again the probability of the claim about John, given
John had stolen the jewelry P(IJe). In Appendix 2, the interested reader can see the text for Experiment
2 that is different, compared to Experiment 1.
3.3.2 Results
We proceed as for Experiment 1. Table 2 shows the estimates for the prior and updated probability for
each person of the story stealing the jewels. The prior probability that John has stolen the jewels, P(Je)
was on average 1.6 %, the updated P(JeI) was on average 39 %, the prior probability for the claim about
John, P(I) was on average 41 %, and the conditional probability for the claim, given that John was known
to have stolen the jewelry, was on average 83 %.
Table 2. Results of Experiment 2 (John). Prior and updated (marked in grey) responses for each
suspect. Shown are frequencies and mean probabilities. Standard deviations are given in
parentheses.
9
Suspect
John (prior)
John (updated)
Jane (prior)
Jane (updated)
Chad (prior)
Chad (updated)
Cheryl (prior)
Cheryl (updated)
Matt (prior)
Matt (updated)
Mary (prior)
Mary (updated)
Cleaner (prior)
Cleaner (updated)
Gardener (prior)
Gardener (updated)
Burglar (prior)
Burglar (updated)
Others (prior)
Others (updated)
0 0.5-10 11-20
21-30 31-40
41-50
51-60
61-70
71-80
81-90
91-100
Frequencies, %
78
0
85
89
78
82
76
86
38
46
40
50
15
25
11
22
7
18
73
75
20
11
11
11
20
18
24
14
38
47
36
39
16
32
22
43
15
39
15
18
0
25
2
0
0
0
0
0
18
7
20
11
25
14
24
14
14
18
5
0
2
18
0
14
0
0
2
0
0
0
6
0
2
0
31
25
34
21
15
7
7
7
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
7
0
7
0
7
7
0
0
0
7
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0
4
0
2
0
27
4
0
0
0
7
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
4
0
0
2
0
0
0
0
4
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
4
0
0
0
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0
0
0
7
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
3
0
0
0
11
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
4
0
0
0
Averaged
probability,
%
1.6 (4.1)
39 (28)
2.9 (13.8)
0.8 (2.6)
1.6 (4.7)
1.3 (3.2)
1.3 (2.7)
1.2 (3.2)
7.5 (8)
4.6 (5.3)
7.4 (9)
4.4 (5.6)
20 (14)
14 (13)
18 (11)
12 (9)
36 (25)
19 (21)
4.0 (8.3)
3.2 (7.5)
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐼)
Using the notation of Experiment 1, we excluded participants for whom
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐼𝐽𝑒)
were uncomputable. This was the case for two participants in the first condition (out of 30) and one in
the second (out of 28). The two quantities on either side of Bayes's law were significantly different,
z=4.7, p=2·10-6 (U=648, n1=28, n2=27), thus we could not sustain the null hypothesis that participants'
probability updating was consistent with Bayes's law. The same conclusion was reached when we ran
the same U-test, but excluding all participants with an easy catch score of 2 or less (23 participants
excluded; z=2.9, p=.004, U=202, n1=17, n2=15).
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐽𝑒)
𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑏(𝐽𝑒𝐼)
or
3. QPT application
In this section we illustrate how QPT can accommodate large jumps in probability updating. The human
behavior we are interested in corresponds just to the process of probability updating. Thus, there is no
detailed model to be constructed, instead we specify the representation and show that QPT can reproduce
the observed probability updating. This is not possible with CPT, as shown in the results sections of the
two experiments.
We illustrate QPT probability updating in two ways, a coarse grained one and a fine grained one.
Starting with the former, let us number the basis vectors as follows: e1==Chad>, e2==the
burglar>, e3==the cleaner>, e4==the gardener>, e5==others>. In what follows, we confine
our consideration to this five-dimensional case. Conveniently, in the above basis, the probabilities for
the different hypotheses are given as the squared norm of coefficients before the basis vectors. Let us
take the prior state in the simplest form, such that the probabilities are those given in Table 3:
.
(8)
Table 3. Prior beliefs for each hypothesis
=John =Jane =Chad =Cheryl =Matt =Mary
0 %
0 %
0 %
0 %
0 %
0 %
the
gardener
20 %
the
cleaner
20 %
the
burglar
50 %
others
10 %
10
023450.50.20.20.1eeee Note that e1 does not appear in the above equation because the probability amplitude for the Chad vector
is zero. The other amplitudes just correspond to the observed data. Given this state vector, 𝜓0, we can
reproduce all the prior probabilities, by projecting ψ0 on the mutually orthogonal basis vectors defined
above, such as =Chad>, =the burglar>,… The corresponding projectors E, (one projector for each
hypothesis; Equation 5) are given by E=ei><ei and lead to the corresponding probabilities in Table 3
through <Eψ0,ψ0>. Note, <vector is the complex conjugate of vector>. Finally, state ψ0 represents the
cognitive state of a typical or average participant in the experiment, after the first step of evaluating
suspect probabilities, but we are not concerned with the cognitive state before this step. This state is
meant to reproduce the response statistics across the sample, on average. As our objective is focused on
probability updating behavior observed in the sample as a whole, we did not pursue modelling of
individual differences (with future extensions, this could be done with the formalism of density
matrices).
What is the effect of new information about Chad on the mental state ψ0? Mostly, it advances the
Chad hypothesis without affecting the other hypotheses. We know the specific effect this new
information has on the mental state, since we know how the prior probabilities change, after the new
information. Thus, if the initial state is ψ0, as above, then we know that the effect of the new information
would be to project ψ0 to a new state ψI with coefficients such that their squared norm gives the updated
probabilities. This new state ψI simply corresponds to the observed updated probabilities, after
participants received the new information; basically, the probability for Chad has "jumped" from zero
to a substantial number, while all other probabilities decreased. We can identify a projector operator that
projects ψ0 to ψI (note that ψI and a projector are not unique; however, all projectors have to be symmetric
and equal to their square) and an example is:
23/32 −9/32
−9/32 23/32
−3√1.5/16 −3√2/16
−3√1.5/16 −3√2/16
0
0
−3√1.5/16 −3√1.5/16
−3√2/16
−3√2/16
0 0
13/16
−√3/8
−√3/8
3/4
0 0
.
(9)
0
0
0)
FI=
(
Using this projector, our initial state (7) is updated to
ψI =
.
(10)
Finally, to obtain the probability of each person being the thief, we again apply the projector E
for a particular suspect 𝜃 as shown in Eq (5). The probability for Chad has "jumped" from zero to 65%,
while all other probabilities decreased. Note, a proper cognitive model of this decision making situation
would focus more on how the different kinds of evidence impact on beliefs about states. However, as
noted, here we only want to illustrate how QPT can accommodate large increases in probability;
Equation (9) effectively constitutes an existence proof that QPT can. Note, for simplicity, we took the
last row of our projector to be zero. Naturally, this resulted in zero updated probability of e5.
In the experiment we observed the following: when updating from P(Je) to P(JeI) (both in
Experiments 1 and 2), 38 % of the participants changed at least one of their estimates from non-zero to
zero; at the same time, 44 % of the participants left at least one of their estimates unchanged.
If one seeks a more fine-grained description of the results, then we can easily extend the above
approach. Let us consider a more fine-grained basis, corresponding to the suspects in the order they
appear in Tables 1, 2, and 3: e1==John>, e2==Jane>, e3==Chad>, e4==Cheryl>,
e5==Matt>, e6==Mary>, e7==the gardener>, e8==the cleaner>, e9==the burglar>,
e10==others>. For Experiment 1, the initial state can be chosen as:
11
12340.650.30.040.01eeee It can be readily confirmed that this state vector reproduces all the estimates for the prior
probabilities for all suspects, as in Table 1 (the unshaded rows). The impact of the new information on
ψ0 can be given through the projector FI=f><f, where
. (11)
(12)
For illustration, we compute the projector explicitly below:
The resulting updated state ψ1=<fψ0>f> is
(13)
(14)
As previously, it is clear that projecting ψ1 to a basis vector ei will yield the corresponding
posterior probability, after participants had processed the new information regarding the theft case (as
specified in ith shaded row of Table 1).
Similarly, for Experiment 2, the initial state can be set to:
, (15)
Thus, prior probabilities coincide with those in the unshaded rows of Table 2. The projector
corresponding to receiving the new information can be taken to be of the form f><f, where
(16)
The resulting state ψ1=<fψ0>f> is then
. (17)
Projecting ψ1 to a basis vector ei will yield the corresponding probability equal to the one
specified in ith shaded row of Table 1.
Finally, we can consider what are the implications regarding psychological process, from the
application of QPT in this example. We can be guided by Dubois and Lambert-Mogiliansky (2015).
Their argument appeals to the incompatibility of perspectives in the mind and the process of learning.
For example, from the perspective of the initial information about possible suspects, John appears as an
12
01234567891010.90.81.51.5115.72822245.110eeeeeeeeee1234567891011.0121.0666.2171.1182.9782.4084.2653.994.3961.96610feeeeeeeeee1.0241.0796.2921.1313.0142.4374.3164.0384.4491.9901.0791.1376.6271.1923.1752.5674.5464.2534.6862.0966.2926.62738.6516.95118.51414.97126.51624.80627.33012.2231.1311.1926.9511.2503.3292.6924.76841100IF.4614.9152.1983.0143.17518.5143.3298.8687.17112.70111.88213.0915.8552.4372.56714.9712.6927.1715.79810.2709.60810.5864.7344.3164.54626.5164.76812.70110.27018.19017.01718.7498.3854.0384.25324.8064.46111.8829.60817.01715.92017.5407.8444.4494.68627.3304.91513.09110.58618.74917.54019.3258.6431.9902.09612.2232.1985.8554.7348.3857.8448.6433.86511234567891010.9341.17.85.11614173.410eeeeeeeeee01234567891011.62.91.61.37.57.4201836410eeeeeeeeee1234567891016.7790.9711.2381.1892.3282.2774.0623.7614.7321.94210feeeeeeeeee1123456789101390.81.31.24.64.41412193.210eeeeeeeeee extremely unlikely suspect. In technical terms, the basis corresponding to the initial perspective makes
it very unlikely that John is a suspect. When the new information about John's gambling becomes
available (Experiment 2), the mind shifts perspectives regarding John and the possibility that he is guilty.
This new perspective incorporates information about how he is perhaps not a bad man, but his weakness
in gambling now endangers his marriage. With this new perspective, the basis set for evaluating the
possible guilt of different suspects likewise changes and the projection onto the subspace corresponding
to John's guilt becomes large. Importantly, the new perspective produces probabilities that are not
linearly related to the priors and so QPT can accommodate changes from priors to posteriors not possible
classically, as well as interference effects etc.
4. Discussion
Experiments 1 and 2 are very similar and demonstrated very similar results. About 20% of the
participants updated their zero or nearly zero priors to high confidence (more than 50%) upon receiving
new information about John or Chad, demonstrating a strong deviation from Cromwell's rule. Probably,
the zeros initially entered by participants for some suspects are but a shorthand for some small number,
like 0.00001. Participants were allowed but not encouraged to input long decimals. Still, the results
cannot be accommodated by Bayesian updating. Moreover, an assumption that people can have such a
refined scale of probability may not be very plausible.
An attempt to reconcile these results with classical Bayesian updating may lie in direct
observation (experimental collection of the relevant data) of all ten conditional probabilities. Denote the
ten possible options =1, =2, …, in general, =i, where by we mean "the thief", and by 1 all
possible suspects, for example, p(=1) is the prior probability that John is the thief. In principle,
.
(18)
In the present work, participants were asked to directly evaluate the probability p(I). Alternatively, we
could have asked them about all p(I=i) on the right hand side of (18) and then calculate p(I). Would
this lead to smaller violation of the Bayesian updating? If yes, this would mean that the present
experiments can be interpreted as an unpacking effect (Tversky & Kohler, 1994), a kind of violation of
the law of total probability, in the form (18), or a conjunction effect, where p(I) is harder to estimate
than p(I=i) and, hence, estimates for p(I) are smaller than p(I=i). For the moment, this is only a
hypothesis, which shall be put to experimental test in the future.
The possibilities p(=i) are always assumed to be mutually exclusive and exhaustive, meaning
that exactly one suspect is actually the thief. Probably, these are the features that make Bayesian updating
problematic in decision making. As noted in the Introduction, in earlier experiments violating Bayesian
updating, Shaferian representation of beliefs was quite successfully applied (staying in the framework
of CP theory). This theory aims to relax assumptions of exhaustiveness and mutual exclusiveness of
options (and account for experimental violation of these assumptions), by working with groups of
options. For example, one option may enter a few groups, so the groups cannot be thought of as mutually
exclusive.
Shafer's idea is that upon the new information in favor or against one option, e.g. 1, probability
is reallocated within each group containing 1, so that structure of the groups may become finer, which
finally leads to a decision. Interestingly, estimates of the other options, not initially grouped with x1,
remain the same. Could our results be accounted for by a generalized version of CP theory, such as the
one proposed by Shafer?
13
101iiipIpIp A common prior probability distribution we observed in our experiment looks like Table 3: the
gardener 20%, the cleaner 20%, the burglar 50%, others 10%, other six personages (four of the family
plus two neighbors) 0% each.
Suppose that the actual belief system was a grouping (for simplicity, the subsets are mutually
exclusive) as shown in Table 4.3 One may interpret this grouping as a reluctance to assign a zero prior
to any hypothesis. Also, this saves computational capacity. A participant may think that the most obvious
suspect is the burglar and that there are two other, equally probable, suspects; then, one can group
whoever is left into the least probable belief set.
Table 4. Prior belief representation.
{the family, the neighbors, others}
{the gardener, the cleaner}
{the burglar}
10 %
40 %
50 %
Now, the evidence pointing towards Chad or John as the possible criminals does not entail
Bayesian updating on a zero prior, rather the new key suspect can reclaim all 10% of belief belonging
to his group. This would nicely correspond to this particular result of our experiment (updating from
zero to a significant probability). Still, other estimates, which remain unchanged in this (rather simple)
Shaferian model, were found to significantly change in the experiment. According to Shafer's theory,
the (classical) belief state updated on the incriminating information about Chad, would be as shown in
Table 5.
Table 5. Updated belief representation.
{Chad}
{the family excluding Chad,
the neighbors, others}
{the gardener, the cleaner}
{the burglar}
0 %
50 %
40 %
10 %
This does not coincide with the results of our experiment (nor with our intuition) and indicates
that QPT approach is the more effective one for our problem. Of course, a more sophisticated Shaferian
representation can be constructed to better accommodate the results, but we shall not address this in
detail. Let us only note that two opposite directions – adding Chad to more and more belief groups (to
all of them, in the extreme case) or separating him from other suspects (in the extreme case, to the group
of his own) finally result in a standard Bayesian updating scheme.
We have shown that Shafer theory does not describe our data (at least, in a straightforward
manner), in contrast to QPT, as our illustration, presented in Section 4, shows. One feature that makes
QPT promising is that quantum belief states are much richer (contain much more information) than
classical belief states.
To summarize, we suggest a method from QPT to describe our experimental data, which, we
found, violates classical Bayesian updating. The latter is based on probability of a joint event
Prob(hypothesisdata)∙Prob(data)=Prob(datahypothesis)∙Prob(hypothesis)=Prob(hypothesis&data).(19)
Finding a direct analogue to this expression consistent with QPT is hardly feasible. To mention one
problem, most often a combination (a product) of two projectors is not a projector. Still, some attempts
can be found in the literature on quantum physics (Steinberg, 1995), but the limitations must always be
in sight. We can safely calculate Prob(data) as <Projector data belief state>2. For example, in our
3 Even if beliefs are assigned to groups of options, presumably probability of a single option may be extracted at
request.
14
example from Section 4, the hypothesis under consideration is =1. Applying operator (9) to prior state
ψ0 in form (8), and taking the norm of the resulting vector
FIψ0= -0.42e1+0.29e2+0.1e3+0.05e4 ,
(20)
we get Prob(data)=0.27 (27%). Now, guided by formula (5) we apply the projector E1=e1><e1 to
ψI = FI ψ0/0.271/2 (ψI is normed FI ψ0) and we get Prob (hypothesisdata)=0.42/0.27=0.65 (65%). Still,
Prob(datahypothesis)=0 as the result of applying operator (9) to zero vector, which, in turn, is the result
of projecting ψ0 to e1. Using these values in formula (19), we get 0.65·0.27=0·0, that is, a violation of
Bayesian updating again, which is due to noncommutativity of operators (9) and E1.
an order effect
Noncommutativity often leads to such order effects and, indeed, our data can be interpreted as
(21)
5. Conclusion
We experimentally observed violations of classical, Bayesian updating of belief. As shown, updating on
strong evidence can lead to a dramatic increase of confidence (from zero, practically denying the
possibility) to almost complete confidence. We explain how and why quantum probability theory can be
applied to describe the experimental results and resolve the zero-prior trap, in a way which is probably
more efficient than following Cromwell's rule (applying only non-zero and non-one probabilities to all
the options). The present work provides new insights potentially applicable in the experimental and
theoretical study of the phenomenon of creativity, which can be interesting not only for cognitive
psychology but also for more applied subjects, such as artificial intelligence.
Acknowledgements
IB was supported by a Marie Sklodowska-Curie Individual Fellowship, grant agreement 696331. EMP
was supported by Leverhulme Trust grant RPG-2013-004 and by Air Force Office of Scientific Research
(AFOSR), Air Force Material Command, USAF, grant FA 8655-13-1-3044. The U.S. Government is
authorized to reproduce and distribute reprints for Governmental purpose notwithstanding any copyright
notation
SES-1326275.
IB and AK were supported by the grant Mathematical Modeling of Complex Hierarchic systems of
Faculty of Technology, Linnaeus University.
supported
thereon.
JST
was
by
NSF
grant
15
pJepIJepJeIpIJepIpJeI References
Acacio de Barros, J. (2014) Decision making for inconsistent expert judgments using negative probabilities. In
Quantum Interaction, pp. 257–269. Springer, Berlin-Heidelberg,
Acacio de Barros, J. & Oas, G. (2014) Negative probabilities and counter-factual reasoning in quantum cognition.
Phys. Scr. T163, 014008
Busemeyer, J. R. & Bruza, P. D. (2012). Quantum models of cognition and decision. Cambridge University Press.
Busemeyer, J. R., Pothos, E. M., Franco, R. & Trueblood, J. S., (2011) A quantum theoretical explanation for
probability judgment errors, Psychological Review, 118(2), 193–218.
Busemeyer, J. R., Wang, Z., & Townsend, J. T. (2006) Quantum dynamics of human decision making. J. Math.
Psychology 50, 220–241.
Busemeyer, J. R., Wang, Z., & Lambert-Mogiliansky, A. (2009). Empirical comparison of Markov and quantum
models of decision making. Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 53, 423–433.
Carlyle, Th. ed. (1855). Oliver Cromwell's Letters and Speeches 1. New York, Harper Publ.
Conte, E., Todarello, O., Federici, A., Vitiello, F., Lopane, M., Khrennikov, A. &Zbilut, J. P. (2007). Some
remarks on an experiment suggesting quantum-like behavior of cognitive entities and formulation of an abstract
quantum mechanical formalism to describe cognitive entity and its dynamics. Chaos, Solitonsand Fractals, 31(5),
1076–1088.
Croson, R. (1999) The disjunction effect and reasoning-based choice in games, Organizational Behavior and
Human Decision Processes, 80, 118–133.
Dubois, F. and Lambert-Mogiliansky, A. (2015) in "Contextuality in Quantum Physics and Psychology" ed. E.
Dzhafarof, S. Jordan, R. Zhang and V. Cervantes, New Jersey: World Scientific.
Griffiths, T. L., Chater, N., Kemp, C., Perfors, A., & Tenenbaum, J. B. (2010). Probabilistic models of cognition:
exploring representations and inductive biases. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 14, 357– 364.
Haven, E. & Khrennikov, A. (2012). Quantum Social Science, Cambridge Press.
Hofstader, D. R. (1983) Dilemmas for superrational thinkers, leading up to a luring lottery. Sc. Am., 6.
Hoppe, F. M. (1984). "Pólya-like urns and the Ewing sampling formula". Journal of Mathematical Biology 20:
91–94
Khrennikov, A. (2003) Quantum-like formalism for cognitive measurements. Biosystems 70: 211–233.
Khrennikov, A. (2010). Ubiquitous quantum structure: from psychology to finance. Springer, Heidelberg-Berlin-
New York.
Luce, R. D. (1997) Several unresolved conceptual problems of mathematical psychology. Journal of mathematical
psychology, 41(1), 79 – 87.
Oaksford, M. & Chater, N. (2007). Bayesian rationality: The probabilistic approach to human reasoning. Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
Pothos, E. M. & Busemeyer, J. R. (2013), Can quantum probability provide a new direction for cognitive
modeling? Behavioral Brain Sciences, 36, 255–274.
Robinson, L. B. & Hastie, R. (1985). Revision of opinion when a hypothesis is eliminated from consideration,
Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception & Performance, 11, 443–456.
Shafer, G. (1976). A mathemaical theory of evidence. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Shafir, E. & Tversky, A. (1992). Thinking through uncertainty: nonconsequential reasoning and choice, Cognitive
Psychology, 24, 449–474.
Steinberg, A. M. (1995). Conditional probabilities in quantum theory and the tunneling-time controversy, Phys.
Rev. A 52, 32 – 42.
Tenenbaum, J. B, Kemp, C., Griffiths, T. L., & Goodman, N. (2011). How to grow a mind: statistics, structure,
and abstraction. Science, 331, 1279–1285.
Trueblood, J. S. & Busemeyer, J. R. (2011), A quantum probability model for order effects on inference, Cognitive
Science 35, 1518–1522.
Tversky, A. &Kahneman, D. (1983). Extension versus intuitive reasoning: The conjunction fallacy in probability
judgement, Psychological Review, 90, 293–315.
16
Tversky, A. & Köhler, D. J. (1994). Support theory: A nonextensional representation of subjective probability,
Psychological Review, 101, 547–567.
Tversky, A. & Shafir, E. (1992). The disjunction effect in choice under uncertainty, Psych. Sc., 3, 305.
Van Wallendael, L. R. (1989). The quest for limits on noncomplementarity in opinion revision. Organizational
Behavior& Human Decision Processes, 43, 385–405.
Van Wallendael, L. R. & Hastie, R. (1990). Tracing the footsteps of Sherlock Holmes: Cognitive representations
of hypothesis testing. Memory and Cognition, 18(3) 240–250.
17
Appendix 1. The text employed in Experiment 1 - Chad.
Main story (the same for groups one and two):
John and Jane are a fairly wealthy family, living in a large house. Their house is located on a
quiet road, in a leafy suburb of a middle-sized town. They have been living there for several years and
know their neighbors quite well. John and Jane have two young children, Chad and Cheryl, who still go
to primary school. Many of their neighbors have children as well and one often sees a crowd of children
playing on their road.
John is a medical doctor, specialized on pediatrics. He works at a local hospital. He seems to be
good at his job and he enjoys a good reputation in the local community.
Jane works as an assistant in a cosmetics shop. The shop is a small business that has been doing
quite well. Jane is very meticulous about her looks and she spends nearly all her money on jewelry. She
has an impressive collection of jewelry, including several diamond rings and golden items. She keeps
her jewelry, in a jewelry box, in the master bedroom of the house. She is very emotionally attached to
her jewelry. The jewelry box has a lock, but she often just forgets the key in the lock.
Chad is 11 years old. He is often seen playing ball, with other children on his street. He is
sociable. He likes school and does all right at school.
Cheryl is 9 years old. She likes drawing and takes an evening art class. She would like to become
a doctor, like her dad. She is very close friends with some other children in the neighborhood.
Sibyl is a cleaner who comes to John and Jane's house once every week, usually on a Saturday
morning, while everybody is out. She seems conscientious and has been working for John and Jane for
many years. She is a single mother who lives just with her one child. She is 32 years old and she
sometimes feels that her life is going nowhere. Recently, her child has been sick, but she has not been
able to afford to take her to the hospital for proper care.
Richard is the gardener who comes to John and Jane's house once a week as well. The days on
which he comes vary, since he avoids coming when it is rainy. Richard is hard working and has, so far,
seemed content with this lot in life. He has access to the backdoor of the house. He has recently started
going out with a girlfriend from a very wealthy family. He is very much in love with her and wants to
impress her.
Matt and Mary are neighbors. They also have a large house and are good friends with John and
Jane. They are not as wealthy as John and Jane and recently they had to trade their car for a smaller one.
They also have two children.
Matt is a lawyer. He specialized on criminal law. However, he has been finding his work stressful
and has not been taking many new cases. He would like to find, somehow, a chunk of money to repay
the remaining of the mortgage on his house and then sit back and reevaluate his career.
Mary does not work. She had her two children when she was fairly young. Now, the children are
older and need less attention, but she never managed to get a career going. She is now mostly happy to
look after the house and pass her time with various hobbies.
Andrew is a burglar operating in the town where John and Jane live. He is very professional and
likes to do his research before attempting to enter a house. He prefers to steal smaller valuables, since
these are easier to sell.
(At this point participants see the following test questions)
Who is John's wife?
o Sibyl
o Katy
o Cleopatra
18
How many children does John have?
o 1
o 2
o 3
o 4
Where does Jane work?
o At a cosmetics shop.
o At a supermarket.
o At a law firm.
o At a nuclear station.
How old is Cheryl?
o 7
o 8
o 9
o 10
Who is Cheryl's brother?
o Richard.
o Chad.
o John.
o Matt.
What is the name of the cleaner?
o Richard.
o Mary.
o Sibyl.
o Jane.
When does the cleaner usually come?
o Mondays.
o Thursdays.
o Saturdays.
o We don't know.
What is the name of gardener?
o Richard.
o Sibyl.
o Matt.
o Mary.
What does Matt do?
o He is a cleaner.
19
o He is a secret agent.
o He is a doctor.
o He is a lawyer.
How many children do Matt and Mary have?
o 1
o 2
o 3
o 4
(At this point participants see the following catch questions)
What is the probability that Jane has a daughter?
o 0%
o 25%
o 50%
o 75%
o 100%
What is the probability that Sybil has a daughter?
o 0%
o 25%
o 50%
o 75%
o 100%
What is the probability that Sybil has a son?
o 0%
o 25%
o 50%
o 75%
o 100%
What is the probability that Mary has two daughters?
o 0%
o 25%
o 50%
o 75%
o 100%
What is the probability that Mary has no daughters?
o 0%
o 25%
o 50%
o 75%
o 100%
What is the probability that Cheryl has a sister?
o 0%
o 25%
o 50%
20
o 75%
o 100%
At this point participants see the information about theft
Theft
It's Sunday evening, after dinner. Chad and Cheryl are in their rooms, reading, before going to sleep.
John is having a shower. Jane is getting ready for bed. She opens her jewelry box to discover that all her
jewelry is missing! John and Jane quickly call the police. These are the facts: The last time Jane checked
her jewelry was Friday evening. Saturday morning was a sunny day. Sibyl (the cleaner) was due to come
(she did). Richard (the gardener) came too, at some point in the morning, though he did not see Sibyl.
All the family (John, Jane, Chad, Cheryl) was out Saturday morning. John went for a bicycle ride; Jane
was working; Char and Cheryl visited some friends. They came back home at different times on
Saturday, though no one came before 1:00 pm and they did not see either Sibyl or Richard at the house.
In the evening of Saturday, John and Jane had invited Matt and Mary for dinner.
At this point participants are asked to rate the suspects.
The above part of the scenario, including the prior rating, is the same for Experiment 1 (both
groups) and Experiment 2 (both groups).
We continue with Experiment 1. The remainder of the test goes differently for the two groups.
The first group of participants is given new information as follows.
Chad is in big trouble. One evening in the last few weeks, he and a friend of his "borrowed" the car of
the friend's dad. They only wanted to drive around the block, but things got a bit out of control, and they
ended up crashing the car. Fortunately, it was possible to have it repaired and returned promptly. But
now Chad needs to settle the bill for the repairs or the mechanic threatens he will go to Chad's family or
the police. Jane's jewelry would cover the cost.
At this point participants of the first group are asked to rate the suspects again and this is the end
of the test for them.
For the second between participants condition, we had main story, catch questions, information
about the theft, prior probability estimates, and then the second group is presented with:
Claim about Chad: The claim is that is that Chad is in big trouble. Allegedly, one evening in the last few
weeks, he and a friend of his "borrowed" the car of the friend's dad. They only wanted to drive around
the block, but things got a bit out of control, and they ended up crashing the car. Fortunately, it was
possible to have it repaired and returned promptly. But now Chad needs to settle the bill for the repairs
or the mechanic threatens he will go to Chad's family or the police. Jane's jewelry would cover the cost.
At this point the second group participants are asked to rate the probability of the claim about
Chad. Then, the second group is given new information:
After some investigation, it turns out that (for some reason) Chad stole the jewelry. This is completely
certain and Chad himself admitted that he stole the jewelry.
At this point participants of the second group are reminded of the Claim about Chad, they are
presented with the text of the claim and are asked to rate the probability of the claim once more.
This is the end of the test for the second group.
Appendix 2. The text employed in Experiment 2 - John.
The main story, catch question, and the text informing that the theft took place are the same. Then, the
participants were asked to estimate prior probabilities that each of the personages is the thief.
Then, remainder of the test goes differently for the two groups of participants in Experiment 2.
21
The first group of participants is given new information as follows
It turns out that John has been having a severe gambling problem. He recently lost a very large amount
of money. He is worried that if his wife were to find out about his debt, she will divorce him and he will
lose everything. Jane's jewelry will cover all of John's gambling debts.
At this point participants of the first group are asked to rate the suspects again and this is the end
of the test for them.
For the second between participants condition, we had main story, catch questions, information
about the theft, prior probability estimates, and then the second group is presented with:
Claim about John: The claim is that John has been having a severe gambling problem and that he
recently lost a very large amount of money. Allegedly, he is worried that if his wife were to find out
about his debt, she will divorce him and he will lose everything. Jane's jewelry will cover all of John's
gambling debts.
At this point the second group participants are asked to rate the probability of the claim about
John. Then, the second group is given new information:
After some investigation, it turns out that (for some reason) John stole the jewelry. This is completely
certain and John himself admitted that he stole the jewelry.
At this point participants of the second group are reminded of the Claim about John, they are
presented with the text of the claim and are asked to rate the probability of the claim once more.
This is the end of the test for the second group.
22
|
1911.02301 | 1 | 1911 | 2019-11-06T10:49:00 | Diversity of neuronal activity is provided by hybrid synapses | [
"q-bio.NC",
"nlin.AO",
"physics.bio-ph"
] | Many experiments have evidenced that electrical and chemical synapses -- hybrid synapses -- coexist in most organisms and brain structures. The role of electrical and chemical synapse connection in diversity of neural activity generation has been investigated separately in networks of varying complexities. Nevertheless, theoretical understanding of hybrid synapses in diverse dynamical states of neural networks for self-organization and robustness still has not been fully studied. Here, we present a model of neural network built with hybrid synapses to investigate the emergence of global and collective dynamics states. This neural networks consists of excitatory and inhibitory population interacting together. The excitatory population is connected by excitatory synapses in small world topology and its adjacent neurons are also connected by gap junctions. The inhibitory population is only connected by chemical inhibitory synapses with all-to-all interaction. Our numerical simulations show that in the balanced networks with absence of electrical coupling, the synchrony states generated by this architecture are mainly controlled by heterogeneity among neurons and the balance of its excitatory and inhibitory inputs. In balanced networks with strong electrical coupling, several dynamical states arise from different combinations of excitatory and inhibitory weights. More importantly, we find that these states, such as synchronous firing, cluster synchrony, and various ripples events, emerge by slight modification of chemical coupling weights. For large enough electrical synapse coupling, the whole neural networks become synchronized. Our results pave a way in the study of the dynamical mechanisms and computational significance of the contribution of mixed synapse in the neural functions. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Diversity of neuronal activity is provided by hybrid synapses
Faculty of Science, Jiangsu University, Zhenjiang, Jiangsu 212013, PR China. ∗ and
Kesheng Xu
Centro Interdisciplinario de Neurociencia de Valparaíso,
Universidad de Valparaíso, Valparaíso, 2360102, Chile
Jean Paul Maidana and Patricio Orio
Centro Interdisciplinario de Neurociencia de Valparaíso,
Universidad de Valparaíso, Valparaíso, 2360102, Chile and
Instituto de Neurociencia, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad de Valparaíso, Valparaíso, 2360102, Chile..†
(Dated: Received: date / Accepted: date)
9
1
0
2
v
o
N
6
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
1
0
3
2
0
.
1
1
9
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
Many experiments have evidenced that electrical and chemical synapses -- hybrid synapses -- coex-
ist in most organisms and brain structures. The role of electrical and chemical synapse connection in
diversity of neural activity generation has been investigated separately in networks of varying com-
plexities. Nevertheless, theoretical understanding of hybrid synapses in diverse dynamical states
of neural networks for self-organization and robustness still has not been fully studied. Here, we
present a model of neural network built with hybrid synapses to investigate the emergence of global
and collective dynamics states. This neural networks consists of excitatory and inhibitory popula-
tion interacting together. The excitatory population is connected by excitatory synapses in small
world topology and its adjacent neurons are also connected by gap junctions. The inhibitory popu-
lation is only connected by chemical inhibitory synapses with all-to-all interaction. Our numerical
simulations show that in the balanced networks with absence of electrical coupling, the synchrony
states generated by this architecture are mainly controlled by heterogeneity among neurons and the
balance of its excitatory and inhibitory inputs. In balanced networks with strong electrical coupling,
several dynamical states arise from different combinations of excitatory and inhibitory weights. More
importantly, we find that these states, such as synchronous firing, cluster synchrony, and various
ripples events, emerge by slight modification of chemical coupling weights. For large enough elec-
trical synapse coupling, the whole neural networks become synchronized. Our results pave a way in
the study of the dynamical mechanisms and computational significance of the contribution of mixed
synapse in the neural functions.
I.
INTRODUCTION
Over the past decades, spatiotemporal patterns has
been observed in experimental recordings of neural activ-
ity, such as synchronous states[1, 2], complex spatiotem-
poral patterns[3 -- 9] and chimera states[10, 11], has long
been of interest, but their underlying mechanism of the
generation of these patterns has not been fully under-
stood yet.
It is generally accepted that there are two main modali-
ties of synaptic transmission -- chemical and electrical[12,
13]. At chemical synapses,
information is transferred
through the release of a neurotransmitter from presy-
naptic neuron and detection of the neurotransmitter by
an adjacent postsynaptic cell[14], whereas in electrical
synapses, the cytoplasm of adjacent cells is directly con-
nected by clusters of intercellular channels called gap
junctions[15]. From this different characteristics and
functionality, chemical synaptic communication is typi-
cally unidirectional and episodic. By contrast, electrical
synaptic transmission through gap junctions underlies di-
rect, continuous, reliable and rapid neuronal communi-
cation in the CNS[15].
In addition, electrical synapses
∗ [email protected]
† [email protected]
are bidirectional and local connections between neurons
which are spatially very close. Theoretical work has
shown that diversity of firing patterns and cortical func-
tions is provided by balance between coactivated exci-
tatory and inhibitory synaptic inputs[16 -- 19] (for a re-
view see ref.[20]). For example, when externally driven,
circuits of recurrently connected by excitatory and in-
hibitory neurons with strong synapses settle rapidly into
a state in which population activity levels ensure a bal-
ance of excitatory and inhibitory currents[21 -- 23]. Over
all, excitatory neurons are thought to do only one thing:
excite each other, whereas inhibitory neurons can gen-
erate nonlinear effects[24], such as modulating stimulus
response gain, sharpening tuning to stimuli, and pac-
ing cortical oscillations[20, 24]. For electrical coupling,
it is responsible for a variety of network effects, particu-
larly in networks that generate rhythmic activity, some
of which are well established, such as regulation of phase
relationships, synchrony, and pattern formation[25 -- 29],
and some are novel, such as a direct role in rhythmogen-
esis (also see review[2]).
The relationship between spatiotemporal patterns of
neuronal activity and the types of synaptic transmission
can be investigated in modeling studies[30 -- 33]. Com-
putational models have shown that the synchronous oc-
currence of action potentials in many neurons is mainly
due to connections of chemical inhibitory synapses[34 --
38] or electrical synapses between neurons[1, 2, 39 -- 42].
The results obtained by Börgers et al.
[43] also suggest
that synchronous oscillations often comes from interplay
of chemical synapses connections between E-cells (excita-
tory neurons) and I-cells (inhibitory neurons) but under
ideal conditions -- homogeneity in relevant network pa-
rameters and all-to-all-connections. Synchronous states
have traditionally been thought to involve precise zero-
lag synchrony[44, 45].
Instead of precise zero-lag syn-
chrony, a range of flexible phase offsets -- phase differences
between two (or more) oscillations -- is possible. These
flexible phase relationships can, in their simplest form,
be traveling waves of various shapes (including plane,
radial and spiral waves[46]). The combination of mul-
tiple traveling waves can form complex spatiotemporal
patterns [4, 47].
It has been shown, in spiking neural
networks[46, 48 -- 51]that transmission delays[41], the spa-
tial reach of connections[7] and the strength of inhibition
of the excitatory-inhibitory networks influence the emer-
gence of spatiotemporal patterns, such as asynchronous
and irregular activity, or propagating waves. Most pre-
vious modeling studies have shown that the formation of
spatiotemporal patterns such as traveling waves in neu-
ral networks has mainly been investigated by means of
phenomenological neural-field models. These models un-
cover the existence and uniqueness of diverse patterns
which are stationary or nonstationary in space and time,
such as waves, wave fronts, bumps, pulses, and periodic
patterns[32, 52, 53]. Recently, much attention has been
paid to the chimera state[54 -- 57]. In chimera state, popu-
lations of coupled oscillators may exhibit two coexisting
subpopulations, one with synchronized oscillations and
the other with unsynchronized oscillations, even though
all of the oscillators are coupled to each other in an equiv-
alent manner[58, 59]. This symmetry-breaking behav-
ior has been studied in a variety of complex dynamical
systems and has attracted growing attention in neural
system studies from both theoretical and experimental
perspectives[60 -- 62].
The role of purely electrical synapse or chemical
synapse connections in generation of the diversity of neu-
ral activity has been investigated deeply in networks of
varying complexities as discussed above. Many exper-
iments have evidenced that diverse neural circuits use
a combination of electrical and chemical synapses -- hy-
brid synapses -- coexisting in most organisms and brain
structures[63 -- 66], to convey signals between neurons (re-
viewed in[12, 67] ). At first, the synchronous dynami-
cal behavior of the neuronal systems with two types of
synapses have attracted more and more attention. Kopell
et al.[68] found that both electrical and chemical synapses
play the different but complementary roles in the syn-
chronization of neuronal networks. Baptista et al.[69]
further combined two types of synapses to study the pro-
cess of synchronization and the information production.
Liu et al.[70] studied the combined effects of the infor-
mation transmission delay and the ratio of the electri-
cal and chemical synapses on the synchronization transi-
2
tions. Secondly, the concept in which chimera-like states
emerge spontaneously with suitable tunning of electri-
cal and chemical coupling strengths, surfaced in the pio-
neering theoretical and computational work of Hizanidis
et al.[60].
In another work, Majhi et al.[61] analyzed
chimera states in a two-layer neural network connected
with hybrid synapses. The results obtained by them
showed that the emergence of chimera states depends
significantly on chemical synapses, not electrical ones.
More recently, Calim et al.[62] highlighted the impor-
tance of the excitability level and nonlocal network fea-
tures on spatiotemporal patterns in networks of neurons
coupled only via chemical synapses. Furthermore, they
mapped the transitions between incoherent states, trav-
eling waves, chimeras, coherent states, and global am-
plitude death in the parameter space. More importantly,
Pernelle et al.[71] showed that gap junction plasticity acts
as a mechanism to regulate oscillations in the networks
connected by hybrid synapses.
All these approaches mentioned above only identify the
essential mechanisms for generating various complex spa-
tiotemporal patterns (such as synchrony state, chimeras
state, and etc) in neural networks coupled via chemical
synapse or hybrid synapses. Nevertheless, they give little
insight on how the electrical and chemical synapses are
related in the emergence of a diversity of dynamical states
in neural networks for self-organization and robustness.
In other words, the relationship between spatiotempo-
ral patterns of neuronal activity and the types of synap-
tic transmission together with corresponding synaptic
weights has not been systematically investigated yet. For
example, whether the excitatory-inhibitory balance or
gap junction make significant different contributions to
generate firing patterns , and whether these different
states can coexist in the same parameter space or the
same time bins of interest still have not been fully stud-
ied yet.
Our first finding is that, in the E/I balanced networks
of excitatory population in absence of gap junction, the
excitatory population has a tendency to cluster synchro-
nization as the weight of inhibitory synaptic currents
into the excitatory part is increase. In other words, the
larger the chemical inhibitory synapse strength used for
excitatory part the higher degree of synchronization to
achieve. However, introducing the gap junction to the
excitatory population, it usually can go through several
phases of network state, that are asynchronous activity,
synchronous firing, various ripples events (such as trav-
eling wave) and lastly subthreshold oscillations without
spikes. For example, we find that for stronger inhibitory
synaptic strengths larger than a certain amount leads to
suppression of the spikes oscillation, and for moderate
inhibitory synaptic strengths one should expect to find
chimera-likeness behaviors, which is also metastable state
in some time windows. More importantly, it first time to
show the coexistence of these dynamics states, such as
coexistence of coherent state, traveling wave and oscil-
lation without spikes, depending on the inhibition level
. Finally, our results suggest that if excitatory popula-
tions are connected with hybrid synapses, the excitation
and inhibition balance can make a great contribution to
generate various spatiotemporal patterns.
sity, EL, EN a, EK are the reversal potential and func-
tion m∞ is the steady-state activation variables m of the
Hodgkin-Huxley type[74].
3
II. MODELS AND METHODS
A. Neuronal dynamics
Wang-Buzsáki model. The Wang-Buzsáki model
we used has been presented detailly in Ref[72, 73], here
we give a brief overview. This conductance-based model
has three states variables for each neurons: membrane
potential of each cells V , the Sodium inactivation vari-
able h and Potassium activation variable n corresponding
to the spikes-generating N a+ and K + voltage-dependent
ion currents (IN a and IK), respectively. Sodium activa-
tion variable m is considered to be instantaneous. The
neuronal dynamics can be described as :
Cm
dV
dt
dh
dt
dn
dt
= −IN a − IK − IL − ISyn + Iapp
= φ(αh(1 − h) − βhh)
= φ(αn(1 − n) − βnn)
(1)
Where IL = gL(V − EL), IN a = gN am3∞h(V − EN a)
and IK = gKn4(V − EK) represent the leak currents,
transient sodium currents and the delayed rectifier cur-
rents, respectively. Isyn stands for the synaptic currents
and Iapp is the injected currents (in µA/cm2). The pa-
rameters gL, gN a, gK are the maximal conductance den-
TABLE I.
model(1996)[72]
Parameters and functions of Wang-Buzsáki
gN a = 35
φ = 5
EN a = 55
gL = 0.1
EL = −65
Cm = 1 (µF )
αm(V ) = −0.1(V + 35)/[exp(−0.1(V + 28)) + 1]
αh(V ) = 0.07exp[−(V + 58)/20]
αn(V ) = −0.01(V + 34)/[exp(−0.1(V + 34)) − 1]
m∞ = αm/(αm + βm)
Network architecture and parameters. A. The
FIG. 1.
balanced neural networks containing excitatory (red) and in-
hibitory populations (green). The synaptic input (excita-
tory synaptic input or inhibitory synaptic input) between the
populations are generated by all-to-all connections. Their
coupling strength between the populations is denoted with
constants JIE and JEI. Self-inhibitory connections (of the
weights JII) is all to all connections. Excitatory (inhibitory)
connections are represented in red (black). νext is the ex-
ternal drive to each neuron in the excitatory population by
external excitatory inputs. B. Diagram of excitatory popu-
lations connected by electrical (linear diffusive coupling) and
chemical (nonlinear coupling) synapses. The excitatory pop-
ulation is connected by excitatory synaptic (red solid lines)
strength JEE in a small world topology and adjacent neurons
are also connected by electrical synaptic strength Jgap (black
dashed lines ). Without loss of generality, we fix JII = 0.04,
JIE = 0.01.
In the simulation, unless stated otherwise, the param-
eters and functions used are given in Table I.
gK = 9 (mS/cm2)
VK = −90 (mV)
Iapp = 0 (µA/cm2)
βm(V ) = 4exp[−(V + 60)/18]
βh(V ) = 1/exp[−0.1(V + 28)] + 1
βn(V ) = 0.125exp[−(V + 44)/80]
Synaptic dynamics. By applying the Wang-Buzsáki
model to the nodes of the network that incorporates
both types of synapses, neurons in the networks are con-
nected by electrical (linear diffusive coupling) and chem-
ical (nonlinear coupling) synapses. The total synaptic
input currents into neuron i within excitatory popula-
NE(cid:88)
NI(cid:88)
j=1,j(cid:54)=i
j=1,j(cid:54)=i
tion, is given by:
NE(cid:88)
NE(cid:88)
i=1
j=1,j(cid:54)=i
ISynE,i = Jgap
gap(Vi − Vj) + JEE
C ij
EEgsyn,i(Vi − EsynE)
Lij
+ JEI
EI gsyn,i(Vi − EsynI ) +
Lij
gsyn,i(Vi − EsynE)
4
(2)
The four terms on right-hand side of Eq.(2) cor-
responds to electrical synaptic inputs, self-excitatory
synaptic inputs,
inhibitory synaptic inputs (from in-
hibitory population) and external excitatory synaptic in-
put to each neuron in the excitatory population, respec-
tively. The connection matrices C ij
EI are de-
scribed in the network connectivity section. Lastly purely
chemical synaptic input currents for inhibitory popula-
tion is as follows:
EE, Lij
gap, Lij
NI(cid:88)
j=1,j(cid:54)=i
ISynI,i = JII
II gsyn,i(Vi − EsynI ) + JIE
Lij
NE(cid:88)
j=1,j(cid:54)=i
IEgsyn,i(Vi − EsynE)
Lij
(3)
The two terms on right-hand side of Eq.(3) represent
self-inhibitory synaptic input and excitatory synaptic in-
puts (from excitatory population).
We use a second-order differential equation to model
chemical synaptic conductances gsyn[75, 76], provided by:
d2gsyn
dt2 = ¯gs(E,I,ν)f δ (t0 + td − t) −
(cid:18) 1
τ1
(cid:19) dgsyn
dt
+
1
τ2
− gsyn
τ1τ2
(4)
The delta function δ (t0 + td − t) represents the spike
signal from presynatpic cell. The time t0 is the time
of the presynaptic spike and td is synaptic delays from
the presynatpic to postsynaptic cell. The conductance
peaks occurs at time tpeak = t0 + td + τ1τ2
ln(τ1/τ2).
τ1−τ2
The normalization factor f, ensures that the amplitude
equals ¯gs(E,I,ν), follows:
f =
e−(tpeak−t0−td)/τ1 − e−(tpeak−t0−td)/τ2
1
In simulations and for practical reasons, second order
differential equations are solved as follows:
(cid:19)
(cid:18) 1
τ1
+
1
τ2
y − gsyn
τ1τ2
dy
dt
dgsyn
dt
= ¯gs(E,I,ν)f δ (t0 + td − t) −
= y
(5)
(6)
In simulations, both peak synaptic conductances
¯gs(E,I,ν) and synaptic delays td are Gaussian distributed
random variables with prescribed means gs(E,I) and D,
and standard deviation σgs(E,I) and σD. The background
drive vext to each neuron in the excitatory population was
provided by external excitatory inputs, modeled as in-
dependent and identically distributed Poisson processes
with rate ν for different neurons. Peak conductances of
the external drive were also heterogeneous and assumed
values sampled from a truncated Gaussian distribution
with mean gsν and standard deviation σgsν . These rules
are the same as the previous study[73]. Parameters of
synaptic model are summarized in Table II.
5
6
A: Global simulation paramters
Description
Simulation duration
Start-up transient
Time step
B: Populations and external input
Description
Population size of excitatory neurons
Population size of inhibitory neurons
Possion input rate (external excitatory inputs)
C: Connection parameters
Description
Weight of gap junction
Weight of self-excitatory connection
Weight of self-inhibitory connection
Weight of inhibitory connections for excitatory populations
Weight of excitatory connections for inhibitory populations
Probability of local inhibitory connections
Symbol
Tsim
Ttrans
dt
Symbol
NE
NI
ν
Symbol
Jgap
JEE
JII
JEI
JIE
PI
Synaptic dynamics (Difference of Two Exponentials)
Reversal potential for excitatory synapses
Reversal potential for inhibitory synapses
Excitatory synaptic decay time
Ihibitory synaptic decay time
Excitatory synaptic time
Inhibitory synaptic time
Mean synaptic delay
Mean synaptic excitatory conductance
Mean synaptic inhibitory conductance
Mean synaptic input conductance
Standard deviation delay
Standard synaptic excitatory conductance
Standard inhibitory conductance
Standard input conductance
Probability of replacing new links
Degree of nearest neighbours connections
Small-world networks (SW)
EsynE
EsynI
τ1E
τ1I
τ2E
τ2I
D
gsE
gsI
gsν
σD
σgsE
σgsI
σgsν
Psw
K
Value
2000 ms
400 ms
0.02 ms
Value
1000
250
6000 Hz
Value
0.1
0.5
0.04
0.03
0.01
0.2
0 mV
-80 mV
3 ms
4 ms
1 ms
1 ms
1.5 ms
5 nS
200 nS
3 nS
0.1 ms
1 nS
10 nS
1 nS
0.01
10
TABLE II. List of simulation and default network parameters in the E/I balanced networks.
B. Network connectivity
To build the connectivity matrix, we consider a bal-
anced neural network, consisting of NE excitatory and
NI inhibitory neurons shown in Fig.1. We will use the
subscript E to denote the excitatory populations and I
for the inhibitory ones. The connections between the ith
neurons of the kth population and the jth neurons of
the lth population, denoted by Lij
kl. Here k, l = E, I.
The neurons in excitatory population are connected by
chemical synapses in a small world topology and adjacent
neurons are connected by gap junctions. The connection
7
each neurons in the excitatory populations. The closer to
0 (1) R becomes, the more asynchronous (synchronous)
the dynamics is. NE is the total number of excitatory
k is the time of the nth spikes of neurons
populations, tn
k and tn+1
is the time of the following (n + 1)th spikes.
k
In order to quantify the metastability and chimera-
likeness of the observed dynamics, the global metastabil-
ity M et[82] , is the variance in time of order parameter
R, by:
(cid:88)
t≤∆t
M et =
1
∆t
(φc(t) − R)2
(9)
where ∆t in Eq.(9) is the time windows to quantify the
metastability of the excitatory populations. Metastabil-
ity is 0 if the system is either completely synchronized
or completely desynchronized -- a high value is present
only when periods of coherence alternate with periods of
incoherence.
EE and C ij
matrices of chemical and electrical synapses in the exci-
tatory populations are defined as Lij
gap, while
the connection matrices of chemical synapses inside the
inhibitory one are given by Lij
II. The weights of self-
excitatory connections or self-inhibitory ones is symbol-
ized by JEE or JII. The coupling strengths of adjacent
electrical connections are denoted with Jgap. The link
matrices between populations with all-to-all connections
are Lij
EI. Their coupling strength between the
populations is denoted with constants JIE and JEI. The
connectivity matrix Lij
kl = 0) corresponds to
connections between neuron i and j (or not). The de-
fault network parameters used are shown in Table II.
kl = 1 (Lij
IE and Lij
The small-world topology mentioned above is imple-
mented as two basic steps of the standard algorithm[77]:
1. Construct a regular ring lattice with N nodes of mean
degree 2K. Each node is connected to its K nearest
neighbors on either side. 2. For every node i = 0, ..., N−1
take every edge connecting i to its K rightmost neighbors
-- that is every edge (i, j mod N) with i < j ≤ i + K ,
and rewire it with probability Psw. Rewiring is done by
replacing (i, j mod N) with (i, k) where k is chosen uni-
formly at random from all possible nodes . Self-inhibitory
connections is all-to-all connections. The rewiring edge
cannot be a duplicate or self-loop.
C. Network Activity Characterization
In this paper we first use the synchronization index
χ(N ), previously introduced by Ref [78, 79] , to account
for the synchronization level of the neural activity of the
considered networks, where:
(cid:80)N
N σ2
V (t)
i=1 σ2
Vi(t)
(7)
III. RESULTS
χ2 =
(cid:80)N
i=1 Vi(t) is populations average of the
Here V (t) = 1
N
membrane potential Vi(t). The variables σV (t) and σVi(t)
denote the standard deviation of V (t) over time, or re-
spectively, of the membrane potential traces Vi(t) of the
each isolated neuron i.
To further investigate the global dynamical behaviour
of the neural networks, we then introduce the order
parameter and its the variance in time, metastabil-
ity. The order parameter R, describes the global level
of phase synchrony in a system of NE oscillators[80, 81],
given by:
(cid:42)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) 1
NE
NE(cid:88)
k=1
R =
e2πi[(t−tn
k )/(tn+1
k −tn
k )]
(8)
(cid:43)
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
Influence of the electrical coupling in the generation
of several firing patterns
In what follows, our main goal is to investigate how
the electrical and chemical coupling can affect the fir-
ing patterns diversity within the excitatory population
of the E/I balanced networks. To do this, we simulated
balanced networks containing excitatory and inhibitory
populations. Neurons in the excitatory population are
connected by both electrical and chemical synapses, while
neurons in inhibitory one are only coupled by chemical
synapses (See II B section for detail). In this work, we
consider the network composed of Wang-Buzsáki neu-
rons. To measure the level of synchronization, we use
the synchronization index χ(N ) (Eq.(7)) and Kuramoto
order parameter R (Eq.(8)). We also introduce the
metastability M et Eq.(9) to quantify the metastability
and chimera-likeness of the observed dynamics within ex-
citatory populations.
Where the vertical bars (= φc(t)) denotes the modu-
lus of the complex number and the angle brackets is the
temporal average value of that quantity, while the expo-
nent, 2π[(t − tn
k )], is the phase we assign to
k − tn
k )/(tn+1
8
(Row 2 of Fig.2A), to find that there is an emergence
of traveling wave (wave propagation), which can not
be observed in the same parameter space without gap
junction (see Row 1 of Column a). On the other
sides, traveling waves observed in excitatory populaton
has a tendency to synchrony with increasing the weights
of gap junction (see Rows 2,3,4 of Column a with
Jgap = 0.1, 0.5, 1,respectively). Columns b, c, e (illus-
trated in Row 2 of Fig.2A with Jgap = 0.1) correspond
to dynamical regimes with almost completely synchrony
state, and the corresponding time series exhibits spiking
behavior shown in Fig.2B. Note that, we have shown that
raster plots and action potentials provide totally discrim-
ination in the observed synchrony regimes. The type of
oscillatory synchronization occurs in columns b, c (Row
2) with suitable inhibition corresponding to the oscilla-
tions with period 2 and 1, respectively, while column e is
related to subthreshold oscillatory synchronization with-
out spikes under stronger inhibition. The result in col-
umn e shows that the cooperation of electrical synapse
connections and stronger inhibition leads to suppression
of the spikes oscillation, namely subthreshold synchro-
nized oscillations. More importantly, increasing the value
of electrical synapse connections weights causes no obvi-
ous change in the modes of synchronized oscillation (see
Columns b, c, e with Jgap = 0.5, 1 in Fig.2A). An inter-
esting highly metastable behavior is found in the regime
with higher inhibitory level, where d is located in Fig.3.
Raster plot of this point (in Row 2 of Column d with
Jgap = 0.1) displays chimera-likeness state, which coex-
ists two subpopulations of synchronous states and inco-
herent state with various ripples events (such as traveling
waves) in the same certain time, e.g. at time t1. More
importantly, chimera-likeness state sometimes is also a
metastable state in time, meaning that they can stay in
the vicinity of one stable state for a certain time inter-
val and then, spontaneously move towards another -- such
as dynamics switching between time t1 and t2 shown in
Fig.2A (see also Fig.5). The firing patterns located in
column d have a slightly tendencty to synchrony as elec-
trical connections are increase. From the corresponding
actions potentials shown in Fig.2B, it is evident that the
system is in the bursting regime. These results imply that
the level and balance of excitation and inhibition, when
introducing the gap junction to the excitatory popula-
tion, leads to various firing patterns, such as wave prop-
agation, synchronized oscillations, chimera-likeness and
metastable state.
Examples of spatiotemporal firing patterns (A)
FIG. 2.
and their corresponding action potentials (B) in each dy-
namical regimes against several level of electrical strengths
Jgap in (JEE, JEI) parameter space. The 1th row and 2-
4th rows in (A) correspond the excitatory population built
with or without gap junction, respectively. Raster plots of
spatiotemporal firing patterns within 5 different dynamical
regimes (a-e) that are shown in Fig.3. Example of chimera-
likeness and incoherent state respectively at time t1 and t2 in
point d with Jgap = 0.1. Metastable state is that synchronous
part of chimera-likeness state alternates between synchronous
and incoherent behaviors with different times, eg. t1 and t2.
Weights of gap junction Jgap from top to bottom panels are
0.0, 0.1, 0.5, 1.0. The red Ex (green In) of y labels in (A) in-
dicates the neurons index of excitatory population (inhibitory
population). In all traces the scale bar in (B) is 10 ms.
Fig.2 shows the typical examples of spatiotemporal fir-
ing patterns (A) and corresponding action potentials (B)
from each dynamical regime (corresponding marked by
letters a, b, c, d, e in Fig.3), and their changes with differ-
ent degree of electrical synapse connections. If excitatory
population of networks are only built with the chemi-
cal synaptic connections, raster plots (Row 1 in Fig.2A)
show that the larger the inhibitory strengths used for ex-
citatory population the higher level of synchronization to
achieve, and denote three different dynamical regimes --
incoherent state, metastable state and generalized syn-
chronous state (or cluster synchronous states), respec-
tively. Incoherent state (Columns a to c in Row 1 of
Fig.2) is clear in the network of excitatory population
and note that, firing patterns of panels b, c easily tend to
clustering. An interesting behavior is metastable state
(Column d of Fig.2), but it is difficult to show in this
case. The panel e displays generalized synchronous state,
this is because of stronger inhibition. The action po-
tentials corresponding to these raster plots in excitatory
population are plotted in the first panels of Fig.2B.
In the case of networks built with hybrid synapses, it
is clear, from the raster plot of column a with Jgap = 0.1
9
excitatory population with purely chemical synaptic con-
nections (Jgap = 0) in Fig.3A. The results obtained in
this figure display a region e of lower level synchroniza-
tion for high inhibitory chemical coupling with the rest of
dynamical regimes being incoherent. This is because the
level of recurrent inhibition controls the overall level of
synchrony of the excitatory population, which is the first
known reason to induce networks synchronization. How-
ever, when networks of excitatory population built with
hybrid synapses, with weaker electrical coupling shown in
Fig.3B, it exhibits higher level synchronization (χ or R is
close to 1) than those of networks without gap junction
in the same region e for stronger inhibition. In addition,
there are other two emergence regions (b, c) of high-level
synchronzaiton where their synchronization index (or or-
der parameter) are close to 1 for weaker inhibition. These
two regions can not be observed clearly in networks with-
out electrical synapse connections (see corresponding re-
gions b, c in Fig.3A). Apart from that, the contribution
of electrical coupling on synchronization is also reflected
in the same parameter space, but with slight stronger
weights of gap junction when Jgap = 0.5, 1 (Fig.3C-D).
Note that, increasing electrical synapse weights of excita-
tory population in network can enlarge regimes b, c, d, e
and shrink regime a, comparing Fig.3B,C and D. This
is the second mainly mechanism to increase the level of
synchronization in a way that enhancing the electrical
synapse weights. Besides, it is also easy to see that the
boundaries between each regime are obvious.
Another usefully measurement related to network ac-
tivity is the metastability, which measures the chimera-
likeness/metastable state in the excitatory population
along time. More surperisely, we found that intro-
ducing electrical connections, even with weaker cou-
pling weights, to excitatory population leads to chimera-
likeness/metastable in region d of the observed dynam-
ics, as captured by metastability (bottom row of Fig.3B-
D). More importantly, enhancing weights of the electrical
connections can expand the metastability region d. It is
clear that the region in which M et attains values close to
0 coincides with all the neurons where excitatory popula-
tion are in a synchronized state (region b, c, e) or incoher-
ent state (region a). In other parts of the parameter space
(region d) where M et achieves higher values, indicating
that the system is in chimera-likeness state, coexisting
two subpopulations of synchronous states and incoher-
ent state, or metastable state, often switching between
synchronous and asynchronous states. The results shown
above imply that in excitatory networks build with hy-
brid synapses, diverse dynamical regimes arises from dif-
ferent combinations of excitatory and inhibitory weights,
and their boundary between each dynamical regime are
clear, which can not display in the network coupled by
purely chemical synapses (bottom panel of Fig.3A).
Next we focus on the influence of excitation and inhi-
bition together with their balance to network firing pat-
terns, in the networks of excitatory population built with
hybrid synapses.
FIG. 3.
Dynamical regimes of spatiotemporal firing pat-
terns on (JEE, JEI) parameter space with different weights
Jgap of electrical synaptic connections. Density plots show
synchronization index χ(N ) (Upper panels) as well as or-
der parameter R (Middle panels) and metastability M et
(Bottom panels) of excitatory populations in the same
plane. The marked points a, b, c, d, e denote different dy-
namical regimes. A.Collective dynamics behavior of excita-
tory populations with purely chemical synaptic connections
(Jgap = 0).
(a-c) Incoherent state corresponds to low val-
ues of both, χ and M et; (d)Metastable state where χ is low
and M et is high; (e) Generalized synchronous state (not fully
synchronous state) where χ is much higher but less than 1
and M et is low. Subplots B-D illustrate different dynamics
regimes in network of excitatory population built with hy-
brid synapses: (a) Traveling wave (wave propagation) where
both χ and M et are low values; (b) and (c) Synchronous
states; (d) Metastable state or chimera-likeness where χ is
low and M et is high; This indicates a highly metastable be-
havior and desynchronous dynamics; (e) Subthreshold syn-
chronous states (but neurons within excitatory populations
oscillate without spikes). The electrical weights for each sub-
plot are Jgap = 0.1, Jgap = 0.5, Jgap = 1, respectively.
The dynamics of spatiotemporal firing patterns, in the
excitatory populations with 4 different level of electri-
cal coupling weights, are characterized in Fig.3 of the
(JEE, JEI) parameter spaces. These dynamical regimes
are quantified via synchronization index as well as order
parameter and metastability. In order to highlight some
characteristic patterns that emerge in our system, we se-
lect 5 dynamical regimes of interest, marked by letters a,
b, c, d and e in parameter spaces. Excitatory population
network built with hybrid synapses, are chosen so that
the following cases are covered (see Fig.3B-D). a: both
χ (or R ) and M et are low-valued; b,c and e: χ is high-
value but M et is low-value; d: χ is middle-value and M et
is high-value. To further understand the role of electrical
coupling on emergence of the diversity firing patterns,
the corresponding 5 points also have been selected in the
same parameter space of excitatory population but with-
out gap junction shown in Fig.3A .
We first investigate collective dynamical behavior of
Influence of excitation and inhibition on excitatory
population behavior
We investigate now the emergence of various firing pat-
terns with variation of inhibitory level accessible by the
weights parameter JEI. To do this, we separately choose
excitatory level JEE = 0.5 and 2.5, in the networks of
excitatory population built with (Jgap = 0.1) or without
(Jgap = 0) electrical synapse connections.
FIG. 4.
Influence of the inhibitory level JEI on the
emergence of spatiotemporal dynamical states shown in A
( Jgap = 0) and B ( Jgap = 0.1) where JEE = 0.5. The
emergence of collective dynamics in the excitatory popula-
tion quantified by the order parameters (blue circle lines) and
metastability (red star lines).
Inset plots show a detail of
the typical spatiotemporal firing patterns in each dynamics
regimes of sweeping parameter JEI.
To clearly distinguish these different types of popula-
tion behaviors and characterize the effect of inhibition on
their firing patterns, we compute both order parameter
R and metastability M et as a function of inhibitory level
JEI in the networks of excitatory population, which built
with (without) gap junction when JEE = 0.5. The ob-
tained results are presented in Fig.4 where each subplot
illustrates measures of synchronization and metastabil-
ity as well as examples of several firing patterns in each
dynamics regime, indicated in the inset plots. As seen
in the Fig.4A, in the network of excitatory population
in absence of gap junction, variation of JEI only induces
incoherent state, metastable state (it is still irregular but
with slight clustering firing pattern) and generalized syn-
chronous state when both R and M et satisfy the follow-
ing conditions: R ≈ 0, M et ≈ 0; 0.4 < R < 0.8, 0 < M et;
0.7 < R < 0.8, M et ≈ 0, respectively.
It is confirmed
again that increasing JEI has a tendency to induce the
lower level of synchronization, namely generalized syn-
chronous state. However, it is seen that the excitatory
population built with gap junction, in Fig.4B, exhibits
characteristically distinct types of dynamical behaviors
as JEI varies. Note that their respective dynamics were
10
previously illustrated in Fig.3 and Fig.2. More precisely,
we observe traveling wave patterns with lower level of
inhibition for JEI (cid:54) 0.1 when R ≈ 0.2, M et < 0.01.
Excitatory population starts to exhibit synchrony pat-
terns with period 2 as shown inset plot with a slight
increase in JEI which is in range of 0.1 < JEI (cid:54) 0.25
when R > 0.91, M et < 0.01. Then, a further increase
in inhibitory level to the range of 0.25 < JEI (cid:54) 0.3
when R (around 0.65) is middle-value and M et (greater
than 0.07) is high-value, we observe the metastable state
in which the dynamics in excitatory population switches
between synchronous and asynchronous state (traveling
wave patterns or subthreshold oscillations state). If the
inhibitory level is chosen in the range of 0.3 < JEI (cid:54) 0.45
when R ≈ 1, M et ≈ 0, we find that it gives rise to an-
other synchrony neural activity with period 1. Subse-
quently, when JEI lies in the range of 0.45 < JEI (cid:54) 0.675
with middle-value of both R and M et, we see a pecu-
liar chimeraness behavior in which the excitatory pop-
ulation splits into three domains: coherent state, vari-
ous ripples events (such as traveling waves) and oscilla-
tion without spikes. Coexistence of these three dynamics
states depending on the inhibition level is the first time to
be observed. Eventually, the excitatory populations ex-
hibits subthreshold synchronous states -- oscillation with-
out spikes -- due to stronger inhibitory level in the range
of 0.675 < JEI. It is evident that inhibitory level JEI is
a significant system parameter which plays a major role
in determining the emergence of the above mentioned
firing patterns, including traveling wave, synchrony state
with period 2 (or 1), a peculiar chimera-likeness behavior
and subthreshold synchronous states. More importantly,
there are transitions between dynamical states depending
on inhibitory level among individual neurons.
FIG. 5. Distinct types of dynamical behavior as JEI varies
as illustrated in A (Jgap = 0 ) and B (Jgap = 0.1) but with
high excitatory level where JEE = 2.5.
Inset plots present
typical firing patterns in each dynamics regimes.
We have so far focused on changes in the inhibitory
level to study the emergence of several firing patterns
with fixed weaker excitability level. In the following, we
continue investigating the population dynamics as a func-
tions of inhibitory level JEI but with stronger excitability
level. As an extension of the findings about the effect of
inhibitory level in the emergence of various firing pat-
terns, we still consider excitatory population built with
(or without) gap junction that are shown in Fig.5. For
each case, we calculate the order parameter and metasta-
bility of various firing patterns by varying the inhibitory
level JEI for a fixed value of stronger excitatory strength
JEE = 2.5. The typical firing patterns of excitatory pop-
ulation for each dynamics regimes are shown in inset plots
of Fig.5. As seen in the Fig.5A, variation of inhibitory
level of the excitatory part built without gap junction
causes the similar modes of firing pattern, which has been
shown in Fig.4A. In network built with hybrid synapses,
it is seen that there are three different types of neuronal
activity in the excitatory population obtained as shown
in Fig.5B. There exists a much more regular population
activity, however it is still an incoherent state, for weak
inhibitory synaptic connections. It is because the range
of JEI becomes narrower for traveling waves and wider
for chimera-likeness state with increasing excitability lev-
els that are shown in Fig.3B. This indicates that traveling
waves vanish at very high excitability levels (see Fig.3B-D
and Fig.5B) , which is similar with previous study[62]. If
the inhibitory coupling strength is sufficiently increased
among range 0.25 < JEI (cid:54) 0.7 where both R and M et
are high-value, we observe chimera-likeness behavior in
which the excitatory population coexists the synchrony
state and traveling waves at the same time. In addition,
we also see metastable state that alternates between syn-
chronous and incoherent behaviors with different time
windows. To check the persistence of these two special
behavior, we further inscreased JEI and observed that
chimera-likeness and metastable state does no longer ex-
ist, instead a subthreshold oscillations (without spikes)
emerges for 0.7 < JEI. To sum up, we show that bal-
anced and hybrid synaptic connected network of Wang-
Buzsáki neurons can displays various types of different
levels of synchronous activity that imply vastly different
computational properties. For weak excitatory coupling,
the network of excitatory population displays rich col-
lective dynamics -- traveling waves, synchrony patterns
with period 2, metastable state, synchrony patterns with
period 1, chimera-likeness/metastable state and lastly os-
cillation without spikes -- as inhibitory level JEI varies.
However, for strong excitatory couplings, we find that the
increasing inhibitory level JEI in the networks of excita-
tory population only leads to three fundamentally differ-
ent types of neuronal activity, namely, less regular pop-
ulation activity, chimera-likeness behavior/metastable
state and subthreshold synchronous states (oscillation
without spikes).
11
FIG. 6.
Influence of probability Psw for small-world topology
on different levels of synchronization and its robustness on
(JEE, JEI) plane, unfolding a clear comparison with Fig.3.
Influence of probability Psw on excitatory population
behavior
To present a broader perspective on different levels of
synchronization and to confirm its robustness, we choose
a bigger probability Psw (= 0.15) for small-world topol-
ogy of excitatory synapse connections and show exci-
tatory population behavior on (JEE, JEI) plane as de-
picted in Fig.6. It is clear, in the network built with hy-
brid synapses, that the bigger probability for small-world
topology still supports rich excitatory population behav-
ior emerging as five different dynamical regimes marked
by latters a, b, c, d, e -- that is traveling waves, two types
of synchronous states, chimera-likeness or metastable
state with various ripples events, and subthreshold syn-
chronous states. Our results reveal that the role of gap
junction and excitatory-inhibitory balance to network
states are robust with network densities.
IV. DISCUSSION
We briefly discuss the different characteristics and
functionality of these two types of chemical and electrical
synapses (For reviews, see[12, 13]). The most common
mechanism for transmission between neurons is chemical
synapses, which is typically unidirectional and relies on
the intermittent presence of coming spikes from presy-
naptic terminal to generate transient changes. From this
point, chemical synaptic communication is episodic. In
addition, neurotransmitter release is probabilistic, and
failures in transmission will occasionally occur despite
the presence of coming spikes from presynaptic terminal.
Depending on the neurotransmitter, a chemical synapse
can either be excitatory or inhibitory. By contrast, elec-
trical synaptic transmission through gap junctions under-
lies direct, continuous, reliable and rapid neuronal com-
munication in the CNS. Electrical synapses are bidirec-
tional and of local connections between neurons which
are spatially very close. The gap junctional conduc-
tance is remarkably and characteristically constant for
sustained periods of time. However, recent studies had
evidenced that both chemical and electrical modalities of
synaptic transmission are plastic and capable of modify-
ing their strength in a bidirectional fasion. For example,
activity-dependent changes in the strength of chemical
synapses are thought to underlie mechanisms of learn-
ing and memory (for a review, see ref [83]). Regarding
to the functional role of gap junction plasticity, such as
changes in light conditions[84], has been experimentally
demonstrated [71, 85 -- 88] (also reviewed in refs [12, 89]).
The distribution and role of electrical synapses have
been investigated in the previous studies[90, 91]. A se-
ries of reports had demonstrated that electrical synapses
occur between excitatory projection neurons of the in-
ferior olivary nucleus and between interneurons in sev-
eral regions of the adult brain, including the cerebellum,
neocortex, hippocampus and so on (see review[90] de-
tailly). Computer simulations had greatly contributed
to revealing the impact and functional role of gap junc-
tions between inhibitory interneurons on network activ-
ity. Firstly, gap junctions between inhibitory interneu-
rons have been shown to enhance synchronized neu-
ronal firing[91, 92], which is one of the most distinct
and recognizable properties of the electrical synapses.
Secondly,
it has been suggested that the presence of
electrical synapses could mediate close synchronization
of subthreshold and spiking activity among clusters of
neurons[13, 93]. In all, the role of electrical synapses for
network activity has been the topic of various review arti-
cles (see Ref[90, 94]) and therefore will not be extensively
discussed here. The influence of electical coupling for
balanced networks on generation of distinct dynamical
regimes has been investigated in this paper. Introducing
the gap junction, even with weaker coupling weights, to
excitatory population leads to various firing patterns --
such as traveling wave, synchronous states etc. However,
gap junctions are often observed between inhibitory neu-
rons. The role and function of gap junctions between
inhibitory neurons, in the generation of spatiotemporal
firing patterns, will be the subject for the future work.
Coactivated inhibitory and excitatory synaptic inputs
plays a role in diversity of cortical functions and general
information processing[24, 95]. It is generally accepted
that activity of excitatory networks, if only excitatory
cells were present in networks, is simple and predictable
-- excitation just leads to futher excitation.
Inhibitory
networks are totally different[20], namely, it can generate
12
nonlinear effects. In the absence of inhibition, any type
of external input, would generate more or less the same
one-way patterns. Theoretical work has shown that net-
works built from both excitatory and inhibitory elements
can self-oranize and generate complex properties[16 -- 19].
For example, study of Rubin et al.[95] shown that the ra-
tio of excitation-inhibition balance is essential for robust
neuronal selectivity and crucial for stability in associative
memory networks in the presence of noise.
In this work, we investigate the emergence of vari-
ous firing patterns in excitation and inhibition balance
networks of itself excitatory cells coupled via hybrid
synapses. Our findings in this class of network illustrate
how level of inhibition can synchronize or desynchro-
nize, detect coincidences, inhibit on population behav-
ior. More detail, with weaker excitability level, variation
of inhibitory level for excitatory population leads to rich
collective dynamics, such as traveling waves, synchrony
and desynchrony state (chimera-likeness or metastable
state) and oscillation without spikes due to stronger in-
hibition. With stronger excitability level, increasing in-
hibitory level for the same networks causes three fun-
damentally different types of neuronal activity -- less
order population activity, chimera-likeness behavior (or
metastable state at some times) and subthreshold syn-
chronous states.
Brain dynamics is often inherently variable and unsta-
ble, consisting of sequences of transient spatiotemporal
patterns[96, 97]. These squences of transients are a hall-
mark of metastable dynamics that are neither entrely sta-
ble nor completely unstable. Our results pay a possible
way to uncover the underlying mechanisms of generating
metastable dynamics, such as chimera-likeness, that may
mediate perception and cognition.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We
thank the
funding from Fondecyt Project
Nos.3170342 (K.X.) and 1181076 (P.O.) from CONICYT,
Chile. P.O. is partially funded by the Advanced Cen-
ter for Electrical and Electronic Engineering (FB0008
Conicyt, Chile). The Centro Interdisciplinario de Neu-
rociencia de Valparaíso (CINV) is a Millennium Insti-
tute supported by the Millennium Scientific Initiative of
the Ministerio de Economía (ICM-MINECON, Proyecto
P09-022-F,CINV, Chile).
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors declare that they have no conflict of in-
terest.
[1] Robert C Elson, Allen I Selverston, Ramon Huerta, Niko-
lai F Rulkov, Mikhail I Rabinovich, and Henry DI Abar-
banel. Synchronous behavior of two coupled biological
neurons. Physical Review Letters, 81(25):5692, 1998.
[2] Jian Jing. Network Functions and Plasticity: Perspec-
tives from Studying Neuronal Electrical Coupling in Mi-
crocircuits. Academic Press, 2017.
[3] Stephen Coombes. Large-scale neural dynamics: simple
and complex. NeuroImage, 52(3):731 -- 739, 2010.
[4] Lyle Muller, Frédéric Chavane, John Reynolds, and Ter-
rence J Sejnowski. Cortical travelling waves: mechanisms
and computational principles. Nature Reviews Neuro-
science, 19(5):255, 2018.
[5] Jun Ma, Xinlin Song, Jun Tang, and Chunni Wang.
Wave emitting and propagation induced by autapse in
a forward feedback neuronal network. Neurocomputing,
167:378 -- 389, 2015.
[6] Qing Yun Wang, Qi Shao Lu, and Guan Rong Chen. Or-
dered bursting synchronization and complex wave propa-
gation in a ring neuronal network. Physica A: Statistical
Mechanics and its Applications, 374(2):869 -- 878, 2007.
[7] Kesheng Xu, Wenwen Huang, Baowen Li, Mukesh
Dhamala, and Zonghua Liu. Controlling self-sustained
spiking activity by adding or removing one network link.
EPL (Europhysics Letters), 102(5):50002, jun 2013.
[8] Kesheng Xu, Xiyun Zhang, Chaoqing Wang, and
Zonghua Liu. A simplified memory network model based
on pattern formations. Scientific reports, 4:7568, 2014.
[9] Chris I De Zeeuw, Freek E Hoebeek, Laurens WJ
Bosman, Martijn Schonewille, Laurens Witter, and Se-
bastiaan K Koekkoek. Spatiotemporal firing patterns in
the cerebellum. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 12(6):327,
2011.
[10] Chang-Hai Tian, Xi-Yun Zhang, Zhen-Hua Wang, and
Zong-Hua Liu. Diversity of chimera-like patterns from
a model of 2d arrays of neurons with nonlocal coupling.
Frontiers of Physics, 12(3):128904, 2017.
[11] Siyu Huo, Changhai Tian, Ling Kang, and Zonghua Liu.
Chimera states of neuron networks with adaptive cou-
pling. Nonlinear Dynamics, pages 1 -- 12, 2019.
[12] Alberto E Pereda. Electrical synapses and their func-
tional interactions with chemical synapses. Nature Re-
views Neuroscience, 15(4):250, 2014.
[13] Pepe Alcami and Alberto E Pereda. Beyond plasticity:
the dynamic impact of electrical synapses on neural cir-
cuits. Nature reviews. Neuroscience, 2019.
[14] Morgan Sheng, Bernardo Sabatini, and Thomas.(eds)
Sudhof. The Synapse. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
Press, 2012.
[15] Michael VL Bennett and R Suzanne Zukin. Electrical
coupling and neuronal synchronization in the mammalian
brain. Neuron, 41(4):495 -- 511, 2004.
[16] Jeffrey S Anderson, Matteo Carandini, and David Fer-
ster. Orientation tuning of input conductance, excita-
tion, and inhibition in cat primary visual cortex. Journal
of neurophysiology, 84(2):909 -- 926, 2000.
[17] Bassam V. Atallah and Massimo Scanziani.
Instanta-
neous modulation of gamma oscillation frequency by bal-
ancing excitation with inhibition. Neuron, 62(4):566 --
577, 2009.
[18] Michael Wehr and Anthony M. Zador. Balanced inhibi-
tion underlies tuning and sharpens spike timing in audi-
tory cortex. Nature, 426(6965):442 -- 446, 2003.
[19] Cindy Poo and Jeffry S. Isaacson. Odor representations
"sparse" coding, global inhibition,
in olfactory cortex:
and oscillations. Neuron, 62(6):850 -- 861, 2009.
13
[20] Jeffry S. Isaacson and Massimo Scanziani. How inhibition
shapes cortical activity. Neuron, 72(2):231 -- 243, 2011.
[21] C. van Vreeswijk and H. Sompolinsky. Chaos in neu-
ronal networks with balanced excitatory and inhibitory
activity. Science, 274(5293):1724 -- 1726, 1996.
[22] Sean R. Bittner, Ryan C. Williamson, Adam C. Snyder,
Ashok Litwin-Kumar, Brent Doiron, Steven M. Chase,
Matthew A. Smith, and Byron M. Yu. Population activ-
ity structure of excitatory and inhibitory neurons. PLOS
ONE, 12(8):1 -- 27, 08 2017.
[23] Ran Rubin, L. F. Abbott, and Haim Sompolinsky. Bal-
anced excitation and inhibition are required for high-
capacity, noise-robust neuronal selectivity. Proceedings of
the National Academy of Sciences, 114(44):E9366 -- E9375,
2017.
[24] Gyorgy Buzsaki. Rhythms of the Brain. Oxford Univer-
sity Press, 2006.
[25] Michael Beierlein, Jay R Gibson, and Barry W Connors.
A network of electrically coupled interneurons drives syn-
chronized inhibition in neocortex. Nature neuroscience,
3(9):904, 2000.
[26] Dirk Bucher, Astrid A Prinz, and Eve Marder. Animal-
to-animal variability in motor pattern production in
adults and during growth.
Journal of Neuroscience,
25(7):1611 -- 1619, 2005.
[27] Eve Marder and Dirk Bucher. Understanding circuit dy-
namics using the stomatogastric nervous system of lob-
sters and crabs. Annual Review of Physiology, 69(1):291 --
316, 2007.
[28] Romuald Nargeot, Morgane Le Bon-Jego, and John Sim-
mers. Cellular and network mechanisms of operant
learning-induced compulsive behavior in aplysia. Cur-
rent Biology, 19(12):975 -- 984, 2009.
[29] Angela Wenning, Brian J. Norris, Anca Doloc-Mihu, and
Ronald L. Calabrese. Bringing up the rear: new premotor
interneurons add regional complexity to a segmentally
distributed motor pattern. Journal of Neurophysiology,
106(5):2201 -- 2215, 2011. PMID: 21775711.
[30] Marlene Bartos, Imre Vida, and Peter Jonas. Synap-
tic mechanisms of synchronized gamma oscillations in
inhibitory interneuron networks. Nature reviews neuro-
science, 8(1):45, 2007.
[31] Alex Roxin, Nicolas Brunel, and David Hansel. Role
of delays in shaping spatiotemporal dynamics of neu-
ronal activity in large networks. Physical review letters,
94(23):238103, 2005.
[32] Bard Ermentrout. Neural networks as spatio-temporal
pattern-forming systems. Reports on Progress in Physics,
61(4):353 -- 430, apr 1998.
[33] Rory G Townsend and Pulin Gong. Detection and anal-
ysis of spatiotemporal patterns in brain activity. PLoS
computational biology, 14(12):e1006643, 2018.
[34] Roger D Traub, John GR Jefferys, and Miles A Whit-
tington. Fast oscillations in cortical circuits. MIT press
Cambridge, MA, 1999.
[35] György Buzsáki and Xiao-Jing Wang. Mechanisms of
gamma oscillations. Annual review of neuroscience,
35:203 -- 225, 2012.
[36] Andre Fisahn, Fenella G Pike, Eberhard H Buhl, and Ole
Paulsen. Cholinergic induction of network oscillations at
40 hz in the hippocampus in vitro. Nature, 394(6689):186,
1998.
[37] György Buzsáki and James J Chrobak. Temporal struc-
ture in spatially organized neuronal ensembles: a role for
interneuronal networks. Current opinion in neurobiology,
5(4):504 -- 510, 1995.
[38] Larry S Benardo. Recruitment of gabaergic inhibition
and synchronization of inhibitory interneurons in rat neo-
cortex.
Journal of Neurophysiology, 77(6):3134 -- 3144,
1997.
[39] FK Skinner, L Zhang, JL Perez Velazquez, and
PL Carlen. Bursting in inhibitory interneuronal net-
works: a role for gap-junctional coupling. Journal of
neurophysiology, 81(3):1274 -- 1283, 1999.
[40] Goran Söhl, Stephan Maxeiner, and Klaus Willecke. Ex-
pression and functions of neuronal gap junctions. Nature
reviews neuroscience, 6(3):191, 2005.
[41] Guoning Tang, Kesheng Xu, and Luoluo Jiang. Syn-
chronization in a chaotic neural network with time de-
lay depending on the spatial distance between neurons.
Physical Review E, 84(4):046207, 2011.
[42] Kesheng Xu, Jean Paul Maidana, Samy Castro, and
Patricio Orio. Synchronization transition in neuronal
networks composed of chaotic or non-chaotic oscillators.
Scientific reports, 8(1):8370, 2018.
[43] Christoph Börgers and Nancy Kopell.
Synchroniza-
tion in networks of excitatory and inhibitory neurons
with sparse, random connectivity. Neural computation,
15(3):509 -- 538, 2003.
[44] Charles M Gray, Peter König, Andreas K Engel, and
Wolf Singer. Oscillatory responses in cat visual cor-
tex exhibit inter-columnar synchronization which reflects
global stimulus properties. Nature, 338(6213):334, 1989.
[45] Peter Uhlhaas, Gordon Pipa, Bruss Lima, Lucia Melloni,
Sergio Neuenschwander, Danko Nikolić, and Wolf Singer.
Neural synchrony in cortical networks: history, concept
and current status. Frontiers in integrative neuroscience,
3:17, 2009.
[46] Adam Keane and Pulin Gong. Propagating waves can ex-
plain irregular neural dynamics. Journal of Neuroscience,
35(4):1591 -- 1605, 2015.
[47] Lyle Muller and Alain Destexhe. Propagating waves in
thalamus, cortex and the thalamocortical system: exper-
iments and models. Journal of Physiology-Paris, 106(5-
6):222 -- 238, 2012.
[48] Carsten Mehring, Ulrich Hehl, Masayoshi Kubo, Markus
Diesmann, and Ad Aertsen. Activity dynamics and prop-
agation of synchronous spiking in locally connected ran-
dom networks. Biological cybernetics, 88(5):395 -- 408,
2003.
[49] Pierre Yger, Sami El Boustani, Alain Destexhe, and Yves
Frégnac. Topologically invariant macroscopic statistics
in balanced networks of conductance-based integrate-
and-fire neurons. Journal of computational neuroscience,
31(2):229 -- 245, 2011.
[50] Nicole Voges and Laurent U Perrinet. Complex dynamics
in recurrent cortical networks based on spatially realistic
connectivities. Frontiers in computational neuroscience,
6:41, 2012.
[51] Johanna Senk, Karolína Korvasová, Jannis Schuecker,
Espen Hagen, Tom Tetzlaff, Markus Diesmann, and
Moritz Helias. Conditions for traveling waves in spik-
ing neural networks. arXiv preprint arXiv:1801.06046,
2018.
[52] S. Coombes. Waves, bumps, and patterns in neural field
theories. Biological Cybernetics, 93(2):91 -- 108, Aug 2005.
[53] Paul C. Bressloff. Waves in Neural Media. Springer,
2014.
14
[54] Erik A Martens. Bistable chimera attractors on a trian-
gular network of oscillator populations. Physical Review
E, 82(1):016216, 2010.
[55] Iryna Omelchenko, Yuri Maistrenko, Philipp Hövel, and
Eckehard Schöll. Loss of coherence in dynamical net-
works: spatial chaos and chimera states. Physical review
letters, 106(23):234102, 2011.
[56] Changhai Tian, Liang Cao, Hongjie Bi, Kesheng Xu, and
Zonghua Liu. Chimera states in neuronal networks with
time delay and electromagnetic induction. Nonlinear Dy-
namics, 93(3):1695 -- 1704, 2018.
[57] Erik A Martens, Carlo R Laing, and Steven H Strogatz.
Solvable model of spiral wave chimeras. Physical review
letters, 104(4):044101, 2010.
[58] E Omel'chenko, Yuri L Maistrenko, and Peter A Tass.
Chimera states: The natural link between coherence and
incoherence. Physical review letters, 100(4):044105, 2008.
[59] Mark R Tinsley, Simbarashe Nkomo, and Kenneth
Showalter. Chimera and phase-cluster states in popu-
lations of coupled chemical oscillators. Nature Physics,
8(9):662, 2012.
[60] Johanne Hizanidis, Nikos E Kouvaris, Gorka Zamora-
López, Albert Díaz-Guilera, and Chris G Antonopoulos.
Chimera-like states in modular neural networks. Scien-
tific reports, 6:19845, 2016.
[61] Soumen Majhi, Matjaž Perc, and Dibakar Ghosh.
Chimera states in a multilayer network of coupled and
uncoupled neurons. Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal
of Nonlinear Science, 27(7):073109, 2017.
[62] Ali Calim, Philipp Hövel, Mahmut Ozer, and Muhammet
Uzuntarla. Chimera states in networks of type-i morris-
lecar neurons. Physical Review E, 98(6):062217, 2018.
[63] John E Rash, Kimberly GV Davidson, Naomi Kama-
sawa, Thomas Yasumura, Masami Kamasawa, Chunbo
Zhang, Robin Michaels, Diego Restrepo, Ole P Ot-
tersen, Carl O Olson, et al. Ultrastructural localiza-
tion of connexins (cx36, cx43, cx45), glutamate recep-
tors and aquaporin-4 in rodent olfactory mucosa, olfac-
tory nerve and olfactory bulb. Journal of neurocytology,
34(3-5):307 -- 341, 2005.
[64] Carmen Vivar, Roger D Traub, and Rafael Gutiér-
rez. Mixed electrical -- chemical transmission between hip-
pocampal mossy fibers and pyramidal cells. European
Journal of Neuroscience, 35(1):76 -- 82, 2012.
[65] Farid Hamzei-Sichani, Kimberly GV Davidson, Thomas
Yasumura, William GM Janssen, Susan L Wearne,
Patrick R Hof, Roger D Traub, Rafael Gutiérrez, Ole Pet-
ter Ottersen, and John E Rash. Mixed electrical --
chemical synapses in adult rat hippocampus are primar-
ily glutamatergic and coupled by connexin-36. Frontiers
in neuroanatomy, 6:13, 2012.
[66] Sidney P Kuo, Gregory W Schwartz, and Fred Rieke.
Nonlinear spatiotemporal integration by electrical and
chemical synapses in the retina. Neuron, 90(2):320 -- 332,
2016.
[67] James I Nagy, Alberto E Pereda, and John E Rash. Elec-
trical synapses in mammalian cns: past eras, present fo-
cus and future directions. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta
(BBA)-Biomembranes, 1860(1):102 -- 123, 2018.
[68] Nancy Kopell and Bard Ermentrout. Chemical and elec-
trical synapses perform complementary roles in the syn-
chronization of interneuronal networks. Proceedings of
the National Academy of Sciences, 101(43):15482 -- 15487,
2004.
[69] MS Baptista, FM Moukam Kakmeni, and Celso Grebogi.
Combined effect of chemical and electrical synapses in
hindmarsh-rose neural networks on synchronization and
the rate of information. Physical Review E, 82(3):036203,
2010.
[70] Chen Liu, Jiang Wang, Haitao Yu, Bin Deng, Xile Wei,
Kaiming Tsang, and Wailok Chan. Impact of delays on
the synchronization transitions of modular neuronal net-
works with hybrid synapses. Chaos: An Interdisciplinary
Journal of Nonlinear Science, 23(3):033121, 2013.
[71] Guillaume Pernelle, Wilten Nicola, and Claudia Clopath.
Gap junction plasticity as a mechanism to regulate
network-wide oscillations. PLoS computational biology,
14(3):e1006025, 2018.
[72] Xiao-Jing Wang and György Buzsáki. Gamma oscillation
by synaptic inhibition in a hippocampal interneuronal
network model. Journal of neuroscience, 16(20):6402 --
6413, 1996.
[73] Agostina Palmigiano, Theo Geisel, Fred Wolf, and
Demian Battaglia. Flexible information routing by tran-
sient synchrony. Nature neuroscience, 20(7):1014, 2017.
[74] Alan L Hodgkin and Andrew F Huxley. A quantitative
description of membrane current and its application to
conduction and excitation in nerve. The Journal of phys-
iology, 117(4):500 -- 544, 1952.
[75] Christof Koch and Idan Segev. Methods in neuronal mod-
eling: from ions to networks. MIT press, 1998.
[76] David Sterratt, Bruce Graham, Andrew Gillies, and
David Willshaw. Principles of computational modelling
in neuroscience. Cambridge University Press, 2011.
[77] Duncan J. Watts and Steven H. Strogatz. Collective dy-
namics of 'small-world' networks. Nature, 393(6684):440 --
442, 1998.
[78] David Golomb and John Rinzel. Dynamics of globally
coupled inhibitory neurons with heterogeneity. Physical
review E, 48(6):4810, 1993.
[79] David Golomb and John Rinzel. Clustering in globally
coupled inhibitory neurons. Physica D: Nonlinear Phe-
nomena, 72(3):259 -- 282, 1994.
[80] Yoshiki Kuramoto. Chemical oscillations, waves, and
turbulence. Courier Corporation, 2003.
[81] Elena Bertolotti, Raffaella Burioni, Matteo di Volo,
and Alessandro Vezzani. Synchronization and long-time
memory in neural networks with inhibitory hubs and
synaptic plasticity. Physical Review E, 95(1):012308,
2017.
[82] Murray Shanahan.
in
community-structured oscillator networks.
Chaos:
An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science,
20(1):013108, 2010.
Metastable chimera states
[83] S. J. Martin, P. D. Grimwood, and R. G. M. Morris.
Synaptic plasticity and memory: An evaluation of the
hypothesis. Annual Review of Neuroscience, 23(1):649 --
711, 2000. PMID: 10845078.
15
[84] Stewart A Bloomfield and Béla Völgyi. The diverse
functional roles and regulation of neuronal gap junctions
in the retina. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 10(7):495,
2009.
[85] Jennifer Claire Robinson, C. Andrew Chapman, and
Richard Courtemanche. Gap junction modulation of low-
frequency oscillations in the cerebellar granule cell layer.
The Cerebellum, 16(4):802 -- 811, Aug 2017.
[86] Zemin Wang, Ryan Neely, and Carole E. Landisman. Ac-
tivation of group i and group ii metabotropic glutamate
receptors causes ltd and ltp of electrical synapses in the
rat thalamic reticular nucleus. Journal of Neuroscience,
35(19):7616 -- 7625, 2015.
[87] Josef Turecek, Genevieve S. Yuen, Victor Z. Han, Xiao-
Hui Zeng, K. Ulrich Bayer, and John P. Welsh. Nmda
receptor activation strengthens weak electrical coupling
in mammalian brain. Neuron, 81(6):1375 -- 1388, 2014.
[88] Philippe Coulon and Carole E. Landisman. The potential
role of gap junctional plasticity in the regulation of state.
Neuron, 93(6):1275 -- 1295, 2017.
[89] Julie S. Haas, Corey M. Greenwald, and Alberto E.
Activity-dependent plasticity of electrical
Pereda.
synapses: increasing evidence for its presence and func-
tional roles in the mammalian brain. BMC Cell Biology,
17(1):14, May 2016.
[90] Mario Galarreta and Shaul Hestrin. Electrical synapses
between gaba-releasing interneurons. Nature Reviews
Neuroscience, 2(6):425 -- 433, 2001.
[91] Barry W. Connors and Michael A. Long. Electrical
synapses in the mammalian brain. Annual Review of
Neuroscience, 27(1):393 -- 418, 2004. PMID: 15217338.
[92] Guillaume Pernelle, Wilten Nicola, and Claudia Clopath.
Gap junction plasticity as a mechanism to regulate
network-wide oscillations. PLOS Computational Biology,
14(3):1 -- 29, 03 2018.
[93] Dimitris G. Placantonakis, Anatoly A. Bukovsky, Sue A.
Aicher, Hans-Peter Kiem, and John P. Welsh. Continu-
ous electrical oscillations emerge from a coupled network:
A study of the inferior olive using lentiviral knockdown of
connexin36. Journal of Neuroscience, 26(19):5008 -- 5016,
2006.
[94] Barry W. Connors. Synchrony and so much more: Di-
verse roles for electrical synapses in neural circuits. De-
velopmental Neurobiology, 77(5):610 -- 624, 2017.
[95] Ran Rubin, L. F. Abbott, and Haim Sompolinsky. Bal-
anced excitation and inhibition are required for high-
capacity, noise-robust neuronal selectivity. Proceedings of
the National Academy of Sciences, 114(44):E9366 -- E9375,
2017.
[96] Olaf Sporns. Networks of the Brain. MIT press, 2010.
[97] Mikhail I. Rabinovich, Ramón Huerta, Pablo Varona,
and Valentin S. Afraimovich. Transient cognitive dynam-
ics, metastability, and decision making. PLOS Compu-
tational Biology, 4(5):1 -- 9, 05 2008.
|
1507.01390 | 1 | 1507 | 2015-07-06T11:20:31 | Predictive coding: A Possible Explanation of Filling-in at the blind spot | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Filling-in at the blind-spot is a perceptual phenomenon in which the visual system fills the informational void, which arises due to the absence of retinal input corresponding to the optic disc, with surrounding visual attributes. Though there are enough evidence to conclude that some kind of neural computation is involved in filling-in at the blind spot especially in the early visual cortex, the knowledge of the actual computational mechanism is far from complete. We have investigated the bar experiments and the associated filling-in phenomenon in the light of the hierarchical predictive coding framework, where the blind-spot was represented by the absence of early feed-forward connection. We recorded the responses of predictive estimator neurons at the blind-spot region in the V1 area of our three level (LGN-V1-V2) model network. These responses are in agreement with the results of earlier physiological studies and using the generative model we also showed that these response profiles indeed represent the filling-in completion. These demonstrate that predictive coding framework could account for the filling-in phenomena observed in several psychophysical and physiological experiments involving bar stimuli. These results suggest that the filling-in could naturally arise from the computational principle of hierarchical predictive coding (HPC) of natural images. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Predictive coding: A Possible Explanation of
Filling-in at the blind spot
Rajani Raman, Sandip Sarkar
Saha Institute of Nuclear Phycsis, Kolkata, India
Abstract
Filling-in at the blind-spot is a perceptual phenomenon in which
the visual system fills the informational void, which arises due to the
absence of retinal input corresponding to the optic disc, with surround-
ing visual attributes. Though there are enough evidence to conclude
that some kind of neural computation is involved in filling-in at the
blind spot especially in the early visual cortex, the knowledge of the
actual computational mechanism is far from complete. We have inves-
tigated the bar experiments and the associated filling-in phenomenon
in the light of the hierarchical predictive coding framework, where the
blind-spot was represented by the absence of early feed-forward con-
nection. We recorded the responses of predictive estimator neurons at
the blind-spot region in the V1 area of our three level (LGN-V1-V2)
model network. These responses are in agreement with the results
of earlier physiological studies and using the generative model we also
showed that these response profiles indeed represent the filling-in com-
pletion. These demonstrate that predictive coding framework could
account for the filling-in phenomena observed in several psychophysi-
cal and physiological experiments involving bar stimuli. These results
suggest that the filling-in could naturally arise from the computational
principle of hierarchical predictive coding (HPC) of natural images.
Introduction
Filling-in at the blind spot is one of the examples of how brain interpolates
the informational void due to a deficit of visual input from the retina. Due
1
to the absence of photoreceptors at optics disc, the retina is unable to send
the corresponding signal to the brain and thereby, hides some portion of the
visual field. This concealed visual field is known as the blind spot. How-
ever, we never notice any odd patch in our visual field, even in monocular
vision, but rather we see the complete scene; filled up in accordance with
the surrounding visual attributes [1]. This completion is known as percep-
tual filling-in or simply filling-in.
In addition to the blind spot, filling-in
also occurs in other visual input deficit conditions, like filling-in at the arti-
ficial and natural retinal scotoma [2,3]. Besides the deficit of input, filling-in
also occurs in visual illusions such as Neon color spreading, Craik-O’Brien-
Cornsweet illusion, Kanizsa shapes, etc. and steady fixation condition like
Troxler effect (for review see [4]).
Many psychophysical and physiological studies have been performed to
gain insight into the neural mechanism of perceptual completion at the blind
spot [5–7]. The two main findings of these studies have been: first, filling-in
is an active phenomena, where the visual system, rather than being idle in
the absence of visual information, is involved in some neural computation,
and second, activities in early visual cortical areas are involved in filling-in
process. Physiological studies on the monkeys show that perceptually corre-
lated neural activities are evoked in the deep layer of primary visual cortex,
in the region that retinotopically corresponds to the blind spot (BS region),
when filling-in completion occurs [5, 6]. In an experiment, Matsumoto and
Komatsu [7] showed that some active neuron in BS region in deep layer of
primary visual cortex (BS neurons), which possess larger receptive fields that
extend beyond the blind spot, exhibits non-linear elevated response when a
long moving bar cross over the blind spot and perceptual completion oc-
curs (See fig.1).
Although some initial attempts have been made to understand the com-
putational mechanism of completion of illusory contour and surface [8–12],
little work has been devoted to the study of computational mechanism of
filling-in completion at the blind spot. Recent studies [13] have suggested
the computational mechanism of completion of the bar in terms of a com-
plex interaction of velocity-dependent pathways in the visual cortex under
the framework of regularization theory. But the fitness of his proposal in the
context of a general coding principle of the visual cortex is not clear. Here
in this study, we suggest the filling-in completion at the blind spot natu-
rally follows from the mechanism of Hierarchical predictive coding (HPC)of
natural images, which has been, recently, gained growing support as general
2
Figure 1: Schematic Illustration of bar completion experiment(adopted
from Matsumoto and Komatsu [4]). (a) The gray oval area represents the blind
spot, whereas the dashed circle represents the receptive field of a neuron. The
actual stimulus and corresponding retinal input and percept at position 1,2,3 and
4 has shown. Stimuli, here, is the bar with one end fixed outside and the other end
is drifting across the blind spot. (b) The response of a typical neuron in BS region
at the deep layer of primary visual cortex. The gray rectangle indicates the blind
spot and the dotted rectangular area represent the receptive field of the typical
neuron. The solid line is the response obtained through the eye that provides
the blind spot (BS eye) and the dotted line is the response of the same neuron
obtained through the fellow eye. While the drifting end of the bar was inside the
blind spot the perception of the bar was of a short isolated bar and corresponding
neural responses were low and constant. But the moment bar end crossed the
blind spot, the neural response elevated rapidly and completion of the bar was
perceived. These elevated response exhibit nonlinearity; the response to the long
bar that stimulate simultaneously the both sides of the blind spot was larger than
the sum of responses to the stimuli either side of blind spot separately.
3
coding principle of visual cortex [14–21].
The root of Hierarchical predictive coding lies in the probabilistic hierar-
chical generative model and the efficient coding of natural images. In such
probabilistic frameworks, the job of the visual system is to infer or estimate
the properties of the world from signals coming from receptors [22–24]. In
HPC framework, this job is hypothesized to be completed by concurrent
prediction-correction mechanism along the hierarchy of the visual system.
Accordingly, each higher visual area (say V2) attempt to predict response
at its lower area (say V1) on the basis of the learned statistical regularities,
and send that prediction signal to the lower area by feedback connection.
In response to this top-down information, lower area sends a residual error
signal to the higher area, by feed-forward connection, to correct the next
prediction. This idea is based on the anatomical architecture of the vi-
sual system that is hierarchically organized and reciprocally connected [25].
Probabilistic generative model, in HPC framework, accounts for learning the
statistical regularities found in natural images and generation of prediction
of input based on that learning. Recently, several neuronal tuning proper-
ties in different visual area such as the lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN),
primary visual cortex (V1) and middle temporal level (MT) has been ex-
plained using this framework [18, 19]. For example, Rao [14] suggested that
the extra-classical properties of neurons in V1 could be understood in terms
of predictive-feedback signal from the secondary visual cortex (V2) that is
made in the larger context and the backdrop of learned statistical regularity
from natural Scene. We speculated that the similar mechanism could also
explain the filling-in completion across the blind spot.
In this work, we have conducted simulation studies involving horizontal
bars on three leveled (LGN-V1-V2) HPC model network having a blind spot
which was emulated by removing the feed-forward (LGN-V1) connection. In
our first investigation we have employed shifting bar stimuli as described
in [7](See fig. 1), to study the properties of our model network and recorded
the model predictive estimator neurons (PE neurons) in V1 in BS region. We
found that these neurons exhibit similar non-linear response and represents
the filling-in completion when bar crosses the blind spot. In another inves-
tigation, we presented two separate bar segment at the opposite end of the
model blind spot to verify the tolerance of completion by varying the align-
ment of those segments. We found that the filling-in completion is best when
the bars are perfectly aligned. The completion is visible for small orders of
misalignment, but it fades out quickly with increasing misalign. These re-
4
sults are consistent with the finding of psychophysical experiments [26, 27].
These findings suggest that the filling-in process could naturally arise in the
computational principle of hierarchical predictive coding (HPC) of natural
images which has been, recently, argued to be a general coding principle of
the visual system.
Model
Hierarchical Predictive coding of natural images:
General Model and Network Architecture: As indicated in the pre-
vious section, the problem of vision, in a probabilistic framework, has been
considered as an inference or an estimation problem; where an organism try
to estimate the hidden physical cause (object attributes such as shape, tex-
ture and luminance etc.) behind the generated image that organism receives
as an input. In line with these suggestions, it is assumed that, in HPC frame-
work, image generation involves the interaction between physical causes at
multiple spatial and temporal level along the hierarchy. The goal of the vi-
sual system is, thus, to estimate (or internally represent) these hidden causes
at different levels of visual processing, efficiently [14]. This goal is, in HPC
framework, hypothesized to be achieved by the visual system using recurrent
predictions-corrections mechanism throughout the hierarchy (See fig. 2a).
In this framework, on the arrival of an input, predictor estimator mod-
ules (PE module) at each visual processing level generate the prediction
(or estimate) on the basis of the learned statistical regularities of natural
scenes. Each higher area (say V2) then sends these generated prediction
to its immediate lower level (say V1) by feedback connections and in re-
turn receives the error signal, by feed-forward connections, which is used
to correct the current estimate. An equilibrium state is achieved after con-
current prediction-correction cycle; where the estimate matches the input
signal. This optimum-estimate is regarded as a representation of the input
at that level. The optimum-estimate achieved at different levels of network
is depicted as a perception corresponding to that image.
In general, a single PE module (See fig. 2b) consist of: (i) Predictive es-
timator neurons (PE neurons) which represent the estimate of current input
signal I with response vector r (state vector), (ii) neurons, carrying pre-
diction signal U r (for the input I) to lower level by feed-back connections,
5
Figure 2: General HPC Architecture. a) On arrival of input, predictive esti-
mator module at each higher visual processing level makes the estimate and sends
prediction signal to its next lower level by feedback connection and receives the
corresponding prediction error by a feed-forward connection. The error signal is
used by the predictive estimator to correct the estimate for better prediction. b)
General predictive estimator (PE) module constitutes of (i) neurons to represent
the estimate of the input I by their response vector r by minimizing the bottom-
up (I − U r) and top-down (r − rtd) error, (ii) feed-forward error carrying neurons
has the efficacy matrix U , which encode the basis vectors their synaptic weights
(or receptive fields), (iii) prediction U r carrying neurons and (iv) top down error
detecting neutrons.
6
whose synapse encode encoding efficacy matrix U , (iii) neurons, carrying
feed-forward error signal (I − U r) form level 0 to level 1, whose synapses
encoded rows of efficacy matrix U T , and (iv) error detecting neurons which
carry the residual error signal r − rtd to the higher level.
Network dynamics and learning rule: The dynamics, the learning rules
and hence the above-mentioned architecture of a general PE module directly
stem from probabilistic estimation methods.
In the Bayesian framework,
these originate from maximum a posteriori (MAP) approach. In this case,
maximizing the posterior probability P (r, rtd, UI), which is equal to the
product of generative models P (Ir, U ), P (rtdr) and prior probabilities P (r)
and P (U ), with respect to r and U provides the dynamics and learning rule
respectively. Equivalently, in the framework of information theory, the mini-
mum description length (MDL) approach leads to same results by minimizing
the coding length E, which is equal to negative log of posterior probability
defined above, with respect to r and U (for details, see [14, 28]).
By assuming the probability distributions P (Ir, U ) and P (rtdr) as Gaus-
td respectively, the total coding
sians of zero mean and variances σ2 and σ2
length E can be written as,
E =
1
σ2 (I − U r)T (I − U r) +
1
σ2
td
(r − rtd)T (r − rtd) + g(r) + h(U )
(1)
here, g(r) and h(U ) are the negative log of prior probabilities P (r) and
P (U ) respectively. Minimizing the coding length E, with respect to r (using
the gradient descent method) provides the dynamics of PE module as,
dr
dt
= −k1
2
∂E
∂r
=
k1
σ2 U T (I − U r) +
k1
σ2
td
(rtd − r) − k1
2
g(cid:48)(r)
(2)
here, k1 is a rate parameter that governs the rate of descent towards a
minimum of E, and U T is the transpose to weight matrix U . The steady
state of this dynamical equation provides an optimum-estimate, which is
regarded as the representation of the input. Coding length E, roughly, can
be seen as the mean square error at the input and the output level of a PE
module, subjected to constraints of prior probabilities. And minimization
of the coding length is equivalent to optimization of estimate by recurrently
matching of estimate to the corresponding “sensory driven” input from lower
7
area as well as “context driven” prediction signal from higher area. The
prediction signal U r is the linear combination of basis vectors Ui‘s. The
Ui is the ith column of the matrix U , and represents the receptive field for
ith neuron. The weighted coefficient in this combination, ri, represents the
response of ith neuron having receptive field Ui. The visual representation
of the predication U r corresponding to optimum-estimate r is, in this study,
termed as ”perceptual image.”
Furthermore, the minimization of coding length E, with respect to U
using gradient descent method provides the learning rule for basis matrix U
as,
dU
dt
= −k2
2
∂E
∂U
=
k2
σ2 (I − U r)rT − k2
2
h(cid:48)(U )
(3)
here k2 is learning rate, which operates on the slower time scale than the
rate parameters k1, and rT is the transpose of state vector r. This learning
rule can be seen as of Hebbian type. In this study, prior probability, P (r), on
state vector r, are chosen according to sparse coding; where it is assumed that
the visual system encodes any incoming signal with a small set of neurons
from the available larger pool. The kurtosis prior distribution (P (ri) =
exp(−αlog(1 + r2
i ))) constrains the dynamics for the sparse representation of
the input. This distribution gives us:
g(cid:48)(ri) = 2αri/(1 + r2
i )
(4)
which is used in equation (2). The prior probability distribution, P (U )
has been chosen here to be Gaussian type, which finally gives us:
h(cid:48)(U ) = 2λU
(5)
which is used in the equation (3). Here α and λ are variance related
parameters.
Simulation
Network In this work we simulated a three level linear hierarchical pre-
dictive network (See fig.3). In this network, Level 1, which is equivalent to
V1, consists of 9 predictor estimator modules (PE modules). These modules
receive input from level 0 and send the output to the sole module at level 2.
Level 0 is equivalent to the LGN and level 2 is equivalent to V2. Therefore,
8
Figure 3: Three level HPC model network. Each of nine level 1 PE module
sends prediction to level 0 by feedback connection and receives error signal cor-
responding to their own local image patches by a feed-forward connection. On
the other hand, the sole PE module at level 2 sends the prediction signal to all
level 1 modules and in reply, receives the error signal collectively from all these
modules. Level 2, therefore, encodes larger visual patch and hence possess the
larger receptive field.
the PE module at level 2 receives input from all the nine level 1 PE modules
and sends back the feedback signal to all of them. This architecture is based
on the fact that the visual area higher in hierarchy operates on a higher
spatial scale.
Each of nine PE modules at level 1 consists of 64 PE neurons, 144 Predic-
tion carrying neuron, 64 afferent error carrying neurons and 64 error detect-
ing neurons for conveying the residual error to level 2. The layer 2 module
consists of 156 PE neurons, 576 prediction carrying neurons and 156 error
carrying neurons.
Training: Six natural images (fig 4a) of size 512 × 512 pixels were used
for training after pre-processing. The pre-processing involved DC removal
and the filtering of images with circular symmetric whitening/lowpass filter
with spatial frequency profile W (f ) = f exp(−(f /f0)4)( see
[24]). Cut-
off frequency f0 was taken to be 200 cycles/image. The pre-processing has
been argued to emulate the filtering at LGN [29]. Variance normalized 1000
batches of 100 image patches of size 30 × 30 pixel, which were extracted
9
Figure 4: Natural Images. a) These images, taken from of different natural
environments, are used for simulation. b) A typical sample of 30 x 30 pixels image
patches extracted from the natural image (top rightmost) from the position shown
by the white rectangle. Each of these patches is broken down to 9 sub-patches of
12 × 12 pixel each with 3 overlapping pixels. Three such sub-patches are shown
here by three dotted rectangles in yellow, magenta and white. Each of these sub-
patches forms the local input to the 9, level 0 modules in the HPC model network.
from randomly selected locations from the randomly selected pre-processed
images, were given as input to the network. A single 30 × 30-pixel image
consisted of nine tiled 12× 12-pixel image patches, which were overlapped by
3 pixels (see fig.4b) and which were fed to the corresponding level 1 PE mod-
ules. For each batch of image patches, the network was allowed to achieve
steady states (according to the equ. (2)) and the average of these states was
used to update the efficacy of neurons ( according to the equ. 3), initially
assigned to random values. During training the gain of efficacy vectors (rows
of U T or columns of U ) was adopted so as to maintain equal variance on ri.
The level 1 was trained first and then the level 2. Parameter values used in
this study are: k1 = 1, k2 = 3, σ2 = 3, σ2
td = 10, α = 0.05 at level 1 and 0.1
at level 2, λ = 0.0025
To simulate the deficit of input related to optic disc (or blind spot), the
efficacy of early feed-forward (level 0 - level 1) neurons, that carry the error
signal corresponding to the middle region (of size 8 × 8) of input patches (of
size 30 × 30), were set to zero.
10
Figure 5: Learned synaptic weight: Learned synaptic weights of feed-forward
model neurons, achieved with sparse prior distribution on network activities after
training with natural image patches, at level 1 and level 2 are presented in (a) and
(b) respectively.
Results
To ascertain whether the computational mechanism of HPC could account for
filling-in completion across the blind spot, we conducted a pair of experiments
using bar stimuli on the trained HPC model network. The HPC network
was allowed to learn the synaptic weight of model neurons, by exposing it
to natural image patches under the constraints of the sparseness of model
neuron responses (see method). The learned synaptic weights of neurons
carrying feed-forward signal of one of the modules at level 1 and level 2 are
shown in fig. 5. The weighting profiles at level 1 (fig.5a) resemble the Gabor-
like receptive field at V1, which is similar to the results reported earlier
in several studies [14, 18, 24]. The weighting profile at the level 2 (fig.5b)
resembles the more abstract visual feature like the long bar, curve, etc..The
blind spot was emulated in the network by removing feed-forward connection
(see method), whereas, the training was performed on a network with feed-
forward connection. We designate the network with the blind spot as BS
network and the one without the blind spot as a non-BS network.
11
Filling-in of shifting bar : Both BS and non-BS Network were exposed
to images of a horizontal bar of different length. One end of the bar was
fixed at a position outside of the blind spot, whereas, the position of other
end was varied (by one pixel each instant) across the blind spot. Pictures of
the bar for six different end positions are shown in figure (6a). The response
vector, r, of PE neurons in the central module in the model network (let say
BS module) at level 1 was recorded for the different end position of the bar.
Figure(7) shows the bar plots of the response of 64 neurons in BS module
at level 1 for six different bar position in both model networks(BS and non-
BS). The comparison shows that almost the same set of a small number of
neurons responded in both networks. The receptive field of highly responsive
neurons in this set possesses a horizontal bar-like structures. We plotted the
response of some of these highly responsive neurons against the bar position
(varying by one pixel)
(see fig. 8) which show that these neurons exhibit
non-linearly elevated response when bar crosses the blind spot. This nature
of the nonlinear behavior as well as the final elevated response are in line
with the experimental results [7]. The response of neurons in BS network
is elevated reasonably close to the responses of those neurons in the non-BS
network. The closeness of responses indicates the representation of objects in
the BS network is similar to the one in the non-BS network. This is reflected
in the corresponding “perceptual images” ( see figure 6b) reconstructed using
the generative process.
It is evident from these results that, in the case of BS Network, as long
as the bar end reside inside the blind spot the response of neurons, in the BS
module, remained constant and relatively low (fig. 7 and fig.8) which results
in the perception of a bar of constant length on one side of the blind spot.
But as the bar crosses the blind spot their responses significantly elevated and
the filling-in completion occurred. The elevation in response depends on the
localization and the profile of the receptive field of neurons in BS area. These
could also be understood by observing the relative deviation of the response
of each neuron (typically the highly responsive neurons) in both networks
(fig.7). These results are consistent with the findings of neurophysiological
studies with bar stimuli on macaque monkeys.
Filling-in for misaligned bars : Two bar segments were presented on
the opposite side of the blind spot. One of those bar segments was kept fixed,
whereas another one was shifted along the vertical direction (see figure(9a).
12
Figure 6: Bar Shift Exp. a) A typical 30× 30 pixel stimulus is shown here. The
darkened object in the stimulus is a bar, whose endpoint is represented by the
number 1. Five more stimuli were constructed by shifting the bar end to positions
2 to 6. The larger rectangle of size 12 × 12 pixels (shown by the dotted line at
the center) indicates the extension of BS module and the smaller one of size 8 × 8
(shown by the solid line) indicate the extension of blind-spot. b) Generated 30×30
“perceptual images” corresponding to response profile of PE neurons at level 1 of
the HPC network for non-BS (top row) and BS (bottom row) cases are shown.
13
Figure 7: Responses profiles: Normalized responses of 64 PE neurons at BS
module, corresponding six stimuli discussed in figure 6(a) are presented. The dark
blue bar represents the response of PE neurons for the BS network, whereas, the
light blue bar represents the responses for the non-BS network. Three most highly
active neurons (in bottom leftmost bar plot) are marked by red arrows.
14
Figure 8: Nonlinear response in BS region at level 1: Plots of the normalized
absolute value of response are shown against the bar position for three highly active
neurons (indicated by red arrows in the sixth bar blot of figure 7) In these plots,
dotted rectangular area indicates the extension of BS module whereas, the solid
gray rectangular area indicates the extension of blind spot. The receptive fields of
these three neurons are shown at the top of the respective plots, which show that
these neurons participated in encoding information of a horizontal bar.
We recorded the response of PE neurons, in the BS module, at Level 1 and
generated the ”perceptual images” corresponding to these misaligned bars.
The result presented in the figure(9b) shows that the bar appears completed
when both segments are aligned, but this filling-in fades away when misalign-
ment increases. This result indicates that the filling-in completion is highly
favorable for perfect alignment and have some degree of tolerance against the
misalignment. Similar results are reported in earlier psychophysical studies
[26, 27].
To understand the mechanism of filling-in, we should recall that in HPC,
feed-forward connection propagates up the residual error, corresponding to
prediction made by higher area using generative model of natural images, to
correct the current estimate for the betterment of the next prediction. The
optimum-estimate, where prediction closely matches the “driving sensory”
input as well as “contextual signal” from higher area, which produce a min-
imum prediction error, is then depicted as a percept of the input. But the
blind spot is characterized by the absence of such feed-forward connection
that is responsible for propagating up the error. Therefore, the estimate made
by higher area, on the basis of surrounding information and the learned nat-
15
Figure 9: Nonaligned bar investigation. a) A typical stimulus is shown, where
two non-aligned bar segments are presented at opposite sides of the blind spot.
For our study, one bar was fixed (left one) and the other one was shifted vertically
by one pixel per instant for the seven positions emulating seven stimuli. b) The
generated “perceptual images” for those stimuli (as discussed in (a)) corresponding
to the recorded response profile of PE neurons at level 1
16
ural image statistics, prevails and this provides the ground for the filling-in
completion at the blind-spot.
The estimate at level 2, which operate on a larger spatial scale than the
blind spot, is made in a larger context. In such context, an optimum-estimate
(or prediction) will be the one that matches the “driving sensory” input in
the surrounding region of the blind spot, which results in the minimal error
signal. Since this estimate is made on the basis of the learned statistical
regularity of natural image, the stimuli which have similar statistics in the
surrounding region of the blind spot is estimated as continuous regular object
across the blind spot, which ultimately results in completion at level 2. In
the absence of feed-forward connection in BS region, the corresponding local
optimum-estimate at level 1 will, therefore, evolve by matching the “context
driven” feedback signal from level 2. This process at level 1 locally captures
all the course of the completion process at level 2. Thus, the properties of the
filling-in are highly determined by the matching of statistics of input stimuli
around the blind spot and natural statistics learned by the network. The
higher degree of matching leads to higher chances of completion.
For example, in the bar shifting experiment while one end the bar end re-
sides inside the blind spot, the incoming sensory input, which is of a short bar
residing on one side of the blind spot, deviates reasonably from learned sta-
tistical regularity, in which the bars are usually longer (extended across the
blind spot) [14]. That turns out as a non-completion of the bar and PE neu-
rons at BS module, whose response represent bar, exhibit low response. On
the other hand, when bar crosses the blind spot, the probability of matching
with the learned statistical regularity and this abruptly elevates the response
of PE neurons which encodes the bar in BS module. This process resembles
the AND-gate functionality and reflects the nonlinearity in response profiles
shown above (fig 8).
When two aligned bar segments are presented on opposite sides of the
blind spot, level 2 estimate (or predict) those bar segments as parts of the
single continuous bar extended across the blind spot. Since there is no feed-
foreword corrective information to correct the estimate at level 2 correspond-
ing to blind spot, an estimated long continuous bar extended across the blind
spot provides the best match with aligned bar segments as well as with the
learned statistical regularity. This process results in the perception of a long
continuous bar. On the other hand, two non-aligned such bar is less likely
to be a continuous object in the context of the natural image and, hence,
their likelihood of completion. The findings of our study suggest that the
17
learned statistical regularity of natural objects along with one way prediction
mechanism plays a significant role in filling-in completion.
Discussion
The aim of this study was to investigate the computational mechanism re-
lated to the filling-in at the blind spot. We speculated that this can be un-
derstood in the framework of HPC. We conducted simulation studies on the
three level HPC model network to investigate the filling-in completion using
bar stimuli. In the first study, we recorded the response of PE neurons at V1
in BS module, while shifting a long bar across the blind spot, and generated
the corresponding perceptual counterpart using the generative model. The
recorded response shows similar non-linear profile and represents the filled
up segment of the bar which is reported by Matsumoto and Komatsu [7].
In the other study, to verify the tolerance of perception of completion of
a non-aligned bar, a pair of bar segments were presented on the opposite
side of the blind spot, with varying alignment. We found that the filling-in
completion, which occurs in the case of perfectly aligned bar segments, also
occurs with small degree of misalignment, but as the misalignment increases,
the completion doesn’t happen. These results are in good agreement with
the physiological and psychophysical results reported earlier [7, 26].
Previous studies have suggested hierarchical predictive processing of nat-
ural images, as a general unified coding principle of visual system [14, 17–19,
28]. This study suggests that the same coding principle could also account
for filling-in at the blind spot. Where, for an input stimulus around the
blind spot, higher areas (V2) generates unified estimate (which also incor-
porate the estimate corresponding to blind spot) of the input stimuli on the
basis of the learned regularities from natural image statistics. The comple-
tion phenomena is the BS region are then simply the outcome of remaining
such contextually made, natural image statistics biased estimate uncorrected
due to the absence of error carrying feed-forward connection in BS region.
The BS region at V1 takes part in this process by not propagating up any
error signal and achieving local optimum-estimate by matching contextual
and statistically influenced top-down prediction. The achieved multilevel
optimum-estimate, comprising a continuous visual object across the blind
spot result in a percept of completion. The nonlinearity observed in re-
sponses and, hence, the properties of filling-in, result from the degree of
18
similarity between statistics of stimuli around the blind spot and the natural
image statistics. This study provides another support to the suggestions of
predictive coding as a general computational principle of visual cortex.
Studies [8, 11], have suggested the role of cortico-cortical (V2-V1) inter-
action in the filling-in of illusory contours and the surfaces. Neumann [9]
suggested that the filling-in of illusory contour could be the outcome of mod-
ulation mechanism of feedback signal from V2, which enhance the favorable
response profile of feature detecting neurons, mainly in the superficial layers,
at V1, in the context of larger contour coded at V2. This model, there-
fore, has its limitation in explaining the completion across the blind spot
where activity is mainly found in the deep layer of the V1. In another re-
cent study [30],authors tried to explain the non-linear behavior of neurons
in filling-in in terms of interaction of top-down and bottom-up signal in a
Bayesian framework, where the feed-forward signal carrying the “prediction
match” plays a crucial role. However, in this study, we have demonstrated
similar response profiles along with the other properties of filling-in under a
simple, unifying framework of hierarchical predictive processing, where feed-
forward signal carries the “prediction error”in spite of “prediction match”
which determines the activities of PE neurons. These PE neurons, in this
framework, hypothetically, resides in the deep layer of the cortex [31] which
is consistent with the physiological findings.
This study does not reject any possible role of intra-cortical interaction
in V1 in filling-in completion. There could be some other (or more than one)
prediction-correction pathway within V1 which can contribute to filling-in on
the basis of contextual information surrounding the blind spot. In this study,
we use a simple linear hierarchical predictive coding model network, which
deals with static images. The inclusion of a Kalman filter, which can imple-
ment spatiotemporal prediction-correction mechanism, could account for the
motion related filling-in properties (such as [32]). Moreover, in our study, we
have focused only on filling-in completion of a bar, which is primarily based
on the learned statistics on contrast information (edge, boundary, etc.) found
in natural scenes. The surface filling-in at the blind spot could also be un-
derstood under the similar mechanism, given a proper surface representation
(learning) in the hierarchical probabilistic framework, which is the present
challenge of visual science. The future research along these directions could
provide the basis for HPC to explain the complete phenomena of filling-in.
Finally, our study suggests that the filling-in could be a manifestation of
a hierarchical predictive process which is, recently, argued to be a general
19
and unifying coding principle of visual cortex.
Acknowledgements:
We thank Rajesh P N Rao, Director of the NSF Center for Sensorimotor
Neural Engineering and Professor of Computer Science and Engineering at
the University of Washington in Seattle, for valuable discussions and sugges-
tions regarding this work. This work was supported by research grants from
the Department of Atomic Energy (DAE), Govt of India.
References
[1] Vilayanur S Ramachandran.
Blind spots.
Scientific American,
266(5):86–91, 1992.
[2] Vilayanur S Ramachandran, Richard L Gregory, et al. Perceptual
filling in of artificially induced scotomas in human vision. Nature,
350(6320):699–702, 1991.
[3] HJM Gerrits and GJMEN Timmerman. The filling-in process in patients
with retinal scotomata. Vision Research, 9(3):439–442, 1969.
[4] Hidehiko Komatsu. The neural mechanisms of perceptual filling-in. Na-
ture reviews neuroscience, 7(3):220–231, 2006.
[5] M Fiorani J´unior, MG Rosa, Ricardo Gattass, and Carlos Eduardo
Rocha-Miranda. Dynamic surrounds of receptive fields in primate stri-
ate cortex: a physiological basis for perceptual completion? Proceedings
of the National Academy of Sciences, 89(18):8547–8551, 1992.
[6] Hidehiko Komatsu, Masaharu Kinoshita, and Ikuya Murakami. Neu-
ral responses in the retinotopic representation of the blind spot in the
macaque v1 to stimuli for perceptual filling-in. The Journal of Neuro-
science, 20(24):9310–9319, 2000.
[7] Masayuki Matsumoto and Hidehiko Komatsu. Neural responses in the
macaque v1 to bar stimuli with various lengths presented on the blind
spot. Journal of Neurophysiology, 93(5):2374–2387, 2005.
20
[8] Heiko Neumann, Luiz Pessoa, and Thorsten Hansen. Visual filling-in
for computing perceptual surface properties. Biological Cybernetics,
85(5):355–369, 2001.
[9] Heiko Neumann and Wolfgang Sepp. Recurrent v1–v2 interaction in
early visual boundary processing. Biological Cybernetics, 81(5-6):425–
444, 1999.
[10] Stephen Grossberg and Ennio Mingolla. Neural dynamics of form per-
ception: boundary completion, illusory figures, and neon color spread-
ing. Psychological review, 92(2):173, 1985.
[11] Stephen Grossberg and Frank Kelly. Neural dynamics of binocular
brightness perception. Vision Research, 39(22):3796–3816, 1999.
[12] Stephen Grossberg, Ennio Mingolla, and William D Ross. Visual brain
and visual perception: How does the cortex do perceptual grouping?
Trends in neurosciences, 20(3):106–111, 1997.
[13] Shunji Satoh and Shiro Usui. Computational theory and applications of
a filling-in process at the blind spot. Neural Networks, 21(9):1261–1271,
2008.
[14] Rajesh PN Rao and Dana H Ballard. Predictive coding in the visual
cortex: a functional interpretation of some extra-classical receptive-field
effects. Nature neuroscience, 2(1):79–87, 1999.
[15] Tai Sing Lee and David Mumford. Hierarchical bayesian inference in the
visual cortex. JOSA A, 20(7):1434–1448, 2003.
[16] Karl Friston. A theory of cortical responses. Philosophical transactions
of the Royal Society B: Biological sciences, 360(1456):815–836, 2005.
[17] Jakob Hohwy, Andreas Roepstorff, and Karl Friston. Predictive cod-
ing explains binocular rivalry: an epistemological review. Cognition,
108(3):687–701, 2008.
[18] Janneke FM Jehee and Dana H Ballard. Predictive feedback can ac-
count for biphasic responses in the lateral geniculate nucleus. PLoS
computational biology, 5(5):e1000373, 2009.
21
[19] Janneke FM Jehee, Constantin Rothkopf, Jeffrey M Beck, and Dana H
Ballard. Learning receptive fields using predictive feedback. Journal of
Physiology-Paris, 100(1):125–132, 2006.
[20] Yanping Huang and Rajesh PN Rao. Predictive coding. Wiley Interdis-
ciplinary Reviews: Cognitive Science, 2(5):580–593, 2011.
[21] Andy Clark. Whatever next? predictive brains, situated agents, and the
future of cognitive science. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 36(03):181–
204, 2013.
[22] David Mumford. Neuronal architectures for pattern-theoretic problems.
Large-Scale Theories of the Cortex. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1994.
[23] Peter Dayan, Geoffrey E Hinton, Radford M Neal, and Richard S Zemel.
The helmholtz machine. Neural computation, 7(5):889–904, 1995.
[24] Bruno A Olshausen et al. Emergence of simple-cell receptive field proper-
ties by learning a sparse code for natural images. Nature, 381(6583):607–
609, 1996.
[25] Daniel J Felleman and David C Van Essen. Distributed hierarchical
processing in the primate cerebral cortex. Cerebral cortex, 1(1):1–47,
1991.
[26] Yukyu Araragi. Anisotropies of linear and curvilinear completions at
the blind spot. Experimental brain research, 212(4):529–539, 2011.
[27] Yukyu Araragi and Sachio Nakamizo. Anisotropy of tolerance of per-
ceptual completion at the blind spot. Vision research, 48(4):618–625,
2008.
[28] Dana H Ballard and Janneke Jehee. Dynamic coding of signed quantities
in cortical feedback circuits. Frontiers in psychology, 3, 2012.
[29] Joseph J Atick. Could information theory provide an ecological theory of
sensory processing? Network: Computation in neural systems, 3(2):213–
251, 1992.
[30] Haruo Hosoya. Multinomial bayesian learning for modeling classical and
nonclassical receptive field properties. Neural computation, 24(8):2119–
2150, 2012.
22
[31] Rajesh PN Rao and Terrence J Sejnowski. Predictive coding, cortical
feedback, and spike-timing dependent plasticity. To appear in: Statisti-
cal Theories of the Brain (R. Rao, B. Olshausen, and M. Lewicki, eds.),
2000.
[32] Ikuya Murakami. Motion aftereffect after monocular adaptation to filled-
in motion at the blind spot. Vision research, 35(8):1041–1045, 1995.
23
|
1209.5559 | 1 | 1209 | 2012-09-25T09:51:33 | Dynamic State Estimation Based on Poisson Spike Trains: Towards a Theory of Optimal Encoding | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Neurons in the nervous system convey information to higher brain regions by the generation of spike trains. An important question in the field of computational neuroscience is how these sensory neurons encode environmental information in a way which may be simply analyzed by subsequent systems. Many aspects of the form and function of the nervous system have been understood using the concepts of optimal population coding. Most studies, however, have neglected the aspect of temporal coding. Here we address this shortcoming through a filtering theory of inhomogeneous Poisson processes. We derive exact relations for the minimal mean squared error of the optimal Bayesian filter and by optimizing the encoder, obtain optimal codes for populations of neurons. We also show that a class of non-Markovian, smooth stimuli are amenable to the same treatment, and provide results for the filtering and prediction error which hold for a general class of stochastic processes. This sets a sound mathematical framework for a population coding theory that takes temporal aspects into account. It also formalizes a number of studies which discussed temporal aspects of coding using time-window paradigms, by stating them in terms of correlation times and firing rates. We propose that this kind of analysis allows for a systematic study of temporal coding and will bring further insights into the nature of the neural code. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Dynamic State Estimation Based on Poisson Spike
Trains - Towards a Theory of Optimal Encoding
Alex Susemihl1,2, Ron Meir3 and Manfred Opper1,2
1 Department of Artificial Intelligence, Technische Universitat Berlin, Franklinstr.
28-29, Berlin 10587, Germany
2 Bernstein Center for Computational Neuroscience Berlin, Philippstr. 13, Haus 6,
Berlin 10115, Germany
3 Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Technion, Haifa 32000, Israel
Abstract. Neurons in the nervous system convey information to higher brain regions
by the generation of spike trains. An important question in the field of computational
neuroscience is how these sensory neurons encode environmental information in a way
which may be simply analyzed by subsequent systems. Many aspects of the form and
function of the nervous system have been understood using the concepts of optimal
population coding. Most studies, however, have neglected the aspect of temporal
coding. Here we address this shortcoming through a filtering theory of inhomogeneous
Poisson processes. We derive exact relations for the minimal mean squared error
of the optimal Bayesian filter and by optimizing the encoder, obtain optimal codes
for populations of neurons. We also show that a class of non-Markovian, smooth
stimuli are amenable to the same treatment, and provide results for the filtering and
prediction error which hold for a general class of stochastic processes. This sets a sound
mathematical framework for a population coding theory that takes temporal aspects
into account. It also formalizes a number of studies which discussed temporal aspects
of coding using time-window paradigms, by stating them in terms of correlation times
and firing rates. We propose that this kind of analysis allows for a systematic study
of temporal coding and will bring further insights into the nature of the neural code.
PACS numbers: 87.19ls, 87.19lo, 87.19lt
Submitted to: Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment
1. Introduction
Populations of neurons transmit information through their joint spiking activity. One
of the main goals of computational neuroscience is to gain insight into the mechanisms
which shape the functional activity of neurons, and to better understand and possibly
decode the information encoded by neurons. In the study of optimal population codes,
it is usual to start from considerations about the nature of the neural information
processing and of the tasks performed by the neurons to search for the best possible
coding strategies (see for example [1, 2, 3, 4]). Considering the encoding and decoding
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
2
of stimuli from the information-theoretical viewpoint, we can develop a theory for the
optimal Bayesian estimator for any given task. Given a particular estimation task and
a noise model, the Bayesian estimator is the best estimator for the task, minimizing
a well-defined cost function (see [5]). In the broader context of Systems Theory, spike
train encoding and decoding can be viewed within the context of optimal filtering based
on point process observations [6].
Here we focus on a specific question: Given a stimulus ensemble and the optimal
Bayesian decoder, how can we design an encoder to minimize the mean squared error in
a stimulus reconstruction/state estimation task? That is, we would like to determine an
optimal response distribution, to make the reconstruction of the stimulus easier. This
has been the subject of previous investigations in a number of contexts.
In [7, 2, 3]
the authors sought to answer the question in the framework of static stimuli. These
papers established the existence of a finite optimal tuning width for bell-shaped tuning
functions. In [1] the authors study a similar problem in the context of finite-state Markov
models. In the Deep Belief Network literature, the study of Autoencoders, which deal
with a very similar question, has recently received a lot of attention as well [8]. We focus
here on the framework proposed in [9], where a dynamic stimulus is observed through
noisy spike trains and is decoded online. This falls within the general theory of Bayesian
filtering of point processes [6]. So, given an ensemble of stochastic stimuli and a family
of possible encoders, we seek the encoder that minimizes the mean squared error of the
Bayesian decoder (filter) in a state estimation task.
We observe that the task of designing an optimal encoder-decoder pair in our setting
is very different from the case often studied within Information Theory [10], where
real-time constraints are absent and solutions are asymptotic in nature, being based
on infinitely increasing block sizes. In the present real-time setting, we are interested
in guaranteeing good real-time performance for finite observation times.
In fact, the
problem studied in this work falls into the category of a decentralized multi-agent
sequential stochastic optimization problem (viewing the encoder and decoder as agents),
the general solution to which is not known [11]. The approach taken here is based on
selecting a decoder using optimal Bayesian decoding assuming a fixed encoder, and then
optimizing the encoder itself.
A central aspect of neural coding is its speed. Neural populations typically
perform computations within less than 50 milliseconds, accounting for the fast responses
characteristic of animals [12, 13]. Most studies of optimal population coding, however,
still resort to the paradigm of time-slots, in which a (mostly static) stimulus is presented
to a network for a given time window, spikes are pooled for each neuron and a rate
code is assumed [3, 4]. Here we follow a different path, focusing on the dynamical
aspect of natural stimuli, and developing the optimal Bayesian filter for a dynamic state
estimation problem (this has been hinted at in [9] and developed for finite-state models
in [1]). In filtering theory, one tries to estimate the value of a certain function of the
system's state, given noisy observations of that system's state in the past.
Drawing from the theory of stochastic dynamics, we present a model for the joint
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
3
dynamics of signal and noise, where the signal is assumed to be a diffusion process and
the noise arises from the Poisson spiking of the neurons. For the subclass of linear
stochastic processes, we find that the mean squared error (MSE) is equal to the average
posterior variance of the filter. This can be shown to be independent of the specific
signal, and we can analyze the marginal dynamics of the variance of the filter. Analyzing
this marginal dynamics, we obtain results regarding the value of the mean squared error
through simulations and in a mean-field approximation, which hold in the equilibrium
as well as in the relaxation period. In spite of the simplifications involved, the mean-
field results are shown to be in very good agreement with the the full Monte Carlo
simulations of the system.
For the linear stochastic processes considered we obtain an interesting relation
for the timescales involved. Specifically, we find that whenever the average interspike
interval is larger than the correlation time of the observed process, the distribution of
possible errors diverges around the upper bound for the error. This implies that the
firing rate of the sensory neurons must exceed a threshold in order to be able to track
the input properly. The threshold is defined by the statistics of the stimulus. This
relation holds exactly for the class of processes considered, and is specially pronounced
in the Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process, where we present a closed-form solution of the full
distribution of the posterior variance. We also provide an exact analysis of the prediction
error which holds for the general class of processes discussed. Furthermore, we show that
for the stimuli considered there is a finite optimal tuning width for the tuning functions
which minimizes the error in the reconstruction of the stimulus. The dependence of this
optimal tuning width as a function of the stimulus properties is discussed in the context
of an ecological theory of sensory processing [14].
Much effort has been devoted to understand how spiking neural networks can
implement operations such as marginalization, optimal inference under uncertainty and
others. The finding that humans and animals combine uncertain cues from separate
senses near-optimally [15, 16, 17] has given a lot of traction to this line of research. We
note that this paper takes a different path. We seek the encoder that saturates the limits
given by the Bayesian optimal decoder. In [18], the authors have considered a similar
problem, but tried to devise a spiking neural network that would optimally decode the
stimulus. Similarly, in [19] a procedure based on divisive normalization was presented
that performs marginalization optimally for similar problems, and was applied to a
filtering problem similar to the one considered here. We, however, focus on the optimal
design of an encoder given an ensemble of stimuli assuming optimal decoding and study
their relation to the statistical structure of the stimulus. This has been studied before
in different settings (e.g. [1, 2, 3, 20]).
We propose that the framework of Bayesian filtering is more suited to study
population coding than the usual time-binning method, as it allows for a natural
inclusion of the time scales of the observed process and of the internal dynamics of the
neurons. We have shown that for a simple model, we find a general relation connecting
the time scales of the population spiking and that of the stimulus observed with the
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
4
error of an ideal observer. This has implications for the optimal tuning width of tuning
functions of neurons. We believe that different strategies for temporal coding in different
sensory systems might be traced to similar arguments, as has been done in [14] for the
limit of slow temporal stimulation.
The main contribution of the present paper is in providing insight, combined with
closed form mathematical expressions, for the reconstruction error of stimuli encoded by
biologically motivated point processes. While precise expressions can be obtained only in
limiting cases, they provide an essential starting point for a theory of optimal encoding-
decoding within a biologically relevant framework, and demonstrate the importance of
adaptive encoding to the neural processing of dynamic stimuli. Note that even in the
simple case of linear processes observed by linear systems (e.g., [21]), it is in general
impossible to obtain closed form expressions for the estimation error, and one usually
resorts to bounds.
1.1. Structure of the Paper
In section 2 we present the framework used. We will derive a number of results on
the Minimum Mean Squared Error (MMSE) for a stimulus reconstruction task with
a Gaussian process observed through Poisson spike trains. A thorough analysis is
presented for both Ornstein-Uhlenbeck processes and for smoother, non-Markovian,
processes. In section 3 we will discuss the application of these results to the study of
optimal population codes. Namely we show the scaling of the optimal tuning width
and its corresponding MMSE as a function of the correlation structure of the process
and the overall firing rate. We finalize by discussing the implications of the presented
framework to the field and future applications of our framework.
2. Reconstructing Dynamic Stimuli Based on Point Process Encoding
The problem of reconstructing dynamic stimuli based on noisy partial observations falls
within the general field of filtering theory (e.g., [21]). Consider a dynamic stimulus x(t),
x ∈ Rn, which is observed through a noisy set of sensors leading to output y(t), y ∈ Rm.
For example, x(t) could represent the position and velocity of a point object, and y(t)
could represent the firing patterns of a set of retinal cells. The objective is to construct
a filter, based only on the observation process, which provides a good estimator for the
unknown value of the stimulus. Formally, denoting by y([0, t]) the set of observations
from time 0 to the present time, we wish to construct an estimator x(y([0, t])) which
is as close as possible (in some precisely defined manner) to x(t). A classic example of
filtering is the case of a stimulus x(t) generated by a noisy linear dynamical system,
and an observer y(t) which is based on a noisy linear projection of the stimulus. The
classic Kalman filter (e.g., [21]) then leads to the optimal reconstruction in the MMSE
sense.
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
5
For a filtering task, the use of an Lp norm as a cost function is a natural choice,
given that we are interested in reconstructing the system's state as precisely as possible.
Here we choose to use the L2 norm as a cost function for our reconstruction task. This
is a natural choice for a filtering task (see [21]) and has been frequently used in studies
of optimal population coding [1, 2, 3]. Another popular cost function for studies of
optimal population coding is the mutual information between the input distribution
and the conditional response distribution [4]. This allows one to find the code that
optimally codes the information contained in the input in its response. Though recent
theoretical advances are sketching out the relationship between information- and MMSE-
optimal codes [22, 23, 24], there seems to be no simple equivalence between these two
cost functions. In Gaussian additive channels, the MMSE is equal to the derivative of
the mutual information between input and output with respect to the signal-to-noise
ratio. Though similar relationships have been derived for Poisson processes, these hold
only for linearly modulated inhomogeneous processes and do not relate directly to the
MMSE [24, 25]. Furthermore, these results have been derived only for single point
processes, not for populations thereof. We therefore choose to work strictly with the
L2 cost function, as this is not only a natural choice for the problem at hand, but also
allows for a number of analytical results.
We consider the case of
linear Gaussian stochastic processes observed by a
population of neurons with unimodal tuning functions. This is analogous to considering
stimuli drawn from a Gaussian process prior, as has been done in [9]. We will have a
prior distribution over the stimulus x(t) given by a Gaussian process with zero mean and
covariance function K(t, t′) = hx(t)x(t′)i, where the angled brackets denote the average
over the ensemble of Gaussian processes.
Rather than considering general Gaussian processes we will focus on a class of
processes which are particularly amenable to analytic investigation. This will allow us
to consider both simple Markov Gaussian processes (the so-called Ornstein-Uhlenbeck
process) and higher order Markov Gaussian processes. We will consider stochastic
processes described by a stochastic differential equation of the form
(cid:18) d
dt
+ γ(cid:19)P
x(t) = η
dW (t)
dt
,
(1)
where W (t) is a scalar Wiener process. We can find the covariance of the process by
calculating the Fourier transform, computing the power spectrum and then reversing
the Fourier transform. We will have
hx(ω)x∗(ω)i =
η2
(γ + 2πiω)P (γ − 2πiω)P .
(2)
211].
[26, p.
spectrum leads to stochastic processes with the so-called Matern
This power
kernel
the distribution over x will converge to
the equilibrium distribution, given by a Gaussian distribution with zero mean
and covariance σ2
These processes can also be written as
multidimensional first-order processes by defining X(t) ≡ (X1(t), X2(t), . . . , XP (t))⊤ =
x = η2/2P γ2P −1.
If unobserved,
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
6
(cid:0)x(t), x(1)(t), . . . , x(P −1)(t)(cid:1)⊤
associated stochastic differential equation
, where x(i)(t) denotes the i-th derivative of of x(t), and its
dX(t) = −ΓX(t)dt + HdW(t),
(3)
where W(t) is a P -dimensional Wiener process. Γ and H are defined in Appendix A.
Note that the process x(t) itself will not in general be Markovian. The process X(t)
of x(t) along with its first P − 1 derivatives will, however, be Markov. This allows
us to treat smooth non-Markov dynamics as the marginal case of a higher-dimensional
Markov stimulus and so to draw from the theory of Markov stochastic processes, which
is very well-established [27].
The spike trains will be modeled by inhomogeneous Poisson processes N m(t),
namely, Poisson processes whose rates are functions of the stochastic process X(t).
More precisely, N m(t) represents the number of times neuron m has spiked since the
beginning of the experiment. Furthermore, we will assume each spike train N i(t) to be
conditionally independent of all others, that is, given a value of the stimulus X(t) the
spiking of each neuron is independent of all others. The function relating the stimulus
X(t) to the rate of the Poisson process is often referred to as a tuning function, and will
be denoted by λm(X(t)). We will consider unimodal tuning function of the form
λm(x(t)) = φ exp(cid:18)−
(x(t) − θm)2
2α2
(cid:19) ,
where θm is the preferred stimulus value of neuron m. Tuning functions of this form
are often found in orientation-selective cells in visual cortex of mammals and in place
cells in the hippocampus [28, 29, 30]. For multi-dimensional stimuli, we can write these
more generally as
λm(X(t)) = φ exp(cid:0)−(X(t) − Θm)⊤A+(X(t) − Θm)/2(cid:1) .
We will prefer this notation as it allows us to derive a general theory which also
holds for multidimensional stimuli. The case of a one-dimensional P -th order process
along with its P − 1 derivatives would be recovered by setting A+
i,j = δ1,iδ1,j/α2 and
Θm = (θm, 0, . . . , 0). While in many cases biological tuning functions are unimodal, we
have chosen to work with Gaussian functions for reasons on analytic tractability.
The likelihood of a spike train {N m([0, t])} is given by (see [31])
L({N m([0, t])}X([0, t])) = exp Xm Z dN m(t) log(λm(X(t))) −Xm Z dt λm(X(t))! .
We have denoted here by {N m([0, t])} the value of all spiking processes N m(s) for any
instant s such that 0 ≤ s ≤ t, and likewise X([0, t]) denotes all values of X(s), for all
s such that 0 ≤ s ≤ t. With this likelihood we can then find the posterior distribution
for X([0, t]) using Bayes' rule,
P (X([0, t]){N m([0, t])}) ∝ L({N m([0, t])}X([0, t]))P (X([0, t])).
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
7
Averaging out the values of X(t) up to but excluding the time t, will give us the time-
dependent Gaussian posterior P (X(t){N m([0, t])}). If the likelihood were Gaussian in
X we could use results from conditional distributions on Gaussian measures to average
over X([0, t)) (for more details, see [9]). This is indeed the case when the tuning functions
are densely packed, as we will see in the following.
Let us then turn to the spiking dynamics of the whole population. Because each
neuron spikes as a Poisson process with rate λm(X(t)), and the processes N m(t) are
conditionally independent when conditioned on X(t), the process N(t) =Pm N m(t) is
also Poisson with rate λ(X(t)) ≡ Pm λm(X(t)). If the neurons' tuning functions are
dense, however, the sum does not depend on X(t) and therefore the overall firing rate
of the population does not depend on the stimulus at all. The rate can be estimated
for equally spaced tuning centers Θm by considering it a Riemann sum [2]. Assuming
the tuning centers Θm are tiled in a regular lattice with spacing ∆Θ along each axis, we
have
λ = φXm
exp(cid:0)−(Θm − X)⊤A+(Θm − X)/2(cid:1) ≈
φ(cid:2)(2π)rank(A) det∗(A)(cid:3)1/2
∆Θn
,
where det∗(A) is the pseudo-determinant of A defined in Appendix B. The assumption
of dense tuning functions is clearly very strong as the number of neurons necessary to
cover an n-dimensional stimulus space grows exponentially with n. Note however, that
the deviation from this approximation is very small when the tuning center spacing is
of the order of the diagonal elements of A, i.e. when the tuning functions have a strong
overlap.
If this assumption is violated we would have to treat the filtering problem
through the stochastic partial differential equation for the probability, as was done in
[6] for general Poisson processes.
Given the assumption of dense tuning functions and due to the prior assumption
about x(t),
and the posterior distribution
P (X(t){N m([0, t])}) will also be Gaussian. Since the dynamics of X(t) is linear, the
Gaussian distribution will be conserved and, in the absence of spikes, the mean µ(t) and
the likelihood becomes Gaussian,
covariance Σ(t) =(cid:10)(X(t) − µ(t))(X(t) − µ(t))⊤(cid:11) will evolve as
dµ(t)
= −Γµ(t),
and
dt
dΣ(t)
dt
= −ΓΣ(t) − Σ(t)Γ⊤ + H 2.
(4a)
(4b)
If a spike from a neuron m occurs at a time t, the posterior distribution of X(t) gets
updated via Bayes' rule. The prior is then given by N (X(t); µ(t), Σ(t)) and the likelihood
is N (X(t); Θm, A). We denote the mean and covariance immediately after the spike at
time t by µ(t+) and Σ(t+). By standard Gaussian properties we obtain
µ(t+) =(cid:0)Σ(t)−1 + A+(cid:1)−1
= µ(t) +(cid:0)Σ(t)−1 + A+(cid:1)−1 A+ (Θm − µ(t))
(Σ(t)−1µ(t) + A+Θm)
(5a)
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
8
(5b)
Σ(t+) =(cid:0)Σ(t)−1 + A+(cid:1)−1
= Σ(t) +(cid:0)Σ(t)−1 + A+(cid:1)−1 A+Σ(t)
This fully determines the optimal Bayesian filter, namely,
it is given by Pt(X) =
N (X; µ(t), Σ(t)), where the evolution of µ(t) and Σ(t) is given by (4a) and (4b) in
the absence of spikes and by (5a) and (5b) whenever there are spikes. It is interesting
to observe that the dynamics of the mean and variance between spikes, given in (4a)
and (4b), is precisely that obtained for the continuous time Kalman filter [21] when
observations are absent. This is not surprising since between spikes we are tracking a
linear dynamical system, as does the Kalman filter.
In order to determine the properties of the optimal encoder, we aim at obtaining
expressions for the mean-squared error of the optimal filter. This gives us a measure
of the best-case performance that can be achieved for a signal reconstruction task from
the observation of the spike train. Specifically, we want a measure of the average
performance over all stimuli and all spike trains. For that, note that because of the
Gaussian nature of the stimulus and the linear dynamics of the prior, the evolution of
the posterior variance does not depend on the spike trains of each neuron, but rather
only on N(t), the total spike count of the population. The average of the posterior
covariance matrix is given by
S(t) =(cid:10)(X(t) − µ(t))(X(t) − µ(t))⊤(cid:11)X,{N m([0,t])} .
Note that the diagonal terms give us the mean squared error on the estimation of every
coordinate of X(t). More specifically, the MMSE in the estimation of x(t) is given by
S11(t). We can simplify this by noting that µ(t) = E(X(t){N m([0, t])}) and evaluating
the average over P (X(t){N m([0, t])}) [2]. We have
S(t) = hΣ(t)i{N m([0,t])} = hΣ(t)iN ([0,t]) ,
where in the last step we have used the fact that the dynamics of Σ(t), and therefore
its average, only depend on the population spike count N(t). Up to the last step,
this derivation is generally valid, though one must take care to consider the marginal
distribution of the observations, averaging out the signal. Note that, although we can
give an account of the temporal evolution of the mean squared error this cannot be
given a biological interpretation in the absence of an experiment to contextualize the
time dependence of the error. However, in the limit of long spike trains, the MSE
will converge to its equilibrium value (see figure 1 and figure 3) and we can study the
equilibrium statistics of Σ(t) to determine the average MSE of the reconstruction task.
We will look at the transition probability for Σ(t) after marginalization over N(t).
Consider the probability P (Σ′, t + dtΣ, t), of the covariance having a value Σ′ at time
t + dt given that at time t the covariance was Σ. For infinitesimal dt, Σ′ is either given
by (4b), or with a probability λ dt there is a jump as specified in (5b), with λ =Pm λm.
This will yield the transition probability
P (Σ′, t + dtΣ, t) = (1 − λ dt)δ(cid:0)Σ′ − Σ − dt(H 2 − ΓΣ − ΣΓT )(cid:1)
+ λ dt δ(cid:0)Σ′ − (Σ−1 + A+)−1(cid:1) .
(6)
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
9
The evolution of the time-dependent probability over the covariance matrices P (Σ, t)
will be given by the Chapman-Kolmogorov equation [27, p.47]
∂P (Σ, t)
∂t
= −∇ [B(Σ)P (Σ, t)]+λC(Σ)P (cid:0)(Σ−1 − A+)−1, t(cid:1)−λP (Σ, t), (7)
where B(Σ) = −ΓΣ − ΣΓ⊤ + H 2. Note that this gives us the MSE(t) through the
average of Σ over the distribution P (Σ, t). The term C(Σ) arises from the integration
of the second Dirac delta function in (6) and is given by C(Σ) = 1/ det(J(Σ)), where
J(Σ) is the Jacobian matrix
J(i,j),(k,l) =
∂(Σ−1 + A+)−1
i,j
∂Σk,l
= (I + A+Σ)−1
k,i (I + ΣA+)−1
j,n
The exact choice of the ordering of the indices is not of importance, as it would only
account for a change in the sign of the determinant in C(Σ), which only enters the
equation through its absolute value. This term is not of great importance, however, as
it will be cancelled when we calculate the evolution of the averages.
We can now formalize what we mean by the equilibrium condition mentioned above.
Note that under the stimulus and noise models proposed the evolution of the distribution
of the error is given by (7). Given some initial condition for P (Σ, t0), the distribution
will evolve and eventually it will reach an equilibrium, such that ∂tP (Σ, t) = 0. We
are interested in this equilibrium regime, as it provides the average performance of the
optimal filter after all transients from the initial conditions have vanished.
The evolution of S(t) = hΣit can be found easily from (7). Using
d
dtZ dΣf (Σ)P (Σ, t) =Z dΣf (Σ)
∂P (Σ, t)
∂t
,
and integrating by parts we obtain
d hΣit
dt
,
(8)
= −Γ hΣit − hΣit Γ⊤ + H 2 + λD(cid:0)Σ−1 + A+(cid:1)−1
A+ΣEt
where hf (Σ)it = R dΣ f (Σ)P (Σ, t). This cannot be treated exactly, though, as the
nonlinear averages on the right hand side are intractable even for simple cases. Similar
relations for the evolution of the average mean and variance of a filter were presented
in [6] as approximations to the true filter (based on discarding higher order moments).
The evolution of the distribution over covariance matrices is thus determined.
However, evaluating the averages is intractable even for the case of dense neurons when
λ is independent of X(t). We will therefore look into three different ways of treating
(7). First, we can simply simulate the population spiking process N(t) as a Poisson
process to obtain samples of P (Σ, t). By averaging over multiple realizations of N(t)
we can estimate the average value of Σ(t) and by monitoring its evolution we can
determine when it has relaxed to the equilibrium. The second possibility is to analyze
(8) in a mean-field approximation, i.e. to simply replace all averages of the form hf (Σ)i
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
10
with f (hΣi), disregarding all fluctuations around the mean. We would then have the
dynamics
A+ hΣ(t)it .
(9)
d hΣit
dt
= −Γ hΣit − hΣit Γ⊤ + H 2 + λ(cid:0)hΣ(t)i−1
t + A+(cid:1)−1
A third possibility is to analyze (7) directly. This leads to a number of interesting
results for the one-dimensional Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process, but the generalization to
higher dimensions is not straightforward. We will proceed by analyzing the case of the
Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process first. Subsequently we will look at the case of smoother
linear stochastic processes, which are produced by Gaussian processes with Matern
kernels [26]. The generalization to linear diffusion processes is straightforward. We
will finalize this section with a discussion of the prediction error for the optimal filter
considered.
2.1. Filtering the Ornstein-Uhlenbeck Process
As is well known, the OU process is the only homogeneous Markov Gaussian process in
one dimension, and is therefore particularly convenient as a starting point for analysis
[27]. When we consider the OU process described by the stochastic differential equation
dx(t) = −γx(t)dt + η dW (t),
the analysis we presented above is greatly simplified. The evolution of the posterior
variance s is then given simply by
d hsit
dt
= −2γ hsit + η2 − λ(cid:28) s2
α2 + s(cid:29)t
.
(10)
We will denote the one-dimensional variance by s, reserving Σ for the multidimensional
covariance matrix. In the case of the OU process we can give a more complete account
of the distribution of the errors for the filter. For the one-dimensional case (7) simplifies
to
∂P (s, t)
∂t
=
∂
∂s(cid:2)(2γs − η2)P (s, t)(cid:3)+λ(cid:18) α2
Clearly P (s, t) = 0, ∀s < 0. In the equilibrium we will have
P (cid:18) α2s
α2 − s
, t(cid:19)−λP (s, t).(11)
−
d
ds(cid:2)(2γs − η2)P (s)(cid:3) = λ(cid:18) α2
α2 − s(cid:19)2
α2 − s(cid:19) − λP (s).
(12)
This is a delayed-differential equation with nonlinear delays in s. To see this, note
that for every s such that 0 < s < α2, we have α2s/(α2 − s) > s. For s > α2, this
term becomes meaningless, as the posterior variance will always fall below α2 after the
observation of a spike. This means, that for any s > 0, the derivative of P (s) is a
function of P (s) and P (α2s/(α2 − s)). Defining the function j(s) = α2s/(α2 + s) we
can define intervals I0 = [j(s0), s0), I1 = [j2(s0), j(s0)), . . . with s0 = η2/2γ. We will
then have that given the solution of P (s) on In, the solution in In+1 is the solution
of a simple inhomogeneous ordinary differential equation with a continuity condition
α2 − s(cid:19)2
P (cid:18) α2s
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
11
on jn(s0). This can be simply solved through numerical integration schemes. We will
show in Appendix C that in the equilibrium P (s > η2/2γ) = 0. We therefore define the
boundary conditions as Peq(s) = 0, ∀s > η2/2γ. This will imply that the jump term in
(12) will be absent whenever the jump originates in the domain s > η2/2γ. This is the
case when s ∈ I0. For these values of s we arrive at
This is solved by
d
ds(cid:2)(2γs − η2)Peq(s)(cid:3) − λPeq(s) = 0.
Peq(s) = C(cid:18) η2
− s(cid:19)
s ∈ I0.
λ
2γ −1
2γ
,
(13)
(14)
We can use this solution as a boundary condition to solve (12) as a delayed-differential
equation with variable delays, but an analytical solution is not available for the
subsequent intervals.
In figure 2 we present the numerical solution of (12) alongside
with histograms from simulations. Note that the solution in (14) is exact for the interval
I0 and is therefore in significant agreement with the simulations.
In the subsequent
intervals numerical errors degrade the precision of the solution. Especially when α is
very large the intervals In will get smaller, and the numerical integration of (12) will
become less stable.
This solution can also be obtained in the limit of very small firing rates, that is
when λ ≪ 2γ. We can then assume that between two spikes the variance has already
relaxed to its free equilibrium value s0. A spike at time ts will then take the variance
to s′ = j(s0). The evolution will then be given by
s(t) = e−2γ(t−ts)s′ + s0(1 − e−2γ(t−ts )),
which can be inverted into
t − ts = −
1
2γ
log(cid:18)s0 − s(t)
s0 − s′ (cid:19) .
We can then write the distribution over s as a distribution over interspike intervals
τ = t − ts. We know the probability distribution over τ is given by an exponential with
coefficient λ. Changing the variables, we will have
P (s) = P (τ )(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
dτ
ds(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
∝ e−λτ e2γτ .
Which in turn gives us (14) for the equilibrium distribution of s. Note that this
derivation only holds in the limit of λ ≪ 2γ, while the deduction above for the interval
[s′, s0) holds irregardless of the value of the parameters. The mentioned limit is very
useful in the multidimensional case, however.
In the mean-field approximation for the equilibrium condition we will have
ds
dt
= −2γs + η2 − λ
s2
α2 + s
.
(15)
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
12
Figure 1: General setup of the inference task. The upper panel shows the true stimulus
or signal x(t) in red solid line, the filtered posterior mean in the blue dotted line and
the shading represents the posterior probability distribution. The lower panel shows the
evolution of the posterior variance. The red dotted line gives the sample variance of the
sample in the upper panel, the solid black line shows an average over 100 realizations
and the blue line gives the evolution of the mean-field equation with the same initial
conditions.
This gives a remarkably good account of the equilibrium properties of the system, as is
show in figure 1. Surprisingly, the mean-field equation gives a very good account of the
transient behavior of the error as well as of the equilibrium.
We can also derive a simple Gaussian approximation for the rescaled inverse
variance z = η2/(γs). Note that the distribution of the inverse variance at the
equilibrium is given by
−
d
dz
[γz(2 − z)Peq(z)] + λPeq(z −
η2
γα2 ) − λPeq(z) = 0.
(16)
In the limit where η2/γα2 ≪ z we can Taylor expand the second term to second order.
In this regime we will have very broad tuning functions and each individual spike will
have little effect. This can be thought of as a diffusion limit. Further linearizing
the drift term around its equilibrium we will obtain the Van Kampen expansion for
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
α = 1.0, φ = 1.0
0.2
0.3
s
α = 100.0, φ = 1.0
0.4
0.5
8
6
)
s
(
P
4
2
0
0.1
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
)
s
(
P
0
0.496
0.497
0.498
0.499
0.5
0.501
s
80
60
)
s
(
P
40
20
0
0
60
40
20
0
0
)
s
(
P
13
α = 0.4, φ = 1.0
Simulated Histogram
Van Kampen
Numeric Integ. of DDE
0.1
0.2
s
0.3
0.4
0.5
α = 1.0, φ = 100.0
0.1
0.2
s
0.3
0.4
0.5
Figure 2: Different treatments of the distribution of the variance for different sets
of parameters of the encoder for a first-order OU stimulus. The red line shows the
histogram obtained through simulations. The blue line shows the numerical integration
of (12) using the mentioned boundary condition. The black line shows the Van Kampen
expansion given in the text. Note that the numerical integration of (12) provides a very
good account of the simulated histogram, except for very large values of α, when the
integration becomes unstable. The Van Kampen approximation in turn provides a good
account for the limit of large firing rates, for large α as well as for large φ.
the problem [27].
It will
lead to a Fokker-Planck equation whose solution is the
Gaussian distribution Pz(z) = N (cid:16)1 + [1 + λδ/γ]1/2 , λδ2 [4γ]−1 [1 + λδ/γ]−1/2(cid:17). By
writing P (s) = Pz(η2/γs)η2/γs2 we can then recover the distribution over the variances.
These results are all compared in figure 2.
2.2. Filtering Smooth Processes
In section 2.1 we considered Markovian Gaussian processes. However, within an
ecologically oriented setting,
it is often more natural to assume smooth priors [9].
Since in general smooth priors lead to non-Markovian processes, which are very hard
to deal with mathematically, we look at a special case of a smooth non-Markovian
prior. Specifically, we will look at the multidimensional embedding X(t) of the smooth
processes given by (3). We choose to study these processes as they allow us to consider
smooth stochastic processes with the same set of parameters as were used to consider the
OU process. Figure 3 shows the general inference framework for higher-order smooth
processes.
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
14
Figure 3: Inference task for the P = 2 process. The upper panel shows the true stimulus
or signal x(t) in red solid line, the filtered posterior mean in the blue dotted line and
the shading represents the posterior probability distribution. The lower panel shows the
evolution of the posterior variance. The red dotted line gives the sample variance of the
sample in the upper panel, the solid black line shows an average over 100 realizations
and the blue line gives the evolution of the mean-field equation with the same initial
conditions.
Taking the observation matrix Aij = δ1,iδ1,jα2 with pseudo-inverse A+ = δ1,iδ1,j/α2,
the form of A will allow us to somewhat simplify equation (5b) and we can write a
simple mean-field equation for the evolution of hΣit = ¯Σ(t). We have in the mean-field
approximation
d ¯Σ(t)
dt
= −Γ ¯Σ(t) − ¯Σ(t)Γ⊤ + H 2 − λ
¯Σ(t)A+ ¯Σ(t)
1 + ¯Σ(t)1,1/α2
.
(17)
This equation still describes the average performance of the Bayesian filter remarkably
well, not only in the equilibrium phase but also in the transient period (see figure 3).
Note that the sole contributor to the nonlinearity in the equation above is the first
column of the covariance matrix. Given ¯Σ1,j solving for the remaining elements of the
matrix is a matter of linear algebra.
The argument made in Appendix C cannot be rigorously be made here, as we have
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
15
Σ evolving in a high dimensional space with nonlinear jumps. In principle, one could
map out a subspace such that P (Σ, t) is zero outside of it, and then proceed to locate
a set of Σ such that (Σ−1 − A+)−1 falls in it, and then seek to solve equation (7) in
that domain. This could, in principle, be made rigorous, but as we will see below, this
approach is not as useful when considering smoother processes. To see why, let us study
the small λ limit as we did in the OU process. Assuming λ ≪ ∇ · B, we can assume that
the covariance matrix has nearly relaxed to its equilibrium value Σ0 every time there is
a spike. Whenever there is a spike the covariance matrix jumps to Σ′ = (Σ−1
0 + A+)−1.
The free evolution is then given by
Σ(t) = e−(t−t0)ΓΣ′e−(t−t0)Γ⊤
Changing variables to τ = t − t0 we have
Σ(τ ) = e−τ ΓΣ′e−τ Γ⊤
+Z t
t0
+Z τ
0
ds e−(t−s)ΓH 2e−(t−s)Γ⊤
.
ds e−sΓH 2e−sΓ⊤
.
Clearly there is no simple solution to these matrix equations as there is for the OU
case, but we can still use the same approach as before numerically. We can assume an
unknown function of Σ that gives us the time since the spike τ (Σ). We can then proceed
as before and evaluate the marginal distributions. We would have for Σ1,1
P (Σ11) =
P (τ (Σ11))
∝
(cid:12)(cid:12)
dΣ11
dτ (cid:12)(cid:12)
e−λτ
dΣ11
.
dτ (cid:12)(cid:12)
(cid:12)(cid:12)
When we analyzed the analog of this relation for the OU process we could find a simple
correspondence between the divergence of the distribution around the equilibrium value
of the variance and the parameters λ and γ. Though we can argue similarly in this
case, note that immediately after the jump, we have dΣ11/dτ = Σ′
12 = 0 which results
itself in a divergence in the distribution in this approximation. So, even in the limit
λ ≪ ∇ · B, there is always some probability mass concentrated around the value Σ′, so
the divergence argument is not so strong for smoother processes. This can be seen in
figure 4.
2.3. Prediction Error
The prediction error can easily be derived as a function of the filtering error in this
framework. We have the predictive probability P (Xt+δ{N m([0, t])}), with δ > 0. The
average prediction error would simply be the deviation of Xt+δ from the estimator
µ(t + δ). The prediction error is then
P(δ) =(cid:10)(X(t + δ) − µ(t + δ))(X(t + δ) − µ(t + δ))⊤(cid:11)X,{N m([0,t])} .
This gives us the matrix S(t) when δ = 0. For δ > 0 we have the prediction error
matrix. Note that given a value of X(t) and a realization of the Wiener process dW(s)
e−(t+δ−s)ΓHdW(s) + e−δΓX(t). Clearly,
(18)
for t ≤ s ≤ t + δ, we have X(t + δ) = R t+δ
t
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
16
Figure 4: The small firing rate approximation provides a very good account of the
distribution of the variance of the observed process Σ11.
conditioning on X(t) the above average is only over the Wiener process between t and
t + δ. The estimator µ(t + δ) is also given by µ(t + δ) = e−δΓµ(t) in the absence of spikes.
The prediction error matrix will then be given by
P(δ) = (cid:28)(Z t+δ
(Z t+δ
t
t
e−(t+δ−s)ΓHdW(s) + e−δΓX(t) − e−δΓµ(t))×
e−(t+δ−u)ΓHdW(u) + e−δΓX(t) − e−δΓµ(t))⊤(cid:29)X,{N m([0,t])}
.(19)
Since e−(t+δ−u)ΓH is non-anticipating and does not depend on X(t) or N m(t), we have
that (see [27])
(cid:28)Z t+δ
t
e−(t+δ−u)ΓHdW(u)Z t+δ
t
(e−(t+δ−s)ΓHdW(s))⊤(cid:29) =Z t+δ
t
and therefore, changing variables,
e−(t+δ−u)ΓH 2e−(t+δ−u)Γ⊤
du
P(δ) = e−δΓP(0)e−δΓ⊤
e−sΓH 2e−sΓ⊤
ds.
(20)
This is the usual relation for the evolution of the variance of linear stochastic processes,
and it shows us that the prediction error is a simple function of the filtering error. This
+Z δ
0
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
17
Figure 5: The evolution of the average prediction error P(δ) is completely determined
by the filtering error P(0). The blue line shows the prediction error obtained from the
optimal filter in simulations, whereas the green line shows the evolution of the prediction
error according to (20) with the initial condition given by the average filtering error
obtained in the simulations. The small discrepance between both curves is due to finite
sample size effects.
is also a consequence of the Markov nature of the posterior probability. Taking a non-
Markov prior process would result in a posterior probability whose parameters could
not be described by a set of ordinary differential equations.
In figure 5 we show the comparison between the theoretical result in (20) and
simulation results for the prediction error. We can see that the prediction error is very
well described by the derived equation.
3. Optimal Population Coding
We can now apply the results from the previous section to study the optimal coding
strategies for neurons in the dynamic case. The study of bell-shaped and more
specifically Gaussian tuning curves has been frequently discussed in the literature
[32, 20, 2, 3]. Our framework treats the case of densely packed Gaussian tuning functions
for stochastic dynamic stimuli. We can study the performance of the tuning functions
by mapping the minimal mean squared error for an encoder given by a certain tuning
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
18
function. In our case, given the sensory neurons, specified by their preferred stimuli Θm,
the tuning functions are specified by the maximal firing rate φ and the tuning width α.
figure 6 shows a colormap of the MMSE for an Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process for a
range of values of α and φ. There are some clear trends to be observed. First, we note
that for any given value of α, increasing the maximal firing rate φ leads, not surprisingly,
to a decrease in the MMSE. When the value of φ tends to zero, the MMSE tends to
the equilibrium variance of the observed process, which is expected, as in the absence
of spikes, the best estimate of the stimulus is given by the equilibrium distribution of
the OU process. A second interesting observation is that for any given fixed value of φ
there is a finite value of α which minimizes the MMSE. This is in accord with findings in
[2, 3, 20], which also report that the optimal tuning width is a finite value, as well as with
experimental data [28, 33]. This can be intuitively understood by noting that when we
decrease the tuning width keeping φ constant, we decrease the population's firing rate λ,
and eventually, for very sharp tuning functions, we will have a vanishingly small number
of spikes. On the other hand, increasing the width α will lead to a gain in information
through more spikes but eventually these spikes become so uninformative that there is
no more advantage from increasing α, as these barely give us more information than is
already present in the equilibrium distribution. The right panel of figure 6 shows the
MMSE as a function of α for some values of φ.
The situation is very similar when we consider higher-order processes. Although
the decay of the posterior covariance to its equilibrium value follows a more convoluted
dynamics, the argument relating α and the improvement in the reconstruction still holds.
Figure 7 shows the analog of figure 6 for the process with P = 2. We can see that the
general structure of the color plot is very similar. One important difference though, is
that for the same firing rate, we are able to obtain a larger improvement in the MMSE,
relative to the equilibrium variance of the process. This is clear in the right panel of
figure 7. This is to be expected, as the higher-order processes have more continuity
constraints and are therefore more predictable.
3.1. Ecological Analysis of the Optimal Code
We will now look at how the optimal value of α depends on the parameters of the process.
We can, fixing φ, γ and η find the optimal value of α that minimizes the MMSE. This will
give us a mapping of how the optimal tuning width depends on the different parameters
of the stimulus. We consider the case of the second-order Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process
(P = 2). Note that changing γ also influences the signal variance, as the equilibrium
variance of the stimulus is given by σ2
x = η2/4γ3. To better separate these influences
of the timescale and variance of the stimulus, we chose to look at the process given by
an OU process with diffusion coefficient η′ = ηγ3/2 resulting in a equilibrium variance
of σ2
In that way we can better analyze the influence of the timescale and
intensity of the covariance of the stimulus.
x = η2/4.
This analysis is shown in figure 8 for the second-order OU process. The timescale
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
19
Figure 6: MMSE landscape as a function of the encoder's tuning width α and maximal
firing rate φ for the one-dimensional OU process. For simplicity we show the case where
γ = η = 1. When either parameters are very near 0, the MMSE is equal to the stimulus'
equilibrium variance. For fixed values of φ we observe the existence of a finite optimal
tuning width, as is shown in the right panel.
of the process strongly influences the optimal tuning width as can be seen in the figure.
With an increase in γ the optimal tuning width increases. This is in accord with the
finding in [3], where it was reported that for static stimuli a larger decoding window
leads to a narrower optimal tuning width. This can be cast into our framework by
making an analogy between the decoding time window and the characteristic time of
the decay of the autocorrelation of the observed process. A very large correlation time
means a very slowly changing process, which needs less spikes and therefore allows for
narrower tuning widths. This can be also understood by referring to the solution for the
error distribution of the OU process given by (14). Smaller values of γ allow for a good
reconstruction of the stimulus with less spikes. An increase in the stimulus variance
σ2
x leads to an increase in the optimal tuning width. Meanwhile, an increase in the
maximal firing width of each neuron results in a decrease of the optimal tuning width,
as is expected. Increasing the height of each tuning function allows the tuning functions
to sharpen without decreasing the overall firing rate of the population.
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
20
Figure 7: MMSE landscape as a function of the encoder's tuning width α and maximal
firing rate φ for the second-order OU process. Again, we show the case where γ = η = 1.
When either parameters are very near 0, the MMSE is equal to the stimulus' equilibrium
variance. For fixed values of φ we observe the existence of a finite optimal tuning width,
as is shown in the right panel.
An interesting perspective on the coding-decoding problem we are studying can be
obtained from rate-distortion theory [34], where one seeks the optimal tradeoff between
coding rate and reconstruction error (distortion). The celebrated rate-distortion curve
provides the smallest rate for which a given level of distortion can be achieved (usually
asymptotically). We study the analog of a rate-distortion curve in our case. The rate is
given by the average population firing rate λ while the distortion would be the minimal
mean squared error. In figure 9 we show a plot of the MMSE of the optimal encoder
against the firing rate of the optimal code for given values of φ, γ and η. Interestingly,
the rate-distortion curve is independent of the value of η. The dependence in γ is
as expected. For smaller values of γ (i.e., for longer correlation times), the error
decays faster with the population firing rate. Meanwhile, larger values of γ (i.e., shorter
correlation times), lead to a slower decay in the distortion as a function of the firing
rate.
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
21
0.5
0.45
0.4
0.35
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
t
p
o
α
a
φ=0.5
φ=1.0
φ=5.0
0.8
b
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.5
φ=0.5
φ=1.0
φ=5.0
c
γ=0.5
γ=1.0
γ=5.0
0.45
0.4
0.35
0.3
0.05
0
0.5
1
γ
1.5
2
0
0
0.5
σ
x
1
0.25
0
0.5
1
φ
1.5
2
Figure 8: Dependence of the optimal tuning width on the parameters of the stimulus
and encoder for the P = 2 process. Panel a shows the optimal tuning width as a
function of the forcing parameter γ which is the inverse of the characteristic timescale
of the stimulus for three different values of the maximal firing rate φ. Panel b shows the
optimal tuning width as a function of the equilibrium standard deviation of the stimulus
for the same values of φ. Panel c shows the optimal tuning width as a function of the
maximal firing rate of the encoding neurons for three values of the inverse time constant
γ.
3.2. Comparison to Previous Research
The existence of an optimal finite tuning width for unimodal tuning curves has been
repeatedly determined in the literature. This has been found to be the case with the
mutual information as objective function [7] as well as with the reconstruction error as an
objective function [20, 3, 2, 35]. Our findings on the optimal tuning width as a function
of the correlation time of the observed process, summarized in figure 8, generalize the
findings in [3] and in [2] for dynamic processes. Namely, it was established that longer
integration times lead to narrower optimal tuning widths. In our case, longer integration
times correspond to longer correlation times and therefore smaller values of γ. We have
found that for smaller values of γ, i.e. for longer correlation times, the optimal tuning
width decreases, as would be expected. Also, as was found in [2], we have established
that noisier prior processes lead to broader optimal tuning widths (see figure 8). These
results seem to hold in a fairly general set of conditions and this indicates that the
tradeoff between firing rate and accuracy is central to the coding strategies in the nervous
system.
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
22
γ=0.5
γ=1.0
γ=2.0
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
/
2 x
σ
E
S
M
M
0
0
2
4
6
8
10
Firing Rate λ
12
14
16
18
Figure 9: Rate distortion curve of the optimal encoding scheme for the second-order
OU process.
4. Discussion
The temporal aspect of neural coding has often been neglected in studies of optimal
population coding. A framework for the use of filtering in neural coding had been
proposed in [9], but even there the offline paradigm was favored, and most studies
either bypass the issue of time completely [4] or resort to time-binning to address the
temporal aspects [3, 36]. We have extended the filtering theory presented in [1, 2] for
finite-state Markov processes and static processes, where the whole spike train is used
for decoding and, using a model of the dynamics of the stimulus, we have addressed the
decay of the information as well.
Our framework generalizes a number of findings from previous studies. The finding
from [3] and [2] that the reconstruction error decays with the length of the decoding
time-window is here framed in terms of the correlation time of the stimulus. We also find
the same relation between the optimal tuning width for bell-shaped tuning functions
and the correlation time as had been found for the tuning width as a function of the
decoding time.
Another advantage of our treatment is that it allows us to study more complex
aspects of temporal correlation than just the length of the decoding window. By
considering a class of higher-order stochastic processes, we can address different temporal
correlation structures. This had been also proposed in [9], but not explored any deeper.
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
23
In that spirit, we have established that smoother processes allow for a more efficient
coding strategy with the same firing rate in the sensory layer. The complexity of the
process results in a higher cost in the decoding of the spike train, however, implying that
although smooth processes allow for very efficient reconstruction strategies, they will
require a more complex decoding strategy. In [37], a decoding strategy using recoding
of spikes for RBF processes had been suggested. The approach taken in [1] is to encode
the dynamics of the process explicitly into the recurrent connections of the decoding
network, which would be straightforward to generalize for smooth processes, but would
imply that the number of decoding neurons scales with the order of the process. Clearly,
biological systems are not concerned with the degree of continuity, and the model of the
temporal structure of the world should be adapted to the (biological and evolutionary)
experience of the natural environment. This does, however, suggest a tradeoff between
the effort spent in optimally coding a stimulus and the effort spent in decoding it.
Our approach allows for a more flexible and structured way of dealing with the
temporal aspects in the neural code. The generalization of the filtering scheme for
more complex neuron models such as generalized linear models is relatively simple,
although the assumption of dense tuning functions clearly cannot hold then and the
solution of the filtering problem will not be Gaussian anymore. One can still consider
a Gaussian approximation to it, as has been done in [38], or resort to particle filter
approximations [39]. One other interesting direction for further research is to develop
filtering approaches to biologically inspired neuron models, such as leaky-integrate-and-
fire models. The hurdles in this case are the same, the Gaussian assumption will not hold
and we have to work with approximations. However, through a systematic treatment of
the resulting problems, more insights might be gained into the temporal aspects of the
neural code.
5. Acknowledgements
The work of A.S. was supported by the DFG Research Training Group GRK 1589/1.
The work of R.M. was ...
We kindly thank...
6. References
[1] Omer Bobrowski, Ron Meir, and Yonina C Eldar. Bayesian filtering in spiking neural networks:
noise, adaptation, and multisensory integration. Neural computation, 21(5):1277 -- 320, May 2009.
[2] Steve Yaeli and Ron Meir. Error-based analysis of optimal tuning functions explains phenomena
observed in sensory neurons. Frontiers in computational neuroscience, 4(October):16, 2010.
[3] Philipp Berens, Alexander S Ecker, Sebastian Gerwinn, Andreas S Tolias, and Matthias Bethge.
Reassessing optimal neural population codes with neurometric functions. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 108(11):4423 -- 8, March 2011.
[4] Gasper Tkacik, Jason S Prentice, Vijay Balasubramanian, and Elad Schneidman. Optimal
population coding by noisy spiking neurons. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
of the United States of America, 107(32):14419 -- 24, August 2010.
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
24
[5] Christian P. Robert.
The Bayesian Choice: From Decision-Theoretical Foundations to
Computational Implementation. Springer, New York, NY, 2nd edition, 2007.
[6] Donald L Snyder. Filtering and detection for doubly stochastic Poisson processes.
IEEE
Transactions on Information Theory, 18(1):91 -- 102, January 1972.
[7] Nicolas Brunel and JP Nadal. Mutual information, Fisher information, and population coding.
Neural Computation, 10(7), 1998.
[8] Pascal Vincent, Hugo Larochelle, Yoshua Bengio, and Pierre-Antoine Manzagol. Extracting and
composing robust features with denoising autoencoders. Proceedings of the 25th international
conference on Machine learning - ICML '08, pages 1096 -- 1103, 2008.
[9] Quentin J M Huys, Richard S Zemel, Rama Natarajan, and Peter Dayan. Fast population coding.
Neural Computation, 19(2):404 -- 441, 2007.
[10] Claude E. Shannon. The mathematical theory of communication. 1963. Bell System Technical
Journal, 27:379 -- 423 and 623 -- 656, 1948.
[11] Aditya Mahajan and Demosthenis Teneketzis.
real-time
communication systems. IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, 55(11):5317 -- 5338, 2009.
[12] Terrence R Stanford, Swetha Shankar, Dino P Massoglia, M Gabriela Costello, and Emilio Salinas.
Perceptual decision making in less than 30 milliseconds. Nature neuroscience, 13(3):379 -- 85,
March 2010.
Optimal design of
sequential
[13] Simon Thorpe, Denis Fize, and Catherine Marlot. Speed of processing in the human visual system.
Nature, 381(6):520 -- 522, 1996.
[14] Joseph J Atick. Could information theory provide an ecological theory of sensory processing?
Network: Computation in neural systems, 3(2):213 -- 251, January 1992.
[15] Marc O Ernst and Martin S Banks. Humans integrate visual and haptic information in a
statistically optimal fashion. Nature, 415(6870):429 -- 33, January 2002.
[16] David C Knill and Alexandre Pouget. The Bayesian brain: the role of uncertainty in neural coding
and computation. Trends in neurosciences, 27(12):712 -- 9, December 2004.
[17] Timm Lochmann and Sophie Deneve. Neural processing as causal inference. Current opinion in
neurobiology, 21(5):774 -- 81, October 2011.
[18] Martin Boerlin and Sophie Den`eve. Spike-based population coding and working memory. PLoS
computational biology, 7(2):e1001080, February 2011.
[19] Jeffrey Beck, Vikranth R Bejjanki, and Alexandre Pouget.
Insights from a simple expression
for linear fisher information in a recurrently connected population of spiking neurons. Neural
computation, 23(6):1484 -- 502, June 2011.
[20] Matthias Bethge, David Rotermund, and Klaus R Pawelzik. Optimal short-term population
coding: When Fisher information fails. Neural Computation, 14(10):2317 -- 2351, 2002.
[21] Brian D O Anderson and John B Moore. Optimal filtering, volume 11. Prentice-hall, Englewood
Cliffs, NJ, 1979.
[22] DP Palomar and Sergio Verd´u. Representation of mutual information via input estimates. IEEE
Transactions on Information Theory, 53(2):453 -- 470, 2007.
[23] N Merhav. Optimum estimation via gradients of partition functions and information measures:
a statistical-mechanical perspective. Information Theory, IEEE Transactions on, 57(6):3887 --
3898, 2011.
[24] Dongning Guo, S Shamai, and Sergio Verd´u. Mutual information and conditional mean estimation
in Poisson channels. IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, 54(5):1837 -- 1849, 2008.
[25] Rami Atar and Tsachy Weissman. Mutual information, relative entropy, and estimation in the
Poisson channel. 2011 IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory Proceedings,
pages 708 -- 712, July 2011.
[26] Carl Edward Rasmussen and Christopher K. I. Williams. Gaussian Processes for Machine
Learning. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1st edition, 2005.
[27] Crispin W Gardiner. Handbook of Stochastic Methods: for Physics, Chemistry and the Natural
Sciences, volume Vol. 13 of Series in synergetics. Springer, 2004.
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
25
[28] Andrea Benucci, Dario L Ringach, and Matteo Carandini. Coding of stimulus sequences by
population responses in visual cortex. Nature neuroscience, 12(10):1317 -- 24, October 2009.
[29] John O'Keefe and Jonathan Dostrovsky. The hippocampus as a spatial map . Preliminary evidence
from unit activity in the freely-moving rat. Brain Research, 34:171 -- 175, 1971.
[30] James J Knierim, Hemant S Kudrimoti, and Bruce L McNaughton. Place cells, head direction
cells, and the learning of landmark stability. The Journal of Neuroscience, 15(3):1648 -- 1659,
1995.
[31] Donald L Snyder and Michael I Miller. Random Point Processes in Time and Space. Springer-
Verlag, 1991.
[32] Kechen Zhang and TJ Terrence J. Sejnowski. Neuronal tuning: To sharpen or broaden? Neural
Computation, 11(1):75 -- 84, 1999.
[33] Yoram Gutfreund and Eric I Knudsen. Adaptation in the auditory space map of the barn owl.
Journal of Neurophysiology, 96(2):813 -- 25, 2006.
[34] Thomas M Cover and Joy A Thomas. Elements of Information Theory, volume 6 of Wiley Series
in Telecommunications. Wiley, 1991.
[35] Alex Susemihl, Ron Meir, and Manfred Opper. Analytical Results for the Error in Filtering of
Gaussian Processes.
In J. Shawe-Taylor, R. S. Zemel, P. Bartlett, F.C.N. Pereira, and K.Q.
Weinberger, editors, Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, pages 2303 -- 2311,
2011.
[36] Sebastian Gerwinn, Jakob Macke, and Matthias Bethge. Bayesian Population Decoding of Spiking
Neurons. Frontiers in computational neuroscience, 3(October):14, 2009.
[37] Rama Natarajan, Quentin J M QJM Huys, Peter Dayan, and Richard S RS Zemel. Encoding and
Decoding Spikes for Dynamic Stimuli. Neural computation, 20(9):1 -- 36, 2008.
[38] Jean-Pascal Pfister, Peter Dayan, and M´at´e Lengyel. Synapses with short-term plasticity are
optimal estimators of presynaptic membrane potentials. Nature neuroscience, 13(10):1271 -- 5,
October 2010.
[39] Dan Crisan and Boris Rozovskii. The Oxford Handbook of Nonlinear Filtering. Oxford University
Press, Oxford, 2011.
Appendix A. Definition of Γ and H
To obtain the process defined in (1) we define
Γi,j = −δi+1,j + δP,i(cid:18) P
j − 1(cid:19)γP −j+1, and Hi,j = δi,P δj,P η.
Appendix B. Definition of the Pseudo-determinant
The pseudo-determinant of a square n × n matrix A is given by
det∗(A) = lim
α→0
det(A + αI)
αn−rank(A)
.
For positive semi-definite matrices as are used in the text, the pseudo-determinant is
the product of all non-zero eigenvalues.
Dynamic State Estimation from Poisson Spike Trains
26
Appendix C. Boundary Conditions for the Differential
Chapman-Kolmogorov Equation
We want to show that in the equilibrium P (s)eq = 0, ∀s > η2/2s. We will proceed by
cases. If α2 < η2/2γ, we have that the jump term will be absent of (11) for s > η2/2s
and we will have
∂P (s, t)
∂t
=
∂
∂s(cid:0)(2γs − η2)P (s, t)(cid:1) − λP (s, t).
It is easy to see that given a solution of equation
∂P ∗(s, t)
∂t
=
∂
∂s(cid:0)(2γs − η2)P ∗(s, t)(cid:1)
with some initial condition P ∗(s, t0) = P0(s), P (s, t) = e−λ(t−t0)P ∗(s, t) is a solution of
the first equation with the same initial condition. Therefore P (s, t) < P ∗(s, t), t > t0.
But P ∗(s, t) is the solution of the Liouville equation for the system s = −2γs + η2.
Namely, as t → ∞, P ∗(s, t) → δ(s − η2/2γ). Therefore, ∀s > η2/2γ, P (s, t) → 0, as
t → ∞.
If α2 > η2/2γ, we first proceed in the same manner, but taking s > α2 and imposing
an absorbing boundary condition at s = α2. Thus we show that P (s, t)eq = 0, ∀s > α2.
We can then subsequently apply the same argument for the intervals [jn(α2), jn−1(α2)],
as long as jn(α2) > η2/2γ. Finally, we use the same argument for [η2/2γ, jm(α2)], where
m is the highest integer such that jm(α2) > η2/2γ. This shows our desired result.
|
1103.2070 | 1 | 1103 | 2011-03-10T16:23:58 | The collective brain is critical | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cond-mat.dis-nn",
"physics.bio-ph"
] | The unique dynamical features of the critical state endow the brain with properties which are fundamental for adaptive behavior. This proposal, put forward with Per Bak several years ago, is now supported by a wide body of empirical evidence at different scales demonstrating that the spatiotemporal brain dynamics exhibits key signatures of critical dynamics previously recognized in other complex systems. The rationale behind this program is discussed in these notes, followed by an account of the most recent results, together with a discussion of the physiological significance of these ideas. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
The collective brain is critical
1Departamento de F´ısica, Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales, Universidad de Buenos Aires,
Enzo Tagliazucchi1& Dante R. Chialvo2,3,4
Argentina. 2Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cient´ıficas y Tecnol´ogicas (CONICET),
Buenos Aires, Argentina. 3Facultad de Ciencias M´edicas, Universidad Nacional de Rosario,
Rosario, Argentina. 4David Geffen School of Medicine, UCLA, Los Angeles, CA. USA.
The unique dynamical features of the critical state can endow the brain with properties which
are fundamental for adaptive behavior. This proposal, put forward with Per Bak several years ago,
is now supported by a wide body of empirical evidence at different scales demonstrating that the
spatiotemporal brain dynamics exhibits key signatures of critical dynamics previously recognized in
other complex systems. The rationale behind this program is discussed in these notes, followed by
an account of the most recent results, together with a discussion of the physiological significance of
these ideas.
I.
INTRODUCTION:
Throughout the years, brain theory incarnated in various forms following contemporaneous technology. As expressed
by Braitenberg [12]: ...Fascinating aspects of the latest technology are always creeping into science and being turned
into subconscious motives for theory. For brain science, in the nineteenth century it was optics, with its idea of
projection, and in the twentieth century it was radio engineering, with its logical circuits...".
In the nineties, the
fundamental concepts behind the physics of complex systems, motivated us to work on ideas that now seem almost
obvious: 1) the mind is a collective property emerging from the interaction of billions of agents; 2) animate behavior
(human or otherwise) is inherently complex; 3) complexity and criticality are inseparable concepts. These points
were not chosen arbitrarily, but derived, as discussed at length here, from considering the dynamics of systems near
the critical point of a order-disorder phase transition. Simply put, this view considered the brain as just another
dynamical system at criticality, knowingly non unique.
The brain seen as a dynamical object as discussed in these notes is grounded on accessible empirical evidence: as
brain activity unfolds in time at all spatial scales, different patterns evolve. Proper measurements provide quantita-
tive information regarding these patterns (for example, neuron spike trains, local field potentials, metabolic signals,
behavioral measures, etc). The question is whether is it possible to explain all these results from a single fundamental
principle, as it is the tradition in physics. And, in case the answer is affirmative, what does this unified explanation
of brain activity implies about goal oriented behavior? We will submit that, to a large extent, the problem of the
dynamical regime at which the brain operates it is already solved in the context of critical phenomena and phase tran-
sitions. Indeed several fundamental aspects of brain phenomenology have an intriguing counterpart with dynamics
seen in other systems when posed at the edge of a second order phase transition.
The paper is organized as follows: first, emergent complex phenomena and the intimate connection between crit-
icality and complexity will be described. This will be in Section II, which reviews earlier work on ant's swarm, a
metaphorical mind in itself, which is mathematically very close to nowadays models of collective decision-making.
The large scale analysis of brain dynamics will be introduced in Section III, where the experimental results indicating
criticality are discussed in detail. Section IV provides examples of how complexity and criticality manifest themselves
in a relatively smaller scale (scale of a few millions of neurons). As mentioned above, the statistical properties of the
brain dynamics must be reflected in the dynamics of behavior. This is treated in Section V where recent reports seems
to show such correspondence. Section VI, dwells into the evolutionary argument by which the brain and the animate
behavior must be critical anytime an organism needs to survive and evolve in an environment which, by thermody-
namic reasons, is also critical. Secton VII is dedicated to discuss the tendency in the field to consider equilibrium
models driven by external noise to accommodate the empirically observed fluctuations. Section VIII closes the paper
with a prospective of some relevant issues to pursue further.
II. EMERGENT COMPLEX DYNAMICS IS ALWAYS CRITICAL
Emergence refers to the observation of dynamics that is not expected from the systems equations of motion and,
almost by (circular) definition, is exhibited by complex systems. As discussed at length elsewhere [3, 15, 17, 19, 37,
47, 56], three features are present in complex systems: (I) they are large conglomerate of interacting agents, (II)
each agent own dynamics exhibits some degree of nonlinearity and (III) energy enters the system. [60] These three
components are necessary for a system to be able to exhibit, at some point, emergent behavior. It is well established
that a number of isolated linear elements cannot produce unexpected behavior (mathematically, this is the case in
which all motion can be formally predicted).
2
FIG. 1: A: In typical binary bridge experiments, ants are allowed to walk over bridges connecting two or more areas with
different concentration of pheromones. The dynamics of decision-making changes depending on the pheromone lying in the
surface and on the ant's density. B: Gedanken experiment: the beginning of a network constructed by connecting binary
bridges.
An inspiring example of emergence of complexity is the dynamic of swarms [33 -- 35], which we used in the past
as a toy model to understand how cognition could arise in neural networks [21, 42]. Of course, the case for social
insects representing a paradigm of cooperative dynamics was extensively discussed before [59]. The uncertainty was
centered at what collective property of foraging ants allows the emergence of trails connecting the nest with the food
sources, forming structures spanning sizes several order of magnitude larger than any of the individual's temporal or
spatial scales. To clarify that, Millonas introduced [33] a spatially extended model of what he called "protoswarm".
His objective was to understand the microscopic mechanism by which relatively unsophisticated ants can build and
maintain these very large macroscopic structures. [61]
In the swarm model, there are two variables of interest, the organisms (in large number) and a field, representing
the spacial concentration of a scent (such as pheromone). As in real ants, the model's organisms are influenced in
their actions by the scent field and in turn they are able to modify it by depositing a small amount of scent in each
step. The scent is slowly evaporating as well. The organisms only interact through the scent's field. The model is
inspired in the behavior of real ants, in which they are exposed to bridges connecting two or more areas where the ants
move, feed, explore, etc. Eventually they will discover and cross one of the bridges. As it is illustrated in Figure 1A
they will come to a junctions where they have to choose again a new branch, and continue moving. Since ants both
lay and follow scent as they walk, the flow of ants on the bridges typically changes as time passes. In the example
illustrated in Figure 1A, after a while most of the traffic will eventually concentrate on one of the two branches. The
collective switch to one branch is the emergent behavior, something that can be understood intuitively on the basis
of the positive feedback between scent following, traffic, and scent laying. What is less obvious is linking these ideas
with the microscopic rules governing the dynamics of a single ant. Numerous mathematical models and computer
simulations were able to capture the ants behavior in the bridge experiment. [8, 22, 38].
The bridge experiment results can be used as building blocks to more sophisticated settings, such as ants freely
exploring an extended arena. The insight comes from a rather clever way that Millonas's model discretized space.
The model can be viewed, for descriptive purposes, as a network constructed by connecting each point of a square
lattice to its eight nearest neighbors, as in the cartoon of Figure 1B. Thus, at each step each ant makes a decision
to choose one of eight bridges; and deposits a fixed amount of pheromone as it walks. The decision is based on the
amount of scent at each of the eight locations. The ants' sensory apparatus embedded in a physiological response
function was modeled following biological realism, having two parameters: one which could be considered analogous
to gain and the other the inverse of sensory capacity (or dynamic range). The plot in Figure 2 condenses the results
from the numerical simulations with different values for the physiological response function. At each combination of
AB 3
FIG. 2: Disordered, complex and ordered patterns can be observed as asymptotic dynamic in synthetic swarms for different
values of gain (β) and dynamic range (δ) in the ants' sensory system. For each parameter β and δ value indicated on the
axis the dots in each of the 48 squares represent a snapshot of the ants' positions at the last ten iterations (after 5000 time
steps starting from a random initial distribution of agents). The circles joined by a line are the values for the phase transition
predicted by the theory [33 -- 35]. There are three distinct behaviors: one region (below the line) where ants trajectories are
random, eventually covering the entire arena; a second dynamics (near and above the line) where lines of traffic over complex
paths appear, and yet another patterns with clusters of immobile ants (far above the line). The arena is a 32x32 lattice and
the other parameters as in [21, 42] . Replotted from [18] .
the explored β and δ values there is a square plot which depicts the locations of each ant at the last ten steps of the
simulation. It can be seen that ants converge to different behaviors depending on the parameter' values. For values of
both small gain and small dynamic range ants execute a random path, resulting in the plots fully covered, as in the
right bottom corner. Thus, because of the low sensitivity ants are just making random choices at each juncture. For
large enough gain (top left corner), ants senses saturate resulting in clusters of immobile ants in the same attracting
spot. It is between these two states, one disordered and the other frozen, that the swarm can organize and maintain
large structures of traffic flow as those seen in nature.
The stability analysis in [33] makes straightforward to understand the transition between the disordered walks and
the complex structures of trails (line and circles in Figure 2). Intuition already suggests that the model's β,δ values
at which the order-disorder transition happens must depend on the number of ants able to reinforce the scent field.
In Figure 3 results from several hundreds runs with fixed parameters and increasing density of ants are shown. The
degree of collective order was evaluated by the proportion of ants "walking" on lattice points having above average
4
FIG. 3: Collective swarm behavior near the phase transition. Collective order (top) increases as a function of increasing density
of ants (i.e., the pheromone field is more frequently renewed). Note the generic increase in the amplitude of the fluctuations of
the order parameter (bottom) near the critical point. Order parameter values from individual runs are plotted using dots and
circles for the average. S.D: Standard deviation of the data in the top panel. Replotted from [18].
scent concentration (see further details in [21, 42]). The top panel shows a plot of the results where the dots indicate
the outcome of each individual run (with different initial conditions) and circles the average of all runs. For low
ants' density the expected random behavior is observed, with equal likelihood for ants to be in or out of a high
scent field. For increasing number of ants the swarm suddenly starts to order until it reaches the point in which
the majority of the ants are walking on a field with scent concentration larger than the average. Notice that, as the
density approaches the transition, the amplitude of the order parameter's fluctuation increases (see bottom panel of
Figure 3), a divergence which is generic for criticality. Thus, at the transition, large trial-to-trial variability is found
for repeating realizations of the same numerical experiment. The most significant point here is to note that the best
performance for the swarm, namely where long trails are formed (see Figure 2) corresponds also to the conditions for
maximum variability. Thus maximum variability and performance coexist. [62]
These results were the first to show the simplest (local, memoryless, homogeneous and isotropic) model which leads
to trail forming, where the formation of trails and networks of ant traffic is not imposed by any special boundary
conditions, lattice topology, or additional behavioral rules. The required behavioral elements are stochastic, nonlinear
response of an ant to the scent, and a directional bias. There are other relevant properties, discussed in detail elsewhere
[21, 42], that arise only at the region of ordered line of traffic, including the ability to reconstitute trails and amplify
weak traces of scent, in analogy to memory traces. The conclusions important to these notes are that simple local
rules allow the emergence of complex self organized patterns, which extend in a non local way beyond the scale of a
single agent and which appear suddenly in a dynamical regime between random and uniform behavior, the "critical
state".
The remaining of these notes will show evidence of an analogous behavior when neurons interact nonlinearly in the
human brain, giving rise to the emergence of complex non-local patterns, as well as the functional and behavioral
consequences of these patterns.
0.50.751Order Parameter60708090100Number of Ants 00.010.020.030.04S.D. 5
III. THE COLLECTIVE LARGE-SCALE BRAIN DYNAMICS
To visualize the collective activity of the individual constituents of the human brain (neurons) is harder, of course,
than to contemplate the ants of the previous sections. For this purpose different methodologies have been developed
which are capable to register this activity at different timescales and with different limitations. Large scale activity
(resulting from the averaging of thousands of neurons) can be measured with excellent spatial and good temporal
resolution using fMRI (functional magnetic resonance imaging). This non-invasive technique allows indirect mea-
surements due to metabolic and oxygenation changes correlated with synaptic activity, finally encoded in the BOLD
(Blood Oxygen Level Dependent) signal.
Patterns of global activity can be analyzed studying the relationship between the behavior of different members of
the collective, in this case, regions of cortical tissue on the millimeter scale. Functional interactions between these
areas can be studied comparing their BOLD signal time-courses. These functional interactions are not only present
when the brain engages in a task but also during rest (i.e. spontaneous activity, in contrast to evoked activity).
During the remainder of this notes we will focus mostly on resting state brain dynamics. These interactions can be
represented using the concept of a network or a graph [15, 24, 45, 48, 49, 57]. A graph consists of nodes connected
by links, in this case the nodes are voxels (the smallest cubic regions that the spatial resolution of the method can
resolve) and links represent coordinated activity between these two linked voxels.
Different measures of coordination between the time course of the BOLD signal may be employed, the simplest
being linear correlation. Functional connectivity networks can be constructed computing the linear correlation between
BOLD signal pairwise for all voxels and introducing a link between voxels if they are correlated beyond an arbitrary
threshold (for a diagram of the procedure see Figure 4). For a wide and reasonable range of thresholds, functional
brain networks thus constructed are scale free, this is, the degree histogram of the voxels follows a power law of
exponent approximately 2 (where degree is defined as number of neighbors in the network) [24, 57]. Also, functional
connectivity networks have the small world property [1, 6, 7, 50] (the mean number of links that must be crossed to
connect a given pair of nodes is small relative to the local structure of the network) and are assortative (connectivity
is stronger between nodes of similar degree). These properties are shared with a large number of networks constructed
from different biological and social systems [48, 49]. They have strong implications regarding information transfer,
stability and general robustness of the networks. Together, the scale free and small world properties imply the
presence of long range (non-local) functional interactions between brain regions. Most important to these notes,
FIG. 4: Procedure to extract brain functional connectivity networks. A: BOLD signal is extracted for every pair of voxels (in
this case, voxels in the precuneus and middle frontal gyrus). B: Linear correlation (r) is computed between each pair of signals,
leading to a correlation matrix. C: Correlations are thresholded at a given arbitrary value, a link is established between two
nodes (or voxels) if the correlation of their respective BOLD signals exceeds the threshold, leading to a graph or network.
functional connectivity networks constructed from time-courses extracted from a paradigmatic example of a system
with critical dynamics (Ising model for ferromagnetic materials) are virtually indistinguishable from brain functional
connectivity networks [26]. This striking similarity between both networks is not imposed in the model:
it arises
as a very general consequence of critical dynamics, thus giving an explanation to the topological properties of brain
functional connectivity networks solely based on the concept of criticality.
6
FIG. 5: A: Degree distribution of functional connectivity networks extracted from the Ising model at different temperatures
and different mean degree ((cid:104)k(cid:105)) (up) and degree distributions of brain functional connectivity networks (down) B: Correlation
vs. distance to a given node for brain functional connectivity networks (up) and for Ising model networks (down). Adapted
from [26]
Functional connectivity networks are a useful global description of the brain, albeit a static one. They can be
regarded as the "skeletons" of the dynamical systems, over which patterns of activity unfold over time. Deeper insight
is gained from dynamical analysis (temporal and spatiotemporal) of large scale brain activity. Imaging experiments
have gathered evidence showing that (even in the absence of explicit perception and cognitive performance) this
activity displays complex behavior. In the purely temporal domain, it is not homogeneous nor periodic (as EEG,
MEG, fMRI, etc, recordings indicate) neither there is a representative or predominant frequency, as shown by the 1/f
decay of spectral density.
In the spatiotemporal domain, fMRI whole brain recordings reveal how activity explores complex patterns with
long range correlations and anticorrelations [27, 28]. Strikingly, these patterns can be reduced to a small number of
prototypical ones using a mathematical technique termed Independent Component Analysis (ICA) [9, 10]. Careful
examination shows that these structures appear and disappear over time in the fashion of "passing clouds" that last
only a few seconds. It has been shown that the spatial maps of these resting state independent components (also called
resting state networks or RSNs) can be associated with different cognitive functions and are strongly correspondent
with activation maps obtained during task performance [46].
This correspondence supports a dynamical view of resting state, in which activity continuously explores patterns
(which are "metastable states") only to get temporarily locked in one of them as a task is executed or a sensory system
stimulated. Not surprisingly, it is when operating at the critical point that a dynamical system becomes most efficient
in the flexible exploration of these metastable states. This dynamical view of resting state need to be exploited given
the strong support [52] from recent experiments involving simple motor tasks and resting state. Briefly, it has been
shown that average BOLD signals associated with spontaneous co-activations of key motor cortical areas strongly
resemble co-activations during evoked activity, not only in location and temporal shape but also in intensity.
In
other words, spontaneous activations are completely analogous to evoked activations, except that the first ones are
transient and their timing is uncertain. This correspondence is shown in Figure 6 for regions in the primary motor
cortex, supplementary motor area and cerebellum, during finger tapping and rest. The continuous exploration of
these patterns during resting state may have strong neurophysiological relevance, yet to be fully understood.
It must be noted that while resting-state and spontaneous brain activity seems an ill defined concept, the bulk of
results described in this last paragraph has not only been observed in conscious behaving humans but also during sleep
and anesthesia. A great consistency is observed across subjects: approximately 10 minutes of fMRI measurements
from a single subject are enough to reveal the main resting state networks (as shown in Figure 8)
7
FIG. 6: Averages of the BOLD signal triggered by increments of activity (beyond 0.5 S.D. from the mean) in left primary
motor cortex (PreCG.L) during right finger tapping (up) and resting state (down). Whenever the signal at PreCG.L exceeds
the threshold, 30 sec. of the signal are extracted from right primary motor cortex (PreCG.R), supplementary motor area (SMA)
and left cerebellum (Cer.L) and averaged. Notice the similarity between task and rest conditions, not only in shape but also
in BOLD intensity. Replotted from [52]
This dynamical scenario is highly consistent with the brain operating in a critical regime. A final observation
regarding whole brain measurements is that the lack of measurement scale implied by critical dynamics is also
manifest in the invariance of the two-point correlation function of the BOLD signal after a normalization procedure
(spatial coarse graining) is repetitively carried out [23]. Additional evidence is derived from the computation of the
correlation length of the BOLD signal fluctuations, which are known to diverge near the critical point. Figure 7 shows
experimental results obtained from human fMRI at rest indicating that correlation length is not constant but diverges
with the size of the cluster considered.[20]. This demonstration is a landmark of critical phenomena, together with
previous observations [23, 32] of scale invariance at large scale add weigth to the contention of criticality as the brain's
dynamical state.
IV. NEURONAL AVALANCHING IN SMALL SCALE IS CRITICAL
Historically, the first direct demonstration of collective critical dynamics was the observation that a cultured slice
of neurons supported "avalanches", this is, intermittent bursts of activity that spread up to the whole system [11, 41].
This dynamical state is halfway between highly synchronized oscillatory activity and disordered noise. Even though
pairwise correlations are low, and with highest probably only a small number of neurons fire in synchronized fashion,
occasionally activity spreads in the form reminiscent of an avalanche in Per Bak's sandpile model. Power laws are
observed for event size (number of electrodes registering electrical activity) with exponents agreeing with those of
a critical branching process. These results have been replicated in other experimental settings, including cortical
measurements in awake, behaving monkeys [39] and rats [43].
Modeling efforts to understand the precise neuronal cause of avalanches are currently being made. Certain models
are able to replicate these scale free densities while explicitly avoiding criticality, however, recent numerical results
show that their predicted exponents are in the wrong order of magnitude as those experimentally observed. Also, even
if avalanches are a dynamical process, explanations of scale free behavior can be based on the underlying connectivity
of the neurons. However, directly incorporating long range correlations in the structural connectivity of the collectivity
solves one problem (integration) but succumbs to a different one (segregation). Critical dynamics is, thus, a natural
constraint to incorporate into a model of neuronal avalanches. Models of neurons with activity dependent synaptic
coupling undergoing self organized criticality reproduce statistics of neuronal avalanches, even with trivial (random)
(cid:239)551525(cid:239)1012(cid:239)551525(cid:239)1012(cid:239)551525(cid:239)1012(cid:239)551525(cid:239)1012(cid:239)551525(cid:239)1012(cid:239)551525(cid:239)1012 8
FIG. 7: Top panel:
increase of correlation length with cluster size. Each line shows the cross-correlation of BOLD activity
fluctuations as a function of distance averaged over all time series of thirty five clusters (fragments of resting state networks).
Bottom panel: Functional dependence of the correlation length (crossing of each curve of top panel through zero). The
correlation length grows linearly with the cluster diameter. Thus, for example, the BOLD activity of two voxels spaced 4 mm
apart on a cluster composed by 20 voxels, are as strongly correlated as two points 10 mm apart on a cluster composed by 1000
voxels. Replotted from [20].
FIG. 8: Up: Approximately 10 minutes of resting state brain activity from a single subject (red-yellow for BOLD signal above
the mean, blue-purple for BOLD signal below the mean). Images are separated by 2.5 s. Down: Main resting state networks
obtained through seed based correlation from data shown above. Replotted from [19].
0102030r [mm]-0.500.51C(r)10100100010000Cluster Size (N)10Correlation Length ( (cid:106) )(cid:106) 9
FIG. 9: Size distribution for avalanches in mature cortical cultured networks and different electrode array sizes (15,30,60
electrodes). Power laws with different cutoffs arise for each number of electrodes (finite size scaling). Measurements comprise
70 hours of data recording. Replotted from [15].
connectivity of its elements.
Finally, even though the most salient features of experimental findings regarding neuronal avalanches are power
laws probability densities for size and event durations, there are other predictions to be fulfilled if the underlying
dynamics are in fact critical. In short, these are: I) time scales separation between the dynamics of the triggering
event of the avalanche and the avalanche itself, II) stationary avalanche size statistics regardless of avalanching rate
fluctuations (excluding non-homogeneous Poisson processes), III) Omori's law for earthquakes must apply to avalanche
probabilities after and before main events, IV) average size of avalanches following a main avalanche decays as an
inverse power law, V) avalanches spreads spatially on a fractal. Recently, it has been reported [40] that experimental
data in fact supports these predictions, thus narrowing the search of models of avalanches to those undergoing critical
dynamics.
V. PSYCHOPHYSICS AND BEHAVIOR
As exposed in the previous sections, the hypothesis that collective brain dynamics operates at a critical point has
received plenty experimental support. This evidence spans a wide range of scales both in time and space and leads in
a natural way to a discussion of consequences at a behavioral level. Simply put: if brain activity is critical, signatures
of criticality must be as well observed in behavior and perception.
An old unsolved problem of psychophysics relates to the need of a very ample dynamic range of neuronal responses,
spanning several orders of magnitude[16]. For example, visual perception is known to adapt from very dimly lit
environments (such as caves, forests, etc) to landscapes of high luminosity; however, the dynamic range of an isolated
neuron (spanning at most a single order of magnitude) is too limited to do so. The key to solve this problem resides
in the consideration of a connected network of excitatory neurons which has an amplification factor of one. In this
model, neurons operate in a critical point, in contrast to a subcritical regime in which sensory inputs quickly die, or
a supercritical regime, in which any input spreads in an explosive fashion throughout the network [31]. These three
possibilities are exemplified in Figure 10. Thus, the fact that a system at the critical point has the greatest dynamical
range, is now the key to solve the dilemma of human perception optimized over several orders of magnitude.
On the other hand, animal behavior has been shown to reflect the critical dynamics of brain activity. Recordings of
spontaneous motion activity of rats during large periods of time reflects scale free distribution for length of movement
times and pauses [2]. This result, observed in an animal model and controlled laboratory conditions, has similarities
with reports on human activities such as writing of letters, emails, web browsing and motion initiation. Together,
these results suggest the presence of behavioral signatures of critical dynamics in animals and human beings.
10
FIG. 10: The three dynamical regimes of a sensory network model: subcritical regime (amplification or branching ratio less
than one), critical (amplification equal to one), and supercritical (amplification greater than one). In critical networks, activity
levels are conserved, and the dynamical range of responses is maximized. Redrawn from [16].
VI. AN EVOLUTIONARY PERSPECTIVE
The ingredients for complex emergent behavior presented in the first section of these notes (a large number of
energy-driven nonlinearly interacting elements) are not only present in the human brain, but are also ubiquitous in
the whole natural world [3, 4, 13, 37]. Humans and other animals navigate in this complex critical world, which as
such offers constantly surprises and unexpected events. One can argue that in a subcritical and uniform world a brain
is a superfluous organ since there is nothing to learn, on the other hand, an ever-changing supercritical world offers
no regularities to be learned [5, 14]. In the middle of these two extreme situations there is a real need for a learning
device. The coupling between a critical world and a critical brain is best exemplified in the playing habits of children.
Young children become quickly bored of inanimate toys (even the addition of sophisticated motion mechanisms does
not dramatically improve this situation), however, they obtain unending fun from animal pets for long periods of
time. The reason behind is that animate behavior is a mixture of order and surprise in the same sense than the
spatiotemporal patterns of a system at the critical point are composed of a blend of order and disorder. Thus, the
need of a brain stems from the fact that the world around is critical, thus, in turn evolutionary pressures constraint
brains to operate in a critical regime.
Brains must not only be capable of mere learning: the ability to forget is central to adaptive behavior. In a sub-
critical brain state of highly correlated activity, memories would be "frozen" and ever present. On the other hand, a
supercritical brain would have its activity patterns changing wildly and constantly in time, resulting in the inability
to retain any memories. The conclusion is that, in order to adapt to a complex world that constantly presents us
with novelties, evolution has created brains and forced them operate at the critical point.
VII. NOISE OR CRITICAL FLUCTUATIONS? EQUILIBRIUM VS NON-EQUILIBRIUM.
As discussed in Section II, criticality is a universal dynamics exhibited by a large class of systems. Consequently it
offers a unified theoretical framework to explain a myriad of apparently unrelated observations. We will briefly provide
an illustration of this possibility, discussing work recently reported, where the current theoretical understanding can
be fruitfully applied.
In a series of papers [29, 36] the variance and mean-based spatial fMRI patterns obtained in subjects of different
ages were compared, concluding that the descriptive value of the variance was greater than the averages. The authors
suggested that "examination of BOLD signal variability may reveal a host of novel brain-related effects not previously
considered in neuroimaging research". Additional work (by the same authors) went even further, revealing that
11
BOLD signal variability is greater at younger age, confirming that "younger, faster, and more consistent performers
exhibited significantly higher brain variability across tasks, and showed greater variability-based regional differentiation
compared to older, poorer performing adults"[30].
The origin of this variability was explained [36] by suggesting that: "The interplay between local and global dynamics
governs the spatiotemporal configuration of the brain's functional architecture and keeps the system in a high-energy
state, at the 'edge of instability' among a number of different states and configurations.", while the switch between
such configurations was suggested to happen by the action of noise originated in the following manner: "Intrinsic
neural noise -- stochastic fluctuations in information transfer caused by imprecise timing of cellular processes -- serves
to nudge the system from one state to another and thus confers the capacity to make fluid and adaptive transitions
between different states and reconfigure either spontaneously or in response to external (task) demand."
Besides the obvious merits of calling attention to the variability, the crucial question here should be how much
[63] But lets
real understanding was gained by finding that the variability was more informative than the average.
postpone the answer to this question until we consider yet another example.
The second example is concerned with a very interesting book [44] dedicated recently to the topic of noise in the
brain, which in its very first five lines reads: "The relatively random spiking times of individual neurons produce a
source of noise in the brain. The aim of this book is to consider the effects of this and other noise on brain processing.
We show that in cortical networks this noise is an advantage, for it leads to probabilistic behavior that is advantageous
in decision making, by preventing deadlock, and is important in signal detectability". This is not an isolated quote
taken out of the proper context. The authors enumerate a three "reasons why the brain is inherently noisy and
stochastic"[44] including sensory noise arising external to the brain, cellular noise due to stochastic opening and
closing of ion channels, and synaptic noise.
These two examples are in line with nearly all detailed models of neuronal function which require ad-hoc noise
inputs to function properly. Simply put, without noise the system is at equilibrium, stuck on a stable state. All
these analysis overlook a crucial question: where does this (fine tuned or not) noise comes from? If it is generated
by specific systems within the brain, then experimental evidence ("a noisy center" ?) should be found pointing to
where these systems are and how they work. Of course, sarcasms aside, no such center would be found. Instead,
ad-hoc noisy driving is not required by the theory of critical brain dynamics, since noise is self-generated by the
collective dynamics which spontaneously fluctuates near the critical point as was shown in Figure 3. It is well known,
that large fluctuations are inherent to a system approaching the critical point [3], and in that sense "variability" is
perfectly understood as part of the critical dynamics, and not a force external to the system. In our opinion, the often
conjectured reasons for the noise presence, assigning a purpose to it [64], are teleological dead-ends that postpone true
understanding.
The fact is that the correct interpretation of the noise is a much deeper issue, which reflects the general tendency
to consider only equilibrium models. These models achieve a better agreement with empirical observations only with
the addition of external noise (see for instance Chapter 12 in [48] or work compiled by Steyn-Ross [51] recently). This
deformation is not exclusive of neuroscience and its consequences are far reaching. For example, similar views in other
complex systems include the explanation of episodes with very large number of species going extinct throughout earth
history by adding external noise, such that for each extinction an out of space event (meteorite) hits the earth. In
contrast, non-equilibrium models [3, 37] show that similar exceptionally rare and large extinctions (and their mirror
situations, namely speciations) can be inherent of the co-evolutionary species dynamics, and that large extinctions
could have happened in absence of meteorites. In these type of models, variability and disparate fluctuations are
(at criticality) typical. Another example belongs to macro-economics, as the late Per Bak hammered many times
in his writings[3] and lectures, criticizing models in which each market crash would have required an event that
drove the shares to plunge.
In analogy, historians will assure us that in Sarajevo on the 28th of June of 1914 a
member of the Black Hand, a Serbian nationalist secret society, assassinated Archduke Franz Ferdinand, heir to the
Austro-Hungarian throne. The equilibrium view will identify this single event (noise?) as responsible to trigger the
mobilization of 65 millions soldiers, 7 millions missing, 8 millions killed and 21 millions wounded. In contrast, the
non-equilibrium approach will assert that the First War World (and other infrequently large conflicts) will eventually
happen in absence of an isolated gunman.
Thus, coming back to the brain, where its main dynamics are fluctuations, it need to be recognized that having to
add fluctuations (noise) to the model equations to get fluctuating dynamics is a serious limitation. It seems reasonable
that future work consider that the differences between modeling a "noisy brain" or a "critical brain" are significant
and relevant, because the gap separating these two views is conceptually as large as for physics is the difference
between equilibrium and non-equilibriums dynamics.
VIII. OUTLOOK
12
The study of collective dynamics and critical phenomena was pioneered by physicists during the past century, in
order to solve problems related with material science and solid state physics. It is now clear that the theoretical frame-
work used for these problems is very general and can be applied to understand an impressive range of phenomenology
from many disciplines. Emergent dynamical properties of interacting agents (phase transitions, divergence of corre-
lation length and fluctuations, maximum dynamical range, etc) are far from explicit in the individual equations of
motion, thus, a reductionist approach will be (by its very definition) unable to explain this emergence.
Pure reductionism has in fact been abandoned in a large list of fields which study complex many particle systems,
from economics and sociology to molecular biology. It is surprising that this revolution has only recently began to
have an impact on neuroscience, a discipline which deals more than any other with a collective of interacting agents.
Still today, a large number of published results stem from detailed experiments or simulations of neurons or networks
of millions of neurons, including sometimes great biological detail but no considerations related with the statistical
physics of collective phenomena in large systems. However, after the realization that theories of brain function must
be compatible with the laws of collective behavior, a non-return point has been reached: a rapidly increasing number
of reports being deal with theoretical and experimental evidence grounding the emergent critical dynamics hypothesis
[19].
Researchers now find that paradoxical situations and seemingly disconnected facts can be re conciliated within
the critical brain dynamics theory, without need of complicated ad-hoc hypothesis. A good example of this is the
integration/segregation dilemma [53 -- 55], a problem haunting neuroscientists since the beginnings of the discipline:
how does the brain manages to integrate information from different modalities into a single decomposable scene,
while making easy to segregate particular aspects of this scene at will? Or in other terms: how does brain activity
from different regions coordinates without collapsing into a single block of uniform dynamics? A concrete example
is the synchronous coexistence of multiple operational modules studied by Fingelkurts & Fingelkurts [25]. Many
connectionistic approaches have been taken to this problem, implying that coordination is hardwired into anatomical
connectivity. These proposed solutions are able to solve one problem (integration) but still fail to explain the ease of
brain dynamics to segregate. Within the theory of critical brain dynamics, however, this situation arises naturally:
even systems with trivial structural connectivity (for example, the first-neighbor connections of the Ising model)
achieve (transient) long range correlations at the critical point [26].
Any scientific theory needs to explain and integrate previous facts, solve apparently paradoxical situations, and
make predictions amenable to experimental verification. Along these notes we have shown how these requirements
are fulfill by the theory of emergent brain collective critical dynamics. The transfer of ideas from statistical physics
to other disciplines is a young and exciting endeavor, even younger in neuroscience[58], however exciting results have
already been achieved. Only with the realization that brain is a collective (and henceforth must follow the physical
laws that govern collectives) a deep understanding of brain and human behavior will be achieved.
Work supported by NIH (USA) and by CONICET (Argentina). E.T. was supported by an Est´ımulo Fellowship
from the University of Buenos Aires.
Acknowledgements
[1] S. Achard, R. Salvador, B. Whitcher, J. Suckling, E. Bullmore. Resilient, low-frequency, small-world human brain functional
network with highly connected association cortical hubs. J Neurosci 26, 63 (2006).
[2] C. Anteneodo & D.R. Chialvo. Unraveling the fluctuations of animal motor activity. Chaos 19, 033123 (2009).
[3] P. Bak. How Nature works. (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1997).
[4] P. Bak, C. Tang, K. Wiesenfeld. Self-organized criticality: an explanation of the 1/f noise. Phys. Rev. Lett. 59, 381 (1987).
[5] P. Bak & D.R. Chialvo. Adaptive learning by extremal dynamics and negative feedback. Phys. Rev. E 63, 031912 (2001).
[6] D. S. Bassett, A. Meyer-Lindenberg, S. Achard, T. Duke, E. Bullmore. Adaptive reconfiguration of fractal small-world
human brain functional networks, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 103, 19518 (2006).
[7] D.S. Bassett & E. Bullmore. Small-World Brain Networks Neuroscientist 12, 512 (2006).
[8] R. Beckers, J.L. Deneubourg, S. Goss, J.M. Pasteels. Collective decision making through food recruitment. Insectes Soc.
37, 258 (1990).
[9] C.F. Beckmann & S.M. Smith. Probabilistic independent component analysis for functional magnetic resonance imaging.
IEEE Trans. Med. Imag. 23, 137 (2004).
13
[10] C.F. Beckmann, M. DeLuca, J.T. Devlin, S.M. Smith. Investigations into resting-state connectivity using independent
component analysis. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B 360, 1001 (2005).
[11] J.M. Beggs & D. Plenz. Neuronal avalanches in neocortical circuits, J. Neuroscience 23, 11167 (2003).
[12] V. Braitenberg. Some arguments for a theory of cell assemblies in the cerebral cortex. in Neural connections, mental
computation, eds. L Nadel,L Cooper, P. Culicover, M Harnish. (The MIT Press,Cambridge, MA, 1989).
[13] M. Buchanan. Ubiquity. (Weidenfeld and Nicholson, London, 2000).
[14] D.R. Chialvo & P. Bak. Learning from mistakes. Neuroscience 90, 1137(1999).
[15] D.R. Chialvo. Critical brain networks, Physica A 340, 756 (2004).
[16] D.R. Chialvo. Are our senses critical? Nature Physics 2, 301 (2006).
[17] D.R. Chialvo. The brain near the edge. In: Cooperative behavior in neural systems: Ninth Granada Lectures. AIP Confer-
ence Proceedings 887,1 (2007).
[18] D.R. Chialvo. Emergent complexity: what uphill analysis or downhill invention can not do. New Ideas in Psychology 3,158
(2008).
[19] D.R. Chialvo. Complex emergent neural dynamics Nature Physics 6, 744 (2010).
[20] D.R. Chialvo & D. Fraiman. Optimal information-sharing in brain resting state networks. arXiv:1011.1192v1 [q-bio.NC]
(2010).
[21] D.R. Chialvo & M.M. Millonas. How swarms build cognitive maps. In: The biology and technology of intelligent autonomous
agents. Luc Steels (ed.) NATO ASI Series, 144, 439 (1995).
[22] J.L. Deneubourg, S. Goss, N. Franks, J.M. Pasteels. The blind leading the blind: Modeling chemically mediated army ant
raid patterns. J. Insect Behavior 2, 719 (1989).
[23] P. Expert, R. Lambiotte, D.R. Chialvo, K. Christensen, H.J. Jensen, D.J. Sharp, F. Turkheimer. Self-similar correlation
function in brain resting state fMRI. J. R. Soc. Interface 8, 472 -- 479 (2011).
[24] V.M. Eguiluz, D.R. Chialvo, G. Cecchi, M. Baliki, A.V. Apkarian. Scale free brain functional networks, Phys. Rev. Lett.
94, 018102 (2005).
[25] A.A. Fingelkurts & A.A. Fingelkurts. Persistent operational synchrony within brain default-mode network and self-
processing operations in healthy subjects. Brain and Cognition 75, 79 (2011).
[26] D. Fraiman, P. Balenzuela, J. Foss, D.R. Chialvo. Ising-like dynamics in large scale brain networks. Phys. Rev. E 79,
061922 (2009).
[27] M.D. Fox & M.E. Raichle. Spontaneous fluctuations in brain activity observed with functional magnetic resonance imaging.
Nat. Rev. Neurosc. 8 700 (2007).
[28] M.D. Fox, A.Z. Snyder, J.L. Vincent, M. Corbetta, D.C. van Essen, M.E. Raichle. The human brain is intrinsically
organized into dynamic, anticorrelated functional networks. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 102, 9673 (2005).
[29] D.D. Garrett, N. Kovacevic, A.R. McIntosh, C.L. Grady. Blood Oxygen Level-Dependent signal variability is more than
just noise. J. Neurosci.30, 4914 (2010).
[30] D.D. Garrett, N. Kovacevic, A.R. McIntosh, C.L. Grady. The importance of being variable. J. Neurosci. in press (2011).
[31] O. Kinouchi & M. Copelli. Optimal dynamical range of excitable networks at criticality. Nature Physics 2, 348 (2006).
[32] M.G. Kitzbichler, M.L. Smith, S.R. Christensen, E. Bullmore. Broadband criticality of human brain network synchroniza-
tion. PLoS. Comput. Biol. 5, e1000314(2009).
[33] M.M. Millonas. A connectionist type model of self-organized foraging and emergent behavior in ant swarms. J. Theor.
Biol. 159, 5299 (1992).
[34] M.M. Millonas. Swarms, Phase Transitions, and Collective Intelligence. In: Artificial Life III. C.G. Langton (ed.), (Proc.
Santa Fe Institute Studies in the Sciences of Complexity, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1994)
[35] M.M. Millonas. A nonequilibrium statistical field theory of swarms and other spatially extended complex systems. In:
Pattern Formation in Physical and Biological Sciences. P. Claudis, (ed.), (Proc. Santa Fe Institute Studies in the Sciences
of Complexity, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1994)
[36] B. Mlslc, T. Mills, M. J. Taylor, A. R. McIntosh. Brain noise is task dependent and region specific. J. Neurophysiol. 104.
2667 (2010).
[37] M. Paczuski & P. Bak. Self-organization of complex systems. In: Proceedings of 12th Chris Engelbrecht Summer School.
Also as cond-mat/9906077.(1999).
[38] J.M. Pasteels, J.L. Deneubourg, S. Goss. Transmission and amplification of information in a changing environment: The
case of ants. In: Laws of Nature and Human Conduct. (Prigogine, I. & Sanglier, M., eds.) (Gordes, Brussels, 1987).
[39] T. Petermann, T.C. Thiagarajan, M.A. Lebedev, M.A. Nicolelis, D.R. Chialvo, D. Plenz. Spontaneous cortical activity in
awake monkeys composed of neuronal avalanches. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 106, 15921 (2009).
[40] D. Plenz & D.R. Chialvo. Scaling properties of neuronal avalanches are consistent with critical dynamics. arXiv:0912.5369v1
[q-bio.NC] (2009).
[41] D. Plenz & T.C. Thiagarajan. The organizing principles of neuronal avalanche activity: cell assemblies in the cortex?
Trends Neurosci. textbf3, 101 (2007).
[42] E.M. Rauch, M.M. Millonas, D.R. Chialvo. Pattern formation and functionality in swarm models, Physics Letters A 207,
185 (1995).
[43] T.L. Ribeiro, M. Copelli, F. Caixeta, H. Belchior, D.R. Chialvo, M.A.L. Nicolelis, S. Ribeiro. Spike avalanches exhibit
universal dynamics across the sleep-wake cycle. PLoS ONE 5, e14129 (2010).
[44] E. Rolls & G. Deco. The noisy brain. Stochastic dynamics as a principle of brain function. (Oxford Univ. Press, UK, 2010)
[45] R. Salvador, J. Suckling, M.R. Coleman, J.D. Pickard, D. Menon, E. Bullmore. Neurophysiological architecture of functional
magnetic resonance images of human brain. Cerebral Cortex 15, 1332 (2005).
14
[46] S.M. Smith, P.T. Fox, K.L. Miller, D.C. Glahn, P.M. Fox, C.E. Mackay, N. Filippini, K.E. Watkins, R. Toro, A.R. Laird,
C.F. Beckmann. Correspondence of the brain's functional architecture during activation and rest. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.
USA 106, 13040 (2009).
[47] R. Sole & B.C. Goodwin. Signs of Life: How Complexity Pervades Biology (Basic Books, MA, 2000).
[48] O. Sporns. Networks of the brain (MIT Press, Cambridge, 2010).
[49] O. Sporns, D.R. Chialvo, M. Kaiser, C.C. Hilgetag. Organization, development and function of complex brain networks,
Trends Cog. Sci. 8, 418 (2004).
[50] C.J. Stam, B.F. Jones, G. Nolte, M. Breakspear, Ph. Scheltens. Small-world networks and functional connectivity in
Alzheimer's disease.Cerebral Cortex 17, 92 (2007).
[51] S.A. Steyn-Rose & M. Steyn-Rose (eds). Modeling phase transitions in the brain. (Springer, NY, 2010).
[52] E. Tagliazucchi, P. Balenzuela, D. Fraiman, P. Montoya, D.R. Chialvo. Spontaneous BOLD event triggered averages for
estimating functional connectivity at resting state, Neurosci. Letters 488, 158 (2011).
[53] G. Tononi, G.M. Edelman, O. Sporns. Complexity and coherency: integrating information in the brain. Trends Cog. Sci.
2, 474 (1998).
[54] G. Tononi & G.M. Edelman. Consciousness and complexity. Science 282, 1846 (1998).
[55] G. Tononi. An information integration theory of consciousness, BMC Neurosci. 5, 42 (2004).
[56] D.L. Turcotte. Self-Organized Criticality, Reports on Progress in Physics 62, 1377 (1999)
[57] M.P. van den Heuvel, C.J. Stam, M. Boersma, H.E. Hullshof Pol. Small-world and scale-free organization of voxel-based
resting-state functional connectivity in the human brain. NeuroImage 43, 528 (2008)
[58] G. Werner. Perspectives on the neuroscience and consciousness. BioSystems 87, 82 (2006)
[59] O.E. Wilson. The Insect Societies. (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 1971)
[60] As an example, think that the agents are humans who are driven by food, sunlight and other energy sources, they can
form families and communities. After many generations, eventually some political structure arises. Whatever the type of
structure that emerges is unlikely to appear in the absence of any of the three elements emphasized above.
[61] Most readers will recognize the similarities with brain's phenomenology.
[62] The brain correlate for this divergence will be a large variance in some order parameter (extracted from the dynamics)
coexisting with optimal response to the same input, for instance.
[63] The first and second moments are usually linked by some functional relation, thus it is not completely surprising that
averages and variance share predictability.
[64] "the noise serves to...,"
|
1012.4422 | 1 | 1012 | 2010-12-20T18:08:22 | Formation and Stability of Synaptic Receptor Domains | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cond-mat.soft",
"cond-mat.stat-mech",
"q-bio.BM",
"q-bio.MN",
"q-bio.SC"
] | Neurotransmitter receptor molecules, concentrated in postsynaptic domains along with scaffold and a number of other molecules, are key regulators of signal transmission across synapses. Employing experiment and theory, we develop a quantitative description of synaptic receptor domains in terms of a reaction-diffusion model. We show that interactions between only receptor and scaffold molecules, together with the rapid diffusion of receptors on the cell membrane, are sufficient for the formation and stable characteristic size of synaptic receptor domains. Our work reconciles long-term stability of synaptic receptor domains with rapid turnover and diffusion of individual receptors. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Formation and Stability of Synaptic Receptor Domains
Christoph A. Haselwandter,1, ∗ Martino Calamai,2 Mehran Kardar,1 Antoine Triller,2 and Rava Azeredo da Silveira3
1Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139
2Biologie Cellulaire de la Synapse N&P, INSERM UR497,
Ecole Normale Sup´erieure, 46 rue d'Ulm, 75005 Paris, France
3Department of Physics and Department of Cognitive Studies,
Ecole Normale Sup´erieure, 24 rue Lhomond, 75005 Paris, France
(Dated: October 26, 2018)
Neurotransmitter receptor molecules, concentrated in postsynaptic domains along with scaffold
and a number of other molecules, are key regulators of signal transmission across synapses. Employ-
ing experiment and theory, we develop a quantitative description of synaptic receptor domains in
terms of a reaction-diffusion model. We show that interactions between only receptor and scaffold
molecules, together with the rapid diffusion of receptors on the cell membrane, are sufficient for the
formation and stable characteristic size of synaptic receptor domains. Our work reconciles long-term
stability of synaptic receptor domains with rapid turnover and diffusion of individual receptors.
PACS numbers: 87.16.-b, 82.40.-g, 87.19.lp, 87.19.lw
How the physiological stability necessary for memory
storage can be achieved in the presence of rapid molec-
ular turnover and diffusion is a central problem in neu-
robiology [1]. Synapses, in particular, are believed to be
the physiological seat of memory, and rely on the stabil-
ity of postsynaptic domains containing neurotransmitter
receptor molecules, as well as scaffold and a number of
other molecules, over days, months, or even longer peri-
ods of time [2, 3]. Yet, recent experiments have demon-
strated that individual receptor [4 -- 6] and scaffold [7 --
9] molecules leave and enter postsynaptic domains on
typical timescales as short as minutes. How can these
seemingly contradictory observations -- long-term stabil-
ity and a well-defined characteristic size of postsynaptic
domains on the one hand, rapid molecular turnover and
diffusion on the other hand -- be integrated in a unified
understanding of postsynaptic domain formation and sta-
bility?
Classically,
it has been assumed that interactions
between presynaptic and postsynaptic neurons play a
paramount role in the stability and in setting the char-
acteristic size of synaptic receptor domains [10]. Over
recent years, though, a number of studies [4, 6, 11], car-
ried out on a variety of chemical synapses, have indi-
cated that molecular domains containing synaptic recep-
tor molecules may form spontaneously even in the ab-
sence of presynaptic neurons. However, a detailed molec-
ular understanding of the mechanism governing the for-
mation and stability of synaptic receptor domains has re-
mained elusive. In this Letter, we first discuss a minimal
experimental system which enables us to determine the
molecular components essential for the self-organization
of stable receptor domains of the characteristic size ob-
served in neurons [9, 12, 13]. On this basis, we then
formulate a mathematical model of the formation and
stability of synaptic receptor domains which quantita-
tively accounts for our experimental observations, and
also makes further predictions pertaining to the stability
and regulation of synaptic receptor domains.
In our experiments we used single fibroblast cells,
which are devoid of the molecular machinery commonly
associated with postsynaptic domain formation [10] but
allow for the rapid turnover and diffusion of receptors
observed in neurons [4, 6], as well as for interaction of
receptors with scaffold molecules. Fibroblast cells were
transfected [14] with glycine receptors, one of the main
receptor types at inhibitory synapses, and their associ-
ated scaffolds, gephyrin molecules [9].
In our minimal
system, the mere presence of both receptor and scaf-
fold molecules led to the spontaneous emergence of sta-
ble receptor-scaffold domains (RSDs) [see Fig. 1(a,b)].
These domains corresponded to a joint enhancement of
the receptor and scaffold molecule densities, over a char-
acteristic area of 0.2 to 0.3 µm2 [Fig. 1(c)]. Once the
RSDs were formed, their mean area remained stable over
a time scale of days, with little cell-to-cell variability in
the mean area of RSDs but larger variability in the mean
number of RSDs per cell [Fig. 1(c)]. If only receptors
were transfected, in the absence of scaffold molecules, re-
ceptor domains did not emerge, apart from possible oc-
currences of transient microdomains [12, 15]. If only scaf-
fold molecules were transfected, in the absence of recep-
tors, then these formed large intracellular blobs but no
association with the cell membrane was detected [12, 16].
The experiments carried out on our minimal system in-
dicate that receptor-scaffold interactions, together with
the diffusion properties of each molecular species at the
membrane, are necessary and sufficient for RSD forma-
tion and stability. In particular, the presence of a presy-
naptic terminal is not essential for the occurrence of sta-
ble RSDs. In agreement with previous studies [4, 6, 11],
our results point to a picture in which postsynaptic do-
mains form in the absence of presynaptic stimulation,
which subsequently intervenes in their maturation and
2
Finally, the diffusion properties of receptors are similar
in cells with transfected [9] and endogenous [17] scaffold
molecules. Thus, we expect that receptors and scaffolds
in neurons exhibit the necessary and sufficient proper-
ties for RSD formation and stability, as they do in our
experiments.
We now turn to the mathematical description of our
minimal experimental system. The concentration of re-
ceptors is represented by the function r(x, y, t) and that
of scaffolds by the function s(x, y, t), where the variables
x and y denote coordinates along the cell membrane, and
the variable t denotes time. The spatiotemporal evolu-
tion of these fields is governed by the reaction-diffusion
equations
= F (r, s) + νr∇ [(1 − s)∇r + r∇s] ,
= G(r, s) + νs∇ [(1 − r)∇s + s∇r] ,
(1)
(2)
∂r
∂t
∂s
∂t
where F and G are simple (cubic) polynomials in r and
s that describe the reactions in our system [14], and νr
and νs are the receptor and scaffold diffusion coefficients.
The nonlinear corrections to the standard diffusion terms
νr∇2r and νs∇2s in Eqs. (1) and (2) arise from the con-
straint 0 ≤ r + s ≤ 1, where we have normalized r and s
so that the maximum concentration of receptors and scaf-
folds is equal to 1, and account for steric repulsion [4, 6]
of receptors and scaffolds in the confined membrane envi-
ronment of a living cell. Experimental studies [4 -- 9, 15] of
the diffusion properties of glycine receptors and gephyrin
scaffolds, as well as of other types of synaptic receptors
and scaffolds, yield νr > νs.
The reaction and diffusion properties of receptors and
scaffolds [4 -- 9, 15] suggest that Eqs. (1) and (2) exhibit
pattern formation via a Turing instability [18, 19] which
emerges from the interplay between the two molecular
species in our system: Receptors diffuse quickly and tend
to repel nearby molecules, whereas scaffolds diffuse more
slowly and tend to attract nearby molecules. In agree-
ment with experiments, the formation of synaptic recep-
tor domains via a Turing mechanism necessarily relies
on the presence of both receptors and scaffolds. Expres-
sions of the reaction terms F and G in Eqs. (1) and (2)
are obtained from the relevant chemical interactions, re-
ported previously [4 -- 9], together with the general math-
ematical constraints associated with Turing instabilities
[19], a point we return to below. Reaction-diffusion mod-
els akin to the one described here have, in recent years,
been used to describe molecular localization during cell
division [20 -- 22], and are to be contrasted with models
of domain formation which rely on phase separation and
coarsening [23].
We simulated Eqs. (1) and (2), starting from random
initial conditions, with units of space and time set by the
diffusion coefficient of unbound receptor molecules and
the rate of receptor endocytosis. Using typical values for
FIG. 1: (color online). Experimental results on the formation
and stable characteristic size of RSDs composed of glycine
receptors and gephyrin scaffolds [14]. (a) Example of a trans-
fected COS-7 cell with domains on its membrane: Receptor
(R, red) and scaffold (S, green) concentration and overlay (co-
domains in yellow). A fraction of the apparent green-labeled
scaffolds is endoplasmic. Scale bar, 5 µm. (b) Examples of se-
lected RSDs at higher resolution. For ease of visualization, the
concentration maps of the two molecular species were slightly
shifted with respect to one another in the color panel. Scale
bars, 0.5 µm. (c) Mean RSD (cluster) area and number of
RSDs (clusters) per cell versus time. Error bars: standard er-
rors; n > 10 cells from two independent experiments for each
point.
regulation. Both the characteristic size and the stability
of the RSDs observed in our experiments are similar to
those of synaptic receptor domains in neurons. Indeed,
when scaffold molecules are transfected to young neu-
rons devoid of synapses, domains of a comparable size
arise [12]. When they are transfected to mature neurons
with synapses, the domain size remains unchanged [13].
3
tion trails behind scaffold aggregation in time [Fig. 2(b)],
which is in fact a general feature of our model and is also
in agreement with experimental observations [25, 26].
The Turing mechanism implies that RSDs attain
a steady state once a dynamical equilibrium between
strong receptor diffusion and the attractive effect of scaf-
folds is reached. In our simulations of Eqs. (1) and (2)
we found that, for the diffusion coefficient of glycine re-
ceptors reported in experiments [4 -- 6, 9, 15], the resulting
characteristic size of RSDs was comparable to that ob-
tained in experiments [see Figs. 2(b,c) and 1(c)]. This
result necessitated only gross adjustment of the reaction
rates, so that Eqs. (1) and (2) would exhibit a Turing
instability but, apart from that, the characteristic size of
domains was found to be largely insensitive to variations
in reaction rates or, indeed, to the reaction kinetics con-
sidered. The timescale for the formation of stable RSDs
in our simulations [see Fig. 2(b)] was set by the rate of
receptor endocytosis. For the measured range of values
of the rate of receptor endocytosis [4, 6, 8] this timescale
was also in broad agreement with experimental observa-
tions [see Fig. 1(c)]. Further consistency checks between
Eqs. (1) and (2) and experimental results would pertain
to the geometry of domain edges, the effect of changes in
diffusion rates on domain size and stability, and the rel-
ative extent of the enhanced concentrations of receptors
and scaffolds in RSDs. In particular, our model predicts
that once dynamical equilibrium has set in, the recep-
tor profile is wider than the scaffold profile in any given
domain [see Fig. 2(c)].
While, in accordance with experimental observations
[4 -- 9, 15], we allowed [14] for a variety of interactions be-
tween receptors and scaffolds when simulating Eqs. (1)
and (2), we found that only a handful of chemical reac-
tions were crucial for the formation and stability of RSDs
via a Turing instability. To lowest order, these reactions
correspond to R → Rb and Rb + S → R + S for the
receptors, and to S → Sb and Sb + 2S → 3S for the
scaffolds, respectively. In these expressions, the symbols
R and S stand for receptors and scaffolds at the mem-
brane, and Rb and Sb denote molecules in the bulk of the
cell. In particular, the reaction Sb + 2S → 3S, in which
a scaffold molecule from the bulk is adsorbed onto the
membrane by two other scaffold molecules into a trimer,
is key to domain formation, whereas the simpler reaction
Sb + S → 2S alone is not sufficient.
Indeed, gephyrin
scaffold molecules are thought to form both dimers and
trimers under the usual conditions in which neural do-
mains are observed [4]. However, if trimerization is pre-
vented, no domains (or only very small ones) appear [9].
The above results demonstrate how stable synaptic re-
ceptor domains can emerge in the absence of presynaptic
stimulation.
In a synapse, however, presynaptic activ-
ity regulates [27] the concentration of receptors in the
postsynaptic domain. Our reaction-diffusion model sug-
gests novel mechanisms for how such regulation may be
FIG. 2: (color online). Model results on the formation and
stable characteristic size of RSDs [14]. (a) Irregular patterns
of stable RSDs, with an area of approximately 0.2 to 0.3 µm2
each, emerge on a timescale of hours. The distributions of
receptors (upper panel) and scaffolds (middle panel) are over-
layed (lower panel), and the domain shapes and patterns are
stable. (b) Formation and (c) shape of RSDs at higher reso-
lution. Scale bars, 0.5 µm.
these parameters taken from experiments [4 -- 9, 15], we
found that irregular patterns of stable RSDs similar to
experimental ones emerged over a timescale of hours [see
Figs. 2(a) and 1(a)]. Individual domains resulted from
a coordinated increase of receptor and scaffold densities.
Occasionally, we observed sets of closely-spaced RSDs in
the outcomes of simulations, resulting from initial ran-
dom fluctuations [see Figs. 2(a,b)]. At lower resolution,
these appeared as larger than average, irregularly shaped
domains reminiscent of similar instances obtained exper-
imentally [see the lower panels in Fig. 1(b)].
Inclusion
of molecular noise in our reaction-diffusion model is ex-
pected to further distort the simulated patterns with-
out changing their overall characteristics [24]. Moreover,
we observed in our simulations that receptor aggrega-
0.50.2500.250.5xm0.50.2500.250.5ymr0.50.2500.250.5xm0.50.2500.250.50.2500.250.5xm0.50.2500.250.5yms0.50.2500.250.5xm0.50.2500.25abcStableRdomainsStableSdomainsOverlayRdomains1.4hoursSdomains1.4hoursRdomains1.6hoursSdomains1.6hoursRdomains1.8hoursSdomains1.8hoursRprofileSprofile 4
istic size observed in neurons can emerge from noth-
ing more than interactions between receptors and scaf-
folds, together with the rapid diffusion of receptors on
the cell membrane. A reaction-diffusion model quanti-
tatively accounts for our experimental results, yielding
spontaneous formation of stable receptor domains and
their observed characteristic size, as well as new puta-
tive mechanisms for the regulation of synaptic strength.
Collectively, our results show how stable synaptic recep-
tor domains may form even in the absence of presynaptic
stimulation [4, 6, 11], and how rapid turnover and diffu-
sion of receptors [4, 6], far from being a hindrance, may
in fact be crucial [1] for ensuring overall stability and
delicate control of synaptic receptor domains.
This work was supported by the Austrian Science Fund
(C.A.H.), the Pierre-Gilles de Gennes Foundation and a
FEBS grant (M.C.), the NSF through grant No. DMR-
08-03315 and a Visiting Professorship at the Ecole Nor-
male Sup´erieure (M.K.), the Inserm UR 789 (A.T.), and
the CNRS through UMR 8550 (R.A.d.S.).
∗ Present address: Department of Applied Physics, Cali-
fornia Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125
[1] F. Crick, Nature 312, 101 (1984).
[2] J. T. Trachtenberg et al., Nature 420, 788 (2002).
[3] J. Grutzendler, N. Kasthuri, and W.-B. Gan, Nature
420, 812 (2002).
[4] D. Choquet and A. Triller, Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 4, 251
(2003).
[5] A. Triller and D. Choquet, Trends Neurosci. 28, 133
(2005).
[6] A. Triller and D. Choquet, Neuron 59, 359 (2008).
[7] N. W. Gray et al., PLoS Biology 4, 2065 (2006).
[8] C. G. Specht and A. Triller, Bioessays 30, 1062 (2008).
[9] M. Calamai et al., J. Neurosci. 29, 7639 (2009).
[10] A. K. McAllister, Ann. Rev. Neurosci. 30, 425 (2007).
[11] T. T. Kummer, T. Misgeld, and J. R. Sanes, Curr. Opin.
Neurobiol. 16, 74 (2006); and references therein.
[12] J. Meier et al., J. Cell Sci. 113, 2783 (2000).
[13] C. Hanus, M.-V. Ehrensperger, and A. Triller, J. Neu-
rosci. 26, 4586 (2006).
[14] For further details,
see the supplementary material
posted with this article.
[15] J. Meier et al., Nat. Neurosci. 4, 253 (2001).
[16] J. Kirsch, J. Kuhse, and H. Betz, Mol. Cell. Neurosci. 6,
450 (1995).
[17] M. Dahan et al., Science 302, 442 (2003).
[18] A. M. Turing, Phil. Trans. B 237, 37 (1952).
[19] M. C. Cross and P. C. Hohenberg, Rev. Mod. Phys. 65,
851 (1993).
[20] M. Howard, A. D. Rutenberg, and S. de Vet, Phys. Rev.
Lett. 87, 278102 (2001).
[21] R. V. Kulkarni et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 228103 (2004).
[22] M. Loose et al., Science 320, 789 (2008).
[23] A. Gamba et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 158101 (2007).
[24] T. Butler and N. Goldenfeld, Phys. Rev. E 80, 030902(R)
(2009).
[25] J. Kirsch et al., Nature 366, 745 (1993).
FIG. 3: (color online). Model results on the regulation of ma-
ture RSDs [14]. Left panel: temporal profiles of step stimula-
tions. Inset: receptor concentration profiles at times of maxi-
mum domain size. Right panel: time course of the in-domain
receptor population size, R, following stimulation, normalized
by the in-domain receptor population size in the absence of
any stimulation, R0.
achieved. It has been observed [8, 28] that the diffusion of
receptors on the postsynaptic membrane can be modified
through binding of presynaptic neurotransmitters. Sim-
ilarly, scaffold diffusion may be [29, 30] modulated by
synaptic activity. This suggests that local modification
of the diffusion properties of receptors or scaffolds may
contribute to the regulation of postsynaptic domains. As
a simple phenomenological perturbation to our model,
we therefore implemented pre- and postsynaptic inter-
actions through a local increase in the receptor diffu-
sion rate which, within the framework of our reaction-
diffusion model, has the same effect as a local decrease
in the scaffold diffusion rate.
As shown in Fig. 3, our model predicts that modu-
lation of receptor or scaffold diffusion yields a transient
increase of the in-domain receptor population following
presynaptic activity. Clearly, this speculative, purely bio-
physical mechanism may coexist with biochemical mech-
anisms of postsynaptic plasticity. Applying a few seconds
of stimulation at a time (Fig. 3, left panel), we found
a correlation between the increase in in-domain recep-
tor population and the duration of stimulation (Fig. 3,
right panel). After an initial, short-lived suppression, the
population increase lasted for a few tens of seconds -- the
timescale typically associated with short-term plasticity.
In this window of time, RSDs were richer in receptors
(Fig. 3, inset) and, hence, yielded a larger synaptic ef-
ficacy. This phenomenon has a simple explanation in
terms of the Turing instability exhibited by our model:
Enhanced (diminished) receptor (scaffold) diffusion de-
pletes the receptor (increases the scaffold) population in
a transient manner which, because receptors are repulsive
and scaffolds are attractive, in turn attracts even more
receptors and scaffolds into RSDs.
In summary, we have used a minimal experimental
system devoid of synaptic machinery to show that neu-
rotransmitter receptor domains of the stable character-
[26] C. B´echade et al., Eur. J. Neurosci. 8, 429 (1996).
[27] J. D. Shepherd and R. L. Huganir, Ann. Rev. Cell Dev.
1324 (2005).
[30] C. Dean and T. Dresbach, Trends Neurosci. 29, 21
Biol. 23 613 (2007).
(2006).
[28] H. Bannai et al., Neuron 62, 670 (2009).
[29] B. Chih, H. Engelman, and P. Scheiffele, Science 307,
5
|
1612.00644 | 1 | 1612 | 2016-12-02T11:48:17 | Bayesian Population Receptive Field Modelling | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | We introduce a probabilistic (Bayesian) framework and associated software toolbox for mapping population receptive fields (pRFs) based on fMRI data. This generic approach is intended to work with stimuli of any dimension and is demonstrated and validated in the context of 2D retinotopic mapping. The framework enables the experimenter to specify generative (encoding) models of fMRI timeseries, in which experimental manipulations enter a pRF model of neural activity, which in turns drives a nonlinear model of neurovascular coupling and Blood Oxygenation Level Dependent (BOLD) response. The neuronal and haemodynamic parameters are estimated together on a voxel-by-voxel or region-of-interest basis using a Bayesian estimation algorithm (variational Laplace). This offers several novel contributions to receptive field modelling. The variance / covariance of parameters are estimated, enabling receptive fields to be plotted while properly representing uncertainty about pRF size and location. Variability in the haemodynamic response across the brain is accounted for. Furthermore, the framework introduces formal hypothesis testing to pRF analysis, enabling competing models to be evaluated based on their model evidence (approximated by the variational free energy), which represents the optimal tradeoff between accuracy and complexity. Using simulations and empirical data, we found that parameters typically used to represent pRF size and neuronal scaling are strongly correlated, which should be taken into account when making inferences. We used the framework to compare the evidence for six variants of pRF model using 7T functional MRI data and we found a circular Difference of Gaussians (DoG) model to be the best explanation for our data overall. We hope this framework will prove useful for mapping stimulus spaces with any number of dimensions onto the anatomy of the brain. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Bayesian Population Receptive Field
Modelling
Peter Zeidmana *
Edward Harry Silsonb
Dietrich Samuel Schwarzkopfc,d
Chris Ian Bakerb
Will Pennya
a The Wellcome Trust Centre for Neuroimaging, University College London, 12 Queen Square,
London, UK. WC1N 3BG.
b Laboratory of Brain and Cognition, National Institute of Mental Health, Bethesda, Maryland 20892-
1366, USA.
c Experimental Psychology, University College London, 26 Bedford Way, London, UK. WC1H 0AP.
d UCL Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience, 17-19 Queen Square, London, UK. WC1N 3AR.
* Corresponding author
The Wellcome Trust Centre for Neuroimaging is supported by core funding from the Wellcome Trust
091593/Z/10/Z.
1
Abstract
We introduce a probabilistic (Bayesian) framework and associated software toolbox for mapping
population receptive fields (pRFs) based on fMRI data. This generic approach is intended to work
with stimuli of any dimension and is demonstrated and validated in the context of 2D retinotopic
mapping. The framework enables the experimenter to specify generative (encoding) models of fMRI
timeseries, in which experimental manipulations enter a pRF model of neural activity, which in turns
drives a nonlinear model of neurovascular coupling and Blood Oxygenation Level Dependent (BOLD)
response. The neuronal and haemodynamic parameters are estimated together on a voxel-by-voxel
or region-of-interest basis using a Bayesian estimation algorithm (variational Laplace). This offers
several novel contributions to receptive field modelling. The variance / covariance of parameters are
estimated, enabling receptive fields to be plotted while properly representing uncertainty about pRF
size and location. Variability in the haemodynamic response across the brain is accounted for.
Furthermore, the framework introduces formal hypothesis testing to pRF analysis, enabling
competing models to be evaluated based on their model evidence (approximated by the variational
free energy), which represents the optimal tradeoff between accuracy and complexity. Using
simulations and empirical data, we found that parameters typically used to represent pRF size and
neuronal scaling are strongly correlated, which should be taken into account when making
inferences. We used the framework to compare the evidence for six variants of pRF model using 7T
functional MRI data and we found a circular Difference of Gaussians (DoG) model to be the best
explanation for our data overall. We hope this framework will prove useful for mapping stimulus
spaces with any number of dimensions onto the anatomy of the brain.
2
Introduction
1
There are many examples of neuronal populations which represent stimulus spaces. In the auditory
cortex, the 1-dimensional space of sound frequencies is mapped onto the surface of the brain
(Merzenich and Brugge, 1973; Moerel et al., 2012). In the visual system, retinotopic mapping has
revealed that the 2-dimensional plane of the retina is mapped multiple times onto the surface of
visual cortex (e.g. Holmes, 1945). Place cells in the bat hippocampus respond maximally to a specific
location in 3-dimensional space (Palacci et al., 2013) and conceptual knowledge may be represented
neuronally in spaces of two dimensions or more (Constantinescu et al., 2016). Populations of
neurons can be characterised by their receptive fields – the area(s) of N-dimensional space to which
they maximally respond. In this paper, we introduce a generic framework for mapping stimulus
spaces onto the brain and for performing hypothesis testing. We illustrate this approach in the
context of visual population receptive field (pRF) mapping.
To enable pRF mapping, model parameters are required which capture the response of neuronal
populations to experimental stimuli. The spatial distribution of these parameters across the brain
can reveal large-scale topographic features, such as the presence of retinotopic maps. pRF mapping
can therefore be seen a special case of building generative models of imaging timeseries. We seek to
understand how stimuli cause a change in neuronal activity, which in turns causes a change in
observations. For functional MRI (fMRI), this involves modelling neuro-vascular coupling and the
BOLD response (Kumar et al., 2014), which is an inherently nonlinear mapping. For instance, the
BOLD response has a refactory period which depends on the interstimulus interval (Friston et al.,
1998). Furthermore, brain regions differ in the extent of their vascularization, giving rise to regional
differences in BOLD response. Typically, pRF mapping experiments use a canonical haemodynamic
response function, which may be determined on a per-subject basis. Here, to obtain the best
possible estimators of neural activity for constructing pRF maps, we specified and estimated a non-
linear model for each voxel's fMRI timeseries which included a biologically motivated differential
equation model of neurovascular coupling and the BOLD response (Buxton et al., 2004; Stephan et
al., 2007).
The objective of modelling (and of science more generally) is to test hypotheses. In the context of
pRF mapping, hypotheses may be specified explicitly or implicitly. For instance, He et al. (2015)
tested the explicit hypothesis that pRF position is modulated by perceived 3D space. Other pRF
studies have been exploratory, for instance examining the reorganisation of visual field maps after
lesions or disease (e.g. Levin et al., 2010). In studies such as this, there is an implicit hypothesis that
pRF parameters will deviate from the normal range in specific areas of cortex. Despite the popularity
of pRF mapping, a framework for formal hypothesis testing is currently lacking.
Here we introduce a set of tools for probabilistic (Bayesian) model fitting and inference in the
context of pRF mapping, which could offer several benefits to experimenters. The optimal method
for testing hypotheses is to compare the likelihood of the data under one model (or hypothesis)
against the likelihood of the data under another model (Neyman and Pearson, 1933). For instance,
an experimenter may wish to test the hypothesis that in certain brain regions there are receptive
fields with an excitatory centre and inhibitory surround, as identified by Hubel and Wiesel (1959)
with single unit recordings. Such receptive fields may be modelled using a Difference of Gaussians
(DoG) function (Rodieck, 1965), which can also capture the neuronal response at the level of voxels
in fMRI data (Zuiderbaan et al., 2012). Alternatively, if the evidence for an inhibitory surround is
lacking, a simple excitatory receptive field may be the better model (as applied to fMRI data by
Dumoulin and Wandell, 2008). This kind of question, regarding which of several models is the best
3
explanation of the available imaging data, may be addressed by comparing the evidence for the fMRI
data under competing models at each point in the brain.
Normally, pRF models are assessed based on the percentage variance they explain (their accuracy).
This cannot be used for hypothesis testing, as it ignores complexity – any model with more
(independent) parameters will explain more of the variance, with the added risk of overfitting the
noise and failing to generalise. In the framework proposed here, an approximation of the model
evidence is used known as the negative variational free energy (Friston et al., 2007; Penny, 2012).
This quantity, estimated for each pRF model, represents the accuracy of the model minus its
complexity. By comparing models based on their free energy, the experimenter can select the
simplest model which explains the most variance. Furthermore, by taking into account the
covariance between parameters, the free energy offers a more sensitive approximation to the model
evidence than other approximations such as the AIC or BIC.
As well as enabling competing models to be compared, the framework we propose has advantages
for parameter-level inference, which may be of particular relevance for exploratory pRF studies.
Here, parameters such as the pRF's size are each represented as a (normal) probability distribution,
with both an expected value and variance / covariance (uncertainty). Thus, the uncertainty of
parameter estimates may be expressed when visualising the pRF and when making comparisons
within and between subjects. Uncertainty about the parameter estimates may arise from multiple
sources – observation noise, subjects' movement, as well as any covariance among parameters.
Also, it may not always be possible to confidently assign variance in the measured signal to either
neuronal or haemodynamic causes. By estimating the full covariance among neuronal and
haemodynamic parameters, we ensure that any uncertainty induced by ambiguity between these
parameters is accounted for when visualising the pRF or testing hypotheses.
Here, we generalise an approach previously introduced in the context of tonotopic mapping (Kumar
et al., 2014), making several novel contributions. We extend the method to stimuli of any dimension,
and demonstrate its application in the context of visual (retinotopic) pRF mapping (Section 3.1, 3.2).
We evaluate the face validity and robustness to noise of the method using simulated data (Section
3.3), and evaluate test-retest reliability across scanning runs using empirical data (Section 3.4).
Finally, we demonstrate the use of this method for hypothesis testing (Section 3.5), by comparing
the evidence for two established forms of pRF model: a Gaussian response function (Dumoulin and
Wandell, 2008) and a Difference of Gaussians (centre-surround) response function (Zuiderbaan et
al., 2012). Within each category of model we also compared the evidence for circular, elliptical, or
angled receptive fields. All of the methods described and evaluated here are made available to
experimenters via a freely available software toolbox (Appendix A).
2 Methods
2.1 Participants
Empirical data were acquired as part of a previously reported study (Silson et al., 2015). Data from
one participant was included here. All participants in the previous study had normal or corrected-to-
normal vision and gave written informed consent. The National Institutes of Health Institutional
Review Board approved the consent and protocol (93-M-0170, NCT00001360).
2.2 Data acquisition
Data were acquired using a Siemens 7 tesla Magnetom scanner in the Clinical Research Center on
the National Institutes of Health campus (Bethesda, MD). Partial EPI volumes of the occipital and
temporal cortices were acquired using a 32-channel head coil (42 slices; 1.2 x 1.2 x 1.2 mm; 10%
4
interslice gap; TR, 2 s; TE, 27 ms; matrix size, 170 x 170; FOV, 192 mm). Anatomical T1 weighted
volumes were acquired before the experimental runs. Standard MPRAGE (Magnetization-Prepared
Rapid-Acquisition Gradient Echo) and corresponding GE-PD (Gradient Echo–Proton Density) images
were collected and the MPRAGE images were then normalized by the GE-PD images, for use as a
high-resolution anatomical data for the fMRI data analysis.
2.3 Task and procedure
Naturalistic scene images were presented through a bar aperture that gradually traversed the visual
field (Figure 1). During each 36 s sweep, the aperture took 18 evenly spaced steps (each 2s or 1TR) to
traverse the entire screen (Dumoulin and Wandell, 2008). Eight of these sweeps formed one run, in
the following order: L-R, BR-TL, T-B, BL-TR, R-L, TL-BR, B-T, and TR-BL. There were 16 identical runs
per participant. The scene stimuli, which covered a circular area (21° diameter) changed every
400ms (5 per aperture position). During runs, participants performed a colour-detection task at
fixation, indicating via button press when the white fixation dot changed to red. Colour fixation
changes occurred semi-randomly, with ~2 colour changes per sweep.
Figure 1 Example stimulus frames used for pRF mapping. Scene images covering a circular (21° diameter) area of the display
were presented through a bar aperture that moved gradually through the visual field. A single sweep across the visual field
took 36 s and consisted of 18 equally timed (2 s) steps of equal width. In each run, the aperture completed eight sweeps (2
orientations, 4 directions). Participants were required to maintain fixation and indicate the detection of a colour change at
fixation, via a button press. Adapted from Silson et al. 2015 (license CC BY 4.0).
2.4 Pre-processing
As reported in Silson et al. (2015), functional data were initially motion-corrected using the Analysis
of Functional NeuroImages (ANFI) software package (http://afni.nimh.nih.gov/afni), following
removal of eight "dummy" volumes to allow stabilisation of the magnetic field. Subsequent analyses
were conducted using SPM (Statistical Parametric Mapping) version 12
(http://www.fil.ion.ucl.ac.uk/spm/).
2.5 Feature selection
To reduce computation time of the Bayesian pRF procedure we performed an initial General Linear
Model (GLM) analysis to pick out any voxels showing some differential response depending on the
location of the bar aperture. This also enabled us to model and regress out nuisance effects (e.g.
motion and scanner drift). We first divided the stimulus display into 9 equally sized squares. For each
2s frame of the stimulus, we identified which of the 9 squares had any illumination. We then built a
5
GLM with one regressor for each square, as well as 6 regressors representing head motion and a
regressor modelling the mean of each run (Figure 2). We estimated the parameters of this model
and created an F-contrast to identify positive or negative effects from any of the first 9 regressors
(defined as an identity matrix of dimension 9). The resulting statistical image, thresholded at p < 0.05
family-wise error corrected (F = 5.48) revealed 14,395 voxels located primarily in the occipital lobe,
extending ventrally into the posterior fusiform / parahippocampal region. These voxels were taken
forward for pRF analysis.
Figure 2 General linear model for feature selection. We split the stimulus space into 9 squares (top) and constructed a
general linear model (bottom right). One run out of 16 is enlarged (bottom left). The first 9 columns represent locations in
stimulus space, the remaining 6 columns represent the subject's head motion.
2.6 Timeseries extraction
pRF modelling was performed on a per-voxel basis. To enable this, timeseries were extracted from
each voxel identified above, high-pass filtered (with cut-off 128 seconds) to remove low frequency
scanner drift and whitened to remove auto-correlation over time. The motion regressors and mean
of each run were regressed out. This procedure was repeated for each scanning run and the
resulting timeseries were averaged over runs. Data from the 8 odd-numbered runs were used for
the main analysis and the 8 even-numbered runs were kept aside to evaluate test-retest reliability
(Section 3.4).
2.7 Model specification
We specified a generative model which predicted BOLD timeseries given visual stimuli. The model
(based on Kumar et al., 2014) consisted of two parts – a neuronal model describing the brain's
response to the stimuli, and an observation model describing the change in neurovascular coupling
and BOLD response caused by the neuronal activity.
2.7.1 Stimulus specification
At each time step 𝑡, a set of points 𝑈𝑡 was illuminated on the screen, where each point was defined
by an 𝑥- and 𝑦-coordinate:
6
𝑈𝑡 = {𝑝1, … , 𝑝𝑛}
𝑝𝑖 = (𝑥 ∈ ℝ, 𝑦 ∈ ℝ)
(1
The on-screen coordinates were discretised to give a reduced stimulus resolution of 41x41 pixels and
expressed in units of degrees of visual angle.
2.7.2 Neuronal model
The neuronal activity 𝑧(𝑡) was modelled as a multivariate normal probability density function 𝑁:
𝑧(𝑡) = 𝛽 ∑ 𝑁(𝑝𝑖μ, Σ)
𝑁(𝑝𝑖𝜇, Σ) =
𝑝𝑖∈𝑈𝑡
1
√(2𝜋)𝑘Σ
1
2
(𝑝𝑖−𝜇)′Σ−1(𝑝𝑖−𝜇)
𝑒−
(2
This function is commonly used in pRF mapping (since Dumoulin and Wandell, 2008), although we
used a normalised rather than the unnormalised density 𝑁. The response was summed over each
illuminated pixel on the screen 𝑝𝑖 and scaled by parameter 𝛽. The model was parameterised by 𝑘-
dimensional vector 𝜇, which specified the position of the pRF in 𝑘-dimensional stimulus space, and
𝑘-dimensional covariance matrix Σ which specified the width and rotation of the receptive field.
Here we used stimuli of dimension 𝑘 = 2, specified by their Cartesian coordinates (𝑥, 𝑦) in visual
space.
The neuronal parameters (𝜇, 𝛽 and the elements of matrix Σ) needed certain constraints to be
placed on their values. For instance, 𝛽 needed to be positive whereas 𝜇 was constrained within the
stimulated area of the visual field. However, the optimisation algorithm we employed (variational
Bayes) expected normally distributed prior distributions for each parameter, constrained only by
their variance. To overcome this, we substituted each parameter for a latent variable, which could
be freely adjusted by the optimisation algorithm. Within the pRF model, these variables were
transformed to be within the desired range of values, before being used to calculate the neuronal
response in Equation 2. Next, we detail these transformations for each parameter.
pRF centre parameters
We constrained the centre of the pRF to fall within the circular area of the screen that was
illuminated during scanning. While the pRF approach can model the influence of stimulation from
beyond the stimulated area, finding the parameters for such a model is a particularly ill-posed
problem (any number of parameter combinations could give rise to the same observations). To
constrain the pRF location we introduced latent variables 𝑙𝜌 and 𝑙𝜃, which controlled the distance
and angle (polar coordinates) of the pRF location relative to the centre of the visual field. These
variables were freely adjusted by the optimisation algorithm during model fitting, and were
transformed to polar coordinates (𝜌, 𝜃) within the model as follows:
𝜌 = 𝑟 ∗ NCDF(𝑙𝜌, 0,1)
𝜃 = 2𝜋 ∗ NCDF(𝑙𝜃, 0,1) − 𝜋
7
(3
Where NCDF is the cumulative density function for the univariate normal distribution. These
transforms ensured that the distance 𝜌 of the pRF from the centre of the visual field was constrained
between 0 and 𝑟 = 10.5° and the polar angle 𝜃 was constrained between – 𝜋 and 𝜋 radians. A
second transform then converted from polar to Cartesian coordinates:
𝜇𝑥 = 𝜌 ∗ cos(𝜃)
𝜇𝑦 = 𝜌 ∗ sin(𝜃)
𝜇 = (𝜇𝑥, 𝜇𝑦)
(4
Which then entered the model as 𝜇 in Equation 2. We could therefore guarantee that whatever
values were selected for latent variables 𝑙𝜌 and 𝑙𝜃 by the optimisation algorithm, the pRF location
(𝜇𝑥, 𝜇𝑦) would fall within the circular stimulated area.
pRF width parameter
The width of the pRF was parameterised by its standard deviation 𝜎. To constrain the width to be in
the range [𝑟0 𝑟], we introduced a latent variable 𝑙𝜎. This latent variable could be freely adjusted by
the optimisation algorithm and was transformed within the model to give the pRF width:
𝜎 = (𝑟 − 𝑟0) ∗ NCDF(𝑙𝜎, 0,1) + 𝑟0
(5
We set 𝑟0, the smallest allowed pRF width, to 0.5°. The pRF model which forms the first part of the
results (Section 3.1-3.4) had a receptive field which was circular in shape (isotropic). This was
modelled by setting the covariance matrix Σ in Equation 2 as follows:
Scaling parameter
Σ = [𝜎2
0
0
𝜎2]
(6
Parameter 𝛽 scaled the neuronal response (see Equation 2). It was constrained to be positive by
substituting it for latent variable 𝑙𝛽 :
𝛽 = exp (𝑙𝛽)
(7
Priors
To complete the specification of the neuronal model, each latent variable (𝑙𝜌, 𝑙𝜃, 𝑙𝛽) was assigned a
prior (normal) distribution, representing our beliefs before model fitting. The latent variables
representing the pRF location 𝑙𝜌 and 𝑙𝜃 had priors 𝑁(0,1). The transformation to constrain these
(Equation 3) converted these normal prior distributions to bounded flat distributions over 𝜌 and 𝜃,
with all values in the allowed ranges equally likely (this is known as the probability integral
transform). The second transformation, from polar to Cartesian coordinates (Equation 4), changed
this to a peaked distribution around the origin. We considered this a reasonable prior given the over-
representation of the fovea in cortex (e.g. Azzopardi and Cowey, 1993).
8
We set the prior on the latent variable representing the pRF width 𝑙𝜎 to 𝑁(0,1). Because of the CDF
transformation (Equation 5), this gave an equal prior probability of all widths in the allowed range.
We set 𝑙𝛽 to have prior distribution 𝑁(−2,5), which translated to an expected 𝛽 parameter of 0.14
with 95% confidence interval [0.003 5.35]. This large variance reflected our uncertainty about this
parameter. We found that having a small positive prior value for this parameter provided a
reasonable starting point for the optimisation algorithm.
2.7.3 Haemodynamic model
The predicted neuronal activity from the pRF model was fed into the extended Balloon model
(Buxton et al., 2004; Stephan et al., 2007), which is a series of differential equations describing how
neuronal activity causes a change in blood flow, and how blood flow causes the BOLD response.
Most parameters of this model are fixed, based on previous empirical measurements, however
three parameters are estimated on a voxel-wise basis: the transit time 𝜏, the rate of signal decay 𝜅,
and the ratio of intra- to extra-vascular signal 𝜖. Certain parameters in this model are field-strength
specific, which we adjusted for our 7T data according to recommendations by Heinzle et al. (2016).
We set 𝑟0, the intravascular relaxation rate, to 340, the frequency offset at the outer surface of
magnetized vessels to 197.86Hz and the prior distribution on log 𝜖 to the normal distribution with
mean -3.99 and variance 0.83. The 3 free neurovascular / haemodynamic parameters were
concatenated with the parameters of the neuronal model and estimated simultaneously.
The model was completed by setting prior expectations on the observation noise, which was
assumed to be I.I.D. and normally distributed with mean zero. We set the prior log precision of the
noise to 4 with variance (uncertainty) 1/55, based on values typically used with SPM's Bayesian
modelling framework.
2.8 Model estimation
For each voxel separately, the model was fitted to the data using the variational Laplace algorithm
(Friston et al., 2007), implemented in the Matlab function spm_nlsi_gn.m, which is included with the
SPM software package. This Bayesian estimation procedure provides two important estimates. The
first is an approximation of the log model evidence, which is the log probability of the observing the
data 𝑦 given the model 𝑚, log 𝑝(𝑦𝑚). The approximation, known as the negative variational free
energy (henceforth 'free energy'), may be expressed as follows:
log 𝑝(𝑦𝑚) = 𝐹(𝑚) + 𝐾𝐿[𝑞(𝜃𝑚) 𝑝(𝜃𝑦, 𝑚)]
(8
Here, 𝐹 is the free energy approximation of the model evidence, which we estimate. The second
term is a distance measure (the Kullback-Leibler divergence, KL) between two distributions: the
estimated parameters 𝑞(𝜃𝑚) and the true parameters 𝑝(𝜃𝑦, 𝑚). We cannot compute this, as we
do not know the true parameters. However, because the log model evidence log 𝑝(𝑦𝑚) is fixed, we
know that by maximising the free energy 𝐹(𝑚), we minimise the second term and get the closest
approximation of the model evidence. The free energy is defined in full elsewhere (see Appendix B
of Penny, 2012), however it is important to recapitulate that it may be decomposed into two parts
(Beal and Ghahramani, 2003):
𝐹(𝑚) = accuracy(𝑚) − complexity(𝑚)
(9
9
The accuracy is the fit of the model to the data. The complexity is the difference (the KL divergence)
between the prior distribution of the parameters and the estimated (posterior) distribution of the
parameters. This definition of complexity gives the free energy advantages over other
approximations such as the AIC and BIC (Penny, 2012). Rather than simply counting the number of
parameters in the model, the KL divergence takes into account the full covariance among
parameters, meaning that parameters which are estimated to be independent contribute more to
the complexity term than those which covary. Using the free energy, we compared pRF models to
find the most accurate and least complex explanation for our data.
The algorithm also provides the estimated parameters 𝑞(𝜃𝑚) which maximise the free energy. The
algorithm employs the Laplace assumption, which means that all parameters – prior and posterior –
are normally distributed. Thus for each parameter, whether neuronal or haemodynamic, we have an
expected value (mean) and uncertainty (variance), as well as the estimated covariance among
parameters. We report these parameters and their uncertainty in various forms throughout the
paper.
We performed model estimation separately for timeseries from each voxel. To improve
performance, we initialized the VL model fitting algorithm with pRF parameters identified using a
grid search (Dumoulin and Wandell, 2008) with a canonical haemodynamic response function. To
further reduce the total estimation time, we developed software functions to divide the voxels
across a parallel computer cluster and combine the results following estimation, which are included
in the software implementation (Appendix A). Here we divided the estimation across a 192-core
cluster computer (running CentOS 6.3 with a clock speed ranging from 2.1Ghz to 2.5Ghz). On each
core of this cluster, estimation took an average of 123 seconds per voxel to complete, or around 2
hours 40 minutes for the whole analysis.
Inference
2.9
2.9.1 Parameter map generation
Having estimated the pRF models in each voxel, we generated maps of the estimated pRF
parameters across the brain (Section 3.1). We then thresholded these parametric maps to only
include voxels where something was learnt about the parameters after seeing the data, relative to
the priors. To perform this thresholding, we compared the evidence for each estimated pRF model
against a nested model, in which the pRF parameters were fixed at their prior means. If the evidence
for these two models was similar, it meant that our knowledge about the pRF parameters did not
improve as a result of seeing the data. On the other hand, if the evidence for the full model was
stronger than the evidence for the nested model, it would mean that we can be more confident
about these parameters after seeing the data.
To compute this model comparison, for each voxel's pRF model we specified a nested model 𝑚𝑁, in
which the prior variance of the pRF location and width parameters (𝜇𝑥, 𝜇𝑦, 𝜎) were fixed at zero. We
then computed the ratio of the evidence of the full model 𝑚𝐹 against this nested model 𝑚𝑁. This
ratio is called the Bayes factor, and the log of this ratio is approximately equal to the difference in
the free energy of each model:
log BF = log
𝑝(𝑦𝑚𝑁)
𝑝(𝑦𝑚𝐹)
≅ 𝐹𝑁 − 𝐹𝐹
(10
To compute the free energy of the nested models, 𝐹𝑁, we did not need to separately estimate them
using the VL algorithm. Instead, we derived the nested models' evidence and parameters analytically
10
using Bayesian Model Reduction (Friston and Penny, 2011), which is a generalisation of the Savage-
Dickey ratio used in classical statistics. This calculation was performed on the order of milliseconds
for each voxel. Having computed the log Bayes factor for each voxel, we then computed the
posterior probability of the full model 𝑚𝐹:
𝑝(𝑚𝑁𝑦) =
1
1 + exp(− log BF)
𝑝(𝑚𝐹𝑦) = 1 − 𝑝(𝑚𝑁𝑦)
(11
We thresholded the parametric maps to only include voxels where the posterior probability of the
full model was at least 0.95. These surviving voxels were used to generate the maps in Figure 3.
2.9.2 Plotting haemodynamic response
To illustrate the estimated variability in BOLD response across the brain, we computed the impulse
response function of each pRF model (those with significant pRF parameters, above) and averaged
these responses across voxels (Section 3.1). The response functions were computed using Volterra
kernels, as described by Friston et al. (1998).
2.9.3 Plotting pRFs
We plotted the receptive field of an example pRF model before and after fitting it to the data (Figure
5). The prior receptive field was computed by taking 1000 samples from model's prior multivariate
distribution over the parameters, and for each sample, computing the response of the neuronal
function (Equation 2) at evenly spaced locations in the visual field (Figure 5A). These responses were
then averaged. This is referred to as the prior predictive density (PD) 𝑞 for each point in space (𝑥, 𝑦):
𝑞(𝑥, 𝑦) = ∫ 𝑔(𝑥, 𝑦, 𝜃)𝑝(𝜃)𝑑𝜃
(12
Where 𝑔(𝑥, 𝑦, 𝜃) is the response of the neuronal (pRF) function to a single point in space with
parameters 𝜃. By using this approach, we were able to plot the pRF while accounting for uncertainty
over its location and size. The posterior response was similarly computed using the estimated
parameters following model fitting.
2.9.4 Bayesian Parameter Averaging
In order to summarise pRF models' expected values and covariance across voxels, we computed the
Bayesian Parameter Average (BPA). The BPA is the average of the parameters across voxels,
weighted by the precision of each estimate. The data entering BPA was the vector of estimated pRF
parameters 𝜇𝑣 for each voxel 𝑣, together with the precision matrix Λ𝑣 (inverse of the covariance
matrix). The BPA provides a probability distribution over the parameters, with vector of means Μ
and covariance matrix 𝐶:
11
𝑁
Λ = ∑ Λ𝑣
𝑣=1
𝐶 = Λ−1
𝑁
Μ = Λ−1 ∑ μvΛ𝑣
𝑣=1
𝑝(Μi > 0) = 1 − 𝑁𝐶𝐷𝐹(0; Μi, 𝐶𝑖,𝑖)
(13
The final line of equation 13 states the probability that any given parameter 𝑖, averaged across
voxels, is different to zero. 𝑁𝐶𝐷𝐹(𝑥; 𝑎, 𝑏) is the normal cumulative distribution function with mean
𝑎 and variance 𝑏. In this formulation, we made the simplifying assumption that each voxel's data
were independent.
2.9.5 Computing correlations and entropy maps
To compute the correlation between parameters we converted the covariance matrix 𝐶 from the
BPA (described above) to a correlation matrix in the normal way. To visualise the spatial distribution
of parameter uncertainty, we created maps of the entropy, defined for each voxel 𝑣 as:
ℎ𝑣 = log Σv
(14
Where … is the determinant and Σv is the estimated covariance matrix of the model for voxel 𝑣.
The entropy ℎ𝑣 of a multivariate Gaussian has units of nats, where more positive values indicate
greater uncertainty in the parameters.
2.9.6 Simulation
To evaluate the face validity of the approach, we performed simulations. First, we estimated the
empirical signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of our data. To do this we randomly selected an estimated pRF
model, which had been fitted to the timeseries from a voxel in right hemisphere near the midline
(within the hOC2 anatomical mask, described in section 2.9.8). We integrated this model over time
to give the predicted BOLD timeseries 𝑦 and computed the residual timeseries 𝑟. We calculated the
SNR based on the standard deviation:
𝑆𝑁𝑅 =
𝜎𝑦
𝜎𝑟
= 1.56
(15
Next we chose a random 1000 voxels from our empirical data (which had survived the test for
significance described in section 2.9.1), and we used the estimated pRFs from these voxels to
generate 1000 simulated BOLD timeseries. We then added five levels of observation noise to each
timeseries, from very noisy (SNR 0.5) down to a level of noise similar to our empirical data at 7T (SNR
1.56). We fitted pRF models to these simulated timeseries and correlated the estimated parameters
against the 'true' parameters that generated the data. Note that for all validation analyses, we
converted from latent variables (e.g. 𝑙𝜌 and 𝑙𝜃) to the underlying parameters which entered the
model (e.g. 𝜌 and 𝜃), as these are the quantities of interest to experimenters.
2.9.7 Alternative models
We compared pRF models to address two questions. The first was whether a single Gaussian or a
Difference-of-Gaussians (DoG) response function would be a better explanation for the data. The
DoG function has an excitatory centre and inhibitory surround. The second question asked what
shape of receptive field would best explain the data (circular, elliptical or elliptical with rotation).
12
Thus, we formed a 2x3 factorial model space to address these questions. Here we describe the
modifications made to the basic circular (isotropic) model to form these alternative models.
Elliptical models
We specified models which replaced the pRF width (standard deviation) parameter 𝜎 with separate
parameters representing horizontal width 𝜎𝑥 and vertical width 𝜎𝑦. This enabled the pRF to take on
an elliptical shape. This was implemented by changing the covariance matrix Σ (see Equation 2) to
include two separate parameters:
Σ = [
2
𝜎𝑥
0
0
2]
𝜎𝑦
(16
Latent variables were introduced for each of the two width parameters, as for the single width
parameter in the basic model, with the same priors.
Elliptical models with rotation
Enabling the pRF to rotate required the introduction of a parameter Ρ representing the correlation
coefficient:
σ𝑃 = Ρ ∗ σx ∗ 𝜎𝑦
(17
Σ = [
2 σ𝑃
𝜎𝑥
σ𝑃 𝜎𝑦
2]
Parameter Ρ was constrained within the range -1 to 1 by substituting it for a latent variable 𝑙Ρ . The
latent variable was transformed within the model as follows:
Ρ = 2 ∗ 𝑁𝐶𝐷𝐹(𝑙Ρ, 0,1) − 1
(18
Difference of Gaussians
We created versions of the circular, elliptical and elliptical + rotation models which used a Difference
of Gaussians response function (Rodieck, 1965; Zuiderbaan et al., 2012). The existing Gaussian
distribution was complemented by a second distribution, which had certain constraints to ensure
that it would act as an inhibitory surround. For the basic case of a circular receptive field, the
modified response function was as follows:
𝑧(𝑡) = 𝛽𝑐 ∑ 𝑁(𝑝𝑖μ, Σc)
− 𝛽𝑠 ∑ 𝑁(𝑝𝑖μ, Σs)
𝑝𝑖∈𝑈𝑡
𝑝𝑖∈𝑈𝑡
Σ𝑐 = [𝜎2
0
0
𝜎2]
Σs = [
2)
(𝜎2 + 𝜎𝑑
0
0
]
2)
(𝜎2 + 𝜎𝑑
(19
𝛽𝑠 = max(𝛽𝑐 − 𝛽𝑑, 0)
(βc, βd, σd) > 0
13
Here, the neuronal response 𝑧 was the difference of two normal distributions. The first represented
the excitatory response of the centre of the pRF. It was parameterised by scaling parameter 𝛽𝑐,
centre location 𝜇 and covariance matrix Σ𝑐. The second normal distribution represented the
inhibitory surround of the pRF. It has the same location as the excitatory centre 𝜇, but different
scaling 𝛽𝑠 and covariance Σ𝑠. The difference in scaling between the two pRFs was controlled by
parameter 𝛽𝑑 and the difference in the pRFs' widths was controlled by the parameter 𝜎𝑑. Positivity
constraints were enforced on the 𝛽 scaling parameters and 𝜎𝑑. This formulation, which introduced 2
new free parameters compared to the previous model (𝛽𝑑, 𝜎𝑑), ensured that the response of the
centre was positive and the response of the surround was negative.
Using a latent variable, we constrained parameter 𝜎𝑑 to fall into the range [0 𝑟] with a flat prior. The
difference in scaling of the surround relative to the centre of the pRF, 𝛽𝑠, was constrained to be
positive using a log parameter. This translated to a prior expectation for 𝛽𝑠 of 0.05 with 95%
confidence interval [0.001 1.97].
2.9.8 Bayesian model comparison
We compared the evidence for our data under 6 different pRF models, using the free energy,
described above. For each voxel we had 6 numbers - the free energy of each competing model -
which we collated into a [voxels x 6] matrix. We submitted this matrix for analysis using a random
effects (RFX) model (Stephan et al., 2009). Typically, this approach is used in the context of studying
groups of subjects. One assumes that each subject's data were generated by one of the models in
the comparison, and the RFX model estimates the probability that any randomly selected subject's
data were generated by each model. These are known as the expected probabilities of each model.
Additionally, it gives the probability that any one model is better than all the others in the
comparison – these are the protected exceedance probabilities. (The word 'protected' refers to a
statistical correction to account for the possibility that all models are equally likely (Rigoux et al.,
2014).) Here, we simply used multiple voxels instead of multiple subjects, and the RFX model
identified which pRF best explained the data in spatially extended regions of the brain.
After performing model comparison at the level of all included voxels, we next performed
comparisons on a region of interest (ROI) basis. We used anatomical masks supplied with the SPM
Anatomy Toolbox version 2.2b (Eickhoff et al., 2005), which were defined based on
cytoarchitectonic observations from a series of studies (Amunts et al., 2000; Kujovic et al., 2013;
Malikovic et al., 2015; Rottschy et al., 2007). These regions were hOC1, hOC2, hOC3d, hOC4d,
hOC3v, hOC4v, hOC4la and hOC4lp. The closest corresponding functionally defined regions are V1,
V2, V3d, V3a, V3v, V4v, LO-1 and LO-2 respectively, however this correspondence between
cytoarchitecture and function is not exact, nor does it take into account between-subjects variability.
We made one modification to the masks, which was to split the hOC2 mask into dorsal and ventral
parts to give hOC2d and hOC2v, situated either side of hOC1. We inverse warped each mask from
MNI space into the native space of our subject and used these custom masks to constrain our model
comparisons.
Strictly, the RFX procedure described above assumes that the sources of data (the voxels) are
independent. This assumption was violated here due to the spatial smoothness of the fMRI data, but
nonetheless this method allowed us to provide summary measures for each ROI (see section 3.5.2).
For completeness, we repeated the pRF analyses and model comparison while removing the issue of
spatial smoothness assumptions, by using the mean timeseries for each ROI rather than each
14
individual voxel. We initially found the model fits to be very poor. This was because the prior on
observation noise (log precision of 4) was no longer realistic – averaging over voxels had essentially
eliminated any zero-mean Gaussian noise (due to central limit theorem). We therefore increased the
prior log precision of the noise to 10, effectively stating that in these averaged timeseries, we did not
expect there to be any (zero-mean Gaussian) observation noise. The results of this analysis are
illustrated in Supplemental Figure 1 and are summarised in Section 3.5.2 of the results.
3 Results
3.1 Parameter estimates
After estimating a pRF model for each voxel, we produced maps of the parameters (Figure 3). These
confirmed that the parameters were in keeping with established properties of visual cortex. There
was a gradient of pRF centre position, from the periphery to the fovea, along the midline of occipital
cortex (Figure 3, left) and each hemisphere responded to the contralateral visual field (Figure 3,
middle). pRF widths were estimated to be smallest in early visual cortex, becoming larger as one
descends into temporal cortex (Figure 3, right).
Figure 3 Parameter maps after estimating the basic pRF model. Left: Distance of the pRF centre from the middle of the
visual field (eccentricity), with colours indicating degrees of visual angle, projected onto a sagittal slice of the subject's
structural MRI, close to the midline. Middle: Polar angle of the pRF within the visual field, with units of radians, shown in the
axial plane. Right: Width parameter (standard deviation), with the colour bar indicating degrees of visual angle - smaller
pRFs are in blue, larger in red. Maps thresholded at model posterior probability > 0.95 (see methods Section 2.9.1).
The remaining parameters controlled the scaling of the neuronal response (𝛽), the transit time (𝜏),
the rate of decay (𝜅) and ratio of intra- to extra-vascular signal (𝜖), all of which were estimated on a
voxel-wise basis together with the pRF parameters. To investigate whether estimating the
neurovascular / haemodynamic response on a voxel-wise basis was justified – i.e. whether there was
variation across voxels – we calculated the estimated BOLD impulse response function for each voxel
and summarised these responses by their mean and standard deviation (Figure 4). This revealed
considerable variability in the height of the peak across voxels, emphasising the importance of
estimating haemodynamic as well as neuronal parameters in the model.
15
Figure 4 The variability of the estimated BOLD impulse response function across voxels, in response to a stimulus at time 0
of duration 0. The solid line is the mean across voxels and the shaded area is mean +- 1 standard deviation across voxels.
The prior response, posterior response and fitted timeseries for an example voxel are shown in
Figure 5. In Figure 5A, the response of the pRF model is shown for each point in retinotopic space,
with the model's parameters set to their prior means and variances. To account for uncertainty, we
sampled from the parameters according to their prior probability distributions, then generated the
pRF response based on the sampled parameters. Repeating this 1000 times and averaging the
responses gave the prior Predictive Density (PD) shown. Figure 5B shows the response of the model
with parameters estimated from the data (the posterior parameters), demonstrating a punctate pRF
estimate in the left visual field. This plot again takes into account uncertainty over the parameters
through sampling (the posterior PD). Strikingly, the uncertainty visible as the diffuse pattern in the
prior PD has been explained away after seeing the data. This close fit to the data can be also be seen
qualitatively in the modelled timeseries (Figure 5C). We noted that the post-stimulus undershoot in
the BOLD response was not well captured, which is a known limitation of the haemodynamic model
we are applying (Havlicek et al., 2015). We return to this issue in the discussion.
16
Figure 5 Estimated pRF and fitted timeseries for an example voxel in putative right V1 (voxel 14381). A. The response of the
model to each position in visual space prior to Bayesian model fitting. This is the prior Predictive Density (PD), which uses
sampling to take into account uncertainty over the parameters. The prior model parameters were sampled 1000 times and
the predicted responses generated and averaged. The units of the axes are degrees of visual angle. B. The posterior PD,
which is the estimated pRF response after Bayesian estimation. C. The modelled timeseries (red) and observed timeseries
(grey).
3.2 Correlation and entropy
A key advantage of the Bayesian approach is that the uncertainty of each parameter (the variance) is
estimated, as is the covariance among parameters. The covariance is important because parameters
which strongly covary cannot be precisely estimated, and this uncertainty should be taken into
account when making inferences. To investigate the covariance among parameters, we averaged
models over voxels using Bayesian Parameter Averaging (see methods Section 2.9.4) and then
transformed the averaged covariance matrix to give a correlation matrix. This is shown in Figure 6,
where the upper left quadrant shows the correlations among neuronal (pRF) parameters, the
bottom right quadrant shows correlations among haemodynamic parameters and the top right
quadrant shows the correlation between neuronal and haemodynamic parameters.
Reassuringly, the parameters representing the location of the pRF in visual space (𝑙𝜌, 𝑙𝜃) had only
weak correlation with other parameters. However, the pRF width parameter 𝜎 was strongly
correlated with the scaling parameter 𝑙𝛽 (Pearson's correlation 0.63). In practice, this means that
one could increase the pRF width or increase the scaling parameter and, to some extent, get the
same change in the predicted timeseries. This phenomenon is not specific to the Bayesian approach
proposed here, and may be of concern for any pRF estimation method, despite this correlation not
generally being quantified. The correlation matrix also revealed statistical dependencies among the
haemodynamic parameters, as well as between the scaling parameter 𝑙𝛽 and the haemodynamic
parameters. In practice, correlations among the haemodynamic parameters are unlikely to be a
problem, as experimenters rarely need to make inferences about these parameters individually.
17
Figure 6 Correlation among model parameters (latent variables), averaged over voxels. There were 4 neuronal (pRF)
parameters (𝜌, 𝜃, 𝜎, 𝛽) and 3 neuro-vascular / haemodynamic parameters (𝜏, 𝜅, 𝜖). Only values with an absolute value
greater than 0.01 are labelled.
Having covariance among parameters induces uncertainty in the parameter estimates, in addition to
any uncertainty induced by observation noise. Next, we mapped this uncertainty by computing the
entropy for each pRF model, where more positive values indicate greater uncertainty about the
parameter estimates. We computed separate entropy maps for the pRF location (𝑙𝜌, 𝑙𝜃) and width
(𝑙𝜎) parameters. The entropy map for pRF location (Figure 7, top) showed that we could be most
certain about the position of the pRF in early visual cortex, and as one moves laterally or descends
into temporal cortex, the uncertainty increases. There was less confidence overall for pRF width than
for pRF location – the minimum entropy was -5.75 nats for pRF width compared to -18.99 nats for
pRF location (lower is more confident). Surprisingly, in early visual cortex - where we would
expected to have been most certain about pRF width - we were in fact least certain (Figure 7,
bottom). This could be because smaller pRFs, which typify early visual cortex, require higher
resolution stimuli in order to gain confident estimates about their size. Additionally, uncertainty over
pRF width may have been induced by covariance with the scaling parameter 𝑙𝛽, identified above.
18
Figure 7 Entropy maps showing uncertainty over the pRF location (top) and uncertainty over the pRF width (bottom) after
estimation of the models. More positive values (red) indicate greater uncertainty. Colours indicate entropy in units of nats.
3.3 Face validity
We next performed two forms of validation: we used simulations to establish the face validity of the
approach and we used empirical data to evaluate test-retest reliability across runs.
We fitted pRF models to 1000 simulated timeseries where the 'true' parameters which generated
the data were known, under varying levels of observation noise. The expected values of the pRF
position, width and neuronal scaling parameters closely matched the true parameters (Figure 8,
left), with the width and beta parameters only dropping markedly in accuracy below an SNR of 0.75.
While all correlations were highly significant (all p < 4.96e-4), the neurovascular / haemodynamic
parameters (𝜏, 𝜅, 𝜖) were estimated less accurately and were more sensitive to the SNR than the pRF
parameters. This may have been due to the covariance among the haemodynamic parameters,
reducing the identifiability of their expected values. The accuracy of the 𝜃 polar angle parameter
was slightly lower than we had expected (correlation 0.96 at maximum SNR). We found this was an
artefact of the use of polar coordinates. There were pRFs with parameter 𝜃 close to – 𝜋 radians in
the test set and close to +𝜋 radians in the validation set, or vice versa. Despite being adjacent in
visual space, the difference in sign reduced the test-reliability. When we corrected for this by
converting from polar to Cartesian coordinates, accuracy of the 𝜃 parameter was at ceiling
(correlation 1.00) for SNR 1.56, SNR 1.25 and SNR 1, reducing to correlation 0.99 at SNR 0.75 and
correlation 0.97 at SNR 0.5.
We also investigated the accuracy of the estimated uncertainty of the parameters (Bayesian
confidence intervals). We anticipated that the posterior 95% confidence interval of each parameter
would include the "true" parameter which generated the simulated data, approximately 95% of the
time. For each level of SNR and for each parameter, we computed the fraction of the 1000 voxels
which included the 'true' parameter in their estimated 95% confidence interval (Figure 8B). At the
estimated SNR of our data (SNR 1.56), the confidence intervals behaved as expected. With reducing
SNR, the accuracy of the confidence intervals decayed slowly (in particular the width parameter),
19
perhaps due to the appearance of local optima in the parameter space, coupled with the correlation
among certain parameters. However, overall, these results demonstrate that our estimates of
uncertainty were robust to noise, even for the haemodynamic parameters which had the least
accurate expected values.
Figure 8 Accuracy of parameter estimates assessed by simulation. Left: Pearson's correlations between the parameters
used to simulate data and parameters estimated from those simulated data. The vertical axis lists 5 levels of observation
noise, quantified as the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). Darker colours indicate lower correlations. Parameters as for Figure 6.
Right: The percentage of voxels where the estimated 95% (posterior) confidence interval contained the parameter which
generated the data.
3.4 Test-retest reliability
Next we tested the consistency of the parameter estimates across scanning runs on empirical data.
The main analysis, above, used only the 8 odd-numbered runs. Here we used the 8 even-numbered
runs as a validation set, correlating parameter estimates from each half of the data on a voxel-wise
basis. Note that this made a strong assumption about the success of coregistration – it assumed that
the voxels in all runs were perfectly aligned. Nevertheless, the correlation between parameter
estimates from odd- and even-numbered runs was strong (Table 1). Converting from polar
coordinates (𝜌, 𝜃) to Cartesian coordinates (𝜇𝑥, 𝜇𝑦) raised the test-retest accuracy to 0.98 and 0.95
for the 𝜇𝑥 and 𝜇𝑦 coordinates respectively.
Table 1: Correlations between parameters estimated from alternating runs
𝜌
𝜃
𝜎
𝛽
𝜏
𝜅
𝜖
Pearson's
correlation
0.92
0.89
0.85
0.90
0.89
0.88
0.83
20
3.5 Model comparison
Having validated the modelling framework, we next used it to ask two questions. First, we asked
whether the neuronal population within each voxel had only an excitatory response to stimuli within
their receptive fields, or whether they also exhibited an inhibitory response at the periphery of their
receptive fields. We represented these two alternatives using models with a single Gaussian
response function, and models with a Difference of Gaussians (DoG) response function with an
excitatory centre and inhibitory surround, as has previously been introduced (Zuiderbaan et al.,
2012). We also asked which of three shapes of receptive field would offer the best explanation for
our data – circular (Model 1), elliptical (Model 2), or elliptical with rotation (Model 3). We formally
addressed these questions by comparing the evidence for the data under competing models
(Bayesian model comparison). The model that wins in such a comparison is the model that strikes
the optimal balance between accuracy and complexity.
We formed a model space akin to a 2x3 factorial design. The first factor was the response function:
models either had a single Gaussian or a DoG response function. The second factor was the shape of
the receptive field (x3). We specified each of these 6 models and estimated the free energy (log
model evidence) within each voxel. Thus, we had six free energies per voxel, representing the
relative evidence for each model, which we pooled across voxels using a random effects analysis
(see methods section 2.9.8 for details).
3.5.1 Whole volume analysis
Figure 9A shows the expected probability of each model. If a voxel were picked at random, these are
the probabilities of each model having generated that data. The model with the strongest probability
was the DoG Model 1 – that is, a model with circular receptive field and excitatory / inhibitory
dynamics. Thus, if choosing a voxel at random, there would be a 55% chance that DoG model 1
would be the best model, 𝑝(𝑚𝑦) = 0.55. The next best model was the single Gaussian Model 1,
with 𝑝(𝑚𝑦) = 0.29. The remaining models all had much weaker probability. Figure 9B shows the
Protected Exceedance Probability (PXP), which is the probability that any one model is better than all
other models in the comparison. With probability approaching certainty, DoG Model 1 was the
winning model, and therefore the best explanation for any randomly chosen voxel's data. An
example timeseries fitted by DoG Model 1 is shown in Figure 9C. Together, this comparison
demonstrates that DoG is a better explanation than a single Gaussian model overall, and having
elliptical and angled pRFs does not, at the level of the whole visual cortex, contribute enough to the
model evidence to outweigh the added complexity they induce.
21
Figure 9 Comparison of 6 pRF models across all included voxels. Models either had a single Gaussian or Difference of Gaussians
(DoG) receptive field (rows) and were circular (Model 1), elliptical (Model 2) or elliptical with rotation (Model 3), shown in the
columns. A. The expected probability of each model. B. The protected exceedance probability (PXP) of each model, which is
the probability that each model is better than the all the others in the comparison. C. An example timeseries for the winning
model (DoG Model 1), fitted to data from the same voxel as shown in Figure 5.
3.5.2 Regions of interest analysis
We next investigated whether the 6 competing pRF models had different explanatory power in
different brain regions. We repeated the model comparison within each of 9 regions of interest,
based on predefined (cytoarchitecturally defined) anatomical masks.
In most regions (hOC1, hOC2d, left hOC2v, hOC3d, hOC3v, hOC4lp), a DoG model rather than a
single Gaussian model best explained the data (Figure 10, black grids). The single Gaussian models
were preferred in right hOC2v, hOC4d, right hOC4v and hOC4la. The result in left hOC4v was
ambiguous, with 𝑥𝑝 = 0.36 for Gaussian Model 1 and 𝑥𝑝 = 0.64 for DoG Model 1, which may
indicate a heterogeneous population of response in this region. So with regards to our first question
of whether there was evidence for an excitatory-inhibitory receptive field, we can conclude that this
was the case in most regions lower in the visual hierarchy, however the benefit was not seen in the
majority of the highest level regions we modelled, where a simpler Gaussian model was selected as
the winner.
Our second question regarded the shape of the receptive field. In most regions (hOC1, hOC2d,
hOC3d, hOC4d, hOC2v, hOC3v, left hOC4v, hOC4lp), the model with a simple circular receptive field
(Model 1) was the winner. Therefore, modelling an elliptical shape and rotation did not improve the
model fit sufficiently to outweigh the added complexity. The clear exception was bilateral hOC4la,
where there was strong evidence (PXP > 0.99) that the single Gaussian angled model (Model 3) was
the winner. In right hOC4v, the evidence was divided between the Model 1 and Model 3.
Having identified the best model in each region, we next visualised the extent of the visual field
covered by these models' receptive fields. For each ROI, we summed the (posterior) receptive field
of the overall winning model across voxels, to form coverage maps (Figure 10, right columns). This
22
confirmed that each pRF responded primarily to the contralateral side of retinotopic space, with
dorsal regions responding to the lower visual field and ventral regions responding to the upper visual
field. Lateral regions responded preferentially to the lower visual field, and strikingly, the coverage
area of the bilateral hOC4la models was angled towards the fovea. To quantify the angle estimates
in hOC4la, we averaged the parameters across voxels using Bayesian Parameter Averaging. This gave
a probability distribution representing the average correlation coefficient (rotation parameter), with
an expected value of 0.08 in left hemisphere and -0.37 right hemisphere. The probability that these
parameters were non-zero were 0.99 and 1.00 respectively.
Figure 10 Results of comparing 6 different pRF models (black grids in the left 2 columns) in 9 regions of interest. Left
columns: Each grid shows a 2x3 factorial model space. The models either employed a 2D Gaussian distribution or a
Difference of Gaussians (DoG). For each type there were three variants: Circular (Model 1), Elliptical (Model 2) or Elliptical
with Rotation (Model 3). The shades of grey / white and labels indicate the Protected Exceedance Probability (PXP), which is
the probability that a model is better than all the others being tested. Right columns: The summed pRFs of the winning
model within each region (see text for details). Colours are scaled within each plot individually, representing arbitrary units
of neuronal activity. Region identities are detailed in Section 2.9.8.
Finally, we performed an analysis to investigate whether similar results would be found by fitting
pRF models to the mean timeseries of each region, rather than fitting a pRF model to every voxel
independently (Supplementary Figure 1). Note that the model which best explains the average
response for an extended region is not necessarily the model which best explains individual voxels'
timeseries, due to variability across voxels in pRF response (Figure 3). Nonetheless, in this analysis
using far less data, every region with the exception of left hOC1 favoured a DoG rather than a
Gaussian response function. Whereas individual voxels' receptive fields were best described with a
circular model (DoG Model 1, Figure 10), the averaged timeseries in most regions were best
explained with an angled and rotated receptive field (DoG Model 3). The pRF response functions in
23
most regions were remarkably similar to the summed voxel-level response functions shown in Figure
10.
4 Discussion
In this paper we introduced a Bayesian framework for specifying, estimating and comparing pRF
models. The framework is generic and so can be applied to stimulus spaces of any dimension; here
we evaluated it for mapping 2D visual receptive fields. Having validated the method using both
simulations and a simple evaluation of test-retest reliability, we demonstrated how it may be used
to test hypotheses about neuronal response functions, at the voxel level and within predefined
regions of interest.
A key advantage of this approach is that the uncertainty of each parameter estimate is estimated, by
computing the full covariance matrix of the parameters. This gave rise to a striking observation –
there was a strong correlation between the neuronal scaling parameter 𝑙𝛽 and the pRF width
parameter 𝑙𝜎. In other words, increasing either parameter would, to a certain extent, give the same
change in the modelled BOLD response, which limits the precision with which either can be
estimated. An appropriate way of dealing with this is to take account of the uncertainty when
making inferences. Here, we did this by plotting the pRF's posterior predictive density (PD) to
visualise the receptive field, which represents the uncertainty in the pRF position and width. This
made clear that with the relatively high SNR data we used, which had been scanned at 7T and
averaged over 8 runs, the receptive field was estimated with high precision despite the covariance
between parameters. It will be interesting to see how the precision of the parameters vary when
acquiring empirical data at lower field strengths. As suggested by our simulations, with reduced SNR,
taking uncertainty into account becomes increasingly important.
In the generative model implemented here, we included an established model of neurovascular
coupling and BOLD response. Whereas most pRF studies use a canonical haemodynamic response
function, which may be tailored on a subject-by-subject basis, we estimated parameters of the
haemodynamic model simultaneously with the pRF parameters, on a voxel-wise basis. (Readers
familiar with Dynamic Causal Modelling will note that we are effectively estimating a single region
DCM for every voxel.) This comes with a computational cost – estimation takes longer than standard
approaches to pRF estimation. However, our results demonstrate the utility of this voxel-wise
model. There was considerable variability in the peak (and to a lesser degree, the undershoot) of the
BOLD response across voxels (Figure 4), which would not be modelled using a fixed BOLD response
across voxels. Reassuringly, the parameters of the haemodynamic model were only weakly
correlated with the parameters representing the pRF location and width (Figure 6), meaning
neuronal and haemodynamic contributions to the BOLD timeseries can be separated with high
confidence.
We demonstrated testing hypotheses about pRF response function or shape by embodying each
hypothesis as a model and comparing the evidence for each. It has previously been stated that "pRF
models…are not centered on statistical hypothesis testing…Rather, the strategy follows the
constructivist philosophy of creating models to account for an increasingly large range of stimuli in
many visual areas." (Wandell and Winawer, 2015, p. 350). Developing pRF models that are as
general as possible requires identifying those which offer the best trade-off between accuracy and
complexity. A penalty for complexity (also called an Occam factor) is required when comparing
models, otherwise the most complex model will always be considered the best (explain the most
variance), at the risk of overfitting the noise and failing to generalise. Finding the best of several
models in terms of balancing accuracy and complexity is achieved by identifying the model with the
24
highest model evidence, a procedure referred to as Bayesian model comparison. Here we used an
approximation of the model evidence, the free energy, to score models. Unlike other
approximations such as the AIC and BIC, the free energy takes into account the full covariance
among parameters (Penny, 2012), which reflects the fact that independent parameters contribute
more to a model's complexity than correlated parameters.
Using Bayesian model comparison, we first asked whether the response in each voxel is best
described as a single multivariate normal distribution, or as a Difference of Gaussians (DoG) model
with excitatory centre and inhibitory surround (Rodieck, 1965; Zuiderbaan et al., 2012). The DoG
model had previously been found to explain more variance in V1, V2 and V3, but offered little or no
improvement in higher level regions V3a, hV4 and LO1 (Zuiderbaan et al., 2012). Similarly, using
Bayesian model comparison, we found DoG models to be better than single Gaussian models in
cytoarchitecturally defined regions roughly corresponding to V1, V2 and V3, with the exception of
right hOC2v, where there was strong evidence for the basic single Gaussian model. In higher level
regions, we found strong evidence for the simpler single Gaussian model. This was the case in region
hOC4d (which may mostly closely align with V3a of Zuiderbaan et al. (2012)) and region hOC4la
(which may align with LO-1). The fact that we found strong evidence for a simpler model in higher
regions, and Zuiderbaan et al. (2012) found little or no difference in explained variance in these
higher regions, speaks to the notion that the model evidence will favour the simpler model unless
there are sufficient gains in accuracy to outweigh the added complexity.
We found that the single Gaussian pRF model, coupled with the Balloon model of BOLD response,
failed to capture the majority of the post-stimulus undershoot in the BOLD response (Figure 5C).
These parts of the timeseries appear to have fitted slightly better using a DoG model, and may
coincide with the inhibitory activity in centre-surround dynamics (Figure 9C), although a noticeable
post-stimulus undershoot remains unmodelled. A recently proposed upgrade to the BOLD response
model we used here offers a more physiologically plausible representation of the post-stimulus
undershoot (Havlicek et al., 2015), which could be included in our framework. Model comparisons
could then be performed to ensure that there is still strong evidence for a DoG neuronal response
function, in the context of a haemodynamic model which better explains the BOLD undershoot.
Having identified the DoG model as being preferred in most regions, our second question regarded
the shape of the receptive field. We compared three receptive field shapes – circular, elliptical and
elliptical with rotation – and tested the evidence for models with these specifications in sub-regions
of the brain. In most regions, a simple circular model was the winner - meaning the data could not
support a more complex explanation involving an elliptical shape or rotation. We could only be
confident that a more complex model was the winner in bilateral V4la. Coverage maps (Figure 10,
right) showed that the pRFs in these regions covered an area of the contralateral lower visual field,
which were angled towards the fovea. While anatomically defined region V4la was proposed to
correspond to functionally defined region LO-1 (Malikovic et al., 2015), it may be more closely
related to region of V3B of Smith et al (Smith et al., 1998), which was defined as responding to the
contralateral lower hemifield. For a detailed discussion on the definitions of regions within LOC, we
refer readers to Larsson and Heeger (2006).
We do not wish to draw strong conclusions from these region-of-interest analyses, as we were only
using data from a single subject, and we did not use functionally-defined regions demarcated on the
cortical surface. Indeed, these results may suggest limitations to the correspondence between
anatomically defined and retinotopically defined regions. For instance, hOC4d has been suggested to
align with functional region V3a (Kujovic et al., 2013). However, V3a has a full hemifield
representation, whereas in our results we only found coverage of the lower hemifield. These
25
uncertainties will be resolved by extending this modelling framework to operate at the cortical
surface, so that subject-specific visual regions can be delineated. With the analyses presented here,
we simply hope to have demonstrated that pRF models can be formerly compared based on their
model evidence and summarised within regions of interest, to address interesting hypotheses. We
found that, of the models we tested, the most parsimonious (simplest) model that explained the
most data was a Difference of Gaussians model with a circular (isotropic) receptive field (Figure 9).
A limitation on the explanatory power of the pRF model used here, and of pRF models more
generally, is that they are phenomenological. They are very effective at describing the summed
receptive field of a voxel or a brain region, but they give no insight into how this receptive field
arises from the underlying neuronal circuitry. Developments in modelling neuronal circuitry using
functional imaging data, Dynamic Causal Modelling (Friston, 2003), have come about by iteratively
developing models which afford greater model evidence than their predecessors. By providing a
framework for evaluating models, we hope to facilitate the development of biologically plausible
generative models for pRFs. These are likely to be spatiotemporal models which explain how lateral
connections between neuronal populations give rise to the distributed pattern of activity across the
cortical sheet. Neural field models (Moran et al., 2013; Pinotsis and Friston, 2011), which have so far
been applied in the context of magneto- and electro-encephalography recordings, offer a first step in
this direction.
Future work will be in several directions. Estimation speed of the pRF models was generally over 100
seconds per voxel (around 2 hours, 40 minutes in total on the 192-core cluster computer we used to
estimate 14,395 voxels). As such, we expect this framework to be primarily used in a voxel-wise
manner for small regions of interest, or alternatively on summary timeseries (the mean or first
principal component) from regions of interest, although the latter is not guaranteed to identical
results (Supplementary Figure 1). However, there may be opportunities for software optimisation,
for instancing removing the overhead of converting between polar and Cartesian coordinates. In the
meantime, we have addressed the performance issue by providing software tools for distributed
model estimation over parallel processors (Appendix A), and in future this could be extended to take
advantage of massively parallel GPU computing, which has already been demonstrated in the
context of Dynamic Causal Modelling (Aponte et al., 2016). It would also be helpful to develop
integration with the Freesurfer software package, to enable projection of results to the cortical
surface. In terms of applications, the main focus of our ongoing efforts will be to model higher
dimensional spaces. The generality of the approach makes it ideally suited to mapping multimodal or
abstract stimulus spaces onto the brain, with any number of model parameters. We hope that the
tools we have implemented (Appendix A) will be useful to researchers in a variety of fields.
5 Appendix A: Software implementation
We have developed a suite of software tools for specifying, estimating and comparing pRF models.
These are Matlab functions which depend on the open-source SPM software package
(http://www.fil.ion.ucl.ac.uk/spm/), and use the same underlying algorithms as Dynamic Causal
Modelling (Friston, 2003). This toolbox forms the reference implementation of the Bayesian
framework we have described, although we hope to have given sufficient detail in the manuscript
that it could be re-implemented in other software packages. The BayespRF toolbox is available from
https://github.com/pzeidman/BayespRF .
The toolbox is structured around a series of operators which act upon pRF models. A pRF model,
together with one or more timeseries, is represented as a Matlab structure and is stored in a file
with the format PRF_<name>.mat. A typical workflow proceeds as follows. One performs an initial
26
analysis using a general linear model (GLM) to identify voxels to take forward for pRF analysis (Figure
2). Timeseries are then extracted using the 'Eigenvariate' button in SPM, which also performs all the
necessary pre-processing. The resulting file (VOI_<name>.mat) contains both a summary timeseries
of all included voxels, and individual timeseries for each voxel. Next, one specifies a pRF model using
spm_prf_analyse('specify',…), which provides options for whether to use a summary timeseries or
individual voxels' timeseries. If averaging over runs is required, this will be performed at this stage.
The model evidence and parameters may then be estimated using spm_prf_analyse('estimate',…).
The results of the estimation are reviewed and projected onto 3D orthogonal projections of the
brain using the GUI spm_prf_review(…), which will create parameter maps (as shown in Figure 3) if
they do not already exist.
If there are a large number of voxels to be estimated, it may be more tractable to use parallel
computing and estimate pRF models for multiple voxels simultaneously. The toolbox provides two
methods for this. The estimation function has an option 'useparfor', which will take advantage of the
Mathworks Parallel Computing Toolbox, if available. Alternatively, a function is provided to take a
multi-voxel pRF file and split it into multiple pRF files: spm_prf_analyse('split',…). These individual
pRF files can be estimated on separate machines, for instance on separate nodes of a cluster
computer, and then merged once estimation is complete using spm_prf_analyse('merge',…). The
results of the merged pRF file may then be reviewed.
Within the pRF model file are stored the priors, posteriors, timeseries data and model configuration.
A summary of the most important fields are given in Table A1. Users wishing to design new pRF
models, or modify the current ones, may wish to take advantage of the spm_prf_editor tool, which
provides a GUI for manipulating the parameters of a model.
Table A1: Key fields within the Matlab structure representing a pRF model
Field
M.pE
M.pC
M.IS
Y.y
xY.XYZmm
U
Ep
Cp
Eh
F
Description
Prior mean (expectation) of each parameter
Prior covariance of the parameters
Name of the pRF model function to use
Matrix of timeseries data against which to
estimate the model
Coordinates (mm) of each timeseries in the
brain
[1 x T] structure representing the T stimuli
displayed during scanning, including onsets,
durations and coordinates of stimulated pixels
Estimated parameters for each voxel
Estimated covariance of the parameters for
each voxel
Estimated log precision of the noise
Variational free energy (approximate evidence)
of the model for each voxel
27
6 References
Amunts, K., Malikovic, a, Mohlberg, H., Schormann, T., Zilles, K., 2000. Brodmann's areas 17 and 18
brought into stereotaxic space-where and how variable? Neuroimage 11, 66–84.
doi:10.1006/nimg.1999.0516
Aponte, E.A., Raman, S., Sengupta, B., Penny, W.D., Stephan, K.E., Heinzle, J., 2016. Mpdcm: A
toolbox for massively parallel dynamic causal modeling. J. Neurosci. Methods 257, 7–16.
doi:10.1016/j.jneumeth.2015.09.009
Azzopardi, P., Cowey, A., 1993. Preferential representation of the fovea in the primary visual cortex.
Nature 361, 719–721. doi:10.1038/361719a0
Beal, M.J., Ghahramani, Z., 2003. The variational Bayesian EM algorithm for incomplete data: with
application to scoring graphical model structures. Bayesian Stat. 7. doi:10.1152/jn.00664.2010
Buxton, R.B., Uludag, K., Dubowitz, D.J., Liu, T.T., 2004. Modeling the hemodynamic response to
brain activation. Neuroimage 23 Suppl 1, S220–33. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2004.07.013
Constantinescu, A.O., O'Reilly, J.X., Behrens, T.E.J., 2016. Organizing conceptual knowledge in
humans with a gridlike code. Science (80-. ). 352, 1464–1468. doi:10.1126/science.aaf0941
Dumoulin, S.O., Wandell, B.A., 2008. Population receptive field estimates in human visual cortex.
Neuroimage 39, 647–660. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2007.09.034
Eickhoff, S.B., Stephan, K.E., Mohlberg, H., Grefkes, C., Fink, G.R., Amunts, K., Zilles, K., 2005. A new
SPM toolbox for combining probabilistic cytoarchitectonic maps and functional imaging data.
Neuroimage 25, 1325–1335. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2004.12.034
Friston, K., Mattout, J., Trujillo-Barreto, N., Ashburner, J., Penny, W., 2007. Variational free energy
and the Laplace approximation. Neuroimage 34, 220–234.
doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2006.08.035
Friston, K., Penny, W., 2011. Post hoc Bayesian model selection. Neuroimage 56, 2089–2099.
doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.03.062
Friston, K.J., 2003. Dynamic causal modelling. Neuroimage 19, 1273–1302. doi:10.1016/S1053-
8119(03)00202-7
Friston, K.J., Josephs, O., Rees, G., Turner, R., 1998. Nonlinear event-related responses in fMRI.
Magn. Reson. Med. 39, 41–52. doi:10.1002/mrm.1910390109
Havlicek, M., Roebroeck, A., Friston, K., Gardumi, A., Ivanov, D., Uludag, K., 2015. Physiologically
informed dynamic causal modeling of fMRI data. Neuroimage.
doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2015.07.078
He, D., Mo, C., Wang, Y., Fang, F., 2015. Position shifts of fMRI-based population receptive fields in
human visual cortex induced by Ponzo illusion. Exp. Brain Res. 233, 3535–3541.
doi:10.1007/s00221-015-4425-3
28
Heinzle, J., Koopmans, P.J., den Ouden, H.E.M., Raman, S., Stephan, K.E., 2016. A hemodynamic
model for layered BOLD signals. Neuroimage 125, 556–570.
doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2015.10.025
Holmes, G., 1945. Ferrier Lecture: the organization of the visual cortex in man. Proc. R. Soc. London.
Ser. B, 361, 2239–59. doi:10.1098/rstb.2006.1832
Hubel, D.H., Wiesel, T.N., 1959. Receptive fields of single neurones in the cat's striate cortex. J.
Physiol. 148, 574–591. doi:10.1113/jphysiol.2009.174151
Kujovic, M., Zilles, K., Malikovic, A., Schleicher, A., Mohlberg, H., Rottschy, C., Eickhoff, S.B., Amunts,
K., 2013. Cytoarchitectonic mapping of the human dorsal extrastriate cortex. Brain Struct.
Funct. 218, 157–172. doi:10.1007/s00429-012-0390-9
Kumar, S., Penny, W., Sommer, F.T., Wennekers, T., Wang, X., 2014. Estimating neural response
functions from fMRI. doi:10.3389/fninf.2014.00048
Larsson, J., Heeger, D.J., 2006. Two retinotopic visual areas in human lateral occipital cortex. J.
Neurosci. 26, 13128–42. doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1657-06.2006
Levin, N., Dumoulin, S.O., Winawer, J., Dougherty, R.F., Wandell, B.A., 2010. Cortical Maps and White
Matter Tracts following Long Period of Visual Deprivation and Retinal Image Restoration.
Neuron 65, 21–31. doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2009.12.006
Malikovic, A., Amunts, K., Schleicher, A., Mohlberg, H., Kujovic, M., Palomero-Gallagher, N., Eickhoff,
S.B., Zilles, K., 2015. Cytoarchitecture of the human lateral occipital cortex: mapping of two
extrastriate areas hOc4la and hOc4lp. Brain Struct. Funct. doi:10.1007/s00429-015-1009-8
Merzenich, M.M., Brugge, J.F., 1973. Representation of the cochlear partition on the superior
temporal plane of the macaque monkey. Brain Res. 50, 275–296. doi:10.1016/0006-
8993(73)90731-2
Moerel, M., De Martino, F., Formisano, E., 2012. Processing of Natural Sounds in Human Auditory
Cortex: Tonotopy, Spectral Tuning, and Relation to Voice Sensitivity. J. Neurosci. 32, 14205–
14216. doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1388-12.2012
Moran, R., Pinotsis, D. a, Friston, K., 2013. Neural masses and fields in dynamic causal modeling.
Front. Comput. Neurosci. 7, 57. doi:10.3389/fncom.2013.00057
Neyman, J., Pearson, E.S., 1933. On the Problem of the Most Efficient Tests of Statistical Hypotheses.
Philos. Trans. R. Soc. A Math. Phys. Eng. Sci. 231, 289–337. doi:10.1098/rsta.1933.0009
Palacci, J., Sacanna, S., Steinberg, A.P., Pine, D.J., Chaikin, P.M., Yartsev, M.M., Ulanovsky, N., 2013.
Representation of Three-Dimensional Space in the Hippocampus of Flying Bats. Science (80-. ).
340, 367–372. doi:10.1126/science.1235338
Penny, W.D., 2012. Comparing dynamic causal models using AIC, BIC and free energy. Neuroimage
59, 319–330. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.07.039
Pinotsis, D.A., Friston, K.J., 2011. Neural fields, spectral responses and lateral connections.
Neuroimage 55, 39–48. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2010.11.081
29
Rigoux, L., Stephan, K.E., Friston, K.J., Daunizeau, J., 2014. Bayesian model selection for group studies
- Revisited. Neuroimage. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.08.065
Rodieck, R.W., 1965. Quantitative analysis of cat retinal ganglion cell response to visual stimuli.
Vision Res. 5, 583–601. doi:10.1016/0042-6989(65)90033-7
Rottschy, C., Eickhoff, S.B., Schleicher, A., Mohlberg, H., Kujovic, M., Zilles, K., Amunts, K., 2007.
Ventral visual cortex in humans: Cytoarchitectonic mapping of two extrastriate areas. Hum.
Brain Mapp. 28, 1045–1059. doi:10.1002/hbm.20348
Silson, E.H., Chan, a. W.-Y., Reynolds, R.C., Kravitz, D.J., Baker, C.I., 2015. A Retinotopic Basis for the
Division of High-Level Scene Processing between Lateral and Ventral Human Occipitotemporal
Cortex. J. Neurosci. 35, 11921–11935. doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0137-15.2015
Smith, A.T., Greenlee, M.W., Singh, K.D., Kraemer, F.M., Hennig, J., 1998. The processing of first- and
second-order motion in human visual cortex assessed by functional magnetic resonance
imaging (fMRI). J Neurosci 18, 3816–30.
Stephan, K.E., Penny, W.D., Daunizeau, J., Moran, R.J., Friston, K.J., 2009. Bayesian model selection
for group studies. Neuroimage 46, 1004–17. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2009.03.025
Stephan, K.E., Weiskopf, N., Drysdale, P.M., Robinson, P.A., Friston, K.J., 2007. Comparing
hemodynamic models with DCM. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2007.07.040
Wandell, B.A., Winawer, J., 2015. Computational neuroimaging and population receptive fields.
Trends Cogn. Sci. doi:10.1016/j.tics.2015.03.009
Zuiderbaan, W., Harvey, B.M., Dumoulin, S.O., 2012. Modeling center – surround configurations in
population receptive fields using fMRI. J. Vis. 12, 1–15. doi:10.1167/12.3.10.Introduction
30
Supplementary Figure 1
Figure S1. Results of comparing 6 different pRF models (black grids in the left 2 columns) in 9 regions of interest, where the
data were the mean timecourse from each region. Regions are given their cytoarchitectonic name with the name of closest
matching functionally defined region in brackets. Left columns: Each grid shows a 2x3 factorial model space. The models
either employed a 2D Gaussian distribution or a Difference of Gaussians (DoG). For each type there were three variants:
Circular (Model 1), Elliptical (Model 2) or Elliptical with Rotation (Model 3). The shades of grey / white and labels indicate
the posterior probability of each model. Right columns: The modelled response of the winning model within each region.
Colours are scaled within each plot individually, representing arbitrary units of neuronal activity.
31
|
1911.07012 | 1 | 1911 | 2019-11-16T10:54:50 | Three cooperative mechanisms required for recovery after brain damage | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Stroke is one of the main causes of human disabilities. Experimental observations indicate that several mechanisms are activated during the recovery of functional activity after a stroke. Here we unveil how the brain recovers by explaining the role played by three mechanisms: Plastic adaptation, hyperexcitability and synaptogenesis. We consider two different damages in a neural network: A diffuse damage that simply causes the reduction of the effective system size and a localized damage, a stroke, that strongly alters the spontaneous activity of the system. Recovery mechanisms observed experimentally are implemented both separately and in a combined way. Interestingly, each mechanism contributes to the recovery to a limited extent. Only the combined application of all three together is able to recover the spontaneous activity of the undamaged system. This explains why the brain triggers independent mechanisms, whose cooperation is the fundamental ingredient for the system recovery. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | open
three cooperative mechanisms
required for recovery after brain
damage
D. Berger1, e. Varriale2, L. Michiels van Kessenich1, H. J. Herrmann3 & L. de Arcangelis4*
Stroke is one of the main causes of human disabilities. experimental observations indicate that
several mechanisms are activated during the recovery of functional activity after a stroke. Here we
unveil how the brain recovers by explaining the role played by three mechanisms: plastic adaptation,
hyperexcitability and synaptogenesis. We consider two different damages in a neural network: A
diffuse damage that simply causes the reduction of the effective system size and a localized damage,
a stroke, that strongly alters the spontaneous activity of the system. Recovery mechanisms observed
experimentally are implemented both separately and in a combined way. interestingly, each
mechanism contributes to the recovery to a limited extent. only the combined application of all three
together is able to recover the spontaneous activity of the undamaged system. this explains why the
brain triggers independent mechanisms, whose cooperation is the fundamental ingredient for the
system's recovery.
Brain strokes, caused by an interruption in blood supply1, are a leading cause of adult disability. The reduced oxy-
gen supply in localized regions, perturbing energy-dependent metabolisms, ultimately results in neuronal death2,
also affecting the activity over large regions. Experimental observations3 evidence that the ischemic core, i.e. the
region where cells are irreversibly injured, is surrounded by a region experiencing reduced blood flow, which is
termed penumbra1. This is the prime region where most of the compensatory recovery mechanisms take place4:
(1) Structural recovery after a stroke leads to the reactivation of activity dependent plasticity5. (2) Neurons in the
penumbra exhibit an increased firing rate6, named hyperexcitability, because of a reduced efficacy of GABAA syn-
apses7. (3) Growth-associated genes important in axonal sprouting are expressed shortly after a stroke8,9 leading
to long distance axonal sprouting near the ischemic injury10,11 Synaptogenesis is observed to depend on neuronal
activity4. Although a rich description of different physiological mechanisms triggered after a stroke and during
the recovery has been provided experimentally, how the observed mechanisms each work towards the recovery is
still unknown. Computational models of neural networks, which have been designed to understand the function-
ing of the brain, have up to now not looked into the implications of brain injuries and the recovery mechanisms12.
Understanding the role of each mechanism in the recovery is of fundamental importance to understand how
the brain reacts to such injuries and opens the way to boost the recovery. Here we address this open problem by
considering the main experimental observations in a neuronal network. We unveil the physiological role played
by each mechanism and evidence that only the interplay among them leads to full recovery.
Unlike higher brain functions, the spatio-temporal features of spontaneous activity in healthy brains, are not
only well described by experiments13 -- 21 but also confirmed by neuronal models22 -- 25. In particular, spontane-
ous activity exhibits a characteristic spatio-temporal pattern, critical avalanches, first observed in organotypic
cultures from coronal slices of rat cortex13. The distribution of avalanche sizes consistently exhibits the scaling
P(s) ∝ s−1.5. Critical avalanche dynamics is also found in cortical activity of awake moneys18 as well as in human
fMRI26 and MEG recordings20. Inspired in self-organized criticality (SOC)27,28, a model implementing the main
physiological features of real neurons22,29 was able to reproduce the experimental MEG spectra and avalanche
statistics. Neuronal network models implementing both short- and long-term synaptic plasticity also reproduce
neuronal avalanche behaviour at a tunable parameter critical value23,25. Spontaneous activity plays a relevant
1Computational Physics for Engineering Materials, IfB, ETH Zürich, CH, Zürich, Switzerland. 2Physics Department,
University of Naples Federico II, 80125, Naples, Italy. 3PMMH, ESPCI, 7 quai St. Bernard, 75005 Paris, France and
Departamento de Fisica, Universidade Federal do Ceará, 60451-970, Fortaleza, Ceará, Brazil. 4Dept. of Engineering,
University of Campania "Luigi Vanvitelli", 81031 Aversa (CE), INFN sez. Naples, Gr. Coll., Salerno, Italy. *email: lucilla.
[email protected]
Scientific RepoRtS (2019) 9:15858 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-50946-y
1
www.nature.com/scientificreports Figure 1. Configuration with localized damage. Configuration of a neural network (N = 200) where a 30%
localized damage is implemented: The damaged neurons (red) are surrounded by neurons of the penumbra
(green). Unaffected neurons are grey. The connections of all damaged neurons are removed. The penumbra size
is 20%N.
role in the response of a brain to a given task. Arieli et al.30 have evidenced, by combining optical imaging with
electrophysiological techniques, that in awake animals the response to repeated presentations of the same stim-
ulus depends on the instantaneous cortical state of ongoing activity. As a consequence, the observed disabilities
in brain functions after a stroke may be intimately related to alterations in the resting state. Here we address the
question how a damage affects the spontaneous activity of a neuronal network and how the system is able to
recover. In order to identify more clearly the consequence of a stroke, we investigate also the case of a damage not
localized but affecting the same number of neurons randomly distributed throughout the system. This last dam-
age condition is reminiscent of brains affected by advanced atherosclerosis or senile dementia. The physiological
mechanisms observed to take place after a stroke are implemented and their role in re-establishing the healthy
critical state is discussed evidencing the key role of cooperative effects.
Results
A configuration of the neuronal system with N neurons is generated with a scale free network of connections.
Synaptic strengths, initially assigned with a random value, are sculpted by activity dependent plasticity (see
Methods). All systems exhibits critical avalanche dynamics (see Supplementary Information). Structural damage
is introduced into the experienced system, i.e. at the end of plastic adaptation. The network does not represent the
entire brain, but only the functional region wherein the lesion occurs. Indeed, the modular brain structure31 has
a relevant role in spontaneous activity and brain damage is often not constrained into a single functional area, as
it is the case of atherosclerosis and senile dementia. In order to shed light on the role of each mechanism in the
recovery process, here we focus on the particular case of an intra-module damage. The stroke can affect a variable
fraction of neurons, up to 50% of the region, and has a spherical shape (Fig. 1)32. Similar results are obtained for
ellipsoidal damage and for a different neuronal model22. All neurons in the damaged area are removed together
with all incoming and outgoing synapses. In addition to the localized damage, we also analyse the case of diffuse
damage (see Supplementary Information), where we remove the same number of neurons, with all incoming and
outgoing connections, but choosing the neurons at random in the system.
Activity after damage.
In order to monitor the effects of damage, we analyse the statistics of spontaneous
activity, namely the avalanche size distribution. The avalanche size is measured either as the number of firing
neurons, or as the sum of potential variations induced at post-synaptic neurons. In healthy systems the largest
avalanche involves all neurons N. For both damages, the largest avalanche is affected by the irreversible death of
neurons and therefore can involve only all surviving neurons. In order to compare the avalanche statistics for
damages of different magnitudes, we evaluate the rescaled avalanche size distribution P(s)s1.5 as function of s/c,
the size rescaled by the cutoff, defined as the value of avalanche size for which only 0.1% of avalanches are larger.
In the following the avalanche size is measured in terms of potential variations.
Interestingly, in the case of diffuse damage (Fig. 2b) the scaling of the distribution is weakly affected in the
middle size range showing a small increase of intermediate size avalanches. Conversely, for the localized damage
case (Fig. 2a) the distributions are sensibly modified exhibiting an excess of intermediate and large size ava-
lanches, which indicates that the system behavior tends to become supercritical. In order to further characterize
Scientific RepoRtS (2019) 9:15858 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-50946-y
2
www.nature.com/scientificreportswww.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 2. Activity after damage. Rescaled avalanche size distribution P(s)s1.5 versus s/c for different localized (a)
and diffuse damages (b). In both panels the distribution for undamaged networks is also shown. (c) Average
firing rate for different avalanche size s plotted versus the rescaled size s/c. Inset: Scatter plot of the average
avalanche size versus the cutoff c for different localized and diffuse damages and for the undamaged case
(black). Each symbol represents a different network configuration. The straight line indicates the relation
∝s
c.
the consequences of damage we measure the average avalanche size versus c for each configuration. In the undam-
aged case, where the distribution follows a power law scaling s−1.5 up to the cutoff fixed by the system size, the
average avalanche varies with the cutoff as < > ∝s
c. The scatter plot in Fig. 2c (inset) shows that this scaling is
indeed verified for different sizes of diffuse damage, namely for increasing damage the average size is solely tuned
by the cutoff, confirming that diffuse damage slightly affects the critical behaviour. Conversely for increasing
localized damage the average size decreases more slowly, as c0.2, which implies the emergence of an excess of large
avalanches compensating the reduced cutoff. In order to further understand the origin of the strong increase in
large avalanches observed for localized damage, we monitor the average firing rate for a given rescaled avalanche
size, s/c (Fig. 2c). This is obtained by evaluating the average firing rate for all neurons active during an avalanche
of size s. In agreement with previous results, the average firing rate does not appreciably change for diffuse dam-
age, whereas strongly increases in the range of intermediate sizes after a stroke. This counter-intuitive result can
be understood by considering that, because of the death of neurons and all their ingoing and outgoing synapses,
activity involves only the surviving neurons which fire more often. In conclusion, diffuse damage has a limited
effect on spontaneous activity, basically rescaling it to a smaller system size. Conversely, the localized damage has
a much stronger impact on the system which goes well beyond rescaling activity because of the reduced number
of neurons. Surviving neurons exhibit a higher firing rate causing an unexpected excess of large avalanches lead-
ing to a supercritical scaling behavior for the distribution.
Recovery after damage.
In order to implement the three different recovery mechanisms, we define the
penumbra as 20% the number of neurons N, placed in the shell surrounding the lesion. We test the recovery
performance of the system under the main three mechanisms detected experimentally (Fig. 3). In particular,
(1) synaptic plasticity is reactivated following the same rules as in the training period, with a maximum num-
ber of plastic adaptations Nrec = 20000, and affects only synapses whose pre-synaptic neuron is the penumbra.
(2) Hyperexcitability involves neurons belonging to the penumbra and implies a change in the firing rate of
both excitatory and inhibitory neurons. This is implemented by decreasing (increasing) the firing threshold of
excitatory (inhibitory) neurons by the same δt. (3) Synaptogenesis is implemented at the end of each avalanche
by adding a new connection to all presynaptic neurons belonging to the penumbra which fired more than once
during the avalanche. The new synapse connects to a post-synaptic neuron not belonging to the penumbra and
at an average distance larger than the initial connections10,11. The recovery performance is analysed for different
Scientific RepoRtS (2019) 9:15858 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-50946-y
3
www.nature.com/scientificreportswww.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 3. Illustration of the three recovery mechanisms. Excitatory neurons and synapses are shown in
red, inhibitory ones in blue. The penumbra (yellow area) is a circular shell around the stroke (grey). (1)
Plasticity reactivation: Outgoing synapses from neurons belonging to the penumbra are strengthened. (2)
Hyperexcitability: Neurons in the penumbra have their firing threshold modified (empty symbols). (3)
Synaptogenesis: The neuron in the penumbra that fired at least twice in the previous avalanche (full star) sprouts
a new connection to a neuron outside the penumbra.
values of the average distance and different numbers of sprouted synapses, expressed in terms of the percentage
of the number of connections killed by the stroke.
We first analyse the effect of reactivating the plastic adaptation of synapses outgoing from neurons belonging
to the penumbra. Figure 4 shows that plasticity has a little effect in the recovery of the undamaged system for all
three criteria. This limited role in the recovery is observed also increasing the temporal duration of the plastic
adaptation Nrec to 40000 stimulations and the spatial extension of the penumbra to 40% the number of neurons
(see Supplementary Information). It therefore appears that plasticity alone is unable to act on any monitored
quantity to retrieve the critical behavior of avalanche activity. Next, we implement hyperexcitability by varying
the firing thresholds of excitatory and inhibitory networks in the penumbra by δt. Small variations of the thresh-
old indeed leave the average firing rate totally unaffected but reduce the excess of large avalanches, as well as the
value of the cutoff (inset of Fig. 4). This counter-intuitive effect can be understood by considering that excitatory
neurons, by firing more often, weaken the signal to connected neurons. Interestingly, for values of δt larger than
0.2 the scaling behaviour of the distribution is strongly affected and a further increase in the firing rate is observed
bringing the system away from criticality. Larger penumbra sizes do indeed help the recovery, however penum-
bras larger than 20% are not realistic experimentally (see Supplementary Information).
Finally, the sprouting of new connections, by increasing the connectivity, has the strongest effect on the recov-
ery of critical scaling properties: The excess of large avalanches and the average firing rate are reduced but also a
slight increase in the cutoff is observed, The effect improves with long-ranged connections for all three criteria,
Scientific RepoRtS (2019) 9:15858 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-50946-y
4
www.nature.com/scientificreportswww.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 4. Activity after recovery. (a) Rescaled avalanche size distribution as function of the rescaled size s/c
for the damaged (50%) and undamaged networks, for the three recovery mechanisms applied separately and
in a combined way (Comb): Plasticity (Pl), hyperexcitability (Hy) and synaptogenesis (Sg). The parameters
are: Nrec = 20000, δt = 0.2, r0 = 9. (b) Firing rate vs. s/c for undamaged, localized damage (50%) and the three
recovery mechanisms as in (a). The inset shows the scatter plot of the average avalanche size vs. the cutoff for the
same color code.
since larger areas of the system are involved in the recovery. The number of newly sprouted synapses is also a
relevant parameter, providing the optimal performance already for the creation of about 5% the number of syn-
apses killed by the stroke (see Supplementary Information). None of the three mechanisms at work alone after a
stroke is able to fully recover the behavior of the undamaged system. In Fig. 4 we compare the three mechanisms:
Synaptogenesis has the stronger effect in the recovery of the scaling of the size distribution, the firing rate and the
cutoff. However, hyperexcitability is able to modify the dependence of the average size on the cutoff. Interestingly,
only the application of the three mechanisms in a combined parallel way is able to recover the critical behaviour
of avalanche activity. Because of irreversible cell death, the cutoff in avalanche size extension is always limited.
However, deviations observed from the healthy state are drastically reduced for the combined three criteria.
The existence of cooperative effects is confirmed by the implementation of the three mechanisms in a random
sequential order (see Fig. 5). Indeed similar recovery performance is observed if the three mechanisms are not
applied simultaneously but one after the other on the same system. Conversely, the recovery observed for an
ensemble of networks where one of the three mechanisms is applied at random and independently of the others, is
drastically reduced. This result confirms that is the interaction among the three mechanisms the main ingredient
for recovery. These three mechanisms are observed to take place after a stroke but for completeness we verified
their efficacy also after diffuse damage (see Supplementary Information). In this case the penumbra is identified
as a percentage of surviving neurons. Interestingly, we find that only plasticity and synaptogenesis would partly
help the recovery, whereas hyperexcitability has a counterproductive effect. The three mechanisms combined
bring the system even farther from the healthy state, confirming that these mechanisms are problem specific and
triggered by the brain only after a stroke.
Discussion
A stroke has important consequences on the activity of a neuronal system, which go beyond the functional disa-
bilities but affect also the resting state. Indeed the localized death of a number of neurons has a strong impact on
the spontaneous activity of the system and, more precisely, on the average size of avalanches or bursts, their size
distribution and their average firing rate. Interestingly, it is the localization of the damage that is responsible for
such deviations, not observed in the case of a diffuse damage of the same size. Experimental observations indi-
cate that three main mechanisms take place after a stroke, here we unveil their role. Synaptogenesis performs the
most important task since it is able, by increasing the connectivity, to distribute the signal over a wider region and
therefore reduce the firing rate of surviving neurons. As a consequence, also the excess of large avalanches and
their average size are drastically reduced. At the same time, hyperexcitability, by facilitating the neuronal firing
in the penumbra, acts on avalanches of all sizes reducing, both, the excess of large avalanches and their average
size. By itself, hyperexcitability is unable to reduce the average firing rate and its presence could appear counter-
productive. However, hyperexcitability is intimately related to synaptogenesis since, increasing the firing rate of
excitatory neurons in the penumbra, it facilitates the sprouting of new synapses partially restoring the connectiv-
ity. Plasticity by itself appears to be unable to recover healthy behavior but is important in sculpting the strength
Scientific RepoRtS (2019) 9:15858 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-50946-y
5
www.nature.com/scientificreportswww.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 5. Comparison of recovery mechanism implementation. (a) Rescaled avalanche size distribution
as function of the rescaled size s/c for the damaged (50%) and undamaged networks, for the three recovery
mechanisms applied independently of each other, sequentially and in a parallel way. The parameters are:
Nrec = 20000, δt = 0.2, r0 = 9. (b) Firing rate vs. s/c for undamaged, localized damage (50%) and the three
recovery mechanisms as in (a). The inset shows the scatter plot of the average avalanche size vs. the cutoff for the
same color code.
of new synapses. We stress that both synaptogenesis and hyperexcitability are local effects, involving mostly neu-
rons in the penumbra. Conversely, plasticity can have long-range effects involving in a cascade also connections
far from the penumbra or even beyond the functional region. This mechanism could then be effective at the
scale of the entire brain, leading to even contralateral effects balanced by ipsilateral compensation. It is only the
combined application of all three mechanisms, either sequentially or in parallel, that leads to recovery towards
healthy conditions. These results suggest that experiments on animals after an induced stroke by the combined
use of receptor antagonists, as bicuculline or picrotoxin, which reduce and enhance the activity of inhibitory and
excitatory neurons, respectively, may confirm that controlling the excitability level in the system may enhance
synaptogenesis and help the recovery.
Methods
network model. We consider a network with N neurons, placed randomly in a three-dimensional cube.
Synaptic connections are directed and a fraction pinh = 0.2 of neurons inhibitory. The network of out-going con-
nections is scale-free, sampled according to the experimental distribution of functional networks33, n(kout) ∝ kout
−2
with kout ∈ [kmin, kmax] = [5,100]. Since inhibitory neurons are hubs34, they are assigned among neurons with large
out-degree. The probability to establish a connection depends on the spatial distance r between two neurons
035, with r0 = 3. Initial synaptic strengths ωij are chosen to be uniformly distributed
according to
within the interval [0.04,0.06]. Every neuron i is characterized by a membrane potential vi, whose initial values
are uniformly distributed in the interval [0.1,0.4]. At each time step all neurons with a potential exceeding a
threshold value vi ≥ vc = 1.0 fire, causing a change in the potential of the connected post-synaptic neurons j as25
= −
e
p r
( )
1
r
0
r r
/
v t
(
j
u t
(
i
v t
(
i
+
+
+
1)
1)
1)
ω
ij
v t u
( )
i
i
u
)
−
δ
=
=
=
v t
( )
±
j
u t
( )(1
i
0
(1)
where ui stands for the amount of releasable neurotransmitter, which initially is set equal to one for all neurons
and for simplicity is the same for all synapses of neuron i. The amount of releasable neurotransmitter reduces by
roughly 5% after a spike36,37, therefore δu = 0.05. The plus or minus sign in Eq. (1) stands for excitatory or inhibi-
tory synapses, respectively. After a neuron fires, it remains in a refractory state for one time step during which it is
unable to receive or send any signal. The important feature generating the critical dynamics of the resting state is
the slow recovery process of ui combined with the the fast depletion during activity23,25. The recovery of synapses
takes a time of the order of seconds38 whereas synaptic transmission is of the order of milliseconds. Also stimula-
tion by spontaneous vesicle release occurs at a rate of hundreds of milliseconds to seconds39. This consideration
allows us to assume that during an avalanche neurotransmitter resources are not retrieved. After an avalanche
ends, ui of each neuron i is increased by an amount Δur, which determines if the network will be in a subcritical,
critical or supercritical state. The value Δur = 3⋅10−5 sets the system for N = 40000 neurons at criticality, i.e. the
Scientific RepoRtS (2019) 9:15858 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-50946-y
6
www.nature.com/scientificreportswww.nature.com/scientificreports/ distribution behaves as s−1.5 and the cutoff scales as the system size. Moreover, activity is kept ongoing by adding
a small δv = 0.1 to a random neuron (see Suppl. Figure 2).
The synaptic network structure is shaped by activity-dependent plasticity: Whenever a neuron i fires, all
weights of outgoing synapses, connecting i to an active post-synaptic neuron j are strengthened according to the
voltage variation induced in the post-synaptic neuron
+ =
(2)
where δωij = α(vj(t + 1) − vj(t)) and α = 0.0003 only determines the rate of this plastic change. At the end of each
s where Ns is the
avalanche unused synapses are weakened by the average increase per bond ω
ij
total number of synapses. Synaptic plasticity efficiently weakens loops in the network structure, depending
strongly on the length of the refractory period40,41. When an avalanche ends, all strengths ωij are decreased by the
average increase in synaptic strength per bond. Plastic adaptation is implemented for a given number of external
stimulations, e.g. Np = 10000. If, however, a synaptic strength reaches zero, the adaptation is interrupted and the
synapse is pruned. Data are averaged over 50 configurations of networks with N = 40000 neurons.
− ∑
δω
ij
ω
ij
(
t
ω
ij
t
( )
=
ω
ij
+
δω
ij
N/
1)
Received: 29 April 2019; Accepted: 19 September 2019;
Published: xx xx xxxx
(2006).
(2009).
References
1. Hossmann, K.-A. Pathophysiology and therapy of experimental stroke. Cellular and molecular neurobiology 26, 1055 -- 1081 (2006).
2. Murphy, T. H., Li, P., Betts, K. & Liu, R. Two-photon imaging of stroke onset in vivo reveals that nmda-receptor independent
ischemic depolarization is the major cause of rapid reversible damage to dendrites and spines. Journal of Neuroscience 28, 1756 -- 1772
(2008).
3. Hossmann, K.-A. Viability thresholds and the penumbra of focal ischemia. Annals of neurology 36, 557 -- 565 (1994).
4. Wieloch, T. & Nikolich, K. Mechanisms of neural plasticity following brain injury. Current opinion in neurobiology 16, 258 -- 264
5. Murphy, T. H. & Corbett, D. Plasticity during stroke recovery: from synapse to behaviour. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 10, 861
6. Schiene, K. et al. Neuronal hyperexcitability and reduction of gabaa-receptor expression in the surround of cerebral
photothrombosis. Journal of Cerebral Blood Flow & Metabolism 16, 906 -- 914 (1996).
7. Neumann-Haefelin, T., Hagemann, G. & Witte, O. W. Cellular correlates of neuronal hyperexcitability in the vicinity of
photochemically induced cortical infarcts in rats in vitro. Neuroscience letters 193, 101 -- 104 (1995).
8. Carmichael, S. T. et al. Growth-associated gene expression after stroke: evidence for a growth-promoting region in peri-infarct
cortex. Experimental neurology 193, 291 -- 311 (2005).
9. Carmichael, S. T. Cellular and molecular mechanisms of neural repair after stroke: making waves. Annals of Neurology: Official
Journal of the American Neurological Association and the Child Neurology Society 59, 735 -- 742 (2006).
10. Dancause, N. et al. Extensive cortical rewiring after brain injury. Journal of Neuroscience 25, 10167 -- 10179 (2005).
11. Buchli, A. D. & Schwab, M. E. Inhibition of nogo: a key strategy to increase regeneration, plasticity and functional recovery of the
lesioned central nervous system. Annals of medicine 37, 556 -- 567 (2005).
12. Alstott, J., Breakspear, M., Hagmann, P., Cammoun, L. & Sporns, O. Modeling the impact of lesions in the human brain. PLoS
computational biology 5, e1000408 (2009).
13. Beggs, J. M. & Plenz, D. Neuronal avalanches in neocortical circuits. Journal of neuroscience 23, 11167 -- 11177 (2003).
14. Beggs, J. M. & Plenz, D. Neuronal avalanches are diverse and precise activity patterns that are stable for many hours in cortical slice
cultures. Journal of neuroscience 24, 5216 -- 5229 (2004).
15. Mazzoni, A. et al. On the dynamics of the spontaneous activity in neuronal networks. PloS one 2, e439 (2007).
16. Pasquale, V., Massobrio, P., Bologna, L., Chiappalone, M. & Martinoia, S. Self-organization and neuronal avalanches in networks of
dissociated cortical neurons. Neuroscience 153, 1354 -- 1369 (2008).
17. Gireesh, E. D. & Plenz, D. Neuronal avalanches organize as nested theta-and beta/gamma-oscillations during development of
cortical layer 2/3. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 105, 7576 -- 7581 (2008).
18. Petermann, T. et al. Spontaneous cortical activity in awake monkeys composed of neuronal avalanches. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences 106, 15921 -- 15926 (2009).
19. Haimovici, A., Tagliazucchi, E., Balenzuela, P. & Chialvo, D. R. Brain organization into resting state networks emerges at criticality
on a model of the human connectome. Physical review letters 110, 178101 (2013).
20. Shriki, O. et al. Neuronal avalanches in the resting meg of the human brain. Journal of Neuroscience 33, 7079 -- 7090 (2013).
21. Massobrio, P., de Arcangelis, L., Pasquale, V., Jensen, H. J. & Plenz, D. Criticality as a signature of healthy neural systems. Frontiers
in Systems Neuroscience 9, 1 -- 3 (2015).
22. de Arcangelis, L., Perrone-Capano, C. & Herrmann, H. J. Self-organized criticality model for brain plasticity. Physical review letters
23. Levina, A., Herrmann, J. M. & Geisel, T. Dynamical synapses causing self-organized criticality in neural networks. Nature physics 3,
96, 028107 (2006).
857 -- 860 (2007).
24. Kanders, K., Lorimer, T. & Stoop, R. Avalanche and edge-of-chaos criticality do not necessarily co-occur in neural networks. Chaos:
An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science 27, 047408 (2017).
25. van Kessenich, L. M., Luković, M., De Arcangelis, L. & Herrmann, H. J. Critical neural networks with short-and long-term plasticity.
Physical Review E 97, 032312 (2018).
newborn brain. Cerebral cortex 23, 638 -- 646 (2012).
26. Fransson, P. et al. Early development of spatial patterns of power-law frequency scaling in fmri resting-state and eeg data in the
27. Bak, P., Tang, C. & Wiesenfeld, K. Self-organized criticality: An explanation of the 1/f noise. Physical review letters 59, 381 (1987).
28. Bak, P., Tang, C. & Wiesenfeld, K. Self-organized criticality. Physical review A 38, 364 (1988).
29. de Arcangelis, L. Are dragon neuronal avalanches dungeons for self-organized brain activity? The European Physical Journal. Special
Topics 205, 243 -- 257 (2012).
cortical responses. Science 273, 1868 -- 1871 (1996).
30. Arieli, A., Sterkin, A., Grinvald, A. & Aertsen, A. Dynamics of ongoing activity: Explanation of the large variability in evoked
31. Gallos, L., Makse, H. & Sigman, M. A small-world of weak ties provides optimal global integration of self-similar modules in
functional brain networks. PNAS 109, 2825 -- 2830 (2012).
32. Cheng, B. et al. Stroke subtype classification by geometrical descriptors of lesion shape. PloS one 12, e0185063 (2017).
Scientific RepoRtS (2019) 9:15858 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-50946-y
7
www.nature.com/scientificreportswww.nature.com/scientificreports/ 33. Eguiluz, V., Chialvo, D., Cecchi, D., Baliki, M. & Apkarian, A. Scale-free brain functional networks. Physical review letters 94, 018102
34. Bonifazi, P. et al. Gabaergic hub neurons orchestrate synchrony in developing hippocampal networks. Science 326, 1419 -- 1424
35. Roerig, B. & Chen, B. Relationships of local inhibitory and excitatory circuits to orientation preference maps in ferret visual cortex.
(2005).
(2009).
Cerebral cortex 12, 187 -- 198 (2002).
Academy of Sciences 106, 2945 -- 2950 (2009).
36. Ikeda, K. & Bekkers, J. M. Counting the number of releasable synaptic vesicles in a presynaptic terminal. Proceedings of the National
37. Rizzoli, S. O. & Betz, W. J. Synaptic vesicle pools. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 6, 57 (2005).
38. Tsodyks, M. V. & Markram, H. The neural code between neocortical pyramidal neurons depends on neurotransmitter release
probability. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 94, 719 -- 723 (1997).
39. Bruns, D. & Jahn, R. Real-time measurement of transmitter release from single synaptic vesicles. Nature 377, 62 (1995).
40. Kozloski, J. & Cecchi, G. A. A theory of loop formation and elimination by spike timing-dependent plasticity. Frontiers in neural
41. Van Kessenich, L. M., de Arcangelis, L. & Herrmann, H. Synaptic plasticity and neuronal refractory time cause scaling behaviour of
neuronal avalanches. Scientific reports 6, 32071 (2016).
circuits 4, 7 (2010).
Acknowledgements
HJH would like to thank the Agencies CAPES and FUNCAP for financial support. LdA would like to acknowledge
the financial support from MIUR-PRIN2017WZFTZP.
Author contributions
L.d.A. and H.J.H. conceived the research, D.B., E.V. and L.M.v.K. ran the simulations and analysed the results. All
authors reviewed the manuscript.
competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Supplementary information is available for this paper at https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-50946-y.
Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to L.d.A.
Reprints and permissions information is available at www.nature.com/reprints.
Publisher's note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and
institutional affiliations.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or
format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Cre-
ative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this
article are included in the article's Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the
material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons license and your intended use is not per-
mitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the
copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
© The Author(s) 2019
Scientific RepoRtS (2019) 9:15858 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-50946-y
8
www.nature.com/scientificreportswww.nature.com/scientificreports/ |
1509.08954 | 3 | 1509 | 2016-11-18T18:56:06 | Griffiths phase and long-range correlations in a biologically motivated V1 model | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cond-mat.dis-nn",
"cond-mat.stat-mech",
"nlin.AO",
"physics.bio-ph"
] | Activity in the brain propagates as waves of firing neurons, namely avalanches. These waves' size and duration distributions have been experimentally shown to display a stable power-law profile, long-range correlations and $1/f^{b}$ power spectrum \textit{in vivo} and \textit{in vitro}. We study an avalanching biologically motivated model of mammals visual cortex and find an extended critical-like region -- a Griffiths phase -- characterized by divergent susceptibility and zero order parameter. This phase lies close to the expected experimental value of the \textit{excitatory postsynaptic potential} in the cortex suggesting that critical behavior may be found in the visual system. Avalanches are not perfectly power-law distributed, but it is possible to collapse the distributions and define a cutoff avalanche size that diverges as the network size is increased inside the critical region. The avalanches present long-range correlations and $1/f^{b}$ power spectrum, matching experiments. The phase transition is analytically determined by a mean-field approximation. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Griffiths phase and long-range correlations in a
biologically motivated visual cortex model
M. Girardi-Schappo1,+, G. S. Bortolotto1, J. J. Gonsalves1, L. T. Pinto2, and
M. H. R. Tragtenberg1,*
1Departamento de F´ısica, Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, 88040-900, Florian´opolis, Santa Catarina,
Brazil
2Departamento de Engenharia Qu´ımica e Engenharia de Alimentos, Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina,
88040-900, Florian´opolis, Santa Catarina, Brazil
[email protected]
*[email protected]
doi:10.1038/srep29561
ABSTRACT
Activity in the brain propagates as waves of firing neurons, namely avalanches. These waves' size and duration distributions
have been experimentally shown to display a stable power-law profile, long-range correlations and 1/ f b power spectrum in vivo
and in vitro. We study an avalanching biologically motivated model of mammals visual cortex and find an extended critical-like
region -- a Griffiths phase -- characterized by divergent susceptibility and zero order parameter. This phase lies close to the
expected experimental value of the excitatory postsynaptic potential in the cortex suggesting that critical behavior may be
found in the visual system. Avalanches are not perfectly power-law distributed, but it is possible to collapse the distributions and
define a cutoff avalanche size that diverges as the network size is increased inside the critical region. The avalanches present
long-range correlations and 1/ f b power spectrum, matching experiments. The phase transition is analytically determined by a
mean-field approximation.
Introduction
The most important feature of a living complex system to survive is adaptability. In order to adapt, the organism cannot be
inflexible, but also cannot act randomly. The border of chaos or a critical behavior seems to be the best evolutionary choice to
survival beings.1, 2 Turing conjectured a similar idea referring to our minds and learning machines.3
More recently, brain criticality has become a trendy research subject.4 -- 6 Some believe that the brain became critical by
self-organization and selection,4 analogously to the sandpile self-organized criticality (SOC).7 Criticality has the advantages of
maximizing the response dynamic range of neural networks,8 optimizing memory and learning processes,9 the computational
power of the brain10 and information processing flexibility.11
The brain critical state is usually experimentally characterized via power-law (PL) distributed neuronal avalanches12 -- 16
or diverging long-range spatial or temporal correlations.17, 18 On the other hand, criticality in (non-)equilibrium Statistical
Mechanics is only rigorously defined via the PL convergence to zero of an order parameter and the simultaneous PL divergence
of its associated susceptibility.19 -- 21 In addition, finite systems avalanche size distributions present cutoffs, which also must
diverge according to PLs on the critical state.22 These PL critical exponents must follow well-defined scaling relations.20, 21, 23, 24
Notice, however, that some authors do not take into account the finite-size scaling (FSS) of avalanche distributions cutoff.16
Also, only a few authors use an order parameter -- susceptibility pair to probe for criticality in Neuroscience.25, 26
Here we show that there is a Griffiths26 -- 28 phase (GP) in the non-equilibrium percolation-like phase transition of the
visual processing activity as a function of the excitatory postsynaptic potential (EPSP). The GP is known to emerge from rare
over-active region effects due to the quenched disorder of the network. One of the macroscopic consequences of such effects is
the appearance of an extended region of critical behavior in the phase diagram of the system. This result for the visual system
is consistent with recent findings that suggest that excitable systems running over the connectome structure (a whole brain
network) present GP.26 Our control parameter is the EPSP and the GP is found close to the experimental values of EPSP in the
cortex.29 -- 31 The EPSP threshold for a complete network activation is determined via a mean-field approximation and is close to
the expected numerical and experimental values of this parameter.
We define the density of activated neurons as an order parameter and verify that it converges to zero whereas its associated
susceptibility diverges inside the while GP by applying standard FSS technique. This scaling rigorously defines the critical
phase transition in our model. Our order parameter is usual for absorbing state phase transitions.21, 32 Additionally, we show
that the avalanches are PL distributed with a cutoff that scales with the system size inside the GP. We also study the visual
system avalanches correlations and power spectrum. Throughout the critical region, the power spectrum of avalanche time
series has the form 1/ f b, with 0.2 ≤ b ≤ 1.3 as experimentally expected.17, 33 -- 36 The activity time series inside the critical
region also presents long-range correlations yielding Detrended Fluctuation Analysis17, 37, 38 (DFA) exponent g (cid:38) 0.7.
Avalanche distributions presenting PL alone have been questioned as insufficient evidence for identifying the critical
regime10, 39, 40 since there may be critical dynamical systems which have no PL distributed avalanches39 and non-critical
dynamical systems that present PL distributed avalanches.40 Our model's avalanche distributions have PL shape inside the
GP and even outside it. Thus, we show another example that PL distributed avalanches is not a sufficient condition for
criticality. More than that, we use an order parameter -- susceptibility pair as usually done for phase transitions to probe for
criticality.20, 21, 23, 24
We chose to model the visual cortex because it has a well-known anatomy and function.41 -- 45 The visual cortex also has
a valuable data set available that we may use to benchmark our model results, such as the power spectrum17, 33 -- 36 and a few
avalanche experiments.13, 14, 16 We focus on understanding the dynamics of the signal propagation and the avalanche activity
related to the network disordered structure. Our model is biologically motivated in the sense that the network we study here is
layered, columnar, and recurrent, resembling the architecture of the visual cortex45 (full details of the network are given in the
Supplementary Material). Also, our parameters are either fitted to experiments (such as the attenuation constant29) or have been
experimentally measured (such as the structural parameters41 -- 44).
The avalanches spontaneously emerge after a flash stimulus presented to the the model's retina, instead of artificially
imposing an abstract Poisson stimulus as in most of the brain critical models (see8, 9, 13, 16, 46 -- 49 to cite a few). Avalanche
dynamics is thus essential for the reliable signal propagation in our model.
We describe key features of the considered model in the following section. In the introduction of the Results section,
we define the Griffiths phase and briefly discuss its origin in the model, the tools we use to characterize it (order parameter
and susceptibility) and the observables of interest (avalanches, processing time, avalanche distributions and correlation
measurements). Results are presented and discussed in the subsections of Results section. We finish the paper by briefly
reviewing our main results and pointing how they relate to experiments and to SOC models in the Concluding Remarks section.
Model
This model was originally developed by Andreazza & Pinto50 in order to study the signal propagation dynamics in the visual
cortex of mammals. They detected some sort of phase transition which will be analyzed in details throughout this work. The
model is composed of six interconnected square layers. The signal propagates directionally from the retina (the Input layer) to
the secondary visual cortex (Output layer). The other four layers have lateral size L and are selected from the form recognition
pathway: the lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN, from the thalamus) and the layers II/III, IVCβ and VI from the primary visual
cortex (V1). The architecture of the network is illustrated in Figure 1A, where arrows point the direction of the connections
through which the signal propagates. The direction of the connections characterizes the adjacency of layers. The LGN layer
consists of only its parvocellular neurons. Their synapses are mostly connected to V1 layer IVCβ .41 -- 44 The synaptic buttons
density over the dendrites is also based on experiments.41 -- 44 The bulk of the network (layers LGN, VI, IVCβ and II/III together)
has N = 4L2 neurons. The Input layer (composed of photoreceptors) and the Output layer (composed of axon terminals that
connect to secondary visual cortex) have Nio = (10L)2 elements each. Each neuron i of the four internal layers is composed of
a dendrite with 100 compartments, the soma, and an axon with 10 compartments.
The network is built in four steps: (a) for each neuron of the network, a postsynaptic neuron is chosen from an adjacent
layer using a two-dimensional Gaussian distribution inside a limited excitatory field of size l2; (b) an axonal compartment is
chosen from the presynaptic neuron using an exponential probability distribution plotted in Figure 1C (left); (c) a dendritic
compartment of the postsynaptic neuron is chosen using a Gaussian distribution centered in the middle of the dendrite, as
in Figure 1C (right); and (d) a synapse is formed by connecting the chosen axonal compartment and the chosen dendritic
compartment. There is a different number of outward synapses per presynaptic neuron depending on the presynaptic layer (see
tables in Supplementary Material). The randomly chosen postsynaptic neurons and the randomly chosen pairs of presynaptic
axonal compartments and postsynaptic dendritic compartments give rise to quenched disorder.
This structure generates a directed path of square columns of highly connected neurons for the signal propagation centered
in each neuron of each layer. Each column has Nc = 4l2 ≈ 200 neurons (see Figure 1B). As an example, a network with L = 99
(the largest considered size in this work) has approximately N = 4× 104 neurons and 32.5× 106 synapses in total. It is thus
computationally costly to simulate larger networks. Once the network structure is built, it is kept fixed for a single signal
propagation dynamics.
2/14
Figure 1. Elements of the V1 model. A: Architecture of the network. B: Spatial organization of the network of N = 4L2
neurons. The columnar structure is highlighted in red. There is a column of size Nc = 4l2 = 196 neurons centered on each
neuron of the network. C: Compartmental scheme of neurons. The probability, P(ak), of choosing a presynaptic axonal
compartment, ak, of any neuron is exponential such that most of the synapses start from the end of the axon (left). The
probability, P(dm), of choosing a dendritic postsynaptic compartment, dm, is Gaussian with mean 50 and standard deviation
10, so that most of the synapses lay in the middle of the dendrite (right).
The EPSP (in the dendrites) and the action potential (in the axons) advance one compartment per time step t, coming from
the dendrites through the soma to the last axonal compartment. The variables d(i)
m (t) [Equation (1)], vi(t) [Equation (2)] and
a(i)
k (t) [Equation (3)] represent the local values of the EPSP sum (for each dendritic compartment m) or the action potential (for
each axon compartment k) in the membrane of neuron i at time t, respectively.
These rules may be summarized in the following equations:
(cid:20)
(cid:16)
Θ
(cid:17)
a( j)
n (t) ,
d(i)
1 (t + 1) = λ E ∑
j,n
d(i)
k−1(t) + E ∑
j,n
d(i)
k (t + 1) = λ
(cid:21)
a( j)
n (t)
,for k > 1,
vi(t + 1) =
100(t)− vT
d(i)
−R
vi(t) + 1
, if vi(t) = 0 ,
, if vi(t) = 1 ,
, if vi(t) < 0 ,
a(i)
1 (t + 1) = Θ (vi(t)) ,
a(i)
k (t + 1) = a(i)
k−1(t),for k > 1,
(1)
(2)
(3)
where E > 0 is the EPSP, λ = 0.996 is the dendritic attenuation constant (chosen to match experimental attenuation29), Θ(x)
is the Heaviside step function and vT = 10 mV is the firing threshold needed to induce an action potential.51 After the soma
spikes, it is reset to the value R which represents the refractory period (in time step unit). R is set to avoid self-sustained activity
in the interlayer loops (between layers IVCβ and VI). The signal propagates in the direction of increasing k (as t increases). The
control parameter E sets the level of excitation, whereas λ sets the level of dissipation. The double sum in Equation (1) is over
each of the axonal compartments n of the presynaptic neuron j connected to the dendritic compartment k of the postsynaptic
neuron i.
m (0) = vi(0) = 0 ∀ (k,m,i). The time scale of the model is arbitrary,
so the spike signal of the soma takes about 1 ms. The different number of compartments for dendrites and axons copes with
their different velocities for the signal propagation.52
Every neuron initial condition is given by a(i)
k (0) = d(i)
3/14
Results and discussion
For each E and L, the activity is initiated by flashing once a square of 30× 30 photoreceptors in the center of the Input layer
(which, in turn, will activate a region of 3× 3 neurons in the LGN). We also consider different positions for the initial stimulus,
such as flashing a square near the corner of the Input layer in order to verify if results are stable. Notice that this procedure is
similar to that used in the study of epidemic spreading in systems having absorbing phase transitions, in which a single site (or
a small fraction of sites) is initially infected.21 However, in epidemic spreading models each site is a simple three or four states
cellular automaton and the network is generally regular and hypercubic.21
In the present case, the extended body of each neuron (or site) and the disordered structure of the network generates a
spreading pattern that works like a branching process.53 Nevertheless, the adjusted R ensures that the activity will always die
out and our model (as considered in this paper) has no active stationary state (see in Figure 2A that activity eventually fades
away for every E). After the activity of a single stimulation has ended, the amount of neurons that fired is NR. The configuration
of the network made of NR activated neurons and N −NR inactivated neurons is an absorbing state. As we vary E, we notice that
a larger fraction of neurons gets activated by the initial stimulus. For E > Eth, the activity will definitely percolate the network
before getting extinguished (i.e. NR = N). Our model, thus, presents an absorbing state phase transition from a non-percolating
inactive phase (small E) to a dynamically percolating phase (large E).54 We employ a mean-field analysis to determine Eth in
the next subsection. Intermediary values of E yield vanishing non-zero probability of percolation.
After the activity is ceased, another trial is started by (a) rewiring the network according to the rules described in last
section and in the Supplementary Material; (b) resetting the state of the neurons; and (c) flashing the same square stimulus
to the network. This procedure is repeated many times for each E and L. Therefore, the averages and variances presented in
this section are calculated over these several trials of the network quenched disorder in the connections between neurons. The
disorder of the system creates rare region fluctuation effects on the size NR of the percolation cluster for a finite range of the E
parameter. The system then presents a GP in this interval.26 -- 28 Figure 2A shows the temporal profile of activity A(t) (the sum
of every soma spike in the network for a given time step) for a single trial of the network with L = 99 and four different E.
The temporal profile of activity comprises interspersing small and large peaks of activity that spontaneously emerge (see
Figure 2A) due to the delay caused by the propagation of potentials through dendrites and axons. Thus, the separation of
the peaks (i.e. the separation of time scales) in our model output data is not externally imposed, as commonly done in SOC
models.22 This emergent separation of activity intervals provides a natural way to define the avalanches of our model. The
observed avalanches are correlated because the peaks follow from each other in an organized temporal sequence. This is different
from the Poisson independently generated avalanches obtained in most models of absorbing state phase transitions.8, 9, 13, 22, 46 -- 49
In such models, each avalanche is generated by a single stimulus and one avalanche is defined as all the activity between
two inactive absorbing states of the system.22, 23 On the contrary, the dynamics of our model allows us to define avalanches
using the experimental protocol: here, one avalanche is all the activity between two moments of silence in the network, even if
the system did not reach its absorbing state during such silent period. In fact, when analyzing experimental data there is no
guarantee that the system is in its inactive absorbing state between consecutive avalanches because background activity of the
network is always neglected by applying ad hoc thresholds to the electrodes' signals.12 -- 14, 16 The size s of the avalanche is the
sum of all the activity A(t) between two consecutive instants in which A(t) = 0. In fact, each s is the area under each of the
peaks in Figure 2A. The distribution of avalanche sizes s of our model will be discussed in the sections to follow.
Absorbing state phase transitions are commonly studied through the definition of two order parameters:21 the density of
active sites in the active stationary state (which defines the critical exponent β ); or the percolation probability (which defines the
critical exponent β(cid:48)). The second one is most commonly used for systems without active stationary state. However, the density
of activated sites by an initial stimulus (i.e. the density of sites that pertain to the percolating cluster, also known as debris
density) is also used to describe phase transitions without active absorbing states.32 Thus, we chose to study our systems' phase
transition using the density of activated neurons, ρ ≡ (cid:104)NR/N(cid:105), as our order parameter, because it may be directly measured for
each quenched disorder configuration of the network. Notice that the average is taken over the many trials of the network for
fixed E and L: for a given trial, a quantity NR of neurons has been activated after the activity dies out; ρ is then the average of
NR/N. The amount of activated neurons for each trial is simply calculated by NR = ∑T
t=0 A(t), where T is the total propagation
time (time from the moment the activity is sparked until the moment it dies out). The quantity T is also known as mean survival
time in absorbing phase transitions.21
The variance of ρ is regarded as a susceptibility, χ ≡ N((cid:104)ρ2(cid:105)−(cid:104)ρ(cid:105)2), and defines the critical exponent γ(cid:48) for models
presenting typical absorbing phase transitions.21, 55 Nevertheless, notice that in such systems the variance of ρ is often taken
over its temporal fluctuations in the absorbing active state.21 Our model does not have an active absorbing state, so the
fluctuations of ρ arise from different trials of the network disorder for fixed E and L, similarly to how ρ is measured: after each
trial, a total density NR/N of activated neurons is left by the propagated network activity. Thus, the variance is calculated over
all these trials for each E and L. Since our network is not regular, we chose to study a modified version of the susceptibility for
complex networks, χρ = χ/(cid:104)ρ(cid:105), which defines a critical exponent γ = γ(cid:48) + β .55 Notice that this γ is not related to the average
4/14
avalanche size of absorbing phase transitions. The plot of the standard susceptibility χ is shown in the Supplementary Material.
It presents the diverging pattern with exponent γ(cid:48) expected for absorbing critical systems. However, the modified susceptibility
shows in a more neat way the extent of the GP.
Near the critical point, we may write the following scaling functions:19, 21, 26, 28
ρ(E;L) ∼ L−β /ν⊥ ¯ρ(E − EcL1/ν⊥) ,
χρ (E;L) ∼ Lγ/ν⊥ ¯χρ (E − EcL1/ν⊥) ,
(4)
(5)
where β , ν⊥, and γ = γ(cid:48) + β are scaling exponents and ¯ρ(x) and ¯χρ (x) are universal scaling functions. If equations (4) and (5)
hold for the computational data, then a critical phase transition occurs on Ec.19 -- 21, 24 The value Ec marks the point in which the
probability of appearing a percolation cluster due to the system dynamics continuously changes from zero to positive.21 This is
the strong criterion to define criticality, although it is not commonly applied in neural networks models. Only one work has
experimentally applied it so far in the brain context.25 Notice that the exponent γ(cid:48) is calculated for the variance of ρ over the
trials of the network, whereas the usual γ(cid:48) is obtained through temporal fluctuations. Thus, the γ(cid:48) we calculate in this work
might not correspond to the usual γ(cid:48) of absorbing phase transitions.
We also compute the avalanche size distributions, P(s) ∼ s−α, the complementary cumulative distributions, F (s), the
avalanches' autocorrelation, C(t(cid:48)), and power spectrum, S( f ), the activity time series DFA, F(∆t), and measure the network
processing time, T (E;L). In the critical point, these quantities may be written as:
F (s) ∼ s1−α ,
C(t(cid:48)) ∼ t(cid:48)−θ exp(cid:0)−t(cid:48)/τ(cid:1) ,
S( f ) ∼ f −b ,
F(∆t) ∼ (∆t)g ,
T (E;L) ∼ Lµ ¯T (E)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
where α is the exponent of avalanche sizes distribution, t(cid:48) is the time lag between two avalanches, τ is the characteristic time of
the autocorrelation exponential cutoff, θ and b are the autocorrelation and power spectrum exponents of the avalanche time
series, respectively, g is the DFA exponent of the activity time series, µ is a scaling exponent and ¯T (E) is a universal scaling
function. Since S( f ) is the Fourier transform of C(t(cid:48)), θ + b = 1 for t(cid:48) (cid:28) τ.
distribution. We assume that P(s) ∼ s−α is valid for s ≤ Z, therefore
The cumulative avalanche size distribution provides a clearer and direct way to calculate the cutoff Z of the avalanche size
(cid:90) Z
s
F (s) ≡
P(s(cid:48))ds(cid:48) = c1 + c2s−α+1 ,
(11)
and thus Z = (−c1/c2)1/(−α+1) with c1, c2 and α fitted to the cumulative distribution data.48 At the critical point, the cutoff is
expected to scale as Z ∼ LD and D is an exponent defining a characteristic dimensionality of the avalanches.22 If this scaling
relation does not hold, then the system is not critical.
Mean-field approximation
It is clear in Fig. 2A that there is a change in the activity profile as E is varied. The signal may reach only a few neurons of each
layer for E = 1.1 mV whereas for E (cid:38) 1.19 mV, it excites the whole network. Such a behavior arises from the competition
between excitation and dissipation. The excitation level of the network is controlled by the EPSP parameter, E, whereas the
dissipation level is controlled by the attenuation constant, λ .
At the point where excitation balances dissipation, one expects that every neuron in the network will fire once. We will call
this point the activation threshold, where E = Eth. In order for any neuron i to fire, the signal that reaches the soma should be
greater than or equal to the firing threshold, vT :
100(cid:105) ≥ vT ,
in (cid:104)d(i)
n(i)
in is the average amount of inward synapses per dendritic compartment of the postsynaptic neuron i, (cid:104)d(i)
where n(i)
100(λ )E
is the average signal arriving on the soma compartment from one single synapse on any dendritic compartment of neuron i and
100(cid:105) = r(i)
(12)
5/14
Figure 2. Network activity, order parameter and susceptibility. Panel A: Temporal profile of the avalanches for many EPSP.
Arrows mark the processing time T of the network. For E = 1.1 mV, only very small avalanches occur; E = 1.2 mV shows
many small avalanches; for E = 2.0 mV there is a dominating avalanche (compare to the dotted line that marks zero activity);
and for E = 13.0 mV the dominating avalanche takes over all the dynamics. Panel B: Density of activated neurons ρ during
total activity time and its associated susceptibility χρ = N((cid:104)ρ2(cid:105)−(cid:104)ρ(cid:105)2)/(cid:104)ρ(cid:105)55 as function of E for many L. Red circles
(G,G,G,G) indicate ρ and blue squares (I,I,I,I) indicate χρ; the larger L the darker the color shade. White background
indicate the inactive phase, light gray background indicates the critical (Griffiths) phase with diverging χρ and dark gray
background indicates the percolating phase. Panels C,D: FSS of ρ order parameter26, 28 yielding scaling exponent
β /ν⊥ = 0.55(3) -- Equation (4) -- and FSS of χρ yielding scaling exponent γ/ν⊥ = 3.1(1) -- Equation (5); fits performed on
the transition point Ec = 1.19 mV; ((cid:79)) inactive phase, ((cid:35)) critical phase, ((cid:50)) and ((cid:77)) percolating phases. Vertical bars are
standard deviation and dotted lines are only guides to the eyes.
r(i)
100(λ ) = λ 50(1+lnλ ) is the fraction of the signal that reaches the soma as function of λ from a single presynaptic cell. See
Supplementary Material for a derivation of (cid:104)d(i)
100(cid:105).
in ≈ 6.5 (from Table S2 in Supplementary
Since the structure of the network is fixed for each trial, we may estimate n(i)
100(λ )] ≈ 1.88 mV, which we know from
in r(i)
Material). It is then simple to calculate Eth from Equation (12): Eth = vT /[n(i)
numerical data to be overestimated. Anyway, it is still close to the average experimental value of the E in the cortex.29 -- 31
Computational results
We performed between one hundred and three hundred trials of the network disorder for each EPSP of each L in order to
calculate averages [equations (4) to (10)] and standard deviations (vertical bars in Figure 2).
Griffiths phase and critical phase transition
A critical point is found for E = Ec if:19 -- 21, 26, 28 (a) ρ(E = Ec;L) → 0 according to Equation (4), and (b) χρ (E = Ec;L) → +∞
according to Equation (5); both when L → ∞. It is easy to notice that both conditions are fulfilled within the light gray region
6/14
Figure 3. Avalanche size distributions and cumulative distributions. Panel A: Typical avalanche distributions P(s) for many
E: ((cid:72)) inactive phase, (G) critical phase, ((cid:4)) and ((cid:78)) percolating phases. Note the bump around avalanches of size Nc ≈ 200
for E = 1.88 mV ((cid:4)); this bump reveals the internal structure of the network (see text for discussion). The light gray
background highlights the range of avalanche size s in which all phases have PL-shaped distributions. Panel A inset: avalanche
distributions for the critical phase (E = 1.15 mV) for increasing L. Panel B: avalanche cumulative distributions F (s)
corresponding to panel A inset, E = 1.15 mV (the critical phase), for increasing L. Solid line is the fit of Equation (11) used to
estimate Z(L = 20) and α = 1.4(1). Panel B inset: scaling law of Z ∼ LD for E = 1.15 mV yielding D = 1.0(1); this scaling
holds inside the whole critical phase. Avalanche distributions for the other phases have different D and are presented in
Figure 4.
in Figure 2B (circles stand for ρ and squares stand for χρ). The light gray region is called a Griffiths phase because it is an
extended region that satisfies both conditions, instead of being a single critical point. This Griffiths phase is due to the rewiring
of the network, which originates rare regions. In some connection patterns the network allows neurons to fire more easily.
Although rare, the presence of this behavior in the range of 1.11 ≤ E ≤ 1.19 causes large fluctuation of ρ when several trials of
the network are considered.
In fact, Figures 2C,D show that the PL scale functions [Equations (4) and (5)] are satisfied inside the whole EPSP range
1.11 ≤ E ≤ 1.19: the circles and squares in the light gray region in Figure 2B correspond to the red circles in panels C and D.
These panels explicitly show that ρ → 0 and χρ → ∞ for L → ∞. We fitted these equations to the data on E = 1.19 mV ≡ Ec
and obtained the critical exponents β /ν⊥ = 0.55(3), γ/ν⊥ = 3.1(2) and γ(cid:48)/ν⊥ = (γ −β )/ν⊥ = 2.5(2). See the Supplementary
Material for comments on the values of these exponents. Notice that Ec = 1.19 mV is of the same order of our naive mean-field
calculation, Eth ≈ 1.88, although Ec is even closer to the average EPSP in the cortex.29 -- 31
The left-hand side of the Griffiths phase (white background in Figure 2B) has ρ = 0 (green upside down triangles in
Figures 2C,D) and is named the inactive phase whereas the right-hand side (dark grey background) of the Griffiths has ρ
growing rapidly to saturated ρ ≈ 1 (purple squares and blue triangles in Figures 2C,D) and is named the percolating phase.
Both of these phases have finite susceptibility for increasing L.
Avalanche distributions
PL avalanche size and duration distributions are believed to be the ultimate signature of criticality in avalanching dynamical
systems since the seminal work of Bak et al.7, 22 However, recent works have shown that either critical systems may have no PL
distributed avalanches39 or non-critical systems may have PL distributed avalanches.40 We have shown in the previous section
that our model has a continuous phase transition through a GP. Then, this section is devoted to show that PL avalanches may
emerge in our system even outside of the critical regime. The scaling of the cutoff of the distributions must be calculated as
function of the system size in order to have a better estimate of the critical regime of the system. In addition, we highlight some
features of the avalanche distributions which are related to the structure of the network.
Figure 3A shows the distribution of avalanche sizes s for L = 99 and four typical EPSP: E = 1.1 mV (inactive phase),
E = 1.15 mV (Griffiths phase), E = 1.88 mV (percolating phase), and E = 13 mV (percolating phase). Notice that all the four
distributions have PL shape inside the highlighted region (s ≤ 100). We confirmed the PL decay of these distributions via
the Maximum Likelihood test presented in the Supplementary Material. Therefore, a PL shape alone in the distribution of
avalanche sizes is not enough to determine which distribution correspond to a critical regime. Sethna's scaling law (a law which
relates avalanche sizes and durations and is expected to hold only in criticality) also holds for the four phases of the model.53
7/14
Figure 4. Collapse of avalanche size cumulative distributions for many realizations of the simulation for each E. Panel A:
Collapse of avalanches in inactive phase; the cutoff does not scale with system size (D = 0) but the distribution presents a PL
regime with exponent α = 1.5(1) due to noisy activity in the LGN. Panel B: Collapse of avalanches in Griffiths (critical) phase
with exponents α = 1.4(1) and D = 1.0(1) corresponding to Figure 3B. Panel C: Collapse of avalanches in weakly percolating
phase with exponents α1 = 1.4(1), α2 = 1.72(8) and D = 3.1(3); the bump separating both PL ranges is a consequence of the
columnar structure of the network, as it lies where s ≈ Nc. Panel D: Collapse of avalanches in strongly percolating phase with
exponents α = 1.5(1) and D = 2; the gap in this distribution shows that propagation occurs mainly through a large dominating
avalanche, so the PL scaling represents only noisy avalanche activity in the LGN. The straight black lines guide the eyes over
the collapse of the PLs. Notice that α is the exponent of P(s). All the PL exponents were checked using Maximum
Likelihood test (see Supplementary Material).
The distribution of avalanche sizes for fixed E = 1.15 mV (inside the GP) is shown in the inset of Figure 3A for systems of
sizes L = 20,40,80,99. Notice that the larger the system the farther the reach of the distribution. This fact becomes clearer in
the plot of the cumulative distribution of s in Figure 3B. Although the cumulative distributions seem to be turning flat for large
L, they are actually accumulating towards a non-zero slope as L increases corresponding to a PL with exponent −α + 1. We
fitted Equation (11) to the distributions in this figure in order to estimate their cutoffs, Z(L), and their PL exponent, α = 1.4(1)
(this value is obtained for all system sizes). The plot of Z(L) is in the inset of Figure 3B. We fitted Z(L) ∼ LD for the cutoffs
and obtained D = 1.0(1). This value agrees with the scaling exponent for the largest avalanche of the system presented in the
Supplementary Material.
Figure 4 shows the collapse of the cumulative distributions, sα−1F (s/LD) for many L. Each panel corresponds to a different
phase of the model. Panel B of Figure 4 corresponds to the collapsed data of Figure 3B yielding α = 1.4 and D = 1.0(1),
evidencing the PL shape and the scaling of the cutoff of the cumulative distribution in the GP. Both values agree very well with
the fitted data from Figure 3B. The data corresponding to the inactive (or subcritical) phase is collapsed in Figure 4A yielding
D = 0 (avalanches do not scale with system size) and α = 1.5. The data corresponding to the percolating (or supercritical)
phase is presented in panels C and D of Figure 4. D varies inside this phase between D = 3 (for 1.2 (cid:46) E (cid:46) 2 mV) and D = 2
8/14
Figure 5. Autocorrelation, power spectrum, DFA and processing time. Panel A,B: Average autocorrelation (A) and average
power spectrum (B) of avalanche sizes time series for L = 99 and many E: (−−−) inactive phase, ( -- -- ) critical phase,
(−·−) and (·····) percolating phases. The bold lines show the exponential cutoff fit of the autocorrelation E = 1.6 mV giving
τ = 16.2 ts (A). and the fit S( f ) ∼ f −b giving b = 0.97(5) for E = 1.15 mV (critical phase), b = 0.74(4) for E = 1.6 mV and
b = 0.20(2) for E = 2 mV (weakly percolating phase) as examples (B). Notice how the curves' slope in panel B smoothly vary
and yield b ∼ 1 inside the Griffiths phase (see panel C too). Panel C: Power spectrum and DFA exponents versus E inside and
close to the Griffiths region. b is the avalanches power spectrum exponent and g is the DFA exponent of the activity time series
(of Figure 2A). Notice that b ≈ 1 and g (cid:38) 0.7 inside the critical region indicating long-range temporal correlations of both the
avalanche time series and the spiking activity of the network. Panel D: Processing time T as function of E for many L; solid
line indicates the asymptotic behavior of T . Panel D inset: collapse plot ¯T = T /Lµ yielding µ = 0.9(1). Arrows indicate the
minimum of T , vertical bars are standard deviation, light gray is the Griffiths phase and dark gray is the weakly percolating
phase. See Supplementary Material for more details about T .
and becomes D = 2 for large E. α also varies and becomes α = 1.5 for large E.
The characteristic dimension D of avalanches sizes indicates how the activity spreads throughout the network:53 D = 1
means that the activity is rather spreading through the columns of the model, D = 3 means that activity is spreading both
radially and inside the columns and D = 2 means that the activity is spreading only radially and simultaneously within all
the layers. Thus, the different values of D in the percolating phase gives rise to two dynamically distinct phases: the weakly
percolating regime (for 1.2 (cid:46) E (cid:46) 2 mV) and the strongly percolating regime (for E (cid:38) 2 mV). A detailed discussion concerning
the spreading of the network activity is presented elsewhere.53
We identified two PL ranges for the avalanche distributions in the weakly percolating regime (see the purple squares
in Figure 3A and all the curves in Figure 4C). The first range, s < Nc, has α1 = 1.4(1) and the second range, s > Nc, has
α2 = 1.7(1). Nc ≈ 200 is the amount of neurons in a single column of the network. These ranges are separated by a characteristic
bump located at s ≈ Nc that is generated by the columnar structure of the network. If the column size, l, tended to L, the
left-most bump would move to the right until merging with the right-most bump (the cutoff of the distribution). Then, there
9/14
would be a single PL for the avalanches as the one presented by the columnless layered model of Teramae & Fukai.56
Long-range correlations and processing time
From Figure 2A, it is clear that avalanches are temporally organized: each of the four presented time series has a low amplitude
beginning, a growth until a maximum amplitude and then the activity the activity decreases until fading out. We computed
the sequence of avalanche sizes, s(n), its autocorrelation, C(t(cid:48)), and its power spectrum, S( f ). The time t(cid:48) is the lag between
every two avalanches, s(n) and s(n−t(cid:48)). The DFA is calculated over the raw time series, A(t), presented in Figure 2A. These
calculations are described in Supplementary Material.
The autocorrelation function of avalanche sizes is presented in Figure 5A and the power spectrum of avalanche sizes is given
in Figure 5B. Each of the curves is averaged out of many realizations of the simulation. The more long-lasting correlations are
inside the Griffiths phase (red curves) or very close to it (purple curves for E (cid:38) 1.19 mV). The characteristic time τ has been
fitted by the exponential cutoff of Equation (7). τ is expected to scale with exp(LD) inside a Griffiths phase.26, 28, 57 We present
the study of τ in the Supplementary Material.
The power spectrum shows a stable f −b behavior with b ≈ 1 inside the critical phase (see Figure 5B, red curves) for
f < 100 Hz, suggesting long-range correlations in the avalanche size time series. In fact, the smooth change of slopes in
Figure 5B indicates that b varies continuously with E (green squares in Figure 5C). We calculated the DFA exponent g for
the activity time series in order to verify the long-range correlation. The exponent g also varies continuously with E (purple
upside down triangles in Figure 5C) and remains bounded in the interval 0.7 ≤ g ≤ 1 inside the Griffiths phase, confirming the
presence of long-range correlations. Both exponents b and g are close to the expected experimental values.33, 35, 36
Figure 2A also shows that the activity propagation time (also known as mean survival time in absorbing state phase
transitions21) has a non-monotonic behavior with E. Figure 5D shows in details how T varies with E. We found that T has a
deep local minimum at E = 1.18 mV (pointed by arrows) and a global maximum around E = 1.2 mV. The maximum grows
with system size in the critical point Ec according to the law T ∼ Lµ [Equation (10)], as expected. After that, T slowly decays
asymptotically through a landscape full of shallow minima. The more intense the EPSP, the less active presynaptic neurons
are needed to propagate the signal. As a result, the network as a whole will take less time to get activated for large E. The
solid line is an arbitrary fit to the asymptotic decay of T (E). The FSS exponent of the propagation time is µ = 0.90(1) [see
Equation (10) and Supplementary Material]. The rescaled processing time, ¯T ∼ T /Lµ, is shown in the inset of Figure 5D.
For E < Ec, T versus E is shaped similarly to ρ (compare dark circles in Figure 2B to the behavior of T in Figure 5D):
the more neurons get activated, the more time the signal takes to completely cease. Such proportionality causes a deep local
minimum in T near the phase transition and inside the critical phase. Additionally, T has maximum variance inside all the
Griffiths region (see Supplementary Material), meaning that although the signal propagates quickly (in average), the system
is flexible enough to adapt to external input as suggested by experimental work.16 Therefore, it may be conjectured that the
processing of information occur preferably around this region.
Concluding remarks
We studied a model for the visual cortex presenting its characteristic columnar structure. The key elements of this model are the
neurons dynamical structure and dendritic excitation/dissipation balance. While the delay due to action potential propagation in
the dendrites and axons causes the avalanches separation of time scales, the signal attenuation balances the network information
processing. If we were to model lateral inhibition inside the layers, we would expect the activation threshold Eth and the critical
point Ec to grow in accordance with inhibition levels, leaving the described phase transition qualitatively unaltered. Certainly,
the absorbing states of the system would depend on the reach, the quantity and the intensity of the lateral connections inside the
layers. The detailed analysis of this scenario is a matter of future work.
We may summarize this work within five main findings:
• The extended critical phase is confirmed by the scaling laws of the density of activated neurons and of its associated
susceptibility. The quenched disorder of the network generates the zero mean and the divergent variance of the density
of activated neurons in an extended region of the parameter space. This phase is known as a Griffiths phase.26, 28 The
critical phase lies near the average value of EPSP in the cortex (namely E ≈ 1 mV29 -- 31).
• Avalanche size distributions are PL-shaped and their cutoff scale with system size as expected inside the critical region.
However, avalanches also present a PL shape within a limited range of s for non-critical phases, corroborating the
argument that PL avalanches alone (without the cutoff scaling law verified) are not necessarily connected to criticality.39, 40
• The model displays long-range temporal correlations inside the critical region: the power spectrum of avalanche sizes
have the form 1/ f b with b ≈ 1 whereas the activity time series DFA exponent is g (cid:38) 0.7; both match experimental
results.17, 33, 35, 36
10/14
• The model columnar structure was evidenced in the characteristic scale of small avalanches in the avalanches size
distributions for the weakly ordered regime. We hypothesize that the two different power-law regimes could be
experimentally found if the visual system was working in a slightly supercritical regime; for instance, with E = 1.88 mV.
• We discovered a local minimum of the network processing time inside the Griffiths phase close to Ec. At E = Ec,
the propagation time diverges as expected for absorbing phase transitions. Although minimum, the variance of the
propagation time is maximum, resembling the variance of the order parameter. We conjecture that this behavior could be
essential for a reliable processing of information. Inside the inactive or strongly percolating phases, either the network
will respond with noisy activity or will fire a quick single dominating avalanche.
All these evidences strongly suggests that visual processing occurs preferably at or near the critical phase. Our system's
observed criticality results from the average over the rewiring of the network quenched disorder. In the real brain, cortex
synapses are reinforced or weakened on the time scales of seconds to hours, altering the microscopic structure of the network.58
This phenomenon is known as sensory adaptation.59 Moreover, the rewiring of brain connections occurs preferably during
quiescent states, in which there is no processing of information59 -- similarly, after the network has become inactive, we rewire
it in order to stimulate the system again . Thus, Griffiths phases could potentially be experimentally measured if one considers a
long-term measurement of brain activity. Such data would naturally comprise different trials of connections for the propagation
of activity in the many regions of the cortex. Therefore, averages of the long-term activity could potentially be subject to rare
region effects.
The studied model presents essential SOC features, such as the separation of time scales (which emerges naturally in the
critical regime), PL avalanches that scale with system size, long-range temporal correlations and approximately 1/ f power
spectrum (inside the critical regime). Still, this model does not present an explicit mechanism of self-organization that would
allow it to reach the critical state independently of its parameters. Anyhow, the real visual system may adapt to external stimuli
and is indeed self-organized.16, 58 Besides, our model presents an extended region of critical behavior and gives us hints that
these rare region effects might play a role in the real systems. If so, the critical state would be easier to achieve by evolutionary
means due to its extended region in the parameter space.
It is not our aim in this work to determine the universality class of our model. Some issues need to be addressed in order to
do that:
1. The dimensionality of our network is not trivially determined: although N ∼ L2, the connections are chosen randomly
between neurons of adjacent layers within a very small and well determined excitatory field. Notice also that multiple
interactions between the same neighbors happen. On the other hand, mean-field (random) networks have connections
distributed all around the network without multiple interactions.
2. Our exponents α and D are well determined but they rely on an unusual definition of avalanches: we define avalanches
between two consecutive instants of soma silence whereas usually they are defined between two absorbing states of the
system.
3. The dynamics of our model is somewhat similar to the general epidemic process (GEP) or generalized GEP;32 however,
γ(cid:48) is defined for our model but not for these systems.
We stress that the strong way to describe critical phase transitions in the brain is to define an order parameter and its
associated susceptibility and check in which range of parameters the first goes continuously to zero and the second diverges
according to power laws, instead of only studying avalanche distributions or long-range correlations.
Some future work may focus on improving some of the model's features. We can add disorder in E, background noise,
synaptic dynamics or plasticity16, 46, 47 to model adaptability, and use different input stimuli. We also plan to make the excitatory
field of each neuron to change with depth
Our study indicates that being critical or quasi-critical is advantageous for the brain sensory networks. Our network
architecture could be further used to inspire the development of pattern recognition applications because of the short processing
time inside the critical region. The high variability of activated density of neurons may enhance the sensitivity to different
patterns, which may also aid in the pattern recognition tasks. Finally, we hope to provide here a kinematic framework for
microscopic cortical modeling.
References
1. Chialvo, D. R., Balenzuela, P. & Fraiman, D. The brain: What is critical about it? AIP Conf. Proc. 1028, 28 DOI
10.1063/1.2965095 (2008).
11/14
2. Hidalgo, J. et al. Information-based fitness and the emergence of criticality in living systems. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. (USA)
111(28), 10095 -- 10100 DOI 10.1073/pnas.1319166111 (2014).
3. Turing, A. M. Computing machines and intelligence. Mind 59, 433 -- 460 (1950).
4. Chialvo, D. R. Emergent complex neural dynamics. Nat. Phys. 6, 744 -- 750 (2010).
5. Shew, W. L. & Plenz, D. The functional benefits of criticality in the cortex. Neuroscientist 19(1), 88 -- 100 DOI 10.1177/
1073858412445487 (2013).
6. Beggs, J. Editorial: Can there be a physics of the brain? Phys. Rev. Lett. 114(22), 220001 DOI 10.1103/PhysRevLett.
114.220001 (2015).
7. Bak, P., Tang, C. & Wiesenfeld, K. Self-organized criticality: An explanation of 1/f noise. Phys. Rev. Lett. 59(4), 381 -- 384
(1987).
8. Kinouchi, O. & Copelli, M. Optimal dynamical range of excitable networks at criticality. Nat. Phys. 2, 348 -- 351 (2006).
9. de Arcangelis, L., Perrone-Capano, C. & Herrmann, H. J. Self-organized criticality model for brain plasticity. Phys. Rev.
Lett. 96, 028107 (2006).
10. Beggs, J. M. & Timme, N. Being critical of criticality in the brain. Front. Physiol. 3, 163 (2012).
11. Mosqueiro, T. S. & Maia, L. P. Optimal channel efficiency in a sensory network. Phys. Rev. E 88(1), 012712 DOI
10.1103/PhysRevE.88.012712 (2013).
12. Beggs, J. M. & Plenz, D. Neuronal avalanches in neocortical circuits. J. Neurosci. 23(35), 11167 -- 11177 (2003).
13. Ribeiro, T. L. et al. Spike avalanches exhibit universal dynamics across the sleep-wake cycle. PLoS ONE 5(11), e14129
(2010).
14. Hahn, G. et al. Neuronal avalanches in spontaneous activity in vivo. Journal of Neurophysiology 104(6), 3312 -- 3322 DOI
10.1152/jn.00953.2009 (2010).
15. Priesemann, V. et al. Spike avalanches in vivo suggest a driven, slightly subcritical brain state. Front Syst Neurosci. 8, 108
DOI 10.3389/fnsys.2014.00108 (2014).
16. Shew, W. L. et al. Adaptation to sensory input tunes visual cortex to criticality. Nat. Phys. 11, 659 -- 663 DOI 10.1038/
nphys3370 (2015).
17. Linkenkaer-Hansen, K., Nikouline, V. V., Palva, J. M. & Ilmoniemi, R. J. Long-range temporal correlations and scaling
behavior in human brain oscillations. J. Neurosci. 21(4), 1370 -- 1377 (2001).
18. Haimovici, A., Tagliazucchi, E., Balenzuela, P. & Chialvo, D. R. Brain organization into resting state networks emerges at
criticality on a model of the human connectome. Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 178101 (2013).
19. Barber, M. N. Finite-size scaling. In Domb, C. & Lebowitz, J. L. (eds.) Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena, vol. 8
(Academic Press, New York, USA, 1983).
20. Stanley, H. E. Introduction to Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena (Oxford University Press, New York, UK, 1971).
21. Henkel, M., Hinrichsen, H. & Lubeck, S. Non-Equilibrium Phase Transitions (Springer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands,
2008).
22. Pruessner, G. Self-Organised Criticality (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 2012).
23. Munoz, M. A., Dickman, R., Vespignani, A. & Zapperi, S. Avalanche and spreading exponents in systems with absorbing
states. Phys. Rev. E 59(5), 6175 -- 6179 DOI 10.1103/PhysRevE.59.6175 (1999).
´Odor, G. Universality classes in nonequilibrium lattice systems. Rev. Mod. Phys. 76(3), 663 -- 724 (2004).
24.
25. Yu, S., Yang, H., Shriki, O. & Plenz, D. Universal organization of resting brain activity at the thermodynamic critical point.
Front. Syst. Neurosci. 7 DOI 10.3389/fnsys.2013.00042 (2013).
26. Moretti, P. & Munoz, M. A. Griffiths phases and the stretching of criticality in brain networks. Nat. Commun. 4, 2521 DOI
10.1038/ncomms3521 (2013).
27. Griffiths, R. B. Nonanalytic behavior above the critical point in a random Ising ferromagnet. Phys. Rev. Lett. 23(1), 17 -- 19
DOI 10.1103/PhysRevLett.23.17 (1969).
28. Vojta, T. Rare region effects at classical, quantum and nonequilibrium phase transitions. J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 39, R143
DOI 10.1088/0305-4470/39/22/R01 (2006).
12/14
29. Williams, S. R. & Stuart, G. J. Dependence of EPSP efficacy on synapse location in neocortical pyramidal neurons. Science
295, 1907 -- 1910 (2002).
30. Song, S., Sjostrom, P. J., Reigl, M., Nelson, S. & Chklovskii, D. B. Highly nonrandom features of synaptic connectivity in
local cortical circuits. PLoS Biol. 3(3), e68 DOI 10.1371/journal.pbio.0030068 (2005).
31. Lefort, S., Tomm, C., Floyd Sarria, J.-C. & Petersen, C. C. The excitatory neuronal network of the c2 barrel column in
mouse primary somatosensory cortex. Neuron 61(2), 301 -- 316 DOI 10.1016/j.neuron.2008.12.020 (2009).
32. Janssen, H.-K., Muller, M. & Stenull, O. Generalized epidemic process and tricritical dynamic percolation. Phys. Rev. E
70, 026114 DOI 10.1103/PhysRevE.70.026114 (2004).
33. Novikov, E., Novikov, A., Shannahoff-Khalsa, D., Schwartz, B. & Wright, J. Scale-similar activity in the brain. Phys. Rev.
E 56(3), R2387 -- R2389 (1997).
34. Teich, M. C., Heneghan, C., Lowen, S. B., Ozaki, T. & Kaplan, E. Fractal character of the neural spike train in the visual
system of the cat. J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 14(3), 529 -- 546 DOI 10.1364/JOSAA.14.000529 (1997).
35. Andrew Henrie, J. & Shapley, R. LFP power spectra in V1 cortex: The graded effect of stimulus contrast. J. Neurophysiol.
94, 479 -- 490 DOI 10.1152/jn.00919.2004 (2005).
36. Hermes, D., Miller, K. J., Wandell, B. A. & Winawer, J. Stimulus dependence of gamma oscillations in human visual
cortex. Cereb. Cortex DOI 10.1093/cercor/bhu091 (2014).
37. Peng, C.-K., Havlin, S., Stanley, H. E. & Goldberger, A. L. Quantification of scaling exponents and crossover phenomena
in nonstationary heartbeat time series. Chaos 5, 82 -- 87 DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.166141 (1995).
38. Hardstone, R. et al. Detrended fluctuation analysis: a scale-free view on neuronal oscillations. Front. Physiol. 3, 450 DOI
10.3389/fphys.2012.00450 (2012).
39. Taylor, T. J., Hartley, C., Simon, P. L., Kiss, I. Z. & Berthouze, L. Identification of criticality in neuronal avalanches: I. A
theoretical investigation of the non-driven case. J. Math. Neurosci. 3, 5 DOI 10.1186/2190-8567-3-5 (2013).
40. Touboul, J. & Destexhe, A. Power-law statistics and universal scaling in the absence of criticality. arXiv:1503.08033
[q-bio.NC] (2015).
41. O'Kusky, J. & Colonnier, M. A laminar analysis of the number of neurons, glia and synapses in the visual cortex (area 17)
of adult macaque monkeys. J. Comp. Neurol. 210, 278 -- 290 (1982).
42. Lund, J. S. Spiny stellate neurons. In Peters, A. & Jones, E. G. (eds.) The Cerebral Cortex, vol. 1, chap. 7, 255 -- 308
(Plenum Press, New York, USA, 1984).
43. Callaway, E. M. Local circuits in primary visual cortex of the macaque monkey. Annu. Rev. Neurosci. 21(2), 47 -- 74 (1998).
44. Yabuta, N. H. & Callaway, E. M. Functional streams and local connections of layer 4c neurons in primary visual cortex of
the macaque monkey. J. Neurosci. 18(22), 9489 -- 9499 (1998).
45. Albright, T. D., Jessell, T. M., Kandel, E. R. & Posner, M. I. Neural science: A century of progress and the mysteries that
remain. Neuron 25, S1 -- S55 DOI 10.1016/S0896-6273(00)80912-5 (2000).
46. Levina, A., Herrmann, J. M. & Geisel, T. Dynamical synapses causing self-organized criticality in neural networks. Nat.
Phys. 3, 857 -- 860 (2007).
47. de Andrade Costa, A., Copelli, M. & Kinouchi, O. Can dynamical synapses produce true self-organized criticality? J. Stat.
Mech. P06004 DOI 10.1088/1742-5468/2015/06/P06004 (2015).
48. Girardi-Schappo, M., Kinouchi, O. & Tragtenberg, M. H. R. Critical avalanches and subsampling in map-based neural
networks coupled with noisy synapses. Phys. Rev. E 88, 024701 DOI 10.1103/PhysRevE.88.024701 (2013).
49. Williams-Garc´ıa, R. V., Moore, M., Beggs, J. M. & Ortiz, G. Quasicritical brain dynamics on a nonequilibrium widom line.
Phys. Rev. E 90(6), 062714 DOI 10.1103/PhysRevE.90.062714 (2014).
50. Andreazza, J. K. & Pinto, L. T. Simulation of the primary visual cortex of the macaque monkey by natural neural networks.
In Prooceedings of 2nd LNCC Meeting on Computational Modelling (Petr´opolis, RJ, Brazil, 2006).
51. Kandel, E., Schwartz, J. & Jessell, T. Principles of Neural Science (McGraw-Hill Education, Columbus, OH, USA, 2012).
52. Deutsch, S. & Deutsch, A. Understanding the Nervous System (IEEE Press, New York, NY, USA, 1993).
53. Bortolotto, G. S., Girardi-Schappo, M., Gonsalves, J. J., Pinto, L. T. & Tragtenberg, M. H. R. Information processing
occurs via critical avalanches in a model of the primary visual cortex. J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 686, 012008 DOI 10.1088/
1742-6596/686/1/012008 (2016).
13/14
54. Grassberger, P. On the critical behavior of the general epidemic process and dynamical percolation. Math. Biosci. 63(2),
157 -- 172 DOI 10.1016/0025-5564(82)90036-0 (1983).
55. Ferreira, S. C., Castellano, C. & Pastor-Satorras, R. Epidemic thresholds of the susceptible-infected-susceptible model on
networks: A comparison of numerical and theoretical results. Phys. Rev. E 86, 041125 DOI 10.1103/PhysRevE.86.
041125 (2012).
56. Teramae, J.-N. & Fukai, T. Local cortical circuit model inferred from power-law distributed neuronal avalanches. J.
Comput. Neurosci. 22(3), 301 -- 312 DOI 10.1007/s10827-006-0014-6 (2007).
57. Bray, A. J. & Rodgers, G. J. Diffusion in a sparsely connected space: A model for glassy relaxation. Phys. Rev. B 38(16),
11461 -- 11470 (1988).
58. Chung, S., Li, X. & Nelson, S. B. Short-term depression at thalamocortical synapses contributes to rapid adaptation of
cortical sensory responses in vivo. Neuron 34, 437 -- 446 DOI 10.1016/S0896-6273(02)00659-1 (2002).
59. Castro-Alamancos, M. A. Absence of rapid sensory adaptation in neocortex during information processing states. Neuron
41, 455 -- 464 DOI 10.1016/S0896-6273(03)00853-5 (2004).
Acknowledgements
The model and the first version of its code have been conceived and implemented by J. K. Andreazza and LTP. We thank
J.-P. Thivierge for providing the code for Maximum Likelihood test. We also thank M. Copelli, O. Kinouchi, R. Dickman,
S. Boettcher and T. B. Pedro for discussions. MGS and GSB thank the partial financial support of CNPq and FAPESC,
respectively.
Author contributions statement
LTP conceived the model; MGS and LTP updated the code; MGS, GSB and LTP ran the simulations; All authors analyzed the
results; MGS and GSB wrote the manuscript; All authors reviewed the manuscript.
Additional information
Supplementary information accompanies this paper at http://www.nature.com/srep
Competing financial interests: The authors declare no competing financial interests.
14/14
|
1103.5112 | 1 | 1103 | 2011-03-26T06:57:37 | Weight-conserving characterization of complex functional brain networks | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cond-mat.dis-nn",
"physics.data-an"
] | Complex functional brain networks are large networks of brain regions and functional brain connections. Statistical characterizations of these networks aim to quantify global and local properties of brain activity with a small number of network measures. Important functional network measures include measures of modularity (measures of the goodness with which a network is optimally partitioned into functional subgroups) and measures of centrality (measures of the functional influence of individual brain regions). Characterizations of functional networks are increasing in popularity, but are associated with several important methodological problems. These problems include the inability to characterize densely connected and weighted functional networks, the neglect of degenerate topologically distinct high-modularity partitions of these networks, and the absence of a network null model for testing hypotheses of association between observed nontrivial network properties and simple weighted connectivity properties. In this study we describe a set of methods to overcome these problems. Specifically, we generalize measures of modularity and centrality to fully connected and weighted complex networks, describe the detection of degenerate high-modularity partitions of these networks, and introduce a weighted-connectivity null model of these networks. We illustrate our methods by demonstrating degenerate high-modularity partitions and strong correlations between two complementary measures of centrality in resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) networks from the 1000 Functional Connectomes Project, an open-access repository of resting-state functional MRI datasets. Our methods may allow more sound and reliable characterizations and comparisons of functional brain networks across conditions and subjects. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | 1
Weight-conserving characterization of
complex functional brain networks
Mikail Rubinov1,2,3 and Olaf Sporns4
Abstract: Complex functional brain networks are large
networks of brain regions and functional brain connections.
Statistical characterizations of these networks aim to
quantify global and local properties of brain activity with a
small number of network measures. Important functional
network measures
include measures of modularity
(measures of the goodness with which a network is
optimally partitioned
into
functional subgroups) and
measures of centrality (measures of the functional influence
of individual brain regions). Characterizations of functional
networks are increasing in popularity, but are associated
with several important methodological problems. These
problems include the inability to characterize densely
connected and weighted functional networks, the neglect of
degenerate topologically distinct high-modularity partitions
of these networks, and the absence of a network null model
for testing hypotheses of association between observed
nontrivial network properties and simple weighted
connectivity properties. In this study we describe a set of
methods to overcome these problems. Specifically, we
generalize measures of modularity and centrality to fully
connected and weighted complex networks, describe the
detection of degenerate high-modularity partitions of these
networks, and introduce a weighted-connectivity null model
of
these networks. We
illustrate our methods by
demonstrating degenerate high-modularity partitions and
strong correlations between two complementary measures
of centrality in resting-state functional magnetic resonance
imaging
the 1000 Functional
from
(MRI) networks
Connectomes Project, an open-access repository of resting-
state functional MRI datasets. Our methods may allow more
sound and reliable characterizations and comparisons of
functional brain networks across conditions and subjects.
Introduction
Large-scale functional brain networks are networks of
brain regions and functional connections – coactivations or
correlations – between pairs of these regions. Complex
functional brain networks are
large and extensive
1. Black Dog Institute and School of Psychiatry, University of New South
Wales, Sydney, Australia; 2. Mental Health Research Division, Queensland
Institute of Medical Research, Brisbane, Australia; 3. CSIRO Information
and Communication Technologies Centre , Sydney, Australia; 4.
Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, Indiana University,
Bloomington, USA.
Corresponding author: Mikail Rubinov, Mental health research division,
Queensland institute of medical research, PO Royal Brisbane Hospital,
QLD 4029, Australia. Email: [email protected]
networks of nontrivially interacting brain regions that
often serve as maps of global brain activity (Bullmore and
Sporns, 2009). Interactions between regions in complex
functional networks vary in magnitude from large to small,
and vary in sign from positive to negative. In contrast, the
more traditional “simple” functional networks are smaller
groupings of strongly and mutually correlated regions that
often serve as maps of specialized functional systems (Fox
and Raichle, 2007). Simple functional networks form
highly connected modules – components or subnetworks –
within complex functional networks (Meunier et al., 2010).
Statistical characterizations of complex
functional
networks attempt to quantify global and local properties of
these networks with a small number of network measures
(Stam and Rejneveld, 2007; Bullmore and Sporns, 2009;
Rubinov and Sporns, 2010). Important functional network
measures include measures of modularity (measures of
the goodness with which a network
is optimally
partitioned into modules) and measures of centrality
(measures of the functional influence of individual brain
regions). For instance, recent characterizations partitioned
complex resting-state
functional MRI networks
into
modules which correspond to visual, attention, default
mode and other “simple” networks (Fair et al., 2008; He et
al., 2009; Meunier et al., 2009) and identified prominent
central brain regions in heteromodal association areas
(Achard et al., 2006; Buckner et al., 2009). Interestingly,
several studies reported alterations of complex functional
network
topology
in neurological and psychiatric
disorders, such as Alzheimer’s disease (Supekar et al.,
2008) and schizophrenia (Lynall et al., 2010).
Despite
current
these
promising
findings,
characterizations of complex functional networks are
associated with several methodological problems. Firstly,
most current network measures are optimally suited for
sparse and binary networks and are less well suited for
dense and weighted networks. This often necessitates the
conversion of dense and weighted complex functional
networks to sparse and binary form. Such conversions are
threshold, setting all
made by defining a weight
suprathreshold connection weights
to and all
subthreshold weights to . These thresholding and
binarizing manipulations are associated with loss of
information and are often arbitrarily made. Secondly,
current modularity studies typically describe only one
high-modularity partition. Recently, Good et al. (2010)
2
analytically showed that modular complex networks are
likely to have many topologically distinct, high-modularity
partitions. The presence of such “degenerate” partitions
makes it less meaningful to focus on only one potentially
unrepresentative case. Degenerate partitions have not
been previously reported in functional brain networks,
although similar concepts have been considered in the
context of cluster stability (Bellec et al., 2010). Thirdly, no
satisfactory null model of complex functional networks is
currently available. A null model of functional networks
should allow to test null hypotheses of association
between observed nontrivial network properties, such as
high modularity and degeneracy, and simple network
properties, such as basic organization of weighted
connectivity.
In this study, we describe a set of methods that aim to
overcome the above methodological problems. Firstly, we
generalize measures of modularity and centrality to fully
connected networks with positive and negative weights.
Secondly, we describe the detection of degenerate high-
modularity partitions of these networks. Thirdly, we
introduce a weighted null model of these networks. We
illustrate our methods by characterizing resting-state
functional MRI networks from the 1000 Functional
Connectomes Project, an open-access repository of
resting-state functional MRI datasets (Biswal et al., 2010).
Methods
In this section we provide mathematical definitions of
our proposed measures and algorithms. The Brain
Connectivity Toolbox
(http://www.brain-connectivity-
toolbox.net), an open-access Matlab network analysis
toolbox which we maintain, contains software to compute
these measures. We encourage readers unfamiliar with
complex networks methodology to consult our
less
technical and more accessible recent overview (Rubinov
and Sporns, 2010).
Complex functional brain networks are fully connected,
undirected, positively and negatively weighted networks
connections. We denote the
of nodes and
presence of a positively weighted connection between
and
,
nodes and in these networks with
and we denote the weight of this connection with
,
. Equivalently, we denote the presence
of a negatively weighted connection between nodes and
, and the weight of this connection
,
with
. The degree of node ,
,
with
,
is the number of positive or negative connections of . The
strength of node ,
, is the sum of positive or
negative connection weights of . The total weight,
, is the sum of all positive or negative
connection weights (counted twice for each connection).
Measures of modularity in networks with positive and
negative weights
A modularity partition is the complete subdivision of the
network into nonoverlapping modules (Fortunato, 2010).
Measures of modularity quantify
the goodness of
modularity partitions (Newman, 2004). In networks with
no negative weights, a de-facto-standard measure of
modularity is the average difference between present
and chance-
within-module connection weights
,
expected within-module connection weights
, when and are in the same
where
module and otherwise (Newman, 2006).
Partitions with high therefore have larger than chance-
expected total positive within-module weight. The factor
rescales the maximized to the range of .
In this study we assume that both positively and
negatively weighted
connections
provide
useful
information about the goodness of modularity partitions.
Specifically, we consider positively weighted connections
to represent similar activation patterns and hence to
support placement of positively connected pairs of nodes
in the same module. The measure reflects this
contribution of positive weights. On the other hand, we
consider negatively weighted connections to represent
distinct activation patterns or antiphase coupling and
hence to support placement of negatively connected pairs
of nodes in distinct modules. An analogous measure
reflects this contribution of negative weights,
We now consider a simple modularity measure for
networks with positive and negative weights,
simple
This measure is problematic because it does not rescale
and . For instance, the presence of precisely one
negative connection in the network always inappropriately
to ,
contributes
irrespectively of other
connectivity (this follows from the definition of ). A
number of recently proposed modularity measures
attempt to overcome this problem by rescaling and
by the total connection weight . For instance,
Traag and Bruggeman (2009) generalize the standard
modularity measure as
T
where and are module size parameters. Gomez,
Jensen and Arenas (2009) consider a special case of T
for ,
3
GJA
Finally, Kaplan and Forrest (2008) generalize the
standard modularity measure slightly differently, by
additionally rescaling the chance-expected within-module
connection weights,
where
. All
replaces
modularity measures reduce to the standard measure
when there are no negative weights in the network.
these
An asymmetric measure of modularity in networks with
positive and negative weights
treat and
the above generalizations
All
symmetrically and are hence based on the assumption that
positive and negative weights are equally important. Here
we argue that this assumption
is neurobiologically
problematic, because the role and importance of positive
and negative weights in functional networks is intrinsically
unequal. Positive weights associate nodes with modules
explicitly, while negative weights associate nodes with
modules implicitly, by dissociating nodes from other
modules. Empirically, high- modularity partitions are
than high- modularity
objectively
less optimal
partitions (see Results).
The unequal
importance of positive and negative
weights in modularity-partition determination motivates
an asymmetric generalization of the standard measure. We
hence define
Our definition explicitly makes the contribution of
negative weights auxiliary to the contribution of positive
weights. For instance, increase in positive weights reduces
the influence of negative weights in , unlike in . On
the other hand, increase in negative weights does not
reduce the influence of positive weights in , unlike in
T (hence GJA ) and KF . In networks with approximately
equal numbers of positive and negative weights, the
influence of positive weights in will be twice as large as
the influence of negative weights. High- partitions
should theoretically have most positive weights within
modules, and most negative weights between modules.
Maximized values of are in the range of .
We now illustrate the advantage of our measure with an
example. We consider a network of 100 nodes and four
equally sized modules. The network has a maximal
number of positive weights within modules, and no
positive weights between modules. Initially, the network
.
has no negative weights. For simplicity we set all
We now randomly add negative weights to this network
until the network becomes fully connected (Figure 1a), and
observe the resulting changes in values of the modularity
measures (Figures 1b-e). We note that only behaves as
we intuitively expect: the contribution of positive weights
does not change, while the contribution of negative
weights gradually increases. The contribution of negative
weights to simple is paradoxically large when there are few
negative weights, while the contribution of positive
weights to (hence ) and paradoxically
decreases, even as the number and organization of positive
weights does not change.
Evaluation of the goodness of modularity partitions
The goodness of modularity partitions may in general be
quantified with many measures. In addition to and ,
these measures include the proportion of within-module
positive and negative weights,
and the geometric mean of balanced and unbalanced
within-module triangle weights (Onnela et al., 2005),
where . is a generalization of the
weighted clustering coefficient to networks with positive
and negative weights and is related to the within-module
density. Good modularity partitions should have an
unexpectedly large proportion of clustered, positively
weighted connections within modules (high , and
, respectively), and an unexpectedly small proportion of
unclustered, negatively weighted connections within
modules (high , and , respectively). Note that
, and lie in the range of , while and lie
in the range of .
Detection of degenerate high-modularity partitions
Degenerate high-modularity partitions are topologically
distinct modularity partitions with similarly high values of
the modularity (Good et al., 2010). We argue that
characterization of the modularity in functional networks
should comprehensively describe
the set of
these
partitions. In this study, we searched for degenerate
partitions in two steps:
4
Figure 1. Conceptual advantages of an asymmetric modularity measure.
(a) A network with a maximal number of within-module positively
weighted (red) connections and an increasing number (from left to right)
of between-module negatively weighted (blue) connections. (b)-(e)
Contributions to modularity of positive (red) and negative (blue) weights,
and the total modularity (black) as a function of the proportion of
negative between-module connections. (b) , (c) (note the
semilogarithmic scale), (d) for ; results for (
are shown in bold, (e) . Values are averages of simulations.
identified several seed partitions for
1. We first
subsequent systematic exploration of degeneracy. We
identified
these partitions with a popular greedy
modularity-maximization algorithm (Blondel et al., 2008)
and a fine-tuning algorithm (Sun et al., 2009), but in
principle many other modularity-maximization algorithms
may be used (Fortunato, 2010). Most modularity-
maximization algorithms search
for high-modularity
partitions heuristically and discover slightly different
partitions from run to run. Accordingly, the Blondel et al.
(2008) algorithm estimates optimal module affiliation for
each node by sequentially and repeatedly examining nodes
in random order. This randomness is associated with
potential variations
in discovered high-modularity
partitions. We applied this algorithm times to each
examined network to obtain preliminary seed
partitions. We further refined these partitions with a
Kernighan-Lin (1970)-based fine-tuning algorithm (Sun et
al., 2009). More specifically, we iteratively refined each
partition by computing changes
in the modularity
associated with all potential between-module node moves,
including moves that resulted in creation of new modules.
We then considered a node associated with an optimal
move, and made the corresponding move if it increased the
modularity. At each
iteration of the algorithm we
considered each node exactly once, and we repeatedly
iterated until no further moves increased the modularity.
These refined partitions constituted our seed partitions for
step 2 and represent peaks in the modularity landscape of
the network. Seed partitions were not all necessarily
distinct.
2. We next systematically searched for degenerate high-
modularity partitions by rerunning one further iteration of
fine-tuning algorithm on seed partitions, and
the
incorporating
into this
iteration random moves of
randomly chosen (but not previously considered) nodes.
We defined partitions to be degenerate when the
modularity of these partitions was in the top of the
estimated maximum. We examined million candidate
degenerate partitions by varying the probability of random
moves for each seed partition from (no randomization)
to in increments (we empirically
determined
that
the
lower bound
captured an
overwhelming majority of degenerate partitions in the
studied networks).
We quantified the similarity of individual partitions with
the variation of information, a popular information-
theoretic measure of distance in partition space (Meila,
2007). To compute the variation of information, we first
define the entropy associated with a partition as
where the sum is over all modules in ,
and
is the number of nodes in module . We then analogously
define the mutual information between two partitions
and as
where
and is the number of nodes that
are simultaneously in module of partition , and in
module of partition . We finally define the variation of
information as
5
where the factor
rescales the variation of information
to the range of , such that corresponds to equal
partitions, and corresponds to maximally distant
partitions (Karrer et al., 2008).
We note two things about our algorithm. Firstly, the
threshold
is conservative and may potentially miss
meaningful partitions with lower modularity. Secondly, the
study of modularity degeneracy is still in its infancy, and
efficient and exhaustive search algorithms are only
beginning to be developed (Good et al., 2010; Duggal et al.,
2010). Consequently, while we find a reasonably large
number of degenerate partitions with our algorithm, we
cannot claim that the algorithm searches exhaustively. On
the other hand, the knowledge of all possible partitions
may not be needed as long as the discovered partitions are
evenly sampled and are representative of the whole
partition set.
We now illustrate the application of our algorithm to
simple model networks. We first consider, as previously, a
network of 100 nodes and four equally sized modules. The
network has a maximal number of positive weights within
modules, and a maximal number of negative weights
between modules (Figure 2a). We randomize this network
and examine the number of discovered degenerate
partitions as a function of randomization. Figure 2b shows
that the number of discovered partitions is close to at
low levels of randomization (in modular networks), is
relatively low at large levels of randomization (in random
networks) and peaks at the transition from modular to
random network topology. Figure 2c shows that the
distance between discovered partitions is low for modular
networks, rapidly rises at the transition, and remains high
for random networks.
To probe the evenness with which our algorithm
samples degenerate partitions, we apply this algorithm to
a lattice network (Figure 2d) and obtain a within-module
connectivity likelihood matrix by averaging the topology of
all discovered partitions for this network. Connections
with high values in this matrix are hence likely to be
located
inside modules. Figure 2e shows that the
likelihood matrix
the
reconstructs
accurately
homogeneous lattice topology, and hence suggests an even
sampling of degenerate partitions of the lattice.
Measures of centrality in networks with positive and
negative weights
Central brain regions have functional connections to
many diverse regions. These properties are intuitively
captured in measures of regional connection strength and
regional connection diversity. We define the normalized
connection strength as
and we define the normalized connection diversity as
where
is the strength of node within
,
module (the total weight of connections of i to all nodes
in u), and is the number of modules in modularity
and
to
rescale
and
partition . The factors
and
the range of . Central nodes should have high
but low
and
. As above, we consider the strength
and diversity of positively weighted connections to be
important than the strength and diversity of
more
negatively weighted
connections. We
accordingly
and
as
generalize
where we rescale the contribution of negative weights by
, due to the local nature of
, rather than by
centrality measures. Our generalizations favor nodes with
high but equal positive and negative strength and diversity
over nodes with low and equal positive and negative
and
are in the range of
strength and diversity. Both
.
Our measures of centrality have clear parallels, but also
important differences, with
the
commonly used
“cartographic” classification of node roles in complex
networks (Guimera and Amaral, 2005). The cartographic
classification of node roles likewise quantifies connection
strength and connection diversity, but uses a measure of
the within-module strength for the former, and a measure
of the participation coefficient for the latter. Here we use
the total connection strength, rather than the within-
module connection strength, because functional centrality
usually presumes global integration, and because within-
module strength profiles should be similar by transitivity
of correlations. In addition, we compute connection
diversity with the normalized Shannon (1948) entropy,
rather than the participation coefficient, or equivalently
the Simpson (1949) index. Shannon entropy and Simpson
index are similar measures of diversity (e.g. Keylock,
2005) but importantly differ in the upper bound on
maximally central nodes. The normalized Shannon entropy
has a constant upper bound of , while the Simpson index
has a variable upper bound of
. The upper bound of
the Simpson index may hence differ for partitions of
different networks, and for different partitions of the same
network. These considerations
led us to adopt the
Shannon entropy as a more consistent measure of
diversity.
6
degrees, preserve connection weights and closely
approximate node strengths. The corresponding null
hypothesis hence asserts
that observed network
properties are associated with degree, weight and strength
properties of the network.
Our algorithm consists of two steps:
1. We first randomize network connections in a way that
preserves positive and negative degrees. There are a
number of ways to achieve this and we use a simple
popular heuristic known as the connection-switching
method (e.g. Wormald, 1999). We choose four nodes , ,
and
that
at random, such
,
. We
and
then set
. We iteratively repeat this process until
the network is randomized.
2. We next associate original network weights with
connections in a way that closely approximates the
positive and negative strengths. This procedure
is
equivalent for positive and negative weights . For positive
by magnitude.
weights, we begin by ranking all original
in the network
At the same time, we associate all
, and we rank all
by the expected weight
with
magnitude,
, noting that
. We then choose a random
when all
of the same rank as the chosen
, set
to
,
and
pair
remove the chosen
from further
and
. We
consideration, and re-rank all remaining
repeat
this process until each positively weighted
connections in the new network is associated with one of
the original positive weights. Re-ranking at every step is
important and allows convergence
the original
to
strengths. In larger networks however, less frequent re-
ranking may be performed without detriment to accuracy.
We now illustrate the effectiveness of our algorithm
with an example. We consider networks of four equally
sized modules with normally distributed weights centered
at . Figure 3a,b shows a representative network, and an
example null model of this network. Figure 3c shows the
correlation coefficients between positive and negative
strengths of the original network and its null model. These
strength correlations exceed for networks of size
, and exceed for networks of size (solid
lines). On the other hand, strength correlations effectively
vanish when weights are randomly associated with
connections, even if the degrees are preserved (broken
lines). Figure 3d shows that the correlation coefficients
between the positive and negative weights of the original
and null model networks are very weak, which suggests an
effective randomization. Strength correlations in empirical
networks are likely to be even higher (see Results)
because empirical networks typically have nonuniform
degree distributions.
Figure 2. Detection of degenerate high-modularity partitions. (a)
Modular, intermediate and random networks with positively weighted
(red) and negatively weighted (blue) connections. (b) Number of
discovered partitions and (c) average distance between discovered
partitions as a function of network randomization. Error bars represent
the standard error of the mean from 10 simulations. (d) A lattice network
and (e) the estimated within-module connection likelihood of the lattice
network, computed as the average over a ll discovered degenerate
partitions. The number of discovered degenerate partitions for the lattice
was approximately .
Degree-, weight- and strength-preserving null model
Nontrivial properties of network topology, such as high
modularity and degeneracy, can only be conclusively
claimed through comparisons with appropriate null
models. A standard null model of binary networks is a
random network with preserved degrees. To our
knowledge, there is no corresponding null model of
weighted networks. Here we introduce such a model by
generalizing the binary null model to preserve node
7
Figure 3. Degree-, weight- and strength-preserving null model. (a) A network with a maximal number of positive within -module connections (warm
colors), a maximal number of negative between modules connections (cool colors), and a normally distributed weight distributi on with mean of . (b) A
null model of the network in (a), reordered by modular organization. (c) Correlation coefficients between positive (red) and negative (blue) strengths of
the original and null model networks (solid lines), as a function of network size. Correlations between degree -preserving, but strength-non-preserving
networks are shown for comparison (dashed lines). (d) Correlations between connection weights in the original and null-model networks. Error bars
represent the standard error of the mean from 10 simulations.
Results
In this section, we apply our measures to functional
connectivity networks constructed from datasets in the
1000 Functional Connectomes Project (Biswal et al., 2010).
The 1000 Functional Connectomes Project
is an
international open-access repository of resting-state
functional connectivity MRI datasets. For the following
analyses, we
connectivity
functional
characterized
networks from 18 available sites in this repository (Figure
4). The functional network associated with each site
represents the group-average network of all subjects in
that site. Each network contains 112 cortical and
subcortical regions defined according to the Harvard-
Oxford atlas, a probabilistic anatomical landmark -based
atlas (Makris et al., 1999; Table S1). Demographic,
recording and preprocessing details associated with these
networks are described in Biswal et al. (2010) and
references therein. The networks were kindly provided by
Xi-Nian Zuo and Mike Milham, and are available on the
project website (http://fcon_1000.projects.nitrc.org/).
Goodness of high-modularity partitions
Network weights were near-normally distributed
around a mean of (Figure S1), and consequently all
networks had large numbers of negative weights. We first
considered the effect of these weights by studying
properties of high- , , and partitions. The
respective modularity measures
incorporate differing
influences of negative weights, from absent influence in
to sole influence in . Figure 5 shows properties of these
high-modularity partitions averaged over all degenerate
partitions of each network. Increasing
influence of
negative weights was associated with reduced numbers of
modules and increased module size (Figure 5a,b), with
larger numbers of within-module positive weights and a
lower density of these weights (Figure 5c,d) and with
increased non-rescaled contribution of negative weights
(i.e. ) and reduced non-rescaled contributions of
positive weights (i.e. ) (Figure 5e). High- partitions
were associated with very low values of non-rescaled
contributions of positive weights (Figure 5e), and with
very high numbers of discovered degenerate partitions
(Figure 5f). These partitions were objectively less optimal
than the other partitions, supporting our argument for a
less important role of negative weights in partition
determination.
Most current studies characterize functional network
topology indirectly, by characterizing sparse and binary
representations of these networks (Rubinov and Sporns,
2010). We next studied properties of high-modularity
partitions of these representations, by considering binary
networks with preserved , , , and
of the strongest positive connections. Figure 6 shows
properties of high-modularity partitions associated with
these networks, averaged over all degenerate partitions of
each network. For meaningful comparison, we computed
properties of these partitions
in the original
fully
connected networks; this allowed us, for instance, to
examine organization of negative weights
in these
partitions even if the binary representations did not have
negative weights. Figure 6 shows that reduced numbers of
preserved connections
in the binary networks was
associated with
increased numbers of modules and
reduced module size (Figure 6a,b), with smaller numbers
of within-module positive weights and a higher density of
these weights (Figures 6c,d). Non-rescaled contributions of
positive weights peaked when binary representations
preserved of
strongest
connections, while
representations with fewer connections had low non-
rescaled contributions of both positive and negative
weights (Figure 6e) and high numbers of degenerate
partitions (Figure 6f).
8
Figure 4. The examined resting-state functional MRI networks from the 1000 Functional Connectomes Project. All networks represent group averages
over all subjects at each site, parcellated using the Harvard-Oxford Atlas. Node order is in Table S1.
We finally compared properties of observed high-
modularity partitions to properties of high-modularity
partitions of constructed null models. Null models had
highly
conserved
strengths:
the
strength-strength
correlation coefficient for empirical networks and their
null model was for positive strengths and
for negative strengths (mean standard
deviation). Figures 5 and 6 show that null models had
substantially smaller numbers of within-module positive
weights, a lower density of these weights and lower non-
rescaled contributions of positive and negative weights.
These findings suggest that observed properties of high-
modularity partitions of empirical networks were not
associated with weight, degree and strength properties of
these networks.
Degeneracy of high-modularity partitions
Figures 5f and 6f show that the empirical networks had
many degenerate high-modularity partitions. The number
of discovered partitions varied for modularity measures
and network topologies. Measures or topologies that
ignored important weight information (by maximizing
or by discarding a
large number of weights) had
substantially larger numbers of degenerate partitions. On
the other hand, null models of all networks had very few
degenerate partitions. The number of degenerate
partitions
associated
with
weight-conserving
characterizations may hence reflect inherently present
degeneracy, but not spurious degeneracy due to loss of
information.
Figures 5g and 6g show average distances between
degenerate high-modularity partitions of
the same
network. In general, distances between partitions of
empirical networks were much smaller than distances
between partitions of corresponding null models. Despite
this, distances between partitions of empirical networks
remained substantial. For example, Figure 7a shows
topologies of four representative high- degenerate
partitions. These partitions all have very similar but
differ in their organization, as reflected graphically and
quantified with inter-partition distances. Figure 7b shows
the distance matrix of all discovered high- degenerate
partitions of all empirical networks. Clusters on the
diagonal represent distances between partitions of the
same network, while clusters off the diagonal represent
distances between partitions of different networks.
Between-network partition distances were higher than
within-network partition distances. Movie S1
loops
through all discovered high- degenerate partitions in
9
Figure 7b.
Figure 8 shows averages of all degenerate partitions of
individual networks, and hence
the within-module
connection likelihoods in these networks. Degenerate
partitions revealed a substantial module overlap in many
networks. This overlap implies that certain regions or
connections are not clearly associated with single modules.
Figure 9a shows the mean within-module connection
likelihood matrix averaged over all matrices in Figure 8
and illustrates that many within-module connections were
not consistently present between networks. Figure 9b
shows the topology of connections that were present
inside modules
in more
than of
cases.
Figure 5. Properties of (from left to right) high- , , and partitions averaged over all degenerate partitions of all 18 networks: (a) number of
modules, (b) size of modules (total number of within-module connections) as a proportion of network size, (c) number of positive and negative within -
module weights, as a proportion of total within-module weights, (d) geometric mean of balanced and unbalanced within-module triangle weights, (e)
non-rescaled contribution of positive and negative weights, (f) number of degenerate partitions, (g) distance between degenerate partitions of the same
network. Black lines represent corresponding values in the null models. Error bars represent the standard error of the mean f rom networks.
10
Figure 6. Properties of high- partitions computed on binary networks with (from left to right) , , and of preserved
connections. Panel descriptions are the same as in Figure 5.
four bilaterally symmetric
form
These connections
modules (Table 1): 1) a large frontotemporoparietal
module which includes primary somatosensory, motor and
auditory areas; 2) a default-network module which
includes parts of the prefrontal cortex, cingulate cortex
and the inferior parietal lobule; 3) a temporolimbic
module which includes visual association areas, amygdala
and hippocampus; 4) a predominantly occipital module
which includes the primary visual area. The discovered
modules broadly agree with recent similar reports (Fair et
al., 2009; He et al., 2009; Meunier et al., 2009) and our
estimate of the default network agrees with convergent
evidence for the composition of this network from
multiple functional MRI approaches (Buckner et al., 2008).
Our estimates of module composition are conservative as
we only consider modules with highly stable connections.
Consequently, we did not associate regions ( of all
examined regions) with specific modules.
11
Properties of regional centrality
We finally examined the correlation between regional
centrality measures within networks. As above, we
considered measures that use positive or negative weights
alone, measures that treat positive and negative weights
symmetrically ( , ) and our proposed
measures that treat positive and negative weights
asymmetrically ( , ). Figure 10a shows the correlation
between the strength and diversity measures within
individual partitions for these four cases, averaged over all
degenerate partitions. Diversity measures were computed
on their respective partitions (e.g. was computed on
high- partitions, while was computed on high-
partitions), but the choice of partition types did not
qualitative change our results. Correlations between
strength and diversity reflect the consistency of two
complementary measures of regional importance and are
clearly highest for the pair of measures. Figure 10b-
d shows scatter plots of regional strength and diversity,
with data pooled from all 18 networks. Regions with
simultaneously high and were predominantly
heteromodal, limbic and paralimbic (i.e. transmodal) in
origin, and included the insula, the superior temporal
cortex, the orbitofrontal cortex, the amygdala, the anterior
cingulate cortex and the temporal pole.
Discussion
We defined measures of modularity, high-modularity
degeneracy and centrality in complex functional brain
networks, and we described a null model against which
these measures may be assessed. We applied our measures
to an ensemble of resting-state functional MRI networks
and demonstrated degeneracy of high-modularity
partitions
two
correlations between
strong
and
complementary measures of centrality.
Figure 7. Exploration of high- degenerate partitions. (a) Illustration of four degenerate partitions from the NIMH network. For each partition, labels
specify the value of , and the distance to the left-most partition. (b) Distances between all discovered degenerate partitions of all networks.
12
Figure 8. Within-module connection likelihood matrices, computed by averaging degenerate partitions within each ne twork.
Our measures characterize fully connected, positively
and negatively weighted functional networks. In contrast,
most measures in current use characterize sparse and
binary representations of functional networks. Sparse
representations are typically constructed by defining
arbitrary weight thresholds, require the exploration of
many thresholds, and are consequently associated with
multiple statistical comparison problems. Furthermore,
thresholds are sometimes chosen not to preserve strong
connections and remove weak connections, but to achieve
levels of sparseness at which between-group differences
are pronounced. In this study, we showed that partitions
computed on increasingly sparse representations became
increasingly less optimal. Our proposed measures may
obviate the need for these arbitrary analyses and open the
way
towards more
sound and
reliable network
characterizations.
incorporate negative weights but
Our measures
recognize the fundamentally different role of positive and
negative weights in network organization. The nature of
negative correlations
in resting-state functional MRI
remains controversial (Murphy et al., 2009; Fox et al.,
2009)
although
recent
studies
unambiguously
demonstrate the neurophysiological origin of strong
negative correlations (e.g. Chang and Glover, 2009). We
note that our measures primarily depend on the relative
difference between weight magnitudes and secondarily on
the sign of the weights. For instance, when we linearly
mapped the weight range to the range , such
that all negative correlations were transformed into weak
positive correlations, we found that properties of the
resulting high-modularity partitions remained broadly
similar (result not shown).
To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to report
degeneracy of high-modularity partitions in functional
brain networks. Analytical evidence for the presence of
this degeneracy in real-world networks (Good et al., 2010)
strongly suggests that degeneracy is a true feature of
functional brain networks and not an artifact of noisy
measurements or
imprecise node definition. Current
characterizations of the modularity in functional networks
typically focus on only one high-modularity partition or
report highly reproducible partitions (Joyce et al., 2010).
13
Figure 9. (a) Averaged within-module connection likelihood matrices from Figure 8. (b) Binary representation of the matrix in (a), showing connections
with greater than within-module likelihood. Table 1 lists regions in the four large connected components of this matrix.
TABLE 1: Consistent modules in 18 examined networks .
Region
Left
Right
Module 1
Precentral Gyrus
Supplementary Motor Cortex
Postcentral Gyrus
Supramarginal Gyrus, anterior
Superior Temporal Gyrus, anterior
Superior Temporal Gyrus, posterior
Heschl’s Gyri
Planum Polare
Planum Temporale
Insular Cortex
Central Opercular Cortex
Parietal Opercular Cortex
Module 2
Frontal Pole
Superior Frontal Gyrus
Middle Frontal Gyrus
Inferior Frontal Gyrus, pars triangularis
Paracingulate Gyrus
Caudate
Angular Gyrus
Module 3
Temporal Pole
Temporal Fusiform Cortex, anterior
Temporal Fusiform Cortex, posterior
Middle Temporal Gyrus, anterior
Inferior Temporal Gyrus, anterior
Amygdala
Hippocampus
Parahippocampal Gyrus, anterior
Parahippocampal Gyrus, posterior
Module 4
Lingual Gyrus
Cuneal Cortex
Lateral Occipital Cortex, inferior
Supracalcarine Cortex
Intracalcarine Cortex
Temporal Occipital Fusiform Cortex
Occipital Fusiform Gyrus
Occipital Pole
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Modules were bound by within-module connections present in more than of examined partitions (see Figure 9).
14
Figure 10. (a) Correlation between (from left to right) and , and , and , and , averaged over all discovered
degenerate partitions. Error bars represent the standard error of the mean from networks. (b)-(d) Scatter plots of strength and diversity values,
pooled from all networks (the and plot is not shown).
We argue that such characterizations are incomplete for
two reasons. Firstly, a single observed modularity
partition is unlikely to represent a true global optimum
because modularity maximization
algorithms
are
approximate and because observed partitions are subject
to recording and preprocessing distortions. Secondly and
more importantly, degenerate partitions have the potential
to collectively capture dynamic regional interactions that
cannot be possibly detected with single parti tions. These
interactions may
include context-dependent regional
activation in distinct functional systems or switching
between distinct systems in the resting state (e.g. Bressler
and McIntosh, 2007). Our consideration of degenerate
partitions led us to consider the likelihood with which
connections bind nodes into coherent modules. This view
is related to notions of cluster stability (Bellec et al., 2010),
connection-based modules (Ahn et al., 2010) and
overlapping modules (Palla et al., 2005).
We purposefully restricted network characterization to
measures with simple neurobiological interpretations. It is
important to emphasize that connections
in cross-
correlation-based functional networks do not occupy
physical space and typically represent the dynamic
outcome of numerous direct and
indirect network
interactions (Koch et al., 2002; Honey et al., 2009). Several
popular measures of network topology are difficult to
interpret in these networks. For instance, measures of
wiring cost are difficult to interpret because sparse
anatomical topologies can generate highly coherent and
“costly”
functional patterns (Vicente et al., 2008).
Measures based on paths, such as characteristic path
length and small-worldness, are also difficult to interpret
because functional networks are fully connected and
statistical relationships between all pairs of regions are
already directly expressed by connection weights between
these regions. Short characteristic path lengths may reflect
a large number of inter-modular connections, but not
necessarily correspond to high functional integration, as is
often suggested. Such ambiguities underscore
the
desirability of combining functional connectivity with an
underlying structural connectivity model (Sporns et al.,
2005) and are likely to become more apparent with
further characterization of increasingly highly-resolved
and fully-connected functional networks. We hope that our
proposed approach will enable more meaningful
characterizations of functional networks across conditions
or subjects and will stimulate further discussion on the use
and interpretation of functional brain network measures.
Acknowledgments
We are very grateful to Mike Milham and Xi-Nian Zuo for
making the resting-state functional connectivity datasets
used in this study freely available, and to Ben Good for
providing detailed feedback on an earlier version of the
manuscript. We thank Dani Bassett, Jonathan Power and
James Roberts for stimulating discussions. The study was
funded
in part by the Human Connectome Project
(1U54MH091657-01) from the 16 NIH Institutes and
Centers that support the NIH Blueprint for Neuroscience
Research. MR and OS were supported by the JS McDonnell
Foundation. MR was supported by the CSIRO ICT centre.
References
Achard, S., Salvador, R., Whitcher, B., Suckling, J., Bullmore, E., 2006. A
resilient, low-frequency, small-world human brain functional network
with highly connected association cortical hubs. J Neurosci 26, 63-72.
Ahn, Y.Y., Bagrow, J.P., Lehmann, S., 2010. Link communities reveal
multiscale complexity in networks. Nature 466, 761-764.
Bellec, P., Rosa-Neto, P., Lyttelton, O.C., Benali, H., Evans, A.C., 2010. Multi -
level bootstrap analysis of stable clusters in resting-state fmri.
NeuroImage 51, 1126-1139.
Biswal, B.B., Mennes, M., Zuo, X.N., Gohel, S., Kelly, C., Smith, S.M.,
Beckmann, C.F., Adelstein,
J.S., Buckner, R.L., Colcombe, S.,
Dogonowski, A.M., Ernst, M., Fair, D., Hampson, M., Hoptman, M.J.,
Hyde, J.S., Kiviniemi, V.J., Kotter, R., Li, S.J., Lin, C.P., Lowe, M.J., Mackay,
C., Madden, D.J., Madsen, K.H., Margulies, D.S., Mayberg, H.S., McMahon,
K., Monk, C.S., Mostofsky, S.H., Nagel, B.J., Pekar, J.J., Peltier, S.J.,
Petersen, S.E., Riedl, V., Rombouts, S.A., Rypma, B., Schlaggar, B.L.,
Schmidt, S., Seidler, R.D., Siegle, G.J., Sorg, C., Teng, G.J., Veijola, J.,
Villringer, A., Walter, M., Wang, L., Weng, X.C., Whitfield-Gabrieli, S.,
Williamson, P., Windischberger, C., Zang, Y.F., Zhang, H.Y., Caste llanos,
F.X., Milham, M.P., 2010. Toward discovery science of human brain
function. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 107, 4734-4739.
Blondel, V., Guillaume, J.-L., Lambiotte, R., Lefebvre, E., 2008. Fast
15
unfolding of communities in large networks. J Stat Mech 2008, P10008.
Bressler, S.L., McIntosh, A.R., 2007. The role of neural context in large -
scale neurocognitive network operations. In: Jirsa, V.K., McIntosh, A.R.
(Eds.), Handbook of brain connectivity. Springer, New York, pp. 403 -
419.
Buckner, R.L., Andrews-Hanna, J.R., Schacter, D.L., 2008. The brain's
default network. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1124, 1-
38.
Buckner, R.L., Sepulcre, J., Talukdar, T., Krienen, F.M., Liu, H., Hedden, T.,
Andrews-Hanna, J.R., Sperling, R.A., Johnson, K.A., 2009. Cortical hubs
revealed by intrinsic functional connectivity: Mapping, assessment of
stability, and relation to alzheimer's disease. J Neurosci 29, 1860-1873.
Bullmore, E., Sporns, O., 2009. Complex brain networks: Graph theoretical
analysis of structural and functional systems. Nat Rev Neurosci 10,
186-198.
Chang, C., Glover, G.H., 2009. Effects of model-based physiological noise
correction on default mode network anti -correlations and
correlations. NeuroImage 47, 1448-1459.
Duggal, G., Navlakha, S., Girvan, M., Kingsford, C., 2010. Uncovering many
views of biological networks using ensembles of near-optimal
partitions. MultiClust: 1st International Workshop on Discovering,
Summarizing and Using Multiple Clusterings at KDD.
Fair, D.A., Cohen, A.L., Power, J.D., Dosenbach, N.U.F., Church, J.A., Miezin,
F.M., Schlaggar, B.L., Petersen, S.E., 2009. Functional brain networks
develop from a "Local to distributed" Organization. PLoS Comput Biol
5, e1000381.
Fortunato, S., 2010. Community detection in graphs. Phys Rep 486, 75-
174.
Fox, M.D., Raichle, M.E., 2007. Spontaneous fluctuations in brain activity
observed with functional magnetic resonance imaging. Nat Rev
Neurosci 8, 700-711.
Fox, M.D., Zhang, D., Snyder, A.Z., Raichle, M.E., 2009. The global signal
and observed anticorrelated resting state brain networks.
J
Neurophysiol 101, 3270-3283.
Girvan, M., Newman, M.E., 2002. Community structure in social and
biological networks. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 99, 7821-7826.
Gomez, S., Jensen, P., Arenas, A., 2009. Analysis o f community structure in
networks of correlated data. Phys Rev E 80, 016114.
Good, B.H., de Montjoye, Y.A., Clauset, A., 2010. Performance of
modularity maximization in practical contexts. Phys Rev E 81, 046106.
Guimera, R., Amaral, L.A., 2005. Cartography of complex networks:
Modules and universal roles. J Stat Mech 2005.
He, Y., Wang, J., Wang, L., Chen, Z.J., Yan, C., Yang, H., Tang, H., Zhu, C.,
Gong, Q., Zang, Y., Evans, A.C., 2009. Uncovering intrinsic modular
organization of spontaneous brain activity in humans. PLoS ONE 4,
e5226.
Honey, C.J., Sporns, O., Cammoun, L., Gigandet, X., Thiran, J.P., Meuli, R.,
Hagmann, P., 2009. Predicting human resting-state
functional
connectivity from structural connectivity. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 106,
2035-2040.
Joyce, K.E., Laurienti, P.J., Burdette, J.H., Hayasaka, S., 2010. A new
measure of centrality for brain networks. PLoS ONE 5, e12200.
Kaplan, T.D., Forrest, S., 2008. Title: A dual assortative measure of
community structure. arxiv [physics data-an], 0801.3290v1.
Karrer, B., Levina, E., Newman, M.E.J., 2008. Robustness of community
structure in networks. Physical Review E 77, 046119.
Kernighan, B.W., Lin, S., 1970. An efficient heuristic procedure for
partitioning graphs. Bell Syst Tech J 49, 291-307.
Keylock, C.J., 2005. Simpson diversity and the Shannon–Wiener index as
special cases of a generalized entropy. Oikos 109, 203-207.
Koch, M.A., Norris, D.G., Hund-Georgiadis, M., 2002. An investigation of
functional and anatomical connectivity using magnetic resonance
imaging. NeuroImage 16, 241-250.
Lynall, M.E., Bassett, D.S., Kerwin, R., McKenna, P.J., Kitzbichler, M., Muller,
U., Bullmore, E., 2010. Functional connectivity and brain networks in
schizophrenia. J Neurosci 30, 9477-9487.
Makris, N., Meyer, J.W., Bates, J.F., Yeterian, E.H., Kennedy, D.N., Caviness,
V.S., 1999. Mri-based topographic parcellation of human cerebral
white matter and nuclei ii. Rationale and applications with systematics
of cerebral connectivity. NeuroImage 9, 18-45.
Meila, M., 2007. Comparing clusterings---an information based distance. J
Multivar Anal 98, 873-895.
Meunier, D., Lambiotte, R., Bullmore, E.T., 2010. Modular and
hierarchically modular organization of brain networks. Frontiers in
Neuroscience 1, 5.
Meunier, D., Lambiotte, R., Fornito, A., Ersche, K.D., Bullmore, E.T., 2009.
Hierarchical modularity in human brain functional networks. Front
Neuroinformatics 3, 37.
Murphy, K., Birn, R.M., Handwerker, D.A., Jones, T.B., Bandettini, P.A.,
2009. The impact of global signal regress ion on resting state
correlations: Are anti-correlated networks introduced? NeuroImage
44, 893-905.
Newman, M.E., 2004. Fast algorithm for detecting community structure in
networks. Phys Rev E 69, 066133.
Newman, M.E., 2006. Finding community structure in networks using the
eigenvectors of matrices. Phys Rev E 74, 036104.
Onnela, J.P., Saramaki, J., Kertesz, J., Kaski, K., 2005. Intensity and
coherence of motifs in weighted complex networks. Phys Rev E 71,
065103.
Palla, G., Derenyi, I., Farkas, I., Vicsek, T., 2005. Uncovering the
overlapping community structure of complex networks in nature and
society. Nature 435, 814-818.
Rubinov, M., Sporns, O., 2010. Complex network measures of brain
connectivity: Uses and interpretations. NeuroImage 52, 1059-1069.
Shannon, C.E., 1948. A mathematical theory of communication. Bell Syst
Tech J 27, 379–423.
Simpson, E.H., 1949. Measurement of diversity. Nature 163, 688.
Sporns, O., Tononi, G., Kötter, R., 2005. The human connectome: A
structural description of the human brain. PLoS Comput Biol 1, e42.
Stam, C.J., Reijneveld, J.C., 2007. Graph theoretical analysis of complex
networks in the brain. Nonlinear Biomed Phys 1, 3.
Sun, Y., Danila, ., Josić, K., assler, K.E., 2009. Improved community
structure detection using a modified fine-tuning strategy. Europhysics
Lett 86, 28004.
Supekar, K., Menon, V., Rubin, D., Musen, M., Greicius, M.D., 2008. Network
analysis of intrinsic functional brain connectivity in alzheimer's
disease. PLoS Comput Biol 4, e1000100.
Traag, V.A., Bruggeman, J., 2009. Community detection in networks with
positive and negative links. Phys Rev E 80, 036115.
Vicente, R., Gollo, L.L., Mirasso, C.R., Fischer, I., Pipa, G., 2008. Dynamical
relaying can yield zero time lag neuronal synchrony despite long
conduction delays. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 105, 17157-17162.
Wormald, N.C., 1999. Models of random regular graphs. In: Lamb, J.D.,
Preece, D.A. (Eds.), Surveys in combinatorics. Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, pp. 239-298.
|
1512.03785 | 1 | 1512 | 2015-12-10T18:49:36 | Noisy threshold in neuronal models: connections with the noisy leaky integrate-and-fire model | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Providing an analytical treatment to the stochastic feature of neurons' dynamics is one of the current biggest challenges in mathematical biology. The noisy leaky integrate-and-fire model and its associated Fokker-Planck equation are probably the most popular way to deal with neural variability. Another well-known formalism is the escape-rate model: a model giving the probability that a neuron fires at a certain time knowing the time elapsed since its last action potential. This model leads to a so-called age-structured system, a partial differential equation with non-local boundary condition famous in the field of population dynamics, where the {\it age} of a neuron is the amount of time passed by since its previous spike. In this theoretical paper, we investigate the mathematical connection between the two formalisms. We shall derive an integral transform of the solution to the age-structured model into the solution of the Fokker-Planck equation. This integral transform highlights the link between the two stochastic processes. As far as we know, an explicit mathematical correspondence between the two solutions has not been introduced until now. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Noname manuscript No.
(will be inserted by the editor)
Noisy threshold in neuronal models: connections with
the noisy leaky integrate-and-fire model.
G. Dumont · J. Henry · C.O. Tarniceriu
5
1
0
2
c
e
D
0
1
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
5
8
7
3
0
.
2
1
5
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
Abstract Providing an analytical treatment to the stochastic feature of neu-
rons' dynamics is one of the current biggest challenges in mathematical biol-
ogy. The noisy leaky integrate-and-fire model and its associated Fokker-Planck
equation are probably the most popular way to deal with neural variability.
Another well-known formalism is the escape-rate model: a model giving the
probability that a neuron fires at a certain time knowing the time elapsed
since its last action potential. This model leads to a so-called age-structured
system, a partial differential equation with non-local boundary condition fa-
mous in the field of population dynamics, where the age of a neuron is the
amount of time passed by since its previous spike. In this theoretical paper,
we investigate the mathematical connection between the two formalisms. We
shall derive an integral transform of the solution to the age-structured model
into the solution of the Fokker-Planck equation. This integral transform high-
lights the link between the two stochastic processes. As far as we know, an
explicit mathematical correspondence between the two solutions has not been
introduced until now.
1 Introduction
Neurons are strongly noisy. They never respond in the same way under re-
peated exposure to identical stimuli and it is difficult for theoreticians to ap-
ply the correct analytical treatment in order to express this variability. Two
G. Dumont
Physics Department, 150 Louis Pasteur Ottawa, Ontario, Canada K1N 6N5
E-mail: [email protected]
J. Henry
INRIA Bordeaux Sud Ouest, 200 avenue de la vieille tour, 33405 Talence Cedex, France
E-mail: [email protected]
C.O. Tarniceriu
Department of Sciences of "Al. I. Cuza" University, Lascar Catargi 54, 700107 Ia¸si, Romania
E-mail: [email protected]
2
G. Dumont et al.
distinct sources of noise are usually mentioned: external and internal [15].
While the external source of noise usually refers to the random fluctuations
attributed to the environment of the neurons, the internal source is mainly
imputed to the probabilistic nature of the chemical reactions governing the
firing process of neurons. More precisely, noise is present because a neuron is
bombarded by thousands of synaptic inputs, and also due to the randomness
in the openings and closings of the ion channels underlying action potentials
[28].
The noisy leaky integrate-and-fire (NLIF) model is a mathematical model
that takes into account the stochastic features of neurons [7]. The model is
preferred by theoreticians since it can be seen as a simplification of the bio-
physiological Hodgkin-Huxley model [22], which is sufficiently detailed to allow
a qualitative comparison with physical data obtained via intracranial recording
[24] (see also [20] for a recent discussion about the quality of the neural mod-
eling). Nonetheless, despite its apparent simplicity, many questions regarding
its dynamics remain open.
By definition, the NLIF model describes a stochastic process, which is given
by a Langevin equation plus a discontinuous reset mechanism to mimic the
onset of the action potential (see [7] and [24]). Starting with the Langevin
equation, one can write the well-known associated Fokker-Planck (FP) equa-
tion [16], that gives the evolution in time of the density probability to find a
neuron's membrane potential in a certain voltage value [27].
Let us remind that, in mathematical neuroscience, the concept of proba-
bility density function has already a long history, as it can be seen in [40], [2],
and it is used in a variety of contexts. Indeed, assuming the number of neu-
rons to be infinitely large, one can write the so-called thermodynamics' mean
field equation, where the effect of the whole network on any given neuron is
approximated by a single averaged effect. Under some assumptions and ap-
proximations, the equation takes the form of a nonlinear FP equation. It is in
particular pertinent for the simulation of large sparsely connected populations
of neurons [33], [32], [13]. Furthermore, this density approach has brought an
important added value on the theoretical understanding of synchronization
and brain rhythms. Particularly, this approach has been successfully used to
understand synchronization caused by recurrent excitation [11], [12], [8], by
delayed inhibition feedback [5], by both recurrent excitation and inhibition [4]
and by gap junction [35]. On a similar trend, it has been used to study the
occurrence of the neural cascade [30], [31] and the emergence of self criticality
[29] with synaptic adaptation.
In this paper, we do not investigate the effect of interactions among neu-
rons, but focus on the analytical treatment of neural noise. NLIF model is a
popular way to deal with the stochastic aspect of neurons, another way is the
escape-rate model [38], [19]. The main difference between the two approaches
consists in the treatment of noise; while in the NLIF model the noise acts
on the trajectories, the escape rate model considers deterministic trajectories
and the noise is present in expressing the variability of firings that is modeled
in the form of a hazard function. Therefore, the noisy trajectories with fixed
Age-structure in neuronal populations
3
threshold are replaced by deterministic trajectories with noisy thresholds. In
the equivalent description of the NLIF model as a FP equation with absorb-
ing boundary condition at the firing threshold, the noise is expressed by the
diffusion term of the FP equation; it has been shown in [38] that, in the sub-
threshold regime, the integrate and fire model with stochastic input (diffusive
noise) can be mapped onto an escape rate model with a certain escape rate.
Starting from this, the equivalence of the FP equation with escape noise and
a partial differential equation that describes the evolutions of refractory den-
sities has been shown [19]; the last equation is strikingly similar to those of
the well-known age-structured (AS) models and it gives the evolution in time
of the refractory densities with respect to their refractory state, which is in
fact the time elapsed since the last firing. To underline the above mentioned
similarity, we will refer to this variable in this paper as age. Age structure in
a neural context has been also discussed in [36].
In our paper, we shall prove that the solution to the AS system can be
transformed via an integral transform into the solution to the FP equation as-
sociated to the NLIF model. The kernel of the integral transform will involve
in particular the notion of survivor function [18], [19]. In renewal theory, the
hazard is known also as the age dependent death rate and expresses the rate
of decay of the survivor function [10]. The concept of time dependent inter-
spike interval (ISI) distribution and corresponding survivor function has been
considered later [17].
In the neuroscience context, the survivor function, which was introduced
initially to describe the probability of a particle to reach a given target, will
give the probability for a neuron to "survive" without firing. We refer again for
more about these considerations to [19], and further analysis on these functions
and the related first passage time problem in the neural context can be found
in the review [3]. First passage time problem in cellular domains has been
investigated in [39] and [23].
There is a strong advantage in using an AS formalism: the AS systems have
been thoroughly investigated in the last decades, and many qualitative results
of the various forms of AS population models have been obtained. By proving
an equivalence between a membrane potential density model and an AS model,
we will be in position to obtain insights of the qualitative behavior of the
population density function such as long time behavior, stability, bifurcation
points, and so on.
The paper is structured as follows: we remind in the first two sections the
NLIF model and its associated FP equation, and we present some simula-
tions of the models. Next, some considerations about the survivor function,
the interspike interval distribution and the first passage time problem are pre-
sented. We introduce in the following the stochastic threshold model and the
corresponding AS system. We prove our main theoretical results in the last two
sections: first we establish in Proposition 1 an integral correspondence between
its solution and the solution to FP equation. We also consider the stationary
case, and show that, by our integral transform, we obtain an expression of the
corresponding stationary solution which verifies the stationary FP equation.
4
G. Dumont et al.
Last, we show the asymptotic convergence of the solution to FP system to the
solution of the stationary system defined through our transform. The existence
of an inverse transform to the one introduced here as well as extensions of the
problem to the case of time-dependent parameters of the systems are subject
to our further investigations .
Before getting started, let us summarize in Table 1 the main mathematical
notations and their associated biophysiological meaning used throughout this
document.
Notation
v(t)
vr
µ
σ
p(t, v)
r(t)
a(t)
q(a, v)
ISI(a)
S(a)
n(t, a)
Biophysiological interpretation
Neuron's membrane potential
Reset potential
Bias current
Noise intensity
Population density with respect to potential
Neuron's firing rate
Neuron's age, i.e. time elapsed since the last spike
Joint probability density of the membrane's potential and neuron's age
First passage time
Age dependent death rate
Population density for the age-structured model
Table 1 Main notations used throughout this paper and their biophysiological interpreta-
tions
2 The noisy leaky integrate and fire model
The NLIF model is a well known model in the field of computational neuro-
science [24]. The model consists in an ordinary differential equation describing
the subthreshold dynamics of a single neuron membrane's potential and the
onset of an action potential described by a reset mechanism: a spike occurs
whenever a given threshold VT is reached by the membrane potential variable
V . Whenever the firing threshold is reached, it is considered that a spike has
been fired and the membrane potential is instantaneously reset to a given value
VR. The dynamics of the subthreshold potentials are given by
V (t) = −g(V (t) − VL) + η(t),
τ
d
dt
where V (t) is the membrane potential at time t, τ is the membrane capaci-
tance, g - the leak conductance, VL - the reversal potential and η(t) - a gaussian
white noise, see [6] and [1] for the history of the model, [7] for a recent review
and see [24] for other spiking models. In what follows, we will use a normalized
version of the above equation, i.e. we define µ as the bias current and v the
membrane's potential which will be given by
Age-structure in neuronal populations
5
Fig. 1 Simulation of the neuron model (1) for different values of the noise coefficient. The
parameters of the simulation are: vr = 0.3, µ = 20, and σ = 0.1 for the first simulation,
σ = 0.4 for the second simulation, σ = 0.6 for the third simulation.
µ =
VL
VT
,
v =
V
VT
,
vr =
VR
VT
.
After rescaling the time in units of the membrane constant g/τ , the normalized
model reads
(cid:26) d
dt v(t) = µ − v(t) + ξ(t)
then v = vr.
v > 1
If
(1)
Again, ξ(t) is a Gaussian white noise stochastic process with intensity σ:
(cid:104)ξ(t)(cid:105) = 0,
(cid:104)ξ(t)ξ(t(cid:48))(cid:105) = σδ(t − t(cid:48)).
In Fig. 1, a simulation of the neuron model (1) is presented. The three pan-
els correspond to the same simulation with different level of noise. As expected,
when the stochastic coefficient is increased, the corresponding dynamics be-
come much more irregular. Note that for µ small enough, the equilibrium of
the membrane potential will be located under the threshold. In this situation,
the neuron will fire only due to the stochastic Brownian motion. We refer to
this situation as to a subthreshold regime. In a real-world setting, such situ-
ation appears in a balanced neural network for instance, when the excitatory
and inhibitory pre-synaptic inputs cancel out.
3 The population density function (Fokker-Planck formalism)
Considering a population of neurons that are individually described by the
stochastic equation (1), the evolution of the population density function has
been proven to satisfy the FP equation. We remind that the FP equation has
been used in two different contexts in mathematical neuroscience: to model the
evolution of both probability density function and population density function.
For more considerations about the link between the two approaches we refer
to [32], [26], [25], [5].
In this paper we shall use both formalisms: we shall consider a density
of neurons characterized by a population density function, denoted here by
p(t, v), which satisfies the FP equation, and each neuron of the given popu-
lation has the evolution of the potential of the membrane given by the NLIF
00.200.51TimePotential00.200.51TimePotential00.200.51TimePotential00.500.20.4AgeDensity00.500.20.4AgeDensity00.500.20.4AgeDensity 6
G. Dumont et al.
Fig. 2 Schematic representation of the state space for the FP equation (2).
model. Then, the probability density function of each neuron to be at a cer-
tain voltage at a given time will be described by the same FP equation [16],
this time considered only in an inter-spike interval, as we shall see in the next
section.
This equation is a conservation law taking into account three phenomena
modeled by: a drift term due to the continuous evolution in the NLIF model,
a diffusion term due to the noise and a term due to the reset to vr right after
the firing process. Let r(t) be the firing rate of the population, i.e. the flux
through the threshold. Then, the dynamics of the population density p(t, v)
is:
(cid:122)
∂
∂v
∂
∂t
p(t, v) +
(cid:125)(cid:124)
Drift
(cid:125)(cid:124)
Diffusion
(cid:123)
(cid:123)
(cid:122)
σ2
2
[(µ − v)p(t, v)]−
∂2
∂v2 p(t, v) =
δ(v − vr)r(t) .
(2)
(cid:122)
(cid:125)(cid:124)
Reset
(cid:123)
We show in Fig. 2 a schematic representation of the state space for the FP
equation (2). Because a neuron reaching the threshold fires an action potential
and is instantaneously reset to vr, we impose an absorbing condition at the
threshold ([21]), namely
(3)
Usually, a reflecting boundary is imposed at v = −∞ in order to assure the
conservation property
p(t, 1) = 0,∀t ≥ 0.
v→−∞(−µ + v)p(t, v) +
lim
σ2
2
∂
∂v
p(t, v) = 0,∀t ≥ 0.
(4)
Of course, an initial distribution of the membrane potential is taken as a given
function:
p(0, v) = p0(v),
v ∈ (−∞, 1].
(5)
As previously said, the firing rate r(t) is defined as the flux at the threshold
and, due to the boundary condition for the population density function in this
value, is given by
r(t) = − σ2
2
∂
∂v
p(t, 1).
(6)
Age0Reset After SpikePotential1Reset After SpikeThresholdDriftDrift + Diffusion Age-structure in neuronal populations
7
Fig. 3 Simulations of the FP equation (2)-(6) and of the stochastic process (1): black curve
for the FP equation, blue curve for the stochastic process. A gaussian was taken as initial
condition; the parameters of the simulation are: vr = 0.3, µ = 20, σ = 0.4. The plots show
the evolution in time of the solution at t = 0, t = 0.1, t = 0.3, t = 0.5, t = 0.7, t = 7.
Using the boundary condition and the expression of r(t) given by (6), one
can easily check the conservation property of the equation (2) by directly
integrating it on the interval (−∞, 1), so that, if the initial condition satisfies
p0(v) dv = 1,
(7)
(cid:90) 1
−∞
(cid:90) 1
−∞
then the solution to (2)-(6) necessarily satisfies the normalization condition
p(t, w) dw = 1.
(8)
Despite its "weird" singular source term, the existence of a solution to the
above model has been proved in [9]. The FP equation can be written as a
Stephan problem and an implicit solution can be given in the form of an
integral equation. Note that in the literature, the equation (2) is often exposed
in terms of a conservation law. In this setting, the flux that we denote J(t, v)
is defined as
−J(t, v) = (−µ + v)p(t, v) +
σ2
2
∂
∂v
p(t, v).
Therefore, the evolution in time of the density function p is given by
∂
∂t
p(t, v) = − ∂
∂v
J(t, v).
In this formulation, the singular source term that appears in (2) can be seen
as a flux discontinuity, see [4] for instance,
lim
v→v+
r
J(t, v) − lim
v→v
−
r
J(t, v) = J(t, 1).
00.5105PotentialDensity00.5105PotentialDensity00.5105PotentialDensity00.5105PotentialDensity00.5105PotentialDensity00.5105PotentialDensity 8
G. Dumont et al.
Fig. 4 Simulation of the firing rate of the neuron (6) via the FP formalism (2)-(6), black
curve, and the stochastic process (1), blue curve. The parameters of the simulation are:
vr = 0.3, µ = 15 and σ = 0.4 for the first simulation, µ = 20 and σ = 0.4 for the second
simulation and µ = 30 and σ = 0.4 for the third simulation. We also show the raster plot
depicting the spike timing of 200 neurons.
We present in Fig 3 a simulation of the FP model (2)-(6). The numerical
results are compared with Monte Carlo simulations for the stochastic NLIF
model (1). In Fig 3, the black curve corresponds to the FP equation (2)-(6) and
the blue curve to the stochastic process (1). A Gaussian was taken as initial
condition (see the first panel of Fig. 3). Under the drift and the diffusion
effects, the density function gives a non zero flux at the threshold. This flux is
reset to vr according to the reset process. This effect can be seen clearly in the
third panel of the simulation presented in Fig. 3. Asymptotically the solution
reaches a stationary density. The steady state is shown in the last panel of
Fig. 3. Note that the stationary state can be easily computed (we remind its
expression later in the text). One can show the convergence of the solution
towards the stationary density using the general relative entropy principle.
In Fig. 4 a comparison of the firing rate (6) computed via the FP formalism
(2) and via the stochastic model (1) is represented. Again the blue curve is
obtained by direct simulations of the stochastic process (1), and the black
curve corresponds to the simulations of the FP model (2)-(6). To be more
precise, we also show a raster plot depicting the spike timing of the neurons
for each simulation run. In the three different simulations that we present, we
have varied the drift term µ.
The stationary state of the FP equation is known from decades. A straight-
forward computation shows that the steady state p∞(v) is given by
(w − µ)2
e
σ2
dw,
(9)
− (v − µ)2
σ2
p∞(v) =
2r∞
σ2 e
(cid:90) 1
max(v,vr)
with r∞ the corresponding stationary firing rate (see Fig 4). The latter is
determined by the normalization condition:
00.20100200TimeNeuron #00.20100200TimeNeuron #00.20100200TimeNeuron #00.200.10.2TimeFiring rate00.200.10.2TimeFiring rate00.200.10.2TimeFiring rate Age-structure in neuronal populations
9
Fig. 5 Simulation of the model (11) - (14), black curve, and the stochastic process (1), blue
curve. A Dirac mass at the reset potential was taken as initial condition. The parameters of
the simulation are vr = 0.3, µ = 20, σ = 0.4. The plots show the evolution in time (age) of
the solution at a = 0, a = 0.1, a = 0.3, a = 0.5, a = 0.7, a = 7.
(cid:90) 1
−∞
r−1∞ =
2
σ2
(cid:90) 1
− (v − µ)2
σ2
e
max(v,vr)
(w − µ)2
e
σ2
dw dv.
(10)
These expressions are well-known and details can be found in [14] for example.
4 The inter-spike interval and the first passage time
In the following we will define the age of a neuron as the time passed since
its last firing. Age is a somehow forced notion in this context, but we have
chosen to use it due to the similarity of the model that we will present in
the next section to those from the AS systems theory. The evolution of a
probability density function for a neuron's membrane potential to be at age a
in the potential value v, q(a, v), is given by a similar FP equation:
(cid:122)
(cid:125)(cid:124)
Drift part
Diffusion
(cid:123)
(cid:122)
(cid:125)(cid:124)
(cid:123)
∂
∂a
q(a, v) +
∂
∂v
[(µ − v)q(a, v)]−
σ2
2
∂2
∂v2 q(a, v) = 0,
(11)
again with an absorbing boundary condition for the threshold value v = 1
q(a, 1) = 0,∀a ≥ 0,
and a reflecting boundary condition at the boundary v = −∞
v→−∞(−µ + v)q(a, v) +
lim
σ2
2
∂
∂v
q(a, v) = 0,∀a ≥ 0.
(12)
(13)
Since a neuron firing an action potential is reset to vr, we consider the initial
density given by
q(0, v) = δ(v − vr),
v ∈ (−∞, 1),
(14)
00.5101020PotentialDensity00.5101020PotentialDensity00.5101020PotentialDensity00.5101020PotentialDensity00.5101020PotentialDensity00.5101020PotentialDensity 10
G. Dumont et al.
Fig. 6 Simulation of the ISI function (15) via the FP formalism (11), black curve, respec-
tively the stochastic process (1), blue curve. The parameters of the simulation are vr = 0.3,
µ = 15 and σ = 0.4 for the first simulation, µ = 20 and σ = 0.4 for the second simulation
and µ = 30, σ = 0.4 for the third simulation. We also show the raster plot depicting the
spike timing of 200 neurons.
where δ is the Dirac distribution. As for the equation (2), the equation (11)
is often represented in terms of an integral equation. In this setting, the flux
that we denote F(a, v) is defined as
−F(a, v) = (−µ + v)q(a, v) +
σ2
2
∂
∂v
q(a, v).
Therefore, the evolution in time of the density function q is given by
∂
∂a
q(a, v) = − ∂
∂v
F(a, v).
Note that, in the case considered here, the re-injection of the (probability)
flux to the reset value (right hand side of equation (2)) is not considered,
therefore the above model represents the evolution of the probability density of
neurons before firing, i.e. in an inter-spike interval. The interpretation is that,
once the neuron fired, it becomes of age zero, and the source term δ(v − vr)
as initial condition can be understood intuitively as that, right after a spike
the membrane potential is vr with probability 1. It should be stressed that
as the bias current µ and the noise intensity σ do not depend on time, the
probability density q does not depend on time but only on age a. The flux at
the threshold value, which is again given only by the diffusive part of the flux,
is a measure of great interest since it gives the ISI distribution (for a neuron
having at age a = 0 the potential vr):
ISI(a) = − σ2
2
∂
∂v
q(a, 1),∀a ≥ 0.
(15)
Until now, no analytical solution of the ISI curve has been found.
We present in Fig. 5 a simulation of the problem (11) -- (14). Again, we
have made a comparison between the stochastic process (blue curve) and the
evolution in time of the density function (black curve). The simulation starts
00.20100200AgeNeuron #00.20100200AgeNeuron #00.20100200AgeNeuron #00.200.10.2AgeISI00.200.10.2AgeISI00.200.10.2AgeISI Age-structure in neuronal populations
11
with a Dirac mass as initial condition (see first panel of Fig. 5). Under the
influence of the drift term and the diffusion process (gaussian white noise),
the density function spreads to the threshold. This is clearly seen in the upper
plot of Fig. 5. At last, as expected, it converges to a zero density (see the
last panel in Fig. 5). In Fig. 6, we make some different simulations of the
ISI curve. As before, the blue curve corresponds to the stochastic process
simulated via a Monte Carlo method, and the black curve - to the deterministic
process (11). We present here three different panels corresponding to three
different simulations where the bias current µ was increased. We also present
a raster plot depicting the spike timing of each neuron simulated via the NLIF
model (see upper panels of Fig 6). It can be clearly seen that, increasing the
intensity current leads to a more concentrated ISI density. The ISI curve starts
at zero, which means that right after spiking the neuron needs some time before
spiking again. Then, the ISI curve increases and, after reaching a maximum,
it decreases rapidly. This is depicted by the raster plot presented in Fig 6.
The first passage time problem is intimately related to the FP equation.
Starting from the Chapman-Kolmogorov equation, it has been shown that the
probability to find the state (potential) of a neuron at time t in a certain
value v, is the solution to the FP or Kolmogorov's forward equation. From
it, one can derive the equation that describes the evolution in time of the
probability for a neuron that started at time 0 from a potential value v to
not have reached yet the value threshold, named survival probability density.
This equation is known as Kolmogorov's backward equation, and the choice
of boundary conditions has been discussed in [16].
5 Noisy threshold model
In what follows, we shall use the concept of survival probability or survivor
function as in [19]. In our case, this function will be only age-dependent since
we shall consider it for the case of a neuron that starts at age zero from the
reset potential vr.
Namely, if q(a, v) is the solution to (11)-(14), then the following quantity
(cid:90) 1
−∞
q(a, v) dv
stands for the probability of survival at age a of a neuron that started at age
0 from the position vr. Again, "survival" at age a means that up to that time,
the potential of the neuron's membrane has not reached yet the threshold
value. Then, the rate of decay of the survivor function
(cid:82) 1
(cid:82) 1
S(a) = − d
da
−∞ q(a, w) dw
−∞ q(a, w) dw
(16)
represents the rate at which the threshold is reached and it has been called
age-dependent death rate or hazard. S(a) has the interpretation that, in order
12
G. Dumont et al.
Fig. 7 Simulation of the function S(a) given by (16) in the lower panels and its correspond-
ing ISI given by (15) in the upper panels. The parameters of the simulation are vr = 0.7,
µ = 5, σ = 0.1, σ = 0.2, σ = 0.3.
to emit a spike, the neuron has to "survive" without firing in the interval (0, a)
and then fire at age a.
In Fig. 7, numerical simulations of the age-dependent death rate for dif-
ferent parameters is presented. Let us notice that S defines clearly a positive
function that converges toward a constant. Indeed, q(a, v) has the same asymp-
totic behavior as
e−λaq(v),
which implies that
a→+∞ S(a) = λ,
lim
with λ the dominant eigenvalue of the operator of the stationary FP equation
and q the corresponding eigenvector (see [34] for example).
Note that S can also be expressed in terms of the ISI function given above
S(a) = −
1 −(cid:82) a
ISI(a)
0 ISI(s) da
which is the expression that we used in our numerical estimations of S.
We can now define properly the new stochastic process. The model is given
by the evolution of the age of the neuron plus a stochastic reset mechanism to
take into account the initiation of an action potential, and it is
d
a(t) = 1
dt
The spiking probability in (t, t + dt) is given by S(a(t))dt
If a spike is triggered then a(t) = 0,
(17)
where S is the age-dependent death rate given by (16). In this model, the age
of the neuron follows a trivial deterministic process, but the firing threshold
is stochastic since at each time the neuron can fire. When this happens, its
age is reset to zero. As reminded before, the difference between the models
(1) and (17) is that, in the NLIF the dynamics are stochastic and the reset
00.500.10.2AgeISI00.500.10.2AgeISI00.500.10.2AgeISI00.500.5AgeS00.500.5AgeS00.500.5AgeS Age-structure in neuronal populations
13
Fig. 8 Simulation of the escape rate model (17). The parameters of the simulation are
vr = 0.7, µ = 5, σ = 0.1, σ = 0.2, σ = 0.3.
process is deterministic while in the escape-rate model above, the dynamics
are deterministic but the reset mechanism is stochastic.
As we pointed out in the introduction, the escape-rate models have been
introduced in [38] in order to arrive to more tractable models from mathe-
matical point of view. It has been shown here that in the subthreshold regime
for integrate and fire neurons, the diffusive noise can be replaced by a hazard
noise (noisy threshold) described by a certain escape rate. More considerations
about viable choices of age-dependent death rates as well as the derivation of
the refractory-densities model that we will remind in the next section can be
found in [19].
We present in Fig. 8 a numerical simulation of the stochastic process defined
by (17) for different age-dependent death rates. Note that the neuron never
fires exactly at the same age, since its probability to fire (escape) is purely
stochastic.
6 The population density function (age-structure formalism)
We can now introduce the AS model in the same way as it has been done in
[19], [36] and [37].
The model describes the evolution in time of the population density func-
tion with respect to the age of a neuron in the following way: denoting by
n(t, a) the density of neurons at time t at age a, then the evolution of n is
(cid:122)
(cid:125)(cid:124)
Drift part
(cid:122)
(cid:125)(cid:124)
(cid:123)
Spiking term
∂
∂t
n(t, a) +
∂
∂a
n(t, a) +
S(a)n(t, a) = 0.
(18)
In Fig. 9, a schematic representation of the state space of the AS equation
(18) is presented.
Because once a neuron triggers a spike, its age is reset to zero, we get the
natural boundary condition
(cid:123)
(cid:123)
Reset
(cid:122)
(cid:125)(cid:124)
(cid:90) +∞
0
n(t, 0) = r(t),
∀t > 0,
where r(t) is the firing rate and is given by
r(t) =
S(a)n(t, a) da,
∀t ≥ 0.
(19)
00.10.200.020.04TimeAge00.10.200.020.04TimeAge00.10.200.020.04TimeAge00.500.20.4AgeDensity00.500.20.4AgeDensity00.500.20.4AgeDensity 14
G. Dumont et al.
Fig. 9 Schematic representation of the state space of the AS equation (18).
An initial distribution is assumed known:
n(0, a) = n0(a),
∀a > 0.
(20)
In the above equations, S(a) stands for the age-dependent death rate given
by (16). Using the boundary condition and the expression of r(t) given by
(19), one can check easily the conservation property of the equation (2) by
integrating it on the interval (0,∞), so that if the initial condition satisfies
(cid:90) +∞
(cid:90) +∞
0
0
n0(a) da = 1,
n(t, a) da = 1.
(21)
(22)
the solution at any t > 0 satisfies the normalization condition
We present in Fig. 10 a simulation of the problem (18)-(20). Again, we
have made a comparison between the stochastic process (blue curve) given by
(16) and the evolution in time of the density function (black curve) given by
(18)-(20). The simulation starts with a Gaussian as initial condition (the first
panel of Fig. 10). Under the influence of the drift term, the density function
advances in age, which is clearly seen in the upper plots of Fig. 10. After
the spiking process, the age of the neuron is reset to zero. The effect is well
perceived in the lower panels of Fig. 10. As expected from the model, the
density function converges to an equilibrium density (see the last panel in Fig.
10). The stationary state of the AS model can be easily computed; denoting
by r∞ the stationary firing rate, we get:
n∞(a) = r∞e−(cid:82) a
0 S(s) ds,
and, if we take into account the normalization condition, we obtain the ex-
pression of the stationary firing rate
r−1∞ =
0 S(s) ds da.
Since e−(cid:82) a
0 S(s) ds is the expression of the survivor function, its integral over
(0,∞) has the interpretation of the mean firing time, therefore the last relation
says nothing else than the fact that the stationary firing rate equals to the
inverse of the mean firing time.
0
(cid:90) +∞
e−(cid:82) a
Age0Reset After SpikePotential1Reset After SpikeThresholdDriftDrift + Diffusion Age-structure in neuronal populations
15
Fig. 10 Simulation of the AS model (18)-(20). Inhere, the black curve represents the sim-
ulation of the AS model and the blue curve the simulation of the stochastic process (17).
A gaussian was taken as initial condition; the parameters of the simulation are: vr = 0.7,
µ = 5, σ = 0.1. The six plots in the figure show the evolution in time of the solution at
t = 0, t = 0.1, t = 0.3, t = 0.5, t = 0.7, t = 7.
7 A theoretical link between the AS and FP problems
In this section, we present our main result that introduces an analytical link
between the two formalisms, that states that there exists an integral transform
that translates the solution to the problem (18)-(20) into the solution to (2)-
(5).
Proposition 1 Let p a solution to (2)-(5) and n a solution to (18)-(20), and
p0(v) and n0(a) two corresponding initial distributions. Then, if p0 and n0
satisfy
(cid:90) +∞
0
(cid:90) +∞
(cid:82) 1
(cid:82) 1
n0(a) da,
n(t, a) da.
(23)
the following relation holds true:
p0(v) =
q(a, v)
−∞ q(a, w) dw
p(t, v) =
q(a, v)
0
−∞ q(a, w) dw
Here, q(a, v) is the solution to (11)-(14).
preted with the help of probability theory. Since the integral (cid:82) 1
Remark 1 The integral transform given by the equation (23) can be inter-
−∞ q(a, w) dw
is the survivor function and q(a, v) is the probability density for a neuron to
be at age a and at potential v, the kernel of the transform can be interpreted
as the probability density for a neuron to be at potential value v given that
it survived up to age a. The solution n(t, a) denotes the density of population
at time t in state a, the integral over the whole possible states a of the kernel
multiplied by the density n gives indeed the density of population at time t in
the state v.
00.500.20.4AgeDensity00.500.20.4AgeDensity00.500.20.4AgeDensity00.500.20.4AgeDensity00.500.20.4AgeDensity00.500.20.4AgeDensity 16
G. Dumont et al.
Remark 2 In proposition 1, the integral transform is given in the sense of
distributions, as we shall define it bellow.
Let us show for the beginning that the integral in (23) is well defined.
If we denote by N (t, a) =
, since
n(t,a)
(cid:82) 1−∞ q(a,v) dv
(cid:82) 1
(cid:82) 1
∂
∂a n(t, a)
∂
∂a n(t, a)
=
=
(cid:32)
(cid:82) 1
(cid:82) 1
∂
∂a
n(t, a)
+ n(t, a)
+ S(a)
1
,
−∞ q(a, v) dv
−∞ q(a, v) dv
(cid:33)
−∞ q(a, v) dv
−∞ q(a, v) dv
−∞ q(a, v) dv
(cid:82) 1
∂
∂a
n(t, a)
where we have used the definition of S(a), one can see that N is solution to
the following system: ∂
∂a N (t, a) = 0,
N (0, a) =
∂t N (t, a) + ∂
N (t, 0) = r(t) =(cid:82) ∞
(cid:82) 1−∞ q(a,v) dv
(cid:26) N0(a − t),
n0(a)
.
N (t, a) =
r(t − a),
a > t,
t ≥ a,
The system above can be easily integrated
0 ISI(a)N (t, a) da,
(24)
and the regularity of the solution is dictated by the regularity of the initial
condition. In particular, if N0 ∈ L1(0,∞) then N (t,·) ∈ L1(0,∞). Also, choos-
ing n0 such that N0 ∈ H 1(0,∞), and as soon as N0(0) =
ISI(a)N0(a) da,
we obtain that N (t,·) ∈ H 1(0,∞).
0
(cid:90) ∞
On the other hand, q(a, v) is the solution to (11)-(14), which is a parabolic
equation with zero right hand side and homogeneous boundary conditions,
therefore its exponential convergence towards zero as a → ∞ for a.e. v ∈
(−∞, 1] is immediate. We therefore can assert that, for every ε,
q(a, v) < c(v), a.e. v ∈ (−∞, 1], a > aε.
Since the product of a function from L∞ with an L1 function is integrable, we
have then that the transform (23) is well defined.
We also point out that, due to the large time behavior of q, we have that
(cid:90) ∞
S(a) da = +∞,
0
condition which is known in age structured systems theory to imply that n(t, a)
tends to zero as a tends to infinity (which can be easily seen by simply in-
tegrating (18) ). We have chosen to work on [0,∞) as the age interval, but
one could have chosen, exactly as in AS systems theory, to work on a finite
interval [0, Amax], where Amax is the maximal age that can be reached. In this
Age-structure in neuronal populations
17
context, the condition that on the age interval, the integral of mortality rate to
be infinity, has the biological interpretation that the density of the population
at ages bigger than maximal one is zero, therefore the meaning of maximal age
is exact. Of course, in our context, it would mean that all the neurons would
have fired before reaching this maximal value. Also, let us notice that the sys-
tem in n has a classical solution on the defined domain; since the mortality
rate does not depend explicitly on t, the derivatives with respect to t and a
exist in classical sense.
Before starting the proof, let us make some considerations over the solutions
to the systems (2) -- (5), respectively (11)-(14). We shall consider weak solutions
to both systems in the sense introduced in [8], namely:
Definition 1 A pair of nonnegative functions (p, r) such that
p ∈ L2(cid:0)0, T ; L2
+(−∞, 1)(cid:1) , r ∈ L2
+(0, T )
is a solution to (2) -- (5) if, for any test functions ϕ(t, v) ∈ L2([0, T ] × (−∞, 1])
such that
ϕ(t, v) ∈ L2((0, T ) × (−∞, 1)), ϕ(T, v) = 0,
ϕ(t, v), (µ − v)
∂2
∂v2 ϕ(t, v),
the following relation takes place:
∂
∂v
∂
∂t
(cid:20)
(cid:90) T
(cid:90) 1
(cid:90) T
0
=
0
p(t, v)
− ∂ϕ(t, v)
− (µ − v)
∂t
−∞
r(t)[ϕ(t, vr) − ϕ(t, 1)] dt +
(cid:90) 1
−∞
(cid:21)
dv dt
∂ϕ(t, v)
∂v
− σ2
2
∂2ϕ(t, v)
∂v2
p0(v)ϕ(0, v) dv.
(25)
As functions of the form Φ(v)Ψ (t) with Φ(v) ∈ L2(−∞, 1) such that
(µ − v)Φ(cid:48)(v), Φ(cid:48)(cid:48)(v) ∈ L2(−∞, 1),
and Ψ (t) ∈ L2(0, T ) with Ψ(cid:48)(t) ∈ L2(0, T ), Ψ (T ) = 0 are a dense subset of the
test functions in definition 1, we will restrict (25) to
(cid:20)
(cid:90) 1
(cid:90) T
(cid:90) T
0
0
p(t, v)
−∞
r(t)[Φ(vr) − Φ(1)]Ψ (t) dt +
(cid:90) 1
−∞
−Ψ(cid:48)(t)Φ(v) − Ψ (t)(µ − v)Φ(cid:48)(v) − σ2
2
Ψ (t)Φ(cid:48)(cid:48)(v)
dv dt =
p0(v)Φ(v)Ψ (0) dv,
(26)
(cid:21)
which gives the expression of the distributional derivative with respect to t:
p(t, v)Φ(v) dv
(cid:20)
p(t, v)
(µ − v)Φ(cid:48)(v) +
Φ(cid:48)(cid:48)(v)
σ2
2
(cid:21)
(27)
dv + r(t)[Φ(vr) − Φ(1)],
(cid:90) 1
(cid:90) 1
−∞
−∞
∂
∂t
=
18
G. Dumont et al.
again, for all the test functions Φ defined as above.
(cid:21)
dv da =
(28)
In the same way we will use a weak formulation for (11) as
q(a, v)
−χ(cid:48)(a)Φ(v) − χ(a)(µ − v)Φ(cid:48)(v) − χ(a)
Φ(cid:48)(cid:48)(v)
σ2
2
(cid:90) ∞
(cid:90) 1
0
−∞
(cid:20)
(cid:90) ∞
Φ(vr)χ(0) − Φ(1)
χ(a)ISI(a) da,
0
with χ(a) ∈ L2(0,∞) and χ(cid:48)(a) ∈ L2(0,∞) and Φ(v) as in the previous defi-
nition.
We can now proceed with our proof.
Proof Let us notice for the beginning that the AS system in n(t, a) can be
formulated equivalently as (24) in terms of the new variable
N (t, a) =
n(t, a)
.
−∞ q(a, v) dv
Moreover, using this notation, the integral transform reads:
(cid:82) 1
(cid:90) ∞
0
(cid:90) 1
(cid:90) ∞
−∞
0
(cid:90) 1
(cid:90) ∞
−∞
0
(cid:90) 1
−∞
∂
∂t
(cid:90) 1
−∞
∂
∂t
p(t, v) =
q(a, v)N (t, a) da.
(29)
In order to show that the above formula defines a solution to the FP system,
let us apply the distributional derivative to (29) and show that it satisfies (27):
p(t, v)Φ(v) dv =
q(a, v)
∂
∂t
N (t, a)Φ(v) da dv.
Using the fact that N (t, a) is solution to (24), the last equation becomes:
p(t, v)Φ(v) dv = −
q(a, v)
∂
∂a
N (t, a)Φ(v) da dv.
Let us turn now to the definition of the weak solution q(a, v) given by (28).
Noticing that, under proper assumptions over the initial state N0, for each t
∂a N (t, a) are in L2(0,∞), we can apply the
arbitrary but fixed, N (t, a) and ∂
definition for q by choosing χ(a) as N (t,·). Then we get that
(cid:90) 1
(cid:90) 1
−∞
(cid:90) ∞
(cid:90) ∞
0
−∞
0
−
=
q(a, v)
∂
∂a
N (t, a)Φ(v) da dv
N (t, a)q(a, v)
(µ − v)Φ(cid:48)(v) +
(cid:21)
da dv
Φ(cid:48)(cid:48)(v)
σ2
2
(cid:20)
(cid:90) ∞
0
+Φ(vr)N (t, 0) − Φ(1)
N (t, a)ISI(a) da.
(cid:90) ∞
Age-structure in neuronal populations
19
N (t, a)ISI(a) da, the last two terms in the expres-
Since N (t, 0) = r(t) =
sion above give
0
r(t)[Φ(vr) − Φ(1)]
and therefore, we have obtained that
(cid:90) 1
(cid:90) 1
−∞
(cid:90) ∞
(cid:90) ∞
0
−∞
0
∂
∂t
=
q(a, v)N (t, a)Φ(v) da dv
(cid:20)
q(a, v)N (t, a)
(µ − v)Φ(cid:48)(v) +
Φ(cid:48)(cid:48)(v)
σ2
2
(cid:21)
da dv + r(t)[Φ(vr) − Φ(1)],
which is exactly (27) for p(t, v) given by (29), which completes our proof.
The integral transform gives a corresponding relation between the two
stationary states. Due to the form of the age-dependent death-rate S, the
stationary density of the AS systems is completely determined by the solution
to (11)-(14):
Using now the integral transform, we obtain that the stationary solution to
(2)-(5) satisfies
n∞(a) =
−∞ q(a, v) dv
−∞ q(a, v) dv da
.
p∞(v) =
q(a, v) da
−∞ q(a, v) dv da
0
(cid:82) 1
(cid:82) +∞
(cid:82) 1
(cid:82) +∞
(cid:82) +∞
(cid:82) 1
(cid:82) +∞
(cid:82) 1
0
0
1
.
,
Since we have the relation
r∞ =
0
−∞ q(a, v) dv da
one may check directly that the above formula is indeed a solution to the
stationary problem of the potential-structured system by multiplying (11) by
r∞ and integrating it on (0,∞).
8 Asymptotic behavior
In the previous section, we have shown that there is an integral transform
relating the solution of the time elapsed model and the solution of the FP
equation. Our integral transform goes that way: for a density in age, n(t, a),
one can associate a corresponding solution p(t, v) to the (2)-(5). Let us define
the operator
F : L1
+(0, +∞) → L1
+(−∞, 1)
n∞
(cid:55)→
p∞
20
defined by
(cid:90) +∞
0
p∞(v) =
(cid:82) 1
q(a, v)
−∞ q(a, w) dw
G. Dumont et al.
n∞(a) da,
where p∞ and n∞ are the stationary solutions to the potential- respectively
age- structured systems. In the previous section, we have shown that, as soon
as the initial conditions p0 and n0 are related by F , the whole trajectories
p(·, v) and n(·, a) are also related by F . Here we show that in the case the
relation between initial conditions is not satisfied, F transforms the known
convergence of n to n∞ for t → ∞ in the convergence of p to p∞ = F n∞.
This gives an additional way to study the behavior of p for large time, already
studied in [8], [9] by other means.
+(−∞, 1), the so-
Proposition 2 For all initial conditions p0 belonging to L1
lution p of the potential structured problem (2)-(5) converges to F n∞ where
n∞ is such that, for any initial condition, the solution n to (18), verifies
t→+∞(cid:107)n(t,·) − n∞(·)(cid:107)L1
lim
+(0,∞) = 0.
Proof The model (18)-(20) is a classical McKendrick-von Foerster model, well
known in population dynamics, with the particularity that the age specific
mortality and fertility rates are the same. Then, defining the intrinsic repro-
duction number R0 as
R0 =
S(a(cid:48))da(cid:48)) da,
(cid:90) +∞
S(a) exp(−
(cid:90) a
by direct computations we get
0
0
R0 = 1.
Then it is well known that in this case, for t → ∞, n converges to n∞ satisfying
n∞(a) + S(a)n∞(a) = 0,
a > 0,
d
da
with
and
(cid:90) ∞
n∞(0) =
(cid:90) ∞
0
S(a)n∞(a)da,
0
n∞(a)da = 1.
(30)
(31)
(32)
Let us now define α(t, v) the solution to:
∂
∂t
α(t, v) +
∂
∂v
[(µ − v)α(t, v)] − σ2
2
∂2
∂v2 α(t, v) = δ(v − vr)r(t),
with boundary conditions similar to (3), (4), r(t) being the firing rate relative
to (18) and the initial condition is given by
Age-structure in neuronal populations
21
α(0,·) = α0 = F n0.
Then, thanks to Proposition 1,
α(t,·) = F n(t,·).
The transform F being continuous from to L1
+(0, +∞) to L1
+(−∞, 1), we get
α(t, v) → p∞(v) = F n∞ in L1(−∞, 1),
as t → ∞, where one can check as in Proposition 1 that p∞(v) satisfies
∂
∂v [(µ − v)p∞(v)] − σ2
2
∂2
∂v2 p∞(v) = δ(v − vr)r∞,
(33)
with
and boundary conditions
r∞ = − σ2
2
∂
∂v
p∞(1),
v→−∞(−µ + v)p∞(v) +
lim
σ2
2
∂
∂v
p∞(v) = 0,
p∞(1) = 0.
Now let us consider β(t, v) = p(t, v) − α(t, v). It satisfies
∂
∂t
β(t, v) +
∂
∂v
[(µ − v)β(t, v)] − σ2
2
∂2
∂v2 β(t, v) = 0,
with boundary conditions
v→−∞(−µ + v)β(t, v) +
lim
σ2
2
∂
∂v
β(t, v) = 0,
β(t, 1) = 0,
and with the initial condition given by:
β(0, v) = p0(v) − F n0(a).
Using a change of variable similar to the one in [9], this equation is transformed
in a heat equation on (−∞, 0) with a zero Dirichlet condition in 0. Then it is
clear that β(t, v) goes to 0 as t → ∞ in L∞(−∞, 1) ∩ L1(−∞, 1), which ends
the proof.
22
G. Dumont et al.
9 Conclusions and perspectives
It has been shown in [38] that the integrate-and-fire model with stochastic
input can be mapped approximately onto an escape-rate model. Despite the
fact that the two systems reproduce the same statistical activity, no analytical
connection between them has been given until now. This paper is intended as
a first step in this direction. We have proven here the existence of an exact
analytical transform of the solution to the AS system into the solution to the
F-P system which is an equivalent description of the NLIF model. Our finding
highlights the theoretical relationships between the two stochastic processes
and explain why the statistical firing distributions across time are similar for
both models, see the red dots in Fig. 11. To our knowledge, such a result has
not been proven until now.
As we have pointed it out in the introduction section, there are several
advantages in using the AS formalism, and the main reason is that it has been
already well-studied by mathematicians throughout the past decades. Another
advantage in using the age structured model regards its numerical simulations,
see Fig. 11. While the NLIF model requires the numerical implementation
of the Euler-Maruyama scheme, the escape model can be simulated via a
Gillespie-like algorithm. However, the noisy threshold model is probably a
little bit more difficult to relate to the underlying biophysics of a cell. For this
crucial point, one would prefer the use of NLIF model where each parameter
of the model can be easily measured by neuroscientists.
We have to stress though that the results obtained here have been proven
in the case of a not-connected neural population, which is a strong simplifying
assumption. The case we considered is known in the framework of renewal
systems as a stationary process. A possible extension of the present transform
for the case of interconnected neurons remains thus for us an open issue to be
investigated. But the most important thing to be investigated, and which is
currently in working progress, is the existence of an inverse transform to the
one introduced here. Nevertheless, in the absence of such an inverse transform,
we proved here that the set of solutions to the F-P system defined through
our transform is an attractor set of the solutions as t tends to infinity.
The integral transform given in Proposition 1 has a probability meaning
and this meaning can be interpreted using Bayes' rule. Indeed, the kernel
of our transformation can be read out as P(va), the probability to find a
neuron at potential v knowing its age a. The most important feature of this
kernel is that it is time independent; the very nature of the age a contains
all the information about time that is needed to properly define the integral
transform. On contrary, to define an inverse transform, one faces the problem
of having a kernel that must depend on time. Transforming then the solution
to the FP system into the solution to the AS system is therefore a little bit
trickier. Another important aspect about the nature of the AS formalism is
that the variable a also entails information about the last firing moment.
Indeed, attributing an age to a neuron presupposes that the considered neuron
has already fired an action potential. From our perspective, the membrane
Age-structure in neuronal populations
23
Fig. 11 In the top panel, we show a schematic representation of the integral transformation
between the two mathematical representations of the neural noise. In the bottom panel, we
give two simulations illustrating the different mathematical treatments of noise in neuro-
science context. The red dots indicates the firing time of the cell. The time distribution
of those dots are similar in the two representations. The parameters of the simulation are
vr = 0.6, µ = 5, σ = 0.2.
potential variable v does not carry out such knowledge. There is therefore a
hidden information in the AS model that is not present in the FP approach. It
is therefore our belief that, in order to properly define an inverse transform, one
would be forced to assume that the FP initial density shares the information
about the last firing event. A compatibility condition on the initial data is
then required, we therefore believe that p0 and n0 should be related through
the same transform presented in this paper.
The easiest way to formalize all this is probably to write down the Bayes'
rule
P(av; t) = P(va) ∗ P(a; t)/P(v; t) = P(va) ∗ n(t, a)/p(t, v)
Note that the time-dependence of P(av; t) is inescapable. Moreover, the full
form of P(av; t) is not useful within the context of an inverse transformation,
since such an inverse transformation is trivial (reducing to n(t, a) on both
sides). Given these observations, it might make sense to assume that the system
is close to equilibrium. With this maximum-entropy-like assumption, we can
write a time-independent version of P(av; t):
P(av) ≈ P(va) ∗ n∞(a)/p∞(v)
where n∞(a) and p∞(v) are the equilibrium distributions for n(t, a) and p(t, v),
respectively. These equilibriums can be calculated. With such reasoning, a
perfect theoretical inverse from the AS model to the FP representations can
be found, and an approximate inverse transformation can be constructed using
the values of n and p at equilibrium, see Fig. 11.
PotentialRepresentationp(t,v)AgeRepresentationn(t,a)Theoretical TransformationApproximative Transformation00.10.20.30.20.40.60.81TimePotential00.10.20.300.020.04TimeAge 24
G. Dumont et al.
As we stressed in the introduction, the benefit of such a representation
would be the transfer of the analysis of special behaviors of the function p(t, v)
which is the solution of a system that raises technical problems, to the study of
the behavior of the AS system, which is obviously simpler. The only quantity
which will be significant then it will be the age dependent death rate which
will contain all the information needed to give insights of the behavior of the
system.
References
1. Abbott, L.: Lapique's introduction of the integrate-and-fire model neuron (1907). Brain
Research Bulletin 50(5), 303 -- 304 (1999)
2. Abbott, L.F., van Vreeswijk, C.: Asynchronous states in networks of pulse-coupled os-
cillators. Phys. Rev. E. 48, 1483 -- 1490 (1993)
3. Bressloff, P.C., Newby, J.M.: Stochastic models of intra-cellular transport. Review of
Modern Physics 85 (1) (2013)
4. Brunel, N.: Dynamics of sparsely connected networks of excitatory and inhibitory spik-
ing neurons. Journal of Computational Neuroscience 8, 183 -- 208 (2000)
5. Brunel, N., Hakim, V.: Fast global oscillations in networks of integrate-and-fire neurons
with low firing rates. Neural Computation 11, 1621 -- 1671 (1999)
6. Brunel, N., van Rossum, M.: Lapicque's 1907 paper: from frogs to integrate-and-fire.
Biological Cybernetics 97, 341 -- 349 (2007)
7. Burkitt, A.N.: A review of the integrate-and-fire neuron model: I. homogeneous synaptic
input. Biological Cybernetics 95, 1 -- 19 (2006)
8. C´aceres, M.J., Carrillo, J.A., Perthame, B.: Analysis of nonlinear noisy integrate & fire
neuron models: blow-up and steady states. The Journal of Mathematical Neuroscience
1 (2011)
9. Carrillo, J.A., d M Gonz´alez, M., Gualdani, M.P., Schonbek, M.E.: Classical solutions
for a nonlinear fokker-planck equation arising in computational neuroscience. Commu-
nications in PDEs 38, 385-409, 2013 38, 385 -- 409 (2013)
10. Cox, D.R.: Renewal Theory. Mathuen, London (1962)
11. Dumont, G., Henry, J.: Population density models of integrate-and-fire neurons with
jumps, well-posedness. Journal of Mathematical Biology 67(3), 453 -- 81 (2013)
12. Dumont, G., Henry, J.: Synchronization of an excitatory integrate-and-fire neural net-
work. Bulletin of Mathematical Biology 75(4), 629 -- 48 (2013)
13. Dumont, G., Henry, J., Tarniceriu, C.: A density model for a population of theta neu-
rons. Journal of Mathematical Neuroscience 4(1) (2014)
14. Ermentrout, G.B., Terman, D.: Mathematical foundations of neuroscience. Springer
(2010)
15. Faisal, A., Selen, L., Wolpert, D.: Noise in the nervous system. Nature Reviews Neuro-
science 9(4), 292 -- 303 (2008)
16. Gardiner, C.W.: Handbook of Stochastic MMethod for Physics, Chemistry and Natural
Sciences. Springer (1996)
17. Gerstner, W.: Time structure of the activity in neural network models. Phys. Rev. E.
51, 738 -- 758 (1995)
18. Gerstner, W.: Population dynamics of spiking neurons: fast transients, asynchronous
states, and locking. Neural Computation 12, 43 -- 89 (2000)
19. Gerstner, W., Kistler, W.: Spiking neuron models. Cambridge university press (2002)
20. Gerstner, W., Naud, R.: How good are neuron models? Science 326(5951), 379 -- 380
(2009)
21. Gillespie, D.T., Seitaridou, E.: Simple Brownian Diffusion: An Introduction to the Stan-
dard Theoretical Models. Oxford university press (2012)
22. Hodgkin, A.L., Huxley, A.F.: A quantitative description of membrane current and its
application to conduction and excitation in nerve. The Journal of physiology 117(4),
500 -- 544 (1952)
Age-structure in neuronal populations
25
23. Holcman, D., Schuss, Z.: The narrow escape problem. SIAM Rev 56(2), 213 -- 257 (2014)
24. Izhikevich, E.M.: Dynamical Systems in Neuroscience. The MIT Press (2007)
25. Knight, B.: Dynamics of encoding in neuron populations: Some general mathematical
features. Neural Computation 12(3), 473 -- 518 (2000)
26. Knight, B., Manin, D., Sirovich, L.: Dynamical models of interacting neuron populations
in visual cortex. Robotics and cybernetics 54, 4 -- 8 (1996)
27. Longtin, A.: Stochastic dynamical systems. Scholarpedia 5(4), 1619. (2010)
28. Longtin, A.: Neuronal noise. Scholarpedia 8(9), 1618 (2013)
29. Millman, D., Mihalas, S., Kirkwood, A., Niebur, E.: Self-organized criticality occurs
in non-conservative neuronal networks during 'up' states. Nature physics 6, 801 -- 805
(2010)
30. Newhall, K.A., Kovacic, G., Kramer, P.R., Cai, D.: Cascade-induced synchrony in
stochastically-driven neuronal networks. Physical review 82 (2010)
31. Newhall, K.A., Kovacic, G., Kramer, P.R., Zhou, D., Rangan, A.V., Cai, D.: Dynamics
of current-based, poisson driven, integrate-and-fire neuronal networks. Communications
in Mathematical Sciences 8, 541 -- 600 (2010)
32. Nykamp, D.Q., Tranchina, D.: A population density appraoch that facilitates large-scale
modeling of neural networks : analysis and an application to orientation tuning. Journal
of computational neurosciences 8, 19 -- 50 (2000)
33. Omurtag, A., Knight, B., Sirovich, L.: On the simulation of large population of neurons.
Journal of computational 8, 51 -- 63 (2000)
34. Ostojic, S.: Interval interspike distributions of spiking neurons driven by fluctuating
inputs. Journal of Neurophysiology 106, 361 -- 373 (2011)
35. Ostojic, S., Brunel, N., Hakim, V.: Synchronization properties of networks of electrically
coupled neurons in the presence of noise and heterogeneities. Journal of computational
neurosciences 26, 369 -- 392 (2009)
36. Pakdaman, K., Perthame, B., Salort, D.: Dynamics of a structured neuron population.
Nonlinearity 23, 23 -- 55 (2009)
37. Pakdaman, K., Perthame, B., Salort, D.: Relaxation and self-sustained oscillations in
the time elapsed neuron network model. SIAM Journal of Applied Mathematics 73(3),
1260 -- 1279 (2013)
38. Plesser, H.E., Gerstner, W.: Noise in integrate-and-fire neurons: from stochastic input
to escape rates. Neural Computation 12(2), 367 -- 384 (2000)
39. Schuss, Z., Singer, A., Holcman, D.: The narrow escape problem for diffusion in cellular
domains. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104(41), 16,098 -- 16,103
(2007)
40. Wilbur, W.J., Rinzel, J.: A theoretical basis for large coefficient of variation and bi-
modality in interspike interval distributions. J. Theor. Biol. 105, 345 -- 368 (1983)
|
1512.00058 | 1 | 1512 | 2015-11-30T21:51:05 | Observations on recent progress in the field of timing and time perception | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Time is an important dimension of brain function, but little is still known about the underlying cognitive principles and neurobiological mechanisms. The field of timing and time perception has witnessed rapid growth and multidisciplinary interest in the recent years with the advent of modern neuroimaging, neurophysiological and optogenetic tools. In this article, I review the literature from the last ten years (2005-2015) using a data mining approach and highlight the most significant empirical as well as review articles based on the number of citations (a minimum of 100 citations). Such analysis provides a unique perspective on the current state-of-the-art in the field and highlights subtopics in the field that have received considerable attention, and those that have not. The objective of the article is to present an objective summary of the current progress in the field of timing and time perception and provide a valuable and accessible resource summarizing the most cited articles for new as well current investigators in the field. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Observations on recent progress in the field of timing and time perception !1
!!
!
Sundeep Teki!
Auditory Neuroscience Group, Department of Physiology, Anatomy & Genetics,
University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3QX, UK.
[email protected]
!
Abstract
Time is an important dimension of brain function, but little is still known about the
underlying cognitive principles and neurobiological mechanisms. The field of timing and
time perception has witnessed rapid growth and multidisciplinary interest in the recent years
with the advent of modern neuroimaging, neurophysiological and optogenetic tools. In this
article, I review the literature from the last ten years (2005-2015) using a data mining
approach and highlight the most significant empirical as well as review articles based on the
number of citations (a minimum of 100 citations). Such analysis provides a unique
perspective on the current state-of-the-art in the field and highlights subtopics in the field
that have received considerable attention, and those that have not. The objective of the article
is to present an objective summary of the current progress in the field of timing and time
perception and provide a valuable and accessible resource summarizing the most cited
articles for new as well current investigators in the field.
!
This article was originally written for an invited review on Auditory perception and Timing for a special issue of
1
Current Opinion in Behavioural Sciences on ‘Interval Timing and Skill Learning: The Multisensory Representation of
Time and Action’ guest edited by Warren Meck and Richard Ivry. The article was rejected as it did not conform to the
specific journal guidelines and is reproduced here in its original form.
Page
1
of
23
I. Introduction!
!
This is not an editorial piece. For that, please read the editorial article for this special issue on
‘Interval Timing and Skill Learning: The Multisensory Representation of Time and Action’, by
Richard Ivry and Warren Meck, who are in the best position to comment on the various review
articles and provide a succinct summary of the field. My objective is to present my personal
observations on the current state of research on timing and time perception, specifically from
the point of view of a postdoctoral researcher interested in building an independent research
program focused on timing.!
!
My advisor, Tim Griffiths and I were invited by the editor, Warren Meck to contribute a review
focused on ‘Auditory perception and timing’. As per the guidelines circulated to all invited
authors, the review should focus on, and highlight recent articles of note, especially those
published in the last couple of years. My own contribution to the field, during my doctoral
research with Tim Griffiths, is represented by two empirical papers (Teki et al., 2011, Teki and
Griffiths, 2014) and a review article (Teki et al., 2012) in a special issue on timing, that was also
edited by Warren Meck. More recently, Tim and I collaborated with Warren Meck and Melissa
Allman on a review elaborating the subjective principles of time perception (Allman et al., 2014). !
!
The guide for authors provided by the Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences (COBS) clearly
stipulates that - “the aim of the manuscript is to review recent articles, with particular emphasis
on those articles published in the past two years.” As the guide encourages the authors to
describe recent trends and provide subjective opinions of the topics discussed, I decided to take
the liberty to do exactly as instructed, and provide my subjective opinions of recent progress in
the field.!
Page
2
of
23
A review article is meant to highlight and discuss recent trends and results on a particular topic.
Invariably, there is a tendency on the part of most authors to emphasize one’s own work at the
expense of not adequately discussing results from other research groups. At the outset, I also
outlined a possible structure for the review based on my work on duration-based and beat-
based timing (Teki et al., 2011, 2012). However, this work does not comply with the publication
timeline suggested by the journal. Thus, I decided to not discuss this work which was discussed
in a recent review article (Allman et al., 2014). Even if the restricted timeline of two years were
to be relaxed, Tim and I struggled to find ten recent articles of note on the particular topic and
published in the last two years to emphasize and highlight in our review. After further
discussions, we decided to focus on ‘Disorders of sequence and interval timing’ based on
recent neuropsychological work from Tim’s group that examined perceptual timing abilities of
patients with striatal and cerebellar degeneration in the form of Huntington’s disease, Multiple
Systems Atrophy and Parkinson’s disease (Cope et al., 2014a, b). !
!
This new topic was more exciting, for the list of authors and topics provided by COBS did not
include any clinically oriented articles. Although timing abilities are known to be impaired in a
range of neuropsychological and neurological disorders (Allman and Meck, 2012) including
Parkinson’s disease, Huntington’s disease, Multiple Systems Atrophy and Schizophrenia
amongst others, the extent to which their timing performance is affected and related to the
primary neurological deficits is not fully known. However, even though this field is gaining
traction and represents a highly fruitful area of translational research, a review of the recent
literature on this topic, again, yielded few promising articles to form the basis of a constructive
review that would be beneficial to the field.!
!
Page
3
of
23
At this juncture, it appeared that the two topics of specialization investigated in Tim’s lab could
not be covered in a detailed and topical review for COBS. At this point, I wondered whether the
lack of recent significant breakthroughs is true of the field of timing and time perception as a
whole, or is it just a representation of the specific topics we focused on? !
!!
!!
!
II. Key papers on timing and time perception!
To obtain a representative picture of the field, I decided to examine recent papers by the authors
invited to contribute to this special issue (75 authors). As the list of invited authors was a fairly
small sample, I extended the list by considering all members of the recently concluded
European COST Action - Timely which included members from all over the world. This list
provided another 129 authors who were not already invited to contribute to the COBS special
issue, thus resulting in a reasonable sample size of 204 authors.!
A number of metrics are used to evaluate the quality and impact of research articles including
impact factor, h-index, i-10 index amongst others. Although none of these metrics are accepted
as standard across the scientific community, I decided on the number of citations as a metric as
it indicates the impact of a paper and how well the idea is accepted and circulated in the field by
other researchers. It is not a perfect measure, for the number of citations an articles receives is
often skewed by the impact factor of the journal where it is published but good ideas tend to
circulate well no matter where the ideas are published. Furthermore, to draw reasonable
conclusions about progress in the timing field, I focused on a period of 10 years and considered
all articles that were indexed in Google Scholar and published by the above set of authors from
2005 onward. In order to restrict my sample of publications and consider only the most impactful
papers (ideas), I used a threshold of a minimum of 100 citations. This timeframe is also not
Page
4
of
23
ideal, for it is biased towards older papers than more recent articles which have not had the
same time to accumulate as many citations. !
Using these search criteria, 66 papers (an average of 1 article per every 3 authors) were found
as described in Table 1. These papers covered research on topics related to perception of time,
rhythm, music, inter-sensory synchrony amongst others and used techniques including
psychophysics, neuroimaging, electrophysiology and modeling. Out of these 66 papers, 24
papers were review articles (marked with an asterisk next to the number of citations) that
received an average of 223.5 citations (Z-score ranged from - 0.65 to 4.44), i.e. one of out three
prominent articles on timing in the last ten years were review articles that discussed the current
state of research. The remaining empirical papers, 42 in all, received an average of 181.6
citations per paper (Z-score ranged from - 0.82 to 3.70). !
!
!
There are several conclusions to be drawn from Table 1, for instance that review articles tend to
dominate the overall citations in the field while only an average of four significant empirical
papers are published a year. Although many of these reviews are now ‘classic’ in the field, even
the most recent article in the table is a review (Merchant et al., 2013). Among other things, this
suggests that either the field is still in an embryonic stage where review articles by established
researchers are needed to set the precedent on certain topics or that the field of timing is too
diverse, at an intersection of various fields including time perception, rhythm perception, music
perception, temporal coding, inter sensory asynchrony, motor timing and coordination, that is
reflected in the diversity of topics covered by the review articles. Although not evident from the
list, there has been a recent proliferation of review articles given the rise of specialist open
access journals like Frontiers that encourage researchers (repeatedly and frequently) to
commission special issues covering empirical work as well as reviews. It is not known whether a
similar analysis of the most recent and highly cited papers in other fields like memory, vision, or
Page
5
of
23
decision-making will yield the same ratio of reviews to empirical studies but one could make a
reasonable null hypothesis that this ratio may be smaller than for the field of timing.
Alternatively, compared to fields like vision and memory that have been intense topics of
investigation for several decades the field of timing is more nascent and does not boast a large
research community as evident by the number of participants at specialist meetings in such
fields, for instance, the annual Vision Science Society conferences. !
!
In order to drive more experimental work, it is clear that the field of timing needs to attract more
young researchers and ensure a a bright future for the field, and this would need concerted
efforts from the entire timing community. A recent positive step in this direction is represented by
the launch of a specialist journal for timing, Timing and Time Perception as well as its
corresponding review journal, Timing and Time Perception Reviews. Another step forward would
be the launch of an academic society exclusively for researchers in timing that would promote
interdisciplinary exchange of ideas amongst researchers with diverse interests in timing via
annual conferences that draw on a range of methods from purely behavioral to
neurophysiological and neuroanatomical measures, and from neurostimulation and
neuropsychological approaches to animal work and computational models; share pertinent
news and information like grant funding calls, new papers, job opportunities for doctoral and
postdoctoral candidates, workshops and training opportunities; and promote career
development of young researchers through grants for short cross-disciplinary collaborations or
exchange visits, funding for attending conferences and general mentoring support. Although
there already exist a few scientific societies and communities relevant to timing like the Society
for Music Perception and Cognition (SPMC: http://www.musicperception.org), Rhythm
Perception and Production Workshop (RPPW: http://rppw.org), European Society for Cognitive
Sciences of Music (ESCOM: http://escom2015.org), Society for Education, Music and
Page
6
of
23
Psychology Research (SEMPRE: http://www.sempre.org.uk), Deutsche Gesellschaft fur
Musikpsychologie (DGM: http://www.music-psychology.de), Asia-Pacific Society for the
Cognitive Sciences of Music, Fondazione Mariani (http://fondazione-mariani.org/) that organizes
the NeuroMusic conferences, their scope is limited to music perception and psychology, and do
not cover the interests of the entire field of timing and time perception. Society for Neuroscience
(SfN) represents the primary venue where researchers gather together for structured mini- or
nano-symposia on human and animal timing research but the scientific interaction and
discussions are limited given the hectic nature of SfN meetings. A recent example of such a
successful academic organization is the Society for the Neurobiology of Language (http://
www.neurolang.org/) funded by the National Institutes of Health, which since its inception in
2009, attracts more than 400 researchers for its annual conferences that are held alternatively
in the USA (as a satellite meeting of SfN) and Europe.!
III. Future directions!
Organizational considerations apart, there are several new scientific directions that the field can
and should embrace to achieve a more comprehensive understanding of the neurobiology of
timing in natural environments. Animal models of timing focused on core timing networks
including the basal ganglia, cerebellum, premotor and parietal cortex (Grahn 2012; Teki et al.,
2012; Schneider and Ghose, 2012; Merchant et al., 2013; Allman et al., 2014; Hayashi et al.,
2015) will be key to understanding the encoding of time by neuronal ensembles. Such a line of
work has been recently pioneered by Hugo Merchant colleagues in rhesus macaques that
combines timing behaviors and the examination of the underlying neuronal code in the basal
ganglia (Merchant et al., 2011, 2013; Bartolo et al., 2014; Bartolo and Merchant, 2015). Recent
work by Mello et al. (2015) further demonstrated that a population code for time exists in the
striatum that scales with the interval being timed and multiplexes information about action as
!!
!
Page
7
of
23
well as time. Optogenetic approaches in specific target cells in animal models will yield further
crucial insights into the causal role of such mechanisms and their impact on timing behaviors
(Grosenick et al., 2015). For instance, a recent study by Chen et al. (2014) reported rapid
modulation of striatal activity by the cerebellum via a disynaptic pathway which has implications
for the coordinated processing of temporal information in the two core timing areas.!
!
The other dominant view of timing is that it is not a computation of specific dedicated circuits but
rather the output of intrinsic neuronal dynamics (Karmarkar and Buonomano, 2007; Ivry and
Schlerf, 2008). In this respect, the activity of sensory areas including auditory, visual and
somatosensory cortices merits further attention. Combining optogenetics and single-unit
recordings in primary visual cortex (V1), Hussain Shuler and colleagues have recently provided
beautiful insights into how V1 responses predict and drive the timing of future actions
(Namboodiri et al., 2015) and recruit basal forebrain and cholinergic input within V1 to encode
the timing of visually cued behaviors (Liu et al., 2015). !
!
In order to obtain a fundamental understanding of timing, it is also imperative to use stimuli and
paradigms that mimic timing behaviors in the natural world. Such naturalistic sequences that go
beyond the use of single intervals that have been traditionally used will offer additional insights
on encoding of time as well as associated motor behaviors (Kornysheva and Diedrichsen,
2014). Table 1 and the reviews therein highlight that timing is not mediated by a single brain
area but rather involves a distributed network (Meck, 2005) in cortical and subcortical areas
including prefrontal, parietal, premotor and sensory cortices, insula, basal ganglia, cerebellum,
inferior olive amongst others. To form a clear picture of how timing is mediated by these
structures, it is also important to understand the core functions of these areas and what
particular aspect of timing they mediate, whether it is related to attention, memory or perception.
Page
8
of
23
The use of comparative paradigms in healthy human volunteers as well as clinical populations
that show timing deficits such as patients with Parkinson’s, Huntington’s, Schizophrenia
amongst others will provide a more uniform understanding of timing functions and dysfunctions
in health and disease. An identical approach (and even the use of similar paradigms) in animal
models via use of control animals as well as lesion or knock-out models will complement
findings from the human literature and provide a more generic understanding of fundamental
mechanisms of timing.!
Irrespective of the present state of affairs, the field of timing and time perception represents a
promising and highly active field of research that is growing every year in terms of number of
researchers and scientific output and one where new students and researchers can find a niche
topic and leave a significant mark on the field. !
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Page
9
of
23
Table List of 66 papers on timing, rhythm and music perception from 2005 to present sorted
according to the number of citations (minimum of 100 citations) in Google Scholar collated
during the period from August 30 to September 16, 2015 (see section II for more details).
Asterisks next to the number of citations denote review articles.!
!
Page
10
of
23
No. of citationsReferenceYearJournalSummary1068*Buhusi & Meck2005Nat Rev NeurosciTime is represented in a distributed manner through coincidental activation of cortico-striatal neuronal populations.550Casasanto & Boroditsky2008Cognition!Spatial information affects judgments about duration but not vice versa.442Wittmann et al.2006Chronobiol IntSocial jetlag, i.e. the discrepancy between social and biological timing affects wellbeing and stimulant consumption.417Grahn et al.2007J Cogn NeurosciBasal ganglia and Supplementary Motor Areas mediate beat perception, in addition to motor production.310*Grondin2010Att Percept PsychophysReview of recent behavioral and neuroscientific studies of timing.305Karmarkar & Buonomano2007NeuronCortical networks can read out time as a result of intrinsic network dynamics294*Ivry & Schlerf 2008Trends Cogn SciDedicated models of timing are preferred over intrinsic models.292Shuler & Bear2006SciencePrimary sensory cortex, like V1, mediates reward-timing activity.289*Coull et al2011NeuropsychopharmacologyReview of neuroimaging, neuropsychological and psychopharmacological aspects of timing.276Morrone et al.2005Nat NeurosciShort intervals of time between two successive perisaccadic visual stimuli (but not auditory) are underestimated. Page
11
of
23
274Chen et al.2008Cereb CortexPassively listening to rhythms recruits motor regions of the brain.265*Droit-Volet & Meck2007Trends Cogn SciReview of how emotional arousal and valence modulates attentional time-sharing and clock speed.261Patel et al.2009Curr BiolSnowball, a cuckatoo, can spontaneously synchronize its movements to a musical beat.253*Wittman & Paulus2008Trends Cogn SciReview of how impulsivity affects perception of time and decision making.237Winkler et al.2009Proc Natl Acad SciNewborn infants show beat perception.228MacDonald et al.2011NeuronHippocampal time cells encode successive moments during a sequence of events.222*Meck2005Brain & Cognition!Review of timing that suggests a distributed representation of time across multiple neural systems.220*Meck et al.2008Curr Opin NeurobiolReview that proposes striatum serves as a core timer, as part of a distributed timing system.219*Wiener et al.2010NeuroImage!Meta analysis that suggests distinct for perceptual vs. motor timing; SMA and right IFG are most commonly activated in various timing tasks.212*Coull & Nobre2008Curr Opin NeurobiolReview that suggests basal ganglia is key for explicit timing while parietal and premotor areas mediate implicit timing.210*Nobre et al.2007Curr Opin NeurobiolReview that describes how temporal expectations modulate perception and action, and the underlying neural mechanisms.193Patel et al.2005Brain ResBeat perception and synchronization show modality specific benefits for auditory vs. visual beat patterns.No. of citationsReferenceYearJournalSummary Page
12
of
23
192Chen et al.2008J Cogn NeurosciMusicians show greater prefrontal cortex activity vs. non-musicians while tapping to complex auditory rhythms.177Grahn & Rowe2009J NeurosciPutamen, SMA and premotor cortex are important for internal generation of the beat and auditory motor coupling during beat perception.177*Lewis & Miall2006Trends Cogn SciDorsolateral prefrontal cortex mediates working memory as well as timing.175Meck2006Brain ResDopamine depleting lesions in different parts of the basal ganglia shows dissociable effects on duration discrimination.173Noesselt et al.2007J NeurosciTemporal correspondence between auditory and visual streams modulates activity of multisensory STS as well as unisensory cortices.170Arvaniti2009PhoneticaReview of work on rhythmic categorization which argues that timing is distinct from rhythm.168Wittmann et al.2007Exp Brain ResPosterior insula mediates delayed gratification of reward while striatum encodes time delay.165*Kotz & Schwartze2010Trends Cogn SciReview which suggests that temporal and speech processing is processed by cortical and subcortical systems associated with motor control. 162Burr et al.2007Nat NeurosciShort visual events are encoded by visual neural mechanisms with localized receptive fields rather than by a centralized supramodal clock.159*Vroomen & Kreetels2010Att Percept PsychophysReview that focuses on intersensory timing and mechanisms that encode intersensory lags.155*Wittmann2009Phil Trans R Soc BReview that discusses different models of time perception with a particular focus on the insula as a core timer.No. of citationsReferenceYearJournalSummary Page
13
of
23
153McAuley et al.2006J Exp Psychol: GeneralEvent timing profiles for a battery of perceptual-motor timing tasks vary across the life span (4-95 years old).152Chen et al.2006NeuroImage!Metrical structure of musical rhythms modulates functional connectivity between auditory and dorsal premotor cortex.151Boroditsky et al.2011Cognition!English and Mandarin speakers think about time differently.150*Taatgen et al.2007Psychol RevA time perception model based on adaptive control of thought-rational can explain effects of attention and learning during time estimation.150*Correa et al.2006Brain ResReview that focuses on how temporal attention modulates the amplitude and latency of ERPs like N2 and P300 components.144Matlock et al.2005Cogn SciFictive motion influences temporal reasoning.136*Allman & Meck2012Brain!Review that focuses on distortions of time perception and timed performance in various neurological and psychiatric conditions.135*Block et al.2010Acta PsycholMeta analysis that focuses on the effects of cognitive load on prospective and retrospective duration judgments.135Kotz et al.2009CortexReview that focuses on the non-motor functions of basal ganglia with particular emphasis on prediction in speech and language.134Teki et al.2011J NeurosciPerception of relative and absolute time is mediated by distinct networks based in the basal ganglia and the cerebellum respectively.134Lewis & Miall2006Behav ProcDorsolateral prefrontal cortex mediates working memory and posterior parietal cortex and anterior cingulate attentional aspects of timing.No. of citationsReferenceYearJournalSummary Page
14
of
23
130*Rubia et al.2009Phil Trans R Soc BReview that suggests that impulsivity in ADHD is related to compromised timing functions and dopamine dysregulation.130Styns et al.2007Hum Mov SciWalking speed is modulated by the tempo of musical and metronome stimuli.128Kanai et al.2006J VisTemporal frequency of a stimulus serves as the clock for perceived duration.125Noulhiane et al.2007EmotionEmotional stimuli are judged longer than neutral stimuli, when balanced for the levels of arousal.124Fuhrman & Boroditsky2010Cogn SciTemporal judgments in nonlinguistic tasks are influenced by culturally specific spatial representations.122Grahn & Brett2009CortexParkinson’s patients show selective deficits in discrimination of beat-based rhythms.122*Eagleman et al.2005J NeurosciReview of timing based on psychophysics, electrophysiology, imaging and computational modeling.120Keller et al.2007Consc & CognAction simulation in ensemble musicians like pianists underlies synchronization and self-recognition.120Correa et al.2005Psychon Bull & RevTemporal orienting enhances perceptual processing.118*Merchant et al.2013Ann Rev NeurosciReview that highlights the role of a core timing mechanism in the basal ganglia and its interaction with context dependent areas.113Grahn & McAuley2009NeuroImage!Individual differences in beat perception exist and modulate activity in auditory and motor areas.110Zarco et al.2009J NeurophysPerformance of rhesus monkeys and humans is compared on a number of sub-second interval reproduction tasks.No. of citationsReferenceYearJournalSummary !!!!!!!!!!!!
Page
15
of
23
109Wearden et al.2008Q J Exp PsycholDecreasing arousal affects performance on time perception tasks.108Vatakis & Spence2006Brain ResCross-modal temporal discrimination performance is better for audiovisual stimuli of lower complexity.107Nozaradan et al.2011J NeurosciEEG frequency tagging reveals neural entrainment to beat and meter.107Wassenhove et al.2008PLoS OneMultisensory interactions influence perception of time: vision can impact auditory temporal perception.107Ishihara et al.2008CortexA mental time line exists from left to right along the horizontal axis in space.105*Keller2008Emerg CommReview that addresses cognitive processes underlying joint action in music performance.102Casasanto et al.2010Cogn SciSpatial information influences temporal judgments more than time affects spatial judgments in children as well as adults.101Iversen et al.2009Ann NY Acad SciBeta-band activity influences auditory rhythm perception.100*Droit-Volet & Gil2009Phil Trans R Soc BReview that addresses the role of emotional context on timing.100Jahanshahi et al.2006J NeurosciBasal ganglia and cerebellum are involved in reproduction of both short and long intervals.No. of citationsReferenceYearJournalSummary References!
!
1.! Allman MJ, Meck WH: Pathophysiological distortions in time perception and
5.! Block RA, Hancock PA, Zakay D: How cognitive load affects duration judgments:
timed performance. Brain 2012, 135:656–677.!
2.! Arvaniti A: Rhythm, timing and the timing of rhythm. Phonetica 2009, 66:46–63.!
3.! Bartolo R, Merchant H: β oscillations are linked to the initiation of sensory-cued
movement sequences and the internal guidance of regular tapping in the
monkey. J. Neurosci. 2015, 35:4635–4640.!
4.! Bartolo R, Prado L, Merchant H: Information processing in the primate basal
ganglia during sensory-guided and internally driven rhythmic tapping. J.
Neurosci. 2014, 34:3910–3923.!
A meta-analytic review. Acta Psychol. 2010, 134: 330-343.!
think about time differently? Cognition 2011, 118:123–129.!
of interval timing. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 2005, 6:755–765.!
spatially selective in real-world coordinates. Nat. Neurosci. 2007, 10:423–425.!
Cognition 2008, 106:579–593.!
6.! Boroditsky L, Fuhrman O, McCormick K: Do English and Mandarin speakers
7.! Buhusi CV, Meck WH: What makes us tick? Functional and neural mechanisms
8.! Burr D, Tozzi A, Morrone MC: Neural mechanisms for timing visual events are
9.! Casasanto D, Boroditsky L: Time in the mind: Using space to think about time.
10.!Casasanto D, Fotakopoulou O, Boroditsky L: Space and Time in the Child’s
Mind: Evidence for a Cross-Dimensional Asymmetry. Cognitive Science 2010,
34:387–405.!
Page
16
of
23
11.!Chen CH, Fremont R, Arteaga-Bracho EE, Khodakhah K: Short latency
cerebellar modulation of the basal ganglia. Nat. Neurosci. 2014, 17:1767–1775.!
12.!Chen JL, Penhune VB, Zatorre RJ: Listening to musical rhythms recruits motor
regions of the brain. Cereb. Cortex 2008, 18:2844–2854.!
13.!Chen JL, Penhune VB, Zatorre RJ: Moving on time: brain network for auditory-
motor synchronization is modulated by rhythm complexity and musical training. J
Cogn Neurosci 2008, 20:226–239.!
14.!Chen JL, Zatorre RJ, Penhune VB: Interactions between auditory and dorsal
premotor cortex during synchronization to musical rhythms. Neuroimage 2006,
32:1771–1781.!
15.!Correa Á, Lupiáñez J, Madrid E, Tudela P: Temporal attention enhances early
visual processing: A review and new evidence from event-related potentials.
Brain research 2006, 1076:116–128.!
16.!Correa Á, Lupiáñez J, Tudela P: Attentional preparation based on temporal
expectancy modulates processing at the perceptual level. Psychonomic Bulletin
& Review 2005, 12:328–334.!
17.!Coull J, Nobre A: Dissociating explicit timing from temporal expectation with
fMRI. Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 2008, 18:137–144.!
18.!Coull JT, Cheng R-K, Meck WH: Neuroanatomical and neurochemical substrates
of timing. Neuropsychopharmacology 2011, 36:3–25.!
19.!Droit-Volet S, Meck WH: How emotions colour our perception of time. Trends
Cogn. Sci. (Regul. Ed.) 2007, 11:504–513.!
20.!Eagleman DM, Tse PU, Buonomano D, Janssen P, Nobre AC, Holcombe AO:
Time and the brain: how subjective time relates to neural time. J. Neurosci. 2005,
25:10369–10371.!
Page
17
of
23
21.!Fuhrman O, Boroditsky L: Cross-cultural differences in mental representations of
time: evidence from an implicit nonlinguistic task. Cogn Sci 2010, 34:1430–1451.!
22.!Grahn JA, Brett M: Impairment of beat-based rhythm discrimination in
Parkinson’s disease. Cortex 2009, 45:54–61.!
23.!Grahn JA, Brett M: Rhythm and beat perception in motor areas of the brain. J
Cogn Neurosci 2007, 19:893–906.!
24.!Grahn JA, Rowe JB: Feeling the beat: premotor and striatal interactions in
musicians and nonmusicians during beat perception. J. Neurosci. 2009,
29:7540–7548.!
25.!Grahn JA: Neural mechanisms of rhythm perception: current findings and future
perspectives. Top Cogn Sci 2012, 4:585–606.!
26.!Grondin S: Timing and time perception: a review of recent behavioral and
neuroscience findings and theoretical directions. Atten Percept Psychophys
2010, 72:561–582.!
27.!Grosenick L, Marshel JH, Deisseroth K: Closed-loop and activity-guided
optogenetic control. Neuron 2015, 86:106–139.!
28.!Hayashi MJ, Ditye T, Harada T, Hashiguchi M, Sadato N, Carlson S, Walsh V,
Kanai R: Time Adaptation Shows Duration Selectivity in the Human Parietal
Cortex. PLoS Biol. 2015, 13:e1002262.!
29.!Ishihara M, Keller PE, Rossetti Y, Prinz W: Horizontal spatial representations of
time: evidence for the STEARC effect. Cortex 2008, 44:454–461.!
30.!Iversen JR, Repp BH, Patel AD: Top-down control of rhythm perception
modulates early auditory responses. Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 2009, 1169:58–73.!
31.!Ivry RB, Schlerf JE: Dedicated and intrinsic models of time perception. Trends
Cogn. Sci. (Regul. Ed.) 2008, 12:273–280.!
Page
18
of
23
32.!Jahanshahi M, Jones CR, Dirnberger G, Frith CD: The substantia nigra pars
compacta and temporal processing. The Journal of neuroscience 2006,
26:12266–12273.!
33.!Kanai R, Paffen CLE, Hogendoorn H, Verstraten FAJ: Time dilation in dynamic
visual display. J Vis 2006, 6:1421–1430.!
34.!Karmarkar UR, Buonomano DV: Timing in the absence of clocks: encoding time
in neural network states. Neuron 2007, 53:427–438.!
35.!Keller PE, Knoblich G, Repp BH: Pianists duet better when they play with
themselves: on the possible role of action simulation in synchronization.
Conscious Cogn 2007, 16:102–111.!
36.!Keller PE: Joint Action in Music Performance. Emerging Communication: Studies
in New Technologies and Practices in Communication 2008, 14: 205-221. IOS
Press Ebooks Volume 10: Enacting Intersubjectivity!
37.!Kornysheva K, Diedrichsen J: Human premotor areas parse sequences into their
spatial and temporal features. Elife 2014, 3:e03043.!
38.!Kotz SA, Schwartze M, Schmidt-Kassow M: Non-motor basal ganglia functions: a
review and proposal for a model of sensory predictability in auditory language
perception. Cortex 2009, 45:982–990.!
39.!Kotz SA, Schwartze M: Cortical speech processing unplugged: A timely
subcortico-cortical framework. Trends in Cognitive Science 2010, 14:392–399.!
40.!Lewis PA, Miall RC: A right hemispheric prefrontal system for cognitive time
measurement. Behavioural Processes 2006, 71:226–234.!
41.!Lewis PA, Miall RC: Remembering the time: a continuous clock. Trends in
cognitive sciences 2006, 10:401–406.!
Page
19
of
23
42.!Liu C-H, Coleman JE, Davoudi H, Zhang K, Hussain Shuler MG: Selective
activation of a putative reinforcement signal conditions cued interval timing in
primary visual cortex. Curr. Biol. 2015, 25:1551–1561.!
43.!MacDonald CJ, Lepage KQ, Eden UT, Eichenbaum H: Hippocampal “time cells”
bridge the gap in memory for discontiguous events. Neuron 2011, 71:737–749.!
44.!Matlock T, Ramscar M, Boroditsky L: On the experiential link between spatial and
temporal language. Cognitive science 2005, 29:655–664.!
45.!McAuley JD, Jones MR, Holub S, Johnston HM, Miller NS: The time of our lives:
life span development of timing and event tracking. Journal of Experimental
Psychology: General 2006, 135:348.!
46.!Meck WH, Penney TB, Pouthas V: Cortico-striatal representation of time in
animals and humans. Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 2008, 18:145–152.!
47.!Meck WH: Neuroanatomical localization of an internal clock: a functional link
between mesolimbic, nigrostriatal, and mesocortical dopaminergic systems.
Brain Res. 2006, 1109:93–107.!
48.!Meck WH: Neuropsychology of timing and time perception. Brain Cogn 2005,
58:1–8.!
49.!Mello GBM, Soares S, Paton JJ: A scalable population code for time in the
striatum. Curr. Biol. 2015, 25:1113–1122.!
50.!Merchant H, Harrington DL, Meck WH: Neural basis of the perception and
estimation of time. Annu. Rev. Neurosci. 2013, 36:313–336.!
51.!Merchant H, Pérez O, Zarco W, Gámez J: Interval tuning in the primate medial
premotor cortex as a general timing mechanism. J. Neurosci. 2013, 33:9082–
9096.!
Page
20
of
23
52.!Merchant H, Zarco W, Pérez O, Prado L, Bartolo R: Measuring time with different
neural chronometers during a synchronization-continuation task. Proc. Natl.
Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 2011, 108:19784–19789.!
53.!Morrone MC, Ross J, Burr D: Saccadic eye movements cause compression of
time as well as space. Nat. Neurosci. 2005, 8:950–954.!
54.!Namboodiri VMK, Huertas MA, Monk KJ, Shouval HZ, Hussain Shuler MG:
Visually cued action timing in the primary visual cortex. Neuron 2015, 86:319–
330.!
55.!Nobre AC, Correa A, Coull JT: The hazards of time. Current opinion in
neurobiology 2007, 17:465–470.!
56.!Noesselt T, Rieger JW, Schoenfeld MA, Kanowski M, Hinrichs H, Heinze H-J,
Driver J: Audiovisual temporal correspondence modulates human multisensory
superior temporal sulcus plus primary sensory cortices. J. Neurosci. 2007,
27:11431–11441.!
57.!Noulhiane M, Mella N, Samson S, Ragot R, Pouthas V: How emotional auditory
stimuli modulate time perception. Emotion 2007, 7:697–704.!
58.!Nozaradan S, Peretz I, Missal M, Mouraux A: Tagging the neuronal entrainment
to beat and meter. J. Neurosci. 2011, 31:10234–10240.!
59.!Patel AD, Iversen JR, Bregman MR, Schulz I: Experimental evidence for
synchronization to a musical beat in a nonhuman animal. Curr. Biol. 2009,
19:827–830.!
60.!Patel AD, Iversen JR, Chen Y, Repp BH: The influence of metricality and modality
on synchronization with a beat. Exp Brain Res 2005, 163:226–238.!
61.!Rubia K, Halari R, Christakou A, Taylor E: Impulsiveness as a timing disturbance:
neurocognitive abnormalities in attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder during
Page
21
of
23
temporal processes and normalization with methylphenidate. Philos. Trans. R.
Soc. Lond., B, Biol. Sci. 2009, 364:1919–1931.!
62.!Schneider BA, Ghose GM: Temporal production signals in parietal cortex. PLoS
Biol. 2012, 10:e1001413.!
63.!Shuler MG, Bear MF: Reward timing in the primary visual cortex. Science 2006,
311:1606–1609.!
64.!Styns F, van Noorden L, Moelants D, Leman M: Walking on music. Hum Mov Sci
2007, 26:769–785.!
65.!Taatgen NA, van Rijn H, Anderson J: An integrated theory of prospective time
interval estimation: the role of cognition, attention, and learning. Psychol Rev
2007, 114:577–598.!
66.!Teki S, Grube M, Griffiths TD: A unified model of time perception accounts for
duration-based and beat-based timing mechanisms. Front Integr Neurosci 2011,
5:90.!
67.!Teki S, Grube M, Kumar S, Griffiths TD: Distinct neural substrates of duration-
based and beat-based auditory timing. J. Neurosci. 2011, 31:3805–3812.!
68.!Vatakis A, Spence C: Audiovisual synchrony perception for music, speech, and
object actions. Brain Res. 2006, 1111:134–142.!
69.!Vroomen J, Keetels M: Perception of intersensory synchrony: a tutorial review.
Attention, Perception, & Psychophysics 2010, 72:871–884.!
70.!Wearden JH, Norton R, Martin S, Montford-Bebb O: Internal clock processes and
the filled-duration illusion. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human
Perception and Performance 2007, 33:716.!
71.!Wiener M, Turkeltaub P, Coslett HB: The image of time: a voxel-wise meta-
analysis. Neuroimage 2010, 49:1728–1740.!
Page
22
of
23
72.!Winkler I, Háden GP, Ladinig O, Sziller I, Honing H: Newborn infants detect the
beat in music. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 2009, 106:2468–2471.!
73.!Wittmann M, Dinich J, Merrow M, Roenneberg T: Social jetlag: misalignment of
biological and social time. Chronobiol. Int. 2006, 23:497–509.!
74.!Wittmann M, Leland DS, Paulus MP: Time and decision making: differential
contribution of the posterior insular cortex and the striatum during a delay
discounting task. Exp Brain Res 2007, 179:643–653.!
75.!Wittmann M, Paulus MP: Decision making, impulsivity and time perception.
Trends Cogn. Sci. (Regul. Ed.) 2008, 12:7–12.!
76.!Wittmann M: The inner experience of time. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond., B, Biol.
Sci. 2009, 364:1955–1967.!
77.!Zarco W, Merchant H, Prado L, Mendez JC: Subsecond timing in primates:
comparison of interval production between human subjects and rhesus monkeys.
J. Neurophysiol. 2009, 102:3191–3202.!
!!
Page
23
of
23
|
1712.04602 | 2 | 1712 | 2018-05-15T21:07:55 | On the organization of grid and place cells: Neural de-noising via subspace learning | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cs.IT",
"cs.LG",
"cs.NE",
"cs.IT"
] | Place cells in the hippocampus are active when an animal visits a certain location (referred to as a place field) within an environment. Grid cells in the medial entorhinal cortex (MEC) respond at multiple locations, with firing fields that form a periodic and hexagonal tiling of the environment. The joint activity of grid and place cell populations, as a function of location, forms a neural code for space. An ensemble of codes is generated by varying grid and place cell population parameters. For each code in this ensemble, codewords are generated by stimulating a network with a discrete set of locations. In this manuscript, we develop an understanding of the relationships between coding theoretic properties of these combined populations and code construction parameters. These relationships are revisited by measuring the performances of biologically realizable algorithms implemented by networks of place and grid cell populations, as well as constraint neurons, which perform de-noising operations. Objectives of this work include the investigation of coding theoretic limitations of the mammalian neural code for location and how communication between grid and place cell networks may improve the accuracy of each population's representation. Simulations demonstrate that de-noising mechanisms analyzed here can significantly improve fidelity of this neural representation of space. Further, patterns observed in connectivity of each population of simulated cells suggest that inter-hippocampal-medial-entorhinal-cortical connectivity decreases downward along the dorsoventral axis. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
On the organization of grid and place cells: Neural de-noising via
subspace learning
David M. Schwartz∗1 and O. Ozan Koyluoglu†2
1Dept. of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Arizona
2Dept. of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, University of California, Berkeley
Abstract
Place cells in the hippocampus are active when an animal visits a certain location (referred
to as a place field) within an environment. Grid cells in the medial entorhinal cortex (MEC)
respond at multiple locations, with firing fields that form a periodic and hexagonal tiling of the
environment. The joint activity of grid and place cell populations, as a function of location,
forms a neural code for space. An ensemble of codes is generated by varying grid and place cell
population parameters. For each code in this ensemble, codewords are generated by stimulating
a network with a discrete set of locations. In this manuscript, we develop an understanding of
the relationships between coding theoretic properties of these combined populations and code
construction parameters. These relationships are revisited by measuring the performances of
biologically realizable algorithms implemented by networks of place and grid cell populations, as
well as constraint neurons, which perform de-noising operations. Objectives of this work include
the investigation of coding theoretic limitations of the mammalian neural code for location and
how communication between grid and place cell networks may improve the accuracy of each
population's representation. Simulations demonstrate that de-noising mechanisms analyzed
here can significantly improve fidelity of this neural representation of space. Further, patterns
observed in connectivity of each population of simulated cells suggest that inter-hippocampal-
medial-entorhinal-cortical connectivity decreases downward along the dorsoventral axis.
1 Introduction
Place cells are a classs of spatially modulated neuron with an approximately bivariate Gaussian
tuning curve centered on a particular location in the environment, and have been identified in
the hippocampus [1–3]. Grid cells are spatially modulated neurons with firing fields that form a
periodic and hexagonal tiling of the environment, and are found in the Entorhinal Cortex (EC) of
rats, mice, bats, and humans [4–8]. Grid cells are clustered in discrete modules wherein cells share
grid scale [9]. Anatomically, both cell types share a dorsoventral organization, with cells possessing
∗[email protected]
†[email protected]
1
wider receptive fields distributed towards the ventral end [9, 10]. It is known that the rat grid cell
network requires communication from the hippocampus to maintain grid-like activity [11], and that
a significant improvement in accuracy of the rodent place cell representation is tightly correlated
with the emergence of the grid cell network [12]. However, the mechanisms by which these networks
communicate and how each may bolster the other's accuracy are unknown. Objectives of this work
include the investigation of coding theoretic limitations of the mammalian neural code for location
and how communication between grid and place cell networks may improve the accuracy of each
population's representation.
Associative memories are a class of biologically implementable content addressable memory
consisting of networks of neurons, a learning rule, and in some instances, a separate recall process
[13, 14]. This means that they can be exploited to stabilize the states of their constituent neurons
to match a previously memorized network state if enough of the network already lies in this state.
2 log n bits, for a
network of n binary neurons [15] . However, recent advances by Salavati et al. take advantage of
The information capacity of the simplest of these constructions is quite limited:
n
sparse neural coding and non-binary neurons to design an associative memory with information
storage capacity exponential in the number of neurons [16]. Sparse connectivity confers the memory
network with other performance improvements: infrequent spiking implies reduced energy costs and
faster convergence to a stable state.
In communications, this principle is leveraged by low density parity check codes (LDPC), a
class of linear block code whose power (in coding and decoding complexity) depends on sparsity
of the code's parity check matrix. Commonly, de-noising a LDPC code involves iteratively passing
messages along edges of a bipartite graph consisting of a collection of nodes that stores and updates
an estimate of the originally transmitted word connected to a collection of nodes that computes
the code's parity check equations [17,18]. Recent developments in the intersection of coding theory
and machine learning demonstrate that neural networks can learn an approximation of a LDPC
code's parity structure, and by executing message passing algorithms recover memorized patterns
in the presence of noise [16].
Grid cell population activity forms a dense modulo code, in which (in the absence of noise) in-
formation about position at any grid scale may be present in the activity of each module [19]. Place
cell activity forms a relatively sparse code (for enough cells, and a sufficiently large environment),
thus combining populations of grid and place cells realizes codes that are sparser than the grid cell
component of the code.
Nature provides myriad circumstances in which many neural computations (e.g. object recog-
nition, acoustic source localization, and self localization) must be executed robustly in the presence
of neural noise if the organism is to survive. We propose a de-noising mechanism for populations
of grid and place cells, in the form of the associative memories described in [16], [20], and [21],
which takes advantage of coding theoretic properties of these populations to eliminate the negative
impacts of noise. In particular, we propose a de-noising algorithm that relies on the biological or-
ganization of grid cells into discrete modules, and observe that after learning, average connectivity
between place cells and grid modules decreases with increasing place cell size for each module.
2
Redundancy in receptive field (RF) population codes is known to confer improvements in decod-
ing accuracy when a small tolerance to error is introduced (expressed in this case, in the stimulus
space to which we decode) [22]. We believe we are the first to investigate coding theoretic impacts
of redundancy in grid cell populations. We investigate the impact of this redundancy on decoding
accuracy by comparing de-noising and decoding performance across codes of varying redundancies.
We demonstrate that a maximum likelihood (ML) estimator reliably decodes position from popu-
lation activity with small position estimation error in the presence of bounded noise. Overall, our
work shows that the biological organization of grid cells into modules may be necessary for optimal
estimation of self location.
This paper is organized sectionally. In section 1 we introduce a few key concepts and present
the main results. Section 2 introduces the theoretical framework upon which our model is built, de-
scribing the code construction, de-noising network, learning algorithms, and de-noising algorithms
in sections 2.1, 2.2, 2.3, and 2.4, respectively. Section 3.1 presents results of all coding theoretic
analysis and experimentation. Section 3.2 annotates results of the aforementioned learning algo-
rithms. Section 3.3 describes outcomes of performance tests of the de-noising algorithms. Section 4,
consists of discussion of these results, their implications, limitations, and a physiologically testable
hypothesis they inform.
2 Theoretical framework
2.1 A hybrid code
We consider a population of place and grid cells, a total of N neurons. There are M grid cell
modules, each module, m, containing Jm neurons, and P place cells. Throughout this manuscript,
we use J to refer to the number of grid cells in module 1, which - if grid cells are allocated to
modules non-uniformly - is not equal to each other module's Ji. The firing rate of each grid cell is
denoted as gm,j, for m ∈ {1,··· , M} and j ∈ {1,··· , Jm}. Place cells' firing rates are denoted as
pi, for i ∈ {1, . . . , P}. The activity of this population, as a function of location (cid:96), is represented by
Jk + j, i ≤ M(cid:80)
Jm
m=1
m−1(cid:80)
M(cid:80)
k=1
m=1
i =
i >
Jm
xi((cid:96)) =
pi−M J ((cid:96)),
gm,j((cid:96)),
(cid:34) 3(cid:88)
(cid:18) 4
cos
k=1
where the location dependent mean firing rates of the grid cells, gm,j((cid:96)), are given by the following
two-dimensional distributions resembling von Mises density functions,
(cid:19)
(cid:35)
gm,j(s) =
fmax
Z
exp
√
3
λm
u(θk − θm,j
· (s − cm,j) +
) − 1
3
2
,
(1)
where u(θk − θm,j) is a unit vector in the direction of θk − θm,j, s ∈ [0, L] × [0, L] is the position
stimulus, cm,j, θm,j, and λm are the grid cell's spatial phase offset, orientation offset, and scaling
ratio. Grid cell orientations were taken to be ideal values about which the measurements presented
in [9] appear to fluctuate. More precisely, we choose θk ∈ {−60◦, 0◦, 60◦}. A scaling ratio of λ
3
defines the scale of module m as λm = λ1(λ)m−1. Z is a normalizing constant (≈ 2.857399), and
fmax is the grid cell's maximum firing rate. In two dimensions, place cells have bivariate Gaussian
tuning curves, with mean ξ ∈ [0, L] × [0, L], correlation, ρ ∈ [− 1
2 ] (chosen uniformly randomly),
(cid:1), where σ1 and σ2 are chosen independently and uniformly randomly
2 , 1
and covariance(cid:0) σ2
1
ρσ1σ2
σ2
2
ρσ1σ2
from [0.9λ1, 1.1λM ]. We require that σ1 and σ2 depend on λ1 so that both grid and place cell
receptive fields lie in similar spatial scales.
Figure 1: Concatenation of activities of grid and place cells (shown with typical idealized model
receptive fields) to form the hybrid code
A hybrid codebook: C codewords, of length N = P +
M(cid:80)
Jm, are generated by choosing
locations, l, from the vertices of a square lattice imposed on the plane, with unit area equal to
(∆L)2, and total area equal to L2. C is assembled by placing these codewords in its rows, and
represents the states of the grid and place cells when stimulated with these positions.
m=1
2.2 De-noising network
Two high-capacity associative memory designs are considered to test the hybrid code's resilience
to noise. In each case, the memory network is a bipartite graph consisting of N pattern neurons
(i.e., grid and place cells) and ni constraint neurons.
neurons are connected to a random set of pattern neurons.
In the un-clustered design, all constraint
In the clustered configuration, the
constraint neurons were split into M distinct clusters of n constraint neurons per cluster, with
each cluster connected to a distinct grid module. Each cluster's constraint neurons were connected
randomly to pattern neurons, chosen from a set consisting of every grid cell in the corresponding
module, and every place cell.
4
module m=1module m=Mg1,1g1,J1g2,1gM,1gM,JMp1pPdorsalventralg2,J2position (cm)firing rateposition (cm)firing rateposition (cm)firing rate (a)
(b)
Figure 2: (a) Structure of an un-clustered de-noising network - considered as a baseline for compar-
ison to the neurophysiologically inspired systematic clustering scheme (b) Structure of a systemat-
ically clustered de-noising network in which clusters of constraint neurons connect to all place cells
but only to the corresponding module of grid cells.
We also consider a foil to this systematic clustering scheme organized by grid modules: Grid and
place cells are randomly assigned to clusters. Figures 2a and 2b depict the general connectivity
structure of the un-clustered and clustered designs, respectively.
In both the clustered and un-
clustered configurations, a neurally plausible modified version of Oja's subspace learning rule was
applied to learn the code, i.e., a sparse connectivity matrix is found such that the weights of
connections from constraint neurons to pattern neurons lie orthogonal to the code space (i.e., the
space spanned by C) [23]. This way, constraint neuron connectivity converges to the parity structure
of the code and may be utilized in de-noising operations.
2.3 Code construction via subspace learning
Before we can use the de-noising system to correct corrupted codewords, it must learn (i.e.,
adapt its weights for) the hybrid code. This process is complete when the constraint neurons may
be read to determine if the states of the pattern neurons map to a valid codeword. Formally,
this amounts to finding a connectivity matrix, W (Wi,j is the synaptic weight between constraint
neuron i and pattern neuron j), whose rows are approximately perpendicular to the code space. A
procedure to procure such a matrix is outlined in [23], and improved in [16]. Note here that this
learning process is not a model for the development of either grid or place cells' apparent receptive
fields nor their remapping, as in [24]. These algorithms begin with a random set of vectors, and
for each, seeks a nearby vector orthogonal to C (i.e., a vector onto which each element of C has
minimal projection). We implement this in Algorithm 1 (a derivation of this algorithm can be
found in the appendix).
In the clustered design, Algorithm 1 is applied to each cluster's local
5
module m=1module m=Mg1,1g1,J1gM,1gM,JMp1pPp2g1,2gM,2cnccnc-1c1module m=1module m=Mg1,1g1,J1gM,1gM,JMp1pPp2c1,1c1,ncM,1cM,ng1,2gM,2 connectivity matrix. Note that here, all arithmetic on the synaptic weights, Wi,j is performed in R,
while arithmetic on states of neurons (i.e., their firing rates), is quantized to the nearest integer in
[0, Q − 1]. The maximum firing rate, fmax = Q − 1, is identical for all neurons. With each update,
w ← w − αt(y(x − yw(cid:107)w(cid:107)2 ) + ηΓ(w, θ)), where θ is a sparsity threshold, η is a penalty coefficient,
y = xT w is the scalar projection of x onto w, and αt is the learning rate at iteration t. Γ is a sparsity
2),
enforcing function, approximating the gradient of a penalty function, g(w) =
m(cid:80)
tanh(σwk
which, for appropriate choices of σ, penalizes non-sparse solutions early in the learning procedure
k=1
[16].
Algorithm 1 Neural Learning
Input: set of C patterns, C, stopping point,
Output: learned weights matrix, W
1: for rows, w, of W do
for t ∈ {1, ..., Tmax} do
50+log10(t) , 0.005}
50·α0
αt ← max{
θt ← θ0
for c ∈ C do
t
if (cid:107)c(cid:107) > then
αt ← α0(cid:107)c(cid:107)2
2:
3:
4:
5:
6:
7:
8:
9:
10:
11:
12:
13:
14:
15:
16:
17:
18:
19:
20:
end if
w ← Dale(update(c, w, αt, θt, η))
end for
if (cid:107)Cw(cid:48)(cid:107) < then
break
end if
t ← t + 1
end for
for components, wi of w do
if wi ≤ then
wi ← 0
end if
end for
21: end for
As in [16], to speed up learning, we approximate Γ = ∇g with
(cid:40)
Γ(wt, θt) =
: wt ≤ θt
: otherwise
wt
0
This update rule is a an improved approximation to Oja's Hebbian learning algorithm [23], with
advantages in both biological plausibility and computational complexity. For connections of fixed
type (i.e., inhibitory vs. excitatory), Oja's rule alone is biologically dubious without the inclusion of
6
many constraint neurons to manage this change in type. Dale's Principle states that real synaptic
connections change type rarely, if ever [25]. In accordance with this principle, our update rule does
not allow weights to change sign. This is accomplished after the updated weights are determined: If
the sign has changed after applying the update, set the new weight to a value just above (resp. just
below) zero if the previous weight was positive (resp. negative). Thus, when learning is complete,
these weights will be small in magnitude and are thresholded to zero.
In Algorithm 1, line 12 terminates learning of the current weight, w, if the sum of the projections
of w on each pattern is no more than away from zero, that is, if the current weight vector is
approximately orthogonal to the code space. Lines 17-19 perform a thresholding operation that
maps to zero any weight sufficiently small in magnitude. This is primarily to suppress numerical
errors and promote consistency, as in Line 11, we use as a small positive constant. Note that since
the weights processed on each iteration are independent of those in other iterations, this algorithm
can be readily parallelized so that each constraint neuron learns its weights simultaneously.
2.4 De-noising and decoding
We implemented a Bit Flipping style neural de-noising process, which we applied to both the
clustered and un-clustered de-noising networks. For all configurations (clustered and un-clustered,
and for a fixed maximum number of de-noising iterations, the bit flipping algorithm has perform no
worse than winner-take-all. Moreover, since it requires only the additional implementation parallel
thresholding operations for each pattern neuron, a biological realization of their inclusions is no
less plausible. The goal of this algorithm is to recover the correct activity pattern, x, which has
been corrupted by noise, and as such, is currently (and errantly) represented by a noisy version,
xn = x + n, where n is this noise pattern. Since each weight vector is nearly perpendicular to
every pattern, for a matrix of weights, W , xnW (cid:48) reveals inconsistencies in xn, which the de-noising
algorithm seeks to correct in the feedback stage 1. In de-noising, feedback weights from constraint
neurons to pattern neurons are taken to be equal to the corresponding feed-forward weight (i.e.,
synaptic connectivity is symmetric). The clustered de-noising process begins with Algorithm 3, in
which each cluster attempts to detect errant pattern neurons. If no errors are detected, the process
is complete. Otherwise, algorithm 2 is invoked for each cluster that detected errant neurons.
This and other de-noising processes are discussed in greater detail in [21] and [16]. Note that
this de-noising mechanism differs from error correction methods presented in [19] and [26] in that
information contributed by place cells only reaches grid cells through constraint neurons, and place
information contributed by grid cells at module i only reaches other modules through constraint
neurons if connectivity allows.
In order to quantify the information content of the population, we estimated the location en-
coded by the population using a maximum likelihood decoder in 4 different schemes. Joint hybrid
decoding utilizes information from all cells. Grid (resp. place) only decoding utilizes information
from only grid (resp. place) cells. Grid decoding conditioned on place response performs decoding
using only information provided by the grid cells, however, the only candidate locations considered
1To see this, consider that xnW (cid:48) = (x + n)W (cid:48) = xW (cid:48) + nW (cid:48) ≈ 0 + nW (cid:48)
7
for the estimate are those that are not impossible given the place cell activity.
Algorithm 2 Modular Recall
Input: local weights for this cluster, W , maximum number of iterations, Tmax, noisy subpattern,
x, feedback threshold, φ
Output: denoised subpattern, d
1: d ← x
2: while t < Tmax do
y ← xW (cid:48)
if (cid:107)y(cid:107) < then
break;
end if
f ← y(cid:48)·W
W
m(cid:80)
i=1
for each pattern neuron,j do
if fj ≥ φ then fj = sign(xj)
else fj = 0
end if
end for
d ← d − f
13: end while
3:
4:
5:
6:
7:
8:
9:
10:
11:
12:
3:
4:
5:
6:
7:
8:
Algorithm 3 Sequential de-noising
Input: local weights, Wi, for each cluster, i ∈ {1, ..., M}, noisy pattern, xn, stopping threshold,
Output: denoised pattern, xd
1: xd ← xn
2: while t < Tmax and a cluster has an unsatisfied constraint do
for each cluster, i ∈ {1, ..., M} do
x ← subpattern corresponding to cluster i
d ← Modular Recall(x, Wi)
if dWi ≤ then
xd(cluster i's subpattern indices) ← d
end if
9:
end for
t ← t + 1
11: end while
10:
8
3 Results
3.1 Coding theoretic results
We now endeavor to disentangle the impacts of grid and place cell parameter choices on coding
theoretically relevant dependent variables, and the way that these are linked. We begin our inves-
tigation of coding theoretic properties of the hybrid code by defining two measures of redundancy
for grid cells: µp and µo. Define µp, a hybrid code's spatial phase multiplicity, as the number of
grid cells with the same phase in the same module. In [27], it is revealed that there may be a highly
ules consisting of multiple grid cells of the same phase) allows us to investigate coding theoretic
non-uniform distribution of phases among grid cells. Considering replication of grid cells (i.e. mod-
repercussions of this phenomenon. We also set µo =(cid:4) J
(cid:5), the code's orientation multiplicity (i.e.,
3
minimum number of replications of a orientation offset in the first module). These replications are
the main sources of grid cell redundancy under consideration. Inspired by [28], for each of these
λm
schemes, we consider two distributions of grid cells to modules: uniform and non-uniform. Mosheiff
et. al find in [28] that choosing Jm ∝ 1
as the
modelling the non-uniform allocation of grid cells to modules, we chose Jm =
scale of module m is defined as λm = λ1(λ)m−1. Neural recordings show that the smallest scale is
λ1 ≈ 40cm (the value used here) [9].
produces a more efficient representation of space. When
λ1(λm−1)
We construct a codebook matrix, C, by placing elements of C in its rows. We computed
∈ [0, 1] as a function of the grid scaling ratio. Normalized
normalized rank of the code, R = rank(C)
rank is an indicator of a code's density, expressed as the fraction of possible dimensions of the
N
J
(cid:106)
(cid:107)
code space occupied by a particular code. R is an important feature to consider since a code's
dimensionality determines the dimensionality of it's null space, the object that is learned by the
de-noising network. As discussed in [16], if we suppose that C ⊂ Rn, and dim(C) = k < n, then
there are n − k mutually orthogonal vectors that are also orthogonal to our code space (e.g. any
basis for the null space of the code), each representing one valid constraint equation. Thus R
provides a fundamental limit on the number of unique effective constraint nodes we the de-noising
network may learn.
The grid cell code is known to be dense [19]. This is especially pronounced when all orientations
and phases are chosen randomly (uniformly from [0, 2π] and [0, L] × [0, L] respectively), where
for all choices of other parameters, the hybrid code achieves full rank at low rate. That is to
say that the experimentally observed properties of the grid cell code described in [9] produce a
measurable decrease in R compared to typical ranks observed when orientations and phases are
chosen randomly.
When µp = 1, a hybrid code with no place cells achieves the largest normalized rank. Since
place cells communicate redundant information, their inclusion also reduces rank, which is precisely
the trend observed in Figure 3. However, this appears to reverse when µp > 1, for a sufficiently
small number of participating place cells. This occurs because rendering grid cells redundant lowers
the rank of the grid-only hybrid code. Consequently, including place cells increases rank, until the
information contributed by the place cells reaches its maximum, at which point the inclusion of
9
additional place cells only lowers rank.
In contrast to the uniformly allocated grid cells, non-
uniformity shifts the rank curve up, though the effect is less pronounced as µp increases. In all
cases, for a fixed rate, code rank has little dependence on λ. Figure 4 illustrates the influence of
µo on rank. Increasing µo decreases rank, even for less dramatic changes than those shown. This
is because increases in µo correspond to increases in N , to which R is inversely proportional. It
is this common demoninator (N ) that links the dependence on population size of both rank and
rate (R and r respectively). Interestingly, when phase redundancy (µp) is minimized, minimal rank
is achieved when µo is maximized. However when µp is maximal (i.e., µp = 5), changes in µo
have little effect on R. Error bars (measuring SEM) are included due to the stochastic nature of
instantiating certain hybrid code parameters (e.g. ξ, which is always chosen uniformly randomly
from the set of quantized locations).
Figure 3: Code rank (R) vs. number of place cells, P , for a uniform allocation of grid cells.
Increasing µp produces a code with low rank until sufficiently many place cells are included in the
code that additional place cells contribute only redundant location information. Here (and in any
other plot containing them) error bars show standard error of the mean.
10
Figure 4: Code rank (R) vs. scaling ratio (λ) for a non-uniform allocation of grid cells to modules
for r = 1, for µo ∈ {6, 10}. R is insensitive to changes in λ but strongly affected by changes
in N and µp. Nearly identical trends are also observed when grid cells are allocated to modules
uniformly. Interestingly, when phase redundancy (µp) is minimized, minimal rank is achieved when
µo is maximized. However when µp is maximal (i.e., µp = 5), changes in µo have little effect on R.
We also computed rank, R, as a function of code rate, r = C
N (number of locations represented
per neuron), measures spatial resolution, i.e., for a fixed L, a higher code rate, r, is obtained by
lowering ∆L or by decreasing N . That is, r measures efficiency of an encoding of position when
the only cost considered is the number of neurons required to encode this position. We expect
that R is a non-decreasing function of r as each is inversely proportional to N . When phases
are chosen randomly, low rank is difficult to obtain at all but the smallest of code rates tested
(r ∈ [0, 1] and µp > 1 may result in low ranks if enough place cells are included). In contrast,
Figure 5 shows that codes spanning the spectrum of normalized ranks may be instantiated over a
wide range of rates with appropriate choice of parameters. Further, this indicates that redundancy
reduces dimensionality so low ranks are achievable even at rates much greater than biologically
relevant. Later, it will be shown that this low dimensionality is important in constructing sparse and
readily de-noisable representations of space. Figure 5 demonstrates that without the redundancy
introduced by increasing µp > 1, a hybrid code that encodes in 90 neurons more than 90 locations
in a 9 m2 environment has full rank. However when µp > 1, there is a stark drop in the maximum
rank achieved. As shown, when µp > 1, one may encode orders of magnitude more locations
while maintaining low dimensionality, with relatively fewer cells. This trend is observed in each
configuration shown when sufficient replication of grid phase is ensured. Therefore both dense
and sparse hybrid codes may be instantiated by proper choice of population size and redundancy
parameters.
11
Figure 5: Code rank (R) vs. log of code rate (log10(r)) for grid cell organization choices consistent
with observations in [9] with M = 4, J = 20, P ∈ {10, 100}, µp ∈ {1, 4, 5}, and µo = 6. Without
grid cell phase redundancy, rank saturates for very small rates. In contrast, when phase redundancy
is imposed on the grid cell population, low ranks are achievable at a wide range of rates.
Figure 6: Minimum distance (d) vs. r, for grid cell organization consistent with observations in [9],
with M = 4, J = 20, and P = 10. In all cases, d decreases with increases in r and a non-uniform
allocation of grid cells across modules diminishes minimum distance.
A code's resilience to neural noise can be assessed by the minimum pairwise (euclidean) distance
between codewords, (d). Traditionally, Hamming distance is used as the operative metric for
characterizing minimum distance of a code. However, in cases when soft information is used by the
decoder, Euclidean distance can prove to be more useful. Higher d (i.e., larger distances between
codewords) corresponds a more noise tolerant neural representation of space [29]. In fact, ideally
12
all errors induced by noise with amplitude less than(cid:4) d−1
2
(cid:5) are correctable [29] [30]. We computed d
as a function of rate, r, for different grid scales (Fig. 6). For each configuration there is a trade-off
between d and r. Since rank tends to increase and saturate with rate, this is also a tradeoff between
d and R. When the rate is low, a low resolution of location is targeted: d is larger, so more eroneous
neurons may be corrected. For a fixed r, a lower rank yields a larger minimum distance, and lower
rates give more desirable tradeoffs between rank and d. Note that the code with non-uniformly
allocated grid cells has significantly smaller d for a fixed r. Thus for a fixed r (i.e., for codes of
the same rate), the code with uniformly allocated grid cells should exhibit measurably better de-
noising performance. We confirm this prediction by simulating the de-noising process and collecting
statistics presented in Figures 11 through 15. Surprisingly, for a uniform allocation of grid cells to
modules, increases in µp appear to effect small decreases in d, while when grid cells are allocated to
modules non-uniformly, increases in µp produce small but detectable increases in d. Non-uniformity
appears to shift the curve down and to the left. This is no surprise since non-uniform allocation
decreases the total number of grid cells. Increasing µp results in marginal decreases in d, though d
is less sensitive to increases in phase redundancy than decreases in population size (i.e., codeword
length).
. Thus the spatial sampling period, ∆L is inversely proportional to
√
For environments of a fixed size, x2
maxcm2, and a hybrid code with N neurons, varying code
). Since rate, r = C
N ,
r. In order to
rates implies quantizations of space with varying unit width (∆L = xmax√
C
∆L = xmax√
N r
ensure we probed reasonable code rates, we estimate the typical perceivable spatial period of a rat
(through its place cells) by considering its running speed (ranging from .1 to 100 cm
s ), and average
ISI of 150ms [31], which bounds neural sampling periods for space, implying that ∆L should lie
somewhere in [0.15, 15]cm. Code rates considered in this work assume ∆L < 15cm. To satisfy
curiosity, and probe rate dependent phenomena at even greater rates, the smallest ∆L considered
is 0.0022cm.
In order to investigate how the fundamental limits on denoisability of the code scale with
the number of pattern neurons (i.e., grid and place cells), we compute d as a function of N ,
independently varying P , M , {Ji}i∈{1,...,M}), fixing other paramters. As illustrated in Figure 7,
minimum distance increases exponentially with increases in N due to increases in number of place
cells, P and number of grid cells per module, Ji.
value cease to improve minimum distance because the spatial scale at which higher order modules
In contrast, increases of M past a critical
represent position fails to capture relevant differences in location encoded. Notably, when all other
parameters are fixed, non-uniform allocations of grid cells to modules provides a code with inferior
minimum distance. This is a direct result of the greater number of pattern neurons in the uniform
case.
13
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 7: (a) Minimum distance, d, vs. M , with J = 20, µo = 6, µp = 5, uniform and non-uniform
allocations of grid cells to modules, and no place cells. (b) d vs. J for uniform and non-uniform
allocations of grid cells to modules, and no place cells (c) d vs. P for a population of place cells
resembling those observed in experiment [12, 32, 33] with no grid cells. A more complete list of
parameters may be found in appendix 5.3
3.2 Code learning results
Typical learned connectivity matrices and their associated degree distributions are found in
Figures 8 and 9. These demonstrate that for a typical hybrid code, the clustered network has a
sparser connectivity, with less variability in its sparsity compared to the un-clustered network. This
is because clustering enforces a tighter limit on the number of pattern neurons to which an constraint
neuron may connect. We simulated an ensemble of 4 modules of 20 grid cells each, together with 20
place cells, which produced the following connectivity matrices and associated degree distributions.
Interestingly, in both cases, there are place cells (i.e., pattern neurons with index exceeding 80) that
are left unconnected to grid modules via constraint neurons. An illustration of the learned weights
matrix corresponding to a randomly clustered de-noising network was omitted, as it is sparser, but
otherwise very similar to that of the un-clustered weights image.
14
Figure 8: Image of typical synaptic weight matrices learned by two de-noising networks for a hybrid
code with M = 4, J = 20 and P = 20.
Figure 9: Degree distributions of the connectivity matrices shown in Figure 8
Figure 10 depicts the average connection strength between place cells and grid modules, where
wi,jwi,p), where
the connection strength between place cell p and grid module m is defined as 1
ni
((cid:80)
(i,j)
i indexes constraint neurons, and j indexes grid cells in module m. Note here that connectivity
does not imply direct synaptic connection, but effective connectivity through constraint neurons.
Results were obtained from configurations with M = 4, J = 20 and P = 20; place cells in legend
are ordered by increasing receptive field size; connectivities depicted are averaged over 50 networks.
Place cells are ordered by increasing size of receptive field. This trend appears for any µp > 1. In the
modularly clustered case, average connectivity (between place cells and all grid modules) appears to
decrease with increasing place cell size, as compared to a random clustering which produces nearly
the same connectivity for each place cell. This phenomenon was not observed when grid phases or
grid orientations were chosen randomly. It does not appear in the un-clustered configuration.
15
Figure 10: Average connectivities between place cells (x-axis) and grid modules for configurations
with M = 4, J = 20, and P = 20; place cell indices are ordered from smallest to largest receptive
field size; grid cell phases were uniformly distributed across the environment and grid orientations
were chosen in agreement with the data presented in [9]; connection strengths depicted are averaged
over 50 networks
3.3 De-noising and Decoding Results
To measure the denoising performance of this system, we first perturb the states (i.e., firing
rates) of the grid and place cells by incrementing or decrementing randomly and clipping to the
boundaries of [0, Q − 1]. A pattern error occurs if after de-noising, any entry of the de-noised
pattern differs from the corresponding component of the original pattern. A symbol error occurs
each time any symbol of the de-noised pattern differs from the corresponding symbol of the correct
pattern. For identical populations of grid and place cells (M = 4, J = 20, and P = 10), in pattern
error rate, the clustered network dramatically outperforms the un-clustered (when the grid cells
have sufficient redundancy), and the modular clustering scheme always outperforms the random
clustering scheme. By fixing the size of the populations we compare, we ensure no improvement in
d that results from a larger N . Figure 11 depicts pattern error rate (Ppe) for a clustered hybrid
code, with varying phase multiplicity and biologically observed orientation multiplicity. All other
configurations (that is, those configurations that did not employ clustering in de-noising, or had
randomly selected phases or randomly selected orientations) had 100 percent pattern error rate
even for a small number of initial errors. This shows that for a small number of initial errors,
the full pattern of population activity corresponding to the correct location may be recovered,
but that for many noise-induced errors, this is rarely possible. That only the modularly clustered
de-noising network is able to achieve low Ppe (and only when µp is large enough) shows that the
biological organization of grid cells into discrete modules, is important for high quality self location
in the presence of noise. Further, clustering is the only way to achieve such a small Ppe, since
no non-clustered de-noising network consistently reduces Ppe below 0.99.
It is no surprise that
for a small number of errors, the modularly clustered de-noising mechanism achieves a better Ppe
when de-noising hybrid codes with uniform allocations of grid cells to modules (as compared to
non-uniform allocations of grid cells to modules), as Figure 6 demonstrates that such codes tend
to have a larger minimum distance at any rate probed. This result also demonstrates that whether
16
or not grid cells are distributed uniformly to modules has a smaller impact on Ppe than µp.
Figure 11: Pattern error rate vs. initial number of errors for a clustered hybrid code with M = 4,
J = 20, P = 10, with deliberately chosen spatial phases and orientations (i.e. so as to mirror those
observed in [9]); all other pattern error rates tested (i.e., those with random redundancy parameters
or those with a non-clustering denoising network) have Ppe = 1 for any initial number of errors
Figure 12: Symbol error rate vs.
initial number of errors for clustered and non-clustered hybrid
codes; here, each code utilizes a uniform distribution of grid cells to modules, and deliberately
chosen spatial phases and orientations (i.e. so as to mirror those observed in [9])
Figure 12 shows symbol error rates of hybrid codes for several configurations with deliberately
chosen grid cell phases and orientations (i.e. so as to mirror those observed in [9]. This demonstrates
that generally, clustered de-noising networks do not offer improved symbol error rate, Pse, compared
to their un-clustered counterparts. However, for a small initial number of errors, when the grid
cells exhibit sufficient redundancy in their phases, a randomly clustered de-noising network is
only outperformed by a modularly clustered network. Figure 13 shows Pse for a hybrid code
with deliberately chosen phases and orientations, de-noised by a modularly clustered network.
Consistent with the observations on pattern error rate, hybrid codes with grid cells uniformly
allocated to modules achieve better Pse. This may result directly from the fact that d is larger for
such codes. On the other hand, it is possible that the smaller population sizes resulting from a non-
uniform allocation (thus allowing fewer opportunities for grid cell redundancy) are behind both the
improvement in denoising performance and the larger minimum distance. Plotted in both Figures
17
N
12 and 13 is a red, solid curve, log10( initial number of errors
). This curve is a threshold between regions
of desirable and unacceptable Pse (i.e., log10(Pse) for a network that performs no de-noising). To
see this, consider a de-noising network that does not change the initial number of errors, E. For
N , so log10(Pse) = log10(E)−log10(N ). Surprisingly, Figure 12 shows that for a
this network, Pse = E
small initial number of errors, configurations with µp = 1 have log10(Pse) above this threshold, that
is, they increase the number of symbol errors! Figure 13 shows that this observation is independent
of uniformity of the distribution of grid cells to modules.
Figure 13: Symbol error rate vs.
initial number of errors for uniform and non-uniform clustered
hybrid codes; here, each de-noising network employs the modular clustering scheme
Figure 14: MSE of decoding after de-noising for a hybrid code with M = 4, J = 20, P = 10, and
µp = 5, and deliberately chosen grid cell parameters (i.e. so as to mirror those observed in [9])
Figure 14 shows MSE of different decoding processes after de-noising for a Hybrid code with
M = 4, J = 20, P = 10, and µp = 5, for deliberately chosen grid cell parameters (i.e. so as to
mirror those observed in [9]). This plot demonstrates that an ideal observer decoder which considers
information from all cells outperforms all others for any initial number of errors. This disparity
may, in part, be accounted for by the difference between the number of grid cells and the number of
18
place cells. Figure 15 shows MSE of joint hybrid decoding after de-noising for a hybrid code with
µp = 5, for the configuration that achieved the best error correction performance in both Ppe and
Pse. This plot demonstrates that the code with grid cells distributed to modules uniformly, with a
modularly clustered de-noising network achieves the best decoding performance, outperforming its
non-uniformly distributed analogue. Since the code with a non-uniform allocation of grid cells to
modules had a smaller minimum distance (compared to the same code with a uniform allocation of
grid cells to modules), this result confirms our earlier hypothesis that codes with uniform allocations
of grid cells across modules may be de-noised more effectively. This is no surprise since in section
3.1, we demonstrated that these codes achieve larger minimum distance as a result of the inclusion
of a larger total number of grid cells. Further, this demonstrates (in a natural metric of the stimulus
space) that in the most redundant hybrid code considered, a modularly clustered de-noising network
is far superior to a randomly clustered or un-clustered one. Interestingly, for a small number of
initially eroneous pattern neurons, the loss (in MSE) due to a lack of modular clustering is much
greater than the loss due to non-uniformity, which was also observed in Figure 11.
Figure 15: MSE of ideal decoding after neural de-noising (cm2) vs. initial number of errors for a
hybrid code with µp = 5 and µo = 6.
4 Discussion
We demonstrated that both dense and sparse hybrid codes may be constructed by proper choice
of grid and place cell parameters. We also showed that in the presence of neural noise, the activity
of only those configurations with sufficient redundancy in the grid cell component of the code
19
may be consistently de-noised. It is somewhat counterintuitive that choosing µp > 1 produces a
more noise resilient code (as shown in the de-noising performance results) as codes with uniformly
allocated grid cells and largest d are those with unique spatial phases (i.e., µp = 1) (Figure 6).
This result is biologically counterintuitive as in [4] it is noted that the distribution of grid cell
phases observed in experiment did not deviate significantly from uniformity. However, in a recently
published M.S. thesis, [27], it is revealed that the distribution of spatial phase offsets of grid cells
may be significantly non-uniform. The dataset from which this conclusion is drawn is identical
to that obtained from rat 14147 in [9]. Our results imply that this observed non-uniformity in
distribution of grid cell phases provides value in de-nosiability.
Our results reveal another suprise in Figure 7, in which the gap in minimum distance achieved
between codes with uniformly and non-uniformly allocated grid cells is shown to be quite large and
grow dramatically with increases J. Additionally, this observation demonstrates that the hybrid
code for space may trade off improvements in de-noising performance (in d) for efficiency of encoding
(r) by distributing grid cells to modules non-uniformly [28].
Hybrid codes of widely varying R, d, and r may be instantiated by choosing appropriate pa-
rameters for the populations of grid and place cells, a fact that showcases the code's adaptability.
This means that the grid and place cells may be chosen for participation in neural computations,
whose performance relies on assumptions other than those presented here, which insist on a low
dimensional code space, and a sparse connectivity matrix. It is particularly difficult to characterize
the apparent tradeoff between r and d, presented in Figure 6, as it should indicate that µp has little
effect on d, a fundamental limit of the code's de-noisability. It is quite possible that the de-noising
networks presented here are incapable of achieving the codes' error correction capacity in the cases
considered here. Such a scenario would allow for other properties endowed by a larger µp to effect
the stark differences apparent de-noising efficacy of networks across codes with different values of
t =(cid:4) d−1
2
µp. Furthermore, this explanation seems likely, as traditional coding theory suggests that the max-
imum number of correctable errors in a linear block code (as a function of d) can be computed as
(cid:5) [29]. For example, in the strongest code (as measured by largest value of d in Figure 6)
achieves d ≈ 8 when r is large, so t ≈ 3. Figure 11 corroborates this in demonstrating that pattern
error rate saturates at 1 for approxmiately 4 errant pattern neurons.
We demonstrate that the chosen de-noising network architecture performs quite well for hybrid
codes that fit its assumptions regarding rank, and poorly for those that do not. Additionally,
we assessed average connectivity between place cells of varying receptive field sizes and modules
of grid cells by analyzing the learned connectivity matrix. This analysis demonstrates that our
model place cells of smaller receptive field size are more strongly connected to grid modules, and
that they are most strongly connected to grid modules of the smallest scale. Moreover, this result
presents a physiologically testable hypothesis. While difficult, two photon microscopy has been
successfully employed to accurately image the microscopic structure of nervous tissue [34]. One
way to estimate connection strength between real neurons is to count the number of boutons
expressed on the pre-synaptic neurons, assuming that weight should be proportional to this number,
though there are may be simpler ways to estimate connection strength [35]. Thus, if groups of
20
place cells connected via constraint neurons to several distinct grid modules may be identified,
this theoretical prediction - that connectivity between the hippocampus and MEC will decrease
downward along the dorsoventral axis - can be confirmed or refuted. Another interesting experiment
is made possible by recent advances in optogenetics, which enable single cell resolution of network
activity for a population of inoculated cells (e.g. a collection of grid cells, as in [36]). While
technically challenging due to the physical separation of each population in the brain, it should be
possible to image simultaneous activity of grid and place cells at high temporal precision [37]. From
these measurements, for a set of quantized locations, simultaneous firing rates may be estimated [38].
Then, the rank, rate, and minimum distance of this empirical codebook may be computed to offer
insight about limits of noise tolerance of real spatial navigation circuitry. Of particular interest is
discovering the extent to which neural noise transiently varies such attributes for grid and place
cells in real brains, and how these coding theoretic properties adapt (if at all) to changes in speed,
context, and other variables.
In Figures 11, 13, 14, and 15, we demonstrate the differences in performance of each network
structure, and of the various decoding algorithms. The universal improvements from place only
decoding to joint hybrid decoding show that highly accurate position estimation can be significantly
more difficult without both populations of cells. The discrepancy between 'grid only decoding'
and 'grid decoding conditioned on place response' shows that even utilizing place cell information
indirectly (by eliminating places deemed impossible given the state of the place cell population)
yields a sizable improvement in decoding accuracy when there are many place cells, or when place
cells are less noisy than grid cells. That the modular clustering network universally outperforms
the corresponding randomly clustered network implies that the physiological organization of grid
cells by their scale may provide a computational advantage in de-noising and decoding. This may
be because the un-clustered network is essentially a randomly clustered network that does not take
advantage of synergistic cluster computing. In any cluster, both grid cells and place cells are able
to correct each others' errant activity. However, under modular clustering, in order for a grid cell
in module i to correct the activity of a grid cell in a different module j, the activity of each neuron
in module i must be correct so that the activity of place cells (connected to both modules i and j)
will contradict and correct the erroneous activity.
It should be noted here that the de-noising constraint neurons are a hypothetical construct
and need not reside in the hippocampus or MEC in order to provide the previously described
computations. Our conception of these constraint nodes is as single units. However, these may
represent larger networks of neurons performing the identical computations. Furthermore, this work
is not intended to convince readers of the necessity or existence of these cells, only to demonstrate
tangible coding theoretic advantages conferred by constraint neuron moderated communication
between grid and place cells. Additionally, some models of development of the grid and place cell
networks demonstrate dependence between properties of each populations' apparent receptive fields
that our model is unable to capture [24]. Thus, coding theoretic results presented here are confined
to consideration of a more static code than what is often observed in recordings of real neuronal
populations. While our model is limited in the sense that neurons are defined functionally (in
21
contrast with biophysical models where behavior emerges from the time evolution of the model's
physics), the learning algorithms considered are analogous to a Hebbian plasticity and operations
required for de-noising can be feasibly implemented by networks of real neurons (if not by single
units). Hence, the results discussed here have potential implications about neural codes for other
continuously valued stimuli (e.g. pitch of an auditory signal, another variable encoded in the
mammalian hippocampus [33]).
Further development along these threads of investigation of neural codes for space include
studying coding theoretic properties of more complete navigational codes including head direction
cells, boundary vector cells, and time cells [39–41]. It would be most interesting to probe coding
and information theoretic properties of place cells that encode 3D space as demonstrated to reside
in the bat hippocampus [42]. Even with these classes of neuron, the hybrid code might be unable
to encode and de-noise path information, unless there is a higher level structure that provides the
encoded activity in the correct sequence. One strong candidate solution for this is to include so
called hippocampal time cells. Just as place cells code for distinct locations on paths through
space, time cells encode ordered moments in a temporally ordered sequence of events, precisely the
information, which, when coupled with location, allows for the encoding of paths [43].
References
[1] J. O'Keefe and J. Dostrovsky, "The hippocampus as a spatial map: Preliminary evidence from
unit activity in the freely-moving rat." Brain research, 1971.
[2] J. O'Keefe, "Place units in the hippocampus of the freely moving rat," Experimental neurology,
vol. 51, no. 1, pp. 78–109, 1976.
[3] A. D. Ekstrom, M. J. Kahana, J. B. Caplan, T. A. Fields, E. A. Isham, E. L. Newman, and
I. Fried, "Cellular networks underlying human spatial navigation," Nature, vol. 425, no. 6954,
pp. 184–188, 2003.
[4] T. Hafting, M. Fyhn, S. Molden, M.-B. Moser, and E. I. Moser, "Microstructure of a spatial
map in the entorhinal cortex," Nature, vol. 436, no. 7052, p. 801, 2005.
[5] M. Fyhn, T. Hafting, M. P. Witter, E. I. Moser, and M.-B. Moser, "Grid cells in mice,"
Hippocampus, vol. 18, no. 12, pp. 1230–1238, 2008.
[6] M. M. Yartsev, M. P. Witter, and N. Ulanovsky, "Grid cells without theta oscillations in the
entorhinal cortex of bats," Nature, vol. 479, no. 7371, pp. 103–107, 2011.
[7] C. F. Doeller, C. Barry, and N. Burgess, "Evidence for grid cells in a human memory network,"
Nature, vol. 463, no. 7281, p. 657, 2010.
[8] J. Jacobs, C. T. Weidemann, J. F. Miller, A. Solway, J. F. Burke, X.-X. Wei, N. Suthana,
M. R. Sperling, A. D. Sharan, I. Fried et al., "Direct recordings of grid-like neuronal activity
in human spatial navigation," Nature neuroscience, vol. 16, no. 9, pp. 1188–1190, 2013.
22
[9] H. Stensola, T. Stensola, T. Solstad, K. Frøland, M.-B. Moser, and E. I. Moser, "The entorhinal
grid map is discretized," Nature, vol. 492, no. 7427, pp. 72–78, 2012.
[10] B. A. Strange, M. P. Witter, E. S. Lein, and E. I. Moser, "Functional organization of the
hippocampal longitudinal axis," Nat Rev Neurosci, vol. 15, no. 10, pp. 655–669, Oct. 2014.
[Online]. Available: http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nrn3785
[11] T. Bonnevie, B. Dunn, M. Fyhn, T. Hafting, D. Derdikman, J. L. Kubie, Y. Roudi, E. I.
Moser, and M.-B. Moser, "Grid cells require excitatory drive from the hippocampus," Nature
neuroscience, vol. 16, no. 3, pp. 309–317, 2013.
[12] L. Muessig, J. Hauser, T. J. Wills, and F. Cacucci, "A developmental switch in place cell
accuracy coincides with grid cell maturation," Neuron, vol. 86, no. 5, pp. 1167–1173, 2015.
[13] J. J. Hopfield, "Neural networks and physical systems with emergent collective computational
abilities," Proceedings of the national academy of sciences, vol. 79, no. 8, pp. 2554–2558, 1982.
[14] D. J. Amit and A. Treves, "Associative memory neural network with low temporal spiking
rates," Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 86, no. 20, pp. 7871–7875, 1989.
[15] R. J. McEliece, E. C. Posner, E. R. Rodemich, and S. S. Venkatesh, "The capacity of the
hopfield associative memory," Information Theory, IEEE Transactions on, vol. 33, no. 4, pp.
461–482, 1987.
[16] A. H. Salavati, K. R. Kumar, and A. Shokrollahi, "Nonbinary associative memory with ex-
ponential pattern retrieval capacity and iterative learning," Neural Networks and Learning
Systems, IEEE Transactions on, vol. 25, no. 3, pp. 557–570, 2014.
[17] J. Chen and M. P. Fossorier, "Near optimum universal belief propagation based decoding of
low-density parity check codes," IEEE Transactions on communications, vol. 50, no. 3, pp.
406–414, 2002.
[18] D. Declercq and M. Fossorier, "Decoding algorithms for nonbinary ldpc codes over gf (q),"
IEEE Transactions on Communications, vol. 55, no. 4, pp. 633–643, 2007.
[19] I. R. Fiete, Y. Burak, and T. Brookings, "What grid cells convey about rat location," The
Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 28, no. 27, pp. 6858–6871, 2008.
[20] A. Karbasi, A. H. Salavati, A. Shokrollahi, and L. R. Varshney, "Noise facilitation in associative
memories of exponential capacity," Neural computation, 2014.
[21] A. Karbasi, A. H. Salavati, and A. Shokrollahi, "Iterative learning and denoising in convolu-
tional neural associative memories," in Proceedings of The 30th International Conference on
Machine Learning, 2013, pp. 445–453.
[22] C. Curto, V. Itskov, K. Morrison, Z. Roth, and J. L. Walker, "Combinatorial neural codes
from a mathematical coding theory perspective," Neural Computation, 2013.
23
[23] E. Oja and T. Kohonen, "The subspace learning algorithm as a formalism for pattern recog-
nition and neural networks," in Neural Networks, 1988., IEEE International Conference on.
IEEE, 1988, pp. 277–284.
[24] J. D. Monaco and L. F. Abbott, "Modular realignment of entorhinal grid cell activity as a
basis for hippocampal remapping," Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 31, no. 25, pp. 9414–9425,
2011.
[25] J. Eccles, "From electrical to chemical transmission in the central nervous system," Notes and
records of the Royal Society of London, vol. 30, no. 2, pp. 219–230, 1976.
[26] M. Stemmler, A. Mathis, and A. V. Herz, "Connecting multiple spatial scales to decode the
population activity of grid cells," Science Advances, vol. 1, no. 11, p. e1500816, 2015.
[27] D. Wennberg, "The distribution of spatial phases of grid cells," M.S. Thesis, NTNU, 2015.
[Online]. Available: http://hdl.handle.net/11250/2359808
[28] N. Mosheiff, H. Agmon, A. Moriel, and Y. Burak, "An efficient coding theory for a dynamic
trajectory predicts non-uniform allocation of entorhinal grid cells to modules," PLoS compu-
tational biology, vol. 13, no. 6, p. e1005597, 2017.
[29] S. Lin and D. Costello, Error-Correcting Codes. Prentice-Hall, Inc, 1983.
[30] S. Sreenivasan and I. Fiete, "Grid cells generate an analog error-correcting code for singularly
precise neural computation," Nature neuroscience, vol. 14, no. 10, p. 1330, 2011.
[31] A. S. Gupta, M. A. Van Der Meer, D. S. Touretzky, and A. D. Redish, "Segmentation of
spatial experience by hippocampal theta sequences," Nature neuroscience, vol. 15, no. 7, p.
1032, 2012.
[32] L. Nadel and J. O'Keefe, The hippocampus as a cognitive map. Clarendon, 1978.
[33] D. Aronov, R. Nevers, and D. W. Tank, "Mapping of a non-spatial dimension by the
hippocampal–entorhinal circuit," Nature, vol. 543, no. 7647, p. 719, 2017.
[34] K. Svoboda and R. Yasuda, "Principles of two-photon excitation microscopy and its applica-
tions to neuroscience," Neuron, vol. 50, no. 6, pp. 823–839, 2006.
[35] G.-q. Bi and M.-m. Poo, "Synaptic modifications in cultured hippocampal neurons:
Dependence on spike timing, synaptic strength, and postsynaptic cell type," Journal
of Neuroscience, vol. 18, no. 24, pp. 10 464–10 472, 1998.
[Online]. Available:
http:
//jneurosci.org/content/18/24/10464
[36] C. Sun, T. Kitamura, J. Yamamoto, J. Martin, M. Pignatelli, L. J. Kitch, M. J. Schnitzer,
and S. Tonegawa, "Distinct speed dependence of entorhinal island and ocean cells, including
respective grid cells," Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 112, no. 30, pp.
9466–9471, 2015. [Online]. Available: http://www.pnas.org/content/112/30/9466.abstract
24
[37] B. F. Grewe, D. Langer, H. Kasper, B. M. Kampa, and F. Helmchen, "High-speed in vivo
calcium imaging reveals neuronal network activity with near-millisecond precision," Nature
methods, vol. 7, no. 5, pp. 399–405, 2010.
[38] L. Theis, P. Berens, E. Froudarakis, J. Reimer, M. R. Ros´on, T. Baden, T. Euler, A. S. Tolias,
and M. Bethge, "Benchmarking spike rate inference in population calcium imaging," Neuron,
vol. 90, no. 3, pp. 471–482, 2016.
[39] C. Lever, S. Burton, A. Jeewajee, J. O'Keefe, and N. Burgess, "Boundary vector cells in the
subiculum of the hippocampal formation," The journal of neuroscience, vol. 29, no. 31, pp.
9771–9777, 2009.
[40] D. M. Salz, Z. Tiganj, S. Khasnabish, A. Kohley, D. Sheehan, M. W. Howard, and H. Eichen-
baum, "Time cells in hippocampal area ca3," Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 36, no. 28, pp.
7476–7484, 2016.
[41] J. S. Taube, R. U. Muller, and J. B. Ranck, "Head-direction cells recorded from the post-
subiculum in freely moving rats. i. description and quantitative analysis," The Journal of
neuroscience, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 420–435, 1990.
[42] M. Yartsev, N. Ulanovsky et al., "Representation of three-dimensional space in the hippocam-
pus of flying bats (vol 340, pg 367, 2013)," Science, vol. 342, no. 6158, pp. 559–559, 2013.
[43] C. J. MacDonald, K. Q. Lepage, U. T. Eden, and H. Eichenbaum, "Hippocampal "time cells"
bridge the gap in memory for discontiguous events," Neuron, vol. 71, no. 4, pp. 737–749, 2011.
[44] E. Oja and J. Karhunen, "On stochastic approximation of the eigenvectors and eigenvalues of
the expectation of a random matrix," Journal of mathematical analysis and applications, vol.
106, no. 1, pp. 69–84, 1985.
[45] L. Xu, A. Krzyzak, and E. Oja, "Neural nets for dual subspace pattern recognition method,"
International Journal of Neural Systems, vol. 2, no. 03, pp. 169–184, 1991.
5 Appendix
5.1 Subspace learning
In [44], the authors propose an algorithm that is capable of computing a basis for the null space
of a random matrix, A, which is assumed to be the expected value of sample matrices, At. The
update rule for the matrix whose columns are the resulting basis vectors is
Wt = Wt−1 + At−1Wt−1αt−1
Wt = WtR−1
t
,
25
(2)
(3)
where αt is a diagonal (and compatible) matrix of gain factors. As in [44], equations 2 and 3 may
be re-written as operations on column vectors, wt.
wt = wt−1 + αt−1At−1wt−1
wt =
wt(cid:107) wt(cid:107) ,
(4)
(5)
in which αt is the gain factor corresponding to the current column. This number may be equivalently
understood as a learning rate. Indeed in [45], the authors show that for appropriate choices of At,
the update rule is a form of anti-Hebbian learning. In [44] the authors prove convergence of this
algorithm to the eigenvectors of A corresponding to the largest eigenvalues. Further, when At is
replaced by −At, wt converges to the eigenvectors of A corresponding to the smallest eigenvalues.
In [44], it is demonstrated that by combining equations 4 and 5, expanding as a power series in αt,
and ignoring second (and higher) order terms, we arrive at
t At−1wt−1
wt = wt−1 + αt−1(At−1wt−1 − wT
t−1wt−1
wT
wt−1).
(6)
t wt = wT
t xt)Pxt = xtxT
The authors of [16] choose At = (xT
t , the product of projections onto the space
spanned by xt, and define yt = xT
t xt. In [44], it is mentioned that this update rule finds
eigenvectors corresponding to the largest eigenvalue of At, or those corresponding to the smallest
eigenvalues of −At, when this matrix is used instead. Since At is a projection matrix, it has
rank 1. Thus it has one eigenvector with non-zero eigenvalue, xt, and dim(x) − 1 eigenvectors
with eigenvalue 0. Each of these eigenvectors, v, is guaranteed to be perpendicular to x because
Atv = 0v = 0, that is, the v's projection onto x has magnitude 0. By choosing xt ∈ C, with the
aforementioned choice for At, this algorithm should compute vectors approximately perpendicular
to the code space.
Now, we may rewrite equation 6 as
wt = wt−1 − αt−1xt−1xT
t−1wt−1 + αt−1
wT
t−1xt−1xT
(cid:107)wt−1(cid:107)2
t−1wt−1
= wt−1 − αt−1yt−1xt−1 + αt−1
y2
t−1
(cid:107)wt−1(cid:107)2 wt−1.
wt−1
(7)
To obtain a sparse basis for null(C), one may add to equation 7 a regularizing term that penalizes
non-sparse solutions. In particular, using ηΓ(wt−1, θt−1), as considered in [16], to arrive at
wt = wt−1 − αt−1(yt−1(xt−1 − yt−1wt−1
(cid:107)wt−1(cid:107)2 )) − αt−1ηΓ(wt−1, θt−1).
(8)
5.2 Structure of the performance testing simulations
In order to evaluate the performance of the de-noising mechanisms proposed here, we first
generate codes from the parameters considered in appendix 5.3. Then algorithm 1 is applied
to the chosen de-noising network. After learning is complete, in sequence, C randomly chosen
codewords are corrupted and presented to the network to de-noise using algorithms 2 and 3. After
the de-noising process is complete, the de-noised pattern is assessed and performance is computed
incrementally.
26
5.3 Choices of parameters
In learning, normalized weights are initialized randomly with degree (cid:100)4 loge(n)(cid:101), where n is the
length of the weight vector. We used, θ0 = 0.031, η = 0.075, and α0 = 0.95. In de-noising, we set
φ = 0.95. Unless otherwise noted, dependent variables measured and computed are mean values
averaged over 100 networks. Error bars represent standard error of the mean.
Here we present a table of parameters indexed by figure in this manuscript. "N/A" in this
appendix is taken to mean either that this parameter was varied or was not used.
µo
6
µp
N/A
N/A N/A
N/A N/A
N/A N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
6
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
5
5
5
N/A
C10−3
C10−3
C10−3
5
N/A C10−3
N/A C10−3
N/A C10−3
C10−3
5
η
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
0.075
0.075
0.075
0.075
0.075
0.075
0.075
Figure number L (cm)
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
300
300
300
300
300
300
300
300
300
300
300
300
C
P
λ
J
20
M
4
20
4
4
1000
1000
1000 N/A N/A N/A N/A
N/A (cid:112)(2)
1000 N/A N/A N/A (cid:112)(2)
10 (cid:112)(2)
0 (cid:112)(2)
20 (cid:112)(2)
20 (cid:112)(2)
20 (cid:112)(2)
10 (cid:112)(2)
10 (cid:112)(2)
10 (cid:112)(2)
10 (cid:112)(2)
1000
106
106
106
106
106
106
106
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
λ1 (cm)
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
27
|
1707.04484 | 1 | 1707 | 2017-07-14T12:34:47 | Coexistence of critical sensitivity and subcritical specificity can yield optimal population coding | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | The vicinity of phase transitions selectively amplifies weak stimuli, yielding optimal sensitivity to distinguish external input. Along with this enhanced sensitivity, enhanced levels of fluctuations at criticality reduce the specificity of the response. Given that the specificity of the response is largely compromised when the sensitivity is maximal, the overall benefit of criticality for signal processing remains questionable. Here it is shown that this impasse can be solved by heterogeneous systems incorporating functional diversity, in which critical and subcritical components coexist. The subnetwork of critical elements has optimal sensitivity, and the subnetwork of subcritical elements has enhanced specificity. Combining segregated features extracted from the different subgroups, the resulting collective response can maximise the tradeoff between sensitivity and specificity measured by the dynamic-range-to-noise-ratio. Although numerous benefits can be observed when the entire system is critical, our results highlight that optimal performance is obtained when only a small subset of the system is at criticality. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Coexistence of critical sensitivity and subcritical specificity can yield optimal
population coding
Leonardo L. Gollo1, 2
1Systems Neuroscience Group, QIMR Berghofer Medical Research Institute, Brisbane, Australia
2The University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia
The vicinity of phase transitions selectively amplifies weak stimuli, yielding optimal sensitivity
to distinguish external input. Along with this enhanced sensitivity, enhanced levels of fluctuations
at criticality reduce the specificity of the response. Given that the specificity of the response is
largely compromised when the sensitivity is maximal, the overall benefit of criticality for signal
processing remains questionable. Here it is shown that this impasse can be solved by heterogeneous
systems incorporating functional diversity, in which critical and subcritical components coexist. The
subnetwork of critical elements has optimal sensitivity, and the subnetwork of subcritical elements
has enhanced specificity. Combining segregated features extracted from the different subgroups, the
resulting collective response can maximise the tradeoff between sensitivity and specificity measured
by the dynamic-range-to-noise-ratio. Although numerous benefits can be observed when the entire
system is critical, our results highlight that optimal performance is obtained when only a small
subset of the system is at criticality.
Keywords: diversity, heterogeneity, criticality, subcrit-
icality, complex systems, systems neuroscience.
1. Introduction
Reliable estimations of stochastic inputs is a ma-
jor challenge to many physical [1] and biological sys-
tems [2, 3]. The estimation of input intensity, for in-
stance, is fundamental for life because it constitutes the
basis of sensory detection in unicellular organisms [4],
single neurons [5], and animals [6]. A main issue of build-
ing a perceptual representation of inputs that arrive in
a stochastic fashion derives from their unpredictable na-
ture. Hence, the steady state of a discrete random (point)
process can be easily confounded with a time-dependent
one. This is also known as the gambler's fallacy [7], in
which the agent (gambler) perceives a steady process
as being time-varying (with hot and cold moments of
luck referring to periods of short and long inter-event
intervals [8]).
In this case, the perception of a steady
mean rate is replaced by erratic fluctuations of the sig-
nal around the mean rate. In particular, the larger the
amplitude of the fluctuations, the greater the challenge
is to overcome this limitation to efficiently estimate the
steady rate.
Critical states mediate phase transitions and exhibit
numerous special features that distinguish them from
other non-critical states: They have peaked correlation
length, specific heat [9], entropy [10, 11],
information
flow [12 -- 15], computation [16] and so on. An impor-
tant practical benefit is the maximal dynamic range [17],
which means that critical systems have optimal abilities
to distinguish stimulus intensity that spans several or-
ders of magnitude. Hence, systems posed at critical-
ity offer maximal sensitivity to detect changes in stim-
ulus rate [17 -- 19]. This is particularly important to psy-
chophysics in which variations of input must be detected
for a wide range of stimulus intensity [6, 17]. On the
other hand, critical systems also exhibit maximal fluc-
tuations [20, 21]. This feature strongly compromises the
system's specificity (the confidence of the estimated stim-
ulus intensity). Therefore, it is not clear whether the
overall advantage of the enhanced sensitivity can over-
come the limitations of reduced specificity.
To take advantage of optimal sensitivity, evidences sug-
gest that visual [22, 23] and auditory systems [24 -- 26]
operate at (or very near) critical states. However, it re-
mains puzzling what are the workaround strategies used
by living systems to overcome the blatant problem of re-
duced specificity that is associated with critical states.
Here we investigate sensitivity and specificity at the crit-
ical state in homogeneous and heterogeneous systems.
We show that heterogeneity in node excitability leads to
functional diversity, in which a subgroup of units at crit-
icality coexists with other subgroups of subcritical units.
This separation can simultaneously confer to networks
the benefits of maximal sensitivity of critical units and
enhanced specificity of subcritical units.
2. Methods
For concreteness we employ a general model of ex-
citable networks [17, 27, 28], adapted to incorporate
nodal heterogeneity [29]. Susceptible (quiescent) nodes
can be excited either by (global) external driving or by
(local) neighbour contributions: External inputs arrive at
a steady Poisson rate h. An input rate h indicates that at
each time step δt (=1 ms), an external input may arrive
with a probability ph = 1 − exp(−hδt). Neighbour con-
tributions may propagate from active units with a proba-
bility p. Active nodes become refractory in the next time
step, and refractory nodes become quiescent with proba-
bility q = 0.5. The system is synchronously updated and
the time step is fixed at one millisecond. Networks have
5000 nodes that are connected as a sparse Erdos-R´enyi
random network with average degree K = 50. Further-
more, diversity is introduced in the excitability threshold
θ: Nodes fire from neighbouring contributions if they re-
ceive at least θ inputs within one time step.
Homogeneous networks. We consider homogeneous
networks in which all nodes have the same excitability
threshold θ = 1. This is a simple yet very influential case
that highlights the benefit of criticality to enhance net-
work sensitivity [17]. Other homogeneous networks with
θ > 1 may also enhance network sensitivity [29] but they
come along a discontinuous phase transition and hystere-
sis, increasing the complexity of the dynamics. Hence,
here we focus on the most standard choice of θ = 1 that
gives rise to a continuous phase transition [17].
Heterogeneous networks. Node diversity is a hallmark
of the brain [30] that is associated with several benefits
to the system [31 -- 33]. For simplicity, diversity is intro-
duced as a discrete uniform distribution of the threshold
θ = 1, 2, ..., θmax. The subpopulation of most excitable
units has θ = 1 as in the previous case of homogeneous
populations, and the least excitable subpopulation has
θmax = 6. Integrator units (with θ > 1) become active
at a lower rate since they must integrate several inputs
to fire.
Response Function. The mean firing response F
across nodes and trials is a smooth sigmoidal function of
the input h that vary over orders of magnitude (Fig. 1a).
This is called a response (or transfer) function. It indi-
cates the mean output firing rate of the system for vary-
ing input rates (regularly spaced in logarithmic scale).
Response functions represent a fundamental feature of
the system under the rate-code framework [34].
Dynamic range. A key property of response functions
(shown in Fig.1a) is the dynamic range [35]. It measures
the range of stimulus intensities resulting in distinguish-
able network responses. The dynamic range quantifies
the interval of stimulus in which the network is sensi-
tive to small variations of input, and neglects regions of
saturated responses which are too close to the minimal
or maximal firing rates (saturation). Hence, dynamic
range is a measure of network sensitivity that focuses on
the range of stimuli in which changes are effectively de-
tected, and influence the firing rate. Dynamic range is
typically defined as ∆ = 10 log10(h90/h10). In this defi-
nition [17], hx ≡ F −1(Fx) corresponds to the input level
of Fx = F0 + x
100 (Fmax − F0), where Fmax(= 250 Hz) is
the maximal firing rate of the network, and F0 is the min-
imal firing rate of the network, or the firing rate in the
absence of input F (h = 0). The main elements required
to compute the dynamic range of a response function are
illustrated in Fig. 1b.
Noise. Another central feature of response functions
is the inter-trial variability, which reflects the specificity
2
of the network response (Fig. 1c). We quantify this
noise by measuring the area between plus and minus one
standard deviation of the mean of the response-function
curves. The numerical integration was computed over
the entire range of the response function using the trape-
zoidal rule.
an
Dynamic-range-to-noise-ratio. As
informative
measure of the balance between sensitivity and speci-
ficity of the network response, we focus on a simple
ratio:
the dynamic-range-to-noise-ratio (DNR). DNR
is applicable and convenient when dynamic range and
noise are greater than zero. Despite the similarity of the
DNR with the traditional signal-to-noise ratio (SNR),
there are some important differences that need to be
emphasised. The noise in our definition of DNR refers to
the inter-trial variability of the response (and not to the
error associated with the measure of the dynamic range).
In addition, in contrast to SNR, the DNR is designed to
quantify the trade-off between sensitivity and specificity
l
a
c
i
t
i
r
c
r
e
p
u
s
(a)
)
1
-
s
m
(
F
(b)
)
1
-
s
m
(
F
0.2
0.1
0
0.2
0.1
0
(c)
10 -1
)
1
-
s
m
(
F
10 -5
h 90
h 10
∆=26 dB
l
a
c
i
t
i
r
c
b
u
s
(d)
25
20
15
(e)
0.01
)
B
d
(
∆
i
e
s
o
N
0
(f)
10 4
R
N
D
10 -5
10 -1
10 -3
h (ms -1)
10 1
10 3
0
0.05
coupling
0.1
FIG. 1. Maximal sensitivity and reduced specificity occurs
at criticality in homogeneous networks (θ = 1). (a) Family
of response functions F for variable input h. From right to
left: Subcritical curves are in black (p = 0.005, 0.015), critical
curve is in red (pc = 0.02), and supercritical curves are in blue
(p = 0.0225, 0.025). Response functions represent an average
over ten trials. (b) Illustration of the dynamic range defini-
tion for the critical curve. Dashed lines indicate h10 and h90,
whereas dotted lines indicate F10 and F90. (c) Response func-
tion variability for ten independent trials at criticality. Gray
line indicates the critical exponent m = 0.5.
(d) Dynamic
range as a function of the coupling strength p. (e) Noise, de-
fined as the area between the confidence interval (standard
deviation) over the entire response function, versus p.
(f)
Dynamic-range-to-noise ratio (∆/noise) versus p.
in response to a range of stimulus intensities covered
by the response function. Moreover, since uncoupled
units (e.g., single neurons [5]) may have non-negligible
dynamic ranges, the DNR for uncoupled networks may
attain large values.
Branching ratio. A typical measure of the spreading
process in a network is the branching ratio σ. It is de-
fined as σ ≡ ρ(t+1)/ρ(t), where ρ is the fraction of active
nodes, and is computed as the geometric mean over many
initial conditions for each value of ρ. A branching ratio
σ > 1 indicates increasing levels of activity; σ < 1 in-
dicates decreasing levels of activity, and σ = 1 indicates
stable levels of activity [17].
Subnetwork perspective.
In a heterogeneous network,
the branching ratio, the firing rate, and its associated fea-
tures (dynamic range, noise, and DNR) can be computed
for each subnetwork defined by nodes that have the same
threshold. It is often convenient to analyse the network
in this detailed fashion because it clearly highlights the
different dynamic behaviour (functional diversity) of the
subpopulations.
3. Results
Sensitivity and specificity in homogeneous networks.
In a homogeneous network, nodes require only one neigh-
bouring input to activate. This homogeneous case has
been subjected to numerous studies since the seminal
work of Kinouchi and Copelli [17]. Response functions
vary depending on the coupling strength (Fig. 1a), and
strong coupling allows for self-sustained activity (F0 >
0). Because response functions saturate at a similar level
(h90, Fig. 1a), the dynamic range (illustrated in Fig.
1b) is mostly driven by the sensitivity of the system to
weak stimuli. By varying the coupling strength between
nodes p, the maximum dynamic range is found at criti-
cality (pc = 1/K = 0.02). This peak shown in Fig. 1d
demonstrates the optimal sensitivity of the critical state
(red dot) [17].
Besides from high sensitivity, the critical state also ex-
hibits a large trial-to-trial variability associated with en-
hanced critical fluctuations. The noise curve (computed
over the entire response function, see Methods) follows
a trend similar to the dynamic range, with a peak close
to the critical state and a fast decay away from it (Fig.
1e). The DNR exhibits larger values in the subcritical
region, decreases near the critical state, and slowly in-
creases again in the supercritical regime as the coupling
is moved away from the trough (Fig 1f). The larger DNR
at subcriticality indicates an advantage of this regime
with respect to the critical and supercritical ones. This
finding is compatible and also adds to other recent find-
ings and proposals that take advantage of the subcritical
regime [36 -- 38]. Moreover, the minimal DNR occurs very
close to the critical state, raising concerns about the abil-
3
ity of critical systems to overcome their limited specificity
when the sensitivity is optimal. Is this an intrinsic and
unavoidable limitation, or can it be harnessed by natural
or designed systems?
Branching ratio for different dynamical regimes. To
address this question, we first want to highlight the sep-
aration of the three non-overlapping regimes occurring
in homogeneous systems for different coupling strengths:
subcritical (p < pc), critical (p ≈ pc), and supercritical
(p > pc). Each regime has a specific signature of the
spreading of activity in the system [39]. Since the num-
ber of quiescent nodes decays owing to larger numbers
of active and refractory nodes, the branching ratio also
decays with ρ (Fig. 2a).
(a)
)
ρ
(
σ
,
n
o
i
t
c
n
u
f
i
g
n
h
c
n
a
r
b
1
0.5
0
0.05
(b)
1
0.5
0
θ=1
θ=2
θ=3
θ=4
θ=5
θ=6
0.15
0.25
fraction of active nodes (ρ)
0.05
0.15
0.25
FIG. 2. Branching function σ(ρ) in homogeneous and het-
erogeneous systems. (a) Branching function decays with the
fraction of active nodes (ρ). Curves represent p = 0.025 (blue,
supercritical case), pc = 0.02 (red, critical), p = 0.015 (black,
subcritical).
(b) Branching function in heterogeneous net-
works with discrete uniform distribution (θ = 1, 2, ..., 6) at
p1
c = 0.14. The branching function of the whole network is
in black, and in coloured curves for subnetworks. Results ob-
tained for different initial conditions in the absence of external
driving (h = 0).
In the subcritical state, σ(ρ) is consistently less than
one, thereby the network activity quickly vanishes in the
absence of external input (Fig. 2a). At criticality, σ ≈ 1
for small ρ, allowing large critical fluctuations that even-
tually drives the network activity to cease [40]. Network
activity grows (σ > 1) in the supercritical regime for
small ρ, and stabilises (σ ≈ 1) at a level of self-sustained
activity consistent with F0.
In all cases, nodes behave
similarly because they are governed by the same rules.
Additionally, since the subcritical regime shows a clear
enhancement of the DNR (Fig. 1f), one possibility to
overcome the limitation of the DNR at criticality comes
from diversity where some nodes are at criticality and
the remainder are subcritical.
Response of heterogeneous networks.
Integration
(θ > 1) makes the transmission of activity less reli-
able [41], which reduces the branching ratio of these
subpopulations (Fig. 2b). Compared to the homoge-
neous case, networks in the presence of diversity require
stronger coupling to reach a critical state, which vary for
the different subpopulations (multiple-percolation [33,
42]). For the critical state (p1
c ) of the subpopulation with
θ = 1, the branching ratio of this most excitable subpop-
ulation is σ ≈ 1 for a large range of ρ, and less than
one for the other subpopulations. While the branching
ratio for the whole network (black curve of Fig. 2b) re-
sembles the monotonic decay of homogeneous networks
(Fig. 2a), the subpopulations exhibit distinct behaviour
for the very same coupling strength, which leads to func-
tional diversity.
4
(a)
sensitivity
specificity
r
e
y
a
l
y
r
a
d
n
o
c
e
s
n
o
i
t
a
g
e
r
g
e
s
critical
state
θ=1
n
o
i
t
a
r
g
e
t
n
i
subcritical state
θ=2
θ=3
...
θ= max
θ
r
e
y
a
l
y
r
a
m
i
r
p
∆1
∆T
x=T
x=1
∆T-1
x=T-1
(c)
0.08
Σ
,
i
e
s
o
N
(e)
0
10 4
10 3
x
Σ
/
T
∆
0
0.1
0.2
coupling
0.3
0
0.1
0.2
coupling
0.3
(b)
50
)
B
d
(
∆
20
(d)
10 4
10 3
x
Σ
/
1
∆
(f)
c
R
N
D
10 4
10 3
10 2
F1
F2
F6
h(ms -1)
10 1
(b)
50
)
B
d
(
∆
(d)
10
0
10 4
R
N
D
10 3
∆1
∆2
∆6
0.3
coupling
0.2
(a)
)
1
-
s
m
(
F
0
10 -10
(c)
0.08
i
e
s
o
N
0
0
coupling
0.3
0
coupling
0.3
1
1/Σ
∆
T
1/Σ
∆
T-1
1/Σ
∆
1
T/Σ
∆
T
T/Σ
∆
T-1
T/Σ
∆
θ=1
FIG. 3. Maximal sensitivity and minimal specificity occurs at
criticality in heterogeneous networks (θmax = 6). (a) Family
of response functions F for the different subpopulations F θ
as a function of h for p1
c = 0.14. Subpopulations are ordered
from left to right. (b) Dynamic range as a function of the
coupling strength for the subpopulations ∆θ.
(c) Noise as
a function of the coupling strength. (d) Dynamic-range-to-
noise ratio as a function of the coupling strength. Horizontal
dashed lines indicate the corresponding values at criticality
for the homogeneous system of Fig. 1. Red dashed lines
indicate the critical coupling for the subpopulation of θ = 1,
p1
c.
The response functions of the subpopulations in het-
erogeneous systems are also very different (Fig. 3a). At
p1
c, whereas the subpopulations of integrators (θ > 1) are
in the subcritical state, the subpopulation with θ = 1 is in
the critical state. For this critical subpopulation both the
dynamic range (Fig. 3b) and the noise (Fig. 3c) are en-
hanced compared to the homogeneous case (shown in Fig.
1).
In addition, the DNR of this subpopulation essen-
tially replicates the behaviour of the homogeneous case
(Fig. 1f): Minimum near criticality, and larger values
for the subcritical compared to the supercritical regime
3d). Notably, in the presence of diversity the
(Fig.
dynamic range at criticality for the subpopulation with
θ = 1 is enhanced. Yet, since the noise is enhanced even
more for this subpopulation, the DNR is minimal.
FIG. 4. Combining critical sensitivity with subcritical speci-
ficity. (a) Minimal two-level hierarchical structure with hori-
zontal integration (within layer) and vertical segregation (be-
tween layers). (b) Dynamic range versus coupling strength p
for the most excitable subpopulation ∆1, the average of all
subpopulations ∆T , and the average of all integrators ∆T −1.
(c) Noise versus p for the same groups: Σ1 (most excitable,
red), ΣT (all, black), ΣT −1 (integrators, blue). (d) Dynamic-
range-to-noise ratio combining the dynamic range from ∆1
with the noise from the other groups. (e) Dynamic-range-to-
noise ratio combining the dynamic range from ∆T with the
noise from the other groups. Horizontal dashed lines indi-
cate critical values for the homogeneous system of Fig. 1.
Red dashed lines indicate p1
c. (f) Comparison of the above
results for the dynamic-range-to-noise ratio at criticality with
the homogeneous case θ = 1 (grey). Red borders denote a
minimum and the green border denotes a maximum of the
DNR at criticality.
Combining critical sensitivity with subcritical speci-
ficity. The response of the critical subpopulation has
enhanced sensitivity but compromised specificity, and the
responses of the subcritical subpopulations have lower
sensitivity but improved specificity. These specialised re-
sponses allow for the possibility of combining the optimal
features of the output of each group that coexist in het-
erogeneous systems (Fig. 4a). To explore this avenue, it is
first convenient to split the network into three groups: (i)
the subpopulation of most excitable elements (θ = 1), (ii)
the whole network, and (iii) the union of all integrators
(θ > 1). These groups exhibit distinct properties with
(i) and (iii) showing opposite features and (ii) represent-
ing a middle ground between them. The most excitable
group (i) and the whole network (ii) show peaks for both
dynamic range and noise at p1
c. This is in contrast to in-
tegrators (iii) that exhibit smooth curves (without peaks)
for both dynamic range and noise because they are in the
subcritical regime (blue lines, Figs. 4b,c).
By exploring the differences among subpopulations,
the DNR is estimated combining the sensitivity of groups
(i) and (ii), ∆1 and ∆T , with the specificity of the three
groups (Σx, Fig. 4d,e). Marrying the dynamic range of
group (i) with the noise of group (iii) leads to maximal
DNR at criticality (Fig. 4d). Thus, optimal sensitivity
can coexist with maximal DNR when the estimations of
dynamic range and noise come from segregated groups.
Comparing the DNR at criticality across groups
demonstrates the advantage of diversity with respect to
homogeneous networks (Fig. 4f). This comparison re-
veals the importance of combining integration and segre-
gation [43, 44] of heterogeneous groups as illustrated in
the generic scheme of Fig. 4a: Integration occurs within
the network as nodes interact with nodes from other sub-
populations (purple arrows); segregation corresponds to
the separation of the outputs from critical and subcritical
subpopulations of the primary level towards a secondary
level (red and blue arrows). Enhanced sensitivity occurs
only in one subpopulation (θ = 1). And optimal DNR
requires the dynamic range of the critical subpopulation
and the noise of subcritical subpopulations. Without
this separation, heterogeneous networks perform worse
than homogeneous networks for dynamic range (∆T in
Fig. 4b), noise (ΣT in Fig. 4c), and DNR (∆T /ΣT in
Figs. 4e, f). To behave optimally the system needs to
take advantage of the best feature of each subgroup.
4. Discussion
The importance of critical systems is now widely estab-
lished [45 -- 48], and more recently enhanced consistency
and stability of subcritical systems have also been recog-
nised as important features [36 -- 38]. In addition to affect
the dynamics of systems [32, 49, 50] and improve perfor-
mance in several aspects [31, 33], heterogeneity can also
lead to functional diversity in which the dynamics of sub-
groups are tuned to different dynamical regimes. Com-
pared to homogeneous systems, functional diversity can
furnish several simultaneous advantages: (i) Specificity is
enhanced in subcritical subpopulations because their re-
sponse is more reliable and less variable. (ii) Sensitivity
is enhanced in the critical subpopulation because these
nodes are more excitable (stronger critical coupling) and
thus, more effective in amplifying weak stimuli (with-
out significant early saturation for strong stimuli). (iii)
5
The ratio between critical sensitivity (dynamic range)
and subcritical variability (noise) is maximised. Adding
to the ever-growing list of advantages of diversity [51, 52],
we find that functional diversity can promote the coexis-
tence of enhanced specificity with optimal sensitivity and
maximal DNR.
To take advantage of features of critical and subcrit-
ical regimes, we propose a simple hierarchical organisa-
tion [53 -- 57] that segregates and integrates the activity
of the subpopulations, which are two major processes
of complex dynamics [43, 58]. The proposed structure,
illustrated in Fig. 4a, involves integration among hetero-
geneous elements, and segregation of the output from
critical and subcritical groups towards higher hierarchi-
cal levels. At the bottom of the hierarchy, integration
only requires recurrent connections, and segregation re-
quires the separation of the different responses. A fu-
ture task consists in elucidating the precise mechanism in
which neurons at the top of the hierarchy optimally asso-
ciate inputs from critical and subcritical sources. Grow-
ing evidence indicates that this separability leads to an
exquisite level of specialisation observed in neuronal ac-
tivity [59, 60], including regions responding to stimulus
noise or prediction error [61]. Given the specialisation of
brain activity, which is most widely found in neuroimag-
ing experiments [62], it is reasonable to expect that the
sensitivity and specificity of subnetwork responses are
also separable features that can be combined to generate
an accurate DNR estimation as well as other more so-
phisticated combinations of features from heterogeneous
responses.
The appealing critical-brain hypothesis has been pro-
posed as a method that would allow the brain to take
advantage of several features that are optimised at crit-
icality [63 -- 65]. However, despite clear benefits for infor-
mation processing, this hypothesis remains controversial,
especially because numerous evidences of non-critical dy-
namics also exist [36 -- 38]. By revealing that the advan-
tages of critical systems only require a small proportion
of critical units, our findings conciliate these two points of
view. The coexistence of subcritical and critical subparts
of a system can optimise the collective response. Hence,
experiments may highlight critical and/or the subcriti-
cal aspects of the dynamics since these regimes are not
exclusive.
In summary, we propose a mechanism that allows
a critical system to overcome the limitations of en-
hanced critical fluctuations, improving specificity, opti-
mising sensitivity, and maximising DNR, which reflects a
tradeoff between sensitivity and specificity. The proposal
requires functional diversity and separated pathways that
are responsible for conveying complementary representa-
tions of the network response: sensitivity from critical
elements, and specificity from subcritical ones. The ben-
efits of functional diversity are likely (i) to find further
applications because they allow for the combination of
multiple specialised features, and (ii) to transfer to a va-
riety of systems because heterogeneity is ubiquitous in
nature.
Funding. This work was supported by the Australian
Research Council and the Australian National Health
and Medical Research Council (APP1110975).
[1] J. Von Neumann, "Probabilistic logics and the synthesis
of reliable organisms from unreliable components," Au-
tomata studies 34, 43 -- 98 (1956).
[2] F. Rieke, Spikes: exploring the neural code (MIT press,
1999).
[3] A. A. Faisal, L. P. J. Selen, and D. M. Wolpert, "Noise
in the nervous system," Nature reviews neuroscience 9,
292 -- 303 (2008).
[4] D. Bray, M. D. Levin, and C. J. Morton-Firth, "Receptor
clustering as a cellular mechanism to control sensitivity,"
Nature 393, 85 -- 88 (1998).
[5] L. L Gollo, O. Kinouchi, and M. Copelli, "Active den-
drites enhance neuronal dynamic range," PLoS Compu-
tational Biology 5, e1000402 (2009).
[6] S. S. Stevens, Psychophysics (Transaction Publishers,
1975).
[7] P. S. Laplace, Pierre-Simon Laplace Philosophical Essay
on Probabilities: Translated from the fifth French edition
of 1825 With Notes by the Translator, Vol. 13 (Springer
Science & Business Media, 2012).
[8] P. Ayton and I. Fischer, "The hot hand fallacy and the
gambler's fallacy: Two faces of subjective randomness?"
Memory & cognition 32, 1369 -- 1378 (2004).
[9] H. E. Stanley, Introduction to phase transitions and crit-
ical phenomena (Oxford University Press, 1987).
[10] C. Haldeman and J. M. Beggs, "Critical branching cap-
tures activity in living neural networks and maximizes
the number of metastable states," Phys. Rev. Lett. 94,
058101 (2005).
[11] T. S. Mosqueiro and L. P. Maia, "Optimal channel effi-
ciency in a sensory network," Phys. Rev. E 88, 012712
(2013).
[12] J. T. Lizier, M. Prokopenko, and A. Y. Zomaya, "Infor-
mation modification and particle collisions in distributed
computation," Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of
Nonlinear Science 20, 037109 (2010).
[13] W. L Shew, H. Yang, S. Yu, R. Roy,
and D. Plenz,
"Information capacity and transmission are maximized
in balanced cortical networks with neuronal avalanches,"
Journal of neuroscience 31, 55 -- 63 (2011).
[15] B. V´azquez-Rodr´ıguez,
[14] R. V. Williams-Garc´ıa, M. Moore, J. M. Beggs,
and
G. Ortiz, "Quasicritical brain dynamics on a nonequilib-
rium widom line," Physical Review E 90, 062714 (2014).
A. Avena-Koenigsberger,
and H. Larralde,
O. Sporns, A. Griffa, P. Hagmann,
"Stochastic resonance and optimal
information trans-
fer at criticality on a network model of the human
connectome," arXiv preprint arXiv:1705.05248 (2017).
[16] C. G. Langton, "Computation at the edge of chaos: phase
transitions and emergent computation," Physica D: Non-
linear Phenomena 42, 12 -- 37 (1990).
[17] O. Kinouchi and M. Copelli, "Optimal dynamical range
of excitable networks at criticality," Nature Phys. 2, 348 --
6
351 (2006).
[18] L. L. Gollo, O. Kinouchi, and M. Copelli, "Single-neuron
criticality optimizes analog dendritic computation," Sci.
Rep. 3, 3222 (2013).
[19] D. Plenz and E. Niebur, Criticality in neural systems
(John Wiley & Sons, 2014).
[20] M. Scheffer, J. Bascompte, W. A. Brock, V. Brovkin,
S. R. Carpenter, V. Dakos, H. Held, E. H. Van Nes,
M. Rietkerk, and G. Sugihara, "Early-warning signals
for critical transitions," Nature 461, 53 -- 59 (2009).
[21] A. Gal and S. Marom, "Self-organized criticality in
single-neuron excitability," Physical Review E 88, 062717
(2013).
[22] W. L Shew, W. P. Clawson, J. Pobst, Y. Karimipanah,
N. C. Wright, and R. Wessel, "Adaptation to sensory
input tunes visual cortex to criticality," Nature Physics
11, 659 -- 663 (2015).
[23] R. Publio, R. F Oliveira, and A. C. Roque, "A compu-
tational study on the role of gap junctions and rod i h
conductance in the enhancement of the dynamic range of
the retina," PLoS One 4, e6970 (2009).
[24] V. M. Egu´ıluz, M. Ospeck, Y. Choe, A. J. Hudspeth, and
M. O. Magnasco, "Essential nonlinearities in hearing,"
Physical Review Letters 84, 5232 (2000).
[25] S. Camalet, T. Duke, F. Julicher, and J. Prost, "Audi-
tory sensitivity provided by self-tuned critical oscillations
of hair cells," Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences 97, 3183 -- 3188 (2000).
[26] A. J. Hudspeth, "Making an effort to listen: mechanical
amplification in the ear," Neuron 59, 530 -- 545 (2008).
[27] L. L. Gollo, O. Kinouchi,
and M. Copelli, "Statis-
tical physics approach to dendritic computation: The
excitable-wave mean-field approximation," Phys. Rev. E
85, 011911 (2012).
[28] C.Y. Wang, Z.X. Wu, and M. Z. Q. Chen, "Approximate-
master-equation approach for the kinouchi-copelli neural
model on networks," Phys. Rev. E 95, 012310 (2017).
[29] L. L. Gollo, C. Mirasso,
and V. M. Egu´ıluz, "Signal
integration enhances the dynamic range in neuronal sys-
tems," Phys. Rev. E 85, 040902 (2012).
[30] S. B. Nelson, K. Sugino, and C. M. Hempel, "The prob-
lem of neuronal cell types: a physiological genomics ap-
proach," Trends in neurosciences 29, 339 -- 345 (2006).
[31] J. F. Mejias and A. Longtin, "Optimal heterogeneity for
coding in spiking neural networks," Phys. Rev. Lett. 108,
228102 (2012).
[32] K. Padmanabhan and N. N. Urban, "Intrinsic biophysical
diversity decorrelates neuronal firing while increasing in-
formation content," Nature Neuroscience 13, 1276 -- 1282
(2010).
[33] L. L. Gollo, M. Copelli, and J. A. Roberts, "Diversity
improves performance in excitable networks," PeerJ 4,
e1912 (2016).
[34] M. N. Shadlen and W. T. Newsome, "Noise, neural codes
and cortical organization," Current opinion in neurobiol-
ogy 4, 569 -- 579 (1994).
[35] T. A. Cleland and C. Linster, "Concentration tuning me-
diated by spare receptor capacity in olfactory sensory
neurons: a theoretical study," Neural Comput. 11, 1673 --
1690 (1999).
[36] V. Priesemann, M. Valderrama, M. Wibral,
and
M. Le Van Quyen, "Neuronal avalanches differ from
wakefulness to deep sleep -- evidence from intracranial
depth recordings in humans," PLoS Comput Biol 9,
e1002985 (2013).
[37] V Priesemann, M Wibral, M Valderrama, R Propper,
M Le Van Quyen, T Geisel, J Triesch, D Nikoli´c, and
M. H. Munk, "Spike avalanches in vivo suggest a driven,
slightly subcritical brain state." Frontiers in systems neu-
roscience 8, 108 -- 108 (2013).
[38] N. Tomen, D. Rotermund, and U. Ernst, "Marginally
subcritical dynamics explain enhanced stimulus dis-
criminability under attention," Front. Syst. Neurosci 8
(2015).
[39] S. S. Poil, A. van Ooyen, and K. Linkenkaer-Hansen,
"Avalanche dynamics of human brain oscillations: rela-
tion to critical branching processes and temporal corre-
lations," Human brain mapping 29, 770 -- 777 (2008).
[40] D. B. Larremore, W. L. Shew, E. Ott, F. Sorrentino,
and J. G. Restrepo, "Inhibition causes ceaseless dynamics
in networks of excitable nodes," Phys. Rev. Lett. 112,
138103 (2014).
[41] H. P. Wang, D. Spencer, J. M. Fellous, and T. J. Se-
jnowski, "Synchrony of thalamocortical inputs maximizes
cortical reliability," Science 328, 106 -- 109 (2010).
[42] P. Colomer-de Sim´on and M. Bogun´a, "Double perco-
lation phase transition in clustered complex networks,"
Phys. Rev. X 4, 041020 (2014).
[43] G. Tononi, O. Sporns, and G. M. Edelman, "A measure
for brain complexity: relating functional segregation and
integration in the nervous system," Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences 91, 5033 -- 5037 (1994).
[44] O. Sporns, Networks of the Brain (MIT press, 2010).
[45] A. Roli, M. Villani, A. Filisetti,
and R. Serra, "Dy-
namical criticality: overview and open questions," arXiv
preprint arXiv:1512.05259 (2015).
[46] T. Mora and W. Bialek, "Are biological systems poised at
criticality?" Journal of Statistical Physics 144, 268 -- 302
(2011).
[47] G. Deco and V. K. Jirsa, "Ongoing cortical activity at
rest: criticality, multistability, and ghost attractors," The
Journal of Neuroscience 32, 3366 -- 3375 (2012).
[48] W. L. Shew and D. Plenz, "The functional benefits of
criticality in the cortex," The neuroscientist 19, 88 -- 100
(2013).
[49] J. H .E Cartwright, "Emergent global oscillations in het-
erogeneous excitable media: The example of pancreatic
β cells," Physical review E 62, 1149 (2000).
7
[50] C. J. Tessone, C. R. Mirasso, R. Toral, and J. D. Gun-
ton, "Diversity-induced resonance," Phys. Rev. Lett. 97,
194101 (2006).
[51] D. Van Knippenberg and M. C. Schippers, "Work group
diversity," Annu. Rev. Psychol. 58, 515 -- 541 (2007).
[52] A. Joshi and H. Roh, "The role of context in work team
diversity research: A meta-analytic review," Academy of
Management Journal 52, 599 -- 627 (2009).
[53] S. Zeki and S. Shipp, "The functional logic of cortical
connections," Nature 335, 311 -- 317 (1988).
[54] M. M. Mesulam, "From sensation to cognition." Brain
121, 1013 -- 1052 (1998).
[55] D. J. Felleman and D. C. Van Essen, "Distributed hier-
archical processing in the primate cerebral cortex," Cere-
bral cortex 1, 1 -- 47 (1991).
[56] S. Hochstein and M. Ahissar, "View from the top: Hi-
erarchies and reverse hierarchies in the visual system,"
Neuron 36, 791 -- 804 (2002).
[57] S. J. Kiebel, J. Daunizeau, and K. J. Friston, "A hier-
archy of time-scales and the brain," PLoS Comput Biol
4, e1000209 (2008).
[58] P. T. Fox and K. J. Friston, "Distributed processing; dis-
tributed functions?" Neuroimage 61, 407 -- 426 (2012).
[59] R Q. Quiroga, L. Reddy, G. Kreiman, C. Koch, and
I. Fried, "Invariant visual representation by single neu-
rons in the human brain," Nature 435, 1102 -- 1107 (2005).
[60] C. G. Gross, "Genealogy of the "grandmother cell"," The
Neuroscientist 8, 512 -- 518 (2002).
[61] S. Iglesias, C. Mathys, K. H. Brodersen, L. Kasper,
M. Piccirelli, H. E. M den Ouden, and K. E. Stephan,
"Hierarchical prediction errors in midbrain and basal
forebrain during sensory learning," Neuron 80, 519 -- 530
(2013).
[62] T. Yarkoni, R. A. Poldrack, T. E. Nichols, D. C. Van Es-
sen, and T. D. Wager, "Large-scale automated synthesis
of human functional neuroimaging data," Nature meth-
ods 8, 665 -- 670 (2011).
[63] D. R. Chialvo, "Critical brain networks," Physica A:
Statistical Mechanics and its Applications 340, 756 -- 765
(2004).
[64] D. R. Chialvo, "Emergent complex neural dynamics,"
Nature physics 6, 744 -- 750 (2010).
[65] J. M. Beggs, "The criticality hypothesis: how local cor-
tical networks might optimize information processing,"
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of Lon-
don A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences
366, 329 -- 343 (2008).
|
1805.01552 | 3 | 1805 | 2018-11-17T04:03:38 | Normative atlases of neuroelectric brain activity and connectivity from a large human cohort | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Magnetoencephalographic (MEG) recordings from a large normative cohort (n = 619) were processed to extract measures of regional neuroelectric activity. The overall objective of the effort was to use these measures to identify normative human neuroelectric brain function. The aims were (a) to identify and measure the values and range of those neuroelectric properties which are common to the cohort, (b) to identify and measure the values and range of those neuroelectric properties which distinguish one individual from another, and (c) to identify relationships of the measures to properties of the individual, e.g. sex, biological age, and sleep symptoms. It is hoped that comparison of the resultant established norms to measures from recordings of symptomatic individuals will enable advances is our understanding of pathology.
MEG recordings during resting and task conditions were provided by The Cambridge (UK) Centre for Ageing and Neuroscience Stage 2 cohort study. Referee consensus processing was used to localize and validate neuroelectric currents, p < 10-12 for each, p < 10-4 for each when corrected for multiple comparisons.
Comparisons of regional activity and connectivity within-subjects produced profuse reliable measures detailing differences between individuals, p < 10-8 for each comparison, p < 0.005 for each when corrected for a total of 5 x 105 comparisons. Cohort-wide regional comparisons (p < 10-8 for each) produced profuse measures which were common to the preponderance of individuals, detailing normative commonalities in brain function. Comparisons of regional gray matter (cellular) vs white matter (communication fibers) activity produced robust differences both cohort-wide and for each individual. These results validate the high spatial resolution of the results and establish the unprecedented ability to obtain neuroelectric measures from the white matter. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Normative atlases of neuroelectric brain activity and
connectivity from a large human cohort
Don Krieger1, Paul Shepard2, David O. Okonkwo1
1Department of Neurological Surgery, University of Pittsburgh
2Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pittsburgh
Corresponding author:
e-mail: [email protected]
Contributions:
Don Krieger participated in all aspects of the effort.
Paul Shepard participated in conceptualization, formal analysis, methodology, validation, writing
and review.
David Okonkwo participated in conceptualization, funding acquisition, methodology, project
administration, resources, supervision, validation, writing and review.
Abstract
Magnetoencephalographic (MEG) recordings from a large normative cohort (n = 619) were
processed to extract measures of regional neuroelectric activity and connectivity. The overall
objective of the effort was to use these measures to identify normative human neuroelectric brain
function. The aims were (a) to identify and measure the values and range of those neuroelectric
properties which are common to the cohort, (b) to identify and measure the values and range of
those neuroelectric properties which distinguish one individual from another, and (c) to identify
relationships of the measures to properties of the individual, e.g. sex, biological age, and sleep
symptoms. It is hoped that comparison of the resultant established norms to measures from
recordings of symptomatic individuals will enable advances is our understanding of pathology.
MEG recordings during resting and task conditions were provided by The Cambridge (UK)
Centre for Ageing and Neuroscience Stage 2 cohort study. Referee consensus processing was
used to localize and validate neuroelectric currents, p < 10-12 for each, p < 10-4 for each when
corrected for multiple comparisons. Comparisons of regional activity and connectivity within-
subjects produced profuse reliable measures detailing differences between individuals, p < 10-8
for each comparison, p < 0.005 for each when corrected for a total of 5 x 105 comparisons.
Cohort-wide regional comparisons (p < 10-8 for each) produced numerous measures which were
common to the preponderance of individuals, detailing normative commonalities in brain
function. Comparisons of regional gray matter (cellular) vs white matter (communication fibers)
activity produced robust differences both cohort-wide and for each individual. These gray vs
adjacent white matter results (1) validate that the spatial resolution of the method is better than 5
mm and (2) establish the unprecedented ability to obtain neuroelectric measures from the white
matter.
The atlases derived from the results include the mean and standard deviation for each of
hundreds of normative measures. These may be used to transform the same measures obtained
from any individual to z-scores for statistical comparison with the norm.
INTRODUCTION
It has been the informed expectation for a century that the keys to understanding the human
brain will be found in measuring and understanding the electrical activity of neurons. Today,
clinical neurophysiologists routinely measure single neurons to aide implantation of therapeutic
devices deep in the brain [1]. Epileptologists use arrays of implanted "stereo EEG" electrodes
and the population recordings obtained from them to diagnose and guide the treatment of
intractable seizure disorders [2].
Population neuronal activity is presumed to be the basis for human behavior. Stereo EEG and
comparable invasive methods produce voltage recordings with resolution of a few millimeters at
best from up to a few hundred recording sites. Because the electric field interacts strongly with
the conducting tissue in the brain, these measures are difficult to localize for currents at a
distance from the electrodes. This problem is particularly pronounced when the recordings are
made noninvasively from electrodes placed on the scalp.
Magnetoencephalography (MEG) provides an alternative noninvasive measurement approach
with several advantages over scalp and even implanted EEG recordings. Electrical current flow
within populations of neurons is a fundamental constituent of brain function. The magnetic fields
produced by these electric currents within the brain are measured at the MEG sensor array with
high fidelity. Unlike electric fields, magnetic fields do not interact with brain tissue. Therefore,
in principle, the currents which are the sources of the measured magnetic field are more readily
localized.
For almost all MEG studies, the neuroelectric sources of the measured magnetic fields are
presumed to be due to population post-synaptic currents within the cerebral cortex [3,4]. For this
reason, most source level analyses are constrained to identify neuroelectric currents in the cortex
only, although there are occasional reports in which neuroelectric dipoles are localized to the
white matter, e.g. [5].
In the work reported here, the referee consensus solver yields profuse measures of
neuroelectric currents localized to the white matter. This can only be due to summed axial
currents in bundles of nearly parallel axons. These currents and the resultant magnetic fields
have been modelled [6]. The physical model has been verified and the magnetic field waveform
due to a propagating action potential (AP) has been measured from the medial giant axon of the
crayfish [7].
Production of a detectable magnetic field requires coincidence of many APs within a small
volume of white matter, i.e. passage of a volley. Since the individual APs are of short duration,
1-4 msec, the duration of the volley must be near that to avoid overwhelming destructive
interference between the magnetic fields produced by the individual APs.
Measurement of activity with duration of 5-10 msec requires sampling with band pass at 200
Hz or more. The great majority of published findings in MEG are confined to bands below 25 Hz
with 1-80 Hz being the most typical pass band [8]. In many studies, the pass band is cut off 5-10
Hz below the line frequency, i.e. 5-10 Hz below 60 Hz in the United States. Hence in the
majority of published MEG work, detection of neuroelectric currents within the white matter is
de novo excluded by confining the measurements (1) to low frequencies and (2) to the cerebral
cortex.
With the pass band open to 250 Hz and the neuroelectric current localization unrestricted,
substantive difficulties remain. The measurements at the MEG sensor array are due to an
unknown and almost certainly large number of neuroelectric currents. If the location of a single
contributor to the MEG measurements can be identified, i.e. the location of a single neuroelectric
current, then the corresponding current can be accurately computed using the Biot-Savart law
[9], regardless of the number and amplitude of other currents. Hence the fundamental problem of
extracting source space information from MEG recordings is deconvolution, i.e. separation of the
signal from each current from that of all the others sufficiently to accurately identify the location
of each current, one at a time.
In restricted special cases, the data may be manipulated so that the activity of only one or a
few currents is a significant contributor to the MEG. Most commonly this is accomplished (1) by
averaging multiple data segments, each synchronized to an event, e.g. a stimulus, and (2) by
restricting the analysis to MEG sensors in which the signals are expected to be largest for the
expected current(s). In these cases, Equivalent Current Dipole (ECD) source localization may be
used. The signals in the selected sensors are fit to the forward solution for one or a few point
dipole sources. This nonlinear optimization problem is typically solved using a damped gradient
descent algorithm which works well typically for one source, e.g. [10,11], but may be effective
for two to four sources, e.g. [12-14], so long as there is little interference in the measurements
from simultaneously active currents.
For the general multiple source problem, many investigators have opted to use methods with
which thousands of point sources are estimated in a single operation, e.g. MNE [15], LORETA
[16]. These approaches produce estimates of activity from fixed current locations with sufficient
density to ensure that no presumed true current is more than a few mm from one of them. These
methods produce thousands of parameters from hundreds of data points; the problem is "poorly
posed" and the solution is grossly over-fit. Because of this, localization accuracy is compromised
and the ability to resolve currents which are near each other is poor. In addition, these methods
are vulnerable to interference which is typically minimized using up front averaging with
consequent loss of information.
ECD, MNE, LORETA, and comparable methods all fit a single model to the observed
magnetic field measures. The referee consensus method avoids the fundamental problem that the
number of contributors to the MEG is unknown and likely large. Instead of fitting a global model
to the MEG, it uses a gradient search to identify a single current dipole at a time. It is like ECD
in that it uses a search but it is different in that it fits a model to the dipole time series within a
narrowly defined subspace of the MEG measures. That signal subspace is defined by a novel and
tight spatial filter, i.e. a projection operator, which constrains the measures to those which
closely fit the correct amplitude ratios for the signal due to a current at the search location, i.e.
the forward solution.
In this way, the referee consensus method is like other methods which explicitly use spatial
filters, e.g. [17-21]. Such methods avoid the generally unsolvable problems of accurately
accounting for all of the information contained in the MEG recordings without knowing the
number of contributors and without having sufficient measures to solve the equations. For the
cited examples, all of which are beam formers, a set of filters is generated, each of which is
optimized to yield source space measures from a constrained volume of the brain while
minimizing interference from currents in "nulled" brain volumes.
In summary, there are four properties of the referee consensus method which distinguish it.
(1) It does not use a global solution like ECD, MNE, LORETA, and others in which the MEG
recordings are fit to a single source space model. Hence it avoids both the over-fitting problem
and the problem that the number of contributors to the MEG recordings is unknown. (2) The
method uses spatial filters which are optimized to measure differentials in the close vicinity of
one test location at a time. These filters are paradoxical in that their transfer functions include
zeroes either at or very near the test location.
(3) For each test location 1080 filter sets are used to compute 1080 separate "referee
opinions" regards the presence of a current at the location. The signal/noise enhancement
provided by using a family of filters to make each of these decisions is estimated at 50. This is
the key property which enables extraction of useful information from the raw recordings without
averaging. (4) Each of the 1080 filter sets produces an estimate of the waveform for the current
at the test location. The signal/noise for each waveform estimate is about 5. The signal/noise
enhancement obtained by combining the 1080 waveform estimates is estimated at 50. The
appendices detail (I) the method and (II) its advantages in extracting and localizing neuroelectric
measures. The Methods section presents the dataset and then the sequence of processing steps,
primary, secondary, and tertiary.
It is the secondary processing which is central to understanding the results, particularly the
definitions and normalizations for regional neuroelectric activity and regional network
connectivity. It is the normalizations described in equations (1) and (3) which are the bases for
the differential measures implemented in the tertiary processing steps. The subsections in the
Results section mirror the subsections in the Methods section.
The paper closes with conclusions and suggested steps going forward. This last is particularly
apropos given the path-finding nature of the work in this report. There are numerous alternative
approaches which are yet to be explored with the profuse and reliable measures yielded by the
referee consensus solver. Directions for access to the full set of those measures for the CamCAN
lifespan cohort may be may be found at http://stash.osgconnect.net/+krieger/. This transformed
data set is approximately three TBytes. Example files from this data set are contained in the
supplementary file, S1_Tables.zip.
Materials and Methods
Magnetoencephalographic (MEG) recordings were processed from each member of a
normative cohort, n = 619, ages 18-87 [22,23]. The raw data from each subject was initially
transformed to a collection of probabilistically validated neuroelectric currents, mean = 701,020
per minute per subject. Each current is 80 msec in duration and is localized in time and space
with millisecond (msec) and better than 5 millimeter (mm) resolution. This primary processing
step yielded profuse validated high resolution neurophysiological measures from within the brain
of each subject.
These currents were then counted to produce normalized measures of activity and network
connectivity for each of 158 standard regions of interest (ROIs). This data reduction step
produced tonic regional measures. Each regional measure is a count of all the neuroelectric
currents localized within the region over the nine-minute recording. The statistical power when
comparing counts to test for regional differences is high because the count for each ROI is high.
Tests using the χ2 statistic are used throughout the report to provide confidence that
comparisons do or do not show differences. In most cases, the counts are large, providing
considerable statistical power. For all comparisons, the threshold p-values which are used to
decide if results are significant or not is stringent. The large number of significant findings and
the magnitude of the statistics recommend both (a) the validity of the results and (b) the potential
for benefit from analyses which utilize the high-resolution temporal and spatial information in
the neuroelectric current measures.
CamCAN dataset
The Cambridge Centre for Ageing and Neuroscience (CamCAN) Stage 2 cohort study is a
large cross-sectional adult lifespan study (ages 18-87) of the neural underpinnings of successful
cognitive ageing [22,23]. The work reported here utilized the majority subset (n=619) of the
cohort for whom high resolution (1 mm) anatomic T1-weighted MR imaging and MEG
recordings were available.
MR imaging was obtained on all subjects at a single site using a 3T Siemens TIM Trio
scanner with 32-channel head coil. The T1-weighted imaging was obtained using the MPRAGE
sequence. The field of view for these scans was 256 x 240 x 192 at 1 mm resolution.
MEG recordings were collected at a single site using a 306-channel VectorView MEG system
(Elekta Neuromag, Helsinki). The data were sampled at 1 KHz with anti-aliasing low-pass filter
at 330 Hz and high-pass filter at 0.03 Hz. Continuous head position measures were enabled
throughout the recordings. All recordings were obtained with the subject sitting up.
560 seconds were recorded continuously with eyes closed resting [22]. 560 seconds were
recorded continuously during performance of a sensorimotor task. Subjects detected visual and
auditory stimuli and responded to detection of each with a button press with the right index
finger. The stimuli were two circular checkerboards presented simultaneously to the left and
right of a central fixation cross, 34 msec duration, and a binaural tone of 300 msec duration. The
tone was at 300, 600, or 1200 Hz in equal numbers with the order randomized. 121 trials were
presented with simultaneous visual and auditory stimulation. Eight trials were randomly
intermixed in which one stimulus was presented at a time, four visual and four auditory. This
was done to discourage dependence on one stimulus modality only. The average inter-trial
interval was approximately 4.3 seconds
120 seconds were recorded continuously during passive attendance to the same stimuli as
those presented in the sensorimotor task [22]. Here the visual and auditory stimuli were
presented singly rather than simultaneously and no response was required. The average inter-trial
interval was 1 per second.
Anxiety and depression scores were obtained from the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale
(HADS) [23,24]. Of the 619 subjects included in the study, supra threshold scores were obtained
for 41 subjects for anxiety and 13 for depression. The elevated number for anxiety scores
perhaps reflects testing induced anxiety. The Addenbooke Cognitive Examination Revised
(ACE-R) [25] total score was used as a measure of cognitive function and the Pittsburgh Sleep
Quality Index (PSQI) [26] was used as a measure of sleep quality.
The data processing pipeline is detailed below and is schematized in Table 1.
MEG
Recordings
1o
Neuroelectric currents:
80 msec duration
≈10,000 per second
p < 10-12 for each
2o
Normalized
regional activity
and connectivity
density
3o
Individual and
cohort-wide
properties
p < 10-8 for each
Referee
Consensus
Solver
Regional
segmentation
and counting
Comparison of
regional density
differences
Table 1. Processing pipeline summary. Primary (1o), secondary (2o), and tertiary (3o) processing are detailed in the
sections below.
Primary Processing
MRI processing, MEG filtering, and continuous head positioning
The high resolution T1-weighted MRI scan was processed with Freesurfer, version 5.3
[27,28]. Freesurfer is a segmentation package which automatically and reliably identifies brain
regions. The 3-dimensional coordinates of the extent of the brain volume and 232 standardized
regions of interest (ROI's) were identified. Figure 1 shows the expected descending relationship
Figure 1. The brain volume for each subject was obtained
using Freesurfer (see text). Brain volume for this
normative cohort shows the expected decrease with age
[29] beginning at about age 60. Over the full age range,
the Pearson's correlation between brain volume and age
is -0.295, df = 617, p < 10-18
between brain volume and age.
The subject's head position within the MEG scanner was manually coregistered to the TI-
weighted MRI scan using Elekta's Mrilab visualization tool. The coordinates of the center point
of a sphere most nearly approximating the brain was identified. Using the brain segmentation
provided by Freesurfer, a set of non-overlapping 8x8x8 mm voxels was identified which cover
the brain volume excluding the sphere at the center of the volume with 30 mm radius.
Continuous head positioning measures were extracted using Elekta's MaxFilter tool [30]. The
MEG channels were each filtered with high and low pass at 10 and 250 Hz, 5 Hz roll-off, using
MNE tools [31]. Note that the 10 Hz high pass filtering effectively demeans each channel. For
each 1.24 second data segment, mains noise was removed at 50, 100, 150, 200, and 250 Hz using
polynomial synchronous noise removal [32]. No other preprocessing was applied and no data
segments were excluded by manual artifact identification. Instead, artifact rejection relied upon
the solver's inherent failure to identify validated neuroelectric currents when presented with
excessively noisy data.
MEG processing: Identification of validated neuroelectric currents
The coregistration of the MEG sensor array with the location of the subject's head and brain
was corrected once per second using the continuous head positioning information. This
correction was applied to the forward solution used by the solver.
The forward solution is the mathematical relationship between a putative electric current
within the brain and the resultant magnetic field measurements at the sensor array. It models the
brain as a uniformly conducting sphere [9]. Currents within 30 mm of the center of the sphere
are nearly undetectable and the mathematical formulation for the forward solution is poorly
behaved for this volume; hence it was excluded from the search. The intersection of this region
with an MRI slice is shown in Figure 2. Note that the excluded volume typically includes the
posterior thalamus, the posterior commissure, and much of the midbrain (not shown in the
figure).
Figure 2. Two typical simultaneously active neuroelectric currents were identified and validated by the referee
consensus solver, p < 10-12 for each, i.e. p < 10-4 for each when corrected for multiple comparisons. Each waveform
has duration of 80 msec sampled at 1000 Hz. The bandpass is 10 -- 250 Hz. The currents are 5 mm apart with zero-
lag cross-correlation of 0.157, df = 80, p = 0.16. The yellow dot and circle delineate the region near the center of the
head which is excluded from the search for neuroelectric currents. See text for details.
The referee consensus solver [33,34] was applied to the continuous recordings to identify and
validate neuroelectric currents throughout the brain. The search of the brain volume was
conducted for one 80-msec data segment at a time. The search progressed through the 560
second data stream in 40 msec steps, i.e. 25 steps/second. The number of searches to cover the
volume of the brain for an entire recording session was less than 108. The choice of 10-12 as the
threshold for acceptance yields a threshold corrected for multiple comparisons of p < 10-4 for
each validated neuroelectric current. This provides confidence that almost all identified and
validated currents are real.
Secondary processing
Regional counts
Rather than pursuing analyses which capitalize on the high time resolution of the current
waveforms, it was the stability of the measures over time which was emphasized in this work.
Counting for several minutes of data was used to obtain measures of tonic activity, i.e. the
number of identified currents per unit volume. Counts were obtained for standardized regions of
interest to enable volumetric comparisons between individuals. This also enables comparisons of
MEG-derived results with results derived from other functional imaging modalities, e.g. fMRI.
As described above, freesurfer [27] was used to identify 232 standard brain regions of interest
(ROIs). Both regional neuroelectric activity and connectivity were normalized to enable
comparisons between ROIs and between activity and connectivity. The ROIs vary widely in
volume. This approach therefore surveys regional measures with a wide range of statistical
power. That information will be useful in refining the approach.
For each cortical ROI, freesurfer identifies the adjacent white matter ROI with rim up to 5
mm thick. It also identifies a border of tissue 1 mm thick dividing the cortex and white matter.
There are 68 standard ROI triples. Because their volumes are so small, the 68 border ROIs were
excluded from most of the analyses. The optic chiasm and five subdivisions of the corpus
callosum ROIs were also excluded due to their small volumes. This left a total of 158 ROIs for
which regional counts were analyzed, 68 cortical, 68 adjacent white matter, and 22 other ROIs
including unsegmented white matter, cerebellar ROIs, sub-cortical ROIs, the corpus callosum,
and the brain stem.
Regional neuroelectric activity
The validated neuroelectric currents identified within each ROI were counted and normalized
to a current density, ρroi, as shown in equation (1). The purpose of this normalization was to
enable comparisons of an ROI with or between individuals, during different states, at different
times, or comparisons of one ROI with another. The normalization was defined so that ρroi = 1.0
for all ROIs if the neuroelectric currents were uniformly distributed throughout the brain. In that
isotropic case, the regional count fraction was always equal to the regional volume fraction and
the null hypothesis was true for all comparisons.
ρroi = (countroi/counttotal) ÷ (volroi/voltotal)
(1)
countroi is the count of the currents found inside the ROI, counttotal is the count of all the currents
found inside the brain, volroi is the volume of the ROI, and voltotal is the total volume of the brain.
Thus ρroi is a dimensionless "density." It is the ratio of the ROI's fractional count and
fractional volume. Note that dividing the counts for an ROI by the total count normalizes the
"density" for variations due to both data quality and record length. The normalization for data
quality is particularly important since poor data quality markedly reduces the yield of the solver,
e.g. Figure 5.
The count of validated neuroelectric currents is high because the method is effective when
applied to the raw data stream. The false identification rate is low because the validation
threshold is stringent, p < 10-12, i.e. p < 10-4 per individual identified current when corrected for
multiple comparisons. These characteristics produce ample statistical power to identify
differences between regional density measures, e.g. for a cortical ROI vs the adjacent white
matter ROI, or for an ROI during rest vs the same ROI during task. The activity densities are
reduced in deep structures and in the cerebellum. This is likely due to reduced sensitivity at the
MEG sensor array as the distance to the magnetic field source increases. However, the numbers
are ample even in the brainstem to see significant differential activity, e.g. when comparing rest
and task.
Regional network connectivity
A normalized connectivity measure was computed for each ROI, qroi as shown in equation (3)
below. As was described above for regional neuroelectric activity, the purpose of normalization
is to enable comparisons of an ROI with or between individuals, during different states, at
different times, or comparisons of one ROI with another. The basis for the connectivity measure
is a count of pairs of simultaneously occurring neuroelectric currents. The normalization is
defined so that qroi = 1.0 for all ROIs if both legs of all pairs are uniformly distributed
throughout the brain. In that isotropic case, the null hypothesis is true for all comparisons and, as
shown in equation (2b), the ROIs' count fractions are always equal to a product of two volume
fractions: (1) the volume fraction of the ROI within which one leg of the pair is constrained
multiplied by (2) the volume fraction of the region within which the other leg is constrained.
The equivalence between count fraction and a product of volume fractions is clarified by an
example. Consider a large number of simultaneously active pairs with both legs distributed
uniformly throughout the brain, counttotal. For each pair, we identify one leg as #1 and the other
as #2. Suppose we have an ROI whose volume is 0.1 of the brain and we count the pairs with one
leg inside the ROI and the other leg outside, i.e. in the remaining 0.9 of the brain. Since the
distribution of both legs of the pair is uniform, 0.1 of both legs are inside the ROI and 0.9 of both
are outside. For the 0.1 with leg #1 inside the ROI, 0.9 of those pairs have leg #2 outside and are
included in countroi. In addition for the 0.9 with leg #1 outside, 0.1 of those pairs have leg #2
inside and are also included in countroi. Hence countroi = counttotal x [0.1 x 0.9] x 2. In general
then,
countroi = counttotal x [(volroi/voltotal) x ((voltotal- volroi)/voltotal)] x 2
(2a)
We divide both sides of equation (2a) by counttotal to get the expression for the ROI count
fraction,
countroi/ counttotal = [(volroi/voltotal) x ((voltotal- volroi)/voltotal)] x 2
(2b)
The equivalence between ROI count fraction, left side of equation 2b, and the product of volume
fractions on the right side of the equation enable defining qroi to be the analogue of ρroi for pairs
as shown in equation (3).
qroi = (countroi/counttotal) ÷
[(volroi/voltotal) x ((voltotal- volroi)/voltotal)] x 2, where
(3)
countroi is the number of simultaneously occurring pairs for which one member of the pair is
inside the ROI and the other member is outside.
For a cortical or adjacent white matter ROI, the outside member of the pair is constrained to
fall outside both the cortical ROI and the adjacent white matter. This also applies to pair counts
for either the cerebellar gray or white matter ROI's. This constraint is included to exclude
counting pairs which span only local connections. counttotal is the count of all such pairs found
for all ROIs, volroi is the volume of the ROI, and voltotal is the total volume of the brain.
Coincidence of neuroelectric current pairs
The average number of simultaneously active (coincident) currents validated at 10-12 over the
entire cohort is approximately 440. For an interval with 440 coincident currents, the total number
of possible pairs is equal to the combinations of 440 currents taken 2 at a time, C(440,2) = (440 x
439)/2. The subset of those pairs which are likely functionally coupled was selected by
identifying the pairs which occurred much more often than by chance, p < 10-8 for each.
Figure 3. Two minutes from the resting recordings of a single subject are shown. The 3000 brain locations at which
the largest number of validated currents occurred were identified. The names of most of the ROIs into which these
fall are listed at the right. The time at which each current occurred is plotted as a black dot. The times at which a
simultaneously active pair of validated currents occurred are plotted as red dots.
Computing this probability is conceptualized and implemented as follows. Consider a
recording with 400 second duration. The solver proceeds through the recording in 40 msec steps,
i.e. 25 per second. Hence there are 400x25=10,000 intervals. Suppose that a current was
identified at location #1 within the brain m times and at location #2 n times. What is the
probability that the currents found at both locations will coincide at least ℓ times?
We reformulate this question as one of sampling with replacement. We place 10,000 balls
which represent the intervals in a bowl of which m are red and the rest are white. Each of the m
red balls represents an interval during which a current was identified at location #1. We now
draw a ball from the bowl n times and each time we put it back when we are done. Each of the n
draws represents an interval during which a current was identified at location #2. We return the
ball to the bowl each time because each draw represents a different interval. What is the chance
that we will draw at least ℓ red balls from the bowl? On any draw, the chance that we will draw a
red ball is m/10000. The chance that we will draw exactly ℓ red balls is [m/10000]ℓ x C(n,ℓ).
Finally, the chance that we will draw at least ℓ red balls is ∑
{[𝐦/𝟏𝟎𝟎𝟎𝟎]𝐤 𝐱 𝐂(𝐧, 𝐤)}
𝐤=𝓵,𝐧
CDFBIN [35] was used for the calculation. The threshold probability for accepting a pair for
inclusion was 10-8. This value was chosen as follows. The number of neuroelectric currents
found within each 1 mm3 brain voxel was counted and sorted. The 3000 locations with the
highest counts were selected as the individual locations which would be included in
simultaneously occurring pairs as shown in figure 3. This limited the counts to (3000x2999)/2 =
4,498,500 possible location pairs, a manageable number both computationally and
probabilistically. With approximately 5 million pairs to be tested, the chance that even a single
pair would produce a probability less than 10-8 by chance is 0.05 .
Tertiary processing - comparisons
For each ROI the secondary processing provides both a count and the corresponding
normalized density measure. When comparing activity or connectivity for one ROI for a single
subject, it is the counts which are compared using the χ2 statistic, e.g. equation (3).
𝝌𝟐 = ∑
𝐢=𝟏,𝟐
(𝐨𝐛𝐬𝐞𝐫𝐯𝐞𝐝𝐢 − 𝐞𝐱𝐩𝐞𝐜𝐭𝐞𝐝𝐢)𝟐
⁄
(
𝐞𝐱𝐩𝐞𝐜𝐭𝐞𝐝𝐢
)
(3)
The calculations used to normalize the count to a density measure as formulated in equations
(1) and (2) are also used to compute the expected counts. To control for false positive findings
due to multiple comparisons, p < 10-8 was used as the threshold for significance. This is
conservatively corrected to p < 10-2 for each test since there are less than 106 comparisons (619
subjects x 158 ROIs/subject) for each of seven within-individuals comparisons. It is noteworthy
that because the counts are so high for each subject's ROIs, there is considerable statistical
power for identifying differential regional activity and connectivity.
When comparing activity or connectivity of each ROI for the entire cohort, the differences
between the means of the density measures may be compared using Welch's t-statistic. A more
conservative approach was used. The comparison for each ROI for each individual provided a
measure of confidence for a difference, e.g. between the regional activity during rest vs task. The
χ2 statistic was used to determine if one side of the comparison was greater than the other in the
preponderance of subjects. For this test, the contribution to the χ2 statistic for each ROI is the
same for each subject. Hence the test is not vulnerable to the effects of outliers. For a group
comparison, there is one test per ROI, i.e. 158 tests. For these, p < 10-8 was used as the threshold
for significance. Hence the chance that even a single test would appear significant was p < 10-5.
Rest vs task activity
For each subject, the count for each ROI during rest was compared with the count during the
task. As stated above, p < 10-8 was the threshold for acceptance of a significant difference, i.e. p
< 10-2 for each test corrected for multiple comparisons.
For each ROI for the entire cohort, the number of individuals who demonstrated a significant
difference with rest > task was compared with those with rest < task. p < 10-8 was used as the
threshold for a significant preponderance, i.e. p < 10-5 for each test corrected for multiple
comparisons.
Cortex vs adjacent white matter activity
Each cortical ROI was paired with the adjacent white matter ROI. The white matter ROI
extends into the cortical gyri and includes a white matter rim whose thickness is limited to 5 mm.
The comparison for each ROI pair between cortex and white matter was computed separately for
each individual. For each comparison, the counts for the two ROIs were compared using χ2 with
p < 10-8 used as the threshold for significance for each test, i.e. p < 10-2 corrected for multiple
comparisons.
For each ROI, the following comparison was carried out for the cohort as a whole. The
number of subjects who demonstrated a significant difference with cortex > adjacent white
matter was compared with the number with cortex < adjacent white matter. p < 10-8 was used as
the threshold for a significant preponderance, i.e. p < 10-5 for each test corrected for multiple
comparisons.
Activity vs network connectivity
The activity and connectivity density measures were computed with the same normalization
and scaling. Hence they may be directly compared. The comparison for each ROI between
activity and network connectivity was computed separately for each individual. For each
comparison, the counts for the two measures were compared using the χ2 statistic. As stated
above, p < 10-8 was the threshold for acceptance of a significant difference, i.e. p < 10-2 for each
test corrected for multiple comparisons.
For each ROI, the following comparison was carried out for the cohort as a whole. The
number of individuals who demonstrated a significant difference with connectivity > activity was
compared with the number with connectivity < activity. p < 10-8 was used as the threshold for a
significant preponderance, i.e. p < 10-5 for each test corrected for multiple comparisons.
Global activity patterns
The secondary processing described above provided a set of 158 activity density measures for
each subject. Hence each subject may be conceived as a point in a 158-dimensional space.
Principle components (PC) analysis [36,37] was then applied to reduce this number, 158, to 20
linear combinations of these measures which are orthogonal to each other, i.e. uncorrelated.
The subset of 20 PCs which capture the maximum variance in the original data were selected.
This reduction in the number of measures was necessary to enable practical use of all subsets
regression [38] as described below. It also favors inclusion of information from each individual
which is representative of the cohort.
The "first" 20 PCs accounted for 38.6% of the total variance. The 1st PC accounted for 12.8
times its fair share of the variance; the 20th accounted for 1.8 times its fair share.
All subsets linear regression was applied to identify linear combinations of these 20 PCs
which were optimally correlated with either (a) subject age (b) subject sex, (c) anxiety, (d)
depression. Anxiety and depression symptom scores were used from the Hospital Anxiety and
Depression Symptom scale (HADS) [24].
Sex was encoded as a dummy variable with value 0 for male and 1 for female. Age took an
integer value ranging from 18 to 87. Those anxiety and depression scores with values above 10,
the cut-off for asymptomatic, were excluded. This reduced the number of subject scores from
619 to 578 for anxiety and to 606 for depression.
All subsets regression [38] was used to select the "best" subset of the 20 PCs and the best
rotation of the retained PCs. Let the 20 PCs be ψi, i=1,20 where ψi,k is the value of ψi for subject
k, i.e. the projection of the original 158 measures for subject k onto ψi. BMDP9R was used to
solve for the A's by minimizing the sum of the squared errors, the εk's, in equation (4). The
solution maximizes R, the multiple correlation of the dependent variable, e.g. age, with the
retained ψi's. For PCs which were eliminated, the corresponding Ai was set to zero.
agek =
A0 + εk + ∑
(4)
𝐢=𝟏,𝟐𝟎
𝐀𝐢𝛙𝐢,𝐤
Results
The primary and secondary processing were completed for 619 members of the cohort for the
resting recordings and for 617 for the task recordings. Although the thresholds for acceptance of
significant differences are stringent, there are more than 380,000 results to report with p < 10-8
for each, i.e. p < 10-2 for each when corrected for multiple comparisons. The majority are for
comparisons of the measures from individual subjects. The results are summarized in the tables
which follow with several detailed examples presented.
Identification of validated neuroelectric currents
The number of validated currents identified inside freesurfer ROI's for the resting recordings (n
= 619) was mean 6,365,040 per subject. This reduces to a mean of 455 simultaneously active
currents at each moment throughout the recording. This number is lower than those for the subset
Figure 4. The brain volume for each subject was obtained
using Freesurfer (see Figure 1). The count of validated
neuroelectric sources shows the expected increase with brain
volume. The Pearson's correlation between brain volume
and current count is 0.634, df = 617, p < 10-44
of the cohort aged 18-65, viz. 471 (rest) and 481 (task). The reduction is at least partially due to
the progressive reduction in brain volume with age. Figure 4 shows the positive correlation
between brain volume and the number of validated neuroelectric currents.
Figure 5: Each neuroelectric source is validated at p < 10-12. The referee consensus solver automatically fails when
the recordings are noisy. 300 seconds of raw MEG (lower) and neuroelectric current counts (upper) are shown. The
number of validated (p < 10-12) currents drops markedly when the MEG is noisy.
Regional neuroelectric activity
Results of comparisons are reported for each subjects' ROIs and for the cohort as a whole.
Sample results are shown for a single subject in Table 2 and in Figure 6. A significant difference
in activity between rest and task was seen for a mean of 59.3% of the 158 ROIs for each subject,
i.e. 57,803 of 97,486 ROIs. The threshold for significance for each test was p < 10-8, i.e. p < 10-2
for each when corrected for multiple comparisons.
29,007 of the tests demonstrated greater activity during task than rest; 28,796 demonstrated the
opposite. This insignificant difference was reflected in the same comparisons for each ROI, i.e.
there was no ROI for which the preponderance of subjects demonstrated either greater or lesser
activity in one state vs the other, even with 10-2 used as the threshold for significance.
Task
Rest vs Task
Rest
Activity χ2 (df=1)
ROI
Count Activity Count
2.22041 -159.716 p < 10-35
R_Hippocampus
2.41695 42270
46675
2.11868 -44.333 p < 10-10
R_Pallidum
16733
2.28240 15312
2.33002 -144.721 p < 10-32
R_Putamen
2.50938 50363
55022
1.21808 -45.703 p < 10-10
R_Thalamus-Proper
44225
1.27562 41630
207291 1.68703 185400 1.53062 -927.580 p < 10-203
R_UnsegmentedWhiteMatter
L_ctx_bankssts
17808
L_ctx_caudalanteriorcingulate
6298
L_ctx_caudalmiddlefrontal
40347
L_wm_bankssts
16162
L_wm_caudalanteriorcingulate
13732
44136
L_wm_caudalmiddlefrontal
Table 2. Typical regional counts and activity measures are shown for a sampling of ROIs for this individual. The
white matter ROIs in the 3rd block are adjacent to the cortical ROIs in the 2nd block. Note that the normalized
activity measure is 1.0 if the number of currents validated within an ROI is precisely that ROI's fair share based on
its volume. Hence the sub-cortical ROIs demonstrate relatively high activity for this individual. The significance of
the change in activity from rest to task is shown in the 6th column. The χ2 statistic (column 5) is positive/negative
when task activity is greater/less than rest activity.
1.68396 -14.672 p < 10-3
1.01662 -177.416 p < 10-39
1.49210 136.668 p < 10-30
1.37269 -45.801 p < 10-10
1.21814 102.223 p < 10-23
p < 10-6
1.51937 24.115
1.75472 16847
1.31083 4815
1.37955 45897
1.48261 14751
1.08158 15246
1.47019 44964
Figure 6. Differences are shown for the same subject presented in Table 2. Individual ROIs whose activity during
task performance was greater (red) or less (blue) than activity during rest are indicated, p < 10-8 for each. Color is
fully saturated for p < 10-12. This is the same subject whose counts and measures are shown in Table 2. The labelled
ROIs are those listed in the table. Borders between cortex and white matter for 4 ROIs are shown as landmarks:
precentral, cingulate, insula and fusiform.
Network connectivity
The number of current pairs which occur simultaneously much more often than expected was
counted, p < 10-8 for each pair, p < 0.05 for each when corrected for multiple comparisons. For
each individual, the number of instances of such pairs had a mean = 1,000,008, i.e. this count is
about 1/6th the count for the validated neuroelectric currents. Sample results are shown for a
single subject in Table 3.
Figure 7 shows the number of pair instances vs the pair separation for a single subject. For
pairs of currents with relatively short separation, e.g. a few cm, it is possible that some form of
cross-correlation analysis of the current waveforms may enable identification of pairs which fall
on the same neuronal transmission line. Marrying that identification with each pair's localization
and white matter tractography may produce realistic estimates of action potential propagation
velocities.
Connectivity ROI
4.9448
1.88862
2.46307
1.50517
1.42010
1.19306
0.43091
1.74554
0.51305
0.17638
1.10577
R_Hippocampus
R_Pallidum
R_Putamen
R_Thalamus-Proper
R_UnsegmentedWhiteMatter
L_ctx_bankssts
L_ctx_caudalanteriorcingulate
L_ctx_caudalmiddlefrontal
L_wm_bankssts
L_wm_caudalanteriorcingulate
L_wm_caudalmiddlefrontal
Count
16,377
2,381
9,253
8,927
29,331
2,074
355
9,236
958
384
5,630
Table 3. Typical regional pair counts and connectivity measures from the resting recordings are shown for
the same ROIs and individual as those in Table 2. Note that as for activity, the normalized connectivity
measure is 1.0 if the number of validated pairs for which one leg falls within a ROI is precisely that ROI's
fair share of the total based on its volume. As for activity, the sub-cortical ROIs demonstrate relatively high
connectivity for this individual.
Figure 7. The number of pair instances validated
at p < 10-8 (y-axis) is shown as a function of pair
separation (x-axis). These data are from the
resting recordings from the same subject as
shown in Tables 2 and 3 and Figure 6.
Cortex vs adjacent white matter -- cortical excitability
Comparisons are reported for each cortical/white matter ROI pair for individuals and for the
cohort as a whole. Sample results are shown for a single subject in Tables 4 and 5 and Figure 8.
White matter
1.48261
1.08158
1.47019
Activity
Cortex
1.75472
1.31083
1.37955
Table 4. Typical regional pair comparisons of cortical vs white matter activity during rest are shown for the same
individual as shown in Tables 2 and 3. The ratio of the volumes of the two ROIs in a pair is used to weight the
expected count ratio. When χ2 is greater/less than 0, the cortical activity is greater/less than the white matter
activity.
Cortex vs Adjacent White Matter
χ2 (df=1)
240.723
192.226
-88.253
ROI
L_bankssts
L_caudalanteriorcingulate
L_caudalmiddlefrontal
p < 10-53
p < 10-42
p < 10-20
Activity: Task
Activity: Rest
Cortex White matter Cortex White matter
1.75472 1.48261
1.31083 1.08158
1.37955 1.47019
Table 5. Typical change from rest to task for cortex vs white matter regional pairs are shown for the same individual
as shown in Tables 2-4. The ratio of the volumes of the two ROIs in a pair and the ratio of the total counts during
rest and task are used to weight the expected count ratios. When χ2 is greater/less than zero, cortical vs white matter
activity increased/decreased during task compared with rest.
Rest Task: cortex vs adjacent white matter
χ2 (df=3)
5.250
-276.980
23.046
ROI
L_bankssts
L_caudalanteriorcingulate
L_caudalmiddlefrontal
1.68396 1.37269
1.01662 1.21814
1.49210 1.51937
--
p < 10-58
--
Figure 8. Differences are shown for the same subject presented in Tables 2-5 and figure 6. Upper Panel:
Differences between the activity in cortical and adjacent white matter ROI pairs are shown. Each pair which shows a
difference, p < 10-8, is indicated in color with the ROI with higher activity shown in red, the adjacent ROI in blue.
Color is fully saturated for p < 10-12. Lower Panel: The change from rest to task in the difference between cortex
and adjacent white matter is shown, p < 10-8. For each pair, cortex vs white matter activity changed in the indicated
direction for task compared with rest. E.g. for the left caudal anterior cingulate, the cortex was significantly more
active (red) than the adjacent white matter (blue) during rest (upper panel). The activity in the cortex dropped
significantly (blue) compared with the adjacent white matter (red) during the task (lower panel).
For the resting recordings for the subjects aged 18-65 (n = 411), 23,008 of the cortex/white
matter ROI pairs demonstrated a significant difference in current density at p < 10-8. That is
82.3% of all the ROI pairs. For those which showed significance, the white matter ROI showed
higher current density than the adjacent cortical ROI for 62.7% (14,438 pairs), i.e. the activity in
the white matter was higher than that in the cortex in the preponderance of the ROIs, χ2 = 1496,
df = 1, p < 10-323.
The 32 single ROIs for which the preponderance of subjects demonstrated a cortex vs
adjacent white matter difference in one direction (p < 10-8 for each) are listed in Table 6 and are
graphically presented in Figure 9. The table shows that the cortex is consistently more active
Cortex > WM
425
385
332
330
Cortex < WM
109
154
185
185
145
54
169
186
187
95
189
65
116
152
127
182
181
70
142
131
173
146
155
106
65
155
168
171
131
64
118
171
113
176
181
40
125
126
341
177
356
364
359
411
319
487
413
303
362
321
329
498
411
438
355
348
324
401
176
394
363
343
349
486
432
302
351
324
330
529
433
437
χ2 (df=1)
186.996
99.000
41.796
40.824
-79.044
-65.492
-66.606
-57.606
-54.182
-197.342
-33.266
-322.614
-166.746
-50.112
-112.934
-38.410
-42.948
-322.506
-130.850
-165.638
-62.734
-82.598
-59.626
-171.646
-51.124
-104.044
-71.610
-57.556
-99.008
-323.788
-179.264
-36.280
-122.076
-43.808
-43.446
-420.246
-170.006
-171.794
ROI
L_inferiorparietal
R_inferiorparietal
L_parsopercularis
R_parsopercularis
L_cuneus
L_frontalpole
L_inferiortemporal
L_insula
L_isthmuscingulate
L_lingual
L_medialorbitofrontal
L_middletemporal
L_paracentral
L_parahippocampal
L_pericalcarine
L_postcentral
L_posteriorcingulate
L_precuneus
L_rostralmiddlefrontal
L_superiorfrontal
L_superiorparietal
L_superiortemporal
R_cuneus
R_entorhinal
R_frontalpole
R_insula
R_isthmuscingulate
R_lateraloccipital
R_lingual
R_middletemporal
R_paracentral
R_parahippocampal
R_pericalcarine
R_postcentral
R_posteriorcingulate
R_precuneus
R_rostralmiddlefrontal
R_superiorfrontal
p < 10-41
p < 10-22
p < 10-9
p < 10-9
p < 10-18
p < 10-15
p < 10-15
p < 10-13
p < 10-12
p < 10-44
p < 10-8
p < 10-71
p < 10-37
p < 10-11
p < 10-25
p < 10-9
p < 10-10
p < 10-71
p < 10-29
p < 10-37
p < 10-14
p < 10-18
p < 10-13
p < 10-38
p < 10-12
p < 10-23
p < 10-16
p < 10-13
p < 10-22
p < 10-71
p < 10-40
p < 10-8
p < 10-27
p < 10-10
p < 10-10
p < 10-92
p < 10-38
p < 10-38
p < 10-14
p < 10-24
349
371
-64.192
-106.658
167
138
Table 6. Cohort-wide differences are shown. These are ROIs during rest for which the preponderance of subjects (p
< 10-8) demonstrated a cortical vs adjacent white matter activity difference in one direction. For the ROIs whose χ2
statistic is negative (unshaded), the cortex was less active than the adjacent white matter for the preponderance of
subjects for whom there was a significant difference, p < 10-8 for each subject. The ROIs listed in the table are the
same as those shown in color in Figure 9. The numbers of subjects for whom the cortex differed from the white
matter in the indicated direction are shown in columns 1 and 2, p < 10-8 for each of the enumerated subjects.
R_superiorparietal
R_superiortemporal
than the adjacent white matter for 2 ROI pairs, left and right inferior parietal. The white matter is
more consistently active than the adjacent cortex for 30 ROI pairs.
For the 410 subjects aged 18-65 with both resting and task recordings, resting cortex vs white
matter activity was different from task cortex vs white matter activity for 12,132 ROI pairs. That
is 43.5% of all the ROIs. There was no preponderance of ROI pairs which changed in one
direction or the other. And there was no single ROI pair for which the preponderance of subjects
demonstrated a significant change in either direction, even at p < 10-3. That is consistent with the
fact that there were 68 comparisons so the chance that one would reach the threshold of 10-3 is
only 1/14.
Figure 9. Cohort-wide differences are shown. For each pair of ROIs shown in color, the preponderance of resting
recordings (p < 10-8) demonstrated cortex vs adjacent white matter activity difference in the indicated direction, i.e.
the red ROI was more active than the adjacent blue ROI, p < 10-8 for each. For fully saturated colors, p < 10-12. The
ROIs are listed in Table 6.
Activity vs connectivity -- locality
Comparisons of connectivity with activity are reported for each ROI for individuals and for
the cohort as a whole. The cohort wide group results are confined to those aged 18-65. Sample
results are shown for a single subject in Tables 7 and 8 and Figure 10.
ROI
p < 10-218 R_Hippocampus
---
p < 10-84
R_Pallidum
R_Putamen
R_Thalamus-Proper
Activity
2.416965
2.28240
2.50938
1.27562
1.68703
1.75472
1.31083
1.37955
1.48261
1.08158
1.47019
Connectivity Count
46675
4.94448
16733
1.88862
2.46307
55022
44225
1.50517
207291
1.42010
17808
1.19306
6298
0.43091
1.74554
43047
16162
0.51305
13732
0.17638
1.10577
44136
Count
16377
2381
9253
8927
29331
2074
355
9236
958
384
5630
Table 7. Typical regional connectivity and activity measures are shown for a sampling of ROIs for this individual
during rest. The white matter ROIs in the 3rd block are adjacent to the cortical ROIs in the 2nd block. Note that the
normalized measures are 1.0 if the number of pairs or currents validated within a ROI is precisely that ROI's fair
share based on its volume. Hence the sub-cortical ROIs demonstrate relatively high activity for this individual. The
significance of the difference in connectivity vs activity is shown in the 6th column. The χ2 statistic (column 5) is
positive/negative when connectivity is greater/less than activity.
Resting Connectivity vs Activity
χ2 (df=1)
999.900
-159.709 p < 10-35
-5.539
384.668
-999.900 p < 10-218 R_UnsegmentedWhiteMatter
-636.055 p < 10-139 L_ctx_bankssts
-999.900 p < 10-218 L_ctx_caudalanteriorcingulate
782.128
-999.900 p < 10-218 L_wm_bankssts
-999.900 p < 10-218 L_wm_caudalanteriorcingulate
-905.090 p < 10-198 L_wm_caudalmiddlefrontal
p < 10-171 L_ctx_caudalmiddlefrontal
For the resting recordings, the activity measure differed from connectivity for 82,918 of
97,802 ROIs, p < 10-8 for each, i.e. 84.8%. For those comparisons which showed differences, the
activity measure was greater than the connectivity measure for 58.7% (48,652 ROIs), i.e. the
activity measure was greater than the connectivity measure in the preponderance of the ROIs, χ2
= 2495.92, df = 1, p < 10-323.
Activity
2.41695
2.28240
2.50938
1.27562
1.68703
1.75472
1.31083
1.37955
1.48261
1.08158
1.47019
Task
Connectivity
1.64761
2.22257
1.82803
1.34027
1.41384
3.02629
0.06222
1.38375
0.15680
0.36038
1.89572
Activity
2.22041
2.11868
2.33002
1.21808
1.53062
1.68396
1.10662
1.49210
1.37269
1.21814
1.51937
Rest
Connectivity
4.94448
1.88862
2.46307
1.50517
1.42010
1.19306
0.43091
1.74554
0.51305
0.17638
1.10577
Table 8. Typical changes from rest to task for connectivity vs activity measures are shown for the same individual as
shown in Tables 2-6,7 above. When χ2 is greater/less than 0, the connectivity measure increased/decreased compared
with the activity measure during task compared with rest.
Rest Task: connectivity vs activity
χ2 (df=1)
-2881.228 p < 10-323
p < 10-40
181.279
-17.520
---
---
26.994
p < 10-182
831.712
1771.912 p < 10-323
-138.270 p < 10-31
p < 10-20
-89.333
-234.933 p < 10-52
p < 10-34
152.520
1430.320 p < 10-312
ROI
R_Hippocampus
R_Pallidum
R_Putamen
R_Thalamus-Proper
R_UnsegmentedWhiteMatter
L_ctx_bankssts
L_ctx_caudalanteriorcingulate
L_ctx_caudalmiddlefrontal
L_wm_bankssts
L_wm_caudalanteriorcingulate
L_wm_caudalmiddlefrontal
Figure 10. Differences are shown for the same subject presented in Tables 2-7 and Figure 6-9. Upper Panel:
Differences between connectivity and activity are shown. Each ROI which shows a difference, p < 10-8, is indicated
in color. ROIs with higher connectivity than activity are shown in red; ROIs with lower connectivity than activity
are shown in blue. Color is fully saturated for p < 10-12. Lower Panel: The change from rest to task in the difference
between connectivity and activity is shown, p < 10-8. For each ROI, connectivity vs activity changed in the indicated
direction for task compared with rest. E.g. for the left caudal anterior cingulate cortex, connectivity vs activity
dropped during task compared with rest (blue). It's interesting that the adjacent white matter (WM) changed in the
opposite direction (red).
The 73 ROIs for which the preponderance of subjects demonstrated connectivity vs activity
difference in one direction (p < 10-8 for each) are listed in Table 9 and are graphically presented
in Figure 11. The table shows that connectivity is consistently greater than activity for 12 ROIs
and consistently less than activity for 61.
For all 158 ROIs, resting connectivity vs activity was different from task connectivity vs
activity for 77,707 ROIs. That is 79.4% of all the ROIs. For those which showed a significant
change, the connectivity measure increased compared with the activity measure in 51.8%, a
small but significant preponderance, χ2 = 71, df = 1, p < 10-14. There was no single ROI for which
the preponderance of subjects demonstrated a significant change in either direction, even at p <
10-3. That is consistent with the fact that there were 158 comparisons so the chance that even one
would reach the threshold of 10-3 is only 1/6.
Figure 11. Cohort-wide differences are shown. For each ROI shown in color, the preponderance (p < 10-8) of
subjects demonstrated a connectivity vs activity difference in the indicated direction. Red indicates that connectivity
was greater than activity for the ROI for the preponderance of the subjects for whom there was a significant
difference between connectivity and activity, p < 10-8 for each subject. For fully saturated colors, p < 10-12. The
ROIs are listed in Table 9.
Connectivity > Activity Connectivity < Activity χ2 (df=1)
354
411
365
393
368
354
419
362
367
378
389
381
82
80
94
216
182
88
83
110
151
145
132
126
190
135
199
150
124
158
162
161
198
114
182
Table 9. These are ROIs during rest for which the preponderance (p < 10-8) of subjects demonstrated a connectivity
vs activity difference in one direction. For the ROIs whose χ2 statistic is negative (unshaded), connectivity was less
than activity for the preponderance of subjects for whom there was a significant difference between connectivity
and activity, p < 10-8 for each subject. The ROIs listed in the table are the same as those shown in color in Figure 11.
The numbers of subjects for whom connectivity differed from activity in the indicated direction are shown in
columns 1 and 2, p < 10-8 for each of the enumerated subjects. Table 9 is continued below.
ROI
L_ctx_caudalmiddlefrontal
L_ctx_lateraloccipital
L_ctx_precentral
L_ctx_rostralmiddlefrontal
R_ctx_caudalmiddlefrontal
R_ctx_inferiorparietal
R_ctx_lateraloccipital
R_ctx_middletemporal
R_ctx_postcentral
R_ctx_precentral
R_ctx_rostralmiddlefrontal
R_ctx_superiorparietal
Brain-Stem
L_Cerebellum-Cortex
L_Cerebellum-White-Matter
L_Hippocampus
R_Caudate
R_Cerebellum-Cortex
R_Cerebellum-White-Matter
L_ctx_caudalateriorcingulate
L_ctx_cuneus
L_ctx_fusiform
L_ctx_isthmuscingulate
L_ctx_lingual
L_ctx_medialorbitofrontal
L_ctx_paracentral
L_ctx_parahippocampal
L_ctx_pericalcarine
L_ctx_posteriorcingulate
L_ctx_precuneus
L_ctx_rostralanteriorcingulate
L_ctx_transversetemporal
R_ctx_bankssts
R_ctx_caudalanteriorcingulate
R_ctx_cuneus
210
167
204
184
190
203
166
209
198
197
184
191
512
524
493
363
343
514
508
245
327
435
273
446
356
294
357
330
296
376
322
296
336
251
311
p < 10-8
36.764
p < 10-23
103.002
p < 10-10
45.554
p < 10-17
75.702
p < 10-13
56.780
p < 10-9
40.934
p < 10-24
109.416
p < 10-9
40.996
p < 10-11
50.559
p < 10-13
56.974
p < 10-17
73.342
p < 10-14
63.110
-311.278 p < 10-68
-326.384 p < 10-72
-271.210 p < 10-60
p < 10-8
-37.320
p < 10-11
-49.372
-301.454 p < 10-66
-305.626 p < 10-67
p < 10-12
-51.338
p < 10-15
-64.802
-145.000 p < 10-32
p < 10-11
-49.088
-179.020 p < 10-40
p < 10-11
-50.468
p < 10-13
-58.930
p < 10-10
-44.898
p < 10-15
67.500
p < 10-16
-70.438
p < 10-20
-88.996
p < 10-12
-52.892
p < 10-9
-39.878
p < 10-8
-35.662
p < 10-12
-51.420
p < 10-8
-33.754
Table 9 is continued from above.
Connectivity > Activity Connectivity < Activity χ2 (df=1)
p < 10-12
-51.130
192
-128.444 p < 10-29
152
p < 10-16
120
-71.804
-104.206 p < 10-23
160
p < 10-20
-89.982
157
p < 10-10
-46.226
142
p < 10-16
183
-70.670
p < 10-9
-40.510
187
p < 10-10
-45.444
138
p < 10-15
-67.934
173
p < 10-17
-76.910
130
p < 10-9
166
-40.018
p < 10-15
-66.064
183
p < 10-19
-84.128
134
p < 10-15
-65.586
157
-105.934 p < 10-24
159
p < 10-9
-40.818
207
p < 10-8
-34.186
206
-167.215 p < 10-37
131
p < 10-13
162
-57.932
p < 10-15
-65.450
176
p < 10-10
-45.224
197
p < 10-17
-75.356
159
p < 10-19
171
-84.236
p < 10-13
-56.222
167
p < 10-13
-57.064
186
p < 10-10
42.978
202
p < 10-9
143
-41.684
p < 10-14
-64.362
183
p < 10-15
-66.068
140
p < 10-18
-78.902
181
-117.448 p < 10-26
151
p < 10-12
-55.224
169
p < 10-17
-75.940
172
p < 10-10
-42.016
144
p < 10-12
-54.030
172
p < 10-18
171
-81.126
p < 10-14
146
-60.760
Table 9 is continued from above.
360
424
292
402
376
282
383
332
275
364
315
303
375
332
337
403
359
343
440
331
364
355
356
388
335
363
357
275
372
313
394
407
336
376
277
338
383
313
ROI
R_ctx_entorhinal
R_ctx_fusiform
R_ctx_isthmuscingulate
R_ctx_lingual
R_ctx_medialorbitofrontal
R_ctx_paracentral
R_ctx_parahippocampal
R_ctx_pericalcarine
R_ctx_posteriorcingulate
R_ctx_precuneus
R_ctx_rostralanteriorcingulate
R_ctx_transversetemporal
L_wm_bankssts
L_wm_caudalanteriorcingulate
L_wm_cuneus
L_wm_fusiform
L_wm_inferiortemporal
L_wm_insula
L_wm_lingual
L_wm_paracentral
L_wm_parahippocampal
L_wm_pericalcarine
L_wm_posteriorcingulate
L_wm_precuneus
L_wm_rostralanteriorcingulate
L_wm_superiortemporal
L_wm_supramarginal
L_wm_transversetemporal
R_wm_bankssts
R_wm_caudalanteriorcingulate
R_wm_fusiform
R_wm_lingual
R_wm_paracentral
R_wm_parahippocampal
R_wm_parsorbitalis
R_wm_posteriorcingulate
R_wm_precuneus
R_wm_rostralanteriorcingulate
For the resting recordings for the full cohort, the Pearson's correlation between connectivity
and activity is 0.63037. Although this is high, the percentage of ROIs for which there is a
significant difference (p < 10-8) between connectivity and activity is also high, 82,918 of the
97,802 ROIs, i.e. 84.8%. Furthermore, of those ROIs for which connectivity and activity differ,
connectivity is less than activity for 58.7%, χ2 = 2495.92, p < 10-323.
Global activity patterns
A factor was identified with optimal correlation to each of several subject measures. The
factor was a weighted sum of principle components obtained from the resting data regional
activity measures for the entire cohort. The multiple correlation between factor scores on
optimally selected global activity patterns and subject measures are listed in Table 10. A scatter
plot of age vs factor score with regression line is shown in Figure 12. Figure 13 shows the ROIs
which are the dominant contributors to the Age and Sex factors.
F-statistic
8.99
7.82
4.03
3.54
3.87
2.94
n
12/606
15/603
2/575
5/600
7/610
4/580
R
0.38883
0.40362
0.11756
0.16932
0.20621
0.14104
p-value
p < 10-15
p < 10-15
p < 0.02
p < 0.004
p < 0.0004
p < 0.02
Age
Sex
Anxiety
Depression
ACE-R
PSQI
Table 10. Multiple correlation, R, between subject measures and factor scores on global activity patterns are
listed. The relationships with Age and Sex are robust; those with anxiety and depression scores are much less so.
Figure 12. Age and score on the age factor (see text) are
plotted on the x and y axes for each member of the CamCAN
cohort. The best fit regression line is also shown; the
multiple correlation from the factor rotation is 0.38883,
Table 10.
The full cohort was divided by age into three subsets
(vertical gray bars), ages 18-41, 42-64, and 65-87. The
multiple correlations are 0.33985, 0.28373, and 0.33387
respectively, all with p < 10-3. When the cohort is divided
into male and female, p < 10-5 for both subsets. Hence this
result is stationary across the cohort.
The multiple correlation from the factor rotation for Sex vs factor score was 0.40362, Table
10. For the three data subsets, ages 18-41, 42-64, and 65-87, the multiple correlations are
0.47596, 0.45045, and 0.42335 respectively, all with p < 10-5. The correlation between the Age
factor and the Sex factor is 0.0012, i.e. these factors are independent. This was obtained by
computing the dot product of the two factors.
Figure 13. Regional weights are indicated in color. Red indicates a positive weight, blue a negative weight. More
highly saturated colors indicate stronger weights. The weights were obtained using all subsets regression on the 20
"best" principle components of the regional activity measures (see text of Methods). Upper Panel: Weights are
shown for the factor most highly correlated with age. Lower Panel: Weights are shown for the factor most highly
correlated with sex. Note that the correlation between the two weight vectors is 0.0012, i.e. they are independent.
Discussion
Figures 3 and 5 are illustrative examples which are included to provide an overall sense of the
primary output of the referee consensus method, i.e. the copious but fragmentary validated
neuroelectric currents. Figure 5 shows the number of simultaneously active currents for a 300-
second interval from one recording. The number varies markedly with time throughout, as is
typical. In particular, the number of validated currents drops precipitously during periods when
the MEG recording contains movement and other artifacts. This property of the method is
critically important, i.e. that the yield of the solver is sensitive to noise in the MEG recordings. It
supports the supposition that (a) the probabilistic validation of the neuroelectric currents works
and (b) that it automatically rejects noisy recordings, obviating the requirement to identify and
remove noisy data segments from the analysis by hand.
For a two-minute period from one recording, Figure 3 illustrates all of the occurrences of
validated currents for the 3000 locations which showed the greatest activity for this subject. The
activity at each of the 3000 locations waxes and wanes markedly over the two minutes, as does
the occurrence of simultaneous activity for pairs of locations. There are significant periods of
activity at many locations during which there was little or no simultaneous pair activity.
There is considerable detectable neuroelectric activity from the white matter. This is not
unprecedented. MEG-derived evoked responses from thalamocortical fibers have previously
been reported [3,5]. The source magnetic fields are presumed to be due to synchronous volleys
of action potentials, APs. Each AP produces a travelling current quadrupole. The approximate
amplitude has been estimated at 100 Amp-15 meters in an unmyelinated axon [39] with separation
of 1 mm between the two dipoles forming the quadrupole assuming a propagation velocity of 1
meter/second. It is presumed that the velocity is greater in the myelinated fibers which comprise
the white matter. Hence the velocity and dipole separation would be greater. This would decrease
the distance-dependence of the magnetic field strength and so enhance the detectability of this
activity. In addition the magnetic field due to an action potential in a single axon has been
directly measured at about 150 x 10-12 Tesla [7].
A trivial explanation of the profuse findings reported here is that cortical activity is localized
in nearby white matter due either to poor resolution or to head movements. The robust finding of
differential activity between adjacent cortical and white matter ROIs argues against this. So too
does the design of the method which relies on gradients between points within the brain that are
1 mm apart (Appendix 1) coupled with the use of once per second corrections to the forward
solution using continuous head positioning information.
Under the assumption that the white matter is, in fact, the source of profuse measurable
neuroelectric activity, the measured magnetic field components can only be due to synchronous
volleys of APs (Table 11). These produce transient longitudinal intra-axonal currents which are
nearly synchronous in many parallel running axons due to near simultaneous passage of
propagating APs. The detected magnetic field waveforms, e.g. Figure 2, are envelopes which
follow the high frequency waveforms of several AP volleys in sequence. The envelope of a
single highly synchronized AP volley would require well under 10 msec to rise and fall. Hence
this type of activity would be dominated by high frequency content. This is consistent with the
observation that the yield of the solver improves when the low pass cut-off with which the
signals are preprocessed is increased from 150 Hz to 330 Hz [33, figure 3]. It is also consistent
with the observation from a typical task recording that the frequency content of the current
waveforms includes profuse resonant activity with frequency content above 70 Hz [40].
white matter ROI
efferent action potential volleys
▲
▼
afferent action potential volleys
--
--
cortical ROI
action potential volleys
▲
▼
population post-synaptic currents
▲
▼
Table 11. The columns labelled "cortical ROI" and "white matter ROI" indicate the neuroelectric activity which is
the presumed source of the MEG-derived activity measures. The effects of feed-forward excitation and inhibition on
cortical and adjacent white matter activity are indicated with the up- and down- arrows (see text). and indicate
the flow direction for efferent (leaving) and afferent (arriving) action potentials (APs) at the cortical ROI. It is
population post-synaptic currents (shaded) which are presumed to be the primary generators of the magnetic fields
detected using standard MEG processing methods.
effector
Feed-forward excitation
Feed-forward inhibition
Feed-forward excitation
Feed-forward inhibition
For the resting recordings for the full cohort, the Pearson's correlation between cortical and
adjacent white matter activity is 0.81006. Although this is high as might be expected, the
percentage of pairs for which there is a significant difference (p < 10-8) between cortex and
adjacent white matter is also high, 34,640 of the 42,092 ROI pairs, i.e. 82.3%. Furthermore, of
those 34,640 ROI pairs which show a significant cortex vs white matter difference, the white
matter shows more activity than the cortex for 62.6%, χ2 = 2195, df = 1, p < 10-323.
The number of pairs for which the cortex vs adjacent white matter difference changes
between resting and task recordings is also high, 19,402 of 42,092 pairs, 46.1%. But for these
comparisons, there is no preponderance in the direction of the change. A simple speculative
interpretation of this finding is that these rest vs task changes are due to task related feed-forward
excitatory vs inhibitory afferent volleys arriving at the effected ROI pairs (Table 11). Feed-
forward inhibition would reduce (a) the population post-synaptic currents (PPSCs), (b) cortical
excitability, and therefore (c) the incidence of APs in cortical neurons. Efferent APs in the
adjacent white matter would drop due to (c) but afferent APs would remain constant or rise;
hence white matter vs cortical activity would go up. Note that it is cortical PPSCs which are
presumed to be the primary generators of the magnetic fields detected using standard MEG
processing methods.
Conversely, feed-forward excitation would produce the opposite of effects (a) -- (c). Afferent
activity in the white matter ROI would be comparable to that for feed-forward inhibition.
Efferent volleys would increase since cortical APs would increase. But since both AP and PPSC
activity in the cortex would increase, these would supersede increases in the white matter and
cortical vs white matter activity would go up. Note that this implies that changes in cortical vs
white matter activity provide a measure of changes in cortical excitability.
The initiation of an AP in a neuron produces a large voltage difference between the base of
the dendritic tree and the AP trigger zone, i.e. across the neuron's cell body. Since the lumen of
the cell body is much larger than the lumen of an axon, so too is the transient electric current
across the soma and the resultant magnetic field. Hence the changes in AP activity within the
cortex may have a predominant effect on changes in the difference between cortical and adjacent
white matter activity.
The comparison of connectivity with activity provides a measure of locality of neuroelectric
function, e.g. Tables 7, 8, 9, Figures 10, 11. It is not surprising that it is activity, i.e. locality,
rather than connectivity which predominates for most ROIs.
There are robust findings for many ROIs for the preponderance of those in this large
normative cohort from these connectivity vs activity comparisons (Figure 11, Table 9) and from
the cortical vs adjacent white matter activity comparisons (Figure 9, Table 6). The strength of
the statistical analysis provides considerable confidence in the veracity of the findings.
The principle components extracted from this large normative cohort may be conceived as
normative patterns of regional neuroelectric activity. They may be used as measuring rods
against which the MEG-derived activity measures of any individual may be compared. Factors
composed of weighted sums of these patterns may be computed from the neuroelectric measures
during rest from any cohort for which both MEG and symptoms scores or other clinically
relevant measures are present. The factor scores may then be computed for the CamCAN cohort
to identify the normal range. The regions and overall pattern for the factor may then elucidate the
brain mechanisms which underlie the clinical entity.
Concluding remarks
The primary processing of unaveraged MEG recordings with the referee consensus solver
yielded approximately 10,000 neuroelectric current 80-msec waveforms per second localized
with better than 5 mm spatial resolution, each validated at p < 10-4 when corrected for multiple
comparisons. The yield of the solver is summarized in Table 12.
For each cortical region, freesurfer identifies the adjacent white matter rim up to 5 mm thick.
This dimension provides a nominal upper limit for the resolution demonstrated by the consistent
finding of a significant difference in activity between cortical regions and the adjacent white
#currents/subject
6,365,040
6,148,898
#pairs/subject
66,190
59,277
n
619
617
Rest
Task
Table 12. The mean number of neuroelectric currents and number of validated neuroelectric pairs is shown. There
were 516,264 comparison tests were performed for individual measures and 836 tests were performed for cohort-
wide measures. p < 10-12 was set as the threshold for acceptance of each test as significant. This insures that p < 10-2
for each test for individual measures when corrected for multiple comparisons and p < 10-5 for each test of cohort-
wide measures when corrected for multiple comparisons. There were 386,189 significant tests for individual
measures, i.e. a mean of 74.8% of all the comparisons for each subject. There were 221 significant tests of cohort-
wide measures,
matter regions, Tables 4, 6 and Figures 8, 9.
#pair instances/subject
1,000,008
893,435
The secondary processing used in this report reduced the voluminous set of fragmentary
neuroelectric currents to regional counts over several minutes. Tests of differential activity using
these tonic regional measures yield profuse results with robust significance.
(1) The referee consensus method provides profuse reliable measures of neuroelectric brain
activity from cerebral cortex, white matter, and subcortical structures, e.g. hippocampus
and cerebellum. In addition, robust high resolution measures of neuroelectric activity
from the white matter are now accessible.
(2) Post-processing of validated neuroelectric currents using counting statistics provides
profuse reliable measures of neuroelectric connectivity.
(3) Regional measures of activity and connectivity provide a statistically robust and detailed
characterization of each individual's neuroelectric brain function. Comparisons of
regional measures yield profuse and reliable differences between cortex and adjacent
white matter ROIs, between connectivity and activity for a single ROI, between rest and
task for a single ROI, etc.
(4) The group results are robust and demonstrate that a large minority of ROIs demonstrate
stereotypic behavior whereas most ROIs vary from person to person. These findings may
prove useful to (a) identify correspondences between these results and those found using
standard MEG processing methods and/or fMRI and (b) to elucidate the mechanics of
normal and abnormal brain function. Cohort-wide findings include (a) identification of
specific ROIs whose behavior is similar for the preponderance of the cohort and (b)
identification of patterns of brain activity which are correlated with age and sex. The
same factor analytic approach used for these latter results may prove useful in identifying
patterns of neuroelectric brain function related to disease states.
The differential comparison post-processing used here delivers profuse and detailed regional
differences differences/subject (mean)
characterizations of the activity and connectivity for each individual. These findings are
summarized in Table 13. They come with high confidence due to the statistical power of the
individual results. This property provides great promise that these and other MEG-derived
measures may prove useful for clinical diagnosis and for guidance of treatment.
n
Task Rest: Activity
617 57,803
619 81,997
Rest: Activity vs Connectivity
Task: Activity vs Connectivity
617 81,082
Task Rest: Activity vs Connectivity 617 76,879
Rest: Cortex vs Adjacent White Matter 619 34,607
Task: Cortex vs Adjacent White Matter 617 34,513
Task Rest: Cortex vs White Matter 617 19,308
Table 13. Summary of individual and cohort wide differential activity and connectivity comparisons. There were
516,264 comparison tests were performed for individual measures and 836 tests were performed for cohort-wide
measures. p < 10-8 was set as the threshold for acceptance of each test as significant. This insures that p < 10-2 for
each test for individual measures when corrected for multiple comparisons and p < 10-5 for each test of cohort-wide
measures when corrected for multiple comparisons. There were 386,189 significant tests for individual measures,
i.e. a mean of 74.8% of all the comparisons for each subject. There were 221 significant tests of cohort-wide
measures,
differences cohort-wide
0 of 158
73 of 158
69 of 158
3 of 158
40 of 68
36 of 68
0 of 68
93.7 of 158 59.3%
131.9 of 158 83.8%
131.4 of 158 83.2%
124.6 of 158 78.9%
82.2%
55.9 of 68
82.2%
55.9 of 68
46.0%
32.3 of 68
0%
46.2%
43.7%
1.9%
44.144
58.9%
52.9%
0%
The profusion of significant findings for each individual and the implication that this provides
a detailed characterization of regional neuroelectric brain function must be tested for repeat
reliability. Follow up MEG studies have been obtained on 280 of the CamCAN cohort [22] and
are being processed.
The neuroelectric waveforms are extracted with millisecond (msec) resolution. With each 40
msec step through a recording, the solver yields a mean of 455 simultaneously active currents,
each with 80 msec duration and band pass of 10 -- 250 Hz. Hence there is considerable
opportunity to explore network connectivity with multivariate time series methods.
Although the content of the individual waveforms at frequencies below 10 Hz is strongly
attenuated, the solver yields a new bolus of currents for each 40 msec step through the recording.
Hence the count of currents throughout the brain is sampled at 25 Hz, providing access to low
frequencies. Averaging of time series of these counts time locked to a trigger is one approach to
accumulate sufficient counts to explore this low frequency range. Such averaged evoked
responses could be accumulated over voxels up to 6 mm on a side [33, figures 9,10].
The results in this report depend on high localization resolution (better than 5 mm) of each
neuroelectric current. That dependence is of particular importance in enabling comparison of
activity measures between a cortical region and the adjacent white matter rim. Each current is a
vector, i.e. it has a direction in space. Note that analysis of MEG provides two of the three
direction vectors. The magnitude of the radial component of the current cannot be measured.
For the currents localized to cortical layers 4-6, that direction should be normal to the cortical
surface and pointed in toward the white matter. For the currents localized to the deep white
matter, that direction should be concordant with the prevailing direction of the axonal bundles'
course. It may be possible to confirm this directional conjecture for the cortex using the MEG-
derived direction of the currents and the measured geometry of the cortex from the anatomic MR
imaging. Although not available for this cohort, it may be possible to confirm the directional
conjecture for the white matter in a cohort for which both MEG and diffusion tensor imaging
have been obtained.
A formidable problem posed by these results is that there is no comparable method or ground
truth measures to which these findings may be compared. This is particularly true for the
measures of activity from the white matter but only incrementally less so for the measures of
connectivity. It may be that correspondences will be found to findings from fMRI and/or other
MEG studies.
In order to promote exploration of these data by other workers, the output of the primary
processing step is available from the authors. That output includes the complete population of
neuroelectric currents from both resting and task recordings for the full cohort
[http://stash.osgconnect.net/+krieger/ . Example files from this data set are contained in the
supplementary file, S1_Tables.zip.] Access requires registration with CamCAN
[http://www.mrc-cbu.cam.ac.uk/datasets/camcan/] which will also provide access if needed to
the MR imaging, demographics, MEG recordings, and behavioral test results.
Acknowledgements
We gratefully acknowledge the invaluable contributions made to this effort by the Cambridge
(UK) Centre for Ageing and Neuroscience, the Extreme Science and Engineering Development
Environment (XSede), the Open Science Grid (OSG), the San Diego Supercomputing Center, the
Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center, the XSede Neuroscience Gateway, Darren Price, Mats
Rynge, Rob Gardner, Frank Wurthwein, Derek Simmel, Mahidhar Tatineni, Ali Marie Shields.
Data used in the preparation of this work were obtained from the CamCAN repository [22,23].
The OSG [41,42] is supported by the National Science Foundation, 1148698, and the US
Department of Energy's Office of Science.
Supporting Information
S1_Tables.zip: This archive contains several of the cohort-wide atlases and sample summary
results from the individual presented in Tables 2-7 and Figures 6-10. It also contains a typical
output file created by the referee consensus solver. This file contains the particulars from the
13,758 80-msec neuroelectric current waveforms identified in one second from this same
individual's resting MEG recordings.
References
[1] Telkes I, Jimenez-Shahed J, Viswanathan A, Abosch A, Ince N, "Prediction of STN-DBS
electrode implantation track in Parkinson's Disease by using local field potentials," Front.
Neurosci 2016; 10: 1-16. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2016.00198
[2] Moroni F, Nobili L, Curcio G, De Carli F, Fratello F, Marzano C, De Gennaro L, Ferrillo F,
Cossu M, Francione S, Lo Russo G, Bertini M, Ferrara M, "Sleep in the human hippocampus: a
stereo-EEG study," PLoS One 12 Sep 2007; 2(9): e867. doi: 10.13j1/journal.pone.0000867
[3] Kimura T, Ozaki I, Hashimoto I. Impulse propagation along thalamocortical fibers can be
detected magnetically outside the human brain. JNeurosci 19 Nov 2008; 28(47): 12535-12538.
doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.3022-08.2008
[4] S Baillet, J Mosher, R Leahy. Electromagnetic brain mapping. IEEE Signal Procg Mag 18(6),
2001: 14-30, https://ieeexplore-ieee-org.pitt.idm.oclc.org/document/962275
[5] C Papadelis, E Leonardelli, M Staudt, C Braun. Can magnetoencephalography track the
afferent information flow along white matter thalamo-cortical fibers? NeuroImage 60(2), 2012:
1092-1105, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2012.01.054
[6] KW Swinney, JP Wikswo Jr.. A calculation of the magnetic field of a nerve action potential.
BiophysJ 32, 1980: 719-732, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1327234/
[7] BJ Roth, JP Wikswo Jr. The magnetic field of a single axon. A comparison of theory and
experiment. BiophysJ 48, 1985: 93-109,
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1329380/
[8] S Baillet. Magnetoencephalography for brain electrophysiology and imaging. Nature
Neuroscience 20(3), 2017: 327-339, http://www.nature.com/articles/nn.4504
[9] Sarvas J, "Basic mathematical and electromagnetic concepts of the biomagnetic inverse
problem," Phys. Med. Biol. 1987; 32(1): 11-22.
[10] Stok, CJ. The influence of model parameters on EEG/MEG single dipole source estimation.
IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 34(4), 1987: 289-296.
[11] Ossenblok P, Spekreijse H. The extrastriate generators of the EP to checkerboard onset: A
source localization approach. Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology 80, 1991:
181-193.
[12] Rossini, PM, Narici L, Romani GL, Peresson M, Torrioli G, Traversa R. Simultaneous motor
output and sensory input: Cortical interference site resolved in humans via neuromagnetic
measurements. Neuroscience Letters 96, 300-305, 1989.
[13] Cheyne D, Weinberg D. Neuromagnetic fields accompanying unilateral finger movements: Pre-
movement and movement-evoked fields. Experimental Brain Research 78, 1989: 604-612.
[14] Harrop R, Weinberg H, Brickett P, Dykstra C, Robertson A, Cheyne D, Baff M, Crisp D. The
biomagnetic inverse problem: Some theoretical and practical considerations. Physics in
Medicine and Biology 32(12), 1987: 1545-1557.
[15] MS Hamalainen, RJ Ilmoniemi, "Interpreting magnetic fields of the brain: minimum norm
estimates," Med. and Biol. Engg and Compg 32(1): 35-42, 1994, PDF.
[16] RD Pascual Marqui, CM Michel, D Lehmann, "Low-resolution electromagnetic tomography -- a
new method for localizing electrical activity in the brain," Intl J Psychophys 18(1): 49-65, 1994,
PDF.
[17] Van Veen BD, Buckley KM. Beamforming: a versatile approach to spatial filtering. ASSP
Mag. IEEE 5, 1988: 4-24. Doi: 10.1109/53.665
[18] Robinson S, Vrba J. Functional neuroimaging by synthetic aperture magnetometry. Recent
Advances in Biomagnetism, ed T. Yoshimoto, Sendaic Tohoku University Press, 1999: 302-
305.
[19] Hui HB, Pantazis B, Bressler SL, Leahy RM. Identifying true cortical interactions in MEG
using the nulling beamformer. Neuroimage 49, 2010: 3161-3174. doi:
10.1016/j.neuroimage.2009.10.078 .
[20] Diwaker M, Huang MX, Srinivasan R, Harrington DL, Robb A, Angeles A. Dual-core
beamformer for obtaining highly correlated neuronal networks in MEG. Neuroimage 54, 2011:
253-263. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2010.07.023 .
[21] Rana KD, Hamalainen, MS, Valna LM. Improving the nulling beamformer using subspace
suppression. Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience, Methods, 12Jun2018: 1-9. doi:
10.3389/fncom.2018.00035 .
[22] Taylor JR, Williams N, Cusack R, Auer T, Shafto MA, Dixon M, Tyler LK, CamCAN, Henson
RN, "The Cambridge Centre for Ageing and Neuroscience (CamCAN) data repository:
Structural and functional MRI, MEG, and cognitive data from a corss-sectional adult lifespan
sample," Neuroimage 2015; 144: 262-269. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimag.2015.09.018
[23] Shafto MA, Tyler LK, Dixon M, Taylor JR, Rowe JB, Cusack R, Calder AJ, Marslen-Wilson
WD, Duncan J, Dalgleish T, Henson RN, Brayne C, CamCAN, Matthews FE, "The Cambridge
Centre for Ageing and Neuroscience (CamCAN) study protocol: a cross-sectional, lifespan,
multidisciplinary examination of healthy cognitive ageing. BMC Neurology 2014; 14(204).
doi: 10.1186/s12883-014-0204-1
[24] Zigmond AS, Snaith RP. The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale. Acta Psychiatric
Scandinavica Jun 1983; 67(6): 361-370. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0447.1983.tb09716.x
[25] Mioshi E, Dawson K, Mitchell J, Arnold R, Hodges JR. The Addenbrooke's cognitive
examination revised (ACE-R): a brief cognitive test battery for dementia screening. Intl J
Geriatr Psychiatry 2006; 21: 107-1085. doi: 10.1002/gps.1610
[26] Buysse DJ, Hall ML, Strollo PJ, Kamarck TW, Owens J, Lee L, Reis SE, Matthews KA.
Relationships between the Pittsburgh sleep quality index (PSQI), Epworth sleepiness scale
(ESS), and clinical/polysomnographic measures in a community sample. J Clin Sleep Med
2008; 4(6): 563-571.
[27] Fischl B, Sereno M, Dale A, "Cortical surface-based analysis," NeuroImage 199; 9: 195-207.
doi: 10.1006/nimg.1998.0396
[28] Reuter, M., Schmansky NJ, Rosas, HD, Fischl, B. Within-Subject Template Estimation for
Unbiased Longitudinal Image Analysis. Neuroimage 2012; 61 (4), 1402-1418. doi:
10.1016/j.neuroimage.2012.02.084
[29] Scahill RI, Frost C, Jenkins R, Whitwell JL, Rossor MN, Fox NC. A longitudinal study of brain
volume changes in normal aging using serial registered magnetic resonance imaging. Arch
Neurology 2003; 60(7): 989-994. doi: 10.1001/archneur.60.7.989
[30] Elekta Neuromag Oy, Helsinki, Finland. MaxFilter User's Guide, Software Version 2.1, 2008,
Available from http://www.unicog.org/pmwiki/files/MEG/MaxFilter-2.1.pdf
[31] Hamalainen M, MNE Software User's Guide, Version 2.6, 2009. Available from
http://www.nmr.mgh.harvard.edu/martinos/userInfo/data/MNE_register/index.php
[32] Krieger D, Onodipe S, Charles PJ, Sclabassi RJ. Real time signal processing in the clinical
setting. Annals of Biomed Engg 1998; 26: 462-472. 1998. Available from
https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1114%2F1.95.pdf
[33] Krieger D, McNeil M, Zhang J, Puccio A, Schneider W, Li X, Okonwko DO, "Very high
resolution neuroelectric brain imaging by referee consensus processing," Intl. J. Advd. Comp.
Sci. Jan 2014; (4)1: 15-25.
[34] Krieger D, Shepard P, Zusman B, Jana A, Okonkwo DO. Shared high value research resources:
The CamCAN human lifespan neuroimaging dataset processed on the Open Science Grid.
Proceedings of the 2017 IEEE International Conference on Bioinformatics and Biomedicine.
Available from https://arxiv.org/abs/1710.05246
[35] Brown B, Lovato J, Russell K. DCDFLIB, Library of Fortran Routines for Cumulative
Distribution Functions, Inverses, and Other Parameters. Feb1994. Available from
http://www.netlib.org/random/
[36] K Pearson. On Lines and Planes of Closest Fit to Systems of Points in Space. The London,
Edinburgh, and Dublin Philosophical Magazine 1901; 2(11): 559-572. doi:
10.1080/14786440109462720
[37] Hotelling H. Analysis of a complex of statistical variables into principle components. J Educl
Psychology 1933, 24: 417-441, 498-520.
[38] Lawless JF, Singhal K. ISMOD: an all-subsets regression program for generalized linear
models. I. Statistical and computational background. Computer Meth Programs Biomed Apr
1987; 24(2): 117-124. doi: 10.1016/0169-2607(87)90022-8
[39] Hamalainen M, Hari R, Ilmoniemie RJ, Knuutila J, Lounasmaa OV. Magnetoencephalography
-- theory, instrumentation, and applications to noninvasive studies of the working human brain.
Rev. Mod. Physics Apr 1993; 65(2): 413-497. doi: 10.1103/revmodphys.65.413
[40] Krieger DN, Becker J, Fabrizio M, McNeil M, Schneider W, Habeych M, Okonkwo DO.
LP35: Task relevant high frequency neuroelectric oscillations in humans. 30th International
Congress of Clinical Neurophysiology (Berlin, Germany), Mar2014, Abstract published in
ClinNeurophys, Jun 2014; 125(suppl 1): S193. doi: 10.1016/S1388-2457(14)50630-X
[41] Pordes R, Petravick D, Kramer B, Olson D, Livny M, Roy A, Avery P, Blackburn K, Wenaus
T, Wurthwein F, "The open science grid," J Physics 2008; 78. doi: 10.1088/1742-
6596/78/1/012057
[42] Sfiligoi I, Bradley DC, Holzman B, Mhashilkar P, Padhi S, Wurthwein F, "The pilot way to
grid resources using glideinWMS," WIR World Cong Comp Sci and Info Engg 2009; 2: 428-
432. doi: 10.1109/CSIE.2009.950
[43] Krieger D, McNeil M, Zhang J, Schneider W, Li X, Okonkwo DO, "Referee consensus: a
platform technology for nonlinear optimization," XSEDE 2013, ACM Sep 13 2007; 978-1-
4503-2170-9/13/07. doi: 10.1145/2484762.2484789
Appendix I. The referee consensus method
The 2-fold task of the solver is (1) provide a robust measure of confidence that a dipole
current is detected at location X and (2) estimate the time course of the current amplitude
The solver is applied to one 80 msec data segment (Mt=1,…,80) at a time. A decision is made for
one location at a time, e.g.: "Is there a dipole current present at location X?" To answer this
question, spatial filters are constructed from the "viewpoints" for each of 90 distant "referee"
locations distributed widely through the volume of the brain, e.g. R.
Filter PR!X' is constructed with gain 1.0 at R and gain 0.0 at X' 1 mm from X. PR!X' is applied
to the 80 data vectors, Mt=1,…,80, to produce the 80-point univariate time series, VR!X'. A 2nd filter
is constructed, PR!X, with gain 1.0 at R and gain 0.0 at X. PR!X is also applied to Mt=1,…,80 to
produce the 80-point univariate time series, VR!X. Note that there is a small contribution to VR!X'
from activity at X but none from X'. Contrariwise there is a small contribution to VR!X from
activity at X' but none from X. The difference filter is constructed, PR!X'-R!X. This has gain 0.0 at
R and nearly equal and opposite gains at X and X'. PR!X'-R!X applied to Mt=1,…,80 produces VR!X'-
R!X, the difference: VR!X' - VR!X. Note that there is no contribution to this from R. Note too that
each of these 3 filters is constructed with gain 0.0 at each of 89 other "referee" locations coarsely
covering the brain so VR!X'-R!X includes only small contributions from other neuroelectric
currents. This insures that the primary contributors to VR!X' - VR!X are currents close to X and/or
X'.
The "opinion" from the viewpoint of referee R regards the presence of a current at X is obtained
by evaluating this inequality:
(VR!X'-R!X• VR!X')2 > (VR!X'-R!X• VR!X)2
(5)
If the inequality is true, then there is a current at X from the viewpoint of R since VR!X' (left side)
has no contribution from X', VR!X (right side) has none from X, and VR!X'-R!X has nearly equal
contributions from both.
This procedure is repeated for two vector components for each of the 90 referee locations to
produce 180 yes/no "opinions." 114 or more must be "yes" (p << 0.01) to produce an acceptable
"consensus" for this differential. The same procedure is repeated for each of the other 5
differentials since there are two differentials along each of the 3 spatial axes. Only if all 6 exceed
the threshold, i.e. 57 or more of 90 for each of the 6, is a current accepted. 0.016 = 10-12 is
therefore the threshold for accepting a current.
Once a location is validated, an eigenvector analysis is used to identify the 80-point time
course of the current at that location as the waveform which captures the most variance in the
complete set of VR!X'-R!X's. The estimated signal/noise enhancement of 10 provided by this
operation is detailed in the introduction. Note that the validation insures that there is a current
present at X and not at any of the six X's. Hence VR!X'-R!X is used because the primary
contributor to all of the VR!X'-R!X's is due to the current at X. Because the current at X must
dominate any current present at any of the X' s, the ability of the method to identify two currents
near each other is limited to twice the distance, X -- X', i.e. 2 mm.
Appendix II: The referee consensus method -- advantages
Like beamformers, the filters used in the referee consensus method are generated in sets, seven
at a time. But unlike standard filter which are optimized to yield source space measures at the
target/test location, X, all seven referee consensus filters are optimized to yield source space
measures at referee locations remote from the test location, X.
Note that the estimated neuroelectric currents are two-dimensional vector quantities [9]. For
the purpose of intelligibility, they are treated as scalars in the following explanation without loss
of generalization.
For a particular referee location, R, all of the filters have gain 1.0 at R. There is one filter
constrained to have zero gain at X, filter PR!X . This filter, designated "R not X," is optimized to
measure the signal at the referee location but with no contribution from activity at X. There are
six other filters, each constrained to have zero gain at one of the six points 1.0 mm away from X
along the x, y, or z-axis. Hence these filters are also optimized to measure the signal at the referee
location but with no contribution from one of the locations 1 mm away from X along one of the
coordinate axes.
These seven filters are used to generate six difference filters, e.g. PR!X'-R!X where X' is the
location +1 mm away from X along the x-axis.. Note that the difference filters are constrained to
have zero gain at the referee location and near equal but opposite gains at X and the location 1
mm away. Hence they are optimized to measure the difference between the signals at X and at a
location 1 mm away. The magnitude of the gain of these filters at these two "differential"
locations is typically 0.05 -- 0.08 [43, figure 6]. Note that the differencing delivers signal/noise
enhancement of about 2.0 in measuring the differential between activity at X and activity 1 mm
from X.
Conceptually this approach to source space measurement is upside down. The filters for the
location at which measurements are made do not have gain 1.0 at the test location, X, as is the
standard but rather have zero gain either at X or very near it. The power of the approach comes
from the use of families of these filters to develop a consensus decision on the question: Is there
or is there not a neurolectric current at the test location, X? For example, filters PR!X' , PR!X , and
PR!X'-R!X are each applied to an 80 msec MEG data segment to yield three 80 msec data traces,
VR!X' , VR!X , and VR!X'-R!X . If VR!X'-R!X • VR!X' > VR!X'-R!X • VR!X , then there is a current at X
from the "point of view" of referee R.
Note the number of MEG measures used to assess this inequality between two numbers, i.e.
the two dot products. Each element of each of the V's is the dot product of the corresponding
filter with the 306 MEG measures for a single time point. Were both the filter weights and the
MEG measures uncorrelated and normally distributed, the signal/noise enhancement due to the
filtering operations would be approximately sqrt(306) ≈ 17 . To account for the certain significant
departure from both assumptions, we divide the 306 degrees of freedom by 10 as a nominal
correction to this estimate. Hence we estimate signal/noise enhancement due to the filters:
sqrt(30) ≈ 5.
For the decision dot product, i.e. for evaluation of VR!X'-R!X • VR!X' > VR!X'-R!X • VR!X , each V
is composed of 80 such filtered MEG measures. Hence the numbers VR!X'-R!X • VR!X' and VR!X'-
R!X • VR!X are each obtained using 306 x 80 = 24,480 degrees of freedom. By the same reasoning
as above with the same factor of 10 nominal correction, the estimated signal/noise enhancement
due to the filters and the use of the 80-point times series is sqrt(2448) ≈ 50. Note that this estimate
ignores the factor of 2.0 signal/noise enhancement inherent in the difference filter. Note too that
this high signal/noise enhancement applies only to the numbers used in evaluating the inequality,
not to the individual current amplitude measures, i.e. the elements of the V's. This is why the
emphasis in this paper is on the direct results of those decisions, i.e. the counts of validated
neuroelectric currents.
There are 1080 binary decisions computed for a test location, X. one for each of two
orthogonal orientations for each 90 referee locations for each of the six X' s. The collection of
2x90x6 = 1080 decisions provides a cost function which is used to assess the consensus: Is there
or is there not a neuroelectric current at X. This procedure is robust enough to use 10-12 as the
threshold p-value to accept X as a true source of a detectable magnetic field. If and only if this
probabilistic threshold is met, the 1080 outputs of the difference filters, the VR!X'-R!X's, are
combined by an eigenvector calculation which is akin to averaging [Appendix I] to generate an
estimate of the 80-point time course for the current.
Computation for each of these decisions generates its own optimal difference filter, PR!X'-R!X,
and corresponding optimal 80-point current time series estimate, VR!X'-R!X. As detailed above, the
signal/noise enhancement estimate for the elements of the V's, i.e. the current magnitude
measures, are modest, ≈ 5, and likely comparable to those for most filtering methods. But the
estimate obtained by this average-like operation over 1080 such difference filters again enhances
the signal/noise by an additional factor of perhaps sqrt(1080/10) ≈ 10, producing total signal/noise
enhancement for the current times series waveform estimate of about 50.
|
1601.06420 | 1 | 1601 | 2016-01-24T19:31:44 | Explicit moments of decision times for single- and double-threshold drift-diffusion processes | [
"q-bio.NC",
"math.PR",
"q-fin.MF"
] | We derive expressions for the first three moments of the decision time (DT) distribution produced via first threshold crossings by sample paths of a drift-diffusion equation. The "pure" and "extended" diffusion processes are widely used to model two-alternative forced choice decisions, and, while simple formulae for accuracy, mean DT and coefficient of variation are readily available, third and higher moments and conditioned moments are not generally available. We provide explicit formulae for these, describe their behaviors as drift rates and starting points approach interesting limits, and, with the support of numerical simulations, discuss how trial-to-trial variability of drift rates, starting points, and non-decision times affect these behaviors in the extended diffusion model. Both unconditioned moments and those conditioned on correct and erroneous responses are treated. We argue that the results will assist in exploring mechanisms of evidence accumulation and in fitting parameters to experimental data. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Explicit moments of decision times for single- and double-threshold
drift-diffusion processes
V. Srivastava1, P. Holmes1,2 and P. Simen3
1Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering,
2Program in Applied and Computational Mathematics and Princeton Neuroscience Institute
Princeton University, NJ 08544.
3Department of Neuroscience, Oberlin College, OH 44704.
September 19, 2018
Abstract
We derive expressions for the first three moments of the decision time (DT) distribution
produced via first threshold crossings by sample paths of a drift-diffusion equation. The "pure"
and "extended" diffusion processes are widely used to model two-alternative forced choice deci-
sions, and, while simple formulae for accuracy, mean DT and coefficient of variation are readily
available, third and higher moments and conditioned moments are not generally available. We
provide explicit formulae for these, describe their behaviors as drift rates and starting points
approach interesting limits, and, with the support of numerical simulations, discuss how trial-
to-trial variability of drift rates, starting points, and non-decision times affect these behaviors
in the extended diffusion model. Both unconditioned moments and those conditioned on cor-
rect and erroneous responses are treated. We argue that the results will assist in exploring
mechanisms of evidence accumulation and in fitting parameters to experimental data.
Keywords: decision time, diffusion model, conditioned and unconditioned moments
Classification: Decision theory
Running title: Explicit moments for diffusion processes
1
Introduction
In this paper we derive explicit expressions for the mean, variance, coefficient of variation and
skewness of decision times (DTs) predicted by the stochastic differential equation (SDE)
dx = a dt + σ dW, x(0) = x0,
(1)
which models accumulation of the difference x(t) between the streams of evidence in two-alternative
forced-choice tasks. An example of such a perceptual decision-making task is one in which a
participant determines if the image on the screen has more white or black pixels (e.g., [23]) Here
drift rate a and standard deviation σ are constants, dW denotes independent random (Wiener)
increments, and dx is the change in evidence during the time interval (t, t + dt). Decision times
(DTs) are determined by first passages through upper and lower thresholds x = +z and −z that
respectively correspond to correct responses and errors, between which the starting point x0 is
1
assumed to lie. Thus, without loss of generality we may set a > 0, although we will also consider
limits a → 0. Predictions of response times (RTs) for comparison to behavioral data are obtained
by adding to DTs a non-decision latency, Tnd, to account for sensory and motor processes.
SDEs like Eqn. (1) are variously called diffusion or drift-diffusion models (DDMs); in [4] Eqn. (1)
was named the pure DDM to distinguish it from Ratcliff's extended diffusion model [20], which
allows trial to trial variability in drift rates and starting points x0. See [20, 24, 4] for background
on diffusion models, and note that several different variable-naming conventions are used in param-
eterizing DDMs, e.g. in [20, 24, 32] v and s replace a and σ, and thresholds are set at x = 0 and
x = a with x0 ∈ [0, a]; in [4] a and σ are named A and c.
Many of the following results have appeared in the stochastic process literature, or are implicit
in it, and some have appeared in the psychological literature (e.g.
[20, 32, 13]). However, their
dependence on key parameters such as threshold and starting point and behaviors in the limits of
low and high drift rates have not been fully explored (see [32] for some cases of a → 0). Nor are
we aware of explicit derivations of third order moments. Here we provide these, and also prove
a Proposition that describes the structure of the coefficient of variation (CV) for DTs predicted
by Eqn. (1), relating it to the CV for a single-threshold DDM. We summarize the expressions for
moments of decision times in Table 1. The MatLab and R code for these expressions is available at:
https://github.com/PrincetonUniversity/higher_moments_ddm. We end by considering the
extended DDM, introduced in [20], showing how trial-to-trial variability of drift rates and starting
points affects the results for the pure DDM and examining the effects of non-decision latency on
response times.
Notation and units
We start by reviewing definitions and dimensional units and establishing notation. For a random
variable ξ, we define the n-th non-central moment by E[ξn] and the n-th central moment by E[(ξ −
E[ξ])n]. The first central moment is zero and the second central moment is the variance. The
coefficient of variation (CV) of ξ is defined as the ratio of standard deviation to mean of ξ, i.e.,
CV =(cid:112)E[(ξ − E[ξ])2]/E[ξ]. Similarly, the skewness of ξ is defined as the ratio of the third central
moment to the cube of the standard deviation of ξ:
skew =
E[(ξ − E[ξ])3]
E[(ξ − E[ξ])2]3/2
.
The variable x(t) and thresholds ±z in Eqn. (1) are dimensionless, while the parameters a and σ
have dimensions [time]−1 and [time]− 1
2 respectively. When providing numerical examples we will
work in secs. For a > 0 we define the normalized threshold kz and starting point kx:
kz =
az
σ2 ≥ 0 and kx =
ax0
σ2 ∈ (−kz, kz);
(2)
these nondimensional parameters will allow us to give relatively compact expressions.
2 The single-threshold DDM
Eqn. (1) with a single upper threshold z > 0 necessarily produces only correct responses in de-
cision tasks, but it is of interest because it provides a simple approximation of the two-threshold
2
DDM when accuracy is at ceiling and errors due to passages through the lower threshold are
rare. Specifically, for a > 0, DTs of this model with starting point x0 are described by the Wald
(inverse-Gaussian) distribution [6, Eq. (2.0.2)],[33, 18].
(cid:114) 1
(cid:18)−(z − x0 − at)2
p(t) =
z − x0
σ
2πt3 exp
2σ2t
(cid:19)
(cid:112)Var[DT]
E[DT]
(3)
(4)
=
1√
kz − kx
,
The mean DT, its variance, and CV are:
E[DT] =
σ2
a2 (kz − kx), Var[DT] =
σ4
a4 (kz − kx), and CV =
and the skewness is
3√
kz − kx
(5)
In the limit a → 0+, the distribution (3) converges to the L´evy distribution, and in this limit none
of the moments exist. However, as shown below, moments of the double threshold DDM exist in
this limit.
(= 3 CV).
The single threshold process has been proposed as a model for interval timing [25, 19, 2, 28].
Interval timing, loosely defined, is the capacity either to make a response or judgment at a specific
time relative to some event in the environment, or simply to estimate inter-event durations. Classic
timing tasks include "production" tasks, such as the Fixed Interval (FI) task, in which a participant
receives a reward for any response produced after a delay of a given duration since the last reward
was received [9], and discrimination tasks, in which two different stimulus durations are compared
to see which is longer (see [7] and [29] for historical reviews of early human timing research).
Production tasks can be modeled similarly to decision tasks by a diffusion model:
instead of
accumulating evidence about a perceptual choice, a timing diffusion model accumulates a steady
"clock signal" toward a threshold for responding [7, 12, 17, 29]. The resulting production times,
relative to stimulus onset, are then comparable to perceptual decision-making response times,
typically yielding a slightly positively skewed Gaussian density [11]. Simen et al. [27] show that
the single-threshold DDM can fit RT data from a variety of interval timing experiments when the
starting point is set to 0, drift is set equal to threshold over duration (a = z/T , with T = target
duration), and normalized thresholds kz are set to high values, typically of order 20 (see [25]). In
contrast, kz is usually much lower in fits of typical two-choice decision data, typically of order 1.
Noise σ is typically fixed at 0.1 in the literature [30] and fitted thresholds typically range from
0.05 to 0.15; see e.g.
[3, 5, 8, 22]. Despite this difference, DDM can be fitted to both two-choice
decision RTs and timed production RTs in humans with suitably larger thresholds for timing [28],
suggesting that both tasks may be accomplished by similar accumulation processes.
3 The double-threshold DDM: Unconditional moments of decision
time
We now turn to the two-threshold DDM and derive unconditional moments of decision time. The
DT distribution for the double-threshold DDM may be expressed as a convergent series [20, Ap-
pendix], and successive moments of the unconditional DT (i.e. averaged over correct responses
and errors) may be obtained by solving boundary value problems for a sequence of linear ordinary
3
differential equations (ODEs) derived from the backwards Fokker-Planck or Kolmogorov equation
[10, Chap. 5].
3.1 Error rate and expected decision time
The expressions for error rate and mean decision time are well known, although the following forms
are more compact than those given in [4], for example:
ER =
E[DT] =
(cid:104)
e−2kx − e−2kz
e2kz − e−2kz
σ2
a2
,
kz coth(2kz) − kze−2kx csch(2kz) − kx
(cid:105)
.
In Appendix A we show that these expressions agree with the analogous ones of [4].
For an unbiased starting point kx = 0 the mean decision time becomes
σ2kz
a2
and in the limit a → 0 (kz → 0, kx → 0) we have
E[DT] =
tanh(kz),
ER =
kz − kx
2kz
z − x0
2z
=
and E[DT] =
σ2(k2
z − k2
x)
a2
z2 − x2
0
σ2
.
=
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
Expressions for the error rate and unconditional moments of decision time are illustrated in
Figs. 1 and 2 below.
3.2 Variance and coefficient of variation of decision time
We derive the following expression for the unconditional variance of decision time in Appendix B:
(cid:104)
σ4
a4
z e−4kx csch2(2kz) + kz coth(2kz) − kze−2kx csch(2kz) − kx
−k2
z csch2(2kz) − 2k2
3k2
(cid:105)
z e−2kx csch(2kz) coth(2kz) − 4kzkxe−2kx csch(2kz)
Var =
.
(10)
For an unbiased starting point kx = 0 Eqn. (10) reduces to
(cid:2)2k2
z (csch2(2kz) − csch(2kz) coth(2kz)) + kz(coth(2kz) − csch(2kz))(cid:3)
(cid:2)kz tanh(kz) − k2
(cid:20) kz(1 − 4kze−2kz − e−4kz )
z sech2(kz)(cid:3) =
(cid:21)
(1 + e−2kz )2
σ4
a4
Var =
=
σ4
a4
σ4
a4
(cf. [32, Eqns. (10-12)]), and in the limit a = 0 we have
Var =
2σ4(k4
z − k4
x)
3a4
=
2(z4 − x4
0)
3σ4
.
(cid:2)3k2
The coefficient of variation can be determined from Eqns. (10) and (7):
CV =
1
2
[Var]
E[DT]
=
z csch2(2kz) − 2k2
z e−2kx csch(2kz) coth(2kz) − . . . − kx
kz coth(2kz) − kze−2kx csch(2kz) − kx
4
(11)
(12)
(cid:3) 1
2
;
(13)
the complete numerator appears in brackets in Eqn. (10). For kx = 0 Eqn. (13) reduces to
CV =
1 − 2kz csch(2kz)
kz[coth(2kz) − csch(2kz)]
=
1 − 4kze−2kz − e−4kz
kz(1 − e−2kz )2
,
and in the case a = 0, from Eqs. (12) and (9) we have
CV =
2(z2 + x2
0)
3(z2 − x2
0)
→
as z → ∞ or x0 → 0.
(cid:115)
(cid:115)
(cid:115)
(cid:114) 2
3
(14)
(15)
Note that the multiplicative factors σ2/a2 cancel and that CV depends only upon the nondimen-
sional threshold and starting point kz, kx (or x0/z in case a = 0).
following behaviors in the limit z → ∞ (kz → ∞) for kx fixed:
If a > 0, as the threshold z increases, E[DT] and Var both increase, but CV decreases, with the
E[DT]
kz
→ σ2
a2 ,
→ σ4
a4
Var
kz
z cschn(2kz) ∼ km
and CV → k
− 1
z
2
;
(16)
limit (cid:112)2/3 (Eqn. (15)). In §5 we describe the behavior of the CV with unbiased starting point
z e−2nkz and coth(2kz) ∼ 1. For a = 0,
these behaviors follow from the facts that km
E[DT] and Var also increase with z, as one sees from Eqns. (9) and (12), but CV approaches the
kx = 0 throughout the range kz ∈ (0,∞), and show that the CV of the single threshold DDM
provides an upper bound for Eqn. (14).
3.3 Third moment and skewness of decision time
We end this section by computing the expression for skewness. The third moment of decision time
can be computed by solving a boundary value problem analogous to that in Appendix B. However,
this computation is very tedious. Instead we obtain skewness from the non-central third moments
of DTs conditioned on correct responses and errors derived in §4 below (this also illustrates the
relationships between unconditioned and conditioned moments). Introducing the notation τ for
DT, the non-central third moments can be written as
E[τ 3x(τ ) = z] = Skew+Var3/2
+ + 3Var+ E[DT]+ + E[DT]3
+,
E[τ 3x(τ ) = −z] = Skew−Var3/2− + 3Var− E[DT]− + E[DT]3−,
(18)
where E[DT]±, Var±, Skew± denote expected value, variance, and skewness of DT conditioned
on correct responses and errors, respectively. Summing appropriate fractions of these conditional
moments gives the unconditioned third moment
and
(17)
E[τ 3] = (1 − ER) × E[τ 3x(τ ) = z] + ER × E[τ 3x(τ ) = −z],
(19)
from which skewness can be derived as follows:
(cid:34)(cid:18) τ − E[DT]
(cid:19)3(cid:35)
Var
1
2
Skew = E
E[τ 3] − 3Var E[DT] − E[DT]3
Var
3
2
.
(20)
=
5
Substituting the expressions (6) for ER and (29), (31) and (36) for conditional moments from §4
into Eqns. (17-19), and using the expressions (7) and (10) for the mean and variance of DT, we
obtain
(cid:20)(cid:16)
E[τ 3] − 3Var E[DT] − E[DT]3
z − 12k3
z + 6k2
(24kxk2
σ6
a6
=
− (12k2
− 8k3
z )e−2kz−4kx + (24k2
z + 6kz)e−2kx
z + 12k3
z + 6k2
xkz + 12kxk2
z e−6kx − 3kz cosh(2kz) + 3kz cosh(6kz) + 9kx sinh(2kz) − 3kx sinh(6kz) + 56k3
z sinh(2kz) − (3kz − 6k2
xkz + 24kxkz − 16k3
z + 3kz)e4kz−2kx − (24kxk2
z + 12kxkz − 12kxk2
xkz)e−4kz−2kx
z + 12kxkz + 4k3
z + 12k2
z + 6k2
z + 4k3
z )e2kz−4kx
(cid:21)
z cosh(2kz)
(cid:17) csch3(2kz)
+ 36k2
.
(21)
4
(cid:104)
Finally, skewness may be obtained by substituting Eqns. (10) and (21) into Eqn. (20). After
substitution, the σ6/a6 factors cancel out so that, like CV, skewness depends only on kz and kx.
For an unbiased starting point x0 = kx = 0, Eqn. (21) can be simplified to
E[τ 3] − 3Var E[DT] − E[DT]3 =
σ6
a6
3kz tanh(kz) − 3k2
z sech2(kz) − 2k3
z tanh(kz)sech2(kz)
.
(22)
We also note that the limits of the double-threshold moments approach those of the single-threshold
moments as kz → ∞ with kx fixed. Specifically:
a4 , CV → k
and Skew → 3k
− 1
z = 3 CV.
→ σ2
a2 ,
→ σ4
E[DT]
− 1
z
(23)
2
2
kz
Var
k2
z
(cid:105)
In the limit a = 0, we obtain
E[τ 3] − 3Var E[DT] − E[DT]3 =
16(z6 − x6
0)
σ6
,
and Skew =
(cid:114) 96
25
(z6 − x6
0)
(z4 − x4
0)3/2
,
(24)
and the skewness to CV ratio is 12/5 as z → ∞ or x0 → 0.
Two further limits are of interest, those in which the starting point approaches either threshold:
kx → ±kz with kz fixed and finite. In this case ER → 0 or 1, E[DT] → 0, CV → ∞, and Skew
→ ∞. Letting kx = ±kz(1 − ) and expanding for small ≥ 0, we have
(cid:104)
(cid:20)
E[DT] =
=
σ2
a2
σ2
a2
kz coth(2kz) − kze∓2kz(1−) csch(2kz) ∓ kz(1 − )
±1 −
(kz ∓ kx) + O(kz ∓ kx2) → 0+.
4kz
e±4kz − 1
(cid:21)
(cid:105)
Similarly, for the variance and third central moment, we have
Var =
σ2
a2
E[(τ − E[τ ])3] = ∓ σ3
a3
z (1 + 3e±4kz )
(e±4kz − 1)2 +
18 sinh(2kz) − 6 sinh(6kz) + e±2kz (112k3
e±4kz − 1
± 1
4kz
(cid:20)∓8k2
(cid:104)
(cid:21)
(cid:105)
(kz ∓ kx) + O(kz ∓ kx2) → 0+,
z − 12kz) + 24kze∓kz
−12kze−6kz + 256k3
z e∓2kz + 16k3
z e∓6kz
(kz ∓ kx) + O(kz ∓ kx2) → 0+,
(27)
(25)
(26)
6
so that both CV and skewness diverge like kz ∓ kx−1/2. However, the ratio of skewness to CV
remains finite as kx → ±kz.
Examples of the functions E[DT], Var, CV, skewness and the third central moment of DT are
plotted vs. threshold z in the left hand columns of Figs. 1 and 2 below.
4 The double-threshold DDM: Conditional moments of decision
time
We now turn to moments of DTs conditioned on correct and incorrect responses, deriving them
from cumulant and moment generating functions using a method detailed in Appendix C that
requires only successive differentiation (see [15, Chap 4, §6] and [10, §2.6]). It suffices to consider
only correct decisions, because the moments conditioned on errors can be obtained by replacing x0
by −x0, or equivalently, kx by −kx in the following expressions, as demonstrated by the moment
generating functions (58) and (59) in Appendix C. The following expressions for the conditional
moments of decision time are illustrated in Figs. 1 and 2.
4.1 Conditional cumulant generating function and expected decision time
As derived there from Eqn. (58), the cumulant-generating function of DTs conditioned on correct
decisions is
(cid:16) (z + x0)
√
(cid:17) − log sinh
(cid:16) 2z
√
(cid:17)
a2 − 2ασ2
σ2
a2 − 2ασ2
σ2
,
(28)
K+(α) = C(a, σ, z, x0) + log sinh
where C(a, σ, z, x0) is a function independent of α that will disappear when the cumulants are
computed by successive differentiation of K+(α) with respect to α.
The expected DT conditioned on correct decisions is the first derivative of K+(α) evaluated at
and it can be verified that in the limit a → 0+
E[DT]+ =
4z2 − (z + x0)2
3σ2
.
7
α = 0:
E[DT]+ = E[τx(τ ) = z] =
=
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)α=0
(cid:16) 2az
(cid:17) − z + x0
(cid:16) a(z + x0)
(cid:17)
σ2
2z
a
=
coth
K+(α)
2kz coth(2kz) − (kx + kz) coth(kx + kz)
σ2
a
coth
(cid:17)
(cid:16)
d
dα
σ2
a2
,
(29)
(30)
4.2 Conditional variance and coefficient of variation of decision time
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)α=0
(cid:16) 2za
σ2
The variance of DT conditioned on correct decisions is the second derivative of K+(α) at α = 0:
Var+ = Var[τx(τ ) = z] =
(cid:17)
d2
dα2 K+(α)
2σ2z
a3 coth
(cid:17) − (z + x0)2
a2 csch2(cid:16) 2za
(cid:2)4k2
z csch2(2kz) + 2kz coth(2kz) − (kx + kz)2 csch2(kx + kz) − (kx + kz) coth(kx + kz)(cid:3) ;
(cid:17)
(cid:16) a(z + x0)
csch2(cid:16) a(z + x0)
σ2
− σ2(z + x0)
(cid:17)
coth
σ2
σ2
a2
a3
+
=
=
4z2
σ4
a4
in the limit a → 0+:
Var+ =
32z4 − 2(z + x0)4
45σ4
.
(31)
(32)
The CV of DT conditioned on correct decisions is therefore
z csch2(2kz) + 2kz coth(2kz) − (kx + kz)2 csch2(kx + kz) − (kx + kz) coth(kx + kz)(cid:3)1/2
(cid:2)4k2
2kz coth(2kz) − (kx + kz) coth(kx + kz)
CV+ =
1
2
Var+
E[DT]+
=
;
(33)
again, the factors σ2/a2 cancel and the conditional CV depends only on kz and kx.
As in §3 Eqns. (25-26), it can be shown that CV+ diverges as kx → kz (and hence, by the
kx ↔ −kx symmetry, CV− diverges as kx → −kz). However, the behavior as kx → −kz is more
interesting and quite subtle, especially as kz also becomes small. To study this double limit we first
set kx = βkz, where β ∈ (−1, 1), and expand the hyperbolic functions in Taylor series for kz (cid:28) 1
(e.g. [1, Eqns.(4.5.65-66]) to obtain
(34)
z )(cid:3)1/2
z + O(k6
(cid:2) 2
45 (β2 + 2β + 5)(3 − 2β − β2)k4
(cid:21)1/2
(cid:20) 2(β2 + 2β + 5) + O(k2
3 (3 − 2β − β2)k2
z + O(k4
z )
z )
5(3 − 2β − β2) + O(k2
z )
1
.
CV+ =
=
It follows that
(cid:115)
CV+ →
2(β2 + 2β + 5)
5(3 − β2 − 2β)
In these distinguished limits, CV+ can approach any value in the range ((cid:112)2/5,∞). For β = 0
(kx = 0) the starting point is unbiased (or a = 0), and we obtain the limit CV+ =(cid:112)2/3, as for
the unconditioned CV; cf. Eqn. (15) and see Proposition 5.1 below. For β → 1− the starting point
lies on the correct threshold and CV+ diverges as noted above. Aspects of this limiting behavior
are illustrated in Fig. 4 below.
(35)
as kz → 0+.
8
4.3 Conditional third moment and skewness of decision time
Skew+Var
3
2
3
2
The third central moment of DT conditioned on correct decisions is the third derivative of K+(α),
evaluated at α = 0. The skewness of DT is obtained by dividing the third central moment with
the cube of standard deviation. Thus, the third central moment of DT is
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)α=0
csch2(cid:16) 2az
(cid:17)
(cid:16) a(z + x0)
σ2
+
+
σ2
+ = Var
12σ2z2
a4
=
− 3σ2(z + x0)2
− 3σ4(z + x0)
a4
(cid:17)
16z3
a3 coth
d3
dα3 K+(α)
csch2(cid:16) 2az
(cid:16) 2az
(cid:17)
+ × skewness[τx(τ ) = z] =
(cid:17) − 2(z + x0)3
(cid:17)
csch2(cid:16) a(z + x0)
(cid:16) a(z + x0)
(cid:17)
z coth(2kz) csch2(2kz) + 6kz coth(2kz) − 3(kz + kx)2 csch2(kz + kx)
(cid:16) 2az
csch2(cid:16) a(z + x0)
(cid:2)12k2
−2(kz + kx)3 coth(kz + kx) csch2(kz + kx) − 3(kz + kx) coth(kz + kx)(cid:3) .
z csch2(2kz) + 16k3
6σ4z
a5 coth
(cid:17)
=
σ6
a6
(cid:17)
coth
coth
(36)
σ2
σ2
σ2
σ2
σ2
a3
σ2
a5
An expression for Skew+ is obtained by dividing Eqn. (36) by the 3/2 power of Eqn. (31). In the
limit a → 0+ Eqn. (36) becomes
1024z6 − 16(z + x0)6
3
2
+ =
Skew+Var
Similar to CV+, Skew+ diverges as kx → kz. For kx = βkz and β ∈ (−1, 1),
and Skew+ =
945σ6
2
8(64z6 − (z + x0)6)
21(16z4 − (z + x0)4)
√
Skew+ → 4
10
7
(β2 + 3)(β2 + 4β + 7)
(β2 + 2β + 5)3/2(3 − 2β − β2)1/2
,
as kz → 0+.
√
In these distinguished limits Skew+ can approach any value in the range (4
In Figs. 1 and 2 key expressions derived above are plotted vs. threshold z for the DDM (1) with
a = 0.2, σ = 0.1, and x0 = −0.01. These parameter values were chosen as representative of fits to
human data (e.g. [26]), and to illustrate the general forms of the functions. Drift values in this case
might be expected to range from -0.4 to 0.4 (e.g. [22]). See also, among many others, [3, 2, 5, 8],
for similar ranges of fitted parameter values. The results of Monte-Carlo simulations of Eqn. (1)
using the Euler-Maruyama method [16] with step size 10−4 are also shown for comparison. Note
that, even with 10,000 sample paths, numerical estimates of the third moment and skewness have
not converged very well.
10/7,∞).
(cid:35)
.
3
2
(37)
(38)
(cid:114) 45
(cid:34)
5 Behavior of CVs
We first consider the unconditional CV with unbiased starting point x0 = kx = 0, for which we can
prove the following result.
Proposition 5.1. Behavior of CVs of decision times for the DDM. The CV for the double-threshold
DDM with kx = 0, Eqn. (14), is bounded above by the CV for the single-threshold DDM, Eqn. (4):
(cid:113) 1
kz
(1 − e−4kz − 4kze−2kz )
1 − e−2kz
def= F (kz) <
9
(cid:114) 1
kz
.
(39)
(a) Expected DT
(b) Expected DT conditioned on cor-
rect decision
(c) Expected DT conditioned on error
(d) Variance of DT
(e) Variance of DT conditioned on cor-
rect decision
(f) Variance of DT conditioned on er-
ror
(g) CV of DT
(h) CV of DT conditioned on correct
decision
(i) CV of DT conditioned on error
Figure 1: Expected decision times, variances and CVs of decision times for a DDM with a = 0.2,
σ = 0.1, and x0 = −0.01, showing dependence on threshold z. Solid curves represent functions
derived in §3 and §4; dashed line segments connect point values obtained by 10,000 Monte-Carlo
simulations of Eqn. (1). Note the non-monotonicity evident in panel h.
Moreover, F (0) =(cid:112)2/3 and F (kz) decays monotonically as kz increases.
For the proof of the above proposition see Appendix D. Fig. 3 illustrates the proposition by
plotting both CV functions over the range 0 ≤ kz ≤ 10.
It seems difficult to prove a result analogous to Proposition 5.1 for the general CV expressions
of Eqns. (10) and (31) due to their complexity. However, plots of the unconditional and conditional
10
Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1E[DT]00.10.20.30.40.50.60.7Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1E[DT]+00.10.20.30.40.50.60.7Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1E[DT]−00.10.20.30.40.50.60.7Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1Var00.050.10.15Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1Var+00.050.10.15Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1Var−00.050.10.15Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1CV0.511.5Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1CV+0.511.5Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1CV−0.511.5 (a) Third central moment of DT
(b) Third central moment of DT con-
ditioned on correct decision
(c) Third central moment of DT con-
ditioned on incorrect decision
(d) Skewness of DT
(e) Skewness of DT conditioned on
correct decision
(f) Skewness of DT conditioned on in-
correct decision
Figure 2: Third central moments and skewnesses of decision times for a DDM with a = 0.2, σ = 0.1,
and x0 = −0.01, showing dependence on threshold z. Solid curves represent functions derived in
§3 and §4; dashed line segments connect point values obtained by 10,000 Monte-Carlo simulations
of Eqn. (1).
Figure 3: Coefficients of variation as functions of kz for the single threshold DDM (dashed) and
the DDM with double thresholds and kx = 0 (solid).
11
Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1Skew×Var3/200.010.020.030.040.050.060.07Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1Skew+×Var3/2+00.010.020.030.040.050.060.07Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1Skew−×Var3/2−00.010.020.030.040.050.060.07Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1Skew11.522.533.5Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1Skew+11.522.533.5Thresholdz0.020.040.060.080.1Skew−11.522.533.5kz0246810CV00.20.40.60.81 (a) Unconditioned CV vs. kx
(b) Unconditioned CV vs. kz
(c) CV conditioned on correct decision vs. kx
(d) CV conditioned on correct decision vs. kz
(e) CV conditioned on error vs. kx
(f) CV conditioned on error vs. kz
Figure 4: Coefficients of variation of decision time as functions of kx = ax0/σ2 for several kz's (left
column) and kz = az/σ2 for several kx's (right column). Unconditioned CVs are shown in top row,
conditioned CVs in middle and bottom rows. Observe the symmetry kx (cid:55)→ −kx relating the latter,
as noted at the beginning of §4.
CVs as functions of the normalized threshold and starting point kz = az/σ2 and kx = ax0/σ2
12
kx-2-1.5-1-0.500.511.52CV012345kz=2kz=1.6kz=1.2kz=0.8kz=0.4kx=±0.01kx=±1kx=±1.5kx=0kx=±0.5kz00.511.52CV012345kz=0.4kz=0.8kz=1.2kz=1.6kz=2kx-2-1.5-1-0.500.511.52CV+012345kx=0.5kx=0.01kx=1kx=1.5kx=−0.01kx=−0.5kx=−1kx=−1.5kz00.511.52CV+012345kz=0.4kz=0.8kz=1.2kz=1.6kz=2kx-2-1.5-1-0.500.511.52CV−012345kx=−0.01kx=0.01kx=0.5kx=−0.5kx=−1.5kx=1.5kx=1kx=−1kz00.511.52CV−012345 shown in Fig. 4 illustrate their behavior over the (kz, kx)-plane.
ditioned CVs converge to(cid:112)2/3 from below as kz → 0+ (see right column). However, for kx (cid:54)= 0,
Here, as shown in Proposition 5.1 and Eqns. (34-35), for kx = 0 both conditioned and uncon-
the behavior is significantly different. In particular, as shown in §3, Eqns. (25-26), the uncondi-
tioned CVs diverge as kx → ±kz (see left column). CVs for symmetric starting points ±kx diverge
along different curves as kx → kz; however, these curves converge to each other as kz → 0+ (see
left column). Similarly, CVs conditioned on correct responses and errors diverge as kx → kz and
kx → −kz respectively. Interestingly, CVs conditioned on correct responses and errors converge to
finite limits smaller than (cid:112)2/3 as kx → −kz < 0 and kx → kz > 0 respectively. In Fig. 4(d), as
shown in §4, CV+ converges to(cid:112)2/5 as kx → −kz and kz → 0+. It is interesting to note that this
convergence is not monotone.
The bottom four panels of Fig. 4 illustrate the symmetry of moments conditioned on correct
responses and errors with respect to kx (cid:55)→ −kx, noted at the beginning of §4. Unlike the case kx = 0
for which CV is monotonic in kz, as shown in Proposition 5.1, conditioned CVs are not monotone
functions of z or kz in general. Some instances of non-monotonicity appear in Figs. 1(h), 4(d) and
4(f) above.
6 Behavior of moments for the extended DDM
We end by describing some results for the extended DDM introduced by Ratcliff [20], specifically,
the effects of drawing drift rates and starting points for Eqn. (1) from Gaussian and uniform
distributions N (a, σa) and U(x0 − sx
2 ∈ [−z, z], and standard
deviation σa and range sx characterize trial-to-trial variability of drift rates and starting points.
Complete analytical results on moments for this extended model are not known, and we therefore
perform numerical studies.
In particular we investigate departures from the analytical results
derived above as the variance/range of the distributions N and U increase from zero. We also
consider the effects of non-decision time.
2 ) respectively, where x0 ± sx
2 , x0 + sx
6.1 Analytical and semi-analytical expressions
We first discuss how expressions for the moments of decision times and error rate for the pure DDM
can be leveraged to efficiently compute analogous explicit expressions for the extended DDM. For
clarity, we denote the decision time of the pure DDM for a given drift rate a and starting point x0
by τ (a, x0), and the error rate by ER(a, x0). The following expressions for the extended DDM are
illustrated in Fig. 5.
The error rate of the extended DDM is the expected value of the error rate of the pure DDM
averaged over the distributions of drift rates and starting points:
(cid:2)EX0
(cid:2)ER(A, X0)(cid:3)(cid:3),
ER = EA
(40)
where EY [·] denotes the expected value computed over the distribution of random variable Y . The
expectation over the random starting point X0 in (40) can be computed explicitly as
(41)
where kδ = aδ/σ2 and sinch(·) := sinh(·)/(·). Note that this expression reduces to Eqn. (6) for
δ = 0, using sinch(0) = 1.
e2kz − e−2kz
,
EX0[ER(a, X0)] =
e−2kx sinch(2kδ) − e−2kz
13
The non-central moments of the decision times can be computed similarly.
In particular, if
Tn(a, x0) is the non-central n-th moment of the decision time for the pure DDM, then the non-
central n-th moment for the extended DDM is
(cid:2)EX0
(cid:2)Tn(A, X0)(cid:3)(cid:3).
¯Tn = EA
(42)
The non-central moments obtained using Eqn. (42) can be used with Eqns. (10) and (21) to com-
pute variance and skewness of decision time for the extended DDM. Eqn. (42) is valid for both
unconditional and conditional moments. The above expressions for the error rate and expected
decision time for the extended DDM can be found in [4, Appendix, pp 761 -- 763].
For unconditional moments, the expectation over X0 in (42) can be computed in closed form
for first two moments, which may be written as
(cid:16)
(cid:16)
EX0[T1(a, X0)] =
EX0[T2(a, X0)] =
σ2
a2
σ4
a4
(cid:17)
;
k2
z + 4k2
kz coth(2kz) − kze−2kx sinch(2kδ) csch(2kz) − kx
(43)
z csch2(2kz) + kz coth(2kz) − 4k2
z e−2kx0 sinch(2kδ) csch(2kz) coth(2kz)
(cid:16)
k2
− 2kzkx coth(2kz)
δ
3
sinch(2kδ) − cosh(2kd)
− kze−2kx0 sinch(2kδ) csch(2kz) − kx + k2
− 2kzkxe−2kx
sinch(2kδ) +
csch(2kz)
.
(cid:17)
(cid:17)
(44)
x +
2kx
Expected values in Eqn. (42),
tractable in closed form, can easily be computed numerically, for example, using Simpson's rule.
involving integrals over the Gaussian distribution that are not
Fig. 5 illustrates the behavior of the unconditional moments of the extended DDM, computed
as described above. The introduction of variability in starting points results in increase in error
rate, decrease in expected decision time, increase in CV, and decrease in skewness to CV ratio.
Introduction of variability in drift rate also causes increase in error rate, decrease in expected
decision time and increase in CV, but the skewness to CV ratio increases (compare bottom panels).
Interestingly, for high values of drift rate variability CV is a monotonically increasing function of kz,
in contrast to the behavior of CV for pure DDM discussed in §5. The effect of drift rate variability
seems to dominate when both initial condition and drift rate variability are present.
6.2 Effect of non-decision time
Before returning to the extended DDM, we investigate the role of the non-decision part of the reac-
tion time, the sensory-motor latency, on its CV and skewness. Recall that RT = DT + Tnd, where
Tnd is the non-decision time. We define the following coefficients to characterize the dependence
of DT and Tnd:
E[(DT − E[DT])(Tnd − E[Tnd])]
,
E[(DT − E[DT])(Tnd − E[Tnd])2]
(cid:112)Var[DT] Var[Tnd]
(cid:112)Var[DT] E[(Tnd − E[Tnd])4]
(cid:112)E[(DT − E[DT])4 Var[Tnd]
E[(DT − E[DT])2(Tnd − E[Tnd])]
ρ11 =
ρ12 =
ρ21 =
,
.
(45)
(46)
(47)
14
Figure 5: Behavior of moments for the extended DDM. In all panels a = 0.2 and σ = 0.1. Three
sub-panels in each panel correspond to x0 = −z/2, 0 and z/2, respectively, from top to bottom.
Left panels correspond to σa = 0 and green solid with dots, red dashed, and black solid curves to
2 = 0, 0.45 min{z − x0, x0 + z} and 0.9 min{z − x0, x0 + z}, respectively. Middle panels correspond
sx
to sx = 0 and green solid with dots, red dashed, and black solid curves to σa = 0, 0.1 and 0.2,
2 = 0.45 min{z −
respectively. Right panels are analogous to middle panels and correspond to sx
x0, x0 + z}.
15
00.20.40.60.8 a) 00.45 0.900.20.40.60.8 b)ERkz00.511.5200.20.40.60.8 c) 00.20.40.60.8 a) 00.10.200.20.40.60.8 b)ERkz00.511.5200.20.40.60.8 c) 00.20.40.60.8 a) 00.10.200.20.40.60.8 b)ERkz00.511.5200.20.40.60.8 c) 00.20.40.60.8 a) 00.45 0.900.20.40.60.8 b)E[DT]kz00.511.5200.20.40.60.8 c) 00.20.40.60.8 a) 00.10.200.20.40.60.8 b)E[DT]kz00.511.5200.20.40.60.8 c) 00.20.40.60.8 a) 00.10.200.20.40.60.8 b)E[DT]kz00.511.5200.20.40.60.8 c) 0.611.4 a) 00.45 0.90.611.4 b)CVkz00.511.520.611.4 c) 0.611.4 a) 00.10.20.611.4 b)CVkz00.511.520.611.4 c) 0.611.4 a) 00.10.20.611.4 b)CVkz00.511.520.611.4 c) 0123 a) 00.45 0.90123 b)Skew/CVkz00.511.520123 c) 0123 a) 00.10.20123 b)Skew/CVkz00.511.520123 c) 0123 a) 00.10.20123 b)Skew/CVkz00.511.520123 c) Note that ρ11 is the standard correlation coefficient between DT and Tnd, and ρ12, ρ21 can be
interpreted as higher order correlation coefficients. If DT and Tnd are independent, then all these
correlation coefficients are zero. In this case, it follows from the definition of RT that
E[RT] = E[DT] + E[Tnd]
Var[RT] = Var[DT] + Var[Tnd] + 2ρ11
(cid:112)Var[DT] Var[Tnd]
E[(RT − E[RT])3] = Skew[DT]Var[DT]3/2 + Skew[Tnd]Var[Tnd]3/2
(cid:112)Kur[Tnd]Var[DT]Var[Tnd] + 3ρ21
(cid:112)Kur[DT]Var[Tnd]Var[DT],
+ 3ρ12
where Kur[·] is the kurtosis1. The conditional mean decision time and variance can be defined
similarly by introducing conditional equivalents of correlation coefficients (45-47). However, for
simplicity of exposition, in the following we assume that non-decision time and decision time are
independent; accordingly, the above correlation coefficients are zero. Formulae for CV and Skew
for RT's follow immediately from above expressions. For use below, we assume Tnd is uniformly
distributed with mean E[Tnd] and range st.
6.3 Effects of trial-to-trial variability
Seeking to provide a more complete picture, we conducted simulations of the extended and pure
DD models. To obtain the following simulation results we used the RTdist package for graphical
processing unit (GPU) based simulation of the DDM [31] to simulate a large subset of the param-
eter space spanning the range of plausible parameter values. We simulated 1, 518, 750 parameter
combinations in about 5.5 hours on a Tesla NVIDIA GPU, with 1 msec timesteps up to 5 secs
maximum RT, with 105 trials simulated per parameter combination. In Fig. 6, the noise level was
fixed at σ = 0.1 and we varied mean drift a and threshold z over the ranges [0.1, 1.0] and [0.05, 0.3]
respectively. Fig. 6 shows accuracy, mean RT, CV, skewness to CV ratio (SCV) and the percentage
of trials that failed to cross threshold within 5 secs. (The latter quantity is small except for low
drift and high threshold, where it rises to 15− 20%.) Note that the left hand column of Fig. 6 show
results for the pure DDM with Tnd = 0, and thus provide standards for comparison with other
cases. See Appendix E for additional simulation results.
The most profound effect on higher moments of the RT distributions is due to changes in non-
decision latency, Tnd, as shown in Fig. 6. Specifically, note the dramatic drop in the CV of RTs
as Tnd increases from 0 to 0.28 sec, and the corresponding increase of skewness to CV ratio (red
arrows, row 3).
Fig. 7 shows this phenomenon most clearly, using behaviorally plausible values for the extended
DDM. When the correct expected non-decision latency of 0.45 sec is subtracted from the RTs, the
CV (middle plot) approaches(cid:112)2/3 ≈ 0.8165 as drift approaches 0. Thus researchers may be able
gressively subtracting from the RT until the CV approaches(cid:112)2/3 from below (cf. Proposition 5.1
to estimate Tnd at low accuracy levels when behavior is unbiased toward either alternative by pro-
and Fig. 3). In contrast, the SCV ratio grows substantially as drift, and hence accuracy, increase
(Fig. 6, red arrows, row 4). Researchers may therefore be able to estimate Tnd at high drift levels
by subtracting postulated non-decision time from the RT until the SCV ratio declines to 3. These
1We consider kurtosis as the ratio of the fourth central moment and the square of the variance. This is in contrast
to the convention of subtracting 3 from the above ratio so that the kurtosis of the standard normal random variable
is zero.
16
Figure 6: Effect of deterministic non-decision time Tnd in the extended DDM. Left column: Tnd = 0
sec. Middle column: Tnd = 0.28 sec. Right column: Tnd = 0.45 sec. Curves plotted on the drift-
threshold plane in top row denote equally spaced contours of the accuracy surface; red arrows show
the effect of increasing Tnd on CV and SCV.
two heuristics for estimating Tnd independently at both low and high levels of drift may provide
robust and easily-computable sanity checks for constraining the values of Tnd when using fitting
algorithms.
7 Conclusion
We analyzed in detail the first three moments of decision times of the pure and extended DDMs. We
derived explicit expressions for unconditional and conditional moments and used these expressions
to thoroughly investigate the behavior of the CV and skewness of decision times in terms of two
useful parameters: the non-dimensional threshold and non-dimensional initial condition (kz and
kx, Eqn. (2)). These expressions are summarized in Table 1. The MatLab and R code for these
17
Tnd = 0 secAccuracyaaaaaaaaaaaaaaazzzzzzzzzzzzzzzAccuracyAccuracyMean RTMean RTMean RTCVCVCVSkew/CVSkew/CVSkew/CV% Fail to Cross% Fail to Cross% Fail to CrossTnd = 0.28 secTnd = 0.45 secxx Figure 7: Comparison of CVs and SCVs, as a function of drift, computed from raw RTs (dot-dashed)
and from DTs (solid). DTs have the true, average non-decision latency of 0.45 sec subtracted.
Representative levels of extended DDM parameter values were used (z = 0.06, x0 = 0, δ = 0.5 · z ,
σa = 0.25 · a, E[Tnd] = 0.45 sec, and st = 0.112 sec.)
expressions is available at: https://github.com/PrincetonUniversity/higher_moments_ddm.
In particular, we computed several limits of interest for the pure DDM. We established that,
for an unbiased starting point (x0 = 0), the CV of decision times is a monotonically decreasing
function of kz and that it approaches(cid:112)2/3 as kz → 0 (Proposition 5.1 and Fig. 3). In the limits of
small drift rate and unbiased starting point, we showed that the ratio of skewness to CV approaches
12/5. Furthermore, for non-zero drift rates and in the limit of large thresholds (high accuracy), we
showed that skewness to CV ratio approaches 3. We showed that both CV and skewness of decision
times diverge as the starting point approaches either threshold; however, the ratio of skewness to
CV is a bounded function of non-dimensional threshold. We also showed that in the limit of large
thresholds, these moments match those of first passage times for single-threshold drift-diffusion
processes, and we established similar results for conditional CV and skewness of decision times.
We established that the decision time distribution for the double-threshold DDM converges to he
decision time distribution of the single-threshold DDM for large thresholds (Appendix C).
We then derived analytic and semi-analytic expressions for the moments of decision times of
the extended DDM, and numerically investigated the effects of trial-to-trial variability in starting
18
DriftDriftDrift00.20.40.60.810.40.60.810.40.60.81RT in secondsCVSCV ratio% correctMeanRTAccuracy00.20.40.60.8100.51CVs of decision times & response times00.20.40.60.8101020Skew to CV ratio (SCV) of decision & response timesCV(DT)DT = RT - 0.450 secSCV(DT)DT = RT - 0.450 sec0.81653SCV(RT) CV(RT) 1-threshold
2-threshold
e−2kx−e−2kz
e2kz−e−2kz
(cid:2)kz coth(2kz) − kze−2kx csch(2kz) − kx
(cid:3)
a2 (2kz coth(2kz) − (kx + kz) coth(kx + kz))
σ2
a2
σ2
Error rate
ER
Mean
E[DT]
E[DT]+
Variance
Var
Var+
Coefficient of Variation
CV
CV+
Skewness
Skew × Var3/2
Skew+ × Var3/2
+
NA
σ2
a2 (kz − kx)
NA
σ4
a4 (kz − kx)
NA
1√
kz−kx
NA
3σ6
a6 (kz − kx)
NA
see equation (10)
see equation (31)
see equation (13)
see equation (33)
see equation (21)
see equation (36)
Table 1: Summary of expressions of error rate and moments of decision time.
points and drift rates on the DDM's performance. We observed that variability in drift rate appears
to dominate these effects, compared to starting point variability.
Finally, we investigated the effect of non-decision times (sensory-motor latencies, Tnd) on
decision-making performance. We observed that CVs of reaction times (DT + Tnd) decrease and
their skewness-to-CV ratios increase as mean Tnd's increase (Fig. 6). We propose that the decrease
in CVs and increase in skewness-to-CV ratios could be used to estimate non-decision times in low
and high accuracy regimes respectively (see Fig. 7). The development of rigorous methods using
these metrics to estimate non-decision time is a potential avenue for future research.
It should be noted that difficulties in estimating higher moments of empirical RT data have
been highlighted in the literature [18, 21]. However, at least in the context of interval-timing
tasks, predictions regarding CV and skewness have proved to be useful in discriminating between
different models [25, 28]. Furthermore, it is possible that future two-alternative perceptual decision
task designs could be found that would yield data amenable to estimation of higher moments, in
which case, the expressions we derive here may prove helpful.
More generally, the explicit expressions derived in this paper can be used to quickly identify
ranges of parameters that are relevant to fitting specific behavioral data sets, thereby reducing
the volumes of multi-dimensional space in which parameter fits need to be run. In principle, the
cumulant generating function method outlined in Appendix A can be used to produce formulae
for fourth and higher moments, and although the results will be complex, they and their limiting
behaviors may also provide guidance for parameter fitting.
19
Acknowledgements
This work was jointly supported by NIH Brain Initiative grant 1-U01-NS090514-01 (PH), NSF-
CRCNS grant DMS-1430077 and the Insley-Blair Pyne Fund (VS), and an OKUM Fellowship
(PS). The authors thank Jonathan Cohen and Michael Shvartsman for helpful suggestions.
References
[1] M. Abramowitz and I.A. Stegun, eds. Handbook of Mathematical Functions with Formulas,
Graphs, and Mathematical Tables. Wiley - Interscience, New York, 1984.
[2] F. Balci and P. Simen. Decision processes in temporal discrimination. Acta Psychologica,
149:157 -- 168, 2014.
[3] F. Balci, P. Simen, R. Niyogi, A. Saxe, P. Holmes, and J.D. Cohen. Acquisition of decision mak-
ing criteria: Reward rate ultimately beats accuracy. Attention, Perception & Psychophysics,
73(2):640 -- 657, 2011.
[4] R. Bogacz, E. Brown, J. Moehlis, P. Holmes, and J.D. Cohen. The physics of optimal decision
making: A formal analysis of models of performance in two alternative forced choice tasks.
Psychological Reveiw, 113 (4):700 -- 765, 2006.
[5] R. Bogacz, P. Hu, P. Holmes, and J.D. Cohen. Do humans produce the speed-accuracy tradeoff
that maximizes reward rate? Quarterly Journal Experimental Psychology, 63(5):863 -- 891, 2010.
[6] A.N. Borodin and P. Salminen. Handbook of Brownian Motion: Facts and Formulae. Springer,
New York, 2002.
[7] C. D. Creelman. Human discrimination of auditory duration. The Journal of the Acoustical
Society of America, 34:582 -- 593, 1962.
[8] G. Dutilh, J. Vandekerckhove, F. Tuerlinckx, and E-J. Wagenmakers. A diffusion model
decomposition of the practice effect. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review, 16(6):1026 -- 1036,
2009.
[9] C. B. Ferster and B. F. Skinner. Schedules of Reinforcement. Appleton-Century-Crofts, New
York, 1957.
[10] C.W. Gardiner. Stochastic Methods: A Handbook for the Natural and Social Sciences. Springer,
New York, 2009. 4th edition.
[11] J. Gibbon and R. M. Church. Representation of time. Cognition, 37:23 -- 54, 1990.
[12] J. Gibbon, R. M. Church, and W. H. Meck. Scalar timing in memory. In J. Gibbon and L. G.
Allan, editors, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences: Timing and Time Perception,
volume 423, pages 52 -- 77, New York, 1984. New York Academy of Sciences.
[13] R. P. P. P. Grasman, E-J. Wagenmakers, and H. L. J. van der Maas. On the mean and variance
of response times under the diffusion model with an application to parameter estimation.
Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 53(2):55 -- 68, 2009.
20
[14] G. Grimmett and D. Stirzaker. Probability and Random Processes. Oxford University Press,
Oxford, UK, 2001.
[15] A. Gut. Probability: A Graduate Course. Springer, New York, 2007. Corrected 2nd printing.
[16] D.J. Higham. An algorithmic introduction to numerical simulation of stochastic differential
equations. SIAM Review, 43:525 -- 546, 2001.
[17] Peter R. Killeen and J. Gregor Fetterman. A behavioral theory of timing. Psychological Review,
95(2):274 -- 295, 1988.
[18] R.D. Luce. Response Times: Their Role in Inferring Elementary Mental Organization. Oxford
University Press, New York, 1986.
[19] A. Luzardo, E. A. Ludvig, and F. Rivest. An adaptive drift-diffusion model of interval timing
dynamics. Behavioral Processes, 95:90 -- 99, 2013.
[20] R. Ratcliff. A theory of memory retrieval. Psychological Review, 85:59 -- 108, 1978.
[21] R. Ratcliff. Methods for dealing with reaction time outliers. Psychological Bulletin, 114:510 --
532, 1993.
[22] R. Ratcliff. Measuring psychometric functions with the diffusion model. Journal of Experi-
mental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 40(2):870 -- 888, 2014.
[23] R. Ratcliff and J. N. Rouder. Modeling response times for two-choice decisions. Psychological
Science, 9:347 -- 356, 1998.
[24] R. Ratcliff and P.L. Smith. A comparison of sequential sampling models for two-choice reaction
time. Psychological Review, 111:333 -- 367, 2004.
[25] P. Simen, F. Balci, L. deSouza, J.D. Cohen, and P. Holmes. A model of interval timing by
neural integration. Journal of Neuroscience, 31(25):9238 -- 9253, 2011.
[26] P. Simen, D. Contreras, C. Buck, P. Hu, P. Holmes, and J.D. Cohen. Reward rate optimization
in two-alternative decision making: Empirical tests of theoretical predictions. Journal of
Experimental Psychology: Humam Perception Performance, 35(6):1865 -- 1897, 2009.
[27] P. Simen, F. Rivest, E. A. Ludvig, F. Balci, and P. R. Killeen. Timescale invariance in the
pacemaker-accumulator family of timing models. Timing and Time Perception, 1:159 -- 188,
2013.
[28] P. Simen, K. Vlasov, and S. Papadakis. Scale (in)variance in a unified diffusion model of
decision making and timing. Psychological Review, 2016.
[29] M. Treisman. Temporal discrimination and the indifference interval: implications for a model
of the 'internal clock'. Psychological Monographs, 77:1 -- 31, 1963.
[30] J. Vandekerckhove and F. Tuerlinckx. Fitting the ratcliff diffusion model to experimental data.
Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 14(6):1011 -- 1026, 2007.
21
[31] S. Verdonck, K. Meers, and F. Tuerlinckx. Efficient simulation of diffusion-based choice rt
models on CPU and GPU. Behavior Research Methods, pages 1 -- 15, 2015.
[32] E-J. Wagenmakers, R. P. P. P. Grasman, and P. C. M. Molenaar. On the relation between the
mean and the variance of a diffusion model response time distribution. Journal of Mathematical
Psychology, 49:195 -- 204, 2005.
[33] A. Wald. Sequential Analysis. John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1947.
Appendices
A Error rate and unconditional variance of decision time
In this section we show that error rate (6) and expected decision time (7) are equivalent to the
expressions given in the subsection "The Drift Diffusion Model" of [4, Appendix, Eqns. (A27-31)].
In our notation, the quantities z and a defined in [4] are
z =
z
a
,
and a =
a2
σ2 .
Define x0 = x0/a. Note that kz = za and kx = ax0. Also note that x0 and x0 are referred to as x0
and y0, respectively in [4].
The expression (6) for error rate may be rewritten as follows
ER =
e−2kx − e−2kz
e2kz − e−2kz
1 − e−2kz
e2kz − e−2kz
=
e2kz − 1
=
(e2kz + 1)(e2kz − 1)
− 1 − e−2kx
e2kz − e−2kz
− 1 − e−2kx
e2kz − e−2kz
=
=
=
which is identical to the ER expression in [4]. Similarly,
kz coth(2kz) − kze−2kx csch(2kz) − kx
coth(2kz) − csch(2kz) + (1 − e−2kx) csch(2kz) − kx
kz
+ (1 − e−2kx) csch(2kz) − x0
z
(cid:104)
(cid:20)
(cid:20) e2kz + e−2kz − 2
E[DT] =
=
=
=
σ2
a2
σ2
a2 kz
z
a
z
a
tanh(kz) +
e2kz − e−2kz
(1 − e−2kx)
− x0
2z
e2kz − e−2kz
a
a
2z(1 − e−2ax0)
e2az − e−2za − x0,
= z tanh(za) +
− 1 − e−2kx
e2kz − e−2kz
− 1 − e−2kx
(cid:20) 1 − e−2x0a
e2kz − e−2kz
e2za − e−2za
e2kz − 1
e4kz − 1
1
1 + e2kz
1
1 + e2za −
(cid:105)
(cid:21)
(cid:21)
(cid:21)
,
(48)
(49)
which is identical to the expected decision time expression in [4].
22
B Unconditional variance of decision time
The second moment of the decision time T2 is the solution of the following linear ODE:
a
(50)
with boundary conditions T2(±z) = 0 (e.g. [10, §5.5.1; see Eqn. (5.5.19) for the general n'th
moment ODE]). To solve Eqn. (50) we first rewrite E[DT] to make dependence on the starting
point x0 explicit:
+
dT2
dx0
σ2
2
d2T2
dx2
0
= −2E[DT],
E[DT] = α1 − α2e−2kx0 − x0
a
.
Here α1 = z
z and x0. A particular solution to (50) is
a coth(2kz), α2 = z
a csch(2kz) and unlike kz, kx defined above, k = a
σ2 is independent of
T p
2 =
x2
0
a2 − α3x0 − 2α2
a
x0e−2kx0,
where α3 = 2
a (α1 + 1
2ka ), and the general solution takes the form
a2 − α3x0 − 2α2
T2(x0) = c1 + c2e−2kx0 +
x2
0
a
x0e−2kx0.
Substituting the boundary conditions T2(±z) = 0, and solving for c1 and c2, we obtain
2z2
a2 csch2(2kz)
and
z
=
c1 =
ka2 coth(2kz) − z2
a2 +
z
ka2 coth(2kz),
4z2
a2 csch2(2kz) +
2z2
a2 coth2(2kz) +
z2
a2 +
c2 = − 4z2
a2 csch(2kz) coth(2kz) − z
a3 coth(2kz) − 4z2e−2kx0
a2 coth(2kz) − σ2x0
a2 − 2zx0
σ2z
x2
0
a2
ka2 csch(2kz),
csch(2kz) coth(2kz) − σ2ze−2kx0
a3 − 2zx0e−2kx0
csch(2kz).
a3
csch(2kz)
(51)
and we therefore find that
T2 =
z2
a2 +
4z2
a2 csch2(2kz) +
+
a2
We can now obtain the expression for the variance of decision time:
Var = T2 − E[DT]2
=
3z2
a2 csch2(2kz) +
σ2z
a3 coth(2kz) − σ2x0
− σ2ze−2kx0
csch(2kz) − 4zx0e−2kx0
a3 − 2z2e−2kx0
csch(2kz) − z2e−4kx0
a2
a2
a3
a2
csch(2kz) coth(2kz)
csch2(2kz).
(52)
Equivalently, we may write
(cid:104)
σ4
a4
z e−4kx csch2(2kz) + kz coth(2kz) − kze−2kx csch(2kz) − kx
−k2
z csch2(2kz) − 2k2
3k2
(cid:105)
z e−2kx csch(2kz) coth(2kz) − 4kzkxe−2kx csch(2kz)
Var =
.
(53)
23
C Method for computation of conditional moments
The moment generating function MX : H → R>0 of a random variable X is defined by
MX (α) := E[eαX ],
provided the expectation exists for each α in some neighborhood of zero, i.e., for each α ∈ H, where
H ⊂ R is some interval containing zero. The moment generating function is a special case of the
characteristic function defined on the complex plane (see [14, §5.7, Theorem 12]), and from it the
cumulant generating function KX : H → R of X can be obtained by taking the natural logarithm:
The n-th cumulant κn of X is defined as κn = dnKX (α)
It can then be shown that
dαn
KX (α) = log MX (α).
(cid:12)(cid:12)α=0, or equivalently KX (α) =(cid:80)∞
n=1
(54)
κnαn
n!
.
κ2 = µcen
κ3 = µcen
3
,
and κ4 = µcen
,
2
κ1 = µ1,
n = E[(X − E[X])n] denote the nth non-central and central moments.
where µn = E[X n] and µcen
Thus, successive moments of the distribution from which X is drawn can be generated from MX (α).
For further details and derivations of moment generating functions, see [15, Chap 4, §6] and [10,
§2.6].
A → R>0, M+ : A → R>0, and M− : A → R>0 by
We now derive the moment generating function for DTs of the DDM (1). We define MDT :
4 − 3κ2
2,
MDT(α) = E[eατ ], M+(α) = E[eατx(τ ) = z],
(55)
where A ⊂ R is some interval containing zero in which the above expectations exist. MDT(α),
M+(α) and M−(α) are, respectively, the moment generating functions for unconditional decision
times (for all responses) and for decision times conditioned on correct responses and on errors.
Expressions for these functions are well known in the literature (e.g. [6]). Here, for completeness,
we derive them from first principles.
and M−(α) = E[eατx(τ ) = −z],
We begin by deriving an expression for M+(α). We note that for a given set of parameters
a, σ, z, and α, M+(α) depends only on x0. Let τ (x0) denote the decision time (DT) starting from
initial condition x0. Define g : R → R>0 as the map from initial condition x0 to M+(α)P(x(τ ) = z),
i.e.,
g(x0) = E[eατ (x0)1(x(τ (x0)) = z)],
(56)
where 1(·) is the indicator function.
h ∈ R>0. Let Xh := x(h) = x0 + ah + σW (h). It follows that
Consider the evolution of the DDM (1) starting from x0 at t = 0 for an infinitesimal duration
g(x0) = EXh
Eτ (Xh)[eα(h+τ (Xh))]
= eαh(cid:16)
= eαhEXh[g(Xh)]
dg
dx0
g(x0) +
ah +
1
2
d2g
dx2
0
(cid:17)
σ2h
+ O(h2),
24
where O(h2) represents terms of order h2 and higher. Rearranging terms and setting h → 0+, we
obtain the following ODE for g
(57)
with boundary conditions g(z) = 1 and g(−z) = 0. The solution to (57) is of the form g(x0) =
ζ1eλ1x0 + ζ2eλ2x0, where λ1 and λ2 are roots of the equation σ2λ2/2 + aλ + α = 0, i.e.,
+ αg = 0,
+ a
σ2
2
d2g
dx2
0
dg
dx0
−a − √
λ1 =
a2 − 2ασ2
σ2
−a +
,
and λ2 =
√
a2 − 2ασ2
σ2
.
Substituting the boundary conditions, we get two simultaneous equations
ζ1e−λ1z + ζ2e−λ2z = 0,
ζ1eλ1z + ζ2eλ2z = 1,
and
the solution to which is
ζ1 =
eλ1z
e2λ1z − e2λ2z ,
and ζ2 = −
eλ2z
e2λ1z − e2λ2z ,
and consequently,
g(x0) =
eλ1(z+x0) − eλ2(z+x0)
e2λ1z − e2λ2z
e−a(z+x0)/σ2
e−2az/σ2
=
sinh( (z+x0)
√
sinh( 2z
√
a2−2ασ2
σ2
a2−2ασ2
σ2
)
a(z−x0)
σ2
= e
sinh( (z+x0)
√
sinh( 2z
√
a2−2ασ2
σ2
a2−2ασ2
σ2
)
)
.
Thus, recalling the definition (56) of g(x0), the moment-generating function conditioned on
correct decisions is
M+(α) = E[eατx(τ ) = z] =
a(z−x0)
σ2
e
P(x(τ ) = z)
sinh( (z+x0)
√
sinh( 2z
√
a2−2ασ2
σ2
a2−2ασ2
σ2
)
)
,
(58)
and substituting this in the definition (54) yields the cumulant generating function (28) used in §4.
Similarly, we may obtain analogous expressions for incorrect decisions
√
sinh( (z−x0)
√
sinh( 2z
M−(α) = E[eατx(τ ) = −z] =
P(x(τ ) = −z)
−a(z+x0)
σ2
e
a2−2ασ2
σ2
a2−2ασ2
σ2
)
)
,
(59)
and for all decisions, correct and incorrect:
MDT(α) = E[eατ ] = e
√
sinh( (z−x0)
√
sinh( 2z
It should be noted that in the limit z → ∞
−a(z+x0)
σ2
a2−2ασ2
σ2
a2−2ασ2
σ2
)
(cid:32)
(cid:32)
(cid:114)
MDT(α) = exp
1 −
az
σ2
1 − 2ασ2
a2
(cid:33)(cid:33)
,
)
+ e
a(z−x0)
σ2
sinh( (z+x0)
√
sinh( 2z
√
a2−2ασ2
σ2
a2−2ασ2
σ2
)
)
.
(60)
which is the moment generating function of the Wald distribution [6, Eq. 2.0.1], i.e., the decision
time distribution of the single-threshold DDM. Consequently, the decision time distribution of the
double-threshold DDM converges to the the decision time distribution of the single-threshold DDM
as z → ∞.
25
D Proof of Proposition 5.1
threshold case. Canceling the (cid:112)1/kz terms in the inequality (39), squaring, rearranging and
We first show that the CV for the single-threshold DDM provides an upper bound for the double
dividing by 2e−2kz shows that this is equivalent to
(1 − e−2kz )2 > (1 − e−4kz − 4kze−2kz ) ⇔ e−2kz > 1 − 2kz,
(61)
which clearly holds for all kz (cid:54)= 0.
We next evaluate the limit of F (kz) as kz → 0 by expanding the numerator of Eqn. (39) in
Taylor series:
(cid:115)
(cid:20)
(cid:18)
(cid:18)
(cid:19)
(cid:113) 8
(cid:21)
(cid:114) 8
3
(cid:19)
)
4k2
z
2
(cid:114) 2
3
1
kz
1 −
1 − 4kz +
16k2
z
2
− 64k3
3!
z
−
4kz(1 − 2kz +
+ O(k4
z )
=
z + O(k3
k2
z ).
Expanding the denominator likewise, we have
F (kz) =
z + O(k3
z )
[1 − (1 − 2kz + O(k2
3 k2
z ))]
→
as kz → 0.
(62)
from(cid:112)1/kz by less than 0.24% for kz ≥ 4, implying that the slow monotonic decay ∼ k
The exponentials in the numerator and denominator of F (kz) decay rapidly, so that it differs
1
z dominates
2
for large kz; see Fig. 3. However, the behavior for smaller kz is more subtle and requires computation
of all terms in the Taylor series.
To prove monotonic decay throughout we use the fact that F (kz) > 0 and show that the
derivative of
F 2(kz) =
(cid:16) 1−e−4kz
− 2e−2kz
2kz
(1 − e−2kz )2
(cid:17)
(63)
(64)
is strictly negative for all kz > 0. Henceforth, for convenience, we set y = 2kz and compute
(cid:16)− 1
(1 − e−y)
y2 + e−2y
y2 + 2e−2y
y + 2e−y(cid:17) − 2e−y(cid:16) 1−e−2y
y − 2e−y(cid:17)
(1 − e−y)3
−(1−e−y)(1−e−2y)
y2
− 2e−y(1−e−y)
(1 − e−y)3
y
+ 2e−y(1 + e−y)
.
d
dy
[F 2(y)] =
=
Since (1 − e−y)3 > 0 it suffices to show that the numerator of Eqn (64) is negative, or, multiplying
by y2e3y and rearranging, that
1 + e3y + 2ye2y def= L > ey + e2y + 2yey + 2y2ey + 2y2e2y def= R.
(65)
26
We expand both L and R in Taylor series, obtaining
(cid:18)
L = 1 +
1 + 3y +
= 2 + 3y +
+
(3y)2
2!
27y3
+
(3y)3
3!
+ . . . +
(3y)j
j!
+ . . . + 2y + (2y)2 +
+ . . .
(2y)3
2!
y4 +
403
120
y5 + . . . +
9y2
2
17
2
y2
2!
+
6
17
2
y3
3!
2y3
2!
23y4
2!
+
2y4
3!
145
24
yj
j!
2yj
(j − 1)!
2j−1yj
(j − 2)!
145
24
y4 +
+ 2y
(cid:19)
(cid:18)
(cid:18) 3j + j2j
+ . . . +
(2y)2
2!
(2y)j
(j − 1)!
1 + 2y +
+
(3y)j
(cid:19)
j!
(cid:19)
(2y)j−1
(j − 1)!
+ . . .
+ . . . +
+ . . .
j!
(2y)3
3!
(2y)2
2!
+
+ . . . +
2jyj
j!
+ . . .
2y4
2!
+ . . . +
2yj
(j − 2)!
+ . . .
= 2 + 5y +
y2 +
y3 +
yj + . . . ; and
(66)
R = 1 + y +
+ . . . +
+ . . . + 1 + 2y +
+ 2y + 2y2 +
+ . . . +
+ . . . + 2y2 + 2y3 +
+ 2y2 + 22y3 +
+ . . . +
+ . . .
= 2 + 5y +
17
2
y2 +
17
2
y3 +
y5 + . . . +
1 + 2j + 2j2 + 2j−1j(j − 1)
j!
+ . . . .
(67)
403
120
Note that the first 6 terms of L and R, up to O(y5), are identical, and the 4 succeeding coefficients
of L− R up to O(y9) are strictly positive (specifically, 1/45, 1/30, 11/420 and 1/70). To show that
all succeeding coefficients are likewise positive, we make pairwise comparisons of the six terms in
the numerator of the general coefficient of L − R:
3j + j2j − [1 + 2j + 2j2 + 2j−1j(j − 1)] = [j2j − 2j2] + [j2j−1 − (1 + 2j)] + [3j − j22j−1].
(68)
It can be checked that
j2j > 2j2 ⇔ 2j > 2j for j ≥ 3,
j2j−1 > 1 + 2j ⇔ j > 2 +
(cid:18) 3
(cid:19)j
2
1
2j−1
j2
2
>
for j ≥ 3,
for j ≥ 10;
3j > j22j−1 ⇔
thus, all coefficients of terms greater than O(y5) are strictly positive, completing the proof.
(69)
(70)
(71)
2
E Additional Figures
In this section we present some additional simulations for the extended and pure DD models.
Simulations were performed using the RTdist package for graphical processing unit (GPU) with
the same details as outlined in §6. In Figs. 8-11, the noise level was fixed at σ = 0.1 and we varied
mean drift a and threshold z over the ranges [0.1, 1.0] and [0.05, 0.3] respectively. Each figure shows
accuracy, mean RT, CV, skewness to CV ratio (SCV) and the percentage of trials that failed to
cross threshold within 5 secs. (The latter quantity is similar in all cases: it remains small except
for low drift and high threshold, where it rises to 15 − 20%.) Other parameters chosen for these
figures are listed in Table 2. Note that the center column of Fig. 9 and the left hand columns of
Fig. 11 show results for the pure DDM with Tnd = 0, and thus provide standards for comparison
with other cases.
27
Fig. 6
Fig. 8
Fig. 9 −z/3, 0, +z/3
Fig. 10
Fig. 11
+z/3
x0
0
0
0
sx
0
0
0
0, z/3, 0.6z
σa
0
0
0
0
0
0, 0.5a, a
E[Tnd] (sec)
0, 0.28, 0.45
0, 0.28, 0.45
st (sec)
0
0.25 E[Tnd]
0
0
0
0
0
0
Table 2: Parameter values for extended DDM simulations. Here sx is the range of the starting
point distribution, σa the standard deviation of drift rate, and st the range of the non-decision
time distribution. These parameters are given as fractions of threshold, mean drift and mean
non-decision time respectively.
Figs. 9 and 10 show that deviations in mean starting point in either direction lead to increases in
CV, but with little effect on SCV ratios. Introducing trial-to-trial variability raises CVs for x0 = 0,
and yields lower SCV ratios for high thresholds and drift rates. Fig. 11 shows that trial-to-trial
variability in drift rates reduces accuracy, that CVs increase substantially for high variability, and
that SCV ratios initially increase and then decrease with variability.
The remaining figures show the effects of variability in Tnd, of starting point and its variability,
and of variability in drift rates. In Fig. 8 we keep the ratio st/Tnd constant at 0.25 and use the
same values of Tnd as in Fig. 6, revealing similar effects to those of Fig. 6, except for SCV, which
increases as Tnd increases.
28
Figure 8: Effects of range st of uniformly distributed Tnd. High values of st (25% of Tnd) produce
little effect compared with that of increasing Tnd.
29
st = 0 sec, Tnd = 0 secst = 0.70 sec, Tnd = 0.28 secst = 0.112 sec, Tnd = 0.45 secAccuracyAccuracyAccuracyMean RTMean RTMean RTCVCVCVSkew/CVSkew/CVSkew/CV% Fail to Cross% Fail to Cross% Fail to Crossaaaaaaaaaaaaaaazzzzzzzzzzzzzzz in the CV of decision times, raising it above(cid:112)2/3, but with very little change in SCV. Note that
Figure 9: Effects of mean starting point x0. Positive and negative biases from 0 produce increases
Tnd = 0 in all plots.
30
x0 = -z/3x0 = +z/3x0 = 0AccuracyMean RTCVSkew/CV% Fail to CrossAccuracyMean RTCVSkew/CV% Fail to CrossAccuracyMean RTCVSkew/CV% Fail to Crossaaaaaaaaaaaaaaazzzzzzzzzzzzzzz Figure 10: Effects of range of starting point distribution sx. Increasing sx has little effect, except
at unrealistic parameter combinations of high threshold and high drift, where a decrease in SCV
is evident. Mean starting point in all plots is +z/3, 2/3 of distance from lower to upper threshold
biased toward the correct response. Indeed, sx is used to explain differences in conditional decision
times, and any apparent lack of effect in Fig. 10 is due to the fact that only unconditional quantities
are plotted.
31
x0 = +z/3, sx/2 = 0x0 = +z/3, sx/2 = 0.5 x0x0 = +z/3, sx/2 = 0.9 x0AccuracyMean RTCVSkew/CV% Fail to CrossAccuracyMean RTCVSkew/CV% Fail to CrossAccuracyMean RTCVSkew/CV% Fail to Crossaaaaaaaaaaaaaaazzzzzzzzzzzzzzz Figure 11: Increases in drift variability σa across trials reduce accuracy, increase CVs, and initially
raise and then lower SCV ratios; overall mean RTs are little changed.
32
σa= 0σa= 0.25 aσa= adriftAccuracyAccuracyAccuracyMean RTMean RTMean RTCVCVCVSkew/CVSkew/CVSkew/CV% Fail to Cross% Fail to Cross% Fail to Crossaaaaaaaaaaaaaaazzzzzzzzzzzzzzz |
1211.4766 | 1 | 1211 | 2012-11-20T15:04:40 | State-dependent changes of connectivity patterns and functional brain network topology in Autism Spectrum Disorder | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Anatomical and functional brain studies have converged to the hypothesis that Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD) are associated with atypical connectivity. Using a modified resting-state paradigm to drive subjects' attention, we provide evidence of a very marked interaction between ASD brain functional connectivity and cognitive state. We show that functional connectivity changes in opposite ways in ASD and typicals as attention shifts from external world towards one's body generated information. Furthermore, ASD subject alter more markedly than typicals their connectivity across cognitive states. Using differences in brain connectivity across conditions, we classified ASD subjects at a performance around 80% while classification based on the connectivity patterns in any given cognitive state were close to chance. Connectivity between the Anterior Insula and dorsal-anterior Cingulate Cortex showed the highest classification accuracy and its strength increased with ASD severity. These results pave the path for diagnosis of mental pathologies based on functional brain networks obtained from a library of mental states. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | State-dependent changes of connectivity patterns and functional brain network
topology in Autism Spectrum Disorder
Pablo Barttfeld1, Bruno Wicker1,2, Sebastián Cukier1,4, Silvana Navarta1, Sergio Lew3, Ramón
Leiguarda4 and Mariano Sigman1
1- Laboratory of Integrative Neuroscience, Physics Department, FCEyN UBA and IFIBA, Conicet;
Pabellón 1, Ciudad Universitaria, 1428 Buenos Aires, Argentina.
2- Institut de Neurosciences de la Timone, CNRS UMR 7289 & Aix-Marseille University,
Marseille, France.
3- Instituto de Ingeniería Biomédica, Facultad de Ingeniería, Universidad de Buenos Aires,
Argentina.
4- FLENI, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
e-mail: [email protected]
Abstract
Anatomical and functional brain studies have converged to the hypothesis that Autism Spectrum
Disorders (ASD) are associated with atypical connectivity. Using a modified resting-state paradigm
to drive subjects' attention, we provide evidence of a very marked interaction between ASD brain
functional connectivity and cognitive state. We show that functional connectivity changes in
opposite ways in ASD and typicals as attention shifts from external world towards one's body
generated information. Furthermore, ASD subject alter more markedly than typicals their
connectivity across cognitive states. Using differences in brain connectivity across conditions, we
classified ASD subjects at a performance around 80% while classification based on the connectivity
patterns in any given cognitive state were close to chance. Connectivity between the Anterior Insula
and dorsal-anterior Cingulate Cortex showed the highest classification accuracy and its strength
increased with ASD severity. These results pave the path for diagnosis of mental pathologies based
on functional brain networks obtained from a library of mental states.
Running title: Brain networks in ASD are tuned for introspection.
Keywords: Autism Spectrum Disorders, functional connectivity, brain states, classification.
1. Introduction
Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD) refer to neurodevelopmental disorders characterized by poor
social communication abilities in combination with repetitive behaviours and restricted interests
(APA, 2000). Research in the physiopathology of ASD has largely focused on the identification of
structural or functional brain abnormalities. Structural MRI studies have reported abnormal
developmental trajectory of brain growth, with evidence of poorly organized white matter
(Alexander et al., 2007; Barnea-Goraly, Lotspeich, & Reiss, 2010; Egaas, Courchesne, & Saitoh,
1995; Fletcher et al., 2010; Herbert et al., 2005; McAlonan et al., 2005; Thakkar et al., 2008) ,
atypicalities in gyration and cortical thickness patterns (Hadjikhani, Joseph, Snyder, & Tager-
Flusberg, 2006; Hardan, Muddasani, Vemulapalli, Keshavan, & Minshew, 2006) , possibly caused
by irregular neuronal migration, cortical organization and myelinisation in ASD (Wass, 2011).
Functional neuroimaging studies using a range of experimental tasks targeting emotional and social
information processing have reported hypoactivation in the fusiform gyrus, the amygdala, the
dorsomedial prefrontal cortex, the superior temporal sulcus, and insula (Di Martino et al., 2009;
Hadjikhani, Joseph, Snyder, & Tager-Flusberg, 2006) . A recent shift in emphasis to investigating
dynamic processes of functional brain connectivity has led to a convergence on the hypothesis that
ASD is associated with atypical connectivity, producing a system that is ineffective for integrating
information. Critically, the study of functional brain networks of ASD and typical subjects in the
resting state (i.e. during free thought) showed qualitatively different organizations at the group
level, which broadly reflects an excess of local connectivity and a deficit in long-range connectivity,
especially along the long distance fronto-posterior axis (Schipul, Keller, & Just, 2011) although an
excess in local connectivity (over-connectivity) has also been observed (Barttfeld et al., 2011;
Belmonte et al., 2004; Just, Cherkassky, Keller, Kana, & Minshew, 2007; Wass, 2011) . At the
neuronal level, these findings are supported by data revealing a different ASD phenotype in neurons
and axons that make up the brain’s communication system (van Kooten et al., 2008; Zikopoulos &
Barbas, 2010).
While the differences in brain network connectivity are significant and robust at the group level, the
effect is not strong enough to classify robustly whether an individual belongs to the typical or ASD
group. In this respect, the main objectives of the present work are: first at the theoretical level, to
investigate with a systems level approach whether the difference in large-scale brain network
organization between ASD and typical subjects depends on the specific task in which subjects are
engaged. Second at the practical level, to investigate whether brain network connectivity differences
in specific mental states may be more informative to distinguish the organization of the typical and
ASD mind.
We measured functional brain connectivity in three different mental states, varying the focus of
attention on internal stimulus (focus on respiration, Interoceptive state), external auditory stimulus
(oddball task, Exteroceptive state), or having the subjects lying eye closed in the scanner
(mindwandering, Rest state). This approach is motivated by the fact that paying attention to an
external or internal stimuli is equivalent in term of cognitive demand but qualitatively different
regarding the origin of the stimulus to pay attention to, and by the observation that kids with ASD
have a heightened interoception (Santos et al., 2010) and have a greater reliance in proprioception
which correlates with the impairments in social function and imitation (Haswell, Izawa, Dowell,
Mostofsky, & Shadmehr, 2009). Our results show a very marked interaction between group of
subjects (ASD or typical) and cognitive state. Network changes between groups in the Interoceptive
and Exteroceptive states showed opposite effects, revealing that inferences about connectivity
differences in ASD should be state-dependent. Besides, within group brain connectivity differences
across cognitive states are more pronounced in the ASD than in the typical group, with brain
connectivity in the ASD group being more strongly affected by cognitive state than in the typical
group. Furthermore, while network measures are inefficient to decode whether a subject belongs to
the ASD or typical group, comparing how network parameters change with cognitive state achieves
a significant decoding performance, suggesting that within-group functional change across
cognitive states is a better marker of ASD than between-group changes in a given cognitive state.
2. Material and Methods.
2.1 Participants
Two groups of subjects took part in this study. The ASD group included 12 individuals with high-
functioning autism or Asperger’s Syndrome (9 men and 3 women; mean age = 23.7, std =7,13). The
participants with ASD were provisionally included in the study if they had received a diagnosis of
autism or Asperger’s Syndrome from a psychiatrist or licensed clinical psychologist. Actual
participation required that this diagnosis be recently confirmed, with each having met the criteria
for ASD within the past 3 years on the basis of the revised fourth edition of the Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders and on the score on the Autistic Diagnostic Observation
Schedule-Generic (Lord et al., 2000). IQs were measured with the third edition of the Wechsler
Adult Intelligence Scale and ranged from 85 to 121 (mean=101.33, SD=13.79). At the time of
testing, no ASD subject had known associated medical disorders. ASD participants were matched to
a group of 12 typically developing individuals (8 men and 4 women; mean age= 28,83; std= 5,00;
IQ: mean=108.91 SD=12.62). Participants in the typical group had a history free of psychiatric
disorders.
2.2 fMRI acquisition.
Functional images were acquired on GE Hdx 3T with a conventional 8 channels head coil. Twenty
four axial slices (5 mm thick) were acquired parallel to the plane connecting the anterior and
posterior commissures and covering the whole brain (TR = 2000 ms, TE = 35 ms, flip angle = 90).
To aid in the localization of functional data, high-resolution images (3D Fast SPGR-IR, inversion
time 700 mm; FA=15; FOV=192x256x256 mm; matrix 512x512x168; slice thickness 1.1 mm) were
also acquired.
Subjects underwent three functional runs lasting 7 minutes 22 seconds each. During all runs a series
of tones were presented at very low volume within the noise of the scanner. The duration of each
tone was 200 ms and the inter-tone interval was 400 ms. The pitch of the majority (94%) of the
tones of the sequence was 400 Hz. The remaining tones (referred as oddballs) had a slightly higher
pitch (410 hz), and were presented, on average, every 15 tones. In the Rest state run, subjects were
instructed to keep their eyes closed, and avoid moving and falling asleep. In the Interoceptive state
run, subjects were instructed to focus on their respiration cycle, perceiving the air flowing in and
out. In the Exteroceptive state run, participants were asked to focus on the sequence of sounds and
identify the oddballs. At the end of the experiment we asked subjects whether they heard the tones
in the Rest and Interoceptive runs. None of the subjects (0 out of 24, including participants in both
groups) reported noticing the tones in the Rest or Interoceptive state, which indicates that the tones
were well camouflaged within the noise of the scanner in absence of voluntary directed attention to
them. A strict measure of audibility of the tones was not necessary for the purpose of this study
since our aim was to broadly direct attention endogenously or exogenously.
2.3 Data processing and analysis
Functional data were preprocessed using statistical parametric mapping software (SPM5;
http://fil.ion.ucl.ac.uk/spm). The first 4 volumes of each run were discarded to allow for
longitudinal relaxation time equilibration. EPI images from all sessions were slice-time corrected
and aligned to the first volume of the first session of scanning to correct for head movement
between scans. There was no excessive motion in any of the scans (lower than 3 mm). A mean
image was created using the realigned volumes. T1-weighted structural images were first co-
registered to the mean EPI image of each participant. Normalization parameters between the co-
registered T1 and the standard MNI T1 template were then calculated, and applied to the anatomy
and all EPI volumes. Data were then smoothed using an 8 mm full-width-at-half-maximum
isotropic Gaussian kernel to accommodate for inter-subject differences in anatomy.
One hundred-sixty previously published regions defining 6 functional networks (Fronto-parietal
(FP), Cingulo-Opercular (OP), Default Brain Network (DEF, Occipital (OC), Sensorimotor (SE)
and Cerebellum (CER) were used to build spherical ROIs defined as the set of voxels contained in a
5-mm sphere around a coordinate (Dosenbach et al., 2010). The mean time course in each ROI was
extracted by averaging the time courses of all of the voxels contained in the ROI
(http://marsbar.sourceforge.net). For each ROI, a time series was extracted separately for each
individual and each experimental condition. These regional fMRI time series were then used to
construct a 160-node functional connectivity network for each subject and condition. We used
wavelet analysis to construct correlation matrices from the time series (Supekar, Menon, Rubin,
Musen, & Greicius, 2008). We followed the procedures exactly as described by Supekar and
collaborators: We applied a maximum overlap discrete wavelet transform (MODWT) to each of the
time series to obtain the contributing signal in the following three frequency components: scale 1
(0.13 to 0.25 Hz), scale 2 (0.06 to 0.12 Hz), and scale 3 (0.01 to 0.05 Hz). All subsequent analysis
was done based on the scale 3 component, whose frequency lies in the range of slow frequency
correlations of the Default network (Fox et al., 2005; Raichle, 2009) . To account for the relatively
small number (220) of data points per time series for low frequency correlation analysis, the vector
representing the time series beyond its boundaries (0 and 220) was assumed to be a symmetric
reflection of itself (Supekar, Menon, Rubin, Musen, & Greicius, 2008) . The resulting connectivity
matrices describe frequency-dependent correlations, a measure of functional connectivity, between
spatially-distinct brain regions.
We also conducted a seed analysis (Fox et al., 2005), with the five most relevant ROIs for the
classification analysis (i.e. those ROIS that most contributed to classify the subjects). These ROIS
were -in descending relevance- from CO network: Anterior Insula [38, 21, -1], Dorsal Anterior
Cingulate [9, 20, 34], Anterior Prefrontal Cortex [27, 49, 26], Basal Ganglia [-6, 17, 34], Medial
Frontal Cortex [0, 15, 45]; from FP network: Intraparietal Sulcus [32, -59, 41], Dorsal Frontal
Cortex [44, 8, 34], Dorsal Frontal Cortex [40, 17, 40], Inferior Parietal Lobule [44, -52, 47], Dorsal
Frontal Cortex [-42, 7, 36]; from DEF network: Precuneus [9, -43, 25], left Inferior Temporal
Cortex [-61, -41, -2], Ventromedial Prefrontal Cortex [9, 51, 16], Angular Gyrus [51, -59, 34], right
Inferior Temporal Cortex [52, -15, -13].
To obtain a brain volume containing the correlation of every voxel with the seed ROI, we followed
the same methods than for the connectivity analysis, calculating the wavelet-correlation at low
frequencies between each seed's time series and all voxel time series for each subject and condition,
and remapping the resulting correlation vector into a 3D brain volume of the same size than the
normalized images, obtaining five volumes per subject and condition (one per ROI). We averaged
these five volumes to get an average volume representing the average connectivity between all
voxels in the brain and the five ROIs. Using these correlation volumes we conducted a second-level
multiple regression analysis, including IQ and sex as covariables of no interest, to regress each
correlation value to the ADOS score of each ASD subjects. To account for multiple comparisons,
the resulting statistical images were assessed for cluster-wise significance using a cluster-defined
threshold of p=0.005; extent threshold=5 voxels.
3 Graph Theory metrics
The connectivity matrix defines a weighted graph where each electrode corresponds to a node and
the weight of each link is determined by the wavelets correlation at low frequency. To calculate
network measures, functional connectivity matrices were converted to binary undirected matrices
by applying a threshold T. We explored a broad range of threshold values of 0.0005 < T < 1, with
increments of 0.001- and repeated the full analysis for each value of T. After transforming the
functional connectivity matrices to a binary undirected graph, we measured the Degree (K), Path
Length (L) and Clustering Coefficient (C) using the BCT toolbox (Sporns & Zwi, 2004). Network
visualizations were performed using the Pajek software package (http://pajek.imfm.si/doku.php)
using a Fruchterman–Reingold layout algorithm (Fruchterman & Reingold, 1991). Differences
between groups were assessed by means of independent ANOVAs with group and threshold (the
cutoff to determine whether two ROIs are connected) as independent factors. A broad range of
thresholds was used, from 50 to 750, in steps of 50 (excluding the extreme values where networks
disaggregate).
4 Classification analysis
In order to investigate the interaction between cognitive states and individual ROI connectivity, we
conducted a multi-parametric classification analysis using support vector machines (SVM)
(Theodoridis, 2009), to classify subjects as typical and ASD. We selected the degree (K) of each
individual ROI as features, averaged across all thresholds to avoid the use of an arbitrary one. We
chose SVM because they are resilient to over-fitting and allow the extraction of feature weights
(Dosenbach et al., 2010; Formisano, De Martino, Bonte, & Goebel, 2008; Norman, Polyn, Detre, &
Haxby, 2006) to explore in an unbiased way the ROIs that better characterize ASD changes across
conditions. A leave-one-out-cross-validation was used to estimate the significance of the
classification performance. This is a frequently used method because it allows the use of most of the
data for training (Fukunaga & Hummels, 1989). In this procedure, all samples except one are used
to train the SVM. The remaining sample is used to test the decision function derived from the
training stage. Each sample is designated only once as test, and the final accuracy of the SVM is
calculated averaging the accuracies for all test stages (repeating the analysis for each sample as test
sample). A permutation analysis was used to assess statistics of the classification procedure
(Golland & Fischl, 2003). The whole process of classification was repeated 10.000 times,
randomizing class labels to estimate an empirical distribution of the classifier accuracies under the
hypothesis of no discriminability (no actual group separation). P values are estimated as the
proportion of accuracies in the null-distribution higher than the observed accuracy.
3. Results
For each state s (Interoceptive, Exteroceptive or Rest) and participant p (24, 12 of each group) we
measured a 160*160 connectivity matrix where the matrix entry C(s,p) ij indicates the lag-0
correlation of the average fMRI signal of ROIs i and j for participant p in state s. As expected from
previous work (Dosenbach et al., 2007; Dosenbach et al., 2010) , simple inspection of correlation
matrices for all conditions and groups (Figure 1a) reveals that, the ROIs within each functional
system form clusters, with closely correlated temporal profiles.
group
Age
Total IQ
ADOS
Comm. Soc. Int.
Control
ASD
28,8 (5,00)
23,7 (7,13)
108,91 (12,62)
101,33 (13,79)
-
3,5
-
6,66
Total
-
10,16
Table 1. Details of ASD and Typical subjects: diagnosis, IQ and ADOS scores.
For each state, we conducted t-tests for each entry of the matrix comparing the ASD and typical
group of subjects (Figure 1a). A positive t-value indicates that connectivity increased in ASD com -
pared to typical population. Conversely, a negative t-value indicates that connectivity is greater in
the typical than in the ASD population. Figure 1b shows the distribution of absolute t-values to pic -
ture an unsigned estimate of change across groups for each cognitive state). The distributions of t-
values differences between groups is shifted towards negative values, showing a strong decreased
connectivity in ASD compared to typicals in the Exteroceptive condition (mean = -0.5539; std =
0.937; t-value = -94.53, Cimin = -0.5654; Cimax = -0.5424). The same trend is observed in the Rest
state condition (mean = -0.0938; std = 1.035; t-value = -14.507; CImin = -0.10; CImax = -0.08). By
contrast, an opposite effect is observed in the Introspective state condition, where there is a very
pronounced increase of connectivity in the ASD compared to typical group (mean = 0.4837; std =
1.059; t-value = 73.053, Cimin = 0.4707; Cimax = 0.496). This shows that, averaging across all
pairs of regions, connectivity increases in the ASD group for the Interoceptive condition and de -
creases for the Exteroceptive state condition. To better quantify this we conducted independent
mixed ANOVAs with group as a between subjects factor, and type of connection (21 possible sym -
metrical combinations between and within functional the 6 functional systems) as within factor. Full
results of the ANOVA are listed on table S1. The effect of connection type was significant for the
three cognitive states, confirming the functional segregation of the 6 functional systems and an in -
homogeneity in their specific pattern of connection (Dosenbach et al., 2010). In the Exteroceptive
and Interocepctive states we observed a significant effect of group with no interaction between both
factors: Effect of group in the Exteroceptive (F(1, 231) = 15,55; p < 0,001; mean typical = 0.4089;
mean ASD = 0.3565), and Interoceptive (F(1,231) =
Figure 1. Networks connectivity matrices. a) Averaged correlation matrices, for groups and conditions. Bottom raw
shows t-values for test-t between groups. b) T-value distributions for ASD (red) and Typicals (Blue).
9.72; p <0.01; mean typical = 0.3772; mean ASD = 0.4205). Instead, in the Rest state the effect of
group was non significant (F(1,231) = 0,58; p > 0,1; mean typical = 0.3741; mean ASD = 0.3664),
with no interaction between type of connection and group. These results reveal that, as seemed ap -
parent from an inspection of Figure 1, average functional brain connectivity decreases in the Exte -
roceptive state condition and increases in the Interoceptive state condition in ASD compared to typ -
icals. In the Rest state condition the excess and deficit of connectivity balance.
The previous analysis investigated how brain connectivity networks varied across groups for each
cognitive state. Another possible way of analysing our factorial dataset is to investigate how
networks vary within states for each group. Simple inspection of the connectivity matrices (Figure
1, Supplementary Figure 2) suggests that changes in connectivity matrices are more pronounced
across states in ASD subjects than in typicals. To quantify this observation we conducted within
group t-tests for each entry of the matrix comparing connectivity between Exteroceptive and
Interoceptive state conditions (Supplementary Figure 2). A positive t-value indicates that
connectivity increased in the Interoceptive state compared to the Exteroceptive state condition.
Conversely, a negative t-value indicates that connectivity is greater in the Exteroceptive than in the
Interoceptive state condition. The distributions of t-values differences for the typical group is almost
centered at zero (mean = 0.01; std = 0.734; t-value = -3.43, Cimin = 0.0068; Cimax = 0.024),
showing that there is no net change in connectivity across conditions. On the contrary, the
distribution of t-values for the ASD group is strongly shifted to positive values (mean = 0.4837; std
= 1.059; t-value = 112.19, Cimin = 0.5575; Cimax = 0.5773). This shows that connectivity in ASD
subjects strongly fluctuates in different cognitive states while in the typical subjects it shows modest
fluctuations and remains relatively stable. The systems showing greater variability in connectivity
across states in the ASD groups were the CO, FP and DEF (Supplementary Figure 2).
To investigate the impact of changes in connectivity in network topology, we constructed functional
networks assigning one node for each ROI and considering a link between nodes if connectivity
exceeded a fixed threshold. We used an arbitrary threshold of 0.55 and embedded the network in the
two-dimensional plane using a force-directed algorithm of energy minimization (Fruchterman &
Reingold, 1991). This is merely for visualization purposes; the results described here were robusts
within a wide range of thresholds and statistical analysis used a varying threshold as an independent
factor (see Supplementary Figure S3). The embedded functional networks revealed patterns
consistent with Figure 1 and allow to further zoom in specific topological changes between groups
and states. Networks of both groups are quite similar in the Rest state condition, with the exception
of the Default system whose nodes are quite apart in the ASD network but form a compact cluster
in the Typical network (Figure 2a, pink dots, centre). This is consistent with previous observations
Figure 2. Organization of functional brain networks and network metrics. a) Two-dimensional projections of the net-
works for ASD and typical subjects for all conditions b) Comparison of S=C/L which estimates the small-worldness of
a network for typical and ASD. ASD subjects present lower S in Exteroceptive, almost equal S in Resting and higher S
in Interoceptive.
identifying a main change in the connectivity of the default system between ASD and typicals in the
resting state (Belmonte et al., 2004; Courchesne, Redcay, Morgan, & Kennedy, 2005; Just,
Cherkassky, Keller, Kana, & Minshew, 2007; Kennedy & Courchesne, 2008; Monk et al., 2009;
Wass, 2011; Weng, 2010). Networks obtained in the Exteroceptive state condition show more
pronounced topological differences across both groups: The typical network is more packed and
clustered, suggesting a lower diameter of the entire network (Figure 2a, left). by contrast, the ASD
network is more compact in the Interoceptive state condition. We observe that the Cingulo-
Opercular (black dots) system is more tightly packed (self-connected) for the ASD group, and
closely connected to the Fronto-parietal (yellow) and Default (pink) systems (Figure 2a, right).
To quantify these observations we performed independent ANOVA analyses for the Path Length
(L) and the Clustering Coefficient (C) (Gallos, Song, Havlin, & Makse, 2007; Sporns & Zwi, 2004)
and for each states with group and threshold (the cutoff to determine whether two ROIs are
connected) as independent factors. Threshold effect was significant for all conditions, while
interaction between group and threshold was never significant. This means that threshold selection
did not change the pattern observed across groups. Comparisons between typical and ASD revealed
an effect of group on C (higher in ASD) and L (lower in ASD) in the Interoceptive state condition
(C: F(1,330) = 4,60; p < 0,05; L: F(1,330) = 8,52; p < 0,01 ). Comparisons between groups also
revealed a main effect of group in the Exteroceptive state condition for C (lower in ASD) and L
(higher in ASD) (C: F(1,330) = 6,60; p < 0,01; L: F(1,330) = 8,73; p < 0,01 ). On the contrary, there
was no effect either for C nor for L in the Resting state condition (C: F(1,330) = 0,17; p > 0,1; L:
F(1,330) = 0,02; p > 0,5). The combined changes of path length and clustering can be combined in
the quotient S=C/L (Figure 2b), which indicates how closely the network is organized as a Small-
World (The higher S, the more small-world organization). Small-world refers to an ubiquitous
present topological network which has a relatively short (compared to random networks)
characteristic path length (L) and high clustering coefficient (C)(Watts & Strogatz, 1998). Our
results show that S increases for the typical compared to the ASD group in the Exteroceptive state
condition (F(1,330) = 10,01; p < 0,01). Instead,S is higher for the ASD than the typical group in the
Interoceptive state condition (F(1,330) = 17,4; p < 0,0001). There are no significant differences in
the Resting state condition (F(1,330) = 0,27; p > 0,5) (Figure 2b).
The next aim was to investigate which aspects of connectivity are more informative to classify
subjects as belonging to the typical or ASD group. For classification purposes, we used a support
vector machine (SVM), an algorithm from the Machine Learning field widely used in the
classification of neuroimages (Ecker, Marquand et al., 2010; Kloppel et al., 2011; Theodoridis,
2009; Vapnik, 1998). We investigated the classification power of functional connectivity using the
degree of each ROI, which broadly estimates mean connectivity, as the main classification feature.
Results, based on a leave-one-out procedure (see Experimental procedures) showed non significant
classification rate for all cognitive states: Resting = 0.50; p > 0.1; Interoceptive = 0.50; p > 0.1.
Exteroceptive = 0.45; p > 0.1). Based on our previous analysis which showing a very marked
interaction between group and cognitive state, we reasoned that instead of considering the
connectivity within one cognitive state a better classification feature might be the difference in
connectivity between the Exteroceptive and Interoceptive states. When the difference in
connectivity between these two states was used as a feature, we indeed observed a significantly
better classification (0.75; p < 0.01). Other differences did not show any significant results
(Exteroceptive – Resting = 0.62; p > 0.1.
Figure 3. Classification analysis. a) Weighted degree for all subjects, sorted by the difference between groups. b)
Averaged across subjects per group showing the incremental difference between degree between groups. Shadow
represents s.e.m. C) Top 20 ROIs for the classification analysis.
Interoceptive – Resting = 0.50; p > 0.1). A direct comparison of variability in connectivity across
states for the ASD condition was mostly concentrated in the Fronto-parietal (FP), Cingulo-
Opercular (CO) and Default (DEF) (Supplementary Figure 2). These are particularly relevant brain
structures since they account for a segregation of executive control in adaptive control (FP) and
stable set-maintenance (CO) functions (Dosenbach et al., 2007). They have also been proposed to
play a key role in psychopathology (Menon, 2011). As expected, when we restricted to the CO-FP-
DEF set of ROIs, performance in the leave-one out procedure achieved higher scores, reaching
performance above 90% for the Interoceptive – Exteroceptive difference (0.9167; p < 0.0001) (See
Table S2).
An interesting aspect of SVM analysis is that it allows to measure the weight with which each ROI
contributes to the classification (Figure 3). To visualize the relative contribution of different
systems and ROIs to classification, we sorted the value of all features weighted by their
classification power. This analysis showed that the majority of ROIs that better separate ASD from
typicals belong to the cingulo opercular (CO) system. The four regions with the strongest
classification power are: right Anterior Insula [38, 21, -1], the Dorsal Anterior Cingulate [9, 20, 34],
the right Anterior Prefrontal Cortex [27, 49, 26] and the Basal Ganglia [-6, 17, 34]), which belong
to the CO. Within the DEF system, the ROIs with strongest classification power are the Precuneus
[9, -43, 25], left Inferior Temporal Cortex [-61, -41, -2], Ventromedial Prefrontal Cortex [9, 51, 16],
right Angular Gyrus [51, -59, 34], and right Inferior Temporal Cortex [52, -15, -13]. In the FP
system, the ROIs that are within the top 20 contributers to classification are right Intraparietal
Sulcus [32, -59, 41], right Dorsal Frontal Cortex [44, 8, 34 and 40, 17, 40]], and right Inferior
Parietal Lobule [44, -52, 47].
The preceding analysis is based on categorical classification, where each participant is assigned to
the typical or ASD group. Although significant, this classification is based on a relatively small
sample size (a total of 24 subjects, 12 belonging to each category). A more taxing way to
investigate the impact of specific connectivity patterns and their dependence with cognitive state on
ASD is to investigate progressive changes in connectivity with a continuous progression of ASD
severity. If the observed differences in connectivity between groups truly characterize ASD, these
differences should also progress according to the severity of ASD. ASD severity is measured
through ADOS score which varied from 7 (the minimal value for ASD diagnosis) to 16 in our
clinical population. We examined how the connectivity between ROIs and the rest of the brain
covaried with ADOS.
To be able to visualize the topography of this covariation without presenting an overwhelming
amount of data we calculated the correlation between each of the three main systems (FP, CO and
DEF) that were previously identified by the classification and variance analysis as the most
sensitive systems to detect differences between typicals and ASD and the rest of the brain. For each
of these three systems, we first calculated the five ROIs which ranked higher in their classification
power. We then ran an independent seed analysis measuring the average correlation of the five
ROIs to all voxels in the brain. Finally, we averaged the five correlation brain volumes of each
system to obtain a single volume per subject and system. In a second (group) level of analysis, the
resulting correlation volumes calculated for each individual and system were submitted to a linear
model using ADOS score as a regressor, and Intelligence Quotient (IQ) and sex as potential
regressors of no interest which could account for the variance. To account for multiple comparisons,
the resulting statistical images were assessed for cluster-wise significance using a cluster-defined
threshold of p=0.005; extent threshold=5 voxels. We observed a strong dependence of connectivity
with ADOS in the Resting and Interoceptive state conditions (Figure 4).A full detail of the
correlation maps is presented in Table S4 We refer below to the most relevant findings, but a full
detail of the correlation maps is presented in Table S4. First we note that none of the correlations
was significant in the Exteroceptive state condition. This finding is somewhat
Figure 4. Projection of statistically significant clusters for positive (red) and negative (blue) correlation between ADOS
and connectivity. All negative relations between ADOS and connectivity are found in Neutral condition. Most of the
positive relations between ADOS and connectivity are found in Interoceptive conditions. There are no significant
correlation between ADOS and Exteroceptive condition.
puzzling since we had observed that at the group level connectivity decreased for the ASD
compared to typicals. This result shows that this effect is not smoothly graded with the severity of
the disease. Second, we observe a main trend in regions showing negative covariation (i.e. whose
connectivity decreases with ADOS). Negative covariations are only observed in the Rest state
condition. They are largely localized within the posterior brain in the parietal, occipital and
temporal regions, which tend to be more disconnected from the three main systems (CO, FP and
DEF). Instead, regions showing positive correlations (i.e. whose connectivity increases with ADOS)
are mainly observed in the Interoceptive state condition and largely localized in the more dorsal
regions of the brain.
4. Discussion
The purpose of this study was to characterize and compare large-scale functional brain connectivity
networks in ASD and typical subjects in three different cognitive states. The main novelty of our
work lies in demonstrating that connectivity changes between ASD and typical populations are state
dependent. Beyond the specific functional properties of the brain areas involved, which we review
below, our results show a consistent global trend in the ASD relative to the typical population: brain
network connectivity increases when attention is directed towards an internal stimulus
(Interoceptive state) and decreases when attention is directed to an external stimulus (Exteroceptive
state). In the Rest state, our data replicate previous findings suggesting a decrease in the intrinsic
connectivity of the default system in ASD (Belmonte et al., 2004; Just, Cherkassky, Keller, Kana, &
Minshew, 2007; Kennedy & Courchesne, 2008; Monk et al., 2009; Wass, 2011; Weng, 2010) . In
addition, classification analysis revealed that changes in brain networks connectivity in different
mental states are more informative than direct comparison of brain networks between populations in
a given state to distinguish typical and ASD subjects.
Neuroanatomical brain abnormalities in psychiatric pathologies have previously been investigated
as potential classifiers aiming to assist or refine diagnosis (Ecker, Marquand et al., 2010; Kloppel et
al., 2011; Kloppel et al., 2008) . Most studies using a classification approach to explore specific
neuropathological underpinnings and brain-based biomarkers of ASD have used sets of
morphological data parameters such as cortical thickness or gray matter volume (Ecker, Marquand
et al., 2010; Ecker, Rocha-Rego et al., 2010; Uddin et al., 2011) . To date, no published studies have
used functional imaging data to identify precisely which brain regions can be used to discriminate
individuals with ASD from typically developing individuals. Our study is the first to apply analytic
SVM approach to functional imaging data and large scale network modelisation. We show that the
properties of functional brain connectivity networks in any given cognitive state are poor classifiers
to separate ASD and typical populations. Quite timely, our results thus reveal that the exploration of
resting state within a library of other mental states contains much more information to classify ASD
and typical subjects. This may constitute a powerful methodology beyond the specific domain of
ASD.
The linear classifier method we used has the advantage to enable the identification of which specific
brain regions contribute the most to the classification process (Figure 3). Interestingly, all six
regions showing the highest classification accuracy in our study -anterior insula (AI), dorsal
Anterior Cingulate Cortex (dACC), anterior Prefrontal Cortex (aPFC), Intra-Parietals Sulcus (IPS),
Middle Frontal Cortex (mFC), and Precuneus (PC) - are relevant to the ASD pathology.
In our data, the Anterior Insula (AI) showed the greatest classification accuracy and appears as a
key region showing differences between Exteroceptive and Interoceptive attentional states. It is also
one of the brain regions showing the strongest correlation with ADOS score. Several independent
sources of evidence predict that the AI would play a key role in this classification process. First, AI
is situated at the interface between the cognitive, homeostatic and affective systems of the human
brain, providing a link between stimulus-driven processing and brain regions involved in
monitoring the internal milieu and interoceptive awareness of physiological changes in the body
(Craig, 2002, 2009, 2010, 2011; Menon, 2011). Moreover, Critchley (2004) provided evidence that
there are strong links between the right AI, perception of one’s own bodily state, and the experience
of emotion. The AI would be part of a “salience network” that mediates dynamic interactions
between externally oriented attention and internally oriented self-related processes, and serves to
integrate sensory data with visceral, autonomic, and hedonic information (Sridharan, Levitin, &
Menon, 2008; Uddin & Menon, 2009) . Second, it has been shown to be involved in social cognition
and emotion processing, through integration of interoceptive informations and body awareness
(Lamm & Singer, 2010; Straube & Miltner, 2011) . Interestingly, interoceptive representation has
been suggested to modulate many skills known to be compromised in ASD, such as motivational
behaviour (Craig, 2002), empathy (Lamm, Decety, & Singer, 2011; Lamm & Singer, 2010),
processing of basic emotions (Wicker et al., 2003) and social skills such as theory of mind (Bird et
al., 2010). In concordance, AI has been reported as significantly hypo-activated and underconnected
in ASD during social and empathic tasks (Di Martino et al., 2009; Silani et al., 2008) . Third, at the
anatomical level, the AI is among the few brain regions (along with the dACC, our second most
predictive ROI) containing Von Economo or “spindle” neurons, thought to be unique to higher
primates (Nimchinsky et al., 1999) and whose abnormal development may cause the social
disabilities characteristic of ASD (Allman, Watson, Tetreault, & Hakeem, 2005; Frith, 2001; Santos
et al., 2010).
Craig and collaborators have postulated that the AI is an evolutionary specialization in primates that
is tailored to integrate a map of internal bodily states with motivational drives generated in the
dACC (see Craig, 2009 for review). Interestingly, the dACC ranks second in classification accuracy
and our results demonstrate specifically that dACC and AI connectivity (both within the cingulo-
opercular system) show a very marked interaction with condition and cognitive state: their
connectivity increases in ASD compared to typical population in the Interoceptive state and
decreases in ASD compared to typical population in the Exteroceptive state. Consistent with this,
hyper-activation of the dACC to social targets has been reported to predict the severity of social
impairments in ASD subjects (Dichter, Felder, & Bodfish, 2009). Similarly, our results are inline
with the observed specific increase in functional connectivity between striatal subregions –another
Cingulo-opercular ROI– and insula (Di Martino et al., 2011) which in our study is only observed in
the Interoceptive state. AI and dACC are believed to constitute the main nodes of the Cingulo-
opercular system, and to integrate cognitive, homeostatic and emotional information (Menon, 2011;
Menon & Uddin, 2010). Altogether, previous data consistently show that interaction of the AI with
other brain systems such as the dACC plays a key role in the mediation of interoceptive and
exteroceptive states. The function of this ‘salience network’ is to identify the most homeostatically
relevant among several internal and extrapersonal stimuli in order to guide behavior (Seeley et al.,
2007). Our findings suggest that this “salience network” may be affected by ASD condition.
The right aPFC ranked third in our classification analysis. This region has been related to several
functions including explicit processing of internal states and the introspective evaluation of one’s
own thoughts and feelings (Fleming, Weil, Nagy, Dolan, & Rees, 2010) . Anterior PFC functioning
and structure are also known to be altered in ASD, with evidence of dysfunctionning during
executive functioning (Kawakubo et al., 2009), mentalising (Dumontheil, Burgess, & Blakemore,
2008; Schmitz et al., 2006) and self representation (Lombardo et al., 2010). Structurally, the aPFC
is characterized by an increased amount of gray matter in ASD (Lombardo et al., 2012). The
dorsomedial Prefrontal Cortex (mPFC) has been repeatedly reported as underactivated in ASD,
particularly during tasks requiring attribution of mental states or social information processing
(Castelli, Frith, Happe, & Frith, 2002). Furthermore, abnormal effective connectivity has been
reported between the mPFC and the right lateral anterior prefrontal cortex in a task involving
explicit emotional processing in ASD (Wicker et al., 2008). Abnormal development of the medial
prefrontal cortex has been proposed in ASD, with evidence of abnormal local over-connectivity and
long distance disconnection (Courchesne, Redcay, Morgan, & Kennedy, 2005; Zikopoulos &
Barbas, 2010). The mPFC is also a key structure of the default mode network, along with the IPS
and the precuneus, two brain regions ranking high in the classification analysis. Abnormal
functioning of these structures was reported in several resting state studies in ASD (Kana, Keller,
Cherkassky, Minshew, & Just, 2009; Monk et al., 2009).
Recent mathematical efforts have established connecting bridges between connectivity measures
and functional properties of the emergent network (Gallos, Song, Havlin, & Makse, 2007; Sporns &
Zwi, 2004) and the main relevance of brain connectivity patterns lies in their implications for global
function in terms of information transfer and segregation between regions. While at this stage
conclusions based on graph metrics are purely speculative, our findings suggest that the ASD
functional connectivity brain networks largely vary across conditions: when subjects are asked to
focus attention to external stimuli, the associated brain connectivity network reveals sub-optimal
metrics, suggesting that ASD networks are badly suited for this kind of information processing.
When attention is focused on internally generated stimuli, ASD brain networks improve their
metrics –even surpassing those of typicals’- suggesting that ASD networks may be better tuned for
interoception. Although the processing of an interoceptive stimulus may be adequate, it is the
balance and switch between exteroceptive and interoceptive information and the importance that
they are assigned that could be different in ASD.
What would be the consequences of such dysfunctionning of the cingulo-opercular network salience
network in ASD? On a speculative ground, it is possible that ASD subjects are more likely to focus
on "internal sensations" than typical subjects. But paying too much attention to internal information
can be a problem. Indeed, typical individuals can attend to higher level cognitive and social tasks by
virtue of not needing to attend to the background delivery of interoceptive information. In ASD
subjects, on the other hand, interoceptive information might become distracting, creating an
imbalance between functional brain networks and sources of information. An interesting and
challenging idea linked to the fact that the ASD physiopathology may be mainly expressed in
changes in connectivity of core ROIs of the Cingulo-Opercular system such as AI and dACC is the
recently proposed “Triple Network model” of psychopatology (Menon, 2011). This model proposes
that most, if not all major psychopathologies are due to dysfunctions in large scale brain networks,
principally involving these nodes of the CO system. The CO system dysfunction plays a major role:
weak mapping from the AI - dACC areas gives rise to aberrant engagement of the FP system,
compromising cognition and goal-relevant adaptive behaviour (Menon, 2011).
Finally, an open aspect of these results is whether the network changes between the two groups
reveal a distinct pattern of thoughts, a different functional implementation of a comparable pattern
of thoughts, or both. This note of caution is actually relevant for all studies comparing resting state
activity between groups. The content of thoughts evoked during the resting state of a group of
patients might be qualitatively different than those evoked by a typical group and this may account
for the observed differences. By directing typicals and patients to different mental states and by
observing opposed differences, the possibility that all the effects observed here reflect a different
pattern of thought becomes unlikely but requires of course quantitative argumentation. Future work
should elucidate whether indeed the observed imbalances in functional brain connectivity constitute
a central aspect of ASD etiology, understand how they may relate to the organization of thought in
the different states and validate their potential to become a clinically useful ASD biomarker.
Acknowledgements
This work is supported by the Human Frontiers Science Program. BW is supported by the CNRS.
PB has a fellowship of the National Research Council of Argentina (CONICET) and was supported
by a Human Frontiers Science Program research grant. The work is part of a collaborative ECOS
project A08S03 between the French CNRS and the argentinian MinCyT.
References
Alexander, A. L., Lee, J. E., Lazar, M., Boudos, R., DuBray, M. B., Oakes, T. R., Miller, J. N., Lu,
J., Jeong, E. K., McMahon, W. M., Bigler, E. D., & Lainhart, J. E. (2007). Diffusion tensor
imaging of the corpus callosum in Autism. Neuroimage, 34, 61-73.
Allman, J. M., Watson, K. K., Tetreault, N. A., & Hakeem, A. Y. (2005). Intuition and autism: a
possible role for Von Economo neurons. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 9, 367-373.
APA. (2000). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, Text
Revision. Washinton DC: American Psychiatric Association, (Chapter Chapter).
Barnea-Goraly, N., Lotspeich, L. J., & Reiss, A. L. (2010). Similar white matter aberrations in
children with autism and their unaffected siblings: a diffusion tensor imaging study using
tract-based spatial statistics. Archives of General Psychiatry, 67, 1052-1060.
Barttfeld, P., Wicker, B., Cukier, S., Navarta, S., Lew, S., & Sigman, M. (2011). A big-world
network in ASD: dynamical connectivity analysis reflects a deficit in long-range
connections and an excess of short-range connections. Neuropsychologia, 49, 254-263.
Belmonte, M. K., Allen, G., Beckel-Mitchener, A., Boulanger, L. M., Carper, R. A., & Webb, S. J.
(2004). Autism and abnormal development of brain connectivity. Journal of Neuroscience,
24, 9228-9231.
Belmonte, M. K., Gomot, M., & Baron-Cohen, S. (2010). Visual attention in autism families:
'unaffected' sibs share atypical frontal activation. Journal of Child Psychology and
Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines, 51, 259-276.
Bird, G., Silani, G., Brindley, R., White, S., Frith, U., & Singer, T. (2010). Empathic brain
responses in insula are modulated by levels of alexithymia but not autism. Brain, 133, 1515-
1525.
Castelli, F., Frith, C., Happe, F., & Frith, U. (2002). Autism, Asperger syndrome and brain
mechanisms for the attribution of mental states to animated shapes. Brain, 125, 1839-1849.
Courchesne, E., Redcay, E., Morgan, J. T., & Kennedy, D. P. (2005). Autism at the beginning:
microstructural and growth abnormalities underlying the cognitive and behavioral
phenotype of autism. Development and Psychopathology, 17, 577-597.
Craig, A. D. (2002). How do you feel? Interoception: the sense of the physiological condition of the
body. Nature Review Neuroscience, 3, 655-666.
Craig, A. D. (2009). How do you feel--now? The anterior insula and human awareness. Nature
Review Neuroscience, 10, 59-70.
Craig, A. D. (2010). The sentient self. Brain Structure and Function, 214, 563-577.
Craig, A. D. (2011). Significance of the insula for the evolution of human awareness of feelings
from the body. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1225, 72-82.
Critchley, H. D., Wiens, S., Rotshtein, P., Ohman, A., & Dolan, R. J. (2004). Neural systems
supporting interoceptive awareness. Nature Neuroscience, 7, 189-195.
Di Martino, A., Kelly, C., Grzadzinski, R., Zuo, X. N., Mennes, M., Mairena, M. A., Lord, C.,
Castellanos, F. X., & Milham, M. P. (2011). Aberrant striatal functional connectivity in
children with autism. Biological Psychiatry, 69, 847-856.
Di Martino, A., Ross, K., Uddin, L. Q., Sklar, A. B., Castellanos, F. X., & Milham, M. P. (2009).
Functional brain correlates of social and nonsocial processes in autism spectrum disorders:
an activation likelihood estimation meta-analysis. Biological Psychiatry, 65, 63-74.
Dichter, G. S., Felder, J. N., & Bodfish, J. W. (2009). Autism is characterized by dorsal anterior
cingulate hyperactivation during social target detection. Social Cognitive and Affective
Neuroscience, 4, 215-226.
Dosenbach, N. U., Fair, D. A., Miezin, F. M., Cohen, A. L., Wenger, K. K., Dosenbach, R. A., Fox,
M. D., Snyder, A. Z., Vincent, J. L., Raichle, M. E., Schlaggar, B. L., & Petersen, S. E.
(2007). Distinct brain networks for adaptive and stable task control in humans. Proceedings
of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 104, 11073-11078.
Dosenbach, N. U., Nardos, B., Cohen, A. L., Fair, D. A., Power, J. D., Church, J. A., Nelson, S. M.,
Wig, G. S., Vogel, A. C., Lessov-Schlaggar, C. N., Barnes, K. A., Dubis, J. W., Feczko, E.,
Coalson, R. S., Pruett, J. R., Jr., Barch, D. M., Petersen, S. E., & Schlaggar, B. L. (2010).
Prediction of individual brain maturity using fMRI. Science, 329, 1358-1361.
Dumontheil, I., Burgess, P. W., & Blakemore, S. J. (2008). Development of rostral prefrontal cortex
and cognitive and behavioural disorders. Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology, 50,
168-181.
Duncan, J. (2010). The multiple-demand (MD) system of the primate brain: mental programs for
intelligent behaviour. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 14, 172-179.
Ecker, C., Marquand, A., Mourao-Miranda, J., Johnston, P., Daly, E. M., Brammer, M. J., Maltezos,
S., Murphy, C. M., Robertson, D., Williams, S. C., & Murphy, D. G. (2010). Describing the
brain in autism in five dimensions--magnetic resonance imaging-assisted diagnosis of
autism spectrum disorder using a multiparameter classification approach. Journal of
Neuroscience, 30, 10612-10623.
Ecker, C., Rocha-Rego, V., Johnston, P., Mourao-Miranda, J., Marquand, A., Daly, E. M.,
Brammer, M. J., Murphy, C., & Murphy, D. G. (2010). Investigating the predictive value of
whole-brain structural MR scans in autism: a pattern classification approach. Neuroimage,
49, 44-56.
Egaas, B., Courchesne, E., & Saitoh, O. (1995). Reduced size of corpus callosum in autism.
Archives of Neurology, 52, 794-801.
Fleming, S. M., Weil, R. S., Nagy, Z., Dolan, R. J., & Rees, G. (2010). Relating introspective
accuracy to individual differences in brain structure. Science, 329, 1541-1543.
Fletcher, P. T., Whitaker, R. T., Tao, R., DuBray, M. B., Froehlich, A., Ravichandran, C.,
Alexander, A. L., Bigler, E. D., Lange, N., & Lainhart, J. E. (2010). Microstructural
connectivity of the arcuate fasciculus in adolescents with high-functioning autism.
Neuroimage, 51, 1117-1125.
Formisano, E., De Martino, F., Bonte, M., & Goebel, R. (2008). "Who" is saying "what"? Brain-
based decoding of human voice and speech. Science, 322, 970-973.
Fox, M. D., Snyder, A. Z., Vincent, J. L., Corbetta, M., Van Essen, D. C., & Raichle, M. E. (2005).
The human brain is intrinsically organized into dynamic, anticorrelated functional networks.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 102,
9673-9678.
Frith, U. (2001). Mind blindness and the brain in autism. Neuron, 32, 969-979.
Fruchterman, T., & Reingold, E. (1991). Graph drawing by force-directed placement. Software -
Practice and Experience, 21, 1129 - 1164.
Fukunaga, K., & Hummels, D. M. (1989). Leave-one-out procedures for nonparameric error
estimates. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 11, 421-423.
Gallos, L. K., H;, M., & Sigman, M. (in press). The conundrum of functional brain networks: small-
world or fractal modularity. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United
States of America.
Gallos, L. K., Song, C., Havlin, S., & Makse, H. A. (2007). Scaling theory of transport in complex
biological networks. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States
of America, 104, 7746-7751.
Golland, P., & Fischl, B. (2003). Permutation tests for classification: towards statistical significance
in image-based studies. Information Processing in Medicine Imaging, 18, 330-341.
Hadjikhani, N., Joseph, R. M., Snyder, J., & Tager-Flusberg, H. (2006). Anatomical differences in
the mirror neuron system and social cognition network in autism. Cerebral Cortex, 16,
1276-1282.
Hardan, A. Y., Muddasani, S., Vemulapalli, M., Keshavan, M. S., & Minshew, N. J. (2006). An
MRI study of increased cortical thickness in autism. American Journal of Psychiatry, 163,
1290-1292.
Haswell, C. C., Izawa, J., Dowell, L. R., Mostofsky, S. H., & Shadmehr, R. (2009). Representation
of internal models of action in the autistic brain. Nature Neuroscience, 12, 970-972.
Herbert, M. R., Ziegler, D. A., Deutsch, C. K., O'Brien, L. M., Kennedy, D. N., Filipek, P. A.,
Bakardjiev, A. I., Hodgson, J., Takeoka, M., Makris, N., & Caviness, V. S., Jr. (2005). Brain
asymmetries in autism and developmental language disorder: a nested whole-brain analysis.
Brain, 128, 213-226.
Just, M. A., Cherkassky, V. L., Keller, T. A., Kana, R. K., & Minshew, N. J. (2007). Functional and
Anatomical Cortical Underconnectivity in Autism: Evidence from an fMRI Study of an
Executive Function Task and Corpus Callosum Morphometry. Cerebral Cortex, 17, 951--
961.
Kana, R. K., Keller, T. A., Cherkassky, V. L., Minshew, N. J., & Just, M. A. (2009). Atypical
frontal-posterior synchronization of Theory of Mind regions in autism during mental state
attribution. Social Neuroscience, 4, 135-152.
Kawakubo, Y., Kuwabara, H., Watanabe, K., Minowa, M., Someya, T., Minowa, I., Kono, T.,
Nishida, H., Sugiyama, T., Kato, N., & Kasai, K. (2009). Impaired prefrontal hemodynamic
maturation in autism and unaffected siblings. PLoS One, 4, e6881.
Kennedy, D. P., & Courchesne, E. (2008). The intrinsic functional organization of the brain is
altered in autism. Neuroimage, 39, 1877-1885.
Kloppel, S., Abdulkadir, A., Jack, C. R., Jr., Koutsouleris, N., Mourao-Miranda, J., & Vemuri, P.
(2011). Diagnostic neuroimaging across diseases. Neuroimage.
Kloppel, S., Stonnington, C. M., Barnes, J., Chen, F., Chu, C., Good, C. D., Mader, I., Mitchell, L.
A., Patel, A. C., Roberts, C. C., Fox, N. C., Jack, C. R., Jr., Ashburner, J., & Frackowiak, R.
S. (2008). Accuracy of dementia diagnosis: a direct comparison between radiologists and a
computerized method. Brain, 131, 2969-2974.
Lamm, C., Decety, J., & Singer, T. (2011). Meta-analytic evidence for common and distinct neural
networks associated with directly experienced pain and empathy for pain. Neuroimage, 54,
2492-2502.
Lamm, C., & Singer, T. (2010). The role of anterior insular cortex in social emotions. Brain
Structure and Function, 214, 579-591.
Lombardo, M. V., Ashwin, E., Auyeung, B., Chakrabarti, B., Taylor, K., Hackett, G., Bullmore, E.
T., & Baron-Cohen, S. (2012). Fetal Testosterone Influences Sexually Dimorphic Gray
Matter in the Human Brain. Journal of Neuroscience, 32, 674-680.
Lombardo, M. V., Chakrabarti, B., Bullmore, E. T., Sadek, S. A., Pasco, G., Wheelwright, S. J.,
Suckling, J., & Baron-Cohen, S. (2010). Atypical neural self-representation in autism.
Brain, 133, 611-624.
Lord, C., Risi, S., Lambrecht, L., Cook, E. H., Jr., Leventhal, B. L., DiLavore, P. C., Pickles, A., &
Rutter, M. (2000). The autism diagnostic observation schedule-generic: a standard measure
of social and communication deficits associated with the spectrum of autism. Journal of
Autism and Developmental Disorders, 30, 205-223.
McAlonan, G. M., Cheung, V., Cheung, C., Suckling, J., Lam, G. Y., Tai, K. S., Yip, L., Murphy,
D. G., & Chua, S. E. (2005). Mapping the brain in autism. A voxel-based MRI study of
volumetric differences and intercorrelations in autism. Brain, 128, 268-276.
Menon, V. (2011). Large-scale brain networks and psychopathology: a unifying triple network
model. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 15, 483-506.
Menon, V., & Uddin, L. Q. (2010). Saliency, switching, attention and control: a network model of
insula function. Brain Structure and Function, 214, 655-667.
Monk, C. S., Peltier, S. J., Wiggins, J. L., Weng, S. J., Carrasco, M., Risi, S., & Lord, C. (2009).
Abnormalities of intrinsic functional connectivity in autism spectrum disorders.
Neuroimage, 47, 764-772.
Nimchinsky, E. A., Gilissen, E., Allman, J. M., Perl, D. P., Erwin, J. M., & Hof, P. R. (1999). A
neuronal morphologic type unique to humans and great apes. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 96, 5268-5273.
Nordahl, C. W., Dierker, D., Mostafavi, I., Schumann, C. M., Rivera, S. M., Amaral, D. G., & Van
Essen, D. C. (2007). Cortical folding abnormalities in autism revealed by surface-based
morphometry. Journal of Neuroscience, 27, 11725-11735.
Norman, K. A., Polyn, S. M., Detre, G. J., & Haxby, J. V. (2006). Beyond mind-reading: multi-
voxel pattern analysis of fMRI data. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 10, 424-430.
Raichle, M. E. (2009). A paradigm shift in functional brain imaging. Journal of Neuroscience, 29,
12729-12734.
Santos, M., Uppal, N., Butti, C., Wicinski, B., Schmeidler, J., Giannakopoulos, P., Heinsen, H.,
Schmitz, C., & Hof, P. R. (2010). von Economo neurons in autism: a stereologic study of
the frontoinsular cortex in children. Brain Research, 1380, 206-217.
Schipul, S. E., Keller, T. A., & Just, M. A. (2011). Inter-regional brain communication and its
disturbance in autism. Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience, 5, 10.
Schmitz, N., Rubia, K., Daly, E., Smith, A., Williams, S., & Murphy, D. G. (2006). Neural
correlates of executive function in autistic spectrum disorders. Biological Psychiatry, 59, 7-
16.
Seeley, W. W., Menon, V., Schatzberg, A. F., Keller, J., Glover, G. H., Kenna, H., Reiss, A. L., &
Greicius, M. D. (2007). Dissociable intrinsic connectivity networks for salience processing
and executive control. Journal of Neuroscience, 27, 2349-2356.
Silani, G., Bird, G., Brindley, R., Singer, T., Frith, C., & Frith, U. (2008). Levels of emotional
awareness and autism: an fMRI study. Social Neuroscience, 3, 97-112.
Sporns, O., & Zwi, J. D. (2004). The small world of the cerebral cortex. Neuroinformatics, 2, 145-
162.
Sridharan, D., Levitin, D. J., & Menon, V. (2008). A critical role for the right fronto-insular cortex
in switching between central-executive and default-mode networks. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 105, 12569-12574.
Straube, T., & Miltner, W. H. (2011). Attention to aversive emotion and specific activation of the
right insula and right somatosensory cortex. Neuroimage, 54, 2534-2538.
Supekar, K., Menon, V., Rubin, D., Musen, M., & Greicius, M. D. (2008). Network analysis of
intrinsic functional brain connectivity in Alzheimer's disease. PLoS Computational Biology,
4, e1000100.
Thakkar, K. N., Polli, F. E., Joseph, R. M., Tuch, D. S., Hadjikhani, N., Barton, J. J., & Manoach,
D. S. (2008). Response monitoring, repetitive behaviour and anterior cingulate abnormalities
in autism spectrum disorders (ASD). Brain, 131, 2464-2478.
Theodoridis, S. K. K. (2009). Pattern Recognition: Theory and Applications”, 4th edition
(Chapter Chapter).
Uddin, L. Q., & Menon, V. (2009). The anterior insula in autism: under-connected and under-
examined. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 33, 1198-1203.
Uddin, L. Q., Menon, V., Young, C. B., Ryali, S., Chen, T., Khouzam, A., Minshew, N. J., &
Hardan, A. Y. (2011). Multivariate searchlight classification of structural magnetic
resonance imaging in children and adolescents with autism. Biological Psychiatry, 70, 833-
841.
van Kooten, I. A., Palmen, S. J., von Cappeln, P., Steinbusch, H. W., Korr, H., Heinsen, H., Hof, P.
R., van Engeland, H., & Schmitz, C. (2008). Neurons in the fusiform gyrus are fewer and
smaller in autism. Brain, 131, 987-999.
Vapnik, V. (1998). Statistical Learning Theory. Computational Learning Theory, (Chapter
Chapter).
Wass, S. (2011). Distortions and disconnections: disrupted brain connectivity in autism. Brain and
Cognition, 75, 18-28.
Watts, D. J., & Strogatz, S. H. (1998). Collective dynamics of 'small-world' networks. Nature, 393,
440-442.
Weng, S. J., Wiggins, J. L Peltier S. J Carrasco, M Risi, S, Lord, C Monk, C.S. (2010). Alterations
of resting state functional connectivity in the default network in adolescents with autism
spectrum disorders. Brain Research, 1313, 202-214.
Wicker, B., Fonlupt, P., Hubert, B., Tardif, C., Gepner, B., & Deruelle, C. (2008). Abnormal
cerebral effective connectivity during explicit emotional processing in adults with autism
spectrum disorder. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 3, 135-143.
Wicker, B., Keysers, C., Plailly, J., Royet, J. P., Gallese, V., & Rizzolatti, G. (2003). Both of us
disgusted in My insula: the common neural basis of seeing and feeling disgust. Neuron, 40,
655-664.
Zikopoulos, B., & Barbas, H. (2010). Changes in prefrontal axons may disrupt the network in
autism. Journal of Neuroscience, 30, 14595-14609.
Supplementary Figure 1: 160 Regions of interest (ROIs) utilized in the analysis.
Supplementary Figure 2: Networks connectivity matrices. a) Averaged correlation matrices, for both groups in
Exteroceptive and Interoceptive conditions. b) within group across conditions T-values distributions. Positive t-values
(red) indicate higher connectivity in Interoceptive, negative t-values (blue) indicate higher connectivity in
Exteroceptive.
Supplementary Figure 3: Characteristic Path Length (a) and Clustering coefficient (b) for different thresholds (the cut -
off to determine whether two nodes (ROIs) of the network are connected). Shadowed areas indicate mean standard er -
ror. Red (blue) curves show the dependence for the networks of the group of ASD (Typical) subjects.
Source
Group effect
Type of Connection
Interaction
Source
Group effect
Type of Connection
Interaction
Source
Group effect
Type of Connection
Interaction
Exteroceptive
F
15.55
46.75
0.224
Resting
F
0.581
42.89
0.34
Interoceptive
F
9.722
37.73
0.48
p-value
<0.001
<0.0001
0.99
p-value
0.44
<0.0001
0.99
p-value
<0.01
<0.0001
0.96
Supplementary Table 1. Leave-one-out performance and p-value for all conditions and differences between condi -
tions.
Condition
Exteroceptive
Neutral
Interoceptive
Interoceptive – Exteroceptive
Interoceptive - Neutral
Exteroceptive - Neutral
Performance P-value
>0,1
0,5
0,625
>0,1
>0,1
0,625
0,916
<0,0001
>0,1
0,54
0,45
>0,1
Supplementary Table 2. a) Results for the ANOVA for connectivity values, for the three cognitive states.
ROI label
Mni
coordinates
z
Y
x
-1 Anterior Insula
21
38
9
20
34
dACC
26
49
27
aPFC
Basal Ganglia
34
17
-6
32
-59
41
IPS
mFC
45
15
0
Precuneus
25
-43
9
Temporal
5
-30
51
-48
6
1
vFC
Mid Insula
1
-14
-30
27
30
-2
ACC
Inf Temporal
-61
-41
-2
34
8
44
dFC
Sup temporal
21
-46
42
16
51
9
vmPFC
40
17
40
dFC
34 Angular Gyrus
-59
51
Anterior Insula
2
18
-36
52
-15
-13
Inf temporal
Basal ganglia
2
-24
11
vPFC
7
32
34
ACC
20
39
9
58
-41
20
Parietal
IPL
47
-52
44
Occipital
32
-75
-2
11
-68
42
Precuneus
Post Insula
9
-28
-30
temporal
11
-47
-59
precuneus
50
-40
8
32
-12
2
Mid Insula
Post Cingulate
17
-52
-5
33
-50
5
Precuneus
Post Cingulate
10
-55
17
dFC
36
7
-42
dlPFC
31
28
46
32
51
0
mPFC
-41
-47
29 Angular Gyrus
Fusiform
-15
-37
28
Temporal
8
-43
43
-46
10
14
vFC
aPFC
18
57
29
TJP
15
-63
-52
-12
-12
6
Thalamus
Occipital
41
-72
-9
dlPFC
29
36
40
-6
-56
29
Precuneus
Relative weighted
degree difference
network
1
0.94
0.76
0.74
0.70
0.66
0.64
0.56
0.52
0.50
0.47
0.47
0.46
0.46
0.45
0.40
0.39
0.36
0.36
0.36
0.35
0.27
0.27
0.27
0.26
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.24
0.24
0.23
0.22
0.21
0.21
0.21
0.21
0.20
0.20
0.20
0.19
0.19
0.18
0.17
0.171
0.16
0.16
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Fronto-parietal
Cingulo-opercular
Default
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Default
Fronto-parietal
Cingulo-opercular
Default
Fronto-parietal
Default
Cingulo-opercular
Default
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Default
Cingulo-opercular
Fronto-parietal
Default
Default
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Default
Default
Default
Fronto-parietal
Fronto-parietal
Default
Cingulo-opercular
Default
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Fronto-parietal
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Default
Fronto-parietal
Default
-59
-12
-25
-48
1
-5
-29
-3
-32
-11
-4
54
-44
46
-53
-41
37
39
54
-52
-8
23
6
-11
-1
-36
-48
11
8
-16
-35
45
14
-43
-6
-42
-20
42
-28
51
-55
-25
-3
51
-47
-26
-43
57
-38
-58
45
-31
-31
27
39
-50
-40
-2
42
-44
28
-41
33
64
-58
28
-69
-63
-12
42
29
-46
-72
6
47
50
-76
6
48
-42
23
-44
Inf Temporal
-15
Thalamus
13
aPFC
27
IPL
49
Post Cingulate
31
Post Cingulate
25
aPFC
10
Precuneus
45
IPS
46
vmPFC
17
Post Cingulate
-4
Fusiform
-18
dlPFC
33
vlPFC
-15
IPL
39
IPL
42
Mid Insula
-3
vlPFC
16
IPL
43
vPFC
17
Post Cingulate
3
Sup Frontal
47
vmPFC
3
Post Cingulate
17
ACC
40
IPS
40
35 Angular Gyrus
Thalamus
6
vmPFC
-5
54
Sup Frontal
Post Parietal
48
29
Occipital
Basal Ganglia
7
vent aPFC
2
vmPFC
-1
26
Occipital
Basal Ganglia
7
vent aPFC
-3
Occipital
-11
8
vFP
Parietal
30
0.15
0.13
0.13
0.13
0.12
0.12
0.12
0.12
0.11
0.10
0.10
0.09
0.09
0.09
0.08
0.08
0.07
0.07
0.07
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.04
0.04
0.04
0.02
0.02
0.02
0.02
0.02
0.02
0.02
0.01
0.00
0.00
0.00
Default
Cingulo-opercular
Default
Fronto-parietal
Default
Default
Fronto-parietal
Default
Fronto-parietal
Default
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Fronto-parietal
Default
Fronto-parietal
Fronto-parietal
Cingulo-opercular
Fronto-parietal
Fronto-parietal
Fronto-parietal
Default
Default
Default
Default
Fronto-parietal
Default
Default
Cingulo-opercular
Default
Default
Fronto-parietal
Default
Cingulo-opercular
Fronto-parietal
Default
Default
Cingulo-opercular
Fronto-parietal
Default
Cingulo-opercular
Cingulo-opercular
Supplementary Table 3. Contribution of all ROIs to the prediction of ASD condition, relative to maximum.
a) Cingulo-opercular network
Neutral
condition
Number
of voxels
Peak voxel
z-score
Uncorrect
ed p-
value
242
211
155
90
117
91
84
72
258
4,43
4,08
3,80
3,56
3,47
3.37
3,60
3,57
3,51
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
0,001
<0,001
0,001
0,002
0,007
<0,001
Interoceptive
condition
Number
of voxels
Peak voxel
z-score
Uncorrect
ed p-
value
355
248
262
151
127
4,32
4,06
3,86
4,01
3,39
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
0,002
Peak voxel
MNI
coordinates
P-value
(FWE
cluster
corrected
Positive slopes
<0,001
28, -4, 56
<0,001
<0,001
-36, -8, 48
-14, -16, 50
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
-10,-90,36
6,-22,-36
18,-84,0
Negative slopes
-40,-80,-42
<0,001
46,-68,46
<0,001
<0,001
-58,-60,-24
Peak voxel
MNI
coordinates
P-value
(FWE
cluster
corrected
Positive slopes
-64, -26, 2
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
60, -24, 34
-6,2,56
26, 2, 56
60, 10,12
Laterality
Label
R
L
L
L
R
R
L
R
L
Middle frontal
Precentral
Cingulate
Gyrus
Cuneus
Pons
Calcarine
Cerebellum
Angular
Inferior
Temporal
Laterali
ty
Label
L
R
L
R
R
Superior Temporal
Supramarginal
Cingulate Gyrus
Middle frontal
Opercular
b) Fronto-parietal network
Neutral
condition
Number
of voxels
Peak voxel
z-score
Uncorrect
ed p-
value
interoceptive
condition
Number
of voxels
Peak voxel
z-score
Uncorrect
ed p-
value
999
386
198
240
441
230
147
4,38
4,36
4,03
3,85
3,62
3.59
3.55
594
294
353
454
164
230
147
4,55
4,40
4,23
4,00
3,92
3.59
3.55
Peak voxel
MNI
coordinates
P-value
(FWE
cluster
corrected
Negative slopes
<0,001
-20, -66, -16
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
-34, -50, 66
40, -74, -18
20,-68,-18
26,-96,10
48,-56,-26
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
0,001
<0,001
4,2,-14
Peak voxel
MNI
coordinates
P-value
(FWE
cluster
corrected
Positive slopes
44, -54, 42
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
40, 14, 46
-48, -54, 52
12,-64,28
-6,-32,28
48,-56,-26
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
0,001
<0,001
0,001
<0,001
4,2,-14
Laterali
ty
Label
L
L
R
R
R
R
R
Occipital
Parietal Superior
Fusiform Gyrus
Cerebellum
Occipital Superior
Fusiform /
Temporal Inferior
Anterior Cingulate
/ subcallosal gyrus
Laterali
ty
Label
R
R
L
R
L
R
R
Parietal Inferior
Opercular cortex
Parietal Inferior
Precuneus
Mid Cingulum
Fusiform /
Temporal Inferior
Anterior Cingulate
/ subcallosal gyrus
c) Default network
Neutral
condition
Number
of voxels
Peak voxel
z-score
Uncorrect
ed p-
value
518
124
176
230
311
92
84
210
116
78
84
93
82
145
93
3,78
4,09
3,69
3,65
3,59
3,53
3,38
3,37
3,37
3,28
3,25
3,22
3,19
3,17
3,13
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
0,002
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
0,008
0,005
0,002
0,006
<0,001
0,002
Interoceptive
condition
Number
of voxels
Peak voxel
z-score
Uncorrect
ed p-
value
216
3,93
<0,001
Peak voxel
MNI
coordinates
P-value
(FWE
cluster
corrected
Negative slopes
-22, -60, -16
<0,001
24, -46, -48
<0,001
<0,001
12,-54,-14
-30, -56, -48
<0,001
<0,001
-22,-30,70
-10,4,16
<0,001
-34,-24,20
<0,001
<0,001
-44,-62,-6
-32,-84,-30
<0,001
-34,-52-68
<0,001
<0,001
-12,50,-24
34,-82,-14
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
30,-70,-36
-22,-40,-28
-8,28,-22
Peak voxel
MNI
coordinates
P-value
(FWE
cluster
corrected
Positive slopes
<0,001
2, -18, 2
Laterali
ty
Label
L
R
R
L
L
L
L
L
L
L
L
R
R
L
L
Cerebelum
Cerebellum
Cerebellum
Cerebellum
Parietal Sup / Inf
Caudate
Insula
Temporal Inferior
Cerebellum
Parietal Sup / Inf
Orbital cortex
Occipital /
Fusiform
Cerebellum
Cerebellum
Orbital cortex
Laterali
ty
Label
R
Thalamus
Supplementary Table 4. Correlation between CO (a), FP (b), and DEF (c) and individual voxels, associ -
ated with ADOS score entered into multiple regression model (Whole brain corrected clusters ( P < 0.001,
extent threshold of 5).
3
|
1701.04782 | 1 | 1701 | 2017-01-17T17:44:16 | Organization and hierarchy of the human functional brain network lead to a chain-like core | [
"q-bio.NC",
"physics.bio-ph",
"physics.soc-ph",
"stat.AP"
] | The brain is a paradigmatic example of a complex system as its functionality emerges as a global property of local mesoscopic and microscopic interactions. Complex network theory allows to elicit the functional architecture of the brain in terms of links (correlations) between nodes (grey matter regions) and to extract information out of the noise. Here we present the analysis of functional magnetic resonance imaging data from forty healthy humans during the resting condition for the investigation of the basal scaffold of the functional brain network organization. We show how brain regions tend to coordinate by forming a highly hierarchical chain-like structure of homogeneously clustered anatomical areas. A maximum spanning tree approach revealed the centrality of the occipital cortex and the peculiar aggregation of cerebellar regions to form a closed core. We also report the hierarchy of network segregation and the level of clusters integration as a function of the connectivity strength between brain regions. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
1
Organization and hierarchy of the human functional brain network
lead to a chain-like core
Rossana Mastrandrea∗1, Andrea Gabrielli1,2, Fabrizio Piras3,4, Gianfranco Spalletta4,5, Guido Caldarelli1,2
Tommaso Gili3,4
1 IMT School for Advanced Studies, Lucca, piazza S. Ponziano 6, 55100 Lucca, Italy
2 Istituto dei Sistemi Complessi (ISC) - CNR, UoS Sapienza, Dipartimento di Fisica,
Universit´a "Sapienza"; P.le Aldo Moro 5, 00185 - Rome, Italy
3 Enrico Fermi Center, Piazza del Viminale 1, 00184 Rome, Italy
4 IRCCS Fondazione Santa Lucia, Via Ardeatina 305, 00179 Rome, Italy
5 Menninger Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Baylor College of Medicine,
Houston, Tx, USA
∗ E-mail: [email protected]
Abstract
The brain is a paradigmatic example of a complex system as its functionality emerges as a global property
of local mesoscopic and microscopic interactions. Complex network theory allows to elicit the functional
architecture of the brain in terms of links (correlations) between nodes (grey matter regions) and to extract
information out of the noise. Here we present the analysis of functional magnetic resonance imaging data
from forty healthy humans during the resting condition for the investigation of the basal scaffold of the
functional brain network organization. We show how brain regions tend to coordinate by forming a highly
hierarchical chain-like structure of homogeneously clustered anatomical areas. A maximum spanning tree
approach revealed the centrality of the occipital cortex and the peculiar aggregation of cerebellar regions to
form a closed core. We also report the hierarchy of network segregation and the level of clusters integration
as a function of the connectivity strength between brain regions.
Introduction
The intrinsic functional architecture of the brain and its changes due to cognitive engagement, ageing and
diseases are nodal topics in neuroscience, attracting considerable attention from many disciplines of scientific
investigation. Complex network theory (Caldarelli, 2007; Barab´asi, 2009; Newman, 2010) provides tools rep-
resenting the state-of-the-art of multivariate analysis of local cortical and subcortical mesoscopic interactions.
The new amount of data available from a variety of different sources showed clearly that the complex network
description of both the structural and the functional organization of the brain demonstrates a repertoire of un-
expected properties of brain connectomics (Bullmore and Sporns, 2009). Accordingly network theory allows
a description of brain architecture in terms of patterns of communication between brain regions, treated as
evolving networks and associate this evolution to behavioral outcomes (Bassett et al., 2011). Brain networks
are characterized by a balance of dense relationships among areas highly engaged in processing roles, as well
as sparser relationships between regions belonging to systems with different processing roles. This segregation
facilitates communication among brain areas that may be distributed anatomically but are needed for sets
of processing operations (Sporns, 2013). Along with that the integrated functional organization of the brain
involves each network component executing a discrete cognitive function mostly autonomously or with the
support of other components where the computational load in one is not heavily influenced by processing
in the others (Bertolero et al., 2015). In this quest for a constantly improving quantitative description of
the brain and of the cardinal features of its functioning complex networks plays a crucial role (Rubinov and
Sporns, 2010; Deco et al., 2011; Van Den Heuvel and Sporns, 2011; Sporns, 2012). Specifically, it proved to be
able to elicit both the scaffold of the mutual interactions among different areas in healthy brains (Bullmore
and Sporns, 2009; Bassett and Bullmore, 2016) and the local failure of the global functioning in diseased
brains (Bassett and Bullmore, 2009; Rosazza and Minati, 2011; Aerts et al., 2016). Network representation
describes the brain as a graph with a set of nodes - a variable number of brain areas (from 102 to 104) -
connected with links representing functional, structural or effective interactions. The use of complex network
theory passed progressively from an initial assessment of basic topological properties (Salvador et al., 2005;
van den Heuvel et al., 2008; Telesford et al., 2010) to a more sophisticated description of global features of the
2
brain, as small-worldness (Achard et al., 2006), rich-club organization (Van Den Heuvel and Sporns, 2011)
and topology (Petri et al., 2014; Bardella et al., 2016). However, a clear understanding of the functional
advantage of a network organization in the brain, the characterization of its substrate and a description of
the network structure as a function of the level of brain regions interaction are still missing. In this paper, we
investigate resting state functional networks, where links represent the strength of correlation between time
series of spontaneous neural activity as measured by blood oxygen-level-dependent (BOLD) functional MRI
(fMRI) (Eguiluz et al., 2005). Specifically we interpret a functional connection between two nodes as the
magnitude of the synchrony of their low-frequency oscillations, which is associated with the modulation of
activity in one node by another one (Wang et al., 2012; Honey et al., 2012) largely constrained by anatomical
connectivity (Hagmann et al., 2008; Honey et al., 2009). A percolation analysis of the functional network
(Gallos et al., 2012; Bardella et al., 2016) is used to highlight the progressive engagement of brain regions in
the whole network as a function of the connectivity strength. Subsequently, by means of the maximum span-
ning forest (MSF) and the maximum spanning tree (MST) representations (Caldarelli, 2007; Caldarelli et al.,
2012) we obtain the basal scaffold of the brain network, that shows to be characterized by a linear backbone
in which few nodes (cerebellar and occipital regions) play a central role, even progressively increasing the
spatial resolution or reducing nodes size.
Results
Percolation Analysis
The representative human functional brain network is often analyzed introducing specific thresholds to map
the fully-connected correlation matrix in a sparse binary matrix (Bullmore and Sporns, 2009). Here, to avoid
any arbitrary assumption we perform a percolation analysis (Gallos et al., 2012; Bardella et al., 2016) on
the whole network. We rank correlations in increasing order, one at a time we remove from the network
the link corresponding to the observed value and explore the global organization of the remaining network.
Specifically, in fig.1 (a) we show the number of connected components updated each time a new link is
removed. The emergence and the number of plateaux shed light on the hierarchical structure of the network,
their length unveils the intrinsic stability of certain network configurations after the removal of links. For
the human functional brain network a remarkable hierarchy in the disaggregation process emerges from the
comparison with a proper null model. The same percolation analysis is performed on the ensemble of 100
randomizations (Methods) of the observed correlation matrix showing a faster disaggregation in disconnected
components with plateaux absent or of small length.
We compute the distribution of plateaux length looking at the increment of correlation values when the
network passes from n to n + 1 components and show it in fig.1 (b). In the same figure we also report the
average plateaux length computed on the ensemble of randomizations. A great variability characterizes the
percolation curve of the real network with significant deviations of the plateaux length from the random case.
3
(a)
(b)
Fig. 1: Percolation analysis. (a) Distribution of the number of network components versus the threshold
applied to the correlation matrix. (b) Distribution of plateaux length observed in figure 1(a) and computed
as the increment of correlation value between two newborn components. All figures show the percolation
curves for the real case (blue) and the ensemble of its randomizations (green). Moreover figure (b) reports
upper confidence intervals: mean plus respectively, one (red), two (orange), three (light blue) and four (bleak)
standard deviations.
Chain-like modules
The percolation analysis highlights the existence of a not trivial functional organization of the human brain
network. Here, we investigate it considering a filtered network where for each area all weighted links but
the strongest are discarded. This approach gives rise to 36 disconnected components forming a Maximum
Spanning Forest (Methods) with a new information on link directionality. It simply indicates that each source
points toward its maximally correlated brain area and it is not necessarily reciprocated. Figure 2 shows the
abundance of modules with size 2 and reciprocated links: those are meanly mirror-areas of the right and
left brain hemispheres or adjacent/very close ROIs belonging to the same hemisphere. Nodes are coulored
according to the anatomical regions reported in figure 2 (a) (detailed names of ROIs in table 1 in SI). A
noteworthy result concerns groups of size greater than 3 exhibiting a chain-like structure, sometimes very
long as for the Cerebellum. This implies that most of the nodes in the MSF have in-degree1 equal to one,
few equal to 2 and very few greater than 2. Furthermore, nodes tend to connect with nodes belonging to the
same anatomical region. The only exception is represented by the Temporal Lobe: ROIs in this region are
linked with all the other anatomical areas except for the Cerebellum and the Deep Grey Matter ones.
1Out-degree is equal to 1 for construction.
00.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9020406080100120Correlation valueNumber of components Real brain networkEnsemble of randomizations 210182634425058667482909810611610−410−310−210−1Number of componentsPleateau length Real brain networkEnsemble of randomizations (µ) µ+σµ+2σµ + 3σµ + 4σ 4
We build the MSF of the 100 randomizations of the real network obtaining a number of components varying
in the range [12, 24]. All randomized correlation matrices exhibit a star-like organization of components in
the MSF, while the number of modules of size 2 is dramatically reduced. Moreover, colors of linked nodes
are completely random.
In figure S1 we show the MSF performed on one of such randomizations. We
compute the distribution of node in-degree of the observed MSF and of the ensemble of its randomizations
(fig. 2(c)). In the real case the in-degree is small with almost the 70% of values equal to 1. The ensemble
of randomizations shows more variability and a left-skewed distribution of in-degree, with almost the 50%
of values equal to 0, the 30% equal to 1 and a maximum of 15. The outcome confirms that the MSF of
all the randomized correlation matrices shows similar features: star-like organization of modules with few
in-degree hubs representing the strongest connected partner for several brain areas. This result highlights
the fundamental hierarchical organization of brain functional areas.
Fig. 2: Maximum Spanning Forest of the real human functional brain network. (a) Anatomical
grouping of AAL parcellation of the human brain. • Frontal Lobe; • Insula; • Cingulate; • Temporal
Lobe; • Occipital Lobe; • Parietal Lobe; • Deep Grey Matter; • Cerebellum. (b) Maximum spanning
forest components. Arrows indicate that the ROI-source is maximally correlated with the ROI-target. (c)
Node in-degree distribution of the MSF. Comparison between the real brain network and the ensemble of its
randomizations (100).
5
From forest to tree
As next step, we link together all groups of nodes in fig.2(b) such that (i) we add only one link between
two modules previously disconnected and with the greatest weight; (ii) we end up with a unique connected
component (Methods). The resulting network is a Maximum Spanning Tree as all nodes are connected
through a maximal weighted path without forming loops.
The MST in fig.3(a) preserves the chain-like organization of nodes and mainly reproduces the anatomical
division in regions. Some star-like aggregations emerge revealing the centrality of certain nodes as ROI 99,
belonging to the Cerebellum and 82, part of the Temporal Lobe. Remarkable is the separation of the Deep
Grey Matter, which represents the ancient part of the human brain, connecting to the periphery of the
tree with the Temporal Lobe, the Insula and Cingulate areas. Nor chain-like organization neither relevant
agglomeration of nodes are observable in the tree obtained from the MSF of the randomized correlation
matrices (one examples in fig. S2). Also in this case the distribution of node degree characterizes the two
kinds of network organization: star-like (null model) and chain-like (real brain network). The comparison
between the real network and the ensemble of its randomization (fig. 3(b)) confirms the star-like organization
of the random MST, with half of nodes having degree equal to 1 and maximum degree equal to 17.
Hierarchical integration of brain areas
The maximum spanning tree approach doesn't provide any evidence about the internal connectivity of com-
ponents observed in the MSF, as loops are not allowed. Here we showed a number of snapshots of the network
associated with specific percolation phases. By selecting appropriate thresholds and discarding correlation
values below them, we inspected the network formation process according to the strength of edges. The
rationale behind this approach comes from the possibility to explore the level of segregation of brain areas
and how they functionally and hierarchically integrate. Thresholds are chosen looking at figure 1 (b) and
considering only correlation values associated to significant deviations of plateaux length of the real network
from the random case.
Panels from (a) to (n) in fig.4 show the human functional brain network related to the aforementioned
thresholds. As the threshold value decreases (from (a) to (n)), the number of links increases showing how
groups of nodes appear and their between and within connections intensify. The sequence of snapshots reveal
the hierarchical functional organization of the brain network. Nodes do not connect forming several large
and disconnected components, but: (i) nodes belonging to the Occipital Lobe start to connect each other
and the anatomical region is almost completely connected after few steps; (ii) some nodes belonging to the
same region form small chains; (iii) several nodes directly connect to the Occipital Lobe. Therefore, the most
central area is represented by the Occipital Lobe, while ROIs belonging to the Deep Grey Matter lie in the
periphery connecting to the network at the last moment in the percolation phases. The Cerebellum forms a
quite long chain before joining the Occipital Lobe through the ROI 99 already emerged in the MST for its
centrality.
6
Fig. 3: Maximum Spanning Tree of the real human functional brain network. (a) Colors represent
anatomical regions according to the grouping of AAL parcellation in fig.2(a) :• Frontal Lobe; • Insula; •
Cingulate; • Temporal Lobe; • Occipital Lobe; • Parietal Lobe; • Deep Grey Matter; • Cerebellum. (b)
Node degree distribution in the MST. Comparison between the real brain network and the ensemble of its
randomizations (100).
1(cid:20)(cid:21)(cid:22)(cid:23)(cid:24)(cid:25)(cid:26)(cid:27)(cid:28)(cid:20)(cid:19)(cid:20)(cid:20)(cid:20)(cid:21)(cid:20)(cid:22)(cid:20)(cid:23)(cid:20)(cid:24)(cid:20)(cid:25)(cid:20)(cid:26)(cid:20)(cid:27)(cid:20)(cid:28)(cid:21)(cid:19)(cid:21)(cid:20)(cid:21)(cid:21)(cid:21)(cid:22)(cid:21)(cid:23)(cid:21)(cid:24)(cid:21)(cid:25)(cid:21)(cid:26)(cid:21)(cid:27)(cid:21)(cid:28)(cid:22)(cid:19)(cid:22)(cid:20)(cid:22)(cid:21)(cid:22)(cid:22)(cid:22)(cid:23)(cid:22)(cid:24)(cid:22)(cid:25)(cid:22)(cid:26)(cid:22)(cid:27)(cid:22)(cid:28)(cid:23)(cid:19)(cid:23)(cid:20)(cid:23)(cid:21)(cid:23)(cid:22)(cid:23)(cid:23)(cid:23)(cid:24)(cid:23)(cid:25)(cid:23)(cid:26)(cid:23)(cid:27)(cid:23)(cid:28)(cid:24)(cid:19)(cid:24)(cid:20)(cid:24)(cid:21)(cid:24)(cid:22)(cid:24)(cid:23)(cid:24)(cid:24)(cid:24)(cid:25)(cid:24)(cid:26)(cid:24)(cid:27)(cid:24)(cid:28)(cid:25)(cid:19)(cid:25)(cid:20)(cid:25)(cid:21)(cid:25)(cid:22)(cid:25)(cid:23)(cid:25)(cid:24)(cid:25)(cid:25)(cid:25)(cid:26)(cid:25)(cid:27)(cid:25)(cid:28)(cid:26)(cid:19)(cid:26)(cid:20)(cid:26)(cid:21)(cid:26)(cid:22)(cid:26)(cid:23)(cid:26)(cid:24)(cid:26)(cid:25)(cid:26)(cid:26)(cid:26)(cid:27)(cid:26)(cid:28)(cid:27)(cid:19)(cid:27)(cid:20)(cid:27)(cid:21)(cid:27)(cid:22)(cid:27)(cid:23)(cid:27)(cid:24)(cid:27)(cid:25)(cid:27)(cid:26)(cid:27)(cid:27)(cid:27)(cid:28)(cid:28)(cid:19)(cid:28)(cid:20)(cid:28)(cid:21)(cid:28)(cid:22)(cid:28)(cid:23)(cid:28)(cid:24)(cid:28)(cid:25)(cid:28)(cid:26)(cid:28)(cid:27)(cid:28)(cid:28)(cid:20)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:20)(cid:19)(cid:20)(cid:20)(cid:19)(cid:21)(cid:20)(cid:19)(cid:22)(cid:20)(cid:19)(cid:23)(cid:20)(cid:19)(cid:24)(cid:20)(cid:19)(cid:25)(cid:20)(cid:19)(cid:26)(cid:20)(cid:19)(cid:27)(cid:20)(cid:19)(cid:28)(cid:20)(cid:20)(cid:19)(cid:20)(cid:20)(cid:20)(cid:20)(cid:20)(cid:21)(cid:20)(cid:20)(cid:22)(cid:20)(cid:20)(cid:23)(cid:20)(cid:20)(cid:24)(cid:20)(cid:20)(cid:25)(a)Node degree00.110.220.33Frequency0.4450.560.678910111213Real NetworkEnsemble of Randomizations(b) 7
(a) Threshold = 0.77
(b) Threshold = 0.72
(c) Threshold = 0.68
Fig. 4: Snapshots of the human functional brain network. Each snapshot is realized thresholding
the correlation matrix. Thresholds are chosen looking at the most significant deviation of plateaux length
of the real percolation curve from its ensemble of randomization (fig.1(b). ) Colors represent anatomical
regions according to the grouping of AAL parcellation in fig.2(a): • Frontal Lobe; • Insula; • Cingulate; •
Temporal Lobe; • Occipital Lobe; • Parietal Lobe; • Deep Grey Matter; • Cerebellum.
1237192033344344454647485758676812347812141920232425262728313233344344454647484950525758676869701234781214192023242526272831323334434445464748495052575867686970 8
(a) Threshold = 0.58
(b) Threshold = 0.54
(c) Threshold = 0.52
Fig. 5: Snapshots of the human functional brain network. Each snapshot is realized thresholding
the correlation matrix. Thresholds are chosen looking at the most significant deviations of plateaux length
of the real percolation curve from its ensemble of randomizations (fig.1(b).) Colors represent anatomical
regions according to the grouping of AAL parcellation in fig.2(a): • Frontal Lobe; • Insula; • Cingulate; •
Temporal Lobe; • Occipital Lobe; • Parietal Lobe; • Deep Grey Matter; • Cerebellum.
123467811121314192023242526272831323334353643444546474849505152535657585960626467686970869091929394991001011021031234567811121314171920232425262728293132333435364344454647484950515253555657585960616264676869707778818286909192939499100101102103104112123456789101112131416171920232425262728293132333435364344454647484950515253555657585960616264676869707778818286909192939499100101102103104112 9
(a) Threshold = 0.50
(b) Threshold = 0.47
(c) Threshold = 0.39
Fig. 6: Snapshots of the human functional brain network. Each snapshot is realized thresholding
the correlation matrix. Thresholds are chosen looking at the most significant deviation of plateaux length
of the real percolation curve from its ensemble of randomization (fig.1(b). ) Colors represent anatomical
regions according to the grouping of AAL parcellation in fig.2(a): • Frontal Lobe; • Insula; • Cingulate; •
Temporal Lobe; • Occipital Lobe; • Parietal Lobe; • Deep Grey Matter; • Cerebellum.
1234567891011121314161719202324252627282931323334353643444546474849505152535455565758596061626364676869707778818286909192939499100101102103104112123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646667686970777881828689909192939499100101102103104112123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475777879808182838485868990919293949596979899100101102103104111112113 10
Inter-subject variability
We explore the inter-subject variability with several approaches. We compute the standard deviation of
pairwise correlation values across the 40 individuals and report it together with the average correlation
matrix used for the analysis. Figure 7 (a) shows that there are few negative correlation values, however
small in absolute term. The standard deviation ranges in the interval [0.039, 0.55], with most of the highest
values concerning correlation averages close to zero (Fig. 7 (b)). Those are few links which show positive and
negative values across the 40 individuals and average around zero. They mainly belong to the Cerebellum
(see SI) and the inter-subjects variability in this case could be due to the specific anatomical location with
consequences on the resulting fMRI. However, they do not affect our results as in our analysis only the
greatest correlation values play a key-role (percolation, MSF, MST), while the smallest threshold considered
in the hierarchical integration of brain areas is 0.33. In figure 7 (c) we also report the coefficient of variation
for the correlation matrix thresholded using the False Discovery Rate (FDR). Most of the values concentrate
around zero, while the greatest ones correspond to correlation values close to zero.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 7: Inter-subjects variability. (a) Mean, (b) standard deviation and (c) coefficient of variation of
pairwise correlation values across the 40 subjects involved in the study.
As next step, we compute the pairwise cosine similarity between the correlation matrices of subjects.
We find high similarity between subjects (fig.S15 (a)), with few exceptions (mainly, subjects 35 and 38).
However, their presence does not affect the average correlation matrix as explicitly shown by applying the
Jackknife resampling technique. One at a time, we remove the correlation matrix corresponding to a subject
from the sample and average the remaining 39 correlation matrices. Then, we compute the cosine similarity
between the 40 resulting correlation matrices (fig.S15 (b)). The similarity values belong to [0.9996, 0.9999],
revealing that the emerged diversity for some subjects is negligible when we compute the average correlation
matrix.
Discussion
In this paper we have reported the results of a network theory-based investigation of a large human fMRI
dataset, aimed at assessing the basal architecture of the resting state functional connectivity network.
We have computed the Maximal Spanning Forest (MSF) and the Maximal Spanning Tree (MST) for our
population-wise brain. The former showed a peculiar composition of the basic modules composing the net-
work, by revealing their structure as linear chains. The MSF reveals both intra- and inter-hemispherical
modules, and the presence of small modules alongside with larger sub-networks. The MST, on the other
hand, enables the classification of connectors and provincial areas. We also used a modified percolation anal-
ysis that retains the information on all the connected components of a given network. Such variation of the
percolation analysis does not require the application of a threshold to obtain binary connectivity networks.
By means of this technique, applicable to experimental correlation matrices, we showed hierarchically the
progressive integration of brain regions in the whole organization of the connectivity network, which does
not appear in a null model defined by constraining the spectrum of the observed correlation matrix. The
percolation analysis here used represents a generalization of the classical one (Gallos et al., 2012) and is
20406080100ROI20406080100ROI-1-0.500.5120406080100ROI20406080100ROI00.20.40.60.8120406080100ROI20406080100ROI-10-50510 11
characterised by some improvements (Bardella et al., 2016) among which it must be recognized the ability
to detect newly disconnected modules from secondary components. As a complex system, the human brain
is intrinsically organized into modules, creating a high degree of flexibility and adaptability of the system
without fundamentally altering underlying structure (Bassett and Gazzaniga, 2011). Remarkably, our perco-
lation analysis unearthed the existence of a hierarchical organization of areas, clusters of areas and modules
within the human functional brain network. The process of network aggregation from isolated components
appeared slow - compared to the null-model - with the emergence of significant stable configurations identified
by several plateaux in the percolation curve. This outcomeda suggests a progressive engagement of brain
regions according to the local amount of connectivity, namely a network organization in hierarchical modules
whose participation to the entire structure is progressively included as the links strength decreases. The
sequence of stable network configurations that, from the single areas, leads to the fully connected network,
can be achieved by choosing values associated with specific plateaux of the percolation curve. Although
this is technically topological modularity it is remarkable that it reflects functional and anatomical features.
For instance bilateral correspondence of regions belonging to the same module was obtained without the
introduction of symmetry constraints imposed in the analyses, supporting the conclusion that a hallmark
of large-scale resting-state networks is their inter-hemispheric symmetry (Smith et al., 2009). Interestingly,
descending the hierarchical staircase of the percolation we found that occipital regions as the cuneus, the
lingual gyrus, the occipital superior and middle gyrus and the calcarine sulcus tended to form a densely
interconnected module. Along with that, frontal, cerebellar and temporal regions resulted involved in dif-
ferent modules characterised by linear chains, which joined the occipital cluster, in a progressive integration
process, through a nodal bridge represented by the precuneus. In particular, temporal and occipital lobes
resulted connected thanks to the bridging action of the fusiform and the inferior occipital gyrus as expected
by considering the local cytoarchitecture (Caspers et al., 2013). Thalamus, putamen, pallidus, hippocampus,
amygdala and caudate (here refereed to as deep grey matter) was found to form binary bilateral modules that
joined the whole structure at the end of the integration process. If on one hand the remarkable connectivity
within the occipital lobe can be ascribed to an efficient coupling via the interplay of tangential intracortical
and callosal connections (Gen¸c et al., 2015), on the other hand such connectedness could be ascribed to fixa-
tional eye movements (Martinez-Conde et al., 2004). In support to this observation, it must be noticed that
in Parkinsons disease patients, which present with eye movement disturbances that accompany the cardinal
motor symptoms, the worse the oculomotor performance is, the more the regional functional connectivity is
decreased (Gorges et al., 2016). A second striking result has been obtained from MSF and MST analysis of
the whole brain network. For the first time we report a non-trivial and ordered structure for the basal scaffold
of the functional network of the brain. Keeping track only of the strongest connection for each region, the
network appeared organised in components exhibiting a linear chain-like structure. When the same procedure
has been applied to a proper randomisation of the real human brain functional network, the outcome strongly
differed: hubs and star-like structure emerged. This result was tested for robustness by improving the num-
ber of regions included in the grey matter parcellation. We calculated correlation matrices from two further
templates composed of 276 and 531 regions of interest, respectively, each obtained as a sub-parcellation of
the AAL template. The chain-like organization has been proved to persist as the topological outcome of
the MSF and the MST analyses of the human brain functional network, against the randomised counterpart
that showed a star-like organization (figures S3-S14 in the Supplementary Information). Firstly, modules
composition within the MSF deserves a comment. We found linear clusters of regions grouped according
neuroanatomical criteria, except the temporal and insular regions. While it is expected to find close portions
of the cortex strongly coupled, it is not obvious that the same amount of coupling encompasses regional bilat-
erality embedded in the modularity of the whole brain network. The exception represented by the temporal
and insular regions can be ascribed to different reasons. The insular lobes showed to be more connected with
frontal regions, through the Rolandic opercula, than with each other (each one respecting its own laterality).
Concurrently, the fronto-insular cortex, wherein generation and experience of emotion are found (Gu et al.,
2013), is implicated in the elaborate circuitry associated with awareness (Craig, 2009) and uniquely (together
with the anterior cingulate cortex and the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex) characterized by the presence of
Von Economo neurons (Fajardo et al., 2008; Allman et al., 2011). On the other hand the fragmentation of
the temporal lobe can follow the mosaic structure of its functional specialization. In fact it includes auditory
sensory and association cortices, part of the posterior language cortex, visual and higher order association
cortices, primary and association olfactory cortices and enthorinal cortex (Frackowiak et al., 2004). The
grouping of other heterogeneous clusters is due both to spatial closeness (precentral and postcentral gyrus)
12
and to homofunctional specialization (hippocampus and parahippocampal gyrus). The MST representation
of the functional brain network scaffold was found characterized by a long linear structure, whose skeleton
follows the anatomical spatial distribution of lobes (from the frontal to the occipital lobe, passing through the
temporal and parietal lobes), small chains linked alongside and a star-like structure (composed of cerebellar
regions) at the end of one side. The main connectors along the main chain included: the cuneus/precuneus ,
the superior temporal gyrus, the superior occipital gyrus, the inferior parietal lobule, the medial orbitofrontal
cortex/gyrus rectus and the VI lobule of the cerebellum. Notably, precuneus, inferior parietal cortex and
medial orbitofrontal cortex constitute the Default Mode Network (Greicius et al., 2003; Raichle and Snyder,
2007), which is a crucial module of the whole brain network both for its functioning and as the first target
of metabolic alterations both in neurological and psychiatric diseases (Buckner et al., 2008; Broyd et al.,
2009). The large connectivity with the Default Mode Network showed by the superior temporal gyrus, which
confers to this region a central role in the MST, has been observed in fMRI data (Zhang and Chiang-shan,
2012) but never found in FDG-PET data. Since one of the differences between the two techniques is the
level of noise produced during the recordings (relatively silent during FDG-PET vs intensively noisy during
MRI), the absence of overlap of the patterns of connectivity reported in that region might be explained by
the auditory engagement included in the MRI experiments (Passow et al., 2015). The same argument works
as far as the central role of the superior occipital cortex, being the visual activity engaged by the fixation
during the resting-state fMRI experiment. A final comment must be reserved to the cerebellar module. The
understanding of human cerebellar function has undergone a paradigm shift. No longer considered purely
devoted to motor control, a wide role for the cerebellum in cognitive and affective functions is supported by
anatomical, clinical and functional neuroimaging data (Picerni et al., 2013; Laricchiuta et al., 2014). Re-
cent evidence from functional connectivity studies in humans indicates that the cerebellum participates in
functional networks with sensorimotor areas engaged in motor control and with association cortices that are
involved in cognitive processes (Habas et al., 2009; Krienen and Buckner, 2009; O'Reilly et al., 2010). The
evidence of the cerebellar engagement in higher cognitive functions as well as in sensorimotor processes might
explain its central role in the basal scaffold of the whole functional brain network. Specifically, it has been
reported that the lobule VI of the cerebellum, here found as a main connector of the network, has been found
to be involved in different cognitive tasks, from mental rotation to working memory processing (Stoodley
et al., 2012). In addition, it has been showed that during the first stages of consciousness loss, induced by
mild sedation, the pattern of thalamic functional disconnections included regions belonging to the cerebellum
(Gili et al., 2013), supporting the evidence of a strong cerebello-thalamic interaction showed by the MST
analysis. Lastly it must be noticed that both in MSF and MST analysis, as weights of our graphs, the square
of the correlation coefficient (r2) was used. Positive and negative correlations, characterized by the same
absolute value, refer to the same amount of information in terms of connectivity strength. Since in this
study we considered undirected weighted graphs, the phase-shift between time series, which gives rise to the
sign of the correlation coefficient, was not significantly informative. Indeed, Goelman et al. (2014) showed
that both positive and negative correlations are related to synchronized neural activity and that the sign of
correlations can result from neural-mediated hemodynamic mechanisms, which lead to temporal and spatial
heterogeneity. Moreover, r2 was chosen since it has a strict relationship with the coefficient of determination
R2. Specifically, after a simple linear regression, R2 equals the square of the correlation coefficient between
the observed and modelled data values (Draper and Smith, 1998). In terms of a correlation analysis, r2 esti-
mates how well a time series can predict another one and can be considered as a measure of the magnitude of
the relationship between time series. In conclusion we have reported that the whole architecture of the brain
activity at rest is characterised by chain-like structures organized in a hierarchical modular arrangement.
This kind of organization is thought to be stable under large-scale reconnection of substructure (Robinson
et al., 2009), and efficient in terms of wiring costs (Bullmore and Sporns, 2012). In addition the chain-like
feature of the basal modules facilitate the wiring and reconnection processes, not asking for a specific region
as a hub, but functioning the whole module as a multiple access point for the functional plasticity.
13
Methods
Forty healthy subjects (mean age=38, SD=10; mean educational attainment=15, SD=3; male N=19) par-
ticipated in this study. All subjects were carefully screened for a current or past diagnosis of any DSM-5
Axis I or II disorder using the SCID-5 Research Version edition (SCID-5-RV: First et al., 2015) and the
SCID-5 Personality Disorders (SCID-5-PD:First et al., 2016). Exclusion criteria included: (1) a history of
psychoactive substance dependence or abuse during the last one year period evaluated by the structured
interview SCID-5-RV, (2) a history of neurologic illness or brain injury, (3) major medical illnesses, that is,
diabetes not stabilized, obstructive pulmonary disease or asthma, hematological/oncological disorders, B12
or folate deficiency as evidenced by blood concentrations below the lower normal limit, pernicious anemia,
clinically significant and unstable active gastrointestinal, renal, hepatic, endocrine or cardiovascular system
disease, newly treated hypothyroidism, (4) the presence of any brain abnormality and microvascular lesion
apparent on conventional FLAIR-scans. The presence, severity and location of vascular lesions was com-
puted using a semi-automated method(Iorio et al., 2013), (5) IQ below the normal range according to TIB
(Test Intelligenza Breve, Italian analog of the National Adult Reading Test NART ) (6) global cognitive
deterioration according to a Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) (Folstein et al., 1975) score lower than
26, (7) dementia diagnosis according with DSM-5 criteria (American-Psychiatric-Association, 2013) and (8)
non-Italian language native speaker. All participants were right-handed, with normal or corrected-to-normal
vision. They gave written informed consent to participate after the procedures had been fully explained. The
study was approved and carried out in accordance with the guidelines of the IRCCS Santa Lucia Foundation
Ethics Committee.
Data acquisition and preprocessing
FMRI data were collected using gradient-echo echo-planar imaging at 3T (Philips Achieva) using a (T2*)-
weighted imaging sequence sensitive to blood oxygen level-dependent (BOLD) (TR = 3 s, TE = 30 ms, matrix
= 80 x 80, FOV=224x224, slice thickness = 3 mm, flip angle = 90, 50 slices, 240 vol). A thirty-two channel
receive-only head coil was used. A high-resolution T1-weighted whole-brain structural scan was also acquired
(1x1x1 mm voxels). Subjects were instructed to lay in the scanner at rest with eyes open. For the purposes
of accounting for physiological variance in the time-series data, cardiac and respiratory cycles were recorded
using the scanners built-in photoplethysmograph and a pneumatic chest belt, respectively. The human brain
was segmented into 116 macro-regions from the AAL template (Tzourio-Mazoyer et al., 2002). Resting state
fMRI signals were averaged across each region to generate 116 time-series, which in turn were pairwise cor-
related calculating the Pearson's coefficient and organized in a symmetric matrix. Two further templates
were used to test the robustness of results at increasing spatial resolution by subdividing AAL regions as
described in Fornito et al. (2010). The number of regions included in the two templates was 276 and 531
respectively. Several sources of physiological variance were removed from each individual subjects time-series
fMRI data. For each subject, physiological noise correction consisted of removal of time-locked cardiac and
respiratory artifacts (two cardiac harmonics and two respiratory harmonics plus four interaction terms) using
linear regression (Glover et al., 2000) and of low-frequency respiratory and heart rate effects (Birn et al., 2006;
Shmueli et al., 2007; Chang and Glover, 2009). FMRI data were then preprocessed as follows: correction
for head motion and slice-timing and removal of non-brain voxels (performed using FSL: FMRIBs Software
Library, www.fmrib.ox.ac.uk/fsl). Head motion estimation parameters were used to derive the frame-wise
displacement (FD): time points with high FD (FD > 0.2 mm) were replaced through a least-squares spectral
decomposition as described in Power et al. (2014). Data were then demeaned, detrended and band-pass
filtered in the frequency range 0.01-0.1 Hz, using custom software written in Matlab (The Math Works). For
group analysis, a two-step registration process was performed. fMRI data were transformed first from func-
tional space to individual subjects structural space using FLIRT (FMRIBs Linear Registration Tool) and then
non-linearly to a standard space (Montreal Neurological Institute MNI152 standard map) using Advanced
Normalization Tools (ANTs; Penn Image Computing & Science Lab, http://www.picsl.upenn.edu/ANTS/).
Finally data were spatially smoothed (5x5x5 mm full-width half-maximum Gaussian kernel). In order to
create an average adjacency matrix at the population level, subject-wise matrices were Fisher-transformed,
averaged across subjects and back-transformed.
14
Percolation Analysis and Thresholding
We used a variation of the percolation analysis proposed by Gallos et al. (2012), recently developed by Bardella
et al. (2016). We ranked all experimentally determined correlation coefficients in increasing order and one
at a time we removed from the network the link corresponding to the observed value in order to explore the
global organization of the remaining network. by considering the connected components. This enabled us to
calculate connected components by systematically varying the threshold on the network. Among the possible
thresholds we looked at those values associated with the plateaux showed in the curve "number of connected
components vs thresholds" obtained by the percolation process. Specifically, we considered all correlation
values corresponding to points in the distribution of the real plateaux length overcoming the mean plus four
standard deviations of the distribution of plateaux length of the ensemble of randomizations. This procedure
led to the definition of 23 values, for which stable configurations of brain networks were found.
Maximum Spanning Forest and Maximum Spanning Tree
Starting from the initial correlation matrix we built a new matrix keeping only the maximum values along
each row and sending all the rest to zero. We construct a directed network whose links connect each source-
ROI with its maximally correlated target-ROI. This approach is equivalent to create a network from scratch
in three steps: (i) to rank in decreasing order all the pairwise correlation values; (ii) to look at the list from
the top and adding a new link if at least one of the two involved nodes has degree zero, otherwise discarding
such correlation; (iii) to update the node degrees. The procedure ends when all nodes have at least degree
equal to one. In both cases, the resulting network is made up by several components of nodes connected
through their strongest links and without forming loops.
In other terms, we have a Maximum Spanning
Forest (MSF) of the initial correlation network. Furthermore, the first procedure introduced a directionality,
simply revealing for each brain area which is its maximally correlated counterpart. The correlation values
discarded during the construction of the MSF and ranked in increasing order were then used to build a
Maximum Spanning Tree (MST). Starting from the top of the list, a link between the two involved nodes
was drawn if they did not belong to the same group, then the two sets were merged into one; otherwise the
correlation value was discarded. The procedure ended when all the nodes belonged to the same connected
component.
A statistical benchmark for human brains
In order to define to what extent the stepwise structure highlighted by the percolation analysis, the MSF and
MSF were significant, we compared the results with a proper statistical benchmark. Specifically, in order to
understand whether the results were a proper representation of the real intrinsic organization of the brain
functioning at rest we needed to define an appropriate null model. A matrix has to satisfy some requirements
in order to be a correlation matrix: it must be symmetric, with diagonal elements equal to 1, with off-diagonal
elements in the range [-1,1] and it has to be positive semidefinite. Not all standard randomization techniques
are suitable in this case. Here, we kept fix the spectrum distribution of the observed correlation matrix
applying a series of givens rotations. This choice avoids to introduce further procedures to adjust reshuffled
matrices in order to be positive semidefinite. We generated 100 randomizations of the observed correlation
matrix. All comparisons between the ensemble of randomizations and the real network were performed on
the pointwise squared matrix in order to neglect signs but to keep the ranking of correlation values. Relevant
quantities were computed on each randomization, than averaged over the ensemble.
References
Achard, S., Salvador, R., Whitcher, B., Suckling, J., and Bullmore, E. (2006). A resilient, low-frequency,
small-world human brain functional network with highly connected association cortical hubs. The Journal
of neuroscience, 26(1):63–72.
Aerts, H., Fias, W., Caeyenberghs, K., and Marinazzo, D. (2016). Brain networks under attack: robustness
properties and the impact of lesions. Brain, page aww194.
15
Allman, J. M., Tetreault, N. A., Hakeem, A. Y., Manaye, K. F., Semendeferi, K., Erwin, J. M., Park, S.,
Goubert, V., and Hof, P. R. (2011). The von economo neurons in the frontoinsular and anterior cingulate
cortex. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1225(1):59–71.
American-Psychiatric-Association (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (DSM-5 R(cid:13)).
American Psychiatric Pub.
Barab´asi, A.-L. (2009). Scale-free networks: a decade and beyond. science, 325(5939):412–413.
Bardella, G., Bifone, A., Gabrielli, A., Gozzi, A., and Squartini, T. (2016). Hierarchical organization of
functional connectivity in the mouse brain: a complex network approach. Scientific Reports, 6:32060 EP
–.
Bassett, D. S. and Bullmore, E. T. (2009). Human brain networks in health and disease. Current Opinion
in Neurology, 22(4).
Bassett, D. S. and Bullmore, E. T. (2016). Small-world brain networks revisited. The Neuroscientist, page
1073858416667720.
Bassett, D. S. and Gazzaniga, M. S. (2011). Understanding complexity in the human brain. Trends in
cognitive sciences, 15(5):200–209.
Bassett, D. S., Wymbs, N. F., Porter, M. A., Mucha, P. J., Carlson, J. M., and Grafton, S. T. (2011).
Dynamic reconfiguration of human brain networks during learning. Proceedings of the National Academy
of Sciences, 108(18):7641–7646.
Bertolero, M. A., Yeo, B. T., and D´ Esposito, M. (2015). The modular and integrative functional architecture
of the human brain. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 112(49):E6798–E6807.
Birn, R. M., Diamond, J. B., Smith, M. A., and Bandettini, P. A. (2006). Separating respiratory-variation-
related fluctuations from neuronal-activity-related fluctuations in fmri. Neuroimage, 31(4):1536–1548.
Broyd, S. J., Demanuele, C., Debener, S., Helps, S. K., James, C. J., and Sonuga-Barke, E. J. (2009).
Default-mode brain dysfunction in mental disorders: a systematic review. Neuroscience & biobehavioral
reviews, 33(3):279–296.
Buckner, R. L., Andrews-Hanna, J. R., and Schacter, D. L. (2008). The brain's default network. Annals of
the New York Academy of Sciences, 1124(1):1–38.
Bullmore, E. and Sporns, O. (2009). Complex brain networks: graph theoretical analysis of structural and
functional systems. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 10(3):186–198.
Bullmore, E. and Sporns, O. (2012). The economy of brain network organization. Nature Reviews
Neuroscience, 13(5):336–349.
Caldarelli, G. (2007). Scale-free networks: complex webs in nature and technology. Oxford University Press.
Caldarelli, G., Cristelli, M., Gabrielli, A., Pietronero, L., Scala, A., and Tacchella, A. (2012). A network
analysis of countries? export flows: firm grounds for the building blocks of the economy. PloS one,
7(10):e47278.
Caspers, J., Zilles, K., Eickhoff, S. B., Schleicher, A., Mohlberg, H., and Amunts, K. (2013). Cytoarchitec-
tonical analysis and probabilistic mapping of two extrastriate areas of the human posterior fusiform gyrus.
Brain Structure and Function, 218(2):511–526.
Chang, C. and Glover, G. H. (2009). Effects of model-based physiological noise correction on default mode
network anti-correlations and correlations. Neuroimage, 47(4):1448–1459.
Craig, A. D. (2009). How do you feel?now? the anterior insula and human awareness. Nature reviews
neuroscience, 10(1).
Deco, G., Jirsa, V. K., and McIntosh, A. R. (2011). Emerging concepts for the dynamical organization of
resting-state activity in the brain. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 12(1):43–56.
16
Draper, N. and Smith, H. (1998). Applied regression analysis: Wiley interscience. New York, pages 505–553.
Eguiluz, V. M., Chialvo, D. R., Cecchi, G. A., Baliki, M., and Apkarian, A. V. (2005). Scale-free brain
functional networks. Physical review letters, 94(1):018102.
Fajardo, C., Escobar, M. I., Buritic´a, E., Arteaga, G., Umbarila, J., Casanova, M. F., and Pimienta, H.
(2008). Von economo neurons are present in the dorsolateral (dysgranular) prefrontal cortex of humans.
Neuroscience letters, 435(3):215–218.
First, M., Williams, J., Karg, R., and Spitzer, R. (2015). Structured clinical interview for dms-5, research
version. Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Association.
First, M. B., Williams, J. B., Benjamin, L. S., and Spitzer, R. L. (2016). Structured Clinical Interview for
DSM-5 Personality Disorders: SCID-5-PD. American Psychiatric Association Publishing.
Folstein, M. F., Folstein, S. E., and McHugh, P. R. (1975). ?mini-mental state?: a practical method for
grading the cognitive state of patients for the clinician. Journal of psychiatric research, 12(3):189–198.
Fornito, A., Zalesky, A., and Bullmore, E. T. (2010). Network scaling effects in graph analytic studies of
human resting-state fmri data. Resting state brain activity: Implications for systems neuroscience, page 40.
Frackowiak, R. S., Friston, K. J., Frith, C. D., Dolan, R. J., Price, C. J., Zeki, S., Ashburner, J. T., and
Penny, W. D. (2004). Human brain function. Academic press.
Gallos, L. K., Makse, H. A., and Sigman, M. (2012). A small world of weak ties provides optimal global
integration of self-similar modules in functional brain networks. Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences, 109(8):2825–2830.
Gen¸c, E., Scholvinck, M. L., Bergmann, J., Singer, W., and Kohler, A. (2015). Functional connectivity
patterns of visual cortex reflect its anatomical organization. Cerebral Cortex, page bhv175.
Gili, T., Saxena, N., Diukova, A., Murphy, K., Hall, J. E., and Wise, R. G. (2013). The thalamus and
brainstem act as key hubs in alterations of human brain network connectivity induced by mild propofol
sedation. The Journal of Neuroscience, 33(9):4024–4031.
Glover, G. H., Li, T.-Q., and Ress, D. (2000). Image-based method for retrospective correction of physiological
motion effects in fmri: Retroicor. Magnetic resonance in medicine, 44(1):162–167.
Goelman, G., Gordon, N., and Bonne, O. (2014). Maximizing negative correlations in resting-state functional
connectivity mri by time-lag. PloS one, 9(11):e111554.
Gorges, M., Muller, H.-P., Lul´e, D., Pinkhardt, E. H., Ludolph, A. C., Kassubek, J., Consortium, L., et al.
(2016). The association between alterations of eye movement control and cerebral intrinsic functional
connectivity in parkinson?s disease. Brain imaging and behavior, 10(1):79–91.
Greicius, M. D., Krasnow, B., Reiss, A. L., and Menon, V. (2003). Functional connectivity in the resting
brain: a network analysis of the default mode hypothesis. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,
100(1):253–258.
Gu, X., Hof, P. R., Friston, K. J., and Fan, J. (2013). Anterior insular cortex and emotional awareness.
Journal of Comparative Neurology, 521(15):3371–3388.
Habas, C., Kamdar, N., Nguyen, D., Prater, K., Beckmann, C. F., Menon, V., and Greicius, M. D. (2009). Dis-
tinct cerebellar contributions to intrinsic connectivity networks. The Journal of Neuroscience, 29(26):8586–
8594.
Hagmann, P., Cammoun, L., Gigandet, X., Meuli, R., Honey, C. J., Wedeen, V. J., and Sporns, O. (2008).
Mapping the structural core of human cerebral cortex. PLoS Biol, 6(7):e159.
Honey, C., Sporns, O., Cammoun, L., Gigandet, X., Thiran, J.-P., Meuli, R., and Hagmann, P. (2009).
Predicting human resting-state functional connectivity from structural connectivity. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences, 106(6):2035–2040.
17
Honey, C. J., Thesen, T., Donner, T. H., Silbert, L. J., Carlson, C. E., Devinsky, O., Doyle, W. K., Rubin,
N., Heeger, D. J., and Hasson, U. (2012). Slow cortical dynamics and the accumulation of information
over long timescales. Neuron, 76(2):423–434.
Iorio, M., Spalletta, G., Chiapponi, C., Luccichenti, G., Cacciari, C., Orfei, M. D., Caltagirone, C., and
Piras, F. (2013). White matter hyperintensities segmentation: a new semi-automated method. Frontiers
in aging neuroscience, 5:76.
Krienen, F. M. and Buckner, R. L. (2009). Segregated fronto-cerebellar circuits revealed by intrinsic functional
connectivity. Cerebral cortex, 19(10):2485–2497.
Laricchiuta, D., Petrosini, L., Piras, F., Macci, E., Cutuli, D., Chiapponi, C., Cerasa, A., Picerni, E.,
Caltagirone, C., Girardi, P., Tamorri, S. M., and Spalletta, G. (2014). Linking novelty seeking and harm
avoidance personality traits to cerebellar volumes. Human Brain Mapping, 35(1):285–296.
Martinez-Conde, S., Macknik, S. L., and Hubel, D. H. (2004). The role of fixational eye movements in visual
perception. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 5(3):229–240.
Newman, M. (2010). Networks: an introduction. Oxford university press.
O'Reilly, J. X., Beckmann, C. F., Tomassini, V., Ramnani, N., and Johansen-Berg, H. (2010). Distinct and
overlapping functional zones in the cerebellum defined by resting state functional connectivity. Cerebral
cortex, 20(4):953–965.
Passow, S., Specht, K., Adamsen, T. C., Biermann, M., Brekke, N., Craven, A. R., Ersland, L., Gruner,
R., Kleven-Madsen, N., Kvernenes, O.-H., et al. (2015). Default-mode network functional connectivity is
closely related to metabolic activity. Human brain mapping, 36(6):2027–2038.
Petri, G., Expert, P., Turkheimer, F., Carhart-Harris, R., Nutt, D., Hellyer, P., and Vaccarino, F. (2014). Ho-
mological scaffolds of brain functional networks. Journal of The Royal Society Interface, 11(101):20140873.
Picerni, E., Petrosini, L., Piras, F., Laricchiuta, D., Cutuli, D., Chiapponi, C., Fagioli, S., Girardi, P.,
Caltagirone, C., and Spalletta, G. (2013). New evidence for the cerebellar involvement in personality
traits. Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience, 7(133):1–11.
Power, J. D., Mitra, A., Laumann, T. O., Snyder, A. Z., Schlaggar, B. L., and Petersen, S. E. (2014). Methods
to detect, characterize, and remove motion artifact in resting state fmri. Neuroimage, 84:320–341.
Raichle, M. E. and Snyder, A. Z. (2007). A default mode of brain function: a brief history of an evolving
idea. Neuroimage, 37(4):1083–1090.
Robinson, P., Henderson, J., Matar, E., Riley, P., and Gray, R. (2009). Dynamical reconnection and stability
constraints on cortical network architecture. Physical review letters, 103(10):108104.
Rosazza, C. and Minati, L. (2011). Resting-state brain networks: literature review and clinical applications.
Neurological Sciences, 32(5):773–785.
Rubinov, M. and Sporns, O. (2010). Complex network measures of brain connectivity: uses and interpreta-
tions. Neuroimage, 52(3):1059–1069.
Salvador, R., Suckling, J., Coleman, M. R., Pickard, J. D., Menon, D., and Bullmore, E. (2005). Neu-
rophysiological architecture of functional magnetic resonance images of human brain. Cerebral cortex,
15(9):1332–1342.
Shmueli, K., van Gelderen, P., de Zwart, J. A., Horovitz, S. G., Fukunaga, M., Jansma, J. M., and Duyn,
J. H. (2007). Low-frequency fluctuations in the cardiac rate as a source of variance in the resting-state
fmri bold signal. Neuroimage, 38(2):306–320.
Smith, S. M., Fox, P. T., Miller, K. L., Glahn, D. C., Fox, P. M., Mackay, C. E., Filippini, N., Watkins,
K. E., Toro, R., Laird, A. R., et al. (2009). Correspondence of the brain's functional architecture during
activation and rest. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 106(31):13040–13045.
18
Sporns, O. (2012). From simple graphs to the connectome: networks in neuroimaging. Neuroimage, 62(2):881–
886.
Sporns, O. (2013). Network attributes for segregation and integration in the human brain. Current opinion
in neurobiology, 23(2):162–171.
Stoodley, C. J., Valera, E. M., and Schmahmann, J. D. (2012). Functional topography of the cerebellum for
motor and cognitive tasks: an fmri study. Neuroimage, 59(2):1560–1570.
Telesford, Q. K., Morgan, A. R., Hayasaka, S., Simpson, S. L., Barret, W., Kraft, R. A., Mozolic, J. L., and
Laurienti, P. J. (2010). Reproducibility of graph metrics in fmri networks. Frontiers in neuroinformatics,
4:117.
Tzourio-Mazoyer, N., Landeau, B., Papathanassiou, D., Crivello, F., Etard, O., Delcroix, N., Mazoyer, B.,
and Joliot, M. (2002). Automated anatomical labeling of activations in spm using a macroscopic anatomical
parcellation of the mni mri single-subject brain. Neuroimage, 15(1):273–289.
Van Den Heuvel, M. P. and Sporns, O. (2011). Rich-club organization of the human connectome. The Journal
of neuroscience, 31(44):15775–15786.
van den Heuvel, M. P., Stam, C. J., Boersma, M., and Pol, H. H. (2008). Small-world and scale-free organiza-
tion of voxel-based resting-state functional connectivity in the human brain. Neuroimage, 43(3):528–539.
Wang, L., Saalmann, Y. B., Pinsk, M. A., Arcaro, M. J., and Kastner, S. (2012). Electrophysiological low-
frequency coherence and cross-frequency coupling contribute to bold connectivity. Neuron, 76(5):1010–
1020.
Zhang, S. and Chiang-shan, R. L. (2012). Functional connectivity mapping of the human precuneus by
resting state fmri. Neuroimage, 59(4):3548–3562.
|
1809.05336 | 1 | 1809 | 2018-09-14T10:15:54 | Characterizing functional brain networks and emotional centers based on Rasa theory of Indian aesthetics | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | In Indian history of arts, Rasas are the aesthetics associated with any auditory, visual, literary or musical piece of art that evokes highly orchestrated emotional states. In this work, we study the functional response of the brain to movie clippings meant to evoke the Rasas through network analysis. We extract functional brain networks using coherence measures on EEG recordings of film clips from popular Indian Bollywood movies representing nine Rasas in the Indian Natyasastra. Structural and functional network measures were computed for these brain networks, averaging over a range of significant edge weights, in different brainwave frequency bands. We identify segregation of neuronal wiring in the brain into modules using a community detection algorithm. Further, using mutual information measure, we compare and contrast the modular organizations of brain network corresponding to different Rasas. Hubs identified using centrality measure reveal the network nodes that are central to information propagation across all Rasas. We also observe that the functional connectivity is suppressed when high-frequency waves such as beta and gamma are dominant in the brain. The significant links causing differences between the Rasa pairs are extracted statistically. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Characterizing functional brain networks and
emotional centers based on Rasa theory of Indian
aesthetics
Richa Tripathi1, Dyutiman Mukhopadhyay2, 1, Chakresh Kumar Singh1, Krishna Prasad
Miyapuram1, and Shivakumar Jolad1,*
1Indian Institute of Technology Gandhinagar, Gandhinagar- 382355, India
2University College London, WC1E 6BT, UK
*[email protected]
ABSTRACT
In Indian history of arts, Rasas are the aesthetics associated with any auditory, visual, literary or musical piece of art that
evokes highly orchestrated emotional states. In this work, we study the functional response of the brain to movie clippings
meant to evoke the Rasas through network analysis. We extract functional brain networks using coherence measures on EEG
recordings of film clips from popular Indian Bollywood movies representing nine Rasas in the Indian Natyasastra. Structural
and functional network measures were computed for these brain networks, averaging over a range of significant edge weights,
in different brainwave frequency bands. We identify segregation of neuronal wiring in the brain into modules using a community
detection algorithm. Further, using mutual information measure, we compare and contrast the modular organizations of brain
network corresponding to different Rasas. Hubs identified using centrality measure reveal the network nodes that are central to
information propagation across all Rasas. We also observe that the functional connectivity is suppressed when high-frequency
waves such as beta and gamma are dominant in the brain. The significant links causing differences between the Rasa pairs
are extracted statistically.
Introduction
Emotions affect the body functioning in multiple ways such as by introducing electro-physiological changes in the facial
muscles, electrical activity in the brain, changes in heartbeat rates and respiration1. These physiological changes involve all the
Sub-Systems of the body to a small or large extent and hence affect our perception, thoughts and actions. Emotion states also
have a significant effect on the social development of the individuals2. Apart from the cognitive origin, at the neurological level,
it is believed that changes in the density of neural stimulations3 drive the emotions through agents such as inborn releaser and
external audio and visual stimulations. The functional changes that induce emotions through neural segregation of emotional
and non-emotional pathways can be inferred using brain imaging and EEG studies of individuals4.
In the recent years, analysis of brain networks constructed from EEG and advanced brain imaging techniques has contributed
to the understanding of the complex structure and functioning of the human brain5, 6 and has given clues to understanding
its higher cognitive exhibits such as emotions and reasoning abilities7 -- 9. The functional brain networks studies have given
reasonable evidence against the locationist approach of functional segregation of distinct brain regions corresponding to specific
emotion categories in favour of constructionist approach i.e. different emotions involve brain circuits comprising of brain areas
not specific to a particular emotion8, 10, 11. Emotional stimuli affect large scale functional brain networks which can be evaluated
in terms of parameters such as node betweenness and network efficiency12. The human brain can be decomposed into multiple,
distinct, and interacting networks such as salience network, executive control network and task negative network, and emotional
stimuli can differentially affects these subnetworks9, 12, 13. For example, strong changes in salience networks have been reported
during watching an aversive movie segment as compared to watching a neutral movie segment through fMRI studies14 .
Studies on emotion based on the analysis of single-electrode level based EEG in the frequency domain have demonstrated
the association of emotion with asymmetric activity in the frontal brain in alpha band. Ekman and Davidson (1993)15 in
their study found that voluntary facial expressions of smiles of enjoyment produced high left frontal brain activity. On the
contrary, Coan et al.16 reported that face expressions of fear produce low frontal activation. Also, in a study by Sammler and
colleagues17, it was proposed that increase in frontal midline theta power was associated with happy emotion. Apart from using
alpha and theta asymmetry for emotional classification, power spectral features of EEG signals were extracted in five frequency
bands and used for emotion recognition using Deep Learning network architecture with considerable accuracy18. It has also
been demonstrated that different patterns of functional connectivity are associated with different emotional states in either
single or combined frequency bands ascertaining distinct response patterns of the central nervous system to different emotional
stimuli7.
In previous studies on classifying emotions, researchers have largely focused only on few contrasting dimensions such
as threat-safe, sadness-happiness, positive-negative-neutral and with a small number of recording sites of EEG activity7, 19, 20.
Also, the film-based studies on emotions and functional response of brain has been previously carried out primarily based on
the Western classification of emotions which are happiness, sadness, fear, anger, surprise, disgust21, 22. However, audio-visual
stimuli such as film viewing are capable of evoking sentiments which might be due to interplay the basic emotions (dominant
states) and transitory and temperamental states of emotions. Indian Rasa theory, as described in the Natyasastra has outlined
these sentiments or Rasas as the superposition of these states of emotions23.
In this work, we study the functional response of brain captured through 128 channel EEG recordings to movie clippings
eliciting the response corresponding to the nine Rasas classified according to Indian Natyasastra. We have recorded the response
of participants to a wide range of audio-visual stimuli from clippings of popular Indian Bollywood movies in Hindi. We have
analysed the patterns of brain activity in different frequency bands corresponding to Brainwaves24 and examined whether
these activities would show specific neural signatures across viewers. Different network measures were used to characterises
the structural and functional differences among the Rasa states. Community structure corresponding to different Rasas were
computed to highlight the specificity to different brain areas or circuits and fill the gap of brain network analysis. Modular
organisations of networks corresponding in each of the frequency bands were compared using information flow measure to
quantify the difference between the Rasas. Most central of the nodes were identified using leverage centrality measure for
each of the networks, enabling us to find the most significant nodes for emotion perception and segregate designated areas
for particular emotion processing. The significant links across all Rasas pairs were identified statistically to locate origins of
differences in functional networks using Honest Significant difference test across emotion groups after the F-test as followed in
a work by Lee (2014)7.
Background
Rasa and Natyasastra
A major source of the Indian system of classification of emotional states comes from the 'Natyasastra', the ancient Indian
treatise on the performing arts, which dates back to 2nd Century AD (pg. LXXXVI:23). The 'Natyasastra' speaks about
'sentiments' or 'Rasas' (pg.102:23) which are produced when certain 'dominant states' (sthayi bhava), 'transitory states'
(vyabhicari bhava) and 'temperamental states' (sattvika bhava) of emotions come together (pgs.102, 105:23). This Rasa theory,
which is still widely followed in classical Indian performing arts, classifies eight Rasas or sentiments which are: Sringara
(erotic), Hasya (comic), Karuna (pathetic), Raudra (furious), Veera (heroic), Bhayanaka (terrible), Bibhatsa (odious) and
Adbhuta (marvelous). There was a later addition of the ninth sentiment or Rasa called Santa (peace) in later Sanskrit poetics
(pg.102:23).
The eight dominant states (sthayi bhava) of emotions which give rise to these corresponding eight Rasas or sentiments are:
love (for Sringara), mirth (for Hasya), sorrow (for Karuna), anger (for Raudra), energy (for Veera), terror (for Bhayanaka),
disgust (for Bibhatsa) and astonishment (for Adbhuta). Apart from these there are thirty three 'transitory states' (vyabhicari
bhava) and eight 'temperamental states' (sattvika bhava) of emotions mentioned in the Natyasastra which play a critical role in
the generation of Rasas or sentiments (pg.102:23).
Western emotional classification and Rasa theory
According to Western version of emotion classification by Ekman, there are basic or universal emotions21, 25,22 which are
happiness, sadness, fear, anger, surprise, disgust. However, there are also background emotion sets which are: wellbeing-
malaise; calm-tense; pain-pleasure;26 as well as self-referential social emotions which are: embarrassment, guilt, shame,
jealousy, envy, empathy, pride, admiration.27 -- 32. Also, there are pioneering works of scientists like Lisa Feldman Barrett33 who
questions Ekman's concepts of discreteness of emotions. Apart from defining the boundaries of universal emotions, research in
emotion science also places equal emphasis in trying to understand the interplay of the different orchestrated processes that
give rise to a basic emotion33 -- 35. For example, Panksepp34, 36 defined primary processes of emotion (not the basic or universal
emotions of Ekman) as primary sub-neocortical processes of emotion having their corresponding affective states which can be
artificially generated by brain stimulation in animals. Also, the four-step cascade process proposed by Jerome Kagan35 defines
a provocative event which leads to brain-change and subsequently leads to a feeling and the interpretation of the feeling gives
rise to an emotion.
We can find startling similarities between the Rasa theory (its concepts of the generation of Rasas from the Bhavas) with
the works of Panksepp and Kagan34 -- 37. However, there had been very little previous work done on the perception or brain
science of emotional states based on Rasa theory mostly due to the lack of awareness regarding the science of the Rasa theory
among the scientific community. One behavioural study was conducted by Hejmadi38, which investigated the identification of
2/13
these emotions across cultures. An image processing study was conducted in Ref.39 for investigating the variations in facial
features based on nine Rasas. The study proposes a tool for the design of intelligent emotion recognition system but does not
offer a psychophysical or brain-based perspective on how these individual emotions differ in the way they affect our perceptual
process. There have been no brain-imaging based works on Rasa-theory comparable with similar works done on emotions
based on Western literature. We analyze through EEG, the patterns of brain activity generated through nine different emotional
responses based on Indian Rasa theory while watching films and to find out whether these activities would show specific neural
signatures across viewers.
Results
Brain Network Characterization
Functional properties of complex networks are largely determined by the statistical properties of its structure. We have
calculated six well-known network measures- Clustering Coefficient (CC), Characteristic Path Length (L), Network Density
(d), Local and Global efficiency (LE,GE), and Small-worldness index (SW ) using Area Under Curve method (see Methods for
details).
The clustering coefficient (CC) is a measure of network segregation. The high global clustering coefficient of the brain
network quantifies functional segregation in the brain for specialized processing to occur within densely interconnected groups
of brain regions. The characteristic path length L (average shortest path length between all pairs of nodes in the network -
see e.g.40) on the other hand, is the most commonly used measure of functional integration41. Network density d measures
the number of links present as compared to the number of possible connections in the network. Global efficiency of network
quantifies information exchange across the whole network where the information flow occurs on a global scale. The local
efficiency quantifies the network's robustness to failure in the local node neighbourhood i.e. measure of information flow
between the neighbours of a node if it is removed from the network.
Small-worldness index (SW = C/Crand
L/Lrand
, see Methods) measures the amount of deviation of actual networks from the random
networks40. Functional brain networks with high correlations retained show many biologically relevant features such as
"small-world" behavior40, 42, 43, existence of hubs and high network modularity. Small-world topology supports distributed as
well as segregated information processing at the same time and is highly economical in terms of wiring cost involved in this
information processing42.
In Fig. 1, we plot the six measures described above for all the Rasas across all frequency bands. Network density d > 0.45
for all the networks obtained through AUC method shows that they are dense. Average shortest path length lies between 1.2
to 1.8, indicating the ease of information propagation. Network density decreases with increasing frequency, except in the
gamma band- where it becomes denser. Correspondingly we see a drop in path length. Clustering coefficient shows small
variations from 0.75 to 0.9. Gamma band has greater spread than all other bands. Veera and Bhayanaka shows the maximum
difference across δ ,θ ,α, and β bands. SW greater than one for all Rasas, indicating deviation from absolute randomness
as well as regularity of connections in the brain. Global efficiency of the networks is high - ranging from 0.7 to 0.87. Local
efficiency is even higher- 0.88 to 0.95, indicating high robustness to the failure of nodes. The trend (increase or decrease of
network measures with frequency) is flipped at high frequency in the γ band. This is seen for all the Rasas and for each network
metric, suggesting a dynamic reorganisation of brain structure at high frequency. Information flow at gamma frequency the
brain has a special structural organisation quite very different from the one at just lower frequency band.
Across all the frequency bands, except γ it is seen that the Rasas Bhayanaka and Veera are at opposite extremities in terms
of the values of Network measures. The order of Rasas across the extent of network properties enveloped by properties of these
two Rasas is Bhayanaka, Karuna, Raudra, Santa, Hasya, Sringara, Bibhatsa, Adbhuta and Veera. This order is not followed in
gamma bands, where Karuna and Hasya are at the ends of Rasas spectrum.
Edge Weight distribution
Edge weights denote the strength of connections between the nodes. The cumulative edge weight distribution of all Rasas is
shown in supplementary information Fig.SI2. We find that edge weights are considerably high for δ , θ and α bands for all
networks and lower for α and β bands. Through which we infer that functional connectivity of brain for emotion perception
is stronger in δ , θ, and γ bands whereas the emotional pathways have lesser average information flow in α and β frequency
regimes. We also observe that Raudra, Bhayanaka and Hasya have higher correlations specially in δ , θ an α bands as compared
to other Rasas.
Community structure
Quantitative analysis of brain using complex networks measures has revealed the presence of highly connected hubs and
significant modular architecture44, apart from showing small-worldness. Modules are functionally specialised and spatially
localised groups of nodes that function together in unison to integrate the information globally that they process locally.
3/13
Figure 1. Network measures Network Density (d), Path Length (L), Clustering Coefficient (CC) , Small Worldness , Global
Efficiency (GE), and Local Efficiency (LE) (see text for details) of brain networks corresponding to different Rasas across the
five frequency bands (δ ,θ ,α,β and γ) along with their error bars.
In Fig. 2, we show community structure of brain networks corresponding to all the Rasas, with top 10% of the edges
retained, extracted using the modularity optimisation algorithm in Gephi. The communities were then extracted from the
complete networks (with all the edges retained, after removing the 5 % weakest connections) corresponding to all the Rasas.
All the networks were highly modular with modularity, Q ≥ 0.58, and had with five to six communities in each case. Broadly,
the community structure appears similar across all networks, with one major community in the frontal lobes (C1), two in the
left and right hemisphere's central/parietal brain regions (C2, C3), one that encompasses a large area in the visual cortex in the
occipital areas (C4) and two other smaller communities along the left and right temporal regions (C5, C6). The Bibhatsa Rasa
shows split of the community in the parietal lobe. The communities C4 and C5 are merged into one for most of the graphs.
However, the frequency band wise networks as shown in the supplementary information (Fig. SI 3), generally shows them as
separate communities.
Distance between Networks
To compare the similarities and differences in the network's modular organization (communities), we use the Variation of
information (VI) measure45 (See Eq. 3 in Methods). The VI measure signifies the difference in the modular organisation of the
networks, summarising the differences in segregation and network wiring. In Fig. 3, we show the Variation of Information
measure for different Rasas in different frequency bands. Networks that are farthest from each other are shown in brighter
cell colour (V I (cid:39) 0.5), and those which are closest are shaded dark (V I (cid:39) 0.0). Six VI measure matrices were obtained - one
corresponding to overall spectrum and five other corresponding to each of frequency bands (see Fig. 3). We have evaluated the
distance matrix between all Rasas based on the total power to visualise the overall differences in network partitions. In the
supplementary information (Fig. SI 1), we have compared the modular organization of each emotion across all frequencies i.e
with one emotion at a time.
For all the pairs of Rasas, the VI falls in the range 0.22 to 0.56. The colour bar (common for all matrices) range is chosen to
represent the maximum variation in VI. We observe that, for the full network, the dynamic range of VI variation is much small,
hence we cannot infer much about the similarity or dissimilarity of different network organizations. In the lowest frequency δ
band - Bibhatsa, Hasya and Karuna are closest to each other. Maximum difference is between Adbhuta and Bhayanka. For θ
band- Bhayanaka, Bibhatsa , Sringara are relatively closest. Others are far from each other. The α band is the most distinctive
4/13
1 Figure 2. Brain Networks for various Rasas with 10 per cent highest edge weight edges, organised into clear community
structure. For all the Rasas the network is dissociated into 5 to 6 communities. One can notice the changes in the community
structure from this figure, while there are a few clear communities consistently present across all the networks. The modularity
value for network partition was above 0.5 for all the Rasas, depicting highly modular structure at the level of strongest
connections in the network.
frequency band where all the Rasas are much closer to each other (except the Karuna). The α band activity for all the Rasas ,
except Karuna seems indistinguishable from each other. For β band, the pairs Adbhuta, Bhayanaka, Raudra, and Sringara
are the closer to each other, and Hasya and Adbhuta are the farthest. In the γ band, Veera is farthest from Santa, Hasya and
Bhayanaka. Adbhuta is much closer to Bhayanaka and Karuna.
Honest significant edges among different Rasas
To assess whether a particular edge weight in the brain network of a given Rasa is on average higher, or lower compared to other
groups, we performed F-test on all the edge weights against the null hypothesis that all Rasas (groups) yield the same mean
edge weight. The edge weights that pass the F-test were the ones considered significant across all groups (with significance
α ≤ 0.05). But, this does not reveal which individual group means contribute to this significance. To identify where the group
differences lie, Tukey's Honest Significant Difference (HSD) was performed as a post-hoc analysis on the edge weights that
were proven significant by the F-test. Tukey's test enables us to determine two Rasas/ groups, corresponding to each of these
5/13
(a)Adbhuta(b)Bhayanaka(c)Bibhatsa(d)Hasya(e)Karuna(f)Raudra(g)Santa(h)Sringara(i)Veera1 Figure 3. Variation of Information (Eq. 3) matrices for various Rasas in different frequency bands arranged in order overall,
δ, θ, α, β and γ, from left to right and top to bottom. It can be seen that Rasas have more similar modular organization in δ
and α bands than in θ, β and γ bands.
Figure 4. Brain maps showing Honest Significant Differences of coherences for groups, (a)Adb-Kar (b)Bha-Sri (c)Bib-Has
(d)Has-Rau (e)Rau-Sri and (f) Sri-Veer, with higher (Blue) and lower (Red) coherences for the group on the left. The values in
the panel on the left of each figure is the Variation of information measure corresponding to the two Rasas in all frequency
bands and in overall spectrum.
6/13
1ADB-KARBHA-SRIBIB-HASHAS-RAURAU-SRISRI-VEER1 significant edge weights.
We extracted significant edges for all 36 pairs of un-thresholded networks. The pairs are shown in the Fig. 4 shows
significant edges for six such pairs. The edges represent higher (Blue) and lower (Red) coherence for the group on the left in
each pair. The group means of edge weights that contribute to the significant difference is spread over the entire space for some
and it is highly localized for others.Between Adbhutam and Karunyam , edges in the central and parietal left regions show
significant positive differences. Bhayanka and Sringara have differences in the frontal and temporal left regions. Raudra and
Sringara has differences in right frontal and left parietal regions.
A detailed table with all the significant connections for all the pairs is in the supplementary information (Table SI 4). In the
figure, a panel with corresponding VI measure value for the corresponding network pair for overall spectrum and the individual
frequency bands are provided.
Figure 5. Brain map showing nodes with (a)highest positive leverage centralities (b) highest negative leverage centralities for
all the Rasas. Pink coloured nodes are the one which are consistently central for at least eight Rasas, other colors are for Rasas
as shown in the color panel above.
Hub Identification Using Centrality measure
Hubs in the brain networks are nodes that are critical to information flow across the network and are identified based on various
centrality measures such as Degree Centrality, Eigen-Vector Centrality46, Betweenness Centrality47, and Leverage Centrality48.
As far as Brain networks are concerned, work by Joyce et al. suggests that Leverage centrality48 is computationally cheaper
and more accurate for identifying hubs than other centrality measures, as revealed by their Receiver Operating Characteristic
curves (see Methods for details).
Leverage centrality also incorporates information about local node neighbourhood, such that a node with high positive
leverage centrality is more impactful to its neighbours so that its neighbours draw more information from it than any other
nodes in their neighbourhood. In contrast, a negative leverage centrality node is influenced more by its neighbours than being
an influencer node. In the present study, we designate central nodes as nodes with the largest positive and negative leverage
centralities.
In Fig. 5, are shown a brain map with coloured nodes having the highest (top 12) positive and highest negative (top 12)
leverage centralities. Colour coding is based on the Rasas as shown in the figure. Nodes shown in pink are consistently central
across all the Rasas. For the positive centrality case, they all lie in the periphery of the brain map, mostly in the parietal brain
regions indicating that most important information relay centres for the perception of emotions are located at the parietal
regions of the brain. The central nodes with most negative leverage centralities are in the frontal and central brain regions
demonstrating that nodes drawing maximum information from their neighbours are in these regions (In the Supplementary
Information, we provide two tables (Table SI 2, Table SI 3) with labels of nodes with highest positive and negative leverage
centralities for all the Rasas ).
Discussion
The Rasas discussed in this work evoke emotions which are related to, but are different from the western classification of
emotions such as anger, fear, happiness, and sadness. But there is very little work done on the science of Rasas and how they
7/13
1 are perceived in the brain. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first attempt to design a network analysis probe to identify
neural signatures for different Rasas mentioned in Indian Natyasastra.
We have studied changes in the functional connectivity and modular network organisation in different frequency bands,
concerning different Rasa states, elicited in participants through watching of movie clips. We have characterized how the
emotional states are similar or dissimilar by measuring network segregation in different frequency bands. We find that the
community structure in the alpha band is most similar across all Rasa genres and low synchrony of nodes in higher frequency
bands. Previous studies have reported higher correlations for negative or stress full visual stimuli49 for lower frequency bands.
In line with this, our results indicate higher coherence in these bands for Raudra and Bhayanaka Rasas.
Our coherence analysis has also shown higher synchronization among nodes in lower frequency bands delta, theta and
alpha and weaker correlations in beta and gamma bands for all the networks. We have identified the community structure of the
brain for different Rasas at the level of strongest links through which we can track the community evolution such as the birth,
growth, merger and collapse of communities. We find the existence of four dominant communities consistently across all Rasas
and localisation of hubs on brain map. We have also located the origins of coherence differences across Rasa pairs in edges
that are significantly different for these groups. Finally, we identified most central nodes in all the networks using Leverage
centrality and located them on the scalp, showing crucial centres for information processing.
There are a few limitations to this work. Our observations are based on analysis of the signal space of electrodes placed on
the scalp which does not have a clear source mapping inside the brain. Western classification of emotions such as those by
Ekman, have been studied for decades using various imaging methods and analytical tools by researchers in various disciplines.
However, we find very limited literature on quantitative study of Rasas based on brain imaging or EEG. Lack of reference
limits standardization of our results. But we hope that our work will trigger interest in the research community to explore the
scientific study of Rasas further.
Materials and Methods
Prior to conducting EEG experiments, ethical clearance was taken from the Institute Ethical Committee (IEC) of Indian Institute
of Technology Gandhinagar. Informed consent was obtained from all the participants before conducting experiments.
Subjects
Participants were 20 healthy, right-handed students from Indian Institute of Technology Gandhinagar (mean age: 26 years, 16
males; 4 females). All of the participants were proficient in Hindi and English languages. They were all informed about the
task and were asked to remain attentive while watching the film clip. We did an independent ranking of many movie clips
corresponding to each of the Rasas and only those were selected which were ranked best suited to evoke a particular response
among the Rasas.
Movie Clips
Complex, naturalistic stimuli like film-viewing evoke highly reliable brain activity across viewers as per current research
works50. In this work, we used nine film clips from Bollywood films (popular Indian Hindi language cinema) made between
1970's to the current time (see Table SI 1). These film clips were chosen to elicit the nine Rasas among the viewers, based on
the opinion of experts in Natyashastra. Independent rating of the movies was done on a small number of subjects. The length
of the movie clips varied from 42s to 2 mins 37s. Based on Natyasastra51 human Rasas are classified into nine categories22 as
given in the background section
EEG Experimental Procedure
We conducted the EEG experiment on the participants during which they were asked to watch chosen film clips representative
of nine different Rasa Genres. The electrical activity of the brain was recorded using 128 channel high-density Geodesic EEG
SystemsTM with a sampling frequency of 250Hz. A representative diagram of the node placement (along with node numbers
from 1 to 128) used in the present work for brain network visualization, is shown in Fig. 6 (a). The figure also depicts the
electrode allocations to anatomical regions of the brain. The following abbreviations are used: F, L O and T stand for Frontal,
Parietal, Occipital and Temporal lobes; L and R represent Left and Right regions. In Fig. 2, brain maps for the nine Rasas of
the overall spectrum are shown.
The participants were shown all the film clips in random order. A white fixation cross with a black screen for ten secs
was shown before each clip. Initial few seconds of the time series recordings were neglected before analysis to avoid major
fluctuations due to adjustment. Signals beyond 60 Hz frequencies were filtered out to avoid noise effects. The design of the
experiment was done in E-primeTM and synced with Net-stationTM acquisition software. The entire study on the collected data
from the EEG experiment is summarised in the Fig. 6.
8/13
(a)
(b)
Figure 6. (a) A brain map of the electrode positions of the EEG cap. All the Brain networks and extracted communities in the
present work follow this Node placement. (b) Workflow structure governing EEG data recording, pre-processing, network
construction and analysis
Construction of Brain Network
Standard time series analysis measures such as Coherence52, Phase Synchronization53, Mutual Information54, and Granger
Causality55 offer a huge depth into understanding the synchrony and information propagation in the functional brain. We
use Electroencephalographic Coherence as a metric for deriving functional brain connectivity i. e. the degree of association
between any two brain regions (whose electrical activity is recorded by electrodes in the signal space). Holding values between
0 (nil coherence) and 1 (complete coherence), it compares similarity of the power spectra (measured in microvolts squared,
µV 2 ) of the time-series recorded by these electrodes. The regions showing highest coherence are assumed to be the most
synchronized functionally and vice-versa. The coherence measure (Eq. 1) between two time series X and Y is defined as,
CXY ( f ) =
GXY ( f )2
GXX ( f )GYY ( f )) ,
(1)
where GXY ( f ) is the cross-power spectral density and GXX ( f ) and GYY ( f ) are the respective auto-power spectral densities56.
The time series data (in microvolts, µV) was transformed to frequency domain via Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) and the
power in different Brainwave frequency bands24: δ (1-4 Hz), θ (4 - 8 Hz), α (8 - 12 Hz), β (12 - 40 Hz) and γ (40 - 100 Hz),
corresponding to different brain waves was calculated. The Coherence spectra, thus decomposed into five frequency bands
resulted in five 128× 128 coherence matrices corresponding to each of the nine stimuli. The frequency decomposition of the
spectrum was made to estimate the power in each of these bands and capture the brain state when a particular emotion was
evoked. Apart from powers in individual bands we also used average coherence across the whole spectrum in the analysis. The
coherence matrix was mapped to a weighted adjacency matrix, and corresponding brain network was constructed with N = 128
nodes. In this network, the nodes are the electrode locations on the scalp and edges are connections between them measured by
the coherence values.
Each of the electrodes from the EEG cap records the mean activity from a brain region and has contributions from the
neighbouring brain areas as well, which may be spatially distant from the recording point. The resulting functional brain
network is a dense network, retaining all the edges (O ∼ N2) with non-zero edge weights. Also, in such functional networks,
weak and non-significant links may represent spurious connections or false statistical dependencies. Such links tend to obscure
the topology of stronger and significant connections and should ideally be discarded, by applying hard, or weighted thresholding.
In the present work, the edges weights (coherences) representing functional correlations are Fischer Z-transformed, averaged
over all the participants and then thresholded to retain only significant connections. To this end, 5 % of the weakest connections
were omitted from the network, for all the nine cases. All the network analysis was done on these thresholded networks.
Network Analysis
Network analysis of the functional networks performed in the present study consists of five elements as summarised in the
Fig. 7. They are explained in the following sections.
Small-worldness index
To distinguish between true functional connections from random connections among vertices, networks metrics must be
compared to the corresponding mean values of a benchmark random graph with the same number of nodes and edges. We
9/13
1 Figure 7. Block diagram of the methods used in the Network analysis of Brain Networks.
measured the small-worldness index of the networks defined as [C/Crand]/[L/Lrand], where Crand and Lrand are the mean
clustering coefficient and the characteristic path length of an ensemble of random networks with fixed number of nodes N and
edges (cid:104)E(cid:105) = EB of the Brain network.
Area Under Curve method
The network measures and metrics were evaluated on the un-thresholded networks, using the Area Under the Curve (AUC)
approach57. In the AUC procedure two cutoffs (one upper, one lower)on the edge strengths are consistently determined for
each network, such that a range of important connections are retained, and only important network structure is dealt with. The
lower bound in this threshold range, κ−, is an edge weight at which network is fully connected and the upper bound, κ+ is the
threshold at which the network just gets disconnected. The network is binarised at each threshold within this range, retaining
only edges with weights larger than the threshold value and eliminating the remaining ones and network metric (M) is evaluated
at each connection density. This results in a curve showing the variation of M with edge weights lying in the threshold range.
The curve was then integrated over all these thresholds to yield the AUC value of the metric M.
Community detection and Graph Visualization
For visualisation of dominant communities in the brain networks of all the Rasas, we retained top 10 % of the edges and
extracted communities on the obtained network. We used Gephi software58 which utilises a modularity optimisation algorithm59
for detection of communities from the brain networks and Geolayout scheme for node positioning. The community structure of
networks in different frequency bands for all the Rasas is provided as animated graphic files in the supplementary material.
Leverage Centrality
Leverage centrality (defined in Eq 2),
lv =
1
kv ∑
Nv
kv − kw
kv + kw
(2)
measures the relationship between the degree of a vertex kv and the degree of each of its neighbors kw, averaging over all the
neighbors Nv. For the weighted network, as in our case, degrees are weighted degrees.
Variation of Information
Between two network partitions X and Y , the V I is defined in terms of the conditional entropy as below:
V I(X,Y ) = H(X/Y ) + H(Y /X).
The conditional entropy H(X/Y ) of partition X given Y , with Mx and My modules can be computed as :
H(X/Y ) = − Mx∑
i=1
My
∑
j=1
p(xi,yi)log p(xi/y j),
(3)
(4)
10/13
where p(xi,y j) = ni j/N is the joint probability of randomly selecting a node that belongs to modules Xi and Yj and p(XiYj) =
ni j/b j is the conditional probability that a node belongs to module Xi in partition X, given that it is in module Yj in partition Y ,
and b j is the number of nodes in community Yj of partition Y . ni j is the number of nodes that are simultaneously present in
module Xi and Yj.
we ran F-test(cid:0)128
2
Honest Significant Difference across Rasas
In our case, each of the Rasas was a group formed by twenty networks (corresponding to twenty participants coherence
matrices) and mean of a particular edge weight was calculated over these twenty networks. The edge weight values in the
coherence matrices corresponding to these groups were the ones tested for significance using the above two tests. So, practically
test, to reveal which edge weight is significant across any two groups, with significance α ≤ 0.05. So, the two groups with
significantly different mean were calculated for each edge weight, and in this group pair, one has a significantly higher or lower
mean edge weight than the other. These are depicted for six pairs in the Fig. 4 in the results section.
(cid:1) (number of edges) times. The edges that were significant according to the F-test were subject to Tukey's
Data availability
All the figures generated and used in the study, Gephi network files, coherence matrices, and tables are uploaded on a Google
drive folder (Rasas_BrainNetwork_Data). Raw EEG data can be provided upon request to authors. Details of the movie
clippings (start and end times) are given in the Supplementary Information.
Acknowledgments
We would like to thank Dipanjan Roy from National Brain Research Center (NBRC), India and Pranjali Kulkarni, Indian
Institute of Technology Gandhinagar (IITGn) for insightful suggestions into this study. The study is a part of the Department
of Science and Technology (India) sponsored Cognitive Science Research Initiative (DST-CSRI) project (Project number:
SR/CSRI/PDF-08/2013, Dated 30/10/2014). RT would like to thank Amit Reza from IITGn for helpful discussions. We thank
IITGn for providing access to the High-Performance Computing services.
References
1. Izard, C. E. The emotions in life and science. In Human emotions, 1 -- 18 (Springer, 1977).
2. Izard, C. E. Human emotions (Springer Science & Business Media, 2013).
3. Tomkins, S. S. Affect Imagery Consciousness: The Positive Affect (1962).
4. Pfurtscheller, G. & Da Silva, F. L. Event-related eeg/meg synchronization and desynchronization: basic principles. Clin.
neurophysiology 110, 1842 -- 1857 (1999).
5. Bullmore, E. & Sporns, O. Complex brain networks: graph theoretical analysis of structural and functional systems. Nat.
Rev. Neurosci. 10, 186 (2009).
6. Sporns, O., Chialvo, D. R., Kaiser, M. & Hilgetag, C. C. Organization, development and function of complex brain
networks. Trends cognitive sciences 8, 418 -- 425 (2004).
7. Lee, Y.-Y. & Hsieh, S. Classifying different emotional states by means of eeg-based functional connectivity patterns. PloS
one 9, e95415 (2014).
8. Pessoa, L. On the relationship between emotion and cognition. Nat. reviews neuroscience 9, 148 (2008).
9. McMenamin, B. W., Langeslag, S. J., Sirbu, M., Padmala, S. & Pessoa, L. Network organization unfolds over time during
periods of anxious anticipation. J. Neurosci. 34, 11261 -- 11273 (2014).
10. Lindquist, K. A., Wager, T. D., Kober, H., Bliss-Moreau, E. & Barrett, L. F. The brain basis of emotion: a meta-analytic
review. Behav. brain sciences 35, 121 -- 143 (2012).
11. Pessoa, L. & Adolphs, R. Emotion processing and the amygdala: from a'low road'to'many roads' of evaluating biological
significance. Nat. reviews neuroscience 11, 773 (2010).
12. Pessoa, L. & McMenamin, B. Dynamic networks in the emotional brain. The Neurosci. 23, 383 -- 396 (2017).
13. V, M. & Toga, A. W. E. Salience Network. In: Brain mapping: An encyclopedic reference (Academic Press, 2015).
14. Hermans, E. J., Henckens, M. J., Joëls, M. & Fernández, G. Dynamic adaptation of large-scale brain networks in response
to acute stressors. Trends neurosciences 37, 304 -- 314 (2014).
11/13
15. Ekman, P. & Davidson, R. J. Voluntary smiling changes regional brain activity. Psychol. Sci. 4, 342 -- 345 (1993).
16. Coan, J. A., Allen, J. J. & Harmon-Jones, E. Voluntary facial expression and hemispheric asymmetry over the frontal
cortex. Psychophysiol. 38, 912 -- 925 (2001).
17. Sammler, D., Grigutsch, M., Fritz, T. & Koelsch, S. Music and emotion: electrophysiological correlates of the processing
of pleasant and unpleasant music. Psychophysiol. 44, 293 -- 304 (2007).
18. Jirayucharoensak, S., Pan-Ngum, S. & Israsena, P. Eeg-based emotion recognition using deep learning network with
principal component based covariate shift adaptation. The Sci. World J. 2014 (2014).
19. Nie, D., Wang, X.-W., Shi, L.-C. & Lu, B.-L. Eeg-based emotion recognition during watching movies.
engineering (NER), 2011 5th international IEEE/EMBS conference on, 667 -- 670 (IEEE, 2011).
In Neural
20. Dmochowski, J. P., Sajda, P., Dias, J. & Parra, L. C. Correlated components of ongoing eeg point to emotionally laden
attention -- a possible marker of engagement? Front. human neuroscience 6, 112 (2012).
21. Ekman, P. Expression and the nature of emotion. Approaches to emotion 3, 19 -- 344 (1984).
22. Ekman, P. An argument for basic emotions. Cogn. & emotion 6, 169 -- 200 (1992).
23. Ghosh, M. The natyasastra ascribed to bharata muni (vol. i). Calcutta: Asiatic Soc. Bengal (1951).
24. Tatum, W. O. Ellen r. grass lecture: Extraordinary eeg. The Neurodiagnostic J. 54, 3 -- 21 (2014).
25. Ekman, P. & Friesen, W. V. Constants across cultures in the face and emotion. J. personality social psychology 17, 124
(1971).
26. Damasio, A. R. The feeling of what happens: body and emotion in the making of consciousness. New York Times Book
Rev. 104, 8 -- 8 (1999).
27. Oatley, K. & Johnson-Laird, P. N. Towards a cognitive theory of emotions. Cogn. emotion 1, 29 -- 50 (1987).
28. Bennett, M. & Gillingham, K. The role of self-focused attention in children's attributions of social emotions to the self.
The J. genetic psychology 152, 303 -- 309 (1991).
29. Diener, E., Suh, E. M., Lucas, R. E. & Smith, H. L. Subjective well-being: Three decades of progress. Psychol. bulletin
125, 276 (1999).
30. Hareli, S. & Eisikovits, Z. The role of communicating social emotions accompanying apologies in forgiveness. Motiv.
Emot. 30, 189 -- 197 (2006).
31. Leary, M. R. & Baumeister, R. F. The nature and function of self-esteem: Sociometer theory. In Advances in experimental
social psychology, vol. 32, 1 -- 62 (Elsevier, 2000).
32. Tangney, J. P. E. & Fischer, K. W. Self-conscious emotions: The psychology of shame, guilt, embarrassment, and pride.
(Guilford Press, 1995).
33. Barrett, L. F. Are emotions natural kinds? Perspectives on psychological science 1, 28 -- 58 (2006).
34. Panksepp, J., Normansell, L., Cox, J. F. & Siviy, S. M. Effects of neonatal decortication on the social play of juvenile rats.
Physiol. & Behav. 56, 429 -- 443 (1994).
35. Kagan, J. Temperament and the reactions to unfamiliarity. Child development 68, 139 -- 143 (1997).
36. Panksepp, J. Affective neuroscience of the emotional brainmind: evolutionary perspectives and implications for under-
standing depression. Dialogues clinical neuroscience 12, 533 (2010).
37. Parrott, W. G. Emotions in social psychology: Essential readings (Psychology Press, 2001).
38. Hejmadi, A., Davidson, R. J. & Rozin, P. Exploring hindu indian emotion expressions: Evidence for accurate recognition
by americans and indians. Psychol. Sci. 11, 183 -- 187 (2000).
39. Srimani, P. & Hegde, R. Analysis of facial expressions with respect to navarasas in bharathanatym styles using image
processing. Int. J. Knowl. Eng. 3, 193 -- 196 (2012).
40. Watts, D. J. & Strogatz, S. H. Collective dynamics of 'small-world'networks. nature 393, 440 (1998).
41. Rubinov, M. & Sporns, O. Complex network measures of brain connectivity: uses and interpretations. Neuroimage 52,
1059 -- 1069 (2010).
42. Bassett, D. S. & Bullmore, E. Small-world brain networks. The neuroscientist 12, 512 -- 523 (2006).
43. Hayasaka, S. & Laurienti, P. J. Comparison of characteristics between region-and voxel-based network analyses in
resting-state fmri data. Neuroimage 50, 499 -- 508 (2010).
12/13
44. Achard, S., Salvador, R., Whitcher, B., Suckling, J. & Bullmore, E. A resilient, low-frequency, small-world human brain
functional network with highly connected association cortical hubs. J. Neurosci. 26, 63 -- 72 (2006).
45. Karrer, B., Levina, E. & Newman, M. E. Robustness of community structure in networks. Phys. Rev. E 77, 046119 (2008).
46. Newman, M. E. The mathematics of networks. The new palgrave encyclopedia economics 2, 1 -- 12 (2008).
47. Freeman, L. C. A set of measures of centrality based on betweenness. Sociom. 35 -- 41 (1977).
48. Joyce, K. E., Laurienti, P. J., Burdette, J. H. & Hayasaka, S. A new measure of centrality for brain networks. PLoS One 5,
e12200 (2010).
49. Miskovic, V. & Schmidt, L. A. Cross-regional cortical synchronization during affective image viewing. Brain research
1362, 102 -- 111 (2010).
50. Hasson, U., Nir, Y., Levy, I., Fuhrmann, G. & Malach, R. Intersubject synchronization of cortical activity during natural
vision. science 303, 1634 -- 1640 (2004).
51. Thirumalai, M. An introduction to natya shastra-gesture in aesthetic arts. Lang. India 1, 27 -- 33 (2001).
52. Bowyer, S. M. Coherence a measure of the brain networks: past and present. Neuropsychiatr. Electrophysiol. 2, 1 (2016).
53. Varela, F., Lachaux, J.-P., Rodriguez, E. & Martinerie, J. The brainweb: phase synchronization and large-scale integration.
Nat. reviews neuroscience 2, 229 (2001).
54. Salvador, R. et al. Frequency based mutual information measures between clusters of brain regions in functional magnetic
resonance imaging. Neuroimage 35, 83 -- 88 (2007).
55. Hesse, W., Möller, E., Arnold, M. & Schack, B. The use of time-variant eeg granger causality for inspecting directed
interdependencies of neural assemblies. J. neuroscience methods 124, 27 -- 44 (2003).
56. Thatcher, R., Krause, P. & Hrybyk, M. Cortico-cortical associations and eeg coherence: a two-compartmental model.
Electroencephalogr. clinical neurophysiology 64, 123 -- 143 (1986).
57. Bassett, D. S., Meyer-Lindenberg, A., Achard, S., Duke, T. & Bullmore, E. Adaptive reconfiguration of fractal small-world
human brain functional networks. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 103, 19518 -- 19523 (2006).
58. Bastian, M., Heymann, S., Jacomy, M. et al. Gephi: an open source software for exploring and manipulating networks.
Icwsm 8, 361 -- 362 (2009).
59. Blondel, V. D., Guillaume, J.-L., Lambiotte, R. & Lefebvre, E. Fast unfolding of communities in large networks. J.
statistical mechanics: theory experiment 2008, P10008 (2008).
13/13
|
1903.11915 | 1 | 1903 | 2019-03-28T12:27:32 | Early deafness leads to re-shaping of global functional connectivity beyond the auditory cortex | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Early sensory deprivation such as blindness or deafness shapes brain development in multiple ways. While it is established that deprived brain areas start to be engaged in the processing of stimuli from the remaining modalities and in high-level cognitive tasks, some reports have also suggested the possibility of structural and functional changes in non-deprived brain areas. We compared resting-state functional network organization of the brain in early-deaf adults and hearing controls by examining global network segregation and integration. Relative to hearing controls, deaf adults exhibited an altered modular organization, with regions of the salience network coupled with the fronto-parietal network. They showed weaker connections between auditory and somatomotor regions, stronger coupling between the fronto-parietal network and several other large-scale networks (visual, memory, cingulo-opercular and somatomotor), and an enlargement of the default mode network. Their overall functional segregation of brain networks was also lower. Our findings suggest that brain plasticity in deaf adults is not limited to changes in auditory cortex but additionally alters the coupling between other large-scale networks. These widespread functional connectivity changes may provide a mechanism for the superior behavioral performance of the deaf in visual and attentional tasks. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Early deafness leads to re-shaping of global functional connectivity
beyond the auditory cortex
Kamil Bonna1,2,+, Karolina Finc1,+, Maria Zimmermann3, Łukasz Bola3, Piotr Mostowski3,
Maciej Szul4, Paweł Rutkowski4, Włodzisław Duch1,2, Artur Marchewka5, Katarzyna Jednoróg6,
and Marcin Szwed3,*
1Centre for Modern Interdisciplinary Technologies, Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń, Toruń, 87-100, Poland
2Institute of Physics, Faculty of Physics, Astronomy and Informatics, Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń, Toruń,
3Department of Psychology, Jagiellonian University, Kraków, 30-060, Poland
4Section for Sign Linguistics, Faculty of Polish Studies, University of Warsaw, Warsaw, 00-927, Poland
5Laboratory of Brain Imaging, Neurobiology Center, Nencki Institute of Experimental Biology, Polish Academy of Sciences,
87-100, Poland
Warsaw, 02-093, Poland
6Laboratory of Psychophysiology, Neurobiology Center, Nencki Institute of Experimental Biology, Polish Academy of
Sciences, Warsaw, 02-093, Poland
*[email protected]
+these authors contributed equally to this work
March 29, 2019
Abstract
Early sensory deprivation such as blindness or deafness shapes brain development in multiple ways. While
it is established that deprived brain areas start to be engaged in the processing of stimuli from the remaining
modalities and in high-level cognitive tasks, some reports have also suggested the possibility of structural and
functional changes in non-deprived brain areas. We compared resting-state functional network organization of
the brain in early-deaf adults and hearing controls by examining global network segregation and integration.
Relative to hearing controls, deaf adults exhibited an altered modular organization, with regions of the salience
network coupled with the fronto-parietal network. They showed weaker connections between auditory and so-
matomotor regions, stronger coupling between the fronto-parietal network and several other large-scale networks
(visual, memory, cingulo-opercular and somatomotor), and an enlargement of the default mode network. Their
overall functional segregation of brain networks was also lower. Our findings suggest that brain plasticity in
deaf adults is not limited to changes in auditory cortex but additionally alters the coupling between other large-
scale networks. These widespread functional connectivity changes may provide a mechanism for the superior
behavioral performance of the deaf in visual and attentional tasks.
Keywords: brain plasticity, deafness, functional connectivity, graph theory, resting-state fMRI.
INTRODUCTION
The lack of input from one sensory modality profoundly
impacts brain development (Rauschecker et al., 1995;
Bavelier and Neville, 2002; Merabet and Pascual-Leone,
2010). First, a large body of data shows that the de-
prived brain regions become involved in the processing
of stimuli from remaining modalities. Following deaf-
ness, the auditory cortex becomes involved in tactile
(Lessard et al., 1998; Karns et al., 2012; Auer Jr et al.,
2007) and visual (Petitto et al., 2000; Finney et al.,
2001, 2003; Dewey and Hartley, 2015; Bola et al., 2017;
Scott et al., 2014) processing, while following blind-
ness the visual cortex becomes involved in tactile (Held
et al., 1996; Sadato et al., 1998) and auditory (Alho
et al., 1993; Kujala et al., 1997; Lessard et al., 1998; Ku-
jala et al., 2005) processing. Second, sensory deprived
areas can also become engaged in higher-level cogni-
tive tasks such as sign language processing (Nishimura
et al., 1999; MacSweeney et al., 2002; Sadato et al.,
2004), speechreading (MacSweeney et al., 2001; Capek
et al., 2008), visual attention (Bavelier et al., 2001) and
visuo-spatial working memory (Ding et al., 2015) in the
deaf and speech processing (Röder et al., 2002; Bur-
1
ton et al., 2002; Burton, 2003; Amedi et al., 2003; Bur-
ton et al., 2006; Bedny et al., 2015), syntax processing
(Bedny et al., 2015; Lane et al., 2015; Bedny, 2017),
mathematical thinking (Kanjlia et al., 2016) and verbal
memory (Amedi et al., 2003) in the blind. This func-
tional reorganization has been associated with anatom-
ical changes in sensory deprived areas (Emmorey et al.,
2003; Jiang et al., 2009).
Alterations in the brain structure and function of
blind or deaf individuals are not restricted to sensory
deprived areas. In the blind, besides a volume reduction
in the visual cortex, several studies have reported an en-
larged auditory cortex (Elbert et al., 2002), hippocam-
pus (Fortin et al., 2008) and frontal brain areas (Leporé
et al., 2009). In the deaf, researchers found an increased
volume of the frontal areas (Leporé et al., 2010) and of
the insula (Allen et al., 2008). Moreover, deaf individu-
als showed an increased recruitment of multimodal pari-
etal and occipital areas during performance of attention
tasks (Neville and Lawson, 1987; Bavelier et al., 2000,
2001; Armstrong et al., 2002; Finney et al., 2003), and
an increased recruitment of the insula, anterior cingu-
late and thalamus during verbal memory tasks (Bave-
lier et al., 2008). As the presented evidence suggests,
changes caused by deprivation of sensory input are not
limited to the corresponding domain-specific cortices,
e.g. the primary auditory cortex in deafness. However,
the possible impact of these changes on whole-brain net-
work organization has not received adequate attention.
Resting-state fMRI (rsfMRI) offers a solution to in-
vestigate whole-brain functional network organization
with no explicit task requirements (Van Den Heuvel
and Pol, 2010). Using rsfMRI data, one can estimate
functional connectivity (FC) between different brain ar-
eas by measuring the temporal dependence of the low-
frequency (< 0.1 Hz) MRI signal fluctuations among
them (Friston et al., 1993; Biswal et al., 1995). Stud-
ies on early-blind subjects reported both enhancement
and attenuation of functional connections. In the blind,
FC enhancement was found between the visual and lan-
guage networks (Liu et al., 2007; Bedny et al., 2011) and
between the visual cortex and regions associated with
memory and cognitive control (Burton et al., 2014);
weakened connections were found mostly between the
visual and somatosensory networks, and between the
motor and auditory networks (Liu et al., 2007). Stud-
ies on deaf individuals found an increased FC of the
right auditory cortex (superior temporal gyrus, STG)
with key nodes of the salience network such as the an-
terior insula and the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex
(dACC) (Ding et al., 2016).
Increased resting-state
FC was also reported between the right superior pari-
etal gyrus (rSPG) and the right insula, and between
the middle temporal gyrus and the posterior cingulate
gyrus (Li et al., 2016); this indicates that changes in
connectivity can occur beyond the deprived auditory
cortex.
Graph theoretical measures of rsfMRI functional
connectivity provide an effective way to describe and
understand the organizational features of brain net-
works in health, disease and throughout development
(He and Evans, 2010). To the best of our knowledge,
only one study so far has used graph theory measures
on rsfMRI data in early-deaf adults (Li et al., 2016). In
the whole brain analysis, Li and colleagues reported hub
regions in the frontal and parietal cortices in the deaf
but not in the control group. However, the authors did
not examine network integration or modular organiza-
tion, measures commonly applied to characterize plas-
ticity during development (Chen and Deem, 2015) and
following brain injury (Nakamura et al., 2009). Brain
network integration can be interpreted as the overall
efficiency in exchanging information, whereas modular
organization describes the propagation and processing
of local information. Thus, the question of the level
of integration and segregation of functional networks in
early-deaf adults remains unanswered.
The goal of the present study was to examine dif-
ferences between the whole-brain functional networks
of early-deaf and hearing adults. We sought to com-
pare whole-brain connectivity patterns between these
two groups,
focusing on differences in the strength
of functional association between individual brain re-
gions as well as graph measures of the segregation and
integration of the entire network (Sporns, 2013; Van
Den Heuvel and Pol, 2010). We hypothesized that deaf
adults have increased integration of multiple cortical ar-
eas. Specifically, we expected to find differences in the
connection strength beyond the auditory network.
METHOD
Participants
Twenty-five early-deaf subjects (15 females; Mage =
27.8 ± 5.2; range 19-37 years) and 29 hearing subjects
(16 females; Mage = 27.2 ± 4.7; range 19-37 years) par-
ticipated in the study. All subjects were right-handed
with normal or corrected to normal vision and no neu-
rological or psychiatric diseases. Four deaf subjects and
eight hearing subjects were excluded from further anal-
yses due to excessive motion (more than 10% of out-
lier scans identified by a scrubbing procedure; see Data
Processing section) or image acquisition errors. After
exclusion, the deaf group consisted of 21 subjects (14 fe-
males; Mage = 26.6 ± 4.8; range 19-37 years) and hear-
ing group of 21 subjects (14 females; Mage = 26.6 ± 5.2;
range 19-37 years). The groups did not differ in age, sex
or years of education. The etiology of deafness was ei-
ther genetic (hereditary deafness) or pregnancy-related
(maternal disease or drug side effects). The mean hear-
ing loss was 100.2 dB (range 70 -- 120 dB) for the left
ear and 101.4 dB (60 -- 120 dB) for the right ear. All
2
subjects had some experience with hearing aids (cur-
rently or in the past) but did not rely on them on a
daily basis. All subjects were proficient users of Polish
Sign Language (polski język migowy, PJM, a natural
visual-gestural language used by the deaf community
in Poland; see Table S1 for details). Written informed
consent was obtained from each participant. During the
study, deaf subjects were assisted by a PJM interpreter.
The research project was approved by the Committee
for Research Ethics of the Institute of Psychology of
Jagiellonian University, in accordance with the Decla-
ration of Helsinki.
Data acquisition
Neuroimaging data were collected using Siemens MAG-
NETOM Tim Trio 3T scanner with a 32-channel head
coil (Erlangen, Germany). Resting-state functional im-
ages covering the whole brain were acquired with a
gradient-echo planar imaging (EPI) sequence (33 ax-
ial slices in interleaved ascending order; repetition time
(TR) = 2190 ms; echo time (TE) = 30 ms, flip angle
= 90◦; field of view (FOV) = 192; matrix size = 64
× 64; slice thickness = 3.6 mm; voxel size = 3 × 3 ×
3.6 mm). During the 10-minute resting-state run, 282
volumes were obtained for each subject. Participants
were instructed to relax and focus on the fixation point
displayed on the screen. Communication with deaf sub-
jects in the scanner was provided in PJM via web-
cam video. High-resolution T1-weighted images were
acquired using a magnetization-prepared rapid acqui-
sition gradient echo (MPRAGE) sequence (176 slices;
TR = 2530 ms; TE = 3.32; flip angle = 7◦; FOV =
256; voxel size = 1 × 1 × 1 mm).
Data processing
Neuroimaging data were preprocessed using the SPM12
toolbox (Wellcome Department of Imaging Neuro-
science, Institute of Neurology, London, UK) running
on MATLAB 8.3 (R2014a) (Mathworks, Natick, MA).
First, resting-state functional
images were corrected
for acquisition time (slice-timing) and spatially re-
aligned to the mean image using rigid body registration.
Next, outlier scans with a mean signal higher than 3
SD and frame-displacement (FD) higher than 0.5 mm
were identified using the Artifact Detection Toolbox
(ART; http://www.nitrc.org/projects/artifact_
detect/). Only subjects with less than 10% of outlier
scans detected were included in the subsequent analy-
sis. There was no significant difference between the deaf
and the control group in the mean motion (t(39.85) = -
0.37; p = 0.71) and the number of outlier scans detected
(t(31.93) = -0.62; p = 0.54).
Then, the structural image was coregistered to the
first functional volume and functional images, gray mat-
ter, white matter (WM), and cerebrospinal fluid were
normalized to the MNI space (voxel size: 2 × 2 × 2
mm) using a unified normalization-segmentation algo-
rithm (Ashburner and Friston, 2005).
Further data processing for the purpose of func-
tional connectivity analysis was performed using the
CONN Functional Connectivity Toolbox v.
17.f
(Whitfield-Gabrieli and Nieto-Castanon, 2012) (http:
//www.nitrc.org/projects/conn/). The anatomical
component correction (aCompCor) strategy was used
to estimate and remove physiological noise (Behzadi
et al., 2007). The principal components of the subject-
specific WM, cerebrospinal fluid, as well as outlier
scans detected by the ART procedure and the six rigid-
body motion parameters (and their first level temporal
derivatives) were removed in covariate regression analy-
sis (Whitfield-Gabrieli and Nieto-Castanon, 2012). Fi-
nally, the resting-state time series were filtered using a
0.008 -- 0.09 Hz band-pass filter to remove the effect of
high-frequency noise and low-frequency drift.
Network construction
A brain parcellation containing 264 regions of interests
(ROIs) provided by functional neuroimaging data meta-
analysis (Power et al., 2011) was selected to construct
correlation matrices for the purpose of the whole-brain
network analysis. This brain parcellation was exten-
sively validated on other datasets and was used to di-
vide the 264 ROIs into 13 large-scale networks (LSNs)
(Power et al., 2011; Cole et al., 2014). Each ROI was
modeled as a 10 mm diameter sphere centered around
the coordinates listed by Power et al.
(Power et al.,
2011). Six ROIs (four cerebellar ROIs and two ROIs
covering the inferior temporal gyrus) were excluded
from analysis due to incomplete coverage of the brain
in some participants. Denoised functional time series
were extracted from the remaining ROIs and Pearson's
correlation coefficients were calculated for each pair of
regions. This resulted in one 258 × 258 correlation
matrix for each participant. Finally, Fisher's transfor-
mation was used to normalize Pearson's correlation co-
efficients into z-scores.
Edge-wise comparisons
We aimed to identify functional connections for which
the connection strength was either increased or de-
creased in the deaf group in comparison to the con-
trol group. We used a mass univariate approach by
independently testing each of the m = 33153 functional
connections for difference in connectivity strength be-
tween deaf and control subjects with a two-tailed t-
test. Then, we estimated associated p-values and cor-
rected with false discovery rate (FDR), using bootstrap
method with Nper = 10000 permutations (Genovese
et al., 2002).
3
Whole-brain graph measures
In order to determine if functional brain networks ex-
hibit different topological properties in hearing ver-
sus deaf subjects, for each participant we created a
weighted, undirected graph by proportionally thresh-
olding the functional connectivity matrix to retain the
top 10-25% functional connections (with a step of 5%).
Here we present the results for the remaining 25% of
connections. As graph metrics depend on network cost
(sum of connection strengths) (Rubinov and Sporns,
2011), we normalized them -- on a subject level -- against
a set of randomly rewired null networks (Maslov and
Sneppen, 2002). Specifically, for each functional net-
work we created 100 null networks with preserved size
and degree distribution, and random topology. Then, to
estimate null distributions of network metrics we calcu-
lated them for respective set of null networks. Finally,
we normalized each functional network metric by di-
viding it by the mean value of the corresponding null
distribution. We focused on two widely used graph met-
rics of network segregation and integration: modularity
and global efficiency. All graph measures were calcu-
lated using the Brain Connectivity Toolbox (Rubinov
and Sporns, 2010).
The modularity of a network quantifies the extent
to which it can be divided into modules.
Informally,
module is densely interconnected set of nodes sparsely
connected with the rest of the network (Newman, 2006).
For a weighted network, modularity is calculated by
maximizing the modularity quality function:
(Aij − sisj
v
)δmi,mj ,
ij
nodes i and j, v is the cost of the network v =(cid:80)
si =(cid:80)
where Aij is a weighted connection strength between
ij Aij,
i Aij is the strength of a node, and δmi,mj is the
Kronecker delta that equals 1 when nodes i and j be-
long to the same community and 0 otherwise. To find
the community structure by maximizing Q, we ran the
Louvain algorithm (Blondel et al., 2008) 100 times per
network, and considered the division that yielded the
highest modularity value.
Global efficiency Eglo enabled us to quantify a net-
work integration by measuring the length of short-
est paths between pairs of network nodes.
In a
weighted network the shortest path can be calculated
as the path with a smallest sum of inverse weights,
since the stronger connections are intuitively associated
with more efficient communication. Formally, weighted
global efficiency is given by:
(cid:88)
Q =
1
v
Eglo =
1
n(n − 1)
(dij)−1,
(cid:88)
(cid:88)
j,j(cid:54)=i
i
where dij is shortest weighted path length between
i and j.
4
To test whether graph metrics differ between
deaf and hearing groups we used the non-parametric
Wilcoxon rank sum test (Wilcoxon, 1945).
Large-scale brain networks
To assess more general differences of the large-scale
brain systems between hearing and deaf participants
we examined the modular structure of the functional
networks in both groups. For each group, we created
a single representative network by averaging connec-
tion strengths across subjects. To eliminate insignif-
icant connections in each group-averaged connection
matrix we calculated the significance of the connection
strength against zero. Assessed p-values were corrected
using the false discovery rate (FDR) method for both
groups separately (Genovese et al., 2002). Connections
that survived thresholding, i.e.
those with pF DR <
0.05, were retained in the group-averaged connection
matrix. Next, to establish a representative modular
structure, we ran the Louvain algorithm 1,000 times for
both group-averaged networks and considered runs that
produced divisions with the highest modularity value.
Finally, we compared the modular structure in the deaf
and hearing group with the large-scale network division
revealed by resting-state meta-analysis (Power et al.,
2011; Cole et al., 2014).
In order to quantify our findings, we calculated the
overlap coefficient between empirically found modules
and well-known large-scale brain systems. Overlap co-
efficient is a measure of similarity between two overlap-
ping sets. Here, as sets we consider subsets of nodes
grouped together in large-scale module. Formally, for
two sets A and B overlap coefficient is given as
overlap(A, B) =
A ∩ B
min(X ,Y )
,
where · denotes the number of elements of the set.
Note that the overlap coefficient equals one for every
pair of sets that A ⊆ B or B ⊆ A.
RESULTS
Edge-wise whole-brain differences between the
deaf and hearing
We compared the strength of all pairwise functional
connections (edges) between 258 ROIs in the deaf ver-
sus the control group. These comparisons revealed 10
weaker and 5 stronger connections in early-deaf adults
(Fig. 1, FDR corrected p < 0.05). Weaker connections
in the deaf relative to the controls were found mostly be-
tween the auditory and somatomotor networks, as well
as between the visual network and regions not assigned
to any large-scale networks. Interestingly, stronger con-
nections in the deaf were found between regions be-
yond the auditory network. These included two en-
hanced connections between the default mode network
and the subcortical network. Enhanced connections
were also found between the fronto-parietal and default-
mode networks, between the fronto-parietal and visual
networks and between the memory and somatomotor
networks (see Fig. 1b for edge counts after large-scale
network assignment).
Differences in whole-brain graph measures
Functional brain network topology is believed to sup-
port an optimal balance between functional segrega-
tion and integration enabling complex network dynam-
ics (Tononi et al., 1994). These two network features
can be captured using two graph theory measures:
modularity index for segregation (Newman, 2006) and
global efficiency for integration (Latora and Marchiori,
2001). Here, we tested whether these measures differ
between deaf and hearing subjects (Fig. S1). Anal-
ysis performed on brain graphs parcellated with 258
functional ROIs revealed significant differences in net-
work modularity (z − val = -2.36; p = 0.019, Wilcoxon
rank sum test, see Methods) between the two groups.
Whole-brain modularity was lower in deaf participants
(Qdeaf =3.50; std(Qdeaf ) = 0.31) than in hearing partic-
ipants (Qcontrol = 3.65; std(Qcontrol) = 0.14 Wilcoxon
rank sum test). A significant difference in modularity
was also observed for functional networks constructed
for all threshold values (p < 0.05). The difference in
functional network integration measured as global effi-
ciency (z − val = 1.26; p = 0.21, Wilcoxon rank sum
test) was not significant. Taken together, these re-
sults imply that functional brain networks in early-deaf
adults are less segregated than those in hearing adults.
Group-average modular organization
In the analysis that followed we assessed the modu-
lar division of the group-averaged networks using a
data-driven approach(Blondel et al., 2008) (see Meth-
ods). We found that for both groups this approach
returned a connectivity structure arranged into four
large-scale functional modules (Fig. 3, Fig. S1): the
fronto-parietal (FP) module, the multi-system (MS)
the default mode module (DM) and the visual mod-
ule (VIS). In both groups we then analyzed the overlap
of these four modules with 13 well-known large-scale
networks (LSNs) that were defined a priori based on
meta-analyses (Power et al., 2011; Cole et al., 2014))
(Fig. 3) by calculating an overlap coefficient between
the data-driven modules and all 13 LSNs.
In this
analysis, an overlap coefficient of 100% means that a
given network (for example, the somatomotor network)
is completely included in a given module (for exam-
ple, the multi-system module). The first module, the
fronto-parietal module, consisted mostly of regions from
the fronto-parietal network (overlap in the deaf group
(X f p
deaf , X f p) = 100%; overlap in the control group
(X f p
control, X f p) = 96%). This module had a signifi-
cantly different composition in the deaf as compared to
the control group. In the deaf, the salience network was
associated almost exclusively with the fronto-parietal
network within the fronto-parietal module (overlap in
the deaf group (X f p
deaf , X sal) = 72.2%). In the hear-
ing group, however, the fronto-parietal module made
only a small contribution to the salience network nodes
(overlap in the control group (X f p
control, X sal) = 22.2%),
which turned out to be predominantly associated with
the multisystem module (Fig. 3, black). The second
module (referred to here as the multi-system module)
was the largest and most diverse module (X ms
deaf =
78; X ms
deaf = 99). In the control group, it was com-
posed of the somatomotor, salience, auditory, cingulo-
opercular, ventral-attention, subcortical and cerebel-
lum nodes (overlap > 66%). In the deaf group, however,
this module did not include the salience and ventral-
deaf , X sal) = 5.5%; over-
attention networks (overlap(X ms
lap (X ms
deaf , X va) = 11.1%) which were associated with
other modules, i.e. the salience network with the fronto-
parietal module, and the ventral attentional network
with the default mode module. The third module,
the default mode module, had a very high overlap
with the default mode network (overlap in the deaf
deaf , X dmn) = 93%, overlap in the control
group (X dm
group (X dm
control, X dm) = 93%).
It consisted of 75
nodes in the deaf group and 66 nodes in the control
group. The default mode module was larger in the deaf
group as a result of large contribution from the ventral-
attention (overlap the deaf group (X dm
deaf ,Xva) = 66.7%)
and memory network nodes (overlap in the deaf group
(X dm
deaf ,X mem) = 60%), which, as mentioned previously,
in the hearing group were mostly part of the multi-
system module. The last module, the visual module,
deaf ,
was the most consistent in both groups (overlap(X vis
control = 45). In
control) = 88.6%; X vis
X vis
both groups it was composed primarily from visual net-
work nodes. In agreement with the previous modularity
analysis, we also found that the group-averaged func-
tional network was less modular in the deaf group than
in the hearing group (Qdeaf−av = 0.4571; Qcontrol−av
= 0.4748).
deaf = 44; X vis
DISCUSSION
In this study we investigated the whole-brain func-
tional organization differences between early-deaf and
hearing adults. Deaf adults exhibited weaker connec-
tion strengths, especially between the auditory and the
somatomotor networks. Besides changes in the func-
tional connectivity of auditory regions, we also found
pronounced connectivity differences between regions lo-
cated outside of the auditory system. These differ-
ences included a stronger functional connectivity be-
tween the fronto-parietal network and other large-scale
5
Figure 1: Edge-wise functional network differences visualized (A) in brain space and (B) as a chord diagram. (A) Connections that
are significantly stronger (red) or weaker (blue) in deaf adults. Edge thickness reflects t-test statistic strength. (B) Chord diagram
representing the number of significant edges between different large-scale networks. Red bands represent edges with stronger functional
connectivity in the deaf compared to hearing control, while blue bands represent edges with weaker functional connectivity.
Figure 2: Differences in graph measures of cortical segregation and integration between deaf adults and the control group. (A) Dif-
ference in network segregation measured as modularity. (B) Difference in network integration measured as global efficiency. Boxplots
represent topological values calculated for 25% threshold. *p < 0.05
6
B Uncertain (UNC)Auditory (AU)Default Mode (DM)Fronto-Parietal (FP)Memory (MEM)Somato-Motor (SOM)Subcortical (SUB)Ventral Attention (VA)Visual (VIS)Deaf < ControlEdges:Large-scale networks:Deaf > ControlA*AB Figure 3: An alluvial diagram representing the segregation of group-averaged networks using a data-driven approach in the deaf (left
side of the diagram) and the control group (right side of the diagram). This segregation is then compared against an a priori segregation
into 13 well-known networks based on meta-analysis studies Power et al. (2011), shown in the middle column and described in the
right-hand side legend. Note that salience nodes (black) are part of the fronto-parietal (FP) module in the deaf group but fall into the
multi-system (MS) module in the control group. In addition, the ventral-attention nodes (dark green) are part of the MS module in
the control group, but in the deaf group they are part of the default mode module (DM). The composition of the last, visual module
(VIS) is highly consistent in both groups.
networks (salience, visual, memory, cingulo-opercular
and somatomotor, default mode) and between the de-
fault mode and the subcortical network in deaf adults.
Using graph theoretical measures, we showed that deaf
adults had a less segregated (modular) network. We
also found different modular organization of functional
networks in deaf subjects. Differences were pronounced
for the salience and ventral-attention systems:
in the
control group they were part of a multi-system mod-
ule, but in the deaf they were coupled with the fronto-
parietal and default-mode modules. These results sug-
gest that compensatory brain plasticity in sensory loss
is a combination of changes in the sensory-deprived
brain areas themselves and changes beyond this in non-
deprived brain areas.
Reduced functional connectivity between
auditory and somatomotor areas
In the deaf, we observed reduced functional connectiv-
ity between auditory and somatomotor areas (Fig. 1).
Previous results showed cross-modal plasticity of the
auditory cortex and its engagement in tactile (Auer Jr
et al., 2007; Levänen et al., 1998; Karns et al., 2012)
and visual processing (Petitto et al., 2000; Finney et al.,
2001, 2003; Scott et al., 2014; Dewey and Hartley, 2015;
Bola et al., 2017). One may intuitively expect that this
cross-modal plasticity could be expressed in enhanced
functional connections between the auditory and so-
matomotor networks. However, functional connectivity
results are not always consistent with results of task-
based fMRI studies, and these two approaches might
reveal different properties of brain organization (Grat-
ton et al., 2016; Khambhati et al., 2017). While task-
related activations of the auditory cortex in deaf indi-
viduals or the visual cortex in blind individuals dur-
ing tactile processing were consistently found in previ-
ous studies (Levänen et al., 1998; Karns et al., 2012;
Held et al., 1996; Sadato et al., 1998; Auer Jr et al.,
2007), none of the existing functional connectivity stud-
ies have reported increased connectivity between the
somatomotor cortex and sensorially deprived areas in
deaf or blind individuals (Liu et al., 2007; Burton et al.,
2014; Ding et al., 2016; Li et al., 2016). Moreover,
some studies have demonstrated that blind individu-
als have weakened functional connections between the
visual and somatosensory and motor networks, which is
strongly consistent with our results on deaf individuals
(Liu et al., 2007). Recent evidence revealed a very sim-
ilar effect of weakened connectivity between somatomo-
tor and deprived auditory cortices in deaf cats (Butler
et al., 2018). Liu and colleagues (Liu et al., 2007) inter-
preted their finding of weakened connectivity between
sensory deprived areas and the somatomotor network in
terms of general loss hypothesis (Pascual-Leone et al.,
2005). According to this hypothesis, the functional or-
ganization of the sensory deprived brain may be gen-
erally disrupted because of the lack of sensory input.
However, many studies on early sensory deprivation do
not support this notion (Bavelier and Neville, 2002;
Merabet et al., 2005) (Théoret et al., 2004; Pascual-
Leone et al., 2005). Here, we propose a different expla-
nation for our findings in terms of the neural efficiency
hypothesis (Neubauer and Fink, 2009). According to
this hypothesis, less engagement of certain brain ar-
eas during task processing may indicate that the task
is performed more automatically, with less energy con-
7
DeafVISDMMSFPReferenceControlVISDMMSFPUncertain (UNC)Cerebellar (CER)Auditory (AU)Cingulo-Opercular (CO)Default Mode (DM)Dorsal Attention (DA)Fronto-Parietal (FP)Memory (MEM)Salience (SA)Somato-Motor (SOM)Subcortical (SUB)Ventral Attention (VA)Visual (VIS) sumption.
In the context of functional connectivity,
learning a new skill can be associated with a reduced
connectivity between areas associated with the trained
domain (Kelly and Castellanos, 2014; Bassett et al.,
2015; Yoo et al., 2013; Wang et al., 2016). For ex-
ample, Yoo et al.(Yoo et al., 2013) reported decreased
functional connectivity between the parietal cortex and
the motor system after 8 weeks of practicing using chop-
sticks with a non-dominant hand. Bassett et al. (Bas-
sett et al., 2015) found that training of a visuomotor
task is associated with reduced connectivity between
the visual and motor networks, suggesting that these
systems are autonomous in relation to task automatiza-
tion. Also, Wang et al. (Wang et al., 2016) reported re-
duced functional connectivity of the somatomotor sys-
tem in world-class gymnasts. In the case of deaf indi-
viduals, the trained skill may be related to the use of
sign language to communicate and to superior tactile
processing. Taken together, the reduced functional con-
nectivity between the auditory and somatomotor areas
in early-deaf adults may be linked to more efficient, au-
tomated sensorimotor processing rather than a general
loss of connectivity.
Increased fronto-parietal connectivity in
deafness
Besides the connectivity decreases outlined above, deaf
subjects exhibited strengthened interconnections, no-
tably with the frontoparietal system. Edge-wise analy-
sis revealed an increased coupling between the fronto-
parietal network and visual areas (Fig. 1). This cou-
pling might support the higher need for visual atten-
tion resources in the deaf. While deaf subjects con-
sistently outperform hearing subjects in several visual
tasks (Scott et al., 2014; Dewey and Hartley, 2015) this
occurs almost exclusively under conditions of high at-
tentional load (Heimler et al., 2017). We speculate that
enhanced connectivity between the sensory and fronto-
parietal networks may provide the neural basis for vi-
sual compensation mechanisms. The altered functional
role of the fronto-parietal system and the enhanced
visual -- fronto-parietal interconnections may constitute
the neural basis for the congenitally deaf's superior per-
formance in both sensory attention and visual working
memory.
Decreased modularity of functional networks in
deafness
Modularity of whole-brain functional networks was
lower in deaf subjects compared to hearing controls,
thus indicating disrupted boundaries between function-
ally specialized systems following early deafness (Fig.
S1). Our findings provide the first evidence of an al-
tered modular organization of functional networks in
sensory deprived subjects. Several studies reported dis-
rupted modular organization associated with healthy
aging (Song et al., 2012; Geerligs et al., 2014), adoles-
cence (Fair et al., 2009), childhood-onset schizophre-
nia (Alexander-Bloch et al., 2010) and autism spec-
trum disorder (Rudie et al., 2013). Other studies
reported increased modularity in patients with ma-
jor depressive disorder (Ye et al., 2015) or attention-
deficit/hyperactivity disorder (Lin et al., 2014). Here,
for the first time we show that sensory deprivation may
reduce modularity at the global brain network level.
These results suggest that sensory deprivation can lead
to a blurring of the lines between specialized brain sub-
systems, while network integration (measured as global
efficiency) remaining at the same level as in normally
developing individuals.
Coupling of salience and fronto-parietal
networks in deafness
Our study found that that the salience network was as-
sociated with the fronto-parietal network in the deaf
group, but not in the control group. Consistently with
our results,
in congenitally and early blind subjects
the salience network has previously been shown to ex-
hibit stronger resting-state functional connectivity with
fronto-parietal regions than in the sighted population
(Wang et al., 2014). The effect revealed in our study
may thus be a general consequence of early sensory de-
privation.
The salience network is responsible for identifying
behaviorally important stimuli, forwarding them to the
executive functions network, and mediating higher or-
der cognitive processes (Seeley et al., 2007). Its func-
tional association with fronto-parietal structures plays
a role in working memory processing. Activity of the
salience network is gradually enhanced with increased
working memory load, and this enhancement corre-
lates positively with working memory task performance
(Liang et al., 2015). It can be therefore inferred that its
strengthened association with the fronto-parietal mod-
ule in deafness reflects the enhanced working memory
abilities reported in early sensory deprivation.
In line with this interpretation, task-based studies
reveal the specifically important role the salience net-
work can play in deafness for working-memory-related
functions. When compared with the hearing, deaf sub-
jects recruit the salience network more strongly for
short-term verbal memory tasks (Bavelier et al., 2008)
and exhibit stronger functional connectivity between
salience and auditory structures when processing a vi-
sual working memory task (Ding et al., 2016). Addi-
tionally, deaf subjects have increased gray and white
matter within the salience network (Allen et al., 2008),
and this structural reinforcement has been suggested to
contribute to sign language processing (Kassubek et al.,
2004).
8
Altered connectivity of default mode network
in deafness
Our results show differences in the default mode net-
work (DMN) connectivity in the deaf. Whole-brain
network analysis revealed that in the deaf the DMN
has strengthened connections with the subcortical net-
work and the fronto-parietal network, and a weakened
connection with the visual system (Fig. 1). Moreover,
we found that the default mode module in the deaf in-
cludes the ventral attention system. In the hearing, in
contrast, the ventral attention system is coupled with
the multi-system module (Fig. 3).
The exact role of the DMN is debatable. Some stud-
ies provide evidence that it is associated with internally
directed cognitive processing such as mind-wandering
or autobiographical memory (Buckner et al., 2008).
The DMN is also often referred to as a task-negative
network due to its anticorrelation with networks related
to attentional processing (Fox et al., 2005). However, a
new wave of research provides evidence for an integra-
tive role of the DMN which may be crucial for higher
cognitive functions (Vatansever et al., 2015; Margulies
et al., 2016; Finc et al., 2017)).
In line with this re-
search, stronger connectivity between the DMN and the
subcortical and fronto-parietal networks may suggest
that the DMN is engaged in network integration that
is necessary to compensate for sensory deficits.
The ventral attention system is typically recruited
by infrequent or unexpected events that are behav-
iorally relevant, and has been implicated in stimulus-
driven, involuntary attentional control (Corbetta and
Shulman, 2002). Therefore, it is plausible that its closer
association with the DMN in the deaf corresponds to an
easier and faster transition between resting state and
the action in response to the unexpected input. The
ability to shift quickly from rest to action seems to be
particularly adaptive in an environment lacking audi-
tory input, as one must deal with a constrained field of
view and higher latency in response time for vision.
Compensatory mechanisms lead deaf people to out-
perform hearing individuals in certain visual tasks, es-
pecially when the location or the exact time of the on-
set of the stimulus is unknown (Bavelier et al., 2006),
or when the stimulus appears outside the central visual
field. The lack of auditory signal is compensated for in
the deaf by enhanced peripheral visual attention (Lore
and Song, 1991; Neville and Lawson, 1987; Stevens and
Neville, 2006). These effects make deaf subjects more
distractible by peripheral visual input (Proksch and
Bavelier, 2002), which may enable them to detect un-
expected stimulus more quickly and respond to unpre-
dicted cues in sign language. On the more general level,
deaf subjects manifest consistently lower response time
to visual input across a variety of visual tasks (Pavani
and Bottari, 2012). The enhanced coupling between
resting-state DMN and the ventral attention system in
the deaf could thus reflect their general higher reactiv-
ity to visual stimuli in deafness as well as more specific
capacities in visual attention.
Overall, our results show substantial differences
in the functional brain network organization between
early-deaf and hearing adults. We have shown that
deaf adults have reduced coupling between the auditory
and the visual cortex. However, we also found mul-
tiple differences in functional connectivity beyond the
auditory network, including the fronto-parietal, default-
mode and salience networks. These results suggest that
changes in brain connections related to sensory depriva-
tion are not limited to the deprived cortices, but mani-
fest themselves in altered connectivity across the entire
brain network.
Acknowledgements
Study supported by National Science Centre grants no
2015/19/B/HS6/01256 and 2016/21/B/HS6/03703 to
M. S., P. M. and P. R. were supported under the Na-
tional Programme for the Development of Humanities
of the Polish Ministry of Science and Higher Education
(0111/NPRH3/H12/82/2014). K. F. was supported by
National Science Centre (2017/24/T/HS6/00105) and
and Foundation for Polish Science, Poland (START
23.2018). The study was conducted with the aid
of CePT research infrastructure purchased with funds
from the European Regional Development Fund as part
of the Innovative Economy Operational Programme,
2007 -- 2013. We thank Karolina Dukała for administra-
tive assistance, and Michael Timberlake for language
editing.
Author contributions statement
K.B. and K.F. analyzed data; K.B., K.F, M.Z., and
M.S. wrote manuscript; Ł.B., M.Z., and M.S. designed
research and Ł.B., M.Z., P.M., K.J., A.M., P.R., and
M.S. performed research; W.D. reviewed manuscript.
Additional information
Data availability
The datasets generated and analysed during the cur-
rent study are available from the corresponding author
on request.
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
References
Alexander-Bloch, A. F., Gogtay, N., Meunier, D., Birn,
R., Clasen, L., Lalonde, F., Lenroot, R., Giedd, J.,
and Bullmore, E. T. (2010). Disrupted modularity
9
and local connectivity of brain functional networks
in childhood-onset schizophrenia. Frontiers in Sys-
tems Neuroscience, 4:147.
Bedny, M. (2017). Evidence from blindness for a cog-
nitively pluripotent cortex. Trends in Cognitive Sci-
ences, 21(9):637 -- 648.
Alho, K., Kujala, T., Paavilainen, P., Summala, H.,
and Näätänen, R. (1993). Auditory processing in vi-
sual brain areas of the early blind: evidence from
event-related potentials. Electroencephalography and
Clinical Neurophysiology, 86(6):418 -- 427.
Allen, J. S., Emmorey, K., Bruss, J., and Damasio, H.
(2008). Morphology of the insula in relation to hear-
ing status and sign language experience. Journal of
Neuroscience, 28(46):11900 -- 11905.
Amedi, A., Raz, N., Pianka, P., Malach, R., and Zo-
hary, E. (2003). Early 'visual'cortex activation cor-
relates with superior verbal memory performance in
the blind. Nature Neuroscience, 6(7):758.
Armstrong, B. A., Neville, H. J., Hillyard, S. A., and
Mitchell, T. V. (2002). Auditory deprivation affects
processing of motion, but not color. Cognitive Brain
Research, 14(3):422 -- 434.
Ashburner, J. and Friston, K. J. (2005). Unified seg-
mentation. NeuroImage, 26(3):839 -- 851.
Auer Jr, E. T., Bernstein, L. E., Sungkarat, W., and
Singh, M. (2007). Vibrotactile activation of the audi-
tory cortices in deaf versus hearing adults. Neurore-
port, 18(7):645.
Bassett, D. S., Yang, M., Wymbs, N. F., and Grafton,
S. T. (2015). Learning-induced autonomy of sensori-
motor systems. Nature Neuroscience, 18(5):744.
Bavelier, D., Brozinsky, C., Tomann, A., Mitchell, T.,
Neville, H., and Liu, G. (2001). Impact of early deaf-
ness and early exposure to sign language on the cere-
bral organization for motion processing. Journal of
Neuroscience, 21(22):8931 -- 8942.
Bavelier, D., Dye, M. W., and Hauser, P. C. (2006).
Do deaf individuals see better? Trends in Cognitive
Sciences, 10(11):512 -- 518.
Bavelier, D. and Neville, H. J. (2002). Cross-modal
plasticity: where and how? Nature Reviews Neuro-
science, 3(6):443.
Bavelier, D., Newport, E. L., Hall, M., Supalla, T., and
Boutla, M. (2008). Ordered short-term memory dif-
fers in signers and speakers: Implications for models
of short-term memory. Cognition, 107(2):433 -- 459.
Bavelier, D., Tomann, A., Hutton, C., Mitchell, T., Co-
rina, D., Liu, G., and Neville, H. (2000). Visual atten-
tion to the periphery is enhanced in congenitally deaf
individuals. Journal of Neuroscience, 20(17):RC931 --
6.
Bedny, M., Pascual-Leone, A., Dodell-Feder, D., Fe-
dorenko, E., and Saxe, R. (2011). Language pro-
cessing in the occipital cortex of congenitally blind
adults. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sci-
ences, 108(11):4429 -- 4434.
Bedny, M., Richardson, H., and Saxe, R. (2015). "vi-
sual" cortex responds to spoken language in blind
children.
Journal of Neuroscience, 35(33):11674 --
11681.
Behzadi, Y., Restom, K., Liau, J., and Liu, T. T.
(2007). A component based noise correction method
(compcor) for bold and perfusion based fmri. Neu-
roImage, 37(1):90 -- 101.
Biswal, B., Zerrin Yetkin, F., Haughton, V. M., and
Hyde, J. S. (1995). Functional connectivity in the mo-
tor cortex of resting human brain using echo-planar
mri. Magnetic Resonance in Medicine, 34(4):537 --
541.
Blondel, V. D., Guillaume, J.-L., Lambiotte, R., and
Lefebvre, E. (2008). Fast unfolding of communities
in large networks. Journal of Statistical Mechanics:
Theory and Experiment, 2008(10):P10008.
Bola, Ł., Zimmermann, M., Mostowski, P., Jednoróg,
K., Marchewka, A., Rutkowski, P., and Szwed, M.
(2017). Task-specific reorganization of the auditory
cortex in deaf humans. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences, 114(4):E600 -- E609.
Buckner, R. L., Andrews-Hanna, J. R., and Schacter,
D. L. (2008). The brain's default network. Annals of
the New York Academy of Sciences, 1124(1):1 -- 38.
Burton, H. (2003). Visual cortex activity in early
Journal of Neuroscience,
and late blind people.
23(10):4005 -- 4011.
Burton, H., McLaren, D., and Sinclair, R. (2006). Read-
ing embossed capital letters: an fmri study in blind
and sighted individuals. Human Brain Mapping,
27(4):325 -- 339.
Burton, H., Snyder, A. Z., Conturo, T. E., Akbudak, E.,
Ollinger, J. M., and Raichle, M. E. (2002). Adaptive
changes in early and late blind: a fmri study of braille
reading. Journal of Neurophysiology, 87(1):589 -- 607.
Burton, H., Snyder, A. Z., and Raichle, M. E. (2014).
Resting state functional connectivity in early blind
humans. Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience, 8:51.
10
Butler, B. E., de la Rua, A., Ward-Able, T., and
Lomber, S. G. (2018). Cortical and thalamic con-
nectivity to the second auditory cortex of the cat is
resilient to the onset of deafness. Brain Structure and
Function, 223(2):819 -- 835.
Capek, C. M., MacSweeney, M., Woll, B., Waters,
D., McGuire, P. K., David, A. S., Brammer, M. J.,
and Campbell, R. (2008). Cortical circuits for silent
speechreading in deaf and hearing people. Neuropsy-
chologia, 46(5):1233 -- 1241.
Chen, M. and Deem, M. W. (2015). Development of
modularity in the neural activity of children's brains.
Physical biology, 12(1):016009.
Cole, M. W., Bassett, D. S., Power, J. D., Braver, T. S.,
and Petersen, S. E. (2014). Intrinsic and task-evoked
network architectures of the human brain. Neuron,
83(1):238 -- 251.
Corbetta, M. and Shulman, G. L. (2002). Control
of goal-directed and stimulus-driven attention in the
brain. Nature reviews neuroscience, 3(3):201.
Dewey, R. S. and Hartley, D. E. (2015). Cortical cross-
modal plasticity following deafness measured using
functional near-infrared spectroscopy. Hearing Re-
search, 325:55 -- 63.
Ding, H., Ming, D., Wan, B., Li, Q., Qin, W., and Yu,
C. (2016). Enhanced spontaneous functional connec-
tivity of the superior temporal gyrus in early deaf-
ness. Scientific Reports, 6:23239.
Ding, H., Qin, W., Liang, M., Ming, D., Wan, B., Li,
Q., and Yu, C. (2015). Cross-modal activation of au-
ditory regions during visuo-spatial working memory
in early deafness. Brain, 138(9):2750 -- 2765.
Elbert, T., Sterr, A., Rockstroh, B., Pantev, C., Müller,
M. M., and Taub, E. (2002). Expansion of the tono-
topic area in the auditory cortex of the blind. Journal
of Neuroscience, 22(22):9941 -- 9944.
Emmorey, K., Allen, J. S., Bruss, J., Schenker, N.,
and Damasio, H. (2003). A morphometric analysis
of auditory brain regions in congenitally deaf adults.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,
100(17):10049 -- 10054.
Fair, D. A., Cohen, A. L., Power, J. D., Dosenbach,
N. U., Church, J. A., Miezin, F. M., Schlaggar, B. L.,
and Petersen, S. E. (2009). Functional brain net-
works develop from a "local to distributed" organiza-
tion. PLoS Computational Biology, 5(5):e1000381.
Finc, K., Bonna, K., Lewandowska, M., Wolak, T.,
Nikadon, J., Dreszer, J., Duch, W., and Kühn, S.
(2017). Transition of the functional brain network re-
lated to increasing cognitive demands. Human brain
mapping, 38(7):3659 -- 3674.
Finney, E. M., Clementz, B. A., Hickok, G., and
Dobkins, K. R. (2003). Visual stimuli activate au-
ditory cortex in deaf subjects: evidence from meg.
Neuroreport, 14(11):1425 -- 1427.
Finney, E. M., Fine, I., and Dobkins, K. R. (2001).
Visual stimuli activate auditory cortex in the deaf.
Nature Neuroscience, 4(12):1171.
Fortin, M., Voss, P., Lord, C., Lassonde, M., Pruessner,
J., Saint-Amour, D., Rainville, C., and Lepore, F.
(2008). Wayfinding in the blind: larger hippocampal
volume and supranormal spatial navigation. Brain,
131(11):2995 -- 3005.
Fox, M. D., Snyder, A. Z., Vincent, J. L., Corbetta, M.,
Van Essen, D. C., and Raichle, M. E. (2005). The
human brain is intrinsically organized into dynamic,
anticorrelated functional networks. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences, 102(27):9673 -- 9678.
Friston, K., Frith, C., Liddle, P., and Frackowiak,
R. (1993). Functional connectivity: the principal-
component analysis of large (pet) data sets. Journal
of Cerebral Blood Flow & Metabolism, 13(1):5 -- 14.
Geerligs, L., Renken, R. J., Saliasi, E., Maurits, N. M.,
and Lorist, M. M. (2014). A brain-wide study of age-
related changes in functional connectivity. Cerebral
Cortex, 25(7):1987 -- 1999.
Genovese, C. R., Lazar, N. A., and Nichols, T. (2002).
Thresholding of statistical maps in functional neu-
roimaging using the false discovery rate. NeuroImage,
15(4):870 -- 878.
Gratton, C., Laumann, T. O., Gordon, E. M.,
Adeyemo, B., and Petersen, S. E. (2016). Evidence
for two independent factors that modify brain net-
works to meet task goals. Cell reports, 17(5):1276 --
1288.
He, Y. and Evans, A. (2010). Graph theoretical mod-
eling of brain connectivity. Current Opinion in Neu-
rology, 23(4):341 -- 350.
Heimler, B., Baruffaldi, F., Bonmassar, C., Venturini,
M., and Pavani, F. (2017). Multisensory interference
in early deaf adults. The Journal of Deaf Studies and
Deaf Education, 22(4):422 -- 433.
Held, R., Freedman, S., and Harris, C. (1996). Activa-
tion of the primary visual cortex by braille reading
in blind subjects. Nature, 380:11.
11
Jiang, J., Zhu, W., Shi, F., Liu, Y., Li, J., Qin, W.,
Li, K., Yu, C., and Jiang, T. (2009). Thick visual
cortex in the early blind. Journal of Neuroscience,
29(7):2205 -- 2211.
Lessard, N., Paré, M., Lepore, F., and Lassonde,
Early-blind human subjects localize
M. (1998).
sound sources better than sighted subjects. Nature,
395(6699):278.
Kanjlia, S., Lane, C., Feigenson, L., and Bedny, M.
(2016). Absence of visual experience modifies the
neural basis of numerical thinking. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences, 113(40):11172 -- 11177.
Levänen, S., Jousmäki, V., and Hari, R. (1998).
Vibration-induced auditory-cortex activation in a
congenitally deaf adult. Current Biology, 8(15):869 --
872.
Karns, C. M., Dow, M. W., and Neville, H. J. (2012).
Altered cross-modal processing in the primary au-
ditory cortex of congenitally deaf adults: a visual-
somatosensory fmri study with a double-flash illu-
sion. Journal of Neuroscience, 32(28):9626 -- 9638.
Kassubek, J., Hickok, G., and Erhard, P. (2004). In-
volvement of classical anterior and posterior language
areas in sign language production, as investigated by
4 t functional magnetic resonance imaging. Neuro-
science letters, 364(3):168 -- 172.
Kelly, C. and Castellanos, F. X. (2014). Strengthening
connections: functional connectivity and brain plas-
ticity. Neuropsychology Review, 24(1):63 -- 76.
Khambhati, A. N., Sizemore, A. E., Betzel, R. F., and
Bassett, D. S. (2017). Modeling and interpreting
mesoscale network dynamics. NeuroImage.
Kujala, T., Lehtokoski, A., Alho, K., Kekoni, J., and
Näätänen, R. (1997). Faster reaction times in the
blind than sighted during bimodal divided attention.
Acta psychologica, 96(1-2):75 -- 82.
Kujala, T., Palva, M. J., Salonen, O., Alku, P., Huoti-
lainen, M., Järvinen, A., and Näätänen, R. (2005).
The role of blind humans' visual cortex in auditory
change detection. Neuroscience Letters, 379(2):127 --
131.
Lane, C., Kanjlia, S., Omaki, A., and Bedny, M. (2015).
"visual" cortex of congenitally blind adults responds
to syntactic movement.
Journal of Neuroscience,
35(37):12859 -- 12868.
Latora, V. and Marchiori, M. (2001). Efficient behav-
ior of small-world networks. Physical review letters,
87(19):198701.
Leporé, N., Shi, Y., Lepore, F., Fortin, M., Voss, P.,
Chou, Y.-Y., Lord, C., Lassonde, M., Dinov, I. D.,
Toga, A. W., et al. (2009). Pattern of hippocampal
shape and volume differences in blind subjects. Neu-
roImage, 46(4):949 -- 957.
Leporé, N., Voss, P., Lepore, F., Chou, Y.-Y., Fortin,
M., Gougoux, F., Lee, A. D., Brun, C., Lassonde,
M., Madsen, S. K., et al. (2010). Brain structure
changes visualized in early-and late-onset blind sub-
jects. NeuroImage, 49(1):134 -- 140.
Li, W., Li, J., Wang, J., Zhou, P., Wang, Z., Xian,
J., and He, H. (2016). Functional reorganizations of
brain network in prelingually deaf adolescents. Neu-
ral Plasticity, 2016.
Liang, X., Zou, Q., He, Y., and Yang, Y. (2015).
Topologically reorganized connectivity architecture
of default-mode, executive-control, and salience net-
works across working memory task loads. Cerebral
Cortex, 26(4):1501 -- 1511.
Lin, P., Sun, J., Yu, G., Wu, Y., Yang, Y., Liang, M.,
and Liu, X. (2014). Global and local brain network
reorganization in attention-deficit/hyperactivity dis-
order. Brain Imaging and Behavior, 8(4):558 -- 569.
Liu, Y., Yu, C., Liang, M., Li, J., Tian, L., Zhou, Y.,
Qin, W., Li, K., and Jiang, T. (2007). Whole brain
functional connectivity in the early blind. Brain,
130(8):2085 -- 2096.
Lore, W. H. and Song, S. (1991). Central and peripheral
visual processing in hearing and nonhearing individ-
uals. Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society, 29(5):437 --
440.
MacSweeney, M., Calvert, G. A., Campbell, R.,
McGuire, P. K., David, A. S., Williams, S. C.,
Woll, B., and Brammer, M. J. (2002). Speechread-
ing circuits in people born deaf. Neuropsychologia,
40(7):801 -- 807.
MacSweeney, M., Campbell, R., Calvert, G. A.,
McGuire, P. K., David, A. S., Suckling, J., Andrew,
C., Woll, B., and Brammer, M. J. (2001). Dispersed
activation in the left temporal cortex for speech-
reading in congenitally deaf people. Proceedings of
the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences,
268(1466):451 -- 457.
Margulies, K. B., Hernandez, A. F., Redfield, M. M.,
Givertz, M. M., Oliveira, G. H., Cole, R., Mann,
D. L., Whellan, D. J., Kiernan, M. S., Felker, G. M.,
et al. (2016). Effects of liraglutide on clinical stabil-
ity among patients with advanced heart failure and
reduced ejection fraction: a randomized clinical trial.
Jama, 316(5):500 -- 508.
Maslov, S. and Sneppen, K. (2002). Specificity and
stability in topology of protein networks. Science,
296(5569):910 -- 913.
12
Merabet, L. B. and Pascual-Leone, A. (2010). Neu-
the op-
ral reorganization following sensory loss:
portunity of change. Nature Reviews Neuroscience,
11(1):44.
Merabet, L. B., Rizzo, J. F., Amedi, A., Somers, D. C.,
and Pascual-Leone, A. (2005). What blindness can
tell us about seeing again: merging neuroplasticity
and neuroprostheses. Nature Reviews Neuroscience,
6(1):71.
Nakamura, T., Hillary, F. G., and Biswal, B. B. (2009).
Resting network plasticity following brain injury.
PloS One, 4(12):e8220.
Neubauer, A. C. and Fink, A. (2009). Intelligence and
neural efficiency. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Re-
views, 33(7):1004 -- 1023.
Neville, H. J. and Lawson, D. (1987). Attention to cen-
tral and peripheral visual space in a movement de-
tection task: An event-related potential and behav-
ioral study. i. normal hearing adults. Brain Research,
405(2):253 -- 267.
Newman, M. E. (2006). Modularity and community
structure in networks. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences, 103(23):8577 -- 8582.
Nishimura, H., Hashikawa, K., Doi, K., Iwaki, T.,
Watanabe, Y., Kusuoka, H., Nishimura, T., and
Kubo, T. (1999). Sign language 'heard'in the au-
ditory cortex. Nature, 397(6715):116.
Pascual-Leone, A., Amedi, A., Fregni, F., and Merabet,
L. B. (2005). The plastic human brain cortex. Annu.
Rev. Neurosci., 28:377 -- 401.
Pavani, F. and Bottari, D. (2012). Visual abilities in
individuals with profound deafness a critical review.
The Neural Bases of Multisensory Processes.
Petitto, L. A., Zatorre, R. J., Gauna, K., Nikelski, E. J.,
Dostie, D., and Evans, A. C. (2000). Speech-like
cerebral activity in profoundly deaf people process-
ing signed languages: implications for the neural ba-
sis of human language. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences, 97(25):13961 -- 13966.
Power, J. D., Cohen, A. L., Nelson, S. M., Wig, G. S.,
Barnes, K. A., Church, J. A., Vogel, A. C., Laumann,
T. O., Miezin, F. M., Schlaggar, B. L., et al. (2011).
Functional network organization of the human brain.
Neuron, 72(4):665 -- 678.
Rauschecker, J. P., Tian, B., and Hauser, M. (1995).
Processing of complex sounds in the macaque nonpri-
mary auditory cortex. Science, 268(5207):111 -- 114.
Röder, B., Stock, O., Bien, S., Neville, H., and Rösler,
F. (2002). Speech processing activates visual cortex
in congenitally blind humans. European Journal of
Neuroscience, 16(5):930 -- 936.
Rubinov, M. and Sporns, O. (2010). Complex network
measures of brain connectivity: uses and interpreta-
tions. NeuroImage, 52(3):1059 -- 1069.
Rubinov, M. and Sporns, O. (2011). Weight-conserving
characterization of complex functional brain net-
works. NeuroImage, 56(4):2068 -- 2079.
Rudie, J. D., Brown, J., Beck-Pancer, D., Hernandez,
L., Dennis, E., Thompson, P., Bookheimer, S., and
Dapretto, M. (2013). Altered functional and struc-
tural brain network organization in autism. NeuroIm-
age: clinical, 2:79 -- 94.
Sadato, N., Pascual-Leone, A., Grafman, J., Deiber,
M.-P., Ibanez, V., and Hallett, M. (1998). Neural
networks for braille reading by the blind. Brain: a
Journal of Neurology, 121(7):1213 -- 1229.
Sadato, N., Yamada, H., Okada, T., Yoshida, M.,
Hasegawa, T., Matsuki, K.-I., Yonekura, Y., and
Itoh, H. (2004). Age-dependent plasticity in the su-
perior temporal sulcus in deaf humans: a functional
mri study. BMC neuroscience, 5(1):56.
Scott, G. D., Karns, C. M., Dow, M. W., Stevens, C.,
and Neville, H. J. (2014). Enhanced peripheral visual
processing in congenitally deaf humans is supported
by multiple brain regions, including primary auditory
cortex. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 8:177.
Seeley, W. W., Menon, V., Schatzberg, A. F., Keller, J.,
Glover, G. H., Kenna, H., Reiss, A. L., and Greicius,
M. D. (2007). Dissociable intrinsic connectivity net-
works for salience processing and executive control.
Journal of Neuroscience, 27(9):2349 -- 2356.
Song, J., Desphande, A. S., Meier, T. B., Tudorascu,
D. L., Vergun, S., Nair, V. A., Biswal, B. B.,
Meyerand, M. E., Birn, R. M., Bellec, P., et al.
(2012). Age-related differences in test-retest relia-
bility in resting-state brain functional connectivity.
PLoS One, 7(12):e49847.
Sporns, O. (2013). Network attributes for segregation
and integration in the human brain. Current Opinion
in Neurobiology, 23(2):162 -- 171.
Proksch, J. and Bavelier, D. (2002). Changes in the spa-
tial distribution of visual attention after early deaf-
ness. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 14(5):687 --
701.
Stevens, C. and Neville, H. (2006). Neuroplasticity
as a double-edged sword: Deaf enhancements and
dyslexic deficits in motion processing. Journal of
Cognitive Neuroscience, 18(5):701 -- 714.
13
Théoret, H., Merabet, L., and Pascual-Leone, A.
Behavioral and neuroplastic changes in
(2004).
the blind: evidence for functionally relevant cross-
modal
Journal of Physiology-Paris,
98(1-3):221 -- 233.
interactions.
Wang, J., Lu, M., Fan, Y., Wen, X., Zhang, R., Wang,
B., Ma, Q., Song, Z., He, Y., Wang, J., et al. (2016).
Exploring brain functional plasticity in world class
gymnasts: a network analysis. Brain Structure and
Function, 221(7):3503 -- 3519.
Tononi, G., Sporns, O., and Edelman, G. M. (1994).
A measure for brain complexity: relating functional
segregation and integration in the nervous system.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,
91(11):5033 -- 5037.
Van Den Heuvel, M. P. and Pol, H. E. H. (2010).
Exploring the brain network: a review on resting-
state fmri functional connectivity. European neu-
ropsychopharmacology, 20(8):519 -- 534.
Vatansever, D., Menon, D. K., Manktelow, A. E., Sa-
hakian, B. J., and Stamatakis, E. A. (2015). De-
fault mode dynamics for global functional integra-
tion. Journal of Neuroscience, 35(46):15254 -- 15262.
Wang, D., Qin, W., Liu, Y., Zhang, Y., Jiang, T., and
Yu, C. (2014). Altered resting-state network con-
nectivity in congenital blind. Human brain mapping,
35(6):2573 -- 2581.
Whitfield-Gabrieli, S. and Nieto-Castanon, A. (2012).
Conn: a functional connectivity toolbox for corre-
lated and anticorrelated brain networks. Brain Con-
nectivity, 2(3):125 -- 141.
Wilcoxon, F. (1945). Individual comparisons by rank-
ing methods. Biometrics Bulletin, 1(6):80 -- 83.
Ye, M., Yang, T., Qing, P., Lei, X., Qiu, J., and Liu, G.
(2015). Changes of functional brain networks in ma-
jor depressive disorder: a graph theoretical analysis
of resting-state fmri. PloS One, 10(9):e0133775.
Yoo, K., Sohn, W. S., and Jeong, Y. (2013). Tool-
use practice induces changes in intrinsic functional
connectivity of parietal areas. Frontiers in Human
Neuroscience, 7:49.
14
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
Table S1. Characteristics of deaf participants.
SubID
Sex
Age
Cause of
deafness
Hearing loss
(left
ear/right
ear/mean)
Hearing
aid use
How well the
subject
understands
speech with
hearing aid
Native
language
(oral/sign)
Lan-
guages
primarily
used at
the
moment
of the ex-
periment
Sub01
Sub02
Sub04
Sub05
Sub06
Sub07
Sub08
F
M
M
M
M
F
F
Sub09
M
Sub10
Sub14
Sub17
F
F
F
Sub18
M
Sub19
Sub20
Sub21
F
F
F
30
27
23
27
27
27
27
27
32
32
19
27
30
25
37
Hereditary
deafness
Maternal
disease/
drug side
effect
Hereditary
deafness
Hereditary
deafness
Hereditary
deafness
Hereditary
deafness
Hereditary
deafness
Hereditary
deafness
Hereditary
deafness
Maternal
disease/
drug side
effect
Hereditary
deafness
Hereditary
deafness
Hereditary
deafness
Hereditary
deafness
Maternal
disease/
drug side
effect
110/90/100
dB
Uses
currently
120/90/105
dB
Used in
the past
Moderately
Sign
Moderately
Sign
avg: 120 dB,
profound
Uses
currently
Moderately
Sign
avg: 90-119
dB, severe
avg: 90-119
dB, severe
avg: 120 dB
or more,
profound
avg: 90-119
dB, severe
Used in
the past
Used in
the past
Used in
the past
Used in
the past
Used in
the past
120/120/120
dB
89/80/85 dB Uses
currently
Poorly
Poorly
Poorly
Poorly
Poorly
Sign
Oral
Oral
Sign
Sign
Moderately
Sign
105/115/110
dB
Uses
currently
Moderately
Oral
95/100/98
dB
Uses
currently
94/107/101
Used in
dB
the past
90/90/90 dB Used in
the past
70/60/65 dB Uses
currently
110/110/110
dB
Used in
the past
Moderately
Sign
Poorly
Poorly
Well
Sign
Sign
Sign
Poorly
Oral
15
Sign
Sign
Sign &
oral
Sign
Sign &
oral
Sign &
oral
Sign
Sign
Sign &
oral
Sign &
oral
Sign &
oral
Sign
Sign &
oral
Sign
Sign
Sub22
Sub23
Sub24
Sub28
Sub29
Sub31
F
M
F
F
F
F
20
19
19
30
23
30
Hereditary
deafness
Hereditary
deafness
Hereditary
deafness
Hereditary
deafness
Maternal
disease/
drugs side
effect
Maternal
disease/
drug side
effect
113/115/114
dB
Used in
the past
90/110/100
dB
Uses
currently
Uses
currently
94/103/99
dB
78/92/85 dB Uses
currently
Poorly
Well
Very well
Poorly
Oral
Sign
Sign
Sign
102/120/111
dB
Uses
currently
Moderately
Oral
100/120/110
dB
Uses
currently
Well
Oral
Sign &
oral
Sign &
oral
Sign &
oral
Sign &
oral
Sign &
oral
Sign &
oral
Figure S1: Overlap between data-driven representative network modules in hearing and deaf participants and 13 well-known large
scale networks (LSNs) (Power et al., 2011). Vertical axis corresponds to four large-scale functional modules discovered by community
detection algorithm (see Results). Horizontal axis corresponds to LSNs from Power et al. (2011). Darker colors reflect higher overlap
coefficient between pair of modules.
16
|
1312.7861 | 1 | 1312 | 2013-12-30T20:44:24 | Sleep, Neuroengineering and Dynamics | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Modeling of consciousness-related phenomena and neuroengineering are fields that are rapidly growing together. We review recent approaches and developments and point out some promising directions of future research: Understanding the dynamics of consciousness states and associated oscillations, pathological oscillations as well as their treatment by stimulation, neuroprosthetics and brain-computer-interface approaches, and stimulation approaches that probe, influence and strengthen memory consolidation. In all these fields, computational models connect theory, neurophysiology and neuroengineering research and pave a way towards medical applications. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Cognitive Neurodynamics manuscript No.
(will be inserted by the editor)
Sleep, Neuroengineering and Dynamics
Jens Christian Claussen · Ulrich G. Hofmann
3
1
0
2
c
e
D
0
3
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
1
6
8
7
.
2
1
3
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
Cognitive Neurodynamics 6 (3), 211-214 (2012)
DOI: 10.1007/s11571-012-9204-2
Received: 23.04.2012
Cognitive Neurodynamics 6 (3), 211-214 (2012)
Abstract Modeling of consciousness-related phenom-
ena and neuroengineering are fields that are rapidly
growing together. We review recent approaches and de-
velopments and point out some promising directions of
future research: Understanding the dynamics of con-
sciousness states and associated oscillations, patholog-
ical oscillations as well as their treatment by stimula-
tion, neuroprosthetics and brain-computer-interface ap-
proaches, and stimulation approaches that probe, in-
fluence and strengthen memory consolidation. In all
these fields, computational models connect theory, neu-
rophysiology and neuroengineering research and pave a
way towards medical applications.
Keywords sleep · neuroengineering · dynamics ·
computational neuroscience · brain-computer interface ·
neuroprosthetics · pathological oscillations · plasticity ·
consciousness
Retweeting John von Neumann's words from the 1950s,
"All stable processes we shall predict. All unstable pro-
cesses we shall control.", it becomes immediate how
computational neuroscience might form a basis for novel
Jens Christian Claussen
University of Luebeck
Institute for Neuro- and Bioinformatics
D-23538 Lubeck
E-mail: [email protected]
Ulrich Hofmann
Neuro-Electronic Systems
University Clinic Freiburg
D-79095 Freiburg
E-mail: [email protected]
engineering approaches in neural medicine. Brain mod-
eling and neural engineering are, in footsteps of these
words, aiming at understanding the brain and its emerg-
ing phenomena on the scientific side, and interacting
with the brain – also with the perspective of medical
treatment – from the engineering science side. Both
sides of the theory-experiment coin have always been
connected as, e.g., electrodes are used for data acquisi-
tion as well as to influence neural systems, be it only
by well-defined input pulses of a measurement protocol
[Bi and Poo 2001], [Siegelbaum and Kandel 1991].
This roadmap, however, persistently is a difficult
enterprise for various reasons. The brain is a highly
nonlinear dynamical system and remains a challenge
for data analysis, theoretical modeling, and large-scale
computation [Singer 1999], [Kantz and Schreiber 1997],
[Pikovsky et al. 2001], [Lehnertz et al. 2000],
[Olbrich et al. 2011].
In review of these challenges, we would like to em-
phasize on four areas of research that mark out out-
standing future potential, and are related to central
keywords: Consciousness, Pathological Oscillations, Neu-
roprosthetics, and Neuroenhancement. In these four ar-
eas, computational models in a similar way connect nat-
ural sciences and neuroengineering research and pave a
way towards medical applications.
Understanding consciousness, anaesthesia and sleep. –
Large-scale synchronized oscillations are easily observed
experimentally and can be both of physiological and
pathological character. The mammal sleep-wake cycle
is a remarkably robust oscillation, in whose regulation
again various neural oscillations are involved, including
the cortical slow oscillation in the so-called delta band,
2
Jens Christian Claussen, Ulrich G. Hofmann
with frequencies around 1 Hz [Compte et al. 2003],
[Ngo et al. 2010], [Mattia and Sanchez-Vives 2012].
Electrical stimulation of the brain at this slow wave
frequency enhanced the slow oscillations themselves as
well asincreased their memory consolidation effect
[Marshall et al. 2006]. The slow oscillations, comprised
by the interplay between bursting activity and an activity-
dependent self-inhibition, exhibit a specific anticorrela-
tion in the durations of Up and Down states; as Mattia
and Sanchez-Vives show in comparison of ferret brain
slice data, mean-field models, and simulations
[Mattia and Sanchez-Vives 2012]. Mean-field models de-
scribe the gross activity of a neural subpopulation (at
column level or below) but keep track of main types of
neurons and their simplified connectivity. They are of
great advantage in describing the consciousness transi-
tions of sleep and general anaesthesia [Hutt et al. 2012,
Steyn-Ross et al. 2012]. As modeled by [Hutt et al. 2012],
GABAergic tonic inhibition influences the brain's arousal
system during general anaesthesia including a loss of
consciousness. Including the effect of gap junctions on
the dynamics elucidated the influence on the propen-
sity of generalized seizures [Steyn-Ross et al. 2012].
Medical treatment: pathological oscillations. – It is
only a recent development that medicine has spotted
the essential importance of dynamical phenomena for
understanding and treatment of certain diseases. These
are primarily those where oscillations themselves com-
prise the disease as in movement disorders, namely es-
sential tremor and Parkinson's disease, for which elec-
trical stimulation methods co-developed with theoret-
ical work and computer simulations have found their
way into clinical practice [Tass et al. 2006]. But even
when there is no observable mechanical or electrical os-
cillation, as in the cortical spreading depression which
is comprised by slow (102–103s timescale) Ca2+ waves,
control methods may become means of treatment
[Dahlem et al. 2008]. In epilepsy, and in more severe
cases of mood disorders, deep brain stimulation is ap-
plied [Abelson et al. 2005] and sophisticated technical
implementations as radio stimulation are developed
[Delgado et al. 1968]. Also, mechanical damages to neu-
ral pathways can result in pathological dynamical phe-
nomena, as in the case of spinal cord injury which leads
to a hyperexcitability of motorneurons. The modeling
approach by [Venugopal et al. 2012] goes down to the
role of each ion channels and aims at a reduction of
spasticity. Finding suitable parameter ranges for elec-
trical stimulation is annother important issue.
[Krishnamurthi et al. 2012] investigate by measuring ve-
locity reduction how an optimal amplitude of DBS can
be found for Parkinson's disease. Considering a Rempe-
Terman based computational model of basal ganglia, in
[Njap et al. 2012] it is demonstrated that a high con-
centration of the inhibiting neurotransmitter GABA to-
gether with electrical stimulation reestablishes faithful
thalamocortical relaying. A more general question is ad-
dressed in [Schutt and Claussen 2012] by investigating
low- to high-frequency stimulation in an Izhikevich-type
cortical network model, with the observation that in a
frequency range around 100Hz, a dynamical desynchro-
nization is observed.
Neuroprosthetics and Brain-Computer Interfaces. –
The consequent continuation of few-electrode stimu-
lations and recordings are Human-Machine interfaces
(HMIs) [Birbaumer 2006], the most apparent applica-
tions where theoretical brain science and engineering
meet. In the loss of direct control through the natu-
ral pathways, prosthetic devices have to be controlled
through an HMI which comprises a "thought-control"
[Hochberg et al. 2006,Pfurtscheller et al. 2003]. The con-
sequent continuation of that idea – and most immediate
demonstration of an HMI at work is that a blind pa-
tient can use the HMI for reading [Zrenner et al. 2011],
cochlea implants improve hearing [Edgerton et al. 1982],
and patients with locked-in syndrome can use an EEG-
based BCI for expressing words [Wolpaw et al. 2002].
Overall, prosthetic applications require a sound model-
ing approach and understanding of the neural process-
ing, and, if possible, also coding, to design an effective
information interfacing with the brain. The visual sys-
tem is a part of the brain where experimental research
and detailed modeling have made large progress. Here,
[Norheim et al. 2012] and [Einevoll and Plesser 2012]
investigate both a minimal and a feedback - extended
model for temporal processing in the lateral geniculate
nucleus (LGN). The final step of brain-machine inter-
facing goes towards dissolution of the border between
computer and brain itself: In their beautiful experimen-
tal setup, [Perez-Marcos et al. 2012] demonstrate vir-
tual hand illusions and – at least for a part of the
body – question the conscious awareness of our Self,
and thereby connect two quite different fields.
Understanding and influencing neural plasticity. –
Neural plasticity, the basis of all learning, can not only
be influenced pharmacologically, but also by various
means of electrical stimulation with remarkable effects
on cognitive learning and consolidation
[Marshall et al. 2006]. Stimulation, as well as learning,
can effect on both the dynamics [Mattia and Sanchez-Vives 2012],
[Schutt and Claussen 2012] and on the plasticity [Clopath 2012],
[Vogt and Hofmann 2012]. [Vogt and Hofmann 2012] demon-
Sleep, Neuroengineering and Dynamics
3
strate modulatory effects of dopamine based on an un-
derlying STDP learning. Modulatory or multi-input based
learning mechanisms are good candidates to explain
memory consolidation. In this direction, [Clopath 2012]
compares two recently proposed mechanisms, namely
tag-trigger consolidation, and a metastate tagging model,
and provides a comprehensive comparison of both con-
cepts. Finally, [Weigenand et al. 2011], [Weigenand et al. 2012]
investigate the phase-dependence of stimulation of cor-
tical slow waves. It would be highly interesting, based
on improved understanding of neural coding and plas-
ticity mechanisms, to design specific stimulation proto-
cols that selectively strengthen desired acquired mem-
ories.
Compte et al. 2003. Compte A, Sanchez-Vives MV, Mc-
Cormick DA, Wang X (2003) Cellular and network mech-
anisms of slow oscillatory activity (<1 hz) and wave prop-
agations in a cortical network model. J Neurophysiol 89:
2707–2725.
Dahlem et al. 2008. Markus A. Dahlem, Felix M. Schneider,
and Eckehard Scholl, Failure of feedback as a putative
common mechanism of spreading depolarizations in mi-
graine and stroke. Chaos 18 026110 (2008).
DOI: 10.1063/1.2937120
Delgado et al. 1968. Delgado JM, Mark V, Sweet W, Ervin
F, Weiss G, Bach YR, and Hagiwara R: Intracerebral ra-
dio stimulation and recording in completely free patients.
J Nerv Ment Dis 147, 329-340 (1968).
Edgerton et al. 1982. Edgerton,B.J.; House,W.F.; Hitsel-
berger,W. Hearing by cochlear nucleus stimulation in hu-
mans. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol Suppl 91 (2 Pt3), 117-
124 (1982).
Outlook. While it is tempting to go beyond the
purpose of medical treatment by "enhancing the brain"
[Farah et al. 2004], a deeper understanding of neural
plasticity mechanisms by theoretical and computational
models also is expected to offer pathways to the treat-
ment of various neural disabilities and disorders, be
them memory-related like Alzheimer, or mood-related
disorders as depressive disorders. How emotion mod-
ulates learning, and how emotional processes dynami-
cally regulate psychological states is an emerging field
[Figueroa Helland et al. 2008,Huber et al. 1999] and can
be expected to become the 'neuroengineering" exten-
sion of of computational modeling for the treatment of
brain disorders.
Acknowledgments. – The collection of articles on these
topics in the current and the subsequent issue of Cognitive
Neurodynamics emerged from the 1st Baltic Autumn School
"Applied Computational Neuroscience: Sleep, Neuroengineer-
ing and Dynamics", hosted by the University of Lubeck with
generous support from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft
(DFG). We thank all invitees and participants for their contri-
butions for this Special Issue as well as for their enthusiastic
and stimulating discussions during the workshop.
References
Abelson et al. 2005. Abelson JL, Curtis GC, Sagher O, Al-
bucher RC, Harrigan M, Taylor SF, Martis B, Gior-
dani B.: Deep brain stimulation for refractory obsessive-
compulsive disorder. Biol Psychiatry 57, 510-6 (2005).
Bi and Poo 2001. G. Bi, M. Poo, Synaptic modification by
correlated activity: Hebb's postulate revisited. Ann. Rev.
Neurosci. 24, 139-166 (2001)
Birbaumer 2006. Birbaumer, N.: Brain-Computer-Interface
Research: Coming of Age. Clin Neurophysiol. 117, pp.
479- 483 (2006).
Clopath 2012. Claudia Clopath, Synaptic consolidation: an
approach to long-term learning, Cognitive Neurodynam-
ics 6 (3), (2012)
10.1007/s11571-011-9177-6
Einevoll and Plesser 2012. Gaute T. Einevoll and Hans E.
Plesser, Extended difference-of-Gaussians model incor-
porating cortical feedback for relay cells in the lateral
geniculate nucleus of cat, Cognitive Neurodynamics 6 (4),
(2012)
DOI: 10.1007/s11571-011-9183-8
Farah et al. 2004. Farah MJ, Illes J, Cook-Deegan R, Gard-
ner H, Kandel E, King P, Parens E, Sahakian B, and
Wolpe PR: Neurocognitive enhancement: what can we
do and what should we do? Nat Rev Neurosci 5 2004,
421-425.
Figueroa Helland et al. 2008. V. Carolina Figueroa Helland,
Svetlana Postnova, Udo Schwarz, Jurgen Kurths, Bernd
Kundermann, Ulrich Hemmeter, and Hans A. Braun,
Comparison of Different Methods for the Evaluation of
Treatment Effects from the Sleep EEG of Patients with
Major Depression, J Biol Phys. 34, 393-404 (2008).
DOI: 10.1007/s10867-008-9096-x
Hochberg et al. 2006. Hochberg, L.R. et al.: Neuronal en-
semble control of prosthetic devices by a human with
tetraplegia. Nature 442, 164-171 (2006).
Huber et al. 1999. Martin T. Huber, Hans A. Braun, Jurgen
C. Krieg Consequences of deterministic and random dy-
namics for the course of affective disorders, Biol. Psychi-
atry 46,
10.1016/S0006-3223(98)00311-4
Hutt et al. 2012. Axel Hutt, The population firing rate in the
presence of GABAergic tonic inhibition in single neurons
and application to general anaesthesia, Cognitive Neuro-
dynamics 6 (3), (2012) 10.1007/s11571-011-9182-9
Kantz and Schreiber 1997. Holger Kantz and T. Schreiber,
Nonlinear Time Series Analysis, Cambridge University
Press (1997)
Krishnamurthi et al. 2012. Narayanan Krishnamurthi, Ste-
fani Mulligan, Padma Mahant, Johan Samanta and
James J. Abbas, Deep brain stimulation amplitude al-
ters posture shift velocity in Parkinsons disease, Cogni-
tive Neurodynamics 6 (4), (2012)
DOI: 10.1007/s11571-012-9201-5
Lehnertz et al. 2000. K Lehnertz, C.E. Elger, J. Arnhold, P.
Grassberger (Eds.), Chaos in Brain?, World Scientific
(2000)
Marshall et al. 2006. Lisa Marshall, Halla Helgadottir,
Matthias Molle, Jan Born Boosting cillations during
sleep potentiates memory, Nature 444, 610-613 (2006).
Mattia and Sanchez-Vives 2012. Maurizio Mattia and Maria
V. Sanchez-Vives, Exploring the spectrum of dynamical
regimes and timescales in spontaneous cortical activity,
4
Jens Christian Claussen, Ulrich G. Hofmann
changes in firing causality, Cognitive Neurodynamics 6
(4), (2012)
DOI: 10.1007/s11571-012-9202-4
Weigenand et al. 2011. Arne Weigenand, Thomas Martinetz,
and Jens Christian Claussen, Switching of cortical Up
and Down states: reproduction of the Shu-Hasenstaub-
McCormick experiment from a conductance-based model
BMC Neuroscience 12, S1, P39 (2011)
DOI: 10.1186/1471-2202-12-S1-P39
Weigenand et al. 2012. Arne Weigenand, Thomas Martinetz,
and Jens Christian Claussen, Phase response of the corti-
cal slow oscillation, Cognitive Neurodynamics 6(4), 367-
375 (2012)
DOI: 10.1007/s11571-012-9207-z
Wolpaw et al. 2002. Wolpaw, J. R., Birbaumer, N., McFar-
land, D. J., Pfurtscheller, G., and Vaughan, T. M.: Brain-
Computer Interfaces for Communication and Control.
Clin. Neurophysiol. 113, 767-791 (2002).
Zrenner et al. 2011. Zrenner E, Bartz-Schmidt KU, Benav H,
Besch D, Bruckmann A, Gabel VP, Gekeler F, Grepp-
maier U, Harscher A, Kibbel S, Koch J, Kusnyerik A,
Peters T, Stingl K, Sachs H, Stett A, Szurman P, Wil-
helm B, Wilke R. Subretinal electronic chips allow blind
patients to read letters and combine them to words. Proc
Biol Sci. 278, 1489-97 (2011).
Cognitive Neurodynamics 6 (3), (2012)
DOI: 10.1007/s11571-011-9179-4
Ngo et al. 2010. Ngo HV, Kohler J, Mayer J, Claussen JC,
Schuster HG Triggering up states in all-to-all coupled
neurons. epl Europhysics Letters 89, 68002 (2010).
DOI: 10.1209/0295-5075/89/68002
Njap et al. 2012. Felix Njap and Jens Christian Claussen and
Andreas Moser and Ulrich G. Hofmann, Modeling Effect
of GABAergic Current in Basal Ganglia Computational
Model, Cognitive Neurodynamics 6 (4), (2012)
DOI: 10.1007/s11571-012-9203-3
Norheim et al. 2012. Eivind S. Norheim, John Wyller, Eilen
Nordlie and Gaute T. Einevoll, A minimal mechanistic
model for temporal signal processing in the lateral genic-
ulate nucleus, Cognitive Neurodynamics 6 (3), (2012)
DOI: 10.1007/s11571-012-9198-9
Olbrich et al. 2011. Eckehard Olbrich and Jens Christian
Claussen and Peter Achermann, The multiple time scales
of sleep dynamics as a challenge for modeling the sleep-
ing brain, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 369, 3884-3901 (2011)
DOI: 10.1098/rsta.2011.0082
Perez-Marcos et al. 2012. Daniel Perez-Marcos, Maria V.
Sanchez-Vives and Mel Slater, Is my hand connected to
my body? The impact of body continuity and arm align-
ment on the virtual hand illusion, Cognitive Neurody-
namics 6 (4), (2012)
DOI: 10.1007/s11571-011-9178-5
Pfurtscheller et al. 2003. Pfurtscheller, G., Mueller, G. R.,
Pfurtscheller, J., Gerner, H. J., and Rupp, R.: 'Thought'-
Control of Functional Electrical Stimulation to Restore
Hand Grasp in a Patient with Tetraplegia. Neurosci. Lett.
351, 33-36 (2003).
Pikovsky et al. 2001. Arkady Pikovsky, Michael Rosenblum,
Jurgen Kurths (Eds.), Synchronization: A Universal Con-
cept in Nonlinear Sciences, Cambridge University Press
(2001)
Schutt and Claussen 2012. Markus Schutt and Jens Chris-
tian Claussen, Desynchronizing effect of high-frequency
stimulation in a generic cortical network model, Cogni-
tive Neurodynamics 6 (4), (2012)
DOI: 10.1007/s11571-012-9199-8
Siegelbaum and Kandel 1991. Steven A. Siegelbaum, Eric R.
Kandel Learning-related synaptic plasticity: LTP and
LTD, Current Opinion in Neurobiology 1, 113-120 (1991)
Singer 1999. Wolf Singer. Neuronal Synchrony: A versatile
Code for the Definition of Relations? Neuron 24, 49-65
(1999)
Steyn-Ross et al. 2012. Moira L. Steyn-Ross, D. Alistair
Steyn-Ross and Jamie W. Sleigh, Gap junctions mod-
ulate seizures in a mean-field model of general anesthesia
for the cortex, Cognitive Neurodynamics 6 (3), (2012)
DOI: 10.1007/s11571-012-9194-0
Tass et al. 2006. Peter A Tass, Christian Hauptmann, Olek-
sandr V Popovych, Development of therapeutic brain
stimulation techniques with methods from nonlinear dy-
namics and statistical physics, International Journal Of
Bifurcation And Chaos 16, 1889-1911 (2006)
Venugopal et al. 2012. Ranu Sharmila Venugopal, Thomas
M. Hamm and Ranu Jung, Differential contributions of
somatic and dendritic calcium-dependent potassium cur-
rents to the control of motoneuron excitability follow-
ing spinal cord injury, Cognitive Neurodynamics 6 (3),
(2012)
DOI: 10.1007/s11571-012-9191-3
Vogt and Hofmann 2012. Simon M. Vogt and Ulrich G. Hof-
mann Neuromodulation of STDP through short-term
|
1501.04901 | 4 | 1501 | 2016-03-07T09:27:49 | Testing quantum-like models of judgment for question order effect | [
"q-bio.NC",
"quant-ph"
] | Lately, so-called "quantum" models, based on parts of the mathematics of quantum mechanics, have been developed in decision theory and cognitive sciences to account for seemingly irrational or paradoxical human judgments. We consider here some such quantum-like models that address question order effects, i.e. cases in which given answers depend on the order of presentation of the questions. Models of various dimensionalities could be used, can the simplest ones be empirically adequate? From the quantum law of reciprocity, we derive new empirical predictions that we call the Grand Reciprocity equations, that must be satisfied by several existing quantum-like models, in their non-degenerate versions. Using substantial existing data sets, we show that these non-degenerate versions fail the GR test in most cases, which means that, if quantum-like models of the kind considered here are to work, it can only be in their degenerate versions. However, we suggest that the route of degenerate models is not necessarily an easy one, and we argue for more research on the empirical adequacy of degenerate quantum-like models in general. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Testing quantum-like models of judgment for
question order effect
Thomas Boyer-Kassem∗, S´ebastien Duchene†, Eric Guerci†
to appear in Mathematical Social Sciences, 80 (2016): 33-46.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.mathsocsci.2016.01.001
Abstract
Lately, so-called "quantum" models, based on parts of the mathematics of quantum
mechanics, have been developed in decision theory and cognitive sciences to account
for seemingly irrational or paradoxical human judgments. We consider here some such
quantum-like models that address question order effects, i.e. cases in which given
answers depend on the order of presentation of the questions. Models of various
dimensionalities could be used; can the simplest ones be empirically adequate? From
the quantum law of reciprocity, we derive new empirical predictions that we call the
Grand Reciprocity equations, that must be satisfied by several existing quantum-like
models, in their non-degenerate versions. Using substantial existing data sets, we show
that these non-degenerate versions fail the GR test in most cases, which means that,
if quantum-like models of the kind considered here are to work, it can only be in their
degenerate versions. However, we suggest that the route of degenerate models is not
necessarily an easy one, and we argue for more research on the empirical adequacy of
degenerate quantum-like models in general.
Keywords: question order effect; quantum model; quantum-like model; non-degenerate
model; law of reciprocity; double stochasticity; empirical adequacy
"Research is needed which designs tests of quantum properties
such as the law of reciprocity and the law of double stochasticity"
(Busemeyer and Bruza 2012, 342)
1
Introduction
In decision theory and in cognitive sciences, classical cognitive models of judgment
rely on Bayesian probabilities and suppose that agents' decisions or choices are guided by
preferences or attitudes that are determined at any time. Yet, various empirical results
have threatened the predictive and explanatory power of these classical models: human
judgments display order effects -- the answers given to two questions depend on the order
∗Archives H. Poincar´e (UMR 7117: CNRS, Universit´e de Lorraine), 91 avenue de la Lib´eration, 54000
Nancy, France, and Tilburg Center for Logic, General Ethics and Philosophy of Science, Tilburg University,
PO Box 90153, 5000 LE Tilburg, The Netherlands. E-mail: [email protected]
†GREDEG (UMR 7321: CNRS, Universit´e de Nice Sophia Antipolis), 250 rue Albert Einstein, 06560
Valbonne, France. E-mail: [email protected], [email protected]
1
of presentation of these questions (Schuman and Presser 1981, Tourangeau, Ribs and
Rasinski 2000, Moore 2002) -- , conjunction fallacies -- someone is judged less likely to
have characteristic C than characteristics C and D (Tversky and Kahneman 1982 and
1983, Gavanski and Roskos-Ewoldsen 1991, Stolarz-Fantino et al. 2003) -- , violate the
sure-thing principle -- stating that preferring X to Y given any possible state of the world
should imply preferring X to Y when the exact state of the world is not known (Allais
1953, Ellsberg 1961, Shafir and Tversky 1992) -- , or asymmetries in similarity -- X is
judged more similar to Y than Y to X (Tversky 1977, Krumhansl 1978, Ashby and Perrin
1988). In the classical cognitive framework, these behaviors have often been dubbed as
irrational or paradoxical.
Recently, a research field that rely on so-called "quantum" or "quantum-like" models
has developed to account for such behaviors. The qualifier "quantum" is used to indicate
that the models exploit the mathematics of a contemporary physical theory, quantum
mechanics. Note that only some mathematical tools of quantum mechanics are employed,
and that the claim is not that these models are justified by an application of quantum
physics to the brain. For that reason, we shall prefer to call them "quantum-like" models.
Such models put into question two classical characteristics recalled above: they abandon
Bayesian probabilities for others which are similar to probabilities in quantum mechanics,
and they allow for preferences or attitudes to be undetermined. Quantum-like models
have received much interest from psychologists, physicists, economists, cognitive scientists
and philosophers. For example, new theoretical frameworks have been proposed in decision
theory and bounded rationality (Danilov and Lambert-Mogiliansky 2008 and 2010, Yukalov
and Sornette 2011).
Various quantum-like models have been proposed to account for any of the seemingly
paradoxical behaviors recalled above (for reviews, see Pothos and Busemeyer 2013, Ash-
tiani and Azgomi 2015). First, as the mathematics involved in quantum mechanics are
well-known for their non-commutative features, one of their natural application is the ac-
count of question order effects. For instance, Wang and Busemeyer (2009) and Wang et
al.
(2014) offer a general quantum-like model for attitude questions that are asked in
polls. Conte et al. (2009) present a model for mental states of visual perception, and
Atmanspacher and Romer (2012) discuss non-commutativity. Quantum-like models have
also been offered to explain the conjunction fallacy. For instance, Franco (2009) argues
that it can be recovered from interference effects, which are central features in quantum
mechanics and at the origin of the violation of classical probabilities. Busemeyer et al.
(2011) present a quantum-like model that could explain conjunction fallacy from some or-
der effects. The violation of the sure thing principle has also been investigated by means of
quantum-like models. Busemeyer, Wang and Townsend (2006), and Busemeyer and Wang
(2007) use quantum formalism to explain this violation by introducing probabilistic inter-
ference and superposition of states. Khrennikov and Haven (2009) also explain Ellsberg's
paradox, and Aerts et al. (2011) model the Hawaii problem. Lambert-Mogiliansky et al.
(2009) offer a model for the indeterminacy of preferences. Dynamical models, that rely on
a time evolution of the mental state, have also been introduced (Pothos and Busemeyer
2009, Busemeyer et al. 2009, and Trueblood and Busemeyer 2011). Several other empirical
features, such as asymmetry judgments in similarity have also been offered a quantum-like
model (Pothos and Busemeyer, 2011).
We shall concentrate in this paper on one kind of quantum-like models, those which
claim to account for question order effect -- that answers depend on the order in which
questions are asked. We choose these models because (i) order effect is a straightforward
application of the non-commutative mathematics from quantum mechanics, (ii) order effect
2
models are perhaps the simplest ones and (iii) some of them are at the roots of other models.
All quantum-like models for order effect are not identical. Yet, several of them are built
along the same lines, as in Conte et al. (2009), Busemeyer et al. (2009), Busemeyer et
al. (2011), Atmanspacher and Romer (2012), Pothos and Busemeyer (2013), Wang and
Busemeyer (2013) and Wang et al. (2014). We choose to focus here on this kind of models
for order effect (to be characterized, at least partly, in Section 2). So, we do not consider
for instance the model in Aerts, Gabora and Sozzo (2013) that rely on different hypotheses,
or a quantum-like model for order effect in inference that can be found in Trueblood and
Busemeyer (2011) or in Busemeyer et al. (2011). Our analyses only bear on the previously
mentioned kind of models.
When such quantum-like models for order effects were proposed, empirical adequacy
was cared about: it was argued that the models were able to account either for existing
empirical data (e.g. Wang and Busemeyer 2013 for the data from Moore 2002, Wang et
al. 2014 for data from around 70 national surveys) or for data from new experiments (e.g.
Conte et al. 2009, Wang and Busemeyer 2013). This is not all: a supplementary a priori
constraint (the "QQ equality") has been derived and it has been successfully verified on
the above-mentioned data (Wang and Busemeyer 2013, Wang et al. 2014). So, it seems
that quantum-like models for question order effects are well verified and can be considered
as adequate, at least for a vast set of experiments.
However, some details remain to be settled. In many cases, the above-referred papers
do not specify exactly which model, with which parameters, is to account for the data in
this or thus order effect situation. In particular, when it is claimed that some data can be
accounted for by a quantum-like model, the dimensionality of the model is often not spec-
ified, and the most general case is assumed: the model is supposed to be N dimensional,
and the answers to the questions can be represented by subspaces of any dimension. This
encompasses two cases: either the answers are represented by 1-D subspaces, in which
case the model is said to be non-degenerate, or the answers are represented by subspaces
of larger dimensions, in which case the model is said to be degenerate. The papers do
not always specify whether the model that is to account for the data can remain simple
and be non-degenerate, or has to be degenerate -- this is a question of theoretical im-
portance, as we shall argue. The quantum-like literature is inclined to favor degenerate
models, insisting on the high-dimensionality of the space and on the complexity of the
experimental situation to be modeled, and often considers non-degenerate models as toy
models and use them for illustrative purposes only1. So, the question of choosing between
non-degenerate and degenerate models on an empirical basis has not been fully dealt with,
and it remains unclear so far whether the simple non-degenerate version of the models
could be empirically adequate. Is there a simple way to test whether a non-degenerate
version of the quantum-like models is sufficient to account for some order effect data?
The present paper argues that this question can receive a positive answer. We show that
the non-degenerate versions of the quantum-like models under consideration can actually
be empirically tested in another unstudied -- although simple -- way, that bears on
data that were not intended to be explained but that are nevertheless predicted by the
models. After reconstructing a non-degenerate quantum-like version of a model for order
effect (Section 2), we derive from the quantum law of reciprocity a set of constraints
for it that we call the Grand Reciprocity (GR) equations (Section 3). In Section 4, we
1For instance, in Busemeyer and Bruza (2012), the non-degenerate model is presented as "a simple
example" (p. 100) or as "much too simple" (p. 108), before the general model, which is degenerate, is
presented. That non-degenerate models are "toy models" is also what suggest Busemeyer et al. 2015 p.
240, albeit for quantum-like models for the conjunction fallacy. An exception towards degeneracy is Conte
et al. (2009), one of the first papers in the field, which only considers non-degenerate models.
3
argue that the non-degenerate versions of the models that can be found in Conte et al.
(2009), Busemeyer and Bruza (2012), Pothos and Busemeyer (2013), Wang and Busemeyer
(2013) and Wang et al. (2014), have to obey the GR equations -- note that these papers,
except for Conte et al. (2009), also consider degenerate versions of the models, that are
not required to obey the GR equations, and thus will not be tested here. Using only
available data and without carrying out any new experiment, we are able to put the GR
equations to the test (Section 5). We show that a vast majority of empirical cases fail
to satisfy the GR equations, which means that the non-degenerate versions of the above-
mentioned models cannot account for these cases.
In other words, if the quantum-like
models that have been proposed are indeed to work, it cannot be in the special case of
their non-degenerate versions, as the authors themselves had rightly anticipated, and the
data should be accounted for with degenerate models. In Section 6, we suggest however
that the route of degenerate models is not necessarily an easy one, and we argue for more
research on the empirical adequacy of models in general. Overall, the positive conclusion of
our results, we suggest, is that research on quantum-like models for question order effect
should be directed towards degenerate models, both as a consequence of the failure of
non-degenerate ones and in order to find generalizations of the GR equations that should
enable to empirically test them. This paper is the first one to challenge non-degenerate
models for order effect and to show that they cannot be used as such in many cases. Our
work puts warnings about the future use of these specific models, and provides a critical
and constructive look at quantum models of cognition.
2 A general non-degenerate quantum-like model for ques-
tion order effect
As indicated in the introduction, we are concerned here with the following quantum-
like models for order effect: Conte et al. (2009), Busemeyer et al. (2009), Busemeyer et
al. (2011), Atmanspacher and Romer (2012), Pothos and Busemeyer (2013), Wang and
Busemeyer (2013) and Wang et al. (2014). As they are more or less built along the same
lines, we choose for simplicity to present in this section one simple and general model,
which sets the notations and on which all the discussions will be made. A crucial point is
this: these models, except for Conte et al. (2009), are quite general and can be degenerate
or non-degenerate, as already noted. As we shall be concerned here with testing their
non-degenerate versions only, as a special case, the model we present in this section is
non-degenerate. In Section 4, we shall discuss in detail how this model is included in the
models from the above list.
The model is about the beliefs of a person, about which dichotomous yes-no questions
can be asked, for instance "is Clinton honest?". A vector space on the complex numbers
is introduced to represent the beliefs of the agent, and the answers to the questions. In
the model, two dichotomous questions A and B are posed successively to an agent, in
the order A-then-B or B-then-A. Answer "yes" (respectively "no") to A is represented
by the vector a0(cid:105) (respectively a1(cid:105)), and similarly for B, with vectors b0(cid:105) (respectively)
b1(cid:105). It is important to note that an answer is supposed to be represented by a vector (or
more exactly, see below, by the ray defined by this vector), and not by a plane or by any
subspace of dimension greater than 1. Since there are no other possible answers to question
A (respectively B) than 0 and 1, the set (a0(cid:105), a1(cid:105)) (respectively (b0(cid:105), b1(cid:105))) forms a basis
of the vector space of possible answers, and the vector space is thus of dimension 2. Note
that it is the same vector space that is used to represents answers to questions A and B;
4
a1(cid:105)
(cid:104)a1b1(cid:105)
6
b1(cid:105)
BBM
B
B
9δ
B
B
B
(cid:104)a0b1(cid:105)
(cid:104)a1b0(cid:105)
1 b0(cid:105)
O δ
- a0(cid:105)
(cid:104)a0b0(cid:105)
B
B
B
a1(cid:105)
6
b1(cid:105)
BBM
B
B
B
α1
B
B
B
B
β1
ψ(cid:105)
>
1 b0(cid:105)
β0
- a0(cid:105)
B
α0
[Left:] The basis vectors b0(cid:105) and b1(cid:105) can be decomposed on the other basis
Figure 1:
vectors a0(cid:105) and a1(cid:105), so as to be expressed as in eq. 1 and 2. The scalar products are
either equal to cos δ or to sin δ. [Right:] The state vector ψ(cid:105) can be expressed in the two
orthonormal bases (a0(cid:105), a1(cid:105)) and (b0(cid:105), b1(cid:105)). These figures assume the special case of a
Hilbert space on real numbers.
this space just has two different bases.2
The vector space is supposed to be equipped with a scalar product, thus becoming a
Hilbert space: for two vectors x(cid:105) and y(cid:105), the scalar product (cid:104)xy(cid:105) is a complex number;
its complex conjugate, (cid:104)xy(cid:105)∗, is just (cid:104)yx(cid:105). The Hilbert space is on the complex numbers,
and vectors can be multiplied by any complex number.3 The basis (a0(cid:105), a1(cid:105)) is supposed
to be orthonormal, i.e. (cid:104)a0a1(cid:105) = 0 and (cid:104)a0a0(cid:105) = (cid:104)a1a1(cid:105) = 1; similarly for B. Note that
there exists a correspondence between the two bases (cf. figure 1 left):
b0(cid:105) = (cid:104)a0b0(cid:105)a0(cid:105) + (cid:104)a1b0(cid:105)a1(cid:105),
b1(cid:105) = (cid:104)a0b1(cid:105)a0(cid:105) + (cid:104)a1b1(cid:105)a1(cid:105),
(1)
(2)
and similarly for a0(cid:105) and a1(cid:105) expressed as a function of b0(cid:105) and b1(cid:105).
An agent's beliefs about the subject matter of the questions A and B are represented
by a normalized belief state ψ(cid:105) from this vector space ((cid:104)ψψ(cid:105)2 = 1). It is supposed to
gather all the relevant information to predict her behavior in the situation (like in orthodox
quantum mechanics). ψ(cid:105) can be expressed in the basis (a0(cid:105), a1(cid:105)) as
with (α0, α1) ∈ C2 (cf. fig. 1 right). It can also be expressed in the basis (b0(cid:105), b1(cid:105)) as
ψ(cid:105) = α0a0(cid:105) + α1a1(cid:105),
ψ(cid:105) = β0b0(cid:105) + β1b1(cid:105),
(3)
(4)
with (β0, β1) ∈ C2, and with an appropriate correspondence between the coefficients.
The belief state ψ(cid:105) determines the answer in a probabilistic way, and changes only
when a question is answered, according to the following rules:
2In the literature, questions that can be represented in this way are known as "incompatible". "Com-
patible" questions have a common basis, but the model is then equivalent to a classical one, and there is
nothing quantum about it. Cf. for instance Busemeyer and Bruza (2012, 32 -- 34).
3We consider here this general case. In the literature, some quantum-like models consider a real Hilbert
space, in which scalar products are real numbers, and vectors can be multiplied by real numbers only.
5
• Born's rule: the probability for the agent to answer xi (i = 0, 1) to question X
(X = A, B) is given by the squared modulus of the scalar product between ψ(cid:105) and
xi(cid:105):
(5)
• projection postulate: the agent's belief state just after the answer xi is the normalized
projection of her belief state prior to the question onto the vector xi(cid:105) corresponding
to her answer:
Pr(xi) = (cid:104)xiψ(cid:105)2
ψ(cid:105)
(cid:55)−→ (cid:104)xiψ(cid:105)
(cid:104)xiψ(cid:105)xi(cid:105).
(6)
For instance, if an agent is described by the state vector ψ(cid:105) = α0a0(cid:105) + α1a1(cid:105), the
probability that she answers i to question A is given by αi2, in which case the state
αiai(cid:105). In fig. 1, this probability can be obtained by first orthogonally
after the answer is αi
projecting ψ(cid:105) on the basis vector corresponding to the answer, and then taking the square
of this length. A consequence of the projection postulate in this model is that, just after
an answer i to question X has been given, the state is of the form λxi(cid:105) with λ ∈ C and
λ = 1. The fact that the state after the answer is equal to xi(cid:105) "up to a phase factor", as
one says, is true whatever the state prior to the question. In fig. 1, in the case of a real
Hilbert space, the projection postulates can be interpreted as follow: project ψ(cid:105) on the
basis vector corresponding to the answer, then normalize it (i.e. expand it so that it gets
a length 1); the result is ±xi(cid:105), according to the relative orientation of ψ(cid:105) and xi(cid:105). In
the general case, answering a question modifies the agent's state of belief, but there are
exceptions: if an agent's state of belief is λxi(cid:105) (with λ = 1), Born's rule states that she
will answer i ("yes" or "no") with probability 1, and her state of belief is thus unchanged.
Such vectors from which an answer can be given with certainty are called "eigenvectors",
and their set is the "eigenspace", for the "eigenvalue" i. In this model, all eigenspaces are
of dimension 1, and are called "rays" (equivalently, one can say that the eigenvalue is not
degenerate), since it has been supposed that an answer is represented by a vector, and
not by several independent vectors; this will be of decisive importance in the next section.
Another consequence of the projection postulate is that, once an agent has answered i to
question A, she will answer i with probability 1 to the same question A if it is posed again
just afterwards.4
Such a quantum-like model displays order features. Compare for instance p(a0, b0),
the probability to answer 0 to question A and then 0 to question B, and p(b0, a0), the
probability to give the same answers but in the reverse order. To compute p(a0, b0), one
can project the initial state on a0(cid:105) without normalizing the result, then project the result
on b0(cid:105), still without normalizing, and take the squared modulus of the final result.5 In
other words, to compare the two probabilities, one can just compare the length of successive
projections of ψ(cid:105), first on a0(cid:105) and then b0(cid:105), or in the reverse order. Figure 2 shows that
they are not necessary equal. Because quantum-like models display these order features, it
has been naturally suggested that they can account for experimentally documented order
effects; Section 4 discusses several such models.
4Of course, this is not true if another question, say B, is posed in-between.
5Proof. Note p(yjxi) the probability to answer j to question Y given that question X has been
answered with i. After the answer xi, the state is λxi(cid:105) with λ = 1, so p(yjxi) = (cid:104)yjxi(cid:105)2. Note p(xi)
the probability to answer i to question X when this question is asked first. p(a0, b0) = p(a0) · p(b0a0) =
0(cid:105) = (cid:104)a0ψ(cid:105)a0(cid:105). Since a(cid:48)
(cid:104)a0ψ(cid:105)2·(cid:104)b0a0(cid:105)2 = (cid:104)a0ψ(cid:105)·(cid:104)b0a0(cid:105)2 = (cid:104)b0a(cid:48)
0(cid:105) is ψ(cid:105) projected onto
0(cid:105) is projected onto b0(cid:105) and not normalized,
a0(cid:105) and not normalized, computing (cid:104)b0a(cid:48)
before the squared modulus is computed. QED.
0(cid:105)2, where a(cid:48)
0(cid:105)2 means that a(cid:48)
6
a1(cid:105)
6
b1(cid:105)
BBM
B
B
B
B
ψ(cid:105)
>
1 b0(cid:105)
B
B
B
B
- a0(cid:105)
Figure 2: The state vector ψ(cid:105), projected first on a0(cid:105) and then on b0(cid:105), or first on b0(cid:105)
and then on a0(cid:105), gives different lengths. Consequently, the corresponding probabilities
p(a0, b0) and p(b0, a0) are different.
3 Constraints: the Grand Reciprocity equations
Some general empirical predictions can be derived from the non-degenerate model
presented in the previous section.
3.1 Derivation of the Grand Reciprocity equations
Be xi and yj the answers an agent gives to two successive questions X and Y , in
one order or in the other (X may be equal to Y , and i to j). Because of the projection
postulate, the state just after the answer xi (respectively yj) is λxi(cid:105) (respectively λ(cid:48)yj(cid:105)),
with (λ, λ(cid:48)) ∈ C2 and λ = λ(cid:48) = 1. On the one hand,
On the other hand,
As indicated previously, (cid:104)yjxi(cid:105) = (cid:104)xiyj(cid:105)∗, hence (cid:104)yjxi(cid:105)2 = (cid:104)xiyj(cid:105)2, and so
p(yjxi) = (cid:104)yj(λxi(cid:105))2 = (cid:104)yjxi(cid:105)2.
p(xiyj) = (cid:104)xi(λ(cid:48)yj(cid:105))2 = (cid:104)xiyj(cid:105)2.
p(yjxi) = p(xiyj).
(7)
(8)
(9)
This equation is well-known in quantum mechanics, and is called the law of reciprocity
(cf. Peres 1993, p. 35 -- 36 and 56). The only condition for this law is that the eigenvalues
are not degenerate6. It is a quantum law: it is not verified in general by a classical model, in
which P (bjai) = P (aibj)× P (bj)/P (ai), so P (bjai) (cid:54)= P (aibj) as soon as P (bj) (cid:54)= P (ai).
6If the eigenvalues are degenerate, i.e.
if the eigenspaces are of dimension greater than 1, then the
projection postulate is generalized in the following way: the agent's belief state just after the answer xi
is the normalized projection of her belief state prior to the question onto the eigenspace corresponding
to her answer. This eigenspace is the ray spanned by xi(cid:105) if the eigenvalue is not degenerate, but more
generally it can be a plane or a hyperspace. Here is why the hypothesis of non-degeneracy is necessary to
the reciprocity law. Suppose for simplicity that the Hilbert space is on the real numbers. Suppose that
the eigenspace for the eigenvalue 0 for question A is a ray, while the eigenspace for the eigenvalue 0 for
B is a plane, with an angle π/4 between them. Once the answer 0 is obtained from question A, the state
vector is on the ray, and if a0(cid:105) is projected onto the plane, then there is by hypothesis an angle of π/4,
so p(b0a0) = cos2(π/4). Now, once the answer 0 is obtained from question B, the state vector can be
anywhere in the plane, for instance with a right angle to the ray, so p(a0b0) can be null. The reciprocity
law does not hold anymore.
7
For quantum-like models of judgment, the law of reciprocity is somehow well-known7,
but it has not been fully investigated. In the case of our model, it can be instantiated in
the following ways:
p(b0a0) = p(a0b0),
p(b1a0) = p(a0b1),
p(b0a1) = p(a1b0),
p(b1a1) = p(a1b1).
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
For each of these equations, the left member is about questions posed in one sense (A-then-
B), while the right member is about the other sense (B-then-A). This set of equations is
actually equivalent to another set, in which each equation is about one order of questions:
p(b0a0) = p(b1a1),
p(a0b0) = p(a1b1),
p(b1a0) = p(b0a1),
p(a0b1) = p(a1b0).
(14)
(15)
(16)
(18)
(19)
(17)
Here's a proof of the first equation (others are similar): p(b0a0) = 1− p(b1a0) because
there are only two possible answers (b0 and b1) to question B; then 1−p(b1a0) = 1−p(a0b1)
because of eq. 11; then 1− p(a0b1) = p(a1b1) because there are only two possible answers
to question A; then p(a1b1) = p(b1a1) because of eq. 13.
This set of equations 14 to 17 shows that there exist some equations that a quantum-
like model must satisfy even if the questions are not reversed, although the reciprocity
law (eq. 9) is originally about questions in reverse orders. The reciprocity law actually
gives some constraints on one unchanged experimental setup too, when instantiated for
all cases. The equivalence of the two sets of equations (reversing-the-order, eq. 10-13, and
not-reversing-the-order, eq. 14-17) suggests that there is nothing special about equations
which compare reversed orders.
Eq. 14 is equal to eq. 15, because of eq. 10 or 13; similarly for eq. 16 and 17. So, a new
set of equations, that we call the Grand Reciprocity equations, or just the GR equations,
can be written:
p(b0a0) = p(a0b0) = p(b1a1) = p(a1b1),
p(b1a0) = p(a0b1) = p(b0a1) = p(a1b0).
This set of equations is equivalent to either of the two previous sets, but it should be
preferred as its form is more explicit. It is also equivalent to the reciprocity law itself,
because it states it for all possible cases in the model. Further, eq. 18 and 19 are equivalent
to one another, because p(y0xi) + p(y1xi) = 1 by definition. So, each of these equations
is actually equivalent to the other sets and to the reciprocity law itself.
To the best of our knowledge, these equations have not yet been fully written in the
literature on quantum-like models. Many papers note the law of reciprocity and the
consequences for conditional probabilities (cf. footnote 7), but always for one order of the
questions only.
7Cf. Franco (2009, 417 -- 418), Wang and Busemeyer (2013, 697 -- 698), Busemeyer et al. (2011, 197),
Pothos and Busemeyer (2013, 317), Wang et al. (2014, 5).
8
The GR equations set the value for all possible conditional probabilities: among the
eight quantities that can be experimentally measured, there is just one free real parameter.
In the case of a real Hilbert space, the origin of this constraint is to be found in the δ angle
between the two bases (cf. fig. 3).
b1(cid:105)
(cid:104)b1a1(cid:105)
BBM
B
B
a1(cid:105)
(cid:104)a1b1(cid:105)
6
9δ
B
B
B
B
B
B
(cid:104)b0a0(cid:105)
1 b0(cid:105)
O δ
- a0(cid:105)
(cid:104)a0b0(cid:105)
a1(cid:105)
6
b1(cid:105)
BBM
B
B
(cid:104)a1b0(cid:105)
(cid:104)b0a1(cid:105)
1 b0(cid:105)
O δ
B
- a0(cid:105)
9δ
B
B
B
B
B
(cid:104)a0b1(cid:105)
(cid:104)b1a0(cid:105)
Figure 3: A graphical illustration of the Grand Reciprocity equations, in the special case
of a real Hilbert space. A δ angle is enough to define the two orthonormal bases relatively
from one another. Then, conditional probabilities, of the form (cid:104)xiyj(cid:105)2, are either equal
to cos2(δ) [Left] or to sin2(δ) [Right], with a sum to 1.
3.2 Generalizations
Let us now consider some generalizations of the GR equations to cases which go beyond
the non-degenerate quantum-like model presented in Section 2.
First, the GR equations have been shown for a single agent; by averaging, they ob-
viously still hold for any population of N agents, with various initial state vectors ψk(cid:105),
with k ∈ {1, ..., N}. Another possible generalization concerns the basis vectors: what if
they depend on the agent k, with a0,k(cid:105), a1,k(cid:105), b0,k(cid:105), b1,k(cid:105)?8 In this case, the above GR
equations can be established for each agent k in the same way as previously, except that
the terms are now indexed for each agent k, in the form pk(xy) = pk(zt) (or respectively
= 1 − pk(zt)), with (x, y, z, t) ∈ {a0,k, a1,k, b0,k, b1,k}4. For the whole population, p(xy) is
now defined by the average of the statistical probabilities pk on all N agents:
and similarly for p(zt). But because for any k, pk(xy) = pk(zt), then
p(xy) =
Σkpk(xy),
(20)
1
N
1
N
Σkpk(xy) =
Σkpk(zt).
1
N
(21)
So finally p(xy) = p(zt) (or respectively = 1− p(zt)), and the GR equations hold for the
whole population even if the basis vectors depend on the agent. This is just because it
holds for any agent, and that the average on the agents is a linear operation that enables
to keep the form of the equations.
Also, quantum systems can be described with more general mixed states, instead of
ψ(cid:105) has been supposed to be equal to a vector from
pure states. Here is the difference:
8This situation is considered for instance by Busemeyer et al. 2011 p. 212.
9
the Hilbert space, i.e. a pure state, and this supposes that the modeler knows to which
vector the state is equal. But there are cases in which the modeler does not know exactly
to which vector the state is equal (for instance, she only knows that there are 50% chances
that the state is a0(cid:105), and 50% chances that it is a1(cid:105)). To express this, the belief state is
considered as a statistical ensemble of pure states, and it is represented by a density matrix
(for instance, we write ρ = 0.5a0(cid:105)(cid:104)a0 + 0.5a1(cid:105)(cid:104)a1 for the above case). The question is
then: are the GR equations valid for pure states only, or also for mixed states? For both,
because no particular hypothesis has been made on the state before the first question is
asked. What matters for the demonstration is the state after the first question, and it
is doomed to be the corresponding eigenvector (up to a phase factor), whether the belief
state was described as a statistical mixture or not before the question was asked. So, the
GR equations hold even if mixed states are assumed, which can prove very powerful.
The GR equations apply to a model with 2 questions with 2 possible answers each, but
one could also consider a larger set of questions. Consider a model with q questions A,
B, C, . . . that are asked in a row, in various orders, each with 2 possible non-degenerate
answers, in a Hilbert space of dimension 2. For the questions considered 2 by 2, the
reciprocity law (eq. 9) holds, since what matters is that answers are represented by 1D
subspaces, and so the GR equations hold too. This gives a set of q· (q− 1)/2 GR equations
that this model must satisfy. Consider now a model with 2 questions, each with r possible
answers, with non-degenerate eigenvalues, in a complex Hilbert space of dimension r. The
reciprocity law still holds in this case, and the GR equations hold for each couple of indexes
(i, j) ∈ {1, ..., r}2. Overall, the GR equations can be generalized to apply for models with
q questions and r possible non-degenerate answers.
The hypothesis that eigenvalues are non-degenerate, i.e. that eigenspaces are of dimen-
sion 1, can be relaxed in some cases. Suppose a model M with eigenspaces of dimensions
greater than 1 is empirically equivalent to a model M(cid:48) with eigenspaces of dimension 1.
So to speak, the supplementary dimensions of M are theoretically useless, and empirically
meaningless. As the GR equations hold for M(cid:48), they will also hold for M , to which it is
equivalent. So, more generally, the GR equations hold for models which have eigenspaces
of dimension 1, or which are reducible (i.e. equivalent) to it.
These results may have a larger impact still. Suppose that there exists a set of elemen-
tary questions, the answers of which would be represented by non-degenerate eigenspaces,
i. e. rays. These elementary rays would define the fundamental basis belief states, on
which any belief could be decomposed. The number of such elementary rays would define
the dimensionality of the Hilbert space representing human beliefs. Such an assumption
is widespread in the quantum-like literature. For instance, a similar idea is expressed by
Pothos and Busemeyer about emotions:
"one-dimensional sub-spaces (called rays) in the vector space would correspond to the
most elementary emotions possible. The number of unique elementary emotions and
their relation to each other determine the overall dimensionality of the vector space.
Also, more general emotions, such as happiness, would be represented by subspaces of
higher dimensionality." (Pothos and Busemeyer 2013, 258).
Generalized GR equations would hold for such elementary questions. Then, all models
with degenerate eigenspaces would just be coarse-grained models, which could be refined
with more elementary questions and rays. For instance, a degenerate answer represented
by a plane combines two elementary dimensions because it fails to distinguish between
them. As a consequence, the meaning of a degenerate answer could be specified through
more specific elementary answers. More importantly, the degenerate model could actually
10
be tested on these fundamental questions, with our GR equations or their generalized
versions with q questions and r answers. In other words, if elementary questions existed
-- and it seems to be a usual assumption in the quantum-like literature -- any model of
the kind presented in Section 2, but with non-degenerate answers or not, could be tested
with GR equations. This is of fantastic interest, as it enables to test any model, and it
has never been noted before. We shall come back on this point in Section 6.
3.3 Link with double stochasticity
"double stochasticity". Let us analyze the links between the two constraints.
Part of the GR equations is actually known in the literature as the requirement of
Define the change of basis matrix µa,b between the two bases (a0(cid:105),a1(cid:105)) and (b0(cid:105),b1(cid:105)),
as:
µa,b =
(cid:18)(cid:104)a0b0(cid:105)
(cid:104)a1b0(cid:105)
(cid:19)
(cid:104)a0b1(cid:105)
(cid:104)a1b1(cid:105)
.
(22)
As the two bases are orthonormal by hypothesis, this matrix is unitary. From it, a transi-
tion matrix T a,b can be defined by T a,b
(cid:18)(cid:104)a0b0(cid:105)2
(cid:104)a1b0(cid:105)2
(cid:19)
ij = µa,b
ij 2:
(cid:104)a0b1(cid:105)2
(cid:104)a1b1(cid:105)2
=
(cid:19)
(cid:18)p(a0b0) p(a0b1)
p(a1b0) p(a1b1)
T a,b =
.
(23)
T a,b contains the probabilities for the answers to question A given the previous answer to
question B (T a,b could be also called T AB).
Transition matrices are left stochastic: they are square matrices of non-negative real
numbers, of which each column sums to 1. This expresses the fact that, once an answer
has been given to the first question, there is a probability 1 that one of the answers is
given to the second question. A matrix is said to be doubly stochastic in case all columns
and all rows sum to 1. Saying that T a,b is doubly stochasticity amounts to the following
equations:
p(a0b0) + p(a1b0) = 1
p(a0b1) + p(a1b1) = 1
p(a0b0) + p(a0b1) = 1
p(a1b0) + p(a1b1) = 1
(24)
(25)
(26)
(27)
Subtracting these equations one by one gives eq. 15 and 17 -- but no more9. So, one gets
one half of the reciprocity relations. This should be no surprise: the double stochasticity
constraint bears on only one experiment, when the order of the questions is the same,
and cannot be informative about the reverse order. It is easy to see that if the double
stochasticity of the reverse transition matrix (T b,a) is assumed, then one gets the other half
of our reciprocity relations (eq. 14 and 16), and then also the GR equations. Conversely,
our GR equations imply double stochasticity for both transition matrices. So, the GR
equations are equivalent to the requirement of double stochasticity for transition matrices
in both senses.
In the literature, double stochasticity is a well-known property of transition matri-
ces for quantum-like non-degenerate models10, but it has generally been required for one
9Eq. 14 and 16 cannot be derived from eq. 24 -- 27: as they bear on questions asked in different orders,
it is easy to imagine a case in which the former are false, whereas the latter are true.
10 Cf.
for instance Busemeyer and Bruza (2012, 53 -- 54), Busemeyer, Wang and Lambert-Mogiliansky
(2009), Pothos and Busemeyer (2013, 269).
11
transition matrix only (i.e.
for questions posed in one order). An exception is Khren-
nikov (2010, 24 and 36), who studies double stochasticity for transition matrices in both
senses, and shows that it must be verified by quantum-like probability models with non-
degenerate eigenvalues, i.e.
like in our general model. However, he does not insist on
testing experimentally this property in a systematic way, as we shall do here, with impor-
tant consequences for existing models.
Although the GR equations are equivalent to double stochasticity in both orders for
transition matrices, there are several reasons why the former formulation should be pre-
ferred, both pragmatically and theoretically. To test double stochasticity, one first needs
to write equations like eq. 24 -- 27. But such equations are not independent, so it compli-
cates the statistical tests of significance. Or in order not to test useless equations, some
work needs to be done beforehand to find the independent equations. Actually, untangling
the equations would just lead to the GR equations, which are directly usable. Overall,
the GR equations can be considered as the pragmatic form one should use to test double
stochasticity in both orders. They also clearly show that two set of equations (18 and
19) are equivalent, and that one needs to pick only the corresponding data. Also, the GR
equations show at first sight that there is only one free parameter among all the possi-
ble conditional probabilities, while this is not transparent from the double stochasticity
requirement. More theoretically, the GR equations are directly linked with a central math-
ematical property of the scalar product in the model, making it clear why it holds. On
the other hand, the reason why double stochasticity should hold in this model is more ob-
scure. Finally, the GR equations connect with a fundamental law of quantum mechanics,
namely the law of reciprocity, which helps to understand why it holds only in the case of
non-degenerate eigenvalues, like in quantum mechanics.
3.4 Link with the QQ equality
Wang and Busemeyer (2013) and Wang et al.
(2014) defend the test of a relation
called "the QQ equality" that they introduce. This equality holds for the non-degenerate
quantum-like model presented in Section 2, and also if eigenvalues were degenerate. In the
case of non-degenerate eigenvalues, it can be derived from our GR equations, as can be
shown in the following way.
With the notations of our model (and adding the notation pXY (zi) for the probability
to answer i to question Z, when posed in the order X-then-Y ), the QQ equality (Wang
and Busemeyer 2013, 698) can be written as:
p(a0, b1) + p(a1, b0) = p(b0, a1) + p(b1, a0),
(28)
that is,
p(b1a0)pAB(a0) + p(b0a1)pAB(a1) = p(a1b0)pBA(b0) + p(a0b1)pBA(b1).
(29)
Because pXY (z0) + pXY (z1) = 1, it is equivalent to:
p(b1a0)pAB(a0) + p(b0a1)[1 − pAB(a0)] = p(a1b0)pBA(b0) + p(a0b1)[1 − pBA(b0)], (30)
which can be rewritten as:
[p(b1a0) − p(b0a1)]pAB(a0) + p(b0a1) = [p(a1b0) − p(a0b1)]pBA(b0) + p(a0b1).
(31)
The square brackets are null because of eq. 16 and 17, and the two remaining terms are
equal because of eq. 19. So, the QQ equality is demonstrated from the GR equations when
eigenspaces are not degenerate.
12
The GR equations cannot be derived in general from the QQ equality: below, Section 5
gives an example of data which satisfy the QQ equality, but not our GR equations. So
the two tests are not equivalent. They test different things: if a data set does not satisfy
the GR equations, the non-degenerate quantum-like model of Section 2 cannot apply to it
(it remains an open question whether a degenerate model would); if a data set does not
satisfy the QQ equality, the non-degenerate quantum-like model of Section 2 cannot apply
to it, and a degenerate version of it could not either. In other words, a non-degenerate
quantum-like model must satisfy both the GR equations and the QQ equality, and a
degenerate quantum-like model must satisfy the QQ equality.
3.5 Testing the Grand Reciprocity equations
Why test these GR equations? As noted before, the quantum-like literature often
consider models that can be either non-degenerate (answers are represented by rays) or
degenerate (answers are represented by subspaces of any dimension). So, a first reason
to test the GR equations is simplicity: if a non-degenerate model is empirically adequate,
why bother considering a degenerate one? The possibility to have a non-degenerate model
should be settled, and the GR test exactly enables it. Conversely, for models that are
proposed only in a non-degenerate version, the GR equations should be verified with-
out condition, and they provide a decisive test of empirical adequacy. So, in any case,
we suggest that (one of) the GR equation(s) be directly tested experimentally for any
quantum-like model that contains the model presented in Section 2, as a particular case
only or not. "Directly tested" here means that what should be measured are the conditional
probabilities that are present in these equations, or data that enable their computation.
On a more pragmatic ground, the needed data are basic ones, easy to get experimen-
tally. The equations are ready-to-use ones, simpler than the test of double stochasticity
(cf. Section 3.3). More theoretically, each GR equation is equivalent to a fundamental
property of quantum-like models, namely the law of reciprocity. It is not just a conse-
quence of it but it is just the expression of this law for all possible cases in the model.
Testing the GR equations is exactly testing the reciprocity law (testing the QQ equality,
which is only a consequence of the reciprocity law, amounts to another test). The benefit
is that testing the GR equations is more economical: they state that only 4 conditional
probabilities need to be compared to test the law in general. Another reason to test the
GR equations is that a classical model does not verify them; so they can be seen as a test
of the quantum-like character of the data.11
A last point in favor of the test is that, when some empirical data verify the GR
equations, it can be used to define a quantum-like model in a real Hilbert space. Define
p = p(a0b0); because of the GR equations, any conditional probability p(xiyj) is either p
or 1 − p, and eq. 23 becomes:
.
(32)
T a,b =
1 − p
1 − p
p
(cid:18) p
(cid:19)
(cid:18)cos δ − sin δ
(cid:19)
On the other hand, a model from a real Hilbert space (like in fig. 1) has a change of basis
matrix
µa,b =
sin δ
cos δ
,
(33)
11Indeed, the GR equations are equivalent to the reciprocity law, which is not true in general for classical
models (cf. Section 3.1). Note that classical models which satisfy the GR equations are uninteresting: all
P (xi) and all P (xiyj) are equal to 0.5.
13
and hence a transition matrix
T a,b =
(cid:19)
.
(34)
(cid:18)cos2 δ
sin2 δ
sin2 δ
cos2 δ
√
Taking δ = arccos(
p) enables the real model to account for the data of conditional
probabilities. To put it another way, checking the empirically validity of the GR equations
enables at the same time to define the two bases relatively from one another.
Note that testing the GR equations require that the experiment be conducted in both
question orders (A-then-B and B-then-A). If only one question order is studied, a test
can still be performed, but only on half of the equations. So, whenever a quantum-like
model of the kind depicted here is proposed to account for the results of a succession of
two questions in one order only, then the model should also be tested for the reverse order.
4 Applying the GR equations to non-degenerate (versions
of ) existing models
The non-degenerate quantum-like model that we introduced in Section 2 was intended
to serve as a concise presentation for several models from the literature. In this section,
we discuss in detail the relation between our model and existing ones, in order to clarify
whether the latter should verify the GR equations. Recall that satisfying the GR equations
is required in general for non-degenerate models only. So, if an existing model is proposed
in the most general case either as non-degenerate or degenerate, then the GR equations
apply only to the non-degenerate version of the model, not to its degenerate version.
Consider first Conte et al. (2009), who propose a quantum-like model to account for
order effects in mental states during visual perception of ambiguous figures. Their model
can be cast into the lines of our general model: the two dichotomous questions or tests are
also called A and B, and the probabilities of the answers are noted p(A = +), p(A = −),
p(B = +) and p(B = +), corresponding to our p(a0), p(a1), p(b0) and p(b1). The questions
concern visual perception of ambiguous figures, and a vector state, noted here φ (instead
of our ψ) represents the state of consciousness about the perception.
It belongs to a
complex Hilbert space, and an answer is represented by a one-dimensional subspace (this
is implicit in their formula (3)). The usual Born rule makes the link with probabilities.
The model also involves a projection postulate: during perception, the "potential" state of
consciousness is collapsed onto "an actual or manifest state of consciousness" (p. 6 and 7).
Note however a slight difference: for Conte et al., the projection of the state arises during
perception of the figure, not during answering a question. But as the latter quickly follows
the former, and as an agent answers a question only once her perception has stabilized,
this does not make any difference in practice. Overall, Conte et al. (2009)'s model matches
our general model in all respects, as it supposes that eigenspaces are of dimension 1. So,
it has to obey the GR equations.
Consider now the model proposed by Wang and Busemeyer (2013), called the QQ
model, which is to account for several types of order effects about judgments on various
topics (politics, sports, society, etc.). The clear presentation of the model in their Section 2,
together with their geometric approach which provides figures similar to ours (in the case
of a real Hilbert space), easily enables to see that it encompasses the non-degenerate model
of Section 2. However, Wang and Busemeyer's model is more general and allows for an
answer to be represented either with a subspace of dimension 1 (non-degenerate version),
or with a subspace of dimension larger than 1 (degenerate version). The GR equations
14
apply only to the former version, as a special case. For instance, they apply to figures 1
and 2 (p. 4 and 5), which represent "a two-dimensional example of the quantum-like model
of question order effects". Hence, the GR test will exactly fit here the aim we set it in
the introduction: within this general model, specify whether non-degenerate model can be
sufficient, or degenerate model are required.
Wang and Busemeyer's general model is also at the basis of two other presentations:
in Busemeyer and Bruza's 2012 book (p. 99 -- 116), and in the review article of Pothos and
Busemeyer (2013). Here too, the model can be non-degenerate or degenerate, and the GR
equations apply with the same conditions: only to the special case of the non-degenerate
version.
Atmanspacher and Romer (2012, p. 277) make the suggestion that Wang and Buse-
meyer's model could be extended to mixed states, instead of just pure states. Although
this is an interesting theoretical possibility, it is clear that it cannot be used to avoid the
GR equations, as they are valid for pure as for mixed states (cf. Section 3.2).
Building on the paper of Wang and Busemeyer (2013), Wang et al. (2014) take up
the same quantum-like model for order effect, in order to apply it to a much larger set
of experiments. Here again, answers are supposed to be represented with subspaces of
any dimension. So, the GR equations apply only to the special case of the model in its
non-degenerate version, i. e. when answers are represented with rays as in the model of
Section 2.
5 An empirical glimpse: the GR tests
The previous section has listed several cases in which the GR equations can be tested.
For all cases but Conte et al. (2009), the models have been proposed for any N dimen-
sions, i. e. as either non-degenerate or degenerate. Then, the GR equations can test the
special case of the non-degenerate version of these models, in order to determine whether
this simplest case is sufficient, or if the more general degenerate models are required. This
section is concerned with performing these empirical GR tests. They are done using the
empirical data that are provided in the papers, and which come from either laboratory or
field experiments. To study these empirical data, we divide them into two sets, according
to the topic and the authors: first, in Sections 5.1 to 5.3, we consider the data on exper-
iments about judgment on social or political questions, which enable to test the model
first proposed by Wang and Busemeyer (2013) and considered by Busemeyer and Bruza
(2012), Pothos and Busemeyer (2013), and Wang et al. (2014); second, in Section 5.4, the
data concern an experiment about visual perception, and we test the model proposed by
Conte et al. (2009).
5.1 First data set
Our first data set gathers 72 experiments on order effects, with 70 national surveys
made in the USA plus 2 laboratory experiments:
-- 66 national surveys from the Pew Research Center run between 2001 and 2011 about
politics, religion, economic policy and so on, considered in Wang et al. (2014) (noted
in Table 1 as experiments 1 to 66);
-- 3 surveys from Moore (2002) concerning Gallup public opinion polls (noted as ex-
periments 67 to 69), which are considered in Wang and Busemeyer (2013) and in
Wang et al. (2014) ;
15
Table 1: Questions of the experiments included in the first data set.
1-26 (26 experiments).
A. Do you approve or disapprove of the way Bush/Obama is handling
the job as President?
B. All in all, are you satisfied or dissatisfied with the way things are going
in this country today?
27-41 (15 experiments).
A. Do you approve or disapprove of the job the Republican leaders
in Congress are doing?
B. Do you approve or disapprove of the job the Democratic leaders
in Congress are doing?
42-66 (25 experiments).
These experiments include diverse questions covering topics, from religious
beliefs to support to economic policy.
A. Do you generally think Bill Clinton is honest and trustworthy?
B. Do you generally think Al Gore is honest and trustworthy?
67.
68.
A. Do you think Newt Gingrich is honest and trustworthy?
B. Do you think Bob Dole is honest and trustworthy?
69 and 70.
A. Do you think that only a few or many white people dislike black people?
B. Do you think that only a few or many black people dislike white people?
71.
72.
A. Do you generally favor or oppose affirmative action (AA) programs for
racial minorities?
B. Do you generally favor or oppose affirmative action (AA) programs for
women?
A. Do you think it should be possible for a pregnant woman to obtain
a legal abortion if she is married and does not want any more children?
B. Do you think it should be possible for a pregnant woman to obtain
a legal abortion if there is a strong chance of serious defect in the baby?
-- 2 laboratory experiments conducted by Wang and Busemeyer (2013). In the first
experiment, the authors replicate in a laboratory setting the experiment proposed
by Moore (2002) about racial hostility, whereas, in the second one, they replicate
the survey of Wilson et al. (2008) (experiments 70 and 71) ;
-- one further Gallup survey reported by Schuman and Presser (1981), also considered
in Wang et al. (2014) (experiment 72).
Figure 4 reports the box plot of the distribution of the total number of subjects per
experiment. The median experiment (741 subjects) is thus supposed to involve half of the
samples (about 370 subjects) in the A-then-B treatment and the remaining half in the
B-then-A treatment. The circle on the left part of the box-plot, outside the left whisker,
pinpoints the two laboratory experiments 70 and 71, which involve the smallest sample,
that is, 228 subjects.
16
0
500
1000
1500
2000
Figure 4: Distribution of number of subjects per experiment.
Each experiment can be described according to the following common model and no-
tations: two response categorical variables,
-- the Bernoulli random variable A ∈ {a0, a1} that represents the possible replies (re-
spectively "yes" or "no") to the dichotomous question A,
-- the Bernoulli random variable B ∈ {b0, b1} that represents the possible replies (re-
spectively "yes" or "no") to the dichotomous question B,
and one explanatory categorical variables,
-- the variable O ∈ {0, 1} that represents the order of appearance of the questions --
0 for the A-then-B order and 1 for the B-then-A order.
Empirically, what is observed is not conditional probabilities like p(bjai), but joint fre-
quencies n(ai, bj), that is, the outcome of the counting process of the people responding
i to the first question A and then j to the second question B (the order matters in this
notation: n(bj, ai) refers to the B-then-A experiment). This information can be reported
as a contingency table (Table 2).
Table 2: The contingency table of a generic experiment.
O = 0
O = 1
A = a0
A = a1
B = b0
n(a0, b0)
n(a1, b0)
B = b1
n(a0, b1)
n(a1, b1)
B = b0
n(b0, a0)
n(b0, a1)
B = b1
n(b1, a0)
n(b1, a1)
Validity conditions for hypothesis testing are sensitive to the number of counts -- it
is commonly required at least 5 counts for the joint frequencies. To this end, Table 3
reports some statistical information about the distributions of the joint frequencies over
the 72 experiments.
In particular, Table 3 focuses on the region of the distributions
corresponding to small values: the rows report the first decile of each distribution (D1 -
10%), the smallest number of subjects occurred in one experiment (min) and the number
of experiments presenting a joint frequency value lower than 5. Summarizing, more than
90% of the experiments have joint frequency values greater or equal to 5, 5 out of 8 joint
frequencies never present values less than 5, and only 6 experiments present for only one
joint frequency a value smaller than 5.
17
Table 3: Descriptive statistics for the joint frequencies.
n(a0, b0) n(a0, b1) n(a1, b0) n(a1, b1) n(b0, a0) n(b0, a1) n(b1, a0) n(b1, a1)
D1
min
n<5
33
6
0
19
5
0
5
2
4
47
19
0
30
11
0
9
2
1
17
3
1
47
14
0
5.2 The statistical test
The aim of our statistical study is to study the validity of quantum-like modeling on
order effect experiments by testing the theoretical GR equations (eq. 18 and 19). As they
are equivalent, we focus on the first set of equations,
p(b0a0) = p(a0b0) = p(b1a1) = p(a1b1).
(35)
The conditional probabilities, which are not observable, are estimated by considering con-
ditional relative frequencies f (aibj) and f (bjai), under the hypothesis that relative fre-
quencies converge to probabilities when the number of people involved in the experiment
tends to infinity. Eq. 35 is equivalent to 6 two-by-two comparisons:
T1:
T2:
T3:
T4:
T5:
T6:
f (b0a0) = f (a0b0),
f (b0a0) = f (b1a1),
f (b0a0) = f (a1b1),
f (a0b0) = f (b1a1),
f (a0b0) = f (a1b1),
f (b1a1) = f (a1b1).
(36)
(37)
(38)
(39)
(40)
(41)
(cid:16) y
(cid:17)
Each test is to compare two conditional relative frequencies y and x, with the null
hypothesis that they are equal.12 From a statistical viewpoint, it is convenient to per-
, or even whether the
form an equivalent test in terms of logits:
1−y
= 0. The
natural logarithm of the odds ratio is equal to zero:
sampling distribution of the log odds ratio X, under the hypothesis of the large sample
approximation, is approximately normal: X ∼ N(log(OR), σ2). Instead of conditional
relative frequencies, the log odds ratio can be easily expressed equivalently in terms of
joint frequencies (cf. Appendix A). For instance, instead of computing the first statistical
test (eq. 36), we can perform the following test:
log(OR) = log
(cid:16) x(1−y)
(1−x)y
= log
(cid:17)
log
(cid:17)
(cid:16) x
1−x
(cid:18) n(a0, b0)n(b0, a1)
(cid:19)
n(a0, b1)n(b0, a0)
log(OR) = log
= 0.
(42)
A continuity correction is also applied, because the normal approximation to the binomial
is used, which is effective in particular for small values of n(ai, bj) or n(bj, ai). The above
test becomes:
(cid:18) (n(a0, b0) + 0.5)(n(b0, a1) + 0.5)
(cid:19)
= 0.
(43)
log(OR) = log
(n(a0, b1) + 0.5)(n(b0, a0) + 0.5)
12 Note that there is some arbitrariness in the comparison of the number of a test between two experi-
ments, as it depends on our labeling of both "a/b" and "0/1". For instance, an experiment which fails T1
would fail T6 if it were labeled differently, and similarly for T2 with T5, and T3 with T4.
18
We suppose here that
log(OR)
SElogOR
∼ N(0, 1),
(44)
where SElogOR is the standard error of the log odds ratio. It is estimated as the square root
of the sum of the inverse of all the joint frequencies that are considered in the estimation
of the OR:
SElogOR =
1
n(a0, b0)
+
1
n(b0, a1)
+
1
n(a0, b1)
+
1
n(b0, a0)
.
(45)
Finally, a Bonferroni correction of the type I error is adopted because of the multiple
comparisons (six). Note that this statistical correction is a very conservative one, which
means that it makes false positive rejections much less liable to occur. Concretely, the two-
tailed test implies the null hypothesis of equality between the two conditional frequencies
at the K% significance level is rejected if:
(cid:115)
(cid:18)
p-value = 2 ·
1 − CDFstdNorm
≤ K
100
(46)
(cid:18)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) log(OR)
SElogOR
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:19)(cid:19)
where CDFstdNorm is the cumulative distribution function of the standard normal distribu-
tion (mean = 0 and standard deviation = 1). Finally, we test by estimating the adjusted
p-value based on the Bonferroni correction, with
adjusted p-value = 6 · p-value.
(47)
5.3 Results on the first data set
Table 7 in Appendix B reports the adjusted p-values of the tests (columns) for each of
the 72 experiments (rows). Recall that only one rejection of the six tests T1-T6 is sufficient
for a non-degenerate quantum-like model to be considered as empirically inadequate. In
this sense, satisfying 5 tests over 6 is not more desirable than satisfying 1 -- this is an
all-or-nothing problem, or a "zero-or-non-zero" rejection matter.
First, let us take a general viewpoint on the rejection question. Some summary statis-
tics are provided in Table 4 relative to the distribution of number of test rejections per
experiment. The rejection rate per experiment is high, above 3. The distribution of the
test rejections is highly skewed with respect to a uniform distribution. More than 75%
of the experiments (Q1 - first quartile) reject half or more than half of the 6 tests and
both the median and the mode are equal to 4. The key point is that the first decile
(D1) is equal to 1, that is, more than 90% of the experiments exhibit at least one test
rejection, thus confirming the hypothesis that quantum-like modeling in which one dimen-
sional subspaces (rays) represent answers to questions is not empirically adequate for the
experiments considered in this first data set.
Second, it is possible to have an individual analysis of the experiments: as the last
column of Table 7 (Appendix B) reports the experiment identifier (exp ID) adopted in
Table 1, it is possible to track each question in the ranked-based list of experiments.
For each experimental protocol (laboratory or field experiments, Gallup or Pew Research
Center surveys and different authors), at least one experiment rejects at least one test,
which shows that the result of non-satisfaction is robust also against experimental settings
and questions. For instance, the two laboratory experiments (70 and 71) of the data set
exhibit one test rejection -- as they involve the smallest subject pools, one can conjecture
that a higher number of test rejections would occur with more subjects involved.
19
Table 4: Descriptive statistics for the number of test rejections per experiment.
mean
mode
Q3 (75%)
median
Q1 (25%)
D1 (10%)
3.63
4
5
4
3
1
Figure 5: Scatterplot of the number of test rejections versus the size of the subject pool.
The red triangles pinpoint the 7 experiments with 0 test rejections, the green plus (+) the
two overlapping laboratory experiments.
7 out of the 72 experiments exhibit zero rejections. From a statistical viewpoint,
they all satisfy the validity condition of the test in terms of joint frequency values, that
is more than 5 counts. These experiments have adjusted p-values for all joint frequencies
significantly greater than the 5% significance level. Further investigation would be required
to understand the rationale of the occurrence of no test rejection in these experiments, in
order to exclude spurious statistical arguments. As a first step, Figure 5 plots the number
of test rejections against the size of the subject pool among the experiments. The plot
suggests that low subject pools (say, below 500) tend to reject less tests. It also suggests
that it would be interesting to replicate these 7 experiments with a larger subject pool
(say, 1000 or 1500), to check whether they still verify all the tests.
An important point is however the following one: all 7 polls that do satisfy all GR tests
actually display no order effect (cf. Table 5)13. Yet, it is well-known that data sets that
display no order effect can be accounted for by classical models and that quantum-like
ones are not needed, whether degenerate or not. In other words, in the 7 cases in which
non-degenerate quantum-like models can account for the data, quantum-like models are
13The data that can be obtained from Wang et al. (2014), together with their statistical tests, easily
enable to test the absence of an order effect.
20
500100015000123456sample size# test rejections Table 5: p-values for the order effect tests performed over the 7 experiments that do satisfy
the GR equations. The null hypothesis of absence of order effect cannot be rejected.
exp ID
p-value
26
0.33
27
0.85
42
0.17
43
0.62
44
0.94
47
0.18
51
0.38
actually not needed. Hence, in all the 72 polls considered in this first data set, no non-
degenerate quantum-like model is needed or, when needed, is possible.
Let us now sum up the consequences for each paper. The 6 experiments considered
in Wang and Busemeyer (2013) fail at least one GR test, and thus we can safely say that
they cannot be accounted for with a non-degenerate quantum-like model. For instance,
their 2D figures with rays cannot be considered as representations of the model for their
data, but instead should be thought as an illustrative toy model. Of course, as Wang
and Busemeyer (2013) allow their model to be either degenerate or non-degenerate, there
remains the possibility to account for the data with a degenerate version of the model, but
our GR test is not able to pronounce on that option (cf. Section 6 for a further discussion).
Among the 66 extra experiments considered in Wang et al. (2014), which all come
from the PEW Research Center, a very large majority, 59, fail at least one test and the
same consequence holds: they cannot be accounted for with a non-degenerate quantum-like
model either. Similarly, as Wang et al. (2014) allow their models to be either degenerate or
non-degenerate, we do not claim here that they are wrong but only that the non-degenerate
versions are not empirically adequate for these data -- there remains the theoretical pos-
sibility of degenerate versions of the model. 7 experiments remain that can be accounted
for with a non-degenerate model (it would be interesting to replicate these experiments
with a larger number of subjects, to check whether this still holds), but as they display no
order effect, a quantum-like model is actually not needed here and a classical model could
account for them.
5.4 Second data set: Conte et al. (2009)
This section considers the experiments conducted by Conte et al. (2009) about visual
perception. The validity conditions of the statistical test are not fully met because the
number of subjects per experiment is around 60, posing the issue of statistical significance
for such a small sample.
In particular, the statistical requirement of at least 5 counts
for each joint frequency is not always met in this data set. However, for the sake of
completeness, the statistical tests are reported here.14
4 distinct experiments are performed, each comprising two treatments involving a pop-
ulation of 19 to 22 year-old students. The first treatment of each experiment involves a
group of subjects exposed only to test A, whereas the second one to test B and "soon
after" to test A. Only the second (52 subjects) and the third (64 subjects) experiments
implement the same visual task (subjects have to look at ambiguous figures of animal),
but exchanging tests A and B. Therefore, by considering only the treatment/group 2 of
these two experiments, the full GR equations can be tested.
14An experiment similar to the one reported in Conte et al. (2009) is mentioned in Khrennikov (2010,
p. 79-86). However, we prefer to focus on the former because in the latter (i) the number of subjects
involved is still lower and (ii) as no reverse order in the questions is considered, data is lacking to fully test
the GR equations.
21
Table 6: Experiments of Conte et al.
rejection is highlighted at the 5% significance level.
(2009), adjusted p-values for the 6 tests. The
T1
4.300
T3
T2
2.404 0.029 3.782
T4
T5
0.079
T6
0.268
Table 6 reports the adjusted p-values for the 6 tests. As the third test is rejected
at the 5% significance level, we can conclude that a quantum-like non-degenerate model
does not adequately fit the experimental data.15 Here, too, the small size of the sample
is associated with a small number of test rejections. A more rigorous empirical test of
the GR equations would require a larger subject pool. Anyway, as the model proposed by
Conte et al. (2009) is supposed to be only non-degenerate, we can already say that it fails
and cannot be said to be empirically adequate for the reported data.
6 Discussion: degenerate models and the future of quantum-
like research on order effect
This paper has been concerned with the quantum-like models that have been recently
proposed to account for question order effect. So far, many of them have been proposed
in the most general way, either as non-degenerate or as degenerate, while it was suggested
that degenerate models would be probably required. We settled on the project to document
this empirically, by testing whether the non-degenerate versions of the models could be
sufficient. To this end, we have advocated the test of novel predictions of the models,
which are equivalent to the law of reciprocity: the GR equations. After performing the
test against available data, the result is quite clear: non-degenerate models are not an
option, being not empirically adequate or not needed. This confirms the suggestions from
the literature (cf.
footnote 1) that they are too simple to be empirically adequate and
should be considered as toy models only.
As we have also made it clear, our results do not rule out all quantum-like models:
degenerate versions of the model, to which the GR equations do not apply, have not
been tested here. So, a natural line of research is now to turn to degenerate quantum-like
models, where answers are represented by sub-spaces of dimension 2 or larger. For instance,
this is the solution adopted by Busemeyer, Wang and Lambert-Mogiliansky (2009): after
showing that a 2D quantum-like model is not doubly stochastic (which implies that it does
not respect our GR equations), they switch to a 4D model.16
A strong suggestion in favor of this line of research comes from the following fact.
While the GR equations are violated on a vast majority of experimental data sets, the
QQ equality is experimentally verified in all these cases (for the data considered in Wang
and Busemeyer 2013 and Wang et al. 2014). Recall that the QQ equality is valid for
quantum-like models of the kind considered here, whether they are degenerate or not (cf.
Section 3.4). It is just an empirical prediction they all have to satisfy. Also, Wang and
15As the GR equations are not satisfied, neither is double-stochasticity in both senses (cf. Section 3.3).
(2009) fail to follow double-stochasticity is noted by
Actually, the fact that the data of Conte et al.
Khrennikov (2010, 107 and 114).
16However, note that their 4D model is not just a degenerate version of their 2D model, as it adds some
time evolution of the state between the two questions. On another question than order effect, namely
the account for the conjunction fallacy, Franco (2009) considers a non-degenerate 2D model only, while
Busemeyer et al. (2011) considers n-dimensional ones, which can be degenerate.
22
Busemeyer (2009, Section 6) have argued that other kinds of models, like Bayesian or
Markov ones, do not generally satisfy the QQ equality, which gives good grounds to think
that some quantum-like model could account for the data (cf. also Wang et al. 2014). As
our present results exclude non-degenerate models, the hopes are now on the degenerate
ones. Overall, the following tests might be made on a data set of question order effect:
1) test the QQ equality; if it is violated, no quantum-like model (of the sort considered
in this paper) can account for it; if it is not violated, it gives good grounds to think (but
does not prove) that a degenerate or non-degenerate quantum-like model can account for
it; 2) test the GR equations; if they are violated, no non-degenerate quantum-like model
can account for the data; if they are not, one can.
However, in our view, the route of degenerate models is not necessarily an easy one, and
we would like to recommend that some research be done about their empirical adequacy.
First, degenerate models are not a priori freed from any constraint, and this is the point
on which we would like to insist very much. One should not consider that, when a data
set satisfies the QQ equality and violates the GR equations, the solution safely lies in
a degenerate model. The moral of our paper should be taken as insisting on the need
to empirically test all quantum-like models. Note that we do not just call for running
more experiments; all the tests we have done here have been made on available data, and
could have been made beforehand. Importantly, empirical adequacy does not only mean
applying to a vast number of empirical cases, but also, for one experimental case, making
correct predictions in all respects, and for that it is crucial to pull the threads of all possible
predictions. Here, we have found simple and ready-to-use tests for non-degenerate models,
and we suspect that some other constraints apply to degenerate models. Research is
urgently needed here to find general tests. At least, when a degenerate model is proposed
to account for some features of a data set, we suggest that all parameters be specified
and that serious efforts be directed towards empirically testing this model by unveiling
experimental predictions that lie outside the feature one intends to explain, so as to prevent
later "bad surprises".
A promising way to test degenerate models has already been indicated in the end of
Section 3.2: degenerate eigenspaces may actually encompass non-degenerate and more
fundamental eigenspaces, that correspond to fundamental elementary questions -- to be
identified. If such elementary questions exist, and the quantum-like literature seems not
to have doubts on that, all degenerate models can actually be tested against generalized
GR equations for these more fundamental questions. In other words, our GR test for non-
degenerate models can possibly apply at a fundamental level for all degenerate models,
provided elementary questions are identified.17 We are ready to admit, however, that the
fundamental dimensions and the corresponding tests can be hard to uncover.
The need to specify the elementary dimensions of the Hilbert space for degenerate
models is also required by other arguments. Introducing dimensions of degeneracy should
be justified, so as not to be accused of being just ad hoc. As Pothos and Busemeyer (2013,
p. 215) write, "Dimensionality is not a free parameter". In quantum physics for instance,
degeneration is usually theoretically justified with a symmetry in the Hamiltonian, and
the degeneration can be experimentally removed by introducing some factor that was
not present (e.g., the spin degeneration is removed by introducing a magnetic field). For
quantum-like judgment models as well, one should provide a similar theoretical justification
and an experimental way of removing the degeneration. In this respect, the idea that there
17These generalized GR equations for elementary questions might help to establish the constraints that
degenerate models must satisfy in general, but for non-elementary questions, that have been discussed in
the above paragraph.
23
exists fundamental questions and rays will certainly be helpful; the work is then to find
out which fundamental dimensions are hidden behind the degenerate eigenspace.
Overall, all this argues against the view that switching to degenerate models when
GR equations are violated would be a natural or unquestioned move to have and that it
would solve all problems. Instead, supplementary dimensions should be justified, probably
with elementary questions, and other predictions of the model than those one intends to
account for should be investigated and tested, possibly with generalized GR equations.
Beyond degenerate quantum-like models in the flavor of the model presented in Sec-
tion 2, there are also other possible lines of research around quantum ideas. For instance,
Khrennikov has proposed to consider hyperbolic Hilbert space models, instead of complex
ones like in this paper. Hyperbolic models enable probabilities that are not constrained in
the same way, and can account for some data that are out of reach for complex quantum-
like models (see Khrennikov 2010 for a synthesis). Also, other tools than projectors, like
POVMs, could be considered; or other axioms of standard quantum-like models, like the
projection postulate or the Born rule, could be abandoned or modified.
To conclude, quantum-like models have brought to discussion many provoking and
seminal ideas, such as the hypotheses that judgments or preferences might be undetermined
instead of only unknown, or that non-classical probabilities could be considered. We have
insisted on the need to empirically test existing models for question order effect, and our
results suggest that non-degenerate quantum-like models should be considered more as
toy models than as empirically adequate models, in accordance with suggestions from the
literature, and that future investigations should focus on degenerate models. In spite of
the potential difficulties that such models face, there is plenty of room for future research
in the area, and besides our results can be taken as posing a challenge liable to trigger a
revival of the discussion on quantum-like models of various sorts.
Acknowledgments
Many thanks to Camille Aron, Jerome R. Busemeyer, Sophie Dubois, Dorian Jullien,
Corrado Lagazio, Ariane Lambert-Mogiliansky, Gabriel Lemari´e, Zheng J. Wang, and
to the audience from conferences at the MSHS du Sud-Est (Nice, France) and at the
Toronto Fields Institute (Canada) for valuable comments or suggestions. Of course, we
are solely responsible for our analysis and conclusions. We further thank Zheng J. Wang,
Tyler Solloway, Richard M. Shiffrin, and Jerome R. Busemeyer who kindly gave us the
opportunity to use their data set to perform our tests.
References
Aerts, Diederik, Jan Broekaert, Marek Czachor and Bart D'Hooghe (2011), "A
Quantum-Conceptual Explanation of Violations of Expected Utility in Economics",
Quantum Interaction. Lecture Notes in Computer Science 7052: 192-198.
Aerts, Diederik, Liane Gabora and Sandro Sozzo (2013), "Concepts and Their Dy-
namics: A Quantum-Theoretic Modeling of Human Thought", Topics in Cognitive
Sciences 5: 737 -- 772.
Allais, Maurice (1953), "Le comportement de l'homme rationnel devant le risque : cri-
tique des postulats et axiomes de l'´ecole Am´ericaine", Econometrica 21:503 -- 546.
Ashby, F. Gregory and Nancy A. Perrin (1988), "Towards a unified theory of similarity
and recognition", Psychological Review, 95:124 -- 50.
24
Ashtiani, Mehrdad and Mohammad A. Azgomi (2015), "A survey of quantum-like ap-
proaches to decision making and cognition", Mathematical Social Sciences 75: 49 -- 80.
Atmanspacher, Harald and Hartmann Romer (2012), "Order effects in sequential mea-
surements of non-commuting psychological observables", Journal of Mathematical
Psychology 56: 274-280.
Busemeyer, Jerome R. and Peter D. Bruza (2012), Quantum models of Cognition and
Decision, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Busemeyer, Jerome R., Emmanuel M. Pothos, Riccardo Franco and Jennifer S. True-
blood (2011), "A Quantum Theoretical Explanation for Probability Judgment Er-
rors", Psychological Review 118 (2): 193 -- 218.
Busemeyer, Jerome R., Zheng J. Wang (2007), "Quantum information processing expla-
nation for interactions between inferences and decisions", in: D. Bruza, W. Lawless, K.
van Rijsbergen and D.A. Sofge (eds.), Quantum Interaction: Papers from the AAAI
Spring Symposium, Technical Report SS-07-08, AAAI Press, p. 91 -- 97.
Busemeyer, Jerome R., Zheng J. Wang, and Ariane Lambert-Mogiliansky (2009),
"Empirical comparison of Markov and quantum models of decision making", Journal
of Mathematical Psychology 53: 423 -- 433.
Busemeyer, Jerome R., Zheng J. Wang, Emmanuel M. Pothos and Jennifer S. True-
blood (2015), "The Conjunction Fallacy, Confirmation, and Quantum Theory: Com-
ment on Tentori, Crupi, and Russo (2013)", Journal of Experimental Psychology:
General 144(1): 236-243.
Busemeyer, Jerome R., Zheng J. Wang, and James T. Townsend (2006), "Quantum
dynamics of human decision-making", Journal of Mathematical Psychology 50 (3):
220-241.
Conte, Elio, Andrei Yuri Khrennikov, Orlando Todarello, Antonio Federici, Leonardo
Mendolicchio, and Joseph P. Zbilut (2009), "Mental States Follow Quantum Me-
chanics During Perception and Cognition of Ambiguous Figures", Open Systems &
Information Dynamics 16(1) 1 -- 17.
Danilov, Vladimir I. and Ariane Lambert-Mogiliansky (2008), "Measurable systems
and behavioral sciences", Mathematical Social Sciences 55(3): 315 -- 340.
Danilov, Vladimir I. and Ariane Lambert-Mogiliansky (2010), "Expected utility the-
ory under non-classical uncertainty", Theory and Decision 68(1): 25 -- 47.
Ellsberg, Daniel (1961), "Risk, ambiguity, and the Savage axioms", Quarterly Journal
of Economics 75(4): 643 -- 669.
Franco, Riccardo (2009), "The conjunction fallacy and interference effects", Journal of
Mathematical Psychology 53: 415 -- 422.
Gavanski, Igor and David R. Roskos-Ewoldsen (1991), "Representativeness and con-
joint probability", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 61:181 -- 94.
Khrennikov, Andrei (2010), Ubiquitous Quantum Structure. From Psychology to Fi-
nance, Heildelberg: Springer.
Khrennikov, Andrei and Emmanuel Haven (2009), "Quantum mechanics and violations
of the sure-thing principle: The use of probability interference and other concepts",
Journal of Mathematical Psychology 53: 378-388.
Krumhansl, Carol L. (1978), "Concerning the applicability of geometric models to similar-
ity data: The interrelationship between similarity and spatial density", Psychological
Review 85:445 -- 63.
Lambert-Mogiliansky, Ariane, Shmuel Zamir and Herv´e Zwirn (2009), "Type inde-
terminacy: A model of the KT(Kahneman -- Tversky)-man", Journal of Mathematical
Psychology 53:349 -- 361.
25
Moore, David W. (2002), "Measuring new types of question-order effects", Public Opinion
Quarterly, 66: 80 -- 91.
Peres, Asher (1993), Quantum Theory: Concepts and Methods, Kluwer.
Pothos, Emmanuel M. and Jerome R. Busemeyer (2009), "A quantum probability ex-
planation for violations of 'rational' decision theory", Proceedings of the Royal Society
B 276:2171-2178.
Pothos, Emmanuel M. and Jerome R. Busemeyer (2011), "A quantum probability ex-
planation for violations of symmetry in similarity judgments", Proceedings of the 32nd
Annual conference of the Cognitive Science Society 2848-2854.
Pothos, Emmanuel M. and Jerome R. Busemeyer (2013), "Can quantum probability
provide a new direction for cognitive modeling?", Behavioral and Brain Sciences 36:
255 -- 327.
Schuman, Howard and Stanley Presser (1981), Questions and answers in attitude sur-
veys: Experiments on question form, wording, and context, Academic Press.
Shafir, Eldar and Amos Tversky (1992), "Thinking through uncertainty: nonconse-
quential reasoning and choice", Cognitive Psychology 24:449 -- 74.
Stolarz-Fantino, Stepanie, Edmund Fantino, Daniel J. Zizzo, and Julie Wen (2003),
"The conjunction effect: New evidence for robustness", American Journal of Psychol-
ogy 116(1):15 -- 34.
Tourangeau, Roger, Lance J. Rips and Kenneth A. Rasinski (2000), The psychology
of survey response, Cambridge University Press.
Trueblood Jennifer S. and Jerome R. Busemeyer (2011), "A Quantum Probability
Account of Order Effects in Inference", Cognitive Science 35: 1518 -- 1552.
Tversky, Amos (1977), "Features of similarity", Psychological Review 84(4): 327 -- 52.
Tversky, Amos and Daniel Kahneman (1982), "Judgments of and by representative-
ness", in: Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases, ed. by D. Kahneman,
P. Slovic & A. Tversky, p. 84 -- 98, Cambridge University Press.
-- (1983), "Extensional versus intuitive reasoning: The conjunction fallacy in probability
judgment", Psychological Review 90(4): 293 -- 315.
Wang, Zheng J. and Jerome R. Busemeyer (2013), "A quantum question order model
supported by empirical tests of an a priori and precise prediction", Topics in Cognitive
Science 5(4): 689 -- 710.
Wang, Zheng J., Tyler Solloway, Richard M. Shiffrin and Jerome R. Busemeyer
(2014), "Context effects produced by question orders reveal quantum nature of human
judgments", PNAS, www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1407756111.
Wilson, David C., David W. Moore, Patrick F. McKay, and Derek R. Avery (2008),
"Affirmative action programs for women and minorities", Public Opinion Quarterly
72(3), 514-522.
Yukalov, Vyacheslav I. and Didier Sornette (2011), "Decision theory with prospect
interference and entanglement", Theory and Decision, 70: 283 -- 328.
26
A Testing the equality of two conditional relative frequen-
cies
The statistical test is to compare two conditional relative frequencies y and x, with the
null hypothesis that they are equal. The test is therefore
y = x,
(48)
where both y and x are observed conditional relative frequencies.
Testing equation 48 is equivalent to test
(cid:18) y
(cid:19)
(cid:18) x
(cid:19)
log
1 − y
= log
1 − x
,
given that y and x are not equal to zero.
Alternatively, we can formulate the test in terms of the log odds ratio (OR)
log(OR) = log
Now let us suppose that we want to test
(cid:32) y
(cid:33)
1−y
x
1−x
= 0.
We can thus test the following condition:
log
or
f (a0b0) = f (b0a0).
(cid:18) f (a0b0)
(cid:18) f (a0b0)
1 − f (a0b0)
(cid:19)
(cid:19)
log
f (a1b0)
(cid:18) f (b0a0)
(cid:19)
(cid:18) f (b0a0)
1 − f (b0a0)
f (b1a0)
.
= log
= log
(49)
(cid:19)
,
By expressing the conditional relative frequencies in terms of joint frequencies, that is,
f (a0b0) =
n(b0, a0)
n(b0,·)
, f (b0a0) =
n(a0, b0)
n(a0,·)
, . . .
being n(b0,·) and n(a0,·) the marginal frequencies of B and A, respectively, we obtain
(cid:18) n(b0, a0)
n(b0,·)
log
or simplifying
(cid:19)
,
n(a0,·)
n(a0, b1)
(cid:19)
(cid:18) n(a0, b0)
(cid:19)
n(a0,·)
n(b0,·)
n(b0, a1)
= log
(cid:18) n(b0, a0)n(a0, b1)
n(b0, a1)n(a0, b0)
log
= 0.
(50)
We can thus test indifferently eq. 49 or 50.
27
B Results of the tests for the first data set
Table 7: Adjusted p-values of the 6 tests for the 72 experi-
ments of the first data set. The rejection is highlighted at the
5% significance level. The 7th column reports the number of
rejections (#R) at the 5% significance level, and the 8th one
reports the experiment ID (cf. Table 1).
T2
T3
T6
0.975
T4
T5
T1
0.057
0.023 0.000
0.011 0.000 4.718
5.163
0.000 0.001
0.000 0.004 2.652
3.828
0.000 0.033
0.135
0.321
0.191
0.078
0.000
0.000 0.000 0.113
1.151
0.008 0.000
0.000 0.000 1.653
2.138
0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 4.577
0.023 0.006 0.000
0.000 0.000 1.400
0.001
0.180
0.000 0.000 0.001 1.279
0.000
0.024 1.682
0.021 0.000 0.181
0.000
0.006 0.096
0.001 0.000 0.274
0.000
0.000 2.517
0.749
0.000 0.066
0.000 0.000
0.607
0.000 0.000 3.319
0.000 0.000
1.728
0.000 0.000 0.102
0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 1.506
5.892
0.000 0.000 0.002 1.050
0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.032 0.033 0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.014 0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.001 0.002 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.004 0.019 0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.535
0.001 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.001 0.000 0.354
0.000
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.025 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.107
0.037 0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.002 0.000
0.728
4.172
4.213
2.316
5.811
4.289
4.261
3.540
0.150
0.001 0.003 4.611
1.557
0.039 0.072
0.001 0.001 2.092
5.368
0.026 0.070
0.135
0.005 0.000 2.286
1.870
0.427
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 3.896
0.912
0.002 0.068
0.011 2.285
0.000 0.000
0.002 0.000 0.000 0.021
0.012 1.420
0.580
0.074
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.038
0.041 0.035 0.000 0.427
1.382
1.093
0.073
2.913
0.000 0.001 0.000 0.107
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 1.062
0.179
1.373
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 2.482
4.564
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 4.084
Continued on next page
2.708
1.406
1.423
4.154
0.020 0.450
2.720
1.408
0.096
0.082
28
#R at 5% exp ID
4
4
2
3
4
4
5
4
4
4
3
4
4
4
5
6
6
6
6
4
6
5
6
5
6
0
0
1
3
3
2
4
4
5
4
3
3
4
4
4
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
0.181
T3
T4
T5
T6
1.649
2.212
2.414
1.723
5.452
3.554
4.837
4.402
4.837
1.999
Table 7 -- Continued from previous page
T2
T1
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 5.716
1.936
1.343
5.229
2.101
5.188
6.000
5.452
2.212
2.651
5.064
4.249
3.965
1.999
0.055
0.001 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.546
0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.860
0.523
1.039
0.050
3.527
0.036 0.212
0.004 0.044 2.358
0.103
1.537
0.005 0.347
2.185
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000 4.281
1.910
1.939
3.856
3.307
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.025 0.377
0.141
0.003 4.472
0.003 0.003 0.000 0.023
0.035 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.060
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 4.845
5.498
0.046 0.360
0.013 0.125
3.852
0.000 0.000 1.843
0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.043
1.922
0.389
0.001 3.012
0.026 0.000 0.179
0.000 1.570
0.001 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.128
0.003 0.000 0.001 0.004 0.608
2.054
0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 5.106
3.456
0.000 0.000 0.000 3.333
0.012 0.000
0.001 0.000 0.039
0.021 4.789
0.002 0.466
0.000 0.000
0.024 0.011 0.000
0.000 0.000 2.771
0.000 0.000 2.909
0.075
0.000 0.000
0.020 0.000 0.000 0.001 0.004 3.581
2.110
0.038 0.293
4.481
0.332
1.616
0.511
0.115
0.479
0.016 0.000 0.010 0.014 0.654
0.130
0.709
0.008 4.589
0.065
0.027 0.135
5.503
3.163
2.282
4.369
4.872
#R at 5% exp. ID
4
0
0
0
4
4
0
3
1
5
0
4
5
5
4
2
4
5
3
5
4
4
4
5
4
4
5
4
5
1
1
4
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
29
|
1711.10991 | 2 | 1711 | 2017-11-30T13:26:37 | Early processing of consonance and dissonance in human auditory cortex | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Pitch is the perceptual correlate of sound's periodicity and a fundamental property of the auditory sensation. The interaction of two or more pitches gives rise to a sensation that can be characterized by its degree of consonance or dissonance. In the current study, we investigated the neuromagnetic representations of consonant and dissonant musical dyads using a new model of cortical activity, in an effort to assess the possible involvement of pitch-specific neural mechanisms in consonance processing at early cortical stages.
In the first step of the study, we developed a novel model of cortical pitch processing designed to explain the morphology of the pitch onset response (POR), a pitch-specific subcomponent of the auditory evoked N100 component in the human auditory cortex. The model explains the neural mechanisms underlying the generation of the POR and quantitatively accounts for the relation between its peak latency and the perceived pitch.
Next, we applied magnetoencephalography (MEG) to record the POR as elicited by six consonant and dissonant dyads. The peak latency of the POR was strongly modulated by the degree of consonance within the stimuli; specifically, the most dissonant dyad exhibited a POR with a latency that was about 30ms longer than that of the most consonant dyad, an effect that greatly exceeds the expected latency difference induced by a single pitch sound.
Our model was able to predict the POR latency pattern observed in the neuromagnetic data, and to generalize this prediction to additional dyads. These results indicate that the neural mechanisms responsible for pitch processing exhibit an intrinsic differential response to concurrent consonant and dissonant pitch combinations, suggesting that the perception of consonance and dissonance might be an emergent property of the pitch processing system in human auditory cortex. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Early processing of consonance and dissonance in human
auditory cortex
Alejandro Tabas12*, Martin Andermann3*, Valeria Sebold3, Helmut Riedel3, Emili
Balaguer-Ballester14+, and Andr´e Rupp3+
1Faculty of Science and Technology, Bournemouth University; UK
2Max Planck Institute for Human Cognitive and Brain Sciences; Leipzig, Germany
3Biomanetism Section, Heidelberg University; Germany
4Bernstein Center for Computational Neuroscience Heidelberg/Mannheim; Germany
*Joint first author
+Joint last author
Abstract
Pitch is the perceptual correlate of sound's periodicity and a fundamental property of the auditory
sensation. The interaction of two or more pitches gives rise to a sensation that can be characterized
by its degree of consonance or dissonance, an essential element in the perception of highly complex
sound patterns. In the current study, we investigated the neuromagnetic representations of consonant
and dissonant musical dyads using a new model of cortical activity, in an effort to assess the possible
involvement of pitch-specific neural mechanisms in consonance processing at early cortical stages.
In the first step of the study, we developed a novel model of cortical pitch processing designed
to explain the morphology of the pitch onset response (POR), a pitch-specific subcomponent of
the auditory evoked N100 component in the human auditory cortex. The model explains the neu-
ral mechanisms underlying the generation of the POR and quantitatively accounts for the relation
between its peak latency and the perceived pitch.
Furthermore, we applied magnetoencephalography (MEG) to record the POR as elicited by six
consonant and dissonant dyads. The peak latency of the POR was strongly modulated by the degree
of consonance within the stimuli; specifically, the most dissonant dyad exhibited a POR with a
latency that was ∼30 ms longer than that of the most consonant dyad, an effect that greatly exceeds
the expected latency difference induced by a single pitch sound.
Our model was able to predict the POR latency pattern observed in the neuromagnetic data,
and to generalize this prediction to additional dyads that were not included in the MEG experiment.
These results indicate that the neural mechanisms responsible for pitch processing exhibit an intrinsic
differential response to concurrent consonant and dissonant pitch combinations, suggesting that the
perception of consonance and dissonance might be an emergent property of the pitch processing
system in human auditory cortex.
1
Introduction
Pitch is the perceptual correlate of the periodicity in a sound's waveform. It is a fundamental attribute of
auditory sensation that forms the basis of both music and speech perception; consequently, understanding
the neural foundations of pitch is a major challenge in auditory neuroscience.
A combination of two sounds that simultaneously elicits two different pitches is referred to as a
dyad, and the pitch interactions within a dyad give rise to a sensation that can be characterized by its
consonance or dissonance. Loudness, timbre, and the absolute fundamental frequencies of the sounds
can have subtle effects on whether a dyad is perceived as consonant or dissonant; however, the dominant
factor in determining the degree of consonance is the relationship between the fundamental periods of
the sounds that make up the dyad [1]: Simple periodicity ratios result in more consonant sensations;
on the other hand, sensation becomes more and more dissonant as the complexity of the periodicity
1
ratio increases [2 -- 4]. Previously, it was argued that dissonance correlates with the beating, or roughness
sensation that is elicited by the interfering regularities of the involved sounds [2 -- 4]. However, listeners
that showed impaired pitch perception but were sensitive to beating and roughness have been reported
to be unable to differentiate between consonant and dissonant dyads [5, 6]. This suggests that pitch-
rather than roughness-related auditory processing is responsible for the emergence of consonance.
Neurophysiological evidence for a tight link between consonance and pitch has recently been provided
by Bidelman and colleagues [7]; they showed, using electroencephalography (EEG), that the amplitude
of the cortical pitch onset response (POR) is strongly modulated by a dyad's perceived consonance.
The POR is a pitch-selective component of the transient auditory evoked potential/field (AEP/AEF)
that occurs within the time range of the well-known N100 wave [8, 9], around 100 ms after pitch onset.
The morphology of the POR is strongly correlated with the perceived pitch in single tones: its latency
scales linearly with the period of the sound, and its amplitude increases with the strength of the pitch
percept [10 -- 12]. The neural sources of the POR are located in the anterolateral section of Heschl's gyrus
(alHG) in auditory cortex [7,10,11], consistently with the anatomical location of pitch-selective neurons in
non-human primates (e.g., [13 -- 16]), and with pitch-selective regions that were reported for human listen-
ers [17 -- 21]. Further experiments in humans have demonstrated that the dyad-evoked frequency-following
response in the brainstem is predictive for the perceived consonance of a dyad [22 -- 24]; also, functional
magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies showing selective activation to consonance/dissonance con-
trasts in the superior temporal gyrus [25] and in frontal cortex [26] lead the auditory community to link
neural representations of consonance and dissonance with higher, cognitive processes [27].
In this study, we used a combined experimental and theoretical approach to assess whether consonance
and pitch share similar processing mechanisms in human auditory cortex. Towards this goal, we first
developed an innovative, realistic model of cortical ensemble responses to pitch, specifically designed to
understand the mesoscopic representation of pitch in alHG. The model can account, mechanistically, for
the latency effects in the POR that have been robustly reported for decades in multiple experimental
settings [10, 11, 28] but, up to now, remained poorly understood. Second, we recorded the AEF elicited
by consonant and dissonant dyads using magnetoencephalography (MEG); here, our experimental results
revealed a strong correlation between POR latency and the degree of consonance, extending previous
EEG findings [7]. Finally, we aimed to replicate the results from our MEG experiment using our model.
If the hypothesis that consonance and pitch are processed by similar mechanisms in cortex is correct,
we would expect the model to explain the dependence of POR latency on the degree of consonance
without the inclusion of higher processing stages within the auditory hierarchy [25, 26].
In line with
this hypothesis, the model provided a quantitative, mechanistic explanation for the relationship between
POR dynamics and consonance, suggesting that consonance and dissonance perception might be linked
to the pitch processing sub-regions of the auditory cortex.
2 Results
2.1 Neural mechanisms underlying pitch processing in auditory cortex
Model overview We introduced a model of cortical pitch processing designed to explain the mor-
phology of the POR as elicited by the onset of consonant and dissonant dyads (see full description in
Methods). The model consists of three processing stages located at different levels of the auditory hier-
archy. In the first stage, an array of idealized coincidence detector units extracts periodicities from the
auditory nerve activity in response to the target stimulus [29, 30]. Subsequently, the second and third
stages, putatively located at adjacent locations within alHG, generate a stable pitch characterization
from the first stage, previous representation.
Auditory nerve responses were generated by a recent model of the auditory periphery [31,32]; period-
icity detection was implemented using the principles of the autocorrelation models of pitch [29,30,33,34].
At this stage, the representation of the stimulus shows a harmonic shape along the periodicity axis,
with prominent peaks of activation at the neurons which encode the pitch of the stimulus and its lower
harmonics (see Figure 1e).
The array of periodicity detectors provides excitatory input to a first cortical processing stage, termed
the decoder network in this study. The decoder network is putatively located in alHG and effectively
extracts the pitch value(s) from the subcortical input. The decoder network connects to a second
2
a)
s
d
e
l
d
e
k
o
v
e
b)
t
u
o
d
a
e
r
l
a
c
i
t
r
o
c
c)
i
r
e
n
a
t
s
u
s
r
e
d
o
c
e
d
e)
t
u
p
n
i
l
a
c
i
t
r
o
c
)
z
H
(
e
t
a
r
g
n
i
r
e
g
a
r
e
v
a
60
40
20
0
0
0
1
2
y
t
i
v
i
t
c
a
.
c
x
e
e
v
i
t
c
e
l
l
o
c
)
z
H
(
r
e
d
o
c
e
d
e
h
t
n
i
perceived pitch: 250Hz (T = 4ms)
perceived pitch: 125Hz (T = 8ms)
perceived pitch: 83Hz (T = 12ms)
predicted POR latency
(minus cortical onset)
predicted POR latency
(minus cortical onset)
predicted POR latency
(minus cortical onset)
0
50
100
150
0
50
100
150
0
50
100
150
200
time after cortical onset (ms)
time after cortical onset (ms)
time after cortical onset (ms)
)
z
H
(
e
t
a
r
g
n
i
r
e
g
a
r
e
v
a
80
60
40
20
0
0
5
10
15
20
25
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
5
10
15
20
25
30
characteristic period of the population (ms)
characteristic period of the population (ms)
characteristic period of the population (ms)
d)
)
s
m
l
(
n
o
i
t
a
u
p
o
p
c
i
t
p
a
n
y
s
t
s
o
p
e
h
t
f
o
d
o
i
r
e
p
c
i
t
s
i
r
e
t
c
a
r
a
h
c
5
10
15
20
25
30
5
10
15
20
25
30
decoder exc-to-inh
1
5
10
15
20
25
30
presynaptic period (ms)
decoder inh-to-exc
i
t
h
g
e
w
y
t
i
v
i
t
c
e
n
n
o
c
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
presynaptic period (ms)
perceived pitch
rst lower harmonic
second lower harmonic
perceived pitch
rst lower
harmonic
5
10
15
20
25
30
5
10
15
20
25
30
5
10
15
20
25
30
characteristic period of the population (ms)
characteristic period of the population (ms)
characteristic period of the population (ms)
Figure 1: Basic schematics of the model. a) Average response across populations of the excitatory
ensembles of the decoder network, accounting for the evoked fields in the cortical sources of the POR,
in response to three stimuli with different pitches. Stimuli were iterated rippled noises (16 iterations,
bandpass filtered between 0.8 and 3.2 kHz) with pitches: 250 Hz, 125 Hz, and 83 Hz. b) Excitatory ac-
tivation, averaged between 150 and 200 ms after sound onset, in the different ensembles of the decoder
network elicited by the same stimuli as above. c) Model architecture. d) Connectivity weights between
excitatory and inhibitory ensembles in the decoder network. e) Typical input to the decoder correspond-
ing to the three IRN stimuli used above, averaged between 150 and 200 ms after sound onset (see also
Supplementary Video S1).
3
cortical ensembles network, termed sustainer ; this stage integrates the decoder network output and
modulates it through cortico-cortical top-down efferents. The sustainer reinforces and sustains the
decoder mechanism, reminiscent to recent models of perceptual decision making [35].
Both decoder and sustainer comprise a network of cortical microcolumns, each of which is tuned to a
specific pitch value along the human perceptual range (see Methods for details). Pitch is encoded in the
active pitch-selective populations of the processing network (see Figure 1b), in agreement with cortical
recordings in non-human mammals [15, 36, 37].
Microcolumns in the cortical networks are modelled as blocks comprising an excitatory and inhibitory
neural ensemble (see Figure 1c). Ensembles communicate with each other through realistic synapses.
Connectivity weights between populations in the decoder network (see Figure 1e) are specifically tuned to
facilitate the inhibition of the lower harmonics elicited in the periodicity detectors (see Figure 2; a video
detailing the integration process is available in Supplementary Video S1). Similar connectivity patterns
have been consistently found in the mammalian auditory cortex (see [38] for a review); moreover, neurons
mapping harmonic templates to a pitch-selective representation like those introduced in this model have
been recently reported in the primate auditory cortex [16].
The detailed formulation of the model allows us to perform quantitative predictions regarding the
neuromagnetic field that are elicited by the activation of each of the cortical networks within the model
(Figure 1b). More specifically, the equivalent dipole moment elicited by each of the networks is monoton-
ically related to the aggregated excitatory activation of its ensembles [39] (see Methods for details), while
the characteristic period of the excitatory population with the largest activity in the network corresponds
to the perceived pitch (see Figures 3b and c). Below, we will argue that the characteristic responses of
the decoder network during pitch processing can be identified with the responses of the neural sources
of the POR.
Dynamics of the decoder network Figure 2 illustrates an example of the model dynamics in re-
sponse to a stimulus with a pitch corresponding to T = 4 ms (i.e., f = 250 Hz; details are shown in
Supplementary Video S1). In a first step, periodicity detectors, tuned to T ≃ 4 ms, become active after
t1 ∼ 1.25 T [40] (see the top prominent horizontal line at T = 4 ms in Figure 2a). These active neurons
provide the bottom-up excitatory input to the excitatory ensemble in the corresponding decoder net-
work column (see Figure 2b). Likewise, the harmonics of the stimulus' period (i.e., 2 T , 3 T etc.) are
subsequently represented in the subcortical model after t2 = 2 t1, t3 = 3 t1 etc., and provide the input
to the corresponding excitatory populations in the decoder network (see Figure 2b).
Excitatory ensembles characterized by the periods of the harmonic series {T, 2 T 3 T . . . } are con-
nected to inhibitory neural populations identified by the fundamental period T (see Figure 1). Synaptic
efficacy is tuned such that the inhibitory drive is strong enough to elicit activity only when a sufficient
number of excitatory inputs (typically 3) are simultaneously active, thus providing robustness to the
upcoming decoding process. Thus, the inhibitory population characterized by T ≃ 4 ms becomes ac-
tive only when it receives simultaneous synaptic drive from the excitatory ensembles characterizing the
periods T = 4 ms, 2T = 8 ms, and 3T = 12 ms (see Figure 2C).
Correspondingly, the inhibitory ensemble associated with the period T is connected to the excitatory
populations encoding the lower harmonics {2 T, 3 T, 4 T, . . . } (see Figure 1). Thus, when active, the
inhibitory activity progressively silences populations that are activated by the periodicity detectors but
that do not correspond to the fundamental period of the stimulus (see the shunting process in the decoder
excitatory network between 60 ms and 100 ms in Figure 2b).
The processing dynamics described above explains the neural mechanisms underlying the morphology
of the POR. The aggregated excitatory activity in the decoder, monotonically related to the neuromag-
netic fields elicited by this network, is shown in Figure 2f. The accumulation of excitatory activity
corresponding to the harmonic series of the period of the stimulus T results in the increase of the simu-
lated field magnitude observed between 10 ms and 65 ms in Figure 2f. The subsequent decay of the model
collective excitatory response between 70 ms and 120 ms in the figure, is similarly caused by the action of
the most activated inhibitory ensemble on the excitatory populations encoding the lower harmonics. We
identify the maximum in the aggregated excitatory activity, corresponding to the time point in which
the model performs a perceptual decision about the pitch of the stimulus, with the POR latency (further
details regarding this correspondence are shown in Supplementary Video S1).
The proposed mechanism also explains, quantitatively, the dependence of the POR latency with the
4
period of the stimulus. A periodicity detector tuned to T needs & 1.25 T to robustly detect a periodicity
T in the auditory nerve activity [40]. Thus, the arrival of sufficient excitatory drive to activate an
inhibitory ensemble shows a dependence with several periods of the stimulus. This result also provides
a mechanistic explanation for the minimum stimulus duration required for robust pitch discrimination,
which is around four times the period of the stimulus [10].
Dynamics of the sustainer network The dynamics of the decoder network are sufficient to explain
how the harmonic representations held in the first step of the model are transformed into the final
y
t
c
i
d
o
i
r
e
p
s
r
o
t
c
e
t
e
d
r
e
d
o
c
e
d
y
r
o
t
a
t
i
c
x
e
r
e
d
o
c
e
d
y
r
o
t
i
b
h
n
i
i
i
r
e
n
a
t
s
u
s
y
r
o
t
a
t
i
c
x
e
i
r
e
n
a
t
s
u
s
y
r
o
t
i
b
h
n
i
i
)
s
m
l
(
n
o
i
t
a
u
p
o
p
e
h
t
f
o
d
o
i
r
e
p
c
i
t
s
i
r
e
t
c
a
r
a
h
c
e
h
t
n
i
y
t
i
v
i
t
c
a
g
v
a
y
r
o
t
a
t
i
c
x
e
r
e
d
o
c
e
d
)
z
H
(
s
n
o
i
t
a
u
p
o
p
l
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
5
10
15
5
10
15
5
10
15
5
10
15
5
10
4
2
0
0
150
100
50
)
z
H
(
y
t
i
v
i
t
c
a
n
o
i
t
a
u
p
o
p
l
0
response in a single trial
average response
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
time (ms)
Figure 2: Illustration of the decoding process. The plots show the evolution of key variables of
the model during the processing of the first 200 ms of an iterated rippled noise with a fundamental
period of T = 4 ms (parameters were as in Figure 1). a) -- e) Evolution of the model neural ensembles
encoding characteristic periods between 0.5 ms and 15 ms. a) Activity of periodicity detectors within
the first stage of the model. b) and c) Activity of excitatory and inhibitory ensembles in the decoder
network. d) and e) Activity of excitatory and inhibitory activities in the sustainer network. f) Aggregated
excitatory activity in the decoder. Detailed dynamics of the process are illustrated in an animation in
Supplementary Video S1.
5
representations shown in Figures 1b and 1c. However, after the transformation has taken place, the
excitatory ensembles corresponding to the lower harmonics of the stimulus' pitch are no longer active,
and hence the inhibitory population silencing them loses its drive. Thus, without top-down control,
the decoder network would rapidly reset and need to repeatedly extract the pitch from the harmonic
representation, eliciting a series of PORs; this, however, does not reflect the experimental observations
(Figure 1a). The role of the sustainer network is to regulate the dynamics of the decoder network once
the pitch value has been extracted from the harmonic representation, in order to effectively sustain the
perceptual decision until a significant change is produced in the cortical input.
In the absence of external input, the sustainer network rests at equilibrium, with a steady activation
in the inhibitory populations and complete deactivation of the excitatory populations (see Figures 2d
and e).
Excitatory/inhibitory ensembles in the sustainer receive direct input from their respective excita-
tory/inhibitory counterparts in the decoder (see Figure 1d). Thus, a significantly active inhibitory
population in the decoder effectively silences the steady activity of the analogous inhibitory population
in the sustainer. If this afferent drive coincides with a strong activation of the corresponding excitatory
population in the decoder, the combined bottom-up input results in a strong activation in the equivalent
excitatory population within the sustainer (see Figures 2d and 2e).
Top-down efferents connect each excitatory population in the sustainer with its inhibitory counterpart
in the decoder network (see 1b), compensating for the loss of excitatory drive of the silenced populations
for as long as the subcortical input remains unchanged (the behaviour of the network under pitch changes
is described in Supplementary Figure S9).
Model predictions The POR is defined as the subcomponent of the N100 transient that responds
selectively to pitch onset and pitch changes [10, 11, 41]. In order to isolate the POR from other sub-
components of the N100 like, e.g., the energy onset response (EOR), experimental setups use iterated
rippled noise (IRN) preceded by a noise burst of the same energy and bandwidth [7, 10, 11]; the POR
is then measured as the transient elicited at the transition between noise and IRN (i.e., at the pitch
onset). Thus, we tested the predictive power of our model using IRN stimuli with different pitch values
(an isolated POR can be elicited using energy-balanced stimuli, but see Supplementary Figure S6for an
example of how more general predictions could be drawn for other stimuli.)
Latency predictions of the POR elicited by IRN stimuli are compared with experimental data in
Figures 3a and 3b. Results show that the model replicates the relation between the POR latency and
the period of the stimuli as typically reported in the MEG literature [10,11]. Replication of these results
for IRN stimuli with different parametrisations are shown in Supplementary Figure S4.
To ensure that the model is correctly representing the pitch of the IRN stimuli used in the experiment,
we also plotted the average activation in the different ensembles in Figures 3d -- h. Since periodicity
detectors and excitatory neurons at the decoder do not show selective activation with pitch (e.g., neurons
representing harmonics of the actual pitch value also activate during the decoding process), the perceptual
readout of the model can only be robustly measured in the inhibitory populations in the decoder and the
populations in the sustainer. Perceptual results in Figures 3 and Supplementary Figure S4indicate that
the model is able to robustly represent the pitch of the stimulus when at least two harmonics are present
in the cortical input (since we only consider periodicity detectors tuned to periods under Tmax = 30 ms,
the highest period robustly extracted by the model is Tmax/2 = 15 ms; a larger pitch range could be
easily achieved by increasing Tmax). Robust pitch extraction is shown for IRN stimuli with different
parametrisations, pure tones, harmonic complex tones and click trains in Supplementary Figure S3.
2.2 Neuromagnetic correlates of consonance and dissonance in auditory cor-
tex
Next, we recorded neuromagnetic fields evoked by six different dyads from 37 normal hearing subjects.
Data were preprocessed using standard MEG procedures, and equivalent current dipoles were fitted,
independently, for the POR for each subject and hemisphere, pooled over conditions (see Methods).
Dipole locations in Talairach space are plotted in Figure 4b.
Dyads consisted of two IRN sounds. The lower note pitch was 160 Hz; the pitch of the upper note
was adjusted accordingly to form either a consonant dyad (unison, P1; perfect fifth, P5; major third,
6
a)
200
180
160
140
120
c)
0
)
z
H
(
r
e
d
o
c
e
d
e
h
t
n
i
1
2
3
0
)
s
m
(
y
c
n
e
t
a
l
n
o
i
t
a
v
i
t
c
a
.
c
x
e
e
v
i
t
c
e
l
l
o
c
d)
)
s
m
(
d
o
i
r
e
p
s
u
u
m
l
i
t
s
5
10
15
20
25
30
g)
)
s
m
(
d
o
i
r
e
p
s
u
u
m
l
i
t
s
5
10
15
20
25
30
predicted POR latency
experimental POR latency
b)
200
180
160
140
120
4
6
10
8
12
IRN delay (ms)
14
16
2
4
16
number of iterations
8
50
100
150
200
32
0
-10
-20
-30
l
i
t
n
e
m
o
m
e
o
p
d
n
e
a
v
u
q
e
l
i
)
m
A
n
(
r
o
t
a
r
e
n
e
g
R
O
P
e
h
t
n
i
cortical input
decoder excitatory
decoder inhibitory
e)
5
10
15
20
25
30
f)
5
10
15
20
25
30
sustainer excitatory
sustainer inhibitory
h)
5
10
15
20
25
30
10
20
30
10
20
30
characteristic delay (ms)
characteristic delay (ms)
10
20
30
characteristic delay (ms)
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
)
z
H
(
y
t
i
v
i
t
c
a
n
o
i
t
a
u
p
o
p
e
g
a
r
e
v
a
l
Figure 3: Model predictions for iterated rippled noise pitch. a) -- b) Latency predictions for iterated
rippled noise compared with experimental data obtained by a previous study [10] for the same stimuli.
c) Comparison of the collective activation of the excitatory ensembles in the decoder (computed as an
average across populations) with the equivalent dipole moment elicited at the generator of the POR;
stimulus was an IRN of 16 iterations and a delay of 8 ms. d) -- h) Averaged responses at: (d) periodicity
detectors, (e/f) excitatory/inhibitory ensembles in the decoder, (g/h) excitatory/inhibitory ensembles in
the sustainer.
7
M3) or a dissonant dyad (tritone, TT; minor seventh, m7; minor second, m2). To dissociate the EOR
in Planum temporale from the POR in alHG, the dyads were preceded by an energy-balanced noise
segment, cross-faded with the dyad to avoid discontinuous waveforms (like for the single IRN sounds
analyzed in the previous section; see Methods).
Figure 4A presents the MEG grand-mean source waveforms, for both hemispheres, in response to
the six stimulus conditions. The noise onset from silence (depicted in grey below the source waveforms)
was followed by a transient P1m-N1m-P2m AEF complex. Since the first stimulus segment did not
vary between conditions, we did not expect to find any significant differences in the corresponding
neuromagnetic activity at this point.
Figure 4: Auditory fields evoked at dyad onset. a) MEG grand-mean source waveforms in response
to the pooled stimulus conditions. The course of the stimuli is shown in grey (noise) and black (IRN)
below the source waveforms; note the prominent negative POR deflection (N1m) at the transition from
the first to the second stimulus segment. BL = baseline. b) Projection of the dipole locations (means
and 99,% Bootstrap confidence intervals) onto the axial view of auditory cortex as suggested by Leonard
et al. [42]. c) Morphology of the POR in response to the dyad onset in the single experimental conditions
(second stimulus segment), pooled over hemispheres. d) 99 % Bootstrap confidence intervals for the
POR amplitudes and latencies in the single experimental conditions. In subplots, b) and d), confidence
intervals are bias-corrected and accelerated, as recommended by Efron and Tibshirani [43].
In contrast, the transition to the second stimulus segment (IRN dyads; black signal below the source
waveforms) elicited prominent POR waves, and the morphology of the POR varied considerably be-
tween conditions. Figure 4C show close-up views of the POR. Consonant dyads (pooled conditions
[P1+P5+M3]) elicited a much earlier (p < .0001) and larger (p < .0001) POR than dissonant dyads
(pooled conditions [m7+TT+m2]). Figure 4D depicts 99 % bootstrap confidence intervals for the POR
amplitudes and latencies, pooled over hemispheres, in response to the experimental conditions; the ac-
tivity pattern observed here also points to a close relationship between the degree of a dyad's consonance
and the morphology of the respective POR.
When pooling across conditions, we found a noticeable difference between the left and the right
8
hemisphere in the POR amplitude (p = .01), but not in the POR latency (p = .36); also, the difference
between the neuromagnetic responses to consonant or dissonant dyads did not significantly vary between
hemispheres (latency: p = .58; amplitude: p = .48).
2.3 Neural mechanisms underlying the responses of auditory cortex to con-
sonance and dissonance
The difference in POR latency in response to consonant and dissonant dyads in alGH suggests that
consonance and dissonance are computed at relatively early stages of the cortical auditory hierarchy. We
used our model of cortical pitch processing, designed to reproduce the neuromagnetic responses elicited
by iterated rippled noises, to test this interpretation. If the differential responses to consonance and
dissonance in alHG were intrinsic to pitch processing, we would expect our prospective mechanism to be
able to reproduce this behaviour.
First, we verified that the model's was able to provide a representation of the individual pitches of
the two tones comprised in dyads; results are shown in Figure 5a -- c (see Supplementary Figure S6for
additional perceptual results obtained with different families of dyads). It should be emphasized that
even phenomenological (i.e., non-mechanistic) models of pitch perception are generally unable to perform
correct perceptual predictions for sounds with concurrent pitches (e.g. [44, 45]; see [46] for a review).
Figure 5j shows the latency predictions of the model are compared with the experimental data for the
respective dyads. Although the model predicted a slightly shorter POR latency for the semitone (m2)
dyad than observed (see discussion), latency predictions faithfully reproduced the experimental trend;
moreover, the differential response to consonant (P1, M3, P5) and dissonant (m2, TT, m7) dyads found
in the MEG data was perfectly reproduced by the model (latency of P1 and P5 < latency of dissonant
dyads: p < 10−7, U > 5150; latency of M3 < latency of m2: p = 0.005, U = 4120; latency of M3 <
latency of TT: p = 0.63, U = 3571; latency of M3 < latency of m7: p = 0.06, U = 3927); according to
pair-wise single-tailed Wilcoxon rank-sum tests performed over the results of n = 60 runs). The temporal
dynamics of the dipole moment predicted by the model is shown in Figures 5d -- i.
Last, we extended the POR latency predictions of the model to include all 13 dyads within the
chromatic scale (see Figure 5), and tested if the differential responses to consonance and dissonance were
generalizable to additional dyads. Following Helmholtz [2], we considered an extended set of consonant
dyads, including the octave (P8) and the perfect fourth (P4); and an extended set of dissonant dyads,
including the major seventh (M7) and the major second (M2). Once again, consonant dyads produced
longer latencies than dissonant dyads (latencies of P1, P4, P5 and P8 < latencies of the extended set of
dissonant dyads: p < 0.0003, U > 4290; latency of M3 < latency of M2: p < 10−5, U = 4497; latency
of M3 < latency of M7: p = 0.54, U = 3610); according to pair-wise single-tailed Wilcoxon rank-sum
tests performed over the results of 60 runs of the model). These results, fully in line with previous
findings, reveal that the differential response of our model to consonance and dissonance in dyads is a
general phenomenon caused by the fundamental relationships between the periodicities of the two dyad
components. These analyses are extended to further families of dyads in Supplementary Figure S7,
yielding similar results.
The model provides a mechanistic explanation of how the harmonic relationships between the com-
ponents of the dyads modulate processing time. Consonant dyads consist of tones that share a larger
number of lower harmonics than the ones in dissonant dyads. For instance, in the just intonation, the
perfect fifth of a given fundamental shares one in every two harmonics with that fundamental, whilst
only one in 16 harmonics are shared by a minor second and its fundamental. Our model suggests that
cortical pitch processing is triggered by the joint activation of, at least, three periodicity detectors char-
acterizing a specific harmonic series. Consonant dyads elicit a dramatically larger signal-to-noise ratio
in the periodicity detectors tuned to their common harmonics, resulting in a collaborative effort towards
pitch extraction that effectively speeds up processing dynamics (an animation of this process is depicted
in Supplementary Video S2).
3 Discussion
This work combines new theoretical and experimental methods to study how the auditory cortex repre-
sentations of a sounds' pitch also generate the sensation of consonance and dissonance.
9
unison
minor second
second
minor third
third
fourth
tritone
perfect fifth
minor sixth
sixth
minor seventh
seventh
octave
)
z
H
(
y
t
i
v
i
t
c
a
g
v
a
r
e
d
o
c
e
d
0
1
2
0
2
4
6
0
cortical input
decoder excitatory
decoder inhibitory
a)
b)
c)
10
20
30
10
20
30
10
20
30
characteristic delay (ms)
characteristic delay (ms)
characteristic delay (ms)
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
)
z
H
(
y
t
i
v
i
t
c
a
n
o
i
t
a
u
p
o
p
e
g
a
r
e
v
a
l
f)
third
i)
d)
unison
g)
tritone
50 100 150 200 250
time (ms)
0
2
4
6
0
2
4
6
0
e)
minor second
h)
perfect fifth
50 100 150 200 250
time (ms)
0
2
4
6
0
2
4
6
0
model prediction (Hz)
experimental data (nAm)
5
0
-5
)
m
A
n
(
t
n
e
m
o
m
e
o
p
d
i
l
-10
-15
-20
-25
5
0
-5
-10
-15
-20
-25
-30
model prediction
experimental data
k)
j)
)
s
m
(
y
c
n
e
t
a
l
R
O
P
180
175
170
165
160
155
150
145
m in or s e c o n d
u nis o n
third
trito n e
p erfe ct fifth
m in or s e v e nth
m in or s e c o n d
s e c o n d
m in or third
u nis o n
minor seventh
50 100 150 200 250
time (ms)
typically judged as consonant
typically judged as dissonant
sixth
fo urth
trito n e
m in or s e v e nth
p erfe ct fifth
s e v e nth
m in or sixth
third
o cta v e
Figure 5: Model responses to the IRN dyads used in the MEG experiment. a) -- c) Neural
representation of the dyads at different levels of the model: (a) periodicity detectors, (b/c) excita-
tory/inhibitory ensembles in the decoder network; each row shows the activity elicited by each dyad.
Excitatory and inhibitory ensembles in the sustainer are precisely correlated to the decoder-inhibitory
heatmap. Note that, unlike in the perceptual results for simple IRNs, the neural activity representing
the pitch of the second note shifts toward the left because dyads are arranged in ascending order. d) -- i)
Examples of the collective excitatory activity at the decoder network (monotonically related to the equiv-
alent dipole moment elicited by the network) in comparison with the elicited dipole moment measured
during the experimentation in the neural generator of the POR. The scale of the field derived for the
unison dyad was adjusted to account for the comparatively smaller effect on the network of the unison
input, which effectively activates half of the populations than the other dyads. j) Latency predictions
for IRN dyads compared with the experimental results reported in the previous section. k) Latency
predictions for the remaining dyads in the chromatic scale. Strongly consonant dyads are represented
with a green triangle, whilst strongly dissonant dyads are represented with a red triangle; dissonance was
assessed according to Helmholtz [2], Table on Fig. 61. Dyads were generated using the same parameters
as in the experimental procedures: the lower note pitch was set to 160 Hz and the chromatic scale was
generated using the just intonation [2].
10
First, we introduced a novel ensemble model of pitch designed to understand the neuromagnetic
fields elicited in alHG during pitch processing. The model proposes a mechanistic explanation of the
POR morphology and the dependence of its peak latency with the perceived pitch, a phenomenon
that has been robustly observed for over two decades [10, 11, 41], yet remained poorly understood.
Thereafter, we designed an MEG protocol to investigate whether the POR properties are influenced
by the degree of consonance or dissonance, as elicited by different dyads from common Western music.
Results revealed a strong correlation between the POR peak latency and the degree of dissonance elicited
by each dyad, extending previous EEG results that have also reported a modulation of the POR amplitude
by consonance [24].
Last, we showed that our model, originally designed to explain pitch processing in IRN stimuli with
a single pitch, can quantitatively account for the correlation between POR latency and the degree of
consonance and dissonance. The model can explain the shorter POR latencies in response to consonant
dyads as an effect of harmonic facilitation during pitch extraction. Combined, our results indicate that
the neural mechanisms accounting for pitch processing show a differential response to consonant and
dissonant dyads, suggesting that the sensation of consonance and dissonance might be elicited as a result
of pitch processing in alHG.
3.1 The POR latency reflects pitch processing time
The dynamics of the decoder network proposes a new mechanistic interpretation for the POR latency
in the sense that it might reflect the amount of time that is necessary for the network to stabilize in an
unequivocal pitch (see Figure 2). Although an association between POR latency and processing time
has been hypothesized previously in experiments (e.g., [9 -- 11, 41]) and a in a model [44], a biophysical
understanding of this phenomenon was still lacking. Our model identifies the magnitude of the POR
with the instant in which the net inhibition at the decoder network exceeds the excitatory activity from
the periodicity detectors; from a dynamic system perspective, this is equivalent to the instant in which
the trajectory in the phase-space is unequivocally directed towards the attractor state dominated by the
neural ensemble that is characterized by the perceived pitch (see animation in Supplementary Video S1).
The model suggests that a robust perceptual decision concerning stimulus pitch is made after the
cortical system identifies, typically, three peaks from the harmonic series of the stimulus' period in the
representation of the periodicity detectors. This accounts for the relation between the POR latency and
the stimulus period [10, 11]; moreover, it also may explain why pitch identification is only robust when
the stimulus duration exceeds four times the pitch periodicity [10]. Previous studies have postulated
that cortical pitch processing mechanisms must integrate along several period cycles in order to make
a perceptual decision [10, 28, 47]; however, a specific mechanism for such an integration has not been
proposed up to now.
Moreover, since phase-locked activity is not robustly present above 50 -- 200 Hz in cortex [19], integra-
tion along several repetition cycles was only possible in subcortical areas. The decoder network in our
model takes advantage of the input harmonic representations provided by an autocorrelation model that
does not require phase-locking to transmit information concerning several repetition cycles [34], and thus
provides a parsimonious solution to this problem.
3.2 Effect of consonance and dissonance on cortical processing time
Combined, our results suggest that cortical processing of dissonant dyads is slower than the processing
of consonant dyads, in the sense that it requires a longer processing time. The model provides a physical
rationale for this phenomenon: cortical extraction of consonance is based on the accumulation of activ-
ity in the columns with preferred periods characterizing the lower harmonics of the target sound; thus,
concurrent pitch frequencies sharing common lower harmonics contribute to the build-up of each other's
representation, thereby speeding up the stabilization of the network. Since consonant dyads are char-
acterized by simpler frequency ratios, they comprise tones sharing a larger number of lower harmonics
than dissonant dyads.
Early phenomenological models based on Helmholtz's roughness theory described dissonance as the
beating sensation produced by tones with fundamental frequencies that were not harmonically related
[1 -- 4, 48]. More recent explanations of consonance, based on pitch processing, have linked the regularity
of the autocorrelation harmonic patterns elicited by dyads to their evoked consonance and dissonance
11
percepts [6, 22 -- 24, 49]. Thus, in one way or another, previous phenomenological models of consonance
have consistently related perceived consonance with the amount of harmonics shared between the tones
comprising the dyad. The present model confirms that assumption and introduces a potential explanation
for its underlying biophysical rationale.
Although our modelling results generally show a good fit with the data from the MEG experiment,
the model prediction falls around 5 ms short when explaining the POR latency evoked by the minor
second dyad. This relatively small underestimation might result from the limited number of harmonics
considered during the integration step in the decoder network: dissonant dyads, whose components do
not share any common harmonic within the first three peaks of their harmonic series, present comparable
processing times. An adaptive mechanism adjusting the number of harmonics required to trigger the
decoding process according to the degree of overlap of the peaks in the input could potentially yield more
accurate results. This adaptive mechanism would be necessary to explain how humans can differentiate
dyads that differ in a quarter of a semitone.
Our study did not evaluate, however, if the general (yet not universal [50, 51]) association between
consonance and pleasantness might be a consequence of differential processing in alHG. Future work
should investigate whether this link could be due to different processing times, as described above, or
whether it can be better explained by processes at higher levels of the auditory hierarchy that might be
more sensitive to cultural and background modulations.
3.3 Experimental discussion and comparison with results of the literature
Our neuromagnetic findings concerning the POR morphology in response to consonant and dissonant
dyads resemble and extend recent EEG data reported by Bidelman and Grall [7], and by Proverbio et
al. [52]. Specifically, Bidelman and Grall [7] applied EEG in a smaller sample (N = 9) of musically
trained listeners and revealed a close relation between their subject's consonance/dissonance ratings and
the morphology of the POR that was elicited by the respective dyads in alHG. In their study, the POR
latency difference between consonant and dissonant dyads (cf.
their figure 4B) appears to have non-
significant (p = 0.22) effect size, smaller than the results that were obtained in our study by means of
MEG.
One reason for this might be that Bidelman and Grall [7] applied shorter IRN stimuli with a higher
number of iterations, resulting in an increased saliency of the pitch percept; moreover, they employed a
dichotic stimulation paradigm in which each ear was presented with only one dyad component, whereas in
our experiment, sounds were delivered diotically to the listeners. On the other hand, the POR was found
to originate from very similar locations in alHG, in both our MEG experiment and the work of Bidelman
and Grall [7]; this is consistent with earlier fMRI [53] and intracranial [54] studies, as well as with other
MEG studies that have linked subcomponents of the N100 wave to pitch processing (e.g., [11,28,55,56]).
3.4 Relation to previous models of pitch processing
Previous studies have introduced a wide range of phenomenological models that were originally designed
to predict the pitch of complex sounds (e.g., [30,33,34,44,45,57,58], see [46] for a review). The correlation
between pitch and cortical AEFs was previously addressed by the Auditory Image Model's buffer [45]
and its derivative [59]; and the derivative of the activation in the population encoding the pitch in [12,44].
However, these models do not provide the biophysical mechanisms underlying the generation of the POR,
or its latency dependence with pitch.
Other models, designed to explain the precise biophysical mechanisms of pitch perception, were
primarily focused on subcortical or early processing. Two of these models describe how neurons, mainly
in subcortical nuclei, might process periodicities from the auditory nerve activity: Meddis and O'Mard's
model [29] proposes a biophysical implementation of the summary autocorrelation function [33,34], based
on the joint action of chopper neurons in the cochlear nucleus and coincidence detectors in the inferior
colliculus. More recently, Huang and Rinzel [60] describe the neural implementation of a coincidence
detector which is able to detect periodicities by comparing neural activity across different cochlear
channels. Despite their mechanistic differences, both models present a spectral output comparable to
that of the autocorrelation function [60]. The model presented here is downstream, with respect to
Meddis' and Huang's models, with its focus on explaining how pitch-related information is extracted
12
from spectral patterns in alHG. Neurons implementing this transformation have been recently observed
in the primary auditory cortex of marmosets [16].
3.5 Relation to previous models of sensory integration
The decoder network dynamics can be understood as an extension of the decision making model of the
well-known winner-take-all ensemble competition [61,62]: excitatory populations in the decoding network
compete with each other, whilst the inhibitory ensemble that is arbitrating this selective competition is in
the column sensitive to the fundamental (see the inhibitory connections in Figure 1). Since competition
is restricted to harmonically related populations, multiple fundamentals can be simultaneously processed
by the decoder network in cases where the input presents concurrent pitch values (e.g., Figure 5).
The hierarchical structure of our model is inspired by a recent model that was designed to explain
sensory integration in the medial temporal area of the macaque monkey [35]. In that model, perceptual
decisions are first transiently computed in a sensory circuit that follows winner-take-all dynamics; after
convergence, the decision then propagates to an integration circuit, that further modulates the dynamics
of the sensory circuit, thus ensuring stability until a significant change occurs in the input to the cortex.
Similarly, once a pitch value has been extracted in the decoder network of our model, the activity of
the winner column is reinforced by the sustainer network (rather than being repeatedly decoded) until
a new change in the subcortical input triggers a new decoding process (see Supplementary Figure S9).
The sustaining strategy is also reminiscent of predictive coding [63 -- 65] and reversed hierarchical
strategies [44, 66], where top-down efferents convey expectations about the input (here: expectations
regarding its harmonic structure), whereas bottom-up afferents convey prediction error (peaks not corre-
sponding to the expected harmonic series) [67]. Additional top-down expectations could coexist at higher
cognitive levels based on, for instance, prior knowledge, experience, or focused attention. Such biases
could modulate the sustaining network by increasing the baseline activity of the inhibitory ensembles
that characterize the target pitch values, thereby facilitating the extraction of that privileged pitch in
the decoder.
To summarize, in this study we have introduced a novel model designed to understand the neural
mechanisms of cortical pitch processing. The model proposes a mechanistic link between the latency of
the POR subcomponent of the N100 wave and the processing time required for the system to achieve
convergence, explaining the classical result that tones with a lower pitch elicit PORs with longer latencies.
Moreover, our modelling and experimental results indicate that processing time varies with the degree
of consonance in dyads, suggesting that the sensation of consonance and dissonance might directly stem
from cortical pitch processing.
4 Methods
4.1 Experimentation
4.1.1 Participants
Thirty-seven normal-hearing adults (22 female, 2 left-handed; mean age: 29.1 ± 8.3 years) participated in
the experiment. None of the subjects reported any history of central or peripheral hearing impairments
or any neurological or psychiatric disorders. The study and the experimental procedures were approved
by the ethics committee of the Heidelberg University's Medical School, and were conducted with written
informed consent of each listener.
4.1.2 Stimuli
All stimuli were generated on-line using MATLAB 7.1 (The MathWorks, Inc., USA) and a sampling rate
of 48000 Hz. The basic stimulus was a 750 ms long IRN segment, bandpass-filtered at 125 -- 2000 Hz, with
eight iterations and gain for the delay-and-add filter gf = 1. The delay of the IRN was varied between
experimental conditions in an effort to build three consonant and three dissonant musical intervals, as
classified by Western music theory. The delay of the lower note was always 6.25 ms, corresponding to a
pitch of 160 Hz; the delay of the upper note was adjusted accordingly to form either a consonant dyad
13
musical interval
freq. ratio
freq. (rounded, Hz) # of semitones
consonance percept.
unison (P1)
perfect fifth (P5)
major third (M3)
tritone (TT)
minor seventh (m7)
minor second (m2)
1:1
3:2
5:4
45:32
16:9
16:15
160 / 160
160 / 240
160 / 200
160 / 225
160 / 284
160 / 171
0
7
4
6
10
1
PC
PC
IC
D
D
D
Table 1: Overview of the experimental conditions. Dyads are listed in descending consonance order,
and are categorized as Perfect consonant (PC), imperfect consonant (IC) or dissonant (D) according to
Western music theory and empirical results [70, 71].
(unison, P1; perfect fifth, P5; major third, M3) or a dissonant dyad (tritone, TT; minor seventh, m7;
minor second, m2). Table 1 presents an overview of the six experimental conditions.
In order to separate the dyad-specific neuromagnetic responses from the cortical activity associated
with the onset of sound energy [68, 69], each IRN dyad was preceded by a 750 ms long, energy-balanced
noise segment (bandpass-filtered at 125 -- 2000 Hz). There were 10 ms Hanning windows at stimulus onset
and offset; moreover, between the first (noise) and the second (IRN) segment of a stimulus, signals were
cross-faded for a duration of 10 ms in an effort to avoid discontinuous waveforms. The overall stimulation
level was set to 80 dB SPL.
4.1.3 Data acquisition and processing
Gradients of the magnetic field were acquired with a Neuromag-122 whole-head MEG system (Elekta
Neuromag Oy, Helsinki, Finland) inside a magnetically shielded room (IMEDCO, Hagendorf, Switzer-
land). Raw data were acquired at a sampling rate of 1000 Hz and low-pass filtered at 330 Hz. Prior to
the recordings, the nasion, two pre-auricular points and 32 surface points were measured as anatomical
landmarks, individually for each participant, using a Polhemus 3D-Space Isotrack2 systems. In an effort
to keep vigilance stable, participants watched a silent movie of their own choice during data acquisition,
and they were asked to direct their attention to the movie and ignore the sounds in the earphones. The
IRN dyads were delivered to the subjects via Etymotic Research (ER3) earphones with 90 cm plastic
tubes and foam earpieces. Sounds were presented using a 24-bit sound card (RME ADI 8DS AD/DA
interface), an attenuator (Tucker-Davis Technologies PA-5) and a headphone buffer (Tucker-Davis Tech-
nologies HB-7). 250 sweeps per stimulus condition were played during the MEG recording, diotically
and in pseudo-randomized order. The inter-stimulus interval was 1000 ms. The total duration of the
measurement was 62 minutes.
4.1.4 Data analysis
Data were analyzed off-line using the BESA 5.2 software package (BESA GmbH, Germany) with a
spherical head model and a homogeneous volume conductor. After visual inspection of the raw data,
noisy channels and sweeps with amplitudes greater than 8000 fT/cm or gradients exceeding 800 fT/cm/ms
were excluded from further analyses. About 235 sweeps per subject and condition remained after artifact
rejection; they were averaged, trigger-synchronously, in the epoch from 500 ms before to 3000 ms after
stimulus onset. The baseline was defined as the average level in the interval of -100 ms to 0 ms, relative
to stimulus onset.
After pre-processing, we applied spatio-temporal source models [72 -- 74] in BESA, in an effort to study
the POR component in response to the second stimulus segment, i.e., at the transition from noise to IRN
dyads. In this source localization approach, the intracortical sources of the activity observed at the scalp
are modeled as equivalent current dipoles, and their spatial position and orientation is varied iteratively
until a maximum amount of variance is explained in the scalp data. The source model includes both
the spatial information for each dipole, and its physiological activity across time (source waveform). We
calculated source models with one dipole per hemisphere for the POR component in the second stimulus
segment. Dipole fits were based on pooled conditions [P1+P5+M3+TT+m7+m2]. The fitting interval
covered about 30 ms around its peak, and MEG data were zero-phase filtered 2 -- 20 Hz.
14
Individual fits at the AEF components were successful for 36 subjects. In ten participants we included
a symmetry constraint in the model to stabilize the individual dipole fits. One participant failed to show
stable fits in the dipole model, and was excluded from subsequent analyses. Aside from symmetry,
no further constraints were made concerning the orientation and location of the dipoles. The average
maximum of explained variance within the fitting window was 64.1% (SD: 18.9) for the POR dipole
model. After fitting, this dipole model was used as spatio-temporal filter, i.e., the source waveforms
corresponding to the model were extracted separately for each condition and each subject. Finally, the
source waveforms were exported from BESA to MATLAB for statistical analysis.
The statistical evaluation of the MEG source waveforms was conducted using the bootstrap method
[43]. Here, the distribution of a test statistic is approximated by repeated random drawing, with replace-
ment, from the original dataset; based on the resulting bootstrap distribution, confidence intervals can
then be derived for that test statistic. Contrary to most standard techniques, the bootstrap method is
well-suited for neurophysiological data where peaks cannot be clearly identified for each participant in
every condition. Prior to statistical analyses, each source waveform of the POR model was adjusted to
the baseline calculated as the average of the last 100 ms before the transition.
4.2 Modelling
4.2.1 Peripheral model and periodicity detectors
Neural activity at the auditory nerve was simulated using a recent biophysically realistic model of the
auditory periphery [31,32]. Peripheral parameters were chosen as in [29], considering 40 cochlear channels
with centre frequencies between 125 Hz and 10 kHz.
Periodicity detectors were modeled according to the summarized autocorrelation function (SACF) of
the auditory nerve activity [29,30,34]. This highly idealized model yields a harmonic neural representation
of pitch-related information (see Figure 1e), often connected to subcortical processing. The SACF was
chosen for its comparably low computational complexity, but more detailed biophysical models yielding
similar representations (e.g. [29, 60]) should produce comparable results.
The SACF used here follows the same formulation as the first stage in the cascade autocorrelation
model [30]. The nth component An(t) of the SACF represents a measure of the regularity of the auditory
nerve activity with respect to a fixed period δtn. The model considers N = 250 components An(t) with
characteristic periods uniformly spaced between δt1 = 0.5 ms, a conservative estimation of the phase-
locking limit of the auditory nerve [75], up to the lower limit of melodic pitch, δtN = 30 ms [76].
The output is further regularized through a procedure An(t) → An(t) that reduces the dependence
of the SACF with stimulus intensity level and minimizes signal-to-noise variations within sounds with
the same pitch but different timbre. The regularization procedure makes use of the principles of neural
normalization [77] (see details in Supplementary Methods).
4.2.2 Ensemble dynamics
Neural ensembles follow mean-field dynamics characterised by their instantaneous firing rate H e
citatory) and H i
n(t) (ex-
n(t) (inhibitory), at each cortical column n. Evolution dynamics were adapted from [62]:
τ pop H e,i
n (t) = −H e,i
n (t) + φe,i(I e,i
n (t))
with transfer functions φe,i(I e,i
n (t)) [62]:
φe,i(I) =
ae,iI − be,i
1 − e−de,i(ae,iI−be,i)
(1)
(2)
Realistic parameters of the excitatory and inhibitory transfer functions (ae, be and de for the excita-
tory; ai, bi and di for the inhibitory) were taken from the literature [62, 78]. The total synaptic inputs
I e
n(t) and I i
n(t) are defined below. Numerically simulations were performed using the Euler's method
with a time step ∆t = 1 ms.
Dynamics of excitatory and inhibitory ensembles at the decoder and sustainer networks follow the
n (t)
n (t) for the
same formulation. In order to differentiate between the two cortical networks, we use H e,i
to characterize populations and synaptic inputs of the decoder layer, and H e,i
n (t) and I e,i
n (t) and I e,i
15
populations and synaptic inputs of the sustainer layer. Population effective time constants τ pop are
adaptive and depend on the activity of the population [79, 80]:
τ pop(H(t)) = τ pop
0 ∆T
φ′(I(t))
H(t)
(3)
where φ′(I(t)) is the slope of the transfer function (see Equation 2) and ∆T is the sharpness of the
action potential initiation. The mean-field dynamics of the populations in our model was based on a
LIF neuron [62] that approximates the action potential initiation as instantaneous [81]; thus, we used a
small ∆T ≪ 1 = 0.05 mV.
4.2.3 Synaptic dynamics
Ensemble connectivity is mediated through realistic AMPA, NMDA and GABAA synapses [61,62,78,82].
Synaptic dynamics were modelled according to Brunel and Wang formulation [78]:
SAMPA
n
(t) = −
SGABA
n
(t) = −
SNMDA
n
(t) = −
(t)
(t)
SAMPA
n
τAMPA
SGABA
n
τGABA
SNMDA
n
τNMDA
(t)
+ H e
n(t) + σνn(t)
+ H i
n(t) + σνn(t)
+ γ (1 − SNMDA(t)) H e
n(t) + σνn(t)
(4)
(5)
(6)
NMDA time constant was set to τNMDA = 30 ms; GABA and AMPA time constants τGABA = 2 ms and
τAMPA = 5 ms, and the coupling parameter γ = 0.641, were all taken from the literature [62, 78]. Gating
variables at the sustainer and decoder layers SNMDA, AMPA, GABA
n (t) follow similar dynamics.
(t), H e,i
n
4.2.4 Synaptic inputs
Total synaptic inputs to populations I i,e
n (t) consist of three different contributions: internal
input Iint, accounting for inputs from populations within the same network; external input Iext, exerted
by sources from other networks; and a constant input drive I0:
n (t) and I i,e
n (t) = I i,e
I i,e
I i,e
n (t) = I i,e
n,int(t) + I i,e
n,int(t) + I i,e
n,ext(t) + I i,e
n,ext(t) + I i,e
n,0(t)
n,0(t)
(7)
(8)
Internal input Connectivity weights between any two ensembles in the decoder network are provided
by the matrices C ee, C ei, C ie, C ii. C ei and C ie. C ei and C ie present a harmonic structure inspired
in connectivity patterns reported in the mammal auditory cortex (see [38] for a review); this matrices
are plotted in Figure 1d. C ee is the identity matrix, and C ii has a similar diagonal structure: C ii
αβ =
(1 − cie
0 is the baseline inhibitory weight cie
0 = 0.1 and δαβ is the Kronecker delta.
0 , where cie
0 )δαβ + cie
Altogether, the internal inputs at the decoder Iint(t) are defined as follows:
n,int(t) = X
I e
k
n,int(t) = X
I i
k
nk (cid:0)J ee
C ee
NMDA SNMDA
k
C ei
nk (cid:0)J ie
NMDA SNMDA
k
(t) + J ee
AMPA SAMPA
k
(t) + J ei
AMPA SAMPA
k
(t)(cid:1) − X
k
(t)(cid:1) − X
k
C ie
nkJ ie
GABA SGABA
k
C ii
nkJ ii
GABA SGABA
k
(t)
(9)
(t)
(10)
Ensembles ni the sustainer network only communicate internally with ensembles within the same
block:
I e
n,int(t) = J ee
n,int(t) = J ei
I i
NMDA
NMDA
SNMDA
n
SNMDA
n
(t) + J ee
(t) + J ei
AMPA
AMPA
SAMPA
n
SAMPA
n
(t) − J ie
(t) − J ii
GABA
GABA
SGABA
n
SGABA
n
(t)
(t)
(11)
(12)
16
Conductivities JNMDA,AMPA,GABA and JNMDA,AMPA,GABA (see Table 2) were initialized to typical values
in the literature J ≃ 0.15 nA [62], and fine-tuned within a range of realistic values to ensure the conver-
gence of the ensembles activity to match perceptual results in iterated rippled noises [10]. Model's final
parameters are listed in Table 2.
External input Excitatory ensembles in the decoder network receive bottom-up input An(t) via
AMPA-driven synapses, according to previous studies in perceptual integration [62]:
I e
n,ext(t) = J th
AMPA Sth,AMPA
n
(t)
(13)
The conductivity J th
AMPA was adjusted to ensure a smooth and robust propagation of the activity in
the periodicity detectors to the decoder's excitatory populations. The corresponding gating variables
Sth,AMPA
(t) follow AMPA-like dynamics:
n
Sth,AMPA
n
(t) = −
n
Sth,AMPA
τAMPA
(t)
+ An(t)
(14)
Inhibitory ensembles in the decoder receive efferent external input from the sustainer network. Top-
down excitatory processes in cortex are typically dominated by NMDA dynamics [64]; thus, efferent
AMPA synapses were not considered:
I i
n,ext(t) = J e
NMDA
Sth,NMDA
n
(t)
(15)
The efferent conductivity J e
NMDA (Table 2) was tuned to enable the top-down enhancement of the
inhibitory ensembles at the decoder once the lower harmonics that have been inhibited after the decoding
process (see Dynamics of the decoder network in Results).
Sustainer's external inputs are sourced in the decoder network, driven by inhibitory GABAergic and
excitatory AMPAergic synapses [62, 64]:
I e
n,ext(t) = J a
n,ext(t) = J a
I i
AMPA SAMPA
GABA SGABA
n
n
(t)
(t)
(16)
(17)
Afferent conductivities J a
AMPA, GABA (Table 2) were set to make the sustainer both sensitive to
decoded decisions, yet robust to spurious activations.
Constant input drive Constant inputs to the decoder I e
0 (Table 2) were
selected to enable the system to be reactive to external input, yet silent in absence of a significant
input. An additional constant drive I sus
0 = 0.24 nA was applied to the populations at the sustainer (see
Dynamics of the sustainer network in Results).
n,0(t) = I e
n,0(t) = I i
0 and I i
4.2.5 Derivation of the evoked fields
Assuming that all microcolumns within each of the two cortical networks present similar orientations,
the total dipolar moment representing the neuromagnetic field elicit by each network is monotonicallt
related to the collective excitatory activity in the network [39, 84, 85]:
m(t) = X
H e
n(t + ∆tsubcort)
n
(18)
The subcortical delay ∆t accounts for the time elapsed from tone onset until the signal first arrives in
the decoder network. This delay reflects not only propagation time, but also processing time of secondary
processes like the regularization of the output of the periodicity detectors.
The delay was fixed to ∆t = 75 ms, according to the experimentally observed latency of the POR
elicited by an IRN with a delay of 8 ms. We used a longer ∆tdyads = 95 ms in dyads to compensate for a
systematic 20 ms delay of the experimental observations, most likely due to the different rescaling factors
used for the regularized SACF of simple tones and dyads (see Supplementary Methods for details).
17
parameter
value
source
AMPA
GABA
AMPA
J th
J e
NMDA
J a
GABA
J a
AMPA
J ee
NMDA
J ee
J ei
NMDA
J ei
AMPA
J ie
J ii
GABA
J ee
NMDA
J ee
AMPA
J ei
NMDA
J ei
AMPA
J ie
GABA
J ii
GABA
cie
0
γ
ae
be
de
ai
bi
di
I e
0
I i
0
I e
0
I i
0
τAMPA
τGABA
τNMDA
τ pop
∆T
σ
τ adap
α =
2.6 nA
0.45 nA
0.45 nA
0.35 nA
0.14 nA
9.9 × 10−4 nA
0.20 nA
6.5 × 10−5 nA
0.55 nA
0.11 nA
0.25 nA
9.9 × 10−4 nA
0.00 nA
9.9 × 10−4 nA
0.80 nA
0.00 nA
0.1
0.641
310 (VnC)−1
125 Hz
0.16 s
615 (VnC)−1
177 Hz
0.087 s
0.315 nA
0.15 nA
0.26 nA
0.18 nA
2 ms
5 ms
30 ms
10 ms
0.05 mV
0.007 nA
100 ms
3 × 10−6 nA
fitted
fitted
fitted
fitted
fitted
[62]
fitted
[62]
fitted
fitted
fitted
[62]
fitted
[62]
fitted
fitted
fitted
[78]
[62]
[62]
[62]
[62]
[62]
[62]
fitted
fitted
fitted
fitted
[78]
[78]
fixed
[79]
fixed
[62]
[83]
fitted
Table 2: Values for the parameters used in the cortical model source in the literature.
The Last column specifies the source of the parameter value; entries with the label fitted were tuned
according to the indications described in the main text; entries with the label fixed were selected to a
fixed value according to theoretical considerations (see main text).
18
References
[1] A. Kameoka and M. Kuriyagawa, "Consonance theory part I: consonance of dyads.," The Journal
of the Acoustical Society of America, vol. 45, no. February, pp. 1451 -- 1459, 1969.
[2] H. L. F. von Helmholtz, Die Lehre von den Tonempfindungen als physiologische Grundlage fur die
Theorie der Musik. Braunschweig: Vieweg, 1863.
[3] F. Krueger, "Consonance and Dissonance," The Journal of Philosophy, Psychology and Scientific
Methods, vol. 10, p. 158, mar 1913.
[4] R. Plomp and W. J. M. Levelt, "Tonal Consonance and Critical Bandwidth," The Journal of the
Acoustical Society of America, vol. 38, no. 4, pp. 548 -- 560, 1965.
[5] M. Cousineau, J. H. McDermott, and I. Peretz, "The basis of musical consonance as revealed
by congenital amusia.," Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of
America, vol. 109, no. 48, pp. 19858 -- 63, 2012.
[6] M. J. Tramo, P. A. Cariani, B. Delgutte, and L. D. Braida, "Neurobiological Foundations for the
Theory of Harmony in Western Tonal Music," Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, vol. 930,
pp. 92 -- 116, jan 2006.
[7] G. M. Bidelman and J. Grall, "Functional organization for musical consonance and tonal pitch
hierarchy in human auditory cortex," NeuroImage, vol. 101, pp. 204 -- 214, 2014.
[8] R. Naatanen and T. Picton, "The N1 wave of the human electric and magnetic response to sound: a
review and an analysis of the component structure.," Psychophysiology, vol. 24, no. 4, pp. 375 -- 425,
1987.
[9] C. Alain, D. L. Woods, and D. Covarrubias, "Activation of duration-sensitive auditory cortical fields
in humans," Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology - Evoked Potentials, vol. 104,
no. 6, pp. 531 -- 539, 1997.
[10] K. Krumbholz, R. D. Patterson, A. Seither-Preisler, C. Lammertmann, and B. Lutkenhoner, "Neu-
romagnetic evidence for a pitch processing center in Heschl's gyrus," Cerebral Cortex, vol. 13, no. 7,
pp. 765 -- 772, 2003.
[11] S. Ritter, H. Gunter Dosch, H.-J. Specht, and A. Rupp, "Neuromagnetic responses reflect the
temporal pitch change of regular interval sounds.," NeuroImage, vol. 27, pp. 533 -- 43, sep 2005.
[12] A. Tabas, A. Siebert, S. Supek, D. Pressnitzer, E. Balaguer-Ballester, and A. Rupp, "Insights on the
Neuromagnetic Representation of Temporal Asymmetry in Human Auditory Cortex," PLoS One,
vol. 11, no. 4, p. e0153947, 2016.
[13] D. Bendor and X. Wang, "Cortical representations of pitch in monkeys and humans.," Current
opinion in neurobiology, vol. 16, no. 4, pp. 391 -- 9, 2006.
[14] D. Bendor and X. Wang, "Neural Coding of Periodicity in Marmoset Auditory Cortex," Journal of
Neurophysiology, vol. 103, no. 4, pp. 1809 -- 1822, 2010.
[15] J. K. Bizley, K. M. M. Walker, F. R. Nodal, A. J. King, and J. W. H. Schnupp, "Auditory cortex
represents both pitch judgments and the corresponding acoustic cues," Current Biology, vol. 23,
no. 7, pp. 620 -- 625, 2013.
[16] L. Feng and X. Wang, "Harmonic template neurons in primate auditory cortex underlying complex
sound processing," Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, p. 201607519, 2017.
[17] T. D. Griffiths, S. Uppenkamp, I. Johnsrude, O. Josephs, and R. D. Patterson, "Encoding of the
temporal regularity of sound in the human brainstem.," Nature Neuroscience, vol. 4, pp. 633 -- 7, jun
2001.
19
[18] H. Penagos, J. R. Melcher, and A. J. Oxenham, "A neural representation of pitch salience in
nonprimary human auditory cortex revealed with functional magnetic resonance imaging.," The
Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 24, pp. 6810 -- 5, jul 2004.
[19] J. F. Brugge, K. V. Nourski, H. Oya, R. a. Reale, H. Kawasaki, M. Steinschneider, and M. a. Howard,
"Coding of repetitive transients by auditory cortex on Heschl's gyrus.," Journal of neurophysiology,
vol. 102, pp. 2358 -- 74, oct 2009.
[20] S. Norman-Haignere, N. Kanwisher, and J. H. McDermott, "Cortical pitch regions in humans re-
spond primarily to resolved harmonics and are located in specific tonotopic regions of anterior
auditory cortex.," The Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 33, no. 50, pp. 19451 -- 69, 2013.
[21] M. Moerel, F. De Martino, and E. Formisano, "Processing of natural sounds in human auditory
cortex: tonotopy, spectral tuning, and relation to voice sensitivity.," The Journal of Neuroscience,
vol. 32, pp. 14205 -- 16, oct 2012.
[22] G. M. Bidelman and A. Krishnan, "Neural Correlates of Consonance, Dissonance, and the Hierarchy
of Musical Pitch in the Human Brainstem," Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 29, pp. 13165 -- 13171, oct
2009.
[23] G. M. Bidelman and A. Krishnan, "Brainstem correlates of behavioral and compositional preferences
of musical harmony," NeuroReport, vol. 22, pp. 212 -- 216, mar 2011.
[24] G. M. Bidelman, "The Role of the Auditory Brainstem in Processing Musically Relevant Pitch,"
Frontiers in Psychology, vol. 4, no. MAY, pp. 1 -- 13, 2013.
[25] I. Peretz, A. J. Blood, V. Penhune, and R. Zatorre, "Cortical deafness to dissonance," Brain,
vol. 124, pp. 928 -- 940, may 2001.
[26] L. Minati, C. Rosazza, L. D'Incerti, E. Pietrocini, L. Valentini, V. Scaioli, C. Loveday, and M. G.
Bruzzone, "Functional MRI/event-related potential study of sensory consonance and dissonance in
musicians and nonmusicians.," Neuroreport, vol. 20, no. 1, pp. 87 -- 92, 2009.
[27] C. A. Seger, B. J. Spiering, A. G. Sares, S. I. Quraini, C. Alpeter, J. David, and M. H. Thaut, "Cor-
ticostriatal Contributions to Musical Expectancy Perception.," Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience,
vol. 25, no. 7, pp. 1062 -- -1077, 2013.
[28] A. Gutschalk, R. D. Patterson, S. Uppenkamp, M. Scherg, and A. Rupp, "Recovery and refractori-
ness of auditory evoked fields after gaps in click trains.," The European Journal of Neuroscience,
vol. 20, pp. 3141 -- 7, dec 2004.
[29] R. Meddis and L. P. O'Mard, "Virtual pitch in a computational physiological model," The Journal
of the Acoustical Society of America, vol. 120, no. 6, p. 3861, 2006.
[30] E. Balaguer-Ballester, S. L. Denham, and R. Meddis, "A cascade autocorrelation model of pitch
perception.," The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, vol. 124, pp. 2186 -- 95, oct 2008.
[31] M. S. a. Zilany, I. C. Bruce, and L. H. Carney, "Updated parameters and expanded simulation
options for a model of the auditory periphery," The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,
vol. 135, no. 1, pp. 283 -- 286, 2014.
[32] M. S. A. Zilany, I. C. Bruce, P. C. Nelson, and L. H. Carney, "A phenomenological model of
the synapse between the inner hair cell and auditory nerve: long-term adaptation with power-law
dynamics.," The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, vol. 126, no. 5, pp. 2390 -- 412, 2009.
[33] J. C. R. Licklider, "A duplex theory of pitch perception.," Experientia, vol. 7, no. 4, pp. 128 -- 34,
1951.
[34] R. Meddis and L. O'Mard, "A unitary model of pitch perception.," The Journal of the Acoustical
Society of America, vol. 102, pp. 1811 -- 1820, sep 1997.
20
[35] K. Wimmer, A. Compte, A. Roxin, D. Peixoto, A. Renart, and J. de la Rocha, "Sensory integra-
tion dynamics in a hierarchical network explains choice probabilities in cortical area MT.," Nature
Communications, vol. 6, p. 6177, 2015.
[36] X. Wang and K. M. M. Walker, "Neural Mechanisms for the Abstraction and Use of Pitch Infor-
mation in Auditory Cortex," Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 32, no. 39, pp. 13339 -- 13342, 2012.
[37] L. Gao, K. Kostlan, Y. Wang, and X. Wang, "Distinct Subthreshold Mechanisms Underlying Rate-
Coding Principles in Primate Auditory Cortex," Neuron, vol. 91, pp. 905 -- 919, aug 2016.
[38] X. Wang, "The harmonic organization of auditory cortex.," Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience,
vol. 7, no. December, p. 114, 2013.
[39] S. J. Kiebel, M. I. Garrido, R. J. Moran, and K. J. Friston, "Dynamic causal modelling for EEG
and MEG.," Cognitive neurodynamics, vol. 2, pp. 121 -- 36, jun 2008.
[40] L. Wiegrebe, "Searching for the time constant of neural pitch extraction," The Journal of the
Acoustical Society of America, vol. 109, pp. 1082 -- 1091, mar 2001.
[41] A. Seither-Preisler, R. Patterson, K. Krumbholz, S. Seither, and B. Lutkenhoner, "Evidence of
pitch processing in the N100m component of the auditory evoked field.," Hearing Research, vol. 213,
pp. 88 -- 98, mar 2006.
[42] C. M. Leonard, C. Puranik, J. M. Kuldau, and L. J. Lombardino, "Normal Variation in the Fre-
quency and Location of Human Auditory Cortex Landmarks. Heschl's Gyrus: Where Is It?," Cere-
bral Cortex, vol. 8, no. 5, pp. 397 -- 406, 1998.
[43] B. Efron and R. J. Tibshirani, An Introduction to the Bootstrap. New York: Chapman and Hall,
1993.
[44] E. Balaguer-Ballester, N. R. Clark, M. Coath, K. Krumbholz, and S. L. Denham, "Understanding
pitch perception as a hierarchical process with top-down modulation," PLoS Computational Biology,
vol. 5, p. e1000301, mar 2009.
[45] R. D. Patterson, "The sound of a sinusoid: Time-interval models," The Journal of the Acoustical
Society of America, vol. 96, no. 3, p. 1419, 1994.
[46] A. de Cheveign´e, "Pitch Perception Models," in Pitch: Neural Coding and Perception (C. J. Plack,
R. R. Fay, A. J. Oxenham, and A. N. Popper, eds.), ch. 6, pp. 169 -- 233, Springer New York, 2005.
[47] A. de Cheveign´e, "Pitch Perception," in Oxford Handbook of Auditory Science: Hearing (C. J. Plack,
ed.), pp. 71 -- 104, Oxford University Press, 2010.
[48] W. A. Sethares, "Local consonance and the relationship between timbre and scale," The Journal of
the Acoustical Society of America, vol. 94, p. 1218, nov 1993.
[49] M. Ebeling, "Neuronal periodicity detection as a basis for the perception of consonance: a mathe-
matical model of tonal fusion," Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, vol. 124, pp. 2320 -- 2329,
oct 2008.
[50] J. Plantinga and S. E. Trehub, "Revisiting the Innate Preference for Consonance.," Journal of
Experimental Psychology. Human Perception and Performance, vol. 40, no. 1, pp. 40 -- 49, 2014.
[51] J. H. Mcdermott, A. F. Schultz, E. A. Undurraga, and R. A. Godoy, "Indifference to dissonance
in native Amazonians reveals cultural variation in music perception," Nature, vol. 535, no. 7613,
pp. 547 -- 550, 2016.
[52] A. M. Proverbio, A. Orlandi, and F. Pisanu, "Brain processing of consonance/dissonance in musi-
cians and controls: a hemispheric asymmetry revisited.," European Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 44,
no. 6, p. 2340 -- 2356, 2016.
[53] R. D. Patterson, S. Uppenkamp, I. S. Johnsrude, and T. D. Griffiths, "The processing of temporal
pitch and melody information in auditory cortex.," Neuron, vol. 36, pp. 767 -- 776, nov 2002.
21
[54] M. Schonwiesner and R. J. Zatorre, "Depth electrode recordings show double dissociation between
pitch processing in lateral Heschl's gyrus and sound onset processing in medial Heschl's gyrus,"
Experimental Brain Research, vol. 187, no. 1, pp. 97 -- 105, 2008.
[55] M. Andermann, R. D. Patterson, M. Geldhauser, N. Sieroka, and A. Rupp, "Duifhuis Pitch: Neu-
romagnetic representation and auditory modeling.," Journal of Neurophysiology, aug 2014.
[56] M. Andermann, R. D. Patterson, C. Vogt, L. Winterstetter, and A. Rupp, "Neuromagnetic correlates
of voice pitch, vowel type, and speaker size in auditory cortex.," NeuroImage, vol. 158, pp. 79 -- 89,
2017.
[57] A. De Cheveign´e, "Cancellation model of pitch perception," The Journal of the Acoustical Society
of America, vol. 103, no. 3, pp. 1261 -- 71, 1998.
[58] E. Balaguer-Ballester, M. Coath, and S. L. Denham, "A model of perceptual segregation based on
clustering the time series of the simulated auditory nerve firing probability," Biological Cybernetics,
vol. 97, pp. 479 -- 491, dec 2007.
[59] A. Gutschalk, R. D. Patterson, M. Scherg, S. Uppenkamp, and A. Rupp, "The effect of tempo-
ral context on the sustained pitch response in human auditory cortex.," Cerebral Cortex, vol. 17,
pp. 552 -- 61, mar 2007.
[60] C. Huang and J. Rinzel, "A Neuronal Network Model for Pitch Selectivity and Representation,"
Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience, vol. 10, no. June, pp. 1 -- 17, 2016.
[61] X. J. Wang, "Probabilistic decision making by slow reverberation in cortical circuits," Neuron,
vol. 36, no. 5, pp. 955 -- 968, 2002.
[62] K.-F. Wong and X.-J. Wang, "A recurrent network mechanism of time integration in perceptual
decisions.," The Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 26, no. 4, pp. 1314 -- 1328, 2006.
[63] R. Auksztulewicz, N. Barascud, G. Cooray, A. C. Nobre, M. Chait, and K. Friston, "The Cumulative
Effects of Predictability on Synaptic Gain in the Auditory Processing Stream," The Journal of
Neuroscience, vol. 37, no. 28, pp. 6751 -- 6760, 2017.
[64] K. Friston, "A theory of cortical responses.," Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of
London. Series B, Biological sciences, vol. 360, pp. 815 -- 36, apr 2005.
[65] K. Friston and S. Kiebel, "Predictive coding under the free-energy principle.," Philosophical trans-
actions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences, vol. 364, no. 1521, pp. 1211 -- 21,
2009.
[66] S. Hochstein and M. Ahissar, "View from the Top: Hierarchies and Reverse Hierarchies Review,"
Neuron, vol. 36, no. 5, pp. 791 -- 804, 2002.
[67] K. Rauss and G. Pourtois, "What is bottom-up and what is top-down in predictive coding," Frontiers
in Psychology, vol. 4, pp. 1 -- 8, 2013.
[68] S. Biermann and P. Heil, "Parallels between timing of onset responses of single neurons in cat and
of evoked magnetic fields in human auditory cortex," Journal of Neurophysiology, vol. 84, no. 5,
pp. 2426 -- 2439, 2000.
[69] A. Gutschalk, R. D. Patterson, A. Rupp, S. Uppenkamp, and M. Scherg, "Sustained magnetic
fields reveal separate sites for sound level and temporal regularity in human auditory cortex.,"
NeuroImage, vol. 15, pp. 207 -- 16, jan 2002.
[70] D. A. Schwartz, C. Q. Howe, and D. Purves, "The statistical structure of human speech sounds
predicts musical universals.," The Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 23, no. 18, pp. 7160 -- 7168, 2003.
[71] K. Itoh, S. Suwazono, and T. Nakada, "Central auditory processing of noncontextual consonance
in music: an evoked potential study.," The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, vol. 128,
no. 6, pp. 3781 -- 3787, 2010.
22
[72] M. Scherg, R. Hari, and M. Hamalainen, "Frequency-specific sources of the auditory N19-P30-
P50 response detected by a multiple source analysis of evoked magnetic fields and potentials," in
Advances in Biomagnetism, pp. 97 -- 100, Springer US, 1989.
[73] M. Scherg, "Fundamentals of dipole source potential analysis," Advances in Audiology, vol. 6, pp. 40 --
69, 1990.
[74] M. Scherg and P. Berg, "Use of Prior Knowledge in Brain Electromagnetic Source Analysis.," Brain
Topography, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 143 -- 150, 1991.
[75] D. Bendor, M. S. Osmanski, and X. Wang, "Dual-pitch processing mechanisms in primate auditory
cortex.," The Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 32, pp. 16149 -- 61, nov 2012.
[76] D. Pressnitzer, R. D. Patterson, and K. Krumbholz, "The lower limit of melodic pitch.," The Journal
of the Acoustical Society of America, vol. 109, no. 5 Pt. 1, pp. 2074 -- 2084, 2001.
[77] M. Carandini and D. J. Heeger, "Normalization as a canonical neural computation.," Nature Re-
views. Neuroscience, vol. 13, no. 1, pp. 51 -- 62, 2011.
[78] N. Brunel and X. J. Wang, "Effects of neuromodulation in a cortical network model of object working
memory dominated by recurrent inhibition," Journal of Computational Neuroscience, vol. 11, no. 1,
pp. 63 -- 85, 2001.
[79] S. Ostojic and N. Brunel, "From spiking neuron models to linear-nonlinear models.," PLoS compu-
tational biology, vol. 7, no. 1, p. e1001056, 2011.
[80] W. Gerstner, W. M. Kistler, R. Naud, and L. Paninski, Neuronal Dynamics. Cambridge University
Press, 1st ed., 2014.
[81] N. Fourcaud-Trocm´e, D. Hansel, C. van Vreeswijk, and N. Brunel, "How spike generation mecha-
nisms determine the neuronal response to fluctuating inputs," The Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 23,
no. 37, pp. 11628 -- 11640, 2003.
[82] G. Deco, A. Ponce-Alvarez, D. Mantini, G. L. Romani, P. Hagmann, and M. Corbetta, "Resting-
State Functional Connectivity Emerges from Structurally and Dynamically Shaped Slow Linear
Fluctuations," The Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 33, pp. 11239 -- 11252, jul 2013.
[83] W. Gerstner and W. M. Kistler, Spiking Neuron Models, vol. 66. Cambridge University Press, 2002.
[84] C. C. Kerr, C. J. Rennie, and P. A. Robinson, "Physiology-based modeling of cortical auditory
evoked potentials.," Biological Cybernetics, vol. 98, no. 2, pp. 171 -- 84, 2008.
[85] M. Bruyns-Haylett, J. Luo, A. J. Kennerley, S. Harris, L. Boorman, E. Milne, N. Vautrelle,
Y. Hayashi, B. J. Whalley, M. Jones, J. Berwick, J. Riera, and Y. Zheng, "The neurogenesis of
P1 and N1: A concurrent EEG/LFP study," NeuroImage, vol. 146, pp. 575 -- 588, 2016.
[86] T. P. Roberts, P. Ferrari, S. M. Stufflebeam, and D. Poeppel, "Latency of the auditory evoked
neuromagnetic field components: stimulus dependence and insights toward perception," Journal of
Clinical Neurophysiology, vol. 17, no. 2, pp. 114 -- 29, 2000.
[87] M. S. A. Zilany and L. H. Carney, "Power-Law Dynamics in an Auditory-Nerve Model Can Account
for Neural Adaptation to Sound-Level Statistics," Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 30, pp. 10380 -- 10390,
aug 2010.
[88] W. T. Catton, "Tone Sensation produced by Repetitive Trains of Auditory 'Click' Stimuli," Nature,
vol. 168, pp. 882 -- 882, nov 1951.
[89] E. Terhardt, "Pitch, consonance, and harmony," The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,
vol. 55, no. 5, pp. 1061 -- 1069, 1974.
23
|
1708.00534 | 1 | 1708 | 2017-08-01T21:58:34 | Myelin and saltatory conduction | [
"q-bio.NC",
"q-bio.TO"
] | Essential tutorial on myelin, oligodendrocytes and their functional relevance in the pathophysiology of the brain. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Myelin and saltatory conduction
Maurizio De Pitt`a
The University of Chicago, USA
EPI BEAGLE, INRIA Rhone-Alpes, France
August 3, 2017
(Submitted as contributed section to the chapter on "Neurophysiology" of the book
"Dano cerebral " (Brain damage), JC Arango-Asprilla & L Olabarrieta-Landa eds.,
Manual Moderno Editions.)
7
1
0
2
g
u
A
1
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
4
3
5
0
0
.
8
0
7
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
1
Myelin allows fast and reliable conduction of nerve pulses
Myelin is a fatty substance that ensheathes the axon of some nerve cells, forming an
electrically insulating layer. It is considered a defining characteristic of jawed vertebrates
and is essential for the proper functioning of the nervous system of these latter. Myelin
is made by different cell types, and varies in chemical composition and configuration, but
performs the same insulating function. Myelinated axons look like strings of sausages
under a microscope, and because of their white appearance they are integral components
of the "white matter" of the brain. The myelin sausages ensue from wrapping of axons
by myelin in multiple, concentric layers and are separated from each others by small
unmyelinated axonal segments known as nodes of Ranvier. Typically the length of a node
is very small (0.1%) compared to the length of the myelinated segment. Single myelinated
fibers range in diameter from 0.2 to 20 µm on average, while unmyelinated fibers range
between 0.1 and 1 µm [1]. Peripheral axons are myelinated only if their diameter is larger
than about 1 µm, and the axonal caliber maintains a rather constant ratio to the myelin
sheath thickness [2]. A normal myelin ensheathing of a mature peripheral nerve is usually
100 times as long as the diameter of the corresponding axon [3].
Like insulating tape around an electrical wire, myelin helps to insulate the axons from
electrically charged atoms and molecules that are found in the fluid surrounding the entire
nervous system. Yet, the main purpose of myelin likely is to increase the speed at which
neural electrical impulses propagate along the nerve fiber. Along unmyelinated fibers,
impulses move continuously as waves, but, in myelinated fibers, they "hop" or propagate
by a process known as saltatory conduction. Myelin in fact decreases capacitance and
increases electrical resistance across the cell membrane (the axolemma) thereby helping
to prevent the electric current from leaving the axon. This is achieved by a heterogeneous
distribution of voltage-gated sodium channels along myelinated fibers, whose density is
low (∼25 channels/µm2) along myelinated internodes (i.e. the myelin "sausages") but
high at the nodes of Ranvier (between 2000 and 12000 channels/µm2) [4]. In this fash-
2
ion, sodium leakage into the extracellular fluid (ECF) is reduced along the myelinated
internodes, thereby maintaining a strong separation of electrical charge between the in-
tracellular fluid and the ECF. This increases sodium's ability to travel along the axon
more freely. However, although sodium diffuses along the axolemma rapidly, this process
is decremental by nature so that sodium cannot trigger the opening of the voltage-gated
sodium channels as it becomes weaker. The nodes of Ranvier, on the contrary, contain
large amounts of voltage-gated sodium channels and are easily excited as they are exposed
to the ECF allowing enough sodium into the axon to regenerate the action potential [5].
An action potential is thus restored to the original depolarization at onset at the axon
hillock each time it reaches a node of Ranvier and travels fast along the myelinated axon,
hopping from one node of Ranvier to the following one, with a propagation speed that
can exceed 10–50 m/s in humans [6, 7].
Specialized glial cells are responsible of myelin production
Production of myelin – a process known as myelination or myelogenesis – is by spe-
cialized glial cells: oligodendrocytes myelinate the axons of the central nervous system
(CNS), whereas Schwann cells supply the myelin for the peripheral nervous system (PNS).
Oligodendrocytes and Schwann cells are small cells with relatively few processes, yet with
distinct structural differences. While oligodendrocytes can envelop from one to 30 axonal
segments (i.e. internodes) depending on axon diameter, one Schwann cell only envelops
a single segment of one peripheral axon. Moreover, Schwann cells, but not oligodendro-
cytes, are surrounded by a basal lamina that forms the demarcation to the mesenchymal
environment with the nerve [8]. Both oligodendrocytes and Schwann cells not only in-
fluence axons by enhancing signal conduction by myelin sheaths but are also responsible
of segregating voltage-sensitive ion channels into distinct axonal domains that form the
nodes of Ranvier.
In addition to formation, maturation and maintenance of nodes of
Ranvier are further key functions of these cells [9].
3
The periodicity of nodes of Ranvier along axons is directly and positively related to
axon caliber [10]. In the CNS, internodal lengths are relatively uniform, ranging from
50 to 500 µm depending on oligodendrocyte nature [11, 12], and nodal periodicity is
established developmentally before myelin compaction [13, 14]. As axons grow in length,
unmyelinated gaps are myelinated by late developing oligodendrocytes, and this continues
well into adulthood, which could explain the extremely short internodes observed in
oligodendrocytes of late myelinated areas such as the cortex [15]. In the PNS, on the
contrary, the internodal distance can reach 1 to 1.5 mm [16]. This means that if we
consider the human femoral nerve, whose primary axon is approximately 0.5 m, there
are approximately 300 to 500 nodes of Ranvier occurring along a primary afferent fiber
between the thigh muscle and the cell body in the dorsal root ganglion. Because each
internodal segment is formed by a single Schwann cell, then as many as 500 Schwann
cells could participate in the myelination of each peripheral sensory axon [9].
Myelinating glial cells and axons are entirely interdependent and should be regarded
as functional units rather than separate functional entities per se [15]. Neuronal signaling
molecules and electrical activity trigger the proliferation of axon-associated glial cells and
control the synthesis of myelin [17–19]. Likewise, myelin proteins are essential for axon
radial growth and protection from extracellular insults. Additionally, in the presence of
injury or pathology, axonal signals are allegedly required for survival of myelinating glial
cells, and reciprocally, demyelinated axons do not survive indefinitely when they lose
their myelin. Severed myelinated fibers may only regenerate in the PNS but not in the
CNS [9].
Myelination is fundamental for normal brain function
In humans, myelination begins as early as in the third trimester after birth, although
little myelin already exists in the brain at the time of birth – and quickly occurs during
infancy leading to a child's fast development, including crawling and walking in the first
4
year [20]. Myelination continues through adolescences up to the fifth decade of life [21].
Normal aging, on the other hand, correlates with degenerative changes in myelin, such as
shorter internodes or thinners myelin sheaths or splitting, blebbing, ballooning of these
latter [22, 23].
Magnetic resonance imaging has revealed many examples of differences in white mat-
ter structure that correlate with specific cognitive abilities such as learning to read [24],
juggling [25] or complex skills like playing the piano [26]. In this latter case, for exam-
ple, the level of white matter structure seems to increase proportionately to the number
of hours each subject practice piano, indicating that white matter changes in acquir-
ing the skill, rather than performance being pre-determined by a limitation on white
matter development. On the other hand, lack of myelination, active demyelination, loss
of myelinating glial cells or a combination thereof, associate with age-related cognitive
decline [21, 27] as well as neurological disorders like major depressive disorder [28] and
schizophrenia [29].
When a peripheral fiber is severed, the myelin sheath provides a track along which
regrowth can occur. However, the myelin layer does not ensure a perfect regeneration
of the nerve fiber. Some regenerated nerve fibers do not find the correct muscle fibers,
and some damaged motor neurons of the peripheral nervous system die without regrowth.
Damage to the myelin sheath and nerve fiber is often associated with increased functional
insufficiency [9].
In general, many diseases of the nervous system involve myelin [30]. Multiple sclero-
sis (MS) is one of the most common neurological diseases affecting the CNS. It involves
demyelination, likely due to an autoimmune attack on myelin and oligodendrocytes. Al-
though, in most cases of relapsing and remitting MS, it appears that there is initial
remyelination due to the generation of new oligodendrocytes and new myelin, at some
point in the disease this repair process fails leading to unrecoverable motor and cognitive
deficits [31]. In the PNS, autoimmune reactions to proteins P0 and PMP22 that are main
components of peripheral myelin produce instead a demyelinating peripheral neuropathy:
5
the Guillain-Barr´e syndrome [32]. Mutations in myelin protein genes also cause a variety
of demyelinating diseases in both peripheral and central axons. In the CNS, one example
is the Pelizaeus-Merzbacher disease, a leukodystrophy in humans resulting from a reces-
sive mutation of the gene on the long arm of the X-chromosome (Xq21-22) that codes for
a myelin protein called proteolipid protein 1 (or PLP1) [33]. In the PNS, a duplication
of the PMP22 gene on chromosome 17 causes instead one form of Charcot-Marie-Tooth
disease, which is the most common inherited peripheral neuropathy, and is characterized
by progressive muscle weakness, greatly decreased conduction in peripheral nerves, and
cycles of demyelination and remyelination [34].
Overall, demyelination slows down, or even stops, conduction of the action potential in
an affected axon, because it allows electrical current to leak out of the axonal membrane.
Thus, demyelinating diseases have devastating effects on neuronal circuits in the brain,
spinal cord, and peripheral nervous system.
Iron balance is critical to myelination
Iron is an essential metal in biological systems where it is necessary for the consumption
of oxygen and production of adenosine trisphosphate (ATP) which is a key molecule
for intracellular energy transfer. It is also involved in cholesterol and neurotransmitter
synthesis and protein degradation. Because of the ability of iron to interact with oxygen,
it can also be a potent generator of free radicals. Thus cells have developed an elegant
system to keep iron bound to proteins during delivery to cells and storage therein [35].
Iron and glia have both distinctive regional and cellular distribution. At the regional
level, iron is most prominent in areas associated with motor functions such as basal
ganglia, substantia nigra (pars reticulata) and deep cerebellar nuclei and is also present
in high concentration in white matter [36]. At the cellular level, the cells that most
prominently need iron for normal function appear to be oligodendrocytes [37]. These
cells may acquire iron either in earlier stages of development or uptake it as H-ferritin,
6
both from the blood-brain barrier (mainly, but not exclusively, by astrocyte-mediated
pathways) and from microglia. Ferritin is then used by oligodendrocytes for maturation
and myelin production [38].
Oligodendrocytes are also the most sensitive to low iron insofar as hypomyelination
is a consistent finding of decreased iron availability both in development and adults
[39]. There is also emerging evidence that iron changes in white matter tracts may
mark demyelination, which could be clinically meaningful information to guide timing of
treatment intervention [40]. A further area of active investigation is on the role of genetic
variations that impact brain iron status, and hence myelination, leading to alterations in
rates of cognitive decline with age or degree of damage with disease.
Iron balance is critical to glial function given that proinflammatory cytokines, hypoxia
and other means of damage to the brain use the ability of iron to generate oxidative stress
to promote cell death in all of glial subtypes, but the most sensitive are oligodendrocytes
followed by astrocytes and then microglia [41]. Remarkably, the ability of iron chelation to
protect oligodendrocytes not only from direct exposure to proinflammatory cytokines but
also from the toxic effects of activated microglia, suggest that attempts to use this method
to treat hypoxic or ischemic injury and demyelinating diseases are well founded [42, 43].
There is indeed clear evidence that iron chelation will decrease inflammatory reaction,
although the challenge remains in the delivery of the iron chelator and the timing of
delivery. The chelating compound or the mechanism of delivery must be able to traverse
the blood-brain barrier in adequate amounts. Moreover, the chelating compound has
to discern between "good" and "bad" iron not to limit energy production that may be
needed for remyelination.
Preliminary experiments in cell culture models suggest that commercially available
chelators like deferoxamine (DFOA) could be viable clinical options to limit damage of
glial cells by hypoxia, ischemia and traumatic brain injury, although more research is
needed to identify the physiological mechanisms that could regulate the chelating com-
pound both in terms of amount of iron being chelated and the distribution of the chelator
7
with the brain [44]. Lowering dietary iron may be one way to limit iron available to exac-
erbate damage associated with neurological trauma, but again, iron must be reintroduced
for remyelination and return to normal function [45, 46].
Oxidative stress could be a key mechanism in demyelinating disorders. Substantial
histological evidence exist indeed for ongoing oxidative stress in demyelination by multiple
sclerosis [47]. Moreover, in support of a role of iron and oxidative stress in promotion of
demyelination is the finding that iron deposit in the white matter in multiple sclerosis
and that treatment with an iron chelator or an antioxidant can limit the amount of
demyelinaton and behavioral abnormalities that are associated with experimental allergic
encephalomyelitis [47–49].
A further area that involves oxidative stress damage is radiation used to treat brain
tumors. Oligodendrocytes are the most radiosensitive of glial cells [50] and human white
matter specimens obtained post-radiation confirm a delayed onset of demyelination which
correlates with loss of oligodendrocyte function [51]. Although there is not direct evidence
that iron could contribute to radiosensitivity of oligodendrocytes, it is worth noting that
exposing oligodendrocytes in cell cultures to radiation increases oxidative stress sixfold
in these cells [52], suggesting that such increase in oxidative stress could be prevented by
iron chelation.
8
References
[1] C. Koch. Biophysics of computation: information processing in single neurons. Ox-
ford University Press, Inc., New York, 1999.
[2] R. L. Friede and R. Bischhausen. How are sheath dimensions affected by axon caliber
and internode length? Brain Res., 235:335–350, 1982.
[3] R. L. Friede and W. Beuche. A new approach toward analyzing peripheral nerve
fiber populations. I. Varance in ssheath thickness corresponds to different geometric
proportions of the iinternode. J. Neuropathol. Exp. Neurol., 44:60–72, 1985.
[4] K. S. Saladin. Anatomy & physiology: the unity of form and function. McGraw-Hill,
New York, NY, 6 edition, 2012.
[5] S. T. Brady, G. J. Siegel, R. Wayne Albers, and D. L. Price. Basic neurochem-
istry: Molecular, cellular and medical Aspects. Lippincott-Raven, Philadelphia, PA,
8 edition, 2011.
[6] G. Schalow, G. A. Zch, and R. Warzok. Classification of human peripheral nerve
fiber groups by conduction velocity and nerve fiber diameter is preserved following
spinal cord lesion. J. Aut. Nervous Syst., 52:125–150, 1995.
[7] B. K. Van Veen, R. L. L. A. Schellens, D. F. Stegeman, R. Schoonhoven, and A. A.
W. M. Gabreels-Festen. Conduction velocity distributions in normal human sural
nerve. Muscle & Nerve, 18:1121–1127, 1995.
[8] R. Martini and A. Patzk´o. Neuroglia, chapter Schwann cells and myelin, pages 74–85.
Oxford University Press, 3rd edition, 2013.
[9] E. R. Kandel, J. H. Schwartz, T. M. Jessell, S. A. Siegelbaum, and A. J Hudspeth.
Principles of Neural Science. McGraw-Hill, New York, NY, 5th edition, 2012.
9
[10] M. Ibrahim, A. M. Butt, and M. Berry. Relationships between myelin sheath diam-
eter and internodal length in axons of the anterior medullary velum of the adult rat.
J. Neurol. Sci., 133(1–2):119–127, 1995.
[11] A. M. Butt, M. Ibrahim, and M. Berry. Axon-myelin sheath relations of oligoden-
drocyte unit phenotypes in the adult rat anterior medullary velum. J. Neurocytol.,
27(4):259–269, 1998.
[12] J. C. Murtie, W. B. Macklin, and G. Corfas. Morphometric analysis of oligoden-
drocytes in the adult mouse frontal cortex. J. Neurosci. Res., 85(10):2080–2086,
2007.
[13] A. M. Butt and B. R. Ransom. Morphology of astrocytes and oligodendrocytes
during development in the intact rat optic nerve. J. Comp. Neurol., 338(1):141–158,
1993.
[14] A. M. Butt, M. Ibrahim, and M. Berry. The relationship between developing oligo-
dendrocyte units and maturing axons during myelogenesis in the anterior medullary
velum of neonatal rats. J. Neurocytol., 26(5):327–338, 1997.
[15] A. M. Butt. Neuroglia, chapter Structure and function of oligodendrocytes, pages
62–73. Oxford University Press, 2013.
[16] C. Hildebrand, C. M. Bowe, and I. N. Remahl. Myelination and myelin sheath
remodelling in normal and pathological PNS nerve fibres. Prog. Neurobiol., 43:85–
141, 1994.
[17] B. A. Barres and M. C. Raff. Proliferation of oligodendrocyte precurs cells depends
on electrical activity in axons. Nature, 361:258–260, 1993.
[18] C. Demerens, B. Stankoff, M. Logak, P. Anglade, B. Allinquant, F. Couraud, B. Zalc,
and C. Lubetzki. Induction of myelination in the central nervous system by electrical
activity. Proc. Natl. Acad, Sci. USA, 93(18):9887–9892, 1996.
10
[19] H Wake, P. R. Lee, and R. D. Fields. Control of local protein synthesis and initial
events in myelination by action potentials. Science, 333(6049):1647–1651, 2011.
[20] P. I. Yakovlev and A. R. Lecours. Regional development of the brain, chapter The
myelogenetic cycles of regional maturation of the brain, pages 3–70. Blackwell,
Oxford, U. K., 1967.
[21] G. Bartzokis, P. H. Lu, and J. Mintz. Quantifying age-related myelin breakdown
with MRI: novel therapeutic targets for preventing cognitive decline and Alzheimer's
disease. J. Alzheimer's Disease, 6(Suppl. 6):S53–59, 2004.
[22] A. Peters. The effects of normal aging on myelin and nerve fibers: a review. J.
Neurocyt., 31(8):581–593, 2002.
[23] A. Peters, A. Verderosa, and C. Sethares. The neuroglial population in the primary
visual cortex of the aging rhesus monkey. Glia, 56(11):1151–1161, 2008.
[24] M. Carreiras, M. L. Seghier, S. Baquero, A. Est´evez, A. Lozano, J. T. Devlin, and
C. J. Price. An anatomical signature for literacy. Nature, 461(7266):983–986, 2009.
[25] J. Scholz, M. C. Klein, T. E. J. Behrens, and H. Johansen-Berg. Training induces
changes in white-matter architecture. Nature Neuroscience, 12(11):1370–1371, 2009.
[26] S. L. Bengtsson, Z. Nagy, S. Skare, L. Forsman, H. Forssberg, and F. Ull´en. Extensive
piano practicing has regionally specific effects on white matter development. Nature
Neuroscience, 8(9):1148–1150, 2005.
[27] M. P. Bowley, H. Cabral, D. L. Rosene, and A. Peters. Age changes in myelinated
nerve ffiber of the cingulate bundle and corpus callosum in the rhesus monkey. J.
Comp. Neurol., 518(15):3046–3064, 2010.
[28] C. Aston, L. Jiang, and B. P. Sokolov. Transcriptional profiling reveals evidence for
signaling and oligodendroglial abnormalities in the temporal cortex from patients
with major depressive disorder. Molecular Psychiatry, 10(3):309–322, 2005.
11
[29] C. Takasaki, M. Yamasaki, M. Uchigashima, K. Konno, Y. Yanagawa, and
M. Watanabe. Cytochemical and cytological properties of perineuronal oligoden-
drocytes in the mouse cortex. Eur. J. Neurosci., 32(8):1326–1336, 2010.
[30] B.A. Barres. The mystery and magic of glia: a perspective on their roles in health
and disease. Neuron, 60(3):430–440, 2008.
[31] F. D. Lublin and S. C. Reingold. Defining the clinical course of multiple sclerosis
results of an international survey. Neurology, 46(4):907–911, 1996.
[32] R. A. C. Hughes and D. R. Cornblath. Guillain-Barr´e syndrome. The Lancet, 366
(9497):1653–1666, 2005.
[33] A. H. Koeppen and Y. Robitaille. Pelizaeus-Merzbacher disease. J. Neuropathol.
Exp. Neurol., 61(9):747–759, 2002.
[34] M. M. Reilly, S. M. Murphy, and M. Laur´a. Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease. J. Periph.
Nervous Sys., 16(1):1–14, 2011.
[35] J. R. Connor and S. A. Benkovic.
Iron regulation in the brain: histochemical,
biochemical, and molecular considerations. Ann. Neurol., 32(S1), 1992.
[36] J. R. Connor and S. L. Menzies. Altered cellular distribution of iron in the central
nervous system of myelin deficient rats. Neuroscience, 34(1):265–271, 1990.
[37] J. R. Connor and S. L. Menzies. Relationship of iron to oligondendrocytes and
myelination. Glia, 17(2):83–93, 1996.
[38] J. R Connor, G. Pavlick, D. Karli, S. L. Menzies, and C. Palmer. A histochemical
study of iron-positive cells in the developing rat brain. J. Comp. Neurol., 355(1):
111–123, 1995.
[39] D. L. Schonberg, P. G. Popovich, and D. M. McTigue. Oligodendrocyte generation is
differentially influenced by toll-like receptor (TLR) 2 and TLR4-mediated intraspinal
macrophage activation. J. Neuropathol. Exp. Neurol., 66(12):1124–1135, 2007.
12
[40] J. R. Connor. Neuroglia, chapter Iron and glia, pages 586–602. Oxford University
Press, 2013.
[41] E. E. Benarroch. Oligodendrocytes: susceptibility to injury and involvement in
neurologic disease. Neurology, 72(20):1779–1785, 2009.
[42] T. V. Pedchenko and S. M. LeVine. Desferrioxamine suppresses experimental allergic
encephalomyelitis induced by MBP in SJL mice. J. Neuroimmunol., 84(2):188–197,
1998.
[43] F. A. Sorond and R. R. Ratan. Ironing-out mechanisms of neuronal injury under
hypoxic–ischemic conditions and potential role of iron chelators as neuroprotective
agents. Antioxid. Redox Signal., 2(3):421–436, 2000.
[44] S. J. Robb and J. R. Connor. An in vitro model for analysis of oxidative death in
primary mouse astrocytes. Brain Res., 788(1):125–132, 1998.
[45] S. Cortese, E. Konofal, B. D. Bernardina, M.-C. Mouren, and M. Lecendreux. Sleep
disturbances and serum ferritin levels in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity
disorder. Eur. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry, 18(7):393–399, 2009.
[46] E. Luders, K. L. Narr, L. S. Hamilton, O. R. Phillips, P. M. Thompson, J. S.
Valle, M. Del'Homme, T. Strickland, J. T. McCracken, A. W. Toga, and J. G.
Levitt. Decreased callosal thickness in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Biol.
Psychiatry, 65(1):84–88, 2009.
[47] S. M. LeVine.
Iron deposits in multiple sclerosis and Alzheimer's disease brains.
Brain Res., 760(1):298–303, 1997.
[48] N. Bowern, I. A. Ramshaw, I. A. Clark, and P. C. Doherty. Inhibition of autoimmune
neuropathological process by treatment with an iron-chelating agent. J. Exp. Med.,
160(5):1532–1543, 1984.
13
[49] H.-P. Hartung, B. Schafer, K. Heininger, and K. V. Toyka. Suppression of experi-
mental autoimmune neuritis by the oxygen radical scavengers superoxide dismutase
and catalase. Annals Neurol., 23(5):453–460, 1988.
[50] J. H. Kim, S. L. Brown, K. A. Jenrow, and S. Ryu. Mechanisms of radiation-induced
brain toxicity and implications for future clinical trials. J. Neurooncol., 87(3):279–
286, 2008.
[51] G. Panagiotakos, G. Alshamy, B. Chan, R. Abrams, E. Greenberg, A. Saxena,
M. Bradbury, M. Edgar, P. Gutin, and V. Tabar. Long-term impact of radiation
on the stem cell and oligodendrocyte precursors in the brain. PloS One, 2(7):e588,
2007.
[52] S. K. Thorburne and B. H. J. Juurlink. Low glutathione and high iron govern the
susceptibility of oligodendroglial precursors to oxidative stress. J. Neurochem., 67
(3):1014–1022, 1996.
14
|
1812.05156 | 2 | 1812 | 2019-05-21T20:57:54 | Chaotic Dynamics Enhance the Sensitivity of Inner Ear Hair Cells | [
"q-bio.NC",
"physics.bio-ph"
] | Hair cells of the auditory and vestibular systems are capable of detecting sounds that induce sub-nanometer vibrations of the hair bundle, below the stochastic noise levels of the surrounding fluid. Hair bundles of certain species are also known to oscillate without external stimulation, indicating the presence of an underlying active mechanism. We propose that chaotic dynamics enhance the sensitivity and temporal resolution of the hair bundle response, and provide experimental and theoretical evidence for this effect. By varying the viscosity and ionic composition of the surrounding fluid, we are able to modulate the degree of chaos observed in the hair bundle dynamics in vitro. We consistently find that the hair bundle is most sensitive to a stimulus of small amplitude when it is poised in the weakly chaotic regime. Further, we show that the response time to a force step decreases with increasing levels of chaos. These results agree well with our numerical simulations of a chaotic Hopf oscillator and suggest that chaos may be responsible for the sensitivity and temporal resolution of hair cells. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Chaotic Dynamics Enhance the Sensitivity of Inner
Ear Hair Cells
Justin Faber1 and Dolores Bozovic1,2,*
1Department of Physics & Astronomy, University of California, Los Angeles, California 90095, USA
2California NanoSystems Institute, University of California, Los Angeles, California 90095, USA
*[email protected]
ABSTRACT
Hair cells of the auditory and vestibular systems are capable of detecting sounds that induce sub-nanometer vibra-
tions of the hair bundle, below the stochastic noise levels of the surrounding fluid. Hair bundles of certain species
are also known to oscillate without external stimulation, indicating the presence of an underlying active mechanism.
We propose that chaotic dynamics enhance the sensitivity and temporal resolution of the hair bundle response, and
provide experimental and theoretical evidence for this effect. By varying the viscosity and ionic composition of the
surrounding fluid, we are able to modulate the degree of chaos observed in the hair bundle dynamics in vitro. We
consistently find that the hair bundle is most sensitive to a stimulus of small amplitude when it is poised in the
weakly chaotic regime. Further, we show that the response time to a force step decreases with increasing levels of
chaos. These results agree well with our numerical simulations of a chaotic Hopf oscillator and suggest that chaos
may be responsible for the sensitivity and temporal resolution of hair cells.
The auditory system exhibits extraordinary sensitivity and
temporal resolution. It is capable of detecting sounds that
induce motion in the A regime, below that of the stochastic
noise levels of the surrounding fluid.1 Humans are able to
resolve two stimulus impulses that are temporally separated
by only 10 microseconds, where the stimulus waveform is
presented simultaneously into both ears.2 These and other
remarkable features of the auditory system are not fully un-
derstood, and the physics of hearing remains an active area of
research.3
Mechanical detection is performed by hair cells, special-
ized sensory cells named after the organelle that protrudes
from their apical surface. This organelle, called the hair bun-
dle, consists of rod-like stereovilli that are organized in in-
terconnected rows. An incoming sound wave pivots the hair
bundle, modulating the open probability of the transduction
channels that are embedded at the tips of the stereovilli. The
mechanical energy of a sound wave is thus transduced into
an electrical potential change, due to the influx of ionic cur-
rent.4, 5
Hair bundles of several species have been shown to oscil-
late even in the absence of a stimulus.6, 7 These spontaneous
oscillations are a manifestation of an internal active process,
as they violate the fluctuation dissipation theorem.8, 9 Sponta-
neous oscillations of the hair bundle hence provide a useful
experimental probe for studying the underlying active mech-
anism in vitro.7 While their role in vivo remains to be deter-
mined, the presence of spontaneous otoacoustic emissions10
suggests that active innate oscillators may be present in the
inner ears of intact animals. Several numerical studies have
applied dynamical systems models to demonstrate that spon-
taneous motility could produce otoacoustic emissions.11, 12
Dynamics of the auditory response have been modeled
using the normal form equation for Hopf bifurcations.13, 14
This simple differential equation accounts for many experi-
mentally observed phenomena, including the sensitivity and
frequency selectivity of hearing exhibited by many species.
To reproduce the empirically measured sensitivity, the models
have assumed that the system is poised in close proximity to
the Hopf bifurcation. This assumption raises the question of
how the biological system achieves and then maintains such
fine-tuning of the parameters. To circumvent this issue, some
models include a dynamic feedback equation responsible for
automatically tuning the control parameter towards or away
from criticality.15, 16 Other studies proposed that the inclusion
of a homeostatic equation can broaden the parameter regime
of extreme sensitivity, frequency selectivity, and compressive
nonlinearity.17 A second issue with proximity to criticality is
the phenomenon of critical slowing down: near the bifurca-
tion, a system would exhibit a slow response, which seems
inconsistent with the high temporal resolution that character-
izes hearing. This second objection is not resolved by the
inclusion of homeostasis or feedback.
We propose that the system is poised in the oscillatory
state, not in the immediate vicinity of the Hopf bifurcation.
We focus our theoretical and experimental studies on that
regime, as it is consistent with the occurrence of spontaneous
otoacoustic emissions in vivo, a phenomenon that is ubiqui-
tous across vertebrate species. In a prior study, we demon-
strated experimentally that spontaneous oscillations exhibit
chaotic dynamics.18 Further, we showed theoretically that
the Hopf oscillator exhibits enhanced temporal resolution and
1
arXiv:1812.05156v2 [q-bio.NC] 21 May 2019
sensitivity when poised in the unstable regime where noise
induces chaos.19 As chaotic oscillators are a subclass of
nonlinear systems that exhibit extreme sensitivity to initial
conditions,20 we propose that chaos leads to both high sen-
sitivity and rapid response to mechanical perturbation that
characterizes hair bundle dynamics.
In the current work, we show that, for a wide range of pa-
rameter conditions, additive noise induces chaotic dynamics.
We use a simple theoretical model to demonstrate that extreme
sensitivity and rapid response time of the chaotic system both
occur over a wide parameter range, without the need for a feed-
back equation. This alternative view could explain how the
performance of the hair cells would be robust to noise as well
as to changes in parameters, and how it can achieve extreme
sensitivity in the oscillatory regime, from which otoacoustic
emissions can originate. In the numerical model, we vary the
degree of chaos and show that the sensitivity to different stim-
ulus waveforms is enhanced and the response time reduced, as
the degree of chaos is increased. We propose to view the hair
cell not just as a mechanical resonator, but as an information
processor that extracts selective information from its acoustic
environment. We then show that the amount of information
extracted by the active oscillator from an imposed stimulus
waveform is maximized in the weakly chaotic regime. We
verify our theoretical predictions by experiments performed
on in vitro preparations of the bullfrog sacculus. By varying
the viscosity and the ionic conditions of the fluid in which
the hair bundles are immersed, we modulate the chaoticity of
their dynamics, and we measure the sensitivity, information
transfer, and temporal response to various imposed signals.
We find consistent experimental agreement with all of the
theoretical predictions of the model. We therefore propose
that the instabilities giving rise to chaotic dynamics enhance
the sensitivity and temporal resolution of the auditory and
vestibular hair cells.
Numerical Model
We use the normal form equation for the supercritical Hopf
bifurcation with additive Gaussian white noise, ηz(t):
dz(t)
dt
where
= (µ + iω0)z(t)− (α + iβ )z(t)2z(t) + ηz(t), (1)
z(t) = x(t) + iy(t),
ηz(t) = ηx(t) + iηy(t),
hηx(t)ηx(t0)i = hηy(t)ηy(t0)i = 2Dδ (t −t0),
and
hηx(t)ηy(t0)i = 0.
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
Here, x(t) represents the bundle position, while y(t) reflects
internal parameters of the bundle and is not assigned a specific
measurable quantity. µ represents the control parameter of
the system, with positive values yielding a limit cycle and neg-
ative values resulting in a stable fixed point. The autonomous
angular frequency of this system in the absence of noise is
Ω0 = ω0 − β r2
α is the radius of the limit
cycle. Thus, ω0 represents the angular frequency at the Hopf
bifurcation (µ = 0). α and β characterize the cubic nonlin-
earity of the system, while D represents the noise strength.
Auditory and vestibular stimuli induce lateral deflections on
the hair bundle, so we consider forces in the x direction, which
coincides with the direction of spontaneous oscillation.
0, where r0 =q µ
A characteristic feature of chaotic systems is that neigh-
boring solutions to the differential equations diverge exponen-
tially with time: ∆z(t) ≈ eλt∆z(0), where ∆z(t) is the sep-
aration between two neighboring trajectories in phase space,
and λ is the Lyapunov exponent.20 Thus, small perturbations
to a chaotic system will have a drastic impact on future dy-
namics. The Lyapunov exponent characterizes how quickly
the perturbations grow and serves as a measure of the degree
of chaos. A stable fixed point is characterized by a negative
Lyapunov exponent, as neighboring trajectories converge to
the same location. A limit cycle has a Lyapunov exponent
equal to zero, since a perturbation tangential to the direction
of motion neither grows nor shrinks. A positive value of the
Lyapunov exponent indicates chaotic dynamics, with larger
values corresponding to more irregular behavior and weaker
predictability.
In the presence of stochastic processes, the Lyapunov ex-
ponent is calculated by measuring the exponential rate of diver-
gence of two neighboring trajectories, subjected to identical
realizations of noise (i.e. common noise).21 -- 23 This has been
observed in other 2-dimensional systems24 and is commonly
referred to as noise-induced chaos. In Fig. 1, we demonstrate
that the additive noise to equation 1 induces chaotic dynamics,
as it causes solutions to diverge exponentially. Further, the
attractor exhibits a fractal structure, which is ubiquitous to
chaotic systems.25 The simplicity of this model allows us
to use an analytic approximation of the Lyapunov exponent,
applying Fokker-Planck theory (see Methods):
λ ≈ βD
µ .
(6)
Without loss of generality, we set α = Ω0 = 1, scaling the
units of length and time. The remaining three parameters, µ,
β , and D are used to modulate the Lyapunov exponent.
The Lyapunov exponent provides the simplest measure
of chaos for numerical models. However, the Kolmogorov
entropy (K-entropy) constitutes a more appropriate measure
of chaoticity for experimental data sets, which inherently
contain measurement noise and are more limited in duration
than typical numerical simulations.26 Similar to the Lya-
punov exponent, the K-entropy measures the divergence rate
of neighboring trajectories.27 Specifically, K-entropy quanti-
fies the rate at which phase space information is lost due to
an expansion of measurement uncertainty. K-entropy is zero
2/13
Figure 1. (a) The divergence of two neighboring solutions to equation (1). The two time-dependent solutions are depicted
with black (solid) and red (dashed) lines. (b) The natural logarithm of the average separation of neighboring trajectories. Each
of the five colors represents an average of 200 pairs of neighboring trajectories, taken with different initial conditions and
realizations of common noise. The dashed line represents the linear fit to all of the data within the first 400 time steps. (c) The
spreading of trajectories throughout the phase space. 104 initial conditions were randomly selected in the same neighborhood
(red points). After 500 time steps, these solutions spread across the phase space to reveal the fractal structure of the attractor
(black points). Side panels show zoomed-in sections corresponding to the colored squares in the main figure.
for non-chaotic systems, non-zero for chaotic systems, and
infinity for white noise. We therefore use the K-entropy as
our measure of chaoticity when making direct comparisons
between theory and experiment.
Theoretical Results
We next explore the effects of chaos and noise on the system's
sensitivity to a weak stimulus. The oscillator demonstrates
higher responsiveness to sinusoidal and square wave stimuli
when it is poised in the weakly chaotic regime (Fig. 2). We
note that the traditional linear response function is not an ap-
propriate measure of sensitivity in the oscillatory regime, as it
would yield infinite sensitivity at the natural frequency, in the
limit of vanishing stimulus amplitude and noise. Instead, we
use the amplitude gain at the frequency of the applied signal
as a measure of the system's responsiveness.11, 18 We define
gain = x(ωstim)
, where x(ωstim) and x0(ωstim) are the Fourier
x0(ωstim)
components at the stimulus frequency in the presence and
absence of stimulus, respectively. Fig. 2 shows sample traces
that can be used to calculate the gain. Notice that the weakly
chaotic regime is easily entrained to off-resonance stimulus
frequencies. We consistently find that the chaotic regime is
more sensitive than the stable limit cycle regime. Upon a
further increase in the chaoticity of the system, reflected by a
higher Lyapunov exponent, the sensitivity deteriorates.
We measure the gain of the system in response to an on-
resonance sinusoidal stimulus for a wide range of Lyapunov
exponent values and noise strengths (Fig. 3a). We find that
the system is most responsive in the weakly chaotic regime
(low, but nonzero Lyapunov exponent). Importantly, this is
true even at high levels of additive noise (signal-to-noise ratio
< 1). Further, we see similar results for off-resonance stimuli
(see supplemental material, Fig. S2).
Next, we explore the effects of chaos and noise on the
amount of signal information captured by the detector (trans-
fer entropy28). In contrast to measures such as mutual in-
formation, transfer entropy explicitly identifies the direction
of information flow. For continuous stimulus and response
signals, calculation of transfer entropy requires discretizing
the range of the signals and assigning a state for each bin
(see Methods). We therefore use a square wave stimulus with
stochastic variation of the period (burst noise or random tele-
graph noise).18 Such stochastic signals constantly produce
3/13
Figure 2. (a-b) Time-domain responses to (off-resonance) sinusoidal and step stimulus, respectively. The top, black traces
show the stimulus waveform. Bottom, middle, and top blue traces represent responses of a system with no chaos, weak chaos,
and strong chaos, respectively. The degree of chaos was modulated by varying β and ω0, while keeping the natural frequency
fixed at Ω0 = 1. (c-e) Power spectral density of the response to on-resonance sinusoidal stimulus (ωstim = Ω0 = 1, as indicated
by the vertical, dashed lines) for systems exhibiting no chaos (c), weak chaos (d), and strong chaos (e). Red and black curves
represent the spectral density in the presence and absence of the stimulus, respectively. (f-h) Power spectral density of the
response to off-resonance sinusoidal stimulus (ωstim = 1+√5
exhibiting no chaos (f), weak chaos (g), and strong chaos (h). The stimulus frequency was set to the golden ratio with respect to
the natural frequency to avoid mode locking. Red and black curves represent the spectral density in the presence and absence of
the stimulus, respectively.
2 Ω0, as indicated by the vertical, dashed lines) for systems
new information, and the transfer entropy measures how much
of this new information is captured by the detector. The square
wave intervals are randomly generated from a flat distribution
that spans two octaves on either side of the natural frequency
( 1
4Ω0 to 4Ω0). We measure the transfer entropy over a wide
range of Lyapunov exponent values and noise strengths and
find results consistent with the measurements of the gain (Fig.
3b). We also show that consistent results are obtained when µ
is used to modulate the Lyapunov exponent in place of β (see
supplemental material, Fig. S3). The weakly chaotic regime
is optimal for extracting information from the signal. This
feature persists at high levels of additive Gaussian white noise
(signal-to-noise ratio < 1).
As an additional test of the system's response, we also
measure the mean displacement induced by a step stimulus.
We apply a step stimulus to the system and average over many
different initial conditions and realizations of noise. We then
compute the difference between the averaged curves before
4/13
Figure 3. (a) Phase-locked amplitude gain for on-resonance, sinusoidal stimulus. (b) Transfer entropy from burst noise
stimulus to response of the Hopf oscillator. For (a-b), β , ω0, and D, were varied, resulting in a range of Lyapunov exponents.
All other parameters were fixed (µ = α = Ω0 = 1). Color was generated by linearly interpolating a grid of 21 Lyapunov
exponent values and 29 noise strengths. The stimulus amplitude was set to 0.5 for both panels. The vertical dashed lines
indicate the points where the signal-to-noise ratio is 1, as defined by the ratio of the signal power to the noise power. (c)
Phase-locked amplitude gain for on-resonance, sinusoidal stimulus. (b) Transfer entropy from burst noise stimulus to response
of the Hopf oscillator. (c) Mean displacement in response to a step stimulus. (d) Response time to the step stimulus, calculated
by taking the decay time of an exponential fit to the mean response. For (c-f), the Kolmogorov entropy was modulated by
varying β and ω0. All other parameters were fixed (µ = α = Ω0 = 1, D = 0.05).
the onset of the step stimulus and after the system settles to
the new steady state. Both the transfer entropy and the mean
response amplitude show a local maximum as the degree of
chaos is varied (Fig. 3d-e), consistent with the sensitivity
observed in response to sinusoidal stimuli.
Finally, we measure the characteristic time of the exponen-
tial rise of the averaged response to the step-function forcing.
We use this response time to characterize the temporal res-
olution of the system. The response time decreases with
increasing levels of chaos (Fig. 3f). Increasing chaoticity
therefore allows the system to exhibit a faster response to an
external perturbation.
Experimental Results
We use two experimental parameters to modulate the degree of
chaos exhibited by oscillatory hair cells in vitro. The first pa-
rameter varied is the calcium concentration of the endolymph
solution, which has been shown to affect the dynamics of
the adaptive mechanisms within the hair bundle.29 Varying
the calcium concentration alters the spontaneous oscillation
profile,7 with higher concentrations resulting in more irregular
dynamics (Fig. 4a,c). As expected, increasing the calcium
concentration increases the degree of chaos (see supplemental
material, Fig. S4).
The second experimental parameter we vary is the viscos-
ity of the endolymph solution. It has recently been shown
that increasing the viscosity suprisingly increases the regu-
larity of the spontaneous oscillations.30 Once the viscosity
5/13
Figure 4. (a) Spontaneous oscillations of a hair bundle under various calcium concentrations of the endolymph. From bottom
to top: 100 µM (low calcium), 250 µM (natural calcium), and 325 µM (high calcium). (b) Spontaneous oscillations of a hair
bundle with various endolymph viscosities. From bottom to top: 0, 70, and 100 mg
ml of Dextran 500. (c) Power spectral density
of the traces in (a). (d) Power spectral density of the traces in (b).
is increased beyond about five times its natural value, the
regularity of the spontaneous oscillations then decreases (Fig.
4b,d). We vary both of these parameters in our experiments in
order to densely sample the parameter space of this chaotic
oscillator.
While the variations described above yield visible differ-
ences in the regularity of the oscillations, rigorous mathemati-
cal tests are required to establish whether the active motility is
chaotic or not. One reliable method for determining the pres-
ence of chaos in a system is provided by observing the type of
transition it undergoes as it phase-locks to an external signal.
If the external signal induces a torus-breakdown transition,
this feature is an indicator of chaos. We hence constructed
Poincar´e maps of hair bundle oscillations driven by sinusoidal
mechanical perturbations of increasing amplitude,18 follow-
ing methods developed earlier.31 We determine the discrete
time series, [In], where each element reflects the time interval
between the steepest rising flanks of consecutive hair bundle
oscillations. We then plot the nth versus the (n + 1)th point
of the series to obtain the Poincar´e map (Fig. 5a-c). For low-
amplitude, off-resonance stimuli, the points comprise a ring
structure, revealing a cross-section of the underlying torus,
and are indicative of quasiperiodic dynamics. Chaotic dy-
namics arise when this ring structure loses smoothness.32 -- 34
To check for smoothness of a Poincar´e map, we determine
the series of angles that each point makes with the abscissa
and construct a circle map, θn+1 = f (θn) (Fig. 5d-f). When
the surface of the torus is smooth, the map f is a monotoni-
cally increasing function. When chaos arises, the torus loses
smoothness, and the map f loses monotonicity and may cease
to be a function at all.
Under the natural conditions of the hair cell, we con-
sistently find that off-resonance stimulus induces the torus-
breakdown transition to/from chaos. Likewise, under high-
calcium conditions, the circle map shows the absence of
smoothness indicative of a chaotic system. However, when the
hair cell is immersed in a low-calcium endolymph solution,
the torus breakdown transition vanishes, and the circle map
becomes a function (Fig. 5d). This finding suggests that spon-
taneous oscillations in low-calcium solution are non-chaotic,
consistent with the observation of their regularity, reflected in
a higher quality factor (Q > 3).
6/13
Figure 5. (a-c) Poincar´e maps constructed from the time intervals between the steepest rising flanks of consecutive hair
bundle oscillations under low (175µM), natural (250µM), and high (325µM) calcium concentrations of the endolymph, during
presentation of off-resonance stimulus. (d) Circle map corresponding to the low-calcium conditions. The monotonic function
suggests the absence of chaos. (e-f) Circle maps corresponding to the natural- and high-calcium conditions, respectively. The
absence of a monotonic function indicates the presence of chaos. We use Spearman's rank correlation coefficient to test for
monotonicity of the circle maps. Under low-, natural-, and high-calcium conditions, Spearman's coefficient is 0.60 ± 0.01,
0.14 ± 0.01, and 0.30 ± 0.02, respectively. Uncertainties represent 1 standard deviation from a sample of 100 bootstraps.
In addition to the Poincar´e maps, we quantify the degree
of chaos in the active dynamics of hair cells by estimating
their Kolmogorov entropy, following techniques previously
developed for the analysis of experimental records (see Meth-
ods).26 We note that this measure is useful for characterization
of the degree of chaos in a system, once other methods have
confirmed its presence. Any amount of measurement noise
imposes a noise floor on the K-entropy, and hence, even the
most regular spontaneous oscillations yield a small, positive
K-entropy. An independent method must therefore be used to
identify the crossover from stable to chaotic dynamics, and
thus determine the effective noise floor on K-entropy. The
circle maps described above indicate a non-chaotic state under
low-calcium conditions, with the corresponding K-entropy
that is small and positive, at ∼ 0.5 bits/τ. We hence use this
value of K-entropy as an experimental estimate of the noise
floor.
To obtain different levels of chaos in bundle dynamics,
we immersed the preparations in solutions of different com-
binations of calcium concentration and viscosity. At each
experimental condition, we first record the innate oscillations
of hair bundles, followed by measurements of their response
to sinusoidal stimuli, presented at several fixed frequencies
selected to yield both on- and off-resonance responses. Subse-
quently, we present burst noise, with square waves of various
duration, selected from a random distribution (see Methods).
Measurements of the response to sinusoidal stimuli allow us to
extract the phase-locked amplitude gain as an estimate of the
mechanical sensitivity of the system. The burst noise yields
the measure of the transfer entropy, as well as that of the mean
displacement and response time of the bundle. The same
methods are used to analyze the experimental records as those
obtained from numerical simulations in the prior section.
Our findings consistently show optimal sensitivity and in-
formation gain in the weakly chaotic regime, as shown in Fig.
6 and in the supplemental material (Fig. S5). Upon increasing
the degree of chaos, we find that the gain increases by at least
2-fold (even 5-fold for some cells). The information extracted
from the burst noise stimulus also increases by more than 2-
fold as the level of chaos is increased. Furthermore, increasing
chaoticity yields a more rapid response time (Fig. 6d and S6),
indicating a higher temporal resolution. Within the range of
7/13
Figure 6. (a) Phase-locked amplitude gain for 2 pN sinusoidal stimulus, presented at the natural frequency. Data points and
error bars on this measure represent the mean and standard deviation from 100 bootstraps. The noise floor (dashed curve) was
calculated by treating a segment of the spontaneous oscillation recording as if a stimulus were present and calculating the gain.
This curve represents the mean plus one standard deviation from 100 bootstraps. (b) Transfer entropy from burst noise stimulus
to hair bundle response. Data points and error bars represent the mean and standard deviation obtained from 100 bootstraps.
The noise floor (dashed curve) was determined by calculating the transfer entropy in the reverse direction (response to
stimulus). This curve represents the mean plus one standard deviation from 100 bootstraps. (c) Average displacement induced
on the hair bundle from the step stimulus, averaged over ∼ 200 square waves. Data points and error bars represent the mean
and standard deviation of the response plateau. Orange-open and purple-filled data points represent averages over steps in the
positive (channel open) and negative (channel closed) directions, respectively. The noise floor is represented by the dashed line.
(d) Response time to step stimulus, characterized by fitting the mean response to an exponential and extracting the decay time.
Error bars represent the standard deviation of the residual associated with the exponential fit. All measurements were
performed on the same cell.
experimentally accessible levels of chaos, we see the response
time reduce by about 5-fold (3-fold if measured in terms of
the natural period of the hair bundle, see Fig. S6g-i).
Discussion
The auditory and vestibular systems have provided a powerful
experimental testing ground for concepts in nonlinear dynam-
ics,13, 15 nonequilibrium thermodynamics,35 and condensed
matter theory.36 Some of the long-standing open questions
in this field pertain to how hair cells can reliably transform
8/13
a sound wave into a neural spike train with such sensitivity,
frequency selectivity, and temporal resolution. Most theoret-
ical studies of hair cell detection have focused on the stable
limit cycle regime or on the interface between a stable limit
cycle and a stable fixed point. Using the simplest model of
hair cell dynamics, we have identified a chaotic state that
has greater sensitivity to both sinusoidal and step-function
stimuli than either of these traditional regimes in the presence
of noise. Further, we have shown that this chaotic regime
extracts more information from its acoustic environment and
achieves greater temporal resolution, all while maintaining
robustness to additive noise.
Chaos is typically considered a harmful element to dynam-
ical systems. For example, a chaotic heartbeat is an indicator
of cardiac fibrillation.37, 38 Chaos may also be responsible for
the anti-reliability of neurons.22, 39 However, in the present
work, we have demonstrated that chaos is beneficial to sen-
sory detection by hair cells. The dynamic state of a chaotic
system depends sensitively on its initial conditions, and hence
a small perturbation can result in a drastic change in the sub-
sequent dynamics. We speculate that evolution has exploited
this feature of chaos to enable hair cells to achieve sensitivity
to displacements in the A regime. Furthermore, auditory de-
tection relies on high temporal resolution, in order to enable
accurate spatial localization of a sound. Our results, obtained
both theoretically and experimentally, indicate that a chaotic
system exhibits faster response times than one poised in the
stable regime. This is again consistent with the general nature
of chaotic systems, which show exponential divergence of
trajectories in response to a perturbation. We propose that this
regime provides an attractive alternative to proximity to the
Hopf bifurcation, which achieves high sensitivity, but at the
price of critical slowing down.
As most biological systems are nonlinear and contain
many degrees of freedom, chaos is likely to be a ubiquitous
feature of their dynamics. We speculate that many other sys-
tems in biology, beyond those currently known, may exhibit
chaotic dynamics. In particular, sensory systems that are re-
sponsible for detection of external signals may have evolved
to harness the power of these instabilities.
In the present
work, we explored the effects of chaos on the sensitivity of
an individual hair cell, and demonstrated that it enhances its
responsiveness. Our future work entails exploring the effects
of chaos on the sensitivity of detection in systems of coupled
hair cells.
References
1. Hudspeth, A. J. Integrating the active process of hair cells
with cochlear function. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 15, 600 -- 614
(2014).
3. Reichenbach, T. & Hudspeth, A. J. The physics of hear-
ing: fluid mechanics and the active process of the inner
ear. Reports on Prog. Phys. 77, 076601 (2014).
4. LeMasurier, M. & Gillespie, P. G. Hair-cell mechan-
otransduction and cochlear amplification. Neuron 48,
403 -- 415 (2005).
5. Vollrath, M. A., Kwan, K. Y. & Corey, D. P. The micro-
machinery of mechanotransduction in hair cells. Annu.
Rev. Neurosci. 30, 339 -- 365 (2007).
6. Benser, M. E., Marquis, R. E. & Hudspeth, A. J. Rapid,
active hair bundle movements in hair cells from the bull-
frog's sacculus. J. Neurosci. 16, 5629 -- 5643 (1996).
7. Martin, P., Bozovic, D., Choe, Y. & Hudspeth, A. J. Spon-
taneous oscillation by hair bundles of the bullfrog's sac-
culus. J. Neurosci. 23, 4533 -- 4548 (2003).
8. Martin, P., Hudspeth, A. J. & Julicher, F. Comparison of
a hair bundle's spontaneous oscillations with its response
to mechanical stimulation reveals the underlying active
process. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 98, 14380 -- 14385
(2001).
9. Hudspeth, A. J. Making an effort to listen: mechanical
amplification in the ear. Neuron 59, 530 -- 545 (2008).
10. Kemp, D. T. Evidence of mechanical nonlinearity and
frequency selective wave amplification in the cochlea.
Arch. Oto-Rhino-Laryngology 224, 37 -- 45 (1979).
11. Vilfan, A. & Duke, T. Frequency clustering in sponta-
neous otoacoustic emissions from a lizard's ear. Biophys.
J. 95, 4622 -- 4630 (2008).
12. Fruth, F., Julicher, F. & Lindner, B. An active oscillator
model describes the statistics of spontaneous otoacoustic
emissions. Biophys. J. 107, 815 -- 824 (2014).
13. Egu´ıluz, V. M., Ospeck, M., Choe, Y., Hudspeth, A. J.
& Magnasco, M. O. Essential nonlinearities in hearing.
Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 5232 -- 5235 (2000).
14. Kern, A. & Stoop, R. Essential role of couplings be-
tween hearing nonlinearities. Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 128101
(2003).
15. Camalet, S., Duke, T., Julicher, F. & Prost, J. Auditory
sensitivity provided by self-tuned critical oscillations of
hair cells. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 97, 3183 -- 3188
(2000).
16. Shlomovitz, R. et al. Low frequency entrainment of os-
cillatory bursts in hair cells. Biophys. J. 104, 1661 -- 1669
(2013).
17. Milewski, A. R., ´O Maoil´eidigh, D., Salvi, J. D. & Hud-
speth, A. J. Homeostatic enhancement of sensory trans-
duction. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 114, E6794 -- E6803
(2017).
2. Leshowitz, B. Measurement of the two-click threshold.
The J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 49, 462 -- 466 (1971).
18. Faber, J. & Bozovic, D. Chaotic dynamics of inner ear
hair cells. Sci. Reports 8, 3366 (2018).
9/13
19. Faber, J. & Bozovic, D. Noise-induced chaos and signal
detection by the nonisochronous hopf oscillator. Chaos
29, 043132 (2019).
20. Anishchenko, V. S., Astakhov, V., Neiman, A., Vadi-
vasova, T. & Schimansky-Geier, L. Nonlinear Dynam-
ics of Chaotic and Stochastic Systems (Springer-Verlag
Berlin Heidelberg, 2007).
21. Goldobin, D. S. & Pikovsky, A. Synchronization and
desynchronization of self-sustained oscillators by com-
mon noise. Phys. Rev. E 71, 045201 (2005).
22. Goldobin, D. S. & Pikovsky, A. Antireliability of noise-
driven neurons. Phys. Rev. E 73, 061906 (2006).
23. Neiman, A. B., Dierkes, K., Lindner, B., Han, L. &
Shilnikov, A. L. Spontaneous voltage oscillations and
response dynamics of a hodgkin-huxley type model of
sensory hair cells. The J. Math. Neurosci. 1, 11 (2011).
24. Gan, C. Noise-induced chaos in a quadratically nonlin-
ear oscillator. Chaos, Solitons & Fractals 30, 920 -- 929
(2006).
25. Strogatz, S. H. Nonlinear Dynamics and Chaos (Addison-
Wesley, 1994).
26. Grassberger, P. & Procaccia, I. Estimation of the kol-
mogorov entropy from a chaotic signal. Phys. Rev. A 28,
2591 -- 2593 (1983).
27. Kolmogorov, A. N. A new metric invariant of transitive
dynamical systems and lebesgue space automorphisms.
Dokl. Acad. Sci. USSR 119, 861 -- 864 (1958).
28. Schreiber, T. Measuring information transfer. Phys. Rev.
Lett. 85, 461 -- 464 (2000).
29. Eatock, R. A. Adaptation in hair cells. Annu. Rev. Neu-
rosci. 23, 285 -- 314 (2000).
30. Barral, J., Julicher, F. & Martin, P. Friction from trans-
duction channels' gating affects spontaneous hair-bundle
oscillations. Biophys. J. 114, 425 -- 436 (2018).
31. Hegger, R. & Kantz, H. Embedding of sequences of time
intervals. Europhys. Lett. 38, 267 -- 272 (1997).
32. Fenichel, N. & Moser, J. K. Persistence and smoothness
of invariant manifolds for flows. Indiana Univ. Math. J.
21, 193 -- 226 (1971).
33. Aronson, D. G., Chory, M. A., Hall, G. R. & McGe-
hee, R. P. Bifurcations from an invariant circle for two-
parameter families of maps of the plane: A computer-
assisted study. Commun. Math. Phys. 83, 303 -- 354
(1982).
34. Shilnikov, A., Shilnikov, L. & Turaev, D. On some math-
ematical topics in classical synchronization.: A tutorial.
Int. J. Bifurc. Chaos 14, 2143 -- 2160 (2004).
35. Dinis, L., Martin, P., Barral, J., Prost, J. & Joanny, J. F.
Fluctuation-response theorem for the active noisy oscilla-
tor of the hair-cell bundle. Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 160602
(2012).
36. Risler, T., Prost, J. & Julicher, F. Universal critical be-
havior of noisy coupled oscillators. Phys. Rev. Lett. 93,
175702 (2004).
37. Garfinkel, A. et al. Quasiperiodicity and chaos in cardiac
fibrillation. The J. Clin. Investig. 99, 305 -- 314 (1997).
38. Kim, Y. H. et al. Spatiotemporal complexity of ventricular
fibrillation revealed by tissue mass reduction in isolated
swine right ventricle. further evidence for the quasiperi-
odic route to chaos hypothesis. The J. Clin. Investig. 100,
2486 -- 2500 (1997).
39. Stoop, R., Vyver, J. J. V. D. & Kern, A. Limit cycles,
noise, and chaos in hearing. Microsc. Res. Tech. 63, 400 --
412 (2004).
Data Availability
The data supporting the findings of this study are available
within the article and its supplementary material file. Raw
datasets generated during the current study are available from
the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Acknowledgements
The authors gratefully acknowledge support of NSF Physics
of Living Systems, under grant 1705139. The authors thank
Dr. Sebastiaan Meenderink for developing the software used
for tracking hair bundle movement.
Author contributions statement
D.B. conceived the experiments, J.F. conducted the experi-
ments, D.B. and J.F. analyzed the results. D.B. and J.F. wrote
the manuscript.
Competing Interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
10/13
from the noiseless limit cycle radius. We now use Fokker-
Planck theory to find the probability distribution, P(∆r), of
this stable potential. Inserting the drift and diffusion terms
into the Fokker-Plank equation, we get
∂ P
∂t
∂
∂∆r
= −
(−2µ∆rP) + D(
We seek the steady-state solution, ∂ P
∂
∂∆r
∂t = 0.
)2((∆θ )2P).
(14)
2µ∆rP + D
∂
∂∆r
((∆θ )2P) = constant = 0.
(15)
The constant must be zero in order for P(∆r = ∞) = 0.
2µ∆rP + D(∆θ )2 ∂ P
∂∆r
+ 2D(∆θ )P
∂∆θ
∂∆r
= 0.
(16)
We will assume that P(∆θ ) reaches steady state quickly
due to the stability of the limit cycle. If the dynamics in r can
quickly stabilize upon variation in θ, we can ignore the third
term and easily find the probability distribution;
∂ P
∂∆r
2µ∆r
D(∆θ )2 P
= −
P(∆r) = Ce−
µ∆r2
D(∆θ )2 ,
(17)
(18)
where C =q µ
1
∆θ is a normalization constant. As expected,
this distribution spreads out as we increase the noise strength
or the angular deviation, ∆θ. We now treat the θ equation:
πD
θ2 − θ1 = −β (r2
2 − r2
1) + ηy(t)(
−ηx(t)(
cosθ2
r2 −
sinθ2
r2 −
cosθ1
r1
sinθ1
r1
)
(19)
).
Lyapunov exponents are calculated by averaging divergences
rates over all of the phase space or, equivalently, over all time.
We therefore take the time average of equation (19) and only
two terms survive:
(20)
(21)
(22)
(23)
∆rP(∆r)d∆r
−∞
(∆r)2P(∆r)d∆r
µ∆r2
D(∆θ )2 d∆r
1
(∆r)2e−
h∆θiZ ∞
t h∆θi = −β Dh∆θi2
−∞
2µ
−∞
d d
h ∆θi = −2r1βZ ∞
−βZ ∞
h ∆θi = −βr µ
h ∆θi =
πD
h ∆θi = −2r1βh∆ri− βh(∆r)2i.
We evaluate these average values using P(∆r):
This equation has a semi-stable fixed point at h∆θi = 0. In the
presence of noise, this point is unstable. Linearizing near the
11/13
Methods
Analytic Approximation of the Lyapunov Exponent
We use a similar approach to a previous Lyapunov exponent
approximation.22 Simulations show that the divergence of
neighboring trajectories occurs predominantly in the θ direc-
tion. In the noiseless case, the r direction is stable, while the θ
direction is only marginally stable. Therefore, we seek an ap-
proximation of the diverging perturbation in θ. We look for an
equation of the form dh∆θidt = λh∆θi, where λ is the Lyapunov
exponent. Making the change of variables z(t) = r(t)eiθ (t),
equation (1) becomes
dr
dt
= µr− αr3 + ηx(t)cosθ + ηy(t)sinθ
(7)
(ηy(t)cosθ − ηx(t)sinθ ),
(8)
1 r
= ω0 − β r2 +
dθ
dt
where a nonzero β yields nonisochronic dynamics.19 Now we
express these two differential equations in terms of a small
difference between two neighboring solutions (r1(t),θ1(t))
and (r2(t),θ2(t)). We define ∆r = r2 − r1 and ∆θ = θ2 − θ1.
Making this substitution yields
∆r = µ∆r− α((r1 + ∆r)3 − r3
1) + 2sin(
∆θ
2
)η1(t),
(9)
where we have defined new noise terms:
η1(t) = cos(
θ1 + θ2
2
)ηy(t)− sin(
θ1 + θ2
2
)ηx(t)
(10)
and
and
θ1 + θ2
η2(t) = cos(
θ1 + θ2
)ηx(t) + sin(
)ηy(t),
(11)
2
the
also
have
properties
2
hη1(t)η1(t0)i =
which
hη2(t)η2(t0)i = 2Dδ (t −t0) and hη1(t)η2(t0)i = 0.
Since the Lyapunov exponent is defined only in the limit
of infinitesimal devations, we let ∆r
<< 1, ∆r
<< 1, and
r1
r2
∆θ << 1. Keeping only the the first-order terms, equation (9)
becomes
∆r ≈ µ∆r− 3αr2
1∆r + ∆θη1(t).
(12)
start one of the two solutions at this radius, r1 = r0 =q µ
As the system spends the most time at the stable radius, we
α ,
and allow the second solution to be a perturbation from this
radius, r2 = r0 + ∆r. Making this substitution, equation (12)
simplifies further:
∆r ≈ −2µ∆r + ∆θη1(t).
(13)
Notice that the dynamics are stable to perturbations in r. How-
ever, as deviations in θ grow, so does the effective noise term,
∆θη1(t), and trajectories will tend to spread farther away
fixed point, we find that the solution diverges exponentially
with Lyapunov exponent,
λ = βD
µ .
(24)
Using numerical simulations, we verify the validity of this
approximation (see supplemental material, Fig. S1).
Transfer Entropy
The transfer entropy28 from process J to process I is defined
as
TJ→I = ∑ p(in+1,i(k)
n , j(l)
n )log
p(in+1 i(k)
n , j(l)
n )
p(in+1 i(k)
n )
,
(25)
n , j(l)
where i(k)
n = (in, ...,in−k+1) are the k most recent states of
process I. Therefore, p(in+1 i(k)
n ) is the conditional prob-
ability of finding process I in state in+1 at time n + 1, given
that the previous k states of process I were i(k)
n and given that
the previous l states of process J were j(l)
n . The summation is
performed over the length of the time series, as well as over
all accessible states of processes I and J. Given the history of
process I, the transfer entropy TJ→I is a measure of how much
one's ability to predict the future of process I is improved
when one gains knowledge of the history of process J. If
these processes are completely unrelated, then TJ→I = 0. We
discretize the recordings of hair bundle position into two bins,
a natural choice due to the bimodal distribution in position of
the hair bundle. Likewise, the bimodal burst noise stimulus
is characterized by two states. The choice of k and l has little
effect on our results, so we select k = l = 5.
Experimental Techniques
Biological Preparation
Experiments were performed in vitro on hair cells of the Amer-
ican bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana) sacculus, an organ responsi-
ble for low-frequency air-borne and ground-borne vibrations.
Sacculi were excised from the inner ear of the animal, and
mounted in a two-compartment chamber with artificial peri-
lymph and endolymph solutions.6 Hair bundles were accessed
after digestion and removal of the overlying otolithic mem-
brane.8 All protocols for animal care and euthanasia were
approved by the UCLA Chancellor's Animal Research Com-
mittee in accordance with federal and state regulations.
Mechanical Stimulus
To deliver a stimulus to the hair bundles, we used glass capil-
laries that had been melted and stretched with a micropipette
puller. These elastic probes were calibrated by observing their
Brownian motion with a high-speed camera and applying the
fluctuation dissipation theorem. Typical stiffness and drag
coefficients of these probes were 50 -- 150 µN/m and 100 --
200 nNs/m, respectively. These elastic probes were treated
with a charged polymer that improves adhesion to the hair
bundle. Innate oscillations persisted after the attachment of a
probe. The position of the probe base was controlled with a
piezoelectric actuator. Stimulus waveforms were delivered to
the actuator using LabVIEW.
Data Collection
Hair bundle motion was recorded with a high-speed camera
at framerates of 500 Hz or 1 kHz. The records were analyzed
in MATLAB, using a center-of-pixel-intensity technique to
determine the position of the center of the hair bundle in each
frame. Typical noise floors of this technique, combined with
stochastic fluctuations of bundle position in the fluid, were 3 --
5 nm.
Stimulus Waveforms
Experiments were carried out as follows. First, we obtained
a 60 second recording of the spontaneous oscillation, im-
mediately followed by sinusoidal stimuli applied at several
frequencies (20 stimulus cycles for each frequency). Then, the
hair bundle was stimulated with burst noise (random telegraph
noise), which was generated by randomly selecting time inter-
vals between rising and falling flanks of the square wave. The
intervals were selected such that the frequencies of the square
waves ranged from 3 to 50 Hz, all with equal probability. This
distribution spans the full frequency range of typical spon-
taneously oscillating hair bundles in the American Bullfrog
sacculus7 and is comparable to the 4-octave range of stimu-
lus in our simulations. The wide range and flat probability
distribution ensured that a change in sensitivity could not be
due to a simple shift in the natural frequency of spontaneous
oscillations. This stimulus lasted 20 seconds and included
300-400 full square waves. After this initial recording, the
experimental parameters (calcium concentration and viscosity
of the endolymph) were varied, and identical stimulus proto-
cols were delivered again. Recordings were obtained under
several different variations of calcium concentration and/or
viscosity, so as to elicit different degrees of chaos from the
same hair cell.
Data Analysis
The Kolmogorov entropy was calculated from the 60 second
recording segment with no stimulus. We scaled these mea-
surements to the time scale of each recording, τ, which was
taken to be the time for the autocorrelation function of the
spontaneous oscillations to cross zero. This ensured that a
change in K-entropy was indeed a change in the predictability
of the system and not simply a shift in the natural frequency.
A consequence of this scaling was that it rendered the noise
floor on K-entropy (∼ 0.5 bits/τ) large with respect to the
measurements (0.5− 1.3 bits/τ).
The response to sinusoidal stimulus and the spontaneous
oscillations were used to calculate the gain. The response to
the burst noise was used to calculate the transfer entropy, the
mean displacement, and the response time, using the same
techniques as described in the Theoretical Results.
12/13
Bootstrap data sets were generated by adding fluctuations
to the original data set based on the uncertainty in measur-
ing hair bundle position. The position measurement uncer-
tainty was quantified by recording a stationary object with
the high-speed camera. To generate a bootstrap data set, each
measurement of position in the original data set was given a
random perturbation of magnitude based on the statistics of
the fluctuations in position of the stationary object.
13/13
Supplemental Material for: Chaotic Dynamics Enhance the Sensitivity of Inner Ear
Hair Cells
1Department of Physics & Astronomy and 2California NanoSystems Institute,
Justin Faber1 and Dolores Bozovic1,2
University of California, Los Angeles, California 90095, USA
(Dated: May 23, 2019)
FIG. S1. Comparison of the analytic calculation of the Lyapunov exponent (red line) to the numerical calculation (black
points). (a) The noise strength is varied, while all other parameters are fixed (µ = α = Ω0 = 1, β = 50). (b) β is varied, while
all other parameters are fixed (µ = α = Ω0 = 1, D = 0.05)
arXiv:1812.05156v2 [q-bio.NC] 21 May 2019
2
FIG. S2. Phase-locked amplitude gain for above-resonance (ωstim = 1.05Ω0), sinusoidal stimulus as the noise strength and
Lyapunov exponent are varied. Color was generated by linearly interpolating a grid of 10 Lyapunov exponent values and 10
noise strengths.
FIG. S3. (a) Phase-locked amplitude gain for on-resonance, sinusoidal stimulus as the noise strength and Lyapunov exponent
are varied. Color was generated by linearly interpolating a grid of 10 Lyapunov exponent values and 10 noise strengths. (b)
Transfer entropy from burst noise stimulus to response of the Hopf oscillator as noise strength and Lyapunov exponent are
varied. In the λ < 0 regime, the system is quiescent, and the Lyapunov exponent characterizes the stability of this fixed point.
Color was generated by linearly interpolating a grid of 10 Lyapunov exponent values and 10 noise strengths. For both panels,
the Lyapunov exponent was modulated by varying µ.
3
FIG. S4. The dependence of Kolmogorov entropy on the endolymph calcium concentration. Each of the six colors corresponds
to a different cell.
4
FIG. S5. Phase-locked amplitude gain for 2 pN sinusoidal stimulus at the natural frequency (a-c) and above the natural
frequency (d-f ) for three additional cells. Data points and error bars on the gain represent the mean and standard deviation
from 100 bootstraps. The noise floor (dashed curve) was calculated by treating a segment of the spontaneous oscillation
recording as if a stimulus were present and calculating the gain. This curve represents the mean plus one standard deviation
from 100 bootstraps. (g-i) Transfer entropy from burst noise stimulus to response. Data points and error bars represent the
mean and standard deviation obtained from 100 bootstraps. The noise floor (dashed curve) was determined by calculating the
transfer entropy in the reverse direction (response to stimulus). This curve represents the mean plus one standard deviation
from 100 bootstraps.
5
FIG. S6. (a-c) Average displacement induced on the hair bundle from the step stimulus, averaged over ∼ 200 square waves.
Data points and error bars represent the mean and standard deviation of the response plateau. (d-f ) Response time to step
stimulus, characterized by fitting the mean response to an exponential and taking the decay time. Error bars represent the
standard deviation of the residual associated with the exponential fit. (g-i) Response times from (d-f) scaled to the natural
periods of oscillation for each recording. For all panels, open-dashed and closed-solid data points represent averages over steps
in the positive (channel open) and negative (channel closed) directions, respectively.
|
1907.10009 | 1 | 1907 | 2019-07-23T17:07:50 | Temporal connection signatures of human brain networks after stroke | [
"q-bio.NC",
"q-bio.QM",
"stat.AP"
] | Plasticity after stroke is a complex phenomenon initiated by the functional reorganization of the brain, especially in the perilesional tissue. At macroscales, the reestablishment of segregation within the affected hemisphere and interhemispheric integration has been extensively documented in the reconfiguration of brain networks. However, the local connection mechanisms generating such global network changes are still largely unknown as well as their potential to better predict the outcome of patients. To address this question, time must be considered as a formal variable of the problem and not just a simple repeated observation. Here, we hypothesize that the temporal formation of basic connection blocks such as intermodule edges and intramodule triangles would be sufficient to determine the large-scale brain reorganization after stroke. To test our hypothesis, we adopted a statistical approach based on temporal exponential random graph models (tERGMs). First, we validated the overall performance on synthetic time-varying networks simulating the reconfiguration process after stroke. Then, using longitudinal functional connectivity measurements of resting-state brain activity, we showed that both the formation of triangles within the affected hemisphere and interhemispheric links are sufficient to reproduce the longitudinal brain network changes from 2 weeks to 1 year after the stroke. Finally, we showed that these temporal connection mechanisms are over-expressed in the subacute phase as compared to healthy controls and predicted the chronic language and visual outcome respectively in patients with subcortical and cortical lesions, whereas static approaches failed to do so. Our results indicate the importance of considering time-varying connection properties when modeling dynamic complex systems and provide fresh insights into the network mechanisms of stroke recovery. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Temporal connection signatures of human brain
networks after stroke
Catalina Obando1,2,*, Charlotte Rosso2,3,4, Joshua Siegel5, Maurizio Corbetta6,7
Fabrizio De Vico Fallani1,2,*
1 Inria Paris, Aramis Project Team, Paris, France
2 Institut du Cerveau et de la Moelle epiniere, ICM, Inserm U 1127, CNRS UMR 7225,
Sorbonne Universite, Paris, France
3 AP-HP, Urgences Cerebro-Vasculaires, Hopital Pitie-Salpetriere, Paris, France
4 ICM Infrastructure Stroke Network, STAR team, Hopital Pitie-Salpetriere, Paris,
France
5 Department of Psychiatry, Wasingthon University, St Louis, US
6 Department of Neuroscience and Padova Neuroscience Center, University of Padova,
Italy
7 Department of Neurology, Wasingthon University School of Medicine, St Louis, US
* corresponing authors: [email protected] ; [email protected]
Abstract
Plasticity after stroke is a complex phenomenon initiated by the functional reorganization of the
brain, especially in the perilesional tissue. At macroscales, the reestablishment of segregation
within the affected hemisphere and interhemispheric integration has been extensively documented
in the reconfiguration of brain networks and proved to be a potential biomarker of functional
recovery. However, the local connection mechanisms generating such global network changes
are still largely unknown as well as their potential to better predict the outcome of patients.
To address this question, time must be considered as a formal variable of the problem and not
just a simple repeated observation. Here, we hypothesize that the temporal formation of basic
connection blocks such as intermodule links -or edges- and intramodule connected triads -or
triangles- would be sufficient to determine the large-scale brain reorganization after stroke.
To test our hypothesis, we adopted a statistical approach based on temporal exponential
random graph models (tERGMs). First, we validated the overall performance on synthetic time-
varying networks simulating the reconfiguration process after stroke. Then, using longitudinal
functional connectivity measurements of resting-state brain activity, we showed that both the
formation of triangles within the affected hemisphere and interhemispheric links are sufficient
to reproduce the longitudinal brain network changes from 2 weeks to 1 year after the stroke.
Finally, we showed that these temporal connection mechanisms are over-expressed in the
subacute phase as compared to healthy controls and predicted the chronic language and visual
outcome respectively in patients with subcortical and cortical lesions, whereas static approaches
failed to do so. Our results indicate the importance of considering time-varying connection
properties when modeling dynamic complex systems and provide fresh insights into the network
mechanisms of stroke recovery.
July 24, 2019
1/18
Introduction
The brain is a networked system whose parts dynamically interact over multiple temporal
and spatial scales. Such network properties are at the basis of neuroplasticity allowing
for the acquisition of new skills (e.g., learning) as well as for the functional recovery after
brain injuries (e.g., stroke). When locally damaged, the brain tends to spontaneously
adapt by recruiting new resources through the network to compensate for the loss of the
neuronal tissue and recover the associated motor or cognitive functions. At micro/meso
spatial scales, dendritic remodeling, axonal sprouting, and synapse formation have been
best demonstrated in the peri-lesional tissue of animal models during the first weeks after
stroke [1 -- 3]. At larger macro scales, it has been shown that post-stroke plasticity also
involves regions outside the peri-infarct cortex - including the contralesional hemisphere
- and that the associated brain activity and connectivity changes can last several months
in an effort to return to a normal condition [4 -- 9].
Recovery after stroke is a temporally dynamic network phenomenon, but only recent
longitudinal studies have allowed to demonstrate a direct association between changes
in brain functional connectivity (FC) networks and spontaneous recovery in humans [10].
Both increased interhemispheric homotopic integration and intrahemispheric segregation
appear to be fundamental principles for recovery of associative/higher cognitive functions
(e.g. attention, language), as quantified by the return to a normal modular organiza-
tion [11]. Indeed, the role of time in complex networks has been recently revised as a
fundamental variable to model and analyze real-world connection phenomena [12, 13].
By introducing time, new higher-order properties emerge that cannot be captured by
static network, or graph, approaches. In a temporal network two disconnected nodes
can, for example, still interact if there exists a time-ordered sequence of links connecting
their neighbors [12, 13]. This way of rethinking networks naturally extend standard
topological properties with purely temporal concepts such as latency, persistence, or
formation of connectivity patterns or motifs.
Interestingly, the inherent ability of
temporal-topological graph metrics to characterize dynamic brain networks, as well as to
predict future behavior, have been increasingly demonstrated in the context of human
neuroscience [14 -- 19].
To date, however, the existence of dynamic brain network signatures in stroke and
their ability to predict functional outcome in individual patients has not been proved
directly. Based on these theoretical and empirical grounds, we hypothesized that temporal
connection mechanisms constitute fundamental building blocks of the recovery process
after stroke. More specifically, we expected that the formation of interhemispheric links
and intrahemispheric clustering connections, and not just their static appearance, would
characterize the crucial phases of brain reorganization after stroke. Furthermore, we
hypothesized that these temporal connection signatures in the subacute phase would
allow to predict the future behavior of patients in the chronic phase.
To test this hypothesis, we considered longitudinal brain networks derived from
resting-state fMRI BOLD activity recorded in a group of patients at 2 weeks, 3 months
and 1 year after their first-ever unilateral stroke. Neurological impairments were described
using multidomain behavioral measurements at each visit. We evaluated the significance
of the hypothesized temporal connection mechanisms through a rigorous statistical
network approach based on temporal exponential random graph models (tERGMs).
We compared our results with respect to a group of demographically-matched healthy
subjects and we tested their ability to predict the future outcome of stroke patients. See
Material and Methods for more details on the experimental design and methods of
analysis.
July 24, 2019
2/18
Results
A statistical model of temporal networks
It has been theoretically hypothesized and recently empirically observed that recovery
after stroke is accompanied by the emergence of FC patterns supporting interhemispheric
integration and intrahemispheric segregation (Fig 1A). To quantify these dynamic
network properties we introduced two temporal graph metrics which account respectively
for the formation of edges between hemispheres (E) and triangles -i.e., interconnected
triads- within hemispheres (T ) (Material and methods). Both E and T quantify
connection patterns through time that cannot be derived by looking within single time
steps (Fig 1B). Without loss of generality, time steps corresponded here to different
longitudinal visits, or sessions.
Fig 1. Dynamic network hypothesis of brain reorganization after stroke A) Graphical
representation of the known resting-state functional connectivity (FC) changes occurring after
stroke. Brain networks tend to restablish functional segregation within the affected hemisphere
(orange) as well as functional intergation with the homotopic areas in the unaffected hemisphere
(blue) [11]. B) Temporal graph metrics to quantify the hypothesized local mechanisms underlying
the global network FC changes, i.e.
formation of interhemispheric links (temporal edge E)
and clustering connections within the affected hemisphere (temporal triangle T ). Both E
and T quantify connection patterns taking place across consecutive time steps. Hence, the
closure of a triangle from time t − 1 to t, does not necessarily imply the existence of a complete
interconnected triad as illustrated by the dashed edges in T .
To validate the relevance of these metrics we first generated synthetic dynamic graphs
that reproduce the known topological changes observed in resting state brain networks
after stroke [5, 11]. The model consisted of a network of two modules - representing the
hemispheres - that were initially not interconnected and randomly initiated with a fixed
connection density. This condition ideally reproduce the effects of stroke with complete
destruction of between-hemisphere integration and within-hemisphere segregation. To
simulate the reorganization process underlying recovery, a fraction of links was randomly
rewired in each subsequent time step to form inter-module edges (E) and intra-module
triangles (T ) (Fig 2A). To simulate realistic time dependencies [12, 13], we applied the
rewiring rule in a way that each network at time t could be obtained by the network at
time t − 1 (Materials and methods).
By construction, the cumulative occurrence of temporal edges E and triangles T
in the synthetic networks increased over time (Fig 2B). To evaluate the extent to
July 24, 2019
3/18
which these connection mechanisms were also sufficient for statistically reproducing
the observed networks we adopted a general framework based on temporal exponential
graph models (tERGM) [20]. The probability of observing the entire series of networks
was here controlled by two main parameters, θE and θT , which weighted the relative
contribution of E and T . Because tERGMs are in practice fitted through numerical
approximations, we also introduced two secondary parameters to ensure the convergence
to an optimal solution, namely the connection density and stability (Material and
methods).
Results showed a high goodness-of-fit in terms of link prediction capacity (cid:104)AU P(cid:105) =
0.8(0.02) and (cid:104)AU R(cid:105) = 0.88(0.01) (Fig 2C), which we did not obtain when using static
graph metrics merely counting the appearance of edges and triangles (cid:104)AU P(cid:105) = 0.22(0.01)
and (cid:104)AU R(cid:105) = 0.59(0.05). Global dynamic network changes were determined by the
local formation of temporal edges and triangles as indicated by the positive values of
the corresponding parameters meaning that they occur more often than expected by
chance (θT = 0.13, θE = 0.16). Furthermore, we showed that the networks sampled with
the fitted tERGM also captured the global integration and segregation changes, here
quantified by a decreasing network modularity Q [21], which were not directly included
in the model but indirectly resulting from the simulated process. Instead, the use of
static metrics which simply account for the presence of edges and triangles in each time
step failed to retrieve the actual trend (Fig 2D, Supp. text) .
Fig 2. Validation of temporal exponential graph models (tERGMs) on synthetic
networks. A) Sequence of connectivity matrices representing a time-varying synthetic network.
Unweighted and undirected networks are generated by a model that reproduces the large-
scale reconfiguration changes after stroke. Interhemispheric integration and within-hemisphere
segregation are obtained by allowing the formation of temporal edges E between blocks and
temporal triangles T within blocks. Blocks (i.e.
red squares) represent the hemispheres
(Material and methods). B) Cumulative counts of E and T between consecutive time steps
for the synthetic temporal network. C) Prediction performance: area under the curve for the
receiver operating characteristic (AUR, red curve) and precision recall (AUP, blue curve) of
the out-of-sample link prediction in the networks simulated by the tERGM. Different curves
correspond to different time steps. D) Validation: modularity Q values for i) the actual
time-varying synthetic network (black line), ii) the ones simulated by the tERGM (green line),
and iii) those simulated by a static version of the tERGM where the graph metrics were only
accounting for the presence - not the formation - of edges and triangles (gray line) (Material
and methods)
July 24, 2019
4/18
Dynamic connection mechanisms after stroke
We next considered longitudinal brain networks underlying functional recovery in uni-
lateral stroke patients (Material and methods). Brain networks were obtained by
computing functional connectivity between fMRI activity of different regions of interest
(ROIs) (Fig 3A) [22]. Damaged ROIs and the corresponding connections were excluded
by the network analysis (Materials and methods). Stroke lesions involved both
subcortical and cortical ROIs, with cortical lesions mainly covering cingulo-opercular,
auditory, ventral-attention and default mode network systems (Fig 3B). While the
number of occurrences was slightly higher for the left hemisphere, the average size of the
lesion was larger for the right hemisphere, i.e. 5, 6 cm3 versus 4, 7 cm3 (File S1).
Previous analysis demonstrated a progressive restoration of modularity in the large-
scale functional brain network after stroke that was associated with good recovery (Fig
3C,D) [11]. These network changes were more evident in the sub-acute phases (from
2 weeks to 3 months), but, critically, they were obtained separately in each session
thus ignoring the time-ordered nature of the reorganization process. Here, we used
tERGMs to statistically identify the temporal reconfiguration mechanisms after stroke
and evaluate their ability to predict the future behavioral outcome of patients. In this
experimental setting, the temporal graph metrics E and T now quantify respectively
homotopic integration between the hemispheres and segregation within the lesioned
hemisphere. To increase the specificity of our approach, we restricted the analysis to
the subnetwork corresponding to the affected system for patients with cortical lesions
(n = 23), while we considered the whole hemisphere as affected for subcortical-lesioned
patients (n = 26) (Materials and methods).
After fitting a tERGM to each patient, we found a general high goodness-of-fit
regardless of the observation window (i.e. 3 months or 1 year) and location of the lesion
(i.e. subcortical/cortical)(Tab S1). Sometimes, the parameter coefficients were not
assigned because the respective counts were not sufficiently represented in the network.
This mainly occurred for the θT coefficients of cortical-lesioned patients, whose network
were relatively small (Materials and methods). These situations were excluded from
any subsequent analysis. We then focused on the subacute phase (from 2 weeks to 3
months), where most changes were previously observed [11]. The main parameter values
θE and θT were in average positive indicating that both the formation of interhemispheric
connections and triangles within the lesioned hemisphere are peculiar mechanisms of
brain network reconfiguration after stroke (File S2). We validated this result in the
subcortical-lesioned group by showing that both θE and θT values were significantly
higher compared to those obtained in a group of demographically-matched healthy
controls (Wilcoxon test p < 0.01, Fig 4A, File S1).
A similar group comparison could not be performed for cortical-lesioned patients
because tERGMs were fitted to the subnetwork affected by the lesion, and there was a high
variability in the lesion locations and size across patients (Material and methods).
Nevertheless, such variability allowed us to elucidate the relationship between the
observed dynamic network mechanisms and the cortical system that was affected. Results
showed that different systems were not responding in the same way to the lesion and that
primary cortical areas reacted with a higher formation of temporal edges and triangles.
Specifically, we found higher θE values when the stroke involved visual and sensorimotor
systems (Fig 4B). θT values were higher in visual and default-mode systems prevalently
in the right hemisphere, whose damages were in average larger compared to the left
hemisphere. However, we reported no significant relationships between the size of the
lesion and the tERGM coefficients.
Taken together, these findings unveil the specific local connection mechanisms giving
July 24, 2019
5/18
Fig 3. Longitudinal brain networks and behavior after stroke. A) Cortical parcel-
lation used to define the nodes (i.e. ROIs) of brain networks [22]. Different colors highlight
the belonging to different functional systems. B) Spatial position of the ROIs affected by the
stroke and their occurrences in the cortical-lesioned subgroup of patients (n = 23). 55, 82%
of the damages are in the left hemisphere; 44, 18% are in the right hemisphere. The average
size of the lesion is however larger for the right hemisphere (5, 6 cm3 versus 4, 7 cm3). C)
Dynamic brain network of a stroke patient over time. Nodes are spatially arranged according to
a spring layout. Network are filtered and binarized to retain the 10% of the links with strongest
functional connectivity (FC) values. D) Longitudinal multidomain behavioral scores for the
stroke population including both cortical- and subcortical-lesioned patients. Only patients with
score in every visit are reported here (n = 23). Values are Z-normalized with respect to a
demographically-matched control group (n = 21). Bars show the group-averaged values and
whiskers indicate standard error means (SEM). Behavior is significantly recovering in all domains
but visual and regardless of the damage location, i.e. cortical/subcortical (Repeated-measures
ANOVAs, p < 0.05, File S3).
rise to global network segregation within the lesioned hemisphere and interhemispheric
homotopic integration after stroke.
Prediction of future outcome
Given the dynamic nature of brain connectivity after stroke, we finally asked whether
such temporal network properties could predict the future outcome of patients. To do
so, we correlated the values of the tERGM parameters fitted over the dynamic brain
networks in the subacute phase with the multi-domain behavioral scores gathered in
the chronic phase (1 year) (Materials and methods). Due to patient dropouts, some
behavioral scores were missing. For the correlations analysis we only considered patients
with all scores in all the visits (Fig 3D).
For subcortical lesions (n = 14), we found that both the formation of interhemispheric
temporal edges (θE) and intrahemispheric temporal triangles (θT ) significantly predicted
the future language score (Spearman correlation R > 0.62, p < 0.02, Fig 4C). This
tendency was also confirmed in patients with stronger deficit (n = 13), i.e. when the
July 24, 2019
6/18
behavioral score at 2 weeks was at least one SD below the mean of the healthy group
(R = 0.74, p = 0.005 for θE; R = 0.64, p = 0.021 for θT ). For cortical lesions (n = 9),
we only reported a significant correlation between θE values and the visual score in the
chronic phase (R = 0.73, p = 0.031), which however we could not assess for the few
patients with greater impairment (n = 3). No other significant predictions were found
for the other behavioral scores (Tab S2).
In a separate analysis, we verified that these predictions could be obtained neither
when we calculated the temporal graph metrics outside the tERGMs nor when we
considered equivalent static graph metrics for E and T , by neglecting the past networks
(Supp. text). Notably, language and visual outcomes after 1 year were not predicted
by the precedent values at 2 weeks or by the relative difference between 3 months and
2 weeks. In addition, no significant correlations were reported when we considered
the lesion size as predictor. Only the age factor exhibited a weak correlation with the
future visual outcome in cortical-lesioned patients (R = 0.56, p = 0.04), but it was not a
significant predictor for the language outcome in the subcortical-lesioned group.
These results indicate that the statistical occurrence of temporal connection mech-
anisms reflecting within-hemisphere segregation and interhemispheric homotopic inte-
gration after unilateral stroke, might be also crucial for the prediction of functional
recovery.
Fig 4. Temporal connection mechanisms after stroke and prediction of outcome A)
Statistical comparison between the main tERGM coefficients of subcortical lesioned patients
(red shape) and healthy controls (white shape). Violin plots show the distribution of the
values, while innze box-plots denote median and quartiles. Significant increases in the stroke
group are reported for both temporal formation of interhemispheric edges (θE, Wilcoxon test
t = 4.75, p = 0.002) and within-hemisphere triangles (θT , Wilcoxon test t = 3.59, p = 0.002).
B) Cortical maps of the main tERGM coefficients for the cortical-lesioned group of patients.
Colors denote the average of the parameter values (violet for θE, green for θT ) for the ROIs
within the affected functional systems. C) Correlation plots of the tERGM coefficients and
future outcome in the subcortical-lesioned group. Both temporal edges and triangles in the
subacute phase (from 2 weeks to 3 months) significantly predict the global language score in
the chronic phase (1 year) normalized to the control group (Spearman correlation R = 0.62,
p = 0.0186 for θE; R = 0.69, p = 0.006 for θT ).
July 24, 2019
7/18
Discussion
Modeling dynamic networks
Many natural and social interconnected systems are characterized by time-varying
interactions so that the network's structure changes over time. Such temporality has
been shown to affect many dynamical processes on the network such as slowing down
synchronization and diffusion of information [23], impeding exploration and accessibility
[24, 25], as well as favoring system control [12].
More pertinent to this paper, recent evidence suggests that brain functional connec-
tivity is inherently dynamic and exhibits relatively fast fluctuations that support normal
cognitive abilities [26, 27] as well as slower changes associated to neurodegenerative dis-
eases [28] or recovery after brain injuries [29]. Despite the ubiquity of temporality, brain
connectivity networks have been mostly studied with cross-sectional experiments and
static graph approaches. Furthermore, the statistical relevance of the extracted network
properties remain largely unknown and group-level analysis is typically used to determine
the confidence intervals, thus leading to a critical loss of individual specificity [30].
To address these limitations we adopted a model-based statistical framework to
test the significance of specific local connection rules to generate an observed sequence
of temporal networks. We showed that the temporal formation of local clustering
connections and long-range edges, i.e. basic components of segregation and integration
of information [31 -- 33], are sufficient to statistically reproduce longitudinally dynamic
brain networks in single stroke patients and reproduce the main global changes.
Brain plasticity and stroke
Although stroke represents a focal damage, it is well known that consequences involve
areas that are also outside the perilesional tissue [1, 4, 34]. Efforts to characterize brain
network reorganization after stroke has focused almost exclusively on the static repre-
sentation of underlying connectivity patterns [35]. However, both scientific intuition and
recent evidence suggest that temporal network properties might also contain important
information about the mechanisms of brain plasticity [14].
Our exploration of temporal network properties provides new insights into the
brain organizational principles after unilateral stroke. We found that the formation
of clustering connections within the affected hemisphere and of functional interactions
with the contralesional hemisphere, constitute fundamental building blocks of cortical
plasticity during the initial phases after stroke. Biologically, these local connection
processes can be seen as precursors of the large-scale within-hemisphere segregation
and between-hemisphere integration, which have been hypothesized to underlie stroke
recovery [5] and are in line with recent evidence showing a progressive return to a normal
modular organization [11].
Specifically, both temporal triangles and edges were evident in the visual system, with
temporal edges being also pronounced in the sensorimotor system. These primary systems
are known to be more densely connected as compared to other secondary ones [36 -- 38],
with many anatomical fibers crossing the hemispheres for the integration of lower-level
visuomotor functions [39]. Vulnerability and modeling analyses indicate that attacking
such systems will indeed have relatively little effect in terms of widespread connectivity
disruption as compared, for example, to midline and fronto-temporal cortices [40, 41].
This higher structural redundancy would therefore represent a potential reserve of the
primary cortical systems to functionally react and reorganize after stroke [42]. In parallel,
we showed that the higher values of temporal edges and triangles observed in the right
hemisphere might not only reflect the lesion size. Patients with right lesions often suffer
from severe attention disorders [43] which cause poorer outcome overall [44, 45], as well
July 24, 2019
8/18
as stronger cognitive deficits including language [46]. It is possible that the higher
propensity of the right hemisphere to reorganize would therefore reflect attentional
increases that are known to globally support recovery. Further studies will be crucial to
elucidate how these temporal connection mechanisms are affected by the lesion side and
by the intrinsic FC lateralization [47, 48].
Forecasting behavior and recovery
Forecasting behavior is paramount in many real-life situations. In clinical neuroscience,
a correct prognosis can have concrete impact on the life of people allowing to identify
appropriate therapeutics to slow down the progression of disease or promote effective
recovery. Our results show that the intrinsic temporal brain network signatures in the
subacute phase after unilateral stroke (from 2 weeks to 3 months) can predict the future
outcome of patients in the chronic phase (1 year), whereas static approaches failed to do
so.
In the case of subcortical lesions, where the entire hemisphere is concerned, both
the temporal formation of interhemispheric links and clustering connections within the
affected hemisphere were associated with a better language recovery. These results are
in line with previous evidence showing that large-scale functional connectivity changes
correlate with cognitive and integrative functions, whereas structural changes such as
the lesion location better predict motor deficits [5, 11]. Language disorders can indeed
arise not only from the disruption of language processing, but also from the deterioration
of distributed support functions including auditory processing, visual attention as in
reading, and motor planning for speech [49].
As for cortical lesions, where specific systems are attacked, the formation of new
connections between the perilesional tissue and the homotopic area in the unaffected
hemisphere was found to be predictive of the future visual outcome. While it has been
demonstrated that lesions to the visuomotor system mainly affect the corresponding
functions [40], the visual pathway involve several remote regions including frontal,
temporal, and parietal lobes [50]. Hence, deficits to visual fields can be also given by
damages of other areas controlling for example the eye movement or interpreting what
we see. This evidence would support the oberved predicition in spite of the heterogenity
of the cortical systems that are damaged.
In conclusion, our results highlight the importance of the formation of specific
connection mechanisms in the initial phases after stroke. Further research will be crucial
to elucidate the intermingled relationship between the damaged brain systems and the
affected functions.
Limitations/perspectives
The studied dynamic brain networks consisted of three time points - two for the subacute
phase and one for the chronic phase - allowing to have a partial sampling of the
reorganizational mechanisms taking place after stroke. From a methodological perspective
tERGMs can fit short network time series and do not make any assumptions as to whether
the time that passes between time steps is long or short [51]. Nevertheless, a denser follow-
up would have provided more detailed dynamics on the brain network reconfiguration
after stroke, but this remains difficult because of the scarce availability of patients to
be recruited frequently over long periods. This is the reason why the large parts of the
studies are cross-sectional or only consider two time points [35,52]. Although the dataset
used here is one of the most complete currently available, longitudinal studies with more
frequent visits will be important to assess dynamic neural mechanisms after stroke at a
finer temporal resolution.
July 24, 2019
9/18
The temporal graph metrics implemented in our tERGMs were designed to capture
monotonic network changes over time, such as the formation of specific connectivity
motifs. This means that in general, these models cannot capture inverse trends - e.g.
pattern dissolution - or more complex dynamics. While this is not a major issue in the
case of neural recovery and neurodegeneration, the study of functional brain networks at
shorter time scales might need more sophisticated approaches to also model connectivity
fluctuations. More research is needed in this direction and possible solutions may come
from the development of ERGMs with time-varying parameters [53] and stochastic
actor-oriented models [54].
The cohort of stroke patients was heterogeneous in terms of stroke lesion type and
location. Because patients suffered from unilateral lesions - except for brainstem damages
- we only considered the corresponding cortical hemisphere as the affected one. However,
unilateral lesions of subcortical structures including white matter and cerebellum, might
result in a more complex pattern which partly involving both cortical hemispheres [4].
In a supplemental analysis, we showed that considering both the hemispheres as affected
significantly decreases the predictive power of the temporal triangle θT coefficients
(Tab S3). These findings confirmed that the formation of clustering connections after
unilateral lesions to white matter or cerebellum were actually taking place within the
corresponding affected hemisphere in the cortex.
Finally, head motion and hemodynamic lags can both alter resting-state fMRI FC
[55,56] and impact FC-behavior relationships [57]. While both motion and hemodynamic
lags are areas of ongoing methods development, the data used in this study have
been carefully censored and cleaned following state-of-the art procedures, including
head motion and frame-to-frame fMRI signal intensity change thresholds, tissue-based
timecourse regression and excluding subjects showing severe hemodynamic disruption
(hemodynamic lag > 1 s) (more details in [58]).
Conclusion
Consistent with our hypothesis, we have identified two significant temporal network
signatures that characterize dynamic brain networks after stroke. The formation of both
clustering connections within the perilesional tissue and interhemispheric interactions
with the homotopic regions are significantly abundant in stroke patients as compared
to healthy controls. These temporal signatures, which are respectively related to
intrahemispheric segregation and interhemispheric integration, varied over individuals
during the subacute phases of stroke and were specific predictors of language outcome
in the chronic phase. Furthermore, we reported a general framework for the statistical
validation of hypothesized connection rules in time-varying complex networks. Taken
together, our results offer new insights into the crucial role of temporal connection
mechanisms in the prediction of the system performance.
Material and Methods
Temporal exponential random graph models (tERGMs)
To evaluate the relevance of the hypothesized local connection mechanisms in generating
the observed time-varying networks, we adopted a statistical framework based on
temporal exponential random graph models (tERGM) [20].
Let A0, ..., AT be a time-ordered series of graphs with N fixed nodes that represents
a temporally dynamic network. By assuming one-step time dependencies, the probability
of observing the entire sequence of graphs can be then written as
July 24, 2019
10/18
.
P (A1, A2, ..., ATA0) =
T(cid:89)
t=1
P (AtAt−1)
The transition probability P (AtAt−1) has the following exponential form
P (AtAt−1, θ) =
exp(θ
(cid:48)
g(At, At−1))
Z(θ)
(1)
(2)
where θ is the vector of r model parameters which weight the different graph metrics
(or statistics) g = [g1, g2, ..., gr], and Z is a normalizing constant estimated over the
space of all the graphs of size N .
To incorporate temporal dependencies between time steps graph metrics can incorpo-
rate memory terms as a function of consecutive graphs. Here, we define the temporal
formation of edges between components (E) and the formation of triangles within
modules (T ) as
(cid:88)
E =
(cid:88)
T =
(1 − At−1
ij )At
ij(1 − δij)
ij
At−1
ik At−1
kj (1 − At−1
ij )At
ijδikδkjδij
(3)
(4)
ijk
where δij = 1 if node i and j belong to the same component or module. In brain
networks, components correspond to the cortical hemispheres so that E quantifies the
formation of interhemispheric interactions and T the formation of within-hemisphere
clustering connections (Fig. 1B).
Because the parameter values cannot be obtained analytically, due to the compu-
tational intractability of the normalizing constant Z, numerical approximations are
typically employed. Here, we used Markov-chain MonteCarlo maximum likelihood esti-
mates (MCMCMLE) which is relatively fast and robust for short network sequences as
compared to maximum pseudolikelihood estimates (MPLE) [51].
stability S =(cid:80)
To ensure the convergence to a meaningful solution, we introduced two secondary
parameters in the tERGM, namely the instantaneous connection density L and the
ij ), which measures the number of persisting
dyads (tied or not) between two consecutive time points. These metrics have been shown
to help avoiding combinations of parameter values leading to degenerate simulations (i.e.
full or empty graphs) [51].
ij +(1−At
ij)(1−At−1
ijAt−1
ij At
Hence, the transition probability that we used in Eq. 1 to fit our data reads as
P (AtAt−1, θ) =
exp(θLL + θEE + θT T + θSS
Z(θ)
(5)
The estimated parameter coefficients can be interpreted as the (log-odds) likelihood
of establishing an edge given the rest of the network and up to previous ones [51]. θ
values can be negative or positive, with higher values indicating that the connection
mechanism measured by the graph metric occurs in the network transition more often
than we would expect by chance alone.
To evaluate the adequacy of the fit, we compared the actual network sequence with
the ones generated by the tERMG drawing new samples from the probability function
P . Here, we generated 100 simulated network sequences. First, we assessed the extent
to which the links in the temporal network are predicted accurately by the generated
simulations in each time step. We measured the prediction performance by using receiver
operating characteristic and precision-recall curves and by computing the respective area
under the curve AUP and AUR [51]. Then, we validated the goodness of fit by comparing
July 24, 2019
11/18
the simulated values of graph quantities that were not explicitly included in the tERGM
to their observed counterparts [20, 59, 60]. Here, we used the modularity index Q as
defined in [21], which intuitively captures both the integration and segregation properties
of a network.
Network model of brain reorganization after stroke
We tested our tERGM on a series of time-varying networks generated by a dynamic
toy-model where we could control for the formation of temporal edges and triangles over
time. The initial network A0 consists of a graph with two disconnected modules (i.e.
the hemispheres) having the same size N and density L. This condition would represent
the extreme limit for the acute effects of a stroke, i.e. low intrahemispheric segregation
and low interhemispheric integration.
To simulate the reestablishment to a normal condition, we imposed the formation
of inter-module edges and intra-module triangles as time elapses. For each time-step
t = 1, 2, ..., τ each link of the previous network At−1 will be selected with a probability q
and rewired to form either an inter-module edge or an intra-module triangle.
Specifically, for each selected link
if random(0, 1) < p
(a) reassign it between two random nodes (i, j) belonging to different modules for
which Aij = 0
else
(b) reassign it between two random nodes (i, j) in the same module for which Aik =
Akj = 1 and Aij = 0
When p = 1, only inter-module connections are formed over time, while when p = 0
only intra-module triangles are formed and the modules are kept disconnected. Because
the links can be rewired multiple times depending on the random selection, we could
generate arbitrary long network sequences. Without loss of generality, we considered
here undirected and unweighted modules with N = 50, L = 0.2, τ = 5, q = 0.2, and
p = 0.5 as model parameters. Note that the size of the entire network is 2 × N = 100
and its density is 0.0495 (∼ L/2 for large N ), which are comparable to the values of the
actual brain networks.
Experimental protocol and data acquisition
The experimental data were taken after permission from a longitudinal cohort of stroke
patients and healthy subjects used in a recently published study [5, 11]. We remind to
those papers for all details related to data acquisition and processing, ethical issues,
clinical and demographic information. For the purposes of this work, we considered a
group of 49 first time human stroke patients with clinical evidence of motor, language,
attention, visual, or memory deficits based on neurological examination and a group of
demographically matched healthy controls (n = 21). Lesions were unilateral (26/49 in
the left hemisphere), 23 of them occurring at the level of the cortex (Fig. 3B) and 26
at subcortical level including cerebellum, white matter and brainstem (File S1).
All subjects were recruited and underwent the same neuroimaging and behavioral
exams at the Washington University School of Medicine (WUSM). Stroke patients had
three longitudinal visits, i.e. 2 weeks, 3 months and 1 year after the stroke onset. Healthy
controls only had two longitudinal visits at a distance of about 3 months. At each visit,
resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rs-fMRI) data were acquired by a
Siemens 3T Tim-Trio scanner with a standard 12-channel head coil and with gradient
July 24, 2019
12/18
echo EPI sequence (TR = 200 msec, TE = 2 msec, 32 contiguous 4 mm slices,4 × 4 mm
in-plane resolution). The acquisitions were six to eight resting state fMRI runs, each
including 128 volumes (30 min total).
Neuropsychological behavioral data were measured by assessing six different functional
domains i.e., 1) spatial attention - assessing visual attention to the contralesional
hemifield, 2) spatial memory, 3) verbal memory, 4) global language - both comprehension
and production, 5) contralesional motor, and 6) contralesional visual field. Scores in each
domain were normalized to have a mean of 0 and standard deviation of 1 in controls,
with lower scores indicating a greater deficit (see Fig. 3D).
fMRI preprocessing and functional connectivity
For each patient, lesions were manually segmented using structural MRI images (T1-
weighted MP-RAGE, T2-weighted spin echo images, and FLAIR images obtained 1-3
weeks post-stroke) using the Analyze biomedical imaging software system (www.mayo.
edu). Preprocessing of fMRI data included: 1) compensation for asynchronous slice
acquisition; 2) elimination of odd/even slice intensity differences; 3) whole brain intensity
normalization; 4) removal of distortion using synthetic field map estimation and spatial
realignment within and across fMRI runs and 5) resampling to 3 mm cubic voxels in atlas
space. Cross-modal image registration was accomplished by aligning image gradients.
Following cross-modal registration, data were passed through several additional
preprocessing steps: 1) tissue-based regressors were computed based on FreeSurfer
segmentation surfer.nmr.mgh.harvard.edu/; 2) removal by regression of the following
sources of spurious variance; 3) temporal filtering retaining frequencies in the .009-.08
Hz range; and 4) frame censoring. Surface generation and processing of functional data
followed procedures similar to [61], with additional consideration for cortical segmentation
in stroke patients. The left and right hemispheres were then resampled to 164000 vertices
and registered to each other [62], and finally down-sampled to 10242 vertices each for
projection of functional data. fMRI signals were then smoothed using a 3 mm Gaussian
kernel.
The cortical surface was parcellated according to the Gordon & Laumann atlas which
includes 324 regions of interest (ROI) [22]. To generate parcel-wise connectivity matrices,
time-courses of all vertices within a ROI were averaged. Functional connectivity (FC)
was then computed between the signals of each ROI using Fisher z-transformed Pearson
correlation. All vertices that fell within the lesion were masked out, and ROIs with
greater than 50% lesion overlap were excluded from all analyses together with their
connections. To increase the interpretation of the results, we eventually excluded ROIs
that were not assigned to known systems (e.g., visual, salience, default, etc). As a
result, we obtained FC connectivity matrices with slightly different number of nodes
((cid:104)N(cid:105) = 275.6, sd=6.8).
Brain network construction and modeling
ERGMs assume that there is a homogeneous process operating on the entire network.
In stroke, the reconfiguration processes are mainly taking place within and between
the affected regions of the brain. To take into account such heterogeneity and improve
the specificity our approach we modeled for each patient only the network impacted
by the damage. For cortical lesions, we considered only the connections among the
ROIs of the systems directly affected by the lesion (e.g. Fig. 3B). This procedure
gave in average connectivity matrices with smaller size ((cid:104)N(cid:105) = 81.13, sd= 47.78, File
S1). For subcortical lesions - including damages to cerebellum, white matter, and
brainstem - we considered that all the ROIs were potentially affected and we preserved
July 24, 2019
13/18
the entire connectivity matrix. To ensure a fair comparison we also considered the whole
connectivity matrix for the healthy controls.
Because tERMGs have been mainly studied for unweighted networks, we thresholded
the connectivity matrices to retain a same percentage of strongest links in each brain
network. While loosing information, this procedure has the advantage to ensure a
more robust comparison across different subjects and conditions [30]. Specifically, we
considered a connection density of 0.1, which falls in the range of typically studied
values, i.e. (0.05, 0.2) [11, 63, 64] . The resulting sparse time-varying brain networks were
represented by adjacency matrices At, where each entry indicated the presence At
ij = 1
or the absence At
ij = 0 of a link between nodes i and j at the visit t.
We modeled every network sequence through a tERGM as described in Eq. 5.
Because the graph metric T counts the number of triangles formation within the affected
hemisphere, we specified this information in the model by restricting opportunely the
sum indices in Eq. 4. For cortical lesions the affected hemisphere corresponded to the
lesion side. For subcortical-lesioned patients, the affected hemisphere corresponded to
the lesion side if the damage was in white matter, while we considered the contralesional
hemisphere if the stroke was in the cerebellum; if the damage was in the brainstem we
labelled both the cortical hemispheres as affected. Finally, because we were interested in
the strict formation of triangles over time we added the product term (1 − At
ik)(1 − At
kj)
in Eq. 4. This term imposes that complete triangles can never occur in one step; instead
the closure of triangles can only exist longitudinally.
Acknowledgments
Authors would like to acknowledge Gordon Shulman for the design/collection of the
experiemntal data used in this work. The research leading to these results has received
funding from the program "Investissements d'avenir" ANR-10-IAIHU-06 (Agence Na-
tionale de la Recherche-10-IA Institut Hospitalo-Universitaire-6). FD acknowledges
support from the "Agence Nationale de la Recherche" through contract number ANR-
15-NEUC-0006-02. MC acknowledges support from the "National Institute of Health"
through contracts number R01-HD06117 and R01-NS095741. The content is solely the
responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of any
of the funding agencies.
July 24, 2019
14/18
References
1. Mostany R, Portera-Cailliau C. Absence of Large-Scale Dendritic Plasticity of Layer 5
Pyramidal Neurons in Peri-Infarct Cortex. Journal of Neuroscience. 2011;31(5):1734 -- 1738.
doi:10.1523/jneurosci.4386-10.2011.
2. Brown CE, Wong C, Murphy TH. Rapid Morphologic Plasticity of Peri-Infarct
Stroke. 2008;39(4):1286 -- 1291.
Ischemic Stroke.
Dendritic Spines After Focal
doi:10.1161/strokeaha.107.498238.
3. Carmichael ST, Wei L, Rovainen CM, Woolsey TA. New Patterns of Intracortical
Projections after Focal Cortical Stroke. Neurobiology of Disease. 2001;8(5):910 -- 922.
doi:10.1006/nbdi.2001.0425.
4. Carrera E, Tononi G. Diaschisis: past present, future. Brain. 2014;137(9):2408 -- 2422.
doi:10.1093/brain/awu101.
5. Siegel JS, Ramsey LE, Snyder AZ, Metcalf NV, Chacko RV, Weinberger K, et al.
Disruptions of network connectivity predict impairment in multiple behavioral domains
after stroke. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2016;113(30):E4367 -- E4376.
doi:10.1073/pnas.1521083113.
6. Weiller C, Chollet F, Friston KJ, Wise RJS, Frackowiak RSJ. Functional reorganization
of the brain in recovery from striatocapsular infarction in man. Annals of Neurology.
1992;31(5):463 -- 472. doi:10.1002/ana.410310502.
7. Dancause N. Extensive Cortical Rewiring after Brain Injury. Journal of Neuroscience.
2005;25(44):10167 -- 10179. doi:10.1523/jneurosci.3256-05.2005.
8. van Meer MPA, van der Marel K, Wang K, Otte WM, el Bouazati S, Roeling TAP, et al.
Recovery of Sensorimotor Function after Experimental Stroke Correlates with Restoration
of Resting-State Interhemispheric Functional Connectivity. Journal of Neuroscience.
2010;30(11):3964 -- 3972. doi:10.1523/jneurosci.5709-09.2010.
9. He BJ, Snyder AZ, Vincent JL, Epstein A, Shulman GL, Corbetta M. Breakdown of
Functional Connectivity in Frontoparietal Networks Underlies Behavioral Deficits in
Spatial Neglect. Neuron. 2007;53(6):905 -- 918. doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2007.02.013.
10. Ramsey LE, Siegel JS, Baldassarre A, Metcalf NV, Zinn K, Shulman GL, et al. Nor-
malization of network connectivity in hemispatial neglect recovery. Annals of Neurology.
2016;80(1):127 -- 141. doi:10.1002/ana.24690.
11. Siegel JS, Seitzman BA, Ramsey LE, Ortega M, Gordon EM, Dosenbach NUF, et al.
Re-emergence of modular brain networks in stroke recovery. Cortex. 2018;101:44 -- 59.
doi:10.1016/j.cortex.2017.12.019.
12. Li A, Cornelius SP, Liu YY, Wang L, Barabasi AL. The fundamental advantages of
temporal networks. Science. 2017;358(6366):1042 -- 1046. doi:10.1126/science.aai7488.
13. Holme P, Saramaki J. Temporal networks. Physics Reports. 2012;519(3):97 -- 125.
doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2012.03.001.
14. Bassett DS, Wymbs NF, Porter MA, Mucha PJ, Carlson JM, Grafton ST. Dynamic
reconfiguration of human brain networks during learning. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences. 2011;108(18):7641 -- 7646. doi:10.1073/pnas.1018985108.
15. Tang J, Scellato S, Musolesi M, Mascolo C, Latora V. Small-world behavior in time-
varying graphs. Physical Review E. 2010;81(5). doi:10.1103/physreve.81.055101.
16. Thompson WH, Brantefors P, Fransson P. From static to temporal network theory
Applications to functional brain connectivity. Network Neuroscience. 2017;1(2):69 -- 99.
doi:10.1162/netn00011.
17. Braun U, Schafer A, Bassett DS, Rausch F, Schweiger JI, Bilek E, et al. Dynamic
brain network reconfiguration as a potential schizophrenia genetic risk mechanism modu-
lated by NMDA receptor function. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
2016;113(44):12568 -- 12573. doi:10.1073/pnas.1608819113.
July 24, 2019
15/18
18. Cole MW, Reynolds JR, Power JD, Repovs G, Anticevic A, Braver TS. Multi-task connec-
tivity reveals flexible hubs for adaptive task control. Nature Neuroscience. 2013;16(9):1348 --
1355. doi:10.1038/nn.3470.
19. Ekman M, Derrfuss J, Tittgemeyer M, Fiebach CJ. Predicting errors from reconfiguration
patterns in human brain networks. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
2012;109(41):16714 -- 16719. doi:10.1073/pnas.1207523109.
20. Hanneke S, Fu W, Xing EP. Discrete temporal models of social networks. Electronic
Journal of Statistics. 2010;4(0):585 -- 605. doi:10.1214/09-ejs548.
21. Newman MEJ. Modularity and community structure in networks. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences. 2006;103(23):8577 -- 8582. doi:10.1073/pnas.0601602103.
22. Gordon EM, Laumann TO, Adeyemo B, Huckins JF, Kelley WM, Petersen SE. Generation
and Evaluation of a Cortical Area Parcellation from Resting-State Correlations. Cerebral
Cortex. 2014;26(1):288 -- 303. doi:10.1093/cercor/bhu239.
23. Masuda N, Klemm K, Eguiluz VM. Temporal Networks: Slowing Down Dif-
Physical Review Letters. 2013;111(18).
fusion by Long Lasting Interactions.
doi:10.1103/physrevlett.111.188701.
24. Lentz HHK, Selhorst T, Sokolov IM. Unfolding Accessibility Provides a Macro-
scopic Approach to Temporal Networks. Physical Review Letters. 2013;110(11).
doi:10.1103/physrevlett.110.118701.
25. Starnini M, Baronchelli A, Barrat A, Pastor-Satorras R. Random walks on temporal
networks. Physical Review E. 2012;85(5). doi:10.1103/physreve.85.056115.
26. Vidaurre D, Smith SM, Woolrich MW. Brain network dynamics are hierarchically
organized in time. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2017;114(48):12827 --
12832. doi:10.1073/pnas.1705120114.
27. Deco G, Kringelbach ML, Jirsa VK, Ritter P. The dynamics of resting fluctuations in
the brain: metastability and its dynamical cortical core. Scientific Reports. 2017;7(1).
doi:10.1038/s41598-017-03073-5.
28. L S, Cercignani M, Mastropasqua C, Torso M, Span`o B, Makovac E, et al. Longitudinal
Changes in Functional Brain Connectivity Predicts Conversion to Alzheimer's Disease.
Journal of Alzheimer's Disease. 2016;.
29. Ovadia-Caro S, Villringer K, Fiebach J, Jungehulsing GJ, van der Meer E, Margulies DS,
et al. Longitudinal Effects of Lesions on Functional Networks after Stroke. Journal of
Cerebral Blood Flow & Metabolism. 2013;33(8):1279 -- 1285. doi:10.1038/jcbfm.2013.80.
30. De Vico Fallani F, Richiardi J, Chavez M, Achard S. Graph analysis of functional
brain networks: practical issues in translational neuroscience. Philosophical Transac-
tions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 2014;369(1653):20130521 -- 20130521.
doi:10.1098/rstb.2013.0521.
31. Watts DJ, Strogatz SH. Collective dynamics of small-world networks. Nature.
1998;393(6684):440 -- 442. doi:10.1038/30918.
32. BOCCALETTI S, LATORA V, MORENO Y, CHAVEZ M, HWANG D. Com-
plex networks: Structure and dynamics. Physics Reports. 2006;424(4-5):175 -- 308.
doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2005.10.009.
33. Sporns O. Network attributes for segregation and integration in the human brain. Current
Opinion in Neurobiology. 2013;23(2):162 -- 171. doi:10.1016/j.conb.2012.11.015.
34. Nudo RJ. Recovery after brain injury: mechanisms and principles. Frontiers in Human
Neuroscience. 2013;7. doi:10.3389/fnhum.2013.00887.
35. Grefkes C, Fink GR. Reorganization of cerebral networks after stroke: new in-
sights from neuroimaging with connectivity approaches. Brain. 2011;134(5):1264 -- 1276.
doi:10.1093/brain/awr033.
36. Narayanan NS. Redundancy and Synergy of Neuronal Ensembles in Motor Cortex.
Journal of Neuroscience. 2005;25(17):4207 -- 4216. doi:10.1523/jneurosci.4697-04.2005.
July 24, 2019
16/18
37. Reich DS. Independent and Redundant Information in Nearby Cortical Neurons. Science.
2001;294(5551):2566 -- 2568. doi:10.1126/science.1065839.
38. So K, Ganguly K, Jimenez J, Gastpar MC, Carmena JM. Redundant information
encoding in primary motor cortex during natural and prosthetic motor control. Journal
of Computational Neuroscience. 2011;32(3):555 -- 561. doi:10.1007/s10827-011-0369-1.
39. Schulte T, Muller-Oehring EM. Contribution of Callosal Connections to the Interhemi-
spheric Integration of Visuomotor and Cognitive Processes. Neuropsychology Review.
2010;20(2):174 -- 190. doi:10.1007/s11065-010-9130-1.
40. Alstott J, Breakspear M, Hagmann P, Cammoun L, Sporns O. Modeling the Impact
of Lesions in the Human Brain. PLoS Computational Biology. 2009;5(6):e1000408.
doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1000408.
41. Honey CJ, Sporns O. Dynamical consequences of lesions in cortical networks. Human
Brain Mapping. 2008;29(7):802 -- 809. doi:10.1002/hbm.20579.
42. Medaglia JD, Pasqualetti F, Hamilton RH, Thompson-Schill SL, Bassett DS. Brain and
cognitive reserve: Translation via network control theory. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral
Reviews. 2017;75:53 -- 64. doi:10.1016/j.neubiorev.2017.01.016.
43. Corbetta M, Shulman GL. Spatial Neglect and Attention Networks. Annual Review of
Neuroscience. 2011;34(1):569 -- 599. doi:10.1146/annurev-neuro-061010-113731.
44. Ween JE, Alexander MP, D'Esposito M, Roberts M. Factors predictive of stroke outcome
in a rehabilitation setting. Neurology. 1996;47(2):388 -- 392. doi:10.1212/wnl.47.2.388.
45. Aszal´os Z, Barsi P, Vitrai J, Nagy Z. Lateralization as a Factor in the Prognosis of Middle
Cerebral Artery Territorial Infarct. ENE. 2002;48(3):141 -- 145. doi:10.1159/000065515.
46. Connor LT, Albert ML, Helm-Estabrooks N, Obler LK. Attentional Modulation of Lan-
guage Performance. Brain and Language. 2000;71(1):52 -- 55. doi:10.1006/brln.1999.2210.
47. Liu H, Stufflebeam SM, Sepulcre J, Hedden T, Buckner RL. Evidence from intrinsic
activity that asymmetry of the human brain is controlled by multiple factors. PNAS.
2009;106(48):20499 -- 20503. doi:10.1073/pnas.0908073106.
48. Wang D, Buckner RL, Liu H. Functional Specialization in the Human Brain Es-
timated By Intrinsic Hemispheric Interaction. J Neurosci. 2014;34(37):12341 -- 12352.
doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0787-14.2014.
49. Fedorenko E, Thompson-Schill SL. Reworking the language network. Trends in Cognitive
Sciences. 2014;18(3):120 -- 126. doi:10.1016/j.tics.2013.12.006.
50. Rowe FJ, Wright D, Brand D, Jackson C, Harrison S, Maan T, et al. A Prospective Profile
of Visual Field Loss following Stroke: Prevalence Type, Rehabilitation, and Outcome.
BioMed Research International. 2013;2013:1 -- 12. doi:10.1155/2013/719096.
51. Leifeld P, Cranmer SJ. A theoretical and empirical comparison of the temporal expo-
nential random graph model and the stochastic actor-oriented model. Network Science.
2019;7(1):20 -- 51. doi:10.1017/nws.2018.26.
52. Westlake KP, Nagarajan SS. Functional Connectivity in Relation to Motor Per-
formance and Recovery After Stroke. Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience. 2011;5.
doi:10.3389/fnsys.2011.00008.
53. Lee J, Li G, Wilson JD. Varying-coefficient models for dynamic networks. arXiv preprint
arXiv:170203632. 2017;.
54. Kolar M, Song L, Ahmed A, Xing EP. Estimating time-varying networks. The Annals of
Applied Statistics. 2010;4(1):94 -- 123. doi:10.1214/09-aoas308.
55. Power JD, Barnes KA, Snyder AZ, Schlaggar BL, Petersen SE. Spurious but system-
atic correlations in functional connectivity MRI networks arise from subject motion.
NeuroImage. 2012;59(3):2142 -- 2154. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.10.018.
56. Satterthwaite TD, Wolf DH, Loughead J, Ruparel K, Elliott MA, Hakonarson H, et al.
Impact of in-scanner head motion on multiple measures of functional connectivity:
Relevance for studies of neurodevelopment in youth. NeuroImage. 2012;60(1):623 -- 632.
doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.12.063.
July 24, 2019
17/18
57. Siegel JS, Mitra A, Laumann TO, Seitzman BA, Raichle M, Corbetta M, et al. Data
Quality Influences Observed Links Between Functional Connectivity and Behavior. Cereb
Cortex. 2017;27(9):4492 -- 4502. doi:10.1093/cercor/bhw253.
58. Siegel JS, Shulman GL, Corbetta M. Measuring functional connectivity in stroke:
approaches and considerations. 2017;doi:10.1101/177618.
59. Betzel RF, Bassett DS. Generative models for network neuroscience: prospects
Journal of The Royal Society Interface. 2017;14(136):20170623.
and promise.
doi:10.1098/rsif.2017.0623.
60. Obando C, De Vico Fallani F. A statistical model for brain networks inferred
from large-scale electrophysiological signals. Journal of The Royal Society Interface.
2017;14(128):20160940. doi:10.1098/rsif.2016.0940.
61. Glasser MF, Sotiropoulos SN, Wilson JA, Coalson TS, Fischl B, Andersson JL, et al.
The minimal preprocessing pipelines for the Human Connectome Project. Neuroimage.
2013;80:105 -- 124. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.04.127.
62. Van Essen DC, Drury HA, Dickson J, Harwell J, Hanlon D, Anderson CH. An Integrated
Software Suite for Surface-based Analyses of Cerebral Cortex. J Am Med Inform Assoc.
2001;8(5):443 -- 459. doi:10.1136/jamia.2001.0080443.
63. Lord A, Horn D, Breakspear M, Walter M. Changes in Community Structure of Resting
State Functional Connectivity in Unipolar Depression. PLOS ONE. 2012;7(8):e41282.
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0041282.
64. De Vico Fallani F, Latora V, Chavez M. A Topological Criterion for Filtering Informa-
tion in Complex Brain Networks. PLOS Computational Biology. 2017;13(1):e1005305.
doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1005305.
July 24, 2019
18/18
|
1903.09542 | 1 | 1903 | 2019-03-22T15:00:25 | Nonmodular architectures of cognitive systems based on active inference | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cs.AI"
] | In psychology and neuroscience it is common to describe cognitive systems as input/output devices where perceptual and motor functions are implemented in a purely feedforward, open-loop fashion. On this view, perception and action are often seen as encapsulated modules with limited interaction between them. While embodied and enactive approaches to cognitive science have challenged the idealisation of the brain as an input/output device, we argue that even the more recent attempts to model systems using closed-loop architectures still heavily rely on a strong separation between motor and perceptual functions. Previously, we have suggested that the mainstream notion of modularity strongly resonates with the separation principle of control theory. In this work we present a minimal model of a sensorimotor loop implementing an architecture based on the separation principle. We link this to popular formulations of perception and action in the cognitive sciences, and show its limitations when, for instance, external forces are not modelled by an agent. These forces can be seen as variables that an agent cannot directly control, i.e., a perturbation from the environment or an interference caused by other agents. As an alternative approach inspired by embodied cognitive science, we then propose a nonmodular architecture based on the active inference framework. We demonstrate the robustness of this architecture to unknown external inputs and show that the mechanism with which this is achieved in linear models is equivalent to integral control. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Nonmodular architectures of cognitive systems
based on active inference
Manuel Baltieri, Christopher L. Buckley
EASY group, Sussex Neuroscience - Department of Informatics
University of Sussex
Brighton, UK
[email protected], [email protected]
9
1
0
2
r
a
M
2
2
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
2
4
5
9
0
.
3
0
9
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
Abstract -- In psychology and neuroscience it is common to de-
scribe cognitive systems as input/output devices where perceptual
and motor functions are implemented in a purely feedforward,
open-loop fashion. On this view, perception and action are often
seen as encapsulated modules with limited interaction between
them. While embodied and enactive approaches to cognitive
science have challenged the idealisation of the brain as an
input/output device, we argue that even the more recent attempts
to model systems using closed-loop architectures still heavily rely
on a strong separation between motor and perceptual functions.
Previously, we have suggested that the mainstream notion of
modularity strongly resonates with the separation principle of
control theory. In this work we present a minimal model of a
sensorimotor loop implementing an architecture based on the
separation principle. We link this to popular formulations of
perception and action in the cognitive sciences, and show its
limitations when, for instance, external forces are not modelled
by an agent. These forces can be seen as variables that an
agent cannot directly control,
i.e., a perturbation from the
environment or an interference caused by other agents. As an
alternative approach inspired by embodied cognitive science, we
then propose a nonmodular architecture based on the active
inference framework. We demonstrate the robustness of this
architecture to unknown external
inputs and show that the
mechanism with which this is achieved in linear models is
equivalent to integral control.
Index Terms -- modularity, separation principle, active infer-
ence, Bayesian inference, optimal control
I. INTRODUCTION
In cognitive science it is often assumed that agents can be
described as input/output systems, an idea based on traditional,
computational accounts of cognition [1] -- [3]. In these models,
the emphasis is on internal models of the world, central
processing and the sense-model-plan-act framework, often
neglecting embodiment, situatedness and feedback from the
environment [4]. More recent attempts, e.g., [5] -- [7], have
proposed closed-loop descriptions of cognitive system using
internal forward/inverse models in an attempt to provide better
accounts of behaviour in living organisms. However in both
the input/output and the closed-loop architectures advocated by
these approaches, the role of perceptual and motor processes is
thought to be fundamentally modular [2], i.e., these functions
can be described as nearly independent, (informationally)
encapsulated components with minimal interactions.
In recent years, theories of estimation and control have
become increasingly popular accounts of perception [8] -- [10]
and action [5] -- [7] respectively. In this context, the Kalman-
Bucy filter is used as a model of perception [9], [11] while
LQR (linear quadratic regulator) constitutes the basis of var-
ious accounts of motor control [12], [13]. In previous work
[14] we claimed that the idea of modularity of action and
perception can be seen as an analogy of the separation prin-
ciple in control theory [15] -- [17]. According to this principle,
problems of estimation and control of a system can be solved
separately and their solutions can be optimally combined under
a set of assumptions. Following this, one can sequentially
combine a Kalman-Bucy filter and LQR to create the LQG
(linear quadratic Gaussian) architecture, used as a general
methodology for several models of sensorimotor loops, e.g.,
[6], [13], [18], [19]. The "classical sandwich" [3] of cognitive
science thus survives, we claim, even in the forward/inverse
models formulation of perception and motor control.
The fields of embodied and enactive cognitive science on the
other hand emphasise the deep integration of perception and
action, seen as fundamentally intertwined [20] -- [22]. In [14]
we proposed to use a framework based on the formulation
of perception and action as estimation and control while not
implementing the conditions for the separation principle, i.e.,
active inference. Active inference is a process theory based on
the free energy principle [23] describing cognitive functions
(perception and action, but also learning and attention) as
processes of minimisation of sensory surprisal [23], [24]. More
precisely, since this quantity is not directly accessible by
an agent, it is thought that the variational free energy (an
upper bound to sensory surprisal) is minimised in its place.
In active inference, perceptual and motor processes are often
described as entangled and inseparable [25] -- [27] providing
thus a new possible methodology combining estimation and
control following embodied/enactive theories of the mind. We
previously presented a conceptual account of active inference
and its role for nonmodular architectures of cognitive systems
[14]. Here we introduce a minimal agent model highlighting
the different implementations (LQG vs. active inference) es-
pecially in presence of unknown external stimuli affecting an
agent's observations.
II. LQG AND THE SEPARATION PRINCIPLE
The framework provided by LQG control and based on
the separation principle linearly combines two processes of 1)
estimation or inference of hidden properties of the environment
and 2) control or regulations of variables of interest. The
estimation of hidden variables is based on the presence of
a Kalman (for discrete time systems) or Kalman-Bucy (for
continuous time systems) filter, while the control of the desired
variables on LQR [15] -- [17]. In particular, this combination is
provably optimal according to a set of assumptions:
1) the estimator is implemented through a state-space
model where only linear process dynamics and observa-
tion laws describe the environment and its latent states
2) uncertainty or noise in both dynamics and observations
are represented by white, zero-mean Gaussian variables
3) the properties of these random variables, in particular
their (co)variance matrices, are known
4) the performance of the regulator can be evaluated using
a quadratic cost function
5) all the inputs/forces applied to the agent are known, e.g.,
external disturbances and internal signals such as motor
actions.
Following the separation principle,
the LQG controller
produces optimal estimation and optimal control for linear
systems, sequentially combining two separate sub-systems, a
Kalman-Bucy filter and LQR, in an optimal (i.e., minimum-
variance) way [16], [17]. The Kalman-Bucy filter provides the
optimal state-estimate of a signal and the LQR controller uses
such estimate (i.e., the mean) to implement the optimal deter-
ministic controller: LQG control makes use of the estimated
mean and feeds it into an LQR controller.
A general linear system to be regulated in the presence of
noise on the observed state is described by:
dx = Ax dt + Ba dt + dw
y = Cx + dz
(1)
where all the variables and parameters are the same as pre-
viously defined for Kalman-Bucy filters and LQR. Using the
separation principle, it can then be shown that minimising the
expected value of the cost-to-go is equivalent to minimising
the cost-to-go for the expected (estimated) state [17]
c(x, a) = c( x, a) =
1
2
xT Q x +
1
2
aT Ra
(2)
where we replaced states x with their estimates x, meaning
that
the optimal control can be computed using only the
state estimate (i.e., the mean) x rather than x. The combined
problem of estimation and control
in LQG terms is then
implemented by the following system combining Kalman-
Bucy filter and LQR equations:
x =A x + Ba + K(y − C x)
a = − L x
K =P H T (Σz)−1
L =R−1BT V
P =Σw + AP + P AT − K(Σz)K T
− V =Q + AT V + V A − LT RL.
(3)
III. ACTIVE INFERENCE
Active inference is a process theory proposed to explain
brain functioning and other functions of living systems based
on Bayesian inference and optimal control theory [23], [24],
[28]. In this section we establish its relations to the LQG
architecture, starting by building an active inference version of
the regulation of a linear multivariate system, and highlighting
differences, limitations and possible extensions proposed for
the control problem. As with LQG control, we build an
estimator of the hidden states x. In this case however, we
will give a variational account of the estimator in generalised
coordinates of motion that generalises the MLE/MAP deriva-
tion of Kalman-Bucy filters [29] using Variational Bayes with
a Laplace approximation [24], [30]. We start by defining a
generative model for an agent capturing the dynamics of the
system to control and how these relate to observations and
represented in a generalised state-space form [24], [31]:
x(cid:48) = Ax(cid:48) + Bv + w
y = Cx + z
(4)
where the hat over the matrices simply represents the fact that
the matrices used in the generative model don't necessarily
mirror their counterparts describing the world dynamics ( [32],
[33]), as shown in our model later. The main difference with
respect to LQG however is that LQG explicitly mirrors (by
construction in the linear case) the dynamics of the observed
system, thus including knowledge of inputs a. On the other
hand, in active inference this vector is not explicitly modelled
by an agent, assuming that such information is not available to
a system, in accordance with evidence in motor neuroscience
suggesting the lack of knowledge of self-produced controls
(i.e., efference copy) [25], [34], [35]. It is in fact proposed
that a deeper duality of estimation and control exists whereby,
in the simplest case (i.e., a purely reflexive account), actions
are simply responses to the presence of prediction errors at the
proprioceptive level, irrespectively of the cause of sensations
(self-generated or external forces) [25], [33]. The vector v in
the generative model encodes instead external or exogenous
inputs in a state-space models context or, from a Bayesian
perspective, priors or "desired" outcomes generated by higher
layers in hierarchical (Bayesian) implementations [10], [31].
In this light, priors can be used to effectively bias the estimator
to "infer" desired rather than observed states, with a controller
instantiating actions on the world to fulfil the "observed" (=
desired) states of an agent. Variables z, w model the real noise
in the environment making, however, use of the definition of
state space models in generalised coordinates of motion [30],
[31], where z, w are treated as analytical noise with non-zero
autocorrelation, generalising the definition of Wiener processes
with Markov property.
This state-space model can then be written down in a
probabilistic form, mapping the measurements equation to a
likelihood P (yx) (no direct influence of inputs on observa-
tions), and a the dynamics to a prior P (x, v) [24], [31], [32].
The two multivariate Gaussian probabilities densities can then
be combined and used in the general formulation of Laplace
the free energy for a generic linear multivariate system be-
comes then:
encoded variational free energy defined in [24], [30] (without
constants):
F ≈ − ln P (y, x, v)
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)x=µx,v=µv
(cid:17)T
(cid:16)
(cid:17)
(cid:17)T
F ≈ 1
y − Cµx
y − Cµx
Πz
2
(cid:21)
(cid:12)(cid:12) + (m + n) ln 2π
(cid:12)(cid:12) − ln(cid:12)(cid:12)Πw
x − Aµx − Bµv
x − Aµx − Bµv
µ(cid:48)
µ(cid:48)
(cid:20)(cid:16)
(cid:16)
− ln(cid:12)(cid:12)Πz
(cid:16)
(cid:17)
+
(6)
Πw
(5)
+
+
where we explicitly replaced x, v with their expectations
µx, µv since under the Laplace assumption this represents
the best estimate of x, v (i.e., covariances of the approximate,
variational density can be recovered analytically [24], [30]).
Variables m, n represent
the length of vectors y and x
respectively. Expectations µx play the same role of estimates
x in LQG, we simply decided to use a notation consistent
with some of our previous work [24], [32], [36]. We also
defined precision matrices Πz, Πw as the inverse of covariance
matrices Σz, Σw and used · to define the determinant of
a matrix. It is important to highlight that, in general, the
covariance matrices used in the generative model can be
different from the ones used to describe the environment or
generative process [32], [33]. To simplify the already heavy
notation we will however represent them in the same way.
The recognition dynamics, encoding perception and action
in a system minimising free energy [24], [30] and equivalent
to estimation and control functions respectively, are imple-
mented in standard active inference formulations as a gradient
descent scheme minimising the free energy with respect to the
variables µx for perception/estimation:
(cid:16)
(cid:17)
µx = Dµx − ∂F
x + C T Πz
∂µx
(cid:16)
x − Aµx − Bµv
µ(cid:48)
x − Πw
x − ∂F
∂µ(cid:48)
+ AT Πw
µ(cid:48)
x = Dµ(cid:48)
y − Cµx
= µ(cid:48)(cid:48)
= µ(cid:48)
(cid:17)
(cid:16)
(cid:17)
(7)
+
x
and actions a for action/control, assuming only that actions
have an effect on observations y [28]:
T
= − ∂y
∂a
a = − ∂F
∂a
= − ∂F
∂y
y − Cµx
∂y
∂a
(8)
Πz
.
x − Aµx − Bµv
µ(cid:48)
(cid:17)
(cid:16)
The estimation expressed in (7) prescribes a generalisation of
Kalman-Bucy filters to trajectories with arbitrary embedding
orders where random variables are not treated as Markov
processes [30]. In (7), we also include an extra term Dµx
that represents the "mode of the motion" (also the mean
for Gaussian variables) for the minimisation in generalised
coordinates of motion [24], [31], with D as a differential
operator shifting the order of motion, i.e., Dµx = µ(cid:48)
x. More
intuitively, since we are now minimising the components of a
generalised state representing a trajectory rather than a static
variable, variables are in a moving framework of reference
where the minimisation is achieved for µx = µ(cid:48)
x rather than
µx = 0. Action as expressed in (8) may appear similar to
the traditional LQR/LQG form, but is fundamentally different
since it depends explicitly on observations y rather than
estimated hidden states µx.
IV. THE MODEL
The double integrator is a canonical example used in control
theory and represents one of the most fundamental problems
in optimal control, modelling single degree of freedom motion
of different physical systems [37], [38]. In the case presented
here, this could be thought of as a block on frictionless surface.
In motor neuroscience, this is the simplest model of single-
joint movement [39] and can, in some cases, be easily gener-
alised to multiple degrees of freedom [28]. The standard dou-
ble integrator is usually described as a deterministic system.
The control policy is thus defined using a feedback law applied
directly to the known dynamics, as the full state of the system
is measured with no uncertainty [37]. For the purposes of this
work, where uncertainty and noise are crucial components,
we will introduce process and measurement noise into the
system, making the estimation of hidden states necessary. This
will then allow us to compare LQG and active inference in
one of the simplest possible examples in the control theory
literature with direct applications to the study of motor systems
and behaviour 1. The double integrator is described by the
following state-space model:
x = Ax + Ba + w y = Cx + z
(9)
where matrices A, B, C are defined as:
A =
0
1
and covariance matrices Σz, Σw as:
B =
0
(cid:20)0
(cid:21)
(cid:20)exp(0)
1
0
(cid:20)0
(cid:21)
0
(cid:21)
(cid:20)1 0
(cid:21)
C =
(cid:20)0
0
(cid:21)
0 1
0
exp(−1)
Σz =
0
0
exp(0)
Σw =
A. The LQG solution to the double integrator
For LQG we implement
(3) using the same matrices
A, B, C, Σz, Σw specified above and furthermore define:
(cid:20)1
0
(cid:21)
0
1
(cid:20)4
0
(cid:21)
0
4
Q =
R =
(10)
with no specific optimisation of these parameters since it is
beyond the scope of this work. For further analysis see for
instance [37]. As we can see in Fig. 2a, the block is effectively
driven to the desired position x = 0 and velocity x(cid:48) = 0
from a set of 5 randomly initialised conditions (position and
velocity are sampled from zero-mean Gaussian distributions,
sd=300). In Fig. 2b we then show the actions over time of
the same 5 example agents, all converging to zero since the
agents effectively reach their desired target. The main feature
of LQG, and from which active inference will depart, is the
1The code is available at https://github.com/mbaltieri/doubleIntegrator
Fig. 1: The generative process, a double integrator. The
double integrator models the motion of a system with a single
degree of freedom, corresponding to a block of mass=1kg
placed on a surface with no friction. The block is initialised at
a random position with a random velocity and needs to stop,
x(cid:48) = 0, at position x = 0.
reliability of estimates of both position and velocity (the red
line in the phase space), using a Kalman-Bucy filter. In LQG,
accurate estimates are necessary to then enact the LQR com-
ponent implementing a negative feedback mechanism based
on estimates x rather than true hidden states x. In Fig. 3 we
introduced a new external force not modelled by the agents,
equivalent to a disturbance from the environment (black line in
Fig. 3b). Fig. 3a then shows that the agents are incapable of
regulating their position/velocity against this unknown input
(blue lines), after an initial convergence towards the desired
state, they in fact move away from it when the unexpected
force is introduced. Furthermore, these agents are incapable
of correctly inferring their trajectories, providing inaccurate
estimates of their sensed variables (red lines). In Fig. 3b we
see that all of these agents attempt to counteract the effects of
unexpected stimuli (they minimise their velocity after the force
is introduced), however the lack of an appropriate mechanism
to track their position correctly (e.g., integral action) pushes
them away from the target.
B. The double integrator with active inference
To solve the same control problem, active inference relies
on the generation of predictions of proprioceptive sensations
(position, velocity as in LQG, and also acceleration in this
case), followed by the implementation of actions in the world
via (trivial) reflex arcs. The proprioceptive modality is es-
sentially treated as other inputs (vision, audition, etc.) and
estimates/predictions are generated using the same generative
model taking advantage of incoming proprioceptive sensations.
This produces a considerably different control system, with
state estimates and actions now created by the same model,
making it hard to clearly separate processes of perception
and action. The copy of motor control signals (cf. efference
copy [40]), necessary in standard LQG settings to meet the
observability constraints of Kalman-Bucy filters [16], [17] is
(a)
(b)
Fig. 2: The double integrator solved using LQG. (a) Five
examples with different initial conditions showing in blue the
observed trajectories of different blocks in the phase-space
and in red the agent's estimates of the same trajectories. (b)
Actions taken by the five agents.
not included in this formulation, as explained in section III.
Active inference postulates in fact that direct representations
of the causes or actions a of self-generated sensations need not
be discounted during the prediction of new incoming sensory
inputs. This could be seen as a limitation of active inference,
but in general this speaks to the robustness of this approach
in face of unknown inputs (i.e., motor actions produced by
an agent or exogenous forces from the environment), see
[36]. In this framework, inputs can also be estimated using
an appropriate generative model of the world dynamics [30],
a feature thought to be fundamental in biological systems
[41]. Simple and effective approximations are also possible,
for example with integral control, thought to be the most
basic heuristic dealing with the problem of uncertain inputs
in biological systems down to the unicellular level [41], [42]
and already shown to be consistent with formulations of active
m =1kgSliding block on a frictionless surface,
target: x = 0, x' = 0x=0Force
appliedTarget0123456789101112131415Time (s)7550250255075100Action, a (m/s2)Action of double integrator - LQGAgent 1Agent 2Agent 3Agent 4Agent 5 (a)
(b)
Fig. 3: The double integrator solved using LQG. (a) Five
examples with different initial conditions showing in blue the
observed trajectories of different blocks in the phase-space
and in red the agent's estimates of the same trajectories. (b)
Actions taken by the five agents after an external force is
introduced (black line).
inference [36].
To derive an active inference solution to the double integra-
tor, we start by defining a generative model for the agent, i.e.,
the block:
x(cid:48) = Ax + Bv + w y = Cx + z
(11)
where matrix A is:
A =
0
1
−α1 −α2
0
0
0
0
0
while B is diagonal with exp(1) values, C is zero everywhere
but in C2,2 where the motor action is applied (with a value
of 1) and covariance matrices Σz, Σw are also diagonal with,
respectively, exp(1) and exp(8) values on the main diagonals.
Fig. 4: The generative model. To implement the regulation of
position and velocity, the agent implements a model whereby
an imaginary spring pulls the block back to the origin (x = 0)
while an imaginary damper slows it down (x(cid:48) = 0).
The agent implements beliefs of a world where it is pulled
back to the desired state x = x(cid:48) = 0 by an imaginary spring
and slows down thanks to an imaginary piston-like damper,
"designed" (in this case by us, but more in general one could
imagine evolutionary processes for biological system [28]) to
favour normative behaviour.
Following (6), the variational free energy for our controller
(cid:20)
is then described by:
F ≈ 1
2
πz(y − µx)2 + πz(cid:48)(y(cid:48) − µ(cid:48)
x)2 + πz(cid:48)(cid:48) (y(cid:48)(cid:48) − µ(cid:48)(cid:48)
x)2+
x − µv)2 − ln(πzπz(cid:48)πz(cid:48)(cid:48)πw(cid:48)) + (3 + 2) ln 2π
+ πw(cid:48)(µ(cid:48)(cid:48)
(cid:21)
(12)
where precisions π are taken from the diagonals of precision
matrices Πz, Πw (inverse covariances matrices Σz, Σw defined
in the generative model). After explicitly writing out
the
equations derived from the matrix formulation in (7), we get
the following formulation of perceptual inference:
x + αµx − βµv)
x − βµ(cid:48)
x + αµ(cid:48)
v)
x − βµ(cid:48)
x + αµ(cid:48)
v)
x + πz(y − µx) + πw(µ(cid:48)
x + πz(cid:48)(y(cid:48) − µ(cid:48)
x + πz(cid:48)(cid:48) (y(cid:48)(cid:48) − µ(cid:48)(cid:48)
x) + πw(cid:48)(µ(cid:48)(cid:48)
x) + πw(cid:48)(cid:48) (µ(cid:48)(cid:48)
(13)
µx =µ(cid:48)
µ(cid:48)
x =µ(cid:48)(cid:48)
µ(cid:48)(cid:48)
x =µ(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48)
and
x = − πw(µ(cid:48)
µ(cid:48)
x = − πw(cid:48)(µ(cid:48)(cid:48)
µ(cid:48)(cid:48)
x + αµx − βµv)
x − βµ(cid:48)
x + αµ(cid:48)
v)
(14)
showing the lack of the Kalman gain K and an important
difference derived from its absence: if K is non-diagonal as
in this case (one can simply verify this claim with standard
functions solving continuous Riccati equations, as in the
provided code), both orders of motion are present
in the
optimal filter problem in (3), but only one appears in (13)
since the precision matrices are assumed to be diagonal in our
formulation. More in general, in active inference the Kalman
gain K matrix is replaced by learning rates such as in this work
TargetTrajectorywith ext. force0123456789101112131415Time (s)10050050100150200Action, a (m/s2)Action of double integrator - LQG, no external force in KBFAgent 1Agent 2Agent 3Agent 4Agent 5Ext. forcem =1kgSpring-mass-damper system−α1x−α2x′ x=0 or [32], or by clever implementations that allow for adaptive
update schemes with varying integration steps as in [30].
The action component is, however, the one most signif-
icantly different, starting from the assumption that direct
knowledge of motor signals is not available and thus not
modelled in the generative model (motor commands a are
replaced by inputs v acting as priors). This entails a new
approach to the problem, with active inference suggesting that
the only information needed comes from observations y, see
(8). On this account, action reduces to
a = −
and with the assumption that
(cid:19)T
(cid:18) ∂y(cid:48)
=(cid:2)1
∂a
∂y
∂a
Πz(y − Cµx)
(15)
1 1(cid:3)T
the explicit, scalar version of action becomes
a = −πz(y − µx) − πz(cid:48)(y(cid:48) − µ(cid:48)
x) − πz(cid:48)(cid:48) (y(cid:48)(cid:48) − µ(cid:48)(cid:48)
x),
(16)
replacing the LQR component in (3). This type of control
is equivalent to a PID controller, and is the "optimal" linear
solution when knowledge of inputs a is not available in the
generative model [36]. As in the case of filtering, the feedback
gain L is missing in the active inference formulation, once
again replaced by learning rates of the gradient descent or
by other approximations.
In Fig. 5 we can see an example
implementation of the double integrator using active inference.
Five agents are initialised at random position and velocity
(zero-mean Gaussian distributed, sd=300) and converge to
the target solution where the output actions are essentially
zero (excluding some noise), as expected Fig. 5b. The most
striking feature is that estimates of both position and velocity
of the block are very inaccurate but the agent nonetheless
reaches the desired target in the phase space, Fig. 5a. These
differences are given by the generative implemented by the
agent, encoding an imaginary spring-damper system that pulls
it towards its desired state Fig. 4. Fig. 6 shows the robustness
of this implementation when an external force is introduced:
by implementing integral control [36], active inference can
in this case counteract the effects of unexpected inputs. The
presence of integral action perfectly counteracts the effects
of disturbances Fig. 6b (cf. Fig. 3b), and more importantly
allows for the desired regulation of the agents' positions,
Fig. 6a, which is impossible in LQG accounts assuming perfect
knowledge of the world (cf. Fig. 3a).
V. DISCUSSION
LQG-based architectures are modular in nature, with per-
ception and action seen as separate problems solved nearly
independently. According to this view, a system should ini-
tially find accurate estimates of the hidden properties of
its observations, and only once such estimates are available
should an agent attempt
to regulate variables that are of
interest to achieve its goals, e.g., temperature, oxygen level,
etc.. On the other hand, we can define a framework based
(a)
(b)
Fig. 5: The double integrator solved using active inference
(α1 = exp (2), α2 = exp (1)). Same layout as Fig. 2. (a)
Five examples with different initial conditions showing in blue
the observed trajectories of different blocks in the phase-space
and in red the agent's estimates of the same trajectories. (b)
Actions taken by the five agents.
on mathematical formulations of control problems where the
separation principle is not included or required. According to
one such proposal, that we identified in active inference [23],
[28], perception and action are combined in an inseparable
sensorimotor loop described by the minimisation of variational
free energy for an agent. In this set up, action and perception
are seen as instances of a fundamentally unique process [20],
using different labels for our (i.e., the observers') convenience.
In particular, the idea of precise inferences of world variables
is called into question [32], [43], to the point that inaccurate
perception is not only possible but becomes a pre-requisite
to act on the world [26], [33]. In architectures based on
the separation principle, the estimated state of a system is
thought of as a relevant account of real observations, e.g.,
their means and covariances. Conversely, in active inference it
Target0123456789101112131415Time (s)2001000100200300400500Action a (m/s2)Action of double integrator - Active inferenceAgent 1Agent 2Agent 3Agent 4Agent 5 minimise, an agent becomes a simple mirror of its world with
no strong desire or even necessity to act [32], [33], [46].
In other words, depending on different precision weights an
agent can accurately estimate its observations without acting
or potentially discard its sensations to only pursue its desires,
generating all possible cases in between as a balanced mix of
weighted prediction errors [47].
VI. CONCLUSIONS
In recent years the more traditional understanding of per-
ceptual and motor as nearly independent processes as been put
into discussion by different authors, especially in neuroscience
[48] -- [50]. It is clear that many experimental set ups are limited
[51], requiring new and ethologically meaningful paradigms
for an appropriate study of different aspects of living systems
[52]. In this context, we propose some new ideas that could
drive future experiments. These ideas are centred around a
critical appraisal of LQG as a model architecture for cognitive
systems, focusing in particular on the assumptions made by
the use of Kalman-Bucy filters, central to these proposals [11],
[18], [53]. One of the key requirements for Kalman-Bucy
filters to generate an accurate estimate of the hidden state of a
system is to have access to all the outputs (the observations)
and all the inputs (forces that affect the state) of a system. The
inputs, in particular, include both motor commands, which in
classical forward/inverse models are identified using the idea
of efference copy [40] (see for instance [5] -- [7]), and external
forces/signals from the environment that cannot be in principle
accounted by an organism, i.e., a sudden change in weather
conditions or unexpected interactions with other agents.
In this work we focused on the latter, since the presence
of external unaccounted forces is often overlooked in many
experimental set-ups with fixed or predictable conditions (e.g.,
the classic and still dominating two-alternative forced choice
paradigm). In more realistic and ethological scenarios, how-
ever, one should expect that external and unpredictable stimuli
constantly affect the behaviour of an agent [50] -- [52]. In this
case, introducing noise or varying experimental conditions
may help in testing the robustness of LQG-based architectures.
In practice, if some inputs are not known, one should expect
LQG to perform rather poorly until
these inputs can be
estimated and adaptation (e.g., learning) to new conditions
can take place. However, one should then explain how such
forces can be described in LQG since Kalman-Bucy filters
cannot estimate inputs [29] (cf. DEM [30]). More in general,
if a system is well adapted to deal with unpredictable stimuli,
simple mechanisms such as integral control could be in place,
as shown formally in [41] and in experiments on chemotactic
adaptation in E. Coli [42] for instance. More recently, some
promising results have been presented in [54], supporting
the idea that integral feedback control, unlike Kalman(-Bucy)
filters, is a good model for adaptation in environments with
varying conditions. Integral control constitutes a linear ap-
proximation to problems of control with unknown forces
affecting the observations of an agent [36], [38], providing a
robust solution with fast responses to problems that otherwise
(a)
(b)
Fig. 6: The double integrator solved using active inference
(α1 = exp (2), α2 = exp (1)). Same layout as Fig. 2. (a)
Five examples with different initial conditions showing in blue
the observed trajectories of different blocks in the phase-space
and in red the agent's estimates of the same trajectories. (b)
Actions taken by the five agents after an external force is
introduced (black line).
becomes clear that estimates of latent variables of the world
are deeply connected to the current goal of an agent, e.g., to
regulate its observations, cf. [44]. To do so, its targets are
encoded as prior expectations and used to bias inferential
processes toward its desires so that prediction errors are
created as the mismatch of observations and the estimates of
hidden variables. These errors are then minimised by acting on
the world [28], taking advantage of proprioceptive prediction
errors that enact reflex arcs to make observation better accord
with existing predictions [26], [45]. More in general, the active
inference formulation allows also for accurate estimates of
the latent variables generating observations, see for instance
[30], but this modality fundamentally excludes the possibility
of acting: if no prediction errors are generated for action to
Target02468101214Time (s)4002000200400600Action a (m/s2)Action of double integrator - Active inferenceAgent 1Agent 2Agent 3Agent 4Agent 5Ext. force would require slower learning mechanisms [42], which may
be ineffective in fast-paced environments [55].
VII. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This work was supported in part by a BBSRC Grant
BB/P022197/1.
REFERENCES
[1] A. Newell, H. A. Simon et al., Human problem solving. Prentice-Hall
Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1972, vol. 104, no. 9.
[2] J. Fodor, The Modularity of Mind. MIT Press, 1983.
[3] S. Hurley, "Perception and action: Alternative views," Synthese, vol. 129,
[4] R. A. Brooks, "New approaches to robotics," Science, vol. 253, no. 5025,
no. 1, pp. 3 -- 40, 2001.
pp. 1227 -- 1232, 1991.
[5] M. Kawato, "Internal models for motor control and trajectory planning,"
Current opinion in neurobiology, vol. 9, no. 6, pp. 718 -- 727, 1999.
[6] D. M. Wolpert and Z. Ghahramani, "Computational principles of move-
ment neuroscience," Nature neuroscience, vol. 3, no. 11s, p. 1212, 2000.
[7] E. Todorov, "Optimality principles in sensorimotor control," Nature
neuroscience, vol. 7, no. 9, pp. 907 -- 915, 2004.
[8] D. C. Knill and W. Richards, Perception as Bayesian inference. Cam-
bridge University Press, 1996.
[9] R. P. Rao and D. H. Ballard, "Predictive coding in the visual cortex: a
functional interpretation of some extra-classical receptive-field effects,"
Nature neuroscience, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 79 -- 87, 1999.
[10] T. S. Lee and D. Mumford, "Hierarchical bayesian inference in the visual
cortex," JOSA A, vol. 20, no. 7, pp. 1434 -- 1448, 2003.
[11] D. M. Wolpert, J. Diedrichsen, and J. R. Flanagan, "Principles of
sensorimotor learning," Nature Reviews Neuroscience, vol. 12, no. 12,
p. 739, 2011.
[12] W. Li and E. Todorov, "Iterative linear quadratic regulator design for
nonlinear biological movement systems." in ICINCO (1), 2004, pp. 222 --
229.
[13] I. H. Stevenson, H. L. Fernandes, I. Vilares, K. Wei, and K. P. Kording,
"Bayesian integration and non-linear feedback control in a full-body
motor task," PLoS computational biology, vol. 5, no. 12, p. e1000629,
2009.
[14] M. Baltieri and C. L. Buckley, "The modularity of action and percep-
tion revisited using control theory and active inference," in The 2018
Conference on Artificial Life: A Hybrid of the European Conference on
Artificial Life (ECAL) and the International Conference on the Synthesis
and Simulation of Living Systems (ALIFE), T. Ikegami, N. Virgo,
O. Witkowski, M. Oka, R. Suzuki, and H. Iizuka, Eds., 2018, pp. 121 --
128.
[15] W. Wonham, "On the separation theorem of stochastic control," SIAM
Journal on Control, vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 312 -- 326, 1968.
[16] B. Anderson and J. B. Moore, Optimal control: linear quadratic
methods. Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1990.
[17] R. F. Stengel, Optimal control and estimation. Courier Corporation,
1994.
[18] E. Todorov and M. I. Jordan, "Optimal feedback control as a theory of
motor coordination," Nature neuroscience, vol. 5, no. 11, p. 1226, 2002.
[19] S.-H. Yeo, D. W. Franklin, and D. M. Wolpert, "When optimal feedback
control is not enough: Feedforward strategies are required for optimal
control with active sensing," PLoS computational biology, vol. 12,
no. 12, p. e1005190, 2016.
[20] A. Clark, Being there: Putting brain, body, and world together again.
MIT press, 1998.
[21] M. Wilson, "Six views of embodied cognition," Psychonomic bulletin
& review, vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 625 -- 636, 2002.
[22] E. Di Paolo, T. Buhrmann, and X. Barandiaran, Sensorimotor Life: An
Enactive Proposal. Oxford University Press, 2017.
[23] K. Friston, "The free-energy principle: a unified brain theory?" Nature
reviews. Neuroscience, vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 127 -- 138, 2010.
[24] C. L. Buckley, C. S. Kim, S. McGregor, and A. K. Seth, "The free energy
principle for action and perception: A mathematical review," Journal of
Mathematical Psychology, vol. 14, pp. 55 -- 79, 2017.
[25] K. Friston, "What is optimal about motor control?" Neuron, vol. 72,
[26] W. Wiese, "Action is enabled by systematic misrepresentations," Erken-
no. 3, pp. 488 -- 498, 2011.
ntnis, pp. 1 -- 20, 2016.
[27] G. Pezzulo, F. Donnarumma, P. Iodice, D. Maisto, and I. Stoianov,
"Model-based approaches to active perception and control," Entropy,
vol. 19, no. 6, p. 266, 2017.
[28] K. J. Friston, J. Daunizeau, J. Kilner, and S. J. Kiebel, "Action and
behavior: A free-energy formulation," Biological Cybernetics, vol. 102,
no. 3, pp. 227 -- 260, 2010.
[29] Z. Chen, "Bayesian filtering: From kalman filters to particle filters, and
beyond," Statistics, vol. 182, no. 1, pp. 1 -- 69, 2003.
[30] K. J. Friston, N. Trujillo-Barreto, and J. Daunizeau, "DEM: A variational
treatment of dynamic systems," NeuroImage, vol. 41, no. 3, pp. 849 -- 885,
2008.
[31] K. Friston, "Hierarchical models in the brain," PLoS Computational
Biology, vol. 4, no. 11, 2008.
[32] M. Baltieri and C. L. Buckley, "An active inference implementation of
phototaxis," in Proc. Eur. Conf. on Artificial Life, 2017, pp. 36 -- 43.
[33] H. Brown, R. A. Adams, I. Parees, M. Edwards, and K. Friston, "Ac-
tive inference, sensory attenuation and illusions," Cognitive processing,
vol. 14, no. 4, pp. 411 -- 427, 2013.
[34] A. G. Feldman, "New insights into action -- perception coupling," Exper-
imental Brain Research, vol. 194, no. 1, pp. 39 -- 58, 2009.
[35] -- -- , "Active sensing without efference copy: referent control of percep-
tion," Journal of neurophysiology, vol. 116, no. 3, pp. 960 -- 976, 2016.
[36] M. Baltieri and C. L. Buckley, "A probabilistic interpretation of pid
controllers using active inference," in From Animals to Animats 15,
P. Manoonpong, J. C. Larsen, X. Xiong, J. Hallam, and J. Triesch, Eds.
Springer International Publishing, 2018, pp. 15 -- 26.
[37] V. G. Rao and D. S. Bernstein, "Naive control of the double integrator,"
IEEE Control Systems, vol. 21, no. 5, pp. 86 -- 97, 2001.
[38] K. J. Astrom and R. M. Murray, Feedback systems: an introduction for
scientists and engineers. Princeton university press, 2010.
[39] G. L. Gottlieb, "A computational model of the simplest motor program,"
Journal of Motor behavior, vol. 25, no. 3, pp. 153 -- 161, 1993.
[40] E. von Holst and H. Mittelstaedt, "Das reafferenzprinzip," Naturwis-
senschaften, vol. 37, no. 20, pp. 464 -- 476, 1950.
[41] E. D. Sontag, "Adaptation and regulation with signal detection implies
internal model," Systems & control letters, vol. 50, no. 2, pp. 119 -- 126,
2003.
[42] T.-M. Yi, Y. Huang, M. I. Simon, and J. Doyle, "Robust perfect
adaptation in bacterial chemotaxis through integral feedback control,"
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 97, no. 9, pp.
4649 -- 4653, 2000.
[43] A. Clark, "Radical predictive processing," The Southern Journal of
Philosophy, vol. 53, no. S1, pp. 3 -- 27, 2015.
[44] W. T. Powers, Behavior: The control of perception. Aldine Chicago,
1973.
[45] A. Clark, Surfing Uncertainty: Prediction, Action, and the Embodied
Mind. Oxford University Press, 2015.
[46] K. Friston, C. Thornton, and A. Clark, "Free-energy minimization and
the dark-room problem," Frontiers in psychology, vol. 3, p. 130, 2012.
[47] M. Allen and K. J. Friston, "From cognitivism to autopoiesis: towards
a computational framework for the embodied mind," Synthese, vol. 195,
no. 6, pp. 2459 -- 2482, 2018.
[48] E. Ahissar and E. Assa, "Perception as a closed-loop convergence
process," Elife, vol. 5, p. e12830, 2016.
[49] L. Busse, J. A. Cardin, M. E. Chiappe, M. M. Halassa, M. J. McGinley,
T. Yamashita, and A. B. Saleem, "Sensation during active behaviors,"
Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 37, no. 45, pp. 10 826 -- 10 834, 2017.
[50] C. L. Buckley and T. Toyoizumi, "A theory of how active behavior
stabilises neural activity: Neural gain modulation by closed-loop envi-
ronmental feedback," PLoS computational biology, vol. 14, no. 1, p.
e1005926, 2018.
[51] J. W. Krakauer, A. A. Ghazanfar, A. Gomez-Marin, M. A. MacIver,
and D. Poeppel, "Neuroscience needs behavior: correcting a reductionist
bias," Neuron, vol. 93, no. 3, pp. 480 -- 490, 2017.
[52] F. Najafi and A. K. Churchland, "Perceptual decision-making: A field
in the midst of a transformation," Neuron, vol. 100, no. 2, pp. 453 -- 462,
2018.
[53] D. W. Franklin and D. M. Wolpert, "Computational mechanisms of
sensorimotor control," Neuron, vol. 72, no. 3, pp. 425 -- 442, 2011.
[54] H. Ritz, M. R. Nassar, M. J. Frank, and A. Shenhav, "A control
theoretic model of adaptive learning in dynamic environments," Journal
of cognitive neuroscience, pp. 1 -- 17, 2018.
[55] W. R. Ashby, An introduction to cybernetics. Chapman & Hall Ltd.,
1957.
|
1410.8799 | 3 | 1410 | 2015-10-13T11:50:55 | Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cond-mat.stat-mech"
] | A recent study on the effect of colored driving noise on the escape from a metastable state derives an analytic expression of the transfer function of the leaky integrate-and-fire neuron model subject to colored noise. Here we present an alternative derivation of the results, taking into account time-dependent boundary conditions explicitly. This systematic approach may facilitate future extensions beyond first order perturbation theory. The analogy of the quantum harmonic oscillator to the LIF neuron model subject to white noise enables a derivation of the well known transfer function simpler than the original approach. We offer a pedagogical presentation including all intermediate steps of the calculations. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary
conditions
Jannis Schuecker,1 Markus Diesmann,1, 2, 3 and Moritz Helias1, 3
1Institute of Neuroscience and Medicine (INM-6) and Institute for Advanced Simulation
(IAS-6) and JARA BRAIN Institute I, Jülich Research Centre, Jülich, Germany
2Department of Psychiatry, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics,
Medical Faculty, RWTH Aachen University, Aachen, Germany
3Department of Physics, Faculty 1, RWTH Aachen University, Aachen, Germany
(Dated: July 11, 2021)
A recent study on the effect of colored driving noise on the escape from a metastable state derives
an analytic expression of the transfer function of the leaky integrate-and-fire neuron model subject
to colored noise. Here we present an alternative derivation of the results, taking into account time-
dependent boundary conditions explicitly. This systematic approach may facilitate future extensions
beyond first order perturbation theory. The analogy of the quantum harmonic oscillator to the LIF
neuron model subject to white noise enables a derivation of the well known transfer function simpler
than the original approach. We offer a pedagogical presentation including all intermediate steps of
the calculations.
PACS numbers: 05.40.-a, 05.10.Gg, 87.19.La
1.
INTRODUCTION
In a recent study [1] we show that the effect of colored noise on the escape from a metastable state can be captured
by a parametric shift of the location of the boundary conditions for the probability density in the corresponding
effective system driven by white noise. We offer an alternative view of the effective white-noise system, explicitly
using a time-dependent boundary condition at the original location. To linear order in the perturbation parameter
k (cf. (1)) these two approaches are identical. While the shift of the boundary location is generic and applicable to
any arbitrary system at hand for which the white noise solution is available, the approach given here comes along
with additional calculations. In the application to the leaky integrate-and-fire (LIF) model neuron we first include
a complete and simplified derivation of the white-noise transfer function [2, 3] and subsequently present the colored
noise calculations in the alternative view.
2. EFFECTIVE DIFFUSION
Effective diffusion: a heuristic argument
Consider the pair of coupled stochastic differential equations (SDE) with a slow component y with time scale τ
driven by a fast Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process z with time scale τs. In dimensionless time s = t/τ and with k =pτs/τ
relating the two scales we have
z
k
∂sy = f (y, s) +
k∂sz = −
z
k
+ ξ,
(1)
with a unit variance white noise hξ(s + u) ξ(s)i = δ(u). We are interested in the case τs ≪ τ and start with a heuristic
argument on how to map the system of coupled SDEs to a single diffusion equation. The subsequent sections will
detail this mapping. The autocorrelation function of z is (see Appendix A)
with time scale k2 ∝ τs. Since y integrates z on a time scale τ ≫ τs, the effective quantity determining the variance
of y is the integral of the autocorrelation function of z
hz(s)z(s + s′)i =
e−s′/k2
1
2
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
e−s/k2
ds = k2.
Z 1
2
(2)
We can compare this result to the limit k → 0, i.e. the adiabatic approximation of (1), where z(s) follows ξ(s)
instantaneously. Thus z(s) = kξ(s) becomes a white noise with autocorrelation k2δ(s), yielding the same integral of
the autocorrelation as for finite τs (2). Therefore the slow component y effectively obeys the one-dimensional SDE
∂sy = f (y, s) + ξ(s).
Effective diffusion: a formal derivation
We will now formalize the preceding heuristic argument. In order to derive an effective one-dimensional diffusion
equation for the component y and to obtain a formulation in which we can include the treatment of absorbing boundary
conditions, we consider the Fokker-Planck equation [4] corresponding to (1)
k2∂sP = ∂z(cid:18) 1
2
∂z + z(cid:19) P − k2∂ySy P,
where P (y, z, s) denotes the probability density and
Sy = f (y, s) +
z
k
(3)
(4)
is the probability flux in y-direction. In order to obtain a perturbation expansion in terms of simple eigenfunctions
of the z-dependent fast part of the Fokker-Planck operator, we factor-off its stationary solution so that P (y, z, s) =
Q(y, z, s) e−z2
√π . Inserting the product into (3), the chain rule suggests the definition of a new differential operator L
acting on Q by observing
∂ze−z2
and
2
(cid:18) 1
∂z(cid:18) 1
2
so compactly
∂z + z(cid:19) e−z2
∂z + z(cid:19) e−z2
◦ = e−z2
◦ = e−z2(cid:18) 1
◦ = e−z2 (cid:18) 1
(∂z − 2z) ◦
∂z − z + z(cid:19)◦ = e−z2 1
∂z − z(cid:19) ∂z◦ ≡ e−z2
2
2
L ◦ .
∂z ◦
2
Expressed in L the Fokker-Planck equation (3) transforms to
k2∂sQ = LQ − kz∂yQ − k2∂y f (y, s) Q.
(5)
(6)
In the following we refer to Q as the outer solution, since initially we do not consider the boundary conditions. We
√π Q(y, z, s) that is correct
up to linear order in k. This is equivalent to knowing the first order correction to the marginalized probability flux
√π SyQ(y, z, s). Due to the form of (4) this requires calculation of Q up to second order in k. In
addition we keep only those terms that contribute to the zeroth and first order of νy(y, s). Inserting the perturbation
ansatz
aim at an effective Fokker-Planck equation for the z-marginalized solution P (y, s) =R dz e−z2
νy(y, s) ≡ R dz e−z2
into (6) we obtain
Q(y, z, s) =
2
Xn=0
kn Q(n)(y, z, s) + O(k3)
LQ(0) = 0
LQ(1) = z∂yQ(0)
LQ(2) = ∂sQ(0) + z∂yQ(1) + ∂yf Q(0).
2
(7)
(8)
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
Noting the property Lzn = 1
2 n(n− 1)zn−2 − nzn, we see that the lowest order does not imply any further constraints
on the z-independent solution Q(0)(y, s), which must be consistent with the solution to the one-dimensional Fokker-
Planck equation corresponding to the limit k → 0 of (1). With Lz = −z the particular solution for the first order
is
Q(1)(y, z, s) = Q(1)
0 (y, s) − z∂yQ(0)(y, s),
(9)
where we have the freedom to choose a function Q(1)
0 (y, s) so far not constrained further except being independent
of z, due to L 1 = 0. To generate the term linear in z on the right hand side of the second order in (8), we need a
term −z∂yQ(1). The terms constant in z require contributions proportional to z2, because Lz2 = −2z2 + 1. However,
they can be dropped right away, because terms ∝ k2z2 only contribute to the correction of the flux in order of k2,
while their contribution to the first order resulting from the application of the ∝ k−1 term in (4) vanishes after
marginalization. For the same reason the homogeneous solution Q(2)
0 (y, s) can be dropped. Hence the relevant part
of the second order solution is
Q(2)(y, z, s) = −z∂yQ(1)(y, s) + terms causing νy ∝ O(k2).
Inserting (9), we also omit the term z2∂2
y Q(0) as it is again ∝ k2z2 and are left with
Q(y, z, s) = Q(0)(y, s) + kQ(1)
0 (y, s) − kz∂yQ(0)(y, s) − k2z∂yQ(1)
0 (y, s) + terms causing νy ∝ O(k2).
(10)
Calculating the resulting flux marginalized over the fast variable z amounts to deriving the form of the effective flux
operator acting on the slow, y-dependent component. With (10) this results in
SyQ
νy(y, s) = Z dz
e−z2
√π
= (cid:18)f (y, s) −
√π = 1 and R dz z2e−z2
√π = 1
where we used R dz e−z2
dimensional system driven by unit variance white noise and
1
2
∂y(cid:19)(cid:16)Q(0)(y, s) + kQ(1)
2 . We recognize that f (y, s) − 1
0 (y, s)(cid:17) + O(k2),
(11)
2 ∂y is the flux operator of a one-
P (y, s) ≡ Q(0)(y, s) + kQ(1)
0 (y, s)
(12)
corresponds to the marginalization of the relevant terms in (10) over z, whereby the terms linear in z vanish. Note
that in (10) the higher order terms in k appear due to the operator kz∂y in (6) that couples the z and y coordinate.
Eq. (11) shows that these terms cause an effective flux that only depends on the z-marginalized solution P (y, s).
This allows us to obtain the time evolution by applying the continuity equation to the effective flux (11) yielding the
effective Fokker-Planck equation
∂s P = −∂yνy(y, s)
= ∂y(cid:18)−f (y, s) +
1
2
∂y(cid:19) P .
(13)
For specific boundary conditions given by the physics of the system, we need to determine the corresponding boundary
condition for the marginalized density. This amounts to determining the boundary condition for Q(1)
0 , because we
assume the one-dimensional white noise problem to be exactly solvable and hence the boundary value of Q(0) to be
known. Effective Fokker-Planck equations have been derived earlier [5 -- 9], but these approaches have been criticized
for lacking a proper treatment of the boundary conditions [10]. In the framework introduced in [10 -- 12], boundary
conditions are deduced using boundary layer theory for the two-dimensional Fokker-Planck equation. In the next
section we extend this framework to the transient case.
Effective boundary conditions
For the dynamics (1) with an absorbing boundary at y = θ, the flux vanishes for all points (θ, z) along the border
k < 0. Thus, the boundary condition lives on a half
with negative velocity in y-direction; these are given by f (θ, s) + z
3
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
line in y, z-space. This suggests, a translation of the z coordinate to
so that Sy = f (y, s) − f (θ, s) + z
condition at threshold then takes the form
k is the flux operator in y-direction (4) in the new coordinate z. The boundary
z + kf (θ, s) → z,
(14)
and it follows that
0 =
z
k
Q(θ, z, s) ∀z < 0
Q(θ, z, s) = 0 ∀z < 0.
(15)
(16)
If, after absorption by the boundary, the system is reset to a smaller value by assigning y ← R, this corresponds to
the flux escaping at threshold being re-inserted at reset. The corresponding boundary condition is
νy(θ, z, s) = SyQ(θ, z, s) = Sy (Q(R+, z, s) − Q(R−, z, s)) .
With (15) it follows that
(cid:16)f (R, z, s) − f (θ, z, s) +
from which we conclude
z
k(cid:17) (Q(R+, z, s) − Q(R−, z, s)) = 0 ∀z < 0,
0 = Q(R+, z, s) − Q(R−, z, s)
∀z < 0.
(17)
This boundary conditions allows a non-continuous marginalized solution at reset and enables us to deduce the value
for the jump of the marginalized density (12). Due to the time dependence of the coordinate z (14) the Fokker-Planck
equation (3) with the time derivative of the density ∂sP (y, z(s), s) = ∂sP − k(∂sf (θ, s)) ∂zP transforms to
k2∂sP = ∂z(
1
2
∂z + z − kf (θ, s)) P − k2∂y(f (y, s) − f (θ, s) +
z
k
)P − k3 ∂sf (θ, s)∂zP.
With P = Q e−z2
√π we obtain
k2∂sQ = LQ − kz∂yQ
+k [f (θ, s)(2z − ∂z) − k∂y (f (y, s) − f (θ, s))] Q
+k3 (∂sf (θ, s))(2z − ∂z)Q.
(18)
(19)
The last term originating from the time dependence of f is of third order in k and will therefore be neglected in the
following. To derive the boundary condition for the effective diffusion, we need to describe the behavior of the original
system near these boundaries by transforming to either of the two shifted and scaled coordinates r = y−{θ,R}
. To
treat the reset condition analogously to the condition at threshold, we introduce two auxiliary functions Q+ and Q−:
here Q+ is a continuous solution of (19) on the whole domain and, above reset, agrees to the solution that obeys the
boundary condition at reset. Correspondingly, the continuous solution Q− agrees to the searched-for solution below
reset. Due to linearity of (19) also
k
QB(r, z, s) ≡ (Q(y(r), z, s)
Q+(y(r), z, s) − Q−(y(r), z, s) ≡ ∆Q(y(r), z, s)
at threshold
at reset
is a solution. With this definition, the two boundary conditions (16) and (17) take the same form QB(0, z, s) =
0 ∀z < 0. The coordinate r zooms into the region near the boundary and changes the order in k of the interaction
term −kz∂yQ between the y and the z component from first to zeroth order, namely
k2∂sQB = LQB − z∂rQB
+k [f (θ, s)(2z − ∂z) − ∂r (f (kr + {θ, R}, s) − f (θ, s))] QB + O(k3).
(20)
4
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
With a perturbation ansatz in k, i.e. QB =P1
n=0 knQB(n) + O(k2), we obtain
LQB(0) − z∂rQB(0) = 0
LQB(1) − z∂rQB(1) = [f (θ, s)(2z − ∂z) − ∂r (f (kr + {θ, R}, s) − f (θ, s))] QB(0).
(21)
(22)
The boundary layer solution must match the outer solution. Since the outer solution varies only weakly on the length
scale of r, a first order Taylor expansion of the outer solution at the boundary yields the matching condition
QB(r, z, s) = (Q(θ, z, s) + kr ∂yQ(θ, z, s)
∆Q(R, z, s) + kr ∂y∆Q(R, z, s) at reset.
at threshold
To zeroth order in k we hence have
QB(0)(0, z, s) = 0,
(23)
(24)
because the white noise system with k = 0 has a vanishing density at threshold and is continuous at reset. Together
with the homogeneous partial differential equation (21) this implies QB(0) = 0 everywhere. To perform the matching
of the first order of (23) we need to express the outer solution in the shifted coordinate z (14). The first order of the
perturbation expansion (7) of the outer solution expressed in the new coordinate (14) has a vanishing correction term
f (θ, s) ∂Q(0)(y,s)
= 0. We can therefore insert (9) into (23) to obtain
∂z
QB(1)(r, z, s) = (Q(1)
0 (θ, s) − z∂yQ(0)(θ, s) + r∂yQ(0)(θ, s)
∆Q(1)
0 (R, s) − z∂y∆Q(0)(R, s) + r∂y∆Q(0)(R, s)
at threshold
at reset.
At threshold (25) can be simplified to
y (s) (z − r),
where we again exploit that Q(0)(θ, s) = 0 in the white noise system and therefore
0 (θ, s) + 2ν(0)
QB(1)(r, z, s) = Q(1)
∂yQ(0)(θ, s) = −2(−
1
2
∂y + f (θ, s)) Q(0)(θ, s) = −2ν(0)
y (θ, s).
(25)
(26)
(27)
. Here ν(0)
y (θ, s) is the instantaneous flux at the boundary of the white noise system. At reset (25) takes the form
QB(1)(r, z, s) = ∆Q(1)
0 (R, s) + 2ν(0)
y (θ, s) (z − r),
(28)
where we again use the continuity ∆Q(0)(R, s) = Q(0)(y, s)(cid:12)(cid:12)
∂y∆Q(0)(R, s) = ∂yQ(0)(y, s)(cid:12)(cid:12)
= −2ν(0)
y=R+
y=R−
y (θ, s) .
y=R+
y=R−
= 0 of the white noise system at reset and therefore
Using (24) the first order solution (22) must satisfy
Half-range expansion
With the definitions v = √2r, w = √2z, and g(v, w, s) = QB(1)(r, z, s), equation (29) takes the form
LQB(1) − z∂rQB(1) = 0.
(29)
Note that the time argument plays the role of a parameter here, since the time derivatives in (19) and (20) are of
higher order in k. With the absorbing boundary condition g(0, w, s) = 0 for w < 0, following at threshold from (16)
(∂2
w − w∂w) g(v, w, s) = w∂vg(v, w, s).
5
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
and at reset from (17), the solution not growing faster than linear in v → −∞ is given by Kłosek and Hagan [10,
B.11]
g(v, w, s) =
C(s)
√2 α
√2
+ w − v + √2
bn(w/√2) e√nv!
(30)
∞Xn=1
with α = √2ζ( 1
2 ) given by Riemann's ζ-function and bn proportional to the n-th Hermitian polynomial. The constant
α defined here follows the notation used in Fourcaud and Brunel [12] and differs by a factor of √2 from the notation
in Kłosek and Hagan [10, B.11]. At threshold and in the original coordinates we equate (30) to (26) which reads
∞Xn=1
The term proportional to (z − r) fixes the time dependent function C(s) = 2ν(0)
y (θ, s) (z − r) = C(s) α
0 (y, s) + 2ν(0)
+ z − r +
Q(1)
2
y (θ, s). The exponential term on the
right hand side has no equivalent term on the left hand side. It varies on a small length scale inside the boundary layer,
while the terms on the left hand side originate from the outer solution, varying on a larger length scale. Therefore
the exponential term can not be taken into account and the term proportional to α fixes the boundary value
bn(z) e
√2nr! .
At reset we equate (30) and (28) and consider the left-sided limit y ↑ R ensuring r < 0, which is sufficient to determine
the value of ∆Q(R, s). We obtain
Q(1)
0 (θ, s) = αν(0)
y (θ, s).
(31)
∆Q(1)
0 (R, s) + 2ν(0)
y (θ, s) (z − r) = C(s) α
2
bn(z) e
√2nr! ,
so that we find the jump of the outer solution at reset ∆Q(1)
0 (R, s) = Q(1)
= αν(0)
y (θ, s). This concludes the
central argument of the general theory: The effective Fokker-Planck equation (13) has the time-dependent boundary
conditions
P (θ, s) = Q(0)(θ, s)
+kQ(1)
0 (θ, s) = kαν(0)
y (θ, s)
(32)
+ z − r +
∞Xn=1
0 (y, s)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
y=R+
y=R−
R+
R−
P (y, s)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
=0
}
{z
= Q(0)(y, s)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
{z
=0
R+
R−
}
+k Q(1)
0 (y, s)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
R+
R−
= kαν(0)
y (θ, s),
reducing the colored noise problem to the solution of a one-dimensional Fokker-Planck equation, for which standard
methods are available [4].
Shifted reset and threshold
Kłosek and Hagan [10], Fourcaud and Brunel [12, B.11] stated that the steady state density in the colored noise
case can be interpreted as the solution to the stationary white noise problem with shifted threshold θ = θ + k α
2 and
reset R = R + k α
2 . We formally show that to first order in k the dynamic boundary conditions (32) found for the
time-dependent problem can as well be expressed as a shift of the boundaries. We perform a Taylor expansion of the
effective density at θ
P (θ, s)
=
=
, s)
P (θ + k
α
2
P (θ, s) + k
α
2
(32) and (27)
=
kαν(0)
y (θ, s) − k
=
O(k2),
6
∂y P (θ, s) + O(k2)
α
2
2ν(0)
y (θ, s) + O(k2)
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
where in the second last step we used that the derivative ∂y P (θ, s) with (27) can be written as 2ν(0)
2f (θ, s) P (θ, s) = 2ν(0)
For the reset we have
y (θ, s) + O(k).
y (θ, s) −
R+
R−
P (y, s)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
= P (y, s)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
(32)
= kαν(0)
R+
R−
+ k
y (θ, s) + k
+ O(k2)
+ O(k2)
R+
R−
∂y P (y, s)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
∂y Q(0)(y, s)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
α
2
α
2
α
2
R+
R−
= kαν(0)
y (θ, s) + k
∂yQ(0)(θ, s) + O(k2)
= O(k2),
where we used that the white noise density is continuous at reset and the flux at threshold ν(0)
2 ∂y Q(0)(θ, s)
. We conclude that the colored noise dynamic boundary
conditions (32) are equivalent to white noise boundary conditions at shifted threshold and reset. This view is pursued
in [1], while in the following sections we derive the colored-noise correction explicitly using the time-dependent colored-
noise boundary condition (32).
is reinserted at reset, e.g ∂y Q(0)(θ, s) = ∂y Q(0)(y, s)(cid:12)(cid:12)
y (θ, s) = − 1
R+
R−
3. EXAMPLE: LIF NEURON MODEL
We now apply the general formalism to the leaky integrate-and-fire (LIF) neuron model, revealing a novel analytical
expression for the transfer function for the case that the synaptic noise is filtered. Previous work shows that this
correction vanishes in the case of the perfect integrate-and-fire model Fourcaud and Brunel [12, p. 2077] in the low
frequency domain.
The LIF model: the harmonic oscillator of neuroscience
The membrane potential V of the LIF neuron model without synaptic filtering (white noise) evolves according to
the differential equation
where τ is the membrane time constant and the input is described by mean µ and variance σ2 in diffusion approxi-
mation. If V reaches the threshold θ the membrane potential is reset to a smaller value V ← R. The corresponding
Fokker-Planck equation is
τ V = −V + µ + σ√τ ξ(t),
(33)
∂tP (V, t) = −∂V ϕ(V, t)
ϕ(V, t) ≡ (cid:18)−
1
τ
(V − µ) −
1
2
σ2
τ
∂V(cid:19) P (V, t).
In dimensionless coordinates it takes the form
∂sρ(x, s) = −∂x (−x − ∂x)
}
{z
≡S0
ρ(x, s) ≡ L0 ρ(x, s),
σ , s = t/τ , ρ(x, s) ≡ σ√2
where x = √2 V −µ
P (V, t) and S0 is the probability flux operator. The Fokker-Planck operator
L0 is not Hermitian. However, we can transform the operator to a Hermitian form, for which standard solutions
are available. We therefore follow Risken [4, p. 134, eq. 6.9] and apply a transformation that is possible whenever
the Fokker-Planck equation possesses a stationary solution ¯ρ0 (here ¯ρ0 = e− x2
threshold and reset are absent). We define a function u(x) = e− 1
is the stationary solution of (35) if
4 x2
2
=p¯ρ0(x) and observe that it fulfills the following
(34)
(35)
7
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
relations
Here we defined the operators
that fulfill the commutation relation
∂xu(x)◦ = u(x) (−
(x + ∂x)u(x)◦ = u(x) (
1
2
1
2
x + ∂x)
◦
}
◦.
≡−a†
x + ∂x)
{z
{z
≡a
}
a ≡
a† ≡
1
2
1
2
x + ∂x
x − ∂x = x − a
[a, a†] = aa† − a†a = 1.
Hence, writing ρ(x, s) = u(x) q(x, s), the flux operator S0 and the Fokker-Planck operator L0 transform to
The Fokker-Planck equation (35) can then be expressed in terms of a† and a as
S0 u◦ = (−x − ∂x) u◦ = −ua ◦
L0 u◦ = ∂x(x + ∂x) u◦ = −ua†a ◦ .
∂sq(x, s) = −a†a q(x, s)
x2 +
= (∂2
1
4
x −
1
2
) q(x, s).
(36)
(37)
(38)
(39)
(40)
The right hand side is the Hamiltonian of the quantum harmonic oscillator. Note, however, that the i is missing on
the left hand side. The operator now is Hermitian and the eigenfunctions of a†a form a complete orthogonal set. In
) is constant
the stationary case, the probability flux between reset xR and threshold xθ (with x{θ,R} = √2{θ,R}−µ
(τ ν0), whereas it vanishes below xR and above xθ. With (39) the flux takes the form
σ
The homogeneous solution a qh = (∂x + 1
noise boundary condition q0(xθ) = 0 is
− ua q0 = τ ν0 H(x − xR)H(xθ − x).
2 x) qh(x) = 0 is qh(x) = u(x). Hence, the full solution satisfying the white
(41)
q0(x) = τ ν0 u(x) Z xθ
4 Z xθ
= τ ν0 e− x2
max(x,xR)
max(x,xR)
u−1(x′)u−1(x′) dx′
x′2
2 dx′.
e
Consequently, the solution in terms of the density ρ is ρ0(x) = u(x) q0(x) = τ ν0 e− x2
with [13, eq. 19]. We determine the (as yet arbitrary) constant ν0 from the normalization condition 1 =R ρ(x) dx as
max(x,xR) e
2 R xθ
(42)
x′2
2 dx′, in agreement
−∞
(τ ν0)−1 =Z xθ
=Z xθ
= 2Z yθ
−∞
−∞
ρ(x) dx
e− x
2
e−y2
2Z xθ
{z}f′ Z yθ
8
x′2
2 dx′ dx
e
eu2
du
dy,
max(x,xR)
max(y,yR)
g
{z
}
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
where in the last step we substituted y = x/√2 and u = x′/√2. Using integration by parts with f (y) =R y
√π
2 (1 + erf(y)) and g′(y) = −ey2
f (−∞) = 0 we have
dx =
H(y − yR) and noting that the boundary term vanishes, because g(yθ) = 0 and
e−x2
−∞
(τ ν0)−1 = √πZ yθ
yR
(1 + erf(y)) ey2
dy.
(43)
This is the formula originally found by Siegert for the mean-first-passage time determining the firing rate ν0 [13, 14].
The higher eigenfunctions of L0u (39) are obtained by repeated application of a†, as the commutation relation
[a, a†] = 1 holds and hence
a†a(a†)nq0 = a†(a†a + [a, a†])(a†)n−1q0
= a†(a†a + 1)(a†)n−1q0
= . . .
= (a†)n(a†a + n)q0 = n(a†)nq0.
(44)
So the spectrum of the operator is discrete and specified by the set of integer numbers n ∈ N0.
Stationary firing rate for colored noise
Let us now consider a leaky integrate-and-fire model neuron with synaptic filtering, i.e. the system of coupled
differential equations in diffusion approximation [12]
τ V = −V + I + µ
τs I = −I + σ√τ ξ(t).
(45)
τ(cid:1) = hξ(s + u
The general system (1) can be obtained from (45) by introducing the coordinates z = k
σ I, setting f (y, s) = −y, and
observing that the rescaling of the time axis s = t/τ cancels a factor √τ in front of the noise, because h√τ ξ(t +
u)√τ ξ(t)i = τ δ(u) = δ(cid:0) u
Using again x = √2y, and the marginalized density ρ(x, s) = 1√2
(46)
P (x/√2, s), the effective reduced system (13) is the
white noise case (40) with the boundary conditions deduced from the half range expansion (32). As in the white noise
case (41) we solve
τ )ξ(s)i. The corresponding two-dimensional Fokker-Planck equation is (3)
k2∂sP = ∂z(
z
k
) P.
1
2
∂z + z) P − k2∂y(−y +
where ν denotes the colored noise firing rate. With the homogeneous solution u the general solution is given by
− ua q0(x) = τ ν H(x − xR)H(xθ − x),
uq0 = (uq+ ≡ D+u2 + uqp
uq− ≡ D−u2
for xR < x < xθ
for x < xR
with the particular solution of (47) for xR < x < xθ chosen to vanish at threshold
uqp = τ ν u2(x)Z xθ
x
u−2dx′.
(47)
(48)
The constants D+ and D− are fixed by the boundary conditions (32). With the stationary flux ν(0)
white noise system we get
y = τ ν0 in the
u(xθ)q+(xθ) = D+u2(xθ) =
1
√2
u(xR)q+(xR) − u(xR)q−(xR) = A.
kατ ν0 ≡ A
9
(49)
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
Thus we have D+ = Au−2(xθ) and D− can be determined as
D+u2(xθ) = A = u(xR)q+(xR) − u(xR)q−(xR)
= (D+ − D−)u2(xR) + τ ν u2(xR)Z xθ
⇔ D− = A(cid:0)u−2(xθ) − u−2(xR)(cid:1) + τ νZ xθ
xR
xR
u−2 dx
u−2 dx.
The firing rate ν is determined by the normalization condition
1 = Z xθ
= Z xR
−∞
∞
uq dx
uq− dx +Z xθ
xR
uq+ dx.
Inserting (48) with D+ and D− suggests the introduction of
F (x)
and
I
=
=
=
=
int. by parts
=
From (51) we obtain
2 x′2
−∞
−∞
e− 1
u2 dx′
(1 + erf(
Z x
Z x
r π
u2Z xθ
Z xθ
−F (xR) Z xθ
xR
xR
2
x
dx′
x
√2
))
u−2 dx′dx
u−2 dx′ +Z xθ
xR
F (x) u−2(x) dx.
1 = A(cid:0)u−2(xθ) − u−2(xR)(cid:1) F (xR) + Au−2(xθ) (F (xθ) − F (xR)) + τ ν F (xR)Z xθ
= A u−2(x)F (x)(cid:12)(cid:12)
+ τ ν Z xθ
u−2(x)F (x) dx,
xθ
xR
xR
xR
so that
Furthermore the firing rate without synaptic filtering ν0 can be expressed as
τ ν =
xθ
xR
u−2F dx
1 − A u−2F(cid:12)(cid:12)
R xθ
xR
.
With (49) we have
τ ν0 =
1
u−2F dx
.
xR
R xθ
τ ν = τ ν0 − τ ν0
= τ ν0 −
αk
√2
xR
xθ
xR
u−2F dx
αk
√2
u−2F(cid:12)(cid:12)
R xθ
u−2F(cid:12)(cid:12)
(cid:16)R xθ
u−2F dx(cid:17)2
xθ
xR
xR
10
(50)
(51)
(52)
(53)
u−2 dx + τ ν I
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
and finally determined the first order correction ν1 of the perturbation ansatz ν = ν0 + kν1 + O(k2) in agreement with
Fourcaud and Brunel [12]. Up to linear order in k this is equivalent to
τ ν = Z xθ+ αk
xR+ αk
√2
√2
u−2F dx!−1
(54)
as shown by Taylor expansion of the latter expression up to linear order in k. Comparison of (54) to the white noise
case (52) shows that we can reformulate (32) as a shift of the locations of the white noise boundaries by αk√2
, as found
in Kłosek and Hagan [10] for the static case.
White noise transfer function
We now simplify the derivation of the transfer function of the LIF neuron model for white noise [2, 3] by exploiting
the analogy to the quantum harmonic oscillator introduced above. Consider a periodic modulation of the mean input
in (33)
and the variance
µ(t) = µ + δµ(t)
δµ(t) = ǫµeiωt
σ2(t) = σ2 + δσ(t)2
δσ(t)2 = Hσ2eiωt.
(55)
To linear order this will result in a modulation of the firing rate ν0(t) = ν0(1 + n(ω)eiωt), where n(ω) is the transfer
function. Note that both modulations δµ and δσ have their own contribution to n(ω) and in principle could be treated
separately since we only determine the linear response here. For brevity we consider them simultaneously here. The
time dependent Fokker-Planck equation takes the form
∂tP (V, t) = −∂V (ϕ(V, t) + δϕ(V, t))
δϕ(V, t) = (cid:18) δµ(t)
τ −
∂V(cid:19) P (V, t)
δσ2(t)
2τ
or, in the natural coordinates
∂sρ(x, s) = L0(x)ρ(x, s)
{z
Here, G = √2ǫµ/σ and we defined the perturbation operator L1(x).
+ eiωτ s (−G ∂x + H∂2
x)
}
≡L1(x)
ρ(x, s).
(56)
Perturbative treatment of the time-dependent Fokker-Planck equation
For small amplitudes n(ω) ≪ 1, so weak modulations of the rate compared to the stationary baseline rate, we
employ the ansatz of a perturbation series, namely that the time-dependent solution of (56) is in the vicinity of the
stationary solution, ρ(x, s) = ρ0(x) + ρ1(x, s), with the correction ρ1 of linear order in the perturbing quantities δµ(t)
and δσ(t). Inserting this ansatz into (56) and using the property of the stationary solution L0ρ0 = 0 we are left with
an inhomogeneous partial differential equation for the unknown function ρ1
∂sρ1(x, s) = L0(x)ρ1(x, s) + eiωτ s L1(x)ρ0(x)
+ eiωτ sL1(x)ρ1(x, s).
(57)
11
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
Neglecting the third term that is of second order in the perturbed quantities, the separation ansatz ρ1(x, s) =
ρ1(x) eiωτ s (for brevity we drop the ω-dependence of ρ1(x)) then leads to the linear ordinary inhomogeneous differential
equation of second order
From here the operator representation introduced in Section 3 guides us to the solution. Writing ρ1(x) = u(x) q1(x)
and with the commutation relation (36) ∂xu(x)◦ = −u(x) a†◦ the transformed inhomogeneity takes the form '
iωτ ρ1 = L0ρ1 + L1ρ0.
L1u q0 = −∂x (G − H ∂x)
}
= u a†(G + H a†) q0,
u q0
≡S1
{z
(58)
where we defined the contribution of the perturbation to the flux operator as S1. With L0uq1 = −ua†aq1 we need to
solve the equation
(iωτ + a†a) q1 = (G a† + H (a†)2) q0.
(59)
Since the equation is linear in q1, its solution is a superposition of a particular solution and a homogeneous solution.
The latter needs to be chosen such that the full solution complies with the boundary conditions but we first need to
find the particular solution. To this end we will use the property (44). For n = 1 and n = 2 we have
a†a (a†q0) = a†q0
and
a†a ((a†)2q0) = 2(a†)2q0.
Hence a term proportional to a†q0 reproduces the first part of the inhomogeneity in (59) and a term proportional to
(a†)2q0 generates the second term. We therefore use qp = (γa† + β(a†)2) q0 as the ansatz for the particular solution
and determine the coefficients γ and β by inserting into (59), which yields
iωτ (γa† + β(a†)2) q0 + (γa† + 2β(a†)2) q0 = (G a† + H (a†)2) q0.
Sorting by terms according to powers of a†, we obtain two equations determining γ, β
(iωτ γ + γ − G) a†q0 = 0
(iωτ β + 2β − H) (a†)2q0 = 0,
where the factor in parenthesis must be nought, because neither a†q0(x) nor (a†)2q0(x) vanish for all x. This leaves
us with the particular solution
qp = (cid:18) G
1 + iωτ
a†q0 +
H
2 + iωτ
(a†)2q0(cid:19) .
(60)
above the ground state, because the two terms are proportional to a†q0 and (cid:0)a†(cid:1)2
This equation together with (44) shows that the perturbed solution consists of the first and the second excited state
q0. Thus the modulation of the
input to the neuron is equivalent to exciting the harmonic oscillator to higher energy states. Since only the ground
state is a stationary solution, it is intuitively clear that the response of the neuron relaxes back after some time, in
analogy to the return from the exited states.
The homogeneous equation follows from (59)
Homogeneous solution
Evaluating a†a yields
(iωτ + a†a) qh = 0.
(61)
(−∂2
x +
1
4
x2 + iωτ −
1
2
) qh = 0,
12
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
which can be rearranged to the form
∂2
xqh − (
1
4
x2 + m) qh = 0
with m = iωτ −
1
2
,
(62)
the solution of which can be written as a linear combination of two parabolic cylinder functions [15, 12.2]. The
x−m− 1
function U (m, x) = D−m− 1
for x → −∞ [16, 19.8.1]. The other independent solution V (m, x) ∝ e
2 is divergent for x → ∞, so that
u(x) V (m, x) ∝ x−1+iωτ is due to the logarithmic divergence not integrable on (−∞, 0). The contribution of V (m, x)
therefore needs to vanish in order to arrive at a normalizable density. Due to the boundary conditions, we distinguish
two different domains
4 x2
(x) of Whittaker [16, 19.3.1/2] has the asymptotic behavior U (m, x) ∝ e− 1
xm− 1
1
4 x2
2
2
q1(x) = qp(x) +(c1−U (x)
c1+U (x) + c2+V (x)
for x < xR
for xR ≤ x < xθ.
(63)
In the following we skip the dependence of the parabolic cylinder function on m for brevity of the notation. The
homogeneous solution (i.e. the coefficients c1,2±) adjusts the complete solution q1 = qp +qh to the boundary conditions
dictated by the physics of the problem.
Boundary condition for the modulated density
The complete solution q1 = qh + qp of (59) must fulfill the white noise boundary conditions
q1(xθ) = 0
q1(xR+) − q1(xR−) = 0
at threshold
at reset ,
(64)
whereby it must vanish at threshold to ensure a finite probability flux and be continuous at reset for the same reason.
Introducing the short hand
f (x)x′ = (f (x′)
f (x′+) − f (x′−)
for x′ = xθ
for x′ = xR
(65)
we state these two conditions compactly as
q1(x){xR,xθ}
= 0.
To determine the boundary values of the homogeneous solution we need the boundary values of the particular solution
first. The latter follow with (37) and the stationary flux (41)
a†q0(cid:12)(cid:12){xR,xθ}
(37)
= (x − a) q0{xR,xθ}
(41)
= u−1({xR, xθ}) τ ν0,
(66)
where the term xq0 vanishes because of the continuity of q0. Along the same lines follows the term proportional to
(a†)2q0
(a†)2q0 = (x − a)a†q0
= (xa† − [a, a†] − a†a)q0
= (xa† − 1)q0.
(38)
With (66) and the continuity of q0 we therefore have
(a†)2q0(cid:12)(cid:12){xR,xθ}
= {xR, xθ}u−1({xR, xθ}) τ ν0.
(67)
13
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
From the explicit expression of the particular solution (60) with the term proportional to a†q0 specified by (66), the
term proportional to (a†)2q0 by (67) and the continuity of the complete solution (64) then follows the initial value for
the homogeneous solution as
− qh{xR,xθ}
= qp{xR,xθ}
= (cid:18) G
1 + iωτ
+
H
2 + iωτ {xR, xθ}(cid:19) τ ν0 u−1({xR, xθ}).
(68)
Boundary condition for the derivative of the density
The boundary condition for the first derivative of q1 follows considering the probability flux: The flux at threshold
must be equal to the flux re-inserted at reset. Given the firing rate follows the periodic modulation ν0(t) = ν0(1 +
n(ω)eiωt), we can express the flux τ ν0 n(ω) due to the perturbation (the stationary solution fulfills S0uq0{xR,xθ}
=
−ua q0{xR,xθ}
= τ ν0) as a sum of two contributions, corresponding to the first two terms in (57)
Again we first evaluate the contribution of the particular solution (60) considering
τ ν0 n(ω) = S0uq1 + S1uq0{xR,xθ}
= −ua q1 + u(G + Ha†)q0(cid:12)(cid:12){xR,xθ}
.
(69)
Analogously follows
a a†q0
(38)
= (1 + a†a)q0
= q0 + a†aq0
.
{z}=0
a (a†)2q0 = 2a†q0,
so that the flux due to the particular solution (60) can be written as
− ua qp = −u(cid:18) G
1 + iωτ
+
2H
2 + iωτ
a†(cid:19) q0.
(70)
As the stationary solution vanishes at threshold q0(xθ) = 0 and is continuous at reset, the first term vanishes when
inserted into (69). Hence with (66) the contribution to the flux (69) yields
−ua qp{xR,xθ}
= −
2Hτ ν0
2 + iωτ
.
With (66) the term due to the perturbed flux operator S1 in (69) is
Inserting the previous two expressions into (69) we obtain
u (G + Ha†)q0(cid:12)(cid:12){xR,xθ}
= H τ ν0.
τ ν0 n(ω) = τ ν0
iωτ H
2 + iωτ − uaqh{xR,xθ}
2 + iωτ − n(ω)(cid:19) ,
= τ ν0(cid:18) iωτ H
where we used the explicit form of a = 1
2 x + ∂x. The derivative then follows as
⇔ u(
1
2
x + ∂x)qh(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12){xR,xθ}
= τ ν0(cid:18) iωτ H
14
∂xqh{xR,xθ}
2 + iωτ − n(ω)(cid:19) u−1({xR, xθ}) −
1
2
xqh(x)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12){xR,xθ}
(71)
(72)
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
and with (68) we obtain
∂xqh{xR,xθ}
2 + iωτ − n(ω) +
= τ ν0(cid:18) iωτ H
= τ ν0(cid:18)−n(ω) +
1
+
H
2{xR, xθ}(cid:18) G
+(cid:18) 1
1 + iωτ
2 + iωτ {xR, xθ}(cid:19)(cid:19) u−1({xR, xθ})
2 + iωτ(cid:19) u−1({xR, xθ}).
2{xR, xθ}2 + iωτ(cid:19) H
1 + iωτ
G
1
2{xR, xθ}
(73)
Transfer function
Having found the function value and the derivative at threshold, the homogeneous solution (of the second order
differential equation) is uniquely determined on xR < x < xθ. Writing the solution on this interval as
the coefficients follow as the solution of this linear system of equations, which is in matrix form
U (xθ) c1+ + V (xθ) c2+ = qh
U′(xθ) c1+ + V ′(xθ) c2+ = ∂xqh
1 (xθ)
1 (xθ),
The solution is
U′(xθ) V ′(xθ)(cid:19)(cid:18) c1+
(cid:18) U (xθ) V (xθ)
c2+ (cid:19) = (cid:18) qh(xθ)
∂xqh(xθ)(cid:19) .
−U′ U (cid:19)(cid:18) qh
1 (xθ)
1 (xθ)(cid:19)
∂xqh
1
c2+ (cid:19) =
(cid:18) c1+
W = det(cid:18) U V
W (xθ)(cid:18) V ′ −V
U′ V ′ (cid:19) ,
with
(74)
where the function W (x) is the Wronskian and for the given functions U, V is a constant W =q 2
coefficients follow from the previous expression using (68) and (73) and c2+ is hence
π [16, 19.4.1]. The
c2+ = r π
2
u−1(xθ)τ ν0(cid:18)U′(xθ) (cid:18) G
1 + iωτ
+U (xθ) (cid:18)−n(ω) +(cid:18) 1
2
xθ
G
1 + iωτ
+ (
1
2
+ xθ
H
2 + iωτ(cid:19)
x2
θ + iωτ )
H
2 + iωτ(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19) .
(75)
An analog expression holds for c1+, which is, however, not needed in the following, because we just need a condition
for the solvability. As the function V is absent in the lower interval x < xR, the boundary condition at reset also
determines c2+, as seen in the following. Expressing the solution in terms of U and V and subtracting the solutions
above and below xR, leads to the linear system of equations
U (xR) (c1+ − c1−) + V (xR) c2+ = qh
U′(xR) (c1+ − c1−) + V ′(xR) c2+ = ∂xqh
(cid:18) c1+ − c1−
c2+
(cid:19) =
1
W (xR)(cid:18) V ′ −V
.
1(cid:12)(cid:12)xR
1(cid:12)(cid:12)xR
−U′ U (cid:19) qh
1(cid:12)(cid:12)xR ! .
1(cid:12)(cid:12)xR
2 + iωτ(cid:19)
∂x qh
+ xR
H
+ (
xR + iωτ )
1
2
H
2 + iωτ(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19) .
(76)
(77)
The coefficients c1+ − c1− and c2+ are determined as above as the solution of this system of linear equations
π and the expressions (68) and (73) for the boundary values we obtain
Using the Wronskian W (xR) =q 2
c2+ = r π
2
u−1(xR)τ ν0(cid:18)U′(xR) (cid:18) G
1 + iωτ
+U (xR) (cid:18)−n(ω) +(cid:18) 1
2
xR
G
1 + iωτ
15
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
Equating (75) and (77) determines the transfer function
n(ω) =
G
1 + iωτ
+
H
2 + iωτ
xθ
xR
xθ
2 U(cid:1)(cid:12)(cid:12)
u−1 (cid:0)U′ + x
u−1UxR
2 + iωτ ) U(cid:17)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
u−1 (cid:16)x U′ + ( x2
u−1UxR
xθ
xR
xθ
.
With the definition (using m = iωτ − 1
2 as defined in (62))
Φω(x) ≡ Φ(m, x) = u−1(x) U (m, x)
follows
Φ′ω(x) = u−1(x)(U′(m, x) +
x
2
U (m, x))
and
Φ′′ω(x) =
(30)
=
x
2
x
2
u−1(U′ +
u−1(U′ +
x
2
x
2
x2
2
U ) + u−1(U′′ +
U ) + u−1((
1
2
U +
x
2
x2 + iωτ −
1
4
U′)
1
2
)U +
1
2
U +
x
2
U′)
= u−1 (xU′ + (
+ iωτ )U ).
Inserting into (78) we obtain the final result
n(ω) =
G
1 + iωτ
xθ
Φ′ω(x)xR
Φω(x)xR
xθ
+ H 1
2 + iωτ
xθ ! .
Φ′′ω(x)xR
Φω(x)xR
xθ
(78)
(79)
(80)
(81)
This is the transfer function of the LIF model neuron as it was derived in [2, 3, 17].
Colored noise transfer function
We now consider the periodic modulation (55) of the mean input µ in the colored noise system (45). Note that here
we consider a modulation of V . If one is interested in the linear response of the system with respect to a perturbation
of I, as it appears in the neural context due to synaptic input, one needs to take into account the additional low pass
filtering ∝ (1 + iωτs)−1, which is trivial. The modulated Fokker-Planck equation follows with f (y, s) = −y + ǫµ
σ eiωτ s
from (3), and the effective system takes the form (56) with H = 0 (since we have no σ−modulation) and with specific
boundary conditions. We only consider a modulation of the mean µ, which dominates the response properties. The
treatment of an additional modulation of the variance σ is shown in [1] . The boundary conditions follow considering
again the perturbation ansatz for ν = ν0 + kν1 + O(k2) which must hold for each order of k separately, i.e.
so that to lowest order k0 we have
ν(t) = ν (1 + ncn(ω) eiωt),
ν(0)
y (θ, s) = ν(0)
y
(1 + ncn(ω) eiωτ s),
(82)
(83)
where ncn is the colored noise transfer function to be determined. Likewise to the case without synaptic filtering
(Section 3) we make a perturbative ansatz for the effective density
P (y, s) = P (y) + eiωτ s P (y).
16
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
Therefore it follows from (32)
and thus the boundary value for the time modulated part of the density is
= kα ν(0)
y (1 + ncn(ω) eiωτ s)
P (y, s) + eiωτ s P (y)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12){R,θ}
P (y)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12){R,θ}
= kαν(0)
y ncn(ω).
(84)
In the white noise derivation (Section 3) we obtain the simultaneous boundary conditions for the homogeneous part
of the modulated density and its derivative. In the following we adapt these conditions respecting the new boundary
conditions of the colored case (84) and perform the subsequent steps of the derivation analogously to the white noise
scenario. This leads to an analytical expression for the transfer function valid for synaptic filtering with small time
constants τs. Note that with Section 2 we would directly obtain an approximation for the colored noise transfer
in the white noise solution (81), which we denote by n. We will later show
function ncn, replacing x{R,θ} → x
that the expression obtained with the time-dependent modified boundary condition (84) is to first order equivalent
ton.
{ R, θ}
Colored noise boundary condition for the modulated density
The boundary condition for the function value of q1(x) = 1√2
P (x/√2)u−1(x) follows from (84) so
q1(x){xR,xθ} = qh
1 + qp
1{xR,xθ} = Au−1ncn(ω).
(85)
From here on we skip the dependence of u on {xR, xθ}. The contribution of the particular solution yields boundary
conditions for the homogeneous solution. With H = 0 the particular solution is (60)
The contribution of a†q0{xR,xθ} is
qp
1 =
G
1 + iωτ
a†q0.
a†q0{xR,xθ} = (x − a)q0{xR,xθ}
= {xR, xθ}Au−1 + τ ν u−1,
where we use (47) and (49). From (85) we obtain the boundary value of the homogeneous solution
− qh
1{xR,xθ} = qp
1{xR,xθ} − Au−1ncn(ω)
G
=
1 + iωτ
({xR, xθ}Au−1 + τ ν u−1) − Au−1ncn(ω).
Colored noise boundary condition for the derivative of the density
From (69) we have with H = 0
τ ν ncn(ω) = S0uq1 + S1uq0{xR,xθ}
= −uaq1 + uGq0{xR,xθ}
= −ua(qh
1 + qp
1) + uGq0{xR,xθ}.
(86)
(87)
(88)
(89)
Here we again employ that ncn(ω) is simultaneously valid for all orders of k. Therefore ν, containing the first order
correction in k, appears on the left hand side. The contribution of the particular solution is given by (70) with H = 0
17
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
−ua qp
1 = −u(cid:18) G
1 + iωτ(cid:19) q0.
Inserting in (89) and using (49) yields
Substituting a = 1
2 x + ∂x and the expression for the function value (88) this expands to
τ ν ncn(ω) = −
GA
1 + iωτ
+ GA − uaqh
1{xR,xθ}.
τ ν ncn(ω) = −
GA
+ GA
1 + iωτ
1
1 + iωτ
+
2{xR, xθ}(cid:18) G
1
2{xR, xθ}A ncn(ω)
−
−u∂xqh
1{xR,xθ}.
({xR, xθ}A + τ ν)(cid:19)
The terms in the first line of the right hand side can be simplified by elementary algebraic manipulations so that
rearranging for the derivative yields
u∂xqh
1{xR,xθ} = −ncn(ω)(τ ν +
1
2{xR, xθ}A)
+
G
1 + iωτ (cid:18)iωτ A +
1
2{xR, xθ}({xR, xθ}A + τ ν)(cid:19) .
(90)
Solvability condition
Above we have determined the boundary conditions for the function value (88) as well as the derivative (90). Now
we consider the solvability condition to determine the transfer function as in Section 3. According to (74) and (76)
we obtain two equations determining the coefficient c2+ of the homogeneous solution in (63) for the conditions at xθ
and xR respectively
Since the two coefficients cθ
Inserting (88) and (90) we sort for terms proportional to ncn(ω) and obtain
xθ
2+ and cR
2+ must be equal, the transfer function ncn(ω) is determined by cθ
2+ = cR
2+.
Using (79) and (80) we can write the transfer function as
[−U′qh
1 (xθ) + U ∂xqh
1 (xθ)]
cθ
2
2+ = r π
2+ = r π
2
ncn(ω)
xθ
xR
.
=
+
].
cR
+ U ∂xqh
[−U′ qh
1(cid:12)(cid:12)xR
1(cid:12)(cid:12)xR
x(cid:19) + U u−1τ ν(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
A(cid:18)U′u−1 + U u−1 1
xU(cid:19)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
τ νu−1(cid:18)U′ +
x2)(cid:19)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
u−1(cid:18)U′x + U (iωτ +
xR
1
2
1 + iωτ
1 + iωτ
AG
1
2
G
xR
xθ
2
ncn(ω) = τ ν
+
G
1 + iωτ
AG
1 + iωτ
18
Φ′ωxR
xθ
xθ
AΦ′ω + Φωτ νxR
.
AΦ′ω + Φωτ νxR
Φ′′ωxR
xθ
xθ
(91)
(92)
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
Since we neglected all terms of second order in k we state our final result linearly in k and neglect higher orders by
performing an expansion into a geometric series. From (92) we obtain
Linearization in k
ncn(ω) =
G
1 + iωτ " Φ′ωxR
ΦωxR
xθ
xθ
+
xθ (cid:19)2!# .
kα ν0√2ν Φ′′ωxR
xθ −(cid:18) Φ′ωxR
ΦωxR
ΦωxR
xθ
xθ
(93)
The first term is denoted by nwn
correction terms in k could be obtained by a shift in the boundaries in nwn
cn
cn since it is equivalent to the white noise solution (81). As mentioned earlier the
xR = xR +
xθ = xθ +
k
α
√2
α
√2
k
and a Taylor expansion in k
ncn(ω)
=
quotient rule
=
xθ
G
1 + iωτ
Φ′ωxR
ΦωxR
1 + iωτ " Φ′ωxR
ΦωxR
G
xθ
xθ
xθ
+
which is to first order equivalent to (93) since ν0
ν = ν0
ν0+kν1
= 1 − k ν1
ν0
xθ
kα
√2 Φ′′ωxR
xθ (cid:19)2!# ,
xθ −(cid:18) Φ′ωxR
ΦωxR
ΦωxR
+ O(k2).
xθ
4. NUMERICAL SIMULATION
We perform direct simulations of (45) with periodic modulation of the mean (55). Simulations were done in NEST
[18]. For each data point in Figure 1 we simulate 10000 ms, whereby we allow for a warm-up time of 100 ms, and
average over 100000 neurons (model: "iaf_psc_exp"). We use a time resolution of dt = 0.001 ms to have a good
agreement to the analytical limit dt → 0, which is important regarding the implementation of the white noise ξ as
a step-wise constant current with stepsize dt. We perform a fast Fourier transform on the summed spike trains to
obtain the amplitude and phase of the transfer function.
Finally we are in the position to compare the colored noise transfer function (93) to the white noise case (81). To
this end we examine the contributions of the different terms in (93)
5. DISCUSSION
+
xθ
xθ
G
G
1 + iωτ
1 + iωτ
ncn(ω) =
Φ′ωxR
ΦωxR
}
{z
kα ν0√2ν
{z
shown in Figure 1. We notice that the correction term nH
cn is similar to the H−term in (81), meaning that colored
noise has a similar effect on the transfer function as a modulation of the variance in the white noise case. For
infinite frequencies this similarity was already found: modulation of the variance leads to finite transmission at
infinite frequencies in the white noise system [3] and the same is true for modulation of the mean in the presence of
filtered noise [17]. The latter can be calculated in the two-dimensional Fokker-Planck problem and the result is (cf.
Appendix C)
xθ (cid:19)2
kα ν0√2ν (cid:18) Φ′ωxR
ΦωxR
}
{z
Φ′′ωxR
ΦωxR
}
1 + iωτ
nsquare
−
nwn
cn
nH
cn
xθ
xθ
xθ
,
G
cn
nlim,2D
cn
(ω) = 1.3238
ǫkµ
σ
.
19
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
A
)
0
(
n
/
)
ω
(
n
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0
B
)
s
n
a
i
d
a
r
(
)
ω
(
n
100
101
102
100
101
102
frequency ω/2π (1/s)
frequency ω/2π (1/s)
Figure 1: Absolute value (A) and phase (B) of the transfer function for µ = 18.94 mV, σ = 1.5 mV, θ = 19.5 mV, Vr = 14.5 mV,
τm = 10 ms, τs = 1.0 ms. Different contributions nwn
(green) and complete solution ncn (black)
compared to white noise case (dashed). Complete transfer functions for white noise and colored noise separately normalized to
zero frequency limit n(0) = dν0
cn (blue) and nsquare
cn (red), nH
cn
dµ and ncn(0) = dν
dµ (cf. Appendix B).
However, our analytical expression behaves differently and does not provide an accurate limit. The two correction
terms nsquare
cn cancel each other (see Figure 1), since [15, 12.8]
and nH
cn
Φ′(iωτ −
Φ′′(iωτ −
1
2
1
2
, x) = −iωτ Φ(iωτ +
, x) = iωτ (iωτ + 1) Φ(iωτ +
, x)
1
2
3
2
, x),
→ (iωτ )2 Φ2. Thus nwn
so Φ′′ → (iωτ )2 Φ and Φ′2
cn is the only term left, meaning that the transfer function decays
to zero as in the white noise case. This discrepancy originates from our derivation of the boundary value (85): We
neglect all terms with time derivatives in (18), since they are of second and third order in k and we assume ωτ k ≪ 1,
although this holds only true for moderate frequencies. Note that in fact only the terms including time derivatives in
(18) play a role in the limit ω → ∞ as seen in Eq. (C2), leading to the correct limit in the two-dimensional system.
We also expect that the deviations at high frequencies increase with the synaptic time constant, since the neglected
terms are ∝ ωk ∝ ω√τs.
Nevertheless up to moderate frequencies the analytical expression for the transfer function found in the present
work (93) is in agreement to direct simulations as shown in Figure 1. In this regime the color of the noise suppresses
the resonant peak and reduces the cutoff frequency compared to the white noise case. The effect of the noise at
intermediate frequencies is hence opposite to its effect in the high frequency limit [17]. This constitutes a novel insight
into the dependence of the transfer properties of LIF neurons on the details of synaptic dynamics.
In summary, in these pages we supply intermediate steps of the derivation of the theory presented in [1] that
may prove useful for the reader interested in further developments of the approach. Showing the applicability of the
alternative method of reduction of a colored-noise to a white noise system, namely explicitly taking into account the
time-dependent boundary condition, may facilitate future extensions of the theory that go beyond the first order in
the perturbation parameter k. We hope that the pedagogical presentation chosen here, exposing the analogy of the
LIF model to the quantum harmonic oscillator and including all intermediate steps of the calculations, will be of use
especially for students entering the field with a general background in physics, math or equivalent, but unfamiliar
with Fokker-Planck theory.
20
6
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
Fourier transformation of the second equation in (1) yields
Appendix A: Autocorrelation of z
z =
k
1 + iωk2 ξ(ω),
where z denotes the Fourier transform of z. The power-spectrum then follows as
hz(ω)z(−ω)i = k2
1
(1 + iωk2)(1 − iωk2)
,
where we used hξ(ω)ξ(−ω)i = 1. We perform the back transform using the residue theorem and assume s′ > 0 (which
allows us closing the contour in the upper complex half plane due to the term eis′ω), thus
hz(s)z(s + s′)i
=
pole ω = i
k2
=
1
2πZ k2
k2 1
2π
2πi
eiωs′
dω
(1 + iωk2)(1 − iωk2)
(ω − i
ik2(ω − i
k2 )e−s′/k2
k2 )(1 + 1)
=
e−s′/k2
2
.
If s′ < 0 we have to close the contour in the lower half plane. Together we get
hz(s)z(s + s′)i =
e−s′/k2
2
.
Appendix B: Zero frequency limit
The zero frequency limit of the colored noise transfer function ncn(ω) is given by the derivative of the firing rate
(53) with respect to µ. For brevity we introduce Ψ(x) = u−2F = ex2/2(cid:16)p π
that
2 (1 + erf( x√2
)(cid:17) and S = (cid:16)R xθ
xR
Ψ dx(cid:17) so
τ ν = τ ν0 −
αk
√2
xR
Ψxθ
S2 .
With x = √2 V −µ
σ we have
dΨ(x)
dµ
= −
and
dS
dµ
= (−
)(Ψ(xθ) − Ψ(xR)),
2 xex2/2(1 + erf(
x
√2
π!
)) +r 2
√2
σ r π
√2
σ
yielding
dν
dµ
=
=
dν0
dµ −
dν0
dµ −
αk
√2τ
αk
√2τ
(Ψ′(xθ) − Ψ′(xR))S2 − (−
(Ψ′(xθ) − Ψ′(xR))S + 2√2
σ (Ψ(xθ) − Ψ(xR))2
.
√2
σ )(Ψ(xθ) − Ψ(xR))2S((Ψ(xθ) − Ψ(xR))
S4
S3
21
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
Appendix C: High frequency limit
For completeness we rederive the high frequency limit of the transfer function in the two-dimensional Fokker-Planck
problem, closely following Brunel et al. [17]. The firing rate is given by the probability flux in y-direction at threshold,
marginalized over z. With the ansatz of a sinusoidal modulation of the density we therefore have
νy(θ, s) = Z ∞
= Z ∞
−∞
−∞
1
k
1
k
zP (yθ, z, s) dz,
z(P (yθ, z) + P (yθ, z)eiωτ s) dz,
with (82) resulting in
ντ ncn(ω) = Z ∞
−∞
1
k
z P (yθ, z) dz.
(C1)
σ eiωτ s in (18) and using the perturbation ansatz P (yθ, z, s) = P (yθ, z) + P (yθ, z)eiωτ s we
Inserting f (y, s) = −y + ǫµ
get for ω → ∞
P (yθ, z) = −ǫk
µ
σ
∂zP (yθ, z),
(C2)
which shows that the density is necessarily time-modulated up to arbitrary high frequencies. Together with (C1) we
have
τ ν ncn(ω)
=
perturbation series in k
=
Q(0)(yθ)=0
=
integration by parts
=
(30) and r = 0
=
symmetry and Kłosek and Hagan [10]
=
Brunel et al. [17]
≃
−∞
−∞
−Z ∞
−Z ∞
−Z ∞
Z ∞
Z ∞
−∞
ǫ
−∞
µ
σ
ǫ
−∞
µ
σ
ǫk
ǫ
1
k
zk
µ
σ
∂zP (yθ, z) dz
dz
ǫz
ǫz
µ
σ
µ
σ
√π
∂z(cid:16)Q(0)(yθ) + kQ(1)(yθ, z)(cid:17) e−z2
k∂z Q(1)(yθ, z)
e−z2
√π
√π ! dz
e−z2
dz
kQ(1)(yθ, z)
+ z +
∞Xn=1
N (√n)
n!√n
2
µ
σ
k2τ ν0 α
∞Xn=1
1
√2
τ ν0(α −
µ
σ
τ ν0.
bn(z)! e−z2
√π
dz
e− n
2 n
n
2 )
(C3)
1.3238 ǫk
The numerical value in the last expression is taken from [12]. We divide by the firing rate in the colored-noise case
(53) ν = ν0 + kν1 and linearize the right hand side in k which gives
1.3238 ǫkµ
ν0
ncn(ω) ≃
=
σ
1.3238 ǫkµ
σ
= 1.3238
ǫkµ
σ
ν0 + kν1
ν1
(1 − k
ν0
+ O(k2).
) + O(k2)
(C4)
[1] J. Schuecker, M. Diesmann, and M. Helias, arXiv pp. 1411.0432v7 [cond -- mat.stat -- mech] (2014).
22
Reduction of colored noise in excitable systems to white noise and dynamic boundary conditions
Schuecker et al.
[2] N. Brunel and V. Hakim, Neural Comput. 11, 1621 (1999).
[3] B. Lindner and L. Schimansky-Geier, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 2934 (2001).
[4] H. Risken, The Fokker-Planck Equation (Springer Verlag Berlin Heidelberg, 1996).
[5] J. M. Sancho, M. S. Miguel, S. L. Katz, and J. D. Gunton, Phys. Rev. A 26, 1589 (1982).
[6] K. Lindenberg and B. J. West, Physica A 119, 485 (1983).
[7] P. Hanggi, T. J. Mroczkowski, F. Moss, and P. V. E. McClintock, Phys. Rev. A 32, 695 (1985).
[8] R. F. Fox, Phys. Rev. A 33, 467 (1986).
[9] P. Grigolini, Phys. Lett. 119, 157 (1986).
[10] M. M. Kłosek and P. S. Hagan, J. Math. Phys. 39, 931 (1998).
[11] C. R. Doering, P. S. Hagan, and C. D. Levermore, Phys. Rev. Lett. 59, 2129 (1987).
[12] N. Fourcaud and N. Brunel, Neural Comput. 14, 2057 (2002).
[13] N. Brunel, J. Comput. Neurosci. 8, 183 (2000).
[14] A. J. Siegert, Phys. Rev. 81, 617 (1951).
[15] NIST Digital Library of Mathematical Functions, http://dlmf.nist.gov/, Release 1.0.5 of 2012-10-01, online companion to
[19], URL http://dlmf.nist.gov/.
[16] M. Abramowitz and I. A. Stegun, Handbook of Mathematical Functions: with Formulas, Graphs, and Mathematical Tables
(Dover Publications, New York, 1974).
[17] N. Brunel, F. S. Chance, N. Fourcaud, and L. F. Abbott, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 2186 (2001).
[18] M.-O. Gewaltig and M. Diesmann, Scholarpedia 2, 1430 (2007).
[19] F. W. J. Olver, D. W. Lozier, R. F. Boisvert, and C. W. Clark, eds., NIST Handbook of Mathematical Functions (Cambridge
University Press, New York, NY, 2010).
23
|
1203.6832 | 1 | 1203 | 2012-03-30T14:46:47 | Activity-dependent neuronal model on complex networks | [
"q-bio.NC",
"physics.bio-ph"
] | Neuronal avalanches are a novel mode of activity in neuronal networks, experimentally found in vitro and in vivo, and exhibit a robust critical behaviour: These avalanches are characterized by a power law distribution for the size and duration, features found in other problems in the context of the physics of complex systems. We present a recent model inspired in self-organized criticality, which consists of an electrical network with threshold firing, refractory period and activity-dependent synaptic plasticity. The model reproduces the critical behaviour of the distribution of avalanche sizes and durations measured experimentally. Moreover, the power spectra of the electrical signal reproduce very robustly the power law behaviour found in human electroencephalogram (EEG) spectra. We implement this model on a variety of complex networks, i.e. regular, small-world and scale-free and verify the robustness of the critical behaviour. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Activity-dependent neuronal model on complex
networks
Lucilla de Arcangelis1 and Hans J. Herrmann2
,
3
July 25, 2018
1 Department of Information Engineering, Second University of Naples, Aversa (CE), Italy
2 Institute Computational Physics for Engineering Materials, ETH, Zurich, CH
3 Departamento de F´ısica, Universidade Federal do Cear´a, 60451-970 Fortaleza, Cear´a, Brazil
Abstract
Neuronal avalanches are a novel mode of activity in neuronal networks,
experimentally found in vitro and in vivo, and exhibit a robust critical
behaviour: These avalanches are characterized by a power law distribu-
tion for the size and duration, features found in other problems in the
context of the physics of complex systems. We present a recent model in-
spired in self-organized criticality, which consists of an electrical network
with threshold firing, refractory period and activity-dependent synaptic
plasticity. The model reproduces the critical behaviour of the distribution
of avalanche sizes and durations measured experimentally. Moreover, the
power spectra of the electrical signal reproduce very robustly the power
law behaviour found in human electroencephalogram (EEG) spectra. We
implement this model on a variety of complex networks, i.e. regular, small-
world and scale-free and verify the robustness of the critical behaviour.
1
Introduction
The activity in neuronal networks consists in one or more action potentials in
a single neuron or an ensemble of neurons. The first case is typical for small
networks, as some experimental systems in vitro, where isolated spikes can be
observed. The presence of a number of action potentials in an ensemble of neu-
rons not always is a consequence of an external stimulus. Neuronal systems
exhibit an intense spontaneous activity, known since a long time, whose relation
with the response to stimulation is not fully understood yet. It is however well
established that spontaneous activity cannot be simply reduced to a background
noise uncorrelated to the system response. Indeed, experimental results for the
cat visual cortex ([Arieli et al., 1996]) have shown that the intensity of the re-
sponse to an external stimulus is roughly proportional to the intensity of the
spontaneous activity state of the system when the stimulus is applied. The vari-
ability in the response provided to the repeated application of the same stimulus
is therefore caused by the different levels of ongoing activity. A similar analysis
has been performed at the intracellular level on the same system, confirming
that the spatio-temporal structure of the spontaneous activity influences the
response signal ([Azouz et al., 1999]).
1
The typical form of spontaneous activity consists in the almost synchronous
emission of action potentials in a large number of neurons, followed by periods of
substantial inactivity. These high activity events, named bursts, are observed
both during development and in mature systems and can last from a few to
several hundreds milliseconds. Conversely, the quiet periods can last seconds
and have been attributed to a variety of mechanisms: The decrease in the avail-
able neurotransmitter ([Stevens et al., 1995, Staley et al., 1998]); the presence
of an inhibitory factor leading to a disabilitation of the neurotransmitter release
([Stevens et al., 1995, Staley et al., 1998]); the inactivation, or remodulation of
the response, of the glutamate receptors ([Maeda et al., 1995]). An alternative
form of temporal organization is slow oscillations between high activity and low
activity states with a typical frequency of 0.3 - 1 Hz. The temporal organiza-
tion of this spontaneous activity has been characterized by the distribution of
inter-times, i.e. the temporal intervals between successive bursts or successive
spikes ([Segev et al., 2002]).
In 2003 Beggs and Plenz have identified a novel form of spontaneous activity,
neuronal avalanches ([Beggs et al., 2003, Beggs et al., 2004]). Coronal slices of
rat somatosensory cortex were placed onto a 8 × 8 multielectrode array (MEA)
and spontaneous activity was induced by bath perfusion with the glutamate
receptor agonist NMDA in combination with a dopamine receptor agonist. The
intrinsic activity of the system was monitored by measuring the potential at
each electrode. This local field potential (LFP) integrates the electrical activ-
ity of neurons placed in the region surrounding the electrode: negative peaks
in the LFP measure the influx of positive ions and therefore the cumulative
membrane potential variation of the neurons in the region. Experimental data
show that before 6 days in vitro activity is mainly composed of sparse acti-
vations but during the second week simultaneous activations occur in several
electrodes. The novel idea was to examine this electrophysiological signal on
a finer temporal scale, which was able to evidence a complex spatio-temporal
structure. Indeed, activity starting at one electrode may involve more, non nec-
essarily neighbouring, electrodes. Binning time in cells of duration δt, allows to
create a spatio-temporal grid reporting the active electrodes in each temporal
cell. A neuronal avalanche is therefore defined as a sequence of successively
active electrodes between two temporal bins with no activity. The total number
of active electrodes, or alternatively the sum of all LFPs, is defined as the size
s of an avalanche and the time interval with ongoing activity as its duration T .
The striking result is that both size and duration have no characteristic
value, i.e. their distributions exhibit a power law behaviour. The analysis at a
finer temporal scale is then able to enlighten the non synchronous character of
the bursts. The exponents of these power law distributions depend on the choice
for the temporal bin δt. Indeed larger bins make active electrodes belonging to
different avalanches to merge into the same larger event, leading to a smaller
exponent.
In order to identify the appropriate value of δt, Beggs and Plenz
verified that if δt is equal to the average value of the time delay between two
successive LFPs in the culture, the exponent does not depend any longer on the
specific culture. They were then able to identify the universal scaling behaviour
P (s) ∝ s−α with α = 1.5 ± 0.1
P (T ) ∝ T −β with β = 2.0 ± 0.1.
(1)
2
The power law behaviour for the size distribution is followed by an expo-
nential cutoff due to the finite size of the system, whereas for the duration
distribution it extends over about one decade and the exponential cutoff sets in
at about 10ms.
The results in vitro have been confirmed by extended studies in vivo on
anaesthetized rats during development ([Gireesh et al., 2008]) and awake reshus
monkeys ([Petermann et al., 2009]). Spontaneous neuronal activity recorded by
MEA placed in the rat cortical layer 2/3 at the beginning and the end of the
second week postnatal, shows higher frequency (up to 100Hz) oscillations nested
into lower frequency (4-15Hz) oscillations. At the end of the first week postna-
tal, bursts start to organize into high frequency oscillations and become more
synchronized during the second week. Synchronous activity in the bursts ex-
hibits the same scaling behaviour found for neuronal avalanches in vitro (Eq.s1).
This similarity between in vitro and in vivo experiments support the idea that
the emergence of nested oscillations reflects the development of layer 2/3 in the
cortex. Ongoing activity measured in the primary motor and premotor areas
of two awake monkeys, sitting with no behavioural task, nor under particular
stimulus, exhibits also neuronal avalanches. Their organization is independent
of the detection threshold and exhibits scale invariance. Power laws for the size
and duration distributions confirm the scaling behaviour in Eq.1 and suggest
that in large neuronal networks a wide variety of avalanche sizes is possible,
including clusters percolating throughout the system. This indicates that the
largest cluster is solely controlled by the system size and not by the dynam-
ics. This result also generalizes avalanche dynamics across species and different
cortical areas. Criticality can be therefore considered as a generic property of
spontaneous cortical activity, which may indicate that networks with a larger
response repertoire were selected over others throughout evolution. A flexi-
ble spontaneous activity could then underlie and optimize important cortical
functions as learning and memory.
The investigation on the spontaneous activity has been performed also for
dissociated neurons from different networks as rat hippocampal neurons ([Mazzoni et al., 2007]),
rat embryos ([Pasquale et al., 2008]) or leech ganglia ([Mazzoni et al., 2007]).
Neurons are mechanically dissociated by trituration through fine-tipped pipettes
and placed onto a MEA, pre-coated with adhesion promoting molecules, in a
nutrient medium. Under fixed conditions of humidity and temperature, neurons
start to develop a network of synaptic connections and, after a variable period
in vitro, exhibit spontaneous electrical activity. The electrodes of the MEA in
these experiments record the spikes, rather than the LFPs, due to individual
neurons attached to them. As a consequence, the temporal scale for the data
analysis has to take into account this difference in order to properly charac-
terize the neuronal response. Choosing the average inter-spike time at a single
electrode as the temporal scale for data binning, the spontaneous activity is
monitored during the development and in mature cultures. Different behaviours
are observed. Only those systems exhibiting a medium level of synchronization
between random spikes and synchronized bursts exhibit critical behaviour. For
those cultures the scaling behaviour is very robust and in agreement with Eq.1.
In particular, the emergence of a critical state has been found to be strongly re-
lated to the aging of the system, namely after the first few weeks in vitro, where
the behaviour of the system is subcritical, some cultures may self-organize and
reach the critical state as they mature ([Pasquale et al., 2008]).
3
In real brain neurons are known to be able to develop an extremely high
number of connections with other neurons, that is a single cell body may re-
ceive inputs from even a hundred thousand presynaptic neurons. One of the
most fascinating questions is how an ensemble of living neurons self-organizes,
developing connections to give origin to a highly complex system. The dynamics
underlying this process might be driven both by the aim of realizing a well con-
nected network leading to efficient information transmission, and the energetic
cost of establishing very long connections. The morphological characterization of
a neuronal network grown in vitro has been studied ([Shefi et al., 2002]) by mon-
itoring the development of neurites in an ensemble of few hundred neurons from
the frontal ganglion of adult locusts. After few days the cultured neurons have
developed an elaborated network with hundreds of connections, whose morphol-
ogy and topology has been analyzed by mapping it onto a connected graph. The
short path length and the high clustering coefficient measured indicate that the
network belongs to the category of small-world networks ([Watts et al., 1998]),
interpolating between regular and random networks. In classical small-world
networks the majority of sites have a number of connections close to the aver-
age value in the network. Real neuronal networks behave quite differently, since
neurons with quite diverse number of connections are observed.
Indeed, the
properties of the functionality network have been measured experimentally in
human adults ([Eguiluz et al., 2005]). Functional magnetic resonance imaging
has shown that this network has universal scale free properties, namely it ex-
hibits a distribution of out-going connection number, kout, which follows a power
law, i.e. n(kout) ∝ k−2
out, independent of the different tasks performed by the
patients. This behaviour suggests that in the network few neurons are highly
connected and act as hubs with respect to information transmission. Small
world features have been also measured for functionality networks in healthy
humans, whereas they are not present in patients affected by neurological dis-
eases: Alzheimer patients have longer path lengths (as in regular networks)
([Stam et al., 2006]) whereas schizophrenic patients show a more random archi-
tecture of the underlying network ([Rubinov et al., 2009]). Epileptic patients
exhibit a more ordered neuronal network during seizures ([Ponten et al., 2007]),
whereas brain tumour patients a more random one ([Bartolomei et al., 2006]).
2 The model
2.1 Connectivity networks
The first step to develop a model simulating neuronal dynamics is the choice of
the specific network of connections. The simplest choice is a regular lattice, i.e.
a square lattice for a two-dimensional system. However, following recent exper-
imental results, we allow neurons to develop long range connections: Starting
from a regular lattice, a small fraction of bonds, from 0 to 10%, is rewired,
namely one of the two connected neurons is chosen at random in the system.
This procedure originates long range connections and gives rise to a small world
network ([Watts et al., 1998, Shefi et al., 2002]), which more realistically repro-
duces the connections in the real brain.
In a small world networks the number of connections for different neurons
In order to reproduce the experimental data
is close to an average number.
4
on the connectivity distribution in functionality networks, we implement also
scale free networks. More precisely, we set N neurons at random positions in
two-dimensional space and to each neuron we assign an out-going connectivity
degree, kout, according to the distribution measured by fMRI measurements of
ongoing activity in humans ([Eguiluz et al., 2005]). Each neuron has a degree
equal to a random number between kmin
out = 100 according to the
probability distribution n(kout) ∝ k−2
out. The two neurons are chosen according
to a distance dependent probability, p(r) ∝ e−r/5<r>, where r is their spatial
distance ([Roerig et al., 2002]).
out = 2 and kmax
In order to consider a network with both features, small-world and scale-
free, we also implement the Apollonian network. This has been recently intro-
duced ([Andrade et al., 2005]) in a simple deterministic version starting from
the problem of space-filling packing of spheres according to the ancient Greek
mathematician Apollonius of Perga. In its classical version the network asso-
ciated to the packing gives a triangulation that physically corresponds to the
force network of the sphere packing. One starts with the zero-th order triangle
of corners P1, P2, P3, places a fourth site P4 in the centre of the triangle and
connects it to the three corners (n = 0). This operation will divide the original
triangle in three smaller ones, having in common the central site. The iteration
n = 1 proceeds placing one more site in the centre of each small triangle and
connecting it to the corners (Fig.1). At each iteration n, going from 0 to N ,
the number of sites increases by a factor 3 and the coordination of each already
existing site by a factor 2. More precisely, at generation N there are
m(k, N ) = 3N , 3N −1, 3N −2, . . . , 32, 3, 1, 3
vertices, with connectivity degree
k(N ) = 3, 3 × 2, 3 × 22, . . . , 3 × 2N −1, 3 × 2N , 2N +1 + 1
respectively, where the two last values correspond to the site P4 and the three
corners P1, P2, P3. The maximum connectivity value then is the one of the very
central site P4, kmax = 3 × 2N , whereas the sites inserted at the N -th iteration
will have the lowest connectivity 3.
The important property of the Apollonian network is that it is scale-free.
In fact, it has been shown ([Andrade et al., 2005]) that the discrete cumulative
distribution of connectivity degrees P (k) = Pk′≥k m(k, N )/NN , where NN =
3+(3(N +1) −1)/2 is the total number of sites at generation N , can be fitted by a
power law. More precisely, P (k) ∝ k1−γ, with γ = ln 3/ ln 2 ∼ 1.585. Moreover
the network has small-world features. This implies ([Watts et al., 1998]) that
the average length of the shortest path l behaves as in random networks and
l ∝ (ln N )3/4. Furthermore
grows slower than any positive power of N , i.e.
the clustering coefficient C is very high as in regular networks (C = 1) and
contrary to random networks. For the Apollonian network C has been found
to be equal to 0.828 in the limit of large N . On this basis, the Apollonian
network appears to have all the new features that we would like to investigate:
small-world property found experimentally ([Shefi et al., 2002]) and possibility
of a very high connectivity degree (scale-free). Moreover it also presents sites
connecting bonds of all lengths. Also this last feature can be found in real
neuronal networks, where the length of an axon connecting the pre-synaptic
with the post-synaptic neuron can vary over several orders of magnitude, from
5
Figure 1: Apollonian network for N = 2:
(cid:13), (cid:4), •, respectively.
iterations n = 0, 1, 2 are symbols
µms to cms. Finally, most studies in the literature consider the case of a fully
connected network, where each neuron is connected to every other neuron. Even
if not completely realistic, we consider also this last case.
2.2 Neuronal dynamics
We here discuss a neuronal network model based on self-organized criticality
ideas ([Bak, 1996]). The model implements several physiological properties of
real neurons: a continuous membrane potential, firing at threshold, synaptic
plasticity and pruning. In order to define the model we need to specify the be-
haviour of the single neuron under different conditions, the dynamics then deter-
mines the system behaviour ([de Arcangelis et al., 2006, Pellegrini et al., 2007,
de Arcangelis et al., 2010]). We consider N neurons at the nodes of the chosen
network, characterized by their potential vi. The neuron positions will then
be ordered in space for regular lattices and small world networks, organized
in a hierarchical manner for the Apollonian network and randomly chosen in
two dimensions for the scale-free and fully connected networks. Once the net-
work of output connections is established, we identify the resulting degree of
in-connections, kinj , for each neuron j. To each synaptic connection we assign
an initial random strength gij, where gij 6= gji, and to each neuron randomly
either an excitatory or an inhibitory character, with a fraction pin of inhibitory
synapses. Whenever at time t the value of the potential at a site i is above a
certain threshold vi ≥ vmax, the neuron sends action potentials which arrive to
each of the kouti pre-synaptic buttons and lead to a total production of neuro-
transmitter proportional to vi. As a consequence, the total charge that could
enter into connected neurons is proportional to vikouti . Each of them receives
charge in proportion to the strength of the synapses gij
vj(t + 1) = vj (t) ±
vi(t)kouti
gij(t)
kinj
Pk gik(t)
(2)
where the sum is extended to all out-going connections of i.
In Eq.(2) the
membrane potential variation is obtained by dividing the received charge by the
6
surface of the soma of the post-synaptic neuron, proportional to the number of
in-going terminals kinj . The plus or minus sign in Eq.(2) is for excitatory or
inhibitory synapses, respectively. In regular networks neurons have the same
number of ingoing and outgoing connections, therefore Eq.(1) reduces to the
Pk gik(t) . The same consideration
simpler expression vj (t + 1) = vj(t) ± vi(t)
holds for small world networks.
gij (t)
The firing rate of real neurons is limited by the refractory period, i.e. the
brief period after the generation of an action potential during which a second
action potential is difficult or impossible to elicit. The practical implication of
refractory periods is that the action potential does not propagate back toward
the initiation point and therefore is not allowed to reverberate between the cell
body and the synapse. In our model, once a neuron fires, it remains quiescent for
one time step and it is therefore unable to accept charge from firing neighbours.
This ingredient indeed turns out to be crucial for a controlled functioning of
our numerical model.
In this way an avalanche of charges can propagate far
from the input through the system. The initial values of the neuron potentials
are uniformly distributed random numbers and the value of vmax is fixed equal
to 6 in all simulations. Moreover, a small fraction (10%) of neurons is chosen
to be output sites, i.e. an open boundary, with a zero fixed potential, playing
the role of sinks for the charge. They model neurons connected to neurons not
belonging to the slice and avoid that an excess to charge influx would lead to
supercritical behaviour. Each time neuronal activity stops in the network, an
external stimulus is necessary to trigger further activity, which therefore mimics
the nutrients from the bath needed to keep a real neuronal network alive. This
stimulus consists in increasing the potential of a random neuron by a random
quantity uniformly distributed between 0 and vmax.
During the propagation of an avalanche according to Eq. (2), we identify
the bonds connecting two successively active neurons, namely neurons whose
activity is correlated. The strength of their connections is increased proportion-
ally to the activity of the synapse, namely the membrane potential variation of
the post-synaptic neuron induced by the presynaptic neuron
gij(t + 1) = gij(t) + αiij(t)
(3)
where iij (t) is the current through that synaptic connection and α a dimension-
less parameter. Once an avalanche of firings comes to an end, the strength of
all inactive synapses is reduced by the average strength increase per bond
∆g = X
ij,t
δgij(t)/Na
(4)
where Na is the number of bonds active in the previous avalanche. Here α is
the only parameter controlling both the strengthening and the weakening rule
in the Hebbian plasticity and represents the ensemble of all possible physiolog-
ical factors influencing synaptic plasticity. By implementing these rules, our
neuronal network "memorizes" the most used paths of discharge by increasing
their strength, whereas the less solicited synapses slowly atrophy. Indeed, once
the strength of a bond is below an assigned small value gt = 10−4, we remove it,
i.e. set its strength equal to zero, which corresponds to the so-called pruning.
We implement synaptic plasticity rules during a series of Np stimuli in order
to modify the synaptic strengths, initially set at random. In this way we do
7
25000
Npb
20000
15000
10000
5000
α=0.005
α=0.08
α=0.03
0
0
5000
10000
% act
0,8
0,78
0,76
0,74
0,72
0,7
0
Np
α
0,04
0,08
15000
20000
Figure 2: Average number of pruned bonds Npb as function of the number
of external stimuli Np for a square lattice of linear size L = 100, equal initial
conductances and different values of α. In the inset we show the asymptotic
value of the percentage of surviving bonds as function of α.
not impose a strength configuration but let the system activity tune their val-
ues. Once a percentage of bonds is pruned, we stop plastic adaptation and we
perform our measurements, by applying a new sequence of stimuli without mod-
ifying the synaptic strengths. The extension of the plastic adaptation procedure
then represents the level of experience, or age, of the system, whose response we
monitor over a time-scale much shorter than the one needed for structural adap-
tation. All data presented in this manuscript are averaged over long temporal
sequences in several initial network configurations. More precisely, for regular
and small-world networks we average data on 10 different initial configurations
with a sequence of 10000 avalanches per configuration. On the Apollonian net-
work we average over 100 different initial configurations and a sequence of 30000
avalanches per configuration. For scale free and fully connected networks we av-
erage over 60 different initial configurations and a sequence of 50000 stimulations
per configuration.
3 Pruning
The total number of pruned bonds at the end of each avalanche, Npb, in general
depends on the initial conductance g0, therefore it is interesting to investigate
the two cases of either all initial conductances equal to 0.25, or being uniformly
distributed between 0 and 1. First the case of equal initial conductances is
analysed. The strength of the parameter α, controlling both the increase and
decrease of synaptic strength, determines the plasticity dynamics in the net-
work. This homeostatic mechanism implies that the more the system learns
strengthening the used synapses, the more the unused connections will weaken.
For large values of α the system strengthens more intensively the synapses car-
rying current but also very rapidly prunes the less used connections, reaching
8
Figure 3: Probability of pruning for bonds of different iterations n of Apollonian
networks, from bottom n = 0 to top n = 9, as function of the number of external
stimuli Np for equal initial synaptic strengths. In the inset, the asymptotic Npb
(after 5000 stimuli) is shown as function of n with the exponential fit Npb ≃
exp 0.5n.
after a short transient a plateau where it prunes very few bonds. On the con-
trary, for small values of α the system takes more time to initiate the pruning
process and slowly reaches a plateau (Fig. 2). The inset of the figure shows
the asymptotic value of the fraction of surviving bonds, calculated as the total
number of bonds in the unpruned network minus the asymptotic number of
pruned bonds, as function of α. The number of unpruned bonds asymptoti-
cally reaches its largest value at the value α ≃ 0.03 for different networks. This
could be interpreted as an optimal value for the system with respect to plastic
adaptation.
For the Apollonian network it is interesting to investigate if pruning acts
in the same way on bonds created at different iterations n, n = 0, . . . , N , or
rather tends to eliminate bonds of some particular iteration. The probability to
prune bonds of different n is evaluated, that is the number of pruned bonds over
the total number of bonds for each iteration stage, as function of the number
of applied stimuli. Fig.3 shows that the plateau is reached at about the same
value of Np and the shape of the curve is similar for each n. However the
probability to prune bonds with large n is higher: These are the bonds created
in the last iterations and therefore embedded in the interior of the network.
This suggests that the most active bonds are the long range ones (small n),
which therefore support most of the information transport through the network.
It is also interesting to notice that, since the total number of bonds depends
exponentially on n, the gaps between the asymptotic values of the probability
for successive generations depend exponentially on n. In the inset of Fig.3 we
show the asymptotic number of pruned bonds per generation on a semi-log scale,
this quantity is well fitted by the exponential behaviour Npb ≃ exp n.
The same analysis has been performed for random initial conductances be-
9
10000
n(k)
1000
100
10
1
1
Np = 0
Np = 2000
10
100
k
1000
Figure 4: Connectivity degree distribution n(kout) at different pruning stages
Np for Apollonian networks with equal initial synaptic strengths and α = 0.020.
As soon as pruning starts to eliminate bonds, new connectivity degrees appear,
not present in the original network. Conversely, two out of the three corner
sites, which for the generation N = 9 have initially a connectivity degree 1025,
may loose bonds because of pruning and, as a result, n(1025) = 1.
tween 0 and 1. The results are similar to the previous case. It can be noticed
that pruning starts already at Np = 1, since conductances close to zero are
present, and the plateau is reached after about 1000 stimuli. The value of α
which now optimizes the number of active bonds is about 0.030 also for the
Apollonian network.
In this case, the pruning behaviour for different itera-
tions is similar to the previous case, with the pruning probability exponentially
increasing with n, as Npb ≃ exp n.
The effect of pruning on the connectivity degree of the network is an in-
teresting quantity to monitor on scale free networks. On Apollonian networks
we evaluate the number of sites with a number of outgoing connections kout as
function of kout in the initial network and after application of a given number
of external stimuli (Fig.4). After the application of few external stimuli, i.e.
for a short plastic adaptation, the distribution n(kout) shows the same scaling
behaviour of the original Apollonian network. As the pruning process goes on,
sites exhibit varying connectivity degree and new values of kout appear. The
result is that the scaling behaviour is progressively lost, as well as the scale-free
character of the network, since there is a generalized decrease of the connectivity
in the network.
4 Avalanche statistics
After "aging" the system applying plasticity rules during Np external stimuli,
we submit the system to a new sequence of stimuli with no modification of
synaptic strengths. The response of the system to this second sequence models
the spontaneous activity of a trained neuronal network with a given level of ex-
10
107
n(s)
106
105
104
103
102
101
100
100
Npb
25000
20000
15000
10000
5000
0
500 1000 1500 2000
Np
Np = 0
Np=800
Np = 1000
scale free
square lattice
exp = 1.8
exp = 1.5
101
102
s
103
104
105
Figure 5: Avalanche size distribution for different networks with pin = 0.05: the
square lattice (N = 106, α = 0.03); the scale free network (N = 4000) and the
Apollonian network for different values of Np (9th generation with α = 0.030).
Initial synaptic strengths are randomly distributed. Data are logarithmically
binned.
In the inset, the corresponding behaviour of the number of pruned
bonds for the Apollonian network is shown.
perience. We analyse this activity by measuring the avalanche size distribution
n(s) and the time duration distribution n(T ).
The avalanche size distribution n(s) consistently exhibits power law be-
haviour for different values of model parameters. Fig.5 shows the avalanche
size distribution for different networks and values of Np, including also the case
Np = 0 (no plasticity adaptation), for random initial conductances and the op-
timal value of α. The value of the exponent is obtained by regression of the
log-binned data and found to be σ = 1.5 ± 0.1 for all networks, except the
Apollonian network where σ = 1.8 ± 0.2. The exponent is stable with respect
to variations of the parameters for both equal and random initial conductances.
More accurate methods, as maximum likelihood fitting, should verify the sta-
bility of these values ([Clauset et al., 2009]).
It is interesting to stress the importance of noise: Indeed, by applying the
external stimulation not at random but at a fixed neuron, the scaling expo-
nent becomes σ = 1.2 ± 0.1 ([de Arcangelis et al., 2006]). We notice that, for
fixed size s, increasing Np decreases the number of avalanches of that size,
suggesting that strong plasticity remodelling decreases activity. The exponent
appears to be independent of Np, as long as the number of pruned bonds,
Npb, is far from the plateau (see inset in Fig.5). Similar results are found
for equal initial conductances. The dependence of the critical behaviour on
synaptic strengths has been recently investigated in networks of integrate-and-
fire neurons ([Levina et al., 2007]). The value of the exponent is compatible
within error bars with the value found in the experiments of Beggs and Plenz
([Beggs et al., 2003]), 1.5 ± 0.4. However, one has to notice that experimental
results for neuronal avalanches were obtained for local field potentials, i.e. the
11
n(s)
10000
1000
100
10
1
0,1
0,01
1
Np=10000
Np=30000
Np=50000
Np=100000
exp = -2.3
10
s
100
1000
Figure 6: Avalanche size distribution for 100 configurations of fully connected
networks with N=1000 neurons with pin = 0.05. The different curves correspond
to different durations of the plastic adaptation period Np.
underlying events correspond to local population spikes, whereas the numerical
events are single neuronal spikes. The slightly larger value of the exponent,
found on the Apollonian network, suggests that the peculiar hierachical struc-
ture of the network may reduce the probability of very large avalanches but does
not change substantially the electrical activity. For larger Np, the distribution
exhibits an increase in the scaling exponent and finally looses the scaling be-
haviour for very large Np values, in the plateau regime for the number of pruned
bonds.
In order to investigate the role of plastic modifications on the production of
very large avalanches, simulations are performed for fully connected networks
which undergo plastic adaptation routines of different length. All networks
exhibit supercritical behaviour, namely an excess of very large avalanches, due
to the high level of connectivity in the system (Fig.6). Very large avalanches
involve almost all neurons and their large number hinders pruning, namely there
are only very few synapses in the system repeatedly inactive which progressively
weaken and atrophy. This behaviour is independent of the extension of the
plastic adaptation. No pruning is observed even following the application of
hundred thousand stimuli. Very large avalanches therefore seem to be sustained
by the high connectivity in the system and apparently do not depend on the
synaptic strengths. The analysis of the effect of pruning on very large avalanches
confirms this observation. Plastic adaptation of different duration is now applied
to scale free networks, leading to pruning of synapses. Supercritical behaviour,
that appears in the unpruned networks, survives when only few percentage of
the synapses is removed. Conversely, a more extended pruning strongly affects
connectivity and hampers the development of very large avalanches.
At time t = 0 a neuron is activated by an external stimulus initiating the
avalanche. This will continue until no neuron is at or above threshold. The
number of avalanches lasting a time T , n(T ), as function of T also exhibits
power law behaviour (Fig.7) followed by an exponential cut-off. The scaling
12
107
n(T)
106
105
104
103
102
101
100
100
α
= 0.015
α
= 0.080
α
= 0.030
scale free
fully conn.
exp=2.1
101
T
102
103
Figure 7: Avalanche duration distribution for different networks with pin = 0.05:
the scale free network(N = 4000); the fully connected network with Np = 50000;
the Apollonian networks for different values of α (9th generation, Np = 500).
Data are logarithmically binned. The dotted line has slope 2.1.
exponent is found to be τ = 2.1 ± 0.2 for all networks and equal and random
initial conductances. Only for the fully connected networks the distribution
exhibits a bump at long durations, due to the excess of large avalanches which
all contribute to the tail of the distribution. The value of the exponent is found
to be stable with respect to different parameters, provided that the number of
pruned bonds Npb is lower than the plateau for that value of α. Finally this
value agrees within error bars with the value 2.0, exponent found experimentally
by Beggs and Plenz ([Beggs et al., 2003, Beggs et al., 2004]).
5 Power spectrum
The power spectrum of the time signal for the overall electrical activity can be
calculated. The aim is to compare the scaling behaviour of the numerical spec-
trum with the power law observed usually in medical data ([Freeman et al., 2000,
Novikov et al., 1997]). For this purpose, the number of active neurons is mon-
itored as function of time, which recalls the experimental condition in which
electrodes are placed on the scalp in order to study the patient's spontaneous
electrical activity. In neuronal networks neuronal activity consists in avalanches
of all sizes generated in response to the external stimulus. Here the unit time
is the time for the avalanche to propagate from one neuron to the next one.
The power spectrum is calculated as the squared amplitude of the time Fourier
transform as function of frequency, averaged over many initial configurations.
Because of the definition of the numerical time unit, the frequency unit does
not correspond to the experimental one in Hertz.
Fig.8 shows the spectrum for different networks and different values of Np.
We also show the magnetoelectroencephalography (similar to EEG ) obtained
13
y
t
i
s
n
e
t
n
I
106
105
104
103
102
101
100
10-1
10-2
100
Np=0
Np = 2000
square lattice
small world
exp 1.0
exp 0.8
101
102
frequency
103
Figure 8: Power spectra obtained for different networks: square lattice (N =
106, α = 0.03, Np = 10); small world networks (N = 106, α = 0.05, Np = 1000,
1% rewired bonds); Apollonian networks for different Np (9th generation, α =
0.020). The experimental data (black line) are from ref. [Novikov et al., 1997]
with frequency in Hz. Experimental data are shifted in order to be in the same
frequency range of numerical data.
from channel 17 in the left hemisphere of a male subject resting with his eyes
closed, as measured in ref.
[Novikov et al., 1997], having the exponent 0.795.
For Np = 0, i.e. without plasticity adaptation, the spectrum has a 1/f be-
haviour, characteristic of SOC. For values of Np different from zero, but before
the Npb plateau, one can distinguish two different regimes: a power law be-
haviour with exponent β = 0.8 ± 0.1 at high frequency, followed by a crossover
toward white noise at low frequency. The difference between β = 1 for Np = 0
and β ≃ 0.8 for higher Np, suggests that plasticity reduces the relevance of small
frequencies in the power spectrum, in better agreement with experimental EEG
spectra ([Freeman et al., 2000, Novikov et al., 1997]). The stability of the expo-
nent with respect to α has also been verified, finding consistently β = 0.8 ± 0.1
at high frequency. The stability of the spectrum exponent suggests that an
universal scaling characterizes a large class of brain models and physiological
signal spectra for brain controlled activities. Medical studies of EEG focus on
subtle details of a power spectrum (e.g. shift in peaks) to discern between vari-
ous pathologies. These detailed structures however live on a background power
law spectrum that shows universally an exponent of about 0.8, as measured
for instance in refs. [Freeman et al., 2000] and [Novikov et al., 1997]. A similar
exponent was also detected in the spectral analysis of the stride-to-stride fluc-
tuations in the normal human gait which can directly be related to neurological
activity ([Hausdorff et al., 2001]). The measured value for the power spectra
exponent is in agreement with the expected relation β = 3 − τ , being the scaling
exponent of the avalanche duration distribution τ > 1 ([Jensen, 1998]).
The scaling behaviour of the power spectrum can be interpreted in terms
14
of a stochastic process resulting from the superposition of multiple inputs tak-
ing Gaussian distributed random values ([Hausdorff et al., 1996]). The output
signal sum of different and uncorrelated superimposed processes is character-
ized by a power spectrum with power law regime, crossing over to white noise
at low frequencies and to brown noise to high frequencies. The low crossover
frequency is related to the inverse of the longest characteristic time among the
superimposed processes. 1/f noise characterizes a superposition of processes
of different frequencies with similar amplitudes. In our case the scaling expo-
nent is smaller than unity, suggesting that processes with high characteristic
frequency are more relevant than processes with low frequency in the superpo-
sition ([Hausdorff et al., 1996]).
6 Discussion
Several experimental evidences suggest that the brain behaves as a system act-
ing at a critical point. This statement implies that the collective behaviour of
the network is more complex than the functioning of the single components.
Moreover, the emergence of self-organized neuronal activity, with the absence
of a characteristic scale in the response, unveils similarities with other nat-
ural phenomena exhibiting scale-free behaviour, as earthquakes or solar flares
([de Arcangelis et al., 2006]). For a wide class of these phenomena, self-organized
criticality has indeed become a successful interpretive scheme. As in self-
organized criticality, the threshold dynamics ensures time scale separation (slow
external drive and fast internal relaxation). This dynamics leads to criticality
and therefore power law behaviour ([Jensen, 1998]). The model belongs to the
class of non-conservative models, since output neurons can drive charge outside
the system. However the model presents a number of different features: The
propagation of charge from one neuron to the connected one is non-uniform
and non-isotropic. Moreover the connectivity network is not static but dynam-
ically evolves following activity. In this scenario the plastic rules introduce a
homeostatic regulatory mechanism between excitation and inhibition leading
to critical behaviour. The ensemble of these new ingredients is at the origin
of the measured exponents, different from the typical exponents found in SOC
models. Ii is interesting to notice that in fully connected networks the excess of
very large avalanches hampers the synaptic depression mechanisms and there-
fore alters the self-organized regulation between excitation and inhibition. As a
consequence, supercritical behaviour is observed.
Extensive simulations of this activity dependent model are derived for regu-
lar, small world, scale free and fully connected lattices. The results are compared
with experimental data. The first result is that an optimal value of the plasticity
strength α exists with respect to the pruning process, optimizing information
transmission. This remark could be interpreted as the evidence of a homeostatic
mechanism between strengthening and weakening processes in the adaptation of
real synapses. Moreover the avalanche size and duration distributions exhibit a
power law behaviour with stable exponents compatible with the values experi-
mentally found for neuronal avalanches. These values appear to be independent
of the model parameters and the specific connectivity network. This univer-
sal behaviour is also in agreement with experimental results, which provide the
same exponents for very different systems (dissociated neurons, cortex slices
15
and networks in vivo), evidently characterized by connectivity networks with
different complexity. Solely the fully connected networks consistently exhibit
supercritical behaviour due to the high connectivity level which sustains large
avalanche activity. The stability of the spectrum exponent suggests that a uni-
versal scaling characterizes a large class of brain models and physiological signal
spectra for brain controlled activities. This work may open new perspectives to
study pathological features of EEG spectra by including further realistic details
into the neuron and synapse behaviour.
References
[Arieli et al., 1996] G.A. Arieli, A. Sterkin and A. Aertsen, Dynamics of ongoing
activity: explanation of the large variability in evoked cortical responses,
Science 273, (1996) 1868-1871.
[Azouz et al., 1999] R. Azouz and C.M. Gray, Cellular Mechanisms Contribut-
ing to Response Variability of Cortical Neurons In Vivo, J. Neurosci. 19,
(1999) 2209-2223.
[Stevens et al., 1995] C.F. Stevens and T. Tsujimoto, Estimates for the pool
size of releasable quanta at a single central synapse and for the time required
to refill the pool, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 92, (1995) 846-849.
[Staley et al., 1998] K.J. Staley et al, Presynaptic modulation of CA3 network
activity, Nat. Naurosci. 1, (1998) 201-209.
[Maeda et al., 1995] E. Maeda, H.P. Robinson and A. Kawana, The mecha-
nisms of generation and propagation of synchronized bursting in developing
networks of cortical neurons, J. Neurosci. 15, (1995) 6834-6845.
[Segev et al., 2002] R. Segev et al, Long Term Behavior of Lithographically Pre-
pared In Vitro Neuronal Networks, Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, (2002) 118102.
[Beggs et al., 2003] J.M. Beggs and D. Plenz, Neuronal avalanches in neocorti-
cal circuits, J. Neurosci. 23, (2003) 11167-11177.
[Beggs et al., 2004] J.M. Beggs and D. Plenz, Neuronal avalanches are diverse
and precise activity patterns that are stable for many hours in cortical slice
cultures, J. Neurosci. 24, (2004) 5216-5229.
[Gireesh et al., 2008] E.D. Gireesh and D. Plenz, Neuronal avalanches organize
as nested theta- and beta/gamma-oscillations during development of cortical
layer 2/3, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 105, (2008) 7576-7581.
[Petermann et al., 2009] T. Petermann et al, Spontaneous cortical activity in
awake monkeys composed of neuronal avalanches, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 106,
(2009) 15921-15926.
[Mazzoni et al., 2007] A. Mazzoni et al, On the dynamics of the spontaneous
activity in neuronal networks, PLoS ONE 5, (2007) e439.
[Pasquale et al., 2008] V. Pasquale et al, Self-organization and neuronal
avalanches in networks of dissociated cortical neurons, Neuroscience 153,
(2008) 1354-1369.
16
[Shefi et al., 2002] O. Shefi, I. Golding, R. Segev, E. Ben-Jacob, A. Ayali, Mor-
phological characterization of in vitro neuronal networks, Phys. Rev. E. 66,
(2002) 021905.
[Watts et al., 1998] D. J. Watts, S. H. Strogatz, Collective dynamics of 'small-
world' networks, Nature 393, (1998) 440.
[Eguiluz et al., 2005] Eguiluz VM, Chialvo DR, Cecchi GA, Baliki M, Apkarian
AV, Scale-free brain functional networks, Physical Review Letters 94, (2005)
0181021-4.
[Roerig et al., 2002] Roerig B, Chen B, Relationships of local inhibitory and ex-
citatory circuits to orientation preference maps in ferret visual cortex, Cere-
bral Cortex 12, 187-198 (2002).
[Stam et al., 2006] Stam CJ, Jones BF, Nolte G, Breakspear M, Sceltens Ph,
Small-World Networks and Functional Connectivity in Alzheimer's Disease,
Cerebral Cortex 17, 92 (2007).
[Rubinov et al., 2009] Rubinov M, Knock SA, Stam CJ, Michelojannis S, Harris
AWF, Williams LM, Breakspear M, Small-world properties of nonlinear brain
activity in schizophrenia, Human Brain Mapping 30, 403 (2009).
[Ponten et al., 2007] Ponten Sc, Bartolomei F, Stam CJ, Small-world networks
and epilepsy: Graph theoretical analysis of intracerebrally recorded mesial
temporal lobe seizures, Clinical Neurophysiology 118, 918 (2007).
[Bartolomei et al., 2006] Bartolomei F,Bosma I, Klein M, Baayen JC, Reijn-
eveld JC, Postma TJ, Heimans JJ, van Dijk BW, de Munck JC, de Jongh
A, Cover KS, Stam CJ, Disturbed functional connectivity in brain tumour
patients: Evaluation by graph analysis of synchronization matrices, Clinical
Neurophysiology 117, 2039-2049 (2006).
[Andrade et al., 2005] J.S. Andrade, H.J. Herrmann, R.F.S. Andrade, L.R. da
Silva, Apollonian Networks: Simultaneously Scale-Free, Small World, Eu-
clidean, Space Filling, and with Matching Graphs, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94,
018702 (2005).
[Bak, 1996] P. Bak, How nature works. The science of self-organized criticality,
Springer, New York, 1996.
[de Arcangelis et al., 2006] L. de Arcangelis, C. Perrone Capano, H.J. Her-
rmann, Self-organized criticality model for brain plasticity, Phys. Rev. Lett.
96, 028107 (2006).
[Pellegrini et al., 2007] G.L. Pellegrini, L. de Arcangelis, H.J. Herrmann, C.
Perrone Capano, Modelling the brain as an Apollonian network, Phys. Rev.
E 76, 016107 (2007).
[de Arcangelis et al., 2010] L. de Arcangelis, H.J. Herrmann, Learning as a phe-
nomenon occurring in a critical state, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 107, 3977
(2010).
[Clauset et al., 2009] A. Clauset, C.R. Shalizi , M.E.J. Newman, Power-Law
Distributions in Empirical Data, SIAM Review 51, 661 (2009).
17
[Levina et al., 2007] A. Levina, J.M. Herrmann, T. Geisel, Dynamical synapses
causing self-organized criticality in neural networks, Nature Phys. 3, 857
(2007).
[Freeman et al., 2000] W. J. Freeman et al, Spatial spectral analysis of human
electrocorticograms including the alpha and gamma bands, J. Neurosci. Meth.
95, 111 (2000).
[Novikov et al., 1997] E. Novikov, A. Novikov, D. Shannahoff-Khalsa, B.
Schwartz, J. Wright, Scale-similar activity in the brain, Phys. Rev. E. 56,
R2387 (1997).
[Hausdorff et al., 2001] J. M. Hausdorff et al, When human walking becomes
random walking: fractal analysis and modeling of gait rhythm fluctuations,
Physica A. 302, 138 (2001).
[Jensen, 1998] H.J. Jensen, Self-Organized Criticality, Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, 1998.
[Hausdorff et al., 1996] J.M. Hausdorff, C.K. Peng, Multiscaled randomness: A
possible source of 1/f noise in biology, Phys. Rev. E 54, 2154 (1996).
[de Arcangelis et al., 2006] de Arcangelis L, Godano C, Lippiello E, Nicodemi
M, Universality in Solar Flare and Earthquake Occurrence, Phys. Rev. Lett.
96, 051102 (2006).
18
|
1702.05254 | 1 | 1702 | 2017-02-17T08:22:52 | A Biased Look at Phase Locking: Brief Critical Review and Proposed Remedy | [
"q-bio.NC",
"stat.AP"
] | A number of popular measures of dependence between pairs of band-limited signals rely on analytic phase. A common misconception is that the dependence revealed by these measures must be specific to the spectral range of the filtered input signals. Implicitly or explicitly, obtaining analytic phase involves normalizing the signal by its own envelope, which is a nonlinear operation that introduces broad spectral leakage. We review how this generates bias and complicates the interpretation of commonly used measures of phase locking. A specific example of this effect may create spurious phase locking as a consequence of nonzero circular mean in the phase of input signals, which can be viewed as spectral leakage to 0 Hz. Corrections for this problem which recenter or uniformize the distribution of phase may fail when the amplitudes of the compared signals are correlated. To address the more general problem of spectral bias, a novel measure of phase locking is proposed, the amplitude-weighted phase locking value (awPLV). This measure is closely related to coherence, but it removes ambiguities of interpretation that detract from the latter. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | A Biased Look at Phase Locking:
Brief Critical Review and Proposed Remedy
Christopher K. Kovach∗, ∗Department of Neurosurgery, University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics, Iowa City, IA
1
7
1
0
2
b
e
F
7
1
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
4
5
2
5
0
.
2
0
7
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
Abstract-A number of popular measures of dependence be-
tween pairs of band-limited signals rely on analytic phase. A
common misconception is that the dependence revealed by these
measures must be specific to the spectral range of the filtered
input signals. Implicitly or explicitly, obtaining analytic phase
involves normalizing the signal by its own envelope, which is a
nonlinear operation that introduces broad spectral leakage. We
review how this generates bias and complicates the interpretation
of commonly used measures of phase locking. A specific example
of this effect may create spurious phase locking as a consequence
of nonzero circular mean in the phase of input signals, which
can be viewed as spectral leakage to 0 Hz. Corrections for
this problem which recenter or uniformize the distribution of
phase may fail when the amplitudes of the compared signals
are correlated. To address the more general problem of spectral
bias, a novel measure of phase locking is proposed, the amplitude-
weighted phase locking value (awPLV). This measure is closely
related to coherence, but it removes ambiguities of interpretation
that detract from the latter.
Index Terms-coherence; phase locking; cross-frequency cou-
pling; spectral analysis
I. INTRODUCTION
M EASURES of phase locking are rapidly becoming a
standard tool in the analysis of biophysical signals,
especially so in applications to neurophysiology, where they
are used to study interactions between anatomically separated
neural populations [1]–[3] as well as cross-frequency coupling
within responses from the same population [4], [5]. Their
burst in popularity has been followed by a more gradually
dawning awareness of the many pitfalls that accompany their
use [6]–[16]. For example, recent entries to the body of
cautionary literature [17]–[19] point out how non-uniformity
of the distribution of phase in the input signals may create
spurious results in many of the most commonly used indices
of phase locking. This problem may be identified as one
of a more general family of biases related to the spectral
interpretation of phase.
Viewed from the spectral domain, it becomes clear that all
members of this family share the same culprit: the transfor-
mation through which phase is obtained, which divides an
analytic signal by its own envelope. The nonlinearity of this
transformation induces spectral leakage across a broad range
of frequencies, and the resulting unit-amplitude representation
of phase is in general not a bandlimited function [20], [21].
Moreover, consequences of this are not confined to measures
that explicitly invoke envelope normalization, but also extend
to those that extract phase from the argument of the analytic
Corresponding author: C.K. Kovach
signal, for which one may consider normalization as implicit.
The measures in question include phase-locking values (PLV),
also known as phase coherence [2], phase-amplitude coupling
[4] and information-theoretic measures derived from the em-
pirical distribution of phase angles [5], along with others that
correct for small-sample bias [22].
One class of measure is immune to spectral biases of this
type: those obtained directly from signal cross spectra, of
which coherence is the prime example. By avoiding amplitude
normalization, coherence circumvents the underlying spectral
distortions. However, the ambiguity of its interpretation, which
depends on both phase locking and amplitude correlation,
has dampened its popularity, motivating the aforementioned
alternatives that discard amplitude [2].
After reviewing the origin of spectral
leakage in ana-
lytic phase, another alternative is considered, the amplitude-
weighted phase locking value (awPLV), which combines some
of the favorable qualities of coherence with those of PLV. Un-
like coherence, awPLV always yields a value of 1 for perfectly
phase-synchronized signals (meaning here two signals whose
phase difference remains constant over time), regardless of
amplitude correlations. It improves on PLV and other phase-
only measures by avoiding the spectral distortion responsi-
ble for the aforementioned biases. It also addresses another
potential drawback of PLV, which is that PLV weights all
samples equally, including those in which the signal amplitude
approaches zero, for which phase is either poorly defined or
likely to be dominated by background noise. Like coherence,
awPLV weights the phase of each sample according to the
product of the input signal amplitudes; its numerator therefore
contains a cross-spectral estimate. It diverges from coherence
by normalizing with the sum of amplitude products rather
than the product of separate root-mean-square amplitudes.
Weighting this way allows the resulting measure to be viewed,
like PLV, as an average of unit-length phase vectors, but a
weighted average.
A. Nonlinearity and Phase
Throughout the following discussion, spectral broadening
related to amplitude normalization will be described as "spec-
tral leakage," and its effect as a form of "bias." Some readers
may rightly object to this terminology: spectral leakage bias
normally describes a set of artifacts extrinsic to the signal,
related to multiplying the signal with an externally determined
window function, not, as with amplitude normalization, a
"window" pulled from the signal itself. Our use (or rather
abuse) of this terminology calls for more justification. It should
be emphasized at the outset that spectral broadening from
amplitude normalization is neither an artifact nor inherently
a flaw in conventional measures of phase. Though phase
synchronization may arise through linear interactions, "pure"
phase-phase interactions, which are not affected by signal
amplitude, are nonlinear, so it would be a mistake to assume
that the spectral constraints of linear interactions must apply
generally to phase locking. In many settings, this nonlinearity
is what makes phase interesting [23]. On the other hand, it
is very difficult to resist the urge to think of phase as a
spectrally localized quantity, given that the underlying signals
are often band-limited and the rate of change of phase defines
the instantaneous frequency.
A detailed consideration of the spectral interpretation of
instantaneous phase is not the primary goal of the present
work, however. A large body of work already addresses this
topic [20], [24]–[27], which is also closely related to the
longstanding question of the relationship between instanta-
neous frequency and and the signal spectrum [21], [28],
[29]. The present aim is instead to describe conditions under
which phase locking might be safely viewed as a measure
of frequency-specific dependence between pairs of signals, in
the same way as measures of linear dependence derived from
the cross-spectrum. For this purpose, spectral broadening in
analytic phase will be treated as a form of spectral leakage
bias, although readers who prefer more nuanced terminology
might wish to replace "bias" with "misinterpretation of the
spectral nature of phase locking."
B. Organization
Sections II-C and III are intended as a tutorial introduction.
Section IV presents the basic problem of bias related to non-
uniform phase distributions, while section V explains how and
why previously described solutions to this problem may fail
in the presence of correlated amplitude modulation. Section
VI considers some methods for overcoming the problem, with
emphasis on the awPLV.
II. MEASURES OF DEPENDENCE IN COMPLEX SIGNALS
A. Complex and Analytic Signal Representations
Most commonly used measures of phase locking are derived
from complex signal representations of the type obtained with
a combination of band-limiting filter and Hilbert transform
or related procedures such as a continuous wavelet transform
[30], [31], short-time Fourier transform [32] or complex
demodulation [33]–[35]. In all cases, the resulting complex
signal can be understood as the outcome of a band-limiting
filter applied to the original real-valued signal.
It is common to think of the result as analytic, meaning that
it contains no negative frequencies, but this restriction is not
essential. The important feature is rather that the filter be of
a bandpass type, attenuating energy outside a single spectral
band. Because its spectrum must be symmetric about 0 Hz, a
real-valued signal fulfills this condition only if it is lowpass
filtered; for this reason, the result is in general complex-valued,
even when not strictly analytic. In the following discussion,
the term "analytic signal" will be used loosely to refer to any
2
complex-valued signal obtained with a single-band filter. The
conventional procedure combines an ordinary bandpass filter,
g, with a Hilbert-transform-approximating quadrature filter,
which suppresses energy in the negative band, so that the
complex-valued result is the filtered signal in the real part
and its (approximate) Hilbert transform in the imaginary part:
X(t) = g ∗ x(t) + iH {g ∗ x(t)}
(1)
In all cases, the result may be understood as the outcome of
a simple band-limiting filter, which will therefore contain no
spectral component lacking in the original signal.
The same nonlinearity of phase that complicates its spectral
interpretation also makes its meaning unclear when the signal
is the sum of many components. One purpose of bandpass
filtering in this setting is to isolate components in the hope
of obtaining an interpretable result. While bandpass filtering
is the simplest and most common approach the problem, it
is by no means the only one [36], [37]. To avoid questions
tangential to the present aim it will therefore be assumed that
the signal of interest, x, falls within the passband of g, so that
g∗ x(t) ≈ x(t), except where otherwise specified. Finally, it is
very often useful to represent the analytic signal in a form that
makes phase explicit, as the product of a positive real-valued
envelope function A(t) and a complex unit-magnitude valued
phase:
X(t) = Ax(t)eiφx(t)
with Ax = X(t) and φx = arg(X).
(2)
B. Cross Spectra and Coherency
Instantaneous linear relationships between complex signals
are quantified in the same way as for real-valued signals
through measures derived from the second moment at zero
lag:
RXY (t) = E [X(t)Y ∗(t)]
(3)
When X and Y are stationary, this expectation assumes a
constant value, which may then be estimated by integrating
over time:
1
T
AxAyei(φx−φy) dt
X(t)Y ∗(t) dt =
SXY =
(cid:90)
(cid:90)
1
T
(4)
T
T
Because the analysis filter in the present case, g introduces tim-
ing uncertainty, the relationship revealed by this is not properly
"instantaneous," rather its timing is ambiguous according to
the uncertainty relationship. Eq. (3) instead may be regarded
as an estimate of a cross-spectral coefficient within the band
of the analysis filter, g [38].
Measures of dependence derived from Sxy in essence reflect
the spectral overlap between signals within the originating
band. This fact follows from Plancherel's theorem:
X(ω) Y ∗(ω) dω
X(t)Y ∗(t) dt =
(cid:90) ∞
(cid:90) B
(5)
−∞
A
where the support of X(ω) Y ∗(ω) is restricted to the band
[A, B]. Two signals with non-overlapping spectra will there-
fore always have a cross-spectrum of 0. Signals whose spectra
overlap but are otherwise uncorrelated will yield cross-spectral
estimates subject
to small-sample bias tending to 0 with
increasing sample size.
Just as one quantifies the degree of instantaneous depen-
dence between real-valued sequences with Pearson's correla-
tion coefficient, a measure of dependence for analytic signals
is obtained by scaling the cross-spectral estimate, coherency:
(6)
Sxy(cid:112)SxxSyy
Cxy =
is,
that
Coherency differs from its real-valued analog in one critical
respect: its nature is composite, blending two distinct aspects
of the dependence between analytic signals. The first relates to
the correlation of envelopes, and the second to the consistency
of phase difference between the signals, ∆φxy = φx(t) −
φy(t),
their degree of phase locking. The overall
degree of dependence may be quantified by the magnitude
of the coherency, Cxy (referred to as coherence) while the
characteristic difference of phase between signals is given by
the argument (phase angle), θxy = arg Cxy.
Because of its composite nature, the meaning of coher-
ence is inherently ambiguous. A given value might reflect
either correlated amplitudes or phase locking. Moreover, the
contribution of each term depends on an interaction with
the other. When the signals remain in a perfectly constant
phase relationship (∆φxy(t) = c), coherence reduces to an
uncentered correlation of the amplitudes. In such cases, it will
tend to vary around some intermediate value when amplitudes
are uncorrelated, but it can assume any other value depending
on the variance and skewness of the amplitude distributions.
On the other hand, two signals that have no phase relationship
will give coherence that tends to 0, regardless of amplitude
correlation. This ambiguity represents a significant drawback
to an otherwise appealingly simple measure.
C. Measures on Phase Only
The problems with coherence motivate alternative measures
that are more easily interpreted. A seemingly straightforward
way to address the issue is to examine dependence between
the phases of analytic signals in isolation from amplitude.
Measures of pure phase dependence discard information about
signal amplitudes by dividing each signal by its own modulus,
thus normalizing away amplitude fluctuations:
Φx(t) =
X(t)
X(t) = eiφx(t)
(7)
The simplest of these pure phase measures, phase-locking
value (PLV), or phase coherency, computes coherency as in (6)
from the amplitude normalized signals, giving the expectation
of the phase difference vector, E(cid:0)ei∆φxy(cid:1) [2]. The magnitude
of this vector remains at 1 when the phase difference between
the signals is perfectly stable and tends to zero when there is
no consistent phase relationship. This measure also has an
intuitive geometric interpretation as the degree to which a
sample of unit length phase vectors, representing the angular
difference, align in the same direction.
One drawback of PLV is that it addresses only second-order
dependence between the phase vectors. More general forms
3
of dependence can be revealed through information-theoretic
metrics applied to the bivariate distribution of phase angles,
such as Kullback–Leibler divergence or the Kolmogorov–
Smirnov test. However, both PLV and these alternatives are
fundamentally measures on the same distribution of phase
angles, meaning that differences between them reflect
the
nature of the measure rather than any property of the quantity
measured. For this reason, one may view amplitude normal-
ization as implicit in measures based purely on phase, along
with any spectral consequence.
D. Nonstationary Extensions
Discussion has so far been confined to stationary and er-
godic signals, but it is often of interest to consider applications
in which stationarity is not assumed. One simple approach
to the nonstationary case accounts for time dependence by
introducing time-weighting to the estimator. Formulating Eq.
(4) as a Riemann-Stieltjes integral over the relevant weighting
measure allows the extension to apply both to continuous and
atomic weighting. Such weighting may, for example, describe
a subsampling of the signal used to reveal phase-locking at
specific delays with respect to some externally defined series
of events, allowing for event-related phase-locking analyses.
This point will be considered again briefly in section VI-C.
III. SPECTRAL BIAS FROM AMPLITUDE NORMALIZATION
We have just seen that measures derived from cross-spectral
estimates represent the dependence between signals within
their originating bands. The same is not true for measures
based purely on phase. This fact follows from the nonlinearity
of amplitude normalization, which may induce spectral com-
ponents outside the original signal bandwidth. Two signals that
initially shared no common spectral features, with coherence
strictly zero, may therefore exhibit nonzero coherence after the
normalization (i.e. phase locking) should any of the induced
spectral features happen to overlap. Next, we consider how
this comes about.
A. Origin in the Fourier Domain
Normalization entails multiplying the original band-limited
analytic signal, X(t), by a function obtained from the inverse
of its norm, Nx(t) = X(t)−1. The spectral consequences of
this follow from the convolution theorem, according to which
multiplying two signals in the time domain is equivalent to
convolving them in the frequency domain, and vice versa. As
a result, the spectrum of Φ is that of the original signal smeared
with the spectrum of its inverse envelope, creating a form of
spectral leakage bias.
One worrisome aspect of this is that the inverse envelope
tends to have a very broad spectrum because it contains large
spikes wherever the envelope approaches zero; as a result,
amplitude normalization tends to smear spectral energy across
a wide swath of the spectrum. The effect of such spectral
smearing can be appreciated most easily in phase "jumps" or
"slips" within the normalized signal. An example of this effect
is shown in Fig. 1 for an amplitude modulated signal composed
4
Spectral consequence of amplitude normalization. Top panels: the test signal, X(t) is composed of two sinusoids at 10 Hz and 12 Hz, whose
Fig. 1.
summation creates an amplitude modulated signal with center frequency 11 and modulation frequency of 2. Middle panels: the inverse amplitude function,
Nx(t), exhibits spikes where the amplitude envelope approaches 0, for which reason its spectrum, N (ω), includes harmonics of the modulation frequency.
Bottom panels: As a result of the convolution property of the Fourier transform, multiplying X by its inverse modulus to obtain Φ gives a signal that includes
harmonics and subharmonics of the test signal spaced at 2 Hz. These features create the potential for spurious phase locking if they overlap with features of
spectrally unrelated signals.
of the sum of a 10 Hz and a 12 Hz sinusoid, giving an 11
Hz signal modulated at 2 Hz. The inverse envelope contains
energy at all harmonics of the modulation frequency, as a
result of which the normalized signal also contains energy at
harmonics of 2 Hz in addition to 10 Hz and 12 Hz. These new
harmonics, which were not present in the original signal, may
create spurious phase locking if they overlap with components
of a compared signal.
B. Some Nasty Statistics, or, the Futility of Filtering
If the example in Fig. 1 seems contrived to produce broad
spectral artifacts, one may consider the somewhat more rele-
vant cases of random noise. For an analytic signal whose real
and imaginary parts are independent and Gaussian, amplitude
follows a Rayleigh distribution [39]. For this distribution one
finds that the inverse amplitude has a finite expected value,
(cid:10)X−1(cid:11) =
(cid:114) π
but unbounded variance,(cid:10)X−2(cid:11) → ∞
1
σ2
2
meaning in practice that sample variance for the inverse
amplitude will increase with sample size as the number of
intermittently appearing large outliers grows, creating a signal
whose energy comes increasingly to be dominated by such
outliers, whose spectrum therefore becomes broader as its
duration increases.
It is natural to suppose that bandpass filtering does away
with this problem by smoothing out the dips in amplitude
responsible for spectral broadening of the inverse. Casual
inspection of the signal might lead one to take this point for
granted, as a noisy signal initially full of phase jumps and
amplitude kinks looks smooth and oscillatory after filtering.
Unfortunately, any such improvement is an illusion: filtering
only decreases the effective sample size of the signal, thereby
decreasing sample variance of the inverse amplitude, but it
does not change the underlying distribution, which remains
as poorly behaved as before. To see why this must be true,
one need only note that decimating a stationary narrowband
Gaussian signal to a sampling rate that matches its bandwidth
should yield nearly independent Gaussian samples; but dec-
imation does not change the ergodic distribution of sampled
amplitudes.
A similar conclusion may be reached in an entirely different
way [21]: consider that the autocorrelation of the spectrum of
a signal is the Fourier transform of the square of the signal's
time envelope. The constant envelope of Φ entails a spectrum
composed of a single delta spike at 0 Hz. If a discrete finitely
sampled spectrum is band-limited, its autocorrelation must
contain a nonzero value at the lag separating the outermost
nonzero samples. This precludes the possibility that a band-
limited spectrum of a finite signal can generate the required
autocorrelation, unless the bandwidth is infinitesimal, in which
case the signal must be a pure sinusoid. This argument leaves
no escape from the conclusion that amplitude normalization
causes spectral broadening of the normalized signal, except in
trivial cases.
555657585960frequency (Hz)02468101214161820time (s)SignalRe{X(t)}andX(t) 1 X(t)SpectrumX(ω)N(ω)Φ(ω)N(t) =Φ(t) = N(t)X(t)dBscale∼∼∼ 5
modulation, as a peak at a given phase value means that the
progression of phase in the signal must linger around the peak
value, implying a drop in average instantaneous frequency. For
the signal to be zero-mean, such a dip must be accompanied
by a drop in amplitude to compensate for the corresponding
bias in the direction of phase. These spectral features in the
amplitude carry over to its inverse, and normalization therefore
induces a 0 Hz spectral component through the cancellation
of the dominant component in the original signal and the
matching (phase-locked) component in amplitude modulation.
Decentering bias therefore occurs whenever the phase and
magnitude of the underlying signal are correlated. This can
also be shown from the fact that the covariance of amplitude
and phase vector yields the expectation of the original signal,
which here is assumed to be 0:
E [XΦX ] = E[X] = 0
(8)
so that the two are second-order independent only if phase is
centered:
E [XΦX ] = E [X] E [ΦX ]
iff E [ΦX ] = 0
(9)
For this to happen in a stationary signal, the signal bandwidth,
which governs the spectral content of amplitude fluctuations,
generally must approach the spectral range of the signal, that
is, ∆W ≈ f1, where f1 is the lower bound of the signal
spectrum; however, because spectral leakage from amplitude
normalization may be infinitely extended, this condition should
be taken as a rule of thumb rather than a guarantee. The
example of two interfering sinusoids in Fig. 1 gives a simple
case in which spectral leakage extends to 0 Hz, even though
bandwidth condition is met.
It should be noted here that in spite of the examples consid-
ered in the previous sections, stationary Gaussian signals are
not susceptible to this type of bias because they are completely
characterized by their first two moments (mean and cross-
covariance). Any dependence between the signal envelope
and phase must involve moments of order 3 or higher. For
this reason, if the originating signals are strictly Gaussian,
pure phase-locking measures must still be directly related to
second order statistics, which has recently been confirmed by
Aydore et al. [12]. But many if not most biological signals are
manifestly non-Gaussian; this fact is exploited by widely-used
blind-source separation techniques, which equate sources with
maximally non-Gaussian signal components [40]. Here it will
likewise be taken for granted that the signals in question are
non-Gaussian.
A. The Problem with Recentering
Centering the normalized signal removes the bias resulting
from an off-center mean. It has been suggested that this cor-
rection effectively serves to uniformize the phase distribution,
implying that it deals more generally with problems related
to non-uniform phase [19]. Such a conclusion is premature
because it neglects another important consequence of recenter-
ing: following mean subtraction, phase vectors no longer have
uniformly unit length. It is therefore mistaken to suppose that
mean centering of the normalized signal implies a balancing
Fig. 2.
Example of decentering bias. Before amplitude normalization a
test signal with non-uniform phase distribution (inset) has a mean of zero
(top panel). After normalization (bottom panel) the mean is offset from zero
(dashed line). This effect can be understood as an instance of spectral leakage
from the original signal bandwidth to 0 Hz following normalization. Before
normalization, the analytic amplitude (gray line) is modulated with the same
period as the original signal. This fact induces the 0 Hz component following
multiplication by the inverse amplitude.
IV. DECENTERING BIAS
Spectral leakage from amplitude normalization increases the
opportunity for bias in measures of phase locking by spreading
energy in the Fourier domain, but this effect is not sufficient
by itself to create such bias. We will now consider a specific
example of how spectral leakage may cause the appearance of
a phase relationship between signals that are, in fact, entirely
independent. As touched on in the discussion of Eq. (4), cross-
spectral estimation generally does not involve mean centering
because the input signals are band-limited by assumption and
so should already have an expectation of 0. Clearly, spectral
leakage means this condition may no longer apply following
amplitude normalization.
An instance of this effect was recently highlighted by van
Driel et al. [19], who describe it as resulting from non-
uniformity of the distribution of phase angles in the input
signals. If this distribution is not at least radially symmetric,
any non-uniformity will cause a deviation of the expected
phase vector from the origin. One obtains a nonzero value
in the absence of any true correlation if both expectations
are nonzero. One solution may seem obvious at this point:
subtract the mean phase vector from at least one of the signals
before computing any statistics related to phase locking. From
our Fourier domain perspective, this correction amounts to
applying a maximally high-pass filter, eliminating only the
0 Hz component. There are immediate problems with this
solution, however, which will be considered in the following
section.
First, to understand how energy comes to be leaked to 0
Hz, consider that a peak in the distribution of a signal's phase
implies the presence of amplitude and frequency modulation
whose spectrum overlaps with that of the original signal
(Fig. 2). This is easiest to understand in terms of frequency
-2-1012-101Ref.gImfgjjhRefgiX(t)Φ(t)Phase distribution...time time −π−π 2 π 2 π 0rad of the distribution of phase angles. Instead, the correction
depends in part on a re-injection of some of modulation that
was removed through amplitude normalization.
The centered signal is:
Φ∗(t) = h(t)eiφ∗(t)
= eiφ(t) − µφeiθµ
(10)
where the amplitude-normalized signal before centering is
Φ(t) = eiφ(t) and the centering term is given as (cid:104)Φ(t)(cid:105) =
µφeiθµ. It is easy to see that this results in an amplitude
modulated signal with envelope:
h(t) =
1 + µφ2 − 2µφ cos (φ(t) − θµ)
(11)
(cid:113)
This mean-centered signal is no longer the pure representation
of phase we had hoped to obtain, and we find ourselves back
in the position from which we started.
B. Corrections to Recentering
The foregoing example illustrates the whack-a-mole char-
acter such corrections often assume in the spectral domain,
where compensating for one artifact introduces others else-
where. To preserve the desired properties of the phase vector,
we briefly point out two improvements to mean-subtraction.
1) Iterated recentering: The first of these simply repeats
recentering and normalization through multiple iterations:
Φ(n+1)
ic
(t) =
ic (t) − µ(n)
Φ(n)
h(n)(t)
φ
(12)
We have observed this to converge rapidly on a phase repre-
sentation with the desired properties: unit amplitude and zero
mean. The resulting distribution of phase is radially symmetric
but not generally uniform.
2) Phase Uniformization: The second correction enforces
a strictly uniform distribution by applying a suitable transfor-
mation to the phase angle [17]. This is easily done by passing
the angular representation of phase through its cumulative
distribution over [0, 2π]
φu(t) = 2π F (φ(t))
Such a correction is a more general fix for any problem that
might arise from a lack of uniformity. A possible drawback
in some settings is the need to estimate the cumulative
distribution function, F , which is a more complex problem
than recentering, involving more degrees of freedom. It may
therefore not suit cases in which a reliable estimate is difficult
to obtain, such as with small samples.
Most importantly, neither of these approaches addresses
the general problem of spectral bias. They only correct the
problem as it affects mean phase. We next consider how and
when such corrections fail.
V. BIAS AND CORRELATED AMPLITUDE MODULATION
We have just seen a concrete example of how spectral leak-
age might affect measures of phase locking through decenter-
ing of the amplitude normalized signal. We also reviewed some
simple techniques to correct that particular incarnation of bias.
6
Next we will describe conditions under which decentering bias
can escape any correction designed to recenter the distribution
of phase. The key to understanding how this comes about lies,
once again, in the spectral effect of amplitude modulation.
Modulating (i.e. multiplying) a signal, X(t) by a pure
complex sinusoid, eiωct, has the effect of shifting the entirety
of the signal's spectrum over by an amount equal
to the
frequency of the sinusoid. This follows directly from the
The result, X(ω − ωc), is therefore
convolution theorem.
in every respect identical to the original spectrum of X(ω),
except for having been shifted along the frequency axis by ωc.
This property brings up an important point that will prove
conceptually useful:
the invariance of the spectrum under
frequency translation carries over to all measures of phase
locking we have encountered so far. This follows from the fact
that the modulating term ωct enters into the complex argument
(phase angle) of the modulated signal and will therefore cancel
when computing the phase difference between two signals
that have been modulated by the same sinusoid, resulting in
the same outcome as if no modulation had been applied to
either.
It should also be apparent that this property extends
more generally to any complex-valued modulating signal with
unit amplitude, eiβ(t). Modulation of the original signal with
a complex unit-amplitude function will therefore cause some
of the 0 Hz component of the normalized signal, responsible
for decentering bias, to shift to modulating frequency(-ies).
In this scenario, it is possible for the mean phase vector to
be zero and the distribution of phase angles perfectly uniform
in the input signals. Yet, if the two signals under comparison
share amplitude modulation, the cancellation of the common
component in the argument reestablishes decentering bias.
The relevance of this to real-valued signals becomes clear by
constructing the modulating signal from a zero-mean analytic
signal B(t) = B(t)eiβ(t) representing amplitude fluctuations
around a constant offset µb:
b(t) = B(t) cos (β(t)) + µb
B(t)(cid:16)
eiβ(t) + e−iβ(t)(cid:17)
=
1
2
(13)
+ µb
Provided the spectrum of b(t) is confined to a lower
range of frequencies than the signal it modulates, x(t), the
Hilbert transform preserves the amplitude modulation with b
(Bedrosian's theorem) [41]:
H {b(t)x(t)} = b(t)H {x(t)}
(14)
Consequently, the analytic representation of the modulated
signal is
Abx(t)eφbx(t) = b(t)X(t)
(cid:104)B(t) eiβ(t) + B(t) e−iβ(t) + µb
(cid:105)
=
(15)
X(t)
From Eq. (15), one can see that modulation with a low-
frequency real-valued sinusoid (e.g. b(t) = cos(ωct), µb = 0)
has the effect of reduplicating and summing the original
spectrum,
translating one copy by +ωc and the other by
−ωc along the frequency axis. More generally, a smeared out
version of the original spectrum will be translated in both
directions by an amount reflecting the spectral range of B,
7
Fig. 3. Comparison of decentering bias in different measures. Test data are generated by skewing the magnitude of independent Gaussian samples drawn
from two processes exhibiting phase dependence. For both processes, amplitude is skewed according to an ellipse (example given in upper inset panel),
with the degree of skew related to eccentricity (). The phase differences (∆φ) between samples from each process follow a von Mises distribution with
scale parameter, κ. Compared measures are phase-locking value (PLV), centered phase-locking value (cPLV), iteratively centered phase locking (icPLV)
and amplitude-weighted phase locking (awPLV). Left columns, κ = 1.0, giving expected unbiased PLV of 0.45; Right columns, κ = 0.0, giving expected
unbiased PLV of 0 (i.e. no phase locking). The directional dependence of amplitude results in decentering bias in measures of phase locking that normalize
by magnitude; this bias is shown as the deviation from the proper phase locking value for the von Mises distribution used to generate phase differences.
Displayed values are averaged over 100 draws of 100 samples each and shown as a function of and ∆φ. Four cases are addressed: Top rows: amplitude skew
aligned in the same ( > 0) or opposite ( < 0) directions; Bottom rows: skew at right angles. In the presence of actual phase locking (left columns), PLV
and cPLV underestimate phase locking when the difference matches the skew directions. In the absence of phase locking (right columns), PLV overestimates
phase locking at large (note different color scales for left and right columns). Other measures are not affected. The differences in awPLV are a consequence
of increasing small sample bias rather than decentering (see section VI-A1 in the text).
creating "sidebands". If µb is nonzero, then a third copy at
the original location, the "baseband", will reflect the presence
of an offset (non-vanishing 0 Hz component) in the spectrum
of b.
The consequence this will have for measures of phase lock-
ing depends on the analysis filter used to obtain the relevant
statistics. If the passband covers the full spectral range of the
modulated signal, b(t)X(t), and if b is positive, the distribution
of phase remains unaffected because the modulation is retained
within the amplitude of the result. If the passband instead
isolates one of the side bands, Be±iβ, then the effect of
amplitude modulation enters into the phase of the result by
way of the complex argument.
Appendix A reviews three cases: (1) an analysis filter whose
passband covers the entire spectrum of the modulated signal
(broadband case); (2) a passband that covers only one of the
shifted sidebands (sideband case); and (3) a passband that
covers the unshifted band induced by any nonzero offset of
the modulating signal, as occurs when the modulating signal is
strictly non-negative (baseband case). In all cases, pure phase-
locking measures remain unaffected by the modulating signal
because any influence on the phase of the separate signals
cancels from the difference. This means, however that any
decentering bias in the unmodulated case remains in effect
after modulation, even though the distribution of phase may
be uniform within each side band. The off-center mean may
be obscured as a result of phase dispersion introduced by
amplitude modulation, making recentering ineffective. This
effect is illustrated in Fig. 5, which also compares some of
the alternative measures discussed in the following section,
"?"?εε PLV cPLVicPLVawPLV PLV cPLVicPLVawPLV PLV cPLVicPLVawPLV PLV cPLVicPLVawPLV0.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.055 = 1 Xe \→ .45-0.8-0.6-0.4-0.200.20.40.60.8-0.8-0.6-0.4-0.200.20.40.60.8-:-:20:2:-:-:20:2:-:-:20:2:-:-:20:2:iΔφ 5 = 0Xe \→ 0 Xe \iΔφ iΔφ 0.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.050.05Value minus -0.2-0.15-0.1-0.0500.05-0.0500.050.10.150.2εReImXY-0.8-0.6-0.4-0.200.20.40.60.8-0.8-0.6-0.4-0.200.20.40.60.8-0.8-0.6-0.4-0.200.20.40.60.8-0.8-0.6-0.4-0.200.20.40.60.8-0.8-0.6-0.4-0.200.20.40.60.8-0.8-0.6-0.4-0.200.20.40.60.8-:-:20:2:-:-:20:2:-:-:20:2:-:-:20:2:-0.25-0.15-0.15-0.15-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.15-0.15-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05εεεεεIm-0.25-0.25-0.15-0.15-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.15-0.15-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05ε 8
VI. REMEDIES
We have seen that measures of dependence taken directly
from the cross spectrum are not affected by the potentially
leakage produced by amplitude
severe forms of spectral
normalization (Fig. 5). But
the canonical measure in this
category, coherency, has other drawbacks, which diminish its
attractiveness as a proxy for phase locking; in particular, it
combines phase locking and amplitude correlation in a way
that complicates interpretation. In the following we consider
how the simple average used by PLV can be replaced with
a weighted average. A variant of this approach, amplitude-
weighted (awPLV), avoids amplitude normalization altogether,
instead retaining the original cross-spectral amplitude weight-
ing but with a rescaling that overcomes some of the interpre-
tational difficulties of coherence. These measures avoid any
effects of spectral broadening that follow from amplitude nor-
malization. We also briefly consider more general extensions
of this scheme to other types of weighted averages.
A. Amplitude-weighted Phase Locking
The covariance of two analytic signals that are perfectly
phase locked, meaning ∆φxy = φx(t) − φy(t) remains
constant, is given by:
(cid:90)
(cid:104)
Ax(t)Ay(t)ei∆φxy(t)(cid:105)
(cid:90)
E [Ax(t)Ay(t)] dt
E [Sxy] =
E
=ei∆φxy
dt
(16)
therefore consider a measure of "pure" phase
One might
locking that
the influence of amplitude co-
variance simply by normalizing the cross spectrum with
(cid:82) E [Ax(t)Ay(t)] dt. Equivalently, such a measure is obtained
factors out
from the normalization of coherency by the uncentered ampli-
tude correlation in the presence of phase locking.
(cid:112)(cid:104)X2(cid:105)(cid:104)Y 2(cid:105)
(cid:104)XY ∗(cid:105)
(cid:104)XY ∗(cid:105)
(cid:104)XY (cid:105) =
Υxy =
=
(cid:44) (cid:104)XY (cid:105)
(cid:112)(cid:104)X2(cid:105)(cid:104)Y 2(cid:105)
(cid:10)AxAye∆φxy(cid:11)
(cid:88)
(cid:104)AxAy(cid:105)
wte∆φxy[ti]
Υxy =
The result of this normalization has a natural interpretation as
a weighted-average phase coherence:
(17)
(18)
(19)
with weights given by normalized amplitude products:
t
AxAy(cid:80)
t AxAy
wt =
The meaning of this measure is therefore much more closely
aligned with that of phase-only measures, despite its close
relationship to coherence. Like PLV, its magnitude becomes
1 if the signals are perfectly phase locked, regardless of how
the amplitudes are related.
This measure will differ from standard PLV in three ways;
first, as already noted, it avoids spectral biases of the type
reviewed above. Second, like coherence, awPLV weights the
estimate towards samples with relatively greater amplitude,
Fig. 4. Test signal used to illustrate shifted decentering bias in Fig. 5. Top
panel: Five second example from a random test signal. Test signals contained
random and independent uncorrelated Gaussian transients modulated by a
common 0–6 Hz signal. The modulating signal (dashed line) was obtained by
squaring 1.5–3 Hz filtered white noise with mean of 1 and standard deviation
of 0.5 after filtering, to which a further positive 0.25 offset was added after
squaring. Power spectral density is shown in the bottom panel. The common
envelope was applied to 100 random uncorrelated trains of 25 ms std. width
Guassians with center times determined by positive peaks in 8–12 Hz filtered
white noise. A common 50 Hz pure sinusoid served as a positive comparison.
Total signal duration was 80 s. Middle panel: Signal after application of an
analysis filter centered at 12 Hz. The analysis filter applied a frequency-
domain cosine window over 0–24 Hz. The presence of the common low-
frequency amplitude modulation creates spurious phase locking in the range
of the uncorrelated train of gaussians at 12 Hz (see Fig. 5).
using test signals described in Fig. 4.
More generally, it is not necessary to assume that the bands
induced by amplitude modulation are fully separated by the
analysis filter. When the bands overlap so that the modulated
signal lacks distinct side bands or the analysis filter otherwise
provides an incomplete separation, the filtered signal contains
an unequally weighted sum of components arising from each
band. In such cases, the effect of amplitude modulation on
the phase of the result is will be intermediate to the side-
and broadband cases, depending on relative weighting, so that
recentering is still incompletely effective.
Unfiltered0 – 24 Hz filtered202122232425time (s)signal 1signal 2envelopeHzdB-50-40-30-20Avg. PSD0 ltered010203040506070Test Signal 9
Fig. 5.
Spectral bias in four measures of phase dependence applied to test signals exemplified in Fig. 4. Phase-locking measures were computed between
all 10,000 pairs of signals drawn from two sets of 100, and the figure color scale indicates the distribution of values for each frequency bin. Lines show
the median, 5th and 95th percentiles of these distributions. In all cases, the peak at 50 Hz reflects the 50 Hz positive comparison signal component. Top
panels: Mean-centered (icPLV) and conventional phase-locking values (PLV) both show spurious phase locking around 12 Hz, in the frequency range of the
uncorrelated train of gaussians, as a result of a common 1.5–3 Hz modulating envelope. Mean centering creates relatively greater suppression of the bias at
low frequencies (top left panel), which reflects the contribution of the unmodulated constant component of the envelope. Bottom panels: awPLV and coherence
are not affected by this bias. Measures were computed within overlapping cosine-windowed 16 Hz frequency bands using the DBT method (Kovach and
Gander, 2016).
and therefore will diverge from PLV if the phase difference
exhibits dependence on signal amplitudes. Third, as reviewed
in the following section, statistical properties of awPLV will
depend on effective sample size, which is always smaller for
a non-uniformly weighted average than for an unweighted
average.
1) Effective Sample Size: For a non-uniformly weighted
average, sample size is no longer an accurate reflection of the
degrees of freedom in the average, which is more accurately
reflected by the effective sample size, ν. For independent
samples, effective sample size is approximated as
ν =
t w2
t
(20)
In general, ν ≤ N. In the absence of phase locking, the
expected value of PLV is related to sample size; this small-
√
sample bias is given by the inverse square root of sample
N (assuming independent samples). Small-sample
size, 1/
bias is approximated for awPLV in the same way, substituting
effective sample size:
((cid:80)
t wt)2(cid:80)
Using this relationship one may define a bias-corrected mea-
sure, which is centered at zero in the absence of phase locking
and otherwise uses the full dynamic range between 0 and 1:
β =
1√
ν
Υ∗
xy =
Υxy − β
1 − β
(21)
(22)
This correction addresses another shortcoming of standard co-
herence estimates, which is that the degree of bias varies across
frequency, depending on the amplitude distributions within the
respective analysis bands [16], potentially creating the false
impression of frequency-dependent changes in coherence.
While inflated small-sample bias is clearly an impor-
tant consequence and possible disadvantage of non-uniform
weighting, the apparent loss of statistical power in awPLV
and coherence relative to PLV is very likely to be offset by
the fact that samples with amplitude approaching zero, for
which phase is either poorly defined or unlikely to reflect
any signal beyond the noise floor, are granted equal weight
in PLV. To the extent that phase locking is associated with the
amplitudes of the carrier signals, awPLV will therefore tend
to improve the signal to noise ratio. On the other hand, for
a signal contaminated with high-amplitude transients, such as
movement artifacts, awPLV will perform poorly, raising the
importance of careful artifact rejection.
For a bandpass-filtered signal, Eq. (21) is clearly not valid
when summing over contiguous samples because filtering
creates correlations among samples over time, violating the
assumption of independence. Using (21) will give a greatly
inflated estimate of the effective sample size in such cases.
One way to correct
the problem is by downsampling the
signal so that samples are more nearly independent; this is
conveniently addressed by spectral estimation techniques that
combine bandpass filtering with downsampling, adjusting sam-
010203040506070-0.100.10.20.30.4icPLV PLVawPLV, bias corrected CoherenceN050100150200250300350400Frequency (Hz)Frequency (Hz)010203040506070-0.100.10.20.30.4010203040506070-0.100.10.20.30.4010203040506070-0.100.10.20.30.4(Hz)(Hz) pling to the bandwidth of the analysis filter. We have recently
described such an approach, the demodulated band transform
(DBT) [35], which uses a frequency-domain implementation
of complex demodulation [33].
Effective sample size is strictly valid only when weights
are independent of phase, which may often fail to hold in the
presence of phase locking. It is, however, a valid assumption
under the null hypothesis of no phase locking. Null hypothesis
tests on awPLV address the question how likely one is to
obtain the observed value for two signals with the respective
amplitude envelopes in the absence of phase locking.
B. Permutation Tests
Statistical validation of phase locking frequently resorts to
a surrogate null distribution generated by shuffling data over
samples. The rationale is that shuffling abolishes any true
phase locking while leaving biases intact. The considerations
reviewed here show the limits of this assumption. In the
case of pure measures of phase locking, we have seen that
bias may depend on correlations of the signal amplitudes.
Clearly, shuffling destroys any amplitude correlation along
with phase locking, meaning that the surrogate distribution
will fail to account for any related bias. Although awPLV
avoids spectral biases, it is not immune to this problem because
shuffling may systematically change effective sample size,
likewise ruining the validity of the comparison. By increasing
the variance of the product of amplitudes, positive correlations
depress effective sample size; shuffling may therefore produce
a systematic decrease in small sample bias, raising type I error
in any test that relies on the comparison to shuffled data.
There seem to be few perfectly satisfactory options for
addressing this problem. One is to shuffle phase independently
of amplitude, but
this creates distortions similar to those
arising from amplitude normalization. A better alternative
might be to shuffle amplitude and phase in tandem but reduce
(or increase) the number of samples in the averages drawn
from the surrogate distribution in proportion to
N (k) = N
ν
ν(k)
(23)
where ν(k) is the effective sample size of the kth resampling
including N samples. Such an adjustment at least removes
the tendency for systematic changes in effective sample size,
although it does not exactly recreate the amplitude distribution
of the original signals. Another more complicated approach
might be to stratify the permutation by amplitude, so that
surrogate data maintain a similar amplitude profile.
C. Generalized Weighting
One might also consider alternative weighting schemes
other than simple amplitude weighting as used by awPLV;
for example, Ehm et al. suggest discarding samples when-
ever amplitude drops below some threshold [42]. In general,
reweighting will take the form:
(cid:82) ΦxΦ∗
Ψxy =
y dW (t,X(t),Y (t))
(cid:82) dW
(24)
10
(cid:88)
(cid:90)
(cid:88)
The hat symbol, used here to indicate an estimator, is de-
liberately retained in (24) because this notion of weighting
also encompasses sampling of the signal at specific points in
time within some window of observation. So that it applies
to this range of cases, the notation in Eq. (24) expresses the
measure as a Riemann–Stieltjes integral, which is a formality
valid for both discrete atomic and continuous weighting. In
general, cross-spectral measures are optimal with respect to
spectral
leakage, so any form of weighting other than a
rescaling of the amplitude product will create some additional
spectral broadening. Nevertheless, reweighting may improve
the measure in other ways, such as in moderating small-sample
bias and other non-spectral-leakage-related biases imparted by
amplitude weighting.
Such reweighting is also implicit when samples are drawn
from selected time points, as arises generally in the context
of digital signal processing, but also more specifically when
measuring phase locking at certain time delays, τ, from some
event, such as trial onset. This case is represented by the
following estimator:
Ψxy(τ ) =
=
w(t)Φxy
δ (t − ti − τ ) dt
i
w (ti + τ ) Φxy (ti + τ )
(25)
i
for which weighting is the composite of a continuous weight-
ing function w and the subsampling represented by the delta
train. To understand the spectral consequences of such sub-
sampling, one may note that the Fourier transform of a train
of delta functions with period ∆T is also a periodic train
of spikes in the frequency domain, with period 2π/∆T . One
can observe that this form of "windowing" has the effect
of reduplicating the original signal spectrum at frequency
intervals of 2π/∆T . If the period of the original train is
less than the inverse bandwidth of the signal, expected cross-
spectral estimates remain unchanged because the reduplicated
spectra do not overlap. More generally,
the cross-spectral
estimate will be relatively unaffected if the minimum interval
between samples is less than the inverse bandwidth of the
signal. This point simply restates the well-known Whittaker–
Nyquist sampling theorem.
In event-related analyses the goal is to reveal nonstationari-
ties associated with some event. In this context, sampled points
are widely spaced and the reduplicated spectral windows over-
lap, which implies convolutional smearing within the signal
bandwidth. Any systematic change that results from this is
not necessarily cause for concern, however, as it captures the
nonstationarities that motivated the sampling in the first case.
VII. DISCUSSION
A. Some Advantages of Linearity
We have treated spectral broadening related to the nonlin-
earity of phase locking as a form of bias, though we also noted
at the outset that this might fairly be considered an abuse of
terminology. The nonlinearity of phase extraction is in fact
faithful to the nature of analytic phase; what we have taken to
calling bias is a genuine property of the signal, not the result of
bias in the usual meaning of the word. More accurately stated,
the problem is a choice between approximations: whether
to approximate phase locking with measures that preserve
linearity or to treat nonlinear measures as approximately linear
in our interpretation of them (wittingly or unwittingly).
One key advantage of the first option is that the underlying
measures behave in a more consistent and predictable fashion.
In particular, nonlinear effects are sensitive to the parameters
of the analysis filter in ways that are difficult to expect, making
the second approximation unreliable. A good example of this
is given in section IV, where we observed that decentering
bias depends on some overlap between the spectrum of the
signal envelope and the signal itself. Decreasing the analysis
bandwidth tends to eliminate or attenuate the overlap, making
the bias disappear. On the other hand, decentering bias masked
by correlated amplitude modulation occurs when the analysis
filter was sufficiently narrow to isolate individual sidebands
arising from the modulation. Both of these effects show the
sensitivity of the result to the analysis filter. In contrast, for
stationary cross-spectral estimates, changing the analysis filter
bandwidth affects frequency resolution but does not funda-
mentally change the result. While broader filters provide a less
highly resolved spectral estimate, the decomposition into more
finely grained bands remains additive: the picture becomes
sharper (and noisier), but it does not otherwise change.
Some authors have cautioned against narrow filters because
they artificially force the signal
to take on an oscillatory
character [43] and create timing ambiguities [44]. A rejoinder
to the first point is that techniques which couple filtering
with complex demodulation and downsampling matched to
bandwidth, don't yield an inherently oscillatory signal rep-
resentation [35]. The equivalence between these techniques
and the more standard approach to filtering shows that the
oscillations in filtered data are really an artifact of the choice
of representation; the errors associated with narrow filtering
come from treating the signal as though it might occupy a
wider bandwidth than what has been forced upon it, but these
errors may be forestalled through downsampling. With respect
to the second point, detailed timing information also remains
encoded in the relationship of phase across multiple bands,
from which it may be recovered using, for example, an inverse
Fourier transform computed across bands.
B. Extensions
Amplitude-weighted PLV joins a host of other measures
designed to address various shortcomings of PLV and coher-
ence. Alternative measures have been proposed to better cope
with small sample bias [22], volume conduction [45], as well
as decentering bias [19] and combinations of these problems
[46]. Each of these proposed alternatives has its strengths
and weakness, making it suited to some applications but not
others, which is certainly also the case for awPLV. Most of
these measures are meant to address problems with analytic
signals considered in isolation. One important advantage of
linearity-preserving measures derived from cross spectra is
that the array of tools afforded by spectral analysis remain
applicable; these might serve to isolate signal components of
11
interest or to more clearly identify salient properties of the
dependence. For example, the time-domain representation of
cross-spectral estimators as impulse response functions may
reveal useful information about timing that is not reliably
conveyed by phase lags considered in isolation. This point
becomes especially relevant whenever within-band time reso-
lution is lost to narrowband filtering. It is easy to forget that
detailed timing information is nevertheless preserved in the
relative phase across multiple bands, which may be recovered
through the inverse Fourier transform.
VIII. CONCLUSION
We have reviewed some pitfalls common to measures of
dependence derived from analytic phase and discussed simple
approaches to remedying these. The main points are:
1) Obtaining analytic phase involves a nonlinear transfor-
mation of the signal that may at times create unexpected
biases and complicate spectral interpretation (Section
III-V).
2) Pure measures of phase exhibit some poor statistical
properties in the presence of noise, including spectral
biases that grow with sample size. By reducing effective
sample size, filtering to limit signal bandwidth provides
only an apparent but not an actual remedy for this
problem (Section III-B).
3) Measures of linear dependence taken directly from the
cross spectrum, such as coherence, preserve spectral
specificity and are often statistically better behaved in
comparison to pure-phase statistics (Section VI).
4) One such measure, amplitude-weighted phase locking,
avoids the ambiguity that is a major drawback of coher-
ence (Section VI-A).
5) Phase is often more informative considered across mul-
tiple bands jointly than in isolation, especially when
drawing inferences related to timing. (Section VII-A).
ACKNOWLEDGMEMTS
The author wishes to thank Phillip E. Gander, Yuki Kikuchi
and Christopher Petkov.
REFERENCES
[1] P. L. Nunez, R. Srinivasan, A. F. Westdorp, R. S. Wijesinghe, D. M.
Tucker, R. B. Silberstein, and P. J. Cadusch, "Eeg coherency: I: statistics,
reference electrode, volume conduction, laplacians, cortical imaging, and
interpretation at multiple scales," Electroencephalography and clinical
neurophysiology, vol. 103, no. 5, pp. 499–515, 1997.
[2] J.-P. Lachaux, E. Rodriguez, J. Martinerie, F. J. Varela et al., "Measuring
phase synchrony in brain signals," Human brain mapping, vol. 8, no. 4,
pp. 194–208, 1999.
[3] F. Mormann, K. Lehnertz, P. David, and C. E. Elger, "Mean phase
coherence as a measure for phase synchronization and its application
to the eeg of epilepsy patients," Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena, vol.
144, no. 3, pp. 358–369, 2000.
[4] R. T. Canolty and R. T. Knight, "The functional role of cross-frequency
coupling," Trends in cognitive sciences, vol. 14, no. 11, pp. 506–515,
2010.
[5] A. B. Tort, R. Komorowski, H. Eichenbaum, and N. Kopell, "Measuring
phase-amplitude coupling between neuronal oscillations of different
frequencies," Journal of neurophysiology, vol. 104, no. 2, pp. 1195–
1210, 2010.
[6] H. P. Zaveri, R. B. Duckrow, and S. S. Spencer, "The effect of
a scalp reference signal on coherence measurements of intracranial
electroencephalograms," Clinical Neurophysiology, vol. 111, no. 7, pp.
1293–1299, 2000.
[7] S. J. Schiff, "Dangerous phase," Neuroinformatics, vol. 3, no. 4, pp.
315–317, 2005.
[8] R. Guevara, J. L. P. Velazquez, V. Nenadovic, R. Wennberg, G. Sen-
janovi´c, and L. G. Dominguez, "Phase synchronization measurements
using electroencephalographic recordings," Neuroinformatics, vol. 3,
no. 4, pp. 301–313, 2005.
[9] M. Chavez, M. Besserve, C. Adam, and J. Martinerie, "Towards a
proper estimation of phase synchronization from time series," Journal
of neuroscience methods, vol. 154, no. 1, pp. 149–160, 2006.
[10] P. Celka, "Statistical analysis of the phase-locking value," IEEE Signal
Processing Letters, vol. 14, no. 9, pp. 577–580, Sept 2007.
[11] M. A. Kramer, A. B. Tort, and N. J. Kopell, "Sharp edge artifacts and
spurious coupling in eeg frequency comodulation measures," Journal of
neuroscience methods, vol. 170, no. 2, pp. 352–357, 2008.
[12] S. Aydore, D. Pantazis, and R. M. Leahy, "A note on the phase
locking value and its properties," NeuroImage, vol. 74, pp. 231–244,
2013. [Online]. Available: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/
pii/S1053811913001286
[13] J. Aru, J. Aru, V. Priesemann, M. Wibral, L. Lana, G. Pipa, W. Singer,
and R. Vicente, "Untangling cross-frequency coupling in neuroscience,"
Current opinion in neurobiology, vol. 31, pp. 51–61, 2015.
[14] R. Srinath and S. Ray, "Effect of amplitude correlations on coherence
in the local field potential," Journal of neurophysiology, vol. 112, no. 4,
pp. 741–751, 2014.
[15] A. M. Bastos and J.-M. Schoffelen, "A tutorial review of functional con-
nectivity analysis methods and their interpretational pitfalls," Frontiers
in Systems Neuroscience, vol. 9, no. 175, 2016.
[16] E. Lowet, M. J. Roberts, P. Bonizzi, J. Karel, and P. De Weerd,
"Quantifying neural oscillatory synchronization: A comparison between
spectral coherence and phase-locking value approaches," PloS one,
vol. 11, no. 1, 2016.
[17] B. Kralemann, L. Cimponeriu, M. Rosenblum, A. Pikovsky, and
R. Mrowka, "Phase dynamics of coupled oscillators reconstructed from
data," Physical Review E, vol. 77, no. 6, p. 066205, 2008.
[18] R. Cox, J. van Driel, M. de Boer, and L. M. Talamini, "Slow oscil-
lations during sleep coordinate interregional communication in cortical
networks," The Journal of Neuroscience, vol. 34, no. 50, pp. 16 890–
16 901, 2014.
[19] J. van Driel, R. Cox, and M. X. Cohen, "Phase-clustering bias in
phase–amplitude cross-frequency coupling and its removal," Journal of
neuroscience methods, vol. 254, pp. 60–72, 2015.
[20] N. Papp and P. Ktonas, "Critical evaluation of complex demodulation
techniques for the quantification of bioelectrical activity," Biomedical
sciences instrumentation, vol. 13, p. 135145, 1977. [Online]. Available:
http://europepmc.org/abstract/MED/871500
[21] B. Picinbono, "On instantaneous amplitude and phase of signals," IEEE
Transactions on Signal Processing, vol. 45, no. 3, pp. 552–560, Mar
1997.
[22] M. Vinck, M. van Wingerden, T. Womelsdorf, P. Fries, and C. M.
Pennartz, "The pairwise phase consistency: a bias-free measure of
rhythmic neuronal synchronization," Neuroimage, vol. 51, no. 1, pp.
112–122, 2010.
[23] W. J. Freeman, "Origin, structure, and role of background {EEG}
amplitude," Clinical Neurophysiology,
[Online]. Available: http:
activity. part 1.
vol. 115, no. 9, pp. 2077–2088, 2004.
//www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1388245704001695
analytic
[24] L. Mandel, "Interpretation of instantaneous frequencies," American Jour-
nal of Physics, vol. 42, no. 10, pp. 840–846, 1974. [Online]. Available:
http://scitation.aip.org/content/aapt/journal/ajp/42/10/10.1119/1.1987876
[25] B. Boashash, "Estimating and interpreting the instantaneous frequency
of a signal. i. fundamentals," Proceedings of the IEEE, vol. 80, no. 4,
pp. 520–538, 1992.
[26] P. J. Loughlin and B. Tacer, "Comments on the interpretation of
instantaneous frequency," IEEE Signal Processing Letters, vol. 4, no. 5,
pp. 123–125, May 1997.
[27] P. Loughlin and B. Tacer, "Instantaneous frequency and the conditional
mean frequency of a signal," Signal Processing, vol. 60, no. 2,
pp. 153–162, 1997. [Online]. Available: http://www.sciencedirect.com/
science/article/pii/S0165168497800035
[28] J. d. Ville et al., "Th´eorie et applications de la notion de signal
analytique," Cables et transmission, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 61–74, 1948.
[29] L. Cohen, "Time-frequency distributions-a review," Proceedings of the
IEEE, vol. 77, no. 7, pp. 941–981, Jul 1989.
12
[30] M. Le Van Quyen, J. Foucher, J.-P. Lachaux, E. Rodriguez, A. Lutz,
J. Martinerie, and F. J. Varela, "Comparison of hilbert transform and
wavelet methods for the analysis of neuronal synchrony," Journal of
neuroscience methods, vol. 111, no. 2, pp. 83–98, 2001.
[31] A. Bruns, "Fourier-, hilbert-and wavelet-based signal analysis: are they
really different approaches?" Journal of neuroscience methods, vol. 137,
no. 2, pp. 321–332, 2004.
[32] D. Gabor, "Theory of communication. part 1: The analysis of in-
formation," Electrical Engineers-Part III: Radio and Communication
Engineering, Journal of the Institution of, vol. 93, no. 26, pp. 429–441,
1946.
[33] C. Bingham, M. D. Godfrey, and J. W. Tukey, "Modern techniques of
power spectrum estimation," Audio and Electroacoustics, IEEE Trans-
actions on, vol. 15, no. 2, pp. 56–66, 1967.
[34] J. B. Allen and L. R. Rabiner, "A unified approach to short-time fourier
analysis and synthesis," Proceedings of the IEEE, vol. 65, no. 11, pp.
1558–1564, 1977.
[35] C. K. Kovach and P. E. Gander, "The demodulated band transform,"
Journal of Neuroscience Methods, vol. 261, pp. 135–154, 2016.
[36] N. E. Huang, Z. Shen, S. R. Long, M. C. Wu, H. H. Shih, Q. Zheng, N.-
C. Yen, C. C. Tung, and H. H. Liu, "The empirical mode decomposition
and the hilbert spectrum for nonlinear and non-stationary time series
analysis," in Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A: Mathemati-
cal, Physical and Engineering Sciences, vol. 454, no. 1971. The Royal
Society, 1998, pp. 903–995.
[37] S. G. Mallat and Z. Zhang, "Matching pursuits with time-frequency
dictionaries," IEEE Transactions on signal processing, vol. 41, no. 12,
pp. 3397–3415, 1993.
[38] L. H. Koopmans, The spectral analysis of time series. Academic press,
[39] K. Krishnamoorthy, Handbook of statistical distributions with applica-
1995.
tions. CRC Press, 2015.
[40] R. Vigario, J. Sarela, V. Jousmiki, M. Hamalainen, and E. Oja, "Inde-
pendent component approach to the analysis of eeg and meg recordings,"
IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, vol. 47, no. 5, pp. 589–
593, May 2000.
[41] E. Bedrosian, "A product theorem for hilbert transforms," Proceedings
of the IEEE, vol. 51, no. 5, pp. 868–869, 1963.
[42] W. Ehm and J. Kornmeier, "Detecting frequency-specific phase syn-
chrony in brain electrical oscillations," Proceedings of Fechner Day,
vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 411–416, 2009.
[43] N. Yeung, R. Bogacz, C. B. Holroyd, and J. D. Cohen, "Detection of
synchronized oscillations in the electroencephalogram: an evaluation of
methods," Psychophysiology, vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 822–832, 2004.
[44] R. Vanrullen, "Four common conceptual fallacies in mapping the time
course of recognition," Frontiers in Psychology, vol. 2, p. 365, 2011.
[Online]. Available: http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.
2011.00365
[45] C. J. Stam, G. Nolte, and A. Daffertshofer, "Phase lag index: assess-
ment of functional connectivity from multi channel eeg and meg with
diminished bias from common sources," Human brain mapping, vol. 28,
no. 11, pp. 1178–1193, 2007.
[46] M. Vinck, R. Oostenveld, M. van Wingerden, F. Battaglia, and C. M.
Pennartz, "An improved index of phase-synchronization for electrophys-
iological data in the presence of volume-conduction, noise and sample-
size bias," Neuroimage, vol. 55, no. 4, pp. 1548–1565, 2011.
APPENDIX A
EFFECT OF AMPLITUDE MODULATION
A. Effect of Modulation on the Cross Spectrum
1) Broadband Case: If the analysis window, within which
the cross spectrum is to be estimated, spans both of the
positively and negatively translated range of copies of the
original signal, then the conjugate product of two identically
modulated signals is given by:
b2XY ∗ =
AxAyei∆φxy
+ µ2
b + 2µbB cos (β) +
1
2
B2 cos (2β)
(cid:18) 1
2
(cid:19)
13
two signals. If the value of b may become negative, phase
undergoes a π rad flip with every sign change. As a result, the
phase distribution for each signal will become more symmetric
and the mean phase vector will tend towards zero as the
probability of b assuming either sign approaches 0.5. However,
in this case there is still no effect on the resulting phase
difference, as
ΦbX Φ∗
bY = (sgn(b))2 e∆φxy = e∆φxy
a.s.
In that case, recentering will provide no remedy for bias. The
±π jumps occurring at each flip of the sign of B will also
contribute to spectral broadening.
2) Sideband Case: As before, when the analysis filter
covers only one of the side bands of the modulating signal,
phase is approximated by
ΦBX =
BX
BX = eiφx+iβ
(30)
In this case, the modulating term enters only the complex
argument of each signal, therefore canceling from the phase
difference and leaving measures of phase locking unchanged.
However, the distribution of the phase of input signals will
come to reflect φx(t) + β(t), and so will be dispersed if φx
and β vary independently. Mean centering therefore has little
chance of suppressing bias in this case.
3) Baseband Case: If the analysis filter only covers the
baseband, the results are unchanged from the unmodulated
signal, as the signal within the analysis band is the same as it
was before modulation, except for having been scaled by µb.
Any decentering bias in this band will therefore be corrected
by mean subtraction, as before.
For simplicity, we consider the case when the envelope of the
modulating signal B is independent of Ax and Ay, so that
(cid:10)b2XY ∗(cid:11) =(cid:18) 1
(cid:19)
Sxy + 2µbµB (cid:104)XY ∗ cos (β)(cid:105)
(26)
σ2
b + µ2
b
b (cid:104)XY ∗ cos (2β)(cid:105)
σ2
2
1
2
+
Thus the cross-spectral estimate now includes two 3rd order
moments with the modulating phase, such that whenever the
phase difference between X and Y , ∆φxy(t), assumes a
consistent relationship with any of ±2β(t) or ±β(t), it will
contribute to the estimate. Correlations between the envelopes
Ax and Ay and the modulating phase will also influence the
result.
Such dependence between the signals and their common
source of modulation may influence coherence, but the in-
terpretation is clear: it reflects the fact that the cross-spectral
measures are weighted according to amplitude. Such measures
will therefore tend to reflect the characteristic phase relation-
ship when the product of the signal amplitudes is large.
On the other hand, if there is no relationship between B
and either of the signals or their amplitudes, the outcome is
only a rescaling of the original cross-spectrum:
(cid:10)b2XY ∗(cid:11) =
(cid:18) 1
(cid:0)σ2
2
Sxy
b + κ1 + κ2
(27)
where κj = (cid:104)cos(jβ)(cid:105). In the large-sample limit, the effect
of such constant scaling will cancel from coherence (although
we will later see that B still plays a role in small sample bias).
2) Sideband Case: If the analysis window only spans one
of the shifted spectral bands arising from modulation with b,
then the outcome of filtering resembles
(cid:19)
(cid:1) + µb
bX =
1
2
AxBei∆φxy+iβ
(cid:10)B2XY ∗(cid:11) =
1
4
The complex argument of B cancels out in the cross-spectral
estimate giving
σ2
b Sxy
(28)
here assuming independence between B and the phase
difference ∆φxy(t). In calculating coherence,
the constant
multiplicative terms above will cancel out in the large-sample
limit, although as mentioned, modulation may still affect
small-sample bias.
3) Baseband case: If the analysis window covers only the
baseband created by any nonzero constant offset µb, the result
is unchanged except for being scaled by µ2
b.
B. Effect of Modulation on Phase Locking
1) Broadband Case: Again, when the analysis window
spans the full range of the modulated signal, we have
ΦbX =
bX
bX =
b
b eiφx = sgn(b)eiφx
(29)
If b is strictly positive then modulation clearly has no effect
on the distribution of phases or phase differences between
|
1611.08928 | 2 | 1611 | 2017-03-21T17:15:23 | A theory of interpretive clustering in free recall | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cs.CL"
] | A stochastic model of short-term verbal memory is proposed, in which the psychological state of the subject is encoded as the instantaneous position of a particle diffusing over a semantic graph with a probabilistic structure. The model is particularly suitable for studying the dependence of free-recall observables on semantic properties of the words to be recalled. Besides predicting some well-known experimental features (contiguity effect, forward asymmetry, word-length effect), a novel prediction is obtained on the relationship between the contiguity effect and the syllabic length of words; shorter words, by way of their wider semantic range, are predicted to be characterized by stronger forward contiguity. A fresh analysis of archival data allows to confirm this prediction. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | A theory of interpretive clustering in free recall
Francesco Fumarola
(Dated: August 6, 2018)
A stochastic model of short-term verbal memory is proposed, in which the psy-
chological state of the subject is encoded as the instantaneous position of a particle
diffusing over a semantic graph with a probabilistic structure. The model is par-
ticularly suitable for studying the dependence of free-recall observables on semantic
properties of the words to be recalled. Besides predicting some well-known experi-
mental features (contiguity effect, forward asymmetry, word-length effect), a novel
prediction is obtained on the relationship between the contiguity effect and the syl-
labic length of words; shorter words, by way of their wider semantic range, are
predicted to be characterized by stronger forward contiguity. A fresh analysis of
archival data allows to confirm this prediction.
I. FREE RECALL: MATRIX MODELS AND GRAPH MODELS
Free-recall experiments are a key tool for the controlled investigation of episodic memory.
A typical free-recall experiment takes place in two stages: during the "presentation stage",
subjects are shown a list of words; during the "memory test", they are requested to recall
them in any order.
Some of the main effects reported are:
(1) power-law scaling: the number of retrieved items scales like a power law of the number
of items in the list (Murray et al., 1976);
(2) the contiguity effect: items contiguous within the list tend to be recalled contiguously
(Kahana, 1996);
(3) forward asymmetry, i.e. the tendency to recall items in forward order (already re-
ported in Ebbinghaus, 1913);
(4) the word length effect: lists of shorter words are recalled better than lists of longer
words (Baddeley et al., 1975).
The contiguity effect and several other phenomena are now well understood by means
of retrieved-context theories of episodic memory such as the Temporal Context Model of
7
1
0
2
r
a
M
1
2
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
2
v
8
2
9
8
0
.
1
1
6
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
2
Howard and Kahana (2002). In these theories, the recovery of a memory is mediated by the
recovery of its "temporal context", and temporal contexts are modeled through a matrix
representation that undergoes a linear evolution in time.
While the effectiveness of these theories is undisputed, recently Romani et al. (2013)
have introduced a somewhat different approach to the modeling of free recall, based not on
matrix methods but on what we will refer to as semantic graphs.
Each node of the graph corresponds, in this description, to a different word in the list.
Retrieval is effected by a diffusive particle moving over the semantic graph, and the subject's
psychological state at each moment is encoded as the current position of the particle. When-
ever the particle moves onto a certain node, the word associated to that node is recalled.
Diffusion is terminated when the path self-intersects.
This scenario was introduced as a toy version of a subtler neural-network model and was
used it to compute explicitly the power-law scaling of retrieval. The power-law exponent
was found to be 1/2, which is indeed close to experimental values. This is a substantial
result that may not have been as easy to obtain through more conventional theories, and it
encourages further exploration of graph methods in the study of free recall.
In this paper, a versatile graph-based model is proposed and, in its simplest form, is
used to extract observable quantities. Some well-known free-recall effects are thus given a
possible new explanation, while a novel effect is predicted and verified by comparison with
data.
I begin by introducing, in the next section, a more realistic family of semantic graphs,
allowing for both random edges and multiple meanings, and I proceed to demonstrate that
the resulting theory exhibits both the contiguity effect and forward asymmetry. I then recall
some well-established results from linguistics concerning the correlation between meaning
and word-length. Applying these to the diffusive-particle model yields a prediction on the
correlation between word-length and the contiguity effect. This prediction is checked through
an original analysis of archival free-recall data. Finally, I show that the underlying mecha-
nism may also provide a semantically grounded explanation for the word-length effect.
3
II. THE SEMANTIC GRAPH AS A RANDOM GRAPH
One assumption made in Romani et al.
is that the semantic graph is complete. In the
most general case, however, we have no detailed information on the structure of the semantic
graph; moreover, because semantic associations are built through individual experience, they
vary from subject to subject over any population. Both uncertainty and variability can be
taken into account by assuming the graph's edges to be chosen at random. The semantic
graph is then a probabilistic graph with a fixed number of nodes.
Call P (G) the probability weight for a specific graph G. The full distribution P (G)
encodes the probabilistic structure of the semantic graph. The quantities we want to predict
(recall probabilities) can be computed by simulating trajectories on each possible graph G
and averaging results over all such graphs, the average being weighed with the factor P (G).
The theory has thus become conceptually closer to conventional retrieved-context theo-
ries. In a non-complete graph, indeed, some pairs of nodes are more closely connected than
others, and since memories are located on individual nodes, we can say of a memory that it
belongs to a certain "region" of the graph. This is equivalent to the statement that a mem-
ory belongs to a certain "context" in retrieved-context theories. The semantic graph may be
seen, therefore, as describing the structure of contextual states (Kahana and Howard, 2002),
which is a probabilistic structure both because of our ignorance of its details and because
of its variability across a population.
A graph model of free recall involves this probabilistic structure in a direct and explicit
way, and may therefore become helpful as part of an endeavor to elucidate the semantic
graph empirically. Connections between various semantic contexts are fully encoded in the
distribution P (G); if we compute the recall probabilities for various choices of the distri-
bution P (G) and compare them with the experimental values, the "true" structure of the
semantic graph will be the choice of P (G) that yields the best agreement with the data.
In this paper, we try out what is arguably the simplest trial distribution P (G), corre-
sponding to a G(N, p) Erdos-R´enyi model with p = 1 − α. In other words, the edges of
the complete graph are removed independently on each other, each having a probability α
of being removed. If α = 0, the semantic graph is complete; for arbitrary values of α, the
probability associated to a given graph with n edges is P (k) = (1 − α)nα
N(N −1))
2
−n .
4
FIG. 1: Panel A: particle diffusing through a complete graph as in the model of Romani et al.,
2013. Panel B: diffusion on a non-complete graph. Panel C: diffusion on a non-complete graph
with the inclusion of polysemy; in this particular example, each word has two semantic nuances, or
"meanings", represented by as many nodes. Nodes of the same color represent different meanings
of the same word.
III.
INTRODUCING POLYSEMY
Before computing measurable quantities, i.e. recall probabilities, we must notice a second
limitation to the model used by Romani et al.. The graph they employ represents every
word in the vocabulary as a single node. On the other hand, fMRI measurements have
convincingly shown that the neural response to free-recall tests exhibits a strong statistical
dependence on the semantic variability of words (Musz and Thompson-Schill, 2015).
In linguistics, the degree of dependence of a word's meaning on context is called polysemy
(Nerlich et al., 2003). Of course, since meaning is inevitably affected by context, no word is
perfectly "monosemic" (i.e. having a single nuance of meaning), but a word with compara-
tively little semantic variability is called "oligosemic" (Fernando, 1996). To graft polysemy
into the graph model, we must identify the nodes of the semantic graph with "meanings"
(or semantic nuances) rather than with words, allowing each word to label multiple nodes.
A word W will then have a degree of polysemy k(W ), defined as the number of nodes
corresponding to word W .
In the simplest scenario the degree of polysemy will have a
constant value K, the same for all words (Fig. 1C).
If the semantic graph is complete, each node will be linked to K − 1 nodes corresponding
to the same word, and to K nodes corresponding to every other word in the vocabulary. If
the semantic graph is the Erdos-R´enyi graph G(KN, 1 − α), with nodes labeled by the N
words, a node corresponding to any given word will be linked on average to (1 − α)K nodes
5
corresponding to every other word, a well as (1 − α)(K − 1) same-word nodes.
Given that each word corresponds to multiple nodes, one question arises concerning the
retrieval process. Will a word be recalled when the diffusive particle touches any of the
nodes corresponding to it? Or are memories encoded each in a given node, even when the
word to be recalled has multiple meanings?
The literature on context-retrieved theories suggests that the latter option holds true.
Indeed, we know that memories are anchored to the contextual region where they have
been created during the presentation of the list (Howard and Kahana, 2002). If a word has
multiple meanings, its recall will require retrieving the specific meaning that was attributed
to that word during presentation.
In order to know which node corresponds to a given memory, we need to formalize the
dynamics during presentation, which can be simply modeled as another diffusive process on
the graph. At every instant during the presentation stage, the diffusive particle lies on a
definite node; once a word is presented, the particle diffuses until it "recognizes" that word,
i.e. until it stumbles on one of the nodes corresponding to it.
This process has an interpretive function: the system interprets each word through the
meaning of that word on which the diffusing particle stumbles first, and that particular node
becomes the location of the memory corresponding to the word.
Notice that this recognition may never occur, as the Erdos-R´enyi graph has a finite
probability of being disconnected; if no available path leads from the current position of
the particle to any of the word's nodes, the particle will be allowed to jump on to a node
randomly chosen amongst them.
This interpretive process takes place for each word in succession: once a word has been
interpreted, the next word in the list is presented, and diffusion goes on. Thus memories
are created.
The model includes therefore two diffusive trajectories: one effecting the interpretation
of words and one effecting their retrieval (as in Fig. 2). These two trajectories, in fact, are
meant to model processes rooted in different cognitive abilities, so it would be more correct
to speak of two different "particles", one employed for interpretation and one for retrieval.
In practice, we only need to be cognizant that the two diffusive trajectories may develop at
different speeds.
6
FIG. 2: Diffusive-particle model of a free-recall experiment. Panel A: a semantic graph, shown with
a specific choice of its edge structure among the many such structures over which final results must
be averaged; meanings corresponding to the same word are shown in the same color; the current
position of the particle is indicated by a black dot. Panel B: presentation stage; each time a new
word is presented, the particle keeps diffusing until it lands onto any of the meanings described by
that word; the resulting trajectory is shown as a sequence of arrows. Panel C: the nodes where
meaning has been found during presentation have become transient memories (circled nodes); in
the interval between presentation and memory test, the diffusive particle's position is reset to a
random point indicated by the black dot. Panel D: during the memory test, a new diffusive process
takes place, similar to the one described in Romani et al., 2013. The diffusive particle has to locate
the circled nodes for the corresponding words to be recalled.
IV. CONTIGUITY EFFECT AND FORWARD ASYMMETRY
Let us call "transition" any sequence of two consecutively recalled word. Obviously,
neither the first word recalled in the test-stage of an experimental trial nor a word recalled
right after an intrusion are part of a transition. We will call "lag" the difference between
the serial positions of two words in a given transition; for example, if the 5th word in the
list is recalled right after the 8th, the corresponding lag is L = −3.
In addition, let us call p(L) the lag probability distribution, i.e. the probability that
an arbitrary transition will have a lag L.
In terms of this distribution, the contiguity
effect may be described as the experimental fact that p(L) is a decreasing function of the
absolute value L for L ≥ 1. Forward asymmetry, on the other hand, is the fact that
PL>0 p(L) > PL<0 p(L) , i.e.
lags are more often positive than negative, meaning that
7
forward transitions are preferred; as we will see, this fact is due almost entirely to the
contribution from contiguous transitions (L = 1).
To check for these phenomena, we proceed to simulate the diffusive-particle model for
a large number of different graph structures. These graphs corresponds to fixed parameter
values N and K (number of nodes and their associated polysemy) but to different combi-
nations of edges. For each graph, we have to mimic the presentation of a large number of
different lists. We then let the retrieval process take place, and compute the probabilities
by averaging over trials. Results for different graphs must be summed up with the weight
factor P (n) mentioned above.
The observed frequency of transitions with a given lag is plotted in Fig. 3A, for various
choices of the vocabulary size N, the polysemy level K, and the semantic disconnectedness
α. To obtain this curve, pseudodata have been generated on a large number of free-recall
trials, and the number n(L) of recall events with lag L has been divided by the total number
of recall events, so as to yield an estimate of the lag probability p(L).
The main features of the curve, as can be seen, are invariant for various combinations of
parameter values. As we are not considering repetitions, by construction the curve vanishes
at L = 0; there are two maxima at L = 1; and the transition probability is a decreasing
function of L, the absolute value of the lag. This amounts to the statement that the
contiguity effect is predicted by this model.
Moreover, the curve is not symmetric around L = 0: the forward branch sums up to a
larger cumulative, although it lies higher up only insofar the peak at L = 1 is concerned.
I will refer to this peak as the "sequential" peak, and to forward contiguous transitions
as "sequential transitions". The sequential peak is always considerably higher than the
backward contiguous peak -- a phenomenon widely documented in experiments (see Kahana,
2012).
To offer an example of how these features emerge in empirical results, panel 3B displays
the curve of transition frequencies for data from PEERS (Penn Electrophysiology of Encod-
ing and Retrieval Study), a large study conducted at the University of Pennsylvania. The
data are those described in Lohnas et al. (2015), summing up to a total of 7360 free-recall
trials on 92 subjects, all performed with lists of 16 words. Intrusions have been discarded
from these data, and no availability correction has been introduced; repetitions, which are
comparatively rare, have been counted in under the lag L = 0.
8
In the database concerning each subject, transition events with the same lag have been
grouped, counted, and normalized by the total number of transition events to yield the
subject's curve of transition frequencies. The averages of these curves over all subjects and
the standard deviations of the corresponding distributions are shown respectively as the
solid curve and the error bars of Fig. 3B.
The empirical curve thus obtained and the curves obtained from simulations are not
identical. Nonetheless, the features we have outlined above are prominent in both.
In
particular, the difference between the backward and the forward branch of the curve is
concentrated in both cases at contiguous transitions, and the maximum at L = 1 is always
the global maximum of the distribution. This is a feature nontrivially displayed by the
model, and the mechanism behind it will become clearer in the next sections.
FIG. 3: Panel A: Results of simulations on the diffusive-particle model for three choices of the
vocabulary size N and polysemy K (see legend) and for α = 1 − 1/K. Lists presented to the model
were permutations of the full vocabulary. The y-axis shows transition frequencies, the x-axis the
serial-position lag normalized by the size of the lists. Panel B: Transition frequency as a function
of lag, as computed from PEERS data.
V. POLYSEMY AND WORD LENGTH
In the previous section, we simulated the model under the assumption that all words
had the same degree K of polysemy, i.e. the same number of "semantic nuances". We may
now wonder how the recall probability of a word varies as a function of the word's degree of
9
polysemy.
Polysemy is, unfortunately, a somewhat elusive variable and rather subtle to measure
(Nerlich et al., 2003). Consider for instance the two words "lion" and "lioness" (a classic
example); does the meaning of "lioness" vary with context? Surely less than the meaning
of "lion" because, aside from finer distinctions, the word "lion" has at least two potential
meanings (a male lion, or a lion of unspecified gender), while "lioness" has, by comparison,
just one (a female lion). Nonetheless, a typical dictionary would only mention gender in
connection with "lioness" and not provide distinct definitions for the two meanings of the
word "lion".
Linguists have been studying this type of problem in depth for decades (Greenberg, 1966;
Jakobson, 1987). One of their most useful conclusions is that the syllabic length of words
may be employed as a reliable, and easily measurable, statistical indicator for oligosemy.
Said otherwise, longer words have proven to be robustly less polysemic than shorter ones,
and (as in Rensinghoff and Nemcov´a, 2010) a Waring distribution seems to fit best this
dependence. For numerical details on the correlation, see the statistical studies in the
literature, in particular Zipf (1949), Guiter (1974), Sambor (1984), Rothe (1994).
I will measure the length of words through their number of syllables; hereafter, by "word-
length" I will always mean the number of syllables in a word. In the experiments of Lohnas
et al. (2015), whose data I have used above, word lists were assembled from a pool consisting
of 1638 words with up to 6 syllables. However, only four 5-syllable words are present, and a
single 6-syllable word ("encyclopedia"); hence, the statistics for these two lengths may not
be representative.
An interesting feature that emerges from these data concerns the "sequential" peak of
the lag probability distribution (the forward contiguous transition frequency). Suppose that
the distribution is computed only over transitions to words of syllabic length M, so that
it can be written as pM (L).
It appears that the height of the sequential peak, pM (+1),
exhibits a nontrivial dependence on the length M of the word recalled, i.e. the probability
of sequential recall varies significantly over words of different lengths.
The relative frequency of sequential transitions can be estimated from the data in at least
two separate ways, through a word-by-word statistics or a subject-by-subject statistics. The
results from both approaches are shown in Fig. 4.
Panel A of the figure shows results obtained by regarding every transition as an indepen-
10
dent event. Call n(S, W, L) the number of observed transitions to word W with lag L in trials
on subject S. In Fig. 4A, each blue dot shows the value of the ratio R(W ) = PS n(S,W,1)
PS PL n(S,W,L)
computed for a particular word W. The histogram of this ratio over all words with the same
length has been plotted vertically for each word-length M (black curves). Red circles show
the means of these values over all words with M syllables: m1(M) = 1
V (M ) PW ∈V (M ) R(W ),
where V (M) is the set of all words with M syllables used in the database, and V (M) their
number.
The trend of the resulting curve is decreasing. Extracting the correlation coefficient yields
r = −0.12, with a negligible p-value p < 10−5. This signifies that the longer a word, the
smaller its chance of being recalled through a forward contiguous transition.
While this is an intriguing result, it relies of course on the assumption that all transition
events could be treated independently. On the other hand, transition events within the
same trial are statistically correlated, and the same may be true for transition events within
different trials performed on the same subject.
In panel B, a different analysis is displayed. Instead of computing the recall statistics for
each individual word, we characterize every transition event solely by the length of the word
of arrival. Information on the particular word involved is ignored, i.e. assumed to average
out.
For each subject S and word-length M,
PW ∈V (M ) n(S,W,1)
I have computed the ratio R(S, M) =
PL PW ∈V (M ) n(S,W,L), and values of these ratio as shown as blue dots in Fig. 4B.; histograms
of these quantities are again shown in black; the mean values m2(M) = 1
PS R(S, M)
Ns
(where Ns is the number of subjects) are shown as red circles.
If the normalization factors depended solely on word length, i.e.
in the case where
PL n(S, W, L) = n(M) for all S and all W ∈ V (M), we would have m1(M) = m2(M) =
PS,W ∈V (M ) n(S,W,1)
for all M. This is the case, in particular, if the samples are identical over
V (M )Nsn(M )
all words and subjects, which is of course not true in any realistic dataset. Nonetheless, the
mean values we have obtained from the subject-by-subject statistics are fairly close to those
obtained in the word-by-word statistics (Fig. 4B).
Moreover, we find once again that the mean probabilities for sequential transitions are
monotonously decreasing as functions of word length. As for the correlation coefficient, it is
also close to the value found above: r = −0.11. The p-value is higher, but still low enough
to enable our correlation hypothesis (p = 0.01). All this provides substantial evidence that
11
sequential transitions (with lag L = +1) are indeed better favored for shorter words.
We should also report that no significant correlation between transition probabilities and
word-length has been found for transitions with lags other than L = +1. For example,
if the foregoing analysis is repeated for backward contiguous transitions, to estimate the
dependence of pM (−1) on the word-length M, a p-value of the order of p ∼ 0.2 is obtained
both from the word-by-word and from the subject-by-subject statistics -- too high for the
correlation to be considered relevant. We must conclude that the effect we are describing
arises from mechanisms that concern exclusively sequential transitions.
Surely several explanations may be conjectured, claiming (as we will do) that the effect is
rooted in polysemy means essentially claiming that it is contextual in nature; by definition,
a word is the more polysemic the larger the semantic context it covers.
If that is true,
we expect that a retrieved-context model of free recall should be suitable to predicting the
effect. The model introduced in the previous sections is particularly handy for a polysemy-
centered discussion. As I will show in the next section, it also provides a particularly simple
explanation for the phenomenon we just singled out.
12
FIG. 4: Panel A: Probability that a word, if recalled, will be recalled sequentially, computed
from PEERS data by regarding all recall events as independent. Each blue dot corresponds to a
different word; for example, the high-lying one-syllable outlier is the word "belt". The black curves
are histograms of these probabilities over all words of a given length, as indicated on the x-axis,
and red circles indicate their means. Panel B: Probability that an individual subject will recall a
word of a given length sequentially, obtained from PEERS data by regarding all words of the same
length as equivalent. Each blue dot corresponds to a different subject; points overlapping at zero
have been jittered for display; histograms over all words of the same length are shown as black
curves, their means as red circles.
VI.
INTERPRETIVE CLUSTERING
Let us consider the above semantic graph in the case where the polysemy k(W ) of word
W varies over different words, i.e. word W has k(W ) semantic nuances.
The quantity we would like to calculate is the lag probability distribution pk(L), i.e. the
conditional probability that a word with k semantic nuances, if recalled, will be recalled
through a transition with lag L.
If the effect we observed in the experimental data is
indeed due to polysemy, we should expect the sequential transition probability pk(1) to be
enhanced for more polysemic words. Moreover, because of the normalization constraint
pk(1) + PL6=1 pk(L) = 1, this entails that the probability pk(L) for any L 6= 1 should be
comparatively suppressed with more polysemic words.
Fig. 5 shows the results of simulations on a semantic graph with α = 0.9. The lists pre-
13
sented to the system were permutations of the whole vocabulary; the conditional probability
pW (L) that a word W , if recalled, will be recalled with a lag L, has been averaged over all
words with the same degree of polysemy k(W ) and the means are displayed as bar plots of
different colors. Panels A, B, and C refer to results for a vocabulary of 2N words of which
N are monosemic (i.e. have one meaning) and the remaining N words are disemic (i.e. have
two meanings). The values of N are respectively 2,3,4, as shown over the plots, and all three
yield qualitatively identical plots.
The most conspicuous feature of these plots is the sequential peak exhibited by the disemic
word as opposed to the monosemic one. The sequential recall probability pk(L = 1) is hence
a sharply increasing function of polysemy (or a decreasing function of word length, just as
found in the data). On the other hand the lag probability distribution for each word-type
is normalized, so this gap should be made up for in nonsequential transitions. Indeed, we
observe that nonsequential transitions are slightly more frequent for the monosemic words
than for the disemic one, the difference at L = 1 being re-distributed over all nonsequential
values of the lag.
We may ask whether the correlation between sequentiality and polysemy holds true also
for words with more than two meanings. As an illustration, panel C of Fig. 5 displays
results of simulations for a vocabulary of 5 words, one for each degree of polysemy between
k = 1 and k = 5. The overall picture that emerges is a straightforwarad extension of what
has been found in the case of only two word-types: again, the sequential probability pk(1)
is a sharply increasing function of a word's degree of polysemy k; again, all other values of
pk(L) are faintly decreasing functions of polysemy.
We conclude that the positive correlation between sequential recall and polysemy is a
feature robustly displayed by this model. The more meanings a word has, the more easily
it is recalled in the order in which it was presented. The question is now why this happens
i.e., what is the ubiquitous mechanism lying at the root of this relationship.
To answer this question, we recall that, by introducing a degree of disconnectedness in
the semantic graph, we have endowed it with a nontrivial topology, in which some meanings
are closer to each other while others lie further apart. A possible way to measure the
distance between any two nodes on a graph is, for instance, by the length of the shortest
path connecting them, or by the mean time it takes to diffuse from one to the other.
It is in this spirit that one should regard Fig. 6, where the distance between any two
14
FIG. 5: Lag probability distribution p(L) from simulations where the lists presented for recall are
permutation of the vocabulary, and the semantic graphs correspond to α = 0.9. Different bar
colors refer to different degrees of polysemy k, shown in the legends. Panels A, B, C: results for a
vocabulary of 2N words of which N are monosemic (i.e. have one meaning) and N are disemic (two
meanings); the values of N are shown over the plots. Panel D: results for a five-word vocabulary
in which each word has a different degree of polysemy (from k = 1 to k = 5).
nodes represents the distance between them (i.e.
length of the shortest path, or time for
first passage) within a wider semantic graph. Of the graph, only a few nodes are shown --
those corresponding to three words (Red, Green, and Blue).
Green and Blue are monosemic words; Red is monosemic in the semantic graph of panels
A-B-C of Fig. 6, and polysemic in the semantic graph of panels D-E-F (having two mean-
ings). The arrays of colored squares over the drawings in panels B-C and E-F represent lists
of words presented to the system for a free-recall trial.
In panels B and C, since all words are monosemic, memories of each word can only be
15
created at a fixed node, and a different order of presentation does not generate different
memories. Hence, Red has the same probability of being recalled after Green or after Blue.
In panels E-F, on the contrary, the memory created by presenting the word "Red" tends
to lie close to the memory created by the word that precedes it. This happens because Red is
polysemic, so the system can "choose" a meaning for it. If the graph is not too disconnected,
the diffusive process that interprets words is continuous (i.e. jumps are rare), so a meaning
close to the current position of the particle will be more likely to be hit first.
In panel E, therefore, Red is more likely to be recalled after Blue than after Green, while
in panel F, Red is more likely to be recalled after Green than after Blue. In both cases,
Red is most likely to be recalled right after the word that precedes it in the list. Thus, the
polysemy of Red makes it more likely to be recalled sequentially.
We will refer to this phenomenon as "interpretive clustering": among the multiple mean-
ings of an input, the cognitive system selects the one that fits best the content of the ongoing
discourse. The more polysemic a word, the more numerous the meanings the system can
choose from; hence, the more likely it is to find a meaning close by. This will logically
translate, during the test stage, into an enhanced probability for sequential recall.
16
A
D
B
E
C
F
FIG. 6: Nodes corresponding to three words (Red, Green and Blue) within a wider semantic
graph; distances on the page are meant to represent roughly shortest-path distances within the
graph. Green and Blue are monosemic words; Red is monosemic in the semantic graph of panels A-
B-C, polysemic in the semantic graph of panels D-E-F, with two meanings. The arrays of colored
squares over figures B-C and E-F represent word-lists presented to the system. Dotted arrows
depict diffusive motion through the semantic graph during presentation.
VII. OPTIMAL SEQUENTIALITY
It is well-known in the literature (Farrell, 2012), that a word-list presented for a free-recall
test is effectively divided by the memory-storage process into "sequential chunks", sections
that tend to be recalled in sequential order. These chunks and their optimal length have
been subjected to extensive studies (see e.g. Cowan, 2001).
Indeed, if the peak at pW (L = +1) is large for a series of consecutive words, these are
likely to be recalled in the order in which they were presented. With high probability, the
peak will "guide" the recall process through a full sequential chunk, and the last word of
the chunk will be the first where the peak is suppressed; at that point, the recall process
becomes fully associative, and free association decides which chunk will be recalled next.
The probability value p(+1) approaches unity only for rare subjects (Healey et al., 2014);
the peak value is, on average, of the order of 0.3 (Fig. 3). Hence, even where information has
been stored the most sequentially, the retrieval process has a finite probability of occurring
in non-chronological orders.
The sequential peak, nonetheless, is regularly the global maximum of the probability
17
distribution p(L), and this fact makes it possible to retrieve the chronological events with
arbitrary accuracy, as one could easily argue in terms of diffusion.
If the chronological ordering is the most probable, a diffusive process has indeed a partic-
ularly simple way of singling it out with arbitrary accuracy; it is sufficient to re-explore the
same contextual area a large number of times, and to choose the ordering of memories that
has been experienced most often during this re-exploration. The more strictly sequential the
memory storage is (i.e. the larger p(1) ), the less time it will take to perform the iterative
sampling needed to establish a chronology with arbitrary accuracy.
It can then be conjectured that the value of p(1) is optimized to compromise between
two conflicting goals: (1) to allow for a fast-enough iterative sampling -- as described -- and
(2) to keep the memories available nonetheless for use by free association.
If the sequential peak is too low, the number of iterations needed to find the most probable
ordering will become large, and the iterative sampling procedure slow; it may be impractical
to devote more than a fraction of a second to ordering any sequence of past events.
If, on the contrary, the sequential peak is too high, associative retrieval of a given memory
will be blocked, as follows from the normalization of probabilities; if we can only arrive at a
memory from its chronological precedent, it cannot be accessed other than chronologically.
It is consequently not available for associative tasks and becomes useless for most cognitive
purposes.
Thus, sequentiality and retrievability are in conflict and a trade-off between the two
requirements may be necessary. A memory must stay available for associative reasoning
and yet its chronology needs to be trackable through iterative sampling. From these two
constraints, the optimal value of the p(+1) may be determined.
This optimization process can further depend on the particular memory involved.
In
other words, what has been referred to as "chunking" may be a process based partly on a
distinction between memories that need chronological storage and memories that do not.
The suggestion of this paper is that polysemy may be one of the criteria for this distinc-
tion. As long as words with adaptable meanings are being presented, the system may keep
grafting them easily into the ongoing semantic chunk. But when a word with a highly spe-
cific meaning appears, there are few chances that the current discourse may accommodate it
logically. Hence a rift in the storage process would have to be introduced and a new chunk
will begin.
18
This may also be understood as implementing a principle of least effort (Zipf, 1949).
Polysemy compels the receiver of verbal input to choose one of many possible understandings,
and that is done on the basis of the chronology of the input. Thus, chronology is an
important part of polysemic communication, but is less essential when the words being used
are oligosemic. Memorizing the chronology of an input is, on the other hand, less useful
when it does not play a role in determining its meaning. Hence, chronological information
related to oligosemic words can be more safely discarded.
VIII. WORD LENGTH EFFECT
The empirical fact that lists of shorter words are easier to recall (word-length effect) is
one of the early findings in the history of free recall (Baddeley et al., 1975). Theories of this
effect may be classified as being either item-based or list-based, i.e. they impute the effect
either to an individual property of words or to a global property of a list.
Recently, item-based theories have been cast doubt upon by new experiments; in partic-
ular, it appears that in experiments with mixed lists (composed of words of various lengths)
shorter words are not always easier to recall (Hulme et al., 2004; Xu et al., 2009; Katkov
et al., 2014). This suggests that the word-length effect in pure lists may exist not because
shorter words are more distinctive, but in spite of the fact that they are not, strongly pointing
toward a list-based explanation for the effect.
In list-based theories, on the other hand, the global property on which the effect is
made to depend is most frequently the total duration of the list (Baddeley, 2007). But this
explanation has now also been called into question. Neath et al. (2003) have shown that with
words having the same number of syllables but dierent pronunciation times, no unambiguous
word length effect arises. This suggests that the effect may depend on the number of syllables
and not on the time it takes to pronounce them (Campoy, 2008). A review of the debate
may be found in Jalbert et al., 2011, where it was argued that "the word-length effect may
be better explained by the differences in linguistic and lexical properties of short and long
words rather than by length per se".
Could this elusive linguistic property be just polysemy? This hypothesis seems not to
have yet been explored, and the diffusive-particle model may help to test it. To do so, I
have simulated the model by presenting lists that contain words with a fixed degree of a
polysemy, while keeping the semantic-graph structure unchanged.
19
FIG. 7: Mean recall probability in the diffusive-particle model. The semantic graph employed for
the simulations contains a vocabulary of ten words, two for each degree of polysemy between k = 1
and k = 5, while α = 0.7. The word-length effect was checked by simulating presentation of a large
number of "pure" lists, i.e. lists consisting entirely of words with the same degree of polysemy k.
The recall probability was averaged over all trials with the same value of k and the results plotted
as a function of k. The three curves refer to lists of three different sizes, shown in the legend.
For all choice of the graph-structure parameters, the relationship between recall proba-
bility and the degree of polysemy of the word list is monotonously increasing. The more
polysemic the words in the list, the easier each will be to recall. Rephrased in terms of
word-length, this is nothing but the word-length effect, as exhibited by the diffusive model
(Fig. 7).
The reason for the word-length effect, in this model, is indeed a global or list-based
mechanism: the fact that lists of shorter words, being more polysemic, produce a higher
degree of interpretive clustering.
When a word has a higher degree of polysemy, it takes on average a smaller distance
to reach one of its meanings from anywhere within the semantic graph. Said otherwise, a
diffusive particle will need to move less far if it has to interpret shorter words. For shorter
words, therefore, the semantic region within which memories are formed will be narrower,
20
and a smaller region will have to be explored during retrieval; thus, recall will be facilitated.
This is shown in Fig. 8, where again distances on the page are meant to represent shortest-
path distances within a denser semantic graph of which only a few nodes are shown. The
nodes being shown refer to both some highly polysemic words (in shades of blue) and some
highly oligosemic ones (in shades of red). Panel A of Fig. 8 shows the diffusive trajectory
of the particle during the presentation of a list of polysemic words; panel B, during the
presentation of a list of oligosemic words. In the latter case, the desired meanings are less
readily available; so longer distances have to be travelled and, afterwards, the memories will
have to be sought over a larger area of the graph.
This is evidently not just an item-based effect. A comparatively long word, by causing
a longer shift in the presentation trajectory, distances all the memories that will be created
afterwards from the ones created before. Moving from memory to memory during the
retrieval stage becomes, on average, harder over the full scale of the list size.
A
B
FIG. 8: Role of interpretive clustering in the word-length effect. Distances on the page are meant
to represent shortest-path distances within a denser semantic graph of which only a few nodes
are shown. These nodes refer to three highly polysemic words (shown in shades of blue) and
three highly oligosemic ones (in shades of red). Dotted arrows depict diffusive motion through
the semantic graph. Panel A depicts the diffusive trajectory during the presentation of a list
of polysemic words; panel B, during the presentation of a list of oligosemic words, to the same
system. In both panels, the list being presented is displayed over the drawing as a sequence of
colored squares. In the oligosemic case, longer distances have to be travelled; therefore memories
are distributed over a wider region (dashed ellipses), impairing recall.
IX. CONCLUSIONS
21
A diffusive-particle approach to the modeling of free recall has been developed, in which
the presentation of words and their recall are modeled as trajectories of a particle diffusing
over a semantic graph with a random structure.
The model has predicted correctly some well-known features of free recall (forward asym-
metry, the contiguity effect, the word-length effect). A novel prediction has also been ob-
tained: shorter words, being more polysemic, are characterized by a stronger "sequentiality",
that is, they are more likely to be recalled through forward contiguity -- a prediction con-
firmed by a fresh analysis of archival data.
The mechanism behind the latter phenomenon ("interpretive clustering") is the same
that lies at heart of the word-length effect as predicted by this theory. The conversion
of words into meaning involves interpretation, and our freedom of interpretation (which
is larger for the more polysemic words) has the effect of turning temporal contiguity into
semantic contiguity. Since we memorize each word through a meaning largely determined
by its context, mixed temporal-semantic correlations are created amongst memories.
Future work on the theory may evolve in to three directions: (1) comparing results from
simulations to additional features of available databases, or to features well-documented
in the literature, some of which are not difficult to envision within this model (semantic
contiguity effect, power-law scaling, recency); (2) trying out more realistic forms for the dis-
tribution P (G) of the probabilistic graph through which the particle moves, and optimizing
this distribution over the data; this may help in interpreting free-recall data as measurements
of semantic connections within specific groups of words; (3) studying further the connections
between this diffusive model and more widely tested retrieved-context models, in order to
ascertain to what extent they differ and in what respects they may correspond.
There are also several experiments that may help test the predictions made so far. In
particular, it may be useful to perform ad-hoc experiments with select pools of words for
which the measurement of polysemy is not overly tricky. This could be done by using
two pools, one composed of decidedly oligosemic words (such as "Parthenon") and one of
extremely polysemic words (such as "let").
Experiments on such mixed lists would serve as a strict test for what we have claimed
to be a polysemy effect in the sequential recall probabilities. Another task would be to test
22
whether the word-length effect survives when each list harbors multiple word-lengths but is
assembled entirely out of either pool (the highly polysemic or the highly oligosemic one).
If recall probabilities do not depend on which pool has been used, that would disprove the
explanation provided above, ruling out the role of interpretive clustering in the word-length
effect.
Finally, the degree of importance of interpretive clustering may be measured through
experiments based on pseudowords. The meanings that a pseudoword inevitably evokes
can affect its association value, playing a potentially important role in the recall process
(Glaze, 1928); at the same time, the recall of pseudowords may be expected to be more
largely phonetical than the recall of real words. If so, effects due to interpretive clustering
will be reduced. Comparing data from experiments with words and from experiments with
pseudowords may help ascertain to what extent semantics matters in the emergence of the
effects we have discussed.
I would like to thank Michael Kahana, of the University of Pennsylvania, for generously
sharing the data obtained in his laboratory.
X. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Baddeley, A.D., Thomson, N., Buchanan M. (1975). Word length and the structure of
short-term memory. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 14, 575-589.
Baddeley, A.D. (2007). Working memory, thought and action. Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
Bousfield W.A. and Sedgewick C.H.W. (1944). An analysis of sequences of restricted
associative responses. Journal of General Psychology (30), 149-165.
Campoy, G. (2008). The effect of word length in short-term memory: Is rehearsal neces-
sary? Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 61 (5) 724-734.
Cowan N. (2001). The magical number 4 in short-term memory: a reconsideration of
mental storage capacity. Behavioral Brain Science, 24, 87114.
Ebbinghaus, H. (1913). Memory: A contribution to experimental psychology. New York,
NY: Teachers College, Columbia University.
Farrell S. (2012). Temporal clustering and sequencing in short-term memory and episodic
memory. Psychological Review, 119, 223271.
23
Frieze, A. and Karonski, M. (2016). Introduction to Random Graphs. Cambridge, UK:
Cambridge University Press.
Fernando, C. (1996). Idioms and idiomaticity. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Glaze, J. A. (1928). The association value of non-sense syllables. Pedagogical Seminary
and Journal of Genetic Psychology, 35, 255-269.
Greenberg, J. (1966). Universals of language. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Guiter, H. (1974). Les relations fr´equence-longeur-sens des mots (langues Romaines et
Anglais). In Atti del Congresso Internazionale di Linguistica (pp. 373-381). Amsterdam,
Netherlands: Benjamins.
Healey, M., Crutchley, P., Kahana, M.J. (2014). Individual differences in memory search
and their relation to intelligence. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 143, 15531569
Howard, M. W., and Kahana, M. J. (2002). A distributed representation of temporal
context. Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 46, 269-299.
Hulme, C., Suprenant, A. M., Bireta, T. J., Stuart, G., and Neath, I. (2004). Abolishing
the word-length eect. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 30, 98-106.
Katkov M., Romani S., Tsodyks M., (2014). Word length eect in free recall of randomly
assembled word lists. Frontiers of Computational Neuroscience (8), 129.
Jalbert, A., Neath, I., Bireta, T. J., and Surprenant, A. M. (2011). When does length
cause the word length effect? Journal of Experimental Psychology, 37, 338-353.
Jakobson R. (1987). Language in Literature. Ed. Krystyna Pomorska and Stephen Rudy.
Cambridge, Massachusetts: Belknap Press.
Kahana, M. J. (1996). Associative retrieval processes in free recall. Memory and Cogni-
tion, 24, 103-109.
Kahana, M. (2014). Foundations of human memory. Oxford, UK: Oxford University
Press.
Lohnas, L.J., Polyn, S.M., and Kahana, M.J. (2015). Expanding the scope of memory
search: modeling intralist and interlist effects in free recall. Psychological Review, 122 (2),
337-363.
Murdock B. (1962). The serial position effect of free recall. Journal of Experimental
Psychology, 64 (2), 482-488.
Murray, D. J., Pye, C., Hockley, W. E. (1976). Standing's power function in long-term
memory. Psychological Research, 38 (4), 319-331.
24
Musz, E., Thompson-Schill, S.L. (2015). Semantic variability predicts neural variability
of object concepts. Neuropsychologia, 76, 41-51.
Neath I., Bireta T.J., Surprenant A.M., (2003). The time-based word length effect and
stimulus set specicity, Psychonomic Bulletin Review, 10 (2), 430-4
Nerlich, B., Todd, Z., Herman, V., Clarke, D.D. (2003). Polysemy: flexible patterns of
meaning in mind and language. Berlin, Germany: Mouton de Gruyter.
Rensinghoff, S. and Nemcov´a, E. (2010). On word length and polysemy in French. Glot-
totheory, 1, 83-88.
Romani, S., Pinkoviezky, I., Rubin, A., Tsodyks, M. (2013). Scaling laws of associative
memory retrieval. Neural Computation, 25(10), 2523-2526.
Rothe, U. (1994). Wortlnge und Bedeutungsmenge: Eine Untersuchung zum Menzerath-
schen Gesetz an drei romanischen Sprachen. In R. Khler and J. Boy (Eds.), Glottometrika
5, 101-112.
Sambor, J. (1984). Menzerath's law and the polysemy of words. Glottometrika 6, 94-114.
Standing L. (1973). Learning 10.000 pictures. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psy-
chology, 25, 207-222.
Xu, Z. and Li, B. Q. (2009). The Mechanism of Reverse Word Length Eect of Chinese
in Working Memory. Acta Psychologica Sinica, 41 (9), 802-811.
Zipf, G. K. (1949). Human behaviour and the principle of least effort. Cambridge, MA:
Addison-Wesley.
|
1610.07161 | 1 | 1610 | 2016-10-23T12:27:05 | Stochastic inference with spiking neurons in the high-conductance state | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cond-mat.dis-nn",
"cs.NE",
"physics.bio-ph",
"stat.ML"
] | The highly variable dynamics of neocortical circuits observed in vivo have been hypothesized to represent a signature of ongoing stochastic inference but stand in apparent contrast to the deterministic response of neurons measured in vitro. Based on a propagation of the membrane autocorrelation across spike bursts, we provide an analytical derivation of the neural activation function that holds for a large parameter space, including the high-conductance state. On this basis, we show how an ensemble of leaky integrate-and-fire neurons with conductance-based synapses embedded in a spiking environment can attain the correct firing statistics for sampling from a well-defined target distribution. For recurrent networks, we examine convergence toward stationarity in computer simulations and demonstrate sample-based Bayesian inference in a mixed graphical model. This points to a new computational role of high-conductance states and establishes a rigorous link between deterministic neuron models and functional stochastic dynamics on the network level. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Stochastic inference with spiking neurons in the high-conductance state∗
Mihai A. Petrovici1*, Johannes Bill1,2*, Ilja Bytschok1, Johannes Schemmel1, Karlheinz Meier1
1Kirchhoff Institute for Physics, University of Heidelberg
2Institute for Theoretical Computer Science, Graz University of Technology
(Dated: October 25, 2016)
The highly variable dynamics of neocortical circuits observed in vivo have been hypothesized
to represent a signature of ongoing stochastic inference, but stand in apparent contrast to the
deterministic response of neurons measured in vitro. Based on a propagation of the membrane
autocorrelation across spike bursts, we provide an analytical derivation of the neural activation
function that holds for a large parameter space, including the high-conductance state. On this
basis, we show how an ensemble of leaky integrate-and-fire neurons with conductance-based synapses
embedded in a spiking environment can attain the correct firing statistics for sampling from a well-
defined target distribution. For recurrent networks, we examine convergence towards stationarity in
computer simulations and demonstrate sample-based Bayesian inference in a mixed graphical model.
This points to a new computational role of high-conductance states and establishes a rigorous link
between deterministic neuron models and functional stochastic dynamics on the network level.
Introduction
In responding to environmental stimuli, brains have
to make predictions based on incomplete, noisy and am-
biguous data. The recent hypothesis that the brain copes
with this challenge by performing Bayesian, rather than
logical inference [1–3], has been strengthened by electro-
physiological data which identified neural correlates of
the involved computations [4, 5] and theoretical work on
potential spiking network implementations [6–8].
In probabilistic inference, possible values of a quan-
tity are described by a random variable (RV) zk and
all dependencies between RVs are stored in a joint
distribution p(z1, . . . , zK). The belief about a set of
unobserved RVs {z1, . . . , zM} given an observed set
of RVs is represented by the posterior distribution
p(z1, . . . , zM zM +1, . . . , zK). In particular, the posterior
contains information on the most likely conclusion, as
well as on all potential alternatives.
With regard to the representation of probability dis-
tributions in the brain, theoretical work [2] has argued
in favor of sample-based codes, i.e., instead of provid-
ing the entire distribution at any point in time, samples
z(t) ∼ p(z1, . . . , zK) are used as a proxy. When model-
ing large systems, this offers three important advantages.
First, approximate solutions can be provided at any time,
with increasingly reliable results as the calculation pro-
gresses ("anytime computing"). Secondly, marginaliza-
tion comes at no cost, as p(zk) can be determined by sim-
ply neglecting the values of all other RVs. Thirdly, some
sampling algorithms support a high degree of paralleliza-
tion with an algorithmic structure that is reminiscent
of neural networks [9]. Recently, a theory has been sug-
gested which combines these advantages by implementing
Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling in spiking
networks of abstract model neurons [7].
In this frame-
work, spike patterns are interpreted as samples of binary
FIG. 1. (A) Spike patterns as samples of a random vector z.
The RV zk is active for duration τon (gray bar) after each
spike. (B) In stochastic neuron models, internal state vari-
ables (red) modulate the firing probability (gray).
(C) In
contrast, deterministic neurons elicit a spike when the mem-
brane potential (blue) reaches a threshold voltage.
RVs as follows (see Fig. 1A):
k = 1 ⇔ Neuron k fired in (t − τon, t]
z(t)
.
(1)
The duration τon of the active state following a spike is a
free parameter for the timescale on which a neuron affects
downstream cells. The neuron model in [7] is inherently
stochastic, with an instantaneous firing probability
(cid:26) exp(vk)
rk(t) = lim
∆t→0
p(spike in [t, t+∆t))
∆t
=
τ
0
if zk = 0
if zk = 1
(2)
where vk is an abstract membrane potential (Fig. 1B).
In contrast to this idealized stochastic neuron model,
in vitro experiments have demonstrated the largely de-
terministic nature of single neurons [10]. Similarly, mi-
croscopic models of neural circuits typically rely on de-
terministic dynamics of their constituents (see Fig. 1C).
The aim of this letter is to demonstrate how a network of
deterministic neurons in a biologically plausible spiking
environment can quantitatively reproduce the stochastic
dynamics required for sampling from a well-defined dis-
tribution and perform inference given observations.
In
this letter, we extend our earlier discussion of this ap-
proach [11].
We start by calculating the dynamics of a single
leaky integrate-and-fire (LIF) neuron in a spiking noisy
environment and derive its activation function in the
high-conductance state. For this biologically relevant
regime, existing analytical descriptions of neuronal re-
sponse functions (e.g., [16, 17]) are not applicable. Here,
we provide an approach based on the propagation of
the membrane autocorrelation throughout spike bursts.
This establishes an equivalence to the abstract, inher-
ently stochastic units (Eq. 2). On the network level, we
show how conductance-based synapses approximate the
interaction for sampling from a well-defined target dis-
tribution. Furthermore, we show that the distribution
sampled by LIF networks remains a good approximation
of the target distribution even for large networks with
strong recurrent interaction. We complement our study
with a demonstration of probabilistic inference by imple-
menting a small graphical model for pattern recognition
in a recurrent network of LIF neurons.
LIF dynamics in a high-conductance state
leak potential El,
consider deterministic LIF neurons defined
d
dt uk = gl(El − uk) + Ik, with membrane poten-
We
by Cm
tial uk, capacitance Cm,
leak con-
ductance gl and input current Ik. When uk crosses a
threshold ϑ from below, a spike is emitted and uk is re-
set to for a refractory period τref . We formally par-
tition the total input current Ik into recurrent synaptic
input, diffuse synaptic noise and additional external cur-
rents: Ik = I rec
and
I noise
k =
k
of the ith
synapse. The temporal evolution of the conductance gki
is modelled as a low-pass filter on pre-synaptic spikes:
d
i ), with synaptic time
constant τsyn, weight wki and spike times ts
i .
(cid:80)
dt gki = −gki/τsyn +(cid:80)
i − uk) with reversal potential Erev
are mediated through synapses and obey I syn
k . The currents I rec
s wki δ(t − ts
i gki (Erev
k + I noise
k
+ I ext
k
i
k
We start by considering a single neuron that receives
diffuse synaptic noise I noise
in the form of Poisson spike
trains from its surrounding. The capacity of recurrent
networks to produce such noise has been shown in, e.g.,
[12]. For the following analysis of individual neurons in a
noisy environment, we omit the index k and set I rec = 0.
When a conductance-based LIF neuron receives
strong synaptic stimulation, it enters a so-called high-
conductance state (HCS, [13]), characterized by acceler-
ated membrane dynamics. For an analytical treatment,
it is advantageous to rewrite the membrane dynamics as
dt u = ueff (t) − u, such that u decays towards an ef-
τeff
fective leak potential ueff with an effective time constant
τeff = Cm/gtot [14] (see Appendix AI). The total conduc-
tance gtot subsumes both leakage and synaptic conduc-
In a high input rate regime, τeff → 0 and the
tances.
effective potential ueff simply becomes a linear transfor-
mation of the synaptic noise input (see AII). Using meth-
ods similar to [15], it can be shown that, in this regime,
ueff (t) can be described as an Ornstein-Uhlenbeck (OU)
d
2
(¯u − u)dt + σdW with parameters (see
process du = 1
τsyn
AIII):
¯u = {I ext + glEl +(cid:80)
(cid:110)(cid:80)
i νi [wi (Erev
σ2 =
i νiwiErev
i − ¯u)]2 τsyn
i
(cid:111)
τsyn} /(cid:104) gtot (cid:105)
/(cid:104) gtot (cid:105)2
.
,
(3)
(4)
The activation function of LIF neurons in the HCS
Similarly to the abstract model [7], we define the re-
fractory state of a neuron as z(t) = 1. The mapping of
spikes to RV states (Eq. 1) naturally leads to the concept
of an activation function p(z = 1¯u), where ¯u = (cid:104) ueff (cid:105)t.
In the following, we derive a general expression for the
activation function of an LIF neuron under Poisson stim-
ulus, which is of particular use in the cortically relevant
HCS regime. Fig. 2A shows an exemplary simulation
(membrane potential and spike train) of such a scenario.
The activation function in Fig. 2B is obtained by sweep-
ing over I ext (see AVII and AVIII).
Related setups have already been examined in [16, 17].
However, the methods in [16, 17] are tailored to certain
parameter ranges, which, in particular, do not include the
HCS regime with refractoriness. This is because [16] re-
quires τsyn (cid:28) τeff , whereas [17] assumes τref (cid:28) τeff , τsyn,
which leads to discrepancies in the predicted activation
functions (Fig. 2B). The deeper reason for the observed
discrepancies is found in the lack of an appropriate prop-
agation of the autocorrelation of ueff through τref . Here,
we propose a derivation that explicitly includes this prop-
agation and thereby covers a large parameter space, in-
cluding the cases studied in [16, 17], as well as the HCS.
In Fig. 2A, two modes of firing can be observed: a
"bursting" mode, where the effective membrane poten-
tial ueff after the refractory period is still above thresh-
old, and a freely evolving mode, where the neuron does
not spike again immediately after the refractory period.
This is illustrated by the distributions in Fig. 2C. Our
approach relies on the calculation of burst lengths and
their associated occurrence probability Pn.
Denoting the relative occurrence of burst lengths n by
Pn, the average drift time from to ϑ between the kth
and (k + 1)st spike in a burst by τ b
k and the average
duration of the freely evolving mode that follows an n-
spike-burst by Tn, we identify the following relation:
p(z = 1¯u) =
(cid:80)
n Pn ·(cid:16)
(cid:80)
nτref +(cid:80)n−1
n Pn · n · τref
(cid:17) .
k=1 τ b
k + Tn
(5)
Knowing the OU process governing ueff , recursive ex-
pressions for Pn and Tn can be derived. These terms
have considerable impact on the activation function if
τref ≈ τsyn. In the limit of strong noise stimuli, we can
calculate the average drift time τ b
k in a quasistatic ap-
proximation [17] of ueff and assume that u ≈ ueff for the
3
FIG. 3. (A) Spike pattern of a recurrent network of K = 5 LIF
neurons during sampling from a randomly generated Boltz-
mann machine. (B) Sampled distribution pN(z) of network
states (blue) and target distribution pB(z) (red). pN(z) was
estimated from ten 10 s simulation runs (errorbars: std. de-
(C) DKL (pN pB) as a function of
viation between runs).
integration time T for 10 trials. The red dotted line shows
convergence for the theoretically optimal abstract model [7].
(D) DKL (pN pB) when sampling for T = 106 ms from 100
different randomly generated target distributions.
regime, this logistic activation can be approximated by
LIF neurons with high accuracy. Fig. 2D shows our the-
oretical prediction and simulation results for the activa-
tion function alongside a fitted logistic function. For the
translation from the LIF domain to the abstract model
(Eq. 2) we have employed a linear mapping
v = (¯u − ¯u0)/α ,
(9)
with scaling factor α and ¯u0 denoting the potential for
which p(z = 1) = 1
2 .
We next connect the neurons to form a recurrent net-
work. In addition to noise stimuli, an LIF neuron in a
network receives synaptic currents I rec
from other neu-
rons. For certain connectivity structures, it is possible
to predict the target distribution [7, 19] of states z(t)
that arise from the stochastic dynamics of the recurrent
network. We use the emulation of Boltzmann machines
(BMs) as an example case. The joint distribution reads:
pB(z) = Z−1 exp(cid:0)zTW z/2 + zTb(cid:1)
,
(10)
k
where W is a symmetric zero-diagonal weight matrix, b
is a bias vector and Z is the normalizing partition func-
tion. This probabilistic model underlies state-of-the-art
machine learning algorithms for image [20] and speech
recognition [21]. It has been shown [7] that a network of
abstract neurons (Eq. 2) with linear membrane potentials
vk = bk +(cid:80)K
j=1 Wkj zj
(11)
FIG. 2. (A) Membrane potential u(t) and spikes of an LIF
neuron in a spiking noisy environment.
(B) Prediction of
the activation function (red) compared to simulation results
(green), as well as to other predictions from literature [16, 17].
(C) In a HCS, u (blue) and ueff (red) are nearly identical when
the neuron is not refractory. After each refractory period
(gray), the predicted distribution of ueff (pink) is used for the
propagation in (Eq. 6).
(D) High-noise regime: theoretical
prediction (red) vs. simulation results (green), with a fitted
logistic function σ(¯u) (blue).
i=1 Pi
freely evolving mode, thus obtaining (see AIV):
(cid:17)(cid:82) ∞
(cid:105)
ϑ dun−1p(un−1un−1 ≥ ϑ)
−∞ dunp(unun−1)
ϑ dun−1p(un−1un−1 ≥ ϑ)
(cid:16)
1 −(cid:80)n−1
×(cid:104)(cid:82) ϑ
Tn =(cid:82) ∞
×(cid:104)(cid:82) ϑ
−∞ dunp(unun < ϑ, un−1)(cid:104) T (ϑ, un)(cid:105)(cid:105)
k =(cid:82) ∞
×(cid:82) ∞
ϑ duk ln
ϑ duk−1p(ukuk ≥ ϑ, uk−1) .
(cid:16) −uk
ϑ−uk
(cid:17)
Pn =
τ b
,
(6)
, (7)
(8)
Fig. 2C displays an intuitive picture of the integrals in
(Eq. 6) and (Eq. 7). The transfer function p(unun−1) is
the Green's function of the OU process at time t−ts = τon
and (cid:104) T (ϑ, un)(cid:105) denotes the average time needed for the
membrane to reach ϑ starting from un, which can be
given in closed form [18]. The dependency of Pn, Tn and
τ b
k on the moments of the OU process (Eq. 3,4) renders
Eq. (5) a function of ¯u.
So far, we have only considered τeff = 0. To further
improve the prediction, we take into account finite values
of τeff by means of an expansion in(cid:112)τeff /τsyn. Due to the
symmetry of the PSP shape in τeff and τsyn, this can be
done analogously to [16, 17], where the opposite limit of
large τeff and small τsyn is used (see AIV). A comparison
between our prediction of p(z = 1¯u) and results from a
numerical simulation is shown in Fig. 2B.
Sampling with networks of LIF neurons
We can now reconcile the response of LIF neurons with
the inherently stochastic neuron model (Eq. 2) that re-
quires a logistic activation function for constant poten-
−1. In the HCS
tial v: p(z = 1v) = σ(v) := [1 + exp(−v)]
4
FIG. 4. Sampling in large networks. Spike raster (top left), joint distribution (bottom) and KL divergence (top right) as
in Fig. 3A,B,C. Since the target distribution cannot be computed analytically for 500 RVs, we define the Gibbs-sampling
estimate after 106 steps as a reference distribution. For the joint, the sampled distribution over 5 RVs (out of 500) obtained
from the LIF network (after Tsim = 104 ms) is plotted alongside the Gibbs estimate. Error bars indicate standard deviation
between 10 simulation runs.
(A)
Small weights: Wkj ∼ 0.6 · [B(0.5, 0.5) − 0.5].
(C) Strong weights:
Wkj ∼ 2.4 · [B(0.5, 0.5) − 0.5]. Systematic deviations between the sampled distribution and the reference manifest mainly in
low-probability modes and are due to the difference in PSP shapes between the abstract model and LIF neurons.
In all panels, biases were drawn from a beta distribution: bk ∼ 1.2 · [B(0.5, 0.5) − 0.5].
(B) Moderate weights: Wkj ∼ 1.2 · [B(0.5, 0.5) − 0.5].
will sample from the desired target distribution (Eq. 10).
This finding uses the fact that individual neurons sam-
ple from the conditionals p(zk = 1 z\k) = σ(vk), with
z\k = {zj j (cid:54)= k}, in an MCMC updating scheme.
As shown above, LIF neurons in a spiking noisy envi-
ronment closely approximate this logistic activation func-
tion if the synaptic currents I rec
shift the mean mem-
brane potential ¯uk according to the linear interaction
(Eq. 11). Using the linear transformation (Eq. 9) between
vk and ¯uk, and estimating the effect of a conductance-
based synapse of weight wkj, we arrive at the following
translation between the abstract and the LIF domain (see
AV):
k
Wkj =
bk = (¯ub
k)/α
k − ¯u0
wkj
1
(cid:20) 1 − e
αCm
×
e
(cid:16)
(cid:17)
kj − µ
Erev
(cid:16)
− 1
τeff
1
τsyn
− τeff
τsyn
− τsyn
τeff − 1
e
(12)
(cid:17)(cid:21)
,
(13)
k) = σ(bk) in Eq. (5), and Erev
where ¯ub
k is the mean potential ¯uk that establishes p(zk =
1¯uk = ¯ub
kj denotes the
reversal potential for synapse wkj. The idea behind
(Eq. 13) is to match the integrals of individual postsynap-
tic potentials (PSPs) on vk and ¯uk. Since the membrane
loses any memory following a reset, in contrast to [7], we
use the synaptic conductance as a memory carrier.
The remaining systematic difference to the abstract
model lies in the additive – instead of renewing – nature
of PSPs elicited by the same presynaptic neuron, which
has a noticeable effect in case of fast consecutive spikes
(bursts). Since the membrane potential closely follows
the effective potential in the HCS, renewing PSPs can be
achieved by using renewing postsynaptic conductances.
For this, we have used short-term synaptic depression
[22] with a recovery time constant equal to τsyn.
The sampling quality with networks of LIF neurons
was examined in computer simulations of BMs, with ran-
domly drawn parameters bk and Wkj (Fig. 3A,B). The
target distribution pB(z) is approximated by the distri-
bution pN (z) of network states with τon = 10 ms. The
chosen integration time T = 10 s displays a conservative
estimate of the maximum duration a neuronal ensemble
will experience stable stimulus conditions in a behaving
organism and can thus be expected to sample from a
stable target distribution. For this integration time, we
find that the recurrent network of LIF neurons accurately
encodes the target distribution, within the precision im-
posed by the sample-based representation. The network
distribution pN (z) becomes increasingly more reliable as
more samples are considered (Fig. 3C). After few sam-
ples, the network has generated a coarse approximation
of pB(z) that could serve as an "educated guess" in on-
line computation tasks. Only for simulation times T well
beyond biologically relevant timescales do systematic er-
rors in pN (z) become apparent. The sampling quality
holds for a variety of target distributions (Fig. 3D, see
AIX for simulation details).
These observations hold for larger-scale networks as
well (Fig. 4). For weak coupling, the networks are in
an asynchronous irregular state of firing, which enables
5
FIG. 5. (A) Graphical model used for the probabilistic inference task. (B) A Gaussian likelihood model provides input to the
sampling neurons. (C) Two dimensional projection of states z(t) when sampling from the prior p(z), which was trained to
store hand-written digits 0, 3 and 4. Solid line: network trajectory over 200 ms. Color maps: Marginals of zk averaged over
25 ms. The time arrow covers the duration of the red trajectory and consecutive snapshots are 25 ms apart. (D) As in (C)
when provided with incomplete input y that is incompatible with digit 0 and ambiguous with respect to digits 3 and 4.
highly accurate sampling of the target distribution. As
synaptic weights increase, the network activity expect-
edly becomes more synchronous and the sampled distri-
bution overall less accurate, especially in low-probability
regions of the state space, but the high-probability modes
are always sampled from with high fidelity.
Demonstration of probabilistic inference
We conclude our investigation of sampling in recurrent
networks of LIF neurons with an example of Bayesian
inference based on incomplete observations. A fully con-
nected BM of K = 144 neurons, aligned on a 12×12 grid,
was trained as an associative network [23] to store pat-
terns of hand-written digits 0, 3 and 4 in the weights Wkj
and biases bk. Each pixel of the image grid was assigned
to one network neuron. The resulting joint distribution
p(z) displays "prior knowledge" stored by the network.
The probabilistic model was augmented by adding
real-valued input channels for each pixel, associated with
random variables yk ∈ R, 1 ≤ k ≤ K. The result-
ing generative model p(y, z) has the structure shown
in Fig. 5A and connects the latent network variables zk
to observable inputs yk by means of likelihood func-
tions p(yk zk), which we have chosen to be Gaussian
with unit variance (Fig. 5B). The likelihoods p(yk zk)
tend to align the network state with the observation, i.e.
zk = 1 for yk > 0, while the prior p(z) reconciles the ob-
servations with knowledge on consistent activation pat-
terns z. The task for the network is to calculate and
represent the posterior distribution according to Bayes'
rule: p(z y) ∝ p(z) · p(y z). A short derivation (see
AVI) shows that the posterior p(z y) is a BM for any
input y with the following abstract membrane potential:
vk = bk + yk +(cid:80)
j Wkj zj .
(14)
In the LIF domain, the sum bk + yk is equivalent to an
effective bias (Eq. 74) and corresponds to an external cur-
rent I ext
k that shifts ¯uk appropriately. Thus,
a neuron receives synaptic input from recurrent connec-
k = I b
k + I y
k
+ I ext
k .
k + I noise
In case of I y
tions and noise sources, as well as an external current,
i.e., Ik = I rec
k = 0 ∀k, the network samples from
the prior distribution p(z) = p(z y = 0). A two-
dimensional projection of network states z(t) ∼ p(z) is
shown in Fig. 5C. The sampled distribution has three dis-
tinct modes that correspond to the three hand-written
digits stored in the recurrent weight matrix. A closer
look at the network trajectory reveals that the system
stays in one mode ("digit") for some duration, traverses
the state space and then samples from a different mode
of the distribution.
A typical inference scenario with incomplete observa-
tions is shown in Fig. 5D. Four input channels at the cen-
ter were picked to inject positive currents I y
k > 0 to the
network while all other inputs remained uninformative.
Positive currents I y
k were chosen such that the observa-
tion y appeared incompatible with digit 0, and remained
ambiguous with respect to digits 3 and 4 (see AX). In
accordance with Bayes' rule, the resulting bimodal pos-
terior distribution p(z y) has a suppressed 0-mode, but
preserves the 3 and 4 modes.
Discussion
We
have
shown
networks
how recurrent
of
conductance-based neurons in a spiking noisy envi-
ronment can perform probabilistic inference through
sampling from a well-defined posterior distribution.
Our approach extends Bayesian spiking network im-
plementations to deterministic neuron models widely
used in computational neuroscience. We have provided
an analytical derivation of the bursty firing response of
LIF neurons under Poisson bombardment, which holds
for a wide range of parameter regimes (both high and
low ratios of τsyn/τeff , as well as both high and low
τref ). Our approach is based on the propagation of the
membrane autocorrelation throughout bursts and can
thereby provide a prediction of the activation function in
a regime where existing approaches [16, 17] do not hold
(see also Fig. 6 in AXI). We have further shown how
high-frequency spiking inputs that could be provided
by the surrounding network can lead to fast membrane
dynamics, which enable individual LIF neurons to cor-
rectly encode conditional distributions given information
from their presynaptic partners. Thereby, our derivation
also identifies a potential functional role of biologically
observed high-conductance states and synaptic memory
within a Bayesian framework of brain computation.
For mathematical tractability, simplifying modeling
assumptions had to be made. The neuron model uses
an absolute refractory time τref , which matches the ac-
tivation time constant τon, and neglects any gradual re-
covery effects. On the network level, we have assumed
statistically independent noise sources and instantaneous
axonal transmission. One important difference to cortical
structure is the requirement of a symmetric connectivity
matrix. The precise symmetry is a consequence of all
neurons sharing the same parameters and can be relaxed
as neurons become diverse (α (cid:55)→ αk in Eq. 13). Further-
more, while Dale's principle is known to not hold univer-
sally [24], negative coupling in large networks between
otherwise excitatory neurons could be, in principle, in-
troduced through populations of inhibitory interneurons.
LIF PSPs differ from the theoretically optimal rectangu-
lar shape, which could impair convergence to the target
distribution outside of the high noise regime [25]. How-
ever, computer simulations indicate that in many bio-
logically relevant scenarios the above approximations are
not critical (see also Fig. 7 in AXII). In particular, the
sampling properties of LIF networks remain preserved as
network size and interaction strength increase (Fig. 4).
Embedding LIF sampling in cortical-size networks ap-
pears feasible in light of our results, but remains a matter
for future work.
For neuroscientific modeling, our analysis of LIF neu-
rons can be readily transferred to other neuron [26] and
synapse models. Beyond neuroscience, the ability to per-
form probabilistic inference with deterministic neurons
displays a promising computing paradigm for neuromor-
phic hardware systems, which typically implement physi-
cal models of integrate-and-fire neurons [27, 28]. The dis-
tributed nature of the proposed LIF sampling networks
allows to exploit the inherent parallelism of neuromor-
phic architectures and fosters their application to online
data evaluation and robotics. In this context, our results
have already provided the basis for the implementation
of Bayesian networks [29] and learning [30].
6
APPENDIX
Appendix I:
Conductance-based LIF neuron model
We restate the set of equations that govern the
conductance-based LIF model. For the membrane po-
tential, we have
Cm
du
dt
= gl(El − u) + I
,
(15)
with capacitance Cm, membrane potential uk, leak po-
tential El, leak conductance gl and input current I. The
input current I can be formally partitioned into recur-
rent synaptic inputs, diffuse synaptic noise and addi-
tional "external" currents, i.e.,
I = I rec + I noise + I ext
.
(16)
I ext may represent external current stimuli, average
synaptic stimulus currents, or changes in the leak mecha-
nism (i.e., changes in gl or El). The total synaptic current
I syn = I rec + I noise obeys the equation
i − u)
(cid:88)
I syn =
(Erev
(17)
gsyn
i
,
syn i
where gsyn
i
and Erev
synaptic conductance obeys the ODE
represents the conductance at the ith synapse
the corresponding reversal potential. The
i
dgsyn
i
dt
= − gsyn
i
τsyn
+
wiδ(t − ts)
,
(18)
(cid:88)
spk s
with synaptic time constant τsyn and weight wi. The sum
runs over all presynaptic spikes s. The solution to this
equation is a superposition of exponentials:
gsyn
i =
wiΘ(t − ts) exp
.
(19)
(cid:19)
(cid:18)
− t − ts
τsyn
(cid:88)
spk s
Putting all of the above together, we obtain the full ODE
for the membrane potential
Cm
du
dt
= gl(El − u)
(cid:88)
(cid:88)
+
wiΘ(t − ts) exp
(cid:19)
(cid:18)
− t − ts
τsyn
(Erev
i − u)
(20)
i
spk s
+ I ext
.
(cid:80)
i gsyn
i
We can now divide the RHS of (Eq. 20) by gtot = gl +
and rearrange the terms in order to obtain
τeff
du
dt
= ueff − u ,
with a new effective membrane time constant
τeff =
Cm
gtot
(21)
(22)
and effective leak potential
glEl +(cid:80)
ueff (t) =
(t)Erev
i + I ext
i gsyn
i
gtot(t)
.
(23)
This transformation is routinely used in studies of
conductance-based neurons (see, e.g., [14]). Here, we
have made the time dependencies explicit, since the fol-
lowing HCS approximation will serve to eliminate t in
the denominator.
Appendix II:
The high-conductance state (HCS)
In a first approximation, assuming a rapidly-firing
Poisson background (νsyn → ∞), the total average con-
ductance can become arbitrarily large ((cid:104) gtot (cid:105) → ∞),
causing the membrane potential to follow the effective
potential nearly instantaneously ((cid:104) τeff (cid:105) → 0). Eq. (23)
can then be rewritten as
glEl +(cid:80)
i +(cid:80)
(cid:104) gtot (cid:105) +(cid:80)
(cid:105)Erev
i(cid:104) gsyn
i
i Erev
i +I ext
i ∆gsyn
i ∆gsyn
i
u ≈ ueff =
where
,
(24)
(25)
∆gsyn
i = gsyn
i − (cid:104) gsyn
i
(cid:105)
denotes the fluctuations of the synaptic conductances.
For a single Poisson source with rate νi connected to
the neuron by a synapse with weight wi and time con-
stant τsyn, the conductance course can be seen as a sum
of independent random variables, each of them represent-
ing the conductance change caused by a single spike. In
the limit of large νi, the central limit theorem guaran-
tees the convergence of the conductance distribution to
a Gaussian, with moments given by
(cid:104) gsyn
i
(cid:105) =
wiΘ(t − ts) exp
(cid:28)
(cid:88)
spk s
= lim
T→∞
(cid:104) N (cid:105)
T
= wiνiτsyn
wi
(cid:19)(cid:29)
(cid:18)
(cid:18)
− t − ts
(cid:19)
τsyn
− t
τsyn
(cid:90) T
0
exp
dt
(26)
is the unique solution of the Fokker-Planck equation
1
θ
∂f (x, t)
∂t
=
∂
∂x
[(x − µ)f ] +
σ2
2θ
∂2f
∂x2
(33)
and
Var [gsyn
i
] =
(cid:88)
spk s
Var
(cid:20)
7
(cid:19)(cid:21)2(cid:43)
(cid:18)
(cid:19)(cid:21)
τsyn
− t − ts
(cid:18)
− t − ts
(cid:19)(cid:21)(cid:29)2(cid:41)
(cid:19)
τsyn
t
dt
τsyn
wiΘ(t − ts) exp
(cid:40)(cid:42)(cid:20)
wiΘ(t − ts) exp
+
wiΘ(t − ts) exp
(cid:18)
(cid:90) T
0
τsyn
− t − ts
(cid:18)
(cid:35)(cid:41)
(cid:19)
exp
−2
dt
1
T
w2
i
(cid:18)
exp
0
− t
τsyn
= lim
T→∞(cid:104) N (cid:105)
(cid:28)(cid:20)
(cid:40)
= lim
T→∞ νiT
(cid:34)(cid:90) T
− 1
T 2
=
1
2
w2
i νiτsyn
,
(cid:115)
(cid:112)Var [gsyn
]
(cid:104) gsyn
i
i
(cid:105) =
1
2 νiτsyn
(27)
(28)
, ∀i.
so the relative fluctuations of gsyn are of the order
and vanish in the limit of large firing rates.
This warrants an expansion of Eq. (24) in ∆gsyn
i
Considering only the first-order term we obtain
I ext + glEl +(cid:80)
synaptic noise current J syn =(cid:80)
u(t) =
(cid:104) gtot (cid:105)
which renders u simply a linear transformation of the
i gsyn
i
(t)Erev
i
,
(29)
i gsyn
i Erev
i
.
Derivation of the equivalence to an OU process
Appendix III:
From Eq.
(18), we can find that the synaptic noise
J syn obeys the first-order inhomogenous ODE
δ(t − ts) ,
∆J syn
dJ syn
+
(cid:88)
(cid:88)
i
= − J syn
τsyn
dt
syn i
spk s
(30)
i = wiErev
where ∆J syn
cent of the ODE that defines the OU process
dx(t) = θ [µ − x(t)] dt + σdW (t) .
i
. This equation is highly reminis-
(31)
It is well-known that the PDF of the OU process
f (x, tx0) =
πσ2(1 − e−2θt)
θ
(cid:20) (x − µ + (µ − x0)e−θt)2
(cid:26)−θ
(cid:21)(cid:27)
(32)
1 − e−2θt
× exp
σ2
(cid:115)
with starting condition x0 := x(t = 0). In the following,
we prove that, under certain assumptions, the distribu-
tion of the synaptic input J syn obeys the same Fokker-
Planck equation. To this end, we follow an approach
similar to [15].
Consider the PDF of the synaptic input f (J syn, t). We
can use the Chapman-Kolmogorov equation to describe
its evolution after a short time interval ∆t as an integral
over all possible intermediate states J(cid:48):
(cid:90) ∞
−∞
f (J syn, t + ∆t) =
f (J syn, t + ∆tJ(cid:48), t)f (J(cid:48), t)dJ(cid:48)
(34)
For a small enough ∆t, the probability of the occurrence
of multiple spikes within ∆t can be neglected. As in-
coming spikes are assumed to be generated by Poisson
processes, the probability of a single spike occurring in
i νi. By summing over the two possible histo-
ries of J syn within ∆t (either a single incoming spike or
no spike at all), we can use Eq. (30) to find
∆t is ∆t(cid:80)
(cid:34)
f (J syn, t + ∆tJ(cid:48))
1 − ∆t
=
νi
δ
(cid:35)
(cid:20)
J syn − J(cid:48) exp
(cid:18)
+ ∆t
νiδ
J syn− (J(cid:48) + ∆J syn
i
) exp
(cid:88)
(cid:20)
i
(cid:88)
i
(cid:19)(cid:21)
(cid:19)(cid:21)
(cid:18)
− ∆t
τsyn
− ∆t
τsyn
where νi represents the afferent firing frequency at the
ith synapse. Plugging this into Eq. (34) and integrating
over J(cid:48) yields
f (J syn, t + ∆t)
(cid:32)
=
(cid:88)
1 − ∆t
(cid:88)
i
νi exp
(cid:18) ∆t
(cid:20)
τsyn
(cid:33)
(cid:18) ∆t
νi
exp
(cid:19)
τsyn
+ ∆t
i
(cid:20)
(cid:19)
f
f
J syn exp
(cid:18) ∆t
(cid:19)
, t
τsyn
− ∆J syn
i
(cid:21)
(cid:21)
J syn exp
(cid:18) ∆t
(cid:19)
τsyn
and rearrange the terms to obtain
8
f (J syn, t + ∆t) − f (J syn, t)
∂f (J syn, t + ∆t)
∂∆t
νi exp
∆t
τsyn
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)∆t=0
(cid:18) ∆t
(cid:19)
(cid:33)
(cid:88)
(cid:19)
(cid:18) ∆t
(cid:19)
(cid:18)
(cid:18) ∆t
(cid:19)
1
τsyn
∆t
τsyn
(cid:20)
(cid:20)
τsyn
νi
2
f
i
J syn
(cid:40)
(cid:32)
=
=
+
−(cid:88)
(cid:40)
i
1 − ∆t
×
exp
(cid:88)
i
+
+ exp
νi exp
(cid:41)
(cid:20)
J syn exp
(cid:18) ∆t
(cid:19)
τsyn
(cid:21)
, t
f
(cid:18) ∆t
τsyn
J syn exp
(cid:104)
∂f
J syn exp
∂J syn exp
(cid:18) ∆t
τsyn
, t
(cid:21)
(cid:19)
(cid:16) ∆t
(cid:16) ∆t
(cid:19)
τsyn
τsyn
(cid:17)
(cid:105)
(cid:17) (cid:41)
(cid:21)
, t
− ∆J syn
i
f
J syn exp
τsyn
, t
(38)
+ (. . . )∆t
∆t=0
By taking the limit ∆t → 0, we obtain:
, (35)
∂f (J syn, t)
∂t
=
+
1
τsyn
(cid:88)
∂
∂J syn [J synf (J syn, t)]
νi [f (J syn − ∆J syn
i
, t) − f (J syn, t)]
.
i
(39)
i → 0),
In the limit of small synaptic weights (i.e., ∆J syn
we can expand the second term on the RHS up to the
second order in ∆J syn
. This yields, after some rearrange-
ment
i
(cid:34)(cid:32)
J syn −(cid:88)
(cid:33)
(cid:35)
νi∆J syn
i
τsyn
f (J syn, t)
∂f (J syn, t)
∂t
1
τsyn
(cid:80)
∂
∂J syn
, t
.
(36)
=
+
i νi∆J syn
i
i
2
∂2f (J syn, t)
2
∂J syn2
,
(40)
We can now expand f (x, t + ∆t) up to first order in ∆t
f (J syn, t + ∆t) ≈ f (J syn, t) +
∂f (J syn, t + ∆t)
∂∆t
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)∆t=0
∆t
(37)
which is the exact equivalent of the Fokker-Planck equa-
tion of the OU process (Eq. 33). Since u(t) is only a
linear transformation of J syn(t), it can also be approxi-
mated by an OU process in the limit of large input fre-
quencies and small synaptic weights, with Eq. (29) and
Eq. (40) giving the specific time constant, mean value
and variance:
θ =
µ =
,
1
τsyn
I ext + glEl +(cid:80)
(cid:80)
(cid:104) gtot (cid:105)
i − µ)]2 τsyn
i νi [wi (Erev
i νiwiErev
i
τsyn
2(cid:104) gtot (cid:105)2
σ2
2
=
(41)
,
(42)
.
(43)
We conclude this section with two important notes.
Firstly, for the above methodology to be generally applic-
i → 0 for
cable, we must be able to take the limit ∆J syn
arbitrary first and second moments of f (J syn, t) without
modifying them. This is possible if at least one excitatory
and one inhibitory input is present, which then give us
two degrees of freedom with a proper choice of νexc → ∞
and νinh → ∞. Secondly, all higher moments (3 and
above) need to vanish in the abovementioned limit. This
has been shown to also be the case under the above con-
ditions [31].
Appendix IV:
Derivation of the activation function
(cid:11)
(cid:10) ts+1
We can distinguish between two firing modes of the
neuron. The first mode can be classified as "burst spik-
ing" and occurs when multiple spikes occur in rapid
succession with an expected ISI of (cid:104) ∆tk (cid:105) = τref +
k represents the av-
erage drift time from the reset to the threshold potential
following the kth refractory period within a burst.
In
this case, for each spike within a burst,
s = τref + τ b
k , where τ b
k − ts
k
ueff (ts) ≥ ϑ ,
and also, for all but the last spike,
ueff (ts + τref ) ≥ ϑ .
(44)
(45)
The second mode appears between such bursts, where the
membrane potential evolves freely in the subthreshold
regime. If we define, just like in the abstract model, that
the kth neuron is in the state zk = 1 for a duration
τon = τref following a spike, we can write
(cid:80)
n Pn ·(cid:16)
(cid:80)
nτref +(cid:80)n−1
n Pn · n · τref
k=1 τ b
k + Tn
(cid:17) ,
(46)
p(z = 1) =
where Pn represents the distribution of burst lengths
(conditioned on the existence of the first spike) and Tn is
the mean time interval between the end of a burst (i.e.,
the endpoint of its last refractory period) and the next
spike. The variables Pn, Tn and τ b
k depend on all neuron
and noise parameters, but for calculating the activation
function (Fig. 2 in the main manuscript and Fig. 6 in the
Appendix), we only vary ¯u.
9
We can now calculate both Pn and Tn iteratively. The
idea behind this approach is to propagate the membrane
potential PDF from spike to spike within a burst and cut
off the irrelevant parts for a particular burst length n.
We denote the spike times within a burst of length n
by t0, . . . , tn−1 and the endpoint of such a burst by tn :=
tn−1+τref . For brevity, we also use ui := u(ti). Assuming
a first spike at some time t0 (u0 := u(t0) = ϑ), a "burst"
of length n = 1 requires a subthreshold free membrane
potential after the first refractory period (u1 := u(t0 +
τref ) < ϑ). This occurs with probability
P1 : = p(u1 < ϑu0 = ϑ)
(cid:90) ϑ
(cid:124)
−∞
=
du1p(u1u0 = ϑ)
,
(47)
(cid:123)(cid:122)
I1
(cid:125)
where p(ui+1ui) := f (u, τrefui), which was defined in
Eq. (32). On average, the neuron then stays in the sub-
threshold regime for a period equal to the mean first pas-
sage time from u1 to ϑ, so the mean duration of the time
interval until the onset of the next burst can be expressed
as
T1 =
du1p(u1u0 = ϑ)(cid:104) T (ϑ, u1)(cid:105)
.
(48)
(cid:90) ϑ
−∞
The first-passage time problem of the OU process has
often been discussed [32]. While no closed-form expres-
sion for the distribution of first-passage times T (b, a) =
inf t ≥ 0 : x(t) = bx(0) = a is known, its moments can be
computed analytically [18]. In particular, the mean first
passage time reads
(cid:104) T (b, a)(cid:105)
(cid:114) π
(cid:90) b
=
θ
σ
2
a
(cid:20) (x − µ)2
(cid:21)(cid:20)
2σ2
(cid:19)(cid:21)
(cid:18) x − µ√
2σ
dx exp
1+erf
. (49)
A burst of n = 2 spikes can only occur when the effec-
tive membrane potential lies above the spiking threshold
(u1 ≥ ϑ) after the first refractory period and below after
the second (u2 < ϑ). This makes P2 and T2 recursive
functions of P1:
P2 = p(u2 < ϑ, u1 ≥ ϑu0 = ϑ)
= p(u1 ≥ ϑu0 = ϑ) p(u2 < ϑu1 ≥ ϑ, u0 = ϑ)
= (1 − I1)
=1−P1
du1p(u1u1 ≥ ϑ)
−∞
du2p(u2u1)
(Eq.47)
(cid:90) ∞
(cid:124)
ϑ
(cid:34)(cid:90) ϑ
(cid:123)(cid:122)
I2
(cid:35)
(cid:125)
du1p(u1u1 ≥ ϑ)
du2p(u2u2 > ϑ, u1)(cid:104) T (u2, ϑ)(cid:105)
(cid:35)
,
(50)
(51)
(cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125)
(cid:90) ∞
(cid:34)(cid:90) ϑ
ϑ
−∞
T2 =
×
where p(uiui ≥ ϑ) is a shorthand notation for p(uiui ≥
ϑ, ui−1 ≥ ϑ, . . . , u1 ≥ ϑ, u0 = ϑ).
In particular, this
represents a renormalization of the PDF of the effective
membrane potential to values above the spiking threshold
after i refractory periods.
We can now continue this recursion up to an arbitrary
burst length and write
Pn = p(un < ϑ, un−1 ≥ ϑ, . . . , u1 ≥ ϑu0 = ϑ)
= p(u1 ≥ ϑu0 = ϑ)
× p(un < ϑ, un−1 ≥ ϑ, . . . , u2 ≥ ϑu1 ≥ ϑ, u0 = ϑ)
= (1 − I1) p(u2 ≥ ϑu1 ≥ ϑ, u0 = ϑ)
× p(un < ϑ, un−1 ≥ ϑ, . . . , u3 ≥ ϑ
(Eq.47)
u2 ≥ ϑ, u1 ≥ ϑ, u0 = ϑ)
(Eq.50)
= (1 − I1)(1 − I2) p(u3 ≥ ϑu2 ≥ ϑ, u1 ≥ ϑ, u0 = ϑ)
× p(un < ϑ, un−1 ≥ ϑ, . . . , u4 ≥ ϑ
u3 ≥ ϑ, . . . , u1 ≥ ϑ, u0 = ϑ)
(1 − Ii) p(un < ϑun−1 ≥ ϑ, . . . , u1 ≥ ϑ, u0 = ϑ)
Pi)
dun−1p(un−1un−1 ≥ ϑ)
(52)
(cid:34)(cid:90) ϑ
−∞
dunp(unun−1)
(cid:35)
(cid:125)
(cid:123)(cid:122)
In
=
i=1
n−1(cid:89)
= (1 − n−1(cid:88)
(cid:90) ∞
(cid:124)
(cid:90) ∞
(cid:34)(cid:90) ϑ
i=1
ϑ
ϑ
×
×
−∞
Tn =
dun−1p(un−1un−1 ≥ ϑ)
dunp(unun < ϑ, un−1)(cid:104) T (un, ϑ)(cid:105)
(cid:35)
(53)
(54)
The transition from a product to a sum between Eq. (52)
and Eq. (53) requires the identity
n−1(cid:89)
(1 − Ii) = 1 − n−1(cid:88)
Pi
,
(55)
i=1
i=1
(cid:81)n−1
which can be easily shown by induction from Pn =
i=1 (1 − Ii) (Eq. 52) and P1 = I1 (Eq. 47). Since
In
limn→∞ Pn = 0, one can stop the recursion at some small
enough Pn.
What remains to be calculated is the average time-to
threshold τ b
k within a burst that follows the kth refrac-
tory period. Since we assume a HCS, we are looking at
a regime in which τeff (cid:28) τsyn. Therefore, we can assume
ueff to be approximately unchanged during the short time
interval τ b
k (adiabatic approximation, see also [17]). For
a fixed uk, the jump time can be easily calculated from
Eq. (21):
(cid:19)
(cid:18) − uk
ϑ − uk
τ b
k (uk) = ln
10
.
(56)
The average jump time can then be obtained by inte-
grating over all suprathreshold values of uk, which in
turn have probabilities that follow from integrating over
all suprathreshold values of uk−1 :
(cid:90) ∞
(cid:18) − uk
(cid:19)(cid:90) ∞
ϑ
ϑ
duk ln
τ b
k =
ϑ − uk
duk−1p(ukuk > ϑ, uk−1) .
(57)
With Eq. (46), (53), (54), (57) and (49), one could
now predict the activation function of an LIF unit in an
extreme high-noise regime (τeff → 0). We can, however,
generalize our approach by taking the finite nature of the
effective time constant into account.
If we go back to Eq. (21) and leave τeff = C/(cid:104) gtot (cid:105)
small but finite, we can still perform all the remaining
approximations, but are required to modify Eq. (29):
τeff u(t) =
I ext + glEl
(cid:104) gtot (cid:105) +
J syn(t)
(cid:104) gtot (cid:105) − u(t)
.
(58)
(cid:17)
(cid:16)
Together with Eq. (30), we now have a system of first-
order ODEs which can be solved analytically by standard
techniques (variation of constants). The PSPs are then
no longer a linear transformation of the exponentially
shaped PSCs, but rather alpha-shaped (more precisely, a
difference of exponentials):
τsyn
− t−ts
us(t) = Θ(t − ts)A
− t−ts
τeff − e
e
τeff − τsyn
with A = wi(Erev
. This shape causes a lower
PSP peak than in the case of exponential PSPs, decreas-
ing the overall width of the membrane potential distri-
bution. Intuitively speaking, this results in a horizontal
shift and compression of the activation function.
i −(cid:104) ueff (cid:105))τsyn i
(cid:104) gtot (cid:105)
(59)
,
More recently, analytical treatments of these phenom-
ena have been proposed [33]. In these approaches, large
membrane time constants (equivalent to a long τeff ) and
small synaptic time constants are usually considered.
However, Eq. (59) is symmetric in τeff and τsyn, so the
same argument applies to our case as well, but the two
time constants need to be switched. It is, for example,
possible to correct the first passage time from the reset to
(with τ(cid:48) and τ being the smaller and the larger of the
two time constants, respectively) [16]:
the threshold potential by using an expansion in(cid:112)τ(cid:48)/τ
(cid:104) T (ϑ, u)(cid:105) = τ
√
π
(cid:90) ϑeff −µ
σ
u−µ
σ
dx exp(x2)[erf(x)+1]
, (60)
with µ and σ2 the first two moments of the free membrane
potential distribution and an effective threshold
ϑeff ≈ ϑ − ζ
τ(cid:48)
2τ
σ ,
(61)
(cid:19)(cid:114)
(cid:18) 1
2
11
Additionally, depressing short-term plasticity [22] has
been applied to attenuate the amplitudes of consecu-
tively arriving alpha-shaped PSPs from a network neuron
and emulate renewing synapses. In particular, within the
Tsodyks-Markram short-term plasticity model [22], the
synaptic efficacy parameter and recovery time constant
have been chosen as USE = 1 and τrec = τsyn, respec-
tively.
mined from the condition σ(bk) = σ((cid:2)¯ub
Analogously to the weights, the biases can be deter-
(cid:3) /α) in the
k − ¯u0
k
absence of recurrent activity, i.e. I rec
k = 0.
Probabilistic model for demonstration of inference
Appendix VI:
We define a joint model p(y, z) over real-valued in-
put nodes y = (y1, . . . , yK) and binary latent variables
z = (z1, . . . , zK) as sketched in Fig. 4A of the main
manuscript. The real-valued variables yk encode inten-
sities of the input pixels. The latent variables zk corre-
spond to neurons in the network. Our aim is to demon-
strate that the network can sample from the posterior
distribution p(z y).
For this example, we have chosen a particularly simple
likelihood function, namely a Gaussian emission model
with variance σ2 = 1 and mean values µ = ± 1
2 . From
the graphical model we identify the structure of the joint
distribution
p(y, z) = p(z) · K(cid:89)
p(yk zk)
(66)
k=1
where p(z) is a Boltzmann distribution and the likelihood
is defined by
p(yk zk) = N (yk; µ = 1/2)zk · N (yk; µ = −1/2)1−zk
,
(67)
which is equivalent to
log p(yk zk) = zk · [log N (yk; 1/2) − log N (yk; −1/2)]
+ log N (yk; −1/2)
= zk · yk + log N (yk; −1/2) ,
using normal distributions
N (y; µ) := exp[−(y − µ)2/2] /
√
2π
with unit variance. The posterior of this model reads:
p(z y) =
p(y, z)
(68)
(69)
= exp
zTW z + zT (b + y)
Norm , (70)
p(y)
(cid:18) 1
2
(cid:19)(cid:46)
By setting τref = τsyn, we obtain the mapping between
the abstract and LIF synaptic weight domains:
Wkj =
×(cid:104)
1
αCm
τsyn
(cid:17)(cid:105)
− τsyn
τeff − 1
.
(65)
where the normalizing constant depends on the input y,
but is independent of the network variables and thus
particular case, the expansion is done in (cid:112)τeff /τsyn, so
in which ζ denotes the Riemann zeta function.
In our
τ(cid:48) = τeff and τ = τsyn. With this approximation, we
assume that u converges from ρ to ueff in negligible time
after it is released from the refractory state. Afterwards,
its convergence to ueff is determined by Eq. (21). Note
how Eq. (60) is equivalent to a change of the integration
variable and limits in the original equation (Eq. 49) for
the first passage time.
Appendix V:
Translation of synaptic weights
A sufficient condition for a single neuron to sample
from the correct conditional distribution is given by its
activation function:
p(zk = 1z\k) = σ(vk)
.
(62)
The relationship between the abstract model and the LIF
implementation is defined by the lateral dilation α and
relative offset ¯u0
k of the LIF activation function:
p(zk = 1z\k) = σ
.
(63)
(cid:18) ¯uk − ¯u0
k
(cid:19)
α
The parameters α and ¯u0
k can be determined by fitting
Eq. (63) either to simulation results or to the theoreti-
cal prediction (Eq. 46). As a consequence, also synaptic
weights need to be rescaled by the factor α. Addition-
ally, the difference in PSP shapes needs to be taken into
account.
We choose a translation rule in which we set the LIF
synaptic weights wij such that the area under a PSP
(Eq. 59) during the refractory state of the correspond-
ing afferent neuron (i.e., for a duration τref ) is equal to
Wij τref α:
Wkjτref α =
(cid:90) τref
(cid:16)− t−ts
(cid:16)
τeff
0
× exp
=
×(cid:104)
(cid:16)
wkjτsyn
(cid:104) gtot (cid:105)
e
τsyn
kj − (cid:104) ueff (cid:105))τsyn
(cid:104) gtot (cid:105)
(cid:17)
τsyn
(cid:16)
wkj(Erev
(cid:17) − exp
(cid:16)− t−ts
(cid:17)
τeff − τsyn
kj − µ
Erev
(cid:17) − τeff
τeff − τsyn
− τref
τsyn − 1
(cid:17)
(cid:16)
kj − µ
Erev
(cid:16)
(cid:0)e−1 − 1(cid:1) − τeff
1 − τsyn
wkj
τeff
e
dt
(cid:17)(cid:105)
− τref
τeff − 1
.
(64)
e
vk = bk + yk +(cid:80)
defines a Boltzmann distribution over z for any y.
In
particular, we identify the abstract membrane potential
j Wkj zj for sampling from p(z y) by
means of a spiking network.
12
The deviations from the theoretical prediction (Eq. 46)
are smaller than the size of the symbols, therefore no
errorbars are shown.
The ordinate values and standard errors were calcu-
lated from the simulated spike train data according to
pi
1
N
N(cid:88)
(cid:118)(cid:117)(cid:117)(cid:116) 1
i=1
N − 1
p(z = 1) =
s =
(72)
[pi − p(z = 1)]2
,
(73)
,
· N(cid:88)
i=1
Appendix VII:
Simulation parameters
All simulations have been performed with the NEU-
RON simulation package [34] and the PyNN API [35],
with a time step of dt = 0.01 ms. For the LIF neuron,
we have chosen the following parameters (compare with,
e.g., [36] for parameters fitted to experimental data):
5 nS leak conductance
-65 mV leak potential
-53 mV reset potential
Cm 0.1 nF membrane capacitance
gl
El
ρ
exc 0 mV excitatory reversal potential
inh -90 mV inhibitory reversal potential
ϑ -52 mV threshold voltage
Erev
Erev
τon
being the fraction of time spent in
with pi = N spk
i
Tsim
z = 1 and N spk
representing the total number of spikes
in the ith out of N = 10 performed simulations. Since
the respective standard errors of the mean are smaller
than the size of the symbols, no error bars are shown.
i
Appendix IX:
τsyn 10 ms synaptic time constant
τref
10 ms refractory time constant
Sampling via recurrent networks of LIF neurons
(Fig. 3 and 4 in main manuscript)
TABLE I. Neuron parameters used for the simulations in the
main manuscript.
Synaptic noise was implemented as bombardment by
inhibitory and excitatory Poisson stimuli with rates
νinh = νexc = 5000 Hz. The excitatory synaptic weight
for the noise stimuli was set to wnoise
exc = 0.0035 µS.
The inhibitory weight wnoise
inh was adjusted as to yield
p(zk = 1) ≈ 0.5 with no current stimulus present. For
above parameters, this happens at an average free mem-
brane potential of ¯u = −55 mV. This determines wnoise
according to
inh
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) Erev
inh − ¯u
exc − ¯u
Erev
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) =
exc
wnoise
wnoise
inh
.
(71)
Appendix VIII:
The activation function of LIF neurons in a spiking
noisy environment (Fig. 2 in main manuscript)
In order to sweep through the activation function, the
external current I ext was varied. However, in order to
facilitate a comparison with the logistic activation func-
tion of the abstract model, we have represented p(z = 1)
as a function of ¯u instead. The latter is equivalent to the
mean µ of the corresponding Ornstein-Uhlenbeck pro-
cess, with Eq. (42) allowing a direct translation between
I ext and ¯u.
The abscissa values in Fig. 2D in the main manuscript
represent averages of the free membrane potential ob-
tained from 10 simulation runs with a total duration of
Tsim = 100 s and firing threshold θ set to Erev
exc = 0 mV.
The simulated network consists of K = 5 neurons
with a synaptic weight matrix W and a bias vector
b (both in the Boltzmann domain). All entries were
drawn from a beta distribution B(0.5, 0.5) and mapped
[−0.6, 0.6]. More specifically,
linearly to the interval
bk, Wkj ∼ 1.2 · [B(0.5, 0.5) − 0.5]. The parameters and
mapping of the beta distribution were chosen with the
intent of generating diverse distributions, spanning mul-
tiple orders of magnitude. The bias bk, defined in the
Boltzmann domain, determines the probability p(zk =
1 z\k = 0) for neuron k. In the LIF domain, the proba-
bility p(zk = 1 z\k = 0) = 0.5 corresponds to the mean
free membrane potential ¯u0
k. Then, a nonzero bias can
be described in the LIF domain as a linear shift from ¯u0
k
to a mean membrane potential ¯ub
k. This yields the linear
transformation
bk =(¯ub
k − ¯u0
k)/α ,
(74)
where α represents the scaling factor between the two
domains. Both quantities ¯u0
k and α can be determined
from the predicted activation function of a single LIF
unit. The first quantity constitutes the inflection point
of the activation function (at p(zk = 1 z\k = 0) = 0.5),
the latter follows from the slope of the function.
By computing ¯ub
k, we can map any bias bk of a single
unit of the Boltzmann machine onto a yet unconnected
LIF neuron. In simulations, ¯ub
k was established by inject-
ing a temporally constant external current I k
ext according
to
I ext
k = (αbk+¯u0
νiwnoise
i
Erev
i
τsyn. (75)
k)(cid:104) gtot (cid:105)−glEl−(cid:88)
i
In order to achieve sampling network dynamics in the
LIF domain faithful to those displayed by an equivalent
Boltzmann machine, the Boltzmann weight matrix W
was translated into LIF network weights wij according
to Eq. (65). Thus, superposing PSPs saturate the mem-
brane potential, approximating the constant amplitude
of a PSP in the abstract neuron model.
For Fig. 3B in the main manuscript, this setup of a
random Boltzmann machine was simulated N = 10 times
with different random seeds for the Poisson background
for a duration of Tsim = 10 s. The red bars show the
analytically computed target joint distribution pB(z).
The blue bars depict the network distribution pN(z),
calculated from the firing activity of the simulated LIF
network set up to match pB(z). The means and error
bars have been calculated as in Eq. (72) and (73),
respectively.
The above simulations were repeated with a signifi-
cantly longer duration in order to study systematic devia-
tions due to the LIF implementation. Fig. 3C in the main
manuscript shows the distance between the target distri-
bution pB(z) and its LIF network representation pN(z)
in form of the Kullback-Leibler divergence
DKL (pN pB) = (cid:104) log [ pN(z) / pB(z) ](cid:105)pN(z)
(76)
This estimate has been taken for one set of parameters
(W , b) for ten independent trials (thin lines) in an LIF
network at integration times T : 0 ≤ T ≤ Tsim = 106 ms.
The red dashed line displays the averaged DKL (pN pB)
for the abstract network model with identical parameters
(W , b). The decrease of DKL (pN pB) for longer integra-
tion times indicates the increasing precision of the sam-
pling network over time. Eventually, the DKL (pN pB)
converges for the LIF network to a nonzero value, re-
flecting small systematic errors. Fig. 3D in the main
manuscript shows the distribution of DKL (pN pB) val-
ues for 100 randomly drawn Boltzmann machines emu-
lated by LIF networks, evaluated from a single run of
Tsim = 106 ms each.
Fig. 4 was generated in the same way as Fig. 3, except
for the network size and weight distribution.
Appendix X:
Demostration of probabilistic inference
(Fig. 5 in main manuscript)
We trained a fully visible, fully connected Boltzmann
machine to store three hand-written digits (0, 3, 4) that
were taken from the MNIST data set [37] and were scaled
down to 12x12 pixels. The pixel intensities of these pat-
terns (ranging from 0 to 1) were linearly scaled to an ac-
tivation between 0.05 and 0.95, defining the target statis-
tics (cid:104) zk (cid:105)T and (cid:104) zk zj (cid:105)T for the Boltzmann machine.
Then, external currents I b
k and synaptic weights wkj
13
k ∝ (cid:104) zk (cid:105)T − zk
were optimized via the update rules ∆I b
and ∆wkj ∝ (cid:104) zk zj (cid:105)T − zk zj, with samples z obtained
The recurrent connections, defined by wkj,
through sampling from an LIF network set up with
synaptic noise and neuron parameters as described above.
induce
synaptic currents I rec
in addition to the noise currents
I noise
. Additionally, each neuron's mean effective mem-
k
brane potential Eq. (42) is shifted by external currents
k as well as input currents I y
of the trained quantities I b
k .
The latter encode observations y which are defined in
the context of the probabilistic model described in AVI.
Hence, the total received current of neuron k in the net-
work amounts to
k
Ik = I rec
k + I noise
k
+ I b
k + I y
k .
(77)
The resulting samples z(t) displayed in subplots 5C
and 5D were taken for 4000 ms, after a burn-in time
that ensured that the network had converged to its
equilibrium distribution.
Figure 5C, main manuscript: Sampling from the prior.
From the probabilistic model it follows that p(z y =
0) = p(z). This means that the LIF network will sample
k = 0, ∀k. The figure makes use
from the prior when I y
of two projections of network states z(t) to illustrate the
sampled distribution:
1. Star plot:
In order to illustrate the 12x12-
dimensional network states z(t), a two-dimensional
linear projection in a star plot has been chosen
(blue dots). The axes indicate the three basis vec-
tors B, representing pixel intensities (cid:104) zk (cid:105)T of the
digits (0, 3, 4),
(cid:104) zk (cid:105)034
(cid:113)(cid:80)
with a total
j2 = 1.
j Bi
T = (B0, B3, B4)T
(78)
intensity normalization Bi =
The network states z(t) acquired from the simula-
tion are projected onto this basis:
z034(t) = (B0 · z(t), B3 · z(t), B4 · z(t))T
(79)
.
This three-dimensional vector is then projected
onto a two-dimensional plane in coordinates
(cid:19)
(cid:18)sin(φ0
cos(φ0
zproj(t) =
B) sin(φ3
B) cos(φ3
B) sin(φ4
B)
B) cos(φ4
B)
z034(t)
(80)
B, φ4
B, φ3
3 , 4 π
B) = (0, 2 π
3 ) indicating the di-
with (φ0
rections of the normalized basis vectors.
These linear projections zproj(t) of network states
z(t) are used to illustrate similarity of states as dis-
tance in the two-dimensional plane. In Fig. 5C in
the main manuscript, a network evolution time of
4000 ms is shown, samples z(t) taken every 2 ms,
i.e. in total 2000 projected states are displayed. We
ensured in longer simulations that the total simu-
lation runtime is sufficient to represent the distri-
bution under the mixing of the Markov chain.
The significant clustering of the network states
around the directions of the arrows indicates the
proximity to the target states (0, 3, 4) for a major-
ity of time.
The transitions of the network states z(t) are de-
picted as a red trajectory in the star plot. This
trajectory connects 100 projected network states
within a time interval of 200 ms, demonstrating the
time evolution of zproj(t).
2. Snapshots: The squared color maps on the time
axis display the averaged pixel intensity of the net-
work in a time window 25 ms:
(cid:90) t+12.5 ms
25 ms
t−12.5 ms
¯zk(t) =
1
z(t(cid:48))
k dt(cid:48).
(81)
The equidistant time intervals between these snap-
shots were taken every 25 ms within the time frame
of the above mentioned red trajectory of 200 ms.
In summary, the network spends most of the time in
distinct modes (digits) and only little time in "blurred"
states that could not be clearly assigned to one digit.
Furthermore, it spends an approximately equal amount
of time in each mode, indicating that the prior p(z) does
not favor one of the three digits.
Figure 5D, main manuscript: Sampling from the pos-
terior.
Incomplete and ambiguous input y was provided
to the network by setting four of the inputs different from
zero: yk (cid:54)= 0 for k ∈ I with I denoting an index set and
I = 4. These inputs were chosen at the center of the
image where digits 3 and 4 both have black pixels, while
digit 0 is white. More precisely, I = {77, 78, 79, 80} when
pixels are indexed row-wise starting from the top-left cor-
ner. In the LIF implementation, positive values yk cor-
respond to positive currents I y
k , as specified in Eq. (75).
We set I y
k = 0.831 nA for the four non-zero inputs, induc-
ing an effective bias bk + yk by injecting a total current
k + I y
I b
k . For the plot, the same projections of network
states were used as in Fig. 5C in the main manuscript.
Under the incomplete input, the network spends only
little time in the 0-mode or "blurred" states, while the
equilibrium distribution exhibits two distict modes in the
3- and 4-directions. Thus the posterior reflects both the
almost certain conclusion that "the input is not a zero"
and the uncertainty that "the input could either be a
three or a four". In particular, the network response is
well-suited for further processing (e.g. by other cortical
populations or in a technical application). For instance,
14
the network states could be integrated by a linear classi-
fier to recognize the digit class.
Appendix XI:
Prediction of the activation function for various
parameter sets
We have used Eq. (46) for predicting the activation
functions of LIF neurons in the HCS regime.
In this
regime, the refractory time τref and the synaptic time
constant τsyn become the dominant time constants:
τeff (cid:28) τref ≈ τsyn
.
(82)
So far, we have compared our prediction to simulation
data, as well as to two other predictions by [16] and [17]
in Fig. 2B of the main manuscript. Here, we depart from
these assumptions and show in Fig. 6 that our prediction
holds for several different parameter sets. In particular,
the predictions from [16] and [17] are only valid when ei-
ther synaptic time constants (Fig. 6C) or refractory times
(Fig. 6E) become shorter.
Appendix XII:
Validity of the LIF sampling framework for various
parameter sets
For our various network simulations (Fig. 3-5 in the
main manuscript) we have used a set of biologically plau-
sible parameters from [36] (see also "Appendix VII: Sim-
ulation parameters"). In particular, we have used high
input noise rates and weights in order to achieve the HCS,
as well as a small distance between firing threshold and
reset, in order to reduce τ b
k , during which a neuron falsely
encodes the state z = 0. Furthermore, we have assumed
τref = τsyn. Fig. 7 shows that these are by no means
strict constraints.
∗ The first two authors have contributed equally to this
work. We thank W. Maass for his essential support,
as well as S. Habenschuss, M. Brixner and the three
anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments. This
research was supported by EU grants #269921 (Brain-
ScaleS), #237955 (FACETS-ITN), #604102 (Human
Brain Project), the Austrian Science Fund FWF #I753-
N23 (PNEUMA) and the Manfred Stark Foundation.
[1] K. Kording and D. Wolpert, Nature 427, 244 (2004).
[2] J. Fiser, P. Berkes, G. Orb´an, and M. Lengyel, Trends
in cognitive sciences 14, 119 (2010).
[3] K. Friston, J. Mattout, and J. Kilner, Biological cyber-
netics 104, 137 (2011).
[4] T. Yang and M. N. Shadlen, Nature 447, 1075 (2007).
[5] P. Berkes, G. Orb´an, M. Lengyel, and J. Fiser, Science
331, 83 (2011).
15
FIG. 6. Comparison of our prediction of the activation function (Eq. 46) to simulation data, as well as to the predictions
given by [16] and [17], for several parameter sets. (A) Standard parameter set as given in Tab. I. This figure shows the same
curves as Fig. 2B in the main manuscript. (B) Same as A, but with quadrupled membrane capacitance Cm and one quarter
of the leak conductance gl, input rates νexc,inh and weights wexc,inh. This parameter set is identical to the one used for the
top left corner of Fig. 7 and has the effect of slowing the membrane, i.e., increasing τeff by a factor of 16. (C) Same as A, but
with a decreased synaptic time constant τsyn = 3 ms. The prediction from [16] is improved, since the correlations in the pre-
and post-refractory effective membrane potential are smaller in this scenario. (D) Same as A, but with an increased synaptic
time constant τsyn = 30 ms. The prediction from [16] deteriorates due to the longer-range membrane potential autocorrelation.
Conversely, the prediction from [17] improves, since the refractory time becomes less important. (E) Same as A, but with a very
short refractory time τref = 1 ms. Here, we enter the parameter range where [17] provides good predictions. (F) Same as A,
but with the input rates νexc,inh and weights wexc,inh decreased by a factor of 10, thereby slowing the membrane considerably
(imperfect HCS). Additionally, we have chosen a large reset-to-threshold distance of ϑ − = 10 mV.
In this scenario, the
τ b
k -term in Eq. (46) becomes dominant and the activation function departs from the logistic shape that it has in the HCS.
[6] S. Deneve, Neural computation 20, 91 (2008).
[7] L. Buesing, J. Bill, B. Nessler, and W. Maass, PLoS
computational biology 7, e1002211 (2011).
[8] R. P. Rao (2004) pp. 1113–1120.
[9] P. O. Hoyer and A. Hyvarinen, Advances in neural infor-
mation processing systems , 293 (2003).
[21] A.-R. Mohamed, G. E. Dahl,
and G. Hinton, IEEE
Trans. on Audio, Speech, and Lang. Proc. 20, 14 (2012).
[22] M. Tsodyks and H. Markram, Proceedings of the Na-
tional Academy of Sciences of the United States of Amer-
ica 94, 719 (1997).
[23] G. Hinton, P. Dayan, B. Frey, and R. Neal, Science 268,
[10] Z. F. Mainen and T. J. Sejnowski, Science 268, 1503
1158 (1995).
(1995).
[11] M. A. Petrovici, J. Bill, I. Bytschok, J. Schemmel, and
[24] D. Sulzer and S. Rayport, Amino acids 19, 45 (2000).
[25] W. Gerstner and J. L. van Hemmen, Network: Compu-
K. Meier, arXiv preprint arXiv:1311.3211 (2013).
tation in Neural Systems 3, 139 (1992).
[12] A. Destexhe, J. Comp. Neurosci. 27, 493 (2009).
[13] A. Destexhe, M. Rudolph, and D. Pare, Nature Reviews
[26] R. Brette and W. Gerstner, J. Neurophysiol. 94, 3637
(2005).
Neuroscience 4, 739 (2003).
[27] S. Mitra, S. Fusi, and G. Indiveri, IEEE Transactions on
[14] M. J. Richardson and W. Gerstner, Neural computation
Biomedical Circuits and Systems 3, 32 (2009).
17, 923 (2005).
[28] M. A. Petrovici, B. Vogginger, P. Muller, O. Breitwieser,
[15] L. M. Ricciardi and L. Sacerdote, Biol. Cybern. 35, 1
et al., PLOS ONE 9, e108590 (2014).
(1979).
[29] D. Probst, M. A. Petrovici, I. Bytschok, et al., Frontiers
[16] N. Brunel and S. Sergi, Journal of Theoretical Biology
in Computational Neuroscience 9, 13 (2015).
195, 87 (1998).
[30] E. Neftci, S. Das, B. Pedroni, et al., Frontiers in Neuro-
[17] R. Moreno-Bote and N. Parga, Physical Review Letters
morphic Engineering (2014).
92, 028102 (2004).
[18] L. M. Ricciardi and S. Sato, Journal of Applied Proba-
[31] P. L´ansk`y, Physical Review E 55, 2040 (1997).
[32] M. U. Thomas, Journal of Applied Probability , 600
bility 25, 43 (1988).
(1975).
[19] D. Pecevski, L. Buesing, and W. Maass, PLoS compu-
tational biology 7, e1002294 (2011).
[33] A. N. Burkitt, Biological cybernetics 95, 97 (2006).
[34] M. L. Hines and N. T. Carnevale, The NEURON Book
[20] R. Salakhutdinov and G. E. Hinton (2009) pp. 448–455.
(Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 2006).
16
FIG. 7. Sampling with LIF neurons over a broad range of relevant model parameters. All plots depict the Kullback-Leibler
divergence between the sampled distribution (with a certain set of parameters) and the target distribution, which is identical to
the one used in Fig. 3B in the main manuscript. (A) Sweep over neuron size and leakage, as well as background input parameters.
The axes represent multiplicative scaling values for four parameters: background (Poisson) synaptic weights wexc,inh and firing
rates νexc,inh on the abscisa, neuron capacitance Cm and leak conductance gl on the ordinate. The parameter values used
throughout the main manuscript (see also "Appendix VII: Simulation parameters") therefore have the coordinates (1, 1). The
network simulation runtimes were chosen as Tsim = 106 ms. As expected, the large neuron / weak noise scenario (top left
square) does not permit accurate sampling, as the activation function is no longer logistic (see also Fig. 6F). In general, the
plot shows that good sampling quality can be achieved for any neuron capacitance and leak as long as the background noise is
strong enough (HCS). (B) Sweep over the ratio of the synaptic and refractory time constants. The best sampling performance
is, indeed, achieved for τsyn ≈ τref , but the network still produces good approximations of the target distribution when the
two time constants are not precisely identical. All DKL data points result from 20 simulations with runtimes of Tsim = 105 ms
each. The error bars represent the standard error of the mean. (C) Effect of an increased distance from reset to threshold
potential. An increase in ϑ − causes a gradual decay of the sampling quality, since the membrane requires additional time
to reach a suprathreshold ueff when the refractory period is over. This can, in principle, be accomodated by defining a larger
time window τon during which the neuron is considered to encode the state z = 1. Nevertheless, in an HCS, the effective time
constant can be low enough to render the threshold-to-reset distance irrelevant.
[35] A. P. Davison, D. Bruderle, J. Eppler, J. Kremkow,
E. Muller, D. Pecevski, L. Perrinet, and P. Yger, Front.
Neuroinform. 2 (2008).
[36] R. Naud, N. Marcille, C. Clopath, and W. Gerstner,
Biological Cybernetics 99, 335 (2008).
[37] Y. LeCun and C. Cortes, (1998).
|
1610.00611 | 1 | 1610 | 2016-10-03T16:12:27 | Analytical modelling of temperature effects on synapses | [
"q-bio.NC",
"physics.bio-ph"
] | It was previously reported, that temperature may significantly influence neural dynamics on different levels of brain modelling. Due to this fact, while creating the model in computational neuroscience we would like to make it scalable for wide-range of various brain temperatures. However currently, because of a lack of experimental data and an absence of analytical model describing temperature influence on synapses, it is not possible to include temperature effects on multi-neuron modelling level. In this paper, we propose first step to deal with this problem: new analytical model of AMPA-type synaptic conductance, which is able to include temperature effects in low-frequency stimulations. It was constructed on basis of Markov model description of AMPA receptor kinetics and few simplifications motivated both experimentally and from Monte Carlo simulation of synaptic transmission. The model may be used for efficient and accurate implementation of temperature effects on AMPA receptor conductance in large scale neural network simulations. This in fact, opens wide-range of new possibilities for researching an influence of temperature on brain functioning. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Analytical modelling of
temperature effects on synapses
Dominik S. Kufel∗
The Polish Children's Fund, Pasteura 5a, 02-093 Warsaw, Poland
S. Staszic High School no. 1, Raclawickie 26, 20-043 Lublin, Poland
Grzegorz M. Wojcik†
Maria Curie-Sklodowska University in Lublin, Akademicka 9, 20-033 Lublin, Poland
Abstract
It was previously reported, that temperature may significantly influence neural dynamics on different
levels of brain modelling. Due to this fact, while creating the model in computational neuroscience
we would like to make it scalable for wide-range of various brain temperatures. However currently,
because of a lack of experimental data and an absence of analytical model describing temperature
influence on synapses, it is not possible to include temperature effects on multi-neuron modelling
level.
In this paper, we propose first step to deal with this problem: new analytical model of AMPA-type
synaptic conductance, which is able to include temperature effects in low-frequency stimulations. It
was constructed on basis of Markov model description of AMPA receptor kinetics and few simplifi-
cations motivated both experimentally and from Monte Carlo simulation of synaptic transmission.
The model may be used for efficient and accurate implementation of temperature effects on AMPA
receptor conductance in large scale neural network simulations. This in fact, opens wide-range of
new possibilities for researching an influence of temperature on brain functioning.
I.
Introduction
From medical perspective, it was suggested that
tight control of brain temperature in patients
suffering posttraumatic period is highly recom-
mended [1]. However, direct mechanism of influ-
ence of temperature on neural dynamics is still
uncertain and better understanding of tempera-
ture effects on different levels of brain function-
ing may be useful in developing sophisticated
treatment methods of different neurological dis-
orders associated with increased or decreased
brain temperatures [2].
On level of single neurons, different effects of
temperature were observed. The most impor-
tant from perspective of neural dynamics are:
should be addresed
∗[email protected] - to who correspondence
†[email protected]
1) Temperature influences membrane resting po-
tential ([3], [4]). 2) Temperature affects ion
channels dynamics ([5], [6]). 3) Temperature
affects synaptic transmission ([7], [8], [9]).
However, temperature effects on membrane rest-
ing potentials (Goldman-Hodgkin-Katz equa-
tion) and ion channels dynamics [3] are now well-
known, an influence of temperature on synaptic
transmission was proven to be more elaborating
than on voltage-gated ion channels (see: [15]).
This may come from the fact, that for the vari-
ous processes involved in synaptic transmission,
like presynaptic release of neurotransmitter, dy-
namics of a vesicle pore, diffusion of neurotrans-
mitter, binding of the neurotransmitter, kinetics
of postsynaptic receptors, temperature influence
is different and may significantly modify overall
effect of heat on synaptic transmission [10].
Generally, in creation of models in computa-
1
D. Kufel and G. Wojcik • September 2016 •
tional neuroscience it is useful to make it easily
scalable for different temperatures. This is espe-
cially important, due to the fact, that some of
the neurobiological experiments are conducted
in lower temperatures (for example in vitro stud-
ies). Actually, a better knowledge about tem-
perature dependence of synaptic transmission
is a basis of linking in vitro and in vivo stud-
ies. Furthermore, optimal way of including full
description of temperature effects in neural sim-
ulations may open computational brain research
for new thermodynamic arguments.
We may tackle the problem of including temper-
ature effects on synapses from different perspec-
tives.
(1) A first approach is to include some coef-
ficients associated with temperature in phe-
nomenological synapse models. Through time,
different, phenomenological methods of mod-
elling of synaptic conductance were developed
(alpha function, dual-exponential functions, sin-
gle exponential function etc.). In practice, to
include effects of temperature we would have
to multiply all of the time constants and am-
plitudes of phenomenological functions by some
(probably different) factors associated with tem-
perature. However, there are different problems
related to this approach. Firstly, we do not
know the values of the temperature coefficients,
by which we would like to multiply parameters of
function (which are dependent on synaptic con-
ductance function we use). This values would
have to be obtained from extra experiment in
different temperature, fitted directly to same
modelling function. Furthermore, due to the
fact that we do not know, whether all of the
coefficients scale linearly with temperature, for
each temperature we would have to perform
additional experiment (which is not always pos-
sible for ex. when we are conducting in vitro
research).
(2) A second approach to take temperature ef-
fects into account is to model synapses on mi-
crophysiological level - so to investigate temper-
ature effects on kinetics of synaptic receptors
(proteins, which conformation is described by
kinetic scheme). To include temperature effects
we multiply all of the kinetic rate constants be-
2
tween different conformational states of protein
by some coefficients dependent on temperature.
This approach was previously taken experimen-
tally ([11],[18]). However, the problem is that all
of the temperature coefficients, which scale rate
constants, are specific for given kinetic scheme.
So, even if we have found temperature coeffi-
cients in one kinetic scheme, they are invalid for
others (unless, we find some way to link different
kinetic schemes, which is still not possible apart
from linking very simple kinetic models [16]).
So again, for our model we need to additionally
find all of the temperature coefficients each time,
which may be elaborating task for some types
of synapses.
Actually, both of the approaches have the same
essence. In second approach, to include tem-
perature effects we multiply all of the kinetic
rates by some temperature factors. In the first
approach we multiply amplitude and time con-
stants of functions. However, amplitude and
time constants in phenomenological modelling,
under certain assumptions, may be interpreted
as a combination of different kinetic rates, as it
was proposed before [12].
Generally, the problem of including temperature
effects on synapse modelling is complex. Both
first and second approaches are hard to gener-
alize for different phenomenological functions
describing synaptic conductance or different mi-
crophysiological kinetic schemes and need addi-
tional experiments to conduct, which prevents
previously developed model to be easily scalable
for wide-range of temperatures.
In this paper, novel approach to problem
of including temperature effects on modelling
synapses was proposed. On basis of previous ex-
perimental and numerical research we construct
assumptions of new analytical model to include
temperature effects in modelling of α-amino-
3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionic acid
(AMPA) receptor. Firstly, we propose simplifi-
cations of experimental kinetic scheme (by [11])
to allow for analytical solution of problem. Sec-
ondly using Monte Carlo simulation and Markov
modelling we introduce concept of uncoupling of
differential equation system describing AMPA
receptor kinetics. Thirdly, after solving set of
D. Kufel and G. Wojcik • September 2016 •
differential equations we compare results of con-
structed model with numerical and experimental
data. Finally, we suggest that our model is capa-
ble to include temperature effects in neural dy-
namics simulations at low frequencies, regardless
to phenomenological function of AMPA synap-
tic conductance used. This in fact allows, for
the first time, to optimally and accurately simu-
late neural dynamics in different temperatures,
without performing any additional experiments.
II. Methods and model
Monte Carlo simulation of synaptic trans-
mission For additional information to prove
assumptions and validate some of the results of
the analytical model, Monte Carlo simulation
of synaptic transmission was used. Monte Carlo
simulation was constructed on basis of assump-
tions and parameters by [11] - code in MCell
simulator [17] of their original simulation is avail-
able 1. To account for proper average responses,
we assumed variable vesicle location above cen-
tral postsynaptic density(PSD). Additionally,
four neighbouring PSDs were included, posi-
tioned in the same geometry as used in model
by [11].
Figure 1: Scheme 1 - modified kinetic scheme model by
[11],independent binding was assumed (see
below) and no transitions between desensi-
tized states (with minor influence on accu-
racy of results).
O1
O2
O3
O4
o
k
c
k
o
k
c
k
o
k
c
k
o
k
c
k
C0
kb
ku
C1
kb
ku
C2
kb
ku
C3
kb
ku
C4
k
r
k
d
k
r
k
d
k
r
k
d
k
r
k
d
D1
D2
D3
D4
Analytical model Our model is based on the
following numerical and experimental findings:
(1) Acceleration in postsynaptic AMPA receptor
kinetics is the predominant effect of tempera-
ture on altered synaptic responses [11] at low
1https://senselab.med.yale.edu/modeldb/
showModel.cshtml?model=85981
frequencies (to avoid effects of short-term synap-
tic plasticity). This assumption leads to the fact,
that in our model the problem of temperature
effects on synapses was simplified by consider-
ing temperature effects only on AMPA receptor
kinetics, rather than also on modified presy-
naptic release and/or neurotransmitter diffusion
dynamics. Furthermore, we assumed that to
include temperature effects on AMPA receptor
kinetics it is enough to multiply all of the rate
constants by single temperature coefficient Q10.
2
(2) All of the state transitions except transition
from closed to bound states in AMPA recep-
tor kinetics (considering single mesh of Scheme
2) were assumed to be Markov models: time
and voltage independent and dependent only
on the occupancy of neighbouring states as was
previously proposed by [12].
Figure 2: Scheme 2. Kinetic scheme used for construc-
tion of an analytical model consists four
orders of subconductance(index numbers of
states - we do not consider 0-th order) and
four meshes (colored triangles).
1. mesh
O1
2. mesh
O2
3. mesh
O3
4. mesh
O4
k c
o
k
k c
o
k
k c
o
k
k c
o
k
C0
kb
ku
k
r
kb
ku
k
r
C1
k
d
D1
kb
ku
k
r
C2
k
d
D2
kb
ku
k
r
C3
k
d
D3
C4
k
d
D4
Information Flow
(3) As it was suggested by [11] temperature
effects are mediated by driving AMPARs to
higher subconductance states. To include higher
subconductance states in analytical model of
AMPA receptor few simplifications of complex
13 states and 30 transitions kinetic scheme
by [11] (Scheme 1) were proposed. Generally,
Scheme 1 was re-written into simplified form of
Scheme 2. This form uses symmetry of states
and transitions in Scheme 1. This symmetry
2This approach is analogical to way of including tem-
perature effects on voltage-gated ion-channels [3] and
motivated by Arrhenius equation. Q10 informs how
many times given speed of reaction increases with 10◦C
increase of temperature.
3
D. Kufel and G. Wojcik • September 2016 •
comes from the fact, that (when combined with
(6)) we may divide kinetic scheme (Scheme 1)
to overall four orders of subconducting states.
Additionally, one further analytical simplifica-
tion is made: modification in directions of transi-
tions with rates kr and kc where taken to 'relieve'
state Ci tangled in many transitions with minor
influence on solutions for open and desensitized
states of AMPA receptor. This approach allows
for a much easier analytical solution of differen-
tial equations describing kinetic scheme.
Figure 3: Scheme 3. Single mesh described by an inde-
pendent pair of coupled differential equations
k c
kb
ku
k
r
Ci−1
k
o
Ci
Oi
kd
Di
(4) Separately, the 1st order (and symmetrically,
with additional assumptions described below, i-
th order) of AMPAR kinetic states was assumed
to behave as a single mesh, according to Scheme
3 (here, for i = 1). The form C0 was considered
to be in excess compared to other states in this
scheme. This is directly the case, when very
few receptors bind glutamate, so that nearly all
receptors remain in form C0. This is motivated
by comparing number of channels in different
states in Monte Carlo simulation(see Figure 4).
Therefore fraction of channels in C0 state (and
consequently due to further simplification in
each Ci−1 state in i-th mesh) is considered al-
ways as 1. This assumption is taken because
considering fractions of channels in all other
states multiplied by some function dependent
on time (see assumption (6)) leads to much
less trivial system of differential equations with
much more complexed solution. Furthermore,
without this assumption including higher sub-
conductance states would be not possible in an
analytical way (see below).
After generalization (assumption (5)) for i-th
order, the assumption is true for every mesh of
kinetic scheme (see below and Scheme 2).
4
(5) To account for higher subconductance states
a concept of uncoupling of a set of differential
equations introduced below was used.
In general, this what influences complexity of
system of differential equations describing ki-
netic states are multiple transitions between
some state and the others. To find functions
of AMPA receptor open 3 states (O1,O2,O3,O4)
dependent on time in given kinetic state with
m states,one would have to write m − 1 cou-
pled differential equations, which complexity is
proportional to number of transitions between
different states [12]. However, generally for some
cases system of coupled differential equations
may be uncoupled with minor loss of accuracy
of solution. In our problem, we would like to
uncouple i-th order (where i <1;4>) of bound
state Ci with (i+1)-th order of bound state Ci+1
(which are only causes of coupling between dif-
ferent orders of kinetic scheme).
Our approach is based on an idea, taken as an
analogy from a very simple economical model.
Consider an agent selling some product on the
market. Now, let's assume that decision of an
agent about selling the product is dependent on
current state of a market (whether its condition
is good or bad etc.). So, in general market is
affecting seller by its current state and seller is
affecting market by selling product and there-
fore changing its state. Then, an information
(about decisions of agent or state of market)
goes both directions: from agent to market and
from market to agent. This situation may be de-
scribed by differential equation. Sometimes, the
form of differential equation may not be trivial.
However, to simplify this situation we use an as-
sumption, that if market is huge, an influence of
a single agent on a market will not be significant.
Then, the essence of this simplification is the
fact, that information flows only from market
to agent (rather than both directions), therefore
leading to much easier mathematical description
of this problem.
In case of kinetic scheme simplification, a similar
approach was used: it is enough to assume, that
transitions from higher order subconductance
3experimental data suggest, that only open state of
protein can influence synaptic conductance [19]
D. Kufel and G. Wojcik • September 2016 •
states to lower order have little (no) influence
on lower states. It means, that from perspective
of lower order of conductance, all of the transi-
tions from higher order states are neglectable.
However, from perspective of higher order of
conductance, all of the transitions from lower
order are still significant (see information flow
on Scheme 2).
However, validity of this assumption requires,
that sum of all of the transition rates from higher
to current order of subconductance has to be
much smaller than transition rate from current
order to higher plus from lower to current order
(see: Scheme 2). This assures, that relatively
little information goes from higher to lower sub-
conductance orders, so we may neglect this in-
fluence of higher states in construction of the
model.
In mathematical terms, assumption of uncou-
pling for i-th order may be written as:
kb(t)(xi−1+xi) >> kcyi+1+krzi+1+ku(xi+1+xi)
(1)
Particulary, for 1st order we get:
kb(t)(x0+x1) >> kcy2+krz2+ku(x2+x1) (2)
This method allows us to uncouple set of twelve
coupled differential equations with complex for-
mulation to set of 4 pairs of differential equations
(coupled only in pairs, rather than between dif-
ferent orders of subconductance). Thanks to
this approach, we are able to include higher or-
der subconductance states and, as a result, find
an analytical solution of the problem.
Actually, this approach is similar to assumption
(4): we may say that from perspective of (i+1)-
th order subconductance state, the fraction of
channels in i-th order subconductance bound
state (Ci) is perceived as 1. However, to differ-
entiate how huge this 1 is absolutely, for each
i-th order of conductance λi(t) function is intro-
duced. λi(t) scales 'relative fraction of channels
in each state' to 'absolute (scaled samely to all
of the orders of kinetic scheme) fraction'.
(6) Glutamate binding was assumed to be
independent, similary to model by [13] This
departure from [11] was motivated by a dispro-
portionate increase of complexity of analytical
solution of a set of differential equations when
assuming cooperative binding. Cooperative
binding requires a more elaborating form
of kinetic scheme, mostly due to assump-
tions associated with including AMPAR higher
order subconductance states taken in this model.
(7) Glutamate concentration was assumed to be
time-dependent according to single exponential
decay function, which parameters were fitted
to data of glutamate concentration at synap-
tic cleft (and consequently at PSD) in Monte
Carlo model of synaptic transmission. Therefore
function of binding rate constant from closed to
bound states has a form dependent on concen-
tration of glutamate at PSD:
kb(t) = kbAe−ωt
(3)
where parameters ω [1/s] and A [molar] were
fitted from averaging of glutamate concentration
(in cleft) in Monte Carlo simulation of synaptic
transmission. This approach was taken due to
several causes. Departure from model based on
neurotransmitter concentration occuring as a
pulse (described by Dirac Delta at tpulse) pro-
posed by [12] or [14] was motivated by availabil-
ity of direct data of glutamate concentration
on PSDs in Monte Carlo simulation and unit
inconsistency problem4. Furthermore, an influ-
ence of temperature on glutamate concentration
was also investigated (to investigate whether
diffusion of neurotransmitters altered by tem-
perature may lead to more accurate solution in
comparison to experimental data).
Dual-exponential function was also considered as
a fitting method of glutamate concentration, but
4Modelling of glutamate concentration at PSD as a
pulse of transmitter (motivated by the fact, that concen-
tration of neurotransmitter rises and falls rapidly [21]) in
t = tpulse and assumption about considering fraction of
channels in C0 state as 1 leads to unconsistency in units
in function of fraction of channels in open state versus
time (just as in derivation of alpha function in Appendix
B of [12]) and therefore not being able to normalize to
1, which would make model unable to reproduce data
quantitatively. However, one has to admit that mod-
elling of neurotransmitter concentration by Dirac Delta
has some advantages (see [14] and [12]) and may be use-
ful in obtaining dual-exponential solution for synaptic
conductance, which can be easily interpreted [15].
5
D. Kufel and G. Wojcik • September 2016 •
Figure 4: Fraction of AMPAR channels in unbound
state C0. Fraction of channels decays from
1 to about 0.8 in 3ms. It shows, why we as-
sumed that fraction of channels in state Ci−1
in first mesh is in excess when compared to
the other states.
generally the problem was that solution of sys-
tem of differential equations describing kinetic
scheme were getting extremely complex (and
therefore AMPAR higher order subconductance
states could not be included), unproportionally
to gain in accuracy of analytical model.
(8) According to experimental data, AMPA
receptors are tetramers [22]. Conductance of
AMPA receptor can be described as a sum of
conductances of all orders of subconductance
multiplied by different constants for different
orders of states in kinetic scheme (as suggested
before [20]):
n=4X
g(t) = g4
aiyi(t)
(4)
i=1
where, g4 is a peak conductance of a channel
in 4-fold bound state, n is a number of orders
in kinetic scheme and ai, yi are scalling factor
and fraction of open channels in the i-th state
respectively.
Conductances of different orders of states in
kinetic scheme were set as fractions of the peak
conductance at the 4-fold bound state O4 (O1
: a1 = 0.1, O2 : a2 = 0.4, O3 : a3 = 0.7,
O4 : a4 = 1.0) as it was proposed by [11] and
motivated by previous experimental work by [19].
This assumption in turn, suggests, that we may
break down the problem of finding conductance
into sum of four functions, which suggest that
we should operate on so called before 'orders' of
kinetic scheme.
Combination of all of assumptions made before,
simplifies complex kinetic scheme, containing
13 states and multiple transitions (described by
12 coupled differential equations). Modification
of directions of transitions (from Oi and Di)
with uncoupling concept splits system of differ-
ential equations to four, one-side dependent and
specular between themselves, meshes of kinetic
scheme. Furthermore, by assuming fraction of
channels in state Ci−1 for i-th order of scheme to
be equal to 1 we are able to solve coupled pair of
differential equations in every single mesh. Thus,
simplification leads to 4 independent pairs of
coupled differential equations, which solution
for first order of conductance we know explic-
itly and for higher orders we use λi(t) = xi−1(t)
6
(which is solution in respect to fraction of chan-
nels in state Ci−1 of pair of differential equation
for (i-1)-th order), which assures information
flow from lower to higher orders of AMPAR
subconductance.
Making these assumptions, one obtains general
system of differential equations, describing i-th
order of kinetic states (Scheme 2):
= kbAe−ωtλi(t) − (ko + ku + kd)xi(t) (5)
dxi
dt
= koxi(t) − kcyi(t)
dyi
dt
(6)
where yi(t) = [Oi(t)] is a fraction of channels
in an open state of i-th order, xi(t) = [Ci(t)]
is a fraction of channels in a bound state of
i-th order, λi(t) is a function to convert frac-
tion of all channels to same absolute scale (not
only relative for each order) - for i-th order of
Scheme 2 it equals to solution with respect to
fraction of channels in state C0 of two differen-
tial equations of (i-1)-th order: λi(t) = xi−1(t).
Thanks to this approach we may include higher
subconductance states of AMPA receptor with
analytical approach, due to the fact of uncou-
pling of differential equations describing kinetic
scheme.
D. Kufel and G. Wojcik • September 2016 •
The solution for the first order of coupled dif-
ferential equations (5) and (6) with boundary
conditions y1(0) = 0 and x1(0) = 0 is:
SP e−ωt + Akbko
RP e−(P +ω)t − Akbko
RS e−kct
y1(t) = Akbko
(7)
where S = kc − ω, P = kd + ko + ku − ω, R =
−kc + kd + ko + ku.
As it is possible to be seen, first-order approxi-
mating function is a sum of exponents (as sug-
gested by [12]).
The full solution for all of the orders of kinetic
scheme (Scheme 2) can be found in Appendix
A.
Normalization of
fraction of channels
Due to the assumptions of model presented
above, without any correction, it would not be
able to fit to experimental data quantitatively
(because sum of all of the fractions of channels
in different states does not sum to one). The
reason is the assumption (4) and (5): fraction
of channels in state Ci for (i+1)-th order mesh
equals (relatively) to one. For example, fraction
of channels in state C0 for 1st order mesh equals
to one.
To fix this problem, we introduce normalization
constant, which is an accuracy of assumption (4)
with Monte Carlo simulation (accuracy is taken
as 1 − C0 in time of amplitude of function of
fraction of open channels). Assuming, that most
of the channels remain in state C0 (Figure 4) we
may see that this accuracy equals about 12.5%
(in a time of peak of synaptic conductance). So,
to reproduce Monte Carlo results, we only have
to multiply all of the fractions of channels in
analytical model by 0.125.
III. Results
Analytical model of AMPA receptor We
found that, for kinetic rates fitted from model
by [11], our model is able to reproduce both
results of Monte Carlo simulation (describing
fractions of AMPAR channels in different states:
see Figure 2B by [11]) and experimental data
(describing shape of curve of AMPAR synaptic
conductance: see [11] Figure 1A).
√
Number of channels Fractions of AMPAR
channels in different states (Figure 5) are both
qualitatively and quantitatively (after normaliza-
tion: see methods) consistent with this obtained
in Monte Carlo simulation (with mean 5% error
for function of open states in time).
In the beginning, binding of glutamate leads
AMPARs from unbound to bound states. The
fraction of channels in bound state is dependent
on glutamate concentration at PSDs and rate
of unbinding in AMPA receptor kinetic scheme.
Excluding for a while effects of unbinding, due
to the fact, that the diffusion of neurotransmit-
ters in synaptic cleft is considered as a random
walk, mean distance of single neurotransmitter
from location of release (vesicle pore) should
increase proportionally to
N where N is num-
ber of steps (with certain displacement) in time.
So, glutamate concentration should decay with
√
1/
N and number of bound states should in-
crease proportionally to 1 − √
N. However, be-
cause constantly, some of the AMPAR channels
unbind neurotransmitters(transitioning from C1
to C0 state), function of bound states' fraction
in time should be close to a 'flattened' 1 − √
N.
Afterall, different conformations of AMPA recep-
tor protein occur in time. The speed of confor-
mational changes is proportional to temperature
(reflected by scaling all of the rate constants of
kinetic scheme by Q10 parameter).
Continous growth of fraction of channels in de-
sensitized states comes from the fact that resen-
sitizing rate of reaction is about three orders of
magnitude smaller than rate of desensitization.
Therefore, channels after entering, unlikely leave
desensitized states and fraction of channels in
desensitized states slowly approaches fraction of
channels in all bound states.
Generally, model is a little bit underestimating
fraction of AMPAR channels in states bound
and desensitized. This may come from an as-
sumption in analytical model about directions
of transitions between states from Oi to Ci−1
(rather than Ci) and from Di to Ci−1 (rather
than Ci−1) - in first order of subconductance
7
D. Kufel and G. Wojcik • September 2016 •
states some of the transitions go back to un-
bound state (rather than first bound closed state
as assumed in Scheme 1). Underestimation in
fraction of channels in desensitized state comes
from the fact, that due to modification in direc-
tions of transitions for first order of subconduc-
tance, smaller fraction of AMPARs is in bound
state (resensitization due to its small transition
likelihood has a minor influence).
Figure 5: Fraction of channels in different states as a
function of time. Open scaled channels is
a fraction of channels in open states, multi-
plied by respective four order conductances.
Figure 6: Conductance curve of AMPA synapse in
25◦C and 35◦C. Conductance in 35◦C in
comparison to 25◦C has bigger and faster
peak.
model is able to reproduce (with accuracy for
relative amplitude and relative time of peak to
< 5 %, which is within the experimental error
range) shape and scale of temperature effects
on synaptic transmission (compare with Figure
1B by [11]). In 35◦C both rise and decay time
constant of synaptic conductance are smaller
(faster). The peak conductance is bigger (for
ratio about 1.25) and is reached faster in 35◦C
in comparison to 25◦C.
However, analytical model predicts too rapid
rise time of conductance in comparison to ex-
perimental data (see time of peak on Figure 6
and on Figure 1B by [11]). This is due to the
assumption about fitting function to glutamate
concentration in synaptic cleft. In this model,
only single exponential decay (from peak value
at t = 0) of glutamate concentration was as-
sumed. It is only an approximation of reality,
where evidently there is not infinitely fast rise of
glutamate concentration (see Figure 7). Hence,
strength of temperature effects on synaptic con-
ductance is shaped by decay time constant of
glutamate concentaration function. However, it
is not possible to include any other, more elabo-
rating forms (dual exponential function, fast and
slow exponents etc.) of glutamate concentration
function, due to no existence of closed analytical
form of solution of differential equation system
including higher subconductance states.
Figure 7: Glutamate
concentration obtained
from
Monte Carlo simulation in 25◦C and
assumed fitting curve proportional to e−ωt
Synaptic conductance AMPAR conduc-
tance curve (Figure 6) obtained from analytical
It was found that diffusion of neurotransmit-
8
D. Kufel and G. Wojcik • September 2016 •
that it is possible to achieve same dynamics
of AMPAR synaptic conductance (qualitatively
and quantitatively) by using 3rd approximation
(without including 4-th order) and changing frac-
tion of the peak conductance at the 4-fold bound
state for 3rd state from 0.7 to 0.9. Therefore, we
support one of the work's results by [11], which
claims that higher temperature leads AMPARs
to higher conducting states(thus increasing con-
ductance peak amplitude).
Figure 9: Different order approximations of higher
subconductance states.
ters altered by diffusion cannot lead to more
accurate solution in comparison to experimental
data (Figure 8). Modifying Q10dif f coefficient
of diffusion (effectively multiplying diffusion co-
efficient of glutamate) with temperature, leads
to faster decay of glutamate concentration in
synaptic cleft and faster time rise and decay of
synaptic conductance (the physical meaning is,
that glutamate molecules should simply move
faster in higher temperatures). However, increas-
ing Q10dif f causes also smaller AMPAR peak
conductance, than this observed experimentally.
This supports previous thesis by [11] about pre-
dominant role of postsynaptic site of synapse
in temperature effects on synapses. In turn, it
may be important in the context of possible
medical application: implementing drug, which
is able to slow down receptor kinetics may lead
to successful prevention of adverse temperature
effects on dynamics of synapses (for example in
state of hyperthermia or hypothermia in human
brain).
Figure 8: Influence of different Q10 diffusion coeffi-
cients on synaptic conductance.
IV. Discussion
Glutamate binding model An analytical
model showed that in a light of assumptions
we made independent glutamate binding is able
to reproduce experimental and numerical results.
However, considering complexity of biological
systems and the role of variability in their be-
haviour, we do not argue, that independent bind-
ing is a biological reality, but rather a reliable
approximation of system's average behaviour.
In work by [11] it was shown, that variability of
both rise and decay time constants of AMPAR
conductance as a function of the mEPSC peak
amplitude was not successfully reproduced by
an independent binding model. However, it is
not possible to research this relationships using
our model describing only an average behaviour.
9
Significance of including higher subconductance
states in analytical model was also investigated.
It turned out, that including higher and higher
states of subconductance leads to saturating
increase of ratio (in 35◦C relatively to 25◦C)
of synaptic conductance peak amplitudes (for
about 12% in comparison to first order approxi-
mation), with minor influence on ratio of times
of peak (Figure 9). Furthermore, it was found
D. Kufel and G. Wojcik • September 2016 •
Temperature dependence of AMPA re-
ceptor conductance In this paper it is
clearly showed, that increased temperature leads
to bigger peak amplitude of AMPAR conduc-
tance, which is achieved faster than in lower
temperature. However, this results are not eas-
ily interpretable in more general context - for
example, an influence of modified synaptic con-
ductance curve on temporal summation of sig-
nals across neuron's morphology.
From the one point of view, due to the fact, that
synaptic conductance has bigger peak amplitude
in higher temperature, thus smaller number of
EPSPs should elicit action potential than in
lower temperature. From the other side, due to
the fact that time constants of AMPAR conduc-
tance function decline faster, temporal summa-
tion should overlap less efficiently. So, this two
naturally opposite features of AMPAR synaptic
conductance hinder simple description of com-
pounded temperature effects on multi-synaptic
networks: it iss actually hard to strictly predict
(because we do not know relative importance
of amplitude and time constants of synaptic
conductance curve) how it is going to influence
temporal summation of synaptic signal. In the
future, more detailed study on this topic may
allow us to investigate temperature effects from
level of single synapses to large neural-networks,
which may help in better understanding of com-
plex and paradoxical field interactions in brain
imposed by temperature [23].
Uncoupling assumption accuracy To test
an assumption of uncoupling of differential sys-
tem equations we use Monte Carlo simulation
of synaptic transmission for kinetic scheme pro-
posed here (Scheme 3). This comes from the fact,
that directions between some of the transitions
were changed (see assumption (3)), therefore
to capture correct dynamics of AMPAR confor-
mational changes Monte Carlo simulation was
employed.
For case of model we propose, differential equa-
tion system uncoupling assumption is fulfilled
with different accuracy for every order (Figure
10).
Generally, the assumption is best for first order
10
Figure 10: Uncoupling assumption validation for dif-
ferent orders of kinetic scheme. 'Left' and
'Right' are values of sides of equation (1)
for parameters by [11].
of kinetic scheme (so transitions from C0, C2,
O2, D2 to C1 - see Scheme 2) and error associ-
ated with this approach is < 0.5%. For second
and fourth order error is on level of 15%. The
worst accuracy is for the third order of kinetic
scheme, for parameters of this model and single
exponential decay function of glutamate concen-
tration hitting error level of 40% in a peak of
curve. However, in reality the accuracy of all
of the orders is better for about factor of 1.8
in peak, due to the fact that glutamate concen-
tration function is not able to perfectly capture
dynamics of glutamate concentration in synaptic
cleft (see Figure 9). From equation (1), we may
see that actually accuracy of the assumption
is dependent on glutamate concentration: the
bigger glutamate concentration is at PSDs, the
better accuracy of the assumption.
New modelling method of temperature
effects on AMPA receptor Creation of an
analytical model for AMPA type synapse, capa-
ble to simulate temperature effects, has many po-
tential applications. Firstly, we achieved model
successfully validated with experimental data in
closed form analytical solution. The analytical
model developed here is capable to include tem-
perature effects with both high accuracy and
efficiency in huge neural network simulations,
which (when combined with previous studies
D. Kufel and G. Wojcik • September 2016 •
about voltage-gated ion channels) may open
new possibility of researching temperature in-
fluence on neural dynamics in computational
neuroscience. Secondly, due to generality5 of
this model, it is weakly dependent on kinetic
scheme or phenomenological method of synaptic
conductance modelling we have chosen (which
was discussed as an important problem in the
Introduction). This in fact mean that we may
generalize some model created in one tempera-
ture to any other, by using the model developed
here as a 'linking bridge', without performing
any additional experiments. This can be done
as follows: 1. To some synaptic conductance
curve we fit (with free parameters being rate con-
stants and glutamate concentration constants
A,w) the model developed here. 2. Then in
fitted model, we multiply all of the AMPAR ki-
netic rate constants by temperature dependent
factors Q10 = 2.4 and hence create new synaptic
conductance curve. 3. We fit any phenomeno-
logical model to the synaptic conductance curve
we achieved in previous step. (see also Scheme
4). This approach is insensitive on eventual fit-
ting parameter degeneration, due to the fact of
the same multiplication Q10 = 2.4 factor.
Figure 11: Scheme 4
The model was efficiently implemented in NEU-
RON [24] using NMODL [25], making it ready
for easy implementation in neural network sim-
ulations.
V. Conclusion
In the present study, an analytical model of
AMPA-type synapse including temperature ef-
fects was created.
It was done on basis of
Markov Models describing kinetics of AMPA
receptor, uncoupling of differential equation sys-
tem method and simplifications motivated by
5Sum of multi-exponentials is capable to capture wide-
range of various conductance curve dynamics
Monte Carlo simulation of synaptic transmis-
sion. Due to its generality, model may be used
to make any simple model of synaptic conduc-
tance easily-scalable for any temperature, which
provides simple theoretical linking of research
conducted in different temperatures. Thanks
to its accuracy (in comparison to experimental
data) and efficiency, model may be used in big
neural network simulations. This opens new pos-
sibility of research various temperature effects
on neural dynamics in large-scale multi-neuron
experiments and may provide theoretical basis
of better understanding of different neurological
disorders associated with sub- and super- physi-
ological temperatures.
From previous research of shifting attention phe-
nomena [29] and large biological neural networks
dynamics in function of connections number
[28]turns out that with large number of varying
parameters it may be difficult to find optimal
ranges of simulation initial conditions. That is
why we may be in demand of using artificial
neural network approach ([26], [27]) in order
to find starting points for future investigations
of temperature influence on neural dynamics.
Such approach may shed some light on under-
standing paradoxical temperature influence in
serious neurological disorders like autism spec-
trum disorder [30], which will be in a scope of
our interest in the forthcoming future.
VI. Acknowledgments
Special thanks to Matthias Hennig, Daniel Woj-
cik and Piotr Kononowicz, who helped in devel-
opment of this work.
11
1
2
VII. Appendix A
et(P +2ω)(ω−P )
P R + ekc t
R + e(kc−P )t
b + 0.35A3e−t(kc+P +3ω)ko(− 2et(P +S+ω)(kc−G)(−G+S−ω)(S−G)
Solution of all order of differential equation system describing AMPA receptor kinetics.
yscaled(t) = 0.1Ae−t(kc+ω)ko(− etωS
R(P−ω)(S−ω)(R+ω))k2
R(kc−3ω)(R+ω)(R+2ω)
+
P R(kc−4ω)(P−3ω)(P−2ω)(P−ω)(R+ω)(R+2ω)(R+3ω)
R(kc−4ω)(R+ω)(R+2ω)(R+3ω) + ekc t(kc−G)(S−G)(−G+S−ω)
where, S = kc − ω, R = −kc + kd + ko + ku, P = kd + ko + ku − ω, G = kd + ko + ku
2et(kc+ω)(kc−G)(−G+S−ω)
R(P−ω)ω2(R+ω)(R+2ω) )k3
et(P +S+ω)(kc−G)(S−G)(−G+S−ω)(−G+kc−3ω)
6P Rω3(R+ω)(R+2ω)(R+3ω) )k4
2et(P +3ω)
et(P +4ω)
−
P S )kb + 0.4A2e−t(kc+P +2ω)ko(− et(P +S+ω)(kc−G)
P R(kc−3ω)(P−2ω)(P−ω)(R+ω)(R+2ω) − et(kc+2ω)(−G+S−ω)(ω−P )(S−G)
P R(P−ω)(S−ω) − et(kc+ω)(ω−S)
R(P−ω)(S−ω)ω + ekc t(ω−S)
R(P−2ω)(P−ω)ω2(R+ω)(R+2ω) + ekc t(kc−G)(S−G)
A4e−t(kc+P +4ω)ko(− et(kc+3ω)(S−G)(−G+S−ω)(ω−P )(3ω−G)(−G+kc−3ω)
6R(P−3ω)(P−2ω)(P−ω)ω3(R+ω)(R+2ω)(R+3ω)
et(kc+ω)(kc−G)(S−G)(−G+kc−3ω)
2R(P−ω)ω3(R+ω)(R+2ω)(R+3ω)
P (S−ω)ω(R+ω) +
P Rω2(R+ω)(R+2ω) −
+
−
et(kc+2ω)(kc−G)(−G+S−ω)(−G+kc−3ω)
2R(P−2ω)ω3(R+ω)(R+2ω)(R+3ω)
−
+
b
b
D
.
K
u
f
e
l
a
n
d
G
.
W
o
j
c
i
k
•
S
e
p
t
e
m
b
e
r
2
0
1
6
•
D. Kufel and G. Wojcik • September 2016 •
References
[1] Shigemori, M., Abe, T., Aruga, T., Ogawa,
T., Okudera, H., Ono, J. (2012) Guidelines
for the Management of Severe Head Injury,
2nd Edition Guidelines from the Guidelines
Committee on the Management of Severe
Head Injury, the Japan Society of Neuro-
traumatology. Neurologia medico-chirurgica
, 52(1), 1-30.
[2] Dietrich, W. D. (1992) The importance of
brain temperature in cerebral injury Jour-
nal of neurotrauma 9, S475-85.
[3] Hodgkin, A. L., Huxley, A. F. (1952). A
quantitative description of membrane cur-
rent and its application to conduction and
excitation in nerve. The Journal of physi-
ology, 117(4), 500.
[4] Buzatu, S. (2009)
The temperature-
induced changes in membrane potential.
Biology Forum/Rivista di Biologia, (Vol.
102, No. 2).
[5] Hille, B. (2001) Ion channels of excitable
membranes (Vol. 507), Sunderland, MA:
Sinauer.
[6] Sterratt, D. C. (2015) Q10: the Effect of
Temperature on Ion Channel Kinetics. En-
cyclopedia of Computational Neuroscience,
2551-2552.
[7] Asztely F, Erdemli G, Kullmann DM
(1997). Extrasynaptic glutamate spillover
in the hippocampus: dependence on tem-
perature and the role of active glutamate
uptake. Neuron, 18, 281-293
[8] Weight, F. F., Erulkar, S. D. (1976) Synap-
tic transmission and effects of temperature
at the squid giant synapse. Nature 261, 720
- 722
[9] Schiff, S. J., Somjen, G. G. (1985) The
effects of temperature on synaptic trans-
mission in hippocampal tissue slices. Brain
research 345(2), 279-284
[10] Fuxe, K., Rivera, A., Jacobsen, K. X., Hois-
tad, M., Leo, G., Horvath, T. L., et al.
(2005). Dynamics of volume transmission
in the brain. Focus on catecholamine and
opioid peptide communication and the role
of uncoupling protein J. Neural. Transm,.
112, 65âĂŞ76
[11] Postlethwaite, M., Hennig, M. H., Steinert,
J. R., Graham, B. P., Forsythe, I. D. (2007).
Acceleration of AMPA receptor kinetics un-
derlies temperature-dependent changes in
synaptic strength at the rat calyx of Held.
The Journal of physiology, 579(1), 69-84.
[12] Destexhe, A., Mainen, Z. F., Sejnowski,
T. J. (1994). Synthesis of models for ex-
citable membranes, synaptic transmission
and neuromodulation using a common ki-
netic formalism. Journal of computational
neuroscience, 1(3), 195-230.
[13] Robert, A., Howe, J. R. (2003). How AMPA
receptor desensitization depends on recep-
tor occupancy. The Journal of neuroscience,
23(3), 847-858.
[14] Destexhe, A., Mainen, Z. F., Sejnowski, T.
J. (1994). An efficient method for com-
puting synaptic conductances based on a
kinetic model of receptor binding. Neural
computation, 6(1), 14-18.
[15] Destexhe, A., Mainen, Z. F., Sejnowski, T.
J. (1994). An efficient method for com-
puting synaptic conductances based on a
kinetic model of receptor binding. Neural
computation, 6(1), 14-18.
[16] Shelley, C., Magleby, K. L. (2008). Linking
exponential components to kinetic states
in Markov models for single-channel gating.
The Journal of general physiology, 132(2),
295-312.
[17] Stiles, JR, et al. (1996) Miniature endplate
current rise times <100 Îijs from improved
dual recordings can be modeled with pas-
sive acetylcholine diffusion from a synaptic
vesicle. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 93:5747-5752
13
D. Kufel and G. Wojcik • September 2016 •
[28] Wojcik, G. M., Ważny, M. (2015). Bray-
Curtis Metrics as Measure of Liquid State
Machine Separation Ability in Function of
Connections Density. Procedia Computer
Science, 51, 2979-2983.
[29] Ważny, M., Wojcik, G. M. (2014). Shifting
spatial attention-numerical model of Posner
experiment. Neurocomputing, 135, 139-144.
[30] Helt, M., Kelley, E., Kinsbourne, M.,
Pandey, J., Boorstein, H., Herbert, M.,
Fein, D. (2008). Can children with autism
recover? If so, how? Neuropsychology re-
view, 18(4), 339-366.
[18] Cais, O., Sedlacek, M., Horak, M., Dittert,
I., Vyklicky, L. (2008). Temperature de-
pendence of NR1/NR2B NMDA receptor
channels. Neuroscience, 151(2), 428-438.
[19] Smith T,Wang L, Howe J (2000) Heteroge-
neous conductance levels of native AMPA
receptors. J Neurosci , 20, 2073-2085
[20] Sahara Y, Takahashi T (2001) Quantal
components of the excitatory postsynaptic
currents at a rat central auditory synapse.
Q. J Physiol, 536, 189-197
[21] Colquhoun, D. (1998) Binding, gating,
affinity and efficacy: The interpretation
of structure-activity relationships for ag-
onists and of the effects of mutating re-
ceptors. British journal of pharmacology
125(5), 923-947
[22] Rosenmund C, Stern-Bach Y, Stevens C
(1998) The tetrameric structure of a gluta-
mate receptor channel. Science 280, 1596-
1599
[23] Andersen, P., Moser, E. I. (1995) Brain tem-
perature and hippocampal function Hip-
pocampus 5(6) 491-498
[24] Hines M, Carnevale N (1997) The NEU-
RON simulation environment. Neural Com-
put 9 1179-1209
[25] Hines M, Carnevale N (2000) Expanding
NEURON's repertoire of mechanisms with
NMODL. Neural Comput 12 995-1007
[26] Szaleniec M., Tadeusiewicz R., Witko M.
(2008) How to select an optimal neural
model of chemical reactivity? Neurocom-
puting, 72(1), 241-256.
[27] Szaleniec
J., Wiatr M.,
Szaleniec
M., Skladzien J., Tomik J., Oles K.,
Tadeusiewicz R. Artificial neural network
modelling of the results of tympanoplasty
in chronic suppurative otitis media patients.
Computers in biology and medicine, 43(1),
16-22.
14
|
1605.06925 | 4 | 1605 | 2017-09-01T06:39:55 | Neural Sampling by Irregular Gating Inhibition of Spiking Neurons and Attractor Networks | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | A long tradition in theoretical neuroscience casts sensory processing in the brain as the process of inferring the maximally consistent interpretations of imperfect sensory input. Recently it has been shown that Gamma-band inhibition can enable neural attractor networks to approximately carry out such a sampling mechanism. In this paper we propose a novel neural network model based on irregular gating inhibition, show analytically how it implements a Monte-Carlo Markov Chain (MCMC) sampler, and describe how it can be used to model networks of both neural attractors as well as of single spiking neurons. Finally we show how this model applied to spiking neurons gives rise to a new putative mechanism that could be used to implement stochastic synaptic weights in biological neural networks and in neuromorphic hardware. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Neural Sampling by Irregular Gating Inhibition
of Spiking Neurons and Attractor Networks
Lorenz K. Muller, Giacomo Indiveri
Abstract
A long tradition in theoretical neuroscience casts sensory processing
in the brain as the process of inferring the maximally consistent inter-
pretations of imperfect sensory input. Recently it has been shown that
Gamma-band inhibition can enable neural attractor networks to approx-
imately carry out such a sampling mechanism. In this paper we propose
a novel neural network model based on irregular gating inhibition, show
analytically how it implements a Monte-Carlo Markov Chain (MCMC)
sampler, and describe how it can be used to model networks of both neu-
ral attractors as well as of single spiking neurons. Finally we show how this
model applied to spiking neurons gives rise to a new putative mechanism
that could be used to implement stochastic synaptic weights in biological
neural networks and in neuromorphic hardware.
1
Introduction
A fundamental question in computational neuroscience is related to how the
brain can reconcile noisy sensory inputs and its internal models of the world
to reach maximally consistent abstract interpretations of the physical causes of
the sensory input. It has been argued that the dynamics and spiking behavior
of neurons can be interpreted as an expression of a sampling process by means
of which the brain performs such inference operations [7, 2]. This approach is
appealing because it allows drawing parallels between neural dynamics and well-
established algorithms such as Markov-Chain Monte-Carlo (MCMC) sampling
[5, 20, 13] or restricted Boltzmann-Machines (RBM) [12, 17, 22], and various
constraint satisfaction problem (CSP) solvers [10, 15].
A key problem in such models is related to how probabilistic behaviour
can be implemented within these models. Up to now there have been two
major approaches proposed: either the neuron model has been assumed to be
the intrinsically stochastic [5] (which is non-ideal for corresponding hardware
implementations and incomplete from a theoretical point of view); or given a
deterministic neuron model, such as an integrate-and-fire one, high-rate, weak
Poisson input, that stochastically keeps the neurons close to the firing threshold
has been used [20].
1
We focus on a third approach in which stochasticity arises from a sparsely
relieved gating inhibition that can be thought of as a model of gamma oscil-
lations. This is a computationally efficient approach as the required source of
randomness is one Poisson spiketrain of fixed rate per neuron and even simpler
sources of randomness, such as mismatched oscillations can suffice in practice
[16, 14].
A by-product of this approach is a new mechanism that could underlie the
implementation of stochastic synaptic weights and weight updates, both in bi-
ology and in neuromorphic systems. Stochastic synaptic weights (and updates)
are of interest because they may improve learning capabilities [23, 18] and allow
for novel models of neuronal sampling, such as the one we suggest in this paper.
2 Theory and Results
2.1 Abstract Sampling Model
In this section we will describe an abstract, mathematically tractable model
of biological neural networks (that we will refer to as the Gating Inhibition
Sampling Network or GISnet). Nodes in this network change their states at
Poisson distributed times that correspond to periods of lifted gating inhibition;
communication between nodes is mediated by weights that are random variables
and nodes take new states according to which of their possible values received
maximal input.
A GISnet, see figure 1, consists of interconnected nodes that represent pop-
ulations of neurons or single neurons. In the following superscripts will be used
to denote the membership of a quantity to a node. Each node represents a
variable. The state of node i at any time is given by two vectors (cid:126)Ii(t), the input
and (cid:126)Vi(t) the output: (cid:126)Vi(t) represents the discrete output value of the variable
corresponding to the node in a 'one-hot encoding' (one entry is one, the others
zero). If the kth entry of (cid:126)Vi(t), i.e. V k
i (t) is one, the corresponding variable has
state k. The input vector (cid:126)Ii(t) keeps track of the weighted and summed inputs
to the node. The vector (cid:126)Ii(t) has one entry I k
(i.e.
i
the vectors (cid:126)Ii(t) and (cid:126)Vi(t) have the same length).
for each possible value V k
i
Intuitively one may think of the vector (cid:126)V as the vector that identifies which
of m mutually exclusive attractor states (or 'patterns') receives the highest input
in the input vector (cid:126)I. This (and only this) 'winning' population then may be
able to influence the competitions in other nodes.
The nodes communicate through connections between different possible val-
ues; each connection between node i and k is weighted according to a weight
matrix Wik that specifies the impact state V q
i of node i has on input channel
I r
k of node k. Note that for each pair i, k there is a full weight matrix (cor-
responding to connections between different possible values nodes i and k can
encode).
A GIS-node can only change its output value at special time points that
we will refer to as 'spike windows' or 'update times'. Let si(t) be the function
2
Figure 1: A GISnet consisting of three nodes; the inputs and outputs to these
nodes are vectorial. In (cid:126)Ik inputs from 'active' presynaptic values are aggregated;
at input independent 'spike-windows' the node 'activates' the value with the
highest summed input. The weight matrices of the directed connection edges
like Wik are random variables.
that takes value one, in spike windows of i and zero otherwise. The spike-
windows Si = {tsi(t) = 1} of node i are Poisson-distributed in time with a
fixed average density of R (the spike-rate of the node); notably these spike-
windows are determined 'a priori' in the sense that they are independent of
the input node i receives. The 'a priori' determined spike windows are a key
difference to models like [5] or [19] and lend themselves to efficient neuromorphic
implementation: Per neuron only a single Poisson spike train of similar rate as
the desired output rate of that neuron is required, which is far more efficient
than previously suggested methods in the vein of [20].
(cid:88)
At a spike window node i takes a new value V q
inputs. Specifically it takes the value V q
weighted input, q = argmaxx(I x
i (t)); the input I q
i (t) depending on its recent
i (t) for which node i received the highest
i (t) to node i is given by
I q
i (t) =
(cid:126)VjWij
(1)
j
Where the sum over j goes over all upstream connected neurons. In words, at
a spike window, each possible value of the node sums its current input from
connected variable values, weighted by the (random variable) weight matrices;
then the value with the highest input becomes the node's new value.
Note that it is irrelevant how often an upstream neuron has changed its state
('spiked') since the downstream neuron's last spike window, only the current
If there is ambiguity about which value
state at the update time matters.
received the highest input (i.e. if there is no unique argmaxx(I x
i (t))) the node
maintains its previous value (other 'tie-breaking' mechanisms could be used).
Since the spike-times are independent of other state variables, we can analyse
this continuous time system as a discrete time system: Each discrete time-step
corresponds to a time ts at which one of the nodes may change its state. Then
we can say for the discrete time system that at each round one (uniformly)
3
(a) Schematic neuron modelled by GIS
node
(b) A small GISnet with
such nodes.
Figure 2: (a) A neuron under gating inhibition that releases at Poisson dis-
tributed times (rate 1/TG) for a short time (Topen). At these times it evaluates
whether the sum of EPSPs (time constant τe) or IPSPs (time constant τi) is
greater. Typically assume τi ≈ τe, Topen (cid:28) τe and τe < TG. (b) If the neuron
gets above threshold input (i.e. more excitatory than inhibitory input I e > I i)
it emits a spike (i.e. goes to state V e). To model a spiking neuron connection
weights out of V i are zero, those out of V e are random variables that model the
interplay of postsynaptic gating inhibition and PSP shape.
random node undergoes a state change (this state 'change' may be the trivial
transition from a state to itself).
Notably the corresponding discrete-time system is Markovian, which simpli-
fies its analysis.
2.2 Single Neurons
Here we layout how spiking neurons can be modelled as GIS nodes. In figure 2
the GIS node used to implement a single neuron is shown.
Let us consider a neuron that receives strong shunting inhibition that is at
Poisson times briefly lifted. During that short open window the membrane of
the neuron will see the current influx through other activated ion channels and
will evaluate, whether their combined conductance is high enough to overcome
its spiking threshold; in other words, it measures whether it has received higher
input to the inhibitory or excitatory 'mode' (for a typical biological neuron with
a bias to the inhibitory one). In the latter case, the neuron sends a spike to all
downstream connected neurons that gets multiplied by the synaptic weight; this
spike may or may not have an effect on the downstream neuron, depending on
whether it is relieved of its gating inhibition within the post-synaptic potential
(PSP) time constant (τe or τi). This varying impact of spikes is modelled in the
GISnet by the fact that weights are random variables. The case of inhibition ex-
ceeding excitation, in which no output (spike) is produced, can be incorporated
into a GISnet simply by making all outgoing connections of the 'inhibitory' node
state have zero weight.
4
Let us consider the distribution of weights we need to assume to correctly
describe a spiking neuron as a GIS node. If we assume some fixed, post-synaptic
kernel and a sufficiently short window during which the neuron's gating inhibi-
tion is released and it integrates its inputs on to the membrane potential the
effective weight the incoming spike will have, is simply the integral over the
post-synaptic kernel for the duration of the time window; to obtain a proba-
bilistic weight we assume (as previously) that the presynaptic spike time and
the release of inhibition occur at random time points. Note that in this way the
effective weight distribution is generated by the interplay of the post-synaptic
kernel shape and the time-constant of the lifted gating inhibition. For a gating
window of duration TG and a gating function
(cid:40)
G(t) =
we obtain
(cid:90) ∆t
0
Weff =
0
1
if t < Topen
otherwise
PSP(t) · (1 − G(t + δt))dt
(2)
(3)
where PSP(t) is the post-synaptic potential at time t, ∆t is its maximal duration
and δt is a random variable that expresses the time that passed between the
arrival of the presynaptic spike and the onset of the relief of gating inhibition
on the postsynaptic neuron. δt is a random variable and thereby Weff is a
random variable too. In the case of independent Poisson distributions for pre-
and postsynaptic spike windows, δt is distributed according to
p(δt) ∝ exp(t/λ)
(4)
where λ is the rate of the postsynaptic spike windows. Note that for a box-
shaped postsynaptic potential and ∆t (cid:28) TG we obtain a Bernoulli distribution
for Weff.
If the timings of the pre- and post-synaptic spike windows can be controlled,
e.g.
through some coupling mechanism on the neurons providing the gating
input, one could effectively control the weight distributions between the neurons.
In other words, the network could thus dynamically change its connectivity to
'load' a particular effective connectivity matrix by way of coupling the timing
spike windows. In other words the GISnet allows naturally for an instantiation of
the concept of 'communication through coherence' [9]: The effective connectivity
of the network can be modified by the coupling of the gating inhibition timings
between various nodes.
A simple biological observation complicates this picture somewhat and de-
viates from the GIS model: A neuron can spike more than once, if it receives
a very high input. This issue steps outside the proposed GIS model. It can be
dismissed if we assume a neuron model whose refractory time constant is longer
than the spike window opened by intermittently inactive shunting inhibition.
However, the possibility of spiking more than once makes the network more
'expressive' (there is a greater number of possible states) and could have useful
5
effects. Namely if the single neuron has a linear transfer-function, this would
lead to a linear response with Gaussian noise in the limit of a high fan-in, low
leak neuron (see section 2.5).
2.3 Attractor Networks
[16] studied WTA networks under oscillatory inhibition and demonstrated that
they can be modelled by an MCMC sampler: The MCMC operator given in
therein with purely empirical justification, is in fact the MCMC operator of a
GISnet (detailed comparisons of the network model and the MCMC sampler are
given there as well). Thus we provide here the theoretical top-down complement
to the bottom-up approach of that paper.
Notably irregular gating inhibition with periods of relief that are particular
to single nodes can be interpreted as a model of gamma-oscillations [16].
In
summary this is the case, because the interneurons that mediate gamma oscilla-
tions inhibit their targets mostly perisomatically and because gamma-rhythms
originate locally [6]. Perisomatic inhibition is particularly effective in hinder-
ing its targets from firing (while less impacting the integration of currents that
takes place on the dendrites) and the local origin of the gamma-rhythms implies
that at the very least different local neighbourhoods of neurons, are driven with
differing periods.
In practice the local gamma periods are not perfectly stable, but the period
lengths vary [8].
In other words the true distribution of the 'spike-windows'
mentioned earlier lies somewhere between the analysable Poisson distribution
we assumed here and the oscillatory case simulated in [16] (notably the latter
two produce very similar high level behaviour).
Intuitively the mapping between a GISnet and a network of irregularly inhib-
ited WTA nodes can be understood as follows: Each node of a GISnet models
one WTA unit and each possible value of the node corresponds to one exci-
tatory population in the WTA. The random nature of the connections comes
about by the relative timings of the irregular inhibitory signals to the various
WTA nodes; if a node x is completely unihibited while the inhibition on y is
lifted, it affects it with the full weight, otherwise with a down-scaled weight.
These relative timings occur pseudo-randomly.
2.4 The MCMC Transition Matrix
Here we will describe a method of obtaining the limiting distribution of a GISnet
(if it exists). The key question is how to construct the transition matrix T of
the corresponding MCMC sampler, since this fully determines its behaviour.
Let the system be in state si; what is the probability that it will transition into
state sj? We study three cases for different relationships between si and sj.
1. si and sj differ in more than one variable. In this case the probability Tij
is set to zero, because it is impossible for multiple variables to change their
state at the same time in a GISnet (time is continuous and state changes
6
are instantaneous, so that the probability of two occurring simultaneously
vanishes).
2. si and sj differ in exactly one variable. In this case Tij = P (vup)·P (vnew =
v(sj)si, vup), where P (vup) is the probability that the variable v in which
si and sj differ is the one that changes its state and P (vnew = v(sj)si, vup)
is the probability that v takes the value it has in sj given that the system
state at the change is si and that vup is the variable that changes its
state. We will shortly address how to construct these probabilities from
the network connectivity.
3. si and sj are the same state. In this case we can construct Tij using the
fact that the previous item implicitly defines the probability p(cid:54)= = P (si (cid:54)=
j(cid:54)=i Tij, so that Tii = 1 − p(cid:54)= by virtue of the
sj) by the relation p(cid:54)= =(cid:80)
normalization of(cid:80)
j Tij.
The probability P (vup) is simply set to 1
nN
where nN is the number of nodes
in the GISnet: Each node updates at Poisson distributed time points and it is
therefore equally likely that any node is the next one to update (the update
probability density is constant).
For notational simplicity we will consider the special case where each variable
has two possible states {0, α} and all weights are Bernoulli variables of absolute
value α or always zero. Then Wij,eff = Wij · bij,p, where bij,p is a matrix of
Bernoulli variables with probability p and W is a matrix whose entries are either
zero or α. The general case without these restrictions is straight forward to
write down based on this simpler case, but is notationally cumbersome. Instead
of summing up weights, in this case we simply count numbers of inputs to
a particular state. Let i be the updating node and let ui be the number of
potential inputs to state 0 of i and ti the total number of potential inputs to
node i. The number of potential inputs to state 1 is then ti − ui. In formulas
we define
(cid:88)
(cid:88)
j
j
ti =
ui =
(cid:126)VjWij,
V 0
j
(cid:126)W 0
ij.
(5)
(6)
(7)
By assumption every potential input is set to zero with probability p. In this
formulation the node receives an effective number ti,eff of inputs. This number
is distributed according to
(cid:18)ti
(cid:19)
k
P (ti,eff = k) =
(1 − p)kpti−k.
The aforementioned conditional transition probability P (vnew = 0sprev, vup)
7
is the probability that most of the received inputs go to state 0:
P (vnew = 0sprev, vup) =
(1 − p)kpti−k
which simplifies to
P (vnew = 0sprev, vup) =
k=0
ti(cid:88)
ti(cid:88)
(cid:19)
(cid:18)ti
(cid:124)
k
(cid:123)(cid:122)
P (ti,eff=k)
(1 − p)kpti−k
k=0
l=0
k/2(cid:88)
(cid:125)
(cid:124)
(cid:18) ui
l
k
k−l
(cid:0) ui
(cid:1)(cid:0)ti−ui
(cid:0)ti
(cid:1)
(cid:123)(cid:122)
(cid:19)(cid:18)ti − ui
P (ui > ti − ui)
k − l
l
k/2(cid:88)
l=0
,
(cid:1)
(cid:125)
(cid:19)
(8)
(9)
(10)
and finally yields
Tij =
1
nN
ti(cid:88)
k=0
(1 − p)kpti−k
(cid:18) ui
k − l
k/2(cid:88)
l=0
(cid:19)(cid:18)ti − ui
l
(cid:19)
.
Note that the above is dependent on the previous state and the target state
because ui and ti depend on them.
Using the above construction, we can evaluate the probability distribution
induced by a certain connectivity by finding the limiting distribution of the
associated MCMC sampler. To get this one still has to solve a large system of
linear equations (the limiting distribution is the eigenvector with eigenvalue one
of the transition matrix).
The construction of the limiting probability distribution would be simpler,
if the transition matrix fulfilled 'detailed balance' (Tij = Tji). This is however
not the case in general for a GISnet, similar to the neuronal MCMC sampler
suggested in [5].
2.5 The Single Node Activation Function
A more concise way of describing nodes in a GISnet can be obtained by studying
their individual activation functions. The activation function expresses what the
output response of a single node is for a given network state and connectivity.
By definition we need to evaluate which of the competing states receives the
highest input. For a binary node this means we want to find (for given network
state (cid:126)v, and weight tensor W ) the probability that the input to one node state
exceeds the input to the other. We can equivalently asses the probability that
the difference of the two inputs exceeds zero. In this formulation it becomes
clear that a binary GIS node is equivalent to a McCulloch-Pitts-Neuron [11] with
stochastic synapses.. Consider the activation a of a McCulloch-Pitts-Neuron
with Bernoulli input weights:
i − I 0
ij − (cid:126)W 0
(cid:88)
(cid:88)
j ( (cid:126)W 1
V 1
ai = I 1
(cid:126)VjUij
ij) =
i =
(11)
j
j
8
where V j are the presynaptic activities, Uij is a redefined connection weight (the
difference between the weights to the two states) Further we assume (cid:126)V jUji =
qj · bp(i, j) to be fixed up to a Bernoulli variable bp(i, j) with probability pon;
then we can write
ai =
qjbp(i, j).
(12)
(cid:88)
j
ai is now a sum over weighted Bernoulli trials. The central limit theorem states
that the mean of a sufficiently large number of independent random variables
is approximately normally distributed [3] (if the random variables have well
defined means and variances, which is the case here). Formulaically this yields
for a neuron with sufficiently many inputs
(cid:88)
j
ai =
qjbp(i, j) ≈ N
,
i
ponqi,
(cid:88)
(cid:115)(cid:88)
(cid:18) −µ√
i ponqi and σ = (cid:112)(cid:80)
erfc
1
2
i
pon(1 − pon)q2
i
(cid:19)
2σ
i pon(1 − pon)q2
,
(13)
(14)
where the angular brackets denote an average. The probability that ai is greater
than zero then is
where we introduced µ = (cid:80)
p (N (µ, σ) > 0) =
i . Note that
the McCulloch-Pitts Neuron with Bernoulli distributed synaptic weights has
recently also been studied in [18]; the 'synaptic sampling machine' presented
therein is closely related to a GISnet with binary nodes and Bernoulli distributed
synaptic weights.
is simply ai, indeed a linear response (linear in (cid:80)
We can now also revisit the question from section 2.2, what the output rate
of a neuron that can fire multiple times in one 'spike window' would be: This
i qi) with Gaussian noise,
however the variance of the noise increases with increasing mean.
For higher order nodes (with more than 2 competing modes) we can make
similar considerations. Here the input to a single state of the node must exceed
the input to all others for that node to become active. The probability of state
i becoming active is then1
p(i is active) =
=
(cid:90) ∞
(cid:90) ∞
−∞
−∞
(cid:89)
(cid:89)
i(cid:54)=j
(cid:34)
1
2
p(Ii = α)
i(cid:54)=j
N (α; µi, σi)
p(Ij < α)dα
(cid:33)(cid:35)
(cid:32)
α − µj√
2σj
(15)
dα
(16)
1 + erf
where µi and σi are the mean and variance of the Gaussian approximation to
the input to state i as introduced for the binary node.
1note the correction compared to the previous version
9
3 Conclusion
In this paper we described an abstract neural network whose functional be-
haviour it is to sample in a Markovian manner from a probability distribution
defined by its weights and detail how it maps both onto networks of individual
spiking neurons as well as populations thereof acting as attractors.
We showed that this model can be viewed as a generalization of synap-
tic sampling machines [18] or McCullough-Pitts-Neurons [11] with probabilistic
synapses and highlighted a new mechanism that could underlie the generation
of probabilistic synaptic weights. While it has been hypothesised that biological
substrates can directly tune the full distribution of the postsynaptic potentials
evoked by single synapses [1] and the reliability of neurotransimitter release of
a particular synapse can indeed be highly variable [4], such hypotheses are as
of yet unsubstantiated.
At the same time the proposed model describes analytically a good approxi-
mation of networks of neural attractors under gating inhibition, that constitutes
a model of gamma oscillations [16].
Neuromorphic systems currently lack the capability of cheaply implement-
ing stochastic synaptic strengths. The here proposed mechanism could be im-
plemented in any asynchronous neuromorphic platform that offers parametric
changes of the PSP shape, such as [21], with the simple addition of a gating
functionality of the kind we described.
The computational efficiency of the generation of stochasticity in the model
we propose, lends itself to direct mapping to neuromorphic hardware: Per rep-
resented variable only a single Poisson spike train of similar rate as the desired
output rate of that neuron is required, which is more efficient than previously
suggested methods in the vein of [20].
Finally the analytically well-described GISnet model will allow us to formu-
late theoretically motivated learning rules for networks of spiking neurons and
attractor networks under gating inhibition in future work.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Hesham Mostafa for pointing out an error in the previous
version of this manuscript. This work was supported by the Swiss national
science foundation grant Nr. CRSII2 160756.
References
[1] Laurence Aitchison and Peter E Latham. "Synaptic sampling: A connec-
tion between PSP variability and uncertainty explains neurophysiological
observations". In: arXiv preprint arXiv:1505.04544 (2015).
10
[2] Pietro Berkes, Gergo Orb´an, M´at´e Lengyel, and J´ozsef Fiser. "Sponta-
neous cortical activity reveals hallmarks of an optimal internal model of
the environment". In: Science 331.6013 (2011), pp. 83–87.
[3] Gerhard Bohm and Gunter Zech. Introduction to statistics and data anal-
ysis for physicists. DESY, 2010.
[4] Tiago Branco and Kevin Staras. "The probability of neurotransmitter
release: variability and feedback control at single synapses". In: Nature
Reviews Neuroscience 10.5 (2009), pp. 373–383.
[5] Lars Buesing, Johannes Bill, Bernhard Nessler, and Wolfgang Maass.
"Neural dynamics as sampling: A model for stochastic computation in
recurrent networks of spiking neurons". In: PLoS computational biology
7.11 (2011), e1002211.
[6] Gyorgy Buzs´aki and Xiao-Jing Wang. "Mechanisms of gamma oscilla-
tions". In: Annual review of neuroscience 35 (2012), pp. 203–225.
[7] J´ozsef Fiser, Pietro Berkes, Gergo Orb´an, and M´at´e Lengyel. "Statistically
optimal perception and learning: from behavior to neural representations".
In: Trends in cognitive sciences 14.3 (2010), pp. 119–130.
[8] Stacia Friedman-Hill, Pedro E Maldonado, and Charles M Gray. "Dy-
namics of Striate Cortical Activity in the Alert Macaque: I. Incidence and
Stimulus-dependence of Gamma-band Neuronal Oscillations". In: Cerebral
Cortex 10.11 (2000), pp. 1105–1116.
[9] Pascal Fries. "A mechanism for cognitive dynamics: neuronal communi-
cation through neuronal coherence". In: Trends in cognitive sciences 9.10
(2005), pp. 474–480.
[10] Stefan Habenschuss, Zeno Jonke, and Wolfgang Maass. "Stochastic com-
putations in cortical microcircuit models". In: PLoS computational biology
9.11 (2013), e1003311.
[11] W.S. McCulloch and W. Pitts. "A logical calculus of the ideas immanent
in nervous activity". In: Bull. Math. Biophys. 5 (1943), pp. 115–133.
[12] Paul Merolla, Tristan Ursell, and John Arthur. "The thermodynamic tem-
perature of a rhythmic spiking network". In: arXiv preprint arXiv:1009.5473
(2010).
[13] Nicholas Metropolis, Arianna W Rosenbluth, Marshall N Rosenbluth, Au-
gusta H Teller, and Edward Teller. "Equation of state calculations by
fast computing machines". In: The journal of chemical physics 21 (1953),
p. 1087.
[14] Hesham Mostafa and Giacomo Indiveri. "Stochastic Interpretation of Quasi-
periodic Event-based Systems". In: arXiv preprint arXiv:1512.02930 (2015).
[15] Hesham Mostafa, Ali Khiat, Alexander Serb, Christian G Mayr, Giacomo
Indiveri, and Themis Prodromakis. "Implementation of a spike-based per-
ceptron learning rule using TiO2-x memristors". In: Frontiers in Neuro-
science 9.357 (2015). doi: 10.3389/fnins.2015.00357.
11
[16] Hesham Mostafa, L. K. Muller, and Giacomo Indiveri. "Rhythmic inhi-
bition allows neural networks to search for maximally consistent states".
In: Neural Computation 27 (2015), pp. 2510–2547. doi: 10.1162/NECO_
a_00785. url: http://ncs.ethz.ch/pubs/pdf/Mostafa_etal15.pdf.
[17] E. Neftci, J. Binas, U. Rutishauser, E. Chicca, G. Indiveri, and R. Douglas.
"Synthesizing cognition in neuromorphic electronic systems". In: Proceed-
ings of the National Academy of Sciences 110.37 (2013), E3468–E3476.
doi: 10.1073/pnas.1212083110. url: http://ncs.ethz.ch/pubs/pdf/
Neftci_etal13.pdf.
[18] Emre O Neftci, Bruno U Pedroni, Siddharth Joshi, Maruan Al-Shedivat,
and Gert Cauwenberghs. "Unsupervised Learning in Synaptic Sampling
Machines". In: arXiv preprint arXiv:1511.04484 (2015).
[19] B. Nessler, M. Pfeiffer, and W. Maass. "STDP enables spiking neurons to
detect hidden causes of their inputs". In: Advances in Neural Information
Processing Systems (NIPS). Ed. by Y. Bengio, D. Schuurmans, J. Lafferty,
C.K. I. Williams, and A. Culotta. Vol. 22. 2009, pp. 1357–1365.
[20] Mihai A Petrovici, Johannes Bill, Ilja Bytschok, Johannes Schemmel, and
Karlheinz Meier. "Stochastic inference with deterministic spiking neu-
rons". In: arXiv preprint arXiv:1311.3211 (2013).
[21] Ning Qiao, Hesham Mostafa, Federico Corradi, Marc Osswald, Fabio Ste-
fanini, Dora Sumislawska, and Giacomo Indiveri. "A Re-configurable On-
line Learning Spiking Neuromorphic Processor comprising 256 neurons
and 128K synapses". In: Frontiers in Neuroscience 9.141 (2015). issn:
1662-453X. doi: 10 . 3389 / fnins . 2015 . 00141. url: http : / / www .
frontiersin.org/neuromorphic_engineering/10.3389/fnins.2015.
00141/abstract.
[22] Paul Smolensky. "Information processing in dynamical systems: Founda-
tions of harmony theory". In: (1986).
[23] Nitish Srivastava, Geoffrey Hinton, Alex Krizhevsky, Ilya Sutskever, and
Ruslan Salakhutdinov. "Dropout: A simple way to prevent neural net-
works from overfitting". In: The Journal of Machine Learning Research
15.1 (2014), pp. 1929–1958.
12
|
1502.05176 | 2 | 1502 | 2015-11-26T10:10:07 | Network events on multiple space and time scales in cultured neural networks and in a stochastic rate model | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Cortical networks, in-vitro as well as in-vivo, can spontaneously generate a variety of collective dynamical events such as network spikes, UP and DOWN states, global oscillations, and avalanches. Though each of them have been variously recognized in previous works as expressions of the excitability of the cortical tissue and the associated nonlinear dynamics, a unified picture of their determinant factors (dynamical and architectural) is desirable and not yet available. Progress has also been partially hindered by the use of a variety of statistical measures to define the network events of interest. We propose here a common probabilistic definition of network events that, applied to the firing activity of cultured neural networks, highlights the co-occurrence of network spikes, power-law distributed avalanches, and exponentially distributed `quasi-orbits', which offer a third type of collective behavior. A rate model, including synaptic excitation and inhibition with no imposed topology, synaptic short-term depression, and finite-size noise, accounts for all these different, coexisting phenomena. We find that their emergence is largely regulated by the proximity to an oscillatory instability of the dynamics, where the non-linear excitable behavior leads to a self-amplification of activity fluctuations over a wide range of scales in space and time. In this sense, the cultured network dynamics is compatible with an excitation-inhibition balance corresponding to a slightly sub-critical regime. Finally, we propose and test a method to infer the characteristic time of the fatigue process, from the observed time course of the network's firing rate. Unlike the model, possessing a single fatigue mechanism, the cultured network appears to show multiple time scales, signalling the possible coexistence of different fatigue mechanisms. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Network events on multiple space and time scales in
cultured neural networks and in a stochastic rate model
Guido Gigante1,2,*, Gustavo Deco3,4, Shimon Marom5, Paolo Del Giudice1,6
1 Italian Institute of Health, viale Regina Elena 199, Rome,
00161, Italy
2 Mperience srl, via Elea 8, 00183, Rome, Italy
3 Center for Brain and Cognition, Computational Neuroscience
Group, Department of Information and Communication
Technologies, Universitat Pompeu Fabra, Roc Boronat 138,
Barcelona, 08018, Spain
4 Instituci´o Catalana de la Recerca i Estudis Avan¸cats (ICREA),
Universitat Pompeu Fabra, Passeig Llu´ıs Companys 23,
Barcelona, 08010, Spain
5 Technion - Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa 32000, Israel
6 INFN, Sezione di Roma 1, Italy
* E-mail: Corresponding [email protected]
Abstract
Cortical networks, in-vitro as well as in-vivo, can spontaneously generate a
variety of collective dynamical events such as network spikes, UP and DOWN
states, global oscillations, and avalanches. Though each of them have been
variously recognized in previous works as expressions of the excitability of
the cortical tissue and the associated nonlinear dynamics, a unified picture of
their determinant factors (dynamical and architectural) is desirable and not
yet available. Progress has also been partially hindered by the use of a variety
of statistical measures to define the network events of interest. We propose
here a common probabilistic definition of network events that, applied to
the firing activity of cultured neural networks, highlights the co-occurrence
of network spikes, power-law distributed avalanches, and exponentially dis-
tributed 'quasi-orbits', which offer a third type of collective behavior. A
rate model, including synaptic excitation and inhibition with no imposed
1
topology, synaptic short-term depression, and finite-size noise, accounts for
all these different, coexisting phenomena. We find that their emergence is
largely regulated by the proximity to an oscillatory instability of the dynamics,
where the non-linear excitable behavior leads to a self-amplification of activity
fluctuations over a wide range of scales in space and time. In this sense,
the cultured network dynamics is compatible with an excitation-inhibition
balance corresponding to a slightly sub-critical regime. Finally, we propose
and test a method to infer the characteristic time of the fatigue process,
from the observed time course of the network's firing rate. Unlike the model,
possessing a single fatigue mechanism, the cultured network appears to show
multiple time scales, signalling the possible coexistence of different fatigue
mechanisms.
Introduction
The spontaneous activity of excitable neuronal networks exhibits a spectrum
of dynamic regimes ranging from quasi-linear, small fluctuations close to
stationary activity, to dramatic events such as abrupt and transient syn-
chronization. Understanding the underpinnings of such dynamic versatility
is important, as different spontaneous modes may imply in general differ-
ent state-dependent response properties to incoming stimuli and different
information processing routes.
Cultured neuronal networks offer a controllable experimental setting to
open a window into the network excitability and its dynamics, and have been
used intensively for the purpose.
Neuronal cultures in early development phases naturally show alternating
quasi-quiescent states and 'network spikes' (NS) of brief outbreaks of network
activity [1 -- 6].
In addition, recent observations in-vitro (and later even in-vivo) revealed a
rich structure of network events ('avalanches') that attracted much attention
because their spatial and temporal structure exhibited features (power-law
distributions) reminiscent of what is observed in a 'critical state' of a physical
system (see e.g. [7, 8], and [9, 10] and references therein). Generically, an
avalanche is a cascade of neural activities clustered in time; while there persist
ongoing debate on the relation between observed avalanches and whatever
'criticality' may mean for brain dynamics [11], understanding their dynamical
origin remains on the agenda.
2
Quasi-synchronous NS, avalanches and small activity fluctuations are
frequently coexisting elements of the network dynamics. Besides, as we will
describe in the following, in certain conditions one can recognize network
events which are clearly distinct from the mentioned network events, which
we name here as 'quasi-orbits'.
The abundant modeling literature on the above dynamical phenomena has
been frequently focused on specific aspects of one of them [12,13]; on the other
hand, getting a unified picture is made often difficult by different assumptions
on the network's structure and constitutive elements and, importantly, by
different methods used to detect the dynamic events of interest.
In the present paper we define a common probabilistic criterion to detect
various coexisting dynamic events (NS, avalanches and quasi-orbits) and
adopt it to analyze the spontaneous activity recorded from both cultured
networks, and a computational rate model.
Most theoretical models accounting for NS are based on an interplay
between network self-excitation on one side, and on the other side some
fatigue mechanism provoking the extinction of the network spike [12, 13]. For
such a mechanism two main options, up to details, have been considered:
neural 'spike-frequency adaptation' [3,14] and synaptic 'short-term depression'
(STD) [4,5,15 -- 18]. Despite their differences, both mechanisms share the basic
property of generating an activity-dependent self-inhibition in response to
the upsurge of activity upon the generation of a NS, the more vigorously, the
stronger the NS (i.e. the higher the average firing rate). In this paper, we
will mainly focus on STD, stressing the similarities of the two mechanisms,
yet not denying their possibly different dynamic implications.
While STD acts as an activity-dependent self-inhibition, the self-excitability
of the network depends on the balance between synaptic excitation and inhi-
bition; investigating how such balance, experimentally modifiable through
pharmacology, influences the dynamics of spontaneous NSs is interesting and
relevant as a step towards the identification of the 'excitability working point'
in the experimental preparation.
To study the factors governing the co-occurrence of different network
events and their properties we adopt a rate model for the dynamics of the
global network activity, that takes into accounts finite-size fluctuations and
the synaptic interplay between one excitatory and one inhibitory population,
with excitatory synapses being subject to STD.
On purpose we implicitly exclude any spatial topology in the model, which
is meant to describe the dynamics of a randomly connected, sparse network,
3
since we intend to expose the exquisite implications of the balance between
synaptic excitation and inhibition, and the activity-dependent self-inhibition
due to STD. In doing this, we purposely leave out not only the known relevance
of a topological organization [9, 19, 20], but also the role of cliques of neurons
which have been proposed to play a pivotal role in the the generation of NS
as functional hubs [21], as well as the putative role of 'leader neurons'.
We perform a systematic numerical and analytical study of NSs for varying
excitation/inhibition balance. The distance from an oscillatory instability of
the mean-field dynamics (in terms of the dominant eigenvalue of the linearized
dynamics) largely appears to be the sole variable governing the statistics of the
inter-NS intervals, ranging from a very sparse, irregular bursting (coefficient
of variation CV ∼ 1) to a sustained, periodic one (CV ∼ 0). The intermediate,
weakly synchronized regime (CV ∼ 0.5), in which the experimental cultures
are often observed to operate, is found in a neighborhood of the instability
that shrinks as the endogenous fluctuations in the network activity become
smaller with increasing network size.
Moreover, the model robustly shows the co-presence of avalanches with
NS and quasi-orbits. The avalanche sizes are distributed according to a
power-law over a wide region of the excitation-inhibition plane, although the
crossing of the instability line is signaled by a bump in the large-size tail of
the distribution; we compare such distributions and their modulation (as well
as the distributions of NS) across the instability line with the experimental
results from cortical neuronal cultures; again the results appear to confirm
that neuronal cultures operate in close proximity of an instability line.
Taking advantage of the fact that the sizes of both NS and quasi-orbits
are found to be significantly correlated with the dynamic variable associated
with STD (available synaptic resources) just before the onset of the event, we
developed a simple optimization method to infer, from the recorded activity,
the characteristic time-scales of the putative fatigue mechanism at work.
We first tested the method on the model, and then applied it to in-vitro
recordings; we could identify in several cases one or two long time-scales,
ranging from few hundreds milliseconds to few seconds.
Weak or no correlations were found instead between avalanche sizes and
the STD dynamics; this suggests that avalanches originate from synaptic
interaction which amplifies a wide spectrum of small fluctuations, and are
mostly ineffective in eliciting a strong self-inhibition.
4
Models and Analysis
Experimental data
As originally described in [2], cortical neurons were obtained from newborn
rats within 24 hours after birth, following standard procedures. Briefly, the
neurons were plated directly onto a substrate-integrated multielectrode array
(MEA). The cells were bathed in MEM supplemented with heat-inactivated
horse serum (5%), glutamine (0.5 mM), glucose (20 mM), and gentamycin
(10 µg/ml) and were maintained in an atmosphere of 37◦ C, 5% CO2/95%
air in a tissue culture incubator as well as during the recording phases. The
data analyzed here was collected during the third week after plating, thus
allowing functional and structural maturation of the neurons. MEAs of 60
Ti/Au/TiN electrodes, 30 µm in diameter, and spaced 200 µm from each other
(Multi Channel Systems, Reutlingen, Germany) were used. The insulation
layer (silicon nitride) was pretreated with poly-D-lysine. All experiments were
conducted under a slow perfusion system with perfusion rates of ∼100 µl/h. A
commercial 60-channel amplifier (B-MEA-1060; Multi Channel Systems) with
frequency limits of 1-5000 Hz and a gain of 1024× was used. The B-MEA-
1060 was connected to MCPPlus variable gain filter amplifiers (Alpha Omega,
Nazareth, Israel) for additional amplification. Data was digitized using two
parallel 5200a/526 analog-to-digital boards (Microstar Laboratories, Bellevue,
WA). Each channel was sampled at a frequency of 24000 Hz and prepared
for analysis using the AlphaMap interface (Alpha Omega). Thresholds (8×
root mean square units; typically in the range of 10-20 µV ) were defined
separately for each of the recording channels before the beginning of the
experiment. The electrophysiological data is freely accessible for download at
marom.net.technion.ac.il/neural-activity-data/.
Network rate dynamics
A set of Wilson-Cowan-like equations [22] for the spike-rate of the excitatory
(νE) and the inhibitory (νI) neuronal populations lies at the core of our
dynamic mean-field model:
τE νE = −(cid:0)νE − Φ(IE)(cid:1)
τI νI = −(cid:0)νI − Φ(II)(cid:1),
5
(1)
where τE and τI represent two characteristic times (of the order of few to few
tens of ms), and Φ is the gain function of the input currents, IE and II, that
in turn depend on νE, νI, and the synaptic efficacies. We chose Φ to be the
transfer function of the leaky integrate-and-fire neuron under the assumptions
of Gaussian, uncorrelated input of mean µ and infinitesimal variance σ2 [23]:
exp(cid:0)s2)(cid:2)erf(cid:0)s) + 1(cid:3) ds + τref ract
(cid:105)−1
,
Φ(cid:2)µ, σ2(cid:3) ≡(cid:104)√
π τV
(cid:90) V thresh−V rest−µ τV
σ2 τV
V reset−V rest−µ τV
√
√
σ2 τV
(2)
where τV is the membrane time constant, τref ract is a refractory period, and
V rest, V reset, and V thresh are respectively the rest, the post-firing reset, and the
firing-threshold membrane potential of the neuron (we assume the membrane
resistance R = 1).
The model incorporates the non-instantaneous nature of synaptic trans-
mission in its simplest form, by letting the νs being low-pass filtered by a
single synaptic time-scale τ :
τ ν =(cid:0)ν − ν(cid:1).
(3)
One can regard the variables νs as the instantaneous firing rates as seen by
post-synaptic neurons, after synaptic filtering. The form of Eq. 3 and our
choice of τ values (see Table 1) implicitly neglects slow NMDA contributions
and is restricted to AMPA and GABA synaptic currents. Thus, the input
currents IE and II in Eq. 1 will be functions of the rates νs through these
filtered rates; with reference to Eq. 2, the model assumes the following form
for the mean and the variance of the current IE (the expressions for II are
similarly defined):
µE ≡ c nE νE wexc JEE rE +
c nI νI winh JEI + νext Jext
E ≡ c nE νE w2
σ2
c nI νI w2
inh
exc
EE + σ2
EI + σ2
JEI
JEE
(cid:0)J 2
(cid:0)J 2
(cid:1) r2
(cid:1) + νext
E +
(cid:0)J 2
(4)
(cid:1),
ext + σ2
Jext
where the nE and nI are the number of neurons in the excitatory and inhibitory
population respectively; c is the probability of two neurons being synaptically
connected; JEE (JEI) is the average synaptic efficacy from an excitatory
(inhibitory) pre-synaptic neuron to an excitatory one, σ2
J is the variance
6
of the J-distribution; wexc and winh are dimensionless parameters that we
will use in the following to independently rescale excitatory and inhibitory
synapses respectively. Finally, an external current is assumed in the form of
a Poisson train of spikes of rate νext driving the neurons in the network with
average synaptic efficacy Jext. In Eq. 4 rE(t) (0 < rE < 1) is the fraction
of synaptic resources available at time t for the response of an excitatory
synapse to a pre-synaptic spike; the evolution of rE evolves according to the
following dynamics, which implements the effects of short-term depression
(STD) [24, 25] into the network dynamics:
τSTD rE = (1 − rE) − uSTD rE τSTD νE,
(5)
where 0 < uSTD < 1 represents the (constant) fraction of the available synaptic
resources consumed by an excitatory postsynaptic potential, and τSTD is the
recovery time for the synaptic resources.
Finally, for a network of n neurons, we introduce finite-size noise by
assuming that the signal the synapses integrate in Eq. 3 is a random process
νn of mean ν; in a time-bin dt, we expect the number of action potentials
fired to be a Poisson variable of mean n ν(t) dt; Eq. 3 will thus become:
τ ν = (cid:0)νn − ν(cid:1)
νn ≡ Poisson[n ν dt]
n dt
.
(6)
Putting all together, the noisy dynamic mean-field model is described by
the following set of (stochastic) differential equations:
τE νE = Φ(cid:0)µE, σ2
= Φ(cid:0)µI, σ2
(cid:1) − νE
(cid:1) − νI
E
I
τI νI
τE νE = νnE − νE
= νnI − νI
τI νI
τSTD rE = (1 − rE) − uSTD τSTD rE νE
(7)
complemented by Eqs. 2, 4, and 6. The values of all the fixed network
parameters are shown in Table 1. Since we will compare the dynamics of
networks of different sizes, we scale the connectivity with network size in
order to keep invariant the mean field equations: we hold the number of
synaptic connection per neuron constant by rescaling, with reference to Eq. 4,
the probability of connection c so that c nE and c nI are kept constant to the
reference values that can be deduced from Table 1.
7
Table 1. Network parameters.
Parameter
nE / nI
c
τV / τref ract
V rest / V f iring
JEE ± σJEE
JIE ± σJIE
JEI ± σJEI
JII ± σJII
Jext ± σJext
νext
τE / τI
τr
uSTD
τE = τI
Value
160 / 40
20 / 2 ms
0.25
−70 / −55 mV
0.809 ± 0.202 mV
1.23 ± 0.307 mV
−0.340 ± 0.0850 mV
−0.358 ± 0.0894 mV
0.416 ± 0.104 mV
1.25 kHz
10 / 2 ms
800 ms
0.2
20 ms
Spike-frequency adaptation (SFA) (not present in simulations unless where
explicitly stated) is introduced by subtracting a term to the instantaneous
mean value of the IE current:
µE → µE − gSFA cE(t)
(8)
proportional to the instantaneous value of the variable cE, that simply inte-
grates νnE :
τSFA
dcE
dt
= −cE + νnE ,
(9)
with a characteristic time τSFA. This additional term aims to model an after-
hyperpolarization, Ca2+-dependent K+ current [26, 27]. In this sense, cE can
be interpreted as the cytoplasmic calcium concentration [Ca2+]), whose effects
on the network dynamics are controlled by the value of the "conductance"
gSFA.
Simulations are performed by integrating the stochastic dynamics with a
fixed time step dt = 0.25 ms.
In the following, by "spike count" we will mean the quantity ν(t) n dt.
8
Network events detection
For the detection of network events (NSs, quasi-orbits, and avalanches) we
developed a unified approach based on Hidden Markov Models (HMM) [28].
Despite HMM have been widely used for temporal pattern recognition in many
different fields, to our knowledge few attempts have been made to use them in
the context of interest here [29,30]. For the purpose of the present description,
we just remind that a HMM is a stochastic system that evolves according
to Markov transitions between "hidden", i.e. unobservable, states; at each
step of the dynamics the visible output depends probabilistically on the
current hidden state. Such models can be naturally adapted to the detection
of network events, the observations being the number of detected spikes
per time bin, and the underlying hidden states, between which the system
spontaneously alternates, being associated with high or low network activity
('network event - no network event'). A standard optimization procedure
adapts then the HMM to the recorded activity sample by determining the
most probable sequence of hidden states given the observations.
The two-step method we propose is based on HMM, has no user-defined
parameters, and automatically adapts to different conditions.
In the first step, the algorithm finds the parameters of the two-state HMM
(one low-activity state, representing the quasi-quiescent periods, and one
high-activity state, associated with network events) that best accounts for a
given sequence of spike counts -- the visible states in the HMM; such fitting
is performed through the Baum-Welch algorithm [28]. In the second step,
the most probable sequence for the two alternating hidden levels, given the
sequence of spike counts and the fitted parameters, is found through the
Viterbi algorithm. Network events are identified as the periods of dominance
of the high activity hidden state.
In order to retain only the most significant events a minimum event
duration is imposed; such threshold is self-consistently determined as follows.
The Viterbi algorithm is also applied to a "surrogate" time-series obtained by
randomly shuffling the original one, thereby generating a set of "surrogate"
events. The purpose is to determine the desired minimum event duration
from the high duration tail of surrogate events (which, by construction,
come from a time-series with no real temporal structure). Since the high
duration distribution tail is found to be roughly exponential, we fit such tail
by considering only the surrogate events of duration larger than the 75th
percentile. Then, from the fitted exponential, we compute the duration value
9
such that the probability of durations greater than this value is P (surrogate) =
10−3. In other words, we set the threshold on minimum duration of detected
events to the duration of exceptionally long (P < 10−3) surrogate events.
As already remarked, we used essentially the same algorithm for detecting
NS/quasi-orbits and avalanches. The only significant difference is that, in
the case of avalanches, the emission probability of the low-activity hidden
state is kept fixed during the Baum-Welch algorithm to p(n) (cid:39) δn0 (δij
is the Kronecker delta; p(n) is the probability of emitting n spikes in a
time-bin). Thus the lower state is constrained to a negligible probability of
outputting non-zero spike-counts, conforming to the intuition that in between
avalanches the network is (almost) completely silent. More precisely, we
set p(1) = 10−6 (cid:104)n(cid:105), where (cid:104)n(cid:105) is the average number of spikes that the
network emits during a time-bin dt. After the modified Baum-Welch first
step, avalanches are determined, as above, by applying the Viterbi algorithm;
no threshold is applied in this case, neither to the avalanche duration nor to
its size.
The proposed procedures introduce three arbitrary parameters: the time
bin dt, the probability P (surrogate) for network spikes and quasi-orbits, and
the probability p(1). To test the robustness of the algorithms, we varied
these parameters over ample ranges: dt between 0.25 and 8 ms; P (surrogate)
between 10−2 and 10−4; p(1) between 10−8 and 10−4. We found that avalanche
size distributions are virtually unaffected under variations of p(1), and only
mildly affected for the largest dt explored; higher values of P (surrogate)
lead, as expected, to detect a larger number of small quasi-orbits, yet these
additional events do not alter the overall shape of the size distribution
predicted by the theory (see next section); on the other hand, a large number
of very small quasi-orbits does have a detrimental effect on the correlation
results reported in Section "Inferring the time-scales".
Simulations and data analysis have been performed using custom-written
mixed C++/ MATLAB (version R2013a, Mathworks, Natick, MA) functions
and scripts.
Size distribution for quasi-orbits and network spikes
The non-linear rate model described above can show a wide repertoire of
dynamical patterns, as for example multiple stable fixed points and large,
quasi-periodic oscillations. As we will show, for sufficiently excitable networks,
a stable state of asynchronous activity (fixed point) is destabilized, in favor
10
of stable global oscillations. Finite size noise probes differently network's ex-
citability at different distances from such instability. Before global oscillations
become stable (in the infinite network limit), the network's highly non-linear
reaction to its own fluctuations can ignite large, relatively stereotyped, "net-
work spikes". Also, in the proximity of the oscillatory (Hopf) instability, noise
can promote "quasi orbits", i.e., transient departures from the fixed point
which develop on time-scales dictated by the upcoming oscillatory instability,
of which they are precursors. Under a linear approximation, the probability
distribution of the amplitude l of these quasi-orbits can be explicitly derived
as explained in the following.
Consider a generic planar linear dynamics with noise:
z = A z + σ ξ,
(10)
where A is 2×2 real matrix, and ξ = (ξ(t), 0) is a white noise with (cid:104)ξ(t)ξ(t(cid:48))(cid:105) =
δ(t−t(cid:48)). We here assume that the system is close to a Hopf bifurcation; in other
words that the matrix A has complex-conjugated eigenvalues λ± = (cid:60)λ + i(cid:61)λ,
with (cid:60)λ < 0 and (cid:60)λ (cid:28) (cid:61)λ.
By means of a linear transformation, the system can be rewritten as:
x = (cid:60)λ x − (cid:61)λ y + σx ξ
y = (cid:61)λ x + (cid:60)λ y + σy ξ,
(11)
with σx and σy constants determined by the coordinate transformation. Mak-
ing use of It¯o's lemma to write:
x2 = 2(cid:60)λ x2 − 2(cid:61)λ x y + σ2
y2 = 2(cid:61)λ x y + 2(cid:60)λ y2 + σ2
x + 2 x σx ξ
y + 2 y σy ξ,
and summing the previous two equations, we find for the square radius
l2 ≡ x2 + y2 the dynamics:
l2 = 2(cid:60)λ l2 + σ(cid:48)2 + 2(cid:0)σx x + σy y(cid:1) ξ,
(12)
with σ(cid:48)2 .
= σ2
x + σ2
y.
As long as (cid:61)λ (cid:29) (cid:60)λ, it is physically sound to make the approximation:
(x(t), y(t)) = l(0)(cid:0) cos((cid:61)λ t + φ), sin((cid:61)λ t + φ)(cid:1),
(13)
11
for 0 ≤ t ≤ T = 2 π/(cid:61)λ and then to average the variance of the noise over
such period to get:
σx cos((cid:61)λ t + φ) + σy sin((cid:61)λ t + φ)
dt =
(cid:105)2
(cid:90) T
(cid:104)
l(0)2
T
= l(0)2 σ2
0
x + σ2
y
2
l(0)2 σ(cid:48)2
2
.
=
in order to rewrite Eq. (12) as:
l2 = 2(cid:60)λ l2 + σ(cid:48)2 +
√
2 l σ(cid:48) ξ.
(14)
Such stochastic differential equation is associated with the Fokker-Planck
equation:
(cid:2)2(cid:60)λ l2 + σ(cid:48)2] p(l2, t) +
exp(cid:0) − 2(cid:60)λ l2
l exp(cid:0) − 2(cid:60)λ l2
(cid:1),
(cid:1).
σ(cid:48)2
σ(cid:48)2
(15)
(16)
(17)
(18)
∂t p(l2, t) = −∂l2
+ σ(cid:48)2 ∂2
l2 l2 p(l2, t) ≡ Ll2 p(l2, t)
that admits an exponential distribution as stationary solution:
pss(l2) =
2(cid:60)λ
σ(cid:48)2
that is, a Rayleigh distribution for l:
4(cid:60)λ
σ(cid:48)2
pss(l) =
On the other hand, we found a correlation between l (the maximal depar-
ture from the low-activity fixed point) and the duration of the quasi-orbit.
Therefore the size of the quasi-orbit (the 'area' below the firing rate time
profile during the excursion from the fixed point) is expected to scale as l2,
so that it should be exponentially distributed.
For network spikes we do not have a theoretical argument to predict the
shape of the size distribution, however empirically a (left-truncated) Gaussian
distribution proved to be roughly adequate. Since we expect that quasi-orbits
and NS contribute with different weights for varying excitatory/inhibitory
balance, we adopted the following form for the overall distribution of network
event size to fit experimental data:
exp(cid:0) − (x − x0)
(cid:1) +
τ0
exp(cid:0) − (x − m1)2
(cid:1).
2 σ2
1
1 − p0
√
2 π σ1
p(x) =
p0
τ0
12
The parameters of the two distributions and their relative weight 0 ≤ p0 ≤ 1
are estimated by minimizing the log-likelihood on the data. A threshold
for the event size is determined as the value having equal probability of
being generated by either the exponential or the normal distribution. In the
following, NSs are defined as events having size larger than this threshold.
In those cases in which a threshold smaller than the peak of the normal
distribution could not be determined, no threshold was set.
Results
In the following, we will study a stochastic firing-rate model and make
extensive comparison of its dynamical behavior with the activity of ex-vivo
networks of cortical neurons recorded through a 60-channel multielectrode
array.
The first question we want to answer is how the excitation-inhibition
balance affects network dynamics. Starting from the statistics of network
spikes (NS) we show that it is well described by a single variable measuring
the distance from an oscillatory instability of the dynamics. We then study
in the model the effects of finite-size fluctuations on the statistics of NS.
Then, taking advantage of new detection algorithm we introduce (see
Models and Analysis), we recognize the presence of a spectrum of network
events, including three families: NS, "quasi-orbits", and avalanches. The
predicted size distribution of quasi-orbits , exponential component in Eq. 18,
is confirmed by simulations and recovered in experimental data analysis. We
investigate how the different network events characterize in various propor-
tions the network dynamics depending on the excitatory-inhibitory balance;
experimental data offer an interesting match with model findings, compatible
with ex-vivo network being typically slightly below the oscillatory instability.
Finally we introduce a simple procedure to infer the time-scales of putative
slow self-inhibitory mechanisms underlying the occurrence of network events.
The inference is obtained based on knowledge of the firing activity alone; this
makes the method interesting for analysis of experimental data, as we show
through exemplary results.
The stochastic firing-rate model consists of two populations of neurons,
one excitatory and one inhibitory, interacting through effective synaptic
couplings; excitatory synaptic couplings follow a dynamics mimicking short-
term depression (described after the Tsodyks-Markram model, [24]). We
13
adopted the transfer function of the leaky integrate-and-fire neuron subject
to white-noise current with drift [23] as the single population input-output
function; moreover the activity of each population is made stochastic by
adding realistic finite-size noise. Working with a noisy mean field model
allows in principle to easily sweep through widely different network sizes and,
more importantly, allows us to perform the stability analysis.
To start the exploration that follows, we chose a reference working point
where the model's dynamics has a low-rate fixed point (2 − 4 Hz) just on
the brink of an oscillatory instability or, in other words, where the dominant
eigenvalue λ of the dynamics, linearized around the fixed point, is complex
with null real part. The model network (Fig. 1, panel A) shows in proximity of
this point a dynamical behavior qualitatively similar, in terms of population
spikes, to what is observed in ex-vivo neuronal networks (Fig. 1, panel B).
A
B
Figure 1. Time course of the network firing rate. Panel A: noisy
mean-field simulations; panel B: ex-vivo data. Random large excursions of
the firing rate (network spikes and quasi-orbits) are clearly visible in both
cases.
14
t (s)05101520spike counts0306090spike counts02040 Excitation-inhibition balance and network spike statis-
tics
As the relative balance of excitation and inhibition is expected to be a
major determinant of NS statistics we investigated first, for spontaneous NSs,
how the inter-NS intervals (INSI) and their regularity (as measured by the
coefficient of variation, CVINSI) depend on such balance. In Fig. 2 we report
the average INSI (left panel) and CVINSI (right panel) in the plane (wexc,
winh) of the excitatory and inhibitory synaptic efficacies (JEE → wE JEE,
JIE → wE JIE, JEI → wI JEI, JII → wI JII, see Eq. 4). Starting from the
center of this plane (wexc = 1, winh = 1) and moving along the horizontal axis,
all the excitatory synapses of the network are multiplied by a factor wexc:
moving right, the total excitation of the network increases (wexc > 1), toward
left it decreases (wexc < 1). Along the vertical line, instead, all the inhibitory
synapses are damped (moving downward, winh < 1) or strengthened (going
upward, winh > 1).
It is clearly seen that both (cid:104)INSI(cid:105) and CVINSI are approximately dis-
tributed in the plane along almost straight lines of equal values: for a chosen
(cid:104)INSI(cid:105) or CVINSI one can trade more excitation for less inhibition keeping
the value constant, suggesting that, at this level of approximation, a measure
of net synaptic excitation governs the NS statistics. Besides, not surprisingly,
for high net excitation NSs are more frequent (∼ 1 Hz) and quasi-periodic
(low CVINSI), due to the fact that the STD recovery time determines quasi-
deterministically when the network is again in the condition of generating a
new NS. Weak excitability, on the other hand, leads to rare NSs, approaching
a Poisson statistics (CVINSI (cid:39) 1), since excitability is so low that fluctuations
are essential for recruiting enough activation to elicit a NS, with STD playing
little or no role at the ignition time; below an "excitation threshold", NSs
disappear.
The solid lines in Fig. 2 are derived from the linearization of the 5-
dimensional dynamical system (see Eq. 7), and are curves of iso-(cid:60)λ, where λ
is the dominant eigenvalue of the Jacobian: (cid:60)λ = 0 Hz (white line, signaling
a Hopf bifurcation in the corresponding deterministic system), (cid:60)λ = 3.5 Hz
(red line), and (cid:60)λ = −3.5 Hz (black line). Values of CV found in typical
cultured networks are close to model results near the bifurcation line (cid:60)λ = 0
Hz. We observe, furthermore, that such lines roughly follow iso-(cid:104)INSI(cid:105) and
iso-CVINSI curves, suggesting that a quasi one-dimensional representation
might be extracted.
15
A
B
(cid:104)
I
N
S
I
(cid:105)
C
V
N
S
I
I
Figure 2. Inter-network-spike interval (INSI) statistics in the noisy
mean-field model, for varying levels of excitation (wexc) and inhibi-
tion (winh). Panel A: (cid:104)INSI(cid:105) (the scale is in seconds); panel B: coefficient of
variation of INSI (CVINSI). For high net excitation (bottom-right quadrant)
short-term depression plays a determinant role in generating frequent and
regular (low CVINSI) NSs; for weak excitability (upper-left quadrant) random
fluctuations are essential for the generation of rare, quasi-Poissonian NSs
(CVINSI (cid:39) 1). The solid lines are isolines of the real part (cid:60)λ of the dominant
eigenvalue of the mean-field dynamics' Jacobian; white line: (cid:60)λ = 0 Hz; red
line: (cid:60)λ = 3.5 Hz; black line: (cid:60)λ = −3.5 Hz. Note how such lines roughly
follow isolines of (cid:104)INSI(cid:105) and CVINSI.
We show in Fig. 3 (cid:104)INSI(cid:105) (panel A) and CVINSI (panel B) against (cid:60)λ
for the same networks (circles) of Fig. 2, and for a set of larger networks
(N = 8000 neurons, squares) that are otherwise identical to the first ones,
pointwise in the excitation-inhibition plane (the average number of synaptic
connections per neuron for the larger networks is kept constant to the value
used in the original, smaller ones, as explained in Models and Analysis) The
difference in size amounts, for the new, larger networks, to weaker endogenous
noise entering the stochastic dynamics of the populations' firing rates (see
Eq. 6, second line). The points are seen to approximately collapse onto
lines for both sets of networks, thus confirming (cid:60)λ as the relevant control
quantity for (cid:104)INSI(cid:105) and CVINSI. It is seen that, for the smaller networks,
(cid:104)INSI(cid:105) and CVINSI depend smoothly on (cid:60)λ, due to finite-size effects smearing
the bifurcation. Also note the branch of points (filled circles) for which
(cid:61)λ = 0 and then no oscillatory component is present, corresponding to points
16
wexcwinh 0.80.911.11.20.40.60.811.21.41.61.01.62.54.06.31016wexcwinh 0.80.911.11.20.40.60.811.21.41.60.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9 in the extreme top-left region of the planes in Fig. 2. For the set of larger
networks, the dependence of (cid:104)INSI(cid:105) and CVINSI on the (cid:60)λ is much sharper, as
expected given the much smaller finite-size effects; this shrinks the available
region, around the instability line, allowing for intermediate, more biologically
plausible values of CVINSI.
A
B
Figure 3. Stability analysis of the linearized dynamics captures
most of the variability in the inter-network-spike interval (INSI)
statistics. (cid:104)INSI(cid:105) (panel A) and CVINSI (panel B) vs the real part (cid:60)λ of
the dominant eigenvalue of the Jacobian of the linearized dynamics, for two
networks that are pointwise identical in the excitation-inhibition plane, except
for their size (circles: 200 neurons, as in Fig. 2; squares: 8000 neurons). The
data points almost collapse on 1-D curves when plotted as functions of (cid:60)λ,
leading effectively to a "quasi one-dimensional" representation of the INSI
statistics in the (wexc, winh)-plane. The region in which the INSIs are neither
regular (CVINSI ∼ 0) nor completely random (CVINSI (cid:39) 1), as typically
observed in experimental data, shrinks for larger networks. The filled circles
mark a null imaginary part (cid:61)λ.
We remark that NSs are highly non-linear and relatively stereotyped
events, typical of an excitable non-linear system. The good predictive power
of the linear analysis for the statistics of INSI signals that relatively small
fluctuations around the system's fixed point, described well by a linear analysis,
can ignite a NS.
17
ℜ λ (Hz)<INSI> (s) −4−2024100101200 neurons8000 neuronsℜ λ (Hz)CVINSI −4−202400.20.40.60.81200 neurons8000 neurons A spectrum of network events
Our mean-field, finite-size network is a non-linear excitable system which,
to the left of the Hopf bifurcation line, and close to it, can express different
types of excursions from the otherwise stable fixed point. Large (almost
stereotyped for high excitation) NSs are exquisite manifestations of the non-
linear excitable nature of the system, ignited by noise; the distribution of NS
size (number of spikes generated during the event) is relatively narrow and
approximately symmetric (the Gaussian component of Eq. 18).
Noise can also induce smaller, transient excursions from the fixed point
which can be adequately described as quasi-orbits in a linear approximation.
In fact, noise induces a probability distribution on the size of such events,
which can be computed as explained in Methods and Analysis (the exponential
part in Eq. 18). Fig. 4, panel A, shows the activity of a simulated network
(blue line) alongside with detected network events. We remark that the the
different event types may not in general be easily distinguished on a single-
event basis, while we argue that they are probabilistically distinguishable.
From the best fit for the expected size distribution a threshold for the event
size can be determined to separate events that are (a-posteriori ) more probably
quasi-orbits from the ones that are more probably NSs (for details, see Models
and Analysis). Following such classification, the green line in Fig. 4, panel A,
marks the detection of two NSs (first and third event) and two quasi-orbits
(second and fourth event).
We also emphasize that the existence of quasi-orbits is a specific conse-
quence of the fact that in the whole excitation-inhibition plane explored for
the model, the low-activity fixed point becomes unstable via a Hopf bifur-
cation. It is indeed known that for nonlinear systems in the proximity of a
Hopf bifurcation, noise promotes precursors of the bifurcation, which appear
as transient synchronization events (see, e.g., [31]).
As one moves around the excitation-inhibition plane, to the left of the
bifurcation line, the two types of events contribute differently to the overall
distribution of network event sizes. Qualitatively, the farther from the bifur-
cation line, the higher the contribution of the small, "quasi-linear" events.
This fact can be understood by noting that the average size of such events is
expected to scale as 1/(cid:60)λ, where (cid:60)λ is the real part of the dominant eigen-
value of the (stable) linearized dynamics (see Models and Analysis, Eq. 16).
The average size is furthermore expected to scale with the amount of noise
affecting the dynamics, thus the contribution of quasi-linear events is also
18
A
B
Figure 4. Algorithms for network events detection. Panel A: total
network activity from simulation (blue line) with detected NS/quasi-orbits
(green line) and avalanches (red line). Four large events (green line) are
visible; the first and third are statistically classified as network spikes; the
other smaller two as quasi-orbits. Note how network spikes and quasi-orbits
are typically included inside a single avalanche. Panel B: a zoom over 0.5
seconds of activity, with discretization time-step 0.25 ms, illustrates avalanches
structure (red line).
expected to vanish for larger networks.
It has been previously reported that activity dynamics may be different
from one network to the other, reflecting idiosyncrasies of composition and
history-dependent processes ( [32]). Moreover, the dynamics of a given
network, as well as its individual neurons, may shift over time (minutes and
hours) between different modes of activity ( [32 -- 34]). We therefore chose
19
t (s)01234567spike counts01020304050t (s)2.52.62.72.82.93spike counts012 to demonstrate the efficacy of our analytical approach on two data sets of
large-scale random cortical networks.
In panels A-C of Fig 5, we show the experimental distributions of event sizes
for two cultured networks: panels A and B are ∼40-minute recordings taken
from a very long recording for the same network; panel C is ∼1-hour recording
from a different cultured network. By visual inspection, the distributions
appear to be consistent with two components contributing with various
weights, both for different periods of the same network, and for different
networks. In the light of the above theoretical considerations, one is led to
generate the hypothesis that the two components contributing to the overall
distribution were associated with quasi-orbits and network spikes respectively;
to test this hypothesis, we fitted (solid lines in Fig. 5) the experimental
distributions with the sum of an exponential and a Gaussian distribution (see
Models and Analysis, Eq. 18), prepared to interpret a predominance of the
exponential (Gaussian) component as a lesser (greater) excitability of the
network. We remark that (see panels A and B) the relative weights of the
two components appear to change over time for the same network, as if the
excitability level would dynamically change; more on this at the end of this
section.
To substantiate the above interpretation of experimental results, we turned
to long simulations (about 5.5 hours) of networks in different points in the
excitation-inhibition plane (Fig. 2), from which we extracted the distribution
of network events and fitted them with Eq. 18 as for experimental data (see
panels D-F in Fig. 5). Again, to the eye, the fits appear to be consistent
with the two components variously contributing to the overall distribution,
depending on the excitability of the network.
If, however, the fits are subject to a Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, the test
fails (p < 0.01) for panels D and F. By inspecting the maximum distance
between the cumulative distributions for simulation data and the fit, we found
it at the lowest size bin for panel D, while the "Gaussian" part gives the
greater mismatch for panel F. As for panel D, while the theoretical argument
for the quasi-orbits clearly captures the shape of the size distributions, the
way the test fails in the exponential part is interesting.
In fact, network events cannot be detected with arbitrarily small size: in
a way, the detection procedure imposes a soft threshold on the event size,
below which the exponential distribution is not applicable.
We can provide a rough estimate of such soft threshold as follows. A
quasi-orbit duration is, to a first approximation, proportional to 1/(cid:61)λ, which
20
is of the order of few hundreds milliseconds not too far from the bifurcation
line in the excitation-inhibition plane. Taking, for instance, 150 ms, an
event will be detected if network activity within this time-span is larger than
average (typically few spikes per second per neuron; we take 3 for the present
example): this leads to a soft threshold of about 100 spikes. This would be
the lower limit of applicability of the exponential part of the distribution;
this also explains the trough observed for very small sizes.
As for the failure of the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test for the right part of
the distribution in panel F, it should be remarked that the assumption of
a Gaussian distribution for the size of network spikes, although generically
plausible, is not grounded in a theoretical argument, and it's not surprising
that, on the order of 104 detected events, even a moderate skewness, as the
one observed, can make the test fail.
The fit for experimental data of panels A-C passed the Kolmogorov-
Smirnov test (p > 0.01).
As mentioned in the introduction, avalanches are cascades of neural
activities clustered in time (see Models and Analysis for our operational
definition; examples of different methods used in the literature to detect
avalanches can be found in [7, 35 -- 37]). Fig. 4, panel A and panel B, shows an
example of the structure of the detected avalanches (red lines) in the model
network.
We extracted avalanches from simulated data, as well as from experimental
data. For simulations, we choose data corresponding to three points in the
(wexc, winh) plane of Fig. 2, with constant winh = 1 and increasing wexc, with
the rightmost falling exactly over the instability line (white solid line in Fig. 2).
Three experimental data sets were extracted from different periods of a very
long recording of spontaneous activity from a neural culture; each data set is
a 40-minute recording.
In Fig. 6 we show (in log-log scale) the distribution of avalanche sizes for
the three simulated networks (top row) and the three experimental (bottom
row) data sets (blue dots); red lines are power-law fits [38].
From the panels in the top row we see that the distributions are well
fitted, over a range of two orders of magnitude, by power-laws with exponents
ranging from about 1.5 to about 2.2, consistent with the results found in [7].
Note that in the cited paper the algorithm used for avalanche detection
is quite different from ours, and the wide range of power-law exponents
is related to their dependence on the time-window used to discretize data.
In [39] (adopting yet another algorithm for avalanche detection), both the
21
Experimental data
A
Simulation
D
B
E
C
F
Figure 5. A broad spectrum of synchronous network events: simu-
lations vs ex-vivo data. Panels A-C: experimental distributions of network
events. Panels A and B: ∼40-minute recordings from a very long recording,
for the same network; panel C: ∼1-hour recording from another cultured net-
work. Panels D-F: distributions from simulations of networks corresponding
to the points in Fig. 2 ((wexc, winh) = (0.82, 0.7), (wexc, winh) = (0.82, 0.55),
(wexc, winh) = (0.88, 0.55)). The three networks of panels D-F have increasing
levels of subcritical excitability. Note the logarithmic scale on the y-axis.
The solid lines are fits of the theoretical distribution of event sizes, a sum
of an exponential (for quasi-orbits) and a Gaussian (for NS) distribution
(see Models and Analysis, Eq. 18). The vertical lines mark the probabilistic
threshold separating NS and quasi-orbits.
shape of the avalanche distribution and the exponent vary depending on using
pharmacology to manipulate synaptic transmission, over a range compatible
with our model findings; notably, they find the slope of the power-law to be
increasing with the excitability of the network, which is consistent with our
modeling results.
Panels B and C of Fig. 6 clearly show the buildup of 'bumps' in the high-
22
NS/quasi-orbit size100200300400500counts100101102NS/quasi-orbit size200400600800counts100101102NS/quasi-orbit size100200300400500counts101102NS/quasi-orbit size200400600counts100102NS/quasi-orbit size200400600counts101102NS/quasi-orbit size200400600800counts101102 Simulation
A
Experimental data
D
B
E
C
F
Figure 6. Avalanche size distribution: simulations vs ex-vivo data.
Panels A-C: mean-field simulations, with fixed inhibition winh = 1. and
increasing excitation (wexc = 0.9, 0.94, 1). The distributions are well fitted
by power-laws; panel B and C clearly show the buildup of 'bumps' in the
high-size tails, reflecting the increasing contribution from network spikes
and quasi-orbits in that region of the distribution. Panels D-F from ex-vivo
data, different ∼ 40-minute segments from one long recording; power-laws
are again observed, although fitted exponents cover a smaller range; in
panels E and F , bumps are visible, similar to model findings. The similarity
between the theoretical and experimental distributions could reflect changes
of excitatory/inhibitory balance in time in the experimental preparation.
Since all the three simulations lay on the left of or just on the bifurcation line
(white line in Fig. 2), the shown results are compatible with the experimental
network operating in a slightly sub-critical regime.
size tails, increasing with the self-excitation of the network; this is understood
as reflecting the predominance of a contribution from NS and possibly quasi-
orbits in that region of the distribution, on top of a persisting wide spectrum
of avalanches. This feature also is consistent with the experimental findings
23
Avalanche Size332320p(AS)10-510-310-1γ = 1.44Avalanche Size332320p(AS)10-510-310-1γ = 1.92Avalanche Size332320p(AS)10-510-310-1γ = 2.23Avalanche Size332320p(AS)10-610-410-2γ = 2.03Avalanche Size332320p(AS)10-510-310-1γ = 2.35Avalanche Size332320p(AS)10-510-310-1γ = 2.24 of [39], and has been previously shown in a theoretical model [40] for non-leaky
integrate-and-fire neurons endowed with STD and synaptic facilitation.
Turning to the plots in the bottom row of Fig. 6, we observe the following
features: power-laws are again observed over two decades and more; in panels
E and F , bumps are visible, similar to model findings; power-law exponents
cover a smaller range just above 2.
While the sequence of plots in two rows (modeling and experiment)
clearly shows similar features, we emphasize that experimental data were
extracted from a unique long recording, with no intervening pharmacological
manipulations affecting synaptic transmission; on the other hand, it has
been suggested [41] that a dynamic modulation of the excitatory/inhibitory
balance can indeed be observed in long recordings; although our model would
be inherently unable to capture such effects, it is tempting to interpret the
suggestive similarity between the theoretical and experimental distributions
in Fig. 6 as a manifestation of such changes of excitatory/inhibitory balance
in time, of which the theoretical distributions would be a 'static' analog.
To rule out the possibility that different behaviors in time could be due
to intrinsic and global modifications in the experimental preparation, we
checked (see Fig. ?? - S1 Fig) the waveforms of the recorded spikes across all
MEA electrodes, comparing the earliest and latest used recordings (about 40
minutes each, separated by about 34 hours). In most cases the waveforms
for the two recordings are remarkably similar, and when they are not, no
systematic trend in the differences is observed.
If our interpretation is correct, the experimental preparation operates
below, and close, to an oscillatory instability; on the other hand, contrary
to NS, the appearance of avalanches does not seem to be exquisitely related
to a Hopf bifurcation, rather they seem to generically reflect the non-linear
amplification of spontaneous fluctuations around an almost unstable fixed
point -- a related point will be mentioned in the next section. We also remark
that we obtain power-law distributed avalanches in a (noisy) mean-field rate
model, by definition lacking any spatial structure; while the latter could well
determine specific (possibly repeating) patterns of activations (as observed
in [19]), it is here suggested to be not necessary for power-law distributed
avalanches.
The avalanche size distribution for the same network as in Fig. 5, panel C,
is sparser but qualitatively compatible with the distribution in Fig. 6, panel
F (see Fig. ?? - S2 Fig); in particular, the distribution shows a prominent
peak for high-size avalanches, consistently with the interpretation, given in
24
connection with Fig. 5, of high excitability.
We do not provide examples of avalanche and NS-quasi orbits size dis-
tributions in the super-critical region on the right of the Hopf bifurcation
line in Fig. 2; this is because the phenomenology in that region is relatively
stereotyped and easy to guess/understand: the high excitability of the network
generates, moving on the right of the bifurcation line, increasingly stereo-
typed network spikes, which dominate the size distribution of the network
events (see Fig. ?? - S3 Fig, panel A); even though finite-size fluctuations
blur the bifurcation line, quasi-orbits are expected to contribute very little
in the supercritical region; the distribution of avalanche sizes is increasingly
dominated by the high-size bump associated with network spikes (see Fig. ??
- S3 Fig, panel B).
Inferring the time-scales
The fatigue mechanism at work (STD in our case) is a key element of the
transient network events, in its interplay with the excitability of the system.
While the latter can be manipulated through pharmacology, STD itself (or
spike frequency adaptation, another neural fatigue mechanism) cannot be
directly modulated. It is therefore interesting to explore ways to infer relevant
properties of such fatigue mechanisms from the experimentally accessible
information, i.e. the firing activity of the network. We focus in the following
on deriving the effective (activity-dependent) time scale of STD from the
sampled firing history.
The starting point is the expectation that the fatigue level just before a
NS should affect the strength of the subsequent NS. We therefore measured
the correlation between r (fraction of available synaptic resources) and the
total number of spikes emitted during the NS (NS size) from simulations. We
found that the average value of r just before a NS is an effective predictor of
the NS size, the more so as the excitability of the network grows.
Based on the r-NS size correlation, we took the above "experimental"
point of view, that only the firing activity ν is directly observable, while r is
not experimentally accessible. Furthermore, the success of the linear analysis
for the inter-NS interval statistics (due to the NS being a low-threshold very
non-linear phenomenon), suggests that without assuming a specific form for
the dynamics of the fatigue variable f , we may tentatively adopt for it a
generic linear integrator form, of which we want to infer the characteristic
25
time-scale τ∗:
f = − f
τ∗ + ν(t)
(19)
To do this, first we reconstruct f (t) from ν(t) for a given τ∗; then we set
up an optimization procedure to estimate τ∗
optim, based on the maximization of
the (negative) f -NS size correlation (a strategy inspired by a similar principle
was adopted in [11]). Fig. 7, panel A, shows an illustrative example of how
the correlation peaks around the optimal value. As a reference, the dotted
line marks the value below which 95% of the correlations computed from
surrogate data fall; surrogate data are obtained by shuffling the values of f
at the beginning of each NS.
A
B
Figure 7. Slow time-scales inference procedure: test on simulation
data. Panel A: correlation between low-pass filtered network activity f (see
Eq. 19) and the size of the immediately subsequent network spike plotted
against the time-scale τ∗ of the low-pass integrator (continuous line). The
correlation presents a clear (negative) peak for an 'optimal' value τ∗
optim = 0.58
s of the low-pass integrator; such value is interpreted as the effective time-scale
of the putative slow self-inhibitory mechanism underlying the statistics of
network events -- in this case, short-term synaptic depression (STD); as a
reference, the dotted line marks the value computed for surrogate data (see
text). Panel B: for each point in the (wexc, winh)-plane (see Fig. 2), τ∗
optim vs
average network activity; the continuous line is the best fit of the theoretical
expectation for STD's effective time-scale (Eq. 20); the fitted values for the
STD parameters τSTD and uSTD are consistent with the actual values used in
simulation (τSTD = 0.8 s, uSTD = 0.2).
We remark that in this analysis we use both NS and quasi-orbit events
26
τ* (s)−corr 1001020.10.20.30.40.50.6τ*optim = 0.58 s<ν> (Hz)τ*optim (s) 2345670.40.50.60.7Fit: τSTD = 0.83 s, uSTD = 0.23 (which are both related to the proximity to a Hopf bifurcation). This is
reasonable since we expect to gain more information about the anti-correlation
between f and NS size by including both types of large network events.
Although the procedure successfully recovers a maximum in the correlation,
the value of τ∗
optim (0.58 s) reported in Fig. 7, panel A, is not close to the
value of τSTD (0.8 s). Yet this is expected, since in Eq. 19, τ∗ will in general
depend on τSTD and other parameters of the dynamics, but also on the
point around which the dynamics is being linearized, more precisely on
the average activity (cid:104)ν(cid:105). Specifically, when the fatigue variable follows the
Tsodyks-Markram model of STD (which of course was actually the case
in the simulations), linearizing the dynamics of r around a fixed point (cid:104)r(cid:105)
((cid:104)r(cid:105) = 1/(1 + uSTD (cid:104)ν(cid:105) τSTD)), r behaves as a simple linear integrator with a
time-constant:
optim = τSTD (cid:104)r(cid:105) =
τ∗
that depends on τSTD, uSTD, and (cid:104)ν(cid:105).
To test this relationship, we performed the optimization procedure for
each point of the excitation-inhibition plane. The optimal τ∗ values across
the excitation-inhibition plane against (cid:104)ν(cid:105) are plotted in Fig. 7, panel B
(dots). The solid line is the best fit of τSTD and uSTD from Eq. 20, which are
consistent with the actual values used in simulations.
(20)
τSTD
1 + uSTD (cid:104)ν(cid:105) τSTD
This result is suggestive of the possibility of estimating from experiments
the time-scale of an otherwise inaccessible fatigue variable, by modeling it as
a generic linear integrator, with a "state dependent" time-constant.
Fig. 8 shows the outcome of the same inference procedure for two segments
of experimental recordings. The plot in panel A is qualitatively similar to
panel A in Fig. 7: although the peak is broader and the maximum correlation
(in absolute value) is smaller, the τ∗ peak is clearly identified and statistically
significant (with respect to surrogates, dotted line), thus suggesting a dominant
time scale for the putative underlying, unobserved fatigue process. However,
Fig. 8, panel B, clearly shows two significant peaks in the correlation plot; it
would be natural to interpret this as two fatigue processes, with time scales
differing by an order of magnitude, simultaneously active in the considered
recording segment.
To test the plausibility of this interpretation, we simulated networks with
simultaneously active STD and spike-frequency adaptation (SFA, see Models
and Analysis). Fig. 9 shows the results of time scale inference for two cases
sharing the same time scale for STD (800 ms) and time scale of SFA differing
27
A
B
Figure 8. Slow time-scales inference procedure on ex-vivo data.
Correlation between low-pass filtered network activity f (see Eq. 19) and the
size of the immediately subsequent network spike plotted against the time-
scale τ∗ of the low-pass integrator for two experimental datasets (different
periods -- about 40 minutes each -- in a long recording). The plot in panel A
is qualitatively similar to the simulation result shown in panel A of Fig. 7: a
peak, although broader and of smaller maximum (absolute) value, is clearly
identified and statistically significant (with respect to surrogate data, dotted
line). Panel B shows two significant peaks in the correlation plot, a possible
signature of two concurrently active fatigue processes, with time scales differing
by roughly an order of magnitude. Panel A: same data as Fig. 5, panel B.
by a factor of 2 (τSFA = 15 and 30 s respectively). In both cases the negative
correlation peaks at around τ∗ (cid:39) 500 ms; this peak is plausibly related to
the characteristic time of STD, consistently with Fig. 7. The peaks at higher
τ∗s, found respectively at 12 and 22 s, roughly preserve the ratio of the
corresponding τSFA values.
This analysis provides preliminary support to the above interpretation
of the double peak in Fig. 8, right panel, in terms of two coexisting fatigue
processes with different time scales.
We also checked to what extent the avalanche sizes were influenced by
the immediately preceding amount of available synaptic resources r, and
we found weak or no correlations; this further supports the interpretation
offered at the end on the previous section, that avalanches are a genuine
manifestation of the network excitability which amplifies a wide spectrum of
small fluctuations.
28
τ* (s)−corr 10−21001020.10.150.20.250.30.350.4τ*optim = 0.20 sτ* (s)−corr 10−21001020.10.150.20.250.3τ*optim = 0.11 sτ*optim = 8.9 s A
B
Figure 9. Slow time-scales inference procedure on simulation data
with STD and spike-frequency adaptation. Correlation between low-
pass filtered network activity f (see Eq. 19) and the size of the immediately
subsequent network spike plotted against the time-scale τ∗ of the low-pass
integrator. In this case, the mean-field model includes, besides short-term
depression (STD), a mechanism mimicking spike-frequency adaptation. Panel
A: spike-frequency adaptation with characteristic time τSFA = 15 s. Panel B:
τSFA = 30 s. In both cases the correlation presents a STD-related peak at
around τ∗ (cid:39) 500 ms (τSTD = 800 ms), consistently with Fig. 7. The peaks at
higher τ∗s, found respectively at 11 and 18 s, roughly preserve the ratio of
the corresponding τSFA values.
Discussion
Several works recently advocated a key role of specific network connectivity
topologies in generating 'critical' neural dynamics as manifested in power-law
distributions of avalanches size and duration (see [20, 42]). Also, it has been
suggested that 'leader neurons', or selected coalitions of neurons, play a pivotal
role in the onset of network events (see e.g. [21,43 -- 45]). While a role of network
topology, or heterogeneity in neurons' excitability, is all to be expected, we
set out to investigate what repertoire of network events is accessible to
a network with the simplest, randomly sparse, connectivity, over a wide
range of excitation-inhibition balance, in the presence of STD as an activity-
dependent self-inhibition. In the present work we showed that network spikes,
avalanches and also large fluctuations we termed 'quasi-orbits' coexist in such
networks, with various relative weights and statistical features depending on
the excitation-inhibition balance, which we explored extensively, including the
29
τ* (s)−corr 10−11001011020.10.20.3τ*optim = 12 sτ*optim = 0.51 sτ* (s)−corr 10−11001011020.10.20.3τ*optim = 22 sτ*optim = 0.41 s role of finite-size noise (irregular synchronous regimes in balanced excitatory-
inhibitory networks has been studied in [35]). We remark in passing that
the occurrence of quasi-orbits is primarily related to the proximity to a Hopf
bifurcation for the firing rate dynamics; on the other hand, the occurrence of
NS and, presumably, avalanches, does not necessarily require this condition:
for instance, NS can occur in the proximity of a saddle-node bifurcation,
where the low-high-low activity transitions derive from the existence of two
fixed points, the upper one getting destabilized by the fatigue mechanism
(see e.g. [46, 47]); notably, in [12] the authors find that, in a network of leaky
integrate-and-fire neurons endowed with STD, when a saddle-node separates
an up- and a down-state, the dynamics develops avalanches during up-state
intervals only. We also remark that, with respect to the power-law distribution
of avalanches, it is now widely recognized that while criticality implies power-
law distributions, the converse is not true, which leaves open the problem of
understanding what is actually in operation in the neural systems observed
experimentally (for a general discussion on the issues involved, see [48]). In the
present work, we do not commit ourselves to the issue of whether avalanches
could be considered as evidence of Self-Organized Criticality.
In summary, the main contributions of the present work can be listed as
follows.
We present a low-dimensional network model, derived from the mean
field theory for interacting leaky integrate-and-fire neurons with short-term
depression, in which we include the effect of finite-size (multiplicative) noise.
At the methodological level we introduce a probabilistic model for events
detection, and a method for inferring the time-scale(s) of putative fatigue
mechanisms. At the phenomenological level we recognize the existence of
quasi-orbits as an additional type of network event, we show the coexistence of
quasi-orbits, network spikes, and avalanches, and study their different mixing
depending on the excitability of the network. We also offer a theoretical
interpretation of the phenomenology, through a bifurcation analysis of the
mean-field model, and a prediction on the effect of noise in the proximity of
a Hopf bifurcation.
Acknowledgments
We thank Neta Haroush and Maurizio Mattia for several stimulating discus-
sions.
30
References
1. Baltz T, Herzog A, Voigt T (2011) Slow oscillating population activity
in developing cortical networks: models and experimental results. J
Neurophysiol 106: 1500 -- 1514.
2. Eytan D, Marom S (2006) Dynamics and effective topology underly-
ing synchronization in networks of cortical neurons. The Journal of
Neuroscience 26: 8465 -- 8476.
3. Giugliano M, Darbon P, Arsiero M, Luscher HR, Streit J (2004) Single-
neuron discharge properties and network activity in dissociated cultures
of neocortex. Journal of Neurophysiology 92: 977 -- 996.
4. Gritsun T, le Feber J, Stegenga J, Rutten WL (2011) Experimental
analysis and computational modeling of interburst intervals in sponta-
neous activity of cortical neuronal culture. Biological Cybernetics 105:
197 -- 210.
5. Park IPI, Xu DXD, DeMarse TB, Principe JC (2006). Modeling of
Synchronized Burst in Dissociated Cortical Tissue: An Exploration of
Parameter Space. doi:10.1109/IJCNN.2006.246734.
6. Wagenaar DA, Pine J, Potter SM (2006) An extremely rich repertoire
of bursting patterns during the development of cortical cultures. BMC
Neurosci 7: 11.
7. Beggs JM, Plenz D (2003) Neuronal avalanches in neocortical circuits.
The Journal of Neuroscience 23: 11167 -- 11177.
8. Petermann T, Thiagarajan TC, Lebedev MA, Nicolelis MA, Chialvo
DR, et al. (2009) Spontaneous cortical activity in awake monkeys
composed of neuronal avalanches. Proceedings of the National Academy
of Sciences 106: 15921 -- 15926.
9. Plenz D, Thiagarajan TC (2007) The organizing principles of neuronal
avalanches: cell assemblies in the cortex? Trends in neurosciences 30:
101 -- 110.
10. Plenz D, Schuster HG (2014) Criticality in neural systems. Wiley-VCH
New York, NY.
31
11. Linaro D, Storace M, Mattia M (2011) Inferring network dynamics and
neuron properties from population recordings. Frontiers in Computa-
tional Neuroscience 5.
12. Millman D, Mihalas S, Kirkwood A, Niebur E (2010) Self-organized crit-
icality occurs in non-conservative neuronal networks during/up/'states.
Nature Physics 6: 801 -- 805.
13. Levina A, Herrmann JM, Geisel T (2007) Dynamical synapses causing
self-organized criticality in neural networks. Nature Physics 3: 857 -- 860.
14. Thivierge JP, Cisek P (2008) Nonperiodic synchronization in hetero-
geneous networks of spiking neurons. Journal of Neuroscience 28:
7968 -- 7978.
15. Tsodyks M, Uziel A, Markram H (2000) Synchrony generation in
recurrent networks with frequency-dependent synapses. Journal of
Neuroscience 20: RC50.
16. Vladimirski BB, Tabak J, O'Donovan MJ, Rinzel J (2008) Episodic
activity in a heterogeneous excitatory network, from spiking neurons
to mean field. Journal of Computational Neuroscience 25: 39 -- 63.
17. Benita JM, Guillamon A, Deco G, Sanchez-Vives MV (2012) Synaptic
depression and slow oscillatory activity in a biophysical network model
of the cerebral cortex. Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience 6.
18. Reig R, Gallego R, Nowak LG, Sanchez-Vives MV (2006) Impact of
cortical network activity on short-term synaptic depression. Cerebral
Cortex 16: 688 -- 695.
19. Beggs JM, Plenz D (2004) Neuronal avalanches are diverse and precise
activity patterns that are stable for many hours in cortical slice cultures.
The Journal of Neuroscience 24: 5216 -- 5229.
20. Massobrio P, Pasquale V, Martinoia S (2014) Criticality in cortical
ensembles is supported by complex functional networks. BMC Neuro-
science 15: O15.
21. Luccioli S, Ben-Jacob E, Barzilai A, Bonifazi P, Torcini A (2014) Clique
of functional hubs orchestrates population bursts in developmentally
regulated neural networks. PLoS Computational Biology 10: e1003823.
32
22. Wilson HR, Cowan JD (1972) Excitatory and inhibitory interactions in
localized populations of model neurons. Biophysical Journal 12: 1 -- 24.
23. Ricciardi LM (1977) Diffusion processes and related topics in biology .
24. Tsodyks MV, Markram H (1997) The neural code between neocortical
pyramidal neurons depends on neurotransmitter release probability.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 94: 719 -- 723.
25. Tsodyks M, Pawelzik K, Markram H (1998) Neural networks with
dynamic synapses. Neural Computation 10: 821 -- 835.
26. Wang XJ (1998) Calcium coding and adaptive temporal computation in
cortical pyramidal neurons. Journal of Neurophysiology 79: 1549 -- 1566.
27. Ermentrout B (1998) Linearization of fi curves by adaptation. Neural
Computation 10: 1721 -- 1729.
28. Baum LE, Petrie T (1966) Statistical inference for probabilistic func-
tions of finite state markov chains. The Annals of Mathematical
Statistics : 1554 -- 1563.
29. Chen Z, Vijayan S, Barbieri R, Wilson MA, Brown EN (2009) Discrete-
and continuous-time probabilistic models and algorithms for inferring
neuronal up and down states. Neural Computation 21: 1797 -- 1862.
30. Tokdar S, Xi P, Kelly RC, Kass RE (2010) Detection of bursts in ex-
tracellular spike trains using hidden semi-markov point process models.
Journal of Computational Neuroscience 29: 203 -- 212.
31. Khovanov I, Schimansky-Geier L, Zaks M (2006) Spectral analysis of
noisy oscillators near hopf bifurcations. Acta Physica Polonica Series
B 37: 1551.
32. van Pelt J, Vajda I, Wolters PS, Corner MA, Ramakers GJ (2005)
Dynamics and plasticity in developing neuronal networks in vitro.
Progress in Brain Research 147: 171 -- 188.
33. Wagenaar DA, Nadasdy Z, Potter SM (2006) Persistent dynamic at-
tractors in activity patterns of cultured neuronal networks. Physical
Review E 73: 051907.
33
34. Gal A, Eytan D, Wallach A, Sandler M, Schiller J, et al. (2010) Dynam-
ics of excitability over extended timescales in cultured cortical neurons.
The Journal of Neuroscience 30: 16332 -- 16342.
35. Benayoun M, Cowan JD, van Drongelen W, Wallace E (2010)
Avalanches in a stochastic model of spiking neurons. PLoS Com-
putational Biology 6: e1000846.
36. Poil SS, Hardstone R, Mansvelder HD, Linkenkaer-Hansen K (2012)
Critical-state dynamics of avalanches and oscillations jointly emerge
from balanced excitation/inhibition in neuronal networks. The Journal
of Neuroscience 32: 9817 -- 9823.
37. Priesemann V, Wibral M, Valderrama M, Propper R, Le Van Quyen
M, et al. (2014) Spike avalanches in vivo suggest a driven, slightly
subcritical brain state. Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience 8: 108.
38. Clauset A, Shalizi CR, Newman ME (2009) Power-law distributions in
empirical data. SIAM Review 51: 661 -- 703.
39. Mazzoni A, Broccard FD, Garcia-Perez E, Bonifazi P, Ruaro ME,
et al. (2007) On the dynamics of the spontaneous activity in neuronal
networks. PLoS One 2: e439.
40. Levina A, Herrmann JM, Geisel T (2009) Phase transitions towards
criticality in a neural system with adaptive interactions. Physical
Review Letters 102: 118110.
41. Haroush N, Marom S (2015) Slow dynamics in features of synchronized
neural network responses. Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience 9:
40.
42. Friedman EJ, Landsberg AS (2013) Hierarchical networks, power laws,
and neuronal avalanches. Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of
Nonlinear Science 23: 013135.
43. Eckmann JP, Jacobi S, Marom S, Moses E, Zbinden C (2008) Leader
neurons in population bursts of 2d living neural networks. New Journal
of Physics 10: 015011.
34
44. Shein M, Volman V, Raichman N, Hanein Y, Ben-Jacob E (2008)
Management of synchronized network activity by highly active neurons.
Physical Biology 5: 036008.
45. Pirino V, Riccomagno E, Martinoia S, Massobrio P (2014) A topological
study of repetitive co-activation networks in in vitro cortical assemblies.
Physical Biology 12: 016007 -- 016007.
46. Gigante G, Mattia M, Del Giudice P (2007) Diverse population-bursting
modes of adapting spiking neurons. Physical Review Letters 98:
148101.
47. Mejias JF, Kappen HJ, Torres JJ (2010) Irregular dynamics in up and
down cortical states. PLoS One 5: e13651.
48. Beggs JM, Timme N (2012) Being critical of criticality in the brain.
Frontiers in Physiology 3.
35
|
1312.1876 | 1 | 1312 | 2013-12-06T14:55:53 | Identifying Combinatorial Biomarkers by Association Rule Mining in the CAMD Alzheimer's Database | [
"q-bio.NC",
"stat.AP"
] | Background: The concept of combinatorial biomarkers was conceived around 2010: it was noticed that simple biomarkers are often inadequate for recognizing and characterizing complex diseases.
Methods: Here we present an algorithmic search method for complex biomarkers which may predict or indicate Alzheimer's disease (AD) and other kinds of dementia. We applied data mining techniques that are capable to uncover implication-like logical schemes with detailed quality scoring. Our program SCARF is capable of finding multi-factor relevant association rules automatically. The new SCARF program was applied for the Tucson, Arizona based Critical Path Institute's CAMD database, containing laboratory and cognitive test data for more than 6000 patients from the placebo arm of clinical trials of large pharmaceutical companies, and consequently, the data is much more reliable than numerous other databases for dementia.
Results: The results suggest connections between liver enzyme-, B12 vitamin-, sodium- and cholesterol levels and dementia, and also some hematologic parameter-levels and dementia. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Identifying Combinatorial Biomarkers by Association
Rule Mining in the CAMD Alzheimer's Database
Bal´azs Szalkaia, Vince K. Grolmuszc, Vince I. Grolmusza,b,∗, Coalition
Against Major Diseases∗∗
aProtein Information Technology Group, Eotvos University, H-1117 Budapest, Hungary
bUratim Ltd., H-1118 Budapest, Hungary
c2nd Department of Internal Medicine, Semmelweis University, Budapest, Hungary.
Abstract
Background: The concept of combinatorial biomarkers was conceived
around 2010:
it was noticed that simple biomarkers are often inadequate
for recognizing and characterizing complex diseases.
Methods: Here we present an algorithmic search method for complex
biomarkers which may predict or indicate Alzheimer's disease (AD) and other
kinds of dementia. We applied data mining techniques that are capable to
uncover implication-like logical schemes with detailed quality scoring. Our
program SCARF is capable of finding multi-factor relevant association rules
automatically. The new SCARF program was applied for the Tucson, Ari-
zona based Critical Path Institute's CAMD database, containing laboratory
and cognitive test data for more than 6000 patients from the placebo arm of
clinical trials of large pharmaceutical companies, and consequently, the data
is much more reliable than numerous other databases for dementia.
Results: The results suggest connections between liver enzyme-, B12 vita-
min -, sodium- and cholesterol levels and dementia, and also some hemato-
logic parameter-levels and dementia.
1
1. Introduction
Dementia is a major problem presently of high-income countries and also
an increasing concern of low-income nations worldwide. Though sporadic
before the age of 60, its occurrence is doubled by every five years of age
thereafter (Bermejo-Pareja et al., 2008; Carlo et al., 2002). About 40 percent
of the population over 90 are affected, and up to 20 percent of those between
75 and 84 suffer from this condition (Wortmann, 2012; Prince and Jackson,
2009). The most common cause of dementia is Alzheimer's disease (AD).
The earliest symptoms of AD include memory problems; disorientation in
time and space; and difficulty with calculation, language, concentration and
judgment. As the disease evolves, patients may develop severe behavioral
abnormalities and may even become psychotic.
In the final stages of the
disease the sufferers are incapable of self-care and become bed-bound, for
years or even decades.
The diagnosis of AD in the great majority of the cases is done by clinical
criteria, using standardized questionnaires (Mossello et al., 2010). Generally
accepted evidences show that neuropathological damage begins more than
20 years before those clinical signs (Jack et al., 2009), and by the time it is
diagnosed, a large part of the neurons are already irreversibly lost.
In the last years, by the combination of cerebrospinal fluid analysis, clin-
ical signs and neuroimaging techniques a quite reliable diagnostic method
emerged (Dubois et al., 2007). The method, however, is prohibitively ex-
pensive, is not an early warning-type biomarker, and does not seem to be
applicable for wide-scale screening of the senior population.
Very recently, using the combination of usual clinical laboratory data, cog-
nitive impairment questionnaires and blood-based proteomics assays was re-
ported to reliably diagnose AD, without neuroimaging or cerebrospinal fluid
assays (O'Bryant et al., 2010, 2011). However, early warning biomarkers are
still need to be found.
∗Corresponding author
∗∗Data used in the preparation of this article were obtained from the Coalition Against
Major Diseases database (CAMD). As such, the investigators within CAMD contributed
to the design and implementation of the CAMD database and/or provided data, but did
not participate in the analysis of the data or the writing of this report.
2
The final goal of ours is finding new combinatorial biomarkers for Alzheimer's
disease. In this paper we report our results that may be used to reach this
final goal; but presently we are able to show only that certain sets of labo-
ratory data may make dementia (and not AD) more probable, and certain
other sets may make dementia less probable.
There are several large databases on Alzheimer's disease available for re-
searchers. The quality of their data obviously depends on the methodology
of the research that produced the database in question. The most well-
organized, strictly overseen and rigorously documented experiments are per-
haps conducted by the order of large pharmaceutical companies in hospitals
and clinics in phase 1, 2 and 3 drug trials. Unfortunately, the detailed re-
sults of those trials are seldom published (especially those corresponding to
unsuccessful drug trials) since they are owned by the companies that ordered
the trials.
In their Alzheimer's disease database the Tucson, Arizona based Critical Path
Institute made available the results of the placebo arm of numerous multi-
million dollar clinical trials conducted by the order of large pharmacological
companies (Romero et al., 2009, 2010; Rogers et al., 2012). The data of the
placebo line of the trials does not contain proprietary information concerning
the effects of the novel drugs under trial, but it does contain reliable, well-
organized laboratory and cognitive test-data, presumably in much higher
quality than other, larger, but perhaps less strictly conducted and controlled
studies for AD.
Data used in the preparation of this article have been obtained from the
Coalition Against Major Diseases (CAMD) database (Romero et al., 2009).
In 2008, Critical Path Institute, in collaboration with the Engelberg Cen-
ter for Health Care Reform at the Brookings Institution, formed the Coali-
tion Against Major Diseases (CAMD). The Coalition brings together pa-
tient groups, biopharmaceutical companies, and scientists from academia,
the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the European Medicines
Agency (EMA), the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke
(NINDS), and the National Institute on Aging (NIA). Coalition Against Ma-
jor Diseases (CAMD) includes over 200 scientists from member and non-
member organizations. The data available in the CAMD database have been
volunteered by both CAMD member companies and non-member organiza-
tions.
3
In contrast with more conservative statistical methods, we applied data min-
ing techniques for data analysis and combinatorial biomarker search. Data
mining, as defined in (Hand et al., 2001), is the analysis of large observational
sets of data for finding new, still unsuspected relations with novel, usually
high-throughput methods. Frequently, data mining uses large data sets orig-
inally collected for uses other than the data mining analysis (Hand et al.,
2001).
Simple biomarkers (e.g., the high level of glucose in diabetes) show a physi-
ological condition, related to the appearance or the status of a disease. The
concept of combinatorial biomarkers appeared around 2010, and numerous
authors simply use the term in the following sense: If -- say -- the high con-
centration of all the molecules A, B and C characterizes a certain condition
X well (and the high concentration of any subset of the set {A, B, C} would
not), then they say that {A, B, C} is a combinatorial biomarker of the condi-
tion X (Wu et al., 2012). In (O'Bryant et al., 2011), by applying proteomics
assays, a 30-protein set was identified as a combinatorial biomarker of AD.
We intend to discover more involved combinatorial biomarkers that may con-
tain clinical laboratory data and psychiatric test data, and we count not only
on positive findings (i.e., high concentration or appearance of a certain value),
but also the lack thereof (i.e., normal or low concentration). We start with
frequent item set analysis, then apply association rule mining (Hand et al.,
2001). We apply a new methodology that discovers complex combinatorial
biomarkers only if these complex biomarkers have stronger implications than
the simpler biomarkers.
Therefore, our program SCARF will not produce artificially complex
biomarkers: the more complex the new biomarker, the more valid the new
implication.
1.1. Association Rule Mining
Our research group was among the first applying association rule mining in
molecular biology (Ivan et al., 2007). Recently, association rule mining has
been gaining applications in drug discovery (Galustian and Dalgleish, 2010),
in the design of clinical trials (Epstein, 2009), and most recently, also in
image analysis in Alzheimer's research (Chaves et al., 2011).
4
Association rule mining is a field of data mining (Hand et al., 2001) developed
by marketing experts for discovering implication-like rules in uncovering cus-
tomer behavior (Agrawal et al., 1993), without a priori assumptions on this
behaviour. We intended to apply this method for laboratory and cognitive
test data from the CAMD database (Romero et al., 2009).
We analyzed how the presence/absence/severity of cognitive impairment
could be detected from combinations of known biomarkers, demographic in-
formation and measurements of vital signs. As an example, consider this
expression:
sodium = high & (protein = high or age ≥ 60) → mmse total ≤ 15 (1)
Here & stands for logical AND. This rule states that if blood sodium is high,
AND urine protein is high OR age is at least 60, then the total MMSE (Mini
Mental State Examination) score will be at most 15 out of 30. Let us call the
left-hand side of the expression (abbreviated by LHS) a combinatorial marker
of the right-hand side (abbreviated by RHS). Thus the statement above can
be reformulated as follows: high serum sodium combined with either high
urine protein or age of at least 60 is a marker of a total MMSE score less
than or equal to 15.
An expression consists of elementary clauses combined by logical operators.
These elementary clauses may include equalities and inequalities. By substi-
tuting all elementary clauses with some wildcard, we can obtain the pattern of
an expression. For example, the expression above is of the following pattern:
(cid:3) & ((cid:3) or (cid:3)) → (cid:3)
(2)
During our analysis we started with a given pattern like the one above. Then
we considered all the possible logical expressions according to this pattern,
and assigned numerical values to them that indicated the reliability and
validity of the logical rules. Then we filtered and sorted the vast amount
of possible rules according to these numerical criteria, and selected the best
ones. We changed a simpler rule to a more complex rule only if the more
complex rule had higher reliability/validity than the simpler rule (see the
5
next section for the exact definitions).
2. Materials and Methods
Our data source, which will be referred to as CAMD from now on
(Romero et al., 2009), was provided by the Coalition Against Major Dis-
eases, and consisted of the placebo arm of several drug trials. Over 6000
subjects participated in these trials including demented and not demented
people of various age and sex (see Table 1) for basic statistics). Standard
laboratory data that have been collected for the subjects included about
300 different values in blood or urine altogether. These values were gener-
ally measured multiple times per subject (on different visit days), though
each person was tested for only about 30 different values. The cognitive and
psychological status of the subjects was measured at different times by stan-
dardized questionnaires ADAS-COG, ADCS-ADL, MMSE, NPI and SIB. In
addition, some genetic tests have been performed, e.g., ApoE and MTHFR
genotypes were recorded. Vital sign measurements (BP, pulse rate, respira-
tory rate and body temperature) have also been taken. Results concerning
this dataset will be described in greater detail below.
We transformed this large dataset into a conveniently processable form. The
CAMD database contained several rows describing one person and these were
scattered between multiple data tables. So we collected the essential data
from CAMD into one single table: this simplified table contained only one
row for each subject.
If a subject was tested on different visit days, then we took the average of
these test results. The resulting main table for CAMD consisted of around
170 columns (record fields) and 6000 rows (entries).
Our main method of processing the resulting table was association rule min-
ing. First, we took a given pattern like (cid:3) & ((cid:3) or (cid:3)) → (cid:3). Notice that
the LHS (Left Hand Side) is in conjunctive normal form here (multiple OR
clauses ANDed together). This pattern can be encoded as "1 2", as the first
OR clause has one sub-clause and the second one has two. This pattern
matches all statements of the following kind: "if property A is present and
property B or property C is present, then property D is present".
6
Since we are interested in implication-like association rules that indicate fac-
tors implying normal or demented mental state, we made restrictions on
which data columns can occur on the LHS (Left Hand Side) and the RHS
(Right Hand Side). Laboratory data and sex were allowed on the LHS, and
columns directly indicating mental status on the RHS. Then we gave numer-
ical constraints on the "goodness" of a rule -- thus introducing an ordering on
the rules. Finally we tried to fill in all the void boxes in all possible ways to
find the best rules.
If done without any optimization, this process would have yielded a vast
amount of different rules that would have needed to be evaluated "by hand".
Even just enumerating all the possible matches to this pattern would have
required enormous computational resources. Consequently, we needed to
make the computation feasible: we used a branch-and-bound approach similar
to the Apriori Algorithm (Hand et al., 2001): if certain values for the first two
boxes made a rule fail our constraints -- regardless of what would be written
in the third box -- , then we threw out the rule and did not bother checking
all the possible values for the third box. (A good analogue would be cutting
a tree in a clever way: one does not bother removing all the little twigs one
by one, but rather cuts the trunk.) This technique saved us considerable
computational time, and made possible this study.
The association rule mining was done with our own program written in the
C++ programming language, named SCARF (Simple Combinatorial Asso-
ciation Rule Finder). We calculated various standard numerical values for
all association rules, which would indicate their validity. First, we defined
the universe of a rule: this is the set of the database rows where all columns
present in the rule have a known value. As we mentioned before, not all sub-
jects were tested for everything, so our database contained a large amount
of N/A entries. For testing the validity of a rule, only those rows could be
taken into account, where there is no N/A written to any of the columns
participating in the rule.
For evaluating the validity of a rule, we continued to work with only its
universe and temporarily discarded all other rows in the database. Next, we
calculated the LHS support, RHS support and support of a rule. The LHS
support is the number of the rows where the LHS is true, the RHS support is
the number of the rows where the RHS is true, and the support is the number
of the rows where both the LHS and the RHS are true.
7
Then, we calculated the confidence, lift, leverage and χ2-statistic for a rule.
The confidence is defined as the conditional probability of the RHS, assuming
that the LHS is true.
If one has high serum sodium combined with high
urine protein or age at least 60 in our example, then confidence describes the
chance of having a low MMSE score. The lift shows how many times the
presence of the LHS increases the probability of RHS. Generally it indicates
how big a risk factor the LHS is -- though it is not certain that the LHS
causes the RHS, as they both may be only consequences of some background
phenomenon (Hand et al., 2001).
The leverage is the difference between the observed probability of both the
LHS and RHS being true, and the estimated probability we get by assuming
that the LHS and RHS are independent events. It indicates the level of de-
pendency between the LHS and the RHS in a way. Finally, the χ2-statistic is
a well-known measure of the estimated dependence of the indicator variables
of the LHS and RHS. The p-value output by SCARF comes from this χ2 test.
The E-value (also calculated by SCARF) equals to the p-value multiplied by
the total number of possible rules. The E-value is a more useful measure of
randomness, since if we examine many rules, there is a high probability that
the p-value will be small enough, while the E-value is insensitive for this kind
of artifact.
The following table formalizes some of the above definitions. Here P denotes
the probability measure, and P (AB) denotes the conditional probability of
event A on condition B:
Confidence = P (RHSLHS)
Lift =
P (RHSLHS)
P (RHS)
Leverage = P (RHS ∧ LHS) − P (RHS)P (LHS)
For the CAMD database the acceptable values were set as follows: universe ≥
500, support ≥ 50, confidence ≥ 0.5, lift ≥ 1.2, p − value ≤ 0.05. In partic-
ular, we recorded rules on data that were measured on at least 500 subjects.
8
We defined the goodness of a rule to be equal to its lift.
Therefore we listed association rules of lift at least 1.2, i.e., only those rules
were listed where the LHS increased the probability of RHS with at least
20%.
One of the most significant novelties in our approach was filtering out those
rules which were too complicated. The SCARF program threw out elemen-
tary clauses from the LHS as long as the overall goodness (i.e. the lift) of
the rule did not decrease by more than 2%. Then it deleted the whole rule if
its numerical values dropped below our constraints during the simplification
process. In other words, we sacrificed some of the lift for simplicity, to avoid
overfitting.
Having listed the best rules, we also tried to determine whether the elemen-
tary clauses (like lb ast = h, lb f olate = l, etc.) have positive or negative
effect on mental state. Therefore we counted their appearances on LHS, and
classified these occurrences by the nature of the RHS: does it indicate normal
cognition or rather dementia? We counted how many times an elementary
clause occurred on the LHS of a rule when the RHS indicated a positive men-
tal state, and how many times it occurred in rules where the RHS showed a
negative state. Thus, in addition to mining rules whose LHS could probably
serve as good combinatorial risk factor of dementia, we estimated the contri-
bution of the individual clauses, for example "protein=high" to the onset of
cognitive impairment.
For an elementary clause, Positive score was the number of rules with positive
RHS, and Negative score was the number of rules with negative RHS. Then
we compared Positive score with Negative score : by subtracting the negative
score from the positive score we got a value called simply the score of the
clause. Those elementary clauses whose score was positive were called positive
clauses, and similarly, those where the score was negative were called negative
clauses.
To summarize our method: we searched for combinatorial biomarkers us-
ing a branch-and-bound algorithm for association rule mining; then made
statistical analysis regarding elementary clauses.
9
3. Results
The program outputs 725 rules from the CAMD database. Selected rules,
ordered by lift (i.e. "goodness") decreasing are listed in Table 2. The whole
set of rules is presented as Table S1 of the online supporting material.
On the LHS, clauses concerning biomarkers end in "=l", "=h", "=n", or com-
binations of these. Here l means low, h means high and n means normal.
If there are multiple letters (such as nh), then the corresponding equality
states that the value is either high or normal. In other words, single letters
correspond to a value category, while multiple letters mean the union of these
categories.
For example, the second rule in Table 2 was that of the second best lift. It
can be interpreted in the following way: It is likely that if serum sodium level
is elevated, and serum glucose level is either too low or normal, then the total
MMSE score will be less than 15. Note that it is true for all rules of ours
that there is not necessarily a causal relation between the LHS and RHS, as
both the LHS and RHS can be consequences of an unknown process in the
background.
The third rule states that "if serum sodium level is elevated, and calcium level
is either low or normal, then MMSE orientation subscore will be at most 2".
The seventh rule in Table 2 states that "if serum sodium level is elevated,
and body temperature is too low, then total MMSE score will be less than
15".
From these selected rules we can conclude that elevated sodium combined
with various other factors (not too high glucose, not too high calcium, low
temperature) might be a good indicator (or even the cause) of mental decline.
Elementary clauses with the greatest positive effect on normal cognition are
listed in Table 5.
Elementary clauses with the greatest negative effect on normal cognition are
listed Table 6.
10
4. Discussion
Among the 725 rules identified, 513 had lift values exceeding 2.00. Most of
the rules exceeding even the 3.00 lift value had one thing in common: the
LHS contained the premise lb sodium = h.
4.1. Liver function
The rules found suggest that having high serum levels of AST (aspartate
aminotransferase), as well as having low or high serum levels of ALT (ala-
nine aminotransferase) may predispose to an impaired cognition character-
ized by low mini mental state examination (MMSE) scores.
It should be
noted that low ALT was much more rare in the CAMD database than high
ALT, so the negative effect should be attributed mainly to high ALT. How-
ever, serum ALP (alkaline phosphatase) levels seem to have a controversial
effect on mental status.
AST, ALT and ALP levels derive from the liver. Elevated ALP might indicate
bile duct obstruction. AST or ALT may elevate in a number of cases of liver
injury or damage, spreading from acute or chronic viral infections to alcohol
induced or non-alcoholic steatohepatitis. It is interesting to note that elevated
serum levels of AST (more than those of ALT) have been associated with
impaired mental status. Although mild elevations in serum levels of AST
and ALT are nonspecific to the etiology of liver injury, certain alteration
patterns in these parameters may reflect the nature of the hepatic disease.
For instance, the value of the AST/ALT ratio -- also known as the De Ritis
ratio -- is approximately 0.8 in normal subjects, a ratio exceeding 2.00 being
suggestive to alcoholic hepatitis.
Therefore we scanned the subjects with high AST values for higher than 2
AST/ALT ratio: we have only found 10 subjects satisfying both conditions.
In addition, only 2 rules had AST/ALT on the left-hand side. Consequently,
we may assume that high serum AST in the study subjects is not typically
accompanied with high De Ritis ratio (i.e. probable alcoholic hepatitis).
The association of impaired liver function with mental decline can be illu-
minated in two perspectives. On one hand, impaired liver function might
be insufficient to prevent the brain from the effects of certain neurotoxins,
e.g. ammonia. This happens in the case of hepatic encephalopathy (HE),
11
when severe liver damage resulting in acute liver insufficiency cannot detox-
ificate ammonia and other neurotoxins. On the other hand, the association
of elevated AST/ALT ratio with impaired mental status proposes that an-
other obscure element (e.g. chronic alcohol consumption) might be the factor
responsible for both cognitive and metabolic damages.
Our results raise the possibility of a pathogenetic linkage between liver func-
tion and mental status in patients with AD. Such linkage has also been
proposed by other studies (Sutcliffe et al., 2011; Astarita et al., 2010). One
study concludes that peripheral reduction of β-amyloid is sufficient to reduce
brain β-amyloid and proposes that β-amyloids, which are of major pathogenic
importance in AD may originate from the liver (Sutcliffe et al., 2011). An-
other research found that deficient liver production of docosahexaenoic acid
(a neuroprotective fatty acid) correlates with impaired cognitive status in
AD patients (Astarita et al., 2010).
To rule out the possibility when the elevated AST level is due to some med-
ications taken, we compiled a detailed Table S3 (in the supporting on-line
material) containing the number of subjects taking certain drugs, and the
number of drug-takers with high AST. The data shows that, for example,
1929 subjects took Donepezil, while among the Donepezil-takers, only 415
have had high AST levels.
4.2. Serum sodium
A great number of rules (224) have high sodium on the left hand side, all
of which have impaired cognition on the right hand side. Net water loss is
responsible for the majority of cases of hypernatremia (Adrogue and Madias,
2000). A recent publication, examining the causes and comorbidities in
patients older than 65 years, has found that the most common cause of
community-acquired hypernatremia is dehydration due to reduced oral in-
take (Turgutalp et al., 2012). More interestingly, they found that the most
common comorbidity in this patient group was AD, present in 31.4% of pa-
tients with hypernatremia (Turgutalp et al., 2012). Hydration status has a
significant impact on the volume of grey and white matter in the brain and
on the quantity of cerebrospinal fluid as a hallmark of ventricular enlarge-
ment (Streitbuerger et al., 2012). The pattern of shrinkage in white matter
volume and increase of the ventricular system due to dehydration is consis-
tent with the structural brain changes observed during the progression of
12
AD (Streitbuerger et al., 2012). In another study, patients with AD under-
went bioelectrical impedance vector analysis to assess the body cell mass and
hydration status related to AD (Buffa et al., 2010). Results demonstrated
a tendency towards dehydration in patients with AD (Buffa et al., 2010).
Although the association of dehydration and AD is supported by these pub-
lications, the specific pathogenic nature of this association remains obscure
(Turgutalp et al., 2012; Streitbuerger et al., 2012; Buffa et al., 2010).
4.3. Vitamin B12
Our results were able to present the beneficial impact of high levels of vita-
min B12, also known as cobalamin, on cognition. Along with folate, vitamin
B12 has an important role in the maintenance of genome integrity (Fenech,
2012). Although previous publications found association of low serum levels
of vitamin B12 and AD (Malaguarnera et al., 2004; McCaddon et al., 2004),
a recent systemic review on vitamin B12 status and cognitive impairment
fails to declare a clear association between vitamin B12 status and dementia
(O'Leary et al., 2012). However, this review also found that studies using
newer and more specific biomarkers of vitamin B12 status such as methyl-
malonic acid and holotranscobalamin were able to draw an association be-
tween mental decline and poor vitamin B12 status (O'Leary et al., 2012).
Although clinically vitamin B12 deficiency may result in macrocytic anaemia,
in the case of AD patients the occurrence of macrocytic anaemia is rare and
the neurological and hematological features are unrelated (McCaddon et al.,
2004).
4.4. Hematological parameters
Additional interesting rules were detected regarding hematological param-
eters.
In particular, independently from each other, high values of mean
corpuscular hemoglobin (MCH), low values of mean corpuscular hemoglobin
concentration (MCHC), and low values of mean corpuscular volume (MCV)
were also associated with high MMSE scores. Although high values of MCH
and low values of MCHC are present in the case of macrocyctic anaemia
(with the addition of high levels of mean corpuscular volume, low levels of
hemoglobin and hematocrit), such solely associations should not be discussed,
as they may be coincidental.
13
Among the rules with lift values exceeding 2.00, other parameters of hemato-
logical status (such as level of hemoglobin, red blood cell number, white blood
cell number) were also present. Monocyte and eosinophil levels also appear
on the left hand side of many rules with high lift. These premises appear in
combinations with various other (mostly non-hematological) premises.
4.5. Blood cholesterol and cognition
The positive or negative effects of high cholesterol values to Alzheimer's dis-
ease and cognition is a controversial issue. Some studies (e.g., (Helzner et al.,
2009; Whitmer et al., 2005; Zambon et al., 2010)) show negative effects of
high cholesterol value for cognition, while other studies ((Reitz et al., 2004,
2005; Mielke et al., 2005)) prove the positive effects for cognition.
Our data supports both conclusions in a sense. That is, low, low-normal and
high cholesterol levels are all associated with impaired mental status, but
with a different extent (scores -21, -13 and -42, respectively). See Table 5 for
a selection of cholesterol-related rules from the larger Table S1 in the on-line
supporting material.
It is worth to note that, by Table 5, elevated, low or low-normal cholesterol
levels do not necessarily mean a higher likelihood of impaired cognition by
themselves, but only combined with high sodium.
A most recent study (Pierrot et al., 2013) shows that the neuronal expression
of amyloid precursor protein APP controls the cholesterol 24-hydroxylase
mRNA levels and decreases cholesterol turnover; therefore in certain setups,
the presence of amyloid precursor proteins imply lowered cholesterol levels.
5. Conclusions
A 6000-patient, high-quality database was analyzed with original methods
for biomarkers of dementia. We have found some novel and also some al-
ready well established relations connected to good or bad cognition in a 6000
patient database. The already established findings prove the validity of our
datamining approach, and the new findings, related to MCH, ALP and AST
levels prove its power. Some more controversial biomarkers, including choles-
terol level, were also re-discovered, and we found that the high cholesterol
levels seem to be beneficial only with combination with old age.
14
References
References
Adrogue, H. J. and Madias, N. E. (2000). Hypernatremia. N Engl J Med ,
342(20), 1493 -- 1499.
Agrawal, R., Imielinski, T., and Swami, A. N. (1993). Mining association
rules between sets of items in large databases. In P. Buneman and S. Jajo-
dia, editors, Proceedings of the 1993 ACM SIGMOD International Confer-
ence on Management of Data, Washington, D.C., May 26-28, 1993 , pages
207 -- 216. ACM Press.
Astarita, G., Jung, K.-M., Berchtold, N. C., Nguyen, V. Q., Gillen, D. L.,
Head, E., Cotman, C. W., and Piomelli, D. (2010). Deficient liver biosyn-
thesis of docosahexaenoic acid correlates with cognitive impairment in
Alzheimer's disease. PLoS One, 5(9), e12538.
Bermejo-Pareja, F., Benito-Leon, J., Vega, S., Medrano, M. J., Roman, G. C.,
and in Central Spain (NEDICES) Study Group, N. D. (2008). Incidence
and subtypes of dementia in three elderly populations of central spain. J
Neurol Sci , 264(1-2), 63 -- 72.
Buffa, R., Mereu, R. M., Putzu, P. F., Floris, G., and Marini, E. (2010).
Bioelectrical impedance vector analysis detects low body cell mass and
dehydration in patients with Alzheimer's disease. J Nutr Health Aging,
14(10), 823 -- 827.
Carlo, A. D., Baldereschi, M., Amaducci, L., Lepore, V., Bracco, L., Maggi,
S., Bonaiuto, S., Perissinotto, E., Scarlato, G., Farchi, G., Inzitari, D., and
Group, I. L. S. A. W. (2002). Incidence of dementia, Alzheimer's disease,
and vascular dementia in italy. the ilsa study. J Am Geriatr Soc, 50(1),
41 -- 48.
Chaves, R., Gorriz, J. M., Ramirez, J., Illan, I. A., Salas-Gonzalez, D., and
Gomez-Rio, M. (2011). Efficient mining of association rules for the early
diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease. Phys Med Biol , 56(18), 6047 -- 6063.
Dubois, B., Feldman, H. H., Jacova, C., Dekosky, S. T., Barberger-Gateau,
P., Cummings, J., Delacourte, A., Galasko, D., Gauthier, S., Jicha, G.,
15
Meguro, K., O'brien, J., Pasquier, F., Robert, P., Rossor, M., Salloway, S.,
Stern, Y., Visser, P. J., and Scheltens, P. (2007). Research criteria for the
diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease: revising the NINCDS-ADRDA criteria.
Lancet Neurol , 6(8), 734 -- 746.
Epstein, R. J. (2009). Unblocking blockbusters: using boolean text-mining
to optimise clinical trial design and timeline for novel anticancer drugs.
Cancer Inform, 7, 231 -- 238.
Fenech, M. (2012). Folate (vitamin b9) and vitamin b12 and their function
in the maintenance of nuclear and mitochondrial genome integrity. Mutat
Res, 733(1-2), 21 -- 33.
Galustian, C. and Dalgleish, A. G. (2010). The power of the web in cancer
drug discovery and clinical trial design: research without a laboratory?
Cancer Inform, 9, 31 -- 35.
Hand, D. J., Mannila, H., and Smyth, P. (2001). Principles of Data Mining.
MIT Press.
Helzner, E. P., Luchsinger, J. A., Scarmeas, N., Cosentino, S., Brickman,
A. M., Glymour, M. M., and Stern, Y. (2009). Contribution of vascular
risk factors to the progression in alzheimer disease. Arch Neurol , 66(3),
343 -- 348.
Ivan, G., Szabadka, Z., and Grolmusz, V. (2007). Being a binding site: Char-
acterizing residue composition of binding sites on proteins. Bioinformation,
2(5), 216 -- 221.
Jack, C. R., Lowe, V. J., Weigand, S. D., Wiste, H. J., Senjem, M. L.,
Knopman, D. S., Shiung, M. M., Gunter, J. L., Boeve, B. F., Kemp, B. J.,
Weiner, M., Petersen, R. C., and Initiative, A. D. N. (2009). Serial PIB
and MRI in normal, mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimer's disease:
implications for sequence of pathological events in Alzheimer's disease.
Brain, 132(Pt 5), 1355 -- 1365.
Malaguarnera, M., Ferri, R., Bella, R., Alagona, G., Carnemolla, A., and
Pennisi, G. (2004). Homocysteine, vitamin b12 and folate in vascular
dementia and in Alzheimer's disease. Clin Chem Lab Med , 42(9), 1032 --
1035.
16
McCaddon, A., Tandy, S., Hudson, P., Gray, R., Davies, G., Hill, D., and
Duguid, J. (2004). Absence of macrocytic anaemia in Alzheimer's disease.
Clin Lab Haematol , 26(4), 259 -- 263.
Mielke, M. M., Zandi, P. P., Sj A?gren, M., Gustafson, D., Ostling, S., Steen,
B., and Skoog, I. (2005). High total cholesterol levels in late life associated
with a reduced risk of dementia. Neurology, 64(10), 1689 -- 1695.
Mossello, E., Ballini, E., Mello, A. M., Tarantini, F., Simoni, D., Bal-
dasseroni, S., and Marchionni, N. (2010). Biomarkers of Alzheimer's dis-
ease:
Int J Alzheimers Dis,
2011, 342980.
from central nervous system to periphery?
O'Bryant, S. E., Xiao, G., Barber, R., Reisch, J., Doody, R., Fairchild, T.,
Adams, P., Waring, S., Diaz-Arrastia, R., and Consortium, T. A. R. (2010).
A serum protein-based algorithm for the detection of Alzheimer disease.
Arch Neurol , 67(9), 1077 -- 1081.
O'Bryant, S. E., Xiao, G., Barber, R., Reisch, J., Hall, J., Cullum, C. M.,
Doody, R., Fairchild, T., Adams, P., Wilhelmsen, K., Diaz-Arrastia, R.,
Research, T. A., and Consortium, C. (2011). A blood-based algorithm for
the detection of Alzheimer's disease. Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord , 32(1),
55 -- 62.
O'Leary, F., Allman-Farinelli, M., and Samman, S. (2012). Vitamin b12
status, cognitive decline and dementia: a systematic review of prospective
cohort studies. Br J Nutr , 108(11), 1948 -- 1961.
Pierrot, N., D., T., L., D., I., D., P., G., A., H., B., T., LE., H., N., M.,
F., N., A., L., JB., D., D., C., JP., B., PJ., C., P, K.-C., and JN., O.
(2013). Amyloid precursor protein controls cholesterol turnover needed for
neuronal activity. EMBO Mol Med , 5, 608 -- .
Prince, M. and Jackson, J. (2009). World Alzheimer Report 2009. Technical
report, Alzheimer's Disease International.
Reitz, C., Tang, M.-X., Luchsinger, J., and Mayeux, R. (2004). Relation of
plasma lipids to alzheimer disease and vascular dementia. Arch Neurol ,
61(5), 705 -- 714.
17
Reitz, C., Luchsinger, J., Tang, M.-X., Manly, J., and Mayeux, R. (2005). Im-
pact of plasma lipids and time on memory performance in healthy elderly
without dementia. Neurology, 64(8), 1378 -- 1383.
Rogers, J. A., Polhamus, D., Gillespie, W. R., Ito, K., Romero, K., Qiu, R.,
Stephenson, D., Gastonguay, M. R., and Corrigan, B. (2012). Combining
patient-level and summary-level data for alzheimer's disease modeling and
simulation: a beta regression meta-analysis. J Pharmacokinet Pharmaco-
dyn, 39(5), 479 -- 498.
Romero, K., de Mars, M., Frank, D., Anthony, M., Neville, J., Kirby, L.,
Smith, K., and Woosley, R. L. (2009). The coalition against major diseases:
developing tools for an integrated drug development process for alzheimer's
and parkinson's diseases. Clin Pharmacol Ther , 86(4), 365 -- 367.
Romero, K., Corrigan, B., Tornoe, C. W., Gobburu, J. V., Danhof, M.,
Gillespie, W. R., Gastonguay, M. R., Meibohm, B., and Derendorf, H.
(2010). Pharmacometrics as a discipline is entering the "industrialization"
phase: standards, automation, knowledge sharing, and training are critical
for future success. J Clin Pharmacol , 50(9 Suppl), 9S -- 19S.
Streitbuerger, D.-P., Moller, H. E., Tittgemeyer, M., Hund-Georgiadis, M.,
Schroeter, M. L., and Mueller, K. (2012). Investigating structural brain
changes of dehydration using voxel-based morphometry. PLoS One, 7(8),
e44195.
Sutcliffe, J. G., Hedlund, P. B., Thomas, E. A., Bloom, F. E., and Hilbush,
B. S. (2011). Peripheral reduction of beta-amyloid is sufficient to reduce
brain beta-amyloid: implications for Alzheimer's disease. J Neurosci Res,
89(6), 808 -- 814.
Turgutalp, K., Ozhan, O., Gok Oguz, E., Yilmaz, A., Horoz, M., Helvaci,
I., and Kiykim, A. (2012). Community-acquired hypernatremia in elderly
and very elderly patients admitted to the hospital: clinical characteristics
and outcomes. Med Sci Monit, 18(12), CR729 -- CR734.
Whitmer, R. A., Sidney, S., Selby, J., Johnston, S. C., and Yaffe, K. (2005).
Midlife cardiovascular risk factors and risk of dementia in late life. Neu-
rology, 64(2), 277 -- 281.
18
Wortmann, M. (2012). Dementia: a global health priority - highlights from
an ADI and World Health Organization report. Alzheimers Res Ther ,
4(5), 40.
Wu, W., Juan, W. C., Liang, C. R. M. Y., Yeoh, K. G., So, J., and Chung, M.
C. M. (2012). S100A9, GIF and AAT as potential combinatorial biomarkers
in gastric cancer diagnosis and prognosis. Proteomics Clin Appl , 6(3-4),
152 -- 162.
Zambon, D., Quintana, M., Mata, P., Alonso, R., Benavent, J., Cruz-
Sanchez, F., Gich, J., Pocova, M., Civeira, F., Capurro, S., Bachman,
D., Sambamurti, K., Nicholas, J., and Pappolla, M. A. (2010). Higher in-
cidence of mild cognitive impairment in familial hypercholesterolemia. Am
J Med , 123(3), 267 -- 274.
19
Tables
Table 1: Basic statistics on the subjects of the CAMD data
Age distribution
Gender distribution
MMSE distribution
A: up to 65 years
B: 66-75 years
C: 76-85 years
D: more than 85
1093 Female
2070 Male
2408
397
3315 A: severe cog. impairment
2653 B: moderate cog. impairment
C: mild cog. impairment
D: normal cognition
255
611
3224
1352
20
Table 2: Several association rules of the highest lift. The lift value describes the multipli-
cation factor, increasing the probability of the Right Hand Side (RHS) if the Left Hand
Side is true. For example, our best rule (the first below) is saying that one can have the
a bad result of a cognitive test with four times higher probability if one has high serum
sodium and either low cholesterol or low or normal blood glucose level.
(lb_sodium=h) & (lb_chol=l or lb_gluc=ln) ---> mm_ori=B
Universe: 2783, LHS support: 87, RHS support: 401, Support: 50
Confidence: 0.574713, Lift: 3.98859, Leverage: 0.0134618, p-value: 0, E-value: 0
3.98859
(lb_gluc=ln) & (lb_chol=l or lb_sodium=h) ---> mm_ori=B
Universe: 2783, LHS support: 105, RHS support: 401, Support: 57
Confidence: 0.542857, Lift: 3.76751, Leverage: 0.0150451, p-value: 0, E-value: 0
3.76751
(lb_sodium=h) & (lb_hct=l or lb_gluc=ln) ---> mm_ori=B
Universe: 2926, LHS support: 95, RHS support: 420, Support: 51
Confidence: 0.536842, Lift: 3.74, Leverage: 0.0127695, p-value: 0, E-value: 0
3.74
(lb_sodium=h) & (bpsys=ln or lb_gluc=ln) ---> mm_ori=B
Universe: 3091, LHS support: 102, RHS support: 425, Support: 52
Confidence: 0.509804, Lift: 3.70777, Leverage: 0.0122858, p-value: 0, E-value: 0
3.70777
(lb_gluc=ln) & (lb_creat=l or lb_sodium=h) ---> mm_ori=B
Universe: 3091, LHS support: 99, RHS support: 425, Support: 50
Confidence: 0.505051, Lift: 3.6732, Leverage: 0.0117722, p-value: 0, E-value: 0
3.6732
(lb_sodium=h) & (age=D or lb_gluc=ln) ---> mm_ori=B
Universe: 3091, LHS support: 101, RHS support: 425, Support: 51
Confidence: 0.50495, Lift: 3.67248, Leverage: 0.0120068, p-value: 0, E-value: 0
3.67248
(lb_gluc=ln) & (lb_ast=l or lb_sodium=h) ---> mm_ori=B
Universe: 3091, LHS support: 101, RHS support: 425, Support: 51
Confidence: 0.50495, Lift: 3.67248, Leverage: 0.0120068, p-value: 0, E-value: 0
3.67248
21
Table 3: Some association rules involving serum cholesterol level
(lb_sodium=h) & (lb_chol=l or lb_gluc=ln) ---> mm_ori=B
Universe: 2783, LHS support: 87, RHS support: 401, Support: 50
Confidence: 0.574713, Lift: 3.98859, Leverage: 0.0134618, p-value: 0, E-value: 0
3.98859
(lb_gluc=ln) & (lb_chol=l or lb_sodium=h) ---> mm_ori=B
Universe: 2783, LHS support: 105, RHS support: 401, Support: 57
Confidence: 0.542857, Lift: 3.76751, Leverage: 0.0150451, p-value: 0, E-value: 0
3.76751
(lb_sodium=h) & (lb_chol=ln or lb_gluc=ln) ---> mm_ori=B
Universe: 2783, LHS support: 106, RHS support: 401, Support: 55
Confidence: 0.518868, Lift: 3.60102, Leverage: 0.0142747, p-value: 0, E-value: 0
3.60102
(lb_chol=h) & (lb_cl=h or lb_sodium=h) ---> mm_ori=B
Universe: 1420, LHS support: 71, RHS support: 304, Support: 51
Confidence: 0.71831, Lift: 3.35526, Leverage: 0.0252113, p-value: 2.22045e-016, E-value: 1.88773e-007
3.35526
(lb_chol=h) & (lb_monole=l or lb_sodium=h) ---> mm_total=AB
Universe: 1364, LHS support: 73, RHS support: 325, Support: 58
Confidence: 0.794521, Lift: 3.33454, Leverage: 0.02977, p-value: 1.51101e-013, E-value: 0.00012846
3.33454
(lb_sodium=h) & (lb_monole=h or lb_chol=h) ---> mm_total=AB
Universe: 1364, LHS support: 66, RHS support: 325, Support: 51
Confidence: 0.772727, Lift: 3.24308, Leverage: 0.0258608, p-value: 5.9952e-015, E-value: 5.09687e-006
3.24308
(lb_chol=h) & (lb_hbsag=h or lb_sodium=h) ---> mm_attcal=B
Universe: 1164, LHS support: 67, RHS support: 312, Support: 50
Confidence: 0.746269, Lift: 2.78416, Leverage: 0.0275268, p-value: 6.2725e-011, E-value: 0.0533262
2.78416
(lb_sodium=h) & (lb_bun=h or lb_chol=h) ---> mm_attcal=B
Universe: 1387, LHS support: 61, RHS support: 429, Support: 52
Confidence: 0.852459, Lift: 2.75609, Leverage: 0.023888, p-value: 8.87168e-012, E-value: 0.00754232
2.75609
(lb_sodium=h) & (lb_ca=l or lb_chol=h) ---> mm_attcal=B
Universe: 1420, LHS support: 61, RHS support: 460, Support: 51
Confidence: 0.836066, Lift: 2.5809, Leverage: 0.0219996, p-value: 2.52266e-011, E-value: 0.0214466
2.5809
(lb_sodium=h) & (lb_cl=h or lb_chol=h) ---> mm_attcal=B
Universe: 1420, LHS support: 66, RHS support: 460, Support: 55
Confidence: 0.833333, Lift: 2.57246, Leverage: 0.0236759, p-value: 1.65421e-010, E-value: 0.140634
2.57246
22
age
ast alt
bpdia
bpsys
lb alb
lb alp
lb alt
lb ast
lb baso
lb bili
lb bun
lb ca
lb chol
lb ck
lb cl
lb creat
lb eos
lb gluc
lb hba1c
lb hbsag
lb hct
lb hgb blood
lb k
lb ketones
lb ldh
lb lym
lb lymle
lb mch
lb mchc
lb mcv
lb mono
lb monole
lb neut
lb neutle
lb ph
lb phos
lb plat
lb prot
lb rbc blood
lb sodium
lb tsh
lb vitb12
lb wbc blood
mm attcal
mm lang
mm ori
mm recall
mm total
pulse
resp
sex
temper
Table 4: Legends for Table 2 and 3
Subject age (A: ≤ 65 years, B: 66 -- 75 years, C: 76 -- 85 years, D: >85 years)
De Ritis ratio
Diastolic blood pressure
Systolic blood pressure
Serum albumine
Serum alkaline phosphatase
Serum alanine aminotransferase
Serum aspartate aminotransferase
Basophils, particle concentration
Serum indirect bilirubin
Blood Urea Nitrogen
Serum calcium
Serum cholesterol
Serum creatine kinase
Serum chlorine
Serum creatinine
Eosinophils, particle concentration
Serum glucose
Hemoglobin A1C
Hepatitis B virus surface antigen
Hematocrit
Blood hemoglobin
Serum potassium
Ketones
Lactate dehydrogenase
Lymphocytes, particle concentration
Lymphocytes/leukocytes ratio
Mean Corpuscular Hemoglobin
Mean Corpuscular Hemoglobin Concentration
Mean Corpuscular Volume
Monocytes, particle concentration
Monocytes/leukocytes ratio
Neutrophils, particle concentration
Neutrophils/leukocytes ratio
pH
Phosphate
Platelets
Total protein
Red blood count
Serum sodium
Thyrotropin
Serum B12 vitamin
White blood count
MMSE attention and calculation subscore (B: 0 -- 1, C: 2, D: 3, E: 4 -- 5)
MMSE language subscore (B: 0 -- 2, C: 3 -- 4, D: 5 -- 6, E: 7 -- 9)
MMSE orientation subscore (B: 0 -- 2, C: 3 -- 4, D: 5 -- 7, E: 8 -- 10)
MMSE recall subscore (B: 0, C: 1, D: 2, E: 3)
MMSE total score (A: <10, B: 10 -- 14, C: 15 -- 23, D: ≥ 24)
Heart rate
Respiratory rate
Subject sex (F: female, M: male)
Temperature
23
Table 5: Elementary clauses with the greatest positive effect on normal cognition
lb vitb12=h
lb mch=h
lb mchc=l
lb k=h
sex=M
pulse=l
lb bun=l
age=AB
lb mono=nh
resp=ln
lb plat=ln
lb eos=nh
lb prot=nh
score: 67
score: 25
score: 22
score: 17
score: 10
score: 9
score: 8
score: 4
score: 3
score: 3
score: 2
score: 2
score: 2
24
Table 6: Elementary clauses with the greatest negative effect on normal cognition
score: -10
score: -10
score: -10
score: -12
score: -12
score: -12
score: -12
score: -12
score: -12
score: -12
score: -13
score: -13
score: -13
score: -13
score: -14
score: -14
score: -14
score: -16
score: -17
score: -18
score: -18
score: -19
score: -20
score: -21
score: -21
score: -22
score: -22
score: -26
score: -27
score: -28
score: -32
score: -42
score: -43
score: -50
score: -57
score: -99
score: -173
score: -224
temper=nh
lb wbc blood=h
age=BCD
lb prot=h
lb gluc=h
pulse=h
lb ck=h
lb hct=nh
lb k=ln
lb alp=h
lb chol=ln
lb ph=h
lb hct=l
lb alt=h
age=A
bpsys=ln
lb creat=ln
lb creat=h
temper=l
lb alp=ln
lb bun=ln
lb alt=l
lb wbc blood=l
lb chol=l
pulse=nh
lb prot=ln
lb bun=h
lb plat=h
lb gluc=ln
bpdia=ln
age=CD
lb chol=h
lb ast=h
lb ca=l
sex=F
age=D
lb cl=h
lb sodium=h
25
|
1011.4143 | 1 | 1011 | 2010-11-18T07:01:30 | Neuronal networks with coupling through amyloid beta: towards a theory for Alzheimer's disease | [
"q-bio.NC",
"nlin.CD"
] | Alzheimer's disease (AD) is a common form of dementia observed in the elderly due to neurodegenerative disorder and dysfunction. This arises from alterations in synaptic functioning of neurons leading to cognitive impairment and memory loss. Recent experimental studies indicate that the amyloid beta (A beta) protein, in its dimer and oligomer forms, affects the synaptic activity of neurons in the early stages of AD. However, the precise mechanism underlying A beta induced synaptic depression is still not clearly understood. In this paper, we introduce an electrical model that provides a possible mechanism for this. Our studies show that the competing effects of synaptic activity and the indirect interaction mediated by A beta, can disrupt the synchrony among neurons and severely affect the neuronal activity. This then leads to sub-threshold activity or synaptic silencing. This is in agreement with the reported disruption of cortical synaptic integration in the presence of A beta in transgenic mice. We suggest that direct electrophysiological measurements of A beta activity can establish its role in AD and the possible revival, proposed in our model. The mechanism proposed here is quite general and could account for the role of the relevant protein in other neuronal disorders also. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Neuronal networks with coupling through amyloid beta: towards a theory for
Alzheimer's disease.
V. Resmi∗ and G. Ambika†
Indian Institute of Science Education and Research, Pune - 411021, India
Physical Research Laboratory, Ahmedabad - 380009, India
R. E. Amritkar‡
Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore - 560 012, India
G. Rangarajan§
Alzheimer's disease (AD) is a common form of dementia observed in the elderly due to neurode-
generative disorder and dysfunction. This arises from alterations in synaptic functioning of neurons
leading to cognitive impairment and memory loss. Recent experimental studies indicate that the
amyloid beta (Aβ) protein, in its dimer and oligomer forms, affects the synaptic activity of neurons
in the early stages of AD. However, the precise mechanism underlying Aβ induced synaptic depres-
sion is still not clearly understood. In this paper, we introduce an electrical model that provides a
possible mechanism for this. Our studies show that the competing effects of synaptic activity and
the indirect interaction mediated by Aβ , can disrupt the synchrony among neurons and severely
affect the neuronal activity. This then leads to sub-threshold activity or synaptic silencing. This
is in agreement with the reported disruption of cortical synaptic integration in the presence of Aβ
in transgenic mice. We suggest that direct electrophysiological measurements of Aβ activity can
establish its role in AD and the possible revival, proposed in our model. The mechanism proposed
here is quite general and could account for the role of the relevant protein in other neuronal disorders
also.
PACS numbers: 05.45.Xt, 87.19.xr, 87.19.lj
1.
INTRODUCTION
Alzheimer's disease (AD) is the most common cause
for dementia characterized by a progressive neuronal dys-
function leading to neuronal death and depressed brain
function [1 -- 3].
It has been established over the past
decade that pathologically this neurodegenerative disor-
der may arise from extra cellular deposits of Amyloid β
(Aβ) protein in senile plaques and inter neuronal neuro-
fibrillatory tangles [4]. However, recent experimental
studies indicate that the amyloid beta (Aβ) protein, in
its dimer and oligomer forms, affects the synaptic ac-
tivity of neurons in the early stages of AD [5 -- 8]. The
actual mechanism by which Aβ oligomers participates in
the impairment of synaptic function is still not clearly
established.
In this work, we introduce a physical model that can
explain the mechanism of Aβ induced synaptic depres-
sion especially in the early stages and point towards pos-
sible methods for prevention or reversal. We start with
the simple hypothesis that since the primary functions of
neurons are through electrical activity, it is quite possible
that the disturbance or impairment of this function is also
∗Electronic address: [email protected]
†Electronic address: [email protected]
‡Electronic address: [email protected]
§Electronic address: [email protected]
electrical in nature. This is supported by the fact there is
no evidence of physical blocking or damage of synapses or
neurons in the very early stages [7]. Amyloid beta, being
a protein is not expected to have any electrical activity of
its own and no such activity has been reported so far. But
there exists a possibility of an induced electrical activity
(for example, through polarization) caused by electrical
signals generated by nearby neurons. Recent molecular
dynamics based study on Aβ indicates the possibility of
such an induced dipole moment due to rearrangement of
charges in the presence of an electric field [9]. This in-
duced electrical activity of Aβ, in turn, provides an input
back to the surrounding neurons (giving rise to a feed-
back loop). Thus Aβ can act as an intermediate agency
that provides an extra channel of interaction among neu-
rons. This is in addition to the regular synaptic interac-
tion between the neurons. The normal coupling through
synapse leads to in-phase synchronization of the activ-
ities of neurons. The additional coupling through Aβ
is equivalent to an environmental coupling of the type
discussed in a previous paper [11], where it was shown
that it can lead to an anti-phase synchronization. Thus
the above two types of couplings between the neurons
represent two competing synchronizing tendencies. Both
these tendencies become effective above their respective
thresholds for the coupling strengths. In addition, if their
effects balance each other, we expect the electrical activ-
ity of the neurons to be severely affected. The numerical
simulation carried out on a neuronal network with ad-
ditional coupling through Aβ establishes disruption of
activity and silencing.
2. NEURONS COUPLED INDIRECTLY VIA Aβ
The mechanism proposed in the paper is applied to a
network of 10 neurons using the Hindmarsh-Rose ( HR)
model [10]. A simple way of modeling the effect of the
extra channel via Aβ, in such a network is given below.
xi = yi − x3
i − zi + I
i + ax2
1
+ǫaw +
ǫs(Vr − xi)
ni
X
Aij
j
1 + exp(−λ(xj − θ))
yi = 1 − bx2
i − yi
zi = ρ(s(xi + χ) − zi)
w = −κw −
ǫa
n X
j
xj
(1)
The first three equations in (1) come from the HR model
(except for the w term) and represent the neuronal ac-
tivity in a normal brain. Here the variable x represents
the voltage of the neuron and y and z are variables re-
lated to ion currents and the neurons are coupled via ex-
citatory synaptic couplings [21] represented by the last
term in the first equation. We model the pathologi-
cal activity of Aβ in the case of AD by the additional
variable w. The nature of the electrical activity of Aβ
considered here is not inherent but induced. So with-
out input from neurons, this induced electrical activity
should decay. This is represented by the decay term, -
κw, in the w equation where κ is the damping parame-
ter. The second term in the w equation represents the
input from the surrounding neurons. The additional ǫaw
term in x equation is the extra input to the neuron volt-
age through Aβ as induced electrical activity. Here, we
choose the parameters a = 3,b = 5, ρ = 0.006, s = 4,
χ = 1.6,I = 3.2, such that the individual neurons have
chaotic responses. The damping parameter of the amy-
loid beta is taken to be κ = 1 . The synaptic coupling is
modeled by the sigmoidal function given in the last term
in the first equation. Here the reversal potential Vr < xi
makes the synapse excitatory. The other parameters in
the synaptic coupling term are chosen to be θ = −0.25
and λ = 10. The network is constructed using an adja-
cency matrix A, whose elements are randomly chosen as
either 0 or 1 in Eq.(1). Aij = 1 indicates that ith neuron
receives synaptic input from jth neuron. Here the matrix
A is asymmetric, such that the coupling is mostly unidi-
rectional though bidirectional couplings can also occur.
The synaptic input represented by a sigmoid function is
the self-feedback current of ith neuron modulated by the
jth neuron. Using random initial condtions, the network
is evolved using Runge-Kutta algorithm with step size
0.01 for sufficiently long time.
First we study the baseline activity by considering a
network of 10 neurons with HR model as the nodal dy-
namics and coupled via excitatory synapses alone ( ig-
2
(cid:1)
(cid:1)
FIG. 1: Time series of the voltage of all neurons (grey) and
their average (black). Here a random network of 10 neurons
is used with different strengths of synaptic coupling in the
absence of coupling through Aβ. (A) Unsynchronized state
for ǫs = 0.01 . Here the average voltage is much smaller than
individual spikes. (B) Synchronized bursting for ǫs = 0.5 and
(C), Synchronized states for ǫs = 1.0. HR parameters chosen
are as a = 3,b = 5,ρ = 0.006,s = 4,χ = 1.6 and I = 3.2, for
which individual neurons are in the chaotic state.
noring the influence of Aβ). For very small strengths of
synaptic coupling ǫs, the neurons do not act in synchrony.
This is clear from the sequences of neuronal voltages plot-
ted in Fig. 1.A. Here the grey lines give the neuronal
voltages from all the neurons while the black shows the
average response. The emergence of synchronous behav-
ior becomes evident as the synaptic strength ǫs increases.
Thus, Figs. 1.B and 1.C correspond to two typical cases
of coordinated activity when only synaptic interaction is
present.
Next, we introduce the extra coupling through Aβ in
the same network and the consequent changes in neu-
ronal voltages are shown in Fig. 2.A-F. We see that the
competing effects of the two modes of interaction lead to
severe disruptions of the neuronal activity which result
in sub threshold behavior and in some cases to complete
silencing. Further, the synaptic activity at one neuron is
calculated using the last term in Eq. (1) and is shown in
Fig. 2.G,H,I. In Fig. 2, we plot the total synaptic activ-
ity at one neuron and for different values of Aβ coupling
,show that Aβ coupling also disrupts the synaptic behav-
ior (Fig.2.G-I). We note that such disruptions in synaptic
behavior due to Aβ have been reported in earlier exper-
imental observations [12]. The induced activity of Aβ
based on our mechanism is evident from the behavior of
the variable w shown in Fig 2.J-L. This induced activity
of Aβ is caused by the electrical signal from the neurons
and when it is of sufficient strength, it can cause neuronal
dysfunction. We also observe that the route to synaptic
silencing or sub threshold activity is through a stage of
desynchronization of the neuronal outputs. This is clear
from Fig.2.B and E where the strength of ǫa is just not
sufficient for synaptic depression. We note that this is
consistent with the measurements of cortical neuronal
signals reported in transgenic mice [13].
That the resultant behavior of neurons under the
two competing interactions depends on their relative
3
(cid:1)
(cid:1)
FIG. 2: Disruption of neuronal activity by Aβ. (A)-(F) Time series of the voltage of all neurons in the network (grey)
and their average (black) for different strengths of synaptic coupling and coupling through Aβ. (A) Normal synchronized state
(ǫs = 0.50, ǫa = 0.01) (B) Desynchronized state (ǫs = 0.50, ǫa = 0.50).
(C) Sub-threshold activity (ǫs = 0.50, ǫa = 3.50)
(D) Normal synchronized state (ǫs = 1.00, ǫa = 0.01). (E) Desynchronized state (ǫs = 1.0, ǫa = 1.60) (F) synaptic silencing
(ǫs = 1.00, ǫa = 2.00). (G-I) Synaptic input to one neuron and (J-L) Induced activity on Aβ as a function of time at different
strengths of synaptic coupling and coupling through Aβ (G) Synaptic input for synchronized state (ǫs = 1.00, ǫa = 0.01) (H)
synaptic input for desynchronized activity near sub-threshold oscillatory state ( ǫs = 0.50, ǫa = 0.50 ). (I) synaptic input for
desynchronized activity near neuronal silencing (ǫs = 1.0, ǫa = 1.60) (J) Induced activity on Aβ due to signal from neurons for
ǫs = 1.00, ǫa = 0.01 (K) Induced activity on Aβ for ǫs = 0.50, ǫa = 0.50. (L) Induced activity on Aβ for ǫs = 1.0, ǫa = 1.60.
strengths is evident from Fig. 2. Hence we study in de-
tail the neuronal activity in the parameter plane of the
coupling strengths (ǫa, ǫs ). The maximum value of the
voltage of neurons in the network is used as an indicator
to identify regions of synaptic silencing in the parame-
ter plane of coupling strengths. This is shown in Fig. 3,
where black regions correspond to complete electrical in-
activity (quiescent state) and red regions correspond to
sub-threshold oscillations. We find two patches of red
and black regions in the parameter plane where the two
competing effects balance each other.
Based on our model, we propose that one of the possi-
ble mechanisms to prevent this regulatory activity of Aβ
is either inhibiting electrical activity on Aβ or by reduc-
ing the value of parameter κ which amounts to very slow
relaxation of the induced activity of Aβ. The latter case
is shown in Fig. 4, where by decreasing κ, the synaptic
activity is found to be restored.
3. DISCUSSION
We have introduced a physical mechanism that ex-
plains the electrophysiological death of neurons due to
the influence of Aβ oligomers in the context of AD. We
note that some of the key features of our analysis agree
with the findings from other related and direct obser-
vational studies. Thus it is found by electrophysiological
measurements in cultured hippocampal neurons that ele-
vated Aβ production disrupts both presynaptic and post-
synaptic functions [14]. Our results also indicate that
synaptic depression occurs in all the neurons. A study of
hippocampal neurons reported that the synaptic depres-
sion requires neuronal activity [15]. In our model also,
with no neuronal activity, Aβ will not become electrically
active and therefore cannot cause depression. We observe
that the synaptic silencing is associated with considerable
disruption of synchronized activity. This is in agreement
with the reported disruption of cortical synaptic integra-
tion in the presence of Aβ in transgenic mice[13].
Some of the mechanisms for AD reported recently
are either biochemical due to generation of free radicals
[16] or chemical due to binding of Aβ in cell membrane
[17, 18]. The mechanism introduced in this paper is novel
in that it is the first electrical model to the best of our
knowledge. Moreover, our model for the first time pro-
poses the presence of induced activity in Aβ oligomers
when synaptic disruption occurs. We note that indirect
evidence for induced electrical activity can be drawn from
the reported studies on birefringence in certain amyloid
proteins such as β-Lactoglobulin under applied electrical
pulses [19]. This indicates the possibility of such an ac-
tivity in Aβ under the influence of neuronal signals. A
direct test for such induced activity can be obtained by
electrophysiological measurements in cultured media or
brain slices. Such experiments can also lead to possible
revival strategies by external interventions of the type
proposed in our model.
None of the studies reported so far explain precisely
the reason why Aβ monomer is not effective in inducing
synaptic suppression but dimers and other n-oligomers
are. We conjecture that a possible explanation through
4
our model would be that the monomer does not develop
electrical activity of the required magnitude to have a
measurable effect, while higher oligomers develop electri-
cal activity of the same order of magnitude as a normal
synaptic interaction. A direct measurement of the in-
duced effect on amyloid monomer and dimer in a field
equivalent to that across the synapse can give direct sup-
port for this conjecture. Thus the theory proposed here
opens up interesting observational research in at least
two directions. We have obtained qualitatively similar
results with other models such as Hodgkin-Huxley and
FitzHugh- Nagumo models. These results are presented
in the supporting information. Finally, we propose that
the mechanism introduced here is quite general and can
be applied in the context of other neurodegenerative dis-
eases such as Parkinson's disease, Huntington's disease,
Creutzfeld- Jakob disease, etc where specific protein de-
posits have been identified as the neurotoxic agents [20].
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
4
a
ε
2
0
0
0.5
ε
s
1
FIG. 3: Regions of disrupted neuronal activity(shown in
red and black) in the parameter plane of coupling strengths
(ǫs, ǫa).The maximum voltage from all neurons , averaged over
10 random realizations of the network of 10 neurons is used
as the index and specific nature of activity is verified from
time series of a few representative cases. Black regions cor-
respond to regions with total absence of activity and the red
regions correspond to regions of sub-threshold activity. Yellow
regions correspond to normal neuronal activity which can in-
clude unsynchronized bursts and spikes, synchronized bursts,
and synchronized spikes for different values of ǫa, and ǫs
A
B
i
x
i
x
1.5
0
-1.5
1.5
0
-1.5
1000
1040
Time
1080
FIG. 4: Revival of neuronal activity by preventing leakage
of induced activity of Aβ. A,Voltage of a neuron recovering
from sub-threshold state with ǫs = 0.5, ǫa = 3.5 .B, Voltage
of a neuron recovering from silent state with ǫs = 1.0 and
ǫa = 2.0. In both cases, κ is reduced to 1% of its initial value
at the 1000th time unit.
[1] Shankar GM , Walsh DM (2009) Alzheimer's disease:
synaptic dysfunction and Aβ. Molecular Neurodegener-
ation 4: 48
caused by the cerebral accumulation and cytotoxicity of
amyloid beta-protein. Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 924: 17-25
[5] Walsh DM, Selkoe DJ (2007) Aβ oligomers - a decade of
[2] Selkoe DJ (2002) Alzheimer's disease is a synaptic failure.
discovery. J. Neurochem. 101: 1172-1184
Science 298: 789-791
[3] Tanzi RE (2005) The synaptic Aβ hypothesis of
Alzheimer's disease, Nat Neurosci. 8: 977 - 979
[4] Selkoe DJ (2000) Towards a comprehensive theory for
Alzheimer's disease hypothesis: Alzheimer's disease is
[6] Walsh DM, Tseng BP, Rydel RE, Podlisny MB, Selkoe
DJ (2000) The oligomerization of amyloid β - pro-
tein begins intracellularly in cells derived from human
brain.Biochemistry 39: 10831-10839
[7] Cleary JP et al. (2005) Natural oligomers of the amyloid
β protein specifically disrupt cognitive function. Nature
Neurosci. 8: 79-84
[8] Walsh DM et.al. (2002) Naturally secreted oligomers of
amyloid β protein potently inhibit hippocampal long-
term potentiation in vivo. Nature 416: 535-540
[9] Toschi F, Lugli F, Biscarini F, Zerbetto F (2009) Effects
of Electric Field Stress on a β-Amyloid Peptide, J. Phys.
Chem. B, 113: 369-376
[10] Hindmarsh JL, Rose RM (1984) A model of neuronal
bursting using three coupled first order differential equa-
tions. Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. B 221: 87-102
[11] Resmi V, Ambika G, Amritkar RE (2010) Synchronized
states in chaotic systems coupled indirectly through a
dynamic environment, Phys Rev E 81: 046216 - 1 - 7
[12] Shankar GM et.al., (2008) Amyloid-β protein dimers iso-
lated directly from Alzheimer's brains impair synaptic
plasticity and memory,Nature Medicine, 14: 837-842
[13] Stern EA et al. (2004) Cortical synaptic integration in
vivo is disrupted by amyloid-β plaques. J. Neurosci. 24:
4535-4540
[14] Ting JT, Kelley BG, Lambert TJ, Cook DG, Sullivan
JM (2007) Amyloid precursor protein over expression de-
presses excitatory transmission through both presynap-
tic and postsynaptic mechanisms. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.
USA 104: 353-358
5
[15] Kamenetz F et al. (2003) APP processing and synaptic
function. Neuron 37: 925-937
[16] Varadarajan S, Yatin S, Aksenova M, Butterfield
DA (2000) Review: Alzheimer's amyloid β-peptide-
associated free radical oxidative stress and neurotoxicity.
J. Struct. Biol., 130: 184-208
[17] Blanchard BJ, Thomas VL, Ingram VM (2002) Mech-
anism of membrane depolarization caused by the
Alzheimer Aβ1-42 peptide. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Com-
mun. 293: 1197-1203
[18] Sokolov Y et. al, (2006) Soluble Amyloid Oligomers In-
crease Bilayer Conductance by Altering Dielectric Struc-
ture, J. Gen. Physiol, 128: 637-647
[19] Rogers SS et.al. (2006) Investigating the permanent elec-
tric dipole moment of β-Lactoglobulin fibrils, using tran-
sient electric birefringence, Biopolymers 82: 241-252
[20] Caughey B, Lansbury PT Jr. (2003) Protofibrils, pores,
fibrils, and neurodegeneration: Separating the respon-
sible protein aggregates from the innocent bystanders,
Annu. Rev. Neurosci. 26: 267-98
[21] Belykh I, de Lange E, Hasler M (2005) Synchronization of
bursting neurons: What matters in the network topology
Phys Rev Lett 94: 188101-1-4
|
1608.03464 | 1 | 1608 | 2016-07-24T06:36:59 | A New Statistical Model of Electroencephalogram Noise Spectra for Real-time Brain-Computer Interfaces | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | $Objective$: A characteristic of neurological signal processing is high levels of noise from sub-cellular ion channels up to whole-brain processes. In this paper, we propose a new model of electroencephalogram (EEG) background periodograms, based on a family of functions which we call generalized van der Ziel--McWhorter (GVZM) power spectral densities (PSDs). To the best of our knowledge, the GVZM PSD function is the only EEG noise model which has relatively few parameters, matches recorded EEG PSD's with high accuracy from 0 Hz to over 30 Hz, and has approximately $1/f^\theta$ behavior in the mid-frequencies without infinities. $Methods$: We validate this model using three approaches. First, we show how GVZM PSDs can arise in population of ion channels in maximum entropy equilibrium. Second, we present a class of mixed autoregressive models, which simulate brain background noise and whose periodograms are asymptotic to the GVZM PSD. Third, we present two real-time estimation algorithms for steady-state visual evoked potential (SSVEP) frequencies, and analyze their performance statistically. $Results$: In pairwise comparisons, the GVZM-based algorithms showed statistically significant accuracy improvement over two well-known and widely-used SSVEP estimators. $Conclusion$: The GVZM noise model can be a useful and reliable technique for EEG signal processing. $Significance$: Understanding EEG noise is essential for EEG-based neurology and applications such as real-time brain-computer interfaces (BCIs), which must make accurate control decisions from very short data epochs. The GVZM approach represents a successful new paradigm for understanding and managing this neurological noise. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | A New Statistical Model of Electroencephalogram
Noise Spectra for Real-time Brain-Computer
Interfaces
Alan Paris∗, Student Member, IEEE, George Atia, Member, IEEE, Azadeh Vosoughi, Member, IEEE and
Stephen A. Berman
6
1
0
2
l
u
J
4
2
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
4
6
4
3
0
.
8
0
6
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
Abstract-Objective: A characteristic of neurological signal
processing is high levels of noise from sub-cellular ion channels up
to whole-brain processes. In this paper, we propose a new model
of electroencephalogram (EEG) background periodograms, based
on a family of functions which we call generalized van der Ziel–
McWhorter (GVZM) power spectral densities (PSDs). To the
best of our knowledge, the GVZM PSD function is the only
EEG noise model which has relatively few parameters, matches
recorded EEG PSD's with high accuracy from 0 Hz to over 30
Hz, and has approximately 1/f θ behavior in the mid-frequencies
without infinities. Methods: We validate this model using three
approaches. First, we show how GVZM PSDs can arise in
population of ion channels in maximum entropy equilibrium.
Second, we present a class of mixed autoregressive models, which
simulate brain background noise and whose periodograms are
asymptotic to the GVZM PSD. Third, we present two real-time
estimation algorithms for steady-state visual evoked potential
(SSVEP) frequencies, and analyze their performance statistically.
Results: In pairwise comparisons, the GVZM-based algorithms
showed statistically significant accuracy improvement over two
well-known and widely-used SSVEP estimators. Conclusion: The
GVZM noise model can be a useful and reliable technique for
EEG signal processing. Significance: Understanding EEG noise
is essential for EEG-based neurology and applications such as
real-time brain-computer interfaces (BCIs), which must make
accurate control decisions from very short data epochs. The
GVZM approach represents a successful new paradigm for
understanding and managing this neurological noise.
Index Terms-1/f noise, brain-computer interface (BCI), elec-
troencephalogram, ion channels, maximum entropy, neural noise,
neurological noise, periodogram, SSVEP
I. INTRODUCTION
S IGNALS recorded from living neurological
A. Neurological Noise Research: Background and Motivation
tissue are
extremely noisy at all scales from individual ion channels
[1] through collections of one or more neurons [2]–[4] up to
scalp-recorded EEGs [5] (Fig. 1). As a result, the theory of
neurological noise continues to be a thriving area for research
Manuscript received January 27, 2016. This material is based upon work
supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant CCF-1525990.
Asterisk indicates corresponding author.
∗Alan Paris, M.S. is with the NeuroLogic Lab, Institute for Simulation
and Training, University of Central Florida, Orlando, FL 32816 (e-mail:
[email protected]) and was supported in part by the Modeling and
Simulation Program, University of Central Florida and the NSF Grant CCF-
1525990. George Atia, Ph.D. and Azadeh Vosoughi, Ph.D. are with the Dept.
of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Central Florida, Or-
lando, FL 32816 (e-mail: {george.atia,azadeh}@ucf.edu). Stephen A. Berman,
M.D., Ph.D. is with the College of Medicine, University of Central Florida,
Orlando, FL 32827 (e-mail: [email protected]).
Fig. 1: Recorded EEG periodogram from a 15-second, SSVEP
experiment showing alpha-band power. The target 28 Hz
response peak is nearly lost in the low SNR background noise.
[6], with theoretical and practical implications for neurological
signal processing and neurology.
In this paper we examine the statistical characteristics of
EEG periodograms [7], [8]. Specifically, we present a new
model for the statistical properties of EEG background pro-
cesses which, for the purpose of many applications, may be
regarded as "brain noise". To the best of our knowledge, it is
the first simple and general noise model in the EEG literature
which closely matches recorded EEG periodograms from near
0 Hz to over 30 Hz. We then validate this new model using
three different and complementary approaches. Our research
on neurological noise is inspired by three main goals:
• To improve the performance of real-time neurological
algorithms: Certain neurological signal processing tasks, such
as extracting event-related potentials (ERPs), increase signal-
to-noise ratios (SNRs) by averaging many epochs of data
recorded over long experimental periods [9]. However, time-
frequency algorithms, which assume high levels of nonstation-
arity [10], and BCIs [11], [12], which are meant to provide
disabled patients with a sense of real-time control, must work
with much shorter, single-trial epochs.
Ordinary linear filtering of such short epochs is problem-
atic, since there is evidence that the brain's responses are
highly nonlinear [13], and because the target signals can
be nearly indistinguishable from the background (cf. Fig.
1). Moreover, poorly-fitting models of the detailed statistical
characteristics of brain processes reduces the precision of
detection/estimation procedures and makes model validation
010203040500102030405060 HzdB28 +/− 0.5 HzSSVEP responsealpha−band:appr. 9−13 Hz uncertain.
We are particularly interested in developing real-time
SSVEP BCI algorithms which are accurate into the γ-band, a
region of the EEG spectrum which is dominated by noise.
• To create statistically-realistic simulations of neurological
signals: The common practice is to add artificial noise sources
to neurological simulations in order to increase their realism
and to measure the performance of models and algorithms
[4]. Good simulations of neurological signals are essential for
development and testing of medical and BCI algorithms. This
is especially true for critical applications to human neurology
[10], [13] for which experimentation is highly restricted.
• To create new insight into the underlying neurological
processes: Statistical models of neurological noise have had
remarkable success in providing indirect tests of neuroscience
hypotheses. This was spectacularly true for the elucidation of
the acetycholine neurotransmission mechanisms in the 1970's
by Katz & Miledi [14]. But noise models continue to enhance
our understanding of neurological illness [15], [16], cognitive
processes [17], and may even explain brain nonlinearity [18].
We believe that the theory of neurological noise processes
will play an increasingly important role in interpreting the
behavior of the billions of neurons and trillions of ion channels
in large-scale, biological brain networks.
B. Steady-State Visual Evoked Potential BCIs
Sudden stimuli such as a touch, a sound, or a bright flash
will elicit a detectable brain reaction called an event-related
potential [9] or evoked potential (EP). Such EPs typically last
on the order of 500 ms before disappearing, and usually may
be reinvoked after a short refractory period. However, if the
stimuli are repeated at a regular rate faster than about 2Hz, the
EPs will not have time to decay and the brain's reaction will
be a periodic signal called a steady-state evoked potential
whose fundamental frequency is the same as the stimulus'. In
particular, periodic visual stimuli will cause an SSVEP [19].
These stimulus-dependent brain frequencies can be used to
control BCIs [12], by flashing lights at various distinct fre-
quencies simultaneously in different locations on a computer
screen or LED device. The strongest SSVEP response peak
detected corresponds to the location on which the subject's
attention was most focused and usually represents the selec-
tion.
Low frequency visual stimuli also induce harmonics [20]
(cf. Fig. 5a) which also may be used for BCI detection [21].
Thus the corresponding subject selections can be identified by
simple algorithms. It is worth remarking that such harmonic
responses prove conclusively that the brain is a nonlinear
system since pure linear systems cannot generate harmonics.
On the other hand, higher frequencies, especially those which
approach the gamma-band above 30 Hz, are much more
difficult to detect, because their response power is close to
that of the background and all harmonics (if they exist at
all) and are lost in the gamma-band noise. This is seen most
clearly in Fig. 1, which shows a 28 Hz brain response almost
indistinguishable from background noise. (However, note that
our new GVZM-based algorithms in Section V detect the 28
Hz peak even in this difficult data set.)
2
C. Modeling EEG Noise and Noise Power Spectral Densities
EEG noise has often been modeled using PSDs [7], [8]
that are power law functions [18], [22] of the form S(f ) ∝
1/f θ for some 0 (cid:54) θ < 2. Neurological noise PSDs at all
scales have long been claimed [1], [4], [23] to have the general
characteristics of such "1/f–type noise" [22] even though this
claim implies the obvious paradox of infinite total power in a
biological system.
Also, autoregressive (AR) [12] and autoregressive-moving
average (ARMA) models of [8] of EEG recordings are very
commonly used, in particular to simulate noise for the SSVEP
detection algorithm [24]. Such models are useful approxima-
tions but yield PSDs which are rational functions and are
more appropriate to stationary, linear systems. However, brain
signals are known to be neither stationary [10] nor linear [18].
A useful approach has been to model the statistical vari-
ations of noise periodograms around their mean PSD. In
many cases, the periodogram values Sx (k) of a discrete-time
random process x (n) are independent, scaled χ2 (2) random
variables [25], whose expected value E [Sx (k)] gives the
mean spectral power at the frequency index k [8]. This result
holds exactly for many important special cases, such as white
Gaussian noise and causal periodic ARMA processes. (See
Appendix A for the definition.) In more general situations,
the χ2 (2) distribution is approached only asymptotically as
the data length increases, however the result still has very
broad applicability [8].
The idea of detecting SSVEP responses for BCI applications
by performing statistical testing of the periodogram (often
called the Spectral F-Test (SFT)) was developed by several
research groups in the mid-90's [26] and is based on "hidden
periodicity" methods dating back to the 40's [8]. The idea has
been used regularly, most notably in [24], [27] which enhanced
the flexibility of the original SFT procedure.
D. Contributions and Paper Organization
The central innovation of this article is a new statistical
model of the discrete Fourier transform (DFT) periodograms
[7] of EEG noise processes, the so-called GVZM noise model.
We validate this model via three distinct approaches: (i)
developing a neurological noise model based on quantum
mechanical ion channel kinetics, (ii) linking autoregressive
time series to the GVZM noise model and EEG noise, (iii)
and designing and evaluating two real-time SSVEP BCI es-
timation algorithms, based on the new GVZM noise model.
Our contributions can be summarized as the following
• We introduce a novel, five-parameter GVZM PSD func-
tion, and we show that this function accurately matches the
PSD function of recorded EEG noise, from near 0 Hz to 30
Hz. Also, we show that this function is approximately of the
form 1/f θ in the mid-frequencies but has finite total power and
finite amplitude as f → 0. We provide a biophysical meaning
of the function parameters and indicate how the function can
be derived from a theory of ion channel noise.
• We use the GVZM PSD function to define a new statistical
model of the DFT periodgrams of EEG noise processes, which
we call the GVZM noise model. We show that this model
successfully captures the statistics of EEG periodograms,
allows rigorous statistical testing, detection, and estimation,
and enables statistically accurate simulations of EEG noise
periodograms.
• We define a class of mixed autoregressive (AR) time
series, which we call AR-GVZM processes, containing ac-
curate simulations of EEG noise time series, and whose PSD
functions converge asymptotically to the GVZM PSD function
(GVZM noise model). We show also that, if recorded EEG
noise is assumed to be Gaussian and satisfies the GVZM
noise model, it can be approximated arbitrarily closely by AR-
GVZM processes.
• We define two new SSVEP frequency estimation al-
gorithms based on the GVZM noise model: a simple χ2-
distribution detection algorithm for frequency spikes and a
more sophisticated, F -distribution estimator based on the well-
known algorithm in [24]. We demonstrate statistically that
these algorithms outperform two well-known rivals [19], [28],
[29], thus providing evidence for the truth of our noise model.
The practical success of the GVZM noise model provides
indirect validation of the underlying ion channel noise model
from which it was developed.
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows: Section
II introduces the GVZM PSD function, defines the GVZM
noise model, and discusses the behavior of the GVZM PSD
function. Section III briefly summarizes the results of the the-
ory of quantum-controlled ion channels. Section IV introduces
AR-GVZM processes and discusses their link to GVZM noise
model and EEG noise. Section V describes and compares
statistically two GVZM-based SSVEP algorithms and two
rival SSVEP estimators. Section VI presents our conclusions.
Fig. 2: The generalized arctangent function tan−1
II. THE GVZM EEG PERIODOGRAM MODEL
θ
(x).
In this section, we first specify the notion of periodogram
we are using and then define the GVZM PSD function. We
then present the GVZM EEG periodogram model.
A. Defining the Periodogram
Definition 1. For the purpose of this article, the single-epoch
periodogram of a discrete-time signal x (n), 0 (cid:54) n (cid:54) N − 1,
is defined as
Sx (k) def=
2π
N
X (k)2 , 0 (cid:54) k (cid:54) N − 1,
where X (k) def= (cid:80)N−1
n=0 x (n) e−i(2π/N )kn is the DFT of x (n)
[7]. The factor 2π is present to convert Sx (k) to dimension
amplitude2/frequency, where frequency has dimension 1/time,
not angle/time; i.e., units of Hz rather than radians/sec.
B. Defining the GVZM PSD Function
Definition 2. The GVZM PSD SGVZM (f ) is the family of
functions with five parameters 0 < θ < 2, 0 < υ1 < υ2,
P0 (cid:62) 0, Ps (cid:62) 0 and defined by
SGVZM (f ) def= P0 f−θ(cid:0)tan−1
(2πυ2 f)
(2πυ1 f)(cid:1) + Ps,
3
(1)
(2)
θ
−tan−1
θ
x(cid:90)
where
tan−1
θ
(x) def= sgn (x)
uθ−1
1 + u2 du.
0
Note that for θ = 1, Eq. (2) is the ordinary arctan (x) (cf.
Fig. 2). The dimension of υ1, υ2 is time while that of P0,
Ps is amplitude2/frequency (i.e., noise power). The spectral
exponent θ is dimensionless. The biophysical meaning of these
parameters is described in Section III-B.
The importance of this definition is that, so far as the authors
are aware, this is the first simple model of the average EEG
background noise spectrum proposed in the literature which
can match recorded EEG periodograms from near 0 Hz to
over 30 Hz, with a fixed number of parameters. Moreover,
the GVZM PSD function approximates a power law 1/f θ in
the mid-frequencies without requiring infinite power. In fact,
SGVZM (f ) always has finite amplitude and finite total power.
In the next section, the GVZM PSD will be used to define
a statistical model of EEG periodograms, the core of our work
and the basis of the new SSVEP algorithms in Section V.
C. The GVZM Noise Model
Definition 3. Let x (n), 0 (cid:54) n (cid:54) N − 1 be samples of
an EEG electrode, taken at sampling frequency fsamp, which
measures a naturally-occuring, stationary ensemble of brain
background processes for a single individual. Then the GVZM
noise model of the periodogram values Sx (k), 0 (cid:54) k (cid:54) N−1
is the random process
Sx (k) = SGVZM (k∆f ) · (1/2) Ξ (k) ,
(3)
where Ξ (k) is a sequence of χ2 (2) distributed [25] random
variables, which are independent for 0 (cid:54) k, l < N/2 when
k (cid:54)= l, ∆f def= fsamp/N, and SGVZM (f ) is an appropriate
GVZM PSD defined by (1).
Note that the reason for the restriction of independence
to 0 (cid:54) k, l < N/2 is that, since x (· ) is real, we have
Sx (N − k) = Sx (k). Also note that the half-interval defi-
nition 0 (cid:54) k, l < N/2 applies whether N is even or odd.
We can write (3) informally as
Sx (k) ∼ SGVZM (k∆f ) · (1/2) χ2 (2) ,
where ∼ denotes "is distributed as."
−10−50510−5−4−3−2−1012345xtan−1θ(x) θ = 0.25θ = 0.5θ = 1θ = 1.5θ = 1.75θ = 1.75θ = 0.25 4
Fig. 3: (a) GVZM PSD function fitted to the 28 Hz stimulus recorded EEG periodogram of Fig. 1. (b) GVZM · (1/2) χ2 (2)
simulated EEG periodogram using the parameters derived from (a).
(b)
(a)
The (1/2) χ2 (2) periodogram distribution holds exactly for
special processes such as N-periodic ARMA described in
Appendix A. When conditions for the Central Limit Theorem
hold, the (1/2) χ2 (2) distribution holds asymptotically as the
data length N → ∞ [8]. Both N-periodic ARMA and the
large-N approximations are appropriate for EEG noise.
Note that Eq. (3) implies that the expected values E [Sx (k)]
are equal to SGVZM (k∆f ). Using general results presented
in [8], the converse holds asymptotically; that is, the process
Sx (k) converges uniformly in distribution to SGVZM (k∆f ) ·
(1/2) Ξ (k) as N → ∞, at least when conditions for Central
Limit Theorem hold. (cf. [8], Chapter 10 for details.)
Def. 3 is consistent with the single-epoch approach of [8],
[24] but multi-epoch averages of such single-epoch spectra can
be used as well. Our methods will apply to such general peri-
odograms merely by replacing "χ2 (2)" with "1/M χ2 (2M ),"
where M is the number of (statistically independent) epochs.
D. The Behavior of the GVZM PSD Function
θ
The properties of tan−1
(x) show that once the noise floor
Ps is subtracted we have the approximate proportionalities
SGVZM (f ) ∝ 1/f 0 (i.e., a constant) for f < 1/ (2πυ2),
SGVZM (f ) ∝ 1/f θ for 1/ (2πυ2) < f < 1/ (2πυ1), and
SGVZM (f ) ∝ 1/f 2 for f > 1/ (2πυ1). Thus its roll-off
transitions smoothly through the 1/f θ regime, without any
of the so-called "catastrophes" [22] of apparent infinite power
when f → 0 and infinite integrals as f → ∞ which plague
true 1/f–type noises. In particular, SGVZM (f ) approaches a
(calculable) limiting value as f → 0.
Fig. 3a shows a GVZM PSD function fitted to the peri-
odogram of recorded EEG data from an SSVEP session. The
GVZM curve follows the periodogram closely except for the
alpha-band power [5] and the SSVEP response spike.
Fig. 3a should be compared closely to Fig. 3b which
shows a simulated periodogram based on the fitted GVZM
PSD function and (3); that is, samples of an independent
and identically distributed (iid) χ2 (2) pseudo–random process
Ξ (k), 0 (cid:54) k (cid:54) N − 1 were generated and each sample was
multiplied by the factor (1/2) · SGVZM (k∆f ). The results
were then plotted against frequency on a log-linear scale. We
observe that the simulated periodogram of Fig. 3b is visually
indistinguishable from the background periodogram of Fig. 3a.
Eq. (1) has it origin in investigations dating to the 1930's
[30] on apparent 1/f-type noise in vacuum tubes and semi-
conductors. In 1957, A.L. McWhorter proposed [31] a simple
explanation for 1/f–type semiconductor noise at
thermal
equilibrium, based on the assumption that the logarithm of
the rate at which electrons drop from an activated state was
proportional to the energy of that state. Subsequently A. van
der Ziel and others [32] abstracted the McWhorter mechanism
to general noise processes. Our formula (1) reduces to the
original van der Ziel-McWhorter PSD function for θ = 1.
III. NEUROLOGICAL NOISE THEORY AND QUANTUM
MECHANICAL ION CHANNEL KINETICS
In this section we briefly discuss the theoretical foundation
of our GVZM PSD function in Def. 2, using a new model of
ion channel quantum stochastic processes we have devel-
oped, and whose details are presented in the supplementary
document [33]. For the present paper we extract a simplified
form of one type of potential autocorrelation function in [33]
and provide the biophysical interpretation of its parameters.
A. Are Ion Channels the Source of 1/f–type Noise?
Ion channels are protein-based micromachines densely em-
bedded in all neuron membranes, which create and control the
transmission of information by regulating the passage of ions
in response to neurotransmitters, local voltages, or external
stimuli such as temperature, pressure, or photon reception [3].
Soon after Hodgkin & Huxley decoded the generation
of action potentials by the K+/Na+ channel system [34],
researchers began to model
ion conductance variations in
membranes as resulting from simple Markov processes gov-
erning the open/close kinetics of the embedded ion channels
[1]. These conductance variations were recognized quickly as
a potential source of neurological noise, at least at the neuron
level [3].
In a series of articles [1] in the early 1970's, Hill & Chen
examined several versions of Markov models, including one
which was claimed to test the original van der Ziel-McWhorter
01020304050−30−20−100102030405060HzdB Recorded EEG periodogramFitted GVZM PSDBrain backgroundnoise spectrumAlpha−bandpower28 Hz SSVEPresponse spike01020304050−30−20−100102030405060HzdB 1/2 χ2(2) × GVZM PSDGVZM PSD paradigm (Section II), with the stated goal of excluding ion
channels as sources of the 1/f–type noise component seen in
neuron-level recordings. The limited computational resources
available at that time prevented detailed simulations, and they
eventually rejected ion channel kinetics as the source of the
1/f–type noise, thus leaving its origin unexplained. Since
then there have been attempts to explain this neurological
noise by various other mechanisms [4], however, none of these
explanations have been completely successful.
B. Maximum Entropy in Populations of Quantum Ion Chan-
nels and GVZM Noise
We have revisited the conclusion of of Hill & Chen in [33]
by considering network-level behavior of large populations
of ion channels in statistical equilibrium. Specifically, we
have returned to McWhorter's original model (Section II)
of noise generation in semiconductors and identified channel
analogies to McWhorter's energy-dependent rate constants and
maximum entropy distributions. We have applied McWhorter's
abstract maximum entropy paradigm by creating a new quan-
tum mechanical model of ion channel kinetics, which we call
activated measurement processes. In the following, we recall
a special case of our work in [33]:
Theorem 1. Let C be a population of
ion channels
whose kinetic rate matrices at gating level V are obtained
from activation energy operators {Ec (V ) c ∈ C} accord-
ing to the standard activated measurement model [33]. Let
(cid:104)Ψ (c) , p (c) c ∈ C(cid:105) be the entropy-maximizing state and
density functions under the energy constraint
(cid:90)
tr [Ec (V ) · Ψ (c)] p (c) dc = ¯E
υ2(cid:90)
C
for fixed gating level V and mean activation energy ¯E, where
tr [· ] is the trace operator.
Then there are conditions such that the autocorrelation of
the population's channel conductance g is
Rg (τ ) = P0
1
υ2−θ e−τ/υdυ + Ps · δ (τ ) ,
(4)
for constants P0,υ1,υ2,θ,Ps.
υ1
(The "conditions" mentioned in Thm. 1 are technical and
are omitted.)
Note that the Fourier transform of (4) is easily seen to be
the GVZM PSD function in Def. 2.
While these results have immediate relevance only for
populations of ion channels, we have argued in [33] that
the presence of GVZM noise in large-scale EEG recordings
ultimately derives from the collective behavior of billions of
ion channels balanced in statistical equilibrium.
A rough idea of the biophysical meaning of the parameters
can be given. The values υ (x) represents the range of possible
reciprocal eigenvalues ("modes") of the kinetic rate matrices
[3] of all possible ion channels in a large network while X is
an index set for these modes. The Ps · δ (τ ) term represents
"sputter" in the channels: the possibility that a channel's state
5
is not quite open or closed completely. The 1/υ (x) prefactor
in the integrand derives from the proportionality between
activation energy and log (υ), a feature common to both the
McWhorter paradigm as well as an alternative ion channel
mechanism called Eyring rate theory [35].
Most
importantly,
the exponent θ is the normalization
parameter for a standard thermodynamic partition function
(cid:90)
Z (θ) =
e−θE(υ) dυ,
X
where, as previously mentioned, the activation energy of mode
υ is E (υ) ∝ log (υ).
This latter point is very significant. Many attempts have
been made to explain irrational exponents in 1/f θ–type spec-
tra by means of purported power laws, "scaling", or "self-
similarity" phenomena in neural tissue [22]. We consider our
interpretation of spectral exponents as normalizing constants
for logarithmically-determined energy levels to represent a
needed influx of reality into the field of neurological noise.
Fig. 4: Periodogram of AR-GVZM simulation of EEG noise,
with K = 300, using the Fig. 3a parameters.
IV. AUTOREGRESSIVE GVZM SIMULATIONS OF EEG
NOISE
The GVZM noise model in Def. 3 concerns periodograms
and makes no claims about the underlying time domain signal
from which they were calculated. In this section, we define a
class of mixed autoregressive time series called autoregressive
GVZM (AR-GVZM) processes, which are useful simulations
of EEG noise and are closely associated with GVZM peri-
odograms. In Section IV-A, we define AR-GVZM processes
and show an example based on the parameters derived from
recorded data (Fig. 4), in Section IV-B we connect the asymp-
totic properties of AR-GVZM, periodograms to the GVZM
noise model.
A. AR-GVZM, Processes
Let 0 < υ1 < υ2 be fixed parameters with the dimension
of time, 0 < θ < 2 be dimensionless, and P0, Ps (cid:62) 0 have
dimension amplitude2/frequency. Let K > 0 be an integer and
define ∆υ = (υ2 − υ1) / (K − 1). Let ∆t > 0 be a time step.
01020304050−30−20−100102030405060HzdB AR−GVZM periodogramFitted GVZM PSD 6
Using (6), suppose the values fs (n) are also samples fs (n∆t)
of a continuous-time,
iid N (0, 1) process fs (t) which is
independent of all
the AR-
GVZM, processes xK (n) in (6) approach a continuous-time,
stationary, Gaussian, mixed AR process with autocorrelation
function
the ek (t)'s. We observe that
(5)
Let xk (n) be the 1st–order, stationary AR process [8]
RK (τ ) = P0
1
υ2−θ e−τ/υ∆υ + Ps · δ (t) .
For 0 (cid:54) k (cid:54) K − 1, define the AR coefficients ak, bk and
(cid:113)
weights wk by ak
wk
def=
(cid:115)
def= e−∆t/(υ1+k∆υ),
def=
bk
1 − a2
k,
1
(υ1 + k∆υ)2−θ ∆υ∆t.
(cid:112)
xk (n) = ak xk (n − 1) + bk
P0 ek (n) ,
where the error processes ek (n) are iid N (0, 1) random
variables.
Then EEG background processes can be modeled by the
discrete-time, mixed AR simulations
K−1(cid:88)
(cid:112)
xK (n) def=
wk·xk (n) +
Ps · fs (n) ,
(6)
k=0
where the error process fs (n) is an N (0, 1) random variable
which is independent of all the ek (n)'s. We call such processes
AR-GVZM, simulations of EEG noise.
Fig. 4 shows the periodogram of such a simulation xK (n),
with K = 300 AR subprocesses xk (n), using the GVZM
parameters that optimally fit the data of Fig. 3a. It can be
seen how accurately the periodogram of xK (n) matches the
characteristics of the recorded data, except for the SSVEP
response spike and the excess alpha-band power. Note that Fig.
4 is the periodogram of a simulated EEG time series, while
Fig. 3b shows the direct simulation of an EEG periodogram,
with no underlying time series.
B. The Convergence of AR-GVZM, Processes to the GVZM
Noise Model
(5). For small ∆t, we find ak = 1−∆t/υ and bk =(cid:112)2∆t/υ,
We choose some 0 (cid:54) k (cid:54) K − 1 and let υ = υ1 + k∆υ in
where we have ignored terms of order higher than ∆t. Defin-
ing ∆xk (n) def= xk (n) − xk (n − 1), we easily calculate
∆xk (n)
· xk (n − 1) =
+
∆t
(7)
Let yk (n) def= wk · xk (n). Using the definition of wk in (5),
2P0
υ∆t
· ek (n) .
1
υ
(7) becomes
(cid:114)
(cid:114)
∆yk (n)
∆t
+
1
υ
· yk (n − 1) =
2P0
υ · υ2−θ ∆υ · ek (n) .
Now suppose the values ek (n) are samples ek (n∆t) of a
continuous-time, iid N (0, 1) process ek (t). Then, as ∆t → 0,
yk (n) will approach a continuous-time, stationary, Gaussian
AR process yk (t) satisfying the stochastic differential equa-
tion
dyk
dt
+
1
υ
· yk (t) =
2P0
υ · υ2−θ ∆υ · ek (t) .
(8)
(cid:114)
It is well-known [6] that the autocorrelation function of yk (t)
satisfying (8) is
Rk (τ ) = P0
1
υ2−θ e−τ/υ∆υ.
K−1(cid:88)
k=0
υ2(cid:90)
Therefore, as K → ∞, the xK (t)'s themselves will approach
a Gaussian process x∗ (t) with autocorrelation
R∗ (τ ) = P0
1
υ2−θ e−τ/υdυ + Ps · δ (τ ) .
(9)
υ1
It is now easy to check that the PSD function of x∗ (t), which
is the Fourier transform of R∗ (τ ) [7], is given precisely by
the formula of Eq. (1); i.e., the GVZM PSD function.
This is a significant result since zero-mean, Gaussian pro-
cesses are uniquely defined by their autocorrelation function
[8]. Noting that the GVZM periodogram model implies the
autocorrelation must be given by (9), if we make the additional
assumption that
the EEG noise time series is zero-mean,
Gaussian, then that time series must be x∗ (t). This means
that the AR-GVZM, simulations can be made to approximate
EEG background noise with arbitrary precision by means of
the double limiting process ∆t, ∆υ → 0 described above.
Note also that the converse can be proven using methods of
[8]; that is, if the EEG noise time series is given by limits of
AR-GVZM, processes, then the GVZM periodogram model
must be valid. This is important for practical applications be-
cause it defines the correct statistical model of the periodogram
if AR-GVZM, approximations are used to simulate EEG noise.
V. REAL-TIME BCI ALGORITHMS AND EEG NOISE
In this section, we explore two new SSVEP frequency
estimation algorithms we have designed, based on the GVZM
noise model, which we refer to as GVZM-χ2 and the GVZM-
F . We evaluate the performance of the new algorithms by
comparing each with an existing, commonly-used procedure
(to be be described later). Our statistical analysis demonstates
that the GVZM-based algorithms outperform both their rivals.
In Section V-B we examine the GVZM-χ2 algorithm, which
is based on GVZM-χ2-critical
levels for the EEG peri-
odogram. These critical levels are curves drawn on the graph
of the periodogram, which are parallel to the GVZM spectrum
SGVZM (f ) defined in Section II-B. Each represents the PSD
level beneath which a random SGVZM (f ) · (1/2) χ2 (2) vari-
able should remain, with specified probability (see Fig. 5a and
Fig. 5b for examples of GVZM-χ2-critical levels.)
In Section V-C, we perform a statistical performance com-
parison of GVZM-χ2 against a commonly-used BCI algorithm
[11], [28], [29] we refer to as BCI-SNR. Note that BCI-SNR is
based on forming certain ratios of periodogram values around
the frequencies that are being tested as SSVEP stimuli (see
Def. 4 in Section V-C).
Section V-D implements two versions of the well-known
periodogram F -test frequency estimation method used in [24],
[27]. The first version, which we call the smoothed-F algo-
rithm, is a direct implementation of [24]. The second version,
which we call the GVZM-F algorithm, replaces a key data-
estimated periodogram with the optimally-fitting GVZM PSD
and making no other alterations. We compare the performance
of the GVZM-F and the smoothed-F algorithms statistically.
All four algorithms are used as SSVEP frequency estimators
according to the protocol described in Appendix B. This
Appendix also describes the procedures we used to generate
the summary data statistics in Table I and Table II.
A. Set-up and Preprocessing
As our data, we used the publicly-available EEG recordings
[27] of four subjects undergoing a series of SSVEP exper-
iments, using a 128-channel Biosemi active-electrode EEG
system (http://www.biosemi.com) sampled at 256 Hz. Each
subject experienced 15 25-second trials divided into five trials
each of approximately 8 Hz, 16 Hz, and 28 Hz stimulation
frequencies. Each 25-second trial consisted of a 5-second
pre-stimulation epoch, a 15-second visual stimulation epoch,
and a 5-second post-stimulation epoch. Further experimental
conditions are presented in [27].
We preprocessed each epoch separately. Using standard
treatments for Biosemi recordings [27], quadratic trends in
each channel were removed and the central Cz channel (in
10/20-nomenclature was subtracted from all other electrodes.
A virtual electrode over the visual cortex was created by
averaging the Biosemi-nomenclature electrodes A14, A15,
A16, A21, A22, A23, A25, A27, A28, and A29. A virtual
electrode close to the eye muscles was created by averaging
the frontal 10/20 Fp2, Fpz, and Fp1 electrodes.The visual
electrode was linearly regressed onto the eye electrode and
the residual was used as the SSVEP response signal. This
simple method of removing eyeblink artifacts worked well for
our subjects.
We excluded the mid-alpha (9.5 Hz–13.5 Hz) and high beta
(23.5 Hz–26.5 Hz) non-stationary bands [24] from all PSD
functions, as well as frequencies below 6 Hz and above 50 Hz.
This left 614 frequencies per periodogram for testing against
the known stimuli.
The cumulative distribution functions (CDFs) of the BCI-
SNR statistic, required in Section V-C, were calculated by
bootstrap resampling [36]. Specifically, for every one of
the four subjects, each of their 15 pre-stimulation epochs
was independently concatenated to their 15 post-stimulation
epochs, yielding 225 sample baseline datasets which were then
multiplied by a Tukey window with parameter 0.1 (using the
window of [29]). For each baseline, the BCI-SNR statistic
was computed using equation Eq. (10) at each of the 614
test frequencies resulting in 614 "urns", each urn containing
the approximately 225 distinct SNR values which occured at
that frequency. For each test frequency, 1000 samples (with
replacement) of size 225 were then selected from its urn. Each
of these 1000 samples generated its own CDF. Then these
1000 CDFs were averaged to obtain a representative CDF at
7
that frequency. Repeating this procedure at every one of the
614 test frequencies yielded 614 empirical CDFs for each of
the four subjects.
The smoothed-F algorithm [24] of Section V-D estimated
the expected PSD of the pre-stimulation epoch xpre (n) by
the smoothed periodogram approach of [37]. The circular
autocorrelation [7] Rpre (m) of xpre (n) was computed and
then the DFT Spre (k) of the windowed autocorrelation h (m)·
Rpre (m) was regarded as the expected PSD. The window
h (m) was a symmetric Hamming window of length 2M + 1,
where M is approximately 10% of the data length of xpre (n).
In [24], the pre-stimulation data length was specifically chosen
to be same as the stimulated epoch xstim (n) so that their re-
spective DFTs Spre (k) and Sstim (k) could be compared easily
at equal frequency indices k. Since our pre-stimulation epochs
are shorter than the stimulation epochs, spline interperpolation
of Spre (k) was performed to resample it to the larger length.
We found that the 10% smoothed periodogram was sufficiently
smooth that such resampling was very accurate.
The authors of [24] time-averaged multiple epochs to im-
prove the SNR prior to detection. This required about 2 min-
utes of trial data, a very long duration for a practical real-time
BCI. For example, the longest epoch used by the well-known
and successful SSVEP BCI of [11] was 8 seconds, which was
then continuously processed to yield average inter-selection
intervals between 3.40 and 5.68 seconds. We therefore tested
the GVZM-F and smoothed-F algorithms on the single-trial,
unaveraged epochs of 15 seconds.
We performed the paired algorithm comparisons of GVZM-
χ2 vs. BCI-SNR in Section V-C and GVZM-F vs. smoothed-F
in Section V-D by procedures outlined in Appendix B. (See
Fig. 6, Fig. 8, Table I, and Table II.)
All fits of GVZM PSDs in Def. 2 to actual EEG peri-
odograms, used by both the GVZM-χ2 and GVZM-F algo-
rithms, were obtained by weighted least-squares optimization.
We used weights proportional to f β, for β ≈ 1.5, where the f
are the frequencies over which we are optimizing. We observed
that weighting increases the accuracy in the higher frequencies
where the signal power is inherently small.
Figures displaying spectra and the results of spectral
tests show power density S in dB relative to 1;
is
10 log10 (S/1). However, all actual critical values have been
determined and hypothesis tests were performed in the original
units of (amplitude unit)2/Hz.
that
B. Real-time Estimation of SSVEP Responses using the
GVZM-χ2 Algorithm
The most direct way to utilize the GVZM noise model in
an estimation algorithm is by optimally fitting a GVZM PSD
to recorded periodogram and calculating (1/2) χ2 (2) critical
levels parallel to it. Recall that a GVZM-χ2-critical level at
particular P -value is a curve parallel to SGVZM(f ), showing
the power below which periodogram values are confined with
probability 1−P , assuming the GVZM noise model to be cor-
rect. The frequencies of any spikes which extend above a pre-
assigned P -value then are regarded as positives: frequencies at
which the GVZM-χ2 algorithm will report the EEG as having
8
(b)
j=−n/2
j(cid:54)=0
(a)
Fig. 5: GVZM · (1/2) χ2 (2) critical levels corresponding to P = 0.005, 0.05, 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 0.95, 0.995 (top to bottom). (a)
8 Hz stimulus. (b) 28 Hz stimulus.
true power, not merely random noise. All others are reported
as negatives. In this way, stimulus frequency estimation is
implemented by a sequence of hypothesis tests [25], [38], one
at every frequency we intend to examine.
kth test frequency fk is the ratio
n · Sx (fk)
Sx (fk + j · ∆f )
SN Rx (fk) =
n/2(cid:80)
,
(10)
Fig. 5a and Fig. 5b show the results of the GVZM-
χ2 algorithm for SSVEP experiments at 8 Hz and 28 Hz
respectively (subject 3, trial 2). In particular, according to the
GVZM noise model, it is 99.5% probable that a spectral spike
will lie below the upper dashed critical level. These critical
levels also display how accurately the GVZM noise model
fits the spectra of recorded EEG background processes.
It
is clear from Fig. 5a that
the GVZM-χ2 algorithm
accurately estimated the 8Hz fundamental SSVEP response
and its two harmonics at significance level P = 0.005, thus
generating no false negatives (also called) Type II errors [25]).
Moreover, it has correctly excluded all other spikes as simply
random noise and thus avoided all false positives. (Also called
Type I errors [25] or false discoveries [38]).
In Fig. 5b the 28 Hz response was estimated accurately
however there are several false positives arising, because of
non-stationary power in the alpha- and beta-bands (approxi-
mately 25 Hz). As discussed in Section V-A, such bands need
to be pre-excluded from the frequencies to be tested.
C. SSVEP Frequency Estimation Using the GVZM-χ2 and
BCI-SNR Algorithms
In this section, we describe the BCI-SNR algorithm and
compare it to the GVZM-χ2 algorithm.
The BCI-SNR statistic for SSVEP procedures was first
defined in [11], where it was used as a simple measure of
signal strength for determining optimal stimulus frequencies.
It subsequently became a popular frequency estimator for
SSVEP BCIs [29] and more general applications [19]. The
phrase "power spectral density analysis" (PSDA) also has been
used [28] for methods based on the BCI-SNR.
Definition 4. The BCI-SNR statistic [11] of a signal x at the
where Sx is an estimator of the sample spectrum, ∆f is the
spectral resolution of the estimated frequency domain, and n
is a small integer. To be consistent with [29], we use n = 6.
The BCI-SNR statistic is sometimes used as a non-blind
detector for a short list f1, . . . , fK of known SSVEP BCI
selection frequencies. The subject's selection is considered to
be that frequency fk which has the largest SN Rx value; i.e.,
SN Rx (fk). (For example, [28], [29].)
fselected = argmaxfk
To use the BCI-SNR algorithm as a blind SSVEP frequency
estimator, as described by Appendix B, we require each
individual probability distribution function of SN Rx (fk) for
every test frequency fk. These were estimated by bootstrap
resampling as described in Section V-A.
Fig. 6: GVZM-χ2 vs. BCI-SNR example:
the minimum-
variance, unbiased, single-trial ROC estimator, showing op-
timal operating points, using the 28 Hz data of Fig. 1.
Fig. 6 shows an example of a minimum-variance, unbiased,
single-trial estimate of the comparison receiver operating
01020304050−1001020304050HzdB Harmonics at 16 Hz, 24 HzTrue positive at P < .005for 8 Hz response01020304050−1001020304050HzdB True positive at P < .005for 28 Hz responsealpha−bandpower00.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9100.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.91FPRTPR GVZM−χ2: Optimal confusion = 10.97% Optimal truth rate = 89.41%BCI−SNR: Optimal confusion = 48.74% Optimal truth rate = 52.87% characteristics (ROC) graph [39] as described in Appendix
B. The dataset is that of Fig. 1 (subject 3, trial 1, 28 Hz
stimulus).
In Fig. 6, TPR and FPR denote the true and false positive
rates, calculated at 256 operating points as detailed in the
Appendix. Confusion measures the fractional distance of an
operating point from ideal performance TPR = 1, FPR = 0
while the truth rate is a weighted average of the TPR and the
true negative rate TNR = (1 - FPR) intended as a measure of
accuracy Confusion =
(cid:113)
(1 − TPR)2 + FPR2/
√
2
Truth Rate = (1 − p0) · TPR + p0 · (1 − FPR) ,
where 0 (cid:54) p0 (cid:54) 1. In a Bayesian situation, with p0 the
probability of the null hypothesis [25], the truth rate is the
probability of a true decision. We assume p0 = 1/2.
We observe that the GVZM-χ2 algorithm outperforms the
BCI-SNR algorithm at nearly every operating point. Moreover,
even on this very difficult 28Hz stimulus, the optimal operating
point for GVZM-χ2 identifies the true stimulus frequency with
probability above 90% with FPR below 20%.
PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT OF GVZM-χ2 OVER
TABLE I
BCI-SNR
Combined Opti-
mal Results
Confusion
Decrease
TruthRate
Increase
%
29.77
17.92
Unconfused
Trials
34
34
Pooled SE
t-score
0.0371
0.0356
3.253
3.133
df
11
11
P-value
0.004
0.005
Table I summarizes the pooled ROC results for N = 34
trials, in which at least one of the algorithms had confusion
below 35% ("unconfused" trials by definition). Pooled SE
denotes the standard error
(cid:113)
Pooled SE =
(σ2
GVZM + σ2
SNR) /N
appropriate to the t-test for the difference of means.
Table I shows that the GVZM-χ2 algorithm outperforms
the BCI-SNR algorithm on both the confusion and truth rate
measures with statistical significance above 99%.
D. SSVEP Frequency Estimation Using the GVZM-F and
Smoothed-F Algorithms
In [24], the authors assume, based on the theory of pe-
riodograms developed in detail in [8], that the periodogram
random process Sx (k), 0 (cid:54) k (cid:54) N−1 of the EEG background
time series x (n) is given asymptotically by
Sx (k) = E [Sx (k)] · (1/2) Ξ (k) ,
(11)
where Ξ (k), 0 (cid:54) k (cid:54) N − 1 is a process with Ξ (k) ∼ χ2 (2)
and which are independent for 0 (cid:54) k, l < N/2 with k (cid:54)= l.
If the function E [Sx (k)] were known, then (11) implies that
the test statistics
sx (k) def= 2 · Sx (k) / E [Sx (k)]
for 0 (cid:54) k (cid:54) N − 1 would be iid χ2 (2) random variables.
A fixed set of indices Ω ⊆ {0, 1,··· , N − 1} is selected to
represent what we regard as stationary frequencies; e.g., alpha-
band frequencies are excluded (cf. Section V-A). Then, under
the null hypothesis that there is no SSVEP spike at frequency
9
(12)
index ktest we have(cid:80)
(cid:80)
k∈Ωtest
sx (k) / Ntest
sx (k(cid:48)) / (NΩ − Ntest)
k(cid:48)∈Ω\Ωtest
∼ F (Ntest, NΩ − Ntest) ,
where Ωtest is the set of indices ktest and its harmonics in Ω,
Ntest is the size of Ωtest, NΩ the size of Ω, and F (d1, d2) is
the F –distribution with degrees of freedom d1, d2 [25].
The key issue is how to obtain the function E [Sx (k)].
In [24], the authors estimated this function by computing
a "smoothed periodogram" Ssmooth (k) of a pre-stimulation
epoch as described in Section V-A and used Ssmooth (k) as
a substitute for E [Sx (k)]. This constituted their smoothed-F
algorithm.
However, by using the GVZM noise model, we expect to
obtain a more accurate baseline estimate by using the GVZM
PSD which optimally fits the same pre-stimulus epoch as a
substitute for E [Sx (k)]. This is our GZVM-F algorithm. Fig.
7 shows the periodogram from the pre-stimulus epoch of the
data of Fig. 1 (subject 3, trial 1, 28Hz stimulus) with both the
smoothed periodogram and the fitted GVZM PSD displayed.
The two algorithms are compared as described in Appendix
B. Fig. 8 shows an example of a minimum-variance, unbiased,
single-trial estimate of the comparison ROC graph.
Fig. 7: Baseline (non-stimulus) PSDs used as the 28 Hz, χ2
references for the smoothed-F and GVZM-F algorithms.
The dataset is that of Fig. 1 (subject 3, trial 1, 28 Hz stimu-
lus). As in Section V-C, the GVZM-F algorithm outperforms
the smoothed-F algorithm at nearly every operating point,
achieving an optimal performance of over 95% probability of
true identification with just above 20% FPR.
PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT OF GVZM-F OVER
TABLE II
SMOOTHED-F
Combined Opti-
mal Results
Confusion
Decrease
TruthRate
Increase
%
30.57
12.67
Unconfused
Trials
56
56
Pooled SE
t-score
0.0322
0.0278
2.901
3.234
df
11
11
P-value
0.007
0.004
010203040500102030405060HzdB Recorded EEGSmoothed−FGVZM−F Table II summarizes the pooled ROC results as described
in Appendix B for the 56 trials in which at least one of the
algorithms had confusion below 35%. The large number of
unconfused trials of these algorithms is a result of the inherent
stability of the carefully-designed underlying statistic (12).
Table II shows that GVZM-F algorithm outperforms the
smoothed-F algorithm on both the confusion and accuracy
measures with statistical significance above 99%.
10
signal simulation, and neuroscience investigations. In addition,
we believe our applied results indirectly validate quantum ion
channel maximum entropy analysis, which is the theoretical
foundation of the GVZM noise model.
VII. APPENDICES
Appendix A presents the background for a useful class
of random processes we call ARM A(P, Q, N ) processes
which provide motivation for the GVZM model of Section
II. Appendix B is an overview of the statistical methodology
used for the algorithm comparisons of Section V.
A. The Periodogram Distribution of Periodic ARMA Processes
Definition 5. A periodic Gaussian ARM A (P, Q, N ) pro-
cess is a zero-mean, stationary random process {x (n)}∞
n=−∞
satisfying
P(cid:88)
Q(cid:88)
ap x (n − p) =
bq ν (n − q),
(13)
Fig. 8: GVZM-F vs. Smoothed-F example: the minimum-
variance, unbiased, single-trial ROC estimator, showing op-
timal operating points, using the 28 Hz data of Fig. 1.
VI. CONCLUSIONS
In this paper, we showed the necessity of accurate statistical
models of EEG background noise for applications to neuro-
science, neurology, and real-time BCIs.
Based on our analysis and numerical experiments, we
proposed a specific, five-parameter statistical family of EEG
background periodograms using the GVZM PSD function. To
the best of our knowledge, the GVZM PSD function is the
only EEG noise PSD model with a fixed number of parameters,
matches recorded EEG PSD's with high accuracy over the full
spectrum from 0 Hz to 30 Hz, and has approximately 1/f θ
behavior in the mid-frequencies without infinities.
We validated this model using three complementary ap-
proaches. First, we briefly discussed our theoretical work [33]
on neurological ion channels and quantum stochastic processes
and noted that this theory implies the applicability of the
GVZM PSD function to large networks of ion channels in
maximum entropy statistical equilibrium. Second, we pre-
sented a class of time series we call AR-GVZM, processes
which simulate EEG background noise. We showed that the
periodograms of AR-GVZM, processes approach the GVZM
PSD function as the number of subprocesses becomes large.
Third, we designed two algorithms to estimate SSVEP
frequencies for real-time BCI applications and applied them to
a public set of SSVEP recorded data. We showed statistically
that both GVZM-based algorithms were more accurate than
two commonly used alternatives, even on difficult data.
We conclude that the GVZM noise model accurately char-
acterizes the statistics of EEG background periodograms and,
therefore, is a very suitable model for algorithm design, brain
p=0
q=0
for all n, and the polynomials A (z) = (cid:80)P
B (z) =(cid:80)Q
where a0 = b0 = 1 and {ν (n)}∞
n=−∞ is an iid, zero-mean,
Gaussian process which is N-periodic: ν (n + N ) = ν (n),
p=0 apzp and
q=0 bqzq have no common zeros. The equality in
the periodicity condition is meant to be exact; i.e., there are
really only N distinct random processes ν (0) , . . . , ν (N − 1).
Definition 6. An ARM A (P, Q, N ) system is causal [8] if
the polynomial A (z) defined above has no zeros on or inside
the unit circle.
Theorem 2. Let x (0) , . . . , x (N − 1) be one period of a
causal Gaussian ARM A (P, Q, N ) process and let Sx (k),
0 (cid:54) k (cid:54) N − 1, be its periodogram (Def. 1). Then
(cid:12)(cid:12)B(cid:0)e−i(2πk/N )(cid:1)(cid:12)(cid:12)2
(cid:12)(cid:12)A(cid:0)e−i(2πk/N )(cid:1)(cid:12)(cid:12)2 · (1/2) Ξ (k) ,
ν ·
Sx (k) = 2πσ2
where Ξ (k), 0 (cid:54) k (cid:54) N − 1, is a sequence of χ2 (2)
distributed [25] random variables which are independent for
0 (cid:54) k, l < N/2 when k (cid:54)= l and σ2
ν is the variance of ν (n) .
Because of space limitations, we omit the proof of this
result, which is a simple application of the techniques of [8].
B. Comparison Protocols for SSVEP Estimation Algorithms
To simplify analysis of the algorithms of Section V, all four
were reduced to a common m-ary test [38] protocol, outlined
by the flow chart Fig. 9.
Every f ∈ Ftest in a given set of test frequencies is to
be independently judged by the algorithm for its presence
or absence as an SSVEP stimulus in the experimental peri-
odogram S. No constraint is placed on the number of test
frequencies f ∈ Ftest the algorithm may report as present
(positives, P), absent (negatives, N), or undetermined (u). Both
pairs in a comparison (GVZM-χ2 vs. BCI-SNR and GVZM-
F vs. smoothed-F ) are tested against the same ground truth,
which has access to the true SSVEP stimulus frequencies
00.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9100.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.91FPRTPR GVZM−F: Optimal confusion = 16.69% Optimal truth rate = 87.21%Smoothed−F: Optimal confusion = 39.72% Optimal truth rate = 68.18% Fig. 9: Flow chart for the calculation of CT (α, ∆f ; S): the minimum variance, unbiased, single-trial estimator of the 3 × 3
contingency table of the input periodogram S, with ROC control parameters α, ∆f.
and possible harmonics for this experiment. Each algorithm
is characterized by a test statistic X (S, f ) with CDFs
11
minimum variance unbiased estimator of CT (· ) [25], can be
calculated. From the cells of CT (S) , we can derive the TPR
and FPR (Section V-C) as TPR def= TP/Na, FPR def= FP/N0,
where TP, FP are the number of true and false positives and
Na,N0 are the number of true hypotheses Ha,H0 respectively.
As seen in Fig. 9, the estimator CT (α, δf ; S) depends
on the parameters α, δf. By varying these, we can plot the
resulting operating points (FPR (α, δf ) , TPR (α, δf )) on a
single-trial ROC graph [39]. The ROC determines the optimal
values of α, δf for the periodogram S. Fig. 6 and Fig. 8
show the operating points of 256 choices of α, δf for the
various algorithms, on the Fig. 1 periodogram, as well as
the optimal operating points according to the two accuracy
measures described in Section V-C.
By creating single-trial ROCs for all periodograms S in
an experiment, the statistical distribution of optimal accuracy
measures can be inferred. Table I and Table II show the analy-
sis of N = 12 optimal operating point measures corresponding
to the three subjects and four possible stimulus frequencies,
each of which were tested in five trials (Section V-A).
REFERENCES
PX (x, f ) def= Prob [X (S, f ) (cid:54) x] ,
where S is a random variable varying over all possible
periodograms that X (· , f ) could receive (S is a particular
value of S). We assume that the larger the value of X (S, f ),
the more likely f is a stimulus frequency.
GVZM-χ2: X (S, f ) = S (f ) /SGVZM (f ) and PX (x, f )
is given by the inverse (1/2)· χ2 (2) distribution (see Eq. (3)).
BCI-SNR: X (S, f ) is given by Eq. (10) and the CDFs are
obtained empirically by bootstrap resampling as described in
Section V-A.
GVZM-F: X (S, f ) is the ratio Eq. (12), with E [Sx (k)]
the GVZM fit to the baseline data. The CDFs are the inverse
F distribution with appropriate degrees of freedom.
smoothed-F: X (S, f ) is the ratio Eq. (12), with E [Sx (k)]
the smoothed periodogram of [37].The CDFs are the inverse
F distribution with appropriate degrees of freedom.
Let 0 (cid:54) α (cid:54) 1 be the 1-ary significance level. The αp-urn
for X (S, f ) is a conceptual container of paired values x0 (cid:54) x1
whose likelihood of occurrence is determined by PX (x, f ).
The αp-urn test is the following randomized procedure:
Calculate X (S, f ) and independently select a pair x0, x1 from
the αp-urn. Then f is adjudged present in S if X (S, f ) (cid:62) x1,
absent if X (S, f ) < x0, and undetermined otherwise.
Ground truth answers questions about binary hypotheses
H0 (f ) , Ha (f ), where the null hypothsis H0 (f ) is: frequency
f is not an SSVEP stimulus. It may fail to answer, which
we symbololize in Fig. 9 by "h (f )". Since no estimation
algorithm can be 100% accurate, ground truth must contain a
parameter δf which determines how much error f − fssvep
it will
tolerate between a test frequency f and a known
stimulus or harmonic frequency fssvep. We have found SSVEP
estimation to be very sensitive to δf and its optimal value must
be determined for each subject during pre-test training.
With these definitions, the single-trial contingency table
CT (S) can be calculated as shown in Fig. 9. Note that
multiple true positives are possible, even with a single stim-
ulus frequency fssvep, both because ground truth may report
harmonics of fssvep and because the resolution δf > 0 must
report test frequencies in an interval around fssvep. When a
particular periodogram S = S is analyzed, the conditional ex-
pectation CT (S) def= E [CT (· ) S], which is known to be the
[1] T. Hill and Y.-D. Chen, "On the theory of ion transport across the nerve
membrane, IV. Noise from the open-close kinetics of K+ channels,"
Biophys. J., vol. 12, pp. 948–959, 1972.
[2] A. Manwani and C. Koch, "Detecting and estimating signals in noisy ca-
ble structures, I: Neuronal noise sources," Neural Computation, vol. 11,
pp. 1797–1829, 1999.
[3] B. Hille, Ion Channels of Excitable Membranes, 3rd ed. Sunderland,
MA: Sinauer Associates, Inc., 2001.
[4] K. Diba, H. Lester, and C. Koch, "Intrinsic noise in cultured hippocam-
pal neurons: Experiment and modeling," J. of Neuroscience, vol. 24,
no. 43, pp. 9723–9733, October 27, 2004.
[5] P. L. Nunez and R. Srinivasan, Electric fields of
the brain: The
neurophysics of EEG, 2nd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006.
[6] A. Destexhe and M. Rudolph-Lilith, Neuronal Noise, ser. Springer Series
in Computational Neuroscience, Vol. 8. Springer, 2012.
[7] A. V. Oppenheim and R. W. Schafer, Digital Signal Processing.
Englewood Cliffs, N.J: Prentice-Hall, 1975, includes bibliographical
references.
[8] P. J. Brockwell and R. A. Davis, Time Series: Theory and Methods,
2nd ed. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1991.
[9] S. J. Luck, An Introduction to the Event-Related Potential Technique,
2nd ed. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2014.
[10] L. Rankine, N. Stevenson, M. Mesbah, and B. Boashash, "A nonstation-
ary model of newborn EEG," IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng., vol. 54, no. 1,
pp. 19–28, January 2007.
[11] Y. Wang, R. Wang, X. Gao, B. Hong, and S. Gao, "A practical VEP-
based brain-computer interface," IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng., vol. 14,
no. 2, pp. 234–239, 2006.
12
[35] J. Woodbury, "Eyring rate theory model of the current-voltage relation-
ships of ion channels in excitable membranes," in Advances in Chemical
Physics, Volume XVI.
John Wiley and Sons Ltd., 1969, pp. 601–617.
[36] B. Efron and R. J. Tibshirani, An Introduction to the Bootstrap, ser.
New York:
Monographs on Statistics and Applied Probability 57.
Chapman & Hall, 1993.
[37] L. Ljung, System Identification – Theory for the User.
Englewood
Cliffs, N.J: Prentice-Hall, 1987.
[38] Y. Benjamini, A. M. Krieger, and D. Yekutieli, "Adaptive linear step-up
procedures that control the false discovery rate," Biometrika, vol. 93,
no. 3, pp. 491 – 507, 2006.
[39] T. Fawcett, "An introduction to ROC analysis," Pattern Recognition
Letters, no. 27, pp. 861 – 871, 2006.
[12] B. Z. Allison, D. J. McFarland, G. Schalk, S. D. Zheng, M. M. Jackson,
and J. R. Wolpaw, "Towards an independent brain-computer interface
using steady state visual evoked potentials," Clin. Neurophysiol., vol.
119, no. 2, pp. 399–408, 2008.
[13] R. Tetzlaff, T. Niederhofer, and P. Fischer, "Automated detection of
a preseizure state: Non-linear EEG analysis in epilepsy by cellular
nonlinear networks and Volterra systems," Int. J. Circuit Th. and
Applications., vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 89–108, Jan-Feb 2006.
[14] B. Katz and R. Miledi, "The statistical nature of the acetycholine
potential and its molecular components," J. Physiol., vol. 224, pp. 665–
699, 1972.
[15] A. D´ıez, V. Suazo, P. Casado, M. Mart´ın-Loeches, and V. Molina,
"Spatial distribution and cognitive correlates of gamma noise power in
schizophrenia," Psychological Medicine, vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 1175–1185,
June 2013.
[16] O. Vysata, A. Proch´azka, J. Mares, R. Rusina, L. Pazdera, M. Valis,
and J. Kukal, "Change in the characteristics of EEG color noise in
Alzheimer's disease," Clinical EEG And Neuroscience, vol. 45, no. 3,
pp. 147–151, July 2014.
[17] R. Legenstein and W. Maass, "Ensembles of spiking neurons with
noise support optimal probabilistic inference in a dynamically changing
environment," PLoS Computational Biology, vol. 10, no. 10, pp. 1–27,
10 2014.
[18] K. D. Miller and T. W. Troyer, "Neural noise can explain expansive,
power-law nonlinearities in neural response functions," J. Neurophysiol.,
vol. 87, pp. 653–659, 2002.
[19] F.-B. Vialette, M. Marice, J. Dauwels, and A. Cichocki, "Steady-state
evoked potentials: Focus on essential paradigms and future perspectives,"
Progress in Neurobiology, no. 90, pp. 418–438, 2010.
[20] C. S. Herrmann, "Human EEG responses to 1-100 Hz flicker: Resonance
phenomena in visual cortex and their potential correlation to cognitive
phenomena," Exper. Brain Res., vol. 137, no. 3-4, pp. 346–353, Apr.
2001.
[21] G. R. Muller-Putz, R. Scherer, C. Brauneis, and G. Pfurtscheller,
"Steady-state visual evoked potential (SSVEP)-based communication:
impact of harmonic frequency components," J. of Neural Eng., vol. 2,
no. 4, pp. 123–130, Dec. 2005.
[22] B. Mandelbrot, Multifractals and 1/f Noise. New York: Springer-Verlag,
1999.
[23] K. Linkenhaer-Hansen, V. V. Nikouline, J. M. Palva, and R. Ilmoniemi,
"Long-range temporal correlations and scaling behavior in human brain
oscillations," J. of Neuroscience, no. 4, pp. 1370–1377, February 2001.
[24] A. P. Liavas, G. V. Moustakides, G. Henning, E. Psarakis, and P. Husar,
"A periodogram-based method for the detection of steady-state visually
evoked potentials," IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng., vol. 45, pp. 242–248,
Feb. 1998.
[25] A. M. Mood, F. A. Graybill, and D. C. Boes, Introduction to the Theory
of Statistics, 3rd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1974.
[26] A. M. L. F. M. de S´a, A. F. C. Infantosi, and V. V. Lazarev, "Evaluating
the event-related synchronization and desynchronization by means of a
statistical frequency test," in 29th Annual International Conference of the
IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, Cit´e Internationale,
Lyon, France, 2007.
[27] H. Bakardjian, T. Tanaka, and A. Cichocki, "Optimization of SSVEP
brain responses with application to eight-command brain computer
interface," Neurosci Lett., vol. 469, no. 1, pp. 34–38, 2010. [Online].
Available: http://www.bakardjian.com/work/ssvep data Bakardjian.html
[28] Q. Wei, M. Xiao, and Z. Lu, "A comparative study of correlation analysis
and power spectral density analysis for SSVEP detection," in Third
International Conference on Intelligent Human-Machine Systems and
Cybernetics, 2011, pp. 7–10.
[29] R. Ku´s, A. Dusyk, P. Milanowski, M. Łabec¸ki et al., "On the quantifi-
cation of SSVEP frequency responses in human EEG in realistic BCI
conditions," PLoS ONE, vol. 8, no. 10, pp. e77 536:1–9, October 2013.
[30] J. Bernamont, Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond., vol. 49, p. 138, 1937.
[31] A. L. McWhorter, "1/f noise and related surface effects in Germanium,
MIT Lincoln Laboratory Report No. 80," in Semiconductor Surface
Physics, R. Kingston, Ed. Univ. of Penns. Press, 1957, p. 207.
[32] A. van der Ziel, Appl. Phys. Lett., pp. 883–884, 1978.
[33] A. Paris, G. Atia, A. Vosoughi, and S. Berman, "Formalized Quantum
Stochastic Processes and Hidden Quantum Models with Applications to
Neuron Ion Channel Kinetics," [Online], 2015, Available: http://arXiv.
org/abs/1511.00057.
[34] A. Hodgkin and A. Huxley, "A quantitative description of membrane
current and its application to conduction and excitation in nerve," J.
Physiol., vol. 117, pp. 500–544, 1952.
|
1804.10093 | 1 | 1804 | 2018-04-26T14:42:03 | A GPP algorithm for hippocampal interneuron characterization | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Correctly identifying neuronal subsets is critical to multiple downstream methods in several areas of neuroscience research. The hippocampal interneuron characterization technology has achieved rapid development in recent years. However, capturing true neuronal features for accurate interneuron characterization and segmentation has remained elusive. In the current study, a novel global preserving estimate algorithm is used to capture the non-linearity in the features of hippocampal interneurons after factor Algorithm. Our results provide evidence for the effective integration of the original linear and nonlinear neuronal features and achieves better characterization performance on multiple hippocampal interneuron databases through array matching. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | A GPP ALGORITHM FOR
HIPPOCAMPAL INTERNEURON
CHARACTERIZATION
KATHERINE MEDINA
SCHOOL OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, UNIVERSITY OF VALPARAÍSO, VALPARAÍSO,
REGIÓN DE VALPARAÍSO, CHILE
CORRESPONDING AUTHOR: KATHERINE MEDINA ([email protected])
Abstract
Correctly identifying neuronal subsets is critical to multiple downstream methods in several areas of
neuroscience research. The hippocampal interneuron characterization technology has achieved rapid
development in recent years. However, capturing true neuronal features for accurate interneuron
characterization and segmentation has remained elusive. In the current study, a novel global preserving
estimate algorithm is used to capture the nonlinearity in the features of hippocampal interneurons
after factor Algorithm. Our results provide evidence for the effective integration of the original linear
and nonlinear neuronal features and achieves better characterization performance on multiple
hippocampal interneuron databases through Array matching.
Key words
Hippocampal Interneuron Characterization, Globally Preserving Estimate, Factor Algorithm
1． INTRODUCTION
As a key area of biologic characterization technology, hippocampal interneuron characterization
technology has achieved rapid development in recent years. A large number of Array characterization
technologies are applied in this field. The main application areas include: FACS based characterization,
immunological characterization, man-machine interaction and so on.
1
From the main process of hippocampal interneuron characterization we can see that the feature
mining and processing as well as classifier selection are the main factors that affect the characterization
performance. The Factor Algorithm (FA) [1], Linear Differential Algorithm (LDA) [2] and Globally
Preserving Estimates (GPP) [3] algorithm have been proved to be able to greatly improve the
characterization rate. It is found that the hippocampal interneuron global feature mining can represent
the hippocampal interneuron overall contour and any other global data, but it is sensitive to changes
of illumination and posture. The native feature mining can represent the native detail of hippocampal
interneuron and has certain robustness to light, but representational capacity for overall data is not
strong [4]. The union of global eigen hippocampal interneurons and native Gabor features improves
the characterization rate, but due to the complexity of computation and the long computation time, its
application scope is limited [5].By using the TAT feature to describe the hippocampal interneuron
features, and extracts the global data and native data. Characterization ability is improved to some
extent. However, the union process of global features and the native features is just amalgamating,
lacking effective integration [6].
In this paper, aiming at the shortcomings of the algorithm, the GPP is introduced to extract the
features. At the same time, Euclidean correlation Algorithm [7] is used to integrate the global features
and the native features effectively, and constructs classifier by the Array Matching algorithm [8]. After
comparing and aggregating multiple hippocampal interneuron databases, the algorithm is better than
contrast algorithm, and has high characterization performance.
2. FEATURE MINING AND DIMENSION DECLINE ALGORITHM
2.1 TAT FEATURE MINING
TAT feature descriptor is evolved from the HULT operator, which can describe the native
difference data of the imprint well and is not easily disturbed by the noise. The TAT feature mining
process is as follows:
Step1. Imprint cropping, in this paper, the imprint length and height can be divisible by 16;
Step2. The divided sample imprint is a number of small blocks, each consists of 4 adjacent cells.
The block slides in the form of overlapping two cells, selects unsigned gradient direction, the number
of the gradient direction angles is 9, the parallel and vertical gradients of the pixel point
in the
imprint are computed as follows:
（1）
（2）
2
(,)xy(,)(1,)(1,)xIxyIxyIxy(,)(,1)(,1)yIxyIxyIxy
The gradient amplitude and the gradient direction of the pixel point
are derived respectively
（3）
（4）
The histogram features of all the pixels in all directions are counted so as to obtain the histogram
features of each cell, and further the histogram of each block is derived.
Step3. Cascading the histogram features of each block sequentially to obtain the overall TAT
feature
of the overall imprint.
For instance: an imprint with a width of 92 * height of 112, each line has (112-16) / 8 + 1 = 13
blocks, since each column cannot be divisible by 16, first incise it to make it into 80, and then compute
the total (80-16) / 8 +1 = 9 blocks, then the whole imprint has 13 * 9 = 117 blocks, each of which has 2
* 2 cells and each cell has 9 bins, and all the feature dimensions of each block are 2 * 2 * 9 = 36
dimensions, thus the TAT feature dimensions of the entire imprint is 117 * 36 = 4212.
In the selection of native features, the difference of the coordinates of the key parts of
hippocampal interneuron is relatively small. After comparison, the selected
pcs sub-blocks can
contain most of the classified data easily, which can not only reduce the feature dimension and
computational complexity, but also the characterization rate will not change too much. In this paper, it
adopts the same steps as the global feature mining method to extract the above
pcs sub-block
features. The original native TAT features are
.
2.2 GPP ALGORITHM
Global features and native features derived through TAT feature mining still have certain
complexity in describing data. In order to improve characterization performance, some transpositions
are needed to extract features. For global features, 2DFA algorithm is used to reduce dimensionality,
compared with the traditional FA, 2DFA algorithm is easier and more accurate to compute distribution
Array, and its corresponding eigenvector is faster; for native features, this paper uses the traditional FA
dimensionality decline method. Because the essence of FA and 2DFA algorithms are still linear, it cannot
effectively describe the non-linear change of hippocampal interneuron imprint data. In this paper,
Globally Preserving Estimates (GPP) algorithm is applied to non-linear data in hippocampal interneuron
imprints capture, GPP algorithm is a kind of new subspace Algorithm method, a linear approximation
of the Laplacian Eigen map nonlinear method, which not only solves the shortcomings of the traditional
3
(,)xy22(,)((,))((,))xymxyIxyIxy(,)(,)arctan(,)xyIxyxyIxyASLL{1,2,,}iBiLL
linear methods such as FA that is difficult to maintain the original data nonlinear manifold, but also
solves the shortcomings of nonlinear method that is difficult to obtain the new sample point's low-
dimensional estimate.
Globally preserving estimates look for linear transpositions
through certain performance goals
in order to achieve dimensionality decline for high-dimensional data:
（5）
Given the existence of
training segments
, the transposition Array can be
derived by minimizing the following objective function:
（6）
Among them,
is the weight Array, which can be defined by nearest neighbor method:
（7）
Among them,
is the
Conduct formula (6) algebraic changes
（8）
Among them,
,
is a
diagonal Array, diagonal element is
,
.
The transposition Array
deduced minimum value can be derived by solving the following
generalized eigenvalue problem.
（9）
The eigenvectors corresponding to
pcs smallest non-zero eigenvalues of the above formula
form a estimate Array
. Due to the small sample problem existing in the GPP
4
W,1,2,TijyWxjlLl1lmiiXxR2,min())TTijijijWxWxSSk2exp(ijijxxStjxknearest neighbor of ixTT212,TTTT,,TTTT)()ijijijiiiiiijiijijWxWxSWxDxWWxSxWWXDSXWWXLXW12[,,]lXxxxLDlliiijjDSLDSWTTXLXWXDXWd12[,,]dWwwwL
algorithm, 2DFA and FA are used to reduce the dimension of the global feature and the native feature
respectively, then the GPP algorithm is applied to construct the facial features in the reduced dimension
subspace. In order to be able to perform 2DFA processing on the global TAT feature, the global TAT
feature vector is considered as an array, and the final global TAT feature
is derived finally through
dimensionality decline by the above algorithm.
For native features
, the FA algorithm is firstly used to reduce the dimension and then GPP
algorithm is used to obtain the final native TAT feature
in the FA subspace.
3. FEATURE UNION AND CLASSIFIER LEARN ING ALGORITHM
3.1 FEATURE UNION
How to use the extracted global features and native features rationally to realize effective
hippocampal interneuron characterization is considered as the next problem. If we just merge the two
groups of features end-to-end by Array (vector) to generate a new feature vector, it will lack rational
use of valuable identification data, feature union through effective optimization combination not only
retain the participant multi-feature identification data, but also to some extent eliminate redundant
data due to subjective factors, is of great significance to improve the characterization rate. In this paper,
Euclidean Correlation Algorithm (ECA) is introduced to achieve feature union.
Euclidean Correlation Algorithm (ECA) process is as follows:
Step1, extract the global and native eigenvectors of the same Array based on the algorithms
described in 2.1 and 2.2 to construct the transformed sample space A and B;
Step2, compute the overall covariance Array
and
of A and B segments, and mutual
covariance Array
;
Step3, according to Theorem 1
in the
literature, compute the nonzero eigenvalues
of
and
as well as the corresponding orthonormal eigenvectors
;
Step4, according to Theorem 1 to compute all the typical estimate vector
,
take the former
pairs of the estimate vector to form the transposition Array
and
The above ECA estimate arrays are constructed with all the native feature subsets
and global features
respectively,
5
AFiB{1,2,,}iFiLLxxSyySxyS22212rL1G2G,(1,2,)iiuvirL(1,2,)iiirL与dxWyW{1,2,,10}iFiLAF
Then 10 estimate Array pairs
are derived, and the estimate Array is
used to respectively extract features from the corresponding feature subsets.
3.2 Classification Algorithm
For a certain sample to be charecterized, firstly, it is divided into pcs subsets according to the
uniform rules, and then based on the construction method of the above sub-Arrays,
pcs feature sub-
vectors
to be tested are derived, and the consistency between two feature sub-vectors
and
can be defined as:
(10)
First, compute the displacement between the ith sub-segments to be tested and the feature
subvector used in the corresponding sub-Array, and then determine the categories of the sub-sample
and a sub-sample most consistent with the sub-sample, call it as
. Finally, correct ultimate
attribution of the sample to be tested by simple voting, and the probability that the sample to be tested
is charecterized as the kth class can be defined as:
(11)
In the formula, when the first sub-mode of the sample to be tested is judged as the first kth class,
the value of
is 1, otherwise the value is 0. Finally, the characterization result of the sample under
test is recorded as:
(12)
4. EXPERIMENTAL RESU LTS AND ALGORITHM
4.1 PRETREATMENT
In this paper, we test the hippocampal interneuron database, mainly including GMR, MIT, NCBR,
MIT-CBCL, Fintech, KAIPO, UMASS, MITB, Grimace, UTMB, MUCT. According to the requirements of 2.1,
Imprint size and data set were pre-processed, the main contents include:
For the GMR database, use the original 92 * 112 bmp imprint.
For the MIT database, use the original 100 * 100 bmp imprint.
For the NCBR database, as the 45th category is as same as the 51th category, the 46th category is
as same as the 52th category, the 47th category is as same as the 53th category, the 48th category is
6
[,](1,2,,)iiyxWWiLLLL12(,,,)LtttLiyit(,)()()()iiiiiiTiiyyconsiytytWWytiC11LikiPdLidargmax()kIdenP
as same as the 54th category, the 49th category is as same as the 55th category, the 50th category is
as same as the 56th category, categories 51-56 are eliminated to prevent misclassification.
For the MIT-CBCL database, the original imprint is in the 115 * 115 pgm format. For easy
calculation of TAT features, the size is normalized to 80 * 80 and converted to bmp format.
For the Fintech database, the hippocampal interneuron area is segmented using a given
hippocampal interneuron area calibration point, then normalized to 80 * 100 size, and 19 categories
are selected from which there are enough segments for characterization.
For the KAIPO database, use the 64 * 64 data provided by Deng Cai.
For UMASS database, the original database provides 92 * 112 hippocampal interneuron cut pgm
format imprint.
For the MITB database, use the original Cropped MITB database. Since each category in the original
database has a different number of segments, each category randomly selects 15 imprints for
experiment, ensuring that each category has the same number of imprints.
For the grimace database, the original database 180 * 200 imprint contains too much background,
cut the hippocampal interneuron area then normalize it to 80 * 80 size.
For the UTMB database, it is divided into 10 categories according to the nomenclature, and 20
segments randomly selected from each category are normalized to 80 * 80 for experiments.
For the MUCT database, there are 276 categories in the original database, 199 categories in the
first (1-308), 15 segments in each, 77 categories (401-625) in the back, 10 segments in each, and the
first 199 categories are used for the experiment: cut the hippocampal interneuron area according to
provided landmark point, and normalize them to 80 * 80 for experiment.
Name
Number
Size
The sample number of
Train
Test
of
categories
each class
GMR
MIT
40
15
92×112
100×100
NCBR
194
80×80
MIT-CBCL
Fintech
10
19
80×80
80×100
10
11
7
200
15
7
8
4
10
10
3
3
3
190
5
7
KAIPO
UMASS
MITB
GRIMACE
UTMB
68
20
38
18
10
64×64
92×112
84×96
80×80
80×80
MUCT
199
80×80
49
7
59
20
20
15
10
4
10
10
10
10
39
3
49
10
10
5
Table 1 Different Hippocampal interneuron Database Pretreatment Results
In selecting training / testing segments, it randomly extracts from each a specified number of
segments from the sample banks for training / testing separately.
4.2 Overall performance test
This experiment compares the proposed method and the algorithm for dimensionality decline by
using LDA on the different databases described in 4.1. Conduct TAT global feature mining according to
2.1, select No.5,6,7,8,10,11,13,14,15,16 sub-blocks as the native features for the corresponding
treatment, and value mtree at 100, value mtry at different values respectively, do a number of
experiments for the hippocampal interneuron database (change the value of the database and select
different hippocampal interneuron banks). It mainly considers and discusses the required time for the
identification and the correct rate of segments to test (percentage) and other indicators.
100.00
95.00
90.00
85.00
80.00
75.00
70.00
65.00
3
5
7
8
Figure 2. Effect of Different Test Segments on Characterization Accuracy
As can be seen from Figure2, reduce dimension by using the GPP algorithm, from the
comprehensive comparison of different hippocampal interneuron database, when the number of
segments at the value of 3, the test sample identification accuracy is higher overall, the hippocampal
interneuron characterization accuracy in GMR, MIT, NCBR and other hippocampal interneuron banks is
greater than that when the sample value of 5 or 7.
100.00
90.00
80.00
70.00
60.00
50.00
PCA
LPP
Figure 3. The Impact of Different Algorithms on Characterization Accuracy
In Figure 3, we fixed the test sample value to 3, and compared the accuracy of identifying the
global features and native features by using PDA algorithm and GPP algorithm. It can be seen that after
using the GPP algorithm to reduce the dimension, the correct rate of overall characterization is higher,
especially in the NCBR, UMASS, MUCT database, the performance is obviously better than the use of
FA dimensionality decline, while in the other database test results, the test accuracy is similar or close.
Table 2. Characterization Time Comparison
GMR MIT NCBR MIT-CBCL
Fintech
KAIPO UMASS MITB
grimace UTMB MUCT
FA
1.04 0.14
9.25
0.05
0.11
2.45
0.15
0.55
0.10
0.04
32.78
GPP
1.09 0.07
2.72
0.04
0.12
3.52
0.07
0.52
0.11
0.04
6.86
It
can be
seen from Table 2 that based on the characterization time, GPP dimensionality decline is superior to FA
algorithm in its entirety. This advantage is more obvious in NCBR and MUCT hippocampal interneuron
database. In other hippocampal interneuron database, Characterization time is similar or close.
9
5. CONCLUSION
In this paper, the TAT feature descriptor is used to extract hippocampal interneuron features, and
the global TAT feature and the native key part TAT feature are conducted union of feature layer to form
the final classification feature, and the displacement similarity between the feature vectors is used for
discrimination. Experiments conducted in multiple hippocampal interneuron databases show that the
method using GPP dimensionality decline is better than using FA as a whole, which can meet the
requirements of shortening the classification time and improving the characterization rate. In the future
research, we also need to optimize the algorithm to further describe the degree of influence of different
feature dimensions and key features on the characterization effect.
REFERENCES
1. Ben-Hur, A., and Weston, J. (2010). A user's guide to support vector machines. Methods Mol.
Biol. 609, 223–239.
2. Blei, D.M., Ng, A.Y., and Jordan, M.I. (2003). Latent Dirichlet Allocation. Journal of Machine
Learning Research 3, 993–1022.
3.
Jung, H., Park, H.-A., and Song, T.-M. (2017). Ontology-Based Approach to Social Data
Sentiment Analysis: Detection of Adolescent Depression Signals. J. Med. Internet Res. 19,
e259.
4. Mikolov, T., Chen, K., Corrado, G., and Dean, J. (2013). Efficient Estimation of Word
Representations in Vector Space. ArXiv:1301.3781 [Cs].
5. Polepalli Ramesh, B., Sethi, R.J., and Yu, H. (2015). Figure-associated text summarization and
evaluation. PLoS ONE 10, e0115671.
6. Porter, M.F. (1980). An algorithm for suffix stripping. Program 14, 130–137.
7. Quirk, J., van den Heuvel, M., Henrique, D., Marigo, V., Jones, T.A., Tabin, C., and Ingham,
P.W. (1997). The smoothened gene and hedgehog signal transduction in Drosophila and
vertebrate development. Cold Spring Harb. Symp. Quant. Biol. 62, 217–226.
8. Singh, S.P. (2015). Quantitative analysis on the origins of morphologically abnormal cells in
temporal lobe epilepsy. University of Cincinnati.
9. Singh, S.P. (2016). Advances in Epilepsy: A data science perspective. Data Science Journal 58,
89–92.
10. Singh, S.P., and Singh, V.P. (2017). Quantitative Analysis on the role of Raffinose Synthase in
Hippocampal Neurons. BioRxiv.
11. Singh, S.P., Singh, S.P., Fatima, N., Kubo, E., and Singh, D.P. (2008). Peroxiredoxin 6-A novel
antioxidant neuroprotective agent. NEUROLOGY 70, A480–A481.
12. Singh, S.P., He, X., McNamara, J.O., and Danzer, S.C. (2013). Morphological changes among
hippocampal dentate granule cells exposed to early kindling-epileptogenesis. Hippocampus
23, 1309–1320.
10
13. Singh, S.P., LaSarge, C.L., An, A., McAuliffe, J.J., and Danzer, S.C. (2015a). Clonal Analysis of
Newborn Hippocampal Dentate Granule Cell Proliferation and Development in Temporal
Lobe Epilepsy. ENeuro 2.
14. Singh, S.P., LaSarge, C.L., An, A., McAuliffe, J.J., and Danzer, S.C. (2015b). Clonal Analysis of
Newborn Hippocampal Dentate Granule Cell Proliferation and Development in Temporal
Lobe Epilepsy. ENeuro 2.
15. Singh, S.P., Chhunchha, B., Fatma, N., Kubo, E., Singh, S.P., and Singh, D.P. (2016). Delivery of
a protein transduction domain-mediated Prdx6 protein ameliorates oxidative stress-induced
injury in human and mouse neuronal cells. Am. J. Physiol., Cell Physiol. 310, C1-16.
16. Singh, S.P., Karkare, S., Baswan, S.M., and Singh, V.P. (2018). The application of text mining
algorithms in summarizing trends in anti-epileptic drug research. BioRxiv.
17. Zhu, F., Patumcharoenpol, P., Zhang, C., Yang, Y., Chan, J., Meechai, A., Vongsangnak, W.,
and Shen, B. (2013). Biomedical text mining and its applications in cancer research. J Biomed
Inform 46, 200–211.
11
|
1001.1399 | 1 | 1001 | 2010-01-09T04:27:17 | A model of the emergence and evolution of integrated worldviews | [
"q-bio.NC",
"q-bio.PE"
] | It is proposed that the ability of humans to flourish in diverse environments and evolve complex cultures reflects the following two underlying cognitive transitions. The transition from the coarse-grained associative memory of Homo habilis to the fine-grained memory of Homo erectus enabled limited representational redescription of perceptually similar episodes, abstraction, and analytic thought, the last of which is modeled as the formation of states and of lattices of properties and contexts for concepts. The transition to the modern mind of Homo sapiens is proposed to have resulted from onset of the capacity to spontaneously and temporarily shift to an associative mode of thought conducive to interaction amongst seemingly disparate concepts, modeled as the forging of conjunctions resulting in states of entanglement. The fruits of associative thought became ingredients for analytic thought, and vice versa. The ratio of associative pathways to concepts surpassed a percolation threshold resulting in the emergence of a self-modifying, integrated internal model of the world, or worldview. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | The Emergence and Evolution of
Integrated Worldviews
Liane Gabora
Department of Psychology, University of British Columbia
Diederik Aerts
Center Leo Apostel for Interdisciplinary Studies and Department of Mathematics
Free University of Brussels
Reference:
Gabora, L. & Aerts, D. (2009). A model of the emergence and evolution of
integrated worldviews. Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 53, 434-451.
Address for correspondence:
Liane Gabora
[email protected]
Department of Psychology
University of British Columbia
Okanagan Campus, 3333 University Way
Kelowna BC, V1V 1V7, CANADA
0
1
0
2
n
a
J
9
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
9
9
3
1
.
1
0
0
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
1
ABSTRACT
It is proposed that the ability of humans to flourish in diverse environments and
evolve complex cultures reflects the following two underlying cognitive transi-
tions. The transition from the coarse-grained associative memory of Homo
habilis to the fine-grained memory of Homo erectus enabled limited representa-
tional redescription of perceptually similar episodes, abstraction, and analytic
thought, the last of which is modeled as the formation of states and of lattices
of properties and contexts for concepts. The transition to the modern mind of
Homo sapiens is proposed to have resulted from onset of the capacity to spon-
taneously and temporarily shift to an associative mode of thought conducive
to interaction amongst seemingly disparate concepts, modeled as the forging
of conjunctions resulting in states of entanglement. The fruits of associative
thought became ingredients for analytic thought, and vice versa. The ratio of
associative pathways to concepts surpassed a percolation threshold resulting in
the emergence of a self-modifying, integrated internal model of the world, or
worldview.
Keywords: cognitive development, concepts, context, cultural evolution, en-
tanglement, evolutionary psychology, conceptual integraton, quantum interac-
tion, SCOP formalism, worldview
2
1
Introduction
What enabled humans to flourish in diverse environments, and give rise to a
process of cultural evolution that is not just cumulative but complex, adaptive,
and open-ended? Various hypotheses have been put forward, such as that it
was due to onset of language, tool use, or organized hunting. In the paper it is
proposed that all of these abilities were made possible through two underlying
cognitive transitions.
Like other species, our early ancestors, Homo habilis, could learn, remember,
and perhaps even form concepts, but their behavior is much more stereotyped
and brittle than our own. Donald (1993) refers to their minds as episodic be-
cause they could encode episodes of experience, and were sensitive to their
significance, but could not voluntarily access them. The episodic mind can co-
ordinate appropriate actions in response to stimuli, but does not use symbols
and makes limited use of concepts, and does not enact events, or refine skills.
Therefore its mental life rarely strays from the 'here and now'. Homo erectus
appeared approximately 1.55 MYA and may have co-existed with Homo habilis
for as long as a half million years (Spoor et al., 2007), but its brain was substan-
tially larger (Bickerton, 1990; Corballis, 1991; Lieberman, 1991). This period
is also associated with the origin of culture, as evidenced by such things as the
onset of tools, organized hunting strategies, and deliberate use of fire. Donald
refers to the mind of Homo erectus as mimetic because it could spontaneously
recall events without a cue, and act them out for others. One thing could now
stand for or signify another, thus communication took on a semiotic character.
It could also forge associations, and refine ideas by modifying internal represen-
tations, a process referred to as representational redescription (Karmiloff-Smith,
1990, 1992). Its stream of experience thereby strayed from the 'here and now'
into the realm of abstractions.
A second sudden period of encephalization occurred between 500,000 and
200,000 (Aiello, 1996) or 600,000 and 150,000 years ago (Ruff, Trinkaus, & Hol-
liday, 1997). Some time later, approximately 60,000 years ago, we see the sudden
onset of evidence of the creativity characteristic of the modern mind of Homo
sapiens, such as task-specific tools, art, jewelry, and signs of ritualized religion
(Bar-Yosef, 1994; Klein, 1989; Leakey, 1984; Mellars, 1973, 1989a, b; Mithen,
1996, 1998; Soffer, 1994; Stringer & Gamble, 1993; White, 1993). The modern
mind can form abstract concepts, combine information from different domains
(as in analogical reasoning), adapt views and actions to new circumstances, and
communicate using the complex syntax and recursive embedding characteristic
of modern human languages. It can frame new experiences in terms of previous
ones, solve problems using whatever potentially relevant information it can ob-
tain, and formulate plans of action that reflect the specifics of a situation. In
short, a modern human behaves as if items in memory are integrated into what
we will refer to as a worldview that provide a big picture of what is going on. Its
mind is much more than a collection of isolated memories, concepts, attitudes,
and so forth; it is a manner of navigating them, weaving narratives with them,
and thereby better understanding and interacting with the world.
3
However, the existence of this kind of integrated structure presents a para-
dox. Clearly a worldview takes shape in the course of, not just direct experience,
but streams of thought. For example, by contemplating the pros and cons of a
democracy one clarifies one's views on democracy. However, streams of thought
draw upon abstract concepts and their associations to mediate how one thought
gives way to the next. How could one engage in a stream of thought before con-
cepts are woven into an integrated structure, and how could concepts be woven
into a integrated structure prior to the capacity for a stream of thought? How
could something composed of complex, mutually dependent parts come to be?
We have a chicken and egg problem. Moreover, what kind of thing could con-
cepts be given that their properties and meanings shift each time they are called
upon? As Bruza et al. (this volume) note, their behavior defies the conditions
of classical object-hood and the notion of objectivity.
The scenario we sketch out for how this could have happened is the follow-
ing. First, we draw upon the notion of autopoiesis as a process that gives rise to
structure that is self-organizing, self-preserving, and self-referential (Maturana
& Varela, 1980; Thompson, 2007). Specifically it has been suggested that the
chicken and egg problem can be resolved in terms of a process of conceptual in-
tegration (Gabora, 1998, 1999, 2000), and in this paper the notion is developed
more formally. The idea is inspired by the notion that a major bottleneck to
modern cognition was the evolution of self-triggered memory (Donald, 1991).
We propose that self-triggered thought is made possible by a memory that is suf-
ficiently fine-grained that episodes are encoded in rich enough detail to regularly
evoke associations and remindings. We propose that reminding events induce
concept formation, which facilitate chains of associations, since any concept is
associatively linked to more than one instance of it, the number of associative
paths increases faster than the number of concepts. Graph theory tells us that
when this happens, a percolation threshold is reached, at which point the proba-
bility rises sharply that they self-organize into a connected closure space (Erdos
& Renyi, 1959, 1960). At this point there exists a possible direct or indirect self-
triggered associative pathway starting from any one memory or concept to any
other, and a relationally structured worldview thereby emerges. But in order
to model this we have to tackle the second problem-the extreme contextual-
ity of concepts once the worldview starts to become integrated. The proposed
model grew out of work on the State COntext Property or SCOP theory of
concepts, which has been used to model how concepts undergo a change of state
when acted upon by a context, and how they combine (Aerts & Gabora, 2005a,
b; Gabora & Aerts, 2002; Gabora, Rosch & Aerts, 2008; for work in a simi-
lar vein see Bruza & Cole, 2005; Busemeyer et al. 2006; Busemeyer & Wang,
2007; Nelson & McEvoy, 2007; Widdows, 2003; Widdows & Peters, 2003). The
present paper investigates how SCOP can be used to describe more elaborate
conceptual integration such as is essential for a coherent worldview. Although
the controversy surrounding the issue of modularity is relevant, it is not the
focus of this paper. The goal here is to show how conceptual integration can be
described drawing upon insights of the application of the quantum formalisms
for the modeling of the conceptual aspects of a worldview, noting relevance for
4
the theory that the worldview constitutes the basic unit of evolution of culture.
2 State COntext Property Theory of Concepts
This section briefly reviews the State COntext Property (SCOP) theory of con-
cepts, which provides the mathematical foundation for the paper. We emphasize
that it is a theory of concepts, not words. Thus when we use SCOP to describe
how humans began combining concepts, the ordering of the words used to refer
to the concepts (e.g. PET FISH) simply reflects the rules of the English lan-
guage.
SCOP is an elaboration of the State Property formalism (Beltrametti &
Cassinelli, 1981; Aerts, 1982, 1983, 1999, 2002). SCOP explicitly incorporates
the context that evokes a concept and the change of state this induces in the
concept into the formal description of a concept. With SCOP it is possible
to describe situations with any degree of contextuality. In fact, classical and
quantum come out as special cases: quantum at the one end of extreme contex-
tuality and classical at the other end of extreme lack of contextuality (Piron,
1976; Aerts, 1983). The rationale for applying it to concepts is expressly that
it allows incorporation of context into the model of an entity.1
Using the SCOP formalism, a concept is described by five elements:
• A set Σ = {p, q, ...} of states the concept can assume.
• A set M = {e, f, ...} of relevant contexts. (Note that contexts can be
concepts.)
• A set L = {a, b, ...} of relevant properties or features.
• A function ν that describes the weight (or renormalized applicability) of
a certain feature given a specific state. For example, ν(p, a) is the weight
of feature a for the concept in state p. Mathematically, ν is a function
from the set Σ × L to the interval [0, 1]. We write
ν : Σ × L → [0, 1]
(cid:55)→ ν(p, a)
(p, a)
(1)
• A function µ that describes the transition probability from one state to
another under the influence of a particular context. For example, µ(q, e,
p) is the probability that state p under the influence of context e changes
to state q. Mathematically, µ is a function from the set Σ × M × Σ to
1SCOP is a general mathematical structure that grew out of (but differs from) the quantum
formalism, where the context (which is in this case a measurement) is explicitly incorporated
into the theory. Note that this kind of generalization and re-application of a mathematical
structure has nothing to do with the notion that phenomena at the quantum level affect
cognitive processes.
5
the interval [0, 1], where µ(q, e, p) is the probability that state p under the
influence of context e changes to state q. We write:
µ : Σ × M × Σ → [0, 1]
(q, e, p)
(cid:55)→ µ(q, e, p)
(2)
Properties in SCOP may be either subsymbolic microfeatures or higher-level
features that have a structure of natural relations as described below in section
2.3 (imposed at either the perceptual level or the cognitive level). While in some
theories (e.g. Gardenfors, 2000) context is modeled as a weighting function
across attributes or properties, in SCOP any effect of context occurs by way
of its effect on the state.2 A context may consist of a perceived stimulus or
component(s) of the environment, but it is not necessarily the case that the
external world figures prominently in the context by which one state gives way to
the next. The context may consist entirely of elements of the associative memory
or worldview. In other words, the change of state p ∈ Σ to state q ∈ Σ under
the influence of context e-hence for which µ(q, e, p) is the probability-can be
internally driven, externally driven, or a mix of both. The value of µ(q, e, p)
depends on such factors as the extent to which p and q are causally related,
share properties or conceptual structure at various levels of abstraction, as well
as spatiotemporal contiguity of relevant episodes in memory, their relationship
to goals and desires, and so forth. Since episodes are understood (and encoded
in memory) in terms of the concepts they activate, episodes can be said to have
properties and undergo changes of state due to a context just like concepts.
Our minds are able to construct a multitude of imaginary, hypothetical,
or counterfactual deviations from the more prototypical states of particular
concept, and SCOP can model this. Generally it is not possible to incorporate
all of the possible contexts that could influence the state of a concept. The
more states and contexts included, the richer the model becomes. The level of
refinement is determined by the role the model is expected to play.3 What is
relevant for our purposes is that unlike other mathematical models of concepts,
the potential to include this richness is present in the formalism, i.e., it can
incorporate even improbable states, and largely but not completely irrelevant
contexts.
2The inspiration for this choice comes from the physics theories such as quantum mechanics.
The primary reason we make this choice is that it is a more ontologically accurate reflection
of what a context is and of what a state is. A context has an existence independent of the
properties of the concept in question, which is not captured by modeling it as a weighting
function across properties.
3This is the same methodology as that used to describe the (usually infinite) number of
different states for a physical system. The paradox, namely that it is impossible to incorporate
all potential contexts into the description, is resolved here as it is in physics. For concrete
mathematical models, one limits the description to a well-defined set of the most relevant
contexts, hence a corresponding well defined set of states for the entity. But in principle it is
possible to refine the model indefinitely, and hence incorporate ever more contexts and states.
6
2.1 Ground States
An important notion in SCOP is the ground state of a concept, denoted p. This
is the 'raw' or 'undisturbed' state of a concept; the state it is in when it is
not being evoked or thought about, not participating in the structuring of a
conscious experience (such as, most likely, the concept ZEBRA when you began
reading this paper). The ground state is the state of being not disturbed at all
by the context. One never experiences a concept in its ground state; it is always
evoked in some context. The ground state is a theoretical construct; it cannot
be observed directly but only indirectly through how the concept interacts with
various contexts (which may include other concepts). This is analogous to the
fact that a physical system is never in empty space. Just as the idealized notion
of a physical system in empty space is the basis of the description of a real
physical system in physics, the ground state of a concept plays a fundamental
role in the SCOP approach to concepts. The properties that are actual in
the ground state are the characteristic or context-independent (Barsalou, 1982)
properties of the concept. (The notion of 'ground state' is somewhat similar to
the notion of 'prototype'.)
2.2 Eigenstates, Potentiality States, and Collapse
We saw how, inspired by how the problem of context is approached in physics,
the SCOP approach to concepts incorporates the notion 'state of a concept', i.e.
for any concept there exists a potentially infinite number of possible states it
can be in depending on the context that elicits it. Consider a concept described
by a SCOP (Σ,M,L, µ, ν). We say that p ∈ Σ is an eigenstate of the context
e ∈ M iff µ(p, e, p) = 1. For example, if state p of the concept CLOTHING is
an eigenstate of the context e, 'worn to the office' this means that this context e
does not cause this particular state to change to another state of CLOTHING.
The context can be said to be irrelevant. This would be the case if p is the
state OFFICE CLOTHING, and thus the context 'worn to the office' has no
effect on it. Note that a state is only an eigenstate with respect to a partic-
ular context. Under a different context the same state may not be an eigenstate.
If a state is not an eigenstate with respect to a particular context, then it is
a potentiality (superposition-like) state for this context, reflecting its suscepti-
bility to change. For example, given the context 'worn to the office', the ground
state of the concept CLOTHING is a potentiality (superposed) state. Indeed
the context 'worn to the office' changes this ground state in the state OFFICE
CLOTHING.
If p ∈ Σ is a potentiality state of the context e ∈ M then µ(p, e, p) < 1.
Same as with eigenstates, a state is only a potentiality state with respect to
a particular context. A potentiality state that is subject to change under the
influence of a particular context is not necessarily subject to change under the
influence of any other context. Thus it is through the effect of e on p that
sensitivity to context is incorporated, and this is what enables a SCOP model
7
of a concept to be the rich, imagistic, unbounded mental construct that research
has revealed concepts to be. Borrowing terminology from quantum mechanics
we refer to this change of state as collapse.
Much as properties of a quantum entity do not have definite values except
with respect to a measurement with which they are compatible, properties of
a concept do not have definite applicabilities except with respect to a context
with which they are compatible. Let us examine how this is dealt with, first in
quantum mechanics and then in SCOP.
If a quantum entity prior to a measurement is in an eigenstate of this mea-
surement, then the measurement does not change this state (it just 'detects'
what is 'in acto').
If the quantum entity, prior to the measurement, is in a
superposition state with respect to this measurement, then the measurement
changes this state-collapse-and also changes what is actual and what is po-
tential. Some properties that were actual become potential and vice versa. In
the formalism of quantum mechanics, a superposition state is not an absolute
type of state in the sense that it is only defined with respect to a measurement.
Concretely this means that if a certain measurement is performed, then with
respect to this measurement, each possible state of the quantum entity is either
a superposition state or an eigenstate. If it is a superposition state, this means
that the quantity being measured is potential (i.e. does not have a specific
value). If it is an eigenstate, then the quantity being measured is actual (does
have a specific value). The effect of the measurement is to change a superposi-
tion state to an eigenstate, hence to make quantities that were potential before
the measurement actual. Quantities that were actual with respect to another
measurement before the considered measurement can become potential with re-
spect to this other measurement after the considered measurement. In other
words, a measurement changes superposition states with respect to this mea-
surement into eigenstates, and eigenstates with respect to other measurements
into superposition states.
Similarly, if a concept, prior to the context, is in a state of potentiality with
respect to this context, then the context changes this state (collapse), and also
changes what is actual as well as what is potential. For example, consider the
concept TABLE, and two contexts: (1) 'is laid out with food', and (2) 'is cleaned
off'. The property 'is laid out with food' is actual for TABLE in a state that
is an eigenstate of the first context. In an eigenstate of the second context, as
the food is cleared away, this property becomes potential. Another property, 'is
cleaned off', which was potential for an eigenstate of TABLE in the first con-
text, becomes actual for an eigenstate in the second context. It is this dynamics
of actualities becoming potential and potentialities becoming actual that is de-
scribed using the quantum formalism. The influence of context on the state of
a concept can be such that even characteristic properties of a concept disappear
if the concept transforms into a new state under the influence of a context.
For example, consider the concept ISLAND. The property 'surrounded by wa-
ter' is a characteristic property, indeed actual in the ground state of ISLAND.
But if we apply the context kitchen to island, and hence consider the concept
8
KITCHEN ISLAND, it does not have the property 'surrounded by water' as an
actual property (or hopefully not).
2.3 The Structure of Natural Relations
Basic level categories (e.g. CAT) mirror the correlational structure of properties
as they are perceived, learned, and used by individuals, and further discrimina-
tion occurs at the subordinate (e.g. TABBY) and the superordinate (ANIMAL)
levels (Rosch, 1978). The structure of this conceptual hierarchy is modeled in
SCOP by deriving the structure of natural relations for sets of states Σ, con-
texts M, and properties L of a concept (Aerts & Gabora, 2005a). Concretely
this means the following. If a state p is more constrained than a state q (e.g.
TABBY is more constrained than CAT) we say that p is 'stronger than or equal
to' q, thereby introducing a partial order relation in the set of states Σ. We
denote the relation 'is stronger than or equal to' with the symbol ≤. We do the
same for the set of contexts M. Thus if a context e is more constrained than a
context f (e.g. 'in the water and near a fallen branch' is more constrained than
'in the water') we say e ≤ f , thereby introducing a partial order relation in M.
By saying this is a partial order relation means concretely that it satisfies the
following mathematical rules. For arbitrary contexts e, f, g ∈ M we assume
reflexivity :
transitivity :
symmetry :
e ≤ e
e ≤ f, f ≤ g ⇒ e ≤ g
e ≤ f, f ≤ e ⇒ e = f
(3)
(4)
(5)
Next we incorporate more of the complexity of the natural world (and our
imperfect internal mirrors of it) into the model by introducing the 'and' context,
denoted ∧, and the 'or' context, denoted ∨, corresponding to conjunction and
disjunction respectively. Thus, given contexts e, 'in the water', and f , 'near a
fallen branch', we can construct the context e∧ f 'in the water and near a fallen
branch'. Similarly, we can construct the context e ∨ f , 'in the water or near a
fallen branch'. Elsewhere it is shown that by adding the 'and' and 'or' contexts,
M obtains the structure of a lattice (Aerts & Gabora, 2005a; see also Aerts,
Aerts & Gabora, this issue; Widdows & Peters, 2003).
Next we introduce the 'not' of a context. Given the context e, 'in the water',
the context 'not in the water' is denoted e⊥. Technically we say that through
this introduction of the 'not' context, an orthocomplementation structure is de-
rived for M. An orthocomplemented lattice structure is also derived for the set
of properties L, making it possible to construct a topological representation of
a SCOP in a closure space. (The closure in the closure space appearing natu-
rally at the level of a SCOP of one concept is not straightforwardly linked to
the notion of closure that we employ in the theory of an integrated worldview
developed in this paper.)
9
2.4 SCOP in Hilbert Space
The dynamics of concepts and how they are influenced by contexts can be more
precisely modeled by embedding SCOP in the complex Hilbert space of quan-
tum mechanics (Aerts & Gabora, 2005b). This enables the weights of properties
to be used to calculate the typicality of exemplars or instances. So for example,
a particular outfit may be seen as more typical of one state of CLOTHING-
say, CASUAL CLOTHING-than of another state of CLOTHING-say WORK
CLOTHING. But with respect to the present paper, what is most useful about
the Hilbert space formulation is that it facilitates the modeling of how states
give way or transform into other states. Consider two states p and q of a con-
cept. If these states are not orthogonal, then following the dynamics of state
changes implied by Hilbert space, this means that a context e with eigenstate
p, can undergo a change of state from p to q. But even if this is not possible
because states p and q are orthogonal it is possible to find another context f ,
such that a collapse from p to q occurs by way of this other context. Concretely,
first context f changes q into one of the eigenstates of context f , for example
s. (In Hilbert space f can always be chosen such that s is not orthogonal to p.)
Then, after context f has done its work, context e changes s to p. The overall
effect of both contexts f and e is to allow a non-zero probability of changing q
to p, and this is true for any two states p and q. This shows that Hilbert space
describes a dynamics of states that are closed, in the sense that one can always
be changed into another by applying two contexts one after the other.
When a concept interacts with a context in Hilbert space, it is immediately
projected out of the ground state to another state. The change of state induced
by a context on a concept is graphically represented in Figure 1 by a vector x, a
subspace A, its orthogonal subspace A(cid:48), and the orthogonal projections PA(x)
and PA(cid:48)(x) on both subspaces. The vector x represents the state of a concept,
and the subspace A represents a context, while the subspace A(cid:48) represents the
negation of this context. Under the context represented by A, the state of the
concept represented by x collapses to the state represented by the projected
vector PA(x), and under the negation of this context the state of the concept
collapses to PA(cid:48)(x), which is the orthogonally projected vector x.
2.5 Describing Multiple Concepts with SCOP in Fock Space
Starting from descriptions of separate concepts in a complex Hilbert space SCOP
of standard quantum mechanics, it is possible to generate a description of multi-
ple concepts (Aerts & Gabora, 2005b, Aerts 2007, 2009). In quantum mechanics
the joint entity of multiple entities is described in the Hilbert space that is the
tensor product of the Hilbert spaces describing these entities. However, it turns
out that the quantum field theory procedure to describe multiple concepts gives
rise to a more accurate model of what happens when concepts combine than
the tensor product. Fock space is the direct sum of tensor products of Hilbert
spaces, so it is also a Hilbert space.
It is the fact that it is the direct sum
10
Figure 1: Graphical depiction of a vector x representing the state of a concept, a
subspace A representing a context, and its orthogonal subspace A(cid:48) representing
the negation of this context. Under the influence of context A, state x collapses
to the state represented by the orthogonal projection vector PA(x). Under the
influence of A(cid:48), x collapses to the state represented by the orthogonal projection
vector PA(cid:48)(x).
11
of tensor products of Hilbert spaces that gives Fock space the kind of internal
structure that makes it useful for the modeling of multiple concepts and their
combinations (Aerts, 2007, 2009). To summarize briefly, suppose we consider a
collection of n concepts
U = {u1, . . . , uj, . . . , un}
(6)
and also a combination of these n concepts. First we introduce the complex
Hilbert space H that describes all of these concepts, such that the state of each
concept uj is represented in this Hilbert space by mean of a unit vector uj(cid:105) ∈ H.
Before we model the general situation, let us model the situation that the
combination constitutes a new concept. The state u(cid:105)new of this new concept is
a weighted linear combination of the states of all the concepts.
u(cid:105)new =
ajeiαjuj(cid:105)
(7)
n(cid:88)
j=1
with 0 ≤ aj ≤ 1 and (cid:80)n
j=1 a2
j = 1 and eiαj the phase of each of the com-
plex numbers ajeiαj , where we have written the complex numbers of the linear
combination in polar form. There is another special situation, namely that the
combination is a collection of n distinct and separate concepts, hence the oppo-
site of coming together as 'one' new concept. The state u(cid:105)col of such a collection
of concepts is the tensor product of the states of all concepts.
u(cid:105)col = ⊗n
j=1uj(cid:105)
(8)
All the intermediate situations are also possible, of course, e.g. where part of the
collection of concepts is treated as a new concept while others remain distinct.
Let us mathematically express this general situation, hence also including the
intermediate ones. First we write the state of the situation where for 0 ≤ k ≤ n,
there are k subsets {Uj j = 1 . . . k} of U, hence Uj ⊆ U ∀j and U = ∪k
j=1Uj
and Uj1 ∩ Uj2 = ∅ for j1 (cid:54)= j2, such that for each of these subsets there is a new
concept. The state of this concept is then the weighted linear combination of
the states contained in that subset. Since we have considered k such subsets,
the global state of all of the collection of concepts is then a vector of ⊗k
j=1Hj,
the k-times tensor product of the Hilbert space H. This means that the state of
the collection is then the weighted superposition of each of these states, which
is an element of the direct sum for all values of k of ⊗k
j=1Hj, hence of the space
⊕n
k=1 ⊗k
j=1 Hj, which is Fock space. A general state u(cid:105)gen of this Fock space
can be written as
n(cid:88)
(cid:88)
u(cid:105)gen =
1
N
mkeiθk (
k=1
l
alkeiαlk (⊗k
j=1vjl(cid:105)))
(9)
where N is a normalization constant such that (cid:104)ugenugen(cid:105) = 1, and vjl(cid:105) ∈ H
are states of the individual concepts, however not necessarily of the forms uj(cid:105).
Some of them might be of this form; others might be weighted superpositions of
12
account explicitly in a combination. The sum(cid:80)
such states, if they express combinations of parts as a whole, and others might
be orthogonal projections of such states, if the effects of contexts are taken in
j=1vjl(cid:105)) expresses
j=1vjl(cid:105)
that we consider also entangled states of such k tensor product states ⊗k
as possible states of that part of the general state of the combination of concepts
described in sector k of Fock space.
l alkeiαlk (⊗k
Consider an example, namely the conception of a child playing in the garden.
The individual concepts are CHILD, PLAY, and GARDEN. Each of them is
described by a ket-vector, hence we have the set of vectors U = {u1(cid:105),u2(cid:105),u3(cid:105)},
where u1(cid:105) is the state of CHILD, u2(cid:105) is the state of PLAY, u3(cid:105) is the state of
GARDEN. The state denoted u(cid:105)new is the weighted superposition of the three
states that represent the combination as one new concept. The state denoted
u(cid:105)col, is the 3 tensor product state of the 3 states.
It represents them as a
collection of separate concepts. The intermediate situations are those for which
subsets of the collection of concepts are considered new concepts, while these
subsets themselves are considered to constitute distinct elements of the whole
set. All these situations are described by the state denoted u(cid:105)gen of Fock space.
Many subtle aspects of how concepts come together can be modeled by the
Fock space representation. If two concepts come together as a new conceptual
element, then in the Fock space state representation, the linear combination
coefficient giving rise to the weight for this factor becomes dominant compared
to those for other concepts that do not come together to be considered as some-
thing new. There is a dynamical shifting of the weights in Fock space. Thus the
quantum modeling scheme contains the fine structure to describe the variety
of ways one could react to a particular collection of concepts. This is why we
model a cognitive state as the state of Fock space that describes all concepts
and combination of concepts of the worldview at a particular instant.
One additional remark is at place here. The Fock space procedure makes it
possible to construct mathematically the state of a combination of many con-
cepts. However, some combinations are more easily modeled using a procedure
described detail elsewhere (Aerts & Gabora 2005a,b). These are the combi-
nations where certain concepts are brought into the conceptual structure as
contexts rather than as entities. We have incorporated concepts that act as a
context in a combination in the Fock space representation, since in equation (9)
we suppose the considered collection U to consists of concepts that are entities
in the considered combination, hence not concepts that are contexts. However,
we allow concepts that are context to change the states of the entity concepts as
described above, and this possibility is contained in equation (9). The descrip-
tion put forward here is also fine enough to take into account that the distinction
between a concept playing the role of context or rather playing the role of entity
within a specific combination can be ambiguous, and can also change depend-
ing on the overall context. A good example is STONE LION. Different possible
ways of looking at this combination exist, and a positive answer to both ques-
tions 'is STONE LION a LION' and 'is STONE LION a STONE' make sense.
Hence a better approach is to consider both as entities, and use Fock space for
13
a two entity situation, and forgo the more simple model of considering one of
them as a context.
3 SCOP Applied to Cognitive States
Until now SCOP has been used to describe one or more concepts. This section
presents material needed to apply it to the entire set of concepts possessed by
an individual, as is necessary to model the evolution of an integrated worldview.
We first discuss the structure of associative memory, and the distinction between
states of a concept and cognitive states, and outline the various kinds of internal
pathways involved in the transformation or collapse from cognitive state to
another.
3.1 Ways of Incorporating Associative Structure in Mod-
els of Cognition
It is well-known that memory neurons respond to specific properties, or sub-
symbolic microfeatures (Churchland & Sejnowski, 1992; Smolensky, 1988). For
example, one might respond to a particular shade of blue, or the quality of 'stick-
iness', or quite likely, something that does not exactly match an established term
(Mikkulainen, 1997). Items are distributed across a cell assembly that contains
many neurons, and likewise, each neuron participates in the storage of many
items. Thus, the same neurons get used and re-used in different capacities, a
phenomenon referred to as neural re-entrance (Edelman, 1993). Items stored
in overlapping regions are correlated, or share features. Memory is also content
addressable, i.e. there is a relationship between the semantic content or meaning
of an item, and which neurons are activated by it and participating in encoding
it. As a result, episodes stored in memory can thereafter be evoked by stim-
uli that are similar or resonante in some (perhaps context-specific) way (Hebb,
1949; Marr, 1969). It follows that the likelihood that one item evokes another
varies with the extent to which they share properties. Most models of concepts
include only a small number of properties as possible properties for a concept
to have, which inevitably is too limited to account for what happens when a
concept appears in a context quite different from previous ones, or when it com-
bines with other concepts. As mentioned previously, SCOP allows that for each
concept there exists some context that could actualize a certain property that
was thought to be very unlikely for that concept; thus each of the properties
can potentially play a possible role in any concept (though the weights for most
properties for any given state will tend to equal zero).
Kanerva (1988) makes some astute observations about the conceptual space
that can be realized by a sparse, distributed, content-addressable memory such
as human memory. We denote the number of subsymbolic microfeatures, or
properties, that are activated by some neuron and can be encoded in the mem-
ory as n. The set of all possible n-dimensional items that can be encoded in the
memory are represented as the set of vertices (if features assume only binary
14
values) or points (if features assume continuous values) in an n-dimensional hy-
percube, where the s items that actually are encoded in the memory occupy
some subset of these points. The distance d between two points in this space
is a measure of how dissimilar they are, referred to as the Hamming distance.
The number of items encoded in memory at Hamming distance d away from
any given item is equal to the binomial coefficient of n and d, which is well
approximated by a Gaussian distribution (Figure 2). Thus, if item X is 111...1
and its antipode is 000...0, and we consider X and its antipode to be the 'poles'
√
of the hypersphere, then approximately 68% of the other items lie within one
n) of the 'equator' region between these two extremes.
standard deviation (
As we move through Hamming space away from the equator toward either X or
n/n.
its antipode, the probability of an item falls off sharply by the proportion
√
Figure 2. Solid black curve is a schematic distribution of the Hamming dis-
tances from any given item to other items encoded in memory. The Gaussian
distribution arises because there are many more ways of sharing an intermedi-
ate number of features than there are of being extremely similar or different.
Activation decreases with distance from the most similar address, as indicated
by green shading. (A typical computer memory stores each item in only the
left-most address, whereas a distributed network stores it throughout the net-
work. A neural network that uses an activation function, such as the radial
basis function, is intermediate between these two extremes.)
Of course conceptual distance is context sensitive, but not in a chaotic way;
thus for example, ROSEBUD is closer to PANSY than to SPACESHIP across
the vast majority of contexts. So the Hamming distances here are for items in
their most prototypical forms, i.e., their most typical or commonly encountered
contexts.)
Note that Figure 2 depicts not the distribution of actual items in memory,
but of possible items; with respect to actual items encoded in memory, the
tail regions would be considerably sparser. This means that while there are
many ways of being somewhat similar to any given item, very few items are
15
either very similar to, or very dissimilar to, a given item, and the lower n is
the more pronounced the effect. This has implications for the model developed
here because interaction and integration is more probable amongst items that
are similar (or more correctly, more correlated). Langton's (1992) finding that
the information-carrying capacity of a system is maximized when its intercon-
nectedness falls within a narrow regime between order and chaos suggests that
to produce a steady stream of meaningfully related yet potentially creative re-
mindings, the correlation between one thought and the next must fall within a
narrow range.
It is interesting to look at how characteristics of associative memory are re-
alized by SCOP as compared to a neural network. A neural network is context-
sensitive in the sense that the output depends on (1) not just one feature but
all features of an input, (2) what patterns the neural network has learned pre-
viously (reflected in the weights on links between nodes), and (3) the activation
function that gives the relationship between activation of a node and its output
to other nodes. The fact that items are distributed in memory is modeled in a
neural network through parallel distributed activation of nodes. The fact that
memory exhibits coarse-coding, such that a given neuron responds maximally to
one microfeature but responds to a lesser degree to other similar microfeatures,
can be modeled by constraining the distribution using a radial basis function
(RBF). Each input activates a hypersphere of hidden nodes, with activation ta-
pering off in all directions according to a (usually) Gaussian distribution of with
standard deviation σ (Willshaw & Dayan, 1990; Hancock et al., 1991; Holden
& Niranjan, 1997; Lu et al., 1997). This enables one part of the network to
be modified without interfering with the capacity of other parts to store other
patterns. Where F is the activation, x is an i-dimensional input vector, and k
is the center of the RBF, hidden nodes are activated as follows
F (x) = e−(cid:80)
i((xi−ki/σ)2)
(10)
The further a node is from k, the less activation it receives from the input and
in turn contributes to the output. If σ is small, the input activates few neurons
but these few are hit hard; we say the activation function is spikey.
If σ is
large, the input activates many neurons to an almost equal degree; we say the
activation function is relatively flat. In effect σ moderates the degree to which
the output is affected by other patterns that have previously been encoded.
This approach nicely resolves the problem of interference amongst stored
patterns, but like all neural net approaches, it assumes the validity of the notion
of spreading activation, which has recently been seriously called into question
(Bruza, Kitto, Nelson & McEvoy, this volume; Nelson, McEvoy & Pointer, 2003;
Nelson & McEvoy, 2007). In SCOP, a similar effect can be obtained using a
variable we will refer to as the association threshold, denoted φ, which adjusts
the extent to which associations constitute part of the context that evokes the
change of state from p to q. For example, at a given moment you may be
pruning a tree. Let us refer to this cognitive state as p. In your next cognitive
state, let's call it q, you might be reminded of another tree you have pruned.
16
This change of cognitive state is possible because both p and q are instances
of the concept TREE-PRUNING with a non-zero transition probability µ(q, e,
p), The change of cognitive state is the result of associative recall (as discussed
in section 3.2.2), i.e., there exists a pathway between p and q denoted p → q.
Alternatively your associations may be not at the level of properties but at
the conceptual level; you might be reminded of your family tree, or the tree
of knowledge. You might be hungry or your hand might be getting sore. All
of these are possible components of the context that evokes the collapse from
state p of the concept to state q. The function φ modulates how you draw upon
these various elements of your situation to create a specific context by which
your current thought transforms into your next thought, as follows. If φ is low,
how p transforms into q is affected by other episodes previously encoded in the
neurons activated by p. The context that evokes the collapse is composed of
associations at the property level and/or at other higher levels of abstraction. In
other words, we posit that the direction of one's thought is shaped by a choice
of contexts that takes associations into account. Since it is impossible to model
with complete precision how these associations affect the collapse from p to q the
model contains a lack of knowledge and µ enables us to incorporate this lack of
knowledge into the model. Lowering φ allows increasingly distant associations
to be made; referring to figure 2 it will tend to increase how great the Hamming
distance can be (how far into the grey area) between the current experience
(experience X) and an item in memory in order for that item to be evoked by
the current experience. If on the other hand φ is high, associations play little
role; in other words, how p transforms into q is not affected by what other
episodes have been encoded in the neurons activated by p. Since mental energy
is not going toward finding associations it is freed up for symbolic operations
on p. Since associations do not affect the collapse from p to q there is much less
lack of knowledge, hence µ values tend to be 0 or 1.
3.2 Cognitive States versus States of a Concept
A cognitive state of the mind of an individual is a state of the composition of
all of concepts and combinations of concepts of the worldview of this individual.
Referring to the mathematical representation for a large combination of concepts
that we put forward in section 2.5, we can consider the state representing the
combination of all concepts contained in the worldview of an individual, i.e., the
cognitive state of the mind of this individual. Hence, making use of equation (9),
and denoting by U the collection of concepts available to an individual, where
we denote the state of an concept u ∈ U by means of the ket-vector u(cid:105) ∈ H,
where H is a complex Hilbert space, this gives
alkeiαlk (⊗k
j=1vjl(cid:105)))
(11)
n(cid:88)
p =
1
N
(cid:88)
mkeiθk (
k=1
l
where N is a normalization constant such that (cid:104)pp(cid:105) = 1, and vjl(cid:105) ∈ H repre-
sent states of the individual concepts, however not necessarily of the forms u(cid:105)
17
for an u ∈ U. Some of them might be of this form, others might be weighted
superpositions of such vectors, and still others might be normalized projections
of such vector due to concepts that only function as context in the considered
combination (we have not included such concepts in U). For a given cognitive
state p, most concepts u ∈ U are in their ground state. They are not evoked in
this instance of experience, hence we say they are not activated. Those concepts
u ∈ U that are not in their ground states for the cognitive state can be said to be
activated, or in the language of quantum mechanics we say they are in 'excited
states'.
Note that U refers to the totality of what has been conceived (framed in
conceptual terms), not what has been perceived. It is possible that one could
have an experience that activates memory but such that it is not framed in
conceptual terms. For example, one might have an experience (such as "I like
the white pebble in the water") without verbalizing it as such even to oneself,
or in the case of an infant without even possessing the concepts WHITE, PEB-
BLE, and WATER. That is, one might simply look at the thing and like it. We
reserve the term cognitive states to refer specifically to episodes that activate
concepts. A cognitive state that is not conceptualized, i.e. not interpreted in
terms of concepts, may still give way to another state through cognitive events
such as reminding, induction, and so forth, but this change of state reflects the
set of properties {a, b, ...} of the current episode, and the properties of similar
previously encoded episodes, not the conceptual structure by which these sets
of properties have been interpreted and organized.
We use the term episode to refer to a cognitive state that is either being en-
coded or has been encoded in long-term memory and that can thus potentially
be recalled from memory (either completely or partially, accurately or inaccu-
rately). The content of an episode can range from rich perceptual data to a
highly abstract or imaginary mental construct that has little relation to some-
thing ever directly perceived. The collection of all episodes is X , and episodes
will be denoted x, y, z ∈ X .
Change of cognitive state is recursive. The new cognitive state is a function
of the effect on the worldview of (1) the previous cognitive state and (2) the
perceived world. Because we use the quantum formalism, or its generalizations,
to mathematically describe states, contexts, and properties, it follows from this
quantum formalism how dynamics should be modeled. One models dynamics
by building the Schrodinger equation, or the generalized version of it. The
Schrodinger dynamics models the change that is provoked by the influence of
all the contexts. Mathematically we write
i
∂
∂t
p(t) = Hp(t)
(12)
where H is the Hamiltonian, which is a self-adjoint operator in the Hilbert
space H. Let us write the exponential form of the Schrodinger equation, which
is equivalent with the standard form, but more easy to interpret in the situation
18
where we use it. We have
p(t) = eiH(t−t0)p(t0)
(13)
This means that the cognitive state at an arbitrary time t is given by the cogni-
tive state of time t0, transformed under influence of the unitary transformation
which is the exponential of i times the Hamiltonian operator multiplied by the
time interval t − t0.
When quantum mechanics is applied in physics to describe the the micro-
world, the Hamiltonian H of a quantum entity under study is the operator
corresponding to the energy of the entity. Hence, it is the energy of the quantum
entity that determines how its state changes under the joint influence of all
contexts. There is no obvious way to define a notion that plays the role of
'energy' in our situation where the entity is a worldview instead of a quantum
entity. One possibility is to approach this situation the other way around. One
looks for a self-adjoint operator H, such that the dynamics of a worldview is
described well by the Schrodinger equation, and then the quantity corresponding
to this self-adjoint operator is introduced as being the energy of the worldview.4
3.3 Ways of Forging Conceptual Structure
This section identifies processes through which conceptual structure is formed.
This includes the formation of concepts, and of pathways connecting episodes to
episodes, episodes to concepts, and concepts to other concepts. In other words,
pathways provide internally generated means of going from thinking about or
experiencing one thing to thinking about or experiencing another. The strengths
of these pathways is reflected in the transition probabilities of SCOP.
3.3.1 Pavlovian Conditioning and Spatiotemporal Contiguity
One source of pathways arises through Pavlovian or classical conditioning, as
in the pairing of a bell with food. The episode (bell with food) can be said
to instantiate multiple concepts (BELL and FOOD). At the heart of classical
conditioning is spatiotemporal contiguity–the pairing of a conditioned stimulus
with an unconditioned stimulus causes a response–an association–to the uncon-
ditioned stimulus. However neutral stimuli that go together in space and /or
time can similarly become associated. To say that two or more properties are
properties of a particular concept or cognitive state is to say that they possess
associative strucure due to spatiotemporal contiguity, thus this kind of struc-
ture is built into SCOP. For example, whether or not BELL has been paired
to FOOD, most instances of BELL involve the sight and sound of a bell–two
4The Schrodinger equation has been used before in this way to model the dynamics of a
cognitive entity. Aerts, Broekaert and Smets (1999a,b) use Schrodinger equations to model
the cognitive dynamics of the Liar paradox. Busemeyer, Matthew and Wang (2006), use
the Schrodinger equation in a quantum game theoretic setting to model a decision of the
type where the disjunction effect appears, and a Hamiltonian is calculated with respect to
experimental data measured in this situation.
19
dissimilar properties. As another example the episode 'Mary is wearing a ball
gown' is an instance of the concept MARY denoted u ∈ U and an instance of
the concept BALL GOWN denoted v ∈ U. Following the experience of this
episode, thoughts of Mary could remember one of ball gowns and thoughts of
ball gowns could remind one of Mary. We say that there exists a bidirectional
pathway between u and v denoted u ↔ v.
3.3.2 Associative Recall
Another source of pathways arises through the experience of an episode that
is so similar to some previously encoded episode that it evokes a reminding or
recall of that previous episode. For example, the episode 'Mary is wearing a
ball gown' may evoke a reminding of the episode 'Jane is wearing a ball gown'.
Let p be the cognitive state of experiencing the episode 'Mary is wearing a ball
gown' and q be the cognitive state of experiencing the episode 'Jane is wearing
a ball gown'. If p evokes q we say that there exists a pathway between p and
q denoted p → q.
3.3.3 Abstraction
An important source of conceptual structure is recognition that particular episodes
could be seen as states of a new concept, resulting in the formation of that new
concept through the process of abstraction. This can occur when due to the
distributed nature of memory, the associative recall process retrieves an episode
with substantial overlap of features or conceptual structure, An example is CAT
reminds one of DOG resulting in formation of the concept PET. Abstraction
generally involves the formation of a more abstract concept out of less abstract
(more constrained) concepts. With SCOP this is described as follows. Sup-
pose that p is an episode involving APPLE (and perhaps another episode q
involving ORANGE). Abstraction occurs if one realizes (or is told) that there
could exist a concept u ∈ U, the concept FRUIT represented by the SCOP
(Σu,Mu,Lu, µu, νu) such that p ∈ Σu, and similarly q ∈ Σu. This can arise
spontaneously as a result of associative recall; for example an apple reminds one
of an orange which leads to the formation of an item in memory that encom-
passes both.
3.3.4 Identifying Natural Relations
Pathways are forged through the learning or recognition of natural relations as
discussed in section 2.3. For example consider the concepts p and q.
If one
learns or realizes that e ∧ f ≤ e, a pathway e ∧ f ↔ e is generated. Similarly if
one learns or realizes that e ≤ e ∨ f , a pathway e ↔ e ∨ f is generated.
An important kind of pathway is the identification of episodes as states or
instances of a particular concept, or of concepts as states of more abstract con-
cepts. This is referred to as instantiation. With SCOP this is described as
20
follows. Suppose that u ∈ U is the concept APPLE, represented by the SCOP
(Σu,Mu,Lu, µu, νu), and p is a state of apple, say, FUJI APPLE. If one learns
or recognizes that p ∈ Σu, then we say that there is an 'isa' pathway connecting
p with u, denoted p → u, as well as a pathway u → p.
If there exists a concept w ∈ U such that p and q are both known to be
states or instances of w, hence p, q ∈ Σw. Thus p ↔ w and q ↔ w. Since p → w
and w → q, through transitivity, p → q. In such cases we refer to p and q as
sister instances of w.
3.3.5 Conjunctions
It is not always the case that a new concept is more abstract or less constrained
than the concepts that gave rise to it. Another important source of conceptual
structure is the formation of a conjunction of concepts, as in the joining of the
concepts SNOW and MAN to give the idea of a man built out of snow, a SNOW-
MAN. This occurs when due to the distributed nature of memory, what the
associative recall process retrieves has components that lack substantial overlap
of features or properties, and that under most contexts would not be retrieved
together, and were thought to be unrelated. In SCOP this is mathematically
described as in Section 2.5. Two concepts combine to give a conjunction using
the tensor product formulation which results in (amongst other states) states of
entanglement. Consider a joint concept u1⊗u2 described in the complex Hilbert
space SCOP formed by means of the tensorproduct H1 ⊗ H2 of the two Hilbert
spaces H1 and H2. If one or more of the states p ∈ u1⊗ u2 is an entangled state,
we say that there exists a bidirectional pathway connecting the two concepts
that comprise the conjunction, hence u1 ↔ u2. above question.
Alternatively, we say there exists a pathway if the following condition is met.
There exists a concept v, such that v in state q ∈ Σv is a context for concept u
in state p ∈ Σu. We call it eq ∈ Mu. eq changes p to a new state of concept u.
This state is q ∧ p ∈ Σu, and µ(p ∧ q, eq, p) ≈ 1.
3.4 The Chaining and Integration of Pathways
The above-mentioned ways of forging conceptual structure work by way of
changing the set M of contexts associated with a given concept. For exam-
ple, consider a SCOP that consists of the concepts STONE and ANIMAL and
instances of ANIMAL, such as LION, TIGER, and MONKEY. We model an
episode involving exposure to a lion made of stone as the concept combination
STONE LION. The set of contexts associated with other animal concepts ex-
pands to include the potentiality that the animal can be made of stone. Thus
M for MONKEY now includes STONE MONKEY and M for TIGER now
includes STONE TIGER.
We said that with respect to a concept, the change of state p ∈ Σ to
state q ∈ Σ under the influence of context e-hence for which µ(q, e, p) is the
21
probability-can can be internally driven, externally driven, or both. This is
also the case with respect to the context that drives a change of cognitive state;
it may consist of a perceived stimulus or component(s) of the environment,
or elements of the associative memory or worldview, or a mixture of the two.
Pathways allow the autonomous (hence internally driven, not dependent upon
change in the external environment) transformation of thoughts and ideas.
Instances of self-triggered recall can be chained together recursively resulting
in a stream of thought. A change from one cognitive state u ∈ U to another
v ∈ U may in turn modify the worldview, hence the (internally driven compo-
nent of the) context by which v is 'measured' or made sense of. Although u may
have been an eigenstate with respect to the context provided by the previous
state of the worldview, v may well not be an eigenstate with respect to the
context provided by this newly updated version of the worldview. This means
that there is another collapse or change of state from v to w. This can continue
recursively, until the concept enters a state that is an eigenstate with respect
to the context provided by the worldview due to the effect on it of the previous
cognitive state. It is through this chaining of episodes that indirect pathways
or what we will refer to as routes through associative memory are forged.
x, y, z ∈ X can be said to be integrated if for each episode there exists some
possible direct or indirect route to any other episode by way of pathways. If
this is the case the whole exhibits emergent structure that cannot be reduced
to the sum of the parts.
Thus conceptual structure arises by way of the creation of new concepts
through abstraction and concept combination, and the creation of new pathways
amongst episodes and concepts through processes such as associative recall, spa-
tiotemporal contiguity, and the identification of natural relations. Examples of
the formation of conceptual structure will be elaborated in the tentative model
of the transition to cognitive modernity proposed in the pages to come.
4 Modeling the Episodic Mind
Now that the basic elements of SCOP and the extension of it to describe con-
ceptual integration have been introduced, let us apply it to the subject of this
paper: evolution of the capacity to develop an internal model of the world,
or worldview, the components of which are accessed spontaneously, recursively,
and in a context-sensitive manner to interpret (and generate) elements of cul-
ture. We begin by modeling the mind for which this is not the case.
4.1 Coarseness of Memory Limits Associative Recall and
Conceptual Structure
The episodic mind may be innately predisposed to categorize some situations-
such as for example situations involving a member of another species-as in-
stances of FRIEND, FOE, OR FOOD (without possessing words for these con-
22
cepts). This facilitates the formation of pathways due to spatiotemporal conti-
guity. An experience that might not have evoked an episode encoded in memory
if it had not been encoded as an instance of FRIEND might evoke it if it is en-
coded as an instance of FRIEND because the fact that both are instances of
FRIEND makes the similarity more salient. Thus innate concepts facilitate the
formation of pathways through associative recall, and thereby allow for a limited
development of conceptual structure.
Although the episodic mind is capable of associative recall-for which the
context that causes the change of cognitive state is something in the externally
perceived world-it cannot engage in self-triggered recall-for which the con-
text is generated internally. This means that instances of associative recall are
not chained together recursively to give a stream of self-triggered thought. For
this reason, the episodic minds of early hominids tended not to deviate far from
the 'here and now' of perceived episodes, as opposed to the world of mental
constructs and imagination. Why might our early ancestors have been inca-
pable of self-triggered recall? It is reasonable to assume that the smaller brain
of the early hominid had fewer neurons, and thus n was small; that is, with
few properties or subsymbolic microfeatures distinguishing one episode or item
encoded in memory from another. Thus episodes were encoded in less detail.
Since associative recall requires similarity of features or conceptual structure,
and since there are fewer features, there are fewer routes for associative recall
(in which one episode evokes another). On those rare occasions when associa-
tive recall does occur, it is unlikely to occur immediately afterward, and even if
it does, since the context that causes it is external as opposed to internal, the
result is not refinement or honing of the current thought. As mentioned earlier
in the discussion of Figure 2, as we move through Hamming space away from
the equator toward either X or its antipode, the probability of encountering a
memory item falls off sharply by a maximum (depending on the number and
n/n. For the episodic mind, the region of sub-
nature of items encoded) of
stantial overlap between X and another episode is extremely small.
√
The situation is compounded by the fact that since two processes by which
new concepts come about, abstraction and conjunction, depend on associative
recall, episodes are less apt to be conceptualized, or framed in terms of their
conceptual structure. Since unconceptualized episodes lack conceptual structure
they are not as deeply rooted into the worldview; thus there are few possible
retrieval routes. As a simple example, an episode involving a ball but not con-
ceptualized as an instance of TOY would not evoke memories of other toys such
as dolls because the similarity between balls and dolls resided primarily at the
conceptual level, not the perceptual level. Therefore there are few ways in which
episodes can be similar not just at the property level but at more abstract con-
ceptual levels.
23
4.2 Associativity is Detrimental for a Coarse-grained Mem-
ory
The occasional episodic mind might (due to a genetic mutation) have a higher
tendency toward associative thought, i.e. a lower φ, meaning that a recalled
episode need not be very similar to the current episode to be evoked by it.
Such an individual would be capable of making associations, perhaps even re-
cursively, i.e. engaging in a kind of representational redescription, or stream of
self-triggered thought. However, recall from section 3.1 Langton's (1992) find-
ing that the information-carrying capacity of a system is maximized when its
interconnectedness or self-similarity of components falls within a narrow regime
between order and chaos. Forcing this kind of interaction between concepts in
a coarse-grained memory (one with low n) would cause discontinuity between
one thought and the next. Therefore thought would readily become chaotic,
lacking the necessary continuity to hone a solution to a problem or develop and
carry out a plan. Abstract thought, unlike episodic thought, cannot rely on
the continuity of the external world (e.g. if a desk is in front of you now it is
likely to still be in front of you now) to lend coherence to conscious experience;
this continuity must be internally driven. Since when n is low, a mutation that
results in a high φ leads to discontinuous (garbled) thought, it would be evolu-
tionarily selected against.
4.3 Coarse-grained Memory Lacks Quantum Structure
In summary, since the episodic mind contains only coarse-grained episodes and
few concepts, there is little opportunity for interaction and transformation of
conceptual structure through reminding events, abstraction, or concept combi-
nation. So for any u ∈ U, represented by the SCOP (Σu,Mu,Lu, µu, νu), any
p ∈ Σ, for any context e, f, g... ∈ M, µ(p, e, p) is close to an eigenstate, hence
≈ 1. One does not need the formalisms of quantum mechanics to model the
dynamics of the episodic mind precisely because concepts are few, and have
little effect on one another. (Note that SCOP can still be used to describe the
episodic mind because as mentioned earlier it can describe both classical and
quantum dynamics.)
5 The Transition from Episodic to Mimetic Mind
We noted that around 1.7 MYA there was a sudden increase in brain size,
and this period is also associated with the origin of culture, and onset of what
is referred to as the mimetic mind (Donald, 1991). The mimetic mind can
access memories independent of external cues and act them out, group episodes
together as instances of an abstract concept, refine ideas, and improve skills
through repetition or rehearsal. We now proceed to examine a tentative scenario
for how this transition came about.
24
5.1 Associativity is Beneficial for a Fine-grained Memory
It seems reasonable to assume that the larger brain of the mimetic mind has
more neurons than the brain of the episodic mind, and thus responds to more
properties or subsymbolic microfeatures of episodes. Therefore episodes are en-
coded in more detail, i.e. n is larger. There are more ways to distinguish one
episode or item encoded in memory from another, and more pathways by which
one episode can evoke representational redescription or a reminding of another
episode. Thus it is well possible that for any given context e, f, g... ∈ M, any
p ∈ Σ is not an eigenstate, i.e., µ(p, e, p) << 1.
Let us now examine what would happen if, again, due to a random mu-
tation, a larger brained mimetic individual had a heightened tendency toward
associative thought, i.e., a high φ. As with the episodic mind, this means that
a recalled episode need not be very similar to the current episode to be evoked
by it, and the individual is capable of representational redescription, or self-
triggered thought. One thought is able to spontaneously evoke another thought
that is a modified version of the first, and so forth recursively, such that the
original thought transforms through interaction with the individual's conceptual
structure. However, since memory is not coarse but fine-grained (large n), the
outcome is different. The Gaussian distribution of possible Hamming distances
between the current episode and an item encoded in memory (as depicted in
Figure 2) is wider, meaning there are now many more ways for an item in mem-
ory to be somewhat similar or loosely correlated to a given episode. This means
that a stream of thought can retain the necessary balance between change and
continuity to hone a solution to a problem or develop and carry out a plan.
Since when n is large a mutation that decreases φ thereby increasing µ leads
to enhanced capacity for fruitful abstract thought, it facilitates a wide range of
cognitive skills, and would be evolutionarily selected for.
Because the individual with a higher φ is more prone to associative recall,
this individual is better equipped to form concepts. Since there is more concep-
tual structure in place, there is more of it to be affected by any given episode,
and it is more likely that conceptual structure thereby contributes to the con-
text that evokes a successive change of state (self-triggered recall).
5.2 Onset of Extensive Abstraction
The next step toward an integrated worldview is the formation of abstract con-
cepts, such that items that share properties become conceived of as instances of
the same thing. Suppose there are two episodes or concepts u, v ∈ U, both mod-
eled respectively by SCOPs (Σu,Mu,Lu, µu, νu) and (Σv,Mv, µv, νv). Suppose
there exists a concept w ∈ U, such that u and v are exemplars (instances) of
w, and hence can be represented as states of w. Suppose that concept w is
modeled by a SCOP (Σw,Mw,Lw, µw, νw). Hence there are states p, q ∈ Σw,
such that concepts u and v are states of w. We say that there exists a pathway
from concept u to concept v and a pathway from concept v to concept u, and
25
denote these pathways u → v and v → u. This can be generalized by saying
that states pu of u and pv of v are also states of w.
Let us now examine how conceptual structure forms, starting with basic level
concepts and moving toward concepts that are more abstract (Rosch, 1978) via
the incorporation of new states and new contexts. Initially each concept has so
few states associated with it that a state of one concept is rarely also a state
of another concept. Thus reminding events are rare. However the activation of
states of one concept that are also states of another is facilitated by the fact
that the properties of any concept can themselves become viewed in concep-
tual terms, i.e. they can become concepts. Consider the concept MONKEY.
A mimetic individual might encode in memory a state p of MONKEY with the
property a: 'has arms', i.e. the state MONKEY WITH ARMS. If the individual
has not just recognized that 'has arms' is a property of MONKEY but realized
ARMS as a concept in its own right, then through the encoding of p, MON-
KEY WITH ARMS, the concept MONKEY becomes connected to the concept
ARMS. The conceptualization of an episode as MONKEY WITH ARMS pro-
vides a pathway from episodes related to monkeys to episodes related to arms.
For the combination MONKEY ARM, the concept MONKEY functions as a
context rather than as an entity. This is clear because if we consider the states
that MONKEY ARM can be in, these states are not states of MONKEY, but
they are states of ARM. (Clearly MONKEY ARM is not a MONKEY, but
MONKEY ARM is an ARM.) To model this, we let H be the Hilbert space
of states of ARM and u(cid:105) be the ground state of ARM. Then MONKEY is
described by an orthogonal projection operator P : H → H, which is a linear
function, which is idempotent, i.e., P 2 = P , and Hermitian, i.e., P ∗ = P , such
that the state of MONKEY ARM is given by Pu(cid:105)/(cid:107)Pu(cid:105)(cid:107) where (cid:107)Pu(cid:105)(cid:107) is the
length of Pu(cid:105). (It is possible to imagine a context where it would be better to
consider MONKEY as the entity. Of course, knowing the rules of the English
language, the combination should then be written as ARM MONKEY, and it
would mean a type of monkey characterized for example by a special ways of
using its arms. It is a characteristic of metaphor that contexts are pushed into
becoming entities.)
Our mimetic individual might subsequently encode a state of MONKEY with
the property b: 'has arms and legs'. The concept MONKEY is now connected
to both concepts ARMS and LEGS. Moreover, 'has arms' and 'has arms and
legs' are connected by the relation b ≤ a. Thus an early step in the forging of
organizational structure amongst the items encoded in memory is the grouping
together of those properties that exhibit spatiotemporal contingency. When the
properties 'has arms' and 'has legs' co-occur, they start to be conceived of as
parts of a whole. This organizing of stimuli into sets of properties that tend
to go together in the world is an important step toward the establishment of
conceptual structure that internally models that world. As episodes accumulate
in memory, so do states and their SCOP structures. As memory comes to en-
compass more of the natural relations amongst concepts, connections amongst
concepts become more widespread, and an integrated conceptual structure starts
to emerge.
26
The same thing happens with contexts (as one might expect, since as stated
earlier concepts can also be contexts). Consider the concept STAR. One might
encode in memory a state of STAR under the context e: to the north. The
concept STAR is thereby connected to the concept NORTH. One might subse-
quently encode a state of STAR under the context f : to the north at dusk. The
concept STAR is now connected to the concept DUSK as well as the concept
NORTH, and the contexts e: to the north and f : to the north at dusk are con-
nected by the relation f ≤ e. As memory comes to encompass contexts that are
increasingly stronger, connections amongst concepts become more widespread,
and the worldview thereby becomes more integrated.
As concepts accumulate, episodes are increasingly interpreted in terms of
them, making episodes increasingly likely to evoke reminding of previously en-
coded episodes, or bring about representational redescription of the current
episode. The probability increases that a given episode is similar enough to at
least one item in memory to evoke it. With SCOP this is modeled as an increase
in the number of potential contexts for which µ(pi, ej, pk) > 0. The upshot is
that one is able to recursively modify and redescribe thoughts and events. As
more concepts become available, this gives rise to self-triggered sequences of
thought, which increase in duration and frequency.
The probability of one MONKEY episode evoking another is enhanced through
the recognition that they are in essence the same thing, i.e.
instances of the
concept MONKEY. The concept MONKEY facilitates the evoking of memories
involving instances of monkeys.
It connects any given monkey episode with
not just other instances involving monkeys but with whatever associations have
been formed amongst the concept MONKEY and other items (such as ARMS,
LEGS...). Since representational redescription is now possible, using SCOP the
function µ(q, e, p) gives a probability greater than zero that a particular state
under a particular context will change to a particular other state, e.g. LARGE
MONKEY might transform to DANGEROUS LARGE MONKEY.
A new state of a concept constitutes a new episodes, hence with each newly-
formed state of a concept the number of episodes increases. If it is an episode
that does not map onto a particular thing or event in the world but an abstrac-
tion (such as FURNITURE, or BEAUTY, or DEMOCRACY), it increases not
just the number of items amongst which one could form associations, but the
density of connections amongst previously encoded items. For example, due
to a memory of someone using twine to strangle something, TWINE may be
associatively linked to ARROW though they share few properties, because they
are both instances of WEAPON. Depending on the context, a concept such as
WEAPON can project onto states with different properties and different mean-
ings. It is because there is greater potential in the mimetic mind for interaction
amongst episodes (both conceptualized and unconceptualized) that a Hilbert
space quantum model is well suited to model its dynamics.
27
5.3 Strengths and Limitations of the Mimetic Mind
It is tentatively proposed that this state of affairs describes a mimetic mode of
cognition. It is not merely a relay-station for coordinating inputs to appropri-
ate responses. Because n is higher, φ can afford to be lower, which facilitates
the forging of meaningful conceptual structure. The mimetic mind engages ex-
tensively in abstraction and is capable of self-triggered recall. Since memories
and concepts are starting to be organized in a way that reflects abstract rela-
tionships amongst them, reminding events are not infrequent, and potentially
chained to give a short stream of self-triggered thought, and the current thought
can become part of the context in which the next is experienced; thus actions
can be refined. However, the mimetic mind is not very creative, and it is not
integrated.
it does not constitute a coherent mental model of how various as-
pects of the world relate to one another.
6 The Transition from Mimetic Mind to Mod-
ern Human Mind
The archaeological record reveals a burst of creativity indicative of a cultural
transition in Europe between 60,000 and 30,000 ka (Bar-Yosef, 1994; Klein,
1989; Leakey, 1984; Mellars, 1973, 1989a, b; Mithen, 1996, 1998; Soffer, 1994;
Stringer & Gamble, 1993; White, 1982). More recently it has been suggested
that modern cognition originated earlier and more gradually in Africa, and that
the European data reflects a wave of immigration of humans from Africa with
sufficient intelligence and creative problem solving skills to cope with the new
environment (McBrearty & Brooks, 2000). Leakey (1984) writes "Known as the
Upper Paleolithic Revolution, this collective archaeological signal is unmistak-
able evidence of the modern human mind at work" (p. 93-94). Mithen (1996)
refers to this period as the 'big bang' of human culture, claiming that it marks
the beginning of art, science, and religion, and that it shows more innovation
than the previous six million years of human evoluti on. What brought about
this cultural transition?
One possibility is that the cultural transition of the Middle/Upper Paleolithic
reflects an enhanced ability to blend concepts (Fauconnier & Turner, 2002). In
a similar vein, Mithen (1998) suggests that it reflects onset of the capacity to
transform conceptual spaces. The answer proposed here is consistent with these
hypotheses but further specifies what kind of cognitive structure could have
arisen to allow for these abilities.
6.1 Onset of the Capacity to Shift between Analytic and
Associative Thought
It is suggested that the transition from a mimetic to a modern form of cognition
is what gave rise to the cultural transition of the Middle/Upper Paleolithic, and
28
that this came about through onset of the capacity to subject different situa-
tions to different kinds of cognitive processing. It is widely believed that there
are two forms of thought, or that thought varies along a continuum between two
extremes (Ashby & Ell, 2002; Dennett, 1978; Gabora, 2002a, b; Gabora, under
revision; Johnson-Laird, 1983; Neisser, 1963, Piaget, 1926; Rips, 2001; Sloman,
1996). At one end of the continuum is an analytic mode of thought conducive to
deduction and to describing and analyzing relationships of cause and effect. At
the other end of the continuum is an intuitive, overinclusive, or associative mode
of thought conducive to finding subtle relationships; i.e. connections between
items that are correlated, but not necessarily causally related. In this mode,
items are represented in terms of not just their most typical properties but also
in terms of less typical, perhaps context-dependent ones as well. Associative
thought is related to the notion of flat associative hierarchies, a term applied to
those who give not only typical but also marginal or atypical items when asked
to say words that come to mind in response to a particular word, e.g. OSTRICH
in response to BIRD, or BEANBAG CHAIR in response to CHAIR (Mednick,
1962). The notion of two forms of thought is also captured in Gardenfors' tiered
model of cognition; the analytic mode is related to the symbolic level of cogni-
tion and the associative mode is related to the conceptual level.
It has been proposed that the transition from mimetic mind to modern hu-
man mind came about through the onset of contextual focus: the capacity to
spontaneously focus or defocus attention in response to the current situation,
and thus alternate between analytic and associative thought according to the
demands of the situation (Gabora, 2003, Aerts & Gabora, 2005a). This allowed
for a worldview with recursively embedded hierarchical structure and concepts
of varying levels of abstraction, which paved the way for conceptual integration.
Let us now formulate this hypothesis more precisely.
Here we describe the onset of the capacity for contextual focus mathemat-
ically as the onset of the capacity to modulate φ. It is proposed that analytic
thought is the result of focusing attention, thereby increasing φ, which globally
(for all states of all concepts, as well as all unconceptualized cognitive states)
decreases µ, the transition probability. Since one state is less likely to spon-
taneously give way to another as a consequence of their shared properties and
abstract conceptual structure, effort can be focused on manipulating items in
their most prototypical, unambiguous form according to the rules of logic, as in
the formation of abstract concepts, the recognition of episodes as instances of a
concept, and furthering development of the structure of the lattices of properties
and contexts associated with known, existing concepts as described above.
It is proposed that associative thought is the result of defocusing attention,
thereby decreasing φ. One is more likely to make associations and be reminded
of items based on not just their most typical properties but also in terms of
less typical, context-dependent properties, or on the basis of abstract structure,
or spatiotemporal contiguity. This is conducive to applying known concepts in
new contexts; for example, application of the concept HANDLE to challenging
situations, as in 'get a handle on the situation' or to intimate relationships, as
in 'love handle'. This results in a transition from domain-specific representa-
29
tions to more broadly applicable representations, enabling seemingly disparate
domains of knowledge to be bridged.
6.2 The Formation of Conjunctions
The capacity to temporarily decrease φ and thereby enter a more chaotic regime
(for example, when one is stuck in a problem or seeking self-expression) is not
just conducive to applying concepts in new contexts, but also to merging con-
cepts to generate new ones. This is described as follows.
For two concepts u, v ∈ U described by SCOPs (Σu,Mu,Lu, µu, νu) and
(Σv,Mv, µv, νv) it may be that a conjunction exists. A conjunction is de-
scribed in SCOP using the tensor product when the SCOPs are Hilbert space
based, as described in section 2.5. The conjunction is considered a new concept,
not just the logical construct of a conjunction. For example, suppose u is the
concept SNOW and v the concept MAN. The tensor product SCOP models the
concept SNOWMAN. States of SNOWMAN are states of SNOW and states of
MAN. For example OG WITH SNOW ON HIS HEAD, as one concept, is not
a state of the concept SNOWMAN, but it is a state of the logical construct of
the conjunction SNOW and MAN.
The formation of a conjunction involves two steps (Aerts & Gabora, 2005b).
The first step involves recognition that one ofthe concepts is a specific kind of
context for the other. For example, consider the concepts SNOW and MAN.
Note that The man is made of snow can be a context for MAN. It changes the
ground state of MAN to a state of MAN that is a 'prelude' to the formation
of the new concept SNOWMAN. This prelude state is the root of the pathway
that connects the concepts SNOW and MAN.
We define this pathway formally as follows. Consider two concepts u, v ∈ U,
modeled by SCOPs (Σu,Mu,Lu, µu, νu) and (Σv,Mv, µv, νv). Supposes that
state p ∈ Σu (hence a state of concept u) is a context of concept v, which we
call ep ∈ Mv. This context ep creates a new state of concept v by acting on
the ground state q of v. We could for example denote this new state as p(cid:52)q.
We say that a pathway exists from p to q, denoted p ↔ q. State p(cid:52)q is a
prelude to the state of the new concept when a conjunction of u and v forms.
For example, the state of MAN that results when the context the man is made
of snow influences the ground state of MAN is the state p(cid:52)q. It is what we
are calling a 'prelude state' of the ground state of the new concept SNOWMAN.
6.3 Conceptual Integration
The formation of a new concept increases the number of concepts by one, but
it increases the number of pathways by, not just the number of states of that
concept, but also other episodes and concepts that share conceptual structure
(e.g. BEANBAG CHAIR is a state of BEANBAG and a state of CHAIR and for
that matter a state of FURNITURE. . . ). Therefore, as the number of concepts
increases, the number of pathways increases faster. It is known in graph theory
30
that when the ratio of edges to points reaches approximately 0.5-sometimes
referred to as the percolation threshold (Kauffman, 1993)-the probability that
one giant cluster emerges goes from extremely unlikely to almost inevitable (Er-
dos & Renyi, 1959, 1960). Here, when the ratio of pathways to episodes and
concepts surpasses this threshold, it becomes almost inevitable that the items in
memory reach a critical density where a large subset of them undergoes a phase
transition to a state wherein for each episode or concept there exists some possi-
ble direct or indirect route to any other episode or concept by way of internally
driven remindings or associations. In this way, they constitute an integrated
conceptual web.
There are numerous ways of achieving conceptual integration even starting
from the same set of episodes, and these ways convey varying degrees of inte-
gration and consistency on the resulting worldview. They differ with respect to
the lattice structures of states and contexts that connect these episodes, and the
degree of penetration of the conceptual space. Under what conditions will the
transformation from discrete memories to interconnected conceptual web actu-
ally occur? We need to show that some subset of the concepts encoded in an
individual's mind inevitably reach a critical point where there exists a direct or
indirect route (sequentially applied pathways) by which every member of that
subset can access every other member. We need to show that R, the number of
pathways by which one episode can evoke another, increases faster than s, the
number of episodes. That is, as the memory assimilates episodes, it comes to
have more ways of generating them than the number of them that has explicitly
been encoded.
Under what conditions does R increase faster than s? The ability to form
context-sensitive concepts plays a crucial role. To determine how this affects R,
let us assume for the moment that memory is fully connected. In other words,
we temporarily assume that all states of all encoded items have a non-zero tran-
sition probability to all states of all other encoded items. Clearly this is not the
case, but this simplification facilitates analysis that also applies to a more real-
istic model of memory. To make things simple we will be conservative and limit
the sort of pathways under consideration to associative recall and pathways be-
tween abstract concepts and their instances. Concepts have n properties, where
the number of applicable properties (properties with non-zero weights) ranges
from a minimum of m to a maximum of M . RA, the number of ways a pathway
can be realized through abstraction, equals the number of pathways enabled by
an n-dimensional concept, multiplied by the number of n-dimensional concepts,
summed over all values of n from m to M − 1. The number of pathways equals
the number of items that are instances of an n-dimensional concept = 2M−n.
The number of n-dimensional concepts is equal to the binomial coefficient of M
and n. The result is multiplied by two since an a concept can evoke an instance,
and likewise, an instance can evoke a concept.
(cid:18) M
(cid:19)
RA = 2(2M−m
+ 2M−(m+1)
+ ... + 2
M − 1
)
(14)
(cid:18)M
(cid:19)
m
(cid:18) M
(cid:19)
m + 1
31
M−1(cid:88)
n=m
= 2
(cid:18)M
(cid:19)
(15)
2M−n(n − 1)
n
This shows that the greater the density of concepts, the greater the likelihood
of conceptual integration. Abstraction (the formation of a general concept out
of instances) increases s by creating a new concept. But it increases R more,
because the more abstract the concept, the greater the number of concepts a
short Hamming distance away (since xi − ki = 0 for the irrelevant properties,
so they make no contribution to Hamming distance). In other words, concepts
with fewer properties enable exponentially more pathways.
A second thing to note is that as n starts to decrease, the number of possible
abstractions for each value of n increases (up to M/2 after which it starts to
decrease). Thus the more likely any given memory item is to get activated and
participate in a reminding or associative recall event. Whereas R increases as
abstraction makes relationships amongst concepts increasingly explicit, s lev-
els off as new experiences have to be increasingly unusual in order to result
in the formation of new concepts. Furthermore, when the carrying capacity of
the memory is reached (such that the encoding of new items entails significant
degradation of previously encoded ones), s plateaus but R does not. Taken
together these points mean: the more deeply a mind delves into abstractions,
the more the distribution in Figure 2 rises and becomes skewed to the left. The
effect is magnified by the fact that the more active a region of conceptual space,
the more likely an abstraction is to be positioned there, such that abstractions
beget abstractions through positive feedback loops.
Thus, as long as φ is low enough to permit abstraction and small enough
to permit temporal continuity, the average value of n decreases, and sooner
or later, the system is expected to reach a critical percolation threshold such
that R increases exponentially faster than s. The memory becomes so densely
packed that any episode is bound to be close enough in Hamming distance to
some previously-encoded episode to evoke it. The memory (or some portion of
it) is holograph-like in the sense that there is a pathway of associations from
any one episode to any other. What was once just a collection of isolated mem-
ories is now a structured network of concepts, instances, and relationships-a
worldview. It can engage in streams of thought that redefine elements of the
world in terms of their substitutable and complementary relationships, plan a
course of action, engage in symbolic communication with others, and so forth,
as outlined in the introduction. It is used not just passively to understand what
the world is like, but actively to navigate life experiences.
6.4 Conceptual Integration in SCOP
Let us now show what conceptual integration means with respect to SCOP. For
an arbitrary subset X ⊂ X of episodes we define
cl(X) = {y y ∈ X , and ∃ x ∈ X such that y ↔ x}
(16)
32
In Appendix 1 we prove that cl is a closure relation. This allows us to consider
for an arbitrary subset of episodes X ⊂ X its closure cl(X). This is the set of
episodes such that for each episode x ∈ cl(X) there is an episode y ∈ X such
that x ↔ y is connected to y.
We now consider 'one' specific episode x, and the subset containing 'only'
this one episode, hence the singleton {x}. We can ask what is the closure of
this subset, hence what is cl({x})? In other words, what is the set of episodes
connected to x? In Appendix 2 we show that the closure relation conserves
full connectedness. This means that if we start by considering a fully connected
subset of episodes, and add all the episodes connected to episodes of this subset,
this is still a fully connected subset of episodes.
The next thing we want to show is that cl(X) is the biggest fully connected
subset containing X. This proof is given in Appendix 3. Let us investigate what
this tells us about the set of all episodes X . Consider two episodes x, y ∈ X .
There are theoretically only two possibilities. Either x ↔ y, or x (cid:54)↔ y.
If
x ↔ y, we can consider cl({x, y}), which is then the biggest fully connected
subset containing x and y. If x (cid:54)↔ y we consider cl({x}) and cl({y}). We know
that cl({x}) is the biggest fully connected subset containing x and cl({y}) is
the biggest fully connected subset containing y. Can cl({x}) and cl({y}) have
elements in common? No, indeed, suppose that z ∈ cl({x}) ∩ cl({y}). Then
z ↔ x and z ↔ y, and from transitivity of the connectivity relation it follows
that x ↔ y. Hence cl({x}) ∩ cl({y}) = ∅. But the situation is more extreme.
We do not even have any element in cl({x}) that is connected with any ele-
ment in cl({y}). We can prove the proposition that for the closure of two single
episodes, the closure subsets are equal, or their intersection is empty. This proof
is given in Appendix 4. In Appendix 5 we prove that X is equal to the disjoint
union of fully connected subsets of episodes, and moreover each of these fully
connected subsets of episodes is the closure of a single episode. This implies
that if one of these regions of fully connected subsets becomes dominant, in the
sense that it is the one used to generate internal contexts and interpret episodes,
and the one generally activated in conscious experience, then also this one is the
closure of one single episode. This one single episode is not unique; there are
many episodes that 'as one single episode' can play the role of being the gener-
ating element for the whole closure. This is the meaning of the possibility that
cl({y}) = cl({z}) is many occasions, and in fact whenever y ↔ z. Others may
continue to exist but be virtually inaccessible from the dominant one, and may
be experienced only in situations where there are fewer social and pragmatic
constraints on how we internally generate the contexts that enable thoughts to
unfold. The bottom line is that the conceptual structure now has a vast amount
of potentiality, and the extent to which this potentiality is accessed at any given
instant depends on the situation and the value of φ.
33
7 The Development and Evolution of an Inte-
grated Worldview
It is possible that some items in memory are isolated outliers-not woven into
this conceptual web, and thus inaccessible. (It seems reasonable that this might
be the case for experiences that are far from everyday reality and insufficiently
reinforced through reminding events, such as dreams or perhaps traumatic ex-
periences.) Since we do not have conscious access to them, it is difficult to know
whether they are abundant or rare. It is possible that much of what constitutes
a mind is never woven into an integrated worldview. What we can say is that
to constitute a worldview, the memory architecture must be such that, for any
typically encountered stimulus or situation, there must exist a means of relating
or re-describing it in terms of previously encoded items. Thus for an integrated
worldview, this includes all memory items necessary for the redescription and
accommodation of frequently encountered experiences.
Note that conceptual integration would be unlikely to be achieved simulta-
neously throughout a society of individuals. It would thus take time for social
propagation of the cultural 'fruits' of such an achievement. However, even if
for example one individual, Agu has a higher activation threshold than another
individual, say Oga, once he has assimilated enough of Oga's abstractions, his
concepts become so densely packed that a version of Oga's worldview snaps
into place in his mind. Agu in turn shares fragments of his worldview with his
friends, who in turn shares them with others. These different 'hosts' expose their
versions of these fragments of what was originally Oga's worldview to different
experiences, different bodily constraints, sculpting them into unique internal
models of the world. Small differences are amplified through positive feedback,
transforming the space of viable worldview niches. Individuals whose activation
threshold is too small to achieve worldview closure are at a reproductive disad-
vantage and, over time, eliminated from the population. When Agu imitates a
mannerism of Ogu's he might, on the fly, modify it by putting his own spin on
it. As worldviews become increasingly complex, the artifacts they manifest in
the world become increasingly complex, which necessitates even more complex
worldviews, and so forth. Thus a positive feedback cycle sets in. The elements
of human culture-the artifacts, the stories, the languages in which they are
told-reflect the states of the worldviews that generated them, specifically the
associative structure amongst concepts (and the words by which they are ac-
cessed), which in turn reflects their underlying motives and desires.
This analysis suggests that animals are not prohibited from evolving com-
plex cognition a priori, but that without the physical capacity to generate and
manipulate complex artifacts and vocalizations there is insufficient evolutionary
pressure to tinker with φ, the association threshold, until it achieves the requi-
site delicate balance to sustain a stream of thought, or to establish and refine the
necessary feedback mechanisms to dynamically tune it to match to the degree
of associativity or 'conceptual fluidity' required at any given instant. It may be
that humans are the only species for which the benefits of this tinkering process
34
have outweighed the risks. This would make sense because with the capacity
for complex speech and hand movement there are clearly more ways to manifest
complex thoughts, i.e., more ways in which they could yield outcomes in the
world.
It was noted that it is not the presence of but the capacity for an integrated
worldview that the human species has come to possess. Following the pioneering
efforts of Piaget, Vygotsky and more recently others, it has become clear that a
worldview is not present from birth but develops naturally through experience
in the world. The infant mind is predisposed to selectively attend to biologically
salient features, and respond accordingly. If it is hungry and sees its mother's
breast, it suckles; if it feels something extremely hot or cold it pulls away, and so
forth. In addition to innate predispositions to respond categorically to certain
stimuli, it is widely thought that infants possess higher cognitive competencies
(Gelman, 1993; Keil, 1995). These competencies may be due to core knowl-
edge (Spelke, 2000), intuitive theories (Carey, 1985), or simply predispositions
to direct attention to salient (particularly social) elements of a situation (Leslie,
2000). An infant is also capable of storing episodes as memories. Although
episodes from infancy are rarely accessible later in life, they do get etched into
memory, as evidenced by the capacity for reminding events, which is present
by two month of age (Davis & Rovee-Collier, 1983; Rovee-Collier et al., 1999;
Matzel et al., 1992) and possibly earlier (Rovee-Collier, pers. comm). Thus, an
infant is born predisposed toward conceptual integration, but the process must
begin anew in each young mind. The infant may be born with innate concepts,
but its memory is not densely packed enough (i.e., distributed representations
do not overlap enough) to prompt recursive redescription or reminding events.
Even if items are encoded in detail, that is, even if n, the mean number of
properties per encoded item, is large, there are too few of them for reminding
events to occur with high frequency. Returning to Figure 2, there are few items
within a given Hamming distance of any item. Moreover, it lacks the conceptual
structure that facilitates efforts to understand and make sense of how episodes
and their contents are related to one another.
Although the issue is controversial, it is widely accepted that between six
and eight years of age, a child moves from implicit, domain-specific represen-
tations to explicit, more broadly applicable representations (Karmiloff-Smith,
1990, 1992). Aided by social exchange, and mediated by artifacts, a framework
for how things are and how things work falls into place in a child's mind, and it
bears some likeness (and also some dis-similarities) to that of its predecessors,
such as the worldviews of parents and other influential individuals. Some ex-
periences are either so consistent, or so inconsistent with the child's worldview
that they have little impact on it. Others mesh readily with existing ideas, or
ring true intuitively, and percolate deep into the worldview, renewing the child's
understanding of a myriad other notions or events. The child is thereby encul-
tured, and becomes a unique cog in the culture-evolving machinery. Human life
offers a continuous stream of situations that disrupt the state of conceptual in-
tegration. For example, problems arise that cannot be consistently explained in
terms of other elements of the worldview as they are currently understood. The
35
individual may reconceptualize the problem or situation from the perspective of
a context generated by the worldview. The process is recursive in that the new
cognitive state is a function of both the previous cognitive state and the context.
Each internally generated context may induce a change in the conception of the
problem or situation, and each change in conception of the problem may modify
he worldview, until it eventually recoups the state of conceptual integration.
The idea of a conceptually integrated worldview sheds light on the thorny
issue of the role of evolution in cognition. Hampton (2004) argues that if evo-
lutionary psychology as a form of strong adaptationism insists that novel be-
haviors are the product of directly selected adaptations, it follows that there
can be no evolutionary account of many modern activities such as driving and
reading. However, one of the four approaches subsumed under by evolutionary
psychology, as laid out in The Adapted Mind (Barkow et al. 1993), is the study
of culture as an evolutionary process in its own right. Even if modern activi-
ties defy explanation in terms of biological evolution they may be explicable in
terms of cultural evolution. As Deacon (1997) points out, language evolution is
probably thousands of times more rapid than brain evolution. Bouissac (1998)
concludes from this that "such a parasitic theory of language evolution is rooted
in Dawkins' meme hypothesis". However, the notion of conceptual integration
suggests an alternative: that it is not discrete memes (transmittable ideas or
artifacts) that evolve through culture, but conceptually integrated networks of
them-worldviews. The argument for this is laid out in detail elsewhere (Gab-
ora 2004); here it is summarized insofar as is necessary and relevant.
A basic tenet of Dawkins' proposal is that the meme is replicator-an en-
tity that makes copies of itself. Clearly ideas and artifacts are not replicators
of the same sort as modern day organisms, which use a DNA- or RNA- based
self-assembly code. A telltale sign of self-assembly coded replication is restricted
inheritance of acquired characteristics. The effects of contextual interactions be-
tween the organism and its environment are wiped out in the next generation,
and do not affect the evolution of lineages. Thus for example, if one cuts off the
tail of a mouse, its offspring have tails of normal length. As many have noted,
however, acquired characteristics may be inherited in cultural transmission. If
you hear a joke and then put your own slant on it in the retelling of it, those
who pass it on subsequently will likely pass on your changed version.) An idea
may retain structure as it passes from one individual to another (like a radio
signal intercepted by a new radio), but does not replicate it.
Cultural artifacts are not the only structures to have evolved without a self-
assembly code. Our application of closure to the origin and evolution of an
integrated worldview was inspired by current thinking on the problem of how
life began (Gabora, 2006; Kaufman, 1993; Morowitz, 1992; Vetsigian, Woese,
& Goldenfeld, 2006; W?echtersh?euser, 1992; Weber, 1998, 2000; Weber & De-
pew, 1996; Williams & Frausto da Silva, 1999, 2002, 2003; Woese, 2002). For
example, Kaufman (1993) uses the concept of autocatalysis to describe how the
earliest self-replicating structures could have emerged. The autocatalytic sets
of polymers widely believed to be the earliest form of life generated self-similar
structure, but since there was no genetic code yet to copy from, there was no ex-
36
plicit copying going on. The presence of a given catalytic polymer, say polymer
X, simply sped up the rate at which certain reactions took place, while another
catalytic polymer, say Y, influenced the reaction that generated X. Eventually,
for each polymer in the set, there existed a reaction that catalyzed it. Thus the
set as a whole was autocatalytic, able to replicate itself.
5 These earliest life forms have been shown to have evolved through a non-
Darwinian process involving not natural selection operating at the population
level but communal exchange of innovations operating at the individual level.
Kauffman (1993) argues that it is extremely unlikely that the earliest life
forms themselves replicated using a self-assembly code, though such a code could
have arisen by way of a simpler, uncoded self-replicating structure. His proposal
is that the first living organism was a set of autocatalytic polymers. Since there
were no self-assembly instructions to copy from, there was no explicit copying
going on. The presence of a given catalytic polymer, say X, simply speeded up
the rate at which certain reactions took place, while another polymer, say Y,
influenced the reaction that generated X. Eventually, for each polymer, there
existed another that catalyzed its formation. Such autocatalytic sets have been
referred to as primitive replicators because they generate self-similar structure,
but in a self-organized manner, through bottom-up interactions rather than a
top-down self-assembly code (such as the genetic code), thus they replicate–
or more precisely, regenerate themselves–with low fidelity (Gabora 2004, 2006,
2008). They are self-mending in the sense that if the web of catalytic reactions
breaks down (if, for example, one of the polymers gets used up) one or more
others is eventually found to take its place, such that the network of reactions
becomes again able to regenerate itself.
It may be that the emergence of this kind of complex, adaptive self-modifying,
self-mending, self-regenerating (i.e., autopoietic) structure is the critical step in
the origin of any kind of evolutionary process, be it biological, cultural, or some
other sort that we may not have identified. The evolution of culture involves
not just creativity, nor just imitation, but a proclivity to put our own spin on
the inventions of others, to use them for our own purposes and adapt them to
our own needs and desires, such that the process becomes cumulative, adap-
tive, and open-ended. The present paper describes steps toward the kind of
cognitive structure that is capable of supporting this process. Like Kauffman's
(1993) autocatalytic sets of polymers, an integrated worldview is autopoietic.
Just as polymers catalyze reactions that generate other polymers, the retrieval
of an item from memory can in turn trigger other items, cross-linking mem-
5Some authors (e.g. Thompson, 2007) claim that life requires a semi-permeable boundary
to allow for spatial demarcation and containment. We believe this is unnecessary because in
an autocatalytic network, if there is a molecule that catalyzes a particular molecule X, then
molecule X can effectively enter and become part of the network.
If there is no molecule
that catalyzes molecule X, then molecule X is effectively excluded. Possession of a membrane
boundary thus strikes us as a redundant, arbitrary requirement, true of life as we know it
but not life as it could be; one can imagine entities that are alive but nonetheless interwoven
without clear-cut physical boundaries separating them. Nevertheless it is indeed the case that
semipermeable membranes play an exceedingly important role in life and may turn out to be
a requirement.
37
ories, ideas, and concepts into an integrated conceptual structure. Moreover,
this conceptual structure regenerates itself; it constitutes a primitive replicator.
Its elements (ideas, stories, and so forth) evoke one another through deduction,
association, and reminding events, frequently resulting in their expression in
the form of cultural artifacts, or get communicated and incorporated into the
worldviews of other individuals. The result is that contextual interactions can
affect the 'cultural lineage' downstream and thus play an important role in their
evolution. Thus a worldview gets regenerated in a piecemeal fashion through
social learning, both directly and mediated by artifacts. Ideas and artifacts are
not full-fledged replicators themselves, but manifestations of a worldview, which
is a primitive replicator. They participate in the evolution of culture by reveal-
ing certain aspects of the worldview that generated them, thereby affecting the
worldviews of those exposed to them.
In Kauffman's (1993) computer simulations of the origin of life through au-
tocatalytic closure, each polymer was composed of up to a maximum of M
monomers, and assigned a low a priori random probability P of catalyzing each
reaction. The lower the value of P , the greater M had to be, and vice versa
in order for autocatalytic closure to occur. Computer simulation of conceptual
integration might be expected to reveal a similar trade-off between M , which in
the cognitive scenario refers to the maximum number of dimensions along which
episodes are encoded, and φ, the probability for items in memory to evoke one
another. We might also expect to see that, as with biological life, worldviews
that replicate themselves more efficiently will proliferate at the expense of oth-
ers that are less efficient. Indeed, we are compelled to engage in behavior that
helps others absorb the knowledge, attitudes, and ways of doing things that
constitute our worldview, and those that were not so inclined in the past may
well have been selected against at this cultural level.
8 Summary and Discussion
Our capacity to adapt ideas to new situations, see one thing in terms of another,
blend concepts together in an endless variety of ways to interpret and express
real or imagined situations, are all indicative of the integrated nature of a hu-
man worldview. This paper has presented a speculative attempt to formalize the
process by which conceptual integration comes about. The paper does not tell
a finished story but merely lays some groundwork and points the way. Several
elements will require further development, such as the use of the Schrodinger
equation to model the dynamical unfolding of the conception of combinations
of concepts.
Let us retrace the major steps taken. The integrated quality of a worldview-
the capacity for interpenetration of one thought or idea into another-presents
a chicken and egg paradox. Until memories are woven into an integrated world-
view, how can they generate the reminding or evoking events that constitute a
stream of thought? Conversely, until a mind can generate streams of thought,
how does it integrate memories into a worldview? How could something com-
38
posed of complex, mutually dependent parts come to be? Moreover given the
chameleon-like behavior of concepts, and what kind of mathematical description
can we give to them? In this paper it is proposed that a worldview emerges
through conceptual integration yielding a structure whose dynamics requires
the quantum formalism for its description.
Let us retrace the steps in how closure and SCOP are used to model the
transition to an integrated worldview. The associative structure of the episodic
minds of Homo habilis, our earliest ancestors was coarse-grained; items were
not encoded in detail. Thus we model the Homo habilis mind as having lit-
tle interaction amongst concepts, little opportunity for reminding events and
associations, no pressing need for a quantum formalism, and no conceptually
integrated worldview.
The memory of the mimetic mind of Homo erectus is more fine-grained; items
are encoded in greater detail. Thus there is opportunity for reminding events
and associations, and interaction amongst concepts, and a need for the quan-
tum formalism to model how concepts emerge from a ground state to an actual
state in a manner that depends on the constellation of other evoked concepts.
There is concept formation through abstraction, modeled as the recognition that
episodes or concepts are instances of a more general concept, and the accumula-
tion of sets of states, contexts, properties, weights and transition probabilities.
There is formation of conceptual structure modeled as the formation of lattices
of properties and contexts through the realization of natural relations. How-
ever, because there is no ability to modulate the degree of interaction amongst
concepts depending on what is called for by the situation, the conceptual web
is crude and fragmented.
The modern human mind has the ability to shift between analytic thought,
conducive primarily to realizing relationships amongst states of a known con-
cept, and associative thought, conducive primarily to forging new concepts
through the formation of conjunctions, which are entangled states that result
through application of the tensor product of the Hilbert spaces of the two con-
stituent concepts. It is proposed that the penultimate step toward achieving
an integrated worldview was to acquire the capacity to spontaneously focus
attention (conducive to analytic thought) or defocus attention (conducive to
associative thought) depending on the circumstance. This is modeled as onset
of the modulation of µ, the transition probabilities using a variable we called
φ. Once the capacity has evolved to alter φ according to the situation, analytic
thought and associative thought can work in concert to organize and reorganize
conceptual structure. Analytic thought enables the identification of causal re-
lationships, while associative thought facilitates recognition of items in memory
that are correlated, i.e. that share properties, which in turn provides more in-
gredients for analytic thought. Many species can learn, imitate, remember, and
perhaps even form concepts. So this capacity to focus or defocus may be the
key step in the attainment of complex language, religion, science, art, and other
aspects of culture that make us unique. Defocused thought forges connections
amongst items that share a deep structure but are superficially unrelated. Since
these relations are often difficult to find, cultural learning also plays a key role
39
here, filling in the missing links that the child does not find on its own (perhaps
the vast majority). Because most of the fruits of such creative achievements are
culturally transmitted, it is not necessary that we each individually generate
an interconnected worldview from scratch. A hard-to-come-by concept or idea
need only be realized in the mind of one individual; the other members of a
society get it 'for free' without any particularly focused or defocused thought.
As episodes accumulate in memory, and concepts acquire more states, the set
of concepts grows and becomes more connected. When the same set of concepts
arise repeatedly, concepts themselves form more abstract concepts, giving rise
to semantic hierarchies. The probability increases that any experience triggers
an episode encoded in memory which in turn triggers another, and so forth,
generating a stream of thought. Streams of thought facilitate the formation
of yet more abstract concepts. When the ratio of cognitive states to concepts
reaches approximately 2:1, the probability becomes almost inevitable that con-
cepts 'join' in the sense that there come to exist cognitive states that are states
of more than one concept. At this point, for any episode in the dominant subset
of episodes there exists a possible route, or sequence of associative pathways
(however indirect) to any other there exists a possible associative path (how-
ever indirect) to any other, enabling new experiences to be framed in terms of
previous ones. We became able to encode, interpret, and reinterpret episodes
using constellations of concepts of varying degrees of abstraction, wherein the
meaning of each concept in the constellation shifts depending on the context
provided by other simultaneously evoked concepts. Together they form a con-
ceptual web that from the inside is experienced as an integrated model of the
world, or worldview. It has been suggested that it is the conceptually integrated
worldview that constitutes the replicating unit of cultural evolution. Like a liv-
ing organism, a worldview may naturally be drawn to gaps or inconsistencies
and attempt to heal them (Gabora 1999, 2008). Elaboration of this approach
may provide formal models of such psychological phenomena as repression, frag-
mentation, and integration.
Acknowledgments
This research is supported by grants from the Social Sciences and Humanities
Research Council of Canada and the Research Council of the Free University
of Brussels, Belgium. Part of the paper was written during a year spent by the
first author at the PACE Center, Tufts University.
Appendix 1
A closure relation is extensive, monotone and idempotent. This means that for
X, Y ⊂ X we have
X ⊂ cl(X)
extensive
(17)
40
X ⊂ Y ⇒ cl(X) ⊂ cl(Y ) monotone
(18)
idempotent
cl(cl(X)) = cl(X)
(19)
Proof: Consider an episode x ∈ X ⊂ X . Since x ↔ x this episode is connected
to an episode x ∈ X , hence, x ∈ cl(X). This proves (17).
Let us prove (18). Suppose there exist two subsets of episodes X, Y ⊂ X
such that X ⊂ Y , and an episode x ∈ cl(X). Since x ∈ cl(X) this means that
there exists an episode y ∈ X such that x ↔ y. From X ⊂ Y it follows that
y ∈ Y . Hence, there exists an episode y ∈ Y such that x ↔ y, which proves
that x ∈ cl(Y ). Hence, this shows that cl(X) ⊂ cl(Y ). This proves (18).
Let us prove (19). From (17) we know that X ⊂ cl(X), and applying (18)
we get cl(X) ⊂ cl(cl(X)). This means that to prove (19) we only need to show
that cl(cl(X)) ⊂ cl(X). Consider x ∈ cl(cl(X)). This means that there exists
an episode y ∈ cl(X) such that x ↔ y. Since y ∈ cl(X), there exists an episode
z ∈ X such that y ↔ z. Applying the transitivity of the 'connection relation'
we get that x ↔ z, which means that x ∈ cl(X). Hence, we have shown that
cl(cl(X)) ⊂ cl(X), and we have proven (19).
.
Appendix 2
Let us prove that the closure relation conserves full connectedness. We start by
stating that a subset of episodes X ⊂ X is fully connected if
∀ x, y ∈ X we have x ↔ y
(20)
Proposition: cl({x}) is a fully connected set of episodes.
Proof: Consider y, z ∈ cl({x}), then we have y ↔ x and z ↔ x, and hence from
the transitivity property of the 'connection relation' follows that y ↔ z.
Proposition: If X is a fully connected set of episodes, then also cl(X) is a
fully connected set of episodes.
Proof: Consider x, y ∈ cl(X), then there exists z, t ∈ X such that x ↔ z and
y ↔ t. Since X is a fully connected set, we have z ↔ t. Hence, from the
transitivity of the 'connection relation' it follows that x ↔ t, and therefore
x ↔ y. This proves that cl(X) is fully connected.
Hence, we have proven that the closure relation conserves full connectedness.
41
Appendix 3
Proposition: If X is a fully connected set of episodes, then cl(X) is the biggest
fully connected subset containing X.
Proof: Consider an arbitrary fully connected subset Y such that X ⊂ Y . Let
us prove that Y ⊂ cl(X). Consider x ∈ Y and an arbitrary y ∈ X. Since Y is
fully connected we have that x ↔ y. This means that x ∈ cl(X). Hence, we
have proven that Y ⊂ cl(X).
Appendix 4
Proposition: Consider x, y ∈ X two episodes. For cl({x}) and cl({y}) we have
cl({x}) = cl({y})
cl({x}) ∩ cl({y}) = ∅
or
(21)
Proof: Suppose that cl({x}) ∩ cl({y}) (cid:54)= ∅, which means that there exists an
episode z ∈ cl({x}) and z ∈ cl({y}). Hence, we have z ↔ x and z ↔ y. From
this it follows that x ↔ y. But then x ∈ cl({y}), and hence, {x} ⊂ cl({y}).
Applying (18) we get cl({x}) ⊂ cl({y}). Analogously it can be shown that
cl({y}) ⊂ cl({x}), and as a consequence cl({x}) = cl({y}). This proves the
proposition, namely that for the closure of two single episodes, the closure sub-
sets are equal, or their intersection is empty.
Appendix 5
We now prove that X is equal to the disjoint union of fully connected subsets,
such that each of the subsets is the closure of a single episode.
Proposition: We have
(cid:91)
i∈I
X =
Xi Xi fully connected Xj ∩ Xk = ∅ for j (cid:54)= k
(22)
such that for each Xi there exists a single episode xi ∈ X , such that Xi =
cl({xi}).
Proof: From set theory it follows that X = ∪x∈X{x}, and since for each x ∈ X it
is the case that {x} ⊂ cl({x}) then also X = ∪x∈X cl({x}). Consider the set the
set {cl({x}) x ∈ X}. From the above proposition it follows that if cl({y}) and
cl({z}) are two elements of this set, cl({y}) = cl({z}) or cl({y}) ∩ cl({z}) = ∅.
This proves the proposition.
42
References
Aerts, D. (1982). Description of many physical entities Without the paradoxes
encountered in quantum mechanics. Foundations of Physics, 12, 1131-
1170.
Aerts, D. (1983). Classical theories and non classical theories as a special case
of a more general theory, Journal of Mathematical Physics, 24, 2441-2453.
Aerts, D. (2007). General quantum modeling of combining concepts: A quan-
tum field model in Fock space. Archive address and link: http://arxiv.org/abs/0705.1740.
Aerts, D. (2009). Quantum structure in cognition. Journal of Mathematical
Psychology (submitted).
Aerts, D., Broekaert, J. and Smets, S. (1999a). The liar paradox in a
quantum mechanical perspective. Foundations of Science, 4, pp. 115-132.
Aerts, D., Broekaert, J., Smets, S. (1999b). A quantum structure descrip-
tion of the liar paradox. International Journal of Theoretical Physics, 38,
pp. 3231-3239.
Aerts, D. & Gabora, L. (2005a). A theory of concepts and their combinations I:
The structure of the sets of contexts and properties. Kybernetes, 34 (1&2),
167-191.
Aerts, D. & Gabora, L. (2005b). A theory of concepts and their combinations
II: A Hilbert space representation. Kybernetes, 34 (1&2), 192-221.
Aiello, L. & Dunbar, R. (1993). Neocortex size, group size, and the evolution
of language. Current Anthropology, 34, 184-193.
Ashby, F. G., & Ell, S. W. (2002). Single versus multiple systems of learning
and memory. In J. Wixted & H. Pashler (Eds.) Stevens? handbook of ex-
perimental psychology: Volume 4 Methodology in experimental psychology.
New York: Wiley.
Barkow, J., Cosmides, L., & Tooby, J. (1992). The adapted mind. New York:
Oxford University Press.
Bar-Yosef, O. (1994). The contribution of southwest Asia to the study of the
origin of modern humans. In M. Nitecki & D. Nitecki (Eds.) Origins of
anatomically modern humans, Plenum Press. Bouissac, P. (1998). Con-
verging parallels: Semiotics and psychology in evolutionary perspective.
Theory and Psychology, 8(6), 731-753.
Beltrametti, E. & Cassinelli, G. (1981). The logic of quantum mechanics.
Boston: Addison-Wesley.
Bickerton, D. (1990). Language and species. Chicago: University of Chicago
Press.
43
Barsalou, L.W. (1982). Context-independent and context-dependent informa-
tion in concepts. Memory & Cognition, 10, 82-93.
Bruza, P. & Cole, R. (2005). Quantum logic of semantic space: An exploratory
investigation of context effects in practical reasoning. In S. Artemov, H.
Barringer, A. S. d'Avila Garcez, L. C. Lamb and J. Woods (Eds.) We Will
Show Them: Essays in Honour of Dov Gabbay. College Publications, 1,
pp. 339?361. Bruza, P. Kitto, K. Nelson, D. & McEvoy, C. (in press). Is
there something quantum-like about the human mental lexicon? Journal
of Mathematical Psychology.
Busemeyer, J. R., Wang, Z., & Townsend, J. T. (2006). Quantum dynamics
of human decision making. Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 50, 220-
242.
Busemeyer, J. R. , Matthew, M., & Wang, Z. (2006) A Quantum Information
Processing Theory Explanation of Disjunction Effects. Proceedings of the
Cognitive Science Society.
Busemeyer, J. R. & Wang, Z. (2007). Quantum Information Processing Ex-
planation for Interactions between Inferences and Decisions. Proceedings
of the AAAI Spring Symposium on Quantum Interaction (pp. 91-97).
Stanford University, March 26-28.
Carey, S. (1985). Conceptual change in childhood. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Churchland, P. S. & Sejnowski, T. (1992). The computational brain. Cam-
bridge MA: MIT Press.
Corballis, M. C. (1991). The lopsided ape: Evolution of the generative mind.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Davis, J., & Rovee-Collier, C. (1983). Alleviated forgetting of a learned con-
tingency in 8-week-old infants. Developmental Psychology, 19, 353-365.
Dawkins, R. (1976). The selfish gene. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Deacon, T. (1997). The symbolic species. New York: Norton. [p. 751]
Dennett, D. (1978). Brainstorms. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Dikranjan, D., Giuli, E. & Tozzi, A. (1988). Topological categories and closure
operators. Questiones Mathematics, 11 (3), 323-337.
Donald, M. (1991) Origins of the modern mind. Cambridge MA: Harvard
University Press.
Edelman, G. E. (1993). Bright Air, Brilliant Fire: On the Matter of Mind.
New York: Basic Books.
44
Erdos, P. & Renyi, A. (1959). On the random graphs. 1(6), Institute of Math-
ematics, University of Debrecenians, Debrecar, Hungary.
Erdos, P. & Renyi, A. (1960). On the evolution of random graphs. Institute of
Mathematics, Hungarian Academy of Sciences Publication number 5.
Fauconnier, G. & Turner, M. (2002). The way we think: Conceptual blending
and the mind's hidden complexities. New York: Basic Books.
Gabora, L. (1998). A tentative scenario for the origin of culture. Psycoloquy,
9 (67).
Gabora, L. (1999). Weaving, bending, patching, mending the fabric of reality:
A cognitive science perspective on worldview inconsistency. Foundations
of Science, 3 (2), 395-428.
Gabora, L. (2000). Conceptual closure: Weaving memories into an intercon-
nected worldview. In G. Van de Vijver and J. Chandler (Eds.) Closure:
Emergent Organizations and their Dynamics. Annals of the New York
Academy of Sciences 901, 42-53.
Gabora, L. (2002a). The beer can theory of creativity. In P. Bentley & D.
Corne (Eds.) Creative Evolutionary Systems, (pp. 147-161). San Fran-
cisco CA: Morgan Kauffman.
Gabora, L. (2002b). Cognitive mechanisms underlying the creative process. In
T. Hewett and T. Kavanagh (Eds.) Proceedings of the Fourth International
Conference on Creativity and Cognition, (pp. 126-133). October 13-16,
Loughborough University, UK.
Gabora, L. (2003). Contextual focus: A cognitive explanation for the cultural
transition of the Middle/Upper Paleolithic. In (R. Alterman & D. Hirsch,
Eds.) Proceedings of the 25th Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science
Society, Boston MA, 31 July-2 August. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Gabora, L. (2004). Ideas are not replicators but interrelated networks of them
are. Biology and Philosophy, 19 (1), 127-143.
Gabora, L. (2005). Creative thought as a non-Darwinian evolutionary process.
Journal of Creative Behavior, 39 (4), 65-87.
Gabora, L. (2006). Self-other organization: Why early life did not evolve
through natural selection. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 241 (3), 443-
450.
Gabora, L. (2008). The cultural evolution of socially situated cognition. Cog-
nitive Systems Research, 9 (1-2), 104-113.
Gabora, L. & Aerts, D. (2002). Contextualizing concepts using a mathematical
generalization of the quantum formalism. Journal of Experimental and
Theoretical Artificial Intelligence, 14 (4), 327-358.
45
Gabora, L. & Aerts, D. (2005). Evolution as context-driven actualization of
potential: Toward an interdisciplinary theory of change of state. Interdis-
ciplinary Science Reviews, 30 (1), 69-88.
Gabora, L., Rosch, E., & Aerts, D. (2008). Toward an ecological theory of
concepts. Ecological Psychology, 20 (1), 84-116.
Gardenfors, P. (2000). Conceptual Spaces: The geometry of thought. Cam-
bridge, MA: MIT press.
Gelman, R. (1993). A rational-constructivist account of early learning about
numbers and objects. In D. Medin (Ed.) Learning and motivation, (pp.
61-96). New York: Academic Press.
Hampton, S. J. (2004). Domina mismatches, scruffy engineering, exaptations
and spandrels. Theory and Psychology 14 (2), 147-166.
Hancock, P. J. B., Smith, L. S. & Phillips, W. A. (1991). A biologically
supported error-correcting learning rule. Neural Computation, 3(2), 201-
212.
Holden, S.B. & Niranjan, M. (1997). Average-case learning curves for radial
basis function networks. Neural Computation, 9(2), 441-460.
Johnson-Laird, P. N. (1983). Mental models. Cambridge MA: Harvard Uni-
versity Press.
Kanerva, P. (1988). Sparse, distributed memory. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Karmiloff-Smith, A. (1990). Constraints on representational change: Evidence
from children?s drawing. Cognition, 34, 57-83.
Karmiloff-Smith, A. (1992). Beyond modularity: A developmental perspective
on cognitive science. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Kauffman, S. (1993). Origins of order. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Keil, F. C. (1995). The growth of causal understandings of natural kinds.
In S. Sperber, D. Premack, & A. Premack (Eds.) Causal cognition: A
multidisciplinary debate, (pp. 234-262). Cambridge: Oxford University
Press.
Klein, R. (1989). Biological and behavioral perspectives on modern human
origins in South Africa. In P. Mellars & C. Stringe (Eds.) The human
revolution. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Langton, C. G. (1992) Life at the edge of chaos. In (C. G. Langton, C. Taylor,
J. D. Farmer & S. Rasmussen, eds.) Artificial life II. Boston: Addison-
Wesley.
46
Leakey, R. (1984). The origins of humankind. New York: Science Masters
Basic Books.
Leslie, A. (2000). Theory of mind as a mechanism of selective attention. Rut-
gers University Tech Report 061.
Lieberman, P. (1991). Uniquely human: The evolution of speech, thought, and
selfless behavior. Boston: Harvard University Press.
Lu, Y.W., Sundararajan, N. & Saratchandran, P. (1997). A sequential learning
scheme for function approximation using minimal radial basis function
neural networks. Neural Computation, 9(2), 461-478.
Maturana, H. & Varela, F. (1973/1980). Autopoeisis and cognition: The real-
ization of the living. Boston: Reidel.
Matzel, L., Collin, C., & Alkon, D. (1992). Biophysical and behavioral corre-
lates of memory storage: Degradation and reactivation. Behavioral Neu-
roscience, 106, 954-963.
McBrearty, S. & Brooks, A. S. (2000). The revolution that wasn?t: A new
interpretation of the origin of modern human behavior. Journal of Human
Evolution 39 (5), 453-563.
Mednick, S. (1962). The associative basis of the creative process. Psychological
Review, 69, 220?232.
Mellars, P. (1973). The character of the middle-upper transition in south-west
France. In C. Renfrew (Ed.) The explanation of culture change. London:
Duckworth.
Mellars, P. (1989a). Technological changes in the Middle-Upper Paleolithic
transition: Economic, social, and cognitive perspectives. In P. Mellars &
C. Stringer (Eds.) The human revolution. Edinburgh: Edinburgh Univer-
sity Press.
Mellars, P. (1989b). Major issues in the emergence of modern humans. Current
Anthropology, 30, 349-385.
Mikkulainen (1997). Neural network perspectives on cognition and adaptive
robotics. In (A Brown, Ed.) Natural language processing with subsymbolic
neural networks. Bristol UK, Philadelphia: Institute of Physics Press.
Mithen, S. (1996). The prehistory of the mind: A search for the origins of art,
science, and religion. London: Thames & Hudson.
Mithen, S. (1998). A creative explosion? Theory of mind, language, and the
disembodied mind of the Upper Paleolithic. In S. Mithen (Ed.) Creativity
in human evolution and prehistory. New York: Routledge.
47
Morowitz, H. J. (2002). The Emergence of Everything: How the World Became
Complex. Oxford University Press, New York.
Neisser, U. (1963). The multiplicity of thought. British Journal of Psychology,
54, 1-14.
Nelson, D. L. & McEvoy, C. L. (2007). Activation at a distance is not spooky
anymore: The conjunction of entangled associative structures and con-
text. Proceedings of the AAAI Spring Symposium on Quantum Interac-
tion, Stanford University, March 26-28.
Nelson, D. L., McEvoy, C. L. & Pointer, L. (2003). Spreading activation or
spooky action at a distance. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learn-
ing, Memory, and Cognition 29, 42?51.
Osherson , D. N. & Smith, E. E. (1981). On the adequacy of prototype theory
as a theory of concepts. Cognition, 9, 35-58.
Piaget 1926). The language and thought of the child. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence
Erlbaum.
Piron, C. (1976). Foundations of Quantum Physics. Reading, MA: W.A.
Benjamin.
Rosch (1978). Principles of categorization. In Rosch, E. & Lloyd, B. (Eds.)
Cognition and categorization. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Rovee-Collier, C., Hartshorn, K., & DiRubbo, M. (1999). Long-term mainte-
nance of infant memory. Developmental Psychobiology, 35, 91-102.
Ruff, C., Trinkaus, E. & Holliday, T. (1997). Body mass and encephalization
in Pleistocene Homo. Nature, 387, 173-176.
Sloman, S. (1996). The empirical case for two systems of Reasoning. Psycho-
logical Bulletin, 9 (1), 3-22.
Smolensky, P. (1988). On the proper treatment of connectionism. Behavioral
and Brain Sciences, 11, 1?43.
Soffer, O. (1994). Ancestral lifeways in Eurasia-The Middle and Upper Pale-
olithic records. In M. Nitecki & D. Nitecki, (Eds.) Origins of anatomically
modern humans. New York: Plenum Press.
Spelke, E. S. (2000). Core knowledge. American Psychologist, 55 (11), 1233-
1243.
Spoor, F. Leakey, M. G., Gathogo, P. N., Brown, F. H., Anton, S. C., Mc-
Dougall, I., Kiarie, C., Manthi, F. K. and Leakey, L. N. (2007). Impli-
cations of new early homo fossils from ileret, east of lake turkana, kenya.
Nature, 448, 688-691.
48
Stringer, C. & Gamble, C. (1993). In search of the Neanderthals. London:
Thames & Hudson.
Thompson, E.(2007). Mind in Life - Biology, Phenomenology and the Sciences
of Mind. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
Vetsigian, K., Woese, C., & Goldenfeld, N. (2006). Collective evolution and
the genetic code. Proceedings of the New York Academy of Science USA,
103, 10696?10701.
W?chtersh?user, G. (1992). Groundwork for an evolutionary biochemistry: the
iron-sulfur world. Prog. Biophys. Molec. Biol. 58, 85-201.
Weber, B. H. (1998). Emergence of life and biological selection from the per-
spective of complex systems dynamics. In: G. van de Vijver, S. N. Salthe
& M. Delpos (Eds.) Evolutionary Systems: Biological and Epistemological
Perspectives on Selection and Self-Organization. Kluwer, Dordrecht.
Weber, B. H. (2000). Closure in the emergence and evolution of life: Multiple
discourses or one? In: J. L. R. Chandler & G. Van de Vijver (Eds.)
Closure: Emergent Organizations and their Dynamics, Annals of the New
York Academy of Sciences 901, pp. 132-138.
Weber, B.H., & Depew, J.D. (1996). Natural selection and self-organization.
Biology and Philosophy, 11 (1), 33-65.
White, R. (1982). Rethinking the Middle/Upper Paleolithic transition. Cur-
rent Anthropology, 23, 169-189.
White, R. (1993). Technological and social dimensions of 'Aurignacian-age'
body ornaments across Europe. In H. Knecht, A. Pike-Tay, & R. White
(Eds.) Before Lascaux: The complex record of the Early Upper Paleolithc.
New York: CRC Press.
Widdows, D. S. (2003). Orthogonal negation in vector spaces for modeling
word meanings and document retrieval. In Proceedings of the 41st Annual
Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (p. 136-143),
Sapporo Japan, July 7-12.
Widdows, D. & Peters, S. (2003). Word vectors and quantum logic: experi-
ments with negation and disjunction. In Eighth Meeting of the Association
for the Mathematics of Language (p. 141-154), Bloomington IN: Associa-
tion for Computational Linguistics.
Williams, R. J. P. & Frausto da Silva, J. J. R. (1999). Bringing Chemistry to
Life: From Matter to Man. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Williams, R. J. P. & Frausto da Silva, J. J. R. (2002). The systems approach
to evolution. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Comm. 297, 689-699.
49
Williams, R. J. P. &Frausto da Silva, J. J. R. (2003). Evolution was chemically
constrained. J. Theor. Biol. 220, 323-343.
Willshaw, D. J. & Dayan, P. (1990). Optimal plasticity from matrix memory:
What goes up must come down. Journal of Neural Computation, 2, 85-93.
Woese, C.R. (2002). On the evolution of cells. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences, 99 (13), 8742-8747.
50
|
1808.01893 | 1 | 1808 | 2018-08-01T08:19:31 | Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata with parameter learning | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cs.FL",
"q-bio.QM"
] | In this paper we present a novel approach to automatically infer parameters of spiking neural networks. Neurons are modelled as timed automata waiting for inputs on a number of different channels (synapses), for a given amount of time (the accumulation period). When this period is over, the current potential value is computed considering current and past inputs. If this potential overcomes a given threshold, the automaton emits a broadcast signal over its output channel , otherwise it restarts another accumulation period. After each emission, the automaton remains inactive for a fixed refractory period. Spiking neural networks are formalised as sets of automata, one for each neuron, running in parallel and sharing channels according to the network structure. Such a model is formally validated against some crucial properties defined via proper temporal logic formulae. The model is then exploited to find an assignment for the synaptical weights of neural networks such that they can reproduce a given behaviour. The core of this approach consists in identifying some correcting actions adjusting synaptical weights and back-propagating them until the expected behaviour is displayed. A concrete case study is discussed. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Noname manuscript No.
(will be inserted by the editor)
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed
Automata
with parameter learning
Elisabetta De Maria · Cinzia Di Giusto ·
Laetitia Laversa
8
1
0
2
g
u
A
1
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
3
9
8
1
0
.
8
0
8
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
Received: date / Accepted: date
Abstract In this paper we present a novel approach to automatically infer param-
eters of spiking neural networks. Neurons are modelled as timed automata waiting
for inputs on a number of different channels (synap-ses), for a given amount of
time (the accumulation period). When this period is over, the current potential
value is computed considering current and past inputs. If this potential overcomes
a given threshold, the automaton emits a broadcast signal over its output chan-
nel, otherwise it restarts another accumulation period. After each emission, the
automaton remains inactive for a fixed refractory period. Spiking neural networks
are formalised as sets of automata, one for each neuron, running in parallel and
sharing channels according to the network structure. Such a model is formally
validated against some crucial properties defined via proper temporal logic formu-
lae. The model is then exploited to find an assignment for the synaptical weights
of neural networks such that they can reproduce a given behaviour. The core of
this approach consists in identifying some correcting actions adjusting synaptical
weights and back-propagating them until the expected behaviour is displayed. A
concrete case study is discussed.
Keywords Neural Networks · Parameter Learning · Timed Automata, Temporal
Logic · Model Checking.
1 Introduction
The brain behaviour is the object of thorough studies: researchers are interested
not only in the inner functioning of neurons (which are its elementary compo-
nents), their interactions and the way these aspects participate to the ability to
move, learn or remember, typical of living beings; but also in reproducing such
capabilities (emulating nature), e.g., within robot controllers, speech/text/face
recognition applications, etc. In order to achieve a detailed understanding of the
brain functioning, both neurons behaviour and their interactions must be stud-
ied. Several models of the neuron behaviour have been proposed: some of them
Universit´e Cote d'Azur, CNRS, I3S, France
2
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
make neurons behave as binary threshold gates, other ones exploit a sigmoidal
transfer function, while, in many cases, differential equations are employed. Ac-
cording to [29, 26], three different and progressive generations of neural networks
can be recognised: (i) first generation models handle discrete inputs and outputs
and their computational units are threshold-based transfer functions; they include
McCulloch and Pitt's threshold gate model [28], the perceptron model[15], Hop-
field networks [21], and Boltzmann machines [1]; (ii) second generation models
exploit real valued activation functions, e.g., the sigmoid function, accepting and
producing real values: a well known example is the multi-layer perceptron [8, 32];
(iii) third generation networks are known as spiking neural networks. They extend
second generation models treating time-dependent and real valued signals often
composed by spike trains. Neurons may fire output spikes according to thresh-
old-based rules which take into account input spike magnitudes and occurrence
times [29].
The core of our analysis are spiking neural networks [16]. Because of the intro-
duction of timing aspects they are considered closer to the actual brain functioning
than other generations models. Spiking neurons emit spikes taking into account
input impulses strength and their occurrence instants. Models of this sort are of
great interest, not only because they are closer to natural neural networks be-
haviour, but also because the temporal dimension allows to represent information
according to various coding schemes [30, 29]: e.g., the amount of spikes occurred
within a given time window (rate coding), the reception/absence of spikes over dif-
ferent synapses (binary coding), the relative order of spikes occurrences (rate rank
coding), or the precise time difference between any two successive spikes (timing
coding).
Several spiking neuron models have been proposed in the literature, having
different complexities and capabilities. In [24], Izhikevich classifies spiking neu-
ron models according to some behaviour (i.e., typical responses to an input pat-
tern) that they should exhibit in order to be considered biologically relevant. The
leaky integrate & fire (LI&F) model [25], where past inputs relevance exponen-
tially decays with time, is one of the most studied neuron models because it is
straightforward and easy to use [24, 29]. On the other end of the spectrum, the
Hodgkin-Huxley (H-H) model [20] is one of the most complex being composed
by four differential equations comparing neurons to electrical circuits. In [24], the
H-H model can reproduce all behaviours under consideration, but the simulation
process is really expensive even for just a few neurons being simulated for a small
amount of time. Our aim is to produce a neuron model being meaningful from a
biological point of view but also amenable to formal analysis and verification, that
could be therefore used to detect non-active portions within some network (i.e.,
the subset of neurons not contributing to the network outcome), to test whether a
particular output sequence can be produced or not, to prove that a network may
never be able to emit, to assess if a change to the network structure can alter
its behaviour, or to investigate (new) learning algorithms which take time into
account.
In this paper we focus on the leaky integrate & fire (LI&F) model originally pro-
posed in [25]. It is a computationally efficient approximation of single-compartment
model [24] and is abstracted enough to be able to apply formal verification tech-
niques such as model-checking. Here we work on an extended version of the discre-
tised formulation proposed in [13], which relies on the notion of logical time. Time
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
3
is considered as a sequence of logical discrete instants, and an instant is a point in
time where external input events can be observed, computations can be done, and
outputs can be emitted. The variant we introduce here takes into account some
new time-related aspects, such as a lapse of time in which the neuron is not active,
i.e., it cannot receive and emit. We encode LI&F networks into timed automata:
we show how to define the behaviour of a single neuron and how to build a network
of neurons. Timed automata [2] are finite state automata extended with timed be-
haviours: constraints are allowed to limit the amount of time an automaton can
remain within a particular state, or the time interval during which a particular
transition may be enabled. Timed automata networks are sets of automata that
can synchronise over channel communications.
Our modelling of spiking neural networks consists of timed automata networks
where each neuron is an automaton. Its behaviour consists in accumulating the
weighted sum of inputs, provided by a number of ingoing weighted synapses, for
a given amount of time. Then, if the potential accumulated during the last and
previous accumulation periods overcomes a given threshold, the neuron fires an
output over the outgoing synapse. Synapses are channels shared between the timed
automata representing neurons, while spike emissions are represented by broadcast
synchronisations occurring over such channels. Timed automata are also exploited
to produce or recognise precisely defined spike sequences.
As a first main contribution, we analyse some intrinsic properties of the pro-
posed model, e.g., the maximum threshold value allowing a neuron to emit, or
the lack of inter-spike memory, preventing the behaviour of a neuron from being
influenced by what happened before the last spike. Furthermore, we encode in
temporal logics all the behaviours (or capabilities) a LI&F model should be able
to reproduce according to Izhikevich and we exploit model checking to prove these
behaviours are reproducible in our model. Izhikevich also identifies a set of be-
haviours which are not expected to be reproducible by any LI&F model. We prove
these limits to hold for our model, too, and we provide, for each non-reproducible
behaviour, an extension of the model allowing to reproduce it.
As a second main contribution, we exploit our automata-based modelling to
propose a new methodology for parameter inference in spiking neural networks. In
particular, our approach allows to find an assignment for the synaptical weights of
a given neural network such that it can reproduce a given behaviour. We apply the
proposed approach to find suitable parameters in mutual inhibition networks, a
well studied class of networks in which the constituent neurons inhibit each other
neuron's activity [27].
This paper is an extended and revised version of the conference papers [10] and
[11]. In particular, in section 5 we propose a refined version of the Advice Back-
Propagation algorithm. Furthermore, we add a second learning technique that is
based on simulation instead of model checking.
The rest of the paper is organised as follows: in Section 2 we recall definitions
of timed automata networks, temporal logics, and model checking; in Section 3 we
describe our reference model, the LI&F one, and its encoding into timed automata
networks; in Section 4 we study some intrinsic properties of the obtained model
and we validate it against its ability of reproducing or not some behaviours; in
Section 5 we develop the novel parameter learning approach and we introduce a
case study; in Section 6 we give an overview of the related work. Finally, Section
7 summarises our contribution and presents some future research directions.
4
2 Preliminaries
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
In this section we introduce the formal tools we adopt in the rest of the paper,
namely timed automata and temporal logics.
2.1 Timed Automata.
Timed automata [2] are a powerful theoretical formalism for modelling and verify-
ing real time systems. A timed automaton is an annotated directed (and connected)
graph, with an initial node and provided with a finite set of non-negative real vari-
ables called clocks. Nodes (called locations) are annotated with invariants (pred-
icates allowing to enter or stay in a location), arcs with guards, communication
labels, and possibly with some variables upgrades and clock resets. Guards are con-
junctions of elementary predicates of the form x op c, where op ∈ {>,≥, =, <,≤},
x is a clock, and c a (possibly parameterised) positive integer constant. As usual,
the empty conjunction is interpreted as true. The set of all guards and invariant
predicates will be denoted by G.
Definition 1 A timed automaton TA is a tuple (L, l0, X,
Σ, Arcs, Inv ), where
-- L is a set of locations with l0 ∈ L the initial one
-- X is the set of clocks,
-- Σ is a set of communication labels,
-- Arcs ⊆ L × (G ∪ Σ ∪ U ) × L is a set of arcs between locations with a guard
in G, a communication label in Σ ∪ {ε}, and a set of variable upgrades (e.g.,
clock resets);
-- Inv : L → G assigns invariants to locations.
It is possible to define a synchronised product of a set of timed automata
that work and synchronise in parallel. The automata are required to have disjoint
sets of locations, but may share clocks and communication labels which are used
for synchronisation. We restrict communications to be broadcast through labels
b!, b? ∈ Σ, meaning that a set of automata can synchronise if one is emitting; notice
that a process can always emit (e.g., b!) and the receivers (b?) must synchronise if
they can.
Locations can be normal, urgent or committed. Urgent locations force the time
to freeze, committed ones freeze time and the automaton must leave the location
as soon as possible, i.e., they have higher priority.
The synchronous product TA1 (cid:107) . . . (cid:107) TAn of timed automata, where TAj =
j , Xj, Σj, Arcs j, Inv j) and Lj are pairwise disjoint sets of locations for each
(Lj, l0
j ∈ [1, . . . , n], is the timed automaton
TA = (L, l0, X, Σ, Arcs, Inv )
such that:
-- L = L1 × . . . × Ln and l0 = (l0
-- ∀l = (l1, . . . , ln) ∈ L : Inv (l) =(cid:86)
1, . . . , l0
j Inv j(lj),
n), X =(cid:83)n
j=1 Xj, Σ =(cid:83)n
j=1 Σj,
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
5
-- Arcs is the set of arcs (l1, . . . , ln)
then l(cid:48)
j = lj.
g,a,r−→ (l(cid:48)
1, . . . , l(cid:48)
n) such that for all 1 ≤ j ≤ n
Its semantics is the one of the underlying timed automaton TA with the fol-
j/lj, j ∈ S] to
lowing notations. A location is a vector l = (l1, . . . , ln). We write l[l(cid:48)
denote the location l in which the jth element lj is replaced by l(cid:48)
j, for all j in some
set S. A valuation is a function ν from the set of clocks to the non-negative reals.
Let V be the set of all clock valuations, and ν0(x) = 0 for all x ∈ X. We shall
denote by ν (cid:15) F the fact that the valuation ν satisfies (makes true) the formula F .
If r is a clock reset, we shall denote by ν[r] the valuation obtained after applying
the clock reset r ⊆ X to ν; and if d ∈ R>0 is a delay, ν + d is the valuation such
that, for any clock x ∈ X, (ν + d)(x) = ν(x) + d.
The semantics of a synchronous product TA1 (cid:107) . . . (cid:107) TAn is defined as a timed
transition system (S, s0,→), where S = (L1×, . . . × Ln) × V is the set of states,
s0 = (l0, ν0) is the initial state, and →⊆ S × S is the transition relation defined
by:
-- (silent): (l, ν) → (l(cid:48), ν(cid:48)) if there exists li
i, for some i, such that l(cid:48) = l[l(cid:48)
g,ε,r−→ l(cid:48)
i/li],
ν (cid:15) g and ν(cid:48) = ν[r],
-- (broadcast): (¯l, ν) → (¯l(cid:48), ν(cid:48)) if there exists an output arc lj
j ∈ Arcs j
k ∈ Arcs k such
and a (possibly empty) set of input arcs of the form lk
that for all k ∈ K = {k1, . . . , km} ⊆ {l1, . . . , ln}\{lj}, the size of K is maximal,
gk,b?,rk−→ l(cid:48)
gj ,b!,rj−→ l(cid:48)
k∈K∪{j} gk, l(cid:48) = l[l(cid:48)
k/lk, k ∈ K ∪ {j}] and ν(cid:48) = ν[rk, k ∈ K ∪ {j}];
ν (cid:15)(cid:86)
-- (timed): (l, ν) → (l, ν + d) if ν + d (cid:15) Inv (l).
The valuation function ν is extended to handle a set of shared bounded integer
variables: predicates concerning such variables can be part of edges guards or
locations invariants, moreover variables can be updated on edges firings but they
cannot be assigned to or from clocks.
Example 1 In Figure 1 we consider the network of timed automata TA1 and TA2
with broadcast communications, and we give a possible run. T A1 and T A2 start
in the l1 and l3 locations, respectively, so the initial state is [(l1, l3); x = 0]. A
timed transition produces a delay of 1 time unit, making the system move to state
[(l1, l3); x = 1]. A broadcast transition is now enabled, making the system move
to state [(l2, l3); x = 0], broadcasting over channel a and resetting the x clock.
Two successive timed transitions (0.5 time units) followed by a broadcast one will
(cid:5)
eventually lead the system to state [(l2, l4); x = 1].
Throughout our modelling, we have used the specification and analysis tool
Uppaal [4], which provides the possibility of designing and simulating timed au-
tomata networks on top of the ability of testing networks against temporal logic
formulae. All figures depicting timed automata follow the graphic conventions of
the tool (e.g., initial states are denoted with a double circle).
2.2 Temporal Logics and Model Checking
Model checking is one of the most common approaches to the verification of soft-
ware and hardware (distributed) systems [7]. It allows to automatically prove
6
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
TA1
l1
x < 2
G : x = 1
S : a!
U : x := 0
l2
x < 2
G : x > 0
S : b!
U : −
G : true
S : a?
U : x := 0
l3
G : x = 1
S : −
U : −
l4
TA2
(a) The timed automata network TA1 (cid:107) TA2.
[(l1, l3); x = 0]
[(l1, l3); x = 1]
[(l2, l3); x = 1]
[(l2, l3); x = 0]
[(l2, l3); x = 0.5]
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
Fig. 1: A network of timed automata with a possible run.
[(l2, l4); x = 1]
(b) A possible run.
whether a system verifies or not a given specification. In order to apply such a
technique, the system at issue should be encoded as a finite transition system and
the specification should be written using propositional temporal logic. Formally, a
transition system over a set AP of atomic propositions is a tuple M = (Q, T, L),
where Q is a finite set of states, T ⊆ Q × Q is a total transition relation, and
L : Q → 2AP is a labelling function that maps every state into the set of atomic
propositions that hold at that state.
Temporal formulae describe the dynamical evolution of a given system. The
computation tree logic CTL∗ allows to describe properties of computation trees.
Its formulas are obtained by (repeatedly) applying boolean connectives (∧, ∨, ¬,
→), path quantifiers, and state quantifiers to atomic formulas. The path quantifier
A (resp., E) can be used to state that all the paths (resp., some path) starting
from a given state have some property. The state quantifiers are X (next time),
which specifies that a property holds at the next state of a path, F (sometimes
in the future), which requires a property to hold at some state on the path, G
(always in the future), which imposes that a property is true at every state on the
path, and U (until), which holds if there is a state on the path where the second
of its argument properties holds and, at every preceding state on the path, the
first of its two argument properties holds. Given two formulas ϕ1 and ϕ2, in the
rest of the paper we use the shortcut ϕ1 (cid:32) ϕ2 to denote the liveness property
AG(ϕ1 → AF ϕ2), which can be read as "ϕ1 always leads to ϕ2 ".
The branching time logic CTL is a fragment of CTL∗ that allows quantification
over the paths starting from a given state. Unlike CTL∗, it constrains every state
quantifier to be immediately preceded by a path quantifier.
Given a transition system M = (Q, T, L), a state q ∈ Q, and a temporal logic
formula ϕ expressing some desirable property of the system, the model checking
problem consists of establishing whether ϕ holds at q or not, namely, whether
M, q = ϕ.
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
7
3 Leaky Integrate and Fire Model and Mapping to Timed Automata
Spiking neural networks [26] are modelled as directed weighted graphs where ver-
tices are computational units and edges represent synapses. The signals propa-
gating over synapses are trains of impulses: spikes. Synapses may modulate these
signals according to their weight: excitatory if positive, or inhibitory if negative.
The dynamics of neurons is governed by their membrane potential (or, simply,
potential ), representing the difference of electrical potential across the cell mem-
brane. The membrane potential of each neuron depends on the spikes received
over the ingoing synapses. Both current and past spikes are taken into account,
even if old spikes contribution is lower. In particular, the leak factor is a measure
of the neuron memory about past spikes. The neuron outcome is controlled by
the algebraic difference between its membrane potential and its firing threshold :
it is enabled to fire (i.e., emit an output impulse over all outgoing synapses) only
if such a difference is non-negative. Spike propagation is assumed to be instan-
taneous. Immediately after each emission the neuron membrane potential is reset
and the neuron stays in a refractory period for a given amount of time. During this
period it has no dynamics: it cannot increase its potential as any received spike is
lost and therefore it cannot emit any spike.
Definition 2 (Spiking Integrate and Fire Neural Network) A spiking in-
tegrate and fire neural network is a tuple (V, A, w), where:
-- V are spiking integrate and fire neurons,
-- A ⊆ V × V are synapses,
-- w : A → Q ∩ [−1, 1] is the synapse weight function associating to each synapse
(u, v) a weight wu,v.
We distinguish three disjoint sets of neurons: Vi (input neurons), Vint (intermedi-
ary neurons), and Vo (output neurons), with V = Vi ∪ Vint ∪ Vo.
A spiking integrate and fire neuron v is characterized by a parameter tuple
(θv, τv, λv, pv, yv),
where:
-- θv ∈ N is the firing threshold,
-- τv ∈ N+ is the refractory period,
-- λv ∈ Q ∩ [0, 1] is the leak factor.
The dynamics of a spiking integrate and fire neuron v is given by:
-- pv : N → Q+
0 is the [membrane] potential function defined as
(cid:26)(cid:80)m
(cid:80)m
i=1 wi · xi(t),
i=1 wi · xi(t) + λv · pv(t − 1), otherwise.
if pv(t − 1) (cid:62) θv
pv(t) =
with pv(0) = 0 and where xi(t) ∈ {0, 1} is the signal received at the time
t by the neuron through its ith out of m input synapses (observe that the
past potential is multiplied by the leak factor while current inputs are not
weakened),
8
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
-- yv : N → {0, 1} is the neuron output function, defined as
(cid:40)
1
0
yv(t) =
if pv(t) (cid:62) θv
otherwise.
As shown in the previous definition, the set of neurons of a spiking integrate
and fire neural network can be classified into input, intermediary, and output
ones. Each input neuron can only receive as input external signals (and not other
neurons' output). The output of each output neuron is considered as an output
for the network. Output neurons are the only ones whose output is not connected
to other neurons.
We present here our modelling of spiking integrate and fire neural networks
(in the following denoted as neural networks) via timed automata networks. Let
S = (V, A, w) be a neural network, G be a set of input generator neurons (these
fictitious neurons are connected to input neurons and generate input sequences
for the network), and O be a set of output consumer neurons (these fictitious
neurons are connected to the broadcast channel of each output neuron and aim at
consuming their emitted spikes). The corresponding timed automata network is
obtained as the synchronous product of the encoding of input generator neurons,
the neurons of the network (referred as standard neurons in the following), and
output consumers neurons. More formally:
(cid:74)S(cid:75) = ( (cid:107)ng∈G(cid:74)ng(cid:75)) (cid:107) ( (cid:107)vj∈V(cid:74)vj(cid:75)) (cid:107) ( (cid:107)nc∈O(cid:74)nc(cid:75))
Input generators. The behaviour of input generator neurons is part of the spec-
ification of the network. Here we define two kinds of input behaviours: regular and
non-deterministic ones. For each family, we provide an encoding into timed au-
tomata.
Regular input sequences. Spike trains are "regular" sequences of spikes and pauses:
spikes are instantaneous while pauses have a non-null duration. Sequences can be
empty, finite or infinite. After each spike there must be a pause, except when the
spike is the last event of a finite sequence. Infinite sequences are composed by two
parts: a finite and arbitrary prefix and an infinite and periodic part composed
by a finite sequence of spike -- pause pairs which is repeated infinitely often. More
formally, such sequences are given in terms of the following grammar:
G ::= Φ.(Φ)ω P (d).Φ.(Φ)ω
Φ ::= s.P (d).Φ ε
with s representing a spike and P (d) a pause of duration d. It is possible to generate
an emitter automaton for any regular input sequence:
Definition 3 (Input generator) Let I ∈ L(G) be a word over the language gen-
{y}, Arcs(I), Inv(I)). It is inductively defined as follows:
-- if I := Φ1.(Φ2)ω
erated by IS, then its encoding into timed automata is(cid:74)I(cid:75) = (L(I), f irst(I), {t},
-- L(I) = L(Φ1) ∪ L(Φ2), where last(Φ2) is urgent
-- f irst(I) = f irst(Φ1)
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
9
(a) (cid:74)Φ1.(Φ2)ω(cid:75)
(b) (cid:74)P (d).Φ1.(Φ2)ω(cid:75)
(c) (cid:74)ε(cid:75)
(d) (cid:74)s.P (d).Φ(cid:48)(cid:75)
Fig. 2: Representation of the encoding of an input sequence
-- Arcs(I) = Arcs(Φ1) ∪ Arcs(Φ2) ∪
{(last(Φ1), true, ε,∅, f irst(Φ2)),
(last(Φ1), true, ε,∅, f irst(Φ2))}
-- if I := P (d).Φ1.(Φ2)ω
-- Inv (I) = Inv (Φ1) ∪ Inv (Φ2)
-- L(I) = {P0} ∪ L(Φ1) ∪ L(Φ2), where last(Φ2) is urgent
-- f irst(I) = P0
-- Arcs(I) = Arcs(Φ1) ∪ Arcs(Φ2) ∪
{(P0, t ≤ d, ,{t := 0}, f irst(Φ1)),
(last(Φ1), true, ε,∅, f irst(Φ2)),
(last(Φ1), true, ε,∅, f irst(Φ2))}
-- if Φ := ε
-- Inv (I) = {P0 (cid:55)→ t ≤ d} ∪ Inv (Φ1) ∪ Inv (Φ2)
-- L(Φ) = {E}
-- f irst(Φ) = last(Φ) = E
-- Arcs(Φ) = ∅
-- Inv (Φ) = ∅
-- if Φ := s.P (d).Φ(cid:48)
-- L(Φ) = {S, P} ∪ L(Φ(cid:48))
-- f irst(Φ) = S,
-- Arcs(Φ) = Arcs(Φ(cid:48)) ∪ {(S, true, y!,∅, P),
(P, t = d, ε,{t := 0}, f irst(Φ(cid:48)))}
-- Inv (Φ) = {P (cid:55)→ t ≤ d} ∪ Inv (Φ(cid:48))
last(Φ) = last(Φ(cid:48))
Figure 2 depicts the shape of input generators. Figure 2(a) shows the generator
(cid:74)I(cid:75), obtained from I := Φ1.(Φ2)ω. The edge connecting the last state of (cid:74)Φ2(cid:75) to
case, the initial location of (cid:74)I(cid:75) is P0, which imposes a delay of d time units. The
the first one allows Φ2 to be repeated infinitely often. Figure 2(b) shows the case
of an input sequence I := P (d).Φ1.(Φ2)ω beginning with a pause P (d): in this
remainder of the input sequence is encoded as for the previous case. Figure 2(c)
shows the induction basis for encoding a sequence Φ, i.e., the case Φ := ε. It is
encoded as a location E having no edge. Finally, Figure 2(d) shows the case of
a non-empty spike -- pause pair sequence Φ := s.P (d).Φ(cid:48). It consists of an urgent
location S: when the automaton moves from S, a spike is fired over channel y and
10
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
the automaton moves to location P, representing a silent period. After that, the
automaton proceeds with the encoding of Φ(cid:48).
Non-deterministic input sequences. This kind of input sequences is useful when no
assumption is available on neuron inputs. These are random sequences of spikes
separated by at least Tmin time units.
Such sequences can be generated by an automaton defined as follows:
Definition 4 (Non-deterministic input generator) A non-deterministic in-
put generator Ind is a tuple
(L, B, X, Σ, Arcs, Inv ),
with:
-- L = {B, S, W}, with S urgent,
-- X = {t}
-- Σ = x
-- Arcs = {(B, t = D, x!,∅, S), (S, true, ε,{t := 0}, W),
-- Inv(B) = (t ≤ D)
(W, t > Tmin, x!,∅, S)}
where D is the initial delay.
The behavior of such a generator depends on clock t and broadcast channel x,
and can be summarized as follows: it waits in location B an arbitrary amount of
time before moving to location S, firing its first spike over channel x. Since location
S is urgent, the automaton instantaneously moves to location W, resetting clock t.
Finally, from location W, after an arbitrary amount of time t, it moves to location
S, firing a spike. Notice that an initial delay D may be introduced by adding the
invariant t ≤ D to the location B and the guard t = D on the edge (B → S).
Standard neurons. The neuron is a computational unit behaving as follows: i)
it accumulates potential whenever it receives input spikes within a given accu-
mulation period, ii) if the accumulated potential is greater than the threshold, it
emits an output spike, iii) it waits during a refractory period, and restarts from
i). Observe that the accumulation period is not present in the definition of neuron
(Definition 2). It is indeed introduced here to slice time and therefore discretise
the decrease of the potential value due to the leak factor. We assume that two
input spikes on the same synapse cannot be received within the same accumula-
tion period (i.e., the accumulation period is shorter than the minimum refractory
period of the input neurons of the network). Next, we give the encoding of neurons
into timed automata.
Definition 5 Given a neuron v = (θ, τ, λ, p, y) with m input synapses, its encod-
ing into timed automata is N = (L, A, X, V ar, Σ, Arcs, Inv ) with:
-- L = {A, W, D} with D committed,
-- X = {t}
-- V ar = {p, a}
-- Σ = {xi i ∈ [1..m]} ∪ {y},
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
11
∀i = 1, ..., m
G : t ≤ T
S : xi?
U : a := a + wi
A
t ≤ T
G : t = T
S : −
U : p := a + (cid:98)λp(cid:99)
t := 0
G : p < θ
S : −
U : a = 0
G : t = τ
S : −
U : t := 0
a := 0
p := 0
t ≤ τ
W
D
C
G : p ≥ θ
S : y!
U : −
(a) Neuron model.
S : y?
W
O
U
U : s := 0
e := not(e)
(b) Output
tomaton.
consumer au-
Fig. 3: Automata for standard neuron and output consumer.
-- Arcs = {(A, t ≤ T, xi?,{a := a + wi}, A) i ∈ [1..m]} ∪ {(A, t = T,
,{p :=
a + (cid:98)λp(cid:99)}, D),
(D, p < θ, ,{a := 0}, A), (D, p ≥ θ, y!, , W),
(W, t = τ, ,{a := 0, t := 0, p := 0}, A)} ;
-- Inv (A) = t ≤ T, Inv (W) = t ≤ τ, Inv (D) = true.
The neuron behavior, described by the automaton in Figure 3(a), depends on
the following channels, variables and clocks:
-- xi for i ∈ [1..m] are the m input channels,
-- y is the broadcast channel used to emit the output spike,
-- p ∈ N is the current potential value, initially set to zero,
-- a ∈ N is the weighted sum of input spikes occurred within the current accu-
mulation period; it equals zero at the beginning of each round.
The behaviour of the automaton modelling neuron v can be summed up as
follows:
-- the neuron keeps waiting in state A (for Accumulation) for input spikes while
t (cid:54) T and, whenever it receives a spike on input xi, it updates a with a :=
a + wi;
-- when t = T , the neuron moves to state D (for Decision), resetting t and
updating p according to the potential function given in Definition 2:
p := a + (cid:98)λ · p(cid:99)
Since state D is committed, it does not allow time to progress, so, from this
state, the neuron can move back to state A resetting a if the potential has not
reached the threshold p < θ, or it can move to state W, firing an output spike,
otherwise;
-- the neuron remains in state W (for Wait) for τ time units (τ is the length of
the refractory period) and then it moves back to state A resetting a, p and t.
12
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
Output consumers. In order to have a complete modelling of a spiking neural
network, for each output neuron we build an output consumer automaton Oy.
The automaton, whose formal definition is straightforward, is shown in Figure
3(b). The consumer waits in location W for the corresponding output spikes on
channel y and, as soon as it receives the spike, it moves to location O. This location
is only needed to simplify model checking queries. Since it is urgent, the consumer
instantly moves back to location W resetting s, the clock measuring the elapsed
time since last emission, and setting e to its negation, with e being a boolean
variable which differentiates each emission from its successor.
Definition 6 (Output consumer) An output consumer is a timed automaton
N = (L, W, X, V ar, Σ, Arcs, Inv )
with:
-- L = {W, O} with O urgent,
-- X = {s}
-- V ar = {e}
-- Σ = {yi yi is an output neuron}
-- Arcs = {(W, , y?, , O),
(O, s := 0, ,{e := not(e)}, W)}
-- Inv (W) = true, Inv (O) = true.
We have a complete implementation of the spiking neural network model pro-
posed in the paper via the tool Uppaal. It can be found on the web page [6]. We
have validated our neuron model against some characteristic properties studied
in [24] (tonic spiking, excitability, integrator, etc.). These properties have been
formalised in temporal logics and checked via model-checking tools.
Observe that, since we rely on a discrete time, we could have used tick automata
[17], a variant of Buchi automata where a special clock models the discrete flow of
time. However, to the best of our knowledge, no existing tool allows to implement
such automata. We decided to opt for timed automata in order to have an effective
implementation of our networks to be exploited in parameter learning algorithms.
4 Validation of the model
In this section we show some properties of the neuron model of Definition 5. The
first group of properties are structural. We can compute a minimum value such
that any neuron, having a threshold greater than or equal to it, will never be able
to fire.
Property 1 Let N = (θ, τ, λ, p, y) be a neuron and amax be the maximum value
received during each accumulation period. Then, if θ ≥ amax
1−λ , the neuron is not
able to fire.
Proof Without loss of generality, we suppose that, during each accumulation pe-
riod, N receives the maximum possible input amax. Then, its potential function
is:
pn = amax + (cid:98)λ · pn−1(cid:99)
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
13
which is always lower than or equal to its undiscretized version:
pn ≤ p
(cid:48)
n = amax + λ · p
(cid:48)
n−1
The same inequality can be written in explicit form:
pn ≤ p
(cid:48)
n =
an−k · λk
n(cid:88)
k=0
and, since we assumed the neuron always receives amax, an−k is constant and does
not depend on k:
pn ≤ amax · n(cid:88)
λk
The rightmost factor is a geometric series:
k=0
pn ≤ amax · 1 − λn
1 − λ
which reaches its maximum value
1
1−λ for n → ∞, therefore:
pn ≤ amax
1 − λ
.
Thus, if θ ≥ amax
and, consequently, the neuron cannot fire.
1−λ , it is impossible for the neuron potential to reach the threshold
(cid:117)(cid:116)
In what follows, we only consider neurons that respect the previous constraint.
Apart from the minimum threshold, we can also quantify the amount of time
that the neuron requires to complete an accumulate -- fire -- rest cycle. We show that
there exists a minimum delay between neuron emissions.
Property 2 Let N = (θ, τ, λ, p, y) be a neuron. Then the time difference between
successive firings cannot be lower than T + τ .
Proof Let An =(cid:80)T
mulation period, then the neuron behaviour can be described as follows:
k=1 ak+t0 be the sum of weighted inputs during the n-th accu-
pn = An + (cid:98)λ · pn−1(cid:99)
which is the potential value after the n-th accumulation period. If the neuron
eventually fires an output spike, then there exists n > 0 such that:
n = arg min
n∈N
{pn : pn ≥ θ}
i.e., the firing will occur at the end of the n-th accumulation period, which means
during the t-th time unit since t0, thus:
t = n · T + t0
where t0 is the last reset time, i.e., the last instant back in time when the neuron
completed its refractory period. Then the next reset time t(cid:48), i.e., the next instant
14
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
in future when the neuron will complete its refractory period, after having emitted
a spike, is:
(cid:48)
t
= t + τ = n · T + τ + t0
At instant t(cid:48), the neuron quits its refractory period, n is reset to 0, t0 is set to t(cid:48),
and n, t and t(cid:48) must be consequently re-computed as described above.
Such a way to describe our model dynamics allow us to express the inter-firing
period as a function of n:
(cid:48) − t0 = n · T + τ
t
(cid:117)(cid:116)
So, the minimum inter-firing period is T + τ for n = 1.
Such a property can also be verified as follows: let I be the non-deterministic
input generator having Tmin = 1 and, without loss of generality1, let the initial
delay D = T + τ . Then the timed automata network I(cid:107)N(cid:107)O satisfies the following
formula:
AG(stateO(O) → evalO(s) ≥ T + τ )
where s measures the time elapsed since last firing, meaning that, whenever the
output consumer receives a spike, the time elapsed since the previous received
spike cannot be lower than T + τ .
The next fact states that only positive stimulations are necessary for the neuron
to produce emissions.
Fact 1 Let N = (θ, τ, λ, p, y) be a neuron, a(t) the sum of weighted inputs received
during the current accumulation period, and p(t − 1) the neuron potential at the
end of the previous accumulation period. If p(t − 1) < θ and a(t) < 0, the neuron
cannot fire at the end of the current accumulation period. Moreover, if p(t) ≥ θ
then a(t) > 0.
The neuron potential is affected by every input spike it received since the last
reset time, but every event that occurred before that instant is forgotten: i.e.,
neurons are memoryless.
Definition 7 (Inter-emission memory) Let N be a neuron, ZN its reset times
set, and I an input sequence. Then N has inter-emission memory if and only if
there exist two different t, t(cid:48) ∈ ZN such that the output sequences produced by N
as a response to I starting from t and t(cid:48) are different.
Property 3 Neurons have not inter-emission memory.
Proof When the neuron moves from location W to A, it resets clock t and variables
p and a, making them equal to their initial values. This entails that the neuron, if
(cid:117)(cid:116)
subjected to the same input sequence, will always behave in the same way.
Next, we validate the neuron model against its ability of reproducing or not
some behaviours, as described by Izhikevich in [24]. We introduce first three be-
haviours that are verified by our model.
1 the initial delay is required in order to make the formula hold for the first output spike
too
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
15
Tonic Spiking. Tonic spiking is the behaviour of a neuron producing a periodic
output sequence as a response to a persistent excitatory constant input sequence.
Property 4 (Tonic spiking) Let N = (θ, τ, λ, p, y) be a neuron having only one
ingoing excitatory synapse of weight w and let I be the input source connected
to N producing a persistent input sequence. Then N produces a periodic output
sequence.
The property holds by construction. It can be tested via model checking in
the following way. Let I be the fixed-rate input generator having arbitrary initial
delay D, and let O be an output consumer. Then the timed automata network
I(cid:107)N(cid:107)O satisfies the following formulae:
(cid:40)
stateO(O) ∧ evalO(e) ; stateO(O) ∧ ¬evalO(e)
stateO(O) ∧ ¬evalO(e) ; stateO(O) ∧ evalO(e)
where O is the location that the consumer automaton O reaches after consuming a
spike and e is an alternating boolean variable whose value flips whenever O moves
into location O. So, whenever automaton O reaches location O, it will eventually
reach it again.
One may also find the value P of the period of some given neuron N by means
of simulations, thus the periodic behaviour can be proven verifying the following
formula:
AG(stateO(O) ∧ evalN (f ) → evalO(s) = P )
where s is the clock measuring the time elapsed since last spike consumed by O,
and f is a boolean variable of automaton N which is initially f alse and is set to
true when edge (W → A) fires (i.e., it indicates whether N has already emitted
the first spike and waited the first refractory period or not).
Integrator. Integrator is the behaviour of a neuron producing an output spike
whenever it receives at least a specific number of spikes from its input sources in
the same accumulation period.
Property 5 (Integrator) Let N = (θ, τ, λ, p, y) be a neuron having m synapses with
maximum excitatory weight R and a threshold n ≤ m. Then the neuron emits if
it receives a spike from at least n input sources during the same accumulation
period.
As in the previous case, we can use model checking tools and test the formula
stating that, if at least n generators are ready to emit (location S) while N is in
A, then O will eventually capture an output of N :
(cid:32) m(cid:88)
(cid:33)
statei(S) ≥ n
∧ stateN (A) ; stateO(O)
i=1
Notice that, since potential depends on past inputs too, the neuron may still
be able to fire in other circumstances, e.g., if it keeps receiving less than n spikes
for a sufficient number of accumulation periods, then it may eventually fire.
16
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
∀i = 1, ..., m
G : t ≤ T
S : xi?
U : a := a + wi
∀i = 1, ..., m
G : t ≤ T
S : xi?
U : a := a + wi
G : t = T &&
a > 0
U : t := 0
G : t = τ
U : t := 0
a := 0
p := 0
AH
G : t = T &&
a ≤ 0
U : t := 0
A
t ≤ T
t ≤ T
G : t = T
U : p := a + (cid:98)λp(cid:99)
t := 0
G : p < θ
U : a = 0
t ≤ τ
W
G : p ≥ θ
S : y!
D
C
Fig. 4: The extended neuron model for phasic spiking.
Additions are colored in blue.
Excitability. Excitability is the behaviour of a neuron emitting sequences having
a decreasing inter-firing period, i.e., an increasing output frequency, when stimu-
lated by an increasing number of excitatory inputs.
Property 6 (Excitability) Let N = (θ, τ, λ, p, y) be a neuron having m excitatory
synapses. Then the inter-spike period decreases as the sum of weighted input spikes
increases.
unit. Consequently, An = (cid:80)T
Proof If we assume the neuron is receiving an increasing number of excitatory
spikes, generated by an increasing number of input sources emitting persistent
inputs, then at is the non-negative, non-decreasing and progressing (i.e., ∀u ∃t :
at > u) succession representing the weighted sum of inputs within the t-th time
k=1 ak+t0 is the non-negative, non-decreasing and
progressing succession counting the total sum of inputs within the n-th accumu-
lation period. Since An is positive and Property 2 holds, we can prove that the
(cid:117)(cid:116)
inter-spike period tn − tn−1 decreases.
The following behaviours are not satisfied by the LI&F model, we show that
our encoding cannot verify them as well.
Phasic Spiking. Phasic spiking is the behaviour of a neuron producing a single
output spike when receiving a persistent and excitatory input sequence and then
remaining quiescent for the rest of it. Such a behaviour depends on the neuron to
have inter-emission memory.
Property 7 Neurons cannot reproduce the phasic spiking behaviour.
Proof The phasic spiking behaviour requires the neuron to ignore any excitatory
input spike occurring after its first emission. This means producing different out-
comes, before and after the first emission, as a response to the same input sequence,
(cid:117)(cid:116)
which is impossible for a memoryless neuron, as stated in Property 3.
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
17
We can extend our model to reproduce phasic spiking, see Figure 4. This variant
makes the neuron able to "remember" if it is receiving a persistent excitatory input
sequence. After each refractory period, the neuron moves to location AH, instead
of A. The only difference between AH and A is that AH ignores positive values
of a at the end of each accumulation period. Conversely, a non-positive value of a
(denoting the end of the persistent input), at the end of some accumulation period,
leads the neuron back in location A.
Bursting. A burst is a finite sequence of high frequency spikes. More formally:
Definition 8 A spike output sequence is a burst if it is composed by spikes having
an occurrence rate greater than 1/τ , with τ being the refractory period of the
neuron.
A burst sequence is a sequence composed by bursts, subject to the following
constraint: the time difference between the last spike of each burst and the first
spike of the next burst it greater than τ .
Property 8 Neurons cannot produce bursts.
Proof A neuron N cannot emit spikes having a rate greater than 1/(T + τ ), as
(cid:117)(cid:116)
stated by Property 2, so it cannot produce bursts.
In order to reproduce bursts our model can be extended by allowing several
subsequent emissions in an interval period smaller than τ . After this period all
clocks and variables are reset and the accumulation-fire-rest cycle can start again.
Several bursting behaviours are described in [24]. Here we discuss only three
of them, as all impossibility results depend on Property 8 and all the automata
extensions are similar.
Tonic Bursting is the behaviour of a neuron producing a burst sequence as
a response to a persistent and excitatory input sequence. Phasic Bursting is the
behaviour of a neuron producing a burst as a consequence of a persistent excitatory
input sequence and then remaining quiescent. Obviously the preceding behaviours
require the ability of producing bursts.
Bursting-then-Spiking is the behaviour of a neuron producing a burst as re-
sponse to a persistent excitatory input sequence and then producing a periodic
output sequence. Such a behaviour, similarly to Phasic and Tonic Bursting, de-
pends on the neuron ability of producing bursts. Moreover it requires inter-emission
memory, in order to detect the beginning of a persistent sequence.
Property 9 Neurons cannot exhibit the Tonic Bursting, Phasic Bursting and Bursting-
then-Spiking behaviours.
Proof Follows from Property 8.
(cid:117)(cid:116)
Spike Frequency Adaptation. Spike Frequency Adaptation is the behaviour
of a neuron producing a decreasing-frequency output sequence as a response to
a persistent excitatory input sequence. In other words, the inter-emission time
difference increases as the time elapses. This behaviour requires the neuron to
have inter-emission memory as it should be able to keep track of the time elapsed
since the beginning of the input sequence.
18
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
∀i = 1, ..., m
G : t ≤ T
S : xi?
U : a := a + wi
A
t ≤ T
G : t = τ
U : t := 0
a := 0
p := 0
τ := τ + ∆τ
G : t = T
U : p := a + (cid:98)λp(cid:99)
t := 0
G : p < θ
U : a = 0
τ := τ0
t ≤ τ
W
G : p ≥ θ
S : y!
D
C
Fig. 5: The extended model for Spike Frequency Adaptation behaviour. Additions
are colored in blue.
Property 10 Neurons cannot reproduce the Spike Frequency Adaptation behaviour.
Proof The Spike Frequency Adaptation behaviour requires the neuron to detect
the beginning of an excitatory input sequence and to increase the time required
to fire a spike, after each emission. This means the neuron will produce different
outcomes as response to equal inputs, which is impossible, as stated in Property
(cid:117)(cid:116)
3.
An extended neuron model able to reproduce Spike Frequency Adaptation
behaviour is shown in Figure 5. This variant allows the refractory period to increase
after each neuron emission, thus making the output frequency decrease.
Spike Latency. Spike Latency is the behaviour of a neuron firing delayed spikes,
with respect to the instant when its potential reached or overcame the threshold.
Such a delay is proportional to the strength of the signal which leads it to emission,
i.e., the sum of weighed inputs received during the accumulation period preceding
the emission. This behaviour requires the neuron to be able to postpone its output.
Property 11 Neurons cannot reproduce the Spike Latency behaviour.
Proof The property holds by construction. As location D is committed, no firing
(cid:117)(cid:116)
can be delayed.
An easy solution to extend our model is to introduce a delay between the
instant the neuron reaches or overcomes its threshold and the actual emission
instant. Such a delay δ depends on the sum of weighted inputs received during the
last accumulation period. If the potential is greater than or equal to the threshold,
the neuron computes the delay duration δ(a), assigning it to an integer variable d,
and then waits in location Del for d time units before emitting a spike on channel
y. The extended version is depicted in Figure 6.
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
19
∀i = 1, ..., m
G : t ≤ T
S : xi?
U : a := a + wi
A
t ≤ T
G : t = τ
U : t := 0
a := 0
p := 0
W
t ≤ T
G : t = d
S : y!
U : t := 0
G : t = T
U : p := a + (cid:98)λp(cid:99)
t := 0
G : p < θ
U : a = 0
Del
G : p ≥ θ
U : d := δ(a)
D
C
Fig. 6: The extended model for the Spike Latency behaviour. Additions are colored
in blue.
∀i = 1, ..., m
G : t ≤ T
S : xi?
U : a := a + wi
A
t ≤ T
G : t = τ
U : t := 0
a := 0
p := 0
G : t = T
U : p := a + (cid:98)λp(cid:99)
t := 0
θ := θ + ∆θ(a)
G : p < θ
U : a = 0
t ≤ τ
W
G : p ≥ θ
S : y!
D
C
Fig. 7: The extended model for the Threshold variability behaviour. Additions
colored are in blue.
Threshold Variability. Threshold variability is the behaviour of a neuron allow-
ing its threshold to vary according to the strength of its inputs. More precisely, an
excitatory input will rise the threshold while an inhibitory input will decrease it.
As a consequence, excitatory inputs may more easily lead the neuron to fire when
occurring after an inhibitory input.
Property 12 Neurons cannot reproduce the Threshold Variability behaviour.
Proof By construction the neuron threshold never changes.
(cid:117)(cid:116)
The neuron model can be extended allowing the threshold to vary after each
accumulation period according to the current sum of weighted inputs (see Figure
20
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
∀i = 1, ..., m
G : t ≤ T
S : xi?
U : a := a + wi
A
t ≤ T
G : t = τ
U : t := 0
a := 0
p := 0
G : t = T
U : p := a + (cid:98)λp(cid:99)
t := 0
θ := bist(θ, a)
G : p < θ
U : a = 0
t ≤ τ
W
G : p ≥ θ
S : y!
D
C
Fig. 8: The extended model for Bistability behaviour.
Additions are colored in blue.
7). The threshold variable initial value is θ0. On every firing of edge (A → D),
the threshold variable is increased of ∆(a), where a is the sum of weighted inputs
occurred during the last accumulation period and ∆(a) is an integer value whose
sign is opposite to the sign of a and whose magnitude is proportional to the
magnitude of a.
Bistability. Bistability is the behaviour of a neuron alternating between two op-
eration modes: periodic emission and quiescence. Upon reception of a single exci-
tatory spike, it emits a periodic output sequence and switches to a quiescent mode
(no emission) as soon as it received another spike. Such a behaviour requires the
neuron to (i) be able to produce a periodic output sequence, even if no excitatory
spike is received, (ii) be able to remain silent when no spike is received, and (iii) be
able to switch between the two operation modes upon reception of an excitatory
spike.
Property 13 Neurons cannot reproduce the Bistability behaviour.
Proof The only possibility of obtaining a periodic output as a result of no exci-
tatory input spike is to set θ = 0. This is a limit case of Property 4. Since, by
construction, the threshold cannot vary, the neuron cannot switch between the
(cid:117)(cid:116)
two operation modes.
The neuron model can be modified as shown in Figure 8. This variant makes
its threshold switch between 0 and a positive value at the end of any accumulation
period during which it received an excitatory sum of weighted inputs a. A null
threshold would make the neuron emit even if no input is received. Conversely, a
positive threshold would prevent the neuron from emitting, if no input is received.
Thus, on every firing of edge (A → D), the threshold value θ is computed by the
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
21
function bist(·):
bist(θ, a) =
0
θ0
θ
if θ > 0 ∧ a > 0
if θ = 0 ∧ a > 0
if a ≤ 0.
Inhibition-induced activities. This is the behaviour of a neuron producing a
spike output sequence as a response to a persistent inhibitory input sequence. We
thus require the neuron to be able to emit as a consequence of some inhibitory
input spikes.
Property 14 Neurons cannot reproduce the Inhibition-induced Spiking behavior.
(cid:117)(cid:116)
Proof Follows from Fact 1.
An easy extension to our automata is to consider the absolute value of all inputs
instead of their signed values.
Rebound activities. Rebound Spike is the behaviour of a neuron producing an
output spike after it received an inhibitory input. Similarly to Inhibition-induced
activities, this behaviour requires the neuron to emit as a consequence of an in-
hibitory input spike.
Property 15 Neurons cannot exhibit the Rebound Spiking behaviour.
Proof Follows from Fact 1.
(cid:117)(cid:116)
We can modify our encoding by setting the neuron potential to be always
non-negative and by fixing the threshold to be 0 as response to an inhibitory
stimulation. Recall that a null threshold would make the neuron emit even if its
potential is 0. Thus, on every firing of the edge (A → D), if the current sum of
weighted inputs a is negative, the threshold θ is set to 0, otherwise it is set to a
θ > 0. This will allow an inhibitory stimulus to produce a rebound spike.
5 Parameter inference
In this section we examine the Learning Problem: i.e., how to determine a pa-
rameter assignment for a network with a fixed topology and a given input such
that a desired output behaviour is displayed. Here we only focus on the estimation
of synaptic weights in a given spiking neural network; the generalisation of our
methodology to other parameters is left for future work.
Our analysis takes inspiration from the SpikeProp algorithm [5]; in a similar
way, here, the learning process is led by supervisors. Differently from the previous
section, each output neuron N is linked to a supervisor instead of an output
consumer. Supervisors compare the expected output behaviour with the one of
the output neuron they are connected to (function Evaluate(N ) in Algorithm
1). Thus either the output neuron behaved consistently or not. In the second case
and in order to instruct the network, the supervisor back-propagates advices to
the output neuron depending on two possible scenarios: i) the neuron fires a spike,
but it was supposed to be quiescent, ii) the neuron remains quiescent, but it was
22
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
discovered = ∅
for all N ∈ Output do
Algorithm 1 The advice back-propagation algorithm
1: function ABP
2:
3:
4:
5:
6:
7:
8:
9:
discovered = discovered ∪ N
if Evaluate(N ) = SHF then
else if Evaluate(N ) = SNHF then
if N /∈ discovered then
SHF(N )
SNHF(N )
Algorithm 2 Should Have Fired algorithm
1: procedure Should-Have-Fired(N )
if N ∈ discovered ∪ Output then
discovered = discovered ∪ N
for all M ∈ Pred(N ) do
return
if M /∈ Input then
Increase-Weight(N ,M)
return
2:
3:
4:
5:
6:
7:
8:
9:
10:
11:
12:
if Wt(N ,M) ≥ 0 ∧ ¬ F(M) then
if Wt(N ,M) < 0 ∧ F(M) then
SHF(M)
SNHF(M)
supposed to fire a spike. In the first case the supervisor addresses a should not
have fired message (SNHF) and in the second one a should have fired (SHF). Then
each output neuron modifies its ingoing synaptic weights and in turn behaves as
a supervisor with respect to its predecessors, back-propagating the proper advice.
The advice back-propagation (ABP), Algorithm 1, basically lies on a depth-
first visit of the graph topology of the network. Let Ni be the i-th predecessor of an
automaton N , then we say that Ni fired, if it emitted a spike during the current or
previous accumulate-fire-wait cycle of N . Thus, upon reception of a SHF message,
N has to strengthen the weight of each ingoing excitatory synapse and weaken the
weight of each ingoing inhibitory synapse. Then, it propagates a SHF advice to
each ingoing excitatory synapse (i.e., an arc with weight greater than 0: Wt ≥ 0)
corresponding to a neuron which did not fire recently (¬F(N ) ), and symmetrically
a SNHF advice to each ingoing inhibitory synapse (Wt < 0) corresponding to a
neuron which fired recently (see Algorithm 2 for SHF, and Algorithm 3 for the dual
case of SNHF). When the graph visit reaches an input generator, it will simply
ignore any received advice (because input sequences should not be affected by the
learning process). The learning process ends when all supervisors do not detect
any more errors.
Example 2 (Turning on and off a diamond structure of neurons.) This example
shows how the ABP algorithm can be used to make a neuron emit at least once
in a spiking neural network having the diamond structure shown in Figure 9. We
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
23
return
if N ∈ discovered ∪ Output then
discovered = discovered ∪ N
for all M ∈ Predecessors(N ) do
Algorithm 3 Abstract ABP: Should Not Have Fired advice pseudo-code
1: procedure Should-Not-Have-Fired(neuron)
2:
3:
4:
5:
6:
7:
8:
if Wt(N ,M) ≥ 0 ∧ F(M) then
if M /∈ Input then
if Wt(N ,M) < 0 ∧ ¬ F(M) then
SNHF(M)
SHF(M)
Decrease-Weight(N ,M)
return
9:
10:
11:
12:
Fig. 9: A neural network with a diamond structure.
assume that N1 is fed by an input generator I that continuously emits spikes.
No neuron in the network is able to emit because all the weights of their input
synapses are equal to zero and their thresholds are higher than zero. We want
the network to learn a weight assignment so that N4 is able to emit, that is, to
produce a spike after an initial pause.
At the beginning we expect no activity from neuron N4. As soon as the initial
pause is elapsed, we require a spike but, as all weights are equal to zero, no emission
can happen. Thus a SHF advice is back-propagated to neurons N2 and N3 and
consequently to N1. The process is then repeated until all weights stabilise and
(cid:5)
neuron N4 is able to fire.
There are several possibilities on how to realise supervisors and the ABP algo-
rithm. We propose here two approaches. The first one is model checking oriented
and it is based on the idea that supervisors are represented by temporal logic
formulae. The second one is simulation oriented, and the implementation of the
algorithm is embedded into the timed automata modelling of the neuron.
Model-checking-oriented approach. Such a technique consists in iterating
the learning process until a desired CTL property concerning the output of the
N1N2N3S4N4w I,1w 1,2w 1,3w 3,4w 2,4xy 1y 3y 2y 4I 24
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
network is verified. The hypothesis we introduce are the following ones: (i) input
generators, standard neurons, and output consumers share a global clock which
is never reset and (ii) for each output consumer, there exists a clock measuring
the elapsed time since the last received spike. The CTL formula specifying the
expected output of the network can only contain predicates relative to the output
consumers and the global clock. At each step of the algorithm, we make an external
call to the model checker to test whether the network satisfies the formula or not.
If the formula is verified, the learning process ends; otherwise, the model checker
provides a trace as a counterexample. Such a trace is exploited to derive the proper
corrective action to be applied to each output neuron, that is, the invocation of
either the SHF procedure, or the SNHF procedure previously described (or no
procedure).
More in detail, given a timed automata network representing some spiking
neural network, we extend it with a global clock tg which is never reset and, for
each output consumer OK relative to the output neuron Nk, we add a clock sk
measuring the time elapsed since the last spike consumed by Ok. Furthermore, let
stateOk (O) be an atomic proposition evaluating to true if the output consumer
OK is in its O location, and let evalOk (sk) be an atomic proposition indicating
the value of the clock sk in OK . In order to make it possible to deduce the proper
corrective action, we impose the CTL formula describing the expected outcome of
the network to be composed by the conjunction of sub-formulae respecting any of
the patterns presented in the following.
Precise Firing. The output neuron Nk fires at time t:
Weak Quiescence. The output neuron Nk is quiescent at time t:
AF ( tg = t ∧ stateOk (O) ).
The violation of such a formula requires the invocation of the SHF procedure.
AG ( tg = t =⇒ ¬stateOk (O) ).
The SNHF procedure is called in case this formula is not satisfied.
Relaxed Firing. The output neuron Nk fires at least once within the time window
[ t1, t2 ]:
AF ( t1 ≤ tg ≤ t2 ∧ stateOk (O) ).
The violation of such a formula leads to the invocation of the SHF procedure.
Strong Quiescence. The output neuron Nk is quiescent for the whole duration of
the time window [ t1, t2 ]:
AG ( t1 ≤ tg ≤ t2 =⇒ ¬stateOk (O) ).
The SNHF procedure is needed in this case.
Precise Periodicity. The output neuron Nk eventually starts to periodically fire a
spike with exact period P :
AF ( AG( evalOk (sk) (cid:54)= P =⇒ ¬stateOk (O) )
∧ AG( stateOk (O) =⇒ evalOk (sk) = P ) ).
If Nk fires a spike while the sk clock is different than P or it does not fire a
spike while the sk clock equals P , the formula is not satisfied. In the former
(resp. latter) case, we deduce that the SNHF (resp. SHF) procedure is required.
Relaxed Periodicity. The output neuron Nk eventually begins to periodically fire
a spike with a period that may vary in [ Pmin, Pmax ]:
AF ( AG( evalOk (sk) /∈ [ Pmin, Pmax ] =⇒
¬stateOk (O) ) ∧
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
25
AF ( stateOk (O) =⇒
Pmin ≤ evalOk (sk) ≤ Pmax ) ).
For the corrective actions, see the previous case.
As for future work, we intend to extend this set of CTL formulae with new formulae
concerning the comparison of the output of two or more given neurons. Please
notice that the Uppaal model-checker only supports a fragment of CTL where the
use of nested path quantifiers is not allowed. Another model-checker should be
called in order to fully exploit the expressive power of CTL.
Next we give a couple of examples.
Example 3 (Diamond network.) In this example, we apply the model-checking
approach to the diamond network of Figure 9. Neuron N4 cannot emit a spike
with the initial weights and parameters, which are:
w0,1 w1,2 w1,3 w2,4 w3,4
0.1
0.1
0.1
0.1
0.1
Neuron T
2
2
2
2
N1
N2
N3
N4
θ
0.35
0.35
0.35
0.55
τ
3
3
3
3
λ
7/9
7/9
7/9
1/2
We expect N4 to spike every 20 time units. After three cycles of the algo-
rithm (i.e., three checks of the formula and modifications of weights), we reach the
following weight assignment:
w0,1 w1,2 w1,3 w2,4 w3,4
0.3
0.3
0.3
0.3
0.3
(cid:5)
Example 4 (Mutual inhibition networks.) In this example we focus on mutual inhi-
bition networks, where the constituent neurons inhibit each other neuron's activity.
These networks belong to the set of Control Path Generators (CPGs), which are
known for their capability to produce rhythmic patterns of neural activity with-
out receiving rhythmic inputs [22]. CPGs underlie many fundamental rhythmic
activities such as digesting, breathing, and chewing. They are also crucial building
blocks for the locomotor neural circuits both in invertebrate and vertebrate ani-
mals. It has been observed that, for suitable parameter values, mutual inhibition
networks present a behaviour of the kind "winner takes all", that is, at a certain
time one neuron becomes (and stays) activated and the other ones are inhibited
[13].
We consider a mutual inhibition network of four neurons, as shown in Figure
10. This example, although being small, it is not trivial as it features inhibitor and
excitatory edges as well as cycles.
We look for synaptical weights such that the "winner takes all" behaviour is
displayed. We assume each neuron to be fed by an input generator I that contin-
uously emits spikes. At the beginning, all the neurons have the same parameters
(that is, firing threshold, remaining coefficient, accumulation period, and refrac-
tory period), and the weight of excitatory (resp. inhibitory) edges is set to 1 (resp.
26
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
I
N1
N2
N3
N4
S1
S2
S3
S4
Fig. 10: We denote neurons by Ni. The network is fed by an input generator I
and the learning process is led by the supervisors Si. Dotted (resp. continuous)
edges stand for inhibitions (resp. activations).
G : handle[n]
U : SHF (n)
A
S : bad?
S : ok?
B
C
R
S : restart!
U : reset()
G : handlenot[n]
U : SN HF (n)
Fig. 11: The automata responsible of the ABP − alg
-1). We use the ABP algorithm to learn a weight assignment so that the first neu-
ron is the winner. More precisely, we find a weight assignment so that, whatever
the chosen path in the corresponding automata network is, the network stabilises
when the global clock tg equals 70. The weight of the edges from the input gen-
erator I to the four neurons equals 0.041. The weight of the edges inhibiting N1
(resp. N2, N3, and N4) is -0.719 (resp. -0.817).
(cid:5)
Simulation-oriented approach. In this second approach, parameters are modi-
fied during the simulation of the network. This entails that the encoding of neurons
needs to be adjusted in order to take care of the adaptation of such parameters.
Algorithm ABP is realised by a dedicated automaton ABP − alg, that is depicted
in Figure 11, and the role of supervisor is given to output consumers, that are
modified as in Figure 12.
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
27
G : s == 21
S : bad!
U : SHF ()
s ≤ 21
W
S : restart?
U : reset()
S : x4?
O C
G : s <= 20 ∧ nbS4 >= 100
S : ok!
U : s := 0
G : s <= 20
U : s := 0; nbS4 + +;
Fig. 12: Example of an output consumer in the simulation approach for the dia-
mond structure
The idea is that, according to the function Evaluate, if the corresponding
output neuron misbehaves, then its output consumer sets whether it has to be
treated according to the SHF or the SNHF function. Furthermore, it signals to
the ABP − alg through the message bad! that some adjustments on the network
have to be done. Then the ABP − alg automaton takes the lead and it recursively
applies the function SHF or SNHF (this is achieved by setting a proper variable in
a vector named handle) on the predecessors of the output neuron. Once there is no
more neuron to whom the algorithm should be applied (for instance all neurons in
the current run have been visited), the simulation is restarted in the network with
the new parameters. If the output consumer does not recognise any misbehaviour,
than it sends an ok! message to the ABP − alg automaton, that in turn moves to
an accepting state A.
More formally:
Definition 9 (Output consumer for the simulation approach) An output
consumer for the simulation approach is a timed automaton
N = (L, A, X, V ar, Σ, Arcs, Inv )
with:
-- L = {W, O} with O committed,
-- X = {s}
-- V ar = {nb, handle[N ], handlenot[N ]}
-- Σ = {xi xi is an output neuron} ∪ {bad, restart, ok},
-- Arcs = {(W, s < Tmin, bad!,{SHF ()}, W),
(W, , restart?,{s := 0, nb := 0}, W),
(W, , xi?, , 0), (O, s > Tmax, bad!,{SN HF ()}, W),
(O, , restart?,{s := 0, nb := 0}, O),
(O, good pattern, ok!,{s := 0}, W),
(O, good not f inished, ,{s := 0}, W)} ;
-- Inv (W) = s ≤ T , Inv (O) = true
where the functions SHF and SNHF modify the global variables handlei and
handlenoti respectively, that are used in the ABP − alg automaton.
28
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
Notice that the precise definition (for instance the value of parameters good pattern,
good not f inished, Tmin, Tmax) of the output consumer depends on the expected
behaviour of the supervisor. As an example, in Figure 12, that depicts the output
consumer for the diamond network, we expect the output neuron to emit a spike
within each window of 20 seconds for at least 100 times.
More in detail, the cycle from W to W is taken whenever a spike has not been
sent before T time units. Thus the automaton sends to the ABP − alg automaton
a bad message (signalling that an adjustment to the network should take place),
and the update part handles the fact that we should perform the SHF algorithm
(a variable corresponding to the concerned output neuron is set to true in the
array handle). From the same state, whenever the message restart is received,
all the variables of the automaton are reset to 0. When a spike from the output
neuron x is received, the output consumer moves to the state O. In this state,
if the spike was received too late (and similarly as in the previous case), a bad
message is sent to the ABP − alg. Otherwise, if everything was received on time
and if the expected pattern has been completely verified, then an ok message is
sent and the automaton moves to the initial state.
In the following, we give the formal definition of the ABP − alg automaton:
Definition 10 (ABP − alg automaton)
-- L = {A, B, R} with R committed,
-- X = ∅
-- V ar = {handle[N ], handlenot[N ]}
-- Σ = {bad, ok, restart},
-- Arcs = {(B, , ok?, , A), (B, , bad?, , R)
(R, handle[n], , SHF (n), R)
(R, handlenot[n], , SN HF (n), R)
(R, f inished?(), restart!, reset(), B)} ;
-- Inv (A) = true, Inv (B) = true, Inv (R) = true.
The arc from the state B to the accepting state A is taken whenever the Output
consumer has finished the analysis of its pattern. Conversely, the arc from the state
B to R is adopted when one of the output neurons has misbehaved (signalled by
the reception of the message bad). In the committed state R, the parameters of
the neural network are changed accordingly to the Algorithms 2 and 2. The arrays
handle (respectively handlenot) have the information on the neurons to which
the Algorithm for SHF (respectively SNHF) has to be applied. Once the cycle
of updates finishes (checked through the function f inished?()), the simulation is
restarted by broadcasting a message restart to all the neurons and the output
consumer.
Last, we give the definition of the changes induced in the standard neuron. As
the update of the neuron parameters is done at the level of ABP − alg, the only
change concerns the treatment of the signal restart. To this aim an arc handling
the reception of the message is added to the states W and A.
Definition 11 ( Standard Neuron for the simulation approach) Given a
neuron v = (θ, τ, λ, p, y) with m input synapses, its encoding into timed automata
is N = (L, A, X, V ar, Σ, Arcs, Inv ) with:
-- L = {A, W, D} with D committed,
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
29
Fig. 13: Example of a neuron in the simulation approach for the diamond network
G : t == τ
U : Reset()
S : restart?
U : Reset()
S : x?
U : a := a + wi
A
t ≤ T
S : restart?
U : Reset()
G : t == T
U : p := a + (cid:98)λp(cid:99)
G : p < θ
U : a := 0
t ≤ τ
W
G : p ≥ θ
S : y!
D
C
-- X = {t}
-- V ar = {p, a}
-- Σ = {xi i ∈ [1..m]} ∪ {y},
-- Arcs = {(A, t ≤ T, xi?,{a := a + wi}, A) i ∈ [1..m]} ∪ {(A, t = T,
a + (cid:98)λp(cid:99)}, D),
(D, p < θ, ,{a := 0}, A), (D, p ≥ θ, y!, , W),
(W, t = τ, ,{a := 0, t := 0, p := 0}, A),
(A, , restart?,{a" = 0, t := 0, p := 0}A),
(W, , restart?,{a" = 0, t := 0, p := 0}A)} ;
-- Inv (A) = t ≤ T, Inv (W) = t ≤ τ, Inv (D) = true.
,{p :=
Notice that the algorithm can be refined by setting some priorities on the
neurons. For instance, if any additional information is known in advance on the
behaviour of a specific neuron, its actions can be constrained and the corrective
operations could be ignored. In some cases, the type of synapse (excitatory or
inhibitory) can also be set, disallowing the possibility of changing its nature (e.g.,
from inhibitory to excitatory).
Example 5 (Diamond network) In this example, we apply the simulation-oriented
approach on the diamond network on Figure 9. We take the same parameters and
aim as in Example 3.
After the simulation, we obtain the following resulting weights :
w0,1 w1,2 w1,3 w2,4 w3,4
0.2
0.3
0.3
0.3
0.3
We obtain these weights when the global clock equals 42 and after only 2 sends
of the message bad (meaning that the neuronal network is stabilising in only two
applications of the ABP algorithm). Note that the resulting weights for the model-
checking-oriented approach, seen in the precedent example, are different. Indeed,
different sets of weights can give the same behaviour.
30
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
I
N1
N2
N3
S1
S2
S3
Fig. 14: A second neural network with "winner takes all" behaviour
Example 6 (Mutual inhibition network ) This example shows the weight estimation
for the network of Figure 14 with the simulation approach. As before, we require
a "winner takes all" behaviour where N1 is the winner. We expect that N1 spikes
every 10 time units at most, and the neurons N2 and N3 do not spike. We take a
network with the following initial parameters:
(cid:5)
Neuron T
2
2
2
N1
N2
N3
θ
0.75
0.75
0.75
τ
3
3
3
λ
1/2
1/2
1/2
wx,y
I
N1
N2
N3
I N1 N2 N3
0.1
0
-0.1
0
0
-0.1
0
-0.1
0.1
0.1
-0.1
0.1
0
0
0.1
0
And we obtain the following weights in 5 executions of the ABP algorithm:
wx,y
I
N1
N2
N3
I N1 N2 N3
0.1
0
-0.1
0
0
-0.1
0
-0.1
0.6
0.1
-0.1
0.6
0
0
0.1
0
Notice that, as the application of the ABP algorithm in the simulation approach is
non-deterministic, the parameters we found may depend on the precise execution
and several solutions are therefore possible. The complete encoding of the examples
shown here can be found at [12].
(cid:5)
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
31
6 Related Work
To the best of our knowledge, there are few attempts of giving formal models for
LI&F. Apart from the already discussed approach of [13], where the authors model
and verify LI&F networks thanks to the synchronous language Lustre, the closest
related work we are aware of is [3]. In this work, the authors propose a mapping
of spiking neural P systems into timed automata. The modelling is substantially
different from ours. They consider neurons as static objects and the dynamics
is given in terms of evolution rules while for us the dynamics is intrinsic to the
modelling of the neuron. This, for instance, entails that inhibitions are not just
negative weights as in our case, but are represented as forgetting rules. On top of
this, the notion of time is also different: while they consider durations in terms of
number of applied rules, we have an explicit notion of duration given in terms of
accumulation and refractory period.
As far as our parameter learning approach is concerned, we borrow inspira-
tion from the SpikeProp rule [5], a variant of the well known back-propagation
algorithm [32] used for supervised learning in second generation learning. The
SpikeProp rule deals with multi-layered cycle-free spiking neural networks and
aims at training networks to produce a given output sequence for each class of
input sequences. The main difference with respect to our approach is that we are
considering here a discrete model and our networks are not multi-layered. We also
rest on Hebb's learning rule [19] and its time-dependent generalisation rule, the
spike timing dependent plasticity (STDP) rule [33], which aims at adjusting the
synaptical weights of a network according to the time occurrences of input and
output spikes of neurons. It acts locally, with respect to each neuron, i.e., no prior
assumption on the network topology is required in order to compute the weight
variations for some neuron input synapses. Differently from the STDP, our ap-
proach takes into account not only recent spikes but also some external feedback
(advices) in order to determine which weights should be modified and whether they
must increase or decrease. Moreover, we do not prevent excitatory synapses from
becoming inhibitory (or vice versa), which is usually a constraint for STDP im-
plementations. A general overview on spiking neural network learning approaches
and open problems in this context can be found in [18].
7 Conclusion
In this paper we formalised the LI&F model of spiking neural networks via timed
automata networks. We have a complete implementation of the proposed model
and examples via the tool Uppaal, that can be found at the pages [6] and [12]. In
our modeling framework, information processing is based on the precise timing of
spike emissions rather than the average numbers of spikes in a given time window.
Timed automata turned out to be very suited to model spiking neural networks,
allowing us to take into account time-related aspects, such as the exact spike
occurrence times and the refractory period, a lapse of time immediately following
each spike emission, when the neuron emission capability is reduced.
In this work, we exploited model checking to automatically validate our automaton-
based mapping of the LI&F model according to a number of behaviours (i.e., typ-
ical responses to an input pattern) the LI&F model should be able to reproduce,
32
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
namely tonic spiking, excitability, and integrator. Formal methods of computer
science turned out to be an effective tool to validate our modelling approach. As
for future work concerning the modeling aspects, we plan to provide analogous
formalisations for more complex spiking neuron models, such as the theta-neuron
model [14] or the Izhikevich one [23]. We also intend to extend our model to include
propagation delays, which are considered important within the scope of spiking
neural networks [29]. Our extension is intended to add suitable states and clocks
to model synapses. We also plan to perform a robustness analysis of the obtained
model, in order to detect which neuron parameters influence most the verification
of some wished temporal properties.
As key contribution, we proposed a novel technique to infer the synaptical
weights of spiking neural networks. At this aim, we adapted machine learning
techniques to bio-inspired models, which makes our work original and comple-
mentary with respect to the main international projects aiming at understanding
the human brain, such as the Human Brain Project [9], which mainly relies on
large-scale simulations.
For our learning approach, we have focussed on a simplified type of supervi-
sors: each supervisor describes the output of a single neuron in isolation from the
other ones. Nonetheless, notice that the back-propagation algorithm is still valid
for more complex scenarios that specify and compare the behaviour of groups of
neurons. As for future work, we intend to formalise more sophisticated supervi-
sors, allowing to compare the output of several neurons. Moreover, to refine our
learning algorithm, we could exploit results coming from the gene regulatory net-
work domain, where a link between the topology of the network and its dynamical
behaviour is established [31].
As a last step, we plan to generalise our technique in order to be able to infer
not only synaptical weights but also other parameters, such as the leak factor or
the firing threshold.
Acknowledgements We are grateful to Giovanni Ciatto for his preliminary implementation
work and for his enthusiasm in collaborating with us.
References
1. Ackley, D.H., Hinton, G.E., Sejnowski, T.J.: A learning algorithm for boltzmann machines.
In: D. Waltz, J.A. Feldman (eds.) Connectionist Models and Their Implications: Readings
from Cognitive Science, pp. 285 -- 307. Ablex Publishing Corp., Norwood, NJ, USA (1988)
2. Alur, R., Dill, D.L.: A theory of timed automata. Theor. Comput. Sci. 126(2), 183 -- 235
(1994)
3. Aman, B., Ciobanu, G.: Modelling and verification of weighted spiking neural sys-
tems. Theoretical Computer Science 623, 92 -- 102 (2016). DOI http://dx.doi.org/
10.1016/j.tcs.2015.11.005. URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/
S0304397515009792
4. Bengtsson, J., Larsen, K.G., Larsson, F., Pettersson, P., Yi, W.: Uppaal -- a Tool Suite for
Automatic Verification of Real -- Time Systems. In: Proceedings of Workshop on Verification
and Control of Hybrid Systems III, no. 1066 in Lecture Notes in Computer Science, pp.
232 -- 243. Springer -- Verlag (1995)
5. Bohte, S.M., Poutr´e, H.A.L., Kok, J.N., La, H.A., Joost, P., Kok, N.: Error-
backpropagation in temporally encoded networks of spiking neurons. Neurocomputing
48, 17 -- 37 (2002)
6. Ciatto, G., De Maria, E., Di Giusto, C.: Additional material.
https://github.com/
gciatto/snn_as_ta (2016)
Spiking Neural Networks modelled as Timed Automata
33
7. Clarke Jr., E.M., Grumberg, O., Peled, D.A.: Model checking. MIT Press, Cambridge,
MA, USA (1999)
8. Cybenko, G.: Approximation by superpositions of a sigmoidal function. Mathematics of
Control, Signals and Systems 2(4), 303 -- 314 (1989)
9. D'Angelo, E., Danese, G., Florimbi, G., Leporati, F., Majani, A., Masoli, S., Solinas, S.,
Torti, E.: The human brain project: High performance computing for brain cells hw/sw
simulation and understanding. In: 2015 Euromicro Conference on Digital System Design,
DSD 2015, Madeira, Portugal, August 26-28, 2015, pp. 740 -- 747. IEEE Computer Society
(2015). DOI 10.1109/DSD.2015.80. URL https://doi.org/10.1109/DSD.2015.80
10. De Maria, E., Di Giusto, C.: Parameter learning for spiking neural networks modelled as
timed automata. In: P. Anderson, H. Gamboa, A.L.N. Fred, S.B. i Badia (eds.) Proceedings
of the 11th International Joint Conference on Biomedical Engineering Systems and Tech-
nologies (BIOSTEC 2018) - Volume 3: BIOINFORMATICS, Funchal, Madeira, Portugal,
January 19-21, 2018., pp. 17 -- 28. SciTePress (2018). DOI 10.5220/0006530300170028. URL
https://doi.org/10.5220/0006530300170028
11. De Maria, E., Di Giusto, C., Ciatto, G.: Formal validation of neural networks as timed
automata. In: Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Computational Systems-
Biology and Bioinformatics, Nha Trang City, Viet Nam, December 7-8, 2017, pp. 15 --
22. ACM (2017). DOI 10.1145/3156346.3156350. URL http://doi.acm.org/10.1145/
3156346.3156350
12. De Maria, E., Di Giusto, C., Laversa, L.: Additional material.
https://digiusto.
bitbucket.io/ (2017)
13. De Maria, E., Muzy, A., Gaff´e, D., Ressouche, A., Grammont, F.: Verification of Temporal
In: Fifth International
Properties of Neuronal Archetypes Using Synchronous Models.
Workshop on Hybrid Systems Biology. Grenoble, France (2016)
14. Ermentrout, G.B., Kopell, N.: Parabolic bursting in an excitable system coupled with a
slow oscillation. SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics 46(2), 233 -- 253 (1986)
15. Freund, Y., Schapire, R.E.: Large margin classification using the perceptron algorithm.
Machine Learning 37(3), 277 -- 296 (1999)
16. Gerstner, W., Kistler, W.: Spiking Neuron Models: An Introduction. Cambridge University
Press, New York, NY, USA (2002)
17. Gruber, H., Holzer, M., Kiehn, A., Konig, B.: On timed automata with discrete time -
structural and language theoretical characterization. In: Developments in Language The-
ory, 9th International Conference, DLT 2005, Palermo, Italy, July 4-8, 2005, Proceedings,
pp. 272 -- 283 (2005). DOI 10.1007/11505877 24
18. Gruning, A., Bohte, S.: Spiking neural networks: Principles and challenges (2014)
19. Hebb, D.O.: The Organization of Behavior. John Wiley (1949)
20. Hodgkin, A.L., Huxley, A.F.: A quantitative description of membrane current and its
application to conduction and excitation in nerve. The Journal of Physiology 117(4),
500 -- 544 (1952)
21. Hopfield, J.J.: Neural networks and physical systems with emergent collective computa-
tional abilities. In: J.A. Anderson, E. Rosenfeld (eds.) Neurocomputing: Foundations of
Research, pp. 457 -- 464. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, USA (1988)
22. Ijspeert, A.J.: Central pattern generators for locomotion control in animals and robots: A
review. Neural Networks 21(4), 642 -- 653 (2008). DOI 10.1016/j.neunet.2008.03.014. URL
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.neunet.2008.03.014
23. Izhikevich, E.M.: Simple model of spiking neurons. Trans. Neur. Netw. 14(6), 1569 -- 1572
(2003)
24. Izhikevich, E.M.: Which model to use for cortical spiking neurons? IEEE Transactions on
Neural Networks 15(5), 1063 -- 1070 (2004)
25. Lapicque, L.: Recherches quantitatives sur l'excitation electrique des nerfs traitee comme
une polarization. J Physiol Pathol Gen 9, 620 -- 635 (1907)
26. Maass, W.: Networks of spiking neurons: The third generation of neural network models.
Neural Networks 10(9), 1659 -- 1671 (1997)
27. Matsuoka, K.: Mechanisms of frequency and pattern control in the neural rhythm gener-
ators. Biological cybernetics 56(5-6), 345 -- 353 (1987)
28. McCulloch, W.S., Pitts, W.: A logical calculus of the ideas immanent in nervous activity.
The bulletin of mathematical biophysics 5(4), 115 -- 133 (1943)
29. Paugam-Moisy, H., Bohte, S.: Computing with Spiking Neuron Networks, pp. 335 -- 376.
Springer Berlin Heidelberg, Berlin, Heidelberg (2012)
34
Elisabetta De Maria et al.
30. Recce, M.: Encoding information in neuronal activity. In: W. Maass, C.M. Bishop (eds.)
Pulsed Neural Networks, pp. 111 -- 131. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, USA (1999)
31. Richard, A.: Negative circuits and sustained oscillations in asynchronous automata net-
works. Advances in Applied Mathematics 44(4), 378 -- 392 (2010)
32. Rumelhart, D.E., Hinton, G.E., Williams, R.J.: Learning representations by back-
propagating errors. In: J.A. Anderson, E. Rosenfeld (eds.) Neurocomputing: Foundations
of Research, pp. 696 -- 699. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, USA (1988)
33. Sjostrom, J., Gerstner, W.: Spike-timing dependent plasticity. Scholarpedia 5(2) (2010)
|
1901.07454 | 1 | 1901 | 2019-01-17T07:44:39 | Arbor -- a morphologically-detailed neural network simulation library for contemporary high-performance computing architectures | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | We introduce Arbor, a performance portable library for simulation of large networks of multi-compartment neurons on HPC systems. Arbor is open source software, developed under the auspices of the HBP. The performance portability is by virtue of back-end specific optimizations for x86 multicore, Intel KNL, and NVIDIA GPUs. When coupled with low memory overheads, these optimizations make Arbor an order of magnitude faster than the most widely-used comparable simulation software. The single-node performance can be scaled out to run very large models at extreme scale with efficient weak scaling.
HPC, GPU, neuroscience, neuron, software | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Arbor -- a morphologically-detailed neural network
simulation library for contemporary
high-performance computing architectures
9
1
0
2
n
a
J
7
1
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
4
5
4
7
0
.
1
0
9
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
Nora Abi Akar
Ben Cumming
Scientific Software & Libraries
Scientific Software & Libraries
Vasileios Karakasis
Scientific Computing Support
CSCS
Zurich, Switzerland
[email protected]
Anne Kusters
CSCS
Zurich, Switzerland
[email protected]
Wouter Klijn
CSCS
Lugano, Switzerland
[email protected]
Alexander Peyser
SimLab Neuroscience, JSC, IAS
SimLab Neuroscience, JSC, IAS
SimLab Neuroscience, JSC, IAS
Forschungszentrum Jlich
Julich, Germany
[email protected]
Forschungszentrum Jlich
Julich, Germany
[email protected]
Forschungszentrum Jlich
Julich, Germany
[email protected]
Stuart Yates
Scientific Software & Libraries
CSCS
Zurich, Switzerland
[email protected]
Abstract -- We introduce Arbor, a performance portable library
for simulation of large networks of multi-compartment neurons
on HPC systems. Arbor is open source software, developed under
the auspices of the HBP. The performance portability is by virtue
of back-end specific optimizations for x86 multicore, Intel KNL,
and NVIDIA GPUs. When coupled with low memory overheads,
these optimizations make Arbor an order of magnitude faster
than the most widely-used comparable simulation software. The
single-node performance can be scaled out to run very large
models at extreme scale with efficient weak scaling.
Index Terms -- HPC, GPU, neuroscience, neuron, software
I. INTRODUCTION
"What I cannot create, I do not understand."
-- Feynmann's blackboard, February 1988
The electrical basis of neuronal activity was experimentally
established in 1902 by Bernstein [1, Review] with preliminary
chemical models of ionic electrodiffusion. Further refinement
by Hodgkin, Huxley, Katz and Stmpfli of the connection
between ionic flow, electrical activity, and axonal firing quickly
followed in the wet lab with the classical series of experiments
on squid giant axons. However, the crucial breakthrough
in understanding the link between biological activity and
electrical activity in neuronal networks was the theoretical
description by Hodgkin and Huxley in 1952 in mathematical
and engineering language which allowed the computation of
the depolarization and repolarization of neurons from a few
experimentally accessible parameters. Full multicompartment
models handling complex, bifurcating dendritic arbors [2]
and assuming binary axonal firing and velocity allowed for
the mathematical construction of entire neurons. With the
addition of synaptic models in the ensuing decades,
the
fundamental formal description of biological neuronal networks
was captured at the scale of cellular behavior.
The evolution of computing equipment ranging from the
desktop PC to supercomputing centers has enabled a plethora
of tools for numerically computing predictions of neuronal
network behavior that is comparable with a variety of experi-
mental results, thus allowing the rigorous testing of possible
functional models with varying levels of experimental verifi-
cation, mathematical validity and stability, and computational
performance. In 1984, the publication of the Thomas algorithm
for neurons and its implementation in CABLE and NEURON
were the computational breakthrough for efficient computations
of complex dendritic arbors and the diffusion of computational
simulation to the wider neuroscientific community [3]. Contin-
uing improvements to NEURON and the addition of automated
code generation for neuron models to allow the injection of
efficient C code by neuroscientists not versed in programming
made NEURON the premier neuronal network simulator for
multicompartment neurons.
However, the field of neuronal network simulators is diverse,
encompassing point neuron simulators like NEST, interpreted
simulators for fast prototyping like BRIAN, and high-resolution
simulators like GENESIS [4, Review]. As the field expands
its ambitions from small neuronal networks towards the 1011
neurons in a human brain, and beyond by a further two orders
of magnitude to include electrically active glial cells, issues of
parallel computational performance have begun to dominate
the field [4], featuring experimental simulators like SPLIT.
Both NEURON and NEST have been ported to MPI for
large clusters and high-performance computing (HPC) centers;
petascale-capable code has been developed as CoreNEURON,
NEST 4G and Arbor. Use cases have included the neocortical
simulations [5], macaque visual cortical areas [6], and olfactory
bulb simulations [7].
New HPC architectures such as the addition of ubiquitous
GPU resources have been a new challenge, requiring new code
adaptation with codes such as CoreNEURON and GeNN for
single-node GPU neuronal networks. Developing performant
algorithms for computing the Hines matrix on GPUs and other
vectorize hardware has been an additional hurdle [8], [9]. The
development of Arbor [10] has focused on tackling issues of
vectorization and emerging hardware architectures by using
modern C++ and automated code generation, within an open-
source and open-development model.
II. MODEL
Arbor simulates networks of spiking neurons, and in partic-
ular, networks of multi-compartment neurons.
In this model, the only interaction between cells is mediated
by spikes1, discrete events initiated by one neuron which are
then propagated and distributed to typically many other neurons
after a delay. This abstracts the process by which an action
potential is generated by a neuron and then carried via an axon
to a number of remote synapses.
For simulation purposes, this interaction between neurons is
modeled as a tuple: source neuron, destination neuron, synapse
on the destination neuron, propagation time, and a weight. The
strictly positive propagation times allow for semi-independent
evolution of neuron state: if ∆T is the minimum propagation
time, then the integration of the neuron state from time t
to t + ∆T /2 only needs spikes that were generated at t <
t − ∆T /2.
While Arbor supports a number of neuron models, the main
focus is on the simulation of multi-compartment neurons. Here
each cell is modeled as a branching, one dimensional electrical
system with dynamics governed by the cable equation, with
ion channels and synapses represented by additional current
sources. (See [11] for an early example of this model applied to
a crustacean axon.) The domain is discretized (hence the term
multi-compartment) and the consequent system of differential
equations is integrated numerically. Spikes are generated when
the membrane voltage at a given point -- typically on the
soma -- exceeds a fixed threshold.
The cable equation is derived from the balance of trans-
membrane currents with the axial currents that travel through
the intracellular medium (Fig. 1). Membrane currents com-
prise a mixture of discrete currents and distributed current
1Interaction via gap junctions is under development in Arbor, but is not
currently supported.
J1
J2
Jmembrane
Fig. 1: Current balance in dendrite section, Jmembrane = J2 − J1. The
membrane is treated as a leaky capacitor with extra current sources,
surrounding an ohmic conductor of variable radius.
densities, derived from: the membrane capacitance; a surface
density of ion channels; and point sources from synapses and
experimentally-injected currents. The synapse and ion channel
currents themselves are functions of local states that are in
turn governed by a system of voltage-dependent ODEs.
The resulting equations have the form
(cid:16)
∂
∂x
σ
∂v
∂x
(cid:17)
=
(cid:16)
(cid:88)
+
channels k
(ssyn
k (t), v(xsyn
cm · ∂v
(cid:88)
∂t
(cid:88)
Isyn
+
i
synapses k
k (t) δxinj
Iinj
+
k ,
injections k
(cid:17) · ∂S
∂x
gk(sk(x, t))(v − erev
k )
k )) δxsyn
k
d
sk(x, t) = fi(sk, v(x, t)),
dt
d
k , v(xsyn
dt
ssyn
k (t) = f syn
(ssyn
i
k , t), t),
(1a)
(1b)
(1c)
where σ is the axial conductivity of the intracellular medium;
cm is the membrane areal capacitance; gk is the areal con-
ductance for an ion channel of type k as a function of an
ion channel state sk, with corresponding reversal potential
erev
k ; S(x) is the membrane surface area as a function of
axial distance x; Isyn
is the current produced by a synapse at
position xsyn
and local
voltage; and Iinj
k. The
functions fk and f syn
encode the biophysical properties of the
ion channels and synapses, and will vary from simulation to
simulation.
as a function of the synaptic state ssyn
k (t) is the injected current at position xinj
k
k
k
k
Arbor performs a vertex-centered 1-D finite volume dis-
cretization in space, using a first-order approximation for the
axial current flux. This provides a coupled set of ODEs for the
discretized voltages Vi for each control volume Xi, the synapse
states ssyn
k , and the discretized states of the ion channels sk,i
in Xi:
ci
dVi
dt
=
j: Xj∩Xi(cid:54)=∅
(cid:88)
σi,j(Vj − Vi) −(cid:88)
−(cid:88)
−(cid:88)
Isyn
k (ssyn
k ∈Xi
Si · gk(sk,i)(Vi − erev
k ),
Iinj
k (t)
k ∈Xi
k , Vi)
k: x
syn
inj
k: x
cell implementations, while target-specific vectorization, code-
generation and cell group implementations allow hardware-
optimized performance of models specified in a portable and
generic way.
(2a)
A. Cells and recipes
channels k
= fk(sk,i, Vi),
= f syn
k (ssyn
k , Vi, t),
dsk,i
dt
dssyn
k
dt
(2b)
(2c)
where ci is the integrated surface capacitance on Xi, Si is the
surface area of Xi, and σi,j is the reciprocal of the integrated
axial resistance between the centers of Xi and Xj.
The ODEs are solved numerically by splitting the integration
of the voltages Vi from the integration of the ion channel and
synapse states sk,i, ssyn
k : at a time t, the synapse, channel
and injection currents are calculated as a function of Vi(t);
Vi(t + δt) is then computed from (2a) by the implicit Euler
method; finally, the state variables are integrated with the
updated voltage values. The method of state integration will
depend upon the particular set of ODEs used to describe their
dynamics.
Synapse state is at best only piece-wise continuous: the
arrival of a spike at the synapse can cause a step change in its
state, and correspondingly in its current contribution. The time
step δt used for integration is shortened as necessary to ensure
that these updates can all be accounted for at the beginning of
an integration step.
For any given δt, the implicit Euler step involves the solution
of the linear system
(cid:88)
V (cid:48)
i +
ci
δt
i −(cid:88)
σi,jV (cid:48)
j
j
σi,jV (cid:48)
j = −Imemb
i
+
ci
δt
Vi,
where σi,j is non-zero only for neighboring control volumes
Xi and Xj. The corresponding matrix on the left hand side
is symmetric positive definite, comprising a weighted discrete
Laplacian on the adjacency graph of the control volumes plus
a strictly positive diagonal component given by ci/δt.
By appropriate numbering of the control volumes, this
matrix becomes nearly tridiagonal, with other non-zero terms
corresponding to branching points in the dendritic tree, and can
be solved efficiently via an extension of the Thomas algorithm
(see [12]; matrices of this form are now often termed Hines
matrices.)
III. DESIGN
Arbor is designed to accommodate three primary goals:
scalability; extensibility; and performance portability.
Scalability is achieved through distributed model construc-
tion, following the abstraction of a recipe as described below,
and through the use of an asynchronous MPI-based spike
communication scheme. Arbor is extensible in that it allows
for the creation of new kinds of cells and new kinds of
The basic unit of abstraction in an Arbor model is the cell.
A cell represents the smallest model that can be simulated,
and forms the smallest unit of work that can be distributed
across processes. Cells interact with each other only via spike
exchange.
Cells can be of various types, admitting different representa-
tions and implementations. Arbor currently supports specialized
leaky integrate and fire cells and cells representing artificial
spike sources in addition to the multi-compartment neurons
described in Section II.
Large models, intended to be run on possibly thousands of
nodes, must be able to be instantiated in a distributed manner;
if any one node has to enumerate each cell in the model, this
component of the simulation is effectively serialized. Arbor
uses a recipe to describe models in a cell-oriented manner.
Recipes derive from a base recipe class and supply methods to
map a global cell identifier to a cell type, a cell description, and
to a list of all connections from other cells that terminate on it.
This provides a deferred evaluation of the model, allowing the
process of instantiation of cell data to be performed in parallel
both on and across ranks.
B. Cell groups
A cell group is an object within the simulation that represents
a collection of cells of the same type together with an
implementation of their simulation. As an example, there are
two cell group implementations for multi-compartment cells:
one for CPU execution, which runs one or a small number
of cells in order to take advantage of cache-locality; and a
CUDA-based implementation for GPUs which runs a very large
number of cells in order to utilize the very wide parallelism
of the device.
The partitioning of cells into cell groups is provided by a
decomposition object; the default partitioner will distribute cells
of the same type evenly across nodes, utilizing GPU-based cell
groups if they are available. Users, however, can provide more
specialized partitions for their models.
The simulation object itself is responsible for managing the
instantiation of the model and the scheduling of the spike
exchange task and the integration tasks for each cell group.
C. Mechanisms
The description of multi-compartment cells also includes
the specification of ion channel and synapse dynamics. In
the recipe, these specifications are called mechanisms and are
referenced by name; the cell group will select a CPU- or
GPU-implementation for the mechanism as appropriate from a
default or user-supplied mechanism catalog.
Mechanisms in the cataloger can be hand-coded for CPU
or GPU execution, but are more typically compiled from
a high-level domain specific language. Arbor provides a
transpiler called modcc that compiles a subset of the NEURON
mechanism specification language NMODL to architecture-
optimized vectorized C++ or CUDA source. These can then
be compiled and linked in to an Arbor-using application for
use in multi-compartment simulations.
IV. IMPLEMENTATION
The Arbor library is written in C++14 and CUDA. The
implementation has been driven by a philosophy of 'simple
by default': the code makes extensive use of the C++ standard
library data structures, and more complicated solutions are used
only where optimization is necessary. External dependencies are
minimized: Arbor includes its own thread pool implementation
and vectorization library, and in general a third-party library
will only be employed if the burden of writing or maintaining
a native solution becomes infeasibly large.
We adopt an open development model, with code, bug reports
and issues hosted on GitHub [10].
A. Simulation workflow
Arbor is a multi-threaded and distributed simulator; it uses
a task-based threading model (see Section IV-B below) for
the scheduling of cell state integration tasks and for the
communication of spike information across MPI ranks.
When the simulation object is initialized, Arbor instantiates
the cell group data from the recipe in parallel, with each
rank running one task per local cell group as described in
Section III-A. The actual execution of the simulation itself is
broken into epochs, each comprising a simulation time interval
of duration ∆T /2 where ∆T is the minimum propagation
delay (see Section II). This propagation time allows for
the overlapping of state integration and spike exchange: the
integration of states in epoch i requires the spikes generated
in epoch i − 2, and exchanged in epoch i − 1 (see Fig. 2 and
Fig. 3). In each epoch, one task is run for each cell group state
integration, and one for the spike exchange.
Spike exchange consists of three steps: first, all spikes
generated in the previous epoch are sorted and then collected
in each MPI rank via an ALLGATHER and ALLGATHERV
operation; each spike from the global list is checked against a
table of local connections, generating corresponding events on
per-cell event queues; finally, these event queues are merged
with the pending events for each cell in parallel.
The local connection table is partitioned by the rank of the
source cell, and then sorted within each partition by destination
cell. The global spike list is also naturally partitioned by
source rank by virtue of the allgatherv operation; the testing
of spikes against local connections is then O(S · log(N C/R))
for homogeneous networks, where S is the number of spikes,
R the number of ranks, N the number of cells per rank, and
C the number of connections per cell.
B. Task pool
We implemented a simple tasking system with dedicated
task queues per thread, task stealing and exception handling.
Tasks are submitted to a task pool and pushed to the thread
queues in a round-robin fashion. Threads execute tasks from
their queues; if their queues are empty, they execute tasks from
another thread's non-empty, available queue.
Tasks are submitted in task groups, within which they are
processed asynchronously, but joined synchronously. Excep-
tions generated by a task within a task group are propagated
to the caller when the task group is joined.
The entire implementation is compact -- only 360 lines of
code -- while its performance is comparable to sophisticated
threading libraries for representative task sizes.
C. Architecture-specific optimization
Arbor employs specific optimizations for GPU and CPU
implementations in order to take advantage of the merits of
each architecture.
As mentioned in Section III-A, efficient utilization of a GPU
requires very wide parallelism. A GPU cell group for multi-
compartment cells will typically encapsulate all the cells on the
rank, with integration and event handling performed in-step.
Mechanism state update is highly parallel, with one CUDA
thread per instance; however the collection of the corresponding
membrane currents in each control volume from potentially
many synapses and other sources must be synchronized. Arbor
uses a CUDA-intrinsics based key reduction algorithm to limit
the use of atomic operations in this summation.
The Thomas algorithm, as used in the implicit Euler step
for the membrane voltage update, is inherently serial. The
GPU implementation uses one thread per cell, but the matrix
layouts for the cell group are interleaved in order to maximize
utilization of the GPU memory bandwidth.
Arbor uses explicit vectorization for CPU targets, with
support for AVX, AVX2, and AVX512. This vectorization
support is provided by a dedicated vectorization library based
on the recent C++ standards proposal P0214R6 [13] that
separates the interface from the architecture-specific vectoriza-
tion intrinsics. The library additionally supports gather/scatter
operations subject
to supplied constraints on the indirect
indices and architecture-specific vectorized implementations of
a number of transcendental functions. Support for additional
vector instruction sets can be added in a modular way.
The modcc transpiler will translate NMODL descriptions
of ion channel and synapse dynamics to vectorized kernels
for the mechanism state update and current contribution
operations, which dominate time to solution on CPU. The
requisite data for these operations is not always sequential
in memory; synapses, in particular, may have a many-to-one
relationship with their corresponding control volumes in the
cell discretizations. Accessing this data via vector gather/scatter
operations, however, is much slower than, for example, a direct
vector load or store operation [14].
Arbor performs a pre-processing step to factor the mecha-
nism data accesses into four indirection categories: sequential;
constant, that is, accessing the one location; independent non-
sequential; and free. These constitute a constraint on the
indirect indices for the gather or scatter operations, which
t0
t1
t2
t3
t4
Fig. 2: A timeline for task execution for 4 threads with 15 cells. Tasks from left to right on the first (top) thread: spike global communication;
enqueue spike events; update cell state; merge per-cell event queues. The spike communication and enqueue tasks are serialized and the event
merge tasks can only be executed when the enqueue is complete. Compute and communication can fully overlap only if the combined time
for spike communication and enqueue does not exceed the time taken for state updates. Thread starvation is evident in the third epoch.
p
u
d
e
e
p
S
4
3 . 5
3
2 . 5
2
1 . 5
1
core
socket
K a b y L a k e
i 7
X e o n B r o a d w e l
l
X e o n S k y l a k e
K N L
Fig. 4: Single core and single socket speedup for explicit vectorization
on four Intel architectures.
Strong scaling measures the performance gain obtained for a
fixed problem size as the number of nodes is increased, and
weak scaling measures the time to solution as a problem size
is increased in proportion to the number of nodes.
For Arbor to meet users' performance expectations, it has
to fit and efficiently execute a large enough model on one
node, and then weak scale well enough to simulate the entire
problem.
We want to emphasize that the aim of the benchmark results
presented here is not to say that one architecture is better than
the other. Instead our intention is to illustrate that Arbor can
be used effectively on any HPC system available to a scientist.
A. Test configuration
1) Test systems: Three Cray clusters at CSCS were used
for the benchmarks, detailed in TABLE II. All benchmarks
benefited from hyperthreading, which was enabled in each
configuration.
TABLE II: The resources on one node of each of the three test
systems.
CPU
memory
CPU sockets
cores/socket
threads/core
vectorization
accelerator
interconnect
MPI ranks
threads/rank
configuration
compiler
Daint-mc
Broadwell
64 GB
2
18
2
AVX2
--
Aries
2
36
--
GCC 7.2.0
Daint-gpu
Haswell
32 GB
1
12
2
AVX2
P100 GPU
Aries
1
24
CUDA 9.2
GCC 6.2.0
Tave-knl
KNL
96 GB
1
64
4
AVX512
--
Aries
4
64
cache,quadrant
GCC 7.2.0
Fig. 3: Overlapped compute and communication.
are then performed in an architecture-optimized manner by the
vectorization library.
The use of the dedicated vectorization library allows for a
significant improvement in time to solution when compared
with compiler auto-vectorized code. We run a benchmark
consisting of cells with 300 compartments with Hodgkin-
Huxley mechanisms and 5,000 randomly connected exponential
synapses. Fig. 4 shows the per-core and per-socket speedup for
four Intel CPUs: a laptop Kaby Lake i7; a Broadwell Xeon; a
Skylake Xeon; and KNL (see TABLE I). The use of data-pattern
optimized loads and stores contributes significantly to the
observed gains; the comparatively low improvement observed
for the Xeon Broadwell is due to the poor performance of
vectorized division on this architecture, with half the throughput
of Kaby Lake and Skylake-X [14].
TABLE I: Vectorization benchmark CPU characteristics.
CPU
Kaby Lake i7
Broadwell
Skylake-X
KNL
cores
2
18
18
64
threads
4
36
36
256
ISA
AVX-2
AVX-2
AVX-512
AVX-512
V. BENCHMARKS
The performance of a neural network simulation application
can be measured in three ways from a HPC user's perspective:
the total time to solution; the allocation resource usage (node
or cpu-core hours to solution); and the maximum model size
that can be simulated.
These measures are determined by single node performance,
and the strong and weak scaling behavior of the application.
integratetot1integratetot2integratetot3with[t0,t1)spikesintegratetot4with[t1,t2)spikesexchange[t0,t1)spikesexchange[t1,t2)spikesexchange[t2,t3)spikeslocalspikes[t0,t1)localspikes[t1,t2)localspikes[t2,t3)localspikes[t3,t4)globalspikes[t0,t1)globalspikes[t1,t2)globalspikes[t2,t3)t0t1t2t3t4∆Tonetask/cellgrouponecommunicationtask 2) Software: Arbor version 0.1; NEURON version 7.6.2,
with Python 3. Arbor and NEURON compiled from source
with Cray MPI.
3) Models: Two models are used to benchmark Arbor and
NEURON.
Ring model: Randomly generated cell morphologies with
on average 130 compartments and 10,000 exponential synapses
per cell, where only one of the synapses is connected to a
spike detector on the preceding cell to form a ring network.
The soma has Hodgkin-Huxley mechanics, and dendrites have
passive conductance. The model is useful for evaluating the
computational overheads of cell updates without any spike
communication or network overheads.
10k connectivity model: Using the same cells as for the
ring model, with a 10,000-way randomly connected network
with no self-connections. The minimum delay is either 10ms
or 20ms, and all synapses are excitatory. All cells spike
synchronously with frequency 50Hz, which is a pathological
case for spike communication, making this model useful for
testing the scalability of spike communication.
Validation of model outputs is not described in this bench-
mark paper due to space constraints. Briefly, the results were
validated by first comparing voltage traces of individual cells.
Then spike trains of the respective models were compared,
which is trivial for the ring model, and required ensuring that
the synchronous spiking occurred with the same frequency and
phase in the 10k connectivity model. Validation of individual
cell models and network spikes is on-going work, that will
be made available online in an open source validation and
benchmarking suite.
B. Single node performance
TABLE III shows the time to solution and energy overheads
[15] of the ring model with 32 -- 16,384 cells on a single node
of Daint-mc, Daint-gpu and Tave-knl.
The nodes on the test sytems offer range of computation
resources, from 76 parallel threads on Daint-mc, to 256 threads
on Tave-knl, and thousands of GPU cores on Daint-gpu. Time
to solution decreases on each system as the number of cells
is reduced, however these gains are marginal for model sizes
below a system-dependent threshold, and this threshold is
higher for systems with more on-node parallelism. Efficient
use of Daint-mc requires a minimum of 64 cells; for Tave-knl,
512 cells; and for Daint-gpu, 1024 cells.
C. Comparison with NEURON
NEURON [3] is the most widely used software for general
simulation of networks of multi-compartment cells. Like Arbor,
it supports running large models in parallel using multi-
threading and MPI [4]. We use NEURON for comparison
because of its ubiquity, because of its support for distributed
execution, because it is under active development, and because,
like Arbor, it is designed for models with user-defined cell
types, synapses and ion channels.
The wall time for simulating the ring benchmark with
NEURON on Daint-mc is also tabulated in TABLE III. Arbor
TABLE III: Single node results. Daint-mc 2 MPI ranks with 36
threads, Daint-gpu 1 rank with 24 threads, Tave-knl cache mode with
4 MPI ranks with 64 threads (4 per core).
cells
32
64
128
256
512
1024
2048
4096
8192
16384
mc
0.35
0.39
0.75
1.42
2.66
5.12
10.04
19.93
39.66
79.22
wall time (s)
knl
gpu
1.13
2.06
1.29
2.10
1.71
2.44
2.97
2.28
3.36
4.19
6.15
6.50
12.27
11.11
24.39
19.96
37.24
48.65
71.65
97.19
nrn
1.73
2.61
8.27
32.92
67.33
135.52
272.87
555.34
1234.70
--
energy (kJ)
gpu
0.25
0.25
0.33
0.43
0.67
1.14
2.11
3.96
7.72
15.11
knl
0.17
0.22
0.34
0.55
0.97
1.81
3.63
7.24
14.45
28.99
mc
0.04
0.05
0.11
0.26
0.58
1.24
2.53
5.16
10.38
20.85
is faster than NEURON for all model sizes, with the speedup
increasing with model size (see Fig. 5). For fewer than 128
cells Arbor is 5 -- 10× faster, and for more than 256 cells it
is over 20× faster. Arbor is also significantly more memory
efficient: the 16k cell model required 4.4 GB of memory,
whereas NEURON was unable to run this model in the 64 GB
memory available on Daint-mc.
These gains are primarily due to more efficient memory
bandwidth and cache use in Arbor: Arbor uses a structure-of-
array (SoA) memory layout, as opposed to the array-of-structure
layout of NEURON, and for larger models, Arbor is able to
keep cell state in L2 and L3 cache where NEURON becomes
DRAM-bandwidth bound.
p
u
d
e
e
p
s
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Arbor-mc
Arbor-gpu
64
128
256
512
1k
2k
4k
8k
cells
Fig. 5: The single node speedup of Arbor running on Daint-mc and
Daint-gpu relative to NEURON on Daint-mc.
D. Strong Scaling
Strong scaling is closely related to single node performance.
The number of cells per node decreases as the number of nodes
increases, and it follows from the single-node scaling results
in Section V-B that for each architecture there is a maximum
number of nodes beyond which there are too few cells per
node to utilize on-node resources. It makes little sense to scale
a model far past this point, because though time to solution
decreases, the total CPU or node hours from an allocation
increases.
TABLE IV shows the time to solution and energy consump-
tion for a 16,384 cell model with 10k connectivity run using 1
to 64 nodes. The multicore and GPU nodes on Daint-mc and
Daint-gpu respectively are equivalent (within 10%) for 4000
or more cells per node (less than 4 nodes), and Daint-mc is
)
%
(
y
c
n
e
i
c
fi
f
e
g
n
i
l
a
c
s
g
n
o
r
t
s
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
(a)
perfect
Daint-mc
Daint-gpu
Tave-knl
1
2
4
8
16
32
64
nodes
)
s
n
(
s
d
n
o
c
e
s
e
d
o
n
400
300
200
100
(b)
1
2
4
8
16
32
64
nodes
)
J
k
(
y
g
r
e
n
E
80
70
60
50
40
30
(c)
1
2
4
8
16
32
64
nodes
Fig. 6: Strong scaling from 1 to 64 nodes of a 100 ms simulation with 16,384 cells and 10,000 randomly connected synapses. Efficiency
decreases as the number of nodes increases, but only the multi-core system scales with 90% efficiency to 64 nodes (256 cells per node) in
(a). The resources consumed, in terms of node-seconds (simulation time × nodes) and total energy to solution are shown in (b) and (c)
respectively.
TABLE IV: Strong scaling of 16,384k cell model up to 64 nodes of
Daint-mc (mc), Daint-gpu (gpu) and Tave-knl (knl).
nodes
1
2
4
8
16
32
64
cell/node
16384
8192
4096
2048
1024
512
256
wall time (s)
energy (kJ)
mc
170.52
85.77
43.09
21.71
11.10
5.78
3.04
gpu
175.16
89.82
46.87
25.39
14.34
8.82
6.08
knl
240.33
119.57
59.60
29.86
15.41
8.35
5.07
mc
48.2
47.1
47.5
47.3
45.7
45.0
43.8
gpu
37.2
36.7
37.3
39.1
41.9
47.2
57.9
knl
69.3
69.6
68.9
68.4
69.1
72.8
79.9
)
s
(
e
m
i
t
l
l
a
w
90
88
86
84
82
80
Daint-mc
Daint-gpu
1
2
4
8
16
32
64
128
nodes
Fig. 7: Simulation time for the weak scaling tests with 8,192 cells
per node, 1 to 128 nodes. Each cells is connected to 10,000 random
cells with no self-connections.
much more efficient for more nodes. A KNL node is uniformly
slower than multicore, using 1.4× more time and energy.
Users of HPC systems are concerned with getting the
most from their resource allocations. The resource allocation
overhead of running the same model each system, measured in
node-seconds, is plotted in Fig. 6 (b). The energy to solution,
which is more interesting for data centers, is shown in Fig. 6
(c). These plots illustrate that resource utilization is efficient
where strong scaling is efficient. Hence both multicore and
GPU systems are efficient for models with many cells on each
node, and multicore systems can be used to more aggressively
strong scale a model to minimize time to solution.
E. Weak Scaling
Weak scaling measures efficiency as the number of nodes is
increased with a fixed amount of work per node. Good weak
scaling is a prerequisite for running large models efficiently
on many nodes.
The weak scaling benchmarks presented here show that
Arbor weak scales perfectly to hundreds of nodes on Daint-mc
and Daint-gpu, and scales efficiently for very large models
that might be run on the largest contemporary HPC systems.
Previous studies have shown that NEURON also weak scales
well to hundreds of nodes [16], hence for the sake of brevity
NEURON weak scaling is not presented here.
Fig. 7 shows the time solution for a model with 8,192 cells
per node weak scaled from one to 1,048,576 cells on 128 nodes.
Both the GPU and CPU back ends have near perfect weak
scaling for this range of nodes. Piz Daint is a very busy system,
and it isn't practical to extend the benchmark to thousands of
nodes.
To explore scaling issues at larger scales, Arbor has a dry
run mode similar to the NEST simulator [17]. Dry run mode
runs a model on a single MPI rank, and mimics running on a
large cluster by generating proxy spikes from cells on other
ranks. This approach allows us to investigate scaling on a larger
numbers of nodes than otherwise practical or possible.
We use dry run mode with 36 threads on an 18 core socket
of Daint-mc to predict and model weak scaling when running
at extreme scale. The largest homogeneous Cray XC-40 system
similar to Daint-mc is the 9,688-node Cori at NERSC. With this
in mind 10,000 nodes was chosen as a reasonable maximum
cluster size, and we test with 1,000 and 10,000 cells per node
for a total model size of 10 million and 100 million cells
respectively on 10,000 nodes.
)
s
(
e
m
i
t
l
l
a
w
10
9
8
7
6
5
10
1
(a)
100
nodes
1k
10k
1
10
1k
100
nodes
10k
(b)
e
m
i
t
100
90
80
70
60
50
)
s
(
l
l
a
w
Fig. 8: Time to solution in seconds for the dry run weak scaling tests
from 1 to 10,000 nodes for (a) 1,000 cells per node and (b) 10,000
cells per node.
The 100 ms simulations have a 10 ms min-delay, for 20
integration epochs (see Section IV-A), with cells firing at
87.5 Hz. Fig. 8 shows that the 1k and 10k models weak scale
very well with 99% and 95% efficiency respectively at 1,000
nodes. Weak scaling is still good at 10,000 nodes, 87% and
79% respectively, however it has clearly started to deteriorate.
TABLE V: The accumulated time spent by all threads on each
rank performing tasks for the dry-run benchmarks with 1k cells per
node (top) and 10k cells per node (bottom). The costs serialized are
highlighted in bold.
region
communication
enqueue
merge
cell state
idle
TOTAL
communication
enqueue
merge
cell state
idle
TOTAL
1
0.00
1.76
5.49
204.50
41.76
253.51
0.01
23.63
62.65
2070.69
372.45
2529.43
10
0.00
1.84
6.15
204.14
41.86
253.98
0.01
24.14
63.33
2092.82
382.93
2563.24
nodes
100
0.01
2.05
6.25
204.47
41.81
254.59
0.10
26.31
63.88
2086.59
387.07
2563.96
1,000
0.09
2.56
6.17
204.25
43.48
256.54
1.27
31.02
62.87
2072.28
486.44
2653.88
10,000
1.31
2.90
6.20
204.19
78.34
292.93
12.80
36.80
62.94
2089.95
993.02
3195.50
The overheads of the cell state and event merging tasks are
fixed in TABLE V, which is reasonable given that the number of
cells and post-synaptic spike events per cell are scale invariant
when weak scaling this model. On the other hand, the number of
spikes that must be communicated and processed on each node
to generate post-synaptic spike events increases proportionally
to the number of nodes. This is significant, because the spike
communication and event enqueue tasks are serialized, and are
not parallelized over multiple threads.
The optimized spike walking algorithm outlined in Sec-
tion IV-A scales well: it takes 1.5 times longer on 10,000
nodes than 1 node, despite walking 10,000 times more spikes.
However, the spike communication task scales linearly2, so
that the combined time for these serialized tasks doubles from
1 to 10,000 nodes for both models.
Fig. 2 shows that when the combined time for communication
and event enqueue tasks on one thread exceeds the time taken
by other threads to update cell state, the other threads are
blocked in idle state, which is 35 threads on Daint-mc. This
model has highly synchronized spiking in 9 waves over 20
integration intervals, so the exchange and spike walk task time
contributions are concentrated on some of the epochs. The
effect of this is clear, with the increased idle thread time and
simulation time in TABLE V and Fig. 8 respectively.
Weak scaling of 80% at extreme scale is considered satis-
factory by the Arbor developers, given that the largest models
being run in the HBP are in the range 1 to 10 million cells.
When the need arises, the spike walk can be parallelized,
however this will only be implemented when users require it to
keep with Arbor's policy of avoiding premature optimization.
2The communication task in dry run generates a global spike vector filled
with proxy spikes in place of an MPI collective, so the timings are also a
proxy for the actual MPI communication overheads. We aim to improve this
part of dry run mode by generating realistic timings with a performance model
for MPI collectives.
VI. CONCLUSION
We have presented Arbor, a performance portable library for
simulation of large networks of multi-compartment neurons
on HPC systems. The performance portability is by virtue of
back-end specific optimizations for x86 multicore, Intel KNL,
and NVIDIA GPUs. These optimizations and low memory
overheads make Arbor an order of magnitude faster than the
most widely-used comparable simulation software. The single-
node performance can be scaled out to run very large models
at extreme scale with efficient weak scaling.
Arbor is an open source project under active development.
Examples of new features that will be released soon include
but are not limited to: a python wrapper for user-friendly model
building and execution; accurate and efficient treatment of gap
junctions; and a GPU solver for Hines matrices exposes more
fine-grained parallelism.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This research has received funding from the European
Unions Horizon 2020 Framework Programme for Research and
Innovation under the Specific Grant Agreement No. 720270
(Human Brain Project SGA1), and Specific Grant Agreement
No. 785907 (Human Brain Project SGA2).
REFERENCES
[1] B. S. Pallotta and P. K. Wagoner, "Voltage-dependent
potassium channels since Hodgkin and Huxley," Physio-
logical Reviews, vol. 72, no. suppl 4, S49 -- S67, 1992,
PMID: 1438586. DOI: 10.1152/physrev.1992.72.suppl 4.
S49.
[2] W. Rall, "Theory of physiological properties of den-
drites," Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences,
vol. 96, no. 4, pp. 1071 -- 1092, 1962. DOI: 10.1111/j.1749-
6632.1962.tb54120.x.
[3] T. Carnevale and M. Hines, The NEURON book. Cam-
bridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2006, ISBN:
0521843219. DOI: 10.1017/CBO9780511541612.
[4] R. Brette, M. Rudolph, et al., "Simulation of networks
of spiking neurons: A review of tools and strategies,"
Journal of Computational Neuroscience, vol. 23, no. 3,
pp. 349 -- 398, Dec. 2007. DOI: 10.1007/s10827- 007-
0038-6.
[5] H. Markram, E. Muller, et al., "Reconstruction and
simulation of neocortical microcircuitry," Cell, vol. 163,
no. 2, pp. 456 -- 492, 2015. DOI: 10.1016/j.cell.2015.09.
029.
[6] M. Schmidt, R. Bakker, et al., "A multi-scale layer-
resolved spiking network model of resting-state dynam-
ics in macaque visual cortical areas," PLOS Computa-
tional Biology, vol. 14, no. 10, pp. 1 -- 38, Oct. 2018. DOI:
10.1371/journal.pcbi.1006359.
[7] M. Migliore, F. Cavarretta, et al., "Synaptic clusters func-
tion as odor operators in the olfactory bulb," Proceedings
of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States
of America, vol. 112, no. 27, pp. 8499 -- 8504, 2015. DOI:
10.1073/pnas.1502513112.
[8] P. Valero-Lara, I. Martnez-Perez, et al., "cuHinesBatch:
Solving multiple Hines systems on GPUs Human Brain
Project," Procedia Computer Science, vol. 108, pp. 566 --
575, 2017, International Conference on Computational
Science, ICCS 2017, 12-14 June 2017, Zurich, Switzer-
land, ISSN: 1877-0509. DOI: 10.1016/j.procs.2017.05.
145.
[9] F. Huber, "Efficient tree solver for Hines matrices on the
GPU using fine grained parallelization and basic work
balancing," in Guest Student Programme on Scientific
Computing, Forschungszentrum Jlich, 2018. eprint: 1810.
12742. [Online]. Available: https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.
12742.
[10] N. Abi Akar, J. Biddiscombe, et al., Arbor-sim/arbor:
Version 0.1: First release, Oct. 12, 2018. DOI: 10.5281/
zenodo.1459679. [Online]. Available: https://github.com/
arbor-sim/arbor.
[11] A. L. Hodgkin and W. A. H. Rushton, "The electrical
constants of a crustacean nerve fibre," Proceedings of the
Royal Society of London B, vol. 133, no. 873, pp. 444 --
479, 1946.
[12] M. Hines, "Efficient computation of branched nerve
equations," International journal of bio-medical comput-
ing, vol. 15, no. 1, pp. 69 -- 76, 1984, ISSN: 0020-7101.
DOI: 10.1016/0020-7101(84)90008-4.
[13] M. Kretz, P0214R6: Data-parallel vector types &
operations, ISO/IEC C++ Standards Committee Paper,
2017. [Online]. Available: http://www.open-std.org/jtc1/
sc22/wg21/docs/papers/2017/p0214r6.pdf.
[14] A. Fog, Instruction tables: 200 lists of
instruction
latencies, throughputs and micro-operation breakdowns
for Intel, AMD and VIA CPUs, 2018. [Online]. Available:
https://www.agner.org/optimize/instruction tables.pdf.
[15] G. Fourestey, B. Cumming, et al., "First experiences
with validating and using the Cray power management
database tool," CoRR, vol. abs/1408.2657, 2014. arXiv:
1408.2657. [Online]. Available: http://arxiv.org/abs/1408.
2657.
[16] M. Migliore, C. Cannia, et al., "Parallel network sim-
ulations with NEURON," Journal of Computational
Neuroscience, vol. 21, no. 2, p. 119, May 2006. DOI:
10.1007/s10827-006-7949-5.
[17] S. Kunkel and W. Schenck, "The NEST dry-run mode:
Efficient dynamic analysis of neuronal network simula-
tion code," Frontiers in Neuroinformatics, vol. 11, p. 40,
2017. DOI: 10.3389/fninf.2017.00040.
|
1511.08260 | 2 | 1511 | 2015-12-08T06:44:07 | Unsupervised decoding of long-term, naturalistic human neural recordings with automated video and audio annotations | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Fully automated decoding of human activities and intentions from direct neural recordings is a tantalizing challenge in brain-computer interfacing. Most ongoing efforts have focused on training decoders on specific, stereotyped tasks in laboratory settings. Implementing brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) in natural settings requires adaptive strategies and scalable algorithms that require minimal supervision. Here we propose an unsupervised approach to decoding neural states from human brain recordings acquired in a naturalistic context. We demonstrate our approach on continuous long-term electrocorticographic (ECoG) data recorded over many days from the brain surface of subjects in a hospital room, with simultaneous audio and video recordings. We first discovered clusters in high-dimensional ECoG recordings and then annotated coherent clusters using speech and movement labels extracted automatically from audio and video recordings. To our knowledge, this represents the first time techniques from computer vision and speech processing have been used for natural ECoG decoding. Our results show that our unsupervised approach can discover distinct behaviors from ECoG data, including moving, speaking and resting. We verify the accuracy of our approach by comparing to manual annotations. Projecting the discovered cluster centers back onto the brain, this technique opens the door to automated functional brain mapping in natural settings. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Unsupervised decoding of long-term, naturalistic
human neural recordings with automated video and
audio annotations
Nancy X. R. Wang1,2,3,4*, Jared D. Olson4,5, Jeffrey G. Ojemann2,4,6, Rajesh P. N. Rao1,2,4,
and Bingni W. Brunton2,3,7
1Dept. of Computer Science and Engineering, University of Washington, Seattle, 98195, USA
2Institute for Neuroengineering, University of Washington, Seattle, 98195, USA
3eScience Institute, University of Washington, Seattle, 98195, USA
4Center for Sensorimotor Neural Engineering, University of Washington, Seattle, 98105, USA
5Dept. of Rehabilitation Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle, 98195, USA
6Dept. of Neurological Surgery, University of Washington, Seattle, 98195, USA
7Dept. of Biology, University of Washington, Seattle, 98195, USA
*[email protected]
ABSTRACT
Fully automated decoding of human activities and intentions from direct neural recordings is a tantalizing challenge in brain-
computer interfacing. Most ongoing efforts have focused on training decoders on specific, stereotyped tasks in laboratory
settings. Implementing brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) in natural settings requires adaptive strategies and scalable algorithms
that require minimal supervision. Here we propose an unsupervised approach to decoding neural states from human brain
recordings acquired in a naturalistic context. We demonstrate our approach on continuous long-term electrocorticographic
(ECoG) data recorded over many days from the brain surface of subjects in a hospital room, with simultaneous audio and video
recordings. We first discovered clusters in high-dimensional ECoG recordings and then annotated coherent clusters using
speech and movement labels extracted automatically from audio and video recordings. To our knowledge, this represents the
first time techniques from computer vision and speech processing have been used for natural ECoG decoding. Our results
show that our unsupervised approach can discover distinct behaviors from ECoG data, including moving, speaking and resting.
We verify the accuracy of our approach by comparing to manual annotations. Projecting the discovered cluster centers back
onto the brain, this technique opens the door to automated functional brain mapping in natural settings.
Introduction
Much of our knowledge about neural computation in humans has been informed by data collected through carefully controlled
experiments in laboratory conditions. Likewise, the success of Brain-Computer Interfaces (BCIs1, 2) -- controlling robotic
prostheses and computer software via brain signals -- has hinged on the availability of labeled data collected in controlled
conditions. Sources of behavioral and recording variations are actively avoided or minimized. However, it remains unclear to
what extent these results generalize to naturalistic behavior. It is known that neuronal responses may differ between experimental
and freely behaving natural conditions.3 -- 5 Therefore, developing robust decoding algorithms that can cope with the challenges
of naturalistic behavior is critical to deploying BCIs in real-life applications.
One strategy for decoding naturalistic brain data is to leverage external monitoring of behavior and the environment
for interpreting neural activity. Previous research that studied naturalistic human brain recordings, including brain surface
electrocorticography (ECoG), have required ground truth labels.6 -- 8 These labels were acquired by tedious and time-consuming
manual labeling of video and audio. In addition to being laborious, manual labeling is prone to human errors from factors
such as loss of attention and fatigue.9 This problem is exacerbated by very long recordings, when patients are monitored
continuously for several days or long. Obtaining labeled data and training algorithms extensively are difficult or even intractable
in rapidly changing, naturalistic environments.
In this article, we describe our use of video and audio recordings in conjunction with ECoG data to decode human behaviour
in a completely unsupervised manner. Fig. 1 illustrates components of the data used in our approach. The data consists of six
subjects monitored continuously over at least one week after electrode array implantation; each subject had approximately 100
intracranial ECoG electrodes with wide coverage of cortical areas. Importantly, subjects being monitored had no instructions to
perform specific tasks; they were undergoing presurgical epilepsy monitoring and behaved as they wished inside their hospital
Figure 1. An excerpt from the data set, which includes video, audio, and intracranial brain activity (ECoG) continuously
recorded for at least one week for six subjects. ECoG recordings from a small subset of the electrodes are shown, along with
the simultaneously recorded audio signals in blue. A typical patient has around 100 electrodes. Overlaid are screen shots of the
video, which is centered on the patient; on the left is a daytime video of the patient eating, and on right is a nighttime infrared
video of the patient sleeping. For patient privacy, faces have been blurred.
room. Instead of relying on manual labels, we used computer vision, speech processing, and machine learning techniques
to automatically determine the ground truth labels for the subjects' activities. These labels were used to annotate patterns
of neural activity discovered using unsupervised clustering on power spectral features of the ECoG data. We demonstrate
that this approach can identify salient behavioral categories in the ECoG data, such as movement, speech and rest. Decoding
accuracy was verified by comparing the automatically discovered labels against manual labels of behavior in a small subset
of the data. Further, projecting the annotated ECoG clusters to electrodes on the brain revealed spatial and power spectral
patterns of cortical activation consistent with those characterized during controlled experiments. These results suggest that our
unsupervised approach may offer a reliable and scalable way to map functional brain areas in natural settings and enable the
deployment of BCI in real-life applications.
Background and Related Work
Intracranial electrocorticography (ECoG) as a technique for observing human neural activity is particularly attractive. Its
spatial and temporal resolution offers measurements of temporal dynamics inaccessible by functional magnetic resonance
imaging (fMRI) and spatial resolution unavailable to extracranial electroencephalography (EEG). Cortical surface ECoG is
accomplished less invasively than with penetrating electrodes10, 11 and has much greater signal-to-noise ratio than entirely
non-invasive techniques such as EEG.12, 13
Efforts to decode neural activity are typically accomplished by training algorithms on tightly controlled experimental data
with repeated trials. Much progress has been made to decode arm trajectories14 -- 16 and finger movements,17, 18 to control robotic
arms,19 -- 21 and to construct ECoG BCIs.22 -- 27 Speech detection and decoding from ECoG has been studied at the level of voice
activity,28 phoneme,23, 29 -- 31 vowels and consonants,32 whole words,33 and sentences.34 Accurate speech reconstruction has
also been shown to be possible.35
The concept of decoding naturalistic brain recordings is related to passive BCIs, a term used to describe BCI systems that
decode arbitrary brain activity that are not necessarily under volitional control.36 Our system, which falls within the class of
passive BCIs, may also be considered a type of hybrid BCI combining electrophysiological recordings with other signals.37
However, past approaches in this domain have not focused on combining alternative monitoring modalities such as video and
audio in order to decode natural ECoG signals.
The lack of ground-truth data makes decoding naturalistic neural recordings difficult. Supplementing neural recordings with
additional modes of observation, such as video and audio, can make the decoding more feasible. Previous studies exploring this
idea have decoded natural speech6, 38, 39 and natural motions of grasping;7, 8 however, these studies relied on laborious manual
annotations. Entirely unsupervised approaches to decoding have previously targeted sleep stages40 and seizures41 rather than
long-term natural ECoG recordings.
Our approach to circumvent the need for manually annotated behavioral labels exploits automated techniques developed
in computer vision and speech processing. Both of these fields have seen tremendous growth in recent years with increasing
processor power and advances in methodology.42, 43 Computer vision techniques have been developed for a variety of tasks
including automated movement estimation,44, 45 pose recognition,46 object recognition,47, 48 and activity classification.49, 50
In some cases, computer vision techniques have matched or surpassed single-human performance in recognizing arbitrary
objects.51 Voice activity detection has been well studied in speech processing.52 In this work, we leverage and combine
2/14
Figure 2. An overview of our methods to discover neural decoders by automated clustering and cluster annotations. Briefly,
the ECoG recordings was broken into short, non-overlapping windows of 2-seconds. Power spectral features were extracted for
each electrode, all electrodes' features were stacked, and the feature space was reduced to the first 50 principal component
dimensions. Hierarchical k-means clustering was performed on these 50-dimensional data, and annotation was done by
correlations in timing with automated detection of motion and speech levels (see Fig. 7). The resultant annotated clusters were
validated against manual annotations; cluster centroids mapped to the brain visualize the automatically detected neural patterns.
techniques from these rapidly advancing fields to automate and enhance the decoding of naturalistic human neural recordings.
Results
Our general approach to unsupervised decoding of large, long-term human neural recordings is to combine hierarchical
clustering of high-dimensional ECoG data with annotations informed by automated video and audio analysis, as illustrated
in Fig. 2 (further details in the Methods section). Briefly, hierarchical k-means clustering was performed on power spectral
features of the ECoG recordings. These clusters are coherent patterns discovered in the neural recordings; video and audio
monitoring data was used to interpret these patterns and match them to behaviorally salient categories such as movement,
speech and rest. Here we describe results of our analysis on six subjects where we used automated audio and video analysis
to annotate clusters of neural activity. The accuracy of the unsupervised decoding method was quantified by comparison to
manual labels, and the annotated clusters were mapped back to the brain to enable neurologically relevant interpretations.
Actograms: automated motion and speech detection
The automated motion and speech detection methods quantified movement and speech levels from the video and audio
recordings, respectively. Fig. 3 shows daily "actograms" for all six subjects. Movement levels were quantified by analyzing
magnitude of changes at feature points in successive frames of the video. Speech levels were quantified by computing the
power in the audio signal in the human speech range.
As expected, Fig. 3 shows that subjects were most active during waking hours, generally between 8:00AM and 11:00PM.
Also, movement and speech levels are often highly correlated, as the subjects were often moving and speaking at the same time
during waking hours. During night time hours, although subjects were generally less active, many instances of movement and
speech can still be seen in Fig. 3 as the subjects either shifted in their sleep or were visited by hospital staff during the night.
Our automated motion and speech detection algorithms were able to perform with reasonable accuracy when compared to
manual annotation of movement and speech. Over all subject days, movement detection was 74% accurate (range of 68% to
90%), while speech detection was 75% accurate (range of 67% to 83%).
Unsupervised decoding of ECoG activity
Unsupervised decoding of neural recordings was performed by hierarchical clustering of power spectral features of the multi-
electrode ECoG recordings. Because the subjects' behavior on each day varied widely, both across days for the same subject
and across subjects (see actograms in Fig. 3), we were agnostic to which specific frequency ranges contained meaningful
information and considered all power in frequency bins between 1 and 53 Hz (see Supplemental Information for results
considering higher frequency bands). Further, data from each subject day was analyzed separately. Clusters identified by
hierarchical k-means clustering were annotated using information from the external monitoring by video and audio. The
hierarchical k-means clustering implementation is detailed in the Methods section. Following a tree structure, successive levels
of clustering contained larger numbers of clusters (Fig. 7).
3/14
ECoGVideoAudioFeatureExtractionHierarchicalClusteringMotionDetectionSpeechDetectionAnnotatedClustersCorrelateAssessments:Validate clusters with manual annotationsMap clusters back to brain Figure 3. Daily actograms for all subjects. Each row shows one day of activity profiles summarized by automated speech and
motion recognition algorithms. Days 3 -- 6 post surgical implantation were analyzed. For purposes of this visualization, the
activity levels were binned to one-minute resolution. Movement and speech levels were highly correlated on most days, and
these were concentrated to the active hours between 8:00 AM and 11:00PM.
Fig. 4 shows results of the annotated clusters for one subject day (Subject 6 on day 6 post implantation) at clustering levels
1 -- 4 as a function of time of day. At level 1, it is clear that rest is separable from non-rest, and the switch in the dominant
cluster occurred around 10:00PM. We presume the timing of the switch to correspond to when the subject falls asleep, as is
corroborated by the video monitoring. when the subject is presumed to have fallen asleep as evident in the video monitoring.
Video S1 shows an example of the infrared video acquired during night time. The subject is in a consolidated period of rest
between 10:00PM and 9:00AM the following day. Interestingly, for a duration of approximately one hour starting at around
11:00AM, the rest cluster dominated the labels (see also red triangle at level 3). This period corresponds to the subject taking a
nap (Video S2).
Starting at level 2, the non-rest behavior separates into movement and speech clusters. These two clusters are generally
highly correlated, as moving and talking often co-occur, especially as the movement quantification can detect mouth or face
movement. We point out several interesting instances labeled at level 3. First, the inverted triangle points to a period around
11:00AM annotated as rest, when the subject rested during a nap (Video S2). Second, the rectangle marks a period around
1:00PM, annotated as predominantly movement but not speech, when the subject shifted around in their bed but did not
engage in conversation (Video S3). Third, the circle marks a period around 5:00PM when the subject engaged in conversation
(Video S4); this period was labeled as both movement and speech. As described in the validation analysis in the following
section, the accuracy of the automated annotations does not change substantially between levels 3 -- 4 across all subject days
(Fig. 5 and Fig. S3).
Validation of automated neural decoding by comparison with manual annotations
The automated neural decoding was assessed by comparison with behaviors labeled manually. Manual labels of the video
and audio were supplied by two human annotators, who labeled a variety of salient behaviors for at least 40 total minutes (or
approximately 3%) of video and audio recordings for each subject day. The labels were acquired for 2-minute segments of data
distributed randomly throughout the 24-hour day.
The entirely automated neural decoding performed very well in the validation for all subjects on the categories of movement,
speech and rest. Table 1 summarizes the accuracy of the annotated clusters averaged over the 4 days analyzed for each subject,
comparing the automated labels to manual labels during the labeled portions of each day. In addition to computing the accuracy,
4/14
Figure 4. Annotated clustering results of one subject day (Subject 6 on day 6 post implant) from hierarchical level 1 to level 4.
The vertical axis represents the fraction of time the neural recording is categorized to each annotated cluster. The triangle marks
when the subject takes a nap (Video S2), the square marks when the subject is seen to move without speech (Video S3), and the
circle marks when the subject spoke more than moved (Video S4). For visualization, the 24-hour day was binned to every 160
seconds.
we also computed the F1 scores of the automated decoding using manual labels as ground truth for each day; the F1 score is a
weighted average of precision and recall (Table S1).
To assess the significance of the automated labels' accuracy, we compared the F1 scores on each day to F1 scores of
randomly shuffled labels. The shuffled labels preserved the relative occurrence of labels and gave an unbiased estimate of
chance performance. Fig. 5 shows the percentile of the true F1 scores within the randomly shuffled F1 scores at hierarchical
clustering level 3. For each category of movement, speech and rest, the median percentile of the true F1 scores are at or near
the 99th percentile; our automatically labeled clusters performed significantly better than chance on most subject days. F1
score percentiles for clustering levels 2 and 4 are shown in Figs S2 and S3. We also repeated the analysis considering spectral
frequencies up to 105 Hz, which does not substantially change the performance of the automated decoder (Table S2 and Fig. S4)
Neural correlates of behavior as discovered by unsupervised clustering
Another way to assess the neural decoder discovered through clustering and automated annotation is to examine the neural
patterns identified in this unsupervised approach. We mapped these patterns by projecting the centroids of annotated clusters
back to feature space. Next, the feature space in electrode coordinates on the brain were averaged within frequency bands,
including those typically of interest to studies of human ECoG.
5/14
10:00 AM12:00 PM02:00 PM04:00 PM06:00 PM08:00 PM10:00 PM12:00 AM02:00 AM04:00 AM06:00 AM0.00.20.40.60.81.0Fraction of occurenceLevel 1Non RestRest10:00 AM12:00 PM02:00 PM04:00 PM06:00 PM08:00 PM10:00 PM12:00 AM02:00 AM04:00 AM06:00 AM0.00.20.40.60.81.0Fraction of occurenceLevel 210:00 AM12:00 PM02:00 PM04:00 PM06:00 PM08:00 PM10:00 PM12:00 AM02:00 AM04:00 AM06:00 AM0.00.20.40.60.81.0Fraction of occurenceLevel 310:00 AM12:00 PM02:00 PM04:00 PM06:00 PM08:00 PM10:00 PM12:00 AM02:00 AM04:00 AM06:00 AM0.00.20.40.60.81.0Fraction of occurenceLevel 4MovementSpeechRest Figure 5. Percentile of the F1 score of our algorithm at level 3 compared to F1 scores from randomly shuffled manual labels.
Each colored dot corresponds to one day for a subject in each behavioral category.
Subject 1
Subject 2
Subject 3
Subject 4
Subject 5
Subject 6
Movement
59.06
62.88
61.22
58.57
55.61
70.08
Speech
54.24
62.20
62.94
60.43
60.01
69.43
Rest
64.98
64.47
64.75
65.88
58.09
57.60
Table 1. Percent accuracy as assessed by comparison of level 3 automated cluster annotation to manual annotations averaged
over all 4 days for each subject.
Fig. 6 shows an example of one subject day's annotated cluster centroids shown as deviations from the daily average in
a low frequency band (LFB, 1 -- 8Hz) and a high frequency band (HFB, 12 -- 45Hz). The LFB was chosen to include activity
in the delta and theta range, while the HFB includes beta and low gamma activity. The accuracy of automated decoding on
this subject day (Subject 1, day 6 post implant) was 0.56, 0.69 and 0.63 for movement, speech and rest, respectively. In the
LFB, there was generalized decrease in power across all recording electrodes during movement and speech, accompanied by a
corresponding relative increase in power during rest. In contrast, in the HFB during movement and speech, we observe more
spatially specific increase in power that is localized to motor areas (orange circle in Fig. 6). There is some overlap in electrodes
showing increased HFB power during movement and speech, which may be due to activation of motor areas to produce speech.
In addition, during speech but not during movement, there is a localized increase in HFB power at associated auditory region
(green circle in Fig. 6).
These features are largely consistent with known functions of human cortical areas and ECoG phenomena, as well as the
existing ECoG literature on motor activation17, 53 and speech mapping.54, 55 We must note that these patterns of frequency
band-specific changes in power for different behavioral categories were discovered in an entirely unsupervised approach, using
continuously acquired naturalistic data, and without the luxury of subtraction of baseline activation immediately before or after
movement. It is important to keep in mind that previous studies typically define rest as the time just before an action, whereas
we compare to daily averages as well as to sleep. During non rapid eye movement sleep, the theta and delta bands tend to
have high power,56 a factor that distinguishes our results from those obtained from more controlled experiments. We observed
qualitatively similar patterns across the four (4) subjects where anatomic reconstruction of the electrode arrays were available
(Figs. S6 -- S8).
Discussion
Our results represent, to our knowledge, the first demonstration of automated clustering and labeling of human behavior from
brain recordings in a naturalistic setting; we achieved annotation without manual labels by leveraging techniques from computer
vision and speech processing. Our unsupervised approach discovers clusters for behaviors such as moving, speaking and resting
from ECoG data. The discovered cluster labels were verified by comparison to manual labels for a subset of the data. We also
demonstrate that projecting the cluster centers back onto the brain provides an avenue for automated functional brain mapping
6/14
Figure 6. Features discovered by automated brain decoding at two different frequency bands are consistent with known
functions of cortical areas. Shown for one subject day (Subject 1 on day 6 post implant), the centroids of the movement, speech
and rest clusters were back projected to brain-electrode space, and then separately averaged over a low frequency band (LFB,
1 -- 8Hz) and a high frequency band (HFB, 12 -- 45Hz). The orange and green circles mark the approximate extent of locations
typically considered to be sensorimotor and auditory regions, respectively. The colormap indicates the Z-Score of the power
levels as compared to the daily average.
in natural settings.
Our goal was to develop an approach to decode human brain recordings by embracing the richness and variability of
complex naturalistic behavior, while avoiding tedious manual annotation of data and fine tuning of parameters. Our current
approach has a number of limitations which can be addressed by improving both the available information streams and the
algorithmic processing. One limitation of our movement detection algorithm is lack of specificity to the subject when other
people enter the frame of the camera. This is particularly challenging when another person overlaps with the subject, for
example, when a nurse examines the patient. We are exploring the potential of better subject segmentation using a depth camera.
The depth stream information will also allow us to perform much more detailed pose recognition, including obtaining specific
movement information from isolated body parts.
A second limitation is our inability to identify the speaker in speech detection. Speech levels include the subject speaking,
the subject listening to another person speaking in the room, and the subject listening to the TV or another electronic audio
source. We expect that by placing an additional microphone in the room and using algorithms to distinguish speaker voices, it
may be possible to more accurately localize the speaker and speech sources.
The temporal aspect of high-dimensional, long-term ECoG data may be better exploited to improve the clusters discovered
by unsupervised pattern recognition techniques. For instance, dimensionality reduction by dynamic mode decomposition
(DMD57) may be able to identify spatio-temporal patterns when repeated trials are not available. Phase synchrony and phase
coupling may also serve as important neural correlates of behavior.58
Overall, these results demonstrate that our method has the practicality and accuracy to passively monitor the brain and
decode its state during a variety of activities. In our results, we see some variation in performance and cluster maps across
days for the same subject. This variance may be due to changes in brain activity as the patient recovers from surgery, or it may
represent natural variation from day to day.
Functional brain mapping acquired by analyzing neural recordings outside instructed tasks has direct relevance to how
an individual brain functions in natural conditions. For instance, neural correlates of a subject repeating a series of specific
actions may differ from the full range of neural signatures associated with movements in general. Previous attempts to do more
"ethological" mapping based on non-cued activities have identified motor59, 60 and speech6, 38 related areas. Our approach to
ethological functional brain mapping explores the analysis of task-free, naturalistic neural data augmented by information from
external monitoring, which enables us to perform the automated analysis at a much larger scale with long-term data.
7/14
We envision our automated passive monitoring and decoding approach with video and audio as a possible strategy to adjust
for natural variation and drift in brain activity without the necessity to retrain decoders explicitly. Such an approach may
enable deployment of long-term BCI systems, including clinical and consumer applications. More generally, we believe the
exploration of large, unstructured, naturalistic neural recordings will improve our understanding of the human brain in action.
Methods
Subjects and recording
All six subjects had a macro-grid and one or more strips of electrocorticography (ECoG) electrodes implanted subdurally for
presurgical clinical epilepsy monitoring at Harborview Medical Center. The study was approved by University of Washington's
Institutional Review Board's human subject division; all subjects gave their informed consent.
Electrode grids were constructed of 3-mm-diameter platinum pads spaced at 1 cm center-to-center and embedded in silastic
(AdTech). Electrode placement and duration of each patient's recording were determined solely based on clinical needs. The
number of electrodes ranged from 82 to 106, arranged as grids of 8×8, 8×4, 8×2 or strips of 1×4, 1×6, 1×8. Figs. S5 -- S9
show the electrode placements of each subject. ECoG was acquired at a sampling rate of 999Hz. All patients had between
six and fourteen days of continuous monitoring with video, audio, and ECoG recordings. During days 1 and 2, patients were
generally recovering from surgery and spent most of their time sleeping; in this study, days 3 to 6 post implant were analyzed
from each subject.
Video and audio recordings
Video and audio were recorded simultaneously with the ECoG signals and continuously throughout the subjects' clinical
monitoring. The video was recorded at 30 frames per second at a resolution of 640×480 pixels. Generally, video was
centered on the subject with family members or staff occasionally entering the scene. The camera was also sometimes adjusted
throughout the day by hospital staff; for instance, the camera may be centered away during bed pan changes and returned
to the patient afterwards. Videos S1 -- S4 show examples of the video at a few different times of one day. The audio signal
was recorded at 48 KHz in stereo. The subject's conversations with people in the hospital room, including people not visible
by video monitoring, can be clearly heard, as well as sound from the television or a music player. Some subjects listened to
audio using headphones, which were not available to our audio monitoring system. For patient privacy, because voices can be
identifiable, we do not make examples of the audio data available in the supplemental materials.
Manual annotation of video and audio
To generate a set of ground-truth labels so that we may assess the performance of our automated algorithms, we performed
manual annotation of behavior aided by ANVIL 61 on a small subset of the external monitoring data. Two students were
responsible for the annotations, and at least 40 minutes (or 2.78%) of each subject day's recording was manually labeled for
a variety of salient behaviors, including the broad categories of movement, speech and rest. Manual labeling was done for
2-minute segments of video and audio, distributed randomly throughout each 24-hour day. For patient privacy, some small parts
of the video (e.g., during bed pan changes) were excluded from manual labeling. These periods were very brief and should not
introduce a generalized bias in manual labels. On average, manual labeling of 1 min of monitoring data was accomplished in
approximately 5 minutes. At least 10 minutes of each subject day were labeled by both students; agreement between the two
labelers was 92.0%, and Cohen's Kappa value for inter-rater agreement is 0.82.
Automated movement and speech detection
For automated video analysis, we first detected salient features for each frame using Speeded Up Robust Features (SURF),
which detects and encodes interesting feature points throughout the frame. The amount of motion in each frame was determined
by matching the magnitude of change in these feature points across successive frames. Since the subject was the only person in
the frame a majority of the time, we are able to determine the subject's approximate movement levels. This approach detected
gross motor movements of the arms, torso and head, as well as some finer movements of the face and mouth during speaking.
To detect speech, we measured the power of human speech frequency levels (100 -- 3500Hz) from audio data.
We assessed the performance of the automated algorithms by comparison to manual annotations. The manual annotations
for each behavior were binary (i.e., either the behavior was present or not in a time window) whereas the automated speech
and movement levels were analog values. Therefore, the agreement was computed after applying a threshold to the automated
movement and speech levels.
ECoG preprocessing and feature extraction
All ECoG recording was bandpassed filtered between 0.1 and 160Hz to reduced noise. The filtered signal was then converted
into a set of power spectral features using short-time Fourier transform using non-overlapping two-second windows. Each
24-hour recording was thus separated into 43200 samples in time.
8/14
Figure 7. A schematic of the hierarchical clustering and annotation method. Features extracted from ECoG recordings of each
subject day were recursively clustered and agglomerated at increasing levels. Annotation consisted of finding the cluster within
each level whose time course had the highest correlation with automatically extracted movement and speech levels. For
illustration purposes, here we show the annotation of clusters at Level 2, which has 4 total clusters.
Because subjects engaged in a variety of activities throughout the day, there is no particular frequency band that would be
solely useful for clustering. We considered power at a range of frequencies between 1 -- 52 Hz for each electrode, binning every
1.5 Hz of power for a total of 35 features per electrode per two-second window. At 82 to 106 electrodes per subject, this process
resulted in 2870 to 3710 features for each two-second window of recording. To normalize the data, we transformed the binned
powers levels at each frequency bin for each channel by computing the Z-Score. The dimensionality of the feature space was
then reduced with principal component analysis (PCA), and the cumulative fraction of variance explained as a function of the
number of PCA modes for each subject day is shown in Fig. S1. These spectra were highly variable, both within and between
subjects. For purposes of unsupervised clustering, we truncated all feature space to the first 50 PC's. The first 50 PC's generally
accounted for at least 40% of the variance in daily power spectral features space.
Hierarchical clustering of ECoG features
We used the 50-dimensional principal component power spectral features of the ECoG data as features for our hierarchical
k-means clustering. The hierarchical k-means procedure and the annotation of clusters by correlation with movement and
speech levels is shown schematically in Fig. 7. For each subject on each day, we first perform k-means with k = 20 clusters.
Next, we segregate the data points into the single cluster with the most number of data points and all the rest of the clusters.
This procedure produces the first level of the hierarchical clustering, which now has two clusters. Next, for level L of the
clustering, this procedure is repeated for each cluster from level L− 1 using k = 20/L (k floored to the largest previous integer).
Again, the single cluster with the most number of data points is separated from the rest of the clusters, so that at level L, we end
up with 2L clusters. This process of recursive k-means clustering and aggregation is stopped when there are fewer than 100 data
points in each cluster, or when L = 10. In this manuscript, we focused on analyzing annotated clusters in levels 1 -- 4.
Automated annotation of clusters using video and audio recordings
Results from the clustering analysis were automatically annotated using movement and speech levels. Each type of unsupervised
analysis produced time series at different temporal resolutions, so they were all first consolidated into a mean analog value
for non-overlapping 16-second windows. For ECoG, we counted how many 2-second windows within each 16-seconds were
assigned to a particular cluster at the target hierarchy level. For movement and speech detection, we considered what fraction of
9/14
ECoG recordingsover one subject dayLevel 1Level 2Level 3largest clusterall other clustersLevel L…RestMovementSpeech………… the 16-second window exceeded a threshold value. These thresholds were determined empirically.
After consolidation into windows of 16 seconds, we computed the Pearson r correlation between each of the ECoG clusters
with the movement and speech levels. The "movement" and "speech" labels were assigned to clusters for which the correlation
was the highest for each behavior. If movement and speech both correlated best with the same cluster, the label was assigned to
the second best cluster for the activity type that had a lower correlation. The "rest" label was assigned to the cluster with the
largest negative correlation with both movement and speech.
We performed this annotation assignment for clustering levels 1 -- 4 (see Fig. 7). At level 1, for which there were only 2 total
clusters, labels were simplified to be "rest" and "non-rest" (for movement and speech combined). Level 3, where there are 8
total clusters, appeared to be the most parsimonious level of granularity for the number of categories available automatically.
Validation with ground truth labels
Ground truth labels for random portions of each day were obtained from two students who hand annotated a small random
fraction of each subject day (about 40 minutes, or 3% of each day) for visible and audible behaviors. The hand annotations
were distributed randomly throughout each day of each patient. The automated results were compared to manual labels using
16 second windows within the manually annotated times. Each 16 second window is determined to contain an activity if the
activity is annotated within any point in the window. Since different clusters have different baseline levels, we determined that
the cluster detects the activity if its level is at or above the 25th percentile over the day. Using the manual labels as ground truth,
accuracy and F1 scores were computed. The F1 score is the harmonic mean of precision and recall.
To determine the statistical significance of the F1 scores compared to chance, we generated shuffled labels by changing the
timing of the ground truth labels of each activity, without changing their overall relative frequency. This shuffling was repeated
over 1000 random iterations to determine the distribution of F1 scores assuming chance, and the true F1 score was compared
against these shuffled F1 scores. We report the percentile of the true F1 scores for all subject days.
Mapping annotated clusters back to the brain
For each annotated cluster, we projected the centroid values of the cluster back to brain coordinates. The centroids values
are 50-dimensional vectors in PCA space, reduced from power spectral features of all recording electrodes. The inverse
PCA transform using the original PCA basis projects the centroid back to brain coordinates, where the relative power in each
frequency bin is available at each electrode. Note that because of the Z-Score normalization step before computing the original
PCA basis, this back-projection reproduces Z-Score values, not voltages. These Z-Scores can be separately averaged according
to frequency bins of interesting bands, including a low frequency band (LFB, 1 -- 8 Hz) and a high-frequency band (HBG,
12 -- 45 Hz) as show in Fig. 6. Fig. S5 -- S8 also show results of brain maps at 72 -- 100Hz. Anatomic reconstruction of electrode
coordinates on structural imaging of subjects' brains was available for only four of the six subjects, so we were unable to
perform this mapping for Subject 2 and Subject 6.
References
1. Wolpaw, J. & Wolpaw, E. W. Brain-computer interfaces: principles and practice (London: Oxford University Press, 2012).
2. Rao, R. P. N. Brain-computer interfacing: an introduction (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2013).
3. Vinje, W. & Gallant, J. Sparse coding and decorrelation in primary visual cortex during natural vision. Science (2000).
URL http://www.sciencemag.org/content/287/5456/1273.short.
4. Felsen, G. & Dan, Y. A natural approach to studying vision. Nature Neuroscience 8, 1643 -- 6 (2005). URL http:
//dx.doi.org/10.1038/nn1608.
5. Jackson, A., Mavoori, J. & Fetz, E. Correlations between the same motor cortex cells and arm muscles during a
trained task, free behavior, and natural sleep in the macaque monkey. Journal of Neurophysiology (2007). URL
http://jn.physiology.org/content/97/1/360.short.
6. Derix, J., Iljina, O., Schulze-Bonhage, A., Aertsen, A. & Ball, T. "Doctor" or "darling"? decoding the communication
partner from ecog of the anterior temporal lobe during non-experimental, real-life social interaction. Frontiers in Human
Neuroscience 251.
7. Pistohl, T., Schulze-Bonhage, A. & Aertsen, A. Decoding natural grasp types from human ECoG. Neuroimage (2012).
URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S105381191100749X.
8. Ruescher, J. et al. Somatotopic mapping of natural upper- and lower-extremity movements and speech production with
high gamma electrocorticography. NeuroImage 81, 164 -- 77 (2013). URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/
science/article/pii/S1053811913004618.
10/14
9. Hill, N., Gupta, D. & Brunner, P. Recording human electrocorticographic (ECoG) signals for neuroscientific research and
real-time functional cortical mapping. Journal of Visualized Experiments (2012). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.
gov/pmc/articles/PMC3471287/.
10. Moran, D. Evolution of brain-computer interface: action potentials, local field potentials and electrocorticograms. Current
opinion in neurobiology 20, 741 -- 5 (2010). URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/
S0959438810001789.
11. Williams, J. & Hippensteel, J. Complex impedance spectroscopy for monitoring tissue responses to inserted neural implants.
Journal of Neural Engineering (2007). URL http://iopscience.iop.org/1741-2552/4/4/007.
12. Lal, T. et al. Methods Towards Invasive Human Brain Computer Interfaces.
In Eighteenth Annual Conference on
Neural Information Processing Systems (NIPS 2004), 737 -- 744 (MIT Press). URL http://pubman.mpdl.mpg.de/
pubman/faces/viewItemOverviewPage.jsp?itemId=escidoc:1791436:1.
13. Ball, T., Kern, M., Mutschler, I., Aertsen, A. & Schulze-Bonhage, A. Signal quality of simultaneously recorded invasive
and non-invasive EEG. NeuroImage 46, 708 -- 16 (2009). URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/
article/pii/S1053811909001827.
14. Nakanishi, Y. et al. Prediction of three-dimensional arm trajectories based on ECoG signals recorded from human
sensorimotor cortex. PloS one 8, e72085 (2013). URL http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=
10.1371/journal.pone.0072085.
15. Wang, Z. et al. Decoding onset and direction of movements using Electrocorticographic (ECoG) signals in humans.
Frontiers in Neuroengineering 5, 15 (2012). URL http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.
fcgi?artid=3413946&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract.
16. Wang, P. T. et al. State and trajectory decoding of upper extremity movements from electrocorticogram.
In 2013
6th International IEEE/EMBS Conference on Neural Engineering (NER), 969 -- 972 (IEEE, 2013). URL http://
ieeexplore.ieee.org/lpdocs/epic03/wrapper.htm?arnumber=6696097.
17. Miller, K. J., Zanos, S., Fetz, E. E., den Nijs, M. & Ojemann, J. G. Decoupling the cortical power spectrum reveals
real-time representation of individual finger movements in humans. The Journal of Neuroscience 29, 3132 -- 7 (2009). URL
http://www.jneurosci.org/content/29/10/3132.abstract.
18. Wang, Z., Ji, Q., Miller, K. J. & Schalk, G. Decoding Finger Flexion from Electrocorticographic Signals Using a Sparse
In 2010 20th International Conference on Pattern Recognition, 3756 -- 3759 (IEEE, 2010). URL
Gaussian Process.
http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/lpdocs/epic03/wrapper.htm?arnumber=5597572.
19. McMullen, D. P. et al. Demonstration of a semi-autonomous hybrid brain-machine interface using human intracranial
IEEE Transactions on Neural
EEG, eye tracking, and computer vision to control a robotic upper limb prosthetic.
Systems and Rehabilitation Engineering 22, 784 -- 96 (2014). URL http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/
articlerender.fcgi?artid=4057363&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract.
20. Yanagisawa, T. et al. Real-time control of a prosthetic hand using human electrocorticography signals. Journal of
Neurosurgery 114, 1715 -- 22 (2011). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21314273.
21. Fifer, M. S. et al.
Simultaneous neural control of simple reaching and grasping with the modular prosthetic
IEEE transactions on neural systems and rehabilitation engineering 22, 695 -- 705
limb using intracranial EEG.
(2014). URL http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=4030429&tool=
pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract.
22. Wang, W. et al. An electrocorticographic brain interface in an individual with tetraplegia. PloS One 8, e55344 (2013).
URL http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0055344.
23. Leuthardt, E. C. et al. Using the electrocorticographic speech network to control a brain-computer interface in humans. Jour-
nal of Neural Engineering 8, 036004 (2011). URL http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.
fcgi?artid=3701859&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract.
24. Leuthardt, E., Miller, K., Schalk, G., Rao, R. & Ojemann, J. Electrocorticography-Based Brain Computer Interface -- The
Seattle Experience. IEEE Transactions on Neural Systems and Rehabilitation Engineering 14, 194 -- 198 (2006). URL
http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/lpdocs/epic03/wrapper.htm?arnumber=1642767.
25. Miller, K. J. et al. Cortical activity during motor execution, motor imagery, and imagery-based online feedback. Proceedings
of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 107, 4430 -- 5 (2010). URL http://www.pnas.
org/content/107/9/4430.short.
11/14
26. Schalk, G. et al. Two-dimensional movement control using electrocorticographic signals in humans. Journal of Neural En-
gineering 5, 75 -- 84 (2008). URL http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=
2744037&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract.
27. Vansteensel, M. J. et al. Brain -- computer interfacing based on cognitive control. Annals of neurology 67, 809 -- 816 (2010).
28. Kanas, V. G. et al. Real-time voice activity detection for ECoG-based speech brain machine interfaces. In 2014 19th
International Conference on Digital Signal Processing, 862 -- 865 (IEEE, 2014). URL http://ieeexplore.ieee.
org/lpdocs/epic03/wrapper.htm?arnumber=6900790.
29. Blakely, T., Miller, K. J., Rao, R. P., Holmes, M. D. & Ojemann, J. G. Localization and classification of phonemes using
high spatial resolution electrocorticography (ECoG) grids. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc. 4964 -- 7 (2008). URL
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19163831.
30. Kanas, V. G. et al. Joint spatial-spectral feature space clustering for speech activity detection from ECoG signals. IEEE
Transactions on Bio-medical Engineering 61, 1241 -- 50 (2014). URL http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/
articlerender.fcgi?artid=4005607&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract.
31. Mugler, E. M. et al. Direct classification of all American English phonemes using signals from functional speech motor
cortex. Journal of Neural Engineering 11, 035015 (2014). URL http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.
1088/1741-2560/11/3/035015.
32. Pei, X., Barbour, D. L., Leuthardt, E. C. & Schalk, G. Decoding vowels and consonants in spoken and
Journal of Neural Engineering 8, 046028
imagined words using electrocorticographic signals in humans.
(2011). URL http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=3772685&tool=
pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract.
33. Kellis, S. et al. Decoding spoken words using local field potentials recorded from the cortical surface. Journal of Neu-
ral Engineering 7, 056007 (2010). URL http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?
artid=2970568&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract.
34. Zhang, D. et al. Spoken sentences decoding based on intracranial high gamma response using dynamic time warping.
Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society 2012, 3292 -- 5 (2012). URL
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23366629.
35. Herff, C. et al. Brain-to-text: decoding spoken phrases from phone representations in the brain. Frontiers in Neuro-
science 9 (2015). URL http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fnins.2015.00217/
abstract.
36. Zander, T. O. & Kothe, C. Towards passive brain-computer interfaces: applying brain-computer interface technology to
human-machine systems in general. Journal of Neural Engineering 8, 025005 (2011). URL http://iopscience.
iop.org/article/10.1088/1741-2560/8/2/025005.
37. Muller-Putz, G. et al. Towards noninvasive hybrid brain -- computer interfaces: Framework, practice, clinical application,
and beyond (2015).
38. Derix, J. et al. From speech to thought: the neuronal basis of cognitive units in non-experimental, real-life communication
investigated using ECoG. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 8, 383 (2014). URL http://www.pubmedcentral.
nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=4056309&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract.
39. Dastjerdi, M., Ozker, M., Foster, B. L., Rangarajan, V. & Parvizi, J. Numerical processing in the human
Nature Communications 4, 2528 (2013). URL
parietal cortex during experimental and natural conditions.
http://www.nature.com/ncomms/2013/131015/ncomms3528/full/ncomms3528.html?utm_
content=buffer4b47c&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer.
40. Langkvist, M., Karlsson, L. & Loutfi, A. Sleep stage classification using unsupervised feature learning. Advances in
Artificial Neural Systems (2012). URL http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=2387786.
41. Pluta, T., Bernardo, R., Shin, H. W. & Bernardo, D. R. Unsupervised learning of electrocorticography motifs with
binary descriptors of wavelet features and hierarchical clustering. Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineer-
ing in Medicine and Biology Society 2014, 2657 -- 60 (2014). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/
25570537.
42. Jordan, M. I. & Mitchell, T. M. Machine learning: Trends, perspectives, and prospects. Science 349, 255 -- 260 (2015).
URL http://www.sciencemag.org/content/349/6245/255.full.
12/14
43. Huang, X., Baker, J. & Reddy, R. A historical perspective of speech recognition. Communications of the ACM 57, 94 -- 103
(2014). URL http://dl.acm.org/ft_gateway.cfm?id=2500887&type=html.
44. Wang, N., Cullis-Suzuki, S. & Albu, A. Automated Analysis of Wild Fish Behavior in a Natural Habitat. Environmental
Multimedia Retrieval at ICMR (2015). URL http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=2764875.
45. Poppe, R. Vision-based human motion analysis: An overview. Computer Vision and Image Understanding 108, 4 -- 18
(2007). URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1077314206002293.
46. Toshev, A. & Szegedy, C. DeepPose: Human Pose Estimation via Deep Neural Networks. In 2014 IEEE Conference
on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, 1653 -- 1660 (IEEE, 2014). URL http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/
lpdocs/epic03/wrapper.htm?arnumber=6909610.
47. Girshick, R., Donahue, J., Darrell, T. & Malik, J. Rich Feature Hierarchies for Accurate Object Detection and Semantic
Segmentation. In 2014 IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, 580 -- 587 (IEEE, 2014). URL
http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/lpdocs/epic03/wrapper.htm?arnumber=6909475.
48. Erhan, D., Szegedy, C., Toshev, A. & Anguelov, D. Scalable Object Detection Using Deep Neural Networks. In 2014
IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, 2155 -- 2162 (IEEE, 2014). URL http://ieeexplore.
ieee.org/lpdocs/epic03/wrapper.htm?arnumber=6909673.
49. Karpathy, A. et al. Large-Scale Video Classification with Convolutional Neural Networks. In 2014 IEEE Conference
on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, 1725 -- 1732 (IEEE, 2014). URL http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/
lpdocs/epic03/wrapper.htm?arnumber=6909619.
50. Ryoo, M. S. & Matthies, L. First-Person Activity Recognition: What Are They Doing to Me? In 2013 IEEE Conference
on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, 2730 -- 2737 (IEEE, 2013). URL http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/
lpdocs/epic03/wrapper.htm?arnumber=6619196.
51. He, K., Zhang, X., Ren, S. & Sun, J. Delving Deep into Rectifiers: Surpassing Human-Level Performance on ImageNet
Classification (2015). URL http://arxiv.org/abs/1502.01852. 1502.01852.
52. Ramıirez, J., Segura, J. C., Benitez, C., de la Torre, A. & Rubio, A. Efficient voice activity detection algorithms using
long-term speech information. Speech Communication 42, 271 -- 287 (2004). URL http://linkinghub.elsevier.
com/retrieve/pii/S0167639303001201.
53. Miller, K. J. et al. Real-time functional brain mapping using electrocorticography. Neuroimage 37, 504 -- 507 (2007).
54. Potes, C., Brunner, P., Gunduz, A., Knight, R. T. & Schalk, G. Spatial and temporal relationships of electrocor-
ticographic alpha and gamma activity during auditory processing. Neuroimage 97, 188 -- 195 (2014). URL http:
//www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1053811914003140.
55. Chang, E. F. et al. Categorical speech representation in human superior temporal gyrus. Nature Neuroscience 13,
1428 -- 1432 (2010). URL http://www.nature.com/neuro/journal/v13/n11/full/nn.2641.html.
56. Cajochen, C., Foy, R. & Dijk, D.-J. Frontal predominance of a relative increase in sleep delta and theta eeg activity after sleep
loss in humans. Sleep Res Online 2, 65 -- 69 (1999). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11382884.
57. Brunton, B. W., Johnson, L. A., Ojemann, J. G. & Kutz, J. N. Extracting spatial-temporal coherent patterns in large-
scale neural recordings using dynamic mode decomposition. Journal of Neuroscience Methods (2015). URL http:
//arxiv.org/abs/1409.5496.
58. Mercier, M. R. et al. Neuro-oscillatory phase alignment drives speeded multisensory response times: An electro-
corticographic investigation. The Journal of Neuroscience 35, 8546 -- 8557 (2015). URL http://www.jneurosci.
org/content/35/22/8546.abstract.
59. Vansteensel, M. et al. Task-free electrocorticography frequency mapping of the motor cortex. Clinical Neu-
rophysiology 124, 1169 -- 1174 (2013). URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/
S1388245712008115.
60. Breshears, J. D. et al. Mapping sensorimotor cortex using slow cortical potential resting-state networks while awake
and under anesthesia. Neurosurgery 71, 305 (2012). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/
PMC4362698/.
61. Kipp, M. Anvil: A universal video research tool. handbook of corpus phonology (2012).
13/14
Acknowledgments
We thank Ryan Shean and Sharon Ke for annotating the videos and audio recordings for ground truth labels. We also thank the
staff and doctors at Harborview Medical Center, in particular Julie Rae, Shahin Hakimian and Jeffery Tsai for aiding in data
collection as well as research discussions. James Wu contributed to brain reconstructions. We thank Ali Farhadi for giving
advice on the computer vision based video processing and Lise Johnson for discussions about unsupervised clustering.
Funding. This research was support by the Washington Research Foundation (WRF), the National Institutes of Health
(NIH) grants NS065186, 2K12HD001097-16 and 5U10NS086525-03, and award EEC-1028725 from the National Science
Foundation (NSF).
Author contributions statement
N.W. conceived the experiments with the help of J.D.O., J.G.O.; N.W. and R.R. conducted the experiment; N.W., R.R., and B.B.
performed the analysis and wrote the manuscript, with input from all authors.
Additional information
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
14/14
|
1903.02147 | 1 | 1903 | 2019-03-06T02:52:59 | NeuroPath2Path: Classification and elastic morphing between neuronal arbors using path-wise similarity | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | The shape and connectivity of a neuron determine its function. Modern imaging methods have proven successful at extracting such information. However, in order to analyze this type of data, neuronal morphology needs to be encoded in a graph-theoretic method. This encoding enables the use of high throughput informatic methods to extract and infer brain function. The application of graph-theoretic methods to neuronal morphological representation comes with certain difficulties. Here we report a novel, effective method to accomplish this task.
The morphology of a neuron, which consists of its overall size, global shape, local branch patterns, and cell-specific biophysical properties, can vary significantly with the cell's identity, location, as well as developmental and physiological state. Various algorithms have been developed to customize shape based statistical and graph related features for quantitative analysis of neuromorphology, followed by the classification of neuron cell types using the features. Unlike the classical feature extraction based methods from imaged or 3D reconstructed neurons, we propose a model based on the rooted path decomposition from the soma to the dendrites of a neuron and extract morphological features on each path. We hypothesize that measuring the distance between two neurons can be realized by minimizing the cost of continuously morphing the set of all rooted paths of one neuron to another. To validate this claim, we first establish the correspondence of paths between two neurons using a modified Munkres algorithm. Next, an elastic deformation framework that employs the square root velocity function is established to perform the continuous morphing, which, in addition, provides an effective visualization tool. We experimentally show the efficacy of NeuroPath2Path, NeuroP2P, over the state of the art. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Noname manuscript No.
(will be inserted by the editor)
NeuroPath2Path: Classification and elastic morphing between
neuronal arbors using path-wise similarity
Tamal Batabyal · Barry Condron · Scott T. Acton
9
1
0
2
r
a
M
6
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
7
4
1
2
0
.
3
0
9
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
Received: date / Accepted: date
Abstract The shape and connectivity of a neuron de-
termine its function. Modern imaging methods have
proven successful at extracting such information. How-
ever, in order to analyze this type of data, neuronal
morphology needs to be encoded in a graph-theoretic
method. This encoding enables the use of high through-
put informatic methods to extract and infer brain func-
tion. The application of graph-theoretic methods to neu-
ronal morphological representation comes with certain
difficulties. Here we report a novel, effective method to
accomplish this task.
The morphology of a neuron, which consists of its
overall size, global shape, local branch patterns, and
cell-specific biophysical properties, can vary significantly
with the cell's identity, location, as well as develop-
mental and physiological state. Various algorithms have
been developed to customize shape based statistical and
graph related features for quantitative analysis of neu-
romorphology, followed by the classification of neuron
cell types using the features. Unlike the classical fea-
ture extraction based methods from imaged or 3D re-
constructed neurons, we propose a model based on the
rooted path decomposition from the soma to the den-
drites of a neuron and extract morphological features on
Tamal Batabyal
Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering
University of Virginia
Tel.: +1 4344665486
E-mail: [email protected]
Barry Condron
Department of Biology
University of Virginia
Scott T. Acton
Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering
Department of Biomedical Engineering
University of Virginia
each path. We hypothesize that measuring the distance
between two neurons can be realized by minimizing the
cost of continuously morphing the set of all rooted paths
of one neuron to another. To validate this claim, we
first establish the correspondence of paths between two
neurons using a modified Munkres algorithm. Next, an
elastic deformation framework that employs the square
root velocity function is established to perform the con-
tinuous morphing, which, in addition, provides an ef-
fective visualization tool. We experimentally show the
efficacy of NeuroPath2Path, NeuroP2P, over the state
of the art.
Keywords Neuron morphology · Assignment algo-
rithm · Elastic morphing · Tree matching · Shape
classification · Biomedical image analysis.
1 Introduction
Neurons process information by transmitting electri-
cal signals via complex circuitry. The functionality of
each neuron depends on a set of intrinsic factors, such
as morphology, ionic channel density, gene expression,
including the extrinsic ones, such as connectivity to
other neurons [1, 8]. In 1899, Cajal [9], considered the
founder of modern neuroscience, put forward his pio-
neering work on neuroanatomy with detailed, accurate,
and meticulous illustrations, and posited that the shape
of a neuron determines its functionality. Experimen-
tal results strongly support this idea. Inspired by this
fundamental work, the study of neuromorphology pri-
marily aims at analyzing and quantifying the complex
shape and physiology of neurons in specific functional
regions to identify relationships.
Neurons vary significantly in size, shape, and length.
A major obstacle towards understanding the brain is
2
Tamal Batabyal et al.
(a)
(c)
(e)
(b)
(d)
(f)
Fig. 1 Pyramidal neurons from (a) primary motor cortex, (b) secondary motor cortex, (c) prefrontal cortex, (d) somatosensory
cortex, (e) primary visual cortex, and (f) secondary visual cortex of the mouse. The dendritic branches in yellow are apical
dendrites, and in green are basal dendrites. The red square in each cell is the soma, used as the designated root node in our
analysis. This figure provides a glimpse of region-based arborial differences among pyramidal cells. Cells differ in size and
volume, which are scaled for visualization.
the development of efficient ways to encode these shapes.
The anatomical and geometrical features of neurons of
any cell-type, for example, pyramidal cells differ based
on the regions in which the cells reside [7, 8]. Fig. 1
shows regional variation in the structure and geometry
of dendritic arbors of pyramidal cells [31]. It is observed
that the number of branches, length, surface area, and
volume of apical dendrites is 4 − 9 times larger for hip-
pocampal than for cortical regions, whereas in terms of
the same features of basal dendritic arbors, it is ap-
proximately 3 times [8]. Another source of variation
stems from technical imprecision in measurements ob-
tained while performing 3D reconstruction from image
stacks using software tracing tools, such as Neurolu-
cida [16]. Noise due to technical imprecision includes
wide variations in the number of manually or semi-
automatically traced 3D locations (approximately be-
tween 60 to 70, 000), the number of ramified branches
and bifurcations by different tracers, and deletion of
dendritic spines adversely affect the registration of neu-
rons, and thereby induce error in morphological feature
quantification. The skeletons of dendritic and axonal
branches form a tree topology with a number of bifur-
cations. The bifurcations at successive stages help in
a series of effective and unambiguous signal process-
ing modules, such as active and passive signal propa-
gation, integration, filter, attenuation, oscillation, and
backpropagation [1, 21].
From the soma to the dendritic terminals of a neu-
ron, the diameter of the dendritic shaft tapers [18, 40].
The increased diameter of a dendritic shaft near the
soma is tailored to faster signal propagation to the soma
compared to the dendritic tuft , which helps generate
action potential in the soma. Several research works
consider the branches in the proximity of soma are more
important compared to the distant dendritic tuft and
spines in the analysis of neuromorphology [10, 19, 22].
The length of dendritic branch segments shows simi-
lar behavior when propagating away from soma. For
instance, the terminal segments are longer than the in-
termediate branch segments for basal dendrites in cor-
tical pyramidal cells [7]. These observations support the
Bayesian philosophy which is geared towards the anal-
ysis of morphogenesis of neurons [22]. Functions such
as synaptic boosting [24], coadaptive local spiking [12],
and global spike amplification [41] suggest the use of
other morphometrics to describe the structural aspects
on the functions. For example, packing density of ram-
ified branches and bifurcations of neuron potentially
trigger intermittently co-adpative spiking.
The tree-type arbors of neurons and the availabil-
ity of the inventory of digitally-traced 3D reconstructed
neurons, Neuromorpho [2], provided significant momen-
NeuroPath2Path: Classification and elastic morphing between neuronal arbors using path-wise similarity
3
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
Fig. 2 (a) A retinal ganglion cell from the inner plexiform layer of a 9 month-old adult mouse. The 3D reconstructed cell has
3938 3D locations, 50 bifurcations, 106 branches, 56 rooted paths, 255.52µm height, 4499.5µm diameter, 9061.14µm3 volume,
18, 213.9µm2 surface area. (b) A 3D reconstructed (traced by Neuromantic [28]) pyramidal cell of an adult mouse having 24, 868
3D locations, 95 bifurcations, 200 branches, 106 tips, 814.05µm height, 16341.8µm diameter, 12569µm3 volume, 24, 825.9µm2
surface area. (c) A hippocampal granule cell (in the dentate gyrus) of a 9 month-old mouse is traced using Neurolucida.
The 3D reconstructed neuron contains 414 3D locations with 7 bifurcations, 15 branches, 14 rooted paths, 98.33µm height,
443.18µm diameter, 3107.27µm3 volume, and 3255.33µm2 surface area. (d) A Purkinje cell in cerebellar cortex of a 28 day-old
mouse. The reconstruction is performed by Neurolucida, containing 3187 3D locations. The neuron has 391 bifurcations, 783
branches, 393 tips, 184.35µm height, 4366.24µm diameter, 12, 794.7µm3 volume, and 31, 574.8µm2 surface area. (e) A motor
cell in the spinal cord of a 10 day-old mouse, which is reconstructed with 5868 locations using Neurolucida tracer. The 3D
traced neuron has 47 bifurcations, 103 branches, 58 tips, 415.6µm height, 784.158µm diameter, 4006.15µm3 volume, and
11, 931.8µm2 surface area. (f) A long-axon projection neuron from the thalamus of a 6 months old mouse - it is traced by
Large Volume Viewer(LVV) [27] with 2818 3D locations. The traced neuron has 169 bifurcations, 265 branches, 2731.69µm
height, 55, 742.44µm3 volume and 189979µm2 surface area. The color code is the following: yellow=apical dendrites, green =
basal dendrites, magenta = axons, red = cell body/soma/root. The quantified statistics on the number of bifurcations and
tips or rooted paths that are mentioned above are extracted from dendritic arbors of each cell-type.
tum in the last decade for the quantitative and qualita-
tive assessment of neuroanatomy via graph-based mor-
phometrics. In Neuromorpho, the sequentially-aligned
slices of microscopic images are registered and traced
using software [23], such as Neurolucida [16] and Neu-
romantic [28], and the reconstructed images can then be
processed through software, such as L-measure [34] to
extract an extensive list of morphological metrics. On
one hand, there are several research works dedicated
to analyze the neuromorphology of specific cell types,
such as basal dendrites of cortical pyramidal cells [7,
22], GABAergic interneuron cells [1] and others. These
works account for region-specific variations in the phys-
iology and anatomy of a neuron cell to establish the ef-
fect of certain functions on the structure. On the other
hand, research efforts, such as blastneuron [39], neu-
rosol [4],and TMD [19], attempt to extract model based
features, which are catered to the need for automated
classification of different neuronal cells. The motivation
behind this avenue of research is that it is impossible
to identify and categorize one trillion neuronal cells by
adopting manual or even semi-automatic methods.
State-of-the-art methods [6,39] for the classification
of neurons can be broadly divided in two categories.
Research in the f irst category, which is supervised in
nature, employs different feature extraction algorithms
followed by suitable classifiers to obtain classification
accuracy in percentage. The validation of the methods
are performed by adopting a series of statistical tests.
However, the significant variation in the neuron skele-
tons precludes the selection of the optimal set of mor-
phometrics as features. Adoption of feature transfor-
mations, such as principal component analysis (PCA)
or kernel transformations, may improve the classifica-
tion accuracy. Nevertheless, these transformations ob-
scures the identity of discriminating features as the
transformed space is formed by linear or nonlinear com-
position of extracted features. In addition, the classifi-
cation accuracy of categorization does not quite explain
4
Tamal Batabyal et al.
the physiological and structural differences between two
neurons.
The second category follows mostly unsupervised
approaches and attempts to compute pairwise distances
between neurons. Authors in [33] used Fourier based
shape descriptors to encode the global shape of a neu-
ron, which however ignored the local features of the
neuron arbor. Gillette [14, 15] performed a sequence
alignment based algorithm for categorization by decom-
posing a neuron into a sequence of branches. The ap-
proach failed to consider geometric features. Blastneu-
ron [39] adopted a mixed strategy. Using a supervised
approach, the method first extracted 21 global mor-
phological features and 13 moment invariant features
to retrieve a set of targets that closely matches to each
test neuron in terms of the anatomical structures. Each
target is then RANSAC sampled [11] and aligned op-
timally to the test neuron, which outputs a distance
value. This unsupervised routine decides the output
category of the test neuron based on the minimum dis-
tance criteria. The method involved initial pruning of
branches and resampling of each neuron, which collec-
tively alters the morphology statistics. Moreover, the
retrieval accuracy of 233 projected neurons (PN) of
Drosophila drops significantly to 39% as the number of
potential candidates that are to be compared with the
target increases. NeuroSoL [4] offered a graph-theoretic
method which is free from registration and resampling.
In spite of its appeal of using graph theory, the ma-
trix alignment routine is NP-hard in nature, thereby
producing suboptimal results. The problem of compar-
ing a pair of neuron topologies can also be regarded as
a graph kernel based similarity measure problem [38].
However, the rationale behind conventional graph ker-
nels, such as the random walk kernel may be inconsis-
tent with the morphological understanding of a neuron.
Instead of modeling a neuron as a generic graph,
the neuron can be modeled as a specialized graph that
contains a collection of rooted paths, where each path
starts from the soma, called the root node, and ends
up in a dendritic terminal. It is important to note that
each path acts like an atomic neuron, as it contains the
soma and a dendritic end to complete a circuit. Most of
the synapses along a path will be nearer the soma than
at the end of the path. It is convenient to think prob-
lems, such as synaptic plasticity as the evolution of a set
of synapses over time along all the paths. During this
evolution, there are birth, death and rearrangement of
paths. Following the same logic, quantifying the prob-
lem of distinguishing two neurons can be equivalently
mapped as finding the cost of evolving a set of circuits
optimally from one neuron to the other.
Another relevant fact is that path based models [3,
5, 19] integrate both global (overall shape based ap-
proach) and local (vertex or sampled location based ap-
proach) features of neuron topology. Topological mor-
phology descriptor (TMD) [19] aimed at solving the
categorization problem, encoded the birth and death of
path segments over time in a persistence diagram used
as a barcode. The authors showed that TMD exhibits
robustness to erroneous 3D sampling and ambiguous
branching when the neuron is reconstructed using two
different tracing tools. However, the conversion of a dis-
crete 3D reconstructed neuron to the persistence image
space is irreversible and many-to-one. Based on the dis-
tance used to mark and quantify the birth and death
of a branch or component of the neuronal tree, a single
persistence image may correspond to multiple neurons.
In addition, an appropriate distance measure between
persistence diagrams is still unavailable. The work in
Path2Path [3] shows potential to address the neuron
cell categorization problem and can be extended to sev-
eral other related problems, such as synaptogenesis, de-
generation of neurons due to neurological diseases, and
synaptic plasticity which can be studied by inspecting
the path statistics. The work described in this article is
motivated by the framework of Path2Path.
1.1 What is Path2Path and its variants?
The principle of Path2Path is based on finding the opti-
mal correspondence between the paths of one neuron to
that of the other using a proposed metric. It is an intu-
itive circuit-based approach that appeals to its electri-
cal engineering inventors. In Path2Path, each sampled
location on a path is endowed with 3D coordinate val-
ues and two features, concurrence and hierarchy. The
concurrence value at each location denotes the num-
ber of paths from the soma to dendritic ends that visit
that node. The hierarchy value at a location indicates
the depth of the location from the soma in terms of the
number of bifurcations between the point and the soma.
The hierarchy value of a location counts the number
of bifurcations one has to cross while traversing from
the soma to that location. Using the 3D coordinates,
concurrence, and hierarchy values of each location on a
path, authors in Path2Path proposed an empirical met-
ric that outputs a distance value between two paths. A
path from a neuron corresponds to a path from another
neuron if the distance between the paths is minimum
over all the paths of the latter neuron.
This approach has several drawbacks. The Path2Path
algorithm is dependent on the number of sampled lo-
cations of each path and the registration. The selec-
tion of the metric is arbitrary in a sense that the met-
NeuroPath2Path: Classification and elastic morphing between neuronal arbors using path-wise similarity
5
Fig. 3 The figure shows a set of morphometrics that are used in our work. The metrics are numerically computed from a
neocortical pyramidal cell with its relevant anatomical information provided at the bottom of the figure. A rooted path of the
neuron (at the center) is shown (pink) with the 3D locations and bifurcation points, and the corresponding concurrence and
hierarchy values are noted on the left hand side of the figure. 18 paths are originated from the soma, indicating 18 synaptic
terminals. The immediate bifurcation point has a concurrence value of 6, because, including the current path, there are a total
of 6 paths that end up in 6 different terminals. Concurrence values of the rest of the 3D locations are computed accordingly. It
can be observed that there are four concurrence values that are marked on the chosen path, {1, 2, 6, 18}. The hierarchy values
are obtained by sorting the indices of these four values in reverse order, which in turn describe the depths of locations with
respect to the root. On the right hand side, three morphometrics on the selected paths are demonstrated, which are tortuosity,
divergence, and bifurcation angle. Quantification of the wrinkle or tangle of a segment (tortuosity) existing between either
two consecutive bifurcation points, or a bifurcation point and a following terminal is performed by measuring the curve length
s, and the Euclidean distance between the start and end locations, d. Neocortical pyramidal cells show pronounced wrinkles
in their branches. Divergence of a location entails competitive behavior. With a distance scale fixed beforehand, the number
of branch segments that are in the immediate neighborhood of a location defines its divergence. Bifurcation angle is another
important morphometric, which we measure by using the inner product between two vectors emanating from the bifurcation
point. Wide bifurcation angles connote greater exploration of extracellular environment. More branches and smaller bifurcation
angles, in general, lead to higher divergence. Neurons with higher divergence tend to have longer path lengths.
ric is null when two paths have the same set of con-
currence values but different locations and hierarchy
values. Therefore, it does not qualify the axioms of
a metric. In addition, the proposed distance measure
uses the Euclidean distance between two paths as a
part of the distance computation routine, which favors
the pair if they are aligned in proximity after regis-
tration. The algorithm of finding the correspondence
is not one-to-one and it often leads to the degener-
ate case where all paths from one neuron are matched
to only one path in the second neuron. The problem
exacerbates when the number of samples in the two
paths are unequal. One potential solution is to resam-
ple each path using a constant step [39], but may, un-
fortunately, eliminate the importance of the locations,
such as curvature of a rooted path prior to resampling.
ElasticPath2Path [5] attempted to address the previ-
ously mentioned problems. It introduced a mid-point
based resampling routine as opposed to constant-length
resampling. To ensure one-to-one correspondence be-
tween a pair of paths from two different neurons, the
Munkres algorithm [26] is employed. Most importantly,
elasticPath2Path envisaged the problem of distinguish-
ing two neurons as a continuous deformation between
the corresponding paths of the neurons. Such home-
omorphism is computed by applying the square root
velocity function (SRVF) [36] to the Euclidean coordi-
nates of each sample on a path. The visual deformation
of the corresponding paths has an enormous impact in
the validation of the path based on customized features
and the proposed distance measure. On the flip side,
elasticPath2Path failed to address the problem where
there is a significant difference in the number of paths
between two neurons. As the correspondence is one-
to-one, it asserts that elasticPath2Path performs sub-
graph matching. Both Path2Path and elasticPath2Path
did not consider important anatomical morphometrics,
such as bifurcation angles and partition asymmetry.
1.2 Key aspects of NeuroPath2Path
1) The inception of NeuroPath2Path comes from the
realization of neuromorphogenesis and the self-similar
6
Tamal Batabyal et al.
Fig. 4 The figure presents a schematic representation of our proposed method and work flow. [Top Left]: An SWC [37] file
encoding the 3D reconstruction of a neuron is read, and later the neuron is decomposed into an assembly of rooted paths.
Each rooted path, spanning from the soma to a synaptic terminal, contains the 3D coordinates of each location traced on the
path. [Top Right]: Each rooted path is subjected to feature extraction from each location on the path. The exhaustive list
of the features that are used in our approach is given in the bottom left (blue box). We extract 7 features, implying that the
path descriptor is a matrix of dimension (number-of-samples × 7).
phenotype of neuronal arbor. Since its birth from the
soma, a path of a neuron has an exploratory attribute to
collect external resources by the minimal-length-maximal-
routing [35] strategy. Due to the parsimonious exploita-
tion of intrinsic resources (ion density, ATP and other
electrophysiological items), the path, which fails to pro-
cure external resources, retracts. The exploratory at-
tribute of a path can be expressed by the concurrence
values at each sample point of a path. More paths imply
more exploration. As the path matures, it has a com-
petitive attribute [13, 22, 25] with respect to the other
paths in its neighborhood in order to form a synapse.
To account for competition, we count the number of
paths in the proximity of each sampled location on a
path and assign the count to that location.
2) The fractal dimension [8, 30] of a neuronal ar-
bor is considered one of the key morphometrics because
the fan-out branches of a neuron bear self-similarity. In
Path2Path and elasticPath2Path, the notion of match-
ing the paths ignores this important feature. We extend
the use of Munkres algorithm to perform one-to-one
matching in a sequential fashion, which replicates the
self-similar behavior.
3) As path features, we consider the bifurcation an-
gle, partition asymmetry, and fragmentation score to
each 3D location on a path. It is shown that the dis-
tribution of bifurcation angles in the basal dendrites of
cortical pyramidal cells follows a Von Mises distribu-
tion [7]. An experimentally observed fact is that the
mean bifurcation angle of branches ordered in a re-
versed fashion is discriminative for pyramidal cells in
different cortical regions. However, the mean bifurca-
tion angle of branches in standard order remains similar
for the pyramidal cells. We take the standard ordering
of branches, instead of the reverse order, to discrim-
inate different neuronal cell types. Partition asymme-
try [8, 29, 32] is another visually-significant morphome-
tric. We use the caulescence measure as defined in [8]
to account for the tree asymmetry.
4) We provide visualization of the continuous de-
formation between a pair of neurons and enumerate
path similarity statistics to justify the correspondences
between the paths. In contrast, conventional methods
perform feature customization and extraction, and the
classification, in supervised or unsupervised settings,
depends on the abstract feature space and the strength
of the classifier. In those methods, the mapping between
the space of 3D reconstructed neurons and the feature
space is irreversible and abstract. Therefore, apart from
the statistical quantification and analysis, it is ambigu-
ous whether improved accuracy of the categorization
stems from the trained classifier or the discriminat-
NeuroPath2Path: Classification and elastic morphing between neuronal arbors using path-wise similarity
7
tinct, it is called a loop. A simple graph without a loop
is termed as a tree. If the degree of each vertex is fixed,
tree has the fastest growth by volume, hence smallest
curvature [20]. A graph is said to be single-connected if
there exists at least one path between a pair of vertices.
In case of a neuron, G is a simple, undirected, weighted,
and single-connected tree.
A path can be considered as an open curve, fi(t), t ∈
[0, 1], as defined in differential geometry. The cardinal-
ity of the set of vertices, or ,equivalently, the total num-
ber of 3D locations, is given by V = N . Here, there
are n dendritic terminals, which implies that the total
number of paths rooted at the soma is n. Let Γ be the
set containing all the paths fi, i ∈ {1, 2, .., n}, which
is a linear subspace of the classical Wiener space. Each
path is sampled with the number of samples as φ with
the sampled path denoted by fi. We extract K features
for each sample on fi, which can be compactly given
by the feature matrix for fi as Θi ∈ Rφ×K. Let Θ be
the ordered set containing the feature matrix for all the
paths, Θ = {Θ1, Θ2, ..., Θn}, where Θi corresponds to
the ith path fi. The path model of a neuron G can be
mathematically represented as H = {Γ, Θ, µ}, where µ
is a measure that we define in the next section. Note
that we use the set of paths, Γ , as an ordered set which
has a one-to-one correspondence with the elements in
Θ. The standard branch order of a path, fi, is defined
as the order in which the locations of bifurcation on a
path are visited from the root to the end of the path.
Similarly, the reverse branch order is defined when the
direction of traversal is reversed. For interclass compar-
ison of neurons, we use the standard order. Whereas,
for intraclass comparison, we follow the reverse order.
3 Proposed methodology
Fig. 5 A schematic representation of the square root velocity
function (q), which is computed at locations on an open curve.
This function endows the curve with elasticity so that it can
continuously deform (bend, stretch, shrink) to another curve.
In a neuron, each rooted path can be modeled as an elastic
open curve.
ing strength of the extracted features or both. In Neu-
roPath2Path, the classification problem is modeled as a
variant of the transport problem. First, the correspon-
dence of paths between a pair of neurons are decided in
the feature space. Next, the correspondence is utilized
to deform one neuron to the other. The distances com-
puted between the paths and the deformation together
justify the validity of the correspondence.
5) With suitable feature selection, NeuroP2P frame-
work can be applied to perform morphological analysis
of any cell type with ramified branching arbors, such as
microglia and astrocytes. The continuum that is present
in the evolution from one cell type to the other can be
utilized in the analysis of cell differentiation. As an ex-
ample, under certain constraints, the strategy of contin-
uous morphing with branch splitting (explained later)
can retrieve the intermediate states of a neuron cell
while it evolves from a neural progenitor cell to its fully
developed state. In short, NeuroP2P can serve as an
effective tool for cell-specific informatics, which is not
restricted to classification only.
2 Path modeling of a neuron
graph be represented by G = (cid:0)V,E,W(cid:1), where V is
As mentioned in the introduction, a digitally-traced 3D
sampled neuron can be modeled as a graph. Let the
the number of 3D locations as vertices and E is the set
of edges connecting the vertices with the corresponding
weights W [17]. G is said to be simple if it does not con-
tain multiple edges between any two vertices. A graph
is called undirected if there is no preferred direction as-
sociated to an edge. A sequence of contiguous edges is
called a path if no vertex and edge are repeated in that
sequence. A path of length k has k number of edges or
equivalently (k + 1) vertices. A sequence of contiguous
edges is called a trail if no edge is repeated. If all the
vertices except the start and the end of a trail are dis-
Our proposed method, which is sequential, scalable and
modular, consists of four key stages as depicted in Fig. 4.
In the first stage, centrally curated files of 3D-traced
neurons in SWC format (or equivalent formats) are read
and then preprocessed to extract only the dendritic ar-
bors, including the soma. Several preprocessing mod-
ules, such as range-wise calibration, bifurcation location
determination, and synaptic tip identification are em-
ployed to aid in preparing an assembly of rooted (soma)
paths.
In the second stage, a set of features are extracted
from each path, forming a feature descriptor of the
path, Θi∀i. An exhaustive list of the features that are
used in our method is provided in Section 3.1, and the
systematic quantification of the features is provided in
the Appendix. Notice that each path descriptor can be
8
Tamal Batabyal et al.
populated with additional structural and geometric fea-
tures in order to perform fine-grained analysis.
The central aspect of the third stage is finding an
appropriate cost function, as illustrated in Section 3.2.
The cost function assimilates several anatomical fea-
tures (such as segment length and bifurcation angle)
and physiologically relevant factors (such as the com-
petitive behavior, decaying anatomical importance of a
path from the soma to synapse). A rigorous optimiza-
tion framework is also formulated to find the relative
contributions of such factors. In short, this stage deliv-
ers a distance measure between a pair of paths to the
last stage.
With a distance measure between neuron paths in
hand, this measure is augmented in the final stage as
elucidated in section 3.3. We theoretically establish the
correspondence of paths of a pair of neurons by repeat-
edly applying the Munkres algorithm. In contrast to the
conventional approaches where the distance between
neurons inherently accounts for sub-graph matching, we
propose a full-tree matching algorithm. The repeated
application of the Munkres algorithm reveals the frac-
tal or self-similar nature of a pair of neurons. Equiva-
lently, the following question may be posed: how many
identical copies, taken together, of the first neuron can
match with the second neuron, assuming the second
neuron is much larger than the first one? Once the
correspondence is found, neurons are diffeomorphically
transformed to each other by morphing corresponding
paths. This visual representation aids in justifying the
correspondence of paths.
3.1 Feature extraction on a path
We extract a set of discriminating features from each
path fi ∈ Γ of H, which are bifurcation angle (bi),
concurrence (Ci), hierarchy (ξi), divergence (λi), seg-
ment length (βi), tortuosity (κi), and partition asym-
metry (αi). Therefore, Θi = [bi, Ci, ξi, λi, βi, κi, αi] ∈
Rφ×7. Each feature encodes a specific structural prop-
erty of a neuronal arbor, as described in the Appendix.
A schematic of different features along with the system-
atic quantification is shown in Fig.3.
3.2 Path alignment and path distance measure, µ
Given an unequal number of samples in a pair of paths,
finding the appropriate distance between two paths or
open curves is challenging. Due to the resampling bias
imposed by a given tracer, in general, a path contains
erroneous sampled locations which could alter the path
statistics. For example, adding an extra leaf vertex changes
the concurrence values of all the locations on a path.
Unlike conventional approaches that used different re-
sampling procedures, such as mid-point based resam-
pling, RANSAC sampling, and spectral sampling, we
use the help of the branch order as mentioned in sec-
tion 2 for suboptimal alignment.
Consider two neurons, G1 and G2, with the cor-
responding path models given as H1 and H2, respec-
tively. Let f and g be the two paths that are arbitrar-
ily selected from Γ1 and Γ2, respectively. Without loss
of generality, let us assume that f and g contain φb
1
and φb
2, the number of locations from which the current
paths bifurcate. In the case, where φb
2, we append
2 − φb
(φb
1) zeros at the end (standard branch order) or
at the front (reverse branch order) of a feature vector
on f .
1 < φb
Experimental evidence [7] suggests that the impor-
tance of a bifurcation location on a path decays as one
travels the path from the soma to the synaptic end.
We utilize this relative importance by way of hierarchy
values of the bifurcation locations on a path. Let the se-
quential order of hierarchy values from the root to the
]. Using ξf , the kth
terminal on f be ξf = [ξ1, ξ2, ..., ξφb
importance weight is given by wk = 1
1
ξj + .
is introduced to avoid the indeterminate case. Accord-
ing to the hierarchy, it is obvious that ξ1 < ξ2 < ... <
. Thus, w1 > w2 > ... > wφb
ξφb
Let us consider a feature υ ∈ {b, C, λ, κ, β, α}. The
values of the feature on the paths, f and g, are defined
by
υf = [υf
ξk+ /(cid:80)φb
(1)
j=1
.
1
1
1
1
1 , υf
2 , ..., υf
φb
1
(cid:124)(cid:123)(cid:122)(cid:125)
, 0, .., 0
]
2−φb
φb
1
υg = [υg
1 , υg
2 , ..., υg
φb
1
]
The distance between υf and υg, weighted by the im-
portance factor, is given by
(cid:118)(cid:117)(cid:117)(cid:116) 1
φb
2
2(cid:88)
φb
k=1
d(υf g) =
wk(υf
k − υg
k)2
(2)
This distance is computed for each υ ∈ {b, C, λ, β, κ, α}.
The overall distance between the paths f and g can be
expressed as a weighted average of individual distances.
µf g = δ1d(bf g) + δ2d(C f g) + δ3d(λf g)
+δ4d(κf g) + δ5d(βf g) + δ6d(αf g).
(3)
6∀i and consider the final
For simplicity, we take δi = 1
distance as the intrinsic distance between the neurons.
For classification, we determine δ through optimiza-
tion using maximizing − interclass − minimizing −
intraclass distance strategy (See algorithm 2 in the
Appendix). We term δ as the relative importance of
features.
NeuroPath2Path: Classification and elastic morphing between neuronal arbors using path-wise similarity
9
Fig. 6 The figure depicts the evolution of 15 paths of one pyramidal neuron to 11 paths of another pyramidal neuron. Both
the neurons are procured and curated from the neocortex (occipital, secondary visual and lateral visual) brain regions of 2
month-old mice. On the leftmost column, the top figure corresponds to the candidate neuron 1; the bottom figure is the target
neuron 2. The evolution is represented in multiple arrays such that the ODD rows are read left-to-right and the EVEN rows
are read right-to-left. The color associated with each path acts as a marker for the correspondence. At each intermediate step,
the morphing of each path is calculated in the SRVF space [36] and then the path is projected back in the real 3D domain.
In accordance with known properties of the SRVF, the SRVF takes care of the translation between paths. However for visual
clarity, we intentionally allow the rotation of each path with respect to the root (soma) while the path advances towards
merging with the target path. Prior to applying the SRVF, we reorganize the coordinates of each neuron in decreasing order
of the ranges along the X, Y , and Z axes, implementing an in-place rotation of each neuron.
3.3 Path assignment and self-similarity
Let the number of paths in H1 be Γ1 = n1. Simi-
larly, for H2, this value is Γ2 = n2. Without loss of
generality, let us assume n1 ≤ n2. Using eq. 3, the
cost matrix of paths between G1 and G2 becomes D
(Dij = µij, i ∈ Γ1, j ∈ Γ2). By applying an analogy
for the path assignment as a job assignment problem
with n1 workers and n2 jobs, we adopt the Munkres
algorithm to find the optimal assignment of jobs to
the workers from D. In most cases, including inter-
and intra-cellular neurons, the job assignment prob-
lem is an unbalanced n1 < n2. We append (n2 − n1)
zero rows to D to serve as dummy workers. Elastic-
Path2Path [5] employed this technique and resulted in
an output of n1 optimally matched paths between G1
and G2. However, this is essentially subgraph match-
ing, which may lead to misclassification while dealing
with two structurally similar, but different, cell types.
For example, hippocampal CA3 pyramidal and cere-
bellar Purkinje cells have similar dendritic branch pat-
terns, but significantly different number of paths. To
resolve this problem we devise an algorithm, given in
the Appendix, by applying Munkres algorithm repeat-
edly to obtain a full-tree matching. To meet such cri-
terion, the algorithm gives n2 pair of paths. Let the
pair be (γ11, γ21), ..., (γ1n2, γ2n2 ), where γ1i ∈ Γ1 and
γ2j ∈ Γ2. Recall that n1 < n2, which implies that some
of the γ1i are repeated while forming the pair. Finally,
the distance between G1 an G2 is given by
n2(cid:88)
k=1
χG1G2 =
µγ1kγ2k
(4)
Let (cid:98) n2
n1(cid:99) = T . Then, this procedure to find the cor-
respondence is termed as T−regular matching, which in
turn can be thought of T nearly self-similar structures
akin to a fractal system. The detailed algorithm is pro-
vided in the Appendix. There are four modules that are
sequentially executed in the algorithm. The first mod-
ule mathematically deciphers the relatively self-similar
anatomy of a larger neuron compared to a smaller one,
yielding the number of copies of the smaller one needed
to stitch together to approximately obtain the larger
one. The routine runs for (cid:98) n2
(cid:99) times, which indicates
that each path in neuron 1 (containing n1 paths), is
matched with (cid:98) n2
(cid:99) paths of neuron 2 (containing n2
paths). Here n2 > n1.
n1
n1
The second module runs for the remaining unpaired
paths of neuron 2. The assigned correspondence is added
to the list of paired paths from the first module. How-
ever, not all the pairs are anatomically consistent. This
is dictated by an internal constraint of Munkres algo-
rithm, in which the assignment is carried out without
replacement. In the Munkres algorithm, if one 'worker'(a
path from neuron 1) is assigned a 'job' (a path from neu-
ron 2), then the 'job' is not available for further assign-
ment. Therefore, if the distance between two paths is
significantly large, it demands further inspection whether
the pair of paths is morphologically different to each
other or the algorithmic constraint induces the large
distance value. This motivates us to introduce the third
module.
In the third module, we inspect the pair of paths
having distances more than a threshold. The threshold
is selected based on the skewness, median and standard
10
Tamal Batabyal et al.
hierarchy value. The highest level of hierarchy values of
two paths are given by h1 and h2 with h1 < h2. We
set a criteria that if h1 − h2 > max[h1,h2]
, we do not
consider the distance between the pair, and opt for the
best match in terms of minimum distance for each path
of the pair separately. This is outlined in the reassign-
ment module. The reassigned pairs are added to the list
of paired paths serving as the list of correspondence.
2
3.4 Path morphing
Once the correspondence of paths between neurons is
established, it is imperative to know the structural sim-
ilarity between the paths - whether a pair of paths are
structurally similar to each other, or the pair is struc-
turally incoherent but the algorithm outputs such a pair
due to its internal constraints. This is achieved in two
ways: with a visual representation by morphing the
paths of one neuron to that of the other using an elastic
framework, and by extracting path statistics. A rooted
path of a neuron can be considered as an open curve as
shown in Fig. 5 [5, 36]. Each location on the path can
be considered as a function of a parameter,t ∈ [0, 1].
The square root velocity function (SRVF) that is ap-
f (t)√
plied on a location f (t) is defined as q(t) =
f (t) .
For a pair of paths i and j, we obtain qi and qj, which
assists in retrieving the intermediate deformations as
ij = qi(1 −
linear combinations of qi and qj given by qn
n) + nqj; n ∈ [0, 1]. n denotes the intermediate algo-
rithmic time steps. Although the deformations are ex-
hibited using the 3D coordinates of the locations of a
path, the deformations can also be computed in the fea-
ture domain. An example of the continuous morphing
process between two pyramidal neurons from the sec-
ondary visual cortex of the mouse is shown in Fig. 6.
The 15 paths of the former neuron merge with 11 paths
of the latter upon termination of the morphing pro-
cess. This implies that more than one path of the first
neuron have the same final destination path of the sec-
ond neuron. It is noted that our algorithm does not
consider the costs that are incurred by the merging or
splitting of paths during progression. The assessment
of such costs requires biophysical measurements of neu-
rons, such as metabolic cost of merging or splitting of
branches. Therefore, the cost between paths in eq. 3 is
proportional to the cost of structural disparity instead
of biophysical costs.
The prime question is: why do we need to inspect in-
termediate deformations? Statistical assessment of anatom-
ical similarities between paths is sufficient to validate
the correspondence that is obtained from the Munkres
algorithm. However, to make the correspondence neces-
Fig. 7 The figure shows the distribution of paths in each
pyramidal cell category from Dataset 1. By glancing at the
distribution profiles, a set of inferences can be drawn. The
distribution of paths in primary motor is fairly uniform. For
neurons from the somatosensory cortex and primary visual
cortex, the histogram is right-skewed, indicating a major-
ity of neurons with the number of paths lying in the range
[10, 40]. The probability distribution of somatosensory pyra-
midal neurons resembles a right-skewed gamma distribution,
and that of primary visual neurons closely follows an expo-
nential distribution. The profiles of secondary visual and pre-
limbic neurons are poorly understood due to scarcity of sam-
ples. Most importantly, their distributions are entirely over-
lapped (within [10, 40]) in the region where the majority of
primary visual and somatosensory neurons can be sampled.
From the figure, it is evident that the number of paths alone
is not sufficiently discriminatory.
deviation of the distance values. As mentioned earlier,
in order to find the distance of a feature on two paths
(eq. 2), we append zeros to the path having relatively
fewer number of locations than the other. The choice of
traversal order dictates to which side the zeros are ap-
pended. Notice that more zeros lead to higher distance
value between paths, and this happens only when there
is significant mismatch in the highest level of hierar-
chy. This fact can be interpreted from the morpholog-
ical viewpoint. A path with a large number of bifur-
cation locations (so, large maximum hierarchy value),
called a central path of a neuron, exploits the environ-
ment of the neuron extensively when compared to path
with fewer number of bifurcations. Unless otherwise re-
quired, a path with large hierarchy values should not
be compared with a path with much smaller maximum
NeuroPath2Path: Classification and elastic morphing between neuronal arbors using path-wise similarity
11
subtended by the color in a pie chart, indicates its relative importance. By property, (cid:80) δ = 1, which implies a probability
Fig. 8 Relative importance δ for subsets of classes of Dataset 1. Each color corresponds to a specific feature and the area,
distribution. The color codes are as follows. green-divergence, orange-bifurcation angle, gray-partition asymmetry, yellow-
concurrence, deep blue-tortuosity, sky blue-segment length. The pie charts taken together asserts a set of inferences. (1)
The relative importance of features δ of all the classes (marked 'overall') somewhat follows a uniform distribution. (2) Segment
length and concurrence are two predominant features when the pyramidal neurons from primary motor cortex (motor-1) are
compared to the rest of the classes. (3) For the prelimbic class, divergence, tortuosity, and segment length appear to be
most important. (4) δ for the somatosensory class toggles between two distributions with comparatively smaller and larger
importance of concurrence.
sary, the intermediate deformations should comply with
key cell-type characteristics [36]. So we use the SRVF
framework to show the deformations so that any notice-
able incoherence can be attributed to the feature selec-
tion, distance measurement, or both algorithms even
though we might obtain improved classification accu-
racy in the end.
4 Datasets and results
We validate the approach on two datasets that are col-
lected from a centrally curated on-line repository of 3D
reconstructed neurons, Neuromorpho.org [2]. To demon-
strate the strength of our approach, one dataset is com-
piled for intraclass and the other one for interclass anal-
ysis and comparison.
4.1 Dataset-1 (Intraclass)
This dataset contains 3D-traced neurons from 6 distinct
regions of the mouse neocortex. The regions with their
cortical locations are visual-1 or primary visual (occip-
ital), visual-2 or secondary visual (occipital), prelimbic
(prefrontal), somato-1 or primary somatosensory (so-
matosensory), motor-1 or primary motor (frontal), and
motor-2 or secondary motor (frontal).
We experiment with 62 neurons of motor-1, 68 neu-
rons of motor-2, 24 neurons of prelimbic, 204 neurons
of somato-1, 237 neurons of visual-1, and 30 visual-2
neurons with 625 neurons in total. The neurons vary
widely in their morphological characteristics, such as
the number of paths in each neuron. The histogram of
paths corresponding to each category is shown in Fig. 7.
Next, we investigate the relative importance of each
feature (mentioned in section 3.1) in terms of δ when
comparing a set of classes. For space constraint, we pro-
vide δ values separately for each pair of classes and
all the classes taken together. The relative importance
is listed in Fig. 8 by a pool of pie charts. A set of
12
Tamal Batabyal et al.
Fig. 9 This gallery of images captures the progressive evolution of paths from a granule neuron to a pyramidal one. The
granule neuron is procured from the hippocampus (dentate gyrus) of a 5 month-old mouse, containing 6 rooted paths. The
pyramidal neuron is sampled from the neocortex (occipital lobe, secondary visual, lateral visual) of a 2 months old mouse,
containing 22 paths. The evolution is represented in multiple arrays such that the ODD rows are read left-to-right and the
EVEN rows are read right-to-left. In the first column, the top image is the granule cell and at the bottom is the pyramidal one.
Structurally, the pyramidal neuron is larger than the granule one. However, they are properly scaled to fit for visualization.
class-specific inferences regarding the relative impor-
tance is enlisted in the figure description. Whereas the
pie charts present a comprehensive view of feature strength.
In practice, however, the values are required to report
the distance between a pair of neurons. The values are
reported in Table 1.
It is worthwhile to note that although there is signif-
icant variance in feature strength when all pairs are con-
sidered, the distribution approximates a uniform distri-
bution when all classes are taken. This result endorses
the selection of our features for all-class classification
tasks. It is also important to mention that this frame-
work can incorporate any set of path-specific features,
not restricted to our selected features only.
In order to verify the consistency of the path corre-
spondence obtained from Munkres algorithm (provided
in section 3.3), we statistically evaluate each pair of
paths in the correspondence list using pyramidal neu-
rons from two different regions (the somatosensory cor-
tex and secondary visual cortex.) The neuron from the
somatosensory cortex (neuron-2) contains 28 rooted paths,
while the other (neuron-1) has 11 rooted paths. Ta-
ble 2 provides the exhaustive list of path correspon-
dences, distances between corresponding paths, corre-
spondences obtained by a competitive approach named
ElasticPath2Path [5], and the best correspondences of
the paths of neuron-2 with that of neuron-1. Notice
that the best correspondence of a path f of neuron-2 is
the path g of neuron-1, which yields minimum distance
with f . Whereas, the Munkres algorithm works on the
criteria where the sum of path distances (in our case 11
paths at a time) is minimized.
In Table 2, the two columns on the left enumerate
the pair that consists of the path number of neuron-1
and that of neuron-2. A subset of paths of neuron-1 is
repeated because neuron-2 (with 28) has more paths
than neuron-1 (with 11). So from neuron-1 to neuron-
2, the correspondence is a surjective mapping. This is
in contrast with ElasticPath2Path, where the mapping
is bijective and, as result of that, the algorithm out-
puts only 11 pairs in the correspondence list. The rest
of the 28 − 11 = 17 paths are left unmatched, yield-
ing a solution of the subgraph matching problem. The
unmatched paths are marked with 'NA' in the fourth
column.
NeuroPath2Path: Classification and elastic morphing between neuronal arbors using path-wise similarity
13
Table 1 Importance weight δ values for dataset-1. For space constraint, we provide feature-specific importance weight for
classification in case of pairwise classes and all classes separately.
Tortuo(κ) Bifur-angle(b) Part-aym(α) Concur(C)
Seg-len(β) Diverg(λ)
Motor1-Motor2
Motor1-Prelimbic
Motor1-Somato
Motor1-Visual1
Motor1-Visual2
Motor2-Prelimbic
Motor2-Somato
Motor2-Visual1
Motor2-Visual2
Prelimbic-Somato
Prelimbic-Visual1
Prelimbic-Visual2
Somato-Visual1
Somato-Visual2
Visual1-Visual2
Overall
0.0729
0.0820
0.0706
0.0689
0.0499
0.2719
0.0452
0.0167
0.0545
0.1314
0.2091
0.2311
0.0693
0.0144
0.0075
0.0785
0.1072
0.0737
0.0929
0.1230
0.1212
0.0737
0.0256
0.0773
0.0411
0.1168
0.0821
0.0551
0.0598
0.0310
0.0880
0.0807
0.0876
0.0631
0.0646
0.0659
0.0812
0.0703
0.0328
0.1041
0.0564
0.1121
0.0617
0.0453
0.0584
0.2043
0.1482
0.1736
0.2644
0.2262
0.2328
0.3317
0.2612
0.0899
0.4008
0.2996
0.2235
0.0568
0.1012
0.0790
0.1319
0.6963
0.3551
0.1956
0.3794
0.4483
0.4175
0.2878
0.3952
0.5367
0.3730
0.2969
0.5489
0.4621
0.4615
0.3556
0.5816
0.0159
0.3558
0.2600
0.0955
0.1067
0.1218
0.1227
0.0912
0.0484
0.1266
0.2055
0.0756
0.1187
0.0795
0.2339
0.0941
0.0382
0.0473
0.2076
The last column, tagged as the best match, identifies
only {4, 5, 8, 9} path indices out of 11 paths of neuron-1.
Nevertheless, this best matching algorithm also elicits
a potential solution for subgraph matching. There are
certain extreme cases where all paths of one neuron are
matched with only one path of the other neuron, posing
degenerate solutions of the neuron matching problem.
We mark the correspondences in yellow, where the re-
sults of our algorithm and best match coincide.
Recall that neuron-1 has 11 paths and neuron-2 con-
tains 28 paths. Careful observation of the first column of
the table suggests that the set of numbers {1, 2, ..., 11}
is repeated twice in the serial order followed by 6 path
indices which are {9, 4, 10, 8, 2, 5}. Here, Munkres algo-
rithm is applied thrice. Each time Munkres algorithm
outputs 11 pairs of paths for correspondence. Therefore,
the first two passes encompass 11 ∗ 2 = 22 pairs leav-
ing 28 − 22 = 6 paths of neuron-2 unassigned. Before
applying the third pass, the cost matrix D is cropped
with a dimension R11×6. The cropped cost matrix is
then transposed (R6×11), zero-appended (R11×11) and
subjected to Munkres. The above observation also indi-
cates that 2 self-similar copies of neuron-1 approximates
neuron-2 in the sense of minimum path to path dis-
tance. Therefore, the relative fractal index of neuron-2
with respect to neuron-1 is 2 6
11 or 2.545.
The question is: can the arithmetic average (which
is 0.92) of the 'Distance' column of Table 2 be regarded
as the final distance between the neuron-1 and neuron-
2? Unfortunately, it is not. The reason is explained in
section 3.3 and reiterated briefly in the following sen-
tences. After computing the correspondences (column-
1 and column-2), we identify the defective sets of pairs
for which there are significant differences in the hier-
archy levels. The larger the difference, the larger the
number of zeros that are appended to each feature on
the path, raising the chances of technical error in the
final distance value. In the table, the defective pairs
are emboldened with blue color. We delete these pairs
and replace the correspondences of path indices 18 and
9 (neuron-2) with their best matches from neuron-1.
Note that path indices 7 and 4 of neuron-1 have already
been matched with other paths of neuron-2, which are
7−−28, 4−−11, and 4−−12. Therefore, those paths are
not subjected to re-assignment. After inserting the best
matches for the path indices 18 and 9 (which are 9 and 5
from neuron-1 respectively), the corresponding distance
values are noted. This is described in the fourth routine,
'Reassignment' of algorithm 2. The final distance be-
tween the two neurons turns out as 0.90 (rounded off).
The competitive approach, ElasticP2P produces a dis-
tance value of 0.67, which implies that the two neurons
are more similar. This is discordant with the fact that
the two neurons are sampled from two different regions
and have two distinct arbor types. This disagreement
can be explained due to subgraph matching nature of
ElasticP2P. Neuron-1 with 11 paths is well-matched
with a part of neuron-2. However, the rest 17 paths of
neuron-2 are structurally dissimilar with neuron-1. In
this case, our method, NeuroPath2Path performs sig-
nificantly better in distinguishing two neurons in terms
of distance owing to its full-graph matching property.
For classification, we compute the importance val-
ues δ from (3) and show them in Table 1. The impor-
14
Tamal Batabyal et al.
Table 2 Distance and correspondence between paths. The correspondences between the paths of neuron-1 and neuron-2 are
enlisted in the first two columns. The numbers in yellow indicate that the correspondence obtained by NeuroP2P matches with
the candidates of best correspondence in the sense of minimum distance. The pairs in blue are subjected for further verification
because of large differences in the hierarchy values (Routine 4 in Algorithm 2).
Index (Neuron-1)
Index (Neuron-2) Distance ElasticP2P [5] Best match
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
9
4
10
8
2
5
25
2
27
12
3
26
28
5
23
13
24
7
1
15
11
6
17
18
20
4
14
10
8
9
16
19
21
22
1.0595
0.8031
0.4530
0.7910
0.5571
0.6165
0.5690
0.5606
0.6271
0.7904
0.6096
1.4997
0.9902
1.1052
0.9223
0.5932
1.7108
1.2869
0.8704
0.7708
0.9186
1.1796
0.8504
1.2279
1.1810
1.1658
1.1522
0.8931
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
9
5
5
4
5
5
5
8
9
4
5
8
9
5
9
5
9
9
9
5
5
9
5
5
5
9
5
5
tance values are applied to compute the distance be-
tween a pair of neurons. Using our distance function,
we resort to the K nearest neighborhood classifier. We
randomly partition the dataset into our training and
test set using a constant ratio and rerun the experi-
ment 5 times. The ratio that we maintain is 0.1 and
0.2 as train and test datasets. As the number of paths
that a neuron has is a distinguishable feature for certain
classes, we devise a strategy to test each neuron from
the testing dataset. For a neuron with number of paths
as nP , we seek candidate neurons from the training set
with the number of paths ranging in [nP − L, nP + L].
Overall, NeuroPath2Path contains two hyperparame-
ters, K (number of nearest neighbors) and L. THis step
is followed by the identical testing procedure while con-
sidering the interclass dataset. We fixed L = 50 for our
experiments. As noted before, we adopt the reverse and
standard branch orders for dataset-1 and dataset-2, re-
spectively.
With the ratio of train and test as 8 : 2, the confu-
sion matrix of NeuroPath2Path for an instance of ran-
dom partition of data is shown in Fig. 14. It can be
seen that, while NeuroPath2Path distinguishes Motor-
1, Visual-1, and Visual-2 quite well, the class of Somato-
1 is significantly misclassified with Motor-1, Motor-2,
and Visual-1, leading to a decline in the classification
score.
Next, in Fig. 11, we illustrate the comparative per-
formance of NeuroPath2Path against TMD and Neu-
roSoL. The train to test ratio is set at 8 : 2. NeuroSoL
shows an erratic behavior as K increases. TMD offers
a consistent margin of classification accuracy per K.
Here, at a given value of K, margin implies the dif-
ference between the maximum and minimum scores of
5 experiments which are independently instantiated by
NeuroPath2Path: Classification and elastic morphing between neuronal arbors using path-wise similarity
15
mouse: ganglion, granule, motor, Purkinje, and pyrami-
dal. We experiment with an imbalanced pool of 500 gan-
glion cells, 490 granule cells, 95 motor cells, 208 purkinje
cells, and 499 pyramidal cells, where the corresponding
SWC files are obtained from the neuromorpho reposi-
tory. The cell-specific distribution of paths is shown in
Fig 13.
Fig. 10 Confusion matrix of an instance of classification
using dataset-1. The overall accuracy is 66%. Here, we set
L = 50 and K = 3.
randomly partitioning the dataset with 8 : 2 train:test
ratio. Fig. 11 suggests that NeuroPath2Path achieves
peak performance when K is set as 7, but with a no-
ticeable margin. To scrutinize the performance of TMD
Fig. 11 The figure shows comparative performance of Neu-
roPath2Path against TMD and NeuroSoL using different val-
ues of K in K-NN classifier. At each K, we perform 5 experi-
ments for each of these methods and the associated scores are
shown with the mean (colored square) and associated range
of values.
Fig. 12 This figure shows one typical
instance of class-
wise retrieval accuracy of NeuroPath2Path and TMD. Neu-
roPath2Path maintains almost consistent classwise perfor-
mance.
and NeuroPath2Path, we routinely inspect the class-
wise retrieval accuracy, a crucial metric which is ob-
scured in Fig. 11 due to the averaging effect. The result
is shown in Fig. 12. In a majority of cases, despite com-
parable overall classification scores, TMD tends to be
affected by class imbalance, leading to significantly poor
accuracy for few classes.
4.2 Dataset-2 (Interclass)
The second dataset consists of 3D-reconstructed neu-
rons that are traced from five major cell types of the
Fig. 13 The figure shows the cell-specific distribution of the
number of paths. It is observed that the distribution of paths
in the case of Purkinje cells is approximately uniform. The
remainder of the distributions are left-skewed.
16
Tamal Batabyal et al.
Fig. 14 Confusion matrix of an instance of classification us-
ing Dataset-2. The overall accuracy is 85.02%. Here, we set
L = 50 and K = 9. It can be seen from the matrix that one-
fifth of ganglion cells are misclassified as pyramidal, leading
to a decline in accuracy. However, granule cells are perfectly
classified.
For classification, we compute the important weights
δ of each features, and due to space constraints, the δ
values are enumerated in Table 3 for pairwise classes
and the case with all the classes taken together. The
importance-weighted distance value, µf g in (3) is used
to compute the distance of a pair of neurons. We em-
pirically find that the nonlinear transformation of µf g,
given by
1+exp(−µf g) , yields an improved classification
performance.
1
With a train:test ratio as 8 : 2, one instance of the
confusion matrix, obtained by NeuroPath2Path is pro-
vided in Fig.14. We demonstrate the effectiveness of
NeuroPath2Path over two state-of-the-art approaches -
Topological Morphological Descriptor (TMD) [19] and
NeuroSoL [4]. For each value of K, we randomly par-
tition the dataset 5 times maintaining a constant 9 : 1
ratio between the train and test datasets. In short, for
every K, we obtain 5 accuracy scores, which are plotted
in Fig. 15.
TMD appears to be very consistent in accuracy and
range scores, achieving an accuracy of 85.02% when
K = 5. However, while computing the confusion ma-
trices of the classification scores obtained by TMD, we
notice that in the majority of instances, the correct
classification of motor cells is abnormally low and ap-
proaches 0% in some cases. It is important to notice
that Dataset-2 has an imbalance in terms of the num-
ber of examples in each cell category, with motor cells
containing the lowest (95) and ganglion cells contain-
ing the highest (500) number of examples. This fact is
unobserved in Fig. 15 due to the averaging effect. We
adopt the metric, class-wise accuracy of retrieval, and
present the results in Fig. 16. It is evident that Neu-
roPath2Path exhibits strong resilience against the class
imbalance problem.
Similar to the train and test ratio of Dataset-1, we
conduct experiments using the ratio of 0.1 and 0.2 sep-
arately. The classification scores are given in Fig. 17.
Fig. 15 The figure shows comparative performance of Neu-
roPath2Path against TMD and NeuroSoL using different val-
ues of K in K-NN classifier. At each K, we perform 5 exper-
iments for each of these methods and the associated scores
are shown with the mean (colored square) and the range val-
ues. The profiles of TMD and NeuroPath2Path surprisingly
appear to have opposite trends over K. NeuroPathPath hits
the top accuracy of 86.2% when K = 9.
Fig. 16 This figure shown the classwise retrieval accuracy of
different methods including NeuroPath2Path. It is observed
that by using TMD the retrieval accuracy of Motor cells
shows minimal improvement when SVM is used. The im-
balance in class adversely affects the classification accuracy.
NeuroPath2Path maintains consistent class performance.
Fig. 17 The performance of NeuroPath2Path on two differ-
ent partitions, which are 9 : 1 and 8 : 2, of Dataset-2 is shown.
K = 9 is found to be a suitable candidate of K-NN classifier.
5 Conclusion
NeuroPath2Path follows a graph-theoretic approach that
utilizes path-based modeling of neuron anatomy and
provides a visualization tool by way of a geometric
model that aids in performing continuous deformation
between two neurons. NeuroPath2Path offers several
advantages. The decomposition of a neuron into paths
can be viewed as an assembly of individual circuits from
the terminals to the soma, integrating semi-local fea-
tures that act as path descriptors. Next, instead of sub-
NeuroPath2Path: Classification and elastic morphing between neuronal arbors using path-wise similarity
17
Table 3 Importance weight δ values for dataset-2
Tortuo(κ) Bifur-angle(b) Part-aym(α) Concur(C)
Seg-len(β) Diverg(λ)
Ganglion-Granule
Ganglion-Motor
Ganglion-Purkinje
Ganglion-Pyramidal
Granule-Motor
Granule-Purkinje
Granule-Pyramidal
Motor-Purkinje
Motor-Pyramidal
Purkinje-Pyramidal
Overall
0.0278
0.0464
0.27
0.0433
0.0356
0.0147
0.0453
0.0094
0.0223
0.0219
0.1304
0.0138
0.0797
0.032
0.0001
0.0491
0.1218
0.0305
0.4046
0.0737
0.2201
0.0372
0.0241
0.0918
0.1437
0.0553
0.0372
0.1875
0.0372
0.0556
0.0465
0.1088
0.0417
0.2102
0.1865
0.1905
0.5121
0.1449
0.1073
0.2231
0.0007
0.1275
0.1528
0.1786
0.6727
0.4730
0.2270
0.3156
0.6697
0.5285
0.5390
0.5167
0.6650
0.4223
0.4489
0.0533
0.1226
0.1368
0.0809
0.0636
0.0402
0.1248
0.0130
0.0650
0.0740
0.1633
graph matching, NeuroPath2Path does not leave a sin-
gle path unassigned, culminating in a full-graph match-
ing algorithm. The matching algorithm presents the
notion of relative fractality and path correspondence,
and incorporates physiological factors, such as decaying
importance of features along the path and exploratory
/competitive behavior for resource exploitation.
NeuroPath2Path also precisely investigates the fea-
sibility of algorithmic constraints (such as on Munkres
algorithm) on the structural repertoire of neuronal ar-
bors, and thereby enforcing criteria, such as hierarchy
mismatch. During classification, NeuroPath2Path de-
livers resilience to the class imbalance problem. In the
future, in order to explore the full potential of the ap-
proach beyond classification, we aim to augment Neu-
roPath2Path in two major domains - morphological anal-
ysis and structural transformation of microglia cells,
and in progressive degradation of neuronal paths in neu-
rodegenerative diseases.
Appendix
Description of features
We extract a set of discriminating features on each path
fi ∈ Γ of H, which are bifurcation angle (bi), con-
currence (Ci), hierarchy (ξi), divergence (λi), segment
length (βi), tortuosity (κi), and partition asymmetry
(αi). • Bifurcation angle is a key morphometric that
dictates the span and the spatial volume of an arbor. It
is hypothesized that the span of an arbor at each level
of bifurcation depends on the bifurcation of its previous
level [6, 7, 22], suggesting the influence of Bayesian phi-
losophy. This organizational principle is utilized in sev-
eral stochastic generative models [22] for the synthesis
of specific neuron cell types. The sequence of bifurcation
angles at bifurcation vertices located on a path of a neu-
ron captures local geometry. For example, a sequence of
non-increasing bifurcation angles from the root to the
dendritic terminal of a path indicates the pyramidal
shape geometry of the neuron. For a location with mul-
tifurcation, we use the maximum of the bifurcation an-
gles computed using pairwise branches originated from
that location towards the dendritic terminals.
• Concurrence, hierarchy and divergence encode the ef-
fect of phenomenological factors, which are exploration
(ex. Purkinje fanning out rostrocaudally) and competi-
tion (ex. retinal ganglion cells), that contribute in the
growth of a neuron. The definition of concurrence and
hierarchy are already given in section 1.1. The diver-
gence of a location on a path, fi is proportional to the
repulsive force that the location experiences from its
neighborhood path segments. Let Cfi be the sequence
of concurrence values of the path fi ∈ Γ when one vis-
its the locations from the root to the dendritic termi-
nal. As an open curve, each path can be parameterized
with the parameter t ∈ [0, 1]. Cfi(ts) = k; ts ∈ [0, 1]
indicates that k(≤ Γ) paths share the location ts on
fi. The divergence λ of a location fi(ts) is defined as
λ(fi(ts)) =1{fj fj (t)−fi(ts)≤,fj(cid:54)=fi,fj(cid:7)fi}. Here, 1 is
the indicator function computing the number of such
fjs which follow the conditions fj(t)− fi(ts) ≤ δ, fj (cid:54)=
fi and fj (cid:7) fi. The first condition implies that a loca-
tion of fj has to be in the neighborhood of fi. fj (cid:7) fi
indicates that the location of bifurcation at which fj
deviates from fi does not appear after fi(ts) on the
path fi.
• Tortuosity and partition asymmetry are two impor-
tant anatomical features of a neuron. Tortuosity refers
to the amount of 'zig-zag' or bending of a path. Let us
take a segment on a path fi as fi([t1, t2]); 0 ≤ t1 < t2 ≤
(cid:80)m
1. Let there be m−1 locations in [t1, t2]. The tortuosity
j=1 fi(tj+1)−fi(tj )2
of the segment is defined as κ =
fi(t2)−fi(t1)2
with tm+1 = t2. Partition asymmetry accounts for how
the size of a neuron tree varies within the neuron. We
use a variant of caulescence, proposed in [8], as a mea-
18
Tamal Batabyal et al.
sure of tree asymmetry. Caulescence at a bifurcation
l−r
location is evaluated by way of α =
l+r , where l is the
size of the left tree and r of the right tree of the bifurca-
tion vertex. We define the size of a tree by the number
of paths or equivalently the number of dendritic termi-
nals. Note that the quantity (l+r)+1 is the concurrence
value of the bifurcation vertex.
Weight determination
Let the combined distance vector containing the indi-
vidual feature distances be Df g = [d(bf g) d(C f g) d(λf g)
d(κf g) d(βf g) d(αf g)]T . The corresponding unknown
weight vector is δ = [δ1, ...δ6]. While comparing two
neurons of sizes N and M with N <= M , the distance
computation after applying the Munkres algorithm re-
peatedly will produce M pairs of paths, indicating M
such Df gs. The desired characteristic of each compo-
nent of δ is positivity. In addition, we enforce(cid:80) δi = 1,
implying a probability estimate. δi thus indicates the
relative importance of the feature υi.
We adopt the constrained maximizing-interclass -
minimizing-intraclass distances strategy to find our de-
sired δ. Mathematically,
Dz(Dz)T(cid:17)
δ
δopt = − arg min
δ
+δT(cid:16) S(cid:88)
1
2
τi
i=1
−ω1logδ + ω2
l=1
z=1
k=1
i,j=1
i<j
δT(cid:16) S(cid:88)
Mkl(cid:88)
Nj(cid:88)
Ni(cid:88)
Dz(Dz)T(cid:17)
Mkl(cid:88)
Ni(cid:88)
(cid:0) 6(cid:88)
δi − 1(cid:1)
k,l=1
k(cid:54)=l
z
δ
(5)
i=1
The first term in the above equation encompasses all
the distances between neurons from pairwise classes.
The second term encodes the intraclass distances, im-
plying the distances between neurons for each class. The
third term enforces positivity of each weight δi. This is
a logarithmic barrier penalty term that restricts the
evolution of δ at intermediate iterations to the region
where δ > ¯0. The last term accounts for the probabilis-
tic interpretation of δ. S is the number of classes.
Eq. 5 is solved by using gradient descent. The equa-
tion and its derivative can be simply written as,
L(δ) = − δT Πδ
δ − ω1logδ + ω2
+ δT
τiΠi
2
2
(cid:0)δ1 − 1(cid:1)
S(cid:88)
i=1
= −Πδ +
dL
dδ
τiΠiδ − ω1
δ
+ ω2
(6)
We use this derivative term in the following algorithm 1
to obtain optimal δ.
S(cid:88)
i=1
Algorithm 1: Find δ
Data: Π, Π1, Π2, ..., ΠS (for all classes);
Initialization: δcur, δtmp, τ1, τ2, ..., τS, ω1, ω2, Iter,
tol, η;
while iter < Iter do
while δcur − δtmp2 < tol do
D ←−(cid:80)S
k=1 τkΠk;
Der ←− −Πδ + Dδ − ω1
δcurr ←− δtmp;
δcurr ←− δcurr/(δcurr1);
δtmp ←− δtmp − ηDer;
δ + ω2;
iter ←− iter + 1;
ω1 ←− ω1/2;
ω2 ←− 2ω2;
τi ←− 1.1τi∀i(more intraclass compaction);
Distance between neurons
The algorithm to find distance between a pair of neu-
rons consists of four stages - finding self-similarity (routine-
1), remaining path assignment (routine-2), finding pairs
with hierarchy mismatch (routine-3) and reassignment
of the defective pairs (routine-4).
References
1. Ascoli, G.A., Alonso-Nanclares, L., Anderson, S.A., Bar-
rionuevo, G., Benavides-Piccione, R., Burkhalter, A.,
Buzs´aki, G., Cauli, B., DeFelipe, J., Fair´en, A., et al.:
Petilla terminology: nomenclature of features of gabaer-
gic interneurons of the cerebral cortex. Nature Reviews
Neuroscience 9(7), 557 (2008)
2. Ascoli, G.A., Donohue, D.E., Halavi, M.: Neuromorpho.
org: a central resource for neuronal morphologies. The
Journal of Neuroscience 27(35), 9247 -- 9251 (2007)
3. Basu, S., Condron, B., Acton, S.T.: Path2path: Hierar-
chical path-based analysis for neuron matching. In: 2011
IEEE International Symposium on Biomedical Imaging:
From Nano to Macro, pp. 996 -- 999. IEEE (2011)
4. Batabyal, T., Acton, S.T.: Neurosol: Automated classifi-
cation of neurons using the sorted laplacian of a graph.
In: Biomedical Imaging (ISBI 2017), 2017 IEEE 14th In-
ternational Symposium on, pp. 397 -- 400. IEEE (2017)
5. Batabyal, T., Acton, S.T.: Elasticpath2path: Automated
morphological classification of neurons by elastic path
matching. arXiv preprint arXiv:1802.06913 (2018)
6. Batabyal, T., Vaccari, A., Acton, S.T.: Neurobfd: Size-
independent automated classification of neurons using
conditional distributions of morphological features.
In:
Biomedical Imaging (ISBI 2018), 2018 IEEE 15th Inter-
national Symposium on, pp. 912 -- 915. IEEE (2018)
7. Bielza, C., Benavides-Piccione, R., L´opez-Cruz, P., Lar-
ranaga, P., DeFelipe, J.: Branching angles of pyramidal
cell dendrites follow common geometrical design princi-
ples in different cortical areas. Scientific reports 4, 5909
(2014)
NeuroPath2Path: Classification and elastic morphing between neuronal arbors using path-wise similarity
19
Fig. 18 This gallery of images captures the progressive evolution of paths from a Purkinje neuron to a granule one. The
granule neuron (426.5µm3 volume) is procured from the hippocampus (dentate gyrus) of a 5 months old mouse, containing 6
rooted paths. The Purkinje cell (13094µm3 volume) is sampled from the cerebellar cortex of a 35 day-old mouse, containing
304 paths. The evolution is represented in multiple arrays such that the ODD rows are read in the left-to-right and the EVEN
rows are read in the right-to-left fashion. In the first column, the top image is the granule cell and the bottom shows the
pyramidal cell. Volume-wise, the Purkinje neuron is significantly larger than the granule neuron. However, they are scaled for
visualization.
8. Brown, K.M., Gillette, T.A., Ascoli, G.A.: Quantifying
neuronal size: summing up trees and splitting the branch
difference. In: Seminars in cell & developmental biology,
vol. 19, pp. 485 -- 493. Elsevier (2008)
9. y Cajal, S.R.: Histologie du syst`eme nerveux de l'homme
et des vert´ebr´es: Ed. fran¸caise revue et mise a jour par
l'auteur. Trad. de l'espagnol par L. Azoulay. Inst. Ramon
y Cajal (1972)
10. Cervantes, E.P., Comin, C.H., Junior, R.M.C., da Fon-
toura Costa, L.: Morphological neuron classification
based on dendritic tree hierarchy. Neuroinformatics pp.
1 -- 15 (2018)
11. Fischler, M.A., Bolles, R.C.: Random sample consensus:
a paradigm for model fitting with applications to image
analysis and automated cartography. Communications of
the ACM 24(6), 381 -- 395 (1981)
12. Gasparini, S., Migliore, M., Magee, J.C.: On the initia-
tion and propagation of dendritic spikes in ca1 pyramidal
neurons. Journal of Neuroscience 24(49), 11046 -- 11056
(2004)
13. Genet, A., Grabarnik, P., Sekretenko, O., Pothier, D.:
Incorporating the mechanisms underlying inter-tree com-
petition into a random point process model to improve
spatial tree pattern analysis in forestry. Ecological mod-
elling 288, 143 -- 154 (2014)
14. Gillette, T., Ascoli, G.: Topological characterization of
neuronal arbor morphology via sequence representation.
i. Motif analysis (2015)
15. Gillette, T.A., Hosseini, P., Ascoli, G.A.: Topological
characterization of neuronal arbor morphology via se-
quence representation: Ii-global alignment. BMC bioin-
formatics 16(1), 209 (2015)
16. Glaser, J.R., Glaser, E.M.: Neuron imaging with neurolu-
cidaa pc-based system for image combining microscopy.
Computerized Medical Imaging and Graphics 14(5), 307 --
317 (1990)
17. Harary, F., et al.: Graph theory (1969)
18. Jan, Y.N., Jan, L.Y.: Branching out: mechanisms of den-
dritic arborization. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 11(5),
316 (2010)
19. Kanari, L., D(cid:32)lotko, P., Scolamiero, M., Levi, R., Shill-
cock, J., Hess, K., Markram, H.: A topological represen-
tation of branching neuronal morphologies. Neuroinfor-
matics 16(1), 3 -- 13 (2018)
20. Lin, Y., Yau, S.T.: Ricci curvature and eigenvalue es-
timate on locally finite graphs. Mathematical research
letters 17(2), 343 -- 356 (2010)
21. London, M., Hausser, M.: Dendritic computation. Annu.
Rev. Neurosci. 28, 503 -- 532 (2005)
22. L´opez-Cruz, P.L., Bielza, C., Larranaga, P., Benavides-
Piccione, R., DeFelipe, J.: Models and simulation of 3d
neuronal dendritic trees using bayesian networks. Neu-
roinformatics 9(4), 347 -- 369 (2011)
23. Meijering, E.: Neuron tracing in perspective. Cytometry
Part A 77(7), 693 -- 704 (2010)
20
Tamal Batabyal et al.
Algorithm 2: Find χ
Data: D, n1, n2 (n1 ≤ n2), Inf;
Output: pairList, dstSum
Initialization: dstSum ←− 0,
pairT mp ←− [1 : n2]T , count ←− 1,
pairList ←− [ ], Dc ←− D, dstB ←− [ ];
Routine 1: (Self-similarity)
while count ≤ (cid:98) n2
n1(cid:99) do
D ←− D (append rows with Inf);
pairL, dst ←− M unkres( D);
dstSum ←− dstSum + dst;
dstB ←− dstB ∪ dst;
pairT mp ←− pairT mp \ pairL[1 : n1]
((n2 − n1) dummy);
pairList ←− pairList ∪ pairT mp[pairL[1 :
n1]];
D ←− D[1 : n1, pairT mp];
count ←− count + 1;
n1(cid:99)n1;
n1(cid:99)n1 paths)
Routine 2: (Remaining n2 − (cid:98) n2
T ←− n2 − (cid:98) n2
D ←− DT ;
D ←− D (append rows with Inf);
pairL, dst ←− M unkres( D);
dstSum ←− dstSum + dst;
dstB ←− dstB ∪ dst;
pairList ←− pairList ∪ pairT mp[pairL[1 : T ]];
Routine 3: (Hierarchy mismatch)
dg ←− Hist[pairList[:, 1]]
deg ←− Hist[pairList[:, 2]] (second column);
md ←− M edian[dstB], sd ←− SD[dstB];
sk ←− Skewness[dstB];
if sk > 0 then
misalign2 ←− [ ];
listU ←− [ ];
for k ← 1 to length[IX] do
pvt ←− pairList[k, 1 : 2];
h1 ←− H[pvt[1]], h2 ←− H[pvt[2]](max
hierarchy);
if h1 − h2 > max[h1,h2]
IX ←− where[dstB > md + sd]
2
then
if deg[pvt[2]] < 2 then
misalign2 ←− misalign2 ∪ pvt[2];
misalign1 ←− misalign1 ∪ pvt[1];
dstSum ←− dstSum − dstB[k];
listU ←− listU ∩ pairList[k, :];
if listU (cid:54)= [ ] then
Del pairList[listU ]
Routine 4: (Reassignment)
for k = 1 to length[misalign2] do
col ←− misalign2[k];
row ←− arg minrow Dc[:, col];
dstSum ←− dstSum + Dc[row, col];
pairList ←− pairList ∪ [row, col];
for k = 1 to length[misalign1] do
if dg[misalign1[k]] > 1 then
row ←− misalign1[k];
col ←− arg mincol Dc[row, :];
dstSum ←− dstSum + Dc[row, col];
pairList ←− pairList ∪ [row, col];
24. Migliore, M., Shepherd, G.M.: Emerging rules for the dis-
tributions of active dendritic conductances. Nature Re-
views Neuroscience 3(5), 362 (2002)
25. Miina, J., Pukkala, T.: Application of ecological field the-
ory in distance-dependent growth modelling. Forest Ecol-
ogy and Management 161(1-3), 101 -- 107 (2002)
26. Munkres, J.: Algorithms for the assignment and trans-
portation problems. Journal of the society for industrial
and applied mathematics 5(1), 32 -- 38 (1957)
27. Murphy, S., Rokicki, K., Bruns, C., Yu, Y., Foster, L.,
Trautman, E., Olbris, D., Wolff, T., Nern, A., Aso, Y.,
et al.: The janelia workstation for neuroscience. Keystone
Big Data in Biology. San Francisco, CA (2014)
28. Myatt, D., Hadlington, T., Ascoli, G., Nasuto, S.:
Neuromantic -- from semi-manual to semi-automatic re-
construction of neuron morphology. Frontiers in neuroin-
formatics 6, 4 (2012)
29. Polavaram, S., Gillette, T.A., Parekh, R., Ascoli, G.A.:
Statistical analysis and data mining of digital recon-
structions of dendritic morphologies. Frontiers in neu-
roanatomy 8 (2014)
30. Puskas, N., Zaletel, I., Stefanovi´c, B.D., Ristanovi´c, D.:
Fractal dimension of apical dendritic arborization differs
in the superficial and the deep pyramidal neurons of the
rat cerebral neocortex. Neuroscience letters 589, 88 -- 91
(2015)
31. Romand, S., Wang, Y., Toledo-Rodriguez, M., Markram,
H.: Morphological development of thick-tufted layer v
pyramidal cells in the rat somatosensory cortex. Fron-
tiers in neuroanatomy 5, 5 (2011)
32. Samsonovich, A.V., Ascoli, G.A.: Morphological home-
ostasis in cortical dendrites. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences 103(5), 1569 -- 1574 (2006)
33. Sarkar, R., Mukherjee, S., Acton, S.T.: Shape descriptors
based on compressed sensing with application to neuron
matching. In: 2013 Asilomar Conference on Signals, Sys-
tems and Computers, pp. 970 -- 974. IEEE (2013)
34. Scorcioni, R., Polavaram, S., Ascoli, G.A.: L-measure:
a web-accessible tool for the analysis, comparison and
search of digital reconstructions of neuronal morpholo-
gies. Nature protocols 3(5), 866 (2008)
35. Sporns, O., Tononi, G., Kotter, R.: The human connec-
tome: a structural description of the human brain. PLoS
computational biology 1(4), e42 (2005)
36. Srivastava, A., Klassen, E., Joshi, S.H., Jermyn, I.H.:
Shape analysis of elastic curves in euclidean spaces. IEEE
Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelli-
gence 33(7), 1415 -- 1428 (2011)
NeuroPath2Path: Classification and elastic morphing between neuronal arbors using path-wise similarity
21
37. Stockley, E., Cole, H., Brown, A., Wheal, H.: A system
for quantitative morphological measurement and electro-
tonic modelling of neurons: three-dimensional reconstruc-
tion. Journal of neuroscience methods 47(1-2), 39 -- 51
(1993)
38. Vishwanathan, S.V.N., Schraudolph, N.N., Kondor, R.,
Borgwardt, K.M.: Graph kernels. Journal of Machine
Learning Research 11(Apr), 1201 -- 1242 (2010)
39. Wan, Y., Long, F., Qu, L., Xiao, H., Hawrylycz, M., My-
ers, E.W., Peng, H.: Blastneuron for automated compar-
ison, retrieval and clustering of 3d neuron morphologies.
Neuroinformatics 13(4), 487 -- 499 (2015)
40. Wen, Q., Chklovskii, D.B.: A cost -- benefit analysis of
neuronal morphology. Journal of neurophysiology 99(5),
2320 -- 2328 (2008)
41. Williams, S.R.: Spatial compartmentalization and func-
tional impact of conductance in pyramidal neurons. Na-
ture neuroscience 7(9), 961 (2004)
|
1304.4676 | 2 | 1304 | 2013-11-23T04:16:14 | Single-Neuron Criticality Optimizes Analog Dendritic Computation | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cond-mat.stat-mech",
"nlin.AO",
"physics.bio-ph",
"q-bio.SC"
] | Neurons are thought of as the building blocks of excitable brain tissue. However, at the single neuron level, the neuronal membrane, the dendritic arbor and the axonal projections can also be considered an extended active medium. Active dendritic branchlets enable the propagation of dendritic spikes, whose computational functions, despite several proposals, remain an open question. Here we propose a concrete function to the active channels in large dendritic trees. By using a probabilistic cellular automaton approach, we model the input-output response of large active dendritic arbors subjected to complex spatio-temporal inputs and exhibiting non-stereotyped dendritic spikes. We find that, if dendritic spikes have a non-deterministic duration, the dendritic arbor can undergo a continuous phase transition from a quiescent to an active state, thereby exhibiting spontaneous and self-sustained localized activity as suggested by experiments. Analogously to the critical brain hypothesis, which states that neuronal networks self-organize near a phase transition to take advantage of specific properties of the critical state, here we propose that neurons with large dendritic arbors optimize their capacity to distinguish incoming stimuli at the critical state. We suggest that "computation at the edge of a phase transition" is more compatible with the view that dendritic arbors perform an analog rather than a digital dendritic computation. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Single-neuron criticality optimizes analog dendritic computation
Leonardo L. Gollo,1, 2, ∗ Osame Kinouchi,3, 4, † and Mauro Copelli5, 4, ‡
1IFISC, Instituto de F´ısica Interdisciplinar y Sistemas Complejos (CSIC - UIB),
Campus Universitat de les Illes Balears, E-07122 Palma de Mallorca, Spain
2Systems Neuroscience Group, Queensland Institute of Medical Research, Brisbane, QLD 4006, Australia
3Faculdade de Filosofia, Ciencias e Letras de Ribeirao Preto, Universidade de Sao Paulo,
Avenida dos Bandeirantes 3900, 14040-901, Ribeirao Preto, SP, Brazil
4Center for Natural and Artificial Information Processing Systems - USP
5Departamento de F´ısica, Universidade Federal de Pernambuco, 50670-901 Recife, PE, Brazil
(Dated: August 5, 2018)
Neurons are thought of as the building blocks of excitable brain tissue. However, at the single
neuron level, the neuronal membrane, the dendritic arbor and the axonal projections can also be
considered an extended active medium. Active dendritic branchlets enable the propagation of den-
dritic spikes, whose computational functions, despite several proposals, remain an open question.
Here we propose a concrete function to the active channels in large dendritic trees. By using a
probabilistic cellular automaton approach, we model the input-output response of large active den-
dritic arbors subjected to complex spatio-temporal inputs and exhibiting non-stereotyped dendritic
spikes. We find that, if dendritic spikes have a non-deterministic duration, the dendritic arbor
can undergo a continuous phase transition from a quiescent to an active state, thereby exhibiting
spontaneous and self-sustained localized activity as suggested by experiments. Analogously to the
critical brain hypothesis, which states that neuronal networks self-organize near a phase transition
to take advantage of specific properties of the critical state, here we propose that neurons with large
dendritic arbors optimize their capacity to distinguish incoming stimuli at the critical state. We
suggest that "computation at the edge of a phase transition" is more compatible with the view that
dendritic arbors perform an analog rather than a digital dendritic computation.
Critical systems are organized in a fractal-like pattern
spanning across numerous temporal and spatial scales.
The brain has recently been included amongst abundant
physical and biological systems exhibiting traces of crit-
icality [1, 2].
In the past decade, several phenomena
suggestive of critical states have been observed in dif-
ferent systems: multielectrode data from cortical slices
in vitro [3 -- 5], anesthetized [6], awake [7] and behaving
animals [8]; human electrocorticography [9], electroen-
cephalography [10], magnetoencephalography [10, 11], as
well as functional magnetic resonance imaging [11, 12]
recordings. Together, these experiments suggest evidence
for the intrinsic pervasiveness of criticality into a wide
range of spatio-temporal brain scales.
The critical brain hypothesis offers an appealing solu-
tion to a long-lasting conundrum of neuroscience: how
can localized information (sometimes from very spe-
cific regions) propagate in the brain without a spa-
tial/temporal exponential decay or saturation [1, 13]?
Advantages of neuronal systems poised around a crit-
ical state include optimization of the dynamic range
of neuronal networks [14], as confirmed experimentally
[15], as well as transmission and storage of informa-
tion [3, 4, 16, 17]. However, a fundamental assumption
of the critical brain hypothesis has so far not been ex-
amined: is the single neuron the minimal dynamic unit
in neuronal networks, like a spin site in the Ising model
for ferromagnets (the prototypical system for phase tran-
sitions)? Or can critical phenomena associated with
phase transitions already occur at the single neuron level?
Adopting a statistical physics approach, we explore the
behavior of dendritic branchlets at the sub-cellular level
as forming a network of functional dynamical units.
Here we treat neurons with their extensive dendritic
trees as excitable media (see Fig. 1a). This task is far
from trivial because of the complexity [18, 19], the di-
versity of neurons [20], and the absence of information
about key elements governing the dynamics, such as how
the zoo of ionic channels is distributed along the den-
drites [21 -- 24].
In fact, there is an entire research area
concerned with biophysically detailed neuronal model-
ing [24 -- 27] and dendritic computation [28].
For our modeling purposes, we evoke the statistical
physics principle that emergent phenomena seem to de-
pend on only few characteristics such as symmetries,
dimensionality, network topology, type of coupling etc.
Hence the basic dynamical units (atoms, spins) need not
be modeled in detail [29]. Our cellular automaton ap-
proach to dendritic computation unveils the emergence
of critical phenomena at the single neuron level from a
large number of sub-cellular interacting units (dendritic
compartments).
We find that the dendritic arbor can fire spontaneously
when we take into account the fact that dendritic spikes
are non-stereotyped, that is, with variable durations [30].
In this case, a smooth continuous phase transition ap-
pears between rest and self-sustained dendritic activity.
At the interface between these states, there is a critical
regime, which optimizes the dynamic range of the input-
output response function of the neuron's dendritic arbor.
a
g=3
g=2
g=1
g=0
s
0
b
c
d
g
/ δ
~
1 p
{
dendritic
spikes a.u.
5 msec
FIG. 1. Model of an active dendritic tree with non-
stereotyped dendritic spikes.
(a), Excitable elements
(circles) connected (bars) in a Cayley tree topology with
G = 3 layers and coordination number z = 3 (one mother
and k = 2 daughter branches). Large green (yellow) arrow
illustrates forward (backward) propagation. (b)-(d), Biolog-
ically motivated dendritic spike with duration depending on
the distance from the soma as a net effect of variable den-
sity of ionic channels. Red arrows indicate that the site is
being stimulated (by an external input and/or by mother or
daughter branches), and 1
represents the average period of
pg
δ
dendritic spikes at layer g.
The presence of the phase transition can increase the
maximum neuronal signal compression capacity by up to
∼ 100 times.
In our critical-neuron model, the mini-
mal dynamic units are dendritic branchlets (or perhaps
patches of dendritic spines), so that even a single neu-
ron can have a highly nonlinear input-output response
function. This capability of a single neuron to compress
stimulus intensity varying over several orders of magni-
tude in a decade of output firing rate could be the basis
of psychophysical power laws [31]. In addition, such re-
finement in the basic dynamical unit corresponds to a
modeling improvement of spatial resolution of a few or-
ders of magnitude.
RESULTS
The overwhelming majority of models of criticality in
neuronal networks, if not all, neglect the characteristic
tree shape of neurons. Typically, the collective behav-
ior studied is generated by oversimplified point-like neu-
rons with no spatial structure [4, 14, 32 -- 36]. Dropping
this strong assumption unveils a new sublevel of neu-
ronal dynamics where concepts from statistical physics
can be applied. In previous work we introduced a simple
model of active dendrites [37]. In the model, nonlinear
excitable waves of activity, not accounted for by passive
dendrites and linear cable theory, propagate and annihi-
late upon collisions, giving rise to large signal compres-
sion abilities. Weak inputs are highly amplified whereas
2
strong inputs are not subjected to early saturation. The
dynamic range, which quantifies how many decades of
stimulus intensity can be distinguished by the excitable
medium, attains large values. This property has proven
robust against several model variants [37, 38].
In fact, excitable media with a tree structure per-
formed better than other network topologies [39, 40].
Moreover, the system dynamics in a tree topology al-
lows analytical treatment due to the absence of loops.
The model was quantitatively understood by solving the
master equation under an excitable-wave (EW) mean-
field approximation [38]. However, phase transitions are
not observed in such dendritic arbors when the dynam-
ics of the excitable elements (active dendritic branch-
lets) is deterministic.
In this paper, we study a differ-
ent dendritic arbor with non-stereotyped dendritic spikes
that exhibit probabilistic spike duration [30], as well as
non-homogeneous spike duration [41], introduced by a
layer-dependent function. Such biologically motivated
improvements in the model give rise to a new dynamical
regime consisting of a self-sustained state with sponta-
neous activity that emerges through a non-equilibrium
phase transition.
Physiological experiments show that dendritic spikes
depend on several voltage-gated ionic channels. Due
to the non-homogeneous density of channels along the
proximal-distal axis, dendritic spikes can present dis-
tinct dynamical features in different regions of the den-
dritic tree. Dominated by the slow calcium-dependent
potentials [27, 41, 42] or N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA)
potentials [30], the dendritic spikes/plateaus have vari-
able duration (see for example Ref. [30] and references
therein), and the duration of active periods can become
effectively longer at more distal sites [41], as illustrated in
Figs. 1b through d. These responses account for a variety
of active behaviors including dendritic spikes with longer
and more variable duration than sodium-dependent so-
matic spikes [30].
In our previous models [37, 38], other parameters have
been studied, but the time-length of the spikes that we
introduce here proves to be a crucial factor. Such vari-
ability in the duration of the spike has been shown to
shape the network dynamics [43], and to enhance the
computational capability of neuronal networks [44].
In
the present model, the variable duration of dendritic
spikes plays an important role in dendritic computation
because it is capable of controlling the emergence of a
phase transition. Evidence for both sides of this contin-
uous non-equilibrium phase transition has been reported
experimentally [23, 41]. Several different patterns of ac-
tivity observed experimentally are candidates for the ac-
tive phase of the putative phase transition we propose:
plateaus [30, 45], single spikes [42, 46, 47], bursts [48, 49],
and oscillations [50, 51].
Model. As illustrated in Fig. 1a, we model the den-
dritic arbor as connected probabilistic cellular automata
with a Cayley tree topology of active branchlets capa-
ble of transmitting dendritic spikes. The states update
in parallel with discrete time steps of δt = 1 ms. Ex-
ploring the idea of a dendritic branchlet as a fundamen-
tal functional unit of the nervous system (see Ref. [52]
and references therein), we consider dendritic branch-
lets as excitable units. Each excitable unit (the i-th
dendritic branchlet) has three possible discrete states
si(t) ∈ {0, 1, 2}. A quiescent site (si(t) = 0) may be-
come active in the next time step (si(t + 1) = 1) either
by external driving or by propagation of an excitable-
wave from an active neighbor with probability pλ. Ex-
ternal input arrives at quiescent sites with probability
ph = 1 − exp(−hδt) per time step, where h stands for
the rate of independent Poisson processes and may vary
in a range of several orders of magnitude. An active site
(si(t) = 1) becomes refractory (si(t + 1) = 2) with prob-
ability pg
δ at each time step, where g indicates the layer
that the site belongs to (see Fig. 1c). To close the cycle,
refractory sites become quiescent with probability pγ (we
fix pγ = 1/2 throughout this paper).
The probabilistic nature of our model takes into ac-
count the fact that the density of ion channels in a
given spatial region is not always large enough to al-
low their mean activation (or inactivation, or deactiva-
tion etc.) to be described by a continuous variable, and
hence fluctuations around the mean are not negligible.
Such non-deterministic and irregular factors have already
been proven to play a crucial role in shaping the neuronal
excitability [53, 54], the propagation [55] and the dura-
tion of dendritic spikes [30]. Despite the fact that sub-
threshold dendritic activity can influence the integration
of synaptic signals [51], we assume a large attenuation of
subthreshold activity to an extent that a boost of activ-
ity is required for activity propagation. It is noteworthy
that our previous model [37], which features this very
same assumption, has been recently validated by detailed
morphologically reconstructed multi-compartmental cell
models with active dendrites but also including passive
propagation of subthreshold activity [56].
The model generalizes our previous work [37, 38] by
introducing a probabilistic spike duration, which is mo-
tivated by experiments (see Ref. [30] for a recent re-
view paper).
In what follows, we first consider a sim-
ple homogeneous model with spike duration controlled
by a uniform probability pg
δ = pδ ≤ 1, ∀ g (our previous
model [37] is thus recovered when pδ = 1). For pδ ≃ 0
the spike duration becomes unreasonably long. Thus, our
attention is mostly concentrated in the regime between
the extremes (0 < pδ < 1). Whereas the stereotyped
sodium-dependent somatic spikes last typically 1 ms, the
duration of dendritic activity exhibits large variability de-
pending on the type of neuron and ion channels involved,
and fall within the range of 1-10 milliseconds (or even
3
longer [30]). This is captured in our model by the fact
that our time step δt = 1 ms, and the time spent in the
active state is about p−1
δ : For pδ = 1, the duration of our
model dendritic spike is 1 ms, and for pδ = 0.1 the aver-
age duration would be 10 ms. We start by analysing this
model with homogeneous spatial distribution of spike du-
ration, which has some advantages: it is clear, intuitive,
and allows analytical insights about its phase transition,
which is controlled by pλ and pδ.
Next, we study a more realistic scenario based on the
relevant physiological evidence previously described: the
model assumes that the spike duration depends on the
proximal distance, such as previously reported in the
Purkinje cell [41]. Owing to the absence of a clear func-
tional dependence in the literature, for simplicity, we con-
sider a linear dependence pg
G α, where G = 10
(unless otherwise stated) stands for the tree size, and the
parameter α (0 ≤ α ≤ 1) controls the inhomogeneity.
δ = 1 − 0.9 g
To characterize the dynamical regimes of our system,
we must define our order parameter [29]. The main order
parameter of interest here is the stationary firing rate of
the proximal site s0 (see Fig. 1a):
F =
1
T
T
Xt=1
δs0(t),1 ,
(1)
where T is an averaging time window and δi,j is the Kro-
necker delta (by definition, δi,j = 1 if i = j, and zero
otherwise). The proximal dendrite firing rate F is bio-
logically interesting because it provides the main input to
the neuronal soma and can be thought of as proportional
to the neuronal firing rate. Notice that s0 and hence F
are functions of the external input with intensity h. One
of our main foci will be on the response function F (h).
Phase diagram without external input.
It is in-
structive to analyze the complex spatio-temporal dynam-
ics of an extensive dendritic tree in the simplest sce-
nario, when average spike durations are homogeneous
(α = 0) and the system is subjected to no external driv-
ing (h = 0). The absence of stimulus is a somewhat ar-
tificial condition, but very informative because it crisply
uncovers the critical region. Starting with the states of
nodes randomly distributed according to a uniform dis-
tribution among the three possible states, we follow the
dynamics for a sufficiently long time (T ∼ 104 time steps)
until a stationary state is reached. If the tree reaches an
active and stable level, in which the activity in the den-
dritic tree does not vanish and the firing rate of the proxi-
mal site is nonzero, the system is said to be supercritical.
On the contrary, if the activity of the system vanishes
rapidly, the system is subcritical. For large systems, the
fate of the system depends weakly on the initial condi-
tion and is mainly determined by control parameters pλ
(which controls the coupling between branchlets) and pδ
(which controls the average spike duration). The critical
a
δ
p
b
δ
p
c
δ
p
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
F
(
m
s
−
1
)
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
R
e
t
u
r
n
n
g
i
0.5
0.45
0.4
0.35
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
p
r
o
b
a
b
i
l
i
t
y
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
pλ
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
F
(
m
s
−
1
)
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
pλ
FIG. 2. Continuous phase transition in active dendritic
trees with non-stereotyped dendritic spikes. (a), Aver-
age firing rate as a function of pλ (which governs the coupling
among branchlets) and pδ (which governs the average spike
duration) in numerical simulations for tree size G = 10. (b),
Returning probability (see Methods for details) as a function
of pλ and pδ. (c), Same as panel (a) but for the general-
ized excitable-wave mean-field approximation (see Methods
for details).
regime occurs at the border between the sub- and super-
critical regimes, where the activity level vanishes slowly
and without a characteristic time scale [14].
As represented in Fig. 2a, we numerically find the crit-
ical curve of the parameter plane (pλ, pδ) in a finite tree
with G = 10. The critical curve corresponds to the bor-
der between the absorbing state with F (h = 0) = 0 (blue)
and the active state with F (h = 0) > 0 (red). Naturally,
a true phase transition occurs only for infinite systems,
but for moderately large systems we already observe ac-
tivity that persists for simulation times much longer than
any relevant biological time scale. It is important to em-
phasize that no active phase exists for dendritic spikes
with a deterministic duration, pδ = 1. Only when they
are non-stereotyped (pδ < 1) does self-sustained activity
become possible.
4
To qualitatively understand why the activity dies out
in a specific part of the parameter space of a finite tree,
we define the returning probability R. It corresponds to
the probability that an active site A stimulates a given
quiescent neighbor B and receives back the stimulus at
later times after performing a complete cycle (i.e., after
going through the refractory (sA = 2) and the quies-
cent (sA = 0) states). A necessary (but not sufficient)
condition for a network without loops to exhibit a stable
self-sustained state (and consequently a phase transition)
is that R 6= 0. A nonzero returning probability is neces-
sary for the persistence of the self-sustained state because
otherwise the activity ceases after a few time steps due
to collisions of the excitable waves with the boundaries
(layer G) and with one another. The Methods section il-
lustrates the fastest example of a successful process of re-
turning activity, which requires at least three time steps,
and extends the calculation for arbitrarily long two-site
processes. Figure 2b shows R(pλ, pδ), in which a transi-
tion similar to that of Fig. 2a is observed. A comparison
between them confirms that R 6= 0 is a necessary but not
sufficient condition for an active phase to emerge.
Another analytical approach to shed light on the re-
sults is to employ one of the many mean-field approxi-
mations available in the statistical physics literature [29].
We have previously developed an excitable-wave (EW)
mean-field approximation that focuses on the wave prop-
agation direction, making it particularly suitable for ex-
citable waves on a tree [38]. In the Methods section we
describe a generalized version of the approximation to
account for non-stereotyped dendritic spikes. As Fig. 2c
shows, the phase transition observed in the simulations
can be qualitatively described by the generalized EW
(GEW) mean-field approximation.
Neuronal response to external
input. From
herein, we focus on the more relevant scenario in which
a neuron has to somehow cope with information arriv-
ing stochastically at its thousands of synapses. We make
the simplest assumption that, at each branchlet, the av-
erage excess of incoming excitatory post-synaptic poten-
tials (EPSPs), as compared to inhibitory post-synaptic
potentials (IPSPs), can be modeled by an independent
Poisson process with rate h. We study the response func-
tion F (h) (averaged over T = 104 time steps and five
realizations) and its dependence on model parameters.
Figure 3a depicts three response functions F (h; pλ) for
a fixed pδ, exemplifying one response function of each
kind:
subcritical (triangles, blue), critical (closed cir-
cles, black) and supercritical (open circles, red). Al-
ternatively, for a fixed pλ, the critical line can also be
crossed by varying pδ, as depicted by Fig. 3b.
In this
case, the maximum firing rate displays its dependence
on pδ: Fmax = (1 + 3pδ)−1.
For some classes of dendrites, it can be more realistic
to employ our heterogeneous model, with α > 0. We con-
5
pλ= 0.755
pδ= 0.7
pδ= 0.9
pδ=1
10-7
10-5
10-3
10-1
101
m= 0.11
α= 0.04
F>0
F=0
0.01 0.1
α
1
10-1
101
1
λ
p
0.6
0.2
10-3
h (ms-1)
a
0.3
0.2
)
1
-
s
m
(
F
0.1
pδ= 0.9
Fmax
F0.9
F0.1
Fmin
∆=20 dB
h0.1
h0.9
0
10-7
c
0.2
)
1
-
s
m
(
F
0.1
10-5
10-3
10-1
101
pλ= 0.85
α= 0.4
α= 0.04
b
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
d
10-1
10-3
0
10-7
10-5
10-3
h (ms-1)
10-1
101
10-7
10-5
FIG. 3. Response functions and phase diagram. (a), Response curves F (h) for pλ = 0.5, 0.755, 1 (from right to left).
Horizontal lines and vertical arrows show the relevant parameters for calculating the dynamic range ∆ (see Eq. (2)). (b),
Response curves dependence on pδ for homogeneous distribution pg
δ = pδ ∀ g. Symbols connected by dashed lines represent
simulation results whereas continuous lines represent the generalized excitable-wave (GEW) mean-field approximation. (c) and
(d), Response curves dependence on g, i.e., pg
G α. (d), Family of response curves for pλ = 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 0.85, 0.9, 1
(from right to left). Solid line represents a power law with exponent m = 0.11, which serves as a guide to the eye for the
simulation results for the critical value pλ = 0.85. Inset: phase diagram. Tree size is G = 10 for all panels.
δ = 1 − 0.9 g
sider α varying in a logarithmic range of several decades
because the phase transition already occurs for α ≪ 1. In
this instance, the phase transition is controlled by both
pλ and α, giving rise to a critical curve in parameter
space, as depicted in the inset of Fig. 3d. Analogously
to the homogeneous case, for fixed pλ the transition de-
pends on α, as depicted in Fig. 3c. For both homoge-
neous and heterogeneous models (solid line of Figs. 3b
and c), the GEW mean-field approximation captures par-
ticularly well the behavior of both sub- and supercritical
curves but fails to capture the strong amplification of the
critical curves under weak external driving. As shown
in the family of curves for fixed α displayed in Fig. 3d,
the critical curve has a very small exponent (m ≃ 0.11),
which cannot be correctly described by mean-field ap-
proximations. This exponent m is similar to a Stevens
psychophysical response exponent [31] observed at the
single-neuron scale [37], as had been previously noticed
at the level of a neuronal ensemble [14, 57, 58].
Excitable networks have a recognized ability to com-
press several decades of input rate in a single decade
of output rate [14, 36 -- 40, 57]. This information pro-
cessing capacity emerges exclusively from local
inter-
actions between the excitable elements. A large dy-
namic range is robust, being also obtained for mod-
els with increasing levels of biophysical realism, such as
networks of FitzHugh-Nagumo and Hodgkin-Huxley ele-
ments [57, 59], as well as more sophisticated models based
on detailed anatomical information of the retina [56, 60].
The definition of dynamic range is illustrated in
Fig. 3a [14]. We start by neglecting the regions of the re-
sponse curves which are close to the detection threshold
Fmin or the saturation level Fmax. According to a con-
ventional definition, only the interval between F0.1 and
F0.9 (arbitrarily defined within 10% of the plateau levels)
properly codes the input. Those firing rates correspond
to external driving with rates h0.1 and h0.9. The dy-
namic range is the range (measured in decibels) between
h0.1 and h0.9, i.e.,
∆ ≡ 10 log10(cid:18) h0.9
h0.1(cid:19) .
(2)
The phase transition is an important feature for signal
compression. Comparing the different regimes, as de-
picted for instance in Fig. 3a, a simple reasoning allows
one to understand why the critical curve optimizes the
a
)
B
d
(
∆
c
)
B
d
(
∆
60
50
40
30
20
60
50
40
30
20
pδ=0.9
G=10
G=7
b
60
50
40
)
B
d
(
pδ= 0.5
pδ= 0.9
6
x
a
m
∆
30
G=4
20
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
2
4
pδ=1
6
G
8
10
G=10
α=1
α=0.4
α=10-4
0
0.2
0.4
pλ
0.6
0.8
1
d
60
50
G=10
)
B
d
(
40
x
a
m
∆
30
20
10-4
G=7
G=5
10-3
10-2
α
10-1
1
FIG. 4. Dynamic range ∆. (a) and (b), for homogeneous distribution of pδ. (c) and (d), for layer-dependent distributions:
pg
δ = 1 − 0.9 g
In each curve phase transitions
occur only at and on the right hand side of arrows. Symbols connected by dashed lines represent simulation results whereas
continuous lines represent the generalized excitable-wave (GEW) mean-field approximation.
G α. (b) and (d) depicts ∆max which is the maximum of the ∆(pλ) curve.
compressing capacity [14]. The subcritical curves cannot
amplify small external stimuli, since the activity from in-
coming pulses vanishes exponentially fast in space and
time. At the other extreme, for supercritical curves, al-
most any pulse initiates the self-sustained network ac-
tivity for arbitrarily long time periods, masking the re-
sponse to weak stimuli. However, when the network has
the correct critical parameters, the spontaneous network
activity is composed of neuronal avalanches launched by
spontaneous fluctuations of the system. In the presence
of an external field h, such avalanches add and super-
pose, creating the response function F (h) (analogous to
magnetization for non-zero fields in magnetic systems).
In this case, the network dynamic range is optimized.
Since phase transitions are properly defined only for in-
finite systems, we have investigated the effects of system
size in our model.
It turns out that, even for moder-
ately large systems (e.g. G = 10, as in Figs. 2 and 3),
self-sustained activity survives for a period of time which
is much longer than any relevant characteristic time for
neuronal processing (T ∼ 104 time steps ∼10 seconds),
which is the operational marker that we have employed
for the transition. Its occurrence is associated with the
peaks in dynamic range shown in Fig. 4a.
In small trees, activity dies out rapidly due to wave
collisions with the boundaries, preventing self-sustained
activity. Taking for example the case of G = 4 in Fig. 4a,
the maximum ∆max (of the ∆ vs. pλ curve) occurs at
pλ = 1, meaning that finite size effects masks the (infi-
nite size) phase transition. Larger trees, in contrast, can
exhibit ∆max = ∆(pλ c) for weaker coupling revealing the
presence of a phase transition at pλ c(G) < 1. The larger
is the tree, the smaller is the pλ c(G) (Fig. 4a), and the
larger is the ∆max (Fig. 4b).
As presented in Fig. 2, pδ = 1 prevents an active state.
However, for pδ < 1 a phase transition to an active state
occurs in large enough trees. The black arrows in Fig. 4b
represent the minimum tree size that gives rise to our
operationally defined transition for pδ = 0.5 (G = 4),
and pδ = 0.9 (G = 6).
The optimization of the dynamic range at the critical
value (Fig. 4c), and the growth of the maximum dynamic
range with the tree size (Fig. 4d) are also observed in the
model with non-uniform spike duration. In this more re-
alistic model version, the phase transition vanishes for
α ∼ 0, as depicted in the inset of Fig. 3d, since in such
case the spike duration is deterministic across the tree.
Increasing α from zero, ∆max(α) grows up to a maximum
around the region where the phase transition appears
(represented by arrows in Fig. 4d). As shown in Fig. 4c,
larger values of α lead to a phase transition with smaller
critical coupling pλ c. On the other hand, as depicted in
Fig. 4d, the ∆max(α) curves show plateaus with heights
and widths that both increase with tree size. This sug-
gests that large active dendritic trees with non-uniform
spike duration lead to a large dynamic range, a result
whose robustness is attested by the width of the plateaus.
In particular, the difference in dynamic range for an op-
timized α compared with the α = 0 case is remarkable,
attaining about 20 dB for G = 5 (Fig. 4d).
DISCUSSION
We have shown that the idea of a critical network of
excitable elements being able to optimally process incom-
ing stimuli can be applied at the subcellular (dendritic)
scale. Instead of a network of excitable point-like neu-
rons connected by synapses, here we have shown that
electrically connected excitable dendritic branchlets can
cause a dendritic arbor of a single neuron to undergo a
phase transition. The key ingredient for this scenario is
stochasticity in the duration of dendritic spikes.
Several experiments indicate that a dendritic spike at
a distal site is usually not strong enough to trigger a
somatic action potential [55]. This suggests that real
dendrites ought not typically show deterministic signal
propagation (that is, pλ < 1). In the present model, tak-
ing for instance a dendrite with tree size G = 10 and
probability of activity propagation pλ = 0.5, the proba-
bility for a most distal dendritic spike to propagate all
over to the proximal site and potentially generate a spike
is very small: (0.5)10 ≃ 10−3. Thus, the model is in ac-
cordance with experimental wisdom. Remarkably, when-
ever the dendritic parameters lie near the silent/active
phase transition, our results prove that non-reliable den-
dritic spike propagation is compatible with an optimal
dynamic range.
We have examined the implications of variable den-
dritic spikes (non-homogeneous and non-deterministic)
for dendritic computation. We have shown that a neces-
sary condition for a phase transition to occur in active
dendrites is that the returning probability R be nonzero,
which in turn can only occur with variable dendritic dura-
tion (pδ < 1). In an attempt to incorporate more details
on dendritic spikes, we have also modeled different spa-
tial functions of average spike duration, and showed that
our main results are robust in that parameter space.
While the variable-duration criterion must be satisfied
to give rise to a critical neuron, it does not play such
a crucial role in giving rise to a critical neuronal net-
work [43]. The key difference between the two spatial
scales is the topology: due to inhibitory signaling mech-
anisms during growth [61], a dendritic tree contains no
loops, whereas in neuronal networks they abound. The
possibility of criticality at both scales naturally raises
7
the question:
if neurons can be critical, why should we
need critical networks? We propose that the answer de-
pends on the type of neuronal computation and the scale
at which it occurs. In the cases where the processing is
distributed among a large number of neurons with small
dendritic trees, it is plausible to look at point-like neurons
as the basic units of a larger system which, via balanced
synapses, can tune itself to a collective critical regime. By
contrast, single-neuron criticality could play a computa-
tional role in cases where neurons have extended den-
dritic trees and therefore must cope with large variations
of synaptic input (such as olfactory mitral cells or cere-
bellar Purkinje cells, for instance). Clearly, in principle
nothing prevents the mechanisms at both scales from act-
ing together.
The input-output response function of a critical neuron
amplifies small-intensity inputs while preventing early
saturation when subjected to large-intensity inputs. The
response function follows a slow-increasing power-law
function F ∼ hm, in which m corresponds to a rather tiny
exponent m ≃ 0.11, as shown in Fig. 3d. Such a slow-
increasing function could be easily confounded with a log-
arithmic (Weber-Fechner's psychophysical) law [31, 57].
These results strengthen previous suggestions that a sys-
tem poised at a critical point is a natural candidate
to explain how m < 1 Stevens' power-law exponents
emerge [14].
Our simple model yields similar results to those ob-
tained with detailed compartmental modeling of mor-
phologically reconstructed dendrites: the maximum dy-
namic range a dendritic arbor can attain grows with the
tree size [56]. This supports the previous proposal that
neurons with large dendritic arbors might have grown
to attain such impressive size and complexity in order
to enhance their capacity to distinguish the amount of
external driving [37, 38].
Owing to our irresistible tendency of comparing brain
processes with whichever technology happens to be dom-
inant at the time, the term dendritic computation is typi-
cally associated with a symbolic and digital-like informa-
tion processing [21]. However, dendritic trees are living
tissues that change all the time, growing and retracting
branchlets, spines and synapses. For example, 30% of
spine surface retracts in hippocampal neurons over the
rat estrous cycle [62]. This, we believe, does not seem
compatible with a fixed circuitry implementing, say, log-
ical gates. In contrast, our framework suggests that den-
dritic arbors perform a robust analog computation, which
is resilient to disturbances of tree properties. For in-
stance, pruning half of the tree corresponds to changing
from G to G − 1, which amounts to a small decrease in
the dynamic range.
In contrast to physical systems, biological systems can
approach the critical state through homeostatic mech-
anisms [33, 63]. This self-organized tuning is essential
for processing information over a large range of stimulus
intensities. We believe that critical neurons do indeed
exist, but experimental limitations or lack of a clear the-
oretical framework possibly prevented spatio-temporal
neuronal criticality from having been reported in the lit-
erature to date. It is important to emphasize, however,
that our model focusses on a regime dominated by the ac-
tive propagation of activity (dendritic spikes). Whether
or not a phase transition occurs in a regime where active
as well as passive mechanisms coexist remains untested
and should be investigated in future models and experi-
ments.
Experimental confirmation of single-neuron criticality
requires spatial and temporal recording resolutions at the
edge of current available techniques. Several lines of ev-
idence already suggest critical phenomena at the neuron
level. In vivo long-range inter-spike time interval correla-
tions, which may have originated from a critical neuron,
have been reported in human neurons from hippocam-
pus [64] and amygdala [65], as well as in rat neurons
from the leech ganglia and the hippocampus [66]. Fur-
thermore, neglecting the extensive spatial features of neu-
rons, criticality in neuronal excitability has recently been
proposed [35].
Signs of a self-sustained state could be associated to
patterns of dendritic activation: spikes, plateaus, bursts,
and oscillations [41]. Evidently, dendritic trees can also
be on the other side of the transition, showing a silent
or rest state. Our model predicts a continuous phase
transition so that criticality lies between such subcritical
(silent) and supercritical (self-sustained active) regimes.
We speculate that adaptation and homeostatic mecha-
nisms, similar to those discussed in Refs. [33, 63], could
finely tune a self-organized critical state (or more pre-
cisely, a self-organized quasi-critical state [63]). Such
homeostatic mechanisms, conceivably present at the den-
dritic level, will be presented in a forthcoming paper.
On the computational side, our cellular automaton
model can be generalized so that each branchlet is
modeled by a detailed biophysical compartment with a
plethora of ion channels [56], coupled with (noisy) axial
resistances. However, as in the proverbial arbor that pre-
vents us from seeing the forest, we must be aware that de-
tailed biophysical modeling may hamper us from detect-
ing phase transitions if the model has few compartments.
Our statistical physics model, with simple excitable units
but connected in a large dendritic network, enables us to
see the forest.
METHODS
Returning probability calculation.
The return-
ing probability R > 0 is a necessary condition for a phase
transition. For the phase transition between quiescent
and self-sustained states to occur the system must allow
8
A
1
2
0
1
pλ
pδ
γp
t
t+1
t+2
t+3
pλ
B
0
1
1
2
1−
pδ
pδ
FIG. 5. Example of returning activity. An active site
A stimulates its neighbor B (red arrow) and receives back
the activity three time steps later. This process involves a
series of intermediate steps. Site A must pass through the
refractory (sA(t + 1) = 2) and quiescent (sA(t + 2) = 0) states
before becoming active (sA(t + 3) = 1) again. Moreover, site
B must be kept in the active state (sB(t + 1) = 1) for at
least one time step (sB(t + 2) = 1) in order to be able to
excite back the susceptible A site (sA(t + 2) = 0). Therefore
a nonzero persistence probability (1 − pδ > 0) is fundamental
for a nonzero returning probability (R > 0).
the self-sustained activity to be kept for arbitrarily long
times. In a finite network without loops, such as a Cay-
ley tree, this condition is only satisfied if the activity can
go back and forth between two neighbor sites, say A and
B, as illustrated in Fig. 5. Otherwise, in the absence of
external driving, the system must go to the rest state
(regardless of the initial condition) after a maximum of
2G + 1 time steps.
It is possible to calculate the returning probability be-
tween two neighbor sites that obey the cyclic cellular
automata rules. The example of Fig. 5 can be com-
puted directly. Considering the initial condition at time
t, sA(t) = 1 and sB(t) = 0, there is a unique possible path
for the excitable wave to go back and forth after three
time steps. Notice that, by construction, sA(t) must com-
plete the cycle (i.e., it must go through states sA = 2
and sA = 0), since we have excluded the trivial solu-
tion: sA(t) = 1, ∀t. The final configuration sA(t + 3) = 1
and sB(t + 3) = 2 is therefore reached with probability
p2
δ(1 − pδ)p2
λpγ, where pδpγpλ is the probability of site A
to go throughout the cycle, and pλ(1 − pδ)pδ is the prob-
ability of site B to receive the input, to remain active,
and finally to become refractory.
This example is the simplest one.
In general, how-
ever, there are infinitely many possibilities that must be
included in a full calculation of R. The configuration
sA = 2 and sB = 1, which was depicted at time t + 1
in Fig. 5, could have also be found at later times: t + 2,
t + 3 and so on, leading to identical final configuration
sA = 1 and sB = 2. The calculation of the returning
probability which accounts for all the possible intermedi-
ate steps, considering that site B has just been activated
(sB(t + 1) = 1), involves three sums of infinite geometric
series, S1, S2 and S3. Site A can spend arbitrarily long
periods active (∝ S1), refractory (∝ S2), or quiescent
(∝ S3) and nevertheless receive back the excitable wave,
given that the pivot site B remains active in the mean-
time. Finally, without loss of generality, we can ignore
the final state of site B to find the returning probability
after infinitely many time steps:
where
R = pδpγ(1 − pδ)p2
λS1S2S3 ,
S1 =
S2 =
S3 =
1
1 − (1 − pδ)2 ,
1
1 − (1 − pγ)(1 − pδ)
1
1 − (1 − pλ)(1 − pδ)
,
.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
Equations (3)-(6) were used in Fig. 2b. However, this
result can also be extended to account for the heteroge-
neous case with pδ belonging to different layers (a and
b). The returning probability Ra,b turns out to be
Ra,b = pa
δ pγ(1 − pb
δ)p2
λ Sa,b
1 Sa,b
2 Sa,b
3
where
Sa,b
1 =
Sa,b
2 =
Sa,b
3 =
1
1 − (1 − pa
δ )(1 − pb
δ)
1
1 − (1 − pγ)(1 − pb
δ)
1
1 − (1 − pλ)(1 − pb
δ)
,
,
.
,
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
the
Generalized excitable-wave mean-field approx-
imation. This approximation generalizes
re-
cently proposed excitable-wave (EW) mean-field calcu-
lation [38]. Here, the scope of the approximation is en-
larged to account for non-stereotyped dendritic spikes
with probabilistic spike duration (pδ ≤ 1) and non-
homogeneous spatial distributions (pδ(g)). This is a
single-site mean-field approximation, but it keeps track
of the excitable-wave direction of propagation. Remark-
ably, the system response is better captured by this ap-
proximation than by the traditional two-site mean-field
approximation [38].
First we explain the notation and then recall the sys-
tem master equations. Assuming that at time t a site at
generation g is in state x; its mother site at generation
g − 1 is in state y; and i (j) of its daughter branches at
generation g +1 are in state z (w) etc., the joint probabil-
ity of this configuration reads as: P g
We also employ the usual normalization conditions
t (x; y; w1, w2). Thus, the
t (cid:0)y; x; z(i), w(j), . . .(cid:1).
t (y; x; w1, w2, w3) = P g
Pw3 P g
master equations for arbitrary coordination number z =
k + 1 and layers 0 < g < G is given by [38]:
9
t+1(; 1; ) = P g
P g
Xi=0
·
t (; 0; ) − (1 − ph)
k
λ(cid:18)k
i(cid:19)(−1)iP g
(cid:20)pi
λ (cid:18)k
i(cid:19)(−1)iP g
+(1 − pδ)P g
−βpi+1
t (; 1; ) ,
t (cid:16); 0; 1(i)(cid:17)
t (cid:16)1; 0; 1(i)(cid:17)(cid:21)
P g
t+1(; 2; ) = pδP g
P g
t+1(; 0; ) = 1 − P g
t (; 1; ) + (1 − pγ)P g
t (; 2; ) ,
t+1(; 1; ) − P g
t+1(; 2; ) ,
(11)
(12)
(13)
t (y; x; w(0)) ≡ P g
where P g
t (y; x; ) is a two-site joint prob-
ability. For simplicity, we also drop the excess of notation
symbols (;), such that P g
t (; x; ) which is
the probability of finding at time t a site at generation g
in state x (regardless of its neighbors).
t (x) stands for P g
Equations controlling the active state for sites belong-
ing to the first (g = 0) and last (g = G) layer can be
obtained from straightforward modifications of Eq. (11),
yielding:
t (; 0; ) − (1 − ph)
k+1
t+1(; 1; ) = P 0
P 0
λ(cid:18)k + 1
(cid:20)pi
Xi=0
+(1 − pδ)P 0
t (; 1; ) ,
·
i (cid:19)(−1)iP 0
t (cid:16); 0; 1(i)(cid:17)(cid:21)
P G
t+1(; 1; ) = P G
t (; 0; ) + (1 − ph)(cid:2)βpλP G
t (1; 0; )(cid:3)
+(1 − pδ)P G
t (; 1; ) ,
(14)
(15)
while equations controlling the refractory (12) and quies-
cent (13) states remain unchanged. The full description
of the dynamics requires higher-order terms (infinitely
many in the limit G → ∞), but, as we show below,
Eqs. (11)-(13) are enough for the GEW approximation.
The rationale for the EW approximation (restricted to
pδ = 1) is simple [38]:
in an excitable tree, activity is
decomposed in forward- and backward-propagating ex-
citable waves. We separate (for g > 0) the active state
(1) into three different active states: (1A), (1B), and
(1C), as represented in Fig. 6. P g
t (1A) (black) corre-
sponds to the density of active sites which received an
external input and thus generates excitable-wave prop-
agating both forwards and backwards. P g
t (1B) (green)
corresponds to the density of active sites which received
only forward-propagating input. Finally, P g
t (1C) (yel-
low) corresponds to the density of active sites which re-
ceived only backward-propagating input.
For a correct description of the general case, pδ ≤ 1,
we need to introduce loops into the topology as repre-
sented by the purple arrows of Fig. 6. First, we assume
that with probability 1 − pδ an active site remains ac-
tive for the next time step. Second, among those sites
that remained active we consider that a fraction 1 − pδ
g=0
1
λp
δp
2
ph
0
γp
g > 0
δp
2
1A
1B
1C
ph
0
λp
λpβ
γp
g=2
C (t) = βpλhP g−1
Λg
t
(1A) + P g−1
t
(1C)i .
10
(21)
t (1A) + P g
t (1B) + P g
Equations (12) and (13) remain unchanged, with
P g
t (1) ≡ P g
t (1C). The dynamics
of the most distal layer g = G is obtained by fixing
ΛG
B(t) = 0. The proximal element (g = 0) has a sim-
pler dynamics since it does not receive backpropagating
waves, so its activity is simply governed by
P 0
t+1(1) = P 0
t (0)Λ0(t) + (1 − p0
δ)P g
t (1) ,
(22)
g=0
g=1
ph
λp
ph
λp
λp
β
ph
...
ph
λp
λp
λpβ
λpβ
λp
...
λp
...
λpβ
λpβ
g= G
with
Λ0(t) = 1 − (1 − ph)(cid:8)1 − pλ(cid:2)P 1
t (1A) + P 1
t (1B)(cid:3)(cid:9)k+1
.
Taking into account the normalization conditions, the
dimensionality of the map resulting from the GEW ap-
proximation is the same as for the EW approxima-
tion [38]: 4(G − 1) + 5. Numerical solutions of this map
with β = 1 leads to the solid curves in Fig. 3 and 4.
FIG. 6. Generalized excitable-wave mean-field approx-
imation. Top-left panel illustrates the dynamics of each node
and of layer g = 0 under the GEW mean-field approximation.
Top-right panel illustrates the dynamics of further layers un-
der the GEW mean-field approximation. Bottom panel shows
the excitable-waves direction of propagation. Notice that in
the absence of purple arrows the flux vanishes in the state
(1C) of the last layer. The purple arrows represent transi-
tions that occur at each time step with probability (1 − pδ)2
(see text for details). This generalization allows a qualitative
description of the system for pδ < 1.
of them can jump to P g
t+1(1A), and therefore contribute
with both forward- and backward-propagating excitable-
waves. This last step mimics the actions of the returning
activity, since state (1A) is a required intermediate step
to fulfill a back and forth movement of the excitable-wave
under the GEW mean-field approximation.
Following these ideas, and applying the usual mean-
field approximations [38], one can write the equations for
the g > 0 layers as
A + (1 − pg
δ)
t (1A) + (1 − pg
δ)
t (1B) + P g
t (0)Λg
t+1(1A) = P g
P g
·(cid:8)P g
·(cid:2)P g
t (0)(1 − Λg
t+1(1B) = P g
P g
+pg
δ(1 − pg
δ )P g
t (0)(1 − Λg
t+1(1C) = P g
P g
δ )P g
δ(1 − pg
+pg
t (1C)(cid:3)(cid:9) ,
A)Λg
B(t)
t (1B) ,
A) [1 − Λg
t (1C) ,
B(t)] Λg
C(t)
where the excitation probabilities are given by
Λg
A = ph,
Λg
B(t) = 1 −(cid:8)1 − pλ(cid:2)P g+1
(1B)(cid:3)(cid:9)k
+P g+1
,
t
t
(1A)
(16)
(17)
(18)
(19)
(20)
We are thankful to James A. Roberts for a careful read-
ing of the manuscript. The authors acknowledge financial
support from Brazilian agency CNPq. LLG and MC have
also been supported by FACEPE, CAPES and special
programs PRONEX. MC has received financial support
from PRONEM, and OK and MC have been supported
by CNAIPS-USP. This research was also supported by
a grant from MEC (Spain) and FEDER under project
FIS2007-60327 (FISICOS) to LLG.
∗ [email protected]
† [email protected]
‡ [email protected]
[1] Chialvo, D. R. Emergent complex neural dynamics. Nat
Phys 6, 744 -- 750 (2010).
[2] Sornette, D. Critical Phenomena in Natural Sciences
(Springer, Berlin, 2000).
[3] Beggs, J. M. & Plenz, D. Neuronal avalanches in neocor-
tical circuits. J Neurosci 23, 11167 -- 11177 (2003).
[4] Beggs, J. M. & Plenz, D. Neuronal avalanches are diverse
and precise activity patterns that are stable for many
hours in cortical slice cultures. J Neurosci 24, 5216 -- 5229
(2004).
[5] Friedman, N. et al. Universal critical dynamics in high
resolution neuronal avalanche data. Phys Rev Lett 108,
208102 (2012).
[6] Gireesh, E. D. & Plenz, D. Neuronal avalanches orga-
nize as nested theta-and beta/gamma-oscillations during
development of cortical layer 2/3. P Natl Acad Sci USA
105, 7576 -- 7581 (2008).
[7] Petermann, T. et al. Spontaneous cortical activity in
awake monkeys composed of neuronal avalanches. P Natl
Acad Sci USA 106, 15921 -- 15926 (2009).
[8] Ribeiro, T. L. et al. Spike avalanches exhibit univer-
sal dynamics across the sleep-wake cycle. PLoS ONE 5,
e14129 (2010).
[9] Miller, K. J., Sorensen, L. B., Ojemann, J. G. & Den Nijs,
M. Power-law scaling in the brain surface electric poten-
tial. PLoS Comput Biol 5, e1000609 (2009).
[10] Linkenkaer-Hansen, K., Nikouline, V. V., Palva, J. M. &
Ilmoniemi, R. J. Long-range temporal correlations and
scaling behavior in human brain oscillations. J Neurosci
21, 1370 -- 7 (2001).
[11] Kitzbichler, M. G., Smith, M. L., Christensen, S. R. &
Bullmore, E. Broadband criticality of human brain net-
work synchronization. PLoS Comput Biol 5, e1000314
(2009).
[12] Eguiluz, V. M., Chialvo, D. R., Cecchi, G. A., Baliki, M.
& Apkarian, A. V. Scale-free brain functional networks.
Phys Rev Lett 94, 4 (2005).
[13] Sporns, O. Networks of the Brain (MIT Press, 2010).
[14] Kinouchi, O. & Copelli, M. Optimal dynamical range of
excitable networks at criticality. Nat Phys 2, 348 -- 351
(2006).
[15] Shew, W., Yang, H., Petermann, T., Roy, R. & Plenz,
D. Neuronal avalanches imply maximum dynamic range
in cortical networks at criticality. J Neurosci 29, 15595 --
15600 (2009).
[16] Haldeman, C. & Beggs, J. M. Critical branching cap-
tures activity in living neural networks and maximizes
the number of metastable states. Phys Rev Lett 94,
058101 (2005).
[17] Shew, W. L., Yang, H., Yu, S., Roy, R. & Plenz, D.
Information capacity and transmission are maximized in
balanced cortical networks with neuronal avalanches. J
Neurosci 31, 55 -- 63 (2011).
[18] Wen, Q., Stepanyants, A., Elston, G. N., Grosberg, A. Y.
& Chklovskii, D. B. Maximization of the connectivity
repertoire as a statistical principle governing the shapes
of dendritic arbors. P Natl Acad Sci USA 106, 12536 --
12541 (2009).
[19] Zomorrodi, R., Ferecsk´o, A. S., Kov´acs, K., Kroger, H. &
Timofeev, I. Analysis of morphological features of thala-
mocortical neurons from the ventroposterolateral nucleus
of the cat. J Comp Neurol 518, 3541 -- 3556 (2010).
[20] Snider, J., Pillai, A. & Stevens, C. F. A universal prop-
erty of axonal and dendritic arbors. Neuron 66, 45 -- 56
(2010).
[21] Koch, C. Biophysics of Computation (Oxford University
Press, New York, 1999).
[22] Reyes, A.
Influence of dendritic conductances on the
input-output properties of neurons. Annu Rev Neurosci
24, 653 -- 675 (2001).
[23] Johnston, D. & Narayanan, R. Active dendrites: colorful
wings of the mysterious butterflies. Trends Neurosci 31,
309 -- 316 (2008).
[24] Coop, A. D., Cornelis, H. & Santamaria, F. Dendritic
excitability modulates dendritic information processing
in a purkinje cell model. Front Comput Neurosci 4, 10
(2010).
[25] Rall, W. Theoretical significance of dendritic trees
for neuronal
In Reiss, R. F.
(ed.) Neural Theory and Modeling (Stanford Univ. Press,
Stanford, CA, 1964).
input-output relations.
[26] Carnevale, N. T. & Hines, M. L. The NEURON Book
(Cambridge University Press, 2009).
[27] Stuart, G., Spruston, N. & Hausser, M. (eds.) Dendrites
(Oxford University Press, New York, 1999).
[28] London, M. & Hausser, M. Dendritic computation. Annu
Rev Neurosci 28, 503 -- 532 (2005).
11
[29] Marro, J. & Dickman, R. Nonequilibrium Phase Tran-
sition in Lattice Models (Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1999).
[30] Antic, S. D., Zhou, W.-L., Moore, A. R., Short, S. M.
& Ikonomu, K. D. The decade of the dendritic NMDA
spike. J Neurosci Res 3001, 2991 -- 3001 (2010).
[31] Stevens, S. S. Psychophysics: Introduction to its percep-
tual, neural, and social prospects (John Wiley and Sons,
1975).
[32] Bak, P. & Chialvo, D. R. Adaptive learning by extremal
dynamics and negative feedback. Phys Rev E 63, 031912
(2001).
[33] Levina, A., Herrmann, J. M. & Geisel, T. Dynamical
synapses causing self-organized criticality in neural net-
works. Nat Phys 3, 857 -- 860 (2007).
[34] Rubinov, M., Sporns, O., Thivierge, J.-P. & Breaks-
pear, M. Neurobiologically realistic determinants of self-
organized criticality in networks of spiking neurons. PLoS
Comput Biol 7, e1002038 (2011).
[35] Gal, A. & Marom, S. Self-organized criticality in sin-
gle neuron excitability. arXiv preprint arXiv:1210.7414
(2012).
[36] Gollo, L. L., Mirasso, C. & Egu´ıluz, V. M. Signal inte-
gration enhances the dynamic range in neuronal systems.
Phys Rev E 85, 040902 (2012).
[37] Gollo, L. L., Kinouchi, O. & Copelli, M. Active dendrites
enhance neuronal dynamic range. PLoS Comput Biol 5,
e1000402 (2009).
[38] Gollo, L. L., Kinouchi, O. & Copelli, M.
Statisti-
cal physics approach to dendritic computation: The
excitable-wave mean-field approximation. Phys Rev E
85, 011911 (2012).
[39] Assis, V. R. V. & Copelli, M. Dynamic range of hyper-
cubic stochastic excitable media. Phys Rev E 77, 011923
(2008).
[40] Larremore, D., Shew, W. & Restrepo, J. Predicting Criti-
cality and Dynamic Range in Complex Networks: Effects
of Topology. Phys Rev Lett 106, 058101 (2011).
[41] Llin´as, R. & Sugimori, M. Electrophysiological properties
of in vitro purkinje cell dendrites in mammalian cerebel-
lar slices. J Physiol 305, 197 -- 213 (1980).
[42] Schiller, J., Schiller, Y., Stuart, G. & Sakmann, B. Cal-
cium action potentials restricted to distal apical dendrites
of rat neocortical pyramidal neurons. J Physiol 505, 605 --
616 (1997).
[43] Manchanda, K., Yadav, A. C. & Ramaswamy, R. Scal-
ing behavior in probabilistic neuronal cellular automata.
Phys Rev E 87, 012704 (2013).
[44] Villacorta-Atienza, J. A. & Makarov, V. A. Wave-
processing of long-scale information by neuronal chains.
PLoS ONE 8, e57440 (2013).
[45] Suzuki, T., Kodama, S., Hoshino, C., Izumi, T. &
Miyakawa, H. A plateau potential mediated by the ac-
tivation of extrasynaptic NMDA receptors in rat hip-
pocampal CA1 pyramidal neurons. Eur J Neurosci 28,
521 -- 534 (2008).
[46] Davie, J. T., Clark, B. A. & Hausser, M. The origin of
the complex spike in cerebellar purkinje cells. J Neurosci
28, 7599 -- 7609 (2008).
[47] Major, G., Polsky, A., Denk, W., Schiller, J. & Tank,
D. W. Spatiotemporally graded NMDA spike/plateau
potentials in basal dendrites of neocortical pyramidal
neurons. J Neurophysiol 99, 2584 -- 2601 (2008).
[48] Wong, R. K. & Prince, D. A. Dendritic mechanisms un-
12
derlying penicillin-induced epileptiform activity. Science
204, 1228 -- 1231 (1979).
laws are transfer functions of excitable media. Phys Rev
E 65, 060901 (2002).
[49] Wong, R. K. & Stewart, M. Different firing patterns gen-
erated in dendrites and somata of CA1 pyramidal neu-
rones in guinea-pig hippocampus. J Physiol 457, 675 --
687 (1992).
[50] Kamondi, A., Acs´ady, L., Wang, X. J. & Buzs´aki, G.
Theta oscillations in somata and dendrites of hippocam-
pal pyramidal cells in vivo: activity-dependent phase-
precession of action potentials. Hippocampus 8, 24461
(1998).
[51] Remme, M. W. H., Lengyel, M. & Gutkin, B. S. The role
of ongoing dendritic oscillations in single-neuron dynam-
ics. PLoS Comput Biol 5, e1000493 (2009).
[52] Branco, T. & Hausser, M. The single dendritic branch
as a fundamental functional unit in the nervous system.
Curr Opin Neurobiol 20, 494 -- 502 (2010).
[53] Carelli, P. V., Reyes, M. B., Sartorelli, J. C. & Pinto,
R. D. Whole cell stochastic model reproduces the ir-
regularities found in the membrane potential of bursting
neurons. J Neurophysiol 94, 1169 -- 1179 (2005).
[54] Cannon, R. C., O'Donnell, C. & Nolan, M. F. Stochas-
tic ion channel gating in dendritic neurons: morphology
dependence and probabilistic synaptic activation of den-
dritic spikes. PLoS Comput Biol 6, e1000886 (2010).
[55] Jarsky, T., Roxin, A., Kath, W. L. & Spruston, N. Condi-
tional dendritic spike propagation following distal synap-
tic activation of hippocampal CA1 pyramidal neurons.
Nat Neurosci 8, 1667 -- 1676 (2005).
[56] Publio, R., Ceballos, C. C. & Roque, A. C. Dynamic
range of vertebrate retina ganglion cells: Importance of
active dendrites and coupling by electrical synapses. PloS
ONE 7, e48517 (2012).
[57] Copelli, M., Roque, A. C., Oliveira, R. F. & Kinouchi, O.
Physics of Psychophysics: Stevens and Weber-Fechner
[58] Furtado, L. S. & Copelli, M. Response of electrically
coupled spiking neurons: a cellular automaton approach.
Phys Rev E 73, 011907 (2006).
[59] Ribeiro, T. L. & Copelli, M. Deterministic excitable
media under Poisson drive: Power law responses, spi-
ral waves and dynamic range. Phys Rev E 77, 051911
(2008).
[60] Publio, R., Oliveira, R. F. & Roque, A. C. A compu-
tational study on the role of gap junctions and rod Ih
conductance in the enhancement of the dynamic range
of the retina. PLoS ONE 4, e6970 (2009).
[61] Jan, Y.-N. & Jan, L. Y. Branching out: mechanisms of
dendritic arborization. Nat Rev Neurosci 11, 316 -- 328
(2010).
[62] Woolley, C. S., Gould, E., Frankfurt, M. & McEwen,
B. S. Naturally occurring fluctuation in dendritic spine
density on adult hippocampal pyramidal neurons. J Neu-
rosci 10, 4035 -- 4039 (1990).
[63] Bonachela, J. A., De Franciscis, S., Torres, J. J. &
Munoz, M. A. Self-organization without conservation:
Are neuronal avalanches generically critical?
J Stat
Mech-Theory E 2010, 28 (2010).
[64] Parish, L. M. et al. Long-range temporal correlations
in epileptogenic and non-epileptogenic human hippocam-
pus. Neuroscience 125, 1069 -- 76 (2004).
[65] Bhattacharya, J., Edwards, J., Mamelak, A. N. & Schu-
man, E. M. Long-range temporal correlations in the
spontaneous spiking of neurons in the hippocampal-
amygdala complex of humans. Neuroscience 131, 547 --
555 (2005).
[66] Mazzoni, A. et al. On the dynamics of the spontaneous
activity in neuronal networks. PLoS ONE 2, e439 (2007).
|
1803.10205 | 1 | 1803 | 2018-03-27T17:43:06 | VIOLA - A multi-purpose and web-based visualization tool for neuronal-network simulation output | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Neuronal network models and corresponding computer simulations are invaluable tools to aid the interpretation of the relationship between neuron properties, connectivity and measured activity in cortical tissue. Spatiotemporal patterns of activity propagating across the cortical surface as observed experimentally can for example be described by neuronal network models with layered geometry and distance-dependent connectivity. The interpretation of the resulting stream of multi-modal and multi-dimensional simulation data calls for integrating interactive visualization steps into existing simulation-analysis workflows. Here, we present a set of interactive visualization concepts called views for the visual analysis of activity data in topological network models, and a corresponding reference implementation VIOLA (VIsualization Of Layer Activity). The software is a lightweight, open-source, web-based and platform-independent application combining and adapting modern interactive visualization paradigms, such as coordinated multiple views, for massively parallel neurophysiological data. For a use-case demonstration we consider spiking activity data of a two-population, layered point-neuron network model subject to a spatially confined excitation originating from an external population. With the multiple coordinated views, an explorative and qualitative assessment of the spatiotemporal features of neuronal activity can be performed upfront of a detailed quantitative data analysis of specific aspects of the data. Furthermore, ongoing efforts including the European Human Brain Project aim at providing online user portals for integrated model development, simulation, analysis and provenance tracking, wherein interactive visual analysis tools are one component. Browser-compatible, web-technology based solutions are therefore required. Within this scope, with VIOLA we provide a first prototype. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
VIOLA - A multi-purpose and web-based
visualization tool for neuronal-network
simulation output
Johanna Senk 1,∗, Corto Carde 2,3,4, Espen Hagen 1,5, Torsten W. Kuhlen 2,3,
Markus Diesmann 1,6,7 and Benjamin Weyers 2,3
1Institute of Neuroscience and Medicine (INM-6) and Institute for Advanced
Simulation (IAS-6) and JARA Institute Brain Structure-Function Relationships
(INM-10), Jülich Research Centre, Jülich, Germany
2Visual Computing Institute, RWTH Aachen University, Aachen, Germany
3JARA - High-Performance Computing, Aachen and Jülich, Germany
4IMT Atlantique Bretagne-Pays de la Loire, Brest, France
5Department of Physics, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway
6Department of Psychiatry, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, Medical Faculty,
RWTH Aachen University, Aachen, Germany
7Department of Physics, Faculty 1, RWTH Aachen University, Aachen, Germany
Correspondence*:
Johanna Senk
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
Neuronal network models and corresponding computer simulations are invaluable tools to aid
the interpretation of the relationship between neuron properties, connectivity and measured
activity in cortical tissue. Spatiotemporal patterns of activity propagating across the cortical
surface as observed experimentally can for example be described by neuronal network models
with layered geometry and distance-dependent connectivity. In order to cover the surface area
captured by today's experimental techniques and to achieve sufficient self-consistency, such
models contain millions of nerve cells. The interpretation of the resulting stream of multi-modal and
multi-dimensional simulation data calls for integrating interactive visualization steps into existing
simulation-analysis workflows. Here, we present a set of interactive visualization concepts called
views for the visual analysis of activity data in topological network models, and a corresponding
reference implementation VIOLA (VIsualization Of Layer Activity). The software is a lightweight,
open-source, web-based and platform-independent application combining and adapting modern
interactive visualization paradigms, such as coordinated multiple views, for massively parallel
neurophysiological data. For a use-case demonstration we consider spiking activity data of a two-
population, layered point-neuron network model incorporating distance-dependent connectivity
subject to a spatially confined excitation originating from an external population. With the multiple
coordinated views, an explorative and qualitative assessment of the spatiotemporal features of
neuronal activity can be performed upfront of a detailed quantitative data analysis of specific
aspects of the data. Interactive multi-view analysis therefore assists existing data analysis
workflows. Furthermore, ongoing efforts including the European Human Brain Project aim
1
Senk et al.
VIOLA
at providing online user portals for integrated model development, simulation, analysis and
provenance tracking, wherein interactive visual analysis tools are one component. Browser-
compatible, web-technology based solutions are therefore required. Within this scope, with VIOLA
we provide a first prototype.
Keywords: interactive visualization, visual data analytics, coordinated multiple views, 3D visualization, neuronal network simulation,
spiking neurons, spatiotemporal patterns, data analysis workflow
1 INTRODUCTION
One common technique to capture brain activity on the neuronal level is to record extracellular potentials in
cortical tissue (Buzsáki et al., 2012; Einevoll et al., 2013). The low frequency ((cid:46) 100 Hz) part of the signal,
often referred to as the local field potential (LFP), remains difficult to interpret as thousands to millions of
proximal and distal neurons contribute to the signal (Kajikawa and Schroeder, 2011; Lindén et al., 2011;
Łe¸ski et al., 2013). From the high-frequency band ((cid:38) 100 Hz), however, one can detect sequences of spikes,
the transient extracellular signatures of action potentials in single neurons nearby the recording electrode.
The number of reliably identified neurons (through spike sorting, Quiroga, 2007) per recording session
is low compared to the number of neurons in vicinity of the recording device, even if the experiment is
performed with hundreds or more electrode contact points (Einevoll et al., 2012). The Utah array from
Blackrock Microsystems1, for example, resolves with 10 × 10 electrodes on 4 × 4 mm2 little more than
a hundred distinct neurons. Also optical methods for measuring neuronal activity have seen continuous
improvements. As recently demonstrated, non-invasive three-photon fluorescence microscopy facilitates
functional imaging at high optical resolution as deep as 1 mm (Ouzounov et al., 2017). While the method
simultaneously images a comparably large number of neurons, the recordings lack the temporal resolution
to reliably detect individual action potentials. Ouzounov et al. (2017) record from as many as 150 neurons
in mouse hippocampal stratum pyramidale within a field of view of 200 × 200 µm.
The rapidly improving parallel recording technology increases the need for suitable analysis methods for
high-dimensional and dynamic data streams. Nevertheless, the recordings will remain to be characterized
by a massive undersampling for some time. Therefore, detailed full scale models of the cortical tissue are
required to understand the microscopic dynamics (van Albada et al., 2015) and to relate the microscopic
activity to mesoscopic measures like the LFP. For this program to succeed, neuroscientists not only need to
analyze model data in the same way as experimental data, but to explore data sets with orders of magnitude
more channels than experimentally available.
Networks of model neurons incorporating varying levels of biophysical and anatomical detail reproduce
a number of features of experimentally obtained spike trains. For networks of point- or one-compartment
neuron models, this list of features includes irregular spike trains (Softky and Koch, 1993; van Vreeswijk
and Sompolinsky, 1996; Amit and Brunel, 1997; Shadlen and Newsome, 1998), asynchronous spiking
(Ecker et al., 2010; Renart et al., 2010; Helias et al., 2014; Ostojic, 2014), correlation structure (Gentet et al.,
2010; Okun and Lampl, 2008; Helias et al., 2013), self-sustained activity (Ohbayashi et al., 2003; Kriener
et al., 2014), realistic firing rates across cortical lamina (Potjans and Diesmann, 2014), single-neuron
spiking activity of different cell types (Izhikevich, 2003; Kobayashi et al., 2009; Yamauchi et al., 2011) and
responses under 'in vivo' conditions (Jolivet et al., 2008; Gerstner and Naud, 2009). Relating point-neuron
network activity to population signals such as the LFP is, however, not straightforward. Approximations
1 http://blackrockmicro.com
2
Senk et al.
VIOLA
Figure 1. Geometry and connectivity of a layered point-neuron network. A Schematic illustration of
distance-dependent network connectivity using connectivity pattern tables (Nordlie and Plesser, 2010).
Each row represents source populations X ∈ {STIM, EX, IN}, and each column target populations
Y ∈ {EX, IN}. The color coding in each image shows the connection intensity between presynaptic
neurons j and postsynaptic neurons i located in (xj, yj) and (xi, yi) with origin (0, 0) at the center. The
connection intensities are defined as the product between pairwise connection probabilities Y X (rij) and
synapse strengths gY X J for each respective connection. Gray values denote connection intensities of zero.
B Illustration of one network instantiation with randomly drawn neuron positions and outgoing connections
from a subset of neuronal units. The colored dots represent individual units at their (x, y)-coordinates.
Gray dots denote units in a stimulus (STIM) layer, blue dots excitatory (EX) units, and red dots inhibitory
(IN) units. Blue and red lines denote excitatory and inhibitory connections respectively, from a source unit
(white circles) onto neurons within the same or another layer.
(see Mazzoni et al., 2015) or forward-model based schemes (Hagen et al., 2016) are required to bridge the
gap to experimental electrophysiological data which predominantly reflects population activity.
The focus of this study lies on visualization methods for activity of spatially extended neuronal network
models. Incorporation of spatial structure is a prerequisite for models aiming to explain experimentally
observed spatiotemporal patterns of activity (Rubino et al., 2006; Denker et al., 2011; Sato et al., 2012;
Muller et al., 2014; Townsend et al., 2015). Such models have an arrangement of neurons in one-, two-
or three-dimensional (1D, 2D or 3D) space and connection rules which typically depend on the distance
between (parts of) the neurons (Mehring et al., 2003; Coombes, 2005; Yger et al., 2011; Bressloff, 2012;
Voges and Perrinet, 2012; Kriener et al., 2014; Keane and Gong, 2015; Rosenbaum et al., 2017). Although
we primarily focus on model data, the same visualization methods can be applied with experimentally
recorded data.
We here consider an example spiking point-neuron network consisting of an excitatory (EX), an inhibitory
(IN) and an external stimulus (STIM) population. EX and IN units are positioned randomly within square
domains while STIM units are randomly positioned within a circle at the center. A schematic representation
of the network connectivity is shown in Figure 1A. We use connectivity pattern tables (Nordlie and Plesser,
2010) for source populations X (rows) and target populations Y (columns). The images indicate the
'connection intensities' for each connection, defined as the product between averaged pairwise connection
probabilities Y X (rij) and synapse strengths gY X J. The distance between a source and a target neuron is
denoted by rij. Pairwise connection probabilities decay with horizontal distance between EX and IN units
according to a Gaussian profile, while STIM units only connect locally to the EX population restricted by
3
x (mm)21012y (mm)21012BINEXSTIMSTIMEXINsourceexc. connectioninh. connection21012X=STIMyi−yj (mm)AY=EXY=IN0150300450YXJgYX (pA)21012X=EXyi−yj (mm)0816243240YXJgYX (pA)21012xi−xj (mm)21012X=INyi−yj (mm)21012xi−xj (mm)16012080400YXJgYX (pA) Senk et al.
VIOLA
Figure 2. Spiking activity of a layered point-neuron network model. A Spike raster plot for STIM
(gray dots), EX (blue dots) and IN (red dots) units from a simulation of the network instantiation depicted
in Figure 1B. Each individual dot corresponds to a unit ID vs. spike time; only the spikes of every fifth
neuron are shown in the raster. The color coding for each population is reused in the subsequent panels.
B Spike count histogram across units in each population, calculated using a bin width of 625 units, sorted
by neuron index j. C Sorted spike raster where dots correspond to the spatial location (projected onto
the x−axis) and spike times of each unit. The raster-plot density is diluted as in Panel A. D Spike count
histogram across spatial bins with a width ∆l = 0.1 mm. E Spike count histogram for each population
across time, computed using a temporal bin width ∆t = 1 ms.
a cut-off radius. The geometry of one network instantiation is depicted in Figure 1B. EX (blue dots), IN
(red dots) and STIM (gray dots) units are placed in separate layers. The distance dependency is illustrated
by outgoing excitatory connections (blue lines) from single units in the STIM and EX populations and
outgoing inhibitory connections (red lines) from single units in the IN population.
The visualization of neuronal activity data poses challenges due to the high dimensionality and time
dependence of the data. Historically, electrophysiological data have been recorded from few electrodes
or from many electrodes with undefined relative and absolute spatial coordinates (see, for example, the
pioneering work of Krüger and Bach, 1981). This is not an essential limitation for recordings within
the local cortical network where a neuron can form a synapse with any other neuron and there is little
spatial organization. Furthermore, the fundamental interaction in a neuronal network is considered to be a
dynamics on a graph; nodes solely interact via the edges of the graph. In this picture the spatial embedding
of the graph is arbitrary as the dynamics is not constrained by the dimensions of physical space. Therefore,
neuroscientists developed concepts for visualizing correlation structure and time dependence of neuronal
activity in multi-channel recordings in ignorance of spatial properties. A temporal segment of activity of
our example network is visualized in Figure 2. Panel A is the spike raster diagram or dot display in use
4
0500010000150002000025000neuron IDAunsorted spike raster0500010000Bspike count(∆=625 units)2.01.51.00.50.00.51.01.52.0x position (mm)Csorted spike raster02000D08000countspike count(∆=0.1 mm)010000150300Espike count (∆t=1 ms)06001200count600800100012001400time (ms)0150300STIMEXIN Senk et al.
VIOLA
for decades (explained in Abeles, 1982). Each row shows the spike train of one neuron where spike times
are marked by dots. The rows either represent data of the same neuron in several trials or, as here, data
of simultaneously recorded neurons in a single trial (Grün, 1996, Fig. 6.2). The spike trains are vertically
arranged by neuron ID and in addition color coded by population. The spike raster highlights global features
of network activity and generations of neuroscientists have been trained to visually inspect these diagrams.
For example, network synchrony appears as a stripy vertical pattern even if individual neurons only rarely
participate in an individual synchronous event. The activation of the stimulus population is reflected in
the other populations as an increased density of the dots. Epping et al. (1984) extend the concept of the
raster diagram by assigning a unique color to the dots of a neuron. In this way multi-channel activity
observed over multiple trials can be superimposed. Panel B shows spike counts along the temporal axis
over neuronal units demonstrating that the per-neuron spike count is similar for the excitatory and the
inhibitory populations. The spike count along the vertical axis in panel E is called the post-stimulus time
histogram (PSTH, Perkel et al., 1967a) originally computed for an individual neuron observed over several
trials. Later the display was also called peri-stimulus time histogram. Here the histogram is computed
over simultaneously recorded neurons in a single trial. The display uncovers the fluctuations of population
activity in time.
The development of adequate visualization concepts for multi-channel neuronal data is an ongoing
endeavor (Allen et al., 2012). The cross-correlation function (Perkel et al., 1967b) exposes the time-
averaged relationship between the spike times of two neurons. The snowflake diagram generalizes the
concept to three neurons (Perkel et al., 1975; Czanner et al., 2005). Gravitational clustering (Gerstein et al.,
1985; Gerstein and Aertsen, 1985 reviewed in Chap. 8 of Grün and Rotter, 2010) attempts to identify
the emergence of correlated groups of neurons, so called cell-assemblies, and the temporal dynamics of
the changing membership of individual neurons in such groups without averaging over trials. The joint
peri-stimulus time histogram (JPSTH, Aertsen et al., 1989) generalizes the cross-correlation function to
visualize the dynamics of the correlation between the spikes of two neurons in reference to a stimulus. Later
Prut et al. (1998) used the idea to investigate the occurrence of spatiotemporal patterns in the spike trains
of three neurons, where "spatio" refers to the abstract space of neuron IDs not physical space. Because of
the difficulties in determining statistical significance Grün et al. (2002) restricted the scope to patterns in
the space of IDs and for visualization mapped significant events, so called unitary events, back into the
spike raster diagram. Progress in the theory of neuronal networks showed that propagating spiking activity
due to the stochastic nature of neuronal activity is likely to exhibit in each instance a random sub-pattern of
spikes of some superset of neurons. Therefore Schrader et al. (2008) designed a matrix spanned by binned
ongoing time in both dimensions where matrix-elements represent the cardinality of the intersection set of
the neurons spiking at the two respective time bins. With color-coded cardinality, in this matrix repeatedly
occurring propagating spiking activity appears as a diagonal feature. Later an assessment of statistical
significance was added (Torre et al., 2016a). Kemere et al. (2008) employ multi-channel recordings to
construct the time course of a multi-dimensional vector of spike rates. A suitable projection to a lower
dimensional space reveals differentiable trajectories of network activity depending on the experimental
protocol (reviewed in Cunningham and Byron, 2014). Another line of work attempts to cope with the
combinatorial explosion of patterns in multi-channel spike trains while maintaining sensitivity by the
construction of a pattern spectrum: a two-dimensional histogram spanned by the number of spikes in a
pattern, called pattern complexity, and the number of occurrences of the particular patterns (Gerstein et al.,
2012; Torre et al., 2013).
Figure 2C modifies the spike raster diagram in panel A to arrange the spike trains on the vertical axis
according to the x-coordinate of the position of the emitting neuron in physical space. In contrast to the
5
Senk et al.
VIOLA
regular spike raster, we observe inhomogeneous spatiotemporal features in network activity. The spatially
binned spike counts along the temporal axis in panel D, however, do not reveal any unexpected structure.
Thus, taking into account one coordinate of the neurons in physical space hints at some organization of
neuronal activity. Nevertheless, a higher-dimensional analysis seems to be required to uncover its origin, as
the features of spatiotemporal patterns can only be conjectured in 2D.
The emergence of planar wavelike spiking activity in 2D networks was shown by Voges and Perrinet
(2012, Figures 3-5), but a 2D spatial visualization of the data could not faithfully capture intermediate
mixed patterns such as rings and spiraling waves. Temporal snapshots of spatial activity show the evolution
of patterns, as seen in Mehring et al. (2003, Figure 5), Yger et al. (2011, Figures 2,12), Voges and
Perrinet (2012, Figure 6) and Keane and Gong (2015, Figure 1). Series of such snapshots combined in
an animation or movie can be informative, but require settings to be defined beforehand, leaving only
little room for interactivity. With such non-interactive visualization methods, crucial decisions about a
figure or an animation thus have to be made before a sufficient intuition about the data exists. Flexible,
interactive visualization techniques identifying relevant dynamical features present in the data would
have the potential to avoid the tedious and time-consuming loop of refining parameters and regenerating
snapshots, animations or movies. In addition, high-dimensional and multi-modal data demand adequate
workflows for analysis, from raw data to statistical measures, where interactive visual analysis methods can
play a major role. It is for example essential to get a basic understanding of the datasets to better decide
what statistical methods to use for more elaborate analysis. Furthermore, interactive visualization allows
for explorative data analysis, including dimensionality reduction of complex datasets, highlighting of data
points, and direct changes to visualization parameters.
For the development of supportive visual analytics tools, Shneiderman (1996) introduced the so-called
'information-seeking mantra'. It describes the steps of common visual analysis workflows: "overview first,
zoom and filter, details on demand". The first step provides a superficial 'overview' of the data. In the
second step, 'zooming' into the dataset allows the user to get a more detailed view on a chosen data subset.
Application of 'filters' implies a change in dimensionality of the data or the extraction of particular features.
Finally, Shneiderman (1996) proposes that visualization tools should enable the user to access all details of
selected data points.
To not restrict the user to only one visual representation of the data, Wang Baldonado et al. (2000)
established the concept of 'coordinated multiple views'. Coordinated multiple views is a paradigm for
the implementation of visual analysis applications that "use two or more distinct views to support the
investigation of a single conceptual entity" (Wang Baldonado et al., 2000, p. 110), and has been applied
in various contexts (see for example Roberts, 2007). Basic coordination of views addresses selection
operations (e.g., whether to display only a subset of the data) and also includes immediate control over
animated frames (e.g., animation time step and playback speed for time-resolved data). In addition, each
view may have an exclusive (view-specific) set of user controls and settings.
The activity exhibited by our example network is characterized by a non-trivial interplay between
neuronal populations resulting in non-stationary activity in time and space. The neuroscientist needs to
identify the propagation of spiking activity within and across individual layers over time and space, and
simultaneously observe population activity measures such as the LFP. This is an opportunity to exercise the
concepts by Shneiderman (1996) and Wang Baldonado et al. (2000). Visualization in most cases focuses
on a specific aspect or hypothesis to be tested by analyzing the corresponding data. Therefore, for each
task the neuroscientist combines a different set of views. Sometimes particular views are not among the
regularly used ones provided by the visualization framework but are created ad hoc specifically for the
6
Senk et al.
VIOLA
research question or the experimental protocol. Therefore the analysis software environment needs to
facilitate fast prototyping of visualizations and an interface to a computing programming language used in
the scientific domain. This focus on a specific aspect under investigation by the neuroscientist necessarily
entails an individual level of reduction or aggregation of the data. A particular visualization realizes this
preprocessing of the data with methods like binning of data points in time or space, or by filtering out a
certain subset of parameters of each data point. For instance, the spike raster plot in Figure 2A displays the
individual spikes of all neurons whereas the bar chart in Figure 2E visualizes the total number of spikes
per time step. The visualization abstracts from the spikes of individual neurons and turns the focus to the
whole population. On the one hand the visualization simplifies interpretation by presenting less detail, on
the other hand the reduction increases the chance of wrong or inaccurate conclusions. Historically, Vaadia
et al. (1988, Fig. 4 middle) illustrate a potential misinterpretation of the PSTH due to variability in the
onset of the neuronal response: a neuron observed over multiple trials exhibits in the PSTH a smooth
increase in spike rate, whereas the raster plots show in each trial an abrupt increase in spike density
with a variable onset. Grün et al. (2002, Fig. 8) demonstrate how such misalignments can propagate to
measures of statistical significance: with respect to one trigger event the data show surplus spike synchrony
simply due to non-stationarity of spike rate, whereas with respect to another trigger the rate is stationary
and no excess synchrony is detected. However, if a multi-view approach is implemented that combines
various visualizations, more than one aspect of the data (more then one visual representation of differently
processed data) can be inspected simultaneously and can be put into relation. By interactive addition and
removal of certain views, this process can be made flexible and thus address changes in the analysis goals
or to consider findings during the analysis. Finally, we require a solution that allows for integration with
platform-independent web-based technologies to keep the accessibility of the tool as high as possible.
A variety of coordinated multi-view applications for the interactive analysis of activity data has been
described in literature, which generally follow the information-seeking mantra. For models of neuronal
systems, the NEURON simulation environment (Carnevale and Hines, 2006) provides a graphical user
interface based a modified version of the discontinued InterViews library in addition to scripting in HOC
and Python (Hines et al., 2009). The software itself offers the possibility of drawing multiple concurrent
windows with dynamic and interactive plots of voltages, currents, morphology shapes and phase planes that
are updated while simulations of single-neuron models or neuron networks are running. 3D visualization is
not directly supported, but NEURON's Python bindings also allows running simulations to interact with
modern visualization software, as for example incorporated by NeuronVisio (Mattioni et al., 2012) that
relies on the OpenGL-accelerated Mayavi visualization toolset (Ramachandran and Varoquaux, 2011). The
simulation software for large-scale neuronal network models NEST2 (NEural Simulation Tool, Gewaltig
and Diesmann, 2007) does not provide built-in interactive visualization. The original authors state this in
their first report (Diesmann et al., 1995) as a design decision based on two considerations. First, in 1995
the life time of graphics frameworks and libraries appeared much shorter than the envisioned period of
relevance of a simulation code. Thus, only a software stack with a strict separation of levels would ensure
platform independence and sustainability of NEST. Second, a basic idea of the project is to contribute to
a software environment for 'in virtu' now often called 'in silico' experiments (restated in Diesmann and
Gewaltig, 2002). In this concept, the authors state, simulated data and experimental data should be analyzed
with the same analysis tools to maximize comparability and reproducibility. At the same time researchers
at the department of Physiology and the Center for Neural Computation of the Hebrew University in
Jerusalem started to work on an integrated analysis and visualization platform based on Open Inventor3
2 http://nest-simulator.org
3 https://www.openinventor.com
7
Senk et al.
VIOLA
called Neural Data Analysis (NDA) but the project was abandoned with the advent of MATLAB (Vaadia,
2017). Recently Nowke et al. took on the challenge to develop a simulator independent visualization
platform for brain-scale neuronal networks. The VisNEST (Nowke et al., 2013, 2015) framework visualizes
the spiking activity of multi-area network models (using as an example Schmidt et al., 2017) in a virtual
environment. The time-resolved activity data is mapped onto a 3D brain model. This enables the researcher
to interact with the model in 3D to expose otherwise occluded parts of the brain and to relate brain activity
to anatomy. In a different view, a dynamic 3D graph represents time course of spike exchange between
different cortical areas. These representation of spatial information can be combined with classic charts
such as spike raster plots. The tool does presently not account for the spatial organization of activity
within brain areas. Apart from VisNEST, other standalone interactive multi-view applications have been
developed for simulated spiking data, for instance SNN3DViewer (Kasi´nski et al., 2009) and ViSimpl
(Galindo et al., 2016). SNN3DViewer focuses on 3D neuronal networks by visualizing individual neurons
and their connections schematically, including interactive control over the 3D visualization (navigation,
scale). ViSimpl combines a 3D particle-system-based visualization of the simulated neuronal network
using color coding for the activity, supplemented by a set of data charts for single neurons and populations.
Geppetto4 is a web-based modular platform for visualization and simulation of complex biological systems
including spiking neuronal networks. Unlike the visualization concepts along which these tools have been
developed, we here focus on concepts that expose the spatial organization of neuronal activity in layered
networks and scale to signals from several square millimeters of brain surface.
Beside the aforementioned softwares applicable with spike data, general-purpose multi-view frameworks
exist with different design goals and contexts of use (Roberts, 2007). One generic high-level example is
GLUE5, a Python and OpenGL-based multi-view framework. Another powerful framework is the now
neglected OpenDX6. In contrast to the GLUE toolset, we here aim at web-based visualization. Easy access
to libraries of common plotting functions and methods (scatter, line, surface plots etc.) is provided for most
common programming languages (C++, Python, MATLAB, etc.). Nevertheless, a large amount of time and
resources is still required to construct fully interactive visualization tools adhering to the principles outlined
by Shneiderman (1996) and Wang Baldonado et al. (2000). Including interactivity and time synchronization
between different visualizations may be demanding in terms of software design and development time,
however, existing plotting libraries can be used to realize the individual visualizations.
As a reference implementation of our conceptual study, we introduce the interactive visualization tool
VIOLA, an open-source, platform-independent and lightweight web-browser application. The tool is
designed for initial visual inspection of massively parallel data generated primarily by simulations of
spiking neuronal networks similar to the example network illustrated in Figure 1. VIOLA is designed around
the information-seeking mantra and the concept of coordinated multiple views. 2D and 3D visualizations
support the exploration of neuronal activity across space and time. The software can display raw spiking
output as well as spatiotemporally binned data that may represent instantaneous spike counts gathered
from nearby groups of neurons. Spike and LFP data can be displayed simultaneously, thus allowing for a
multi-modal analysis.
The manuscript is organized as follows: In Results we present different visualization types and their
application. Subsequently (Methods) we describe their implementation in the visualization tool VIOLA,
the example network model and the phenomenological model for the LFP signal. Finally in Discussion and
4 http://www.geppetto.org
5 http://glueviz.org
6 http://www.opendx.org
8
Senk et al.
VIOLA
Outlook we conclude our work and discuss general limitations of frameworks for explorative visualization
and potential future developments.
2 RESULTS
For the analysis of data, static figures can help to highlight certain characteristics of the data or show results
relevant for a particular hypothesis. However, static figures hamper an exploratory analysis of data as the
adaption of data filters, visualization parameters, or changes in the perspective (in case of 3D visualization)
require a re-rendering of the figure resulting in a very slow visual analysis process. Interactive visualization
tools tackle these shortcomings by offering multiple views on the same data simultaneously, for example by
projecting the data across different dimensions. This allows the user to investigate data at different levels of
detail, and to adapt visualization parameters in a dynamic and explorative manner as the rendering of the
visualization is continuously updated. Throughout this section, we use the spike output of the point-neuron
network introduced in the Introduction as an example to demonstrate appropriate visualization types in an
interactive and multi-view framework. Neurons in this network are placed in 2D sheets, and connections
are drawn using distance-dependent probabilities between pairs of neurons. The model represents spatially
heterogeneous neuronal activity across a 4 × 4 mm2 cortical sheet. As we here focus on visualization
methods in VIOLA, we refer the reader to Sections 3.4-3.5 for the details on our network implementation in
NEST (Kunkel et al., 2017), Python-based preprocessing steps and predictions of a mesoscopic population
signal, the local field potential (LFP). We next describe in detail the different views of VIOLA and their
use cases.
2.1 Views of VIOLA
VIOLA incorporates two conceptually different visualization types with two separate 'views' each. The
first visualization type (view 1 and view 2 in Figure 3) focuses on instantaneous snapshots of data across
space. The second visualization type (view 3 and view 4 in Figure 4) shows time series of data. We first
present the visualizations of preprocessed data described in Section 3.1. Views 1-3 may also be used to
visualize raw data (non-preprocessed) as shown in Figure 5.
2.1.1 View 1: 2D spike-count rate
The 2D spike-count rate view (Figure 3A) shows instantaneous activity data in separate sub-panels for
individual populations. The values in each panel correspond to the instantaneous spike-count rate νβ in one
discrete spatiotemporal bin indexed by β = (lx, ly, k) in our preprocessed data format (lx and ly denote
spatial bin indices along the x−and y−axes, and k denotes a temporal bin index). In this format, each spike
event is added to the corresponding spatiotemporal bin as described in detail in Section 3.1. The color bar
denotes bin values in units of spike counts per second (spikes/s) and is shared between all sub-panels. This
view provides a side-by-side comparison of the spatially resolved activity in each individual population.
For a larger number of populations (than shown here), it is, however, difficult to relate the activity of
one population to another population by visual observation. This problem can however be amended by
combining multiple population activities in a single scene.
2.1.2 View 2: 3D layered spike-count rate
In the 3D layered spike-count rate view (Figure 3B), we combine the activity of all network layers in one
3D-animated scene. The view incorporates the possibility to show also other activity measures, for example
the population LFP. The layers in view 2 correspond to the different sub-panels for each population in view
1. Different populations are here assigned unique colors. We chose to illustrate instantaneous spike-count
9
Senk et al.
VIOLA
Figure 3. View 1: 2D spike-count rate Panel A shows the instantaneous spike-count rates, defined as
the number of spikes per second occurring within a spatiotemporal bin, using 2D image plots spanning
the spatial x− and y−axes of the network layers. One separate image plot is created for each network
population and denoted by the population name (EX, IN). The color map and corresponding color bar for
instantaneous spike-count rate values are shared among all populations. In this and subsequent panels, we
show the screen shot of the view itself to the left and highlight its components to the right. View 2: 3D
layered spike-count rate. Panel B combines the data shown in Panel A in a single 3D scene by stacking
the different population data on top of each other. The size of each cubic marker denotes the magnitude of
the corresponding bin-wise instantaneous spike count, and its position corresponds to the spatial positions
of the respective bin. Unique colors are assigned to each layer as indicated by the population names.
Projections of the spike counts along the x− and y−axes are displayed towards the corresponding edges.
The optional bottom image plot layer shows the spatial variation in an LFP-like signal at the present time
step of the rendering loop.
rate νβ by dynamically sized cubic boxes. The box sizes are by default scaled such that their volumes are
proportional to νβ at each time step, thus low-activity bins may still be visualized simultaneously with
high-activity bins.
View 2 offers multiple possibilities for interactive adaptation of the visualization. As suggested by the
information-seeking mantra (Shneiderman, 1996), the user can manually select which part of the data to
show, for example by switching on or off individual layers that may occlude visibility of activity in other
layers or by setting the horizontal x− and y−limits of the layers. It is also possible to reduce the opacity of
10
View 2View 1populationnamebin-wiseinstantaneousspikecountspatialx-/y-axiscamerasettings,time step/ total timebin-wiseinstantaneousspikecountprojectionofspikecountpopulationnamesLFP at currenttime steponelayerperpopulationtime step/ total timecolorbarABabcdedefabc Senk et al.
VIOLA
the colored boxes or to scale their side length linearly. The camera can be set either to an orthographic or
perspective-corrected projection mode. Dependent on the projection mode, the camera can be moved freely
and allows for zooming, panning and rotating the scene. One can easily reset the camera to its default
position by the click of a button or select different preset camera positions such as on top or to the side.
The major benefit provided by view 2 over view 1 is the possibility to visually relate the activity in one
layer to other layers as all layers are drawn in the same 3D scene. As box volumes are computed from
instantaneous spike-count rate values, this view brings the attention of the user to spatial regions of the
network with high local activity. While views 1 and 2 offer flexible visualizations of instantaneous activity
across space, we next consider scenes capable of showing time-series data.
2.1.3 View 3: Scrolling spike-count rate plot
(cid:80)
(cid:80)
νk is defined as νk ≡ 1/(LxLy) ·(cid:80)
The scrolling spike-count rate plot (Figure 4A) is a time-series representation of the data that neglects
spatial features of the network and its activity. It shows the time evolution of the total spike-count rate νk
(black line), defined as the sum over the spike-count rates of all spatial bins and populations divided by
the number of bins, together with the relative rate of each individual population (colored stacked plot).
νβ with β = (lx, ly, k) and where Lx and Ly denote the
number of bins along the x− and y−axes and neuronal populations are denoted X. The per-population
spike-count rates can therefore be inferred by multiplication of the total rate with the fraction of spiking in
individual sub-populations. The color coding of each population corresponds to the one used in view 2, but
can also be read from the bar to the right. The plot is centered on the current time step (vertical white line
indicator) when scrolling through data points in the animation. It allows for interactive change of the width
of the visible time window and also permits to manually select or deselect individual populations to be
displayed. View 3 provides a temporal overview of the data and allows to identify time intervals of interest,
for example, due to an external perturbation.
X
lx
ly
2.1.4 View 4: Scrolling spike-count rate iso-surface plot
The instantaneous spike-count rates of our example network are time-series activity data with 2D spatial
structure. In order to visualize such data without loss of dimensionality, a 3D representation is in general
required (unlike for instance view 3). The scrolling spike-count rate iso-surface scene in Figure 4B
simultaneously shows the evolution of network activity in space (as in views 1 and 2) and time (as in
view 3). The rate iso-value surfaces of each population is rendered using the computer-graphics algorithm
'marching cubes' (Lorensen and Cline, 1987). The color coding of the individual populations matches the
coding used in views 2 and 3. In terms of user interactivity, the user can set the threshold (isolation) for
the surfaces. Furthermore, the user can select which populations to show, vary their opacity level, apply a
temporal offset to individual populations, change the width of the time window, and take full control of the
viewpoint in the 3D scene as in view 2.
2.1.5 Raw data views
In addition to visualizing spatiotemporally binned, preprocessed data, views 1-3 can also be used with
raw simulation output files formatted according to the description in Section 3.1. With raw file output,
view 1 (Section 2.1.1, Figure 5A) displays for each animation time step a square marker for each spike
time ts
j at the spatial location (xj, yj) of neuron j in population X. The square marker color is population
specific. Likewise, view 2 (Section 2.1.2, Figure 5B) shows boxes of equal size for each spike event,
colored according to population. The view allows, as with precomputed spike-count rates, to show spiking
activity in each population in the same scene. We here show a snapshot of the spiking activity in perspective
11
Senk et al.
VIOLA
Figure 4. View 3: Scrolling spike-count rate plot. Panel A is a time-series representation of the data
across a user-variable time interval around the present time step of VIOLA's rendering loop, indicated
by the vertical white line. The instantaneous total spike-count rate summed over all populations is drawn
using a black line. The relative fraction of spikes of each population to the total spike count is shown as a
stacked, normalized histogram. The population outputs are color coded as in view 2. View 4: Scrolling
spike-count rate iso-surface plot. Panel B provides a 3D representation of the spatiotemporally resolved
spike-count rates of one selected network population across a user-variable time window. The spike-count
rate is rendered as a closed iso-value surface in the color of the respective population and extends in both
space (x− and y−axes) and time (delay axis). The present time step in the visualization is indicated by a
time lag of zero on the time-delay axis. At zero time delay we also show the LFP signal corresponding to
the present time step in the animation.
mode, and top-down. The main interactive feature of views 1 and 2 incorporated with raw data files is the
option to reduce the neuron density to be displayed. As with preprocessed data visualization with view 2,
individual layers can be activated/deactivated, one can switch between the orthographic and perspective
viewing modes, and the camera can be positioned freely. View 3 (Section 2.1.3) applied to raw data is
shown in Figure 5C. The temporal bin size of the animation is then equal to the simulation time step dt
(one spike therefore results in the spike count rate 1/dt in units of spikes/s for that instant). The total spike
count (black line) is summed over all neurons, in contrast to the mean over per-bin rates as in the case of
the preprocessed data. The relative spike count per population is shown as a stacked plot normalized by the
total amount of spikes in each temporal bin.
12
View 4View 3time step/total timeinstantaneoustotalspike-countratedelayrelativetocurrenttime steppopulationcolorandnamerelative fractionofeachpopulationtototal spikecountcamerasettings,time step/total timespatiotemporallyresolvedspikecountofonepopulationdelayrelativetocurrenttime stepspatialx-/y-axisLFP at currenttime stepzerodelayindicatorABabcdeabcdef Senk et al.
VIOLA
Figure 5. Views 1-3 applied with raw data formats. A View 1: Each dot corresponds to a single spike
event of a neuronal unit at its spatial location in the network. B View 2: Perspective top-down view onto
stacked layers of Panel A. C View 3: The stacked plot has the temporal bin-size of the simulation resolution.
The black trace shows the spike count of all neurons per time bin (in units of spikes/s).
2.2 VIOLA use case
Numerical model development representing a physical system comprises implementation, simulation,
analysis as well as comparison, validation and verification steps. Such model development is important
for building hypotheses and aiding interpretation based on experimental data and observations. We here
demonstrate how the views described above can be integrated with the development of a spiking point-
neuron network model. For this purpose, we can hypothesize that transient external input to a layered
spiking point-neuron network model with distance-dependent recurrent connections results in propagating
spatiotemporal activity. We wish to assess the spatial extent and temporal duration of the network response
to external perturbation and whether or not the unperturbed network state is recovered. In this use case we do
this assessment by visual inspection prior to any detailed numerical analysis, focusing on the importance of
coordinated multiple views (Wang Baldonado et al., 2000; Roberts, 2007) and Shneiderman's information-
seeking mantra (Shneiderman, 1996). For our hypothesis above we will therefore use our implementations
of views 1-4 in VIOLA to rapidly analyze our network activity. We show that a combination of the different
views is needed to asses the relevant aspects in the data, which is the evoked response to a network
perturbation.
The layered point-neuron network illustrated in Figure 1B consists of an excitatory (EX) and an inhibitory
(IN) neuronal population plus one stimulus population (STIM) . Each neuron is placed randomly within
square sheets. EX, IN and STIM units are connected using distance-dependent rules as illustrated in
Figure 1A. The connectivity is periodic across boundaries (torus connectivity). The detailed network
description is given in Section 3.4. The main simulation output is spike times of individual neurons, neuron
locations and a synthetic LFP signal (see Section 3.5 for details). Our initial preprocessing steps and
corresponding data formats are described in Section 3.1.
2.2.1 Temporal features of evoked network activity
We first focus on ongoing activity of the network in the time domain, as provided by view 3. This
view implements a scrolling spike-count rate plot which ignores spatial information. Interactive control
of the view's time window allows for quick identification of events of interest from the full duration
of the simulation (Figure 6A). One such event that is clearly differentiated from other ongoing activity
is the activation of the external STIM population at the animation time step of 500 ms. Pausing the
13
ABC Senk et al.
VIOLA
Figure 6. Identifying a time interval of interest with view 3. A The spike-count rate summed across
spatial bins and the relative contributions by populations EX, IN and STIM shown for a time window
of ±500 ms around the current time step of the animation. B Same as Panel A, but with a narrower time
window of ±70 ms (indicated by the green frame in panel A), highlighting the activation of the STIM
population and corresponding network response. C Same as panel B, but with the STIM contribution
turned off.
animation at 504 ms and zooming in onto the event (Figure 6B) allows for a detailed look on how the total
spike-count rate (black trace) increases and oscillates while the stimulus is active, and confirms that the
stimulus duration was 50 ms. The color-coded stacked histogram reveals that during stimulus activation a
large relative fraction of spike events is contributed by the STIM units (gray), while the relative fraction
generated by the recurrently connected EX (blue) and IN (red) units is reduced. We may also conclude that
the transient onset of the stimulus results in temporally brief imbalances between excitatory and inhibitory
populations in the network as the relative rate of the inhibitory population drops with regular intervals
during the stimulation period. The imbalances occur at the stimulus onset and during each period of the
resulting network oscillation (from recurrent interactions between excitatory and inhibitory neurons). This
network spike-rate imbalance is even more pronounced when the STIM activity is hidden (Figure 6C). We
note, however, that the rate balance averaged over the stimulus duration is similar to time-averaged rate
balance in the non-perturbed state.
From the visualization we can also infer that the external perturbation to the network does not result in a
shifted network state after the stimulus is switched off. Overall rate fluctuations and relative fractions of
spike-count rates appear comparable before and after the stimulus period, unlike networks that may display
multi-stable patterns of activity (Litwin-Kumar and Doiron, 2012; Miller, 2016) wherein their state can
shift from one attractor to another either spontaneously or due to a perturbation.
2.2.2 Spatial features of evoked network activity
Having identified a time segment of particular interest (the stimulus duration), we next exploit view
1, the 2D spike-count rate view, and focus on spatial aspects of the evoked network activity. Figure 7
shows a series of snapshots from the instantaneous spike-count rate animation across space for the EX
(top row) and the STIM (bottom row) layers. Snapshots are shown for successive bins of width ∆t. The
first three columns in Figure 7 show spontaneous activity of the EX units. Thereafter the STIM population
is switched on, as seen in the fourth column of the bottom row. The activity of the STIM layer is by
construction confined to a circle at the center of the network. As the activity of the NSTIM units in the
STIM layer is governed by Poisson processes with rate expectations νSTIM, its spike intensity remains
fairly constant (except for the bin at 500 ms as the time bin is centered on the time step). In layer EX, the
stimulus elicits an increase in activity spreading outwards from the center. This response dies out after a
14
CBA Senk et al.
VIOLA
Figure 7. From spontaneous to evoked activity, resolved in time and 2D space. Time frames of
populations EX (first row) and STIM (second row) are captured from view 1 every 1 ms. After three frames
showing spontaneous activity of population EX, the STIM layer is activated (first visible in the fourth
column, at 500 ms), resulting in a repeated pattern of outward spread of activity in the EX layer. The time
step highlighted by a green outline (at 504 ms) corresponds to the animation time step in Figure 6.
Figure 8. Coordinated views on a temporal snapshot of the neuronal activity. A Instantaneous spike-
count rates in layers EX, IN and STIM using view 1. The animation time step of 504 ms is identical to
the one in Figs 6-7 in this and subsequent panels. B Orthographic top-down view onto stacked population
layers and LFP image plot with view 2. C Perspective view with large layer separation, including summed
spike counts projected towards the layer edges in view 2.
few milliseconds due to recurrent inhibition, but reoccurs regularly as reflected by the oscillatory behavior
observed in Figure 7B. The time step at 504 ms highlighted by the green outline is the same as in Figure 7
and latter Figures 8 and 9.
2.2.3 2D and 3D views of spatial activity
In order to relate the spatial relationship between activity in individual populations, we compare in
Figure 8 three different layer-wise animations of neuronal activity. View 1 (Figure 8A) shows individual
2D image plots for the spike-count rates per population, with a shared color bar coding for instantaneous
spike-count rate values. This view offers an accurate spatial representation of network activity in temporal
bins of width ∆t, showcasing the locality of the STIM layer activity and the wider spread of evoked
activity in the EX and IN layers. This view does not, however, offer interactive features except time control
of the animation (shared with views 2-4) and global scaling of the color-value mapping (sensitivity control,
shared with views 2 and 3).
15
time step(ms)497498499500501502503504505506508509510507CBA Senk et al.
VIOLA
The 3D-scene provided by view 2 adds additional interactive features and incorporates the layer-resolved
data of view 1 in one animation (Figure 8B,C). Panels B and C show the same temporal snapshot of activity
as in Panel A. The view shows also the spatial variation of the LFP signal that we synthesized from network
activity. The LFP signal, here shown as image plot with a color-coding reflecting its magnitude and sign, is
more difficult to relate to the ongoing activity, as it is inherently a signal driven by past spiking activity
(resulting of delayed synaptic activation on postsynaptic neurons from spiking activity in presynaptic
neurons, cf. Section 3.5). We then compare rate values of one spatial bin and one population to other spatial
locations and other populations through their different color codings and cube sizes. An observation is
that activity in the EX and IN layers are typically confined within the same spatial region of the network,
while a larger fraction of the network is quiescent at the time. This observation can for example explain
high variability in interspike-intervals of individual neurons (Keane and Gong, 2015), as neurons may
fire frequently while fronts of activity spread across the network and remain quiet until the next burst of
activity.
In terms of using interactive features offered in view 2, we turn off the orthographic mode of panel B and
go back to its default 3D perspective in panel C. We also rotate the viewpoint in order to directly focus
on highly active parts of the network. Furthermore, the different layers of the network and LFP are offset
vertically, with dynamic projections of the sum of spiking activity across each respective spatial axis for
each network layer. From this setup of view 2, we can better infer the activity in each individual layer,
including that of the LFP layer, without switching off individual layers.
2.2.4 Spatiotemporally resolved network activity
We finally investigate network activity in space and time using the 3D scene provided by view 4. Similar
to the scrolling spike-count rate plot of view 3, view 4 allows full control of the time axis. The activity
of all populations EX, IN and STIM is displayed for a wide (200 ms) temporal segment using red, blue
and gray iso-surfaces, respectively, in Figure 9A. We have centered the current time step (at 504 ms) on
the evoked activity in the STIM layer (highlighted in Figure 7). It is already possible to identify activity
patterns confined in space and time. However, it remains difficult to assess how spontaneous network
activity changes in response to the stimulus due to occlusion of one surface by another, an inherent issue
with multiple solid surfaces. In Figure 9B we therefore hide the activity of the IN layer and focus on
the activity in the EX layer. The surfaces correspond to the bin-wise instantaneous spike-count rates at
an isolation threshold of 100 spikes/s. Increasing this threshold to 360 spikes/s (Figure 9C) reveals that
regular bursts of high rates occur at the center of the layer, in the period when the STIM layer is activated.
In the other views, these bursts may be seen as rate oscillations (Figure 6) or pulsating spatial activity
(Figures 7-8). We here show that the attenuation of activity radiating outward from the center is rather
strong.
Using view 4, both the oscillation frequency and the outward spread of activity in the EX population can
be assessed. We highlight the STIM activity by reducing the opacity of the EX surfaces in Figure 9D. This
reduces occlusion problems present with multiple overlapping opaque surfaces, and thus allows relating the
activity in these two populations to one another. A smaller time segment of the scene is shown in panels E
and F where we also demonstrate different camera positions. Rotating the camera allows us to observe the
synthesized LFP signal at the current time step, and the corresponding network interactions resulting in a
strong LFP fluctuation. We also observe the temporal offset between stimulus onset and a response in the
EX activity as shown in Figure 9F.
16
Senk et al.
VIOLA
Figure 9. Spatiotemporally resolved activity. A Spike-count rates across time and space of populations
EX (blue), IN (red) and STIM (gray) shown with view 4 for a time window of ±100 ms around the present
time step of the animation. The isolation threshold is set to a rate of 100 spikes/s. The animation time step
is identical to the one in Figures 6-8 in this and subsequent panels. B Same as panel A, but with IN activity
turned off. C Same as Panel B, but with an increased isolation threshold of 360 spikes per second. D Same
as panel C, but with reduced opacity of layer EX activity and an isolation threshold of 195 spikes/s. E A
narrower time window (±55 ms) and shifted camera position (isolation threshold of 195 spikes/s). The
image plot at a delay of 0 ms shows the synthesized LFP signal across space. F Same as panel E, but with
the camera position rotated around the vertical z−axis.
In contrast to the previously discussed applications of views 1-3, the 3D-scene of view 4 allows to
relate both temporal and spatial aspects of the spiking activity of different neuronal populations and the
LFP signal to one another. With this view, we can get an overview of a large time segment and several
populations and then use its incorporated interactive features in order to explore the network activity under
influence of the stimulus. The focus of this view lies on highlighting qualitatively interesting features of
the data on spatiotemporal scales such as the oscillating activity of EX population surrounding the STIM
location (as in Figure 9C) or the temporal offset between STIM and EX seen in Figure 9F. Views 1 and 3,
however, better resolve quantitative rate values or temporal offsets, respectively, than views 2 and 4.
3 METHODS
3.1 Data formats
The data we consider for visualization are sequences Sj of spike times tj =(cid:80)
j) of a neuronal
unit j ∈ X located at coordinate (xj, yj), where X denotes a neuronal population of size NX. Individual
j are constrained to a discrete grid n · dt for n ∈ {0, 1, 2, ..., nsteps − 1}, where dt is the
spike times ts
s∈Sj
δ(ts
17
CBADEF Senk et al.
VIOLA
time-resolution of spike acquisition and nsteps the number of time steps in the acquisition period T . We
assume that the raw spike data to be visualized is available in two pure text files per population X. The first
file contains two columns with values separated by a white space. Its first column contains integer numbers
representing 'global neuron identifiers' (neuron IDs) j, while the second column contains corresponding
spike times ts
j in units of ms. This data format, first introduced for experimental data and reviewed in
Rostami et al. (2017), is the default output format for spike data of the neuronal network simulator NEST
(Kunkel et al., 2017). While the floating point data type is sufficient for displays and the computation of
single-neuron and population spike rates, the format is only safe for correlation analysis if the time step is
a power of two (Morrison et al., 2007, A.2). The latter guarantees that spike times have a representation
in the data type. An alternative is to use the original definition of the format and denote spike times by
the integers n, thus expressing time in units of the resolution of the grid. The second file contains three
space-separated columns. Its first column contains unit IDs j, while columns two and three contain the
corresponding coordinates xj and yj in units of mm. NEST internally represents networks as a graph where
edges denote connections. Neurons cannot be interrogated for their location and are only identified by their
ID, thus the information on the location must be defined and stored explicitly.
We consider another text-based data format for the visualization of spike data that are preprocessed by a
temporal and spatial binning procedure. For the temporal binning we define a temporal bin size ∆t as an
integer multiple of the acquisition time resolution dt. For spatial binning of neuron positions along the x−
and y−axes we define the bin widths ∆l. The third spatial dimension (z−axis) is ignored. Assuming an
acquisition period T and the side length L of the centered square network domain, the number of temporal
bins is K = T /∆t and the numbers of spatial bins along each axis {Lx, Ly} = L/∆l. A spatiotemporal
bin is indexed by the length-three tuple of indices β = (lx ∈ {0, 1, ..., Lx − 1}, ly ∈ {0, 1, ..., Ly − 1}, k ∈
{0, 1, ..., K − 1}), spanning x ∈ [lx∆l − L/2, (lx + 1)∆l − L/2), y ∈ [ly∆l − L/2, (ly + 1)∆l − L/2)
and t ∈ [k∆t, (k + 1)∆t). In each spatiotemporal bin, we sum for every population X the number of
spike events and divide by the temporal bin size ∆t. We refer to this measure as the instantaneous spike-
count rate νβ in units of 1/s. The preprocessed data is contained in one single file per population with
four space-separated columns. Indices lx, ly and k for each spatiotemporal bin are put in columns 1, 2
and 3, respectively, while the 4th column contains the corresponding rate value. Rows are ordered in
iteration running order according to k ∈ [0, 1, ..., K − 1] over all lx ∈ [0, 1, ..., Lx − 1] and finally over all
ly ∈ [0, 1, ..., Ly − 1]. Row entries where νβ = 0 is not written. The same data format is used to represent
the evolution of spatially organized analog data with spatial resolution ∆lφ. The unit of the data depends
on the actual measure, for example mV in case of the LFP.
3.2 Reference implementation
We have made implementations of the visualization types discussed throughout this paper available in the
tool VIOLA (VIsualization Of Layer Activity). Figure 10 illustrates the web-based JavaScript framework
integrating the different visualizations we refer to as views. A central class named Main carries out the
initialization and coordination of the views. The Graphical User Interface (GUI) is comprised of two main
components, the Setup Panel and the Main Panel. The Main Panel also serves as a container
for the views. The Setup Panel is the first entity presented to the user when the application is opened
in a web browser. It serves mainly to specify the data types to be loaded and the basic data features
(spatial dimensionality, time resolution) and visualization features such as the colors for each neuron
population. Parameters can be set manually or be loaded from configuration files, for example specifying
18
Senk et al.
VIOLA
whether to load raw or preprocessed data. These configuration files are JavaScript Object Notation7 (JSON)
files specifying the format of the loaded data, file names, and preset values for the visualizations. After
confirming the entered information, the Main.setup() function extracts the entries and provides them
globally to the other components. The Main Panel shown afterwards is used to load the input data
files from the local file system using JavaScript FileReader, which includes setting up the internal
data structure giving a coherent access to the data to be visualized. The Main.init() function then
initializes the rendering loop, which is built into the web browser and controls the rendering of the various
views. The Main.render() method is executed periodically by built-in functionality of the browser,
which is further used to synchronize the rendering of all views. This is necessary as the rendering of an
individual time step needs different amount of time per view. For example, rendering a complex 3D scene
is slower (because it need more computational resources) than rendering a less complex 2D plot. All views
must have finished rendering before the next rendering step is triggered. Each rendering call is triggered by
updating the global timeStepIndex through the browser. The update of the timeStepIndex calls
the rendering loop, which redirects the rendering call to all views. For rendering the data, all views access
the loaded simulation data structure as part of the Main object.
The timeStepIndex variable can be controlled in two modes. First, it can be manually set by the
user via a slider widget. The slider widget enables the user to scroll manually along the time axis, thus
offering a simple navigation through the time series. Second, the user can start an animation of the loaded
data set by pressing a start button. This triggers a periodic update of the timeStepIndex. As both
manual and periodical updates of the timeStepIndex trigger the same downstream functionality for
updating the views, manual navigation through the time series can be combined with automatic updates of
the timeStepIndex. In case the animation is running, manual intervention by the user overrides the
periodic update of the timeStepIndex, such that the shown data item (time step) corresponds to that
manually selected one. The animation is continued from this manually selected time step.
All views offer view-specific selectors for visualization parameters. These parameters are read in and
used in each render call.
3.3 2D and 3D view implementations
This section describes the visualization algorithms used with the different view implementations in
VIOLA as introduced throughout the Results. As the output data produced by the simulation are scalars
organized on a regular grid (related to the neuron's position), visualization methods applicable to scalar
data are employed as well as standard chart types (Hansen and Johnson, 2011). View 1 implements a
standard image plot in which the color of each spatial bin represents a spike-count rate value. The display
maps a binned measure of neuronal activity on a color by using a lookup table ranging from black to white
over red and yellow (often referred to as 'red hot' or 'white hot' lookup table). We selected this lookup
table as it is widely used and offers (if non-linear interpolated) equidistant colors according to the CIE
L*a*b* color space [EN ISO 11664-4 from 1976]8. This color space is designed to represent equidistant
colors according to human perception: a color twice as light in CIE L*a*b* space is also perceived twice
as light by a human user (Fairchild, 2013). Such a heat map (Spence, 2001) facilitates the representation of
the spatial structure of the data.
In the 3D visualization of view 2, VIOLA also implements a geometrical mapping of activity data to a
cube's edge length, resulting in a cubic mapping of the single scalar value representing activity at each
7 http://www.json.org
8 https://www.vis4.net/blog/posts/mastering-multi-hued-color-scales
19
Senk et al.
VIOLA
time step. The default scaling of the cube's edge length is such that the cube's volume is proportional to the
data value in each bin.
In view 3, the concept of a stacked bar chart supports a global perspective on the simulated model (Spence,
2001). Individual populations in the model are color-coded to be separable in the bar chart. An additional
line graph added on top of the bars shows the total spike-count rate as reference to the global activity.
For view 4, in order to support the visual interpretation of time series of spatially organized activity data,
the 2D-organized activity data (considering the neurons in one layer) are extracted along the time axis
resulting in a regularly structured 3D volume of scalar values. Through contouring, partial sub-volumes
with a certain minimum threshold of activity get extracted and rendered as geometry. By means of a
selected iso-value Ith such geometry gets extracted by applying the marching cubes algorithm for implicit
volume rendering (Lorensen and Cline, 1987). For extraction of the geometry, the algorithm assumes that
each data point of the data set is mapped onto a vertex (corner point) of a regular 3D grid, which can be
subdivided into cells delimited by eight neighboring vertices each. Then, the algorithm calculates for each
vertex of a cell whether the associated data value of the considered vertex lies inside or outside of the
contour defined by the iso-value Ith by comparing the data value with the iso-value. If the data value of a
vertex is smaller than the iso-value, the vertex is assumed to lay inside of the contour. For each possible
combination of inside/outside states of the vertices of a cell, the topology of the contour for each cell gets
extracted from a table by calculating a representative index. This table holds all possible topological states
of a cell, which are constructed under the assumption that there are an infinite number of possibilities how
a contour can pass a cell (for more details, please refer to, for example Hansen and Johnson (2011, Chap.
1). Finally, the exact position of the contour gets calculated by interpolation along the cell's edges.
Views 2, 3 and 4 all use the same color coding to identify the different neuronal populations. The
implementation of the algorithms and views uses native JavaScript. The 2D rendering routine uses the
HTML5 canvas element. The browser rendering engine supports HTML5 and especially the functionality
of the canvas element, therefore no external libraries are required. 3D renderings relied on the three.js9
wrapper for WebGL content which is natively supported by the engine of modern browsers. Node.js10
facilitates the communication between views and the GUI for control.
3.4 Network description
The example network is based on an implementation of a random balanced network (Brunel, 2000)
which is part of NEST as an example (brunel_alpha_nest.py in NEST 2.12.0 by Kunkel et al.,
2017). The model is expressed using PyNEST (Eppler et al., 2009) in Python11. The network consists of
NEX excitatory and NIN inhibitory spiking point-neurons which are sparsely connected with connection
probability c. Neurons have fixed in-degrees of cNEX excitatory and cNIN inhibitory incoming synapses
with weights gY,EXJ and gY,INJ, respectively, with Y ∈ {EX, IN}. The integrate-and-fire model neurons
are connected using static, current-based synapses with an alpha-shaped time course (NEST neuron model:
iaf_psc_alpha). The intrinsic neuron parameters are identical for both neuron types. In addition to the
recurrent connections, each neuron receives uncorrelated, external excitatory input from a Poisson process
of a fixed rate νext = ηνθ , where η denotes the external rate relative to the threshold rate νθ which is
defined as νθ = (Vθ − EL)Cm/(exp(1)Jτmτs). The threshold rate is the hypothetical external rate needed
to bring the average membrane potential of a neuron to threshold Vθ (in the absence of an actual spiking
9 https://threejs.org
10 https://nodejs.org
11 http://www.python.org
20
Senk et al.
VIOLA
mechanism). EL denotes the resting potential, Cm the membrane capacitance, τm the membrane time
constant and τs the postsynaptic current time constant.
Unlike the original network implementation which has no spatial information, we here place neurons
randomly on a square 2D sheet with side lengths L. The connection probability between a presynaptic
neuron j and postsynaptic neuron i decays with increasing horizontal distance rij (using periodic boundary
conditions) while we preserve the in-degrees (number of incoming connections). A Gaussian-shaped profile
pY X (rij) is used with a standard deviation of σY X with X, Y ∈ {EX, IN}. We use Y X (rij) to describe
the distance-dependent connectivity profile assuming that the in-degree is preserved. The transmission
delay function dY X (rij) has a linear distance dependency with an offset d0
Y X and a conduction velocity
vY X.
In addition to the stationary external input to each population, the network receives a spatially confined
transient input with a duration tSTIM. The input is provided by a size NSTIM population of parrot neurons
(NEST's parrot_neuron devices), positioned inside a circle of radius RSTIM around (x, y) = (0, 0).
Parrot neurons simply repeat input spike events as output spike events. Each parrot neuron receives input
from a Poisson process with a rate expectation of νSTIM and connected to KSTIM neurons of the EX
population inside a connection mask radius R from the parrot-neuron location. The Poisson input starts at
TSTIM and consequently the STIM units become active after a delay of dSTIM.
Section 3.4 summarizes the network description with model and simulation parameters listed in Table 2A
and B.
The original parameters for the EX-IN network in the NEST example are modified for this VIOLA use
case demonstration bringing the network in a state with spatially confined network activity. For this we
increase the network's neuron count, reduce the ratio of inhibitory to excitatory weights gY,IN and the
membrane capacitance Cm, while the postsynaptic amplitude J is increased. The parameter J is originally
defined in units of mV, but is here re-defined in units of pA. Finally, the fixed conduction delay is replaced
by a distance-dependent one.
The data sets result from simulations of duration Tsim with a temporal resolution of dt. We discard the
startup transient period Ttrans and record all spike times from all neurons. The unprocessed spike times
together with the corresponding neuron positions are considered as raw output. The temporal and spatial
bin sizes used for preprocessing, ∆t and ∆l respectively, are given in Table 2C.
3.5 LFP predictions
Generation of LFP-like data: The local field potential (LFP) is, due to its relative ease of measurement, a
common measure of neuronal activity (Buzsáki et al., 2012; Einevoll et al., 2013). The LFP is, in general,
assumed to reflect synaptic activity and correlations of a large number of neurons in vicinity of the recording
electrodes (Kajikawa and Schroeder, 2011; Lindén et al., 2011; Łe¸ski et al., 2013). For the purpose of
demonstrating VIOLA's functionality, we synthesize LFP signals from network activity assuming a linear
network-population spike to LFP relationship HX ≡ HX ((cid:126)∆, τ ) derived using a biophysical model. In this
relationship, (cid:126)∆ denotes the displacement between the center of a spatial bin and an electrode contact point
γ at rγ, and τ the time relative to a presynaptic spike event ("lag"). Assuming linearity and homogeneous
spike-LFP responses of individual presynaptic neurons located within the same bin of width ∆lφ indexed
21
Senk et al.
VIOLA
by b = (lφ
x, lφ
y ) (see Section 3.1), the signal φX at one contact γ of one population X is then given by
(cid:32)
(cid:88)
(cid:88)
(
b
s
φX (rγ, t) =
(cid:33)
δ(ts
b)) ∗ HX
(rγ, t) .
(1)
Here, the term(cid:80)
(cid:88)
b of all presynaptic neurons in a bin b where δ
denotes the Dirac delta function, and ∗ a convolution. As contributions of different populations X sum
linearly, the total signal at each contact is
b) represents a series of spike times ts
s δ(ts
φ(rγ, t) =
φX (rγ, t) .
(2)
X
Point-like neurons (as used in our network model) can not generate an extracellular potential, as all in-
and outgoing currents sum to zero at the point's location (due to conservation of charge). As in Hagen
et al. (2016) we assume that spatially extended (morphologically detailed) neurons and corresponding
multicompartment models in combination with an electrostatic forward model are required to compute a
biophysically meaningful LFP signal. To compute the LFP, we here derive for each presynaptic population
X ∈ {EX, IN, STIM} the phenomenological mapping HX ((cid:126)∆, τ ) between a presynaptic spike event time
b occurring in a spatial bin indexed by b to the extracellular potential.
ts
Measurement sites: The electrode contact point locations are defined at the center of each spatial bin as
rγ = ((lφ
x + 1/2)∆lφ − L/2, (lφ
y + 1/2)∆lφ − L/2, 0).
Multicompartment model: We define a ball-and-stick type multicompartment model neuron with morpho-
logical features and passive parameters derived from the network's LIF neuron description (membrane
capacitance Cm, membrane time constant τm, passive leak reversal potential EL). Assuming a homogeneous
specific membrane capacitance cm (capacitance per membrane area) and axial resistivity ra (resistance
times length unit), we choose the dendritic stick length Ldend and radius rdend as follows: To preserve
the total capacity of the point neuron (and equivalent surface area), we compute the corresponding soma
radius as rsoma =
. We define the passive leak conductivity as gL = cm/τm and leak
reversal potential as EL. For these calculations we choose cm, ra, Ldend and rdend values as given in
Table 3, resulting in rsoma ≈ 13.1 µm. The compact ball-like soma is treated as a single segment, while the
elongated dendrite is split into ndend = 11 segments of equal length. The center of the soma segment is set
to r = (0, 0, 0), and the dendritic stick is aligned in the positive direction along the vertical z−axis.
(cid:113) Cm
− rdendLdend
4πcm
2
j−dij)/τsyn)Θ(t−ts
Synapse model: For LFP predictions we use the same current-based synapse model as in the network,
defining the postsynaptic input current of a single presynaptic spike event as Iij(t) = JY X · (t − ts
j −
j−dij), where JY X denotes the connection-specific postsynaptic
dij)/τsyn exp(1−(t−ts
current amplitude as in the network, ts
j the presynaptic spike time, dij = dY X (rij) the conduction delay
between presynaptic cell j and postsynaptic cell i and Θ the Heaviside step function. As we initially ignore
delays and network spike times we set dij = 0 and ts
Synaptic connectivity: For outgoing connections of the excitatory populations X ∈ {EX, STIM} we
distribute synaptic input currents evenly along the entire length of the dendritic stick, while for outgoing
connections of the inhibitory population X = IN all synaptic input currents are assumed to be evenly
distributed on the ball-like soma.
j = τ s.
22
Senk et al.
VIOLA
Electrostatic forward model: As described in detail in Lindén et al. (2014), we assume an extracellular
conductive medium that is linear (frequency independent), isotropic (identical in all directions), homo-
geneous (identical in all positions) and ohmic (linear relationship between current density and electric
potential), as represented by the scalar conductivity σe (cf. Table 3 for values). From the linearity of
Maxwell's equations, contributions to the extracellular potential from different current sources sum linearly.
Here, these current sources are transmembrane currents (summed over resistive, capacitive and synaptic
currents). In the presently used volume conduction theory, the electric potential in location rγ from a point
current with magnitude I(t) in location r0 is
φpoint(rγ, t) =
1
4πσe
I(t)
rγ − r0 .
(3)
This relation is also valid for a sphere current source (i.e., our ball soma) centered at r0 with total
transmembrane current Im,soma and radius rsphere when rγ − r0 ≥ rsphere. Thus
φsoma(rγ, t) =
1
4πσe
Im,soma(t)
rγ − rsoma .
(4)
The elongated dendritic segments are treated as 'line sources', obtained by integrating the point-source
formula along the central axis of the segments (Holt and Koch, 1999; Lindén et al., 2014):
φdend(rγ, t) =
1
4πσe
Im,u(t)
dru
rγ − ru .
ndend(cid:88)
u=1
(5)
(6)
The total extracellular potential from somatic and dendritic sources is then
φ(rγ, t) = φsoma(rγ, t) + φdend(rγ, t) .
Our calculations of extracellular potentials rely on the Python package LFPy12 (Lindén et al. (2014);
Hagen et al. (2018)). The tool implements the above forward-model formalism for extracellular potentials,
and uses the NEURON simulation environment (Carnevale and Hines, 2006) to compute transmembrane
currents Im(t) of multicompartment neuron models. As singularities may occur in the limit rγ − ru → 0,
the minimum distance between sources and measurement locations was set equal to the somatic or dendritic
segment radius.
Prediction of spike-LFP relationship: We here describe the calculation of the linear spike-LFP rela-
tionships HX ((cid:126)∆, τ ) which we use to construct an LFP-like signal from spatially binned network activity.
While Hagen et al. (2016) present a hybrid scheme to compute extracellular potentials from point-neuron
network activity, and incorporated the biophysics-based forward model summarized above, this hybrid
scheme is not adapted to laminar point-neuron networks with distance-dependent connections. We therefore
construct a simpler and numerically much less demanding method inspired by the hybrid scheme, that still
encompasses the governing biophysics underlying the generation of extracellular potentials and accounts
for the laminar structure and distance-dependent connectivity of our network.
In this simplified model, we ignore heterogeneity in spike-LFP responses Hi, of individual presynaptic
cells i ∈ X located within a spatial bin b, i.e., HX ≡ (cid:104)Hi(cid:105). Hi corresponds to the extracellular potential
12 http://lfpy.github.io
23
Senk et al.
VIOLA
resulting of synaptic activation of postsynaptic populations of cells j ∈ Y from a spike in cell i at time
τ = 0. We also assume that HX is invariable across presynaptic bins, and encompasses the overall
distance-dependent connection probabilities and connection delays in the network.
we compute the average out-degree (number of outgoing connections of neuron i) KX =(cid:80)
The calculation of HX ((cid:126)∆, τ ) involves a number of steps. We first estimate the spatially averaged
extracellular potential ϕj((cid:126)∆, τ ) resulting from a single synapse activation at a time τ s of the ball and stick
neuron positioned at the center of a reference bin, for excitatory and inhibitory input. Electrode contact
point locations rγ are defined at the centers of each square spatial bin indexed b (see above). With rotational
symmetry around the z−axis and periodic (torus) connectivity of the network, we compute extracellular
potentials at the unique subset of bin center-to-center distances r ⊂ {(cid:126)∆} up to the maximum distance
√
2L2, where L denotes the side length of the network layers, and {(cid:126)∆} the complete set of center-to-
center displacement vector lengths from reference bin to all spatial bins. We utilize built-in functionality
in LFPy to perform spatial averaging (cf. Eq. 6 in Lindén et al. (2014)), assuming square contact points
parallel to the horizontal xy−plane with side lengths equal to the bin width ∆lφ. In a following step
Y NY c for
X ∈ {EX, IN}, where c denotes the overall connection probability between X and Y (cf. Table 2 which
also gives KSTIM as a fixed parameter). With the distance-dependent connectivity Y X (r) used for each
presynaptic population and out-degree KX we compute the number of activated synapses (denoted by Kr)
in each spatial bin at a distance r from the reference bin (including r = 0) by evaluating pY X (r) at the
bin center points. The average connection delays from the reference bin to other bins are approximated as
dY X (r) = vY X + wY X r, where vY X denotes a constant delay offset and wY X the inverse propagation
speed of action potentials in the network, as summarized in Table 2 With the elements of these steps in
place (single-synapse LFP responses across bins, bin-wise number of activated synapses and delays), we
construct HX ((cid:126)δ, τ ) as function of r as:
(cid:88)
r∈{(cid:126)∆}
HX ((cid:126)∆, τ ) =
Kr · (δ(dY X (r)) ∗ ϕj)((cid:126)∆, τ ) ,
(7)
where δ(·) denotes the Dirac delta function. Note that we sum over all elements r in {(cid:126)∆}.
LFP output: Each HX is calculated at a spatial resolution ∆lφ and temporal resolution of dt (as in the
network, cf. Table 2) for a total duration of 2τ s, with synapse activation time at time τ s. An identical spatial
and temporal binning resolution is also used for spike events entering in (1). The spike rates in each bin are
filtered by a length ∆t normalized boxcar filter using the scipy.signal.lfilter method prior to the
convolution with the corresponding LFP kernel. Otherwise a temporal shift between the spatiotemporally
binned spiking data (cf. Section 3.1) and the downsampled LFP in the visualization occurs. Discrete
convolutions are incorporated using numpy.convolve and scipy.signal.convolve2d methods
in Python. The final LFP signals are low-pass filtered and downsampled to the time resolution ∆t of our
preprocessed network output as described in Hagen et al. (2016) in order to simultaneously show both
datasets in VIOLA. Output is stored in a pure-text format as described in Section 3.1.
Table 3 summarizes the parameter values for the LFP predictions.
3.6 Software summary
All source codes of the tool VIOLA, the example network model and the processing of model output
are hosted at https://github.com/HBPVIS/VIOLA (SHA:ca2f3c5). We simulated the example network
(topo_brunel_alpha_nest.py) with NEST v2.12.0 and Python v2.7.11. Further processing and
24
Senk et al.
VIOLA
plotting of Figures 1 and 2 (nest_preprocessing.py) also relied on Python with numpy v1.10.4,
SciPy v0.17.0, and matplotlib v1.5.1. LFP signals (fake_LFP_signal.py) were computed using
NEURON v7.5 and LFPy from http://lfpy.github.io (SHA:5673a6). We visualized the neuronal activity
with VIOLA using the Google Chrome browser, version 58.0.3029.110 (64-bit). VIOLA used JavaScript
V8 5.8.283.38 with the 3D library three.js of revision 87, including WebGL and HTML5 build in the
browser and Node.js v4.8.3. For colors, VIOLA used Chroma.js in the version 1.3.4.
Screenshots from VIOLA for the other figures were taken with Kazam-"NCC-80102" v1.4.5, and
combined in Microsoft PowerPoint 2013.
4 DISCUSSION AND OUTLOOK
The present study introduces four 2D and 3D visualization concepts, or views, for the interactive visual
analysis of the activity of spiking neuronal network simulations, and a reference implementation for
these views named VIOLA (VIsualization of Layer Activity). VIOLA is an interactive web-technology
based visualization tool designed to fit in between simulations and subsequent in-depth data analysis, and
exemplifies key concepts of the information-seeking mantra by Shneiderman (1996) and the paradigm
of coordinated multiple views (Wang Baldonado et al., 2000). The main application areas are the rapid
validation of simulation results and the exploration of spatiotemporally resolved data prior to further
quantitative analyses. As a use case, we demonstrate the usefulness of the tool with output from a simulation
of a layered spiking point-neuron network model that incorporates distance-dependent connectivity. The
use case shows that we can examine a perturbation of ongoing network activity caused by a temporally and
spatially confined stimulus. The duration and the spatial spread of the event are quickly assessed with the
help of multiple simultaneously displayed views.
In contrast to other visualization tools for simulated network output, for example VisNEST (Nowke et al.,
2013, 2015), SNN3DViewer (Kasi´nski et al., 2009), ViSimpl (Galindo et al., 2016), and Geppetto or more
generic multi-view tools like GLUE, the interactive JavaScript- and WebGLbased visualization integrates
data analysis methods in a web application, thereby achieving mobility and deployability. Our approach
builds on visualization concepts known from the literature for data of similar structure (reviewed in the
introduction), but advances the concepts and adds interactivity and animation. For example, views 1 and
2 compare to series of snap shots (as in Mehring et al. 2003; Yger et al. 2011; Voges and Perrinet 2012;
Keane and Gong 2015), but are here enhanced by the possibilities to show raw or preprocessed data, to
specify visualization parameters interactively, and to provide a 3D and temporally animated view on the
multi-dimensional data. View 4 presents a new concept combining 2D spatial and temporal resolution
of multiple neuron populations, all shown simultaneously. This data representation delivers a wealth of
information, but, to circumvent occlusion and instead expose interesting features of the data, it relies
on interactive usage. The code of the reference implementation is open source and available in a public
repository (https://github.com/HBPVIS/VIOLA) together with the revision history and documentation.
The present work uses the simulation code NEST to generate the data but the VIOLA implementation is
completely independent of the former. The JavaScript code defines a standalone application (accessible at
http://hbpvis.github.io/VIOLA) and interpretable by the browser running on the client device. In the last
decade, JavaScript-based visualization got more and more versatile especially fostered by the introduction
of HTML5 and its canvas environment. Furthermore, the development of WebGL enables the access to
GPU-accelerated 3D rendering in the browser. Beside limitations regarding memory and access to low-level
program control (as needed for controlled use of multi-threading), JavaScript offers the opportunity for
simple deployment and handling of external libraries and dependencies. Unfortunately, JavaScript-based
25
Senk et al.
VIOLA
implementations tend to fail on one or the other browsers as browsers still differ in their interpretation
of JavaScript and in the degree of following the HTML standard. Nevertheless, most browsers are free
to use and usable on most operating systems. Therefore, this work explores the radical decision to use
web-based technology to offer an easy-to-deploy tool for the visualization of dynamic simulation data.
As a consequence, software development and deployment are integrated with minimal effort and no
computational resources are required on the server: researchers immediately profit from progress on
the development platform. Furthermore, due to the web-technology and the minimal requirements on
the client, web portals can embed the application as a visualization backend; a prerequisite for the idea
to create centralized ICT infrastructure for neuroscience. One such portal is currently being developed
by the European Human Brain Project, named the HBP Collaboratory13. Another ongoing effort is the
Neuroscience Gateway14 (Sivagnanam et al., 2013). Online embedding opens the possibility to accompany
interactive visualization with server-side preprocessing steps and a database integration, in particular for
simulation output being generated on the portal itself. This advances the goal of the HBP Collaboratory
to provide a fully digitized workflow from data representation over model construction and simulation
to model validation (Senk et al., 2017). We argue that interactive visual analysis of simulated data is an
obvious feature of a collaboratory, in addition to non-interactive script-based plotting relying for example
on matplotlib.
The reference implementation accesses the file system of the host machine to load data. This is not
recommended for web applications for security reasons. If data processing and storage were handled on
the server-side, SQL-like database queries could restrict communication to only the data needed for the
different view instances. Communication does not have to be limited to the raw data. Binning operations
similar to those performed in our preprocessing steps can be handled by the database in a straightforward
manner, and could also be performed in parallel. The data format HDF15 would also be an option to store
and access large amounts of raw and preprocessed data with improved performance in terms of speed and
compactness compared to the currently used text format.
Inherent in interactive visualization is the problem of reproducibility. The raw data are insufficient to
reproduce the visuals, only in combination with the full collection of GUI parameters adjusted by the
researchers is the data set complete. In the same way as experimental and simulated data need to be
enriched with metadata in order to uniquely specify their origin and enable reuse (Zehl et al., 2016), the
visuals need to be enriched with the parameters of their creation. This new type of metadata could be stored
in a database.
The JavaScript implementation imposes other shortcomings. Prominent is its limited capability for
numerical analysis. While the math.js16 library provides a number of basic math functions and support
for symbolic operations, complex numbers and arrays (matrices), the JavaScript libraries are not comparable
to the Scientific Python stack (SciPy17) which provides an ecosystem of fundamental tools and methods
encountered in mathematics, engineering and science. VIOLA implements the function computing the
spatial correlation of neuronal activity from scratch (not shown). This approach has two conceptual
weaknesses. First, the speed and accuracy of such functions are hampered by the fact that there is little
native support for advanced mathematical operations, like the Fast Fourier Transform (FFT). Second,
13 https://collab.humanbrainproject.eu
14 http://www.nsgportal.org
15 https://www.hdfgroup.org
16 http://mathjs.org
17 https://www.scipy.org
26
Senk et al.
VIOLA
there is no separation between the code carrying out the statistical analysis and the code performing the
visualization. This cuts visualization off from the rich set of analysis tools developed by the community
and their reliable implementations, for example as collected in the Elephant package18. Future work needs
to disentangle numerics from visualization code as separate building blocks in a visual analysis workflow.
As VIOLA's main focus lies on responsive interactive visualization, the reference implementation uses
WebGL for all views. Prior tests exposed the low efficiency of the Document Object Model (DOM) as used
in Scalable Vector Graphics (SVG) based visualization libraries such as d3.js as well as its high memory
consumption. This led to the decision to the sole use of WebGL rendering, which has the limitation that
external tools are required for generating screen shots and screen casts; vector graphics can neither be
recorded nor exported. For the 2D views, an additional implementation based on the HTML 5 support
of SVG graphics can be added and used for the export of vector-based image material. For extracting
vector-based material from the 3D views, WebGL and its access to the underlying rendering pipeline can
be facilitated. The 3D scene can be exported to be viewed in other 3D programs. To this end, three.js
(as used in the reference implementation) offers export functionality for Wavefront OBJ file format, one
standard for 3D content. The alternative is to extract the rendered scene prior to rasterization and use
these data to generate a SVG or postscript-based representation similar to the operation of the C library
gl2ps19. Nevertheless, any export mechanism needs to facilitate means of reproducibility. In particular
metadata such as simulation and visualization parameters, time stamps, viewpoint angle and position etc.
need to be bundled with the raw visualizations. As direct file writes may not be possible in a client side
JavaScript application, one solution is server-based rendering and storage based on visualization parameters
being communicated from the client back to the server. The resulting server-side rendered images are then
stored as provenance information. Another option for reproducible visualization outcome is to only store
the previously mentioned visualization parameters in the database, such that the client-side visualization
application can be set back into the original captured state. If these parameters are captured over a longer
period, the resulting data can ease the regeneration of content for demonstration purposes or a post-hoc
video rendering.
While we here develop our arguments along model data, the different views and the reference implemen-
tation is equally suited for the exploration of experimental data. Our model network describes a neuronal
layer covering a 4 × 4 mm2 patch of cortical tissue. Electrophysiological measurements of neuronal
activity with the Utah multi-electrode array from Blackrock Microsystems sample both spiking activity
of individual cells and population LFPs across near 4 × 4 mm2 of cortex (Milekovic et al., 2015; Torre
et al., 2016b; Denker et al., 2017). Other multi-electrode arrays are used for in vitro experimentation
on neural tissue or cell cultures (Massobrio et al., 2015). No changes to the reference implementation
are required for the processing of these data. Other measurement modalities are of interest as well. One
common experimental method is Ca2+ imaging which may infer changes in intracellular [Ca2+] of neurons
in superficial (Grienberger and Konnerth, 2012) and deep layers (Ouzounov et al., 2017), while another
method is voltage-sensitive dye imaging (VSDi) that measures membrane-voltage time-derivatives in
surface-proximal tissues (Chemla and Chavane, 2010). With modifications to existing views or new view
implementations, VIOLA can also represent this type of spatiotemporally resolved data. In particular the
3D visualization types incorporated in the present views 2 and 4 are well suited to represent the changes
in intracellular Ca2+ ion concentrations across different cell bodies from 2- and 3-photon volumetric
Ca2+ imaging in neural tissue. Within view 2 the visual representations of each cell's concentration can
18 http://elephant.readthedocs.io
19 http://www.geuz.org/gl2ps
27
Senk et al.
VIOLA
be set to a depth and position in the horizontal plane according to its image stack position in the raw
imaging data. Units with baseline Ca2+ concentrations may then be hidden, and increasing levels can be
visualized by scaling the box sizes as we have demonstrated with spike-rate data. A view similar to view 4
could show time-varying ion-concentrations of individual units as 3D tube plots where the tube diameter
at a given time is proportional to a unit's Ca2+ concentration. As VSDi imaging data (typically) lacks
depth-information, color-image plotting can be applied similar to what we utilize here to show LFPs in our
3D view implementations. In addition, the multi-view aspect of visualization enables the combination of
spatial representations with more abstract non-spatial representations of neuronal activity, as reviewed in
the introduction.
The concepts developed here advance the visual exploration of data from cortical networks at cellular
resolution. If the reference implementation finds more widespread interest it can be further developed by a
community driven approach as all requirements like a proper licensing and a suitable development platform
are in place, the primary purpose, however, is to serve as a living supplement to this publication. Creating a
common web portal for the collaboration of neuroscientists is a central long-term goal of the Human Brain
Project. In this endeavor our study contributes knowledge on how a user interface for visual exploration
needs to be designed and on the proper layout of the software stack at the troubled transition point between
data processing and visualization.
AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS
JS, EH, CC, TK, MD, BW conceived and designed the study. JS, EH, CC, BW designed the various
types of visualizations. CC implemented the first version of VIOLA and JS co-developed the tool. JS, EH
implemented simulation, preprocessing and analysis code for the example network. EH incorporated LFP
predictions. JS ran all simulations and created the figures. JS wrote the first version of the paper. EH, BW,
MD, CC, TK co-wrote the paper.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This project received funding from the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme
under grant agreement No. 720270 (HBP SGA1), the European Union Seventh Framework Programme
[FP7/2007-2013] under grant agreement No. 604102 (Human Brain Project, HBP), the Helmholtz Associa-
tion through the Helmholtz Portfolio Theme "Supercomputing and Modeling for the Human Brain", the
Research Council of Norway (NFR) through COBRA.
28
Senk et al.
VIOLA
Figure 10. Flow chart of VIOLA's components. VIOLA incorporates two main parts: 'initialization'
(top) and 'run time' (bottom). The initialization procedure defines a Setup and Main Panel in VIOLA's
GUI and the corresponding Main.setup() and Main.init() functions. The Main.setup()
function is used for setting initial values, while the Main.init() function allows for loading datasets
with parameters that depend on setup values. The Main.init() function also instantiates the different
views in the application. The run-time component of VIOLA uses a rendering loop and time model provided
by the web browser. The time model is needed to synchronize the rendering of each view, such that at all
times each view shows the same time step of the data and thus compensates for different redering times of
the views. By default, the timeStepIndex in the rendering loop is automatically updated by the browser
(using the time model), but can also be set by the user, e.g. by a slider widget. The browser time model is
controlled using the 'animate' widget, while a time bar is used for 'manual' time selection. Each update
of the timeStepIndex triggers an execution of the Main.render() method and a corresponding
update of all views. Parameters for the different views can be modified during run time as each view offers
its individual input widgets.
29
Main.setup()- extraction of setup values from GUI- test for correctness of entered valuesMain.init()- generates data object by loading specified data files- generates configuration dependent panels- instantiate viewsMain.render()RENDER LOOPANIMATEMANUALtimeStepIndexTIME MODELBrowserBrowserDataData'ParametersTime BarSelectorsVIEW1ParametersSelectorsVIEWN...Setup PageMain PageGUI / HTML pageSoftware ComponentDataINITIALIZATIONRUN TIME Senk et al.
A: Model summary
Populations
Topology
Connectivity
Neuron model
Synapse model
Input
Measurement
B: Network model
Subthreshold
dynamics
Spiking
Distance-
dependent
connectivity
VIOLA
Three: excitatory EX, inhibitory IN, external stimulus STIM
EX/IN: random neuron positions on square domain of size L × L; STIM:
random neuron positions inside a circle with radius RSTIM at the center of the
domain; periodic boundary conditions
Random (EX/IN: convergent, fixed in-degree; STIM: divergent, fixed out-
degree) connections described by distance-dependent probability kernels and
cut-off masks
EX/IN: leaky integrate-and-fire (LIF), fixed threshold, absolute refractory time;
STIM: parrot
Static weights, EX/IN: alpha-shaped postsynaptic currents, distance-dependent
delays
Independent fixed-rate Poisson spike trains to all neurons
Spike activity
EX/IN:
If t > t∗ + τref
dV
Isyn (t) =(cid:80)
dt = − V −EL
τm
+ Isyn(t)
Cm
(cid:16)
j Jjα
t − t∗
j − dj
(cid:17)
with connection strength Jj, presynaptic spike time t∗
dj
α (t) = t
τs
1−t/τsΘ (t) with Heaviside function Θ
e
j and conduction delay
else
V (t) = Vreset
If V (t−) < Vθ ∧ V (t+) ≥ Vθ
1. set t∗ = t
2. emit spike with timestamp t∗
3. reset V (t) = Vreset
Neuronal units j ∈ X at location (xj, yj) and i ∈ Y at (xi, yi) in pre- and
postsynaptic populations X and Y , respectively.
Distance between units i and j:
(cid:113)
rij =
(xi − xj)2 + (yi − yj)2
Gaussian kernel for connection probability:
pY X (rij) = e−r2
ij /2σ2
Y X
R is the radius of a cut-off mask.
Transmission delay function:
dY X (rij) = d0
Y X + rij/vY X
Table 1. Description of the network model following the guidelines of Nordlie et al. (2009).
30
Senk et al.
VIOLA
A: Global simulation parameters
Symbol Value
Tsim
dt
Ttrans
TSTIM
tSTIM
B: Point-neuron network
1, 500 ms
0.1 ms
500 ms
999 ms
50 ms
Description
Simulation duration
Temporal resolution
Startup transient
Start time of Poisson input to STIM
Duration of STIM onset
Populations and external input
Description
Name
Population size:
X = EX
X = IN
X = STIM
Extent length
External rate relative to threshold rate for X ∈ {EX, IN}
Radius of circle around (0, 0) for locations of STIM
External rate to each STIM neuron
Connection Parameters
Description
Connection probability for recurrent connections between EX and IN
Reference synaptic strength. All synapse weights are measured in
units of J.
Relative synaptic strengths:
X = EX, Y ∈ {EX, IN}
X = IN, Y ∈ {EX, IN}
X = STIM, Y = EX
Radius of cut-off mask for X = STIM, Y = EX
Number of connections per STIM neuron
Standard deviation of Gaussian kernel:
X, Y ∈ {EX, IN}
Delay offset:
X, Y ∈ {EX, IN}
X = STIM, Y = EX
Conduction velocity:
X, Y ∈ {EX, IN}
X = STIM, Y = EX
Delay from Poisson input to STIM
Neuron model
Description
Membrane capacitance
Membrane time constant
Resting potential
Firing threshold
Reset potential
Absolute refractory period
Postsynaptic current time constant
Description
Temporal bin size
Spatial bin size
Symbol Value
X
NX
EX, IN, STIM
20, 000
5, 000
975
4 mm
2
0.5 mm
300 Hz
L
η
RSTIM
νSTIM
Symbol Value
c
J
0.1
40 pA
gY X
R
KSTIM
σY X
d0
Y X
vY X
dSTIM
1
−4.5
1
0.1 mm
300
0.3 mm
0.5 ms
0.5 ms
2 m/s
−
0.5 ms
Symbol Value
100 pF
Cm
20 ms
τm
0 mV
EL
20 mV
Vθ
0 mV
Vreset
2 ms
τref
0.5 ms
τs
C: Preprocessing
Symbol Value
1 ms
∆t
∆l
0.1 mm
Table 2. Simulation, network and preprocessing parameters.
31
Senk et al.
VIOLA
Simplified LFP model parameters
Symbol Value
cm
ra
Ldend
rdend
ndend
rsoma
τ s
1 µF/cm2
150 Ωcm
500 µm
2.5 µm
11
13.1 µm
25 ms
400 µm
Description
Specific membrane capacitance
Axial resistivity
Dendritic stick length
Dendritic stick radius
Dendritic stick number of segments
Derived soma segment radius
Synapse activation time
Electrode separation, spatial bin width
∆lφ
σe
Table 3. Parameters for prediction of LFP signals.
0.3 S/m
Extracellular conductivity
32
Senk et al.
VIOLA
REFERENCES
Abeles, M. (1982). Local Cortical Circuits: An Electrophysiological Study. Studies of Brain Function
(Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer-Verlag). doi:10.1007/978-3-642-81708-3
Aertsen, A. M. H. J., Gerstein, G. L., Habib, M. K., and Palm, G. (1989). Dynamics of Neuronal Firing
Correlation: Modulation of 'Effective Connectivity'. J Neurophysiol 61, 900–917. doi:10.1152/jn.1989.
61.5.900
Allen, E. A., Erhardt, E. B., and Calhoun, V. D. (2012). Data visualization in the neurosciences: overcoming
the curse of dimensionality. Neuron 74, 603–608. doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2012.05.001
Amit, D. J. and Brunel, N. (1997). Model of global spontaneous activity and local structured activity
during delay periods in the cerebral cortex. Cereb Cortex 7, 237–252. doi:10.1093/cercor/7.3.237
Bressloff, P. C. (2012). Spatiotemporal dynamics of continuum neural fields. J Phys A-Math Theor 45,
033001. doi:10.1088/1751-8113/45/3/033001
Brunel, N. (2000). Dynamics of sparsely connected networks of excitatory and inhibitory spiking neurons.
J Comput Neurosci 8, 183–208. doi:10.1023/A:1008925309027
Buzsáki, G., Anastassiou, C. A., and Koch, C. (2012). The origin of extracellular fields and currents - EEG,
ECoG, LFP and spikes. Nat Rev Neurosci 13, 407–420. doi:10.1038/nrn3241
Carnevale, N. T. and Hines, M. L. (2006). The NEURON Book (Cambridge University Press)
Chemla, S. and Chavane, F. (2010). Voltage-sensitive dye imaging: technique review and models. J Physiol
Paris 104, 40–50. doi:10.1016/j.jphysparis.2009.11.009
Coombes, S. (2005). Waves, bumps, and patterns in neural field theories. Biol Cybern 93, 91–108.
doi:10.1007/s00422-005-0574-y
Cunningham, J. P. and Byron, M. Y. (2014). Dimensionality reduction for large-scale neural recordings.
Nat Neurosci 17, 1500–1509. doi:10.1038/nn.3776
Czanner, G., Grün, S., and Iyengar, S. (2005). Theory of the snowflake plot and its relations to higher-order
analysis methods. Neural Comput 17, 1456–1479. doi:10.1162/0899766053723041
Denker, M., Roux, S., Lindén, H., Diesmann, M., Riehle, A., and Grün, S. (2011). The local field potential
reflects surplus spike synchrony. Cereb Cortex 21, 2681–2695. doi:10.1093/cercor/bhr040
Denker, M., Zehl, L., Kilavik, B. E., Diesmann, M., Brochier, T., Riehle, A., et al. (2017). LFP beta
amplitude is predictive of mesoscopic spatio-temporal phase patterns. arXiv e-print (arXiv:1703.09488)
Diesmann, M. and Gewaltig, M.-O. (2002). NEST: An environment for neural systems simulations. In
Forschung und wisschenschaftliches Rechnen, Beiträge zum Heinz-Billing-Preis 2001, eds. T. Plesser
and V. Macho (Göttingen: Ges. für Wiss. Datenverarbeitung), vol. 58 of GWDG-Bericht. 43–70
Diesmann, M., Gewaltig, M.-O., and Aertsen, A. (1995). SYNOD: an Environment for Neural Systems
Simulations. Language Interface and Tutorial. Tech. Rep. GC-AA-/95-3, Weizmann Institute of Science,
The Grodetsky Center for Research of Higher Brain Functions, Israel
Ecker, A. S., Berens, P., Keliris, G. A., Bethge, M., Logothetis, N. K., and Tolias, A. S. (2010). Decorrelated
neuronal firing in cortical microcircuits. Science 327, 584–587. doi:10.1126/science.1179867
Einevoll, G. T., Franke, F., Hagen, E., Pouzat, C., and Harris, K. D. (2012). Towards reliable spike-
train recordings from thousands of neurons with multielectrodes. Curr Opin Neurobiol 22, 11–17.
doi:10.1016/j.conb.2011.10.001
Einevoll, G. T., Kayser, C., Logothetis, N. K., and Panzeri, S. (2013). Modelling and analysis of
local field potentials for studying the function of cortical circuits. Nat Rev Neurosci 14, 770–785.
doi:10.1038/nrn3599
Epping, W., van den Boogaard, H., Aertsen, A., Eggermont, J., and Johannesma, P. (1984). The
neurochrome. Biol Cybern 50, 235–240
33
Senk et al.
VIOLA
Eppler, J. M., Helias, M., Muller, E., Diesmann, M., and Gewaltig, M.-O. (2009). PyNEST: A convenient
interface to the NEST simulator. Front Neuroinform 2, 1–12. doi:10.3389/neuro.11.012.2008
Fairchild, M. D. (2013). Color appearance models (John Wiley & Sons). doi:10.1002/9781118653128
Galindo, S. E., Toharia, P., Robles, O. D., and Pastor, L. (2016). ViSimpl: Multi-view visual analysis of
brain simulation data. Front Neuroinform 10, 1–14. doi:10.3389/fninf.2016.00044
Gentet, L. J., Avermann, M., Matyas, F., Staiger, J. F., and Petersen, C. C. H. (2010). Membrane
potential dynamics of GABAergic neurons in the barrel cortex of behaving mice. Neuron 65, 422–435.
doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2010.01.006
Gerstein, G. L. and Aertsen, A. M. H. J. (1985). Representation of cooperative firing activity among
simultaneously recorded neurons. J Neurophysiol 54, 1513–1528. doi:10.1152/jn.1985.54.6.1513
Gerstein, G. L., Perkel, D. H., and Dayhoff, J. E. (1985). Cooperative firing activity in simultaneously
recorded populations of neurons: Detection and measurement. J Neurosci 5, 881–889
Gerstein, G. L., Williamns, E. R., Diesmann, M., Grün, S., and Trengove, C. (2012). Detecting synfire
chains in parallel spike data. J Neurosci Meth 206, 54–64. doi:10.1016/j.jneumeth.2012.02.003
Gerstner, W. and Naud, R. (2009). How good are neuron models? Science 326, 379–380. doi:10.1126/
science.1181936
Gewaltig, M.-O. and Diesmann, M. (2007). NEST (NEural Simulation Tool). Scholarpedia 2, 1430.
doi:10.4249/scholarpedia.1430
Grienberger, C. and Konnerth, A. (2012). Imaging calcium in neurons. Neuron 73, 862–885. doi:10.1016/j.
neuron.2012.02.011
Grün, S. (1996). Unitary Joint-Events in Multiple-Neuron Spiking Activity: Detection, Significance,
ISBN
and Interpretation. Reihe Physik, Band 60 (Thun, Frankfurt/Main: Verlag Harri Deutsch).
3-8171-1506-7
Grün, S., Diesmann, M., and Aertsen, A. (2002). 'Unitary Events' in multiple single-neuron spiking
activity. II. Non-Stationary data. Neural Comput 14, 81–119. doi:10.1162/089976602753284464
Grün, S. and Rotter, S. (eds.) (2010). Analysis of Parallel Spike Trains (Springer)
Hagen, E., Dahmen, D., Stavrinou, M. L., Lindén, H., Tetzlaff, T., van Albada, S. J., et al. (2016). Hybrid
scheme for modeling local field potentials from point-neuron networks. Cereb Cortex 26, 4461–4496.
doi:10.1093/cercor/bhw237
Hagen, E., Naess, S., Ness, T. V., and Einevoll, G. T. (2018). Multimodal modeling of neural network
activity: computing LFP, ECoG, EEG and MEG signals with LFPy2.0. bioRxiv doi:10.1101/281717
Hansen, C. D. and Johnson, C. R. (2011). Visualization Handbook (Academic Press)
Helias, M., Tetzlaff, T., and Diesmann, M. (2013). Echoes in correlated neural systems. New J Phys 15,
023002. doi:10.1088/1367-2630/15/2/023002
Helias, M., Tetzlaff, T., and Diesmann, M. (2014). The correlation structure of local cortical networks
intrinsically results from recurrent dynamics. PLoS Comput Biol 10, e1003428. doi:10.1371/journal.
pcbi.1003428
Hines, M. L., Davison, A. P., and Muller, E. (2009). Neuron and python. Front Neuroinform 3. doi:10.
3389/neuro.11.001.2009
Holt, G. R. and Koch, C. (1999). Electrical interactions via the extracellular potential near cell bodies. J
Comput Neurosci 6, 169–184. doi:10.1023/A:1008832702585
Izhikevich, E. M. (2003). Simple model of spiking neurons.
doi:10.1109/TNN.2003.820440
IEEE T Neural Netw 14, 1569–1572.
Jolivet, R., Schürmann, F., Berger, T. K., Naud, R., Gerstner, W., and Roth, A. (2008). The quantitative
single-neuron modeling competition. Biol Cybern 99, 417–426. doi:10.1007/s00422-008-0261-x
34
Senk et al.
VIOLA
Kajikawa, Y. and Schroeder, C. E. (2011). How local is the local field potential? Neuron 72, 847–858.
doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2011.09.029
Kasi´nski, A., Pawłowski, J., and Ponulak, F. (2009). SNN3DViewer-3d visualization tool for spiking neural
network analysis. In Computer Vision and Graphics, ICCVG 2008, eds. L. Bolc, J. L. Kulikowski, and
K. Wojciechowski (Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg), 469–476. doi:10.1007/978-3-642-02345-3
Keane, A. and Gong, P. (2015). Propagating waves can explain irregular neural dynamics. J Neurosci 35,
1591–1605. doi:10.1523/jneurosci.1669-14.2015
Kemere, C., Santhanam, G., Byron, M. Y., Afshar, A., Ryu, S. I., Meng, T. H., et al. (2008). Detecting
neural-state transitions using hidden markov models for motor cortical prostheses. J Neurophysiol 100,
2441–2452. doi:10.1152/jn.00924.2007
Kobayashi, R., Tsubo, Y., and Shinomoto, S. (2009). Made-to-order spiking neuron model equipped with a
multi-timescale adaptive threshold. Front Comput Neurosc 3, 1–11. doi:10.3389/neuro.10.009.2009
Kriener, B., Helias, M., Rotter, S., Diesmann, M., and Einevoll, G. T. (2014). How pattern formation in
ring networks of excitatory and inhibitory spiking neurons depends on the input current regime. Front
Comput Neurosc 7, 1–21. doi:10.3389/fncom.2013.00187
Krüger, J. and Bach, M. (1981). Simultaneous recording with 30 microelectrodes in monkey visual cortex.
Exp Brain Res 41, 191–194
Kunkel, S., Morrison, A., Weidel, P., Eppler, J. M., Sinha, A., Schenck, W., et al. (2017). NEST 2.12.0.
doi:10.5281/zenodo.259534
Łe¸ski, S., Lindén, H., Tetzlaff, T., Pettersen, K. H., and Einevoll, G. T. (2013). Frequency dependence of
signal power and spatial reach of the local field potential. PLoS Comput Biol 9, e1003137. doi:10.1371/
journal.pcbi.1003137
Lindén, H., Hagen, E., Łe¸ski, S., Norheim, E. S., Pettersen, K. H., and Einevoll, G. T. (2014). LFPy: a
tool for biophysical simulation of extracellular potentials generated by detailed model neurons. Front
Neuroinform 7, 1–15. doi:10.3389/fninf.2013.00041
Lindén, H., Tetzlaff, T., Potjans, T. C., Pettersen, K. H., Grün, S., Diesmann, M., et al. (2011). Modeling
the spatial reach of the LFP. Neuron 72, 859–872. doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2011.11.006
Litwin-Kumar, A. and Doiron, B. (2012). Slow dynamics and high variability in balanced cortical networks
with clustered connections. Nat Neurosci 15, 1498–1505. doi:10.1038/nn.3220
Lorensen, W. E. and Cline, H. E. (1987). Marching cubes: A high resolution 3D surface construction
In Proceedings of the 14th Annual Conference on Computer Graphics and Interactive
algorithm.
Techniques (New York, NY, USA: ACM), SIGGRAPH '87, 163–169. doi:10.1145/37401.37422
Massobrio, P., Tessadori, J., Chiappalone, M., and Ghirardi, M. (2015). In vitro studies of neuronal
networks and synaptic plasticity in invertebrates and in mammals using multielectrode arrays. Neural
Plast 2015, 1–18. doi:10.1155/2015/196195. Article ID 196195
Mattioni, M., Cohen, U., and Le Novère, N. (2012). Neuronvisio: a graphical user interface with 3D
capabilities for NEURON. Front Neuroinform 6. doi:10.3389/fninf.2012.00020
Mazzoni, A., Lindén, H., Cuntz, H., Lansner, A., Panzeri, S., and Einevoll, G. T. (2015). Computing the
local field potential (LFP) from integrate-and-fire network models. PLoS Comput Biol 11, e1004584.
doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1004584
Mehring, C., Hehl, U., Kubo, M., Diesmann, M., and Aertsen, A. (2003). Activity dynamics and
propagation of synchronous spiking in locally connected random networks. Biol Cybern 88, 395–408.
doi:10.1007/s00422-002-0384-4
35
Senk et al.
VIOLA
Milekovic, T., Truccolo, W., Grün, S., Riehle, A., and Brochier, T. (2015). Local field potentials in primate
motor cortex encode grasp kinetic parameters. Neuroimage 114, 338–355. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.
2015.04.008
Miller, P. (2016). Dynamical systems, attractors, and neural circuits. F1000Research 5, 992. doi:10.12688/
f1000research.7698.1
Morrison, A., Straube, S., Plesser, H. E., and Diesmann, M. (2007). Exact subthreshold integration
with continuous spike times in discrete-time neural network simulations. Neural Comput 19, 47–79.
doi:10.1162/neco.2007.19.1.47
Muller, L., Reynaud, A., Chavane, F., and Destexhe, A. (2014). The stimulus-evoked population response in
visual cortex of awake monkey is a propagating wave. Nat Commun 5, 3675. doi:10.1038/ncomms4675
Nordlie, E., Gewaltig, M.-O., and Plesser, H. E. (2009). Towards reproducible descriptions of neuronal
network models. PLoS Comput Biol 5, e1000456. doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1000456
Nordlie, E. and Plesser, H. E. (2010). Visualizing neuronal network connectivity with connectivity pattern
tables. Front Neuroinform 3, 1–15. doi:10.3389/neuro.11.039.2009
Nowke, C., Schmidt, M., van Albada, S. J., Eppler, J. M., Bakker, R., Diesmann, M., et al. (2013). VisNEST:
Interactive analysis of neural activity data. In IEEE Symposium on Biological Data Visualization 2013
(Atlanta, Georgia, USA: IEEE), 65–72. doi:10.1109/BioVis.2013.6664348
Nowke, C., Zielasko, D., Weyers, B., Peyser, A., Hentschel, B., and Kuhlen, T. W. (2015). Integrating
visualizations into modeling NEST simulations. Front Neuroinform 9, 1–13. doi:10.3389/fninf.2015.
00029
Ohbayashi, M., Ohki, K., and Miyashita, Y. (2003). Conversion of working memory to motor sequence in
the monkey premotor cortex. Science 301, 233–236. doi:10.1126/science.1084884
Okun, M. and Lampl, I. (2008). Instantaneous correlation of excitation and inhibition during ongoing and
sensory-evoked activities. Nat Neurosci 11, 535–537. doi:10.1038/nn.2105
Ostojic, S. (2014). Two types of asynchronous activity in networks of excitatory and inhibitory spiking
neurons. Nat Neurosci 17, 594–600. doi:10.1038/nn.3658
Ouzounov, D. G., Wang, T., Wang, M., Feng, D. D., Horton, N. G., Cruz-Hernández, J. C., et al. (2017).
In vivo three-photon imaging of activity of gcamp6-labeled neurons deep in intact mouse brain. Nat
Methods 14, 388–390. doi:10.1038/nmeth.4183
Perkel, D. H., Gerstein, G. L., and Moore, G. P. (1967a). Neuronal spike trains and stochastic point
processes. I. The single spike train. Biophys J 7, 391–418. doi:10.1016/S0006-3495(67)86596-2
Perkel, D. H., Gerstein, G. L., and Moore, G. P. (1967b). Neuronal spike trains and stochastic point
processes. II. Simultaneous spike trains. Biophys J 7, 419–440. doi:10.1016/S0006-3495(67)86597-4
Perkel, D. H., Gerstein, G. L., Smith, M. S., and Tatton, W. G. (1975). Nerve-impulse patterns: a quantitative
display technique for three neurons. Brain Res 100, 271–296. doi:10.1016/0006-8993(75)90483-7
Potjans, T. C. and Diesmann, M. (2014). The cell-type specific cortical microcircuit: Relating structure and
activity in a full-scale spiking network model. Cereb Cortex 24, 785–806. doi:10.1093/cercor/bhs358
Prut, Y., Vaadia, E., Bergman, H., Haalman, I., Hamutal, S., and Abeles, M. (1998). Spatiotemporal
structure of cortical activity: Properties and behavioral relevance. J Neurophysiol 79, 2857–2874.
doi:10.1152/jn.1998.79.6.2857
Quiroga, R. Q. (2007). Spike sorting. Scholarpedia 2, 3583. doi:10.4249/scholarpedia.3583. revision
#137442
Ramachandran, P. and Varoquaux, G. (2011). Mayavi: 3D Visualization of Scientific Data. Comput Sci
Eng 13, 40–51. doi:10.1109/MCSE.2011.35
36
Senk et al.
VIOLA
Renart, A., de la Rocha, J., Bartho, P., Hollender, L., Parga, N., Reyes, A., et al. (2010). The asynchronous
state in cortical circuits. Science 327, 587–590. doi:10.1126/science.1179850
Roberts, J. C. (2007). State of the art: Coordinated & multiple views in exploratory visualization. In Fifth
International Conference on Coordinated and Multiple Views in Exploratory Visualization (CMV 2007)
(IEEE Computer Society Press). doi:10.1109/CMV.2007.20
Rosenbaum, R., Smith, M. A., Kohn, A., Rubin, J. E., and Doiron, B. (2017). The spatial structure of
correlated neuronal variability. Nat Neurosci 20, 107–114. doi:10.1038/nn.4433
Rostami, V., Ito, J., Denker, M., Grün, S., and Rougier, N. (2017). [Re] Spike Synchronization And Rate
Modulation Differentially Involved In Motor Cortical Function. ReScience 3, 3. doi:10.5281/zenodo.
583814
Rubino, D., Robbins, K. A., and Hatsopoulos, N. G. (2006). Propagating waves mediate information
transfer in the motor cortex. Nat Neurosci 9, 1549–1557. doi:10.1038/nn1802
Sato, T. K., Nauhaus, I., and Carandini, M. (2012). Traveling waves in visual cortex. Neuron 75, 218–229.
doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2012.06.029
Schmidt, M., Bakker, R., Hilgetag, C. C., Diesmann, M., and van Albada, S. J. (2017). Multi-scale
account of the network structure of macaque visual cortex. Brain Struct Funct , 1–27doi:10.1007/
s00429-017-1554-4
Schrader, S., Grün, S., Diesmann, M., and Gerstein, G. (2008). Detecting synfire chain activity using
massively parallel spike train recording. J Neurophysiol 100, 2165–2176. doi:10.1152/jn.01245.2007
Senk, J., Yegenoglu, A., Amblet, O., Brukau, Y., Davison, A., Lester, D. R., et al. (2017). A collaborative
simulation-analysis workflow for computational neuroscience using HPC. In High-Performance Scientific
Computing. JHPCS 2016. Lect Notes Comp Sci, vol 10164., eds. E. Di Napoli, M. A. Hermanns, H. Iliev,
A. Lintermann, and A. Peyser (Springer, Cham). doi:10.1007/978-3-319-53862-4_21
Shadlen, M. N. and Newsome, W. T. (1998). The variable discharge of cortical neurons: implications for
connectivity, computation, and information coding. J Neurosci 18, 3870–3896
Shneiderman, B. (1996). The eyes have it: A task by data type taxonomy for information visualizations. In
IEEE Symposium on Visual Languages, 1996 (IEEE), 336–343. doi:10.1109/VL.1996.545307
Sivagnanam, S., Majumdar, A., Yoshimoto, K., Astakhov, V., Bandrowski, A., Martone, M. E., et al. (2013).
Introducing the neuroscience gateway. In IWSG
Softky, W. R. and Koch, C. (1993). The highly irregular firing of cortical cells is inconsistent with temporal
integration of random EPSPs. J Neurosci 13, 334–350
Spence, R. (2001). Information visualization (Addison Wesley)
Torre, E., Canova, C., Denker, M., Gerstein, G., Helias, M., and Grün, S. (2016a). ASSET: analysis of
sequences of synchronous events in massively parallel spike trains. PLoS Comput Biol 12, e1004939.
doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1004939
Torre, E., Picado-Muiño, D., Denker, M., Borgelt, C., and Grün, S. (2013). Statistical evaluation of
synchronous spike patterns extracted by frequent item set mining. Front Comput Neurosc 7, 132.
doi:10.3389/fncom.2013.00132
Torre, E., Quaglio, P., Denker, M., Brochier, T., Riehle, A., and Grün, S. (2016b). Synchronous spike
patterns in macaque motor cortex during an instructed-delay reach-to-grasp task. J Neurosci 36,
8329–8340. doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.4375-15.2016
Townsend, R. G., Solomon, S. S., Chen, S. C., Pietersen, A. N. J., Martin, P. R., Solomon, S. G., et al.
(2015). Emergence of complex wave patterns in primate cerebral cortex. J Neurosci 35, 4657–4662.
doi:10.1523/jneurosci.4509-14.2015
Vaadia, E. (2017). private communication Sep 2017
37
Senk et al.
VIOLA
Vaadia, E., Kurata, K., and Wise, S. P. (1988). Neuronal activity preceding directional and nondirectional
cues in the premotor cortex of rhesus monkeys. Somatosens Mot Res 6, 207–230
van Albada, S. J., Helias, M., and Diesmann, M. (2015). Scalability of asynchronous networks is limited by
one-to-one mapping between effective connectivity and correlations. PLoS Comput Biol 11, e1004490.
doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1004490
van Vreeswijk, C. and Sompolinsky, H. (1996). Chaos in neuronal networks with balanced excitatory and
inhibitory activity. Science 274, 1724–1726. doi:10.1126/science.274.5293.1724
Voges, N. and Perrinet, L. (2012). Complex dynamics in recurrent cortical networks based on spatially
realistic connectivities. Front Comput Neurosci 6, 1–19. doi:10.3389/fncom.2012.00041
Wang Baldonado, M. Q., Woodruff, A., and Kuchinsky, A. (2000). Guidelines for using multiple views in
information visualization. In Proceedings of the Working Conference on Advanced Visual Interfaces
(New York, NY, USA: ACM), AVI '00, 110–119. doi:10.1145/345513.345271
Yamauchi, S., Kim, H., and Shinomoto, S. (2011). Elemental spiking neuron model for reproducing diverse
firing patterns and predicting precise firing times. Front Comput Neurosc 5, 1–15. doi:10.3389/fncom.
2011.00042
Yger, P., El Boustani, S., Destexhe, A., and Frégnac, Y. (2011). Topologically invariant macroscopic
statistics in balanced networks of conductance-based integrate-and-fire neurons. J Comput Neurosci 31,
229–245. doi:10.1007/s10827-010-0310-z
Zehl, L., Jaillet, F., Stoewer, A., Grewe, J., Sobolev, A., Wachtler, T., et al. (2016). Handling metadata in a
neurophysiology laboratory. Front Neuroinform 10. doi:10.3389/fninf.2016.00026
38
|
1907.11609 | 1 | 1907 | 2019-07-26T14:56:32 | Correlation transfer by layer 5 cortical neurons under recreated synaptic inputs in vitro | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Correlated electrical activity in neurons is a prominent characteristic of cortical microcircuits. Despite a growing amount of evidence concerning both spike-count and subthreshold membrane potential pairwise correlations, little is known about how different types of cortical neurons convert correlated inputs into correlated outputs. We studied pyramidal neurons and two classes of GABAergic interneurons of layer 5 in neocortical brain slices obtained from rats of both sexes, and we stimulated them with biophysically realistic correlated inputs, generated using dynamic clamp. We found that the physiological differences between cell types manifested unique features in their capacity to transfer correlated inputs. We used linear response theory and computational modeling to gain clear insights into how cellular properties determine both the gain and timescale of correlation transfer, thus tying single-cell features with network interactions. Our results provide further ground for the functionally distinct roles played by various types of neuronal cells in the cortical microcircuit. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Correlation transfer by layer 5 cortical neurons
under recreated synaptic inputs in vitro
Daniele Linaro1,2,3,4, Gabriel K. Ocker5,6, Brent Doiron6,7, Michele Giugliano1,8
1 Molecular, Cellular, and Network Excitability Lab, Department of Biomedical Sciences and Institute
Born-Bunge, Universiteit Antwerpen, Wilrijk B-2610, Belgium
2Université Libre de Bruxelles (ULB), IRIBHM, and ULB Neuroscience Institute, Brussels, B-1050 Belgium
3 VIB-KU Leuven Center for Brain & Disease Research, Leuven B-3000, Belgium
4 Department of Neurosciences, Leuven Brain Institute, KU Leuven, Leuven B-3000, Belgium
5Department of Neuroscience, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 15260, United States of America
6Center for the Neural Basis of Cognition, University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University,
Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA
7Department of Mathematics, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 15260, USA
8Scuola Internazionale Superiore di Studi Avanzati, Neuroscience sector, Trieste, Italy
Corresponding Author: Dr. Michele Giugliano, [email protected]
Universiteit Antwerpen
Campus Drie Eiken -- T665
Universiteitsplein 1, 2610 Wilrijk (Belgium)
Acknowledgments. We are grateful to Drs. J. Couto, A. Bacci, V. Bonin, and K. Farrow
for discussions, and to Mr. D. Van Dyck and M. Wijnants for excellent technical assistance.
Financial support from the European Union's Horizon 2020 Framework Programme for
Research and Innovation under the Specific Grant Agreement n. 785907 (Human Brain
Project SGA2), the Belgian Science Policy Office (grant n. IUAP-VII/20), the Flemish
Research Foundation (grants no. G0F1517N and no. K201619N), and Scuola
Internazionale Superiore di Studi Avanzati ("Collaborazione di Eccellenza 2018") is kindly
acknowledged, NIH grants 1U19NS107613-01, the Vannevar Bush faculty fellowship
N00014-18-1-2002, and a grant from the Simons foundation collaboration on the global
brain. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to
publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
1
Abstract
Correlated electrical activity in neurons is a prominent characteristic of cortical
microcircuits. Despite a growing amount of evidence concerning both spike-count and
subthreshold membrane potential pairwise correlations, little is known about how different
types of cortical neurons convert correlated inputs into correlated outputs. We studied
pyramidal neurons and two classes of GABAergic interneurons of layer 5 in neocortical
brain slices obtained from rats of both sexes, and we stimulated them with biophysically
realistic correlated inputs, generated using dynamic clamp. We found that the physiological
differences between cell types manifested unique features in their capacity to transfer
correlated inputs. We used linear response theory and computational modeling to gain
clear insights into how cellular properties determine both the gain and timescale of
correlation transfer, thus tying single-cell features with network interactions. Our results
provide further ground for the functionally distinct roles played by various types of
neuronal cells in the cortical microcircuit.
Introduction
Throughout the brain, the activity of neurons is correlated across multiple spatial and
temporal scales (Cohen and Kohn, 2011, Doiron et al., 2016). In the cortex, neurons
embedded in the same microcircuit show a high degree of functional similarity, not only in
the correlations between spike trains (Erisken et al., 2014, Bair et al., 2001, deCharms and
Merzenich, 1996), but also in sub-threshold voltage fluctuations (Poulet and Petersen,
2008, Gentet et al., 2010, Gentet et al., 2012). Several studies investigated the magnitude
and timescales of spike-count correlations, known also as noise correlations (Cohen and
Kohn, 2011). In primates, for example, correlations arise on relatively short timescales (i.e.,
up to a few hundred milliseconds) in the visual area MT (Bair et al., 2001) and their
magnitude is strongly modulated both by the stimulus properties and internal brain state
(Steinmetz et al., 2000).
The cortical origin of spike-count correlations has been investigated extensively in vitro
and in theoretical studies. By artificially constraining the fraction of common inputs
received by pairs of neurons, de la Rocha et al. (2007) demonstrated experimentally that
2
spike-count correlations between spike trains increase with the mean firing rate of the cell
pair. Albeit general, this result was based on current-clamp stimuli, which only roughly
approximate the summed activity of a large number of excitatory and inhibitory inputs. The
in vitro and in silico study of (Litwin-Kumar et al., 2011) removed this limitation,
considering the high-conductance state of intact cortical circuits (Destexhe et al., 2001,
Destexhe et al., 2003). The high-conductance state transferred short time scale (~10 ms)
correlations better than the low-conductance state. However, the opposite was true for long
time scale (~100 ms), prompting the overall effect of a shift in background conductance to
be termed correlation-shaping (Litwin-Kumar et al., 2011). These theoretical results were
further experimentally validated in vitro, although for only one value of the mean firing
rate.
Theoretical arguments (de la Rocha et al., 2007, Doiron et al., 2016, Litwin-Kumar et
al., 2011) explain these modulations in correlation transfer by associated shifts in the
dynamical transfer functions of each cell in the pair (Kondgen et al., 2008, Linaro et al.,
2018). This is consistent with studies showing that intrinsic properties -- such as whether
the neuron acts like an integrator or a coincidence detector (Konig et al., 1996) -- also
determine correlation transfer (Hong et al., 2012). It is well known that the input-output
transfer and other intrinsic properties of neurons are quite distinct between cell classes
(Connors and Gutnick, 1990, Markram et al., 2004). Nevertheless, despite this vast
literature, little is known about the way in which different cell types transmit correlations.
Here, we present the results of dynamic-clamp experiments carried out in pyramidal
cells and in fast-spiking (FS) and non-fast-spiking (NON-FS) interneurons from slices of
rat cortical tissue. We found that, for low input correlation and across all cell types, the
experimentally measured values of output covariance and their dependency on firing rate
are in quantitative agreement with the values computed using linear response theory
(Litwin-Kumar et al., 2011, Ocker and Doiron, 2014). Interestingly however, FS
interneurons displayed significantly larger values of output covariance, making this cell
type particularly suited for transmitting correlations to its postsynaptic targets. These
results can be explained by considering single-cell properties -- the steepness of the
stationary rate-current curve, the membrane time constant and the degree of spike-
frequency adaptation -- and how they are modulated by dynamic-clamp stimuli. Indeed, by
3
that
recapitulate
single-compartment
integrate-and-fire models
using
the
electrophysiological response properties of the three cell types considered here, we could
produce covariance values that qualitatively replicate our experimental observations.
Additionally, we found that in pyramidal cells the correlation-shaping mechanism
introduced by (Litwin-Kumar et al., 2011) crucially depends on the properties of the
stimulation paradigm.
In summary, our results highlight how the intrinsic properties of distinct neuronal types
affect their correlated firing and hint at possible functionally distinct roles of different cell
types in propagating correlations within cortical circuits.
Materials and methods
Brain tissue slice preparation
Experiments were performed in accordance with international and institutional guidelines
on animal welfare. All procedures were approved by the Ethical Committee of the
Department of Biomedical Sciences of the University of Antwerp (permission no.
2011_87), and licensed by the Belgian Animal, Plant and Food Directorate-General of the
Federal Department of Public Health, Safety of the Food Chain and the Environment
(license no. LA1100469). Wistar rats of either sex (2-4 weeks old) were anesthetized using
Isoflurane (IsoFlo, Abbott, USA) and decapitated. Brains were rapidly extracted and
immersed, to be sliced, in ice cold Artificial CerebroSpinal Fluid (ACSF), containing (in
𝑚𝑀): 125 NaCl, 25 NaHCO3, 2.5 KCl, 1.25 NaH2PO4, 2 CaCl2, 1 MgCl2, 25 glucose,
saturated with 95% O2 and 5% CO2. Parasagittal sections (300 𝜇𝑚 thick) of the primary
GmbH, Germany) and then incubated in ACSF at 36℃ for at least 45 minutes. Slices were
somatosensory cortex were cut using a vibratome (Leica VT1000 S, Leica Microsystems
then stored at room temperature, until transfer to the recording chamber.
An upright microscope (Leica Microsystems, DMLFS), equipped with infrared
Differential Interference Contrast videomicroscopy, was employed to visually identify
layer 5 (L5) cortical neurons in a submerged slice recording chamber, under 60x
magnification. Recordings were performed at 32±1℃, under continuous perfusion with
4
ACSF at a rate of 1 𝑚𝐿/𝑚𝑖𝑛. All chemicals were obtained from Sigma-Aldrich (Diegem,
Belgium).
Electrophysiological recordings
Patch-clamp recordings were obtained from the cell somata in the whole-cell configuration,
employing glass pipettes pulled on a horizontal puller (P97, Sutter Instruments, Novato
CA, USA) from filamented borosilicate glass capillaries (Hilgenberg, Malsfeld, Germany).
Pipette electrode resistance was in the range 4−8 𝑀Ω, when filled with an intracellular
solution containing (in 𝑚𝑀): 115 K-gluconate, 20 KCl, 10 HEPES, 4 Mg-ATP, 0.3 Na2-
GTP, 10 Na2-phosphocreatine, pH adjusted to 7.3 with KOH.
Recordings and current injections were performed with a single electrode by a current-
clamp amplifier (EPC 10, HEKA Electronics, Lambrecht/Pfalz, Germany), but neither the
bridge balance nor capacitance neutralization circuitries of the amplifiers were activated
during the experiments. Instead, signal transfer properties of the glass microelectrodes were
repeatedly estimated, by a linear non-parametric identification method (Brette et al., 2008),
throughout each recording session. Quantified as the impulse response, the microelectrode
transfer properties were employed to compensate for artifacts in the recorded membrane
potential offline or online (i.e. in conductance-clamp experiments). All experiments were
performed using the software toolbox LCG (Linaro et al., 2014). Liquid junction potentials
were left uncorrected, but are not expected to affect our conclusions. Signals were sampled
at a rate of 20 𝑘𝐻𝑧 and digitized at 16 bits, with an A/D conversion board (NI PCI-6221,
the external voltage-commands to the patch-clamp amplifier, at 20 𝑘𝐻𝑧 and 16 bits of
National Instruments, USA). The D/A converter of the same board was used to synthesize
resolution.
Current-clamp and conductance-clamp stimulation waveforms
Our stimulation protocol closely follows the framework introduced in (de la Rocha et al.,
2007), repeats it, and extends it to the case of conductance inputs, recreated by the dynamic-
clamp technique (Chance et al., 2002, Robinson and Kawai, 1993) (Fig. 3A). While only
one neuron was stimulated and recorded at a time, our entire set of experiments was
examined a posteriori to study and quantify the similarity between the responses from pairs
5
of (unconnected) neurons. In fact, synaptic inputs to these neuronal pairs had been
synthesized a priori with a desired degree of similarity.
In the case of current-driven stimuli as in (de la Rocha et al., 2007), each of the currents
an independent term and of a common term:
𝐼9(𝑡)=𝜇9+𝜎9∙B√1−𝑐 ∙𝜂9(𝑡)+√𝑐 ∙𝜂F(𝑡)G
𝐼=(𝑡)=𝜇=+𝜎=∙B√1−𝑐 ∙𝜂=(𝑡)+√𝑐∙ 𝜂F(𝑡)G
realizations of an Ornstein-Uhlenbeck stochastic process (Uhlenbeck and Ornstein, 1930,
Cox and Miller, 1965). These waveforms have Gaussian amplitude distribution, zero mean,
unitary variance, and an auto-correlation function exponentially decaying with time
𝐼9(𝑡) and 𝐼=(𝑡) injected (non-simultaneously) into two neurons was defined as the sum of
(1)
where 𝑐, 𝜇9,𝜎9,𝜇=,𝜎= are numerical parameters varied experimentally, while 𝜂9(𝑡), 𝜂=(𝑡),
and 𝜂F(𝑡) are randomly fluctuating waveforms, generated offline as independent
constant of 𝜏=5 𝑚𝑠. They are generated as discrete-time approximations, by
independently iterating for each sampling interval Δ𝑡 (i.e. Δ𝑡=(20 𝑘𝐻𝑧)M9) the algebraic
expressions 𝜂N(𝑡+Δ𝑡)=(1−Δ𝑡/𝜏)∙𝜂N(𝑡)+O2Δ𝑡/𝜏∙𝜉N(𝑡) with x∈{1,2,c}, where
the quantities 𝜉9(𝑡),𝜉=(𝑡),and 𝜉F(𝑡) are three independent sequences of Gaussian numbers
(Press, 2007). By such a construction, 𝐼9(𝑡) and 𝐼=(𝑡) are realizations of colored Gaussian
stochastic processes, with means 𝜇9 and 𝜇=, standard-deviations 𝜎9 and 𝜎=, respectively,
and identical autocorrelation length 𝜏=5 𝑚𝑠. Importantly, their cross-correlation
coefficient 𝑐, which is under the direct control of the experimenter, determines a priori the
sources (0≤𝑐≤1) (Fig. 3B).
In the case of conductance-driven stimuli, the total currents 𝐼9(𝑡) and 𝐼=(𝑡) were
degree of similarity between the waveforms and represents, in a compact form, both the
fraction of common inputs and the synchronous inputs coming from distinct presynaptic
obtained by employing three distinct initial seeds for a pseudo-random number generator
computer-generated in real time by conductance-clamp (Chance et al., 2002, Destexhe and
Pare, 1999, Destexhe et al., 2001, Linaro et al., 2014) as a barrage of excitatory and
inhibitory synaptic conductance inputs:
6
membrane potentials instantaneously recorded from the two cells, as shown schematically
in Fig. 3A.
𝐼9(𝑡)=𝐺Z,9(𝑡)(𝐸Z−𝑉9(𝑡))+𝐺],9(𝑡)(𝐸]−𝑉9(𝑡))
𝐼=(𝑡)=𝐺Z,=(𝑡)(𝐸Z−𝑉=(𝑡))+𝐺],=(𝑡)(𝐸]−𝑉=(𝑡))
(2)
where 𝐺Z,9(𝑡),𝐺Z,=(𝑡) (𝐺],9(𝑡),𝐺],=(𝑡)) are randomly fluctuating excitatory (inhibitory)
𝐸Z=0 𝑚𝑉 (𝐸]=−80 𝑚𝑉) (Chance et al., 2002), and where 𝑉9(𝑡) and 𝑉=(𝑡) are the
Similarly to Eq. 1, the excitatory (inhibitory) conductance waveform 𝐺Z,9(𝑡),𝐺Z,=(𝑡),
(𝐺],9(𝑡),𝐺],=(𝑡)) were defined by the sum of an independent term and of a common term:
(3)
where 𝜂Z,9(𝑡), 𝜂Z,=(𝑡), 𝜂Z,F(𝑡), 𝜂],9(𝑡), 𝜂],=(𝑡), 𝜂],F(𝑡), are six independent realizations of
processes have heterogeneous auto-correlation time lengths (𝜏Z=5 𝑚𝑠 and 𝜏]=10 𝑚𝑠
𝑔Z,9and 𝑔Z,= (𝑔],9 and 𝑔],=) and σZ,9 and σZ,= (σ],9 and σ],=) represent the means and
𝐺Z,9(𝑡)=𝑔Z,9+σZ,=∙B√1−𝑐 ∙𝜂Z,9(𝑡)+√𝑐 ∙𝜂Z,F(𝑡)G
𝐺Z,=(𝑡)=𝑔Z,=+σZ,=∙B√1−𝑐 ∙𝜂Z,=(𝑡)+√𝑐 ∙𝜂Z,F(𝑡)G
𝐺],9(𝑡)=𝑔],9+σ],9∙B√1−𝑐 ∙𝜂],9(𝑡)+√𝑐 ∙𝜂],F(𝑡)G
𝐺],=(𝑡)=𝑔],=+σ],=∙B√1−𝑐 ∙𝜂],=(𝑡)+√𝑐 ∙𝜂],F(𝑡)G
for excitatory and inhibitory inputs, respectively), capturing the distinct decay kinetics of
synaptic currents mediated by AMPA- and by GABA-A-receptors (Tuckwell, 1989).
synthetic synaptic conductance waveforms, whose apparent reversal potential is chosen as
an Ornstein-Uhlenbeck stochastic process, generated offline as already described. These
standard deviations of the total excitatory (inhibitory) synaptic conductances, for each of
the cells in the pair. Under the diffusion approximation (Tuckwell, 1989), Eq. 3 mimics the
collective effect of the asynchronous activation of a large number of presynaptic excitatory
(inhibitory) afferents, each with a corresponding a unitary excitatory (inhibitory)
postsynaptic peak conductance gZabc (g]abc). If the presynaptic mean frequency of
excitatory (inhibitory) activation is indicated by 𝑅Z (𝑅]), then 𝑔Z (𝑔]) and σZ (σ]) can be
7
expressed as (Destexhe and Bal, 2009):
inhibitory drives, whenever the postsynaptic membrane potential fluctuates around a value
𝑔Z=gZabc∙𝜏Z∙𝑅Z 𝜎Z=O0.5∙gZabc=∙𝜏Z∙𝑅Z
𝜎]=O0.5∙g]abc=∙𝜏]∙𝑅]
𝑔]=g]abc∙𝜏]∙𝑅]
(4)
In all our experiments, gZabc was fixed to 2% of the inverse of the input resistance of
the cell, while g]abc was fixed to 6% of the same value, as proposed in (Chance et al.,
2002). The mean firing rate of the presynaptic inhibitory population was fixed to 𝑅]=
3000 𝐻𝑧, while 𝑅Z was determined as the value balancing the mean excitatory and
𝑉g. By construction, at such a value 𝑉g of the membrane potential, the mean current injected
(5)
By this definition, acting on the value of a single parameter 𝑉g allows one to change the
patched neuron. In analogy to the current-driven synaptic inputs (Eq. 1), where 𝜇,𝜎 were
employed to increase or decrease the neuronal firing rate of each patched cell, 𝑉g was
⟺ 𝑅Z=[g]abc∙𝜏]∙𝑅]∙(𝐸]−𝑉g)]/[gZabc∙𝜏Z∙(𝐸Z−𝑉g)]
0=〈𝐼(𝑡)〉≈𝑔Z∙(𝐸Z−𝑉g)+𝑔]∙(𝐸]−𝑉g)
ratio between excitatory and inhibitory inputs and thus to alter the output firing rate of the
into each neuron (Eq. 2) vanishes:
employed to study the dependence of the correlation transfer on the neuronal firing rate in
the case of conductance injection.
All electrophysiological experiments were carried out with LCG (Linaro et al., 2014).
Experimental design
As in (de la Rocha et al., 2007), for each recorded neuron we delivered blocks of 𝑁=100
stimulation trials, each lasting 1.1 𝑠 and interleaved by inter-stimulus intervals lasting 1-
6 𝑠, depending on the elicited firing rate (i.e. the higher the rate the longer the resting
stimulation (e.g. 𝑐 and the pair 𝜇,𝜎 or the value of 𝑉g) were kept constant. This series of
8
interval). Each block was repeated for 1 -- 5 times, during which the parameters of the
stimulus sets, differing in the values chosen for 𝑐 and 𝜇, 𝜎, or for c and 𝑉g.
repetitions was termed a stimulus set, and each neuron was presented with 1-7 distinct
The identification of each patch electrode transfer properties, required for the Active
Electrode Compensation, was performed once at the beginning of each block (i.e. every 5-
10 min of recording), although in some instances it was repeated halfway through the block.
The initial seeds of the pseudo-random number generator, used for generating the
shared component of each stimulus, were identical across the repetitions of the stimulation
blocks and across cells. Within a block, each trial was generated by a distinct seed, so that
in Eq. 3) were never fixed, but instead varied across trials, repetitions, and cells. All LCG
scripts, configuration files, and command line strings required to precisely replicate our
experimental protocols, together with the MATLAB scripts for the offline analysis of the
a total of 𝑁 seeds for generating 𝜂F(𝑡) in Eq. 1 and of 2𝑁 seeds for generating 𝜂Z,F(𝑡),
𝜂],F(𝑡) in Eq. 3 were chosen once for all the experiments. On the other hand, the seeds of
all the independent components (i.e. 𝜂9(𝑡), 𝜂=(𝑡) in Eq. 1; 𝜂Z,9(𝑡), 𝜂Z,=(𝑡), 𝜂],9(𝑡), 𝜂],=(𝑡)
recorded data, are available from FigShare.com.
(Chance et al., 2002). Specifically, we injected 1 𝑠-long DC depolarizing current steps
measured the evoked firing rate as the number of emitted spikes divided by 0.9 𝑠, after
discarding the first 0.1 𝑠 of the response to each stimulation step. Equation 3 was used to
generate the synaptic inputs, with c set to zero and 𝜂Z,9(𝑡), 𝜂Z,=(𝑡), 𝜂],9(𝑡), 𝜂],=(𝑡)
generated as independent realizations. The value of 𝑉g was fixed so that the neuron fired
on the average at ~0.5 𝐻𝑧, in the absence of any additional DC current step. This ensured
After establishing the whole-cell configuration, in a subset of the experiments (Figures 1
and 5) we initially also probed the steady-state frequency-current curve of the neuron as in
increasing amplitude, superimposed to conductance-driven recreated synaptic inputs, and
that the modulation effect of the conductance-driven inputs was purely divisive for the
frequency-current curve (Chance et al., 2002).
Data analysis: passive and active membrane electrical properties
Data were analyzed off line, using custom MATLAB scripts (The Mathworks, Natick MA,
USA). Passive membrane electrical properties, such as the input resistance and membrane
time constant, were evaluated. The time constant was estimated as the longest time constant
9
The "sag" in the transient membrane potential trajectory in response to the injection of
estimated as the slope of a steady-state current-voltage relationship, obtained by injecting
of a double exponential function, best fitted to the repolarizing phase following the
amplitude was estimated as the minimal DC stimulus amplitude necessary to elicit
sustained firing.
application of a 10 𝑚𝑠-long pulse of −300 𝑝𝐴 amplitude. The input resistance was
3 𝑠-long subthreshold step current pulses with increasing amplitude. The rheobase current
a 3 𝑠-long hyperpolarizing step of current, was quantified as the ratio 𝛥𝑉ss/𝛥𝑉tuvw: the
steady state voltage deflection 𝛥𝑉ss was computed as the difference between 𝑉xusy, the
resting potential averaged over the 500 𝑚𝑠 preceding the step onset, and the
(hyperpolarized) potential averaged in the final 500 𝑚𝑠 of the step; 𝛥𝑉tuvw was computed
as the difference between the above defined 𝑉xusy and the minimum hyperpolarized
potential, within the 300 𝑚𝑠 following the onset of the step. The amplitude of the
hyperpolarizing current was chosen such that Δ𝑉zz was ∼10 𝑚𝑉.
The times of occurrence 𝑡}~ of the spikes fired by the neuron, in response to a given
exceeding a threshold of −20 𝑚𝑉. Other quantities were also extracted from each spike,
stimulation trial, were detected by finding the peaks of the intracellular voltage traces
al., 2003)
In order to quantify the degree of spike frequency adaptation across cortical cell types,
such as (i) its threshold, defined as the voltage corresponding to the maximum of the third
derivative of the membrane potential (Gentet et al., 2010, Henze and Buzsaki, 2001, Kole
and Stuart, 2008); (ii) its amplitude, defined as the difference between its peak amplitude
and the threshold; and (iii) its duration, measured as the width of the spike waveform at its
half-amplitude.
𝐴=(cid:127)𝑁z(cid:128)(cid:129)z−4−1(cid:130)M9∙ (cid:131) (cid:127)ISI}−ISI}M9(cid:130)/(cid:127)ISI}+ISI}M9(cid:130)
the accommodation index 𝐴 was also computed as (Druckmann et al., 2007, Shinomoto et
(6)
where 𝑁z(cid:128)(cid:129)z is the number of spikes evoked by a constant depolarizing 1 𝑠-long step of
current, ISI} is the 𝑞-th inter-spike interval (i.e. ISI}=𝑡}(cid:141)9−𝑡}), and where the first four
10
(cid:134)(cid:135)(cid:136)(cid:137)(cid:135)M9
}(cid:138)(cid:139)
indicates the largest integer not greater than x:
spikes were always discarded from the analysis (i.e. the sum starts from 𝑞=4). The
amplitude of the step of current was chosen such that it elicited 15, 50 and 20 spikes/s for
pyramidal, FS and NON-FS cells, respectively.
Experimental estimation of the spike-count covariance, in neuronal pairs
For estimating the covariance of the spike counts, we closely followed the procedure
outlined in (de la Rocha et al., 2007). In detail, under current-driven and conductance-
𝑦(𝑗)=(cid:153)1 if there exists (a spike) 𝑞:𝑡} ∈[ 𝑗∙Δ𝑡 ;(𝑗+1)∙Δ𝑡 )
driven recreated synaptic inputs, and after discarding the first 0.1 𝑠 of each stimulation trial
to minimize transient effects, we detected the spike times 𝑡9,𝑡=,…,𝑡},…~ over the
remaining interval of duration 𝐿=1 𝑠. For each trial, the spike times were equivalently
expressed as a discrete-time spike train, converting them into a binary string 𝑦(𝑗), 𝑗=
[0,1,2,…,(cid:145)(cid:146)(cid:147)(cid:148)(cid:149)] upon uniform discretization of time, with a step of Δ𝑡=1.2 𝑚𝑠, where ⌊𝑥⌋
(7)
The discrete-time spike train 𝑦(𝑗) was then used to estimate the spike count, computed
over a sliding window of duration 𝑇 (Dayan and Abbott, 2001):
(8)
with 𝑗={0,1,2,…,𝑀}
where 𝑀=⌊(𝐿−𝑇)/Δ𝑡⌋.
The spike count was obtained for every trial in a block of 𝑁 stimulations, for every block
out of 𝑅 repetitions, and for every cell. In the following, we use the notation 𝑛9(cid:129),›(𝑗) and
𝑛=(cid:129),›fi(𝑗) to indicate, for two neurons, the spike counts of the response of cell 1 and cell 2,
computed for the 𝑘-th trial and the 𝑟-th (or 𝑟′-th) repetition (i.e. as the number of repetitions
𝑅9 and 𝑅= may be different across cells). As in (de la Rocha et al., 2007), the estimate of
11
¤(cid:141)⌊'/(cid:147)(cid:148)⌋
𝑛(𝑗)= (cid:131) 𝑦(𝑖)
"(cid:138)¤
the covariance of the spike counts of the cell pair, obtained during the corresponding trial,
0
otherwise
,
from the spike-count covariance as:
as:
(9)
(cid:127)∑
·¤(cid:138)g
𝑛9(cid:129),›(𝑗)∙𝑛=(cid:129),›fi(𝑗)
(𝑀+1)
𝜌'=
−(cid:127)∑
(cid:130)
𝑛9(cid:129),›(𝑗)∙𝑛=(cid:129)(cid:141)9,›fi(𝑗)
(cid:130)
·¤(cid:138)g
(𝑀+1)
Cov(𝑛9,𝑛=)
OVar(𝑛9)Var(𝑛=),
was corrected for the time-shift and averaged across all 𝑅9 and 𝑅= repetitions and 𝑁 trials1
Cov(𝑛9,𝑛=)
1𝑁∙𝑅9∙𝑅=(cid:131)
=
(cid:134),(cid:181)¶,(cid:181)•
(cid:129),›,›fi
Finally, the correlation coefficient 𝜌' between the response of two neurons was obtained
(10)
with Var(𝑛")=Cov(𝑛",𝑛"). Throughout our work, we used the spike-count covariance,
stimulus sets, each characterized by distinct values for 𝑐 and 𝜇,𝜎 or c and 𝑉g. As those
computed the correlation coefficient only for those stimulus-set pairs 𝑙,𝑚 that elicited
firing rates 𝜈9 and 𝜈= (estimated over the whole stimulus set) that did not differ by more
than 50%, i.e., 0.5≤𝜈9…/ 𝜈=‰≤2. We also tested more stringent conditions on the ratio
𝜈9…/ 𝜈=‰ to select the stimulus-set pairs to include in the analysis (up to 0.8≤𝜈9…/ 𝜈=‰≤
1.25) and found that this does not alter qualitatively the dependence of the covariance on
except for section "Output correlation depends on the fraction of common inputs" (Fig. 3),
where the linear relationship between input and output correlations is discussed.
Finally, as already mentioned in the previous sections, each cell was presented with several
parameters affect the mean spiking rate of the neurons, care was required to choose
comparable responses across cells, out of the entire experimental data set. Therefore, we
the geometric mean firing rate of the cell pair.
one trial after the last, which equals the first, i.e. 𝑛=·(cid:141)9,›fi=𝑛=9,›fi.
1 In order to make the notation consistent, it is intended that across the sum over k there is
12
Unless otherwise noted, all data are presented as mean ± standard deviation and statistical
Statistical analysis
significance was assessed using a two-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (Press, 2007).
Theoretical prediction of the covariance values
We compared the empirical spike-count covariance to the values obtained from a
theoretical prediction. This prediction is based on a well-established linear response theory
for spike train covariability (de la Rocha et al., 2007). We first indicate in continuous time
the spike train 𝑦(𝑡) as a sum of Dirac's Delta functions,
𝑦(𝑡)=(cid:131)𝛿(cid:127)𝑡−𝑡}(cid:130)
(11)
}
and the corresponding spike count 𝑛(𝑡) as its convolution with the window function 𝑤'(𝑡),
=𝑦(𝑡)∗𝑤'(𝑡),
𝑛(𝑡)=(cid:192) 𝑦(𝑥)𝑑𝑥
(12)
(cid:148)(cid:141)'
(cid:148)
where 𝑤'(𝑡)=1,for 𝑡∈[−𝑇 ;0] and otherwise zero. The cross-covariance function of
the spike counts of the two neurons receiving common input can be expressed in
terms of the cross-covariance function of the spike trains (Cox and Isham, 1980) as
(13)
where Δ'(𝜏) is an even function defined as Δ'(𝜏)=∫ 𝑤'(𝑠)𝑤'(𝜏+𝑠)𝑑𝑠
value of 𝑇−𝜏,for 𝜏∈[−𝑇 ;𝑇], and otherwise zero.
By the Wiener-Khinchin theorem, the cross-covariance function Cov(𝑦9,𝑦=)(𝜏) is the
Fourier anti-transform of the cross-spectrum of the spike trains Cov(cid:127)Y9,Y=(cid:130)(𝜔)::
Cov(𝑦9,𝑦=)(𝜏)= 12𝜋∙(cid:192) Cov(cid:127)Y9,Y=(cid:130)(𝜔) e¤¸(cid:204)d𝜔
(14)
(cid:141)
M
amplitude for the common input 𝑞(𝑡) (i.e. 𝜎∙√c), we approximate the instantaneous
the Fourier domain this corresponds to (Brunel et al., 2001)
13
Cov(𝑛9,𝑛=)(𝜏)=Cov(𝑦9,𝑦=)(𝜏)∗Δ'(𝜏)
(cid:141)M
taking the
Considering current-clamp stimuli as in de la Rocha et al. (2007), and assuming a small
spiking responses of the neurons as dominated by linear dynamical transfer properties. In
Y9(𝜔)≅Y9,g(𝜔)+A9(𝜔)⋅Q(𝜔)
Y=(𝜔)≅Y=,g(𝜔)+A=(𝜔)⋅Q(𝜔)
Eq. 15 and obtain
Assuming that the two neurons' spike trains are conditionally independent, given the
Cov(cid:127)Y9,Y9(cid:130)(𝜔)=〈Y9∗(𝜔)⋅Y=(𝜔)〉≅A∗9(𝜔)⋅A=(𝜔)⋅S(cid:209)(𝜔)
functions of the two neurons. For these quantities, a full experimental characterization was
demonstrated previously (Higgs and Spain, 2009, Ilin et al., 2013, Kondgen et al., 2008,
Linaro et al., 2018).
(15)
where Q(𝜔) is the Fourier transform of 𝑞(𝑡), Y",g(𝜔) corresponds to the baseline spike
train (when 𝑞(𝑡)=0, i=1,2), and where A9(𝜔) and A=(𝜔) are the dynamical response
common input 𝑞(𝑡), we evaluate (Holden, 1976) and approximate the cross-spectrum by
(16)
where A∗9(𝜔) is the complex conjugate of A9(𝜔), and S(cid:209)(𝜔)=〈Q∗(𝜔)⋅Q(𝜔)〉 is the
power spectrum of the common input 𝑞(𝑡).
Finally, estimating the covariance of the spike counts 𝑛9(𝑡) and 𝑛=(𝑡), requires evaluating
Eq. 13 in 𝜏=0 and substituting eq. 16 into eq. 14:
(17)
(cid:141)
M
where Δ'(𝜔) is the Fourier transform of Δ'(𝜏), and takes the form of Δ'(𝜔)=
𝑇=sin=(𝜔𝑇/2)/(𝜔𝑇/2)=. For large values of 𝑇, Δ'(𝜔) approaches a Dirac's Delta
function Δ'(𝜔)≈2𝜋𝑇∙𝛿(𝜔), thereby canceling the contribution to the integral for values
of the integrand far from 𝜔≈0. In addition, the dynamical response of cortical cells is
A9(𝜔) and A=(𝜔) are further approximated by their value in 𝜔≈0, which takes the form
of the local slope (i.e., the steady-state gain) of the stationary rate-current curve 𝐹(𝐼),
computed at the cell's mean output firing rate 𝜈 (Brunel et al., 2001, Chance et al., 2002).
14
Cov(𝑛9,𝑛=)(0)≅ 12𝜋∙(cid:192) A∗9(𝜔)⋅A=(𝜔)⋅S(cid:209)(𝜔)⋅Δ'(𝜔)d𝜔
rather constant at low values of the Fourier frequencies (Fourcaud and Brunel, 2002,
Kondgen et al., 2008, Testa-Silva et al., 2014, Linaro et al., 2018). For these two reasons,
Cov(𝑛9,𝑛=)(0)≈𝑑 𝐹9(𝐼)𝑑𝐼
(18)
(cid:211) (cid:212)¶⋅𝑑 𝐹=(𝐼)𝑑𝐼
(cid:211) (cid:212)•⋅12𝜋∙(cid:192) S(cid:209)(𝜔)⋅Δ'(𝜔)d𝜔
(cid:141)
M
The covariance is therefore expected to be proportional to the product of the slopes of
the rate-current curves of the two cells. For some experiments, we thus probed the rate-
current curve of each neuron, in addition to the other stimulation protocol, and we
employed its local slope to approximate the neuron linear response function at the low
frequencies needed to estimate spike-count covariances over long windows. In fact,
although fast experimental techniques for the characterization of A9(𝜔) and A=(𝜔) are
anyway not practical: A9(𝜔) and A=(𝜔) are in fact modulated by the mean firing rate 𝜈9
and 𝜈= of the neurons (Linaro et al., 2018) and their complete estimate, across a sufficiently
available (Higgs and Spain, 2009, Ilin et al., 2013), using the full transfer function is
wide range of firing rates, is incompatible with the limited duration of each experiment.
time as
Neuron models
For modeling different cortical cell types, we used an adaptive exponential integrate-and-
fire model neuron (Brette and Gerstner, 2005), modified to incorporate a slow voltage-
C𝑑V𝑑𝑡=(cid:215)𝑔⋅(𝑉(cid:146)−𝑉)+𝑔⋅𝛥⋅e((cid:217)M(cid:217)(cid:218))/(cid:219)(cid:220)+𝐼z…(cid:213)(cid:214)+𝐼(cid:221)N(cid:148)
𝜏(cid:214)𝑑𝑤𝑑𝑡=(cid:127)1+eM((cid:217)M(cid:217)(cid:222)(cid:223))/(cid:224)(cid:222)(cid:130)M9
𝐼z…(cid:213)(cid:214)=𝑔(cid:214)⋅𝑤⋅(𝑉(cid:214)−𝑉)
𝐼(cid:221)N(cid:148)=𝐺Z(𝑡)(𝐸Z−𝑉)+𝐺](𝑡)(𝐸]−𝑉)
gated adaptation current 𝐼z…(cid:213)(cid:214). The neuron subthreshold membrane potential V evolves in
(19)
where 𝐶 and 𝑔 are the capacitance and conductance per unit of membrane surface,
respectively, 𝑉(cid:146) the resting potential, 𝛥 the spike steepness and 𝑉' the spike initiation
threshold (Fourcaud and Brunel, 2002). 𝑔(cid:214) represents the peak adaptation conductance, 𝑤
its activation state variable and 𝑉(cid:214) its reversal potential. The steady-state activation of the
potential, with half-maximal activation at 𝑉(cid:214)(cid:226) and activation slope 𝐷(cid:214). As soon as 𝑉
15
adaptation conductance is a logistic function, monotonically increasing with the membrane
In order to capture the features of each cortical cell type, we adapted the model parameter
to reproduce the resting membrane potential, the accommodation index, the rheobase, and
the slope of the rate-current relationship measured experimentally. We specifically
crosses the peak threshold 𝑉(cid:148)(cid:226), it repolarizes linearly to its resting value 𝑉(cid:146), over a
(refractory) period 𝜏›(cid:221)(cid:228).
adjusted the values of 𝑉(cid:146), 𝐶 and 𝑔 to match the resting membrane potential and membrane
time constant for each neuron type. The spike initiation threshold of the model, 𝑉', was
(i.e., NON-FS < Pyr < FS). While the resulting ordering of 𝑉' was NON-FS < FS < Pyr,
the value 𝑔(cid:214) of the adaptation conductance and the leak reversal potential also affect the
The peak adaptation conductance, 𝑔(cid:214), was then chosen to approximately match the
adjusted to ensure that the models had the same ordering of rheobases as in the experiments
rheobase.
accommodation indices for each neuron type, upon injecting a depolarizing constant
current as in the experiments. All the parameters were identical across cell types for the
three distinct model cells, as summarized in Table 1.
Table 1: Numerical parameters employed in the integrate-and-fire model neurons.
Parameter
NON-FS
FS
𝐶
𝜏
𝑉(cid:146)
𝑔(cid:214)
𝜏(cid:214)
𝑉(cid:214)(cid:226)
𝐷(cid:214)
𝑉(cid:214)
Δ
𝑉'
𝑉(cid:148)(cid:226)
1
15 ms
-80 mV
Pyramidal
1 uF/cm2
Description
Membrane capacitance
Passive membrane time constant 25 ms
Leak reversal potential
-65 mV
0.002 mS/cm2 0 mS/cm2
Peak Kv7 conductance
200 ms
Kv7 activation time constant
Kv7 half-activation voltage
-40 mV
8 mV
Slope of Kv7 activation
Kv7 reversal potential
-85 mV
1.4 mV
AP steepness
AP initiation threshold
-46 mV
0 mV
AP threshold
200 ms
-40 mV
8 mV
-85 mV
0.2 mV
-50 mV
0 mV
1
25 ms
-65 mV
0.1 mS/cm2
200 ms
-40 mV
8 mV
-85 mV
1.4 mV
-52 mV
0 mV
16
1 ms
4 ms
6 ms
Absolute refractory period
𝜏›(cid:221)(cid:228)
density 𝐼(cid:221)N(cid:148) was synthesized as in the experiments by Eq. 2. For simplicity however, we
set gZabc=g]abc=0.06 𝑚𝑆/𝑐𝑚=, and considered instantaneous synaptic coupling (i.e.
𝜏Z,𝜏]→0) (Tuckwell, 1989), and 𝑅]=10 𝑘𝐻𝑧, while changing the value of 𝑅Z in order
to change the output firing rates. Such a choice for 𝑅] , used for Figure 8C-H, reflects the
With the aim of reproducing the conductance-clamp protocols, the external current
firing rate of the summed activity of the modeled presynaptic inhibitory neurons that is
proportional, for large populations, to the (sample) mean of a neuron's presynaptic
inhibitory pool. Population-averaged firing rates in rat cortex in vivo have been reported
on the order of ~1-5 Hz, with fast-spiking putative inhibitory neurons firing faster than
excitatory cells (e.g. Hengen et al. 2013; Buszaki & Misuzeki 2015). Within a
thalamocortical projection column of the rat barrel cortex, there are ~20'000 neurons
(Meyer et al. 2010). If 15% of those are inhibitory and their average connection probability
is 1/3, the mean number of partners would be 1000, so that an average firing rate of 10 Hz
per cell would yield a total inhibitory input rate of 10 kHz for the entire inhibitory pool. In
Fig. 8C, we set a low excitatory rate of 1.75 kHz to explore the static f-I curve, while we
varied the excitatory input rate in Figure 8D-H.
effective membrane conductance and effective resting potential, respectively, eq. 19 can be
equivalently rewritten as
Defining 𝑔(cid:221)(cid:228)(cid:228)=𝑔+𝑔Z+𝑔] and 𝑉(cid:221)(cid:228)(cid:228)=𝑔(cid:221)(cid:228)(cid:228)M9⋅(cid:127)𝑔⋅𝑉(cid:146)+𝑔Z⋅𝐸Z+𝑔]⋅𝐸](cid:130) as
(20)
C𝑑V𝑑𝑡=(cid:215)𝑔(cid:221)(cid:228)(cid:228)⋅(cid:127)𝑉(cid:221)(cid:228)(cid:228)−𝑉(cid:130)+𝑔⋅𝛥⋅eM((cid:217)M(cid:217)(cid:218))/(cid:219)(cid:220)+𝐼z…(cid:213)(cid:214)+𝑖(cid:221)N(cid:148)
𝜏(cid:214)𝑑𝑤𝑑𝑡=(cid:127)1+eM((cid:217)M(cid:217)(cid:222)(cid:223))/(cid:224)(cid:222)(cid:130)M9
𝐼z…(cid:213)(cid:214)=𝑔(cid:214)⋅𝑤⋅(𝑉(cid:214)−𝑉)
where 𝑔Z(𝑡) and 𝑔](𝑡) are the randomly fluctuating components of the synaptic
conductances, with zero mean and with Dirac's Delta autocorrelation function.
17
𝑖(cid:221)N(cid:148)=𝑔Z(𝑡)(𝐸Z−𝑉)+𝑔](𝑡)(𝐸]−𝑉)
in the model, we set 𝑉=𝑉(cid:221)(cid:228)(cid:228) in the expression of 𝑖(cid:221)N(cid:148) ignoring the multiplicative nature
For our numerical simulations as well as theoretical analysis of the correlation transfer
of the random fluctuations, which then took the approximate form
𝑖(cid:221)N(cid:148)≈(cid:215)𝜎Z∙(cid:127)𝐸Z−𝑉(cid:221)(cid:228)(cid:228)(cid:130)+𝜎]∙(cid:127)𝐸]−𝑉(cid:221)(cid:228)(cid:228)(cid:130)(cid:220)∙𝛾(𝑡)
Under such an approximation, the dynamical response functions A(𝜔) of the model
(22)
Similarly to the experiments, for a pair of neurons receiving partially correlated inputs,
neuron can be obtained directly, by numerical solution of the Fokker-Planck equation
associated with Eqs. 20-21, as described in detail in (Ocker and Doiron, 2014, Richardson,
2009).
𝛾9(𝑡)=√1−𝑐 ∙𝜂9(𝑡)+√𝑐 ∙𝜂F(𝑡)
𝛾=(𝑡)=√1−𝑐 ∙𝜂=(𝑡)+√𝑐 ∙𝜂F(𝑡)
𝛾(𝑡) was chosen as
where 𝜂9(𝑡), 𝜂=(𝑡), and 𝜂F(𝑡) are randomly fluctuating waveforms, generated as
For small values of 𝑐, eq. 18 could then be used instead of Eq. 17 to calculate the
independent realizations of a Gaussian white noise, with zero mean and unitary variance,
instead of an Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process to facilitate the mathematical analysis by
Fokker-Planck equation (Brunel et al., 2001, Fourcaud and Brunel, 2002).
covariance of spike counts in the two model neurons. The MATLAB scripts for
reproducing Fig. 8 are available on FigShare.com.
Results
We closely followed the approach of de la Rocha and colleagues (de la Rocha et al., 2007)
and extended it by dynamic-clamp to the case of conductance inputs, in addition to
conventional current inputs. We examined in the details how altering the fraction of
common inputs changes the similarity of their output spike trains, in pairs of unconnected
neurons.
(21)
18
We recorded in vitro from 𝑛=47 pyramidal cells and 𝑛=52 interneurons in L5 of the
Cell types and electrophysiological responses.
rat primary somatosensory cortex, during the application of current- and conductance-
clamp stimulation. Pyramidal cells were readily identified by the presence of a large apical
trunk emanating from the cell body and oriented toward the pial surface. From an
electrophysiological point of view, pyramidal neurons constituted a homogeneous group,
characterized by a regular spiking phenotype with a variable degree of spike-frequency
Interneurons were morphologically characterized by the absence of visible dendritic
processes emanating from the cell body and presented either rounded or elongated shapes.
Based on their distinct electrophysiological properties, they could be subdivided into two
adaptation (accommodation index 0.0083±0.002, Fig. 1A,D).
non-overlapping classes. The main features of the first interneuron type (𝑛=23; Fig 1B)
were the short AP duration measured at half-width (0.38±0.01 ms), the high maximal
firing rate achievable upon current injection, typically in excess of 200 Hz, the almost
complete lack of spike-frequency adaptation (accommodation index 0.0014±0.0003,
Fig. 1B,E) and the high values of sag ratio (0.94±0.005) indicating very little sag in
response to hyperpolarizing current pulses. Taken together, these features identify this
neuronal type as a fast-spiking (FS) interneuron (Sippy and Yuste, 2013, Kawaguchi and
Kondo, 2002, Markram et al., 2004, Petilla Interneuron Nomenclature et al., 2008, Tateno
and Robinson, 2009), whose most abundant representative in the cortex is the parvalbumin-
positive basket cell (Wang et al., 2002).
The second interneuron type (𝑛=29; Fig. 1C) was characterized by slightly broader
APs (0.53±0.02 ms), sag ratios comparable to those of pyramidal cells (0.77±0.02),
strong spike-frequency adaptation (accommodation index 0.02±0.005, Fig. 1C,F), and
rebound spikes in response to hyperpolarizing current steps, present in 20 out of 30 cells in
this class (Fig. 2D). Taken together, these intrinsic properties suggest that this cell type can
be identified as a non-fast-spiking (NON-FS) interneuron (Goldberg et al., 2004, Ma et al.,
2006, Petilla Interneuron Nomenclature et al., 2008), such as somatostatin-positive
Martinotti cells (Kawaguchi and Kondo, 2002, Silberberg and Markram, 2007, Sippy and
Yuste, 2013, Wang et al., 2002).
19
Figures 1 and 2 summarize the main electrophysiological features of the three cell types
considered in this study. As mentioned in the Materials and Methods section, for a subset
of cells (13 pyramidal, 10 FS and 14 NON-FS) we measured the stationary frequency-
current (f-I) curve, with and without the additional injection of background synaptic
activity recreated by dynamic-clamp. FS cells had the steepest f-I curves, followed by
NON-FS and by pyramidal cells (Fig. 1G-I). This ordering was observed both in the "noise-
free" condition (empty markers in Fig. 1G-I) -- i.e., when only DC current steps were
injected into the cell -- and in the condition in which the DC steps were applied on top of
recreated synaptic background (solid markers in Fig. 1G-I). These results are consistent
with the divisive effect on the slope of the f-I curves produced by a balanced background
synaptic activity (Chance et al., 2002). Another effect attributable to the dynamic-clamp
stimulation is the reduction in the measured membrane time constant. This amounted to:
for pyramidal cells, 22.2±0.6 ms to 9.8±1 ms, 𝑝<10M9g, for FS interneurons 6.1±
0.4 ms to 1.4±0.1 ms, 𝑝<10M9g and for NON-FS interneurons 17.7±1.6 ms to 3.9±
0.3 ms, 𝑝<10M9g, mean ± S.E.M., two-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test.
We first investigated the dependence of output spike-count correlation 𝜌' (T is the
window length over which spikes are counted) on the degree of input correlation 𝑐, in the
experiments and varied 𝑐 in the range [0,1] (Fig 3A-C), while measuring spike-count
correlations using a time window of length 𝑇=40 ms: we chose this specific value of 𝑇
(low values of 𝑇) and covariability (high values of 𝑇). In this set of experiments, we kept
the firing rate of the cells constant, in the range [10,12] Hz, to minimize the effects
attributable to the dependency of 𝜌' on the cells' firing rate (de la Rocha et al., 2007) and
current-clamp stimulation (de la Rocha et al., 2007), 𝜌' increases monotonically with 𝑐
20
to facilitate the comparison across cell types. The results of this first set of experiments are
shown in Fig. 3: similarly to what was described previously for pyramidal cells under a
Output correlation depends on the fraction of common inputs
three cell types previously described. To this end, we performed conductance-clamp
because it constitutes a good compromise between the detection of firing rate synchronicity
under conductance-clamp stimulation, while always remaining smaller than the input
correlation value (Fig. 3A).
Additionally, for values of input correlation lower than 0.5, 𝜌' depends roughly linearly
on 𝑐 for all three cell types (Fig. 3B-D), albeit the linearity is more marked in pyramidal
cells, where it extends up to 𝑐=0.5. These results indicate that, in terms of input-output
linearity of 𝜌' for low values of input correlation 𝑐, the linear response theory previously
developed (de la Rocha et al., 2007, Litwin-Kumar et al., 2011) and summarized in the
Materials and Methods section is suited for interpreting the experimental data.
transfer of correlations, the three neuronal types behave similarly and that, given the
Spike-count covariance depends on cell pairs type
By definition, evaluating the spike-count correlation involves computing the covariance
between the spike counts from neuron pairs and then normalizing by their respective
variances. Linear response theory is only used to approximate the covariance (in the regime
where it is small relative to the variances). By contrast, building a theory for the output
variance of a neuron where complex cellular processes, such as spike frequency adaptation,
that persist beyond a single spike is often difficult (Deger et al., 2014, Naud and Gerstner,
2012, Ocker and Doiron, 2014, Richardson, 2009). For this reason, we now focus on
experimentally measuring and understanding the spike-count covariance between a neuron
pair.
We investigated whether pyramidal cells and FS and NON-FS interneurons behave
similarly in terms of covariance transfer, over a range of geometric mean firing rates. To
this end, we fixed 𝑐=0.5 and varied the ratio of excitatory to inhibitory presynaptic firing
[0,25] 𝐻𝑧. For sufficiently irregular spike trains the absolute magnitude of spike-count
covariation increases with the length of the window 𝑇. It is then convenient to examine the
values of spike-count covariance for a given value of 𝑇 while comparing two conditions,
rates (Eq. 5) to span (geometric) mean firing rates of the pairs of cells over the range
e.g., different cell types or distinct stimulation paradigms.
We first found that cortical interneurons display spike-count covariance values that are
higher than pyramidal cells when using a conductance clamp stimulation, over a broad
21
range of firing rates (Fig. 4A and C) and for 𝑇 in the range 5 to 160 ms (Fig. 4B and D).
Fig. 4B and D), and it increases with the value of 𝑇, reaching values of approximately 5
and of 2 times the covariance of pyramidal cells for FS and NON-FS interneurons,
In particular, the ratio between interneuron and pyramidal covariances is larger at higher
values of geometric mean firing rates (compare diamond-shaped with asterisk markers in
respectively. Interestingly, even when considering mixed cell-type pairs (e.g., one
pyramidal cell and one FS interneuron, as shown in Fig. 7A-B), the resulting covariance
values are always higher than what we observed in pyramidal pairs (Fig. 7).
Taken together, these results indicate that both interneuron types have a greater
capability of transmitting covariation than pyramidal cells, especially on longer timescales
and for higher geometric mean firing rates.
Spike-count covariance in pyramidal cells depends on the stimulation paradigm
In a second set of experiments, we quantified the extent to which a conductance-clamp
stimulation shapes the transfer of covariance, compared to a more conventional current-
clamp stimulus. To this end, we performed additional recordings in pyramidal cells,
employing the current-clamp stimulation described in the Methods, matching the protocol
used by de la Rocha et al. (2007).
We found that for the specific window used (𝑇=40 ms), covariance transfer in
rates above approximately 10 spike/s (Fig. 4E). When performing the same analysis for
different values of 𝑇, the phenomenon of covariance shaping became particularly
prominent (Fig. 4F). In particular, for short time windows 𝑇 the spike-count covariance
conductance clamp is significantly lower than in current-clamp, at geometric mean firing
was higher when employing conductance-clamp stimulation, whereas on longer timescales
it was higher in current clamp, especially at higher geometric firing rates.
Single-cell properties predict cell type-specific correlation transfer
When input correlations 𝑐 are sufficiently small there is an approximate linear relation
between spike correlation 𝜌' and 𝑐 (Fig. 3). Previous work has leveraged this observation
Cov(𝑛9',𝑛=') in terms of single-cell transfer properties (de la Rocha et al., 2007, Litwin-
22
to give a simple theory that expresses the spike-count covariance between two neurons
lim'→Cov(𝑛9',𝑛=')
𝑇
≈𝑐𝜎=∙gain9∙gain=
Kumar et al., 2011) (see Methods). For large values of 𝑇, the window over which the spike
counts 𝑛9',𝑛=' are estimated, this theory reduces to:
(1)
where gain9 and gain= are the slopes of the frequency-current curves of the two neurons.
Indicating by 𝜇9 and 𝜇= the mean amplitudes of the current inputs experienced by the two
neurons, this is formally written as gain"=𝑑𝑟"/𝑑𝜇" for 𝑖={1,2}. Then, the functions
𝑛"'=𝑇𝑟"(𝐼"') link the integrated input experienced by each neuron 𝐼"'=∫ 𝐼"'g
(𝑡)𝑑𝑡 to its
output spike count. Since 𝜇"=lim'→𝐼"'/𝑇 and 𝑟"=lim'→𝑛"'/𝑇 then, for large 𝑇, 𝑟"(𝜇")
is the frequency-current curve that we measured (see Fig. 1G-I), and 𝑑𝑟"/𝑑𝜇" is the firing
rate gain. In other words, Eq. 1 approximates Cov(𝑛9',𝑛=') as the input covariance 𝑐𝜎=
If 𝑟"(𝜇") is linear, then the gain 𝑑𝑟"/𝑑𝜇" remains fixed as 𝜇" changes, so that
Cov(𝑛"',𝑛¤') also does not shift. By contrast, a nonlinear 𝑟"(𝜇") makes Cov(𝑛"',𝑛¤') depend
on the "operating point" of the neuron pair (measured by 𝑑𝑟"/𝑑𝜇"), so that Cov(𝑛"',𝑛¤') is
malleable despite the input covariance remaining fixed at 𝑐𝜎=. Intuition for this effect
comes from an understanding of how the joint input density 𝑝(𝐼9',𝐼=') is mapped to the joint
output density 𝑝(𝑛9',𝑛='). The Gaussian density of 𝑝(𝐼9',𝐼=') is reshaped by the nonlinear
mapping 𝑟9(𝐼9') and 𝑟=(𝐼=') of each cell in the pair, so that the density 𝑝(𝑛9',𝑛=') is non-
Gaussian (Fig. 8A). Nevertheless, Cov(𝑛9',𝑛=') reports the effective spread of 𝑝(𝑛9',𝑛=')
along the diagonal 𝑛9=𝑛=. For low 𝜇9 the spike threshold nonlinearity forces both the
output firing rate 𝑛9/𝑇 and the gain 𝑑𝑟9/𝑑𝜇9 to be small, compromising the spread of
𝑝(𝑛9',𝑛='). When 𝜇9 is increased, the transfer of common fluctuations is enhanced through
sampling larger firing rate gains in the 𝑛9=𝑇𝑟(𝐼9') transfer. This results in an increased
spread of 𝑝(𝑛9',𝑛=') along 𝑛9=𝑛=, and naturally Cov(𝑛9',𝑛=') is larger. Thus, by
controlling the gain of the firing rate transfer (through 𝜇9 and 𝜇=) the output 𝐶𝑜𝑣(𝑛9',𝑛=')
is manipulated despite the input Cov(𝐼9',𝐼=') being fixed.
FS, and NON-FS cell types determine Cov(𝑛9',𝑛='), and how it changes with firing rate.
23
scaled by the product of firing rate gains.
We next used this theory to investigate how the single-cell properties of pyramidal,
Exponential integrate-and-fire models with slow adaptation currents (Badel et al., 2008,
Brette et al., 2008) were matched to the passive and firing rate characteristics of the
experimentally measured pyramidal, FS, and NON-FS cells (Fig. 8B) (see Methods for
details). Mimicking the experiments, we employed a stochastic bombardment of
presynaptic excitatory and inhibitory conductance inputs to drive stochastic spike train
responses (Fig. 8B). The simplicity of the spike generation mechanism combined with
vanishing synaptic timescales and large pre-synaptic ensembles permits a theoretical
calculation of the firing rate curves 𝑟"(𝜇") and their gains 𝑑𝑟"/𝑑𝜇" (see Methods). We first
computed the f-I curves by injecting static currents while fixing the input variance (Fig.
4C), qualitatively matching the experimental results (compare Fig. 8C to Fig. 1G-I). The
FS cells, however, had more similar f-I curves to the NON-FS and pyramidal cells in our
model than in the averaged experimental f-I curves, perhaps due to the different noise levels
(see Methods).
firing rate of the cells, with FS interneurons showing the highest dependence (Fig. 8D).
Furthermore, as output firing rates were driven by a stochastic bombardment of presynaptic
𝑟" by varying the presynaptic excitatory input rate, 𝑅Z. For the fitted cellular and synaptic
FS, and NON-FS cells. For all models the firing rate gain 𝑑𝑟"/𝑑𝜇" increased with the output
inputs, then as the output firing rate increased so did the overall input variance 𝜎=, again
Finally, we modeled a pair of cells receiving correlated conductance fluctuations (𝑐=
0.1) and numerically estimated Cov(𝑛9',𝑛=') as firing rates varied. Our simulations
cell properties also gave a quantitative match to Cov(𝑛9',𝑛=') for all cell types (Fig. 8F,
recapitulated the experimental results, namely at high firing rates FS interneuron pairs
showed the largest covariance, followed by NON-FS interneuron pairs, and with pyramidal
cell pairs having the lowest covariance (Fig. 8F, open circles). Our theory based on single-
for all models (Fig. 8E).
To probe the input-output transfer function, we next increased the output firing rates
parameters the model firing rate curves qualitatively matched those reported for pyramidal,
solid lines). This provides evidence that the cell-type differences in the electrical properties
that determine single-cell firing rate gain (Fig. 8D) underlie, in part, the cell-type
distinctions in covariance transfer (Fig. 8F).
Interestingly, the pyramidal cell model described previously qualitatively captures the
shaping of the covariance values observed in the experiments (Fig. 8G-H). However, how
24
correlation shaping depends on the cell pair firing rates is reversed in the theory compared
to the experiments. More to the point, in the experiments the highest values of
𝐶𝑜𝑣'(cid:128)(cid:240)›,FF /𝐶𝑜𝑣'(cid:128)(cid:240)›,aeF are observed for high values of geometric mean rate (in the range
[16,17] 𝐻𝑧, diamond markers in Fig. 4F) and gradually decrease for decreasing geometric
both theory and experiment the raw Cov(𝑛9',𝑛=') values increase with firing rates (Fig 4E
and 8G), yet in the theory there is a saturation in Cov(𝑛9',𝑛=') with firing rates in current
mean rates. In theory and in simulations, on the other hand, high geometric mean firing
rates correspond to lower values of covariation shaping (diamond markers in Fig. 8H). In
clamp that is absent in the in vitro recordings (and vice versa for the conductance-clamp
case). These discrepancies may be attributed to cellular processes that are ignored in our
model, such as subthreshold voltage-gate conductances whose activation differs between
current- and conductance-clamp activation in real neurons.
Measured covariance values correlate with single-cell properties
Our linear response theory predicts that the magnitude of covariance between two spike
trains from distinct neurons should depend on the slopes of their f-I curves (Eq. 23). If the
f-I curves were truly linear then the spike train covariance would be a fixed value,
independent of the firing rates of the neuron pair. However, in fluctuation driven regimes
the f-I curves are markedly nonlinear, with a slope that grows with the firing rate (Fig. 9
A-C). Thus, by changing the firing rates of a neuron pair we sample a range of gains and
associated pairwise covariances by varying the cell pair firing rates. This in turn provides
an opportunity to quantitatively test our linear response prediction: for each pair of cells in
our dataset we computed the coefficient of determination 𝑟= between the measured
covariance values and the product of the slopes of the f-I curves of the individual cells,
computed with the injection of recreated background synaptic activity, as shown in Fig.
1G-I at the population level (filled markers) and in Fig. 9A-C for the representative cells
used in Fig. 9D-F. In agreement with the prediction of the linear response theory, we found
a very strong correlation between the covariance and the product of the f-I curve gains, on
a cell pair-by-cell pair basis (Fig. 9D-F and Fig. 10A-C), and for each of the three cell types
under analysis. Interestingly, the distribution of coefficients 𝑟= (Fig. 9G-I and Fig. 10D-F)
25
was more strongly skewed towards high values for the FS interneuron cell type, indicating
that the covariation dynamics of GABAergic fast-spiking interneurons are better captured
by our linear response theory, at least for the intermediate value of input correlation used
in these experiments (i.e., 𝑐=0.5). Taken together, these results demonstrate how
microcircuit -- in this case, the slope of their f-I curves.
microcircuit observables -- the magnitude of covariation in the spike trains of two cells --
can be related to intrinsic, single cell properties of the neurons that constitute the
Discussion
We have shown that three distinct cell types -- pyramidal cells and two types of
GABAergic interneurons -- in L5 of rat somatosensory cortex respond differently to the
same level of correlated inputs. In our experiments, cells were stimulated with
biophysically realistic conductance inputs that mimic the activation of synaptic receptors
and that recapitulate the features of the high-conductance state observed in vivo (Destexhe
et al., 2001). It is worth pointing out that our results could not have been obtained using
current-clamp alone, as they crucially depend on the modulation of intrinsic cell properties
that can only be ascribed to conductance injection. To the best of our knowledge, this is
the first time that differences have been found in the capability of distinct neuronal types
to transmit input correlations in a firing rate-dependent manner.
Cell type-specific differences in covariation transfer
We interpreted our experimental data through a theory that predicts how spiking
neurons transfer co-fluctuations in inputs to their output spike trains (Litwin-Kumar et al.,
2011). We observed that pairs of FS interneurons display a degree of covariation that is
several factors larger than pairs of pyramidal cells, while pairs of NON-FS interneurons
produced covariation values that were only slightly larger than pyramidal cells.
Interestingly, this can be explained by an intrinsic cellular property -- the greater steepness
of FS interneurons' static input-output relationship than pyramidal cells -- therefore tying a
single-cell feature to a network observable. Although our experiments were carried out in
juvenile rats, which may not have reached yet a complete degree of neuronal maturation,
the relative ordering of the steepness of the f-I curves of the three cell types considered
26
here is preserved also in adulthood (Jiang et al., 2015), thus making our main results valid
beyond the juvenile stage investigated in the present study.
While our work highlights the importance of cellular differences between cell
classes for correlation transfer, it ignores the specifics of how pyramidal cells and FS and
NON-FS interneurons are positioned within the recurrent cortical circuit (Pfeffer et al.,
2013, Tremblay et al., 2016). Linear response theory has a natural extension to recurrently
coupled networks of spiking neurons (Ocker et al., 2017), where single neuron transfer
functions are mixed with wiring structure to determine network correlations. However,
previous studies that employ this theory have ignored differences in inhibitory neurons and
rather simply model a single interneuron class (Bos et al., 2016). Furthermore, most
modeling studies that include multiple interneuron subtypes have only focused on firing
rate models (Del Molino et al., 2017, Kuchibhotla et al., 2016, Litwin-Kumar et al., 2016),
and they do not discuss how fluctuations are distributed over a network. The cellular
insights exposed in our study when combined with established recurrent circuit theory
promise new insights into how biologically realistic cortical circuits produce and transfer
network-wide correlations.
Role of conductance-clamp stimulation
Our conductance-clamp stimulation protocol was instrumental in clarifying how the
modulation of spike-count covariance by the geometric mean firing rate strongly depends
on the cell type. This is in contrast with what was shown in earlier experiments using a
current-clamp stimulus alone (de la Rocha et al., 2007), where the authors found no major
differences among regular spiking and intrinsic bursting pyramidal cells and fast-spiking
interneurons.
To understand this discrepancy, we explicitly compared conductance and current-
clamp stimulations in pyramidal cells (Fig. 4E-F). Our results are in agreement with the
correlation-shaping mechanism first presented in (Litwin-Kumar et al., 2011), namely that
high conductance states better transfers short timescale covariability, while a low
conductance state (comparable to current clamp) better transfers long timescale
covariability. However, in that study in vitro neurons were held at a constant firing rate,
whereas here we explored a range of firing frequencies. Our work highlights that for higher
27
geometric mean firing rates the increased covariability transfer at short timescales in the
high conductance state is diminished. This should be contrasted with the increased
covariability transfer at long timescales in a low conductance state (current clamp), which
is enhanced at high firing rates.
In summary, our experimental and modeling results show that pyramidal neurons in
the high-conductance state are more suited to transferring covariation on short timescales
(i.e., via synchronous activation) than previously predicted by current-clamp experiments
(de la Rocha et al., 2007). This despite the fact that the firing variability, measured as the
coefficient of variation of the inter-spike intervals, is comparable in these two conditions
(see Fig. 6).
Of course, the major limitation of any dynamic-clamp stimulation consists in the
point nature of the conductance injection. While this might be a reasonable assumption for
neurons with relatively small dendritic trees, such as basket cells (Markram et al., 2004,
Wang et al., 2002), L5 pyramidal cells like the ones considered in this study have extensive
dendrites containing a variety of ion channels (Harnett et al., 2015, Stuart and Sakmann,
1994), which, together with nonlinear mechanisms of synaptic integration (Harnett et al.,
2012, Xu et al., 2012), support a variety of complex processing tasks (for a review see
(Spruston, 2008)). This adds a further dimension to the structure of the inputs, which can
be not only temporally correlated, as is the case for the inputs considered in this work, but
also spatially correlated, thus leading to potentially interesting phenomena of inputs
cooperativity, which largely remain to be explored.
Relating theory and experiment
De la Rocha and colleagues (de la Rocha et al., 2007) put forth a theory that related the
gain of single neuron input-output transfer to how correlated input fluctuations are
transferred by neuron pairs to output spike-count correlations (Eq. 23). However, in that
study, as well as subsequent ones, in vitro experiments were only qualitatively compared
to theory. For instance, while the dependence of spike-count correlations upon the
geometric mean firing rate can be derived from our linear theory at low firing rates (Shea-
Brown et al., 2008), it has only been shown to be qualitatively true in real neurons (de la
Rocha et al., 2007). Similarly, theoretical work has shown how the timescale (Litwin-
28
Kumar et al., 2011) or excitability class (Barreiro et al., 2010, Hong et al., 2012) of
membrane integration determines the timescales over which correlations are transferred,
nevertheless experimental tests were only qualitative in nature (e.g., an increase or decrease
in correlation as membrane properties are changed).
The difficulty with a quantitative test of a linear response theory of correlations is
that a systematic measurement of both neuronal gain and correlations transfer in neuron
pairs is rarely performed over a range of firing rates. Indeed, studies that focus upon single
neuron gain control explicitly ignore populations of neurons, while studies of neuronal
populations often only study the network in a single regime (and hence a single gain value).
The results presented in Fig. 9 of our study thus constitute the most experimentally
validated test of this theory, comparing the mapping between neuronal gain and
covariability over a range of gain values. Furthermore, our work uses the heterogeneity
over pyramidal cells and FS and NON-FS interneurons to test our theory over a broad range
of cellular properties.
Functional implications
Overall, our results raise the intriguing possibility that principal cells in the
neocortex -- and possibly in other areas of the brain, such as the hippocampus -- might be
specifically tuned to operate in a low-correlation level, which could improve the coding
capabilities of a population of principal cells. On the other hand, the higher covariance
values measured in the two interneuron classes, and in particular in fast-spiking
interneurons, are likely to play a role in the regulation of the activity of local circuits by
interneurons. In particular, higher level of correlation might facilitate interneurons in their
function as providers of a "blanket of inhibition" (Karnani et al., 2014, Packer and Yuste,
2011), and, in the case of FS interneurons, could be implicated in the important role these
cells play in orchestrating cortical oscillations (see (Freund and Katona, 2007) and
references therein). Interestingly, it has recently been shown that a class of GABAergic
cells in the prefrontal cortex sends long-range projections to subcortical areas (Lee et al.,
2014): it would be of great interest to investigate whether these cells present correlation
transfer properties that differ from what we have described here.
29
In conclusion, our findings underline the importance of an in-depth characterization
of cortical cell diversity by increased experimental realism and point to a richness of
network behaviors arising from the diversity of intrinsic cell properties.
Contributions
DL, BD, and MG designed and supervised the research. DL performed and analyzed the
electrophysiological experiments, GKO performed numerical simulations and contributed
the theoretical predictions. DL, GKO, BD, and MG wrote the paper. All authors read and
approved the final manuscript.
Data accessibility statement
Authors confirm that the data underlying their findings are fully available. Relevant data
sets and analysis scripts have been stored at FigShare.com (DOI m9.figshare.7241144),
including an index of the deposited data.
References
Badel, L., Lefort, S., Brette, R., Petersen, C. C., Gerstner, W. & Richardson, M. J. 2008.
Dynamic I-V curves are reliable predictors of naturalistic pyramidal-neuron
voltage traces. J Neurophysiol, 99, 656-66.
Bair, W., Zohary, E. & Newsome, W. T. 2001. Correlated firing in macaque visual area
MT: time scales and relationship to behavior. J Neurosci, 21, 1676-97.
Barreiro, A. K., Shea-Brown, E. & Thilo, E. L. 2010. Time scales of spike-train
correlation for neural oscillators with common drive. Phys Rev E Stat Nonlin Soft
Matter Phys, 81.
Bos, H., Diesmann, M. & Helias, M. 2016. Identifying anatomical origins of coexisting
oscillations in the cortical microcircuit. PLoS Comput Biol, 12.
Brette, R. & Gerstner, W. 2005. Adaptive exponential integrate-and-fire model as an
effective description of neuronal activity. J Neurophysiol, 94, 3637-42.
Brette, R., Piwkowska, Z., Monier, C., Rudolph-Lilith, M., Fournier, J., Levy, M.,
Fregnac, Y., Bal, T. & Destexhe, A. 2008. High-resolution intracellular
recordings using a real-time computational model of the electrode. Neuron, 59,
379-91.
Brunel, N., Chance, F. S., Fourcaud, N. & Abbott, L. F. 2001. Effects of synaptic noise
and filtering on the frequency response of spiking neurons. Phys Rev Lett, 86,
2186-9.
30
Buzsáki G and Mizuseki K (2014) The log-dynamic brain: how skewed distributions
affect network operations. Nature Review Neuroscience 15(4): 264 -- 78.
Chance, F. S., Abbott, L. F. & Reyes, A. D. 2002. Gain modulation from background
synaptic input. Neuron, 35, 773-82.
Cohen, M. R. & Kohn, A. 2011. Measuring and interpreting neuronal correlations. Nat
Neurosci, 14, 811-9.
Connors, B. W. & Gutnick, M. J. 1990. Intrinsic firing patterns of diverse neocortical
neurons. Trends Neurosci, 13, 99-104.
Cox, D. & Miller, H. 1965. The theory of stochastic processes, London, Methuen.
Cox, D. R. & Isham, V. 1980. Point processes, CRC Press.
Dayan, P. & Abbott, L. F. 2001. Theoretical neuroscience, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
de la Rocha, J., Doiron, B., Shea-Brown, E., Josic, K. & Reyes, A. 2007. Correlation
between neural spike trains increases with firing rate. Nature, 448, 802-6.
deCharms, R. C. & Merzenich, M. M. 1996. Primary cortical representation of sounds by
the coordination of action-potential timing. Nature, 381, 610-3.
Deger, M., Schwalger, T., Naud, R. & Gerstner, W. 2014. Fluctuations and information
filtering in coupled populations of spiking neurons with adaptation. Phys Rev E
Stat Nonlin Soft Matter Phys, 90, 1-10.
Del Molino, L. C. G., Guangyu, R. Y., Mejias, J. & Wang, X. J. 2017. Paradoxical
response reversal of top-down modulation in cortical circuits with three
interneuron types. eLIFE, 6.
Destexhe, A. & Bal, T. 2009. Dynamic-Clamp, Springer.
Destexhe, A. & Pare, D. 1999. Impact of network activity on the integrative properties of
neocortical pyramidal neurons in vivo. J Neurophysiol, 81, 1531-47.
Destexhe, A., Rudolph, M., Fellous, J. M. & Sejnowski, T. J. 2001. Fluctuating synaptic
conductances recreate in vivo-like activity in neocortical neurons. Neuroscience,
107, 13-24.
Destexhe, A., Rudolph, M. & Pare, D. 2003. The high-conductance state of neocortical
neurons in vivo. Nat Rev Neurosci, 4, 739-51.
Doiron, B., Litwin-Kumar, A., Rosenbaum, R., Ocker, G. K. & Josic, K. 2016. The
mechanics of state-dependent neural correlations. Nat Neurosci, 19, 383-93.
Druckmann, S., Banitt, Y., Gidon, A., Schurmann, F., Markram, H. & Segev, I. 2007. A
novel multiple objective optimization framework for constraining conductance-
based neuron models by experimental data. Front Neurosci, 1, 7-18.
Erisken, S., Vaiceliunaite, A., Jurjut, O., Fiorini, M., Katzner, S. & Busse, L. 2014.
Effects of locomotion extend throughout the mouse early visual system. Curr
Biol, 24, 2899-907.
Fourcaud, N. & Brunel, N. 2002. Dynamics of the firing probability of noisy integrate-
and-fire neurons. Neural Comput, 14, 2057-110.
Freund, T. F. & Katona, I. 2007. Perisomatic inhibition. Neuron, 56, 33-42.
Gentet, L. J., Avermann, M., Matyas, F., Staiger, J. F. & Petersen, C. C. 2010. Membrane
potential dynamics of GABAergic neurons in the barrel cortex of behaving mice.
Neuron, 65, 422-35.
Gentet, L. J., Kremer, Y., Taniguchi, H., Huang, Z. J., Staiger, J. F. & Petersen, C. C.
2012. Unique functional properties of somatostatin-expressing GABAergic
neurons in mouse barrel cortex. Nat Neurosci, 15, 607-12.
31
Goldberg, J. H., Lacefield, C. O. & Yuste, R. 2004. Global dendritic calcium spikes in
mouse layer 5 low threshold spiking interneurones: implications for control of
pyramidal cell bursting. J Physiol, 558, 465-78.
Harnett, M. T., Magee, J. C. & Williams, S. R. 2015. Distribution and function of HCN
channels in the apical dendritic tuft of neocortical pyramidal neurons. J Neurosci,
35, 1024-37.
Harnett, M. T., Makara, J. K., Spruston, N., Kath, W. L. & Magee, J. C. 2012. Synaptic
amplification by dendritic spines enhances input cooperativity. Nature, 491, 599-
602.
Hengen KB, Lambo ME, Van Hooser SD, Katz DB, Turrigiano GG (2013) Firing rate
homeostasis in visual cortex of freely behaving rodents. Neuron 80(2):335-42.
Henze, D. A. & Buzsaki, G. 2001. Action potential threshold of hippocampal pyramidal
cells in vivo is increased by recent spiking activity. Neuroscience, 105, 121-30.
Higgs, M. H. & Spain, W. J. 2009. Conditional bursting enhances resonant firing in
neocortical layer 2-3 pyramidal neurons. J Neurosci, 29, 1285-99.
Holden, A. V. 1976. Models of the Stochastic Activity of Neural Aggregates. Models of
the Stochastic Activity of Neurones. Springer.
Hong, S., Ratte, S., Prescott, S. A. & De Schutter, E. 2012. Single neuron firing
properties impact correlation-based population coding. J Neurosci, 32, 1413-28.
Ilin, V., Malyshev, A., Wolf, F. & Volgushev, M. 2013. Fast computations in cortical
ensembles require rapid initiation of action potentials. J Neurosci, 33, 2281-92.
Jiang, X., Shen, S., Cadwell, C. R., Berens, P., Sinz, F., Ecker, A. S., Patel, S. & Tolias,
A. S. 2015. Principles of connectivity among morphologically defined cell types
in adult neocortex. Science, 350, aac9462.
Karnani, M. M., Agetsuma, M. & Yuste, R. 2014. A blanket of inhibition: functional
inferences from dense inhibitory connectivity. Curr Opin Neurobiol, 26, 96-102.
Kawaguchi, Y. & Kondo, S. 2002. Parvalbumin, somatostatin and cholecystokinin as
chemical markers for specific GABAergic interneuron types in the rat frontal
cortex. J Neurocytol, 31, 277-87.
Kole, M. H. & Stuart, G. J. 2008. Is action potential threshold lowest in the axon? Nat
Neurosci, 11, 1253-5.
Kondgen, H., Geisler, C., Fusi, S., Wang, X. J., Luscher, H. R. & Giugliano, M. 2008.
The dynamical response properties of neocortical neurons to temporally
modulated noisy inputs in vitro. Cereb Cortex, 18, 2086-97.
Konig, P., Engel, A. K. & Singer, W. 1996. Integrator or coincidence detector? The role
of the cortical neuron revisited. Trends Neurosci, 19, 130-7.
Kuchibhotla, K. V., Gill, J. V., Lindsay, G. W., Papadoyannis, E. S., Field, R. E., Sten, T.
A. H., Miller, K. D. & Froemke, R. C. 2016. Parallel processing by cortical
inhibition enables context-dependent behavior. Nature Neuroscience, 20, 62.
Lee, A. T., Vogt, D., Rubenstein, J. L. & Sohal, V. S. 2014. A class of GABAergic
neurons in the prefrontal cortex sends long-range projections to the nucleus
accumbens and elicits acute avoidance behavior. J Neurosci, 34, 11519-25.
Linaro, D., Biro, I. & Giugliano, M. 2018. Dynamical response properties of neocortical
neurons to conductance-driven time-varying inputs. Eur J Neurosci, 47, 17-32.
32
Linaro, D., Couto, J. & Giugliano, M. 2014. Command-line cellular electrophysiology for
conventional and real-time closed-loop experiments. J Neurosci Methods, 230, 5-
19.
Litwin-Kumar, A., Oswald, A. M., Urban, N. N. & Doiron, B. 2011. Balanced synaptic
input shapes the correlation between neural spike trains. PLoS Comput Biol, 7,
e1002305.
Litwin-Kumar, A., Rosenbaum, R. & Doiron, B. 2016. Inhibitory stabilization and visual
coding in cortical circuits with multiple interneuron subtypes. Journal of
Neurophysiology, 115, 1399-1409.
Ma, Y., Hu, H., Berrebi, A. S., Mathers, P. H. & Agmon, A. 2006. Distinct subtypes of
somatostatin-containing neocortical interneurons revealed in transgenic mice. J
Neurosci, 26, 5069-82.
Markram, H., Toledo-Rodriguez, M., Wang, Y., Gupta, A., Silberberg, G. & Wu, C.
2004. Interneurons of the neocortical inhibitory system. Nat Rev Neurosci, 5, 793-
807.
Hanno S. Meyer Verena C. Wimmer M. Oberlaender Christiaan P.J. de Kock Bert
Sakmann Moritz Helmstaedter (2010) Number and Laminar Distribution of
Neurons in a Thalamocortical Projection Column of Rat Vibrissal Cortex. Cerebral
Cortex 20(10):2277 -- 86.
Naud, R. & Gerstner, W. 2012. Coding and Decoding with Adapting Neurons: A
Population Approach to the Peri-Stimulus Time Histogram. PLoS Comput Biol, 8,
1-14.
Ocker, G. K. & Doiron, B. 2014. Kv7 channels regulate pairwise spiking covariability in
health and disease. J Neurophysiol, 112, 340-52.
Ocker, G. K., Hu, Y., Buice, M. A., Doiron, B., Josic, K., Rosenbaum, R. & Shea-Brown,
E. 2017. From the statistics of connectivity to the statistics of spike times in
neuronal networks. Curr Opin Neurobiol, 46, 109-119.
Packer, A. M. & Yuste, R. 2011. Dense, unspecific connectivity of neocortical
parvalbumin-positive interneurons: a canonical microcircuit for inhibition? J
Neurosci, 31, 13260-71.
Petilla Interneuron Nomenclature, G., Ascoli, G. A., Alonso-Nanclares, L., Anderson, S.
A., Barrionuevo, G., Benavides-Piccione, R., Burkhalter, A., Buzsaki, G., Cauli,
B., Defelipe, J., Fairen, A., Feldmeyer, D., Fishell, G., Fregnac, Y., Freund, T. F.,
Gardner, D., Gardner, E. P., Goldberg, J. H., Helmstaedter, M., Hestrin, S.,
Karube, F., Kisvarday, Z. F., Lambolez, B., Lewis, D. A., Marin, O., Markram,
H., Munoz, A., Packer, A., Petersen, C. C., Rockland, K. S., Rossier, J., Rudy, B.,
Somogyi, P., Staiger, J. F., Tamas, G., Thomson, A. M., Toledo-Rodriguez, M.,
Wang, Y., West, D. C. & Yuste, R. 2008. Petilla terminology: nomenclature of
features of GABAergic interneurons of the cerebral cortex. Nat Rev Neurosci, 9,
557-68.
Pfeffer, C., Xue, M., He, M., Huang, Z. J. & Scanziani, M. 2013. Inhibition of inhibition
in visual cortex: the logic of connections between molecularly distinct
interneurons. Nat Neurosci, 16.
Poulet, J. F. & Petersen, C. C. 2008. Internal brain state regulates membrane potential
synchrony in barrel cortex of behaving mice. Nature, 454, 881-5.
33
Press, W. H. 2007. Numerical recipes 3rd edition: The art of scientific computing,
Cambridge university press.
Richardson, M. J. 2009. Dynamics of populations and networks of neurons with voltage-
activated and calcium-activated currents. Phys Rev E Stat Nonlin Soft Matter
Phys, 80, 021928.
Robinson, H. P. & Kawai, N. 1993. Injection of digitally synthesized synaptic
conductance transients to measure the integrative properties of neurons. J
Neurosci Methods, 49, 157-65.
Shea-Brown, E., Josic, K., de la Rocha, J. & Doiron, B. 2008. Correlation and synchrony
transfer in integrate-and-fire neurons: basic properties and consequences for
coding. Phys Rev Lett, 100.
Shinomoto, S., Shima, K. & Tanji, J. 2003. Differences in spiking patterns among cortical
neurons. Neural Comput, 15, 2823-42.
Silberberg, G. & Markram, H. 2007. Disynaptic inhibition between neocortical pyramidal
cells mediated by Martinotti cells. Neuron, 53, 735-46.
Sippy, T. & Yuste, R. 2013. Decorrelating action of inhibition in neocortical networks. J
Spruston, N. 2008. Pyramidal neurons: dendritic structure and synaptic integration. Nat
Neurosci, 33, 9813-30.
Rev Neurosci, 9, 206-21.
Steinmetz, P. N., Manwani, A., Koch, C., London, M. & Segev, I. 2000. Subthreshold
voltage noise due to channel fluctuations in active neuronal membranes. J Comput
Neurosci, 9, 133-48.
Stuart, G. J. & Sakmann, B. 1994. Active propagation of somatic action potentials into
neocortical pyramidal cell dendrites. Nature, 367, 69-72.
Tateno, T. & Robinson, H. P. 2009. Integration of broadband conductance input in rat
somatosensory cortical inhibitory interneurons: an inhibition-controlled switch
between intrinsic and input-driven spiking in fast-spiking cells. J Neurophysiol,
101, 1056-72.
Testa-Silva, G., Verhoog, M. B., Linaro, D., de Kock, C. P., Baayen, J. C., Meredith, R.
M., De Zeeuw, C. I., Giugliano, M. & Mansvelder, H. D. 2014. High bandwidth
synaptic communication and frequency tracking in human neocortex. PLoS Biol,
12, e1002007.
Tremblay, R., Lee, S. & Rudy, B. 2016. GABAergic interneurons in the neocortex: from
cellular properties to circuits. Neuron, 91, 260-292.
Tuckwell, H. C. 1989. Stochastic processes in the neurosciences, Siam.
Uhlenbeck, G. E. & Ornstein, L. S. 1930. On the Theory of the Brownian Motion.
Physical Review, 36, 823-841.
Wang, Y., Gupta, A., Toledo-Rodriguez, M., Wu, C. Z. & Markram, H. 2002.
Anatomical, physiological, molecular and circuit properties of nest basket cells in
the developing somatosensory cortex. Cereb Cortex, 12, 395-410.
Xu, N. L., Harnett, M. T., Williams, S. R., Huber, D., O'Connor, D. H., Svoboda, K. &
Magee, J. C. 2012. Nonlinear dendritic integration of sensory and motor input
during an active sensing task. Nature, 492, 247-51.
34
B
0 mV
5 ms
-65 mV
E
80
65
50
H
120
80
40
C
F
200
100
0
I
80
60
40
20
Figure
A
V
m
0
4
200 ms
A
n
5
.
0
D
40
s
u
o
e
n
a
n
a
t
t
s
n
I
)
s
/
e
k
p
s
(
i
t
e
a
r
g
n
i
r
i
f
25
10
G
30
i
)
s
/
e
k
p
s
(
e
a
r
g
n
i
r
i
F
t
20
10
0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
0.1
Current amplitude, referred to rheobase (nA)
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0
0
0
0
0.2
0.3
0.4
Figure 1. Electrophysiological intrinsic properties of pyramidal cells and two types of
interneurons. (A) Typical membrane potential of pyramidal cells in response to the
injection of hyperpolarizing and depolarizing current steps. Inset: magnification of the first
action potential fired by the cells. (B) Same as (A) but for fast-spiking interneurons with
non-accommodating firing pattern and (C) for low-threshold-spiking, non-fast-spiking
interneurons with accommodating firing pattern. (D) Instantaneous firing rate, computed
as the inverse of the inter-spike intervals, in response to the depolarizing current steps
35
displayed in A. (E-F) Same as D, but for FS and NON-FS interneurons, respectively. (G)
Population summary of the stationary transfer function for pyramidal cells (N = 13) in
response to the injection of depolarizing current steps, with and without the background
synaptic activity recreated in dynamic-clamp (solid and empty markers, respectively). The
solid lines are power-law fits of the form 𝑓(𝐼)=𝑎∙𝐼(cid:244)+𝑐, with a, b, and c free parameters.
Note both the divisive effect of the recreated synaptic background on the slope of the
current-frequency curves, as well as the overall diversity of the average slope of the curves
across cell types. (H-I) Same as G, but for FS (N = 10) and NON-FS (N = 14) interneurons,
respectively. Figure 2 presents the distinct electrophysiological features of the three cell
types.
***
**
***
***
***
*** ***
*** ***
)
Ω
M
(
e
c
n
a
i
t
s
s
e
r
t
u
p
n
I
)
s
m
(
t
h
d
w
i
400
300
200
100
0
1.5
1
0.5
f
l
a
h
P
A
0
600
400
200
0
)
A
n
/
i
e
k
p
s
(
i
n
a
g
I
-
f
***
***
***
Pyr FS
NON-FS
***
***
***
Pyr FS
NON-FS
)
s
m
(
t
n
a
t
s
n
o
c
e
m
T
i
)
1
-
s
m
(
s
s
e
n
d
p
a
r
i
P
A
50
40
30
20
10
0
60
40
20
0
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
x
e
d
n
i
n
o
i
t
a
d
o
m
m
o
c
c
A
**
***
***
**
***
**
***
Pyr FS
NON-FS
)
V
m
(
l
a
i
t
n
e
t
o
p
g
n
i
t
s
e
R
-50
-60
-70
-80
-90
)
g
a
s
/
e
a
t
t
s
y
d
a
e
t
s
(
o
i
t
a
r
g
a
S
)
A
n
(
e
s
a
b
o
e
h
R
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
A
100 ms
B
A
n
4
V
m
5
.
0
C
/
s
m
V
m
0
0
20 mV1
D
V 50 ms
A
n
m
0
4
5
0
.
E
V
m
0
4
A
n
1
50 ms
resting
steady-state
sag
(0,0)
resting
resting
resting
Figure 2. Distinct electrophysiological features of three cortical cell types. Our
classification of pyramidal cells, FS and NON-FS interneurons is supported by a well-
known heterogeneity of passive and active electrophysiological observables, as reported in
36
the literature for basket cells and Martinotti cells and shown in (A) for our dataset. These
observables were compared across 47 pyramidal cells, and 23 FS and 29 NON-FS
interneurons, and their statistically significant differences complement the diversity of
transient and stationary firing transfer properties described in Fig. 1. Two and three
asterisks indicate a value of 𝑝<0.01 and 𝑝<0.001, respectively, for statistically
significant differences as assessed by a Kruskall-Wallis test. (B) Representative voltage
deflections in the three cell types in response to a step of current that caused a
hyperpolarization of approximately 10 mV. Note the comparable amount of sag in the
response of the pyramidal cell and NON-FS interneuron, and the almost complete lack of
sag in the response of the FS interneuron. The membrane voltages have been vertically
aligned to the value of the resting potential before the stimulus onset, for ease of
comparison. (C) Representative voltage traces in the plane d𝑉 dt⁄ versus V of the average
action potential for the three cell types. Note how pyramidal cells display the largest action
potentials, with onset speeds comparable to those of FS interneurons, which however are
also characterized by an extremely fast AP offset. (D-E) Rebound firing following
hyperpolarization and burst generation in response to brief current pulses have been
reported as distinctive features of somatostatin-positive NON-FS interneurons: these
properties were observed in our experiments for NON-FS cells only, as shown here in 5
representative cells.
37
synaptic (conductance) inputs
D
1
A
B
l
T
ρ
-
n
o
i
t
a
e
r
r
o
c
t
u
p
t
u
O
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
T
ρ
-
n
o
i
t
l
a
e
r
r
o
c
t
t
u
p
u
O
0.5
0
E
Pyr
FS
NON-FS
1
0
0.2
0.6
0.4
Input correlation - c
F
0.8
G
Pyr
Linear fit
0.2 0.4 0.6
0
FS
Linear fit
0
0.2 0.4 0.6
Input correlation - c
0
NON-FS
Linear fit
0.2 0.4 0.6
-
+
+
+
-
+
l
p
m
a
c
-
c
m
a
n
y
d
i
.
.
C
E
A
+
.
c : fraction of common/shared synaptic inputs
independent inputs
1-c
+
+
c
+
+
1-c
shared inputs
independent inputs
c = 0.1
c = 0.9
cell 1
cell 2
C
cell 1
cell 2
Figure 3. Output correlation rT as a function of input correlation c, for three cortical
cell types. Two sets of conductance-based fluctuating waveforms, sharing a common
fraction c, were applied to pairs of anatomically unconnected neurons. At the steady-state,
counting window of 𝑇=40 ms and found to increase monotonically with increasing input
the correlation coefficient rT between their spike responses was estimated over a spike-
correlation c, as intuitively expected. (A) Schematic of the dynamic-clamp experimental
setup: the total current injected into the cell is the sum of two conductance waveforms, one
excitatory (red trace) and one inhibitory (blue trace), each multiplied by the appropriate
driving force. This in turn depends on the instantaneous membrane potential, recorded in
real-time by the system and filtered by the Active Electrode Compensation. (B) The
stimulation to each cell in an unconnected pair comprises an independent and a shared
component. The ratio of these two is regulated by the correlation coefficient 𝑐. (C) Effect
of varying 𝑐 on the conductance waveforms injected into the two cells. Notice the high
(low) degree of similarity of the traces corresponding to 𝑐=0.9 (𝑐=0.1). (D) Mean
values of rT for 𝑇=40 ms over the possible range of c for pyramidal cells (black markers),
38
FS (green markers) and NON-FS interneurons (purple markers) cells. Error bars indicate
proportionality to c, a useful property for the subsequent theoretical interpretation of our
the standard deviation. The dashed grey line has a unitary slope and highlights how the
output correlation is always smaller than the input correlation. (E) For weak input
correlations (𝑐≤0.5), the output correlation in pyramidal cells displayed a direct
results. Shown is the same data as in (D), magnified in the interval 𝑐∈[0,0.6] and fit with
a linear function of the form 𝜌'(𝑐)=𝑚 𝑐, where 𝑚 is the proportionality coefficient. The
fit was performed in the interval 𝑐∈[0,0.4] to highlight how the value of rT corresponding
to 𝑐=0.6 departs from the linear relationship between input and output correlation. The
data is the average of N = 6 cells firing at a firing rate 𝜈=12.5±2.2 spike/s. (F) Same
as (E), but for FS interneurons (N=5 and 𝜈=11±2.8 spike/s). (G) Same as (E), but
for NON-FS interneurons (N=6 and 𝜈=10±1.7 spike/s).
39
A
)
i
2
e
k
p
s
(
T
v
o
C
C
)
i
2
e
k
p
s
(
T
v
o
C
E
)
i
2
e
k
p
s
(
T
v
o
C
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
FS
PYR
0
5
10
15
20
25
NON-FS
PYR
0
5
10
15
20
25
PYR (current-clamp)
PYR
[4,5] sp/s
[10,11] sp/s
[16,17] sp/s
5
10
20
40
80 160
B
R
Y
P
T
v
o
C
/
S
F
T
v
o
C
D
R
Y
P
T
v
o
C
5
4
3
2
1
2
/
1.5
S
F
-
N
O
N
T
v
o
C
1
F
R
Y
P
2
5
10
20
40
80 160
T
v
o
C
/
1.5
1
,
C
C
R
Y
P
T
v
o
C
25
5
10
0
5
10
15
20
40
20
T (ms)
80 160
Geometric mean firing rate (spike/s)
dot is a value of covariance for a given pair of cells and repeated stimulation block,
Figure 4. Diversity of correlation transfer across cell type. The covariance of the output
spike count was estimated in cell pairs of identical type, for a fixed input correlation 𝑐=
0.5, across distinct firing regimes (A,C,E) and spike-count window sizes (B,D,F). (A) Each
computed over a count window 𝑇=40 ms and for increasing mean firing rates. Large
fits of the binned data with a power-law function of the form Cov(𝑓)=𝑎∙𝑓(cid:244)+𝑐, where
𝑓 is the geometric mean firing rate of the pair and 𝑎, 𝑏 and 𝑐 are free parameters. Grey dots
40
markers represent the mean of all the individual values, taken in 1 spike/s bins, revealing
over our entire data set a cell-type specific correlation transfer. The solid lines are optimal
and black markers and lines refer to pyramidal cells (N=25, with a total number of 855
pairs), while light green dots and green markers and lines refer to FS interneurons (N=14,
with 285 total number of pairs). (B) Quantification of covariance shaping in pyramidal
cells and FS interneurons, across different spike counting window sizes, for firing
frequency regimes in the ranges [4,5], [10,11] and [16,17] spike/s: note how FS
interneurons transfer up to 4 times more input correlations than pyramidal cells, over long
time-scales and for similar firing rates. (C-D) Same as (A-B), but comparing pyramidal
cells and NON-FS interneurons, shown with light purple dots and purple markers and lines
(N=15, with a total number of 621 pairs). (E-F) Same as (A-B), but comparing pyramidal
stimulation, shown with light red dots and red markers and lines (N=11, with a total
cells subjected to conductance-clamp (same data as in panels A and B) and current clamp
number of 716 pairs). Figures 5 and 6 report representative membrane potential traces, the
coefficient of variation of the interspike interval distributions, respectively. Figure 7
repeats the analysis for mixed cell-pairs.
A
V
m
0
5
B
C
1 s
Figure 5. Representative voltage traces in response to recreated synaptic stimulation
in the three cell types. The average barrage of recreated excitatory and inhibitory synaptic
41
inputs was balanced at a voltage that elicited a firing rate in the range [3,5] spike/s. (A)
Responses of two pyramidal neurons. (B) Responses of two FS cells. Note how the noisy
stimulation employed here allows obtaining arbitrarily low firing rates, effectively turning
this cell type into a type-1 oscillator. (C) Responses of two NON-FS interneurons. Note
how the discharge patterns more closely resemble those of the pyramidal cells.
A
V
C
C
V
C
2
1
0
2
1
0
0
B
D
Pyr - conductance clamp
FS
Pyr - current clamp
NON-FS
10
5
20
Firing rate (spike/s)
15
25
0
10
5
20
Firing rate (spike/s)
15
25
Figure 6. Coefficient of variation (CV) of the inter-spike intervals (ISIs) across cell
types, upon conductance and current stimulation. For each stimulation block used to
compute the values of covariance shown in Fig. 4, we extracted the average CV of the ISIs
and plotted it against the mean firing rate of the cell in that specific stimulation block. (A)
CV as a function of mean firing rate for pyramidal cells upon conductance clamp
stimulation. (B) CV as a function of mean firing rate for pyramidal cells upon current clamp
stimulation. (C) Same as (A), but for FS interneurons. (D) Same as (A), but for low-
threshold-spiking NON-FS interneurons.
42
A
)
i
2
e
k
p
s
(
T
v
o
C
C
)
i
2
e
k
p
s
(
T
v
o
C
E
)
i
2
e
k
p
s
(
T
v
o
C
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
[4,5] sp/s
[10,11] sp/s
[16,17] sp/s
5
10
20
40
80 160
5
10
20
40
80 160
PYR x FS
PYR
5
10
15
20
25
PYR x NON-FS
PYR
5
10
15
20
25
FS x NON-FS
PYR
B
R
Y
P
2
T
v
o
C
/
1.5
S
F
x
R
Y
P
T
v
o
C
D
1
0.5
1.5
R
Y
P
T
v
o
C
/
S
F
-
N
O
N
x
R
Y
P
T
v
o
C
1.25
1
0.75
F
3
2
1
R
Y
P
T
v
o
C
/
S
F
-
N
O
N
x
S
F
T
v
o
C
5
10
15
20
Geometric mean firing rate (spike/s)
25
5
10
40
20
T (ms)
80 160
Figure 7. Correlation transfer in mixed cell-pairs. (A,C,E) Covariance values computed
in heterogeneous pairs of cells: pyramidal and FS interneurons (A, green markers and
traces), pyramidal and NON-FS interneurons (C, purple markers and traces) and FS and
NON-FS interneurons (E, orange markers and traces). Notice how the resulting covariance
is always greater than that computed in homogenous pairs composed of two pyramidal cells
(black markers and traces in all panels, same data as in Fig. 4). (B,D,F) Covariance shaping
of mixed pairs of cells. Same analysis as that of Fig. 4.
43
Figure8: Single-cell properties predict covariance transfer. (A) Schematics of
covariance transfer with two cells. A correlated Gaussian input (bottom left) is transferred
through each cell's f-I curve (top left, bottom right) to produce a correlated, non-Gaussian
output (top right). Linear response theory predicts the covariance of that output distribution
by linearizing the f-I curves around the stimulus mean. (B) Cell type-specific adapting
exponential integrate-and-fire models match the recorded single-cell properties. Units:
Leak reversal potential (𝑉(cid:146)) and spike threshold (𝑉') in mV; passive membrane time
constant (𝜏) in ms; rheobase in nA. (C) Static transfer functions (f(I) curves) for each
model. (D) Slope of the f-I curve as a function of firing rate when the rate of the presynaptic
excitatory population is increased (Methods: Neuron models). (E) Intensity of the input
noise as the rate of the presynaptic excitatory population is increased. (F) Spike count
44
covariance versus geometric mean output rate for each cell type. (G) Spike count
covariance versus firing rate.
FS
NON-FS
C
40
20
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
0
1
Current from rheobase (nA)
0
0.2
0
Current from rheobase (nA)
0.4
0.6
B
80
60
40
20
0
E
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0
PYR
A
30
i
)
s
/
e
k
p
s
(
e
t
a
r
g
n
i
r
i
F
20
10
0
0.2
0
Current from rheobase (nA)
0.8
0.6
0.4
PYR x PYR
6
= 0.7
2
r
r2 = 0.90
r2 = 0.98
0.001
0.002
G1 ⋅ G2 (Hz2/pA2)
0.003
N = 21
D
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0
G
0.6
0.4
0.2
)
i
2
e
k
p
s
(
T
v
o
C
d
e
r
u
s
a
e
M
n
o
i
t
c
a
r
F
NON-FS x NON-FS
3
8
.
0
=
2
r
r2 = 0.92
r2 = 0.82
4
2 = 0.9
r
FS x FS
r2 = 0.98
r2 = 0.99
F
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0.1
0
0
0.05
G1 ⋅ G2 (Hz2/pA2)
0.002
0.004
G1 ⋅ G2 (Hz2/pA2)
0.006
H
0.6 N = 15
0.4
I
0.6 N = 10
0.4
0.2
0.2
0
0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
1
Coefficient of determination r2
0
0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
1
Coefficient of determination r2
0
0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
1
Coefficient of determination r2
Figure 9. The product of the slopes of the f-I curves strongly correlates with the
measured covariance values, on a cell-pair by cell-pair basis and in a frequency-
dependent manner. For each cell pair, we computed several covariance values
corresponding to different geometric mean firing rates. We plotted them as a function of
the product of the slopes of the f-I curves of each cell of the pair (i.e. gain1 and gain2), at
the corresponding value of firing rate. This uncovers a strong correlation between measured
45
covariance and product of gain1 and gain2, as predicted by the linear response theory. (A)
Individual f-I curves upon injection of constant steps of current in addition to recreated
background synaptic activity for the pyramidal cells shown in D. (B-C) Same as A, but for
the FS and NON-FS cells whose covariance values vs. product of f-I gains are shown in E
and F, respectively. (D) Representative examples of correlation between measured
covariance and slopes of the f-I curves, for three pairs of pyramidal cells. Actual values are
shown with square markers, while solid lines are linear fits to the data. The r2 coefficients
are indicated in the panel for each cell pair. (E-F) Same as D, but for FS and NON-FS
interneurons, respectively. (G) Distribution of r2 coefficients for N=20 pairs obtained
from 8 pyramidal cells. (H-I) Same as G, but for FS (N=15 pairs from 6 cells) and NON-
FS interneurons (N=10 pairs from 5 cells), respectively. The value of the spike counting
window is 𝑇=40 ms in all panels. Figure 10 repeats this analysis for mixed cell-pairs.
46
B
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0
PYR x FS
3
r2 = 0.9
r2 = 0.95
r2 = 0.89
0.01
0.005
G1 ⋅ G2 (Hz2/pA2)
0.015
N = 42
A
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
D
0.6
0.4
0.2
)
i
2
e
k
p
s
(
T
v
o
C
d
e
r
u
s
a
e
M
n
o
i
t
c
a
r
F
E
0.6 N = 33
0.4
PYR x NON-FS
r2 = 0.82
r2 = 0.66
8
8
.
0
=
2
r
C
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
FS x NON-FS
8
r2 = 0.9
r2 = 0.98
r2 = 0.96
0.004
0.002
G1 ⋅ G2 (Hz2/pA2)
0.006
0
0
0.01
0.005
G1 ⋅ G2 (Hz2/pA2)
0.015
F
0.6 N = 29
0.4
0.2
0.2
0
0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
1
0
0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
1
0
0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
1
Coefficient of determination r2
Coefficient of determination r2
Coefficient of determination r2
Figure 10. Correlation between the product of the gain of the f-I curves and the
measured covariance values, in mixed cell pairs. Same analysis as that performed in Fig.
9, but for pairs of cells composed of different cell types. Also in this case there is a very
strong correlation between the experimentally measured values of covariance and the
product of the slopes of the f-I curves of the two cells in the pair.
47
|
1101.6054 | 1 | 1101 | 2011-01-31T19:28:46 | Collective oscillations of excitable elements: order parameters, bistability and the role of stochasticity | [
"q-bio.NC",
"cond-mat.dis-nn",
"cond-mat.stat-mech",
"nlin.CG"
] | We study the effects of a probabilistic refractory period in the collective behavior of coupled discrete-time excitable cells (SIRS-like cellular automata). Using mean-field analysis and simulations, we show that a synchronized phase with stable collective oscillations exists even with non-deterministic refractory periods. Moreover, further increasing the coupling strength leads to a reentrant transition, where the synchronized phase loses stability. In an intermediate regime, we also observe bistability (and consequently hysteresis) between a synchronized phase and an active but incoherent phase without oscillations. The onset of the oscillations appears in the mean-field equations as a Neimark-Sacker bifurcation, the nature of which (i.e. super- or subcritical) is determined by the first Lyapunov coefficient. This allows us to determine the borders of the oscillating and of the bistable regions. The mean-field prediction thus obtained agrees quantitatively with simulations of complete graphs and, for random graphs, qualitatively predicts the overall structure of the phase diagram. The latter can be obtained from simulations by defining an order parameter q suited for detecting collective oscillations of excitable elements. We briefly review other commonly used order parameters and show (via data collapse) that q satisfies the expected finite size scaling relations. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Collective oscillations of excitable elements: order
parameters, bistability and the role of stochasticity
Fernando Rozenblit and Mauro Copelli
Departamento de F´ısica, Universidade Federal de Pernambuco, 50670-901, Recife-PE,
Brazil
E-mail: [email protected], [email protected]
Abstract. We study the effects of a probabilistic refractory period in the collective
behavior of coupled discrete-time excitable cells (SIRS-like cellular automata). Using
mean-field analysis and simulations, we show that a synchronized phase with stable
collective oscillations exists even with non-deterministic refractory periods. Moreover,
further increasing the coupling strength leads to a reentrant transition, where the
synchronized phase loses stability.
In an intermediate regime, we also observe
bistability (and consequently hysteresis) between a synchronized phase and an active
but incoherent phase without oscillations. The onset of the oscillations appears in
the mean-field equations as a Neimark-Sacker bifurcation, the nature of which (i.e.
super- or subcritical) is determined by the first Lyapunov coefficient. This allows us
to determine the borders of the oscillating and of the bistable regions. The mean-field
prediction thus obtained agrees quantitatively with simulations of complete graphs and,
for random graphs, qualitatively predicts the overall structure of the phase diagram.
The latter can be obtained from simulations by defining an order parameter q suited
for detecting collective oscillations of excitable elements. We briefly review other
commonly used order parameters and show (via data collapse) that q satisfies the
expected finite size scaling relations.
1
1
0
2
n
a
J
1
3
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
4
5
0
6
.
1
0
1
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
CONTENTS
Contents
1 Introduction
2 Model
2.1 Excitable cellular automata . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2.2 Coupling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2.3 Order parameters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2
2
3
3
4
4
3 Complete graph
6
6
3.1 Simulations
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
8
3.2 Mean-field analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
9
3.3 Linear stability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.4 Phase diagram . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
4 Random graph
12
4.1 Mean-field and simulation results
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
4.2 Annealed random graphs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
4.3 Finite-size scaling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
5 Concluding remarks
Appendix A Lyapunov coefficient
1. Introduction
16
17
Understanding collective oscillations of coupled nonlinear elements remains a challenge
from both theoretical and experimental viewpoints. From the theoretical side, much
progress has been accomplished since the seminal works of Winfree and Kuramoto [1,
2, 3, 4, 5] on coupled oscillators, upon which recent literature has expanded to include
effects of e.g.
complex topologies [6] and noise [7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13]. From the
experimental side, the subject has a longstanding importance in neuroscience: collective
neuronal oscillations stood for a long time as candidates for a solution of the so-called
binding problem [14], but emphasis has recently shifted to attentional processes [15].
Here we are interested in collective oscillations of units which are excitable, i.e.
not intrinsically oscillatory. This topic has been experimentally observed in a variety
of scenarios, from neuroscience [16, 17] to chemistry [18], but theoretical approaches
have been relatively scarce [19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25]. In particular, it is not entirely
clear to which extent these oscillations are robust with respect to noise. On the one
hand, recent studies have shown sufficient conditions for the onset of global oscillations
of deterministic excitable units with noisy coupling, emphasizing e.g.
the interplay
between coupling strength and characteristic time scales of the units [20, 21], or the
importance of the topology of the network [19]. On the other hand, the susceptible-
infected-recovered-susceptible (SIRS) model on a lattice (i.e. a minimum three-state
CONTENTS
3
excitable model) has been thoroughly studied, with several results strongly suggesting
that its stochastic Markovian version does not yield sustained oscillations [26, 27, 28, 23]
(for non-Markovian models, see e.g. [29, 30]).
This raises the question whether it is possible to find sustained global oscillations
in a network of excitable units whose intrinsic dynamics (not only the coupling) is
non-deterministic. We therefore propose and study a simple probabilistic model which
has a well-defined deterministic limit. To study the phase transitions in the model,
we employ an order parameter specifically tailored to assess collective oscillations of
excitable systems. These are described in section 2. We study complete graphs as
well as random graphs, comparing mean-field calculations with simulations. Results are
presented in sections 3 and 4, while section 5 brings our concluding remarks.
2. Model
2.1. Excitable cellular automata
The minimum model of an excitable system consists of three states, representing
quiescence (state 0), excitation (state 1) and refractoriness (state 2) [29] (a prototypical
example being the SIRS model). As shown by Girvan et al., however, such a cyclic three-
state deterministic cellular automaton fails to exhibit sustained collective oscillations.
For them to become stable, their model needs at least 2 refractory states [20]. To obtain
an arbitrary number of refractory states, for each site j = 1, ..., N, let sj = 0, 1, 2, ..., τ be
the consecutive states of the unit (out of the τ +1 states, the last τ−1 are refractory [20],
see figure 1).
The cellular automaton version of the probabilistic SIRS model (also called the
probabilistic Greenberg-Hastings model
[31]) corresponds to τ = 2, with intrinsic
transitions 1 → 2 and 2 → 0 governed by constant probabilities, whereas the
transition 0 → 1 occurs with a probability that usually increases linearly with the
number of excited neighbors [32] (for a study with nonlinear coupling, see [23]).
In the model studied by Girvan et al., on the other hand, all intrinsic transitions
(sj → (sj + 1) mod (τ + 1), sj 6= 0) are deterministic.
Here we study an intermediate variant of these models, where all intrinsic transitions
are deterministic but the last one, which occurs with probability pγ (see figure 1). The
idea is to have a minimum model (lest the number of additional parameters becomes
too large) which incorporates non-determinism in the intrinsic dynamics. The choice to
make the transition from the last refractory state probabilistic is natural and comes from
neuroscience: neuronal dynamics depend on ionic channels which are stochastic [33, 34],
so that a neuron may or may not fire when stimulated at the end of its refractory period
(the so-called relative refractory period) [33].
CONTENTS
4
Figure 1. Single-cell dynamics. pinf is the probability of activation (0 → 1) from
neighbours, pγ is the probability of transitioning from the relative refractory state (τ )
to the rest state (0). Light gray states are refractory. All other transitions are
deterministic.
2.2. Coupling
The only transition that still needs to be described is the excitation process 0 → 1. We
assume each site j is symmetrically connected with kj other sites. Each active site has a
probability σ/K of activating a resting neighbour, where σ is a control parameter (which
corresponds to the system branching ratio [35, 22]) and K is the average connectivity
(K = hkji). The fraction of active sites
δ1,sj (t)
(1)
Pt(1) ≡
1
N
N
Xj=1
is used to measure network activity at time t. At σ = 1 the model shows a transition
from an absorbing to an active state, but without sustained oscillations [22]. With
deterministic units (pγ = 1), the system undergoes a transition to the oscillatory regime
at σ = σc(pγ = 1) > 1, which persists indefinitely if σ is further increased [20, 22].
To motivate the analysis to be developed in section 3, figure 2 shows examples
of single-run results in a complete graph with N = 5 × 105 for pγ = 0.85 and
increasing values of σ. For probabilistic units, we observe the transition to an active but
nonoscillating state at σ = 1 [Figure 2(a)-(b)] and the second transition to an oscillating
state for larger σ [Figure 2(b)-(c)]. Contrary to what is observed in the deterministic
model, however,
in the probabilistic model this second transition is reentrant with
respect to the coupling strength σ, as shown in figure 2(c)-(d).
The nature of this reentrant transition will be clarified in section 3. In order to
analyze it properly, though, one needs to define an adequate order parameter to detect
synchronization among excitable elements.
2.3. Order parameters
Most studies of synchronization employ the Kuramoto order parameter [2, 3], which
corresponds to the time and ensemble average of the norm of the complex vector
eiθj (t) ,
(2)
Z(t) ≡
1
N
N
Xj=1
where θj = 2πsj/(τ + 1). Note that Z corresponds to the center of mass of the phases of
the units. This works fine when the system is composed of coupled uniform oscillators,
CONTENTS
0.6
)
1
(
P
t
0.3
0
0.6
)
1
(
P
t
0.3
σ
0
0.6
)
1
(
P
t
0.3
0
0.6
)
1
(
P
t
0.3
0
0
50
5
σ = 0.95 (a)
σ = 1.2 (b)
σ = 6
(c)
σ = 18
(d)
200
250
100
150
t (steps)
Figure 2. Time series for pγ = 0.85 and increasing values of σ on a complete graph
with N = 5 × 105 sites. Respectively for increasing σ (top-bottom): (a) absorbing
(not-active) state, (b) active state without oscillations, (c) with oscillations and (d)
again active without oscillations. P0(0) = 0.95, P0(1) = 0.05. τ = 3.
because rotational symmetry will ensure that, in the absence of sustained collective
oscillations, the order parameter vanishes in the thermodynamic limit. Consider,
however, the present case of excitable elements. The trivial absorbing state (sj = 0,
∀j), which is always a collective solution of the dynamics, yields a nonzero (in fact,
maximum!) Kuramoto order parameter.
in the absorbing state units are
all "perfectly synchronized" in the sense that they always have the same state. But
this is clearly not what one wants to detect. This problem persists for σ & 1 (below
the onset of collective oscillations), where a small fraction of the units are active (on
average), whereas most remain quiescent. In that case, Z has a constant bias towards
the absorbing state, around which it will fluctuate.
Indeed,
Collective oscillations correspond to rotations of Z which may be misdetected in
the averaging procedure owing to a lurking constant vector. One possibility which has
been used to avoid the weight of the absorbing state is excluding terms with sj = 0
from the sum in eq. (2) [19, 21]. Another strategy makes use of the standard deviation
(measured along time) of Pt(1) to detect oscillations [36], though neither procedure is
easily extensible to continuous-phase systems.
To account for a system of continuous-phase units which may have an arbitrary
number of preferred phases, one could employ the angular momentum L ≡ X∂tY −
Y ∂tX, where Z = X + iY [37, 38]. In our cellular automata, this would require the
discretization of the time derivative, which could introduce unnecessary numerical errors.
CONTENTS
Alternatively, Shinomoto and Kuramoto have previously proposed
q ≡ hZ − hZitit ,
6
(3)
which amounts to subtracting the constant bias from Z before the averaging
procedure [39]. However, this can be computationally expensive, requiring the storage
of the whole time series. Making use of a similar idea, but with much less computational
bookkeeping, in the following we will characterize collective oscillations via the order
parameter
(4)
q =qhZ − hZit2it =qhZ2it − hZit2 ,
which can be seen as a generalized standard deviation of Z(t). Differently from q,
obtaining q is computationally inexpensive, as the means over time are now separated
and may be calculated along with the simulation. In section 4.3 we will show that q
satisfies scaling relations near a phase transition, as expected for an order parameter.
One may grasp intuition about q by considering the different time series in figure 2.
Let P ∗
1 be the stationary value limt→∞hPt(1)it, which is an order parameter in its own
right, measuring whether or not the network is active [22]. In figs. 2(a) and (b), although
the system goes from P ∗
1 6= 0 as the system goes from an absorbing to an
active fixed point, both have q = 0, because there are no oscillations after the transient.
In figure 2(c), on the other hand, we have both P ∗
1 6= 0 and q > 0, as the oscillatory state
becomes stable after increasing σ. Finally, for figure 2(d), the oscillations are unstable,
P ∗
1 6= 0 and q = 0.
1 = 0 to P ∗
3. Complete graph
We start with the complete graph because it is presumably the topology most prone
to exhibiting stable collective oscillations. Besides, it allows a comparison between
simulations and analytical results (see below). From now on, we will focus on the effect
of the probabilistic dynamics (pγ) on synchronization and will fix τ = 3.
3.1. Simulations
We have simulated complete graphs (kj = K = N − 1) with sizes varying from N = 105
to N = 106. At each time step, intrinsic transitions occur as described in section 2. The
transition 0 → 1 is governed by the number N1(t) of active (si = 1) sites at time t, each
of which can activate a quiescent cell with probability σ/N. Therefore, the probability
of a quiescent cell being activated by at least one of its N1(t) active neighbours is
p(0 → 1) = Pinf (t) = 1 −(cid:16)1 −
σ
N(cid:17)N1(t)
,
(5)
which renders the simulations relatively simple despite the large system sizes. Finally,
initial conditions must be chosen to avoid large amplitudes during the transient, which
could throw the system into the absorbing state [20]. Apart from that, the effects we
CONTENTS
7
report below are robust with respect to the initial conditions and we have arbitrarily
fixed P0(0) = 0.8 and P0(1) = 0.2.
To illustrate the kind of reentrant transition exemplified in figure 2, we show in
figure 3(a) the order parameter q as a function of the coupling parameter σ. Starting at
some σmin > 1, for each value of σ we let the system evolve during a transient of ttrans
time steps, after which we start measuring the order parameter q up to t = tmax time
steps. We then increase σ by a constant amount δσ and repeat the procedure, with the
initial condition of the system for each value corresponding to the final condition of the
preceding value. Both constants are chosen so the rate of change is small (δσ/tmax ≪ 1).
After a maximum value σmax is reached, σ is sequentially decreased by the same amount
δσ down to σmin.
As shown in figure 3(a), the reentrance of the transition to collective oscillations
is captured by the non-monotonic behavior of q(σ), which departs from zero at some
lower value σc(pγ) and returns to zero at some upper value σc
2(pγ). Moreover, we have
found that while the first transition is always continuous, the second transition can be
discontinuous. The fingerprint of the discontinuity is the hysteresis observed in the order
parameter: above σc
2, the only stable state of the system has constant (but nonzero)
Pt(1), thus no oscillations (q = 0). If we decrease σ, oscillations do not reappear at σc
2,
but rather at a lower value σc
1, σc
2]
in parameter space where collective oscillations (q > 0) can coexist with an active
(Pt(1) > 0) but non-oscillating (q = 0) state. As it turns out [see Figure 3(a)], for
pγ = 0.95 the size of this bistable region is rather sensitive to the system size. Smaller
systems tend to be perturbed away from collective oscillations by larger fluctuations,
leading to smaller hysteresis cycles.
1. There is therefore a region of bistability σ ∈ [σc
As pγ is decreased, the mean and variance of the refractory periods of the units
increase, rendering the whole system noisier. This might be the explanation for the
result in figure 3(b), which shows a smaller reentrant region with oscillations (q > 0).
The width of the hysteresis cycle also decreases, with both σc
2 decreasing.
Furthermore, σc
2 (along with the width of the hysteresis cycle) becomes less sensitive
to the system size, which could be due to the variance of the refractory periods
overcoming the effects of small-size fluctuations. Albeit subtly, σc also increases slowly
with decreasing pγ, as will be seen in figure 4.
1 and σc
Further decreasing pγ [Figure 3(c)], the bistable region vanishes, whereas the
transition to a collectively oscillating state remains. Finally, for sufficiently small pγ,
collective oscillations are no longer stable [Figure 3(d)].
In the following, we will show that these transitions can be quantitatively
reproduced by a low-dimensional mean-field analysis. For a controlled comparison,
σc and σc
1 were heuristically defined as the values of σ (averaged over n runs) where
q first rose above some threshold value qmin ∝ 1/√N, respectively for increasing and
decreasing values of σ. On the other hand, σc
σ where q first fell below qmin.
2 was defined as the value of (increasing)
CONTENTS
8
1
q
(a)
0
1
σ
c
(b)
q
pγ
pγ
pγ
pγ
0
1
q
0
1
q
0
pγ = 0.95
σ
c
1
pγ = 0.9
σ
c
2
Map
N = 1.0×106
N = 2.5×105
N = 1.0×105
(c)
(d)
pγ = 0.8
0.2
q
0
4
0.015
pγ = 0.75
q
6
σ
8
10
10
20
σ
30
0
4
6
σ
8
40
10
50
Figure 3. Hysteresis loop for the mean-field solution (to be presented in section 3.2)
and complete graph (N = 105, 2.5 × 105 and 106) with pγ = 0.95, 0.9, 0.8 and 0.75.
tmax = 1×103 steps (ttrans = 500) and δσ = 0.05. Mean (symbols) and standard errors
(bars) calculated over 10 runs. Insets zoom into the interesting region 4 ≤ σ ≤ 10.
Note that fluctuations in the inset of (d) decrease with increasing system size, where
the mean-field approximation (section 3.2) predicts q = 0 in the thermodynamic limit
(see also section 4.3).
3.2. Mean-field analysis
In the following we apply the standard mean-field (MF) approximation [40] to the
equations governing our system. We follow closely the steps of Refs. [20, 41, 22], where
every site is considered to have K neighbors, a fraction Pt(1) of which is excited at time
t. If a given site is at rest [with probability Pt(0)], the probability of it becoming excited
by at least one of its excited neighbors is
Pinf (t) = 1 −(cid:18)1 −
σPt(1)
K (cid:19)K
.
(6)
CONTENTS
9
The dynamics of the system is then described by the following closed set of equations:
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
Pt+1(0) = pγPt(τ ) + (1 − Pinf (t)) Pt(0)
Pt+1(1) = Pinf (t)Pt(0)
Pt+1(s) = Pt(s − 1)
Pt+1(τ ) = Pt(τ − 1) + (1 − pγ)Pt(τ ) ,
(2 ≤ s ≤ τ − 1)
where the normalization condition
Pt(0) = 1 −
Pt(s)
τ
Xs=1
renders (7) redundant and reduces the system to a τ -dimensional map [41]. Therefore,
increasing the duration of the refractory period amounts to an increase in the complexity
of the mean-field calculations.
For the complete graph, K = N − 1 and mean field is exact. In the thermodynamic
limit, (6) becomes
which, from (7) and (11), leads to
lim
N→∞
Pinf = 1 − e−σPt(1) ,
Pt+1(1) = (1 − e−σPt(1))"1 −
Pt(s)# .
(12)
(13)
In other words, in the mean field approach the state of the system is completely described
by ~Pt ≡ (Pt(1), Pt(2), . . . , Pt(τ ))T , which evolves according to ~Pt+1 = ~F ( ~Pt). Note that
F1 is the only component of ~F which is nonlinear [see (13)].
s ≡ P∞(s) = P∞(s−1) =
1 /pγ. Finally, in its steady state,
From (9), the fixed point for any 2 ≤ s ≤ τ −1 is clearly P ∗
1 which, upon substitution in (10), gives P ∗
τ = P ∗
τ
Xs=1
· · · = P ∗
(13) becomes:
1 = (1 − e−σP ∗
P ∗
1 )(cid:20)1 −(cid:18)τ − 1 +
1
pγ(cid:19) P ∗
1(cid:21) ,
1 ≃ 0 (note that P ∗
which can be numerically solved. Expanding near P ∗
1 = 0 is always
a solution), one easily obtains the transition from an absorbing to an active (steady)
state at σ = 1 [22]. The collective oscillations appear when the active state becomes
unstable.
(14)
3.3. Linear stability
Considering a small perturbation ηt(s) such that Pt(s) = P ∗
s + ηt(s), the linearized
dynamics can be written as ~ηt+1 = A~ηt, where Aij = ∂Fi/∂Pt(j) ~P ∗ is the Jacobian
matrix calculated at the fixed point:
g(σ, P ∗
1 )
1
0
0
A =
(e−σP ∗
1 − 1)
0
1
0
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
. . .
· · ·
(e−σP ∗
1 − 1)
0
0
(e−σP ∗
1 − 1)
0
0
1
(1 − pγ)
,
(15)
CONTENTS
10
1 ) = e−σP ∗
1 − 1 + σe−σP ∗
j=1
1 [1 − (τ − 1 + 1/pγ)P ∗
1 ]. The eigenvalues {µj}τ
and g(σ, P ∗
of A determine whether ~P ∗ is stable (maxj µj < 1) or unstable (maxj µj > 1) (for
simplicity, in the following we employ µ ≡ µk, where k = argmaxjµj).
We expect to pinpoint the transition to the oscillatory state by looking for a
Neimark-Sacker (NS) bifurcation in the mean field equations (which is the discrete-
time analog of the Andronov-Hopf (AH) bifurcation in continuous time [42]). In other
words, for fixed pγ, we have µ = 1 with Im(µ) 6= 0 at σ = σN S. The relation between
σN S and the pair {σc
2} of critical values depicted in figure 3(a) will be clarified below.
Like the AH bifurcation, the NS bifurcation also comes in two different flavours: in
the supercritical case, a stable closed invariant curve (CIC -- the discrete-time analog
of a limit cycle) is born at σN S and grows continually from zero amplitude;
in the
subcritical case, an unstable CIC exists below σN S and engulfs the fixed point ~P ∗ at
σN S (above which the system is typically attracted to another pre-existing, but stable,
CIC). Since the order parameter q increases with the amplitude of the oscillations (which
is, roughly speaking, proportional to ~η), a supercritical (subcritical) NS bifurcation in
the mean-field equations is suggestive of a continuous (discontinuous) phase transition
in the system (see e.g. [23]).
1, σc
The sign of the first Lyapunov coefficient l1 [42] indicates if the Neimark-Sacker
bifurcation is supercritical (l1 < 0) or subcritical (l1 > 0).
Its calculation is briefly
reviewed in the Appendix. We now have the necessary tools to unveil the complete
phase diagram.
3.4. Phase diagram
We have run simulations of complete graphs with N = 106 excitable units and employed
the protocol described in section 3.1 with tmax = 103 to detect the width of the hysteresis
loop (coexistence region). We have tested and verified that longer values of tmax do not
change our results significantly. The phase diagram thus obtained from the simulations
is shown with symbols in figure 4 (the horizontal gray lines show the values of pγ used
in figure 3). To obtain the NS lines of the mean-field equations, we have numerically
m<n(1 − µnµm), which changes its
sign at the NS bifurcation. As the first Lyapunov coefficient l1 determines whether the
bifurcation is super- or subcritical, its value along the bifurcation line is shown in the
inset of figure 4 (changing sign at σT ). The solid lines in figure 4 show the supercritical
(red) and subcritical (blue) bifurcation curves where ΦN S(σN S; pγ) = 0.
explored a special test function [42] ΦN S(σ; pγ) = Qτ
Comparing the solid lines with the symbols in figure 4, we observe that linear
stability analysis accurately accounts for the transition from an active (but non-
oscillating) phase to an oscillating phase.
In other words, it correctly predicts the
lines σc(pγ) and σc
1(pγ), where in both cases the non-oscillating phase loses stability.
The transition at σc
2(pγ), however, cannot be predicted by linear analysis. Note
that in this case it is the stable CIC that loses its stability (that of the fixed point
~P ∗ remaining intact). This hints at the existence of a global bifurcation, which can be
CONTENTS
1
active with osc.
bistable (active)
11
σ
T
bcrit. N-S
u
S
S
u
p
e
r
c
r
i
t
.
N
-
S
0.9
γ
p
0.8
.
c
s
o
o
/
w
e
v
i
t
c
a
σ
=
1
0.7
0
not active
10
active w/o osc.
σ
T = 7.9837
)
S
N
σ
(
1
l
5
σNS
12
20
σ
30
40
50
Figure 4. Phase diagram for the complete graph (triangles) with N = 106 (mean
over 50 runs, tmax = 103, ttrans = 5 × 102). Solid red (blue) line is the supercritical
(subcritical) Neimark-Sacker bifurcation predicted from linear analysis. Black line
marks the (discontinuous) stability limit of the oscillating phase (as predicted by mean
field). Note that the black and blue lines approach each other very closely before
merging at σT . Inset: first Lyapunov coefficient l1(σ).
numerically detected in the MF equations by direct iteration of the map determined
by equations (9), (10) and (13). To compare the τ -dimensional MF map with system
simulations, we rewrite the complex vector Z from (2) and (11) as
τ
Z(t) = 1 +
Pt(s)(eiφs − 1) ,
(16)
Xs=1
where φs = 2πs/(τ + 1). We can thus calculate q for the MF map and subject it to the
same protocol used for detecting the coexistence region in the simulations. The black
solid line in figure 4 shows the σc
2(pγ) obtained by iteration of the map, which is in good
agreement with simulations (symbols).
Note that in the lower part of the oscillating phase (pγ . 0.8) the order parameter
detects oscillations in the simulations which are not predicted by the mean-field analysis.
This phenomenon is due to stochastic oscillations, as recently explained by Risau-
Gusman and Abramson [43]: the fixed point in the conflicting region is in fact stable,
but with an eigenvalue with a nonzero imaginary part. Inevitable fluctuations throw
the system away from the stable point, to which it returns in spiral-like trajectories,
yielding a nonzero q even for very large system sizes [43, 23].
For pγ = 1, we recover a quenched variant of the model by Girvan et al. [20]. In
this regime where intrinsic transitions are deterministic, increasing the coupling will
CONTENTS
12
only reinforce collective oscillations, and the fixed point P ∗
1 never regains stability (i.e.
σc
1 → ∞). This suggests that even small amounts of noise in the intrinsic dynamics of
excitable elements can lead to qualitatively different collective behavior in a regime of
strong coupling.
4. Random graph
4.1. Mean-field and simulation results
To understand network topology effects on synchronization, we study a bidirectional
random graph similar to an Erdos-R´enyi [44] network, where NK/2 links connect
randomly chosen pairs [22] and remain frozen ("quenched") throughout each run (and
in each run, a new realization of the network is created). The main difference with
respect to the complete graph (CG) is that in the random graph (RG) the value of σ
is bounded from above: σ ≤ K [see (6)]. The mean-field calculations, however, are
otherwise similar to that of the complete graph, with (6) replacing (12). We therefore
applied to the RG problem the same procedures for determining the stability of the
solutions, the nature of the NS bifurcation and the boundary of the bistability region
(see section 3).
Given their uncorrelated assigment of links and short distances among sites, random
graphs are usually regarded as the natural topology in which mean-field predictions are
expected to hold. Indeed, simulations and mean-field calculations agree nearly perfectly
as far as the phase transition at σ = 1 [22] is concerned. In figure 5(a)-(b) we see that
a good agreement is also observed in the transitions to a synchronized phase for large
values of K. Note, however, that simulations and mean-field predictions differ at the
rightmost boundary of the bistable region, and the disagreement worsens as K decreases.
As shown in figure 5(c), for smaller values of K bistability was not even detected in the
simulations, and the oscillating phase is substantially smaller than predicted by mean
field.
4.2. Annealed random graphs
Could correlations (which are neglected by the mean-field approximation) account for
the discrepancy observed in figure 5? In order to assess the role of the correlations
associated with the quenched connectivity, we studied an annealed variant of the model
where the K neighbors of each site are randomly chosen at each time step [20, 45].
Results are shown in figure 6, in which we restrict ourselves to smaller values of K
because results are essentially indistinguishable from the quenched case for large K.
For smaller K, three features are noteworthy. First, the agreement with mean
field results is recovered (apart from the stochastic oscillations in the lower end of the
oscillating phase, like in the previous cases). This therefore confirms the suspicion that
correlations associated to the quenched connectivity can indeed undermine collective
CONTENTS
13
N = 1.0×105
N = 1.0×105
N = 1.0×105
(quenched)
(quenched)
(quenched)
1
γ
p
0.7
1
σ
=
1
K=300
(a)
K=150
(b)
K
K
K
γ
p
0.7
1
γ
p
0.7
0
σ
=
1
σ
=
1
K=30
(c)
5
10
σ
15
20
25
Figure 5. Phase diagram for (quenched) random graphs with (a) K = 300, (b)
K = 150 and (c) K = 30. Solid red (blue) line is the supercritical (subcritical)
Neimark-Sacker bifurcation predicted from linear analysis. Black line marks the
(discontinuous) stability limit of the oscillating phase (as predicted by mean field).
Symbols are obtained from simulations (mean over 5 runs) with tmax = 3 × 103 steps
(ttrans = 2 × 103 steps) and N = 105. Standard errors are smaller than symbol size.
The purple dashed line is a guide for the eyes and marks the stability limit of the
oscillating phase for simulations.
oscillations. This is not surprising, given the difficulty of establishing collective
oscillations of excitable elements in hypercubic lattices [19, 23].
Second, the bound σ < K impoverishes the repertoire of detected phenomena for
small K [see the forbidden gray regions in figure 6(b) and (c)]. Note that the coexistence
region shrinks as K decreases. In fact, since σT varies very slowly with K [see the inset
of figure 6(c)], there is a minimum value of K [satisfying Kc = σT (Kc)] below which
the system shows no bistability (i.e. there is no change in the sign of l1). We have
numerically estimated Kc = 7.8074(1).
Finally, note that the oscillating phase extends into lower values of pγ for decreasing
It means that, for fixed σ and pγ, it is
K. This is a rather counter-intuitive result.
CONTENTS
14
N = 1.0×105
N = 1.0×105
N = 1.0×105
(annealed)
(annealed)
(annealed)
1
γ
p
0.7
1
σ
=
1
K=30
(a)
K
K
K
γ
p
0.7
1
γ
p
0.7
0
σ
=
1
σ
=
1
K=20
(b)
7.85
T
σ
7.8
5
K
K=10
15
(c)
5
10
σ
15
20
25
Figure 6. Phase diagram for (annealed) random graphs with (a) K = 30, (b) K = 20
and (c) K = 10. Solid red (blue) line is the supercritical (subcritical) Neimark-
Sacker bifurcation predicted from linear analysis. Black line marks the (discontinuous)
stability limit of the oscillating phase. Symbols are obtained from simulations (mean
over 5 runs) with tmax = 3× 103 steps (ttrans = 2× 103 steps) and N = 105. Standard
errors are smaller than symbol size. Grey shaded areas correspond to a forbidden
region where σ > K. Inset: σT for different values of K, showing the existence of a
Kc = σT (Kc) = 7.8074(1) below which no bistable region exists.
possible to take the system from a non-oscillating to an oscillating phase by lowering
the connectivity K. This is a particularity of the annealed RG (and the mean-field
approximation), however. Note in figure 5 that the opposite (and expected) trend is
observed for quenched random graphs. It remains to be studied whether refining the
approximation (including e.g. first-neighbor correlations [41, 28]) can reconcile mean-
field with quenched random graph results.
4.3. Finite-size scaling
Our phase diagrams rely heavily on the proposed order parameter q. The inset of figure 7
indicates that near σc its behavior becomes increasingly abrupt with increasing system
CONTENTS
15
size N. In order to confirm that q indeed possesses the basic properties of a bona fide
order parameter, here we show that at the supercritical NS bifurcation (i.e. a second
order phase transition) it satisfies the scaling relations that would be expected from
standard finite-size scaling (FSS) theory.
Defining ∆ ≡ σ − σc, FSS predicts that q ∝ L−β/ν⊥f(cid:0)∆L1/ν⊥(cid:1) for a lattice with
linear size L [40], where the critical exponents are defined as q ∝ ∆β and ξ ∝ ∆−ν⊥
in the limit N = Ld → ∞ (where ξ is the correlation length). This holds for d below
the upper critical dimension dc. For d ≥ dc, mean-field exponents are expected and the
scaling relation has to be modified [46] with L → N 1/dc , so
(17)
q ∝ N −β/dcν⊥f(cid:0)∆N 1/dcν⊥(cid:1) .
This modified version of the usual FSS relation was shown to also hold for infinitely
coordinated networks [47] (i.e. the complete graph).
0.1
10
q
K = 150, pγ=0.9
)
⊥
ν
c
d
(
/
β
N
q
1
0.1
0
4.5
σ
σ
c
5.5
N=6.25×103
N=1.25×104
N=2.50×104
N=3.50×104
N=5.00×104
N=7.00×104
N=1.00×105
100
β
x
β - dc
ν⊥/2
x
101
∆N1/(dc
ν⊥)
102
103
Figure 7. Collapse in a probabilistic (pγ = 0.9) regime for K = 150, σc = 5.16. We
used β = 1/2, ν⊥ = 1/2, dc = 4. Mean over 15 runs, with standard errors smaller than
symbol size. Other parameters were tmax = 104,ttrans = 7 × 103, δσ = 5 × 10−3
For large argument, the scaling function in Equation (17) becomes f (x) ∝ xβ,
In the subcritical regime (∆ < 0), one expects q ∼ O(N −1/2) [3],
as usual [40].
so f (∆N 1/dcν⊥) ∝ N −1/2N β/dcν⊥. For this to be true, f (x) ∝ xβ−
2 when x < 0.
Figure 7 shows an excellent data collapse for (quenched) random graphs with different
system sizes. Consistent power laws are obtained with standard mean-field exponents
(as expected for random graphs), namely β = 1/2 [3], ν⊥ = 1/2 and dc = 4 [40]. Similar
results are obtained with complete graphs (not shown).
dcν⊥
CONTENTS
5. Concluding remarks
16
We have studied the effects of a probabilistic refractory period in the collective behavior
of a large number of coupled excitable cellular automata. We have obtained the mean-
field solution of the model and compared it with simulations of complete as well as
random graphs. The continuous phase transition to a synchronized regime is associated
to a Neimark-Sacker bifurcation in the mean-field equations.
This scenario is similar to what has been previously obtained by Girvan et al. [20]
in a model of deterministic excitable automata (pγ = 1 in our model). The effects of
setting pγ < 1, however, are drastic, and appear for sufficiently strong coupling σ, when
we have observed that oscillations vanish. This is in contrast with the transition to
the absorbing state found in Ref. [20] for strong coupling. While in their model the
transition is due to very large amplitudes driving the system into rest (Pt(1) = 0), in
our model the system is thrown into an active albeit disordered state, which still has
Pt(1) 6= 0, but no oscillations.
Furthermore, only for non-deterministic excitable elements do we observe
bistability, with an oscillating and an active (but non-oscillating) phase coexisting. This
leads to hysteresis cycles, whose sizes can depend on the system size (notably for the
complete graph) and eventually disappear in random graphs with small enough mean
connectivity K.
Although we have restricted ourselves to τ = 3, preliminary results suggest that the
overall scenario is preserved for larger values of τ , specially regarding the first transition
at σc. The observation of bistability and hysteresis is more difficult for larger values of
τ , owing to stronger finite-size effects. These are similar to those reported by Girvan et
al.: for finite N and sufficiently strong coupling, the CIC grows in amplitude and nears
the absorbing state, to which the system is thrown by fluctuations [20]. Distinguishing
between that type of transition and the bistability reported here is not obvious and
remains to be studied.
It is interesting to note that a simple model allows the straightforward application
of standard techniques of nonlinear dynamics to the study of these phase transitions,
which could otherwise be difficult to tackle. Note that in the limit pγ = 1, each excitable
unit in our model has, at the end of its refractory period, a perfect memory of its past τ
time steps. Incorporating this memory in a continuous-time model would require non-
Markovian dynamics, as recently proposed by Gon¸calves et al. [30]. Interestingly, their
model also shows an oscillating phase with reentrance, whose size decreases as memory
time decreases. In our model, this corresponds to lowering pγ, with a similar effect on
the collective behavior. It remains to be investigated whether bistability also occurs in
non-Markovian continuous-time models.
Finally, a note of caution is in order regarding the scaling results of figure 7. The
fact that a data collapse is obtained employing an upper critical dimension dc = 4 by no
means implies that a lower critical dimension exists. In fact, we are not aware of models
which exhibit collective oscillations of excitable elements in hypercubic lattices (though
CONTENTS
17
they do appear if stimulated with a Poisson drive [48]). It remains to be investigated
whether the results of this model hold for small-world networks and other complex
topologies [19, 21], which are extremely appealing for applications in Neuroscience.
This is currently under investigations (results will be published elsewhere).
In summary, we have shown that collective oscillations of excitable elements have
robustness to a certain degree of stochasticity in their intrinsic dynamics. For fixed
coupling, there is a critical value of pγ, below which no oscillations are stable. Fixing
pγ < 1 and increasing the coupling σ, on the other hand, leads to interesting new
phenomena such as bistability and discontinuous transitions. Taken together, our
results suggest that even weakly noisy dynamics can qualitatively change the collective
oscillating behavior. Studies attempting to verify whether these phenomena are observed
in more detailed excitable networks (e.g. modelled by stochastic differential equations)
would certainly be welcome.
Acknowledgments
The authors gratefully acknowledge enlightening discussions with Vladimir R. V. Assis,
as well as finantial support from Brazilian agencies CNPq, FACEPE, CAPES and special
programs PRONEX (F´ısica Biol´ogica) and INCeMaq.
Appendix A. Lyapunov coefficient
Let ~u and ~v be respectively the right and left (adjoint) eigenvector of the Jacobian
matrix:
A~u = eiθ0~u ,
AT~v = e−iθ0~v ,
(A.2)
with both normalized: h~v, ~ui = 1 = h~u, ~ui (brackets denote the standard complex inner
product). Let also ~B(~x, ~y) and ~C(~x, ~y, ~z) be multilinear functions proportional to the
first nonlinear terms of the Taylor expansion of ~F at σ = σN S, i.e.,
(A.1)
(A.3)
(A.4)
(A.5)
τ
∂2Fj(~ξ; σN S)
xkyl ,
∂3Fj(~ξ; σN S)
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)~ξ= ~P ∗
∂ξk∂ξl∂ξm (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)~ξ= ~P ∗
τ
∂ξk∂ξl
Bj(~x, ~y) =
Cj(~x, ~y, ~z) =
Xk,l=1
Xk,l,m=1
~r = (I − A)−1 ~B(~u, ¯~u) ,
~s = (e2iθI − A)−1 ~B(~u, ~u) ,
xkylzm .
If we now define
(A.6)
where I is the τ × τ identity matrix and ¯~u is the conjugate of ~u, the coefficient l1 is
finally given by [42]
1
Rene−iθ0hD~v, ~C(~u, ~u, ¯~u)E + 2D~v, ~B(~u, ~r)E +D~v, ~B(¯~u, ~s)Eio .(A.7)
2
l1 =
CONTENTS
References
18
[1] A. T. Winfree. Biological rhythms and the behavior of populations of coupled oscillators. J.
Theor. Biol., 16(1):15 -- 42, 1967.
[2] Y. Kuramoto, editor. Chemical Oscillations, Waves and Turbulence. Dover, Berlin, 1984.
[3] S. H. Strogatz. From Kuramoto to Crawford: Exploring the onset of synchronization in populations
of coupled oscillators. Physica D, 143:1 -- 20, 2000.
[4] A. Pikovsky, M. Rosenblum, and J. Kurths. Synchronization: A Universal Concept in Nonlinear
Sciences. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 2001.
[5] J. Acebr´on, L. Bonilla, C. P´erez Vicente, F. Ritort, and R. Spigler. The Kuramoto model: A
simple paradigm for synchronization phenomena. Rev. Mod. Phys., 77(1):137 -- 185, 2005.
[6] A. Arenas, A. D´ıaz-Guilera, J. Kurths, Y. Moreno, and C. Zhou. Synchronization in complex
networks. Phys. Rep., 469(3):93 -- 153, 2008.
[7] T. Risler, J. Prost, and F. Julicher. Universal critical behavior of noisy coupled oscillators. Phys.
Rev. Lett., 93(17):175702, 2004.
[8] T. Risler, J. Prost, and F. Julicher. Universal critical behavior of noisy coupled oscillators: A
renormalization group study. Phys. Rev. E, 72(1):016130, 2005.
[9] K. Wood, C. Van den Broeck, R. Kawai, and K. Lindenberg. Universality of synchrony: Critical
behavior in a discrete model of stochastic phase-coupled oscillators. Phys. Rev. Lett., 96:145701,
2006.
[10] K. Wood, C. Van den Broeck, R. Kawai, and K. Lindenberg. Critical behavior and synchronization
of discrete stochastic phase-coupled oscillators. Phys. Rev. E, 74(3):031113, 2006.
[11] K. Wood, C. Van den Broeck, R. Kawai, and K. Lindenberg. Effects of disorder on synchronization
of discrete phase-coupled oscillators. Phys. Rev. E, 75(4):041107, 2007.
[12] K. Wood, C. Van den Broeck, R. Kawai, and K. Lindenberg. Continuous and discontinuous
phase transitions and partial synchronization in stochastic three-state oscillators. Phys. Rev. E,
76(4):041132, 2007.
[13] H. Khoshbakht, F. Shahbazi, and K. A. Samani. Phase synchronization on scale-free and random
networks in the presence of noise. J. Stat. Mech., 2008(10):P10020, 2008.
[14] W. Singer. Neuronal synchrony: a versatile code for the definition of relations? Neuron, 24(1):49 --
65, 1999.
[15] P. J. Uhlhaas, G. Pipa, B. Lima, L. Melloni, S. Neuenschwander, D. Nikoli´c, and W. Singer. Neural
synchrony in cortical networks: history, concept and current status. Front. Integr. Neurosci.,
3:17, 2009.
[16] W. Shew, H. Yang, T. Petermann, R. Roy, and D. Plenz. Neuronal avalanches imply maximum
dynamic range in cortical networks at criticality. J. Neurosci., 29(49):15595 -- 15600, 2009.
[17] C. H. Ko, Y. R. Yamada, D. K. Welsh, E. D. Buhr, A. C. Liu, E. E. Zhang, M. R. Ralph, S. A.
Kay, D. B. Forger, and J. S. Takahashi. Emergence of Noise-Induced Oscillations in the Central
Circadian Pacemaker. PLoS Biology, 8(10):e1000513, 2010.
[18] A. F. Taylor, M. R. Tinsley, F. Wang, Z. Huang, and K. Showalter. Dynamical quorum sensing
and synchronization in large populations of chemical oscillators. Science, 323(5914):614 -- 7, 2009.
[19] M. Kuperman and G. Abramson. Small world effect in an epidemiological model. Phys. Rev.
Lett., 86(13):2909 -- 2912, 2001.
[20] M. Girvan, D. S. Callaway, M. E. J. Newman, and S. H. Strogatz. Simple model of epidemics with
pathogen mutation. Phys. Rev. E, 65:031915, 2002.
[21] P. Gade and S. Sinha. Dynamic transitions in small world networks: Approach to equilibrium
limit. Phys. Rev. E, 72(5):1 -- 4, 2005.
[22] O. Kinouchi and M. Copelli. Optimal dynamical range of excitable networks at criticality. Nat.
Phys., 2:348 -- 351, 2006.
[23] V. R. V. Assis and M. Copelli. Discontinuous nonequilibrium phase transitions in a nonlinearly
pulse-coupled excitable lattice model. Phys. Rev. E, 80:061105, 2009.
CONTENTS
19
[24] Q.-X. Liu, R.-H. Wang, and Z. Jin. Persistence, extinction and spatio-temporal synchronization
of SIRS spatial models. J. Stat. Mech., 2009(07):P07007, 2009.
[25] P. McGraw and M. Menzinger. Self-Sustaining Oscillations in Complex Networks of Excitable
Elements. arXiv:1009.0537v1 [cond-mat.dis-nn], 2010.
[26] G. Rozhnova and A. Nunes. Fluctuations and oscillations in a simple epidemic model. Phys. Rev.
E, 79:041922, 2009.
[27] G. Rozhnova and A. Nunes. SIRS dynamics on random networks: Simulations and analytical
In J. Zhou, editor, Complex Sciences, volume 4, pages 792 -- 797. Springer Berlin
models.
Heidelberg, 2009. arXiv:0812.1812v1 [q-bio.PE].
[28] G. Rozhnova and A. Nunes. Cluster approximations for infection dynamics on random networks.
Phys. Rev. E, 80:051915, 2009.
[29] B. Lindner, J. Garc´ıa-Ojalvo, A. Neiman, and L. Schimansky-Geier. Effects of noise in excitable
systems. Phys. Rep., 392:321 -- 424, 2004.
[30] S. Gon¸calves, G Abramson, and M. F. C. Gomes. Oscillations in SIRS model with distributed
delays. arXiv:0912.1250v3 [q-bio.PE], 2009.
[31] J. M. Greenberg and S. P. Hastings. Spatial patterns for discrete models of diffusion in excitable
media. SIAM J. Appl. Math., 34:515 -- 523, 1978.
[32] V. R. V. Assis and M. Copelli. Dynamic range of hypercubic stochastic excitable media. Phys.
Rev. E, 77:011923, 2008.
[33] C. Koch. Biophysics of Computation. Oxford University Press, New York, 1999.
[34] P. V. Carelli, M. B. Reyes, J. C. Sartorelli, and R. D. Pinto. Whole cell stochastic model reproduces
J. Neurophysiol.,
the irregularities found in the membrane potential of bursting neurons.
94:1169 -- 1179, 2005.
[35] T. E. Harris. The Theory of Branching Processes. Springer, 1963.
[36] J. Garcia-Ojalvo, M. B. Elowitz, and S. H. Strogatz. Modeling a synthetic multicellular clock:
repressilators coupled by quorum sensing. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 101(30):10955 -- 60, 2004.
[37] Y. Kuramoto, T. Aoyagi, I. Nishikawa, T. Chawanya, and K. Okuda. Neural Network Model
Carrying Phase Information with Application to Collective Dynamics. Prog. Theor. Phys.,
87:1119 -- 1126, 1992.
[38] H. Ohta and S. Sasa. Critical phenomena in globally coupled excitable elements. Phys. Rev. E,
78(6):065101, 2008.
[39] S. Shinomoto and Y. Kuramoto. Phase transitions in active rotator systems. Progr. Theoret.
Phys., 75(5):1105 -- 1110, 1986.
[40] J. Marro and R. Dickman. Nonequilibrium Phase Transition in Lattice Models. Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, 1999.
[41] L. S. Furtado and M. Copelli. Response of electrically coupled spiking neurons: a cellular
automaton approach. Phys. Rev. E, 73:011907, 2006.
[42] Y.A. Kuznetsov. Elements of Applied Bifurcation Theory (Applied Mathematical Sciences).
Springer, 2nd edition, 1998.
[43] S. Risau-Gusman and G. Abramson. Bounding the quality of stochastic oscillations in populations
models. Eur. Phys. J. B, 60:515 -- 520, 2007.
[44] P. Erdos and A. R´enyi. On the evolution of random graphs. Publ. Math. Inst. Hung. Acad. Sci,
5:17 -- 61, 1960.
[45] S. Sinha, J. Saramaki, and K. Kaski. Emergence of self-sustained patterns in small-world excitable
media. Phys. Rev. E, 76(1):015101, July 2007.
[46] E. Br´ezin. An investigation of finite size scaling. J. Phys.(Paris), 43(1):15 -- 22, 1982.
[47] R. Botet, R. Jullien, and P. Pfeuty. Size scaling for infinitely coordinated systems. Phys. Rev.
Lett., 49(7):478 -- 481, 1982.
[48] T. J. Lewis and J. Rinzel. Self-organized synchronous oscillations in a network of excitable cells
coupled by gap junctions. Network: Comput. Neural Syst., 11:299 -- 320, 2000.
|
1608.07499 | 1 | 1608 | 2016-08-26T15:54:07 | Stem Cell Therapy for Alzheimer's Disease | [
"q-bio.NC",
"q-bio.CB"
] | The loss of neuronal cells in the central nervous system may happen in numerous neurodegenerative illnesses. Alzheimer's Disease (AD) is an intricate, irreversible, dynamic neurodegenerative sickness. It is the main source of age-related dementia, influencing roughly 5.3 million individuals in the United States alone. Promotion is a typical feeble ailment in individuals more than 65 years, bringing on disability described by decrease in memory, failure to learn and do every day exercises, intellectual weakness and influences the personal satisfaction of patients. Pathologic qualities of AD are an irregular development of specific proteins called Beta-amyloid "plaques" and Tau "Tangles" in the mind. Notwithstanding, current treatments against AD are just to calm manifestations and palliative yet are not the cure and a few promising medications competitors have fizzled in late clinical trials. There is consequently a critical need to enhance our comprehension for pathogenesis of this sickness, making new and creative prescient models with powerful treatments. As of late, stem cell treatment has been appeared to have a potential way to deal with different illnesses, including neurodegenerative disorders. In light of the far reaching nature of AD pathology, stem cell substitution procedures have been seen as an extraordinarily difficult and impossible treatment approach. Stem Cell may likewise offer an effective new way to deal with model and concentrate AD. Patient derived induced Pluripotent Stem Cells (iPSCs), for instance, may propel our comprehension of disease mechanism. In this review we will examine the capability of stem cells to help in these testing tries. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | Stem Cell Therapy for Alzheimer's Disease
Patel, Ankur P.¹, Joshi, Grishma N.², and Ugile, Rupali P.³
¹ Biomedical Sciences Department, Specialization in Immunology, C. W. Post College, Long
Island University, NY.; Email: [email protected].
² Biomedical Sciences Department, Specialization in Cancer Biology, C. W. Post College,
Long Island University, NY.; Email: [email protected].
³ Biomedical Sciences Department, Specialization in Microbiology, C. W. Post College,
Long Island University, NY.; Email:[email protected].
To whom correspondence should be addressed. Tel: +1(212)748-9329, Email:
[email protected].
Abstract
The loss of neuronal cells in the central nervous system may happen in numerous
neurodegenerative illnesses. Alzheimer's Disease (AD) is an intricate, irreversible, dynamic
neurodegenerative sickness. It is the main source of age-related dementia, influencing
roughly 5.3 million individuals in the United States alone. Promotion is a typical feeble
ailment in individuals more than 65 years, bringing on disability described by decrease in
memory, failure to learn and do every day exercises, intellectual weakness and influences
the personal satisfaction of patients. Pathologic qualities of AD are an irregular
development of specific proteins called Beta-amyloid "plaques" and Tau "Tangles" in the
mind. Notwithstanding, current treatments against AD are just to calm manifestations and
palliative yet are not the cure and a few promising medications competitors have fizzled in
late clinical trials. There is consequently a critical need to enhance our comprehension for
pathogenesis of this sickness, making new and creative prescient models with powerful
treatments. As of late, stem cell treatment has been appeared to have a potential way to
deal with different illnesses, including neurodegenerative disorders. In light of the far
reaching nature of AD pathology, stem cell substitution procedures have been seen as an
extraordinarily difficult and impossible treatment approach. Stem Cell may likewise offer an
effective new way to deal with model and concentrate AD. Patient derived induced
Pluripotent Stem Cells (iPSCs), for instance, may propel our comprehension of disease
mechanism. In this review we will examine the capability of stem cells to help in these
testing tries.
Keywords:
Alzheimer's disease, stem cell therapy, oxidative stress, induced pluripotent stem cells,
transplantation, and neurogenesis
Introduction
Alzheimer's Disease (AD), the most widely recognized type of age related dementia, which is
the real reason for incapacity among the more seasoned individuals around the world.
Promotion step by step wrecks the influenced patient's memory and capacity to learn and
reason (after the age of ~65). They show a hindered capacity to grasp or utilize words, poor
coordination, absence of judgment and basic leadership capacity, disarray, state of mind
swings and extra minutes turns out to be comprehensively severe [1][2]. It is the most
widely recognized sort of dementia, at present influencing 35.6 million individuals around
the world, which is an assume that is relied upon to triple by 2050 [3]. By and large, AD is
ordered in two sorts, i.e. familial AD and sporadic AD. The transformation of three qualities:
The amyloid antecedent protein (APP), presenilin-1 (PS-1) and presenilin-2 (PS-2) are key
changes present in Familial AD [4]. Sporadic AD is the aftereffect of ecological elements and
danger qualities, with apolipoprotein (ApoE) supposedly the most vital [5].
The boundless loss of neurons and neurotransmitters that happens in AD seems, by all
accounts, to be brought on by the collection of dangerous types of the "beta-amyloid" (Aβ)
plaques, neurofibrillary tangles (NFT) and neurodegeneration, speaking to obsessive
attributes. Aβ peptides are observed to be the fundamental constituents of senile plaques,
and AB fibrils from pores in neurons have been appeared to prompt calcium influx and
neuronal passing [6]. NFT comprises of neurofibrillary protein aggregates, shaped as
irregular hyper phosphorylation of "tau" protein, which is one of the microtubule-related
proteins [7]. Moreover, microglia have been accounted for to assume an imperative part in
the safe protection arrangement of the central nervous system (CNS). Microglia initiation
and the arrival of related incendiary elements have been accounted for to add to unending
neurodegenerative issue in AD [8]. All the more as of late, stem cell treatment has been
seen as a potential way to deal with its treatment. In this review, we concentrate on Stem
cell treatments for AD
Pathogenesis of AD
The definite reason for AD is not surely understood. Considering the commonness and poor
visualization of AD, there has been an examination need in creating infection models for
concentrating on pathogenicity and to help being developed of restorative methodologies.
In United States starting 2012, 1 out of 8 senior nationals (13%) are experiencing AD, making
it the 6th most regular reason for death. More than 5.4 million AD patients are right now
accepting restorative consideration in the USA and they bring about consideration costs that
are as high as $200 billion a year [9]. Advertisement is normally portrayed by a steady
decrease of memory, dialect, and psychological capacity.
Figure 2- Neurons affected by Alzheimer's disease
Figure 1- Healthy neurons
P.C. (Figure 1 and 2): Alzheimer's disease: how could stem cells help?
http://www.eurostemcell.org/factsheet/alzheimer's-disease-how-could-stem-
cells-help.
The two pathological trademarks known not in the patient's cerebrum, be that as it may,
has an indistinct truth of which of these seems first and/or is primarily in charge of the
illness' advancement are, senile plaques and neurofibrillary tangles (NFT) [10,11]. Senile
plaques are stores of an unmistakable protein pieces called beta-amyloid (Aβ), which causes
neuronal cytotoxicity, and neurofibrillary tangles are irregular structures that are framed by
changes in the tau protein inside the nerve cells. The nerve cells shrink and die progressively
in the brain of Alzheimer's patients. Such neuronal cell demise happens principally, in areas
in charge of the memory, yet it at last spreads to the whole cerebrum. Diminish
acetylcholine, which is a neurotransmitter that is included in the intracellular flagging and
insufficiency in the creation of different neurotransmitters, for example, somatostatin,
serotonin and norepinephrine results in debilitated neuronal systems administration in
Alzheimer's patients [12]. Total of Aβ saw in the Familial Alzheimer's Disease (FAD) come's
about by quality change of the Aβ precursor protein, which is the segment of the senile
plaques. The transentorhinal cortex of the mind is the spot where ailment begins of shows
and dynamically spreads to the entorhinal cortex, the hippocampus, and the cerebral
cortex. With emotional neuronal cell passing, memory misfortune and intellectual
brokenness alongside movement of dementia, additionally prompts demise of the patient
[13-15].
General Treatment for AD
Alzheimer's Disease (AD) may come about because of the collection of amyloid-beta (Aβ)
peptides in the cerebrum. The Cysteine Protease family based Cathepsin B (CatB) corrupts
peptides and proteins and is connected with amyloid plaques in a relative constrained way
in AD brains through endocytosis or phagocytosis. So inhibitors of cathepsin B might be
considered as restorative operators to diminish Aβ in AD [16]. Neprilysin (Nep) has been as
of late recognized as a noteworthy extracellular Aβ corrupting protein in the cerebrum and
proposes that quality exchange methodologies may have potential for the advancement of
option treatments for Alzheimer's Disease [17]. Other pharmacological alternatives are
without further ado accessible for the symptomatic treatment of AD which incorporates
Acetylcholinesterase inhibitors (AChEIs) and memantine, a N-methyl-d-aspartic acid
antagonist, utilized as a joined treatment [18]. High plasma levels of vitamin E are
connected with a diminished danger of AD in cutting edge age, going about as a cell
reinforcement, securing against lipid peroxidation [19].
Stem Cell Treatment for AD
Foundational stem cells are characterized as cells that be able to recharge themselves
ceaselessly and have pluripotent capacity to separate into numerous cell sorts. Two sorts of
mammalian pluripotent stem cells, embryonic stem cells (ESCs) got from the internal cell
mass of blastocysts and embryonic germ cells (EGCs) acquired from post implantation
developing lives, have been distinguished, and these foundational stem cells offer ascent to
different organs and tissues. As of late, there has been an energizing improvement in era of
another class of pluripotent foundational stem cells, induced pluripotent stem cells (iPS
cells), from grown-up physical cells. Notwithstanding ESCs and iPS cells, tissue-particular
stem cells could be separated from different tissues of more progressed formative stages,
for example, hematopoietic stem cells, bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (BMMSCs),
adipose-tissue derived stem cells, amniotic liquid stem cells, and neural stem cells [20].
Degeneration or brokenness of medial ganglionic prominence (MGE) descendants is
regularly connected with learning and memory disorders. Progeny of the MGE-like
progenitors, especially basal forebrain cholinergic neurons (BFCNs), may encourage the
advancement of cell treatments for AD [21]. Stem Cell transplantation increased brain
derived neurotropic factors (BDNF) and nerve development calculate and restored
cholinergic neuronal trustworthiness [22]. The extracellular ligand, Wnt, and its receptors
are included in sign transduction and assume a critical part in pivot arrangement and neural
advancement. In AD, a diminishing of the intracellular Wnt effector, β-catenin, has been
connected to amyloid-β-peptide-impelled neurotoxicity. Secreted frizzled-related proteins
(sFRPs), which are group of Wnt mediators, may have potential ramifications in treatment
of AD in study models [23]. Transplantation of Adipose-determined mesenchymal stem
cells (ADMSCs) enhances intellectual capacity by expanding acetylcholine synthesis and
restoring neuronal integrity. Bone marrow Mesenchymal stem cells are likewise critical to
expel Aβ plaques from the hippocampus and to diminish Aβ stores through the enactment
of endogenous microglia in an affected AD mouse model.
Embryonic stem cells are self-recharging totipotent cells that can separate into neuron
progenitor cells and are transplanted in AD creature models and it can bring about a
treatment of AD. Human neural stem cells (HNSCs) transplanted into aged rat brains
separated into neural cells and fundamentally enhanced the psychological elements of
the animals, showing that HNSCs might be a promising competitor for cell-substitution
treatments for neurodegenerative diseases including Alzheimer's disease (AD). RNA
obstruction of APP or decrease of APP levels in the cerebrum can essentially diminish glial
separation of stem cells and might be helpful in promoting neurogenesis after stem
cell transplantation [24].
Presence of multipotent neural stem cells (NSCs) in creating or grown-up mammalian
cerebrum with properties of inconclusive development and multipotent potential to
separate into three noteworthy CNS cell sorts, neurons, astrocytes, and oligodendrocytes.
Nerve Growth factor (NGF) counteracts neuronal demise and enhances memory in creature
models of maturing, excitotoxicity, and amyloid lethality, proposing that NGF might be
utilized for treating neuronal degeneration and cell passing in AD. Quality treatment is
valuable in conveyance of NGF into the cerebrum. Stem cells can be hereditarily altered to
convey new qualities and have high transient limit after transplantation in mind and they
could be utilized as a part of spot of fibroblasts that are known for their fixed nature taking
after transplantation for conveyance of NGF to counteract degeneration of basal forebrain
cholinergic neurons [25].
Undifferentiated cell has helpful impacts in any case; further studies are expected to decide
the proper conditions to enhance the remedial impacts for AD pathology.
Understanding the pathogenesis of Alzheimer's disease (AD) using Induced
Pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs)
The iPSCs model framework got from familial and additionally sporadic AD patients could be
an instrument to know the atomic premise of sporadic AD furthermore turned out to be
compelling in testing the medication proficiency for AD. Speculation expresses the
helpfulness of iPSCs as these cells could be focused by utilizing propelled quality altering
procedures as a part of familial known change and could be utilized for further cell
transplantation treatments [26]. The study exhibits the dermal fibroblast taken from the
patient determined to have late stage AD and reinvented to iPSCs. These iPSCs lines
indicated pluripotent properties which are like human embryonic foundational stem cells
which could be separated to neuronal cells in vitro. These neuronal cells have demonstrated
the AD phenotype and articulation of p-tau proteins, up control of GSK3B protein and its
phosphorylation as which was not seen in parental dermal cells. Various qualities are
uncovered by neuronal separation try different things with AD-iPSCs line [27, 28]. The study
could demonstrate that the quality direction units and subunits of proteasome complex are
influenced in neurons got from AD patients [27].
The academic study by Yagiet. al. additionally produced iPSCs from patient with familial AD
where changes in Presenilin1 and Presenilin2 were watched [29]. Which results to frame an
off base cleavage and affidavit of amyloid-β protein which is considered to shape plaque
[30, 31].
Hurdles and limitation in stem cell therapy in Alzheimer's disease
There are impediments to know the basic genomic pathology because of some moral issues
in accessibility of suitable neuronal cells from AD patients. Secondly utilizing iPSCs on
substantial scale requires various propelled strategies and expense to deliver iPSCs on huge
scale [32].
To create iPSCs from substantial cells, reconstructing variables must be included by two
techniques utilizing incorporating and non-coordinating framework. These strategies are
turned out to be exceptionally productive however it has the danger of bringing about
disease [33]. There are couple of mistakes in use of iPSCs in people as the creature utilized
as an ailment testing model can't mimic human genetic cells and microenvironment
precisely. In addition, the delayed utilization of normal immunosuppressant drugs in
matured mice utilized for study causes dangerous symptoms to the mice which may modify
the pathology identified with AD. In this manner it influences the translations likewise [34,
35].
As there are different neuronal frameworks and neuro-phenotypes are influenced in AD, it
has gotten to be trying in making cell substitution approach. However, the study in mouse
model may give important useful advantages in undifferentiated cell treatment if approach
towards the exploration could be changed by utilizing AD transgenic model with inept
foundation yet such model has not been distributed yet [36]. Likewise, if stem cells gave
Intravenously may likewise block blood vessels. Numerous inquiries of fundamental science
stay's unanswered as what number of cell need to convey and where and how regularly.
Future Direction
Immunotherapy for AD
Active and Passive Immunization
With different hostile to Aβ systems (anti- Aβ strategies) being sought after, Aβ peptide has
turned into a noteworthy helpful target. By hindering the proteins in charge of Aβ
aggregates, these techniques keep off the development of Aβ totals, and expand the
clearance of Aβ from the cerebrum. The Aβ immunotherapy utilizes anti-Aβ antibodies,
produced immunization or presented inactively, which results in the clearance and averts
collection of Aβ [37]. Since, the primary dynamic Vaccine for AD, AN1792 was stopped in
2002 because of the development of meningoencephalitis in ~6% of the enlisted moderate-
to-serve AD patients, in the clinical trials [38], yet more proficient immunization
advancement looks into are going on and/or are in the phase I clinical trials.
While the pre-clinical studies on transgenic mice when treated with anti-Aβ monoclonal
antibodies, indicated helpful impacts with a noteworthy lessening in mind Aβ levels,
diminished cerebrum senile plaque pathology, and enhanced insight [39, 40].
Bapineuzumab and solanezumab developed as the two driving hopefuls following the
passive immunization route, among the anti-Aβ monoclonal antibodies, prompted their
watchful assessment in a few Phase III clinical trials [41, 42]. Shockingly, these vast clinical
trials have neglected to accomplish the anticipated results [43].
At present, no less than five other anti-Aβ monoclonal antibodies, with properties
particular from bapineuzumab and solanezumab, are in different phases of idevelopment
[44].
Nanotechnology for AD
Nano Carriers:
Since, the general treatment with medications have demonstrated no noteworthy impact on the
treatment of AD, the focused on medication conveyance is a critical part of the nano
prescription [45]. It is apparently confused for the section of the molecules in the Central
nervous system (CNS) tissues, against the Blood Brain Barrier (BBB) [46]. To encourage the
navigation of these helpful particles over the BBB is been broadly investigated in the previous
decade, by the utilization of biocompatible nanoparticles [47], for example, Curcumin, which
is the concoction operator and a dynamic element of Turmeric , the yellow flavor which has
been as of late found as a potential treatment for AD [48,49].
Conclusion and Discussion
In the review, we have discussed many current and future studies that examine the use of
stem cells, Immunotherapy and Nanoparticles to treat and model AD. A growing amount of
evidence suggests that the stem cell based therapies could prove beneficial in the treatment of
AD, by which stem cells not only has the potential to generate new neurons but also replace
damaged neurons. With further clarification, stem cell may well prove as a safe yet efficient
treatment in future for AD. Also, if the causes of AD are well understood and safer cell
therapies are developed, AD could be conquered in the not too distant future.
.
Author Contributions
Patel, Ankur P., Joshi, Grishma N and Ugile, Rupali P.; wrote the manuscript together.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
References
1. Aalten P., Verhey F.R., Boziki M., Brugnolo A., Bullock R., Byrne E.J., Camus V.,
Caputo M., Collins D., de Deyn P.P., et al. Consistency of neuropsychiatric syndromes
across dementias: Results
2. from the European Alzheimer Disease Consortium. Part II. Dement. Geriatr. Cogn.
Disord. 2008; 25:1–8. doi: 10.1159/000111082. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
Wesley W. Chen and Mathew Blurton- Johnes, Concise review- Can stem cell be used
to treat or model Alzheimer's Disease? [NIH] stem cells. 2012 December; 30(12): 2612-
2618.
do:10.1002/stem.1240.
3. World Health Organization and Alzheimer's disease International. Dementia: A Public
Health Priority. WHO Press; Geneva, Switzerland: 2012. p. 103. [Cross ref]
4. Selkoe DJ. Alzheimer's disease: Genes, proteins, and therapy. Physical. Rev.
2001;81:741-766 [PubMed]
5. Person T., Popescu B.O., Cedazo- Minguez A. Oxidative stress in Alzheimer's disease:
Why did antioxidant therapy fail? Ovid. Med. Cell Longev. 2014; 2014:427318. [PMC
free article] [PubMed] [Cross ref]
6. Demuro A., Smith M., Parker I. Single-channel Ca2+ imaging implicates AB 1-42
amyloid pores in Alzheimer's disease pathology. J.cell Biol. 2011; 195:515-524. [PMC
free article] [PubMed][Cross ref]
7. Kuhla, B.; Haase, C.; Flach, K.; Luth, H.J.; Arendt, T.; Munch, G. Effect of
pseudophosphorylation and cross-linking by lipid peroxidation and advanced glycation
end product precursors on tau
aggregation and filament formation. J. Biol. Chem.2007, 282, 6984–6991. [Google
Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
8. Iqbal, K.; Alonso, A.C.; Gong, C.X.; Khatoon, S.; Pei, J.J.; Wang, J.Z.; Grundke-Iqbal,
I. Mechanisms of neurofibrillary degeneration and the formation of neurofibrillary
tangles. J. Neural Transm.
Suppl.1998, 53, 169–180. [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
9. Alzheimer's disease Association (US) 2012 Alzheimer's disease facts and figures.
Washington, D.C: Alzheimer's association; 2012.
10. Bird T.D. Genetic aspects of Alzheimer disease. Genet. Med. 2008; 10:231–239. doi:
10.1097/GIM.0b013e31816b64dc. [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
11. Holtzman D.M., Morris J.C., Goate A.M. Alzheimer's disease: The challenge of the
second century. Sci. Transl. Med. 2011; 3 doi: 10.1126/scitranslmed.3002369. [PMC
free article] [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
12. Feldman H. Gracon S (1996) Alzheimer's disease: symptomatic drugs under
development. In: Clinical diagnosis and Management of Alzheimer's Disease
(GautheirS,ed), pp239-259. Martin Dunitz Ltd. London.
13. Whitehouse PJ, Price DL, Clark AW, Coyle JT, DeLong MR. Alzheimer disease:
evidence for selective loss of cholinergic neurons in the nucleus basalis. Ann Neurol
1981; 10:122–126.
[KOREAMED SYNAPSE REFID:B10] [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
14. Bartus RT, Dean RL 3rd, Beer B, Lippa AS. The cholinergic hypothesis of geriatric
memory dysfunction. Science 1982; 217:408–414. [KOREAMED SYNAPSE
REFID:B11] [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
15. Coyle JT, Price DL, DeLong MR. Alzheimer's disease: a disorder of cortical
cholinergic innervation. Science 1983; 219:1184–1190. [KOREAMED SYNAPSE
REFID:B12] [Pubmed] [Cross Ref]
16. Hook, V.; Toneff, T.; Bogyo, M; Greenbaum, D.; Medzihradzky, K.F.; Neveu, J.; Lane,
W.; Hook, G.; Reisine, T. Inhibition of cathepsin B reduces β-amyloid production in
regulated secretory vesicles of neuronal chromaffin cells. Evidence for cathepsin B as
a candidate β-secretase of Alzheimer's disease. Biol. Chem. 2005, 386,931-940.
17. Iwata N, Tsubuki S, Takaki Y, Watanabe K, Sekiguchi M, Hosoki E, Kawashima-
Morishima M, Lee HJ, Hama E, Sekine-Aizawa Y, Saido TC (2000) Identification of
the major Abeta1–42-degrading catabolic pathway in brain parenchyma: suppression
leads to biochemical and pathological deposition. Nat Med6:143–150.
18. Massound, F.; Leger, G.C. Pharmacological treatment of Alzhemier disease. Can. J.
Psychiatry 2011, 56,579-588.
19. Mangialasche F., Kivipelto M., Mecocci P., Rizzuto D., Palmer K., Winblad B.,
Fratiglioni L. High plasma levels of vitamin E forms and reduced Alzheimer's disease
risk in advanced age. J. Alzheimers Dis.2010; 20:1029–1037.
20. Persson T., Popescu B.O., Cedazo-Minguez A. Oxidative stress in Alzheimer's disease:
Why did antioxidant therapy fail? Oxid. Med. Cell Longev. 2014; 2014:427318.
21. Liu Y., Weick J.P., Liu H., Krencik R., Zhang X., Ma L., Zhou G.M., Ayala M., Zhang
S.C. Medial ganglionic eminence-like cells derived from human embryonic stem cells
correct learning and memory deficits. Nat. Biotechnol. 2013; 31:440–447. doi:
10.1038/nbt.2565.
22. Warrier S, Marimuthu R, Sekhar S, Bhuvanalakshmi G, Arfuso F, Das AK, Bhonde R,
Martins R, Dharmarajan A. sFRP-mediated Wnt sequestration as a potential therapeutic
target for Alzheimer's disease. Int J Biochem Cell Biol. 2016 Apr 7.pii: S1357-
2725(16)30080-2. doi: 10.1016/j.biocel.2016.04.002.PubMed PMID: 27063405.
23. Park, D; Yang, G.; Bae, D K.; Lee, S. H.; Yang, Y.H.;Kyung,J; Kim,D.; Choi, E. K.;
Choi, K. c.; Kim, S.U.; et al. Human adipose tissue derived mesenchymal stem cells
improve cognitive function and physical activity in ageing mice. J. Neurosci. Res. 2013,
91,966-670.
24. Sugaya K , Alvarez A , Marutle A, Kwak YD , Choumkina E; Stem cell strategies for
Alzheimer's disease therapy. PanminervaMedica [2006, 48(2):87-96]
25. Kim SU. 2004. Human neural stem cells genetically modified for brain repair in
neurological disorders. Neuropathology 24: 159–174.
26. Kristine Freude, Carlota Pires, [...], and Vanessa Jane Hall for Induced Pluripotent Stem
Cells Derived from Alzheimer's disease patients: The promise, the hope and the path
ahead. [Pubmed]
27. Amir M Hossini†,Matthias Megges†Alessandro Prigione,Bjoern Lichtner,Mohammad
R Toliat,Wasco Wruck,Friederike Schröter,Peter Nuernberg,Hartmut Kroll,Eugenia
Makrantonaki,Christos C Zoubouliss andJames Adjaye.Induced pluripotent stem
cell-derived neuronal cells from a sporadic Alzheimer's disease donor as a
model for investigating AD-associated gene regulatory networks.
28. Yagi T, Ito D, Okada Y, et al. modeling familial Alzheimer's disease with induced
pluripotent stem cells.HumMol Genet. 2011; 20:4530–4539. [PubMed]
29. Blennow K, de Leon MJ, Zetterberg H. Alzheimer's disease. Lancet. 2006;
368(9533):387–403.PubMed
30. Selkoe DJ. Alzheimer's disease: genes, proteins, and therapy. Physiol Rev. 2001;
81(2):741–66.PubMed
31. Nakamura M., Tsuji O., Nori S., Toyama Y., Okano H. Cell transplantation for spinal
cord injury focusing on iPSCs. Expert Opinion on Biological Therapy. 2012;
12(7):811–821. doi: 10.1517/14712598.2012.681774.
32. Israel MA, Yuan SH, Bardy C, Reyna SM, Mu Y, Herrera C, et al. Probing sporadic
and familial Alzheimer's disease using induced pluripotent stem cells. Nature. 2012;
482(7384):216–20.PubMed CentralPubMed
33. Yoshiyama Y, Higuchi M, Zhang B, et al. Synapse loss and microglial activation
precede tangles in a P301S tauopathy mouse model. Neuron. 2007; 53:337–
351. [PubMed]
34. Mollison KW, Fey TA, Krause RA, et al. Nephrotoxicity studies of the immune
suppressants tacrolimus (FK506) and ascomycin in rat models. Toxicology. 1998;
125:169–181. [PubMed]
35. Hurdles in the development of a stem cell-based approach to treat AD from Concise
Review: Can Stem Cells be used to Treat or Model Alzheimer Disease?
36. Oakley H, Cole SL, Logan S, et al. Intraneuronal beta-amyloid aggregates,
neurodegeneration, and neuron loss in transgenic mice with five familial Alzheimer's
disease mutations: potential factors in amyloid plaque formation. J Neurosci. 2006;
26:10129–10140. [PubMed]
37. Cynthia A. Lemere and EliezerMasliah Nat Rev Neurol. 2010 February; 6(2): 108–119.
doi:10.1038/nrneurol.2009.219, [Cross Ref] [NCBI]
38. Gilman S, Koller M, Black RS, Jenkins L, Griffith SG, Fox NC, Eisner L, Kirby L,
BoadaRovira M, Forette F, Orgogozo J-M: Clinical effects of Aβ immunization
(AN1792) in patients with AD in an interrupted trial. Neurology. 2005, 64: 1553-1562.
10.1212/01.WNL.0000159740.16984.3C.
39. Bard F, Cannon C, Barbour R, et al. Peripherally administered antibodies against
amyloid β-peptide enter the central nervous system and reduce pathology in a mouse
model of Alzheimer disease. Nat Med 2000; 6:916–919. [Cross Ref.].
40. Morgan D. Mechanisms of A beta plaque clearance following passive Abeta
immunization. Neurodegener Dis 2005; 2:261–266. [Cross ref].
41. Panza F, Frisardi V, Imbimbo BP, et al. Antib-amyloid immunotherapy for Alzheimer's
disease: focus on bapineuzumab. Curr Alzheimer Res 2011; 8:808–817. [Cross Ref.]
42. Imbimbo BP, Ottonello S, Frisardi V, et al. Solanezumab for the treatment of mild-to-
moderate Alzheimer's disease. Expert Rev ClinImmunol 2012; 8:135–149. [Cross Ref.]
43. Tayeb HO, Murray ED, Price BH, Tarazi FI. Bapineuzumab and solanezumab for
Alzheimer's disease: is the
'amyloid cascade hypothesis' still alive? Expert
OpinBiolTher 2013; 13:1075–1084. [Cross Ref.]
44. Francesco Panza; Giancarlo Logroscino; Bruno P. Imbimbo; Vincenzo Solfrizzid for Is
there still hope for Amyloid based immunotherapy for Alzheimer's Disease? CurrOpin
Psychiatry.2014; 27(2):128-137.
45. Rawat M, Singh D, Saraf S, Saraf S. Nanocarriers: promising vehicle for bioactive
drugs. Biol Pharm Bull 2006; 29(9):1790-80. [Cross Ref.]
46. Wang J, Valmikinathan CM, Yu X. Nanostructures for bypassing blood brain barrier.
Current Bioactive Compounds 2009; 5(3):195-205.
47. BlasiP, GiovagnoliS, SchoubbenA, RicciM, RossiC. Solid lipid nanoparticles for
targeted brain drug delivery. Adv Drug Deliv Rev 2007; 59(6):454-77.
48. YangF, LimGP, BegumAN, UbedaOJ, SimmonsMR, AmbegaokarSS, et al.
Curcumininhibits formation of amyloid beta oligomers and fibrils, binds plaques, and
reduces amyloid in vivo. J, BiolChem 2005; 280[7], 5892-5901.
49. Amir Nazem,G.AliMansoori for Nanotechnology for Alzheimer's disease detection and
treatment. UIC, 851 S Morgan St. (M/C 063), Chicago, IL 60607-7052, USA.
|
1607.04886 | 2 | 1607 | 2017-04-03T04:13:42 | Neural scaling laws for an uncertain world | [
"q-bio.NC",
"physics.bio-ph"
] | Autonomous neural systems must efficiently process information in a wide range of novel environments, which may have very different statistical properties. We consider the problem of how to optimally distribute receptors along a one-dimensional continuum consistent with the following design principles. First, neural representations of the world should obey a neural uncertainty principle---making as few assumptions as possible about the statistical structure of the world. Second, neural representations should convey, as much as possible, equivalent information about environments with different statistics. The results of these arguments resemble the structure of the visual system and provide a natural explanation of the behavioral Weber-Fechner law, a foundational result in psychology. Because the derivation is extremely general, this suggests that similar scaling relationships should be observed not only in sensory continua, but also in neural representations of ``cognitive' one-dimensional quantities such as time or numerosity. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Neural scaling laws for an uncertain world
Marc W. Howard and Karthik H. Shankar
Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, Center for Memory and Brain, Initiative
for Physics and Mathematics of Neural Systems, Boston University
Abstract
Autonomous neural systems must efficiently process information in a wide
range of novel environments, which may have very different statistical prop-
erties. We consider the problem of how to optimally distribute receptors
along a one-dimensional continuum consistent with the following design prin-
ciples. First, neural representations of the world should obey a neural un-
certainty principle -- making as few assumptions as possible about the statis-
tical structure of the world. Second, neural representations should convey,
as much as possible, equivalent information about environments with differ-
ent statistics. The results of these arguments resemble the structure of the
visual system and provide a natural explanation of the behavioral Weber-
Fechner law, a foundational result in psychology. Because the derivation is
extremely general, this suggests that similar scaling relationships should be
observed not only in sensory continua, but also in neural representations of
"cognitive' one-dimensional quantities such as time or numerosity.
The adapatability of mammals, humans in particular, to many novel environments
has been one of the keys to our evolutionary success. This flexibility is made possible, among
other things, by the ability of the sensory systems to represent information efficiently in
a wide range of circumstances. For instance, consider the differing demands on the visual
system in a desert, or a dense forest, or an office environment (Torralba & Oliva, 2003).
One evolutionary strategy would be to adapt the properties of the sensors to a particular
environment, or a particular stimulus. The "fly detectors" in the frog's brain described by
Maturana and colleagues provides an early example of this reasoning (Lettvin, Maturana,
McCulloch, & Pitts, 1959; Maturana, Lettvin, McCulloch, & Pitts, 1960). However, if the
efficiency of the visual system depended critically on the statistics of a particular visual
environment, it would leave the organism at a disadvantage if it moved to a different envi-
ronment, or if the environment changed. Of course, these considerations do not only apply
to vision; analogous arguments can be made for other sensory modalities and even neural
representation of more abstract quantities, such as time or numerosity. This suggests a
We acknowledge helpful discussions with Eric Schwartz, Haim Sompolinsky, Kamal Sen, Xuexin Wei,
and Michele Rucci. This work was supported by BU's Initiative for the Physics and Mathematics of Neural
Systems, NSF PHY 1444389, CRCNS NIMH R01MH112169, and NIBIB R01EB022864.
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
2
a
b
Figure 1. a. Weber-Fechner law can be generated from receptive fields that are of equal width and
density as a function of log x. This results in receptive fields that increase in width and decrease in
density as a function of x. The increase in receptive field width should go up linearly with x; the
density should go down like 1/x. The spacing of adjacent receptors should be a constant ratio for
all values of x. b. Width of visual receptive fields as a function of eccentricity in three regions of
macaque visual cortex. The "fovea" can be seen as a region of constant spacing (flat line) near an
eccentricity of zero. There is a linear relationship outside of the fovea for all three regions. Figure
taken from Freeman & Simoncelli (2011) who performed a metaanalysis on empirical studies cited
therein.
design principle for the brain: the structure of neural representations should make as few
assumptions as possible about the statistical structure of the world, which one might call a
neural uncertainty principle, and convey, as much as possible equivalent information about
environments with different statistics, which one might call a neural equanimity principle.
We will argue in this paper that the Weber-Fechner law (Fechner, 1860/1912), the
observation that the change in the perceptual magnitude of many one-dimensional quan-
tities1 depends on the relative, rather than absolute change in the physical quantity, can
be understood as a behavioral manifestation of these design principles. The psychological
scales of physical dimensions x obeying the Weber-Fechner law are logarithmic. In the brain
some external scalar quantities, such as weight and luminance, may be expressed simply as
the intensity of the response of a single receptor. This paper is concerned with variables,
such as extrafoveal retinal position, that are expressed by a distributed pattern of firing
across a set of receptors (which Stevens, 1957 referred to as metathetic variables). Each
receptor is associated with a receptive field, which describes the response of the receptor
to a constant stimulus with a particular value x. Each receptor responds to stimuli in a
circumscribed range of values of x; the array of all receptors can thus represent functions
over x, f (x) (Ma, Beck, Latham, & Pouget, 2006). In this paper we study how to optimally
distribute receptors in order to represent arbitrary unknown functions in the world. Before
formalizing this problem, we make some simple mathematical observations about logarith-
mic scaling of receptors and then briefly review the evidence that the visual system does
(and does not) utilize this form of neural scaling.
1The Weber-Fechner law does not apply to circular variables, such as head direction or orientation.
012345670.00.6log(x)Firing rate020040060080010000.00.6xFiring rateFigure 1.Physiological measurements of receptive field size in macaque. (a) Receptive field size(diameter) as a function of receptive field center (eccentricity) for visual areas V1, V2, andV4. Data adapted from Gattass et al. (1981) and Gattass et al. (1988), the only studies tomeasure receptive fields in all three macaque ventral stream areas with comparable methods.The size-to-eccentricity relationship in each area is well described by a "hinged" line (seeSupplementary Methods for details and an analysis of a larger set of ten physiological datasets). (b) Cartoon depiction of receptive fields with sizes based on physiologicalmeasurements. The center of each array is the fovea. The size of each circle is proportionalto its eccentricity, based on the corresponding scaling parameter (slope of the fitted line inFreeman and SimoncelliPage 16Nat Neurosci. Author manuscript; available in PMC 2012 March 1.HHMI Author ManuscriptHHMI Author ManuscriptHHMI Author Manuscript NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
3
Logarithmic neural scales
Receptive fields that are evenly-spaced and of equal width on a logarithmic scale
(Fig. 1a, top) lead naturally to the Weber-Fechner perceptual law. A logarithmic scale
implies several properties of the receptive fields (Fig. 1a bottom). A logarithmic scale implies
that there should be fewer receptive fields centered at high values of x, and receptors coding
for higher values of x should have wider receptive fields. These qualitative impressions can
be refined to several quantitatively precise relationships. If the receptive fields are evenly-
spaced on a logarithmic axis then the width of receptive fields centered on a value x should
go up proportional to x. More generally, if the ith receptor has a receptive field centered
on xi, then the shape of the receptive field should be constant for all receptors, but the
width of the receptive field should scale with the value of xi. If we denote the center of the
ith cells receptive field as xi and define ∆i ≡ xi − xi−1, then a logarithmic scale implies
that the ratio of adjacent receptors, ∆i+i/∆i, is a constant for all values of i.2 Finally we
note that because log 0 is not finite, a logarithmic scale with a finite number of receptors
cannot continue to x = 0. In practice, this means that if the brain makes use of logarithmic
scales, there must be some other consideration for values near zero. In fact, as we will see
below, the brain appears to solve this problem in the visual system by including a region
of approximately constant receptor spacing for small x (note the flat region around zero in
Fig. 1b).
Logarithmic neural scales in the mammalian brain
There is strong evidence that the visual system in mammals obeys logarithmic scaling
in representing extrafoveal retinal position. In monkeys, both the spacing of receptive fields
(the cortical magnification factor) (Daniel & Whitteridge, 1961; Hubel & Wiesel, 1974;
Van Essen, Newsome, & Maunsell, 1984; Gattass, Sousa, & Gross, 1988) and the width
of receptive fields (Hubel & Wiesel, 1974; Gattass et al., 1988; Schwartz, 1977) obey the
quantitative relationships specified by logarithmic scaling to a good degree of approximation
outside of the fovea. Figure 1b (reproduced from Freeman & Simoncelli, 2011) shows
receptive field width in the macaque across several cortical regions. The fovea is visible as
a region of constant receptive field width, followed by a much larger region showing a linear
relationship between field width and eccentricity, consistent with logarithmic scaling. If the
curves obeyed logarithmic scaling precisely, the lines would continue to the origin rather
than flattening out in the fovea. However, because the spacing between receptors would go
to zero, this would require an infinite number of receptors.
In the case of vision, logarithmic scaling can ultimately be attributed to the distribu-
tions of receptors along the surface of the retina. However, this logarithmic mapping may
be more general, extending to other sensory (Merzenich, Knight, & Roth, 1973) and motor
maps (Schwartz, 1977). In addition, evidence suggests that logarithmic scaling holds for
variables that are not associated with any sensory organ. Neural evidence from monkeys
and humans (Nieder & Miller, 2003; Harvey, Klein, Petridou, & Dumoulin, 2013) suggests
2Note that while logarithmic scaling implies a constant ratio of adjacent receptor spacings, the converse
is not true. For instance, if the ratio of receptor spacings was one, this would not lead to logarithmic scaling.
Similarly, if we took a set of receptors on a logarithmic scale and added a constant to each one, the ratio
∆i+1/∆i would be unchanged and remain constant with respect to i whereas xi+1/xi would no longer be
constant with respect to i.
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
4
that neural representations of non-verbal numerosity are arranged on a logarithmic scale,
consistent with a broad range of behavioral studies of non-verbal mathematical cognition
(Gallistel & Gelman, 1992; Feigenson, Dehaene, & Spelke, 2004). Behavioral and theoret-
ical work (Balsam & Gallistel, 2009; Howard, Shankar, Aue, & Criss, 2015) suggests that
a similar form of logarithmic scaling could also apply to representations of time, which is
qualitatively consistent with growing body of neurophysiological evidence from "time cells"
in the hippocampus, entorhinal cortex, and striatum (Salz et al., 2016; Kraus et al., 2015;
Mello, Soares, & Paton, 2015). The neurophysiological evidence that these "cognitive"
variables use logarithmic scaling is not nearly as well-quantified as visual receptive fields.
Overview
If a set of receptors was optimized under the expectation of a particular form of statis-
tics in the world, it would be suboptimal, perhaps disastrous, if the organism encountered a
state of the world with very different statistics. The next section ("Optimal receptor distri-
bution. . . ") considers the problem of optimally placing receptors to represent an unknown
arbitrary function from a local perspective. The result of this section is that for all receptors
to convey the same amount of information as their neighbors, receptor spacings should be
in a constant ratio. The following section ("Global function representation") considers the
amount of information conveyed by a set of receptors about a function controlled by some
fixed, but unknown, scale. The global organization that leads to equivalent information for
a wide range of scales has a region of constant spacing (ratio 1) followed by a region with
constant ratio spacing (ratio > 1) which resembles the organization of the visual system
with a closely-packed fovea surrounded by a logarithmic scale.
Optimal receptor distribution for representing arbitrary unknown
functions
We want to represent a function in the world over some continuous real value x.
Receptors sample the function in some neighborhood such that each receptor is "centered"
on a particular value of x. The goal is to distribute the receptors to enable them to represent
an arbitrary and unknown function f (x). In order for this problem to be meaningful we
must assume that there is a finite number of receptors. We assume here that the lower and
upper bounds of the scale x are physically constrained. At the lower bound, perhaps there
is some minimal degree of resolution that can be achieved with the receptors. In some cases
the upper bound may be given by the properties of the world or anatomy. For instance,
in vision, ecccentricity cannot possibly be larger than π. Our question, then is how to
distribute the location of the receptors within the range of x values to be represented.
Each additional receptor provides an additional benefit to the organism to the extent
that it provides additional information about the function. Intuitively, if we clumped all
of the receptors close together this would be suboptimal, because the receptors would all
be conveying the same information and there would be no receptors to communicate infor-
mation about other regions of the function. Naively, we might expect that the solution is
trivial -- perhaps receptors should be evenly-spaced along the x-axis. It will turn out that
this is not in general the optimal solution. Rather, the spacing of each pair of receptors
should be in a constant ratio to the spacing of the previous pair of receptors. Constant
spacing corresponds to a ratio of 1; it will turn out that other ratios are admissable as well.
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
5
a
b
Figure 2. a. Discretizing the function. After picking some small resolution ("jnd" in the figure),
we discretize the signal. This defines a variable s(x) describing the distance (or scale) between x
and the next location where the function takes on a different discretized value. b. Schematic for
notation. The derivation assumes that there are receptors at xi−1 and xi separated by ∆i. The
goal is to choose ∆i+1 (and thus xi+1) such that the redundancy between the pairs of receptors is
equated.
In order to do the calculation we need to measure the redundancy between a pair of
receptors. There are a number of measures of redundancy one might use. For instance, we
might measure the mutual information between the output of two receptors after observing
the world for some period of time. There are other measures that one might use. All
things equal, we would expect the redundancy between two receptors to be higher for
receptors that are placed close together rather than receptors that are placed far apart. The
development below applies to any measure of redundancy that obeys some basic properties.3
The distribution of receptors is optimal if each receptor is expected to be as redundant with
its predecessor as it is with its successor. If that was not the case, then we could move one
of the receptors and get more non-redundant information out about the function.
Formulation of the problem
Suppose we have set of receptors with receptive fields centered on positions x1, x2,
. . . xN . As before, let us denote the distance between the locations of receptor xi−1 and xi
as ∆i. Constant receptor spacing would imply that ∆i = ∆i+1 for all i. It will turn out
that this is not the general solution to our problem. Rather, the solution is to space the
receptors such that the ratio of adjacent receptor spacings is a constant across the scale.
That is, the ratio ∆i+1/∆i takes the same value for all i.
3After the general derivation we include a worked example with a particularly tractable measure of
redundancy.
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
6
We assume that in the neighborhood of each xi, the function is controlled by some
scale sxi. To quantify this in an unambiguous way, assume that our receptors can only
respond over a finite range with some non-zero resolution. Accordingly, we discretize the
function to be represented to some degree of resolution (Figure 2a) so that at each value
of x, sx gives the distance to the next value of x where the discretized function would take
a different value than the discretized f (x). That is, for each x, the discretized function
f (x) = f (x(cid:48)) for each x < x(cid:48) < x + sx.
Note that if we knew the scale sxi at xi, it would be straightforward to estimate
the redundancy between the receptor at xi and the receptor at xi+1. If we knew that the
spacing between receptors ∆i+1 were much smaller than sxi, the receptors would measure
the same value and we would expect the redundancy to be high. In contrast, if we knew
that the spacing between the receptors were much smaller than sxi then the value of the
function would have changed at least once between xi and xi+1 and we would expect the
redundancy to be low. Let us denote the function relating the redundancy we would observe
between receptors spaced by a particular value ∆i if we knew the scale took a particular
value s as α(s; ∆i). We assume α(s; ∆i) to be a monotonically decreasing function of its
argument. Note that we could choose any number of different ways to measure redundancy.
For instance, we could treat mutual information as our measure of redundancy and this,
coupled with knowledge of the properties of the receptors, would specify a specific form
for α(s; ∆i). But we could just as well measure redundancy in other ways or assume
different properties of our receptors, which would result in a different form for α(s; ∆i).
The arguments below about optimal receptor spacing apply to any measure of redundancy
that obeys some basic properties described below and does not depend critically on how
one chooses to measure redundancy.
Observing the redundancy between the receptors at xi−1 and xi spaced by ∆i allows
us to infer the value of the scale at the first receptor sxi−1. For instance, if the redundancy
is maximal, that implies that the function did not change between xi−1 and xi. In contrast,
if the redundancy between the receptors at xi−1 and xi is very small, that implies that the
scale of the function at xi−1, sxi−1 was smaller than ∆i. Knowing the scale at xi−1 places
constraints on the value at xi. For instance, if we knew with certainty that sxi−1 = ∆i + C,
then we would know with certainty that sxi = C. So, if we knew the probability of each
value of sxi−1 this constrains the probability distribution for sxi.
Let us fix the spacing ∆i between the receptors at xi−1 and xi, sample the world
for some time (observing many values of the the receptor outputs in response to many
samples from the function) and denote the average value of redundancy we observe as αobs.
Denoting the (unknown) probability of observing each possible value of sxi−1 as pi−1 (s),
then the observed value of redundancy, αobs, resulted from an integral:
(cid:90)
αobs =
pi−1 (s) α(s; ∆i) ds
(1)
This can be understood as an inference problem; observation of αobs leads us to some
belief about the distribution pi−1 (s). Informed by this knowledge, we then place the third
receptor at a spacing ∆i+1. If we knew the distribution of scales at xi, pi (s), then we would
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
7
expect to observe a redundancy of
αpred =
(cid:90)
pi (s) α(s; ∆i+1) ds
(2)
between the second pair of receptors. Our problem is to choose ∆i+1 such that we would
expect αpred = αobs.
Minimal assumptions about the statistical properties of the world
The actual value of ∆i+1 that makes αpred = αobs of course depends on the detailed
properties of the receptors, the function α(s; ∆) and the statistics of the world. We show,
however, that for minimal assumptions about the world, this problem results in the solution
that, whatever the value of αobs one finds that for some spacing ∆i, the choice of ∆i+1 is
such that only ∆i+1/∆i is affected by the observed value αobs.
First, we make minimal assumptions about the function to be estimated. We assume
an uninformative prior for pi−1 (s). We make the minimal assumptions that successive
values of s are independent, and that the value of the function past the sx is independent of
the value at x. That is we assume that f (x) and f (x + sx) are independent of one another,
as are sx and sx+sx. 4
Second, we require that the receptors do not introduce a scale via α(s; ∆). In general,
the function α(s; ∆) will depend on how we choose to quantify redundancy and the prop-
erties of the receptors. However, as long as α(s; ∆) rescales, such that it can be rewritten
in a canonical form
α(s; ∆) = α(s/∆),
(3)
the conclusions in this section will hold. One can readily imagine idealized settings where
Eq. 3 will hold. For instance, we could assume we have perfect receptors that sample the
function at only one point and take our measure of redundancy to be one if the receptors
observe the same value up to the resolution used to specify s (Fig. 2b) and zero otherwise.
More generally, for imperfect receptors that sample a range of values, Eq. 3 requires that
the receptive fields scale up with ∆. This assumption is necessary, but not sufficient to
equate redundancy between receptors.
Our third requirement is referred to as the Copernican principle. Because it is critical
to the argument in this section, we discuss it in some detail in the next subsection.
The Copernican Principle
In addition to minimal assumptions about the statistics of the world and the proper-
ties of the receptors, we assume that the world's choice of sxi−1 is unaffected by our choice of
∆i. The belief that there is nothing privileged about one's point of observation is referred
to as the Copernican principle. The Copernican principle was employed by Gott (1993)
to estimate a probability distribution for the duration of human civilization. Because this
4The critical point of these assumptions is that at no point to we introduce an assumption about the
statistics of the world that would fix a scale for our receptors. For instance, the result of receptor spacings
in a constant ratio would also hold if we assumed a power law prior for pi−1 (s) rather than a uniform prior
because the power law is a scale-free distribution. Similarly, it is acceptable to relax the assumption of
independence between f (x) and f (x + sx) as long as doing so does not introduce a scale.
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
8
provides a concrete illustration of an important concept, it is worth explaining Gott's logic
in some detail.
Suppose we observe Fenway Park in 2017 and learn it has been standing for 103
years. Knowing nothing about construction techniques or the economics of baseball we
want to estimate how much longer Fenway Park will stand. Because there is nothing
special about our current viewpoint in 2017, our observation of Fenway should be uniformly
distributed across its lifetime. That is, the observation at tnow in 2017 ought to be uniformly
distributed between tstart when Fenway Park was constructed (in 1914) and the unknown
time of its destruction tend. Gott argued that we should expect tnow to be uniformly
distributed between tstart and tend, such that we should expect tend − tnow to be longer than
tnow − tstart half the time. This means that the age of the structure (102 years) fixes the
units of the distribution of tend − tstart. If we observed an object that has been existing for
1030 years, or for 103 seconds, then our inference about its expected duration would have
the same shape, but only differ in the choice of units.
The Copernican argument also applies to our inference problem. Here the scale at the
first receptor sxi−1 plays a role analogous to the duration of the object tend − tstart. Suppose
that we have a set of receptors with a known function α(s; ∆) that obeys Eq. 3 and we
encounter a world with some unknown statistics. In this first world we choose some ∆i,
observe some measure of redundancy αobs, use some method of inference to estimate pi−1 (s)
and pi (s) and then select the value of ∆i+1 to yield the expectation that αpred = αobs. Let
us refer to the distribution of pi (s) that we inferred from fixing ∆i to its particular value and
observing αobs as pα (s; ∆i). Now, suppose that we encounter another world with the same
receptors. Assume further that we choose a different ∆i but observe the same value of αobs.
How should our inference about the distribution of sxi be related to our inference from the
first world? If Eq. 3 holds, the Copernican Principle requires that all of the distributions
that can be inferred for a particular value of αobs must be related to one another via a
canonical form:
pα (s; ∆i) =
1
∆i
pα(s/∆i).
(4)
If Equation 4 did not hold, it would imply that we can infer something about the world's
choice of sxi from our choice of ∆i+1 beyond that communicated by the value of αobs. As
long as the receptors and our measure of redundancy scale with ∆i as in Eq. 3 then any such
effect would imply that the world's choice of s and our choice of ∆i are not independent
and thus violate the Copernican Principle.
Ratio scaling results from minimal assumptions about the statistics of the world and the
Copernican Principle
Equations 3 and 4 imply that redundancy is equated for receptor spacings in some
ratio. To see this, let us rewrite Eq. 2 and find
(cid:90) ∞
(cid:90) ∞
1
∆i
0
αpred(∆i+1) =
=
pα (s/∆i) α(∆i+1/s) ds
0
pα(s(cid:48)) α(r/s(cid:48)) ds(cid:48)
(5)
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
9
In the second line s(cid:48) ≡ s/∆i and we define the ratio r ≡ ∆i+1/∆i. The right hand side of
Equation 5 clearly does not depend on ∆i+1 directly, but only on the ratio.
The finding, then, is that a principle of minimal assumptions about the statistics of
the world coupled with the Copernican Principle implies that the optimal distribution of
receptor locations is such that the ratio of successive receptor spacings is constant. Loga-
rithmic neural scales also imply that the ratio of successive receptor spacings are constant.
In this sense, logarithmic scales can be understood as a response to the demand that the
receptor layout are expected to equalize redundancy across receptors in a world with un-
known statistics. Because logarithmic scales do not uniquely predict constant ratio spacing
this cannot be the entire story. We pursue additional constraints that imply logarithmic
scales, with some important exceptions when x approaches zero, in the next section. Before
that, for concreteness we include a worked example for a idealized set of receptors and a
specific choice for α(s; ∆).
A worked example
The general development above provides a set of conditions that result in a constant
ratio of spacing between receptors. In order to make this more concrete, we work out a
specific example with specific choices for the properties of the receptors, the measure of
redundancy and the method of inference.
This example assumes that the receptors are perfect and the ith receptor samples the
function only at the location xi. For simplicity we define a measure of redundancy that
gives α = 1 if the two receptors observe the same value of f and α = 0 otherwise. This lets
us write out
(cid:40)
α(s; ∆i) =
1,
0,
if ∆i < sxi−1
if ∆i ≥ sxi−1
The same holds for α(s; ∆i+1), only comparing ∆i+1 to sxi. With our simplified definition
of redundancy, any value of αobs that is not zero or one must have resulted from a mixture
of those two cases with probability αobs and 1 − αobs respectively. Let us first consider the
case where ∆i < sxi−1, as it aligns perfectly with the Gott argument.
If sxi−1 > ∆i, then sxi−1 plays the role of the unknown duration of the lifetime of an
object such as Fenway Park, tend − tstart. The difference between the two receptors ∆i plays
the role of the time of the current observation tnow−tstart and the unknown sxi+1 is analogous
to tend − tnow. Gott's calculation defines the ratio r = (tend − tnow) / (tnow − tstart). The
Copernican Principle leads to the belief that tnow ought to be uniformly distributed between
tstart and tend. Thus the cumulative distribution of r obeys:
P (r > Y ) =
1
1 + Y
(6)
Note that the elapsed duration tnow − tstart only enters this expression via the ratio.
Similar arguments apply to the spacing of receptors. If we observe αobs = 1, then the
posterior pi (s) is controlled by Eq. 6, with ∆i in place of tnow − tstart and ∆i+1 in place
of tend − tnow.5 In this toy problem, the value of αpred is given by Eq. 6 if αobs = 1. If
5That is, Eq. 6 gives the cumulative of the posterior distribution.
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
10
instead of αobs = 1, we observed αobs = 0, we would infer a uniform distribution of s(xi).6
If our prior on the distribution of sxi is uniform, then αpred will be one for any finite value
of ∆i+1.
After sampling the world for some period of time, if we observe αobs as a number
between zero and one, then our posterior distribution of scales should be a mixture of the
inference from the two cases and simplify Eq. 2 as:
1
+ (1 − αobs)
1 + ∆i+1/∆i
αpred(∆i+1) = αobs
(7)
It is clear that the right hand side is only a function of the ratio r ≡ ∆i+1/∆i so that the
value of ∆i+1 that makes αpred = αobs depends only on the ratio.7 For any value of αobs,
the same value of r satisfies this equation for any choice of ∆i.
In this simple problem
we see that the choice of ∆i can only affect the answer by fixing its units. This naturally
results in the ratio of adjacent receptor spacings being constant, as implied by logarithmic
receptor scales.
Global function representation
The foregoing analysis conducted at the level of pairs of receptors showed that the
optimal spacing in order to represent arbitrary functions places the receptors in constant
ratio, but does not specify the value of the ratio. It is convenient to parameterize the ratio
between adjacent receptors by a parameter c such that r ≡ ∆i+1
= 1 + c. If c = 0, receptor
spacing is constant; if c > 0 the ratio is constant, as in a logarithmic scale. We consider the
global coding properties of these two schemes as well as a hybrid scheme in which the first
part of the axis has constant spacing (c = 0) followed by a region with logarithmic spacing
(c > 0), analogous to the organization of the visual system, with the region of constant
spacing corresponding roughly to the fovea (Fig. 1b).
∆i
Formulating the problem
For simplicity, we assume that each receptor perfectly samples the value of a function
in the world at a single perfectly-specified location and consider a simple class of functions
fs(x), which consist of independently chosen values over the range 0 to 1 at a spacing of
s such that fs(x) and fs(x + s) are independent and fs(x) and fs(x + s − ) are identical
for < s. The information about a function contained in a given range by a particular
instantiation of the function is just the number of entries specifying the values of the function
over that range. Note that s controls the density of information conveyed by fs over a given
range of x. We assume that fs(x) is specified over the entire range of x from zero to infinity
so that the total amount of information that could be extracted from a function is infinite
for every finite scale. Figure 3 shows several functions and choices of receptor scaling in
cartoon form.
A set of receptors can do a "good" job in representing a function fs(x) as long as the
spacing between the receptors is less than or equal to s. With the simplifying assumptions
6One can argue for other ways to make the inference in this toy problem when αobs = 0. As long as those
depend only on the ratio ∆i+1/∆i and not explictly on ∆i+1, the conditions of the general argument still
hold.
7In this simple example there is a solution for values of αobs > 1/2.
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
11
a
c
b
d
Figure 3. Cartoon illustrating the interaction of receptor spacing and function scale.
In each panel, the top curve shows a specific function fs(x); the functions in the four panels differ
only in their scale s. On the bottom of each panel, the vertical lines display receptor locations. a-b.
Constant spacing. When c = 0, the receptors are evenly-spaced, fixing a scale to the receptors. If
the function has the same scale as the receptors, as in a, each receptor captures a different value of
the function, the veridical region runs the entire length of the receptor array and the information
transmitted is maximal. However, if the scale of the function is larger than the constant spacing, as
in b, the array of receptors conveys less information because there is less information in the function
over that range. c-d. Ratio spacing. When c > 0, the receptors can extend over a much wider
range of x values than with constant spacing. The receptors carry information about the function
over a veridical region where ∆i < s; the border of the veridical regions is shown (in cartoon form)
as a vertical red line. As s increases (from c to d), the size of the veridical region in x changes,
but as long as the border is covered by the receptors, the amount of nonredundant information in
the veridical region is constant as a function of s. This property does not hold if the scale of the
function approaches the minimum receptor spacing.
used here, each of the non-redundant values of the function is captured by at least one
receptor allowing reconstruction of the function with error in the x location no worse than
s. More generally, even with coarse-graining and noisy receptors it is clear that there is
a qualitative difference between the ability of the receptors to measure the function when
∆ < s compared to when ∆ > s. Let us define the veridical region of the function as the
range of x over which ∆i < s. We also assume there is some minimum possible receptor
spacing ∆min. We measure the amount of veridical information I conveyed by the set of
receptors as the number of unique function values that the function has within the veridical
region.
Constant receptor spacing, c = 0
First, consider the implications of constant receptor spacing. If we knew the value
of s controlling fs(x), placing our receptors with constant separation ∆ = s would be
sufficient to convey all of the information in the function over the entire range of x values
covered by the receptors. N receptors would be able to accurately represent the function
over a veridical region of width N ∆ and the amount of information conveyed about the
function in that region is just N . However, our constant choice of spacing would have poor
consequences if our choice of ∆ did not correspond to the world's choice of s. If s > ∆,
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
12
Figure 4.
Information in the veridical region as a function of scale for three forms of
receptor spacing. The curve labeled c = 0 shows the results for constant spacing. This falls off
rapidly for scales larger than the scale set by the receptor spacing. Solid curves show results for
ratio spacing (c > 0) with a fovea; dashed curves show results for ratio spacing without a fovea.
N = 100 for all curves. See Figure 5a for an intuitive explanation of why the information decreases
for small values of s. The fovea has an additional 1/c receptors. Note that there is a region where
the amount of information conveyed is approximately constant as a function of scale before falling
off as the veridical region exhausts the number of receptors N . For c = .05, this region is off the
scale of this figure. Note also the error at small scales for c > 0 without a fovea.
the veridical region is still of length N ∆, but the amount of information contained in that
region is only N ∆
s , decreasing dramatically as s increases (curve labeled c = 0 in Figure 4).
With constant spacing, c = 0, the amount of information conveyed by the receptors depends
dramatically on s.
Constant receptor spacing ratio, c > 0
If we set c > 0 such that all receptors are placed in constant ratio the responsiveness
to functions of different scales is very different. Let us place the zeroth receptor x0 at xf ,
and the first receptor at x1 = xf + ∆min. Continuing with ∆i = (1 + c) ∆i−1, we find that
the spacing of the ith receptor is given by
The position of the ith receptor is thus given by the geometric series
(cid:104)
(cid:105)
∆i = ∆min (1 + c)i−1
xi = xf +
∆min
c
(1 + c)i − 1
(8)
(9)
c = 0.05c = 0c = 0.03020406080100020406080100s(scaleoftherepresentedfunction)VeridicalInformationrepresented NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
13
Equations 8 and 9 show that when c > 0 the range of x values and scales that can be
represented with N receptors goes up exponentially like (1 + c)N . For a function of scale s,
the set of ratio-scaled receptors has a veridical region ranging from xf to
c − ∆min
c + xf
s ≤ ∆N
s > ∆N
(10)
The amount of information present in the function in the veridical region is just (xs−xf )/s,
which is given by
xs =
xN
s 1+c
1+c
Ic>0 =
s ≤ ∆N
c − ∆min
xN−xf
sc
s
s > ∆N
(11)
The second expression, which happens when s is larger than the largest spacing among the
set of receptors, is closely analogous to the case with constant spacing (c = 0), decreasing
like s−1. However, the first expression with s ≤ ∆N includes a term (1 + c)/c which is
independent of s. The second term is small when s is large, so that for large values of s the
information conveyed is approximately constant. However, when s is small the second term
is substantial and constant ratio spacing (c > 0) fails to convey much information about
the function in the veridical region. When s = ∆min the veridical region includes only one
value of the function (see Figure 5a). The dashed line in Figure 4 shows the analytic result
when c > 0 and is constant across all receptors.
A "fovea" surrounded by a logarithmic scale
Note that if the ∆min
sc
term in Eq. 11 were canceled out, the amount of information
in the veridical region conveyed by the set of receptors would be precisely invariant with
respect to s over the central range. This can be accomplished by preceding the region
of ratio spacing (c > 0) with a region of constant spacing (c = 0). In order to equalize
the information carried at small scales, the region of constant spacing should have n = 1
c
receptors each spaced by ∆min, as in Figure 5b. Adding a set of constantly spaced receptors
enables constant information transfer over a range of scales starting exactly at ∆min (flat
solid curves in Figure 4). When the region with ratio spacing starts at xf = ∆min
, then the
region of constant spacing starts at x = 0. Note that the number of receptors in the fovea
is controlled only by c and is independent of the number of receptors in the region with
ratio spacing. The ratio of adjacent receptor spacings is constant within each region and
only fails to hold exactly at the transition between regions.
c
Discussion
Current technology is rapidly leading to a situation where we can design intelligent
agents. The results in this paper point to a design choice that may have played out on an evo-
lutionary time scale. To the extent neural representations of very different one-dimensional
quantities all obey the same scaling laws, it suggests convergent evolution optimizing some
design principle. One strategy that could be taken in designing receptor systems is to
optimally adapt the organism to the behaviorally-relevant statistics of the environment.
Evolution has certainly made this choice in a number of cases -- the putative "fly detectors"
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
14
b
a
c
Figure 5. Rationale for inclusion of a fovea. a-b. Functions are shown with different scales,
as in Figure 3 for logarithmically-spaced receptor locations. a. With a function scale that is much
larger than ∆min, several values of the function can be represented (here I = 5). b. When the
scale goes to ∆min, then much less total information can be represented. Here only one function
value fits into the veridical region. Note that the information conveyed by the same set of receptors
decreases as s decreases, as in the dashed lines in Figure 4. c. Schematic for notation for hybrid
neural scaling. The first part of the scale, analogous to a fovea, has n evenly spaced receptors from
0 to xf . The second part of the scale region, from xf to xN has N receptors spaced such that the
ratio of adjacent differences is 1 + c. The derivation suggests n should be fixed at 1/c, whereas N
can in principle grow without bound. If xf = ∆min/c, the scale starts precisely at x = 0.
in the frog's visual system are a famous example of this approach (Lettvin et al., 1959;
Maturana et al., 1960, see also Herzog & Barlow, 1992). However, optimizing receptor
arrays to a specific configuration of the world comes with a cost in terms of flexibility in
responding to changes in the world.
Logarithmic receptor scales and natural statistics
In this paper, we have pursued the implications of a neural uncertainty principle --
maintaining maximum ignorance about the statistics of the world -- for the design of sensory
receptors. Operationally, this means we have made only minimal assumptions about the
statistics of the functions to be represented, limiting ourselves to uniform priors and the
assumption of independence. Had we assumed a non-uniform distribution for the prior of s,
this would have required us to estimate at least one parameter. Similarly, if the successive
values of sx were not independent, we would have to have estimated at least one parameter
to characterize the nature of the dependence. It can be shown that the arguments developed
in the first section of this paper ("Optimal receptor distribution . . . ") for uniform priors
also generalize to scale-free (power law) priors (see footnote 4). Much empirical work has
characterized statistical regularities in the world. For instance, power spectra in natural
images tend to be distributed as a power law with exponent near −2 (Field, 1987; Ruderman
& Bialek, 1994; Simoncelli & Olshausen, 2001). Similarly, it has been argued that power
spectra for auditory stimuli are distributed as a power law with exponent −1 (Voss & Clarke,
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
15
1975). Perhaps it would be adaptive to design a set of receptors that is optimized for these
naturally occurring statistics (e.g., Wei & Stocker, 2012; Piantadosi, 2016).
Results showing power law spectra with similar exponents for natural images mask
variability across orientations and categories of images (Torralba & Oliva, 2003). For in-
stance, the exponent observed, and especially second-order statistics, vary widely across
pictures of landscapes vs pictures of office environments or pictures of roads. To the ex-
tent these statistics differ, if receptors were optimized for any one of these categories of
images, they would be suboptimally configured for other environments (Wei & Stocker,
2012). Moreover, because the eyes are constantly in motion, the statistics of natural images
are not necessarily a good proxy for the statistics of light landing on the retina averaged
by synaptic time constants. More concretely, the temporal variation due to fixational eye
movements has the effect of whitening images with conventional power law spectra (Kuang,
Poletti, Victor, & Rucci, 2012; Rucci, 2008). In the time domain, it can be shown that
in the presence of long-range correlated signals, logarithmic receptor spacing is optimal for
predicting the next stimulus that will be presented (Shankar & Howard, 2013).
A derivation based on a uniform prior is more general than a belief that the statistics of
the world should be power law. The former would apply across a range of environments and
equally well apply to any world with some unknown statistics. Moreover, the development
in the next section (entitled "Global function representation"), which predicts the existence
of a fovea under some circumstances, would be quite different if we had a strong prior
belief about the probability of observing a particular scale s. If the goal was to maximize
the information across states of the world, and if there was a non-uniform prior about
the distribution of scales, we would not have obtained asymptotically logarithmic receptor
spacing.
Specific predictions deriving from the approach in this paper
There have been a great many other approaches to understanding the ubiquity of
logarithmic psychological scales and the more general problem of constructing psycholog-
ical scales with well-behaved mathematical properties from continua in the world. These
are briefly reviewed in the next subsection (entitled "Placing this work in historical con-
text") with special attention to drawing contrasts with the present paper. However, to our
knowledge, the predictions about the scaling of the foveal region are unique to the present
approach.
Asymptotically, a logarithmic neural scale enables a set of receptors to provide equiv-
alent information about functions of a wide range of intrinsic scales, implementing the
principle of neural equanimity. However, logarithmic neural scales are untenable as ∆ goes
to zero -- the number of receptors necessary tends to infinity and the set of receptors conveys
less information about functions with scale near the smallest receptor spacing (correspond-
ing to the maximum resolution). In the absence of a fovea, there is a small-scale correction
(dashed lines Fig. 4). A region of constant receptor spacing near zero -- a fovea -- solves this
problem allowing the set of receptors to carry the same amount of non-redundant informa-
tion about functions with every possible scale ranging from ∆min to ∆N .
Equalizing the information across scales results in a fixed number of receptors within
the fovea. Critically, the number of receptors along a radius of the fovea, measured in units
of ∆min, depends only on c. The value of c can be estimated from noting the slope of the
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
16
line relating receptor size to the center of the receptive field, as in Figure 1b. 8 Note that
the value of c is estimated from receptive fields outside of the fovea, whereas ∆min and the
number of receptors along a radius are estimated from information about the fovea. As such,
measurement of the two quantities ought to be completely independent. This quantitative
relationship constitutes a specific prediction of this approach and can be evaluated across
brain regions within the same modality, and even across modalities.
Placing this work in historical context
The present paper provides a rational basis for logarithmic neural scales and the
presence of a "fovea" for values of x near zero. It also adds to a long tradition of work in
mathematical psychology organized along several themes.
Measurement theory. Researchers in mathematical psychology have long consid-
ered the form of psychological spaces. This work has concluded, contra the present ap-
proach, that there is not a privileged status for logarithmic psychological scales. Fechner's
(1860/1912) reasoning for logarithmic psychological scales started with the empirical obser-
vation of a constant Weber fraction and then made what was apparently a straightforward
conclusion:
integration of the Weber law results in logarithmic psychological scale. That
is, the Weber law states that the change in the psychological discriminability ∆p due to a
change in the magnitude of a physical stimulus ∆x goes like ∆p ∝ ∆x
x . Taking the limit as
∆x goes to zero and integrating gives a logarithmic scale p = log x + C. On its face this
seems reasonable; surely the psychological distance between two stimuli should be the sum
of the JNDs along the path between them.
Luce and Edwards (1958) noted that Fechner's reasoning is not in general sound;
the integration procedure is only valid if the empirical Weber fraction result holds. Luce
(1959) showed that a logarithmic psychological scale is one of a class of relationships that
can map a physical scale with a natural zero (a ratio scale) onto an interval scale that is
translation-invariant (Stevens, 1946). Dzhafarov and Colonius (1999, 2001) developed a
much more general framework for constructing multidimensional psychological spaces from
local discriminability functions (see Luce & Suppes, 2002 for an accessible introduction to
the history of these questions) that also does not find any privileged status for logarithmic
functions. And none of these approaches provides a natural account for the existence of a
"fovea" -- a region of heightened discriminabiligy near x = 0. To the extent that logarithmic
neural scales are a general property of the brain, the neural considerations described in this
paper provide a potentially important complement to measurement theory.
Recent approaches to Weber-Fechner scaling. More recently, investigators in math-
ematical psychology and related fields have also considered the rationale underlying the
apparent ubiquity of the Weber-Fechner law. These approaches have in general taken a
more restrictive approach than the quite general considerations in this paper. Moreover,
they do not lead to the specific predictions regarding the fovea derived here. Some recent
approaches have noted that if the psychological scale is designed to minimize a relative
8This prediction is at least roughly consistent with the trend of the hinged linear functions generated by
(Freeman & Simoncelli, 2011) shown in Fig. 1b, but this visual impression should not be taken as strong
quantitative evidence.
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
17
error measure (Sun, Wang, Goyal, & Varshney, 2012; Portugal & Svaiter, 2011), logarith-
mic scales naturally result. For instance, in stimulus quantization, the goal is to choose a
discrete quantization of the stimulus space in order to minimize the expected value of some
measure of reconstruction error between the true stimulus and the quantized stimulus. If
one minimizes mean squared error, the optimal quantization is uniform. However, if one
attempts to minimize relative error, and if the quantization is constrained to have a fixed
entropy, it can be shown that the optimal quantization is on a logarithmic scale independent
of the input stimulus statistics (Sun & Goyal, 2011; Sun et al., 2012). Wilkes (2015) com-
pared the suitability of various relative error measures from an evolutionary perspective.
These approaches depend critically on the assumption of relative error measures, without
explaining why those might be desirable (other than that they result in Weber-Fechner
scales).
Other recent approaches that result in Weber-Fechner spacing make specific assump-
tion about the statistics of the world. For instance Shouval, Agarwal, and Gavornik (2013)
described the variability in perception as due to the variability in spike count statistics from
a neuron with some I/O function and Poisson variability. They concluded that the Weber
law is optimal if the world has power law statistics. Similarly, Piantadosi (2016) derived
a Weber-Fechner scale for numerosity under the assumption that the probability that each
possible number will be utilized goes down like a power law. This builds on earlier work
deriving a rational basis for power law forgetting on the probability of use of a memory a
certain time in the past (Anderson & Schooler, 1991). Wei and Stocker (2012) argued that
receptor spacings should be constructed so that each receptor carries the same amount of
information about the world. This depends on the statistics of the world and a logarithmic
neural scale results only if the world has power law statistics with exponent −1. To the
extent the world has different statistics in different modalities and different environments,
these approaches are limited in accounting for the ubiquity of Weber-Fechner neural scales.
The approach in the present paper is more general in that it does not make any strong prior
assumptions about the statistics of the world.
Universal exponential generalization. On its face, logarithmic neural scales seem to be
closely related to Shepard's work on universal exponential generalization (Shepard, 1987).
If the mapping between the physical world and the neural scale is logarithmic, one would
expect that the mapping between the neural scale and the physical world is exponential.
Indeed, the approach in the section "Optimal receptor distribution . . . " was very much
inspired by Shepard's pioneering approach to the structure of an abstract psychological
space (Shepard, 1987). However, the results are actually quite distinct.
Shepard (1987) studied the problem of generalization; if a particular stimulus x leads
to some response, what is the optimal way to generalize the response to other stimuli in the
neighborhood of x? Shepard's derivation hypothesizes a consequential region of unknown
size. Although the results depend on one's prior belief about the distribution of sizes,
if one uses a Copernican principle like Gott to set the prior, one obtains an exponential
generalization gradient. The size of the consequential region in Shepard's work plays a
role analogous to the scale of the function in this paper. And an exponential gradient is
analogous to a logarithmic scale.
The value 1 + c serves the role of the base of the logarithm in the scales derived
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
18
here. This corresponds (roughly) to an exponential generalization gradient that goes like
(1 + c)x.
In Shepard's framework, the "space constant" of the exponential gradient is
controlled by the expected size of the consequential region, which functions like a prior
choice of scale. Note that the neural scales developed here would not lead to an exponential
generalization gradient around any particular point x. The width of receptive fields (which
is proportional to ∆) provides a natural lower limit to generalization. We would not expect
this generalization gradient to be symmetric in x (see Fig. 1a). Of course psychological
generalization need not be solely a function of neural similarity and is more difficult to
observe than receptive fields.
Neural scales for cognitive dimensions
The quantitative evidence for spacing of visual receptive fields is quite strong, due
to intense empirical study for decades (Daniel & Whitteridge, 1961; Hubel & Wiesel, 1974;
Van Essen et al., 1984). The derivation in this paper applies equally well to any one-
dimensional quantity over which we want to represent a function. If the neural uncertainty
principle is a design goal for the nervous system, it should be possible to observe similar
scaling laws for representations of other dimensions. As discussed in the introduction, there
is evidence that the brain maintains receptive fields for dimensions that do not correspond to
sensory continua. In the visual system, a neuron's spatial receptive field is the contiguous
region over visual space that causes the neuron to be activated. Cognitive continua can
also show the same coding scheme. For instance, in a working memory task that required
macaques to remember the number of stimuli presented over the delay, neurons in lateral
prefrontal cortex responded to a circumscribed set of numbers to be remembered. That is,
one neuron might be activated when the number of stimuli to be remembered is 3-5, but
another neuron might be activated when the number to be remembered is 4-7.
Time cells fire during a circumscribed period of time within a delay interval. Each
time cell can be thought of as having a receptive field over past time. In much the same
way that a neuron with a visually-sensitive receptive field fires when a stimulus is in the
appropriate part of the visual field, so too the time cell fires when a relevant stimulus, here
the beginning of the delay interval, enters its temporal receptive field. Because different time
cells have different receptive fields, as the stimulus recedes into the past with the passage
of time, a sequence of time cells fire. In this way, receptive fields tile time, a continuous
dimension in much the same way that eccentricity or numerosity would be coded.
Time and numerosity do not correspond to sensory receptors in the same way that,
say, eccentricity in the visual system does. Nonetheless, the logic of the arguments in this
paper apply equally well to time and numerosity. Do these "cognitive" receptive fields show
logarithmic spacing? Although this is still an open empirical question, qualitative findings
are consistent with logarithmic spacing. Logarithmic spacing would imply that the width of
time fields should increase linearly with the time of peak firing within the delay. Although
a precisely linear relationship has not been established, it is certain that the width of
time fields increases with time of peak firing. This is true in the hippocampus (MacDonald,
Lepage, Eden, & Eichenbaum, 2011; Salz et al., 2016), entorhinal cortex (Kraus et al., 2015),
striatum (Akhlaghpour et al., 2016; Mello et al., 2015; Jin, Fujii, & Graybiel, 2009), and
medial prefrontal cortex (Tiganj, Kim, Jung, & Howard, in press). Similarly, logarithmic
spacing implies that the number density of cells with a time field centered on time τ should
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
19
go down like τ−1. While this quantitative relationship has not been established thus far,
it is certain that the number density goes down with τ . This qualitative pattern at least
holds in all of the regions where time cells have been identified thus far.
In addition to logarithmic spacing, the logic motivating the existence of a fovea would
apply equally well to cognitive dimensions. This does not imply that foveal organization
ought to be ubiquitous. We would expect the size of the fovea to be large when c is small.
The cost of choosing a small value of c is that the range of scales that can be represented
with a fixed N goes down dramatically (Eq. 8).
In domains where there is no natural
upper limit to x, such as numerosity or (arguably) time, this concern may be quite serious.
However, the cost of failing to represent arbitrarily large scales is perhaps not so high in
cases where there is a natural upper bound on the function to be represented. In the case
of vision, there is a natural upper bound to the value of eccentricity that could be observed.
In the case of functions of numerosity, the subitizing range, the finding that small integers
are represented with little error, may be analogous to the fovea. In the case of functions
of time, the analog of a fovea would correspond to something like traditional notions of
short-term memory. In any case, direct measurement of c, which can be estimated from the
width of receptive fields as a function of their peak, would provide strong constraints on
whether or not there ought to be a "fovea" for numerosity and/or time.
Constructing ratio scales for cognitive dimensions
Ultimately, one can understand the spacing of the retinal coordinate system, or other
sensory domains, as the result of a developmental process that aligns receptors along the
sensory organ. However, if these arguments apply as well to non-sensory dimensions such
as number and time, then this naturally raises the question of how the brain constructs "re-
ceptors" for these entities. One recent hypothesis for constructing representations of time,
space and number describes time cells -- which have receptive fields for particular events
in the past -- as extracted from exponentially-decaying neurons with long time constants.
The requirement for logarithmic neural scales amounts to the requirement that the time
constants of exponentially-decaying cells should be organized such that "adjacent" cells,
along some gradient, should have time constants in a constant ratio.
There is now good evidence for long time constants in cortex both in vitro (Egorov,
Hamam, Frans´en, Hasselmo, & Alonso, 2002) and in vivo (Leitner et al., 2016). The
long time constants can be implemented at the single cell level using known biophysical
properties of cortical neurons (Tiganj, Hasselmo, & Howard, 2015). Noting that a set
of exponentially-decaying cells encode the Laplace transform of the history, it has been
proposed that time cells result from an approximate inversion of the Laplace transform
(Shankar & Howard, 2013). The inversion can be accomplished with, essentially, feedforward
on-center/off-surround receptive fields.
The mathematical basis of this approach is extremely powerful. It is straightfoward
to show that the computational framework for a representation of time can be generalized
to space and number (Howard et al., 2014) or any variable for which the time derivative
can be computed. Moreover, access to the Laplace domain means one can implement
various computations, for instance implementing translation (Shankar, Singh, & Howard,
2016) or comparison operators (Howard et al., 2015). To the extent that representations
from different domains utilize the same scaling relationships, access to a set of canonical
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
20
computations could lead to a general computational framework for cognition.
References
Akhlaghpour, H., Wiskerke, J., Choi, J. Y., Taliaferro, J. P., Au, J., & Witten, I. (2016). Dissociated
sequential activity and stimulus encoding in the dorsomedial striatum during spatial working
memory. eLife, 5 , e19507.
Anderson, J., & Schooler, L.
science, 2 (6), 396 -- 408.
(1991). Reflections of the environment in memory. Psychological
Balsam, P. D., & Gallistel, C. R. (2009). Temporal maps and informativeness in associative learning.
Trends in Neuroscience, 32 (2), 73 -- 78.
Daniel, P. M., & Whitteridge, D. (1961). The representation of the visual field on the cerebral
cortex in monkeys. Journal of Physiology, 159 , 203-21.
Dzhafarov, E. N., & Colonius, H. (1999). Fechnerian metrics in unidimensional and multidimensional
stimulus spaces. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review , 6 (2), 239 -- 268.
Dzhafarov, E. N., & Colonius, H. (2001). Multidimensional fechnerian scaling: basics. Journal of
Mathematical Psychology, 45 (5), 670 -- 719.
Egorov, A. V., Hamam, B. N., Frans´en, E., Hasselmo, M. E., & Alonso, A. A. (2002). Graded
persistent activity in entorhinal cortex neurons. Nature, 420 (6912), 173-8.
Fechner, G. (1860/1912). Elements of psychophysics. Vol. I. Houghton Mifflin.
Feigenson, L., Dehaene, S., & Spelke, E. (2004). Core systems of number. Trends in Cognitive
Sciences, 8 (7), 307 -- 314.
Field, D. J. (1987). Relations between the statistics of natural images and the response properties
of cortical cells. Journal of the Optical Society of America, 4 , 2379-2394.
Freeman, J., & Simoncelli, E. P. (2011). Metamers of the ventral stream. Nature Neuroscience,
14 (9), 1195-201. doi: 10.1038/nn.2889
Gallistel, C. R., & Gelman, R. (1992). Preverbal and verbal counting and computation. Cognition,
44 (1), 43 -- 74.
Gattass, R., Sousa, A. P., & Gross, C. G. (1988). Visuotopic organization and extent of V3 and V4
of the macaque. Journal of Neuroscience, 8 (6), 1831-45.
Gott, J. R.
(1993).
Implications of the Copernican principle for our future prospects. Nature,
363 (6427), 315 -- 319.
Harvey, B., Klein, B., Petridou, N., & Dumoulin, S. (2013). Topographic representation of numeros-
ity in the human parietal cortex. Science, 341 (6150), 1123 -- 1126.
Herzog, E. D., & Barlow, R. B. (1992). The limulus-eye view of the world. Visual neuroscience,
9 (06), 571 -- 580.
Howard, M. W., MacDonald, C. J., Tiganj, Z., Shankar, K. H., Du, Q., Hasselmo, M. E., &
(2014). A unified mathematical framework for coding time, space, and
Journal of Neuroscience, 34 (13), 4692-707. doi:
Eichenbaum, H.
sequences in the hippocampal region.
10.1523/JNEUROSCI.5808-12.2014
Howard, M. W., Shankar, K. H., Aue, W., & Criss, A. H. (2015). A distributed representation of
internal time. Psychological Review , 122 (1), 24-53.
Hubel, D. H., & Wiesel, T. N. (1974). Uniformity of monkey striate cortex: a parallel relation-
ship between field size, scatter, and magnification factor. Journal of Comparative Neurology,
158 (3), 295-305. doi: 10.1002/cne.901580305
Jin, D. Z., Fujii, N., & Graybiel, A. M. (2009). Neural representation of time in cortico-basal ganglia
circuits. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 106 (45), 19156 -- 19161.
Kraus, B. J., Brandon, M. P., Robinson, R. J., Connerney, M. A., Hasselmo, M. E., & Eichenbaum,
H. (2015). During running in place, grid cells integrate elapsed time and distance run. Neuron,
88 (3), 578 -- 589.
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
21
Kuang, X., Poletti, M., Victor, J. D., & Rucci, M. (2012). Temporal encoding of spatial information
during active visual fixation. Current Biology, 22 (6), 510-4. doi: 10.1016/j.cub.2012.01.050
Leitner, F. C., Melzer, S., Lutcke, H., Pinna, R., Seeburg, P. H., Helmchen, F., & Monyer, H. (2016).
Spatially segregated feedforward and feedback neurons support differential odor processing in
the lateral entorhinal cortex. Nature Neuroscience.
Lettvin, J. Y., Maturana, H. R., McCulloch, W. S., & Pitts, W. H. (1959). What the frog's eye tells
the frog's brain. Proceedings of the IRE , 47 (11), 1940 -- 1951.
Luce, R. D. (1959). Detection and recognition. In R. D. Luce, R. R. Bush, & E. Galanter (Eds.),
Handbook of mathematical psychology (p. 103-189). New York: Wiley.
Luce, R. D., & Edwards, W.
(1958). The derivation of subjective scales from just noticeable
differences. Psychological review , 65 (4), 222.
Luce, R. D., & Suppes, P. (2002). Representational measurement theory. Stevens' handbook of
experimental psychology.
Ma, W. J., Beck, J. M., Latham, P. E., & Pouget, A. (2006). Bayesian inference with probabilistic
population codes. Nature Neuroscience, 9 (11), 1432 -- 1438.
MacDonald, C. J., Lepage, K. Q., Eden, U. T., & Eichenbaum, H. (2011). Hippocampal "time cells"
bridge the gap in memory for discontiguous events. Neuron, 71 (4), 737-749.
Maturana, H. R., Lettvin, J. Y., McCulloch, W. S., & Pitts, W. H. (1960). Anatomy and physiology
of vision in the frog (rana pipiens). The Journal of general physiology, 43 (6), 129 -- 175.
Mello, G. B., Soares, S., & Paton, J. J. (2015). A scalable population code for time in the striatum.
Current Biology, 25 (9), 1113 -- 1122.
Merzenich, M. M., Knight, P. L., & Roth, G. L. (1973). Cochleotopic organization of primary
auditory cortex in the cat. Brain Research, 63 , 343-6.
Nieder, A., & Miller, E. K. (2003). Coding of cognitive magnitude: compressed scaling of numerical
information in the primate prefrontal cortex. Neuron, 37 (1), 149-57.
Piantadosi, S. T. (2016). A rational analysis of the approximate number system. Psychonomic
Bulletin & Review , 1 -- 10.
Portugal, R., & Svaiter, B. F. (2011). Weber-Fechner law and the optimality of the logarithmic
scale. Minds and Machines, 21 (1), 73 -- 81.
Rucci, M.
(2008). Fixational eye movements, natural image statistics, and fine spatial vision.
Network , 19 (4), 253-85. doi: 10.1080/09548980802520992
Ruderman, D. L., & Bialek, W. (1994). Statistics of natural images: Scaling in the woods. Physical
Review Letters, 73 (6), 814.
Salz, D. M., Tiganj, Z., Khasnabish, S., Kohley, A., Sheehan, D., Howard, M. W., & Eichenbaum,
H. (2016). Time cells in hippocampal area CA3. Journal of Neuroscience, 36 , 7476-7484.
Schwartz, E. L. (1977). Spatial mapping in the primate sensory projection: analytic structure and
relevance to perception. Biological Cybernetics, 25 (4), 181-94.
Shankar, K. H., & Howard, M. W. (2013). Optimally fuzzy temporal memory. Journal of Machine
Learning Research, 14 , 3753-3780.
Shankar, K. H., Singh, I., & Howard, M. W. (2016). Neural mechanism to simulate a scale-invariant
future. Neural Computation, 28 , 2594 -- 2627.
Shepard, R. N. (1987). Toward a universal law of generalization for psychological science. Science,
237 (4820), 1317 -- 1323.
Shouval, H. Z., Agarwal, A., & Gavornik, J. P.
(2013). Scaling of perceptual errors can pre-
dict the shape of neural tuning curves. Physical Review Letters, 110 , 168102. Retrieved
from http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.110.168102
doi: 10.1103/Phys-
RevLett.110.168102
Simoncelli, E. P., & Olshausen, B. A. (2001). Natural image statistics and neural representation.
Annual Review of Neuroscience, 24 , 1193 -- 1216.
Stevens, S. S. (1946). On the theory of scales of measurement. Science, 103 (2684), 677-680.
Stevens, S. S. (1957). On the psychophysical law. Psychological Review , 64 (3), 153-81.
NEURAL SCALING LAWS FOR AN UNCERTAIN WORLD
22
Sun, J. Z., & Goyal, V. K. (2011). Scalar quantization for relative error. In Data Compression
Conference (DCC), 2011 (pp. 293 -- 302).
Sun, J. Z., Wang, G. I., Goyal, V. K., & Varshney, L. R. (2012). A framework for Bayesian optimality
of psychophysical laws. Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 56 (6), 495 -- 501.
Tiganj, Z., Hasselmo, M. E., & Howard, M. W. (2015). A simple biophysically plausible model for
long time constants in single neurons. Hippocampus, 25 (1), 27-37.
Tiganj, Z., Kim, J., Jung, M. W., & Howard, M. W. (in press). Sequential firing codes for time in
rodent mPFC. Cerebral Cortex .
Torralba, A., & Oliva, A. (2003). Statistics of natural image categories. Network: Computation in
Neural Systems, 14 (3), 391 -- 412.
Van Essen, D. C., Newsome, W. T., & Maunsell, J. H. (1984). The visual field representation in
striate cortex of the macaque monkey: asymmetries, anisotropies, and individual variability.
Vision Research, 24 (5), 429-48.
Voss, R. F., & Clarke, J. (1975). 1/f noise in music and speech. Nature, 258 , 317 -- 318.
Wei, X.-X., & Stocker, A. A. (2012). Bayesian inference with efficient neural population codes. In
Artificial neural networks and machine learning -- icann 2012 (pp. 523 -- 530). Springer.
Wilkes, J. T.
(2015). Reverse first principles: Weber's law and optimality in different senses
(Unpublished doctoral dissertation). UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SANTA BARBARA.
|
1504.07089 | 1 | 1504 | 2015-04-27T13:52:52 | A test of multiple correlation temporal window characteristic of non-Markov processes | [
"q-bio.NC",
"physics.data-an"
] | We introduce a sensitive test of memory effects in successive events. The test consists of a combination K of binary correlations at successive times. K decays monotonically from K = 1 for uncorrelated events as a Markov process; whereas memory effects provide a temporal window with K > 1. For a monotonic memory fading, K < 1 always. Here we report evidence of a K > 1 temporal window in cognitive tasks consisting of the visual identification of the front face of the Necker cube after a previous presentation of the same. The K > 1 behaviour is maximal at an inter-measurement time {\tau} around 2 sec with inter-subject differences. The K > 1 persists over a time window of 1 sec around {\tau}; outside this window the K < 1 behaviour is recovered. The universal occurrence of a K > 1 window in pairs of successive perceptions suggests that, at variance with single visual stimuli eliciting a suitable response, a pair of stimuli shortly separated in time displays mutual correlations. | q-bio.NC | q-bio | A test of multiple correlation temporal window characteristic of
non-Markov processes
F.T.Arecchi,∗ A.Farini,† and N.Megna‡
INO-CNR Largo E.Fermi 6 50125 Firenze
(Dated: October 15, 2018)
Abstract
We introduce a sensitive test of memory effects in successive events. The test consists of a
combination K of binary correlations at successive times. K decays monotonically from K = 1
for uncorrelated events as a Markov process; whereas memory effects provide a temporal window
with K > 1. For a monotonic memory fading, K < 1 always. Here we report evidence of a K > 1
temporal window in cognitive tasks consisting of the visual identification of the front face of the
Necker cube after a previous presentation of the same. The K > 1 behaviour is maximal at an
inter-measurement time τ around 2 sec with inter-subject differences. The K > 1 persists over
a time window of 1 sec around τ ; outside this window the K < 1 behaviour is recovered. The
universal occurrence of a K > 1 window in pairs of successive perceptions suggests that, at variance
with single visual stimuli eliciting a suitable response, a pair of stimuli shortly separated in time
displays mutual correlations.
5
1
0
2
r
p
A
7
2
]
.
C
N
o
i
b
-
q
[
1
v
9
8
0
7
0
.
4
0
5
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
∗ [email protected]; Dipartimento di Fisica Universit`a di Firenze
† [email protected]
‡ [email protected]
1
I.
INTRODUCTION
The K-test highlights memory effects in successive events. It consists of a combination of
binary correlations at successive times. K decays monotonically from K = 1 for uncorrelated
events as a Markov process; whereas memory effects provide a transient peak above K = 1;
the peak duration measures the time extent of the memory effect.
We apply the K test to successive perceptions showing that,at variance with isolated
presentations, sequential presentations display mutual correlations over a characteristic time
interval.
II. A TEST THAT DISCRIMINATES SEQUENCES OF UNCORRELATED PER-
CEPTIONS FROM SEQUENCES OF PAIRWISE CORRELATED PERCEPTIONS
We want to obtain, from the perception of a visual stimulus, a sequence of binary values
(+1,−1). The simplest way is to submit to subjects' observation a bistable figure[1]. Our
choice was the Necker cube[2], where the perceived perspective of the front face of the cube
(Fig.1) alternates between two different options as either facing upward and to the right or
downward and to the left: we attribute respectively measurement values Q = ±1.
In our experiment the measurement corresponds to obtain from a subject an answer
about which face he/she is viewing as front face at a given time. We aim at providing a
sensitive test of correlations between successive presentations of the cube. The key here is
that we have measurements at two different times, and one or more times between the first
and last measurement. Let us perform measurement at three successive times t1 < t2 < t3
with ISI (inter-stimulus interval) = t2−t1 = t3−t2 (the relevance for the experiment of these
intervals will be explained in the next section). For instance, the correlation C13 between
times t1 and t3 for N realizations of the experiment, reads
Qr(t1)Qr(t3)
(1)
We introduce the combination K as K = C12 + C23 − C13. In terms of actual measurements
Q's, K is given by
N(cid:88)
r=1
C13 =
1
N
N(cid:88)
K =
1
N
r=0
2
(Q(t1)Q(t2) + Q(t2)Q(t3) − Q(t1)Q(t3))
(2)
FIG. 1. The Necker Cube
The K-test is the most elementary test to be performed on sequences of binary data. In a
different context, namely in a temporal version of a quantum Bell test, it was introduced by
Leggett and Garg[3] and exploited by many groups[4]. However in the Leggett Garg case
each term of the three sums which yield C12, C23, and C13 is measured sequentially in a single
measurement and the ensemble average is carried over the the whole measurement. Instead
we are carrying separate averages over the three components Cij, so that the resemblance
with the Leggett-Garg test is purely formal.
In order to understand what we can expect from our visual experiment, we analyze some
numerical simulations obtained starting from some models related to Necker cube. A possible
3
model is that the switch from +1 to -1 occurs randomly with a uniform distribution in time
(Poisson process). In this condition the probability p(t) of the first switch at a given time
t decays as a e
−t
τ where τ is the average occurrence of switches (Fig.2a). The probability
pi(t) that at least a switch is occurred at a time t is given by the integral of the previous
function which asymptotically yields 1 (Fig.2b).
In the case of human subjects viewing
the Necker cube a well verified model[5, 6] is that the probability of the first switch p is
given by the gamma function plotted in Fig.2c and the integrated probability pi is given in
Fig.2d. At variance with Fig.2b, Fig.2d displays an initial correlation with the t = 0 event,
followed by a sharp increase. While Fig.2b is uniformly convex, the presence of memory
effects is associated with the change of curvature (from concave to convex) of Fig.2d. In
collecting data on real subjects the differences between Fig.2b and Fig.2d may be masked
by observation features. Furthermore, the gamma function of Ref[5, 6] corresponds to a
continuous presentation of the Necker cube. Instead, as we explain later, we are interested
to a flashing presentation, which seems more appropriate to mimic the variety of perceptions
during an observation. We thus look for a suitable combination of correlation functions which
provides a sensitive test not only for discriminating upper from lower probabilities in Fig.2
but also for discriminating between continuous and flashing presentation of the Necker cube.
We correlate the data at three different times equally spaced t1 (corresponding to the
starting time) t2 and t3, building the corresponding correlation functions. If we set Q(t1) = 1,
C12 = 1· (1− pi(t2− t1)). Notice that since t2− t1 equals t3− t2, a continuous presentation of
a Necker cube yields C23 = (1− pi(t2 − t1))(1− pi(t3 − t2)) whereas if we present the Necker
cube in a flashing way, we have a reset in time and probability and hence C12 = C23. From
these assumptions we can compute K using Eq.2. It results for the memory-less case K < 1
always (Fig.3a), for a continuous presentation of the Necker cube again K < 1 (Fig.3b),
instead for the flashing presentation K goes above 1 within a temporal window (Fig.3c).
Thus the K-test appears as a very sensitive one for extracting memory effects.
Let us discuss the relevance of K. In cognitive perceptions,the associated motor response
emerges from a Bayesian inference[7, 8] whereby the conditional probability that a datum d
follows from an hypothesis h is a memorized algorithm. Such a process requires an elabo-
ration lasting a few hundred milliseconds, up to about 1 second[9]. On the contrary, in the
exposure to a correlated sequences of perception, the interpretation of a piece is not done in
terms of an already established algorithm but it depends on the previous piece. The build
4
FIG. 2. a) (up-left) Probability p to have a single switch at a time t for a sequence of random
switches (uniform probability per unit time) b) (up-right) Probability pithat at least a switch is
occurred at a time t for a sequence of random switches (uniform probability per unit time). The
function corresponds to the integral of function in a) c)(down-left) Probability p to have a single
switch at a time t for the gamma distribution. d) (down-right) Probability pi that at least a switch
is occurred at a time t for the gamma distribution. The function corresponds to the integral of
function in c)
5
0510152000.20.40.60.81tp0510152000.20.40.60.81tpi024600.10.20.30.40.5tp024600.20.40.60.81tpi FIG. 3. a) Computational K for random switches (dotted line), b) for gamma distribution in a
continuous presentation (dashed line) and c) for a gamma distribution in a flashing presentation
(continuous line)
up of such a specific correlation has been called "inverse Bayes inference"[10].
We aim at building a sensitive test of a memory binding lasting for such a characteristic
time in the exposure to a bistable image.
We consider an uncorrelated sequence of perceptions as the standard cognitive state of
a brainy animal, each perception being built by combining a bottom-up sensorial stimulus
with a top-down instruction provided by the long term memory. A cognitive task consists of
a chain of perceptions, each one eliciting a motor reaction[11]. Successive perceptions keep
a Bayesian structure; a sequence of them is then Markovian, in the sense that a previous
perception does not affect in a structural way the next one [8, 12].
6
00.511.522.533.544.5500.20.40.60.811.21.41.6ISI (s)K On the contrary, when successive perceptions display correlations, a bridge has been
provided by the short term memory which has retrieved the previous perception. We hy-
pothesize that this short term bridge is the basis of language, so that referring to correlated
sequences of +/ − 1 states, we are in presence of the most elementary language, consisting
of binary words[13]; whenever a piece of a linguistic text is compared with a previous piece
retrieved by the short term memory in order to infer a comparison a judgment emerges.
Perception and judgments have been associated, respectively, with a Bayes inference and
with an inverse Bayes inference [10, 14]. These last references discuss also the two associated
times, namely, around 1 sec for perception [9, 15, 16] and around 3 sec for judgments. The
3 sec intervals in the judgment operations had been suggested by the extensive analyses of
this cognitive time provided by Ernst Poeppel [13, 17, 18] .
To avoid semantic biases, we take as "linguistic text" an ordered sequence of binary
signals (sequential presentations of the Necker cube).
In Sec.III and IV we describe the
methods and the results. In Sec.V we provide cues for the temporal window of K > 1 and
for the approximate location of its peak value. Finally we discuss possible relations between
the peak time of the K > 1 curve and the peak in the statistics of pauses in linguistic
endeavours.
III. MATERIALS AND METHODS
The stimulus presented to the observers was the Necker cube (Fig.4a) whereby the per-
ceived perspective of the front face of the cube alternates between two different options as
either facing upward and to the right or downward and to the left. These two percepts al-
ternate in time. All visual stimuli were displayed by a 21 inches colour CRT monitor (Sony
GDM-F500 800*600 pixels, refresh rate 100 Hz) and generated by a Personal Computer.
The experiment was written using the Psychophysics Toolbox 2.54 extensions [19 -- 21].
The Necker cube was defined by black lines and covered an area of 5◦ × 5◦. Observers
watched binocularly the display at a viewing distance of 57 cm. The stimulus was displayed
at the center of the screen on a mid gray background with luminance of 25cd/m2. No fixation
point was presented, as observers were asked to passively inspect the stimulus on the screen,
with natural eye movements. Subjects viewed for 120 times (N) per condition a sequence
of three Necker cubes at three different times (t1, t2, t3). Each presentation of the cube
7
FIG. 4. a) The Necker Cube b) Experimental procedure. Sequence of three successive presentations
of the Necker cube (represented as square pulses, lasting 0.30 sec each) separated by time intervals
ISI = t2 − t1 = t3 − t2, adjustable from 1 sec up. The vertical arrows denote a sharp acoustic
signal acting as a stimulus that demands the subject to press either button corresponding to the
perceived front face of the cube. The circles denote the presentation of the cube in the absence
of the acoustic signal. The three sequences correspond to C12, C23 and C13 respectively. The
sequences are repeated after a time much longer than t2 − t1.
had a duration of 0.3 seconds and was separated from the next presentation by a variable
interstimulus interval (ISI) with the condition that t2 − t1 = t3 − t2. Each sequence was
followed by a blank interval (no stimulus displayed) of 5 seconds, well above the maximal ISI.
For two of the three stimuli of the sequence, an acoustic beep was presented to the subjects
(Fig.4b), asking which of the two different percept they had for the corresponding stimulus,
whence pressing a key on the keyboard if they perceived a cube with an upward-right front
8
face or a different key if they perceived a downward-left front face. The subjects, for a total
number of 21, were all students of the University of Firenze, with normal or corrected to
normal vision, without pre-information of the aim of the study. Each subject gave a written
informed consent to participate, and the experiment was done according to the declaration
of Helsinki. The ethics committee of the National Institute of Optics specifically approved
this study. Incidentally, 21 subject could appear a small number, but in visual psychophysics
some important effects were shown using only two subjects (e.g.[22]) also the CIE standard
observers (used to calculate the efficiency of lamps) are averages based on experiments with
small numbers (around 15-20) of people[23].
IV. RESULTS
We expose 21 normal subjects to a balanced presentation of a Necker cube [2, 24], a wire
frame cube with no depth cues, and request to press two different buttons, depending on the
cube face perceived as the front one, anytime a short audio signal alerts the subject (Fig.4).
In Fig.5 we report K versus the inter-stimulus interval (ISI) t2 − t1 = t3 − t2 for 21
subjects. For each subject, successive presentations of the sequence of Fig.4 are separated
by a blank time of 5 sec, well above the maximum ISI explored. In Fig.4 the time duration of
each cube presentation is 0.30 sec. One might guess that the timing is ruled by the acoustic
warning signals (arrows of Fig.4) and the flashed presentation of the cube does not matter.
In fact, we have tested also with a continuous presentation of the cube; however, in such
a case all subjects yield K values consistently below 1 and located between 1.0 and -1.5,
without any correlation with the ISI interval, in accordance with the expectation of Fig.3b.
The K < 1 result for the continuous presentation of the Necker cube reinforces the
guess that the search in the semantic space has to be performed on different items. We
have obtained the same result (K < 1) testing the subjects with another bistable figure, the
rotating sphere [25], with continuous presentation. On the other hand a flashed presentation
of the rotating sphere as done so far with appropriate software implies switching times much
longer than the times here considered and thus it loses any linguistic relevance.
Due to the fact that every subject could have a different decorrelation time we have
created a meta-subject response aligning the peaks at a time t = 0 and plotting the averaged
Ks for negative and positive time separations from the peak τ . The K > 1 result is
9
FIG. 5. K values corresponding to the six selected interstimulus intervals for each of the 21 subjects
that participated to the experiment. The correlation C12 results as a sum of products Q1 ∗ Q2,
similarly for C23 and C13 . By these data introduced into Eqs. (1) and (2), we evaluate K for each
ISI.
statistically significant at the peak(Fig.6). In Fig 7 we plot the statistical distribution of τ
for the 21 subjects.
The mean switching time, related to C12, has been previously measured [5, 26]. As for
the single time correlation C12, a deviation from a purely classical statistics, called Quantum
Zeno effect, has been reported [27]. It refers however to time scales below 1 sec, well within
the perception regime, thus it has no relevance for linguistic purposes.
10
FIG. 6. K values in correspondence of the six tested interstimulus intervals. These values have
been obtained by pooling data from the 21 subjects into a unique meta-observer. The data are
also pooled around the peak time, here denoted as t = 0. The error bars are the variance. K > 1
is statistically significant at the peak.
V. DISCUSSION: WHY τ , A QUALITATIVE EXPLANATION
We elaborate on the K > 1 effect around 2 sec. A very striking new fact is that the peak
τ is close to the maximal value of the statistical distribution of pauses in several linguistic
endeavours[17].
From the neuroscientific side, no attempt has been made to tackle the sharp discrepancy
between perception times, for which several NCC have been devised [15] and the judgment
times necessary to build meanings out of sequences of consecutive linguistic pieces.
Let us speculate about the time location τ . Since τ corresponds to the maximal pertur-
bation that a word exerts on a later word, then the human linguistic processing is organized
11
FIG. 7. Distributions τ of the maxima of K (Fig.4).
so that τ is the most appropriate coupling time between two successive groups of words. A
time window of about 1 sec surrounds τ ; it represents the interval over which K > 1. Thus
K > 1 is in fact a short term memory indicator. Our cognitive abilities seem geared in such
a way that two adjacent groups of words within that window interact in a non-Bayesian way
[14]. Away from that window, that is, for shorter and longer separations of word groups, a
classical Bayesian strategy [8, 12] applies. We hypothesize that, in order to make sense of a
text, two successive pieces must be separated by a time of the order of τ .
The individual lumps generate timeless perceptions by themselves and the time separa-
tions from one to the next are the relevant ones in the K test here discussed.
Thus the K > 1 occurrence is a strategy to correlate successive lumps - as the sequential
pieces of a linguistic text- one another, overcoming (or, better to say, re-adjusting) the
arousal that each piece provokes by itself. Our cognitive abilities seem to be geared for two
12
different tasks, namely,
1. within the single lump, make the best use of the incoming sensorial information ex-
ploiting previous information stored in the long term memory (perception), and
2. combine the current perception with the correlation to the previous lump of the linguis-
tic sequence (short term memory bridge); the two lumps may interact with different
weights depending on the semantic content of the sequence we are exposed to.
The τ measured by us in a sequence with no semantic content provides the first experi-
mental evidence of mechanism 2.
[1] G. M. Long and T. C. Toppino, Psychological bulletin 130, 748 (2004).
[2] L. Necker, The London and Edinburgh Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 1, 329
(1832).
[3] A. Leggett and A. Garg, Physical Review Letters 54, 857 (1985).
[4] C. Emary, N. Lambert, and F. Nori, Reports on Progress in Physics 77, 016001 (2014).
[5] A. Borsellino, A. Marco, A. Allazetta, S. Rinesi, and B. Bartolini, Biological Cybernetics 10,
139 (1972).
[6] G. Gigante, M. Mattia, J. Braun, and P. Del Giudice, PLoS Comput Biol 5, e1000430 (2009).
[7] F. Arecchi, The European Physical Journal Special Topics 146, 205 (2007).
[8] T. Griffiths, C. Kemp, and J. Tenenbaum, "Bayesian models of cognition," (Cambridge Univ
Press, 2008) pp. 59 -- 100.
[9] J. Lachaux, E. Rodriguez, J. Martinerie, F. Varela, et al., Human brain mapping 8, 194 (1999).
[10] F. Arecchi, Journal of Psychophysiology 24, 141 (2010).
[11] E. Rodriguez, N. George, J.-P. Lachaux, J. Martinerie, B. Renault, and F. J. Varela, Nature
397, 430 (1999).
[12] K. Kording and D. Wolpert, Trends in cognitive sciences (2006).
[13] E. Poppel, Acta Neurobiologiae Experimentalis 64, 295 (2004).
[14] F. Arecchi, Nonlinear Dynamics, Psychology and Life Sciences 15, 359 (2011).
[15] C. Koch, The quest for consciousness: A neuroscientific approach (Roberts & Co, 2004).
13
[16] S. Dehaene, C. Sergent, and J. Changeux, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
100, 8520 (2003).
[17] E. Poppel, Trends in cognitive sciences 1, 56 (1997).
[18] E. Poppel, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 364, 1887
(2009).
[19] D. Brainard, Spatial vision 10, 433 (1997).
[20] D. Pelli, Spatial vision 10, 437 (1997).
[21] M. Kleiner, D. Brainard, D. Pelli, A. Ingling, R. Murray, and C. Broussard, Perception 36,
1 (2007).
[22] P. Neri, M. Morrone, and D. Burr, Nature 395, 894 (1998).
[23] G. Wyszecki and W. Stiles, Color science (John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1982).
[24] R. Arrighi, F. Arecchi, A. Farini, and C. Gheri, Cognitive Processing 10, S95 (2009).
[25] D. A. Leopold, M. Wilke, A. Maier, and N. K. Logothetis, Nat Neurosci 5, 605 (2002).
[26] D. Leopold and N. Logothetis, Trends in cognitive sciences 3, 254 (1999).
[27] H. Atmanspacher, T. Filk, and H. Romer, Biological Cybernetics 90, 33 (2004).
14
|
1611.05150 | 1 | 1611 | 2016-11-16T05:25:35 | Positive Feedback and Synchronized Bursts in Neuronal Cultures | [
"q-bio.NC"
] | Synchronized bursts (SBs) with complex structures are common in neuronal cultures. Although the origin of SBs is still unclear, they have been studied for their information processing capabilities. Here, we investigate the properties of these SBs in a culture on multi-electrode array system. We find that structures of these SBs are related to the different developmental stages of the cultures. A model based on short term synaptic plasticity, recurrent connections and astrocytic recycling of neurotransmitters has been developed successfully to understand these structures. A phase diagram obtained from this model shows that networks exhibiting SBs are in an oscillatory state due to large enough positive feedback provided by synaptic facilitation and recurrent connections. In this model, the structures of the SBs are the results of intrinsic synaptic interactions; not information stored in the network. | q-bio.NC | q-bio |
Positive Feedback and Synchronized Bursts in Neuronal
Cultures
Yu-Ting Huang1,2, Yu-Lin Chang2, Chun-Chung Chen2, Pik-Yin Lai1, C. K. Chan1,2
1 Dept. of Physics and Center for Complex Systems, National Central University,
Chungli, Taiwan 320, ROC
2 Institute of Physics, Academia Sinica, Nankang, Taipei, Taiwan 115, ROC
¤Current Address: Institute of Physics, Academia Sinica, Taipei, Taiwan
* [email protected] and [email protected]
Abstract
Synchronized bursts (SBs) with complex structures are common in neuronal cultures.
Although the origin of SBs is still unclear, they have been studied for their
information processing capabilities. Here, we investigate the properties of these SBs in
a culture on multi-electrode array system. We find that structures of these SBs are
related to the different developmental stages of the cultures. A model based on short
term synaptic plasticity, recurrent connections and astrocytic recycling of
neurotransmitters has been developed successfully to understand these structures. A
phase diagram obtained from this model shows that networks exhibiting SBs are in an
oscillatory state due to large enough positive feedback provided by synaptic
facilitation and recurrent connections. In this model, the structures of the SBs are the
results of intrinsic synaptic interactions; not information stored in the network.
Introduction
Synchronized bursts (SBs) [1] are common in our brains. They originate from the
collective dynamics of neurons in the neural networks. These bursts can be related to
the normal functioning of the brain or to some pathological states such as epilepsy.
For the normal functions, it has been proposed that these collective dynamics might
encode information and perform computation. In fact, neuronal cultures grown on top
of a multi-electrode array (MEA), which invariably generate SBs, have become a
standard experimental platform for the study of computational capabilities of living
neural networks. For example, Ben-Jacob et al. studied these SBs for encoded
information [2], complexities and even memories capabilities [3] while Lee et al.
attempted to train [4] these SBs by using external stimulations. The goal of these kind
of works is to understand the mechanisms of these SBs and ultimately to construct a
living neural chip [5] with useful functions. Unfortunately, very little success has been
achieved towards this goal despite of the extensive efforts in the last two decades.
One of the main difficulties for the modeling of SBs is that the dynamics of the SBs
can vary widely depending on the conditions of the cultures [1]. This rich repository of
dynamics might be the results of memories, learning, etc., in the network as mentioned
above. However, it might also simply be the complex behaviors generated by simple
dynamical systems [6]. It is known that SBs are controlled by synaptic
transmission [7] and occur only when there are enough connections [8] in the network.
1/12
Intuitively, minimal recurrent connections are needed for the re-excitation (positive
feedback) of the network to maintain a burst while synaptic mechanism should
determine the detailed dynamics of a SB. Since even simple dynamical systems with
different amount of positive feedback can lead to complex behaviors, it is plausible
that SBs observed are simply the results of different amount of re-excitations.
In this article, we report our investigation by experiments and modeling of a
neuronal network grown on a MEA to understand the origin of these SBs. Specifically,
we are able to produce a special form of SBs similar to reverberations [9] or
superbusrts [1] by controlling the neuron densities in the cultures. The dynamics of
the SBs are characterized by the firing-rate-time-histogram (FRTH, see Fig. 1 ); with
the shapes of these FRTH corresponding consistently well to different stages of
development of the network. A mean field model based on a recurrent connection J
and short term synaptic plasticity (STSP) is constructed to reproduce these measured
FRTHs. We find that the STSP mechanism [10] is able to reproduce generic features
of the FRTHs only when an additional recycling of neurotransmitters mechanism [11]
characterized by the baseline level of the available neurotransmitter (X0) is included.
A phase diagram in terms of J and X0 shows that networks exhibiting SBs are in an
oscillatory state due to the positive feedback provided by synaptic facilitation and
recurrent network structure. Our finding suggests that, at least for the types of SBs
studied in our experiments, the occurrence of SBs just signals that there are too many
connections in the network; with no relation to information stored in the network.
Materials and Methods
Cell culture.
Neuronal cultures grown on top of multi-electrode arrays (MEA) are used in our
experiments. For cultures preparation [8], cortex tissues are extracted from embryonic
day 18 (E18) Wistar rat embryos. The tissues are digested by 0.125% trypsin and
gentle triturated by a fire-polished Pasteur pipette to isolate cells. A small drop (5 µL)
of cell suspension is added on the MEA (MEA60-200-ITO, Qwane Biosciences) that
has been pre-treated with 0.1% Polyethylenimine, yielding a density of 4 × 104 cells/
mm2. The MEAs are filled with culture medium (DMEM with 5% FBS, 5% HS and
1% penicillin/streptomycin) 30 min after seeding. Samples are incubated at 37 °C with
5% CO2 and half of the medium is changed twice a week.
Firing activities recordings.
Firing activities from the cultures are recorded extracellularly by 60 electrodes (ITO
transparent electrodes with 40 µm diameter and 200 µm spacing, arrangement of 8 × 8
grids without 4 corners) in a MEA 1060-Inv-BC (Multi Channel systems) with 1100X
amplification at a sampling rate of 20 kHz. Firing activities of the cultures are
recorded at 33 °C with 5% CO2 by using MC RACK software (Multi Channel
Systems). Before recording, samples are kept in the recording condition for 10 minutes
for adaptation. Data are recorded with samples in culture medium (CM) [8] for 10
minutes; except for experiments of magnesium free samples which are kept in balanced
salt solution (BSS containing (in mM): 130 NaCl, 5.4 KCl, 1.8 CaCl2, 5.5 Glucose, 20
HEPES with different concentration of MgCl2) [8].
Burst and subburst detection.
The firing activities recorded by the MEA are analyzed by a custom made software
written in MATLAB (The Math-Works, Natick, MA). Low frequency components of
2/12
the data are filtered by high-pass filtering at 200 Hz to remove drifts of the signals.
Spikes are then detected from the filtered data by using a threshold of five standard
deviations of the noise levels for each electrode. A SB is detected if more than 10
spikes occurred within 5 ms and persists for more than 100 ms from all electrodes.
Fig. 1 shows a raster plot and a FRTH of a SB from a typical experiment recorded
by the MEA, which has a burst duration (τB) of the order of one second. From the
raster plot, it can be seen that there seems to be sub-bursts within the SB. In order to
show these sub-bursts clearly, the FRTH with non-overlapping 5 ms time bin from all
the 60 channels is presented in Fig. 1b. Note that, for typical experiments, more than
80% of the spikes recorded from the cultures are distributed inside the synchronized
bursts as shown in the inset of Fig. 1b . Therefore, most the information of the state
of the culture is coded into these sub-bursts in a SB.
x
e
d
n
i
l
e
n
n
a
h
c
60
30
0
40
B
)
z
H
k
(
f
20
0
0.0
IBI
40
20
)
z
H
k
(
f
0
0
60
40
20
time (s)
0.5
time (s)
1.0
Fig 1. Raster plot and its firing-rate-time-histogram of a synchronized
burst. a) Raster plots of spiking events (a dot) in the 60 channels of the MEA as a
function of time. b) Firing-rate-time-histogram (FRTH) in a 5 ms time window
constructed from a) together with the definition of burst duration (τB). The inset
shows the FRTH containing 3 SBs together with the definition of inter-burst interval
(τIBI ).
TMX Model.
During a SB, most of neurons in the cultures are firing synchronously; suggesting that
SB can be treated as a mean-field phenomenon; namely the dynamics of the whole
network is similar to the dynamics of a single cell [12]. With this picture, the
mechanism of these SBs can be understood through the modeling of the mean firing
rate E(t) of a single cell. Below, we extend the Tsodyks-Markram (TM) [10] model of
STSP for this purpose. In the TM model, E(t) of a recurrent network receiving a
3/12
global inhibition I0 is governed by (Supplementary Materials of [10]) :
dE
dt
=
1
τ h−E + α ln(1 + e
J uxE+I0
α
)i
(1)
where α is the threshold of the gain function and u is the release probability of the
available neurotransmitter fraction (x). Note that the positive feedback (JuxE)
contains both the structural (J) and synaptic factors (ux). In the TM model, the
dynamics of the depression and facilitation in the synaptic factors are implemented as:
dx
dt
=
χ0 − x
τD − uxE
du
dt
=
U − u
τF
+ U (1 − u)E.
(2)
(3)
where χ0 and U are the baseline level of x and u respectively. The time scales are:
τ ∼ 10, τD ∼ 100 and τF ∼ 1000 ms. In the original TM model, χ0 = 1, with a big
enough positive feedback (J and U ), the TM model can indeed produce
oscillations [13] with time scales similar to that of the sub-bursts shown in Fig. 2.
However, these oscillations in the TM model will not stop as in a SB.
In order to reproduce our experimental observations, we need to modulate the
amount of the positive feedback to stop the sub-bursts. One could control either x or
u through modulating their base values χ0 or U respectively. Since U controls the
sub-burst oscillations and the recycling of x will be affected due to repeated firings [11],
we choose to control x by introducing a time dependent χ0 which is modeled as:
dχ0
dt
=
X0 − χ0
τX
− βE
(4)
for some baseline constant X0, time constant τX (>> τD) and a fatigue rate constant
β. Here one expects the fatigue rate is an even slower process with β << 1/τX,
representing that prolong firing would render significant portion of the
neurotransmitters not be available [12]. We will refer to this extension as the TMX
model. Note that χ0 is similar to the "super-inactive state" used by Volman [14] to
model reverberations in cultures.
Results
Properties of synchronized bursts.
Similar to other experiments [1], SBs can be observed from the cultures around 7 days
after seeding (7 DIV) and characterized by FRTHs. A remarkable feature of the
FRTHs observed is that FRTHs from different SBs measured within 30 minutes from
the same sample all have similar features. Fig. 2 shows two measured FRTHs from the
same sample within 10 minutes as a function of DIV with one of them being shown in
the insets. That is: the network mechanism responsible for the SB is just repeating
itself during different SBs. Thus, a FRTH constructed from anyone of the SBs can be
used to represent the state of the network.
The measured FRTHs can be classified into three types based on the shapes of the
FRTHs as shown in Fig. 2. In the first type ( < 7 DIV), SBs can be observed with a
low firing rate and there is only one single peak in the FRTH. In the second type (7<
DIV < 20), sub-peaks can be observed within the FRTH. For example, on 9 DIV,
seven sub-bursts can be seen in Fig. 2b. At later DIVs, in the third type (DIV> 20),
the sub-peaks disappear and the SB is then consisted only of a single peak similar to
4/12
12
(a)
)
z
H
k
(
f
0
30
0
30
(b)
(c)
0
0.0
6 DIV
IBI = 54.5 s
9 DIV
IBI = 40.0 s
22 DIV
IBI = 10.0 s
1.0
0.5
time (s)
Fig 2. Structures of FRTH at (a) 6 DIV, (b) 9 DIV and (c) 22 DIV. The
mean τIBI (τIBI ) are also shown in the figures. The insets are the FRTHs of another
SB in the same recording. This classification into three types can be observed in 28
out of 30 samples from 14 dissections.
that of the first stage but at a higher firing and repetition rates. The occurrence of the
SBs increases from ∼0.01 Hz (at 7 DIV) to ∼0.1 Hz (at 20 DIV) as the cultures
mature but the burst duration and the number of spikes within a SB decrease as DIV
increases as shown in Fig. 3.
FRTH under different [Mg2+] .
Fig. 2 shows that different developmental stages of the culture can be represented by
FRTHs with different characteristics. To test the effects of synaptic mechanism on the
features of measured FRTHs, we have also performed experiments with reduced
extracellular magnesium concentrations ( [Mg2+] ) which can modify the efficacy of
synaptic connections through the blocking of the NMDA receptors. Fig. 4 shows the
effects of [Mg2+] on the structure of FRTHs. It shows that sub-bursts within the SB
can be induced by decreasing the [Mg2+] from the normal value of 0.8 to 0 mM. The
FRTHs shown in Fig. 4 have similar properties of those shown in Fig. 2; namely
FRTHs constructed from different SBs share similar features. Fig. 4 shows that the
features in the measured FRTHs are controlled jointly by the network structure (DIV)
and synaptic mechanism.
5/12
200
(a)
0
100
(b)
)
z
H
(
f
)
s
(
0
5000
)
s
t
n
u
o
c
(
n
)
s
(
B
(c)
(d)
4
8
12
16
20
24
DIV
0
1
0
Fig 3. Characteristics of SB at different DIVs. a) Mean firing rate (f ) within
10 min. The f at 22 DIV is twice that at 9 DIV. f is defined as the total number of
spikes (N) divided by the recording time. The error (1/√N ) is smaller than the
symbol. b) Mean inter-burst-interval (τIBI ). Note that the τIBI at 9 DIV is 4 times
that at 22 DIV. c) Average number of spikes within SBs (n) . Error bars of data are
smaller than the symbol. d) Mean burst duration τB. The error bars in the figures are
the standard deviation of the data.
Properties of TMX model.
The TMX model has at least two interesting states. The first one is a low firing rate
(E ∼ O(1)) steady state and the other is a periodic state with E(t) showing sub-burst
oscillations. This latter state is just the persistent oscillatory state of the TM model
now modulated by a time dependent χ0. One can consider the low firing rate state as
the cultures in early DIV with little activities and the periodic E(t) as the system at
later DIV with SBs. Fig. 5 shows a phase diagram for these states in terms of J and
X0. Note that the system will be in the periodic state only when either X0 or J
(positive feedback) is large enough.
Simulation results to mimic DIV.
To demonstrate that this TMX model can reproduce essential features of the FRTHs
observed in experiments, we have shown in Fig. 6 different forms of E(t) produced
from the TMX model to mimic the effects of DIV. The figure shows that there are
sub-bursts within these E(t) and the number of sub-bursts decreases; similar late DIV
FRTH shown in Fig. 2. In addition, the τIBI also decreases, agreeing with the
6/12
100
(a)
)
z
H
k
(
f
50
0
40
20
(b)
0
0.0
IBI = 12.0 s
IBI = 3.0 s
0.5
time (s)
1.0
Fig 4. Effect of [Mg2+] on the FRTH at 34 DIV. (a) In culture medium with
0.8 mM [Mg2+] . (b) In BSS with 0 mM [Mg2+] . The induction of sub-burst shown
here can be observed in 8 out of 10 samples from 6 dissections.
experimental results. Note that the time scale of the E(t) is comparable to that of the
experiments. In order to generate Fig. 6, we have assumed i) J and U increase with
DIV as the cultures become mature and ii) the neurotransmitter re-cycling process
becomes faster as the neuron niche improves [15]. Fig. 6c are the time courses of x, u
and χ0. The figure shows that the interaction between x and u generates the
sub-bursts while the depletion and the recovery of χ0 controls the stop and the start of
the SB. Note that when τD is small (fast recycling), the sub-bursts can get very close
and eventually disappear (Fig. 6d).
To mimic the effects of [Mg2+] on FRTH (Fig. 4), we note that the unblocking
effect of the NMDA receptors by a decrease in [Mg2+] can be viewed as an increase in
effective J which will lead to an increase in firing rate. Since an increase in firing rate
will make the recycling of the neurotransmitters slower [16], the overall effects of a
decrease in [Mg2+] will be modeled in the TMX model as an increase in J and an
increase in τD as shown in the Fig. 7. The inset shows that sub-bursts can indeed be
induced by the lengthening of τD while an increase in J shortens the τIBI ; similar to
our experimental findings.
The success of the TMX model requires the existence of the modulations of
available neurotransmitters (glutamate) χ0. A known mechanism for this modulation
is the uptake and recyling of glutamate from the astrocytes [17] surrounding the
synapses. These astrocytes will convert the uptaken glutamate to glutamine and then
transfer the glutamine back to a presynaptic neuron. The modulation of χ0 in the
TMX model is most likely related to this process. To test this idea, experiments are
performed with dihydrokainate (DHK); an astrocytic glutamate transporter (GLT-1)
7/12
0
X
1.0
0.9
0.8
0.7
steady state
20
E
10
0
0
time (s)
50
oscillatory state
20
E
10
0
20
time (s)
70
4
5
6
7
J
Fig 5. Minimal X0 for eliciting an oscillatory firing for a given value of J
for U = 0.3 and τD = 0.15 s . Other parameters are τX = 20 s, I0 = −1.3, β = 0.01,
τ = 0.013 s, τF = 1.5 s and α = 1.5. The insets show the characteristic of E(t) (in Hz)
in the steady and the oscillatory states.
blocker [17]. Since the blocking of GLT-1 will retard the glutamate uptake, the
blocking will produce an increase of τX in the TMX model. When τX is increased in
TMX model, one will expected an increase in inter-burst interval τIBI . In fact, this
prediction is supported by our experiments with DHK as shown in Fig. 8 which is a
measurement of τIBI as a function of DHK concentration. The inset of Fig. 8 is the
corresponding simulation result from the TMX model. These results demonstrate that
the TMX model is consistent with the recycling of glutamate by astrocytes.
Discussion
Although the TMX model can capture some essential features of the dynamics of SBs
observed in our experiments, the periodicity of E(t) predicted are not seen in
experiments. It is because the mean-field nature of the TMX model will work only
when the system is synchronized. When the culture is in the low firing state before the
occurrence of SB, the dynamics of the network cannot be described by a mean-field
and the firing of a particular neuron in the system can triggered a SB. In this case, we
do not expect to see the periodic generation of SBs.
Also, Eqn(4) of the TMX model to take into account the effects of glia is purely
phenomenological. It is needed to stop the oscillations of the TM model by a depletion
of available neuro-transmitters. The form of Eqn(4) is only one of many possible
forms. Its dependence on E and the empirical values of the constants τχ and β
8/12
E (a)
20
10
0
10
0
(b)
(c)
E
u
&
x
0.5
E
0.1
10 (d)
0
0
0.6
0
0.3
5
15
10
time (s)
20
25
Fig 6. Time courses of E(t) (in Hz) of the TMX model to mimic the FRTH
at different DIV. (a) J = 4.8, τD = 0.2 s and U = 0.28. (b) J = 5.8, τD = 0.15 s
and U = 0.3. (d) J = 6.8, τD = 0.1 s and U = 0.32. (c) Corresponding time courses of
x (blue dash-dot), u (red dot) and χ0 (green) for time course (b). Other parameters
are the same as Fig. 5.
remained to be measured by further experiments. However, the main idea here is that
we have given a concrete example to support the long standing hypothesis that glia
can take part in the regulation of the overall activity of a neural network. In this case,
the involvement of glia turns a non-stopping oscillation into bursts.
Conclusion
Several studies have shown that network connectivity and synaptic depression are
critical parameters to control burst appearance [18]. Our TMX model is consistent
with these findings if connections and synapses efficacy increases in the network as the
culture matures [19]. However, the effect of neurotransmitter recycling in the TMX
model, which has not been considered before, is essential for the understanding of
experimental observations of sub-bursts within a burst. Furthermore, since the forms
of bursts in the TMX model are controlled by the intrinsic parameters of the synapses,
information written to the network will be wiped out by these endogenous bursts. In
our view, these SB cannot be used to carry information of the system and perform
computation as believed. Since SBs can also be observed in an acute slice preparation
from a functional brain only when the effective recurrent connections are artificially
increased by the lowering of [Mg2+] (a non-physiological condition [20]), the existence
of SBs in a neuronal system might signal that it is perhaps in a pathological state such
as epilepsy which is also characterized by synchronized firing over large area of the
9/12
)
z
H
(
E
15
10
5
0
10
5
0
0
5
10
15
time (s)
20
25
Fig 7. Time courses of E(t) (in Hz) of the TMX model to mimic different
magnesium treatment . E(t) (in Hz) from the TMX model for situations of a)
normal [Mg2+] : J = 6.8 and τD = 0.1 s and b) low [Mg2+] : J = 7.8 and τD = 0.15 s.
Other parameters are τX = 20 s, I0 = −1.3, β = 0.01, τ = 0.013 s, τF = 1.5 s and
α = 1.5.
brain. The fact that the SBs are generated spontaneously in our 2D cultures under
physiological [Mg2+] suggests that there might already be too many connections in the
network and therefore not suitable for the study of normal functions of a neuronal
system.
Acknowledgments
This work has been supported by the MOST of ROC under the grant nos. NSC
100-2923-M-001-008-MY3, 101-2112-M-008-004-MY3 and NCTS of Taiwan.
References
1. Wagenaar DA, Pine J, Potter SM. An extremely rich repertoire of bursting
patterns during the development of cortical cultures. BMC neuroscience.
2006;7(1):1.
2. Segev R, Baruchi I, Hulata E, Ben-Jacob E. Hidden neuronal correlations in
cultured networks. Physical Review Letters. 2004;92(11):118102.
3. Hulata E, Baruchi I, Segev R, Shapira Y, Ben-Jacob E. Self-regulated
complexity in cultured neuronal networks. Physical review letters.
2004;92(19):198105.
10/12
40
30
)
s
(
)
s
(
20
10
0
20
15
10
5
0
16
20
24
28
32
x
100 200 300 400 500
DHK ( M)
Fig 8. Measurement of τIBI as a function of concentration of DHK
(astrocyte glutamate uptake inhibitor) for a culture at 33 DIV. Similar
results can be observed 5 out of 6 samples from 3 dissections. The inset shows the
dependence of τIBI on τX in the TMX model. Other parameters are X0 = 0.95,
J = 5.8, U = 0.3, I0 = −1.3, β = 0.01, τ = 0.013 s, τD = 0.15 s, τF = 1.5 s and α = 1.5
.
4. Choi JH, Kim JH, Heo R, Lee KJ. Modulating the precision of recurrent bursts
in cultured neural networks. Physical review letters. 2012;108(13):138103.
5. Baruchi I, Ben-Jacob E. Towards neuro-memory-chip: imprinting multiple
memories in cultured neural networks. Physical Review E. 2007;75(5):050901.
6. Schuster HG, Just W. Deterministic chaos: an introduction. John Wiley &
Sons; 2006.
7. Cohen E, Ivenshitz M, Amor-Baroukh V, Greenberger V, Segal M.
Determinants of spontaneous activity in networks of cultured hippocampus.
Brain research. 2008;1235:21 -- 30.
8. Jia L, Sano M, Lai PY, Chan C. Connectivities and synchronous firing in
cortical neuronal networks. Physical review letters. 2004;93(8):088101.
9. Lau PM, Bi GQ. Synaptic mechanisms of persistent reverberatory activity in
neuronal networks. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the
United States of America. 2005;102(29):10333 -- 10338.
11/12
10. Mongillo G, Barak O, Tsodyks M. Synaptic theory of working memory. Science.
2008;319(5869):1543 -- 1546.
11. Hennig MH. Theoretical models of synaptic short term plasticity. Neural
Information Processing with Dynamical Synapses. 2015; p. 5.
12. Zhan X, Lai PY, Chan C. Effects of glial release and somatic receptors on
bursting in synchronized neuronal networks. Physical Review E.
2011;84(1):011907.
13. Cortes JM, Desroches M, Rodrigues S, Veltz R, Munoz MA, Sejnowski TJ.
Short-term synaptic plasticity in the deterministic Tsodyks -- Markram model
leads to unpredictable network dynamics. Proceedings of the National Academy
of Sciences. 2013;110(41):16610 -- 16615.
14. Volman V, Gerkin RC, Lau PM, Ben-Jacob E, Bi GQ. Calcium and synaptic
dynamics underlying reverberatory activity in neuronal networks. Physical
biology. 2007;4(2):91.
15. Sara Y, Mozhayeva MG, Liu X, Kavalali ET. Fast vesicle recycling supports
neurotransmission during sustained stimulation at hippocampal synapses. The
Journal of neuroscience. 2002;22(5):1608 -- 1617.
16. Fesce R, Grohovaz F, Valtorta F, Meldolesi J. Neurotransmitter release: fusion
or 'kiss-and-run' ? Trends in cell biology. 1994;4(1):1 -- 4.
17. Anderson CM, Swanson RA. Astrocyte glutamate transport: review of
properties, regulation, and physiological functions. Glia. 2000;32(1):1 -- 14.
18. Maheswaranathan N, Ferrari S, VanDongen AM, Henriquez C. Emergent
bursting and synchrony in computer simulations of neuronal cultures. Frontiers
in computational neuroscience. 2012;6:15.
19. Poli D, Pastore VP, Massobrio P. Functional connectivity in in vitro neuronal
assemblies. Frontiers in neural circuits. 2015;9.
20. Voss LJ, Sleigh JW. Stability of brain neocortical slice seizure-like activity
during low-magnesium exposure: measurement and effect of artificial
cerebrospinal fluid temperature. Journal of neuroscience methods.
2010;192(2):214 -- 218.
12/12
|
0810.2784 | 4 | 0810 | 2009-07-14T21:11:20 | TeV Gamma Rays from Geminga and the Origin of the GeV Positron Excess | [
"astro-ph",
"hep-ph"
] | The Geminga pulsar has long been one of the most intriguing MeV-GeV gamma-ray point sources. We examine the implications of the recent Milagro detection of extended, multi-TeV gamma-ray emission from Geminga, finding that this reveals the existence of an ancient, powerful cosmic-ray accelerator that can plausibly account for the multi-GeV positron excess that has evaded explanation. We explore a number of testable predictions for gamma-ray and electron/positron experiments (up to ~100 TeV) that can confirm the first "direct" detection of a cosmic-ray source. | astro-ph | astro-ph | TeV Gamma Rays from Geminga and the Origin of the GeV Positron Excess
1Bartol Research Institute and Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Delaware, Newark, Delaware 19716
2Center for Cosmology and Astro-Particle Physics and Department of Physics, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio 43210
Hasan Yuksel,1 Matthew D. Kistler,2 and Todor Stanev1
(Dated: May 5, 2009)
The Geminga pulsar has long been one of the most intriguing MeV -- GeV gamma-ray point sources.
We examine the implications of the recent Milagro detection of extended, multi-TeV gamma-ray
emission from Geminga, finding that this reveals the existence of an ancient, powerful cosmic-ray
accelerator that can plausibly account for the multi-GeV positron excess that has evaded explana-
tion. We explore a number of testable predictions for gamma-ray and electron/positron experiments
(up to ∼ 100 TeV) that can confirm the first "direct" detection of a cosmic-ray source.
9
0
0
2
l
u
J
4
1
]
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
[
4
v
4
8
7
2
.
0
1
8
0
:
v
i
X
r
a
PACS numbers: 95.85.Ry, 98.70.Rz, 98.70.-f
Introduction. -- Geminga holds a place of distinction
among gamma-ray sources, being the first pulsar to be
discovered through gamma rays, with a history of obser-
vations through a variety of techniques [1]. While one
of the brightest MeV -- GeV gamma-ray point sources in
the sky, there was no certain evidence of high-energy ac-
tivity beyond the immediate neighborhood of the pulsar
or its x-ray pulsar wind nebula (PWN) until the recent
detection by Milagro of gamma rays at ∼ 20 TeV from
a region of ∼ 3◦ around the pulsar [2, 3]. This detection
places Geminga among the growing class of TeV PWNe
(e.g., [4, 5]) and is important for understanding aged pul-
sars and their winds. An immediate consequence is the
existence of a population of high-energy particles.
The relative proximity of Geminga raises an interesting
possibility, namely that these high-energy particles, most
likely electrons and positrons, may be at the root of the
explanation of the "positron excess", the observed [6, 7,
8] overabundance of multi-GeV positrons as compared
to theoretical expectations [9] (see Fig. 1). Severe energy
losses of high-energy positrons require a local source of
some kind [10], such as Geminga [11] or even dark matter
through its annihilation products [12].
Here, we connect the Milagro TeV gamma-ray "halo"
to electrons and positrons with energies up to at least
100 TeV, expected to be accelerated in PWNe (e.g.,
[13, 14]; for a review see [15]), and present several pre-
dictions. Principally, while Geminga is apparently young
enough to still produce high-energy particles, it is old
enough that multi-GeV electrons and positrons from its
more active past could have made it to Earth. The ex-
tended gamma-ray emission is strong evidence for e± pro-
duction, acceleration, and escape, suggesting an explana-
tion of the positron excess. Moreover, this single nearest
high-energy astrophysical source can reasonably account
for the e− + e+ spectrum as measured by Fermi [16] and
HESS [17, 18] with an extension to energies beyond sev-
eral TeV, where no signal might be expected otherwise.
The Gamma-ray Source Next Door. -- The observation
of high-energy gamma rays from an astrophysical source
implies the presence of higher-energy particles, typically
e± or protons, that gave rise to them. One striking ele-
ment of the observation of ∼ 20 TeV gamma rays (with a
significance of 4.9 σ in the PSF-smoothed map [2], 6.3 σ
for an extended source [3]) from Geminga by Milagro is
the extent of the emission, θ ∼ 3◦ [2], which corresponds
to a physical size of sG ∼ 10 pc (θG/3◦)(rG/200 pc),
where rG is the distance to Geminga. Since the angu-
lar resolution of Milagro is better than a degree and the
characteristic age of the pulsar, tG ∼ 3 × 105 yr [19],
seemingly excludes a typical TeV supernova remnant, we
shall consider an extended PWN with emission from a
much larger region than seen in x-rays [20, 21]. We will
draw guidance from the TeV-PWN HESS J1825 -- 137 [4],
which, while only a tenth the age of Geminga, would
appear tens of degrees wide if placed at rG ∼ 200 pc.
We first examine whether the gamma rays can be ex-
plained through inverse-Compton (IC) up-scattering of
)
+
e
+
-
e
(
/
+
e
0.3
0.1
0.03
0.01
0.1
PAMELA 2008
HEAT Combined
Clem 2006
AMS-01 1998*
AMS-01 1998
CAPRICE 1994
Golden 1993
100
103
1
10
E [GeV]
FIG. 1: The cosmic-ray positron fraction. Shown are data
compiled from Refs. [7, 8, 31, 34], and scenarios based on the
secondary model of Ref. [9] (shaded) and a plausible Geminga
contribution (solid, dashed, and dotted lines) dependent upon
distance and energetics (see text for details).
cosmic microwave background (CMB) photons by e±.
Note that the pulsar age exceeds the IC cooling time on
CMB photons of the >
∼ 100 TeV e± needed to produce
>
∼ 20 TeV gamma rays, τIC ∼ 104(100 TeV/Ee) yr in the
Thomson limit. Including synchrotron losses further de-
creases τcool, implying fresh e± production. To account
for the Milagro measurement of 6.9 ± 1.6 × 10−15 TeV−1
cm−2 s−1 at 20 TeV (see Fig. 2), we consider a generic
parent e± spectrum of the form dN/dγ ∝ γ−αe−γ/γmax,
with γ = E/(mec2). Lacking more detailed observa-
tions, we choose Emin = 1 GeV, Emax = 200 TeV and
α = 2 (typical to shock acceleration and as inferred in
the Vela X PWN [5]). The resulting IC spectrum is
dΦ
dEγ
=
c
GZ dγZ dEb
4πr2
dN
dγ
nb(Eb) σKN(γ, Eb, Eγ), (1)
where the Klein-Nishina cross section, σKN, is given by
Ref. [22]. The dominant scattering background, nb(Eb),
in the Milagro energy range is the CMB, allowing us to
construct the minimal spectrum shown in Fig. 2 (at lower
energies, other contributions become relevant). When we
normalize the IC spectrum to the Milagro TeV gamma-
ray luminosity of Eγ,TeV ∼ 1032 erg s−1 (for rG ∼ 200 pc),
at least Ee± ∼ 1045 erg of e± is required.
We can relate this phenomenological spectrum to
NGJ ≃
the pulsar. The Goldreich-Julian flux [13] is
B Ω2 R3/ec. For Geminga, R ≃ 10 km, B ≃ 1.6×1012 G,
and Ω ≃ 26.5 s−1 [19], which yield NGJ ≃ 1032 s−1.
For our E−2
e± spectrum, hEe± i ≈ 15 GeV. The total
power is then Ee± ≈ Ne± hEe± i ≈ M NGJ hEe± i ≈
2×1030 M erg s−1, where M = Ne± / NGJ is the pair mul-
tiplicity. For a pure electron flow (M ≃ 1), the power
beyond 10 TeV is only ∼ 5 × 1029 erg s−1 ≪ Eγ,TeV,
thus requiring pair production resulting in M >
∼ 100.
Including synchrotron losses comparable to IC increases
the required M. This can only be avoided by assuming
]
1
-
s
2
-
m
c
V
e
T
[
γ
E
d
/
Φ
d
γ
2
E
10-10
10-11
10-12
10-13
e±
γ
10-14
0.01
Milagro
1044
1043
1042
]
V
e
T
[
±
e
E
d
/
N
d
±
E
2 e
1041
0.1
1
10
100
1000
E [TeV]
1040
104
FIG. 2: Minimal inverse-Compton gamma-ray spectrum of
the extended emission from Geminga (shaded) and the Mi-
lagro measurement at 20 TeV (left axis). Also, the energy
distribution (dotted line) of the associated e
± (right axis).
2
a spectrum much-harder than E−2
(both inconsistent with, e.g., Vela X [5, 23]).
e± or Emin > 100 GeV
While we have been trying to explain the observed sig-
nal alone, there may well be more lower surface bright-
ness emission at larger angles, and also at lower energies.
Two considerations make this likely. First, the pulsar's
e± output was probably much stronger in the past when
its spin-down power was higher. Secondly, no evidence of
a large-scale radio or x-ray nebula exists, and a substan-
tial fraction of the e± may be escaping, so that the above
multiplicity is only a lower limit. M ∼ 104 (as inferred
for younger TeV PWNe [23] or pulsar models [24]) does
not exceed the spin-down power of ∼ 1034.5 erg s−1 [19],
so that a large pair conversion fraction is possible.
The Origin of the Positron Excess. -- The confirmed
presence of a nearby, ancient source of high-energy elec-
trons and positrons immediately suggests an explanation
for the positron excess. If so, then we would essentially
be living "within" the extended halo of the source, seeing
e± that were accelerated long ago when the pulsar was
stronger. The density of particles at a given time and
place, n(r, t, γ), is governed by the diffusion equation,
which (in spherically symmetric geometry) is
∂ n
∂t
=
D(γ)
r2
∂
∂r
r2 ∂ n
∂r
+
∂
∂γ
[ℓ(γ) n] + Q(γ) ,
(2)
In our range of interest,
where Q is the source term.
the energy loss rate is well approximated by ℓ(γ) = ℓ0γ2.
Considering IC losses on the CMB (energy density ∼
0.3 eV cm−3) and synchrotron losses due to a ∼ 3 µG
magnetic field (∼ 0.2 eV cm−3) yields ℓ0 ≃ 5×10−20 s−1.
Calculations that assess the positron flux from dark
matter annihilation typically assume steady-state con-
ditions (i.e., ignoring the time-dependent term). How-
ever, our scenario is manifestly dynamic, with both the
source luminosity and distance potentially changing with
time. The analytic solution given by Atoyan, Aharonian,
and Volk [25] allows for this to be conveniently handled.
Their diffusion coefficient is D(γ) = D0(1 + γ/γ∗)δ, with
γ∗ ≃ 6 × 103 [25]. In the limit of a single burst from a
point source, Q(γ) = dN/dγ δ(r) δ(t − tG), with
n(r, t, γ) =
dN/dγ
π3/2 r3
[r/rd(t, γ)]3 e−[r/rd(t,γ)]2
(1 − ℓ0 t γ)2−α
.
(3)
where the spectrum is cut off at γc = 1/(ℓ0 t). The energy
loss rate and age then set the maximal energy of particles
that reach us today, with a diffusion radius of
rd(t, γ) ≃ 2(cid:0)D(γ) t [1 − (1 − γ/γc)1−δ]/[(1 − δ)γ/γc](cid:1)1/2
For tG ∼ 3 × 105 yr, D0 ≃ 4 × 1027 cm2s−1, and δ = 0.4
(intermediate between δ = 1/3 and 1/2 [26]), the diffu-
sion radius is rd ≃ 150, 175, 250 pc for E = 2, 10, 50 GeV
particles, respectively, so multi-GeV particles are now ar-
riving. We caution against extrapolating to small radius,
.
103
102
]
1
-
r
s
1
-
s
2
-
2
m
V
e
G
[
)
E
(
J
E
3
Fermi 2009
HESS 2009
HESS 2008
ATIC-1,2 2008
PPB BETS 2008
AMS-01
Total
Galactic e-
Geminga e+ + e-
101
10
100
1000
E [GeV]
104
− + e
+ data from Fermi [16], HESS [17,
−-only data [34]; with Galac-
− model modified from Ref. [9] (solid), contributions from
FIG. 3: Cosmic-ray e
18], and Refs. [48, 49] and AMS e
tic e
Geminga (lower lines), and total (upper lines).
since the diffusion solution may transition [27] to a wind-
like n ∝ r−2 form (as does HESS J1825 -- 137 [4]) near the
source, although the data allow no firm conclusions.
For a continuously emitting source such as Geminga,
the injection rate can be parametrized as d N /dγ ∝
Le± (t)γ−αe−γ/γmax, with Le± the e± luminosity. The lo-
cal particle density is n⊙(γ) = R tG dt n(rG, t, γ). Assum-
ing braking via magnetic dipole radiation, the spin-down
luminosity evolves as ∝ (1 + t/t0)−2 [28], with a pulsar-
dependent timescale, t0, and Le± (t) = (EG/tG) [1 + (tG −
t)/t0]−2/R tG dt′[1 + (tG − t′)/t0]−2. For t0 ∼ 3 × 104 yr,
the present spin-down power, ∼ 1034.5 erg s−1, corre-
sponds to an upper limit on the total e± output of
∼ 5 × 1048 erg (larger for smaller t0 [25]). Geminga's
transverse velocity is ∼ 200 km s−1 [29]. A similar radial
velocity would result in a ∼ 100 pc displacement in tG.
In Fig. 3, we display the local flux of e− + e+,
J⊙ = (c/4π) n⊙, from our benchmark model of α = 2,
within a reasonable range of parameters. These have dis-
tances varying (from birth → present) as rG = 150 →
250 pc, 220 pc, 250 → 200 pc; e± energy budgets of
EG = 1 , 2 , 3 × 1048 erg; and δ = 0.4 , 0.5 , 0.6, respec-
tively (lower dotted, solid, dashed lines). The energy in
e± estimated for several younger TeV PWN are at least
as large as these (e.g., [4, 5, 23]). Since the bulk of the
energy is released in this early spin-down phase, the ini-
tial location is the most important. Adding to these the
primary e− spectrum of Moskalenko and Strong [9], with
the normalization decreased by 35% and an added ex-
ponential cutoff at 2 TeV (in order to not exceed HESS
data), yields the total e− + e+ flux (upper lines).
The spectral feature at ∼ 1 TeV naturally results from
a combination of energy losses and pulsar age and dis-
tance (see Fig. 4 of Ref. [11] for comparison). The multi-
3
TeV extension (beyond the last HESS point) is due to the
continuous injection of particles, as evidenced by the Mi-
lagro observations today. Combining these with the ex-
pectations for the secondary e± fluxes [9] (see also [30]),
we compare our positron fraction to measurements in
Fig. 1 (note that solar modulation may account for dis-
agreements between data below ∼ 10 GeV [8, 31]).
It is thus plausible that Geminga is the long-sought [32]
local source of electrons and positrons, influencing the
spectra measured by Fermi [16] (down to tens of GeV)
and HESS [17, 18] in the TeV, although we emphasize
that certain parameters and the underlying Galactic pri-
mary spectrum remain uncertain. The PAMELA [33]
and AMS [34] experiments can measure the e− and e+
spectra separately to isolate this component (since the
e− spectrum from Geminga should be identical to the
e+).
Conclusions. -- The discovery of high-energy gamma
rays from an extended region around Geminga by Mila-
gro reveals the presence of >
∼ 100 TeV e±, as observed
indirectly within the x-ray PWN [20, 21]. A considerable
amount of data should become available as new experi-
ments examine the surrounding area. This will help in
developing more detailed models that account for both
time and spatial evolution in the e± spectra, directly
coupled to cosmic-ray propagation [35]. One need is a
better-determined distance, the most recent quoted be-
ing rG ∼ 250+120
−62 pc [29]. We briefly discuss implications
for several categories of experiments.
Fermi: While the observed features of Geminga will
depend upon details such as whether the source is roughly
spherical or preferentially oriented, we would generally
expect the source to become "larger" with decreasing
energy, reflecting the decrease in IC cooling time with
energy. Our inspection of the point-source subtracted
sky map from EGRET [36] indicates emission in the
GeV range of a size comparable to the Milagro source.
Fermi [37] should be able to more effectively separate the
bright pulsed signal to study diffuse emission.
TeV gamma rays: Obtaining a detailed spectrum and
morphology of the source in the TeV regime will be vi-
tal for further interpretation of the nature of the parti-
cles present. Already, VERITAS [38] has placed rather-
tight upper limits on a point source at the location of
Geminga [39]. Further study of the expected extended
source is needed to better estimate the total energet-
ics. In HESS J1825 -- 137, the surface brightness was seen
to drop off as ∼ 1/θ, inconsistent with pure diffusion
and suggestive of convection, and the gamma-ray spec-
trum was measured to soften with increasing distance
from its pulsar [4]. We expect similar behavior from
Geminga if the same mechanisms are at work, the lat-
ter of which would be a distinct signature of e± cool-
ing [4]. Also, studying the extended TeV emission from
an old, radio-quiet neutron star should have implications
for some heretofore unidentified TeV sources.
Electrons and Positrons: Due to the spin down of the
pulsar, it is possible that the Geminga source was much
brighter in the past and dominated the TeV sky. It is
from this time that multi-GeV e± may still be reaching us
today. If Geminga does account for a substantial fraction
of the total e− + e+ spectrum, a mild anisotropy may be
present [40, 41]. Since the distance to Geminga does
not greatly exceed the scale for field fluctuations of ∼
100 pc [26], with detailed multi-wavelength studies, local
diffusion parameters might be determined (which may
differ from global values estimated across the Galaxy).
Additionally, as Geminga remains a source of ∼ 100 TeV
e±, it may result in a > 10 TeV lepton flux at Earth.
Neutrinos: The gamma rays might be produced via
the decay of neutral pions produced in hadronic scatter-
ing [42] if a nucleonic wind carries away the spin-down
energy (as proposed [43] for Vela X; but see Ref. [23]).
However, this requires ∼ 1047−48 erg of protons to be
present and confined for >
∼ 105 yr (likely confining e± as
well), disfavoring this scenario. There would also be a
neutrino flux from charged pions. This would be simi-
lar to MGRO J2019+37 [44], so that IceCube [45] would
expect >
∼ 1 (0.2) neutrino-induced muon per year with en-
ergy > 1 (10) TeV (see [46]). An improved measurement
of the source extent is needed to estimate the atmospheric
background, which can exceed this rate for a radius much
larger than a degree [45]. Even if no neutrinos are found,
IceCube will be able to provide valuable constraints [47].
We thank John Beacom, Jim Beatty, John Clem, Tom
Gaisser, Francis Halzen, Jamie Holder, Carsten Rott, and
Todd Thompson for discussions; Felix Aharonian, An-
drew Strong, and our Referees for comments. HY and
TS are supported by DOE Grant DE-FG02-91ER40626;
MDK by DOE Grant DE-FG02-91ER40690.
4
A. Tylka, Phys. Rev. Lett. 63, 840 (1989); S. Rudaz
and F. W. Stecker, Astrophys. J. 325, 16 (1988); M.
Kamionkowski and M. S. Turner, Phys. Rev. D 43, 1774
(1991); E. A. Baltz and J. Edsjo, Phys. Rev. D 59, 023511
(1998); J. L. Feng et al., Phys. Rev. D 63, 045024 (2001);
D. Hooper and J. Silk, Phys. Rev. D 71, 083503 (2005).
[13] P. Goldreich and W. H. Julian, Astrophys. J. 157, 869
(1969).
[14] M. J. Rees and J. E. Gunn, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc.
167, 1 (1974); C. F. Kennel and F. V. Coroniti, Astro-
phys. J. 283, 694 (1984).
[15] B. M. Gaensler and P. O. Slane, Ann. Rev. Astron. As-
trophys. 44, 17 (2006); J. Arons, arXiv:0708.1050.
[16] A. A. Abdo et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 181101 (2009).
[17] F. Aharonian et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 261104 (2008).
[18] F. Aharonian et al., arXiv:0905.0105.
[19] J. H. Taylor et al., Astrophys. J. Suppl. 88, 529 (1993).
[20] P. A. Caraveo et al., Science 301, 1345 (2003).
[21] G. G. Pavlov et al., Astrophys. J. 643, 1146 (2006).
[22] G. R. Blumenthal and R. J. Gould, Rev. Mod. Phys. 42,
237 (1970).
[23] O. C. de Jager, Astrophys. J. 658, 1177 (2007).
[24] B. Zhang and A. K. Harding, Astrophys. J. 532, 1150
(2000); J. A. Hibschman and J. Arons, Astrophys. J.
560, 871 (2001).
[25] A. M. Atoyan et al., Phys. Rev. D 52, 3265, (1995).
[26] A. W. Strong et al., Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 57, 285
(2007).
[27] R. Aloisio et al., Astrophys. J. 693, 1275 (2009).
[28] J. E. Gunn and J. P. Ostriker, Nature 221, 454 (1969).
[29] J. Faherty et al., Astrophys. Space Sci. 308, 225 (2007).
[30] T. Delahaye et al., arXiv:0809.5268.
[31] J. Clem and P. Evenson, Proc. 30th Intl. Cosmic Ray
Conf. 1, 477 (2008).
[32] C. S. Shen, Astrophys. J. 162, L181 (1970).
[33] M. Casolino et al., Adv. Space Res. 42, 455 (2008).
[34] M. Aguilar et al., Phys. Lett. B 646, 145 (2007).
[35] F. A. Aharonian, Very High Energy Cosmic Gamma Ra-
diation, (World Scientific, 2004).
[36] A. Cillis and R. Hartman, Astrophys. J. 621, 291 (2005).
[37] N. Gehrels and P. Michelson, Astropart. Phys. 11, 277
(1999).
[38] T. C. Weekes et al., Astropart. Phys. 17, 221 (2002).
[39] G. Maier [VERITAS collaboration], arXiv:0810.0515.
[40] I. Buesching et al., Astrophys. J. 678, L39 (2008).
[41] D. Hooper et al., JCAP 0901, 025 (2009).
[42] T. K. Gaisser, Cosmic Rays and Particle Physics, (Cam-
[1] G. F. Bignami and P. A. Caraveo, Ann. Rev. Astron.
bridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, 1990).
Astrophys. 34, 331 (1996).
[2] A. A. Abdo et al., Astrophys. J. 664, L91 (2007).
[3] A. A. Abdo et al., arXiv:0904.1018.
[4] F. Aharonian et al., Astron. Astrophys. 460, 365 (2006).
[5] F. Aharonian et al., Astron. Astrophys. 448, L43 (2006).
[6] S. W. Barwick et al., Astrophys. J. 482, L191 (1997).
[7] J. J. Beatty et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 241102 (2004).
[8] O. Adriani et al., Nature, 458, 607 (2009).
[9] I. V. Moskalenko and A. W. Strong, Astrophys. J. 493,
694 (1998).
[10] S. Coutu et al., Astropart. Phys. 11, 429 (1999).
[11] F. Aharonian et al., Astron. Astrophys. 294, L41 (1995).
[12] J. Silk and M. Srednicki, Phys. Rev. Lett. 53, 624 (1984);
[43] D. Horns et al., Astron. Astrophys. 451, L51 (2006).
[44] A. A. Abdo et al., Astrophys. J. 658, L33 (2007).
[45] J. Ahrens et al., Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 118, 388
(2003); J. Ahrens et al., Astropart. Phys. 20, 507 (2004).
[46] J. F. Beacom and M. D. Kistler, Phys. Rev. D 75, 083001
(2007); L. Anchordoqui et al., Phys. Rev. D 76, 067301
(2007); M. D. Kistler and J. F. Beacom, Phys. Rev. D
74, 063007 (2006).
[47] R. Abbasi et al., Phys. Rev. D 79, 062001 (2009).
[48] S. Torii et al., arXiv:0809.0760.
[49] J. Chang et al., Nature 456, 362 (2008).
|
0810.1609 | 1 | 0810 | 2008-10-09T09:39:34 | Can opacity changes help to reproduce the hybrid star pulsations? | [
"astro-ph"
] | Hybrid stars like Nu Eridani and 12 Lacertae show two different types of pulsations: (i) low-order acoustic and gravity modes of the Beta Cephei type with periods of about 3-6 hours, and (ii) high-order gravity modes of the SPB type with periods of about 1.5-3 days. Theoretical computations using both OPAL and OP opacity data well reproduce short period low-order pulsations of the Beta Cep type and show a tendency to instability of high-order gravity modes, especially for stellar models built with the OP opacities. However, instability at observed long periods has not been achieved. We test effects of artificial opacity modifications in the deep envelope on the instability of some hybrid star models. For Nu Eri models, an opacity increase both in the Z opacity bump region at temperature of about 200 000 K and in the region of the deeper opacity bump at temperature of about 2-2.5 million degrees (this bump is also mainly due to excited ions of the iron-group elements) may result in instability of the high-order gravity modes with the observed periods. The shortest observed period of 3 hours can also be excited in modified models. However, the required opacity increase seems to be quite large (up to 2 times in some stellar layers) which may be incompatible with atomic physics. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Comm. in Asteroseismology
Contribution to the Proceedings of the Wroclaw HELAS Workshop, 2008
8
0
0
2
t
c
O
9
]
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
[
1
v
9
0
6
1
.
0
1
8
0
:
v
i
X
r
a
Can opacity changes help to reproduce the hybrid star pulsations?
T. Zdravkov1 & A. A. Pamyatnykh1
,
2
1 N. Copernicus Astronomical Center, ul. Bartycka 18, 00-716 Warsaw, Poland
2 Institute of Astronomy, Russian Academy of Science, Pyatniskaya Str. 48, 109017 Moscow, Russia
Hybrid stars like ν Eri and 12 Lac show two different types of pulsations: (i) low-order acoustic
and gravity modes of β Cephei type with periods of about 3 − 6 hours, and (ii) high-order
gravity modes of the SPB type with periods of about 1.5 − 3 days. Seismic models of ν Eri
(Pamyatnykh et al. 2004, Dziembowski & Pamyatnykh 2008) using both OPAL (Iglesias
& Rogers 1996) and OP (Seaton 2005) opacity data well reproduce the observed range of
short period low-order pulsations of the β Cep type and also show a tendency to instability
of long period high-order gravity modes. With the OP data, the instability of the quadrupole
(ℓ = 2) high-order gravity modes was found, but at slightly shorter periods than those
observed. Trying to reproduce both short and long period ranges of the ν Eri pulsations, we
tested the effects of artificial 50 % opacity enhancement around the metal opacity bump at
log T ≈ 5.3 − 5.5, as it is shown on Fig. 1. Models were computed using the OP opacities
log k
model 1
model 3
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
-0.2
-0.4
model 1: k , X=0.70
M=9.625M(cid:1), Z=0.0185, log T
=4.336
eff
model 2: k *1.5, X=0.70
M=9.732M(cid:1), Z=0.0171, log T
=4.340
eff
model 3: k *1.5, X=0.69
M=9.641M(cid:1), Z=0.0174, log T
=4.341
eff
7.0
6.5
6.0
5.5
5.0
4.5
log T
Figure 1: Opacity behavior inside non-modified (1) and modified models (2, 3). Model 2 follows the line
of Model 3, for clearance it was not depicted.
and new solar proportions in the heavy element abundances (A04, see Asplund et al. 2005).
In all models, the frequencies of radial fundamental and two dipole modes (g1 and p1) were
fitted to the observed values with accuracy better than 0.0005 c/d. As we may see, in Fig. 1,
the opacity enhancement in the modified models is less than 50 %, because the fitted models
differ in metal abundances and other parameters.
As a result of the opacity enhancements, Model 3 is very close to have unstable dipole
high order gravity modes at the observed frequency range (Fig. 2). Also, the range of the
unstable short period modes is in a better agreement with the observations.
In addition, a
small decrease of the hydrogen abundance (X = 0.69 instead of X = 0.70) allows to achieve
also a good frequency fit of the ℓ = 1, p2 mode to the observed value of 7.898 c/d.
We note however that the required opacity increase, by 50 % in the Z bump, appears
larger than allowed by uncertainties in current opacity calculations. A similar improvement in
2
Can opacity changes help to reproduce the hybrid star pulsations?
l=1
model 1: X=0.70, Z=0.0185
model 3: X=0.69, Z=0.0174
l=2
0.4
0.2
0.0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
frequency [c/d]
Figure 2: The normalized growth rates, η, of ℓ = 1 and ℓ = 2 modes as a function of mode frequency
in seismic models of ν Eri (η > 0 for unstable modes). Vertical lines mark the observed frequencies
(Jerzykiewicz et al. 2005), with amplitudes given in a logarithmic scale. In all models, the frequencies of
radial fundamental and two dipole modes (g1 and p1) fit the observed values at 5.763, 5.637 and 6.244
c/d, respectively. In Model 3, one more dipole mode (p2) fits the observed value at 7.898 c/d (with the
accuracy 0.001 c/d). Model 2 nearly follows the line of the Model 3, for clearance it was not depicted.
the fit may be achieved with a more modest (few percent) modification of the opacity bump
at log T = 6.3. We plan to examine this option in future.
Acknowledgments. We acknowledge partial financial support from the Polish MNSiW grant
No. 1 P03D 021 28 and from the HELAS project.
References
Asplund N., Grevesse N., Sauval A. J., 2005, in Barnes III T. G., Bash F. N., eds, ASP Conf. Ser. vol.
336, The Solar Chemical Composition, p.25
Dziembowski W.A. & Pamyatnykh A. A., 2008, MNRAS, 385, 2061
Iglesias C. A. & Rogers F. J., 1996, ApJ, 464, 943
Jerzykiewicz M., Handler G., Shobbrook R. R., et al., 2005, MNRAS, 360, 619
Pamyatnykh A. A., Handler G. & Dziembowski W. A., 2004, MNRAS, 350, 1022
Seaton M. J., 2005, MNRAS, 362, L1
h
h
|
0707.1209 | 1 | 0707 | 2007-07-09T09:33:41 | HST's view of the youngest massive stars in the Magellanic Clouds | [
"astro-ph"
] | Accurate physical parameters of newborn massive stars are essential ingredients to shed light on their formation, which is still an unsolved problem. The rare class of compact H II regions in the Magellanic Clouds (MCs), termed ``high-excitation blobs'' (HEBs), presents a unique opportunity to acquire this information. These objects (~ 4" to 10", ~ 1 to 3 pc, in diameter) harbor the youngest massive stars of the OB association/molecular cloud complexes in the MCs accessible through high-resolution near-IR and optical techniques. We present a brief overview of the results obtained with HST mainly on two HEBs, one in the LMC (N159-5) and the other in the SMC (N81). | astro-ph | astro-ph |
HST's view of the youngest massive stars in
the Magellanic Clouds
M. Heydari-Malayeri1, M. R. Rosa2, V. Charmandaris3,1, L. Deharveng4,
F. Martins5, F. Meynadier6, D. Schaerer7, and H. Zinnecker8
1 LERMA, Paris Observatory, France; [email protected]
2 ST-ECF, ESO, Germany; affiliated to the Space Telescope Operations Division,
RSSD, ESA; [email protected]
3 University of Crete, Greece; [email protected]
4 Marseille Observatory, France; [email protected]
5 MPE, Garching bei Munchen, Germany; [email protected]
6 LERMA, Paris Observatory, France; [email protected]
7 Geneva Observatory, Switzerland; Observatoire Midi-Pyr´en´ees, Laboratoire
d'Astrophysique, Toulouse, France; [email protected]
8 Potsdam Astrophysical Institute, Germany; [email protected]
Summary. Accurate physical parameters of newborn massive stars are essential
ingredients to shed light on their formation, which is still an unsolved problem.
The rare class of compact H ii regions in the Magellanic Clouds (MCs), termed
"high-excitation blobs" (HEBs), presents a unique opportunity to acquire this in-
formation. These objects (4′′ to 10′′, ∼ 1 to 3 pc, in diameter) harbor the youngest
massive stars of the OB association/molecular cloud complexes in the MCs acces-
sible through high-resolution near-IR and optical techniques. We present a brief
overview of the results obtained with HST mainly on two HEBs, one in the LMC
(N159-5) and the other in the SMC (N81).
1 Introduction
Massive stars (> 8 M⊙) play a key role in several fields of astrophysics. How-
ever their formation process is still an unsolved problem in spite of progress,
both in theory and observation, in recent years. In order to better understand
their formation one needs photospheric lines to access accurate effective tem-
peratures (Tef f ), luminosities (L), masses (M ), and gravities (g). Tef f and L
are crucial for placing the stars on the HR diagram and to establish whether
they are ZAMS or evolved stars. This is very important since massive stars
evolve fast, and the most massive ones can become supergiants while still
enshrouded in clumps of gas and dust. Spectral signatures are also needed
to understand how and when the stellar wind develops. Moreover, mass loss
may affect the accretion rate and play an important role in massive star for-
mation process. Other important issues are multiplicity and the IMF of the
cluster members. High-resolution radio continuum and IR observations yield
indispensable information about UCHII regions but do not have direct access
to newborn massive stars.
Only observations in the near-IR and optical (mainly spectroscopy) of
nascent stars can accurately provide these physical parameters. This can be
2
Heydari-Malayeri et al.
achieved in the visible by using the traditional methods of spectral classi-
fication (28), or by using the more recent method of line fitting, based on
atmosphere models (12), (20). In the near-IR similar methodology makes use
of 2 µm spectroscopy (1), or profile fitting (20), (21).
The MCs offer valuable opportunities for this study since they are seen
face-on and have well-determined distances. This facilitates obtaining accu-
rate absolute magnitudes and fluxes. Moreover, their overall extinction is
low. Being metal-poor, they provide important templates for studying star
formation in distant metal-poor galaxies which cannot be observed with com-
parable spatial resolution.
2 High-excitation blobs
The youngest massive stars in the MCs accessible to IR and optical observa-
tions are found in High-Excitation Blobs (HEBs), see below for details. The
reason for this terminology is that no spatial features could be distinguished
with ground-based telescopes. This is a rare class of H ii regions in the MCs;
so far only 6 members have been detected in the LMC and 3 in the SMC.
For massive stars the accretion time-scale is larger than the Kelvin-
Helmholtz time-scale. This means that massive stars reach the main sequence
while accretion is still going on. Moreover, they evolve very fast. Therefore,
obtaining the physical parameters of massive stars "at birth" may be an
unattainable task! Consequently, HEBs offer a compromise between stars in-
side ultra-compact H ii regions and the exciting stars of evolved H ii regions.
In contrast to the typical H ii regions of the MCs, which are extended
structures (sizes of several arc minutes corresponding to more than 50 pc,
powered by a large number of exciting stars), HEBs are very dense and small
regions (∼ 4′′ to 10′′ in diameter corresponding to ∼ 1 -- 3 pc). They have a
higher degree of excitation ([O iii]/Hβ]) with respect to the typical H ii re-
gions, and are, in general, heavily affected by local dust. In comparison with
Galactic regions, some of HEBs are similar to classical H ii regions and some
look like compact H ii regions (18). However, HEBs should be considered in
the context of massive star formation in the MCs. Compared with other com-
pact H ii regions of the same sizes in the MCs, they constitute a distinctly
detached group with high excitations and luminosities. (23).
3 LMC N159-5 (Papillon)
This prototype of HEBs is situated in the H ii complex N159 some 500 pc
south of 30 Dor (2). N159 is associated with one of the most important con-
centrations of molecular gas in the LMC (17) and contains several signposts
of ongoing star formation (cocoon stars, IR sources, masers). Several physical
aspects of this object were studied using ground-based observations in the
visible, IR, and radio (3), (15), (16), (13), (25), (26).
Our high-resolution HST observations show N159 to be a turbulent envi-
ronment typical of massive star formation regions with stellar winds, cavities
HST's view of the youngest massive stars in the Magellanic Clouds
3
sculpted in the ionized gas as well as shocks, absorption features, filaments,
and arcs (5). The compact H ii region is resolved for the first time into a
butterfly-shaped structure with the wings separated by ∼ 2′′.3 (0.6 pc). Two
subarcsec features show up in the wings, a kind of "smoke ring" and a "glob-
ule" or sort of cometary structure. These features suggest a dynamic environ-
ment, the physical details of which are still unclear. The butterfly shape may
be due to a bipolar phenomenon, but with the present data we cannot verify.
Regarding the exciting star(s), from the Hβ flux we expect a star of type
O8 at least. The exciting star(s) is(are) not detected since the extinction is
larger than AV = 5 mag. High-resolution near-IR observations are necessary
to penetrate into the dust concentration. However, our JHK VLT/ISAAC ob-
servations were not able to resolve the blob (22). Nonetheless, we could study
the stellar populations associated with the object and we find that there are
two main stellar populations: a massive, young population about 3 Myr old,
and an older population of low mass stars with an age between 1 and 10 Gyr.
The position of the blob on the color-magnitude diagram can be explained
by the presence of a ∼ 50 M⊙ star, affected by an extinction of AV ∼ 7 mag.
4 SMC N81
This object is situated in the wing of the SMC, south-east of the main bar
(4), (15), (16), (25), (26). In contrast to LMC N159, our HST images re-
veal several stars associated with SMC N81 (6). Six stars are grouped in an
area 2′′ wide. The two brightest stars, the main exciting sources, are only
0′′.27 apart (0.08 pc). Two prominent dark lanes divide the nebula into three
lobes. A magnificent curved plume of some 15′′ (4.5 pc) in length is appar-
ently linked to an absorption hole lying towards the center of the H ii region.
It is uncertain whether the plume is due to an outflow or an infall of dust.
The absorption hole has a size of 0′′.25 (0.07 pc). The H ii region is in contact
with a dense medium toward the west where two ridges, representing ioniza-
tion/shock fronts, are present. This idea is corroborated by high-resolution
ATCA interferometer observations in the radio continuum at 3 cm, which
show compressed radio emission in that direction (14), most probably due to
the presence of a molecular cloud.
We also used HST/STIS to obtain UV spectra of 8 stars associated with
N81 (10). Analysis of those spectra shows that all of them are massive stars
of types O6-O8. However, they appear to be sub-luminous, by ∼ 2 mag in
comparison with typical O dwarfs in the MCs. An important property of
these stars is their weakness of the stellar winds as evidenced by the line
profiles. Mass loss rates as low as 10−9 M⊙ yr−1, i.e. ∼ 2 orders of mag weaker
compared with O stars of the same type (19). These stars may belong to the
class of Vz stars: O dwarfs lying on or close to the ZAMS (27). The weakness
of the winds cannot be attributed to metallicity effects. It may be due to
the youth of the stars (younger stars have weaker winds?) and if confirmed
warrants further investigation.
4
Heydari-Malayeri et al.
5 Other objects
Our HST observations allowed us also to resolve other HEBs for the first
time. For example SMC N88A, which in comparison with SMC N81, is more
compact (size ∼ 3′′.5, ∼ 1 pc), denser, and of higher excitation, shows two
components in interaction (7). The extinction rises to more than 3.5 mag in
the visible towards its tight core. Such a high extinction is unprecedented for
an H ii region in the metal-poor SMC. The exciting star(s) of N88A, which
are certainly more massive/hotter than those of N81, are not detected in the
optical due to the heavy extinction.
For LMC N11A, our HST data revealed its previously unknown nebular
and stellar features, notably the presence of an embedded cluster of stars.
Five of the stars are packed in an area less than 2′′ (0.5 pc), with the most
luminous one being a mid O type star(8), (24).
LMC N83B displays an impressive cavity, with an estimated age of only
∼ 30,000 yr, sculpted in the ionized gas by the powerful winds of a mas-
sive star. The observations bring also to light two compact H ii blobs of
only 2′′.8 (0.7 pc) and 1′′(0.3 pc) in size. The former harbors the presumably
hottest star of the burst and is also strongly affected by dust with a strong
extinction. These features plus an outstanding ridge are formed in the border
zone between the molecular cloud and the ionized gas possibly in a sequential
process triggered by the ionization front of an older H ii region. (9).
In addition, the two compact regions A1 and A2 lying toward the giant
H ii region N160 were for the first time resolved and their stellar content and
morphology revealed. A1, being of higher excitation, is powered by a single
massive star whose strong wind has created a surrounding bubble. A2 harbors
several stars enshrouded by large quantities of dust (11).
Apart from the papers cited above, our HST projects have resulted in six
HST NASA/ESA Press Releases (July 23, 1998; June 10, 1999; October 5,
2000; March 28, 2001; December 19, 2001; September 12, 2002).
6 Conclusions
Physical parameters of massive stars are needed to better understand mas-
sive star formation. The exciting stars of HEBs, being the youngest massive
stars reachable through IR and optical techniques, offer a good compromise
between massive stars "at birth" and those in evolved H ii regions. HEBs are
also particularly attractive in the context of massive star formation in the
MCs. An unexpected and intriguing result is the weak winds of O type stars
in SMC N81. Are weak winds a general property of the massive stars em-
bedded in HEBs? Future high-resolution near-IR observations (spectroscopy
& imaging) are needed to make progress. In the near future, near-IR ob-
servations with JWST and E-ELT will yield the photospheric signatures of
newborn massive stars enshrouded in AV = 100-200 mag (29) blobs at even
earlier stages of evolution.
HST's view of the youngest massive stars in the Magellanic Clouds
5
References
[1] Hanson, M.M. et al. 2005, ApJS 161, 154
[2] Heydari-Malayeri, M., Testor, G. 1982, A&A 111, L11
[3] Heydari-Malayeri, M., Testor, G. 1985, A&A 144, 98
[4] Heydari-Malayeri, M., Le Bertre, Th., Magain, P. 1988, A&A 195, 230
[5] Heydari-Malayeri, M., et al. 1999a, A&A 352, 665
[6] Heydari-Malayeri, M., et al. 1999b, A&A 344, 848
[7] Heydari-Malayeri, M., et al. 1999c, A&A 347, 841
[8] Heydari-Malayeri, M., et al. 2001, A&A 372, 527
[9] Heydari-Malayeri, M., et al. 2001, A&A 372, 495
[10] Heydari-Malayeri, M., et al. 2002, A&A 381, 951
[11] Heydari-Malayeri, M., et al. 2002, A&A 381, 941
[12] Hillier, D.J., Miller, D.L. 1998, ApJ 496, 407
[13] Hunt, M. R., Whiteoak, J. B. 1994, Proc. Astr. Soc. of Australia 11, 68
[14] Indebetouw,R., Johnson, K.E., Conti, P. 2004, AJ 128, 2206
[15] Israel, F. P., Koornneef, J., 1988, A&A 190, 21
[16] Israel, F. P., Koornneef, J., 1991, A&A 248, 404
[17] Johansson, L. E. B., Greve, A., Booth, R. S. et al. 1998, A&A 331, 857
[18] Martin-Hernandez, N.L., Vermeij, R., van der Hulst, J.M. 2005, A&A 433, 205
[19] Martins, F., et al. 2004, A&A 420, 1087
[20] Martins, F., Schaerer, D., Hillier, D.J. 2005, A&A 436, 1049
[21] Martins, F., Genzel, R., Hillier, D.J. et al. 2007, A&A 468, 233
[22] Meynadier, F., Heydari-Malayeri, Deharveng, L., et al. 2004, A&A 422, 129
[23] Meynadier, F., Heydari-Malayeri, M. 2007, A&A 461, 565
[24] Parker, J.Wm., Garmany, C.D., Massey, P., Walborn, N.R. 1992 AJ 103, 1205
[25] Vermeij, R. et al. 2002, A&A 390, 649
[26] Vermeij, R., van der Hulst, J.M. 2002, A&A 391, 1081
[27] Walborn, N.R., Parker, J.W. 1992, ApJ L87
[28] Walborn, N.R. 2006, Proc. Joint Discussion, IAU, astro-ph/0610837
[29] Zinnecker, H. 2006, in Proc. of the IAU Sympo. 232 The Scientific Require-
ments for Extremely Large Telescopes, eds. P. Whitelock et al., p. 324
|
astro-ph/0612411 | 2 | 0612 | 2007-01-15T22:14:56 | Metal Absorption Profiles from the Central Star of the Planetary Nebula M27 (NGC 6853, PN G060.8-03.6, the Dumbbell) -- Photospheric and Nebular Line Identifications | [
"astro-ph"
] | High resolution spectra of the hot central star of the planetary nebula (CSPN) M27, acquired with the Far Ultraviolet Spectroscopic Explorer (\FUSE), have revealed an unusually rich set of narrow molecular hydrogen absorption features. This object is also unique in that the velocity of nebular absorption features are cleanly separated from the velocity of the intervening interstellar medium. These features blend with and in many cases obscure atomic features. We have developed a continuum model of the CSPN including atomic and molecular hydrogen absorption. Using this model we have identified and tabulated the metal lines as arising from either photospheric, nebular and/or non-nebular velocity systems. We find the nebular outflow and ionization balance to be stratified with high ionization states favored at low velocity and low ionization states favored at high velocity. Neutrals and molecules are found at a velocity that marks the transistion between these two regimes. These observations are a challenge to the interacting wind model of PN evolution. Mappings at high resolution of the line profiles for \ion{C}{1} \ion{-}{4}, \ion{N}{1} \ion{-}{3}, \ion{O}{1}, \ion{O}{6}, \ion{Si}{2} \ion{-}{4}, \ion{P}{2} \ion{-}{5}, \ion{S}{2} \ion{-}{4}, \ion{Ar}{1} \ion{-}{2} and \ion{Fe}{2} \ion{-}{3} within the \FUSE and STIS bandpasses are presented. The digitial spectra of the stars and the model are freely available on the H$_2$ools website. They will be useful for photospheric analyses seeking to determine the metallicity of the central star and for absorption line based atomic and molecular abundance determination of the nebular outflow. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
ACCEPTED FOR PUBLICATION IN THE ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL SUPPLEMENT SERIES
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 08/22/09
METAL ABSORPTION PROFILES FROM THE CENTRAL STAR OF THE PLANETARY NEBULA M27 (NGC 6853, PN
G060.8-03.6, THE DUMBBELL) -- PHOTOSPHERIC AND NEBULAR LINE IDENTIFICATIONS
STEPHAN. R. MCCANDLISS1 & JEFFREY KRUK1
Department of Physics and Astronomy, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21218.
Received 2006 November 10; accepted 2006 December 14
ABSTRACT
High resolution spectra of the hot central star of the planetary nebula (CSPN) M27, acquired with the Far
Ultraviolet Spectroscopic Explorer (FUSE), have revealed an unusually rich set of narrow molecular hydrogen
absorption features. This object is also unique in that the velocity of nebular absorption features are cleanly
separated from the velocity of the intervening interstellar medium. These features blend with and in many cases
obscure atomic features. We have developed a continuum model of the CSPN including atomic and molecular
hydrogen absorption. Using this model we have identified and tabulated the metal lines as arising from either
photospheric, nebular and/or non-nebular velocity systems. We find the nebular outflow and ionization balance
to be stratified with high ionization states favored at low velocity and low ionization states favored at high
velocity. Neutrals and molecules are found at a velocity that marks the transistion between these two regimes.
These observations are a challenge to the interacting wind model of PN evolution. Mappings at high resolution
of the line profiles for C I - IV, N I - III, O I, O VI, Si II - IV, P II - V, S II - IV, Ar I - II and Fe II - III within the
FUSE and STIS bandpasses are presented. The digitial spectra of the star and the model are freely available
on the H2ools website. They will be useful for photospheric analyses seeking to determine the metallicity of
the central star and for absorption line based atomic and molecular abundance determination of the nebular
outflow.
Subject headings: atomic processes -- ISM: abundances -- (ISM:) dust, extinction -- (ISM:) planetary nebu-
lae: general -- (ISM:) planetary nebulae: individual (NGC 6853) -- line: identification --
line: profiles -- molecular processes -- plasmas -- (stars:) circumstellar matter -- (stars:)
white dwarfs -- ultraviolet: ISM -- ultraviolet: stars
1. INTRODUCTION
High resolution spectra of the hot central star (CS) of the
Planetary Nebula (PN) M27 (NGC 6853, PN G060.8-03.6, the
Dumbbell), acquired with the Far Ultraviolet Spectroscopic
Explorer (FUSE), have revealed an unusually rich set of nar-
row molecular hydrogen absorption features, spanning the en-
tire bandpass. FUSE carriers no on-board source for wave-
length calibrations and consequently M27 has been observed
numerous times for this purpose, producing in the process a
high quality data set as illustrated in Figure 1. The high den-
sity of the molecular lines presents problems for the identifi-
cation and analysis of atomic features arising from the stellar
photosphere and interstellar medium (ISM).
In a separate work (McCandliss et al. 2007, hereafter Pa-
per I) we have developed a molecular and atomic hydro-
gen absorption model that, when applied to a readily avail-
able pure hydrogen helium hot white dwarf model of the CS
(Rauch 2003), provides a reasonable template against which
the atomic absorption features from other metal line systems
can be isolated. Here we compare the model to the obser-
vations and present a list of line identifications for atomic
species associated with the stellar photosphere, the surround-
ing nebula and non-nebular ISM. We also present high reso-
lution absorption line profiles from STIS and FUSE for the
metals C I - IV, N I - III, O I, O VI, Si II - IV, P II - V, S II - IV,
Ar I - II and Fe II - III.
Paper I finds the observed atomic and molecular velocity
stratification in the nebular outflow of M27 is challenging to
explain in the context of the standard interacting winds model
for PNe (Kwok et al. 1978). A similar challenge has been
Electronic address: [email protected]
made by Meaburn (2005) (see also Meaburn et al. 2005a,b)
who used high resolution position-and-velocity spectroscopy
of the optical emission lines to derive the ionization kinemat-
ics of several objects. They find that ballistic ejection could
have been more important than interacting winds in shap-
ing the dynamics of PNe. In the interacting winds model a
high speed (∼ 1000 km s−1) highly ionized radiation driven
wind from the hot star shocks and ionizes a slow moving (∼
10 km s−1), high density mostly molecular asymptotic giant
branch (AGB) wind. In Paper I no evidence was found for a
high speed radiation driven wind. The upper limit to the ter-
minal expansion velocity is ≈ 70 km s−1. The atomic line
profiles show that high ionization material appears at low ve-
locities (. 33 km s−1) and low ionization material appears
at high velocities (33 -- 65 km s−1). At the transition veloc-
ity (33 km s−1) between these two regimes, a predominately
neutral atomic medium appears along with the vibrationally
excited H2. The molecular abudance in the nebula is low
(N(H2)/N(H I) ≪ 1).
The Paper I study found that, despite the close proximity of
a hot central star, the molecular hydrogen ro-vibration levels
of the ground state were close to thermal (∼ 2000 K). They
found no detectable levels of far-UV fluorescence of molec-
ular hydrogen, although Lya pumped fluorescence has been
detected by Lupu et al. (2006). Surprisingly, they also found
that the line-of-sight was devoid of dust. The temperature im-
plied by the molecular hydrogen suggests that the diffuse neb-
ular medium is too hot for dust to form. They argue that the
clumpy medium seen in the CO map of Bachiller et al. (2000),
which cast the [O III] shadows seen by Meaburn & Lopez
(1993) and O'Dell et al. (2002), are the source of the excited
2
McCandliss and Kruk
TABLE 1
FUSE OBSERVATION SUMMARY
Observation
Date
APER
EXP:LiF1a
(ksec)
EXP:SiC1b
(ksec)
EXP:LiF2a
(ksec)
EXP:SiC2a
(ksec)
M1070301
M1070302
M1070303
M1070304
M1070305
M1070306
M1070307
M1070308
M1070309
M1070310
M1070311
M1070312
M1070313
M1070314
M1070315
M1070316
M1070317
M1070319
P1043301
2000-09-03 MDRS
2000-09-24
HIRS
2001-05-28
LWRS
2001-05-29 MDRS
2001-05-29
HIRS
2001-07-28
LWRS
2001-07-28 MDRS
2001-07-29
HIRS
2001-08-01
LWRS
2001-08-01 MDRS
2001-08-01
HIRS
2002-10-30
LWRS
2002-10-30 MDRS
2002-11-02
HIRS
2004-05-25
LWRS
2004-05-25 MDRS
HIRS
2004-05-25
2002-11-03
HIRS
LWRS
2000-06-05
15.5
17.5
7.4
7.0
8.0
7.1
6.7
8.5
7.5
6.6
7.8
5.0
7.0
3.3
5.3
4.0
6.5
2.7
16.9
8.0
4.8
7.5
4.8
4.1
7.1
3.5
3.4
7.6
4.1
0.6
5.1
3.3
0.9
5.3
2.9
3.2
1.1
16.5
15.6
13.3
7.3
6.6
6.3
7.2
6.5
6.3
7.7
6.4
5.6
4.8
6.4
2.4
4.3
4.9
5.0
2.0
16.3
8.9
5.6
7.0
0.6
2.0
7.1
5.1
3.3
7.4
4.8
0.8
5.0
3.0
0.7
4.4
4.4
4.3
0.9
16.9
molecular hydrogen for the diffuse nebular medium and may
harbor depleted material (dust). A depletion analysis of the
Fe, Si, and S in the nebular outflow could provide information
as to whether these clumps are composed of depleted material
that is being released into the diffuse medium along with the
molecular hydrogen.
The digitial spectra used in this study, are available at the
following url,
http://www.pha.jhu.edu/stephan/H2ools/M27kruk04/.
This dataset will be useful for photospheric analyses of the
central star and for studies seeking to understand the kine-
matics of the atomic and molecular abundances in the nebular
outflow.
2. DATASETS
2.1. FUSE
FUSE spectra of the CS (MAST object ID GCRV12336)
were acquired under the observatory wavelength calibration
program (ID: M107). The CS was observed numerous times
through all three focal-plane apertures: large (30′′)2, medium
(20′′× 4′′) and small (20′′× 1.25′′); referred to respectively
as LWRS, MDRS, and HIRS. A summary of the observa-
tions is given in Table 1. All spectra were acquired in TTAG
mode. Each observation was performed as a series of expo-
sures, ranging in length from 0.5 ksec to 3 ksec. Each expo-
sure produces 8 individual spectra; one from each of two de-
tector segments for each of the 4 optical channels. Effective
exposure times are listed in the table for the more interesting
segment in each channel. Exposure times occasionally dif-
fer slightly from one segment to another because the detector
high voltage in a given segment can be reduced temporarily
in response to event bursts or brief current spikes. Exposure
times also differ from one channel to another as a result of
channel misalignment effects. For a description of the de-
tectors, channel alignment issues, systems nomenclature and
other aspects of the FUSE instrument, see Moos et al. (2000)
and Sahnow et al. (2000).
The exposures were processed with the following proce-
dure. The raw data were calibrated using Calfuse 3.0.7.
The resulting spectra for a given aperture (LWRS, MDRS
or HIRS) were screened to identify the peak detected stellar
flux. Exposures with less than 40% of the peak flux (a small
fraction) were discarded. The remaining were normalized to
the peak flux, yielding an effective exposure time. Chan-
nel/segments were coaligned with a cross-correlation proce-
dure on narrow ISM lines. Spectra were shifted by whole
pixel units to avoid smoothing and combined by effective
exposure time weighted average. At this point there is one
spectrum for each spectrograph aperture, divided among the
8 channel/segment combinations. The MDRS spectra were
put on an absolute wavelength scale by adjusting each chan-
nel/segment spectrum so that the H2 lines arising from the hot
component of the molecular gas are at a fiducial offset ( -- 69
km s−1, see § 4.1 regarding this point). Finally, the normaliza-
tion of the MDRS and HIRS were readjusted to match that of
the LWRS and the zero point offsets of the HIRS and LWRS
channel/segment were adjusted to match the MDRS.1 We use
the HIRS data in this work as it yields the highest resolution.
Each extracted segment has associated with it a set of one
dimensional arrays: wavelength ( A), flux (ergs cm−2 s−1
A−1), and estimated statistical error (in flux units). Figure 1
shows the signal-to-noise and spectral range for each of the
coadded HIRS segments, obtained by dividing a flux array by
the corresponding statistical error array. The signal-to-noise
estimated in this way is purely statistical and does not account
for systemic errors, such as detector fixed pattern noise. In the
low sensitivity SiC channels the continuum signal-to-noise
ranges between 10 -- 25, while in the higher sensitivity LiF
channels it is 20 -- 55. The resolution of the coadded spectra
changes slightly as a function of wavelength for each segment.
In modeling the molecular hydrogen absorption, we find that
a gaussian convolution kernel with a full with at half max-
imum of 0.05 A at 1000 A (spectral resolution R = 18,000,
velocity resolution d V ≈ 17 km s−1) provides a good match
to the unresolved absorption features throughout much of the
1 After preforming these procedures spectral overlays the HIRS LiF1b and
LiF2a segments were in obvious disagreement with the LWRS and MDRS
LiF1b and LiF2a segments. Consequently the HIRS wavelength scale was
been adjusted by adding in a linear dilation of the scale of 0.03 A for every
45 A starting at 1125 A. This adjustment to the HIRS wavelength scale has
been incorporated into subsequent versions of CALFUSE. The HIRS LiF2a
flux was also rescaled by a factor or 0.91 to achieve agreement with LiF1b.
Metal Absorption Profiles from M27
3
SiC1b
SiC2a
LiF1a
SiC1a
LiF2b
SiC2b
LiF1b
LiF2a
e
s
i
o
n
−
o
t
−
l
a
n
g
i
S
S
R
W
H
60
40
20
0
60
40
20
0
60
40
20
0
60
40
20
0
900
950
1000
Wavelength (Å)
1050
1100
1150
1200
FIG. 1. -- Signal-to-noise ratio of the eight coadded spectral segments taken through the HIRS spectrograph aperture. The individual segments are labeled.
bandpass.
Close comparison of the wavelength registration for over-
lapping segments reveals isolated regions, a few A in length,
of slight spectral mismatch (∼ a fraction of a resolution ele-
ment) in the wavelength solutions. Consequently, combining
all the spectra into one master spectrum will result in a loss
of resolution. However, treating each channel/segment indi-
vidually increases the bookkeeping associated with the data
analysis. Further, because fixed pattern noise tends to domi-
nate when the signal-to-noise is high, there is little additional
information to be gained in analyzing a low signal-to-noise
data set when high signal-to-noise is available. For these rea-
sons we elected to form two spectra each of which covers the
900 -- 1190 bandpass contiguously, using the following pro-
cedure. The flux and error arrays for the LiF1a and LiF1b
segments were interpolated onto a common linear wavelength
scale with a 0.013 A bin, covering 900 -- 1190 A. The empty
wavelength regions, being most of the short wavelength re-
gion from 1000 A down to the 900 A and the short gap re-
gion in between LiF1a and LiF1b, were filled in with most
of SiC2a and a small portion of SiC2b respectively. We re-
fer to this spectrum as s12. The LiF2b, LiF2a, SiC1a and
SiC1b segments were merged similarily into a spectrum, s21.
Absorption line analyses were carried out using both s12 and
s21.
2.2. STIS
The E140M spectrum of M27 (o64d07020_x1d.fits), taken
from the Multimission Archive at Space Telescope (MAST),
was acquired for HST Proposal 8638 (Klaus Werner -- PI).
These data are a high level data product consisting of arrays
′′2×0.
of flux and wavelength calibrated, one-dimensional extrac-
tions of individual echelle orders. The data were acquired
through the 0.
′′2 spectroscopic aperture for an exposure
time of 2906 s and were reduced with CALSTIS version 2.18.
The spectral resolution of the E140M is given in the STIS
data handbook (version 7.0 Quijano 2003) as R ≈ 48,000
(d V = 6.25 km s−1). The intrinsic line profile for the 0.
′′2
aperture has a gaussian core with this width, but there is non-
negligible power in the wings. These data offer a high velocity
resolution view of the ionization stratification in the nebular
expansion.
′′2×0.
3. MODEL OF CONTINUUM ABSORPTION BY HYDROGEN AND
LINE IDENTIFICATIONS
A model of the CS SED,
including the atomic and
molecular hydrogen absorptions has been developed by
McCandliss et al. (2007) to aid identification of photospheric,
nebular or non-nebular velocity components in the FUSE and
STIS metal line profiles. We used synthetic stellar flux inter-
polated from the grid of Rauch (2003) with logg = 6.5, T =
120,000 K, and ratio of H/He = 10/3 by mass. This model in-
cludes no metals and is consistent with, although slightly hot-
ter than, the quantitative spectroscopy of Napiwotzki (1999).
The adopted temperature and gravity has slightly less pres-
sure broadening and is a better match to the observed Lyman
lines towards the series limit. We also adopt a stellar mass of
0.56 M⊙ as suggested by post asymptotic giant branch evolu-
tionary tracks. Use of this mass along with the above gravity
required a distance of 466 pc to match the absolute flux, which
is at the upper limit given by Benedict et al. (2003). Beyond
our immediate need to match the absolute flux for the given
gravity and mass there is no particular reason to prefer this
4
McCandliss and Kruk
Flux (x10−12 ergs cm−2 s−1 Å−1)
Flux (x10−12 ergs cm−2 s−1 Å−1)
−
6
−
4
−
2 0 2 4 6
5
2
9
4
0
−
6
−
4
−
2 0 2 4 6
5
0
4
9
4
8
4
6
4
5
4
4
5
1
4
7
4
3
9
5
0
W
a
v
e
l
e
n
g
t
h
9
6
0
(
Å
)
9
7
0
9
8
0
9
1
0
9
2
0
9
3
0
9
4
0
6
2
6
0
5
6
5
2
6
3
6
1
5
9
5
8
5
7
5
5
5
4
5
3
5
1
FIG. 2A. -- Hydrogen absorbed continuum model 905 -- 980 A. Identified line blends are numbered and marked with upper and lower + and tabulated in Table
2. Upper portion of each panel is an overplot of the s12 (orange) and s21 (green) FUSE spectra, and the model (black). Lower portion of each panel shows the
data after subtraction of the model, offset by 10−12 ergs cm−2 s−1 A−1.
Metal Absorption Profiles from M27
5
Flux (x10−12 ergs cm−2 s−1 Å−1)
Flux (x10−12 ergs cm−2 s−1 Å−1)
−
4
−
2 0 2 4
−
6
−
4
−
2 0 2 4 6
3
7
3
6
3
5
3
4
3
3
3
5
3
6
9
8
0
9
9
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
4
3
4
2
4
1
4
0
3
8
3
9
3
7
1
0
1
0
1
0
2
0
W
a
v
e
l
e
n
g
t
h
1
0
3
0
(
Å
)
1
0
4
0
1
0
5
0
FIG. 2B. -- Hydrogen absorbed continuum model 975 -- 1050 A. See Figure 2a for a description of the colors and symbols.
6
McCandliss and Kruk
Flux (x10−12 ergs cm−2 s−1 Å−1)
Flux (x10−12 ergs cm−2 s−1 Å−1)
−
4
1
0
8
0
−
2
0
2 4
−
4
−
2 0 2 4
2
9
2
7
2
5
2
3
2
8
2
6
2
4
2
2
2
1
1
0
9
0
W
a
v
e
l
e
n
g
t
h
1
1
0
0
(
Å
)
1
1
1
0
1
1
2
0
1
0
5
0
1
0
6
0
1
0
7
0
1
0
8
0
3
3
3
2
3
0
3
1
2
9
2
8
FIG. 2C. -- Hydrogen absorbed continuum model 1045 -- 1120 A. See Figure 2a for a description of the colors and symbols.
Metal Absorption Profiles from M27
7
Flux (x10−12 ergs cm−2 s−1 Å−1)
Flux (x10−12 ergs cm−2 s−1 Å−1)
−
3
−
2
−
1 0 1 2 3
−
3
−
2
−
1 0 1 2 3
7
4
1
6
5
3
2
0
2
1
1
9
1
7
1
1
2
0
1
1
3
0
1
5
1
3
1
1
9
1
1
4
0
1
1
5
0
2
0
1
8
1
6
1
4
1
2
1
0
8
7
1
1
5
0
1
1
6
0
W
a
v
e
l
e
n
g
t
h
1
1
7
0
(
Å
)
1
1
8
0
1
1
9
0
FIG. 2D. -- Hydrogen absorbed continuum model 1115 -- 1190 A. See Figure 2a for a description of the colors and symbols.
8
McCandliss and Kruk
distance over that derived by Benedict et al. Questions re-
garding the acceptable uncertainty in distance, absolute flux
and derived stellar parameters are best left for a stellar model
specifically tailored to include the effects of metals, gravity
and evolutionary state. The data supplied here is intended to
enable such an effort.
STELLAR, NEBULAR AND NON-NEBULAR LINE ID'S
TABLE 2
Feature
l obs
A
Atomic ID, l rest
A
Component†
0
1
2
. . .
3
4
5
. . .
. . .
. . .
6
7
. . .
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
16
17
18
19
20
21
. . .
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
. . .
30
31
32
. . .
33
. . .
34
. . .
35
36
36
35
37
38
39
40
. . .
41
. . .
42
. . .
43
44
. . .
45
?
?
?
C I UV29
C I UV29
C I 1139.793 (UV22)
C I UV19
P II 1152.818
P II 1152.818
N I 1134.415 + 1134.1653
O VI 1147.072 + 1146.791
N I 1134.165
Fe II 1125.448
O VI 1122.348
Fe II 1121.975
N I 1134.980
N I 1134.980
N I 1134.415
Fe II 1144.938
Fe II 1143.226
Fe II 1142.366
O VI 1124.809 +1124.716
O VI 1122.618 + C I UV27
O VI 1172.439?
O VI 1171.561?
C IV 1168.993
C IV 1168.849
P II** 1159.087
C I UV15.01+16
C I UV15.01+16
C I UV15.01+16
C I UV15.01+16
1171.85
1170.95
1168.90
1168.75
1163.70
1158.97
1157.83
1157.72
1157.63
1157.48
1155.73
1152.71
1152.53
1148.11
1146.75
1144.85
1143.13
1142.28
1141.28
1139.50
1134.86
1134.70
1134.30
1134.10
1133.90
1125.35
1124.65
1122.49
1122.25
1121.88
1117.78
1117.44
1107.48
1106.21
1096.78
1095.20
1085.42
1085.25 N II** 1085.551 + 1085.533
1084.23
N II* 1084.584 + 1084.566
1083.90
1083.70
1066.57
1063.09
1062.47
1062.35
1048.14
1047.98
1039.12
1039.02
1037.48
1036.75
1036.08
1031.79
1012.24
999.76
997.78
991.38
991.22
989.79
989.56
988.71
988.47
976.85
971.65
971.48
964.54
N II 1083.994
N II 1083.994
Ar I 1066.660
Fe II 1063.176
S IV 1062.664
S IV 1062.664
Ar I 1048.220
Ar I 1048.220
O I 1039.230
O I 1039.230
O VI 1037.617
C II* 1037.018
C II 1036.337
O VI 1031.926
S III 1012.495
C III 977.020
O I 977.738
O I 977.738
N I 964.626
N III 991.577 + 991.511
N III 991.577 + 991.511
C IV 1107.593
C I 1106.316
Fe II 1096.877
Si II 989.873
N III 989.799
O I 988.773
O I 988.773 + 988.6549
N II** 1085.710
P III 998.000
?
?
Nb,NN
Nb,NN
Nb,NN
Nb,NN
Nb,NN
Ph?
Ph?
Ph
Ph
?
NN
NN
Nb
?
Ph
NN
NN
NN
?
Nb
NN
Nb
NN
Nb
NN
Ph
Nb+NN
Ph,Nb
Ph,Nb
NN
Nb,NN
Nb,NN
Ph
NN
NN
?
Nb
Nb
Nb
NN
Nb
NN
NN
Ph,Nb
Nb
NN
Nb
NN
Nb
Ph
Nb
Nb
Ph
Nb
?
Nb
Nb
Nb?
NN
Nb
NN
NN
Nb
NN
Nb,NN
Ph,Nb,NN
TABLE 2 -- Continued
Feature
l obs
A
Atomic ID, l rest
A
Component†
. . .
. . .
. . .
46
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
47
48
. . .
49
. . .
50
. . .
. . .
51
52
53
. . .
54
. . .
55
56
57
. . .
58
. . .
59
60
61
62
63
N I 954.104
N I 954.104 + 953.970
N I 964.626
N I 963.990
N I 963.990 +P II 963.801
N I 953.970
N I 953.655
N I 953.655
N I 953.415
N I 953.415
N I 952.415
O I 950.885
P IV 950.657
O I 948.686
O I 948.686
C I 945.579
C I 945.338
C I 945.191
S VI 944.523
964.40
963.93
963.74
954.02
953.88
953.73
953.60
953.43
953.35
953.21
952.34
950.67
950.47
948.60
948.47
945.33
945.09
944.95
944.40
940.01
936.55
936.40
934.85
934.73
933.28
931.90
924.87
924.73
921.77
921.64
920.11
919.85
919.54 Ar II 919.781?,O I 919.658?
916.77
915.47
S VI 933.378?
Ar II* 932.054
O I 924.950
O I 924.950
O I 921.857
O I 921.857
O I 936.623
O I 936.623
O I 916.960+916.815
N II 915.61
?
?
?
?
?
Nb,NN
Nb+(Ph?)
Nb+Ph
Nb
NN
Nb
NN
Nb
NN
Nb
NN
Nb
NN
Nb
NN
Nb
Nb
Nb
Nb
?
NN
Nb
?
?
?
Nb
NN
Nb
NN
Nb
?
?
?
Nb,NN
Nb,NN
† Ph = Photosphere, Nb = Nebular, NN = Non-Nebular, ? = Unknown
The model atomic and molecular absorption spectrum was
created by adding to a master optical depth template, cov-
ering 900 -- 1400 A, all the contributions from the atomic
and molecular hydrogen lines for all the velocity components.
There are two distinct components with heliocentric veloc-
ities of -- 75 and -- 28 ± 2 km s−1 for molecular hydrogen.
The first is associated with the nebular expansion and the
second is associated with non-nebular ISM. For the atomic
Lyman series we used transitions up to n = 49, with the ve-
locity offsets, column densities and doppler parameters listed
in McCandliss et al. (2007). For hot molecular hydrogen we
used the H2ools rovibrational templates of McCandliss (2003)
with b = 7 km s−1, offset by -- 75 km s−1and scaled to the
column densities listed in McCandliss et al. (2007). We ex-
tended the calculation up to J′′= 15 and v′′= 3 by assuming
the upper level ro-vibration populations were thermal with a
temperature of 2040 K as given by the best fit single temper-
ature model. We also used the H2ools templates to model the
cold molecular component at -- 28 km s−1 with a pure thermal
distribution of 200 K. The transmission function, defined as
the negative exponential of the master optical depth template,
is multiplied to the stellar continuum model, which has been
blueshifted to the systemic radial velocity of the nebula, -- 42
km s−1, to produce the model of continuum absorption by
hydrogen. This model is also made available on the H2ools
website.
Figure 2a shows the resulting continuum absorption model.
The top spectral sequence in each panel is an overplot of the
Metal Absorption Profiles from M27
9
1037.0
1037.2
O VI 1037.617 Å
1037.4
1037.6
1037.8
1031.4
O VI 1031.926 Å
1031.6
1031.8
1032.0
1032.2
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
IP=138eV
log(fl )= 1.84
0
−200 −150 −100
IP=138eV
log(fl )= 2.14
0
−200 −150 −100
50
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
100
50
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
100
1171.6 1171.8 1172.0 1172.2 1172.4 1172.6 1172.8 1173.0
O VIe 1172.439 Å
1170.6 1170.8 1171.0 1171.2 1171.4 1171.6 1171.8 1172.0
O VIe 1171.561 Å
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
= −0.42Å
IP=138eV
log(fl )= 2.07
−200
−100
0
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
100
1146.2 1146.4 1146.6 1146.8 1147.0 1147.2 1147.4 1147.6
O VIe 1147.072 Å
IP=138eV
log(fl )= 1.63
−200
−100
0
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
100
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
= −0.42Å
IP=138eV
log(fl )= 2.07
−200
−100
0
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
100
1146.0 1146.2 1146.4 1146.6 1146.8 1147.0 1147.2
O VIe 1146.791 Å
IP=138eV
log(fl )= 1.55
−200
−100
0
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
100
FIG. 3. -- Stellar photospheric O VI and O VIe lines. FUSE spectra s12 (orange), s21 (green) and the model (black) are plotted along with overlapping STIS
orders (purple and grey), if available. Vertical dashed lines mark the transition, Vsys, Vgr and non-nebular velocities at -- 75, -- 42, -- 37 and -- 28 km s−1 respectively.
O VIe l
1172.439, 1171.561 lines were used to assess the offset between the FUSE and STIS spectra. Published rest wavelengths for these lines are discrepant.
D
l
D
l
l
10
McCandliss and Kruk
1124.0 1124.2 1124.4 1124.6 1124.8 1125.0 1125.2
O VIe 1124.809 Å
1123.8 1124.0 1124.2 1124.4 1124.6 1124.8 1125.0 1125.2
O VIe 1124.716 Å
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3
2
1
0
3
2
1
0
3
2
1
0
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3
2
1
0
3
2
1
0
IP=138eV
log(fl )= 3.18
−200
−100
0
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
100
1121.8 1122.0 1122.2 1122.4 1122.6 1122.8 1123.0
O VIe 1122.593 Å
IP=138eV
log(fl )= 2.98
−200
−100
0
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
100
IP=138eV
log(fl )= 3.17
−200
−100
0
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
100
1121.8 1122.0 1122.2 1122.4 1122.6 1122.8 1123.0
O VIe 1122.618 Å
IP=138eV
log(fl )= 1.68
−200
−100
0
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
100
1121.6 1121.8 1122.0 1122.2 1122.4 1122.6 1122.8
O VIe 1122.348 Å
1370.8
O Ve 1371.292 Å
1371.0
1371.2
1371.4
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
IP=114eV
log(fl )= 2.33
0.0
−150
IP=138eV
log(fl )= 3.00
−200
−100
0
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
100
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
FIG. 4. -- Stellar photospheric O VIe and O Ve l 1371.292 lines. Stellar photospheric O VIe and O Ve l 1371.292 lines. The O Ve l 1371.292 line was used to
established the gravitational redshift of the system. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
Metal Absorption Profiles from M27
11
1229.4 1229.6 1229.8 1230.0 1230.2 1230.4
C IVe 1230.043 Å
1229.8 1230.0 1230.2 1230.4 1230.6 1230.8
C IVe 1230.521 Å
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
IP=64eV
log(fl )= 2.00
0.0
−200 −150 −100
50
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
100
1168.4
1168.6
1168.8
1169.0
C IVe 1168.993 Å
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
IP=64eV
log(fl )= 2.00
0.0
−200 −150 −100
50
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
100
1168.4
C IVe 1168.849 Å
1168.8
1168.6
1169.0
1169.2
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
1169.2
1168.2
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
IP=64eV
log(fl )= 3.07
0.0
−200 −150 −100
50
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
100
IP=64eV
log(fl )= 3.07
0.0
−200 −150 −100
50
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1107.2
1107.4
1107.6
1107.8
C IVe 1107.932 Å
1108.0
1108.2
1107.0
C IVe 1107.593 Å
1107.2
1107.4
1107.6
1107.8
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
IP=64eV
log(fl )= 2.73
0
−200 −150 −100
50
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
100
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
IP=64eV
log(fl )= 2.78
0
−200 −150 −100
50
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
100
100
FIG. 5. -- The photospheric lines of excited C IVe. C IVe l
wavelength scales. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
1168.849, 1168.993 were used to reconcile the relative offset between the FUSE and STIS
l
12
McCandliss and Kruk
s12 (orange) and s21 (green) spectral extractions with the ab-
sorbed continuum model (black). The lower sequence in each
panel is the residual formed by substracting the model from
s12 (orange) and s21 (green). An offset of 10−12 ergs cm−2
s−1 A−1 and a two pixel smoothing has been applied to the
residuals. The solid horizonal black line marks the zero level
for the residuals. The high frequency spikes that go rapidly
from positive to negative in the residual are created by lo-
cal wavelength misalignment of the spectral extractions with
respect to the molecular model. The strongest stellar photo-
spheric, nebular and non-nebular absorptions by species other
than H2, H I or photospheric He II are clearly revealed in the
residuals. Emission lines of He II l 1084, l 992 and l 958 are
also evident. The absorption systems are numbered in the fig-
ure in reference to an entry in Table 2 where the line speci-
fications are detailed. The identifications are not exhaustive;
small unidentified lines may yet lurk in the noise.
The residual spectrum allows us to assess the success of the
absorbed continuum model in reproducing the features in the
spectral extractions. Strictly speaking, the subtraction of fea-
tures should take place in the optical depth space t (l ) as op-
posed to the transmission space exp(−t (l )). Abundance de-
terminations whether by profile fitting or equivalent width de-
termination must account for the optical depth blending cor-
rectly. However, as our purpose here is merely line identifica-
tion, the simple subtraction process is adequate.
4. STIS AND FUSE ABSORPTION PROFILES AS A FUNCTION OF
VELOCITY
We separate the display of individual absorption profiles in
Figures 3 -- 15 into four categories, stellar, nebular plus stel-
lar, nebular CNO and nebular metals. The wider stellar lines
we plot over a velocity bandpass of -- 250 to +150 km s−1or
-- 200 to +100 km s−1. Otherwise we use a bandpass of -- 150
to +50 km s−1. We omit the broad H I and He II photospheric
features. The black dashed vertical lines mark the location
of the hot molecular hydrogen component at -- 75 km s−1 the
systemic velocity at -- 42 km s−1, and the cold molecular hy-
drogen component at -- 30 km s−1. The red dashed vertical
lines mark the gravitational redshift of the systemic velocity.
The s12 and s21 spectra are shown in orange and green
respectively. The continuum model, including the hydro-
gen lines, is plotted as a thin black line. Regions where the
agreement is poor between the wavelength scales for the s12,
s21, and model spectra become readily apparent as do regions
where the continuum flux is too high, especially near the O VI
lines. For lines in the STIS region the spectra are plotted in
green.
4.1. Stellar Photospheric Features and the Absolute
Wavelength Scale
Comparison of the FUSE and STIS wavelength scales re-
vealed a systematic offset. The reconciliation of this offset is
essential for investigating the kinematics of the nebular out-
flow, where we seek to determine the velocity of the various
molecular and atomic features with respect to the systemic
velocity of the nebula. In principle, lines that arise from the
photosphere should match the systemic velocity of the system
less the gravitational redshift offset. In practice this has been
difficult to realize except for the narrowest of photospheric
features.
We have examined the overlap of the spectra in the com-
mon wavelength regions below 1190 A, where high excitation
photospheric C IV and O VI lines are located. We have also
checked the registration of the excited molecular hydrogen
lines that appear in the STIS bandpass above 1190 A with the
continuum plus hydrogen model. The disagreements revealed
from these examinations have been reconciled as described
below.
An absolute reference to the heliocentric velocity was es-
tablished by close examination of the O V l 1371.296 feature.
This narrow line is a transition between two highly excited
states in O V and is expected to be an excellent indicator of
the photospheric restframe (Pierre Chayer private communi-
cation). For a compact object of the mass and radius found
by Napiwotzki (1999) we expect the photospheric lines to ex-
1
perience a gravitation redshift, Vgr = c((1 − 2GM∗
2 − 1) =
5.1 km s−1. Applying a shift of -- 13 km s−1 to the STIS spec-
trum placed the centroid of the O V l 1371.296 at -- 37 km s−1,
as expected for a Vsys of -42 km s−1 (Wilson 1953).
R∗c2 )−
In the original analysis of the FUSE M27 spectra by
McCandliss (2001) the hot nebular molecular hydrogen com-
ponent was defined to be at -- 69 km s−1. Examining the over-
lap of common wavelength features in the FUSE and STIS
spectra after defining the O V l 1371.296 to be at -- 37 km s−1,
we found it necessary to shift the FUSE spectra blueward
by -- 6 km s−1, such that the hot nebular molecular hydro-
gen is now at -- 75 km s−1. The most useful overlap lines
for assessing the alignment were the doublet blend of C IV
1171.56,
1172.44. We note that the wavelengths of the O VI doublet
given in the NIST online tables appear to be in error by ≈ --
0.42 A. Jahn et al. (2006) have produced an new empirical set
of O VI wavelengths, which agree to within 0.04 A of those
found here. We also examined the FUSE N I multiplets at
1200 -- 1201
1168.849, 1168.993 and the the narrow O VI l
1134 -- 1135 and the STIS N I multiplets at l
to confirm the wavelength reconciliation.
O VI and O Ve -- In Figure 3 and 4 we show the O VI and O V
profiles we have identified as being photospheric in origin.
Those lines that arise from absorption out of energy levels
well above the ground state are designated as either O VIe or
O Ve. The O VI l 1037.62 resonance line shows some very
slight signs of blue shifted nebular absorption.
C IVe -- In Figure 5 we show the excited C IVe lines. None of
these lines is saturated. Overlapping STIS spectra if available
are plotted in purple (and grey if two orders are available).
These spectra are comparatively noisy, but the alignment with
the FUSE spectra agrees as well as the alignment between the
s12 and s21 spectra. We note that the error in the systemic
velocity is of order the STIS resoution element and is three
times the FUSE resolution element. We consider the agree-
ment of line profiles from spectra acquired with two different
instruments to be excellent. The STIS order, shown in grey,
of the C IVe l
1168.849, 1168.993 doublet has a spurious
absorption feature that does not appear in the order shown in
purple nor in the FUSE spectra and can be ignored.
4.2. Photospheric + Nebular Features
1548.204, 1550.781, and N V l
C IV and N V -- The high ionization resonance doublets C IV
1238.821, 1242.804 show
signs of nebular absorption to the blue of -- 37 km s−1 and pho-
tospheric absorption to the red as can be seen in Figure 6. The
nebular absorption component in the N V lines is strong only
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
Metal Absorption Profiles from M27
13
1550.2
C IV 1550.781 Å
1550.6
1550.4
1550.8
1551.0
1547.6
C IV 1548.204 Å
1547.8
1548.0
1548.2
1548.4
IP=64eV
log(fl )= 2.17
0.0
−150
IP=64eV
log(fl )= 2.47
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
1238.4
N V 1238.821 Å
1238.6
1238.8
1239.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
IP=98eV
log(fl )= 2.29
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
1238.821, 1242.804, showing signs of nebular absorption blueward
N III, N II and N I -- The N III lines in Figure 8 are strongly
blended with overlapping molecular hydrogen. The blended
profile indicates the absorption is saturated between -- 60 and
-- 100 km s−1. The N II* and N II** lines in Figure 9 are sim-
ilarily messy. However, N II l 1083.994 is relatively clean.
It shows absorption throughout the flow, being less saturated
at low velocities and becoming completely saturated at -- 75
km s−1. This line also shows stonger nebular absorption than
non-nebular absorption emphasizing its dominance over N I,
which shows the opposite behavior. The N I multiplets at
1199.550 -- 1200.710, in Fig-
ure 10a, simply show unsaturated absorption centered at -- 75
km s−1.
1134.165 -- 1134.980 and l
O I -- The O I lines in Figure 11 show a range of saturated
to unsaturated profiles centered at -- 75 km s−1.
It may be
possible to determine the column density of this species fairly
accurately with a curve of growth, after properly accounting
for the continuum placement and molecular hydrogen optical
depth subtraction.
4.3.1. Nebular Metals
1242.2
2.5
1242.4
N V 1242.804 Å
1242.6
1242.8
1243.0
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
IP=98eV
log(fl )= 1.99
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
FIG. 6. -- Absorption as a function of velocity for C IV l
of -- 37 km s−1 and photospheric absorption redward. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
between -- 42 and -- 75 km s−1 and is just barely saturated at
≈ -60 km s−1. In contrast, the nebular absorption component
in the C IV lines spans -- 42 to -- 115 km s−1 and is completely
saturated from -- 50 to -- 95 km s−1.
1548.204, 1550.781, and N V l
4.3. Nebular CNO
In general, these lines show absorption from the nebula
to the blue, and varying strengths of the intervening (non-
nebular) ISM absorption components to the red of the sys-
temic velocity. The nebular features that show absorption
only in the nebular expansion (i.e. at velocities blueward of
the systemic velocity) are from intermediate or low ionization
species. The non-nebular velocity features are most promi-
nent in the lowest ionization and neutral species along the
line-of-sight.
C III and C II -- We show lines of C III and C II in Figure 7.
Like the C IV lines, these lines are heavily saturated through-
out the nebular flow region blueward of -- 42 km s−1. The sat-
uration makes it difficult to tell, which if any, ion is dominant
in the different nebular velocity regimes.
l
l
l
l
l
14
McCandliss and Kruk
976.6
976.7
C III 977.020 Å
976.8
976.9
977.0
977.1
1334.0
C II 1334.532 Å
1334.4
1334.2
1334.6
IP=47.9eV
log(fl )= 2.87
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
1035.9 1036.0 1036.1 1036.2 1036.3 1036.4 1036.5
C II 1036.337 Å
IP=24.4eV
log(fl )= 2.10
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1036.5 1036.6 1036.7 1036.8 1036.9 1037.0 1037.1
C II* 1037.018 Å
5
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
1.5
1.0
0.5
IP=24.4eV
log(fl )= 2.23
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1335.2
C II* 1335.708 Å
1335.4
1335.6
1335.8
1.5
1.0
0.5
IP=24.4eV
log(fl )= 2.18
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
50
50
50
IP=24.4eV
log(fl )= 2.10
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
FIG. 7. -- Absorption as a function of velocity for the C III and C II lines. Like the C IV lines, these lines are heavily saturated throughout the nebular flow
region blueward of -- 42 km s−1. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
5
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
IP=47.5eV
log(fl )= 2.09
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
991.1
991.2
991.3
991.4
N III* 991.577 Å
991.5
991.6
991.7
IP=47.5eV
log(fl )= 2.04
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
991.1
991.2
N III* 991.511 Å
991.3
991.4
991.5
991.6
IP=47.5eV
log(fl )= 1.08
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
FIG. 8. -- Absorption as a function of velocity for the N III l
989.799 --
991.577 multiplet. The N III is blended with molecular hydrogen. The N III*
lines are also blended with each other. See Figure 3 for a description of the
colors.
989.4
989.5
N III 989.799 Å
989.7
989.6
989.8
989.9
Metal Absorption Profiles from M27
15
The transition zone between high ionization and low ion-
ization occurs at the velocity of -- 75 km s−1, where H I, C I,
N I, O I and molecular hydrogen show up most strongly in the
nebula.
Si IV, Si III and Si II -- The high ionization low velocity, low
ionization high velocity dichotomy is most clearly seen in the
Si IV l 1393.760 and Si II l 1193.290 lines as shown in Fig-
ure 12a. Since these lines have nearly equal log( f l ) they are
reliable indicators of the relative ionization as a function of
velocity. Si II is stronger than Si IV in the zone between -- 75
and -- 110 km s−1, while Si IV is stronger than Si II in the zone
between -- 42 and -- 75 km s−1. The Si III l 1206.500 line is
saturated throughout most of the flow. It is a very strong line
with a log( f l ) = 3.29, which makes it difficult to determine if
this species is the dominant ion throughout the flow.
P IV, P III and P II -- We detect weak P IV l 950.657, P III
l 998.000, and P II l 1152.818 at progressively high velocities
of ≈ -- 65, -- 70, -- 80 km s−1 respectively as shown in Figure 13.
The P V l 1117.977 line (not shown) of the P V doublet is very
weak, while l 1128.008 is blended with H2.
S IV, S III and S II -- The S IV -- S II ions show similar behavior
to Si and P in Figure 14. The S III l 1190.203 line appears
to have a feature near -- 42 km s−1. However, this is just the
nebular component of the nearby Si II l 1190.416 line. The
nebular portion of this feature is clean and agrees well with
the shape of the S III l 1012.495 profile, with the absorption
stongest near -- 70 km s−1and weakening slowly to the blue
and relatively quickly to the red.
Ar II and Ar I -- Figure 15 shows Ar II l 919.781, Ar II*
932.054, and Ar I 1048.220 are detected, with Ar II appear-
ing at ≈ -- 55 km s−1 and Ar I appearing at ≈ -- 75 km s−1.
Ar I 1066.660 is blended with an overlapping H2 line. Ar II
919.781 is blended with a nearby molecular hydrogen line but
the nebular Ar II* l 932.054 is clearly visible without model
subtraction. The thermal production of Ar II* requires a tem-
perature ∼ 10,000 K, and is a confirmation that the gas at low
velocities is much hotter than that indicated by the molecular
hydrogen. The absorption of the Ar II lines is stronger than
the Ar I lines even though they have transition strengths a fac-
tor of 10 lower. This suggests the Ar II is the dominant over
Ar Iin the nebula.
Fe III and Fe II -- Fe III l 1122.524 may be blended with a
molecular hydrogen line aon the blue side of the photospheric
O VIe l
1122.593 -- 1122.618 doublet as shown in Figure 16.
However, without a good idea of what the photospheric line
shape is in this region, we cannot claim a detection. The
strongest transitions of Fe II l 1608.451 and l 1144.938 appear
weakly at -- 75 km s−1. These lines have transition strengths
(log ( f l ) = 2.06, 2.11) that are nearly identical to that of Si II
l 1304.370 (log ( f l ) = 2.08), yet the Si II feature is much
stronger. The ionization potential of Si II (16.3 eV) is also
nearly identical to that of Fe II (16.2 eV) and they also have
similar condensation temperatures (Morton 2003). We con-
clude that Fe II relative to Si II is underabundant in the nebula.
Arguing in a similar vein, we see that the transition at
Fe II l 1133.665 is not detected in the nebula at all.
It has
nearly the same transition strength (log ( f l ) = 1.15) as the
S II l 1253.811 line (log ( f l ) = 1.14), which is weak but eas-
ily seen. We conclude that Fe II relative to S II is also un-
derabundant. The solar abundance of Si and Fe are nearly
50
50
l
l
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
16
McCandliss and Kruk
1083.6
N II 1083.994 Å
1083.8
1084.0
1084.2
N II* 1084.584 Å
1084.4
1084.6
IP=29.6eV
log(fl )= 2.10
0
−150
IP=29.6eV
log(fl )= 1.97
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1084.2
N II* 1084.566 Å
1084.4
1084.6
1085.2
N II** 1085.710 Å
1085.6
1085.4
1085.8
50
50
50
IP=29.6eV
log(fl )= 1.49
0.0
−150
IP=29.6eV
log(fl )= 2.02
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1085.2
N II** 1085.551 Å
1085.4
1085.6
1085.0
N II** 1085.533 Å
1085.4
1085.2
1085.6
IP=29.6eV
log(fl )= 1.26
0.0
−150
IP=29.6eV
log(fl )= 0.08
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
FIG. 9. -- Absorption as a function of velocity for the N II l
molecular hydrogen. The N II line is relatively clean. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
1083.994 -- 1085.710 multiplet. The N II* and N II** lines are blended with each other and
l
Metal Absorption Profiles from M27
17
1200.8
1199.8
N I 1200.223 Å
1200.0
1200.2
1200.4
1200.2
1200.4
N I 1200.710 Å
1200.6
IP=14.5eV
log(fl )= 1.72
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1199.0
N I 1199.550 Å
1199.4
1199.2
1199.6
IP=14.5eV
log(fl )= 2.02
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1134.6
N I 1134.980 Å
1134.8
1135.0
IP=14.5eV
log(fl )= 2.20
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
IP=14.5eV
log(fl )= 1.67
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1134.0
N I 1134.415 Å
1134.2
1134.4
1134.6
1133.6
1133.8
N I 1134.165 Å
1134.0
1134.2
50
50
50
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
50
50
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
IP=14.5eV
log(fl )= 1.51
0.0
−150
IP=14.5eV
log(fl )= 1.22
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
FIG. 10A. -- Absorption as a function of velocity for the N I lines show unsaturated absorption at -- 75 km s−1. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
18
McCandliss and Kruk
964.2
964.3
N I 964.626 Å
964.4
964.5
964.6
964.7
953.0
953.1
N I 953.415 Å
953.2
953.3
953.4
953.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
5
4
3
2
1
IP=14.5eV
log(fl )= 0.88
0
−150
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
5
4
3
2
1
IP=14.5eV
log(fl )= 1.09
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
FIG. 10B. -- More N I lines. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
identical (7.56, 7.50 respectively) and are slightly higher than
S (7.2). It is not unusual to have the Si abundance greater
than the Fe in the typical ISM because it is depleted onto dust
(Savage & Sembach 1996). However, here we have no Fe in
the gas phase and appearently very little dust in the diffuse
nebular medium. This is a puzzle.
5. SUGGESTIONS FOR FUTURE INVESTIGATIONS
M27 is a excellent laboratory for testing theories regarding
the abundance kinematics in PNe because the stellar temper-
ature, mass, gravity, and the nebular mass, distance, abun-
dances, extinction and excitation states, are well quantified.
The reduced spectra provided by this study and the associated
atomic and molecular hydrogen model for the nebular and
non-nebular absorptions, should enable a photospheric analy-
sis of the metal abundances, similar to the effort undertaken
by Jahn et al. (2006) for PG 1159 - 035. Establishing a re-
liable stellar continuum is the first step towards determining
accurate nebular absorption line abundances for comparision
with those derived from the emission line analyses of Barker
(1984) and Hawley & Miller (1978).
The finding in Paper I, of little extinction by dust in the neb-
ula raises a number of interesting questions concerning the
depletion of metals in the diffuse and clumpy media, which
go beyond the scope of this investigation. A major limitation
to this effort is the requirement for a good stellar model that
can reliably reproduce the observed photospheric features and
continuum, especially in the vicinity of the blend of nebular
Fe III l 1122.52 with photospheric O VI l 1122.62. If such a
stellar model can be produced, the total S, Si, P and Fe abun-
dances should be derivable by profile modeling after account-
ing for the atomic and molecular hydrogen absorption pro-
vided here. The question of whether the abundances of these
metals change across the neutral transition zone could pro-
vide information on whether photo-evaporation of the glob-
ules is an important process for the enrichment of metals in
the high velocity zone. A model of the nebular ionization as a
function of velocity would be useful for this purpose. Such a
model might be produced by melding the detailed time depen-
dent approach to the calculations of the atomic and molecular
emissions followed by Natta & Hollenbach (1998), with the
radiative hydrodynamical rigor of Villaver et al. (2002). The
problem may also be approached by using the Sobolev plus
exact integration (SEI) method of Lamers et al. (1987), from
which a empirical parameterization of the wind velocity 'law"
could be obtained.
We are grateful to Patrick J. Huggins who provided en-
couragement to complete this work. Thanks also to Roxana
Lupu, Kevin France and Eric Burgh for stimulating sugges-
tions. Based on observations made with the NASA-CNES-
CSA Far Ultraviolet Spectroscopic Explorer. FUSE is oper-
ated for NASA by the Johns Hopkins University under NASA
contract NAS5-32985. In addition, some of the data presented
in this paper were obtained from the Multimission Archive at
the Space Telescope Science Institute (MAST). STScI is op-
erated by the Association of Universities for Research in As-
tronomy, Inc., under NASA contract NAS5-26555. Support
for MAST for non-HST data is provided by the NASA Office
of Space Science via grant NAG5-7584 and by other grants
and contracts.
Facilities: HST (STIS), FUSE.
REFERENCES
Bachiller, R., Cox, P., Josselin, E., Huggins, P. J., Forveille, T.,
Miville-Deschenes, M. A., & Boulanger, F. 2000, in ESA SP-456: ISO
Beyond the Peaks: The 2nd ISO Workshop on Analytical Spectroscopy,
171
Barker, T. 1984, ApJ, 284, 589
Benedict, G. F., et al. 2003, AJ, 126, 2549
Hawley, S. A., & Miller, J. S. 1978, PASP, 90, 39
Jahn, D., Rauch, T., E., R., Werner, K., Kruk, J. W., & Herwig, F. 2006,
Kwok, S., Purton, C. R., & Fitzgerald, P. M. 1978, ApJ, 219, L125
Lamers, H. J. G. L. M., Cerruti-Sola, M., & Perinotto, M. 1987, ApJ, 314,
Accepted a
726
Lupu, R., France, K., & McCandliss, S. R. 2006, ApJ
Metal Absorption Profiles from M27
19
1301.6
O I 1302.168 Å
1302.0
1301.8
1302.2
1038.8 1038.9 1039.0 1039.1 1039.2 1039.3 1039.4
O I 1039.230 Å
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
IP=13.6eV
log(fl )= 1.83
0.0
−150
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
IP=13.6eV
log(fl )= 0.98
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
O I 971.738 Å
971.5
971.6
971.7
971.8
971.9
971.3
971.4
4
3
2
1
IP=13.6eV
log(fl )= 1.05
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
O I 948.686 Å
948.5
948.6
948.7
948.8
948.3
948.4
4
3
2
1
IP=13.6eV
log(fl )= 0.78
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
O I 950.885 Å
950.7
950.8
950.9
951.0
950.5
950.6
5
4
3
2
1
IP=13.6eV
log(fl )= 0.18
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
O I 936.630 Å
936.4
936.5
936.6
936.7
936.2
936.3
5
4
3
2
1
IP=13.6eV
log(fl )= 0.53
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
50
FIG. 11. -- Absorption as a function of velocity for the O I ground state lines. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
20
McCandliss and Kruk
1402.2
1402.4
1402.6
Si IV 1402.773 Å
1402.8
1403.0
1393.2
Si IV 1393.760 Å
1393.6
1393.4
1393.8
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
1.5
1.0
0.5
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
50
50
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
IP=45eV
log(fl )= 2.55
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1206.0
Si III 1206.500 Å
1206.2
1206.4
1206.6
IP=45eV
log(fl )= 2.85
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1526.0
1526.2
1526.4
1526.6
1526.8
Si II 1526.707 Å
IP=33.5eV
log(fl )= 3.29
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
IP=16.3eV
log(fl )= 2.30
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1303.8
Si II 1304.370 Å
1304.2
1304.0
1304.4
1259.8
1260.0
Si II 1260.422 Å
1260.2
1260.4
1260.6
50
50
IP=16.3eV
log(fl )= 2.08
0.0
−150
IP=16.3eV
log(fl )= 3.17
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
FIG. 12A. -- Comparision of the Si IV, Si III and Si II. Si II dominates Si IV in the zone between -- 75 and -- 110 km s−1 while Si IV dominates the lower ionization
species near -- 60 km s−1. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
Metal Absorption Profiles from M27
21
1192.8
Si II 1193.290 Å
1193.0
1193.2
1193.4
1190.0
Si II 1190.416 Å
1190.2
1190.4
1190.6
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
IP=16.3eV
log(fl )= 2.84
0.0
−150
IP=16.3eV
log(fl )= 2.54
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
FIG. 12B. -- More Si II lines. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
McCandliss, S. R. 2001, in ASP Conf. Ser. 247: Spectroscopic Challenges
of Photoionized Plasmas, 523
McCandliss, S. R. 2003, PASP, 115, 651
McCandliss, S. R., France, K., Lupu, R., Burgh, B. B., Sembach, K., Kruk,
J., Andersson, B.-G., & D., F. P. 2007, to be submitted to ApJ
Meaburn, J., & Lopez, J. A. 1993, MNRAS, 263, 890
Meaburn, J. 2005, ArXiv Astrophysics e-prints, arXiv:astro-ph/0512099
Meaburn, J., Boumis, P., Christopoulou, P. E., Goudis, C. D., Bryce, M., &
L´opez, J. A. 2005, Revista Mexicana de Astronomia y Astrofisica, 41, 109
Meaburn, J., Boumis, P., L´opez, J. A., Harman, D. J., Bryce, M., Redman,
M. P., & Mavromatakis, F. 2005, MNRAS, 360, 963
Moos, H. W., et al. 2000, ApJ, 538, L1
Morton, D. C. 2003, ApJS, 149, 205
;
Napiwotzki, R. 1999, A&A, 350, 101
Natta, A., & Hollenbach, D. 1998, A&A, 337, 517
O'Dell, C. R., Balick, B., Hajian, A. R., Henney, W. J., & Burkert, A. 2002,
AJ, 123, 3329
Quijano, e. a., J. K. 2003, STIS Instrument Handbook, Version 7.0 (STIS
Instrument Handbook, by Spectrographs Group, (Baltimore: STScI))
Rauch, T. 2003, A&A, 403, 709
Sahnow, D. J., et al. 2000, ApJ, 538, L7
Savage, B. D., & Sembach, K. R. 1996, ARA&A, 34, 279
Villaver, E., Manchado, A., & Garc´ıa-Segura, G. 2002, ApJ, 581, 1204
Wilson, R. E. 1953, in Carnegie Institute Washington D.C. Publication, 0
P IV 950.657 Å
950.4
950.5
950.6
McCandliss and Kruk
950.7
950.8
950.3
950.2
4
3
2
1
IP=51.4eV
log(fl )= 3.15
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
997.6
997.7
P III 998.000 Å
997.9
997.8
998.0
998.1
22
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
5
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
50
50
IP=30.2eV
log(fl )= 2.05
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1152.4
P II 1152.818 Å
1152.6
1152.8
1153.0
IP=19.8eV
log(fl )= 2.45
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
FIG. 13. -- P IV l 950.657, P III l 998.000, and P II l 1152.818 lines are
weak. Although the P IV and P III are surrounded by molecular hydrogen
they show behavior similar to Si. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
Metal Absorption Profiles from M27
23
1062.2
S IV 1062.664 Å
1062.4
1062.6
1062.8
1189.8
S III 1190.203 Å
1190.0
1190.2
1190.4
IP=47.3eV
log(fl )= 1.72
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1012.0 1012.1 1012.2 1012.3 1012.4 1012.5 1012.6
5
S III 1012.495 Å
IP=34.8eV
log(fl )= 1.45
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1259.0
1259.2
1259.4
1259.6
S II 1259.519 Å
IP=34.8eV
log(fl )= 1.65
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
IP=23.3eV
log(fl )= 1.32
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1253.2
1253.4
S II 1253.811 Å
1253.6
1253.8
1254.0
1250.0
1250.2
S II 1250.584 Å
1250.4
1250.6
50
50
50
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
50
50
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
IP=23.3eV
log(fl )= 1.14
0.0
−150
IP=23.3eV
log(fl )= 0.83
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
FIG. 14. -- S IV -- S II lines show behavior similar to Si. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
24
McCandliss and Kruk
919.4
919.5
Ar II 919.781 Å
919.7
919.6
919.8
919.9
931.7
931.6
5
Ar II* 932.054 Å
931.8
931.9
932.0
932.1
932.2
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
4
3
2
1
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
50
1066.8
50
5
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
4
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
IP=27.6eV
log(fl )= 0.92
0
−150
IP=27.6eV
log(fl )= 0.93
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
1047.7 1047.8 1047.9 1048.0 1048.1 1048.2 1048.3
Ar I 1048.220 Å
1066.2
Ar I 1066.660 Å
1066.4
1066.6
IP=15.8eV
log(fl )= 2.44
0
−150
IP=15.8eV
log(fl )= 1.86
0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
FIG. 15. -- Ar II lines appear at a velocity of ≈ -- 55 km s−1, while the Ar I appear at ≈ -- 75 km s−1. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
3
2
1
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
)
1
−
Å
1
−
s
2
−
m
c
s
g
r
e
2
1
−
0
1
x
(
x
u
l
F
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
Metal Absorption Profiles from M27
1122.0
Fe III 1122.524 Å
1122.4
1122.2
1122.6
1607.8
Fe II 1608.451 Å
1608.4
1608.0
1608.2
25
1608.6
IP=30.7eV
log(fl )= 1.79
0
−150
IP=16.2eV
log(fl )= 2.06
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
1144.4
Fe II 1144.938 Å
1144.8
1144.6
1145.0
1142.8
Fe II 1143.226 Å
1143.0
1143.2
1143.4
IP=16.2eV
log(fl )= 2.11
0.0
−150
IP=16.2eV
log(fl )= 1.49
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
1141.8
1142.0
Fe II 1142.366 Å
1142.2
1142.4
1133.2
Fe II 1133.665 Å
1133.4
1133.6
1133.8
IP=16.2eV
log(fl )= 0.82
0.0
−150
IP=16.2eV
log(fl )= 1.15
0.0
−150
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
−100
Heliocentric Velocity (km s−1)
−50
0
50
FIG. 16. -- The detection of Fe III cannot be claimed. Fe II is underabundant relative to S II. See Figure 3 for a description of the colors.
|
astro-ph/0509728 | 1 | 0509 | 2005-09-23T21:03:26 | Investigating disk evolution: A high spatial resolution mid-infrared survey of T Tauri stars | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present a high spatial resolution, 10-20 micron survey of 65 T Tauri binary stars in Taurus, Ophiuchus, and Corona Australis using the Keck 10 m telescopes. Designed to probe the inner ~1 AU region of the circumstellar disks around the individual stellar components in these binary systems, this study increases the number of binaries with spatially resolved measurements at 10 micron by a factor of ~5. Combined with resolved near-infrared photometry and spectroscopic accretion diagnostics, we find that ~10% of stars with a mid-infrared excess do not appear to be accreting. In contrast to an actively accreting disk system, these passive disks have significantly lower near-infrared colors that are, in most cases, consistent with photospheric emission, suggesting the presence of an inner disk hole. In addition, there appears to be a spectral type/mass dependence associated with the presence of a passive disk, with all passive disks occurring around M type stars. The possibility that the passive disks are caused by the presence of an as yet undetected companion at a small separation (0.3-3 AU) is possible for any individual system, however, it cannot account for the spectral type dependence of the passive disk sample as a whole. We propose that these passive disks represent a subset of T Tauri stars that are undergoing significant disk evolution. The fraction of observed passive disks and the observed spectral type dependence can both be explained by models of disk evolution that include disk photoevaporation from the central star. (abridged). | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Investigating Disk Evolution: A High Spatial Resolution
Mid-Infrared Survey of T Tauri Stars
McCabe, C.,1,2,3 Ghez, A.M.,1,4 Prato, L.,1,3,5 Duchene, G.1,6
and
Fisher, R.S.7, Telesco, C.8
ABSTRACT
We present a high spatial resolution, 10–20 µm survey of 65 T Tauri binary
stars in Taurus, Ophiuchus, and Corona Australis using the Keck 10 m telescopes.
Designed to probe the inner ∼1 AU region of the circumstellar disks around the
individual stellar components in these binary systems, this study increases the
number of binaries with spatially resolved measurements at 10 µm by a factor of
∼5. Combined with resolved near-infrared photometry and spectroscopic accre-
tion diagnostics, we find that ∼10% of stars with a mid-infrared excess do not
appear to be accreting. In contrast to an actively accreting disk system, these
passive disks have significantly lower near-infrared colors that are, in most cases,
consistent with photospheric emission, suggesting the presence of an inner disk
hole. In addition, there appears to be a spectral type/mass dependence associ-
ated with the presence of a passive disk, with all passive disks occurring around
1Department of Physics & Astronomy, University of California, Los Angeles, CA 90095-1547, mc-
[email protected], [email protected], [email protected]
2Current address: NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, MS 183-900,
4800 Oak Grove Dr., Pasadena, CA 91109-8099
3Visiting Astronomer at the Infrared Telescope Facility, which is operated by the University of Hawaii
under Cooperative Agreement no. NCC 5-538 with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration,
Office of Space Science, Planetary Astronomy Program.
4Institute of Geophysics and Planetary Physics, University of California, Los Angeles, CA 90095-1565
5Current address: Lowell Observatory, 1400 W. Mars Hill Rd., Flagstaff, AZ 86001
6Current address: Laboratoire d'Astrophysique, Observatoire de Grenoble, Universite Joseph Fourier -BP
53, F-38041, Grenoble Cedex 9, France, [email protected]
7Gemini Observatory, 670 North A'ohoku Place, Hilo, HI 96720
[email protected]
8Department of Astronomy, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL 32611, [email protected]
– 2 –
M type stars. The presence of a passive disk does not appear to be related to the
fact that these objects are in visual binary systems; the passive disk systems span
the entire range of binary separations present in the sample and a similar fraction
of passive disks is observed in a sample of single stars. The possibility that the
passive disks are caused by the presence of an as yet undetected companion at
a small separation (0.3 – 3 AU) is possible for any individual system, however,
it cannot account for the spectral type dependence of the passive disk sample
as a whole. We propose that these passive disks represent a subset of T Tauri
stars that are undergoing significant disk evolution. The fraction of observed
passive disks and the observed spectral type dependence can both be explained
by models of disk evolution that include disk photoevaporation from the central
star.
Subject headings:
systems:protoplanetary disks – binaries:close
stars:pre-main sequence – circumstellar matter – planetary
1.
Introduction
A key component in the formation and evolution of a star and its surrounding planetary
system is believed to be the existence and evolution of a circumstellar disk. Ample evidence
for the prevalence of these disks has been found around the young, low mass, T Tauri stars,
including excess emission above the photosphere at infrared and longer wavelengths (e.g.,
Beckwith et al. 1990; Sargent & Beckwith 1991), strong hydrogen emission lines indicative
of the accretion of disk gas onto the central star (e.g., Hartmann, Hewett & Calvet 1994), and
direct images that resolve the disks in thermal emission (e.g., Dutrey et al. 1998; Guilloteau,
Dutrey & Simon 1999) and scattered light (e.g., Burrows et al.
1996; Stapelfeldt et al.
1998) . While the formation of these disks is a natural consequence of the star formation
process, the details of how they evolve are poorly understood. The way in which the disk
material dissipates has important ramifications not only for the characteristics of the central
star (e.g., rotation rate), but also for the potential for planet formation. One particular
challenge to existing theories of disk evolution is the empirical evidence for two different
timescales in the inner region, which is probed by the infrared excess. The first is the
timescale for this inner disk region to survive as an optically thick structure and is relatively
long (∼ 3 × 106 yr on average, but up to 1 × 107 yr for some objects, Haisch, Lada & Lada
2001). In contrast, the second is the timescale for small dust grains to be removed from this
region and appears to be significantly shorter (∼ 105 yrs, Skrutskie et al.
1990; Skinner,
Brown & Walter 1991; Wolk & Walter 1996; Stassun et al. 2001). The short transition
– 3 –
timescale has been a considerable problem for models of disk evolution (e.g., Kenyon, Yi &
Hartmann 1996; Armitage, Clarke & Tout 1999), which generally invoke processes that
operate on the viscous timescale of the disk (∼ 107 yrs). While theorists have recently
begun to explore other physical processes that could give rise to such a rapid disk evolution
(e.g., Clarke, Gendrin & Sotomayor 2001), the physical processes behind disk evolution and
dispersion are still much debated.
2000; Stassun et al.
A key step to constraining the physical mechanisms responsible for disk evolution is
the detection of young stars with disks that are in the process of dispersing. A number of
surveys have been conducted to search for these so-called 'transition objects', stars that have
disk characteristics that are intermediate between those with clear evidence for disks and
those with no disk material (Skrutskie et al. 1990; Skinner, Brown & Walter 1991; Wolk
& Walter 1996; Duvert et al.
2001). Most of these surveys take
advantage of the significant difference between the near- and mid-infrared excess emission
(i.e., K[2.2µm] − N[10µm] color) from systems with and without disks, in order to establish
the evolutionary state of a system. However, most of this work has been done at low
angular resolution, with the mid-infrared data primarily taken from IRAS which has a beam
size of 30′′ at 12 µm. At the distance to the nearest sites of star formation (d=140 pc),
this corresponds to 4200 AU, within which most young stars are observed to have stellar
companions (e.g., Ghez et al. 1993; Leinert et al. 1993; Simon et al. 1995). The confusion
introduced by these unresolved companions is well illustrated by the case of V773 Tau,
which is one of the two candidate evolved disks identified by Stassun et al. (2001), based
on the lack of accretion and near-infrared excess and considerable excess at mid-infrared
wavelengths and longer. V773 Tau is a quadruple system, with 3 stellar companions within
0.′′3 of the primary. Duchene et al. (2003) show that the excess seen in V773 Tau is actually
from the recently discovered optically invisible, infrared bright, companion only 0.′′24 away
from V773 Tau A. These infrared companions (IRCs) occur with a frequency of ∼10% in the
T Tauri population, a suspiciously similar frequency to the observed fraction of transition
objects in low spatial resolution surveys for evolved systems.
It is clear that in order to
search for transition objects around T Tauri stars, high spatial resolution observations that
resolve the individual components in these young multiple systems are required.
In this study, we have targeted 65 binaries in the nearby star forming regions of Tau-
rus, Ophiuchus and Corona Australis in order to resolve the mid-infrared emission for each
individual component and search for the presence of transition objects. A comparison of
disk properties between stars in binary systems and a sample of single stars taken from the
literature allows us to distinguish between several possible effects, such as mass, and the
presence of a companion. The sample of T Tauri binary stars is presented in §2 and the
observations and data reduction are discussed in §3. The observed distribution of T Tauri
– 4 –
stars in the K − L vs. K − N color plane is discussed in §4; we have discovered a sample of T
Tauri stars that have mid-infrared evidence for disks but that do not appear to be actively
accreting. These results are discussed in §5 in light of disk evolution models.
2. The Sample
(1993), Leinert et al.
(1993), Simon et al.
A sample of T Tauri binary stars was compiled from Reipurth & Zinnecker
(1993),
(1995), Ghez, White & Simon
Ghez et al.
(1997) and Walter et al.
(1988). All objects in the sample are observable from the Keck
telescopes (δ > −40◦), have 2MASS colors consistent with a reddened T Tauri star (see
Appendix A), and have separations between 0.′′2 and 8′′ (28–1120 AU). The lower separation
bound is set by the diffraction limit at 10 µm and the upper bound by the largest separation
detectable in all observations assuming that the primary is centered on the arrays. The
sample is composed of binaries located within 140 pc, in the Taurus (d=140 pc; Elias 1978),
Ophiuchus (d=140 pc; de Geus & Burton 1991), and Corona Australis (d=130 pc; Marraco
& Rydgren 1981) star forming regions. Of the 70 possible targets, 65 were observed in this
study and are listed in Table 1 by star forming region and in order of increasing separation.
LkHa 332/G1, LkHa 332/G2, HBC 412, HBC 360 and NTTS 160946-1851 were not observed
because of insufficient time. The distribution of binary separations has a median value of
0.′′75. As a result, half of the sample stars have separations smaller than the canonical disk
size (100 AU, e.g., Shu et al.
1987), and all have separations larger than the dominant
emission region of the disk at wavelengths shorter than 10 µm (< 1 AU).
The majority (66%) of the observed systems have spatially resolved spectroscopic mea-
surements available in the literature (see Table 4), with spectral types ranging from G2.5 –
M7.5, and have a median type of M2.5. For these systems we define the primary star to be
the one with the earliest spectral type, i.e., highest mass. For the stars that lack spectral
type information, the component that is brightest at K-band is assumed to be the primary.
Many of these systems also have spectroscopic measurements of Hα (6563A) or Br γ
(2.166 µm) line emission for each individual component in the binary, allowing us to deter-
mine the accretion status of each star. Historically, Hα equivalent widths have been used
to determine the presence of accretion. For the stars that have resolved Hα measurements,
we employ the Mart´in (1998) Hα equivalent width limits, which take into account the spec-
tral type dependence of intrinsic chromospheric Hα emission to determine whether a star is
accreting or not. For K spectral types and earlier, if the EW of Hα is more than 5A then
the system is accreting material. For M0-M2 spectral types, the limit is 10A, and for M3
spectral types and later, it is 20A. The use of Br γ emission lines as an accretion diagnostic
– 5 –
is more recent (e.g., Prato & Simon 1997; Muzerolle et al.
1998). It is likely that some
chromospheric contamination occurs, but how much has not been determined. If there are
no resolved Hα measurements but resolved Br γ measurements are available, the presence
(EW (Br γ ) > 0) or absence of a Br γ line is used to define the accretion status, indepen-
dent of spectral type. For the stars in the sample with a measured accretion status, 78%
of them have been defined through Hα line emission. Altogether, of the sample with line
emission measurements, 64% are actively accreting (CTTS) while 36% are not (WTTS), or
are accreting at too low a level to be detectable.
Near-infrared K[2.2 µm] and L[3.5 µm] band photometry for each component in the
binary system are available in the literature for 48 of the binary stars in the sample (White
& Ghez 2001; Prato, Greene & Simon 2003; Woitas, Leinert & Kohler 2001, and references
therein). In contrast, only 11 of these systems have been previously resolved at 10 µm (Ghez
et al.
2004; McCabe, Duchene &
Ghez 2003).
1991, 1994b; Stanke & Zinnecker 2000; Girart et al.
3. Observations and Data Reduction
We obtained 10 µm images of all of the 65 systems in Table 1, and 18 µm data of 26 of
them, at the W.M. Keck Telescopes. Complementary near-infrared observations (2–4 µm) of
25 systems not previously resolved in the 3-4 µm region, and of 21 additional systems in the
target sample, were made at the NASA IRTF. The goal was to obtain near-simultaneous K-
and L-band observations of each star when possible. Combined with information available
in the literature (see §1), 57 of the 65 stars in the sample have resolved photometry in the
2–4 µm window. Here we describe the observations and method of data reduction for each
dataset. A log of all observations made can be found in Table 2, which lists the telescope,
camera, and filters used for each observing run.
3.1. Mid-Infrared
3.1.1. Observations
High angular resolution mid-infrared observations were made at the Keck 10-m tele-
scopes using two instruments, OSCIR, a visiting mid-infrared (8–25 µm) camera (Telesco et
al. 2000), and the Long Wavelength Spectrometer (LWS; Jones & Puetter 1993), the fa-
cility mid-infrared imaging spectrograph. With OSCIR, which has a 128x128 Si:As blocked
impurity band (BIB) array with a plate scale of 0.062 ± 0.001 arcsec pix−1, an orientation
– 6 –
of 0.◦05 ± 0.◦38, and a corresponding field of view of 7.9′′ × 7.9′′, the stars were imaged using
the N-band (λ=10.8 µm, ∆λ = 5.15 µm) and IHW18 (λ=18.1 µm, ∆λ=1.6 µm) filters. With
LWS, a 128x128 Si:As array with a platescale of 0.081 ± 0.002 arcsec pix−1 and orientation
of −3.◦6 ± 1◦ (McCabe et al. 2003), wide band-pass imaging was not possible. Observa-
tions were therefore made using the narrow-band filters OCLI-O (λ=8.8 µm, ∆λ=0.85 µm),
OCLI-S (λ=12.5 µm, ∆λ=1.2 µm), and the SiC filter (11.8 µm, ∆λ=2.3 µm) when it became
available. LWS provides a 10.′′24 square field of view. The plate scale and orientation of both
cameras were calibrated using observations of wide (>2′′) binary systems.
Both instruments were used in chop-nod mode, switching between on-source and sky
frames at an average rate of 4.5 Hz. The chopper amplitude was set to 8–10′′ such that the
off-source beam lay outside the field of view of the array. The average on-source integration
time was 2–3 min and, for all observing runs, observations of target stars were interleaved
with observations of photometric standards, which are listed in Table 5.
3.1.2. Data Reduction
Observations in the mid-infrared are background dominated, with contributions from
both thermal emission from the sky, and the telescope and dome structure. Accurate back-
ground subtraction is therefore critical and was achieved through double differencing chop
pairs at the two nod positions. This double difference was repeated for each chop-nod dataset
taken and the results coadded. Most of the binary stars observed had at least one compo-
nent bright enough to be detected in the double difference image. For these datasets, the
background subtracted nodsets were shifted and averaged using the centroid on the detected
point source. For the fainter systems which were not detected in a single nodset, no relative
position shifting between each of the chop-nod sets was done.
In general, the difference
between the final FWHM for the shifted and non-shifted frames is small; this is consistent
with the small centroid shifts detected for the majority (87%) of stars observed which show
rms shifts of 0.′′02 (<0.3 pixel). A small constant background offset was usually present in
the averaged images. The median background was measured in a large annulus around the
primary star (typically 4.′′8 in radius, but dependent on the binary separation), and sub-
tracted from the image. The inner radius of the annulus was checked against the encircled
flux of the star to ensure that the annuli chosen were not contaminated by stellar flux.
– 7 –
3.1.3. Astrometric and Photometric Analysis
The astrometric and photometric properties of each star in the binary system were
found through fitting observed point spread functions (PSFs) to the data, a method based
on that used by McCabe, Duchene & Ghez (2002). We employed a two-step approach.
First, aperture photometry was done by placing a circular aperture on the centroid1 of
each star observed, providing initial estimates for the stellar position and flux ratio. These
were then used to create a model image of the observations, using both a model Gaussian
PSF of variable FWHM and a library of observed single star PSF's from the same night as
the target. This 3n parameter model for n stellar components (x and y stellar positions,
relative scale of star to model PSF) was then fitted to the data using Amoeba, a downhill
simplex technique (Press et al.
1993). The fitting criteria, the minimization of the sum
of the residuals Σ(data − model)2, was calculated within a 20 pixel radius circular aperture
around each component. Given that the data are background limited, with the noise level
being approximately the same for all pixels, this was equivalent to minimizing χ2. The flux
of each stellar component was then measured using a 20 pixel aperture on the individual
best-fit component model, and compared to the flux from a photometric standard. The
relative fluxes are both aperture and airmass corrected. This method provides photometry
relative to the observed standards; the absolute calibration of the photometric standards
used is described in Appendix B. The results presented in Table 3 are from the PSF fit
that provided the smallest subtraction residuals; the measurement uncertainties for each
parameter were estimated from the standard deviation of the fits from each PSF used. For
systems in which two stars were detected, the separation, position angle and flux ratio of
the binary are reported in Table 3. The corresponding uncertainties were derived from the
measurement uncertainties combined with the uncertainties in the plate scale and orientation
of the camera. If the night was photometric, the photometry of each component also appears
in Table 3, along with the total combined photometry.
In a number of cases, only one star in the binary system was detected. If that source
was unresolved, a model of a single PSF star was fitted to find the best matching parameters.
Determining which component is emitting depends primarily on the separation of the binary
and whether observations resolve the binary at other wavelengths on the same night. For
example, consecutive images at 10 µm and 18 µm , where both components are seen at 10 µm ,
will clarify the source of an 18 µm detection of a single component.
If the source of the
emission cannot be distinguished as either the primary or secondary, the magnitude appears
1On wide binaries, the centroid was calculated for both stars. For close binaries with large flux ratios,
the centroid was calculated for the primary, whereas for the secondary the position of peak flux was used.
– 8 –
in column 9 of Table 3 and starred to indicate that the primary/secondary designation is
lacking. If the source is extended, PSF fitting was done assuming a binary is present. If the
system contains blended point sources that were not accurately fitted through PSF-fitting,
aperture photometry of the total (unresolved) system is provided. This occurred in only 1
case (LkCa 3), for which resolved observations were available in another 10 µm filter.
3.1.4. Filter Comparison
Because of the changing availability of mid-infrared instrumentation and their associated
filters at the Keck telescope during our observing runs, four filters were used to probe these
systems in the 10 µm region, each with slightly different central wavelengths and bandpasses.
The majority (89%) of the systems were observed using either the wide N-band (∆λ ∼5 µm)
or SiC filters (∆λ = 2.3 µm), which are centered on the amorphous Si emission feature. In
contrast, 11% of the systems were observed using the narrow band 8.8 and 12.5 µm filters
(∆λ ∼1 µm), which are centered on the edge of the silicate feature. Since the Si feature
varies in strength from object to object and in time (e.g., Hanner, Brooke & Tokunaga
1998; Natta, Meyer & Beckwith 2000; Przygodda et al. 2003) it is necessary to check that
no large, systematic bias was introduced by using the slightly different 8.8 µm, 12.5 µm, SiC
and N-band filters.
To do this, we used the spectra of 16 typical T Tauri stars presented in Przygodda et
al.
(2003). Our method for the absolute calibration of the filters (see Appendix B) was
applied, using the relative flux spectra of Przygodda et al. (2003). We linearly interpolated
over the ∼0.7 µm gap in the spectra at ∼9.3 µm. The relative integrated fluxes were then
measured for each of these spectra, through each of the filters used. We found that the
SiC filter magnitudes are, on average, 0.02 mag different from N-band photometry, and at
most 0.1 magnitude different. The 8.8 µm filter is on average 0.1 mag different from N-band
magnitudes, but can be as much as 0.5 mag different. On the other hand, the 12.5 µm filter
is on average 0.3 mag different, and as much as 0.5 mag different; this filter is therefore
not used in quantifying colors. Most of these discrepancies are on the order of the average
measurement uncertainties in the dataset (0.11 mag for N-band, 0.12 mag for SiC band
and 0.1 mag for 8.8 µm data). We define the index [N] as the estimate of the 10 µm flux
provided by the measured SiC, N-band and 8.8 µm fluxes, in this order of preference in the
case of multiple measurements (where the order of preference is of most used filter to least
used filter). In the rest of the paper, we directly compare stars measured in these different
filters.
– 9 –
3.2. Near-Infrared
3.2.1. Observations
K-band (λ=2.21 µm, ∆λ=0.39 µm) and L-band (λ=3.5 micron, ∆λ=0.61 µm) observa-
tions were made at the NASA IRTF 3 m telescope, using NSFCAM (Rayner et al. 1993;
Shure et al.
1994), the facility 256×256 In:Sb near-infrared camera, on 2001 May 26–28
and 2001 Nov 28–Dec 1 (UT). Two observing modes were used depending on the required
angular resolution. For binaries with separations greater than 1′′, we used NSFCAM in
direct-imaging mode, with a plate scale of 0.′′150 ± 0.006/pix, an orientation of 0.◦5 ± 1.◦2,
and a field of view of 37.′′9×37.′′9. The targets were imaged in a box-4 dither pattern with
a ∼19′′ dither size. This pattern was repeated 2-4 times depending on the brightness of
the stars, with exposure times varying from 0.5 – 20 seconds per dither position. For bina-
ries with separations less than 1′′, speckle imaging observations were obtained with a plate
scale of 0.′′053 ± 0.′′001 per pixel (White & Ghez 2001), with NSFCAM running in movieburst
mode, allowing a limited amount of data to be obtained at a high duty cycle with an integra-
tion time of 0.1 seconds. Three to four stacks of 400 such images were taken on each object,
interleaved with similar observations of known single stars and blank sky for calibration.
Photometric standards were observed in both filters throughout each night.
3.2.2. Data Reduction
Each direct imaging dither pattern was reduced in the following manner: two dither
positions, with the star placed in diametrically opposite corners, were subtracted from each
other, removing the sky background and dark current components. This difference image
was then corrected for different pixel gains using a flat field and corrected for bad pixels.
The subtracted pairs for each star were then registered and added together, providing two
final, averaged, images, one with a positive image of the binary and one with a negative
image. Photometry was done on both the positive and negative image with the same PSF
fitting method used for the mid-infrared observations (see §3.1.3 for details). The resulting
photometry is the average of the two, with the uncertainty estimated from the range in the
measurements.
For the speckle observations, each data cube of 400 images was reduced; sky and dark
current levels were subtracted and the images were flat-fielded and bad pixel corrected. A
power spectrum of each image was created and divided by the power spectrum of a star that
is known to be single and point-like. The fringe pattern in the power spectrum is a function
of the binary star separation, position angle (PA) and flux ratio. A 2D model was fitted
– 10 –
to the fringe pattern to measure these parameters (see Ghez et al. 1995, for details). To
resolve the 180◦ ambiguity on the PA, and to obtain photometry of the combined system,
the speckle stacks were also shifted and added (Ghez et al. 1998), yielding an average image
of the binary system. The photometric results presented in §4 combine the measured flux
ratio of the two components (from the power spectra analysis) with the photometry of the
combined system to get magnitudes and fluxes for each individual component. The binary
parameters (separation, flux ratio, PA) are from the power spectra analysis of the final,
averaged, images. In all cases, quoted uncertainties are derived from the standard deviation
of results from the individual stacks, combined with the uncertainties in plate scale and
orientation of the camera.
4. Results
Measurements that produce flux ratios and/or absolute photometric results are pre-
sented in Table 3.
In general, objects with [N] band flux densities greater than 10 mJy
and 18 µm fluxes greater than 30 mJy are clearly detected. We therefore took these values
as upper limits in cases where no source was detected. Absolute photometry was obtained
from our observations for 75, 93, 89, and 24 individual components at K, L, [N] and 18 µm ,
respectively. Relative flux measurements for systems observed during non-photometric con-
ditions were made for 1, 4, and 3 systems at L, [N] and 18 µm respectively. There are nine
systems2 in which no stars were detected in the 8–13 µm window, and six3 in which nothing
was detected at 18 µm. No new components were identified in the mid-infrared that were
not already identified at some other wavelength. Approximately 25% of the binary systems
have inverted flux ratios at wavelengths longer than 2 µm; the brightest component at 2 µm
is not necessarily the brightest at either 3.5 µm or 10 µm , highlighting the potential pit-
falls in assigning long wavelength, low spatial resolution measurements to the component
that dominates at shorter wavelengths. These results increase the number of systems with
spatially resolved measurements at 10 µm by a factor of ∼ 5.
We construct a final sample of 71 components in 35 systems that have high spatial
resolution K, L and [N] band measurements; these are listed in Table 4. All but 4 of these 35
systems also have spatially resolved spectroscopic information, providing spectral type and
accretion diagnostics for each stellar component. Measurements used in this final sample are
first taken from our results and then supplemented with other work. Specifically, we have
2HBC 351, HBC 358, HBC 356, HBC 355, SR 12, ROXs 31, WSB 3, ROX 43, HBC 679.
3LkCa 3, FV Tau/c, WSB 11, WSB 26, ROX 15, DOAR 26.
– 11 –
added 2 measurements from the literature at mid-infrared wavelengths (DoAr 24E and HK
Tau, from Stanke & Zinnecker 2000; McCabe, Duchene & Ghez 2003), and approximately
half of the measurements at near-infrared wavelengths (see Table 4 for references).
For our final sample, dereddened K − L vs. K − [N] and K − [N] vs. [N] − 18 colors are
presented in Figure 1, with the symbol type representing whether or not the star is actively
accreting. The de-reddened colors for each component are also listed in Table 4, along with
the visual extinction for the system (inferred using a method detailed in Appendix A), the
spectral type when known, the spectroscopic accretion measure used (i.e., Hα or Br γ )
and the equivalent width (EW) of Hα emission when applicable. In both the K − [N] and
[N] − 18 color indices the stars are well separated into the three groups originally identified
by Lada (1987), corresponding to photospheric emission (Class III), disk emission (Class
II), and embedded protostellar emission (Class I). Here we adopt the following mid-infrared
color limits to delineate these groups:
Class I : K − [N] > 4.5
Class II : 1.75 < K − [N] < 4.5
Class III : K − [N] < 1
These correspond to the Wilking et al. (2001) spectral index limits, with three modifiations:
we include the flat spectrum class defined by Wilking et al.
in our class I definition, we
use a class II lower limit of K − [N] = 1.75 rather than K − [N] =2, and we adopt a class
III cutoff that is intermediate between that suggested by Wilking et al. (K − N = 2) and
Kenyon & Hartmann (1995; K − [N] ∼0.5). The class III color limit therefore incorporates
the photospheric contribution from even the lowest mass star in our sample.
Within our sample, we have detected 3 class I sources, 58 class II sources and 10 class
III sources. Since our sample was selected for T Tauri stars, we did not expect to detect
many class I stars. All three class I stars (T Tau B, FV Tau/c B and DoAr 24E B) are
secondaries to class II primaries and are previously identified infrared companions (IRCs)
or high accretion stars (Koresko, Herbst & Leinert 1997; White & Ghez 2001). At 18 µm
we have detected 2 class I sources, 19 class II sources and 2 class III sources. We lack the
sensitivity at this wavelength to detect the majority of the WTTS in our dataset.
While the distinction between class II and class III stars remains clear in the K −
[N] index in Figure 1, the K − L index shows some overlap. Using the Kenyon & Hartmann
(1995) cutoffs, we would expect class III stars, with only photospheric emission, to have
K − L .0.4 and the boundary between class II and class I to be at K − L ∼ 1.5. However,
several class II objects, with clear K − [N] excesses, have K − L colors consistent with class
– 12 –
III objects. One possibility is that this subset of our sample has disks with inner holes in
their dust distributions.
The possibility of inner disk holes becomes even more intriguing when the accretion
diagnotistics are considered. Of the 58 class II stars, 52 have accretion information. While
the majority of stars with IR excess (class II) are also accreting (CTT), we find that 11% of
the observed class II stars with accretion diagnostics do not appear to be currently accreting.
We define these objects to be passive disks; the star is surrounded by significant amounts of
dust, most likely in the form of a disk, but material does not appear to be actively accreting
onto the photosphere. These objects are highlighted in Table 4 with "passive" in the notes
column and are discussed in more detail in Appendix D. The majority (66%) of the non-
accreting, passive disks also have K − L colors that suggest the presence of an inner disk
hole. A K-S test comparing the distribution of colors between the passive disks and class
II-CTTS sample show that there is only a 0.9% probability (a 2.6 σ result) that they are
sampling the same distribution in K − L . On the other hand, there is no large difference
in the distributions of K − [N] between class II-CTTS and the passive disks (8%, or 1.8 σ ).
The passive disks appear to be associated with the inner disk hole population.
There is a tendency (5/6) for the passive disks to reside in mixed systems4, where a
WTTS is paired with a CTTS. There is also a tendency for the passive disk to be present
around the secondary, the lowest mass component in the binary system. Only one passive
disk is found around a primary and that is FV Tau/c A. The stellar companions to the
passive disk objects appear to be normal CTTS or WTTS based on their K − L and K −
[N] color indices. Because the sample of passive disks is small, neither tendency is statistically
significant.
The passive disks are in binary systems that span almost the entire range of separations
in the sample, from 0.′′3 to 5′′. The presence of a companion star in the range of binary
separations probed here does not appear to affect whether a disk is passive or not. Indeed,
the presence of a passive disk does not appear to be restricted to stars in binary systems.
A comparison sample of known single T Tauri stars with near-infrared and mid-infrared
colors available in the literature is shown in Figure 2 (see Appendix C for sample details).
We now know less about the mid-infrared properties of single T Tauri stars than we do
about those in multiple systems; we therefore have a limited sample size for this comparison
and the majority of the single star mid-infrared colors are based on low spatial resolution
IRAS measurements. With these caveats in mind, we find a similar fraction of passive disks
systems (1/20, or 5%) around single stars. Whatever phenomenon is responsible for the
4One passive disk, WSB 28, is in a WTTS-WTTS pair
– 13 –
passive disks, it does not appear to be related to the presence of a wide separation (>30 AU)
stellar companion.
A closer examination of the stellar properties of the passive disk systems in our binary
sample reveals that this phenomenon appears to be restricted to stars with spectral types
of M2.5 and later. Dividing the class II stars into two roughly equal subsets based on
whether the spectral type is earlier or later than M2.5, we find 0 out of 28 passive disks in
the early spectral type set, and 6 out of 22 in the late spectral type set. The distribution
of spectral types for the sample of normal class II-CTTS stars is compared to those of
passive disks in Figure 3, which combines both the single star sample and binary star sample
together. In this combined sample we find 0/26 passive disks for objects with spectral types
earlier than M0, and 7/46 (15%) for objects with a spectral type of M0 or later. A K-
S test on the two spectral type distributions shown in Figure 3 finds a 0.9% probability
that these samples are drawn from the same parent distribution. Since later type stars
are more chromospherically active, the Hα threshold increases with spectral type. Our
correction for this employs a coarse threshold approximation for an inherently continuous
distribution of upper limit chromospheric Hα equivalent widths as a function of spectral type
(see § 2), raising the possibility that the non-accretion status of these passive disks may be
mis-classified. We have checked the passive disks which have Hα measurements to see how
close to the limit the Hα level is. Although FQ Tau B is a borderline CTTS/WTTS case,
LkHa 332 B, FV Tau/c A and FX Tau B are unambiguous. These results suggest that the
presence of a passive disk with an inner disk hole appears to be dependent on the spectral
type, and hence mass, of the central star.
5. Discussion
Approximately 10% of all class II T Tauri stars, with significant evidence for a circum-
stellar disk at 10 µm, do not appear to be currently accreting. Previous work has shown
that the accretion flow in T Tauri stars is quite variable (e.g., Smith et al. 1999; Alencar,
Johns-Krull & Basri 2001; Alencar & Batalha 2002; Littlefair et al. 2004), suggesting that
a mis-identification of WTT/CTT status can occasionally occur. If what we are observing
is entirely the result of a stochastic accretion process, then the sample of observed passive
disk stars suggests that, on average, class II stars spend approximately 10% of their CTT
lifetime in a non-accreting state. As we point out in Appendix D, a couple of the candidate
passive disk objects may in fact be undergoing stochastic accretion. However, a variable
accretion flow cannot account for the observed link between a non-accreting disk and the
presence of an inner disk hole, or the observed spectral type/mass dependence. In the fol-
– 14 –
lowing subsections we explore two mechanisms that can reproduce the observed inner disk
hole in the passive disk systems: (a) the presence of a nearby, as yet unresolved companion
(either stellar or substellar/planetary in mass, § 5.1), or (b) disk evolution (§ 5.2).
5.1. Evidence for unresolved companions?
In principle, the presence of a nearby companion could reproduce the observed inner
disk hole and, potentially, the lack of significant accretion through star-disk or planet-disk
interactions. Such companions could not have been imaged around the passive disk systems
in our sample as they would have been too close to resolve, and radial velocity monitoring
of these objects has, to the best of our knowledge, not been done. In systems with a stellar
companion (with mass ratios . 10), resonances between the orbit of the star (with semi-
major axis a) and that of the dust in the disk will dynamically clear out material up to 2-3a,
depending on the eccentricity of the orbit (Artymowicz & Lubow 1994). For planetary
mass companions it is generally assumed that the disk clearing occurs essentially at the
apoapstron of the planets orbit (e.g., Quillen et al. 2004). Because the near-infrared and
mid-infrared excesses arise from the inner few AU of the disk, only systems with companions
at separations on order of 1 AU could lead to the absence of such excesses. Consistent with
these predictions, observed spectroscopic binaries with separations less than ∼0.3 AU, do not
show the characteristics of the passive disk systems; they have K − L excesses and accretion
can still occur across the disk gap (e.g., DQ Tau, Mathieu et al. 1997; AK Sco, Alencar et al.
2003; and NTTS 162814-2427, Jensen & Mathieu 1997), whereas there are two systems with
either known or putative companions at separations on the order of a few AU that would
be classified by us as passive disks; HD 98800 B (K5 combined spectral type), which has a
known stellar companion at an apoapstron distance of 1.6 AU (e.g., Koerner et al.
2000;
Prato et al. 2001), and CoKu Tau 4 (an M1.5 star), whose SED has been modelled assuming
an undetected companion with M > 0.1 MJ at 10 AU (Quillen et al. 2004; D'Alessio et al.
2004). Thus, companions with separations on order of 1 AU are capable of mimicking the
color and accretion properties of the passive disk systems.
While a stellar or substellar companion a few AU from the star could be responsible for
the observed lack of accretion and presence of an inner disk hole, companions are unlikely
to be the explanation for all the observed passive disks. The period distribution for stellar
companions to M type dwarfs (for separations . 10 AU) is very similar to that around G
and K type dwarfs, with approximately 10% of the stars having a companion in the 0.3
– 3 AU separation range (Duquennoy & Mayor 1991; Marchal, Delfosse, Forveille et al.
2003). If all the passive disks were caused by a stellar companion in this separation range,
– 15 –
we would be equally likely to find passive disks around K type stars as M type stars in our
sample, which is not the case. The observed mass dependence also suggests that substellar
or planetary companions are not the probable cause. As Butler et al. (2004) show, planets
with separations .1 AU are ∼5 times less likely to occur around M type stars than around
G or K type stars. Therefore the fact that all the passive disks occur solely around M type
T Tauri stars makes the presence of a companion, either stellar or substellar, an unlikely
explanation for the group as a whole.
5.2. Evidence for 'inside out' disk evolution
The transition from the class II to the class III stage has been the focus of a number
of recent theoretical investigations. Different physical processes that could be responsible
for disk evolution will produce different signatures in the color plane as a function of time.
There are 3 classes of models that we will investigate here. The first is the homologous disk
evolution of Wood et al. (2002), in which the disk structure remains constant and the only
property that evolves is the disk mass. The second is the magnetospheric disk accretion
models, which investigate the viscous evolution of disks in the presence of magnetospheric
interactions between a disk and a star (e.g., Kenyon, Yi & Hartmann 1996; Armitage,
Clarke & Tout 1999). Finally, there are models in which the disk evolution is driven by
the competing effects of the ionizing flux from the central star, which creates a disk wind,
and by the viscosity (Hollenbach et al. 1994; Clarke, Gendrin & Sotomayor 2001). In this
section we will use the observed properties of the passive disk systems to constrain which
model (and associated physical processes) is most likely responsible for disk evolution. The
observed passive disk properties we will use are (a) the evidence for an inner disk hole, as
determined through photospheric K − L colors and optically thick, disk-like K − N colors,
(b) the fact that these systems only occur around M type stars, and (c) the observed fraction
of such systems: 10% of the entire class II sample (including both singles and binaries), or,
more accurately, 0% for K type class II stars and 15% for M type class II stars.
Wood et al.
(2002) model the near- and mid-infrared colors of a typical T Tauri disk
under the assumption that the disk evolves through a reduction in the disk mass while
maintaining a constant disk structure. They find that the observed spread of K − L and
K − N colors can, in general, be reproduced by disks of different masses observed at varying
disk inclinations. However, Wood et al. point out that the constant disk structure in this
model assumes that disks with inner holes will not develop as the disks evolve. With ∼10%
of our class II stars showing evidence for an inner disk hole, we can reject this model.
Models that investigate the viscous evolution of magnetospheric T Tauri disks (e.g.,
– 16 –
Kenyon, Yi & Hartmann 1996; Armitage, Clarke & Tout 1999) find that disks evolve in
an inside-out manner. The radius of the inner edge of a magnetically truncated disk is
determined by the balance between the magnetic torques and viscous torques in the disk.
As the system ages and the mass accretion rate drops, the radius at which this balance
occurs increases, hence, an inner disk hole forms and evolves with the mass accretion rate
and magnetic field strength. The disks are predicted to evolve in the K − L vs K − N color
plane through a phase with photospheric K − L and disk-like K − N colors, suggesting that
the passive disk systems could represent a population that is in the process of dispersing
their inner disk material. Hartmann (1998) shows that the size of the inner disk hole is
dependent on a number of parameters (such as stellar radius, accretion rate and magnetic
field strength), most of which are themselves dependent on the stellar mass. Because of the
complexity in the interplay between the parameters, the exact dependence remains unknown,
however, and so the presence of a spectral type dependence in the observations, while not
inconsistent with this model, cannot currently constrain it. The model does fail, however,
to accurately predict the observed fraction of such systems in the sample as a whole. In
this model, disk evolution is driven by the decline in accretion rate over time and occurs
on the viscous timescale of the entire disk (which scales with the outer radius of the disk
and viscosity parameter as R2
outer/ν).Calculations of the observed disk colors as a function
of time predict that roughly 50% of all class II stars should be detected with photospheric
K − L colors and K − N > 2, a factor of 5 too large compared to our observations.
Clarke, Gendrin & Sotomayor
(2001) investigate disk evolution with the inclusion of
disk photoevaporation. An ionizing flux from the central star creates a disk wind that is
launched beyond some critical radius, Rg = GM∗/c2
s. As the mass accretion rate declines
with time, there comes a point when the mass loss in the disk wind at Rg exceeds the
mass accretion into the disk region inside that radius. The lack of replenishment in the
inner disk region causes it to evolve on its own short viscous timescale, producing a rapid
removal of material (Clarke, Gendrin & Sotomayor 2001; Armitage, Clarke & Palla 2003).
This provides the potential for a rapid transition in disk evolution, with the inner disk
region clearing out on a timescale on the order of 105 yrs for a 1M⊙ T Tauri star. The
removal of material at radii smaller than Rg after the mass accretion rate has declined yields
photospheric colors at wavelengths shorter than some critical value and optically thick colors
at longer wavelengths, with the critical wavelength depending only on the size of the inner
disk hole.
(2001) the photoionizing photons from the central star were
assumed to have a constant flux over time. They state that the source of ionizing photons
cannot be predominantly powered by the accretion flow because as the accretion rate drops
over time, this process will essentially become ineffective. Indeed, Matsuyama, Johnstone &
Hartmann (2003) show that if the source of ionizing flux is from the accretion shock, with the
In Clarke et al.
– 17 –
flux declining over time, a disk gap around Rg forms but the inner disk does not clear out any
faster than the outer disk. More recently, Alexander, Clarke & Pringle (2004a,b, 2005) have
explored alternative, constant, sources of ultraviolet (UV) photons and have concluded that
chromospheric far-UV photons in T Tauri stars potentially can provide a high enough flux,
causing the inner disk to rapidly clear once the accretion rate drops. Within this scenario,
our sample of passive disks can be interpreted as objects that have already undergone inner
disk clearing. The observed fraction of passive disks around M type stars (15%) suggests
that this phase of disk evolution, with a cleared inner disk region, lasts for several times 105
yrs. This model also predicts a strong dependence on the mass of the central star as the
disk radius at which a disk wind can be launched scales linearly with the stellar mass. The
Clarke, Gendrin & Sotomayor (2001) model predicts that while a 1.5 M⊙ star will have an
inner disk hole out to 10 AU, a 0.25 M⊙ star will have an inner disk hole that extends out
to only 1–2 AU. Consequently, the reason we detect passive disks solely around M type stars
is purely a selection effect: because our survey covers only the 2–10 µm region, we can only
detect disk holes up to ∼3 AU in size. We would detect a 1.5 M⊙ star with a larger disk
hole as a class III, disk-less, object. In this framework, we therefore predict that Spitzer
observations across the 3 – 160 micron region will identify a number of systems with 5–15
AU inner disk holes around G and K T Tauri stars, and that the size of the inner hole will
scale linearly with the stellar mass. Furthermore, a direct consequence of the linear relation
between stellar mass and inner hole size is that the timescale required for the inner disk
region to clear is also dependent on the stellar mass. This is because the inner disk clears
on its own viscous timescale, which scales as R2
g/ν. We therefore predict a higher likelihood
of detecting objects in the process of clearing their inner disk around higher mass T Tauri
stars, a prediction that can be tested with Spitzer.
To summarize, the homologous disk evolution of Wood et al. (2002) can be discounted
by the detection of the passive disk systems with inner disk holes and models of magneto-
spheric disk evolution that evolve on a purely viscous timescale cannot recreate the small
fraction of observed passive disks. However, models that incorporate the effects of both vis-
cous evolution and disk photoevaporation can recreate all the observed properties of these
systems.
While the disk photoevaporation evolution models seem to be successful at describing
the evolution of the inner edge of the disk, the evolution of disk material further out is still not
well understood. Beyond the disk wind launch radius, disk material remains and continues
evolving on a viscous timescale (Clarke, Gendrin & Sotomayor 2001). In star forming regions
where external photoionization does not cause the disk to evolve in an outside-in manner, the
models predict a remaining outer disk annulus of gas and dust. However, millimeter surveys
of T Tauri stars find that only ∼10% of all WTTS have associated millimeter continuum
– 18 –
emission (e.g., Duvert et al. 2000; Osterloh & Beckwith 1995). The disk evolution timescale
therefore does not seem to have a strong radial function. Recent work by Takeuchi, Clarke
& Lin (2005), suggests that the solution may be the differential radial motion of dust grains
and gas particles in circumstellar disks; for T Tauri disks with 1 mm grain sizes, the dust
particles should migrate inward on a timescale an order of magnitude faster than the gas;
by the time the disk has started the inside-out evolution process, the outer disk is already
depleted of dust grains, leaving a gas-rich disk behind. It is clear that investigating the outer
disk structure of candidate passive disks, both in dust and gas emission, will help explore
this idea further. Our 18 µm data does not have the sensitivity to investigate this question;
of the 4 candidate passive disks observed at 18 µm in our sample, only 1 system was wide
enough and bright enough to provide resolved photometry for each component. For FX Tau
B, the passive dust disk does seem to extend out to further radii. Future deep mid-infrared
images of these systems will be able to pinpoint the radial distribution of small dust grains.
6. Summary
Mid-infrared and near-infrared observations of a sample of 65 binary systems are pre-
sented, increasing the number of T Tauri binary systems with resolved 10 µm data by a
factor of 5. We have discovered a sample of class II stars, with clear evidence for opti-
cally thick disk emission in the mid-infrared, that do not appear to be currently accreting.
The majority of these passive disks have an inner disk hole, determined through the lack
of near-infrared excess, and all of them occur only around the lowest mass stars (M type)
in our sample. These observations are consistent with models that include inside-out disk
evolution. In particular, the observed frequency and spectral type/mass dependence of the
passive disk systems, in the 2–10 µm region covered in this survey, are supportive of models
that include a photoevaporative disk wind caused by an ionizing flux from the central star.
A strong prediction of the photoevaporation models is that there should be a sample of
systems with larger inner disk holes (5-10 AU) around higher mass stars, with the size of the
disk hole scaling with stellar mass. Such systems would not be detectable in the 2–10 µm
study presented here; a multi-wavelength mid-infrared study of T Tauri stars, which will
be available through Spitzer, will be able to determine whether photoevaporative disk wind
models can adequately describe T Tauri disk evolution over a range of stellar masses.
A portion of this research was done while the author held a National Research Council
– 19 –
Research Associateship Award at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory. We are grateful to Cathie
Clarke for helpful comments, to Robert Pina for his assistance with OSCIR observations,
and to the referee for a careful reading of this work. Some of the data presented herein
were obtained at the W.M. Keck Observatory, which is operated as a scientific partnership
among the California Institute of Technology, the University of California and the National
Aeronautics and Space Administration. The Observatory was made possible by the generous
financial support of the W.M. Keck Foundation. Support for this work was provided by the
NASA Astrobiology Institute and the Packard Foundation. This publication makes use
of data products from the Two Micron All Sky Survey, which is a joint project of the
University of Massachusetts and the Infrared Processing and Analysis Center/California
Institute of Technology, funded by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration and
the National Science Foundation. The authors also wish to recognize and acknowledge the
significant cultural role that the summit of Mauna Kea has always had within the indigenous
Hawaiian community. We are fortunate to have the opportunity to conduct observations from
this mountain.
A. Line of sight extinction
Typically, the line of sight extinction to a star is estimated by measuring the excess
color of the star, in comparison to that expected from the photosphere, in band passes
that are dominated by photospheric emission rather than disk emission. Such a method
is not open to us; we lack spectral types for each individual star in approximately 40% of
the binary systems in our sample. Furthermore, a number of these systems have not been
resolved at optical (R- or I- band) wavelengths where the photosphere dominates the flux
density. Instead, a secondary method of determining extinction was applied. Meyer, Calvet
& Hillenbrand (1997), using the sample of T Tauri stars from Strom et al.
(1989), found
that the classical T Tauri stars (CTTS), de-reddened using Av determined from the R − Ic
excesses, defined a narrow locus in the (J − H)CIT vs. (H − K)CIT color-color plane. We
therefore compared the near-infrared colors of the observed binary systems with the CTTS
locus defined by Meyer et al. (1997) in order to estimate the line of sight extinction.
Using the 2MASS database, J,H,K photometry was obtained for stars in the sample.
For most stars, the 2MASS data does not resolve the binary components and therefore
provides composite fluxes only. The magnitudes obtained from 2MASS were converted into
CIT magnitudes using the filter transformations from Carpenter (2001). Using the equation
in §3.1 of Prato, Greene & Simon (2003), which relates the visual extinction with the
distance between the CTTS locus and the stellar position in the (J − H)CIT vs. (H − K)CIT
– 20 –
color-color diagram, the visual extinction, Av , was calculated for each binary system in our
sample. The Av values calculated using this method are given in Table 4. A few stars did not
have 2MASS photometry and some (18% of sample) had initial positions that were below
the CTTS locus, possibly the result of scattering from circumstellar material or photometric
variability. As the Av values cannot be determined in this case, we have arbitrarily set them
to have Av = 0.0. The observed mid-infrared and near-infrared colors are de-reddened using
the Rieke & Lebofsky (1985) extinction coefficients for the K, L and [N] band fluxes and
using the 18 µm extinction coefficient from Allen's Astrophysical Quantities.
B. Absolute Photometric Calibration
During each night's observations, a number of photometric standards were observed.
While these standards have known flux densities for a number of mid-infrared filters, this
project has used a large number of both wide and narrow band filters that differ slightly from
those in the literature. We have therefore re-calibrated the standards in each of the filters
used. The standards can be split into two groups; 'primary' standards, that have absolutely
calibrated photometry and a template stellar spectra, available through the Cohen-Walker
radiometric network (Cohen et al. 1992, 1995, 1999), and 'secondary' standards that have
their absolute calibration estimated through relative photometry with any primary calibra-
tors observed on the same night.
Absolute calibration of the primary standards was done by taking the published, ab-
solutely calibrated, stellar templates and integrating the stellar spectra (Fλ) through the
filter bandpass (Bλ), the instrument detector QE (DQE), and the atmospheric transmission
(Tatmos):
Ff ilter = R Fλ∗Tatmos∗DQE∗Bλ
Tatmos∗DQE∗Bλ
dλ
DQE and filter transmission curves for the LWS and OSCIR instruments were provided
by R. Campbell and S. Fisher, respectively. The model atmosphere used is the ATRANS
atmospheric transmission model by Lord (1992) and includes 1 mm of precipitable water.
These models are available on the Gemini website.5 Models with precipitable water varying
from 1 to 5 mm were tested. For all bandpasses used in this study, changing the atmospheric
water content changed the total weighted flux by less than 1%, well below the observational
5http://www.gemini.edu/sciops/ObsProcess/obsConstraints/ocTransSpectra.html
– 21 –
uncertainties of the data. The resulting flux densities for these primary photometric calibra-
tors, in Janskys, are reported in Table 5 for each filter used. Using the subset of the observed
standards that also have fluxes estimated by the OSCIR team to compare the measured ze-
ropoints, we find that the flux densities are consistent to within ∼6% and <1%, for the N
band filter and IHW18 filter respectively.
The secondary standards are calibrated through relative photometry to primary stan-
dards that are observed on the same night, under photometric conditions. The observed flux
ratios are converted into fluxes using the primary standard fluxes. The average and stan-
dard deviation of the measured fluxes for the secondary standards are also provided in Table
5. For those standards observed only during non-photometric nights we have adopted the
OSCIR team's photometry, if available. These are indicated by fluxes placed inside square
brackets.
Throughout this paper, we assume α Lyr has 0.00 mag in each bandpass used. While
Vega does have a circumstellar shell, the excess emission from this dust does not occur at
wavelengths shorter than 20 µm (e.g., Cox 2000).
C. Known single T Tauri stars
A comparison sample of T Tauri stars which have been determined to be single has been
compiled from Table 7 from White & Ghez (2001) for Taurus sources and from Barsony
et al.
(2003) for Ophiuchus sources. We only include sources that have their single status
determined using high-resolution observations, including speckle interferometry (Leinert et
al. 1993; Ghez et al. 1993; Ageorges et al. 1997; Barsony et al. 2003) and lunar occultation
and imaging (Simon et al. 1995). A literature search on these known single stars was made
in order to obtain K, L and N band information, as well as accretion information from
either Hα or Br γ line emission. The total sample is comprised of 27 objects that have near-
and mid-infrared disk color indices, an Hα measurement of accretion, and an estimate of
the visual extinction from 2MASS photometry. These are listed in Table 6, along with the
spectral type, estimated visual extinction (see Appendix A for method), observed colors,
and equivalent width of Hα line emission for the star. The reference source for multiplicity
is given in column 9, and the observational method used listed in column 12.
– 22 –
D. The Passive Disk Candidates
In this section we provide a summary of each passive disk candidate presented in this
work, identified through the observed combination of a class II-like K − [N] excess and lack
of accretion. As pointed out in §5, our analysis rests on the statistical nature of this sub-set
as a whole, however, for any one of these objects the observed properties may be caused by
one of the other possibilities we have raised (i.e., varying accretion flow, the presence of a
nearby companion).
WSB 28 – This 5′′ binary system in Ophiuchus is one of the smallest mass ratio systems
(q ∼0.1, according to the Baraffe et al.
1998, 2002, tracks) in our sample. It is also the
only non-mixed binary system that contains a passive disk; both components are WTTS
as indicated by a lack of Br γ emission (Prato, Greene & Simon 2003). No Hα equivalent
widths have been measured for either individual component. Wilking, Schwartz & Blackwell
(1987) do, however, list the primary as having a weak Hα measurement. K-band photometry
of the primary has been obtained on 3 separate occasions, including this work; the object
appears to be photometrically stable (σK = 0.03 mag; standard deviation from 2MASS; Prato
Greene & Simon 2003 and this work). Along with Prato, Greene & Simon (2003), we have
obtained K-band photometry on the secondary; this component also appears stable within
the observational uncertainties. There are a number of line of sight extinction measurements,
obtained using different methods; the CTTS locus method applied here finds an Av of 3.3
mag for the system as a whole, similar to that found by Bontemps et al.
(2001) (Av =4.3
mag). Both combined measurements are intermediate in value between the Av determined for
each individual component, measured by spectral fitting, which finds an Av of 5.1 ± 0.6 mag
and 2.5 ± 1 mag for the primary and secondary, respectively (Prato, Greene & Simon 2003).
De-reddening the observed colors with any of the above Av measurements do not change the
classifications for each object; the primary continues to have no excess in either K − L or
K − [N] whereas the secondary, while lacking a K − L excess, shows K − [N] > 2, indicating
that this object may have an inner disk hole. While the observational uncertainties on the
color of the secondary are fairly large, it would take a 3.4σ change for the object to fall in
the class III region and cease to be regarded as a passive disk.
DOAR 26 – This M4/M6 2.′′2 binary system is a mixed pair: the primary is a CTTS
(EW(Br γ ) = 2.2 A) and the secondary a WTTS (non-detection of Br γ ; Prato, Greene &
Simon 2003). No Hα measurements that resolve both components are available; the Wilking,
Schwartz & Blackwell (1987) Hα survey qualitatively measures an Hα level of 2 (on a scale
of 'weak' to '5') for the combined binary system. A comparison of all resolved ground-based
near-infrared photometry on this binary system finds that the K-band flux of both compo-
nents is stable, with an rms of 0.1 mag for each component (Koresko 2002; Prato, Greene &
– 23 –
Simon 2003, this work). Resolved L-band magnitudes of this system are provided only by
Koresko (2002) and this work. Koresko (2002) finds K − L = 0.7 ± 0.3 for the secondary,
which differs by 2σ from the value we find and is associated with much larger observational
uncertainties. Additional, near-simultaneous, K- and L-band measurements are desirable to
explore how variable this system is. The Av toward the system as a whole, measured using
the CTTS locus method, is 1.64 mag, intermediate between the values measured from spec-
tral fits for the primary and secondary (Av = 3.3 ± 1.2 mag and 1 ± 0.9 mag, respectively;
Prato, Greene & Simon 2003). The de-reddened K − [N] colors of this CTTS-WTTS sys-
tem are class II-like for both objects, the class II classification does not change no matter
which Av measurement listed above is used. The de-reddened K − L colors clearly indicate
an excess for the primary and none for the secondary. While the primary is clearly a class
II-CTTS object, the secondary shows evidence for an inner disk hole and a lack of accretion.
FQ Tau – This system appears to be highly variable. Hartigan & Kenyon (2003) find
that it is an M3/M3.5 0.′′73 binary, with both components showing Hα in emission, with
an equivalent width of 110 ± 5 and 23 ± 4 A for the primary and secondary, respectively.
On the basis of Hα alone, the secondary would be classified as a borderline CTTS/WTTS.
Hartigan & Kenyon (2003), however, also use the lack of [O I] line emission and veiling
in the secondary to classify FQ Tau B as a WTTS, which is the designation we use here.
Photometrically, this system varies considerably, with the brightest component at both K-
and L-band inverting between the results presented in White & Ghez (2001) and those in
Table 3. During 1997, White & Ghez (2001) found the south-western component to be the
brightest at 2.2 µm, with observed (and not de-reddened) near-infrared colors of K − L =
0.43 ± 0.11 mag and K − L =0.37 ± 0.11 mag for the primary and secondary, respectively.
In comparison, during 2001, we found the north-eastern component to be brighter by ∼0.3
mag in the K-band, with observed (not de-reddened) near-infrared colors of K − L = 0.61
± 0.07 mag and K − L = 0.75 ± 0.06 mag for the primary and secondary, respectively. The
Av measurement using the CTTS locus (Av =0.35 mag) is smaller than those measured from
a fit to the optical spectra (Av = 1.95 and 1.8 mag for the primary and secondary respectively;
Hartigan & Kenyon 2003). The de-reddened K − [N] colors are class II for both components,
as are the K − L colors; no evidence for an inner disk hole is found using our more recent K-
and L- band photometry. De-reddening with either set of Av measurements does not change
the classification for either component. We consider this object to be a borderline candidate
passive disk and recommend follow-up observations.
FX Tau – Duchene et al.
(1999) resolved the individual components in this 0.′′85
binary system spectroscopically, finding spectral types of M1 and M4 for the primary and
secondary, respectively, with an uncertainty of 2 subclasses for each designation. They
found an Hα equivalent width of 13 and 1 A for the primary and secondary respectively,
– 24 –
indicating that this is a mixed CTTS-WTTS binary system. The resolved Hα measurements
are consistent with previous Hα measurements on the combined binary system (14.5 A ;
Kenyon et al. 1998); Pa β and Br γ are also seen in emission (Muzerolle et al. 1998; Folha
& Emerson 2001). The resolved K-band photometry used is from White & Ghez (2001),
which provides an average of all resolved magnitudes available in the literature. As such,
the observed K − L color given in Table 3 was not derived from simultaneous measurements.
Our observed L-band magnitudes, 7.6 ± 0.05 mag and 8.65 ± 0.06 mag for primary and
secondary, respectively, agree well with the White & Ghez
(2001) measurements (7.49
± 0.1 and 8.67 ± 0.1 mag, respectively). The line of sight extinction, measured using the
CTTS locus method, has an Av of 2.24 mag, similar to the value (Av = 1.08 mag) measured
from the optical colors given in Kenyon & Hartmann (1995). The de-reddened K − L and
K − [N] colors in Table 4 are clearly class II colors, suggesting that this object maybe in fact
undergoing variable accretion as discussed in §5.
LkHa 332 – The 0.′′34 binary system was spectroscopically resolved by Hartigan &
Kenyon (2003) into a K7/M2.5 pair, with Hα equivalent widths of 10.9 ± 0.6 A and 6.2
± 0.6 A respectively, making it a CTTS-WTTS mixed pair, although the CTTS classifica-
tion for the primary is borderline. This object appears to undergo significant variation in
Hα emission; previous narrow band Hα WFPC2 observations found equivalent widths of
45 A and 17 A for the primary and secondary, respectively, which, again, would classify
it as a CTTS-WTTS pair (White & Ghez 2001). However, classification of this object in
the literature is inconsistent. Both Hartigan & Kenyon (2003) and White & Ghez (2001)
classify this binary system as a CTTS-CTTS. According to Tables 3 and 4 in Hartigan &
Kenyon (2003), veiling is not present at a >2σ level in either component (note that this is
contrary to their Table 7 which states that it is present for the secondary component – we
assume this is a typo). The only emission line evidence for active accretion in the secondary
is the presence of the the 6300 A [0 I] line, which is strangely absent in the CTTS pri-
mary. Further spectroscopic follow up on this close binary system is needed. Using the Hα
measurements, we refer to this as a CTTS-WTTS system. For calculating the near-infrared
color, we have combined the 1997 K-band measurement of this object from Woitas, Leinert
& Kohler (2001) with the L-band average measurement provided by White & Ghez (2001);
we do this rather than use an average K-band measurment to minimize any photometric
variability. This provides an observed K − L color of 1.06 ± 0.1 mag and 0.03 ± 0.14 mag for
the primary and secondary, respectively. The average observed K − L colors from Woitas,
Leinert & Kohler
(2001) for these objects (0.97 ± 0.11 mag and 0.32 ± 0.31 mag respec-
tively) shows that photometric variability is likely present; near-simultaneous K- and L-band
photometry on this system would clearly be useful. The line-of sight extinction estimated
through the CTTS locus method is Av = 3.58 mag, which is approximately 1 mag larger
– 25 –
than the Av found through a fit to the spectroscopic data by Hartigan & Kenyon (Av = 2.8
mag and 2.3 mag for the primary and secondary, respectively). The de-reddened colors find
clear K − [N] excesses in both components, independent of the Av measurement used. The
K − L color of the secondary however shows evidence for an inner disk hole, although the
lack of simultaneous measurements places some uncertainty on this.
FV Tau /c – A 0.′′67 binary system, FV Tau/c has been spectroscopically resolved into
an M2.5/M3.5 pair by Hartigan & Kenyon (2003). The system appears to be a mixed
WTTS-class I pair, which is quite unusual, with the WTTS designation for the primary
coming from Hα equivalent width measurements and the lack of veiling and [O I] emission
(White & Ghez 2001; Hartigan & Kenyon 2003). The secondary has very large and variable
Hα equivalent widths (White & Ghez 2001; Hartigan & Kenyon 2003) and White & Ghez
(2001) classify it as a high accretion star. We combine the 1995 K-band measurement from
Woitas, Leinert & Kohler (2001) with the average L-band photometry from White & Ghez
(2001) in order to minimize the uncertainty from photometric variability; these colors do
not represent near-simultaneous measurements. The Av estimated from the CTTS locus
method is 5.23 mag, a value in between the measured Av from a fit to the optical spectra by
Hartigan & Kenyon (2003), who find Av = 3.25 and 7 mag for the primary and secondary,
respectively. The de-reddened K − [N] colors are class II and class I for the primary and
secondary, respectively, independent of the Av measurement used, whereas the K − L colors
of the primary are below the K − L photospheric cutoff used, suggesting the presence of an
inner disk hole.
– 26 –
REFERENCES
Ageorges, N., Eckart, A., Monin, J.-L., & M´enard, F., 1997, A&A, 326, 632
Alencar, S. H. P., Johns-Krull, C.M., & Basri, G., 2001, AJ, 122, 3335
Alencar, S.H.P.; Batalha, C., 2002, ApJ, 571, 378
Alencar, S.H.P., Melo, C.H.F., Dullemond, C.P., Andersen, J., Batalha, C., Vaz, L.P.R., &
Mathieu, R.D., 2003, A&A, 409, 1037
Alexander, R.D., Clarke, C.J., & Pringle, J.E., 2004, MNRAS, 348, 879
Alexander, R.D., Clarke, C.J., & Pringle, J.E., 2004b, MNRAS, 354, 71
Alexander, R.D., Clarke, C.J., & Pringle, J.E., 2005, MNRAS, 358, 283
Armitage, P.J., Clarke, C.J. & Tout, C.A., 1999, MNRAS, 304, 425
Armitage, P.J., Clarke, C.J., Palla, F., 2003, MNRAS, 342, 1139
Artymowicz, P., & Lubow, S.H., 1994, ApJ, 421, 651
Baraffe, I., Chabrier, G., Allard, F., Hauschildt, P.H., 1998, A&A, 337, 403
Baraffe, I., Chabrier, G., Allard, F., Hauschildt, P.H., 2002, A&A, 402, 701
Barsony, M., Koresko, C., & Matthews, K., 2003, ApJ, 591, 1064
Beckwith, S.V.W., & Sargent, A.I., Chini, R.S., & Guesten, R., 1990, AJ, 99, 924
Brandner, W., & Zinnecker, H., 1997, A&A, 321, 220
Bontemps, S., Andr´e, P., Kaas, A.A., Nordh, L., Olofsson, G., Hiuldtgren, M., Abergel, A.,
et al. 2001, A&A, 372, 173
Bouvier, J., & Appenzeller, I., 1992, A&AS, 92, 481
Burrows, C.J., Stapelfeldt, K.R., Watson, A.M., Krist, J.E., Ballester, G.E., Clarke, J.T.,
Crisp, D. et al., 1996, ApJ, 473, 437
Butler, R.P.,Vogt, S.S., Marcy, G.W., Fischer, D.A., Wright, J.T., Henry, G.W., Laughlin,
G., & Lissauer, J.J., 2004, ApJ, 617, 580
Carpenter, J.M., 2001, AJ, 121, 2851
– 27 –
Clarke, C.J., Gendrin, A. & Sotomayor, M., 2001, MNRAS, 328, 485
Cohen, M., Walker, R.G., Barlow, M.B., & Deacon, J.R. 1992, AJ, 104, 1650
Cohen, M., Witteborn, F.C., Walker, R.G., Bregman, J.D., & Wooden, D.H., 1995, AJ, 110,
275
Cohen, M., Walker, R.G., Carter, B., Hammersley, P., Kidger, M., & Noguchi, K., 1999, AJ,
117, 1864
Allen's Astrophysical Quantities, editted by Arthur Cox, 2000, Springer-Verlag, New York,
pg 528
D'Alessio, P., Hartmann, L., Calvet, N., Franco-Hernandez, R., Forrest, W.J., Furlan, E. et
al. 2004, astro-ph/0411522
de Geus, C.J. & Burton, W.B., 1991, A&A, 246, 559
Doppman, G.W., Jaffe, D.T., & White, R.J., 2003, AJ, 126, 3043
Duchene, G., Monin, J.-L., Bouvier, J., & Mnard, F., 1999, A&A, 351, 954
Duchene, G., Ghez, A.M., McCabe, C. & Weinberger, A.J., 2003, ApJ, 592, 288
Dutrey, A., Guilloteau, S., Prato, L., Simon, M., Duvert, G., Schuster, K. & M´enard, F.,
1998, A&A, 338, L63
Duquennoy, A., & Mayor, M., 1991, A&A, 248, 485
Duvert, G., Guilloteau, S., M´enard, F., Simon, M., Dutrey, A., 2000,A&A, 355, 165
Elias, J.H., 1978, ApJ, 224, 857
Folha, D.F.M., & Emerson, J.P., 2001, A&A, 365, 90
Ghez, A.M., Neugebauer, G., Gorham, P.W., Haniff, C.A., Kulkarni, S.R., Matthews, K.,
Koresko, C., & Beckwith, S.V.W, 1991, AJ, 102, 2066
Ghez, A.M., Neugebauer, G. & Matthews, K., 1993, AJ, 106, 2005
Ghez, A.M., McCarthy, D.W., Weinberger, A.J., Neugebauer, J., & Matthews, K., 1994,
"Interacting Binary Stars", ASP conf. series vol 56, pg 221
Ghez, A.M., Emerson, J.P., Graham, J.R., Meixner, M., & Skinner, C.J., 1994b, ApJ, 434,
707
– 28 –
Ghez, A.M., Weinberger, A.J., Neugebauer, G., Matthews, K., McCarthy, D.W., Jr., 1995,
AJ, 110, 753
Ghez, A.M., White, R.J., & Simon, M., 1997, ApJ, 490, 353
Ghez, A.M., Klein, B. L., Morris, M., & Becklin, E. E., 1998, ApJ, 509, 678
Girart, J.M., Curiel, S., Rodr´iguez, L.F., Honda, M., Cant´o, J., Okamoto, Y.K. & Sako, S.,
2004, AJ, 127, 2969
Greene, T.P., & Meyer, M.R., 1995, ApJ, 450, 233
Guilloteau, S., Dutrey, A., & Simon, M., 1999, A&A, 348, 570
Haisch, K.E., Jr., Lada, E.A., & Lada, C.J., 2001, ApJ, 553, L153
Hanner, M.S., Brooke, T.Y. & Tokunaga, A.T., 1998, ApJ, 502, 871
Hartigan, P., Strom, K.M., & Strom, S.E., 1994, ApJ, 427, 961
Hartigan, P., & Kenyon, S.J., 2003, ApJ, 583, 334
Hartmann, L., Hewett, R., & Calvet, N., 1994, ApJ, 426, 669
Hartmann, Lee "Accretion Processes in Star Formation", 1998, Cambridge University Press,
ISBN 0 521 43507 2, pg 184
Herbig, G.H., Robbin, K.R., 1988, Lick Obs. Bull., 1111, 1
Herbst, T.M., Koresko, C.D., & Leinert, Ch., 1995, ApJ, 444, L93
Hollenbach, D., Johnstone, D., Lizano, S., & Shu, F., 1994, ApJ, 428, 654
Jensen, E.L.N. & Mathieu, R.D., 1997, AJ, 114, 301
Jones, B. & Puetter, R.C., 1993, SPIE, vol. 1946 p 610
Kenyon, S.J. & Hartmann, L., 1995, ApJSS, 101, 117
Kenyon, S.J., Yi, I., & Hartmann, L., 1996, ApJ, 462, 439
Kenyon, S.J., Brown, D.I., Tout, C.A., & Berlind, P., 1998, AJ, 115, 2491
Koerner, D.W., Jensen, E.L.N., Cruz, K.L., Guild, T.B., Gultekin, K., 2000, ApJ, 533, L37
Koresko, C.D., Herbst, T.M., & Leinert, Ch., 1997, ApJ, 480, 741
– 29 –
Koresko, C.D., 2002, AJ, 124, 1082
Lada, C.J., 1987, IAUS 115, 1
Leinert, Ch., Zinnecker, H., Weitzel, N., Christou, J., Ridgway, S. T., Jameson, R., Haas,
M., & Lenzen, R., 1993, A&A, 278, 129
Littlefair, S. P., Naylor, T., Harries, T.J., Retter, A., & O'Toole, S., 2004, MNRAS, 347, 937
Lord, S.D. 1992, NASA Technical Memor. 103957
Luhman, K.L., & Rieke, G.H., 1999, ApJ, 525, 440
Marchal, L., Delfosse, X., Forveille, T., Segransan, D., Beuzit, J. L., Udry, S., Perrier, C.,
Mayor, M., & Halbwachs, J.-L., 2003, IAUS, 211, 311
Marraco, H.G. & Rydgren, A.E., 1981, AJ, 86, 62
Mart´in, E.L., 1998, AJ, 115, 351
Mathieu,R.D., Stassun, K., Basri, G., Jensen, E.L.N., Johns-Krull, C.M., Valenti, J.A., &
Hartmann, L. W., 1997, AJ, 113, 1841
Matsuyama, I., Johnstone, D., & Hartmann, L., 2003, ApJ, 582, 893
McCabe, C., Duchene, G., & Ghez, A.M., 2002, ApJ, 575, 974
McCabe, C., Duchene, G. & Ghez, A.M. 2003, ApJ, 588, L113
Meyer, M.R., Calvet, N., & Hillenbrand, L.A., 1997, AJ, 114, 288
Muzerolle, J., Hartmann, L., & Calvet, N., 1998, AJ, 116, 2965
Myers, P.C., Fuller, G.A., Mathieu, R.D., Beichman, C.A., Benson, P.J., & Schild, R.E.,
1987, ApJ, 319, 340
Natta, A., Meyer, M.R., & Beckwith, S.V.W, 2000, ApJ, 534, 838
Osterloh, M. & Beckwith, S.V.W., 1995, ApJ, 439, 288
Prato, L., & Simon, M., 1997, ApJ, 474, 455
Prato, L.A., Ghez, A.M., Pina, R.K., Telesco, C.M., Fisher, R.S., Wizinowich, P., Lai, O.,
Acton, D.S., Stomski, P., 2001, ApJ, 549, 590
Prato, L.A., Greene, T.P. & Simon, M., 2003, ApJ, 584, 853
– 30 –
Press, W.H., Teukolsky, S.A. & Vetterling, W.T., "Numerical Recipes in C: The Art of
Scientific Computing", 1993, Cambridge University Press
Przygodda, F., van Boekel, R., `Abrah`am, P., Melnikov, S. Y., Waters, L. B. F. M., & Leinert,
Ch. 2003, A&A, 412, L43
Quillen, A.C., Blackman, E.G., Frank, A., & Varni`ere, P., 2004, ApJ, 612, L137
Rayner, J.T., Shure, M.A., Toomey, D.W., et al., 1993, SPIE, Vol. 1946, p. 490-501
Reipurth, B. & Zinnecker, H., 1993, A&A, 278, 81
Rieke, G.H. & Lebofsky, M.J., 1985, ApJ, 288, 618
Rydgren, A.E., Strom, S.E., & Strom, K.M., 1976, ApJS, 30, 307 Benson, J. A., & Slowik,
D, 1992, ApJ, 384, 212
Sargent, A.I., & Beckwith, S.V.W., 1991, ApJ, 382, L31
Simon, M., Ghez, A. M., Leinert, Ch., Cassar, L., Chen, W. P., Howell, R. R., Jameson, R.
F., Matthews, K., Neugebauer, G., & Richichi, A., 1995, ApJ, 443, 625
Simon, M., Holfeltz, S.T., & Taff, L.G., 1996, ApJ, 469, 890
Shu, F.H., Adams, F.C., & Lizano, S., 1987, ARA&A, 25, 23
Shure, M.A., Toomey, D.W., Rayner, J.T. et al., 1994, SPIE, vol.2198, p. 614-622
Skinner, S.L., Brown, A., & Walter, F.M., 1991, AJ, 102, 1742
Skrutskie, M.F., Dutkevitch, D., Strom, S.E., Edwards, S., Strom, K.M., & Shure, M.A.,
1990, AJ, 99, 1187
Smith, K.W., Lewis, G.F., Bonnell, I.A., Bunclark, P.S., & Emerson, J.P., 1999, MNRAS,
304, 367
Stanke, T & Zinnecker, H. 2000, IAU Symp 200 "The Formation of Binary Stars", pg 38
Stapelfeldt, K.R., Krist, J.E., Menard, F., Bouvier, J., Padgett, D.L., & Burrows, C.J., 1998,
ApJ, 502, L65
Stassun, K.G., Mathieu, R.D., Vrba, F.J., Mazeh, T., Henden, A., 2001, AJ, 121, 1003
Strom, K.M., Strom, S.E., Edwards, S., Cabrit, S., & Skrutskie, M.F., 1989, AJ, 97, 1451
– 31 –
Strom, K.M., & Strom, S.E., 1994, apJ, 424, 237
Takeuchi, T., Clarke, C.J. & Lin, D.N.C., 2005, ApJ, 627, 286
Telesco, C.M., Fisher, R.S., Pina, R.K., Knacke, R.F., Dermott, S.F., Wyatt, M.C., Grogan,
K., et al., 2000, ApJ, 530, 329
Walter, F.M., Brown, A., Mathieu, R.D., Myers, P.C., & Vrba, F.J., 1988, AJ, 96, 297
Wilking, B.A., Schwartz, R.D., & Blackwell, J.H., 1987, AJ, 94, 106
Wilking, B.A., Lada, C.J., & Young, E.T., 1989, ApJ, 340, 823
Wilking, B.A., Bontemps, S, Schuler, R.E., Greene, T.P., & Andr´e, P., 2001, ApJ, 551, 357
White, R.J., & Ghez, A.M., 2001, ApJ, 556, 265
Woitas, J., Leinert, Ch. & Kohler, R. 2001, A&A, 376, 982
Wolk, S.J., & Walter, F.M., 1996, AJ, 111, 2066
Wood, K., Lada, C. J., Bjorkman, J. E., Kenyon, S.J., Whitney, B., & Wolff, M.J., 2002,
ApJ, 567, 1183
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
– 32 –
Table 1. T Tauri Binary Sample
Object
Separationa
J2000 coords
Refb
(′′)
RA
Dec
Taurus:
IS Tau
GG Tau A
FS Tau
IW Tau
V410 Tau
V927 Tau
Haro 6-37
XZ Tau
GH Tau
GN Tau
CZ Tau
Lk Ha 332
UZ Tau
V807 Tau
LkCa 3
DD Tau
HBC 351
Haro 6-28
VY Tau
FV Tau
T Tau
FV Tau /c
FQ Tau
UY Aur
FX Tau
LkCa 7
RW Aur
GG Tau B
HBC 358/9
HBC 356/7
HBC 411
HK Tau
IT Tau
DK Tau
UX Tau
0.22
0.25
0.27
0.27
0.29
0.30
0.30/2.7
0.30
0.31
0.31
0.33
0.33
0.34/3.78
0.41
0.49
0.56
0.61
0.66
0.66
0.72
0.73
0.74
0.79
0.88
0.90
1.05
1.42
1.48
1.58/20.
2.0
2.04
2.40
2.48
2.53
2.7/5.9
04 33 36.8 +26 09 50
04 32 30.3 +17 31 41
04 22 02.1 +26 57 32
04 41 04.7 +24 51 06
04 18 31.1 +28 27 16
04 31 23.8 +24 10 54
04 46 59.0 +17 02 38
04 31 40.0 +18 13 58
04 33 06.1 +24 09 45
04 39 20.8 +25 45 03
04 18 31.6 +28 16 59
04 42 07.7 +25 23 13
04 32 42.9 +25 52 32
04 33 06.7 +24 09 56
04 14 48.0 +27 52 35
04 18 31.1 +28 16 30
03 52 02.3 +24 39 51
04 35 55.9 +22 54 36
04 39 17.4 +22 47 54
04 26 53.6 +26 06 55
04 21 59.4 +19 32 06
04 26 54.4 +26 06 52
04 19 12.8 +28 29 36
04 51 47.3 +30 47 14
04 30 29.6 +24 26 46
04 19 41.3 +27 49 39
05 07 49.6 +30 24 05
04 32 30.3 +17 31 31
04 03 49.2 +26 10 54
04 03 14.1 +25 53 00
04 35 41.2 +24 11 08
04 31 50.5 +24 24 19
04 33 54.7 +26 13 30
04 30 44.3 +26 01 24
04 30 03.9 +18 13 49
2,3,4
2,3,6
3,4
3,4
6
4
1,3
2,3
2,3
4,5,6
3
3
2,3,4,6
2,3,4
2,3
2,3
3
3,4
3,4
1,2,3,4
2,3
3,4
3
2,3
2,3,4
3
1,2,3,6
3,6
3
8
1,3,4
1,3,4
1,4
1,3,4
1,3
– 33 –
Table 1-Continued
Object
Separationa
J2000 coords
Refb
HN Tau
V710 Tau
J4872
HV Tau
HBC 354/5
Ophiuchus:
SR 24
NTTS162218-2420
NTTS155913-2233
SR 12
V853 Oph
ROXs 31
WSB 11
SR 9
WSB 3
Haro 1-4
DoAr 51
NTTS155203-2338c
WSB 18
WSB 26
ROX 15
AS 205
WSB 19
DoAr 24E
DoAr 26
WSB 4
ROX 43
WSB 28
SR 21
Corona Australis:
S CrA
HBC 679
(′′)
3.1
3.24
3.5
4.00
5.0
0.20/6.0
0.24
0.29
0.30
0.40
0.48
0.50
0.59
0.60
0.72
0.77
0.80
1.1
1.2
1.2
1.32
1.5
2.03
2.3
2.8
4.8
5.1
6.7
1.3
4.5
RA
Dec
04 33 39.3 +17 51 53
04 31 57.6 +18 21 37
04 25 17.6 +26 17 51
04 38 35.3 +26 10 39
03 54 35.6 +25 37 12
16 26 58.8
16 25 19.2
16 02 10.5
16 27 19.5
16 28 45.3
16 27 52.0
16 21 57.3
16 27 40.3
16 18 49.5
16 25 10.5
16 32 11.8
16 32 11.8
16 24 59.7
16 26 18.3
16 26 42.7
16 11 31.4
16 25 01.9
16 26 23.3
16 26 34.8
16 18 50.3
16 31 20.0
16 26 20.9
16 27 10.2
-24 45 37
-24 26 52
-22 41 28
-24 41 40
-24 28 17
-24 40 48
-22 38 16
-24 22 03
-26 32 53
-23 19 14
-24 40 19
-24 40 19
-24 56 01
-25 20 55
-24 20 29
-18 38 26
-24 59 33
-24 20 58
-23 45 41
-26 10 08
-24 40 02
-24 08 51
-24 19 16
19 01 08.5
19 02 22.4
-36 57 20
-36 55 41
1,3
1,3
1
1,3,4,5
8
1,4,7
2
2
4,7
2,4
4
1
2
1
1,2
7
2
1
1
1
1,2
1
1,2,4
1
1
1,4
1
1,4
1
1
aTwo numbers, separated by a slash, highlight a triple system.
bSource: [1] - Reipurth & Zinnecker (1993) [2] - Ghez et al. (1993);
(1995); [5] - Simon,
(1993); [4] - Simon et al.
[3] - Leinert et al.
– 34 –
Holfeltz & Taff (1996); [6] - Ghez, White & Simon (1997); [7] - Ghez
et al. (1994); [8] - Walter et al. (1988)
– 35 –
Table 2. Observation Log
Date (UT)
Telescope
Instrument Filters
Mid-Infrared
1998 May 9-11 Keck II
1998 May 14-15 Keck II
1999 May 5-6
Keck II
1999 Nov 17-20 Keck II
2001 May 10-12 Keck I
2002 Nov 12-13 Keck I
Near-Infrared
2001 Dec 1
2001 May 26-27
IRTF
IRTF
OSCIR
OSCIR
OSCIR
OSCIR
LWS
LWS
N, IHW18
N, IHW18
N, IHW18
N, IHW18
8.9, 12.5, 18.7
SiC
NSFCAM K,L
NSFCAM K,L
Table 3. Observational Results
Object
Date
(UT)
Filter
Sepn
(′′)
PA
(◦)
Flux
Ratio
Magnitudea
Prim.
Sec.
Totalb
Taurus:
IS Tau
GG Tau A
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
GN Tau
FS Tau
IW Tau
· · ·
0.24 ± 0.01 347 ± 3
· · ·
V410 Tau AC
V927 Tau
· · ·
0.26 ± 0.01 292 ± 1
0.29 ± 0.02 291 ± 2
· · ·
0.30 ± 0.01 181 ± 3
2.61 ± 0.07 39 ± 1
· · ·
0.30 ± 0.01 111 ± 2
5.02 ± 0.11
2002 Nov 12 SiC
· · ·
1.03 ± 0.04 5.03 ± 0.17 5.07 ± 0.13 4.30 ± 0.15
1999 Nov 17 N
2.67 ± 0.12
1999 Nov 17 IHW18 · · ·
· · ·
4.19 ± 0.18
1999 Nov 17 N
· · ·
· · ·
1.67 ± 0.03 8.62 ± 0.02 9.18 ± 0.02 8.11 ± 0.02
0.30 ± 0.01 185 ± 1
2001 Dec 01 L
8.10 ± 0.14
2002 Nov 13 SiC
· · ·
· · ·
7.17 ± 0.13
2002 Nov 13 SiC
· · ·
1.64 ± 0.06 9.23 ± 0.02 9.76 ± 0.03 8.71 ± 0.02
2001 Dec 01 K
2.37 ± 0.2 7.82 ± 0.13 8.76 ± 0.16 7.44 ± 0.15
2001 Dec 01 L
8.04 ± 0.15
2002 Nov 12 SiC
· · ·
1.50 ± 0.14 5.04 ± 0.14 5.47 ± 0.10 4.48 ± 0.13
Haro 6-37 Aa-Ab 2002 Nov 13 SiC
1.19 ± 0.20 4.48 ± 0.13 4.68 ± 0.13 3.82 ± 0.15
2002 Nov 13 SiC
Haro 6-37 AB
2.17 ± 0.15
1999 Nov 17 N
XZ Tau
· · ·
1.45 ± 0.05 5.75 ± 0.12 6.15 ± 0.09 5.17 ± 0.11
GH Tau
1999 Nov 17 N
3.70 ± 0.11
1999 Nov 17 IHW18 · · ·
· · ·
1.53 ± 0.03 8.26 ± 0.07 7.80 ± 0.07 7.25 ± 0.07
2001 Dec 01 L
0.36 ± 0.01 126 ± 1
6.66 ± 0.17
1999 Nov 17 N
· · ·
· · ·
5.58 ± 0.41 9.51 ± 0.02 11.38 ± 0.08 9.33 ± 0.03
2001 Dec 01 K
0.33 ± 0.01 88 ± 2
1.71 ± 0.09 8.90 ± 0.08 9.49 ± 0.09 8.40 ± 0.09
2001 Dec 01 L
0.33 ± 0.01 92 ± 2
3.79 ± 0.13
1999 Nov 16 N
· · ·
· · ·
6.06 ± 0.18
1999 Nov 17 IHW18 · · ·
· · ·
1.76 ± 0.08 4.96 ± 0.14 5.57 ± 0.12 4.47 ± 0.14
1999 Nov 17 N
3.87 ± 0.12
1999 Nov 17 IHW18 · · ·
· · ·
1.65 ± 0.06 7.68 ± 0.58 8.23 ± 0.59 7.16 ± 0.84
0.35 ± 0.01 4 ± 1
2001 Dec 01 L
1.17 ± 0.07 6.43 ± 0.08 6.60 ± 0.08 5.76 ± 0.08
1999 Nov 16 N
0.37 ± 0.01 3.7 ± 0.6
1.33 ± 0.05 4.64 ± 0.10 4.94 ± 0.08
4.03 ± 0.1
1999 Nov 17 IHW18 0.37 ± 0.01 2.1 ± 0.9
1.81 ± 0.08 7.60 ± 0.1 8.24 ± 0.05 7.12 ± 0.09
3.5 ± 0.1
2001 Dec 1 K
2.51 ± 0.08 6.78 ± 0.17 7.78 ± 0.13 6.42 ± 0.17
3.5 ± 0.1
2001 Dec 1 L
1999 Nov 16 N
3.52 ± 0.06 272.9 ± 0.4 8.02 ± 0.88 3.50 ± 0.09 5.76 ± 0.08 3.37 ± 0.09
1999 Nov 17 IHW18 3.44 ± 0.06 273.0 ± 0.4 8.79 ± 1.2 2.28 ± 0.11 4.64 ± 0.10 2.16 ± 0.11
5.27 ± 0.18*
1999 Nov 17 N
· · ·
1999 Nov 17 IHW18 · · ·
4.04 ± 0.11*
· · ·
1.18 ± 0.03 8.06 ± 0.03 8.24 ± 0.03 7.39 ± 0.03
2001 Dec 01 K
0.34 ± 0.01 210 ± 1.
0.47 ± 0.01 72 ± 1
275 ± 1
276 ± 1
UZ Tau EW
UZ Tau W
Lk Ha 332
V807 Tau
CZ Tau
LkCa 3
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
–
3
6
–
Table 3-Continued
Object
Date
(UT)
Filter
Sepn
(′′)
PA
(◦)
Flux
Ratio
Magnitudea
Prim.
Sec.
Totalb
· · ·
· · ·
–
3
7
–
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
DD Tau
HBC 351
1.17 ± 0.01
· · ·
8.02 ± 0.03 8.19 ± 0.04 7.35 ± 0.03
7.52 ± 0.19c
· · ·
7.72 ± 0.11 8.10 ± 0.09 7.14 ± 0.10
4.53 ± 0.06 5.13 ± 0.06 4.04 ± 0.06
8.94 ± 0.05
9.20 ± 0.04
10.6 ± 0.1
2001 Dec 01 L
0.47 ± 0.01 72 ± 1
1999 Nov 17 N
· · ·
1999 Nov 17 IHW18 · · ·
2002 Nov 13 SiC
1999 Nov 17 N
2001 Dec 01 K
2001 Dec 01 L
2002 Nov 13 SiC
· · ·
1.41 ± 0.06
0.48 ± 0.02 76 ± 2
1.75 ± 0.08
0.54 ± 0.01 179 ± 2
3.61 ± 0.39
0.55 ± 0.01 314 ± 1
5.14 ± 0.06
0.54 ± 0.02 315 ± 1
· · ·
· · ·
0.65 ± 0.01 247 ± 1
2.07 ± 0.08
Haro 6-28 2001 Dec 01 L
0.64 ± 0.01 246.5 ± 0.4 0.94 ± 0.04
1999 Nov 17 N
1999 Nov 17 IHW18 0.68 ± 0.01 245.1 ± 0.6 0.79 ± 0.07
6.14 ± 0.27
2001 Dec 01 L
1999 Nov 17 N
· · ·
1999 Nov 17 N
1999 Nov 17 IHW18 0.67 ± 0.03 112 ± 1
1999 Nov 17 N
1999 Nov 17 IHW18 0.67 ± 0.02 181.6 ± 0.8 0.87 ± 0.01 -1.48 ± 0.10 -1.63 ± 0.1
0.67 ± 0.01 318 ± 1
· · ·
0.71 ± 0.02 92.1 ± 0.8 2.2 ± 0.2
1.51 ± 0.06
0.67 ± 0.01 181.2 ± 0.4 0.89 ± 0.02
8.81 ± 0.30 9.60 ± 0.32 8.38 ± 0.36
7.38 ± 0.16 7.31 ± 0.18 6.59 ± 0.19
5.85 ± 0.07 5.58 ± 0.07 4.96 ± 0.07
8.47 ± 0.08 10.45 ± 0.11 8.31 ± 0.09
6.63 ± 0.16*
4.07 ± 0.17 4.92 ± 0.12 3.66 ± 0.17
3.07 ± 0.13 3.52 ± 0.11 2.52 ± 0.13
1.54 ± 0.15 1.41 ± 0.16 0.72 ± 0.17
-2.31 ± 0.1
8.59 ± 0.14 8.26 ± 0.17 7.66 ± 0.17
FV Tau /c 1999 Nov 17 N
VY Tau
FV Tau
T Tau
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
0.67 ± 0.02 112 ± 1
0.74 ± 0.09
1999 Nov 17 IHW18 · · ·
· · ·
2002 Nov 12 SiC
0.75 ± 0.04
6.27 ± 0.07 5.96 ± 0.10 5.36 ± 0.09
0.68 ± 0.02 115 ± 1
2001 Dec 01 K
0.77 ± 0.08 10.15 ± 0.06 9.87 ± 0.05 9.25 ± 0.06
0.73 ± 0.01 67 ± 1
2001 Dec 01 L
9.54 ± 0.04 9.12 ± 0.03 8.56 ± 0.03
0.68 ± 0.04
0.73 ± 0.01 67 ± 1
1999 Nov 20 N
7.42 ± 0.04 7.55 ± 0.09 6.73 ± 0.07
1.13 ± 0.04
0.66 ± 0.01 70 ± 1
7.18 ± 0.09 7.24 ± 0.10 6.46 ± 0.10
2002 Nov 12 SiC
0.74 ± 0.02 66 ± 1
1.05 ± 0.02
1999 Nov 16 N
0.88 ± 0.01 227.6 ± 0.4 2.07 ± 0.03
3.37 ± 0.1
4.16 ± 0.08 2.94 ± 0.10
1.28 ± 0.05 2.23 ± 0.04 0.90 ± 0.05
1999 Nov 16 IHW18 0.87 ± 0.01 227.7 ± 0.4 2.41 ± 0.02
7.60 ± 0.05 8.65 ± 0.06 7.25 ± 0.05
0.85 ± 0.02 289 ± 1
2001 Dec 01 L
2.63 ± 0.08
5.36 ± 0.11 6.46 ± 0.06 5.03 ± 0.10
1999 Nov 18 N
0.87 ± 0.02 289.4 ± 0.4 2.75 ± 0.11
1999 Nov 18 IHW18 0.84 ± 0.02 290.5 ± 0.5 2.79 ± 0.33
4.01 ± 0.10 5.13 ± 0.03 3.68 ± 0.08
0.98 ± 0.02 25 ± 1
1.851 ± 0.05 8.66 ± 0.03 9.33 ± 0.04 8.19 ± 0.03
2001 Dec 01 K
0.99 ± 0.02 25 ± 1
1.866 ± 0.02 8.62 ± 0.01 9.29 ± 0.02 8.15 ± 0.01
2001 Dec 01 L
1999 Nov 18 N
8.23 ± 0.12*
· · ·
· · ·
1999 Nov 16 N
1.42 ± 0.02 254.6 ± 0.4 13.63 ± 0.06 3.12 ± 0.09 5.96 ± 0.09 3.04 ± 0.09
1999 Nov 16 IHW18 1.38 ± 0.02 254.7 ± 0.4 10.89 ± 0.46 1.62 ± 0.05 4.22 ± 0.06 1.53 ± 0.05
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
FQ Tau
UY Aur
FX Tau
LkCa 7
RW Aur
Table 3-Continued
Date
(UT)
Filter
Sepn
(′′)
PA
(◦)
Flux
Ratio
Magnitudea
Prim.
Sec.
Totalb
Object
GG Tau B
HBC 358 AB
1999 Nov 18 N
2001 Dec 1 K
2001 Dec 1 L
2002 Nov 13 SiC
IT Tau
HK Tau
HBC 411
HBC 356/357
HBC 358/HBC 359 2001 Dec 1 K
2001 Dec 1 L
2001 Dec 1 K
2001 Dec 1 L
2002 Nov 13 SiC
2001 Dec 1 L
2002 Nov 13 SiC
2001 Dec 1 L
2002 Nov 13 SiC
2001 Dec 1 L
2002 Nov 13 SiC
2002 Nov 13 SiC
2002 Nov 12 SiC
2002 Nov 12 SiC
2002 Nov 13 SiC
2002 Nov 12 SiC
2001 Dec 1 K
2001 Dec 1 L
2002 Nov 12 SiC
2001 Dec 1 K
2001 Dec 1 L
2002 Nov 13 SiC
2001 Dec 1 K
2001 Dec 1 L
2002 Nov 13 SiC
DK Tau
UX Tau AB
UX Tau AC
HN Tau
V710 Tau
J4872
HBC 355/354
HV Tau
1.43 ± 0.02
1.55 ± 0.06
1.55 ± 0.06
· · ·
20.1 ± 0.8
20.1 ± 0.8
1.26 ± 0.05
1.25 ± 0.05
· · ·
2.08 ± 0.08
2.02 ± 0.05
2.39 ± 0.1
2.23 ± 0.06
2.4 ± 0.1
2.31 ± 0.06
2.27 ± 0.06
5.6 ± 0.1
2.50 ± 0.3
· · ·
3.06 ± 0.08
3.4 ± 0.1
3.4 ± 0.1
· · ·
4.0 ± 0.2
3.9 ± 0.2
4.1 ± 0.1
6.3 ± 0.3
6.2 ± 0.3
· · ·
133.2 ± 0.4 6.75 ± 0.25
226 ± 1
224 ± 2
· · ·
267 ± 1
267 ± 1
5 ± 2
4 ± 2
· · ·
175 ± 1
175 ± 1
168.1 ± 2.7 25.5 ± 2.4
170 ± 1
225 ± 2
224 ± 1
117 ± 1
268 ± 1
181 ± 5
· · ·
178 ± 1
234 ± 1
234 ± 1
· · ·
43 ± 1
43 ± 1
43 ± 1
298 ± 1
298 ± 1
· · ·
30 ± 4
3.94 ± 0.06
2.95 ± 0.01
8.53 ± 0.04
11.9 ± 1.8
59.7 ± 7.2
· · ·
12.73 ± 0.11
1.78 ± 0.06
1.75 ± 0.02
· · ·
73.3 ± 8.3
36.4 ± 1.8
1.20 ± 0.01
2.18 ± 0.03
2.22 ± 0.1
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
6.72 ± 0.11 8.80 ± 0.11 6.57 ± 0.12
1.777 ± 0.003 9.80 ± 0.06 10.43 ± 0.06 9.32 ± 0.06
1.77 ± 0.16
9.79 ± 0.04 10.41 ± 0.14 9.30 ± 0.08
· · ·
1.31 ± 0.08
1.18 ± 0.35
1.04 ± 0.01
1.1 ± 0.1
· · ·
5.99 ± 0.24
10.22 ± 0.08
9.51 ± 0.03 9.80 ± 0.06 8.89 ± 0.04
9.61 ± 0.32 9.79 ± 0.04 8.94 ± 0.21
10.72 ± 0.03 10.77 ± 0.03 9.99 ± 0.03
10.86 ± 0.01 10.92 ± 0.1 10.14 ± 0.06
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
7.86 ± 0.01 9.80 ± 0.04 7.69 ± 0.01
4.68 ± 0.12 7.21 ± 0.12 4.58 ± 0.13
8.08 ± 0.1 11.58 ± 0.16 8.04 ± 0.1d
5.33 ± 0.07 9.03 ± 0.16 5.30 ± 0.07
7.67 ± 0.07 9.15 ± 0.05 7.42 ± 0.07
5.31 ± 0.11 6.48 ± 0.11 4.99 ± 0.11
3.42 ± 0.14 5.75 ± 0.13 3.30 ± 0.15
5.62 ± 0.11 8.31 ± 0.12 5.53 ± 0.12
5.62 ± 0.11 10.06 ± 0.07 5.60 ± 0.12
3.53 ± 0.13*
· · ·
· · ·
5.44 ± 0.10 8.21 ± 0.10
5.36 ± 0.1
8.58 ± 0.03 9.20 ± 0.06 8.09 ± 0.04
8.53 ± 0.07
8.04 ± 0.08
9.14 ± 0.1
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
12.2 ± 0.1
7.86 ± 0.04
7.84 ± 0.04
7.66 ± 0.04 11.34 ± 0.04 7.62 ± 0.04
7.59 ± 0.13 7.78 ± 0.14 6.93 ± 0.14
10.15 ± 0.01 10.99 ± 0.01 9.74 ± 0.01
10.16 ± 0.07 11.03 ± 0.11 9.76 ± 0.09
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
–
3
8
–
Ophiuchus:
SR 24N
SR 24 NS
0.112 ± 0.002 63 ± 2
2001 May 26 K
59 ± 6
0.12 ± 0.01
2001 May 26 L
347.7 ± 0.4 0.95 ± 0.01
1999 May 04 N
5.08 ± 0.08
1999 May 04 IHW18 5.01 ± 0.08
347.5 ± 0.4 1.87 ± 0.05
1.523 ± 0.03
1.887 ± 0.16
8.50 ± 0.01 8.96 ± 0.01 7.95 ± 0.01
6.80 ± 0.04 7.49 ± 0.07 6.34 ± 0.05
3.50 ± 0.12 3.45 ± 0.12 2.72 ± 0.13
1.87 ± 0.07 2.55 ± 0.05 1.41 ± 0.06
Table 3-Continued
Object
Date
(UT)
Filter
Sepn
(′′)
PA
(◦)
Flux
Ratio
Magnitudea
Prim.
Sec.
Totalb
NTTS162218-2420 2001 May 26 K
2001 May 26 L
2001 May 10 8.8
2001 May 10 12.5
0.19 ± 0.004 147 ± 2
0.201 ± 0.004 145 ± 1
· · ·
· · ·
1.25 ± 0.12
1.40 ± 0.01
· · ·
8.29 ± 0.06 8.53 ± 0.07 7.65 ± 0.07
8.22 ± 0.01 8.58 ± 0.01 7.63 ± 0.01
7.32 ± 0.15
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
0.228 ± 0.004 82 ± 1
0.237 ± 0.005 83 ± 1
· · ·
0.34 ± 0.01
0.33 ± 0.01
WSB 11
ROXs 31
V853 OPH
0.26 ± 0.04
0.38 ± 0.01
0.38 ± 0.01
· · ·
0.47 ± 0.01
0.48 ± 0.01
0.48 ± 0.01
NTTS155913-2233 1999 May 05 N
2001 May 26 K
SR 12
2001 May 26 L
2001 May 11 8.8
2001 May 26 K
2001 May 26 L
1999 May 04 IHW18 · · ·
1999 May 04 N
2001 May 26 K
2001 May 26 L
1999 May 05 N
2001 May 27 K
1998 May 10 N
1999 May 04 N
1999 May 04 IHW18 · · ·
0.59 ± 0.01
2001 May 26 K
0.61 ± 0.02
2001 May 26 L
0.59 ± 0.02
1999 May 04 N
0.59 ± 0.01
2001 May 27 K
0.60 ± 0.02
2001 May 27 L
2001 May 10 8.8
· · ·
0.74 ± 0.01
2001 May 26 K
0.75 ± 0.01
2001 May 26 L
0.73 ± 0.02
2001 May 11 8.8
0.74 ± 0.02
2001 May 11 12.5
1998 May 09 N
0.76 ± 0.02
1998 May 09 IHW18 0.76 ± 0.01
0.75 ± 0.02
2001 May 27 K
0.72 ± 0.02
2001 May 27 L
1998 May 10 N
0.79 ± 0.02
Haro 1-4
DoAr 51
WSB 3
SR 9
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
8.22 ± 0.02 9.60 ± 0.04 7.95 ± 0.02
7.64 ± 0.03 9.12 ± 0.06 7.39 ± 0.04
3.62 ± 0.05
5.94 ± 0.09 7.42 ± 0.06 5.69 ± 0.09
8.68 ± 0.02 8.97 ± 0.03 8.06 ± 0.02
8.31 ± 0.03 8.85 ± 0.04 7.79 ± 0.03
6.94 ± 0.12*
· · ·
1.292 ± 0.02 8.90 ± 0.01 9.18 ± 0.01 8.28 ± 0.01
1.50 ± 0.02
8.73 ± 0.06 9.17 ± 0.07 8.18 ± 0.07
· · ·
3.55 ± 0.16
3.91 ± 0.19
· · ·
3.9 ± 0.4
1.31 ± 0.04
1.65 ± 0.09
· · ·
2.22 ± 0.06 10.39 ± 0.01 11.26 ± 0.02 9.99 ± 0.01
· · ·
93 ± 1
94 ± 1
· · ·
101 ± 4
252 ± 1
252 ± 1
· · ·
317 ± 1
314.9 ± 0.6 0.94 ± 0.10
1.09 ± 0.18
317 ± 1
· · ·
· · ·
353 ± 1
10.82 ± 0.16 7.18 ± 0.02 9.77 ± 0.03 7.08 ± 0.02
13.88 ± 0.55 6.56 ± 0.02 9.41 ± 0.06 6.48 ± 0.02
353 ± 1
4.37 ± 0.09 6.82 ± 0.11 4.26 ± 0.10
356.8 ± 0.7 9.54 ± 0.9
9.47 ± 0.01 10.40 ± 0.01 9.09 ± 0.01
159 ± 1
159 ± 1
9.07 ± 0.04 10.68 ± 0.08 8.85 ± 0.05
· · ·
30 ± 1
30 ± 1
27 ± 1
26 ± 1
27.2 ± 0.6 1.77 ± 0.06
28.8 ± 0.4 2.51 ± 0.03
9.72 ± 2.64
79 ± 1
79 ± 2
3.41 ± 0.41
77.6 ± 0.4 0.51 ± 0.09
2.36 ± 0.01
4.42 ± 0.24
· · ·
3.37 ± 0.07
5.88 ± 0.02
3.17 ± 0.5
3.14 ± 0.3
7.58 ± 0.02 8.90 ± 0.03 7.30 ± 0.02
6.83 ± 0.02 8.75 ± 0.02 6.66 ± 0.02
7.75 ± 0.07 10.22 ± 0.27 7.64 ± 0.09
7.86 ± 0.14 9.19 ± 0.21 7.58 ± 0.17
7.64 ± 0.06 7.74 ± 0.06 6.94 ± 0.06
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
–
3
9
–
Table 3-Continued
Object
Date
(UT)
Filter
Sepn
(′′)
PA
(◦)
Flux
Ratio
Magnitudea
Prim.
Sec.
Totalb
· · ·
7.49 ± 0.11
3.76 ± 0.06 7.21 ± 0.03 8.65 ± 0.05 6.95 ± 0.03
5.68 ± 0.5
6.69 ± 0.03 8.57 ± 0.08 6.51 ± 0.04
5.34 ± 0.23 7.10 ± 0.05 8.92 ± 0.02 6.92 ± 0.05
7.49 ± 0.11
· · ·
0.62 ± 0.03 231 ± 1
0.73 ± 0.03 233 ± 2
0.72 ± 0.02 232 ± 1
· · ·
0.73 ± 0.02 233.5 ± 0.8 4.36 ± 0.6
1.15 ± 0.3
0.97 ± 0.11 80 ± 1
10.2 ± 0.2 10.38 ± 0.08 9.53 ± 0.16
0.841 ± 0.08 9.94 ± 0.13 9.75 ± 0.03 9.09 ± 0.08
1.04 ± 0.05 83 ± 1
3.87 ± 0.09 9.21 ± 0.08 7.74 ± 0.1
1.03 ± 0.03 85 ± 1
7.49 ± 0.1
4.89 ± 0.23 8.86 ± 0.08 7.14 ± 0.08 6.94 ± 0.08
1.01 ± 0.03 77 ± 3
1.09 ± 0.05 26 ± 2
1.24 ± 0.01 9.87 ± 0.09 10.10 ± 0.08 9.23 ± 0.09
1.10 ± 0.05 25 ± 1
1.31 ± 0.04 9.13 ± 0.03 9.42 ± 0.01 8.51 ± 0.02
1.14 ± 0.02 24.6 ± 0.4 0.41 ± 0.03 7.25 ± 0.11 6.28 ± 0.11 5.91 ± 0.12
1.12 ± 0.02 23.2 ± 0.7 3.78 ± 0.2
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
3.15 ± 0.05 8.22 ± 0.09 9.47 ± 0.07 7.92 ± 0.09
1.40 ± 0.06 69 ± 1
1.40 ± 0.06 69 ± 1
7.39 ± 0.08 8.55 ± 0.04 7.07 ± 0.07
2.90 ± 0.1
1.39 ± 0.02 67.6 ± 0.4 4.86 ± 0.4
1.45 ± 0.02 68.7 ± 0.4 3.97 ± 0.18 5.71 ± 0.05 7.21 ± 0.09 5.47 ± 0.06
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
ROX 15
WSB 26
WSB 18
NTTS155203-2338e2001 May 26 K
2001 May 26 L
2001 May 10 8.8
2001 May 10 12.5
1998 May 09 N
2001 May 27 K
2001 May 27 L
2001 May 12 8.8
2001 May 12 12.5
2001 May 27 K
2001 May 27 L
1999 May 04 N
1998 May 11 N
1999 May 04 IHW18 · · ·
2001 May 27 K
2001 May 27 L
1998 May 11 N
1999 May 05 N
1999 May 05 IHW18 · · ·
2001 May 27 K
2001 May 27 L
2001 May 10 8.8
2001 May 10 12.5
1998 May 11 N
2001 May 27 K
2001 May 27 L
1999 May 05 N
1999 May 05 IHW18 · · ·
1.98 ± 0.08 150 ± 1
2001 May 27 K
1.98 ± 0.08 150 ± 1
2001 May 27 L
1998 May 10 N
2.00 ± 0.03 149.6 ± 0.4 0.35 ± 0.004
1998 May 10 IHW18 2.01 ± 0.03 149.9 ± 0.4 0.40 ± 0.004
2001 May 27 K
2001 May 27 L
2.23 ± 0.09 131 ± 1
2.22 ± 0.09 132 ± 2
DoAr 26f
DoAr 24E
WSB 19
AS 205
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
5.95 ± 0.1 7.07 ± 0.13 5.62 ± 0.11
2.81 ± 0.06
2.90 ± 0.23
6.05 ± 0.02 4.58 ± 0.08
4.9 ± 0.1
2.74 ± 0.02 2.46 ± 0.15 3.55 ± 0.15 2.12 ± 0.16
3.48 ± 0.07 1.47 ± 0.15 2.82 ± 0.14 1.19 ± 0.16
1.30 ± 0.07 214 ± 1
1.32 ± 0.05 213 ± 1
1.30 ± 0.03 210 ± 1
1.30 ± 0.03 210 ± 1
1.31 ± 0.04 212.1 ± 0.6 4.44 ± 0.5
1.48 ± 0.06 262 ± 1
2.12 ± 0.1
9.84 ± 0.04 10.66 ± 0.09 9.42 ± 0.06
1.49 ± 0.06 262 ± 1
2.68 ± 0.03 9.13 ± 0.02 10.20 ± 0.04 8.79 ± 0.03
1.51 ± 0.02 263.2 ± 0.4 2.38 ± 0.06 5.72 ± 0.06 6.67 ± 0.08 5.34 ± 0.07
3.83 ± 0.16
· · ·
6.73 ± 0.14
2.30 ± 0.5
0.78 ± 0.03 6.42 ± 0.09 6.15 ± 0.14 5.52 ± 0.12
3.83 ± 0.16
7.13 ± 0.14
8.0 ± 0.1
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
3.60 ± 0.14
10.4 ± 0.2 8.81 ± 0.32
6.17 ± 0.01 8.28 ± 0.05 10.25 ± 0.06 8.12 ± 0.05
9.1 ± 0.3
–
4
0
–
Table 3-Continued
Object
Date
(UT)
Filter
Sepn
(′′)
PA
(◦)
Flux
Ratio
· · ·
· · ·
2.78 ± 0.11 130 ± 1
2.77 ± 0.12 130 ± 1
· · ·
2.27 ± 0.04 130.6 ± 0.5 8.16 ± 0.9
2.29 ± 0.04 131.4 ± 0.4 5.87 ± 0.10
1998 May 11 N
1999 May 05 N
1999 May 05 IHW18 · · ·
2001 May 27 K
2001 May 27 L
2001 May 12 8.8
2001 May 12 12.5
2001 May 26 K
2001 May 26 L
2001 May 11 8.8
2001 May 11 12.5
2001 May 27 K
2001 May 27 L
2001 May 12 8.8
1998 May 11 N
1998 May 11 IHW18 7.85 ± 0.13 179.1 ± 0.4 3.43 ± 1.2
· · ·
5.00 ± 0.2 358 ± 2
358 ± 1
5.0 ± 0.2
4.9 ± 0.1
356 ± 1
7.67 ± 0.12 177.9 ± 0.4 10.84 ± 5.27
· · ·
4.41 ± 0.18 12 ± 1
4.40 ± 0.18 12 ± 1
· · ·
· · ·
2.70 ± 0.03
4.78 ± 0.06
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
Prim.
· · ·
Magnitudea
Sec.
· · ·
Totalb
· · ·
6.54 ± 0.06
8.46 ± 0.06
6.37 ± 0.06
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
10.65 ± 0.12
· · ·
0.611 ± 0.002 10.92 ± 0.12 10.38 ± 0.12 9.86 ± 0.13
9.28 ± 0.14
0.394 ± 0.02
8.18 ± 0.10*
· · ·
8.18 ± 0.07*
6.66 ± 0.01
6.32 ± 0.01
5.51 ± 0.01 7.221 ± 0.001 5.31 ± 0.01
7.74 ± 0.02
9.64 ± 0.13
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
10.67 ± 3.36 9.540 ± 0.004 12.08 ± 0.3
11.89 ± 0.3
9.18 ± 1.26
1.24 ± 0.04
9.64 ± 0.08
9.49 ± 0.13
9.41 ± 0.11
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
9.44 ± 0.03
9.38 ± 0.16
8.77 ± 0.10
· · ·
· · ·
–
4
1
–
WSB 4
ROX 43
WSB 28
SR 21
Corona Australis:
S CRA
HBC 679
3.27 ± 0.1
1.30 ± 0.05 150 ± 1
2001 May 26 K
3.44 ± 0.1
1.30 ± 0.05 150 ± 1
2001 May 26 L
1.43 ± 0.01
1.27 ± 0.03 148 ± 1
2001 May 12 8.8
1.27 ± 0.03 148 ± 1
1.32 ± 0.01
2001 May 12 12.5
1998 May 10 N
1.31 ± 0.02 149.3 ± 0.4 1.74 ± 0.05
1998 May 10 IHW18 1.30 ± 0.02 149.1 ± 0.4 1.29 ± 0.02
1999 May 05 N
1.32 ± 0.02 149.4 ± 0.4 2.51 ± 0.06
1999 May 05 IHW18 1.30 ± 0.04 149.2 ± 0.6 1.81 ± 0.06
2001 May 26 L
2001 May 10 8.8
2001 May 10 12.5
4.33 ± 0.18 57 ± 1
· · ·
4.76 ± 0.7
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
6.04 ± 0.09
4.62 ± 0.06
3.51 ± 0.11
2.88 ± 0.07
7.33 ± 0.13
5.97 ± 0.03
3.90 ± 0.11
3.18 ± 0.07
5.75 ± 0.10
4.34 ± 0.05
2.93 ± 0.12
2.27 ± 0.07
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
2.63 ± 0.07
1.11 ± 0.11
8.64 ± 0.02
2.26 ± 0.07
3.63 ± 0.05
0.63 ± 0.13
1.75 ± 0.15
10.34 ± 0.15 8.43 ± 0.04
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
aFor the filters used here, vega has the following fluxes: N band - 33.99 Jy; IHW18 - 11.96 Jy; 8.8 µm - 49.26 Jy; SiC
- 28.24 Jy; 12.5 µm - 24.96 Jy. See Appendix B for more details on the absolute photometric calibration.
bRepresents the magnitude of both primary and secondary combined, unless the value is starred. In this case, the
observations reveal one point source and it is not clear which component the flux belongs to.
cChopping errors provide unresolved flux only.
dSecondary marginally resolved in IRTF L-band observations causing large uncertainties in fluxes from PSF fitting.
Used L-band results from White & Ghez (2001) for final sample.
eA third object, situated 11.′′1 from NTTS155203-2338A at a position angle of 164.◦4, was observed at K band (12.2
± 0.2 mag) and L band (11.57 ± 0.01 mag). Given the preponderance of objects within 1′of NTTS 155203-2338, this is
likely to be a background object but has not been confirmed.
f A third object, located 16.′′5 away from DoAr 26 A at a position angle of 49.◦3, was also detected, with K=11.6 ± 0.2
mag and L=11.6 ± 0.8 mag. It is not known whether this object is physically associated with DoAr 26 or not.
–
4
2
–
Table 4. Stellar Component Colors
Object
Component AV
aSpTy
Dereddened
Refb
line? EWHα
TT
Refb notes
K − L
K − [N ] MIR NIR
A
class type
GG Tau
Aa
Ab
Haro 6-37 B
A
GH Tau
B
LkHa 332 A
B
DD Tau
UZ Tau E Aa-Ab
UZ Tau W A
B
A
B
Haro 6-28 A
B
A
B
A
Ba-Bb
FV Tau
T Tau
FQ Tau
UY Aur
FV Tau/c A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
RW Aur A
B
Ba
Bb
A
B
A
B
GG Tau
HK Tau
FX Tau
IT Tau
3.58 K7
0.75 K7
6.68 K5
K6
[0.0] K1
· · ·
0.79 ± 0.15 2.64 ± 0.17
M0.5 0.73 ± 0.16 3.42 ± 0.14
3.89 M1 0.58 ± 0.08 3.76 ± 0.15
1.04 M2 0.64 ± 0.25 2.83 ± 0.26
M2 0.81 ± 0.23 2.23 ± 0.23
0.87 ± 0.10 3.06 ± 0.17
M2.5 -0.16 ± 0.14 3.29 ± 0.16
7.13 M1
0.44 ± 0.2 3.67 ± 0.13
0.28 M2 1.00 ± 0.60 2.25 ± 0.15
M3 1.05 ± 0.61 2.68 ± 0.18
1.61 M3 1.16 ± 0.25 3.79 ± 0.14
M3 1.05 ± 0.29 3.66 ± 0.20
3.09 M2 0.82 ± 0.30 2.23 ± 0.17
M3.5 0.53 ± 0.32 2.80 ± 0.19
0.27 ± 0.21 3.47 ± 0.19
0.95 ± 0.22 3.01 ± 0.17
1.05 ± 0.32 3.84 ± 0.30
3.21 ± 0.32 5.78 ± 0.31
5.23 M2.5 0.17 ± 0.05 2.29 ± 0.08
M3.5 1.81 ± 0.08 5.40 ± 0.10
0.35 M3 0.59 ± 0.07 2.95 ± 0.11
M3.5 0.73 ± 0.06 2.61 ± 0.11
0.94 ± 0.06 4.16 ± 0.10
M2 0.89 ± 0.07 4.13 ± 0.10
2.24 M1 0.87 ± 0.15 3.09 ± 0.18
M4 0.55 ± 0.17 2.72 ± 0.17
1.11 ± 0.22 3.93 ± 0.22
0.73 ± 0.25 2.69 ± 0.25
[0.0] M6 0.81 ± 0.04 3.39 ± 0.11
M7.5 0.79 ± 0.17 3.22 ± 0.13
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
3.41 M1 0.64 ± 0.04 3.14 ± 0.08 14
M2 0.28 ± 0.12 2.77 ± 0.17 14
1
1
0.24 ± 0.09 2.59 ± 0.12
M4 0.77 ± 0.13 3.42 ± 0.16
[0.0] K1
K5
2.05 K7
1.87 K3
3.2 Hα
3.2 Hα
2 Hα
2 Hα
2 Hα
3.2 Hα
3.2 Hα
1 Hα
2.1 Hα
2.1 Hα
2 Hα
2 Hα
3.1 Hα
3.1 Hα
3.2 Hα
3.2 Hα
2 Hα
2
· · ·
3.2 Hα
3.2 Hα
1 Hα
1 Hα
2 Hα
2 Hα
2.1 Hα
2.1 Hα
3.2 Hα
3.2 Hα
2 Hα
2 Hα
2 Hα
2 Hα
2.1 Hα
2.1 Hα
42
21
184
10
10
10.9
6.2
74.
54.
97.
206
635.
57
124
15.
63.
60
· · ·
17
224
110
23
36.
59.
13
1
76
43.
21
32.
50.
12.5
21.7
147.
C 5
C 5
C 2
C 5
C 5
C 5
C 2
C 5
C 5
C 5
C 5
C 5
C 5
C 5
C 5
C 2
C 2
II
II
II
II
II
II
II W 5 passive
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
I
II W 2,5 passive
I
II
II Wc 5 passive
II
II
II
II W 5 passive
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
C 2
C 2
C 2
C 2
C 4
C 4
C 4
C 4
C 5
C 5
C 5
C 2,5
C 5
IRC
IRC
–
4
3
–
Table 4-Continued
Object
Component AV
aSpTy
Dereddened
Refb
line? EWHα
TT
Refb notes
K − L
K − [N ] MIR NIR
A
class type
UX Tau
HV Tau
DK Tau
WSB 26
WSB 18
V710 Tau
ROX 15d
A
B
A
B
C
A
B
A
B
NTTS155203-2338 A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
V853 Oph
DoAr 24E
HBC 411
DoAr 26
WSB 28
WSB 19
LkCa 3
AS 205
S CrA
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
[0.0]
0.35 K9
[0.0] K5
0.97 ± 0.04 3.99 ± 0.14
M1 1.02 ± 0.08 3.22 ± 0.15
0.76 ± 0.06 1.88 ± 0.12
M2 0.09 ± 0.06 0.67 ± 0.13
M5 0.38 ± 0.12 0.51 ± 0.11
[0.0] M0.5 0.44 ± 0.04 3.32 ± 0.11
M2.5 0.31 ± 0.04 0.29 ± 0.11
2.42 M2 0.07 ± 0.06 0.13 ± 0.14
0.73 ± 0.11 4.27 ± 0.17
0.52 ± 0.04 0.11 ± 0.06
0.08 ± 0.09 -0.27 ± 0.05
2.66 M2 0.15 ± 0.24 0.86 ± 0.21
M2.5 0.49 ± 0.09 2.48 ± 0.13
0.79 M0 0.70 ± 0.09 2.57 ± 0.14
M3 0.64 ± 0.08 3.77 ± 0.14
8.43 M3 0.37 ± 0.12 2.00 ± 0.10
M3 0.47 ± 0.08 1.75 ± 0.12
0.92 ± 0.15 3.35 ± 0.18
M3 0.88 ± 0.13 3.37 ± 0.19
1.68 M3 0.62 ± 0.05 4.02 ± 0.07
M5 0.36 ± 0.10 3.89 ± 0.12
0.45 ± 0.17 2.63 ± 0.18
1.62 ± 0.17 5.05 ± 0.15
1.64 M4 0.68 ± 0.26 2.41 ± 0.26
M6 0.10 ± 0.22 1.88 ± 0.22
3.28 M3 -0.13 ± 0.13 -0.07 ± 0.11
M7 0.02 ± 0.44 2.24 ± 0.36
1.40 ± 0.11 3.39 ± 0.12
M0 1.33 ± 0.13 3.67 ± 0.14
-0.02 ± 0.04 0.26 ± 0.11
-0.01 ± 0.05 0.07 ± 0.08
0.65 ± 0.05 3.41 ± 0.13
0.45 ± 0.09 2.36 ± 0.13
0.56 ± 0.04 2.26 ± 0.10
1.20 · · ·
· · ·
6.71 · · ·
· · ·
0.29 · · ·
4.75 K5
· · ·
0.41 K3
2.41 K5
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
13
13
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
2 Hα
2 Hα
2 Hα
2 Hα
2 Hα
2 Hα
2 Hα
1 Hα
1 Hα
1 Br γ
1 Br γ
1 Hα
1 Hα
1 Hα
1 Hα
1 Br γ
1 Br γ
1 Hα
1 Hα
1 Hα
1 Hα
1 Br γ
1 Br γ
1 Br γ
1 Br γ
1 Br γ
1 Br γ
1 Br γ
1 Br γ
1
· · ·
1
2
2
1
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
31
118.
9.5
4.5
8.5
69
7.2
4.3
15.
· · ·
· · ·
8.4
140
109
178
· · ·
· · ·
220
55
56
37
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
8,10
8,10
4
C
II
4
C
II
2
II
C
2
III W
2
III W
2
II
C
2
III W
2
III W
II
2
C
III W 10
III W 10
9
III W
9
C
II
9
C
II
II
C
9
C
II
C
II
C
II
C
II
II
C
C
II
C 8,10,15
II
C
I
II
C
II W 8,10 passive
III W
II W
C
II
II
C
III
III
II
II
II
8,10
8,10
passive
8
8
8
8
IRC
9
9
–
4
4
–
Table 4-Continued
Object Component AV
aSpTy
Dereddened
Refb
line? EWHα
TT
Refbnotes
K − L
K − [N ] MIR NIR
A
class type
B
SR 9 A
B
[0.0]
· · · 0.46 ± 0.07 2.17 ± 0.07
· · · 0.62 ± 0.03 2.81 ± 0.10
· · · 0.36 ± 0.07 2.95 ± 0.12
1
1
1
1
· · ·
1 Hα
1 Hα
· · ·
10.5
13.8
II
II
II
aAV is measured from photometry for combined system. Values given as [0.0] indicate an assumed
extinction of 0.0 mag in cases where J-H and H-K colors fall below the CTTS locus.
bReferences for K − L, K − N color, line emission and spectral type are 1 - This work; 2 - White
& Ghez (2001); 3 - Woitas et al. 2001b; 4 - Duchene et al. (1999); 5 - Hartigan & Kenyon (2003);
6 - Hartigan, Strom & Strom (1994); 7 - Kenyon et al. (1998); 8 - Prato, Greene & Simon (2003);
(1997); 10 - L. Prato, priv. comm; 11 - Mart´in (1998); 12 - Herbst,
9 - Brandner & Zinnecker
Koresko & Leinert (1995); 13 - Stanke & Zinnecker (2000); 14 - McCabe, Duchene & Ghez (2003);
15 - Doppmann, Jaffe & White (2003). If a reference is given as a fractional number, the unitary
number reference corresponds to the K band and the fractional part corresponds to the L-band.
cHartigan & Kenyon (2003) find an EW(Hα) = 23 ± 4 A, on the border between CTTS/WTTS.
Based on this, the lack of veiling and [O I] emission, and NIR excess, they define it to be a WTTS.
We use their classification here.
dROX 15 flickers in accretion; Prato et al.
(2003) see no Br γ in either component, whereas
Greene & Meyer (1995) and Luhman & Rieke (1999) do see Br γ in resolved system. Went with
C/C because system seen to be accreting at least on some occasions.
–
4
5
–
– 46 –
Table 5. Flux Densities of Calibrators
Name
OSCIR (Jy)
N
IHW18
8.8µm
LWS (Jy)
12.5µm
SiC
primary calibrators:
α Lyr
ρ Boo
γ Aql
α Boo
α Ari
β Peg
10 And
HD 27482
HD 1240
secondary calibrators:
α CrB
α CMi
α Sco
δ Sco
µ UMa
SAO90816
33.99
20.81
66.11
619.12
68.8
323.50
5.07
5.95
8.35
11.96
7.52
24.29
219.21
24.93
122.23
1.87
2.33
3.08
49.26
28.23
89.2
877.25
95.37
439.96
6.73
7.86
11.08
24.96
15.72
50.47
457.78
51.72
246.84
3.91
4.78
6.44
28.24
17.8
56.78
520.11
58.52
278.75
4.42
5.25
7.27
6.36 ± 0.6
3.3 ± 0.2
53.88 ± 0.58
4.24 ± 0.25
69.73 ± 5.38
[2269]
6.09 ± 0.9
[96.46]
1.35 ± 0.01
23.1 ± 0.6
[815.75]
2.89± 0.3
[34.02]
11.03 ± 0.9
3.56 ± 0.1
– 47 –
Table 6. Single Stars
Star
SpTy
Av
Observeda
EWHα
K − L
K − [N ]
refb
(A)
refb
Multiplicityb
reference
TT
class
type
Obs.
method
Notes
GM Aur
CW Tau
DS Tau
LkCa 15
BP Tau
GK Tau
AA Tau
DL Tau
GI Tau
CI Tau
DN Tau
IP Tau
DO Tau
DP Tau
DE Tau
DM Tau
FM Tau
DH Tau
V827 Tau
LkCa 4
HBC 374
V819 Tau
IQ Tau
LkCa 1
SR 4
ROX 7
ROX 44
K3
K3
K5
K5
K7
K7
K7
K7
K7
K7
M0
M0
M0
M0.5
M1
M1
M1
M2
K7
K7
K7
K7
M0.5
M4
K5
K7
K3
0.25
1.22
0.00
0.41
0.72
0.32
0.72
0.00
0.93
1.68
0.95
0.37
1.52
2.63
1.18
0.25
0.33
0.25
0.00
1.03
2.45
2.52
1.02
1.30
1.25
6.23
0.90
0.33 ± 0.06
1.20 ± 0.24
0.71 ± 0.08
0.57 ± 0.06
0.57 ± 0.23
0.85 ± 0.07
0.90 ± 0.12
1.21 ± 0.34
0.96 ± 0.18
0.90 ± 0.17
0.55 ± 0.22
0.89
1.21 ± 0.19
0.95 ± 0.29
0.97 ± 0.35
0.83 ± 0.18
0.70 ± 0.24
0.64 ± 0.05
0.10 ± 0.18
0.18
0.01 ± 0.16
0.21
0.96
0.07
0.84
0.29
0.77
3.63
3.33 ± 0.19
3.13
2.48
2.93 ± 0.29
3.21 ± 0.21
3.12 ± 0.19
3.43 ± 0.20
3.74 ± 0.08
3.36
2.53 ± 0.11
2.80
3.85 ± 0.17
3.80
2.85 ± 0.13
4.45
2.53
2.44 ± 0.79
0.31
0.08
0.30
0.61
3.1
0.54
3.29
<1.59
2.6
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
2,3
3
4
96
135
59
13
40
22
37
105
20
102
12
11
100
85
54
139
62
72
1.8
5
3
1.7
8
4
84
1.5
54
5
5
5
5
6
7
5
5
7
5
5
5
5
5
6
5
7
7
5
6
6
6
5
5
5
8
5
10
9,10
10
10
9
9
10
10
9,10
9,10
10
10
9,10
10
9
10
10
9
10
10
9,10
9,10
9,10
10
9,13
11
12,13
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
II
III
III
III
III
II
III
II
-
II
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
W
W
W
W
W
W
C
W
C
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle
speckle/lunar
speckle
speckle/lunar
passive
aUncertainties in the observed colors are given when available in the literature.
bSource: [1] - Kenyon & Hartmann (1995) [2] - Myers et al. (1987) [3] - Wilking, Lada & Young (1989) [4] - Rydgren, Strom & Strom
(1976) [5] - Herbig & Bell (1988) [6] - Strom & Strom (1994) [7] - Hartigan, Strom & Strom (1994) [8] - Bouvier & Appenzeller (1992)
[9] - Ghez et al. (1993); [10] - Leinert et al. (1993); [11] - Ageorges et al. (1997); [12] - Barsony et al. (2003); [13] - Simon et al. (1995)
– 48 –
Fig. 1.- Infrared colors for our sample. (left): The de-reddened K − L vs. K − [N] color
plane. The symbol type represents the accretion status: actively accreting (unfilled circle),
not accreting (filled circle), or accretion status unknown (triangle). The K − [N] color defi-
nitions for the different T Tauri classes are also shown, along with the K − L color limit used
to define whether the de-reddened color is in excess of that expected from a photosphere.
Of particular note is that 10% of the class II stars are not accreting (i.e., are passive disks)
and these systems, on average, have lower K − L colors than accreting class II stars. (right):
The de-reddened K-[N] vs. [N]-18 color plane, with symbol types same as in left panel.
Fig. 2.- The K−L vs K−[N] de-reddened color plane for a sample of single stars from White
& Ghez (2001) and Barsony et al.
(2003). Unfilled circles represent CTTS whereas filled
circles symbols represent WTTS. Of the 20 class II stars in the sample, 1 is not accreting,
corresponding to a 5% detection rate of passive disks in single stars, similar to that seen in
binary systems.
Fig. 3.- A histogram of the spectral types for all class II-CTTS stars in both our binary
star sample and single star sample is shown. For comparison, the distribution of spectral
types for the passive disk stars is overplotted (hatch-marked). All passive disks are found
around M type stars and a K-S test demonstrates that these two distributions are unlikely
to have been drawn from the same parent population.
– 49 –
– 50 –
– 51 –
|
astro-ph/9709098 | 1 | 9709 | 1997-09-10T19:29:36 | The Nature of the Activity in Hickson Compact Groups of Galaxies | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present the results of the spectral classification of the 82 brightest galaxies in a sample of 17 compact groups. We verify that the AGNs are preferentially located in the most early-type and luminous galaxies of the groups, as is usually observed in the field. But these AGNs also appear to be systematically concentrated towards the central parts of the groups. Our observations suggest a correlation between activity types, morphologies and densities of galaxies in the compact groups. This is consistent with a scenario in which galaxies of compact groups evolve by interacting with their environment and are currently in a quiet phase of their activity | astro-ph | astro-ph | The nature of the activity in Hickson compact groups of galaxies.
Roger Coziol1, Andr´e L. B. Ribeiro2
Reinaldo R. de Carvalho3
and
Hugo V.Capelato2
Received
;
accepted
7
9
9
1
p
e
S
0
1
1
v
8
9
0
9
0
7
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
1Laborat´orio Nacional de Astrof´ısica - LNA/CNPq, Rua Estados Unidos, 154, Bairros
das Na¸coes - 37500-000 - Itajub´a, MG, Brasil
2Divisao de Astrof´ısica - INPE/MCT, C.P. 515 - 12201-970 - S. Jos´e dos Campos, SP,
Brasil
3Observat´orio Nacional, Rua Gal. Jos´e Cristino, 77 - 20921-400 - Rio de Janeiro, RJ,
Brasil
-- 2 --
ABSTRACT
We present the results of the spectral classification of the 82 brightest
galaxies in a sample of 17 compact groups. We verify that the AGNs are
preferentially located in the most early -- type and luminous galaxies of the
groups, as is usually observed in the field. But these AGNs also appear to
be systematically concentrated towards the central parts of the groups. Our
observations suggest a correlation between activity types, morphologies and
densities of galaxies in the compact groups. This is consistent with a scenario in
which galaxies of compact groups evolve by interacting with their environment
and are currently in a quiet phase of their activity.
Subject headings: galaxies: Compact groups -- galaxies: Seyfert -- galaxies:
LINERs -- galaxies: interactions
-- 3 --
1.
Introduction
One of the important aspects of the study of the Hickson compact groups of galaxies
(HCGs; Hickson 1982) resides in the attractive possibility of assessing the effects of strong
interactions on the morphology and stellar content of galaxies (Hickson et al. 1992). The
available data on the HCGs however seems to present many contradictions with a fast
merging evolution scenario, suggesting that we still do not fully understand the nature
of these systems. To shed new light on this problem a new spectroscopic survey of faint
galaxies in the regions of Hickson compact groups was recently undertaken by de Carvalho
et al. (1997; see also Ribeiro et al. 1997) to determine the kinematical structure of the
groups. These studies show that HCGs exhibit a variety of dynamical configurations as
opposed to the previous view that they are all isolated and high density structures.
Spectroscopic observations of galaxies around HCGs not only allow to establish how
isolated these structures are from other structures but also yield valuable information on
the nature of the activity of the individual groups. Previous studies on the activity of the
galaxies in compact groups have led to contradictory conclusions. Recently, for example,
Sulentic & Raba¸ca (1993) and Vegnugopal (1995) contest the claim by Hickson et al.
(1989a) that the far infrared emission is enhanced in compact groups. Radio observations
(Menon, 1992,1995), optical spectroscopy and imaging (Rubin et al. 1991) all suggest
that tidal interactions and mergers between compact group galaxies did happen in the
past. However, many galaxies in the groups seem to be normal and it is not clear which
phenomenon, either starburst or AGN, is the main source of activity observed in the
groups. One extreme example of activities encountered in a compact group is HCG 16,
which includes one Seyfert 2 galaxy, two luminous LINER galaxies and 3 starburst galaxies
(Ribeiro et al 1996). But in a sample of 17 groups, HCG 16 is the only one of its kind,
which suggests that in general the activity in the groups is not prominent.
-- 4 --
In this contribution we present the results of our classification of the activity types of
a sample of luminous galaxies from 17 HCGs. We show that a significant fraction of these
galaxies display AGN activity. Moreover, 50% of the AGN population in the groups as
studied here are "low -- luminosity" AGNs (LLAGNs) -- that is, faint AGNs, either Seyfert 2
or LINER, which are hidden behind the strong stellar continuum of their host galaxy. We
also show that the AGN population always appears segregated towards the compact cores
(which generally encompass most of Hickson's original compact groups, Ribeiro et al. 1997)
whereas starburst galaxies tend to be distributed in their external parts.
The organization of the paper is as follows. In Section 2 we define our sample of
compact group galaxies and explain the criteria that we used to do our classification.
We also present the characteristics of the LLAGNs in our sample and show the results
of template subtraction, which is an essential part of the classification scheme. Section
2.1 presents the results of our classification of all the emission line galaxies following two
diagnostic diagrams of line ratios. A brief discussion on the low -- luminosity nature of the
LLAGNs follows in Section 2.2. In Section 3, we discuss the spatial and morphological
distribution of the active galaxies in the compact groups. We conclude, in Section 4, with
a brief digression on the significance of our findings for the understanding of the nature of
compact groups.
2. Spectral classification of the AGNs candidates
The spectra presented in this paper are part of a sample of 316 galaxies in the regions
of 17 HCGs which were observed by de Carvalho et al. (1997). The spectra were taken
at the 4m CTIO telescope using the ARGUS fiber -- fed spectrograph. The details of the
instrumental setup and data reduction are discussed by de Carvalho et al. (1997). In this
sample, 82 galaxies (of which only 67 are kinematically assigned to the groups: see de
-- 5 --
Carvalho et al. 1997) have spectra with sufficiently high S/N to allow a proper classification
of the activity type. Of these galaxies, 28 (34%) present only absorption lines and 54 (66%)
present both emission and absorption lines. In this article the non-emission line galaxies
are considered non -- active. A complete analysis of the absorption features in these galaxies
will be published elsewhere (Coziol et al. in preparation). This article is dedicated to the
classification of the emission -- line galaxies.
Luminous emission -- line galaxies are usually easy to identify and classify. These
galaxies are either starburst or AGN galaxies. For many galaxies in our sample, however,
the usual classification criteria cannot be applied directly, since they do not show any
emission lines (i.e. within the limits of our observations) with the exception of the
[N II]λ6584 line. Figure 1 shows the spectra for these galaxies. The great similarity of the
spectra suggests that either all these galaxies are of similar morphological type or they are
dominated by the same stellar populations. Trace of ionized gaz in early -- type spirals and
ellipticals was already observed before and it is generally suggested that a mild Seyfert or
LINER, that is a low -- luminosity AGN, could reside in the nuclei of all these galaxies (see
Filippenko & Sargent 1985, Phillips et al. 1986; hereafter PJDSB). Given the similarity
of the phenomenon observed here, we will provisionally call the subsample of the galaxies
displayed in figure 1 the LLAGNs candidates. The basic characteristics of the LLAGN
candidates are presented in Table 1. The numbers in columns 1 and 2 follow the numbering
used in de Carvalho et al. (1997) and the letters in column 3 correspond to the galaxies
in the Hickson (1982) list. Redshifts determined by de Carvalho et al. (1997) are listed in
column 4. The B luminosities, as taken from Hickson et al. (1989), are listed in column
5. The absolute magnitudes, presented in column 6, were determined assuming H0 = 75
km s−1 Mpc−1. In column 7 we give also the morphologies of the galaxies, as reported by
Mendes de Oliveira & Hickson (1994).
-- 6 --
In the LLAGN candidates, the presence of an intermediate-age stellar population
introduces strong Balmer absorption lines that interfere with the observation of faint
ionized regions. The problem of detecting and measuring weak emission lines atop a strong
stellar continuum has already been tackled by several groups of investigators in the past.
Subtraction of a template galaxy spectrum that has no comparable emission has proved
to be an effective technique. For our analysis we have taken advantage of having in hand
a significant number of absorption -- line galaxies, all observed under the same instrumental
conditions, in order to build such a template. The spectral characteristics of the galaxies
used as templates are remarkably similar to those of the LLAGN candidates. On average,
the difference between the velocity dispersion of the absorption lines of our template
galaxies and those of the LLAGN candidates is approximately 2 A, which is smaller than
our resolution (∼ 6A). Figure 2 shows the red part of the spectra of the LLAGN candidates
after template subtraction. Note the high [N II]λ6584/Hα ratios typical of AGNs.
The classification of the activity type of all the 54 emission-line galaxies in our sample
was determined after subtraction of a galaxy template. The emission -- lines were measured
by fitting gaussian profiles. Our classification is based on the characteristic line ratios
shown by galaxies of different activity classes (Baldwin et al. 1981; Veilleux & Osterbrock
1987). The emission -- line galaxies in our sample were separated into 3 groups: starburst
galaxies, AGNs and LLAGNs.
The first diagnostic diagram, presented in Figure 3, is the diagram of [N II]λ6584/Hα
vs.
[O III]λ5007/Hβ (Baldwin et al. 1981; Veilleux & Osterbrock 1987). The distinction
between AGN and starburst galaxies is based on the empirical separation proposed by
Veilleux & Osterbrock (1987). The separation between LINER and Seyfert 2 galaxies
corresponds to log([O III]λ5007/Hβ) ≤ 0.4, as proposed by Coziol (1996). The same
criterium is used to distinguish between the low -- excitation Starburst Nucleus Galaxies
-- 7 --
(SBNGs) and the high -- excitation HII galaxies. This diagnostic diagram confirms the AGN
nature of all our LLAGN candidates. It also indicates that the majority of these galaxies
are LINER galaxies.
To double check our classification we also examined the ratio [O I]λ6300/Hα. As
was shown by Baldwin et al. (1981), the presence and the strength of the [O I]λ6300 are
important factors in distinguishing between starburst galaxies and AGNs. This is because
this line is produced only in regions of partial ionization which are much more extended
in AGNs than in normal HII regions. For this reason the [O I] line is rarely observed
and is always weaker in starburst galaxies than in AGNs. In our sample, the [O I] line is
detected in 61% of the starburst galaxies, 88% of the LLAGNs and 60% of the AGNs. It is
interesting to note that the detection rate of [O I] in the starburst galaxies is much higher
than usually observed in other samples of starburst nucleus galaxies (generally of the order
of 40% or less; see Coziol et al. 1997).
In Figure 4, we present the diagnostic diagram of the ratio [O I]λ6300/Hα vs.
[O III]λ5007/Hβ. The vertical line is the [O I] strength limit as proposed by Baldwin et
al. (1981) to separate the starburst galaxies from the AGNs. This diagram confirms the
nature of the LLAGNs as determined using the previous diagnostic diagram. Only one
candidate (otherwise a seyfert galaxy) has an [O I] line with strength comparable to those of
starburst galaxies. Three other galaxies have values with error bars that cross the boundary
between the two activity classes. The fact that many starburst galaxies in our sample have
an unusually strong [O I] line is consistent with previous observations suggesting that a
small fraction of these galaxies show the simultaneous characteristics of an AGN and an
HII region (V´eron et al. 1996). Our result suggests that very few AGNs present the same
ambiguity.
In Table 2, we list the results of our classification. The name of the objects are the
-- 8 --
same as in Table 1. Columns 2, 3 and 4 give the ratios [O III]λ5007/Hβ, [N II]λ6584/Hα
and [O I]λ6300/Hβ respectively. The uncertainties in these ratios were determined using
Poisson statistics. In column 5, the different types of activity are described as: starburst
galaxies (SBNGs or HII), AGNs (Seyfert 2: Sy2 or LINER: LNR) and LLAGNs (dSy2 or
dLNR). Column 7 give the FWHM of the Hα line. It may be interesting to note that no
Seyfert 1 galaxies was found in the groups.
2.1. The low -- luminosity nature of the hidden AGNs
Rubin et al. (1991) already noted that all the elliptical and the S0 galaxies in the
HCGs have ionized gas. They also remarked that this phenomenon is commonly observed in
samples of early -- type galaxies (PJDSB). But because the emission is hidden in the strong
stellar continuum the nature of the activity in these galaxies was not clearly established.
The subtraction of a template galaxy allow us to construct two different diagnostic diagrams
which confirm the AGN nature of these objects. We will now verify that the AGNs in these
galaxies also have a low luminosity. This will be done by comparing our candidates with
the low-luminosity AGNs discovered by PJDSB.
Because we do not have the calibrated spectra of our candidates we cannot compare
their fluxes directly with those of luminous AGNs. To test our assumption we use instead
the EW of the [N II]λ6584 line, which, by definition, is proportional to the ratio of the flux
in the line divided by the stellar continuum near the line. In Figure 5 we compare the EW
of the [N II]λ6584 line as a function of the ratio [N II]λ6584/Hα for all the galaxies in our
sample with those of the low -- luminosity AGNs observed by PJDSB. A very clear pattern
is seen: the LLAGNs have higher [N II]λ6584/Hα ratios and lower EW([N II]λ6584) than
the luminous AGNs and the starburst galaxies. Most important, the values observed for
the LLAGNs are identical to those of the low -- luminosity AGNs as studied by PJDSB. It
-- 9 --
is important to realize that in this diagram there is only one way to obtain the lowest EW
value possible: the flux in the line must be low and the stellar continuum must be high. In
early-type galaxies, as in the galaxies of the sample of PJDSB and also in our candidates
(cf. figure 7), the stellar continuum is already near maximum, which means therefore that
the line flux in the galaxies of these two samples must be similar. PJDSB determined
that the characteristic Hα luminosity of the low -- luminosity AGN in their sample is of the
order of 1039 ergs s−1 or lower. Then, by comparison, the luminosity of the AGNs in our
candidates must be of the same order, which therefore confirms the low -- luminosity nature
of the AGNs in our objects.
3. Discussion
In Table 3 we present the fraction of each type of activity observed in our sample of
82 galaxies. The LLAGNs form more than 50% of the total AGN population found in the
whole sample. From the 82 galaxies studied here, only 67 galaxies are real group members
(de Carvalho et al. 1997). In Table 3 it can be seen that when only group members are
considered, the fraction of starburst galaxies drops and the fraction for the other types
slightly increases.
Going one step further, we can distinguish between the galaxies that reside in the
"core" and the "halo" of the groups. As discussed by Ribeiro et al. (1997) most of
HCG's are embedded in larger structures forming extended haloes around more dense
and dinamically distinct cores. As shown by Ribeiro et al. these cores may be usefully
defined as the circular region around the group baricenter having mean surface brightness
µB = 27 mag arcsec−2, which is almost the same limit used by Hickson (1982) as part of his
criteria for constructing his catalogue of compact groups. Table 4 shows how the 67 galaxies
in the groups distribute between the core (53 galaxies) and the halo (14 galaxies). It is
-- 10 --
important to note that nearly all the AGNs, that is the LLAGNs as well as the luminous
AGNs, reside in the core of the groups.
The fraction of each activity type encountered in the core regions is reported in Table
3. It can be seen that the fraction of starburst galaxies decreases significantly in the core of
the groups, where AGNs (47.2%) and non-emission line galaxies (37.7%) dominate. Because
the star formation rate in all of these galaxies is relatively low, we further conclude that the
star formation rate in the groups is generally at a low level.
Our sample is obviously biased towards galaxies which have high S/N ratios, therefore
favoring the most luminous galaxies in the groups. To verify how this bias affects our
conclusions on the spatial segregation of the different activity types in the groups, we
compare in Figure 6 the absolute magnitude of all the galaxies in our sample. In this
figure we can see that the luminosity distributions for the LLAGNs and the luminous
AGNs are clearly biased towards higher values. However Figure 6 also shows that both
the non emission -- line galaxies and the starburst galaxies show a comparable distribution
of luminosities. Since these two types of galaxies have different spatial locations in the
groups, we may conclude that the segregation of activity types in the groups is not due to
a luminosity bias but corresponds to a real physical effect. The fact that AGNs reside in
the most luminous galaxies of the groups is consistent with studies of AGNs in the field
which show that the probability of finding an AGN increases with the luminosity of the
host galaxy (PJDSB; Veilleux et al. 1995).
In Figure 7 we present the distribution of morphological types of all the galaxies in
our sample. The LLAGNs reside either in elliptical or early -- type spirals whereas the
luminous AGNs seem to reside mostly in early -- type spirals. Figure 7 also shows that all
the non-emission galaxies are early-type galaxies (E, S0 or Sa). Consequently, the LLAGNs
represent 36% (41% in the core) of the early -- type population in the groups. This result is
-- 11 --
consistent with the fraction of LLAGNs discovered by PJDSB in their sample of luminous
E and S0 galaxies.
4. Conclusion
We have shown that a significant fraction of the brightest galaxies of compact groups
display some sort of activity, either starburst or AGN. Moreover, we find that about half
of the AGN population is made of LLAGNs, implying that AGNs are the most frequent
activity types encountered in the groups.
We have further found that the AGNs -- both low -- luminosity and normal -- reside
in the most luminous galaxies of the groups and the most early-type ones. These two
characteristics are not unique to compact groups but are consistent with the fact that
the probability of finding an AGN increases with the luminosity of the galaxies and that
low -- luminosity AGNs are very common in early-type galaxies. However, we have also found
that the AGNs tend to concentrate in the cores of the groups. This may be viewed as a
consequence of the luminosity and/or a morphological segregation already found in the
groups (Ribeiro et al. 1997). In other words, we have discovered a high fraction of AGNs
in the cores of the groups because the most luminous and early-type galaxies are more
concentrated in the groups and because the probability of finding an AGN is higher in
luminous and early-type galaxies.
That the group produces some physical effects is even more obvious when we consider
the starburst galaxies: the fraction of starburst galaxies drops drastically when we go from
the halo to the core of the groups. It would be interesting to see if this behavior for the
starburst galaxies is due to a morphological bias. In Figure 7 we can see that the starburst
galaxies of our sample prefer late -- type spirals. Although suggestive, this result should be
-- 12 --
viewed with caution given the scarcity of the data for these galaxies (less than 20% of the
morphologies determined in our sample).
As it is, our discovery suggests that we do have, at least for the core, a sort of density --
morphology -- activity relation. This relation may be reminiscent of the density -- morphology
relation observed in denser agglomerations of galaxies. For the HCGs, this relation would
suggest that the galaxies in the groups have a common history and that their evolution was
influenced by their environment.
As a working hypothesis we propose the following scenario for galaxy evolution in the
HCGs. Massive galaxies form by subsequent mergers of smaller mass systems made of
gas and stars. Obviously, denser environments will accelerate this process and the more
massive galaxies will form first in the richest regions. The frequency and intensity of
mergers determine the morphologies, the most massive galaxies evolving towards the most
early -- type morphologies. This would explain why in HCGs the most luminous galaxies are
also the most concentrated and the most early -- type.
This formation scenario can incorporate a sequence where the activity level changes
with time. The first phase is characterized by a starburst and a Seyfert. Each merger
triggers a starburst. When the mass of the galaxy is sufficiently high or when a large
amount of gas is available, the gas falls into the center of the galaxy and form or nourish an
AGN. As the starburst fades, depending on the reservoir of gas available and on the rate of
accretion, it remains either a Seyfert or a LINER. Finally, when the matter available to feed
the AGN decreases, it remains a LLAGN or a normal galaxy. This scenario would explain,
for instance, the difference observed in the groups between the morphologies of the LLAGNs
and the luminous AGNs. It would also explain why the core of the groups are dominated by
a high fraction of LLAGNs and non -- active early -- type galaxies, since denser environments
accelerate the process. The galaxies in the cores of the groups are more evolved than in the
-- 13 --
outer regions. This would explain why starburst galaxies are observed in higher number in
the halo than in the core. This scenario may also explain why we do not find any Seyfert 1
galaxy in the core, as they would be visible only at the beginning of the process.
Following this scenario, most of the activity in HCGs would have taken place sometime
in the recent past, and the groups are now observed at a quiet phase of their activity.
We thank Natalie Stout for his careful reading of the manuscript. R. Coziol
acknowledges the financial support of FAPESP under contract 94/3005-0 (while working
at the Instit´uto Nacional de Pesquisas Espacias/INPE) and of CNPq, under contracts
360715/96-6 (NV). For his part, A.L.B. Ribeiro acknowledges the support of the Brazilian
CAPES.
-- 14 --
Table 1. Characteristics of the low -- luminosity AGNs
HCG # Hickson
Vo
B
MB
Hubble
id.
km s−1
Type
22 -- 1
22 -- 5
22 -- 6
23 -- 3
23 -- 5
40 -- 1
42 -- 1
62 -- 1
64 -- 1
67 -- 11
86 -- 1
86 -- 3
87 -- 1
87 -- 3
88 -- 1
88 -- 2
a
d
e
a
c
a
a
a
· · ·
· · ·
a
b
a
b
a
b
2681
9268
9611
4869
5373
6634
3712
4259
6264
6614
6013
5863
8436
8738
6007
6124
12.6
-20.2 E2
15.2
-20.3 E3
15.2
-20.3 E5
15.2
-18.8
Sab
16.1
-18.1
S0
14.3
-20.4 E3
12.6
-20.8 E3
13.3
-20.5 E3
13.8
-20.8
16.5
-18.2
· · ·
· · ·
14.2
-20.3 E2
14.8
-19.7 E2
14.8
-20.4
Sbc
15.4
-19.9
13.7
-20.8
S0
Sb
13.8
-20.8
SBb
-- 15 --
Table 2. Spectral characteristics of HCG's galaxies
HCG #
[OIII]λ50007
[NII]λ6548
Hβ
Hα
[OI]λ6300
Hα
Activity
FWHM
Type
(km s−1)
04 01
04 03
04 11
16 01
16 02
16 03
16 04
16 05
16 06
19 05
22 01
22 05
22 06
22 07
22 08
23 02
23 03
23 04
23 05
23 06
40 01
40 04
40 05
42 01
48 19
48 25
62 01
63 04
-0.26
-0.37
0.77
0.31 ± 0.02
0.58 ± 0.01
0.12 ± 0.01
-0.35
0.35 ± 0.01
-0.31
-0.32
-1.26
0.09
0.05
-0.35
-0.38
-0.22
-1.93
-1.61
-1.96
SBNG
SBNG
HII
-0.80 ± 0.04 LNR
-0.40 ± 0.01
Sy2
-1.56 ± 0.18
SBNG
-1.91 ± 0.13
SBNG
-1.14 ± 0.04 LNR
0.61 ± 0.03
-0.8 ± 0.1
-1.07 ± 0.31 HII
-0.12
-0.495
· · ·
SBNG
0.50 ± 0.03
0.03 ± 0.02
-0.9 ± 0.3
dSy2
0.50 ± 0.08
0.42 ± 0.02
-0.7 ± 0.4
dSy2
0.64 ± 0.08
0.23 ± 0.02
-0.7 ± 0.2
dSy2
-0.5 ± 0.1
-0.34 ± 0.02
· · ·
0.79
0.30
-0.25
0.47
-0.21
-0.11 ± 0.01
0.74
0.21
-0.39
-0.09
-0.50
0.0 ± 0.1
-0.06 ± 0.03
· · ·
· · ·
-0.11
-0.49
-1.78
SBNG
LNR?
Sy2
dLNR
SBNG
-2.0 ± 0.1
dSy2
· · ·
· · ·
SBNG
dLNR
0.1 ± 0.2
-0.19 ± 0.03
-0.9 ± 0.3
LNR
0.43 ± 0.05
-0.22 ± 0.02
· · ·
Sy2
· · ·
0.25 ± 0.01
-1.0 ± 0.5
dLNR
-0.29 ± 0.03
-0.54 ± 0.01
-1.4 ± 0.3
SBNG
0.36 ± 0.01
-0.96 ± 0.07
· · ·
SBNG
0.00 ± 0.05
-0.22 ± 0.01
-1.1 ± 0.2
dLNR
0.11 ± 0.04
-0.18 ± 0.01
· · ·
LNR
535
367
327
498
816
499
489
533
383
424
953
437
518
<360
533
716
542
480
796
356
560
730
776
765
392
366
795
588
-- 16 --
Table 2 -- Continued
HCG #
[OIII]λ50007
[NII]λ6548
Hβ
Hα
[OI]λ6300
Hα
Activity
FWHM
Type
(km s−1)
63 06
64 01
64 22
67 02
67 06
67 11
86 01
86 03
86 04
86 07
86 08
86 09
87 01
87 02
87 03
87 04
87 05
87 07
88 01
88 02
88 07
90 01
90 04
90 09
97 05
97 06
-0.49 ± 0.06
-0.36 ± 0.01
· · ·
SBNG
0.07 ± 0.05
0.42 ± 0.03
-0.8 ± 0.7
dLNR
-0.23 ± 0.08
-0.48 ± 0.02
-1.1 ± 0.2
SBNG
-0.15 ± 0.07
-0.47 ± 0.03
-0.16 ± 0.04
-0.43 ± 0.03
· · ·
· · ·
SBNG
SBNG
0.07 ± 0.14
0.71 ± 0.09
0.3 ± 0.2
dLNR
-0.40 ± 0.19
-0.21 ± 0.06
-0.6 ± 0.2
dLNR
0.95 ± 0.02
-0.08 ± 0.01
-1.1 ± 0.3
dSy2
0.17 ± 0.03
-0.15 ± 0.01
-0.83 ± 0.09
LNR
1.16 ± 0.01
0.09 ± 0.01
-0.37 ± 0.03
Sy2
-0.35 ± 0.04
-0.47 ± 0.01
-1.5 ± 0.2
SBNG
-0.10 ± 0.04
-0.66 ± 0.03
· · ·
SBNG
0.08
-0.34
-0.35
-0.38
0.31
-0.08
0.48
0.18
0.10
-0.08
-0.42
0.11
-0.36
-0.60
-0.42
-0.05
0.28
-0.49
-0.500± 0.001
dLNR
-1.75 ± 0.01
SBNG
· · ·
-0.76
-1.14
-1.65
-1.00
-1.11
· · ·
dLNR
SBNG
SBNG
SBNG
dSy2
dLNR
SBNG
0.97± 0.02
0.08 ± 0.01
-1.3 ± 0.8
Sy2
0.02± 0.07
-0.20 ± 0.01
-1.1 ± 0.2
LNR
0.21± 0.01
-0.61 ± 0.03
-1.4 ± 0.5
SBNG
0.23± 0.06
-0.28 ± 0.04
0.40± 0.04
-0.26 ± 0.03
· · ·
· · ·
LNR
Sy2
512
701
368
658
354
677
402
947
977
728
352
763
601
522
508
<360
358
499
704
517
231
470
441
359
397
394
-- 17 --
Table 3. Fraction of activity types
all
in group
in core
No of Galaxies
82
67
53
No emission
LLAGNs
AGNs
Starbursts
34%
20%
18%
28%
37.3%
37.8%
20.9%
24.5%
19.5%
22.6%
22.3%
15.1%
-- 18 --
Table 4. Classification of activity type
HCG
core
halo
#
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
04
16
19
22
23
40
42
48
62
63
64
67
86
87
88
90
97
· · ·
1a, 2b, 5d
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
4d,5e
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
4a
· · ·
· · ·
4c
4c
· · ·
1a, 4d
5, 6b
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
1a
3a, 5c
1a
1a
· · ·
1a
· · ·
1
· · ·
1a, 3b
1a
3, 4c
· · ·
· · ·
4d
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
2b
· · ·
1a, 3b
2, 5
· · ·
· · ·
1a
3, 4b
· · ·
2b
2b, 4c
1a
2b, 3c, 4
· · ·
· · ·
1a, 3
6d
· · ·
· · ·
2b, 3c, 6
7
9
1a, 2b
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
2, 4c, 3d
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
7
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
11
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
6
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
25
· · ·
6
22
6
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
8
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
8, 9
2,10
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
10, 11
Activity types: (1) = AGN; (2) = LLAGN; (3) = HII-SBNG; (4) = no emission.
-- 19 --
REFERENCES
Allam, S., Assendorp, R., Longo, G., Braun, M., Richter, G. 1996, A&A, 117, 39
Baldwin, J. A., Phillips, M. M., Terlevich, R. 1981, PASP, 93, 5
Coziol, R. 1996, A&A, 309, 345
Coziol, R., Contini, T., Davoust, E., Consid`ere, S. 1997, ApJ, 481, 67
de Carvalho, R. R., Ribeiro, A. L. B., Capelato, H. V., Zepf, S. E. 1997, ApJS, 110, 1
Ebeling, H., Voges, W., Boehringer, H. 1994, ApJ, 436, 44
Filippenko, A. V., Sargent, W. L. W. 1985, ApJS, 57, 503
Hickson, P. 1982, ApJ, 255, 382
Hickson, P., Menon, T. K., Palumbo, G. G. C., Persic, M., 1989a, ApJ, 341, 679
Hickson, P., Kindl, E., Auman, J. R. 1989b, ApJ70, 687
Hickson, P., Mendes de Oliveira, C.M., Huchra, J.P., and Palumbo, G.G.C. 1992, ApJ, 399,
353
Mendes de Oliveira, C., Hickson, P. 1994, ApJ, 427, 684
Menon, K. 1992, MNRAS, 255, 41
Menon, K. 1995, MNRAS, 274, 845
Phillips, M. M., Jenkins, C. R., Dopita, M. A., Sadler, E. M., Binette, L 1986, AJ, 91, 1062
Ponman, T. J., Bourner, P. D. J., Ebeling, H., Boehringer, H. 1996, MNRAS, 283, 690
Ribeiro, A. L. B., de Carvalho, R. R., Coziol, R., Capelato, H. V. & Zepf, S. E. 1996, ApJ,
463, 5
Ribeiro, A. L. B., de Carvalho, R. R., Capelato, H. V., Zepf, S. E. 1997, ApJ, submitted
Rubin, V. C., Ford, W. K. Jr., Hunter, D. A. 1991, ApJS, 76, 153
-- 20 --
V´eron, P., Gon¸calves, A. C., V´eron -- Cetty, M.-P. 1997, A&A, 319, 52
Vegnugopal, V. R. 1995, MNRAS, 277, 455
Veilleux, S., Osterbrock, D. E. 1987, ApJS, 63, 295
Veilleux, S., Kim, D. -C., Sanders, D. B., Mazzarella, J. M., Soifer, B. T. 1995, ApJS, 98,
171
This manuscript was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v4.0.
-- 21 --
Fig. 1. -- Optical spectra of the LLAGN candidates. The spectra are in the rest frame of the
object. The flux scale was normalized to one and the spectra are shifted for presentation.
Note the similarity of all the spectra. Nuclear activity is suggested by the presence of the
Nitrogen emission line ([NII]λ6584).
Fig. 2. -- The spectra of the LLAGN candidates after subtraction of a template galaxy. The
galaxies are shown in the same order as in Fig. 1. The ratios [NII]λ6584/Hα are high and
[OI]λ6300 is detected in almost all the galaxies.
Fig.
3. -- Diagnostic diagram of emission -- line ratio and classification of the different
activity of our sample of emission -- line galaxies The dot-dashed line at log([OIII]/Hβ) =
0.4 establishes a distinction between Seyfert 2 and LINERs (Coziol 1996). The solid line
indicates the empirical separation between starburst galaxies and AGNs as determined by
Veilleux and Osterbrock (1987).
Fig. 4. -- Second diagnostic diagram of emission -- line ratios. The vertical dashed line at
log([OI]/Hα) = 1.3 establishes a distinction between Starbursts and AGNs (Baldwin et al.
1981).
Fig. 5. -- Equivalent widths (EW) of the [NII]λ6584 line vs. its strength in comparison to
Hα. The LLAGN possess a high ratio of [NII]λ6584/Hα and a low EW. The values for the
LLAGN candidates in our sample are the same as those of the LLAGN studied by Phillips
et al. (1986).
Fig. 6. -- Distribution of the luminosities of the galaxies with different activity types in
our sample. The AGNs are located in the most luminous galaxies of the groups, but the
starbursts and the non emission galaxies show comparable luminosities. The low fraction of
starburst observed in the core cannot be explain by a luminosity bias.
-- 22 --
Fig. 7. -- Distribution of the morphologies of the galaxies with different activity type in our
sample. The LLAGNs and the non emission line galaxies are located in the most early -- type
galaxies of the groups. The luminous AGNs are mostly early -- type spirals.
5.0
4.5
4.0
3.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
s
t
n
u
o
c
d
e
z
i
l
a
m
r
o
N
64.1
62.1
42.1
40.1
23.5
23.3
22.6
22.5
22.1
β
H
Mg
NaI
α
H [NII]
4000
4500
5000
5500
λ (A)
o
6000
6500
Fig. 1
4.5
4.0
3.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
s
t
n
u
o
c
d
e
z
i
l
a
m
r
o
N
88.2
88.1
87.3
87.1
86.3
86.1
67.11
β
H
Mg
NaI
α
H [NII]
4000
4500
5000
5500
λ (A)
o
6000
6500
Fig. 1 (Continue)
1.4
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
s
t
n
u
o
c
d
e
z
i
l
a
m
r
o
N
[OI]
6300
88.2
88.1
87.3
87.1
86.3
86.1
67.11
6400
6500
o
λ (A)
[NII]
[NII]
α
H
6600
Fig. 2 (Continue)
1.2
0.8
0.4
HII
0.0
SBNG
-0.4
/
)
β
H
7
0
0
5
λ
]
I
I
I
O
[
(
g
o
L
-1.0
-0.6
Seyfert 2
LINER
AGNs
LLAGNs
Starbursts
-0.2
0.2
Log([NII]λ6584/Hα)
0.6
1.0
Fig. 3
Starburst
AGN
/
)
β
H
7
0
0
5
λ
]
I
I
I
O
[
(
g
o
L
1.2
0.8
0.4
0.0
-0.4
-2.0
-1.6
-1.2
-0.8
Log([OI]λ6300/Hα)
-0.4
Fig. 4
LLAGNs (PJDSB)
AGNs
LLAGNs
Starbursts
)
4
8
5
6
λ
]
I
I
N
[
(
W
E
g
o
L
1.6
1.2
0.8
0.4
0.0
-1.2
-0.8
0.0
-0.4
0.4
Log(NII/Hα)
0.8
1.2
Fig. 5
a)
Low lum. AGN
AGN
-22
-21 -20
-19 -18
MB
-17 -16
b)
No emission
Starbursts
N
N
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
-22
-21 -20
-19 -18
MB
-17 -16
Fig. 6
a)
Low lum. AGN
AGN
-5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Hubble type T
b)
No emission
Starbursts
N
N
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
-5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Hubble type T
Fig. 7
1.6
1.4
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
s
t
n
u
o
c
d
e
z
i
l
a
m
r
o
N
[OI]
6300
64.1
62.1
42.1
40.1
23.5
23.3
22.6
22.5
22.1
6400
6500
o
λ (A)
[NII]
[NII]
α
H
6600
Fig. 2
|
astro-ph/9609035 | 1 | 9609 | 1996-09-05T04:31:23 | Resonant Spin-Flavor Conversion of Supernova Neutrinos and Deformation of the Electron Antineutrino Spectrum | [
"astro-ph",
"hep-ph"
] | The neutrino spin-flavor conversion of \bar\nu_e and \nu_\mu which is induced by the interaction of the Majorana neutrino magnetic moment and magnetic fields in the collapse-driven supernova is investigated in detail. We calculate the conversion probability by using the latest precollapse models of Woosley and Weaver (1995), and also those of Nomono and Hashimoto (1988), changing the stellar mass and metallicity in order to estimate the effect of the astrophysical uncertainties. Contour maps of the conversion probability are given for all the models as a function of neutrino mass squared difference and the neutrino magnetic moment times magnetic fields. It is shown that in the solar metallicity models some observational effects are expected with \Delta m^2 = 10^{-5}--10^{-1} [eV^2] and \mu_\nu >~ 10^{-12} (10^9 G / B_0) [\mu_B], where B_0 is the strength of the magnetic fields at the surface of the iron core. We also find that although the dependence on the stellar models or stellar mass is not so large, the metallicity of precollapse stars has considerable effects on this conversion. Such effects may be seen in a supernova in the Large or Small Magellanic Clouds, and should be taken into account when one considers an upper bound on \mu_\nu from the SN1987A data. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
UTAP-233/96
RESCEU-15/96
Resonant Spin-Flavor Conversion of Supernova Neutrinos
Deformation of the Electron Antineutrino Spectrum
and
Tomonori Totani1 and Katsuhiko Sato1,2
1Department of Physics, School of Science, The University of Tokyo,
7-3-1 Hongo, Tokyo 113, Japan.
e-mail: [email protected]
2Research Center for the Early Universe, School of Science, The University of Tokyo,
7-3-1 Hongo, Tokyo 113, Japan.
Abstract
The neutrino spin-flavor conversion of ¯νe ↔ νµ which is induced by the inter-
action of the neutrino magnetic moment and magnetic fields in the collapse-driven
supernova is investigated in detail. We calculate the conversion probability by us-
ing the latest precollapse models of Woosley and Weaver (1995), and also those of
Nomono and Hashimoto (1988), changing the stellar mass and metallicity in or-
der to estimate the effect of the astrophysical uncertainties. Contour maps of the
conversion probability are given for all the models as a function of neutrino mass
squared difference over neutrino energy (∆m2/Eν ) and the neutrino magnetic mo-
ment times magnetic fields (µνB). The expected deformation of the ¯νe spectrum can
be clearly seen from these maps, and some qualitative features which will be useful
in the future observation are summarized. It is shown that in the solar metallicity
models some observational effects are expected with ∆m2 = 10−5 -- 10−1 [eV2] and
µν >
∼ 10−12(109G/B0) [µB], where B0 is the strength of the magnetic fields at the
surface of the iron core, and B0 = 109 [Gauss] is a reasonable value which is inferred
from the observed magnetic fields in white dwarfs. We also find that although the
dependence on the stellar models or stellar mass is not so large, the metallicity of
In lower metallicity
precollapse stars has considerable effects on this conversion.
stars, strong precession between ¯νe and νµ occurs with small ∆m2/Eν (<
∼ 10−8
[eV2/MeV]), and conversion probability changes periodically with B0. Such effects
may be seen in a supernova in the Large or Small Magellanic Clouds, and should be
taken into account when one considers an upper bound on µν from the SN1987A
data.
1
I. INTRODUCTION
Copious neutrino emission from collapse-driven supernovae attracts significant attention because
it provides rich information not only on the mechanism of supernovae but also on the neutrino
physics through a number of events captured in some underground neutrino detectors, such as
the Super-Kamiokande (SK) [1]. The most noteworthy subject on the nature of neutrinos is the
mass of neutrinos and oscillations between different flavors induced by the mass difference. How-
ever, the ordinary matter oscillation (well known as the MSW effect [2]) has its effect only on
neutrinos but not on antineutrinos under the direct mass hierarchy, and the vacuum oscillation
is not observable unless the mixing angle is unnaturally large compared with that of the quark
sector. In this case, electron antineutrinos (¯νe's), which is the most detectable in a water Cerenkov
detector, do not undergo any oscillation. One of some possibilities that ¯νe's would oscillate or be
converted into other species of neutrinos is the neutrino magnetic moment. If the neutrinos have
a nonvanishing magnetic moment, it couples the left- and right-handed neutrinos, and interaction
with sufficiently strong magnetic fields induces the precession between neutrinos with different
chiralities in the inner region of the collapse-driven supernova [3,4]. In general, non-diagonal ele-
ments of the magnetic moment matrix are possible, and neutrinos can be changed into different
flavors by this flavor changing moment [5]. Furthermore, with the additional effect of the coherent
forward scattering by dense matter in the collapsing star, neutrinos can be resonantly converted1
into neutrinos with different chiralities [6 -- 11] by the mechanism similar to the MSW effect. This
resonant spin-flavor conversion induced by the neutrino magnetic moment may drastically deform
the spectrum of electron antineutrinos (¯νe's) in the water Cerenkov detectors. The earlier publica-
tions have shown that in the future experiment this effect will be observable with inner magnetic
fields of some reasonable strength, if there is a magnetic moment a little smaller than the current
astrophysical upper limits from the argument of the stellar cooling due to the plasmon decay2:
µν <
∼ 10−11 -- 10−10µB, where µB is the Bohr magneton [12,13]. The magnetic moment of neu-
trinos in the standard electro-weak theory with small neutrino masses is very small due to the
chirality suppression; for example, the standard SU(2)L×U(1) model with a singlet right-handed
neutrino gives µν ∼ 3×10−19(mν /1eV)µB, far below the experimental/astrophysical upper bounds
[4,14 -- 16]. However, some particle-physics models [17,18] have been proposed in order to give a
large magnetic moment of ∼ 10−11µB which would explain [19 -- 21] the anticorrelation between
the time variability of the solar neutrino flux and the sun spot numbers suggested in the 37Cl
experiment [22]. (The anticorrelation in the Cl experiment, however, has not yet been statistically
settled.) Therefore, the influence of a large magnetic moment on various physical or astrophysical
phenomena including collapse-driven supernovae deserves more detailed investigation. Discovery
of a large magnetic moment of neutrinos indicates that there exist interactions which violate the
chirality conservation beyond the standard theory.
In this paper, the resonant spin-flavor conversion between right-handed ¯νe's and left-handed
1The precession itself is suppressed by the matter potential.
2This constraint refers to the norm of the neutrino magnetic moment matrix, (Pi,j µij 2)1/2, i.e., this
includes the flavor changing moment.
2
mu or tau neutrinos (νµ or ντ 's) is studied assuming that the neutrino is the Majorana particle.
In general, the matter potential suppresses the interaction of the magnetic moment and magnetic
fields because of the generated difference of the energy levels. However, Athar et al. [11] pointed out
that the resonant conversion of this mode (¯νe ↔ νµ) occurs quite effectively in the region above the
iron core and below the hydrogen envelope of collapsing stars, namely, in the O+Si, O+Ne+Mg,
O+C, and He layers (hereafter referred to 'the isotopically neutral region'). The reason is that
the effective matter potential for the ¯νe ↔ νµ mode is given in the form proportional to the value
of (1 − 2Ye), where Ye is the electron number fraction per nucleon, and Ye is very close to 0.5 in
this region (typically, (1 − 2Ye) ∼ 10−4 -- 10−3); the matter effect is therefore strongly suppressed
compared with the magnetic interaction, and the adiabaticity condition becomes considerably less
stringent. Athar et al. [11] have shown that assuming µν(= µ¯νeνµ ) ∼ 10−12µB, this resonant
conversion would occur with some reasonable assumptions about magnetic fields in a star. We also
consider µν around this value3.
In order to judge the deformation of an observed ¯νe spectrum as the evidence of the existence
of the neutrino magnetic moment, it is necessary that the conversion probability is calculated
with high accuracy in a wide range of some parameters such as the mass of neutrinos or the
magnetic fields. However, only rough estimates or demonstrations in some cases are given in the
earlier publications and the relation between the shape of the deformed spectrum and the physical
parameters has not yet been clarified. Therefore we make the contour maps of the conversion
probability of ¯νe ↔ νµ for some used models of precollapse stars as a function of the two parameters:
∆m2/Eν and µνB0, where ∆m2 is the neutrino mass squared difference, Eν the neutrino energy,
and B0 the magnetic field at the surface of the iron core. The expected observational effects can
be clearly understood by these maps. Some examples of spectral deformation are also calculated
and qualitative features which will be useful for the future observation are summarized by using
these maps.
It is apparent that the deviation of the value of Ye from 0.5 in the isotopically neutral region is
quite important, and this value is strongly dependent on the isotopic composition. Since almost
all nuclei in the isotopically neutral region are symmetric in the number of neutrons and protons,
this deviation is determined by rarely existent nuclei and the accurate estimate of this deviation is
quite difficult. Therefore, the astrophysical uncertainty in (1 − 2Ye) should be discussed. We use
the latest 15 and 25 M⊙ precollapse models of Woosley and Weaver (hereafter WW) [25] which
include no less than 200 isotopes. Such a large number of isotopes have never been used previously
in the calculation of (1 − 2Ye). It is also expected that this value strongly depends on the stellar
metallicity, and hence we use the WW models with the two different metallicities: the solar and
zero metallicity, and the metallicity effect is investigated. Also the models of 4 and 8 M⊙ helium
core of Nomoto & Hashimoto [26] (hereafter NH) are used, which correspond approximately to 15
and 25 M⊙ main sequence stars, and the model dependence of (1 − 2Ye) is discussed.
3There is a further stringent constraint on the transition magnetic moment of massive neutrinos from
observation of the 21-cm (hyperfine) radiation from neutral hydrogen gas in external galaxies: µν ≤
1.7 × 10−15 for the neutrino masses above 30 eV [23,24]. However, we consider only the range of ∆m2 <
∼ 1
[eV2] and this upper bound does not constrain our analysis.
3
We consider ∆m2 smaller than about 1 [eV2], therefore the resonance occurs above the surface of
the iron core. The resonance in the iron core and its implications on the dynamics of the supernova
considered in a recent preprint [27] are not discussed here. The global structure of magnetic field is
assumed to be a dipole moment, and the strength of the magnetic field is normalized at the surface
of the iron core with the values of 108 -- 1010 [Gauss], which are inferred from the observation of the
magnetic fields on the surface of white dwarfs. Throughout this paper, we consider the conversion
between two generations for simplicity. Because νµ and ντ can be regarded as identical particles
in the collapse-driven supernova, our results also apply to the conversion of ¯νe ↔ ντ . Derivation of
the equation which describes the propagation of neutrinos and evolution of conversion probability
is given in section II, and the profile of the effective matter potential and magnetic fields are
given in section III by using the precollapse models of massive stars. Qualitative features of
the conversion are also discussed in this section. Numerical results are given in section IV, and
spectral deformation is also discussed. Discussion and conclusions are given in sections V and VI,
respectively.
II. FORMULATIONS
The interaction of the magnetic moment of neutrinos and magnetic fields is described as
< (νi)RHint(νj )L >= µijB⊥ ,
(1)
where µij is the magnetic moment matrix, B⊥ the magnetic field transverse to the direction of
propagation, (ν)R and (ν)L the right- and left-handed neutrinos, respectively, and i and j denote
the flavor eigenstate of neutrinos, i.e., e, µ, and τ . The magnetic moment interacts only with
transverse magnetic fields. If neutrinos are the Dirac particles, right-handed neutrinos and left-
handed antineutrinos do not interact with matter and therefore undetectable. The conversion into
these sterile neutrinos due to the magnetic moment suffers strong constraints from the observation
of neutrinos from SN1987A by the Kamiokande II [28] and IMB [29], and also from the argument
on energy transportation in the collapse-driven supernova [8,10,30 -- 33]. On the other hand, if
neutrinos are the Majorana particles, as assumed in this paper, νR's are antineutrinos and interact
with matter, and the constraint becomes considerably weak. The diagonal magnetic moment is
forbidden for the Majorana neutrinos, and therefore only the conversion between different flavors
is possible, e.g., (¯νe)R ↔ (νµ,τ )L. As mentioned in introduction, we investigate this mode because
the conversion of this mode occurs quite effectively in the isotopically neutral region and also ¯νe's
are most easily detected in the water Cerenkov detectors.
In dense matter of the collapsing stars, the coherent forward scattering by matter leads to
the effective potential for neutrinos, and this potential for each type of neutrinos is determined
according to the weak interaction theory. The potential due to scattering with electrons is given
as (including both the charged- and neutral-current interactions)
V = ±
√2 GF (±
1
2
+ 2 sin2 θW ) ne ,
(2)
where ne is the number density of electrons, GF the Fermi coupling constant, and θW the Weinberg
angle. The ± sign in the parentheses refers to νe (+) and νµ,τ (−), and that in front to ν (+)
4
and ¯ν (−). In the ordinary flavor oscillation (νe ↔ νµ,τ ), the effective potential is only due to
the charged-current scattering by electrons because the effect of neutral-current interactions is the
same for all flavors. However, we have to consider the neutral-current interaction in the conversion
of ν and ¯ν, because of the opposite signs of the potential. Therefore the neutral-current scattering
by nucleons should also be included, that is
V = ±
√2 GF (
1
2 − 2 sin2 θW ) np ∓
√2 GF
1
2
nn ,
(3)
where np is the number density of protons, nn that of neutrons. The ± or ∓ signs refer to ν
(upper) and ¯ν (lower) for all three flavors of neutrinos. We do not have to consider the form factor
of nuclei because the relevant interaction is forward scattering and there is no momentum transfer.
The isotopically neutral region is far beyond the neutrino sphere and neutrinos go out freely in this
region; hence we do not have to consider the neutrino-neutrino scattering. By using the charge
neutrality, the difference of the potentials for ¯νe's and νµ's (or ντ 's) which we are interested in is
as follows:
∆V ≡ V¯νe − Vνµ = √2GF ρ/mN (1 − 2Ye) ,
(4)
where ρ is the density, mN the mass of nucleons, and Ye = np/(np + nn). Now the time evolution
of the mixed state of ¯νe and νµ is described by the following Schrodinger equation:
i
and ∆H is defined as:
d
dr ¯νe
νµ ! = 0
µν B⊥ ∆H ! ¯νe
νµ ! ,
µν B⊥
∆H ≡
∆m2
2Eν
cos 2θ − ∆V ,
(5)
(6)
2−m2
where Eν is the energy of neutrinos, ∆m2 = m2
1, θ the angle of the vacuum generation mixing,
and r the radius from the center of the star. Here we consider only ¯νe and νµ, but this equation
is actually a truncation of the original 4-component (νe, νµ, and antineutrinos) equation (see ref.
[6]). The neutrino masses, m1 and m2 are those in the mass eigenstates (m2 > m1). The direct
mass hierarchy is assumed here and therefore ∆m2 is positive. The other terms have their standard
meanings and the units of c = ¯h = 1 are used. Also note that we can subtract an arbitrary constant
times the unit matrix from the Hamiltonian, which does not affect the probability amplitudes. In
the MSW flavor oscillation, there appears the term of generation mixing, ∆m2 sin 2θ/4Eν, in the
off-diagonal elements of the Hamiltonian; however, this term does not appear in this spin-flavor
conversion between neutrinos and antineutrinos.
In the following, µν and cos 2θ are set to be
10−12µB and 1, respectively, and the scaling of B or ∆m2 with respect to other values of µν or
cos 2θ is obvious. The resonant spin-flavor conversion occurs when the difference of the diagonal
elements in the Hamiltonian vanishes, and hence the resonance condition is given as ∆H = 0. By
using this equation, the probability of conversion can be calculated provided that ρ(r), Ye(r), and
B⊥(r) are known.
5
III. ASTROPHYSICAL ASPECTS
A. Effective Matter Potential
In this section, we consider the effective matter potential in the isotopically neutral region. The
value of (1 − 2Ye) which we are interested in is easily calculated as:
Ye −
1
2
=Xi (cid:18) Zi
Ai −
1
2(cid:19) Xi ,
(7)
where Zi, Ai, and Xi are the atomic number, mass number, and the mass fraction of the i-th
In order to get
isotope, respectively, and the subscript i runs over all isotopes with 2Z 6= A.
this value and the density profiles, the precollapse models of massive stars of Woosley & Weaver
(WW) [25] and Nomoto & Hashimoto (NH) [26] are used. We assume that the dynamical effect
can be ignored within the time scale of the neutrino emission, and hence use the above static
models. The mass and radius of the helium core of a 15M⊙ main sequence star is ∼ 4M⊙ and
∼ 1R⊙, respectively, and its free-fall time scale, (√Gρ)−1 is ∼ 102 -- 103 [sec], which is longer than
the neutrino emission time scale (at most a few tens of seconds). It takes about several tens of
seconds for the shock wave generated at the core bounce to reach the hydrogen envelope [25], and
the inner region of the isotopically neutral region may be disturbed by the shock wave. We will
discuss about this in section V. The calculation of the WW models of 15 and 25 M⊙ (hereafter
WW15 and WW25, respectively) includes 200 isotopes, up to 71Ge. Although the network of 19
isotopes is used for energy generation up to the end of oxygen burning, the network of 200 isotopes
is updated in each cycle and mixed using the same diffusion coefficients. The NH models are 4
and 8 M⊙ helium cores (hereafter NH4 and NH8, respectively) corresponding approximately to 15
and 25 M⊙ main sequence stars. Their calculation includes 30 isotopes up to the end of oxygen
burning, which are also used for the energy generation. The WW and NH models use the different
reaction rates of 12C(α, γ)16O, and the treatment of convection is also different. As for the WW
models, we use the models with two different metallicities: the solar and zero metallicity, and the
metal abundance of the NH models is that of the Sun.
By using the data of composition as well as the density profile of the solar metallicity WW
models (WW15S and WW25S, where 'S' denotes the solar metallicity), ∆V in the WW15S and
WW25S models are depicted in Figs. 1 and 2, respectively, by the thick solid lines as a function of
the radius from the center of the star. Also shown by the dashed lines is ∆H when ∆m2/Eν is
10−4 and 10−6 [eV2/MeV]. The dominantly existent nuclei are also indicated for each layer in the
top of these figures. In the neutronized iron core, Ye is smaller than 0.5, and ∆V is positive and
much larger than ∆m2/Eν unless ∆m2/Eν is larger than 10−1 [eV2/MeV]. We consider the range of
∆m2/Eν below this value, and hence the resonance does not occur in the iron core. Above the iron
core, i.e., in the isotopically neutral region, Ye becomes quite close to 0.5 (still Ye < 0.5) and ∆V
is strongly suppressed, typically by a factor of ∼ 10−3 in solar metallicity stars, and the term µνB
becomes more effective. This suppression continues to the end of the isotopically neutral region,
namely, just below the hydrogen envelope. The isotopically neutral region is roughly divided into
the four layers: O+Si, O+Ne+Mg, O+C, and He layer, from inner to outer region. The values of
(1− 2Ye) and some nuclei which are relevant to the deviation of Ye from 0.5 are tabulated in Table
6
I for each layer and for the six precollapse models used in this paper. For the solar metallicity
models, (1 − 2Ye) is determined mainly by the isotopes such as 22Ne, 25,26Mg, 27Al, 34S, 38Ar, and
so on.
The resonance occurs when ∆V becomes smaller than ∆m2/2Eν, and after the resonance (above
If the
the resonance layer) ∆H becomes constant with radius because ∆V is negligibly small.
strength of the magnetic field is sufficiently strong for the satisfaction of the adiabaticity condition
at the resonance layer, the neutrinos are resonantly converted into the other helicity state. The
magnetic fields and the adiabaticity condition are discussed in the following subsection. The
resonance layer is in the isotopically neutral region if ∆m2/Eν is in the range of roughly 10−10 --
10−1 [eV2/MeV] (slightly dependent on the stellar models), and the resonance layer moves inward
with increasing ∆m2/Eν. If ∆m2/Eν is smaller than 10−10 [eV2/MeV], the mass term has no effect
on ∆H in this region of the solar metallicity models, and the resonance occurs at the boundary
between the helium layer and the hydrogen envelope due to the change of the sign of (1 − 2Ye). In
contrast with the flavor oscillation, the matter potential changes its sign by itself and the resonance
can occur without the mass term, ∆m2/Eν. However, as explained in the next subsection, if a
dipole moment is assumed as the global structure of the magnetic fields, it seems difficult that B is
strong enough to satisfy the adiabaticity condition at this boundary in the solar metallicity models.
In the hydrogen envelope, Ye is about 0.8 and the suppression of (1− 2Ye) does not work any more.
We can see that most of the qualitative features are the same for the two models: WW15S and
WW25S, and the dependence on the stellar masses is rather small. Note that our result gives 1 -- 2
orders of magnitude larger ∆V than that in the earlier calculation by Athar et al. [11], in which
the older 15 M⊙ Woosley & Weaver model [34,35] is used. It is probably because our calculation
of (1 − 2Ye) includes the larger network of isotopes used in the latest WW models.
In Figs. 3 and 4, we show the same with Figs. 1 and 2, but for the Nomoto & Hashimoto
models. It can be seen that the profiles of ∆V of the WW and NH models are not so different,
and the model dependence seems rather small. However, the situation is drastically changed when
we consider the effect of different metallicities. Figs. 5 and 6 are the same with Figs. 1 and 2, but
for the zero metallicity WW models: WW15Z and WW25Z. ('Z' denotes the zero metallicity.) In
the O+Si and O+Ne+Mg layers, (1 − 2Ye) is smaller than that of the solar metallicity models by
about 1 order of magnitude, and in the O+C and He layers, (1− 2Ye) is further strongly suppressed
(4 -- 6 orders of magnitudes) because of the lack of the heavy nuclei which cause the deviation of
Ye from 0.5 (Table I). In consequence, the metallicity effect becomes especially important when
∆m2/Eν is smaller than ∼ 10−6 [eV2/MeV]. How this effect changes the profile of the conversion
probability will be discussed in more detail in section IV.
B. Magnetic Fields
Let us consider the magnetic fields in the isotopically neutral region. In the earlier publication
[11], the strength of magnetic fields was normalized at the surface of the newly born neutron star
(r ∼ 10 km), but it is unlikely that the magnetic fields of a nascent neutron star have some effects
on the far outer region, such as the isotopically neutral region, within the short time scale of
the neutrino burst. The magnetic fields should be normalized by the fields which are static and
existent before the core collapse. The strength of such magnetic fields above the surface of the iron
7
core may be inferred from that observed on the surface of white dwarfs, because the iron core of
giant stars is similar to white dwarfs in the point that both are sustained against the gravitational
collapse by the degenerate pressure of electrons. The observations of the magnetic fields in white
dwarfs show that the strength spreads in a wide range of 107 -- 109 Gauss [36]. Taking account of
the possibility of the decay of magnetic fields in white dwarfs, it is not unnatural to consider the
magnetic fields up to 1010 Gauss at the surface of the iron core. As for the global structure of the
fields, although the optimistic estimate of B ∝ r−2 is sometimes discussed from the argument of the
flux freezing, a magnetic dipole is natural as static and global fields; we hence assume such fields
in this paper. Therefore the off-diagonal element of the Hamiltonian in Eq.(5), µν B⊥ becomes
µνB0(r0/r)3 sin Θ, where B0 is the strength of the magnetic field at the equator on the iron core
surface, r0 the radius of the iron core, and Θ the angle between the pole of the magnetic dipole
and the direction of neutrino propagation. If the magnetic field is normalized at the surface of the
neutron star, the radial dependence of a dipole (∝ r−3) gives too small field in the isotopically
neutral region, but the normalization at the surface of the iron core inferred from the observations
of white dwarfs makes it possible that the magnetic field is sufficiently strong in the isotopically
neutral region under the condition of a global dipole moment. The lines of µνB [eV] are shown in
Figs. 1 -- 6 for B0 = 108 and 1010 [Gauss], assuming µν = 10−12µB. The strength of magnetic fields
is also discussed from the argument of energetics. The energy density of the maximum strength of
magnetic fields should at most be the same order of magnitudes with that of the thermal plasma
in the star. Let us define the magnetic fields Bth, whose energy density is the same with that of
the gas in the star:
1
8π
B2
th =
3
2
ρ
µmp
kT ,
(8)
where ρ is the density, T temperature, k the Bolzman constant, and µ the mean molecular weight.
The line of µνBth is depicted in Figures 1 -- 6, assuming µ = 1 and µν = 10−12µB, and it can be
seen that the magnetic fields up to B0 ∼ 1010 [Gauss] are far below Bth and therefore natural from
the view point of energetics.
If there is no matter potential, the complete precession of νR ↔ νL occurs; however, the pre-
cession amplitude is suppressed by the matter potential. The precession amplitude is given in the
form [11,19]:
Ap =
(2µνB)2
(2µνB)2 + (∆H)2 .
(9)
In the neutronized iron core, ∆H is much larger than µν B even when B0 ∼ 1010 [Gauss], and the
precession below the surface of the iron core can be completely neglected. (In other words, we
can start the calculation with the pure neutrino states from the iron core surface, with B0 <
∼ 1010
[Gauss].) Above the iron core, i.e., in the isotopically neutral region in the solar metallicity models,
µνB is still much lower than ∆V (or ∆H), except at the resonance layer or the boundary of the
helium layer and the hydrogen envelope, as shown in Figs. 1 -- 4. Therefore, the precession does not
occur in the solar metallicity stars. However, if the strength of the magnetic fields is strong enough
to satisfy the adiabaticity condition at the resonance layer, neutrinos are resonantly converted into
other types of neutrinos. The adiabaticity condition is satisfied when the precession length at the
resonance layer, (µνB)−1, is shorter than the thickness of the resonance layer, i.e.,
8
d(∆H)
1
2
d(∆V )
1
2
(at the resonance),
µνB >
∼(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
since the thickness of the resonance layer, ∆rres, is given as
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
dr
dr
=(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
∆rres = µν B(cid:18)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
d(∆H)
dr
(cid:19)−1
.
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
(10)
(11)
Note that the suppression of (1 − 2Ye) in the isotopically neutral region makes the adiabaticity
condition well satisfied because it reduces the right hand side of Eq.(10) by a factor of (1− 2Ye)1/2.
In order to show how this condition is satisfied, d(∆V )/dr1/2 is shown by the thin solid lines
in Figs. 1 -- 6. If µνB is (roughly) larger than d(∆V )/dr1/2 at the resonance layer (∆H = 0),
the adiabaticity condition is satisfied and ¯νe's and νµ's are mutually converted. In both the WW
and NH models with the solar metallicity, the region where this condition is satisfied appears with
B0 >
∼ 1010 [Gauss]. Because the slope of d(∆V )/dr1/2 is flatter than that of µνB, this condition
is satisfied better in the inner region of the star, in other words, with large values of ∆m2/Eν,
in the solar metallicity models. When ∆m2/Eν is smaller than ∼ 10−10 [eV2/MeV] and the
resonance layer lies at the boundary of the helium layer and the hydrogen envelope, unnaturally
strong magnetic fields are necessary for satisfaction of the adiabaticity condition. However, in the
zero metallicity stars, because the value of (1 − 2Ye) is very strongly suppressed in the O+C and
He layers, µν B becomes much larger than ∆H and hence the strong precession between different
chiralities occurs with small ∆m2/Eν (Figs. 5 and 6). Since the adiabaticity may be broken at
the quite large jump of the matter potential at the boundary of the helium layer and the hydrogen
envelope, the detailed calculation is necessary for the conversion probability when ∆m2/Eν <
∼ 10−8
[eV2/MeV]. It is apparent that the conversion probability in zero metallicity stars will be completely
different from the solar metallicity stars. Now all of the qualitative features of the conversion can
be understood from Figs. 1 -- 6 and the results of final conversion probability obtained by solving
the evolution equation (Eq. 5) numerically are given in the following section.
IV. RESULTS
A. Conversion Probability Maps
In this section the contour maps of the conversion probability (¯νe ↔ νµ) are given for all the
models used in this paper as a function of ∆m2/Eν and B at the surface of the neutronized iron core
(B0). Before we proceed to contour maps, the evolution of conversion probability in the isotopically
neutral region along the trajectory of neutrinos is shown for some cases as a demonstration. Fig. 7
shows the conversion probability as a function of radius from the center of the star using the model
NH4 for some values of B0, with ∆m2/Eν = 10−4[eV2/MeV], µν = 10−12µB, and cos 2θ = 1. The
resonance layer lies at r ∼ 5 × 10−3R⊙ in the O+Si layer and its location is never changed by
strength of the magnetic fields. We can see in this figure that the conversion probability becomes
larger with increasing strength of magnetic fields, and the complete conversion occurs with the
magnetic fields strong enough (B0 >
∼ 5 × 109 [Gauss], in this case) to satisfy the adiabaticity
condition (see also Figure 3). Fig. 8 is the same with Fig. 7, but ∆m2/Eν is 10−5[eV2/MeV] and
9
the resonance layer is hence in more outer region at r ∼ 1.5 × 10−2R⊙ (O+Ne+Mg layer). As
shown in these figures, the necessary B0 for the complete conversion becomes larger with decreasing
∆m2/Eν in the solar metallicity models, because the adiabaticity condition is well satisfied with
larger ∆m2/Eν, as discussed in the previous section. In both the figures, the conversion probability
jumps up a little at the radius of about 2.5 ×10−3R⊙, because this radius corresponds to the surface
of the iron core and the value of (1 − 2Ye) drops quite suddenly here.
Now we calculate the contour maps of the conversion probability for the solar metallicity models,
in the region of ∆m2/Eν = 10−8 -- 10−1[eV2/MeV] and B0 = 108 -- 1010 [Gauss], and the results
are given in Figs. 9 -- 12 (for WW15S, WW25S, NH4, and NH8, respectively). In the region of
∆m2/Eν < 10−8[eV2/MeV] or B0 < 108 [Gauss], the conversion does not occur because of too
weak magnetic fields. Magnetic fields stronger than 1010 [Gauss] induce the precession below the
surface of the iron core which cannot be ignored, and ∆m2/Eν larger than 10−1[eV2/MeV] leads
to the resonance below the surface of the iron core. In this paper, we consider the parameter region
in which the conversion or precession below the iron core surface can be neglected. The contours
are depicted with the probability intervals of 0.1, assuming µν = 10−12µB and cos 2θ = 1. It can
be seen that some observable effects on the spectrum of the emitted ¯νe's are expected if B0 is
stronger than ∼109 [Gauss] and ∆m2 is larger than ∼10−5 [eV2]. Note that the typical energy
range of the neutrinos which are observed in a water Cerenkov detector is 10 -- 70 MeV. The lower
margins of the strong conversion region (P > 0.9, where P is the conversion probability) in the
contour maps are, in all the four models, contours which runs from the upper left to the lower right
direction. This is due to the fact that the adiabaticity condition is well satisfied with larger values
of ∆m2/Eν, as discussed in the previous section. We refer to this marginal region in the contour
maps as "the continuous deformation region", because the conversion probability continuously
decreases with increasing neutrino energy in this region and the spectral deformation is expected
to be continuous. What is interesting about these maps is that some band-like patterns can be seen
in the relation of the conversion probability and the value of ∆m2/Eν . For example, the conversion
probability in the region of ∆m2/Eν = 5 × 10−4 -- 5 × 10−3 [eV2/MeV] in Fig. 11 is much lower
than that in the other regions of the map. These patterns come directly from the jumps in the
matter potential due to the onion-like structure of the isotopic composition in giant stars [11].
When ∆m2/Eν is in the above region, the resonance in the model NH4 occurs at the surface of the
iron core and the interval of ∆m2/Eν corresponds to the jump of ∆V at the surface (see Fig. 3).
Since the matter potential changes suddenly here, very strong magnetic field is necessary for the
satisfaction of the adiabaticity condition, and consequently the resonant conversion is significantly
suppressed. We refer to such bands of ∆m2/Eν as "the weak adiabaticity band", hereafter. At
each boundaries of the onion-like structure of massive stars, this weak adiabaticity band appears
due to the jump in the matter potential. It should also be noted that in the weak adiabaticity
bands, the conversion probability only weakly depends on ∆m2/Eν because the location of the
resonance layer is not changed in a band. In Figs. 9 -- 12, we can see the difference between the WW
and NH models as well as between 15 and 25 M⊙ models. Although there are some quantitative
differences, almost all qualitative features are the same for these four models.
Next we show the contour maps of the conversion probability for the zero metallicity models, in
Figs. 13 and 14 (for the models WW15Z and WW25Z, respectively), with the region of ∆m2/Eν =
10−11 -- 10−1 [eV2/MeV] and B0 = 108 -- 1010. When ∆m2/Eν is larger than ∼ 10−6 [eV2/MeV],
10
the profile of the contour maps is qualitatively similar to that of the solar metallicity models. But
the adiabaticity condition can be satisfied with smaller strength of magnetic fields and the region
of complete conversion becomes somewhat larger, because in the inner part of the isotopically
neutral region (O+Si and O+Ne+Mg layers) the value of (1 − 2Ye) is about 1 order of magnitude
smaller than that in the solar metallicity models. Especially, in the model WW25Z, ∆H and
µνB are comparable in this region (see Fig. 6) and the precession effect is no longer negligible,
leading to the more complicated feature of the contour map of WW25Z than of WW15Z. When
∆m2/Eν <
∼ 10−6 [eV2/MeV], the strong precession occurs in the outer part of the isotopically
In contrast to the
neutral region (O+C and He layers), where µνB is much higher than ∆H.
solar metallicity models, the conversion still occurs with such a low value of ∆m2/Eν, even when
∆m2 = 0. Further interesting is that with ∆m2/Eν lower than ∼10−6 [eV2/MeV], the conversion
probability changes periodically with µνB0 (Fig. 13). This can be understood as follows. The
precession effect in the outer part of the isotopically neutral region is very profound and then
this precession is stopped almost suddenly at the boundary of the helium layer and the hydrogen
envelope where ∆V increases by 5 -- 10 orders of magnitude. The final phase of the precession
strongly depends on µνB0, because the precession length is given as
L =
π
r(cid:16) ∆m2
4Eν (cid:17)2
.
+ (µνB)2
(12)
Therefore the conversion probability changes periodically with µνB0. The examples of strong
precession effect are shown in Fig. 15, using the WW15Z model with ∆m2 = 0 and some values of
B0. The conversion probability as a function of the radius is shown in this figure. The precession
begins at r = 0.025R⊙ and ceases at r = 0.28R⊙ (see also Fig. 5). One can see that the precession
length becomes larger with propagation of neutrinos, because B decreases with r. It is also clear
that the change in B0 leads to the change of the precession length, and hence to the oscillation
of the final phase of precession. Below ∆m2/Eν ∼ 10−11 [eV2/MeV], the effect of the mass term
can be completely neglected and the conversion probability becomes constant (but never vanishes)
with neutrino mass or energy.
B. Spectral Deformation
All of the qualitative features of the spectral deformation due to the resonant spin-flavor con-
version of ¯νe ↔ νµ are clearly understood by the contour maps given in the previous section (Figs.
9 -- 14). The most easily detectable flavor in a water Cerenkov detector is ¯νe's because of the large
cross section of the reaction ¯νep → ne+, and they are detectable above the positron energy of ∼5
MeV in the Super-Kamiokande detector, which has the fiducial volume of 22,000 tons [1]. If we
consider the positron energy range of 10 -- 70 MeV, which includes almost all of the events, this
range corresponds to a vertical bar in the contour maps with fixed values of ∆m2 and B0. The
samples of such a bar are shown in Figs. 11 and 12 (NH models), and the corresponding spectral
deformation of the events at the SK are shown in Fig. 16. The distance of the supernova is set to
10 kpc and the total energy of each type of neutrinos is assumed to be 5 × 1052 erg. We use 5 and
8 MeV as the temperature of ¯νe's and νµ's, respectively, and the Fermi-Dirac distribution with
11
zero chemical potential is assumed for both ¯νe's and νµ's [37]. The cross section of the dominant
reaction of ¯νep → ne+ is 9.72 × 10−44Eepe cm2 [1], where Ee and pe is the energy and momentum
of recoil positrons. The appropriate detection efficiency curve is also taken into account [38]. The
thick solid line in Fig. 16 is the expected differential event number of ¯νe's without any oscillation
or conversion.
As mentioned in the previous section, the three characteristic regions appear in the contour maps
for the solar metallicity models: A) the complete conversion region, B) the continuous deformation
region, and C) the weak adiabaticity band. (A, B, and C correspond to those in Figs. 11 and
12.) When the conversion is complete, we can see the original νµ spectrum as ¯νe's, and the event
number is considerably enhanced because of the higher average energy (thin solid line in Fig. 16).
When the vertical line in the contour map lies in the continuous deformation region, conversion
probability decreases with increasing energy of neutrinos and consequently the original νµ's are
dominant in the lower energy range, while the original ¯νe's are dominant in the higher energy
range (short-dashed line in Fig. 16, also corresponding to the vertical line (B) in Fig. 12). Note
that this feature is based upon the assumption that the radial dependence of the magnetic fields
is a dipole (B ∝ r−3) and µνB drops faster than d(∆V )/dr1/2 with increasing radius. On the
other hand, in the weak adiabaticity band, the energy dependence of conversion probability is
rather weak (long-dashed line in Fig. 16, also corresponding to the vertical line (C) in Fig. 11).
Because the resonance always occurs in the same place (jumps in the matter potential), this feature
does not depend on the assumption of the radial dependence of magnetic fields, in contrast to the
case (B). Finally, quite interesting deformation is expected if the vertical line in the contour maps
crosses the boundary of the weak adiabaticity band (the vertical line (D) in Fig. 11). Because the
conversion probability changes almost suddenly at the boundary, the spectrum of the event rate
suffers drastical deformation at a certain positron energy (dot-dashed line in Fig. 16). The used
values of (∆m2 [eV2], B0 [Gauss]) for the vertical lines A, B, C, and D in Figs. 11 and 12 are
(5×10−3, 7 × 109), (5 × 10−4, 5 × 109), (3 × 10−2, 5 × 109), and (1.5 × 10−2, 2 × 109), respectively.
In the zero metallicity models, the feature of the spectrum deformation is similar to that of the
solar metallictiy models when ∆m2/Eν >
∼ 10−7 [eV2/MeV]. However, if ∆m2 ∼ 10−7 -- 10−6 [eV2],
the conversion probability increases with neutrino energy, because the precession in the outer part
of the isotopically neutral region becomes effective (Fig. 13). With ∆m2/Eν <
∼ 10−9 [eV2/MeV],
the conversion probability becomes constant with neutrino energy, but changes periodically with
B0. In the model WW25Z, the precession in the inner part of the isotopically neutral region (O+Si
and O+Ne+Mg layers) is also effective, and the probability may change rapidly and complicatedly
with neutrino energy (Fig 14).
V. DISCUSSION
We found that the difference of the stellar metallicity significantly affects the resonant spin-flavor
conversion of ¯νe ↔ νµ, and some implications from this fact are discussed in the following. The
lifetime of massive stars which end their life by the gravitational collapses is very shorter than
that of the Sun, and the progenitors of observed supernovae are therefore younger. Consequently,
the metallicity of the Galactic supernova is expected to be at least the solar abundance or more
metal-rich. If the metallicity is higher than that of the Sun, the suppression of (1 − 2Ye) will be
12
weaker and the B0 which is required to satisfy the adiabaticity condition becomes larger. On the
other hand, the Large and Small Magellanic Clouds are known to be very metal-poor systems [39].
Therefore, the resonant conversion will occur with smaller magnetic fields in supernovae in the
Magellanic Clouds, and also the precession effect may be observed. The another object which has
relation to the metallicity effect is the supernova relic neutrino background (SRN) [40]. Because the
SRN is the accumulation of neutrinos from supernovae which have ever occurred in the universe,
the SRN includes neutrinos from supernovae with quite low metallicity in the early phase of galaxy
formation. The conversion of ¯νe ↔ νµ conpensates the energy degradation due to the cosmological
redshift effect and enhances the expected event rate of the SRN. However, because of the small
expected event rate at the SK [40], it will be difficult to get some decisive information on the
spin-flavor conversion from the observation at the SK.
We did not consider the flavor conversion (the MSW effect) in this paper although this can occur
with appropriate generation mixing and neutrino masses. With the same ∆m2/Eν , the resonance
of the flavor conversion occurs in more outer region than the resonance layer of the spin-flavor
conversion, because the matter potential for the flavor conversion are not suppressed by (1 − 2Ye)
[11]. Even if the flavor conversion occurs in more outer region, the spectrum of ¯νe is not changed.
There may be interesting effect if we consider the conversion in the iron core, or the mutual effect
of spin-flavor and flavor conversion among the three generations of neutrinos, as pointed out by
the earlier publication [11].
The turbulence in the radial dependence of the magnetic fields was ignored in this paper. In the
solar metallicity models, ∆H is much larger than µν B except at the resonance, and the conversion
probability is determined only from the strength of the field at the resonance layer. Therefore
the turbulence does not affect the evolution of conversion probability of neutrinos. However, the
turbulence disturbs the relation of B0 and B at the resonance layer. When the neutrino energy
changes, the location of the resonance layer also changes, and hence the neutrino spectrum can be
disturbed by some strong turbulence in the magnetic fields.
The effect of dynamics in the collapse-driven supernova was also not taken into consideration.
Although it seems unlikely that the shock wave is propagated through the whole isotopically neutral
region in a few tens of seconds, the inner part of the isotopically neutral region may be dynamically
disturbed by the shock wave. If ∆m2/Eν is large, the resonance occurs at the inner part of the
isotopically neutral region, and the dynamical effect may change the situation of the resonant
conversion of the neutrinos emitted in the later phase of emission (>
∼ 10 sec after the bounce). We
give here simple discussion on the effect of the change in density, assuming that Ye is conserved
during the shock propagation. (The composition of matter is drastically changed by the shock wave,
but the change in Ye requires the weak interaction.) The matter potential (∆V ) changes as ∝ ρ.
On the other hand, if we assume the conservation of the magnetic flux in dynamical plasma, the
field strength changes as ∝ ρ2/3, and hence the precession becomes more effective with decreasing
(9)). However, the adiabaticity condition is the competition of µνB
matter density (see Eq.
and d(∆V )/dr1/2, and if we assume d(∆V )/dr scales as (length)−4 (homogeneous expansion
or compression), the scaling of d(∆V )/dr1/2 is the same with that of magnetic fields, ∝ ρ2/3.
Therefore, the adiabaticity condition is not strongly affected by the dynamics of the shock wave.
It should also be noted that the observed data of neutrinos from SN1987A [28,29] favor a softer
neutrino spectrum than theoretically plausible spectrum of electron antineutrinos. If ¯νe's are ex-
13
changed with νµ-like neutrinos (νµ, ντ , and their antiparticles) which have higher average energy,
this discrepancy becomes larger. From this view point, an upper bound on the conversion prob-
ability of ¯νe's and νµ-like neutrinos has been derived: P < 0.35 at the 99 % confidence level
[41]. The earlier paper of the spin-flavor conversion [11] used this constraint in order to derive
an upper bound on the neutrino magnetic moment. However, the above constraint on P and its
confidence level suffer considerable statistical uncertainty because of the small number of events
in Kamiokande and IMB. Therefore, we avoid a decisive conclusion about the upper bound on µν
from SN1987A, although the strong conversion region (P > 0.9) in the contour maps (Figs. 9 -- 14)
may be disfavored. Also we point out here that the metallicity effect on the conversion probability
should be taken into account when one attempts to constrain µν from the SN1987A data, because
the Large Magellanic Cloud is a low-metal system.
VI. CONCLUSIONS
Neutrino spin-flavor conversion of ¯νe ↔ νµ induced by the interaction of a flavor changing
magnetic moment of Majorana neutrinos and magnetic fields above the iron core of collapsing
stars was investigated in detail. The effective matter potential of this conversion mode (¯νe ↔ νµ)
is proportional to (1 − 2Ye), and hence this value is quite important to this resonant conversion.
However, this value is determined by isotopes which are quite rarely existent, and in order to
estimate the effect of the astrophysical uncertainties, we used the six precollapse models, changing
the stellar masses, metallicities, and authors of the models. The components of Hamiltonian in
the propagation equation (5) are shown for all the models in Figs. 1 -- 6, and qualitative features of
the conversion can be understood from these figures. The results of the numerical calculation for
all the models are shown in Figs. 9 -- 14 as contour maps of conversion probability as a function of
the two parameters of ∆m2/Eν and B0, where B0 is B at the surface of the iron core.
For the solar metallicity models, observable effects are expected when ∆m2/Eν is in the range of
∼ 10−12(109G/B0) [µB] (Figs. 9 -- 12). The difference of the stellar
10−5 -- 10−1 [eV2/MeV] and µν >
masses leads to the different thickness and location of the layers of the onion-like structure in
massive stars and this effect appears in the contour maps, although the effect is rather small. The
qualitative features of the contour maps for the WW and NH models are also not so different, and
the model dependence of the conversion probability can be roughly estimated by the comparison
of these figures. Although the dependence on the stellar models or stellar masses is rather weak as
shown in Figs. 9 -- 12, it was found that the metal abundance of the precollapse star significantly
affect the value of (1 − 2Ye). The difference between the solar and zero metallicity is prominent
especially in the O+C and He layers, and the strong precession between ¯νe ↔ νµ occurs with
small ∆m2/Eν, because µνB is much larger than ∆m2/Eν in this region.
In contrast to the
solar metallicity models, the conversion occurs even when ∆m2 = 0. The probability changes
periodically with B0 because of the precession effect. (See Figs. 13 and 14.)
Considering the above properties, the expected spectral deformation of ¯νe's can be summarized
as follows. For the solar metallicity models, there are roughly three types of the energy dependence
of the conversion probability: 1) complete conversion in a range of neutrino energy, 2) conversion
probability decreases with increasing energy when the energy range is in 'the continuous defor-
mation region' in the contour maps, and 3) incomplete conversion and weak energy dependence
14
of conversion probability when the energy range is in 'the weak adiabaticity band' in the contour
maps. Examples of these types of spectral deformation are given in Fig. 16. (For the explanation
of 'the continuous deformation region' and 'the weak adiabaticity band', see section IV.) Fur-
thermore, there appear some interesting jumps in the spectrum if the energy range of 10 -- 70 MeV
includes boundaries of the complete conversion region and the weak adiabaticity band. Irrespec-
tive of the stellar models or stellar masses, such a boundary exists especially at the surface of the
iron core, where the matter potential suddenly changes. For the zero metallicity models, although
the feature of the spectral deformation is similar to that of the solar metallicity models when
∆m2/Eν >
(<
∼ 10−9 [eV2/MeV]), which does not occur in the solar metallicity models.
∼ 10−7 [eV2/MeV], energy-independent conversion is possible with quite small ∆m2/Eν
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors would like to thank S.E. Woosley and M. Hashimoto, for providing us the data
of their precollapse models and useful comments. They are also grateful to Y. Totsuka, for the
information on the detection efficiency of the SK detector. This work has been supported in part
by the Grant-in-Aid for COE Research (07CE2002) and for Scientific Research Fund (05243103
and 07640386) of the Ministry of Education, Science, and Culture in Japan.
[1] Y. Totsuka, Rep. Prog. Phys. 55, 377 (1992); K. Nakamura, T. Kajita, M. Nakahata, and A.
Suzuki, Kamiokande, in Physics and Astrophysics of Neutrinos, edited by M. Fukugita and A. Suzuki
(Springer-Verlag, Tokyo, 1994).
[2] L. Wolfenstein, Phys. Rev. D 17, 2369 (1978); S. P. Mikheyev and A. Yu. Smirnov, Yad. Fiz. 42, 1441
(1985) [Sov. J. Nucl. Phys. 42, 913 (1985)]; Nuovo Cim. 9C, 17 (1986).
[3] A. Cisneros, Astrophys. Space Sci. 10, 87 (1970)
[4] K. Fujikawa and R. E. Shrock, Phys. Rev. Lett. 45, 963 (1980).
[5] J. Schechter and J. W. F. Valle, Phys. Rev. D 24, 1883 (1981); 25, 283 (E) (1982).
[6] C. S. Lim and W. J. Marciano, Phys. Rev. D 37, 1368 (1988).
[7] E. Kh. Akhmedov, Sov. J. Nucl. Phys. 48, 382 (1988); Phys. Lett. B 213, 64 (1988).
[8] M. B. Voloshin, Phys. Lett. B 209, 360 (1988).
[9] E. Kh. Akhmedov and Z. G. Berezhiani, Nucl. Phys. B 373, 479 (1992).
[10] J. T. Peltoniemi, Astron. Astrophys. 254, 121 (1992).
[11] H. Athar, J. T. Peltoniemi, and A. Yu. Smirnov, Phys. Rev. D 51, 6647 (1995).
15
[12] M. Fukugita and S. Yazaki, Phys. Rev. D 36, 3817 (1987).
[13] G. G. Raffelt, Phys. Rev. Lett. 64, 2856 (1990); Astrophys. J. 365, 559 (1990).
[14] W. J. Marciano and A. I. Sanda, Phys. Lett. B 67, 303 (1977).
[15] B. W. Lee and R. E. Shrock, Phys. Rev. D 16, 1444 (1977).
[16] S. T. Petkov, Yad. Fiz. 25, 641 (1977) [Sov. J. Nucl. Phys. 25, 340 (1977)].
[17] M. Fukugita and T. Yanagida, Phys. Rev. Lett. 58, 1807 (1987).
[18] K. S. Babu and V. S. Mathur, Phys. Lett. B 196, 218 (1987).
[19] M. B. Voloshin, M. I. Vysotskiı, and L. B. Okun, Yad. Fiz. 44, 677 (1986) [Sov. J. Nucl. Phys. 44,
440 (1986)]; Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 91, 754 (1986) [Sov. Phys. JETP 64, 446 (1986)].
[20] E. Kh. Akhmedov, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 95, 1195 (1989) [Sov. Phys. JETP 68, 690 (1989)].
[21] K. Inoue, Ph. D. thesis, The University of Tokyo, 1993.
[22] G. A. Bazilevskaya, Yu. I. Stozhkov, and T. N. Charakhchyan, Pis'ma Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 35, 273
(1982) [JETP Lett. 35, 341 (1982)]; G. A. Bazilevskaya et al., Yad. Fiz. 39, 856 (1984) [Sov. J.
Nucl. Phys. 39, 543 (1984)]; R. Davis, Jr., in Solar Neutrinos and Neutrino Astronomy -- 1984, AIP
Conference Proceedings No. 126, edited by M. L. Cherry, K. Lande, and W. A. Fowler (American
Institute of Physics, New York, 1985).
[23] Y. Raphaeli and A. S. Szalay, Phys. Lett. B106, 73 (1981).
[24] S. Nusseinov and Y. Raphaeli, Phys. Rev. D 36, 2278 (1987).
[25] S. E. Woosley and T. A. Weaver, Astrophys. J. Suppl. 101, 181 (1995).
[26] K. Nomoto and M. Hashimoto, Phys. Rep. 163, 13 (1988).
[27] E. Kh. Akhmedov et al., preprint SISSA 40/96/A-EP (hep-ph/9603443) (1996).
[28] K. S. Hirata et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 58, 1490 (1987); Phys. Rev. D38, 448 (1988).
[29] R. M. Bionta et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 58, 1494 (1987); C. B. Bratton et al., Phys. Rev. D37, 3361
(1988).
[30] A. Dar, SLAC preprint (1987), unpublished.
[31] J. M. Lattimer and J. Cooperstein, Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 23 (1988).
[32] R. Barbieri and R. N. Mohapatra, Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 27 (1988).
[33] D. Notzold, Phys. Rev. D 38, 1658 (1988).
[34] S. E. Woosley and T. A. Weaver, Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 24, 205 (1986).
[35] S. E. Woosley, N. Langer, and T. A. Weaver, Astrophys. J. 411, 823 (1993).
16
[36] G. Chanmugam, Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 30, 143 (1992).
[37] For the properties of supernova neutrinos, see, e.g., A. Burrows, D. Klein, and R. Gandhi, Phys. Rev.
D 45, 3361 (1992), and references therein.
[38] Y. Totsuka, private communication (1994).
[39] For recent observations, see, e.g., M. Hilker, T. Richtler, and W. Gieren, Astron. Astrophys. 294, 648
(1995); M.T. Meliani, B. Barbuy, and T. Richtler, Astron. Astrophys. 304, 347 (1995).
[40] T. Totani and K. Sato, Astropart. Phys. 3, 367 (1995); T. Totani, K. Sato, and Y. Yoshii, Astrophys.
J. 460, 303 (1996), and references therein.
[41] A. Yu. Smirnov, D. N. Spergel, and J. N. Bahcall, Phys. Rev. D 49, 1389 (1994).
TABLES
TABLE I. The table of (1 − 2Ye) in the isotopically neutral region (O+Si, O+Ne+Mg, O+C, and He
layers) for all the models of precollapse stars used in this paper. The models WW15 and WW25 are 15
and 25 M⊙ models by Woosley and Weaver (1995) [25]. There are models with two different metallicities
in the WW models, and they are distinguished by 'S' (solar metallicity) and 'Z' (zero metallicity). The
models NH4 and NH8 are 4 and 8 M⊙ helium core models (corresponding approximately to 15 and 25
M⊙ main sequence stellar masses) by Nomoto and Hashimoto (1988) [26]. The isotopes in the parentheses
under the values of (1 − 2Ye) are the main isotopes which cause the deviation of Ye from 0.5.
Model
WW15S
WW25S
WW15Z
WW25Z
NH4
NH8
O+Si
2 ×10−3
(34S, 38Ar)
2 ×10−3
(34S, 38Ar)
6 -- 10 ×10−4
(27Al, 29,30Si)
4 ×10−4
(27Al, 30Si)
1 ×10−3
(34S, 38Ar)
2 ×10−3
O+Ne+Mg
2 ×10−3
(23Na, 25,26Mg)
2 ×10−3
(25,26Mg,27Al)
4 ×10−4
(23Na, 26Mg)
1 ×10−4
(23Na, 26Mg)
2 ×10−3
(25,26Mg, 27Al)
1 ×10−3
(27Al, 29,30Si)
(23Na, 25,26Mg)
O+C
2 ×10−3
(22Ne, 25Mg)
2 ×10−3
(22Ne, 25,26Mg)
1 -- 6 ×10−8
(22Ne, 26Mg)
2 ×10−7
He
1 -- 10 ×10−4
(18O, 56Fe)
2 ×10−3
(22Ne)
2 -- 100 ×10−10
(18O)
2 ×10−7
(22Ne, 25,26Mg)
(13,14C, 22Ne)
2 ×10−3
(22Ne, 26Mg)
1 ×10−3
(22Ne, 26Mg)
2 ×10−3
(18O, 22Ne)
2 ×10−3
(18O, 22Ne)
17
Figure Captions
FIG. 1. The components of the Hamiltonian in the propagation equation (5) are shown for the Woosley
& Weaver's solar-metallicity 15 M⊙ model, as a function of the radius from the center of the star. The
absolute value of the effective matter potential, ∆V , is shown by the thick, solid line. The absolute value
of the difference of the diagonal components of the Hamiltonian, ∆H, is shown by the dashed lines for
the two values of the mass term, ∆m2/Eν = 10−4 and 10−6 [eV2/MeV]. The resonant conversion occurs
where ∆H = 0 (the resonance layer). The dotted lines show µν B, i.e., the off-diagonal components of the
Hamiltonian. The indicated values of B are those at the surface of the iron core (B0) in units of Gauss,
assuming µν = 10−12µB. The thin solid line shows d(∆V )/dr1/2 [eV], and the adiabaticity condition
is satisfied when µν B >
∼ d(∆V )/dr1/2 at the resonance layer. The dot-dashed line shows µν Bth, again
assuming µν = 10−12µB, where Bth is the magnetic field whose energy density is the same with the thermal
energy density in the star. The dominantly existent nuclei in each layer of the precollapse model are shown
in the top of this figure.
FIG. 2. The same as Fig. 1, but for the Woosley & Weaver's solar-metallicity 25 M⊙ model.
FIG. 3. The same as Fig. 1, but for the Nomoto & Hashimoto's 4 M⊙ helium-core model.
FIG. 4. The same as Fig. 1, but for the Nomoto & Hashimoto's 8 M⊙ helium-core model. The O+Si
and O+C layers are negligibly thin in this figure.
FIG. 5. The same as Fig. 1, but for the Woosley & Weaver's zero-metallicity 15 M⊙ model. Note that
the scale of the vertical axis is different from the previous four figures.
FIG. 6. The same as Fig. 1, but for the Woosley & Weaver's zero-metallicity 25 M⊙ model.
FIG. 7. The evolution of conversion probability with the radius from the center of the star. The
Nomoto & Hashimoto's 4 M⊙ helium-core model is used, and ∆m2/Eν is assumed to be 10−4[eV2/MeV].
The four different values of B0 are used for the calculation, where B0 is the magnetic field at the surface
of the iron core. The neutrino magnetic moment, µν, is assumed to be 10−12µB.
FIG. 8. The same as Fig. 7, but for the case with ∆m2/Eν = 10−5[eV2/MeV]. The three values of B0
are used as indicated in the figure.
FIG. 9. The contour map of conversion probability for the Woosley & Weaver's solar-metallicity 15 M⊙
model, as a function of ∆m2/Eν and B0, where B0 is the magnetic field at the surface of the iron core. The
neutrino magnetic moment, µν , is assumed to be 10−12µB. The contours are depicted with the interval of
0.1.
18
FIG. 10. The same as Fig. 9, but for the Woosley & Weaver's solar-metallicity 25 M⊙ model.
FIG. 11. The same as Fig. 9, but for the Nomoto & Hashimoto's 4 M⊙ helium-core model. The two
vertical bars, (C) and (D) correspond to the energy range of 10 -- 70 MeV with (∆m2 [eV2], B0[Gauss]) =
(3 × 10−2, 5 × 109) and (1.5 × 10−2, 2 × 109), respectively, where the energy range is that of positrons
which are observed in a water Cerenkov detector.
FIG. 12. The same as Fig. 11, but for the Nomoto & Hashimoto's 8 M⊙ helium-core model. The values
of (∆m2 [eV2], B0 [Gauss]) for the two vertical bars, (A) and (B) are (5 × 10−3, 7 × 109) and (5 × 10−4,
5 × 109), respectively.
FIG. 13. The same as Fig. 9, but for the Woosley & Weaver's zero-metallicity 15 M⊙ model. Note that
the region of ∆m2/Eν is different from that in Figs. 9 -- 12.
FIG. 14. The same as Figure 13, but for the Woosley & Weaver's zero-metallicity 25 M⊙ model.
FIG. 15. The same as Fig. 7, but for the Woosley & Weaver's zero-metallicity 15 M⊙ model and
∆m2/Eν = 0. The three values of B0 are used as indicated in the figure. Strong precession occurs in the
region of 0.025 -- 0.28 R⊙.
FIG. 16. Examples of the spectral deformation of ¯νe's for the solar metallicity models. The expected
time-integrated differential events at the SK detector are shown, assuming that the supernova occurs in the
Galactic center (D = 10 kpc). The upper box shows the corresponding conversion probability of ¯νe ↔ νµ.
The thick solid line shows the ordinary expected events of ¯νe's without any oscillation or conversion, and
the thin solid line the differential events when all of the original νµ's are completely converted to ¯νe's in
the whole energy range. The short dashed line is the events when (∆m2[eV2], B0[Gauss]) = (5 ×10−4,
5 × 109), using the model NH8, corresponding to the case (B) in Fig. 12. The long-dashed and dot-dashed
lines are differential events with (∆m2, B0) = (3 × 10−2, 5 × 109) and (1.5 × 10−2, 2 × 109), respectively,
and the model NH4 is used for both the lines. The former corresponds to the bar (C) and the latter to
the bar (D) in Fig. 11.
19
Fig. 1
Fig. 2
1
Fig. 3
Fig. 4
2
Fig. 5
Fig. 6
3
Fig. 7
4
Fig. 8
Fig. 9
5
Fig. 10
Fig. 11
6
Fig. 12
Fig. 13
7
Fig. 14
Fig. 15
8
Fig. 16
9
|
0802.3742 | 3 | 0802 | 2008-05-19T22:20:13 | X-ray observations of the Coma Cluster in a broad energy band with INTEGRAL, RXTE, and ROSAT observatories | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present results of X-ray observations of the Coma cluster with multiple instruments over a broad energy band. Using the data from INTEGRAL, RXTE and ROSAT observatories, we find that the Coma spectrum in the 0.5-107 keV energy band can be well approximated by a thermal plasma emission model with a temperature of T=8.2 keV. INTEGRAL was used to image the cluster emission in the hard energy band. The cluster is only marginally detectable ~1.6sigma in the 44-107 keV energy band; however, the raw flux in this band is consistent with the previous results from Beppo-SAX and RXTE observatories. We can exclude with high significance that the hard-band flux reported by Beppo-SAX and RXTE could be produced by a single point source. The 20-80 keV flux of a possible non-thermal component in the cluster spectrum is (6.0+-8.8)*10**-12 ergs/cm^2/s. It is unlikely that the IC scattering of CMB photons is able to produce hard X-ray flux at these levels, unless the magnetic field strength is as low as 0.2muG. The latter value can be considered as a lower limit on the field strength in Coma. We also present a temperature map of the central part of the cluster, which shows significant variations and in particular, a hot, ~11.5 keV, region in the extension towards the subcluster infalling from the South-West. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Submitted to ApJ 2/24/2008; Revised 5/15/08; arXiv:0802.3742
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 03/07/07
X-RAY OBSERVATIONS OF THE COMA CLUSTER IN A BROAD ENERGY BAND WITH INTEGRAL, RXTE AND
ROSAT OBSERVATORIES.
A. A. Lutovinov1,2, A. Vikhlinin2,1, E. M. Churazov3,1, M. G. Revnivtsev3,1, R. A. Sunyaev3,1
Submitted to ApJ 2/24/2008; Revised 5/15/08; arXiv:0802.3742
ABSTRACT
We present results of X-ray observations of the Coma cluster with multiple instruments over a broad energy
band. Using the data from INTEGRAL, RXTE and ROSAT observatories, we find that the Coma spectrum in the
0.5 − 107 keV energy band can be well approximated by a thermal plasma emission model with a temperature
of T = 8.2 keV. INTEGRAL was used to image the cluster emission in the hard energy band. The cluster is only
marginally detectable (∼ 1.6 σ) in the 44−107 keV energy band; however, the raw flux in this band is consistent
with the previous results from Beppo-SAX and RXTE observatories. We can exclude with high significance that
the hard-band flux reported by Beppo-SAX and RXTE could be produced by a single point source. The 20 − 80
keV flux of a possible non-thermal component in the cluster spectrum is (6.0 ± 8.8) × 10−12 ergs cm−2 s−1. It
is unlikely that the IC scattering of CMB photons is able to produce hard X-ray flux at these levels, unless the
magnetic field strength is as low as 0.2 µG. The latter value can be considered as a lower limit on the field
strength in Coma. We also present a temperature map of the central part of the cluster, which shows significant
variations and in particular, a hot, ∼ 11.5 keV, region in the extension towards the subcluster infalling from the
South-West.
Subject headings: clusters of galaxies: general -- clusters of galaxies: individual(Coma)
1. INTRODUCTION
Hot intracluster gas should have an admixture of non-
thermal components, including relativistic electrons, mag-
netic fields, relativistic protons, and supra-thermal electrons.
Some of these components are expected on the theoretical
grounds while the presence of relativistic electrons and siz-
able magnetic fields is clear from observations of cluster ra-
dio halos (see e.g., a recent review by Ferrari et al. 2008).
Often, the very existence of non-thermal components in the
ICM poses interesting problems which have been studied in-
tensively (see Rephaeli et al. 2008, for a recent review). The
relativistic electron population in clusters can be studied in
the hard X-ray band through the high-energy spectral compo-
nents observed on top of the thermal bremsstrahlung spectra.
If such components are present at the intensity levels accessi-
ble with the current instrumentation, their likely origin is in-
verse Compton (IC) scattering of the cosmic microwave back-
ground photons; the models in which high-energy X-rays are
produced by bremsstrahlung of the supra-thermal electrons
are less attractive (e.g., Petrosian, 2001; Petrosian, Bykov
& Rephaeli, 2008; Petrosian & Eats, 2008) because subrel-
ativistic electrons are subject to strong Coulomb losses (but
see Dogiel et al. (2007)). At some level, an excess around
20 -- 30 keV with respect to a single-temperature fit can be at-
tributed to the presence of localized patches of hot gas with
temperatures substantially exceeding the cluster average. The
amplitude and the shape of such high energy excess is an im-
portant diagnostic for the non-isothermality of the gas.
A classic application of the hard X-ray spectral observa-
tions is the measurement of the bulk magnetic field strength
via comparison of the inverse Compton and radio synchrotron
emission (e.g., Felten & Morrison 1966, Tucker et al., 1973,
Rephaeli 1979). A prime object for such studies is the Coma
Electronic address: [email protected]
1 Space Research Institute, Moscow, Russia
2 Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, Cambridge, 02138 MA,
USA
3 Max-Planck-Institut fur Astrophysik, Garching, Germany
cluster, which possesses a bright, well-studied radio halo (see,
e.g., Thierbach, Klein, & Wielebinski (2003)). Since Coma
is also the nearest rich cluster, it was observed with virtually
every X-ray observatory flown.
Detection of the hard X-ray component in excess over the
extrapolation of the thermal spectrum in Coma was first re-
ported from the RXTE and Beppo-SAX observations (Rephaeli
et al. 1999; Fusco-Femiano et al. 1999), later confirmed by
more extensive analyses (Rephaeli & Gruber 2002; Fusco-
Femiano et al. 2004). The statistical significance of these
detections remains not very high (e.g., Fusco-Femiano et al.
2004, reported a ∼ 4.8σ detection), and the reported detec-
tions are subject to criticism (e.g., Rossetti & Molendi 2004,
report only a ∼ 2σ significance of the hard component from
independent reanalysis of the data). Even if a hard compo-
nent exists in the Coma spectrum, we cannot exclude, on the
basis of the Beppo-SAX of RXTE data, a possibility that it is
produced by, e.g., a strongly absorbed AGN. Obviously, the
situation can be improved through observations of Coma with
an imaging hard X-ray telescope.
Telescopes of the INTEGRAL observatory (Winkler et al.
2003) offer a unique combination of good sensitivity and an-
gular resolution in hard X-rays. The total INTEGRAL expo-
sure of the Coma cluster is almost 106 sec, leading to the sen-
sitivity for an extended source at E ∼ 50 keV which is com-
parable to that of the Beppo-SAX and RXTE data. Coma is
detected by INTEGRAL with high significance at E < 30 keV,
where the emission is dominated by the thermal component;
the analysis in this energy band has been reported by Renaud
et al. (2006) and Eckert et al. (2007); Renaud et al. (2006) also
used the first 500 ksec of the Coma data to put limits on the
hard X-ray component. In this work, we present a systematic
analysis of the hard X-ray component using the full INTE-
GRAL exposure in combination with the data from ROSAT
and RXTE. The combination of the data from these satel-
lites provides an accurate, self-consistent measurement of the
broad band thermal spectrum of Coma, which is critical for
detection of non-thermal components at or below 50 keV. We
2
LUTOVINOV ET AL.
also present a temperature map of the central region of Coma
obtained from the ratio of INTEGRAL and ROSAT bright-
nesses.
All distance-dependent quantities are reported assuming
that Coma is at d = 90.5 Mpc (corresponding to z = 0.023
and H0 = 70 km s−1 Mpc−1).
2. OBSERVATIONS AND DATA ANALYSIS
We use X-ray observations of the Coma cluster performed
by ROSAT, RXTE, and INTEGRAL. These observatories com-
bined cover a very broad energy range, 0.5 -- 100 keV, and thus
provide a very high-quality broad band spectrum. Since Coma
is a bright X-ray source, the spectral measurements with each
instrument are relatively straightforward. The main compli-
cation is adjusting the observed spectra to account for the dif-
ferent spatial response: ROSAT is a direct-imaging telescope;
INTEGRAL is a coded-mask imager which results in a rather
broad Point Spread Function (PSF) in reconstructed images;
RXTE is a collimator with a beam pattern which is slightly
smaller than the cluster size. Also, the statistical quality of the
Coma data in the ROSAT and RXTE energy bands is very high
and so uncertainties are dominated by the instrument cross-
calibration. These issues are discussed below for each tele-
scope individually.
2.1. INTEGRAL
Fig. 1. -- The "growth functions" (flux integrated within a given radius in
the reconstructed image) of the Coma cluster (solid circles) and Crab nebula
(open circles) in the 17− 22 keV energy band. The solid line shows a growth
curve expected for a β-model profile with β = 0.741 and rc = 10.7(cid:48) (parame-
ters for the β-model in the ROSAT band). The Crab flux was rescaled to the
Coma level for comparison.
Coma was targeted by INTEGRAL in several sets of obser-
vations with a total exposure near 106 seconds (revolutions
36, 71, 72, 274, 275, 317, 318, 319, 324, 325). We con-
centrated here on the data from ISGRI detector (Lebrun et
al. 2003) of the IBIS telescope (Ubertini et al. 2003). This
telescope provides a wide field of view (28◦ × 28◦) and an
angular resolution of 12(cid:48). The telescope is sensitive over ap-
proximately 17 − 200 keV energy band. Some fraction of
the IBIS data was affected by Solar flares and was discarded
from the analysis. The clean set of IBIS data was initially
reduced in individual pointings (so called science windows),
each with a typical duration ∼ 2 ksec. The reconstructed im-
ages were combined into a single mosaic which was analyzed
further. The total dead-time corrected combined exposure was
990 ksec.
The IBIS/ISGRI image reconstruction algorithm was dis-
cussed previously in Krivonos et al. (2005, 2007), and we re-
fer the reader to these works. A crucial prerequisite for this
-- and any other coded mask image reconstruction algorithm
-- is the ability to accurately predict the detector background
image in the absence of any sources. Our image reconstruc-
tion software uses standard calibration tables (OSA 6.04) were
used to correct the event energies depending of their rise-time.
We applied, however, additional corrections associated with
the secular change of gain (see discussion in Tsygankov et al.
2006).
Angular size of the Coma cluster is significantly larger
than the IBIS PSF. This is apparent from the comparison of
the "growth function" (flux integrated within an aperture) for
Coma and a point source (Crab) shown in Fig.1. While es-
sentially all of Crab flux is concentrated within 12(cid:48) (three
4(cid:48) pixels in the reconstructed image), for Coma the curve
continues to grow up to a 30(cid:48) radius. In fact, the observed
growth curve is consistent with that for a β-model (Cava-
liere & Fusco-Femiano 1976) fit to the ROSAT image, S (r) =
S 0(1 + r2/rc2)−3β+0.5, with β = 0.741 and rc = 10.7(cid:48). Because
4 http://isdc.unige.ch
of such a good agreement, the total Coma flux in the INTE-
GRAL energy bands can be obtained by fitting a normalization
of the β-model instead of directly integrating the flux in each
pixel within a wide aperture. The advantage of this method is
that it provides a higher statistical accuracy since each pixel
is added with an optimal weight. Direct integration, however,
is less model-dependent since the hard-band thermal -- and
especially, the inverse Compton -- emission in general does
not have to follow the distribution of the surface brightness in
the ROSAT band. Given the pros and cons, our choice is to
use the β-model fluxes throughout but always check that they
are consistent with the direct integration.
The limiting factor for the INTEGRAL observations of the
Coma cluster is the level of background fluctuations. In addi-
tion to purely statistical fluctuations, the background can leave
systematic variations in the reconstructed image if subtracted
incompletely from the raw detector image. Every care was
taken, therefore, to ensure that the background was subtracted
correctly. Background templates were taken from observa-
tions of "empty" fields closest in time to each Coma pointing
or group of pointings. With this approach, we correctly take
into account all possible temporal variations of ISGRI back-
ground. As a final check, we checked the statistics of fluctua-
tions in the reconstructed image (similar to the analysis in §3
of Krivonos et al. (2007)), and also fluxes within 40(cid:48) circles at
different off-axis locations. In both cases, the variations had
the mean consistent with zero and the dispersion equal to that
expected for the purely Poisson fluctuations. We conclude,
that the accuracy of our background modeling has reached its
fundamental statistical limit (for the exposure time accumu-
lated during Coma observations).
counts
to physical flux units
(erg s−1 cm−2), we used the calibration observations of the
Crab nebula which are regularly performing by INTEGRAL.
Crab observations were reduced with the same software
setup we used for Coma and the counts-to-flux conversion
coefficients were determined assuming the "conventional"
spectral parameters for Crab, I = 9.7 phot s−1 cm−2 keV−1
To convert
ISGRI
INTEGRAL OBSERVATIONS OF THE COMA CLUSTER
3
follows the ROSAT image, the effective flux fraction within
the PCA FOV can be computed as
(cid:82)
(cid:82)
S (x, y) × (R(x, y) ⊗ G(x, y)) dxdy
S (x, y) dxdy
= 0.763,
(1)
where S (x, y) is the ROSAT image and G(x, y) is a Gaussian.
To obtain total Coma fluxes, the observed RXTE count rates
should be divided by this factor.
In addition to the FOV correction, we need to ensure good
cross-calibration of the RXTE/PCA with ROSAT and INTE-
GRAL. To this end, we note that the best-fit parameters of
the Crab spectrum obtained with the standard PCA response
matrix differ significantly from the "conventional" values:
2.09 ± 0.04 and 11.6 ± 0.4 phot s−1 cm−2 keV−1 instead of
2.1 and 9.7 phot s−1 cm−2 keV−1, respectively, indicating a
possible problem with the PCA absolute calibration (Revnivt-
sev et al. 2003). An ad-hoc correction factor,
fcorr(E) = 0.836E−0.01
(2)
applied to the observed PCA spectra brings the Crab results
into agreement with the conventional average spectrum (Toor
& Seward 1994). We apply this correction factor also to the
Coma data. We note that this eliminates a 20% difference in
flux when the PCA spectrum is extrapolated to the ROSAT
band; the INTEGRAL and PCA fluxes near 20 keV are also
in a good agreement after this correction is applied (Fig.2).
Since we effectively base the PCA response calibration on the
absolute Crab spectrum, we need to assign systematic errors
to account for the uncertainties in the latter. The uncertainty
of the Crab spectral index, ±0.04 (Revnivtsev et al. 2003) can
be approximated if we bin the PCA data into five wide en-
ergy channels and assign a 7% uncertainty to the flux in each
channel.
2.3. ROSAT
The ROSAT PSPC pointed observations of Coma were re-
duced as described in Vikhlinin et al. (1999). The reduc-
tion pipeline was based on S. Snowden's software (Snowden
et al. 1994). This software eliminates periods of high parti-
cle and scattered solar backgrounds as well as those intervals
when the detector may be unstable. Exposure maps in several
energy bands are then created using detector maps obtained
during the ROSAT All-Sky Survey. The exposure maps in-
clude vignetting and all detector artifacts. The unvignetted
particle background is estimated and subtracted from the data
even though the PSPC particle background is low compared
to the cosmic X-ray background. The scattered solar X-ray
background also should be subtracted separately, because, de-
pending on the viewing angle, it can introduce a constant
background gradient across the image. Most of Solar X-rays
were eliminated by simply excluding time intervals when this
emission was high, but the remaining contribution was also
modeled and subtracted. The remaining background was esti-
mated by extracting the radial surface brightness profile from
the merged data, and fitting it to the β + const model at large
radii. The background-subtracted images are suitable for di-
rect extraction of fluxes in the energy bands of interest. Our
imaging analysis uses the 0.5 -- 2 keV band images.
3. RESULTS
3.1. Spectral analysis
The combined energy spectrum of Coma from INTEGRAL
(17− 107 keV), RXTE (3− 20 keV), and ROSAT (0.5− 2 keV)
Fig. 2. -- Broadband spectrum of the Coma cluster from INTEGRAL
(filled circles), RXTE (open squares), and ROSAT (open circles). The best-fit
MEKAL model is shown by solid line. The contribution of non-thermal com-
ponents corresponding to the Rephaeli & Gruber (2002) and Fusco-Femiano
et al. (2004) detections is shown by dotted and dashed lines, respectively. A
2σ upper limit for a point source emission is shown by a dashed-dotted line.
(Toor & Seward 1994).
After experimenting with energy bands for the Coma anal-
ysis, we chose to extract fluxes in the 17 − 22, 22 − 28.5,
28.5 − 44, and 44 − 107 keV bands. ISGRI efficiency quickly
drops below 17 keV setting a natural lower limit for the energy
band. The width of the two lower channels, factor of 1.3 in en-
ergy, was chosen to ensure high statistical significance of the
Coma detection (> 7σ). The flux in the 44− 107 keV channel
should be dominated by non-thermal components. The third
channel, 28.5 − 44 keV fills the gap.
Source fluxes were extracted within the 60(cid:48) radius. This
aperture, one the one hand, contains almost all of the INTE-
GRAL X-ray flux (Fig.1), and on the other hand matches the
size of the RXTE field of view, making flux comparisons eas-
ier. ROSAT pointings fully cover this region.
2.2. RXTE
Coma was observed by RXTE for ∼ 90 ksec (Obs.ID 10368)
and the data from its PCA spectrometer can be used to mea-
sure the cluster spectrum in the 3 − 20 keV energy band.
The data reduction was done with standard programs of the
LHEASOFT package (v6.0). To increase the sensitivity and
reduce systematic uncertainties, we used only data of the first
layers of PCA detectors. The background was based on the
"L7 240CM" model (this includes both the particle-induced
detector background and the all-sky average of the Cosmic
X-ray Background).
One of the complications in the RXTE analysis is to cor-
rectly compute the flux fraction outside the PCA collimator
FOV. The PCA beam pattern can be modeled as a convolu-
tion of a near-conical response of the individual collimator,
R(x, y), with a Gaussian (σ = 6(cid:48)) which corresponds to mis-
alignment of individual collimators and spacecraft pointing
drift during the observation (Jahoda et al. 2006). R(x, y) is
tabulated in the calibration file pcacol. Assuming that in the
PCA energy band, the Coma surface brightness distribution
4
LUTOVINOV ET AL.
Beppo-SAX band. The Beppo-SAX data points below 20 keV
seem to be a factor of 1.5 -- 2 below our RXTE and INTEGRAL
measurements, and hence they imply a lower thermal compo-
nent flux. These discrepancies underscore the importance of
using a broad-band spectra for detection of non-thermal com-
ponents from hot clusters at around E = 50 keV.
Where INTEGRAL can do significantly better than the pre-
vious observatories is to check whether this emission can be
attributed to single point source within the cluster. We do
not detect any significant point sources in the hard-band im-
age (see below) and a 2σ upper limit on the point source flux
is 7.6 × 10−12 ergs cm−2 s−1 in the 44 -- 107 keV band. This
is below the fluxes of non-thermal components reported by
Fusco-Femiano et al. (2004) and Rephaeli & Gruber (2002),
and so we can exclude a possibility that these detections can
be attributed to a single persistent AGN.
3.2. Imaging analysis
To study the spatial structure of the cluster emission, we
used images in the 17 − 28.5 keV ("soft") and 44 − 107 keV
("hard") INTEGRAL bands. The first band is a combination of
two spectral channels where the cluster emission was detected
with high significance; the second band is where the putative
non-thermal component should dominate the thermal plasma
emission. The images are shown in Fig.4. In the soft band,
Coma is clearly an extended source (see Eckert et al. 2007, for
detailed modeling of the INTEGRAL image); a point source
would be confined to a ∼ 3 × 3 pixels square in these images.
The contours in Fig.4 show the ROSAT surface brightness
levels in the 0.5 -- 2 keV band. The INTEGRAL soft-band im-
age shows an elongation towards the infalling subcluster and
a small offset relative to the ROSAT surface brightness peak
(see also Eckert et al. 2007). The off-set is ∼ 4.3(cid:48) to the West
(Fig.4); it is small but significant (e.g., the locations of the two
AGNs detected in the Coma field, NGC 4151 and NGC 4388
are within 0.2(cid:48) of their optical positions). As we discuss be-
low, the offset between INTEGRAL and ROSAT images most
likely reflects the temperature variations within the cluster.
We now discuss the hard-band INTEGRAL image (44 --
107 keV). As was discussed above, the total flux within 60(cid:48)
was detected in this band with a 1.6 σ significance. Can this
emission be associated with a small number of point sources
or with an extended component centered on the cluster? The
raw image (Fig.4b) does not show any significant structures.
The brightest spots correspond to 1.5 − 2 σ significance. In
particular, we can exclude a possibility that the flux measured
by INTEGRAL in this band can be attributed to a single point
source; a 2 σ upper limit is ∼ 7.6 × 10−12 ergs cm−2 s−1. Fig-
ure 5 shows the hard-band image smoothed with the ROSAT
β-model to illustrate the distribution of a more extended com-
ponent. Again, there are no statistically significant features in
the smoothed image. A local maximum near the Coma center
is offset from the cluster location and in fact is not the bright-
est feature in the field. Therefore, we cannot conclude that the
hard emission is spatially coincident with the Coma cluster; it
is more consistent with being a statistical fluctuation.
3.3. Temperature Map
INTEGRAL's ability to reconstruct X-ray images in the 20 --
30 keV band opens a unique opportunity to compute the
temperature map of Coma simply from the ratio of INTE-
GRAL and ROSAT surface brightnesses. The INTEGRAL
energy band is above the exponential cutoff in the thermal
T ∼ 10 keV spectrum, thus the resulting temperature map
Fig. 3. -- Photon spectra of Coma, derived in this work (symbols with
the same meaning as in Fig.2) and from Beppo-SAX (open triangles, Fusco-
Femiano et al. 2004). We did not adjust the normalization of the Beppo-SAX
spectrum to account for the cluster flux outside the collimator FOV. Note the
overall mismatch in spectral slope between our RXTE and INTEGRAL mea-
surements in the 15 -- 50 keV energy band. This has implications for the de-
composition of the observed data into thermal and non-thermal components.
is shown in Fig.2. The spectrum can be well fit with the ther-
mal plasma emission (MEKAL) with the temperature T =
8.2 ± 0.2 keV, abundance fixed at 0.250 Solar (Arnaud et al.
2001), and Galactic absorption NH = 9 × 1019 cm−2. The
best-fit approximation is shown in Fig.2 by a solid line. This
model gives a flux in the INTEGRAL band, 17 − 60 keV,
of fx = 5.6 × 10−11 erg cm−2 s−1 and luminosity Lx =
7.1 × 1043 ergs s−1. The corresponding flux and luminosity in
the 2 − 10 keV energy band are fx = 4.2 × 10−10 erg cm−2 s−1
and Lx = 5.1 × 1044 ergs s−1. The flux and luminosity un-
certainties in these bands are dominated by systematic errors
which we estimate to be of order 5%.
INTEGRAL fluxes at E (cid:46) 44 keV are in full agreement with
the thermal spectrum. The thermal component (including pos-
sible contribution from hotter regions within the cluster, see
below) should make a negligible contribution at higher ener-
gies. The INTEGRAL-measured flux in the 44 -- 107 keV band
is (1.8±1.1)×10−11 ergs cm−2 s−1. If real, this emission cannot
be attributed to the high energy tail of the thermal spectrum
and should instead represent a non-thermal component. We
note, however, that the statistical significance is low (1.6 σ)
and INTEGRAL statistical uncertainties are comparable to, or
higher than, those in the earlier RXTE or Beppo-SAX measure-
ments (Rephaeli et al. 1999; Rephaeli & Gruber 2002; Fusco-
Femiano et al. 1999, 2004). We also tried to repeat the Fusco-
Femiano et al. (2004) procedure by fixing the photon index of
a non-thermal component at Γ = 2 and fitting the total spec-
trum with a thermal plus power law model. This gives a power
law flux of (6.0±8.9)×10−12 ergs cm−2 s−1 in the 20−80 keV
energy band (same as in Fusco-Femiano et al. 2004). This is
a factor of 2.5 lower than the flux reported by Fusco-Femiano
et al. (2004) in the same energy band even though we INTE-
GRAL and Beppo-SAX appear to measure the same flux above
∼ 50 keV (Fig.3). The source of discrepancy seems to be
instead in the fluxes measured at the lower boundary of the
INTEGRAL OBSERVATIONS OF THE COMA CLUSTER
5
Fig. 5. -- Same as in Fig.4b, but converted with the beta-model. The gray
scale is different than in Fig.4b.
Fig. 4. -- INTEGRAL images (∼ 3◦ × 3◦) of the Coma region obtained in
17 − 28.5 keV (a) and 44 − 107 keV (b) energy ranges. Contours represent
the ROSAT intensity levels in the 0.5 − 2 keV energy band. Circles indicate
an r = 60(cid:48) regions around the cluster.
is very robust and relatively insensitive to the calibration un-
certainties in either instrument.
The drawback is a relatively poor PSF of INTEGRAL/IBIS
which results in a poor spatial resolution in the resulting tem-
perature map. The PSF angular size is comparable to the clus-
ter core-radius and so the ROSAT-to-INTEGRAL ratio should
take into account the redistribution of flux from the center
to large radii. To improve statistics, we smoothed the IN-
TEGRAL image (Fig.4a) with a Gaussian with σ = 5(cid:48) that
approximates the IBIS PSF in the mosaic images contain-
ing observations with different rotation angles (Krivonos et al.
2007). The smoothed image has an effective PSF that can be
approximated by a σ = 7.1(cid:48) Gaussian. To match the resolu-
tion of soft- and hard-band data, we smoothed the ROSAT im-
age with the same Gaussian before computing the ratio map.
Fig. 6. -- The temperature map of the central part of the Coma cluster. Tem-
peratures of 7.5 -- 8.5 keV, 9.5-10.5 keV and more than 11 keV correspond to
brown, yellow and white colors, respectively. Contours represent the ROSAT
intensity levels.
The obtained INTEGRAL-to-ROSAT ratio map was con-
verted to the temperature map using a lookup table of 17 -- 28.5
to 0.5 -- 2 keV flux ratios for the MEKAL model as a function
of temperature. As can be expected, this ratio is very sensitive
to the temperature (varies by a factor of ∼ 10 when T varies
from 5 to 12 keV). An approximately 10 σ detection of Coma
by INTEGRAL translates into ∼ 0.3 keV temperature uncer-
tainties in the central region. The resulting temperature map
is shown in Fig.6. The map is restricted to the region where
the hard X-ray flux is detected with at least 2.5 σ significance.
Qualitatively, our temperature map is similar to that obtained
by Arnaud et al. (2001) from the XMM-Newton data. The
6
LUTOVINOV ET AL.
most notable features are the cold region to the South-East of
the center coinciding with a filamentary structure in the X-ray
brightness (Vikhlinin et al. 1997) and the hot region in the
direction of the infalling subcluster5.
4. DISCUSSION
The possibility of using radio (synchrotron) and X-ray (In-
verse Compton) observations to constrain the strength of the
magnetic fields in plasma has been extensively discussed in
application to various astrophysical sources (e.g. Felten &
Morrison 1966, Tucker et al., 1973, Rephaeli 1979). We
make similar estimates using the parameters relevant for IN-
TEGRAL observations of the Coma cluster. For an electron
with the Lorentz factor γ (cid:29) 1 moving in a uniform magnetic
field B at a pitch angle θ the synchrotron emission spectrum
peaks at the frequency
νr ∼ 0.29
3
4π
eB sin θ
mec γ2
(3)
(e.g., Ginzburg & Syrovatskii 1965), where me, e, c are the
electron mass and charge, and the speed of light, respectively.
The synchrotron emission of the Coma halo was observed at
frequencies ranging from 30 MHz up to 1.4 GHz, and was
shown to have spectral index α ∼ 1.34 (see e.g. Kim et al.,
1990, Deiss et al., 1997 and references therein). At higher
frequencies the evidence for spectrum steepening has been
reported (Schlickeiser, Sievers & Thiemann 1987, Thierbach,
Klein, & Wielebinski 2003). Below we will use the halo flux
Fr = 0.64 ± 0.035 Jy at νr = 1.4 GHz reported by Deiss et al.
(1997). From eq.3 it follows that emission at this frequency
is provided by electrons with γr ∼ 104 if the field is order of
10 µG. We further assume that the surface brightness distri-
bution at 1.4 GHz can also be approximated by a β-model;
S r(x) ∝(cid:104)
1 +(cid:0)x/rc,r
(cid:1)2(cid:105)−3βr+0.5
,
(4)
Fig. 7. -- Bottom panel: Lorentz factor of electrons emitting synchrotron
radiation at 1.4 GHz (γr, solid line) as a function of magnetic field B and
the Lorentz factor of electrons producing 75 keV photons by up-scattering
CMB radiation (γX, dotted line). Middle panel: The life time of electrons
having Lorentz factors γr γX (solid and dotted lines respectively). The top
panel shows the comparison of the spectral intensity at 75 keV (νFν, in units
of ergs cm−2 s−1, horizontal dotted line) corresponding to the observed INTE-
GRAL 44 -- 107 flux, (1.8± 1.1)× 10−11 ergs cm−2 s−1, with the expected level
of IC emission. The model IC fluxes were computed using eq.7 for the halo
radio flux Fr = 0.64 Jy at 1.4 GHz and uniform magnetic field B. The short
and long dashed lines show the same IC level, but scaled by factors of 2.8
and 11 to illustrate the changes introduced by the assumption that magnetic
fields energy density declines with radius according to eq.8 with the parame-
ter a = 0.5 and a = 1 respectively. In this case the value of B shown along X
axis is the value of magnetic field B0 at the center of the cluster.
where rc,r and βr are the co-radius and beta-parameter of the
radio surface brightness. According to Deiss et al. (1997) the
scale size of the radio halo at 1.4 GHz is similar to that of the
X-ray halo parameters derived by Briel, Henry & Boehringer
rc,r ∼ 10.(cid:48)5, but the radio declines with ra-
(1992) (i.e.
dius more rapidly (i.e. βr > βX = 0.75). Colafrancesco,
Marchegiani & Perola (2005) fitted the surface brightness
distribution from Deiss et al. (1997) with rc,r = 23(cid:48).8 and
βr = 1.47. The volume emissivity Υ(r) of the cluster (assum-
ing spherical symmetry) at 1.4 GHz is then
Υr(r) ∝(cid:104)
1 +(cid:0)r/rc,r
(cid:1)2(cid:105)−3βr
.
(5)
We now can estimate the hard X-ray flux due to Inverse
Compton scattering of CMB photons by relativistic electrons.
The electron with the Lorentz factor γ (cid:29) 1 will up-scatter
CMB photons to a characteristic frequency
νx ∼ 4
3 γ2νCMB ∼ 4
3 γ2 3 kTCMB
,
h
(6)
where TCMB ≈ 2.7K is the CMB temperature and k is the
Boltzmann constant. Thus for the 75 keV photon the required
electron Lorentz factor is γX ∼ 9 × 103, i.e. close to the value
5 This hot region was also identified by Eckert et al. (2007) with a similar
technique (ratio of INTEGRAL and XMM-Newton fluxes); their temperature
for this region is however higher than ours (∼ 12 keV vs ∼ 9.7 keV at the dis-
tance of ∼ 14(cid:48) from the center to south-west) probably because of neglecting
the INTEGRAL PSF effects
needed to produce radio emission at 1.4 GHz for plausible
values of magnetic fields (see Fig.7, bottom panel). The ex-
pected IC flux due to CMB photons up-scattering produced by
the electrons responsible for synchrotron emission is (Felten
& Morrison 1966):
Fx = Fr × C(p)
CMBB−α−1,
T α+3
(7)
(cid:33)α
(cid:32)
νr
νx
where C(p) is a function of the power law slope of the elec-
tron energy spectrum, p, which is related to the synchrotron
spectral index as p = 2α + 1.
Assuming that B is constant across the cluster, one can cal-
culate expected IC flux for a given B and radio flux Fr using
eq.7 as is done in the top panel of Fig.7. The intersection
of the predicted (solid line) and observed (dotted line) curves
gives the value of the magnetic field ∼ 0.1-0.2 µG needed to
explain radio and hard X-ray fluxes as the synchrotron and IC
emission respectively produced by the same electron popula-
tion.
The assumption of constant B across the cluster probably
is too simplistic, especially given that energy density of the
ICM varies strongly from the center to outskirts (see, e.g.,
Dolag, Bartelmann & Lesch, 2002). The spatial variations of
the magnetic field would affect the relation of the synchrotron
and IC fluxes (Rephaeli 1979; Goldshmidt & Rephaeli 1993;
Brunetti et al. 2001; Newman et al. 2002; Colafrancesco et
al. 2005). We estimate the effects of magnetic field variations
INTEGRAL OBSERVATIONS OF THE COMA CLUSTER
7
we can use wider range of a. It follows from Fig.8 that the
change in a from 0 to 1 changes the ratio f (a) by a factor of
∼11. This translates into the uncertainty in the estimated B0
by a factor of f (a)1/(1+α) ∼ 2.8. An additional uncertainty is
introduced by our determination of the hard X-ray flux which
was done by convolution of the INTEGRAL image with the
surface brightness model observed at E = 1 keV by ROSAT.
If, for example, the true surface brightness in the hard band
has the same core-radius but β is varied in the range 0.3-1.5,
this would change our derived values of B0 by ±30%.
Although the modeling uncertainties described above are
substantial, they do not change the conclusion that it is un-
likely that the IC emission in the 44− 107 keV band can reach
the flux levels comparable to the ISGRI/INTEGRAL sensitiv-
ity, unless the magnetic field is as low as a few×0.1 µG. For
these low values of the magnetic field the life time is shorter
for electrons responsible for the radio synchrotron emission
(Fig.7) and thus the IC spectrum of the electron population
has to be close to a power law, as long as a power law spec-
trum is observed in the radio.
If we treat the observed hard X-ray flux as a detection, the
derived B ∼ 0.1 − 0.2 µG is an order of magnitude below the
values derived from Faraday rotation B ∼ 1.7 µG (e.g., Kim
et al. 1990). Various ways to bring these estimates into agree-
ment have been discussed (see e.g. Goldshmidt & Rephaeli
1993, Petrosian 2001, Brunetti et al., 2001, Newman et al.
2002). The most obvious factor affecting these estimates is
the spatial variations of the field strength. Note that the Fara-
day rotation signal depends on the line of sight integral of the
product of the electron density and the parallel component of
the field. The value of the field derived from the compari-
son of the cluster IC and radio fluxes depends instead on the
volume averaged non-linear function of the field (see eq.10).
Thus different assumptions on the non-uniformity of the mag-
netic field will affect differently the estimates of B with these
two methods and the above mentioned discrepancy can be at
least partly removed.
However, given the low significance of the signal, we
should treat the INTEGRAL results as an upper limit on the
IC flux. Our 2σ upper limit in the 44 − 107 keV band is
perfectly consistent with the magnetic fields stronger than
few×0.1 µG. For even larger fields, the expected IC signal
drops as ≈ B−α−1 ≈ B−2.34 and will be below the reach of even
planned future experiments. For example, for B = 10 µG, the
expected IC flux at E = 75 keV is a factor of ∼ 104 below the
INTEGRAL sensitivity, even without account for any possible
electron aging (see Fig.7).
5. SUMMARY
The summary of main results from the deep observations
of the Coma cluster with INTEGRAL and combining these
observations with results of RXTE and ROSAT observatories
lead us to the following conclusions:
1) The total cluster spectrum in the 0.5 -- 50 keV energy band
is well described by the thermal plasma emission with the
mean temperature T (cid:39) 8.2 keV;
2) There are significant temperature variations within the
cluster and the mean 8.2 keV temperature is the result of
mixing emission components with T ranging from 7.5 to
10.5 keV. The temperature near the ROSAT surface brightness
peak is ∼ 8.5 keV.
3) We do not detect a significant excess over the thermal
spectrum at high energies. The upper limit on the non-thermal
flux is, however, consistent with the previous detections re-
Fig. 8. -- Variations of IC flux on the different behavior of the magnetic field
with radius. The parameterization is done in the form B2(r) = B2
. See
0
text for details.
using a simple parameterization,
ρ0
(cid:16) ρ(r)
(cid:17)a
B2(r) = B2
0 (ρ(r)/ρ0)a,
(8)
where ρ(r) is the thermal gas density, which scales approxi-
mately as the ICM pressure if the gas density variations are
much stronger than those of temperature over the region of
interest. Adopting the ROSAT β-model for the gas density
distribution, we can write:
(cid:104)
1 +(cid:0)x/rc,x
(cid:1)2(cid:105)− 3
B(r) = B0
4 aβx
,
(9)
where B0 is the magnetic field at the center of the cluster. In
this parameterization a = 0 corresponds to the case of a con-
stant magnetic field, while a = 1 implies that energy density
of the magnetic field scales as the ICM pressure. Compared
to the constant B case (i.e. eq.7) the ratio of the IC and syn-
chrotron fluxes (within given distance from the center) has to
be multiplied by an additional factor f (a):
(cid:16) B
(cid:17)−α−1 r2dr
(cid:82) Υr(r)
(cid:82) Υr(r)r2dr
B0
f (a) =
,
(10)
where Υr(r) is given by eq.5 where the integration is in the
range r = 0− 60(cid:48). The computed factor f (a) is shown in Fig.8
(in these calculations we assumed the X-ray surface bright-
ness parameters rc,r = rc,x = 10(cid:48).68, βr = βx = 0.741).
The total IC flux (up to infinity) may actually diverge for
large a since the drop of the B at large distances from the cen-
ter has to be "compensated" by energy density of relativistic
particles to maintain the assumed ΥE(r). This causes strong
increase of IC emission. Formally for convergence (up to in-
finity) one needs:
a <
2(2βr − 1)
βx(α + 1) ,
(11)
which translates to a < 0.55 for our parameters. However,
since we integrate the hard X-ray flux only within a 1◦ radius,
8
LUTOVINOV ET AL.
ported on the basis of Beppo-SAX and RXTE observations.
4) It is unlikely that IC emission in hard X-rays can reach
the flux level comparable with the INTEGRAL/ISGRI sensi-
tivity for the magnetic fields strongerr than few×0.1 µG. A 2σ
upper limit of the hard X-ray flux from INTEGRAL is consis-
tent with B (cid:46) 1 µG.
This work is based on observations with INTEGRAL, and
made use of the INTEGRAL Science Data Center (Versoix,
Switzerland), Russian Science Data Center of INTEGRAL
(Moscow, Russia) and the High Energy Astrophysics Sci-
ence Archive Research Center Online Service, provided by
the NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center. The work was sup-
ported by the Chandra grant GO5-6121A, RFBR grant 07-02-
01051, DFG grant CH389/3-2, the "Extended objects in the
Universe" program of the Russian Academy of Sciences, and
a program of support for leading scientific schools (Project
NSH-1100.2006.2). AL thanks CfA for hospitality during the
course of this research.
REFERENCES
Arnaud M., Aghanim N., Gastaud R., et al., 2001, A&A, 365, L67
Briel U., Henry J. & Boehringer H., 1992, A&A, 259, L31
Brunetti, G., Setti, G., Feretti, L., & Giovannini, G. 2001, MNRAS, 320, 365
Colafrancesco S., Marchegiani P. & Perola G., 2005, A&A, 443, 1
Deiss B., Reich W., Lesch H., Wielebinski R., 1997, A&A, 321, 55
Dogiel V., Colafrancesco S., Ko C., et al., 2007, A&A, 461, 433
Dolag K., Bartelmann M. & Lesch H., 2002, A&A, 387, 383
Eckert D., Neronov A., Courvoisier T., Produit N., 2007, A&A, 470, 835
Ferrari C., Govoni F., Schindler S., et al., 2008, Space Sci. Rev.(accepted),
arXiv:0801.0985
Felten J. & Morrison P., 1966, ApJ, 146, 686
Fusco-Femiano R., dal Fiume D., Feretti L., et al., 1999, ApJ, 513, L21
Fusco-Femiano R., Orlandini M., Brunetti G., et al., 2004, ApJ, 602, L73
Ginzburg V. L. & Syrovatskii S. I., 1965, ARA&A, 3, 297
Goldshmidt, O., & Rephaeli, Y. 1993, ApJ, 411, 518
Jahoda K., Markwardt C., Radeva B., et al. 2006, ApJS, 163, 401
Kim K.-T., Kronberg P., Dewdney P., Landecker T., 1990, ApJ, 355, 29
Krivonos R., Vikhlinin A., Churazov E. et al., 2005, ApJ, 625, 89
Krivonos R., Revnivtsev M., Lutovinov A., et al., 2007, A&A, 475, 775
Lebrun F., Leray J., Lavocat P., et al., 2003, A&A, 411,
Neuman , et al., 2003,
Newman, W. I., Newman, A. L., & Rephaeli, Y. 2002, ApJ, 575, 755
Petrosian, V. 2001, ApJ, 557, 560
Petrosian, V., Bykov, A., & Rephaeli, Y. 2008, Space Science Reviews, 37
714
19
Petrosian, V., & East, W. E. 2008, ArXiv e-prints, 802, arXiv:0802.0900
Renaud M., Belanger G., Paul J., et al., 2006, A&A, 453, L5
Rephaeli Y., 1979, ApJ, 227, 364
Rephaeli Y., Gruber D. & Blanco P., 1999, ApJ, 511, L21
Rephaeli Y. & Gruber D., 2002, ApJ, 579, 587
Rephaeli, Y., Nevalainen, J., Ohashi, T., & Bykov, A. M. 2008, Space Science
Reviews, 16 (arXiv:0801.0982)
Revnivtsev M., Gilfanov M., Sunyaev R., et al., 2003, A&A, 411, 329
Rossetti M.& Molendi S., 2004, A&A, 414, L41
Schlickeiser R., Sievers A. & Thiemann H., 1987, A&A, 182, 21
Snowden S., McCammon D., Burrows D., Mendenhall J., 1994, ApJ, 424,
Thierbach M., Klein U., Wielebinski R., 2003, A&A, 397, 53
Toor A. & Seward F., 1994, AJ, 79, 995
Tsygankov S., Lutovinov A., Churazov E., Sunyaev R., 2006, MNRAS, 371,
Tucker W., Kellogg E., Gursky H., et al., 1973, ApJ, 180, 715
Ubertini P., Lebrun F., Di Cocco, et al. 2003, A&A, 411, L131
Vikhlinin A., Forman W. & Jones C., 1997, ApJ, 474, L7
Vikhlinin A., Forman W. & Jones C., 1999, ApJ, 525, 47
Winkler C., Courvoisier T., Di Cocco G., et al., 2003, A&A, 411, L1
|
astro-ph/0002444 | 1 | 0002 | 2000-02-24T01:13:38 | Heliospheric, Astrospheric, and Insterstellar Lyman-alpha Absorption Toward 36 Oph | [
"astro-ph"
] | We use high-resolution UV spectra taken by the Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph instrument on board the Hubble Space Telescope to study the 5.5 pc line of sight to the K0 V star 36 Oph A. The one interstellar component detected for this line of sight has a velocity inconsistent with the local interstellar cloud (LIC) flow vector, but consistent with the flow vector of the so-called G cloud, a very nearby warm cloud in the Galactic Center direction. From our data, we measure the following values for the interstellar temperature, nonthermal velocity, H I column density, and D/H value: T=5900+/-500 K, xi=2.2+/-0.2$ km/s, log N(H)=17.85+/-0.15, and D/H=(1.5+/-0.5)e-5. The temperature of the G cloud is somewhat lower than that of the LIC, and Mg and Fe depletions are also lower, but the D/H value appears to be the same. Based on upper limits for the LIC absorption, we estimate the distance to the edge of the LIC to be d(edge)<0.19 pc, which the Sun will reach in t(edge)<7400 yrs. The H I Lyman-alpha absorption line has properties inconsistent with those of the other absorption lines, indicating the presence of one or more absorption components not seen in the other lines. We present evidence that hot neutral hydrogen local to both the Sun and the star is responsible for the excess Lyman-alpha absorption. This hot H I is created by the interaction between the ISM and the winds of the Sun and 36 Oph A. The observed line of sight lies only 12 degrees from the upwind direction of the LIC flow vector, where hydrodynamic models of the heliosphere suggest that heliospheric H I absorption should be particularly prominent. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Heliospheric, Astrospheric, and Insterstellar Lyman-α Absorption Toward
36 Oph1
Brian E. Wood, Jeffrey L. Linsky
JILA, University of Colorado, and NIST, Boulder, CO 80309-0440.
[email protected], [email protected]
and
Gary P. Zank
Bartol Research Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE 19716.
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
We use high-resolution UV spectra taken by the Space Telescope Imaging Spectro-
graph instrument on board the Hubble Space Telescope to study the 5.5 pc line of sight to
the K0 V star 36 Oph A. The one interstellar component detected for this line of sight has
a velocity inconsistent with the local interstellar cloud (LIC) flow vector, but consistent
with the flow vector of the so-called G cloud, a very nearby warm cloud in the Galactic
Center direction. From our data, we measure the following values for the interstellar
temperature, nonthermal velocity, H I column density, and D/H value: T = 5900 ± 500
K, ξ = 2.2 ± 0.2 km s−1, log NH = 17.85 ± 0.15, and D/H = (1.5 ± 0.5) × 10−5. The
temperature of the G cloud is somewhat lower than that of the LIC, and Mg and Fe
depletions are also lower, but the D/H value appears to be the same. Based on upper
limits for the LIC absorption, we estimate the distance to the edge of the LIC to be
dedge < 0.19 pc, which the Sun will reach in tedge < 7400 yrs.
The H I Lyman-α absorption line has properties inconsistent with those of the other
absorption lines, indicating the presence of one or more absorption components not
seen in the other lines. We present evidence that hot neutral hydrogen local to both
the Sun and the star is responsible for the excess Lyman-α absorption. This hot H I is
created by the interaction between the ISM and the winds of the Sun and 36 Oph A.
The observed line of sight lies only 12◦ from the upwind direction of the LIC flow vector,
where hydrodynamic models of the heliosphere suggest that heliospheric H I absorption
1Based on observations with the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope, obtained at the Space Telescope Science
Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under NASA contract
NAS5-26555.
-- 2 --
should be particularly prominent. The properties of the heliospheric absorption (T =
38, 000 ± 8000 K and log NH = 14.6 ± 0.3) are consistent with previous measurements
of this absorption for the α Cen line of sight 52◦ from the upwind direction.
Subject headings: ISM: atoms -- solar wind -- stars: individual (36 Oph A) -- stars:
winds, outflows -- ultraviolet: ISM
1.
Introduction
In 1996, high quality spectra of the very nearby star α Cen taken by the Goddard High Resolu-
tion Spectrograph instrument on board the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) yielded a serendipitous
detection of neutral hydrogen in the outer heliosphere (Linsky & Wood 1996, hereafter LW96),
thereby providing a unique new way to observationally study the structure and internal proper-
ties of the heliosphere. Previous studies of heliospheric neutral hydrogen had relied primarily on
Lyman-α backscatter measurements, which are mostly sensitive to very nearby H I (Bertaux et
al. 1985; Qu´emerais et al. 1995). In the α Cen data, the heliospheric H I produces an absorption
signature in the stellar Lyman-α line that allows it to be detected despite being highly blended
with absorption from the local interstellar medium (LISM). LW96 demonstrated that the properties
of the heliospheric H I inferred from the data are consistent with the predictions of heliospheric
models (Baranov & Malama 1993, 1995; Pauls, Zank, & Williams 1995; Zank et al. 1996; Zank
1999). Gayley et al. (1997) confirmed this result by directly comparing the data with H I absorp-
tion predicted by the models, and they also found evidence that H I in the "astrosphere" of α Cen
is also accounting for some of the non-LISM absorption observed in the Lyman-α line.
The α Cen line of sight lies 52◦ from the upwind direction of the interstellar flow through the
heliosphere. In the upwind side, the heliospheric H I absorption is expected to be dominated by
neutral hydrogen in the "hydrogen wall" (or "H-wall" for short), located between the heliopause and
solar bow shock. In this region, interactions with solar wind protons heat and decelerate the plasma
component of the interstellar wind. Charge exchange with this plasma then heats, compresses, and
decelerates the neutral hydrogen as well. The high temperature and decelerated velocity of the
H I in the hydrogen wall both play important roles in allowing absorption from this material to be
detectable despite being blended with an LISM absorption component with a much larger column
density. The high temperature broadens the H-wall absorption substantially, and the deceleration
shifts the absorption away from the LISM absorption, resulting in a noticeable excess of Lyman-α
absorption on the red side of the line.
The deceleration should be at its largest in the upwind direction, so the Lyman-α signature
of the H-wall should become even easier to detect if one looks closer to the upwind direction than
the α Cen line of sight 52◦ away. Thus, we searched for another target for HST that would be
much closer to the upwind direction. We chose the nearby (d = 5.5 pc) K0 V star 36 Oph A (=HD
155886), which is only 12◦ from the upwind direction. Our main goals in observing this star are to
-- 3 --
confirm the detection of the solar hydrogen wall claimed in the analysis of the α Cen data, and to
provide additional constraints on the properties of the H-wall.
2. Observations and Data Reduction
On 1999 October 10, we observed 36 Oph A with the Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph
(STIS) instrument on HST. The STIS instrument is described in detail by Kimble et al. (1998) and
Woodgate et al. (1998). We observed the 1160 − 1357 A spectral region with the high-resolution
E140H grating and 0.2′′ × 0.2′′ aperture, and we used two exposures with the E230H grating and
0.1′′ × 0.2′′ aperture to observe the 2430 − 2943 A spectral range. The former region contains the
Lyman-α line at 1216 A that is of primary interest to us, while the latter region contains interstellar
lines of Mg II and Fe II. These metal lines provide important information on the properties of the
LISM that can be used to constrain the LISM H I Lyman-α absorption, making it easier to separate
it from the heliospheric absorption.
The data were reduced using the STIS team's CALSTIS software package written in IDL
(Lindler 1999). The reduction included assignment of wavelengths using calibration spectra ob-
tained during the course of the observations. A substantial amount of scattered light was clearly
present in the saturated core of the Lyman-α line. This flux was removed from the data using
the ECHELLE_SCAT routine in the CALSTIS package. A geocoronal Lyman-α emission feature in
the middle of the interstellar H I absorption was fitted with a Gaussian, and then removed by
subtracting the fitted Gaussian from the data. The centroid of the Gaussian is at −26.6 km s−1,
which agrees very well with the expected location of −26.4 km s−1 based on the Earth's projected
velocity toward the star at the time of observation. This confirms the accuracy of our wavelength
calibration.
3. Data Analysis
3.1. Single Component Fits
Besides H I Lyman-α at 1215.670 A, there are only four interstellar absorption features appar-
ent in our data that can be accurately measured: D I Lyman-α λ1215.339, Fe II λ2600.173, and
the Mg II h & k lines at 2803.531 A and 2796.352 A, respectively. The rest wavelengths quoted
above are vacuum wavelengths. These lines are all shown in Figure 1.
None of the lines in Figure 1 show any asymmetries that would indicate the presence of more
than one absorption component, so all are fitted with a single component. The dotted lines in the
figure are the fits before correction for instrumental broadening, and the thick solid lines that fit the
data are the fits after the instrumental broadening correction is applied. The line spread functions
used in these corrections were taken from Sahu et al. (1999). The oscillator absorption strengths
-- 4 --
assumed in our fits are from Morton (1991). The parameters of the fits are listed in Table 1.
In order to constrain the Mg II fits as much as possible, the 2 Mg II lines were fitted simul-
taneously with both lines forced to have the same column density (N ), Doppler parameter (b),
and central velocity (v). We were concerned about the possibility that much of the residual flux
present below the Mg II absorption lines may be scattered light. Unfortunately, there is currently
no scattered light correction for E230H data like there is for E140H spectra (see above). We tried
fits with much of the possible scattered light flux subtracted from the spectrum to see the degree to
which the fit parameters were affected. The uncertainties quoted in Table 1 include the systematic
uncertainties we estimate due to the uncertain scattered light correction.
Both LISM studies and in situ measurements of LISM material within the solar system suggest
that the velocity of the incoming interstellar wind is about 26 km s−1 (Witte et al. 1993; Lallement
et al. 1995). However, the LISM flow vector appears to be different for lines of sight toward the
Galactic center, with a faster speed of 29.4 km s−1. Thus, it has been proposed that a different
cloud lies in this direction, the so-called G cloud (Lallement & Bertin 1992). If this interpretation is
correct the Sun must be very near the edge of the Local Interstellar Cloud (LIC), since all the LISM
absorption detected by LW96 toward α Cen (which is roughly in the Galactic center direction) is
at the expected velocity of the G cloud and none is at the velocity predicted for that line of sight
by the LIC vector (see also Lallement et al. 1995).
The outlines of the LIC and the G cloud in the Galactic plane are shown in Figure 2, as are
the projected locations of the Sun, α Cen, and 36 Oph. The LIC outline is from Redfield & Linsky
(2000). The G cloud shape is not well known, so the contour shown in Figure 2 is only a crude
but plausible representation for this cloud. The velocity vectors of the LIC and G clouds are also
shown in the figure.
With Galactic coordinates of l = 358◦, b = 7◦; 36 Oph lies almost directly toward the Galactic
center, very near the upwind directions of both the LIC and G cloud vectors. The flow velocities
predicted for the 36 Oph line of sight by these two vectors are −25.1 and −28.4 km s−1, respectively.
The LISM velocity measured toward 36 Oph agrees very well with the latter velocity (see Table 1),
so we conclude that all of the LISM absorption we detect is from the G cloud. Inspection of Figure
1 reveals that there is no visible absorption component centered at the LIC velocity. Thus, our
findings are very similar to those of LW96. However, the evidence for higher flow velocities toward
the Galactic Center, and the close proximity of the edge of the LIC, is particularly striking in our
data, because even the projected LISM velocities that we directly observe are larger than the 26
km s−1 velocity that has been measured for the LIC.
We now try to estimate how far the Sun is from the edge of the LIC. We need to first estimate
an upper limit for the H I column density, and the best way to do this is to determine upper
limits for the D I and/or Mg II column densities and then calculate the H I upper limit based
on the known abundance ratios in the LIC. For both D I and Mg II we repeat the fits shown in
Figure 1, but with added LIC absorption components centered on the known LIC velocity and with
-- 5 --
Doppler parameters consistent with previous observations of LIC material (bD I = 8.2 km s−1 and
bMg II = 3.0 km s−1). We experiment with different LIC/G cloud column density ratios to see at
what point we believe the fits become unacceptable.
One might think that the Mg II lines would provide the best constraints because they are
narrower and more optically thick than D I. However, the D I/Mg II ratio is larger in the LIC
than in the G cloud by about a factor of 4 (see below). Based on experiments with different D I
fits, we estimate that the D I column density of the LIC is no more than 10% that of the G cloud,
corresponding to an upper limit of ND I < 9 × 1011 cm−2. Note that this corresponds to a LIC
contribution of 2.5% to the Mg II lines. For LIC contributions greater than this, the χ2
ν values
of the fits become significantly worse, and the G cloud D I absorption becomes more and more
blueshifted away from the expected velocity of the G cloud. (If we force it to be at the expected
velocity, the quality of the fit degrades even more.)
The LIC D/H value is 1.5 × 10−5 (Linsky 1998; Linsky & Wood 1998), so NH I < 6 × 1016
cm−2 for the LIC. Assuming a density of nH I = 0.10 cm−3 (Linsky et al. 2000), the upper limit
for the distance to the edge of the LIC is dedge < 0.19 pc for the 36 Oph line of sight, consistent
with the dedge = 0.05 pc value suggested by the LIC model of Redfield & Linsky (2000) (see Fig.
2). The LIC material is moving toward the Sun with a velocity of −25.1 km s−1 along this line of
sight, so we will reach the edge in tedge < 7400 yrs.
The Doppler parameters (b) listed in Table 1 are related to the temperature, T , and nonthermal
velocity, ξ, by the following equation:
b2 = 0.0165
T
A
+ ξ2,
(1)
where b and ξ are in units of km s−1, and A is the atomic weight of the element in question. In
Figure 3, the measured Doppler parameters of the Mg II, Fe II, and D I lines are used with equation
(1) to derive curves of ξ vs. T , with error bars. The shaded region in the figure is the area of overlap
for these curves, which identifies the temperature and ξ values for the observed LISM material.
Our measured temperature and nonthermal velocity based on this analysis are T = 5900±500 K
and ξ = 2.2 ± 0.2 km s−1. This temperature is consistent with the T = 5400 ± 500 K temperature
observed toward α Cen, supporting the assertion of LW96 that the G cloud temperature is somewhat
cooler than the LIC temperature of T = 8000 ± 1000 K (Dring et al. 1997; Piskunov et al. 1997;
Wood & Linsky 1998). However, the nonthermal velocity toward 36 Oph appears to be somewhat
larger than that observed toward α Cen (ξ = 1.25 ± 0.25 km s−1).
The relative abundances of D I, Mg II, and Fe II suggested by the column densities in Table
1 are consistent with the α Cen measurements. These results suggest that Mg and Fe are less
depleted in the G cloud than in the LIC. For example, the D I/Mg II ratio is 0.9 ± 0.4 toward
36 Oph and 1.2 ± 0.2 toward α Cen, but is ≥ 4 for the LIC (LW96; Dring et al. 1997; Piskunov
et al. 1997), with the apparent exception of the Sirius line of sight which has a D I/Mg II ratio of
about 1.7 (Lallement et al. 1994; Bertin et al. 1995).
-- 6 --
In Figure 4, we present our single component fit to the H I Lyman-α line, combined with the D I
Lyman-α fit from Figure 1. The parameters of the H I fit are provided in Table 1. In constructing
this fit, we started with an assumed stellar Lyman-α profile based on a broadened version of the
observed Mg II k line profile. We then performed an initial fit, altered the assumed stellar profile to
improve the quality of the fit, and then attempted another fit. Yet another iteration of this process
was required before arriving at the fit in Figure 4.
This Lyman-α fitting technique has been used in many past analyses (LW96; Piskunov et
al. 1997; Wood & Linsky 1998). The argument for using the Mg II line as a starting point is
that the Mg II k and Lyman-α lines are both highly optically thick chromospheric lines that have
similar shapes in the solar spectrum. It should be stated, however, that for single component fits
it actually matters little what initial model is used for the stellar Lyman-α profile. The initial
profile is altered significantly before the final best fit is determined, and the final fit parameters
are therefore independent of the initial assumptions about the shape of the stellar profile. This
was demonstrated clearly in the α Cen analysis, where the Lyman-α lines of both members of the
α Cen binary system were independently fitted with single absorption components and the derived
interstellar parameters were the same (LW96).
The residuals of the single component H I fit in Figure 4 suggest some minor systematic
discrepancies, but the quality of the fit is not too bad. However, the main problem with the fit
is that the velocity and Doppler parameter of the H I absorption are completely inconsistent with
those of the other lines, D I in particular (see Table 1). The central velocity of H I is −25.9
km s−1, as opposed to the −28.4 km s−1 average velocity observed for the other lines. The Doppler
parameter of H I (14.34 km s−1) suggests temperatures of about 12,000 K, compared with the
∼ 6000 K temperature determined mostly from D I (see Fig. 3). If a curve was plotted in Figure
3 for H I it would be a nearly vertical line centered at about 12,000 K, which actually lies off the
right edge of the figure, emphasizing just how discrepant H I is relative to D I and the other lines.
These problems with H I are very reminiscent of those found for the α Cen line of sight
(LW96). Collectively they represent the primary piece of evidence for a hydrogen wall contribution
to the Lyman-α absorption toward both α Cen and 36 Oph, because the only way to resolve the
discrepancies is to add a second absorption component to the H I fit with properties that turn out
to be consistent with those expected for the solar H-wall. The H I Lyman-α line of α Cen exhibits
a +2.2 km s−1 velocity discrepancy and about a +3000 K temperature discrepancy relative to the
other lines (LW96). The 36 Oph discrepancies are in the same direction, but are even larger (+2.5
km s−1 and +6000 K). This is consistent with our expectations, since the H-wall closer to the
upwind direction should be more decelerated and may be a bit hotter (see, e.g., Zank et al. 1996).
Since the LIC velocity is redshifted relative to the G cloud velocity, one might wonder if LIC
H I absorption might be responsible for the velocity discrepancy between H I and the other lines. In
Figure 4 we show the LIC absorption associated with the NH < 6 × 1016 cm−2 upper limit derived
above (dotted line). Essentially all of the LIC absorption is well within the saturated core of the
line, so the LIC will not have any observable effect on the Lyman-α line.
-- 7 --
3.2. The Bisector Technique
Although single component H I fits are unique and well-constrained, this is not necessarily the
case for two component fits, as LW96 demonstrated in the α Cen analysis. Thus, before attempting
a two component fit, we try to constrain the LISM H I column density by other means. Wood,
Alexander, & Linsky (1996) measured an LISM column density toward ǫ Indi by determining the
amount of absorption in the wings of the Lyman-α line, based on the assumption that the far wings
of the stellar Lyman-α profile should be centered on the rest frame of the star, as is the case for
the Sun. This "bisector technique" only works when there is a substantial wavelength difference
between the LISM absorption and the center of the stellar Lyman-α line, creating a situation where
there is more absorption in one wing than the other. This induces an apparent line shift in the
wings, the magnitude of which is dependent on the LISM column density. This analysis technique
could not be tried in the α Cen analysis, since there is no significant shift between the stellar
emission and LISM absorption, but in our 36 Oph data there is about a 30 km s−1 shift between
the two.
The bisector technique relies on an accurate stellar radial velocity. The radial velocity listed
for 36 Oph in the literature is −1 km s−1 (Hirshfeld, Sinnott, & Ochsenbein 1996). However, all
the chromospheric lines in our spectra, including Mg II h & k and the O I triplet at 1300 A, are
centered on +1.0 km s−1. Thus, we believe this is a more likely value for the radial velocity, and in
any case a far more likely value for the centroid of the Lyman-α wings. Since 36 Oph A is a member
of a binary system, we speculate that perhaps orbital motion has changed the stellar velocity from
the systemic value of −1 km s−1. Based primarily on the centroids of the Cl I λ1351.657 and O I]
λ1355.598 lines, which can be measured very accurately because of the very narrow line widths of
these features (F W HM ∼ 0.04 A), we assume a velocity of +1.0 ± 0.2 km s−1 for the star. Since
other chromospheric lines in our spectra have this centroid velocity, including Mg II h & k, it is
reasonable to assume the far wings of Lyman-α, which are formed at the base of the chromosphere,
will have it too.
Figure 5 shows how the analysis technique works. First, we fit polynomials to the wings of the
observed Lyman-α line, interpolating over the D I line. Working from these fits (thick solid lines
in Fig. 5a), we can derive what the wings of the stellar Lyman-α line would look like assuming
different values of the H I column density. The results for five different column densities are shown
in Figure 5a. In Figure 5b we display the bisectors of these wings for various values of log NH. As
the column density increases the bisectors become more and more blueshifted, due to the fact that
the LISM is absorbing more in the blue wing of the line than in the red wing.
Ideally, a vertical bisector centered at the radial velocity of the star should result when the
correct value of log NH is assumed, but in practice this does not happen due to uncertainties in
-- 8 --
the polynomial fits to the data and in measuring the location of the bisectors. Nevertheless, in
Figure 5b we identify with a solid line the bisector that we believe best matches the stellar radial
velocity of +1.0 km s−1, which corresponds to log NH = 17.84. Column densities in the range
log NH = 17.7 − 18.0 all produce bisectors with average velocities within about ±1 km s−1 of the
expected velocity, so we decide on a value of log NH = 17.85 ± 0.15 for our best estimate of the
LISM H I column density toward 36 Oph.
This range of columns yields deuterium-to-hydrogen ratios in the range D/H = (1.0 − 2.0) ×
10−5, so we quote a value of D/H = (1.5 ± 0.5) × 10−5. This is an encouraging result, since it is
consistent with the mean value D/H = (1.5 ± 0.1) × 10−5 for the LIC (Linsky 1998; Linsky & Wood
1998). The error bars in the G cloud D/H value are too large to tell if it is actually identical to
the LIC value, but apparently the G cloud does not have a drastically different D/H value than the
LIC.
3.3. Multi-Component Fits
In Figure 6a, we present a two component fit to the Lyman-α line, where the dotted line
represents LISM absorption and the dashed line represents absorption from the solar hydrogen
wall. The LISM component is forced to have the average velocity observed for the other LISM
lines (v = −28.4 km s−1) and a Doppler parameter derived from the T and ξ values measured from
the other lines (b = 10.11 km s−1). Only a single two component fit is shown in Figure 6, but
in practice we performed many fits assuming different stellar Lyman-α profiles that allowed the
LISM H I column density to vary within the log NH = 17.7 − 18.0 range allowed by the bisector
analysis. This experimentation allowed us to better determine the best fit parameters and their
uncertainties, which are listed in Table 1.
The quality of the two component fit is certainly better than the one component fit in Figure
4, based on both the residuals shown in the figures and the χ2
ν values listed in Table 1. More impor-
tantly, in the two component fit the D I and H I lines are self-consistent. The H-wall temperature
derived from the Doppler parameter of the two component fit is T = 49, 000 ± 9000 K, compared
with T = 29, 000 ± 5000 K toward α Cen. It is worth noting, however, that the meaning of these
measured temperatures is not entirely clear. The absorption component fits to the Lyman-α line
use Voigt functions for the opacity profiles, which amounts to an implicit assumption that velocity
distributions for each component are Maxwellian, but neutrals in the outer heliosphere are far from
being in equilibrium and therefore do not have Maxwellian distributions (Baranov, Izmodenov, &
Malama 1998; Lipatov, Zank, & Pauls 1998; Muller, Zank, & Lipatov 2000). Furthermore, the
absorption components are integrated over a long line of sight through the heliosphere, resulting in
even more complex velocity distributions.
There is a serious problem with the central velocity of the H-wall absorption inferred from the
two-component fit. Heliospheric models all suggest substantial decelerations within the hydrogen
-- 9 --
wall in the upwind direction (Baranov & Malama 1993, 1995; Pauls et al. 1995; Zank et al. 1996;
Baranov et al. 1998; Lipatov et al. 1998; Muller et al. 2000), meaning the H-wall absorption should
be significantly redshifted relative to projected velocity of the LIC for that line of sight, −25.1
km s−1. The measured velocity, v = −26.7 ± 0.3 km s−1, is only slightly redshifted relative to the
G cloud absorption, and it is actually blueshifted relative to the LIC velocity. Figure 6a illustrates
why this is the case. Non-LISM absorption exists on both the blue and red sides of the H I
absorption feature, and the heliospheric component cannot be greatly redshifted away from the
LISM absorption in order to account for the excess absorption on the blue side.
The only way the heliospheric absorption can have decelerations consistent with the models
is for there to be yet another absorption component that accounts for the non-LISM absorption
on the blue side of the line. Gayley et al. (1997) found this to be the case for the α Cen data as
well when they made direct comparisons between the data and the H I absorption predicted by
heliospheric models. Gayley et al. (1997) interpreted this to mean that the "astrosphere" of α Cen
was responsible for the blueshifted non-LISM H I absorption. We propose that our Lyman-α data
are also contaminated by astrospheric absorption.
Figure 2 shows the velocity vector of 36 Oph, which is computed from the radial velocity and
proper motion information in Hirshfeld et al. (1996). From this 32.5 km s−1 stellar vector and the
known 29.4 km s−1 G cloud vector, we can determine the interstellar wind vector in the rest frame
of 36 Oph (dotted arrow in Fig. 2). We find that the wind speed relative to the star is 40 km s−1
and the line of sight toward the Sun is θ = 134◦ from the upwind direction, meaning we are looking
at the downwind portion of 36 Oph's astrosphere.
Much of the heliospheric H I in downwind directions is formed by charge exchange between
LISM neutrals and solar wind protons inside the heliopause, whereas the H-wall H I observed in
upwind directions is created by charge exchange between LISM neutrals and heated LISM protons
outside the heliopause. Another difference is that in the upwind direction, the H I in the H-wall is
decelerated, but models suggest that for downwind directions the H I gas is accelerated relative to
the LISM flow. One consequence of this is that heliospheric absorption will be redshifted relative to
the LISM absorption in all directions. Likewise, astrospheric absorption will always be blueshifted.
Izmodenov, Lallement, & Malama (1999) claim to have detected redshifted heliospheric absorption
in a downwind direction toward the star Sirius, consistent with these theoretical expectations.
Therefore, it is not unreasonable to suppose that astrospheric material downwind from 36 Oph
is responsible for the non-LISM absorption on the blue side of the Lyman-α absorption feature.
Thus, in Figure 6b we present a three component fit to the Lyman-α line, the parameters of which
are listed in Table 1. Because they are so highly blended, the three components must be constrained
somehow to produce a unique fit. The LISM component is constrained the same as in the two
component fit. Furthermore, we force the heliospheric and astrospheric absorption components to
have velocities roughly consistent with model predictions.
Heliospheric models suggest an average deceleration of roughly 40% within the hydrogen wall in
-- 10 --
the upwind direction, meaning the projected velocity toward 36 Oph should be VH = −0.6V0 cos θ,
where V0 = 26 km s−1 is the LISM flow velocity for the Sun and θ = 12◦ is the angle of the line
of sight relative to the upwind direction. Thus, VH = −15 km s−1 for the heliospheric absorption.
In downwind directions, the heliospheric models suggest accelerations of about 30% for the H I.
Assuming this is the case for 36 Oph, the predicted velocity of the astrospheric absorption is then
VH = Vrad + (1.3V0 cos θ), where Vrad = 1.0 km s−1 is the stellar radial velocity, V0 = 40 km s−1
is the LISM flow velocity relative to the star, and θ = 134◦ is the angle relative to the upwind
direction of the solar line of sight. Thus, VH = −35 km s−1 for the astrospheric absorption. We
arbitrarily assume uncertainties of ±5 km s−1 for both the estimated heliospheric and astrospheric
velocities. Analogous to the procedure used in the two component fit, we perform many fits varying
the LISM column density and the heliospheric/astrospheric velocities within the allowed error bars,
which allows us to determine the best fit parameters and uncertainties quoted in Table 1.
Since the heliospheric component no longer has to account for the excess absorption on both the
red and blue sides of the Lyman-α line, the column density and Doppler parameter are significantly
lower than for the two component model (see Table 1). The column density (log NH = 14.6 ± 0.3)
is now consistent with that measured toward α Cen (log NH = 14.74 ± 0.24), as is the temperature
inferred from the Doppler parameter once the quoted uncertainties are considered (T = 38, 000 ±
8000 K for 36 Oph, T = 29, 000 ± 5000 K for α Cen).
The astrospheric component has a column density (log NH = 14.7±0.3) and Doppler parameter
(b = 26.0 ± 3.0 km s−1) very similar to that of the heliospheric component, with the Doppler
parameter implying a temperature of 41, 000 ± 10, 000 K. We would have expected temperatures
somewhat higher than this for a downwind line of sight, based on the H I temperatures predicted
by the hydrodynamic models (e.g., Muller et al. 2000). However, a direct comparison between the
data and the absorption predicted by the models is needed to see if they are truly inconsistent.
The average LISM density toward 36 Oph is nH = 0.03 − 0.06 cm−3. This is lower than the
nH ≈ 0.1 cm−3 densities typically observed toward the nearest stars, including α Cen (Linsky et
al. 2000). One possible explanation for this is that hot interstellar material without any neutral H
occupies part of the line of sight, either in the foreground of the observed absorption between the
LIC and G clouds; or beyond the G cloud, which would mean that 36 Oph lies outside the G cloud.
However, if our detection of astrospheric H I is valid, the LISM around 36 Oph must necessarily
contain H I, meaning 36 Oph must be within the G cloud. Furthermore, the existence of substantial
G cloud material toward α Cen, which is only 1.3 pc away, suggests that a large gap between the
LIC and G clouds toward 36 Oph is unlikely (see Fig. 2). Thus, the most likely explanation for
the low average density is a negative density gradient within the G cloud toward 36 Oph. Wood &
Linsky (1998) used similar reasoning to infer a density gradient within the LIC toward 40 Eri.
-- 11 --
4. Summary
We have analyzed absorption features observed in HST/STIS spectra of the 5.5 pc line of sight
to 36 Oph A. Our findings are summarized as follows:
1. Only one LISM absorption component is seen toward 36 Oph, with a velocity consistent with
the flow vector of the G cloud. No absorption whatsoever is detected from the LIC, meaning
the edge of the LIC must be very close. Because the line of sight is very close to the upwind
directions of both the G and LIC clouds, the velocity of −28.4 km s−1 that we observe is very
close to the actual flow speed of the observed material. The fact that this projected velocity
is greater than the 26 km s−1 velocity of the LIC provides particularly strong evidence for
the existence of faster G cloud material in that direction.
2. We estimate that the LIC D I column density must be less than 9 × 1011 cm−2 to explain why no
LIC absorption is detected. This corresponds to NH I < 6 × 1016 cm−2 based on the known
LIC D/H ratio (1.5 × 10−5). Assuming a density of nH I = 0.1 cm−3, the distance to the edge
of the LIC is dedge < 0.19 pc. The Sun will reach the edge in tedge < 7400 yrs, based on the
LIC velocity vector.
3. The temperature (T = 5900 ± 500 K) and relative abundances of D I, Mg II, and Fe II (e.g.,
D I/Mg II = 0.9 ± 0.4) are within the error bars of the measurements made for the α Cen
line of sight, which also samples G cloud material (LW96). These measurements suggest that
the G cloud has a slightly lower temperature and less Mg and Fe depletion than the LIC.
However, the nonthermal velocity toward 36 Oph, ξ = 2.2 ± 0.2 km s−1, is higher than the
α Cen measurement (ξ = 1.25 ± 0.25 km s−1).
4. Using a Lyman-α bisector technique first described by Wood et al. (1996), we estimate a column
density of log NH = 17.85 ± 0.15 toward 36 Oph and a deuterium-to-hydrogen ratio for the
G cloud of D/H = (1.5 ± 0.5) × 10−5. The latter quantity is consistent with the LIC value of
D/H = (1.5 ± 0.1) × 10−5.
5. The average G cloud density toward 36 Oph is nH = 0.03 − 0.06, significantly less than the
nH ≈ 0.1 cm−3 densities typically observed toward the nearest stars, including α Cen within
the G cloud. The most likely interpretation is that the G cloud H I density decreases toward
36 Oph.
6. The H I Lyman-α absorption line is redshifted and suggests a much higher temperature than the
other lines. LW96 used a very similar discrepancy toward α Cen to argue for the presence of
absorption from heated, decelerated material in the solar hydrogen wall. Our results strongly
support this interpretation.
7. In two component fits to the H I Lyman-α line, the solar hydrogen wall component is not decel-
erated relative to the projected LIC velocity, which is a serious contradiction with theoretical
-- 12 --
expectations, so we propose that absorption from astrospheric material around 36 Oph is re-
sponsible for some of the absorption on the blue side of the line. Thus, our best model of the
Lyman-α absorption has three components: LISM (G cloud), heliospheric, and astrospheric.
In the three component fits, the temperature and column density of the heliospheric absorp-
tion (T = 38, 000 ± 8000 K and log NH = 14.6 ± 0.3) are consistent with the measurements
made for the α Cen line of sight.
We would like to thank the anonymous referee for several helpful suggestions. Support for this
work was provided by NASA through grant number GO-07262.01-99A from the Space Telescope
Science Institute, which is operated by AURA, Inc., under NASA contract NAS5-26555.
-- 13 --
REFERENCES
Baranov, V. B., Izmodenov, V. V., & Malama, Y. G. 1998, J. Geophys. Res., 103, 9575
Baranov, V. B., & Malama, Y. G. 1993, J. Geophys. Res., 98, 15157
Baranov, V. B., & Malama, Y. G. 1995, J. Geophys. Res., 100, 14755
Bertaux, J. -L., Lallement, R., Kurt, V. G., & Mironova, E. 1985, A&A, 150, 1
Bertin, P., Vidal-Madjar, A., Lallement, R., Ferlet, R., & Lemoine, M. 1995, A&A, 302, 889
Dring, A. R., Linsky, J. L., Murthy, J., Henry, R. C., Moos, W., Vidal-Madjar, A., Audouze, J., &
Landsman, W. 1997, ApJ, 488, 760
Gayley, K. G., Zank, G. P., Pauls, H. L., Frisch, P. C., & Welty, D. E. 1997, ApJ, 487, 259
Hirshfeld, A., Sinnott, R. W., & Ochsenbein, F. 1991, Sky Catalogue 2000.0, Vol. 1 (Cambridge:
Cambridge Univ. Press)
Izmodenov, V. V., Lallement, R., & Malama, Y. G. 1999, A&A, 342, L13
Kimble, R. A., et al. 1998, ApJ, 492, L83
Lallement, R., & Bertin, P. 1992, A&A, 266, 479
Lallement, R., Bertin, P., Ferlet, R., Vidal-Madjar, A., & Bertaux, J. L. 1994, A&A, 286, 898
Lallement, R., Ferlet, R., Lagrange, A. M., Lemoine, M., & Vidal-Madjar, A. 1995, A&A, 304, 461
Lindler, D. 1999, CALSTIS Reference Guide (Greenbelt: NASA/LASP)
Linsky, J. L. 1998, Space Sci. Rev., 84, 285
Linsky, J. L., Redfield, S., Wood, B. E., & Piskunov, N. 2000, ApJ, to appear Jan. 10
Linsky, J. L., & Wood, B. E. 1996, ApJ, 463, 254 (LW96)
Linsky, J. L., & Wood, B. E. 1998, in Cosmic Chemical Evolution, IAU Symposium 187 (Dordrecht:
Kluwer), in press
Lipatov, A. S., Zank, G. P., & Pauls, H. L. 1998, J. Geophys. Res., 103, 20631
Morton, D. C. 1991, ApJS, 77, 119
Muller, H. -R., Zank, G. P., & Lipatov, A. S. 2000, J. Geophys. Res., in press
Pauls, H. L., Zank, G. P., & Williams, L. L. 1995, J. Geophys. Res., 100, 21595
Piskunov, N., Wood, B. E., Linsky, J. L., Dempsey, R. C., & Ayres, T. R. 1997, ApJ, 474, 315
-- 14 --
Qu´emerais, E., Sandel, B. R., Lallement, R., & Bertaux, J. -L. 1995, A&A, 299, 249
Redfield, S., & Linsky, J. L. 2000, ApJ, to appear May 10
Sahu, K. C., et al. 1999, STIS Instrument Handbook (Baltimore: STScI)
Witte, M., Rosenbauer, H., Banaszkewicz, M., & Fahr, H. 1993, Adv. Space Res., 13, 121
Wood, B. E., Alexander, W. R., & Linsky, J. L. 1996, ApJ, 470, 1159
Wood, B. E., & Linsky, J. L. 1998, ApJ, 492, 788
Woodgate, B. E., et al. 1998, PASP, 110, 1183
Zank, G. P. 1999, Space Sci. Rev., 89, 413
Zank, G. P., Pauls, H. L., Williams, L. L., & Hall, D. T. 1996, J. Geophys. Res., 101, 21639
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.0.
-- 15 --
Table 1. Fit Parametersa
Ion
b
λrest
(A)
Source of
Absorption
vc
b
(km s−1)
(km s−1)
log N
χ2
ν
One Component Fits
Fe II
2600.173
Mg IId 2796.352
Mg IId 2803.531
1215.339
D I
H I
1215.670
LISM
LISM
LISM
LISM
LISM
−28.4 ± 0.4
−27.9 ± 0.2
−27.9 ± 0.2
−29.0 ± 0.2
−25.9 ± 0.1
2.12 ± 0.61
3.15 ± 0.25
3.15 ± 0.25
7.33 ± 0.17
14.34 ± 0.02
12.65 ± 0.25
13.05 ± 0.15
13.05 ± 0.15
13.00 ± 0.01
18.178 ± 0.002
0.41
2.19
2.19
1.12
2.30
Two Component Fits
H I
1215.670
LISM
(−28.4)
(10.11)
Heliosphere −26.7 ± 0.3
28.5 ± 2.5
(17.85 ± 0.15)
15.08 ± 0.15
1.29
1.29
Three Component Fits
H I
1215.670
LISM
Heliosphere
Astrosphere
(−28.4)
(−15 ± 5)
(−35 ± 5)
(10.11)
(17.85 ± 0.15)
25.0 ± 2.6
26.0 ± 3.0
14.6 ± 0.3
14.7 ± 0.3
1.25
1.25
1.25
aQuantities in parentheses are fixed rather than derived (see text for details).
bIn vacuum.
cCentral velocity in a heliocentric rest frame.
dThe Mg II lines were fitted simultaneously and forced to have the same fit param-
eters.
-- 16 --
Fig. 1. -- Single component absorption line fits to the following lines: Mg II k λ2796.352, Mg II h
λ2803.531, Fe II λ2600.173, and D I λ1215.339. The dotted and thick solid lines are before and after
instrumental broadening. The data are displayed on a velocity scale in a heliocentric rest frame.
Dashed lines show the projected velocities of the LIC and G cloud flow vectors for the 36 Oph line
of sight.
-- 17 --
Fig. 2. -- A map showing the locations of the Sun, α Cen, 36 Oph, the LIC (solid line), and G
cloud (dashed line), projected into the Galactic plane, where Galactic Center is to the right. The
LIC shape in the Galactic plane is from Redfield & Linsky (2000), while the G cloud shape is
only a rough estimate. The solid arrows indicate the velocity vectors of the LIC, the G cloud,
and 36 Oph relative to the Sun, with the length of the arrow being proportional to the speed.
The dotted line indicates the G cloud vector in the rest frame of 36 Oph, thereby indicating the
orientation of the star's astrosphere. Note that the two stars and all the displayed vectors lie within
21◦ of the Galactic plane, so this two-dimensional map is not greatly misrepresentative of the actual
three-dimensional situation.
-- 18 --
Fig. 3. -- Nonthermal velocities (ξ) are plotted versus temperature, based on the Doppler parame-
ters and their uncertainties measured from absorption lines of Fe II, Mg II, and D I (see Table 1).
The shaded area where the three curves overlap indicates the actual temperature and ξ value of
the interstellar material (T = 5900 ± 500 K and ξ = 2.2 ± 0.2 km s−1).
-- 19 --
Fig. 4. -- A single component fit (thick solid line) to the broad H I Lyman-α absorption line centered
at 1215.6 A and the D I Lyman-α absorption at 1215.2 A, which are shown on a heliocentric
wavelength scale. This fit is not realistic because the central velocity and temperature of the H I
line are inconsistent with D I and the other LISM lines. The dotted line shows the LIC absorption
associated with the upper limit for the LIC column density derived in the text (NH I < 6 × 1016
cm−2). Practically all of the absorption is well within the saturated core of the line, so LIC
absorption will have no observable effect on the Lyman-α line.
-- 20 --
Fig. 5. -- In (a), the wings of the unabsorbed stellar Lyman-α line are derived by extrapolating
upwards from polynomial fits to the observed profile (thick solid lines) assuming five different LISM
H I column densities in the range log NH = 17.5 − 18.3. The bisectors of Lyman-α wings computed
in this fashion are shown in (b), as a function of log NH. When the correct value of log NH is
assumed, the bisector should be at the radial velocity of the star, which is shown as a dashed line
in both panels. The thick line in (b) indicates the bisector that best matches the radial velocity,
which corresponds to log NH = 17.84.
-- 21 --
Fig. 6. -- (a) A two component fit to the H I Lyman-α line, where the dotted line is LISM absorption
and the dashed line is heliospheric hydrogen wall absorption. The thick solid line is the combination
of the two components, which fits the data. Unlike the fit in Fig. 4, D I and H I are self-consistent
in this fit. The spectrum is displayed in a heliocentric rest frame. (b) A fit similar to that in (a),
but with the addition of a third component associated with absorption from hot astrospheric H I
surrounding 36 Oph (dot-dashed line). We consider this to be our best model of the Lyman-α
absorption (see text).
|
astro-ph/0507710 | 2 | 0507 | 2005-11-22T14:49:55 | X-ray continuum properties of GRB afterglows observed by XMM-Newton and Chandra | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present a catalog of XMM-Newton and Chandra observations of gamma-ray burst (GRB) afterglows, reduced in a common way using the most up-to-date calibration files and software. We focus on the continuum properties of the afterglows. We derive the spectral and temporal decay indices for 16 bursts. We place constraints on the burst environment and geometry. A comparison of the fast XMM-Newton follow-up and the late Chandra observations shows a significant difference in those parameters, likely produced by a transition from jet expansion taking place between two and ten days after the burst. We do not observe a significant shrinking of the luminosity distribution when we correct for beaming; more burst observations are needed to confirm this result. We also compare our results with those obtained by BeppoSAX and SWIFT; there is no strong discrepancy between the afterglow fluxes observed with these satellites when we carefully take into account the different median observation time of each observatory. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Astronomy&Astrophysicsmanuscript no. article
(DOI: will be inserted by hand later)
October 2, 2018
5
0
0
2
v
o
N
2
2
2
v
0
1
7
7
0
5
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
X-ray continuum properties of GRB afterglows observed by
XMM-Newton and Chandra
B. Gendre1, A. Corsi1, 2, 3, and L. Piro1
1 IASF/INAF Rome, via fosso del cavaliere 100, 00133, Roma, Italy
e-mail: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]
2 INFN - Sezione di Roma c/o Dipartimento di Fisica − Universit´a degli Studi di Roma "La Sapienza" Piazzale A. Moro 5,
00185 Roma, Italy
3 Universit´a degli Studi di Roma "La Sapienza", Piazzale A. Moro 5, 00185, Roma, Italy
Received -- ; accepted --
Abstract.
We present a catalog of XMM-Newton and Chandra observations of gamma-ray burst (GRB) afterglows, reduced in a common
way using the most up-to-date calibration files and software. We focus on the continuum properties of the afterglows. We
derive the spectral and temporal decay indices for 16 bursts. We place constraints on the burst environment and geometry.
A comparison of the fast XMM-Newton follow-up and the late Chandra observations shows a significant difference in those
parameters, likely produced by a transition from jet expansion taking place between two and ten days after the burst. We do
not observe a significant shrinking of the luminosity distribution when we correct for beaming; more burst observations are
needed to confirm this result. We also compare our results with those obtained by BeppoSAX and SWIFT; there is no strong
discrepancy between the afterglow fluxes observed with these satellites when we carefully take into account the different median
observation time of each observatory.
Key words. X-rays:general -- Gamma-rays:bursts -- Catalogs
1. Introduction
Discovered at the end of the 60s (Klebesadel et al. 1973),
Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs)
remained mysterious objects
for decades. The first precise localization of long GRB
(Dezalay et al. 1996; Kouveliotou et al. 1993) provided by
BeppoSAX (Piro et al. 1996) led to the detection of X-ray
(Costa et al. 1997) and optical afterglows (van Paradijs et al.
1997), and finally to the measurement of the distance of
these objects (Metzger et al. 1997). The afterglow emission is
well described by the fireball model (Rees & Meszaros 1992;
Meszaros & Rees 1997; Panaitescu et al. 1998) and provides
powerful diagnostics of the close environment of the burst.
In the framework of the fireball model, the afterglow spec-
tral and temporal evolution can be used to constrain the den-
sity profile of the environment. Many observations point out
a possible association between GRBs and supernovae (e.g.
Stanek et al. 2003; Hjorth et al. 2003), indicating that the long
GRB progenitor may be a massive star. In such a case the
surrounding medium is then expected to be the stellar wind
arising from the star (Chevalier & Li 1999). However most
of the measurements are compatible with a constant den-
sity profile and in some cases exclude a wind profile (e.g;
Panaitescu & Kumar 2002). Only in a few cases does the con-
trary hold (e.g. Gendre et al. 2004a; Piro et al. 2005).
A large number of datasets available for a systematic study
in X-ray is available. Some observations were published in sin-
gle papers, other announced in GCN, and some not published at
all. A uniform sample of afterglows, obtained by using the lat-
est calibration files, is particularly required when one wants to
use the general properties of the afterglows to constrain models.
We have initiated a re-analysis of all X-ray afterglows observed
so far, focusing on the burst environment properties. Following
the release of the BeppoSAX results (De Pasquale et al. 2005),
we present in this article the XMM-Newton and Chandra af-
terglow observations carried out as of October 2004. We will
focus on the continuum properties, and we will not discuss any
line detections within the spectra. In a future paper (Gendre
et al., in preparation), we will expose a methodology to detect
lines, to assess their significance and we will discuss the fea-
tures that we have detected. The light curves and spectra will
be made available through a local web page1.
This article is organized as follows. In Sec. 2 we present
the data reduction. In Sec. 3 we list our results. In Sec. 4 we
discuss these results and compare them with the BeppoSAX
catalog, before providing our conclusions.
Send offprint requests to: B. Gendre
1 http://grb.rm.iasf.cnr.it/catalog
2
Gendre et al.: XMM-Newton and Chandra GRB X-ray afterglows
2. Data reduction and analysis
We retrieved all public data available for GRBs that occurred
before the 1st of October 2004, from the archives of XMM-
Newton2 and Chandra3 observations. The complete list of re-
trieved observations is indicated in Table 1. These observa-
tions were calibrated using the most up-to-date software avail-
able as of October 2004. For the XMM-Newton data, we used
the SAS version 6.0. We focused on the data from the EPIC
(MOS and PN) instruments (Struder et al. 2001; Turner et al.
2001). The calibrations were done using the tasks emchain
and epchain. For the Chandra data, we used CIAO version
3.1 and the calibration database CALDB version 2.28. The
data were processed using the tasks acis process events and
the specific tasks used to obtain calibrated grating data4. The
events were filtered using all provided GTI and standard fil-
tering criteria (GRADE==[0, 2, 3, 4, 6] for Chandra data,
(FLAG==0&&PATTERN<=4) for XMM-Newton EPIC-PN
data, (#XMMEA EM&&PATTERN<=12) for XMM-Newton
EPIC-MOS). The filtered event files were checked for flaring
background activities. We removed any period of such activity
using a very strict condition (a flare is defined as an increase
by a factor of at least 5 of the mean background count rate
during the observation, and we removed the detected flare in-
cluding the 250 seconds that precede and follow this period).
When less than 3000 seconds of observation remain within the
cleaned event file, we discarded the observation. The remaining
events were used to extract spectra and light curves.
For non-grating data and the zero order grating data, we
extracted spectra and light curves using circle regions. The ra-
dius of these regions were chosen to contain at least 90% of the
counts and take into account any possible neighboring source.
The spectral and temporal backgrounds were extracted using
a larger circular area free of sources at the same off-axis an-
gle (except in the case of the zero order grating data, where
we extracted this spectrum using an annulus centered on the
source with inner and outer radii of about 10 and 25 pixels re-
spectively). The XMM-Newton spectral background presents
spatial variations (see Ehle et al. 2004). We have taken this
into account by choosing a position that presents a spectral
background similar to the source region, in order to avoid
spurious emission or absorption features. For the other orders
of grating data, we used the regions created by the grating
processing tasks5. When grating data were available (either
LETG or HETG), we obtained the spectral results by simul-
taneously fitting the zero order spectrum and the +1 and −1
orders added together. In such a case, we have taken into ac-
count the cross-calibration uncertainties, which are about 20%
(see the CIAO calibration web pages), by adding to the spec-
tral model a multiplicative constant left free to vary within the
range 0.8-1.2. The spectral analysis was done using XSPEC
version 11.3.1 (Arnaud 1996). For the temporal analysis we
used FTOOLS version 5.3 and a customized IDL script (see
2 http://xmm.vilspa.esa.es/external/xmm data acc/xsa/index.shtml
3 http://cda.harvard.edu/chaser/mainEntry.do
4 See http://cxc.harvard.edu/ciao3.1/threads/spectra hetgacis/ and
http://cxc.harvard.edu/ciao3.1/threads/spectra letgacis/
5 see the CIAO threads web pages
De Pasquale et al. 2005). We binned all data to contain at least
20 source photons within each bin in order to use the χ2 statis-
tic. For the spectral study, we used a model of an absorbed
power law (with a galactic absorption and a host redshifted
absorption). When the redshift of the host was unknown, we
used the canonical value of z=1. For those afterglows with too
few counts detected to produce a meaningful spectral fitting,
we used only a galactic absorbed power law with a spectral en-
ergy index of 1 to calibrate the count to flux conversion factor.
For the Chandra grating data, we used only the order 0 of the
spectra to extract the light curve, as this was found to optimize
the signal-to-noise ratio and thus reduce the uncertainties.
3. Observation results
We list in Table 2 our results. We indicate undetected after-
glows (we define as afterglow a fading bright source, or a sin-
gle source within the error box too faint to constrain its decay)
with a 'U' flag. For these afterglows, we indicate a flux upper
limit assuming the source was on-axis (when there is no after-
glow detected at other wavelengths) or at the position of the
detected optical/radio afterglow. Bursts detected but with not
enough counts to have a good constraint on the spectral index
are indicated with an 'F' flag. We have derived a flux for those
afterglows using the standard model indicated in Sec. 2. For
the remaining bursts, we indicate if the observation was done
by XMM-Newton ('X' flag) or by Chandra in grating mode
('G' flag) or imaging mode ('I' flag). In the remainder of this
paper, all errors are quoted at the 90% confidence level (except
when another confidence level is indicated). Fluxes are given
unabsorbed and within the 2.0-10.0 keV X-ray band. Readers
interested in using our data are invited to retrieve them through
the dedicated web page1.
There were 31 bursts followed by XMM-Newton or
Chandra (GRB 020321 was followed by XMM-Newton and
Chandra). We obtained good constraints on the spectral and
temporal indexes for 14 of these. For 3 other bursts (GRB
991216, GRB 001025A, GRB 030329), the decay index was
not constrained but we obtained a good statistical error on the
spectral index. For 8 bursts, the observed count rates did not al-
low us to derive good constraints on the spectral and decay in-
dexes. For 3 bursts (GRB 011130, GRB 020531, GRB 021201),
we did not detect any convincing afterglow. We discarded 3
burst (GRB 010220, GRB 010222, GRB 030227) observations.
Except for the case of GRB 011030, all results reported here
are consistent with previous publications (which are listed in
Table 1). In the special case of GRB 011030, Harrison et al.
(2001) reported a very different flux, not consistent with the
count rate observed for this source. An independent analysis
made by d'Alessio et al. (2005) gave results similar to ours.
We show in Fig. 1 the light curves (in flux unit) of those bursts
with a good constraint on both the spectral and decay indexes.
3.1. Rejectedobservations
GRB 010220 A strong flaring background activity occurred
during the XMM-Newton observation, which began 14.8 hours
Gendre et al.: XMM-Newton and Chandra GRB X-ray afterglows
3
Table 1. List of observations retrieved from the archives with some basic information (configuration of the instruments, instru-
ment that detected the prompt emission). We also report the first refereed publication on the X-ray afterglow.
GRB
Instrument
GRB 991216
GRB 000210
GRB 000926
GRB 010222
GRB 011030
GRB 011130
GRB 020127
GRB 020321
GRB 020405
GRB 020427
GRB 020531
GRB 020813
GRB 021004
GRB 021201
GRB 030226
GRB 030328
GRB 030528
GRB 030723
GRB 031220
GRB 040701
GRB 040812
GRB 001025A
GRB 010220
GRB 011211
GRB 020321
GRB 020322
GRB 030227
GRB 030329
Chandra ACIS-S, HETG
Chandra ACIS-S
Chandra ACIS-S
Chandra ACIS-S
Chandra ACIS-S
Chandra ACIS-I
Chandra ACIS-I
Chandra ACIS-S
Chandra ACIS-S, LETG
Chandra ACIS-S
Chandra ACIS-I
Chandra ACIS-S, HETG
Chandra ACIS-S, HETG
Chandra ACIS-I
Chandra ACIS-S
Chandra ACIS-S, LETG
Chandra ACIS-S
Chandra ACIS-S -I
Chandra ACIS-I
Chandra ACIS-I
Chandra ACIS-S
XMM-Newton
XMM-Newton
XMM-Newton
XMM-Newton
XMM-Newton
XMM-Newton
XMM-Newton
GRB 031203
XMM-Newton
GRB 040106
GRB 040223
GRB 040827
XMM-Newton
XMM-Newton
XMM-Newton
archive
Obs-ID
596
602
598, 1047
2424, 1048
3411, 3412
2823
3436, 3437
3477
2825
3493, 3494
2824, 3673
4364
4381, 4409
3784, 3785
4425
4432
3920, 3921
3918, 3922
3905, 3906
4661, 4662
5364, 5365
0128530301
0111520301
0111520401
0094380101
0008820401
0110980301
0128530801
0128531201
0128531401
0128531501
0128531601
0158160201
0163360201
0158160401
0158160601
0164570401
Prompt
detection
BATSE
BeppoSAX
Ulysses
BeppoSAX
BeppoSAX
HETE-2
HETE-2
BeppoSAX
Ulysses
Fluence (band)
erg.cm−2 (keV)
2 × 10−4(20-300)
6.1 × 10−6(40-700)
2.2 × 10−5(25-100)
9.25 × 10−5(40-700)
1.13 × 10−6(40-700)
--
--
3.0 × 10−6(40-700)
3 × 10−5(25-100)
BeppoSAX
< 2.9 × 10−7(40-700)
HETE-2
HETE-2
HETE-2
IPN
HETE-2
HETE-2
HETE-2
HETE-2
HETE-2
HETE-2
INTEGRAL
Ulysses
BeppoSAX
BeppoSAX
BeppoSAX
BeppoSAX
1 × 10−7(8-40)
3.8 × 10−5(25-100)
3.2 × 10−6(7-400)
2 × 10−7(25-100)
5.7 × 10−6(30-400)
3.0 × 10−5(30-400)
4.8 × 10−6(30-400)
0.2 × 10−7(30-400)
1.9 × 10−6(25-100)
4.5 × 10−7(2-25)
2.5 × 10−7(20-200)
3.2 × 10−6(25-100)
--
3.7 × 10−6(40-700)
3.0 × 10−6(40-700)
--
Afterglow
Detection
X, opt, rad
X, rad
X, opt, rad
X, opt, rad
rad
--
X, rad
--
X, opt, rad
X
--
X, opt, rad
X, opt, rad
--
X, opt
X, opt
X, opt
X, opt
X, opt
X
X
--
--
X, opt
--
X, opt
Redshift
Ref
1.02
0.846
2.066
1.477
<3
--
--
--
0.69
--
--
1.25
2.3
--
1.98
1.52
--
--
--
1
--
2
--
--
--
--
--
15
3
--
4
4
--
5
--
6
18
7
0.2146 --
--
8
8
--
--
--
INTEGRAL
HETE-2
8.8 × 10−7(20-200)
1 × 10−4(30-400)
X, opt
X, opt, rad
--
0.168
INTEGRAL
1.5 × 10−6(20-200)
X, opt, rad
0.105
INTEGRAL
INTEGRAL
INTEGRAL
8.3 × 10−7(20-200)
4.4 × 10−7(20-200)
--
X, opt
X
X, opt
--
--
--
2.14
--
--
9
--
10
11
12
13
14
17
16
N.B. References are : 1 : Piro et al. (2000), 2 : Piro et al. (2001), 3 : Amati et al. (2004), 4 : Butler et al. (2003), 5 : Klose et al. (2004), 6 :
Rau et al. (2004), 7 : Melandri et al. (2005), 8 : Watson et al. (2002a), 9 : Reeves et al. (2002), 10 : Watson et al. (2002b), 11 :
Mereghetti et al. (2003), 12 : Tiengo et al. (2003), 13 : Watson et al. (2004), 14 : Gendre et al. (2004a), 15 : Mirabal et al. (2003), 16 :
De Luca et al. (2005), 17 : McGlynn et al. (2005), 18 : (Butler et al. 2005).
after the burst. Due to our strict flare rejection criterion, we
discarded all the observation of this burst.
3.2. Particularafterglows
GRB 010222 This observation was severely piled-up. We de-
cided not to perform data analysis and to conservatively discard
this observation.
GRB 000210 We used the data from BeppoSAX to constrain
the decay index.
GRB 030227 The observation files gave several warnings dur-
ing the data processing by the SAS. After a check of the event
files, we concluded that the calibration could not be correctly
done for this observation. We conservatively discarded this ob-
servation.
GRB 001025A Two sources were detected within the burst er-
ror box, the brightest displaying a marginal decay (δ = 1.2±3.0,
which implies a decrease at the 66% confidence level) while the
dimmer does not feature any variation. Watson et al. (2002a)
associated the bright source with the X-ray afterglow on the
basis of this decay trend. We report on this bright source.
4
Gendre et al.: XMM-Newton and Chandra GRB X-ray afterglows
Table 2. GRB X-ray afterglow results. For each afterglow, we give the source name, the exposure duration and the net observation
duration, together with the results of the spectral and temporal analysis. We quote the absorption (measured at the host redshift
or at a value of z=1 when the host redshift is unknown) in excess to the galactic absorption. The X-ray absorption excess upper
limits are given at the 90 % confidence level. We also indicate the number of detected counts for the source as a proxy of the
detection confidence level.
Source
name
Flag
Time
since burst
Exposure
duration
(ksec)
Net
duration
(ksec)
GRB 991216
GRB 000210
GRB 000926
GRB 001025A
GRB 011030
GRB 011130
GRB 011211
GRB 020127
GRB 020321
GRB 020322
GRB 020405
GRB 020427
GRB 020531
GRB 020813
GRB 021004
GRB 021201
GRB 030226
GRB 030328
GRB 030329
GRB 030528
GRB 030723
GRB 031203
GRB 031220
GRB 040106
GRB 040223
GRB 040701
GRB 040812
GRB 040827
G
I
I
X
I
U
X
F
F?
X
G
F
U
G
G
U
I
G
X
F
F
X
F
X
X
F
F
X
(days)
1.52
0.84
2.67
1.88
10.00
9.77
0.50
4.05
14.53
0.43
0.62
1.68
9.06
17.00
5.14
0.86
0.85
8.73
1.54
0.64
37.04
5.97
11.80
2.14
12.69
0.26
5.62
28.47
0.23
0.20
7.77
16.50
5.04
10.16
0.27
Detected
count
number
1305
533
307
911
248
--
3589
26
13
227
4226
2086
55
24
--
8041
2656
--
371
1575
639
44
--
76
70
6261
31
--
15738
1230
68
39
58
42
2899
Temporal
decay
(0.9)
1.38±0.03
1.9 ± 0.4
(1.2)
1.9 ± 0.4
--
2.1 ± 0.3
--
--
--
Energy
spectral
index
0.7 ± 0.2
0.9 ± 0.2
0.7 ± 0.2
1.8 ± 0.4
0.7 +2.1
−1.0
--
1.3 ± 0.1
--
--
--
Spectral
fit
χ2
ν (d.o.f.)
0.94 (56)
1.0 (15)
1.5 (8)
0.90 (13)
0.1 (6)
--
1.20 (67)
--
--
--
Excess of
absorption
(1021 cm−2)
< 9.6
4.7 ± 1.3
< 3.4
6 ± 3
< 39
--
<4.1
--
--
--
1.3 ± 0.3
1.6 ± 0.9
1.1 ± 0.1
1.0 ± 0.2
1.00 (178)
1.24 (75)
6.5 ± 0.8
5 ± 2
--
--
--
1.4 ± 0.2
1.2 ± 0.3
--
2.7 ± 1.6
1.6 ± 0.3
(2)
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
0.83 ± 0.06
1.01 ± 0.07
--
0.9 ± 0.3
1.1 ± 0.2
1.0 ± 0.2
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
0.93 (364)
1.08 (112)
--
1.1 (10)
0.79 (39)
0.98 (22)
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
< 2.9
< 2.8
--
6.6+4.1
−3.3
< 4.0
<0.5
--
--
--
--
0.5 ± 0.1
0.8 ± 0.1
1.04 (244)
2.6 ± 0.7
--
--
--
--
--
--
1.4 ± 0.1
0.7 ± 0.3
0.49 ± 0.04
1.6 ± 0.3
1.07 (515)
1.04 (43)
--
--
<0.5
(45-88) ± 16a
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
Flux
erg s−1 cm−2
1.92 ± 0.08 ×10−12
2.7 ± 0.2 × 10−13
1.06 ± 0.07 × 10−13
2.0 ± 0.2 × 10−14
5 ± 1.2 × 10−14
< 0.6 × 10−15
7.3 ± 0.2 × 10−14
2.1 ±0.5 × 10−14
0.6 ±0.2 × 10−14
see text
2.11 ± 0.05 × 10−13
8.9 ± 0.3 ×10−13
1.0 ±0.2 × 10−14
0.4 ±0.1 × 10−14
< 1.2 × 10−15
1.63 ± 0.03 ×10−12
4.0 ± 0.2 ×10−13
< 1.2 × 10−15
3.6 ± 0.2 × 10−14
1.70 ± 0.08 ×10−13
1.8 ± 0.2 × 10−14
7.8 ±1.3 × 10−15
< 3.2 × 10−15
1.4 ± 0.7 × 10−14
2.3 ± 1.7 × 10e−15
3.95 ± 0.08 × 10−13
5.2 ±1.3 × 10−15
< 1.5 × 10−15
9.1 ± 0.2 × 10−13
2.3 ± 0.2 × 10−13
1.2 ±0.2 × 10−14
0.8 ±0.2 × 10−14
1.6 ±0.3 × 10−14
1.2 ±0.2 × 10−14
1.25 ± 0.04 × 10−13
9.8
10.0
10.0
40.8
50.0
30.2
33.6
10.0
10.1
50.0
29.0
51.2
13.9
14.8
20.1
78.1
88.1
20.0
40.0
98.1
244.9
26.1
20.3
24.8
84.1
112.8
40.2
19.7
44.6
45.2
20.0
19.0
10.2
10.2
52.3
9.8
10.0
10.0
33.4
29.6
30.2
33.6
10.0
10.1
32.0
28.4
51.2
13.9
14.8
20.1
78.1
88.1
20.0
40.0
98.1
143.5
26.1
20.3
24.8
84.1
92.2
40.2
19.7
37.0
14.3
20.0
17.5
10.2
10.2
39.3
8.6 ± 1.5
Note : a : A high galactic density column affect this observation. See Sec. 4.5 for details.
1.07 (116)
1.4 ± 0.3
1.3 ± 0.1
GRB 011211 There was a change in the attitude of the satel-
lite during the observation. As this change of attitude is not
fully supported by the SAS and complicates the spectral analy-
sis (due to the change of PN CCD-chip during the re-pointing),
we discarded the first 5 kiloseconds of the observation (before
the change of attitude).
(as also noted by in't Zand et al. 2003). Five XMM-Newton
sources are located outside the field of view of Chandra, but
inside the WFC error box. There were no other observations at
other wavelenghts to confirm this likely afterglow, and we can-
not exclude that this variable source may be not related to GRB
020321.
GRB 020321 This burst was detected by BeppoSAX, who
failed to detect its afterglow (in't Zand et al. 2003). It was
followed-up by XMM-Newton and Chandra 10.3 and 240
hours after the burst respectively. We detected 82 sources
within the field of view of XMM-Newton. Twelve of these
sources are located in the Wide Field Camera (WFC) error box
(Gandolfi 2002). The subsequent Chandra observation cov-
ered half of the field of view of XMM-Newton. One bright
XMM-Newton source disappeared in the Chandra field of view,
which was claimed to be the afterglow of GRB 020321 by
in't Zand et al. (2003). This source has a flux of 1.4 × 10−14 ±
0.2 × 10−14 erg cm−2 s−1 17 hours after the burst, and an up-
per limit of ∼ 1.1 × 10−15 erg s−1 cm−2 during the Chandra
observation. On the other hand, only about 80 % of the WFC
error box is covered by Chandra, and in particular not all the
bright XMM-Newton sources are in the Chandra field of view
GRB 030329 There were 3 late observations of this burst.
The analysis was complicated by a neighboring0 source that
contaminated the spectra of the afterglow. While this contam-
ination is low and acceptable in the first and second observa-
tions, the last observation suffered strong contamination that
prevented us from analyzing the data. Due to the late obser-
vation time, the decay index is not constrained using only the
XMM-Newton data (we refer the reader to Tiengo et al. 2003,
for the early RXTE observation).
We report in Table 2 the spectral analysis of only the
first observation. We did not detect any excess of absorption
within the spectra of both observations. The spectral index is
α = 0.85 ± 0.21 (χ2
ν = 0.71, 10 d.o.f.) in the second observa-
tion, consistent with that measured in the first observation.
Gendre et al.: XMM-Newton and Chandra GRB X-ray afterglows
5
Table 3. List of GRB afterglow fluxes extrapolated or interpo-
lated 11 and 12 hours after the burst from their spectral and
temporal parameters (assuming there is no evolution of these
parameters). These two times are chosen to match the works
by De Pasquale et al. (2005) and Berger et al. (2005) about
Beppo-SAX and SWIFT respectively. We have separated the
Chandra Grating (top), Chandra Imaging (center) and XMM-
Newton (bottom) samples due to their different observation
times, and have removed GRB 030329 due to its very late
XMM-Newton observation.
GRB Name
GRB 020405
GRB 020813
GRB 021004
GRB 030328
GRB 000210
GRB 000926
GRB 011030
GRB 030226
GRB 001025A
GRB 011211
GRB 020322
GRB 031203
GRB 040106
GRB 040223
GRB 040827
Flux
11 hours
(erg cm−2 s−1)
7.1 ± 0.3 × 10−12
3.93 ± 0.08 × 10−12
8.4 ± 0.5 × 10−13
2.9 ± 0.2 × 10−13
6.7 ± 0.3 × 10−13
3.1 ± 0.2 × 10−12
1.8 ± 0.5 × 10−11
1.35 ± 0.08 × 10−12
1.2 ± 0.2 × 10−13
1.72 ± 0.05 × 10−13
4.2 ± 0.1 × 10−13
4.5 ± 0.1 × 10−13
9.9 ± 0.2 × 10−13
2.3 ± 0.2 × 10−13
1.40 ± 0.05 × 10−13
Flux
12 hours
(erg cm−2 s−1)
6.2 ± 0.3 × 10−12
3.48 ± 0.07 × 10−12
7.6 ± 0.4 × 10−13
2.5 ± 0.2 × 10−13
6.0 ± 0.3 × 10−13
2.7 ± 0.2 × 10−12
1.6 ± 0.4 × 10−11
1.10 ± 0.07 × 10−12
1.1 ± 0.2 × 10−13
1.46 ± 0.05 × 10−13
3.8 ± 0.1 × 10−13
4.3 ± 0.1 × 10−13
9.0 ± 0.2 × 10−13
2.2 ± 0.2 × 10−13
1.26 ± 0.05 × 10−13
Fig. 1. Light curves of the bursts with a good constraint on both
the spectral and temporal indexes. We have indicated in blue
the XMM-Newton bursts, in black the Chandra Grating bursts
and in red the Chandra Imaging bursts (see electronic version
for color).
GRB 031203 There were 2 observations of this burst, and we
report in Table 2 only the first observation results. The spectral
index is α = 1.0 ± 0.3 (χ2
ν = 0.70, 18 d.o.f.) for the second ob-
servation, consistent with that measured in the first observation.
The decay index is compatible between the two observations.
An expanding ring of X-ray, interpreted as the dust-scattered
echo of the prompt emission was also detected during the first
observation (Watson et al. 2004).
GRB 031220 Melandri et al. (2005) have reported 2 possi-
ble candidates which have the same flux during the first TOO.
We report only the proposed candidate, which was not detected
during the second TOO.
GRB 040106 The light curve of the PN instrument displays
a decay with an index of 1.4 ± 0.1. We note that Moran et al.
(2005) reported a very high constraint on the decay index, using
a summed light curve. We thus summed the light curves of the
three EPIC instruments into a single light curve. We obtained a
decay index of δ = 1.38 ± 0.09 (90% confidence level). Using
only the 1 sigma level (as in Moran et al. 2005), the error drops
to 0.04, i.e. similar to their value.
GRB 040701 This burst was observed twice, but several
sources within the position error box show variations. We re-
port only the candidate proposed by Fox et al. (2004).
4. Discussion
4.1. Comparisonbetweenafterglows
Twenty four afterglows were securely detected (out of 28 ob-
servations), and one observation gave a doubtful afterglow
detection. This is a detection efficiency of 85 % (89 % if
the doubtful detection is indeed an afterglow). We discuss
why some afterglows (GRB 011130, GRB 020531, and GRB
021201) were not detected in Sec. 4.3, and propose as an expla-
nation a jet effect. Our sample can be separated into the XMM-
Newton, Chandra-grating and Chandra-imaging sub-samples.
The selection criteria to perform an observation are differ-
ent in each of these samples. In the Chandra-grating sample,
most of the observations were triggered because of a bright
prompt emission detected in X-ray instruments. These bursts
were therefore selected to be bright (see Table 3) in order to
produce good quality high resolution spectra. The Chandra-
imaging sample is mostly constituted of approved TOOs. Each
of these TOOs have different goals (e.g. accurate localization,
high redshift burst hunt), and one may consider this sample
as not too biased. The XMM-Newton sample is constituted of
bursts observed in the Director's Discretionary Time. These
bursts (except GRB 030329) where rapidly followed because
it was possible to observe them, without a-priori information
on the flux level. One can consider these burst observations
as randomly chosen within all the possible observations, and
thus not biased. In the following, we have assumed that the
Chandra-imaging and XMM-Newton samples do not present a
6
Gendre et al.: XMM-Newton and Chandra GRB X-ray afterglows
Table 4. Mean parameters of each sub-sample from this pa-
per. We include the decay index (δ), the spectral index (α), the
flux at 11 hours after the burst and the observation start time.
We also recall the main parameters from the BeppoSAX sam-
ple (De Pasquale et al. 2005). All errors are quoted at a 68%
confidence level.
Chandra
Imaging
2.0 ± 0.3
0.8 ± 0.1
Chandra
Grating
1.4 ± 0.1
1.0 ± 0.1
XMM
BeppoSAX
1.2 ± 0.2
1.2 ± 0.2
1.3 ± 0.1
1.2 ± 0.1
−11.6 ± 0.3
−11.8 ± 0.3
−12.6 ± 0.2
−12.2 ± 0.1
145.4
95.9
30.1
36.5
δ
α
Log(Flux)
@ 11 hours
Obs. time
(ksec)
selection bias, and we have excluded from the flux comparison
the Chandra-grating sample, as these bursts were chosen to be
very bright (and thus present a bias toward the bright end of the
afterglow luminosity distribution).
We list the fluxes, interpolated or extrapolated to a common
time of 11 and 12 hours, of those bursts with a good constraint
on the decay index in Table 3. We list the mean parameters of
each subsample in Table 4 (not taking into account the doubtful
afterglow of GRB 020321). We recall that the XMM-Newton
and BeppoSAX samples are not very different in the observa-
tion time, while the Chandra sample is observed later. In both
Tables 3 and 4 this discrepancy between the XMM-Newton and
Chandra samples appears in both the fluxes and the decay in-
dex. The higher flux extrapolated at 11 hours for the Chandra
Imaging sample can be explained as due to the steeper decay
of these bursts : the interpolation to early times is very sensi-
tive to a significant change of the decay properties. We stress
that the Chandra Grating data are not strongly affected by this
effect due to the small change of the mean decay index com-
pared to the mean XMM-Newton decay index (see Table 4).
We note a marginal discrepancy not significant in the spectral
index (the errors reported in Table 4 are quoted to the 1σ level
only) between the Chandra Imaging and the other samples. We
also note that there is no strong difference between the XMM-
Newton and BeppoSAX samples, which indicates that there is
no selection bias between these two samples. Taking into ac-
count the flux level of GRB 020321, the mean XMM-Newton
afterglow flux decrease to 10−12.7±0.3 erg cm−2 s−1, still of the
same order of magnitude of the BeppoSAX one.
Berger et al. (2005) found that SWIFT X-ray afterglows
are fainter compared to those observed by other instru-
ments. They explain this discrepancy by a selection effect
on the instrument that detected the burst (BeppoSAX, IPN,
INTEGRAL, HETE-2 versus SWIFT). They support this re-
sult using a dataset of 14 SWIFT bursts and 49 other bursts.
To do so, they extrapolated (or interpolated) to 12 hours after
the burst the flux quoted in published papers or in GCNs, using
the reported decay index (when present) or a mean value of δ
(1.3 if the quoted afterglow flux was measured at least one hour
after the burst, or 1 otherwise), and a simple power law decay.
We have checked if this discrepancy also appears using the lim-
ited sample of XMM-Newton and Chandra bursts (15 bursts).
Fig. 2. Cumulative distribution of flux of the afterglows ob-
served by XMM-Newton (dashed line) and Swift-XRT (con-
tinuous line) 12 hours after the burst.
In order to take into account the bias effect toward higher fluxes
observed in the Chandra data discussed above, we removed the
Chandra observations and retained only the 7 XMM-Newton
bursts. We present in Fig. 2 the comparison of these 14 SWIFT
bursts with the 7 XMM-Newton ones. Four Swift bursts are
observed with a flux larger than 10−12 erg s−1 cm−2, while no
XMM-Newton bursts are observed at this level of flux. Six of
the Swift bursts are brighter than 5 × 10−13 erg s−1 cm−2 while
only one XMM-Newton burst is observed at this level of bright-
ness. It thus seems, using our very limited sample, that SWIFT
bursts are not fainter than the XMM-Newton ones. Because the
XMM-Newton sample is limited (7 bursts), we have checked if
this result still holds using the more complete BeppoSAX sam-
ple. Comparing the mean afterglow flux measured by SWIFT,
which is 10−12.4 erg cm−2 s−1 at 12 hours after the burst, with
the BeppoSAX one (10−12.2 erg cm−2 s−1, extrapolated to 12
hours using the main parameters listed in Table 4), we do not
observe any strong discrepancy between the two samples.
Moreover, we can consider the effect of the early afterglow
evolution on the comparison. As reported by Burrows et al.
(2005) and Chincarini et al. (2005), some of the early after-
glow light curves are not compatible with a simple power law.
For this reason, we have discarded from the 14 SWIFT burst
sample those for which the flux at 12 hours after the burst was
extrapolated using an observation made at less than 3 hours
after the burst. Four SWIFT bursts were removed. Those 4
bursts removed from the sample have the lowest extrapolated
fluxes. We still do not observe significant discrepancies be-
tween SWIFT and BeppoSAX bursts : the mean SWIFT flux
value changes to 10−12.3 erg cm−2 s−1 using only the reduced
SWIFT sample.
Gendre et al.: XMM-Newton and Chandra GRB X-ray afterglows
7
Fig. 4. Composite light curve of an X-ray afterglow. XMM-
Newton bursts are in blue, Chandra Grating bursts in black,
Chandra-Imaging bursts in red. Points relative to the same af-
terglow are connected by a solid line. The two dashed purple
lines represent the mean decay observed from XMM-Newton
and Chandra Imaging bursts.
of the beam is smaller than or equal to the (time dependent) rel-
ativistic collimation, one obtains (Rhoads 1997) independently
of the density profile :
δ − 2.0α = 0
δ − 2.0α = 1
ν > νc
ν < νc
(5)
(6)
We present the closure relationships for all bursts with good
constraints in Fig 3. The average positions for each sub-sample
are δ − 2.0α = −0.93 ± 0.36, −0.36 ± 0.17, 0.33 ± 0.32 and
−1.14 ± 0.18 for XMM-Newton, Chandra (grating), Chandra
(imaging) and BeppoSAX (see De Pasquale et al. 2005, for the
BeppoSAX case) respectively when equations 5 and 6 apply.
When equations 1, 2, 3 and 4 apply, these positions are δ −
1.5α = −0.39 ± 0.31, 0.10 ± 0.14, 0.74 ± 0.32 and −0.6 ± 0.2
respectively.
The XMM-Newton and BeppoSAX results are very similar.
On the other hand, the mean position value changes from the
XMM-Newton sample to the Chandra samples, with two ex-
treme positions (XMM-Newton and Chandra imaging samples)
and one intermediate position (Chandra grating). The mean ob-
servation start times within these three samples are 30.1, 95.9
and 145.4 kiloseconds for the XMM-Newton, Chandra grating
and Chandra imaging samples. We can interpret this evolution
either as a passing through of the cooling frequency in the X-
ray band or as a jet signature. We discuss this in the following
two sections, but note however that this is the first time we ob-
serve a clear evolution with time of the global afterglow prop-
erties from late X-ray data.
Fig. 3. The closure relationships for all bursts with constraints
on both the spectral and temporal decay indexes. We indicate
the closures for the three cases (Jet effects, Wind model, ISM
model) in the three panels. Vertical lines indicate the theoretical
expected values. Afterglows observed by Chandra are located
at the top (in red for Chandra Imaging and in black for Chandra
Grating data), while those observed by XMM-Newton are lo-
cated at the bottom (in blue, see electronic version for colors).
4.2. Timeevolutionoftheclosurerelationships
The values of the decay index (δ) and the spectral index (α) are
linked through closure relationships. These relationships de-
pend on the burst environment and the burst geometry (Rhoads
1997; Sari et al. 1998; Chevalier & Li 1999). According to
Sari et al. (1998), if the burst is surrounded by a medium with
uniform density, then :
δ − 1.5α = −0.5 ν > νc
δ − 1.5α =
ν < νc
0
(1)
(2)
In the case of a surrounding medium with a non uniform
profile decreasing like r−2 (the wind profile, Chevalier & Li
1999; Chevalier et al. 2004), we obtain :
δ − 1.5α = −0.5 ν > νc
δ − 1.5α = 0.5 ν < νc
(3)
(4)
One can also estimate the geometry of the burst by a set of
closure relationships. In case of a jet, when the opening angle
8
Gendre et al.: XMM-Newton and Chandra GRB X-ray afterglows
4.3. Burstgeometry
According to Sari et al. (1999) and assuming a burst located at
z=1, the beaming angle is :
XMM-Newton and Chandra Imaging samples, and taking into
account the mean observation time (1 day after the burst and 2
to 10 days after the burst for XMM-Newton and Chandra re-
spectively), we can set lower and an upper limits :
θ = 0.166 n0
Ei,52!1/8
t3/8
b
rad
(7)
0.166 n0
Ei,52!1/8
< θ < 0.39 n0
Ei,52!1/8
(8)
In Eqn. 7, n0 is the density in particle cm−3, Ei,52 is the
isotropic energy in units of 1052 erg, and tb is the jet break
date expressed in days after the burst. The top panel of Fig.
3 displays the result for the jet signature, and indicates that
we can rule out a jet signature within XMM-Newton bursts
and cannot rule out this signature within Chandra bursts. This
does not exclude the possibility of a collimated fireball in the
XMM-Newton burst cases, but simply puts a lower limit on
the jet opening angle. Other facts indicate a possible break in
the Chandra burst light curves. As can be noted in Table 3, the
Chandra bursts appear brighter than the XMM-Newton ones
when extrapolated back to half a day after the burst. Within the
Chandra sample, there is also a trend : the brightest afterglows
(12 hours after the bursts) are also the ones observed latest. All
of this may indicate that the crude extrapolation using a single
power law is not correct, and that there is a break in the light
curve before the observation. Moreover, the position evolution
with time of the calculated jet closure relationships (Eqn. 5 and
6) as previously discussed can be interpreted as a convergence
toward the expected value in the case of a jet signature. This is
also clear if one produces a composite light curve from all the
bursts observed (see Fig. 4).
To produce Fig. 4, we first rescaled the flux levels of the
XMM-Newton bursts observed before 105 seconds to match
the mean XMM-Newton flux level at 11 hours (which gives
the value 1 in Fig. 4). We then scaled the Chandra grating flux
levels to the mean Chandra grating flux level, and used a mul-
tiplicative factor to smoothly connect the XMM-Newton and
Chandra grating light curves. We then rescaled the remain-
ing bursts (one late XMM-Newton and 3 Chandra Imaging
observations) to connect the composite light curve. One can
clearly see an evolution from the XMM-Newton to the Chandra
Imaging observations. The decay changes from 1.2 ± 0.2 to
2.0 ± 0.3 (∆δ = 0.8 ± 0.5, 90% confidence level), consistent
with a jet break (the theoretical value is ∆δ = 0.83 − 1.33, de-
pending on the position of the cooling frequency and the burst
environment) but not with a cooling break (∆δ = 0.25). We
note however that some faint events feature a shallower appar-
ent decay (e.g. GRB 030723), not compatible with a jet break.
While we cannot exclude the hypothesis that some of these ob-
ject with a shallow decay are not related to GRBs (other galac-
tic X-ray objects are variable, see e.g. Gendre et al. 2003) or
indeed present a large beaming angle, this shallow decay may
also indicate flaring afterglows like GRB 970528 (Piro et al.
1998) or GRB 050904 (Watson et al. 2005; Cusumano et al.
2005). The light curve resolution does not allow us to discrim-
inate between these 3 hypothese, and in the remaining we use
only bursts with a good light curve resolution. Doing so, we
thus explain the evolution of the closure relationship values
and the steep Chandra Imaging burst decays by a jet effect
at late times. Assuming there is no selection bias within the
Assuming typical values for n0 and Ei,52 (0.1, 10 respec-
tively, Frail et al. 2001), we obtain from Eqn. 8 : 0.09 rad
< θ < 0.22 rad (5.1 deg < θ < 12.6 deg), which is in agree-
ment with previous works (e.g. Frail et al. 2001; Berger et al.
2003).
The steep decay observed late can also explain the non-
detections. The observations that led to non detections are per-
formed very late (see Table 2). At that time, one should observe
a steep decay of the afterglow due to the jet effect. This could
prevent a detection due to the afterglow faintness at that time.
We have looked for a standard energy emission in the X-ray
afterglow as in Berger et al. (2003). As the XMM-Newton and
Chandra catalog does not present enough bursts with known
beaming angle to have meaningful results, we have extended
our sample using the BeppoSAX catalog (De Pasquale et al.
2005). We have computed the X-ray luminosity using the con-
version formula quoted in Lamb & Reichart (2000) and used
by Berger et al. (2003). We have included in our sample bursts
neither with unknown redshift, nor bursts with poorly con-
strained spectral and temporal decay indexes. Eighteen bursts
were included, out of which 14 have a known beaming an-
gle. We have computed the luminosity at a common epoch of
11 hours after the burst using for each burst its spectral and
temporal decay indices (note that Berger et al. 2003, used a
mean spectral index and mean values for the temporal decay
index and redshift for unknown values). The result is shown
in Fig. 5. In the top panel, we have plotted the isotropic lu-
minosity distribution for all the 18 bursts indicated above. In
the middle panel, we plotted the isotropic luminosity distri-
bution for only those bursts with a known beaming angle (14
bursts), and in the bottom panel, we plotted the beaming cor-
rected luminosity distribution of these 14 bursts. We have fitted
a Gaussian distribution to each luminosity distribution. We ob-
tained σ = 0.5 ± 0.3 for the upper panel, σ = 0.5 ± 0.2 for
the middle panel and σ = 0.4 ± 0.2 for the lower panel. The
values obtained by Berger et al. (2003) were σ = 0.7 ± 0.2
for the isotropic luminosity distribution and σ = 0.3 ± 0.1
for the beaming-corrected luminosity distribution. We observe
the same (within error bars) distributions when one corrects
for beaming. However, our isotropic luminosity distribution is
narrower than the one observed by Berger et al. (2003), while
compatible within the error bars. In fact, its width is consis-
tent with that of the beaming-corrected distribution. So, we
do not observe a significant shrinking of the luminosity dis-
tribution when taking into account the beaming. We thus can-
not confirm the Berger et al. (2003) claim for a standard re-
lease of energy in the X-ray afterglow. The addition of sev-
eral SWIFT bursts may reduce the error bars and may help to
reach a conclusion on that effect. Also, we can observe in the
top panel a bimodal distribution compatible with the results of
Gendre & Boer (2005).
Gendre et al.: XMM-Newton and Chandra GRB X-ray afterglows
9
4.5. Absorption
From our analysis, 8 bursts (of 17) present an excess of ab-
sorption that ranges from 0.5 × 1021 to 88 × 1021 cm−2, with
a median value of ∼ 5.8 × 1021 cm−2. We present the distribu-
tion of absorption versus the redshift in Fig. 6. GRB 040223
is located near the galactic plane (l=341.6138◦, b=3.1940◦).
The galactic column density in that direction is 6 × 1021 cm−2
(Dickey & Lockman 1990), and varies (within one degree) be-
tween 4.46 ×1021 and 9.26 ×1021 cm−2 (as one may expect, this
increase is due to a change in the distance to the galactic disk).
Schlegel et al. (1998) indicated that their work cannot be used
with b < 5◦; as a diagnostic, the NH value expected from their
map of dust is ∼ 9 × 1021. Assuming that all the absorption
is galactic, we obtain NH = (1.8 ± 0.3) × 1022, which is not
compatible with either the Dickey & Lockman (1990) or the
Schlegel et al. (1998) values. Assuming the largest observed
absorption value within one degree, one obtains an extragalac-
tic absorption of NH,z=1 = (4.5±1.5)×1022, which is larger than
the values observed in other bursts. In the remaining, we will
conservatively use this value. If this burst is at short distances
(z ∼ 0.1), then the extragalactic absorption value becomes of
the same order as the one observed in other bursts.
We have investigated whether some non detections of the
optical afterglow may be due to the absorption. Assuming
a galactic gas to dust law, using the work of Schlegel et al.
(1998), the observed excess of absorption implies an extinc-
tion in the R band between 0.27 and 25.06 magnitudes (with a
mean of 3.23 magnitudes, excluding the value of GRB 040223
from the calculation due to its uncertainty). This high opti-
cal extinction is not in agreement with optical data and lead
Galama & Wijers (2001) to propose that GRBs can destroy
dust around them. On the other hand, Stratta et al. (2004) in-
dicated that the galactic gas to dust law is not suited for GRB
studies, and indicated that the correct laws may be those of
Calzetti et al. (1994) and Calzetti (1997). Using these laws,
the R extinction is still ranging from 0.13 to 11.08 magnitudes
(with a mean of 1.43 magnitudes). A burst like GRB 040223,
with an R extinction of at least 11.08 magnitudes, would not be
detectable in the optical, even at very early times.
Bursts with no optical detection but with a posi-
tive detection in X-rays or radio are called Dark Bursts.
De Pasquale et al. (2003) indicated that 75% of dark bursts are
faint bursts with a failed detection of the optical afterglow due
to its faintness. The remaining ones are those that do not fit
the simple fireball afterglow spectral model (unabsorbed bro-
ken power laws, see Sari et al. 1998) because of a depletion in
the optical. According to De Pasquale et al. (2003), these truly
dark bursts account for the remaining 25 % of dark bursts. They
can be distant bursts (z > 5, so that the Lyα break is redshifted
into the optical range) or absorbed bursts (the effect of absorp-
tion would be more severe in optical than in X-rays or radio,
and can prevent an optical detection). This result was confirmed
by Jakobsson et al. (2004) using a different method.
Eight bursts of our sample do not present an optical af-
terglow. GRB 040223 is located near the galactic plane, and
the galactic absorption can explain the non-detection, as indi-
cated before. Two of the remaining 7 dark bursts are absorbed
Fig. 5. Distributions of
the isotropic luminosity for all
BeppoSAX, XMM-Newton or Chandra bursts with good con-
straints on the spectral and temporal decay index and known
redshift (top panel), for a sub-sample of bursts with known
beaming angle (middle panel), and distribution of the beaming
corrected luminosity of this sub-panel (bottom panel) using the
method of Berger et al. (2003). All luminosities were calcu-
lated at 11 hours after the burst (in the burst rest frame), using
the observed values of spectral index, temporal decay, redshift
and beaming angle. The low luminosity outlier in the top panel
is GRB 031203, not plotted in the two other panels.
4.4. Surroundingmedium
The central and bottom panels of Fig. 3 display the results for
the wind and constant density environments respectively.
Most of the bursts can fit both of the medium classes. This
is mainly due to the degenerations observed for 2 closure rela-
tionships, requiring data taken below νc to constrain the burst
environment. However, we can distinguish the medium type for
one burst.
Using the X-ray afterglow data only, we can constrain the
burst environment of GRB 040106 to be a wind environment
(Gendre et al. 2004b). Moran et al. (2005) ruled out this con-
clusion on the basis of their re-analysis, stating that the closure
was at more than 3σ of the theoretical position. They based
their conclusions on the 1σ error bars they quoted. Using our
analysis and the 90% confidence level as derived from a study
of the χ2 space for all the errors (which is larger than twice the
1σ error), we confirm that the theoretical position of the clo-
sure is within the 90% confidence level region of the observed
closure, and thus we claim that this burst is indeed surrounded
by a wind profile due to the burst progenitor.
10
Gendre et al.: XMM-Newton and Chandra GRB X-ray afterglows
We present the optical versus X-ray fluxes diagram in Fig.
7. Because of the bias discussed earlier and the possible jet
effects in the light curves, we used only the XMM-Newton
sample, together with the BeppoSAX sample, to build this fig-
ure. All the values have been corrected for the galactic ab-
sorption (X-ray) or extinction (R band), using the work of
Schlegel et al. (1998). Not all XMM-Newton bursts are dis-
played in this figure : three GRBs in our sample do not have de-
tected optical afterglows (or the detections are very late). We do
not include the corresponding upper limits in Fig. 7 due to the
poor constraints they give (they are R< 18 at 11 hours after the
burst once corrected for the galactic reddening). We have fitted
these data points using an empirical power law. The best fitted
relationships are indicated in the figure. To derive these rela-
tionships, we have included (dashed line) and excluded (solid
line) from the fit the upper limits. We can use these laws to test
the hypothesis of absorption around faint optical afterglows.
To do so, we focus on GRB 020322. This burst is located in the
"dark" side of the figure : it is a normally bright X-ray after-
glow, while it displays a faint optical afterglow. It also displays
an excess of X-ray absorption (see Table 1 and Watson et al.
2002b). Using the laws of Calzetti et al. (1994) and Calzetti
(1997), we calculated an extinction of 1.6 ± 0.4 in the R band.
The error on this value is calculated taking into account all the
uncertainties of the spectral fit (i.e. on the galactic absorption,
on the intrinsic absorption and on the spectral index). The best
fitted relationships imply an extinction of 0.5−2.5 for this burst,
compatible with our finding from the X-ray. As other bursts
present an extragalactic absorption higher than the one of GRB
020322, some of the dark bursts located in the same area of this
diagram may be absorbed bursts. Note that this does not imply
that all dark bursts are absorbed ones. In fact, ∼ 50% of bursts
present an excess of absorption, and 5 of these are not dark : the
presence of absorption does not conflict in all the cases with the
optical afterglow detection.
5. Conclusion
We have presented a catalog of X-ray afterglows observed with
XMM-Newton and Chandra. We have derived the absorption
in the host galaxy, the decay and spectral indexes, and the ob-
served unabsorbed fluxes.
We have observed variations of the global properties of the
X-ray afterglows within the samples that we explain by a jet
effect in the sample. This is observed from both a variation of
the closure relationships and the steepening of the mean de-
cay index for bursts observed late. We have shown that jet ef-
fects are not present within one day after the burst. Taking ad-
vantage of the late observation time of Chandra, we find that
the jet signature occurs between two and ten days after the
burst. This allowed us to constrain the jet opening angle value.
We have not noticed differences between the XMM-Newton
and BeppoSAX samples that can be explained by an absence
of a selection bias between these observatories. We have not
observed a significant shrinking of the luminosity distribution
when we corrected for beaming. This result needs to be con-
firmed by more burst observations, e.g. by SWIFT. In addition,
we have found that the SWIFT X-ray afterglows are similar to
Fig. 6. X-ray absorption versus redshift. We indicate in this fig-
ure all detected absorptions or the corresponding upper limits
for all bursts bright enough for a spectral study. The redshift
was assumed to be one when not available.
Fig. 7. Optical versus X-ray fluxes of GRB afterglows 11
hours after
the burst. Squares and open circles repre-
sent XMM-Newton and Beppo-SAX data (extracted from
De Pasquale et al. 2003) respectively. Lines indicate the best
fit relationships (see text for details).
(one of these two bursts has been classified as truly dark by
Jakobsson et al. 2004). This represents ∼ 28 % of the dark
burst sample. We used a very limited sample, and that this re-
sult should be considered as a trend. This number is of the same
order as the 25 % of truly dark bursts (the counting statistic un-
certainty is ∼ 14 %). The truly dark bursts may thus be only
absorbed bursts, whereas we cannot exclude that a small frac-
tion (<∼ 14%) of dark bursts may in fact be distant (z> 5)
bursts.
Gendre et al.: XMM-Newton and Chandra GRB X-ray afterglows
11
those of XMM-Newton and BeppoSAX, while Chandra ones
are biased toward higher luminosities. If this bias is not consid-
ered, the SWIFT bursts are fainter than the complete sample of
all bursts listed here. We have also indicated that several dark
bursts may be simply extinguished in optical due to the high
absorption observed around the bursts.
Acknowledgements. We thank G. Garmire for his help during the
analysis of the Chandra grating data, and B. McBreen for pointing
out some missed info in the catalog. We thank the anonymous referee
for the report and for pointing out one missed burst. Thanks are also
due to M. De Pasquale for help with the temporal analysis. This work
was supported by the EU FP5 RTN 'Gamma ray bursts: an enigma and
a tool'. A.C. acknowledges support from an INFN grant. This work is
based on observations obtained with XMM-Newton, an ESA science
mission with instruments and contributions directly funded by ESA
Member States and NASA.
References
D'Alessio, V., Piro, L., & Rossi, E.M., 2005, A&Asubmitted,
astro-ph/0511272
Gendre, B., & Boer, M., 2005, A&A, 430, 465
Harrisson, F.A., Yost, S., Fox, D., et al., 2001, GCN #1143
Hjorth, J., Sollerman, J., Møller, P., et al. 2003, Nature, 423,
847
Jakobsson, P., Hjorth, J., Fynbo, J.P.U., et al., 2004, ApJ, 617,
L21
Klebesadel, R.W., Strong, I.B., & Olson, R.A., 1973, ApJ, 182,
L85
Klose, S., Greiner, J., Rau, A., et al., 2004, AJ, 128, 1942
Kouveliotou, C., Meegan, C.A., Fishman, G.J., et al. 1993, ApJ,
413, L101
Lamb, D.Q., & Reichart, D.E., 2000, ApJ, 536, L1
De Luca, A., Melandri, A., Caraveo, P.A., et al., 2005, A&A,
440, 85
McGlynn, S., McBreen, S., Hanlon, L., et al., 2005, il nuovo
cimento, 28, 481
Melandri, A., de Urgate, A., Gendre, B., et al., 2005, A&A, in
press, astro-ph/0510604
Mereghetti, S., Gotz, D., Tiengo, A., et al., 2003, ApJ, 590, L73
Meszaros, P, & Rees, M.J., 1997, ApJ, 476, 232
Metzger, M.R., Djorgovski, S.G., Kulkarni, S.R., et al., 1997,
Amati, L., Frontera, F., in't Zand, J.J.M., et al., 2004, A&A,
Nature, 387, 879
426, 415
Arnaud, K.A., 1996, in ASP Conf. Ser. Vol. 101, Astronomical
Data Analysis Software and Systems V, ed. G. Jacoby & J.
Barnes, 17
Berger, E., Kulkarni, S. R., & Frail, D. A., 2003, ApJ, 590, 379
Berger, E., Kulkarni, S.R., Fox, D.B., et al., 2005, submitted to
ApJ(astro-ph/0505107)
Mirabal, N., Paerels, F., & Halpern, J.P., 2003, ApJ, 587, 128
Moran, L., Mereghetti, S., Gotz, D., et al., 2005, A&A, 432,
467
Panaitescu, A., Meszaros, P., & Rees, M.J., 1998, ApJ, 503,
314
Panaitescu, A., & Kumar, P., 2002, ApJ, 571, 779
De Pasquale, M., Piro, L., Perna, R., et al., 2003, ApJ, 592,
Butler, N.R., Marshall, H.L., Ricker, G.R., et al., 2003, ApJ,
1018
597, 1010
De Pasquale, M., Piro, L., Gendre, B., et al., 2005,
Butler, N.R., Sakamoto, T., Suzuki, M., et al., 2005, ApJ, 621,
A&Asubmitted, astro-ph/0507708
884
Burrows, D.N., Romano, P., Falcone, A., et al., 2005, Science
Piro, L., Costa, E., Feroci, M., et al., IAUC #6467, 1996
Piro, L., Amati, L., Antonelli, L.A., et al., 1998, A&A, 331,
309, 1833 (astro-ph/0506130)
L41
Calzetti, D., Kinney, A.L., Storchi-Bergmann, T., 1994, ApJ,
Piro, L., Garmire, G., Garcia, M.R., et al., 2000, Science, 290,
429, 582
955
Calzetti, D.,1997, AJ, 113, 162
Chevalier, R.A., & Li, Z.Y., 1999, ApJ, 520, L29
Chevalier, R.A., Li, Z.Y., & Fransson, C., 2004, ApJ, 606, 369
Chincarini, G., Moretti, A., Romano, P., et al., 2005, submitted
to ApJ, astro-ph/0506453
Costa, E., Frontera, F., Heise, J., et al., 1997, Nature, 387, 783
Cusumano, G., Mangano, V., Chincarini, G., et al., 2005, sub-
mitted to Nature, astro-ph/0509737
Dezalay, J.P.., Lestrade, J.P., Barat, C., et al., 1996, ApJ 471,
L27
Dickey, J.M., Lockman, F.J., 1990, ARA&A, 28, 215
Ehle, M., Breitfellner, M., Gonz´alez Riestra, R., et al., 2004,
Piro, L., Garmire, G., Garcia, M.R., et al., 2001, ApJ, 558, 442
Piro, L., De Pasquale, M., Soffitta, P., et al., 2005, ApJ, 623,
314
Rau, A., Greiner, J., Klose, S., et al., 2004, A&A, 427, 815
Rees, M.J., & Meszaros, P., 1992, MNRAS, 258, 41
Reeves, J.N., Watson, D., Osborne, J.P., et al., 2002, Nature,
416, 512
Rhoads, J.E., 1997, ApJ, 487, L1
Sari, R., Piran, T., & Narayan, N., 1998, ApJ, 497, L17
Sari, R., Piran, T., & Halpern, J.P., 1999, ApJ, 519, L17
Schlegel, D.J., Finkbeiner, D.P., & Davis, M., 1998, ApJ, 500,
525
"XMM-Newton Users' Handbook" available
at http://xmm.vilspa.esa.es/external/xmm user support/do-cumentation/index.shtml
591, L17
Stanek, K.Z., Matheson, T., Garnavich, P. M., et al., 2003, ApJ,
Fox, D.B., et al., 2004, GCN notice #2630
Frail, D.A., Kulkarni, S.R., Sari, R., et al., 2001, ApJ, 562, L55
Galama, T.J., & Wijers, R.A.M.J., 2001, ApJ, 549, L209
Gandolfi, G., 2002, GCN #1281
Gendre, B., Barret, D., Webb, N.A., 2003, A&A, 400, 521
Gendre, B., Piro, L., & DePasquale, M., 2004a, A&A, 424, L27
Gendre, B., de Pasquale, M., Piro, L., et al., 2004b, GCN #2523
Stratta, G., Fiore, F., Antonelli, L.A., et al., 2004, ApJ, 608,
846
Struder, L., Briel, U., Dennerl, K., et al. 2001, A&A, 365, L18
Tiengo, A., Mereghetti, S., Ghisellini, G., et al., 2003, A&A,
409, 983
Turner, M. J. L., Abbey, A., Arnaud, M., et al. 2001, A&A, 365,
L27
12
Gendre et al.: XMM-Newton and Chandra GRB X-ray afterglows
van Paradijs, J., et al., 1997, Nature, 386, 686
Watson, D., Reeves, J.N., Osborne, J.P., et al., 2002a, A&A,
393, L1
Watson, D., Reeves, J.N., Osborne, J.P., et al., 2002b, A&A,
395, L41
Watson, D., Hjorth, J., Levan, A., et al., 2004, ApJ, 605, L101
Watson, D., Reeves, N.J., Hjorth, J., et al., 2005, submitted to
ApJ, astro-ph/0509640
in't Zand, J.J.M., Kuiper, L., Heise, J., et al., 2002, in "GRBs
in the afterglow era : 3rd Rome Workshop", eds M. Feroci,
F. Frontera, N. Masetti & L. Piro, ASP Conf. Ser. 312, 209
|
0802.3423 | 1 | 0802 | 2008-02-23T04:44:02 | Correlations in the properties of static and rapidly rotating compact stars | [
"astro-ph",
"gr-qc",
"nucl-th"
] | Correlations in the properties of the static compact stars (CSs) and the ones rotating with the highest observed frequency of 1122Hz are studied using a large set of equations of state (EOSs). These EOSs span various approaches and their chemical composition vary from the nucleons to hyperons and quarks in $\beta$-equilibrium. It is found that the properties of static CS, like, the maximum gravitational mass $M_{\rm max}^{\rm stat}$ and radius $R_{1.4}^{\rm stat}$ corresponding to t he canonical mass and supramassive or non-supramassive nature of the CS rotating at 1122 Hz are strongly correlated. In particular, only those EOSs yield the CS rotating at 1122Hz to be non-supramassive for which $\left (\frac{M_{\rm max}^{\rm stat}}{M_\odot}\right )^{1/2} \left (\frac{10{\rm km}}{R_{1.4}^{\rm stat}})^{3/2} $ is greater than unity. Suitable parametric form which can be used to split the $M_{\rm max}^{\rm stat}$ $-$ $R_{1.4}^{\rm stat}$ plane into the regions of different supramassive nature of the CS rotating at 1122Hz is presented. Currently measured maximum gravitational mass 1.76$M_\odot$ of PSR J0437-4715 suggests that the CS rotating at 1122Hz can be non-supramassive provided $R_{1.4}^{\rm stat} \leqslant 12.4$ km. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Correlations in the properties of static and rapidly rotating compact stars
B. K. Agrawal∗
Saha Institute of Nuclear Physics, Kolkata - 700064, India.
Raj Kumar and Shashi K. Dhiman†
Department of Physics, Himachal Pradesh University, Shimla - 171005, India.
(Dated: November 21, 2018)
Abstract
Correlations in the properties of the static compact stars (CSs) and the ones rotating with the highest
observed frequency of 1122Hz are studied using a large set of equations of state (EOSs). These EOSs
span various approaches and their chemical composition vary from the nucleons to hyperons and quarks
and radius Rstat
in β-equilibrium. It is found that the properties of static CS, like, the maximum gravitational mass Mstat
max
1.4 corresponding to the canonical mass and supramassive or non-supramassive nature of the
In particular, only those EOSs yield the CS rotating at
CS rotating at 1122 Hz are strongly correlated.
1122Hz to be non-supramassive for which (cid:18) Mstat
max − Rstat
M⊙ (cid:19)1/2(cid:18) 10km
1.4 plane into the regions of different supramassive nature of
the CS rotating at 1122Hz is presented. Currently measured maximum gravitational mass 1.76M⊙ of PSR
form which can be used to split the Mstat
is greater than unity. Suitable parametric
max
1.4 (cid:19)3/2
Rstat
J0437-4715 suggests that the CS rotating at 1122Hz can be non-supramassive provided Rstat
1.4 6 12.4 km.
PACS numbers: 26.60.+c,91.60.Fe,97.10.Kc,97.10.Nf,97.10.Pg
∗Electronic address: [email protected]
†Electronic address: [email protected]
1
I.
INTRODUCTION
The accurate knowledge of the properties of static and rotating compact stars (CSs) are of
utmost importance to probe the behaviour of the equation of state (EOS) of superdense matter.
Even the accurate information on the maximum gravitational mass Mstat
max for the static CS and
its radius Rstat
1.4 with the canonical mass (1.4M⊙), not yet well known, would narrow down the
choices for the plausible EOSs to just a few. The newly measured CS mass 1.76±0.20M⊙ of PSR
J0437-4715 [1] is obtained by the precise determination of the orbital inclination angle, the highest
measured mass for any known pulsar to date. Recent observations of the thermal emission from
the quiescent LMXB X7 in the globular cluster 47 Tuc yield the value of R1.4 to be 14.5+1.8
−1.6 km
[2]. The binary pulsars PSR J0737-3039A,B with masses of the individual star being 1.338M⊙ and
1.249M⊙ are plausible candidates for the measurement the moment of inertia due to the spin-orbit
coupling effects [3]. It is expected that a reasonably accurate value of Rstat
1.4 can be deduced from
the moment of inertia measurement of PSR J0737-3039A [4].
Rotating CSs discovered until recent past have periods of rotation close to one millisecond. The
first millisecond pulsar PSR B1937+214 rotating at the frequency ν = 641Hz was discovered in
1982 [5]. In year 2006, a more rapid pulsar PSR J1748-2446ad rotating at ν = 716 Hz was detected
[6]. Such frequencies are too low to affect significantly the structure of CSs with M > 1M⊙ [7],
since, these CSs have the Keplerian (mass-shedding) frequencies larger than 1000Hz. Very recent
discovery of X-ray transient XTE J1739-285 by Kaaret et al [8] suggests that it contains a CS
rotating at 1122Hz. Following this discovery, the structure of the CS rotating with 1122Hz are
studied using several EOSs [9]. It is found that, for some of the EOSs, this CS is supramassive,
i.e.,
δMB = Mstat
B,max − MB,min,
(1)
is less than 0. In the above equation, Mstat
B,max is the maximum baryonic mass of the static CS and
MB,min is the minimum mass for the CS rotating with 1122Hz for a given EOS.
In the present work we search for the possible correlations in some key properties of static CSs
and the ones rotating with the highest observed frequency of 1122Hz. The properties of these
CSs are computed for a large set of EOSs, which are constructed using variety of approaches with
the chemical compositions ranging from nucleons to hyperons and quarks in β-equilibrium. Our
results suggest that the values of Mstat
max and
Rstat
1.4 alone does not show any systematic correlations [10]. We also unmask the underlying feature
1.4 , and δMB are strongly correlated. Though, Mstat
max, Rstat
2
of the EOS responsible for the supramassive or non-supramassive nature of the CS rotating with
1122Hz.
II. EQUATIONS OF STATE
In this work we consider 24 different EOSs with Mstat
max > 1.6M⊙ which exceeds the recent
mass measurements suggesting only 5% probability that the mass of pulsar PSR J1516+02B is
below 1.59 M⊙ [11]. These EOSs are constructed using various approaches which can broadly be
grouped into (i) models based on variational approach, (ii) relativistic or non-relativistic mean-field
models and (iii) Dirac-Brueckner-Hartree-Fock model. The first group contains EOSs involving
neutrons, protons, electrons and muons. The EOSs considered in this group are: BJ-C [12], FPS
[13], BBB2 [14], AU, WS, and UU [15], and APR [16]. For the second group we consider the
EOSs: O [17], GN3[18], GM1 [19], TM1 [20], G2[21], BalbN1H1 [22], GMU110[23], DH [24],
SSK and GSK1 [25], UY, U0 and L0 [26], GM1-H, UQM52, and CFL52. The EOS GM1-H is
composed of nucleons and hyperons in β equilibrium. The nucleon-meson interaction parameters
are taken from the GM1 parameter set whereas hyperon meson couplings are obtained from SU(6)
model. The EOS UQM52 involves noninteracting unpaired quark matter, composed of massive
u, d, and s quarks, is based upon the MIT Bag Model of quarks. This EOS has been calculated
by using model parameters, bag constant, B = 52 MeV/fm3, masses of three quarks, mu = md =
5.00 MeV/c2, ms = 150 MeV/c2, and QCD coupling constant αc = 0.1. The Color-Flavor-Locked
quark matter equation of state (CFL52) is based upon the free energy as described by [27] and
[28], by using pairing gap parameter ∆ = 100 MeV. The other model parameters such as bag
constant, quark masses, and QCD constant are same as used for UQM52 EOS. In the third group
we consider only one EOS: DBHF by Krastev et al. [29].
III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
The properties of spherically symmetric static and axially symmetric rotating CSs are obtained
by solving the Einstein's equations in 1D and 2D, respectively. The numerical computations are
performed by using RNS code written by Stergioulas and Friedman [30]. In Fig. 1 we present the
values of Mstat
1.4 and δMB obtained for several EOSs. We notice that the value of δMB for a
given EOS is only weakly correlated with those of Mstat
1.4 . It seems, larger is
max as compared to Rstat
max, Rstat
3
max or Rstat
max > 2M⊙ and Rstat
1.4 smaller will be the δMB. On the other hand, δMB large means large Mstat
the value of Rstat
small. For instance, δMB < 0 for all those EOSs for which Rstat
for the cases with Mstat
Mstat
and Rstat
the maximum circumferential equatorial radius Rmax
radius Rmin
eq
shedding instability and that of Rmin
max but Rstat
1.4
1.4 & 14km. Whereas, δMB ≈ 0.75M⊙
1.4 ∼ 10 − 11km. Though δMB is not correlated well with
1.4 alone, but, it might be well correlated with some appropriate combination of Mstat
max
1.4 . In Table I we summarize the properties of the CS, rotating with 1122Hz, calculated at
eq and the minimum circumferential equatorial
are determined by the mass
eq are determined by the secular axi-symmetric instability ac-
cording to turning point theorem [31]. It can be verified from the table that the variations in the
for a few selected EOSs. The values of the radius Rmax
eq
gravitational mass,
M(Rmax
eq ) − M(Rmin
,
(2)
δM = (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
eq )(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
of the CS rotating at 1122Hz are correlated with δMB up to some extent. The difference δM .
0.1M⊙ when δMB is negative. For δMB > 0, δM increases with δMB. Therefore, δMB not only
determines whether the CS rotating at 1122Hz is supramassive or not, but, it also gives an estimate
about the value of δM for a given EOS.
and Rstat
In Fig. 2 we consider the variations of δMB with (cid:16) Mstat
M⊙ (cid:17)
. This combination of Mstat
max
1.4 is analogous to the one derived within the Newtonian approximation to determine the
value of the Keplerian frequency. The values of δMB and (cid:16) Mstat
M⊙ (cid:17)
are well correlated. It
1.4 (cid:19)3/2
is interesting to note that δMB > 0 only if (cid:16) Mstat
M⊙ (cid:17)
tions simply suggest that the high density behaviour of a EOS with respect to its behaviour at low
is greater than unity. These correla-
1/2(cid:18) 10km
1.4 (cid:19)3/2
1.4 (cid:19)3/2
1/2(cid:18) 10km
1/2(cid:18) 10km
Rstat
max
Rstat
max
Rstat
max
density plays a predominant role in determining whether the CS rotating at 1122Hz is supramas-
sive or not. Since, the Mstat
1.4 probes relatively
max probes densest segment of the EOS whereas, Rstat
lower density region of EOS.
We parameterize δMB in terms of Mstat
max and Rstat
1.4 as,
= a0 + a1 Mstat
M⊙ !α 10km
1.4 !β
Rstat
max
δMB
M⊙
.
(3)
The best fit values of the parameters appearing in Eq. 3 are calculated using the results displayed
in Fig. 1. The values of parameters are a0 = −2.75, a1 = 2.5, α = 0.75 and β = 1.56. In Fig. 3,
we plot the results for Rstat
max obtained by solving Eq. 3 for fixed values of δMB. These
plots can provide us immediately some idea of δMB once the properties of the static CS like Mstat
max
and Rstat
1.4 are known. We also superpose the results shown in Fig. 1 by dividing them in to three
1.4 versus Mstat
4
1.4 and Mstat
classes depending on the values of the δMB. The symbols, triangles, circles and squares represent
the values of Rstat
max with δMB lie in the range of −0.5 − 0.0, 0.0 − 0.5 and 0.5 - 1.5 M⊙
respectively. It is evident from Fig. 3 that Eqs. 3 can be used to divide the Mstat
1.4 plane in
to the regions with different δMB. It is to be noted from Fig. 3 that the current measurement of
maximum gravitational mass 1.76M⊙ [1] would set the upper limit on Rstat
1.4 to be 12.4 km which
corresponds to δMB = 0. Interestingly, this upper limit on Rstat
1.4 is closer to the lower limit of 12.9
km obtained by analyzing the high quality X-ray spectra from CS in qLMXB X7 [2]. We plot in
Fig. 4 the curves for moment of inertia Istat
max with fixed values of δMB. These curves
1.4 versus Mstat
max − Rstat
are generated by fitting the values of δMB to the following expression,
δMB
M⊙
= a′
0 + a′
M⊙ !α′
1 Mstat
max
1.4
I0 !β′
Istat
,
(4)
where, I0 = 1045g cm−2 and the values of the best fit parameters are a′
0.63 and β′ = 0.85. Similar to the case of Rstat
g cm−2 from maximum mass of CS measured to date [1].
0 = −3.25, a′
1.4 , we obtained the upper limit of Istat
1 = 3.25, α′ =
1.4 = 1.53 × 1045
IV. SUMMARY
The key properties such as Mstat
1.4 of static CS and δMB (Eq. 1) for the CS rotating
with the highest observed frequency of 1122Hz are computed using 24 diverse EOSs. These EOSs
max and Rstat
are chosen in a manner that they correspond to a wide variety of approaches and their chemical
composition vary from the nucleons to hyperons and quarks in β-equilibrium. The values of δMB
max and Rstat
1.4
analogous to the one popularly used to determine Keplerian frequency. For a given EOS, the CS
are found to be almost linearly correlated with (cid:16) Mstat
M⊙ (cid:17)
rotating at 1122Hz is non-supramassive (i.e., δMB > 0) only if (cid:16) Mstat
M⊙ (cid:17)
unity. It is also noticed that the variations in the gravitational mass for the CS rotating with 1122Hz
; a combination of Mstat
1/2(cid:18) 10km
1/2(cid:18) 10km
1.4 (cid:19)3/2
1.4 (cid:19)3/2
is greater than
Rstat
Rstat
max
max
are up to some extent correlated with the values of δMB (see Table I). In view of these results, it
appears that the observation of the rapidly rotating CSs constrain relative behaviour of EOS at high
density with respect to it's behaviour at low or moderate densities. Since, the Mstat
max probes densest
segment of the EOS, whereas, Rstat
1.4 probes relatively lower density region of EOS. The suitable
parametric forms for the δMB in terms of Mstat
1.4 (Eqs. 3 and 4) are also presented.
Using these parametric forms, one can divide the Mstat
1.4 planes into regions
of different δMB. Thus, for a given EOS, only the knowledge of the key properties of static CSs can
1.4 and Mstat
max and Rstat
1.4 or Istat
max − Istat
max − Rstat
5
well estimate a priori the properties of the resulting CS rotating with 1122Hz. Currently measured
maximum gravitational mass 1.76M⊙ of PSR J0437-4715 suggests that the CS rotating at 1122Hz
1.4 6 1.53 × 1045 g cm−2. It
can be non-supramassive provided Rstat
will be worth while to repeat the present investigations for the CS rotating at higher frequencies.
1.4 6 12.4 km or equivalently Istat
Acknowledgments
The authors greatly acknowledge Professors F. Sammarruca and J. A. Pons for providing the
data for EOSs, DBHF and GMU110 respectivelly. This work was supported in part by the Univer-
sity Grant Commission under grant # F.17-40/98 (SA-I).
6
[1] J. P. W. Verbiest, M. Bailes, W. van Straten, G. B. Hobbs, R. T. Edwards, R. N. Manchester, N. D. R.
Bhat, J. M. Sarkissian, B. A. Jacoby, and S. R. Kulkarni, astro-ph/0801.2589 .
[2] C. O. Heinke, G. B. Rybicki, R. Narayan, and J. E. Grindlay, Astrophys. J. 644, 1090 (2006).
[3] A. Lyne, M. Burgay, M. Kramer, A. Possenti, R. N. Manchester, F. Camilo, M. A. McLaughlin, D. R.
Lorimer, D'Amico, B. C. Joshi, et al., Science 303, 1153 (2004).
[4] I. A. Morrison, T. W. Baumgarte, S. L. Shapiro, and V. R. Pandharipande, Astrophys. J. 617, L135
(2004).
[5] D. Backer, S. Kulkarni, C. Heiles, M. M. Davis, and W. M. Goss, Nature 300, 615 (1982).
[6] J. W. T. Hessels, S. M. Ransom, I. H. stairs, P. C. C. Freire, V. M. Kaspi, and F. Camilo, Science 311,
190 (2006).
[7] S. L. Shapiro and S. A. Teukolsky, Black Holes, White Dwarfs, and Neutron Stars (Wiley, New York,
1983).
[8] P. Kaaret, Z. Prieskorn, J. I. T. Zand, S. Brandt, N. Lund, S. Mereghetti, D. Gotz, E. Kuulkers, and
J. Tomsick, Astrophys. J. 657, L97 (2006).
[9] M. Bejger, P. Haensel, and J. Zdunik, Astron. Astrophys. 464, L49 (2007).
[10] M. Bejger, T. Bulik, and P. Haensel, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 364, 635 (2005).
[11] P. C. C. Freire, Astro-ph/ p. 0712.0024 (2007).
[12] H. A. Bethe and M. Johnson, Nucl. Phys. A230, 1 (1974).
[13] C. P. Lorenz, D. G. Ravenhall, and C. J. Pethick, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 379 (1993).
[14] M. Baldo, I. Bombaci, and G. F. Burgio, Astron. Astophys. 328, 274 (1997).
[15] R. B. Wiringa, V. Fiks, and A. Fabrocini, Phys. Rev. C 38, 1010 (1988).
[16] A. Akmal, V. R. Pandharipande, and D. G. Ravenhall, Phys. Rev. C 58, 1804 (1998).
[17] R. L. Bowers, A. M. Gleeson, and R. D. Pedigo, Phys. Rev. D 12, 3043 (1975).
[18] N. K. Glendenning, Astrophys. J 293, 470 (1985).
[19] N. K. Glendenning and S. A. Moszkowski, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 2414 (1991).
[20] K. Sumiyoshi, H. Kuwabara, and H. Toki, Nucl. Phys. A581, 725 (1995).
[21] R. Furnstahl, B. D. Serot, and H.-B. Tang, Nucl. Phys. A615, 441 (1997).
[22] S. Balberg and A. Gal, Nucl. Phys. A625, 435 (1997).
[23] J. A. Pons, S. Reddy, P. J. Ellis, M. Prakash, and J. M. Lattimer, Phys. Rev. C 62, 035803 (2000).
7
[24] F. Douchin and P. Haensel, Aston. Astrophys. 380, 151 (2001).
[25] B. K. Agrawal, S. K. Dhiman, and R. Kumar, Phys. Rev. C 73, 034319 (2006).
[26] S. K. Dhiman, R. Kumar, and B. K. Agrawal, Phys. Rev. C 76, 045801 (2007).
[27] M. G. Alford, Annu. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 51, 131 (2001).
[28] K. Rajagopal and F. Wilczek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 3492 (2001).
[29] P. G. Krastev and F. Sammarruca, Phys. Rev. C 74, 025808 (2006).
[30] N. Stergioulas and J. L. Friedman, Astrophys. J. 444, 306 (1995).
[31] H. L. Friedman, J. R. Ipser, and R. D. Sorkin, Astrophys. J. 325, 722 (1988).
8
TABLE I: The properties of the compact stars, rotating with frequency ν = 1122 Hz, calculated at the
maximum and the minimum circumferential equatorial radius Rmax
eq
and Rmin
eq . The quantities δM and δMB
for a given EOS are determined by using Eqs.(1 and 2) respectively. The central mass densities ǫc at the
eq and Rmin
Rmax
eq are also presented.
EOS
ǫc
M(Rmax
eq )
(1015gcm−3)
GMU110
GM1-H
1.30322
1.25875
BalbN1H1
1.42497
G2
GM1
UQM52
BJ-C
GSK1
O
SSK
FPS
BBB2
DBHF
CFL52
AU
1.05609
0.86585
1.14801
1.05732
0.98210
0.78443
0.94170
0.98885
0.9615
0.7813
0.948
0.9237
(M⊙)
2.071
2.235
1.825
2.051
2.456
1.585
1.695
1.788
2.138
1.684
1.395
1.476
1.732
0.846
1.143
Rmax
eq
(km)
17.53
18.03
16.88
17.48
18.55
16.14
16.46
16.70
17.81
16.39
15.51
15.79
16.54
12.99
14.46
ǫc
M(Rmin
eq )
(1015gcm−3)
1.48038
1.56496
3.56904
1.81037
1.53015
2.33042
2.55674
2.37515
1.69183
2.55229
3.04073
2.87618
2.19589
2.39711
2.87473
(M⊙)
2.053
2.158
1.704
2.116
2.576
1.864
1.954
2.089
2.554
2.127
1.881
2.002
2.412
1.990
2.215
Rmin
eq
(km)
δM
(M⊙)
δMB
(M⊙)
16.33
0.018
-0.393
15.23
0.074
-0.328
9.97
0.123
-0.079
13.02
0.065
-0.064
13.77
0.120
0.007
11.48
0.279
0.246
10.88
0.259
0.278
11.15
0.301
0.335
12.72
0.416
0.461
10.72
0.443
0.537
9.89
0.486
0.583
10.08
0.526
0.654
11.24
0.680
0.861
10.39
1.144
1.357
9.76
1.072
1.402
9
AU
CFL52
UU
APR
DBHF
BBB2
WS
DH
FPS
SSK
O
GSK1
BJ-C
UQM52
U0
GM1
G2
BalbN1H1
L0
GN3
UY
TM1
GM1-H
GMU110
1.6
2
Mstat
max [MO]
2.4
-0.5
0
0.5
δΜΒ[ΜΟ]
.
1
1.5
10
12
Rstat
1.4 [km]
14
FIG. 1: (Color online) Values of the maximum gravitational mass Mstat
max for static CSs, radius Rstat
1.4 for static
CSs with mass 1.4M⊙ and the difference δMB (Eq. 1) obtained for several EOSs.
10
1.5
1
]
.
O
M
[
B
M
δ
0.5
0
-0.5
0.8
1
(Mstat
max/MO)1/2(10 km/Rstat
1.4)3/2
.
1.2
1.4
FIG. 2: (Color online) Correlations between δMB and (cid:18) Mstat
Rstat
1.4 is analogous to the one commonly used to determine the Keplerian frequency.
M⊙ (cid:19)1/2(cid:18) 10km
1.4 (cid:19)3/2
Rstat
max
. This combination of Mstat
max and
11
]
m
k
[
t
a
t
s
4
.
1
R
16
14
12
10
8
1.6
0 . 5
-
0 . 0
0 . 5
2
2.4
max [MO]
.
Mstat
2.8
FIG. 3: (Color online) Plots for Rstat
1.4 versus Mstat
indicated. Different symbols represent the values of Mstat
max generated using Eq. 3 for δMB = −0.5, 0.0 and 0.5 M⊙ as
1.4 with δMB lying in the range of −0.5−0.0
max and Rstat
(triangles), 0.0 − 0.5 (circles) and 0.5 − 1.5 (squares) M⊙ as also depicted in Fig. 1
12
-0.5
0.0
0.5
2
1.75
]
2
-
m
c
g
5
4
0
1
[
t
a
t
s
4
.
1
I
1.5
1.25
1
1.6
2
2.4
max [MO]
.
Mstat
2.8
FIG. 4: (Color online) Same as fig. 3, but, values of moment of inertia Istat
1.4 are used instead of Rstat
1.4 .
13
|
astro-ph/0011078 | 1 | 0011 | 2000-11-03T12:07:05 | Enhanced interactions, mergers and starbursts in dense cluster environments | [
"astro-ph"
] | Optical and X-ray studies have established the prevalence of significant substructure in clusters of galaxies, indicating that clusters are young systems, and that recent major mergers have occurred in many clusters. Numerical simulations show that sub-cluster merging will result in significant tidal forces on disk galaxies in accreting sub-groups, which is likely to lead to the transformation of spirals to S0s in clusters. Simulations predict simultaneous moderate starbursts in gas-rich disk galaxies in clusters which show on-going or recent merger activity, as well as enhanced galaxy-galaxy interactions and mergers. Observational data from studies of spectral indicators, both of starburst activity in late-type galaxies in nearby clusters, and of poststarburst activity in early-type galaxies in nearby and intermediate redshift clusters, support this scenario. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Galaxy Disks and Disk Galaxies
ASP Conference Series, Vol. 3 × 108, 2000
J.G. Funes, S.J., and E.M. Corsini, eds.
Enhanced interactions, mergers and starbursts in dense
cluster environments
C. Moss
Astrophysics Research Institute, Liverpool John Moores University,
Twelve Quays House, Egerton Wharf, Birkenhead CH41 1LD, U.K.
Abstract.
Optical and X-ray studies have established the prevalence of signifi-
cant substructure in clusters of galaxies, indicating that clusters are young
systems, and that recent major mergers have occurred in many clusters.
Numerical simulations show that sub-cluster merging will result in signif-
icant tidal forces on disk galaxies in accreting sub-groups, which is likely
to lead to the transformation of spirals to S0s in clusters. Simulations
predict simultaneous moderate starbursts in gas-rich disk galaxies in clus-
ters which show on-going or recent merger activity, as well as enhanced
galaxy -- galaxy interactions and mergers. Observational data from stud-
ies of spectral indicators, both of starburst activity in late-type galaxies
in nearby clusters, and of poststarburst activity in early-type galaxies in
nearby and intermediate redshift clusters, support this scenario.
1.
Introduction: sub-cluster merging and cluster disk galaxy evolu-
tion
Both optical studies of sky-projected cluster galaxy distributions (e.g. Baier
1979; Geller & Beers 1982) and studies of cluster X-ray morphologies (e.g. Mohr,
Fabricant & Geller 1993; Buote & Tsai 1996) reveal the presence of significant
substructure in clusters of galaxies. Subgroup velocity statistics (e.g. Dressler
& Shectman 1988; Bird 1994; Girardi et al. 1997; Solanes, Salvador-Sol´e &
Gonz´alez-Casado 1999) confirm these results, and are in substantial agreement in
showing that some 30 -- 40% of clusters have statistically significant substructure.
Numerical simulations also show that subclustering is a typical property of
cluster formation in hierarchical theories of structure formation. Such subclus-
tering is expected for a broad range of cosmologies, and its predicted extent is
in agreement with that observed (e.g. Knebe & Muller 2000). Its prevalance
indicates that clusters are young objects, since such substructure is expected to
be smoothed out over a few cluster crossing times. Moreover the existing sub-
structure indicates that recent major mergers have occurred in many clusters.
The evolution of cluster substructure is potentially of great importance
for its influence on the star formation histories and morphological evolution of
cluster galaxies (e.g Tully & Shaya 1984; Lavery & Henry 1988; Gnedin 1999;
Bekki 1999). However, until very recently this potential influence has largely
been neglected (cf. Bekki 1999). Of particular interest, is its relevance to the
evolution of disk galaxies in clusters.
1
2
Moss
As is well known, Butcher & Oemler (1978) found that the cores of inter-
mediate redshift clusters contain a higher fraction of blue, star-forming galaxies
than similar environments at the present. These galaxies have been shown to be
normal spiral or irregular galaxies, a fraction of which are obviously interacting
or disturbed (e.g. Dressler et al. 1994; Oemler, Dressler & Butcher 1997; Smail
et al. 1997). In rich clusters they constitute up to 50% of the population, but
by the present epoch have been depleted by a factor of two and replaced by
a corresponding increase in S0s (e.g. Dressler et al. 1997). Wang & Ulmer
(1997) have found a correlation between the fraction of blue galaxies in inter-
mediate redshift clusters and the cluster X-ray ellipticities. They interpret the
latter as an age sequence, and conclude that the younger clusters have a higher
fraction of blue, star-forming galaxies. As the authors note, this interpretation
is in accord with a hierarchical clustering scenario, in which a typical distant
cluster is assembled from smaller units which tend to contain more gas-rich,
late type galaxies. The relative depletion of such star-forming galaxies in older,
more relaxed clusters, suggests that the process of sub-cluster merging plays a
crucial role in the transformation of an initial population of cluster spirals to a
subsequent S0 population.
What effect is the sub-cluster merging process likely to have on a population
of gas-rich, star-forming disk galaxies? Bekki (1999) using numerical simulation
of a merger between a small group of galaxies and a cluster, shows that the time-
dependent tidal gravitational field of the merger gives strong nonaxisymmetric
perturbations to the disk galaxies in the group, inducing simultaneous moderate
secondary starbursts in the central regions of the galaxies.
Similarly, Gnedin (1999) using self-consistent cluster simulations, demon-
strates that for substantial infall of additional material into a cluster, the time-
varying gravitational potential causes a sequence of tidal shocks on individual
galaxies over a wide area of the cluster. These shocks enhance galaxy -- galaxy
interactions as well as amplifying galaxy merger rates. Again the effect is also
likely to induce simultaneous starbursts in gas-rich infalling disk galaxies over
a wide area of the cluster. Moreover, the tidal shocks are shown to typically
thicken the disks of large spirals by a factor of two, making it unlikely that spi-
ral structure and gaseous shocks in the inner regions of the galaxies will form.
A significant amount of the dark matter halo is stripped, possibly removing the
resevoir of fresh gas which maintains the star formation activity (cf. Larson,
Tinsley & Caldwell 1980). While gas in the outer regions of the disk can be
stripped by the ram pressure of the ambient medium, interpenetrating collisions
with neighbouring galaxies could remove all their gas. The effect of all these
tidal transformations is the conversion of spirals to S0s.
2. Observational evidence for tidally-induced starbursts in cluster
galaxies
The theoretical considerations discussed above suggest that (moderate) tidally-
induced starbursts should be widespread in cluster gas-rich disk galaxies in clus-
ters which show evidence of on-going or recent merger activity. Together with
enhanced starburst activity, enhanced galaxy -- galaxy interactions and mergers
are also expected. In fact, there is considerable observational evidence to support
Enhanced interactions, mergers and starbursts in dense cluster environments
3
this scenario, both from studies of early-type and late-type galaxies in nearby
clusters, and from evidence of poststarburst galaxies in intermediate redshift
clusters. This evidence is now briefly reviewed.
Caldwell et al. (1993) have surveyed early-type galaxies in the Coma cluster
and found an unusually high number with spectra that reflect recent enhanced
star formation activity in a substructure of the cluster. As noted by Bekki
(1999), this may readily be explained as due principally to tidal gravitational
effects of a group-cluster merger with rather large relative velocity. Caldwell
& Rose (1997) also found a larger fraction of poststarburst galaxies in nearby
clusters with obvious double structure. In a similar fashion, Bekki notes that
these results can also be explained by the tidal effects of cluster mergers.
Moss & Whittle (2000) have undertaken an Hα survey of a magnitude-
limited complete sample of 320 galaxies of types Sa and later within 1.5h−1
Mpc of the centres of 8 nearby Abell clusters. Some 116 of the sample were
detected in emission. A subset of the emission-line galaxies are found to have
tidally-induced circumnuclear starburst emission, as evidenced from the partic-
ular Hα morphology, and its strong correlation with a disturbed galaxy mor-
phology. Starburst emission is found to be most prevalent in the richest clusters
in the survey. The percentage of the total sample of late-type galaxies with
starburst emission is ∼ 40% for the two richest clusters, Coma and Abell 1367.
In contrast, the corresponding percentage for field galaxies in the sample is only
a few percent. Moreover X-ray morphologies and temperature structures for
Coma and Abell 1367 indicate that both these clusters are recent post-merger
systems (cf. Donnelly et al. 1998; Honda et al. 1996). Again, a plausible expla-
nation for the enhanced starburst activity seen in the clusters, is tidal effects of
subcluster merging.
Moss & Whittle also identify a class of late-type galaxies in their sample
which are likely to be on-going mergers, in which the companion is indistin-
guishable from its merger partner. These on-going mergers are most prevalent
in the Coma cluster. They are likely to represent a later stage of close double,
interacting systems with tidally induced emission which comprise a significant
fraction (∼ 14%) of the galaxies they detect with starburst emission.
For intermediate redshift clusters, there is also evidence of an enhance-
ment of starburst emission. Galaxies with spectra showing strong Balmer lines
in absorption, indicative of a poststarburst phase, are an order of magnitude
more frequent in the cluster environment as compared to the high redshift field
(e.g. Dressler et al. 1999; Poggianti et al. 1999). A surprising fraction of
the star-forming galaxies at intermediate redshift show signs of morphological
disturbance, of which many are suggestive of merging systems, virtually al-
ways involving a disk galaxy (cf. Ellis 1999). This suggests a tidal origin for
the starburst phase, although no clear difference in the incidence of disturbed
morphology between the high redshift field and cluster environments has been
established (cf. Dressler et al. 1999).
3. Conclusion
Strong theoretical and observational data suggest that sub-cluster merging plays
a crucial role in the transformation of spirals to S0s in the process of cluster for-
4
Moss
mation, due to the strong tidal forces on the disk galaxy members of an accret-
ing sub-group. Theoretical studies predict simultaneous moderate starbursts in
disk galaxies of the accreting sub-group due to tidal forces. This prediction is
supported by observational data for both nearby and intermediate redshift clus-
ters. Tidal shocks due to the time-varying potential associated with sub-cluster
merging are expected to effect morphological transformation of star-forming disk
galaxies to S0s. Thus these can explain the transformation of the majority of the
spiral population in younger, less relaxed clusters to a population of S0s in older,
more relaxed clusters as an integral part of the process of cluster formation.
References
Baier, F. 1979, Astron. Nachr., 300, 85
Bekki, K. 1999, ApJ, 510, L15
Bird, C.M. 1994, ApJ, 107, 1637
Buote, D.A. & Tsai, J.C. 1996, ApJ, 458, 27
Butcher, H. & Oemler, A. 1978, ApJ, 219, 18
Caldwell, N. & Rose, J. 1997, AJ, 113, 492
Caldwell, N., Rose, J., Sharples, R.M, Ellis, R.S. & Bower, R.G. 1993, AJ, 106,
473
Donnelly, R.H. et al. 1998, ApJ, 500, 138
Dressler, A. & Shectman, S.A. 1988, AJ, 95, 985
Dressler, A., Oemler, A., Butcher, H.R. & Gunn, J.E. 1994, ApJ, 430, 107
Dressler, A. et al. 1997, ApJ, 490, 577
Dressler, A. et al. 1999, ApJS, 122, 51
Ellis, R.S. 1999, in IAU Symp. 183, The Formation and Evolution of Galaxies,
ed. K. Sato, (Dordrecht: Boston), 107
Geller, M.J., & Beers, T.C. 1982, PASP, 94, 421
Girardi, M. et al. 1997, ApJ, 482, 41
Honda, H. et al. 1996, ApJ, 473, L71
Gnedin, O.Y. 1999, Ph.D. Thesis, Princeton Univ.
Knebe, A. & Muller, V. 2000, 354, 761
Larson, R.B., Tinsley, B.M. & Caldwell, C.N. 1980, ApJ, 237, 692
Lavery, R.J. & Henry, J.P. 1988, ApJ, 330, 596
Mohr, J.J., Fabricant, D.G. & Geller, M.J. 1993, ApJ, 413, 492
Moss, C., & Whittle, M. 2000, MNRAS, 317, 667
Oemler, A., Dressler, A. & Butcher, H.R. 1997, ApJ, 474, 561
Poggianti et al. 1999, ApJ, 518, 576
Smail, I., Dressler, A., Couch, W.J., Ellis, R.S., Oemler, A., Butcher H. &
Sharples, R.M. 1997, ApJS, 110, 213
Solanes, J.M., Salvador-Sol´e, E. & Gonz´alez-Casado, G. 1999, A&A, 343, 733
Tully, R.B. & Shaya, E.J. 1984, ApJ, 281, 31
Wang, Q.D. & Ulmer, M.P. 1997, MNRAS, 292, 920
|
astro-ph/9907172 | 1 | 9907 | 1999-07-13T14:55:08 | Spectral Models of the Type Ic SN 1994I in M51 | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present detailed non-local thermodynamic equilibrium (NLTE) synthetic spectra for comparison with a time series of observed optical spectra of the Type Ic supernova 1994I which occurred in M51. With the exceptions of Si I and S I, we treat the important species in the formation of the spectrum in full NLTE. We present results for both a hydrodynamic model that has been fit to the light curve and for an illustrative custom crafted model that is more massive. Both models give reasonable fits to the overall observed spectra; however, neither is able to reproduce all the observed features. Some conspicuous observed features are absent and some predicted features are unobserved. No model that we have explored is able to satisfactorily reproduce the observed infrared feature near 1 micron on April 15, 1994 (+7d), which has been attributed to the triplet He I lambda 10830 transition. The low-mass hydrodynamic model produces an infrared feature with a blend of He I, C I, O I, and Si I--II lines, but it predicts a strong unobserved absorption feature near 6100 Angstroms due to Fe III, and the observed feature just blueward of 6000 Angstroms most likely due to Na D is not reproduced. The more massive model does a better job of reproducing the observed infrared lineshape, but also predicts the unobserved feature near 6100 Angstroms. The early-time spectrum of the low-mass model is far too blue; thus, a more massive model may be slightly favored. Since the predicted infrared feature is produced by a blend of so many elements and there is no overwhelming evidence for other helium features such as lambda 5876, it may be premature to conclude that SNe Ic unambiguously contain helium. Thus, we conclude that pure C+O cores are still viable progenitors for SNe Ic. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Spectral Models of the Type Ic SN 1994I in M51
E. Baron, David Branch
Dept. of Physics and Astronomy, University of Oklahoma, 440 W. Brooks, Rm 131, Norman, OK
73019-0225
[email protected],[email protected]
Peter H. Hauschildt
Dept. of Physics and Astronomy & Center for Simulational Physics, University of Georgia,
Athens, GA 30602-2451
[email protected]
Alexei V. Filippenko
Dept. of Astronomy, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720-3411
[email protected]
and
R. P. Kirshner
CfA, 60 Garden St., Cambridge, MA 02138
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
We present detailed non-local thermodynamic equilibrium (NLTE) synthetic spectra
for comparison with a time series of observed optical spectra of the Type Ic supernova
1994I which occurred in M51. With the exceptions of Si I and S I, we treat the important
species in the formation of the spectrum in full NLTE. We present results for both a
hydrodynamic model that has been fit to the light curve and for an illustrative custom
crafted model that is more massive. Both models give reasonable fits to the overall
observed spectra; however, neither is able to reproduce all the observed features. Some
conspicuous observed features are absent and some predicted features are unobserved.
No model that we have explored is able to satisfactorily reproduce the observed infrared
feature near 1 µm on April 15, 1994 (+7d), which has been attributed to the triplet He I
λ10830 transition. The low-mass hydrodynamic model produces an infrared feature with
a blend of He I, C I, O I, and Si I -- II lines, but it predicts a strong unobserved absorption
feature near 6100 A due to Fe III, and the observed feature just blueward of 6000 A
-- 2 --
most likely due to Na D is not reproduced. The more massive model does a better job
of reproducing the observed infrared lineshape, but also predicts the unobserved feature
near 6100 A. The early-time spectrum of the low-mass model is far too blue; thus, a
more massive model may be slightly favored. Since the predicted infrared feature is
produced by a blend of so many elements and there is no overwhelming evidence for
other helium features such as λ5876, it may be premature to conclude that SNe Ic
unambiguously contain helium. Thus, we conclude that pure C+O cores are still viable
progenitors for SNe Ic.
Subject headings: radiative transfer -- supernovae: individual (SN 1994I) -- supernovae:
general
1.
Introduction
Type I supernovae are classified on the basis of their spectra. SNe Ia have strong Si II λ6355
lines in their spectra where the absorption minimum is typically shifted to around 6100 A near
maximum light, April 8, 1994 (Richmond et al. 1996), and their late-time spectra are dominated
by iron peak elements. SNe Ib have weak or absent Si II lines, but strong optical He I λ5876 and
λ6678 at maximum light, with late-time spectra dominated by lines of [O I] and [Ca II]. SNe Ic
appear very similar to SNe Ib at late times, but they lack the strong He I lines at early times.
Supernova 1994I, which occurred in the nearby galaxy M51, is undoubtedly the best studied
Type Ic supernova to date (Filippenko et al. 1995; Baron et al. 1996; Wheeler et al. 1995; Iwamoto
et al. 1994; Nomoto et al. 1994; Woosley & Eastman 1997; Richmond et al. 1996; Woosley et al.
1993; Clocchiatti et al. 1996; Millard et al. 1999). As originally classified (Harkness & Wheeler 1990;
Wheeler & Harkness 1990), SNe Ic were thought to show a complete absence of He I lines. However,
Filippenko et al. (1995) identified He I λ10830 in the spectrum of SN 1994I and Clocchiatti et al.
(1996) have inferred the presence of weak He I λ5876 and λ6678 lines in SN 1994I as well as in SN
Ic 1987M.
The apparent absence of helium in the spectra of the first few observed SNe Ic led to the
inference that the progenitor star was likely to be a bare (or nearly bare) C+O core of a massive
star, which explodes due to the collapse of the iron core to form a neutron star (Wheeler & Harkness
1990; Harkness & Wheeler 1990). The helium envelope of the massive star could be stripped from
the star either through extensive mass loss in a Wolf-Rayet phase, via interaction with a binary
companion, or a combination of the two (Wheeler & Harkness 1990; Harkness & Wheeler 1990;
Filippenko et al. 1990; Podsiadlowski et al. 1992; Woosley et al. 1993; Nomoto et al. 1994). On
the basis of the rate of decline of the light curve, Nomoto and collaborators suggested that the
difference between SNe Ib and SNe Ic was due to the mass and degree of mixing, with SNe Ic being
both less massive and more mixed (Nomoto et al. 1990, 1991; Yamaoka & Nomoto 1991; Hachisu
et al. 1991; Jeffery et al. 1991; Branch et al. 1991). Since helium is the diagnostic for SNe Ib, it
-- 3 --
has been suggested that SNe Ib should in fact be the more thoroughly mixed ones (Baron 1992;
Woosley & Eastman 1997).
2. Model Construction
Hydrodynamic models of SN 1994I have been constructed to fit the light curve for single star
progenitors (Woosley et al. 1993; Woosley & Eastman 1997) and for binary progenitors (Iwamoto
et al. 1994). We use the CO21 model of Iwamoto et al. (1994) (total ejected mass = 0.9 M⊙, total
deposited energy = 1 × 1051 ergs, and a parameterized model constructed by us to represent the
more massive core favored by Woosley and collaborators (Woosley et al. 1993; Woosley & Eastman
1997). The parameterized model is constructed by specifying a density profile, taken to be ρ ∝ r−N ,
with N = 8, a model temperature Tmodel = 6800 K, the reference radius R0, which is the radius
where the continuum optical depth in extinction at 5000 A (τstd) is unity, the expansion velocity,
v0 = 6000 km s−1, at the reference radius, which is determined by fitting the width and position
of the observed spectral features (and using homologous expansion, R0 = v0 t where t is the time
since explosion and we have used an explosion date of Mar 30 in these calculations, 9 days before B
max), and finally the elemental abundances. The total ejected mass of the model is 2.4 M⊙, with
a kinetic energy of 1.3 × 1051 ergs. The total nickel mass is about 0.1 M⊙; however, since we use
only a local deposition function, no strong physical significance should be attached to this value
and it is only indicative (this is not the case for the hydrodynamical models where the deposition
function is calculated accurately). Setting the elemental abundances leads in principle to 1950 free
parameters, since we include 39 elements and we must specify the relative number fraction of each
of these elements in each of the 50 radial zones used in the calculations. In order to minimize the
number of abundance parameters we follow our previous work (Baron et al. 1996) and begin with
a solar abundance (Anders & Grevesse 1989) and then "burn" all the hydrogen to helium. Next
we "burn" some helium to carbon and oxygen with a final number ratio He/O, and a production
ratio by number of carbon to oxygen (C/O). Finally we allow metals heavier than oxygen to be
scaled by a factor Z (taken equal to the solar value in the model we present here, although we
have studied the effects of varying the model content by up to 3 times the solar value, we find our
results to be insensitive to the metallicity in this range). While in our previous models of SN 1994I
(Baron et al. 1996) the composition was uniform throughout the model, in these calculations that
assumption is relaxed. The hydrodynamic models are fully non-uniform in composition. In the
parameterized models we consider only 2 regions which consist of differing composition; a primarily
helium composition of total mass M = 0.06 M⊙ (for the model presented here He/O = 10), the
remaining portion was primarily C/O composition (for the model presented here He/O = 1, so
helium was somewhat mixed throughout the model). A final parameter of the model was the total
mass of the ejecta. We note that while Tmodel is a parameter used to fit the spectral shape, if the
abundances, velocities, and density structure are in significantly error no choice of Tmodel will lead
to a reasonable fit to the overall shape of the spectrum.
-- 4 --
While we present here the results of our single "best" model we base our conclusions on our
total parameter study which for April 15 alone consisted of 33 different compositions, 5 different
total masses and a range of deposition functions (or degree or mixing of Ni) that spanned 4 orders
of magnitude. The parameter study included allowing for 3 differing compositions (a nearly pure
helium layer, a mixed C/O + He layer, and a nearly pure C/O layer).
Our choice of a local deposition function implies that the nickel is distributed throughout the
atmosphere with a constant mass fraction and the non-thermal ionization rates are then calculated
assuming that all of the gamma-ray energy instantaneously produced is deposited locally. Of course
radioactive decay of the nickel is accounted for. Although this is a somewhat crude approximation,
it is expedient and by varying the assumed nickel mass fraction we can simply study the effects
of mixing. At high optical depths where the matter is in LTE, the assumed deposition function is
irrelevant (our results show that we recover the LTE populations exactly) and thus we really can
probe the effects of nickel mixing in the line forming region with this simple approximation.
For the hydrodynamical models our procedure was the same as described in Nugent et al.
(1997). The results from the hydrodynamical calculations were expanded homologously, radioactive
decay was included when adjusting the compositions, and the gamma-ray deposition function was
calculated assuming pure absorptive gamma-ray opacity and local deposition of positrons. Although
Milne et al. (1999) find that local deposition of positrons likely overestimates the energy deposition
of positrons at late times in Type Ia supernovae, this assumption should have negligible effects on
the early times we explore here.
Figures 1 and 2 present the most important species in the two models (CO21 and our more
massive parameterized model for the April 15 [+7d] epoch) as a function of velocity. Figure 3
displays the velocity as a function of τstd (the total continuum extinction optical depth at 5000 A)
in order to aid in the interpretation of the abundance figures. These ions (O I-II, He I-II, C I-II,
Si II-III, Mg II), are expected and support the line identifications herein and in Millard et al. (1999).
The synthetic spectra predicted by the constructed models were then computed using the gen-
eralized stellar atmosphere code PHOENIX (cf. Hauschildt & Baron 1999, and references therein).
Table 1 lists the ions and number of levels/transitions that we treat in full NLTE in these calcula-
tions. PHOENIX is capable of treating a larger number of species in NLTE, but we have chosen the
most important species for these conditions. Even with this subset of NLTE species each model
calculation takes about 1 day using 5 thin-2 nodes of an IBM SP2 parallel supercomputer.
3. Results
Figure 4 displays our synthetic spectrum for the CO21 model of Iwamoto et al. (1994), com-
pared to the spectrum taken at Lick Observatory on April 15, 1994 (+7d). The observed spec-
trum has been dereddened using the reddening law of Cardelli et al. (1989) and assuming E(B-V)
=0.45 mag. Since the supernova shows very strong interstellar Na absorption lines and occurred in
-- 5 --
a dust lane in M51, the reddening is very uncertain. Values of E(B-V) in the range 0.30 − 0.45 mag
(Baron et al. 1996; Richmond et al. 1996) are reasonable and altering the reddening in this range
will not greatly affect our results. Figure 5 displays our best fit with our massive model. Neither
the CO21 model nor the massive model are able to reproduce all of the observed features. In par-
ticular, neither of the models predicts the strong observed absorption feature near 5800 A, which
is likely produced by the Na D lines (Millard et al. 1999).
The CO21 model does a reasonable job at fitting the overall lineshape of the observed infrared
feature, which it does with a blend of He I and C I λ10695 (and other C I) as well as O I and Si I-
II lines. However, the CO21 model also produces strong, unobserved optical absorption features
near 5000 A, mostly due to Fe III. The CO21 model also does a rather poor job reproducing the
O I λ7773 feature and the Ca II IR triplet.
The massive model has less of a problem with the strong absorption near 5000 A and even
begins to reproduce the observed Fe II features in that region of the spectrum, indicating that the
ionization states of the iron-peak elements is better reproduced in this model. The O I λ7773 feature
is even weaker in this model than in the CO21 model, but the Ca II IR triplet is better reproduced.
Both models do poorly at reproducing the flat bottomed absorption feature near 6250 A, which is
produced either by the Si II λ6355 line or by the C II λ6580 line in a detached shell as proposed
by Millard et al. (1999). We discuss the identity of the features in detail in § 4.
Figures 6 -- 8 display the time history of the CO21 model. In general the overall shape of the
spectra is reasonably well reproduced by the model, but the features themselves are not. Figures 6
shows that the model calculation is too blue at early times. This is almost certainly due to the very
low-mass in the ejecta and may also indicate that more Fe is required in the models. Therefore the
need for a somewhat more massive model is indicated both by the early spectra and by the April
15 (+7d) spectrum.
4. Discussion
Our models show that overall, an ejecta mass near 2.4 M⊙, with a mostly C+O+He compo-
sition, leads to reasonably good agreement with the observed spectra near maximum light. Nev-
ertheless, it is useful to examine the deficiencies of the hydrodynamic model and to explore what
the possible line identifications in the observed spectra are by using sophisticated models. This is
especially important once one realizes that in detailed calculations the features that are usually
identified as due to a single line are in reality produced by blends of many different features that
form in many places in the supernova "atmosphere." Figure 9 displays the spectra produced using
the structure of Figure 4, but with all LTE line opacities set to zero and only the indicated NLTE
line opacities included; all continuum opacities are included in all the calculations. Examining the
spectrum with only continuum opacities we see that the "emission" feature near 3800 A is in fact
the result of a (C II) continuum edge. This fact should lead to caution in identifying features (and
-- 6 --
deriving velocity information) based solely on wavelength coincidences. The Fe II and Co II spectra
lead to features that are recognizable and unremarkable although they appear to be too weak in the
synthetic spectrum. The Fe III and Co III lines are too strong and lead to the unobserved features
near 5000 and 6100 A, indicating that the iron-peak elements are over-ionized. While the 6100 A
feature is weak in this figure, we believe it is masking the observed Na D feature. This is a clear
sign that the mass of the CO21 model is too low, since if the iron-peak elements were at higher
density they would be more likely to recombine. The temperature structure of the atmosphere,
(and therefore our value of the total bolometric luminosity), is reasonably well determined since it
is clearly required to reproduce the overall shape of the spectrum. The He I spectrum is interesting,
in that it produces a relatively weak He I λ5876 line and a He I λ10830 feature that is essentially
in emission. In the full spectrum (Figure 4) there is no evidence of the He I λ5876 feature and
clearly the predicted feature due to He I λ10830 is too weak to have fully produced the observed
infrared feature; therefore in our models this feature must be produced by additional contributions
from C I, O I, and Si I -- II (Si I is treated in LTE in our calculations). Swartz et al. (1993) find that
whenever He I λ10830 is present, so too are He I λ5876 and He I λ6678. While this result lends
credence to our suggestion that the IR feature is in fact produced by alternate species, rather than
by helium, we don't find the He I λ10830 to be as pronounced as they do in their calculations,
which could be caused by the fact that we are examining different epochs or that we treat more
species and complex blending effects diminish the strength of the He I λ10830 line. The spectrum
produced by Si II in Figure 9 is also notable in that it predicts a feature from the Si II λ6355
line that is not noticeable in the full synthetic spectrum. Since the infrared feature is produced to
some extent in our calculations by Si I, it is clearly important to include this species in NLTE in
future work. Millard et al. (1999) have shown that in parameterized calculations it is not possible
to determine whether the feature ascribed to He I λ10830 is due to a blend of He I and C I or
to a blend of Si I lines. The fact that the infrared feature is produced by a blend of a number of
different species in our calculations should lead to caution when making line identifications based
solely on wavelength, particularly when there is only a single feature from an identified species.
Since the excited states of He I lie so high above the ground state, a good predictor for the
strength of the He I lines is the abundance of He II. The fact that He II is prevalent in our
parameterized model (see Figure 2), and somewhat less prevalent in the CO21 model, probably
leads to the more massive parameterized model's better reproduction of the observed lineshapes
and lends some support for the identification of the line as due to helium. This support should be
tempered by the realization that our treatment of gamma-ray deposition in the massive model is
parameterized and not based on direct hydrodynamical calculations. However, we have varied the
value of the deposition function by 4 orders of magnitude which mimics a huge range in mixing
(probably a larger range than is physically reasonable). Additionally, the fact that in the CO21
model the observed infrared feature is produced by a blend of other lines should lead to caution in
the identification of helium in SN 1994I in particular, and SNe Ic in general. Although Clocchiatti
et al. (1996) argue that the absence of a redward shift in the Na D feature is evidence for He I
λ5876 in SN 1994I, there is another feature of the same strength just blueward that is unidentified
-- 7 --
in their spectra; thus, while indicative, these features are not conclusive evidence for the presence
of He I. A hydrodynamical model that does a better job of reproducing the spectrum is needed.
Such a model would likely be more massive than CO21, have the iron-peak elements concentrated
in the first ionization stage, and have more Si II at low velocity. Also, since the Na D line is not well
reproduced in any of our models, we suspect that the gamma-ray deposition is incorrectly ionizing
the sodium.
Fassia et al. (1998) find that in order to fit the observed infrared feature (which they assume
to be due to He I λ10830) in the Type II SN 1995V, they need both dredge-up of 56Ni into the
hydrogen envelope as well as clumping of helium within the hydrogen envelope. Given the fact
that their models fail to fit the O I λ7773 line and that blending with O I and Si I-II lines may
be important in SNe II as well as SNe Ib/c, it seems prudent to view any conclusions based solely
on the apparent presence of He I λ10830 in SNe with caution. Clearly detailed synthetic spectral
models of high-quality hydrodynamic simulations is the best way to draw firm conclusions about
the structure of the supernova ejecta.
We note that since we have not calculated the spectra produced by the model of Woosley and
collaborators (Woosley et al. 1993; Woosley & Eastman 1997), our results certainly are compatible
with that model and it should still be considered a viable candidate. Our most important result
is, however, that the IR feature that has been attributed to helium, is not a clear indicator of the
presence of helium, since it can be produced both by a blend of Si I lines (Millard et al. 1999), or at
the very least consists of a blend of helium and carbon. All the models that we have explored where
the feature was produced explicitly by helium showed strong optical helium features in agreement
with the results of Millard et al. (1999). Finally, we note that future explosion models should
focus on more massive progenitors and should consider models with and without helium in order
to determine the identity of the observed IR-feature.
We thank Peter Hoflich and Ken Nomoto for helpful discussions and for providing us with
the CO21 model. This work was supported in part by NSF grants AST-9417213, AST-9417242,
AST-9731450, and AST-9417102; NASA grant NAG5-3505; an IBM SUR grant to the University of
Oklahoma; and NSF grant AST-9720704, NASA ATP grant NAG 5-3018, and LTSA grant NAG 5-
3619 to the University of Georgia. Some of the calculations presented in this paper were performed
at the San Diego Supercomputer Center (SDSC), supported by the NSF, and at the National
Energy Research Supercomputer Center (NERSC), supported by the U.S. DOE. We thank both of
these institutions for a generous allocation of computer time.
REFERENCES
Anders, E. & Grevesse, N. 1989, Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 53, 197
Baron, E. 1992, MNRAS, 255, 267
-- 8 --
Baron, E., Hauschildt, P. H., Branch, D., Kirshner, R. P., & Filippenko, A. V. 1996, MNRAS, 279,
779
Branch, D., Nomoto, K., & Filippenko, A. V. 1991, Comments on Astrophysics, 15, 221
Cardelli, J. A., Clayton, G. C., & Mathis, J. S. 1989, ApJ, 345, 245
Clocchiatti, A., Wheeler, J. C., Brotherton, M., Cochran, A., Wills, D., Barker, E., & Turatto, M.
1996, ApJ, 462, 462
Fassia, A., Meikle, W. P. S., Geballe, T., Walton, N., Pollaco, D., Rutten, R., & Tinney, C. 1998,
MNRAS, 299, 150
Filippenko, A. V., Porter, A. C., & Sargent, W. L. W. 1990, AJ, 100, 1575
Filippenko, A. V. et al. 1995, ApJ, 450, L11
Hachisu, I., Matsuda, T., Nomoto, K., & Shigeyama, T. 1991, ApJ, 368, L27
Harkness, R. & Wheeler, J. C. 1990, in Supernovae, ed. A. Petschek (New York: Springer-Verlag),
1
Hauschildt, P. H. & Baron, E. 1999, J. Comp. Applied Math., in press
Iwamoto, K., Nomoto, K., Hoflich, P., Yamaoka, H., Kumagai, S., & Shigeyama, T. 1994, ApJ,
437, L115
Jeffery, D., Branch, D., Filippenko, A. V., & Nomoto, K. 1991, ApJ, 377, L89
Millard, J., Branch, D., Baron, E., Hatano, K., Fisher, A., Filippenko, A. V., Kirshner, R. P.,
Challis, P. M., Fransson, C., Panagia, N., Phillips, M. M., Sonneborn, G., Suntzeff, N. B.,
Wagoner, R. V., & Wheeler, J. C. 1999, ApJ, in press
Milne, P., The, L.-S., & Leising, M. 1999, ApJ, in press
Nomoto, K., Filippenko, A. V., & Shigeyama, T. 1990, A&A, 240, L1
Nomoto, K., Shigeyama, T., Kumagai, S., Hachisu, I., & Matsuda, T. 1991, in Proceedings of the
ESO/EPIC Workshop on SN 1987A and other Supernovae, ed. I. J. Danziger & K. Kjar
(Munich: ESO), 173
Nomoto, K., Yamaoka, H., Pols, O. R., van den Heuvel, E. P. J., Iwamoto, K., & Shigeyama, T.
1994, Nature, 371, 227
Nugent, P., Baron, E., Branch, D., Fisher, A., & Hauschildt, P. 1997, ApJ, 485, 812
Podsiadlowski, P., Joss, P. C., & Hsu, J. J. L. 1992, ApJ, 391, 245
Richmond, M. W. et al. 1996, AJ, 111, 327
-- 9 --
Schmidt, B. & Kirshner, R. P. 1994, private communication
Swartz, D. A., Filippenko, A. V., Nomoto, K., & Wheeler, J. C. 1993, ApJ, 411, 313
Wheeler, J. C. & Harkness, R. 1990, Repts. Prog. Phys., 53, 1467
Wheeler, J. C., Harkness, R. P., Clocchiatti, A., Benetti, S., Brotherton, M. S., DePoy, D. L., &
Elias, J. 1995, ApJ, 436, L135
Woosley, S. E. & Eastman, R. G. 1997, in Thermonuclear Supernovae, ed. P. Ruiz-Lapuente,
R. Canal, & J. Isern (Dordrecht: Kluwer), 821
Woosley, S. E., Langer, N., & Weaver, T. A. 1993, ApJ, 411, 823
Yamaoka, H. & Nomoto, K. 1991, in Proceedings of the ESO/EPIC Workshop on SN 1987A and
other Supernovae, ed. I. J. Danziger & K. Kjar (Munich: ESO), 193
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.0.
-- 10 --
Table 1. NLTE Species
Element
Ionization Stage
I
15/105
H
He
11/14
C 228/1387
O
36/66
26/37
Ne
3/2
Na
Mg
· · ·
Si
· · ·
S
Ca
Fe
· · ·
· · ·
494/6903
II
· · ·
· · ·
85/336
171/1304
· · ·
· · ·
18/37
93/436
84/444
87/455
617/13675
III
· · ·
· · ·
79/365
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
155/1027
41/170
· · ·
566/9721
Note. -- The species and number of lev-
els/transitions treated in non -- LTE by PHOENIX
in these calculations.
-- 11 --
Fig. 1. -- The partial pressures of the most prevalent species in the CO21 model as a function of
velocity for the April 15 (+7d) epoch. (The synthetic spectrum produced by this model is shown
in Figure 4.)
-- 12 --
Fig. 2. -- The partial pressures of the most prevalent species as a function of velocity in the
parameterized more massive model for the April 15 (+7d) epoch. (The synthetic spectrum produced
by this model is shown in Figure 5.)
-- 13 --
40000
30000
)
s
/
m
k
(
V
20000
10000
0
10−8
10−6
10−4
10−2
τ
std
100
102
Fig. 3. -- The velocity profiles of the two models in Figures 1 (dashed line) and 2 (solid line). τstdis
the total continuum optical depth at 5000 Angstroms.
-- 14 --
April 15 (+7d)
CO21 Model
Ca II
Ti II
Fe II
Na I
Si II?
3
2
1
)
s
t
i
n
U
y
r
a
r
t
i
b
r
A
(
λ
F
O I
Ca II
C I
He I?
C I?
Si I?
0
2000
4000
6000
λ (Angstroms)
8000
10000
12000
Fig. 4. -- The synthetic spectrum of the Iwamoto et al. (1994) model (dashed curve) is compared
to the spectrum taken at Lick Observatory on April 15, 1994 (+7d) (Filippenko et al. 1995). The
line identifications are the combined results of this work and that of Millard et al. (1999).
-- 15 --
Apil 15 (+7d)
Massive Model
Fe II
Na I
Ti II
Ca II
Si II?
O I
Ca II
C I
He I?
C I?
Si I?
3
2
1
)
s
t
i
n
U
y
r
a
r
t
i
r
b
r
A
(
λ
F
0
2000
4000
6000
λ (Angstroms)
8000
10000
12000
Fig. 5. -- The synthetic spectrum of our massive star model (dashed curve) is compared to the
spectrum taken at Lick Observatory on April 15, 1994 (+7d) (Filippenko et al. 1995).
-- 16 --
April 4 (−4d)
CO21 Model
Ca II
Mg II
Fe II
Na I
Si II
C II
O I
Mg II
Ca II
O I
3
2
1
)
s
t
i
n
U
y
r
a
r
t
i
b
r
A
(
λ
F
0
2000
4000
6000
λ (Angstroms)
8000
10000
12000
Fig. 6. -- The synthetic spectrum of the Iwamoto et al. (1994) model (dashed curve) is compared
to the spectrum taken at Lick Observatory on April 4, 1994 (-4d) (Filippenko et al. 1995).
-- 17 --
April 10 (+2d)
CO21 Model
3
2
1
)
s
t
i
n
U
y
r
a
r
t
i
b
r
A
(
λ
F
Ca II
Ti II
Fe II
Na I
Si II
C II
O I
Ca II
0
2000
4000
6000
λ (Angstroms)
8000
10000
12000
Fig. 7. -- The synthetic spectrum of the Iwamoto et al. (1994) model (dashed curve) is compared
to the spectrum taken at the MMT on April 10, 1994 (+2d) (Schmidt & Kirshner 1994).
-- 18 --
April 18 (+10d)
CO21 Model
Ti II
Ca II
Fe II
Na I
C II
O I
Ca II
O I
3
2
1
)
s
t
i
n
U
y
r
a
r
t
i
b
r
A
(
λ
F
0
2000
4000
6000
λ (Angstroms)
8000
10000
12000
Fig. 8. -- The synthetic spectrum of the Iwamoto et al. (1994) model (dashed curve) is compared
to the spectrum taken at Lick Observatory on April 18, 1994 (+10d) (Filippenko et al. 1995).
-- 19 --
Fig. 9. -- The model spectra for the identical conditions as displayed in Figure 4, but with only
NLTE line opacity included; all LTE line opacity has been set to zero. The legend indicates which
particular NLTE lines are included in the calculations.
|
astro-ph/0510302 | 1 | 0510 | 2005-10-11T05:03:24 | Multiplicity of chemically peculiar stars | [
"astro-ph"
] | Recently, with the goal to study multiplicity of chemically peculiar stars, we carried out a survey of 40 stars using diffraction limited near infrared (IR) imaging with NAOS-CONICA (NACO) at the VLT. Here, we announce the detection of 27 near IR companion candidates around 25 late B-type chemically peculiar stars exhibiting strong overabundances of the chemical elements Hg and Mn in their atmospheres. A key point for the understanding of the abundance patterns in these stars may be connected with binarity and multiplicity. It is intriguing that more than half of the sample of HgMn stars studied previously by speckle interferometry and recently using the adaptive optics system NACO belong to multiple systems. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Multiplicity of chemically peculiar stars
Swetlana Hubrig1, Nancy Ageorges1, and Markus Scholler1
European Southern Observatory (ESO), Casilla 19001, Santiago, Chile
Summary. Recently, with the goal to study multiplicity of chemically peculiar
stars, we carried out a survey of 40 stars using diffraction limited near infrared
(IR) imaging with NAOS-CONICA (NACO) at the VLT. Here, we announce the
detection of 27 near IR companion candidates around 25 late B-type chemically pe-
culiar stars exhibiting strong overabundances of the chemical elements Hg and Mn
in their atmospheres. A key point for the understanding of the abundance patterns
in these stars may be connected with binarity and multiplicity. It is intriguing that
more than half of the sample of HgMn stars studied previously by speckle inter-
ferometry and recently using the adaptive optics system NACO belong to multiple
systems.
1 Introduction
Chemically peculiar (CP) stars are main sequence A and B type stars in
the spectra of which lines of some elements are abnormally strong or weak.
The class of CP stars is represented by roughly three subclasses including
magnetic Ap and Bp stars, metallic-line Am stars and HgMn stars which are
late B-type stars showing extreme overabundances of Hg (up to 6 dex) and/or
Mn (up to 3 dex). Among the magnetic Ap stars the rate of binaries is 43% [1].
The main result of this most recent study of multiplicity of magnetic stars is
that, statistically, the orbital parameters of Ap stars do not differ from those
of normal stars, except for an almost complete lack of orbital periods shorter
than 3 days. The studies of the evolutionary state of magnetic Ap stars in
binaries indicate that all of them are rather old main sequence stars and are
well evolved from the zero-age main sequence (e.g. Wade et al. (1996) [2]),
fully in agreement with results of the study of single magnetic Ap stars by
Hubrig et al. (2000) [3].
The number of double-lined spectroscopic binary (SB2) systems among
magnetic Ap stars is abnormally low (only 3 SB2 systems are known to date)
and no eclipsing binary comprising a magnetic Ap star has ever been identi-
fied. The rate of binaries is much smaller among magnetic Bp stars, ∼20%,
and only two double-lined eclipsing binaries have recently been discovered:
HD 123335 was discussed by Hensbergen et al. (2004) [4] and AO Vel by
Gonz´alez et al. (2005) [5]. A total of six magnetic Bp/Ap stars are known to
2
Swetlana Hubrig, Nancy Ageorges, and Markus Scholler
be multiple and are listed in the Multiple Star Catalogue of Tokovinin (1997)
[6].
The metallic-line Am stars show an overabundance of heavy elements and
an underabundance of Ca and Sc. A very high fraction of these stars, at least
90%, are SB systems with orbital periods between 2.5 and 100 days.
HgMn stars are rather young objects and many of them are found in young
associations like Sco-Cen, Orion OB1 or Auriga OB1. HgMn stars do not have
strong large-scale organized magnetic fields and exhibit marked abundance
anomalies of numerous elements. In contrast to Bp and Ap stars with large-
scale organized magnetic fields, they generally do not show overabundances
of rare earths, but exhibit strong overabundances of heavy elements like W,
R, Os, Ir, Pt, Au, Hg, Tl, Pb, Bi. Another important distinctive feature of
these stars is their slow rotation (hv sin ii ≈ 29 km s−1, Abt et al. (1972)
[7]). The number of HgMn stars decreases sharply with increasing rotational
velocity [8]. Evidence that stellar rotation does affect abundance anomalies
in HgMn stars is provided by the rather sharp cutoff in such anomalies at a
projected rotational velocity of 70 -- 80 km s−1 [9].
The mechanisms responsible for the development of the chemical anoma-
lies of HgMn stars are not fully understood yet. A key point for the un-
derstanding of the abundance patterns may be connected with binarity and
multiplicity. More than 2/3 of the HgMn stars are known to belong to spectro-
scopic binaries [10]. Quite a number of HgMn stars belong to triple or even
quadruple systems [11, 12]. Out of 30 SB HgMn stars observed in speckle
interferometry, 15 appear to have more than two components. Indirect evi-
dence for the presence of a third component was found in four other HgMn
SBs (HD 11905, HD 34364, HD 78316 and HD 141556) on the basis of spectro-
scopic and photometric arguments. Further evidence that other HgMn stars
frequently are members of multiple systems is inferred from the results of the
ROSAT all-sky survey. X-ray emission was detected through this survey in
12 HgMn stars (7 SB1s, 3 SB2s and 2 for which no radial velocity data are
available). Previous X-ray observations with the Einstein Observatory and
theoretical estimates had suggested that stars in the spectral range B2 -- A7
are devoid of any significant X-ray emission. In most cases when emission had
been detected in such stars, it was found to originate from a cool companion.
This suggests that the X-ray emission found in HgMn SBs does not origi-
nate from the HgMn primary. From observations investigating late-B X-ray
sources using the ESO 3.6-m with ADONIS [13] we found faint companions
for 4 HgMn stars that were part of the X-ray selected late-B stars observed,
strengthening this interpretation.
In the catalogue of multiple stars by Tokovinin (1997) [6], which com-
piles data on 612 stellar systems of different spectral types, we found four
additional multiple systems containing HgMn stars. It is especially intriguing
that if the relative frequency of HgMn stars in multiple systems is studied,
every third system with a primary in the spectral range between B6 and
Multiplicity of CP stars
3
B9 involves an HgMn star. These observational results clearly show that the
study of multiple systems with an HgMn component is of prime interest for
star formation. In the following we report our results of the recent study of
multiplicity of this amazing class of objects using NACO K-band imaging.
2 Observations
Observations of 40 HgMn stars have been carried out with NACO in service
mode from October 2004 to March 2005. We used the S13 camera, to be able
to discover practically all components down to K=14 with a signal-to-noise
ratio of the order of 12.
Here, we announce the detection of 27 near IR companion candidates in
eight binaries, 16 triple and one quadruple system. The detected companion
candidates have K magnitudes between 5.m5 and 13.m5 and angular separa-
tions ranging from 0.′′1 to 7.′′3 (7-1500 AU).
In Figs. 1 -- 3 we show adaptive optics K-band images obtained with NACO.
The field of view displayed was selected according to the angular distances of
the companions. The intensity scale was adjusted to visualize the respective
companions.
One of our NACO targets, the HgMn star HD 75333, has already been
observed in May 2001 with the adaptive optics system at Keck II. The Keck
images of this system have been presented in Hubrig et al. (2005) [14]. These
observations revealed that this star has two low-mass companions in a binary
system at a separation of 1.′′34. This system is not displayed in Figs. 1 -- 3, since
the separation between the two low-mass companions in the binary system
is only 0.′′06. The diffraction limit for NACO installed at the 8 m telescope is
lower than that for Keck II, hence these companions do not appear resolved
in our NACO images. In Fig. 4 we show the distribution of the projected
separations for the studied multiple systems with HgMn primaries. For most
of the systems the separations are smaller than 100 AU.
If all detected IR objects around the HgMn stars are true companions, the
resulting multiplicity rate is 68%. In Table 1 we present the list of the observed
HgMn stars. Their visual magnitudes and spectral types were retrieved from
the SIMBAD data base. In the last column we give some remarks about their
multiplicity.
3 Discussion
The results of our study clearly confirm that HgMn stars are frequently found
in multiple systems. It is especially intriguing that out of the 40 HgMn stars
in the sample studied only two stars, HD 65950 and HD 70235, are not known
to belong to a binary or multiple system. However, companionship can not be
established based on K photometry alone, and confirming the nature with a
4
Swetlana Hubrig, Nancy Ageorges, and Markus Scholler
Fig. 1. NACO images of the wide systems in our sample. Upper row from left to
right: HD 32964, HD 34880, HD 36881 and HD 53929. Lower row from left to right:
HD 120709, HD 129174, HD 165493 and HD 178065. The field of view in each frame
is 7.95′′
×7.95′′.
Fig. 2. NACO images of the intermediate systems in our sample. Upper row from
left to right: HD 33904, HD 35548, HD 53244, HD 59067 and HD 73340. Lower row
from left to right: HD 78316, HD 101189, HD 110073, HD 158704 and HD 221507.
The field of view in each frame is 1.33′′
×1.33′′.
near infrared spectrograph is essential for establishing their true companion-
ship. Our program to carry out NACO K-band spectroscopy of the discovered
IR-candidate companions has been scheduled at the VLT in service mode for
the period October 2005 to March 2006. Using these observations we will
be able to determine the mass of the IR companions much more accurately,
and explore the physics in their atmospheres by comparison of observed and
synthetic spectra. Since the HgMn type primaries have all Hipparcos par-
allaxes (σ(π)/π < 0.2), their age is known, and assuming coevality we will
Multiplicity of CP stars
5
Fig. 3. NACO images of the close systems in our sample. Upper row from left to
right: HD 21933, HD 28217 and HD 29589. Lower row from left to right: HD 31373,
HD 33647 and HD 216494. The field of view in each frame is 0.66′′
×0.66′′.
N
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
0
200
400
600
1000
Projected separation [AU]
800
1200
1400
Fig. 4. Distribution of the projected separations for the studied systems with HgMn
primaries.
6
Swetlana Hubrig, Nancy Ageorges, and Markus Scholler
Table 1. List of HgMn stars observed with NACO.
Remarks
Remarks
78316 5.2 B8III
HD V Sp. Type
HD V Sp. Type
70235 6.4 B8Ib/II
1909 6.6 B9IV SB2
SB1
7374 6.0 B8III
71066 5.6 A0IV vis. binary
19400 5.5 B8III
vis. binary
vis. binary
71833 6.7 B8II
21933 5.8 B9IV IR comp.
SB2
B9
72208 6.8
IR comp.
B8
73340 5.8
27295 5.5 B9IV SB1
28217 5.9 B8IV vis. binary + IR comp. 75333 5.3
B9
two IR comp.
29589 5.4 B8IV SB1 + IR comp.
SB2 + IR comp.
31373 5.8 B9V IR comp.
32964 5.1 B9V SB2 + IR comp.
33904 3.3 B9IV IR comp.
33647 6.7 B9V SB2 + IR comp.
SB1 + two IR comp.
34880 6.4 B8III
SB2 + IR comp.
35548 6.6
SB1 + IR comp.
36881 5.6 B9III
SB1
49606 5.9 B7III
53244 4.1 B8II
SB1 + IR comp.
53929 6.1 B9.5III SB1 + IR comp.
59067 5.9
B8
63975 5.1 B8II
65950 6.9 B8III
101189 5.1 B9IV IR comp.
110073 4.6 B8II/III SB1 + IR comp.
120709 4.6 B5III
124740 7.9
129174 4.9
141556 4.0 B9IV SB2
144661 6.3 B8IV/V SB1
144844 5.9 B9V SB2
158704 6.1 B9II/III SB2 + IR comp.
165493 6.2 B7.5II SB1 + IR comp.
178065 6.6 B9III
SB1 + IR comp.
216494 5.8 B8IV/V SB2 + IR comp.
221507 4.4 B9.5IV IR comp.
IR comp.
SB1
IR comp.
SB2
SB1 + IR comp.
A
B9
B9
have an unprecedented set of data for the confirmed very young or even PMS
companions.
We would like to note that our observations contribute not only to the
understanding of the formation mechanism of HgMn stars but also to the
general understanding of B-type star formation. An interesting result about
the combination of long- and short-period systems has been presented by
Tokovinin a few years ago [15]. He suggested that the fraction of SBs be-
longing to multiple systems probably depends on the SB periods. It is much
higher for close binaries with 1 to 10 day periods than for systems with 10 to
100 day periods. The statistics of multiple systems is still very poor and much
work remains to be done. The proposed survey of binarity and multiplicity
of HgMn stars will help to understand the connection between close bina-
ries and multiplicity, and especially the formation of close binary systems.
To find out which role membership of HgMn stars in multiple systems plays
for the development of their chemical peculiarities, it would be important to
compare the ranges of periods, luminosity ratios, and orbital eccentricities,
as well as hierarchy of multiples with the same characteristics of normal late
B systems.
A further remarkable feature of HgMn spectroscopic binaries is that many
of them have orbital periods shorter than 20 days. However, binary periods of
less than three days are absent, while they are quite common among normal
Multiplicity of CP stars
7
late B systems. Interestingly, from a survey of the Batten et al. catalogue [16]
limited to systems brighter that V = 7, it appears that only six normal B8
and B9 stars are known to be members of SBs with orbital periods between
3 and 20 days. Four of them are very fast rotating with v sin i values of the
order of 100 km s−1 and more, i.e. much faster than typical HgMn stars. For
the remaining two systems no information on the rotational velocity could
be found in the literature.
In some binary systems with an HgMn primary, the components definitely
rotate subsynchronously [17]. It is striking that the majority of these systems
have more than two components. Probably the most intriguing and most fun-
damental question is whether all late-B close binaries with subsynchronously
rotating companions belong to more complex systems.
References
1. Carrier F., North P., Udry S., Babel J., 2002: A&A 394, 151
2. Wade G.A., North P., Mathys G., Hubrig S., 1996: A&A 314, 491
3. Hubrig S., North P., Mathys G., 2000: ApJ 539, 352
4. Hensberge H., Nitschelm C., Freyhammer L. M., et al., 2004: ASP Conference
Series, Vol. 318, 309
5. Gonz´alez J.F., Hubrig S., Nesvacil N., North P., 2005: A&A submitted
6. Tokovinin A., 1997: A&AS 124, 75
7. Abt H.A., Chaffee F.H., Suffolk G., 1972: ApJ 175, 779
8. Wolff S.C., Wolff R.J., 1974: ApJ 194, 65
9. Hubrig S., Mathys G., 1996: Carrier F., North P., Udry S., Babel J., 2002:
A&A 120, 457
10. Hubrig S., Mathys G., 1995: Comm. on Astroph. 18, 167
11. Cole W.A., Fekel F.C., Hartkopf W.I., et al., 1992: AJ 103, 1357
12. Isobe S., 1991: Proceedings ASA 9, 270
13. Hubrig S., Le Mignant D., North P., Krautter J., 2001: A&A 372, 152
14. Hubrig S., Scholler M., Le Mignant D., et al., 2005: Proceedings of the ESO
Workshop "High resolution infrared spectroscopy in astronomy", p. 499
15. Tokovinin A., 2001: IAU Symposium 200, p. 84
16. Batten A.H., Fletcher J.M., MacCarthy D.G., 1989: Eighth Catalogue of the
Orbital Elements of Spectroscopic Binary Systems, Publ. Dominion Astrophys.
Obs. 17
17. Guthrie B.N.G., 1986: MNRAS 220, 559
|
astro-ph/0402062 | 1 | 0402 | 2004-02-03T03:05:13 | E+A Galaxies and the Formation of Early Type Galaxies at z~0 | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present HST/WFPC2 observations of the five bluest E+A galaxies (z~0.1) in the Zabludoff et al. sample to study whether their detailed morphologies are consistent with late-to-early type evolution and to determine what drives that evolution. The morphologies of four galaxies are disturbed, indicating that a galaxy-galaxy merger is at least one mechanism that leads to the E+A phase. Two-dimensional image fitting shows that the E+As are generally bulge-dominated systems, even though at least two E+As may have underlying disks. In the Fundamental Plane, E+As stand apart from the E/S0s mainly due to their high effective surface brightness. Fading of the young stellar population and the corresponding increase in their effective radii will cause these galaxies to migrate toward the locus of E/S0s. E+As have profiles qualitatively like those of normal power-law early-type galaxies, but have higher surface brightnesses. This result provides the first direct evidence supporting the hypothesis that power-law ellipticals form via gas-rich mergers. In total, at least four E+As are morphologically consistent with early-type galaxies. We detect compact sources, possibly young star clusters, associated with the galaxies. These sources are much brighter (M_R ~ -13) than Galactic globular clusters, have luminosities consistent with the brightest clusters in nearby starburst galaxies, and have blue colors consistent with the ages estimated from the E+A galaxy spectra (several 10^8 yr). Further study of such young star cluster candidates might provide the elusive chronometer needed to break the age/burst-strength degeneracy for these post-merger galaxies. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
E+A Galaxies and the Formation of Early Type Galaxies at z∼0 1
Yujin Yang, Ann I. Zabludoff, and Dennis Zaritsky
Steward Observatory, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721
[email protected], [email protected], [email protected]
Tod R. Lauer
National Optical Astronomy Observatories, Tucson, AZ 85726
[email protected]
J. Christopher Mihos2
Department of Astronomy, Case Western Reserve University, 10900 Euclid Ave, Cleveland, OH 44106
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
E+A galaxies, whose spectra have deep Balmer absorption lines but no significant [OII] emis-
sion, are the best candidates for an evolutionary link between star-forming, gas-rich galaxies and
quiescent, gas-poor galaxies. Yet their current morphologies are not well known. We present
HST /WFPC2 observations of the five bluest E+A galaxies (z ∼ 0.1) in the Zabludoff et al. sam-
ple to study whether their detailed morphologies are consistent with late-to-early type evolution
and to determine what drives that evolution. The morphologies of four galaxies are disturbed,
indicating that a galaxy-galaxy merger is at least one mechanism that leads to the E+A phase.
Two-dimensional image fitting shows that the E+As are generally bulge-dominated systems,
even though at least two E+As may have underlying disks. In the Fundamental Plane, E+As
stand apart from the E/S0s mainly due to their high effective surface brightness. Fading of the
young stellar population and the corresponding increase in their effective radii will cause these
galaxies to migrate toward the locus of E/S0s. E+As have profiles qualitatively like those of
normal power-law early-type galaxies, but have higher surface brightnesses. This result provides
the first direct evidence supporting the hypothesis that power-law ellipticals form via gas-rich
mergers. In total, at least four E+As are morphologically consistent with early-type galaxies.
We detect compact sources, possibly young star clusters, associated with the galaxies. These
sources are much brighter (MR ∼ −13) than Galactic globular clusters, have luminosities consis-
tent with the brightest clusters in nearby starburst galaxies, and have blue colors consistent with
the ages estimated from the E+A galaxy spectra (several 108 yr). Further study of such young
star cluster candidates might provide the elusive chronometer needed to break the age/burst-
strength degeneracy for these post-merger galaxies.
Subject headings: galaxies: evolution - galaxies: interactions - galaxies: starburst - galaxies:
star clusters - galaxies: stellar content
1Based on observations with the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope obtained at the Space Telescope Science Institute,
which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Incorporated, under NASA contract NAS5-
26555.
2NSF CAREER Fellow and Research Corporation Cottrell Scholar
– 2 –
1.
Introduction
If galaxies evolve morphologically from late to early types, then some may be now changing from star-
forming, gas-rich, disk-dominated objects into quiescent, gas-poor spheroidals. Spectroscopic surveys have
identified at least one set of candidates for such a transformation: "E+A" galaxies1, whose spectra have deep
Balmer absorption lines but no significant [OII] emission, indicating that star formation ceased abruptly in
these galaxies within the last ∼ Gyr. In general, E+A galaxies lack significant amounts of HI gas (Chang et
al. 2001) and have hot, pressure-supported kinematics (Norton et al. 2001), suggesting that these galaxies
are indeed evolving - somehow - from late to early types. However, we do not yet know whether their
current morphologies are consistent with late-to-early type evolution or what drives E+A evolution.
While the mechanism (or mechanisms) that causes galaxies to pass through an E+A phase is not
understood, there are several clues. First, E+A spectra suggest a recent burst of star formation that required
the rapid consumption or dispersal of a gas reservoir. Second, although they were first studied in distant
clusters (Dressler & Gunn 1983), E+As - at least at low redshifts (z ∼ 0.1) - lie mostly in low density
environments (Zabludoff et al. 1996; Quintero et al. 2003). Third, in low-resolution POSS images, some
E+As have features suggestive of tidal tails (Zabludoff et al. 1996). Could E+As be the result of disk galaxy
mergers, which are both common in the field and known to enhance star formation? In the merger hypothesis,
E+As are further along the "Toomre sequence" (Toomre, A. 1977) and thus more relaxed than systems like
the Antennae, whose morphology and kinematics are in such disarray that it is nearly impossible to constrain
its endproduct. E+As may thus teach us considerably more about the endpoints of galaxy-galaxy mergers.
We cannot test this picture of E+A formation, or whether the E+A phase is a bona fide late-to-early
type transition, without detailed morphological information. Simulations predict that well-evolved major
mergers have a hybrid morphology, including fading, low surface brightness tidal tails at large radii, a more
relaxed spheroid-dominated core, and a population of young star clusters (Barnes 1988; Barnes & Hernquist
1996; Ashman & Zepf 1992; Mihos & Hernquist 1994). Identifying such low surface brightness or small scale
features, even at low redshifts, requires spatial resolution on the order of 100 pc and low sky background
levels. Therefore, Hubble Space Telescope imaging of nearby E+As is required.
In this paper, we present the detailed HST /WFPC2 morphologies of the five bluest E+A galaxies in the
Zabludoff et al. (1996) sample. We review the sample and the data reduction methods in §2. We describe the
qualitative morphologies of these galaxies in §3.1, discussing the observed tidal features and the implications
for E+A origin. We address the question of whether E+As are consistent with evolution into early types by
fitting two-dimensional, surface brightness models to each image and deriving structural parameters such as
bulge-to-disk ratio, effective radius, and central surface density (§3.2). In §3.4, we examine the color gradients
in the E+As and compare them with the expectations from disk merger models. We compare the results with
the fundamental plane for early type galaxies and with the surface brightness profiles of the nearby elliptical
galaxies in §3.5 and §3.6, respectively. In §3.7, we search for star clusters in the E+As and ask whether
their properties are consistent with late-to-early type galaxy evolution. We discuss the implications of our
results for higher redshift galaxy surveys in §3.8, cautioning that bulge-to-disk decompositions, quantitative
measures of asymmetry, and tests to uncover tidal features may mislead. Section 4 summarizes our results.
1Because their spectra are a superposition of a young stellar population (represented by A stars) and an old population
(characterized by K stars), these galaxies became known as "E (for elliptical) + A" galaxies (Dressler & Gunn 1983) or, more
straightforwardly, "K+A" or "k+a" galaxies (Franx 1993; Dressler et al. 1999; Poggianti et al. 1999).
– 3 –
2. Observations and Data Reduction
Our HST imaging sample is a subset of the 20 nearby E+A galaxies2 that were spectroscopically
identified from 11,113 galaxy spectra in the Las Campanas Redshift Survey (LCRS) with redshifts between
0.07 and 0.18 (Zabludoff et al. 1996). These E+As are selected by requiring that their spectra have strong
Balmer absorption features (average equivalent width hHi of Hβ, Hγ and Hδ > 5.5A) and little if any [OII]
emission (EW[OII] < 2.5 A). Three-quarters of the E+As in the sample are in the field, well outside rich
cluster environments. The number of each E+A (e.g., EA1) is from Zabludoff et al. (1996) and increases
with increasing 4000A break (D4000) strength. D4000 is related to the galaxy's color - bluer galaxies have
smaller D4000. EA1 through EA5, the focus of our HST study, have the smallest D4000's, and therefore are
more dominated by the young stellar population than the other E+As. This dominance can arise either
because they have had the most recent or strongest bursts. For the remainder of this paper, we refer to each
galaxy by its assigned number. Table 1 summarizes the basic data of five galaxies: coordinates, redshift,
and environment. Throughout this paper, we assume H0 = 70 km s−1 Mpc−1, ΩM = 0.3, and ΩΛ = 0.7.
We obtained high resolution images of the five nearby (z ∼ 0.08 − 0.12) E+A galaxies with the Hubble
Space Telescope Wide Field Planetary Camera 2 (WFPC2). Because our sample is at relatively low redshift
(typically z ∼ 0.1, for which 0.5′′= ∼ 1 kpc), it is possible to study the LCRS sample in ways that are
not possible for the more classic E+As discovered in distant clusters. We take advantage of this benefit
to obtain spatially-resolved spectroscopy (Norton et al. 2001) and sub-kpc imaging here. We observed the
sample using the F702W (λeff = 6997A) and F439W (λeff = 4292A) filters and obtained three CR-split 700s
exposures for each object. Stacked images were generated by summing the three individual images for each
galaxy and filter. The pointing was identical for each image, so no shifting or interpolation was required.
We rejected CR events by comparing deviant pixels within the stack to a WFPC2 noise model.
We adopt photometric zero points of the HST /WFPC2 from Holtzman et al. (1995) after correcting for
the gain=7.0 and the nominal infinite aperture. Our values are the same as given in the HST Data Handbook.
For the Planetary Camera, F439W and F702W magnitude zero points are 20.884 and 22.428, respectively.
We adopt Galactic extinction corrections from Schlegel et al. (1998), assuming an RV = 3.1 extinction curve.
AF702W and AF439W are calculated from the relative extinction table in the Appendix (Schlegel et al. 1998).
The value for F439W is not available in the Appendix, so we use the extinction appropriate for the Landolt
B magnitude.
To compare the magnitudes of galaxies within certain filters across a range of redshifts, or to photometric
models, we apply K-corrections. In principle, the K-correction can be calculated by using the spectral energy
distribution (SED) of an object with full spectral coverage and high S/N. Unfortunately, flux-calibrated
spectra with full spectral coverage and high S/N are not available for our sample. The SEDs of E+As
strongly depend both on the stellar mass formed during the starburst and on the time elapsed since the burst.
To account for this variation in stellar populations, we examine both extremes - a pure A type and a pure
K type stellar spectrum. We use A dwarf and K giant templates from the Gunn-Stryker spectrophotometric
atlas (Gunn & Stryker 1983), which covers the wavelength range 3130 to 10800 A. We artificially redshift the
template spectra to (1 + z) and measure the magnitude differences in the F702W and F439W filters using
the CALCPHOT routine within the IRAF/SYNPHOT package. In the F702W band the difference between
the corrections for the two populations is within ∼ 0.19 − 0.31 magnitudes. In contrast, the difference in the
2One (EA20) of the original 21 galaxies turned out to be misclassified as an E+A due to noise in the region of one of the
spectral line diagnostics (Norton et al. 2001).
– 4 –
corrections is larger than 0.62 magnitudes for F439W because the F439W filter band includes the Balmer
jump. A slight shift of the spectra can cause a large change in measured brightness. We list both sets of
corrections in Table 3, but adopt the correction calculated for an A star with the justification that these
are the bluest, most A-like, of the E+As in the Zabludoff et al. (1996) sample. Because the K correction
is the major source of uncertainty in our error budget, the global photometric quantities, especially colors,
possibly harbor significant systematic errors. The sense of any relative colors within a galaxy is not affected,
although the numerical values may be.
3. Results and Discussion
The HST images provide a wealth of information on the small and large scale structure of these galaxies.
With the goal of understanding the origin of the E+A phenomenon and into what these systems will evolve,
we investigate the morphologies of these systems, their color profiles, their location on the Fundamental
Plane (Jorgensen et al. 1996) of elliptical galaxies, and their relationship to "core" and "power-law" ellipticals
(Faber et al. 1997). We also discover a population of associated point sources (possibly young star clusters).
Finally, we review the implications of our results, obtained for low-redshift E+As, for the identification
and study of such systems at higher redshifts. The reader is referred to Tables 2-5 for a summary of the
quantitative results discussed in this section.
3.1. Morphologies: First Impressions
Figure 1 shows the WFPC2 mosaic and PC images of our five E+A galaxies at different contrast levels.
The full mosaic images (80′′ × 80′′) are in the left column. The center of each E+A is located in the PC,
which is in the upper right corner of each mosaic. Tidal features that extend into the other CCDs are evident
in EA1-3. The middle and right columns contain the F702W (24′′ × 24′′) and F439W (12′′ × 12′′) PC images,
respectively, on a logarithmic flux scale. HST /WFPC2 observations are relatively insensitive in the bluer
band so that the signal in the F439W images typically extends out only to ∼ 3 kpc, 25% of the red coverage,
and even there it is of low signal-to-noise.
These five E+As exhibit a variety of morphologies ranging from a highly complex system (EA1) to what
could visually be classified as a barred S0 galaxy (EA5), even though they have been uniformly selected using
spectroscopic criteria, i.e., "k+a" type spectra from the LCRS.
EA1 stands apart from the other four E+As. It is composed of two components that are separated
spatially by ∼ 3 kpc and another companion with a projected separation of 14 kpc (assuming the companion
is at the redshift of EA1). The association is supported by an asymmetric feature emanating from the
companion that could be tidal material and a faint bridge that appears to connect it to EA1.
EA2 and EA3 also exhibit highly disturbed morphologies, although EA3 could be visually classified
as a normal face-on spiral galaxy in the low contrast PC image. This ambiguity in visual classification is
discussed in more detail in §3.8. EA2 has tidal tail that extends to at least 50 kpc.
EA4 and EA5 appear less disturbed, although EA4 has somewhat irregular outer isophotes, some
lopsidedness (in the F439W filter image), and shell-like structures closer to the center that are visible in the
PC image. The mechanism or mechanisms responsible for the spectral E+A phenomenon produce a variety
of morphologies. Whether all of these systems will evolve into a somewhat more homogeneous population
- for example, early-type galaxies - is yet unclear.
– 5 –
3.2. Morphologies : Bulge-Disk Decompositions
While EA2-5 appear to have significant spheroidal components, EA3 and EA4, at least, also seem to
have a flattened, or perhaps disk-like, morphology. Understanding the fate of these systems requires a
quantitative estimate of the relative importance of the dynamically hot and cold stellar components.
Measuring the surface brightness profile for asymmetric, disturbed systems is challenging. To mitigate
potential systematic problems, we use two different algorithms. First, to obtain photometric parameters, re
and µe, we use the two-dimensional image fitting algorithm GALFIT (Peng et al. 2002) designed to extract
structural parameters directly from the galaxy image. GALFIT assumes a two-dimensional model profile for
the galaxy. The functional form of the models we choose to fit include combinations of an r1/4-law, a S´ersic
r1/n-law, an exponential disk profile, and a spatially constant sky background. We fit the following: the
(x, y) position of the center, Mtot (the total magnitude of the component), re (the effective radius), n (the
S´ersic index), q (the axis ratio defined as b/a), the major axis position angle, and c (the diskiness/boxiness
index, where c > 0 indicates boxy). This index c plays the same role as the cos 4θ Fourier coefficient term
used often in isophote analysis (Rix & Zaritsky 1995). As GALFIT explores parameter space, it convolves
the model image with a point-spread function (PSF) and compares it to the data for each parameter set. The
model PSFs are generated for each galaxy by the TinyTim (Krist & Hook 1999) software for the WFPC2.
Although convolution is computer intensive, the advantage of the convolution process is that it preserves the
noise characteristics of the images and can be applied to low signal-to-noise images.
Because GALFIT begins with a very specific, smooth model, which may be a poor representation of
such distorted galaxies, we also measure surface brightness profiles using the IRAF/ELLIPSE algorithm.
This approach allows the center, major axis position angle, and ellipticity of each ellipse to change, but does
not enforce a model radial profile. To accurately recover the surface brightness profiles without recourse to
ad hoc models, we applied 20 iterations of Richardson-Lucy deconvolution (Richardson 1972; Lucy 1974).
Lauer et al. (1998) showed that the WFPC2 PSF can depress the brightness profile as far out as 0 ′′. 5 from
the galaxy center. Richardson-Lucy deconvolution allows the intrinsic brightness profile to be recovered to
the few percent level down to r ∼ 0 ′′. 05, with adequate exposure levels (S/N ∼ 50 in the galaxy center).
With reduced S/N and only 20 deconvolution cycles, the central (r = 0) point in the profile may remain
slightly-depressed, dependent on the (unknown) intrinsic structure of the galaxy center.
Because EA1 is too disturbed to be reasonably modeled by a simple disk+bulge model, we restrict our
analysis to EA2-5. For each galaxy, we fit three different light distributions: r1/4 law, r1/n S´ersic law, and
r1/4 + exponential disk law. For EA2, we do not fit the r1/4 + exponential disk law model because we might
be seeing this galaxy close to edge-on (see the linear residuals in Figure 2), and it is hard for GALFIT to fit an
edge-on disk with an extended tail. The structural parameters and the reduced χ2
ν's of these three GALFIT
models are listed in Tables 4 and 5. With the exception of one case, 1 < χ2
ν are
somewhat larger than statistically acceptable, due presumably to the presence of asymmetric components,
as can be seen in Figure 2.
ν < 2. These values of χ2
Of the three profiles we consider, only the S´ersic profile has the flexibility to model either a spheroidal
or disk-like system by varying the parameter n. Therefore the best-fit value of n can guide our conclusions
about the nature of the galaxy. An exponential disk corresponds to a value of n = 1, while the classic de
Vaucouleurs profile corresponds to n = 4. However, the correspondence between disk system, spheroid, and
– 6 –
n is not quite this simple - fitting S´ersic profiles to SDSS galaxies, Blanton et al. (2003) show a peak at
n = 1 corresponding to disky systems, but no peak at n = 4. Instead, spheroidal systems show a range of n
values. This result is further complicated when one factors in differences in radial ranges fit - for example,
fitting the inner slope of cuspy power-law ellipticals (e.g., Lauer et al. 1995) will give a much higher n value
than will fits at larger radii.
With these caveats in mind, we find that a single S´ersic profile fit yields n > 5 for all our galaxies,
demonstrating that the light is dominated by a spheroidal component. Indeed, the high values for n indicate
a very high concentration of the light, even more than expected for a classic de Vaucouleurs profile. Such
high concentrations are consistent with the idea that central starbursts have raised the central luminosity
density (e.g., Mihos & Hernquist 1994). For example, in the case of EA4, masking the inner kpc and refitting
the Sersic law results in a value of n = 3.6, much more typical of a normal elliptical. This is not always the
case, however - in EA3, the high S´ersic value persists even when the nucleus is masked out. For EA3 the
fitted value (n = 8.7) is unusually high compared to normal ellipticals (e.g., Kelson et al. 2000; Graham et
al. 2001; Graham 2002). An additional complication to the interpretation of these fits is that, while the light
appears to be dominated by a concentrated spheroid, some of the galaxies appear to contain an additional
disk-like component that would affect any dynamical model of a merger and its aftermath.
To determine whether these galaxies do indeed contain a disk component, we also fit models with two
components. The resulting radial profiles for EA3 and 4 (Figure 3) and the significant decrease in χ2
ν
(an improvement in the fit at the 99% confidence level) demonstrate that a pure spheroid model is not
the preferred model for these two systems. To avoid the degeneracies present in fitting disk and bulge
simultaneously, we also fit single S´ersic profiles just to the outer parts of the galaxies. Using the effective
radii of the bulges calculated from the two-component fit, we mask pixels inside a chosen radius, vary that
radius to be ∼ 3 − 5re and refit a single component. We mark the effective radii and disk scale lengths with
circles in Figure 2. For EA3, the best-fit S´ersic indicies are n = 2.5, 1.6 and 1.3 for masks corresponding to
3re, 4re, and 5re, respectively. For EA4, we measure n = 0.93 and 0.86 when we apply 3re and 4re masks,
respectively. In both of these cases, the S´ersic index beyond several re is as expected for an exponential
disk and the fit spans 4 to 5 disk scale lengths. Although we cannot discriminate tidal material from a
possible underlying disk, we conclude that in EA3 and EA4 there is material beyond that described by a
spheroid and that it is consistent with an underlying disk. EA3 and EA4 appear to be sufficiently relaxed
that no significant dynamical evolution is expected, so they may become S0's. We also hypothesize that their
progenitors may have included a disk that was significantly heated but not completely destroyed during an
intermediate mass ratio merger (e.g., Naab 2000; Bendo & Barnes 2000).
Even though no disturbed tidal structure is apparent in EA5, the modeling is complicated by the presence
of a strong bar-like structure. The presence of a bar-like feature suggests an underlying disk. When viewed
at the different contrasts in Figure 4, EA5 is composed of at least three distinct components, a extended
light distribution in outer part (axis ratio q ∼ 0.8), a compact and elliptical bar structure (q ∼ 0.4 − 0.5),
and a very bright blue central nucleus. The three-component fit gives the S´ersic index n = 1.1 for the central
nucleus, n = 0.5 (Gaussian) for the bar, and n = 1.5 for the outer disk-like region. This three-component
S´ersic profile fit (Figure 4) is acceptable and suggests the presence of disk. For mask sizes 2.5re, 3re and
3.5re, the best fit S´ersic indicies n are 2.0, 1.8, and 1.8, respectively. However, unlike for EA3 and EA4, we
do this fit in a limited region and cannot conclude that EA5 has a distinct exponential disk component. The
presence of a bar-like feature also suggests an underlying disk.
For the E+As that may contain a disk component, we calculate a bulge-to-total light ratio (B/T) to
quantify the relative importance of the bulge and disk-like components. B/T for EA3 and EA4 is 0.56 and
– 7 –
0.62, respectively. These values are larger than the typical B/T for Sa galaxies (0.45) and comparable to
the median for S0's (0.63; Kent 1985). Despite the complications of fitting EA5, various modes of fitting the
galaxy produce B/T ∼ 0.7. Unless the bulge and any underlying disk-like component fade at dramatically
different rates, which is unlikely given the relatively weak large-scale population gradients in these galaxies
(Norton et al. 2001), the descendants of these galaxies must be early type (S0 or E, if the disk-like material
is tidal debris that disperses or collapses onto the central component).
Given the asymmetric features, how reliable are these fits? There are several ways to check the results
for possible systematic errors. First, we compare the fitted analytical profiles to the radial surface brightness
profiles obtained from the isophote fitting procedure.
In Figure 3, we plot the radial surface brightness
profiles of a chosen model for each galaxy: r1/4 profile for EA2 and EA5, r1/4 + exponential disk profile
for EA3 and EA4, and the profiles obtained from the isophote fitting. The differences between the data
(ELLIPSE) and models (GALFIT) range mostly between ±0.5 mag/arcsec2, are not global, and reflect local
asymmetric components. Second, we examine the residual images obtained by subtracting the smooth and
symmetric models from the data (see Figure 2). In all cases we see evidence for components beyond the
bulge + disk model. We then calculate how much light remains in the residual images to quantify the
goodness of the fit. The relative asymmetric light - excess (deficit) - within a 10′′ radius is 16(8)%,
6(5)%, 8(9)%, 9(8)% of the symmetric model components for EA2-5, respectively. Most (50% to 80%) of
the under(over)subtracted light comes from the central region within 0.5′′, where the even a small amount of
fractional deviation from the data can dominate the residual flux over the outer faint parts. Except for EA2,
the global under(over)subtractions are roughly the same and localized fluctuations dominate the residuals,
so we conclude that our global fits are reliable. In the case with the most residual light (EA2), 24% of the
light cannot be explained by a symmetric model and the positive residuals dominate all over the galaxy.
Therefore, we cannot exclude the possibility that we are looking right along the interaction plane (the tidal
debris are quite linear). The point sources near the E+A bulges in the residual images are discussed in §3.7.
3.3. Morphologies: Asymmetric Components
So far we have fit symmetric smooth models with moderate success, but have found that asymmetric
features are quite common in our sample. Asymmetry, in particular lopsidedness, has been used to measure
disturbances in local "normal" disk galaxies (Rix & Zaritsky 1995; Zaritsky & Rix 1997) and correlates with
recent star formation (Zaritsky & Rix 1997; Rudnick & Rix 1998). There are multiple ways in which one
can quantify asymmetry, but here we choose to follow what was done for local spirals by Rix & Zaritsky
(1995). This measurement is based on the azimuthal Fourier decomposition of the surface brightness along
elliptical isophotes.
For the two most disk-like of the E+As (EA3 and 4), we calculate the Fourier decomposition of the
F702W band surface brightness distribution. We use a grid with 24 azimuthal and 36 radial bins from semi-
major axes of 4 to 200 pixels. The center of the azimuthal grid is identified as the brightest central point in
the galaxy image. Figure 5 shows the amplitudes of the various first Fourier terms as a function of radius.
In field spirals, A1 > 0.2 is identified as strong lopsidedness, found in ∼ 20% of the cases, and interpreted
as the result of a recent interaction (other explanations, such as halo-induced disk sloshing have since been
suggested; e.g., Levine & Sparke 1998; Kornreich et al 2002). EA3 has A1 ≪ 0.2 at all radii except in the
transition region between the inner spiral arms and the tidal tails at ∼ 3 − 6 kpc and at large radii where the
uncertainties are large. Although EA4 has large A1 within 3 kpc, which is consistent with the appearance of
the residual image (Figure 2), A1 < 0.2 for 1.5 < rd < 2.5, the range used in the study of field spirals. The
– 8 –
lopsidedness of EA3 and EA4 is consistent with that of normal spiral galaxies despite the cataclysmic event
that occurred ∼ Gyr ago indicated by the spectra. This result has two possible interpretations: either these
galaxies have had sufficient time to relax and "smooth out" interaction-induced asymmetries (e.g., Mihos
1995), or they are the result of encounters not strong enough to cause major dynamical damage. Of course,
the latter possibility runs into the problem of how to trigger such a massive starburst without dynamically
disturbing the galaxy.
3.4. Color Gradients
The color gradients of E+As are constraints on merger models and clues as to what these galaxies will
ultimately become. In Figure 6, we show the F702W−F439W color profiles of EA2-5, which are obtained
by using the results from the ELLIPSE task and include the A-type K-correction. Because of the shallow
exposure in F439W band, the color profiles are limited to r . 2 − 3 kpc, which is only 25% of the radial
coverage available in the red. To derive the color profiles within the most central region (< 0.5′′), we use
the deconvolved images. However, because deconvolution can produce large artificial fluctuations in low
signal-to-noise data, we cannot use the deconvolved F439W profiles in the outer regions of the galaxy. We
compromise by using the deconvolved images for r < 0.5′′ and the non-deconvolved images for r > 0.5′′.
The overall colors of E+As are relatively blue globally due to the recent star formation (bottom panel
of Figure 6). The radial extent of the blue colors confirms previous observations (Franx 1993; Caldwell
et al. 1996; Norton et al. 2001) that the recent star formation region is not confined within the innermost
regions. However, the color gradients, especially within 1 kpc of the centers, are as diverse as the overall
morphologies. While, EA3 and EA5 have blue nuclei and become redder going outward, EA2 becomes bluer
with radius, and EA4 shows a relatively flat profile.
The colors are the result of the complicated interplay between age, metallicity and dust. The lack of HI
in these systems (Chang et al. 2001; Miller & Owen 2001) and of any patchiness in the images of EA2-5 argue
against high levels of dust (but it is still possible that high density pockets of dust are present, particularly
toward the nucleus of some of these systems). With the exception of EA1, none of the E+As show the
irregular, filamentary structures expected from strong dust lanes. We thus conclude that the variety of color
gradients within the inner few hundred parsecs reflects variations of the spatial distribution of the young
population, which in some systems appears to be preferentially located near the center of the galaxy and in
others appears to avoid the center. Perhaps this reflects differences in the types of encounter involved and
its ability to drive true nuclear starbursts - e.g., differences between prograde and retrograde encounters
(Barnes & Hernquist 1996), major versus minor mergers (Hernquist & Mihos 1995), or differences in the
structural properties of the progenitor galaxies (Mihos & Hernquist 1996).
3.5. Relationship to Fundamental Plane
To investigate whether E+As can evolve into E/S0 galaxies, we compare the stellar kinematics and
structural parameters of E+As with "normal" early type galaxies. Norton et al. (2001) found that the
old component of E+A galaxies is offset (brighter by ∼ 0.6 mag) from the the local Faber-Jackson relation.
Using the structural parameters that can only be measured using HST imaging, we extend this comparison to
various projections of the Fundamental Plane (hereafter FP) in Figure 7. To compare our results with the FP
of Jorgensen et al. (1996), we correct these observables to our adopted cosmology (H0 = 70 km s−1 Mpc−1,
– 9 –
(ΩM , ΩΛ) = (0.3, 0.7)). Changes in the cosmological parameters only affect zero points in the FP equation.
We use velocity dispersions from Norton et al. (2001) for the K-star component and the structural parameters
from a single r1/4 model 3. We transform the F702W magnitude to a Gunn r magnitude using the average
(F702W − Gunn r) color for galaxies of various Hubble type (Fukugita et al. 1995). The average (r−F702W)
colors range from 0.56 for elliptical to 0.51 for Scd galaxies. Even for the extreme case of irregular (Im)
galaxies, (r − F702W) is different by only ∼ 0.1 magnitude from the average value of 0.54.
We show various projections of the FP in Figure 7. Figure 7(a) shows the face-on view of the FP given
by x = (2.21 log re − 0.82 loghIie + 1.24 log σ)/2.66, y = (1.24 loghIie + 0.82 log σ)/1.49 (see Jorgensen et al.
(1996)). The dashed line indicates the bound set by the limiting magnitude, but the upper dotted boundary
is not caused by a selection effect. Figure 7(b) shows the edge-on view of the FP along the long axis of the
distribution, given by y = 1.24 log σ − 0.82 loghIie. Figure 7(c) shows the Faber-Jackson relation. Figure
7(d) shows the correlations between re and hµei.
The four E+As stand apart from the E/S0s in the edge-on view of the FP, but otherwise populate the
same general region of the 3-D volume. The most striking deviation of the E+As among the scaling laws lies
in the µe − re correlation. EA2-5 are more than a half magnitude brighter than the median E/S0 galaxies
with the same effective radii. Especially, EA3 and EA4 have a large excess surface brightness over the dotted
boundary of E/S0 galaxies in the FP. We measure the excess brightness to be 0.86 and 0.54 mag relative
to the dotted upper boundary of the µe − re projection for EA3 and 4, respectively. As seen Figure 7(c),
although EA2-5 have intermediate luminosities (−22 < Mr < −20) in comparison to E and S0 galaxies, they
have a large mean surface brightness within the effective radius.
Will E+As fade onto the locus of E/S0's after a few Gyr? We estimate the amount of fading within an
effective radius using STARBURST99 models (Leitherer et al. 1999). Assuming solar metallicity, a Salpeter
IMF, an underlying 5 Gyr-old population (not evolving), and a single instantaneous starburst with a mass
fraction of 50%, the E+As will fade ∼ 0.5 magnitudes during the first Gyr after the burst. This degree of
fading places EA2, EA4, and EA5 on the E/S0 locus, but not EA3. This model is oversimplified, however.
The evolutionary tracks in the µe − re projection will proceed from upper-left to lower-right, because of the
decline of the mean surface brightness within re both due to fading and the inclusion of the larger fraction
of the galaxy. But, calculating these effects requires a detailed knowledge of the spatial distribution of the
young and old populations.
3.6. Comparison with to "Core" and "Power-law" Ellipticals
Does the consistency in global surface brightness profiles between E+As and normal early-type galaxies
(as discussed in §3.5) extend to the innermost radii? The recently discovered dichotomy in the central
surface brightness profiles ("core" vs. "power-law"; Lauer et al. 1995; Faber et al. 1997) of normal early-
type provides a framework for this comparison. In Figure 8, we plot the F702W surface brightness profiles
for our E+As and the F555W profiles of Faber et al. (1997) sample (assuming V − R = 0.5 and adjusting for
differences in adopted cosmology). The apparent lack of any central "break" and associated transition to a
shallow cusp in the E+A profiles leads us to classify the E+As as "power-law" galaxies. Not only are the
3There is an issue as to which structural parameters (for the entire galaxy or the bulge only) one should use to construct
1/4 profile, because we are comparing with
the FP for S0 or disk galaxies. However, we opt to use the (re, µe) from a single r
Jorgensen et al. (1996), who also used single de Vaucouleurs profiles for S0's.
– 10 –
profiles shapes consistent, but the total luminosities of these E+As lie within the range spanned by normal
power-law early-types, and any fading will place them even more securely in that range.
Although the profile shapes and total luminosities of E+As are consistent with those of power-law
early-types, Figure 8 shows that the E+A surface brightness are generally higher. EA2 is consistent with the
highest surface brightness normal power-law galaxies, and the other three E+As have even higher surface
brightness.
If fading of the young stellar population does not significantly alter the profile shape, then
these galaxies will retain their power-law profiles. While we cannot be certain that the profiles will remain
unchanged, the current inner profiles and total luminosities are consistent with E+A evolution into normal
power-law early-type galaxies.
3.7. Discovery of Young Star Clusters
A specific type of asymmetric small-scale feature is the compact sources most visible in the residual
images. We identify a set of these sources using SExtractor (Bertin & Arnouts 1996) to analyze both
the combined and residual images. Because we expect stellar clusters to be unresolved at these distances
(one pixel corresponds to ∼ 65 − 95 pc at z = 0.07 − 0.12), confusion between real sources and hot pixels or
background fluctuations is a serious problem. After testing various detection criteria and comparing visually,
we decided to consider an object real only if it has at least three adjacent pixels that are each at a flux level
3 times above the local background rms. To estimate the local background level, we use a background mesh
size for SExtractor of ∼ 4 − 8 pixels, depending on the image. The residual images are used to detect
compact sources close to the galaxy center, where the rapidly varying galaxy light complicates detections in
the original images.
Using these criteria, we detect 35, 9, 29, 10 and 1 point-like sources within the PC images of EA1-5,
respectively. These objects may be foreground stars, background compact sources, giant HII regions, or
star clusters. Unfortunately, due to the insensitivity of the F439W band, we are able to obtain colors for
only a few of the objects. The lack of emission lines in the spectra of these E+A galaxies (Zabludoff et al.
1996; Norton et al. 2001) suggests that these galaxies are not littered with giant HII regions. The spatial
distribution of the compact objects suggests that the majority of these sources are associated with the E+As.
For example, in EA1 almost all of the point sources are located around EA1 and its companion, and three of
them lie in the bridge-like structure connecting the two galaxies. In EA2, some objects lie in the elongated
tidal tails. In EA3, five to six unresolved objects surround the nucleus of EA3 and form a concentric circle.
We apply a Kolmogorov-Smirnoff (K-S) one-sample test to find the probability that the radial distributions
of the compact sources are drawn from a random distribution. We show the cumulative distribution of the
angular distances from the center of each galaxy in Figure 9. There is almost zero probability that the
sources follow the random distribution, indicating that the detected compact sources are truly associated
with the E+A galaxies. Because of the post-starburst nature of E+A galaxies and the discovery of numerous
young clusters in ongoing mergers (e.g., Holtzman et al. 1992; Whitmore et al. 1993), it is likely that the
majority of these objects are relatively young star clusters.
Like the morphological diversity of the E+As themselves, the number of cluster candidates varies widely
among EA1-5. In particular, the difference between EA3 and EA5 is remarkable because these otherwise
appear to have comparable masses (the velocity dispersions of their old populations are the same and the
luminosity ratio is ∼ 0.5). The principal difference between these systems is that EA5 is more distant. To
determine whether the distance difference is responsible for the difference in detected sources, we model the
– 11 –
detectability of the point sources as a function of distance. For a given size (half-light radius) and brightness,
we generate two dimensional surface brightness distributions of the model clusters for a King profile (King
1966) with concentration c = 0.5 − 2.5. We convolve the model profiles with the PC PSF generated from the
TinyTim software (Krist & Hook 1999). All models and PSFs are constructed at a resolution of 1/10th of
a PC pixel, re-binned to the original image size, and smeared using the pixel smearing kernel. After adding
the Poisson noise and sky background, we attempt to detect the cluster using the same detection criteria
that we apply to the original images. The position on the PC and the spectral variation of the PSF do not
affect our detection threshold.
The number of detected pixels above 3σ is nearly insensitive to the size of the sources and the shape of
the profile in the subpixel regime. In other words, the images of point sources give us little or no information
about their spatial structures, but they can be detected if they are sufficiently bright. We adopt the detection
limit as the magnitude at which the number of detected pixels above 3σ drops below three pixels. The number
of compact sources above EA5's detection limit (MR < −12.5 ± 0.25) and well outside the E+A are 6 to 16
for EA3 and is 1 for EA5. The uncertainty in the detection limit arises from uncertainties in the aperture
correction and photometry. Assuming EA5 has the same number of the compact sources as EA3, we would
expect to detect 3 to 8 sources in EA5 after rough scaling of the projected area occupied by the detections
around each galaxy. The statistics of our sample thus preclude us from distinguishing between the cluster
populations of EA3 and EA5. If the difference is significant, it might reflect a difference in the starburst
(strength or progenitors) or an age difference. The latter possibility is consistent with the observation that
EA5 has the reddest D4000 and is the most symmetric among our sample.
Matching the observed colors of the cluster candidates with the predictions of stellar population synthesis
models can help break the degeneracy between the age and starburst strength of our post-merger E+As. We
show the evolution of the color and brightness of a simple stellar population based on Starburst99 models
(Leitherer et al. 1999) in Figure 10. Because of the unknown SEDs of our sources, the K correction of the
observed colors is problematic. To avoid applying an uncertain K correction, we calculate the redshifted
(F439W-F702W) colors from the model spectra provided from Starburst99. Superposed on the various
models, we show the range of the colors observed and the corresponding range of ages for each of the five
point-like sources in EA1 with σ(F439W − F702W) < 0.25 and sufficient S/N. They are identified by eye
in the F439W band and are not located in the crowded region. Because the absence of the O, B stellar
signatures (Zabludoff et al. 1996; Norton et al. 2001) suggest that the ages of the clusters are older than
107 yr, we rule out the solutions in the double trough of the model. Assuming a Salpeter IMF that extends
from 1 to 100 M⊙, solar metallicity (Z = 0.020), and an instantaneous starburst, we estimate the ages of
the candidate clusters to be between ∼ 30 Myr and 500 Myr.
We applied the following statistical test to constrain the time since the starburst under the assumption
that all the candidate clusters formed at the same time and have a spread of estimated age due to photometric
errors. For each model age, we draw a thousand samples of five clusters each with colors scattered according
to a Gaussian of dispersion 0.2 mag. We calculate the percentage of simulations that have a median color
as far from the true color as the observed median color. If that number is 5% or less, the model is rejected.
Because of the slow evolution of colors in the relevant age range, we can constrain the age of clusters (time
elapsed since the starburst) to only ∼ 35 − 450 Myr at the 95% confidence level (see the horizontal line in
Figure 10). While our constraint on the age is drawn from only a few cluster candidates, this range is as
good as the typical age ranges that Leonardi & Rose (1996) derived using CaII and Hδ/λ4045 indices from
the integrated spectra of E+A galaxies. Because any reddening by the host galaxy will make the sources
look older, our estimated ages are upper limits on the true ages. However, it is unlikely that the reddening
– 12 –
affects our results seriously because the five sources are at large radii, where the extinction should be minor
compared to the galaxy center. To improve upon the age estimate, in particular to reduce contamination, to
correct the reddening, and to get more precise ages for the sources, ideally we would need deep multicolor
photometry to produce a two-color diagram like Fig. 6 in Harris et al. (2001). However, we can see from the
present analysis that we would benefit from just more clusters with colors. We conclude that the derived
ages are consistent with what we expect on the basis of the integrated galaxy spectra, again supporting the
claim that these are stellar clusters associated with the E+A phenomenon, and suggesting that this is part
of a population of clusters formed during the E+A phase.
We compare the R band cluster luminosities of EA1, EA3, the Milky Way globular clusters (Harris 1996)
and the clusters in starbursting, merging systems (e.g., NGC3597, Carlson et al 1999). If the compact sources
in the E+As are clusters, they are much brighter (MR ∼ −13) than Galactic globular clusters (MR > −11)
and similar to clusters in galaxies with on-going starburst. The latter agreement supports the interpretation
that we have identified the bright end of a population (e.g., MR ∼ −14 in NGC3597) of star clusters formed
during a starburst that occurred < 1 Gyr ago. A fading of several magnitudes is required for these systems
to resemble the massive end of the Milky Way cluster population.
3.8.
Implications for High Redshift Interacting Galaxies
The difficulty we have experienced in determining whether these E+As have a disk component, have
tidal components, and are asymmetric suggests that at high redshift these galaxies might be classified as
"normal" morphologically. For example, the tidal tails that connect onto what may be a disk would naturally
be interpreted as spiral arms if one is not able to trace the tails out to large radii. To better understand this
effect, we rebin the F702W band image of EA3 and fade it artificially according to our adopted cosmology
to mimic its appearance at higher redshift (Figure 11). The rebined images are convolved with the PSF,
and the sky background and noise proportional to the exposure time are added to the redshifted images.
For each image, we assume the same exposure time (2100s) and average sky brightness. The tidal features
are lost at a redshift over ∼ 0.5 (see also Mihos 1995; Hibbard & Vacca 1997), and EA3 appears to be a
normal spiral or S0 galaxy. The mean surface brightness of the tidal tails of EA3 is ∼ 24 − 25 mag arcsec−2.
This exercise suggests that some of the disky E+A galaxies found frequently in distant clusters might be
misclassified as non-interacting disk galaxies and nevertheless have tidal features like EA2-4. The lack of
apparent tidal features and of asymmetry at high redshift should not be interpreted directly as an absence
of interactions.
4. Summary
Using HST imaging, we have obtained high resolution images of five E+Ai galaxies. Our results, when
coupled with studies of E+A kinematics, star formation histories, and gas content, argue that E+As are in
transition between late and early types, a missing link in the evolution of galaxies. Our principal findings
are:
1. Four (EA1-4) of the five E+As are morphologically disturbed (with tidal tails and shell-like struc-
tures), consistent with being relics of galaxy-galaxy interactions. The dramatic tidal features found in EA1,
2, and 3 further confirm that galaxy-galaxy mergers are at least one mechanism that triggers the starburst
that leads to the E+A phase.
– 13 –
2. E+As have diverse morphologies. Even in this small sample, one highly disturbed galaxy cannot
be morphologically classified (EA1) and one regular galaxy could plausibly be classified as a barred S0
galaxy (EA5). Two other galaxies (EA3 and 4) seem to contain disk components. The striking aspect of
this morphological variety is that all of these galaxies have been selected on the basis of their very similar
spectra.
3. The bulge fractions of these systems are consistent with elliptical and S0 galaxies. E+As have a
central structure consistent with "normal" power-law early type galaxies (Faber et al. 1997), although at
present the E+As have significantly higher surface brightnesses. This is the first direct confirmation that
power-law elliptical galaxies can be formed from gas-rich mergers.
4. E+As are blue due to recent star formation, but their color gradients in the central region are as
diverse as their morphologies. Two galaxies (EA3 and 5) have extremely blue cores that redden toward the
outer regions, one (EA4) has a relatively flat profile, and one (EA2) has a redder core within a few kpc.
The red core is particularly puzzling from the standpoint of merger models that predict gas inflow into the
center and a subsequent starburst. It is possible that the red color arises from dust extinction, but we see
no evidence for the filamentary structure usually associated with dust lanes.
5. E+As stand apart from the E/S0s in the Fundamental Plane mainly due to their high central surface
brightness. Fading of the young stellar population and a corresponding increase in re (if the young population
is more concentrated than the underlying population) will cause the systems to migrate toward the locus of
E/S0s in time. Without a detailed knowledge of the distribution of young and old stars it is not possible to
model this evolution precisely.
6. We find compact sources associated with E+A galaxies. Although some of these sources could be
foreground stars, giant HII regions, or background objects, we conclude that the majority are star clusters
that formed during the starburst phase, such as those found in nearby starburst galaxies. These systems are
similar in luminosity to the brightest clusters in NGC 3597 (Carlson et al. 1999) and have ages consistent with
that expected for the time elapsed since the starburst (several 108 yrs). They are much brighter (MR ∼ −13)
than Galactic globular clusters, but will fade over a Hubble time to be consistent with the most massive
Milky Way clusters. Further study of these systems might provide the elusive chronometer for lifting the
age/burst-strength degeneracy for post-merger galaxies.
One valuable lesson of our work is that despite the recent interactions that at least some of these
E+As have experienced, one of the standard tests for interactions (the lopsidedness measure based on the
azimuthal Fourier decomposition of the isophotes) fails to identify these systems as having experienced a
recent interaction. The tidal features are sufficiently faint and the inner surface brightness profiles sufficiently
regular that the galaxies are measured to be symmetric. Such indicators should therefore be used with caution
on large-scale surveys and at high-redshifts because they obviously miss at least some recently interacting
systems. Furthermore, in a system that one does not suspect to be interacting, the tidal tails can easily be
misidentified as spiral arms.
This work described the observations of the five bluest E+A galaxies in LCRS sample with HST /WFPC2.
To confirm the various results presented here and determine whether this subset was biased by the color
selection requires a study of the remainder of the LCRS sample. We are currently obtaining HST /ACS
imaging of those galaxies.
We thank Chien Peng for help in using his program (GALFIT) and useful discussions about galaxy
– 14 –
morphology. We also thank Greg Rudnick for providing the azimuthal Fourier transform routines. YY and
AIZ acknowledge support from NSF grant AST-0206084, NASA LTSA grant #NAG5-11108, and HST grant
GO-06835.01-95A. J.C.M. acknowledges support by the NSF through CAREER grant AST-9876143 and by
a Research Corporation Cottrell Scholarship. Support for proposal GO-6835 was provided by NASA through
a grant from the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for
Research in Astronomy, Incorporated, under NASA contract NAS5-26555.
REFERENCES
Ashman, K. M. & Zepf, S. E. 1992, ApJ, 384, 50
Barnes, J. E. 1988, ApJ, 331, 699
Barnes, J. E. & Hernquist, L. 1996, ApJ, 471, 115
Bendo, G. J. & Barnes, J. E. 2000, MNRAS, 316, 315
Bertin, E. & Arnouts, S. 1996, A&AS, 117, 393
Butcher, H. & Oemler, A. 1978, ApJ, 219, 18
Caldwell, N., Rose, J. A., Franx, M., & Leonardi, A. J. 1996, AJ, 111, 78
Carlson, M. N. et al. 1999, AJ, 117, 1700
Chang, T., van Gorkom, J. H., Zabludoff, A. I., Zaritsky, D., & Mihos, J. C. 2001, AJ, 121, 1965
Couch, W. J. & Sharples, R. M. 1987, MNRAS, 229, 423
Dressler, A. & Gunn, J. E. 1983, ApJ, 270, 7
Dressler, A., Smail, I., Poggianti, B. M., Butcher, H., Couch, W. J., Ellis, R. S., & Oemler, A. J. 1999, ApJS,
122, 51
Faber, S. M., Tremaine, S., Ajhar, E. A., Byun, Y., Dressler, A., Gebhardt, K., Grillmair, C., Kormendy,
J., Lauer, T. R., & Richstone, D. 1997, AJ, 114, 1771
Franx, M. 1993, ApJ, 407, L5
Fukugita, M., Shimasaku, K., & Ichikawa, T. 1995, PASP, 107, 945
Graham, A. W. 2002, MNRAS, 334, 859
Graham, A. W., Erwin, P., Caon, N., & Trujillo, I. 2001, ApJ, 563, L11
Gunn, J. E. & Stryker, L. L. 1983, ApJS, 52, 121
Harris, J., Calzetti, D., Gallagher, J. S., Conselice, C. J., & Smith, D. A. 2001, AJ, 122, 3046
Harris, W. E. 1996, AJ, 112, 1487
Hernquist, L. & Mihos, J. C. 1995, ApJ, 448, 41
Hibbard, J. E. & Vacca, W. D. 1997, AJ, 114, 1741
– 15 –
Holtzman, J. A. et al. 1992, AJ, 103, 691
Holtzman, J. A., Burrows, C. J., Casertano, S., Hester, J. J., Trauger, J. T., Watson, A. M., & Worthey, G.
1995, PASP, 107, 1065
Jorgensen, I., Franx, M., & Kjaergaard, P. 1996, MNRAS, 280, 167
Kelson, D. D., Illingworth, G. D., van Dokkum, P. G., & Franx, M. 2000, ApJ, 531, 137
Kent, S. M. 1985, ApJS, 59, 115
King, I. R. 1966, AJ, 71, 64
Kornreich, D. A., Lovelace, R. V. E., & Haynes, M. P. 2002, ApJ, 580, 705
Krist, J. & Hook, R. 1999, The TinyTim User's Guide(Baltimore: STSCI)
Lauer, T. R., Ajhar, E. A., Byun, Y.-I., Dressler, A., Faber, S. M., Grillmair, C., Kormendy, J., Richstone,
D., & Tremaine, S. 1995, AJ, 110, 2622
Lauer, T. R., Faber, S. M., Ajhar, E. A., Grillmair, C. J., & Scowen, P. A. 1998, AJ, 116, 2263
Leonardi, A. J. & Rose, J. A. 1996, AJ, 111, 182
Levine, S. E. & Sparke, L. S. 1998, ApJ, 496, L13
Lucy, L. B. 1974, AJ, 79, 745
Leitherer, C. et al. 1999, ApJS, 123, 3
Mihos, J. C. 1995, ApJ, 438, L75
Mihos, J. C. & Hernquist, L. 1994, ApJ, 431, L9
Mihos, J. C. & Hernquist, L. 1996, ApJ, 464, 641
Miller, N. A. & Owen, F. N. 2001, ApJ, 554, L25
Naab, T. 2000, Ph.D. thesis
Norton, S. A., Gebhardt, K., Zabludoff, A. I., & Zaritsky, D. 2001, ApJ, 557, 150
Nugent, P., Kim, A., & Perlmutter, S. 2002, PASP, 114, 803
Peng, C. Y., Ho, L. C., Impey, C. D., & Rix, H. 2002, AJ, 124, 266
Poggianti, B. M., Smail, I., Dressler, A., Couch, W. J., Barger, A. J., Butcher, H., Ellis, R. S., & Oemler,
A. J. 1999, ApJ, 518, 576
Quintero, A. D. et al. 2003, submitted to ApJ, astro-ph/0307074
Richardson, W. H. 1972, J. Opt. Soc. A., 62, 5
Rix, H. & Zaritsky, D. 1995, ApJ, 447, 82
Rudnick, G. & Rix, H. 1998, AJ, 116, 1163
– 16 –
Salpeter, E. E. 1955, ApJ, 121, 161
Schlegel, D. J., Finkbeiner, D. P., & Davis, M. 1998, ApJ, 500, 525
Toomre, A. 1977, in "The Evolution of Galaxies and Stellar Populations", eds. B. Tinsley and R.B. Larson
(New Haven: Yale Univ.), p. 401
Whitmore, B. C., Schweizer, F., Leitherer, C., Borne, K., & Robert, C. 1993, AJ, 106, 1354
Zabludoff, A. I., Zaritsky, D., Lin, H., Tucker, D., Hashimoto, Y., Shectman, S. A., Oemler, A., & Kirshner,
R. P. 1996, ApJ, 466, 104
Zaritsky, D. & Rix, H. 1997, ApJ, 477, 118
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
– 17 –
Table 1. Properties of galaxies
z
kpc/′′
a
fA
hVroti a
σ (kms−1) a
cluster
Old
Young
Old
Young
R.A.
(1950.0)
Dec.
(1950.0)
ID
EA1
EA2
EA3
EA4
EA5
10 58 48.97
2 15 43.24
12 6 31.34
3 58 23.42
1 56 0.12
-11 54 9.80
-44 46 36.70
-12 5 55.40
-44 43 40.29
-44 51 49.00
0.0746
0.0987
0.0810
0.1012
0.1172
1.417
1.823
1.527
1.864
2.119
0.80
0.42
0.59
0.56
0.42
−54
−20
24 +57
23 +16
23 +17
1 + 8
33 +24
−23
− 9
−25
−17
−25
19 +17
22 +24
25 +18
35 +15
52 +34
−17
−16
−18
−35
−16
35 +39
202 +17
120 +22
131 + 9
120 + 7
−20
− 9
− 8
−23
−46
23 +53
193 +32
56 +35
246 +24
94 +34
−32
−25
−41
?
N
N
N
Y
N
aData from Norton et al. (2001)
Table 2. Magnitudes and colors of E+A galaxies
F439W
F702W
F439W−F702W
ID
m (< 4.5′′)
M
m (< 4.5′′)
M
(r < re)
EA1
EA2
EA3
EA4
EA5
17.95 ± 0.02
18.09 ± 0.02
16.75 ± 0.01
17.47 ± 0.01
18.58 ± 0.04
-19.97
-20.50
-21.52
-21.17
-20.51
17.18 ± 0.01
16.44 ± 0.01
15.34 ± 0.01
15.86 ± 0.01
16.83 ± 0.01
-20.40
-21.70
-22.49
-22.31
-21.67
-
1.10 ± 0.01
0.80 ± 0.01
1.18 ± 0.01
0.99 ± 0.01
Table 3. K corrections for A dwarf and K giant
ID
z
K(F439W)
K(F702W)
K(F439W)
K(F702W)
A dwarf
K giant
EA1
EA2
EA3
EA4
EA5
0.0746
0.0987
0.0810
0.1012
0.1172
0.136 ±0.035
0.233 ±0.038
0.157 ±0.036
0.246 ±0.039
0.340 ±0.042
-0.148 ±0.022
-0.192 ±0.028
-0.160 ±0.024
-0.196 ±0.029
-0.225 ±0.033
0.755 ±0.123
0.991 ±0.168
0.823 ±0.136
1.016 ±0.172
1.176 ±0.192
0.042 ±0.032
0.065 ±0.038
0.048 ±0.034
0.068 ±0.039
0.084 ±0.043
Table 4. Structural parameters
ID
re (kpc)
r1/4-Law
µe
EA2
EA3
EA4
EA5
2.74 ± 0.14
1.79 ± 0.07
2.07 ± 0.07
1.62 ± 0.06
19.99 ± 0.09
18.56 ± 0.07
19.22 ± 0.06
18.85 ± 0.07
χ2
ν
1.72
2.08
1.61
1.49
S´ersic r1/n-Law
re (kpc)
µe
n
4.49 ± 0.98
3.74 ± 0.64
2.43 ± 0.24
2.39 ± 0.38
21.10 ± 0.39
20.19 ± 0.28
19.61 ± 0.17
19.70 ± 0.31
6.22 ± 0.53
8.73 ± 0.45
5.10 ± 0.25
6.40 ± 0.56
χ2
ν
1.62
1.51
1.56
1.45
– 18 –
Table 5. Bulge-disk decompositions
ID
re (kpc)
µe
rd (kpc)
µd
χ2
ν
B/T
Bulge
Disk
EA3
EA4
EA5
0.69 ± 0.03
1.11 ± 0.05
1.14 ± 0.03
17.02 ± 0.05
18.11 ± 0.05
18.23 ± 0.04
3.57 ± 0.22
3.44 ± 0.16
4.01 ± 0.45
19.30 ± 0.14
19.50 ± 0.12
21.00 ± 0.21
1.58
1.48
1.45
0.56
0.62
0.70
– 19 –
Fig. 1.- HST WFPC2 images of five E+A galaxies. From top to bottom, EA1 to EA5. (left column)
WFPC2 mosaic images in high contrast. Notice the dramatic tidal tails. (middle column) High resolution
F702W band PC images in low contrast. (right column) Central regions in F439W band. The size of each
field is ∼ 80′′, 24′′, and 12′′ (left to right), and the pixel scale in the middle and right columns is 0′′.046/pixel.
– 20 –
Fig. 1.- Continued.
– 21 –
Fig. 2.- Residual images (15.5′′ × 15.5′′) obtained by subtracting the smooth and symmetric model images
from the data. EA3 and EA4 : r1/4 bulge + exponential disk model. EA2 and EA5 : r1/4 bulge only. The
solid and dashed circles represent 4re and 3rd (if bulge+disk decomposition was done), respectively. The
relative asymmetric light - excess (deficit) - within a 10′′ radius is 16(8)%, 6(5)%, 8(9)% and 9(8)% of
the symmetric model components for EA2-5, respectively.
– 22 –
Fig. 3.- F702W radial surface brightness profiles. The thin solid lines show the radial profiles obtained
from ELLIPSE, the dotted lines show the bulge components fitted to the r1/4 law, and the dashed lines show
the disk/tidal components fitted to the exponential law. The thick solid lines are the superposition of the
bulge and disk components. Pure bulge + disk decomposition was done only for EA3 and EA4 (fitting EA5
was more complicated, see text and Figure 4). The top axis of each panel is the effective radius re of the
bulge component of each galaxy. Bottom panels show the difference between the data (ELLIPSE) and fits
(GALFIT).
– 23 –
Fig. 4.- EA5 galaxy in different contrasts. EA5 shows three components - an extended light distribution
in the outer part, a bar structure, and a very bright blue central nucleus. (Upper left panel ) Three-component
decomposition of EA5. The dashed lines represent each component. Solid thin and thick lines show the data
and the sum of the three model components (n = 1.1, 0.5, and 1.5 from inside to outside), respectively.
– 24 –
Fig. 5.- Amplitudes and phases of each Fourier component in the F702W images. Radius is plotted in disk
scale units and kpc. Am and φ(Am) are the m-th order Fourier amplitudes and phase angles, respectively.
The zeroth order component A0 has no phase and reflects the mean flux at the given radius. The first order
component A1 denotes the lopsidedness of the galaxy at the given radius.
– 25 –
EA2
EA3
EA4
EA5
E
Sa,Sb
A star
Fig. 6.- (F702W − F439W) color profiles of four E+A galaxies. The zero point in the color axis is arbitrary
in the upper panel. The dashed (F702W − F439W) = 1.0 lines for each color profile are shown for reference.
The dashed lines in the lower panel represent the typical colors of elliptical galaxies, spiral galaxies, and A
stars. Notice the diversity of the color gradients within 1 kpc, which is reminiscent of their morphological
diversity.
– 26 –
Fig. 7.- Relative position of four E+A galaxies in the Fundamental Plane (FP). The small open circles are
data from Jorgensen et al (1996). (a) Face-on view of the FP as in Jorgensen et al (1996). The dashed line
indicates the boundary set by the limiting magnitude, but the upper dotted line is not caused by a selection
effect. (b) Edge-on view of the FP in the longest direction (dashed line in panel (a)) of distribution. (c)
The Faber-Jackson relation. Our galaxies occupy a small region in the parameter space. (d ) The re − µe
correlations of early type galaxies and the four E+As. Notice the deviation of EA3 and EA4 from the average
relation (∼ 0.5 − 1.0 magnitudes brighter than E/S0 galaxies within one effective radius).
– 27 –
EA3
EA4
EA5
EA2
14
16
18
20
22
10
100
Semimajor axis (parsec)
1000
10000
Fig. 8.- The F702W surface brightness plots of the sample E+A galaxies versus those of normal early-type
galaxies (Faber et al. 1997). (The present figure is an adaptation of Faber et al.'s Figure 1.) The E+As are
matched to the Faber et al. (1997) scale by assuming V − R = 0.5 mag and adopting H0 = 70. Power-law
galaxies are plotted as solid lines; core galaxies are plotted as dashed lines. E+A galaxies (thick solid lines)
have profiles like those of normal power-law early-type galaxies, but scaled-up in surface brightness.
– 28 –
Fig. 9.- Cumulative distribution of the angular distances of the candidate clusters from the center of the
E+As. Thin solid line represents a uniform (or random) distribution, P (< r) ∝ r2.
– 29 –
Fig. 10.- The evolution of the redshifted (F439W-F702W) color and F702W magnitude of a simple stellar
population calculated from the models of Starburst99 (Leitherer et al. 1999). Evolution is shown for a single
starburst, Salpeter initial mass function (Salpeter 1955), and three different metallicities. The shaded regions
represent the range of colors observed and the corresponding range of ages for each cluster candidate in EA1.
These candidates are identified in both the F702W and F439W image. The horizontal line in the bottom
panel indicates the 95% confidence level of the estimated single age of the clusters - the time elapsed since
the starburst.
– 30 –
Fig. 11.- Artificially redshifted images of EA3. We rebin the F702W band image of EA3 and fade it
artificially to mimic what it would look like at higher redshifts. The rebined images are convolved with the
PSF, and then the sky background and noise proportional to the exposure time are added to the redshifted
images.
|
0808.2367 | 1 | 0808 | 2008-08-18T09:52:38 | Extreme multiplex spectroscopy at wide-field 4-m telescopes | [
"astro-ph"
] | We describe the design and science case for a spectrograph for the prime focus of classical 4-m wide-field telescopes that can deliver at least 4000 MOS slits over a 1 degree field. This extreme multiplex capability means that 25000 galaxy redshifts can be measured in a single night, opening up the possibilities for large galaxy redshift surveys out to z~0.7 and beyond for the purpose of measuring the Baryon Acoustic Oscillation (BAO) scale and for many other science goals. The design features four cloned spectrographs and exploits the exclusive possibility of tiling the focal plane of wide-field 4-m telescopes with CCDs for multi-object spectroscopic purposes. In ~200 night projects, such spectrographs have the potential to make galaxy redshift surveys of ~6 million galaxies over a wide redshift range and thus may provide a low-cost alternative to other survey routes such as WFMOS and SKA. Two of these extreme multiplex spectrographs are currently being designed for the AAT (NG1dF) and Calar Alto (XMS) 4-m class telescopes. NG2dF, a larger version for the AAT 2 degree field, would have 12 clones and at least 12000 slits. The clones use a transparent design including a grism in which all optics are smaller than the clone square subfield so that the clones can be tightly packed with little gaps between the contiguous fields. Only low cost glasses are used; the variations in chromatic aberrations between bands are compensated by changing one or two of the lenses adjacent to the grism. The total weight and length is smaller with a few clones than a unique spectrograph which makes it feasible to place the spectrograph at the prime focus. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Extreme multiplex spectroscopy at wide-field 4-m telescopes
Robert Content* & Tom Shanks
Department of Physics, Durham University, South Road, Durham, DH1 3LE, UK
ABSTRACT
We describe the design and science case for a spectrograph for the prime focus of classical 4-m wide-field telescopes
that can deliver at least 4000 MOS slits over a 1° field. This extreme multiplex capability means that 25000 galaxy
redshifts can be measured in a single night, opening up the possibilities for large galaxy redshift surveys out to z~0.7 and
beyond for the purpose of measuring the Baryon Acoustic Oscillation (BAO) scale and for many other science goals.
The design features four cloned spectrographs and exploits the exclusive possibility of tiling the focal plane of wide-field
4-m telescopes with CCDs for multi-object spectroscopic purposes. In ~200 night projects, such spectrographs have the
potential to make galaxy redshift surveys of ~6x106 galaxies over a wide redshift range and thus may provide a low-cost
alternative to other survey routes such as WFMOS and SKA. Two of these extreme multiplex spectrographs are currently
being designed for the AAT (NG1dF) and Calar Alto (XMS) 4-m class telescopes. NG2dF, a larger version for the AAT
2° field, would have 12 clones and at least 12000 slits. The clones use a transparent design including a grism in which all
optics are smaller than the clone square subfield so that the clones can be tightly packed with little gaps between the
contiguous fields. Only low cost glasses are used; the variations in chromatic aberrations between bands are
compensated by changing one or two of the lenses adjacent to the grism. The total weight and length is smaller with a
few clones than a unique spectrograph which makes it feasible to place the spectrograph at the prime focus.
Keywords: wide-field astronomy, multi-slit spectroscopy, galaxy redshift surveys.
1. INTRODUCTION
Recently there has been increasing appreciation of the contribution that small aperture telescopes with wide fields of
view can make to astronomical imaging surveys. The Pan-STARRS project is one example. However, there has been less
appreciation of smaller telescopes for wide-field multi-object spectroscopy. But the idea of étendue applies just as much
to spectroscopic surveys as to imaging surveys. And the cheap cost of CCD detectors makes possible a huge increase in
the field for spectroscopy as well as imaging. Here we describe the basic concept and preliminary design of R. Content,
and the science case for an extreme multiplex spectrograph for wide-field 4-m telescopes. The beauty of this instrument
design is that there are a number of already existing 4-m telescopes with a 1° field or more where this instrument could
be cheaply implemented. With a 1° field, a rate of ~4000 spectra an hour or ~30000 spectra per night is achievable. With
a 3 deg2 field, ~12000 spectra per hour or ~100000 spectra per night would be possible. These rates make many surveys
possible, especially for cosmology. And the rates that are achievable may be competitive with much more expensive
instrument proposals like WFMOS+SKA.
We shall therefore begin by describing the optical design concept of our proposed wide-field spectrographs, and then
give some examples of the powerful science that might be addressed by these instruments, before describing our
conclusions.
2. NG1DF/XMS CONCEPT
The fundamental technology driver here is the cheap cost of CCDs, which now makes it possible to tile a large focal
plane cheaply and, coupled with an efficient optical design, still retain high image quality. As noted above, imaging
surveys such as Pan-STARRS are already exploiting the étendue of small aperture telescopes with wide fields of view.
Here we propose similarly to take advantage of the large étendue of 4-m class Ritchey-Chretien telescopes for extreme
multiplex spectroscopy.
*[email protected]; phone +44-191-334-3541
2.1 Number of slits
The conceptual design of the Next Generation 1° Field (NG1dF) instrument for the AAT 4-m and the Extreme Multiplex
Spectrograph (XMS) instrument for the Calar Alto 3.5-m exploits this promising combination of aperture and field of
view to allow slits to be placed on ~4000 targets. This estimated number assumes 1.5" width and 10" length; up to 10000
slits could be in principle targeted if the 10" slit width was reduced to a 1.5" aperture, with a few hundred such sky slots
to map the sky over the whole mask. The multiplex gain of the instrument would then be even greater. The estimate of
4000 targets also assumes that the spectra would have a length of 200 slit width images on the detector. The width and
length of the slits depends on the seeing so a higher spectral resolution and a larger number of sources can be achieved
with better seeing.
1° field: no vignetting
1.19° field: 50% vignetting
1.38° field: 100% vignetting
Spectrograph field
Fig. 1. The field of view of NG1dF for AAT 3.9-m, similar to that to XMS for the Calar Alto 3.5-m. The 1° field is divided
into four square subfields.
2.2 Spectrograph at prime-focus
To use the large 1° field or more, the spectrograph must be at the prime focus. This put some constrains on its
characteristics, mostly putting some limits on its weight and length. A unique spectrograph would easily be too large and
too heavy so an array of smaller spectrographs was chosen instead. Our design contains 4 spectrograph units in each of
NG1dF and XMS. Each unit has its own detector. A larger number of units would be used at a site of exceptional seeing
and/or a telescope with a larger field corrector. Figure 1 shows the present baseline design for the AAT. The subfields
are 100 mm wide at the corrector focus which corresponds to 26' on the sky. This size was designed for 2k x 2k
detectors. With 4k x 4k detectors, larger subfields may be possible.
Detector
Removable box
(one per band)
Mask
Fig. 2. The design of a single spectrograph for the NG1dF/XMS instrument; four of these are needed to cover the 1° field of
classical 4-m telescopes shown in Fig. 1. The box containing the disperser is changed when changing of band or
spectral resolution or for imaging.
While there is some vignetting outside the 1° field, there is still a lot of light getting through in the 4 corners of the
spectrograph so this region is not lost. With a proper tiling of the sky, some sources in the vignetted area can be observed
twice and the light added by software. This would increase the effective surface area of the field of view.
One difficulty with many spectrograph units is to place these units near each other to minimize the gaps in the field.
Ideally, all optics in a spectrograph unit would be smaller than the subfield width. This would permit to pack the units
tightly. This is achieved in our design by placing a field lens as near as possible to the input focal plane to bend the
beams toward the centre (fig. 2). Mechanically, the spectrograph can be made as one structure or each unit can be a
separate structure. A combination of both is also possible. While a unique structure would make the spectrograph more
rigid for a specific weight, it makes alignments more difficult.
2.3 Low cost spectrograph
For this concept to be practical, it is necessary that the price is maintained sufficiently low. A first part of the solution is
to avoid the complex mechanism and spectrograph shape that comes with reflective gratings. A transparent disperser
combining a transparent grating, as a grism or a VPH, with prisms permits to make the units straight (fig. 2) and makes it
possible to place optics very near the disperser which in turn reduces the size of the spectrograph and reduces the
aberrations. Different dispersers will have different prism angles and materials depending on the band and spectral
resolution. For low spectral resolution, a grism or a grism plus a prism would do. For high resolution, VPH glued to
prisms would be the preferred option.
The second part of the solution is to use low cost glasses. This however makes it difficult to design the spectrograph
achromatic. To resolve this problem, we take advantage of the need to change the disperser when changing of band. In
our solution, one or 2 lenses are changed with the disperser. These lenses can be made small and thin and would fit in a
small box with the disperser (fig. 2). A special care must be taken when designing them to avoid the need of tight
alignments of the disperser boxes which would increase the cost. One or more of the boxes can be made of lenses only
and used for imaging; alternately, the disperser alone can be replaced by some optics in each box.
2.4 Changing mechanism
To maintain a low cost, there must be as little mechanisms as possible. The basic concept is to use only one disperser per
night and to have it changed by hand during the day. It may however be necessary to have some imaging capability for
acquisition. If no practical alternative method can be found, it would be necessary to have a changing mechanism with 2
positions, most probably a slide.
The problem is different for the mask; many of them are necessary every night. The 2 main alternatives are a wheel or a
jukebox like mechanism as in GMOS. The wheel would support a smaller number of masks than the jukebox but is
simpler mechanically.
2.5 Spectral resolution
The basic concept is for a resolution of 10Ǻ between wavelengths of 0.7 µm and 0.9 µm with a 1.5" slit. We could then
use 2k x 2k CCDs with 24 µm pixels which gives a sampling of 2 pixels per 1.5" slit image. This sampling does not take
advantage of better seeing however. For 0.9" slits, 4k x 4k detectors are necessary. The resolution then becomes 6Ǻ with
the same design. Higher resolution are however possible by changing the disperser. The prisms associated with a high
resolution disperser would need to have a larger interior angle but the present angle is quite small so it is perfectly
possible to at least double the resolution.
Much higher resolutions are also possible but request some significant changes to the design. The camera and collimator
could not be maintained in a straight line; the camera would need to be at an angle. This is feasible with a spectrograph
that has no more than 6 units but would be problematic with a larger number of units where some are completely
encircled by other units. To have a sufficiently large bandwidth at high resolution, it would probably be necessary to
have a camera angle that can be changed. This would of course increase the complexity and the cost of the system.
2.6 Wavelength range
There is a choice of 2 bands in the present design, each with its own disperser+lenses box. Their wavelength ranges are
respectively 0.5 µm to 0.7 µm and 0.7 µm to 0.9 µm. There are then only 2 boxes in the basic design. It is however
possible to have other bands. One choice is to have a range of 0.7 µm to 1.0 µm instead of 0.9 µm with a resolution of
15Ǻ instead of 10Ǻ with 1.5" slits. Another would be to have 3 bands between 0.42 µm and 1.0 µm, for example 0.42
µm to 0.55 µm, 0.55 µm to 0.74 µm and 0.74 µm to 1.0 µm.
3. SCIENCE CASE
There are many science goals for an instrument of this sort, ranging from galaxy surveys for cosmology at low resolution
(R~400) to stellar radial velocity and abundance surveys at 10x higher resolution (R~4000). Here we concentrate on the
low resolution cosmological aspects which form our particular interest in the science from these instruments.
3.1 Emission and absorption line galaxy redshift surveys at z~0.7.
A prime cosmological goal for the NG1dF/XMS instruments is based on their ability to measure 4000 galaxy redshifts
per hour for i<21 absorption-line and i<22 emission-line galaxies at z~0.7 (see Fig. 3). 4000 emission/absorption
redshifts an hour means ~30000 redshifts a night or ~6 x106 galaxy redshifts in a 200 night survey. Such a survey could
cover 1000-2000 deg2 of sky and enable powerful new investigations of the clustering of galaxies to be made over a wide
range of scales (0.1-1000h-1Mpc).
A prime aim would be to measure the scale-length of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO) as detected in galaxy
clustering power spectra and correlation functions. These features are seen as an oscillation in the power spectrum and as
a spike in the galaxy correlation function. These features can be used as standard rods and allow tests of cosmological
models. In particular, such observations will allow us to probe the equation of state of the vacuum energy, p=wρ.
Currently, the spike in the correlation function is tentatively detected in the 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey of 250000 z~0.1
galaxies [1] and also in the SDSS redshift survey of ~75000 z~0.35 Luminous Red Galaxies [2]. In future bigger galaxy
surveys will be needed to measure the BAO scale at higher redshifts and hence track any evolution in the vacuum energy
equation of state with redshift. Instruments like NG1dF/XMS therefore will have a crucial role to play in the future of
observational cosmology.
There are enough galaxies at the magnitude limits quoted above to fill ~4000 NG1dF/XMS slits since galaxy count data
suggest that there are ~4000 galaxies per square degree at i<21 and ~9000 at i<22, 5000 of which will show emission
lines. The ~9000 absorption and emission line galaxies available in total will make it more possible to place slits on a
subset of ~4000 galaxies. The future for BAO studies is to identify systematics caused by non-linearity in galaxy power
spectra that may results in different scale-lengths being measured for different types of galaxy. The high multiplex of
NG1dF/XMS will, for example, mean that a choice will no longer have to be made between emission-line galaxies and
luminous red galaxies for BAO measurement since both can be observed simultaneously in the same volume and the
BAO results compared. Similar comparisons can be made as a function of morphology and luminosity class, given the
high numbers of galaxies available.
Other cosmological applications of redshift surveys containing millions of z~0.7 galaxies will include measuring the rate
of growth of structure using galaxy clustering redshift-space distortions. Here the flattening of galaxy clustering in
redshift-space caused by dynamical infall is used to provide a measure of the infall parameter β=Ω0.6/b and measuring β
at different redshifts gives the gravitational growth rate. This provides a test of Einstein’s gravity independently of
geometrical cosmological tests using standard candles and rods, such as BAO. Redshift distortion results can also be
used to give an estimate of the masses and hence mass-to-light ratios of galaxy group haloes in CDM models. These
allow new tests of the efficiency of the process of galaxy formation as a function of halo mass environment. There are
too many examples of other galaxy redshift survey-based projects to detail here. These include the vast array of results
that will be available on the topic of the dependence of the galaxy stellar mass and luminosity function on environment
and redshift.
3.2 Lyman break galaxy redshift surveys at z~3.
More ambitiously, it may be possible for 4-m telescopes to compete effectively on surveying the Universe of galaxies at
redshift, z~3. In 4x3hr exposures, spectra for ~4000 r<25 Lyman break galaxies at z~3 (fig. 4) can be measured,
producing 100000 z~3 galaxy redshifts in a 50 night survey. Although the exposure time is long, a single mask will
produce as many redshifts at z~3 as are currently known from larger telescopes. A prime scientific aim would then again
be to measure the BAO scale in the LBG clustering, allowing the first constraints on the dark energy equation of state at
z~3. Furthermore, measuring redshift space distortions in the galaxy clustering would give constraints on the gravity
model at z=3 and also allow the dependence of the halo M/L ratio on redshift to be estimated and hence the evolution
with time of the efficiency of the galaxy formation process. In terms of a survey plan that would include the lower
redshift z~0.7 galaxies discussed in Section 3.1, in a total survey time of 250 nights, flexible scheduling might allow the
50 nights with the best seeing to be used to observe fainter LBG targets with 1 arcsec wide slits and the remaining 200
nights could be used for the z~0.7 galaxy redshift survey where 1.5-2 arcsec wide slits might be used. This 250 night
survey plan might then realize redshifts for 100000 z~3 LBGs as well as for ~6 million z~0.7 galaxies.
Fig. 3. The exposure time of 1-2 hrs to measure spectra for i<21 galaxies is suggested from exposure times for LRGs with
the fibre-fed AAOmega spectrograph at the AAT. The figure shows the galaxy spectra measured by the AAOmega
spectrographs at ~5Angstrom resolution and degraded to the ~10Angstrom NG1dF/XMS resolution [3]. These spectra
are therefore typical of those that can be achieved with XMS/NG1dF; emission-line and absorption-line features are
clearly visible at this resolution.
3.3 Calibration of photometric redshifts
A prime use of galaxy surveys like both of those above will be the calibration of photometric redshifts. These are needed
to support satellite surveys such as SNAP and also EUCLID which is the new ESA dark energy mission resulting from
the merging of SPACE and DUNE [6]. For example, it has been suggested that up to ~100000 spectroscopic redshifts
may be needed to calibrate the large photometric redshift surveys planned in the case of the SNAP satellite. Large
numbers of galaxies are particularly needed where large galaxy redshift training sets are needed as in the case of
Artificial Neural Network (ANN) photometric redshift codes [5]. The NG1dF/XMS absorption and emission line galaxy
redshift surveys described above will be uniquely placed to satisfy this huge demand for spectroscopic redshifts for
photo-z calibration and would complement the work of these satellites, for example EUCLID would not observe galaxies
at a redshift smaller than 0.7.
3.4 Stellar velocity and abundance surveys
In its higher resolution mode (R~4000) NG1dF/XMS can also be used for a variety of other purposes. At low Galactic
latitudes and in the Galactic bulge, stars brighter than i=15 will have sky densities larger than 4000 per deg-2 and can
therefore be efficiently observed with this instrument. At these magnitudes, 1-2hr observations will yield an S/N per
Angstrom > 50 and thus allow stellar radial velocities and abundances of useful accuracy to be achieved. This will allow
Galactic archaeology projects searching for stellar streams in the Galactic bulge and thick disk to proceed. Although the
velocity accuracy in will not be high enough in nearby dwarf galaxies, stellar abundance studies will certainly be
possible in the higher resolution mode of NG1dF/XMS.
Fig. 4. Seven spectra of Lyman break galaxies at z~3 from a VLT VIMOS survey [4]. Two faint QSO spectra from the same
survey are also shown. These spectra taken with the VIMOS LR Blue grism have lower resolution (~20Angstroms) and
show that such surveys will be perfectly possible with the default 10Angstrom resolution of the NG1dF/XMS
spectrographs.
4. CONCLUSIONS
Clearly, spectrographs such as NG1dF/XMS have huge potential impact in terms of the significant science goals they
address. There are many ground-based optical and near infra-red imaging surveys coming up such as Pan-STARRS, VST
ATLAS+KIDS, ALHAMBRA/PAU, Dark Energy Survey, VISTA Hemisphere Survey and VIKING surveys and also
LSST. These will inevitably need spectroscopic follow-up and NG1dF is ideally designed to do this. This spectroscopic
follow-up will include the major science programs described above including the measurement of the BAO scale and the
measurement of the evolution of the gravitational growth rate. These address major science questions including the
nature of dark energy and its evolution and whether Einstein’s gravity can explain the observed growth of large-scale
structure. However NG1dF/XMS are not “niche instruments” because of the wide variety of science goals they can
pursue, of which we have only noted a few examples here.
A major driver is that these instruments can exploit already existing 4-m telescopes with large fields of view and
therefore this helps keep costs low. The modular spectrograph design is also aimed at being relatively low-cost as well as
maintaining high throughput over a wide field of view. The exact cost is the subject of the ongoing design studies but a
preliminary cost estimate (including manpower) is around £2m. The four 4kx4k CCD detectors and associated
controllers and Dewars comprise a large fraction (~1/3) of this cost.
We conclude that the future for classically designed 4-m telescopes with large fields may be bright if they are armed with
spectrographs such as NG1dF/XMS. Indeed, such telescope-instrument combinations may offer a very cost-effective
solution to pursuing the large-scale cosmological surveys that are needed to address the fundamental questions of the
dark energy and its evolution with redshift and one which is competitive scientifically with more ambitious projects such
as WFMOS and SKA.
REFERENCES
[1] Cole, S.M., et al., "The 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey: power-spectrum analysis of the final data set and cosmological
implications", MNRAS 362, 505 (2005).
[2] Eisenstein, D.J., et al, "Detection of the Baryon Acoustic Peak in the Large-Scale Correlation Function of SDSS
Luminous Red Galaxies", ApJ 633, 560 (2005).
[3] Bielby, R.M, Ross, N.P., Sawangwit, U., Shanks, T., et al, in prep. (2008).
[4] Bielby, R.M., Infante, L., Shanks, T., et al, in prep. (2008).
[5] Abdalla, F. B., Amara, A., Capak, P., Cypriano, E. S., Lahav, O., Rhodes, J., "Photometric redshifts for weak
lensing tomography from space: the role of optical and near infrared photometry", MNRAS 387, 969 (2008).
[6] Content, R., "Durham Optical Design of EUCLID, the Merged SPACE/DUNE ESA Dark Energy Mission", Proc.
SPIE 7010, TBD (2008).
|
0807.1946 | 2 | 0807 | 2008-07-15T05:23:14 | The estimate of kinetic powers of jets in FRII radio galaxies: existence of invisible components? | [
"astro-ph"
] | We investigate the total kinetic powers (L_j) and ages (t_age) of powerful jets in FR II radio galaxies by comparison of the dynamical model of expanding cocoons with observations. We select four FR II radio sources (Cygnus A, 3C 223, 3C 284, and 3C 219), for which the mass-density profiles of intracluster medium (ICM) are known in the literature. It is found that large fractions > 0.02 - 0.7 of the Eddington luminosity (L_Edd) are carried away as a kinetic power of jet. The upper limit of estimated 2 L_j / L_Edd are larger than unity (< 10) for some sources, suggesting a possibility of super-Eddington mass accretions. As a consequence of the large powers, we also find that the total energy stored in the cocoon (E_c) exceeds the energy derived from the minimum energy condition for the energy of radiating non-thermal electrons and magnetic fields (E_min): 4< E_c /E_min <310. This implies that most of the energy in cocoon is carried by invisible components such as thermal leptons (electron and positron) and/or protons. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
The estimate of kinetic powers of jets in FRII radio galaxies:
existence of invisible components?
Hirotaka Ito1, Motoki Kino2, Nozomu Kawakatu3, Naoki Isobe4, and Shoichi Yamada1,5
--
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
We investigate the total kinetic powers (Lj) and ages (tage) of powerful jets in
FR II radio galaxies by comparison of the dynamical model of expanding cocoons
with observations. We select four FR II radio sources (Cygnus A, 3C 223, 3C
284, and 3C 219), for which the mass-density profiles of intracluster medium
(ICM) are known in the literature. It is found that large fractions & 0.02− 0.7 of
the Eddington luminosity (LEdd) are carried away as a kinetic power of jet. The
upper limit of estimated 2Lj/LEdd are larger than unity (. 10) for some sources,
suggesting a possibility of super-Eddington mass accretions. As a consequence
of the large powers, we also find that the total energy stored in the cocoon (Ec)
exceeds the energy derived from the minimum energy condition for the energy of
radiating non-thermal electrons and magnetic fields (Emin): 4 < Ec/Emin < 310.
This implies that most of the energy in cocoon is carried by invisible components
such as thermal leptons (electron and positron) and/or protons.
Subject headings: radiation mechanisms: non-thermal -- X-rays: galaxies --
radio continuum: galaxies -- galaxies:
individual (Cygnus A, 3C 223, 3C 284,
3C 219)
1Science and Engineering, Waseda University, 3-4-1 Okubo, Shinjuku, Tokyo 169-8555, Japan
2ISAS/JAXA, 3-1-1 Yoshinodai, 229-8510 Sagamihara, Japan
3National Astronomical Observatory of Japan, 181-8588 Mitaka, Japan
4Cosmic Radiation Laboratory, Institute of Physical and Chemical Research, Wako, Saitama, Japan
351-0198
5Advanced Research Institute for Science & Engineering, Waseda University, 3-4-1 Okubo, Shinjuku,
Tokyo 169-8555, Japan
-- 2 --
1.
INTRODUCTION
Relativistic jets in active galactic nuclei (AGN) are a fundamental aspect of plasma
accretion onto supermassive black holes (SMBHs). Although the formation mechanism of
relativistic jets remains a longstanding problem, it is well established that they carry away
some fractions of the available accretion power in the form of collimated beam (e.g., Begelman
et al. 1984 for review). The total kinetic powers of AGN jets Lj is one of the most basic
physical quantities characterizing the jet. A lot of authors have investigated Lj in various
ways so far (e.g., Rawlings & Saunders 1991; Celotti & Fabian 1993; Willot et al. 1999). It
is, however, difficult to estimate Lj, since most of the observed emissions from AGN jets are
of non-thermal electron origin and it is hard to detect the electromagnetic signals from the
thermal and/or proton components. Hence, the free parameter describing the amount of the
invisible plasma components always lurks in the estimates of Lj based on the non-thermal
emissions.
The estimate of Lj for low-power Fanaroff-Riley I (FRI) radio galaxies has been mo-
tivated by the observations of "X-ray cavity" which is the region embedded in ICM with
the suppressed X-ray surface brightness and coincides with the radio lobe (Bohringer et al.
1993). The cavities (or cocoons) are supposed to be a direct evidence of the displacement of
the ambient ICM by the shocked jet matter. Dynamical models of cavities are a good tool,
since the invisible plasma components as well as non-thermal electrons play a role for ex-
pansions of cavities. For FR I sources, the total kinetic energy of the jet has been estimated
as
Ljtage ∼
γc
γc − 1
PcVc,
where tage, Pc, Vc, γc, are the source age, the pressure, the volume, the adiabatic index of
the cavity, respectively (Fabian et al. 2002; Allen et al. 2006). In these studies, however, the
thermal pressure of surrounding ICM (PICM) is substituted for the one in the cavity (i.e.,
Pc ∼ PICM). This assumption may be applied only to subsonic expansions.
On the other hand, the cocoon pressure of powerful Fanaroff-Riley class II (FRII) radio
galaxies is expected to be larger than that of the surrounding ICM, which is expressed as
Pc > PICM (Begelman & Cioffi 1989 hereafter BC89), and the cocoon of FR II radio galaxies
is likely to be expanding super-sonically. Then the substitution of ICM pressure for the
cocoon pressure is not justified. A new estimate of Lj for FR II radio galaxies by use of the
dynamical model of cocoon expansions is proposed by Kino & Kawakatu (2005) (hereafter
KK05), in which Lj and tage are derived from the comparison of the cocoon model with the
morphology of the cocoon obtained by radio observations. It should be stressed that Pc is
not assumed but solved in this model. Hence it can be applied even to the cocoons with
-- 3 --
Pc > PICM. So far, however, this estimate of Lj has been applied only to Cygnus A. The
expansion of the number of samples is evidently crucially important for exploring general
characteristics of the powerful AGN jets. For this purpose, we apply the method of KK05
to other bright FR II radio galaxies, for which the physical conditions of the associated ICM
have been estimated in the literature.
In the present work, we especially focus on the ratio of Lj/LEdd, where LEdd is the
Eddington luminosity of AGN, since Lj/LEdd is a more fundamental quantity than Lj from
the point of view of the jet formation physics. Another interesting quantity we examine in
this work is the ratio of the internal energy deposited in the cocoon (Ec) to the minimum
energy (Emin) obtained by the minimum energy condition for radiating non-thermal electrons
and magnetic fields (e.g., Miley 1980). Some of the previous works studying this quantity
(e.g., Hardcastle & Worrall 2000; Leahy & Gizani 2001) reported that the cocoon pressure
expected from the inferred Emin is smaller than the pressure of ambient matter, suggesting
the difference between Ec and Emin. due to the lack of minimum pressure against the pressure
of ambient medium. Although these studies obtained the lower limit of the ratio, it is the
value of Ec that is of greater importance.
According to a large sample of galaxies collected recently, the fraction of AGNs in all the
galaxies is suggested to be ∼ 20−40%, larger than previously thought (Kauffman et al. 2003;
Miller et al. 2003). The interest in AGNs is gaining momentum in the context of the co-
evolution of galaxies and their central black holes (e.g., Kawakatu et al. 2003, Granato et al.
2004; Di Matteo et al. 2005). AGN outflows in particular are likely to be a key ingredient in
this context (Silk & Rees 1998; Fabian 1999; King 2003). The AGN feedback by the outflows
may be also promising to explain the tight correlations between the ratio of the mass of SMBH
(MBH) to that of galactic bulge (Kormendy & Richstone 1995; Magorrian et al. 1998) and
the ratio of MBH and the stellar velocity-dispersion in the bulge (Ferrarese & Merritt 2000;
Tremaine et al. 2002). In this sense, a robust estimate of the basic quantities such as Lj/LEdd
and tage of radio loud AGNs at low z is an important first step for understanding the AGN
feedback processes in the universe.
The outline of the paper is as follows. In §2, the model of the expanding cocoon by
KK05 is briefly reviewed.
In §3, we explain how to extract the key quantities from the
observations of four nearby FR II radio galaxies, Cygnus A, 3C 223, 3C 284, and 3C 219,
which are required for the comparison with the model. We then estimate the total kinetic
power, Lj, and the dynamical ages, tage, in §4. Finally in §5, we summarize our results and
discuss some implications on the physics of AGN jet. Throughout the paper, we adopt a
cosmology with H0 = 71 km s−1, ΩM = 0.3, and ΩΛ = 0.7 (Spergel et al. 2003).
-- 4 --
2. COCOON MODEL
2.1. Basic equations
Based on BC89 and KK05, we briefly summarize the cocoon model we employ in the
following. We focus on the cocoon expansion in the over-pressured regime, namely Pc > Pa,
where Pc and Pa are the pressures of cocoon and ambient ICM, respectively. We approxi-
mately describe the expansion of cocoon by the following three equations: (1) the equation
of the motion along the jet axis, (2) the equation for the sideways expansion, and (3) the
energy equation. They are expressed, respectively, as
Lj
vj
= ρa(rh)v2
h(t)Ah(t),
Pc(t) = ρa(rc) vc(t)2,
dEc(t)
dt
+ Pc(t)
dVc(t)
dt
= 2Lj,
(1)
(2)
(3)
tmin
tmin
vh(t′)dt′ and rc(t) = R t
where vj, ρa, vh, vc, and Ah are the velocity of jet, the density of ambient medium, the advance
velocity of cocoon head, the velocity of sideways expansion, and the cross sectional area of
cocoon head, respectively. Here Ec = PcVc/( γc − 1) is the total internal energy deposited
in the cocoon, where γc is the specific heat ratio of the plasma inside cocoon. The cocoon
shape is approximated as a spheroid, and its volume is given as Vc(t) = (4π/3)rc(t)2rh(t).
The distance from the jet apex to the hot spot and the radius of cocoon body are obtained
from rh(t) = R t
vc(t′)dt′, respectively, and tmin is the initial
time of source evolution. Throughout this paper, we assume γc = 4/3, since the cocoon is
expected to be dominated by relativistic particles (Kino et al. 2007). In these equations we
also assume that the jet has a relativistic velocity (vj ∼ c) and that Lj is constant in time.
The mass density of ICM, ρa, is assumed to be given by ρa(r) = ¯ρa(r/r0)−α, where r0 and
¯ρa are the reference position and the ICM mass density at r0, respectively. We set r0 to be
rh(tage), where tage is the present age of cocoon, throughout this paper. A cartoon of the
cocoon model is illustrated in Fig. 1. In this paper, we have slightly improved the model of
BC89 and KK05 as follows: (i) a more accurate definition of Vc is employed, and (ii) the P dV
work, which is done by the cocoon against the contact discontinuity between the cocoon and
the shocked ambient medium, is taken into account. These corrections are necessary in the
following quantitative estimate of Lj. In fact, the estimated power is reduced by a factor of
∼ 50 from the value in KK05 for Cygnus A after taking account of the corrections (see §2.4
for details).
-- 5 --
The model parameters are Lj and t, and the unknown physical quantities are vh, vc, Pc,
and Ah. Since the number of unknown quantities is four, while that of basic equations is
three, an additional condition is required for the system of equations to be closed. Here we
assume that the cross sectional area of cocoon body Ac = πr2
c is given by Ac(t) ∝ tX and
treat X as a free parameter which is determined by the imposed condition. Once the value
of X is determined, we obtain vh, vc, Pc, and Ah as a function of Lj and t. It is worth noting
that the model is capable of producing various dynamics by tuning the value of X. For
example, the results of 2D relativistic hydrodynamical simulations by Scheck et al. (2002)
were reproduced fairly well in Kawakatu & Kino (2006).
Fig. 1. -- A cartoon of the employed model. The relativistic jet from FR II radio galaxy
interacts with ICM with a declining density. Most of the kinetic energy of jet is deposited
in the cocoon, which is then inflated by the internal energy.
2.2. Analytical solution
We assume that the physical quantities have a power-law time-dependence of the form
A = ¯A (t/tage)Y , where Y is the power-law index. Then the index and coefficient of vc, for
example, are determined as
vc(t) = ¯vc(cid:18) t
tage(cid:19)0.5X−1
=
¯A1/2
c
tage Cvc(cid:18) t
tage(cid:19)0.5X−1
.
(4)
From this relation and Eqs. (1)-(3), we obtain the following expressions:
-- 6 --
Pc(t) = ¯ρa¯v2
vh(Lj, t) =
Lj
¯ρa¯v2
c
Ah(Lj, t) =
Lj
vj ¯ρa¯v2
hCah(cid:18) ¯vh
,
cCpc(cid:18) ¯vc
v0(cid:19)−α(cid:18) t
tage(cid:19)X(1−0.5α)−2
v0(cid:19)α(cid:18) t
tage(cid:19)X(−2+0.5α)+2
tage(cid:19)X(α−2)(−2+0.5α)+3α−4
¯AcCvh(cid:18) ¯vc
v0(cid:19)α(cid:18) t
,
(5)
(6)
(7)
,
where Cvh = 0.75(γc − 1)(0.5X)−α[3 − (2 − 0.5α)X]/[X(−1 + 0.5α)(γc − 1) + 3γc − 2],
Cvc = 0.5X/π1/2, Cpc = (0.5X)α, and Cah = [X(−2 + 0.5α) + 3]−α, and v0 ≡ rh(tage)/tage
corresponds to the head speed assumed to be constant in time. The difference in Cvh obtained
here from that in KK05 is due to the correction made in Eq. (3). We assume the conditions
of 0.5X > 0 and X(−2 + 0.5α) + 3 > 0, which ensure that the contribution at tmin to the
integrations of rh and rc is small enough. The cases that we focus on in §3 clearly satisfy
these conditions.
2.3. Determination of X
As mentioned in §2.1, an additional condition that determines the free parameter X
is required for the system of equations to be closed.
In the pioneering study of BC89,
Ah(t) = const was assumed. However, as can be confirmed from numerical simulations (e.g.,
Cioffi & Blondin 1992; Scheck et al. 2002), it is obvious that this condition is unlikely to
hold for long-term evolutions from pc to Mpc scales. In this paper, we consider the following
two conditions, which seem more reasonable and equally possible, in determining X:
• Constant aspect ratio (Case I)
The aspect ratio of cocoon, R = rc/rh, is assumed to be constant in time. This corre-
sponds to the widely-discussed self-similar evolution (Begelman 1996; Komissarov & Falle
1997; Kaiser & Alexander 1997; Bicknell et al. 1997). Since the time dependence of R
is given by R(t) ∝ t[X(2.5−0.5α)−3], we obtain X = 6/(5 − α) in this case.
• Constant opening angle (Case II)
The opening angle, θ = tan−1(A1/2
h /π1/2rh) (see Fig. 1), is assumed to be constant in
time. Although there has been no previous work that has employed this condition, it
-- 7 --
seems to be reasonable when the jet is precessing with a constant pitch angle. Since the
time dependence of tanθ is given by tanθ(t) ∝ t[0.25X(α−4)2+1.5α−5], X = (20− 6α)/(4−
α)2 is obtained for this case.
It should be emphasized here that these two independent conditions lead to the solutions
that describe quite similar dynamical evolutions as long as the range of α listed in Table
If the constant opening angle
1 is adopted (1 ≤ α ≤ 2). This can be seen as follows.
is imposed (Case II), the evolution of the aspect ratio is obtained as R(t) ∝ t(2−α)/(4−α)2
.
It is easy to confirm its very weak time dependence, since the power-law index is limited
to the range 0 ≤ (2 − α)/(4 − α)2 ≤ 1/9. Just in the same way, if the constant aspect
ratio is adopted (Case I), we find again a very weak time dependence of the opening angle,
tanθ(t) ∝ t(α−2)/[2(5−α)], with the power-law index being −1/8 ≤ (α − 2)/[2(5 − α)] ≤ 0.
As a consequence of this small difference between the two solutions, the corresponding
values of X also show only a slight difference. For example, when a typical value α = 1.5 is
taken, we obtain X = 12/7 ∼ 1.71 and X = 1.76 for Case I and Case II, respectively. Hence,
the estimated Lj and tage based on these two sets of solutions also do not vary much, either.
Indeed, for the given values of rh, Ah, and R, the derived Lj and tage only differ by a factor
of ∼ 1.7 and ∼ 0.83, respectively, between the two cases for α = 1.5. It is worth noting that
for α = 2, which corresponds to the to 3C 219 (Table 1), the two conditions give the same
value of X = 2 and, as a result, the solutions are identical. Since only a slight change is
found between the two cases, we focus on the widely-discussed self-similar solution (Case I)
in the following.
2.4.
Improvements from KK05
In the present study, we have improved the energy equation given in KK05 for more
accurate quantitative estimations of Lj and tage. As mentioned in §2.1, the resultant change
in the derived Lj turns out to be rather large. Here we explain the reasons for this discrepancy
more in detail.
As mentioned in §2.1, we have (i) modified dVc/dt and (ii) included the P dV term
(3). As for (i), the main flaw in KK05 is the fact that they did not take into
in Eq.
account the sideways expansion in the growth of Vc. In fact, they employed the equation,
dVc/dt = 2πr2
cvh + 2πrcrhvc],
which is adopted in the present study. As for (ii), it was assumed that all injected energy
is converted to internal energy (namely, Ec = 2Ljtage) in KK05.
it is obvious, however,
that a part of the injected energy is consumed for expansions and the P dV work should be
c vh, whereas a more accurate expression is dVc/dt = (4/3)[πr2
-- 8 --
included, particularly for quantitative estimations. As found in §2.2, these corrections are
reflected only in the numerical factor Cvh in Eq. (6). The value of Cvh is reduced by a factor
of ∼ 3.5 owing to (i) and another factor of ∼ 2 due to (ii) and, hence, by a factor of ∼ 7 as a
whole. For a given geometry of cocoon (rh, Ah, and R) and ambient density profile (ρa and
vh and tage ∝ C −1
α), the derived power and age scale with the numerical factor as Lj ∝ C2
vh ,
respectively. As a result, KK05 overestimated Lj by a factor of ∼ 50. On the other hand,
tage was underestimated by a factor of ∼ 0.14, which led to the overestimation of Ec by a
factor of ∼ 14, since the latter is obtained as Ec = 2Ljtage in KK05. It is also worthy to
note that in the present study the following relation holds: Ec ≃ Ljtage. The difference of
the factor ∼ 2 arises from the fact that about a half of the injected energy is used for the
P dV work.
3. EXTRACTION OF THE KEY QUANTITIES FROM THE
OBSERVATIONS
In determining Lj and tage, we essentially follow the same procedure taken in KK05. In
this section, we explain in detail how to extract the key quantities utilized in the model from
the observations.
3.1.
ICM quantities
As for the mass-density profiles (ρa) and pressures (Pa) of ICM, we adopt the values given
in the literature (Reynolds & Fabian (1996); Smith et al. (2002) for Cygnus A, Croston et al.
(2004) for 3C 223 and 3C 284, and Hardcastle & Worrall (1999) for 3C 219). In these papers,
the X-ray surface brightness distribution of ICM was fitted by the isothermal β-model, which
takes the form of ρ(r) = ρcore[1 + (r/rcore)2]−3β/2 (Cavaliere & Fusco-Femiano 1978), where
ρcore and rcore are the core radius and density of the ICM, respectively. Since we employ
the density profile of ρa(r) = ¯ρa(r/rh)−α in our model, a power-law approximation of the
β-model is necessary. In the present study, we determine ¯ρa = ρa(rh) and α from the β-
model as follows. The determination of ¯ρa is done simply by equating it with the density in
the β-model at the corresponding radius rh, namely ¯ρa = ρcore[1 + (rh/rcore)2]−3β/2. In the
case of rh ≫ rcore, it is clear that α can be approximated by 3β. Only Cygnus A satisfies
this condition, though. For the rest of the sources, rh is comparable to rcore: rcore ∼ 340
kpc, 210 kpc, and 90 kpc for 3C 223, 3C 284, and 3C 219, respectively. It is obvious that
the above approximation of α ≈ 3β would cause an overestimation of density gradient for
these cases. Instead α should be taken to be a typical value in the ICM region swept by the
-- 9 --
expanding cocoon. Here we determine α by requiring that ρa(r) should coincide with the
density in the β-model at r = 0.5rh in addition to r = rh. Although there is no compelling
reason for the choice of r = 0.5rh, the estimations of Lj and tage are affected little by this
uncertainty (§4.1). Once ρa is given, Pa is obtained by the equation of state, which is written
as Pa(r) = kB Ta
ρa(r), where Ta and µ = 0.6 are the temperature and mean molecular weight
µmH
of ICM, respectively, and mH is the mass of hydrogen. We adopt the temperature used in
the β-model, ignoring the radial dependence of Ta as usual. In Table 1, we list the values of
ρa and Pa at r = rh and α for each source.
3.2.
rh and Ah
In Fig. 3, we show the VLA images of Cygnus A (Perley et al. 1984), 3C 223 (Leahy & Perley
1991), 3C 284 (Leahy et al. 1986), and 3C 219 (Clarke et al. 1992) in logarithmic scale. Con-
tours in linear scale are also displayed to determine the position of hot spot accurately. The
overlaid straight lines that cross each other at right angle on the hot spot are the lines we
use to measure rh and Ah. For simplicity, we neglect the projection effect of rh, which would
be at most a factor of a few if we believe the unified model of AGN (Urry & Padovani 1995).
Ah is measured as a cross-sectional area of the radio lobe at the position of the hot spot. rh
and Ah for each source are summarized in Table 1.
It should be noted that the plasma just around the hot spot is very fresh in the sense
that a significant synchrotron cooling is absent. Hence, the effect of radiative cooling does
not introduce large ambiguity in the estimation of Ah. The adiabatic cooling, on the other
hand, is not expected to cause any problem in the estimation for the following reason. Since
h /cs, where cs = c/√3 is
the sound crossing time in the head region of the cocoon, ∼ A1/2
the sound speed, is much shorter than the age of the cocoon, we can regard the head region
to be uniform to the lowest order. Hence, the adiabatic cooling, if any, would decrease the
surface brightness gradually as the distance from the hot spot increases. Contrary to this,
the observed radio images show a sharp decline of the surface brightness at the outer edge,
which is most naturally interpreted as the existence of the periphery of cocoon head there.
Next we address the issue in determining Ah that arises from multiple hot spots. Double
hot spots are actually observed in the radio lobes of Cygnus A (see, e.g., Carilli & Barthel
1996).
In determining Ah, we adopt the "disconnected-jet" model by Cox et al. (1991)
to Cygnus A. The double hot spots are referred to as primary and secondary as follows.
The primary hot spot is more compact and located in the inner part of the lobe, whereas
the secondary spot is more diffuse and brighter and located in the outer part of the lobe.
According to the disconnected-jet model, double hot spots are produced by the sudden
-- 10 --
change of the jet-orientation, or the disconnection, which leads to the termination of energy
supply to the original shock and the generation of a new jet. While the primary hot spot is
produced by the terminal shock in the new jet, the secondary hot spot remains as a relic in
the original jet. The schematic picture of the model is illustrated in Fig. 2. Since the primary
hot spot is predicted to be much younger than the source age, we employ the position of
the secondary hot spot to determine Ah. We will discuss this point more in detail in the
following.
The age of Cygnus A is roughly estimated to be tage ≈ rh/βhsc ≈ 2.0 × 107(βhs/10−2)−1
yr, where βhsc is the advance velocity of the hot spot. On the other hand, since the primary
hot spot is observed simultaneously with the secondary hot spot, its age should be younger
than the duration, tdur, in which the secondary spot is bright. tdur is expressed as a sum of
the time up to the shut-off of the energy supply from the disconnected-jet to the spot, tdis,
and the cooling time, tcool:
tdur = tdis + tcool ≈ max(tdis, tcool).
(8)
The cooling time is evaluated as tcool = min(tsyn, tad), where tsyn and tad are the synchrotron
cooling timescale and the adiabatic expansion timescale, respectively. A typical value of tsyn
at the hot spot is estimated as tsyn ≈ 1.0 × 106(B/10−4G)−3/2(ν/1 GHz)−1/3 yr, whilst tad is
given by tad ≈ rhs/cs = 5.6 × 103(rhs/1kpc) yr, where rhs is the size of the hot spot. These
estimates lead to tcool = tad for the secondary hot spot. On the other hand, tdis is given
by tdis = rdis/vj, where rdis is the distance from the tail to the hot spot in the disconnected
jet. Although we do not know rdis from observations, we can at least put the upper limit as
rh > rdis. We then obtain tdis < 2.0× 105(rh/60 kpc)(vj/c)−1 yr. Hence, from Eq. (8), we see
that tdur is in the range ∼ 5× 103 − 2× 105 yr. From these estimates, it is obtained that the
age of the primary hot spot only makes up a small fraction of its whole lifetime. Therefore,
we adopt the secondary spot for the determination of Ah, which reflects the whole evolution
of the cocoon (Fig. 3).
3.3. R
In contrast to rh and Ah, it is difficult to measure the aspect ratio of cocoon, R, from the
VLA radio images, since the cocoon emission from the region far away from the hot spot is
very dim at GHz frequency because of the synchrotron cooling (see Fig. 3). It is well known
that this cooling effect can be used to infer the age of radio galaxy (the spectral ageing
method, e.g., Carilli et al. 1991). As one utilizes lower frequencies, however, the cocoon
image is expected to be thicker, since lower-energy electrons have longer synchrotron cooling
-- 11 --
Fig. 2. -- A cartoon around the double hot spots in the "disconnected-jet" model. As a result
of altering orientation, jet becomes disconnected and forms the primary and the secondary
hot spot which are the location of the present and the previous terminal shock, respectively.
times (e.g., Carilli and Barthel 1996). In fact, a few authors have reported the existence of
prolate cocoons, based on the observations at a relatively low radio frequency (610 MHz)
band (e.g., Readhead et al. 1996). It is mentioned, however, that little attention has been
paid to observational features concerning the structure of cocoons so far.
On the other hand, theoretical studies of jet propagation and cocoon formation with
multi-dimensional hydrodynamic simulations clearly support the existence of cocoon for
reasonably light beams going through surrounding ICM (Scheck et al. 2002; Aloy et al. 2000;
Gomez et al. 1997; Komissarov & Falle 1997; Mioduszewski et al. 1997). The intensity maps
of the synchrotron emissivities obtained in these hydrodynamical simulations well reproduce
the double lobe structures as observed (e.g., Fig. 10 in Scheck et al. 2002).
It seems
natural, therefore, to suppose that cocoons are commonly produced, although there is a
room for further observational investigations. In the present study, we explore a wide range
of 0.5 < R < 1 in order to take account of the large ambiguity on the shape of cocoon.
It is worthwhile to note in this respect that the existence of cocoon can be confirmed for
Cygnus A in the Chandra image (Wilson et al. 2000, 2006) and that the obtained aspect
ratio ∼ 0.5 − 0.7 lies in the range explored in this paper.
-- 12 --
4. RESULTS
4.1. Total kinetic power and dynamical age
The resultant Lj and tage are displayed in Figs. 4, 5, 6, and 7. Since most of the radio
sources show asymmetries in the pair of lobes, we analyze each lobe independently. Three
oblique lines in these figures are the obtained Lj and tage for different α's, and their ranges
reflect the uncertainty in R. The thick solid line shows the result for the parameter set listed
in Table 1. The other two lines correspond to the results obtained by varying α by ±0.5.
From the figures, it is confirmed that the results are rather insensitive to the value α. In
each line, the power and age depend on the aspect ratio R as Lj ∝ R2α−8 and tage ∝ R4−α,
and, therefore, satisfy Lj ∝ t−2
age. Since α does not exceed 4 in any of the four sources, a
lower aspect ratio corresponds to a higher power with a lower age. It should be noted that
the uncertainty in the absolute values of ρa and Pa is not crucial, since Pa is used only to
judge whether the over-pressure condition is satisfied or not, and the dependence of Lj and
tage on ρa is rather weak, Lj ∝ ρa and tage ∝ ρ0
a. The line outside the shaded region must
be discarded, since the over-pressure condition is violated. The Eddington luminosity, LEdd,
of each source is also shown in these figures for comparison. In Table 3, we summarize the
allowed values of Lj and tage and other relevant physical parameters of cocoon obtained for
the parameter set listed in Table 1.
Cygnus A is one of the vastly studied nearby FR II radio galaxies. Tadhunter et al.
(2003) estimated the SMBH mass of Cygnus A as 2.5× 109M⊙, based on the gas kinematics
in the narrow-line region. Its linear size is measured as rh = 70 kpc for the western jet and
rh = 60 kpc for the eastern jet. From the employed values of rh and Ah, the power and age
are obtained as Lj = (0.35 − 1.1) × 1046 ergs s−1 and tage = 30 − 53 Myr for the western
jet and Lj = (0.4 − 2.6) × 1046 ergs s−1 and tage = 19 − 47 Myr for the eastern jet. No
significant difference is seen between the two jets, and we interpret that the actual age lies
in these ranges. Note that Lj is decreased and tage is increased from those in KK05 by the
improvement of Vc and the inclusion of P dV work. In fact, while Lj = 1.3×1048 ergs s−1 and
tage = 2.6 Myr were obtained in KK05, we find Lj = 2.6 × 1046 ergs s−1 and tage = 19 Myr
in this paper when the identical values of rh = 60 kpc, Ah = 150 kpc2, and R = 0.5 are
employed.
3C 223 has radio lobes that extend up to rh = 340 kpc in both sides.
Its SMBH
mass is estimated as 1.4 × 108M⊙ by Woo & Urry (2002), based on the observed stellar
velocity dispersions. As can be seen in Fig. 3, 3C 223 has asymmetry in Ah. While a well
developed cocoon head is seen at the northern hot spot (Ah = 4300 kpc2), the cocoon head
at the southern hot spot is quite compact (Ah = 1800 kpc2). Reflecting this asymmetry,
-- 13 --
the obtained power and age show quite large difference: Lj = (0.15 − 2.9) × 1046 ergs s−1
and tage = 140 − 610 Myr for the northern jet, and Lj = (0.71 − 2.0) × 1045 ergs s−1 and
tage = 330 − 560 Myr for the southern jet.
3C 284 shows asymmetry both in rh and Ah. While rh and Ah in the western lobe are
estimated as 380 kpc and 6200 kpc2, respectively, the corresponding values for the eastern
lobe are 260 kpc and 4600 kpc2. The obtained power and age are Lj = (0.1 − 3.6) ×
1046 ergs s−1 and tage = 100−630 Myr for the western jet and Lj = (0.03−1.8)×1047 ergs s−1
and tage = 32 − 260 Myr for the eastern jet. Since there is no estimate of the SMBH mass
of 3C 284 in the literature, we derive the mass from the B-band magnitude of the buldge
estimated in Shi et al. (2005). By using the equation in Marchesini et al. (2004) which gives
the correlation of the B-band magnitude with the BH mass, we obtain MBH = 8.2 × 108M⊙.
In the case of 3C 219, we only analyze the jet on the western side, since the eastern lobe
shows severe deformation (see Fig. 3). We could not determine Ah on the eastern side from
its morphology. The central SMBH mass for 3C 219 is estimated by Marchesini et al. (2004)
as 6.3 × 108 M⊙. rh and Ah of the western lobe are measured as 210 kpc and 5000 kpc2.
From these values, the kinetic power and age are obtained as Lj = (0.26−4.3)×1047 ergs s−1
and tage = 37 − 150 Myr, respectively.
Large asymmetry between the pair of lobes is observed especially in 3C 223 and 3C
284, and 3C 219. Since it seems natural to suppose that the jet properties are intrinsically
symmetric and the power and age are identical on both sides, we expect that the asymmetry
in the pair of lobes is due to the asymmetry and/or inhomogeneity in the ICM density
profiles. Although this is an interesting subject, a further pursuit is beyond the scope of the
present study. Here we assume that the actual values of Lj and tage are lying in the ranges
obtained from both lobes.
In Table 3 (column 4), the total kinetic powers of jet normalized by the corresponding
Eddington luminosity, 2Lj/LEdd, are displayed.
It can be seen that 2Lj/LEdd takes quite
high values ranging from ∼ 0.02 to ∼ 10. In exploring the physical relations between the
accretion power and the outflow, the total kinetic power of jet normalized by the Eddington
luminosity, 2Lj/LEdd, is one of the most fundamental parameters. We will return to this
issue in §5.1.
4.2. Total internal energy vs. minimum energy
It is intriguing to compare the internal energy, Ec, deposited in the cocoon with the
widely discussed energy, Emin, obtained from the minimum energy condition (e.g., Miley
-- 14 --
1980). Ec is linearly proportional to the total energy injected in the cocoon (2Ljtage) and
is approximately given as Ec ≃ Ljtage. The dependence on the aspect ratio is given by
Ec ∝ Ljtage ∝ L1/2
j ∝ Rα−4 (§4.1). Hence, a smaller aspect ratio (or, equivalently, a larger
power) corresponds to a larger internal energy. Emin is the minimum value of the total energy
(the sum of the energies in radiating non-thermal electrons and magnetic fields) required for
a given synchrotron luminosity and is evaluated as
Emin =
7
24π
V 3/7
R h12π1/2f (αR)(ν0.5−αR
min − ν0.5−αR
max
)ναRLνi4/7
ergs,
(9)
where VR is the volume of the emitting region, αR is the spectral index of the synchrotron
emission, and Lν is the synchrotron luminosity measured at frequency ν, and νmin and νmax
are the lower and higher cut-offs in the synchrotron emission, respectively. f (αR) is a function
of spectral index αR which is given as
f (αR) ≃
3.16 × 1012(0.145)αR(2αR + 1)Γ( αR
6)Γ( αR
(2αR − 1)Γ( αR
6 )Γ( αR
2 + 11
2 + 1
2 + 1)
2 + 3
2)
,
where Γ is the Gamma function (see, e.g., Longair 1994).
The values of the spectral index αR at the low frequency band (178 -- 750 MHz) and the
flux density, Fν, at 178MHz are taken from Table 1 in Hardcastle et al. (1998). From the
employed values of Fν, the synchrotron luminosities are calculated as Lν = 4πd2
LFν, where dL
is the luminosity distance. Although Lν is the sum of the luminosity from lobes, jets and hot
spots, no significant overestimate of Lν is expected because the radio emission is dominated
by the lobe-component for most of FRII sources (Bridle et al. 1994; Hardcastle et al. 1998).
The employed values of αR, Lν and other relevant quantities are summarized in Table 2.
Here we neglect the second term in Eq. (9) in deriving Emin, since αR > 0.5 is satisfied in all
sources. The lower cut-off frequency νmin is taken as 104 Hz. We will comment on this value
in the next paragraph. As noted in §3.3, although GHz radio images do not show a cocoon-
shape clearly and only a pair of lobes can be seen, it is known that radio images at lower
frequencies reflect the cocoon shape more closely (e.g., Readhead et al. 1996; Carilli et al.
1991) because of the absence of efficient radiative coolings. Since we utilize a relatively
low frequency (178MHz) band, the volume of the emission region can be approximated as
VR ∼ Vc. Here we employ the median value of R, i.e. R = 0.75, in evaluating VR. We define
the ratio of Ec to Emin as ηc:
ηc ≡
Ec
Emin
.
(10)
The obtained values of Emin, Ec, and ηc are summarized in Table 3. We find that Ec is larger
than Emin and ηc is in the range of 4 < ηc < 310. This implies that there is a substantial
-- 15 --
deviation from the minimum energy condition. We will discuss this topic more in detail in
§5.2.
Lastly, we comment on the reliability of ηc. The lower cut-off frequency, νmin, is one
of the ingredients, which introduce uncertainties in ηc because it is difficult to determine
by radio observations. The value employed above is obtained from the following relation
νmin ≈ 104 (B/10−5 G)(γe,min/10)2 Hz, where γe,min is the minimum Lorentz factor of non-
thermal electrons. Note that the the resultant Emin does not change significantly by the
uncertainty in νmin because of its weak dependence. For example, when a typical value
of αR = 0.8 is employed Emin ∝ (νmin/104 Hz)6/35. It should be also mentioned that the
difference between the actual emission volume and the employed one, which we do not expect
to vary by orders, does not affect our result, since the dependence of Emin on the emission
volume VR is weak, Emin ∝ V 3/7
R . Hence the precise determination of the latter is not
necessary.
4.3. On the estimation of Lj and Ec
4.3.1. Upper limits and lower limits
It is important to consider the validity of the over-pressure condition (i.e. Pc > Pa),
since the lower limits of Lj and Ec are determined by this condition in most cases (see Figs.
4-7).
In our model, a larger Pc corresponds to a smaller R. Though we explore a wide
range of R (0.5 ∼ 1), it is intuitively more likely that R is smaller than unity, that is, the
cocoon is prolate rather than spherical. Hence, the results of our analysis suggest that the
sources examined in the present study are likely to be over-pressured indeed. Incidentally,
the prolate shape of cocoon is endorsed by the fact that independent age estimations of
Cygnus A (Carilli et al. 1991) and 3C 284 (Alexander & Leahy 1987) based on the spectral
ageing method are more consistent with the results for the aspect ratio of 0.5 than for 1.0.
(Unfortunately, the age estimations are not available for 3C 223 and 3C 219 in the literature).
In all cases, the maximum values of Lj and Ec correspond to the minimum value of R
(Lj ∝ R2α−8). Though R = 0.5 is chosen as the lower limit in the present study (§3.3),
the possibility of even smaller aspect ratios cannot be ruled out, since the radius of cocoon
body rc cannot be constrained very well from the radio images. It is emphasized again that
smaller values of R predict larger Lj and Ec.
-- 16 --
4.3.2. Kinetic energy in the cocoon
We have so far neglected the kinetic energy of bulk flows in the cocoon, assuming that
the internal energy is dominated over the kinetic energy. This may be justified by the fact
that the cocoon is filled with shocked jet matter, which are expected to flow subsonically.
It is, however, important to estimate the possible changes in Lj and Ec that the inclusion
of the kinetic energy in Eq. (3) (energy equation) may make, since our results are rather
sensitive to the changes in the energy equation (see the discussion in §2.4). Although the
lack of our knowledge on the mass deposited in the cocoon makes it difficult to estimate the
kinetic energy quantitatively, the changes in Lj and Ec are not significant for the conclusion
of the paper even in the case, where the kinetic energy is comparable to the internal energy,
as shown shortly.
Just as in §2.4, the modification in energy equation is reflected in the value of the
numerical factor Cvh of Eq. (6). Note that Cvh depends linearly on the ratio of the total
internal energy to the total injected energy, ǫ ≡ Ec/(2Ljtage), which is ∼ 1/2 in the present
study, since roughly a half of the injected energy is consumed for the P dV work. The
inclusion of the kinetic energy modifies ǫ as ǫ ∼ 1/(2 + f ), where f is defined as the ratio of
the kinetic energy to the internal energy and Cvh is reduced from the value obtained in the
present study by a factor of ∼ 2/(2 + f ). It is hence found that even if the kinetic energy
is as large as the internal energy, namely f ∼ 1, Lj(∝ C2
vh) and Ec(∝ Cvh) are reduced only
by factors of ∼ 4/9 and ∼ 2/3, respectively. The inclusion of the kinetic energy, therefore,
does not change the conclusion of this paper.
5. SUMMARY AND DISCUSSIONS
In this paper we have investigated the total kinetic power and age of powerful FR II
jets. We have selected four FR II radio galaxies (Cygnus A, 3C 223, 3C 284, and 3C 219),
for which the surrounding ICM densities and pressures are known in the literature. Below
we summarize our main results.
(I) Large fractions of the Eddington power in the range of & 0.02− 0.7 are carried away
as a kinetic power of jet in the FR II sources.
(II) The energy deposited in the cocoon, Ec, exceeds the minimum energy, Emin, by a
factor of 4 − 310.
Although our results allow a wide range of Lj and Ec, interesting implications can still
be obtained and will be discussed below. In §5.1., we address some issues concerning the
-- 17 --
ratio of Lj to LEdd by referring to the studies of X-ray binaries. In §5.2., the energetics in
the cocoon is constrained from the obtained ηc.
5.1. Lj/LEdd
Postulating that the relativistic jet is powered by the release of gravitational energy
(Lacc) of accreting matter (e.g., Marscher et al. 2002), the jet power can be expressed as
2Lj = ǫjLacc, where ǫj is the efficiency of energy conversion (0 < ǫj < 1). Hence, 2Lj/LEdd
gives the minimum mass accretion rate normalized by the Eddington mass accretion rate.
Our results then suggest that quite high mass accretion rates, at least above 0.02LEdd, are
required to produce FRII radio sources. Moreover, since 10 & 2Lj/LEdd & 0.65 is predicted
for 3C 219, some FRII radio sources may have super-Eddington mass accretion rates. The
theory of accretion disk predicts that the accretion disk of these objects is optically-thick and
called the slim-disk (e.g., Abramowicz et al. 1988). From three distinctive X-ray properties
(the large photon index Γ & 2, rapid variability and soft X-ray excess), narrow line Seyfert
1 galaxies (NLS1s) are considered to be super-Eddington objects and, therefore, are inferred
to have a slim-disk (e.g., Pounds et al. 1995; Boller et al. 1996; Mineshige et al. 2000;
Collin & Kawaguchi 2004; Shemmer et al. 2006). If 3C 219 is indeed super-Eddington, it is
expected to show the above mentioned X-ray features like NLS1s. Note, however, that 3C
219 has a relatively hard X-ray spectrum with Γ = 1.58 < 2 (Shi et al. 2005), and thus the
physical state of the accretion disk in 3C 219 could be different from those in NLS1s.
In order to explore the nature of the accretion disk in 3C 219, we compare the char-
acteristics of AGNs with those of X-ray binaries (XRB), since both of them have common
physical processes such as disk accretions, relativistic jets, and quenching of these jets (e.g.,
Heinz & Sunyaev 2003; Ho 2005; McHardy et al. 2006). Thanks to their much shorter dy-
namical timescales, XRBs in various states have been observed in great detail and are found
to occupy particular X-ray spectral states (Fender et al. 2004; Remillard & McClintock 2006
for a review) as follows;
(i) Lacc/LEdd . 0.01 (low/hard state: LS),
(ii) 0.01 . Lacc/LEdd . 0.3 (high/soft state: HS),
(iii) Lacc/LEdd & 0.3 (very high state: VHS).
State (i) is usually accompanied by a jet. For Lacc/LEdd > 0.01, the radio emission
is quenched in state (ii), while in state (iii), the soft VHS, which has an X-ray spectrum
dominated by a steep power-law component (photon index Γ > 2), is radio quiet and the
-- 18 --
hard VHS and/or the transition from the hard VHS to the soft VHS is accompanied by
relativistic ejection events.
If the analogy between XRBs and AGNs holds, NLS1s may be in the soft VHS, since
many NLS1s have a steep power-law component and high Eddington ratios > 0.3 (e.g., Collin
& Kawaguchi 2004), that is, higher than the upper limit set by the stability of the Shakura
& Sunyaev (1973) disk (Shakura & Sunyaev 1973). On the other hand, 3C 219 (FR II) may
correspond to the hard VHS and/or the transition state because it has hard X-ray spectra
and high Eddington luminosities. In order to judge whether AGNs are scaled-up XRBs, it is
essential to confirm that radio loud AGNs actually have the states analogous to the spectral
states (especially VHS) in XRBs1.
The co-evolution of a central black hole (BH) and its host galaxy together with AGN
feedbacks have been intensively studied in various ways (e.g., Silk & Rees 1998; Di Matteo
et al. 2003; Granato et al. 2004). The intensive surveys of QSOs show that the number
density of QSOs is peaked at z ≈ 2 (Fan et al. 2001). The existence of QSOs at z & 2 with
a central BH of a mass smaller than predicted from the bulge BH-mass relation is naturally
expected in the build-up of SMBHs toward z ≈ 2. For the exploration of the co-evolution
processes, dusty spheroidal galaxies (e.g., galaxies emitting sub-millimeter radiations and
ultra-luminous infrared galaxies) are the ones to be scrutinized, since the dusty-gas in them
is one of the key quantities for the co-evolution. Kawakatu et al. (2003) pointed out the
possibility of radio loud AGNs at high-z being QSOs in the early evolution phase (we call
them proto-QSOs) that contain a growing BH. It is, however, difficult to explore the nature
of proto-QSOs at high-z by observations in optical and X-ray bands owing to severe dust-
absorptions. In contrast, the estimate of Lj and tage presented in this work is applicable even
to high-z sources (e.g., Schmidt et al. 2006) without being suffered from the dust extinction.
Therefore, the estimate of Lj/LEdd based on the cocoon dynamics is a potential new powerful
tool to discover proto-QSOs among high-z radio loud AGNs.
5.2. The energetics
Lastly, we discuss the energetics in the cocoon. Summing up in advance, the total
internal energy of invisible components such as thermal leptons and/or protons tends to be
larger than those of radiating non-thermal electrons and magnetic fields. Ec is expressed by
components as Ec = (Ue + UB + Uinv)Vc, where Ue, UB, and Uinv are the energy densities
1It has been well established that low-luminosity AGNs are the high-mass counterpart of XRBs in LS's
(Ho 2005).
-- 19 --
of non-thermal leptons (electrons and positrons), magnetic fields, and invisible particles,
respectively. The energy ratio ηc ≡ Ec/Emin can be then expressed as ηc = (Ue + UB +
Uinv)/Umin, where Umin = Emin/Vc is the minimum energy density. From the obtained values
of ηc, we investigate here the contribution of Uinv to the total energy by evaluating Ue/Umin
and UB/Umin.
It is useful to express Ue/Umin and UB/Umin in terms of Ue/UB, since Ue/UB has been
intensively investigated by a lot of authors (e.g., Isobe et al. 2002; Kataoka et al. 2003;
Croston et al. 2004; Kataoka & Stawarz 2005; Croston et al. 2005). Since the synchrotron
luminosity Lν is proportional to UeU 3/4
B Vc, we obtain the relation Ue ∝ (Ue/UB)3/7, or equiv-
alently UB ∝ (Ue/UB)−4/7 for fixed values of Lν and Vc. From this relation and Eq. (9), we
can derive the following expressions:
Ue
Umin ≃ 0.5(cid:18) Ue
UB(cid:19)3/7
,
UB
Umin ≃ 0.5(cid:18) Ue
UB(cid:19)−4/7
.
(11)
Hence, Uinv/Umin is given by
Uinv
Umin ≃ ηc − 0.5((cid:18) Ue
UB(cid:19)3/7
+(cid:18) Ue
UB(cid:19)−4/7) .
(12)
Recent observations show that the ratio of Ue to UB is 1 . Ue/UB . 10 on average. Sub-
stituting these values in Eq. (11), we find 0.13 . UB/Umin . 0.5 and 0.5 . Ue/Umin . 1.3.
Since the obtained range of ηc is ∼ 4 − 310, Uinv/Umin is evaluated as 3 . Uinv/Umin . 310
from Eq. (12). Thus, we conclude that the internal energy of invisible particles must be
larger than those of radiating non-thermal leptons and magnetic fields (Ue, UB . Uinv) to
explain the result obtained in this paper that Ec is larger than Emin by a factor of 4 at least.
We are grateful to A. Celotti for useful comments. We thank M. Machida for useful
comments and discussions on §5.1. This work was partially supported by the Grants-in-
Aid for the Scientific Research (14740166, 14079202) from Ministry of Education, Science
and Culture of Japan and by Grants-in-Aid for the 21th century COE program "Holistic
Research and Education Center for Physics of Self-organizing Systems". This research has
made use of SAOimage DS9, developed by Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory.
Abramowicz, M. A., Czerny, B., Laosta, J. P., & Szuszkiewicz, E. 1988, ApJ, 332, 646
REFERENCES
-- 20 --
Allen, S. W., Dunn, R. J. H., Fabian, A. C., Taylor, G. B., & Reynolds, C. S. 2006, MNRAS,
372, 21
Alexander, P., & Leahy, J. P. 1987, MNRAS, 225, 1
Aloy, M. A., Gomez, J. L., Ibanez, J. M., Marti, J. M., & Muller, E. 2000, ApJ, 528, 85
Begelman, M. C. 1996, Cygnus A -- Study of a Radio Galaxy, 209
Begelman, M. C., Blandford, R. D., & Rees, M. J. 1984, Rev. Mod. Phys., 56, 255
Begelman, M. C., & Cioffi, D. F. 1989, ApJ, 345, 21
Bicknell, G. V., Dopita, M. A., & O'Dea, C. P. 1997, ApJ, 485, 112
Bohringer, H., Voges, W., Fabian, A. C., Edge, A. C., & Neumann, D. M. 1993, MNRAS,
264, 25
Boller, T., Brandt, W. N., & Fink, H. 1996, A&A, 305, 53
Bridle, A. H., Hough, D. H., Lonsdale, C. J., Burns, J. O., & Laing, R. A. 1994, AJ, 108,
766
Carilli, C. L., & Barthel, P. D. 1996, A&A Rev, 7, 1
Carilli, C. L., Perley, R. A., Dreher, J. W., & Leahy, J. P. 1991, ApJ, 383, 554
Cavaliere, A., & Fusco-Femiano, R. 1978, A&A, 70, 677
Celotti, A., & Fabian, A. C. 1993, MNRAS, 264, 228
Cioffi, D. F., & Blondin, J. M. 1992, ApJ, 392, 458
Clarke, D. A., Bridle, A. H., Burns, J. O., Perley, R. A., & Norman, M. L. 1992, ApJ, 385,
173
Collin, S., & Kawaguchi, T. 2004, A&A, 426, 797
Cox, C. I., Gull, S. F., & Scheuer, P. A. G. 1991, MNRAS, 252, 558
Croston, J. H., Birkinshaw, M., Hardcastle., M. J., & Worrall, D. M. 2004, MNRAS, 353,
879
Croston, J. L., Hardcastle, M. H., Harris, D. E., Besole, E., Birkinshaw, M., & Worrall, D.
M. 2005, ApJ, 626, 733
-- 21 --
Di Matteo, T., Croft, R. A. C., Springel, V., & Hernquist, L. 2003, ApJ, 593, 56
Di Matteo, T., Springel, V., & Hernquist, L. 2005, Nature, 433, 604
Dunn, R. J. H., & Fabian, A. C. 2004, MNRAS, 355, 862
Fabian, A. C. 1999, MNRAS, 308, L39
Fabian, A. C., Celotti, A., Blundell, K. M., Kassim, N. E., & Perley, R. A. 2002, MNRAS,
331, 369
Fan, X., et al. 2001, AJ, 122, 2833
Fender, R. P., Belloni, T. M., & Gallo, E. 2004, MNRAS, 355, 1105
Ferrarese, L., & Merritt, D. 2000, ApJ, 539, L9
Gomez, J. L., Marti, J. M., Marscher, A. P., Ibanez, J. M., & Alberdi, A. 1997, ApJ, 482,
33
Granato, G. L., De Zotti, G., Silva, L., Bressan, A., & Danese, L. 2004, ApJ, 600, 580
Hardcastle, M. J., Alexander, P., Pooley, G. G., & Riley, M. J. 1998, MNRAS, 296, 445
Hardcastle, M. J., & Worrall, D. M. 1999, MNRAS, 309, 969
Hardcastle, M. J., & Worrall, D. M. 2000, MNRAS, 319, 562
Ho, L. C. 2005, Ap&SS, 300, 219
Isobe, N., Tashiro, M., Makishima, K., Iyomoto, N., Suzuki, M., Murakami, M. M., Mori,
M., & Abe, K. 2002, ApJ, 580, L111
Kaiser, C. R., & Alexander, P. 1997, MNRAS, 286, 215
Kataoka, J., et al. 2003, A&A, 410, 833
Kataoka, J., & Stawarz, L. 2005, ApJ, 622, 797
Kauffmann, G., et al. 2003, MNRAS, 346, 1055
Kawakatu, N., Umemura, M., & Mori, M. 2003, ApJ, 583, 85
Kawakatu, N., & Kino, M. 2006, MNRAS, 370, 1513
King, A. 2003, ApJ, 596, L27
-- 22 --
Kino, M., & Kawakatu, N. 2005, MNRAS, 364, 659
Kino, M., Kawakatu, N., & Ito, H. 2007, MNRAS, 376, 1630
Komissarov, S. S., & Falle, S. A. E. G. 1997, MNRAS, 288, 833
Kormendy, J., & Richstone, D. 1995, ARA&A, 33, 581
Kubo, H., Takahashi, T., Madejski, G., Tashiro, M., Makino, F., Inoue, S., & Takahara, F.
1998, ApJ, 504, 693
Leahy, J. P., & Gizani, N. A. B. 2001, ApJ, 555, 709
Leahy, J. P., & Perley, R. A. 1991, AJ, 102, 537
Leahy, J. P., Pooley, G. G., & Riley, M. 1986, MNRAS, 222, 753
Liu, R., Pooley, G., & Riley, J. M. 1992, MNRAS, 257, 545
Longair, M. S. 1994, High Energy Astrophysics (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press)
Magorrian, J., et al. 1998, AJ, 115, 2285
Marchesini, D., Celotti, A., & Ferrarese, L. 2004, MNRAS, 351, 733
Marscher, A. P., Jorstad, S. G., Gomez, J., Aller, M. S., Terasranta, H., Lister, M. L., &
Stirling, A. M. 2002, Nature, 417, 625
McHardy, M., Koerding, E., Knigge, C., Uttley, P., & Fender, R. P. 2006, Nature, 444, 730
Miley, G. 1980, ARA&A, 18, 16
Miller, C. J., Nichol, R. C., Gomez, P. L., Hopkins, A. M., & Bernardi, M. 2003, ApJ, 597,
142
Mineshige, S., Kawaguchi, T., Takeuchi, M., & Hayashida, K. 2000, PASJ, 52, 499
Mioduszewski, A. J., Hughes, P. A., & Duncan, G. C. 1997, ApJ, 476, 649
Perley, R. A., Dreher, J. W., & Cowan, J. J. 1984, ApJ, 285, 35
Pounds, K. A., Done, C., & Osborne, J. P. 1995, MNRAS, 277, L5
Rawlings, S., & Saunders, R. 1991, Nature, 349, 138
-- 23 --
Readhead, A. C. S., Taylor, G. B., Xu, W., Pearson, T. J., Wilkinson, P. N., & Polatidis,
A. G. 1996, ApJ, 460, 612
Remillard, R. A., & McClintock, J. E. 2006, ARA&A, 44, 49
Reynolds, C. S., & Fabian, A. C. 1996, MNRAS, 278, 479
Scheck, L., Aloy, M. A., Marti, J. M., Gomez, J. L., & Muller, E. 2002, MNRAS, 331, 615
Scheuer, P. A. G. 1995, MNRAS, 277, 331
Schmidt, S. J., Connolly, A. J., & Hopkins, A. M. 2006, ApJ, 649, 63
Shakura, N. I., & Sunyaev, R. A. 1973, A&A, 24, 337
Shemmer, O., Brandt, W. N., Netzer, H., Maiolino, R., & Kaspi, S. 2006, ApJ, 646, L29
Shi, Y., et al. 2005, ApJ, 629, 88
Silk, J., & Rees, M. J. 1998, A&A, 331, L1
Smith, D. A., Wilson, A. S., Arnaud, K. A., Terashima, Y., & Young, A. J. 2002, ApJ, 565,
195
Spergel, D. N., et al. 2003, ApJS, 148, 175
Tadhunter, C., Marconi, A., Axon, D., Wills, K., Robinson, T. G., & Jackson, N. 2003,
MNRAS, 342, 861
Tremaine, S., et al. 2002, ApJ, 574, 740
Urry, C. M., & Padovani, P. 1995, PASP, 107, 803
Willot, C. J., Rawlings, S., Blundell, K. M., & Lacy, M. 1999, MNRAS, 309, 1017
Wilson, A. S., Young, A. J., & Shopbell, P. L. 2000, ApJ, 544, 27
Wilson, A. S., Smith, D. A., & Young, A. J. 2006, ApJ, 644, L9
Woo, J.-H., & Urry, C. M. 2002, ApJ, 579, 530
Young, A. J., Wilson, A. S., Terashima, Y., Arnaud, K. A., & Smith, D. A. 2002, ApJ, 564,
176
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
-- 24 --
Fig. 3. -- Logarithmic-scaled 5-GHz VLA map of Cygnus A (upper-left) and 1.5GHz VLA
maps of 3C 223 (upper-right), 3C 284 (lower-left), and 3C 219 (lower-right) with linearly
spaced contours are displayed. The straight lines overlaid in each map denote the lines we
have used to measure rh and Ah.
-- 25 --
Table 1: The quantities measured from observations.
Source
(1)
Cygnus A E
Cygnus A W
3C 223 N
3C 223 S
3C 284 E
3C 284 W
3C 219 W
rh (kpc) Ah (kpc2) ρa (g cm−3) Pa (dyne cm−2)
(2)
60
70
340
340
260
380
210
(3)
150
150
4300
1800
4600
6200
5000
(4)
8.3×10−27
6.6×10−27
5.5×10−28
5.5×10−28
4.0×10−28
2.3×10−28
1.0×10−27
(5)
8.0×10−11
6.4×10−11
1.2×10−12
1.2×10−12
6.4×10−13
3.7×10−13
1.6×10−12
α Ref.
(7)
(6)
1,2
1.5
1.5
1,2
3
1.6
3
1.6
1.0
3
3
1.4
2.0
4
Note. -- Column (1) shows the names of radio sources, and the following alphabet distinguishes the pair of
jets (see Fig. 3 ). Columns (2) and (3) display, respectively, the cocoon lengths and the cross sectional areas
of cocoon head measured from Fig. 3 . Columns (4) and (5) give the estimated ICM densities and pressures
at r = rh. In Column(6), the estimated power-law indexes of the ICM density are presented. References for
the density profiles and pressures are listed in column (7)
References.
-- (1) Reynolds & Fabian (1996);
(2) Smith et al.
(2002);
(3) Croston et al.
(2004);(4)Hardcastle & Worrall (1999).
-- 26 --
Table 2: The observed radio information.
dL
Source
z
(1)
(2)
Cygnus A 0.0565
0.1368
0.2394
0.1744
3C 223
3C 284
3C 219
(Mpc)
(3)
249
635
1182
829
Fν
(Jy)
(4)
9660
16.0
12.3
44.9
αR
(5)
0.74
0.74
0.95
0.81
Lν
(ergs s−1Hz−1)
(6)
6.2×1035
7.7×1033
1.0×1034
3.7×1034
Note. -- Column (1) shows the names of radio sources. Columns (2) and (3) display, respectively, the
redshift and the luminosity distance calculated for the cosmology with H0 = 71km s−1, ΩM = 0.3, and
ΩΛ = 0.7. Columns (4) and (5) give the values of flux densities and spectral indexes at 178MHz, which are
taken from the table (Table 1) of Hardcastle et al. (1998). In Column (6) the calculated luminosity densities
at 178MHz is presented
Fig. 4. -- The obtained ranges of power and age of Cygnus A. The three oblique lines, which
lie closely to each other are the solutions for the power-law index of the ICM density (α)
shown by arrow; The solid line represents the solution for the estimated power-law index (see
Table 1). The dashed and dot-dashed lines represent the solutions for the power-law index
increased by 0.5 and decreased by 0.5, respectively. The shaded regions show allowed ranges
where the overpressure condition (Pc > Pa) is satisfied. Also the Eddington luminosities are
displayed by the horizontal lines for comparison.
-- 27 --
Fig. 5. -- Same as Fig. 4, but for 3C 223.
Fig. 6. -- Same as Fig. 4, but for 3C 284.
Fig. 7. -- Same as Fig. 4, but for 3C 219.
Table 3. The obtained properties of the jet and the cocoon together with minimum energy of the radio lobe.
Source
(1)
Cygnus A E
Cygnus A W
3C 223 N
3C 223 S
3C 284 E
3C 284 W
3C 219 W
Lj
(1046 ergs s−1)
(2)
0.4 - 2.6
0.35 - 1.1
0.15 - 2.9
0.071 - 0.2
0.3 - 18
0.1 - 3.6
2.6 - 43
tage
(Myr)
(3)
19 - 47
30 - 53
140 - 610
330 - 560
32 - 260
100 - 630
37 - 150
MBH
(M⊙)
(4)
2.5×109(2)
2.5×109(2)
1.4×108(1)
1.4×108(1)
8.2×108(3,4)
8.2×108(3,4)
6.3×108(3)
2Lj/LEdd
Ec
Emin
(1060 ergs)
(1060 ergs)
(5)
0.025 - 0.16
0.021 - 0.068
0.16 - 3.2
0.078 - 0.22
0.053 - 3.4
0.018 - 0.67
0.65 - 10
(6)
6.2 - 16
6.1 - 11
30 - 130
12 - 22
26 - 210
21 - 130
130 - 500
(7)
1.4
1.4
0.88
0.88
1.8
3.0
1.6
ηc
(8)
4.4 - 11
4.3 - 7.8
34 - 150
14 - 25
14 - 120
7 - 43
79 - 310
Note. -- Column (1) shows the names of radio sources, and the following alphabet distinguishes the pair of
jets (see Fig. 3). Columns (2) and (3) display, respectively, the total kinetic powers and ages of the radio jets.
In column (4) and (5), the black hole mass and the kinetic powers normalized by the corresponding Eddington
luminosity are displayed, respectively. References for the central SMBH mass are given in parentheses.
In
Columns (6) and (7), the total energies deposited in the cocoon and the minimum energies required for the
synchrotron emission are displayed, respectively. Column (8) gives the ratios between Ec and Emin.
References. -- (1) Woo & Urry (2002); (2) Tadhunter et al. (2003); (3) Marchesini et al. (2004); (4) Shi et al.
(2005).
--
2
8
--
|
astro-ph/0612618 | 1 | 0612 | 2006-12-21T05:27:01 | Living life on the edge - Wide-field VLBI at 90 cm! | [
"astro-ph"
] | We report on a recent 90 cm wide-field VLBI survey of two 3.1 deg^2 fields using the VLBA, Westerbork and Jodrell Bank telescopes. In-beam calibration was used to calibrate each field, the process was simplified by imaging the calibrators in DIFMAP and transferring the calibration solutions to AIPS using the newly developed DIFMAP task - cordump. We detected and imaged 13 out of the 141 sources originally detected by the low resolution (54") WENSS survey of the same two fields. The sources were detected at 7-12 sigma levels above the image noise, had total flux densities ranging between 85-1640 mJy and were between 16'-58' from the phase centre of each field. This is the first systematic (and non-biased), deep, high resolution survey of the low frequency radio sky. These initial results suggest that new instruments such as LOFAR should detect many compact radio sources and that plans to extend these arrays to baselines of several thousand kilometres are warranted. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Living life on the edge - Wide-field VLBI at 90 cm!
Emil Lenc∗
Swinburne University of Technology
E-mail: [email protected]
Mike Garrett, Olaf Wucknitz and James Anderson
Joint Institute for VLBI in Europe
E-mail: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]
Steven Tingay
Swinburne University of Technology
E-mail: [email protected]
We report on a recent 90 cm wide-field VLBI survey of two 3.1 deg2 fields using the VLBA,
Westerbork and Jodrell Bank telescopes. In-beam calibration was used to calibrate each field,
the process was simplified by imaging the calibrators in DIFMAP and transferring the calibration
solutions to AIPS using the newly developed DIFMAP task - cordump. We detected and imaged
13 out of the 141 sources originally detected by the low resolution (54′′) WENSS survey of the
same two fields. The sources were detected at 7 − 12 sigma levels above the image noise, had
total flux densities ranging between 85−1640 mJy and were between 16′
− 58′ from the phase
centre of each field. This is the first systematic (and non-biased), deep, high resolution survey of
the low frequency radio sky. These initial results suggest that new instruments such as LOFAR
should detect many compact radio sources and that plans to extend these arrays to baselines of
several thousand kilometres are warranted.
8th European VLBI Network Symposium
September 26-29, 2006
Toru´n, Poland
∗Speaker.
c(cid:13) Copyright owned by the author(s) under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike Licence.
http://pos.sissa.it/
Living life on the edge - Wide-field VLBI at 90 cm!
Emil Lenc
1. Introduction
Very little is known about the general properties of the 90 cm sky and even less is known at
VLBI resolution. Previous snapshot surveys at these wavelengths have only targeted the brightest
sources and were plagued by poor sensitivity and limited coherence times. As a result only a few
tens of sources have been imaged with VLBI. Improved calibration and imaging techniques are
required to learn more about the low frequency sky at VLBI resolutions. For example, Garrett et
al. [1] performed a deep VLBI survey at 20 cm of a 36′ wide field by using a central bright source
as an in-beam calibrator. The approach permitted the imaging of many potential target sources
simultaneously and was ideal for survey work. We have set out to apply a similar technique at 90
cm by piggy-backing on a VLBI observation of the gravitational lens 0218 + 357 and the nearby
phase reference source J0226+3421 with the aim of surveying a 3 deg2 field around each of the
sources. The results provide important information with regards to what may be seen by future
low-frequency instruments such as LOFAR, extended LOFAR and the SKA.
2. Observation and Data Reduction
A VLBI observation of the gravitational lens 0218+357 and the nearby phase calibrator
J0226+3421 was made on 2005 November 11 using the Jodrell Bank, Westerbork and VLBA
telescopes. The recorded data were correlated at JIVE in multiple passes to create a single-IF
(4 MHz), single polarisation, wide-field data set with an integration time of 0.25 s and a multi-
band, dual polarisation, narrow-field data-set with higher sensitivity. The wide-field data-set has
a one sigma theoretical thermal noise level of ∼0.7 and ∼1.2 mJy/beam for the target and phase
calibrator respectively.
Initial calibration was performed on the narrow-field data-set to take advantage of the increased
sensitivity available with the additional bands and polarisations. Instrumental delays, which were
assumed to be constant throughout the observation, were calibrated by fringe fitting on 3C84. A
multi-band fringe fit was then performed on the phase calibrator. The resulting solutions were trans-
ferred to the wide-field data set using a ParselTongue1 script and the bandpass calibrated against
observations of 3C84. Additional amplitude and phase calibrations were complicated by the com-
plex structure of the phase calibrator J0226+3421. To simplify calibration, the phase calibrator
data was averaged in frequency and exported to DIFMAP. Several iterations of modelling and self-
calibration were performed in DIFMAP and a new DIFMAP task, cordump2, was used to transfer
the resulting phase and amplitude calibrations back to the unaveraged AIPS data-set. After appli-
cation of these corrections the DIFMAP model of the source was subtracted from the AIPS u-v
data-set to reduce side-lobe effects. The resulting data-set had a measured RMS noise approxi-
mately 1.8 times the theoretical thermal noise. The higher than anticipated noise is attributed to
substantial levels of RFI observed on some baselines. With the phase calibrator solutions applied,
the 0218+357 data set was also averaged in frequency and exported to DIFMAP to further refine
the calibration in that field using the same process that was applied to the phase calibrator.
1A Python scripting tool for AIPS available for download at http://www.radionet-eu.org/rnwiki/ParselTongue
2The cordump patch is available for DIFMAP at http://astronomy.swin.edu.au/ elenc/DifmapPatches/
2
Living life on the edge - Wide-field VLBI at 90 cm!
Emil Lenc
The data from both fields was kept in an unaveraged form to prevent smearing effects during
imaging. Six sub-fields were defined for each field based on the distance from phase centre in 10′
increments. The WENSS catalogue was used as a guide for potential targets in each sub-field. Dirty
maps covering an area greater than that of the WENSS beam were created for each of the potential
targets in each sub-field using the IMAGR task in AIPS. Heavier u-v tapering was applied to the
outer sub-fields to reduce smearing effects but at the expense of reduced resolution and sensitivity.
A 7s detection limit above the measured noise level was imposed to identify positive detections.
Phase corrections were observed to vary significantly between sub-fields as a result of iono-
spheric variations. A ParselTongue library has been written to interpolate and apply ionospheric
total electron content (TEC) corrections to account for the spatially varying effect of the ionosphere
across the field being imaged. However, the corrections did not result in any significant improve-
ment in the resulting images. We suspect that the currently available TEC solutions may be too
coarse both spatially and temporally to account for the ionospheric variations across the field.
3. Results
The phase calibrator and target sources were imaged with a resolution of approximately 20
mas, both exhibited complex large scale structure. As shown in Figure 1, a total of 13 sources
(including the central field sources) were detected from a total of 141 target sources with distances
of up to a degree from the phase centre and at resolutions of between 80 and 140 mas. Six wide-
field sources were detected out of 73 potential targets in the J0226+3421 field at 7 − 11s
levels,
with total fluxes between 85−1640 mJy and with distances between 18′
−56′ from the phase centre.
Five wide-field sources were detected out of 66 potential targets in the 0218+357 field at 7 − 12s
levels, with total fluxes between 87−1400 mJy and with distances between between 16′
− 58′ from
the phase centre. Almost all of the detected sources were extended suggesting that those sources
that were not detected were resolved out by the significantly smaller beam of this observation
compared to that of WENSS (∼ 1′). Nonetheless, our observations have shown that there are many
sources that could be studied at longer wavelengths with instruments such as LOFAR, extended
LOFAR and SKA.
4. Conclusion
Approximately 10% of WENSS survey sources within two 3 deg2 fields have been detected
and imaged using wide-field VLBI imaging techniques at 90 cm. The results provide an indication
of what may be observed by next generation low-frequency instruments such as LOFAR and SKA,
they also suggest that plans to extend these arrays to baselines of several thousand kilometres are
warranted. It would be informative to apply the wide-field techniques described here to a larger
sample of fields. Such a study could better constrain the frequency and nature of sources that may
be targeted by instruments such as LOFAR.
References
[1] M.A. Garrett, J.M. Wrobel, R. Morganti, Deep VLBI Imaging of Faint Radio Sources in the NOAO
Bootes Field, ApJ, 619, 105
3
Living life on the edge - Wide-field VLBI at 90 cm!
Emil Lenc
0218+357
Field
J0226+3421
Field
Figure 1: Source detections using wide-field VLBI at 90 cm in 3.1 degree2 fields around J0226+3421 and
0218+357.
4
|
astro-ph/9609189 | 1 | 9609 | 1996-09-27T08:37:55 | The large-scale structure of the diffuse radio halo of the Coma cluster at 1.4 GHz | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present new measurements of the diffuse radio emission from the Coma cluster of galaxies at 1.4 GHz using the Effelsberg 100-m-telescope. The halo source Coma C has an extent down to noise of about 80 arcmin corresponding to 3 Mpc (H_0 = 50 km/s/Mpc) in Coma. The radio map reveals clear similarities with images of the extended X-ray halo of the Coma cluster. After subtracting the contributions from point sources we obtained an integrated diffuse flux density of S = 640 +- 35 mJy from Coma C. We derive relations between the various observationally determined spectral indices and the spectral index of the synchrotron emissivity, which allow one to achieve a rough estimate concerning the consistency of the presently available data at different frequencies and to place constraints on the emissivity index distribution. In the halo's core region, the inferred emissivity index between 0.3 GHz and 1.4 GHz appears to be in the range 0.4 - 0.75 implying that there must be some very effective mechanism for particle acceleration operating in the intracluster medium. | astro-ph | astro-ph | A&A manuscript no.
(will be inserted by hand later)
Your thesaurus codes are:
02.01.1; 02.04.2; 11.03.4 NGC 1656; 11.09.3; 13.18.1
ASTRONOMY
AND
ASTROPHYSICS
13.11.2018
6
9
9
1
p
e
S
7
2
1
v
9
8
1
9
0
6
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
The large-scale structure of the diffuse radio halo of the
Coma cluster at 1.4 GHz
B.M. Deiss1, W. Reich2, H. Lesch3, and R. Wielebinski2
1 Institut fur Theoretische Physik, J.W. Goethe-Universitat, Robert-Mayer-Strasse 10,
D-60054 Frankfurt am Main, Germany
2 Max-Planck-Insitut fur Radioastronomie, Auf dem Hugel 69, D-53121 Bonn, Germany
3 Institut fur Astronomie und Astrophysik der Universitat Munchen, Scheinerstrasse 1,
D-81679 Munchen, Germany
Received date;accepted date
Abstract. We present new measurements of the diffuse
radio emission from the Coma cluster of galaxies at 1.4
GHz using the Effelsberg 100-m-telescope. Even at that
high frequency, the halo source Coma C has an ex-
tent down to noise of ∼ 80′ corresponding to 3 Mpc
(H0 = 50kms−1Mpc−1) in Coma. The radio map reveals
clear similarities with images of the extended X-ray halo
of the Coma cluster. However, the radio halo appears to
be displaced from the X-ray halo by ∼ 3 − 4 arcmin. Af-
ter subtracting the contributions from point sources we
obtained an integrated diffuse flux density of S1.4GHz =
640 ± 35 mJy from Coma C.
We derive relations between the various observation-
ally determined spectral indices and the spectral index of
the synchrotron emissivity, which allow one to achieve a
rough estimate concerning the consistency of the presently
available data at different frequencies and to place con-
straints on the emissivity index distribution. In the halo's
core region, the inferred emissivity index between 0.3 GHz
and 1.4 GHz appears to be in the range 0.4 - 0.75 imply-
ing that there must be some very effective mechanism for
particle acceleration operating in the intracluster medium.
We discuss implications of our measurements and of the
spectral index information on current theories for radio
halo formation. We stress the importance of having more
measurements of Coma C at frequencies above 1.4 GHz,
in order to be able to derive constraints on the physics of
the formation process of the radio halo.
Key words: galaxies: clusters: individual: Coma -- inter-
galactic medium -- radio continuum: galaxies -- accelera-
tion of particles -- diffusion
Send offprint requests to: B.M. Deiss
1. Introduction
Diffuse cluster-wide radio emission not associated with in-
dividual galaxies defines a separate class of extragalactic
radio sources: the diffuse radio halos of galaxy clusters.
Radio halo sources are observed in the richest and most
X-ray luminous clusters of galaxies. However, one of their
most enigmatic properties appears to be their obvious rar-
ity. At present, only a few clusters are definitely known
to have an extended radio halo: e.g., A754 (Waldthausen
1980), A2255 (Harris et al. 1980), A2256 (Bridle & Foma-
lont 1976), A2319 (Harris & Miley 1978). The best studied
example, however, is the Coma cluster (A1656) with its
extended, diffuse halo source Coma C (e.g.,Hanisch 1980;
Hanisch & Erickson 1980; Waldthausen 1980; Cordey
1985; Schlickeiser et al. 1987; Henning 1989; Venturi et
al. 1990; Kim et al. 1990; Giovannini et al. 1993).
At lower frequencies diffuse radio emission from Coma
C has been observed up to an angular distance of ∼ 35′
from the cluster center [e.g., Henning (1989) at 30.9 MHz],
which corresponds to a radius of 1.5 Mpc in Coma (z =
0.0235; Sarazin et al. 1982).(We adopt H0 = 50km s−1 for
the Hubble constant throughout the paper; i.e., 1′ b= 40
kpc). This implies the existence of a cluster-wide presence
of relativistic electrons as well as of a magnetic field.
Kim et al. (1990) published a detailed image of Coma
C at 1.4 GHz using a synthesis aperture telescope (Domin-
ion Radio Astrophysical Observatory, DRAO). Applying
a Gaussian fit, they inferred a FWHM1.4GHz of the radio
halo of 18.′7 × 13.′7 which is significantly smaller than the
value of the FWHM obtained at lower frequencies, e.g., at
326 MHz (Venturi et al. 1990). From these observations
Giovannini et al. (1993) concluded that the spectral in-
dex of the diffuse radio emission strongly steepens with
increasing radius. The DRAO radio map of Kim et al.
(1990) reveals a halo diameter down to noise level of < 25′.
However, emission from larger structures could be atten-
2
B.M. Deiss et al.: The large-scale structure of the diffuse radio halo of the Coma cluster at 1.4 GHz
uated due to the synthesis aperture technique. This has
implications for the determination of the spectral index
distribution (Giovannini et al. 1993) as well as of the inte-
grated flux at 1.4 GHz. In order to obtain informations on
the large scale characteristics of the halo at high frequen-
cies, we observed Coma C at 1.4 GHz with the Effelsberg
single-dish 100-m-telesope.
The exact shape of the diffuse radio emission spectrum
of Coma C is yet unclear. Schlickeiser et al. (1987) claimed
that the integrated flux density spectrum strongly steep-
ens at high frequencies (ν > 1 GHz). We discuss the con-
sistency of their measurements to our observations, and
we discuss some implications of our new measurements
on current models for radio halo formation which have
been proposed in the literature (e.g. Hanisch 1982, Trib-
ble 1993).
2. Radio continuum observations
We have made radio continuum observations at 1.4 GHz
with the Effelsberg 100-m telescope in April 1993. At
this frequency the telescope has an angular resolution
(HPBW) of 9.′35. A field of 3◦ × 3◦ centered on the Coma
cluster has been mapped twice in orthogonal directions.
We used a two channel receiver with cooled HEMT am-
plifiers. A bandwidth of 20 MHz was centered on 1.4 GHz.
The data have been processed using standard procedures
for continuum mapping observations with the Effelsberg
100-m telescope (e.g. Reich et al., 1990). The data from
both channels have been averaged and the two coverages
have been combined using the method described by Emer-
son and Grave (1988). The final map is limited by confu-
sion and has an r.m.s.-noise of about 7 mJy (or 14.4 mK
Tb). We displayed our result in the form of a contour
plot in Fig. 1. The map shows numerous compact radio
sources, most of them associated with Coma cluster galax-
ies, superimposed on a weak large scale diffuse emission
component.
In order to separate the diffuse extended emission from
the contribution of individual sources, we have used the
master list of radio sources from the Coma cluster as com-
piled by Kim (1994). The data for 298 sources are from
various observations made with synthesis telescopes and
therefore include sources as weak as a few mJy not di-
rectly accessible by us due to our larger beam width and
resulting higher confusion limit. We have used the spectral
fits by Kim et al. (1994) to calculate the flux density of
all sources at 1.4 GHz and subracted these contributions
assuming a Gaussian source shape at the listed positions.
We have in addition subtracted a few sources fitted by a
Gaussian at the edge areas of our field which are outside
the region where Kim (1994) has listed radio sources. The
result of this procedure is shown in Fig. 2 where a weak
diffuse radio component is left which is centered on the
Coma cluster.
The east-west angular extent of the diffuse radio source
is more than 80′. The bridge-like extension of the diffuse
radio emission to the south-west is related to the galaxy
group associated with the bright galaxy NGC 4839. In
order to obtain the integrated flux density of the diffuse
radio emission at 1.4 GHz from Coma C, we integrated the
diffuse flux (Fig. 2) over a circular area of radius 40′ cen-
tered at α = 12h57m10.s7, δ = 28◦12′16′′ (1950), but where
we subtracted contributions from the region around NGC
4839 and from the narrow halo extension to the north.
The latter might be related to the radio source 5C4.109.
Fig. 1. 1.4 GHz map of the Coma cluster from Effelsberg
100-m telesope observations. The rms noise is 7 mJy/beam.
Contours are 10 mJy/beam apart
(dashed contour: 0.0
′35) is indicated in the lower
mJy/beam). The HPBW (9.
left-hand corner
Fig. 2. 1.4 GHz map of the Coma cluster as in Fig. 1 but
with compact sources subtracted. Contours are 10 mJy/beam
′35) is
apart (dashed contour: 0.0 mJy/beam). The HPBW (9.
indicated in the lower left-hand corner
3. Results
3.1. Morphological structure of the radio halo
At 1.4 GHz, the diffuse radio halo Coma C reveals a
butterfly-like shape with an angular extent down to noise
of more than 80′ along the east-west direction and of about
45′ in north-south direction, corresponding to 3.2 Mpc ×
1.8 Mpc respectively. The 1.4 GHz aperture synthesis map
of Coma C recently obtained by Kim et al. (1990) shows
an angular size of the radio halo down to noise of only
22′, due to the low sensitivity to the very large scale radio
emission.
An even more striking feature is the close resemblance
of the spatial structure of the halo source at 1.4 GHz and
the smooth, extended X-ray halo of Coma (Briel et al.
1992; White et al. 1993). The X-ray emission is thermal
bremsstrahlung originating from the hot (T ∼ 108 K) in-
tracluster gas (Sarazin 1988). Both the X-ray halo and the
1.4 GHz radio halo are elongated approximately east-west.
Both the ROSAT PSPC X-ray image (White et al. 1993)
and our 1.4 GHz halo map (Fig. 2) reveal a narrow exten-
sion towards the galaxy group associated with NGC 4839
south-west of the Coma cluster. Our radio map actually
shows that this extended structure represents a narrow,
B.M. Deiss et al.: The large-scale structure of the diffuse radio halo of the Coma cluster at 1.4 GHz
3
low-brightness bridge of diffuse radio emission connecting
the radio source Coma C with the peripheral extended
complex of radio emission, Coma A. This bridge was also
detected at 326 MHz by Venturi et al. (1990).
Fig. 3 shows the azimuthally averaged surface bright-
ness distribution of the 1.4 GHz map of the halo cen-
tered at α = 12h57m10.s7, δ = 28◦12′16′′ (1950). For
comparison, we plotted the model function (normalized
to 200 mJy) given by Briel et al. (1992) which fits the
azimuthally averaged surface brightness distribution of
the X-ray halo observed with ROSAT. As a model func-
tion, Briel et al. (1992) adopted a modified isothermal
King profil (King 1966) I(Θ)/I0 = (1 + (Θ/a)2)−(3β−1/2),
where Θ denotes the projected radius, a is the core ra-
dius, β is the density slope parameter, and I0 is the
central surface brightness. The radial profil of the X-ray
surface brightness distribution is fitted best adopting a
β = 0.75 ± 0.03 and a core radius a = 10.′5 ± 0.′6 (Briel et
al. 1992). The galaxy distribution of the cluster is more
centrally concentrated having a core radius of 6-8 arcmin
(Sarazin 1988, and references therein). The FWHM of the
X-ray halo is FWHMX−ray = 14.′6, while one infers a
FWHM1.4GHz = 15.′2 from the azimuthally averaged, de-
convolved brightness distribution at 1.4 GHz. This shows
that the scale size of the diffuse radio halo source at 1.4
GHz is similar to that of the X-ray halo. However, the
radio emission declines more rapidly in the outer regions
of the cluster.
As has already been noted by Kim et al. (1990), the
positions of the two sources are significantly displaced. On
the largest scale, we find the radio source to be about 3-
4 arcmin west of the X-ray source. The location of the
peak surface brightness in our map (Fig. 2) seems to be
even more displaced. This must not be taken too seri-
ously, considering i) the low angular resolution of the ob-
servation, and ii) the sensitivity of the result of the re-
moval procedure concerning the proper positioning of the
strong radio sources 5C4.85 and 5C4.81 in the center re-
gion of the cluster. Inspecting the 2.7 GHz map of the
diffuse radio halo obtained by Schlickeiser et al. (1987),
one finds that also at this high frequency the halo source
reveals a positional offset of 2-3 armin to the west rela-
tiv to the X-ray source. From the existence of the posi-
tional offset between radio halo and X-ray halo, Kim et
al. (1990) concluded that the relativistic particles in the
radio halo may not be directly responsible for the heating
of the X-ray emitting gas. Since, if the relativistic par-
ticles were the main heating source of the hot gas, the
two sources should be precisely coextensive. Nevertheless,
the close morphological correspondence between thermal
X-ray bremsstrahlung and non-thermal synchrotron radi-
ation suggests that the existence of the diffuse radio emis-
sion is based on the physical condition of the hot thermal
gas.
Fig. 3. Azimuthally averaged surface brightness distribution
of the diffuse radio halo of the Coma cluster at 1.4 GHz (dots).
The measurement points are connected by straight solid lines,
in order to have a better impression about the radial profil.
Dashed curve: Best fitting King model of the radial profil of
the X-ray halo (Briel at al. 1992)
3.2. Integrated diffuse flux from Coma C
Performing the procedure described in Sect. 2 we ob-
tained an integrated diffuse flux density from Coma C of
S1.4GHz = 640 ± 35 mJy. Kim et al. (1990) derived an inte-
grated diffuse flux of 530 ± 50 mJy at 1380 MHz using the
DRAO Synthesis Telescope and the NRAO Very Large Ar-
ray. Our single-dish observation, however, indicates that
the radio halo at 1.4 GHz is much more extended than it
is suggested by the DRAO image, which accounts for the
increased integrated flux at that frequency. Fig. 4 shows
the integrated diffuse flux from Coma C at various fre-
quencies. The data set used (see Table 1) comprises our
measurement together with data used by Schlickeiser et
al. (1987) and by Giovannini et al. (1993). Our measure-
ment seems to fit rather neatly a power law extrapolation
from lower frequencies. The data points in the frequency
range <
= 1.4 GHz may be fitted by a power law with in-
dex α = 1.16 ± 0.03. If we take all data into account a
power-law fit gives α = 1.36 ± 0.03.
3.3. Scale-size-vs.-frequency relation
Our value for the FWHM of the halo at 1.4 GHz (15.′2)
is in agreement with the scale size obtained by Kim et.
(1990) (18.′7×13.′7), who fitted the brightness distribution
with a two-dimensional Gaussian. At 326 MHz, Venturi et
4
B.M. Deiss et al.: The large-scale structure of the diffuse radio halo of the Coma cluster at 1.4 GHz
Table 1. Integrated flux densities from Coma C. References:
(1) Henning 1989; (2) Hanisch & Erickson 1980; (3) Cordey
1985; (4) Venturi et al. 1990; (5) Kim et al. 1990; (6) Hanisch
1980; (7) Giovannini et al. 1993; (8) present paper; (9) Schlick-
eiser et al. 1987; (10) Waldthausen et al. 1980
Frequency (MHz) Flux (Jy) Error (Jy) References
30.9
43
73.8
151
326
408
430
608.5
1380
1400
2700
4850
49
51
17
7.2
3.18
2.0
2.55
1.2
0.53
0.64
0.070
< 0.052
10
13
12
0.8
0.03
0.2
0.28
0.3
0.05
0.035
0.020
...
1
2
2
3
4
5
6
7
5
8
9
10
al. (1990) inferred a FWHM326MHz = 28′ × 20′. Henning
(1989) derived the scale size of the radio halo at an even
lower frequency (30.9 MHz). She found FWHM30.9MHz =
31′ ± 5′ × 15′ ± 5′. In order to obtain a rough estimate of
the halo's FWHM at 2.7 GHz, we azimuthally averaged
the 2.7 GHz map given by Schlickeiser et al. (1987) and in-
ferred a FWHM from that radial distribution. This yields
a FWHM2.7GHz ∼ 12.′6 ± 1.′3 which may be regarded as
an upper limit, since we did not deconvolve the original
map. In any case, this is significantly smaller than the
scale size of the halo at 1.4 GHz. Hence, there appear to
be strong observational evidences that the scale size of the
radio halo is a monotonically decreasing function of fre-
quency. This supports the suggestion made by Giovannini
et al. (1993) that in the external regions of the cluster the
diffuse radio halo exhibits a steeper spectrum than in the
core region. Comparing surface brightness measurements
at 326 MHz and 1.4 GHz, performed with synthesis aper-
ture telescopes, Giovannini et al. (1993) derived a spectral
index distribution which shows an almost constant index
of ∼ 0.8 within a cluster radius of ∼ 8′ and a strong in-
crease of the index up to values higher than 1.8 outside
this central "plateau". However, our single-dish observa-
tions indicate that at larger spatial scales there is much
more diffuse radio power at 1.4 GHz than it is suggested by
the synthesis aperture measurements. Thus, the increase
of the spectral index may be weaker than claimed by Gio-
vannini et al. (1993). A smaller spectral index implies a
weaker net energy loss of the relativistic electrons in the
peripheral region of the cluster.
4. Discussion
Fig. 4. Integrated flux density spectrum of the diffuse radio
halo Coma C. Data are from Table 1.
4.1. Consistency of data and the spectral index distribu-
tion
The integrated diffuse flux measurements listed in Table
1 may be subjected to considerable systematic errors: for
instance, an improper subtraction of contributions from
point sources, a too small integration volume, or an er-
roneous intensity offset of the diffuse emission. Due to
the very low number of data points, these (unknown) sys-
tematic errors may dominate any statistical analysis of
a theoretical halo model. In that respect, it still seems
to be an open question whether the strong steepening of
the integrated-flux spectrum of Coma C above 1 GHz,
claimed by Schlickeiser et al. (1987), is real. Our observa-
tions indicate that, at least up to 1.4 GHz, the integrated
spectrum shows no tendency to steepen. If the 2.7 GHz
value obtained by Schlickeiser et al. (1987) is real this im-
plies a rather distinct cutoff of the spectrum between 1.4
GHz and 2.7 GHz. However, such a sharp spectral break
can hardly be reproduced by any theoretical halo model,
since, even in the case that the electron energy distribution
tends to zero at some characteristic energy, the decline of
the synchrotron emission spectrum is at most exponential.
Hence, one may suspect that at frequencies > 1.4 GHz the
diffuse radio halo is much more luminous than it is sug-
gested by the measurements by Schlickeiser et al. (1987)
and Waldthausen (1980).
Using the combined data of the integrated flux den-
sities, the surface brightness distributions and the scale-
size-vs.-frequency relation one may achieve, under some
B.M. Deiss et al.: The large-scale structure of the diffuse radio halo of the Coma cluster at 1.4 GHz
5
simplifying assumptions, a rough estimate concerning the
consistency of the measurements at different frequencies.
In addition, the considerations described in the following
allow to place some constraints on the spectral index dis-
tribution of the synchrotron emission coefficient.
The FWHM at a given frequency is usually inferred
from a Gaussian fit to the spatial profil of the surface
brightness distribution. This appears to be reasonable,
since the shape of the surface brightness distribution is
more or less Gaussian. This implies that the spatial pro-
fil of the emission coefficient ǫν(r) may be assumed to be
Gaussian-shaped, too. Taking advantage of that allows one
to derive a relation between the spectral index distribution
of ǫν and other spectral indices which can be determined
by observations. For the sake of simplicity, we consider
a spherically symmetric halo. At a given frequency, say
ν = m, the integrated diffuse radio flux density spectrum
Sm and the surface brightness distribution Im(b) at a pro-
jected radius b are given by
∞Z0
r2ǫm(r) dr
Sm = (const)
and
Im(b) = (const)
∞Z0
ǫm(r2 = z2 + b2) dz.
(1)
(2)
In Eqs. (1) and (2) we implicitely assumed a quasi-
locally averaged, isotropic emission coefficient which de-
pends only on the absolute value of the cluster radius r.
This is a reasonable simplification, since the cluster mag-
netic field which generally introduces a directional depen-
dence appears to be tangled on rather small scales. Feretti
et al. (1995) give scale sizes for the magnetic field rever-
sals of less than 1 kpc; this value is required to explain
the dispersion of the rotation measure of the radio source
NGC 4869.
For two different frequencies, say ν1 = m and ν2 = n,
and on the assumption that the radial distributions of
ǫm(r) and ǫn(r) may be reasonably well fitted by Gaus-
sians, the following relations hold:
Sm
Sn
=
and
Im(b)
In(b)
=
(3)
(4)
.
ǫm(0)
ǫn(0) (cid:18) FWHMm
FWHMn(cid:19)3
ǫn(r)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)r=b
ǫm(r)
FWHMn
FWHMm
As it is usually done, we characterize the ratios Sm/Sn,
Im(b)/In(b) and ǫm(r)/ǫn(r) by spectral indices αS,mn,
αI,mn(b) and αǫ,mn(r), respectively. In addition, we de-
fine a corresponding index qmn for the size-vs.-frequency
relation through the ratios
FWHMm
FWHMn
=(cid:16) m
n(cid:17)−qmn
.
(5)
Employing Eqs. (3) and (4) we can now relate the spec-
tral index αǫ,mn(r) of the emission coefficient to the ob-
servationally given indices αS,mn, αI,mn(b) and qmn. We
obtain
αǫ,mn(0) = αS,mn − 3 qmn,
αǫ,mn(r)(r=b) = αI,mn(b) − qmn.
(6)
(7)
In the latter equation, the notation (r = b) means that
the value of the cluster radius r, at which we would like
to know the index αǫ,mn(r), is set equal to the value of
the projected radius b at which the index αI,mn(b) is mea-
sured.
Equations (6) and (7) imply the relation
αS,mn = αI,mn(0) + 2 qmn
(8)
which provides a check on the consistency of the observa-
tional data. It relates to each other the measurements of
the integrated flux, of the central surface brightness, and
of the scale size of the halo at two different frequencies.
Of course, considering the employed simplifications such
a relation will never be exactly fullfilled. Nevertheless, it
can give a hint to whether there are considerable system-
atic errors, e.g., in the measurement of the integrated flux
densities, as discussed above.
Since we assumed that the surface brightness dis-
tributions have Gaussian-shaped profils, the theoreti-
cal spectral-index distribution αI,mn(b) is necessarily a
quadratic function given by
αI,mn(b) = αI,mn(0) +
b2
r2
mn
,
where rmn is defined through
(9a)
rmn = (4ln2)−1/2FWHMmhln
n
mi1/2"(cid:18) FWHMm
FWHMn(cid:19)2
− 1#−1/2
(9b)
index is
At the characteristic radius rmn the spectral
greater than at the cluster center by one. The compari-
son of the theoretical profil (9) and the observed spectral-
index distribution may serve as an additional check on the
consistency of the data; and it gives a hint on the degree
of reliability of the Gaussian fits.
As a first example, we consider the observations at
m = 326 MHz (Venturi et al. 1990) and n = 1.38 GHz
(Kim et al. 1990) (see Table 1 and Sect. 3.3) . Inserting
FWHM326MHz ≃ 24′ and FWHM1.38GHz ≃ 16′ in defi-
nition (5) we obtain qmn = 0.28. The spectral index of
the integrated flux is αS,mn = 1.23. Then, for reasons of
consistency, the central value of the spectral index of the
surface brightness αI,mn(0) should be 0.67 according to
relation (8). This value is slightly smaller but still in good
agreement with the value measured by Giovannini et al.
6
B.M. Deiss et al.: The large-scale structure of the diffuse radio halo of the Coma cluster at 1.4 GHz
(1993) (0.6 - 0.8; their Fig. 4). Hence, according to (7),
the spectral index of the emission coefficient at the clus-
ter's center is αǫ,mn(0) ≈ 0.4 − 0.5. From Eq. (9b) we
infer a characteristic radius of the spectral-index distribu-
tion of rmn = 15.′6; i.e., the spectral index (9a) increases
from its central value of 0.67 to a value of 0.93 at a pro-
jected radius of b = 8′ (the central "plateau" according
to Giovannini et al. 1993), and it reaches 1.8 at b = 16.′6
. This shows that the theoretical spectral-index distribu-
tion fits the main features of the observed one; hence, the
assumption of Gaussian surface brightness profils does not
introduce artificial inconsistencies. Thus, within the frame
of our simplifying assumptions, the observational data at
326 MHz and 1.38 GHz appear to be consistent.
As a second example, we consider the Effelsberg obser-
vations at m = 1.4 GHz (present work) and n = 2.7 GHz
(Schlickeiser et al. 1987). From the measurements of the
integrated flux densities one infers a value for the spectral
index of αS,mn = 3.37. Taking FWHM1.4GHz = 15.′2 and
FWHM2.7GHz ≃ 12′, we obtain rmn = 9.′5 and qmn = 0.36;
the latter implies that, according to (8), the spectral in-
dex of the surface brightness at b = 0 should have a value
of αI,mn(0) = 2.65. The peak surface brightness of the
2.7 GHz map is ∼ 11 mJy/beam (beamwidth 4.′3). The
peak surface brighness of our 1.4 GHz map (Fig. 2) is
∼ 130 mJy, where the beamwidth is 9.′35; this would re-
duce roughly by a factor of (4.′3/9.′35)2 = 0.21 if one used
a 4.′3 beam. Hence, one derives a value of the surface-
brightness index of αI,mn(0) ∼ 1.40 which is consider-
ably smaller than that expected from relation (8). Our
1.4 GHz observations appear to be in accord with the
measurements made by Kim et al. (1990), as has been
discussed above. Hence, the disagreement between the in-
dices strongly indicates that the 2.7 GHz data are incon-
sistent, in the sense that the value of the integrated diffuse
flux given by Schlickeiser et al. (1987) is, most probably,
too low. Since the observed surface brightness at 2.7 GHz
declines rapidly in the peripheral region of the halo, an
extension of the integration area, which might have been
too small, would lead to an increase of the total flux of
only a few percent. Another source of error, to which the
integrated-flux measurement at 2.7 GHz is very sensitive
due to the low surface brightness, is the determination of
the correct intensity offset of the diffuse emission. For in-
stance, one would yield an additional integrated diffuse
flux of ∼ 50 mJy if one lowered the intensity offset by
only 1 mJy/beam; however, the resulting spectral indices
were still inconsistent in that case. The data would be
roughly consistent, if the surface brightness at 2.7 GHz
were about 2.5 mJy/beam higher than the values given
in the 2.7 GHz map; the integrated diffuse flux density
would then presumably amount to S2.7GHz ∼ 200 mJy and
the values of the spectral indices would be αS,mn ≈ 1.8
and αI,mn(0) ≈ 1.1, while the FWHM would increase only
slightly. In that case, αǫ,mn(0) were about 0.75 at the clus-
ter's center.
Since the scale size of the halo appears to be a decreas-
ing function of frequency, one expects, for reasons of con-
sistency, an increase of the spectral index of the integrated
diffuse flux density. However, the extremly sharp spectral
break above 1.4 GHz, suggested by the presently avail-
able integrated-flux data, seems to be unrealistic. Never-
theless, above 1.4 GHz the spectral index of the emission
coefficient seems to increase even in the core region of the
cluster.
4.2. Implications on theories of halo formation
In this section, we discuss some implications on theories
of radio halo formation following from the considerations
of the previous section and from the observed large extent
of the radio halo at 1.4 GHz and its clear similarity with
the X-ray halo.
The dominant energy loss processes of the relativis-
tic electrons in the intracluster medium are synchrotron
emission and inverse Compton scattering off the cosmic
microwave background radiation (CMB).
The "lifetime" of an (isotropic) ensemble of relativistic
electrons radiating at 1.4 GHz is given by (Pacholczyk
1970)
τloss = 1.3 108(cid:18) B
µG(cid:19)1/2(cid:18)1 +
2
3
B2
CMB(cid:19)−1
B2
yr,
(10)
where the "monochromatic approximation" is used, and
where BCMB = 3.18(1 + z)2µG denotes the magnitude of
the magnetic field equivalent to the CMB. The magnetic
field strength in the intracluster medium of the Coma clus-
ter is still a matter of debate. Kim et al. (1990) derived
a magnetic field strength of B = 1.7 ± 0.9µG using ex-
cess Faraday rotation measure (RM) of polarized emis-
sion from background radio sources. Recently, however,
Feretti et al. (1995) inferred a much stronger magnetic
field of ∼ 6 ± 1 h1/2
50 µG from polarization data of the ra-
dio galaxy NGC 4869 located in the central region of the
cluster. Hence, the electrons' lifetime seems to be at most
108 years.
This short lifetime and the observed large extent of
the 1.4-GHz halo augment the well-known diffusion speed
problem of the primary-electron model suggested by Jaffe
(1977) and Rephaeli (1979): In order to reach the edge of
the halo, "primary electrons" which are presumed to be
ejected from central radio galaxies must propagate at a
speed of at least vprop = 1.5 104(R/1.5 Mpc) km/s. This is
an order of magnitude larger than the ion sound speed cion
which is on the order of 1500 km/s, and at which speed
relativistic particles are expected to propagate through
the hot intracluster medium (Holman et al. 1979). Hence,
it seems to be more plausible that the electrons have been
accelerated or, at least, reaccelerated in situ.
From the discussion of the previous section we find
that, in the core region of the Coma cluster, the spec-
tral index of the synchrotron emission coefficient between
B.M. Deiss et al.: The large-scale structure of the diffuse radio halo of the Coma cluster at 1.4 GHz
7
326 MHz and 1.38 GHz is αǫ,mn(r <
= 9′) ≈ 0.4 − 0.75
which implies an energy spectrum index of the electrons
of x ≈ 1.6 − 2.5. Considering only the integrated spec-
trum, Coma C is usually classified as a steep-spectrum
radio source, i.e. α > 0.75 and hence x > 2.5; obviously,
this does not apply to the halo's core region. This indicates
that there must be some very effective mechanism for par-
ticle acceleration operating in the ICM in the core region
of the cluster: one would expect a power-law energy distri-
bution with x = 2.5 if the electrons were purely originat-
ing in a rapid leakage from radio galaxies (see, e.g., Feretti
et al. 1990 for the radio tail galaxy NGC 4869); particle
acceleration in strong shocks would produce a power law
with x = 2 (see e.g. Longair 1994 and references therein),
while stochastic second order Fermi acceleration leads to
an exponentially decreasing energy spectrum (Schlickeiser
1984) which, however, may be rather flat (effective x < 2)
in the low-energy range below some characteristic energy.
Recently, De Young (1992) and Tribble (1993) sug-
gested that radio halos are transient features associated
with a major merger of two galaxy clusters creating tur-
bulence and shocks in the ICM: even a small conversion
efficiency should then easily accelerate high-energy parti-
cles. This model has the great advantage to offer a natural
explanation for the rarity of the radio halo phenomenon:
after a merger event the radio emission fades on time scales
of order ∼ 108 yr due to the energy loss of the relativis-
tic electrons, while the time between mergers is roughly
2 − 4 × 109 yr (Edge et al. 1992). The model seems to be
supported by radio observations (Bridle & Fomalont 1976)
and X-ray observations (Briel et al. 1991) of the merging
cluster A2256 which shows that the large diffuse radio halo
is just covering the merger region of the cluster (Bohringer
et al. 1992; Bohringer 1995). Regarding the Coma cluster,
substructures in the X-ray map as well as in the phase
space distribution of the cluster galaxies have been inter-
preted by White et al. (1993) and Colless & Dunn (1996)
as observational evidences for an ongoing merger between
the main cluster and a galaxy group dominated by NGC
4889 in the cluster's center. Such an ongoing merger may
account for the rather small spectral index αǫ,mn in the
center of the radio halo by just enhancing the (preexisting)
turbulent velocity field in the intracluster medium (Deiss
& Just 1996), leading to an amplification of the stochastic
acceleration process (see below). However, it is yet un-
clear whether the entire extended radio halo is caused by
a single major merger as suggested by Young and Trib-
ble and whether the cluster's substructures observed by
White et al. and Colless & Dunn are the remaining indi-
cations of such an event. In contrast to what is observed
in the Coma cluster, one would expect that aging diffuse
radio halos produced in a single burst had rather irregu-
lar and asymmetric shapes. The relaxation time scale for
a merged system of galaxies is of the order of the galaxies'
crossing time which is ∼ 109 years. If a major merger had
happened only a few 108 years ago, which would be neces-
sary considering the rather short fading time of the halo,
one would expect a much more pronounced double-peaked
phase space distribution of the galaxies of the main clus-
ter than it is observed by Colless & Dunn (1996). Hence,
even if Coma C is a transient phenomenon it can hardly
be explained by a recent major merger of two galaxy clus-
ters. An additional problem is, how, in a single merger
event, electrons could be accelerated to relativistic ener-
gies out of the thermal pool throughout the whole cluster
volume. According to standard particle-acceleration the-
ory (e.g. Longair 1994), a preexisting ensemble of relativis-
tic particles is required, in order to effectively accelerate
electrons to higher energies by shock waves. That, in turn,
suggests the requirement of the existence of some continu-
ously operating reacceleration mechanism as discussed in
the following.
An alternative to the cluster merger model is the "in-
situ acceleration model" proposed by Jaffe (1977). In this
model, the relativistic electrons are assumed to be con-
tinuously reaccelerated by some mechanism operating in
the (turbulent) intracluster medium. An advantage of this
model is that it provides a natural explanation for the
similarities between diffuse radio halo and X-ray halo of
the Coma cluster, since one may expect a close link be-
tween the physical conditions of the relativistic particles
and that of the thermal component of the intracluster
medium. If the relativistic electrons, released from some
central source, are continuously reaccelerated a propaga-
tion speed of ∼ 150 km/s is sufficient to reach the pe-
ripheral regions of the radio halo within a Hubble time.
Giovannini et al. (1993) suggested that the orgin of the
relativistic electrons of Coma C may be the large head-
tail radio galaxy NGC 4869, orbiting at the Coma cluster
center.
Deiss & Just (1996) showed that, due to the gravi-
tational drag of the randomly moving galaxies, one may
expect turbulent motions Vturb of the intracluster medium
of up to 600 km/s in the core region of the Coma cluster.
This suggests that the relativistic electrons are contin-
uously reaccelerated by a stochastic second-order Fermi
process. According to the usual stochastic Fermi accel-
eration theory, the acceleration time scale τacc is given
by τacc = 9κ/ < V 2 > (e.g. Drury 1983), where κ
and V denote the spatial diffusion coefficient and the
rms speed of the scattering centers which are presumably
small-scale magnetic-field irregularities. The diffusion co-
efficient is proportional to the scattering mean free path
of the particles, its value is expected to be on the order of
1027 − 1029cm2/s. The propagation speed of the scatterers
is basically the Alfven speed VAlf which is on the order of
100 km/s relative to the background medium. However,
since the magnetic field is presumably 'frozen' in the tur-
bulent ICM, the scatterers' squared velocity amounts to
V 2 ≈ V 2
Alf . The correlation length Lcorr of the ex-
cited stochastic velocity field is ∼ 20 kpc (Deiss & Just
1996) which is considerably larger than the 'microscopic'
turb + V 2
8
B.M. Deiss et al.: The large-scale structure of the diffuse radio halo of the Coma cluster at 1.4 GHz
scattering mean free path of the particles. That means,
in calculating the stochastic acceleration time scale, the
usual diffusion coefficient κ still applies. Hence, adopting
κ = 1029cm2/s one expects a stochastic acceleration time
scale of τacc ∼ 107 years at the center of the Coma clus-
ter. On the other hand, the more 'macroscopic' turbulent
motions generate a turbulent diffusion, hence increasing
the particles' propagation speed above the Alfven speed,
at least in the cluster's center. The excited turbulent mo-
tions scale like V 2
turb ∝ ngal (Deiss & Just 1996) where ngal
is the number density of the galaxies; hence, at a cluster
radius of 40′ the reacceleration time scale τacc is on the
order of ∼ 109 years. This is still fast enough to sustain an
ensemble of relativistic electrons, although with a steeper
energy distribution than in the cluster's center. This is in
accord with the observed scale-size-vs.-frequency relation
and with the steepening of the spectral index distribution
with increasing cluster radius (see above).
In a simple leaky box model, the steady state energy
distribution of relativistic electrons, being stochastically
accelerated and losing energy via synchrotron emission
and inverse Compton scattering, may be well approxi-
mated by (Schlickeiser et al. 1987)
N (E) ∝ E−Γexp(cid:18)−
E
Ec(cid:19) ,
(11)
where the spectral index of the power law part and the
characteristic energy are given by
3
2(cid:18)1 +
4τacc
9τesc(cid:19)1/2
−
1
2
Γ =
and
Ec = 12.7 GeV(cid:20)(cid:18)1 +
2
3
B2
B2
CMB(cid:19) τacc
108yr(cid:21)−1
(12)
,
(13)
respectively. Since the escape time τesc is on the order of
the Hubble time, we have Γ ≈ 1. If we set B = 6µG
(Feretti et al. 1995) and τacc = 107 years in Eq. (13)
we derive a value of the characteristic electron energy of
Ec = 38 GeV. The relativistic electrons in the cluster
core, radiating at 326MHz and 1.4 GHz, have energies
of only 1.8 (B/6µG)1/2 GeV and 3.8 (B/6µG)1/2 GeV re-
spectively. This implies a value of the energy spectrum in-
dex of only x ≈ 1.1 in that energy range. In order to match
the observationally determined value of x of ∼ 1.6, the ef-
ficiency for stochastic reacceleration may still be even an
order of magnitude smaller than inferred above. Hence,
stochastic reacceleration of the electrons amplified by tur-
bulent gas motion, originating from galaxy motion inside
the cluster, appears to be sufficiently strong to account for
the rather small radio emission index in the core region of
Coma C and to sustain the cluster-wide distribution of the
relativistic particles in that rich cluster.
In order to explain the rarity of the radio halo phe-
nomenon, Giovannini et al. suggested that, while the con-
ditions for the in-situ acceleration and the presence of a
cluster-wide magnetic field (e.g. Kronberg 1994, and ref-
erences therein) are likely to be common in rich clusters,
one or more radio tail galaxies have to be present to pro-
duce the required number of relativistic electrons. How-
ever, there may be another constraint, namely that of a
high enough efficiency of the reacceleration mechanism
which may depend on some details in a cluster's struc-
ture; diffuse radio halos of otherwise globally similar clus-
ters would then have a rather dissimilar appearance. For
instance, for the core region of the Perseus cluster, Deiss
& Just (1996) inferred a turbulent velocity of the ICM of
∼ 200 km/s, i.e., three times smaller than in Coma, which
implies a ten times longer acceleration time than in the
Coma cluster; if, in addition, the magnetic field is ∼ 20µG
like in other cooling flow clusters, i.e. about three times
stronger than in Coma, the inferred characteristic energy
Ec of the electron distribution in the core region of the
Perseus cluster is two orders of magnitudes smaller than
in the Coma cluster. Obviously, such an electron distri-
bution is not able to produce an extended radio halo at
the GHz-range, although it may account for the observed
'minihalo' at 330 Mhz (Burns et al. 1992). This suggests
that, while a cluster-wide distribution of relativistic elec-
trons is likely to be common, in only a few clusters the
conditions are such that the electrons gain enough energy
to produce an extended halo observable at some hundred
Megahertz. We suspect that there are far more galaxy
clusters having a diffuse radio halo than have been ob-
served so far; though these halos would be observable only
at rather low frequencies (well below 100 MHz), at which
a systematic survey has yet to be done. In that picture
of radio halo formation, the role of a merger is that of an
amplifier of the preexisting overall stochastic reaccelera-
tion mechanism, and not that of the prime cause of the
halo formation.
The origin of the intracluster magnetic field still re-
mains unclear. Of course, it appears to be an attractive
idea that galaxy motion may also drive a turbulent dy-
namo by which faint seed fields could be amplified to
(chaotic) microgauss fields. This suggestion has been ex-
plored by Jaffe (1980), Roland (1981), and Ruzmaikin et
al. (1989). More recently, however, De Young (1992) has
shown that it is in general very difficult for this mech-
anism to produce microgauss fields on 10 kpc scales: In
order to drive a turbulent dynamo on such scales, more
energetic processes, like subcluster merging, must be en-
voked. Hence, it appears that, while reaccelerating rel-
ativistic electrons via galaxy motion may work, creating
the intracluster magnetic field via galaxy motion probably
does not.
B.M. Deiss et al.: The large-scale structure of the diffuse radio halo of the Coma cluster at 1.4 GHz
9
5. Summary and Conclusions
We presented new measurements of the diffuse radio emis-
sion from the Coma cluster at 1.4 GHz using the Effelsberg
single-dish telescope. After subtracting contributions from
298 point sources we obtained a radio map exhibiting the
large scale characteristics of the diffuse radio halo source
Coma C. From the large angular extent down to noise of
∼ 80′, one concludes that the radio halo in Coma is a
cluster-wide phenomenon which is not restricted to only
the cluster core region. This implies the presence of rela-
tivistic electrons as well as of a magnetic field throughout
a spatial volume with a diameter of ∼ 3 Mpc.
The integrated diffuse flux from Coma C is 640 ± 35
mJy at 1.4 GHz. This value fits neatly a power-law ex-
trapolation from lower frequencies, showing that a pos-
sible steepening of the integrated spectrum may appear
only above 1.4 GHz.
We derived, under some simplifying assumptions, mu-
tual relations between the observationally determined
spectral indices of the integrated diffuse flux density, the
surface brightness and the halo's scale size, and the spec-
tral index of the synchrotron emission coefficient. These
relations allow one i) to achieve a rough estimate con-
cerning the consistency of the presently available data at
different frequencies and ii) to place constraints on the
emissivity index distribution: i) We conclude that the 2.7
GHz measurements by Schlickeiser et al. (1987) are not
consistent to our measurements. We suspect that the value
of the integrated flux given by these authors is much too
low, which implies that the claimed strong steepening of
the spectrum above 1.4 GHz is not real. This has implica-
tions on current theories of radio halo formation. Hence,
in order to be able to derive constraints on the physics of
the formation process of the Coma radio halo, one needs
more and improved measurements at frequencies above
1.4 GHz. ii) In the core region of the halo, the emissivity
index between 0.3 GHz and 1.4 GHz appears to be in the
range 0.4 - 0.75 which implies an energy spectrum index of
the electrons of x ≈ 1.6 − 2.5. From that we conclude that
there must be some very effective mechanism for particle
acceleration operating in the intracluster medium.
We argued that the observed large extent of Coma C,
its regular shape as well as its clear similarity with the
X-ray halo support an in-situ acceleration model for radio
halo formation, since one may expect a close link between
the physical conditions of the relativistic particles and that
of the thermal component of the intracluster medium. We
showed that in the Coma cluster stochastic reacceleration
of the electrons, amplified by turbulent gas motion origi-
nating from galaxy motion inside the cluster (Deiss & Just
1996), appears to be sufficiently strong to account for the
inferred rather small radio emission index in the core re-
gion of Coma C and to sustain a cluster-wide distribution
of relativistic particles in that rich cluster.
We suggested that the rarity of the radio halo phe-
nomenon has its origin in that the efficiency of the stochas-
tic reacceleration mechanism may depend on some details
of the clusters' structure: diffuse radio halos of otherwise
globally similar clusters may have a rather dissimilar ap-
pearance. That means, while a cluster-wide distribution of
relativistic electrons is likely to be common in rich clus-
ters, in only a few of them the conditions are such that
the electrons gain enough energy to produce an extended
halo observable at some hundred Megahertz. However, we
suspect that at low frequencies (well below 100 MHz) dif-
fuse radio halos of galaxy clusters are much more common
than it is suggested by the presently available data.
Acknowledgements. We like to thank Dr. Tom Landecker for
making the list of radio sources from the Coma cluster of galax-
ies available to us in digital form.
References
Bohringer, H. 1995, Rev. Mod. Astron. 8, 259
Bohringer, H., Schwarz, R.A., Briel, U.G., Voges, W., Ebel-
ing, H., Hartner, G., Crudace, R.G. 1992, in: Clusters and
Superclusters of Galaxies, Fabian, A.C. (ed.), Kluwer, p. 71
Bridle, A.H., Fomalont E.B. 1976, A&A 52, 107
Briel, U.G., Henry, J.P., Bohringer, H. 1992, A&A 259, L31
Briel, U.G., Henry, J.P., Schwarz, R.A., Bohringer, H., Ebeling,
H., Edge, A.C., Hartner, G., Schindler, S., Trumper, J.,
Voges, W. 1991, A&A 246, L10
Burns, J.O., Sulkanen, M.E., Gisler, G.R., Perley, R.A. 1992,
ApJ 388, L49
Colless, M., Dunn, A.M. 1996, ApJ 458, 435
Cordey, R.A. 1985, MNRAS 215, 437
Deiss, B.M., Just, A. 1996, A&A 305, 407
De Young, D.S. 1992, ApJ 386, 464
Drury, L. O'C 1983, Rep. Prog. Phys. 46, 973
Edge, A.C., Stewart, G.C., Fabian, A.C. 1992, MNRAS 258,
177
Emerson, D.T., Grave, R. 1988, A&A 190, 353
Feretti,L., Dallacasa, D., Giovannini, G., Tagliani, A. 1995,
A&A 302, 680
Feretti,L., Dallacasa, D., Giovannini, G., Venturi, T. 1990,
A&A 232, 337
Giovannini, G., Feretti, L., Venturi, T., Kim, K.-T., Kronberg,
P.P. 1993, ApJ 406, 399
Hanisch, R.J. 1980, AJ 85, 1565
Hanisch, R.J. 1982, A&A 116, 137
Hanisch, R.J., Erickson, W.C. 1980, AJ 85, 183
Harris, D.E., Kapahi, V.K., Ekers R.D. 1980 A&AS 39, 215
Harris, D.E., Miley, G.K. 1978, A&AS 34, 117
Henning, P. 1989, AJ 97, 1561
Holman, G.D., Ionson, J.A., Scott, J.S. 1979, ApJ 228, 576
Jaffe, W.J. 1977, ApJ 212, 1
Jaffe, W.J. 1980, ApJ 241, 924
Kim, K.-T. 1994, A&AS 105, 403
Kim, K.-T, Kronberg, P.P., Dewdney, P.E., Landecker, T.L.
1990, A&A 355, 29
Kim, K.-T, Tribble, P.C., Kronberg, P.P. 1991, ApJ 379, 80
Kim, K.-T, Kronberg, P.P., Dewdney, P.E., Landecker, T.L.
1994, A&AS 105, 385
10
B.M. Deiss et al.: The large-scale structure of the diffuse radio halo of the Coma cluster at 1.4 GHz
King, I.R. 1966, AJ 71, 64
Kronberg, P.P. 1994, Rep. Prog. Phys. 57, 325
Longair, M.S. 1994, High Energy Astrophysics (2nd Edition),
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Pacholczyk, A.G. 1970, Radio Astrophysics, eds. G. Burbidge
& M. Burbidge, Freeman and Company, San Francisco
Reich, W., Furst, E., Reich, P., Reif, K. 1990, A&AS 85,633
Rephaeli, Y. 1979, ApJ 227, 364
Ruzmaikin, A.A., Sokoloff, D., Shukurov, A. 1989, MNRAS
241, 1
Sarazin, C.L. 1988, X-ray Emission from Clusters of Galaxies,
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Sarazin, C.L., Rood, J.H., Struble, M.F. 1982, A&A 108, 17
Schindler, S., Muller, E. 1993, A&A 272, 137
Schlickeiser, R. 1984, A&A 227, 236
Schlickeiser, R., Sievers, A., Thiemann, H. 1987, A&A 182, 21
Tribble, P.C. 1993, MNRAS 263, 31
Venturi, T., Giovannini, G., Feretti, L. 1990, AJ 99, 1381
Waldthausen, H. 1980, Ph.D.Thesis, Universiy of Bonn, Ger-
many
White, S.D.M., Briel, U.G., Henry,J.P. 1993, MNRAS 261, L8
This article was processed by the author using Springer-Verlag
LaTEX A&A style file L-AA version 3.
This figure "comafig1.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9609189v1
This figure "comafig2.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9609189v1
2
102
5
2
m
a
e
b
/
y
J
m
101
5
2
100
5
2
5
101
/arcmin
2
102
5
2
101
5
2
y
J
/
S
100
5
2
10-1
5
2
10-2
10-2
2
5
10-1
100
2
5
101
2
5
/GHz
|
astro-ph/0406483 | 2 | 0406 | 2004-06-23T15:49:20 | GRS 1915+105 and the Disc-Jet Coupling in Accreting Black Hole Systems | [
"astro-ph"
] | GRS 1915+105 - the first stellar-scale, highly relativistic jet source identified - is a key system for our understanding of the disc-jet coupling in accreting black hole systems. Comprehending the coupling between inflow and outflow in this source is important not only for X-ray binary systems but has a broader relevance for studies of active galactic nuclei and gamma-ray bursts. In this paper, we present a detailed review of the observational properties of the system, as established in the decade since its discovery. We attempt to place it in context by a detailed comparison with other sources, and construct a simple model for the disc-jet coupling, which may be more widely applicable to accreting black hole systems. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
GRS 1915+105 and the Disc-Jet Coupling in
Accreting Black Hole Systems
Rob Fender
Astronomical Institute Anton Pannekoek, University of Amsterdam, Kruislaan 403, 1098 SJ Amsterdam,
The Netherlands
Tomaso Belloni
INAF -- Osservatorio Astronomico di Brera, Via E. Bianchi 46, I-23807 Merate, Italy
KEYWORDS: accretion, accretion disks, black hole physics, ISM: jets and outflows, X-rays:binaries,
radio continuum:stars
ABSTRACT: GRS 1915+105 -- the first stellar-scale, highly relativistic jet source identified --
is a key system for our understanding of the disc-jet coupling in accreting black hole systems.
Comprehending the coupling between inflow and outflow in this source is important not only
for X-ray binary systems but has a broader relevance for studies of active galactic nuclei and
gamma-ray bursts. In this paper, we present a detailed review of the observational properties of
the system, as established in the decade since its discovery. We attempt to place it in context by
a detailed comparison with other sources, and construct a simple model for the disc-jet coupling,
which may be more widely applicable to accreting black hole systems.
Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 2004 42
1056-8700/04/0610-0000$14.00
CONTENTS
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
GRS 1915+105 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Discovery and Early Observations
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
X-Ray Spectral Variability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2
4
4
4
Radio and Infrared Emission . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
14
Radio and Infrared Evidence for Disc-Jet Coupling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
20
Other Sources: GRS 1915+105 in Context . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
24
Black Hole X-ray Binary States . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
24
GRS 1915+105 A/B/C States and Other Systems
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Active Galactic Nuclei
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
26
27
Interpretation: Many Flavors of Disc-Jet Coupling or Just One? . . . . . . . . . .
28
Hard States and Jet Formation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
28
On the Trigger of Optically Thin Events . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
29
Jet Power and Velocity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
30
A Unified (Toy) Model of Disc-Jet Coupling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
31
Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
34
1
Introduction
Jets -- highly relativistic, collimated, powerful outflows -- seem to be an almost
ubiquitous feature of accreting black holes, and yet remain poorly understood.
Widely studied in active galactic nuclei (AGN), their association with the coupled
process of accretion has been obstructed by the long dynamical timescales asso-
ciated with these objects. How matter falling at high speed toward a black hole
2
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
3
manages to escape to the external universe remains a mystery 1 that can only be
solved by studying the coupled processes of inflow and outflow. The key to this
puzzle seems to lie with binary systems in our own galaxy, which harbor stellar-
mass (5 -- 15 M⊙) black holes that -- we are just beginning to appreciate -- seem to
display the same kind of inflow:outflow coupling as AGN but on timescales typi-
cally six to eight orders of magnitude shorter in proportion to M. Thus, although
AGN are the powerhouses of the universe, it is their nearby cousins, which vary
rapidly enough that humans may follow the changes in the disc-jet coupling, to
which we turn for an understanding of the relation between accretion and jets
around black holes.
With the launch of the Rossi X-Ray Timing satellite (RXTE), an unprece-
dented wealth of X-ray data from black hole candidates (BHC) has become avail-
able to the astronomical community. In particular, several bright transient sys-
tems have been followed with a large number of densely packed observations (see
McClintock & Remillard 2004). These observations have increased our knowledge
of the high-energy properties of these systems, although we still do not have a
complete picture of the physical mechanisms underlying the X-ray emission.
GRS 1915+105, a binary system in our galaxy containing an accreting black
hole of probable mass ∼ 15M⊙, is a key object for the study of the disc-jet
connection. Its peculiar X-ray properties, coupled with other characteristics in
common with other systems, allow us to study in detail the instabilities of the
accreting gas. These instabilities have been positively associated with the ejection
of relativistic jets and to related flaring episodes in the radio band. This means
that the interaction of emitted powerful collimated jets can be studied on different
timescales and associated with (near-)simultaneous events in the accretion flow
that provides the gas for them. The uniqueness of GRS 1915+105 stimulated us
to center a full discussion on the disc-jet coupling on this system.
The review is structured as follows: In Section 2, the X-ray and radio properties
of GRS 1915+105 are described, followed by the disc-jet coupling evidences in
this system. In Section 3, we describe other BHCs in a similar fashion, whereas
in Section 4, we concentrate on discussing the comparison between all systems.
Our main conclusions are presented in Section 5.
1To quote Krolik (1999), "In principle one could imagine that accretion onto a black hole
occurs without any outflow at any point. Put another way, we do not know why jets exist."
4
2 GRS 1915+105
Fender & Belloni
2.1 Discovery and Early Observations
GRS 1915+105 was discovered on August 15, 2002, with the WATCH instru-
ment on board GRANAT as a 300 mCrab transient (Castro-Tirado et al. 1992,
1994) and immediately detected at higher energies by CGRO/BATSE (Harmon
et al. 1992). A time-variable radio counterpart (Mirabel et al. 1993a) and an
IR counterpart (Castro-Tirado et al. 1993, Mirabel et al. 1993b) were discov-
ered in the ROSAT HRI error box (Greiner 1993). The X-ray spectrum ap-
peared to be variable and two-component (see, e.g., Alexandrovich et al. 1994).
GRANAT/WATCH and CGRO/BATSE monitoring of the source showed peri-
ods of nondetection but never simultaneously in both instruments, indicating that
GRS 1915+105 was continuing the same outburst started in 1992 (see Zhang et
al. 1995, Sazonov & Sunyaev 1995, Paciesas et al. 1996, Harmon et al. 1997).
A BATSE hard X-ray light curve extending up to the beginning of 1996 can be
seen in Figure 1. Paciesas et al. (1996) realized that the source was showing an
unusual level of variability, although the true uniqueness of its nature was not
clear from those data. The radio counterpart of GRS 1915+105 was observed
to be variable in flux and spectrum (see Rodr´iguez & Mirabel 1993), and the
radio variability was correlated to the hard X-ray flux (Mirabel et al. 1994). The
major breakthrough took place when Mirabel & Rodr´iguez (1994) used the VLA
radio to observe components moving away from GRS 1915+105 with apparent
superluminal velocity, at the same time estimating a distance of 12.5 kpc (see
Rodr´iguez et al. 1995), which excluded an extragalactic origin. GRS 1915+105
became the first superluminal source in our Galaxy (see Section 2.3.1).
2.2 X-Ray Spectral Variability
The launch of RXTE opened a new window to GRS 1915+105. The large area
of the proportional counter array (PCA) (Jahoda et al. 1996), the broad-band
coverage provided by the High-Energy X-ray Timing Experiment (HEXTE) in-
strument (Rothschild et al. 1998), the monitoring capabilities of the All-Sky
Monitor (ASM) (Levine et al. 1996), and the extreme flexibility of scheduling
and pointing were key factors that allowed a more complete view of the unique
X-ray properties of this system. The full ASM light curve from the start of the
RXTE mission to October 12, 2003, averaged over one-day bins, can be seen in
Figure 2. These data start just after the time window of the BATSE data in
Figure 1. From Figure 2, the peculiarity of the variability of GRS 1915+105 on
timescales longer than one day is evident. Greiner et al. (1996) were the first to
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
5
report an unusual level of X-ray variability in GRS 1915+105 on timescales of
subseconds to days. The light curves presented in that work were complex and
structured in a way that was never observed before in any X-ray source. The
authors attributed this variability to the effect of a major accretion disc instabil-
ity and argued that major events like those shown in Figure 3 could be related
to radio flares observed later. A classification of spectral/timing patterns from
early RXTE/PCA data was presented by Chen et al. (1997), who identified two
spectral states: a hard one with a strong 0.5 -- 6.0 Hz quasi-periodic oscillations
(QPOs), and a soft one with no QPOs (see also Paul et al. 1997). In the same
year, Belloni et al. (1997a) accumulated PCA energy spectra from the high-flux
and low-flux intervals seen in Figure 3 and fitted them with the "standard" sim-
plified model for BHCs, consisting of a disc-blackbody component (see Mitsuda
et al. 1984) plus a power-law component to account for the high-energy tail. The
free parameters of this model are the flux Fpl and photon index Γ of the power-
law and the inner radius of the accretion disc Rin and temperature at the inner
radius Tin. The strong and sudden hardening events seen in the hardness curve in
Figure 3 can then be understood in terms of a hardening (from Γ ∼3.6 to Γ ∼2.2)
of the power law and a softening (kTin ∼ 2.2 to ∼0.6 keV) of the disc component.
At the same time, the inner-disc radius Rin, which in many sources had been
observed to remain constant at a value of a few dozen kilometers (interpreted
as the innermost stable orbit, see Tanaka & Lewin 1995; see below) was seen to
increase from ∼20 to ∼300 km. The interpretation of these transitions, which
happened on a timescale of a few seconds, was that they were due to the onset
of a thermal-viscous instability. In this framework, the sudden increase in Rin
corresponded to the inner portion of the accretion disc becoming unobservable in
the X-ray band. The accreting matter passing through Rin would slowly "refill"
the unobservable region on a viscous timescale, increasing the surface density of
the inner portion of the disc until the reverse transition would take place and go
back to a fully observable disc. In this interpretation, it is not necessary that
the inner part of the disc is completely emptied of gas, but simply that the gas
makes a transition to a much cooler state, which makes it effectively invisible in
X-rays.
This picture was subsequently strengthened by the analysis of more observa-
tions (Belloni et al. 1997b). Time-resolved spectroscopy allowed the evolution
of the spectral parameters to be followed in detail (see Figure 4). In particular,
Belloni et al. (1997b) found that in the soft intervals, Rin was approximately
constant around 20 km, independent of the length of the interval, whereas in
the hard intervals, the radius showed a time evolution. The maximum radius
reached in each hard interval was strongly correlated with the length of the in-
terval thard (see Figure 5) and anticorrelated with the minimum flux reached. In
the framework of the instability picture of Belloni et al. (1997a), this has a direct
6
Fender & Belloni
interpretation: The spectral evolution and the duration of the event are deter-
mined by one parameter only, namely, the radius of the missing inner section of
the accretion disc, i.e., Rin. For a large radius, the drop in flux will be large and
the time needed for refill will be long. Associating the refill time with the disc
viscous timescale tvisc at Rin, can be expressed as
tvisc = 30α−1
−2M −1/2
1
R7/2
7
M −2
18 s,
(1)
where α−2 = α/0.01, R7 is the radius in units of 107cm, M1 is the black hole
mass in solar masses, and M18 is the accretion rate in units of 1018 g/s (see Belloni
M
et al. 1997b). From this, under the reasonable assumption that the external
does not vary within a one-hour observation, we expect to observe
thard ∝ R7/2
in .
(2)
The line in Figure 5 shows a fit of thard versus Rin with a y = x3.5 relation: Only
the longest interval deviates from the expected relation. The two quantities thard
and Rin are determined in a completely different fashion, the first from timing
analysis and the second from a spectral decomposition, ensuring that the observed
correlation is not spurious. The relation in Figure 5 is a direct measurement of
the radial dependence of a fundamental quantity of an accretion disc, obtained
through the analysis of the variability from a source that is indeed peculiar,
but also shows many properties in common with other systems. Owing to the
approximations in the disc blackbody model, the measurement of the inner-disc
radius cannot be considered precise in its absolute value (see Merloni et al. 2000),
although large variations, such as those observed in GRS 1915+105, cannot be
due to these approximations. From this observation, a one-to-one correlation
between the length of an instability interval and the following high-rate interval
was found. Yadav et al. (1999) found that indeed in many observations made
with the IXAE satellite, the length of the instability interval correlated with
the length of the following high-rate interval and not with that of the preceding
one. Therefore, the full observed high-low cycles are caused by the onset of
the instability, which is not directly influenced by the duration of the "stable"
interval.
2.2.1 Classification and Source Spectral States
Markwardt et al. (1999), analyzing in detail a specific RXTE/PCA observation
from 1997, identified three separate states on the basis of timing and spectral
characteristics. Figure 6 shows the spectral characterization of these states in
terms of power-law photon index and inner-disc temperature.
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
7
A complete classification of the light curves observed by RXTE/PCA from
GRS 1915+105 during the first two years of the mission was presented by Belloni
et al. (2000). The observed light curves were divided into 12 classes (shown in
Figure 7) on the basis of their timing and color properties. These 12 classes, later
increased to 13 by Klein-Wolt et al. (2002) and possibly to 14 by Hannikainen et
al. (2003), are not meant to be exhaustive but as a starting point for subsequent
analysis. From this classification and from a detailed analysis of X-ray color-color
diagrams, Belloni et al. (2000) concluded that, as suggested by Markwardt et al.
(1999) for a single observation, indeed the flux and spectral variability of GRS
1915+105 can be interpreted as transitions between three separate states. They
called these states A, B, and C. Figure 8 shows a schematic view of the three
states in terms of their X-ray colors:
• State A: softer spectrum, dominated by a disc component with kTin > 1
keV. Mostly little time variability.
• State B: softer spectrum, dominated by a disc component with a larger
temperature than state A. Substantial red-noise variability on timescales >
1 s.
• State C: hard colors, with the spectrum dominated by a relatively flat
power-law (Γ=1.8 -- 2.5). White noise variability on timescales >1 s.
The transitions between these three states are so far observed only in the direc-
tions indicated by arrows in Figure 8, i.e., no direct C⇒B are seen. These states
connect to the instability picture outlined above in the following way: state C
corresponds to the onset of the instability in the inner section of the disc, whereas
states A and B correspond to stable periods. This means that the transitions that
involve state A are not interpreted within that picture. The existence of definite
events that cannot be interpreted in a thermal-viscous instability framework was
already pointed out by Taam et al. (1997), who analyzed a RXTE/PCA observa-
tion of class ν. They showed that the difference between state A and state B can
be associated to a variation in the inner edge of the accretion disc, although of
smaller amplitude than that observed during state C. This picture is confirmed
by a more complete analysis by Migliari & Belloni (2003).
An analysis of time-resolved spectra from a large number of RXTE/PCA ob-
servations, together with timing analysis, was made by Muno et al. (1999), who
presented a number of correlations between spectral parameters and timing pa-
rameters. Vilhu & Nevalainen (1998) analyzed observations of class ρ and inter-
preted through spectral fitting that the regular "ring" in the color-color diagram
is due to out-of-phase oscillations of different spectral parameters.
A full spectral analysis on a timescale of 16 s of the instability oscillations in
class-β observations showed that indeed the inner-disc radius estimated from the
disc blackbody component is larger during state A than during state B (Migliari &
8
Fender & Belloni
Belloni 2003). Moreover, there is evidence for changes in the local accretion rate
through the disc during states C and B but not during state A, where inner-disc
temperature and radius change in a way that reflects a constant disc accretion
rate (see Figure 9).
These results were followed by a series of theoretical papers aimed at a more
thorough exploration of the connection with accretion disc models (Szuszkiewicz
& Miller 1998, 2001; Nayakshin et al. 2000; Janiuk et al. 2000a,b; Nandi et al.
2001; Zampieri et al. 2001; Livio et al. 2003).
The complexity of the variability observed in GRS 1915+105 is unique and
difficult to model. Clearly, it will not be possible to interpret in detail every
aspect of the complex light curves shown in Figure 7, yet the structure of these
light curves is not random and contains information about the accretion disc of
GRS 1915+105. As can be seen from different works (e.g., Belloni 2001), there are
complex light curves that repeat almost identically years apart. Although at first
sight the X-ray light curves observed from GRS 1915+105 seem wildly different,
the number of repetition patterns observed by RXTE in the past nine years of
observations is relatively small, although clearly larger than 12. All the models
listed in the previous paragraph are aimed at explaining the single A -- B -- C event
and its appearing on different timescales, but the observed sequence of events is
complex and by no means random. This aspect has not been investigated so far.
For instance, Naik et al. (2002) found that certain variability classes are observed
preferably before and after long C-state intervals (plateaux, see below), indicating
a connection between the observed patterns and the long-term behavior, possibly
linked to the mass accretion rate.
The issue of timescales deserves particular attention. As we have shown above,
the length of C-state intervals observed within one PCA light curve can vary
from a few seconds to half an hour. However, there are observations when the
source is observed only in state C (defined as class χ in Belloni et al. 2000).
Because each observation lasts typically one hour, it is reasonable to hypothesize
that these are one-hour segments of longer state-C intervals. In some cases, this
can be measured directly. From Figure 2, one can see intervals of relatively
little variability in the daily ASM scans (for instance, around days 200 and 650),
corresponding to a higher value of hardness ratio. These intervals have been
called plateaux. In addition, a longer, lower, extended hard state is also visible
in Figure 2, lasting more than a year and centered around day 400. The color
properties of these plateaux have been analyzed by Belloni et al. (2000), who
found that their properties are consistent with being long state-C intervals. This
is confirmed also by timing analysis and by the radio properties (see below). A
full spectral analysis of the long plateau was presented by Trudolyubov et al.
(1999a), whereas Trudolyubov (2001) compared in detail the properties of these
three plateaux and found that both spectral and timing characteristics differ
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
9
between the short plateaux and the long plateaux (see also Belloni et al. 2000).
These differences are accompanied by marked differences in the radio emission
(see below). Fast variations, probably associated with B↔A state transitions,
have also been observed in class µ and ρ (Taam et al. 1997, Belloni et al. 2000).
They take place on a timescale as low as 0.1 s.
Such a complex light curve as the one shown in Figure 2 has of course been
searched for patterns and periodicities. The problem is complex owing to the
fact that single ASM scans, lasting a few seconds, sample complex behaviors,
such as those in Figure 7, in a random way. A simple power density spectrum of
this curve would not yield believable results. Different approaches were followed.
Rau et al. (2003), on the basis of spectral analysis of class-χ observations only,
detected a 590-day-long term periodicity in the power-law photon index, which
they also observe in BATSE and radio data, possibly related to disc precession.
Greenhough et al.
(2003), through differencing and rescaling techniques that
allowed them to separate different timescales, identify a 12 -- 17 day timescale in
the ASM light curve, which might be related to the binary orbital period of 35
days.
An obvious question to be answered is why this complex behavior is so unusual
and has not been observed in any other sources. As shown below, both (fast)
timing and spectral properties of this system are not at all peculiar. There is no
definite answer as yet, although it is widely assumed that the large value of mass
accretion rate (which, depending on the observation and on the spectral model,
has been measured even to exceed the Eddington luminosity for a 14M⊙ object)
plays a fundamental role in setting up these instabilities.
2.2.2 X-Ray Spectra
In this section, we describe in more detail the X-ray energy spectra that have
been measured from GRS 1915+105 by different authors.
Broad-band spectra In the presence of strong variability on short timescales,
it is not possible to accumulate energy spectra with sufficient statistics to test
models more complicated than simple phenomenological approximations. There-
fore, most of the efforts have been directed to the fitting and interpretation of
data from observations with little variability.
Grove et al. (1998) reported CGRO/OSSE spectra (40 keV -- 10 MeV) of GRS
1915+105. In all three observations, a single power-law with no observable high-
energy cutoff up to 500 keV was observed, unlike other BHCs in their low/hard
state. OSSE observations span one or two weeks: For the two observations of
1996 and 1997 during this period, the RXTE/PCA database show observations
of classes χ and µ in 1996 and of class α in 1997. This means that, although
10
Fender & Belloni
different states were sampled by OSSE, GRS 1915+105 was probably in the C
state for most of the time, when the power-law component is flatter. This was
confirmed by Zdziarski et al. (2001), who analyzed a total of nine OSSE obser-
vations. The OSSE spectra, extending to 500 keV, do not show evidence of a
high-energy cutoff. By checking the behavior of RXTE/PCA observations taken
during the OSSE periods, they see that at least one of these observations con-
sists probably of γ behavior dominated by state B. The conclusion is that no
high-energy cutoff is seen in either state C or B (see Figure 10, color insert).
The authors interpret this as evidence for the presence of a hybrid population
of thermal and nonthermal electrons emitting through Comptonization and per-
form detailed joint RXTE/OSSE spectral fits. Assuming isotropic emission, the
resulting bolometric luminosity is 6.5×1038 and 1.7×1039 erg/s for states C and
B, respectively. For a black hole mass of 14M⊙, these values correspond to 0.35
and 0.93 of the Eddington luminosity. Evidence for only a thermal Comptoniza-
tion component was presented by Vilhu et al. (2001) on the basis of a sample of
RXTE spectra. These results are probably compatible, as the latter spectra did
not extend to 500 keV as the OSSE ones did.
The issue of the presence/absence of a high-energy cutoff is not easy to solve.
BeppoSAX spectra corresponding to both B and C states were analyzed by Feroci
et al. (1999). The simultaneous 0.1 -- 300 keV spectra were fitted with a multicolor
disc, a cutoff-power-law, and a Compton reflection component. The reflection
was rather large, with a value for R = Ω/2π of ∼0.5 (where Ω is the solid
angle subtended by the reflecting matter to the illuminating source). A definite
high-energy cutoff was found for all observations, varying from 45 to 100 keV.
Moreover, the cutoff energy was positively correlated with the power-law photon
index. These results are clearly not compatible with the OSSE ones. PCA and
HEXTE observations during the long plateau centered around day 400 in Figure
2 led to the detection of a high-energy cutoff whose value was rather constant
around ∼50 -- 100 keV (Trudolyubov et al. 1999a). The model adopted here was
again a simplified multicolor disc plus cutoff-power-law. No correlation similar to
the one reported by Feroci et al. (1999) was seen. As mentioned above, spectral
analysis of PCA observations during the long plateaux and the shorter ones (days
200 and 650 in Figure 2), which are associated to different radio properties (see
below), showed that the energy spectra are also different (Trudolyubov 2001).
The shorter plateaux have a much lower cutoff energy, as low as 12 -- 20 keV.
This is in marked contrast with the OSSE results but is consistent with the
results of the color analysis of Belloni et al. (2000). A simple phenomenological
model consisting of a multicolor disc plus cutoff-power-law was used here again,
to be compared with more complex physical models used to fit the RXTE+OSSE
spectra, which, however, were not completely simultaneous given the length of the
OSSE observations. Fits to class-χ PCA+HEXTE observations over the first four
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
11
years of RXTE by Rau & Greiner (2003) with a model consisting of a reflected
power-law (plus disc), featuring no high-energy cutoff, yielded extremely high
values for the reflection parameter R, inconsistent with other measurements.
It is clear that the different spectral models used are mostly responsible for
the presence/absence of a high-energy cutoff. High signal-to-noise ratio simul-
taneous data are necessary to resolve the issue. The shape of the high-energy
component also affects the measurements at lower energies, in particular, chang-
ing the normalization of the disc component, from which an estimate of the inner
radius of the optically thick disc component can be extracted. Recent obser-
vations of GRS 1915+105 with INTEGRAL have been made and preliminary
results are now available. A simultaneous RXTE and INTEGRAL observation
during a plateau is reported by Fuchs et al. (2003b). Here the energy spectrum
was fitted to a simple power-law up to 400 keV, with no reflection component nor
high-energy cutoff (see Figure 11, color insert). Another INTEGRAL observation
qualitatively confirms these results (Hannikainen et al. 2003).
Overall, the broad-band energy spectrum of GRS 1915+105 can be described
in terms of three major components: a thermal component usually fitted with a
multicolour disc-blackbody, a hard component fitted with either a simple power-
law or a power-law with high-energy cutoff, or a more complex Comptonization
model (with or without Compton reflection) and a emission line between 6 and 7
keV (see below). The relative contribution of these components varies on different
states. The spectra discussed in this section are not different from those observed
in other black hole systems.
Spectral Lines A series of observations with ASCA between 1994 and 1999
produced the first X-ray spectra with a resolution sufficiently high to explore
narrow emission/absorption lines (Kotani et al. 2000). Absorption lines were
detected and identified with resonant lines of calcium and iron, as well as blends
of nickel and iron lines. Similar lines were observed only in the other superluminal
source GRO J1655-40, and the authors speculated that they are associated to jet-
production mechanisms. A 30-ks observation with the Chandra/HETGS (Lee et
al. 2002) confirmed the presence of complex absorption structures, which were
observed during a probable C state.
Although at a lower spectral resolution, a BeppoSAX spectrum taken in 1998
showed the clear presence of a broad emission line at 6.4 keV (Martocchia et
al. 2002). The feature is broad and skewed, and fits with a relativistic model
indicated a nonzero spin for the black hole in the system (see Figure 12). These
observations corresponded to an interval when the line was particularly intense
out of a series of long BeppoSAX exposures.
12
2.2.3 X-ray Timing
Fender & Belloni
As in the case of energy spectra, the fast timing features of GRS 1915+105 are not
as extraordinary as its variability on longer timescales. All observed properties in
all three states appear rather normal, as they have been seen in a number of other
BHCs (see McClintock & Remillard 2004). For a definition and description of
the different components detected in the Fourier domain, see van der Klis (1995).
Noise and Low-Frequency Quasi-Periodic Oscillations Very complex
power density spectra (PDS) have been presented by Morgan et al. (1997). Dif-
ferent continuum noise components and QPOs are visible in the PDS, although
the production of one PDS per observation, without separating different intervals,
makes it difficult to interpret the results. Three types of QPOs were identified:
high-frequency (∼70 Hz) oscillations (described below); low-frequency (1-10 Hz)
QPOs (see also Paul et al. 1997); and very-low-frequency QPOs, which can be
identified with the state transitions described above. A systematic difference be-
tween the PDS of soft and hard intervals was identified by Chen et al. (1997).
On their hard branch (corresponding to state C, see above), the PDS of GRS
1915+105 consists of a flat-top noise component plus a 1 -- 10 Hz QPO. The cen-
troid frequency of the oscillation is well correlated with the count rate (see Figure
13) and shows higher harmonics that tend to disappear at high count rates. In
their soft branch (states A and B), the PDS is steeper, with a broad peaked noise
around 2 Hz. At high rates, selecting state B intervals during oscillations, the
peaked noise disappears and a broad 5-Hz QPO peak appears (Chen et al. 1997).
The three states identified by Markwardt et al. (1999) also have distinct timing
characteristics corresponding to those of Chen et al. (1997).
As in the case of spectral analysis, most of the effort has been dedicated to
the C state, which is relatively easier to analyze because of the long plateaux
and the clear QPO at low frequencies (LFQPO). Markwardt et al. (1999) found
that the LFQPO, like similar oscillations in other systems, has an energy spec-
trum consistent with that of the hard component, and that its centroid frequency
correlates positively with the flux of the disc component (see also Muno et al.
1999). A correlation between the minimum centroid frequency reached during
a C interval and the length of the interval (over a range of 5 -- 500 s) was found
by Trudolyubov et al. (1999b), who showed that in about half of the cases this
correlation is consistent with the relation between viscous timescale at a certain
radius and Keplerian frequency at the same radius. Rodriguez et al. (2002a,b)
presented a combined spectral/timing analysis of PCA data, correlating the fre-
quency of the QPO with the measured inner-disc radius, whereas a correlation
with the power-law photon index was investigated by Vignarca et al.
(2003).
Many groups concentrated their work on the PCA observations of class χ, when
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
13
the source is always in state C. Many of these observations are parts of longer
plateaux (see above). Trudolyubov et al. (1999a) analyzed PCA observations
during the long radio-quiet plateau of 1996 -- 1997 (around day 400 in Figure 2)
and presented a number of correlations between timing and spectral parameters.
A thorough work on timing analysis of PCA observations during both radio-loud
and radio-quiet plateaux was done by Muno et al. (2001), who considered the
correlation between radio and timing properties. Important differences in timing
properties between radio-quiet and radio-loud plateaux, associated to spectral dif-
ferences described above, was found by Trudolyubov (2001). During radio-quiet
plateaux, the total root mean square (rms) of the QPO is the same as during
radio-loud plateaux, but the properties of the noise component are different. Its
total fractional rms variability is higher, and an additional broad component
around 60 -- 80 Hz is present (see Figure 14, left panel). Indeed, there seem to be
two separate "flavors" of C-state PDS: When the QPO frequency is at a certain
value, its width and integrated rms are always the same, but the noise level can
be significantly different (see also Figure 14, right panel). The association with
radio flux differences found by Trudolyubov (2001) is the first direct connection
between X-ray noise variability and radio properties. The energy spectrum of the
oscillations is hard, with fractional rms increasing with energy, but data from the
RXTE HEXTE showed a significant turnoff at high energies (30 -- 40 keV; Tom-
sick & Kaaret 2001). Its first harmonic shows a decrease at 10 keV (Rodriguez
et al. 2002a). The LFQPO shows significant and complex phase lags. Reig et
al. (2000) found that both QPO and continuum noise show hard lags when the
QPO frequency is below 2 Hz, evolving smoothly to soft lags when the QPO fre-
quency exceeds 2 Hz (Figure 15; see also Lin et al. 2000). When the fundamental
frequency shows negative (soft) lags, the fist harmonic shows positive (hard) lags
(Tomsick & Kaaret 2001).
Little work has been done on the timing properties of states A and B. Power
spectra were shown by Chen et al. (1997), Markwardt et al. (1999), and Belloni
(1999a). As mentioned above, the PDS of the soft states are complex and lack
clear narrow QPO peaks like those from state C. A set of PDS from variability
classes φ, ν, and δ (see Figure 7) have been presented by Ji et al. (2003). These
authors also performed a coherence analysis and found that the coherence devi-
ates from unity above a characteristic frequency. A few PDS are also presented
by Reig et al. (2003), selected to separate state A and state B.
High-Frequency Quasi-Periodic Oscillations
¿From a set of 31 early
RXTE/PCA observations of GRS 1915+105, Morgan et al. (1997) discovered
the first QPO at frequencies > 50 Hz in a BHC. In only two observations of those
analyzed, a significant peak at a frequency of 67.7 and 65.5 Hz was detected, with
a width of ∼4 Hz and a fractional rms variability of 1.1 and 1.6%, respectively.
14
Fender & Belloni
Its rms increased with energy up to 6% above 12 keV. Hints of the presence of
the same oscillation were present in four more observations. Belloni et al. (2001)
analyzed the observation when the QPO was strongest (May 5, 1996) and found
strong variations in its energy dependence as a function of the much slower B↔A
oscillation. In a second observation, they found a broad 27 Hz QPO only during
the A intervals. The phase lags of the 65 Hz QPO were studied by Cui (1999),
who found hard lags increasing with energy up to 2.3 radians between the 5.2 -- 7.0
keV and the >13 keV bands.
Strohmayer (2001) analyzed 97 PCA observations from 1997 and found in 5 of
them a QPO at a frequency (∼69 Hz) higher than that found by Morgan et al.
(1997). In addition, a second QPO peak at ∼40 Hz was found in the high-energy
data, simultaneous with the 69 Hz peak (see Figure 16).
These oscillations were found in observations of classes γ and φ and are there-
fore associated with states B and A, but not with state C, when the low-frequency
QPOs are observed. It is interesting that the three frequencies presented above,
27, 40, and 69 Hz, are roughly in 2:3:5 ratio (see Abramowicz et al. 2003).
A representative set of PDS from the three different states is shown in Figure
17 (from Reig et al. 2003).
2.3 Radio and Infrared Emission
2.3.1 Radio
GRS 1915+105 has turned out to be one of the most spectacular radio sources
within our galaxy, displaying not only -- like in X-rays -- highly variable and struc-
tured light curves but also spatially resolvable steady and transient jets at differ-
ent times.
(1993a) reported
Radio variability and relativistic jets Mirabel et al.
the first detection of the radio counterpart of GRS 1915+105 as a relatively
weak (2.5 -- 5 mJy) source at 20 cm with the Very Large Array (VLA). Although
interesting, there was little hint in this first IAU Circular of the excitement to
follow. However, by the end of 1993, Mirabel et al. (1993b) and Rodr´iguez &
Mirabel (1993) reported further VLA observations, indicating a highly variable,
sometimes very luminous, and possibly even moving radio source.
Early in 1994, Mirabel et al.
(1994) published details of the radio and IR
counterpart. They demonstrated that the source probably lies behind more than
30 magnitudes of absorption in the optical band -- which has to date precluded any
identification of an optical counterpart (but see Boer, Greiner & Motch 1996 for a
possible I-band counterpart) -- and that the radio counterpart showed variability
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
15
that was in some way correlated with the X-ray emission. In March 1994, Gerard,
Rodr´iguez & Mirabel (1994) announced a major radio outburst (flux densities >
1 Jy at 20cm) from the source.
It was this outburst that was to change the
way we look at jets from X-ray binaries: In a ground-breaking paper, Mirabel
& Rodr´iguez (1994) reported apparent superluminal motions in twin-sided radio
knots moving away from the core of GRS 1915+105 (Figure 18, left panel). For
the first time, superluminal motions -- previously a characteristic unique to jets
from supermassive black holes in active galactic nuclei -- had been observed in
our galaxy. The term microquasar, first applied to the galactic X-ray source 1E
1740.7-2942 owing to its large-scale radio lobes (Mirabel et al. 1992), seemed
entirely appropriate for GRS 1915+105. The fact that powerful, significantly
relativistic ejections could be observed from a black hole transient that, although
different in some ways from other transients was not that different, ushered in a
new era in the study of jets from stellar mass compact objects. The nonuniqueness
of such highly relativistic jets was dramatically highlighted by the discovery of a
superluminal jets from another X-ray transient, GRO J1655-40, within one year
(Hjellming & Rupen 1995, Tingay et al. 1995).
Rodr´iguez et al. (1995) reported five months' radio monitoring of GRS 1915+105,
which demonstrated that the source was undergoing repeated major radio flares.
Radio monitoring had also begun at the Green Bank Interferometer (GBI) (Fos-
ter et al. 1996) and the Ryle Telescope (RT) (Pooley & Fender 1997). Foster et
al. (1996) reported detailed GBI monitoring at 2.3 and 8.3 GHz, which identified
two states of bright radio emission: flaring (optically thin spectra, rapid decays)
and plateaux (flat-topped periods in the light curve with optically thick radio
spectra). We consider the plateaux to be a bright subset of the χ class/C state
of GRS 1915+105 (also refered to as χRL by Naik & Rao 2000 and type II hard
states by Trudolyubov 2001). A clear example of a plateau state is presented in
Figure 19.
That the flaring periods corresponded to further relativistic ejections was as-
sumed and confirmed by Rodr´iguez & Mirabel (1999), who also noted small
apparent changes in the projection of the jets on the sky. Later the same year
Fender et al.
(1999) reported observations of a major outburst with the UK
Multi-Element Radio Linked Interferometer Network (MERLIN), with five times
the angular resolution of the VLA at 5 GHz (Figure 18, right panel). These
observations revealed again relativistic ejections, but with considerably higher
(by approximately 20%) proper motions than those measured with the VLA.
Comparison with GBI and RT radio monitoring, and X-ray monitoring with the
RXTE ASM, indicated that the multiple relativistic ejections observed by Fender
et al. (1999) orginated in major flares immediately following a protracted plateau
phase. The MERLIN observations further revealed significant and variable (pos-
sibly rotating) linear polarization in the ejecta, and hints of curvature in the jet
16
axis, possibly owing to precession.
Fender & Belloni
The beauty of the observations of two-sided proper motions by Mirabel &
Rodr´iguez (1994) and Fender et al. (1999) is that they allow several clear results
to be drawn. A maximum distance, under the assumption of an intrinsically
symmetric ejection, can be derived as
dmax =
c
,
p(µappµrec)
where µapp and µrec are the approaching and receding proper motions,respectively,
and c is the speed of light. The proper motions reported by Mirabel & Rodr´iguez
(1994) indicated that GRS 1915+105 lay within our galaxy and was therefore
an X-ray binary source. The most recent two-sided proper motions, reported in
Fender et al. (1999), constrain dmax ≤ 13.6 kpc (3σ). The observed proper mo-
tions can also be used to place a lower limit on the velocity of the radio-emitting
knots, independent of distance:
vmin =
µapp − µrec
µapp + µrec
c,
which, when applied to GRS 1915+105, indicates a minimum velocity of ∼ 0.3c
on VLA scales and ∼ 0.4c on MERLIN/Very Long Baseline Array (VLBA) scales
(see below). The discussion of what can be derived from the proper motion mea-
surements is expanded upon in Mirabel & Rodr´iguez (1999) and Fender (2003).
Mirabel & Rodr´iguez (1994) also noted that the flux ratio between the ap-
proaching and receding components was very close to that expected in the case
of true bulk motion:
Sapp
Srec
= (cid:18) 1 + β cos θ
1 − β cos θ(cid:19)k−α
,
where β = v/c and θ are the intrinsic velocity and angle to the line of sight of
the jets, α is the spectral index of their radio emission, and k ranges between 2
(for a steady flow) and 3 (for discrete ejections). The observed flux ratios of 8 ± 1
found by Mirabel & Rodr´iguez (1994) and 6 -- 10 by Fender et al. (1999) correspond
to a value of k in the range 1.3 -- 2.3 and indicate true bulk relativistic motions
at some level. This does not rule out an origin for the observed knots in moving
shocks but does require that the underlying plasma flow has bulk relativistic
motion. In more detailed calculations, Bodo & Ghisellini (1995) concluded that
the observed patterns could be shocks but still required a bulk motion of ≥ 0.7c
(see also Atoyan & Aharonian 1999).
The power in these ejections was also found to be very large -- applying the
minimum energy conditions of Burbidge (1959), Mirabel & Rodr´iguez (1994)
estimated an energy associated with the March 1994 event of 3 × 1046 erg. Con-
servatively estimating an injection/acceleration timescale of ≤ 3 days, this corre-
sponds to a jet power during this period of ≥ 1041 erg s−1. Atoyan & Aharonian
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
17
(1999) and Fender et al. (1999) estimated lower, but still considerable, jet powers
of ≥ 1038 erg s−1. Furthermore, as demonstrated in Fender (2003), the observed
proper motions only allow us to place a lower limit on the bulk Lorentz factor
Γ of the flow, and therefore on total energy associated with the ejections (the
total energy Etot ∼ (Γ − 1)Eint, where Eint corresponds to the above minimum
energy values). The true value of the initial bulk Lorentz factor for the relativistic
ejections, such as those observed by MERLIN, is likely to lie in the range
2 ≤ Γbulk ≤ 30,
where the lower limit can be derived from observations and the upper limit cor-
responds to a mean jet power of ∼ 1041 erg s−1 over a 12-h jet formation phase
(at ∼ 45 times the Eddington limit for a ∼ 15 M⊙ black hole, this should be rea-
sonable!). Clearly, the power expended on particle acceleration and bulk motion
during the jet formation episodes could represent a significant, even dominant,
fraction of the total accretion power available.
The nature of the compact self-absorbed emission during plateaux was revealed
by Dhawan, Mirabel & Rodr´iguez (2000) who found in observations with the
VLBA that it correponded to a compact, relatively steady jet. They further
reported proper motions on small scales that were consistent with those reported
by Fender et al. (1999). The lower values for the proper motions reported in VLA
observations (Mirabel & Rodr´iguez 1994, 1999) may be due to resolution effects
or genuine deceleration of the ejecta as they propagate further from the launch
point. Further very long baseline interferometry (VLBI) observations with the
European VLBI Network (EVN) have confirmed the resolved core during plateux
states (Giovannini et al. 2001) and suggested that the plateaux jet is of lower
velocity than the transient ejections, although the reported details were sparse.
The most recent dual-frequency VLBA observations (Fuchs et al. 2003b) reveal
a compact jet from the source whose size varies as a function of frequency in a
way that appears to be consistent with expectations for a self-absorbed outflow
(Figure 20).
Shortly after the major relativistic ejections were reported, several groups re-
alized that these jets might leave their imprint on the ISM, just as the jets of
AGN produce bright radio lobes. Levinson & Blandford (1996), Kaiser et al.
(2000, 2004), Heinz (2002), and others have discussed the formation of shocks
in the ISM by these jets. However, although large-scale jet-powered nebulae are
known around some X-ray binaries (see, e.g., Fender 2004 and references therein),
searches for large-scale radio structures around GRS 1915+105 have been gen-
erally unsucessful (Chaty et al. 2001, Ostrowski & Furst 2001). Nevertheless,
there are hints of associations with nearby IRAS sources that deserve further
investigation (Chaty et al. 2001; Kaiser et al. 2004). Note though that these
sources are so far distant that if associated it must have been with outbursts
18
Fender & Belloni
much earlier than the one that has been ongoing for the past decade (Chaty et
al. 2001 and discussion therein).
Radio "oscillations" Another major discovery was made with the RT: Pooley
(1995) reported "oscillations" at 15 GHz with an apparent period close to 38
min. Monitoring with both instruments continued apace, and in 1997, Pooley
& Fender (1997) reported comprehensive long-term radio monitoring at 15 GHz.
The presence of quasi-sinusoidal oscillations (see also Rodr´iguez & Mirabel 1997),
with amplitudes up to 50 mJy and periods in the ranges tens of minutes to
hours, was unambiguous. Furthermore, Pooley & Fender (1997) demonstrated
that oscillations at 15 GHz led those at 8.3 GHz by approximately 4 -- 5 min.
Finally, they showed that there appeared to be some connection between these
radio oscillations and X-ray "dips" observed at the same time, with a similar
recurrence period, by RXTE (Figure 21). This was the first example of the great
successes that were to come by combining RXTE with simultaneous radio and/or
IR observations. Fender et al. (1999) noted that approximately four days of radio
oscillations separated two major ejection events resolved with MERLIN. Naik et
al. (2001) have also discussed the association of dips in the X-ray light curve
with radio flaring.
More recently, Klein-Wolt et al. (2002) have reported a comprehensive study
of the relation between radio and X-ray emission in GRS 1915+105 (see below
for more details). Fender et al. (2002a) reported a detailed study of the radio os-
cillations from GRS 1915+105, revealing that the delays between two frequencies
are not constant from epoch to epoch. Finally, Fender et al. (2002b) reported
the detection of circular polarization associated with relativistic ejections from
GRS 1915+105 utilizing simultaneous ATCA and MERLIN observations.
2.3.2
Infrared and Millimeter
Infrared Variability Mirabel et al. (1993b, 1994) first identified the near-IR
counterpart of GRS 1915+105 as a variable source in the J (1.2 µm), H (1.6 µm),
and K (2.2 µm) bands. Whereas spectroscopy and high-resolution imaging (see
below) produced some surprises, a key piece in the disc-jet connection came from
high time-resolution IR photometry of the source. Mirabel et al. (1996) reported
a brightening and reddening of the source in the near-IR following a major ejection
event, which they interpreted as reverberation of the event in circum-binary dust.
Chaty et al. (1996) reported more rapid near-IR variability. Motivated by this
and the discovery of radio oscillations (see above) (Pooley 1995, Pooley & Fender
1997), Fender et al.
(1997) performed relatively high time-resolution K-band
photometry of GRS 1915+105 and found the source to be oscillating with a
comparable amplitude (when dereddened), period, and shape as radio oscillations
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
19
observed earlier the same day. They argued that the IR events, like the radio
events, were likely to be synchrotron in origin, thereby increasing at a stroke the
minimum power associated with these oscillation events by four to five orders of
magnitude. Fender et al. (1997) further suggested that IR synchrotron emission
could explain the result of Mirabel et al. (1996) (see above) without requiring
dust reverberation. Like the major ejections (see above), these smaller, repeated
ejections were clearly a major power output channel.
Follow-up to these observations was intense and rapid. Eikenberry et al.
(1998a) reported high time-resolution IR photometry simultaneous with RXTE
observations, confirming the suspected link between events (Figure 22). Mirabel
et al. (1998) observed simultaneously in the radio, IR, and X-ray bands (Figure
23). These observations appeared to reveal a hard X-ray dip followed by an IR
flare, followed by a radio flare, thereby revealing a progression of the event to lower
frequencies, as expected for models with decreasing optical depth in ejecta. Eiken-
berry et al.
(1998b) reported IR spectroscopy during flare/oscillation events,
which revealed that the IR emission lines varied in strength in an approximately
linear way with the continuum. The mechanism behind this is not immediately
obvious because it was already concluded that the continuum was (mostly) syn-
chrotron emission in origin. Eikenberry et al. (1998b) suggested that the lines
were being radiatively pumped by the synchrotron flares. Fender & Pooley (1998)
presented further simultaneous radio and IR observations, revealing a compara-
ble IR-radio delay to that reported by Mirabel et al. (1998). Ogley et al. (2000)
reported "excess" submillimeter emission from GRS 1915+105, and Fender &
Pooley (2000) reported simultaneous IR and millimeter (1.3 mm) observations of
GRS 1915+105, revealing large oscillation events taking place at both frequencies
near the end of an apparently uninterruped sequence of over 700 events. Eiken-
berry et al. (2000) presented evidence for weaker IR flaring from GRS 1915+105
that was associated with soft dip/flaring cycles.
At longer wavelengths, Winkler & Trams (1998) and Fuchs et al.
(2003a)
report ISO observations of GRS 1915+105. One of the observations of Fuchs et
al. (2003a), between 4 -- 18 µm, was during a plateau state and is consistent with a
flat-spectrum component, probably synchrotron or free-free emission (see below).
Spectroscopy Castro-Tirado, Geballe & Lund (1996) reported K-band spec-
troscopy of the source, revealing emission lines of HI, HeI, and HeII. Whereas
Castro-Tirado et al. (1996) and Eikenberry et al. (1998b) argued that the emis-
sion lines probably arose in an accretion disc in a low-mass X-ray binary, Mirabel
et al. (1997) argued that the lines were likely to originate in an Oe- or Be-type
massive star and that GRS 1915+105 was therefore a high-mass X-ray binary.
The origin of these lines remained controversial until the identification of the
binary companion by Greiner et al. (2001a,b) (see below).
20
Fender & Belloni
Resolved Infrared Jets Sams, Eckart & Sunyaev (1996a) reported the dis-
covery of a near-IR jet in K-band speckle imaging of GRS 1915+105 with the
ESO New Technology Telescope (NTT). Repeat observations less than one year
later revealed that the jet disappeared (Sams, Eckart & Sunyaev 1996b). Eiken-
berry & Fazio (1997) also found no evidence for extended IR emission from GRS
1915+105 and, although the results of Sams, Eckart & Sunyaev (1996a) appear
convincing, it is odd that the IR extension has never been independently verified.
Identification of the Orbit, Companion, and Mass Function Greiner et
al. (2001a) finally managed to identify the binary companion to GRS 1915+105
by observing 12CO and 13CO bandheads in H- and K-band spectroscopy using
ESO's Very Large Telescope (VLT). These features clearly identified the binary
companion as a K- or M-type giant, confirming that GRS 1915+105 was, in fact,
a low-mass X-ray binary. More excitingly, photospheric absorption features such
as these opened the possibility to perform radial velocity studies of the system to
see if, as expected, it contained a black hole. This is precisely what Greiner, Cuby
& McCaughrean (2001b) did: In a comprehensive IR spectroscopic study, they
obtained an orbital period of 33.5 days with an associated radial velocity semi-
amplitude of 140±15 km s−1 (Figure 24). The resulting mass function (minimum
mass for the accreting object) is 9.5±3.0 M⊙, indicating a black hole at the ∼ 2.5σ
level. Assuming a lower-limit on the mass of the binary companion of 1.2 M⊙
and an orbital inclination corresponding to that derived for the relativistic jets
by Mirabel & Rodr´iguez (1994) of 70 ± 2 degrees, they arrived at a most likely
mass for the compact object in GRS 1915+105 of 14 ± 4 M⊙, making it a strong
candidate for the most massive stellar mass black hole known. Several authors
have considered the evolution of the GRS 1915+105 binary system in light of this
result (e.g., Belczynski & Bulik 2002; Podsiadlowski, Rappaport & Han 2003 ;
see also, e.g., King 2004 for a comparison with ultra-luminous X-ray sources in
external galaxies). It is important to realize that the binary plane may not be
perpendicular to the jet axis (Maccarone 2002), in which case the mass of the
black hole in GRS 1915+105 could be significantly greater (although not much
smaller) than the estimate of Greiner, Cuby & McCaughrean (2001b).
2.4 Radio and Infrared Evidence for Disc-Jet Coupling
2.4.1 First Connections from Daily Monitoring
The first obvious connections between the disc (X-rays) and jet (radio initially;
later the jet was also appreciated to emit in the near-IR), were identified via daily
monitoring of the source in multiple bands.
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
21
Foster et al. (1996) and Harmon et al. (1997) first demonstrated the clear
association between periods of hard X-ray emission and major radio outbursts
in GRS 1915+105. Based the imaging of superluminal ejections associated with
just such an outburst by Mirabel & Rodr´iguez (1994), it was reasonable to make
a connection between these long, hard X-ray phases and major ejections. Foster
et al.
(1996) noted that the radio emission during the hard X-ray phase was
actually rather optically thick and coined the phrase plateau states to describe
this combination of hard X-ray emission and strong flat-spectrum radio emis-
sion. The association with radio flares and ejections was -- as discussed below --
probably due to the fact that such plateaux generally reverted to softer X-ray
states within 10 -- 30 days, and that this transition was accompanied by a major
ejection event (Fender et al. 1999, Klein-Wolt et al. 2002). Figure 19 presents
multiwavelength radio and X-ray monitoring of GRS 1915+105 through such a
plateaux phase.
2.4.2 Coupling between X-ray "Dips" and Synchrotron Oscillations
By 1998 it was already established that periods of "hard dips" in the X-ray
light curve of GRS 1915+105 on timescales of minutes to hours were associated
with events in the IR and radio bands. Following the initial hints in Pooley &
Fender (1997), key observations were reported in Eikenberry et al. (1998a,b) and
Mirabel et al. (1998). More recently, Klein-Wolt et al. (2002) have undertaken
the most thorough study of the connection between the X-ray variability and
radio emission, and they highlight a strong link between hard X-ray states and
radio emission, and specifically a one-to-one correspondence between hard X-ray
(state C) "dips" and radio oscillation events.
It seems clear that, although the details of the physics may not be well under-
stood, each hard dip in a sequence is associated with a radio -- millimeter -- IR
event, which itself is associated with a powerful outflow. Note that Feroci et al.
(1999) have reported the association of a radio "flare" from GRS 1915+105, as-
sociated with a dip in the X-ray light curve; with hindsight this event seems more
like an oscillation event associated with an isolated state C. The key observational
characteristics of these oscillation events are as follows:
• Each event is associated with a state C dip followed by a state A/B phase.
• The rise and decay profiles are very similar over a broad range in frequencies
(from the radio through the near-IR). This suggests that the optical depth
effects do not strongly influence the profile of the event, and that adiabatic
expansion losses (which are frequency-independent) dominate the decay
phase.
• The events occur with a delay between different frequencies in the sense
22
Fender & Belloni
that higher frequency events occur earlier; the delays are not constant to
better than a factor of two. These delays suggest optical depth effects.
• The energy associated with the events is large, and it is a significant fraction
of the contemporaneous X-ray luminosity.
Whether these synchrotron events correspond to the ejection of discrete blobs
(e.g., Mirabel et al. 1998), internal shocks in a more continuous flow (Kaiser,
Spruit & Sunyaev 2000) or variations in the jet power in a self-absorbed outflow
(Collins, Kaiser & Cox 2003) is currently not clear (but see below). That are
powerful events -- extracting a sizeable fraction of the available accretion energy
(assuming it is Eddington limited) seems indisputable (see, e.g., power estimates
in Fender & Pooley 2000).
2.4.3
"Steady" Jets in Prolonged Hard X-ray Plateaux
Foster et al. (1996) discovered that prolonged phases of hard X-ray emission --
plateau states -- were associated with steady, relatively bright, flat-spectrum radio
emission, indicating some (self-)absorption of the synchrotron emission. Dhawan
et al. (2000) and Fuchs et al. (2003b) have reported direct imaging of an appar-
ently steady radio jet during this phase (Figure 20). The nature of this steady
radio emission has been discussed at length in, e.g., Falcke & Biermann (1996),
Muno et al. (2001), Klein-Wolt et al. (2002), and Vadawale et al. (2003). We
can now be confident that each plateau episode is associated with such emission,
which can naturally be explained in terms of a conical self-absorbed jet (e.g.,
Blandford & Konigl 1979, Hjellming & Johnston 1988, Falcke & Biermann 1996).
2.4.4 Major Ejections After (and Before?) Plateaux
Although empirically well established, the physical connection between X-ray
emission and the most spectacular of the jet-related phenomena -- the superlu-
minal jets -- has been the hardest to understand. This is perhaps not surprising
given that they do not repeat quasi-periodically many times in a row (like the
oscillation events), nor are they quasi-steady for many days (like the plateaux).
However, a general characteristic did emerge early on, namely that plateau
states are generally followed (and perhaps preceded) by major ejection events
(e.g., Foster et al. 1996, Fender et al. 1999, Dhawan et al. 2000, Klein-Wolt
et al. 2002) (see Figure 19). Furthermore, it seems rather common that the
"post plateau flare" (Klein-Wolt et al. 2002) is followed by several days of X-
ray/radio oscillations. Klein-Wolt et al. (2002) also noted that the pre-plateau
flares are generally stronger than the post-plateau flares. In the study of Fender
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
23
et al. (1999), these oscillations appeared for four days between major relativistic
ejection events.
2.4.5 The Overall Picture -- Two or Three Types of Jets?
Above, we have outlined the observational characteristics of three types of radio
emission associated with jets from GRS 1915+105: oscillations, plateaux, and
major flares. That the source can readily switch between these modes is evident
from the data presented in Fender et al. (1999) and Klein-Wolt et al. (2002)
wherein the source
1. Produces a medium-strength optically thin flare (probable ejection event)
2. Enters a plateau state (steady jet)
3. Produces a major flare (discrete relativistic ejection)
4. Enters several days of oscillations (repeated small ejections)
5. Reflares several times (discrete relativistic ejections)
We have no reason to think that this behavior was particularly unique (in-
spection of the radio light curves in, e.g., Pooley & Fender 1997 suggest that it
definitely is not).
How many types of jet production are required to explain this phenomenology?
The answer would seem to be two or three.
The steady plateau jets and the major ejections are clearly different, as outlined
in Table 1.
[Table 1 about here.]
It is possible that the oscillation events correspond to a third class of jet for-
mation, but it is likely that they do not. Based on the empirical connections
established in Klein-Wolt et al. (2002), we can see that the oscillations are in
fact associated with a combination of steady state C phases and with transitions
from this state C to a softer state. Note that Naik & Rao (2000) and Naik et
al. (2001) interpret sequences of dips/oscillations as the cause of the major flare
events, although this seems at odds with observations where many days of oscil-
lations have not been associated with major flaring (e.g., Pooley & Fender 1997,
Fender & Pooley 2000).
We therefore conclude -- being consistent with Occam's razor -- that the oscil-
lation events are the equivalent of the optically thin events that follow plateaux.
We shall see in the next section that this interpretation is supported by drawing
analogies with other objects. One obvious consequence of this interpretation is
that, regardless of the velocity of the steady plateaux jets, the oscillation events
should also be associated with relativistic bulk velocities.
24
Fender & Belloni
3 Other Sources: GRS 1915+105 in Context
3.1 Black Hole X-ray Binary States
Some of the observed X-ray and IR/radio properties of GRS 1915+105 are clearly
unique to this system. On the other hand, many other properties are similar
to those observed from other black-hole binaries.
In this Section, we briefly
summarize the general common properties of other systems, leaving out other
peculiarities, to compare them with those of GRS 1915+105. We do not discuss
the low-luminosity quiescent state because GRS 1915+105 has been very bright
since its discovery, not allowing a comparison with quiescent systems.
Even after years of RXTE data from both the (few) persistent systems and the
(many) transient systems, our general picture of the X-ray properties of BHCs is
not much clearer in the sense that there are a number of significant exceptions to
the states-scheme discussed below. Also on the theoretical side, there is not much
consensus as to the physical origin of some of the observed spectral components,
the timing feature, nor the physical parameters driving state transitions. Yet, a
classification in terms of source states is very useful and our only current way to
provide an observational view for the development of theoretical models.
Currently, we identify three main "canonical" states in BHCs, identified by
their timing and spectral properties. We summarize here their basic proper-
ties; for a complete description see, e.g., Tanaka & Lewin (1995), McClintock &
Remillard (2004), J. Homan & T. Belloni (manuscript in preparation).
3.1.1 The Low/Hard State
In this state, the energy spectrum is dominated by a power-law-like component,
with photon index typically ∼1.6, showing a clear high-energy cutoff at approxi-
mately ∼100 keV. An additional weak very soft component, probably associated
with the thermal disc, might be observable below 1 keV if the insterstellar ab-
sorption is not too high. This state is positively associated only with the early
and final phases of the outburst of transient systems, which indicates its associa-
tion to relatively lower values of mass accretion rate. In the timing domain, the
PDS shows strong (∼30% -- 40% fractional rms) variability, consisting of few band-
limited components and sometimes a low-frequency QPO, whose characteristic
frequencies appear to be correlated with accretion rate.
The low/hard X-ray state (LS) in canonical X-ray binaries is usually, probably
ubiquitously, associated with flat-spectrum radio emission, which varies in a cor-
related way with the X-ray emission (Fender 2001, 2004). Specifically, the radio
spectral index α ≥ 0 (where α = ∆ log Sν/∆ log ν, i.e., Sν ∝ να). The radio
luminosity varies with the soft X-ray luminosity approximately as Lradio ∝ L0.7
X
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
25
(Corbel et al. 2003, Gallo et al. 2003) until the transition to softer states, when
it drops dramatically (Fender et al. 1999, Corbel et al. 2001, Gallo et al. 2003).
In the bright hard state system Cygnus X-1, this radio emission has been resolved
into a steady milliarsecond-scale jet (Stirling et al. 2001).
3.1.2 The High/Soft State
Here the energy spectrum is dominated by a thermal component, usually mod-
eled as a disc-blackbody with an inner temperature of 1 -- 2 keV. A much weaker
power-law component is present, with a steep photon index. No apparent high-
energy cutoff is observed in high signal-to-noise spectra. Very little variability
is observed, with the PDS showing a power-law component with a few percent
fractional rms. This state is usually found in the central parts of outbursts of
transients, indicating its association to a higher mass accretion rate than the LS.
The high/soft state HS) is associated with a dramatic drop in the radio emission
compared to that observed in the LS, essentially to undetectable levels (Fender
et al. 1999, Gallo et al. 2003), representing a drop in radio luminosity by at least
a factor of 30. Sometimes optically thin radio emission is associated with the HS,
and is probably associated with shocks in material distant from the binary core,
which is itself no longer a radio source (e.g., Gallo et al. 2004).
3.1.3 The Intermediate/Very High State
The name of this state indicates its dual nature and the complex history behind
it. The energy spectrum is characterized by intermediate properties between
the LS and the HS, with both a strong thermal component and a power-law
component with Γ ∼2.5. The relative contribution of these two components to
the 1 -- 10 keV flux can vary between 10% and 90%. As in the HS case, no high-
frequency cutoff has been measured in the hard component (Grove et al. 1998).
The PDS is either a band-limited noise with a strong low-frequency QPO or a
weaker steep power-law component, sometimes with a strong and narrow QPO
at a frequency of ∼ 6 Hz (see Nespoli et al. 2003; P. Casella, T. Belloni, J.
Homan & L. Stella, submitted manuscript; J. Homan & T. Belloni, manuscript
in preparation). This is the state when high-frequency QPOs have been observed
in a few systems. ¿From the analysis of the outburst of a number of transients,
it is emerging that the appearance of this state is both related and unrelated
to the variation of mass accretion rate. The transition between LS and HS and
the reverse transitions, happening at very different accretion rates, take place
through a period of intermediate/very high state (VHS/IS). On the other hand,
clear, brief instances of VHS/IS are observed during the HS periods, indicating
26
Fender & Belloni
that another parameter different from M can trigger a transition. Notice that
in many systems, for instance, XTE J1550-564 (Cui et al. 1999) and GX 339-4
(Belloni et al. 2002), the PDS of the LS at the beginning of the outburst evolve in
a smooth manner, with all characteristic frequencies increasing in time, and this
smooth evolution continues into the VHS/IS, despite the fact that the spectral
properties change considerably.
The association of radio emission with the VHS/IS is unclear. Corbel et al.
(2001) demonstrated that when the X-ray binary XTE J1550-564 entered a rel-
atively soft IS, the radio emission dropped in a way reminscent of the radio
quenching in the HS. Furthermore, the radio quenching in Cyg X-1 (Gallo et al.
2003) may also be associated with a transition to the IS and not the true HS. On
the other hand, many transient outbursts are associated with a rapid rise to the
VHS, and such outbursts are nearly always associated with bright optically thin
events (Fender & Kuulkers 2001).
3.2 GRS 1915+105 A/B/C States and Other Systems
Three states are found in GRS 1915+105 and three main states are known in
other BHCs. It is natural to compare them to see if they are similar or perhaps
even the same states under different names, although the timescales of transitions
are obviously much different. A comparison based mainly on timing properties
was done by Belloni (1999b) and Reig et al.
(2003). Table 2 shows the six
states in terms of X-ray spectral and timing properties, with a comment on the
jet properties. Spectrally, it is clear that the maximum inner temperature of
the disc component is higher in GRS 1915+105, related to the high value of
the accrtion rate. However, the disc component behaves generally in a similar
way during the state C and the LS. Indeed, there is the suggestion that the inner
radius disk during the LS of BHCs is larger than in the other states (see, e.g., Esin
et al. 1997), although the physical model associated to this might be different.
Because the timing properties of LS and VHS/IS seem to be linked (see above),
it is therefore possible that the hardest intervals of GRS 1915+105 are instances
of a LS, and indeed the power-law index does reach LS-like values. However, the
absence of a high-energy cutoff measured by CGRO/OSSE would argue against
this interpretation (Zdziarski et al. 2001). In Table 2 we put a question mark in
the corresponding box, as RXTE measurements shown before seem to indicate
the actual presence of a high-energy cutoff that can reach values as low as a few
dozen keV. Both states A and B have variability properties that would associate
both of them to the VHS in its steep version (see above).
The overall pattern of behavior of the jets in GRS 1915+105 also seems to be
qualitatively very similar to more "normal" black hole X-ray binaries. That is,
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
27
it follows the basic rules of hard states associated with radio emission/jet pro-
duction, soft states associated with a quenching of the radio emission/cessation
of jet production, and (rapid) transitions between hard and soft states associ-
ated with bright optically thin events. The direct imaging of the steady jets in
plateau states seems to be directly comparable to the imaging of such jets (albeit
much weaker) from Cyg X-1 in the LS. Finally, the superluminal ejection events
are likely to be the same phenomenon as has been directly imaged during bright
transient outbursts for some other systems (most notably GRO J1655-40, but see
references in Fender & Kuulkers 2001).
Our conclusion is that probably all three states of GRS 1915+105 are instances
of something similar to the VHS/IS observed in other systems, associated to the
high accretion rate value for this source, although during the hardest intervals a
LS might be reached.
[Table 2 about here.]
3.3 Active Galactic Nuclei
We have discussed the disc-jet coupling in GRS 1915+105 and compared it with
other accreting stellar-mass black holes in X-ray binary systems. But what about
the connection to supermassive black holes (SMBH) in AGN? One of the great
potentials of X-Ray Binary (XRB) research has been the possibility that the
physics can be scaled up in size and timescale to AGN, and thereby provide us
with insights into the workings of the most powerful engines in the universe.
The discovery of the large power and broad ubiquity of jets from BHC XRBs has
only heightened this interest. With a general assumption that physical timescales
scale with the mass of the black hole (e.g., Sams, Eckart & Sunyaev 1996a and
references therein), even one hour of disc-jet coupling in a 10 M⊙ black hole
probes an equivalent timescale of ∼ 1000 years in a 108 M⊙ SMBH.
(2003) and Falcke et al.
GRS 1915+105 displays a steady jet during plateau states. The X-ray and
radio luminosities during this state are compatible with the universal relation
found for the LS of X-ray binaries, namely Lradio ∝ L0.7
X (Gallo et al. 2003).
Merloni et al.
(2003) have, with the inclusion of a
mass term, found that a closely related expression can fit the Lradio:LX:MBH
plane for X-ray binaries (including GRS 1915+105) and AGN (note that Falcke
et al. 2003 restrict themselves to low luminosity AGN). Therefore, the steady
jet in the plateau states is directly comparable with those in AGN not only
qualitatively but quantitatively (see also earlier discussion in Falcke & Biermann
1996). Furthermore, Maccarone et al.
(2003) present evidence for quenching
of the radio emission in AGN in the same range of Eddington-fraction X-ray
luminosities (approximately 2% -- 10% Eddington) as observed in the soft states
28
of X-ray binaries (Figure 25).
Fender & Belloni
The timescales associated with, for example, state transitions and transient jet
formation can vary widely (by factors of at least 104) for black holes of (probably)
very similar masses, so its not obvious how to scale up to SMBH, at least until
the coupling with other parameters, most likely accretion rate, is understood.
Nevertheless, Marscher et al. (2002) have claimed to see an equivalent of the
hard dip -- radio flare cycle, made famous by GRS 1915+105, in the AGN 3C
120 (Figure 26, see color insert). They find dips in the X-ray lightcurve, with
a frequency of ∼ 1/year, with corresponding hardening of the X-ray spectrum.
They further connect these dips to superluminal ejection events directly imaged
with VLBI. The ratio of masses 105 ≤ M3C120/MGRS1915+105 ≤ 106 means that
events of timescales ∼ 1 year in 3C 120 would correspond to timescales of seconds
or minutes in GRS 1915+105, close to those observed. Note that the observation
of these dips being associated with highly relativistic ejections is consistent with
the conclusion drawn earlier that the oscillation events are probably associated
with large bulk velocities.
We can therefore conclude that the physics of disc-jet coupling in XRBs and
AGN are very closely linked, and that by studying the nearby XRBs -- and GRS
1915+105 in particular -- we may understand the flow of energy to and away from
SMBH at the centers of galaxies over timescales of millions, or even billions, of
years.
4
Interpretation: Many Flavors of Disc-Jet Coupling or Just
One?
On the basis of our detailed studies of GRS 1915+105, we can make some progress
with our understanding of the coupled accretion:outflow progress in accreting
black hole systems.
4.1 Hard States and Jet Formation
As discussed above, protracted spells in hard X-ray states are associated with
steady jet formation and long periods in soft states are not. Such observations,
also in the context of similar behavior in other X-ray binaries (Fender 2004 and
references therein) have been considered as strong evidence for the association
of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) outflows with large scale-height accretion flows
(e.g., Meier 2001, Meier et al. 2001). The hard X-ray component in such states
is generally supposed to arise in some form of Comptonization (e.g., Sunyaev &
Titarchuk 1980, McClintock & Remillard 2004), in which case a clear connection
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
29
between the "base" of the outflow and this Comptonizing corona is required (see
discussions in Muno et al. 2001, Zdziarski et al. 2003, Fender 2004). Alterna-
tively, the hard X-ray emission may arise directly in the jet via Comptonization
(see discussion in Atoyan & Aharonian 1999) or, more radically, optically thin
synchrotron emission (Markoff et al. 2001, Vadawale et al. 2001). In either case,
a clear coupling between the hot plasma responsible for the hard X-ray emis-
sion, including its associated strong X-ray variability, and the production of a jet
requires explanation in future models. However, this is only part of the story.
4.2 On the Trigger of Optically Thin Events
Empirically, we can also suggest that hard-to-soft state transitions are associated
with resolvable ejection events, but is there a unique signature in the X-ray
emission that tells us precisely when this event occurs?
Mirabel et al. (1998) suggested that the brief spike seen toward the end of
the state-C dip during the oscillations of GRS 1915+105 corresponded to the
"launch" of the radio oscillation event. During this spike, the X-ray spectrum
softened dramatically, indicating a rapid change in the state of the accretion
flow. However, an overriding problem with seeing clearly the disc-jet coupling in
GRS 1915+105 (despite the many advantages the source offers) has been that the
rise, decay, and recurrence times of the synchrotron events are all comparable.
In general, a synchrotron event begins to rise before the previous event is fully
decayed, so observing the beginning of the "flare" phase is difficult.
By drawing analogies with other X-ray binaries whose temporal evolution is a
little more subdued, we can learn more. Fender, Belloni & Gallo (2004b) have
studied in detail the light curves of GRS 1915+105 and three other black hole
transients -- GX 339-4, XTE J1859+226, and XTE J1550-564 -- to determine at
what point the optically thin radio flare occurred with respect to the X-ray state.
The results indicate that the radio event occurs during a local peak in the X-ray
light curve, which corresponds to the end of a phase of softening in the X-ray
spectrum. In terms of GRS 1915+105, the source makes a transition from state
C to states A/B. In terms of the canonical states of other X-ray binaries, such
as those listed above, the X-ray peak corresponds to neither the canonical LS or
the canonical HS, but to a transition from a "soft" VHS/IS to a "hard" VHS/IS
(often en route between the LS and HS).
In many, possibly most, of the more conventional transients, the spectral evo-
lution of the source around the time of the ejection can be tracked more clearly
than in GRS 1915+105. What is generally observed is a peak in the LS (e.g.,
Brocksopp et al. 2002, Maccarone & Coppi 2003, Yu et al. 2003). At this point
the strongest self-absorbed jet is probably being produced. Subsequently, most
30
Fender & Belloni
sources transit to a softer X-ray peak, which corresponds to the VHS/IS, and
then later to the canonical HS. It is at the VHS/IS peak that the optically thin
radio event occurs; subsequently, the jet is "off" until the return to a harder
X-ray state. Applying the knowledge we have gained from these other transients
to GRS 1915+105, we assert that the optically thin ejection event occurs at the
state C → state A transition.
4.3 Jet Power and Velocity
The power associated with the strongest steady jets (those around the LS peak
in the X-ray light curve) and the subsequent optically thin events seems to be
remarkably close. We can demonstrate this in the following. Fender, Gallo &
Jonker (2003) have presented a simple formula for estimating the power in a jet
in the LS of an X-ray binary:
LJ = AL0.5
X ,
where LJ and LX are the powers in Eddington units in the jet/outflow and radi-
ation from the accretion flow (primarily X-rays), respectively. The value of the
constant is estimated as A ≥ 6 × 10−3. Note that Malzac, Merloni & Fabian
(2004) have suggested that all low-state sources are jet-dominated, in which the
value of the normalization is much larger: A ≥ 0.1.
Fender, Belloni & Gallo (2004b) have further compiled estimates of the power
associated with optically thin ejection events as a function of the corresponding
peak (VHS/IS) X-ray luminosity and found a function of the form
Ljet = BL0.4±0.1
X
,
where the exponent (0.4 ± 0.1) results from a fit to multiple independent esti-
mates. These power estimates are made assuming equipartition on the basis of
observations of rise times and luminosities of radio events (see Fender et al. 2004b
for more details). This is in contrast to the estimates for the steady jets, which
are based on broadband spectra and estimates of radiative efficiency (Fender et
al. 2003 and references therein) or models for the production of correlated optical
and X-ray variability (Malzac et al. 2004).
The normalization for the transients jets, B ∼ 0.5 (with a large uncertainty,
probably as much as an order of magnitude larger or smaller), is directly com-
parable to the normalization A estimated for the steady jets above (assuming no
significant advection of accretion energy in either case). Given the completely
independent methods used to estimate the jet power in the two regimes, it is
remarkable that the exponents of the two functions are the same within uncer-
tainties. In the event that the estimate for A of Malzac et al. (2004) is closer to
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
31
reality than the lower limit given in Fender et al. (2003), then the normalizations
are also very close. From this we draw the conclusion that the power associated
with the strongest self-absorbed jet, and that associated with the subsequent
optically thin flare, are comparable (within an order of magnitude or so). This
strongly suggests a rather smooth function in the relation between jet power and
X-ray luminosity, and not two completely independent mechanisms for powering
the two types of jet.
As noted in Gallo et al. (2003), and hinted at for GRS 1915+105 (see above),
it seems that the velocity of the steady jets is also lower than that associated
with the optically thin ejection events. This is based on the fact that the spread
around a common Ljet ∝ L0.7
X relation for all black hole XRBs in the LS requires
vLS ≤ 0.8c (for a random distribution of viewing angles), otherwise Doppler
boosting would result in a larger scatter. Fender et al. (2004b) have refined this
fit and compiled multiple pieces of evidence that the Lorentz factor associated
with the optically thin ejections of transient XRBs is Γ ≥ 2. Therefore, although
we do not know the form of the function (e.g., it could be step-like or continuous),
it seems clear that the transient jets have larger bulk Lorentz factors than the
steady jets.
4.4 A Unified (Toy) Model of Disc-Jet Coupling
In the following, we attempt to construct a semi-quantitative model for the radio
emission in GRS 1915+105 that is hopefully relevant to other X-ray binaries and
to AGN. In order to lay the foundations for this model, we summarize some of
the key physical indicators:
• Prolonged "hard" X-ray states (e.g., canonical LS, GRS 1915+105 state C)
are associated with steady production of self-absorbed jets.
• Prolonged "soft" X-ray states (e.g., canonical HS, GRS 1915+105 states A
and B) are associated with a suppression of jet production.
• During the transition between hard and soft X-ray states, an optically thin
ejection event occurs. In the canonical definitions of states, this event occurs
at the VHS/IS peak, close to the end of a phase of X-ray spectral softening.
This corresponds to a transition from state C to state A in GRS 1915+105
(the C to B channel is not observed; see Figure 8).
• The transient jets associated with these events have significantly larger bulk
Lorentz factors than those associated with the steady jets.
Based on these observational results, we have arrived at the following semi-
quantitative picture of the evolution of the disc-jet coupling during X-ray binary
32
Fender & Belloni
outbursts in general, and those of GRS 1915+105 in particular. The picture is
summarized in Figure 27 (see color insert), and in the text below.
The upper panel in Figure 27 is a hardness-intensity diagram for the X-ray
emission from a given source. The canonical LS and HS correspond to nearly
vertical strips at the extreme right (hard) and left (soft) of the panel, respectively.
Practically the entire range in hardness between these two canonical states rep-
resents VHS/IS of varying hardness. We suggest that above a certain hardness
(phases i and ii) a jet is produced whose strength correlates with that of the
X-rays in the nonlinear way found by Corbel et al. (2003) and Gallo, Fender &
Pooley (2003). Below that hardness (phase iv) a jet is not produced; these two
regimes correspond to the regions right and left of the vertical line in Figure 27,
respectively. We propose that as a source spectrum softens and it approaches the
line from the right, the velocity of the jet increases monotonically. At first, this
increase is insignificant for the energetics of the outflow, which is not highly rel-
ativistic (bulk Lorentz factor Γ ∼ 1). However, around the time that the source
crosses the line (phase iii), which generally corresponds to a peak in the soft X-
ray flux, the jet velocity increases very rapidly (Γ ≥ 2) before the jet is shut off.
Such a rapid increase in jet velocity would produce a shock in the preexisting,
slower-moving, jet, which would manifest itself in an optically thin flare with
large bulk motions.
For most X-ray binaries, an outburst follows a path similar to that indicated by
the solid arrows in Figure 27. The "quiescent" state of such sources can be found
by extending the LS branch vertically downward. Often, sources will exhibit a few
secondary flaring states in the same outburst, associated with further optically
thin radio flares (e.g., GRO J1655-40, XTE J1550-564, XTE J1859+226 -- see,
e.g., Brocksopp et al. 2001, Homan et al. 2001), but these are usually of declining
strength. It is interesting to note that in the model of Vadawale et al. (2003),
this declining sequence may be naturally explained by the first event having
considerably more material in front of it with which to interact (because there
was a long phase of steady jet production in the "quiescent" state and LS). In
any case, GRS 1915+105 seems to remain, for most of the time, very close to the
dividing line between jet-producing states and states without jets. The radio --
mm -- IR -- X-ray "oscillation" events (e.g., Figures 3, 13, 21, and 23) for which GRS
1915+105 is so famous may be compared to the encircled region in the upper-
left of the diagram, with the direction of a typical oscillation being indicated by
the dahsed arrow. In this picture, GRS 1915+105 is repeatedly entering the jet-
producing state then crossing the dividing line to jet-free states. Each transition
from right to left is associated with an optically thin event; those from left to
right are not. Sometimes GRS 1915+105 remains in the hard state (state C) for
considerably longer and may extend across the upper branch toward the canonical
LS. However, the transition from this state inevitably involves crossing the line
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
33
from right to left once more, producing a major flare event.
This model should be considered as a synthesis of previous observational results
and theoretical interpretations (although any errors resulting from the synthesis
are entirely ours!). Mirabel et al. (1998) first suggested the idea that the X-ray
"spike" at the end of hard "dips" might correspond to the moment of jet pro-
duction. We have expanded on this to show that in other X-ray binaries it is the
(secondary) VHS/IS peak and not the (initial) LS peak that corresponds to the
optically thin radio flare. Meier (1999) discussed a dramtically (discontinuously)
varying jet speed in response to varying conditions in the accretion flow. The
internal-shock model based on varying flow speeds in a semicontinuous jet was
originally developed for the jets of the AGN M87 (Rees 1978), and later consid-
ered for gamma-ray bursts (Rees & Meszaros 1994) and generically for radio-loud
quasars (Spada et al. 2001). Kaiser et al. (2000) considered internal shock models
for GRS 1915+105 and Vadawale et al. (2003) explicitly considered "post-plateau
flares" as resulting from shocks generated by fast moving ejecta interacting with
a slower-moving outflow produced during the plateau. Esimates of the jet power
in steady and transient phases are more recent (Corbel et al. 2003; Gallo et al.
2003; Fender et al. 2003, 2004b), as is the certainty that the transient jets are
considerably more relativistic than the steady jets (Gallo et al. 2003, Fender et
al. 2004b).
The model as it stands is mainly phenomenological, but there are some clues
to the underlying physics. For example, the jet velocity seems to increase as the
optically thin accretion disc moves ever closer to the central accreting object, only
becoming significantly relativistic in the very final stages. This may naturally
reflect the escape velocity of matter from the inner edge of the accretion disc,
which will remain almost constant until it enters regions of significant spacetime
curvature within a few gravitational radii of the black hole (but see Fender et
al. 2004a, where a highly relativistic jet from a neutron star is in contradiction
with the "escape velocity" scenario). This is consistent with the evolution of
the X-ray colors, but what exactly happens at this point? It could be that the
soft state, for some reason (e.g., no significant vertical magnetic field or extreme
Compton cooling of relativistic electrons), inhibits jet formation, and that the
optically thin flare was a last gasp from the jet before it is suppressed. On the
other hand, it may be that the sudden increase in jet velocity/power is enough
to force the accretion flow to settle into a different state, in which case the state
change is a result of, not a cause of, the radio ejection event. The similarity of
the formulae for the power associated with the two types of jet may argue for
a common underlying mechanism, which is simply the release of gravitational
potential in the accretion flow. Alternatively, the boost in the jet velocity, and
possibly power, for the very smallest disc radii may be in response to a sudden
additional contribution from the black hole spin.
34
Fender & Belloni
Finally, what makes GRS 1915+105 so special? As noted above, the evolution
of outbursts from other X-ray transients typically follow the path of the solid
lines in Figure 27. Although some (see, e.g., Homan et al. 2001, Brocksopp et
al. 2002) may make a small number of repeated phase iii transitions, resulting
in several ejection events, they have all returned to relative obscurity within a
year or so. GRS 1915+105 has, on the contrary, been very luminous and active
for ≥ 10 years. It seems clear that its unusual behavior is a result of a very high
(at times probably super-Eddington) accretion rate being maintained for a very
long time, probably as a consequence of binary evolution (the orbital period of
GRS 1915+105 is exceptionally long for an X-ray transient). In this sense, it is
comparable to the brightest Quasars among the sample of AGN.
5 Conclusions
In this review, we discuss at length the observational properties of GRS 1915+105
in the X-ray, IR, and radio bands one decade after the discovery of highly rel-
ativistic jets from the source, the first in our Galaxy. A connection between
the X-rays and the longer-wavelength (IR and radio) emission in this source is
unambiguous, and as a result it has become one of the key systems for our un-
derstanding of the disc-jet coupling. Placing the system into context, we have
argued that its properties are not that dissimilar from the X-ray states observed
in other black hole binaries. Beyond this, the relation of disc-jet coupling in X-ray
binaries to that in AGN is now finally on a quantitative footing, and we can be
confident that insights drawn from GRS 1915+105 will be relevant for the disc-jet
connection around black holes of all masses. Consequently we have proposed a
toy model for the disc-jet coupling in GRS 1915+105 -- heavily inspired by other,
earlier works -- that requires a minimum (i.e., one) different mode of jet formation
and, we hope, is consistent with the picture for other black hole systems.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank Sergio Campana, Elena Gallo, Marc Klein-Wolt, Thomas
Maccarone, and Simone Migliari for many useful comments on earlier drafts of
this review.
References
Abramowicz MA, Karas V, Kluzniak W, Lee WH, Rebusco P. 2003. Publ. ASJ
55:467 -- 71
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
35
Alexandrovich N, Borozdin K, Sunyaev R. 1994. IAU Circ. No. 6080
Atoyan AM, Aharonian FA. 1999. MNRAS 302:253 -- 76
Belczynski K, Bulik T. 2002. Ap. J. 574:L147 -- 50
Belloni T. 1999a. Astrophys. Lett. Comm. 38:225 -- 28
Belloni T. 1999b. MPE Rep. 272:82 -- 85
Belloni T. 2001. In The Neutron Star -- Black Hole Connection, NATO ASI,
Elounda, C567:295 -- 300. Dordrecht: Kluwer
Belloni T, Klein-Wolt M, M´endez M, van der Klis M, van Paradijs J. 2000. Astron.
Astrophys. 355:271 -- 90
Belloni T, M´endez M, King AR, van der Klis M, van Paradijs J. 1997a. Ap. J.
Lett. 479:145 -- 48
Belloni T, M´endez M, King AR, van der Klis M, van Paradijs J. 1997b. Ap. J.
Lett. 488:109 -- 12
Belloni T, M´endez M, S´anchez-Fern´andez C. 2001. Astron. Astrophys. 372:551 -- 56
Belloni T, Nespoli E, Homan J, van der Klis M, Lewin WHG, et al. 2002. New
Views on Microquasars, pp. 83 -- 85. Kolkata, India: Cent. Space Phys.
Blandford RD, Konigl A. 1979. Ap. J. 232:34 -- 48
Bodo G, Ghisellini G. 1995. Ap. J. 441:L69 -- 71
Boer M, Greiner J, Motch C. 1996. Astron. Astrophys. 305:835 -- 38
Brocksopp C, Fender RP, McCollough M, Pooley GG, Rupen MP, et al. 2002.
MNRAS 331:765 -- 75
Burbidge GR. 1959. Ap. J. 12
Castro-Tirado AJ, Brandt S, Lund N. 1992. IAU Circ. No. 5590
Castro-Tirado AJ, Brandt S, Lund N, Laphsov I, Sunyaev RA, et al. 1994. Ap.
J. Suppl. 92:469 -- 72
Castro-Tirado AJ, Davies J, Brandt S, Lund N. 1993. IAU Circ. No. 5830
Castro-Tirado AJ, Geballe TR, Lund N. 1996. ApJ 461:L99 -- 101
Chaty S, Mirabel IF, Duc PA, Wink JE, Rodr´iguez LF. 1996. Astron. Astrophys.
310:825 -- 30
Chaty S, Rodr´iguez LF, Mirabel IF, Geballe TR, Fuchs Y, et al. 2001. Astron.
Astrophys. 366:1035 -- 46
Chen X, Swank JH, Taam RE. 1997. Ap. J. Lett. 477:41 -- 44
Collins RS, Kaise CR, Cox SJ. 2003. MNRAS 338:1365 -- 87
Corbel S, Kaaret P, Jain RK, Bailyn CD, Fender RP, et al. 2001. Ap. J. 554:43 -- 48
Corbel S, Nowak MA, Fender RP, Tzioumis AK, Markoff S. 2003. Astron. Astro-
phys 400:1007 -- 12
Cui W, Zhang SN, Chen W, Morgan EH. 1999. Ap. J. Lett. 512:43 -- 46
Dhawan V, Mirabel IF, Rodr´iguez LF. Ap. J. 543:373 -- 85
Eikenberry SS, Fazio GG. 1997. Ap. J. 476:281 -- 90
Eikenberry SS, Matthews K, Morgan EH, Remillard RA, Nelson RW. 1998a. Ap.
J. 494:L61 -- 64
36
Fender & Belloni
Eikenberry SS, Matthews K, Muno M, Blanco PR, Morgan EH, Remillard RA.
2000. Ap. J. 532:L33 -- 36
Eikenberry SS, Matthews K, Murphy TW Jr, Nelson RW, Morgan EH, et al.
1998b. Ap. J. 506:L31 -- 34
Esin AA, McClintock JE, Narayan R. 1997. Ap. J. 489:865 -- 89
Falcke H, Biermann PL. 1996. Astron. Astrophys. 308:321 -- 29
Falcke H, Koerding E, Markoff S. 2003. Astron. Astrophys. In press (astro-
ph/0305335)
Fender RP. 2001. MNRAS 322:31 -- 42
Fender RP. 2003. MNRAS 340:1353 -- 58
Fender RP. 2004. In Compact Stellar X-ray Sources. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge
Univ. Press. In press (astro-ph/0303339)
Fender RP, Belloni TM, Gallo E. 2004b. MNRAS Submitted
Fender RP, Gallo E, Jonker PG. 2003. MNRAS 343:L99 -- 103
Fender RP, Garrington ST, McKay DJ, Muxlow TWB, Pooley GG, et al. 1999.
MNRAS 304:865 -- 76
Fender RP, Hjellming RM, Tilanus RPJ, Pooley GG,Deane JR, et al. 2001. MN-
RAS 322:L23 -- 27
Fender RP, Kuulkers E. 2001. MNRAS 324:923 -- 30
Fender RP, Pooley GG. 1998. MNRAS 300:573 -- 76
Fender RP, Pooley GG. 2000. MNRAS 318:L1 -- 5
Fender RP, Pooley GG, Brocksopp C, Newell SJ. 1997. MNRAS 290:L65 -- 69
Fender RP, Rayner D, Trushkin SA, O'Brien K, Sault RJ, et al. 2002a. MNRAS
330:212 -- 18
Fender RP, Rayner D, McCormick DG, Muxlow TMB, Pooley GG, et al. 2002b.
MNRAS 336:39 -- 46
Fender RP, Wu K, Johnston H, Tzioumis T, Jonker P, et al. 2004a. Nature
427:222 -- 24
Feroci M, Matt G, Pooley G, Costa E, Tavani M, Belloni T. 1999. Astron. As-
trophys. 351:985 -- 92
Foster RS, Waltman EB, Tavani M, Harmon BA, Zhang SN, et al. 1996. ApJ
467:L81 -- 84
Fuchs Y, Mirabel IF, Claret A. 2003a. Astron. Astrophys. 404:1011 -- 21
Fuchs Y, Rodriguez J, Mirabel IF, Chaty S, Rib´o M, et al. 2003b. Astron. Astro-
phys. 409:L35 -- 39
Gallo E, Corbel S, Fender RP, Maccarone TJ, Tzioumis AK. 2004. MNRAS
347:L52
Gallo E, Fender R, Pooley G. 2003. MNRAS 344:60 -- 72
Gerard E, Rodr´iguez LF, Mirabel IF. 1994. IAU Circ. No. 5958
Giovannini G, Feretti L, Tordi M, Venturi T, Massaglia S, et al. 2001. Astrophys.
Space Sci. Suppl. 276:111 -- 12
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
37
Greenhough J, Chapman SC, Chaty S, Dendy RO, Rowlands G. 2003. MNRAS
340:851 -- 55
Greiner J. 1993. IAU Circ. No. 5786
Greiner J, Cuby JG, McCaughrean MJ, Castro-Tirado AJ, Mennickent RE.
2001a. Astron. Astrophys. 373:L37 -- 40
Greiner J, Cuby JG, McCaughrean MJ. 2001b. Nature 414:522 -- 524
Greiner J, Morgan EH, Remillard RA. 1996. Ap. J. Lett. 473:107 -- 10
Grove JE, Johnson WN, Kroeger RA, McNaron-Brown K, Skibo JG, Phlips BF.
1998. Ap. J. 500:899 -- 908
Hannikainen DC, Vilhu O, Rodriguez J, Brandt S, Westergaard NJ, et al. 2003.
Astron. Astrophys. 411:L451
Harmon BA, Paciesas WS, Fishman GJ. 1992. IAU Circ. No. 5619
Harmon BA, Deal KJ, Paciesas WS, Zhang SN, Robinson CR, et al. 1997. Ap.
J. Lett. 477:85 -- 89
Heinz S. 2002. Astron. Astrophys. 388:L40 -- 43
Hjellming RM, Han H. 1995. In X-ray Binaries, p. 308. Cambridge, UK: Cam-
bridge Univ. Press
Hjellming RM, Johnston KJ. 1988. Ap. J.. 328:600 -- 9
Hjellming RM, Rupen MP. 1995. Nature 375:464 -- 68
Homan J, Wijnands R, van der Klis M, Belloni T, van Paradijs J, et al. 2001.
Ap. J. Supp. Ser. 132:377 -- 402
Jahoda K, Swank JH, Giles AB, Stark MJ, Strohmayer T, et al. 1996. Proc. SPIE
2808:59 -- 70
Janiuk A, Czerny B, Siemiginoswka A. 2000a. Ap. J. Lett. 542:33 -- 36
Janiuk A, Czerny B, Siemiginoswka A. 2000b. Ap. J. 576:908 -- 22
Ji JF, Zhang SN, Qu JL, Li TP. 2003. Ap. J. Lett. 584:23 -- 26
Jorstad SG, Marscher AP, Mattox JR, Wehrle AE, Bloom SD, Yurchenko AV.
2001. Ap. J. Suppl. Ser. 134:181 -- 240
Kaiser CR, Gunn KE, Brocksopp C, Sokoloski JL. 2004. MNRAS. Submitted
Kaiser CR, Sunyaev R, Spruit HC. 2000 Astron. Astrophys. 356:975 -- 88
King AR. 2004. MNRAS 347:L18 -- 20
Klein-Wolt M, Fender RP, Pooley GG, Belloni T, Migliari S. 2002. MNRAS
331:745 -- 64
Kotani T, Ebisawa K, Dotani T, Inoue H, Nagase F, et al. 2000. Ap. J. 539:413 -- 23
Krolik J.H., 'Active Galactic Nuclei: from the central black hole to the galactic
environment', Princeton Series in Astrophysics, Princeton, New Jersey, 1999
Lee JC, Reynolds CS, Remillard R, Schulz NS, Blackman EG, Fabian AC. 2002.
Ap. J. 567:1102 -- 11
Levine AM, Bradt H, Cui W, Jernigan JG, Morgan EH, et al. 1996. Ap. J. Lett.
469:33 -- 36
Levinson A, Blandford RD. 1996. Ap. J. 456:L29 -- 33
38
Fender & Belloni
Lin D, Smith IA, Liang EP, Bottcher M. 2000. Ap. J. Lett. 543:141 -- 44
Livio M, Pringle JE, King AR. 2003. Ap. J. 593:184 -- 88
Maccarone TJ. 2002. MNRAS 336:1371 -- 76
Maccarone TJ, Coppi PS. 2003. MNRAS 338:189 -- 96
Maccarone TJ, Gallo E, Fender R. 2003. MNRAS 345:L19 -- 24
Malzac J, Merloni A, Fabian AC. 2004. MNRAS. In press
Markoff S, Falcke H, Fender RP. 2001. Astron. Astrophys. 372:L25 -- 28
Markwardt CB, Swank JH, Taam RE. 1999. Ap. J. Lett. 513:37 -- 40
Marscher AP, Jorstad SG, Gomez JL, Aller MF, Terasranta H, et al. 2002. Nature
417:625 -- 27
Martocchia A, Matt G, Karas V, Belloni T, Feroci M. 2002. Astron. Astrophys.
387:215 -- 21
McClintock JE, Remillard RA. 2004. In Compact Stellar X-ray Sources. Cam-
bridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press. In press (astro-ph/0306213)
Meier D. 1999. Ap. J. 522:753 -- 66
Meier D. 2001. Ap. J. 548:L9 -- 12
Meier DL, Koide S, Uchida Y. 2001. Science 291:84 -- 92
Merloni A, Fabian AC, Ross RR. 2000. MNRAS 313:193 -- 97
Merloni A, Heinz S, di Matteo T. 2003. MNRAS 345:1057 -- 76
Migliari S, Belloni T. 2003. Astron. Astrophys. 404:283 -- 89
Mirabel IF, Bandyopadhyay R, Charles PA, Shahbaz T, Rodr´iguez LF. 1997. Ap.
J. 477:L45 -- 48
Mirabel IF, Dhawan V, Chaty S, Rodr´iguez LF, Marti J, et al. 1998. Astron.
Astrophys 333:L1 -- 4
Mirabel IF, Duc PA, Teyssier R, Paul J, Rodr´iguez LF, et al. 1993b. IAU Circ.
No. 5830
Mirabel IF, Duc PA, Rodr´iguez LF, Teyssier R, Paul J, et al. 1994. Astron.
Astrophys. Lett. 282:17 -- 20
Mirabel IF, Rodr´iguez LF. 1994. Nature 371:46 -- 48
Mirabel IF, Rodr´iguez LF. 1999. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 37:409 -- 43
Mirabel IF, Rodr´iguez LF, Cordier B, Paul J, Lebrun F. 1992. Nature 358:215 -- 17
Mirabel IF, Rodr´iguez LF, Marti J, Teyssier R, Paul J, Auriere M. 1993a. IAU
Circ. No. 5773
Mirabel IF, Rodr´iguez LF, Chary S, Sauvage M, Gerard E, et al. 1996. Ap. J.
472:L111 -- 14
Mitsuda K, Inoue H, Koyama K, Makishima K, Matsuoka M, et al. 1984. Publ.
ASJ 36:741 -- 59
Morgan EH, Remillard RA, Greiner J. 1997. Ap. J. 482:993 -- 1010
Muno MP, Morgan EH, Remillard RA. 1999. Ap. J. 527:321 -- 40
Muno MP, Remillard RA, Morgan EH, Waltman EB, Dhawan V, et al. 2001. Ap.
J. 556:515 -- 32
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
39
Naik S, Agrawal PC, Rao AR, Paul B, Seetha S, Kasturirangan K. 2001. Ap. J.
546:1075 -- 85
Naik S, Agrawal PC, Rao AR, Paul B. 2002. MNRAS 330:487 -- 96
Naik S, Rao AR. 2000. Astron. Astrophys.. 362:691 -- 96
Nandi A, Chakrabarti SK, Vadawale SV, Rao AR. 2001. Astron. Astrophys.
380:245 -- 50
Nayakshin S, Rappaport S, Melia F. 2000. Ap. J. 535:798 -- 814
Nespoli E, Belloni T, Homan J, Miller JM, Lewin WHG, et al. 2003. Astron.
Astrophys. 412:235
Ogley RN, Bell B, Fender RP, Pooley GG, Waltman EB. 2000. MNRAS 317:158 --
62
Ostrowski M, Furst E. 2001. Astron. Astrophys. 367:613 -- 16
Paciesas WS, Deal KJ, Harmon BA, Zhang SN, Wilson CA, et al. 1996. Astron.
Astrophys. Suppl. 120:205 -- 208
Paul B, Agrawal PC, Rao AR, Vahia MN, Yadav JS, et al. 1997. Astron. Astro-
phys. Lett. 320:37 -- 40
Podsiadlowski P, Rappaport S, Han Z. 2003. MNRAS 341:385 -- 404
Pooley GG. 1995. IAU Circ. No. 6269
Pooley GG, Fender RP. 1997. MNRAS 292:925 -- 33
Rau A, Greiner J. 2003. Astron. Astrophys. 397:711 -- 22
Rau A, Greiner J, McCollough ML. 2003. Ap. J. Lett. 590:37 -- 40
Rees MJ. 1978. MNRAS 184:P61 -- 65
Rees MJ, Meszaros P. 1994. Ap. J. 430:L93 -- 96
Reig P, Belloni T, van der Klis M. 2003. Astron. Astrophys. 412:229
Reig P, Belloni T, van der Klis M, M´endez M, Kylafis ND, Ford EC. 2000. Ap.
J. 541:883 -- 88
Rodriguez J, Durouchoux P, Mirabel IF, Ueda Y, Tagger M, Yamaoka K. 2002a.
Astron. Astrophys. 386:271 -- 79
Rodriguez J, Varni´ere P, Tagger M, Durouchoux P. 2002b. Astron. Astrophys.
387:487 -- 96
Rodr´iguez LF, Gerard E, Mirabel IF, Gomez Y, Velasquez A. 1995. Ap. J. Suppl.
101:173 -- 79
Rodr´iguez LF, Mirabel IF. 1993. IAU Circ. No. 5900
Rodr´iguez LF, Mirabel IF. 1997. Ap. J 474:L123 -- 25
Rodr´iguez LF, Mirabel IF. 1999. Ap. J 511:398 -- 404
Rothschild RE, Blanco PR, Gruber DE, Heindl WA, MacDonald DR, et al. 1998.
Ap. J. 496:538 -- 49
Sams BJ, Eckart A, Sunyaev R. 1996a. Nature 382:47
Sams BJ, Eckart A, Sunyaev R. 1996b. IAU Circ. No. 6455
Sazonov S, Sunyaev R. 1995. IAU Circ. No. 6209
Spada M, Ghisellini G, Lazzati D, Celotti A. 2001. MNRAS 325:1559 -- 70
40
Fender & Belloni
Stirling AM, Spencer RE, de la Force CJ, Garrett MA, Fender RP, Ogley RN.
2001. MNRAS 327:1273 -- 78
Strohmayer TE. 2001. Ap. J. Lett. 554:169 -- 72
Sunyaev RA, Titarchuk LG. 1980. Astron. Astrophys. 86:121 -- 38
Szuszkiewicz E, Miller JC. 1998. MNRAS 298:888 -- 96
Szuszkiewicz E, Miller JC. 2001. MNRAS 328:36 -- 44
Taam RE, Chen X, Swank JH. 1997. Ap. J. Lett. 485:83 -- 86
Tanaka Y, Lewin WHG. 1995. In X-ray Binaries, p. 126. Cambridge, UK: Cam-
bridge Univ. Press.
Tingay SJ, Jauncey DL, Preston RA, Reynolds JE, Meier DL, et al. 1995. Nature
374:141 -- 43
Tomsick JA, Kaaret P. 2001. Ap. J. 548:401 -- 9
Trudolyubov SP. 2001. Ap. J. 558:276 -- 82
Trudolyubov SP, Churazov EM, Gilfanov MR. 1999a. Astron. Lett. 25:718 -- 38
Trudolyubov SP, Churazov EM, Gilfanov MR. 1999b. Astron. Astrophys. Lett.
351:15 -- 18
van der Klis M. 1995. In X-ray Binaries, p. 252. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge
Univ. Press
van der Laan H. 1996. Nature 211:1131 -- 33
Vadawale SV, Rao AR, Chakrabarti SK. 2001. Astron. Astrophys. 372:793 -- 802
Vadawale SV, Rao AR, Naik S, Yadav JS, Ishwara-Chandra CH, et al. 2003. Ap.
J. 597:1023 -- 35
Vignarca F, Migliari S, Belloni T, Psaltis D, van der Klis M. 2003. Astron. As-
trophys. 397:729 -- 38
Vilhu O, Nevalainen J. 1998. Ap. J. Lett. 508:85 -- 89
Vilhu O, Poutanen J, Nikula P, Nevalainen J. 2001. Ap. J. Lett. 553:51 -- 54
Winkler C, Trams N. 1998. Astron. Astrophys. 337:729 -- 38
Yadav JS, Rao AR, Agrawal PC, Paul B, Seetha S, et al. 1999. Ap. J. 517:935 -- 50
Yu W, Klein-Wolt M, Fender R, van der Klis M. 2003. Ap. J. 589:L33-36
Zampieri L, Turolla R, Szuszkiewicz E. 2001. MNRAS 325:1266 -- 74
Zdziarski AA, Grove JE, Poutanen J, Rao AR, Vadawale SV. 2001. Ap. J. Lett.
554:45 -- 48
Zdziarski AA, Lubinski P, Gilfanov G, Revnivtsev M. 2003. MNRAS 342:355 -- 72
Zhang SN, Harmon BA, Paciesas WS, Fishman GJ. 1995. IAU Circ. No. 6209
[Figure 1 about here.]
[Figure 2 about here.]
[Figure 3 about here.]
[Figure 4 about here.]
[Figure 5 about here.]
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
41
[Figure 6 about here.]
[Figure 7 about here.]
[Figure 8 about here.]
[Figure 9 about here.]
[Figure 10 about here.]
[Figure 11 about here.]
[Figure 12 about here.]
[Figure 13 about here.]
[Figure 14 about here.]
[Figure 15 about here.]
[Figure 16 about here.]
[Figure 17 about here.]
[Figure 18 about here.]
[Figure 19 about here.]
[Figure 20 about here.]
[Figure 21 about here.]
[Figure 22 about here.]
[Figure 23 about here.]
[Figure 24 about here.]
[Figure 25 about here.]
[Figure 26 about here.]
[Figure 27 about here.]
42
List of Figures
Fender & Belloni
BATSE 20 -- 100 keV light curve of GRS 1915+105 in 5-day bins. Flux conversion
was done with a Γ=2.5 power-law model (from Harmon et al. 1997). Time
ranges from mid-1991 to the launch of RXTE. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
RXTE/ASM light curve, in 1-day bins, from the start of the RXTE mission up to
October 12, 2003. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
RXTE/PCA light curve of GRS 1915+105 from October 7, 1996, with correspond-
ing hardness ratio (13.3 -- 60.0 keV/2.0 -- 13.3 keV) curve (from Belloni et al.
1997a). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Upper panel: RXTE/PCA light curve of GRS 1915+105 from June 18, 1997.
Middle and lower panels: corresponding inner radius and temperature (from
Belloni et al. 1997b). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Correlation between total length of a hard event and maximum inner radius of
the disc from the data shown in Figure 4. The line is the best fit with a
power-law with fixed index 3.5 (from Belloni et al. 1997b). . . . . . . . . . .
GRS 1915+105 in the kTin-Γ plane for the RXTE/PCA observation of September
9, 1997 (from Markwardt, Swank & Taam 1997). Different symbols corre-
spond to different timing behavior. The gray bands divide the plot into three
sections, corresponding to the three states defined by the authors.
. . . . .
Sample RXTE/PCA 1-s light curves for six of the 12 classes defined in Belloni et
al. (2000). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Schematic PCA color-color diagram showing the basic A/B/C states and their
observed transitions. The X-ray colors are defined in the following way. HR1
is the ratio of the counts in the 5 -- 13 keV band over those in the 2 -- 5 keV
band. HR2 is the ratio 13 -- 60 keV over 2 -- 5 keV. From Belloni et al. (2000).
Inner disc temperature versus inner disc radius for two intervals of instability of
a representative class-β observation of GRS 1915+105. The lines indicate
two levels of constant accretion rate (increasing in the direction of the arrow
(from Migliari & Belloni 2003).
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
(a) OSSE spectra of GRS 1915+105 deconvolved with a power-law model. The
spectrum labeled 813 corresponds to the probable B state observation. (b)
Average of the above with power-law best fit. From Zdziarski et al. (2001).
Combined RXTE PCA+HEXTE and INTEGRAL ISGRI+SPI spectra of GRS
1915+105 during a plateau period on April 2, 2003. The inset shows a PCA
power density spectrum typical of C state. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Residuals for one of the BeppoSAX observation intervals showing the presence of
a broad skewed emission line (from Martocchia et al. 2002). . . . . . . . . .
Top panel: PCA light curve from October 31, 1997 (class β) with 2-s bin size.
Bottom panel: corresponding spectrogram (in logarithmic gray scale). Black
corresponds to high power values. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Left panel: PDS of two PCA observations from plateaux periods. Filled circles
are from August 14, 2000; open circles from July 23, 1996 (adapted from
Trudolyubov 2001). Right panel: two examples at a higher QPO frequency
(open circles: August 18, 1996; filled circles: October 23, 1996). . . . . . . .
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
GRS 1915+105 and Disc-Jet Coupling
Phase lags associated to a sample of radio-loud plateaux observations of GRS
1915+105 (from Reig et al. 2000). Top panel: phase lags at the QPO
frequency. Bottom panel: phase lags of the continuum between 0.1 and 5
Hz. Positive lags correspond to the hard flux lagging the soft flux.
. . . . .
Average power density spectrum of the five PCA observations in 1997 when high-
frequency QPOs were detected. Both the 40 Hz and the 69 Hz peaks are
visible (from Strohmayer 2001). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Representative PDS for the three states of GRS 1915+105. A-short refers to short
intervals of state A. AB is from a smooth A -- B transition during class β (from
Reig et al. 2003). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Major (superluminal) relativistic ejections from GRS 1915+105. The left panel
shows VLA observations over a period of ∼ one month in 1994, from Mirabel
& Rodr´iguez (1994). The right panel shows higher-resolution MERLIN imag-
ing over a period of ∼ 12 days in 1997, from Fender et al. (1999a).
. . . . .
A plateau state in GRS 1915+105, from Fender et al. (1999). The top panel shows
radio monitoring at three frequencies, from the Green Bank Interferometer
(GBI) and Ryle Telescope (RT). The plateau phase lasts from approximately
MJD 50730 to MJD 50750, and is associated with a flat radio spectrum
(middle panel). The plateau is associated with steady X-ray emission (lower
panel), which has a hard spectrum (state C). Prior to the plateau is a small
medium strength optically thin flare (preplateau flare in Klein-Wolt et al.
2002), and following the plateau is a larger optically thin flare (postplateau
flare), which in this case was directly resolved into a relativistic ejection event
(tickmarks indicate the epochs of the MERLIN observations presented in the
of Figure 18). Following the first postplateau flare was a period of four days
of X-ray dip/radio oscillation cycles, indicated as QPO. Other occasions of
plateaux have resolved the flat-spectrum radio emission into a steady jet such
as those presented in Figure 20. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Compact core jet associated with the plateau -- steady, hard X-ray and radio
emission -- state in GRS 1915+105 in April 2003 (adapted from Fuchs et
al. 2003b). A similar jet in a plateau state in 1998 was reported by Dhawan
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
et al. (2000).
Simultaneous radio and X-ray observations of GRS 1915+105 in 1996, from Pooley
& Fender (1997). Despite the patchy X-ray coverage there is a clear hint of
an association between the semiregular X-ray dipping behavior and the radio
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
oscillations.
Simultaneous X-ray and IR observations of GRS 1915+105 in August 1997, from
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
X-ray/IR/radio light curve of GRS 1915+105 during a hard X-ray dip, from
Mirabel et al. (1998). The radio event is certainly associated with the cy-
cle, and the IR precedes it by ∼ 20 min -- probably indicating that the IR is
synchrotron emission from much closer to the base of the jet than the radio.
Note the spike in the X-ray light curve at which point the X-ray hardness
drops dramatically, and has been suggested by Mirabel et al. (1998) as the
time of launch of the relativistic jet.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Eikenberry et al. (1998a).
43
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
44
Fender & Belloni
Orbital parameters of GRS 1915+105 from IR spectroscopy (Greiner et al. 2001).
The top panel shows the most likely orbital period, of 33.5 days, for the
binary. The lower panel shows the radial velocity data folded on this orbital
period. From these data a mass function -- corresponding to an absolute lower
limit on the mass of the accreting object -- of 9.5 ± 3.0 M⊙ can be derived.
Assuming a companion mass of ∼ 1.2 M⊙ and an orbital inclination equal to
the angle the jets make with the line of sight, i.e., ∼ 70◦, then Greiner et al.
estimate a mass of 14 ± 4 M⊙ for the black hole.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Jet power as a function of Eddington-scaled luminosity for X-ray binaries (open
triangles) and AGN (solid squares), adjusted for the mass term of Merloni,
Heinz & di Matteo (2003); from Maccarone, Gallo & Fender (2003). The
reduction in radio power in the approximate range 1% -- 10% Eddington is
well-known in X-ray binaries as the quenching of the jet in soft X-ray states,
a phenomenon that may also therefore occur in AGN. The data for GRS
1915+105 lie in the most luminous bin, corresponding to FRII-type AGN. .
68
69
Possible analogous disc-jet coupling in the AGN 3C 120, from Marscher et al. 2002 70
A schematic illustrating our model for the evolution of outbursts and related phases
of jet formation in GRS 1915+105 and other accreting black holes. Typical
X-ray binary outbursts follow the path of the solid arrows, transiting from
the canonical LS to the canonical HS via a monotonically softening VHS/IS.
This evolution corresponds to leftward motion across the hardness-intensity
diagram (top panel). We suggest that above some hardness a jet is produced,
below that hardness the jet is suppressed, and that close to the transition
(indicated by the vertical line) the jet velocity increases to significantly rel-
ativistic values (lower panel). This line may correspond to the geometrically
thin accretion disc reaching the innermost stable circular orbit around the
black hole.As a result, crossing the vertical line from left to right results in a
shock in the outflow and subsequent cessation of core jet production; this is
observed as a singular optically thin radio event. GRS 1915+105 seems to be
semicontinuously located in the upper-left region of the diagram, repeatedly
crossing the vertical line, producing optically thin radio flares each time it
does so. A loop, such as that indicated by the circle, may correspond to a
single oscillation event. Extended plateau phases correspond to excursions
towards the canonical LS, but are inevitably terminated by a softening and
major radio event as the source crosses the vertical line once more. This
model seems to be consistent with the behavior of other black hole XRBs,
and may even be applicable to AGN. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
71
FIGURES
45
Figure 1: BATSE 20 -- 100 keV light curve of GRS 1915+105 in 5-day bins. Flux conversion
was done with a Γ=2.5 power-law model (from Harmon et al. 1997). Time ranges from
mid-1991 to the launch of RXTE.
46
FIGURES
)
b
a
r
C
(
e
t
a
R
2
1.5
1
0.5
1
R
H
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
)
b
a
r
C
(
e
t
a
R
1
R
H
2
1.5
1
0.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
1800
2000
2200
Time (MJD − 50088.0)
2400
2600
2800
Figure 2: RXTE/ASM light curve, in 1-day bins, from the start of the RXTE mission up
to October 12, 2003.
FIGURES
47
Figure 3: RXTE/PCA light curve of GRS 1915+105 from October 7, 1996, with corre-
sponding hardness ratio (13.3 -- 60.0 keV/2.0 -- 13.3 keV) curve (from Belloni et al. 1997a).
48
FIGURES
Figure 4: Upper panel: RXTE/PCA light curve of GRS 1915+105 from June 18, 1997.
Middle and lower panels: corresponding inner radius and temperature (from Belloni et al.
1997b).
FIGURES
49
Figure 5: Correlation between total length of a hard event and maximum inner radius of
the disc from the data shown in Figure 4. The line is the best fit with a power-law with
fixed index 3.5 (from Belloni et al. 1997b).
50
FIGURES
Figure 6: GRS 1915+105 in the kTin-Γ plane for the RXTE/PCA observation of September
9, 1997 (from Markwardt, Swank & Taam 1997). Different symbols correspond to different
timing behavior. The gray bands divide the plot into three sections, corresponding to the
three states defined by the authors.
FIGURES
51
s
/
s
t
n
c
k
s
/
s
t
n
c
k
s
/
s
t
n
c
k
s
/
s
t
n
c
k
s
/
s
t
n
c
k
s
/
s
t
c
k
40
20
0
40
20
0
40
20
0
40
20
0
40
20
0
40
20
0
0
class φ
class γ
class χ
class µ
class δ
0
1000
2000
class θ
3000
class λ
class ρ
class γ
class κ
class ν
class β
500
1000
2000
1500
Time (seconds)
2500
3000
3500
1000
2000
Time (seconds)
3000
Figure 7: Sample RXTE/PCA 1-s light curves for six of the 12 classes defined in Belloni et
al. (2000).
52
FIGURES
STATE B
HR1
STATE C
STATE A
HR2
Figure 8: Schematic PCA color-color diagram showing the basic A/B/C states and their
observed transitions. The X-ray colors are defined in the following way. HR1 is the ratio of
the counts in the 5 -- 13 keV band over those in the 2 -- 5 keV band. HR2 is the ratio 13 -- 60
keV over 2 -- 5 keV. From Belloni et al. (2000).
FIGURES
53
Figure 9: Inner disc temperature versus inner disc radius for two intervals of instability
of a representative class-β observation of GRS 1915+105. The lines indicate two levels of
constant accretion rate (increasing in the direction of the arrow (from Migliari & Belloni
2003).
54
FIGURES
Figure 10: (a) OSSE spectra of GRS 1915+105 deconvolved with a power-law model. The
spectrum labeled 813 corresponds to the probable B state observation. (b) Average of the
above with power-law best fit. From Zdziarski et al. (2001).
FIGURES
55
RXTE / PCA
INTEGRAL / JEM−X
)
z
H
INTEGRAL / ISGRI
RXTE / HEXTE
INTEGRAL / SPI
/
2
S
M
R
(
r
e
w
o
P
Frequency (Hz)
Figure 11: Combined RXTE PCA+HEXTE and INTEGRAL ISGRI+SPI spectra of GRS
1915+105 during a plateau period on April 2, 2003. The inset shows a PCA power density
spectrum typical of C state.
56
FIGURES
Figure 12: Residuals for one of the BeppoSAX observation intervals showing the presence
of a broad skewed emission line (from Martocchia et al. 2002).
FIGURES
57
Figure 13: Top panel: PCA light curve from October 31, 1997 (class β) with 2-s bin size.
Bottom panel: corresponding spectrogram (in logarithmic gray scale). Black corresponds
to high power values.
58
FIGURES
z
H
/
s
m
r
d
e
r
a
u
q
S
10−2
10−3
10−4
10−5
10−2
10−3
10−4
10−5
z
H
/
s
m
r
d
e
r
a
u
q
S
100
Frequency (Hz)
102
100
101
Frequency (Hz)
Figure 14: Left panel: PDS of two PCA observations from plateaux periods. Filled circles
are from August 14, 2000; open circles from July 23, 1996 (adapted from Trudolyubov
2001). Right panel: two examples at a higher QPO frequency (open circles: August 18,
1996; filled circles: October 23, 1996).
FIGURES
59
Figure 15: Phase lags associated to a sample of radio-loud plateaux observations of GRS
1915+105 (from Reig et al. 2000). Top panel: phase lags at the QPO frequency. Bottom
panel: phase lags of the continuum between 0.1 and 5 Hz. Positive lags correspond to the
hard flux lagging the soft flux.
60
FIGURES
Figure 16: Average power density spectrum of the five PCA observations in 1997 when
high-frequency QPOs were detected. Both the 40 Hz and the 69 Hz peaks are visible (from
Strohmayer 2001).
FIGURES
61
Figure 17: Representative PDS for the three states of GRS 1915+105. A-short refers to
short intervals of state A. AB is from a smooth A -- B transition during class β (from Reig
et al. 2003).
62
FIGURES
Linear distance at 10 kpc (AU)
3000 2000 1000
0
1000 2000 3000
E
N
MAR 27
APR 03
APR 09
APR 16
APR 23
APR 30
752.7
753.7
754.7
755.7
756.7
757.7
.
)
0
0
0
0
0
5
-
1000 AU
D
J
M
(
e
m
T
i
758.7
759.7
760.7
761.7
762.7
1"
763.7
SE
SE
SE
C1
C2
C3
NW
NW
NW
300
200
100
-100
Milliarcseconds
0
-200
-300
Levs = -2.8, -2.0, -1.4, -1.0, 1.0, 1.4, 2.0, 2.8,
4.0, 5.6, 8.0 11.0, 16.0, 22.0, 32.0, 44.0, 64.0
1.00
1.00
0.50
0.50
0.20
0.20
0.20
0.20
0.20
0.15
U
n
i
t
c
o
n
t
o
u
r
l
e
v
e
l
(
m
J
y
)
Figure 18: Major (superluminal) relativistic ejections from GRS 1915+105. The left panel
shows VLA observations over a period of ∼ one month in 1994, from Mirabel & Rodr´iguez
(1994). The right panel shows higher-resolution MERLIN imaging over a period of ∼ 12
days in 1997, from Fender et al. (1999a).
FIGURES
63
Plateau
QPO
Radio
MERLIN
2.0cm (RT)
3.6cm (GBI)
13.3cm (GBI)
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
1
1
)
y
J
m
(
i
y
t
s
n
e
d
x
u
F
l
700
700
720
720
740
740
760
760
780
780
13.3 − 3.6cm spectral index
700
700
720
720
740
740
760
760
780
780
X-ray
x
e
d
n
i
l
a
r
t
c
e
p
S
0
0
.
.
1
1
0
0
.
.
0
0
.
.
0
0
1
1
-
-
0
0
0
0
2
2
c
e
s
/
t
n
u
o
c
M
S
A
E
T
X
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
700
700
720
720
740
740
Date (MJD − 50000.0)
760
760
780
780
Figure 19: A plateau state in GRS 1915+105, from Fender et al. (1999). The top panel
shows radio monitoring at three frequencies, from the Green Bank Interferometer (GBI)
and Ryle Telescope (RT). The plateau phase lasts from approximately MJD 50730 to MJD
50750, and is associated with a flat radio spectrum (middle panel). The plateau is associated
with steady X-ray emission (lower panel), which has a hard spectrum (state C). Prior to
the plateau is a small medium strength optically thin flare (preplateau flare in Klein-Wolt
et al. 2002), and following the plateau is a larger optically thin flare (postplateau flare),
which in this case was directly resolved into a relativistic ejection event (tickmarks indicate
the epochs of the MERLIN observations presented in the of Figure 18). Following the first
postplateau flare was a period of four days of X-ray dip/radio oscillation cycles, indicated
as QPO. Other occasions of plateaux have resolved the flat-spectrum radio emission into a
steady jet such as those presented in Figure 20.
64
FIGURES
C
E
S
C
R
A
i
l
l
i
M
2.0 cm
8
6
4
2
0
-2
-4
-6
-8
C
E
S
C
R
A
i
l
l
i
M
3.6 cm
8
6
4
2
0
-2
-4
-6
-8
8 6 4 2 0 -2 -4 -6 -8
MilliARC SEC
8 6 4 2 0 -2 -4 -6 -8
MilliARC SEC
Figure 20: Compact core jet associated with the plateau -- steady, hard X-ray and radio
emission -- state in GRS 1915+105 in April 2003 (adapted from Fuchs et al. 2003b). A
similar jet in a plateau state in 1998 was reported by Dhawan et al. (2000).
FIGURES
65
Figure 21: Simultaneous radio and X-ray observations of GRS 1915+105 in 1996, from
Pooley & Fender (1997). Despite the patchy X-ray coverage there is a clear hint of an
association between the semiregular X-ray dipping behavior and the radio oscillations.
66
FIGURES
Figure 22: Simultaneous X-ray and IR observations of GRS 1915+105 in August 1997, from
Eikenberry et al. (1998a).
FIGURES
67
Figure 23: X-ray/IR/radio light curve of GRS 1915+105 during a hard X-ray dip, from
Mirabel et al. (1998). The radio event is certainly associated with the cycle, and the IR
precedes it by ∼ 20 min -- probably indicating that the IR is synchrotron emission from
much closer to the base of the jet than the radio. Note the spike in the X-ray light curve
at which point the X-ray hardness drops dramatically, and has been suggested by Mirabel
et al. (1998) as the time of launch of the relativistic jet.
68
FIGURES
Figure 24: Orbital parameters of GRS 1915+105 from IR spectroscopy (Greiner et al. 2001).
The top panel shows the most likely orbital period, of 33.5 days, for the binary. The lower
panel shows the radial velocity data folded on this orbital period. From these data a mass
function -- corresponding to an absolute lower limit on the mass of the accreting object -- of
9.5 ± 3.0 M⊙ can be derived. Assuming a companion mass of ∼ 1.2 M⊙ and an orbital
inclination equal to the angle the jets make with the line of sight, i.e., ∼ 70◦, then Greiner
et al. estimate a mass of 14 ± 4 M⊙ for the black hole.
FIGURES
69
Figure 25: Jet power as a function of Eddington-scaled luminosity for X-ray binaries (open
triangles) and AGN (solid squares), adjusted for the mass term of Merloni, Heinz & di
Matteo (2003); from Maccarone, Gallo & Fender (2003). The reduction in radio power in
the approximate range 1% -- 10% Eddington is well-known in X-ray binaries as the quenching
of the jet in soft X-ray states, a phenomenon that may also therefore occur in AGN. The
data for GRS 1915+105 lie in the most luminous bin, corresponding to FRII-type AGN.
70
FIGURES
Figure 26: Possible analogous disc-jet coupling in the AGN 3C 120, from Marscher et al.
2002
FIGURES
71
Canonical XRB states:
soft − VHS/IS − hard
HS
LS
Plateaux
Oscillations
GRS 1915+105
state C−> A
iii
GRS 1915+105
state C (bright)
ii
hardness
y
t
i
s
n
e
t
n
i
r
o
t
c
a
f
z
t
n
e
r
o
L
t
e
J
no
jet
iv
iv
iii
ii
ii
i
s
u
d
a
r
r
e
n
n
i
c
s
D
i
i
i
iv
GRS 1915+105
state A / B
GRS 1915+105
state C (faint)
i
Figure 27: A schematic illustrating our model for the evolution of outbursts and related
phases of jet formation in GRS 1915+105 and other accreting black holes. Typical X-
ray binary outbursts follow the path of the solid arrows, transiting from the canonical LS
to the canonical HS via a monotonically softening VHS/IS. This evolution corresponds
to leftward motion across the hardness-intensity diagram (top panel). We suggest that
above some hardness a jet is produced, below that hardness the jet is suppressed, and
that close to the transition (indicated by the vertical line) the jet velocity increases to
significantly relativistic values (lower panel). This line may correspond to the geometrically
thin accretion disc reaching the innermost stable circular orbit around the black hole.As
a result, crossing the vertical line from left to right results in a shock in the outflow and
subsequent cessation of core jet production; this is observed as a singular optically thin
radio event. GRS 1915+105 seems to be semicontinuously located in the upper-left region
of the diagram, repeatedly crossing the vertical line, producing optically thin radio flares
each time it does so. A loop, such as that indicated by the circle, may correspond to a single
oscillation event. Extended plateau phases correspond to excursions towards the canonical
LS, but are inevitably terminated by a softening and major radio event as the source crosses
the vertical line once more. This model seems to be consistent with the behavior of other
black hole XRBs, and may even be applicable to AGN.
72
List of Tables
FIGURES
Comparison between the properties of the two apparently distinct types of jets
produced by GRS 1915+105 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Schematic comparison between the A/B/C states of GRS 1915+105 and the canon-
ical states of BHCs. (adapted from Reig et al. 2003) . . . . . . . . . . . . .
73
74
TABLES
73
Table 1: Comparison between the properties of the two apparently distinct types of jets
produced by GRS 1915+105
Relativistic ejections
Produced in < 24 h
Plateaux jets
Can be steadily produced for
up to ∼ 20 days
Optically thick spectrum
Rapidly evolve to an
optically thin spectrum
Up to 20% polarization
Low polarization (< 5%)
Highly relativistic (Γ > 2)
Some evidence for low velocity
Associated with steady hard X-ray Associated with hard→soft
(state C) phases
X-ray state changes
74
TABLES
VHS
1 -- 2
∼ 2.5
no
State A State B
State C
HS
∼ 1
2 -- 3
no
PL
-
LS
< 1
1.5 -- 2
yes
FT
Table 2: Schematic comparison between the A/B/C states of GRS 1915+105 and the
canonical states of BHCs. (adapted from Reig et al. 2003)
Parameter
kTa (keV)
Γb
Cutoffc
Noised
νbreak
rms
no
QPO
aTemperature of the disc blackbody component.
bPower-law index of the hard spectral component.
cPresence of a high-energy cutoff.
dType of noise in the PDS: FT stands for flat-top and PL for power-law.
1 -- 3 Hz
∼10 Hz
5% -- 10% 5% -- 10% 10% -- 20%
1 -- 10 Hz
FT & PL
≥ 1 Hz
1 -- 15%
1 -- 10 Hz
≤ 1 Hz
30 -- 50% < 3%
no
PL
-
no
1.8
∼ 3.5
no
PL
2.2
∼ 3.1
1.8 -- 2.5
0.8
no?
FT
no
no
|
astro-ph/0105464 | 2 | 0105 | 2001-05-31T16:26:41 | The Blandford-Znajek mechanism with Vacuum Breakdown as a Gamma-ray Burst Progenitor | [
"astro-ph"
] | The energetics of the long duration GRB phenomenum is compared with the BZ mechanism. A rough estimate of the energy extracted from a rotating Black Hole with the Blandford-Znajek mechanism is evaluated with a very simple assumption: an inelastic collision between the rotating BH and an accreting torus. The GRB energetics requires an high magnetic field that breaks down the vacuum around the BH and gives origin to a e$^\pm$ fireball. | astro-ph | astro-ph | The Blandford-Znajek mechanism with Vacuum
Breakdown as a Gamma-ray Burst Progenitor
Guido Barbiellini and Francesco Longo†
Department of Physics University of Trieste and INFN, Trieste
† Department of Physics University of Ferrara and INFN, Ferrara
Abstract.
The energetics of the long duration GRB phenomenum is compared with the BZ mechanism.
A rough estimate of the energy extracted from a rotating Black Hole with the Blandford-Znajek
mechanism is evaluated with a very simple assumption: an inelastic collision between the rotating
BH and an accreting torus. The GRB energetics requires an high magnetic field that breaks down
the vacuum around the BH and gives origin to a e
fireball.
PHENOMENOLOGICAL OVERVIEW
Gamma-ray Bursts (GRBs) until a few years ago were largely devoid of any observ-
able counterpart at any other wavelengths. However, a dramatic development in the last
several years has been the measurement and localization of fading X-ray signals from
some GRBs, lasting typically for days and making possible the optical and radio detec-
tion of afterglows, which mark the location of the GRB event. These afterglows in turn
enabled the measurement of redshift distances, the identification of host galaxies, and
the confirmation that GRB were at cosmological distances (for a recent brief review see
[1]). The temporal decay of the emission in different frequencies for several GRBs has
been interpreted according to the fireball model and suggested jet beaming with opening
angle q
4 [2].
Another important discovery made in the last year is the presence of iron lines in
the X-ray spectrum of GRBs (for example [3, 4, 5]). This provides a powerful tool to
understand the nature and the environment of GRB primary sources [6, 7]. The presence
of strong iron lines implies a rich environment located very close to the GRB and it may
be an argument in favour of massive-star progenitor models of GRB [8, 9, 10, 11].
The presence of an iron cloud is in favour of the interpretation of GRBs as a second
step of the residual of the primary explosion(e.g.[11]). In this interpretation the primary
explosion leaves over a compact object that could be a rotating black hole, at the center
of the environment consisting of ejecta. In this scenario, it is plausible the hypothesis
of energy extraction from a rotating BH (compact object left over from the primary
explosion), through the Blandford-Znajek mechanism [12], where the external magnetic
field can be supplied by an Fe torus circulating around the BH at a distance R (of the
order of Rs ).
FIGURE 1. Possible configuration of the magnetic field close to the BH surrounded by an accretion
disk (from [13])
GAMMA-RAY BURST PROGENITOR
At cosmological distances the observed GRB flux es imply energies of order of up to a
1054 erg), and from causality these must arise in regions whose size
solar rest-mass (
if of the order of kilometers in a time scale of the order of seconds. This implies that an
g fireball must form, which would expand relativistically. The short life time of the
e
GRB and the large distance suggest as the GRB source a compact system undergoing a
very energetic transition with high an efficient mechanism for conversion of energy into
g-ray emission. Accreting black holes are so good candidates for being source of GRBs.
Blandford and Znajek have proposed an interaction between a rotating BH and an
accretion disk to explain the energetics of Active Galactic Nuclei[12]. The same mech-
anism could be a good candidate for GRB engines[10, 14]. In the BZ mechanism the
magnetic field of the accretion disk acts as a brake on the BH, and the energy output is
mainly due to the loss of rotational energy. The rotational energy for a maximally rotat-
Jc
1, is 0.29 Mc2 . Even with the optimal
ing BH, with the rotation parameter a
M2G
efficienc y the energy availaible for the BZ mechanism is [14]:
3 1054 M
M
EBZ
erg
0
In the following considerations it we assume that a dissipative interaction is at work
between the BH and the torus surrounding it. The dissipative interaction is due to an in-
ternal torque. If the short interaction is treated as an inelastic shock it is possible to apply
the angular momentum conservation law ( in its classical mechanics approximation ).
IW
IdiskWdisk
IBHWBH
where IBH and Idisk are the momenta of inertia of the BH and the disk, WBH and Wdisk
are the angular velocities. I and W are the same quantities for the resulting BH. In this
approximation the loss of kinetic energy is
IBH Id isk
Id isk
WBH Wd isk
IBH
DE
1
2
2
Let us consider as a typical configuration a BH with a mass of 10 M
disk of 0.1 M
at the last stable orbit Rl
3Rs :
2
5 MBHR2
Mdisk 9R2
IBH
Idisk
s
s
2 Idisk
WBH Wdisk
DE
1
2
IBH
Idisk
Assuming that Wdisk
WBH , the energy availaible for the BZ process to power the
GRB is:
with a rotating
DE
IdiskW2
BH
1
2
8 1053 Mdisk
0
1M
erg
where we have used Id isk
s and WBH
9Md iskR2
c
Rs
.
VACUUM BREAKDOWN
If the environment is sufficiently clean, the GRB fireball
could be generated by the
vacuum breakdown[15] in the volume close to the polar cap of the BH. The magnetic
field required to explain the high luminosity of GRB generates an electric field that could
break down the vacuum.
The luminosity of the BZ mechanism is [10]:
2 MBH
10M
B
1015G
1051
erg s
LBZ
2
1
The BZ mechanism generates a voltage drop of the order [13]:
DV
1023
M
10M
B
1015G
V
, to this voltage drop corresponds
Assuming a mass of the BH of the order of 10 M
an electric field in the proximity of the BH:
DV
B
V
1015G
6p 104
2pR
m
The energy acquired by an electric charge e over the reduced Compton electron
wavelenght l
¯h
me c under this electric field can exceed 2 mec2 if:
eE l
6erg
From this relation it is possible to derive an estimate for the magnetic field:
6 10
1023
E
1
5 1015G
B
In the proximity of the BH is possible to generate e pairs than could give origin to
the GRB fireball, provided a sufficiently clean environment in order to avoid previous
electric field discharge.
ENERGETICS, TIME DURATION AND VARIABILITY
In the following we assume as hypothesis that the energy source of the GRB is the
onto a rotating BH of 10 M
. The available
gravitational collapse of a torus of 0.1 M
energy from this inelastic collision derived in a semiclassical approximation is DE
8 1053 erg. The interaction between the torus and the BH is assumed to be the BZ
mechanism with a magnetic field of the order of 1015 G.
The accreted material which releases its gravitational energy gives origin to a variable
R3
magnetic field that breaks the vacuum in a volume
s . The number of e
pairs
produced is:
0
2
Ne
84 1051
R3
s
l
3
3 1031 e
3 . If we assume that the magnetic energy
cm
The particle density is
3 is shared among them, each particle gets an energy e0
B2
4 1028 erg cm
2µ 0
3 erg, where hacc is the acceleration efficienc y. Each particle has an energy
3hacc 10
1
e0
5hacc 103 .
g0mec2 , so it is possible to derive the relativistic Lorentz factor g0
1
me c2
1051 e pairs in a volume V
R3
After the formation of the plasmoid containing
s ,
the particles undergo three important processes:
103 l
103 mc2 ,
c to acquire an energy
1) Particle acceleration in a time scale tacc
since each particle acquires on average an energy mc2 every l
.
l
c , where l is the mean free path
2) Momenta randomization in a time scale trandom
3 cm, using s
87
nb
1
3 .
5 1031 cm
for e
interaction. l
0
2 and n
3
sn
GeV
E
3) Single particle collimation by synchrotron radiation. The particles momentum
r
c , where
components normal to the magnetic field p
are damped in a time scale tcoll
r is the curvature radius. r
3EGeV
0
m. With the presence of a magnetic field of the
c
BT
order of 1015 G, the particles radiate all the energy corresponding to p
on a small
fraction of a turn.
The momentum components perpendicular to the residual field line outside the plas-
Rs
c and the plasmoids becomes a stream
moid for all the particles are damped in a time
g0 . As a result the
of particles with velocity parallel to the external field lines with g
1
3
plasmoid travels as a parallel stream with bulk Lorentz factor G
g
500hacc .
The energy of the particles in the plasmoid before the cooling by synchrotron emission
is:
2
4hacc 1047erg
3
8 1053 erg, so that the
Eparticles
R3
3 mec2G
l
The available energy in the overall inelastic collision is DE
emission of plasmoids could happen Nplasmoid time where:
DE
Eplasmoid
Nplasmoid
4hB 106
hB
2
where we have taken into account also the efficienc y, hB , for conversion of mechanical
hacc is the total energy available
energy into the magnetic field, and Eplasmoid
Eparticles
in each plasmoid.
Since the time duration of the engine is smaller or equal to the observation time
102s, the average time separation between two consecutive plasmoids is ts
tobs
4h
5s. In the fireball model the prompt g emission of the GRB is
1
10
tobs
Nplasmoid
B
due to internal shocks between plasmoids proceeding at different speed.
CONCLUSIONS
This models predicts for long duration GRB a pulsed emission from 105 emitted plas-
1) with an average time separation Dt
moids (with hB
tobs
4 s, corre-
0
10
Nplasmoids
1010m
1Rs . The train of “sausage”
plasmoids is
sponding to a distance in space of
at the end of engine activity. Its lenght is slightly modi fied during the internal shock
phase so that the overal time duration is dominated by the duration of engine activity,
the shortest time variability instead is determined by the plasmoids interactions.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank A.Celotti, G.Cocconi and M.Tavani for critical reading and valuable comments and
G.Fishman and N.Gehrels for the encouragement.
REFERENCES
1. MészárosP. (2001), Science, 291, 79
2. Frail D.A. et al. (2001), Nature submitted, astro-ph/0102282
3. Amati L. et al (2000), Science 290, 953.
4. Piro L. et al (2000), Science 290, 955.
5. Antonelli L.A. et al. (2000), ApJ 545, L39
6. Rees M.J. & MészárosP. (2000), ApJ 545, L73
7. Vietri M. et al (2001), ApJ 550, L43
8. Woosley S.E. (1993), ApJ 405, 273
9. Paczynski B. (1993), in Texas/Pascos 92, Akerlof C.W. and Srednicki M.A. eds., Annals of
the New York Academy of Sciences 688, 321
10. Paczynski B. (1998), ApJ 494, L95
11. Vietri M. and Stella L. (1998), ApJ 507, L45
12. Blandford R.D. & Znajek R.L. (1977), MNRAS 179, 433
13. Thorne K.S., Price R.H. and Macdonald D.A.(1986), Black holes: the membrane paradigm,
Yale University Press
14. Lee H.K. et al. (2000), Physics Reports 325 83
15. Ruffini R. (1998), astro-ph/9811232 , in Black holes and high energy astrophysics ,
Sato, H. and Sugiyama, N., eds. Proceedings of the Yamada conference XLIX.
|
astro-ph/0506369 | 1 | 0506 | 2005-06-16T06:13:47 | Jet Formation in Black Hole Accretion Systems II: Numerical Models | [
"astro-ph"
] | In a companion theory paper, we presented a unified model of jet formation. We suggested that primarily two types of relativistic jets form near accreting black holes: a potentially ultrarelativistic Poynting-dominated jet and a Poynting-baryon jet. We showed that, for the collapsar model, the neutrino-driven enthalpy flux (classic fireball model) is probably dominated by the Blandford-Znajek energy flux, which predicts a jet Lorentz factor of $\Gamma\sim 100-1000$. We showed that radiatively inefficient AGN, such as M87, are synchrotron-cooling limited to $\Gamma\sim 2-10$. Radiatively efficient x-ray binaries, such as GRS1915+105, are Compton-drag limited to $\Gamma \lesssim 2$, but the jet may be destroyed by Compton drag. However, the Poynting-baryon jet is a collimated outflow with $\Gamma \sim 1-3$. Here we present general relativistic hydromagnetic simulations of black hole accretion with pair creation used to simulate jet formation in GRBs, AGN, and x-ray binaries. Our collapsar model shows the development of a patchy ``magnetic fireball'' with typically $\Gamma\sim 100-1000$ and a Gaussian structure. Temporal variability of the jet is dominated by toroidal field instabilities for $\gtrsim 10^2$ gravitational radii. A broader Poynting-baryon jet with $\Gamma\sim 1.5$ could contribute to a supernova. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
WEB LINK FOR HIGH RESOLUTION DOCUMENT IN FOOTNOTE
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 11/26/04
JET FORMATION IN BLACK HOLE ACCRETION SYSTEMS II: NUMERICAL MODELS
JONATHAN C. MCKINNEY1
June 16, 2005
ABSTRACT
In a companion theory paper, we presented a unified model of jet formation. We suggested that primarily two
types of relativistic jets form near accreting black holes: a potentially ultrarelativistic Poynting-dominated jet
and a Poynting-baryon jet. We showed that, for the collapsar model, the neutrino-driven enthalpy flux (classic
fireball model) is probably dominated by the Blandford-Znajek energy flux, which predicts a jet Lorentz factor
but the jet may be destroyed by Compton drag. However, the Poynting-baryon jet is a collimated outflow with
of Γ ∼ 100 - 1000. We showed that radiatively inefficient AGN, such as M87, are synchrotron-cooling limited
to Γ ∼ 2 - 10. Radiatively efficient x-ray binaries, such as GRS1915+105, are Compton-drag limited to Γ . 2,
Γ ∼ 1 - 3. Here we present general relativistic hydromagnetic simulations of black hole accretion with pair
development of a patchy "magnetic fireball" with typically Γ ∼ 100- 1000 and a Gaussian structure. Temporal
variability of the jet is dominated by toroidal field instabilities for & 102 gravitational radii. A broader Poynting-
baryon jet with Γ ∼ 1.5 could contribute to a supernova.
Subject headings: accretion disks, black hole physics, galaxies: jets, gamma rays: bursts, X-rays : bursts,
creation used to simulate jet formation in GRBs, AGN, and x-ray binaries. Our collapsar model shows the
supernovae: general, neutrinos
1. INTRODUCTION
General relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (GRMHD) is
the black hole mass-invariant (nonradiative) physics com-
monly used to describe black hole accretion systems. Such
systems often exhibit jets. However, the observed jet prop-
erties, such as collimation and speed, are not uniform be-
tween systems. In McKinney (2005b), our goal was to deter-
mine the unifying, or minimum number of, pieces of physics
that would explain jet formation associated with gamma-ray
bursts (GRBs), active galactic nuclei (AGN), and x-ray bi-
naries. Similar ideas have been explored by other authors
(Ghisellini & Celotti 2002; Ghisellini 2003; Meier 2003).
The goal of McKinney (2005b) was to understand jet forma-
tion and explain the origin of the energy, composition, colli-
mation, and Lorentz factor.
This paper implements some of the theoretical ideas of
McKinney (2005b) into a GRMHD numerical model. In par-
ticular, we study the collapsar model with pair creation and
an effective model for Fick diffusion of neutrons that con-
taminate the jet with an electron-proton plasma. The generic
model parameters also allow the numerical model to be inter-
preted as a model for AGN systems such as M87. We also
comment on the applicability of the model to x-ray binary
systems.
§ 2 summarizes the proposed unified model to explain jet
formation in all black hole accretion systems, where more de-
tails are provided in McKinney (2005b).
§ 3 presents the results of a fiducial numerical model corre-
sponding to the collapsar model and describes the jet structure
and formation. The relevance of the presented model to AGN
and x-ray binaries is discussed. The jet is found to have some
piece-wise self-similar features, and curve fits are given for
use by other modellers. Acceleration of the GRB jet is found
to occur over a large range in radii rather than occurring close
1 Institute for Theory and Computation, Harvard-Smithsonian Center for
Astrophysics, 60 Garden Street, MS 51, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA
High Res. Figures: http://rainman.astro.uiuc.edu/~jon/jet2.pdf
Electronic address: [email protected]
to the black hole. The introductory estimates of the Lorentz
factor in McKinney (2005b) are refined based upon these nu-
merical models. The jet characteristic structure, such as the
formation of a double transonic (transfast) flow, is discussed.
§ 4 discusses the results and their possible implications.
The results are compared to similar investigations, and the
limitations of the models presented are discussed.
§ 5 summarizes the key points.
In appendix A, we give the GRMHD equations of motion
solved when accounting for pair creation. See also McKinney
(2005b) for relevant discussions. These are the equations nu-
merically solved that give the results discussed in section 3.
These are straightforward and how one handles the details
of the pair creation ends up not making any qualitative (or
much quantitative) difference in the results, hence why the
material is in the appendix. That is, the energetics of the
Poynting-dominated jet are dominated by the electromagnetic
field. Appendix B summarizes the well-known characteristics
of the GRMHD equations and other surfaces of physical in-
terest used in the discussion in section 3.
2. GRMHD PAIR INJECTION MODEL OF JET FORMATION
In McKinney (2005b), we showed that one can identify a
small subset of physics that can explain the jet energy, com-
position, collimation, and Lorentz factor for all black hole ac-
cretion systems.
One key idea of that paper is that the terminal Lorentz fac-
tor is determined by the toroidal magnetic energy per unit pair
mass density energy near the location where pairs can escape
to infinity (beyond the so-called "stagnation surface"). For
GRBs, neutron diffusion is crucial to explain (and limit) the
Lorentz factor and explain the baryon-pollution or baryon-
contamination problem. For AGN and x-ray binaries, since
a negligible number of baryons cross the field lines, pair-
loading from radiative annihilation is crucial to determine the
Lorentz factor of the Poynting-dominated jet since this deter-
mines the rest-mass flux and density in the jet.
Figure 1 shows the basic picture for GRB systems, while
figure 2 shows the basic picture for AGN and x-ray binary
McKinney, J.C.
2
ENVELOPE
FAR−FIELD JET
MAGNETIC
FIREBALL
TRANSONIC
SHOCKS
100−1000 Rg
CORONA
CORONAL
OUTFLOW
EM JET
e−
e+
NEUTRON
DIFFUSION
STAGNATION
SURFACE
DISK
e
_n e
BH
FIG. 1. -- Schematic of pair-production model and subsequent magnetic
fireball formation for GRB disks. Fireball is extremely optically thick. Below
a stagnation surface, pairs are accreted by the black hole and so do not load
the jet. Here Rg = GM/c2.
ISM/ETC
CORONA
FAR−FIELD JET
PATCHY, COLD
JET
TRANSONIC
SHOCKS
100−1000 Rg
CORONAL
OUTFLOW
EM JET
e−
e+
hard
STAGNATION
SURFACE
g soft
DISK
BH
FIG. 2. -- Schematic of pair-production model and subsequent shock-
heating and emission. AGN jet is optically thin and emits nonthermal and
thermal synchrotron, while x-ray binary jet can be marginally optically thick
and emit via self-absorbed synchrotron and by severe Compton drag. Severe
Compton drag can lead to destruction of the Poynting-dominated jet.
systems. An accreting, spinning black hole creates a mag-
netically dominated funnel region around the polar axis. The
rotating black hole drives a Poynting flux into the funnel re-
gion, where the Poynting flux is associated with the coiling of
poloidal magnetic field lines into toroidal magnetic field lines.
The ideal MHD approximation holds very well, and so only
neutral particles such as photons, neutrinos, and neutrons can
cross the field lines and load the Poynting-dominated jet that
emerges.
The accretion disk emits neutrinos in a GRB model (γ-ray
and many soft photons for AGN and x-ray binaries) that an-
nihilate and pair-load the funnel region within some "injec-
tion region." For GRB systems, neutrons Fick-diffuse across
the field lines and collisionally decay into an electron-proton
plasma.
Many pairs (any type) are swallowed by the black hole, but
some escape if beyond some "stagnation surface," where the
time-averaged poloidal velocity is zero and positive beyond.
Pairs beyond the stagnation surface are then accelerated by
the Poynting flux in a self-consistently generated collimated
outflow. In the electromagnetic (EM) jet, the acceleration pro-
cess corresponds to a gradual uncoiling of the magnetic field
and a release of the stored magnetic energy that originated
from the spin energy of the black hole.
One key result of this paper is that the release of magnetic
energy need not be gradual once the toroidal field dominates
the poloidal field, in which case pinch (and perhaps kink) in-
stabilities can occur and lead to a nonlinear coupling (e.g. a
shock) that converts Poynting flux into enthalpy flux (Eichler
1993; Begelman 1998). In the proposed GRB model, this con-
version reaches equipartition and the jet becomes a "magnetic
fireball," where the toroidal field instabilities drive large vari-
ations in the jet Lorentz factor and jet luminosity.
In McKinney (2005b), we showed that in AGN systems,
nonthermal synchrotron from shock-accelerated electrons and
some thermal synchrotron emission releases the shock en-
ergy until the synchrotron cooling times are longer than the
jet propagation time. For AGN, jet acceleration is negligi-
ble beyond the extended shock zone, as suggested for blazars
beyond the "blazar zone" (Sikora et al. 2005). In x-ray binary
systems, the shock is not as hot and also unlike in the AGN (at
least those like M87) case the jet can be optically thick. Thus
these x-ray binary systems self-absorbed synchrotron emit if
they survive Compton drag.
For all these systems, at large radii patches of energy flux
and variations in the Lorentz factor develop due to toroidal
instabilities. These patches in the jet could drive internal
shocks and at large radii they drive external shocks with the
surrounding medium. The EM jet is also surrounded by a
mildly relativistic matter coronal outflow/jet/wind, which is
a material extension of the corona surrounding the disk. This
Poynting-baryon, coronal outflow collimates the outer edge of
the Poynting-dominated jet, which otherwise internally col-
limates by hoop stresses. The luminosity of the Poynting-
baryon jet is determined, like the Poynting-dominated jet, by
the mass accretion rate, disk thickness, and black hole spin.
In this paper, this unified model is studied numerically
using axisymmetric, nonradiative, GRMHD simulations to
study the self-consistent process of jet formation from black
hole accretion systems. These simulations extend the work
of McKinney & Gammie (2004) by including pair creation
(and an effective neutron diffusion for GRB-type systems) to
self-consistently treat the creation of jet matter, investigating
a larger dynamic range in radius, and presenting a more de-
tailed analysis of the Poynting-dominated jet structure.
2.1. Units and Notation
The units in this paper have GM = c = 1, which sets the
scale of length (rg ≡ GM/c2) and time (tg ≡ GM/c3). The
mass scale is determined by setting the (model-dependent)
observed (or inferred for GRB-type systems) mass accretion
rate ( M0[g s- 1]) equal to the accretion rate through the black
hole horizon as measured in a simulation. So the mass is
scaled by the mass accretion rate ( M0) at the horizon (r =
rH ≡ rL(1 +p1 -
g and
the mass scale is then just m ≡ ρ0,diskr3
g = M0[r = rH]tg. Un-
less explicitly stated, the magnetic field strength is given in
Heaviside-Lorentz units, where the Gaussian unit value is ob-
tained by multiplying the Heaviside-Lorentz value by √4π.
The value of ρ0,disk can be determined for different sys-
s- 1 and
j2)), such that ρ0,disk ≡ M0[r = rH]tg/r3
tems. For example, a collapsar model with M = 0.1M
⊙
n
g
Black Hole Jet Formation: Numerical Models
3
⊙
⊙
⊙
⊙
⊙
M ∼ 10- 2M
, then ρ0,disk ≈ 3.4× 1010g cm- 3. M87 has a mass
M ≈ 3M
yr- 1 and a black hole mass
accretion rate of
of M ≈ 3 × 109M
(Ho 1999; Reynolds et al. 1996) giving
ρ0,disk ∼ 10- 16g cm- 3. GRS 1915+105 has a mass accretion
yr- 1 (Mirabel & Rodriguez 1994;
rate of
Mirabel & Rodríguez 1999; Fender & Belloni 2004) with a
mass of M ∼ 14M
(Greiner et al. 2001), but see Kaiser et al.
(2004). This gives ρ0,disk ∼ 3× 10- 4g cm- 3. This disk density
scales many of the results of the paper. The disk height (H) to
radius (R) ratio is written as H/R.
M ∼ 7 × 10- 7M
The GRMHD notation follows MTW. For example, the
4-velocity components are uµ (contravariant) or uµ (covari-
ant). For a black hole with angular momentum J = jGM2/c,
j = a/M is the dimensionless Kerr parameter with - 1 ≤ j ≤ 1.
The rest-mass density is given as ρ0, internal energy density
it, where ∗F is the
as u, magnetic field 3-vector as Bi ≡
dual of the Faraday tensor. The contravariant metric com-
ponents are gµν and covariant components are gµν, where
beyond the frame-dragging of the black hole the metric in
Boyer-Lindquist coordinates is approximately diagonal such
that an orthonormal contravariant component is u µ = √gµµuµ
for any spatial component of uµ. The comoving energy den-
sity is b2/2, where bµ is the comoving magnetic field. See
McKinney & Gammie (2004) for details.
The Lorentz factor of the jet can be measured either as the
current time-dependent value, or, using information about the
GRMHD system of equations, one can estimate the Lorentz
factor at large radii from fluid quantities at small radii. The
Lorentz factor as measured by a static observer at infinity is
∗F
Γ ≡ ut = ut√- gtt
(1)
in Boyer-Lindquist coordinates, where no static observers
exist inside the ergosphere. This is as opposed to W ≡
utp- 1/gtt, which is the Lorentz factor as measured by the
normal observer as used by most numerical relativists.
In McKinney (2005b) we show that the Lorentz factor and
φ-velocity at large distances are
(2)
= E = - hut + ΦΩFBφ
= L = huφ + ΦBφ,
Γ
∞
u φ
∞
(3)
where h = (ρ0 +ug + p)/ρ0 is the specific enthalpy, Φ is the con-
served magnetic flux per unit rest-mass flux, ΩF is the con-
served field rotation frequency, Bφ is the covariant toroidal
magnetic field, and u φ
. Here E and L simply rep-
∞
resent the conserved energy and angular momentum flux per
unit rest-mass flux. Notice the matter and electromagnetic
pieces are separable, such that
= uφ,∞
Γ
+ Γ(EM)
∞
+ u(MA)
φ,∞
See McKinney (2005b) for more details.
= Γ(MA)
∞
= u(MA)
φ,∞
∞
uφ,∞
,
(4)
(5)
more robust two-dimensional non-linear solver (Noble et al.
2005). The new HARM also uses a parabolic interpola-
tion scheme (Colella 1984) rather than a linear interpolation
scheme. The new HARM also uses an optimal TVD third
order Runge-Kutta time stepping (Shu 1997) rather than the
mid-point method. For the problems under consideration, the
parabolic interpolation and third order time stepping method
reduce the truncation error significantly, including magneti-
cally dominated regions with b2/ρ0 ≫ 1.
Notice that no explicit reconnection model is included.
However, HARM checks the effective resistivity by measur-
ing the rest-mass flux across field lines. For the boundary be-
tween the coronal wind and the Poynting-dominated jet, the
total mass flux across the field line is negligible compared to
the rest-mass flux along the field line and the pair creation
rate. An unresolved model would load field lines with rest-
mass that crosses field lines and not properly represent any
physical resistivity (McKinney 2004).
3.1. Computational Domain
The computational domain is axisymmetric, with a grid that
typically extends from rin = 0.98rH, where rH is the horizon,
to rout = 104rg, and from θ = 0 to θ = π. Full 3D calcula-
tions with this dynamic range are not possible with today's
computers. Our numerical integrations are carried out on a
uniform grid in so-called "modified KS" (MKS) coordinates:
x0,x1,x2,x3, where x0 = t[KS], x3 = φ[KS]. The radial coordi-
nate is chosen to be
r = R0 + exnr
1 ,
(6)
where R0 is chosen to concentrate the grid zones toward the
event horizon (as R0 is increased from 0 to rH) and nr is con-
trols the enhancement of inner to outer radial regions. For
studies where the disk and jet interaction is of primary inter-
est, R0 = 0 and nr = 1 are chosen. For studies where in addition
the far-field jet is of interest, R0 = - 3 and nr = 10 are chosen.
The θ coordinate is chosen to be
θ = πx2 + 1
2
(1 - h(r)) sin(2πx2),
(7)
where h(r) is used to concentrate grid zones toward the equa-
tor (as h is decreased from 1 to 0) or pole (as h is increased
from 1 to 2). The jet at large radii is resolved together with
the disk at small radii using
h(r) = 2 - Q j(r/r0 j)- n jg j
(8)
with the parameters of Q j = 1.3 - 1.8, r0 j = 2.8, n j = 0.3,
r1 j = 20, r2 j = 80, and g j = g j(r) = 1
) is used to
2
control the transition between inner and outer radial regions.
To perform convergence tests, Q j and the overall radial and
θ resolution are varied. An alternative to this fixed refine-
ment of the jet and disk is an adaptive refinement (see, e.g.,
Zhang & MacFadyen 2005).
π atan( r- r2 j
+ 1
r1 j
3. NUMERICAL EXPERIMENTS
3.2. Initial Conditions and Problem Setup
This section presents the results of GRMHD numeri-
cal models with pair creation to self-consistently describe
the Poynting-dominated and Poynting-baryon jet formation
process. Our numerical scheme is HARM (Gammie et al.
2003a), a conservative, shock-capturing scheme for evolv-
ing the equations of general relativistic MHD. Compared to
the original HARM, the inversion of conserved quantities to
primitive variables is performed by using a new faster and
All the experiments evolve a weakly magnetized torus
around a Kerr black hole in axisymmetry. The focus of our
numerical investigation is to study a high resolution model of
the collapsar model. Other simulations were performed, and
the fiducial model's relevance to AGN and x-ray binary sys-
tems is discussed at the end of the section. A generic model
is used so the results mostly can be applied to any black hole
system. A black hole spin of j = 0.9375 is chosen, but this
4
McKinney, J.C.
produces similar results to models with 0.5 . j . 0.97, which
includes most black hole accretion systems.
accretion disk would still be turbulent.
For the collapsar model, at the quasi-steady state mass ac-
cretion rate of 0.1M
⊙/s the disk will last for t . 0.42s. Thus,
this model requires a more extended disk or a fresh supply
of plasma into the disk from the surrounding stellar enve-
lope through an "accretion shock" to generate a long dura-
tion GRBs (MacFadyen & Woosley 1999). However, since
any such system modelled is in quasi-steady state, the results
here do not strongly depend on the mass of the disk as long as
the disk is not too massive, which would require taking into
account the self-gravity of the disk.
The numerical resolution of these models is 512×256 com-
pared to 4562 in McKinney & Gammie (2004). However, due
to the enhanced θ grid, the resolution in the far-field jet region
is ∼ 10 times larger. Also, with the use of a parabolic interpo-
lation scheme, the overall resolution is additionally enhanced.
Compared to our previous model this gives us an effective θ
resolution of ≈ 9000.
As with McKinney & Gammie (2004), into the initial torus
is put a purely poloidal magnetic field. The field can be de-
scribed using a vector potential with a single nonzero com-
ponent Aφ ∝ MAX(ρ0/ρ0,max - 0.2,0) The field is therefore
restricted to regions with ρ0/ρ0,max > 0.2. The field is nor-
malized so that the minimum ratio of gas to magnetic pres-
sure is 100. The equilibrium is therefore only weakly per-
turbed by the magnetic field. It is, however, no longer sta-
ble (Balbus & Hawley 1991; Gammie 2004). Hirose et al.
(2004); McKinney & Gammie (2004) show that no initial
large-scale net vertical field is necessary, since a large-scale
poloidal field is self-consistently generated. The field con-
nects the black hole horizon (as observed by a physical ob-
server) to large distances. Apart from the existence of an over-
all poloidal sign, the results are insensitive to the details of the
initial magnetic field geometry for any physically motivated
geometry (McKinney & Gammie 2004).
3.3. Floor vs. Pair Creation Model
Numerical models often "model" the injection physics in
the Poynting-dominated jet by employing a so-called floor
model. This model forces a minimum on the rest-mass den-
sity (ρ f l) and internal energy density (u f l), which are usually
set to several orders of magnitude lower than the disk density.
Actually, however, floor models have always been treated as
a purely numerical invention in order to avoid numerical ar-
tifacts associated with the inability to numerically solve the
equations of motion when the density is low. Indeed, the idea
was one should convergence test by gradually lowering ρ f l
and u f l. This is perhaps a reasonable for numerical study of
stars, but accretion flows are so hot (baryons with T & 1010K
in the thick disk state near the black hole) that pairs are cre-
ated when neutrinos annihilate (or when photons annihilate
for x-ray binary and AGN systems).
In previous numerical models of Poynting jets, the funnel
region is always completely evacuated, and floor-models nec-
essarily generate mass at least where the poloidal velocity
up = 0 at the stagnation surface. That is, matter inside the stag-
nation surface falls into the black hole, while matter outside
it is ejected as part of the jet. Indeed, arbitrary floor-models
violate the ideal-MHD condition far away from the black hole
where no pairs should be produced. For example, if a numer-
ical model uses ρ f l ∼ Const., then this leads to a completely
unphysical model of pair creation and the ideal-MHD approx-
imation is violated for the entire length of the jet in the funnel.
While pair creation has so far been ignored by those doing
at
the
initial
conditions
consist
of
an
The
center
The donut
(Fishbone & Moncrief
equilibrium
torus which is a "donut" of plasma with a black
1976;
hole
Abramowicz, Jaroszinski, & Sikora 1978).
is
supported against gravity by centrifugal and pressure forces.
The solutions of Fishbone & Moncrief (1976) corresponding
to utuφ = const. are used. The initial inner edge of the torus
is set at redge = 6. The equation of state is a gamma-law
ideal gas with γ = 4/3, but other γ lead to similar results
(McKinney & Gammie 2004). This donut is a solution to the
axisymmetric stationary equations, but the donut is unstable
to global nonaxisymmetric modes (Papaloizou & Pringle
1983). However, when the donut is embedded in a weak
magnetic field,
instability (MRI)
dominates those hydrodynamic modes. Small perturbations
are introduced in the velocity field to seed the instability. The
models have utuφ = 4.281, the pressure maximum is located
at rmax = 12, the inner edge at (r, θ) = (6, π/2), and the outer
edge at (r, θ) = (42, π/2).
the magnetorotational
(1999) find that an energetic outflow develops in the polar re-
This is consistent with the accretion disk that is expected to
form in the collapsar model (MacFadyen & Woosley 1999).
A GRB in the collapsar model is formed after the collapse
and spin
of a massive star as a black hole with MBH ∼ 3M
⊙
j ∼ 0.75- 0.94 accretes at M0 ∼ 0.1M
⊙/s from a torus of mat-
ter within r < 200 km that has a height (H) to radius (R) ra-
tio ("thickness") of H/R ∼ 0.2 - 0.4. MacFadyen & Woosley
gion where ρ ∼ 107 gcm- 3 near the horizon, ρ ∼ 105 g cm- 3
at r ∼ 200 km, and ρ ∼ 103- 4 g cm- 3 at r ∼ 2000 km (see
model 14A in MacFadyen & Woosley 1999).
In the par-
lance of collapsar models, our utuφ model corresponds to a
j16 ≡ j/(1016 cm2s- 1) of j16 ∼ 5, within the range suggested
the H/R ∼ 0.2- 0.4 as suggested that forms according to neu-
by MacFadyen & Woosley (1999) to produce a GRB. Also,
trino emission models (Kohri & Mineshige 2002; Kohri et al.
2005).
The orbital period at
For radiatively inefficient AGN and x-ray binaries this is
simply a reasonable approximate model for the inner-radial
accretion flow. While a slightly thicker disk (H/R ∼ 0.9) may
be more appropriate for radiatively inefficient flows, this is
not expected to significantly affect these results. A study of
the effect of disk thickness, especially thin disks, is left for
future work.
the pressure maximum 2π(a +
(cid:0)rmax/rg(cid:1)3/2)tg ≃ 267tg, as measured by an observer at infin-
ity. The model is run for ∆t = 1.4 × 104tg, which is about
52 orbital periods at the pressure maximum and about 1150
orbital periods at the black hole horizon. For the collapsar
model this is only ∼ 0.2 seconds, and at the spin chosen would
correspond to the late phase of accretion when the Poynting
flux reaches its largest magnitude. For the AGN M87 this cor-
responds to ∼ 7 years. For the x-ray binary GRS 1915+105
this corresponds to ∼ 1 second.
Notice that since the model is axisymmetric, disk turbu-
lence is not sustained after about t ∼ 3000tg ; that is, the anti-
dynamo theorem prevails (Cowling 1934). However, while
this affects the disk accretion, this does not affect the evolu-
tion of the Poynting-dominated jet. That is, from the time of
turbulent accretion to "laminar" accretion, the funnel region
is mostly unchanged. Indeed, the far-field jet that has already
formed is causally disconnected from the region where the
Black Hole Jet Formation: Numerical Models
5
numerical models of jets from black hole accretion systems, it
has been shown that the properties of the Poynting-dominated
jet are almost completely determined by the pair creation
physics, which thus cannot be ignored (Phinney 1983; Punsly
1991; Levinson 2005).
Our collapsar model accounts for pair creation and Fick dif-
fusion of neutrons.
In this paper, there is an injected rest-
mass, enthalpy, and momentum. For the fiducial collapsar-
like model, rest-mass, enthalpy, and momentum are injected
with energy at infinity fractions of, respectively, fρ = 0.05,
fh = 0.45, and fm = 0.5 as described in McKinney (2005b).
The total energy at infinity injected is determined by neutrino
annihilation rates and Fick diffusion rates. The energy injec-
tion rate from neutrino annihilation is based upon viscous disk
models (Popham et al. 1999; MacFadyen & Woosley 1999),
where the rate of injection is determined by choosing a vis-
cosity coefficient α = 0.01 and mass accretion rate M0 =
s- 1 for the collapsar model. As discussed in that pa-
0.1M
per, the rest-mass is dominated by electron-positron pairs only
very close to the black hole.
⊙
The value of α and M0 determine the energy injected in
proportion to the disk density per unit light crossing time (tg).
Thus any system with comparable normalized energy injec-
tion rate would follow similar results. For example, the M87
model is similar, where there the electron-positron pairs do
not annihilate and represent the true density in the jet. In the
M87 model there is no Fick diffusion, yet the dimensionless
model parameters are approximately the same.
The momentum direction is chosen by setting uφ
in j = uφ and
in j = 0, so that fm determines ur
in j. It turns out that the choice
uθ
of fh, fm, and the injected momentum direction very weakly
determine the jet structure for r & 6rg. This is because a large
fraction of the pairs are lost to the black hole and magnetic
forces, rather than the injected momentum, dominate the mo-
tion of the plasma near the black hole.
Beyond this injection region, the rest-mass is dominated
by electron-protons created in collision events from neutrons
that Fick diffuse across the field lines into the jet region. For
the collapsar model this coincidentally corresponds to the in-
jected rest-mass injected in this model. Since the electron-
positron pair annihilation only gives an additional ∼ 10% of
internal energy, then pair annihilation need not be considered,
and the rest-mass injected well-models the rest-mass injected
as an electron-proton plasma from Fick-diffused neutrons that
collisionally decay.
This physical model of the injected particles is augmented
when the rest-mass or internal energy density reaches very
low values. If the density drops below some "floor" value,
then the density is returned to the floor value. The floor model
chosen has ρ f l = 10- 7r- 2.7ρ0,disk and u f l = 10- 9r- 2.7ρ0,disk.
HARM keeps track of how often the density goes below the
floors and how this modifies the conservation of mass, en-
ergy, and angular momentum. The floor model contribution
is negligible compared to the physical injection model at all
spatial locations and at all times. The coefficient of the floor
was chosen to be close to the resulting density near the black
hole horizon. It was not chosen arbitrarily small in order to
avoid numerical difficulties in integrating the equations when,
rarely, the floor is activated in regions of large magnetic en-
ergy density per unit rest-mass density.
3.4. Boundary Conditions
Two different models are chosen for the outer boundary
condition. One model is called an "outflow" boundary con-
dition, for which all primitive variables are projected into the
ghost zones while forbidding inflow. The other model is to
inject matter at some specified rate at the outer boundary, un-
less there is outflow. This would correspond to a Bondi-like
infall for AGN and x-ray binaries, or would correspond to
the collapsing envelope of a massive star for collapsar mod-
els.
In particular, unless there is outflow, the outer bound-
ary is set to inject mass at the free-fall rate, with a density
of ρ0 = 10- 4r- 3/2ρ0,disk and u = 10- 6r- 5/2ρ0,disk and no angular
momentum. Presupernova models suggest that the infalling
matter is at about 30% the free-fall rate we have chosen above
(MacFadyen & Woosley 1999), but this difference is unlikely
to significantly affect the jet formation. Also, for their collap-
sar model, the density structure in the equatorial plane varies
between ρ0 ∝ r- 3/2 to ρ0 ∝ r- 2 and the internal energy is
u ∝ r- 5/2 to u ∝ r- 2.7 (MacFadyen & Woosley 1999). This is
similar to our simplified model, which happens to also model
a Bondi accretion for AGN and x-ray binaries. Thus the re-
sults are indicative of GRBs, AGN, and x-ray binaries. The
outer grid radius corresponds to about 20 presupernova core
radii (Woosley & Weaver 1995) or ∼ 1010 km or about 1/10th
the entire star's radius.
3.5. Fiducial Model
The overall character of the accretion flow is unchanged
compared to the descriptions given in McKinney & Gammie
(2004). The disk enters a long, quasi-steady phase in which
the accretion rates of rest-mass, angular momentum, and en-
ergy onto the black hole fluctuate around a well-defined mean.
Meanwhile, as in McKinney & Gammie (2004), a Poynting-
dominated jet and Poynting-baryon jet (coronal outflow) have
formed. The Poynting-dominated jet forms once the ram pres-
sure of the funnel material is lower than the toroidal mag-
netic pressure. Afterwards the baryons are spread apart in the
launch of a magnetic tube filled with pairs. This occurs within
t . 500tg.
The Poynting-dominated jet forms as the differential rota-
tion of the disk and the frame-dragging of the black hole in-
duce a significant toroidal field that launches material away
from the black hole by the same force described in McKinney
(2005b).
A coronal outflow is also generated between the disk and
Poynting-dominated jet.
In this model the coronal outflow
has Γ
∞ ∼ 1.5. The coronal-funnel boundary contains shocks
with a sonic Mach number of Ms ∼ 100. The inner-radial
interface between the disk and corona is a site of vigorous
reconnection due to the magnetic buoyancy and convective
instabilities present there. These two parts of the corona are
about 100 times hotter than the bulk of the disk. Thus these
coronal components are a likely sites for Comptonization and
nonthermal particle acceleration.
Figure 3 and figure 4 show the final time (t = 1.4 ×
104tg) log of rest-mass density and magnetic field projected
on the Cartesian z vs.
For the purposes of
properly visualizing the accretion flow and jet, we follow
MacFadyen & Woosley (1999) and show both the negative
and positive x-region by duplicating the axisymmetric re-
sult across the vertical axis. Color represents log(ρ0/ρ0,disk)
with dark red highest and dark blue lowest. The final state
has a density maximum of ρ0 ≈ 2ρ0,disk and a minimum of
ρ0 ∼ 10- 13ρ0,disk at large radii. Grid zones are not smoothed
x plane.
6
McKinney, J.C.
FIG. 3. -- Jet has pummelled its way through presupernova core and through
1/10th of entire star. Time is t = 1.4 × 104tg. Panel (A) shows final distribu-
tion of log ρ0 on the Cartesian plane. Black hole is located at center. Red is
highest density and black is lowest. Panel (B) shows magnetic field overlayed
on top of log of density. Outer scale is r = 104GM/c2.
to show grid structure. Outer radial zones are large, but outer
θ zones are below the resolution of the figure.
Clearly the jet has pummelled its way through the surround-
ing medium, which corresponds to the stellar envelope in the
collapsar model. By the end of the simulation, the field has
been self-consistently launched in to the funnel region and
has a regular geometry there. In the disk and at the surface
of the disk the field is curved on the scale of the disk scale
height. Within r . 102rg the funnel field is ordered and sta-
ble due to the poloidal field dominance. However, beyond
FIG. 4. -- Strongest magnetic field near black hole in X-configuration due
to Blandford-Znajek effect and collimation of disk+coronal outflow. As in
figure 3, but outer scale is r = 102GM/c2. Time is t = 1.4 × 104tg. Black hole
is black circle at center. Color scale is same as in figure 3.
r ∼ 10 - 102rg the poloidal field is relatively weak compared
to the toroidal field and the field lines bend and oscillate er-
ratically due to pinch instabilities. The radial scale of the
oscillations is 102rg (but up to 103rg and as small as 10rg),
where r ∼ 10rg is the radius where poloidal and toroidal field
strengths are equal. By the end of the simulation, the jet
has only fully evolved to a state independent of the initial
conditions at r ≈ 5 × 103rg, beyond which the jet features
are a result of the tail-end of the initial launch of the field.
The head of the jet has passed beyond the outer boundary of
r = 104rg. Notice that the magnetic field near the black hole
Black Hole Jet Formation: Numerical Models
7
FIG. 5. -- Contours for t ≈ 1500tg and an outer scale of r ≈ 102rg, where
the disk-corona boundary is a cyan contour where β ≈ u/b2 = 3, the corona-
wind boundary is a magenta contour where β = 1, and the jet-wind boundary
is a red contour where b2/(ρ0c2) = 1. Black contour denotes boundary be-
yond which material is unbound and outbound (wind + jet). Beyond r ≈ 10rg
the jet undergoes poloidal oscillations due to a toroidal pinch instability.
FIG. 6. -- Same as figure 5 but for t ≈ 1.4 × 104tg and an outer scale of r ≈
103rg. Disk wind leads to broad coronal outflow. Jet remains collimated to a
fixed opening angle. By r & 100rg, pinch instabilities subside once magnetic
energy converted into thermal energy and supports jet. Residual slow dense
and fast diffuse patches from the instability are present in the jet, such as the
slower and cooler dense blob shown at top left corner of figure.
is in an X-configuration. This is due to the BZ-effect having
power Pjet ∝ sin2 θ, which vanishes at the polar axis. The X-
configuration is also related to the fact that the disk+corona is
collimating the Poynting-dominated jet. The field is mostly
monopolar near the black hole, and such field geometries
decollimate for rapidly rotating black holes in force-free elec-
trodynamics (Krasnopolsky et al. 2005).
Figures 5 and 6 show the energy structure of the disk,
corona, and jet. This figure is comparable to the left panel of
figure 2 in McKinney & Gammie (2004). Figure 5 shows con-
tours for t ≈ 1500tg and an outer scale of r = 102rg, while fig-
ure 6 shows contours for t ≈ 1.4× 104tg and an outer scale of
r = 103rg. The disk-coronal boundary is represented as a cyan
contour where β ≡ pg/pb ≡ 2(γ - 1)u/b2 = 3, the coronal-
wind boundary as a magenta contour where β = 1, and the
jet-wind boundary as a red contour where b2/(ρ0c2) = 1. The
black contour denotes the boundary beyond where material is
unbound and outbound (wind or jet). Beyond r ≈ 10rg the jet
undergoes poloidal oscillations due to toroidal pinch instabil-
ities, which subside by r ≈ 102 - 103rg where the jet is ther-
mally supported. At large scales, the cyan and magenta con-
tours closer to the equatorial plane are not expected to cleanly
distinguish any particular structure.
Figure 7 shows the disk, corona, and jet magnetic field
structure during the turbulent phase of accretion at t ≈ 1500tg.
Compared to figure 4, this shows the turbulence in the disk,
but is otherwise similar. The jet, disk, and coronal structures
remains mostly unchanged at late times despite the decay of
disk turbulence. That is, the current sheets in the disk do
not decay and continue to support the field around the black
hole that leads to the Blandford-Znajek effect. The corona
thickness and radial extent do not require the disk turbulence,
which only adds to the time-dependence of the coronal out-
flow.
Figure 8 shows a color plot of Γ
, where red is highest and
FIG. 7. -- Field geometry near black hole for t ≈ 1500tg during phase of
strong disk turbulence.
∞ ∼ 103 - 104 and yellow has Γ
∞ ∼ 102 - 103.
reaches up to Γ
Panel (A) shows outer scale of r = 104rg, while panel (B)
shows outer scale of r = 103rg with same color scale. The
inner-radial region is not shown since Γ
is divergent near
injection region where ideal-MHD breaks down. Different re-
alizations (random seed of perturbations in disk) lead to up
∞ ∼ 104 as shown for the lower pole in the color
to about Γ
figures. This particular model was chosen for presentation for
its diversity between the two polar axes. The upper polar axis
is fairly well-structured, while the lower polar axis has under-
∞
∞
8
McKinney, J.C.
FIG. 9. -- A radial cross section along a mid-level field of the jet showing
the velocity structure. Top panel shows formation of magnetic fireball where
matter (MA) and electromagnetic (EM) energy flux per unit rest-mass flux
has Γ(MA)
∞ ∼ Γ(EM)
∞ .
∞
∞
∞
∞
dominated jet along a mid-level field line. The top panel
shows the late-time time-averaged values of Γ(EM)
(solid line),
(dotted line), and Γ = ut[BL - coords] (dashed line) as a
Γ(MA)
function of radius along a mid-level field line. For 2 . r . 10,
the value of Γ(EM)
is highly oscillatory. This shows the lo-
cation of the stagnation surface, where the poloidal veloc-
ity up = 0, is temporally variable. The stagnation surface
varies between 2 . r . 10, within the range studied in prior
sections. This is where ideal-MHD approximation is break-
ing and thus at any moment the value of Γ(EM)
nearly di-
verges. Notice that while at r . 103rg the Poynting flux dom-
inates, the Poynting flux energy is slowly converted into en-
thalpy flux due to nonlinear time-dependent shock heating.
Shocks are expected beyond the magneto-fast surface (see,
e.g., Bogovalov & Tsinganos 2005) and here are due to pinch
instabilities (Eichler 1993; Begelman 1998). For r & 103rg,
the enthalpy flux and Poynting flux are in equipartition.
Thus a "magnetic fireball" has developed and the terminal
∞ ∼ 400 for this choice of flow
Lorentz factor is of order Γ
line. The Lorentz factor by r ∼ 104 is still only 5 . Γ . 10,
with smaller patches with Γ ∼ 25. This implies there will be
an extended acceleration region where the magnetic fireball
loses energy during adiabatic expansion. These results should
also help motivate the boundary conditions used in jet simula-
tions (Aloy et al. 2000; Zhang, Woosley, & MacFadyen 2003;
Zhang W. et al. 2004), which sometimes start out with Γ ∼ 50
and u/ρ0 ∼ 150 near the black hole. Such a high enthalpy
only occurs by 103rg in our simulations. Their simulations are
somewhat indicative of the Lorentz factor growth beyond our
simulated time and radial range. This suggests that Γ ∼ 100
should occur by r ∼ 106rg and that Γ ∼ 103 should occur by
r ∼ 107rg. This is sufficient to avoid the compactness prob-
lem. A simulation of the acceleration region is left for future
work.
The next lower panel of figure 9 shows the electromag-
netic contribution to the specific angular momentum at infin-
ity (L = ΦBφ) (solid line), the matter contribution to the spe-
FIG. 8. -- Jet becomes conical at large radii with a core half-opening angle
θ j ≈ 5◦. Plot of log Γ∞ with red highest (Γ∞ ∼ 104) and blue lowest.
Yellow is Γ∞ ∼ 102 - 103. Panel (A) has outer scale of r = 104GM/c2.
Panel (B) outer scale r = 103GM/c2. Jet is independent of initial conditions
by r ≈ 5 × 103rg.
gone an atypically strong magnetic pinch instability. Various
realizations show that the upper polar axis behavior is typi-
cal, so this is studied in detail below. The strong hollow-cone
structure of the lower jet is due to the strongest field being lo-
cated at the interface between the jet and envelope, and this is
related to the fact that the BZ-flux is ∝ sin2 θ, which vanishes
identically along the polar axis. It is only the disk+corona that
has truncated the energy extracted, otherwise the peak power
would be at the equator.
Figure 9 shows the velocity structure of the Poynting-
Black Hole Jet Formation: Numerical Models
9
∞
t ≈ r2ρ0urΓ
where ǫ(θ) ≡ - r2T r
panel shows Γ
(solid line), Γ (dotted line) and Gaussian fits
to these two as dashed and long-dashed overlapping lines. The
lower left panel shows the angular energy structure of the jet
with an overlapping Gaus-
sian fit as a dotted line. The right panels show the density and
magnetic structure of the jet. The upper right panel shows the
density (solid line) and internal energy density (dotted line).
The lower right panel shows the orthonormal Boyer-Lindquist
coordinate toroidal (solid line) and radial (dotted line) field
components.
∞
∞
is approximately Gaussian with Γ
This jet structure is weakly due to an interaction with the
surrounding medium, and primarily due to internal evolution
of the jet. Clearly the slower jet envelope is non-negligible,
giving credence to the universal structured jet (USJ) model,
but see Lamb et al. (2004) and see Zhang B. et al. (2004);
Lloyd-Ronning et al. (2004). Gaussian jets have been used
to explain a universal connection between GRBs and x-ray
In most of our simulated
flashes (Zhang B. et al. 2004).
models the jet structure is Gaussian with ǫ(θ) = ǫ0e- θ2/2θ2
0 ,
where ǫ0 ≈ 0.18 and θ0 ≈ 8◦, within the range that they sug-
gest fits observations. The total luminosity per pole is L j ≈
0.023 M0c2, where 10% of that is in the "core" peak Lorentz
factor region of the jet within a half-opening angle of 5◦.
∞,0 ≈ 3× 103 and
Also, Γ
θ0 ≈ 4.3◦. Also, Γ is approximately Gaussian with Γ0 ≈ 5 and
θ0 ≈ 11◦. This can be folded into various models, such as the
probability of observing polarised emission in Compton drag
emission models (Ghisellini et al. 2000; Lazzati et al. 2004).
the above gives L j ≈ 4 ×
1051 erg s- 1 for this j = 0.9375 black hole model. This is
approximately equal to the luminosity emitted by the black
hole plus the energy in pairs produced by annihilating neutri-
nos. Not all of this energy can be observed in γ-rays to ob-
tain E j ≈ 2 × 1051 erg for a 30 second event (Zhang B. et al.
2004), unless the black hole has spin j ≈ 0.6 for most of the
burst, which would suggest little spin evolution that requires
a much thicker disk (Gammie, Shapiro, & McKinney 2004)
and so less neutrino emission and annihilation efficiency. In
McKinney (2005b), we found that Γ
is weakly dependent
on the black hole spin for a & 0.6, so the Lorentz factor is
likely unaffected by such changes.
the collapsar model
For
∞
⊙
⊙
M0 ∼ 0.002M
It is more probable that the emission in γ-rays is ineffi-
cient or only a fraction of the total energy is observed (i.e.
this requires . 2% for each if sole effect) ; or the true black
hole mass accretion rate is lower than predicted by current
s- 1 rather than M0 ∼
collapsar models (i.e.
s- 1 if sole effect). For the standard collapsar model, if
0.1M
one only observed the core of the jet, which has only 10% of
the luminosity, then an efficiency of converting to γ-rays of
≈ 20% is required to fit the model of Zhang B. et al. (2004).
Notice that the disk thickness (and so mass accretion rate)
may strongly determine the collimation angle.
In higher
mass accretion rate systems, the disk is thicker than described
here, and the final opening angle may be smaller. Also,
if the mass accretion rate is much lower, the disk is also
thicker (Kohri et al. 2005). The collapsar type model gives
the thinnest disk near the black hole and small changes in
the mass accretion rate lead to a small change in the disk
thickness (Kohri et al. 2005). Also, for the relevant black
hole spins, the spin only weakly determines the final colli-
mation angle (McKinney & Gammie 2004). The universal jet
model requires quite large opening angles that would not be
supported by invoking stellar (and so black hole) spin depen-
FIG. 10. -- A θ cross-section of the jet at r = 5 × 103GM/c2 showing
the velocity, density, energy, and magnetic structure in Gauss. Velocity and
energy structure show Gaussian fits as dashed lines. Vertical dashed lines
marks outer and core jet.
cific angular momentum at infinity (huφ) (dotted line), and the
specific angular momentum uφ (dashed line).
The bottom panel of figure 9 shows the orthonormal ra-
dial (ur = √grrur) (solid line) and φ (u φ = √gφφuφ) (dotted
line) 4-velocities in Boyer-Lindquist coordinates. The di-
rected motion becomes relativistic, while the φ-component
of the 4-velocity becomes sub-relativistic. However, the ro-
tation is still large enough that it may stabilize the jet against
m = 1 kink instabilities, as shown in the nonrelativistic case
(Nakamura & Meier 2004).
Figure 10 shows the θ cross-section of the jet at r = 5 ×
103rg for the upper polar axis according to figures 3, 4, and 8.
This is a location by which the jet has stabilized in time, where
farther regions are still dependent on the initial conditions.
The hot fast "core" of the jet includes θ . 5◦ at this radius
and is marked by the left dashed vertical line. Also, it is useful
to notice that θ ≈ 0.14 corresponds to the radius obtained for
the "mid-level" field line shown for radial cross-sections in
figures 9 and 11.
The region within θ . 27◦ is an expanded cold slow portion
of the jet. It is possible that the gamma-ray burst photons are
due to Compton drag from soft photons emitted by this jet
"sheath" dumping into the faster spine (Begelman & Sikora
1987; Ghisellini et al. 2000; Lazzati et al. 2004). Based upon
the data fits described below for r & 120rg and a radiation-
dominated plasma, the outer sheath's (θ ≈ 0.2) seed photon
temperature as a function of radius is
- 1/3
(9)
Tγ,seed ∼ 50keV(cid:18)
r
5× 103rg(cid:19)
These seed photons can be upscattered by the jet and produce
a GRB and high energy components. A self-consistent study
of a Compton dragged jet that determines Γ and the emission
energy is left for future work.
The right dashed vertical line marks the boundary between
the last field line that connects to the black hole. Beyond this
region is the surrounding infalling medium. The upper-left
10
McKinney, J.C.
limation slightly faster than logarithmic. For the field line
closest to the coronal wind (not shown) starting at θ j ≈ 1.0,
collimation is logarithmic with
- 1/3
θ j ≈ 1(cid:18) r
2.8rg(cid:19)
.
(10)
θ j ∝ r- 2/5
Closer to the polar axis the collimation is faster. For the field
line starting at θ j ≈ 0.3, approximately
(11)
up to r ∼ 102rg. The inner-radial collimation is due to con-
finement by the disk+corona, while in the outer-radial range
the coronal outflow collimates the Poynting flow. The corona
is likely required for the Poynting-dominated jet collima-
tion, since without a disk, a monopole-like field near the
black hole actually decollimates at higher black hole spin
(Krasnopolsky et al. 2005). Far from the coronal outflow, the
internal jet is collimated by internal hoop stresses. Note that
the classical hoop-stress paradigm that jets can self-collimate
is not fully tested here, but these results suggest that collima-
tion is in large part due to, or at least requires, the coronal
outflow.
Notice from figure 9 that there is little acceleration be-
yond r ∼ 102rg while the magnetic fireball is forming. It is
well known that magnetic acceleration requires field lines to
collimate (Begelman & Li 1994). Once the flow is pseudo-
conical the flow is unable to transfer magnetic energy into
kinetic energy and proceeds to convert it into enthalpy flux.
After r & 103rg the flow oscillates around a pseudo-conical
asymptote with a mean half-opening angle of θ j ∼ 5◦. The
opening angle has been found to be weakly dependent on the
black hole spin (McKinney & Gammie 2004) and, as found
in this paper, the details of the injection model. This resulting
pseudo-conical asymptote results once the magnetic energy
no longer dominates and the coronal wind no longer helps
collimate the flow. This opening angle is in line with expecta-
tions built around afterglow achromatic break measurements
and estimates of the opening angle based upon energy of the
burst. During the evolution of the burst, the jet may continue
to collimate due to a more extended coronal outflow. This
would be observed as an overall hard-to-soft evolution of γ-
rays since one is gradually exposed to the slower edges of the
jet since one likely does not observe exactly emission along
the core center. The additional loading of neutrons from the
coronal outflow may also lead to a hard-to-soft evolution of
the jet as the overall Lorentz factor decreases over the dura-
tion of the burst.
Figure 11 shows the toroidal field and pitch angle, which
shows that eventually the toroidal field completely domi-
nates the poloidal field, and the toroidal field remains or-
dered. Thus, large polarizations up to 60% are possible
(Granot & Königl 2003). The inner radial toroidal field is
well fit by
[Gauss] = 0.0023(cid:18) r
390rg(cid:19)
- 0.7
[Gauss] = 0.0023(cid:18) r
390rg(cid:19)
- 1.5
.
.
(12)
(13)
The outer radial field is well fit by
B φ
B φ
pρ0,diskc2
pρ0,diskc2
The transition radius is r ≈ 390rg. Notice that this is along
one mid-level field line, and the coefficients and power laws
FIG. 11. -- A radial cross-section of both poles of (solid and dotted lines)
jet along a mid-level field line in the jet showing the jet collimation, density,
and magnetic structure (B φ,r in Gauss). Overlapping dashed lines are fits.
dence. It would also not be supported by invoking mass ac-
cretion rate dependence, since a system with a higher or lower
accretion rate actually has a thicker disk (Kohri et al. 2005)
and so stronger collimation.
envelope compared to that
There is a weak dependence on the density of
the
seen in relativis-
stellar
tic hydrodynamic simulations of
jets (Aloy et al. 2000;
Zhang, Woosley, & MacFadyen 2003; Zhang W. et al. 2004),
since here the confinement is mostly magnetic. During this
energetic phase of the jet, the medium plays little role in shap-
ing the core of the jet, as has been suggested for other reasons
(Lazzati et al. 2005).
The peak Lorentz factors are obtained in a narrow region
within a core with half-opening angle of θ ≈ 5◦. Notice
as well that the very inner core of the jet is denser and
slower, a feature predicted in the theoretical discussion of
McKinney (2005b). This feature is simply a result that the
Blandford-Znajek flux is ∝ sin2 θ. Most of the Poynting en-
ergy is initially at the interface between the jet and surround-
ing medium, until the jet internally evolves to collimate into
a narrower inner core. Notice that in McKinney (2005b), we
predicted Γ
∞ ∼ 1000 for j = 0.9, where the simulated results
∞ . 103. This
show a peak Γ
is in reasonable agreement with analytic estimates given the
jet structure was not taken into account.
∞ ≈ 3× 103 and typical 102 . Γ
Figure 11 shows the collimation angle along a mid-level
field line in the Poynting-dominated jet, along the same field
line as in figure 9, and for both poles of the simulation. Gen-
erally the two poles are similar but not necessarily identical.
Many simulations that were performed show at least one polar
jet develop some pinch instabilities. In the model shown, one
side develops very strong instabilities by the end of the simu-
lation. The development of the pinch instability mostly affects
the far-radial Lorentz factor (Γ and Γ
-- and so densities).
The value of Γ is up to 5 times larger in pinched regions than
non-pinched regions, while Γ
can be up to a factor 10 times
larger in pinched regions compared to non-pinched regions.
∞
∞
In figure 11, for 7rg . r . 100rg there is a region of col-
Black Hole Jet Formation: Numerical Models
11
are slightly different for each field line. The pitch angle shows
that the field becomes toroidally dominated and at large ra-
dius the magnetic loops have a pitch angle of . 1◦ by 103rg.
For regions not on the axis there is no possibility of recon-
nection unless the flow is kink unstable (Drenkhahn 2002;
Drenkhahn & Spruit 2002). Given the regularity of the flow
field and the lack of randomized field, reconnection is not nec-
essary or likely. Here, the pinch instability drives a nonlinear
coupling such as shocks that converts the Poynting flux to en-
thalpy flux. This mechanism should be investigated in future
work.
The toroidal field dominance leads to m = 0 pinch mag-
netic instabilities. The m = 1 kink mode may also operate, but
studying the 3D jet structure is left for future work. As such
oscillations develop, this leads to arbitrarily sized patches
moving at arbitrary relative velocities as in the internal shock
model. The typical size of a patch is ∼ 100rg to ∼ 103rg in the
lab frame along the length of the jet. For long-duration GRBs
lasting about 30 seconds, the number of pulses should be no
larger than the ratio of the scale of the instability to the length
of the event (106rg), or about 100 - 1000 pulses. Different
realizations of the same simulation show that the likelihood
of an instability growing is random, which could lead to the
large variations in the number of observed pulses and explain
the diversity of observed pulses (Nakar & Piran 2002). That
is, some jets may have very few patches and so pulses. This
type of instability is likely required to produce the diversity
of GRBs. It is uncertain whether toroidal field instability in-
duced variability dominates pair creation loading variability
due to disk structure variability, which can be addressed by
future work that self-consistently treats the neutrino emission
from the disk.
Figure 11 also shows the rest-mass density per disk density,
internal energy density per rest-mass density, and the ratio of
(twice) the comoving magnetic energy density per unit rest-
mass density. Notice that the density is close to that estimated
in McKinney (2005b), so those calculations are likely reason-
able approximations to the simulation results. The inner radial
rest-mass density is well fit by
ρ0
ρ0,disk
= 1.5× 10- 9(cid:18) r
120rg(cid:19)
- 0.9
.
(inner)
(14)
The outer radial rest-mass density is well fit by
ρ0
ρ0,disk
= 1.5× 10- 9(cid:18) r
120rg(cid:19)
- 2.2
.
(outer)
(15)
The transition radius is r ≈ 120rg. Likewise, the inner radial
internal energy density is moderately fit by
- 1.8
u
ρ0,diskc2 = 4.5× 10- 9(cid:18) r
120rg(cid:19)
.
(inner)
(16)
The outer radial internal energy density is moderately fit by
u
ρ0,diskc2 = 4.5× 10- 9(cid:18) r
120rg(cid:19)
- 1.3
.
(outer)
(17)
The transition radius is r ≈ 120rg and is due to the presence
of the thick disk at small radii. Notice that this is along one
mid-level field line, and the coefficients and power laws are
slightly different for each field line. One can compare this to
the "envelope" density model used with
- 1.5
ρ0
ρ0,disk
= 8× 10- 8(cid:18) r
120rg(cid:19)
.
(envelope)
(18)
FIG. 12. -- Jet becomes superfast and toroidal field dominates at large
radii. Stagnation surface time-dependent but stable. Poynting-dominated jet
characteristic (and other interesting) surfaces. Red lines are field lines. From
r = 0 outwards: Blue#1: horizon + ingoing-fast ; Cyan#1: ingoing-Alfvén;
Black#1: B φ = Br ; Green#1: ergosphere ; Purple#1: ingoing-slow ; Black#2:
stagnation surface where poloidal velocity up = 0 ; Purple#2: outgoing-slow ;
Cyan#2: outgoing-Alfvén; Black#3: B φ = Br again ; Black#4: light cylinder
; Blue#2: outgoing-fast.
The envelope has little impact on the jet structure.
Figure 12 shows the characteristic structure of the jet. The
figure shows a log-log plot of one hemisphere of the time-
averaged flow at late time. In such a log-log plot, 45◦ lines
correspond to lines of constant θ. Lines of constant spherical
polar r are horizontal near the z-axis and vertical near the R-
axis. The field lines are shown as red lines. The disk and
coronal regions have been truncated with a power-law cutoff
for r . 100rg and a conical cutoff for larger radii. The inner-
most blue line is the event horizon. Clearly the field lines are
nearly logarithmic until r ∼ 100rg. After this point the field
lines stretch out and oscillate around a conical asymptote.
Blue lines in figure 12 show the ingoing and outgoing fast
surfaces. Clearly the transition to a supercritical (superfast)
flow has occurred. Within r . 10rg the plotting cutoff creates
the appearance that the fast surface and other lines terminate
along the cutoff.
The inner magenta line is the ingoing slow surface, while
the outer magenta line is the outgoing slow surface. The in-
ner cyan line is the ingoing Alfvén surface. Energy can be
extracted from the black hole if and only if the Alfvén surface
lies inside the ergosphere (Takahashi et al. 1990). The ergo-
sphere is shown by the green line, which is indeed outside the
ingoing Alfvén surface. The outer cyan line is the outgoing
Alfvén surface. The inner black line (next to the ergosphere)
is the surface where B φ = Br in Boyer-Lindquist coordinates.
At larger radii there are two overlapping black lines. One
corresponds to, again, where the toroidal field is equal to the
poloidal field. The other corresponds to the light "cylinder"
surface.
Other small artifacts in the plot are a result of unsteady na-
ture of the flow. However, the despite the unsteady nature of
the flow the characteristic structure is quite simple and rela-
12
McKinney, J.C.
tively smooth in appearance. This indicates that the flow is
mostly stationary. The stagnation surface is fairly unsteady,
but stable.
All the results discussed in this paper are robust to increases
or decreases in numerical resolution. Convergence testing has
been performed by choosing different models of the θ grid,
including different Q jet parameters that controls whether the
disk or jet is more resolved at small radii. Another resolu-
tion of 256× 256 instead of 512× 256 was also chosen. No
qualitative differences were found. The interpolation scheme
was also changed from parabolic to linear and no qualitative
differences for the far-field jet region were found.
We find that the pair injection model weakly determines the
bulk structure of the flow at large radii. Other injection mod-
els were simulated by varying the total energy injected ein j,
fraction of rest-mass created fρ, fraction of internal energy
created fh, fraction given to momentum energy fm, and the
φ-velocity of the injected particles. Only ein j and fρ strongly
determine the bulk jet flow.
Most of these results are insensitive to the two different
models of the surrounding medium. One model is a surround-
ing infall of material and the other is an "evacuated" exterior
region. The jet structure is negligibly broader or narrower in
the evacuated case due to magnetic confinement and collima-
tion by the coronal outflow.
∞ ∝ 1/ρ0, jet.
3.6. Simulation as Applied to AGN and X-ray Binaries
Notice that, quantitatively, all of these results can be simply
rescaled by density in the jet in order to apply to other GRB
models, AGN, and even approximately x-ray binary systems.
This is because by the outer regions simulation, the jet has
only reached about Γ ∼ 5 - 10 and Γ
In particular, numerical models for M87 give the same re-
sults with 2 . Γ . 10 patches by r ∼ 103rg. The key dif-
ference is that while the collapsar jet is very optically thick,
the M87 jet is not so most of the shock-heated energy is lost
to synchrotron radiation. The same structured jet is formed,
and is useful to explain TeV BL Lac objects and radio galax-
ies (Ghisellini et al. 2005) and may help explain observations
of blazars (Blandford & Levinson 1995; Ghisellini & Madau
1996; Chiaberge et al. 2000). The full opening angle of the jet
core of ∼ 10◦ also agrees with the observations of the far-field
jet in M87 (Junor et al. 1999). As discussed previously, the
shocks are synchrotron cooled and the heat generated does not
contribute to larger scale acceleration. While self-consistent
synchrotron cooling should be included, these results suggest
the shock zone (or "blazar zone" for blazars) should be quite
extended between r ∼ 102rg and up to about r ∼ 104rg.
Similarly, simulations were performed using an injection
model for GRS 1915+105 giving patches with 1.5 . Γ . 5
by r ∼ 102rg. Due to the efficient pair-loading there is lit-
tle extra Poynting flux to convert to enthalpy flux or kinetic
energy flux by the time shocks occur at r ∼ 102rg. As dis-
cussed in McKinney (2005b), the Poynting-lepton jet in the
GRS 1915+105 model is possibly destroyed by Compton drag
by disk photons and synchrotron self-Compton and limited to
at most Γ . 2, but the jet could be completely destroyed by
Compton drag.
3.7. Summary of Fits
A summary of the fits along a fiducial field line is given.
Near the black hole the half-opening angle of the full
Poynting-dominated jet is θ j ∼ 1.0, while by r ∼ 120rg, θ j ∼
0.1. This can be roughly fit by
- 0.4
θ j ∼(cid:18) r
rg(cid:19)
(inner)
(19)
for r < 120rg and θ j ∼ 0.14 beyond. The core of the jet fol-
lows a slightly stronger collimation with
(20)
up to r < 120rg and θ j ∼ 0.09 beyond. Also, roughly for M87
and the collapsar model, the core of the jet has
θ j ∝ r- 2/5
Γbulk ∼(cid:18) r
5rg(cid:19)0.44
(inner)
(21)
for 5 < r . 103rg and constant beyond for the M87 model
if including synchrotron radiation, while the collapsar model
should continue accelerating and the power law will trun-
cate when most of the internal and Poynting energy is lost
to kinetic energy and the jet becomes optically thin at about
r ∼ 109rg or internal shocks take the energy away.
If the
acceleration is purely thermal without any magnetic effect,
then Γ ∝ r (Mészáros & Rees 1997). However, it is not clear
how the equipartition magnetic field affects the acceleration.
Roughly for GRS 1915+105 the core of the jet has
Γbulk ∼(cid:18) r
5rg(cid:19)0.14
(inner)
(22)
for 5 < r ∼ 103rg and constant beyond, with no account for
Compton drag or pair annihilation. Also, for any jet system
the base of the jet has ρ0 ∝ r- 0.9
(inner) for r . 120rg and
ρ0 ∝ r- 2.2
(outer) beyond. For the collapsar and M87 models
ρ0,disk ∼ 1.5× 10- 9(cid:18) r
120rg(cid:19)
(inner)
(23)
- 0.9
ρ0
and
ρ0
ρ0,disk ∼ 1.5× 10- 9(cid:18) r
120rg(cid:19)
- 2.2
(outer),
(24)
while for GRS 1915+105 the inner-radial coefficient is 10- 5
and outer is 6× 10- 3. For the collapsar model, the inner radial
internal energy density is moderately fit by
- 1.8
u
ρ0,diskc2 = 4.5× 10- 9(cid:18) r
120rg(cid:19)
(inner).
(25)
The outer radial internal energy density is moderately fit by
u
ρ0,diskc2 = 4.5× 10- 9(cid:18) r
120rg(cid:19)
- 1.3
(outer).
(26)
The transition radius is r ≈ 120rg. For M87 the internal en-
ergy is near the rest-mass density times c2 until r ∼ 120rg
when the dependence is as for the collapsar case.
For
GRS1915+105 the internal energy is near the rest-mass den-
sity times c2 until r ∼ 120rg and then rises to about 2.5 times
the rest-mass density times c2. The inner radial toroidal lab
field is well fit by
B φ
pρ0,diskc2
[Gauss] = 0.0023(cid:18) r
390rg(cid:19)
- 0.7
(inner)
(27)
for 5 < r < 390rg. The outer radial toroidal lab field is well fit
by
[Gauss] = 0.0023(cid:18) r
390rg(cid:19)
- 1.5
(outer)
(28)
B φ
pρ0,diskc2
Black Hole Jet Formation: Numerical Models
13
for r > 390rg.
For the typical jet with no atypical pinch instabilities, the
energy and velocity structure of the jet follow
ǫ(θ) = ǫ0e- θ2/2θ2
0 ,
(29)
where ǫ0 ≈ 0.18 and θ0 ≈ 8◦. The total luminosity per pole
is L j ≈ 0.023 M0c2, where 10% of that is in the "core" peak
Lorentz factor region of the jet within a half-opening angle of
5◦. Also, Γ
∞
is approximately Gaussian
∞,0e- θ2/2θ2
(θ) = Γ
Γ
0 ,
∞
where Γ
Gaussian
(30)
∞,0 ≈ 3×103 and θ0 ≈ 4.3◦. Also, Γ is approximately
(31)
where Γ0 ≈ 5 and θ0 ≈ 11◦. The outer sheath's (θ ≈ 0.2) seed
photon temperature as a function of radius is
Γ(θ) = Γ0e- θ2/2θ2
0 ,
Tγ,seed ∼ 50keV(cid:18)
- 1/3
r
5× 103rg(cid:19)
.
(32)
4. DISCUSSION
A collapsar-type GRMHD simulation with a neutrino an-
nihilation model and Fick diffusion model has been studied.
A self-consistent Poynting-dominated jet is produced and the
∞ ∼ 103 in the core of
Lorentz factor at large distances is Γ
the jet, but an equally important structured component exists
∞ ∼ 102. The Lorentz factor of the jet is determined by
with Γ
the electron-proton loading by Fick diffusion of neutrons. No-
tice that estimates of the baryonic mass-loading from the op-
tical flash of GRB990123 suggest a baryon loading that gives
Γ ∼ 103 (Soderberg & Ramirez-Ruiz 2003), which is in basic
agreement with the findings here. The half opening angle of
the core of the jet is θ j ∼ 5◦, while there exists a significant
structured component with a half opening angle of θ j . 25◦.
It is likely that this jet component survives traversing the re-
maining portion of the stellar envelope (r ∼ 105rg, another
decade in radius).
The jet at large distances is unstable to, at least, an m = 0
pinch instability due to the dominance of the toroidal field
to the poloidal field (see, e.g. Begelman 1998). Here it is
found that the energy of the jet is patchy. Typical realizations
of the same model have a random number of patches with
∞ . 103. This likely results in a pulsed sequence
100 . Γ
of magnetic fireballs that move at large relative Lorentz fac-
tors, as required by the internal shock model (Mészáros 2002;
Ghirlanda et al. 2003; Piran 2005). The acceleration region
and internal shock region was not simulated since the dynam-
ical range required is another ∼ 6 orders of magnitude in ra-
dius.
Some models assume the Poynting energy to be con-
verted into radiation far from the collapsing star by internal
dissipation (see, e.g., Thompson 1994; Mészáros & Rees
2001; Drenkhahn
Spruit, Daigne, & Drenkhahn
1997;
Sikora et al.
2002; Drenkhahn & Spruit
2002;
2003;
Lyutikov, Pariev, & Blandford 2003)
such as magnetic
reconnection. However, in our model, significant internal
dissipation occurs already by 103rg.
A very efficient model that reduces the compactness prob-
lem invokes Compton drag (bulk Comptonization) to gen-
erate the emission, where the stellar envelope or presuper-
nova region provides soft photons (Ghisellini et al. 2000;
Lazzati et al. 2004). Our numerical model shows a jet struc-
ture with a slow cold "sheath" necessary for supplying the
seed photons, so this process might explain the GRB emis-
sion process.
As in McKinney & Gammie (2004), a mildly relativistic
Poynting-baryon jet is launched from the inner edge of the
disk with a half-opening angle of roughly 16◦ to 45◦, how-
ever long-time study of this jet component depends on sus-
taining long-time disk turbulence, which cannot be simulated
in axisymmetry. For GRBs, this hot baryon-loaded jet might
play a significant role in the subsequent supernova (by pro-
ducing, e.g., 56Ni) and be an interesting site for the r-process
(Kohri et al. 2005). The mass ejection rate is found to be
M0,coronal ≈ 0.03 M0, which for a 30 second event gives 0.1M
⊙
of baryonic mass. This may be sufficient to power super-
novae. The Lorentz factor is about Γ ∼ 1.5 - 3, such as ob-
served in a component of SN1998bw (Kulkarni et al. 1998).
For GRBs, the picture that emerges is that Poynting flux
is emitted from the black hole at r ∼ rg and is loaded with
electron-positron pairs within r . 20rg. A similar mass-
fraction of neutrons Fick-diffuses into the jet, and they dom-
inate the rest-mass once the temperature decreases to T .
6 × 109K by r ∼ 10rg. Magnetic acceleration occurs over
r . 102rg up to Γ ∼ 10. Notice that this is in contrast
to Mészáros & Rees (1997) who assumed the initial bulk
Lorentz factor is Γ[r = rH] ∼ Γ(EM)
, which assumed instan-
∞
taneous magnetic acceleration.
Once the toroidal field dominates the poloidal field, mag-
netic instabilities develops around r ∼ 10 - 102rg which turns
the jet into an equipartition "magnetic fireball" by r ∼ 103rg.
The spatial structure of the magnetic fireball energy flux is
patchy on the instability scale of r ∼ 102rg. Simulations that
demonstrate how these features would later interact require
much more radial dynamic range. Between 104rg . r . 108rg
the flow accelerates due to adiabatic expansion with a radial
dependence up to Γ ∝ r (Mészáros & Rees 1997), where the
Poynting flux provides a reservoir of magnetic energy that is
continuously shock-converted into thermal energy.
After passing the stellar surface at r ∼ 105rg, the plasma
becomes transparent to γ-rays at 106rg . r . 107rg, where
possibly Compton drag of the sheath seed photons produces
the GRB emission (Ghisellini et al. 2000; Lazzati et al. 2004).
By r ∼ 107, patches of varying Γ ∼ 100 - 1000 have reached
their terminal velocity. Between 108rg . r . 1010rg the fire-
ball is optically thin to Compton scattering, radiation escapes,
and pairs no longer annihilate but can continue to be magnet-
ically accelerated (Mészáros & Rees 1997). Within this same
radial range, internal shocks proceed to convert the remain-
ing kinetic energy to nonthermal γ-rays. Beyond 1010rg a re-
verse shock may occur and external shocks with the interstel-
lar medium (ISM) occur.
Simulations of AGN were performed, which show similar
Γ vs. radius as the collapsar case. That is, there is an early
transfer of Poynting flux to kinetic energy flux leading up to
about Γ ∼ 5- 10 by about r ∼ 103rg for an M87 model. This is
consistent with the lack of observed Comptonization features
in blazars (see, e.g., Sikora et al. 2005), although this is also
consistent with the fact that the optical depth to Comptoniza-
tion is low in such systems.
While prior work assuming Γbulk ∼ 10 and θ j ∼ 15◦ found
that the BZ power is insufficient to account for Blazar emis-
sion (Maraschi & Tavecchio 2003), as shown here the struc-
ture of the Poynting-dominated jet is nontrivial. The re-
gion with Γbulk ∼ 10 is narrower with θ j ∼ 5◦ and jet emis-
sion is likely dominated by shock accelerated electrons with
14
McKinney, J.C.
Γe & 100 with an extended high energy tail. This lowers the
necessary energy budget of the jet to be consistent with BZ
power driving the jet.
4.1. Theoretical Contemporaneous Comparisons
Theoretical studies of ideal MHD jets focused on cold
jets and the conversion of Poynting energy directly to ki-
netic energy (see, e.g., Li et al. 1992; Begelman & Li 1994;
Daigne & Drenkhahn 2002).
Indeed, much of the work
has focused on self-similar models, of which the only self-
consistent solution found is suggested to be R-self-similar
models (Vlahakis 2004). Unfortunately, such models result
in only cylindrical asymptotic solutions, which is apparently
not what is observed in AGN jets nor present in the simula-
tions discussed in this paper. The previous section showed
that some aspects of the jet are nearly self-similar and that
there is some classic ideal-MHD acceleration occurring in
this region. However, once the toroidal field dominates the
poloidal field, the Poynting flux is converted into internal en-
ergy until they reach equipartition. The conversion is due to
a time-dependent nonlinear coupling, such as shocks, due to
the magnetic pinch instability. Cold ideal-MHD jet models
would have no way of addressing this. This region also in-
volves relatively rapid variations in the flow, so stationary jet
models would have difficulty modelling this region.
Notice that GRMHD numerical models show that the mag-
netic field corresponding to the Blandford-Znajek effect dom-
inates all other magnetic field geometries (Hirose et al. 2004;
McKinney 2005a). For example, there are no dynamically sta-
ble or important field lines that tie the black hole to the outer
accretion disk as in Uzdensky (2005). All black hole field
lines tie to large distances or tie to the horizon-crossing accre-
tion disk. Also, there are no field lines that connect the inner-
radial accretion disk and large distances. The Blandford-
Znajek associated magnetic field is completely dominant, as
shown in, e.g., figure 3 and figure 4.
We have not directly included those effects of neutron dif-
fusion that induce a jet structure (Levinson & Eichler 2003).
However, there is probably strong mixing within the jet and
the large-scale jet is probably not affected by the details of
the interface where neutron-diffusion occurs. Alternatively,
the Gaussian structure we find may dominate the power law
structure they find since the Gaussian structure is due to a
strong internal electromagnetic evolution of the jet and matter
plays little role in setting the jet structure.
4.2. Numerical Contemporaneous Comparisons
MacFadyen & Woosley (1999) evolve a presupernova core
with a black hole inserted to replace part of the core and
evolve the nonrelativistic viscous hydrodynamic equations of
motion for various values of viscosity coefficient (α), mass
accretion rate, nuclear burning, stellar angular momentum,
and some models have an injected energy at the poles at some
fixed energy rate. For models in which they inject energy
at some specified rate, they find the baryon-contamination
problem is somewhat alleviated by forming a hot bubble. As
shown in their figure 28, they find the jet has u/(ρ0c2) ∼ 10
and they suggest that this corresponds to Γ
∞ ∼ 10, insuffi-
cient to avoid the compactness problem. Their α = 0.1 model
shows a significant disk outflow, which over the duration of
in mass that could power a
the GRB would yield M ∼ M
supernova. In their α = 0.01 model there are insignificant out-
flows.
⊙
⊙
Our MHD results are most comparable to their α = 0.01
model. We find a disk outflow yielding M ∼ 0.1M
, which
may still be sufficient to produce a supernova component. We
have self-consistently evolved the jet formation and included
an approximate model for the pair creation physics. In our
case the baryon-contamination problem is self-consistently
avoided by magnetic confinement of the jet against baryons,
where only a small number of neutrons Fick-diffuse into the
jet and self-consistently determine the Lorentz factor at large
distances. We find that neutrino annihilation energy is proba-
bly dominated by energy from the black hole. Notice that we
find Γ
The difference between their and our model is the presence
of a magnetic field and a rotating black hole, which drive the
BZ-effect and a stronger evacuation of the polar jet region.
∞ ∼ 100 - 1000, which is much larger than they find.
Proga (2005) have performed nonrelativistic MHD simula-
tions of collapsars with a realistic equation of state. They sug-
gest MHD accretion is able to launch, collimate, and sustain a
strong Poynting outflow, although they measure a jet velocity
of v ∼ 0.2c. They find the jet is Poynting flux dominated such
∞ . 10, insufficient to avoid the compactness problem.
that Γ
The rotation of the black hole is crucial to generate a suffi-
ciently Poynting-dominated jet. Similar fully relativistic sim-
ulations by Mizuno et al. (2004) have performed with a jet
velocity of only v ∼ 0.3c, which is due to their choice of the
"floor" model in the polar regions and the short time of inte-
gration.
Zhang, Woosley, & MacFadyen (2003); Zhang W. et al.
(2004) use a relativistic hydrodynamic model to simulate
jet propagation through the stellar envelope and subsequent
breakout through the stellar surface. They assume a highly
relativistic jet is formed early near the black hole and they
inject the matter with a large enthalpy per baryon of about
u/ρ0c2 ∼ 150. They also tune the injected energy to compare
with observations (Frail et al. 2001). In their view, variability
is due to hydrodynamic instabilities between the cocoon and
core of the jet. They find the stellar envelope can collimate
the flow.
We have self-consistently evolved the formation of the jet
along with the disk without having to assume a jet struc-
ture. We suggest that the injected energy per baryon is only
u/ρ0c2 . 20 unless super-efficient neutrino mechanisms are
invoked. We also find that the self-consistent energy released
is larger than observed, suggesting an fairly inefficient genera-
tion of γ-rays and a dominant lower Γ jet component that may
explain x-ray flashes. We suggest magnetic instabilities due
to pinch or kink modes dominate the variability rather than
hydrodynamic instabilities, which are known to be quenched
by magnetic confinement. We find that the jet structure is
negligibly broader for models with no stellar envelope due to
magnetic confinement and we find that the outer portion of the
Poynting-dominated jet is collimated by the coronal outflow.
Many hydrodynamic jet propagation simulations have been
studied (for a review see Scheck et al. 2002). Scheck et al.
(2002) evolve hydrodynamic relativistic hadronic and lep-
tonic jets using a realistic equation of state. They find that the
resulting morphology of the jets are similar, despite the differ-
ent composition. This suggests jet gross morphology is not a
useful tool to differentiate jet composition. In our model, the
most relativistic jet component is lepton-dominated in AGN
and x-ray binaries and baryon-dominated in GRB systems.
Notice that magnetic confinement quenches most hydrody-
namic instabilities.
De Villiers et al. (2005b) evolve a fully relativistic, black
Black Hole Jet Formation: Numerical Models
15
shocks may more slowly convert magnetic energy to thermal
energy. If this dissipation was delayed until the γ-ray photo-
sphere at r ∼ 107 - 108rg, then those shocks could be directly
responsible for the γ-ray emission from GRBs. Clarification
of this issue is left for future work. However, we expect that
toroidal field instabilities drive efficient magnetic dissipation
as shown in the numerical results presented here.
hole mass-invariant model, showing a jet with hot blobs mov-
ing with Γ ∼ 50. A primary result in agreement with the
results here is that a patchy or pulsed "magnetic fireball" is
produced. This is gratifying since it suggests that the devel-
opment of a "magnetic fireball" is not an artifact of the nu-
merical implementation but is a likely result of shock heating.
We also agree in finding that the core of the jet is hot and fast
and is surrounded by a cold slow flow. One difference is that
they say they seem to find the flow is cylindrically collimated
by r & 300rg, while we find nearly logarithmic collimation
until r ∼ 102rg and an oscillatory conical asymptote beyond.
Another difference is that they suggest temporal variability is
due to injection events near the black hole, while we suggest
it is due to pinch (or perhaps kink) instabilities at r & 102rg.
Another difference is that they find a larger value of Γ at
smaller radius than we find. Indeed, one should wonder why
their black hole mass-invariant model applies to only GRBs
and not AGN or x-ray binaries. This is a result of their much
lower "floor" density of ρ0 ∼ 10- 12ρ0,disk, which is not con-
sistent with self-consistent pair-loading or neutron diffusion
loading. Also, because they use a constant density floor, the
jet region at large radius must be additionally loaded with an
arbitrary amount of rest-mass. The typical "floor" model adds
rest-mass into the comoving frame, but this artificially loads
the jet with extra mass moving at high Γ. We suggest that
rather than the acceleration occurring within r . 700rg of their
simulation, that acceleration occurs much farther away before
the emitting region at r . 109rg. In their Γ ∼ 50 knots the
gas has 103 . u/ρ0c2 . 106. This implies that their actual
∞ . 107,
terminal Lorentz factor is on the order of 105 . Γ
which would imply that the external shocks occur before in-
ternal shocks could occur.
Komissarov (2005) study the BZ process and MHD Pen-
rose process. They found that the prior "jet" results of
(Koide, Shibata, Kudoh, & Meier 2002), who evolve only for
t ∼ 100tg, are only a transient phenomena associated with
the initial conditions. They also suggest that there are seri-
ous problems for the MHD-driven model of jets since they
do not find jets in their models except for contrived field ge-
ometries. However, this is potentially due to three effects.
First, their outer radius is r ∼ 50rg, while here we study out to
r ∼ 104rg. The magnetic acceleration only leads to a logarith-
mic increase in the velocity, so a large radial range is required
to observe relativistic motion. Second, magnetic acceleration
requires collimating field lines (Begelman & Li 1994), and a
disk or disk wind is probably required to collimate the mag-
netic outflow (Okamoto 1999, 2000). The "disk" that forms
in their models is relatively thin. Third, to avoid numerical
errors, they limit their solution to b2/(ρ0c2) . 100. Here we
find that a self-consistent source of jet matter from pair cre-
ation and neutron diffusion leads to b2/(ρ0c2) ∼ 105 near the
black hole. These three effects are probably why they find no
relativistic jets.
4.3. Limitations
As has been pointed out by Komissarov (2005), noncon-
servative GRMHD schemes often overestimate the amount
of thermal energy produced. All GRMHD numerical models
suffer from some numerical error. Shock-conversion of mag-
netic energy to thermal energy is modelled by HARM in the
perfect magnetic fluid approximation with total energy con-
served exactly. However, our numerical model may overesti-
mate the amount of magnetic dissipation in shocks, and so the
In order to evolve for a longer time than simulated in this
paper, other physics must be included. For long-term evolu-
tion of a GRB model, one must include disk neutrino cool-
ing, photodisintegration of nuclei, and a realistic equation of
state. If one wishes to track nuclear species evolution, a nu-
clear burning reactions network is required. For the neutrino
optically thick region of the disk, radiative transport should
be included. The self-gravity of the star should be included
to evolve the core-collapse. This includes a numerical rel-
ativity study of the collapse of a rotating magnetized mas-
sive star into a black hole (see review by Stergioulas 2003,
§4.3). The jet should be followed through the entire star and
beyond penetration of the stellar surface (Aloy et al. 2000;
Zhang, Woosley, & MacFadyen 2003; Zhang W. et al. 2004).
As applied to all black hole accretion systems, some
other limitations of the numerical models presented include
the assumption of axisymmetry,
ideal MHD, and a non-
radiative gas. The assumption of axisymmetry is likely
not important for the inner jet region since our earlier re-
sults (McKinney & Gammie 2004) find quantitative agree-
ment with 3D results (De Villiers, Hawley, & Krolik 2003).
The primary observed limitation of axisymmetry appears to
be the decay of turbulence (Cowling 1934), which we attempt
to avoid by requiring a resolution that gives quasi-steady tur-
bulence for much of the simulation. Also, the jet at large dis-
tances has already formed by the time turbulence decays, and
by that time the jet at large radius is not in causal contact with
the disk.
When the toroidal field dominates the poloidal field, even-
tually m = 1 kink instabilities and higher modes may appear
(see, e.g., Nakamura et al. 2001; Nakamura & Meier 2004).
Thus our models may underestimate the amount of oscillation
in the flow and the conversion of Poynting flux to enthalpy
flux.
The limitation of axisymmetry may also limit the efficiency
of the Blandford-Znajek process. The magnetic arrested disk
(MAD) model suggests that any accretion flow likely accumu-
lates a large amount of magnetic flux near the black hole. This
means the efficiency of extracting energy would be higher
(Igumenshchev et al. 2003; Narayan et al. 2003).
We have neglected low-energy jet and disk radiative pro-
cesses in the numerical simulations. Future work should in-
clude a model of synchrotron radiation for an AGN model in
order to simulate the "jet" emission to verify the claims made
in McKinney (2005b) that the broad "jet" emission observed
by Junor et al. (1999) is actually the coronal outflow rather
than the Poynting-dominated jet.
Also for AGN, a self-consistent simulation with syn-
chrotron emission would likely show the continuous loss of
Poynting flux until the synchrotron cooling timescale is longer
than the jet propagation timescale, which still suggests the jet
Poynting flux is finally in equipartition with the enthalpy flux.
This would suggest that the shock-zone, and so emission re-
gion, is more extended (r ∼ 102 - 104rg) than the simulated
shock-zone (r ∼ 102 - 103rg).
For AGN and x-ray binaries, the radiatively inefficient disk
16
McKinney, J.C.
approximation, which assumes electrons couple weakly to
ions, may not hold. If the electrons and ions eventually couple
near the black hole, then the disk might collapse into an un-
stable magnetically dominated accretion disk (MDAF) (Meier
2005). Like the MAD model, this might drastically alter the
results here, although it is uncertain whether jets are actually
produced under the conditions specified by the MDAF model.
The single-fluid, ideal MHD approximation breaks down
under various conditions, such as during the quiescent out-
put of x-ray black hole binaries, where a two-temperature
plasma likely forms near the black hole as ions and electrons
decouple (see, e.g., Narayan & Yi 1995). Resistivity plays a
role in current sheets where reconnection events may gener-
ate flares as on the sun, such as possibly observed in Sgr A
(Genzel et al. 2003). Finally, radiative effects may introduce
dynamically important instabilities in the accretion disk (e.g.
Gammie 1998; Blaes & Socrates 2003).
5. CONCLUSIONS
Primarily two types of relativistic jets form in black hole
(and perhaps neutron star) systems. The Poynting-dominated
jet region is composed of field lines that connect the rotating
black hole to large distances. Since the ideal MHD approxi-
mation holds very well, the only matter that can cross the field
lines are neutral particles, such as neutrinos, photons, and free
neutrons.
In McKinney (2005b), we showed that the primary differ-
ences between GRBs, AGN, and black hole x-ray binaries
is the pair-loading of the Poynting-dominated jet, a similar
mass-loading by free neutrons in GRB-type systems, the opti-
cal depth of the jet, and the synchrotron cooling timescale of
the jet.
In McKinney (2005b), we showed that for GRB-type sys-
tems the neutron diffusion flux is sufficiently large to be dy-
namically important, but small enough to allow Γ ∼ 100 -
1000. Beyond r ∼ 10rg many of the electron-positron pairs
annihilate, so the Poynting-dominated jet is dominated in
mass by electron-proton pairs from collision-induced neutron
decay. Most of the energy is provided by the BZ effect instead
of neutrino-annihilation.
In McKinney (2005b), we showed that for AGN and x-
ray binaries, the density of electron-positron pairs established
near the black hole primarily determines the Lorentz factor at
large distances. Radiatively inefficient AGN, such as M87,
achieve 2 . Γ
∞ . 10 and are synchrotron cooling limited.
The lower the γ-ray radiative efficiency of the disk, the more
energy per particle is available in the shock-zone. Radia-
tively efficient systems such as GRS1915+105 likely have no
Poynting-lepton jet due to strong pair-loading and destruction
by Comptonization by the plentiful soft photons for x-ray bi-
naries with optically thick jets. However, all these systems
have a mildly relativistic, baryon-loaded jet when in the hard-
low state when the disk is geometrically thick, which can ex-
plain jets in most x-ray binary systems.
A GRMHD code, HARM, with pair creation physics was
used to evolve many black hole accretion disk models. The
basic theoretical predictions made in McKinney (2005b) that
determine the Lorentz factor of the jet were numerically con-
firmed. However, Poynting flux is not necessarily directly
converted into kinetic energy, but rather Poynting flux is first
converted into enthalpy flux into a "magnetic fireball" due to
shock heating. Thus, at large distances the acceleration is pri-
marily thermal, but most of that thermal energy is provided
In GRB systems
by shock-conversion of magnetic energy.
this magnetic fireball leads to thermal acceleration over an
extended radial range. The jets in AGN and x-ray binaries
release this energy as synchrotron and inverse Compton emis-
sion and so the jet undergoes negligible thermal acceleration
beyond r ∼ 102 - 103rg.
Based upon prior theoretical (McKinney 2005b) and this
numerical work, basic conclusions for collapsars include:
1. Black hole energy, not neutrino energy, typically pow-
ers GRBs.
2. Poynting-dominated jets are mostly loaded by e- e+
pairs close to the black hole, and by e- p pairs for
r & 10rg.
3. BZ-power and neutron diffusion primarily determines
Lorentz factor.
4. Variability is due to toroidal field instabilities.
5. Poynting flux is converted into enthalpy flux and leads
to the formation of a "magnetic fireball."
6. Patchy jet develops 102 . Γ
internal shock model.
∞ . 103, as required by
7. Random number of patches (< 1000 for 30 second
burst) and so random number of pulses.
8. Energy structure of jet is Gaussian with θ0 ≈ 8◦.
9. Core of jet with θ j ≈ 5◦ can explain GRBs.
10. Extended slower jet component with θ j ≈ 25◦ can ex-
plain x-ray flashes.
11. Coronal outflows with Γ ∼ 1.5 may power supernovae
processed
(by producing, e.g., 56Ni) with M ∼ 0.1M
by corona.
⊙
Based upon prior theoretical (McKinney 2005b) and this
numerical work, basic conclusions for AGN or x-ray binaries
include:
1. Poynting-dominated jets e- e+ pair-loaded unless advect
complicated field.
2. γ-ray radiative efficiency, and so pair-loading, deter-
mines maximum possible Lorentz factor.
3. Poynting-lepton jet is collimated with θ j ≈ 5◦.
4. Extended slow jet component with θ j . 25◦.
5. For fixed accretion rate, variability is due to toroidal
field instabilities.
6. Poynting flux is shock-converted into enthalpy flux.
7. In some AGN, shock heat in transonic transition lost
to synchrotron emission and limits achievable Lorentz
factor to 2 . Γ . 10 (e.g. in M87).
8. Coronal outflows produce broad inner-radial jet fea-
tures in AGN together with well-collimated jet compo-
nent (e.g. in M87).
9. In some x-ray binaries, Compton drag loads Poynting-
lepton jets and limits Poynting-lepton jet to Γ . 2 or jet
destroyed.
Black Hole Jet Formation: Numerical Models
17
10. In some x-ray binaries, Poynting-lepton jet optically
thick and emits self-absorbed synchrotron.
for some systems. The sensitivity of these results to H/R is
left for future work.
11. Coronal outflows have collimated edge with Γ . 1.5.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
12. Coronal outflows may explain all mildly relativistic and
nonrelativistic jets in radiatively efficient systems (most
x-ray binaries).
For AGN and X-ray binaries, the coronal outflow collimation
angle is strongly determined by the disk thickness. The above
conclusions regarding the collimation angle assumed H/R ∼
0.2 near the black hole and H/R ∼ 0.6 far from the black hole,
while H/R ∼ 0.9 (ADAF-like) is perhaps more appropriate
I thank Avery Broderick for an uncountable number of in-
spiring conversations. I also thank Charles Gammie, Brian
Punsly, Amir Levinson, and Ramesh Narayan, with whom
each I have had inspiring conversations. I thank Scott No-
ble for providing his highly efficient and accurate primitive
variable solver. I thank Xiaoyue Guan for providing her im-
plementation of parabolic interpolation. This research was
supported by NASA-ATP grant NAG-10780 and an ITC fel-
lowship.
A. GRMHD EQUATIONS OF MOTION WITH PAIR CREATION
APPENDIX
A single-component GRMHD approximation that accounts for baryon conservation is summarized. Leptons are assumed to
be conserved in the equation of state (EOS) and by accounting for free-streaming neutrinos. We assume an ideal gas EOS
of relativistic particles and neglect radiative transport since we assume all particles either stream freely or are trapped in the
fluid. Alternatively, we assume the initial conditions well-model the steady-state radiative equilibrium. We model the streaming
photon/neutrino-annihilation into pairs by injecting rest-mass and energy-momentum at an appropriate fraction of the baryon
density.
The black hole has a Kerr metric written in Kerr-Schild coordinates, where the Kerr metric in Kerr-Schild coordinates and
the Jacobian transformation to Boyer-Lindquist coordinates is given in McKinney & Gammie (2004). We use Kerr-Schild rather
than Boyer-Lindquist because in Kerr-Schild coordinates the inner-radial boundary can be placed inside the horizon and so out
of causal contact with the flow. It is difficult to avoid interactions between the numerical inner boundary and the jet when using
Boyer-Lindquist coordinates. This interaction leads to excessive variability in the jet since the ingoing superfast transition is not
on the grid and then the details of the boundary condition significantly impact the jet. Numerical models of viscous flows have
historically had similar issues (see, e.g., McKinney & Gammie 2002).
A single-component MHD approximation is assumed such that baryon number is conserved up to a source term due to pair
creation due to either radiative annihilation or neutron diffusion, such that
where ρ0 ≡ mbnb, mb ≈ mn the neutron mass, nb = nn + np, and mp is the proton mass. One may choose an arbitrary mass weight
to define ρ0 in the single component fluid approximation.
For a magnetized plasma the conservation of energy-momentum equations are
where T µν is the stress-energy tensor, which can be split into a matter (MA) and electromagnetic (EM) part.
approximation
(A3)
with a relativistic ideal gas pressure pg = (γ - 1)ug, γ = 4/3, and Pµν = gµν + uµuν is the projection tensor. Either γ = 5/3 or
γ = 4/3 for either the baryon-dominated component or lepton-dominated component does not change the results described in
section 3.
MA = (ρ0 + ug)uµuν + pgPµν ,
T µν
A.1. Injection Physics
A detailed pair creation model would self-consistently determine the distribution of rest-mass and energy-momentum injected,
which is left for future work. In this paper, the rough results of Popham et al. (1999); MacFadyen & Woosley (1999) are used to
approximate the neutrino annihilation and pair creation. They determine the energy density creation rate in pairs as measured by
an observer at infinity ( ein j). A monoenergetic, monomomentum injection of rest-mass and energy-momentum is assumed. That
is, for a Lorentz invariant particle distribution function of
the fluid equations are derived from the Boltzmann equation
f =
dN
dx1dx2dx3du1du2du3
,
d f
dτ
=
dnin j
dτ
δ[uµ - uµ
in j]
(A4)
(A5)
for a particle creation density rate dnin j/dτ in the comoving frame of the existing fluid. There is no collisional term in the ideal
case. After mass-weighting and taking 4-velocity moments of the Boltzmann equation one has Sρ = (ρ0,in juµ
in j);µ, where ρ0,in j is
the injected rest-mass density and uµ
in j is the 4-velocity of the injected particles. Also, Sµ
. Here,
T = T µν
in j ;ν
dnin j
dτ ≡
me
mb
dne- e+,in j
dτ
=
1
mb
dρ0,e- e+,in j
dτ
,
(A6)
(ρ0uµ);µ = Sρ,
T µν
;ν =(cid:0)T µν
MA
+ T µν
EM(cid:1);ν
= Sµ
T .
(A1)
(A2)
In the fluid
18
McKinney, J.C.
so the fluid is still treated as a single component with a single mass weight mb. As discussed in McKinney (2005b), this is a
good approximation since the late-time Poynting-dominated jet region is dominated by lepton mass while the remaining region
is dominated by baryon mass. The simultaneous advected flux of injected energy is neglected, so then ST t = √- g ein j is valid in
Boyer-Lindquist, Kerr-Schild, or modified Kerr-Schild coordinates. This two-step approach (similar to operator splitting), where
particles are injected and then advected with the normal fluid, is a good approximation for typical numerical integrations that use
a multi-step timestep approach. This is also a good approximation because the injection region has a small 4-velocity beyond the
stagnation surface. Also, the error in the injection approximations being made is larger than the error in neglecting the advection
term. Thus
and
Sρ = ∂/∂t(√- gρ0,in jut
ST µ = ∂/∂t(cid:0)√- g(cid:0)q0,in jut
in juin j
µ
in j),
+ pin jδt
µ(cid:1)(cid:1) .
(A7)
(A8)
(A9)
(A10)
(A11)
where q0,in j ≡ ρ0,in j + uin j + pin j. This represents the source of energy-momentum, such as photon and neutrino losses emitted and
absorbed and the pairs created by annihilation of photons or neutrinos. This accounts for, in the guise of the MHD approximation,
"non-local" transport of energy and momentum. The injected particles are a relativistic gas with γ = 4/3 such that pin j = (γ - 1)uin j.
Two approximate injection methods are used to treat the injected momentum. One assumes that the momentum injected is
in j = Ω[R = rstag] for some typical origin of the neutrinos rstag.
mostly aligned with the axis with uθ
For the other, the particles are injected in the comoving frame of the existing fluid (i.e. uµ
in j = uµ). It turns out that these different
approaches lead to qualitatively similar results for the solution beyond the region where injection is important (r & 6rL in the
jet). The total energy density injected ( ein j as defined by an observer at infinity) is partitioned between rest-mass, enthalpy, and
momentum energy. The fraction of rest-mass injected is defined as fρ and so
in j = 0 and either vφ
in j = 0 or vφ
∂/∂t(√- gρ0,in jut
in j) = fρ√- g ein j.
The fraction of internal energy related injected energy is defined as fh, and so
The fraction of rest-mass plus momentum energy injected is defined as fρ + fm, and so
) = ( fρ + fm)√- g ein j.
∂/∂t(√- gρ0,in jut
in juin j
t
∂/∂t(√- g((uin j + pin j)ut
in juin j
t + pin j)) = fh√- g ein j.
Here fρ + fh + fm = 1.
McKinney (2005b) defines ein j, which along with the injection fractions and uµuµ = - 1 completely define the injection process
by allowing one to solve for ρin j, uin j, ut
for a fixed time interval dt. Radiative cooling effects are important for studying
hundreds of dynamical times, but otherwise can be neglected if the initial model is consistent with the time-averaged radiative
properties. Future work will refine the treatment of the pair creation process, considering the creation effects in the locally flat
comoving frame, once a self-consistent model is available.
in j, and uin j
t
A.2. Pair Plasma Annihilation
The electron-positron pair plasma that forms may annihilate itself into a fireball if the pair annihilation rate is faster than
the typical rate of the jet (c3/GM) near the black hole. Also, if the pair annihilation timescale is shorter than the dynamical
time, then pair annihilation would give a collisional term in the Boltzmann equation. From the pair annihilation rate given
in McKinney (2005b), one finds that tpa ≫ GM/c3 for AGN and marginally so for x-ray binaries. Thus, pairs mostly do not
annihilate, and so formally the pair plasma that forms in the low-density funnel region is collisionless so that the Boltzmann
equation should be solved directly. Plasma instabilities and relativistic collisionless shocks are implicitly assumed to keep the
pairs in thermal equilibrium so the fluid approximation remains mostly valid, as is a good approximation for the solar wind (see,
e.g. Feldman & Marsch 1997; Usmanov et al. 2000). This same approximation has to be invoked for the thick disk state in AGN
and x-ray binaries, such as for the ADAF model (McKinney 2004). For regions that pair produce slower than the jet dynamical
time, each pair-filled fluid element has a temperature distribution that gives an equation of state with P = ρ0,e- e+kbTe/me rather
than P = (11/12)aT 4, where a is the radiation constant. So most of the particles have a Lorentz factor of Γe ∼ u/(ρ0,e- e+c2)
and little of the internal energy injected is put into radiation. This also allow the use of a single-component approximation. A
self-consistent Boltzmann transport solution is left for future work.
On the contrary for GRB systems, due to the relatively high density of pairs, the time scale for pair annihilation is tpa ≪ GM/c3
along the entire length of the jet. Thus a pair fireball forms and the appropriate equation of state is that of an electron-positron-
radiation fireball. Thus, formally the pair fireball rest-mass density is not independent of the pair fireball internal energy density.
However, because the pairs are well-coupled to the radiation until a much larger radius of r ∼ 108 - 1010rL, the radiation provides
effective rest-mass density is ∼ ρ0 + u (u the total internal energy of the fireball), and so the effective rest-mass is independent of
an inertial drag on the remaining pair plasma. That is, the relativistic fluid energy-momentum equation is still accurate. So the
the cooling of the fireball until the fireball is optically thin (see, e.g., Mészáros & Rees 1997).
For GRB systems, the mass conservation equation is reasonably accurate. Even though the electron-positron pairs annihilate,
the rest-mass of pairs injected is approximately that of the pairs that are injected due to Fick-diffusion of neutrons (see appendix A
of McKinney 2005b). The annihilation energy from electron-positron pairs contributes a negligible additional amount of internal
energy, so can be neglected, especially compared to the Poynting energy flux that emerges from the black hole. Thus, the rest-
mass can always be assumed to be due to baryons rather than the electron-positron pairs. This also suggests that the neutrino
annihilation is a negligible effect if the BZ power is larger than the neutrino annihilation power.
In summary, the rest-mass evolution discussed in section 3 is accurate for GRB, AGN, and marginally so for x-ray binaries.
This is despite the lack of Boltzmann transport for the collisional system, or a collisional term due to pair annihilation.
Black Hole Jet Formation: Numerical Models
19
In terms of F µν, the Faraday (or electromagnetic field) tensor,
A.3. Electromagnetic Terms
(A12)
where a factor of √4π is absorbed into the definition of F µν. The induction equation is given by the space components of
∗F µν
;ν = 0, where ∗F is the dual of the Faraday, and the time component gives the no-monopoles constraint. The other Maxwell
equations, Jµ = F µν
;ν, define the current density Jµ. The comoving electric field is defined as
gµνF αβFαβ,
T µν
EM = F µγF ν
γ - 1
4
where η corresponds to a scalar resistivity for a comoving current density jµ = JνPνµ, where Pνµ ≡ gνµ + uνuµ projects any
4-vector into the comoving frame (i.e. Pνµuµ = 0). The classical ideal MHD approximation that η = eµ = 0 is assumed. The
comoving magnetic field is defined as
eν ≡ uµF µν =
1
2
ǫµνkλuν
∗F λk = η jν ,
(A13)
and so the stress-energy tensor can be written as
bν ≡ uµ
∗F µν =
1
2
ǫµνkλuν
∗F λk,
and
T µν
EM =
b2
2
(uµuν + Pµν) - bµbν,
∗F µν = bµuν - bνuµ
(A14)
(A15)
(A16)
and so
F µν = ǫµνσǫuσbǫ
2 ǫµνκλFκλ. Here ǫ is the Levi-Civita tensor. Following the notation of MTW, ǫµνλδ = -
(A17)
since ∗F µν = 1
1
√- g [µνλδ], where [µνλδ]
is the completely antisymmetric symbol and = 0,1, or - 1. Notice that eνuν = bνuν = 0, so they each have only 3 independent
components and are space-like 4-vectors.
With Bi ≡
it and Ei ≡ F it, the no-monopoles constraint becomes
(√- gBi),i = 0,
(A18)
∗F
and the magnetic induction equation becomes
(A19)
The ideal MHD approximation assumes that eµ = 0, and so the invariant eµbµ = 0. Since the Lorentz acceleration on a particle is
f µ
l = qeµ, then this implies that the Lorentz force vanishes on a particle in the ideal MHD approximation. Equation A14 implies
bt = Biui and bi = (Bi + uibt)/ut, so the magnetic induction equation becomes
(√- gBi),t = - (√- g(biu j - b jui)), j.
(√- gBi),t = - (√- g(Biv j - B jvi), j
= - (√- g(ǫi jkεk)), j,
(A20)
where vi = ui/ut, εi = - ǫi jkv jBk = - v× B is the EMF, and ǫi jk is the spatial permutation tensor. A more complete account of the
relativistic MHD equations can be found in Anile (1989).
The ideal MHD dispersion relation is given, e.g., in Gammie et al. (2003a) (there is a sign typo there), and summarized here.
In the comoving frame, the dispersion relation is
B. CHARACTERISTIC (AND OTHER) SURFACES
D(kµ) = 0
ω(cid:0)ω2 -
(cid:0)ω4 - ω2 (cid:0)K2c2
(k· vA)2(cid:1)×
s (k· vA)2/c2(cid:1) + K2c2
+ c2
s = (∂(ρ + u)/∂ p)- 1
ms
s (k· vA)2(cid:1) ,
is the relativistic sound speed, vA = B/√
(B1)
+ c2
s (1 - v2
ms = (v2
A
A/c2)) is the magnetosonic speed, c2
where c2
E is the
relativistic Alfvén velocity, E = b2 + w, and w ≡ ρ + u + p. Here c is the (temporarily reintroduced) speed of light. The invariant
scalars defining the comoving dispersion relation are ω = kµuµ, K2 = KµKµ = kµkµ + ω2, where Kµ = Pµνkν = kµ + ωuµ is the
projected wave vector normal to the fluid 4-velocity, v2
E. The terms in the dispersion relation
correspond to, respectively from left to right, the zero frequency entropy mode, the left and right going Alfvén modes, and the
left and right going fast and slow modes. The eighth mode is eliminated by the no-monopoles constraint.
A = bµbµ/E, and (k· vA) = kµbµ/√
The dispersion relation gives the ingoing and outgoing slow, Alfvén, and fast surfaces. Energy can be extracted from the
black hole if and only if the Alfvén point lies inside the ergosphere (Takahashi et al. 1990). Optimal acceleration of the flow by
conversion of Poynting flux to kinetic energy flux occurs beyond the outer fast surface (Begelman & Li 1994). Other surfaces
s
20
McKinney, J.C.
j2 ; the ergosphere at r ≡ 1 +p1 -
include: the horizon at rH ≡ 1 +p1 -
( j cosθ)2 ; the coordinate basis light surface in where
√gφφ = c/ΩF, where asymptotically √gφφ = r sin(θ) is the Minkowski cylindrical radius ; the surface in Boyer-Lindquist coor-
dinates where the toroidal field equals the poloidal field where B φ = Br. Finally, there is a stagnation surface where the poloidal
velocity up = 0. In a field confined jet where no matter can cross field lines into the jet, and if the jet has inflow near the black
hole and outflow far from the black hole, then this necessarily marks at least one location where rest-mass must be created either
by charge starving the magnetosphere till the Goldreich-Julian charge density is reached, or pair production rates sustains the
rest-mass density.
REFERENCES
Abramowicz, M., Jaroszinski, M., & Sikora, M. 1978, A&A, 63, 221
Aloy, M. A., Muller, E., Ibanez, J. M., Marti, J. M., & MacFadyen, A. I. 2000,
Anile, A.M. 1989, Relativistic Fluids and Magneto-fluids, (New York:
ApJ, 531, L119
Cambridge Univ. Press)
Balbus, S. A. & Hawley, J. F. 1991, ApJ, 376, 214
Begelman, M. C., & Sikora, M. 1987, ApJ, 322, 650
Begelman, M. C., & Li, Z. 1994, ApJ, 426, 269
Begelman, M. C. 1998, ApJ, 493, 291
Blaes, O., & Socrates, A. 2003, ApJ, 596, 509
Blandford, R. D., & Levinson, A. 1995, ApJ, 441, 79
Bogovalov, S., & Tsinganos, K. 2005, MNRAS, 357, 918
Chiaberge, M., Celotti, A., Capetti, A., & Ghisellini, G. 2000, A&A, 358,
104
Colella, P, & Woodward, P., 1984, JCP, 54, 174
Cowling, T. G. 1934, MNRAS, 94, 768
Daigne, F., & Drenkhahn, G. 2002, A&A, 381, 1066
De Villiers, J., Hawley, J. F., & Krolik, J. H. 2003, ApJ, 599, 1238
De Villiers, J., Staff, J., & Ouyed, R. 2005, astro-ph/0502225
Drenkhahn, G. 2002, A&A, 387, 714
Drenkhahn, G. & Spruit, H. C. 2002, A&A, 391, 1141
Eichler, D. 1993, ApJ, 419, 111
Feldman, W. C., & Marsch, E.: 1997, in J. R. Jokipii, C. P. Sonett, and M.
S. Giampapa (eds.), Cosmic Winds and the Heliosphere, Univ. of Arizona
Press, Tucson, 617.
Fender, R., & Belloni, T. 2004, ARA&A, 42, 317
Fishbone, L.G., & Moncrief, V. 1976, ApJ, 207, 962
Frail, D. A., et al. 2001, ApJ, 562, L55
Gammie, C. F. 1998, MNRAS, 297, 929
Gammie, C. F., McKinney, J. C., & G´abor T´oth 2003, ApJ, 589, 444
Gammie, C. F., Shapiro, S. L., & McKinney, J. C. 2004, ApJ, 602, 312
Gammie, C. F. 2004, ApJ, 614, 309
Genzel, R., Schödel, R., Ott, T., Eckart, A., Alexander, T., Lacombe, F.,
Rouan, D., & Aschenbach, B. 2003, Nature, 425, 934
Ghirlanda, G., Celotti, A., & Ghisellini, G. 2003, A&A, 406, 879
Ghisellini, G., & Madau, P. 1996, MNRAS, 280, 67
Ghisellini, G., Lazzati, D., Celotti, A., & Rees, M. J. 2000, MNRAS, 316,
Ghisellini, G., & Celotti, A. 2002, Blazar Astrophysics with BeppoSAX and
Other Observatories, 257
Ghisellini, G. 2003, astro-ph/0310168
Ghisellini, G., Tavecchio, F., & Chiaberge, M. 2005, A&A, 432, 401
Granot, J. & Königl, A. 2003, ApJ, 594, L83
Greiner, J., Cuby, J. G., & McCaughrean, M. J. 2001, Nature, 414, 522
Hirose, S., Krolik, J. H., De Villiers, J., & Hawley, J. F. 2004, ApJ, 606, 1083
Ho, L. C. 1999, ApJ, 516, 672
Igumenshchev, I. V., Narayan, R., & Abramowicz, M. A. 2003, ApJ, 592,
Junor, W., Biretta, J. A., & Livio, M. 1999, Nature, 401, 891
Kaiser, C. R., Gunn, K. F., Brocksopp, C., & Sokoloski, J. L. 2004, ApJ, 612,
L45
1042
332
Kohri, K., & Mineshige, S. 2002, ApJ, 577, 311
Kohri, K., Narayan, R., & Piran, T. 2005, astro-ph/0502470
Koide, S., Shibata, K., Kudoh, T., & Meier, D. L. 2002, Science, 295, 1688
Komissarov, S. S. 2005, MNRAS, 359, 801
Krasnopolsky, R. et al., 2005, in prep.
Kulkarni, S. R., et al. 1998, Nature, 395, 663
Lamb, D. Q., Donaghy, T. Q., & Graziani, C. 2004, New Astronomy Review,
48, 459
Lazzati, D., Rossi, E., Ghisellini, G., & Rees, M. J. 2004, MNRAS, 347, L1
Lazzati, D., Begelman, M., Ghirlanda, G., Ghisellini, G., & Firmani, C. 2005,
astro-ph/0503630
Levinson, A., & Eichler, D. 2003, ApJ, 594, L19
Levinson, A. 2005, astro-ph/0502346
Li, Z., Chiueh, T., & Begelman, M. C. 1992, ApJ, 394, 459
Lloyd-Ronning, N. M., Dai, X., & Zhang, B. 2004, ApJ, 601, 371
Lyutikov, M., Pariev, V. I., & Blandford, R. D. 2003, ApJ, 597, 998
MacFadyen, A. I. & Woosley, S. E. 1999, ApJ, 524, 262
Maraschi, L. & Tavecchio, F. 2003, ApJ, 593, 667
McKinney, J. C., & Gammie, C. F. 2002, ApJ, 573, 728
McKinney, J.C. 2004, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Illinois at
Urbana-Champaign, http://rainman.astro.uiuc.edu/jon/research/thesis.pdf
McKinney, J. C., & Gammie, C. F. 2004, ApJ, 611, 977
McKinney, J. C. 2005a, astro-ph/0506367
McKinney, J. C. 2005b, astro-ph/0506368
Meier, D. L. 2003, New Astronomy Review, 47, 667
Meier, D. 2005, astro-ph/0504511
Mészáros, P. 2002, ARA&A, 40, 137
Mészáros, P. & Rees,M. J. 1997, ApJ, 482, L29
Mirabel, I. F., & Rodriguez, L. F. 1994, Nature, 371, 46
Mirabel, I. F., & Rodríguez, L. F. 1999, ARA&A, 37, 409
Mizuno, Y., Yamada, S., Koide, S., & Shibata, K. 2004, ApJ, 615, 389
Nakamura, M., Uchida, Y., & Hirose, S. 2001, New Astronomy, 6, 61
Nakamura, M., & Meier, D. L. 2004, ApJ, 617, 123
Nakar, E., & Piran, T. 2002, MNRAS, 331, 40
Narayan, R. & Yi, I. 1995, ApJ, 452, 710
Narayan, R., Igumenshchev, I. V., & Abramowicz, M. A. 2003, PASJ, 55,
, Gammie, C.F., McKinney, J.C., Del Zanna, L.D., 2005,
L69
Noble, S.C.
submitted.
Okamoto, I. 1999, MNRAS, 307, 253
Okamoto, I. 2000, MNRAS, 318, 250
Shu, C.W., 1997, NASA/CR-97-206253, No.97-65
Papaloizou, J. C. B. & Pringle, J. E. 1983, MNRAS, 202, 1181
Phinney, E.S. 1983, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, Cambridge University
Piran, T. 2005, Reviews of Modern Physics, 76, 1143
Popham, R., Woosley, S. E., & Fryer, C. 1999, ApJ, 518, 356
Proga, D. 2005, astro-ph/0502509
Punsly, B. 1991, ApJ, 372, 424
Reynolds, C. S., di Matteo, T., Fabian, A. C., Hwang, U., & Canizares, C. R.
Scheck, L., Aloy, M. A., Martí, J. M., Gómez, J. L., Müller, E. 2002,
Sikora, M., Begelman, M. C., Coppi, P., & Proga, D. 2003, ApJ, submitted,
1996, MNRAS, 283, L111
MNRAS, 331, 615
astro-ph/0309504
Sikora, M., Begelman, M. C., Madejski, G. M., & Lasota, J. 2005, ApJ, 625,
Soderberg, A. M. & Ramirez-Ruiz, E. 2003, AIP Conf. Proc. 662: Gamma-
Ray Burst and Afterglow Astronomy 2001: A Workshop Celebrating the
First Year of the HETE Mission, 662, 172
Spruit, H. C., Daigne, F., & Drenkhahn, G. 2001, A&A, 369, 694
Stergioulas, N. 2003, Living Reviews in Relativity, 6, 3
Takahashi, M. , Nitta, S. , Tatematsu, Y. & Tomimatsu, A. 1990, ApJ, 363,
Thompson, C. 1994, MNRAS, 270, 480
Usmanov, A. V., Goldstein, M. L., Besser, B. P., & Fritzer, J. M. 2000,
J. Geophys. Res., 105, 12675
Uzdensky, D. A. 2005, ApJ, 620, 889
Vlahakis, N. 2004, Ap&SS, 293, 67
Woosley, S. E., & Weaver, T. A. 1995, ApJS, 101, 181
Zhang, B., Dai, X., Lloyd-Ronning, N. M., & Mészáros, P. 2004, ApJ, 601,
72
206
L119
Zhang, W., Woosley, S. E., & MacFadyen, A. I. 2003, ApJ, 586, 356
Zhang, W., Woosley, S. E., & Heger, A. 2004, ApJ, 608, 365
Zhang, W., & MacFadyen, A. I. 2005, astro-ph/0505481
|
astro-ph/0604028 | 2 | 0604 | 2006-04-26T09:37:57 | Who Is Eating the Outflow?: High-Angular Resolution Study of an Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206 | [
"astro-ph"
] | Up to now only a few intermediate-mass molecular outflows have been studied with enough high-angular resolution. The aim of this work is to study in detail the intermediate-mass YSO IRAS 22272+6358A, which is embedded in L1206, and its molecular outflow, in order to investigate the interaction of the outflow with the dense protostellar material, and to compare their properties with those of lower mas counterparts. We carried out OVRO observations of the 2.7 mm continuum emission, CO(1-0), C18O(1-0), and HC3N(12-11) in order to map with high-angular resolution the core of L1206, and to derive the properties of the dust emission, the molecular outflow and the dense protostellar envelope. The 2.7 mm continuum emission has been resolved into four sources, labeled OVRO~1, 2, 3, and 4. The intermediate-mass Class~0/I object OVRO 2, with a mass traced by the dust emission of 14.2 Msun, is the source associated with IRAS 22272+6358A. The CO(1-0) observations have revealed a very collimated outflow driven by OVRO 2, at a PA ~140 degr, that has a very weak southeastern red lobe and a much stronger northwestern blue lobe. Photodissociation toward the red lobe produced by the ionization front coming from the bright-rimmed diffuse HII region could be responsible of the morphology of the outflow. The spatial correlation between the outflow and the elongated dense protostellar material traced by HC3N(12-11) suggests an interaction between the molecular outflow and the protostellar envelope. Shocks produced by the molecular outflow, and possibly by the shock front preceding the ionization front could account for the southern enhancement of HC3N. The properties of the intermediate-mass protostar OVRO 2 and the molecular outflow are consistent with those of lower mass counterparts. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Astronomy&Astrophysicsmanuscript no. article
July 30, 2018
c(cid:13) ESO 2018
Who Is Eating the Outflow?: High-Angular Resolution Study of an
Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
M. T. Beltr´an1, J. M. Girart2, and R. Estalella1
1 Departament d'Astronomia i Meteorologia, Universitat de Barcelona, Av. Diagonal 647, 08028 Barcelona, Catalunya, Spain
2 Institut de Ci`encies de l'Espai (CSIC-IEEC), Campus UAB, Facultat de Ci`encies, Torre C-5, 08193, Bellaterra, Catalunya, Spain
Received date; accepted date
ABSTRACT
Context. Up to now only a few intermediate-mass molecular outflows have been studied with enough high-angular resolution.
Aims. The aim of this work is to study in detail the intermediate-mass YSO IRAS 22272+6358A, which is embedded in L1206, and its
molecular outflow, in order to investigate the interaction of the outflow with the dense protostellar material, and to compare their properties
with those of lower mas counterparts.
Methods. We carried out OVRO observations of the 2.7 mm continuum emission, CO (J=1→0), C18O(J=1→0), and HC3N (J=12→11) in
order to map with high-angular resolution the core of L1206, and to derive the properties of the dust emission, the molecular outflow and the
dense protostellar envelope.
Results. The 2.7 mm continuum emission has been resolved into four sources, labeled OVRO 1, 2, 3, and 4. The intermediate-mass Class 0/I
object OVRO 2, with a mass traced by the dust emission of 14.2 M⊙, is the source associated with IRAS 22272+6358A. The CO (J=1→0)
observations have revealed a very collimated outflow driven by OVRO 2, at a PA ≃ 140◦, that has a very weak southeastern red lobe and a
much stronger northwestern blue lobe. Photodissociation toward the red lobe produced by the ionization front coming from the bright-rimmed
diffuse H region could be responsible of the morphology of the outflow. The spatial correlation between the outflow and the elongated dense
protostellar material traced by HC3N (J=12→11) suggests an interaction between the molecular outflow and the protostellar envelope. Shocks
produced by the molecular outflow, and possibly by the shock front preceding the ionization front could account for the southern enhancement
of HC3N. The properties of the intermediate-mass protostar OVRO 2 and the molecular outflow are consistent with those of lower mass
counterparts. The C18O abundance relative to molecular hydrogen estimated toward OVRO 2 is 3 × 10−8, a value ∼6 to 13 times lower than
typical abundances estimated toward molecular clouds. The most plausible explanation for such a difference is CO depletion toward OVRO 2.
Key words. ISM: individual objects: L1206 -- ISM: individual objects: IRAS 22272+6358A -- ISM: jets and outflows -- stars: circumstellar
matter -- stars: formation
6
0
0
2
r
p
A
6
2
2
v
8
2
0
4
0
6
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
1. Introduction
Molecular outflows are an ubiquitous phenomenon during the
earliest stages of star formation for Young Stellar Objects
(YSOs) of all masses and luminosities. During the last decades,
many studies have been devoted to the study and description of
the physical properties of molecular outflows driven by low-
mass protostars and of their embedded driving sources (e.g.
Bachiller 1996; Richer et al. 2000). In recent years, high-mass
molecular outflows have also been studied in detail, and many
surveys have been carried out toward massive star-forming re-
gions to achieve a more accurate picture of their morphology
and properties (e.g. Shepherd & Churchwell 1996a, 1996b;
Zhang et al 2001; Shepherd 2005). However, although the in-
terest for the lower and, in particular, for the higher end of
the mass spectrum has been growing in recent years, this has
Send
[email protected]
offprint
requests
to: M.
T.
Beltr´an,
e-mail:
not been the case for intermediate-mass protostars, which have
masses in the range 2 M⊙ ≤ M⋆ ≤ 10 M⊙ and also power
energetic molecular outflows. In fact, only few deeply em-
bedded intermediate-mass protostars are known to date, and
only for a very limited number of them their outflows have
been studied at high-angular resolution (e.g. NGC 7129: Fuente
et al. 2001; HH288: Gueth et al. 2001; IRAS 21391+5802:
Beltr´an et al. 2002).
Intermediate-mass protostars are rare in comparison with
their low-mass counterparts and tend to be located at greater
distances. The immediate vicinity of intermediate-mass pro-
tostars is a very complex environment, where the extended
emission is usually resolved into more than one source
when observed at high-angular resolution (e.g. G173.58+2.45:
Shepherd & Watson 2002; IRAS 21391+5802: Beltr´an et
al. 2002). The molecular outflows driven by intermediate-mass
objects are usually more energetic. Thus, their interaction with
the circumstellar gas and dust material surrounding the proto-
2
Beltr´an et al.: An Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
Table 1. Parameters of the OVRO observations
Observation
Configuration
Frequency
2.7 mm continuum
CO (J=1→0)
C18O (J=1→0)
HC3N (J=12→11)
L, C
L, C
L, C
L, C
(GHz)
112.53
115.27
109.78
109.17
Synthesized beam
HPBW
(arcsec)
6.3 × 4.8
8.0 × 6.3
8.0 × 6.6
8.1 × 6.7
PA
(deg)
−27
−29
−32
−37
Bandwidth
Spectral resolution
(MHz)
4000
22.5
7.5
7.5
(km s−1)
−
0.65
0.68
0.69
rms noisea
(mJy beam−1)
1.4
45
40
40
(a) For the molecular line observations the 1 σ noise is per channel.
stars is expected to be stronger and more dramatic, disrupting
the envelopes and pushing away the dense gas at high veloc-
ities. Although these outflows are, in general, less collimated
and more chaotic than those of low-mass stars (e.g. NGC 7129:
Fuente et al. 2001), this could probably be due to observational
constraints. Since these regions are located, on average, fur-
ther away, these outflows are usually observed with less linear
spatial resolution than nearby low-mass flows. However, when
observed with high-angular resolution their appearance seems
to be more collimated and less chaotic (e.g. HH 288: Gueth et
al. 2001; IRAS 21391+5802: Beltr´an et al. 2002). Therefore, in
order to better understand intermediate-mass stars and compare
their morphology and evolution with those of low-mass stars,
more high-angular observations of the dust and gas around
them are needed.
In this paper, we present a detailed interferometric study of
the intermediate-mass protostar IRAS 22272+6358A and of its
molecular outflow. IRAS 22272+6358A is a 1200 L⊙ (Sugitani
et al. 1989) YSO located at a distance of 910 pc (Crampton
& Fisher 1974) and deeply embedded in the bright-rimmed
cloud L1206 (BRC 44: Sugitani et al. 1991). This infrared
source has no optical counterpart, and at near-infrared wave-
lengths, the embedded source has been only seen in scattered
light (Ressler & Shure 1991). At far-infrared wavelengths, the
source, undetected at 12 µm, emits most of its energy at 60
and 100 µm and has a flux density at 100 µm greater than
that at 60 µm. This means that its T (60/100) color tempera-
ture is lower than 50 K (38 K; Casoli et al. 1986), and there-
fore, that the source is very embedded, cold, and young. The
embedded source has been detected at 2.7 and 2 mm (Wilking
et al. 1989; Sugitani et al. 2000), but not at 2 nor 6 cm wave-
lengths (Wilking et al. 1989; McCutcheon et al. 1991). Sugitani
et al. (1989) have discovered a CO molecular outflow in the
region, although they have only mapped the blueshifted out-
flow lobe, since the redshifted lobe was too faint to be mapped
with the sensitivity achieved with their CO (J=1→0) 4-m radio
telescope observations. The core toward IRAS 22272+6358A
has also been observed in different high-density tracers, such
as HCO+ (Richards et al. 1987), NH3 (Molinari et al.1996),
CS and N2H+ (Williams & Myers 1999), and 13CO and C18O
(Ridge et al. 2003).
2. Observations
Millimeter interferometric observations of L1206 at 2.7 mm
were carried out with the Owens Valley Radio Observatory
(OVRO) Millimeter Array of six 10.4 m telescopes in the L
Fig. 1. OVRO map of the 2.7 mm continuum emission toward
the core of L1206. The synthesized beam is 6.′′3 ×4.′′8 at P.A. =
−27◦, and is drawn in the bottom left corner. The rms noise of
the map, σ, is 1.4 mJy beam−1. The contour levels are −5 σ,
−3 σ, 3 to 7 times σ by 1 σ, 10 σ, 15 to 30 times σ by 5 σ,
and 40 σ. The error ellipse of IRAS 22272+6358A is indicated
in white. The dotted circle represents the OVRO primary beam
(50% attenuation level).
(Low) and C (Compact) configurations, on 2003 May 1 and
June 1, respectively. The data taken in both array configura-
tions were combined, resulting in baselines ranging from 15
to 115 m, which provided sensitivity to spatial structures from
about 4.′′8 to 37′′. The digital correlator was configured to ob-
serve simultaneously the continuum emission and some molec-
ular lines. Details of the observations are given in Table 1. The
phase center was located at α(J2000) = 22h28h51.s50, δ(J2000)
= +64◦13′42.′′3. Bandpass calibration was achieved by ob-
serving the quasars 3C84, 3C273, and 3C345. Amplitude and
phase were calibrated by observations of the nearby quasar
J1927+739, whose flux density was determined relative to
Uranus. The uncertainty in the amplitude calibration is esti-
mated to be ∼20%. The OVRO primary beam is ∼64′′ (FWHM)
at 115.27 GHz. The data were calibrated using the MMA pack-
age developed for OVRO (Scoville et al. 1993). Reduction and
analysis of the data were carried out using standard procedures
in the MIRIAD and GILDAS software packages. We subtracted
the continuum from the line emission directly in the (u, v)-
domain for C18O (J=1→0) and HC3N (J=12→11), and in the
image domain for CO (J=1→0).
Beltr´an et al.: An Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
3
Table 2. Positions, millimeter flux densities, sizes, and masses of the cores detected in L1206
Position
α(J2000)
h m s
22 28 50.49
22 28 51 41
22 28 53.25
22 28 53.98
δ(J2000)
◦ ′ ′′
+64 13 50.7
+64 13 41.1
+64 13 32.1
+64 13 34.5
Core
OVRO 1
OVRO 2 f
OVRO 3
OVRO 4
Ipeak
(2.7mm)a
ν
(mJy beam−1)
6.8 ± 1.4
59.2 ± 11.8
10.9 ± 2.2
10.7 ± 2.1
S ν(2.7mm)b
(mJy)
9.8 ± 2.0
86.0 ± 17.2
11.0 ± 2.2
13.0 ± 2.6
θc
(arcsec)
9.3
3.5
5.4
5.6
Massd
(M⊙)
1.6
14.2
1.8
2.2
n(H2)e
(cm−3)
6.5 × 105
1.1 × 108
3.7 × 106
4.0 × 106
N(H2)e
(cm−2)
5.5 × 1022
3.4 × 1024
1.8 × 1023
2.0 × 1023
(a) Peak intensity corrected for primary beam response. The uncertainty in the values of the flux density is ∼ 20%.
(b) Integrated flux density corrected for primary beam response. The uncertainty in the values of the flux density is ∼ 20%.
(c) Deconvolved geometric mean of the major and minor axes of the 50% of the peak contour.
(d) Total (gas+dust) circumstellar mass, obtained assuming a dust temperature of 33 K (see Sect. 4.1).
(e) Average H2 volume and column density estimated assuming spherical symmetry and a mean molecular mass per H2 molecule of 2.8mH.
(f) Associated with IRAS 22272+6358A.
Fig. 2. CO (J=1→0) emission integrated in different velocity intervals, (−19.5, −13.5) km s−1 for the low-velocity blueshifted
emission (left panel; blue contours), (−8.5, −2.5) km s−1 for the redshifted one (left panel; red contours), (−30.5, −19.5) km s−1
for the high-velocity blueshifted emission (right panel; blue contours), and (−2.5, +8.5) km s−1 for the high-velocity redshifted
one (right panel; red contours), overlaid on the 2.7 mm continuum emission (greyscale). Contour levels are −3 σ, 3 to 15
times σ by steps of 2 σ, and 15 to 35 times σ by steps of 4 σ, where 1 σ is 0.5 Jy beam−1 km s−1 (left panel; blue contours),
0.18 Jy beam−1 km s−1 (left panel; red contours), 0.4 Jy beam−1 km s−1 (right panel; blue contours), and 0.15 Jy beam−1 km s−1
(right panel; red contours). The synthesized beam is drawn in the bottom left corner. The dotted circle represents the OVRO
primary beam (50% attenuation level). The white cross marks the millimeter continuum position of OVRO 2.
3. Results
3.1. Dustemission
In Fig. 1 we show the OVRO map of the 2.7 mm continuum
emission toward the core of L1206, where IRAS 22272+6358A
is embedded. The continuum dust emission mapped at 2 mm by
Sugitani et al. (2000) is resolved out in four different clumps,
labeled OVRO 1, OVRO 2, OVRO 3, and OVRO 4, with the
higher angular resolution of our interferometric observations.
The position, flux density at 2.7 mm, deconvolved size of the
sources, measured as the geometric mean of the major and mi-
nor axis of the 50% of the peak contour around each source,
the mass of the gas for each source, and the average H2 vol-
ume and column density are given in Table 2. The total inte-
grated flux at 2.7mm is ∼120 ± 24 mJy. This value is consistent
with the 2.7 mm expected flux of ∼ 125 mJy derived from the
2 mm integrated flux of 414 mJy obtained with the single dish
Nobeyama 45-m telescope (Sugitani et al. 2000) for a dust ab-
sorption coefficient proportional to ν2. Therefore, this indicates
that no significant fraction of the total flux has been filtered out
by the interferometer.
The strongest source detected at 2.7 mm in the region is
OVRO 2. As can be seen in Fig. 1, this source is the object asso-
ciated with the infrared source IRAS 22272+6358A. OVRO 2
is located at the center of the CO molecular outflow detected in
the region (see next section and Fig. 2), which suggests that it is
its driving source. The millimeter emission of OVRO 2 shows
two components, a centrally peaked source, which has a diam-
eter of ∼3.′′5 (∼3200 AU) at the 50% of the dust emission peak,
plus an extended and quite spherical envelope, which has a size
4
Beltr´an et al.: An Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
Fig. 3. CO (J=1→0) spectrum obtained at the position of
OVRO 2 in L1206. The continuum has been subtracted. The
1 σ level in one channel is 0.10 K. The conversion factor is
1.82 K/Jy beam−1. The dashed vertical line indicates the sys-
temic velocity of −11 km s−1.
of ∼13′′ (∼11800 AU) at the 3 σ contour level. By fitting an el-
liptical Gaussian to the visibility data at the position of the dust
emission peak, we found a total flux of 78 mJy, and a size of
3.′′6 ± 0.′′3 × 2.′′6 ± 0.′′2 at PA = −75◦. This size corresponds to a
linear size of ∼3200 ×2400 AU. These sizes are consistent with
the values found for envelopes around low- and intermediate-
mass protostars (e.g., Hogerheijde et al 1997, 1999; Looney et
al. 2000; Fuente et al. 2001; Beltr´an et al. 2002).
The source OVRO 1 is a clump, located ∼11′′ northwest
of OVRO 2, elongated along the CO outflow axis (see Fig. 2).
In fact, as can be seen in this figure, OVRO 1 clearly coin-
cides with the the blueshifted emission lobe, and therefore, it
could be dusty material entrained by the outflow. The other two
sources in L1206, OVRO 3 and 4, which are located ∼15 -- 18′′
southeast of OVRO 2, have similar flux densities (∼11 -- 13 mJy)
and deconvolved size (∼5000 AU). Both sources are separated
by only ∼5.′′3 (∼5000 AU) and could be sharing a common en-
velope around them.
3.2. Themolecularoutflow:COemission
outflow in L1206
The molecular
associated with
IRAS 22272+6358A, that is, OVRO 2, has been previously
studied through lower angular resolution CO observations by
Sugitani et al. (1989). However, since the red wing of this
outflow is so weak, those authors were not able to map the
red lobe. In addition, from their CO blueshifted emission
integrated map, it is not clear the direction of the outflow. The
observations reported in this study improve significantly the
angular resolution of the outflow maps, revealing the structure
of the molecular outflow in detail, and its direction as well.
In addition, we have been able to detect and map the weak
outflow redshifted emission.
Figure 2 shows the maps of the integrated CO (J=1→0)
emission in two different blueshifted and redshifted velocity
intervals. The systemic velocity, VLSR, reported in the literature
Fig. 4. PV plot of the CO (J=1→0) emission along the major
axis, PA= 140◦, of the molecular outflow. The position offset
is relative to the projection of the 2.7 mm continuum emission
peak onto the outflow axis, α(J2000) = 22h28h51.s52, δ(J2000)
= +64◦13′41.′′7. Contours are −1.2, −0.9, −0.72, −0.54, −0.36,
−0.18, 0.18 to 0.9 Jy beam−1 by steps of 0.18 Jy beam−1, 1.2,
1.8, 2.7, 3.6, 4.5, 5.4, and 7.2 Jy beam−1. The horizontal line
marks the systemic velocity, VLSR = −11 km s−1.
is roughly −10 km s−1 (Richards 1987; Sugitani et al. 1989;
Wilking et al. 1989; Wouterloot & Brand 1989; Williams &
Myers 1999). However, from our fits to the C18O (J=1→0)
and HC3N (J=12→11) spectra, we have estimated a systemic
velocity VLSR ≃ −11 km s−1 (see next sections), which is the
value used in this paper. Regarding the line widths in the region,
which have been estimated from CO and CS and isotopomers,
HCO+, and N2H+ lines, the values derived are in the range 0.7
to 3.0 km s−1 (Richards 1987; Wilking et al. 1989; Wouterloot
& Brand 1989; Molinari et al. 1996; Williams & Myers 1999;
Ridge et al. 2003). Therefore, taking this into account, we con-
servatively considered the CO ambient cloud velocity interval
to be (−13.5, −8.5) km s−1, that is, −11 ± 2.5 km s−1. And for
the outflow, we took the (−19.5, −13.5) km s−1 velocity interval
for the low-velocity blueshifted emission, (−8.5, −2.5) km s−1
for the redshifted one, (−30.5, −19.5) km s−1 for the high-
velocity blueshifted emission, and (−2.5, +8.5) km s−1 for the
redshifted one. As can be seen in Fig. 2 the molecular outflow
is elongated in a direction with PA = 140◦ and has a very weak
redshifted emission. In fact, the southeastern red lobe is only
visible at low outflow velocities. The outflow is clearly cen-
tered at the position of OVRO 2, which seems to be its driving
source. Figure 3 shows the CO (J=1→0) spectrum toward the
position of OVRO 2, where a blueshifted wing that extends to
Beltr´an et al.: An Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
5
Fig. 5. Velocity channel maps of the C18O (J=1→0) emission (contours) overlaid on the 2.7 mm continuum emission (greyscale).
The VLSR of L1206 is −11 km s−1. The central velocity of each channel is indicated at the upper left corner of each panel. The
1 σ noise in 1 channel is 40 mJy beam−1. Contour levels are −7 σ, −3 σ, 3 to 15 times σ by steps of 4 σ, and 15 to 39 times σ
by steps of 8 σ. The conversion factor from Jy beam−1 to K is 1.93. The synthesized beam is drawn in the bottom left corner of
the bottom left panel. The line outlines the direction of the CO outflow (see Fig. 2).
very high velocities, and a weak redshifted wing are clearly
visible . In this figure a strong self-absorption observed for the
central velocity channels is also visible. This self-absorption
feature is probably due to the filtering out of part of the ex-
tended emission by the interferometer, although we cannot ex-
clude opacity effects as well, and it makes impossible to study
the cloud structure with CO (J=1→0). The direction of the out-
flow and the presence of a red wing are also confirmed by the
position-velocity (PV) cut done along the major axis of the out-
flow (140◦), and centered in the projection of the OVRO 2 dust
emission peak position onto the outflow axis (Fig. 4).
This picture of the molecular outflow supports the scenario
drawn by Ressler & Shure (1991) from near-infrared polarime-
try, photometry, and imaging of the core of L1206. According
to these authors, the near-infrared northwestern object named
A-1, which is composed of scattered light, is the blueshifted
lobe of the jet pointed slightly toward us, while the weaker
southeastern object A-2, also composed of scattered light, is
the redshifted lobe pointed away. The position of these two
lobes coincides with the CO blueshifted and redshifted lobes,
respectively. The protostar that is powering the outflow has
to be heavily embedded, as is not detected at near-infrared
wavelengths. Ressler & Shure (1991) propose that the driving
source is a Class I object with an optically thick disk lying al-
most edge-on to the line-of-sight, and located at α(J2000) =
22h28h51.s54, δ(J2000) = +64◦13′42.′′3, which is roughly coin-
cident with the 2.7 mm OVRO 2 position (see Table 2).
3.3. C18Oemission
for
the velocity channel maps
Figure 5 shows
the
C18O (J=1→0) emission around the systemic velocity,
VLSR ≃ −11 km s−1, overlaid on the continuum emission. The
emission integrated over the central channels, velocity interval
(−12.4,−8.3) km s−1, is shown in the top panel of Fig. 6. The
emission is dominated by a central compact component that
peaks at the position of the continuum intermediate-mass
continuum source OVRO 2, as it can be clearly seen for the
channel maps at velocities of −11.7 and −12.4 km s−1 (see
Fig. 5). Therefore, such emission is tracing the innermost part
of the protostellar envelope. For velocities between −9.7 and
−11.0 km s−1 the C18O emission shows an additional extended
component elongated north and east of OVRO 2 and also in
part associated with the continuum sources OVRO 3 and 4.
As can be seen in the channel and integrated maps, there is
also some redshifted emission, visible at velocities of −8.3
and −9.0 km s−1, which is located in the same direction as the
CO redshifted lobe (see Fig. 2) but much more southeastwards
than the emission traced by CO. The total integrated intensity
of the central emission is ∼15 Jy beam−1 km s−1, and has a
6
Beltr´an et al.: An Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
velocities an emission tail is also visible toward the south-
east, which is associated with the continuum sources OVRO 3
and 4. For the redshifted velocities −9.7 and −10.3 km s−1,
the emission shows a less compact and more elongated mor-
phology (see Figure 7). The emission peak of the gas at
these two redshifted velocities is located southeastwards of
OVRO 2, in the same direction as the the CO redshifted lobe
(see Fig. 2). As can be seen in the channel and integrated
emission maps, the gas emission is elongated along the direc-
tion of the CO molecular outflow. This morphological corre-
lation between the outflow and dense protostellar material is
similar to the case of the low-mass Class 0 source in L1157
(Beltr´an et al. 2004a), mapped in the same molecular line
HC3N (J=12→11). However, for L1206, our OVRO observa-
tions did not provide us with enough angular resolution to trace
in HC3N the apparent base of the outflow conical cavities as
traced by the CO, and to more clearly map the "cross-like"
pattern characteristic of the interaction between the molecu-
lar outflow and the protostellar envelope. The integrated HC3N
emission has a flux density ∼10.5 Jy beam−1 km s−1, and a de-
convolved size of 8.′′8 or ∼ 8000 AU.
The kinematics of HC3N toward the core of L1206 can be
seen in the PV cut done along the direction of OVRO 2 molec-
ular outflow (see Fig. 8). The emission shows two peaks, one
at the position of the continuum source, which corresponds
to offset position zero, at the systemic velocity, and the other
one ∼ 5.′′5 southeast from the central position, at a velocity of
∼ −10.3 km s−1. In addition to this redshifted emission peak, an
excess of emission, or emission tail, is also clearly visible ex-
tending further away than the CO redshifted lobe (up to ∼27′′
or ∼24600 AU southeastwards of OVRO 2), and reaching ve-
locities up to ∼−9 km s−1.
4. Analysis and Discussion
4.1. Dustemission
The masses of the cores given in Table 2 have been estimated
assuming that the dust emission is optically thin, by using
Mclump =
g S ν d2
κν Bν(Td)
,
(1)
where S ν is the flux density, d is the distance to the source,
κν is the dust mass opacity coefficient, g is the gas-to-dust ra-
tio, and Bν(Td) is the Planck function for a blackbody of dust
temperature Td, all measured at ν = 112.5 GHz. We adopted
κ112.5 = 0.20 cm2 g−1 (κ0 = 1 cm2 g−1 at 250 GHz: Ossenkopf
& Henning 1994), g = 100, and Td = 33 K for all the sources.
Estimates of Td have been obtained by fitting a grey-body to
the IRAS fluxes at 60 and 100 µm and to the sum of fluxes of
the 4 clumps at 2.7 mm We have neglected the IRAS fluxes
at 12 and 25 µm in the fit. The reason for this choice is that
two components are known to be present in the SEDs of lu-
minous YSOs (see Sridharan et al. 2002): one associated with
compact, hot gas and dominating the 12 and 25 µm fluxes; the
other due to colder material, contributing to the 60 and 100 µm
emission. The latter is the one of interest to us because we want
to estimate the temperature of the low-temperature dust in the
are −0.36,
0.36
levels
the velocity interval
Fig. 6. (Top) Integrated intensity map of the C18O (J=1→0)
(−12.4,−8.3) km s−1
emission over
toward L1206. Contour
to
1.8 Jy beam−1 km s−1 by steps of 0.36 Jy beam−1 km s−1, and
1.8 to 3.6 Jy beam−1 km s−1 by steps of 0.6 Jy beam−1 km s−1.
(Bottom) Integrated intensity map of the HC3N (J=12→11)
emission over the velocity interval (−11.7,−9.7) km s−1.
Contour levels are −0.3, 0.3 to 1.5 Jy beam−1 km s−1 by steps
of 0.3 Jy beam−1 km s−1, and 1.5 to 2.5 Jy beam−1 km s−1 by
steps of 0.5 Jy beam−1 km s−1. The crosses show the positions
of the 2.7 mm continuum sources detected in the region. The
dashed line indicates the direction of the CO outflow. The
synthesized beam is drawn in the bottom right corner of each
panel.
deconvolved size, measured as the geometric mean of the
major and minor axes of the 50% of the peak contour of the
gas, of 11.′′4 or ∼ 10400 AU.
3.4. HC3Nemission
The HC3N (J=12→11) transition has a high critical density
(8 × 105 cm−3: Chung et al. 1991), which makes it an even
better tracer of high density regions than e.g. CS (J=1→0)
and CS (J=2→1). Figure 7 shows the velocity channel maps
for the HC3N (J=12→11) emission toward the core of L1206,
around the systemic velocity, VLSR ≃ −11 km s−1, overlaid
on the continuum emission. The emission integrated over the
velocity interval (−11.7,−9.7) km s−1 is shown in the bottom
panel of Fig. 6. The gas emission at velocities of −11.0 and
−11.7 km s−1 is very compact and peaks at the position of
the continuum intermediate-mass protostar OVRO 2. At these
Beltr´an et al.: An Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
7
Fig. 7. Velocity channel maps of the HC3N (J=12→11) emission (contours) overlaid on the 2.7 mm continuum emission
(greyscale). The VLSR of L1206 is −11 km s−1. The central velocity of each channel is indicated at the upper left corner of
each panel. The 1 σ noise in 1 channel is 40 mJy beam−1. Contour levels are −5 σ,−3 σ, 3 to 15 times σ by steps of 4 σ, and 15
to 31 times σ by steps of 8 σ. The conversion factor from Jy beam−1 to K is 1.88. The synthesized beam is drawn in the bottom
left corner of the bottom left panel. The line outlines the direction of the CO outflow (see Fig. 2).
circumstellar envelope of the sources. Adopting a dust absorp-
tion coefficient proportional to ν2, we found Td ≃ 33 K. This
is the same value obtained by Sugitani et al. (2000) fitting the
fluxes at 2 mm, 100 and 60 µm, with a dust absorption coeffi-
cient proportional to ν1.8.
The mass estimated for OVRO 2 is 14.2 M⊙, while for the
other sources the mass is 1.6, 1.8, and 2.2 M⊙ for OVRO 1,
OVRO 3, and OVRO 4, respectively. Therefore, OVRO 2,
which has a circumstellar mass consistent with the YSO be-
ing an intermediate-mass source, accounts for most of the mass
toward the core of L1206. The mass estimates of the other
sources suggest that they are low-mass YSOs. We also esti-
mated the average H2 volume density, n(H2), and column den-
sity, N(H2), of the sources by assuming spherical symmetry and
a mean molecular mass per H2 molecule of 2.8mH. The values
are given in Table 2.
4.2. PhysicalparametersoftheCOoutflow
Assuming that the CO emission is in LTE and is optically thin,
the mass of the gas associated with the outflow detected in the
region can be calculated by using
M
M⊙! = 2.3 × 10−5
Tex + 0.93
kpc!2
exp(−5.59/Tex) d
Fig. 8. PV plot of the HC3N (J=12→11) emission along the
major axis, PA= 140◦, of the molecular outflow. The posi-
tion offset is relative to the projection of the 2.7 mm con-
tinuum emission peak onto the outflow axis, α(J2000) =
22h28h51.s52, δ(J2000) = +64◦13′41.′′7. Contours are −0.12,
0.12 to 0.6 Jy beam−1 by steps of 0.12 Jy beam−1, and 0.6 to
1.32 Jy beam−1 by steps of 0.24 Jy beam−1. The horizontal line
marks the systemic velocity, VLSR = −11 km s−1.
×Z S ν
Jy! dv
km s−1!,
(2)
8
Beltr´an et al.: An Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
Table 3. Properties of the CO outflow
va
(km s−1)
[−30.5, −13.5]
[−8.5, −2.5]
Mb
Pc
Ec
Pc
(10−2M⊙)
(M⊙ km s−1)
(1043 erg)
(M⊙ km s−1 yr−1)
8.3
0.2
8.5
0.60
0.01
0.61
4.78
0.03
4.81
7.5 × 10−5
2.3 × 10−6
7.7 × 10−5
Lobe
Blue
Redd
Total
(a) Range of outflow velocities. Momenta and kinetic energies are calculated relative to the cloud velocity, which is taken to be VLSR =
−11 km s−1.
(b) Assuming an excitation temperature of 24 K.
(c) Velocity not corrected for inclination.
(d) The outflow has only been detected for this velocity range.
where Tex is the CO excitation temperature, d is the distance
in kpc, and S ν is the line flux density measured in Jy. An
excitation temperature of 24 K has been estimated from the
CO (J=2→1) antenna temperature, T ∗
A = 15.4 K, obtained
by Wilking et al. (1989), which corresponds to TR = 18.6 K
(Kutner & Ulich 1981) for an efficiency ηc = 1 and a forward
scattering and spillover efficiency ηfss = 0.83. We assumed an
[H2]/[CO] abundance ratio of 104 (e.g. Scoville et al. 1986),
and a mean atomic mass per H atom µ = 1.4. In Table 3 we
give the masses, the CO momentum, the kinetic energy, and
the momentum rate in the outflow. We also report the range of
outflow velocities for the outflow. Note that due to the fact that
some emission is resolved out by the interferometer, and the
absorption by the ambient cloud, the masses calculated should
be considered as lower limits. There is also the possibility that
the CO is optically thick in portions of the flow, although the
correction for opacity should be small, as one would expect
that for high outflow velocities the material is optically thin.
Finally, it should be taken into account the integration range
chosen, which could make that part of the outflow at low ve-
locities is not counted. Note that the momentum, kinetic en-
ergy, and momentum rate in the outflow have not been cor-
rected for the (unknown) inclination angle, i, of the flow with
respect to the plane of the sky. In case of correcting for incli-
nation, the velocities should be divided by sin i. The values of
the mass, momentum, kinetic energy, and momentum rate are
smaller than the values estimated for other intermediate-mass
molecular outflows, such as IRAS 20050+2720 (Bachiller et
al. 1995), IRAS 21391+5802 (Beltr´an et al. 2002), HH288
(Gueth et al. 2001), L1641S (see references in Anglada 1995
and Wu et al. 2004), or NGC 2071 (Snell et al. 1984), as can
be seen in Table 4, and are more consistent with the values
derived for low-mass outflows (e.g. Cabrit & Bertout 1992;
Anglada 1995; Bontemps et al. 1996; Lee et al. 2000, 2002).
The reason for this could be the weakness of the redshifted lobe
of the OVRO 2 flow, which is hardly contributing to the mass,
momentum and energy of the molecular outflow. A possible
explanation for the weakness of the redshifted lobe is given in
Sect. 4.6.
4.3. Envelopemassfromgasemission
One of the major problems when using the gas emission to es-
timate the mass of the molecular core is the uncertainty of the
gas abundance relative to molecular hydrogen. Therefore, due
to these uncertainties, instead of measuring the mass of the gas
toward the intermediate-mass protostar OVRO 2 from the C18O
or HC3N emission, it is better to estimate the fractional abun-
dance of C18O and HC3N. In order to do that, we integrated
the gas emission in the same area (∼162 arcsec2) used to es-
timate the mass of the gas from the continuum dust emission,
and assumed that the mass toward OVRO 2 derived from the
HC3N is the same as that derived from the 2.7 mm continuum
emission; that is, 14.2 M⊙. Following the derivation of Scoville
et al. (1986), and assuming optically thin emission, the C18O
beam averaged column density is given by
hNi = 4.6 1013 (Tex + 0.878)
(3)
e−5.27/Tex
Z TB dv cm−2,
where Tex is the excitation temperature, andR TBdv is the inte-
grated brightness temperature of the C18O (J=1→0) emission
in K km s−1. Assuming an excitation temperature Tex = 24 K,
the estimated C18O (J=1→0) abundance relative to molecular
hydrogen is 3 × 10−8 toward OVRO 2, a value that is ∼6 to
13 times lower than typical fractional abundances estimated
toward molecular clouds, 1.7 -- 4×10−7 (Frerking et al. 1982;
Kulesa et al. 2005). Even if one takes into account the uncer-
tainties up to a factor of 5 introduced in the mass estimates
by the different dust opacity laws used, the value of the abun-
dance derived toward OVRO 2 would be lower than the typ-
ical fractional abundances. In particular, it would be clearly
inconsistent with the abundance of 4×10−7 derived by Kulesa
et al. (2005) in the ρ Ophiuchi molecular cloud. The excita-
tion temperature value adopted cannot account for the abun-
dance difference, as the abundance estimate is not significantly
affected by the excitation temperature (the abundance would
be 2.7×10−8 for Tex = 20 K, and 4×10−8 for Tex = 40 K).
One should also take into account opacity effects, in case the
C18O emission is optically thick. In such a case the gas mass
would be higher and the C18O (J=1→0) abundance relative to
molecular hydrogen higher. In case the opacity of the gas is
τ & 3, the main beam brightness temperature can be given
by Tmb ≃ f [J(Tex) − J(Tbg)], where f
is the beam filling
factor and Tbg is the background temperature. For OVRO 2,
Tmb is 2.94 K (see Table 5), and Tex = 24 K. Therefore, the
filling factor would be f = 0.14, suggesting that the emis-
sion is clumpy. However, if the C18O emission was clumpy,
such clumps should be visible in the maps done with uniform
weighting or with negative robust parameter, and this is not
the case. This means that opacity can be ruled out as the re-
Beltr´an et al.: An Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
9
Table 4. Properties of intermediate-mass outflows
Outflow
IRAS 20050+2720a
IRAS 21391+5802b
HH288c
L1641Sd
NGC 2071e
Mb
(M⊙)
1.7
0.14
11
1.4
10
Pc
Ec
(M⊙ km s−1)
(1045 erg)
25.4
3.6
385
37
81
7.7
1.2
6.7
0.3
8.5
Pc
(M⊙ km s−1 yr−1)
∼ 5.0 × 10−3
1.4 × 10−3
1.4 × 10−2
5.3 × 10−4
5.1 × 10−3
(a) The parameters correspond to the whole emission of the different outflow lobes detected in IRAS 20050+2720 (Bachiller et al. 1995).
(b) Beltr´an et al. (2002).
(c) Because of the difficulty to treat each outflow separately the parameters correspond to the whole emission, thus including the two outflows
detected in HH228 (Gueth et al. 2001).
(d) Anglada (1995) and Wu et al. (2004).
(e) Snell et al. (1984).
sponsible of the mass difference. Therefore, the most plausible
explanation to account for the low C18O (J=1→0) abundance
appears to be CO depletion toward OVRO 2.
Regarding the HC3N emission, the uncertainties in the
HC3N abundance relative to molecular hydrogen (see e.g.
Hasegawa et al. 1986) can make the mass estimates to vary up
to 3 orders of magnitude. Chung et al. (1991) estimate abun-
dances of (2 -- 7) ×10−10 in massive dense cores, while that
of a low-mass dense core, L1551, has been estimated to be
2×10−9. Similar abundances have been estimated by Jørgensen
et al. (2004) for a sample of Class 0 and Class I low-mass proto-
stellar envelopes. The average values determined are 3.5×10−10
and 3.1 × 10−9, respectively. However, abundances as low as
∼3×10−11 have been estimated for a sample of 19 low and mas-
sive molecular clouds (Vanden Bout et al. 1983), and as high
as ∼10−8 for hot cores associated with intermediate- and high-
mass stars (de Vicente et al. 2000; Mart´ın-Pintado et al. 2005).
Therefore, as done before with the C18O emission, we esti-
mated the fractional abundance of HC3N toward OVRO 2.
Following the derivation of Scoville et al. (1986), and assum-
ing optically thin emission, the HC3N beam averaged column
density is given by
hNi = 4.2 1010 (Tex + 0.073)
where Tex is the excitation temperature, andR TBdv is the inte-
grated brightness temperature of the HC3N (J=12→11) emis-
sion in K km s−1. Assuming an excitation temperature Tex =
24 K, the estimated HC3N abundance relative to molecular hy-
drogen is 7 × 10−11 toward OVRO 2, a value in the lower end of
the range of fractional abundances estimated toward molecular
clouds.
e−34.06/Tex Z TB dv cm−2,
(4)
4.4. Physicalparametersofthedensecoretoward
OVRO2
Table 5 lists the fitted parameters for C18O (J=1→0) and HC3N
(J=12→11) toward the 2.7 mm continuum peak position of
OVRO 2. The spectra and the corresponding Gaussian fits are
shown in Fig. 9. In Table 5 we also give the deconvolved size,
and the virial mass estimated assuming a spherical clump with
a power-law density distribution ρ ∝ r−p, and neglecting con-
tributions from magnetic field and surface pressure. In such a
Fig. 9. C18O (J=1→0) (top) and HC3N (J=12→11) (bottom)
spectra obtained at the position of OVRO 2 in L1206. The con-
tinuum has been subtracted. The 1 σ level in one channel is
0.10 K. The conversion factor is 1.93 K/Jy beam−1 for C18O
and 1.88 K/Jy beam−1 for HC3N. The thick grey profiles are
the Gaussian fits to the spectra. The dashed vertical line indi-
cates the systemic velocity of −11 km s−1.
case the virial mass can be computed from the expression (see
e.g. MacLaren et al. 1988):
Mvir
M⊙ ! = 0.305
5 − 2p
3 − p d
kpc!
θ
arcsec! ∆V
km s−1!2
,
(5)
where p is the density distribution power-law index, d is the
distance, θ is the deconvolved size of the source, and ∆V is the
line width. The line widths, which have been estimated from
10
Beltr´an et al.: An Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
Table 5. C18O (J=1→0), and HC3N (J=12→11) line and physical parameters toward the continuum peak position of OVRO 2
in L1206
Molecule &
Transition
C18O (J=1→0)
HC3N (J=12→11)
VLSR
(km s−1)
−10.74 ± 0.02
−10.86 ± 0.03
FWHM
(km s−1)
2.34 ± 0.04
1.83 ± 0.07
TB
(K)
2.94 ± 0.31
2.68 ± 0.10
R TB dV
(K km s−1)
7.31 ± 0.13
5.22 ± 0.17
θa
(arcsec)
8.8
11.4
Mb
vir
(M⊙)
10.6 -- 14.2
13.4 -- 17.8
(a) Deconvolved geometric mean of the major and minor axes of the 50% of the peak contour of the gas.
(b) Estimated from Eq. 5 for typical density distributions with p = 2.0 -- 1.5.
the Gaussian fits to the spectra, coincide with the line widths es-
timated from the second order moment maps. The virial masses
estimated from C18O and HC3N are 13.4 -- 17.8 M⊙, and 10.6 --
14.2 M⊙, respectively, for typical density distributions with
p = 2.0 -- 1.5. Such values are consistent with the mass derived
from the continuum. However, the mass of the central protostar
has not been taken into account in this calculation. Therefore,
in fact, the total mass (circumstellar plus protostar) of OVRO 2
is probably higher than the virial mass, suggesting that this ob-
ject is likely undergoing collapse, as one would expect from a
very young stellar object.
4.5. Intermediate-massprotostarsandtheiroutflows
around
continuum emission
The millimeter
IRAS
22272+6358A has been resolved into four different clumps
(see Fig. 1): an intermediate-mass source, OVRO 2, and
three less massive and smaller objects, OVRO 1, OVRO 3,
and OVRO 4. This situation resembles very closely the
scenario around IRAS 21391+5802, which is located in the
bright-rimmed cloud IC1396N. In this case, the millimeter and
centimeter emission have been resolved into an intermediate-
mass source, BIMA 2, which is the YSO associated with
IRAS 21391+5802, surrounded by two (Beltr´an et al. 2002)
or maybe three (Beltr´an et al. 2004b) much less massive
YSOs, with different morphologies and properties. As already
mentioned, OVRO 2 is the source associated with IRAS
22272+6358A, has the strongest millimeter emission, and is
also the most massive object toward the core of L1206. The
source is associated with OH and CH3OH maser emission
(MacLeod et al. 1998) but not with H2O maser emission (Palla
et al. 1991). The source is neither associated with continuum
emission at 2 and 6 cm (Wilking et al. 1989; McCutcheon et
al. 1991). OVRO 2, as seen in previous sections, is driving
a powerful molecular outflow, which has an estimated kine-
matical age of the order of a few 104 years, which suggests
that the powering source is a very young stellar object. The
source, which has not been detected at 12 µm by IRAS,
has a cold dust temperature, Td ≃ 33 K, and its millimeter
emission, which accounts for most of the dust emission in
the region, exhibits an extended component that is consistent
with an envelope surrounding the source. The circumstellar
mass, M ≃ 14.2 M⊙, is consistent with the masses in the
range 3.5 -- 30 M⊙ found around other
intermediate-mass
protostars (Fuente et al. 2001; Gueth et al. 2001; Shepherd &
Watson 2002), and it is considerably higher than the envelope
masses of 1.4 -- 2.3 M⊙ found by Bontemps et al. (1996)
for low-mass Class 0 sources. Therefore, these properties
to further compare the properties of
indicate that OVRO 2 is an extremely young, deeply embedded
intermediate-mass protostar, with morphology and properties
that do not differ significantly from the properties of low-mass
counterpart protostars. In fact, the source, which has not been
detected at J, H, K, L, or L′ bands (Ressler & Shure 1991),
has been classified as a heavily extinguished Class I object
with an optically thick almost edge-on circumstellar disk.
Pezzuto et al. (2002) also classify IRAS 22272+6358A as a
Class I object based on its [60 -- 100] µm and [100 -- 170] µm
colour temperatures, although the low spatial resolution of
the Long Wavelength Spectrometer (LWS) on board of the
Infrared Space Observatory can cause a high uncertainty in
the measured fluxes due to background emission or source
confusion inside the LWS beam. On the other hand, taken
into account the criterion for Class 0 given by Andr´e et
al. (1993), Lbol/Lsubmm . 200, Sugitani et al. (2000) classify
IRAS 22272+6358A as a Class 0-like object since its ratio
Lbol/Lsubmm is 140. Therefore, OVRO 2 seems to be a very
young intermediate-mass object in transition state between
Class 0 and I.
In order
the
intermediate-mass YSO OVRO 2 with the low-mass case we
also checked whether this object is consistent with some corre-
lations between source and outflow properties found for low-
mass young objects. As already mentioned in Sect. 4.2, al-
though Lbol and the dust continuum emission toward OVRO 2
indicate that the source is an intermediate-mass object, the
properties of the molecular outflow are more consistent with
those derived for low-mass protostars. Therefore, we checked
for the correlation between the circumstellar envelope mass
and the momentum rate in the CO outflow given by Bontemps
et al. (1996) for low-mass embedded YSOs. For this cor-
relation, Bontemps et al. (1996) correct the observed mo-
mentum rate of the CO outflow, Pobs, by a factor 10, P ≃
10 × Pobs, in order to take into account projection and op-
tical depth effects. After applying the same correction fac-
tor to the momentum rate of the OVRO 2 outflow, we found
that OVRO 2 agrees well with the correlation, and also with
the intermediate-mass protostar IRAS 21391+5802 (Beltr´an et
al. 2002). Bontemps et al. (1996) also find a correlation be-
tween the normalized outflow momentum rate or outflow ef-
ficiency, P c/Lbol, and the normalized envelope mass, M/L0.6
bol.
For IRAS 22272+6358A, the estimated bolometric luminos-
ity is Lbol ≃ 1200 L⊙ (Sugitani et al. 1989). However, this es-
timate includes the whole region around the IRAS catalogue
position. Thus, in order to derive a bolometric luminosity for
OVRO 2, we used the relationship between the momentum rate
and the bolometric luminosity given by Bontemps et al. (1996),
Beltr´an et al.: An Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
11
and we inferred a luminosity of Lbol ≃ 580 L⊙. By using
this luminosity we found that the source has an outflow ef-
ficiency consistent with those of low-mass Class I sources,
and also with that of IRAS 21391+5802, if one estimates the
bolometric luminosity of the latter from the outflow momen-
tum rate by using the Bontemps et al. (1996) correlation. Both
intermediate-mass sources, OVRO 2 and IRAS 21391+5802,
fit well the correlation of outflow efficiency and envelope mass
found by Bontemps et al. (1996), and both lie in the limit be-
tween Class 0 and I region of this diagram. Furthermore, an-
other correlation fitted well by both sources is the one between
the radio continuum luminosity at centimeter wavelengths and
the momentum rate of the outflow not corrected for inclination
obtained by Anglada (1996). This correlation is in agreement
with the predictions of a simple model of shock ionization in a
plane-parallel geometry (Curiel 1987, 1989), which would be
able to produce the required ionization in thermal radio jets.
Intermediate-mass outflows have been proposed to be more
complex and with more chaotic morphologies than those
found toward low-mass protostars (e.g. NGC 7129: Fuente et
al. 2001). However, this does not seem to be the case of the
OVRO 2 molecular outflow in L1206. In addition, unlike the
NGC 7129 FIRS1 outflow, the collimation of the OVRO 2
outflow is very high, even at low velocities, similar to the
intermediate-mass outflow driven by BIMA 2 in IC1396N
(Beltr´an et al. 2002) or to the low-mass protostellar flow in
HH 211 (Gueth & Guilloteau 1999). As already discussed by
Beltr´an et al. (2002) for the BIMA 2 outflow in IC1396N, given
that the outflows are usually more energetic for higher mass ob-
jects, that the dust emission is often resolved into more than one
object, and that intermediate- and high-mass sources are em-
bedded in larger amounts of material, it is to be expected that
the interactions between the high-velocity gas and the circum-
stellar material will be more dramatic, disrupting and pushing
more material. Therefore, the complexity of the molecular out-
flows driven by intermediate-mass protostars is likely a result
of the more complex protostellar environment itself.
4.6. Interactionofthemolecularcloudwiththeionized
bright-rimmedcloud
The most striking feature of the morphology of the molecu-
lar outflow powered by OVRO 2 is the weakness and small
size of the redshifted lobe as compared to the blueshifted one
(see Fig. 2). Or, alternatively, the practically lack of outflowing
material south of the YSO OVRO 2. The existence of unipo-
lar, or primarily one-sided, molecular outflows have also been
reported for other low- and intermediate-mass star-forming
regions (e.g. NGC 2024/FIR5: Richer et al. 1989; HH 46-
47: Chernin & Masson 1991; L1641-S3: Stanke et al. 2000;
HH 300: Arce & Goodman 2001). Taking into account that the
molecular outflow consists of ambient gas that is swept up from
a position close to where it is observed, a possible explanation
for the morphology of the OVRO 2 outflow could be that the
redshifted lobe breaks out of the molecular cloud. That is, the
redshifted wind passes into a region where there is no, or lit-
tle, molecular material to be swept up. A similar scenario has
)
0
0
0
2
(
δ
α(2000)
Fig. 10. VLA map of the 6 cm emission (contours) over-
laid with an optical image from the Digitized Sky Survey 2
(colours) of BRC 44. The contours are 0.2, 0.4, 0.7, 1.0, 1.5,
2.5, 3.5, 4.5, 5.5, and 6.5 mJy beam−1. The cross marks the
position of the 2.7 mm continuum source OVRO 2.
been suggested to explain the near unipolarity of the HH 46-47
molecular outflow (Chernin & Masson 1991).
Figure 10 shows the superposition of the VLA1 6 cm emis-
sion (archive data) of the bright-rimmed cloud (BRC 44) on
the red image of the Digitized Sky Survey 2 toward L1206.
The 6 cm emission is spatially coincident with the L1206
dark cloud. The optical bright rim, which is a diffuse H re-
gion, coincides with the southern part of the 6 cm emission.
This suggests that the H region is located in the background
with respect to L1206. Therefore, a more plausible explana-
tion for the morphology of the molecular outflow powered by
OVRO 2, could be photodissociation of the redshifted (south-
ern) lobe. The ionization-shock front probably lies very close
to the southern redshifted outflow, and thus, any redshifted
(southern) ejected material could be destroyed by the intense
radiation field at the ionization front. Photodissociation has
also been proposed as an explanation of the unipolarity of the
NGC 2024/FIR5 outflow (Richer et al. 1989). In order to check
the validity of this possible scenario, we have estimated the in-
ternal pressure of the molecular gas in the L1206 cloud and
compared it with the Ionized Boundary Layer (IBL) pressure.
The IBL pressure divided per Boltzmann's constant, Pi/kB, es-
timated from the NRAO/VLA sky survey (NVSS) data at 20 cm
for this bright-rimmed cloud is 8.5 × 106 cm−3 K (Morgan
et al. 2004)2. Following Morgan et al. (2004), we have esti-
1 The National Radio Astronomy Observatory is a facility of the
National Science Foundation operated under cooperative agreement
by Associated Universities, Inc.
2 After this paper went to press, we realized that there is an error in
the Morgan et al. (2004) paper (L. K. Morgan 2006, private commu-
nication), and that the value quoted for the IBL pressure of the cloud
should be lower. This brings the pressure difference in the cloud to ap-
proximate equilibrium, and therefore, right now, the ionization front
12
Beltr´an et al.: An Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
mated the internal molecular pressure, Pm = σ2ρm, where σ
is the velocity dispersion, which can be given in terms of the
observed line width ∆v as σ2 = (∆v)2/(8 ln 2), and ρm is the
density of the molecular gas. The velocity dispersion has tur-
bulent and thermal contributions. However, as the clouds are
composed mostly of cold gas, one would expect the thermal
contribution to be almost negligible. Sugitani et al. (1989) de-
rive ρm = 2.1 × 104 cm−3 from 13CO observations, but they
do not give the value of the observed line width. Thus, using
the 13CO line width derived by Ridge et al. (2003), we ob-
tained Pm/kB ≃ 3.7 × 106 cm−3 K. If ones uses ρm derived
from the observations of Ridge et al. (2003) by assuming spher-
ical symmetry of the cloud, the values of Pm/kB are 1.8 × 106
and 5.0 × 106 cm−3 K, for 13CO and C18O, respectively. In
summary, the internal molecular pressure ranges from 1.8 to
5.0 × 106 cm−3 K, depending on the values of the density and
line width adopted, but in any case it is always smaller than the
IBL pressure. Thus, the cloud seems to be underpressured with
respect to the IBL, and therefore, one might expect photoion-
ization shocks and the ionization front to be propagating into
the cloud interior, compressing, heating, and photodissociating
the molecular gas. Definitively, the possibility exists that pho-
todissociation is responsible of the morphology of the molecu-
lar outflow, and therefore, that the H region is actually eating
the outflow.
4.7. HC3Nenhancement
As already mentioned in Sect. 3.4, the HC3N emission at veloc-
ities of −11.0 and −11.7 km s−1, which are close to the cloud
velocity, is very compact and traces the same material as the
continuum emission at 2.7 mm; that is, sources OVRO 2, 3,
and 4 (see Fig. 7). On the other hand, at velocities of −9.7 and
−10.3 km s−1, which are redshifted with respect to the cloud
velocity, the HC3N emission is elongated in the same direction
as the CO molecular outflow and peaks south of OVRO 2 (see
Figs. 7 and 11). As already done in Sect. 4.3 toward OVRO 2,
we estimated the HC3N fractional abundance toward the red
lobe by integrating the gas and the continuum emission in the
same area, and assuming that the mass of the gas derived from
HC3N is the same as that derived from the continuum. The
maximum HC3N fractional abundance southwards of OVRO 2
is (2 -- 3) ×10−10, which compared to 7 × 10−11 estimated toward
OVRO 2, indicates that the emission is enhanced toward the
south. The correlation between the dense gas and the molec-
ular outflow suggests that the latter could be responsible of
the southern HC3N enhancement as a result of shocks that
would compress and heat the dense gas. Shock-enhancement
of the HC3N abundance has also been detected toward L1157
(Bachiller & P´erez-Guti´errez 1997; Beltr´an et al. 2004a). This
hypothesis seems to be supported by the HC3N spectrum at the
position of the redshifted peak (see Fig. 12), which is very dif-
ferent from the spectrum at the position of OVRO 2 (Fig. 9).
would probably not be travelling towards the protostar but stalled. This
does not affect the main conclusion of the work; namely, the fact that
the morphology of the L1206 outflow is the result of photoionization
from the H region.
integrated over
Fig. 11. Overlap of the intensity map of the HC3N (J=12→11)
emission (contours)
the velocity interval
(−10.3,−9.7) km s−1 on the CO (J=1→0) blueshifted emis-
sion (blue colours) integrated over the (−19.5,−13.5) km s−1
velocity interval, and the redshifted emission (red colours) in-
tegrated over the (−8.5,−2.5) km s−1 velocity interval. Contour
levels are 0.12, 0.2, 0.28, 0.36, 0.44, 0.52, 0.64, 0.80, 0.96,
and 1.2 Jy beam−1 km s−1(contours), 1.5, 5.5, 9.5, 13.5, and
17.5 Jy beam−1 km s−1 (blue colours), and 0.54, 1.08, 1.62, and
2.16 Jy beam−1 km s−1(red colours). The crosses show the po-
sitions of the 2.7 mm continuum sources detected in the region.
The synthesized beam is drawn in the bottom right corner.
Fig. 12. HC3N (J=12→11) spectrum obtained at the position
of the southern redshifted peak seen at velocities of −9.7 and
−10.3 km s−1 (see Sect. 4.7). The dashed vertical line indicates
the systemic velocity of −11 km s−1.
Note, however, that the velocity of the HC3N gas is somewhat
lower than that of the CO emission at the same location. This
suggests that high velocity material has a lower density, and
would thus not be seen in HC3N.
One should notice that, although the HC3N is well corre-
lated with the molecular outflow, the enhancement of HC3N
is mainly found toward the southern redshifted lobe instead of
Beltr´an et al.: An Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
13
toward the stronger northern blueshifted one, as one would ex-
pect. Furthermore, the peak is found for redshifted velocities
with respect to the cloud. One possible explanation for this is
that, as mentioned in the previous section, the region south-
eastern of OVRO 2 is closer to the bright rim and the ioniza-
tion front, located probably in the background. Therefore, it is
possible that the shock front preceding the ionization front has
compressed and heated the neutral gas, helping to enhance the
HC3N abundance. This would support our hypothesis that the
photoionization front that is coming after the shock front is the
responsible of the weakness and small size of the redshifted
southern lobe. It is worth noticing that once the photoioniza-
tion front will reach the position where the HC3N emission
is found, there will be a decrease of its abundance as HC3N
will be dissociated by the UV photons (e.g. Mon R2: Rizzo et
al. 2005).
5. Conclusions
We studied with the OVRO Millimeter Array the dust and
gas emission at 2.7 mm toward IRAS 22272+6358A, an
intermediate-mass source embedded in the core of the bright-
rimmed cloud L1206.
The 2.7 mm continuum emission has been resolved into
four sources, OVRO 1, OVRO 2, OVRO 3, and OVRO 4. The
strongest source at millimeter wavelengths is OVRO 2, which
is most likely the YSO associated with IRAS 22272+6358A,
and it is probably the driving source of the CO molecular
outflow detected in the region. The millimeter emission of
OVRO 2 shows two components, a centrally peaked source,
which has a diameter of ∼3200 AU at the 50% of the dust emis-
sion peak, plus an extended and quite spherical envelope, which
has a size of ∼11800 AU. The mass of OVRO 2, which has
been estimated from the dust continuum emission, is 14.2 M⊙.
The dust emission morphology and properties of OVRO 2,
which are consistent with those of low-mass counterpart pro-
tostars, indicate that it is an extremely young, deeply embed-
ded intermediate-mass protostar, probably in transition state
between Class 0 and I. The sources OVRO 3 and 4 have a sim-
ilar deconvolved size, ∼5000 AU, and mass, ∼2 M⊙, and are
probably low-mass protostars.The other source in the region,
OVRO 1, could be dusty material entrained by the outflow de-
tected in the region.
The CO (J=1→0) observations have revealed a very weak
southeastern redshifted outflow lobe, which is only visible
at low outflow velocities, and a much stronger northwestern
blueshifted lobe, which extends to very high velocities. This
collimated molecular outflow is elongated in a direction with
PA ≃ 140◦, and it is clearly centered at the position of OVRO 2.
The properties of the outflow are consistent with those of the
outflows driven by low-mass YSOs (Bontemps et al. 1996;
Anglada 1996).
The internal molecular pressure for the bright-rimmed
cloud BRC 44 ranges from 1.8 to 5.0 × 106 cm−3 K, and is
smaller than the IBL pressure, Pi/kB, which is 8.5 × 106 cm−3
K (Morgan et al. 2004)3. This suggests that the cloud is under-
3 See footnote #2.
pressured with respect to the IBL, and therefore, one might ex-
pect photoionization shocks and the ionization front to be prop-
agating into the cloud interior, compressing, heating, and pho-
todissociating the molecular gas. Therefore, photodissociation
could explain the weakness of the redshifted lobe and the mor-
phology of the molecular outflow, drawing an scenario where
the H region would be, in fact, eating the redshifted outflow
lobe.
The
spatial
correlation between the outflow and
the elongated dense protostellar material, as traced by
HC3N (J=12→11), suggests an interaction between the
molecular outflow and the protostellar envelope. Shocks
produced by the molecular outflow, and possibly by the shock
front preceding the photoionization front coming from the
bright rim, would be responsible of the southern enhancement
of the HC3N abundance for redshifted outflow velocities.
The C18O abundance relative to molecular hydrogen esti-
mated toward OVRO 2 is 3 ×10−8, a value ∼6 to 13 times lower
that typical fractional abundances estimated toward molecular
clouds. The most plausible explanation for such a difference is
CO depletion toward OVRO 2. The HC3N abundance relative
to molecular hydrogen estimated toward OVRO 2 is 7 × 10−11.
Acknowledgements. It is a pleasure to thank the OVRO staff for their
support during the observations. MTB, JMG, and RE are supported by
MEC grant AYA2005-08523-C03.
References
Andr´e, P., Ward-Thompson, D., & Barsony, M. 1993, ApJ, 406, 122
Anglada, G. 1995, in Disks, Outflows and Star Formation, ed. S.
Lizano & J. M. Torrelles, RevMexAASC, 1, 67
Anglada, G. 1996, in ASP Conf. Ser. 93, Radio Emission from
the Stars and the Sun, ed. A. R. Taylor & J. M. Paredes (San
Francisco: ASP), 3
Arce, H. G., & Goodman, A. A. 2001, ApJ, 554, 132
Bachiller, R. 1996, ARA&A, 34, 111
Bachiller, R., Fuente, A., & Tafalla, M. 1995, ApJ, 445, L51
Bachiller, R., & P´erez Guti´errez, M. 1997, ApJ, 487, L93
Beltr´an, M. T., Girart, J. M., Estalella, R., Ho, P. T. P., & Palau, A.
2002, ApJ, 573, 246
Beltr´an, M. T., Gueth, F., Guilloteau, S., & Dutrey, A. 2004a, A&A,
416, 631
Beltr´an, M. T., Girart, J. M., Estalella, R., & Ho, P. T. P. 2004b, A&A,
426, 941
Bontemps, S., Andr´e, P., Terebey, S, & Cabrit, S. 1996, A&A, 311,
858
Cabrit, S., & Bertout, C. 1992, A&A, 261, 274
Casoli, F., Dupraz, C., Gerin, M., Combes, F., & Boulanger, F. 1986,
A&A, 169, 281
Chernin, L. M., & Masson, C. R. 1991, ApJ, 382, L93
Chung, H. S., Osamu, K., & Masaki, M. 1991, JKAS, 24, 217
Crampton, D., & Fisher, W. A. 1974, Publ. Dominion Ap. Obs.
Victoria, 14
Curiel, S., Cant´o, J., & Rodr´ıguez, L. F. 1987, RevMexAA, 14, 595
Curiel, S., Rodr´ıguez, L. F. Cant´o, J., Bohigas, J., Roth, M., &
Torrelles, J. M. 1989, Astrophys. Lett. Commun., 27, 299
de Vicente, P., Mart´ın-Pintado, J., Neri, R., & Colom, P. 2000, A&A,
361, 1058
Frerking, M. A., Langer, W. D., & Wilson, R. W. 1982, ApJ, 262, 590
Fuente, A., Neri, R., Mart´ın-Pintado, J., Bachiller, R., Rodr´ıguez-
Franco, A., & Palla, F. 2001, A&A, 366, 873
14
Beltr´an et al.: An Intermediate-Mass Protostar in L1206
Gueth, F., & Guilloteau, S. 1999, A&A, 343, 571
Gueth, F., Schilke, P., & McCaughrean, M. J. 2001, A&A, 375, 1018
Jørgensen, J. K., Schoier, F. L., & van Dishoeck, E. F. 2004, A&A,
Sugitani, K., Fukui, Y., & Ogura, K. 1991, ApJSS, 77, 59
Sugitani, K., Matsuo, H., Nakano, M., Tamura, M., & Ogura, K. 2000,
AJ, 119, 323
416, 603
Vanden Bout, P. A., Loren, R. B., Snell, R. L., & Wootten, A. 1983,
Kulesa, C. A., Hungerford, A. L., Walker, C. K., Zhang, X., & Lane,
ApJ, 271, 161
A. P. 2005, ApJ, 625, 194
Wilking, B. A., Mundy, L. G., Blackwell, J. H., & Howe, J. E. 1989,
Hasegawa, T., Hirano, N., Kameya, O., Taniguchi, Y., Tosa, M., &
ApJ, 345, 257
Takakubo, K. 1986, PASJ, 38, 379
Hogerheijde, M. R., van Dishoeck, E. F., Blake, G. A., & van
Langevelde, H. J. 1997, ApJ, 489, 293
Hogerheijde, M. R., van Dishoeck, E. F., Salverda, J. M., & Blake, G.
Williams, J. P., & Myers, P. C. 1999, ApJ, 511, 208
Wouterloot, J. G. A., & Brand, J. 1989, A&AS, 80, 149
Wu, Y., Wei, Y., Zhao, M., Shi, Y., Yu, W. et al. 2004, A&A, 426, 503
Zhang, Q., Hunter, T. R., Brand, J., Sridharan, T. K. et al. 2001, ApJ,
A. 1999, ApJ, 513, 350
552, 167
Kutner, M. L., & Ulich, B. L. 1981, ApJ, 250, 341
Lee, C.-F., Mundy, L., Reipurth, B., Ostriker, E. C., & Stone, J. M.
2000, ApJ, 542, 925
Lee, C.-F., Mundy, L., Stone, J. M., & Ostriker, E. C. 2002, ApJ, 576,
294
Looney, L. W., Mundy, L. G., & Welch, W. J. 2000, ApJ, 529, 477
MacLaren, I., Richardson, K. Mn., & Wolfendale, A. W. 1988, ApJ,
333, 821
MacLeod, G. C., Scalise, E. Jr., Saedt, S., Galt, J. A., & Gaylard, M.
J. 1998, AJ, 116, 1897
McCutcheon, W. H., Sato, T., Dewdney, P. E., & Purton, C. R. 1991,
AJ, 101, 1435
Molinari, S., Brand, J., Cesaroni, R., & Palla, F. 1996, A&A, 308, 573
Morgan, L. K., Thompson, M. A., Urquhart, J. S., Wjite, G. J., &
Miao, J. A&A, 426, 535
Palla, F., Brand, J., Cesaroni, R., Comoretto, G., & Felli, M. 1991,
A&A, 246, 249
Pezzuto, S., Grillo, F., Benedettini, M., Caux, E., Di Giorgio, A. M. et
al. 2002, MNRAS, 330, 1034
Richer, J. S., Hills, R. E., Padman, R., & Russell, A. P. G. 1989,
MNRAS, 241, 231
Mart´ın-Pintado, J., Jim´enez-Serra, I., Rodr´ıguez-Franco, A., Mart´ın,
S., & Thum, C. 2005, ApJ, 628, L61
Ossenkopf, V., & Henning, Th. 1994, A&A, 291, 943
Ressler, M. E., & Shure, M. 1991, AJ, 102, 1398
Richards, P. J., Little, L. T., Toriseva, M., & Heaton, B. D. 1987,
MNRAS, 228, 43
Richer, J., Shepherd, D. S., Cabrit, S., Bachiller, R., & Churchwell, E.
2000, in protostars and Planets IV, ed. V. Mannings, A. Boss, &
S. Russell (University of Arizona Press), 867
Ridge, N. A., Wilson, T. L., Megeath, S. T., Allen, L. E., & Myers, P.
C. 2003, AJ, 126, 286
Rizzo, J. R., Fuente, A., & Garc´ıa-Burillo, S. 2005, ApJ, 634, 1133
Scoville, N. Z., Carlstrom, J. E., Chandler, C. J., Phillips, J. A. et al.
1993, 1993, PASP, 105, 1482
Scoville, N. Z., Sargent, A. I., Sanders, D. B., Claussen, M. J., Masson,
C. R., Lo, K. Y., & Phillips, T. G. 1986, ApJ, 303, 416
Shepherd, D. S. 2005,
in Massive Star Birth: A Crossroads of
Astrophysics, ed. R. Cesaroni, M. Felli, E. Churchwell, & M.
Walmsley (Cambridge University Press), Proc. IAU Symp. 227,
237
Shepherd, D. S., & Churchwell, E. 1996a, 457, 267
Shepherd, D. S., & Churchwell, E. 1996b, 472, 225
Shepherd, D. S., & Watson, A. M. 2002, ApJ, 566, 1
Snell, R. L., Scoville, N. Z.,Sanders, D. B., & Erickson, N. R. 1984,
ApJ, 284, 176
Sridharan, T. K., Beuther, H., Schilke, P., Menten, & Wyrowski, F.
2002, ApJ, 566, 931
Stanke, Th., McCaughrean, M. J., & Zinnecker, H. 2000, A&A, 355,
639
Sugitani, K., Fukui, Y., Mizuno, A., & Ohashi, N. 1989, ApJ, 342, L87
|
astro-ph/0210594 | 1 | 0210 | 2002-10-28T10:07:25 | Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51: the cluster IMF and the formation history | [
"astro-ph"
] | We study the cluster population in a region of 3.2x3.2 kpc^2 in the inner spiral arms of the intergacting galaxy M51, at a distance of about 1 to 3 kpc from the nucleus, based on HST--WFPC2 images taken through five broadband and two narrowband filters. We found 877 cluster candidates and we derived their ages, initial masses and extinctions by comparing their energy distribution with the Starburst99 cluster models. We describe the 3 and 2-dimensional least-square energy fitting method that was used (3DEF, 2DEF). The lack of [OIII] emission in even the youngest clusters with strong H-alpha emission, indicates the absence of the most massive stars and suggests a mass upper limit of about 25 to 30 solar masses. The mass versus age distribution of the clusters shows a drastic decrease in the number of clusters with age, which indicates that cluster disruption is occurring on a timescale of about 10 Myr for low mass clusters. The cluster initial mass function for clusters younger than 10 Myr has an exponent of alpha = 2.0 (+- 0.05) We derived the cluster formation history from clusters with an initial mass larger than 10^4 solar masses. There is no evidence for a peak in the cluster formation rate within a factor two at about 200 to 400 Myr ago, i.e. at the time of the interaction with the companion galaxy NGC 5194. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. H3780
(DOI: will be inserted by hand later)
October 29, 2018
Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51: the cluster IMF and
the formation history⋆
2
0
0
2
t
c
O
8
2
1
v
4
9
5
0
1
2
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
A. Bik1
,
2 H.J.G.L.M. Lamers1
,
3 N. Bastian1 N. Panagia4
,
5 M. Romaniello6
1 Astronomical
Institute, Utrecht University, Princetonplein 5, NL-3584 CC Utrecht, the Netherlands,
[email protected]
2 Astronomical Institute Anton Pannekoek, University of Amsterdam, Kruislaan 403, NL-1098 SJ Amsterdam,
The Netherlands [email protected]
3 SRON Laboratory for Space Research, Sorbonnelaan 2, NL-3584 CA Utrecht, The Netherlands
4 Space Telescope Science Institute, 3700 San Martin Drive, Baltimore, MD21218, USA; [email protected]
5 On assignment from the Space Science Department of ESA
6 European Southern Observatory, Karl-Schwarzschild Strasse 2, Garching-bei-Muenchen, D-85748, Germany;
[email protected]
received date; accepted date
Abstract. We present the results of an analysis of the HST -- WFPC2 observations of the interacting galaxy M51.
From the observations in 5 broadband filters (U BV RI) and two narrowband filters (Hα and [OIII]) we study the
cluster population in a region of 3.2 ×3.2 kpc2 in the inner spiral arms of M51, at a distance of about 1 to 3 kpc
from the nucleus. We found 877 cluster candidates and we derived their ages, initial masses and extinctions by
means of a comparison between the observed spectral energy distribution and the predictions from cluster synthesis
models for instantaneous star formation and solar metallicity. The lack of [OIII] emission in even the youngest
clusters with strong Hα emission, indicates the absence of the most massive stars and suggests a mass upper limit
of about 25 to 30 M⊙. The mass versus age distribution of the clusters shows a drastic decrease in the number of
clusters with age, much more severe than can be expected on the basis of evolutionary fading of the clusters. This
indicates that cluster dispersion is occurring on a timescale of 10 Myr or longer. The cluster initial mass function
has been derived from clusters younger than 10 Myr by a linear regression fit of the cumulative mass distribution.
This results in an exponent α = −d log N (M )/d log (M ) = 2.1 ± 0.3 in the range of 2.5 103 < M < 5 104 M⊙
but with an overabundance of clusters with M > 2 104 M⊙. In the restricted range of 2.5 103 < M < 2 104 M⊙
we find α = 2.0 ± 0.05. This exponent is very similar to the value derived for clusters in the interacting Antennae
galaxies, and to the exponent of the mass distribution of the giant molecular clouds in our Galaxy. To study the
possible effects of the interaction of M51 with its companion NGC 5195 about 400 Myr ago, which triggered a
huge starburst in the nucleus, we determined the cluster formation rate as a function of time for clusters with an
initial mass larger than 104 M⊙. There is no evidence for a peak in the cluster formation rate at around 200 to
400 Myr ago within 2 σ accuracy, i.e. within a factor two. The formation rate of the detected clusters decreases
strongly with age by about a factor 102 between 10 Myr and 1 Gyr. For clusters older than about 150 Myr this
is due to the evolutionary fading of the clusters below the detection limit. For clusters younger than 100 Myr
this is due to the dispersion of the clusters, unless one assumes that the cluster formation rate has been steadily
increasing with time from 1 Gyr ago to the present time.
Key words. galaxies: individual: M51 -- galaxies: interactions -- galaxies: spiral -- galaxies: starburst -- galaxies:
star clusters --
1. Introduction
Send offprint requests to: H.J.G.L.M. Lamers
⋆ Based on observations with the NASA/ESA Hubble Space
Telescope, obtained at the Space Telescope Science Institute,
which is operated by AURA, Inc., under NASA contract NAS
5-26555
The interaction of galaxies triggers star formation as
clearly seen in the young starbursts in interacting galax-
ies (for reviews see Kennicutt 1998; Schweizer 1998). One
of the best examples is the Antennae system where the
interaction is presently going on and star formation and
2
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
cluster formation occurs on a very large scale in the region
between the two merging nuclei (Whitmore et al. 1999).
The way the triggered star formation progresses
through an interacting galaxy is best studied from a
slightly older interacting system, where the close passage
of the companion is over. In such a system one can hope
to derive the age distribution of clusters as a function of
location in the galaxy and thus measure the time sequence
of the induced star and cluster formation as a function of
location in the galaxy.
One of the best systems for this purpose is the inter-
acting sytem of the Whirlpool galaxy (M51) at a distance
of 8.4 ± 0.6 Mpc (Feldmeier et al. 1997). The M51 sys-
tem consists of a grand design spiral galaxy (NGC 5194)
interacting with its dwarf companion (NGC 5195). The
almost face-on orientation of M51 allows the observation
of its structure in great detail with minimum obscuration
by interstellar dust. The interaction of these two galaxies
has been modelled by various authors, starting from the
fundamental paper by Toomre & Toomre (1972). These
authors derived an age of the closest passage to be 2 × 108
years ago. Later refined models, e.g. by Hernquist (1990),
and reviewed by Barnes (1998), have improved this time
estimate. The closest approach is now believed to have oc-
curred about 250 - 400 Myrs ago. The best model is found
for a distance of the pericenter of 17 to 20 kpc, for a mass
ratio of M/m ≈ 2 and a relative orbit which crosses the
plane of M51 under an angle of about 15 degrees. (For
a discussion of the problems with this model and pos-
sible improvements, see Barnes 1998). Recently Salo &
Laurikainen (2000) suggested that on the basis of N -body
simulations that the M51 system had multiple passages,
with the two last at 50 -100 Myrs and 400-500 Myrs ago.
Because of its relatively small distance from us, and
the fact that we see the M51 system face one, the system
is ideally suited for the study of the progression of clus-
ter formation due to galaxy -- galaxy interaction. For this
reason we started a series of studies of different aspects of
the M51 system based on HST-WFPC2 observations in
six broad band and two narrow band filters.
The nucleus of M51 was studied by Scuderi et al.
(2002). They found that the core contains a starburst with
an age of 410 ± 140 Myrs and a total stellar mass of about
2 × 107M⊙ within the central 17 pc. This age agrees with
the estimated time of closest passage of the companion,
so the starburst in the core is most likely due to the in-
teraction with the passing companion. M51 contains an
unresolved nucleus with a diameter smaller than 2 pc and
a luminosity of 2 × 106L⊙ (Scuderi et al. 2002).
The bulge, i.e. the reddish region with a size of 11 × 16
arcsec2 = 460 × 680 pc2, between the nucleus and the in-
ner spiral arms, was studied by Scuderi et al. (2002) and
by Lamers et al. (2002). The bulge is dominated by an old
stellar population with an age in excess of 5 Gyrs. The
HST − W F P C2 images of the bulge show the presence
of dust lanes. The total amount of dust in the bulge is
about 2.3 × 103 M⊙ and the dust has about the same
extinction law and approximately the same gas to dust
ratio as our Galaxy (Lamers et al. 2002). This suggests a
metallicity close to that in the solar neighbourhood. The
HST − W F P C2 images of the bulge of M51 show clearly
that the dust is concentrated in structures in the forms of
spiral-like dust lanes and a bar that reaches all the way
down into the core. Most intriguingly is the discovery of
about 30 bright and mainly blue point-like sources in the
bulge that are aligned more or less along the spiral-like
dust lanes. Lamers et al. (2002) have shown that these are
most likely very young massive stars 20 < M∗ < 150 M⊙
with little evidence of associated clusters. This mode of
star formation is the result of the peculiar conditions, in
particular the destruction of CO molecules, of the inter-
stellar clouds in the bulge of M51.
In this study we focus on the clusters at a distance
of about 1 to 3 kpc from the nucleus, i.e. near the inner
spiral arms. The purpose of the paper is two-fold:
-- (a) to determine the cluster intitial mass function, and
-- (b) to determine the presence or absence of a starburst
period that can be linked to triggering by the passage
of the companion. This is not an easy task, because our
data will show that the age distribution of the clusters is
strongly affected by the disruption of clusters older than
about 40 Myrs.
We study the clusters and their properties by identi-
fying point-like sources in the HST − W F P C2 images
and measuring their U BV RI magnitudes to obtain their
energy distributions. The magnitudes indicate that the
sources are clusters instead of single stars. Their energy
distributions are compared to cluster evolutionary synthe-
sis models to determine the age, mass and E(B − V ) of
these clusters.
In Sect. 2 we describe the observations and the data
reduction. In Sect. 3 the selection of cluster candidates is
discussed. In Sect. 4 we describe the cluster evolutionary
synthesis models and in Sect. 5 the fitting procedure for
the derivation of the cluster parameters is explained. The
mass versus age distribution of the clusters is derived in
Sect. 6. In Sect. 7 the initial mass function of the clusters
is derived from the sample of clusters younger than 10
Myrs. The cluster formation history is studied in Sect. 8.
The summary and conclusions are given in Sect. 9.
2. Observations and reduction
M51 was observed with HST-WFPC2 as part of the HST
Supernova INtensive Study (SINS) program (Millard et
al. 1999). For this study we use the images taken in the
broad band filters F336W (U ), F439W (B), F555W (V ),
F675W (R) and F814W (I) from the SINS program and
in the narrow band filters F502N ([OIII]) and F656N (Hα)
from the GO-program of H.C. Ford. The image in U was
taken on 1994 May 12, the BV RI images were taken on
Jan 15 1995 and the [OIII] and Hα images on Jan 25
1995. The U and B images were split into three and two
exposures of 400 s and 700 s respectively. The [OIII] and
Hα images are split into two exposures of 1200 s and 500
s ([OIII]), and 1400 s and 400 s (Hα). In the remaining
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
3
bands one single exposure of 600 s was taken. The data
was processed through the PODPS (Post Observing Data
Processing System) for bias removal, flat fielding and dark
frame correction.
To remove the cosmic rays from the U , B [OIII] and Hα
images, we used the STSDAS task crrej for combining the
available exposures. For the V RI images, where only one
exposure is available, we used a procedure called "Cosmic
Eraser". This procedure combines the IRAF tasks cosm-
icrays and imedit to reject as carefully as possible the
cosmic rays. The automatic detection of cosmic rays with
the task cosmicrays is based upon two parameters, a de-
tection threshold and a flux ratio. The first parameter
enables the detection of all the pixels with a value larger
than the average value of the surrounding pixels. The flux
ratio is defined as the percentage of the average value of
the four neighboring pixels (excluding the second bright-
est pixel) to the flux of the brightest pixel. This parameter
allows a classification of the detected objects: cosmic ray
or star. Training objects are used to determine the flux
ratio carefully. These training objects are labeled by the
user to be a cosmic ray or a star. With imedit the detected
cosmic rays signals are replaced by an interpolation of a
third order surface fit to the surrounding pixels.
After the correction for the cosmic rays, the images
were corrected for bad pixels using the hot pixel list from
the STScI W F P C2 website in combination with the task
warmpix. Corrections for non-optimal charge transfer effi-
ciency on the CCD's of the W F P C2 camera were applied
using the formulae by Whitmore & Heyer (1997).
With the task daofind from the DAOPHOT package
Stetson (1987), we identified the point sources on the im-
age. We performed aperture photometry on these sources,
also with the DAOPHOT package. We used an aper-
ture radius of 3 pixels. The sky background was calcu-
lated in an annulus with internal and external radius of
10 and 14 pixels respectively. We only selected the point
sources with an uncertainty smaller than 0.2 in the mag-
nitude. Photometric zeropoints were obtained from table
28.2 of the HST Data Handbook (Voit 1997), using the
VEGAMAG photometric system (Holtzman et al. 1995).
The aperture correction was measured for a number of
isolated, high S/N point sources on each W F P C2-chip.
This output was adopted for all the other point sources
on the chip. Following Holtzman et al. (1995) we have
normalized the aperture correction to 1′′(10 WF pixels).
The aperture corrections we found are between -0.24 and
-0.37 magnitudes. This is larger than the aperture correc-
tions for stars ≈ -0.17 magnitudes (Holtzman et al. 1995),
which means that the detected point sources are fairly well
resolved.
We adopt a distance of d = 8.4 ± 0.6 Mpc (Feldmeier
et al. 1997), which corresponds to a distance modulus of
29.62. At this distance, 1 ′′ corresponds to a linear distance
of 40.7 pc, which means that an HST −W F C pixel of 0.1′′
corresponds to 4.1 pc.
3. Selection of the clusters
The U -band images were taken in 1994, 8 months earlier
than the images in the other passbands. The orientation
of HST − W F P C2 was not the same at the two epochs.
In the 1995 BV RI-images the nucleus of M51 was in the
center of the PC-image. The U -image was centered on
SN1994I (that was 15" off from the nucleus) so that the
nucleus was near the edge of the PC-image. The orienta-
tion of the W F P C2-images is shown in Fig. 1.
For our analysis only the part of W F 4-chip of the U
image that overlap with the W F 2-chip of the BV RI im-
ages is used (see Fig. 1). To identify the various sources,
we obtained a position of the sources in U and transformed
these positions to the coordinate frame of the BV RI im-
ages. The orientation of the [OIII] and Hα images is very
similar to those of the BV RI images. We transformed
these narrow band images to the same orientation as the
BV RI images.
We applied our analysis of the cluster energy distribu-
tions to the sources that were detected in the images of at
least three of the BV RI broad-band filters with a mag-
nitude uncertainty smaller than 0.2 in each band. To this
purpose we compared the positions of all detected sources
in the BV RI images. If objects occur in at least three
images within a position tolerance of 2 pixels they are
selected for our study. This tolerance was chosen on the
basis of tests with clearly identifiable sources that were
observed in most bands. For the sources detected in at
least three images we then checked for the presence of a
source in the U image, in the region where the U image
and the BV RI images do overlap (the dark grey region in
Fig. 1). If a source was not detected in a particular band,
we adopted a conservative lower limit for the magnitude
in that band (see below). This was not always possible for
the U -magnitude, because many of the sources detected
in the BV RI bands are located in an area that was not
covered by the U -image. As a consequence, we have no
information on the U -magnitude for many of the sources.
The location of the sources in the W F 2-chip is shown
in Fig. 2. The overlay of the sources on the V band image
clearly shows that the clusters are concentrated in or near
the spiral arms at a distance of about 1.5 kpc from the
nucleus of M51. The number of sources, detected in the
various bands, is listed in Table 1. The sample contains a
total of 877 sources for which we have reliable photometry
(σ < 0.20 magn.) in at least three bands. 1
Fig. 3 shows the magnitude distribution of the sources
in the various bands. All distributions show a slow in-
crease in numbers towards fainter objects, a maximum
and a steep decrease towards even fainter sources. The
slow increase to fainter sources reflects their luminosity
function. The steep decrease to high magnitudes is due
to the detection limit. This detection limit is not a single
value for each band, because of the variable background
in the W F 2 field due to the spiral arms. The maximum of
1 The coordinates and the photometry of the objects are
available in the electronic version of A& A
4
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
U
BVRI
U
BVRI chip
used
U chip
overlapping
BVRI
BVRI
Fig. 1. The location of the W F P C2 camera when the BV RI images were taken, superimposed on an optical image
of M51. Right: The orientation of the W F P C2 camera when the BV RI and the U images were taken. The grey area
indicates the location of the W F 2 chip, covering an area of 3.25 × 3.25 kpc (for an adopted distance of 8.4 Mpc), that
was used in this analysis. Its exact location and orientation are given in Fig. 2. The dark grey region shows the overlap
of the BV RI and U images.
the distributions are near U ≃ 20.0, B ≃ 22.0, V ≃ 22.0,
R ≃ 21.5 and I ≃ 21.0. These values will be adopted
as conservative lower limits for the magnitudes of sources
that were not detected in any given band.
All the objects fall in the visual magnitude range of
16.5 < V < 23.6. For distance modulus of 29.62 this corre-
sponds to an absolute magnitude range of −12.1 < MV <
−6.0 in the case of zero extinction and −12.6 < MV <
−6.5 in case of moderate extinction with E(B −V ) ≃ 0.17.
This means that the faintest objects could be either very
bright stars or small clusters. The vast majority of the
selected point sources are so bright that they must be
clusters. (See Sect 5.6).
Table 1. Numbers of point sources detected in the differ-
ent W F P C2 − HST -images
F336W F439W F555W F675W F814W number
objects
(B)
(U )
(V )
(R)
(I)
d
l
n
d
l
n
d
l
n
d
d
d
l
l
l
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
l
l
l
76
366
109
30
144
39
21
78
14
877
3.1. The Hα and [OIII] magnitudes
The magnitudes in the narrow-band images of filters
F 656N (m(Hα)) and F 502N (m[OIII]) can be com-
pared with those of the wide-band filters F 675W (R) and
F 555W (V ) respectively to derive a measure of the equiv-
alent width of the Hα and [OIII] lines. When the mag-
nitudes are expressed in the ST-system, the magnitude
differences R − m(Hα) and V − m[OIII] are by definition
equal to 0.0 if the spectrum of a source is a featureless,
flat continuum (i.e. the spectrum of the source is a contin-
uum Fλ = const without a photospheric Hα absorption,
and there is no HII region around the star). The differ-
ences R − m(Hα) and V − m[OIII] are either positive
or negative if the source spectrum has an emission or an
absorption line, respectively, falling in the narrow band
filter, independently of the interstellar extinction. With
d means "detected", l means "lower magnitude limit" (i.e. the
object is fainter than the detection limit) and n means "not
observed".
the Vega-system magnitudes one has to fold in both the
non-zero spectral slope and the discrete features present
in α Lyrae's spectrum. Therefore, a featureless flat con-
tinuum would correspond to R − m(Hα) ≃ +0.08 and
V − m[OIII] ≃ −0.26 colors in the Vega-system.
Fig. 4a shows the m(Hα) versus R and Fig. 4b shows
m[OIII] versus V for the subset of sources for which we
could measure these magnitudes with an accuracy better
than 0.2. The figure shows that many sources have Hα
emission (m(Hα) < R) but none (!) of the sources has
[OIII] emission (note that m[OIII] is slightly fainter than
the V magnitude as appropriate for complete absence of
an emission line). The lack of [OIII] emission indicates that
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
5
the far-UV flux, at λ < 350 A i.e. at energies higher than
the second ionization potential of oxygen, is quite low. For
main sequence stars with L > 2.5 × 105L⊙ (i.e. with M >
30M⊙ and Teff > 33 000 K), surrounded by an HII region
with approximately solar abundances, we would expect
V − m[OIII] > R − m(Hα). We will show later, on the
basis of the study of the energy distributions, that many
of the objects are very young clusters with ages less than
a 10 Myr. The lack of [OIII] emission shows that these
clusters do not contain stars with Teff above about 30 000
K, which corresponds to about 25 to 30 M⊙ (e.g. Chiosi &
Maeder 1986). We can exclude the possibility that the lack
of [OIII] emission be due to just a high metallicity, which
could reduce the electron temperature in an HII region
and weaken optical forbidden lines considerably, without
requiring a lower effective temperature, or, equivalently, a
low upper mass cutoff. This is because in many HII regions
in M51 an in other metal-rich spiral galaxies not only are
the [OIII] lines faint or absent but also the HeI lines are
unusually faint relative to Balmer lines (Panagia 2000;
Lenzuni & Panagia, in preparation). This result indicates
that He is only partially ionized and, therefore, that the
ionizing radiation field is indeed produced exclusively by
stars with effective temperatures much lower than 33,000K
. So we conclude that the upper mass limit for clusters in
the inner spiral arms of M51 is about 25 to 30 M⊙.
4. Cluster evolution models
To determine the age,
initial mass and E(B − V ) of
the clusters, we compare the observed energy distribu-
tions with energy distributions derived from theoretical
cluster evolutionary synthesis models. We used two sets
of models: the Starburst99 models for ages up to 1 Gyr,
and the Frascati models for ages of 10 Myr to 5 Gyr. In
this section the models are described.
4.1. Starburst99 cluster evolution models
To determine the age,
initial mass and E(B − V ) of
the clusters, we compare the observed energy distribu-
tions with energy distributions derived from theoretical
cluster evolutionary synthesis models. We used two sets
of models: the Starburst99 models for ages up to 1 Gyr,
and the Frascati models for ages of 10 Myr to 5 Gyr. In
this section the models are described.
4.2. Starburst99 cluster evolution models
the
observed
spectral
(SED)
of
our
compared
objects with
energy
We
the
distributions
cluster evolutionary synthesis models
et
al. (1999), i.e. the Starburst99 models for instantaneous
star formation. In these models, the stellar atmosphere
models of Lejeune et al. (1997) are included. For stars
with a strong mass loss the Schmutz et al. (1992) extended
model atmospheres are used. The stellar evolution models
of the Geneva group are included in these models. For
of Leitherer
image is
Fig. 2. Left: the location of all the detected point
sources in the WF2 chip superimposed on the V-band
image. This
rotated 90 degrees clockwise
compared to Fig. 1. The coordinates of the lower-left
and upper-right corners of the image are: pixel(1,1):
Dec(2000)=47011'27".2.
RA(2000)=13h29m55s.90,
RA(2000)=13h29m57s.94,
and
pixel800,800:
Dec(2000)=47013'16".6.
Fig. 3. The histogram of the magnitudes in the different
bands. The slow increase at bright magnitudes is due to
the luminosity function and the steep decrease at fainter
magnitudes is due to the detection limit.
6
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
of the cluster models, taking into account the nebular con-
tinuum emission.
To obtain the absolute magnitudes from the theoret-
ical spectral energy distributions in the five broad-band
filters and the two narrow-band filters we convolved the
predicted spectra of the Starburst99 models with the
W F P C2 filter profiles. The spectrum of Vega was also
convolved with the filter functions in order to find the
zero-points of the magnitudes in the VEGAMAG system.
For each combination of Z and Mup we calculated the SED
of 195 models in the range of 0.1 Myr to 1 Gyr, with time
steps increasing from 0.5 Myr for the youngest models to
10 Myr for the oldest models.
The adopted lower mass limit of 1 M⊙ for the cluster
stars has consequences for the derived masses of the clus-
ters. If the IMF with a slope of -2.35 has a lower mass limit
of 0.2 M⊙, as for the Orion Nebula Cluster (Hillenbrand
1997), the derived masses of the clusters would be a fac-
tor 2.09 higher for an upper limit of 30 M⊙. If the lower
limit is 0.6 M⊙, the mass of the clusters will be a fac-
tor 1.28 higher than those of the Starburst99 models for
Mup = 30 M⊙. We will take this effect into account in the
determination of the cluster masses.
Some of the theoretical energy distributions in the
W F P C2 wide-band filters used in this study are shown
in Fig. 5, for clusters with an initial mass of 106 M⊙ at
the distance of M51. During the first 5 Myrs the UV flux
remains high because most of the O-type stars have main
sequence ages longer than 5 Myr. Between 5 and 10 Myr
the O-type stars disappear. This results in a general de-
crease at all magnitudes, except in the I band where the
red supergiants start to dominate. At later ages the flux
decreases at all wavelengths as stars end their lives. After
900 Myrs only stars of types late-B and later have sur-
vived.
Fig. 5 shows that at any wavelength in the observed
range the flux decreases with time. This fading of the clus-
ters indicates that the detection limit of the clusters will
gradually shift to those of higher mass as the clusters age.
This is because the flux of a cluster (for a given stellar
initial mass function) at any age and wavelength is pro-
portional to the initial number of stars. The more massive
the initial cluster, the brighter the cluster and the longer
the flux will remain above the detection limit as the clus-
ter fades due to stellar evolution. For any given detection
limit, we can calculate the lower mass limit of the observ-
able cluster as a function of age.
Fig. 6 shows the relation between the initial mass of a
cluster and its age when it fades below the detection limit,
derived from the Starburst99 models. The R-magnitude
(R) of a cluster of initial mass Mi without extinction at
the adopted distance of 8.4 Mpc of M51 (dm = 29.62) is
related to the absolute R-magnitude (MR) predicted for
the Starburst99 models of 106 M⊙ by
R(t) = MR(t) + 29.62 − 2.5 × log(M/106)
(1)
Fig. 4. The top figure shows m(Hα) versus R and the
lower figure shows m[OIII] versus V for objects were these
magnitudes could be determined with an accuracy better
than 0.2 magn. Notice that many objects have Hα emis-
sion, but no object has detectable [OIII] emission.
our analysis we used the models of the Spectral Energy
Distributions (SEDs).
In the cluster models the stars are assumed to
be formed with a classical Salpeter
IMF-slope of
d log(N )/d log(M ) = −2.35. The lower cut-off mass is
Mlow = 1 M⊙. We adopt two values for the upper cut-
off mass: the standard value of Mup = 100 M⊙, and the
value of Mup = 30 M⊙. This last value is adopted because
it is suggested by the lack of [OIII] emission (see 3.1).
The total initial mass of all models is 106 M⊙. Leitherer
et al. (1999) present models for 5 different metallicities,
from Z = 0.001 to Z = 0.040 = 2 × Z⊙. Observations
of HII-regions have shown that the metallicity of the in-
ner region of M51 is approximately 2Z⊙ or slightly higher
(e.g. Diaz et al. 1991; Hill et al. 1997). Therefore we adopt
the models with Z = 0.020 and 0.040. The almost solar
metallicity agrees with the study of Lamers et al. (2002),
who found that the extinction properties and the gas to
dust-ratio in the bulge of M51 is very similar to that in
the Milky Way. So we use four sets of models, denoted by
the pair (Z, Mup) of (0.02,100), (0.02,30), (0.04,100) and
(0.04,30). For these combinations we calculated the SEDs
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
7
Fig. 5. Examples of some characteristics of the theo-
retical energy distributions, in magnitude versus wave-
length (A) of the U BV RI filters (from left to right), for
STARBURST99 clusters with an initial mass of 106 M⊙
at the distance of M51. The age of the cluster in Myrs is
indicated. The evolutionary variation is discussed in Sect.
4.1
So, for a given detection limit Rlim the critical mass Mlim
of a cluster that can be detected at age t is given by
log Mlim(t) = 6 + 0.4 × (MR(t) + 29.62 − Rlim)
(2)
We have adopted the R magnitudes to calculate the ob-
served lower limits of the distributions for two reasons:
(a) all clusters were detected in the R band and (b) the
effect of extinction is small in the R band. The resulting
relation between Mlim and age is shown in Fig. 6 for de-
tection limits of Rlim= 22.0 and 23.0 magn. We will use
these limits later, in Sect. 5, to explain the distribution of
clusters in the mass versus age diagram.
Fig. 7 shows the variations of the colours of the
Starburst99 models for solar metallicity and with an upper
mass limit of 30 M⊙. The figure shows that the colours do
not change monotonically, but that there are peaks and
dips, especially in the age range of 6.5 < log(t) < 7.3.
These are related to the phases of the appearance of red
supergiants that also produced the dips in the limiting
magnitude curves of Fig. 6.
4.3. The Frascati models
Since the Starburst99 models only cover the age range up
to 1 Gyr, we also used synthetic cluster models for older
ages from the Frascati group. These "Frascati-models"
were calculated by Romaniello (1998) from the evolution-
ary tracks of Brocato & Castellani (1993) and Cassisi et al.
(1994) using the HST −W F P C2 magnitudes derived from
the stellar atmosphere models by Kurucz (1993). These
models are for instantaneous formation of a cluster of so-
lar metallicity stars in the mass range of 0.6 to 25 M⊙,
with a total initial mass of 50 000 M⊙, distributed accord-
Fig. 6. The relation between the critical initial mass Mlim
and age, derived for two values of the R-band magni-
tude limit; 22.0 and 23.0 magn. It is calculated from the
Starburst99 cluster models, for a distance of 8.4 Mpc and
no extinction. Only clusters with an initial mass higher
than Mlim can be detected as faint as Rlim at time t.
Alternatively, clusters with a mass Mlim can only be de-
tected down to a magnitude Rlim when they are younger
than the age t, indicated by these relations.
Fig. 7. The variations of colours with age of
the
Starburst99 models of Z = 0.02 and an upper mass limit
of 30 M⊙. Notice the periods of rapid variability near the
peaks and dips around t ≃ 6 and 16 Myrs, log(t) ≃ 6.8
and 7.2.
ing to Salpeter's IMF. These models cover an age range
of 10 to 5000 Myr. There are 48 models with timesteps
increasing from 10 Myr for the youngest ones to 500 Myr
for the oldest ones. We have increased the magnitudes of
the Frascati models by -3.526 magn. in order to scale these
models to a total mass of 106 M⊙ in the mass range of 1.0
to 25 M⊙; i.e. −3.25 magn. correction for the conversion
from 5 104 to 1 106 M⊙, and 0.279 magn. correction for
the conversion from a lower stellar mass limit of 0.6 M⊙ to
8
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
1.0 M⊙. In this way the masses can be compared directly
with those of the Starburst99 models.
The Starburst99 models are expected to more accu-
rate for the younger clusters, because they are based on
the evolutionary tracks of the Geneva-group which include
massive stars. The Frascati models are expected to be
more accurate for the old clusters, because they include
stars with masses down to 0.6 M⊙.
4.4. The extinction curve
To determine the values of E(B − V ) of the clusters we
assume the mean galactic reddening law. Lamers et al.
(2002) and Scuderi et al. (2002) have shown that the
extinction law of respectively the bulge and the core of
M51 agree very well with the galactic law. The values of
Ri = Ai/E(B − V ) for the HST − W F P C2 filters have
been calculated by Romaniello (1998). They are respec-
tively 4.97, 4.13, 3.11, 2.41 and 1.91 for the U, B, V, R and
I bands.
In the fitting of the energy distributions we did not
take into account the disruption of clusters. We assumed
that the stars contribute to the total energy distribution
of the clusters until the cluster is completely dissolved and
is no longer detectable as a point source. This is a reason-
able assumption because we measured the magnitudes in
a circle of 40.7 pc radius (see Sect. 2).
5. Fitting the observed energy distributions to
observed cluster models
5.1. The fitting procedure
We have fitted the energy distributions of the clusters with
good photometry in four or more filters, viz. U BV RI,
BV RI, U V RI and U BV R (see Table 1), with the energy
distributions of the cluster evolutionary synthesis models,
discussed above, using a three dimensional maximum like-
lihood method. The three fitting parameters are: the age
of the cluster (τ ), the reddening (E(B −V )) and the initial
mass of the cluster (M ). For the clusters detected in only
three filters we reduce the parameter space and make a
two dimensional maximum likelihood fit. For objects not
detected in a band, we adopted the magnitude lower limits
(described in Sect. 3) to check which fits were acceptable.2
5.2. Three dimensional maximum likelihood method
This method was applied to sources that are detected in
at least four bands. We fitted the observed energy dis-
tributions with those predicted for the Starburst99 clus-
ter models and the Frascati models (see Sect. 4.2). For
each model-age we have two fitting parameters M and
E(B − V ). The cluster models are for an initial cluster
2 We will refer to this method in subsequent papers as the
"3(2)DEF- method", i.e. the three (or two) dimensional energy
distribution fitting".
mass of 106 M⊙. For other masses the flux simply scales
M/106M⊙. We have adopted an uncertainty in the model
fluxes of 5 percent (0.05 magnitudes) in all bands.
To reduce the range in masses in the parameter space,
we make an initial guess of the cluster mass based on
the observed magnitudes, since the distance to M51 is
known. By calculating the average difference in magni-
tude -- weighted by the errors -- between the theoretical
energy distribution for 106 M⊙ and the observed one, we
have a good first approximation of the mass of the cluster:
Mguess(E(B − V ), τ ) ≃
1/σλ{mobs
(E(B−V ),τ )}
Pλ
λ
λ −mmod
Pλ
1/σλ
.
(3)
with E(B − V ) between 0.0 and 2.0 in steps of 0.02, where
σ is the uncertainty in the magnitude. This is a reasonable
range, compared to the average colour excess for the bulge
of 0.2 found by Lamers et al. (2002). With this initial guess
we then make a three dimensional likelihood analysis, us-
ing a mass range from 1/1.5 to 1.5 times the initial mass
estimate in steps of 0.004 dex. The extinction was varied
between 0.0 and 2.0 in steps of 0.01 and the age was var-
ied between 0.1 Myr and 1 Gyr for the Starburst99 models
and between 10 Myr to 5 Gyr for the Frascati models.
For every fit we obtain a value for the reduced χ2, i.e.
ν = χ2/ν, where ν is the number of free parameters i.e.
χ2
the number of the observed data points minus the num-
ber of parameters in the theoretical model. For a good fit,
χ2
ν should be about unity. We checked that the fits were
consistent with the faint magnitude limits of the filters in
which the object was not detected. If not, the fit was re-
jected. The fit with the minimum value of χ2
ν was adopted
as the best fit and the corresponding values of E(B − V ),
age and Mi were adopted. This method was applied for
fits with the four sets of the Starburst99 models and with
the Frascati models. Fig. 8 shows some examples of the
results of the fitting process.
ν < χ2
To estimate the uncertainty in the determined parame-
ters we use confidence limits. If χ2
ν(min)+1 then the
resulting parameters, i.e. log(t), log(Mi) and E(B − V ),
are within the 68.3 % probability range. So the accepted
ranges in age, mass and extinction are derived from the
fits which have χ2
ν(min) + 1. With this
method we derived the ages, initial masses3 and extinction
with their uncertainties of 602 clusters.
ν(min) < χ2
ν < χ2
Fig. 9 shows a histogram of number of clusters as func-
tion of E(B − V ). We will use this distribution for the two
dimensional maximum likelihood fit of clusters detected in
3 The initial cluster mass that we derived in this way is in
fact "the initial mass of the current stellar population", i.e. it is
the "current mass corrected for stellar evolution effects". This
value can be different from the the initial mass of the original
cluster if the cluster suffered evaporation or disruption. In that
case the derived initial mass is the initial mass of the original
cluster minus the fraction that has disappeared by evaporation
or disruption.
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
9
Fig. 8. Example of some fits. The filled dots represent the observed energy distributions of objects measured in at
least four bands, with their error bars in magnitude versus wavelength (in µm). In several cases the error bars are
smaller than the size of the dots. Crosses indicate magnitude lower limits. The parameters of the fits are indicated
log(Mcl)). The second array gives the uncertainties in these parameters. The line is
in an array (E(B − V ),
the best fit obtained with the maximum likelihood method. Top figures: fits with χ2
ν < 1; bottom figures: fits with
ν ≃ 3. Notice that the uncertainty of the fit parameters depends not only on χ2
χ2
ν but also strongly on the quality of
the data. For instance, the errors in the magnitudes of the last two clusters are very small, so that the fit parameters
are accurate, despite the high value of χ2
ν.
log(t),
three bands only. The redding is small: 90 % of the clusters
have a reddening lower than 0.40; 67 % of the clusters have
a reddening lower than 0.18 and 23% have no detectable
reddening.
5.3. Two dimensional maximum likelihood method
For the clusters observed in only three bands, it is not
possible to make a three dimensional maximum likelihood
fit. To reduce the parameter space we adopted the proba-
bility distribution of E(B − V ) in the range of E(B − V )
between 0.0 and 0.4, as shown in Fig. 9. For every value
of E(B − V ) between 0.0 and 0.40 (in steps of 0.02) and
for every age of the model cluster, we first determine the
mass of the cluster by means of Eq. (3). The results of the
three dimensional fits have shown this is a good approxi-
mation. This results in a maximum likelihood age of the
cluster for every value of E(B − V ).
The χ2
ν which comes out from the two dimensional
maximum likelihood method is used to distinguish be-
tween the accepted and rejected fits. For the parameter
ν we used a value of 3-1=2, because we only fit the age of
the cluster. The mass of the cluster comes from the scaling
of the magnitudes to the best-fit model. A fit is accepted
if it agrees with the lower magnitude limits in the filters
where it was not measured. To determine the age of the
cluster, we average the ages, weighted by the probability
that each particular value of E(B − V ) occurs, derived
by normalizing the distribution in Fig. 9 in the range of
0.0 < E(B −V ) < 0.40. The error in the age is determined
by calculating the value of the standard deviation σ of the
age, again weighted with the probability that the value of
E(B − V ) occurs. The value of E(B − V ) is determined
by using the one which belongs to the model with the age
closest to the average age. The initial mass of the clus-
ter is then calculated by Eq. (3) for the adopted value of
E(B − V ). With this method we derived the age, initial
mass and the extinction of 275 clusters, using both the
Starburst99 models and the Frascati models.
10
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
method, results not only in the values of log(Mcl), log(t)
and E(B − V ) but also in their maximum and minimum
acceptable values. The best-fit values are not necessarily
in the middle of the minimum and the maximum values. If
we define the uncertainties in the parameters, ∆E(B −V ),
∆ log(Mcl) and ∆ log(t) as half the difference between the
maximum and mimimum values, we find that 30 percent
of the clusters have ∆E(B − V ) < 0.08, 50 percent have
∆E(B−V ) < 0.11 and 70 percent have ∆E(B−V ) < 0.15.
For the uncertainties in the mass determination we find
∆ log(Mcl) < 0.20, < 0.33 and < 0.55 for 30, 50 and 70
percent of the clusters respectively. For the uncertain-
ties in the age determination we find ∆ log(t) < 0.23,
< 0.39 and < 0.69 for 30, 50 and 70 percent of the clus-
ters respectively. Taking the values for 50 percent of the
clusters as representative, we conclude that the uncer-
tainties are ∆E(B − V ) ≃ 0.11, ∆ log(Mcl) ≃ 0.33 and
∆ log(t) ≃ 0.39.
5.6. Contamination of the cluster sample by stars?
To estimate the number of stars that may contaminate
our cluster sample we use the stellar population in the
solar neighbourhood. ¿From the tabulated stellar densi-
ties as a function of spectral type (Allen 1976) we derived
the number of stars brighter than a certain value of MV
per pc3. Using the mass density of 0.13 M⊙pc−3, we de-
rived the number of stars per unit stellar mass. The re-
sults are listed in Table 2. The total stellar mass of the
observed region of M51 (see Fig. 2) is estimated to be
about 1/20 of the total mass of 5 1010 M⊙ in the disk of
that galaxy (Athanassoula et al. 1987), i.e. about 2.5 109
M⊙. This implies that we can expect the following num-
bers of stars brighter than MV < −6.5 per spectral type
in the observed region: 4 (O), 13 (B), 6 (A), 6 (F), 6 (G),
<1 (K) and <1 (M). So we can expect of the order of 40
bright stars with MV < −6.5 in the observed region of
M51. However, these are all massive young supergiants of
which the vast majority will be in clusters! So the number
of bright stars outside clusters, that may contaminate our
sample of clusters will be considerable smaller, and we ex-
pect it to be smaller than about 20 out of the total sample
of 877. Moreover, we have shown above, from the lack of
O[III] emission, that the clusters in M51 have a short-
age of massive stars with M > 30 M⊙. We can expect
this effect also to occur for the massive field stars. This
would reduce the the number of expected contaminating
stars even further. Tests have shown that a considerable
fraction of possibly remaining stellar sources will be elim-
inated by the requirement that their energy distribution
should fit that of cluster models within a given accuracy.
Based on all these considerations, we conclude that con-
tamination of our cluster sample with very massive stars
of MV < −6.5 outside clusters is expected to be negligible.
Fig. 9. Histogram of the values of E(B − V ) from the fits
with observations in BV RI and U BV RI. The extinction
is small: 90% of the clusters have E(B − V ) < 0.40
5.4. Starburst99 or Frascati models?
We have compared the energy distributions of the objects
with five sets of models: four sets of Starburst99 models,
with Z = Z⊙ or 2Z⊙ and Mup = 30 or 100 M⊙, and the
Frascati models with Z = Z⊙ and Mup = 25 M⊙. Based
on the lack of [OIII] emission we adopt the models with
Mup = 25 or 30 M⊙. The models with Mup = 100 M⊙
are only used later to check the influence of this adopted
upper limit on our results.
We have compared the ages derived from fitting the ob-
served SEDs with the Starburst99 models and the Frascati
models, for objects measured in at least four filters and
with fits of χ2
ν < 3.0. We found that in the age range
of 10 to 800 Myr there is a reasonable correlation be-
tween the results of the SB99 models and the Frascati
models, with the Frascati models giving ages systemati-
cally about 0.4 dex smaller than the SB99 models. In this
age range we adopt the SB99 models, because they are
based on more reliable evolutionary tracks, better stellar
atmosphere models and because the nebular continuum
is included. We find that in this mass range the fits with
the SB99 models have smaller χ2
ν than the fits with the
Frascati-models. For objects with ages above about 700
Myrs (log(t) > 8.85) the Frascati-models give the most
reliable fits with smaller χ2
ν than the SB99 models. This
is probably because the lower mass limit of the SB99 mod-
els is 1 M⊙, and the Frascati models go down to 0.6 M⊙.
Moreover the SB99 models do not go beyond 1 Gyr. Based
on this comparison we adopt the SB99 fits for ages less
than 700 Myrs and the results of the Frascati models for
older ages.
5.5. Uncertainties in the derived parameters
The determination of the cluster parameters, age, mass
and extinction, by means of the two or thee dimensional
maximum likelihood fitting method,
i.e. the 3(2)DEF-
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
11
Table 2. Numbers of stars above a certain absolute magnitude limit in the solar neighbourhood
Limit
MV < −5.5
MV < −6.5
MV < −7.5
O
-8.3
-8.8
-9.8
B
-7.6
-8.3
-9.3
A
-8.0
-8.6
-9.6
F
-7.4
-8.6
-9.6
G
K
M
Total
-8.5
-7.4
-8.5
-8.6 <-9.5
<-9.5
-9.6 <-10.5 <-10.5
-6.9
-7.9
-8.9
(1) The data are in log (Number/ per M⊙)
(2) The number of stars with MV < −7.5 was estimated to be about 10 times smaller than for MV < −6.5 because of the small
number of very massive stars formed, and their short evolution time.
6. The mass versus age distribution
We discuss the results from the fitting of the observed
energy distributions to those of cluster models with solar
metallicity and with and upper mass limit of 30 M⊙. We
have checked that the fits with twice solar metallicity and
with an upper limit of 100 M⊙ give about the same results.
Fig. 10 shows the mass versus age distribution of
sources with Mv < −7.5 (to eliminate possible stellar
sources) and with energy distributions that could be fitted
to that of a cluster models with an accuracy of χ2
ν ≤ 3.0.
(The distributions for clusters with χ2
ν ≤ 1 or 10, not
shown here, show the same distribution, but with 294 and
508 clusters respectively.) We see that the lower limit of
the mass increases with increasing age, from about 1000
M⊙ at τ ≃ 5 Myrs to about 5 104 M⊙ at 1 Gyr. This
is due to the expected effect of fading of the clusters as
they age (see Sect. 4.1). The full line in the figure is the
fading line in the R magnitude for clusters which have a
limiting magnitude of Rlim = 22.0 at the distance of M51
for a reddening of E(B − V )=0. The line in Fig. 10 thus
gives the mass of the clusters, that reaches this magnitude
detection limit, as a function of age.
These initial mass versus age distribution of the
clusters in Fig. 10 show the following characteristics:
-- (i) The lower mass limit increases with age due to the
fading of the clusters. The observed lower limit agrees
with the predicted ones for the R band. There are even
hints of the presence of the predicted dips in the lower
limit near log(t)=6.8 and 7.2. This strengthens our
confidence in the adopted models.
-- (ii) There are clear concentrations in the distribution
at log(t) = 6.70 and 7.45 and possibly also around
log(t) ≃ 7.2. These are due to the properties of the
cluster models and the adopted method. In Fig. 7 we
have shown that the colours of the models do not change
monotonically with time, but that there are phases when
the colours change rapidly with time. These phases occur
in the range of 6.5 < log(t) < 7.3. Large changes in the
colours of the models occur just before and after the
peaks where the slopes of the curves in Fig. 7 are large.
It is more difficult to fit the observed energy distributions
with high accuracy to models in the age range when the
spectral changes are large, than in the age range when the
changes are small. So there is a tendency of the model fits
to concentrate in agebins just outside the age-regions of
large spectral changes. This explains the concentrations
Fig. 10. The mass versus age relation of the 392 clus-
ters with MV < −7.5, whose energy distribution could
be fitted with an accuracy of χ2
ν < 3.0. The cross shows
the characteristic uncertainties (Sect. 5.5). The full line
is the predicted fading line due to the evolution of clus-
ters with E(B − V )=0 and with a limiting magnitude of
Rlim = 22.0 at the distance of M51. This line roughly
agrees with the observed lower limit. The distribution is
discussed in the text.
and the voids in the derived age distributions of the
clusters between about 6.5 < log(t) < 7.5.
-- (iii) The density of the points drops at log(t) > 7.5.
Since the age scale is logarithmic, we might have expected
an increasing density of points towards the higher ages,
which is not observed. This is due to the disruption or
dispersion of the clusters (see first paragraphs of Sect. 7).
We conclude that the mass versus age distribution
agrees with the expected evolutionary fading of the clus-
ters and that the decrease in numbers of clusters with age
shows the affect of disruption/dispersion of clusters with
time. The concentrations of the clusters at ages around
log(t) = 6.8, 7.2 and 7.45 are due to statistical effects and
do not represent periods of enhanced cluster formation.
7. The cluster Initial Mass Function
The data in Fig. 10 and the detailed study of this dis-
tribution by Boutloukos & Lamers (2002) show that the
clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51 disrupt on a time
12
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
Table 3. The CIMF for clusters with t < 10 Myr and
Mcl < 2.5 × 103M⊙
Sample
Nr
log Mmin
α
All
∆ log Mcl < 0.25
χ2
ν < 3.0
149
66
82
3.49
3.48
3.46
2.12 ± 0.26
2.04 ± 0.41
2.16 ± 0.40
dicates that the clusters are formed with an CIMF that
has a negative slope of d log(N )/d log(M ), as expected.
If the CIMF can be written as a power law of the type
N (M ) dM ∼ M α dM for Mmin < M < Mmax
(5)
then the normalized cumulative distribution will be
Σ(M ) = A − B × M −α+1
with
A = B × Mmin
B = (M −α+1
−α+1
min − M −α+1
max )−1
(6)
Fig. 12 shows the observed and predicted normalized cu-
mulative distribution of the 149 clusters with an age less
than 10 Myr and with a mass Mcl > 2.5 103 M⊙ that are
used for the determination of the CIMF. We eliminated
the clusters with Mcl < 2.5 103 M⊙ from the sample be-
cause Fig. 11 shows that the sample may not be complete
for smaller masses. The cumulative distributions of the 84
clusters of M > 2.5 103 M⊙, younger than 10 Myr, which
are fitted to the models with an accuracy of χ2
ν ≤ 3.0, or
of the 66 clusters with ∆ log(Mcl) ≤ 0.25, not shown here,
(where ∆ log(Mcl) is the uncertainty in the mass determi-
nation), have the same shape as the distribution in Fig.
12. For these three samples we have determined the val-
ues of α and Mmin by means of a linear regression under
the reasonable assumption that Mmin << Mmax, which
implies that A ≃ 1. The resulting values of α and Mmin
are listed in Table 3. The table shows that α ≃ 2.1 for all
three samples.
The predicted cumulative distribution with the derived
values of α = 2.12 and Mmin is shown in Fig. 12 (full
line). The figure shows a slight underabundance of clus-
ters in the range of 4.0 < log(Mcl) < 4.3 and a slight
overabundance in the range of log(Mcl) > 4.3. In fact,
for the mass range of 3.5 < log(Mcl) < 4.3 a fit with
α = 2.00, shown by dashed lines, fits the distribution ex-
cellently. We conclude that the CIMF of clusters younger
than 10 Myr has a slope of α ≃ 2.1 ± 0.3 in the mass range
of 3.0 < log(Mcl) < 5.0 and a slope of 2.00 ± 0.05 in the
range of 3.0 < log(Mcl) < 4.3 M⊙.
The derived exponent of the cluster IMF is very similar
to the value of α = 2.0 of young clusters in the Antennae
galaxies, as found by Zhang & Fall (1999). It shows that
the IMF of clusters formed in the process of galaxy-galaxy
interaction is very similar to the one of clusters formed in
the spiral arms of a galaxy, long after the interaction. This
mass distribution is also similar to that of giant molecular
Fig. 11. Histograms of the mass of clusters (in log Mcl)
with an age of 10 Myrs or younger. The light shaded
area shows the distribution of all 354 clusters. The dark
shaded area shows the histogram of clusters with an ac-
curate mass determination of ∆logMcl < 0.25. The steep
part at log(M ) < 3.0 is due to the detection limit. The
decrease at log(M ) > 3.0 reflects the slope of the cluster
IMF. (All masses have to be increased by a factor 2.1 if
the lower limit of the stellar mass is 0.2 M⊙ rather than
the value of 1 M⊙ that was adopted in the Starburst99
models.)
scale of about tens of Myrs. In fact, these authors derived
the dependence of the disruption time on the initial mass
of the clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51 as
log tdisr = log t4 + γ × log(Mcl/104M⊙)
(4)
with log t4 = 7.64 ± 0.22 and γ = 0.62 ± 0.06 for the mass
range of 3 ≤ log(Mcl/M⊙) ≤ 5.2, where Mcl is the initial
mass of the cluster. We see that clusters with an initial
mass larger than 104 M⊙ survive 4 × 107 years. Clusters
with an initial mass of only 103 M⊙ disrupt on a time scale
of 1 × 107 yrs. This implies that the cluster initial mass
function cannot be derived from the total sample of clus-
ters, because the disruption will produce a strong bias to-
wards the more massive clusters. However for the youngest
clusters with ages less than about 10 Myr disruption is not
yet an important effect and, therefore, these clusters can
be used to derive the initial cluster mass function.
Fig. 11 shows the resulting mass distribution of clus-
ters with an age less or equal to 10 Myr for two sam-
ples of clusters. The first sample contains all 354 clusters
younger than 10 Myr. The second sample contains 168
clusters in the same age range but with a mass deter-
mination of ∆ log(Mcl) ≤ 0.25. Both samples show the
same characteristics: a steep increase in number between
2.5 < log Mcl < 3.0 and a slow decrease to higher masses.
The steep increase is due to the detection limit or the dis-
ruption of the low mass clusters. The slow decrease reflects
the cluster initial mass function (CIMF). The decrease in-
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
13
age of the huge starburst in the nucleus of M51. There is
a hint of a small peak around log(t) ≃ 8.1. However this
peak is only 2σ high. Its reality has to be verified with a
larger sample of clusters.
(d) The peak in the last bin of 5 Gyr contains all the
clusters ages older than 3 Gyr, because the cluster models
that we used for fitting the energy distributions do not
go beyond 5 Gyr.
We have checked that these characteristics are not the
result of the binning process: the same features appear
for different choices of the binning parameters.
The general decrease in the formation rate of the ob-
served clusters is partly due to the evolutionary fading of
the clusters and partly due to the disruption of clusters.
In Sect. 6 and in Fig. 10 we have shown that clusters with
an initial mass of 104 M⊙ fade below the detection limit
when they are older than log(t) = 8.2. This can explain
the decrease in the formation rate of clusters older than
about 150 Myrs. However, clusters with Mcl > 104 M⊙
and younger than about 100 Myr should still all be de-
tectable. The fact that we see a decrease in the apparent
cluster formation rate must thus be due to the disruption
of clusters (unless for some unknown reason the cluster
formation rate has been steadily increasing from 100 Myrs
up to now, which we consider unlikely).
It is interesting that the CFR in the inner spiral arms
of M51, at a distance of about 1 to 3 kpc from the nu-
cleus, does not show any evidence for a peak at the age
of the strongest interaction of M51 with its companion
galaxy. The closest approach occurred about 250 - 400
Myrs ago according to the dynamical models of Barnes
(1998) or 400-500 and 50-100 Myrs ago according to Salo
& Laurikainen (2000). The only significant peak occurred
at log(t) ≃ 7.4. However we attributed this peak to the
large changes in the energy distributions of the models in
the age range of 6.5 < log(t) < 7.5, and not to a real
increase in the CFR.
9. Summary and conclusions
We have studied images of the inner spiral arms of the
interacting galaxy M51 obtained with the HST −W F P C2
camera in broad-band U BV RI and in the narrow band
Hα and [OIII] filters. The study can be summarized as
follows:
1. We found a total of 877 point-like objects, which are
probably clusters. Many of the clusters are strong
Hα emitters, but none of the clusters, not even the
youngest ones, have an excess of radiation in the [OIII]
line at 5007 A (F 502N -filter). This suggests that the
upper mass limit of the stars in the clusters is about
25 to 30 M⊙.
2. We have compared their energy distributions with
those of Starburst99 cluster models (Leitherer et al.
1999) for instantaneous star formation with a stellar
IMF of exponent 2.35, solar metallicity, a lower and
Fig. 12. The cumulative mass distribution of 149 clus-
ters with an age less than 10 Myrs and an inital mass of
log(M ) > 3.40. The full line is the best power-law fits for
an IMF with the value of α and Mmin from Table 3. The
dashed line is the fit with α = 2.00.
clouds (e.g. McKee 1999; Myers 1999). This may support
the suggestion that the mass distribution of the clusters
is determined by the mass distribution of the clouds from
which they originate.
8. The cluster formation history
One of the goals of this paper is to study the influence
of the interaction between M51 and its companion on the
cluster formation in the region of the inner spiral arms.
To this purpose we compare the observed age distribution
of the clusters with predictions for a constant cluster for-
mation rate. This comparison is hampered by two effects:
(a) the disruption of clusters and (b) the fading of clus-
ters below the detection limit. The disruption time of the
clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51 is given by Eq.
(4). We see that only clusters with an initial mass larger
than about 104 M⊙ will survive more than 40 Myrs.
Figure 13 shows the histogram of the formation rates of
the detected clusters, in number per Myr, for 140 clusters
with Mcl > 104 M⊙ and with an energy distribution that
is fitted with an accuracy of χ2
ν ≤ 3.0. The sample of 111
clusters with Mcl > 104 M⊙ and with an age uncertainty
of ∆ log(t) < 0.25, and the full sample of 285 clusters with
Mcl > 104 M⊙, not shown here, have a distribution very
similar to the one shown in Fig. 12.
All three samples show about the same characteristics.
(a) There is a general trend of a decrease in the cluster
formation rate towards increasing age.
(b) There is a steep drop around log(t) ≃ 7.5. This
drop is the result of the concentration of clusters at ages
log(t) = 7.45 that was apparent in the mass versus age
diagrams of Fig. 10, and was explained in Sect. 6.
(c) There is no clear evidence for a peak in the cluster
formation rate near log(t) ≃ 8.6, which is the time of the
interaction of M51 with its companion, and which is the
14
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
6. We have analysed the observed clusters also with clus-
ter models of higher metallicity, Z = 2 × Z⊙. These
higher metallicity models fit the observations consid-
erably worse than the solar metallicity models. For in-
stance, for solar metallicity models the energy distri-
bution of 294 clusters can be fitted with an accuracy
of χ2
ν ≤ 3.0. For models with
twice the solar metallicity these numbers are respec-
tively 138 and 217. So the energy distributions of the
clusters support the adopted solar metallicity.
ν ≤ 1.0 and 392 with χ2
7. The clusters have masses in the range of 2.5 <
log(Mcl) < 5.7 and ages of log(t) > 5.0. These masses
are the initial masses of the clusters, i.e. the current
mass corrected for stellar evolution effects, but not
corrected for evaporation or disruption. All derived
masses have to be multiplied by a factor 1.3 if the lower
mass of the stars is 0.6 M⊙, instead of the adopted 1
M⊙, and by a factor 2.1 if the lower mass is 0.2 M⊙,
as found for the Orion Nebula cluster.
8. The distribution of the clusters in a mass-versus-age
diagram shows the predicted lower limit due to the
evolutionary fading of the clusters, including the dips
at log(t) ≃ 6.8 and 7.1. Three apparent concentrations
at log(t) = 6.7, 7.2 and 7.45 are not real but due to
the properties of the cluster models used.
9. About 60% of the clusters are younger than 40 Myr.
The number of older clusters is much less than ex-
pected for a constant cluster formation rate. This is
partly due to the evolutionary fading of low mass clus-
ters below the detection limit, and partly due to the
disruption of the clusters.
10. The cluster initial mass function (CIMF) was de-
rived from the cumulative mass distribution of clusters
younger than 10 Myr, for which disruption has not oc-
cured. The CIMF has a slope of α = 2.1 ± 0.3 in the
range of 3.0 < log(Mcl) < 5.0 and α = 2.00 ± 0.05 in
the range of 3.0 < log(Mcl) < 4.5 M⊙, for N (Mcl) ∼
−α. This slope is the same to that found in the
Mcl
interacting Antennae galaxies (Zhang & Fall 1999).
Zhang and Fall deived a power law slope of the CIMF
of α = 1.95 ± 0.03 and 2.00 ± 0.04 for two cluster sam-
ples of the Antennae galaxies. The good agreement
between these slopes and the one found by us suggests
that α is about the same for cluster formation triggered
by strong galaxy-galaxy interactions, such as presently
going on in the Antennae, as for cluster formation that
is not dominated by the interactions.
11. The age distribution of clusters with Mcl > 104 M⊙,
is used to derive the history of the cluster formation
rate (CFR). There is a general trend of a decrease of
the formation rate of the observed clusters with age. It
is unlikely that the real CFR has been increasing con-
tinuously from about 1 Gyr to the present time. The
decrease of the CFR with age of clusters younger than
about 100 Myr cannot be due to evolutionary fading,
but it is due to the disruption of clusters. For clusters
older than 200 Myr the decrease of the derived CFR
could, at least partly, be due to evolutionary fading.
Fig. 13. The formation rates of the observed clusters with
an initial mass of Mi > 104 M⊙ in number per Myr, for
clusters with an accuracy of the fit of the energy distribu-
tion of χ2
ν ≤ 3.0. The 1σ uncertainty due to the Poisson
statistics in each bin (σ = 1/p(N )) is indicated. The
diagram shows that the formation rate of the observed
clusters decreases with age. This is due to the disruption
of the older clusters.
upper stellar mass limit of 1 M⊙ and 30 M⊙ respec-
tively. The energy distributions were also compared
with those of the Frascati models (Romaniello 1998).
For clusters younger than 700 Myr the results from
the fitting with the Starburst99 models were adopted
because these models are more accurate for young clus-
ters and the fits of the energy distributions are better
than those of the Frascati models. For older clusters
the results from the fits with the Frascati models were
adopted.
3. For clusters that were observed in four or five bands
a three dimensional maximum likelihood method was
used to derive the properties of the clusters from the
comparison between the observed and predicted energy
distributions. The free parameters are the age t and
E(B − V ), which together determined the shape of the
energy distribution, and the initial cluster mass Mcl
which determines the absolute magnitude. For clus-
ters that were not observed in all bands, the empiri-
cally derived lower magnitudes limits were taken into
account.
4. For clusters that were observed in only three bands the
age and mass were derived in a two-dimensional maxi-
mum likelihood fitting of the energy distributions, with
t and Mcl as free parameters. The observed probabil-
ity distribution of E(B − V ) was used as a weighting
factor in the fitting procedure.
5. The histogram of E(B − V ) is strongly peaked at very
small E(B − V ) ≃ 0. All cluster have a reddening
smaller than E(B − V ) < 1.0 and 67 % of the clusters
have E(B − V ) < 0.18.
A. Bik, H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, N. Bastian et al.: Clusters in the inner spiral arms of M51
15
Lamers, H.J.G.L.M., Panagia, N., Scuderi, S. et al. 2002, ApJ
566, 818
Leitherer, C., Schaerer, D., Goldader, J.D. et al. 1999, ApJS
123, 3
Lejeune, T., Buser, R., & Cuisinier, F. 1997, A&AS, 99, 173
McKee, C.F. 1999, in "The origin of stars and planetary sys-
tems", C.J. Lada & N.D. Kylafis (eds.), (Dordrecht: Kluwer
Acad. Publ.), 29
Millard, J., Branch, D., Hatano, K., et al. 1999, ApJ, 527, 746
Myers, P.C. 1999, in "The origin of stars and planetary sys-
tems", C.J. Lada & N.D. Kylafis (eds.), (Dordrecht: Kluwer
Acad. Publ.), 67
Panagia, N. 2000, in "The Chemical Evolution of the Milky
Way", eds. F. Matteucci & F. Giovannelli, (Dordrecht:
Kluwer Acad. Publ.), 495
Romaniello, M. 1998 PhD. Thesis: Young stellar Populations
in the Large Magelanic Cloud; surprises from HST obser-
vations, Scuola Normale Superiore di Pisa
Salo, H., & Laurikainen, E. 2000, MNRAS 319, 377
Schmutz, W., Leitherer, C., & Gruenwald, R. 1992, PASP 104,
1164
Schweizer, F. 1998,
in "Galaxies: Interactions and Induced
Star Formation", eds. R.C. Kennicutt, F. Schweizer, J.E.
Barnes, Saas Fee Advanced Course 26, (Berlin: Springer
Verlag), 105
Scuderi, S., Panagia, N., Capetti, A., et al. 2002, ApJ in press
Stetson, P.B. 1987, PASP 99, 191
Toomre, A., & Toomre, J. 1972, ApJ 178, 623
Voit, M. 1997, HST Data Handbook, Space Telescope Science
Institute
Whitmore, B.C., & Heyer, I. 1997, WFPC2 ISR 97-08, Space
Telescope Science Institute
Whitmore, B.C., Zhang, Q., Leitherer, C. et al. 1999, AJ 118,
1551
Zhang, Q., & Fall, S.M. 1999, ApJ 527, L81
12. There is no evidence for a peak in the CFR at about
400 Myr, which is the time of the interaction of M51
with its companion and the age of the huge starburst
in the nucleus.
In a forthcoming paper we describe the cluster forma-
tion as a function of location in a large part of M51, using
the same methods as used here (Bastian et al. 2002). The
disruption of clusters in M51, derived from the results of
the study presented here, are described by Boutloukos &
Lamers (2002).
10. Acknowledgement
H.J.G.L.M.L. and N.B. are grateful to the Space Telescope
Scence Institute for hospitality and financial support dur-
ing several stays. We thank Claus Leitherer for help
and advice in the calculation of the cluster models.
Support for the SINS program GO-9114 was provided
by NASA through a grant from the Space Telescope
Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of
Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc. under NASA
contract NAS 5-26555. N.B. ackowledges a grant from
the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research. We
thank the unknown referee for constructive comments that
resulted in an improvement of this paper.
References
Allen, C.W. 1976, Astrophysical Quantities, (London: the
Athlone Press), p. 247
Athanassoula, E., Bosma, A., & Papaioannou, P. 1987, A&A
179, 23
Barnes, J.E. 1998,
in "Galaxies: Interactions and Induced
Star Formation", eds. R.C. Kennicutt, F. Schweizer, J.E.
Barnes, Saas Fee Advanced Course 26, (Berlin: Springer
Verlag), 275
Bastian, N.R., & Lamers, H.J.G.L.M. 2002 (in preparation)
Boutloukos, S.G., & Lamers, H.J.G.L.M. 2002, MNRAS (ac-
cepted)
Brocato, E., & Castellani, V. 1993, ApJ 410, 99
Cassisi, S., Castellani, V., & Straniero, O. 1994, A&A 282, 753
Chiosi, C., & Maeder, A. 1986, ARA&A, 24, 329
Diaz, A.I., Terlevich, E., Vilchez, J.M., Pagel, B.E.J., &
Edmunds, M.G. 1991, MNRAS, 253, 245
Feldmeier, J.J., Ciardullo, R., & Jacoby, G.H. 1997, ApJ 479,
231
Hernquist, L. 1990,
in "Dynamics and Interactions of
Galaxies", R. Wielen (ed.), (Berlin: Springer Verlag), 108.
Hill, J. K., Waller, W.H., Cornett, R.H. et al. 1997, ApJ 477,
673
Hillenbrand, L.A. 1997, AJ 113, 1733
Holtzman, J.A., Burrows, C.J., Casertano, S. et al. 1995, PASP
107, 156
Kennicutt, R.C. 1998, in "Galaxies: Interactions and Induced
Star Formation", eds. R.C. Kennicutt, F. Schweizer, J.E.
Barnes, Saas Fee Advanced Course 26, (Berlin: Springer
Verlag), 1
Kurucz, R.L. 1993, Kurucz CD-ROM 13, ATLAS9 Stellar
Atmosphere Programs and the 2 km s−1 grid (Cambridge:
SAO)
|
astro-ph/0310071 | 1 | 0310 | 2003-10-02T20:06:29 | GALICS III: Predicted properties for Lyman Break Galaxies at redshift 3 | [
"astro-ph"
] | This paper illustrates how mock observational samples of high-redshift galaxies with sophisticated selection criteria can be extracted from the predictions of GALICS, a hybrid model of hierarchical galaxy formation that couples the outputs of large cosmological simulations and semi-analytic recipes to describe dark matter collapse and the physics of baryons respectively. As an example of this method, we focus on the properties of Lyman Break Galaxies at redshift 3. With the MOMAF software package described in a companion paper, we generate a mock observational sample with selection criteria as similar as possible to those implied in the actual observations of z = 3 LBGs by Steidel et al.(1995). Our model predictions are in good agreement with the observed number density and 2D correlation function. We investigate the optical/IR luminosity budget as well as several other physical properties of LBGs and find them to be in general agreement with observed values. Looking into the future of these LBGs we predict that 75% of them end up as massive ellipticals today, even though only 35% of all our local ellipticals are predicted to have a LBG progenitor. In spite of some shortcomings, this new 'mock observation' method clearly represents a necessary first step toward a more accurate comparison between hierarchical models of galaxy formation and real observational surveys. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 1 -- ?? (2003)
Printed 18 June 2018
(MN LATEX style file v2.2)
GALICS III : Predicted Properties for Lyman Break
Galaxies at redshift 3
J´er´emy Blaizot1,2, Bruno Guiderdoni1, Julien E. G. Devriendt2,1,
Fran¸cois R. Bouchet1, Steve J. Hatton1, and Felix Stoehr3
1 Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris, 98 bis boulevard Arago, 75014 Paris, France.
2 Oxford University, NAPL, Keble Road, Oxford OX1 3RH, United Kingdom.
3 Max-Planck-Institut fur Astrophysik, Karl-Schwarzschild-Str. 1, 85741 Garching, Germany.
ABSTRACT
This paper illustrates how mock observational samples of high -- redshift galaxies with
sophisticated selection criteria can be extracted from the predictions of galics, a
hybrid model of hierarchical galaxy formation that couples the outputs of large cos-
mological simulations, and semi -- analytic recipes to describe dark matter collapse, and
the physics of baryons respectively. As an example of this method, we focus on the
properties of Lyman Break Galaxies at redshift z ∼ 3 (hereafter LBGs) in a ΛCDM
cosmology. With the momaf software package described in a companion paper, we
generate a mock observational sample with selection criteria as similar as possible to
those implied in the actual observations of z ∼ 3 LBGs by Steidel et al. (1995). We
need to introduce an additional "maturity" criterion to circonvene subtle effects due
to mass resolution in the simulation. We predict a number density of 1.15 arcmin−2 at
R ≤ 25.5, in good agreement with the observed number density 1.2 ±0.18 arcmin−2.
Our model allows us to study the efficiency of the selection criterion to capture z ∼ 3
galaxies. We find that the colour contours designed from models of spectrophotomet-
ric evolution of stellar populations are able to select more "realistic" galaxies issued
from models of hierarchical galaxy formation. We quantify the fraction of interlopers
(12 %), and the selection efficiency (85%), and we give estimates of the cosmic vari-
ance. We then study the clustering properties of our model LBGs. They are hosted
by halos with masses ∼ 1.6 × 1012M⊙, with a linear bias parameter that decreases
with increassing scale from b = 5 to 3. The amplitude and slope of the 2D correlation
function is in good agreement with the data. We investigate a series of physical prop-
erties: UV extinction (a typical factor 6.2 at 1600 A), stellar masses, metallicities, and
Star Formation Rates, and we find them to be in general agreement with observed
values. The model also allows us to make predictions at other optical and IR/submm
wavelengths, that are easily accessible though queries to a web interfaced relational
database. Looking into the future of these LBGs, we predict that 75 % of them end
up as massive ellipticals and lenticulars today, even though only 35 % of all our local
ellipticals and lenticulars are predicted to have a LBG progenitor. In spite of some
shortcomings that come from our simplifying assumptions and the subtle propagation
of mass resolution effects, this new 'mock observation' method clearly represents a
first step toward a more accurate comparison between hierarchical models of galaxy
formation and real observational surveys.
Key words: galaxies:high-redshift - galaxies:formation - galaxies:evolution - astro-
nomical data bases:miscellaneous
1
INTRODUCTION
Models of hierarchical galaxy formation are now sophisti-
cated enough to produce a host of predictions for the statis-
tical properties of local and high -- redshift galaxies. These
models have to be tested against observational samples.
However, such a comparison is not as straightforward as
it might appear at first glance, because observations are af-
fected by selection criteria and observational biases. The dif-
ficulty of the comparison is enhanced for samples of high --
redshift galaxies that are selected only on the basis of their
2
Blaizot et al.
apparent magnitudes and colours, that is, according to prop-
erties that are far from the dynamical quantities models of
galaxy formation deal with. In such a case, it is not easy to
track back the propagation of the selection criteria and ob-
servational biases to the "model" parameter space. At this
stage, the best method consists in putting model predictions
into the "observation" parameter space, by producing mock
galaxy samples that are obtained with selection criteria and
observational biases as close as possible to those that affect
the real observational samples.
This paper uses the predictions of the galics model of
hierarchical galaxy formation (for Galaxies in Cosmological
Simulations) that embodies the so -- called "hybrid approach"
by coupling the description of dark matter collapse by means
of cosmological N -- body simulations, and the description of
the physics of baryons with semi -- analytic recipes, including
the estimate of spectral energy distributions in the UV to
sub-millimetre wavelength range (Hatton et al. (2003), here-
after galics i, and Devriendt et al. (2003), hereafter gal-
ics ii). We use the momaf package (for Mock Map Facility)
described in Blaizot et al. (2003) (hereafter momaf) to pro-
duce mock observing cones from which mock samples can
be extracted, with selection criteria and biases that mimic
those of actual observations.
We hereafter illustrate such a method by addressing the
constraints put on models by the so -- called Lyman Break
Galaxies (hereafter LBGs) at redshift z ∼ 3 (Steidel et al.
1996). These galaxies are obtained using the UV drop --
out technique, first employed for the selection of distant
galaxies by Steidel & Hamilton (1993), that simply relies
on the shift of the Lyman break through broad -- band fil-
ters. This break, being mainly due to the absorption of
the UV photons by the Hi of the intergalactic medium
(IGM), is roughly independent from the galaxies' intrinsic
properties, thus allowing the efficient selection of a com-
plete sample of luminous galaxies at a given redshift, with
photometry in only three broad -- band filters. In the last
years, this technique has led to a tremendous increase in
the number of observed objects at z ∼ 3. Although the
set of data is impressively large today, compared to only
a few years ago, a theoretical picture has not yet clearly
emerged. This is mainly due to a poor understanding of
the interplay of star formation, feedback and extinction
on cosmological scales within hierarchical clustering, and
also to the difficulty to compare "unbiased" and "noiseless"
theoretical work with "corrected -- for -- everything" data. In
spite of these difficulties, the predictions of the properties
of LBGs obtained from semi -- analytic models of hierarchi-
cal galaxy formation (Baugh et al. (1998), Somerville et al.
(2001), Idzi et al. (2003)) or fully numerical approaches
(Nagamine (2002), Weinberg et al. (2002)) are encouraging.
We hereafter produce a mock sample of z ∼ 3 LBGs
from our model of hierarchical galaxy formation, by apply-
ing selection criteria and observational biases that are as
similar as possible to those involved in the definition of the
data gathered by Steidel et al. (1996). The comparison of
our mock sample with the actual sample has a three -- fold
interest. First, it helps us to explore the selection criteria
with a plausible model of galaxy formation, whereas the UV --
drop out technique has been primarily designed within the
paradigm of monolithic galaxy formation. This allows us to
get some insight on the efficiency of the selection criteria to
capture bona fide galaxies at z ∼ 3, as well as to assess the
number of interlopers, that is, of galaxies that pass through
the criteria, but are not at the target redshift z ∼ 3. In addi-
tion we study the field -- to -- field cosmic variance. Second, we
compare predictions of our model of hierarchical galaxy for-
mation with observational properties. Since galics has spe-
cific features such as spatial information, multi -- wavelength
predictions from the (rest-frame) UV to sub-mm, and hier-
archical information on the merging history trees, we can
address questions such as clustering, optical/IR luminosity
budget, and current descendants of z ∼ 3 LBGs. Third, our
predictions can be used as an educated guideline for exten-
sive follow -- up observations of LBGs at other optical and
IR/submm wavelengths. The overall agreement of the pre-
dictions with the data, in spite of obvious shortcomings, en-
courages us to think that the picture of hierarchical galaxy
formation implemented in our galics model gives a good de-
scription of optically -- bright, star forming galaxies at z ∼ 3.
We note however that not all galaxies at this redshift are
correctly reproduced by galics.
This paper is the third in the galics series after pa-
per I (galics i) that presented the global features of our
model and a set of properties for local galaxies, and paper
II (galics ii) that showed predictions for hierarchical galaxy
evolution between redshifts 0 and 3. It is also an illustration
of the generic method of mock map making detailed in mo-
maf. Predictions of faint galaxy counts and 2D clustering
for the global population will be given in forthcoming paper
IV (Devriendt et al. 2003b, hereafter galics iv), and paper
V (Blaizot et al. 2003b, hereafter galics v) respectively.
These five galics papers, together with the momaf pa-
per, complete the presentation of the first version of the
galics project. Results of the model, as well as extensive
follow -- up predictions at many optical and IR/submm wave-
lengths, are publicly available from a web interfaced rela-
tional database located at the URL http://galics.iap.fr.
This paper is organised as follows. Section 2 gives a brief
summary of the features of galics and momaf that are rel-
evant for this study. The selection criteria are applied to our
mock observing cone in section 3, where we explore various
aspects of the UV -- drop out technique. Section 4 gives pre-
dictions for the cosmic variance, and compares the predicted
clustering with observational data. The UV to IR luminos-
ity budget is studied in section 5, where we try to clarify
the controversial issue of extinction in LBGs from a theo-
retical point of view. An attempt to elucidate the nature of
LBGs, and their fate at the present time within the context
of hierarchical clustering, is given in section 6. Finally, sec-
tion 7 gives a summary of the results, and discusses their
robustness in light of the shortcomings of the method.
2 SIMULATING OBSERVATIONS
2.1 A brief summary of the galics model
galics is a model of hierarchical galaxy formation which
combines high-resolution cosmological simulations to de-
scribe the dark matter content of the Universe with semi-
analytic prescriptions to deal with the baryonic matter. This
hybrid approach is fully described in galics i and galics ii,
so we only briefly recall its main characteristics hereafter.
GALICS III : Predicted Properties for LBGs at z ∼ 3
3
2.1.1 Dark matter simulation
The cosmological N-body simulation we refer to through-
out this paper was carried out using the parallel tree-
code developed by Ninin (1999). We use a flat Cold Dark
Matter model with a cosmological constant (Ωm = 0.333,
ΩΛ = 0.667). The simulated volume is a cube of side
Lbox = 100h−1
100 = 0.667, containing 2563
particles of mass 8.3 × 109M⊙, with a smoothing length of
29.29 kpc. The power spectrum was set in agreement with
the present day abundance of rich clusters (σ8 = 0.88), and
we followed the DM density field from z = 35.59 to z = 0,
outputting 100 snapshots spaced logarithmically in the ex-
pansion factor.
100Mpc, with h−1
On each snapshot we use a friend-of-friend algorithm
to identify virialised groups of more than 20 particles, thus
setting the minimum dark matter halo mass to 1.66 × 1011
M⊙. We compute a set of properties of these haloes, includ-
ing position and velocity of the centre of mass, kinetic and
potential energies, and spin parameter. Assuming a singu-
lar isothermal sphere density profile for our virialised dark
matter haloes, we then compute their virial radius, enforcing
conservation of mass and energy.
Once all the haloes are identified in each snapshot,
we compute their merging history trees, following the con-
stituent particles from one output to the next. The merging
histories we obtain are by far more complex than in semi-
analytic approaches as they include evaporation and frag-
mentation of haloes. The way we deal with these is described
in details in galics i.
2.1.2 Baryonic prescriptions
When a halo is first identified, it is assigned a mass of hot
gas, assuming a universal baryon to dark matter mass ratio
(ΩB/Ω0 = 0.135 in our fiducial model). This hot gas is as-
sumed to be shock heated to the virial temperature of the
halo, and in hydrostatic equilibrium within the dark matter
potential well. The comparison of the cooling time of this
gas to its free-fall time, as a function of the radius, yields
the mass of gas that can cool to a central disc during a
time-step. The size of this exponential disc is given by con-
servation of specific angular momentum during the gas infall
and scales linearly with the spin parameter of the halo. Cold
gas is then transformed into stars at a rate inversely propor-
tional to the dynamical timescale, with a constant efficiency
β−1. Newly formed stars are distributed according to the
Kennicutt (1983) initial mass function (IMF). These stars
are then evolved between timesteps, using a sub-stepping
of at most 1 Myr. During each sub-step, a fraction of the
stars explode as supernovae, releasing metals into the ISM.
Energy is also released, which heats the ISM and may blow
part of it away into the IGM, with some efficiency ǫ.
When two haloes merge, the galaxies they contain are
placed in the descendant halo. Their initial radial positions
in this new halo are obtained through a perturbation of
the final radial positions they had in each of the progenitor
haloes. Due to subsequent dynamical friction or satellite-
satellite encounters, galaxies can then merge in their new
host halo. When such events occur, a 'new' galaxy is then
created (which is the descendant of the two progenitor galax-
ies that have merged) and the stellar and gaseous contents
of its three components (disc, bulge and starburst) are de-
duced from those of its two progenitors using a single free
parameter χ. Note that the descendant galaxy can either
become elliptical (in shape) or retain a large disc depending
on the mass ratio of its progenitors. After a merging, pro-
vided gas is available, a nuclear starburst is assumed to take
place at the centre of the 'new' galaxy. The radius of this
burst is fixed to be κ times the radius of the 'new' bulge.
The spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of our mod-
elled galaxies are computed by summing the contributions of
all the stars they contain, according to their age and metal-
licity, both of which we keep track of in the simulation. Ex-
tinction is computed assuming a random inclination for disc
components, and the emission of dust is added to the ex-
tinguished stellar spectra in a similar way as prescribed in
the stardust code (Devriendt et al. 1999). Finally, a mean
intergalactic medium (IGM) extinction correction is imple-
mented following the procedure described in Madau (1995),
before we convolve the SEDs with the desired observer frame
filters (see momaf).
Thus our model depends only on a few free parameters,
which are given the standard values quoted in galics i and
galics ii, namely, β−1 = 0.02, ǫ = 0.1, χ = 3.333, κ = 0.1.
As it is explained in galics i, the other two free parameters
(the normalisation ψ of the frequency of satellite -- satellite
encounters, and the efficiency ζ for the recycling of metals
ejected into the intergalactic "reservoir") only have a minor
role.
2.2 Resolution effects
The mass resolution of the N-body DM simulation we use
has important repercussions on the statistical and physical
properties of our modelled galaxies. We outline the main two
effects below.
2.2.1 Magnitude completeness limit
The mass resolution of the N-body simulation is, for our
concerns, the minimum mass of a halo, that is, the mass of
20 particles (∼ 1.6× 1011 M⊙). It is the mass of the smallest
structure in which we may form a galaxy. This halo mass
corresponds to a galaxy mass Mres = 2.2×1010M⊙ assuming
that all the gas in the halo can cool. Galaxies with a mass
higher than this cannot exist in unresolved haloes, and our
sample of such galaxies is thus complete. On the contrary,
galaxies with a lower mass can (and do) exist, but our sample
is not complete since we miss all those that would lie in
unresolved haloes.
It is useful to convert this completeness limit in terms
of magnitudes in order to understand in which range of lu-
minosity our predictions are reliable (e.g. for the luminosity
functions in section 5.1). To do this, we plot the absolute
rest-frame UV magnitude at 1600A (internal dust absorp-
tion included) versus the total baryonic mass of galaxies in
Fig. 1, directly from the z = 3 simulation snapshot. Note
that the large scatter on this plot is due to the fact that at
this wavelength, we see the combined effects of most recent
star formation and dust extinction, which are poorly corre-
lated with the total mass of stars. We define the magnitude
completeness limit M res
AB (1600) so that 90% of the galaxies
4
Blaizot et al.
Figure 1. Absolute AB magnitudes of z = 3 galaxies at rest-
frame 1600 A as a function of baryonic mass. The absolute mag-
nitudes take into account dust absorption. The vertical line indi-
cates our mass resolution, Mres = 2.2 1010M⊙, above which our
sample of galaxies is complete. The horizontal line represents our
completeness limit in terms of magnitude so that galaxies brighter
than M res
AB (1600) = −20.3 also form a complete sample.
brighter than M res
AB (1600) have a mass greater than Mres.
As shown in Fig. 1, we expect our sample of galaxies brighter
than M res
AB (1600) = −20.3 to be complete at z ∼ 3.
The magnitude completeness limit of our simulation is
thus comparable to the detection limit for Steidel's sample
of LBGs (absolute magnitude R ≤ −20.2 in our ΛCDM
cosmology), which allows us to compare our results with
their data.
2.2.2 History resolution
A more subtle effect of resolution is that missing small struc-
tures means missing part of our halo merging histories. As
a matter of fact, the impact on our modelled galaxies is
twofold :
• we miss small galaxy mergers because galaxies close to
the resolution limit are formed smoothly in haloes at the
resolution limit, instead of assembled through mergers of
smaller objects that would have populated smaller progeni-
tor haloes;
• we cool too much gas in too short a time on new central
galaxies in haloes at the resolution limit. Had we resolved
their host halo merging histories, part of this cold gas would
have been split between smaller progenitors at earlier times
and partly processed into stars already.
However, the 'observational' signature of this resolution ef-
fect (physical properties, luminosities of galaxies) tends to
disappear after a while. In practice, a galaxy in our standard
N-body simulation needs to evolve for about 1 Gyr before
we can be sure that its properties have converged. This is
irrelevant at z = 0 (resp. z = 1), where only 3 (resp. 69) out
of 19,372 (resp. 19,257) galaxies above the formal resolution
limit MB = −18.9 (resp. MB = −20.2) are younger than
this threshold. However, it becomes problematic at z = 3,
Figure 2. Mock medium deep field, of size 3 × 3 arcmin2, seen
in the R band. Circles mark the position of LBGs which were
selected using the colour and apparent magnitude criteria given
by Eq. 1.
when the age of the Universe is only a couple of gigayears
old and roughly 75% of the galaxies are concerned. As a con-
sequence, we introduce in the following study an additional
free parameter that we call the maturity age tmat, and we
discard from our sample any LBG whose first progenitor is
younger than tmat = 1.1 Gyr at the time when this LBG is
identified as such. As the need for this kind of selection is one
of the most important drawbacks of our study, section 3.2.2
justifies in detail our choice of maturity criterion.
2.3 A typical mock field
Because Lyman Break selection is by definition an observa-
tional selection, it is necessary to apply as similar as possible
criteria to our modelled galaxies sample before attempting a
thorough comparison with the data. We therefore used the
momaf package to simulate light-cones from galics out-
puts, as described in the momaf paper (see also the gal-
ics/momaf web-page http://galics.iap.fr/). Basically,
the method consists in tiling a time sequence of simulation
boxes along a mock line of sight, and computing the appar-
ent properties of galaxies from their positions in this cone-
like geometry. It allows us to use as much of the spatial
information contained in the N-body simulation as possi-
ble in order to produce realistic mock catalogues, which can
then be analysed in the same way as real observations.
In Fig. 2, we show a typical result of this work : a
mock medium deep field of 3 × 3 arcmin2 seen in the R
band (Steidel & Hamilton 1993). The circles indicate LBGs,
which are identified as indicated in section 3.1.
GALICS III : Predicted Properties for LBGs at z ∼ 3
5
3 LBG SELECTION PROCESS
3.1 Colour-colour selection
It is the IGM extinction that makes the Lyman break se-
lection such an efficient technique for selecting high-redshift
galaxies. Galaxy evolution, along with dust absorption in-
side galaxies, also produce a Lyman-break, but its intensity
varies from one galaxy to the next, so that galaxies end up
scattered all over the colour-colour plane and as a result,
colour and redshift would be strongly degenerate. Not only
does the IGM attenuation yield a more pronounced Lyman-
break, but the fact that it is due to material external to the
galaxies makes this break independent from intrinsic prop-
erties of the observed objects, allowing the observer to select
a whole population of "normal" galaxies at z ∼ 3.
For a galaxy at this redshift, the Lyman break falls
between the Un and G filters (Steidel & Hamilton 1993).
It makes the Un − G colour of galaxies very sensitive to
small variations of redshift around this value, as shown by
the very steep slope in the colour-colour diagram of Fig. 3.
This spread of the galaxy distribution along the Un − G axis
leads to a precise selection of galaxies in redshift space. The
colour criteria for selecting objects at z ∼ 3 proposed by
Steidel et al. (1995), which we adopt throughout this paper,
is the following :
≤ 25.5
R
G − R
≤ 1.2
Un − G ≥ G − R + 1
Un − G ≥ 1.6
≥ 0.0.
G − R
(1)
In Fig. 3, we show a colour-colour diagram for a mock
catalogue of 360 arcmin2. Only galaxies with an apparent
AB magnitude lower than 25.5 in the R band are shown, in
order to mimic the detection limit quoted by these authors.
We represent galaxies which have redshifts between 2.7 and
3.4 as diamonds. Galaxies with other redshifts are marked
as simple dots. The colour criterion given by Eq. 1 is shown
as the solid line.
Notice that the distribution of galaxies in the colour-
colour plane is smooth in Fig. 3. This behaviour stems
from distributing galaxies in a mock light-cone, in contrast
with previous studies based on pure semi-analytical models
(Baugh et al. (1998), Somerville et al. (2001)), where galaxy
properties were only computed for a discrete set of time out-
puts.
3.2 Data sets
3.2.1 Observations
Figure 3. (Un − G)-(G − R) diagram, for a mock 360 arcmin2
field. Only galaxies with apparent magnitude RAB ≤ 25.5 are
shown. Diamonds represent galaxies that have their redshift in
the range [2.7; 3.4], and points show galaxies out of this range.
The solid contour shows the colour criteria for LBGs at z ∼ 3
(Eqs. 1) , and the dashed contour shows our optimised contour
for selecting galaxies at z ∼ 3 (section 3.4). Notice the very steep
rise in Un − G around z ∼ 3, mainly due to the IGM attenuation.
Photometric errors are not added in this plot.
the three filters Un, G, and R, designed to efficiently select
objects at z ∼ 3 (Steidel & Hamilton 1993).
A point which is still unclear in the literature so far is
the definition of interlopers. In principle, these are galaxies
which, although selected by the colour criterion, are not at
the requested redshift. In practise, it seems that the defini-
tion which is used by some authors is somewhat less strict,
and objects are only called interlopers when they are galax-
ies at redshifts lower than ∼ 2.3 or stars. We follow suit and
adopt this broader definition but remark that since there
are no foreground stars in our simulation, we do not expect
to find many interlopers (see following section).
We choose to compare our modelled LBGs to the sample
presented by Steidel and co-workers, for both the variety
of results they have published so far (e.g. Giavalisco et al.
(1998), Steidel et al. (1999), Shapley et al. (2001)), and the
large number of sources it contains. The total area surveyed
by these authors amounts to about a thousand arcmin2,
and contains ∼ 1250 LBG candidates (see Giavalisco et al.
(1998), table 1, for a summary of observations). The density
of observed LBGs on the sky is thus about 1.2 object per
square arcminute, among which roughly 20% are estimated
to be interlopers. Most of the observations were made using
3.2.2 Simulations
We use the (Un, G, R) filter set from Steidel & Hamilton
(1993) to compute the apparent magnitudes of our simu-
lated galaxies. Our standard mock catalogue size is 1 deg2,
and contains sources up to z ∼ 6.5. We also use the same
apparent magnitude detection limit, that is, R ≤ 25.5.
As we discuss in momaf, a unique way to build a mock
catalogue from the outputs of our simulation does not ex-
ist, because the mock light-cone intersects only fractions of
each snapshot. We choose to introduce a random process in
6
Blaizot et al.
Figure 4. LBG counts from galics, compared to data from
Giavalisco & Dickinson (2001) (diamonds with error bars). The
solid line and grey area show the mean and 1-σ region obtained
from 20 mock catalogues of 1 square degree in which we applied
the maturity age selection with tmat = 1.1Gyr. The dashed line
shows the LBG number counts for a single cone, without any ma-
turity selection, and the dot-dashed line shows the same counts
with tmat = 1.3 Gyr. The dotted line shows counts from a higher
resolution simulation covering a much smaller volume. Its normal-
isation justifies the value given to tmat (see text for discussion).
the generation of cones in order to be able to make inde-
pendent realisations which are all a priori equally plausible.
Because we do not include fluctuations on scales larger than
the simulated volume, which is about 1 degree at z ∼ 3, the
dispersion of the number of LBGs found in different cones
will yield an under-estimate of the cosmic variance on scales
of one square degree (the size of our cones). We further point
out that the mean LBG count derived from running a large
number of realisation contains the full information available
in the simulation.
We ran 20 different light-cones, and found a mean num-
ber of LBGs < NLBGs >= 4133 per square degree, with a
standard deviation of σNLBGs = 183. The modelled density
of LBGs is thus 1.15 arcmin−2, consistent with the observed
density of 1.22± 0.18 arcmin−2 (e.g. Giavalisco & Dickinson
(2001)). In Fig. 4, we show the mean number counts, ob-
tained from our 20 mock catalogues (solid line), as well as
the dispersion, given at 1-σ by the grey area. Our counts
compare nicely with the data from Giavalisco & Dickinson
(2001), over-plotted as diamonds. Note also that, as in real
observations, we find very few interlopers (about 0.1%) with
z < 2.3. The dashed line shows counts for our modelled
LBGs when we do not apply any maturity selection, and fo-
cus on a single example cone. The difference between these
counts and the solid line shows that the history resolution
mentioned in Sec. 2.2.2 mainly and strongly affects the faint
end of the luminosity function (LF). Our most robust results
thus concern the bright end of the modelled LBGs, where
resolution does not affect galaxy properties. The dot-dashed
line shows the counts for the LBGs which are older than
1.3 Gyr. The dotted line shows the counts obtained from
a mock observing cone of 0.09 square degrees built with a
higher-resolution ΛCDM simulation. This higher-resolution
simulation contains 3203 particles in a cubic volume of side
32h−1Mpc. It has identical cosmological parameters as given
in Sec. 2.1.1, and the galics post-processing was done us-
ing the same astrophysical parameter set as in galics i.
The smaller volume and larger number of particles result in
a galaxy mass resolution Mres = 3.77 × 108M⊙, i.e. ∼ 60
times better resolution than in the fiducial simulation dis-
cussed here. As expected, the introduction of a maturity age
tmat is irrelevant for the LBG counts of this high-resolution
simulation. The faint-end normalisation of the counts sup-
ports our choice of tmat = 1.1 Gyr for our maturity crite-
rion. The discrepancy in the bright counts are understood in
terms of volume limit of the high-resolution simulation : just
from Poisson statistics we expect about 30 times less objects
per bin of luminosity since the volume is reduced by such a
factor compared to the fiducial simulation. Furthermore, we
have to account for cosmic variance which will affect more
dramatically objects that are more clustered (see Sec. 3.5).
Therefore, we cannot consider our high-resolution simula-
tion as representative of the Universe as a whole, and for
this reason, we prefer to use it only to fix the maturity cri-
terion in the larger, low-resolution simulation, and we take
this latter to make extensive predictions.
In the remainder of the paper, except where mentioned,
we will use a single realisation of a mock catalogue. Since
we have no information on how the data might be biased
(cosmic variance), we can choose any of our available cones.
We settle for one which contains NLBGs = 4156, in good
agreement with the data, and close to our mean value.
3.3 Efficiency of the selection
Internal properties of galaxies are not fully eclipsed by the
IGM attenuation, so one cannot expect to extract all the
galaxies at a given redshift, and only these, from a simple
region selection in the colour-colour plane. It is therefore
interesting to define an efficiency of the selection process,
which should account for the fraction of lost galaxies -- that
is, observable galaxies with the right redshift which do not
meet the colour criteria -- and the fraction of interlopers
restricted here to galaxies lying outside the redshift range
[2.7; 3.4]. We therefore define the two following quantities:
• the completeness (C), which is the ratio of the num-
ber of selected galaxies with redshift ∼ 3 to the number of
detectable galaxies (i.e. galaxies with R ≤ 25.5) at z ∼ 3.
• the confirmation rate (CR) which is the ratio of the
number of selected galaxies with z ∼ 3 to the total number
of selected galaxies (with any redshift).
With these two complementary quantities, we can define
a measurement of the efficiency of a selection process as
E = C×CR. This quantity takes values from 0 to 1, 0 mean-
ing no source was detected at the expected redshift, and 1
meaning that all the detectable sources with z ∈ [2.7; 3.4]
were selected, and only these. For our sample of galaxies ex-
tracted from a 1 square degree field, we find the following
values for the colour criteria given by Steidel and co-workers
(eqs 1) : C = 96%, CR = 88%, and E ∼ 85%. This high ef-
ficiency shows that the LBG selection is indeed a very good
method for selecting distant galaxies, and the high complete-
ness shows that this selection grabs 96% of the detectable
galaxies at z ∼ 3.
In an attempt to mimic observations, we also added
photometric errors to our magnitudes. These are simply
GALICS III : Predicted Properties for LBGs at z ∼ 3
7
modelled here as uniformly-distributed random values, be-
tween ±δ mag, in the three bands U, G, R. The selection
efficiency drops to E = 70% when δ reaches 0.25 mags. For
a more conservative error amplitude of 0.1 magnitude, the
efficiency settles around 80%. Obviously, photometric errors
are far more complex than this simple model and should
take into account systematics. Nevertheless, their impact on
LBG selection as assessed by our simple estimate constitutes
a useful first estimate.
3.4 New contour
Until now, the colour selection used to select distant galax-
ies from multi-band imaging observations has been defined
by placing synthetic galaxies, with a 'wide range' of ages,
star formation histories, metallicities, dust content and red-
shifts (e.g. Steidel et al. (1995), Madau et al. (1996)), onto a
colour-colour plane, and by finding out which region encloses
most distant galaxies and fewest interlopers. This method,
although spectroscopic follow-up showed it gives good re-
sults, sweeps under the carpet the question of the nature
of the distant objects. It is expected to be robust anyway
since IGM extinction -- which is external to galaxies -- plays
a dominant role in the location of galaxies in the colour-
colour plane. However, one might wonder whether a tighter
set of criteria could be found if the 'wide range' of properties
was replaced by more 'plausible' properties for galaxies at
a given redshift. We present here the first attempt to build
such criteria with an ab initio model of galaxy formation, in
which distant galaxies' properties come out naturally of the
hierarchical evolution within the dark matter content of the
universe.
We found our best contour in the colour-colour plane
using the downhill simplex method (Press et al. 1992) in or-
der to maximise the efficiency of the LBG-selection for a
pentagonal contour with two sides bound to be vertical, and
one horizontal in the (Un − G; G − R) plane. For this max-
imisation, we used our full fiducial catalogue of one square
degree so as to have a significant number of LBGs. The con-
tour we calculate is the following :
Un − G ≥ 1.7,
G − R ≥ −0.2,
G − R ≤ 1.9,
Un − G ≥ 0.9(G − R) + 1.1,
Un − G ≤ 0.6(G − R) + 5.1.
This contour (the dashed lines of Fig. 3) gives an effi-
ciency E = 88%, instead of E = 85% for the contour defined
by Eq 1. Our efficiency is higher because we discard a large
fraction of high-z interlopers by setting an upper limit on
the Un − G colour, which increases our confirmation rate to
CR = 95%. However, our contour decreases the complete-
ness (C = 94%), precisely because of this more accurate
selection. In practise, the aim of LBG surveys is twofold :
(i) select a large number of high-z candidates, with redshifts
as high as possible, allowing for a broad redshift range, and
(ii) use the detected galaxies to describe the properties of
'normal' galaxies at a given redshift. In case (i), one wishes
to favour completeness relative to confirmation rate. In the
second case, one wishes to reach a compromise between C
and CR. Bearing this in mind, it is worth pointing out that
our selection is quite similar to that used by Steidel and col-
laborators. This gives the overall impression that the UV-
dropout technique is quite robust, and independent of stellar
population modelling. As mentioned earlier, this robustness
was expected since the locus of galaxies in the colour-colour
plane is mainly given by IGM absorption, and thus by red-
shift.
3.5 Cosmic variance
The degree to which observations of small areas are repre-
sentative of the whole Universe is a crucial question when
one wishes to interpret data in the cosmological context.
Since our model contains spatial information, it is possible
to study the cosmic variance of LBG densities, at least to
a certain extent, because our simulation is volume-limited
and does not include long-wavelength fluctuations.
We estimated the cosmic variance as the field-to-field
variation in the number of LBGs in sub-fields, extracted
from our 20 different 1 deg2 fields. For each size of sub-fields,
ranging from 4 arcmin2 to 1600 arcmin2, we used 20000
random sub-catalogues (1000 per 1 deg2 mock catalogue)
to estimate the mean number of LBGs and the associated
variance.
In table 1 we give the mean numbers of LBGs and the
corresponding standard deviations for fields of 4, 16, 64,400
and 1600 arcmin2. Numbers are given as well for LBGs
brighter than R = 25 and R = 24.5. The fact that the
standard deviation is higher by a factor > 2 to the pois-
sonian deviation is a direct signature of the high clustering
properties of LBGs.
N −σ2
In Fig. 5 we show the variation of the relative devi-
ation (σ/hNi) versus the surface of the mock survey. The
continuous line shows the measured deviation and the dot-
ted line shows the Poissonian prediction. The dashed line
shows the quadratic difference between those : σc/hNi =
(σ2
P oisson)1/2/hNi, where σc is the contribution of clus-
tering to the cosmic variance. The three crosses at 3600
arcmin2 show the total dispersion and the contributions of
clustering and Poisson, from top to bottom. These were es-
timated only from our 20 mock catalogues and thus rely on
less statistics than the curves. On small scales (< 7 arcmin2),
where the sources are rare enough, the Poissonian noise dom-
inates the variance. On larger scales, the variance is domi-
nated by the clustering of LBGs, as the Poissonian variance
falls off more rapidly. As the Universe is homogeneous on
large scales, we expect the clustering contribution to dwin-
dle progressively as the size of the survey increases. This
regime is however out of reach with our current simulation
because the simulated volume has an angular size of ∼ 1
square degree at z ∼ 3. Above this scale we are bound to
under-estimate the dispersion. Because of this, we cannot
tell at the moment whether the points at 3600 arcmin2 in
Fig. 5 are low due to finite volume effect or to the fact that
we reached the point where clustering strength starts to van-
ish.
4 CLUSTERING
The clustering properties of LBGs give important con-
straints on the dynamical processes that drive galaxy for-
8
Blaizot et al.
LBGs
4 arcmin2
64 arcmin2
400 arcmin2
< N > (σN ) < N > (σN ) < N > (σN ) < N > (σN )
16 arcmin2
1600 arcmin2
< N > (σN )
R ≤ 25.5
R ≤ 25.
R ≤ 24.5
4.62 (2.76)
2.71 (1.94)
1.21 (1.20)
18.35 (7.07)
10.74 (4.80)
4.78 (2.74)
73.00 (18.9)
42.74 (12.2)
19.04 (6.69)
454.6 (66.9)
266.1 (42.1)
118.3 (21.4)
1817 (154)
1064 (93.9)
473.1 (46.6)
Table 1. Mean expected numbers of LBGs brighter than R = 25.5, 25 and 24.5, in fields of 4, 16, 64, 400 and 1600 arcmin2. The standard
deviations are also given between brackets. These standard deviations are systematically higher than the square-root of the number of
sources, because of the strong effect of clustering.
Figure 5. Standard deviation in number counts of LBGs as a
function of the survey area in square arcminutes. The solid curve
is the measured standard deviation, and the dotted one is the
Poissonian prediction. The dashed curve shows the quadratic dif-
ference between the measured deviation and the Poissonian one,
namely, the contribution of clustering to the cosmic variance.
mation. Moreover, they can be observed directly and no as-
sumptions are necessary to compute the angular correlation
function. In this section, we show different aspects of the
clustering properties of our modelled LBGs, namely, halo
masses, the location of LBGs in the cosmological simula-
tion, the angular correlation function, the spatial correlation
function, and the bias of LBGs relative to dark matter.
Figure 6. Masses of LBG host haloes as a function of redshift.
The horizontal dotted line shows the median mass value of ∼ 16
1011M⊙.
LBGs
< Mhalo >
(1011M⊙)
R ≤ 25.5
R ≤ 25
R ≤ 24.5
15.8
15.4
14.0
Table 2. Median masses of DM haloes harbouring LBGs.
4.1 Halo masses
4.2 Location of LBGs and their descendants
A first impression of the clustering properties of LBGs can
be given by the mass distribution of the dark matter haloes
which harbour them. In Fig. 6, we show the masses of these
haloes versus the redshifts at which the LBGs are detected
in our simulation. The median halo mass for our LBGs is
15.8 × 1011M⊙, as indicated by the horizontal dotted line.
This mass is about ten times the halo mass resolution of
the simulation. The median values for populations of mod-
elled LBGs with various luminosities are given in table 2.
The relatively large mass of the haloes harbouring our mod-
elled LBGs at z ∼ 3 indicates that these galaxies are highly
biased with respect to the dark matter distribution. This
matches qualitatively what is observed in different surveys
(Giavalisco et al. (1998), Arnouts et al. (2002)).
On the left-hand side panel of Fig. 7, we show the location of
LBGs at z ∼ 3 in a slice of our simulated cosmological vol-
ume. The white discs show LBGs, and the underlying grey
background shows the dark matter density (the darker the
denser), in logarithmic scale. The LBGs are clearly highly
clustered in this picture. The right-hand panel shows the
location of the descendants of LBGs at z = 0 as squares.
Black squares indicating spiral galaxies, and white squares
elliptical or lenticular galaxies. The white discs are ellipti-
cal/lenticular galaxies which do not have a LBG progenitor
at z ∼ 3. The descendants of LBGs are even more highly
clustered than LBGs themselves, as they fell into DM struc-
tures from z = 3 to z = 0. We will come back to the prop-
erties of the descendants of LBGs in section 6.2.
GALICS III : Predicted Properties for LBGs at z ∼ 3
9
Figure 7. Left hand panel : location of LBGs at z=3. White discs show LBGs, and the DM density (in log) is shown in grey scale, the
darker the denser. Right hand panel : location of local ellipticals and the descendants of LBGs in the same comoving volume, at redshift
0. The white symbols show elliptical or lenticular galaxies, the squares indicate descendants of LBGs that are present in the volume of
the left hand side panel. Black squares show spiral descendants of LBGs. The LBGs and their descendants are highly clustered, located
in dense DM regions. The projected volume shown is 150 Mpc on a side, and has a depth of 15 Mpc.
4.3 Angular correlation function
For the computation of the angular correlation function
(ACF), we used the estimator proposed by Landy & Szalay
(1993) (hereafter LS93) :
w(θ) =
DD(θ) − 2DR(θ) + RR(θ)
RR(θ)
,
(2)
where DD(θ) is the number of pairs of LBGs with angular
separation between θ and θ + δθ, RR(θ) is the analogous
quantity for a random catalogue, and DR(θ) the number of
observed-random pairs.
The estimate of the errors in the general case is a dif-
ficult task. Here, we consider Poissonian noise (in the num-
ber of pairs) only. We expect this to be a good approxima-
tion because our survey is large enough (compared to the
scales we probe), and we deal with a rather diluted distribu-
tion of galaxies so that finite-volume errors will be negligible
compared to discreteness errors. Moreover, considering only
Poissonian error-bars implies that we underestimate the real
uncertainties. It is not a concern here as our goal is to show
that our spatial distribution of LBGs is consistent with the
observed one -- and this is the case within Poissonian uncer-
tainties (see next section). Following LS93, we write Poisso-
nian errors as :
σw(θ) =
1 + w(θ)
pNg(Ng − 1)(cid:20) Nr(Nr − 1)
RR
(cid:21)1/2
,
(3)
where Ng is the number of galaxies in our mock survey, and
Nr the number of objects in our random catalogue (here,
Nr ∼ 7 × 104). The first factor in the above equation shows
the Poissonian contribution, as it is inversely proportional
to the square root of the number of LBG pairs. The sec-
ond term is a geometrical contribution, and depends only
on the shape of the survey. In this expression of the stan-
dard deviation, we have assumed that the integral constraint
was negligible. Of course, the standard deviation of Eq. 3
strongly depends on the angular bin-size we use to evaluate
the ACF. This appears only implicitly : if the bin size dou-
bles, RR will also roughly double, and so σw will be divided
by a factor √2. In order to compare our results to those of
Giavalisco et al. (1998), we adopt the same binning as these
authors.
Finally, note that the random transverse shifting of
boxes every 150 comoving Mpc along the line of sight that we
use to suppress replication effects implies an underestimate
of the ACF of about 10% at most, as detailed in momaf.
Our measured ACF is represented in Fig. 8, by crosses
and their error-bars. The solid line shows a maximum likely-
hood fit of a power-law w(θ) = Awθ−β to our data. The best
fit parameters are : Aw = 4.41±0.78 and β = 0.9±0.04. This
is consistent with the results from Giavalisco et al. (1998).
Their fit to observed data is shown in Fig. 8 by the shaded
region1. The vertical dotted line roughly shows the angular
size of a cluster of galaxies at z ∼ 3, below which the con-
tribution to clustering mainly comes from pairs of galaxies
within the same halos. In galics, the positions of galaxies
inside halos are given according to some prescription and
not directly measured from the N-body simulation. Hence
our model only makes reliable predictions for the two-halos
contribution to w(θ).
1 The values from these authors that we consider are those given
by their so-called "LS-random" estimate, which corresponds to
our estimate.
10
Blaizot et al.
Figure 8. Angular correlation function for our sample of LBGs,
extracted from a 1 square degree mock catalogue. The crosses
show our estimate of w(θ) with the LS93 estimator, and the error
bars come from a Poissonian estimate. The grey area shows data
from Giavalisco et al. (1998). This area corresponds to their "LS-
random" estimate, which is similar to ours. The solid line shows a
maximum-likelihood fit to our data by a function w(θ) = Awθ−β,
with best fit values indicated in the panel.
4.4 Spatial correlation function and linear bias
We computed the spatial correlation function (SCF) using
the same estimator (LS93) as for the ACF. This time, how-
ever, we computed the SCF directly from the snapshots of
galics, bypassing the cone of sight generation. We show the
result in Fig. 9. The top panel is the SCF of LBGs identified
in the snapshot at z = 3. The error bars only show the pois-
sonian deviations. The bottom panel shows the linear bias of
LBGs relative to the dark matter particles of the cosmologi-
cal N-body simulation (b2(r) = ξLBG(r)/ξDM (r)). We limit
our plots to the approximate range 1-10 h−1Mpc for two
reasons : (i) we distribute galaxies inside clusters accord-
ing to a semi-analytic spherically symmetric prescription,
so we loose angular information for some galaxies below 1
h−1Mpc, and (ii) to avoid edge effects, we limit the study
to scales below one tenth of the simulated volume size (100
h−1Mpc).
We find that the linear bias slowly decreases from ∼ 5
to ∼ 3 between 0.5 and 20 comoving h−1Mpc. This is com-
patible with the bias estimated by Giavalisco et al. (1998),
Adelberger et al. (1998) and Porciani & Giavalisco (2002).
5 UV/IR LUMINOSITY BUDGET
One of the most important challenges toward understand-
ing galaxy formation is to determine at which epoch stars
formed, or, in other words, how and when did the mass of
stars we see in local Universe galaxies assemble. The ob-
servation of distant galaxies in the optical window is now
known to be insufficient to retrieve star formation rates (e.g.
Devriendt et al. (1999)). The discovery of the cosmic far in-
frared background, and the numerous IR/sub-mm surveys,
have made it clear that dust extinction within galaxies plays
a fundamental role in determining the UV emission of dis-
Figure 9. Top panel : spatial correlation function of our modelled
LBGs in the snapshot corresponding to z=3. Bottom panel : linear
bias of our modelled LBGs with respect to the dark matter.
tant galaxies, and therefore in extracting information on the
cosmic star formation rate. The reason is that the UV lu-
minosity of a galaxy is governed by the amount of recent
star formation -- which is responsible for young massive stars
dominating the energetic part of the SED -- and dust ab-
sorption -- which is most efficient at UV wavelengths, and
re-emits light in the IR/sub-mm domain. Unfortunately, far
infrared or sub-mm instruments do not yet have sensitiv-
ity or resolution which would make a thorough follow-up of
LBGs at large wavelengths possible.
Our model includes a treatment for dust extinction and
emission in the IR/sub-mm domains, which allows us to pre-
dict extinction properties of LBGs, and make the connection
between LBGs, seen in the optical, and sources detected
at IR/sub-mm wavelengths. In this section, we first discuss
the UV luminosity function and selection effects. Second,
we consider the extinction properties of these objects as
predicted by galics. Third, we show how both effects al-
ter the so -- called Madau diagram (Madau et al. 1996). We
eventually make predictions concerning the detectability of
the sub-mm counterparts of LBGs.
5.1 Luminosity functions at z ∼ 3
In Fig. 10, we compare different estimates of our measured
luminosity function (LF) at z ∼ 3 with the LF given by
Steidel et al. (1999).
• The solid histogram shows the LF for all our modelled
LBGs, computed in the same way Steidel et al. (1999) com-
puted their observed LF. First we divide the number of
LBGs in each apparent-magnitude bin by the effective vol-
umes quoted by these authors for our cosmological param-
eters. Then, we convert our apparent magnitudes to abso-
lute magnitudes using the relation Lν = 10−0.4(48.6+mAB ) ×
4πd2
L/(1 + z) where dL = 5.6 1028 h−1cm, is the single value
of the luminosity distance given by Steidel et al. (1999) for
z = 3.04 in a ΛCDM universe (ΩΛ = 0.7, and Ωm = 0.3).
Note that the difference in luminosities induced by using a
single redshift and luminosity distance are negligible when
compared to the uncertainties in the volume corrections.
• The dashed histogram shows the luminosity function of
GALICS III : Predicted Properties for LBGs at z ∼ 3
11
Figure 10. Luminosity functions at z ∼ 3, for LBGs. The x-axis
shows absolute R magnitudes in the observer frame. The black
diamonds show the data from Steidel et al. (1999), converted to
the current cosmology. The solid histogram shows the LF we com-
pute for our sample of LBGs, using the effective volumes given in
Steidel et al. (1999). We assume a single luminosity distance for
the whole sample (also given by Steidel et al. (1999)). This his-
togram is in fair agreement with the data. The dashed histogram
shows the LF computed for all the detectable galaxies (i.e. galax-
ies with R ≤ 25.5) in our sample that have a redshift between
2.7 and 3.4. Here, we normalised the LF to the total volume of
the cone of sight between redshifts 2.7 and 3.4. We also used the
"true" luminosity distance of each galaxy. This LF is lower than
the previous one because of volume corrections. Finally the dotted
histogram shows the true luminosity function of LBGs only, i.e.
without volume corrections. The two vertical dotted lines show
the resolution and detection limits.
all detectable galaxies (R ≤ 25.5) with redshifts between 2.7
and 3.4. This time, we first convert apparent magnitudes to
absolute magnitudes using each galaxy's luminosity distance
and redshift. We then divide the number of objects in each
magnitude bin by the total volume of the cone of sight be-
tween z = 2.7 and z = 3.4, ignoring any volume effect due
to the selection function.
• The dotted histogram is the same as the previous one,
but only includes LBGs. It lies just below the dashed his-
togram in every bin, showing that LBG selection is more or
less equally efficient at all magnitudes.
The resolution and detection limits are shown as dotted ver-
tical lines. The former limit was defined in section 2.2. The
latter is given by Steidel et al. (1999) and corresponds to the
apparent magnitude limit R ≤ 25.5. Our resolution limit is
of the same order.
The solid curve of Fig. 10, which reproduces the analysis
of Steidel et al. (1999), yields a very encouraging match to
the data. At this stage, we remind the reader that in this
paper we use the same galics model that was used in
galics i to reproduce local galaxy properties. It is therefore
an impressive result that we manage to match the observed
luminosity function (or the number counts shown in Fig. 4)
of galaxies at high redshift as well.
In Fig. 11, we show the effect of dust extinction on lu-
minosity functions. The solid histogram on this figure repre-
Figure 11. Effect of dust extinction on the luminosity function
of galaxies at z ∼ 3. The solid histogram shows the LF of all
our modelled LBGs at z ∼ 3, as a function of their apparent R
magnitudes. The dashed histogram is the LF these galaxies would
have if they contained no dust. It was computed directly from the
rest-frame emission of galaxies at 1600A, assuming no extinction.
Finally the dotted histogram presents the same results as the
dashed one but shifted by 2 magnitudes to facilitate comparison
with the solid histogram.
sents the absolute R magnitude (in the observer frame) lu-
minosity function, and includes all our modelled galaxies at
z ∼ 3 (with the usual R ≤ 25.5 criterion on apparent magni-
tude). The dashed histogram corresponds to the luminosity
function of all these galaxies computed directly from their
luminosities at 1600A in the rest-frame, assuming no extinc-
tion. The dotted histogram is the dashed one shifted two
magnitudes fainter to facilitate the comparison with the ex-
tinguished LF (solid histogram). Note that the filters differ
for the two LFs. Indeed, the R filter blue-shifted to z ∼ 3 has
a width ∆λ ∼ 375A and is centred at λR ∼ 1700A, whereas
the filter we used to compute the 1600A emission is centred
at this wavelength (in the galaxy rest-frame), and is a top-
hat function of width 20A. Nevertheless the huge difference
between the two histograms demonstrates how delicate it is
to extract the UV flux really emitted from observed broad
band fluxes. We emphasise that it is this very same UV flux
which is mainly used to compute the cosmic star formation
rate at intermediate and high redshift. Moreover, as a final
note of caution, we stress that even the slopes of the LFs
differ, which means that a unique conversion factor in not
sufficient to accurately correct data for extinction.
5.2 Extinction of LBGs
Obscuration by dust plays a key role for the extraction of
star formation rates from UV observations. Here, we show
how LBGs and other detectable galaxies at z ∼ 3 are af-
fected by this process, and we give the mean extinction fac-
tors predicted by galics for these galaxies.
12
Blaizot et al.
Figure 12. Ratio of IR luminosity (8µm < λ < 1000 µm) to
bolometric luminosity for LBGs (dots) and detectable galaxies
with z ∈ [2.7; 3.4] (crosses) that do not meet the LBG selection
criteria. Most of these galaxies emit more than half their light in
the IR/sub-mm.
5.2.1 Qualitative view
In Fig. 12 we show an estimate of the internal extinction
versus redshift for our sample of LBGs and other galaxies
at z ∼ 3 which are brighter than R = 25.5 (the so-called
'detectable' galaxies). Internal extinction is estimated here
as the ratio of infrared bolometric luminosity (integrated
from 8µm to 1000µm at rest) to bolometric luminosity. A
value of 0.5 of this ratio means that half the light emitted
by stars is absorbed and re-emitted by dust. We find that
∼95% of our LBGs emit more than half their light in the
IR/sub-mm. This fraction of heavily extinguished objects
holds for all detectable galaxies at z ∼ 3. This suggests that
an important contribution of the IR/submm background is
due to z ∼ 3 galaxies.
The fact that missed galaxies (crosses in Fig. 12) lie
on rather narrow redshift bands on either side of z ∼ 3 is
another manifestation of the LBG selection efficiency: fore-
ground galaxies are only missed because of border effects
in the colour-colour plane, whereas background galaxies are
more extinguished on average.
5.2.2 Extinction factor
The usual way to quantify extinction is through the absorp-
tion coefficient A(λ) = k(λ)E(B − V ), where k(λ) is the
adopted attenuation law. In terms of luminosities, this coef-
ficient can be written as
A(λ) = 2.5 log
Lno ext(λ)
Lext(λ)
,
(4)
where Lno ext(λ) is the non-extinguished luminosity at
wavelength λ, and Lext(λ) the extinguished one, computed
for a given inclination of the galaxy. The extinction fac-
tor is then defined by F (λ) = 100.4A(λ), that is, in terms
of luminosities, F (λ) = Lno ext(λ)/Lext(λ). This quantity
is of great importance because it is necessary for the ex-
traction of information about the star formation rates of
LBGs
Fef f (1600)
Fave(1600)
R ≤ 25.5
R ≤ 25
R ≤ 24.5
6.19
6.13
6.21
4.75
4.67
4.83
Table 3. Extinction factors at 1600 A for different sub-
populations of modelled LBGs. The two estimators described by
Massarotti et al (2001) are given for each sub-sample.
distant galaxies. However, its value is still a matter of de-
bate. This is partly due to averaging effects, as emphasised
by Massarotti et al. (2001). Indeed these authors stress that
computing an average extinction factor from an average ab-
sorption coefficient -- namely
Ai(λ)/N = 100.4<A(λ)>,
(5)
where N is the number of galaxies in the sample -- leads to
an underestimate of the effect of dust. They suggest that
one should rather use an effective extinction factor defined
by
Fef f (λ) =
100.4Ai (λ) = 100.4Aef f (λ).
(6)
Fave(λ) = 100.4Pi
1
N Xi
In order to understand the difference between both esti-
mates, it is easier to re-write them in terms of luminosities.
The average extinction factor becomes the geometric mean
Fave(λ) ="Yi
Li
ext(λ) #1/N
no ext(λ)
Li
,
(7)
whereas the effective extinction factor is simply the arith-
metic mean
Fef f (λ) =
1
N Xi
Li
no ext(λ)
Li
ext(λ)
.
(8)
We have computed both factors for our modelled galaxies, in
order to facilitate the comparison with Steidel et al. (1999)
who use Fave(1600) = 4.7, and also to see whether they
give us results which differ by a factor ∼ 3, as claimed by
Massarotti et al. (2001). We summarise our results in table
3. We only find a discrepancy of about a factor 1.3 between
the two estimators, with extinction factors Fef f ∼ 6.2 and
Fave ∼ 4.75. These values are much lower than the value
of 12±2 obtained by Massarroti and co-workers, but their
analysis is based on the Hubble Deep Field only, and in-
cludes galaxies spanning a much wider range of redshifts
than those we consider here. Our average extinction factor
has a value close to that used by Steidel et al. (1999), and
our effective extinction factor is consistent with the detailed
analysis of Adelberger & Steidel (2000) who conclude the
effective extinction should be around a factor ∼ 8.
5.3 Cosmic star formation rate
Another uncertain step in retrieving star formation rates
from UV fluxes is the UV-SFR connection, considering no
absorption (or no dust). This relation is quite sensitive to
the initial mass function (IMF) and we remind the reader
that the IMF in this analysis is the same we used in our
GALICS III : Predicted Properties for LBGs at z ∼ 3
13
LBGs
SFR100/ L(1600)
SFRinst/ L(1600)
R ≤ 25.5
R ≤ 25
R ≤ 24.5
16.7 (3.3)
16.8 (3.6)
16.8 (4.5)
8.94 (2.2)
8.88 (1.1)
8.77 (0.9)
Table 4. SFR to UV luminosity ratios (in M⊙ yr−1 per 1029erg
s−1 Hz−1) computed for different subsamples of our modelled
LBGs. The UV luminosities are computed as if the galaxies con-
tained no dust, that is, with no extinction. In the first column,
the SFR is computed as the mass of stars younger than 100 Myr
divided by 100 Myr. In the second column, the SFR is the in-
stantaneous star formation rate, computed over a Myr only. For
sake of completeness we also give standard deviations between
brackets for each sub-class of LBGs.
fiducial model described in galics i, namely a Kennicutt
(1983) IMF from 0.1 M⊙ to 120 M⊙.
5.3.1 UV/SFR conversion
The first step is to obtain extinction factors, in order to re-
late the observed magnitudes to the UV flux that galaxies
emit prior to extinction. The second step is to make the link
between these extinction-corrected UV luminosities and star
formation rates. This effectively is feasible because massive
stars are the main contributors to the galaxy UV flux and
are sufficiently short-lived. However, star formation rates
have to be averaged over a period of about 100 Myr so that
a robust enough relation may be establish (e.g. Kennicutt
(1998)). In table 4 we give SFR-to-UV luminosity ratios for
different sub-populations of LBGs, whose SFRs are evalu-
ated as the mass of stars younger than 100 Myr, divided by
that period of time. Because of the rapid timescale of stel-
lar evolution, this is an under-estimate of the real SFR, by
about 20% for Kennicutt IMF. We also give ratios computed
using the instantaneous SFR for comparison. Both these es-
timates yield reasonable values because the evolution of the
SFR is generally small over a 100 Myr period and therefore
are consistent with Madau et al. (1996) -- who use a con-
version factor of 9.54 M⊙ yr−1 per 1029erg s−1 Hz−1 -- and
with Kennicutt (1998), who gives a value of 14 M⊙ yr−1
per 1029erg s−1 Hz−1. The ratios we compute, however, are
the result of particular star formation histories: those of our
LBGs. Looking at table 4, one remarks that averaged SFRs
are systematically larger than their instantaneous counter-
parts by about a factor two. This indicates that modelled
LBGs tend to be identified as such when they enter a "post-
starburst" phase.
5.3.2 The cosmic star formation rate history
Following Steidel et al. (1999), we compute the cosmic SFR
at z ∼ 3 from our UV luminosity function. Integrating the
modelled UV LF of LBGs and converting it into a star for-
mation rate density using Table 4, we find ρSF R = 8.9×10−3
M⊙yr−1Mpc−3. Correcting this value for extinction with the
effective factor of Table 3 yields a density ρSF R = 5.5×10−2
M⊙yr−1Mpc−3. The last step is to correct for the missing
faint end of the luminosity function (unresolved galaxies).
Following Steidel et al. (1999), we apply a correction of 0.5
dex and find ρSF R = 0.17 M⊙yr−1Mpc−3, which is con-
sistent with Steidel et al. (1999) and Adelberger & Steidel
(2000).
5.4 Prediction of sub-mm flux
One of the main ambitions and major difficulties of hierar-
chical models of galaxy formation is to reproduce the sub-
mm number counts. Several attempts have been made in
semi-analytic models to fit these observations, but none of
the recipes has yet emerged as a well accepted solution.
Guiderdoni et al. (1998) implemented a massive IMF to ob-
tain SCUBA objects, but there is neither a real physical
motivation for this solution, nor strong observational hints.
Devriendt & Guiderdoni (2000) introduced an ad-hoc red-
shift evolution which did not possess firmer foundations. Fi-
nally, Balland et al. (2003) used a simple yet physically mo-
tivated model to estimate energy exchanges during galaxy
interactions which they propose as the principal mechanism
for triggering starbursts. They show that this solution yields
a good match to mid-IR as well as SCUBA counts. A thor-
ough discussion on this topic will be given in paper 4, but
we forewarn the reader that the fiducial galics model pre-
sented in galics i that we are using for the present study
probably underestimates the cosmic amount of 850 µm light
by a factor ∼2.
In Fig. 13 we show ratios of IR to UV (1600A) lumi-
nosities versus the sum of these luminosities for our mod-
elled LBGs. As a crude approximation, this is equivalent to
"dust absorption" versus "star formation rate". The grey re-
gions broadly indicate the contour of the data analysed by
Adelberger & Steidel (2000), and the solid line shows the
SCUBA detection limit. The good match between obser-
vations and our modelled LBGs suggests that we manage
to compute dust absorption and star formation rates in a
consistent way. We also recover the observed correlation be-
tween star formation and dust content of the galaxies : the
more obscured, the more star-forming. However, we predict
that only about 1 % of our modelled LBGs should be de-
tectable with SCUBA at 850 µm at the 2 mJy level, in agree-
ment with the estimates of Chapman et al. (2000).
The model can be used to make predictions for other
IR/submm surveys. For instance, we find that the SWIRE2
survey with SIRTF will be able to detect only 0.04% (resp.
0%, 0%, 0%, 0.02%, 1.4%, 2.3%) of them at 170 µm (resp.
70µm, 24µm, 8µm, 5.8µm,4.5µm, 3.6µm) at the 17.5 mJy
level (resp. 2.75mJy, 0.45mJy, 32.5µJy, 27.5µJy, 9.7,µJy
7.3µJy). These objects are clearly a key target for ALMA
which should be able to detect all of them at 850 µm or 1.3
mm, at the 0.1 mJy level.
Predictions at other optical and IR/submm wavelengths
can be easily retrieved from queries to our web interfaced
relational database located at http://galics.iap.fr.
6 NATURE OF LBGS
As emphasised by Shapley et al. (2001), the question of the
nature of LBGs remains quite open. Different models sug-
2 http://www.ipac.caltech.edu/SWIRE/
14
Blaizot et al.
Figure 13. Ratio of IR to 1600A luminosity versus the sum of
these luminosities. In a first approximation, this shows absorp-
tion by dust versus star formation rate. The grey region roughly
indicates the location of observed LBGs (Adelberger & Steidel
2000), whereas the dots represent our modelled LBGs. The solid
line marks the SCUBA detection limit at 850 µm.
gest that LBGs are seen because they are undergoing strong
starbursts due to major mergers, whereas others claim that
LBGs are central galaxies of massive haloes that form stars
steadily so as to reach a consequent size by redshift 3. The
increasing number of observations seems to indicate that
LBGs have many facets. Each of the two above-mentioned
scenarios can explain some of their properties. We describe
in this section the general properties of our modelled LBGs
and investigate their star formation histories.
6.1 Physical properties
Sizes
In Fig. 14 we show the distribution of sizes of our modelled
LBGs. The size of a galaxy is defined here as the stellar-
mass weighted average of the three component (disc, bulge,
starburst) half-mass radii. We find a median value of 2.6 kpc
for our LBGs, which is in good agreement with the analysis
by Giavalisco et al. (1996) of a few LBGs observed with the
HST (but identified with ground-based images) for which
they find a typical size of about 2 kpc. The mean values and
standard deviations are summarised in table 6.1.
Stellar masses
The distribution of stellar masses of our modelled LBGs
is given in Fig. 14. The median stellar mass is 2.6 × 1010
M⊙, in very good agreement with the mean stellar mass de-
duced from data by Shapley et al. (2001) (< Mstar >med=
2.4 × 1010 M⊙), and Papovich et al. (2001) (∼ 1010 M⊙).
The shape of our distribution is consistent with that given
by Shapley et al. (2001, their Fig. 10b), and also with the
"accelerated quiescent" model of SPF (Primack et al. 2001).
Metallicity
The distribution of metallicities of our modelled LBGs is
given in Fig. 14. The solid histogram shows the 3-component
average ISM metallicity of our modelled galaxies, the dotted
histogram that of the discs, the dashed line shows that of
the bulges and the dot-dashed one that of the starbursts. We
find a median metallicity of about Z⊙/5, which is again in
good agreement with observations (Pettini et al. 2001). The
starburst and bulge components have higher metallicities,
due to the more intensive star formation taking place there.
Star formation rates
In Fig. 14 we show the distribution of star formation rates
(SFR) for our modelled LBGs computed in two different
ways. The solid line shows the instantaneous star formation
rate (SFRinst), computed over the last Myr. This quantity
is not directly comparable to the value deduced from obser-
vations of the UV through broad band filters (see discus-
sion in Kennicutt (1998)). However, they indicate the cur-
rent state of LBGs, and should compare better to estimates
of SFR obtained from emission lines. For this estimate, we
find a median value of 27.4 M⊙ yr−1, lower than the ob-
served value by a factor ∼ 3. The dotted curve shows the
distribution of star formation rates computed as the mass of
stars younger than 100 Myr, divided by 100 Myr (SFR100).
This is much closer to what is deduced from observations
by Shapley et al. (2001) as it takes into account the star
formation history during a time of order the lifetime of B
and A stars. Our measure is however an under-estimate of
the real SFR (by about 20%) because we miss all the mass
lost through stellar evolution during a 100 Myr. The median
value of SFR100 is 50.8 M⊙ yr−1, with 20% of the modelled
LBGs forming more that 100 M⊙ per year. These SFRs are
in better agreement with the data, although still low com-
pared to the estimate of Shapley et al. (2001) : ∼ 90 M⊙
yr−1.
The question of what triggers these high SFRs has
been investigated by Somerville et al. (2001) who suggest
that star formation in LBGs is triggered by mergers. In our
model, we find that only 30% of the LBGs have undergone
a merger (although this figure goes up to 60% for our high
resolution simulation). Thus we conclude that star forma-
tion in LBGs is both due to merger-triggered starbursts and
active cooling of gas on the galaxies.
Conclusion
The main point that the previous statistics make is that
galics does not reproduce LBG counts by chance, as it
reproduces their dynamical and chemical properties quite
well. Again, we emphasise that this is a natural outcome of
a model which also reproduces quite well the properties of
local galaxies, as shown in galics i.
6.2 The descendants of LBGs
In a recent paper, Nagamine (2002) investigated the nature
of the progenitors and descendants of LBGs within a cos-
mological hydrodynamical simulation. We extend here this
investigation to the new methodology we have developed
GALICS III : Predicted Properties for LBGs at z ∼ 3
15
Figure 14. Top left panel : Radius (kpc) distribution for our modelled LBGs. The radius is a stellar-mass weighted average radius of
three components: disc, bulge and starburst. The median value of ∼ 2.6 kpc, indicated with the dotted vertical line, is in good agreement
with the data from the HDF (Giavalisco et al. 1996). Top right panel : Stellar mass distributions for our modelled LBGs. The median
value of 2.6 × 1010M⊙ is indicated by the dotted vertical line. Bottom left panel : The solid histogram shows the 3-component average
ISM metallicity distribution of our modelled galaxies, the dotted histogram that of the discs, the dashed histogram that of the bulges
and the dot-dashed one that of the starbursts. Bottom right panel : The solid histograms represent the distribution of instantaneous
SFRs of our modelled LBGs, whereas the dotted histogram shows the distribution of SFRs averaged over 100 Myr for the same galaxies.
The median SFRinst is ∼28 M⊙ yr−1, as indicated by the left hand side vertical dotted line, and the median of SFR100 is ∼50.8 M⊙
yr−1, indicated by the right hand side vertical dotted line.
LBGs
< r1/2 > a < Mstar > b < Z > c <SFRinst >d <SFR100 >e
(M⊙ yr−1)
(M⊙ yr−1)
(kpc)
(1010M⊙)
(Z⊙)
R ≤ 25.5
R ≤ 25
R ≤ 24.5
2.61
2.61
2.59
2.60
2.52
2.20
0.219
0.221
0.217
27.4
26.2
23.8
50.8
48.4
43.2
a Half-mass radius of largest galaxy component (disc, bulge, or burst) (standard deviation).
b Stellar mass of galaxies (standard deviation).
c Mean metallicity (standard deviation).
d Instantaneous star formation rate summed over the three components of our modelled galaxies.
e Star formation rate summed over the three components of our modelled galaxies, and averaged over 100 Myr.
Table 5. General properties of our modelled LBGs at z ∼ 3.
16
Blaizot et al.
with galics and momaf. We first start with examples of
star formation histories of modelled LBGs, following them
until z = 0, and continue with an investigation of the nature
of the local descendants of these galaxies.
6.2.1 Star formation histories
In Fig. 15 we show several examples of star formation histo-
ries for our modelled LBGs. The top panels show the star for-
mation rate as a function of cosmic time; the middle panels
the stellar (solid curves) and gas (dashed curve) mass evolu-
tion; and the lower panels that of the metallicity. The verti-
cal dotted lines indicate the moment at which each galaxy is
identified as a LBG. Before this vertical line, the given his-
tory is that of the most massive progenitor at each merger
undergone by the future LBG. Each column represents a
galaxy, and they are sorted from left to right in order of
decreasing redshift of identification.
We find a large variety of star formation histories, rep-
resentative of the variety of states in which galaxies can be
when they meet the LBG criteria. This also illustrates the
two processes that trigger star formation in LBGs : active
cooling of the hot gas in halos onto the young galaxies as
opposed to merger-triggered starbursts.
Finally, notice how some LBGs evolve quiescently until
the present day, resulting in massive spirals of which they
form the bulges, and how some undergo several extra merg-
ers, resulting in present-day massive ellipticals. From the
middle panels of Fig. 15 it can be seen that our LBGs rep-
resent, on average, about 10% of the total mass of their
descendants in the local Universe.
6.2.2 LBGs as progenitors of ellipticals ?
We define the morphology of galaxies at z = 0 using the
ratio of bulge to disc B-band luminosities, as described in
galics i. With this definition, we find that ∼77% of our
modelled LBGs end up in ellipticals or lenticular galaxies,
the remainder ending up in spirals. On the other hand, we
also computed the number of elliptical or lenticular galaxies
at z = 0 that have had at least one LBG progenitor in their
merging history tree. These galaxies represent about 35%
of the whole local population of early-type galaxies (with
MB < −18).
In Fig. 16 we show the expected location of the de-
scendants of our modelled LBGs. The x-axis is the size (i.e.
number of galaxies) of groups or clusters of galaxies, and
the y-axis gives the number of LBGs that end up in groups
of these sizes. Elliptical or lenticular descendants of LBGs
are found in groups with a median number of ∼15 galaxies,
while spiral descendants are found to be satellite galaxies in
clusters/groups of ∼30 galaxies.
7 DISCUSSION
7.1 Summary of results
This paper is the third one of the galics series that presents
a consistent attempt to model hierarchical galaxy formation
within a hybrid approach in which dark matter collapse is
computed in a large cosmological simulation, and the physics
Figure 16. Number of galaxies in haloes where LBG descendants
are found, for three morphological types of descendants. Vertical
dotted lines indicate median numbers.
of baryons is described by semi -- analytic recipes. The first
paper (galics i) has detailed the model and the predicted
statistical properties of local galaxies, which have been com-
pared against data. The second paper (galics ii) has pre-
sented the evolution of a set of these properties from red-
shift z = 3 to z = 0 within the hierarchical paradigm. In
the current paper, we have proposed a more detailed study
of the properties of optically -- bright, star -- forming galaxies
at z ∼ 3. We have converted the predictions of our gal-
ics model into a mock observing cone by means of the mo-
maf package. From this observing cone, a sample of LBGs
has been extracted with selection criteria as close as possi-
ble to those used in the observational sample of Steidel et al.
(1996). This method allows us to get a three -- fold insight on
(i) the efficiency of the selection criteria to capture z ∼ 3
galaxies, (ii) the nature of the objects that have been se-
lected according to these criteria, and (iii) the properties
that could be measured in forthcoming follow -- up. The re-
sults of this paper have been obtained from the same cos-
mological simulation (a ΛCDM model with 2563 particles
in a cubic box with 100h−1 Mpc on a side), and with the
same astrophysical parameters in the semi -- analytic post --
processing as in the first two papers. In doing so, we are
attempting to progressively build up a consistent view of
hierarchical galaxy formation from z = 3 to z = 0.
In this prospect, the successes of the model are satis-
factory, in spite of several shortcomings. Our model LBGs
GALICS III : Predicted Properties for LBGs at z ∼ 3
17
Figure 15. Examples of galaxy histories in a ΛCDM cosmology. Top panels : instantaneous SFR versus cosmic time. Middle panel
: masses of stars (solid curves) and gas (dashed curves) in our LBGs versus cosmic time. Lower panels : evolution of average ISM
metallicities with cosmic time. The vertical dotted lines indicate the time at which galaxies were identified as LBGs.
were selected according to colour and magnitude criteria in
the mock observing cone. This allowed us first to examine
the efficiency of the selection method. We have seen that:
is very similar to the one given in that paper. This shows an
overall consistency between the mock sample and the actual
sample.
• The model is able to reproduce the number density
counts of LBGs on the sky, and gives a number density of
∼1.2 arcmin−2 at the magnitude limit of the sample, in good
agreement with the data.
• The set of colour and magnitude criteria designed by
Steidel & Hamilton (1993) and Steidel et al. (1995) to select
z ∼ 3 galaxies on the basis of synthetic stellar populations
evolving according to the monolithic model, is well suited
to the selection of LBGs within the hierarchical model. Our
best contour in the colour -- colour plot is not very different
from the usual contour.
• The fraction of interlopers, that is, of galaxies that pass
the criteria, but are not located in the target redshift range
[2.7, 3.4], is about 12%. Most of these interlopers are fore-
ground galaxies at z > 2.
of the completeness by the confirmation rate, is 85%.
• The efficiency of the selection, defined as the product
• The contribution of clustering to cosmic variance can
be estimated for scales below the apparent size of the box at
redshift ∼ 3. For a 100 arcmin2 field, the relative variance
is more than twice the Poissonian value.
• The reconstructed luminosity function, provided we ap-
ply a correction for volume effects as in Steidel et al. (1995),
Given this overall agreement, we have explored the na-
ture of LBGs in the model, with special emphasis on three
critical issues (i) clustering and spatial information, (ii) ex-
tinction and the optical -- to -- IR luminosity budget, and (iii)
merging history and fate in the present universe. We have
obtained the following results:
• The amplitude and shape of the projected 2 -- point cor-
relation function is in agreement with the data. With our
choice of the cosmological parameters of the simulation, the
comparison of the 3D correlation function with the dark
matter correlation function gives us an estimate of the linear
bias that slowly decreases on scales from 1 to 20 h−1Mpc,
from b ≃ 5 to b ≃ 3. So we find a higher bias value than
previously found in the literature. This is the first estimate
of the bias for z ∼ 3 LBGs from a hybrid model. The LBGs
are located in haloes with masses ranging from 3 × 1011M⊙
to 3 × 1012M⊙, with a median value 1.6 × 1011M⊙. The po-
sitions of the LBGs nicely delineate the dense regions of the
filaments at z ∼ 3.
• The extinction properties of our model LBGs depend
on the extinction model that has been put in, basically the
one presented in the stardust model of spectrophotomet-
ric evolution (Devriendt et al. 1999). We find a factor ∼ 6.2
18
Blaizot et al.
for extinction at the rest -- frame wavelength 1600 A that is,
a value higher than that used by Steidel et al. (1996), but
consistent with the later analysis of Adelberger & Steidel
(2000). The UV to IR luminosity budget is quite similar
to the re -- construction proposed by Adelberger & Steidel
(2000) on the basis of the available data.
• We estimated a set of properties for our mock LBGs.
The median values are 2.6 × 1010M⊙ for stellar masses, 2.6
kpc for half -- light radii, 0.2 Z⊙ for metallicities, and 27 (resp.
50) M⊙yr−1 for instantaneous (resp. averaged over 100 Myr)
SFRs. These median values for stellar masses, radii and
metallicities are in agreement with the data, although the
measurement of these quantities from observations is not
straightforward. Our value for the median SFR seems to be
too low with respect to observations3. We also find that only
a minority of LBGs (30%) may be starbursts triggered by
mergers, contrary to Somerville et al. (2001).
• Finally, we are able to assess the future of these z ∼ 3
LBGs. We give examples of their SFR and mass histories
from this epoch to the present. We are also interested in
the nature of LBGs as progenitors of current galaxies of
the Hubble sequence, although morphological classification
issues are not easy. We recall that in galics, our Hubble
type is given by the B -- band bulge -- to -- disk luminosity ratio.
The model LBGs observed at z ∼ 3 preferentially end up
in galaxies that are classified as bright, early -- type galax-
ies. More specifically, 77 % of the descendants of our model
LBGs are ellipticals or lenticulars with MB < −18, whereas
the latter population only represents 15 % of the local galax-
ies with MB < −18. On the other hand, 35 % of the bright
ellipticals and lenticulars of the local Universe actually had
a LBG progenitor at z ∼ 3. The other 65 % may have had
already progenitors at z ∼ 3, but with apparent magnitudes
that are to faint to pass the chosen selection threshold. So
we cannot say that LBGs "`a la Steidel" are the progenitors
of local ellipticals, but they clearly are progenitors of local
ellipticals.
Our model gives a very good basis for making predic-
tions of observational strategies for forthcoming follow -- up
observations. For instance, we show that only a small frac-
tion of the LBGs can be detected in a SCUBA follow-up
or with the SWIRE4 survey with SIRTF. These objects are
clearly a key target for ALMA which should be able to de-
tect all of them at 850 µm or 1.3 mm, at the 0.1 mJy level.
The strong potential of our model for making follow -- up pre-
dictions through many optical and IR/submm filters can
be fully exploited by submitting queries to our relational
database at http://galics.iap.fr.
7.2 Summary of drawbacks
The main shortcoming of our model for the present study
comes from the mass resolution of the cosmological simula-
3 We believe, however, that this underestimate is due both to
differences in stellar population models used to retrieve the SFR
and in the definition of the period on which the SFR is com-
puted. When playing the game of fitting our LBG colours with
e.g. the PEGASE model (Fioc & Rocca-Volmerange 1997), we
obtain larger values of the SFR, by a factor 2 -- 3.
4 http://www.ipac.caltech.edu/SWIRE/
tion we use. Only haloes with 20 or more particles are iden-
tified by the fof algorithm. This results in a baryonic mass
limit, below which incompleteness comes in. Galaxies with
baryonic masses below the threshold are included in identi-
fied haloes, in which not all the hot gas has cooled, whereas
galaxies in dark matter structures less massive than our de-
tection threshold are missing. Fortunately, we have shown
in galics i that incompleteness settles slowly for decreasing
masses. On its turn, the baryonic mass threshold converts
into an absolute magnitude limit that we call our formal
magnitude limit. The estimate of this value at z ∼ 3 for
rest -- frame 1600 A absolute magnitude is MAB = −20.3.
This means that this mass resolution just passes the selec-
tion criterion put as MAB ≤ −20.2.
Unfortunately, the mass resolution was shown to "leak"
on galaxy properties through their merging histories by gal-
ics i. It was not crucial for bright galaxies at z = 0, but it is
much more significant at z ∼ 3. Galaxies that should have
been missed because they are not massive enough appear
over the magnitude threshold because they are "immature".
Their history is not resolved enough in the past, because of
the absence of small haloes, and they appear too bright inas-
much as they are too gassy and form stars too actively. We
showed that we can recover from this effect by imposing a
"maturity criterion": only galaxies with at least a progenitor
1.1 Gyr ago have to be selected. The other objects have to
be discarded from our analysis. Such a criterion admittedly
appears as a fine -- tuning to recover the correct number of
LBGs. It is only at z = 3 that we are 'drowning' in major
resolution effects, inasmuch as the correction reaches about
75 %, and we are consequently reaching the limit of this
specific simulation. A study on a higher -- resolution simula-
tion (Blaizot et al, 2004, in progress) shows that the cho-
sen maturity criterion becomes transparent at z = 3 in this
simulation, and that our maturity criterion to by -- pass the
problem in the current simulation is reasonable.
Another shortcoming appears as the consequence of the
volume of our cosmological simulation. The comoving side
of the box 100h−1 Mpc corresponds to an apparent 1 deg
at z ∼ 3. It does not allow us to address the issue of cosmic
variance in fields larger than typically a fraction of a deg2,
and clustering on scales larger than a fraction of a degree.
On scales smaller than that, we have shown in a companion
paper (momaf) that the technique of cone building from
this simulation introduces systematic effects that lower the
correlation function at most by 10 %.
Finally, we have tried to model the selection criteria as
accurately as possible, but we may have missed systematic
effects and subtle observational biases.
8 CONCLUSIONS
The LBG selection is a very efficient way to select high --
redshift galaxies. The z ∼ 3 LBGs seem to naturally come
out of models of hierarchical galaxy formation, as shown by
the current study. The list of properties that are reproduced
is quite impressive, and the overall feeling is that we globally
understand what is going on, both in the selection process
and in the nature of the target galaxies. However, the actual
impact of this set of results is somewhat affected by the
need to correct for the "immaturity" of a large number of
GALICS III : Predicted Properties for LBGs at z ∼ 3
19
z ∼ 3 galaxies in the model. This immaturity reflects mass
resolution in terms of history resolution. For this reason,
there is no point in attempting to go at higher redshift,
and try to model z ∼ 4 LBGs (Steidel et al. 1999) with the
outputs of this specific simulation.
The galics model seems to nicely mimic the properties
of optically -- bright, star -- forming galaxies at z ∼ 3. How-
ever, this obviously does not mean that other galaxy popula-
tions in this redshift range that would be selected according
to other observational criteria, are equally well reproduced.
More specifically, samples of galaxies may be selected for
instance on the basis of their red colours, such as the Ex-
tremely Red Objects. In this prospect, another subtle effect
of mass resolution may appear in terms of the absence of
old stellar populations that should have formed in struc-
tures smaller than the mass threshold. This issue will be
addressed in forthcoming work.
After our first two galics papers that presented a de-
tailed exploration of the nature of model galaxies between
z = 0 and 3, this study is the next milestone in the pre-
sentation of the full sets of results coming out of the gal-
ics model, as far as it illustrates how mock samples can be
extracted with elaborated selection criteria. This study is
complemented by a relational database that can be easily
queried through a web interface at http://galics.iap.fr.
Two forthcoming papers will be more oriented toward pre-
dictions for deep surveys, in terms of multi -- wavelength faint
galaxy counts (galics iv) and 2D correlation functions
(galics v).
The road map for further developments is rather clear.
On the one hand, since we are reaching the limit of this spe-
cific simulation, we have to run simulations with a better
resolution. Such a work is in progress and seems to nicely
confirm the results of the current study. On the other hand,
the logic of mock observing cones should lead us to gener-
ate mock images with all the instrumental effects, and to
try to extract mock samples with the same data processing
pipelines as the actual observations.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank S. Colombi for his precious help on correlation
functions and error estimates, and D. Le Borgne for help-
ing us with the PEGASE web interface. JEGD and SH
were respectively supported by grants from the Leverhulme
trust and the EU TMR network Formation and Evolution
of Galaxies. FS acknowledges support from the Marie Curie
EARASTARGAL program.
REFERENCES
Adelberger K. L., Steidel C. C., 2000, ApJ, 544, 218
Adelberger K. L., Steidel C. C., Giavalisco M., Dickinson
M., Pettini M., Kellogg M., 1998, ApJ, 505, 18
Arnouts S., Moscardini L., Vanzella E., Colombi S., Cris-
tiani S., Fontana A., Giallongo E., Matarrese S., Saracco
P., 2002, MNRAS, 329, 355
Balland C., Devriendt J. E. G., Silk J., 2003, MNRAS, 343,
107
Baugh C. M., Cole S., Frenk C. S., Lacey C. G., 1998, ApJ,
498, 504
Blaizot J., Wadadekar Y., Guiderdoni B., Colombi S.,
Bertin E., Bouchet F. R., Devriendt J. E. G., Hatton S.,
2003, submitted to MNRAS
Chapman S. C., Scott D., Steidel C. C., Borys C., Halpern
M., Morris S. L., Adelberger K. L., Dickinson M., Gi-
avalisco M., Pettini M., 2000, MNRAS, 319, 318
Devriendt J. E. G., Guiderdoni B., 2000, A&A, 363, 851
Devriendt J. E. G., Guiderdoni B., Sadat R., 1999, A&A,
350, 381
Devriendt J. E. G., Hatton S., Ninin S., Blaizot J., Bouchet
F. R., Guiderdoni B., 2003, in preparation
Fioc M., Rocca-Volmerange B., 1997, A&A, 326, 950
Giavalisco M., Dickinson M., 2001, ApJ, 550, 177
Giavalisco M., Steidel C. C., Adelberger K. L., Dickinson
M. E., Pettini M., Kellogg M., 1998, ApJ, 503, 543
Giavalisco M., Steidel C. C., Macchetto F. D., 1996, ApJ,
470, 189
Guiderdoni B., Hivon E., Bouchet F. R., Maffei B., 1998,
MNRAS, 295, 877
Hatton S., Devriendt J. E. G., Ninin S., Bouchet F. R.,
Guiderdoni B., Vibert D., 2003, MNRAS, 343, 75
Idzi R., Somerville R., Papovich C., Ferguson H. C., Gi-
avalisco M., Kretchmer C., Lotz J., 2003, ArXiv Astro-
physics e-prints
Kennicutt R. C., 1983, ApJ, 272, 54
Kennicutt R. C., 1998, ARA&A, 36, 189
Landy S. D., Szalay A. S., 1993, ApJ, 412, 64
Madau P., 1995, ApJ, 441, 18
Madau P., Ferguson H. C., Dickinson M. E., Giavalisco M.,
Steidel C. C., Fruchter A., 1996, MNRAS, 283, 1388
Massarotti M., Iovino A., Buzzoni A., 2001, ApJL, 559,
L105
Nagamine K., 2002, ApJ, 564, 73
Ninin S., 1999, Th`ese de l'Universit´e Paris 11
Papovich C., Dickinson M., Ferguson H. C., 2001, ApJ,
559, 620
Pettini M., Shapley A. E., Steidel C. C., Cuby J., Dickinson
M., Moorwood A. F. M., Adelberger K. L., Giavalisco M.,
2001, ApJ, 554, 981
Porciani C., Giavalisco M., 2002, ApJ, 565, 24
Press W. H., Teukolsky S. A., Vetterling W. T., Flan-
nery B. P., 1992, Numerical recipes in FORTRAN. The
art of scientific computing. Cambridge: University Press,
-- c1992, 2nd ed.
Primack J. R., Wechsler R. H., Somerville R. S., 2001, in
Bender R., Renzini A., eds, Mass of Galaxies at Low and
High Redshift The masses of lyman break galaxies
Shapley A. E., Steidel C. C., Adelberger K. L., Dickinson
M., Giavalisco M., Pettini M., 2001, ApJ, 562, 95
Somerville R. S., Primack J. R., Faber S. M., 2001, MN-
RAS, 320, 504
Steidel C. C., Adelberger K. L., Giavalisco M., Dickinson
M., Pettini M., 1999, ApJ, 519, 1
Steidel C. C., Giavalisco M., Pettini M., Dickinson M.,
Adelberger K. L., 1996, ApJL, 462, L17+
Steidel C. C., Hamilton D., 1993, AJ, 105, 2017
Steidel C. C., Pettini M., Hamilton D., 1995, AJ, 110, 2519
Weinberg D. H., Hernquist L., Katz N., 2002, ApJ, 571, 15
|
astro-ph/0504191 | 2 | 0504 | 2005-10-03T12:12:02 | A Simple Model for Quintessential Inflation | [
"astro-ph",
"hep-ph"
] | We describe a simple toy model for quintessential inflation where a complex scalar field described by a lagrangian with a Peccei-Quinn U(1) symmetry spontaneously broken at a high energy scale and explicitly broken by instanton effects at a much lower energy can account for both the early inflationary phase and the recent accelerated expansion of the Universe. The real part of the complex field plays the role of the inflaton whereas the imaginary part, the "axion", is the quintessence field. | astro-ph | astro-ph | A Simple Model for Quintessential Inflation
R. Rosenfeld∗
Instituto de F´ısica Te´orica - UNESP, Rua Pamplona,
145, 01405-900, Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil
J. A. Frieman†
NASA/Fermilab Astrophysics Center
Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory,
Batavia, IL 60510
and
Department of Astronomy & Astrophysics
and Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics
The University of Chicago,
Chicago, IL 60637
Abstract
We propose a simple toy model for quintessential inflation where a complex scalar field described
by a lagrangian with a U (1)P Q symmetry spontaneously broken at a high energy scale and explicitly
broken by instanton effects at a much lower energy can account for both the early inflationary phase
and the recent accelerated expansion of the Universe. The real part of the complex field plays the
role of the inflaton whereas the imaginary part, the "axion", is the quintessence field.
PACS numbers: 98.80.Cq
5
0
0
2
t
c
O
3
2
v
1
9
1
4
0
5
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
∗Electronic address: [email protected]
†Electronic address: [email protected]
1
I.
INTRODUCTION
Recent observations of the cosmic microwave background [1], type Ia supernovae [2] and
the large scale structure of the Universe [3] have provided evidence that the Universe has
experienced two different stages of accelerated expansion during its history. The inflationary
stage took place at the very first moments of the Universe and superluminally stretched a tiny
patch to become our observable Universe today. It generated the fluctuations responsible
to seed the observed large scale structure and naturally explains why the Universe is flat,
homogeneous and isotropic. It ended with a period of reheating that brought the Universe
back to the usual Friedman-Robertson-Walker expansion. The second stage of accelerated
expansion began at a redshift of order one-half and is still operative. We do not know
whether it will halt in the future.
In order to physically generate an accelerated expansion in the framework of general
relativity it is necessary to invoke some form of vacuum energy, the most popular candi-
dates being either a cosmological constant or a scalar field, sometimes called quintessence,
displaced from the minimum of its potential energy (which can be adjusted to vanish) [4].
Since inflation has to end, a cosmological constant cannot be its source. Furthermore, it
requires a tremendous amount of fine tuning in order to explain the current acceleration
stage with a cosmological constant. Therefore, it is more natural to explore models of scalar
fields in order to explain the two stages of acceleration.
In principle, these two stages of acceleration are independent. They occurred at wildly
different epochs of the Universe and may have been caused by totally unrelated physical
processes. On the other hand, it would be most interesting if these two stages were in
some way connected to each other.
It is possible to develop the so-called quintessential
inflation models, where a carefully crafted single real scalar field potential can be responsible
for both stages [5]. However, these models involve non-renormalizable, ad hoc potentials.
Furthermore, these potentials usually do not have a local minimum, making the conventional
reheating process unoperative. Particle production via preheating is more efficient than
gravitational particle production in this case, but requires the introduction of extra fields [6].
In this paper we propose to use a simple, well motivated and renormalizable, complex scalar
field model to unify the description of both stages of acceleration into a single framework.
2
II. THE MODEL
In our proposal, we use a complex scalar field pertaining to a model with a global U(1)P Q-
like symmetry spontaneously broken at a high energy scale f [7]. This generates a flat
potential for the imaginary part of the field ("axion") that is lifted by small instanton
effects at a much lower energy scale. Essentially the same type of model has been proposed
as a candidate for natural inflation [8] and, separately, for quintessence [9], with different
parameters in each case. Also, complex scalar fields have been recently studied in the context
of quintessence models called "spintessence" [10].
We use a Lagrangian given by:
L = ∂µΦ∂µΦ∗ − V (Φ) − M 4[cos(Arg(Φ)) − 1]
with a renormalizable potential
V (Φ) = λ ΦΦ∗ −
f 2
2 !2
.
(1)
(2)
The global U(1)P Q symmetry is spontaneously broken at a high energy scale determined
by f = O(MP l) and explicitly broken by small instanton effects at a much lower energy scale
M. The real and imaginary parts of the field Φ will be identified with the inflaton and the
quintessence fields, respectively.
Writing the complex field Φ as
Φ =
1
√2
ηeiϕ/f
(3)
we note that, in order that the field ϕ has not dissipated away its energy density today
producing axions, we should require:
mϕ =
M 2
f
<
∼ 3H0
(4)
where H0 = 100 h km/s/Mpc is the Hubble constant today. On the other hand, for the
density in the ϕ field to have the correct order of magnitude to explain the observed data
we should have:
M 4 ≃ ρc =
Combining these two requirements results in:
3H 2
0 M 2
P l
8π
.
f >
MP l√24π
; M ≃ 3 × 10−3 h1/2 eV,
3
(5)
(6)
where we use MP l = 1.2 × 1019 GeV. Such a high energy scale for the axion decay constant
is also required in order to suppress isocurvature fluctuations to acceptable levels [11, 12] in
models where the axion is the dark matter. In our case, however, the axion field will only
become dynamical in the future, behaving today as a cosmological constant and hence there
are no bounds from isocurvature fluctuations.
Recently, a two-axion model for quintessence was proposed that satisfies the above con-
straints in a natural fashion [13].
It is based on a model independent superstring axion
(aM I) [14], with a typical decay constant faM I = MP l, which mixes with another axion (ah)
coming from the dynamics of the hidden sector, responsible for supersymmetry breaking.
The hidden sector axion, with a typical decay constant given by the hidden sector scale,
fah = 1013 GeV, arises from squark condensation that spontaneously breaks a global U(1)
symmetry, leaving supersymmetry intact. Non-perturbative quantum gravity effects, such
as wormholes, may break this symmetry but such effects, even if they exist, can be made
exponentially small [15].
A linear combination of the two axion fields that couples only to SU(3) gauge fields is
identified with the QCD axion, which solves the strong CP problem, while its orthogonal
combination is the axion responsible for quintessence, which has a decay constant close
to MP l. It is this quintessential axion that we will identify with the imaginary part of a
complex scalar field Φ. The breaking of the global U(1) symmetry will be parametrized by
an effective Landau-Ginzburg theory for Φ. 1
In this model, supersymmetry in our world is broken by gravity mediated hidden sector
gaugino condensation and the height of the instanton induced potential, M, depends on
the gaugino mass of TeV scale, as well as on the mass of hidden sector quarks. The right
order of magnitude for M is obtained for parameters which solve the so called µ-problem
as well [13]. The squark condensate in the hidden sector would be described by an effective
Landau-Ginzburg model and Q Qc would be identified with the complex scalar field Φ.
Another version of the two-axion model was recently proposed as a realistic candidate
1 It should be mentioned that an effective theory description is presumably inappropriate for such a large
spontaneous symmetry breaking scale f of the order of the Plack mass, as required by the flatness of the
quintessence potential. However, it is possible to build models with extra axion fields where this flatness
can be achieved for a particular linear combination of the axion fields with a much smaller effective value
of f [16].
4
for natural inflation[16], where one of the axions is identified with the inflaton field. Also,
a natural candidate for the inflaton appears in models of one extra dimension compactified
on a circle of radius R, where the Wilson loop for the 5th component of an abelian gauge
field behaves as an axion for energies below the compactification scale and its effective
decay constant can be made larger than the Planck scale for sufficiently small 4d gauge
coupling[17]. This axion model from extra dimensions can also be used for quintessence
[18], but at this point is unclear if a model with a scalar complex field like the one suggested
here can be incorporated in this context.
The idea that the real part of a complex field of an Peccei-Quinn like axial U(1)P Q
symmetry may drive inflation is also not new. Actually, Pi made this proposal in the
context of a SU(5) ⊗ U(1)P Q model containing a complex SU(5) singlet field [19]. There
are other grand unified models, such as SO(10), where the axion appears naturally [20].
However, our model is different in the sense that it does not start with hΦi = 0, but rather
has an initial value such that hΦi ≫ f , as in a chaotic inflation model [23].
In fact, at large values of the field, Φ ≫ f , the model is basically a λΦ4 model. The
slow roll conditions are satisfied for Φ > MP l/√2π and the Universe undergoes a phase of
chaotic inflation, in which it expands and cools down rapidly. In order to have a sufficient
>
number of e-foldings, the initial value of the field must be Φi
∼ 5MP l. The self-coupling
constant must satisfy λ <
∼ 10−15 to generate the correct amplitude of density perturbations.2
One should keep in mind that, quoting Kinney [22], it is fair to say that λφ4 inflation is
under significant pressure from the data but it cannot be definitively ruled out.
At this stage we can use the classical equations of motion to study the dynamics:
η + 3H η −
ϕ2
f 2 η + V ′(η) = 0
ϕ + 3H +
g
g! ϕ +
1
g(η)
V ′(ϕ) = 0
and
where g(η) = η2/f 2 and
V (η) =
λ
4
(η2 − f 2)2; V (ϕ) = M 4[cos(ϕ/f ) − 1]
(7)
(8)
(9)
2 One may rightly wonder whether the potential can be protected against quantum gravity corrections for
this large field value. It has been shown that introducing the shift symmetry present in axion models allows
a chaotic inflation model to be embedded in a supergravity model with naturally large field values[21].
5
Neglecting the instanton potential it follows that
1
a3g(η)
ϕ ∝
(10)
and therefore the field ϕ is frozen during inflation.
As the field η rolls down the potential, the slow-roll conditions eventually cease to be
valid, inflation ends and the Universe is effectively at zero temperature. For Φ ≃ f , the
systems becomes sensitive to the symmetry breaking process. The dynamics of spontaneous
symmetry breaking (SSB) in the early Universe is complicated by the presence of large
quantum fluctuations due to the tachyonic instability and it has been studied in detail by
Felder et al. [24].
The difference between our model and the one studied by Felder et al.
lies in the fact
that in their case the field rolls from the central hill of the "mexican hat" potential down
to its valley while in our case the field rolls from the border of the hat towards its valley.
Hence, in our case the tachyonic instability does not appear unless a large amount of fine
tuning is invoked in our initial conditions to put the field exactly at the top of the center
of the potential, which is not natural. Therefore, what follows is really a preheating akin to
chaotic models with quadratic potentials.
reheating of the Universe. Reheating can occur via couplings like gΦΦ∗hh or g′
Energy can be efficiently transferred from the field to other particles, resulting in the
M ΦΦ∗ ¯ψψ,
where h is a scalar field and ψ is a fermionic field. The coupling to fermions must be a
dimension-5 operator due to the U(1) symmetry and hence is suppressed by a high energy
scale M. These couplings can introduce resonances which make dominant the first oscillation
of the field, as it happens in no-oscillation models [6].
A detailed analysis of reheating requires a more definite model regarding interactions
with Standard Model fields and is beyond the scope of this paper. However, we mention
that reheating due to coupling to massless scalars in a similar model has been studied in [6]
and results in a reheating temperature of the order of Trh = 0.1(λ3/4g15/2)1/4 MP l. In order
to avoid large radiative corrections to the potential, which are of the order of g2/16π2, the
coupling constant g must be smaller than g ∼ 10−6. Using λ = 10−14 and g = 10−6 one
obtains a reheating temperature Trh = 104 GeV, avoiding the gravitino problem.
A numerical study based on non-perturbative lattice simulations shows that the field is
quickly trapped at the minimum of the potential, Φ = f /√2. The physical heavy scalar
6
η gets a mass of mη = √2λf ≃ 5 × 1011 GeV, too heavy to be produced in any foreseeable
accelerator. The global axionic strings Felder et al. find in their simulation will not appear
in our model since there is inflation before SSB and the phase of the field, which is frozen
at some random value, will be uniform throughout the observable Universe.
In our model, the field ϕ will become dynamical at a time t∗ when mϕ ≃ 3H(t∗). When
this happens, the dark energy will be transferred to axion production arising from the field
coherent oscillation down the instanton induced potential. Therefore, cosmic acceleration
will stop in the future, avoiding the problem with event horizons in string theory [25].
Finally, we would like to mention that one may be concerned that quantum fluctuations
could generate large perturbations in the angular ϕ field. We showed that the classical
zero-momentum mode of the angular field is frozen at early times (that is, until well after
reheating); as a result, any initial spatial gradients in ϕ will be smoothed out by inflation,
providing nearly homogeneous initial conditions for late-time acceleration. Quantum effects
can, however, lead to inhomogeneities in ϕ in two ways: through quantum fluctuations
generated during inflation or via coupling to the radial η field during reheating.
It is well known that quantum fluctuations in ϕ during inflation can generate isocurvature
fluctuations [26]. In fact, dark energy isocurvature fluctuations were recently suggested as
a mechanism to reduce the power spectrum seen at the quadrupole scale in the cosmic
microwave background [27]. A model similar to ours but with tachyonic preheating was
invoked to amplify the dark energy perturbations and at the same time reducing a large
amount of gravitational wave signal that could potentially invalidate the mechanism [28].
However, in our model these quantum fluctuations are not a cause of concern, since they are
of order Hinf , the Hubble parameter during inflation, which is much smaller than the classical
field amplitude, of order f , by a factor of order √λ; these would give rise to isocurvature
perturbations in ϕ, but only at very late times, and are too small to affect the homogeneous
dynamics of ϕ during the late acceleration phase.
As for inhomogeneities generated at reheating, eqns. (7) and (8) show that the coupling
between ϕ and η is strongly suppressed by inverse powers of f , which is of order the Planck
scale. In fact, the interaction cross section of ϕ with other fields is generally of order 1/f 2,
so it decouples at a temperature of order f . In any event, such interactions will only produce
very small-scale fluctuations of ϕ, on scales of order the Hubble radius or smaller during
reheating. For late-time acceleration, we are concerned with the variations of ϕ on the scale
7
of the present Hubble radius, which is many orders of magnitude larger than the comoving
Hubble radius during reheating. A detailed study of reheating in this model is beyond the
scope of this article and will be the subject of a future paper. Nevertheless, the arguments
above indicate that these effects will not lead to large-scale inhomogeneities in the angular
field that would impede its driving late acceleration.
III. CONCLUSION
In conclusion, we have presented in this article a simple, well-motivated model for
quintessential inflation with a complex field. This model unifies the successes of a chaotic
inflation model and a pseudo-goldstone boson quintessence model into a single framework
and naturally relates both phases of cosmic acceleration.
The model suggested here is certainly an incomplete, exploratory toy model. The cou-
pling λ would be naturally small, in the sense of
't Hooft, if the model is embedded in
supergravity-like models, as shown in [21]. The smallness of the instanton scale M is related
to parameters in the hidden sector in models of gravity mediated supersymmetry breaking.
It would be highly desirable to build a realistic model based on these ideas.
Acknowledgments
RR would like to thank the hospitality at the Fermilab Theory Group, where this work
was initiated when he was a Summer Visitor. JAF thanks C. T. Hill and H. P. Nilles for
discussions. RR thanks A. Linde and C. Gordon for providing interesting comments. The
work of RR was supported by grants from Fapesp and CNPq (brazilian agencies) and JAF
acknowledges support from the NSF Center for Cosmological Physics at the University of
Chicago, the DOE at Fermilab and Chicago, and NASA grant NAG 5-7092 at Fermilab.
[1] Spergel D N et al., First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Obser-
vations: Determination of Cosmological Parameters, 2003 Astrophys. J. Supp. 148 175
[astro-ph/0302209].
8
[2] Perlmutter S et al., Measurements of Omega and Lambda from 42 High-Redshift Supernovae,
1999 Astrophys. J. 517 565 [astro-ph/9812133]; Riess A G et al. , Observational Evidence
from Supernovae for an Accelerating Universe and a Cosmological Constant, 1998 Astron. J.
116 1009 [astro-ph/9805201]; Riess A G et al., Type Ia Supernova Discoveries at z>1 From
the Hubble Space Telescope: Evidence for Past Deceleration and Constraints on Dark Energy
Evolution, 2004 Astrophys. J. 607 665 [astro-ph/0402512].
[3] Tegmark M et al., The Three-Dimensional Power Spectrum of Galaxies from the Sloan Digital
Sky Survey, 2004 Astrophys. J. 606 702 [astro-ph/0310725].
[4] For comprehensive reviews, see e.g., Peebles P J E and Ratra B, The Cosmological Constant
and Dark Energy, 2003 Rev. Mod. Phys. 75 559 [astro-ph/0207347]; Padmanabhan T, Cos-
mological Constant - the Weight of the Vacuum, 2003 Phys. Rept. 380 235 [hep-th/0212290].
[5] Spokoiny B, Deflationary Universe Scenario, 1993 Phys. Lett. B315 40 [gr-qc/9306008];
Peebles P J E and Vilenkin A, Quintessential
inflation, 1999 Phys. Rev. D59 063505
[astro-ph/9904396]; Peloso M and Rosati F, On the Construction of Quintessential Inflation
Models 1999, JHEP 12, 026 [hep-ph/9908271]; Dimopoulos K and Valle J W F, Modeling
Quintessential Inflation, 2002 Astropart. Phys. 18 287 [astro-ph/0111417].
[6] Felder G, Kofman L and Linde A, Inflation and Preheating in NO models, 1999 Phys. Rev. D60
103505 [hep-ph/9903350]; Campos A H, Reis H C and Rosenfeld R, Preheating in Quintessen-
tial Inflation, 2003 Phys. Lett. B575 151 [hep-ph/0210152].
[7] Peccei R D and Quinn H, CP Conservation in the Presence of Instantons, 1977 Phys. Rev.
Lett. 38 1440; Weinberg S, A New Light Boson?, 1978 Phys. Rev. Lett. 40 223; Wilczek F,
Problem of Strong P and T Invariance in the Presence of Instantons, 1978 Phys. Rev. Lett.
46 279.
[8] Freese K, Frieman J A and Olinto A V, Natural Inflation with Pseudo - Nambu-Goldstone
Bosons, 1990 Phys. Rev. Lett. 65 3233; Adams F C, Bond J R, Freese K, Frieman J A and
Olinto A V,Natural Inflation: Particle Physics Models, Power Law Spectra for Large Scale
Structure, and Constraints from COBE, 1993 Phys. Rev. D47 426 [hep-ph/9207245].
[9] Frieman J A, Hill C T, Stebbins A and Waga I, Cosmology with Ultra-light Pseudo-Nambu-
Goldstone Bosons, 1995 Phys. Rev. Lett. 75 2077[astro-ph/9505060]; Hill C T and Leibovich
A K, Natural Theories of Ultra-Low Mass PNGB's: Axions and Quintessence, 2002 Phys.
Rev. D66 075010 [hep-ph/0205237].
9
[10] Gu J A and Hwang W Y P, Can the quintessence be a complex scalar field?, 2001 Phys. Lett.
B517 1 [astro-ph/0105099]; Boyle L A, Caldwell R R and Kamionkowiski M, Spintessence!
New Models for Dark Matter and Dark Energy, 2002 Phys. Lett. B545 17 [astro-ph/0105318].
[11] Dine M and Anisimov A, Is There a Peccei-Quinn Phase Transition?, 2004 [hep-ph/0405256].
[12] Kolb E W and Turner M S, The Early Universe, 1990 Addison-Wesley.
[13] Kim J E and Nilles H P, A Quintessential Axion, 2003 Phys. Lett. B553 1 [hep-ph/0210402].
[14] Witten E , Some Properties of O(32) Superstrings, 1984 Phys. Lett. 149B 351.
[15] Kallosh R, Linde A, Linde D and Susskind L, Gravity and Global Symmetries, 1995 Phys.
Rev. D52 912 [hep-th/9502069].
[16] Kim J E, Nilles H P and Peloso M, Completing Natural Inflation, 2005 JCAP 0501 005
[hep-ph/0409138].
[17] Arkani-Hamed N, Cheng H C, Creminelli P and Randall L, Extranatural Inflation, 2003
Phys. Rev. Lett. 90 221302 [hep-th/0301218]; Arkani-Hamed N, Cheng H C, Creminelli P and
Randall L, Pseudonatural Inflation, 2003 JCAP 0307 003.
[18] Pilo L, Rayner D A J and Riotto A, Gauge Quintessence, 2003 Phys. Rev. D68 043503
[hep-ph/0302087].
[19] Pi S Y, Inflation Without Tears, 1984 Phys. Rev. Lett. 52 1725.
[20] Babu K S and Barr S M, Natural Gauge Hierarchy in SO(10), 1994 Phys. Rev. D50 3592
[hep-ph/9402291].
[21] Kawasaki M, Yamaguchi M and Yanagida T, Natural Chaotic Inflation in Supergravity, 2000
Phys. Rev. Lett. 85 3572 [hep-ph/0004243].
[22] Kinney W H, Inflation After WMAP, 2004 [astro-ph/0406670].
[23] Linde A, Chaotic Inflation, 1983 Phys. Lett. 129B 177.
[24] Felder G, Garc´ıa-Bellido J, Greene P B, Kofman L, Linde A and Tkachev I, Dynamics of Sym-
metry Breaking and Tachyonic Preheating, 2001 Phys. Rev. Lett. 87 011601 [hep-ph/0012142];
Felder G, Kofman L and Linde A, Tachyonic Instability and Dynamics of Spontaneous Sym-
metry Breaking, 2001 Phys. Rev. D 64 123517 [hep-ph/0012142].
[25] Hellerman S, Kaloper N and Susskind L, String Theory and Quintessence, 2001 JHEP 0106
003 [hep-th/0104180].
[26] Seckel D and Turner M S, "Isothermal" Density Perturbations in an Axion-Dominated Infla-
tionary Universe, 1985 Phys. Rev. D 32 3178.
10
[27] Gordon C and Hu W, Low CMB Quadrupole from Dark Energy Isocurvature Perturbations,
2004 Phys. Rev. D 70 083003.
[28] Gordon C and Wands D, Amplitude of Dark Energy Perturbations, 2005 Phys. Rev. D 71
123505.
11
|
astro-ph/0509532 | 1 | 0509 | 2005-09-19T10:29:21 | MOND and Cosmology | [
"astro-ph"
] | I review various ideas on MOND cosmology and structure formation beginning with non-relativistic models in analogy with Newtonian cosmology. I discuss relativistic MOND cosmology in the context of Bekenstein's theory and propose an alternative biscalar effective theory of MOND in which the acceleration parameter is identified with the cosmic time derivative of a matter coupling scalar field. Cosmic CDM appears in this theory as scalar field oscillations of the auxiliary "coupling strength" field. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Mass Profiles and Shapes of Cosmological Structures
G. Mamon, F. Combes, C. Deffayet, B. Fort (eds)
EAS Publications Series, Vol. ?, 2005
5
0
0
2
p
e
S
9
1
1
v
2
3
5
9
0
5
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
MOND AND COSMOLOGY
R.H. Sanders 1
Abstract. I review various ideas on MOND cosmology and structure
formation beginning with non-relativistic models in analogy with New-
tonian cosmology. I discuss relativistic MOND cosmology in the con-
text of Bekenstein's theory and propose an alternative biscalar effective
theory of MOND in which the acceleration parameter, a0 is identified
with the cosmic time derivative of a matter coupling scalar field and
cosmic CDM appears as scalar field oscillations of the auxiliary "cou-
pling strength" field.
1 General Remarks
In modified Newtonian dynamics it is postulated that the true gravitational ac-
celeration, g, is related to the usual Newtonian acceleration, gN , as
gµ(g/a0) = gN
(1)
where a0 is a fixed parameter with units of acceleration and µ(x) is a function
interpolating between the MOND regime (µ(x) = x) and the Newtonian regime
(µ(x) = 1) (Milgrom 1983). This algorithm is arguably more successful in ex-
plaining aspects of galaxy phenomenology than is dark matter in the context of
the CDM paradigm (Sanders & McGaugh 2002).
But MOND, as a theory, is clearly incomplete; it makes no prediction about
cosmology or structure formation. The fact that ao ≈ cHo is suggestive of a cos-
mological connection, but the structure of that cosmology is not evident. It might
be expected that a hypothesis positing such a radical departure from Newtonian
dynamics (and hence General Relativity) on the scale of galaxies would result in
a highly unconventional cosmology and that this would be inconsistent with the
phenomenological successes of the standard Big Bang model -- primarily the nu-
cleosynthesis of the light elements in their observed abundances (Steigman 2003)
and the overall absence of spectral or spatial distortions in the Cosmic Microwave
1 Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, P.O.Box 800, 9700 AV Groningen, The Netherlands
c(cid:13) EDP Sciences 2018
DOI: (will be inserted later)
24
Mass Profiles and Shapes of Cosmological Structures
Background radiation (Smoot et al. 1992). Indeed, it would seem safe to assume
that these phenomenological foundations of the Big Bang are so firm, that this
model for the pre-recombination Universe should be taken as a requirement on
any alternative theory; i.e., an alternative theory should not lead to a radically
different cosmological scenario for the early Universe.
Now we all know that MOND was suggested as an alternative to dark matter.
But if MOND is, in some sense, "true" this does not mean that dark matter is
non-existent. Indeed, there is compelling astronomical evidence for the existence
of a cosmic component of pressure-less dark matter (CDM), with an abundance in
excess of any possible baryonic component. This is essentially the same evidence
as that supporting the "Concordance Model" (ΛCDM) for the Universe:
1) The overall amplitude of the first two peaks in the angular power spectrum of
the CMB anisotropies is, given an independent determination of the optical depth
to the last scattering surface, consistent with the presence, at recombination, of
dark matter potential wells (Page et al. 2003); the implied present density of CDM
would be about ΩCDM ≈ 0.25.
2) The re-brightening of SNIa at z ≥ 1 (relative to an empty coasting Universe),
implies matter domination over vacuum energy at this relatively recent epoch,
again at the level of ΩCDM ≈ 0.25 (Tonry et al 2003).
Although the evidence may have been overstated (McGaugh 2004), these two
facts imply that any MOND cosmology should reproduce or simulate the global
effects of cosmic CDM on early structure formation and the expansion history of
the Universe. But it would be inconsistent with MOND if dark matter made a
dominant contribution to the present mass budget of bound gravitational systems --
galaxies and groups of galaxies. I will return to this point later, but I first review
specific ideas on MOND cosmology.
2 Primitive (non-relativistic) MOND cosmology: Modified dynamics
of fluctuations
Is MOND consistent with FRW world models in the context of the Cosmological
Principle? Does MOND promote the formation of the observed range of structure
starting from near homogeneity at decoupling in a Universe without CDM? One
might hope to provide answers to these fundamental questions by considering the
evolution of a uniform sphere in the context of MOND (Felten 1984, Sanders 1998).
We know that the Newtonian evolution of a homogeneous sphere expanding against
its own gravity provides a non-relativistic derivation of the Friedmann equations for
the time dependence of the cosmic scale factor. So, does the MONDian evolution
of such an object lead to similar insights into the structure of a MOND cosmology?
To assert that it does requires two assumptions:
1. The external Universe does not affect the dynamics of a small spherical piece
of the Universe; i.e., there exists an equivalent to the Birkhoff theorem for the
relativistic theory underlying MOND (this is probably not true).
2. The MOND acceleration parameter, a0, is constant with cosmic time (also a
questionable proposition).
MOND and Cosmology
25
The well-known Newtonian equation for the evolution of the radius r of the
sphere is
r = −
4πGr
3
(ρ + 3p).
(2)
The fact that acceleration is proportional to radius means that there exists a criti-
cal radius, rc = pGM/a0, beyond which the acceleration exceeds a0, so we might
expect that on larger scales the evolution is described by the usual Friedmann
equations.
In Friedmann models the critical radius increases as the dimension-
less scale factor: rc ∝ a(t)m where m= 4 in a radiation dominated Universe and
m=3 in a matter dominated Universe. Thus, in a MONDian universe we would
seem to have the possibility of Friedmann expansion on the scale of the horizon,
but MOND expansion and re-collapse on smaller scales. That is, as soon as the
deceleration of a given co-moving region falls below a0, the dynamical equation
becomes
r = −h 4πGaor
3
1
(ρ + 3p)i
2
.
(3)
which leads to the eventual re-collapse of any finite size region, with larger co-
moving regions re-collapsing later.
In such a cosmology the evolution of the early Universe would be as it is in the
standard Big Bang (rc would be very much smaller than the relevant Jeans scale).
Moreover, in the present Universe, where this no longer the case, inhomogeneity on
large scale (≈ 1016 M⊙) would seem inevitable. However, there are clear problems
in principle with this cosmology. It is difficult to reconcile Friedmann expansion
in a large volume with MOND re-collapse about every point within that volume.
If re-collapse occurs only about selected points, what determines the location of
those seeds for re-collapse. The problem is that density fluctuations play no role
in this scenario for structure formation; we might expect that in a proper MOND
cosmology structure would develop from the field of small density fluctuations as
in the standard model of gravitational collapse.
To connect structure formation with density fluctuations one must supplement
the above assumptions with an additional ansatz: the MOND algorithm (eq. 1)
should only be applied to the peculiar accelerations that develop about fluctuations
and not to the overall Hubble flow. This means that the zeroth order Hubble flow
remains intact; there is no MOND in a homogeneous Universe. Such a scenario
would seem to be more consistent with the suggested relativistic theories in which
MOND phenomenology results from a scalar field gradient that dominates the
usual gravity force in the limit of low field gradients (Sanders 1997, Bekenstein
2004). Having said this, the de/acceleration of the Hubble flow over a particular
scale may enter as an external field -- the so-called "external field effect" in which
the internal dynamics of a subsystem is influenced by the presence of a background
acceleration field (Milgrom 1983).
These properties have been realized in a non-relativistic two-field theory of
modified dynamics (Sanders 2001) which is similar to the Bekenstein-Milgrom
Lagrangian-based theory (Bekenstein & Milgrom 1984). The two fields suppos-
edly represent usual gravity and an anomalous MOND force assumed to act only
26
Mass Profiles and Shapes of Cosmological Structures
upon over- or under-dense regions. Following the same procedure as in Newtonian
cosmology, I find that the growth equation for small density fluctuations is non-
linear even in the regime where the density fluctuations are small (this is because
MOND is non-linear). Moreover, as we see in Fig. 1 the growth is dramatically
rapid where the background acceleration vanishes; i.e., when the vacuum energy
density as described by a cosmological constant becomes comparable to the matter
energy density.
Fig. 1. The amplitude of density fluctuations (∆ = δρ/ρ) on various co-moving scales
(Mpc) as a function of scale factor compared to the Newtonian growth in a low-density
baryonic Universe (Sanders 2001). The growth rate is particularly large where the cos-
mological term begins to dominate the expansion.
This effect adds a new aspect to the anthropic argument originally given by
Milgrom (1989): we are observing the Universe at an epoch where the cosmological
term has recently become dominant because it as at this epoch where structure
can form rapidly.
Nusser (2002) and Knebe & Gibson (2004) have carried out cosmic N-body
simulations where the MOND formula is applied to the peculiar accelerations.
Here there is no external field effect of the background Hubble flow (indeed, it is
unclear how such an effect might be realized in N-body simulations). Nusser finds
that, with the value of a0 determined from galaxy rotation curves (≈ 10−8 cm/s2),
structure grows very rapidly -- the present amplitude of density fluctuations would
MOND and Cosmology
27
be much larger than observed (σ8 > 3). If, however, a0 is smaller by about a factor
of 10, then the resulting rate of growth is consistent with standard (CDM) theory
and the topology of the resulting structure is very similar to that seen in CDM
simulations and actually observed in large galaxy redshift surveys -- essentially one
of filaments and walls surrounding large voids.
Basically the rapid growth of structure in these simulations is due to the ab-
sence of the external field effect: the assumption that the deceleration of the Hub-
ble flow over a finite size region enters as a background acceleration field tames
this exponential growth. Without such an effect, some other mechanism, such as
a lower value of a0, must be invoked -- that is, the assumption that a0 is constant
over the history of the Universe must be relaxed. This illustrates the essential
limitations of developing a MOND cosmology in the absence of a relativistic the-
ory. Any one of the assumptions upon which such a cosmology is based may be
wrong, and this would obviate the results. Non-relativistic MOND cosmology,
while useful in getting a broad picture of how a MOND universe may appear and
how various assumptions affect the results, has clearly reached its limits.
3 Relativistic MOND cosmology
A consistent relativistic theory of MOND, such as TeVeS (Bekenstein 2004), per-
mits derivation of cosmological models and consideration of structure formation
without additional assumptions. In TeVeS, the Friedmann equation is standard,
apart from an effectively variable constant of gravity and additional source terms
resulting from the energy density of the scalar and vector fields. But in TeVeS as
it now stands, the proposed form of its free function presents a problem in inter-
polating between a homogeneous evolving universe and quasi-static mass concen-
trations.
The scalar field Lagrangian of TeVeS has the form
Ls =
1
2
[q2φ,αφ,α + 2V (q)]
(4)
where φ is the matter-coupling field and q is a non-dynamical (or at least not explic-
itly dynamical) auxiliary field which determines the strength of that coupling. The
free function, V (q), can be viewed as a potential of this non-dynamical field. Now,
because of the algebraic relation between q and φ,αφ,α (i.e., qφ,αφ,α = V ′(q)), this
is really an aquadratic Lagrangian theory in disguise as discussed by Bekenstein.
That is to say, the scalar field Lagrangian can be written
Ls =
1
2
F(cid:16)φ,αφ,αl2(cid:17)
(5)
where l is a length scale. Here, the MOND interpolating function is given by
µ = dF (X)/dX. If one is to obtain MOND phenomenology in the limit of low
∇φ, then V (q) must be chosen such that F (X) → X 3/2 in the limit of small X
as originally discussed by Bekenstein & Milgrom (1984). However, this obviously
28
Mass Profiles and Shapes of Cosmological Structures
cannot be continued into the cosmological regime where X < 0 (with the sign con-
vention adapted here). This was an early problem for the cosmological extension
of AQUAL and it persists for TeVeS (see Sanders 1986).
Bekenstein chooses to solve this problem by taking V (q) such that F (X) has
two discontinuous branches -- one for cosmology (X < 0), and one for quasi-static
mass concentrations (X > 0). Bekenstein emphasises that this choice is tentative
and not fundamental to the theory. This is fortunate because we see an immediate
problem here with respect to the growth of fluctuations in an evolving Universe.
How do we deal with the discontinuity between the cosmological regime and the
quasi-static regime? It would seem impossible to follow the evolution of structure,
at least to the non-linear level.
None-the-less it does seem possible to consider the linear development of large
scale structure in the context of TeVeS with this somewhat awkward free func-
tion. Skordis et al. (2005) have derived homogeneous Friedmann-like models and
note that the models exhibit the tracking behaviour characterising some scalar
field theories of quintessence: the relative density in the φ field attains attractor
solutions in the radiation, matter and Λ eras. They then consider the evolution of
linear perturbations for a range of the parameters of the theory and find reason-
able agreement with both the angular power spectrum of the CMB fluctuations
(out to the second peak) and with the observed power spectrum of galaxy density
fluctuations, provided that neutrinos are included at a level of Ων = 0.17 -- near
the upper limit permitted by experimental constraints on the electron neutrino
mass. A critical aspect is the amplitude of the third peak in the CMB anisotropy
power-spectrum: dark matter fluctuations seem to be required to make this peak
as large as observed in earlier CMB experiments (see also McGaugh 2004).
These calculations demonstrate the power of a relativistic theory like TeVeS,
in confronting this range of observed cosmic phenomena with a theory producing
MOND in the quasi-static regime. However, the present arbitrariness of the free
function means that the results must still be considered as tentative.
4 A cosmological effective theory of MOND
One short-coming of TeVeS in its present form is that the MOND acceleration
parameter a0 does not appear to arise in a natural way but must be inserted by
hand. The near numerical coincidence of a0 with cH0 remains unexplained. This
coincidence suggests that the correct theory of MOND may be one in which this
characteristic phenomenology arises only in a cosmological background. That is to
say, MOND should be described by an effective theory which reflects the influence
of cosmology on local particle dynamics, as originally supposed by Milgrom (1983,
2002). Scalar-tensor theory offers this possibility (Dicke 1962). Moreover, in any
theory of stronger attraction in the limit of weak gradients that also provides the
observed degree of gravitational lensing, the scalar field must affect particle mo-
tion jointly with the Einstein metric and an additional vector field (Bekenstein
& Sanders 1994, Sanders 1997). The components of the vector are not invari-
ant under a Lorentz transformation so the theory will inevitably single out the
MOND and Cosmology
29
cosmological frame as special.
One possibility for such an effective theory is to explicitly include dynamics for
the auxiliary field q in TeVeS; i.e., write a kinetic term q,αq,α into the scalar La-
grangian eq. 4. The theory then becomes a biscalar preferred frame generalisation
of "phase coupling gravitation" (PCG), an earlier covariant theory also proposed
by Bekenstein (1988) as a basis for MOND. Although PCG, in original form, con-
tains pathologies, it is attractive in the sense that it permits sensible cosmologies
where the fields at large distances from mass concentrations naturally approach
their cosmological values (Sanders 1989). In the biscalar theory, as in PCG, one
field φ couples to matter and the second field q determines the strength of that
coupling. It is then possible to write down a theory in which the MOND phe-
nomenology arises in an evolving Universe where a0 is identified with c φ (Sanders
2005). Here a0 evolves with cosmic time in the sense that it was smaller in the
past (a factor of 10 smaller at z=10).
Fig. 2. Oscillations that develop in the "coupling strength field" q as it seeks the mini-
mum in the potential well. These can constitute CDM with a large de Broglie wavelength
(Sanders 2004)
The cosmology is standard, but oscillations of the q field inevitably develop
as the field settles to the potential minimum (see Fig. 2). If the bare potential is
quadratic (V (q) = 1
2 Aq2 + B), these oscillations comprise cold dark matter, but,
depending upon the parameters of the theory, the de Broglie wavelength of these
30
Mass Profiles and Shapes of Cosmological Structures
bosons may be so large that the the dark matter does not cluster on the scale
of galaxies. So beginning with a theory involving two scalar fields, the matter
coupling field provides MOND phenomenology in the cosmological background,
but oscillations in coupling-strength field provide cosmological dark matter; an
effective theory of MOND produces cosmological CDM for free.
The overall picture is that cosmology is described by a preferred frame theory
with a long range force mediated by a scalar field coupled to a dynamical vector
as well as the gravitational metric. The fact that the scalar coupling to matter be-
comes very weak in the region of high field gradients protects the solar system from
observable preferred frame effects; i.e., the theory becomes effectively identical to
General Relativity in this limit. The outskirts of galaxies would be the transition
region between preferred frame cosmology and a GR dominated local dynamics.
This transition would be observable as an acceleration-dependent deviation from
Newtonian dynamics -- MOND.
References
Bekenstein, J.D., 1988, in Second Canadian Conf. on General Relativity and Relativistic
Astrophysics, eds. Coley, A., Dyer, C., Tupper, T., (Singapore: World Scientific), 487
Bekenstein, J.D., 2004, Phys.Rev.D, 70, 083509
Bekenstein, J.D. & Milgrom, M., 1984, ApJ, 286, 7
Bekenstein, J.D. & Sanders, R.H., 1994, ApJ, 429, 480
Dicke, R.H., 1962, Phys.Rev., 126, 1875
Felten, J.E., 1984, ApJ, 286, 3
Knebe, B.& Gibson, B.K., 2004, MNRAS, 347, 1055
McGaugh, S.S., 2004, ApJ, 611, 26
Milgrom, M., 1983, ApJ, 270, 365
Milgrom, M., 1989, Comm.Ap., 13, 215
Milgrom, M., 2002, New Astron.Rev., 46, 741 [astro-ph/0207231]
Nusser, A., 2002, MNRAS, 331, 909
Page, L. et al., 2003, Astrophys.J.Suppl., 148, 233
Steigman, G., 2003, Carnegie Observatories Astrophysics Series Vol. 2: Measuring and
Modelling the Universe, W. Freedman ed. (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press)
[astro-ph/ 0307244]
Sanders, R.H., 1986, MNRAS, 223, 539
Sanders, R.H., 1989, MNRAS, 241, 135
Sanders, R.H., 1997, ApJ, 480, 492
Sanders, R.H. 1998, MNRAS, 296, 1009
Sanders, R.H., 2001, ApJ, 560, 1
Sanders, R.H., 2005, MNRAS (in press) [astro-ph/0502222]
Sanders, R.H. & McGaugh, S.S., 2002, Ann.Rev.Astron. Astrophys., 40, 263
Skordis, C., D. F. Mota, D.F., Ferreira, P.G. & Boehm, C., 2005, Phys.Rev.Lett. (sub-
mitted) [astro-ph/0505519]
Smoot, G.F., et al., 1992, ApJ, 396, L1
Tonry, J.L., et al., 2003, ApJ, 594, 1 [astro-ph/0305008]
|
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.